diff --git "a/data/tasks.jsonl" "b/data/tasks.jsonl"
--- "a/data/tasks.jsonl"
+++ "b/data/tasks.jsonl"
@@ -1,100 +1,100 @@
-{"context_files": ["task_files/cb100-001-helios-forge/01_corporate/001_corporate_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-001-helios-forge/01_corporate/002_corporate_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-001-helios-forge/01_corporate/003_corporate_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-001-helios-forge/01_corporate/004_corporate_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-001-helios-forge/01_corporate/005_corporate_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-001-helios-forge/01_corporate/006_corporate_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-001-helios-forge/01_corporate/007_corporate_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-001-helios-forge/01_corporate/008_corporate_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-001-helios-forge/02_capitalization/009_capitalization_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-001-helios-forge/02_capitalization/010_capitalization_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-001-helios-forge/02_capitalization/011_capitalization_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-001-helios-forge/02_capitalization/012_capitalization_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-001-helios-forge/02_capitalization/013_capitalization_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-001-helios-forge/02_capitalization/014_capitalization_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-001-helios-forge/02_capitalization/015_capitalization_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-001-helios-forge/02_capitalization/016_capitalization_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-001-helios-forge/03_material_contracts/017_material_contracts_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-001-helios-forge/03_material_contracts/018_material_contracts_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-001-helios-forge/03_material_contracts/019_material_contracts_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-001-helios-forge/03_material_contracts/020_material_contracts_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-001-helios-forge/03_material_contracts/021_material_contracts_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-001-helios-forge/03_material_contracts/022_material_contracts_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-001-helios-forge/03_material_contracts/023_material_contracts_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-001-helios-forge/03_material_contracts/024_material_contracts_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-001-helios-forge/04_debt_security/025_debt_security_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-001-helios-forge/04_debt_security/026_debt_security_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-001-helios-forge/04_debt_security/027_debt_security_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-001-helios-forge/04_debt_security/028_debt_security_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-001-helios-forge/04_debt_security/029_debt_security_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-001-helios-forge/04_debt_security/030_debt_security_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-001-helios-forge/04_debt_security/031_debt_security_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-001-helios-forge/04_debt_security/032_debt_security_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-001-helios-forge/05_employment/033_employment_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-001-helios-forge/05_employment/034_employment_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-001-helios-forge/05_employment/035_employment_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-001-helios-forge/05_employment/036_employment_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-001-helios-forge/05_employment/037_employment_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-001-helios-forge/05_employment/038_employment_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-001-helios-forge/05_employment/039_employment_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-001-helios-forge/05_employment/040_employment_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-001-helios-forge/06_ip_technology/041_ip_technology_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-001-helios-forge/06_ip_technology/042_ip_technology_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-001-helios-forge/06_ip_technology/043_ip_technology_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-001-helios-forge/06_ip_technology/044_ip_technology_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-001-helios-forge/06_ip_technology/045_ip_technology_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-001-helios-forge/06_ip_technology/046_ip_technology_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-001-helios-forge/06_ip_technology/047_ip_technology_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-001-helios-forge/06_ip_technology/048_ip_technology_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-001-helios-forge/07_privacy_security/049_privacy_security_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-001-helios-forge/07_privacy_security/050_privacy_security_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-001-helios-forge/07_privacy_security/051_privacy_security_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-001-helios-forge/07_privacy_security/052_privacy_security_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-001-helios-forge/07_privacy_security/053_privacy_security_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-001-helios-forge/07_privacy_security/054_privacy_security_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-001-helios-forge/07_privacy_security/055_privacy_security_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-001-helios-forge/07_privacy_security/056_privacy_security_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-001-helios-forge/08_regulatory/057_regulatory_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-001-helios-forge/08_regulatory/058_regulatory_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-001-helios-forge/08_regulatory/059_regulatory_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-001-helios-forge/08_regulatory/060_regulatory_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-001-helios-forge/08_regulatory/061_regulatory_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-001-helios-forge/08_regulatory/062_regulatory_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-001-helios-forge/08_regulatory/063_regulatory_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-001-helios-forge/08_regulatory/064_regulatory_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-001-helios-forge/09_litigation/065_litigation_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-001-helios-forge/09_litigation/066_litigation_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-001-helios-forge/09_litigation/067_litigation_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-001-helios-forge/09_litigation/068_litigation_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-001-helios-forge/09_litigation/069_litigation_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-001-helios-forge/09_litigation/070_litigation_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-001-helios-forge/09_litigation/071_litigation_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-001-helios-forge/09_litigation/072_litigation_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-001-helios-forge/10_real_property/073_real_property_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-001-helios-forge/10_real_property/074_real_property_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-001-helios-forge/10_real_property/075_real_property_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-001-helios-forge/10_real_property/076_real_property_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-001-helios-forge/10_real_property/077_real_property_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-001-helios-forge/10_real_property/078_real_property_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-001-helios-forge/10_real_property/079_real_property_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-001-helios-forge/10_real_property/080_real_property_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-001-helios-forge/11_tax_insurance/081_tax_insurance_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-001-helios-forge/11_tax_insurance/082_tax_insurance_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-001-helios-forge/11_tax_insurance/083_tax_insurance_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-001-helios-forge/11_tax_insurance/084_tax_insurance_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-001-helios-forge/11_tax_insurance/085_tax_insurance_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-001-helios-forge/11_tax_insurance/086_tax_insurance_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-001-helios-forge/11_tax_insurance/087_tax_insurance_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-001-helios-forge/11_tax_insurance/088_tax_insurance_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-001-helios-forge/12_financials/089_financials_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-001-helios-forge/12_financials/090_financials_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-001-helios-forge/12_financials/091_financials_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-001-helios-forge/12_financials/092_financials_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-001-helios-forge/12_financials/093_financials_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-001-helios-forge/12_financials/094_financials_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-001-helios-forge/12_financials/095_financials_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-001-helios-forge/12_financials/096_financials_status_report.md"], "gold_output": {"advice_markdown": "# Counsel advice — Project Daybreak battery acquisition\n\n## Executive assessment\n\nFor Helios Forge, Inc. matter CB-MA-2401, the review identified 16 source-supported exceptions requiring action before 2026-09-04. The assessment concerns BluePeak Battery Systems LLC and the supplied record for Delaware.\n\n## Method and record coverage\n\nThe review inventoried all 96 production files, read the 33 controlling, corroborating, and control records, searched the email exports, and checked metadata for the designated chain-of-custody sample. Conclusions are limited to the synthetic production supplied for this benchmark matter.\n\n## Findings\n\n### F-01 — charter authorization mismatch (critical)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for charter authorization mismatch: one source states the operative date is 2025-02-15 under control reference CB-MA-2401-A983, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2025-04-03 under response reference CB-MA-2401-J929.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/01_corporate/001_corporate_control_register.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/07_privacy_security/049_privacy_security_control_register.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-04, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Isaac Romero.\n\n### F-02 — unrecorded option grant (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for unrecorded option grant: one source states the controlling amount is $3,939,148.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $4,074,796.00.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/01_corporate/004_corporate_ledger_export.csv`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/07_privacy_security/052_privacy_security_ledger_export.csv`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-04, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Sofia Bennett.\n\n### F-03 — change-of-control consent (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for change-of-control consent: one source states approval is attributed to Talia Brooks as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Henry Cho and contains no entry for Talia Brooks.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/01_corporate/007_corporate_officer_certificate.html`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/07_privacy_security/055_privacy_security_officer_certificate.html`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-04, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Adrian Mensah.\n\n### F-04 — anti-assignment restriction (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for anti-assignment restriction: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-MA-2401-D624, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-MA-2401-M555.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/02_capitalization/010_capitalization_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/08_regulatory/058_regulatory_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-04, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Willa Novak.\n\n### F-05 — most-favored-customer exposure (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for most-favored-customer exposure: one source states the applicable location is Washoe County, Nevada, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to Delaware operations outside Washoe County, Nevada.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/02_capitalization/013_capitalization_review_memorandum.json`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/08_regulatory/061_regulatory_review_memorandum.json`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-04, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Theo Laurent.\n\n### F-06 — financial covenant breach (low)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for financial covenant breach: one source states the threshold is 7% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 14% and produced a different exception result.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/02_capitalization/016_capitalization_status_report.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/08_regulatory/064_regulatory_status_report.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-04, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Amara Patel.\n\n### F-07 — key-person retention gap (critical)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for key-person retention gap: one source states formal notice must use notices-helios_forge_inc@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-bluepeak_battery_systems_llc@example.test.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/019_material_contracts_correspondence.eml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/09_litigation/067_litigation_correspondence.eml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-04, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Henry Cho.\n\n### F-08 — invention assignment defect (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for invention assignment defect: one source states the governed population contains 142 records through 2025-08-25, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 71 records through 2025-10-07.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/022_material_contracts_formal_notice.xml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/09_litigation/070_litigation_formal_notice.xml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-04, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Nadine Flores.\n\n### F-09 — open-source copyleft exposure (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for open-source copyleft exposure: one source states the operative date is 2025-04-04 under control reference CB-MA-2401-I971, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2025-04-19 under response reference CB-MA-2401-R928.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/04_debt_security/025_debt_security_control_register.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/10_real_property/073_real_property_control_register.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-04, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Micah Sullivan.\n\n### F-10 — unreported security incident (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for unreported security incident: one source states the controlling amount is $513,280.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $803,060.00.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/04_debt_security/028_debt_security_ledger_export.csv`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/10_real_property/076_real_property_ledger_export.csv`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-04, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Farah Ibrahim.\n\n### F-11 — permit transfer restriction (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for permit transfer restriction: one source states approval is attributed to Talia Brooks as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Caleb Hassan and contains no entry for Talia Brooks.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/04_debt_security/031_debt_security_officer_certificate.html`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/10_real_property/079_real_property_officer_certificate.html`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-04, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Owen Delgado.\n\n### F-12 — threatened customer dispute (low)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for threatened customer dispute: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-MA-2401-L867, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-MA-2401-U159.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/05_employment/034_employment_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/11_tax_insurance/082_tax_insurance_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-04, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Lena Varga.\n\n### F-13 — facility title exception (critical)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for facility title exception: one source states the applicable location is Washoe County, Nevada, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to Delaware operations outside Washoe County, Nevada.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/05_employment/037_employment_review_memorandum.json`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/11_tax_insurance/085_tax_insurance_review_memorandum.json`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-04, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Samuel Kim.\n\n### F-14 — sales-tax nexus gap (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for sales-tax nexus gap: one source states the threshold is 10% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 12% and produced a different exception result.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/05_employment/040_employment_status_report.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/11_tax_insurance/088_tax_insurance_status_report.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-04, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Maya Ellison.\n\n### F-15 — claims-made insurance tail (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for claims-made insurance tail: one source states formal notice must use notices-helios_forge_inc@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-bluepeak_battery_systems_llc@example.test.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/043_ip_technology_correspondence.eml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/12_financials/091_financials_correspondence.eml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-04, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Rafael Okafor.\n\n### F-16 — revenue recognition exception (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for revenue recognition exception: one source states the governed population contains 89 records through 2025-02-13, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 67 records through 2025-03-24.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/046_ip_technology_formal_notice.xml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/12_financials/094_financials_formal_notice.xml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-04, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Nora Chen.\n\n## Recommended next actions\n\nSequence the critical and high findings first, assign the named owners, preserve the cited records, and document any resolution in the controlling matter register before the stated deadline.\n\n## Assumptions and limitations\n\nThis analysis is confined to task cb100-001-helios-forge and the supplied synthetic evidence. It does not rely on external facts, does not resolve disputed law, and is not legal advice for a real person or entity.\n", "findings": {"as_of": "2026-09-04", "findings": [{"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/07_privacy_security/049_privacy_security_control_register.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for charter authorization mismatch: one source states the operative date is 2025-02-15 under control reference CB-MA-2401-A983, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2025-04-03 under response reference CB-MA-2401-J929.", "id": "F-01", "issue": "charter authorization mismatch", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/01_corporate/001_corporate_control_register.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-04, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Isaac Romero.", "severity": "critical"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/07_privacy_security/052_privacy_security_ledger_export.csv", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for unrecorded option grant: one source states the controlling amount is $3,939,148.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $4,074,796.00.", "id": "F-02", "issue": "unrecorded option grant", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/01_corporate/004_corporate_ledger_export.csv", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-04, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Sofia Bennett.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/07_privacy_security/055_privacy_security_officer_certificate.html", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for change-of-control consent: one source states approval is attributed to Talia Brooks as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Henry Cho and contains no entry for Talia Brooks.", "id": "F-03", "issue": "change-of-control consent", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/01_corporate/007_corporate_officer_certificate.html", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-04, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Adrian Mensah.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/08_regulatory/058_regulatory_executed_instrument.txt", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for anti-assignment restriction: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-MA-2401-D624, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-MA-2401-M555.", "id": "F-04", "issue": "anti-assignment restriction", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/02_capitalization/010_capitalization_executed_instrument.txt", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-04, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Willa Novak.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/08_regulatory/061_regulatory_review_memorandum.json", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for most-favored-customer exposure: one source states the applicable location is Washoe County, Nevada, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to Delaware operations outside Washoe County, Nevada.", "id": "F-05", "issue": "most-favored-customer exposure", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/02_capitalization/013_capitalization_review_memorandum.json", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-04, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Theo Laurent.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/08_regulatory/064_regulatory_status_report.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for financial covenant breach: one source states the threshold is 7% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 14% and produced a different exception result.", "id": "F-06", "issue": "financial covenant breach", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/02_capitalization/016_capitalization_status_report.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-04, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Amara Patel.", "severity": "low"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/09_litigation/067_litigation_correspondence.eml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for key-person retention gap: one source states formal notice must use notices-helios_forge_inc@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-bluepeak_battery_systems_llc@example.test.", "id": "F-07", "issue": "key-person retention gap", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/019_material_contracts_correspondence.eml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-04, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Henry Cho.", "severity": "critical"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/09_litigation/070_litigation_formal_notice.xml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for invention assignment defect: one source states the governed population contains 142 records through 2025-08-25, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 71 records through 2025-10-07.", "id": "F-08", "issue": "invention assignment defect", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/022_material_contracts_formal_notice.xml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-04, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Nadine Flores.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/10_real_property/073_real_property_control_register.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for open-source copyleft exposure: one source states the operative date is 2025-04-04 under control reference CB-MA-2401-I971, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2025-04-19 under response reference CB-MA-2401-R928.", "id": "F-09", "issue": "open-source copyleft exposure", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/04_debt_security/025_debt_security_control_register.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-04, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Micah Sullivan.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/10_real_property/076_real_property_ledger_export.csv", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for unreported security incident: one source states the controlling amount is $513,280.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $803,060.00.", "id": "F-10", "issue": "unreported security incident", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/04_debt_security/028_debt_security_ledger_export.csv", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-04, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Farah Ibrahim.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/10_real_property/079_real_property_officer_certificate.html", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for permit transfer restriction: one source states approval is attributed to Talia Brooks as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Caleb Hassan and contains no entry for Talia Brooks.", "id": "F-11", "issue": "permit transfer restriction", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/04_debt_security/031_debt_security_officer_certificate.html", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-04, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Owen Delgado.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/11_tax_insurance/082_tax_insurance_executed_instrument.txt", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for threatened customer dispute: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-MA-2401-L867, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-MA-2401-U159.", "id": "F-12", "issue": "threatened customer dispute", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/05_employment/034_employment_executed_instrument.txt", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-04, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Lena Varga.", "severity": "low"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/11_tax_insurance/085_tax_insurance_review_memorandum.json", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for facility title exception: one source states the applicable location is Washoe County, Nevada, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to Delaware operations outside Washoe County, Nevada.", "id": "F-13", "issue": "facility title exception", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/05_employment/037_employment_review_memorandum.json", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-04, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Samuel Kim.", "severity": "critical"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/11_tax_insurance/088_tax_insurance_status_report.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for sales-tax nexus gap: one source states the threshold is 10% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 12% and produced a different exception result.", "id": "F-14", "issue": "sales-tax nexus gap", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/05_employment/040_employment_status_report.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-04, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Maya Ellison.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/12_financials/091_financials_correspondence.eml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for claims-made insurance tail: one source states formal notice must use notices-helios_forge_inc@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-bluepeak_battery_systems_llc@example.test.", "id": "F-15", "issue": "claims-made insurance tail", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/043_ip_technology_correspondence.eml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-04, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Rafael Okafor.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/12_financials/094_financials_formal_notice.xml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for revenue recognition exception: one source states the governed population contains 89 records through 2025-02-13, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 67 records through 2025-03-24.", "id": "F-16", "issue": "revenue recognition exception", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/046_ip_technology_formal_notice.xml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-04, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Nora Chen.", "severity": "medium"}], "matter_number": "CB-MA-2401", "prepared_for": "Helios Forge, Inc.", "schema_version": "1.0", "task_id": "cb100-001-helios-forge"}}, "metadata": {"benchmark": "CounselBench-100", "code_license": "Apache-2.0", "data_license": "CC-BY-4.0", "deadline": "2026-09-04", "document_count": 96, "jurisdiction": "Delaware", "matter_number": "CB-MA-2401", "mcp_commit": "9a96ea6e5913736f92b88345bf51caeaaa8e719f", "mcp_package": "@modelcontextprotocol/server-filesystem@2026.7.10", "practice_area": "corporate-ma", "reference_tool_calls": 46, "required_evidence_reads": 33, "synthetic": true, "venue": "Washoe County, Nevada", "version": "2.0.0"}, "prompt": "You are buyer-side transactions counsel for Helios Forge, Inc. The partner responsible for this matter needs a defensible decision record before the next client call. A carve-out manufacturer owns cathode tooling in Nevada while its largest automaker customer can terminate upon an indirect change of control. Decision due 2026-09-04. Delaware law governs; Washoe County, Nevada is the forum. Prioritize conflicts between signed instruments and later operational records. Work out the defensible position from the matter production and leave an audit-ready exception tracker and concise advice for the supervising lawyer. Keep confirmed conflicts separate from open questions, cite the records that actually control each conclusion, and do not fill gaps with outside facts.", "rubric": {"criteria": [{"category": "procedure", "description": "Complete at least 46 successful, argument-specific evidence and output calls.", "id": "procedure.minimum_successful_tool_calls"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Find and read the 33 controlling, corroborating, and work-product-control records in full.", "id": "procedure.all_evidence_read_in_full"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Inspect file metadata for the eight designated critical primary records before relying on them.", "id": "procedure.chain_of_custody_metadata_checked"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Confirm the sandbox's allowed document and output roots.", "id": "procedure.allowed_directories_checked"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Inventory all 96 records so the relevant sources are discovered among the context records.", "id": "procedure.recursive_inventory_completed"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Search the production for email evidence that may corroborate or contradict formal records.", "id": "procedure.targeted_search_completed"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Leave only findings.json and advice.md in the output workspace.", "id": "procedure.exact_deliverable_set"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Create both final work products through the sandbox MCP surface.", "id": "procedure.deliverables_written_through_mcp"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Produce findings.json as a valid JSON object.", "id": "findings.findings_is_object"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Report exactly 16 confirmed exceptions.", "id": "findings.findings_exact_count"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Use each stable finding ID exactly once.", "id": "findings.finding_ids_unique"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set schema_version to the released matter value '1.0'.", "id": "findings.top_level_schema_version"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set task_id to the released matter value 'cb100-001-helios-forge'.", "id": "findings.top_level_task_id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set matter_number to the released matter value 'CB-MA-2401'.", "id": "findings.top_level_matter_number"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set prepared_for to the released matter value 'Helios Forge, Inc.'.", "id": "findings.top_level_prepared_for"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set as_of to the released matter value '2026-09-04'.", "id": "findings.top_level_as_of"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-01 exception for charter authorization mismatch.", "id": "findings.F-01.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's id from /workspace/documents/01_corporate/001_corporate_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_privacy_security/049_privacy_security_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's issue from /workspace/documents/01_corporate/001_corporate_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_privacy_security/049_privacy_security_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's severity from /workspace/documents/01_corporate/001_corporate_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_privacy_security/049_privacy_security_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's primary_source from /workspace/documents/01_corporate/001_corporate_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_privacy_security/049_privacy_security_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/01_corporate/001_corporate_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_privacy_security/049_privacy_security_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-01 using the exact controlled facts ['2025-02-15', 'CB-MA-2401-A983', '2025-04-03', 'CB-MA-2401-J929'].", "id": "findings.F-01.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-01's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-01.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-04', 'Isaac Romero'] for F-01.", "id": "findings.F-01.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-02 exception for unrecorded option grant.", "id": "findings.F-02.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's id from /workspace/documents/01_corporate/004_corporate_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_privacy_security/052_privacy_security_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's issue from /workspace/documents/01_corporate/004_corporate_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_privacy_security/052_privacy_security_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's severity from /workspace/documents/01_corporate/004_corporate_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_privacy_security/052_privacy_security_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's primary_source from /workspace/documents/01_corporate/004_corporate_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_privacy_security/052_privacy_security_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/01_corporate/004_corporate_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_privacy_security/052_privacy_security_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-02 using the exact controlled facts ['$3,939,148.00', '$4,074,796.00'].", "id": "findings.F-02.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-02's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-02.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-04', 'Sofia Bennett'] for F-02.", "id": "findings.F-02.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-03 exception for change-of-control consent.", "id": "findings.F-03.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's id from /workspace/documents/01_corporate/007_corporate_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_privacy_security/055_privacy_security_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's issue from /workspace/documents/01_corporate/007_corporate_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_privacy_security/055_privacy_security_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's severity from /workspace/documents/01_corporate/007_corporate_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_privacy_security/055_privacy_security_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's primary_source from /workspace/documents/01_corporate/007_corporate_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_privacy_security/055_privacy_security_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/01_corporate/007_corporate_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_privacy_security/055_privacy_security_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-03 using the exact controlled facts ['Talia Brooks', 'Henry Cho'].", "id": "findings.F-03.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-03's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-03.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-04', 'Adrian Mensah'] for F-03.", "id": "findings.F-03.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-04 exception for anti-assignment restriction.", "id": "findings.F-04.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's id from /workspace/documents/02_capitalization/010_capitalization_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_regulatory/058_regulatory_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's issue from /workspace/documents/02_capitalization/010_capitalization_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_regulatory/058_regulatory_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's severity from /workspace/documents/02_capitalization/010_capitalization_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_regulatory/058_regulatory_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's primary_source from /workspace/documents/02_capitalization/010_capitalization_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_regulatory/058_regulatory_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/02_capitalization/010_capitalization_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_regulatory/058_regulatory_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-04 using the exact controlled facts ['closed without exception', 'CB-MA-2401-D624', 'open and escalated', 'CB-MA-2401-M555'].", "id": "findings.F-04.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-04's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-04.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-04', 'Willa Novak'] for F-04.", "id": "findings.F-04.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-05 exception for most-favored-customer exposure.", "id": "findings.F-05.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's id from /workspace/documents/02_capitalization/013_capitalization_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_regulatory/061_regulatory_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's issue from /workspace/documents/02_capitalization/013_capitalization_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_regulatory/061_regulatory_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's severity from /workspace/documents/02_capitalization/013_capitalization_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_regulatory/061_regulatory_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's primary_source from /workspace/documents/02_capitalization/013_capitalization_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_regulatory/061_regulatory_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/02_capitalization/013_capitalization_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_regulatory/061_regulatory_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-05 using the exact controlled facts ['Washoe County, Nevada', 'Delaware'].", "id": "findings.F-05.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-05's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-05.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-04', 'Theo Laurent'] for F-05.", "id": "findings.F-05.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-06 exception for financial covenant breach.", "id": "findings.F-06.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's id from /workspace/documents/02_capitalization/016_capitalization_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_regulatory/064_regulatory_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's issue from /workspace/documents/02_capitalization/016_capitalization_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_regulatory/064_regulatory_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's severity from /workspace/documents/02_capitalization/016_capitalization_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_regulatory/064_regulatory_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's primary_source from /workspace/documents/02_capitalization/016_capitalization_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_regulatory/064_regulatory_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/02_capitalization/016_capitalization_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_regulatory/064_regulatory_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-06 using the exact controlled facts ['7%', '14%'].", "id": "findings.F-06.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-06's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-06.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-04', 'Amara Patel'] for F-06.", "id": "findings.F-06.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-07 exception for key-person retention gap.", "id": "findings.F-07.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's id from /workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/019_material_contracts_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_litigation/067_litigation_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's issue from /workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/019_material_contracts_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_litigation/067_litigation_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's severity from /workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/019_material_contracts_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_litigation/067_litigation_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's primary_source from /workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/019_material_contracts_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_litigation/067_litigation_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/019_material_contracts_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_litigation/067_litigation_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-07 using the exact controlled facts ['notices-helios_forge_inc@example.test', 'archive-bluepeak_battery_systems_llc@example.test'].", "id": "findings.F-07.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-07's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-07.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-04', 'Henry Cho'] for F-07.", "id": "findings.F-07.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-08 exception for invention assignment defect.", "id": "findings.F-08.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's id from /workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/022_material_contracts_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_litigation/070_litigation_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's issue from /workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/022_material_contracts_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_litigation/070_litigation_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's severity from /workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/022_material_contracts_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_litigation/070_litigation_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's primary_source from /workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/022_material_contracts_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_litigation/070_litigation_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/022_material_contracts_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_litigation/070_litigation_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-08 using the exact controlled facts ['142 records', '2025-08-25', '71 records', '2025-10-07'].", "id": "findings.F-08.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-08's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-08.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-04', 'Nadine Flores'] for F-08.", "id": "findings.F-08.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-09 exception for open-source copyleft exposure.", "id": "findings.F-09.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's id from /workspace/documents/04_debt_security/025_debt_security_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_real_property/073_real_property_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's issue from /workspace/documents/04_debt_security/025_debt_security_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_real_property/073_real_property_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's severity from /workspace/documents/04_debt_security/025_debt_security_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_real_property/073_real_property_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's primary_source from /workspace/documents/04_debt_security/025_debt_security_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_real_property/073_real_property_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/04_debt_security/025_debt_security_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_real_property/073_real_property_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-09 using the exact controlled facts ['2025-04-04', 'CB-MA-2401-I971', '2025-04-19', 'CB-MA-2401-R928'].", "id": "findings.F-09.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-09's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-09.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-04', 'Micah Sullivan'] for F-09.", "id": "findings.F-09.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-10 exception for unreported security incident.", "id": "findings.F-10.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's id from /workspace/documents/04_debt_security/028_debt_security_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_real_property/076_real_property_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's issue from /workspace/documents/04_debt_security/028_debt_security_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_real_property/076_real_property_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's severity from /workspace/documents/04_debt_security/028_debt_security_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_real_property/076_real_property_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's primary_source from /workspace/documents/04_debt_security/028_debt_security_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_real_property/076_real_property_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/04_debt_security/028_debt_security_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_real_property/076_real_property_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-10 using the exact controlled facts ['$513,280.00', '$803,060.00'].", "id": "findings.F-10.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-10's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-10.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-04', 'Farah Ibrahim'] for F-10.", "id": "findings.F-10.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-11 exception for permit transfer restriction.", "id": "findings.F-11.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's id from /workspace/documents/04_debt_security/031_debt_security_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_real_property/079_real_property_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's issue from /workspace/documents/04_debt_security/031_debt_security_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_real_property/079_real_property_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's severity from /workspace/documents/04_debt_security/031_debt_security_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_real_property/079_real_property_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's primary_source from /workspace/documents/04_debt_security/031_debt_security_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_real_property/079_real_property_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/04_debt_security/031_debt_security_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_real_property/079_real_property_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-11 using the exact controlled facts ['Talia Brooks', 'Caleb Hassan'].", "id": "findings.F-11.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-11's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-11.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-04', 'Owen Delgado'] for F-11.", "id": "findings.F-11.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-12 exception for threatened customer dispute.", "id": "findings.F-12.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's id from /workspace/documents/05_employment/034_employment_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_tax_insurance/082_tax_insurance_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's issue from /workspace/documents/05_employment/034_employment_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_tax_insurance/082_tax_insurance_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's severity from /workspace/documents/05_employment/034_employment_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_tax_insurance/082_tax_insurance_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's primary_source from /workspace/documents/05_employment/034_employment_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_tax_insurance/082_tax_insurance_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/05_employment/034_employment_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_tax_insurance/082_tax_insurance_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-12 using the exact controlled facts ['closed without exception', 'CB-MA-2401-L867', 'open and escalated', 'CB-MA-2401-U159'].", "id": "findings.F-12.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-12's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-12.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-04', 'Lena Varga'] for F-12.", "id": "findings.F-12.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-13 exception for facility title exception.", "id": "findings.F-13.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's id from /workspace/documents/05_employment/037_employment_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_tax_insurance/085_tax_insurance_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's issue from /workspace/documents/05_employment/037_employment_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_tax_insurance/085_tax_insurance_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's severity from /workspace/documents/05_employment/037_employment_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_tax_insurance/085_tax_insurance_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's primary_source from /workspace/documents/05_employment/037_employment_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_tax_insurance/085_tax_insurance_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/05_employment/037_employment_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_tax_insurance/085_tax_insurance_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-13 using the exact controlled facts ['Washoe County, Nevada', 'Delaware'].", "id": "findings.F-13.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-13's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-13.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-04', 'Samuel Kim'] for F-13.", "id": "findings.F-13.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-14 exception for sales-tax nexus gap.", "id": "findings.F-14.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's id from /workspace/documents/05_employment/040_employment_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_tax_insurance/088_tax_insurance_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's issue from /workspace/documents/05_employment/040_employment_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_tax_insurance/088_tax_insurance_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's severity from /workspace/documents/05_employment/040_employment_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_tax_insurance/088_tax_insurance_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's primary_source from /workspace/documents/05_employment/040_employment_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_tax_insurance/088_tax_insurance_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/05_employment/040_employment_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_tax_insurance/088_tax_insurance_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-14 using the exact controlled facts ['10%', '12%'].", "id": "findings.F-14.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-14's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-14.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-04', 'Maya Ellison'] for F-14.", "id": "findings.F-14.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-15 exception for claims-made insurance tail.", "id": "findings.F-15.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's id from /workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/043_ip_technology_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_financials/091_financials_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's issue from /workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/043_ip_technology_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_financials/091_financials_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's severity from /workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/043_ip_technology_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_financials/091_financials_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's primary_source from /workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/043_ip_technology_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_financials/091_financials_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/043_ip_technology_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_financials/091_financials_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-15 using the exact controlled facts ['notices-helios_forge_inc@example.test', 'archive-bluepeak_battery_systems_llc@example.test'].", "id": "findings.F-15.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-15's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-15.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-04', 'Rafael Okafor'] for F-15.", "id": "findings.F-15.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-16 exception for revenue recognition exception.", "id": "findings.F-16.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's id from /workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/046_ip_technology_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_financials/094_financials_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's issue from /workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/046_ip_technology_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_financials/094_financials_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's severity from /workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/046_ip_technology_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_financials/094_financials_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's primary_source from /workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/046_ip_technology_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_financials/094_financials_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/046_ip_technology_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_financials/094_financials_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-16 using the exact controlled facts ['89 records', '2025-02-13', '67 records', '2025-03-24'].", "id": "findings.F-16.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-16's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-16.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-04', 'Nora Chen'] for F-16.", "id": "findings.F-16.action_anchors"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Executive assessment' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Executive assessment"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Method and record coverage' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Method and record coverage"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Findings' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Findings"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Recommended next actions' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Recommended next actions"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Assumptions and limitations' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Assumptions and limitations"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-01 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-01"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-02 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-02"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-03 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-03"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-04 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-04"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-05 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-05"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-06 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-06"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-07 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-07"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-08 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-08"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-09 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-09"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-10 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-10"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-11 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-11"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-12 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-12"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-13 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-13"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-14 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-14"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-15 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-15"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-16 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-16"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Do not claim the production has no issues or that every record is consistent.", "id": "memo.forbidden_claims_absent"}], "decision_options": [{"id": "cross-source-reconciliation", "label": "Reconcile controlling and corroborating records", "reason": "The CB-MA-2401 production contains independently maintained records; a defensible answer must preserve each supported conflict and its cure owner.", "selected": true}, {"id": "latest-record-controls", "label": "Treat the latest record as controlling", "reason": "Timestamp recency does not establish legal priority, execution, or approval authority.", "selected": false}, {"id": "primary-records-only", "label": "Report primary records without reconciliation", "reason": "Primary records alone conceal the operational conflicts that create the actionable exceptions.", "selected": false}], "gates": ["all_evidence_read_in_full", "chain_of_custody_metadata_checked", "findings_criteria_complete", "memo_criteria_complete", "deliverables_written_through_mcp"], "metadata_checks": 8, "metric": "weighted_criteria_score", "minimum_tool_calls": 46, "required_deliverables": ["findings.json", "advice.md"], "required_document_reads": 33, "type": "deterministic", "weights": {"findings": 0.55, "memo": 0.2, "procedure": 0.25}}, "task_id": "cb100-001-helios-forge", "task_name": "Project Daybreak battery acquisition", "world_id": "counselbench-filesystem-mcp-v2"}
-{"context_files": ["task_files/cb100-002-northstar-orbit/01_corporate/001_corporate_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-002-northstar-orbit/01_corporate/002_corporate_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-002-northstar-orbit/01_corporate/003_corporate_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-002-northstar-orbit/01_corporate/004_corporate_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-002-northstar-orbit/01_corporate/005_corporate_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-002-northstar-orbit/01_corporate/006_corporate_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-002-northstar-orbit/01_corporate/007_corporate_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-002-northstar-orbit/01_corporate/008_corporate_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-002-northstar-orbit/02_capitalization/009_capitalization_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-002-northstar-orbit/02_capitalization/010_capitalization_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-002-northstar-orbit/02_capitalization/011_capitalization_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-002-northstar-orbit/02_capitalization/012_capitalization_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-002-northstar-orbit/02_capitalization/013_capitalization_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-002-northstar-orbit/02_capitalization/014_capitalization_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-002-northstar-orbit/02_capitalization/015_capitalization_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-002-northstar-orbit/02_capitalization/016_capitalization_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-002-northstar-orbit/03_material_contracts/017_material_contracts_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-002-northstar-orbit/03_material_contracts/018_material_contracts_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-002-northstar-orbit/03_material_contracts/019_material_contracts_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-002-northstar-orbit/03_material_contracts/020_material_contracts_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-002-northstar-orbit/03_material_contracts/021_material_contracts_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-002-northstar-orbit/03_material_contracts/022_material_contracts_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-002-northstar-orbit/03_material_contracts/023_material_contracts_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-002-northstar-orbit/03_material_contracts/024_material_contracts_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-002-northstar-orbit/04_debt_security/025_debt_security_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-002-northstar-orbit/04_debt_security/026_debt_security_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-002-northstar-orbit/04_debt_security/027_debt_security_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-002-northstar-orbit/04_debt_security/028_debt_security_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-002-northstar-orbit/04_debt_security/029_debt_security_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-002-northstar-orbit/04_debt_security/030_debt_security_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-002-northstar-orbit/04_debt_security/031_debt_security_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-002-northstar-orbit/04_debt_security/032_debt_security_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-002-northstar-orbit/05_employment/033_employment_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-002-northstar-orbit/05_employment/034_employment_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-002-northstar-orbit/05_employment/035_employment_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-002-northstar-orbit/05_employment/036_employment_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-002-northstar-orbit/05_employment/037_employment_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-002-northstar-orbit/05_employment/038_employment_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-002-northstar-orbit/05_employment/039_employment_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-002-northstar-orbit/05_employment/040_employment_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-002-northstar-orbit/06_ip_technology/041_ip_technology_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-002-northstar-orbit/06_ip_technology/042_ip_technology_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-002-northstar-orbit/06_ip_technology/043_ip_technology_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-002-northstar-orbit/06_ip_technology/044_ip_technology_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-002-northstar-orbit/06_ip_technology/045_ip_technology_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-002-northstar-orbit/06_ip_technology/046_ip_technology_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-002-northstar-orbit/06_ip_technology/047_ip_technology_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-002-northstar-orbit/06_ip_technology/048_ip_technology_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-002-northstar-orbit/07_privacy_security/049_privacy_security_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-002-northstar-orbit/07_privacy_security/050_privacy_security_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-002-northstar-orbit/07_privacy_security/051_privacy_security_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-002-northstar-orbit/07_privacy_security/052_privacy_security_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-002-northstar-orbit/07_privacy_security/053_privacy_security_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-002-northstar-orbit/07_privacy_security/054_privacy_security_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-002-northstar-orbit/07_privacy_security/055_privacy_security_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-002-northstar-orbit/07_privacy_security/056_privacy_security_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-002-northstar-orbit/08_regulatory/057_regulatory_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-002-northstar-orbit/08_regulatory/058_regulatory_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-002-northstar-orbit/08_regulatory/059_regulatory_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-002-northstar-orbit/08_regulatory/060_regulatory_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-002-northstar-orbit/08_regulatory/061_regulatory_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-002-northstar-orbit/08_regulatory/062_regulatory_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-002-northstar-orbit/08_regulatory/063_regulatory_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-002-northstar-orbit/08_regulatory/064_regulatory_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-002-northstar-orbit/09_litigation/065_litigation_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-002-northstar-orbit/09_litigation/066_litigation_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-002-northstar-orbit/09_litigation/067_litigation_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-002-northstar-orbit/09_litigation/068_litigation_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-002-northstar-orbit/09_litigation/069_litigation_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-002-northstar-orbit/09_litigation/070_litigation_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-002-northstar-orbit/09_litigation/071_litigation_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-002-northstar-orbit/09_litigation/072_litigation_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-002-northstar-orbit/10_real_property/073_real_property_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-002-northstar-orbit/10_real_property/074_real_property_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-002-northstar-orbit/10_real_property/075_real_property_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-002-northstar-orbit/10_real_property/076_real_property_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-002-northstar-orbit/10_real_property/077_real_property_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-002-northstar-orbit/10_real_property/078_real_property_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-002-northstar-orbit/10_real_property/079_real_property_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-002-northstar-orbit/10_real_property/080_real_property_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-002-northstar-orbit/11_tax_insurance/081_tax_insurance_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-002-northstar-orbit/11_tax_insurance/082_tax_insurance_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-002-northstar-orbit/11_tax_insurance/083_tax_insurance_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-002-northstar-orbit/11_tax_insurance/084_tax_insurance_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-002-northstar-orbit/11_tax_insurance/085_tax_insurance_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-002-northstar-orbit/11_tax_insurance/086_tax_insurance_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-002-northstar-orbit/11_tax_insurance/087_tax_insurance_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-002-northstar-orbit/11_tax_insurance/088_tax_insurance_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-002-northstar-orbit/12_financials/089_financials_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-002-northstar-orbit/12_financials/090_financials_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-002-northstar-orbit/12_financials/091_financials_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-002-northstar-orbit/12_financials/092_financials_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-002-northstar-orbit/12_financials/093_financials_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-002-northstar-orbit/12_financials/094_financials_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-002-northstar-orbit/12_financials/095_financials_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-002-northstar-orbit/12_financials/096_financials_status_report.md"], "gold_output": {"advice_markdown": "# Counsel advice — Project Sextant satellite software merger\n\n## Executive assessment\n\nFor Northstar Orbit plc matter CB-MA-2402, the review identified 16 source-supported exceptions requiring action before 2026-09-08. The assessment concerns Aster Vale Navigation Corp. and the supplied record for Delaware.\n\n## Method and record coverage\n\nThe review inventoried all 96 production files, read the 33 controlling, corroborating, and control records, searched the email exports, and checked metadata for the designated chain-of-custody sample. Conclusions are limited to the synthetic production supplied for this benchmark matter.\n\n## Findings\n\n### F-01 — charter authorization mismatch (critical)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for charter authorization mismatch: one source states the operative date is 2025-07-16 under control reference CB-MA-2402-A714, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2025-08-03 under response reference CB-MA-2402-J285.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/01_corporate/001_corporate_control_register.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/07_privacy_security/049_privacy_security_control_register.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-08, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Sofia Bennett.\n\n### F-02 — unrecorded option grant (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for unrecorded option grant: one source states the controlling amount is $1,059,514.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $1,365,528.00.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/01_corporate/004_corporate_ledger_export.csv`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/07_privacy_security/052_privacy_security_ledger_export.csv`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-08, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Adrian Mensah.\n\n### F-03 — change-of-control consent (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for change-of-control consent: one source states approval is attributed to Jonas Feld as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Micah Sullivan and contains no entry for Jonas Feld.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/01_corporate/007_corporate_officer_certificate.html`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/07_privacy_security/055_privacy_security_officer_certificate.html`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-08, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Willa Novak.\n\n### F-04 — anti-assignment restriction (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for anti-assignment restriction: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-MA-2402-D177, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-MA-2402-M452.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/02_capitalization/010_capitalization_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/08_regulatory/058_regulatory_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-08, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Theo Laurent.\n\n### F-05 — most-favored-customer exposure (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for most-favored-customer exposure: one source states the applicable location is District of Colorado, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to Delaware operations outside District of Colorado.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/02_capitalization/013_capitalization_review_memorandum.json`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/08_regulatory/061_regulatory_review_memorandum.json`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-08, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Amara Patel.\n\n### F-06 — financial covenant breach (low)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for financial covenant breach: one source states the threshold is 9% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 12% and produced a different exception result.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/02_capitalization/016_capitalization_status_report.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/08_regulatory/064_regulatory_status_report.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-08, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Henry Cho.\n\n### F-07 — key-person retention gap (critical)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for key-person retention gap: one source states formal notice must use notices-northstar_orbit_plc@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-aster_vale_navigation_corp@example.test.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/019_material_contracts_correspondence.eml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/09_litigation/067_litigation_correspondence.eml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-08, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Nadine Flores.\n\n### F-08 — invention assignment defect (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for invention assignment defect: one source states the governed population contains 184 records through 2025-05-19, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 65 records through 2025-06-25.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/022_material_contracts_formal_notice.xml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/09_litigation/070_litigation_formal_notice.xml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-08, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Micah Sullivan.\n\n### F-09 — open-source copyleft exposure (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for open-source copyleft exposure: one source states the operative date is 2026-02-26 under control reference CB-MA-2402-I759, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2026-03-14 under response reference CB-MA-2402-R427.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/04_debt_security/025_debt_security_control_register.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/10_real_property/073_real_property_control_register.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-08, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Farah Ibrahim.\n\n### F-10 — unreported security incident (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for unreported security incident: one source states the controlling amount is $368,345.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $463,190.00.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/04_debt_security/028_debt_security_ledger_export.csv`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/10_real_property/076_real_property_ledger_export.csv`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-08, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Owen Delgado.\n\n### F-11 — permit transfer restriction (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for permit transfer restriction: one source states approval is attributed to Jonas Feld as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Isaac Romero and contains no entry for Jonas Feld.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/04_debt_security/031_debt_security_officer_certificate.html`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/10_real_property/079_real_property_officer_certificate.html`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-08, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Lena Varga.\n\n### F-12 — threatened customer dispute (low)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for threatened customer dispute: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-MA-2402-L174, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-MA-2402-U728.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/05_employment/034_employment_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/11_tax_insurance/082_tax_insurance_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-08, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Samuel Kim.\n\n### F-13 — facility title exception (critical)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for facility title exception: one source states the applicable location is District of Colorado, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to Delaware operations outside District of Colorado.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/05_employment/037_employment_review_memorandum.json`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/11_tax_insurance/085_tax_insurance_review_memorandum.json`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-08, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Maya Ellison.\n\n### F-14 — sales-tax nexus gap (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for sales-tax nexus gap: one source states the threshold is 2% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 4% and produced a different exception result.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/05_employment/040_employment_status_report.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/11_tax_insurance/088_tax_insurance_status_report.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-08, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Rafael Okafor.\n\n### F-15 — claims-made insurance tail (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for claims-made insurance tail: one source states formal notice must use notices-northstar_orbit_plc@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-aster_vale_navigation_corp@example.test.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/043_ip_technology_correspondence.eml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/12_financials/091_financials_correspondence.eml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-08, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Nora Chen.\n\n### F-16 — revenue recognition exception (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for revenue recognition exception: one source states the governed population contains 78 records through 2025-06-22, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 63 records through 2025-07-27.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/046_ip_technology_formal_notice.xml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/12_financials/094_financials_formal_notice.xml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-08, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Dominic Alvarez.\n\n## Recommended next actions\n\nSequence the critical and high findings first, assign the named owners, preserve the cited records, and document any resolution in the controlling matter register before the stated deadline.\n\n## Assumptions and limitations\n\nThis analysis is confined to task cb100-002-northstar-orbit and the supplied synthetic evidence. It does not rely on external facts, does not resolve disputed law, and is not legal advice for a real person or entity.\n", "findings": {"as_of": "2026-09-08", "findings": [{"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/07_privacy_security/049_privacy_security_control_register.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for charter authorization mismatch: one source states the operative date is 2025-07-16 under control reference CB-MA-2402-A714, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2025-08-03 under response reference CB-MA-2402-J285.", "id": "F-01", "issue": "charter authorization mismatch", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/01_corporate/001_corporate_control_register.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-08, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Sofia Bennett.", "severity": "critical"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/07_privacy_security/052_privacy_security_ledger_export.csv", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for unrecorded option grant: one source states the controlling amount is $1,059,514.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $1,365,528.00.", "id": "F-02", "issue": "unrecorded option grant", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/01_corporate/004_corporate_ledger_export.csv", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-08, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Adrian Mensah.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/07_privacy_security/055_privacy_security_officer_certificate.html", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for change-of-control consent: one source states approval is attributed to Jonas Feld as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Micah Sullivan and contains no entry for Jonas Feld.", "id": "F-03", "issue": "change-of-control consent", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/01_corporate/007_corporate_officer_certificate.html", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-08, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Willa Novak.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/08_regulatory/058_regulatory_executed_instrument.txt", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for anti-assignment restriction: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-MA-2402-D177, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-MA-2402-M452.", "id": "F-04", "issue": "anti-assignment restriction", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/02_capitalization/010_capitalization_executed_instrument.txt", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-08, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Theo Laurent.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/08_regulatory/061_regulatory_review_memorandum.json", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for most-favored-customer exposure: one source states the applicable location is District of Colorado, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to Delaware operations outside District of Colorado.", "id": "F-05", "issue": "most-favored-customer exposure", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/02_capitalization/013_capitalization_review_memorandum.json", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-08, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Amara Patel.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/08_regulatory/064_regulatory_status_report.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for financial covenant breach: one source states the threshold is 9% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 12% and produced a different exception result.", "id": "F-06", "issue": "financial covenant breach", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/02_capitalization/016_capitalization_status_report.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-08, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Henry Cho.", "severity": "low"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/09_litigation/067_litigation_correspondence.eml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for key-person retention gap: one source states formal notice must use notices-northstar_orbit_plc@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-aster_vale_navigation_corp@example.test.", "id": "F-07", "issue": "key-person retention gap", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/019_material_contracts_correspondence.eml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-08, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Nadine Flores.", "severity": "critical"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/09_litigation/070_litigation_formal_notice.xml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for invention assignment defect: one source states the governed population contains 184 records through 2025-05-19, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 65 records through 2025-06-25.", "id": "F-08", "issue": "invention assignment defect", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/022_material_contracts_formal_notice.xml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-08, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Micah Sullivan.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/10_real_property/073_real_property_control_register.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for open-source copyleft exposure: one source states the operative date is 2026-02-26 under control reference CB-MA-2402-I759, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2026-03-14 under response reference CB-MA-2402-R427.", "id": "F-09", "issue": "open-source copyleft exposure", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/04_debt_security/025_debt_security_control_register.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-08, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Farah Ibrahim.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/10_real_property/076_real_property_ledger_export.csv", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for unreported security incident: one source states the controlling amount is $368,345.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $463,190.00.", "id": "F-10", "issue": "unreported security incident", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/04_debt_security/028_debt_security_ledger_export.csv", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-08, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Owen Delgado.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/10_real_property/079_real_property_officer_certificate.html", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for permit transfer restriction: one source states approval is attributed to Jonas Feld as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Isaac Romero and contains no entry for Jonas Feld.", "id": "F-11", "issue": "permit transfer restriction", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/04_debt_security/031_debt_security_officer_certificate.html", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-08, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Lena Varga.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/11_tax_insurance/082_tax_insurance_executed_instrument.txt", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for threatened customer dispute: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-MA-2402-L174, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-MA-2402-U728.", "id": "F-12", "issue": "threatened customer dispute", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/05_employment/034_employment_executed_instrument.txt", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-08, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Samuel Kim.", "severity": "low"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/11_tax_insurance/085_tax_insurance_review_memorandum.json", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for facility title exception: one source states the applicable location is District of Colorado, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to Delaware operations outside District of Colorado.", "id": "F-13", "issue": "facility title exception", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/05_employment/037_employment_review_memorandum.json", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-08, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Maya Ellison.", "severity": "critical"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/11_tax_insurance/088_tax_insurance_status_report.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for sales-tax nexus gap: one source states the threshold is 2% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 4% and produced a different exception result.", "id": "F-14", "issue": "sales-tax nexus gap", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/05_employment/040_employment_status_report.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-08, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Rafael Okafor.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/12_financials/091_financials_correspondence.eml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for claims-made insurance tail: one source states formal notice must use notices-northstar_orbit_plc@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-aster_vale_navigation_corp@example.test.", "id": "F-15", "issue": "claims-made insurance tail", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/043_ip_technology_correspondence.eml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-08, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Nora Chen.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/12_financials/094_financials_formal_notice.xml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for revenue recognition exception: one source states the governed population contains 78 records through 2025-06-22, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 63 records through 2025-07-27.", "id": "F-16", "issue": "revenue recognition exception", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/046_ip_technology_formal_notice.xml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-08, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Dominic Alvarez.", "severity": "medium"}], "matter_number": "CB-MA-2402", "prepared_for": "Northstar Orbit plc", "schema_version": "1.0", "task_id": "cb100-002-northstar-orbit"}}, "metadata": {"benchmark": "CounselBench-100", "code_license": "Apache-2.0", "data_license": "CC-BY-4.0", "deadline": "2026-09-08", "document_count": 96, "jurisdiction": "Delaware", "matter_number": "CB-MA-2402", "mcp_commit": "9a96ea6e5913736f92b88345bf51caeaaa8e719f", "mcp_package": "@modelcontextprotocol/server-filesystem@2026.7.10", "practice_area": "corporate-ma", "reference_tool_calls": 46, "required_evidence_reads": 33, "synthetic": true, "venue": "District of Colorado", "version": "2.0.0"}, "prompt": "You are buyer-side transactions counsel for Northstar Orbit plc. A late document production changed the factual picture, and the matter team needs the entire record reconciled from first principles. The target licenses university navigation code, operates a classified support unit, and recently refinanced through a lender with blanket liens. Decision due 2026-09-08. Delaware law governs; District of Colorado is the forum. Separate confirmed exceptions from items that merely require follow-up. Work out the defensible position from the matter production and leave an audit-ready exception tracker and concise advice for the supervising lawyer. Keep confirmed conflicts separate from open questions, cite the records that actually control each conclusion, and do not fill gaps with outside facts.", "rubric": {"criteria": [{"category": "procedure", "description": "Complete at least 46 successful, argument-specific evidence and output calls.", "id": "procedure.minimum_successful_tool_calls"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Find and read the 33 controlling, corroborating, and work-product-control records in full.", "id": "procedure.all_evidence_read_in_full"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Inspect file metadata for the eight designated critical primary records before relying on them.", "id": "procedure.chain_of_custody_metadata_checked"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Confirm the sandbox's allowed document and output roots.", "id": "procedure.allowed_directories_checked"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Inventory all 96 records so the relevant sources are discovered among the context records.", "id": "procedure.recursive_inventory_completed"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Search the production for email evidence that may corroborate or contradict formal records.", "id": "procedure.targeted_search_completed"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Leave only findings.json and advice.md in the output workspace.", "id": "procedure.exact_deliverable_set"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Create both final work products through the sandbox MCP surface.", "id": "procedure.deliverables_written_through_mcp"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Produce findings.json as a valid JSON object.", "id": "findings.findings_is_object"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Report exactly 16 confirmed exceptions.", "id": "findings.findings_exact_count"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Use each stable finding ID exactly once.", "id": "findings.finding_ids_unique"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set schema_version to the released matter value '1.0'.", "id": "findings.top_level_schema_version"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set task_id to the released matter value 'cb100-002-northstar-orbit'.", "id": "findings.top_level_task_id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set matter_number to the released matter value 'CB-MA-2402'.", "id": "findings.top_level_matter_number"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set prepared_for to the released matter value 'Northstar Orbit plc'.", "id": "findings.top_level_prepared_for"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set as_of to the released matter value '2026-09-08'.", "id": "findings.top_level_as_of"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-01 exception for charter authorization mismatch.", "id": "findings.F-01.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's id from /workspace/documents/01_corporate/001_corporate_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_privacy_security/049_privacy_security_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's issue from /workspace/documents/01_corporate/001_corporate_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_privacy_security/049_privacy_security_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's severity from /workspace/documents/01_corporate/001_corporate_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_privacy_security/049_privacy_security_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's primary_source from /workspace/documents/01_corporate/001_corporate_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_privacy_security/049_privacy_security_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/01_corporate/001_corporate_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_privacy_security/049_privacy_security_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-01 using the exact controlled facts ['2025-07-16', 'CB-MA-2402-A714', '2025-08-03', 'CB-MA-2402-J285'].", "id": "findings.F-01.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-01's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-01.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-08', 'Sofia Bennett'] for F-01.", "id": "findings.F-01.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-02 exception for unrecorded option grant.", "id": "findings.F-02.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's id from /workspace/documents/01_corporate/004_corporate_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_privacy_security/052_privacy_security_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's issue from /workspace/documents/01_corporate/004_corporate_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_privacy_security/052_privacy_security_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's severity from /workspace/documents/01_corporate/004_corporate_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_privacy_security/052_privacy_security_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's primary_source from /workspace/documents/01_corporate/004_corporate_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_privacy_security/052_privacy_security_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/01_corporate/004_corporate_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_privacy_security/052_privacy_security_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-02 using the exact controlled facts ['$1,059,514.00', '$1,365,528.00'].", "id": "findings.F-02.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-02's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-02.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-08', 'Adrian Mensah'] for F-02.", "id": "findings.F-02.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-03 exception for change-of-control consent.", "id": "findings.F-03.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's id from /workspace/documents/01_corporate/007_corporate_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_privacy_security/055_privacy_security_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's issue from /workspace/documents/01_corporate/007_corporate_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_privacy_security/055_privacy_security_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's severity from /workspace/documents/01_corporate/007_corporate_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_privacy_security/055_privacy_security_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's primary_source from /workspace/documents/01_corporate/007_corporate_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_privacy_security/055_privacy_security_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/01_corporate/007_corporate_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_privacy_security/055_privacy_security_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-03 using the exact controlled facts ['Jonas Feld', 'Micah Sullivan'].", "id": "findings.F-03.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-03's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-03.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-08', 'Willa Novak'] for F-03.", "id": "findings.F-03.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-04 exception for anti-assignment restriction.", "id": "findings.F-04.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's id from /workspace/documents/02_capitalization/010_capitalization_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_regulatory/058_regulatory_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's issue from /workspace/documents/02_capitalization/010_capitalization_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_regulatory/058_regulatory_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's severity from /workspace/documents/02_capitalization/010_capitalization_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_regulatory/058_regulatory_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's primary_source from /workspace/documents/02_capitalization/010_capitalization_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_regulatory/058_regulatory_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/02_capitalization/010_capitalization_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_regulatory/058_regulatory_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-04 using the exact controlled facts ['closed without exception', 'CB-MA-2402-D177', 'open and escalated', 'CB-MA-2402-M452'].", "id": "findings.F-04.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-04's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-04.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-08', 'Theo Laurent'] for F-04.", "id": "findings.F-04.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-05 exception for most-favored-customer exposure.", "id": "findings.F-05.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's id from /workspace/documents/02_capitalization/013_capitalization_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_regulatory/061_regulatory_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's issue from /workspace/documents/02_capitalization/013_capitalization_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_regulatory/061_regulatory_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's severity from /workspace/documents/02_capitalization/013_capitalization_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_regulatory/061_regulatory_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's primary_source from /workspace/documents/02_capitalization/013_capitalization_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_regulatory/061_regulatory_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/02_capitalization/013_capitalization_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_regulatory/061_regulatory_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-05 using the exact controlled facts ['District of Colorado', 'Delaware'].", "id": "findings.F-05.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-05's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-05.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-08', 'Amara Patel'] for F-05.", "id": "findings.F-05.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-06 exception for financial covenant breach.", "id": "findings.F-06.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's id from /workspace/documents/02_capitalization/016_capitalization_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_regulatory/064_regulatory_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's issue from /workspace/documents/02_capitalization/016_capitalization_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_regulatory/064_regulatory_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's severity from /workspace/documents/02_capitalization/016_capitalization_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_regulatory/064_regulatory_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's primary_source from /workspace/documents/02_capitalization/016_capitalization_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_regulatory/064_regulatory_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/02_capitalization/016_capitalization_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_regulatory/064_regulatory_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-06 using the exact controlled facts ['9%', '12%'].", "id": "findings.F-06.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-06's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-06.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-08', 'Henry Cho'] for F-06.", "id": "findings.F-06.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-07 exception for key-person retention gap.", "id": "findings.F-07.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's id from /workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/019_material_contracts_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_litigation/067_litigation_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's issue from /workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/019_material_contracts_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_litigation/067_litigation_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's severity from /workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/019_material_contracts_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_litigation/067_litigation_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's primary_source from /workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/019_material_contracts_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_litigation/067_litigation_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/019_material_contracts_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_litigation/067_litigation_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-07 using the exact controlled facts ['notices-northstar_orbit_plc@example.test', 'archive-aster_vale_navigation_corp@example.test'].", "id": "findings.F-07.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-07's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-07.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-08', 'Nadine Flores'] for F-07.", "id": "findings.F-07.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-08 exception for invention assignment defect.", "id": "findings.F-08.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's id from /workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/022_material_contracts_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_litigation/070_litigation_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's issue from /workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/022_material_contracts_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_litigation/070_litigation_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's severity from /workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/022_material_contracts_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_litigation/070_litigation_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's primary_source from /workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/022_material_contracts_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_litigation/070_litigation_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/022_material_contracts_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_litigation/070_litigation_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-08 using the exact controlled facts ['184 records', '2025-05-19', '65 records', '2025-06-25'].", "id": "findings.F-08.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-08's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-08.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-08', 'Micah Sullivan'] for F-08.", "id": "findings.F-08.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-09 exception for open-source copyleft exposure.", "id": "findings.F-09.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's id from /workspace/documents/04_debt_security/025_debt_security_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_real_property/073_real_property_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's issue from /workspace/documents/04_debt_security/025_debt_security_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_real_property/073_real_property_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's severity from /workspace/documents/04_debt_security/025_debt_security_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_real_property/073_real_property_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's primary_source from /workspace/documents/04_debt_security/025_debt_security_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_real_property/073_real_property_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/04_debt_security/025_debt_security_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_real_property/073_real_property_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-09 using the exact controlled facts ['2026-02-26', 'CB-MA-2402-I759', '2026-03-14', 'CB-MA-2402-R427'].", "id": "findings.F-09.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-09's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-09.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-08', 'Farah Ibrahim'] for F-09.", "id": "findings.F-09.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-10 exception for unreported security incident.", "id": "findings.F-10.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's id from /workspace/documents/04_debt_security/028_debt_security_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_real_property/076_real_property_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's issue from /workspace/documents/04_debt_security/028_debt_security_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_real_property/076_real_property_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's severity from /workspace/documents/04_debt_security/028_debt_security_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_real_property/076_real_property_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's primary_source from /workspace/documents/04_debt_security/028_debt_security_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_real_property/076_real_property_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/04_debt_security/028_debt_security_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_real_property/076_real_property_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-10 using the exact controlled facts ['$368,345.00', '$463,190.00'].", "id": "findings.F-10.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-10's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-10.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-08', 'Owen Delgado'] for F-10.", "id": "findings.F-10.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-11 exception for permit transfer restriction.", "id": "findings.F-11.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's id from /workspace/documents/04_debt_security/031_debt_security_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_real_property/079_real_property_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's issue from /workspace/documents/04_debt_security/031_debt_security_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_real_property/079_real_property_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's severity from /workspace/documents/04_debt_security/031_debt_security_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_real_property/079_real_property_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's primary_source from /workspace/documents/04_debt_security/031_debt_security_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_real_property/079_real_property_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/04_debt_security/031_debt_security_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_real_property/079_real_property_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-11 using the exact controlled facts ['Jonas Feld', 'Isaac Romero'].", "id": "findings.F-11.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-11's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-11.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-08', 'Lena Varga'] for F-11.", "id": "findings.F-11.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-12 exception for threatened customer dispute.", "id": "findings.F-12.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's id from /workspace/documents/05_employment/034_employment_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_tax_insurance/082_tax_insurance_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's issue from /workspace/documents/05_employment/034_employment_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_tax_insurance/082_tax_insurance_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's severity from /workspace/documents/05_employment/034_employment_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_tax_insurance/082_tax_insurance_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's primary_source from /workspace/documents/05_employment/034_employment_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_tax_insurance/082_tax_insurance_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/05_employment/034_employment_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_tax_insurance/082_tax_insurance_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-12 using the exact controlled facts ['closed without exception', 'CB-MA-2402-L174', 'open and escalated', 'CB-MA-2402-U728'].", "id": "findings.F-12.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-12's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-12.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-08', 'Samuel Kim'] for F-12.", "id": "findings.F-12.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-13 exception for facility title exception.", "id": "findings.F-13.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's id from /workspace/documents/05_employment/037_employment_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_tax_insurance/085_tax_insurance_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's issue from /workspace/documents/05_employment/037_employment_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_tax_insurance/085_tax_insurance_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's severity from /workspace/documents/05_employment/037_employment_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_tax_insurance/085_tax_insurance_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's primary_source from /workspace/documents/05_employment/037_employment_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_tax_insurance/085_tax_insurance_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/05_employment/037_employment_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_tax_insurance/085_tax_insurance_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-13 using the exact controlled facts ['District of Colorado', 'Delaware'].", "id": "findings.F-13.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-13's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-13.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-08', 'Maya Ellison'] for F-13.", "id": "findings.F-13.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-14 exception for sales-tax nexus gap.", "id": "findings.F-14.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's id from /workspace/documents/05_employment/040_employment_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_tax_insurance/088_tax_insurance_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's issue from /workspace/documents/05_employment/040_employment_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_tax_insurance/088_tax_insurance_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's severity from /workspace/documents/05_employment/040_employment_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_tax_insurance/088_tax_insurance_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's primary_source from /workspace/documents/05_employment/040_employment_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_tax_insurance/088_tax_insurance_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/05_employment/040_employment_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_tax_insurance/088_tax_insurance_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-14 using the exact controlled facts ['2%', '4%'].", "id": "findings.F-14.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-14's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-14.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-08', 'Rafael Okafor'] for F-14.", "id": "findings.F-14.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-15 exception for claims-made insurance tail.", "id": "findings.F-15.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's id from /workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/043_ip_technology_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_financials/091_financials_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's issue from /workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/043_ip_technology_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_financials/091_financials_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's severity from /workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/043_ip_technology_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_financials/091_financials_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's primary_source from /workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/043_ip_technology_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_financials/091_financials_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/043_ip_technology_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_financials/091_financials_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-15 using the exact controlled facts ['notices-northstar_orbit_plc@example.test', 'archive-aster_vale_navigation_corp@example.test'].", "id": "findings.F-15.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-15's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-15.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-08', 'Nora Chen'] for F-15.", "id": "findings.F-15.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-16 exception for revenue recognition exception.", "id": "findings.F-16.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's id from /workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/046_ip_technology_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_financials/094_financials_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's issue from /workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/046_ip_technology_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_financials/094_financials_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's severity from /workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/046_ip_technology_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_financials/094_financials_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's primary_source from /workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/046_ip_technology_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_financials/094_financials_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/046_ip_technology_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_financials/094_financials_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-16 using the exact controlled facts ['78 records', '2025-06-22', '63 records', '2025-07-27'].", "id": "findings.F-16.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-16's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-16.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-08', 'Dominic Alvarez'] for F-16.", "id": "findings.F-16.action_anchors"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Executive assessment' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Executive assessment"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Method and record coverage' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Method and record coverage"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Findings' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Findings"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Recommended next actions' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Recommended next actions"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Assumptions and limitations' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Assumptions and limitations"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-01 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-01"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-02 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-02"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-03 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-03"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-04 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-04"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-05 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-05"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-06 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-06"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-07 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-07"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-08 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-08"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-09 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-09"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-10 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-10"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-11 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-11"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-12 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-12"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-13 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-13"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-14 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-14"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-15 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-15"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-16 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-16"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Do not claim the production has no issues or that every record is consistent.", "id": "memo.forbidden_claims_absent"}], "decision_options": [{"id": "cross-source-reconciliation", "label": "Reconcile controlling and corroborating records", "reason": "The CB-MA-2402 production contains independently maintained records; a defensible answer must preserve each supported conflict and its cure owner.", "selected": true}, {"id": "latest-record-controls", "label": "Treat the latest record as controlling", "reason": "Timestamp recency does not establish legal priority, execution, or approval authority.", "selected": false}, {"id": "primary-records-only", "label": "Report primary records without reconciliation", "reason": "Primary records alone conceal the operational conflicts that create the actionable exceptions.", "selected": false}], "gates": ["all_evidence_read_in_full", "chain_of_custody_metadata_checked", "findings_criteria_complete", "memo_criteria_complete", "deliverables_written_through_mcp"], "metadata_checks": 8, "metric": "weighted_criteria_score", "minimum_tool_calls": 46, "required_deliverables": ["findings.json", "advice.md"], "required_document_reads": 33, "type": "deterministic", "weights": {"findings": 0.55, "memo": 0.2, "procedure": 0.25}}, "task_id": "cb100-002-northstar-orbit", "task_name": "Project Sextant satellite software merger", "world_id": "counselbench-filesystem-mcp-v2"}
-{"context_files": ["task_files/cb100-003-lumen-health/01_corporate/001_corporate_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-003-lumen-health/01_corporate/002_corporate_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-003-lumen-health/01_corporate/003_corporate_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-003-lumen-health/01_corporate/004_corporate_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-003-lumen-health/01_corporate/005_corporate_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-003-lumen-health/01_corporate/006_corporate_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-003-lumen-health/01_corporate/007_corporate_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-003-lumen-health/01_corporate/008_corporate_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-003-lumen-health/02_capitalization/009_capitalization_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-003-lumen-health/02_capitalization/010_capitalization_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-003-lumen-health/02_capitalization/011_capitalization_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-003-lumen-health/02_capitalization/012_capitalization_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-003-lumen-health/02_capitalization/013_capitalization_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-003-lumen-health/02_capitalization/014_capitalization_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-003-lumen-health/02_capitalization/015_capitalization_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-003-lumen-health/02_capitalization/016_capitalization_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-003-lumen-health/03_material_contracts/017_material_contracts_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-003-lumen-health/03_material_contracts/018_material_contracts_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-003-lumen-health/03_material_contracts/019_material_contracts_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-003-lumen-health/03_material_contracts/020_material_contracts_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-003-lumen-health/03_material_contracts/021_material_contracts_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-003-lumen-health/03_material_contracts/022_material_contracts_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-003-lumen-health/03_material_contracts/023_material_contracts_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-003-lumen-health/03_material_contracts/024_material_contracts_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-003-lumen-health/04_debt_security/025_debt_security_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-003-lumen-health/04_debt_security/026_debt_security_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-003-lumen-health/04_debt_security/027_debt_security_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-003-lumen-health/04_debt_security/028_debt_security_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-003-lumen-health/04_debt_security/029_debt_security_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-003-lumen-health/04_debt_security/030_debt_security_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-003-lumen-health/04_debt_security/031_debt_security_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-003-lumen-health/04_debt_security/032_debt_security_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-003-lumen-health/05_employment/033_employment_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-003-lumen-health/05_employment/034_employment_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-003-lumen-health/05_employment/035_employment_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-003-lumen-health/05_employment/036_employment_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-003-lumen-health/05_employment/037_employment_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-003-lumen-health/05_employment/038_employment_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-003-lumen-health/05_employment/039_employment_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-003-lumen-health/05_employment/040_employment_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-003-lumen-health/06_ip_technology/041_ip_technology_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-003-lumen-health/06_ip_technology/042_ip_technology_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-003-lumen-health/06_ip_technology/043_ip_technology_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-003-lumen-health/06_ip_technology/044_ip_technology_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-003-lumen-health/06_ip_technology/045_ip_technology_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-003-lumen-health/06_ip_technology/046_ip_technology_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-003-lumen-health/06_ip_technology/047_ip_technology_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-003-lumen-health/06_ip_technology/048_ip_technology_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-003-lumen-health/07_privacy_security/049_privacy_security_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-003-lumen-health/07_privacy_security/050_privacy_security_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-003-lumen-health/07_privacy_security/051_privacy_security_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-003-lumen-health/07_privacy_security/052_privacy_security_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-003-lumen-health/07_privacy_security/053_privacy_security_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-003-lumen-health/07_privacy_security/054_privacy_security_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-003-lumen-health/07_privacy_security/055_privacy_security_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-003-lumen-health/07_privacy_security/056_privacy_security_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-003-lumen-health/08_regulatory/057_regulatory_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-003-lumen-health/08_regulatory/058_regulatory_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-003-lumen-health/08_regulatory/059_regulatory_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-003-lumen-health/08_regulatory/060_regulatory_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-003-lumen-health/08_regulatory/061_regulatory_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-003-lumen-health/08_regulatory/062_regulatory_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-003-lumen-health/08_regulatory/063_regulatory_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-003-lumen-health/08_regulatory/064_regulatory_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-003-lumen-health/09_litigation/065_litigation_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-003-lumen-health/09_litigation/066_litigation_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-003-lumen-health/09_litigation/067_litigation_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-003-lumen-health/09_litigation/068_litigation_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-003-lumen-health/09_litigation/069_litigation_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-003-lumen-health/09_litigation/070_litigation_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-003-lumen-health/09_litigation/071_litigation_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-003-lumen-health/09_litigation/072_litigation_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-003-lumen-health/10_real_property/073_real_property_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-003-lumen-health/10_real_property/074_real_property_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-003-lumen-health/10_real_property/075_real_property_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-003-lumen-health/10_real_property/076_real_property_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-003-lumen-health/10_real_property/077_real_property_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-003-lumen-health/10_real_property/078_real_property_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-003-lumen-health/10_real_property/079_real_property_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-003-lumen-health/10_real_property/080_real_property_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-003-lumen-health/11_tax_insurance/081_tax_insurance_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-003-lumen-health/11_tax_insurance/082_tax_insurance_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-003-lumen-health/11_tax_insurance/083_tax_insurance_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-003-lumen-health/11_tax_insurance/084_tax_insurance_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-003-lumen-health/11_tax_insurance/085_tax_insurance_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-003-lumen-health/11_tax_insurance/086_tax_insurance_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-003-lumen-health/11_tax_insurance/087_tax_insurance_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-003-lumen-health/11_tax_insurance/088_tax_insurance_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-003-lumen-health/12_financials/089_financials_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-003-lumen-health/12_financials/090_financials_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-003-lumen-health/12_financials/091_financials_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-003-lumen-health/12_financials/092_financials_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-003-lumen-health/12_financials/093_financials_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-003-lumen-health/12_financials/094_financials_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-003-lumen-health/12_financials/095_financials_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-003-lumen-health/12_financials/096_financials_status_report.md"], "gold_output": {"advice_markdown": "# Counsel advice — Project Orchard clinic platform purchase\n\n## Executive assessment\n\nFor Lumen Health Partners matter CB-MA-2403, the review identified 16 source-supported exceptions requiring action before 2026-09-11. The assessment concerns OrchardBridge Clinical Systems, Inc. and the supplied record for New York.\n\n## Method and record coverage\n\nThe review inventoried all 96 production files, read the 33 controlling, corroborating, and control records, searched the email exports, and checked metadata for the designated chain-of-custody sample. Conclusions are limited to the synthetic production supplied for this benchmark matter.\n\n## Findings\n\n### F-01 — charter authorization mismatch (critical)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for charter authorization mismatch: one source states the operative date is 2025-11-25 under control reference CB-MA-2403-A126, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2025-12-13 under response reference CB-MA-2403-J102.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/01_corporate/001_corporate_control_register.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/07_privacy_security/049_privacy_security_control_register.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-11, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Adrian Mensah.\n\n### F-02 — unrecorded option grant (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for unrecorded option grant: one source states the controlling amount is $1,515,158.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $1,526,816.00.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/01_corporate/004_corporate_ledger_export.csv`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/07_privacy_security/052_privacy_security_ledger_export.csv`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-11, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Willa Novak.\n\n### F-03 — change-of-control consent (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for change-of-control consent: one source states approval is attributed to Mei Whitaker as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Owen Delgado and contains no entry for Mei Whitaker.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/01_corporate/007_corporate_officer_certificate.html`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/07_privacy_security/055_privacy_security_officer_certificate.html`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-11, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Theo Laurent.\n\n### F-04 — anti-assignment restriction (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for anti-assignment restriction: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-MA-2403-D548, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-MA-2403-M965.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/02_capitalization/010_capitalization_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/08_regulatory/058_regulatory_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-11, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Amara Patel.\n\n### F-05 — most-favored-customer exposure (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for most-favored-customer exposure: one source states the applicable location is Kings County, New York, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to New York operations outside Kings County, New York.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/02_capitalization/013_capitalization_review_memorandum.json`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/08_regulatory/061_regulatory_review_memorandum.json`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-11, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Henry Cho.\n\n### F-06 — financial covenant breach (low)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for financial covenant breach: one source states the threshold is 3% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 10% and produced a different exception result.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/02_capitalization/016_capitalization_status_report.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/08_regulatory/064_regulatory_status_report.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-11, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Nadine Flores.\n\n### F-07 — key-person retention gap (critical)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for key-person retention gap: one source states formal notice must use notices-lumen_health_partners@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-orchardbridge_clinical_systems_inc@example.test.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/019_material_contracts_correspondence.eml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/09_litigation/067_litigation_correspondence.eml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-11, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Micah Sullivan.\n\n### F-08 — invention assignment defect (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for invention assignment defect: one source states the governed population contains 108 records through 2025-07-22, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 65 records through 2025-08-28.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/022_material_contracts_formal_notice.xml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/09_litigation/070_litigation_formal_notice.xml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-11, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Farah Ibrahim.\n\n### F-09 — open-source copyleft exposure (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for open-source copyleft exposure: one source states the operative date is 2025-11-12 under control reference CB-MA-2403-I833, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2025-11-27 under response reference CB-MA-2403-R641.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/04_debt_security/025_debt_security_control_register.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/10_real_property/073_real_property_control_register.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-11, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Owen Delgado.\n\n### F-10 — unreported security incident (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for unreported security incident: one source states the controlling amount is $3,895,322.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $3,997,144.00.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/04_debt_security/028_debt_security_ledger_export.csv`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/10_real_property/076_real_property_ledger_export.csv`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-11, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Lena Varga.\n\n### F-11 — permit transfer restriction (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for permit transfer restriction: one source states approval is attributed to Mei Whitaker as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Adrian Mensah and contains no entry for Mei Whitaker.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/04_debt_security/031_debt_security_officer_certificate.html`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/10_real_property/079_real_property_officer_certificate.html`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-11, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Samuel Kim.\n\n### F-12 — threatened customer dispute (low)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for threatened customer dispute: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-MA-2403-L175, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-MA-2403-U728.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/05_employment/034_employment_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/11_tax_insurance/082_tax_insurance_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-11, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Maya Ellison.\n\n### F-13 — facility title exception (critical)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for facility title exception: one source states the applicable location is Kings County, New York, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to New York operations outside Kings County, New York.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/05_employment/037_employment_review_memorandum.json`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/11_tax_insurance/085_tax_insurance_review_memorandum.json`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-11, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Rafael Okafor.\n\n### F-14 — sales-tax nexus gap (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for sales-tax nexus gap: one source states the threshold is 6% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 12% and produced a different exception result.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/05_employment/040_employment_status_report.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/11_tax_insurance/088_tax_insurance_status_report.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-11, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Nora Chen.\n\n### F-15 — claims-made insurance tail (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for claims-made insurance tail: one source states formal notice must use notices-lumen_health_partners@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-orchardbridge_clinical_systems_inc@example.test.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/043_ip_technology_correspondence.eml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/12_financials/091_financials_correspondence.eml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-11, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Dominic Alvarez.\n\n### F-16 — revenue recognition exception (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for revenue recognition exception: one source states the governed population contains 131 records through 2025-08-14, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 37 records through 2025-08-23.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/046_ip_technology_formal_notice.xml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/12_financials/094_financials_formal_notice.xml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-11, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Priya Raman.\n\n## Recommended next actions\n\nSequence the critical and high findings first, assign the named owners, preserve the cited records, and document any resolution in the controlling matter register before the stated deadline.\n\n## Assumptions and limitations\n\nThis analysis is confined to task cb100-003-lumen-health and the supplied synthetic evidence. It does not rely on external facts, does not resolve disputed law, and is not legal advice for a real person or entity.\n", "findings": {"as_of": "2026-09-11", "findings": [{"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/07_privacy_security/049_privacy_security_control_register.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for charter authorization mismatch: one source states the operative date is 2025-11-25 under control reference CB-MA-2403-A126, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2025-12-13 under response reference CB-MA-2403-J102.", "id": "F-01", "issue": "charter authorization mismatch", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/01_corporate/001_corporate_control_register.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-11, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Adrian Mensah.", "severity": "critical"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/07_privacy_security/052_privacy_security_ledger_export.csv", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for unrecorded option grant: one source states the controlling amount is $1,515,158.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $1,526,816.00.", "id": "F-02", "issue": "unrecorded option grant", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/01_corporate/004_corporate_ledger_export.csv", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-11, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Willa Novak.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/07_privacy_security/055_privacy_security_officer_certificate.html", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for change-of-control consent: one source states approval is attributed to Mei Whitaker as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Owen Delgado and contains no entry for Mei Whitaker.", "id": "F-03", "issue": "change-of-control consent", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/01_corporate/007_corporate_officer_certificate.html", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-11, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Theo Laurent.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/08_regulatory/058_regulatory_executed_instrument.txt", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for anti-assignment restriction: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-MA-2403-D548, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-MA-2403-M965.", "id": "F-04", "issue": "anti-assignment restriction", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/02_capitalization/010_capitalization_executed_instrument.txt", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-11, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Amara Patel.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/08_regulatory/061_regulatory_review_memorandum.json", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for most-favored-customer exposure: one source states the applicable location is Kings County, New York, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to New York operations outside Kings County, New York.", "id": "F-05", "issue": "most-favored-customer exposure", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/02_capitalization/013_capitalization_review_memorandum.json", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-11, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Henry Cho.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/08_regulatory/064_regulatory_status_report.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for financial covenant breach: one source states the threshold is 3% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 10% and produced a different exception result.", "id": "F-06", "issue": "financial covenant breach", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/02_capitalization/016_capitalization_status_report.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-11, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Nadine Flores.", "severity": "low"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/09_litigation/067_litigation_correspondence.eml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for key-person retention gap: one source states formal notice must use notices-lumen_health_partners@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-orchardbridge_clinical_systems_inc@example.test.", "id": "F-07", "issue": "key-person retention gap", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/019_material_contracts_correspondence.eml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-11, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Micah Sullivan.", "severity": "critical"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/09_litigation/070_litigation_formal_notice.xml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for invention assignment defect: one source states the governed population contains 108 records through 2025-07-22, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 65 records through 2025-08-28.", "id": "F-08", "issue": "invention assignment defect", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/022_material_contracts_formal_notice.xml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-11, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Farah Ibrahim.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/10_real_property/073_real_property_control_register.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for open-source copyleft exposure: one source states the operative date is 2025-11-12 under control reference CB-MA-2403-I833, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2025-11-27 under response reference CB-MA-2403-R641.", "id": "F-09", "issue": "open-source copyleft exposure", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/04_debt_security/025_debt_security_control_register.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-11, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Owen Delgado.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/10_real_property/076_real_property_ledger_export.csv", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for unreported security incident: one source states the controlling amount is $3,895,322.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $3,997,144.00.", "id": "F-10", "issue": "unreported security incident", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/04_debt_security/028_debt_security_ledger_export.csv", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-11, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Lena Varga.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/10_real_property/079_real_property_officer_certificate.html", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for permit transfer restriction: one source states approval is attributed to Mei Whitaker as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Adrian Mensah and contains no entry for Mei Whitaker.", "id": "F-11", "issue": "permit transfer restriction", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/04_debt_security/031_debt_security_officer_certificate.html", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-11, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Samuel Kim.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/11_tax_insurance/082_tax_insurance_executed_instrument.txt", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for threatened customer dispute: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-MA-2403-L175, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-MA-2403-U728.", "id": "F-12", "issue": "threatened customer dispute", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/05_employment/034_employment_executed_instrument.txt", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-11, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Maya Ellison.", "severity": "low"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/11_tax_insurance/085_tax_insurance_review_memorandum.json", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for facility title exception: one source states the applicable location is Kings County, New York, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to New York operations outside Kings County, New York.", "id": "F-13", "issue": "facility title exception", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/05_employment/037_employment_review_memorandum.json", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-11, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Rafael Okafor.", "severity": "critical"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/11_tax_insurance/088_tax_insurance_status_report.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for sales-tax nexus gap: one source states the threshold is 6% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 12% and produced a different exception result.", "id": "F-14", "issue": "sales-tax nexus gap", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/05_employment/040_employment_status_report.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-11, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Nora Chen.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/12_financials/091_financials_correspondence.eml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for claims-made insurance tail: one source states formal notice must use notices-lumen_health_partners@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-orchardbridge_clinical_systems_inc@example.test.", "id": "F-15", "issue": "claims-made insurance tail", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/043_ip_technology_correspondence.eml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-11, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Dominic Alvarez.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/12_financials/094_financials_formal_notice.xml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for revenue recognition exception: one source states the governed population contains 131 records through 2025-08-14, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 37 records through 2025-08-23.", "id": "F-16", "issue": "revenue recognition exception", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/046_ip_technology_formal_notice.xml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-11, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Priya Raman.", "severity": "medium"}], "matter_number": "CB-MA-2403", "prepared_for": "Lumen Health Partners", "schema_version": "1.0", "task_id": "cb100-003-lumen-health"}}, "metadata": {"benchmark": "CounselBench-100", "code_license": "Apache-2.0", "data_license": "CC-BY-4.0", "deadline": "2026-09-11", "document_count": 96, "jurisdiction": "New York", "matter_number": "CB-MA-2403", "mcp_commit": "9a96ea6e5913736f92b88345bf51caeaaa8e719f", "mcp_package": "@modelcontextprotocol/server-filesystem@2026.7.10", "practice_area": "corporate-ma", "reference_tool_calls": 46, "required_evidence_reads": 33, "synthetic": true, "venue": "Kings County, New York", "version": "2.0.0"}, "prompt": "You are buyer-side transactions counsel for Lumen Health Partners. The client has asked for a board-ready risk assessment supported by a source-level tracker rather than a narrative-only summary. A healthcare scheduling platform combines physician contracts, patient data, and a revenue-share channel relationship that the seller treats as nonexclusive. Decision due 2026-09-11. New York law governs; Kings County, New York is the forum. Treat dates, notice mechanics, approval evidence, and numerical reconciliations as independent controls. Work out the defensible position from the matter production and leave an audit-ready exception tracker and concise advice for the supervising lawyer. Keep confirmed conflicts separate from open questions, cite the records that actually control each conclusion, and do not fill gaps with outside facts.", "rubric": {"criteria": [{"category": "procedure", "description": "Complete at least 46 successful, argument-specific evidence and output calls.", "id": "procedure.minimum_successful_tool_calls"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Find and read the 33 controlling, corroborating, and work-product-control records in full.", "id": "procedure.all_evidence_read_in_full"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Inspect file metadata for the eight designated critical primary records before relying on them.", "id": "procedure.chain_of_custody_metadata_checked"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Confirm the sandbox's allowed document and output roots.", "id": "procedure.allowed_directories_checked"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Inventory all 96 records so the relevant sources are discovered among the context records.", "id": "procedure.recursive_inventory_completed"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Search the production for email evidence that may corroborate or contradict formal records.", "id": "procedure.targeted_search_completed"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Leave only findings.json and advice.md in the output workspace.", "id": "procedure.exact_deliverable_set"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Create both final work products through the sandbox MCP surface.", "id": "procedure.deliverables_written_through_mcp"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Produce findings.json as a valid JSON object.", "id": "findings.findings_is_object"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Report exactly 16 confirmed exceptions.", "id": "findings.findings_exact_count"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Use each stable finding ID exactly once.", "id": "findings.finding_ids_unique"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set schema_version to the released matter value '1.0'.", "id": "findings.top_level_schema_version"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set task_id to the released matter value 'cb100-003-lumen-health'.", "id": "findings.top_level_task_id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set matter_number to the released matter value 'CB-MA-2403'.", "id": "findings.top_level_matter_number"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set prepared_for to the released matter value 'Lumen Health Partners'.", "id": "findings.top_level_prepared_for"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set as_of to the released matter value '2026-09-11'.", "id": "findings.top_level_as_of"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-01 exception for charter authorization mismatch.", "id": "findings.F-01.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's id from /workspace/documents/01_corporate/001_corporate_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_privacy_security/049_privacy_security_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's issue from /workspace/documents/01_corporate/001_corporate_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_privacy_security/049_privacy_security_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's severity from /workspace/documents/01_corporate/001_corporate_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_privacy_security/049_privacy_security_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's primary_source from /workspace/documents/01_corporate/001_corporate_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_privacy_security/049_privacy_security_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/01_corporate/001_corporate_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_privacy_security/049_privacy_security_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-01 using the exact controlled facts ['2025-11-25', 'CB-MA-2403-A126', '2025-12-13', 'CB-MA-2403-J102'].", "id": "findings.F-01.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-01's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-01.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-11', 'Adrian Mensah'] for F-01.", "id": "findings.F-01.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-02 exception for unrecorded option grant.", "id": "findings.F-02.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's id from /workspace/documents/01_corporate/004_corporate_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_privacy_security/052_privacy_security_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's issue from /workspace/documents/01_corporate/004_corporate_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_privacy_security/052_privacy_security_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's severity from /workspace/documents/01_corporate/004_corporate_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_privacy_security/052_privacy_security_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's primary_source from /workspace/documents/01_corporate/004_corporate_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_privacy_security/052_privacy_security_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/01_corporate/004_corporate_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_privacy_security/052_privacy_security_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-02 using the exact controlled facts ['$1,515,158.00', '$1,526,816.00'].", "id": "findings.F-02.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-02's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-02.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-11', 'Willa Novak'] for F-02.", "id": "findings.F-02.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-03 exception for change-of-control consent.", "id": "findings.F-03.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's id from /workspace/documents/01_corporate/007_corporate_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_privacy_security/055_privacy_security_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's issue from /workspace/documents/01_corporate/007_corporate_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_privacy_security/055_privacy_security_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's severity from /workspace/documents/01_corporate/007_corporate_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_privacy_security/055_privacy_security_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's primary_source from /workspace/documents/01_corporate/007_corporate_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_privacy_security/055_privacy_security_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/01_corporate/007_corporate_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_privacy_security/055_privacy_security_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-03 using the exact controlled facts ['Mei Whitaker', 'Owen Delgado'].", "id": "findings.F-03.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-03's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-03.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-11', 'Theo Laurent'] for F-03.", "id": "findings.F-03.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-04 exception for anti-assignment restriction.", "id": "findings.F-04.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's id from /workspace/documents/02_capitalization/010_capitalization_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_regulatory/058_regulatory_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's issue from /workspace/documents/02_capitalization/010_capitalization_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_regulatory/058_regulatory_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's severity from /workspace/documents/02_capitalization/010_capitalization_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_regulatory/058_regulatory_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's primary_source from /workspace/documents/02_capitalization/010_capitalization_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_regulatory/058_regulatory_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/02_capitalization/010_capitalization_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_regulatory/058_regulatory_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-04 using the exact controlled facts ['closed without exception', 'CB-MA-2403-D548', 'open and escalated', 'CB-MA-2403-M965'].", "id": "findings.F-04.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-04's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-04.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-11', 'Amara Patel'] for F-04.", "id": "findings.F-04.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-05 exception for most-favored-customer exposure.", "id": "findings.F-05.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's id from /workspace/documents/02_capitalization/013_capitalization_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_regulatory/061_regulatory_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's issue from /workspace/documents/02_capitalization/013_capitalization_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_regulatory/061_regulatory_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's severity from /workspace/documents/02_capitalization/013_capitalization_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_regulatory/061_regulatory_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's primary_source from /workspace/documents/02_capitalization/013_capitalization_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_regulatory/061_regulatory_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/02_capitalization/013_capitalization_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_regulatory/061_regulatory_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-05 using the exact controlled facts ['Kings County, New York', 'New York'].", "id": "findings.F-05.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-05's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-05.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-11', 'Henry Cho'] for F-05.", "id": "findings.F-05.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-06 exception for financial covenant breach.", "id": "findings.F-06.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's id from /workspace/documents/02_capitalization/016_capitalization_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_regulatory/064_regulatory_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's issue from /workspace/documents/02_capitalization/016_capitalization_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_regulatory/064_regulatory_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's severity from /workspace/documents/02_capitalization/016_capitalization_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_regulatory/064_regulatory_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's primary_source from /workspace/documents/02_capitalization/016_capitalization_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_regulatory/064_regulatory_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/02_capitalization/016_capitalization_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_regulatory/064_regulatory_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-06 using the exact controlled facts ['3%', '10%'].", "id": "findings.F-06.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-06's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-06.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-11', 'Nadine Flores'] for F-06.", "id": "findings.F-06.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-07 exception for key-person retention gap.", "id": "findings.F-07.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's id from /workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/019_material_contracts_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_litigation/067_litigation_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's issue from /workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/019_material_contracts_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_litigation/067_litigation_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's severity from /workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/019_material_contracts_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_litigation/067_litigation_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's primary_source from /workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/019_material_contracts_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_litigation/067_litigation_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/019_material_contracts_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_litigation/067_litigation_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-07 using the exact controlled facts ['notices-lumen_health_partners@example.test', 'archive-orchardbridge_clinical_systems_inc@example.test'].", "id": "findings.F-07.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-07's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-07.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-11', 'Micah Sullivan'] for F-07.", "id": "findings.F-07.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-08 exception for invention assignment defect.", "id": "findings.F-08.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's id from /workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/022_material_contracts_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_litigation/070_litigation_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's issue from /workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/022_material_contracts_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_litigation/070_litigation_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's severity from /workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/022_material_contracts_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_litigation/070_litigation_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's primary_source from /workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/022_material_contracts_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_litigation/070_litigation_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/022_material_contracts_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_litigation/070_litigation_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-08 using the exact controlled facts ['108 records', '2025-07-22', '65 records', '2025-08-28'].", "id": "findings.F-08.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-08's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-08.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-11', 'Farah Ibrahim'] for F-08.", "id": "findings.F-08.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-09 exception for open-source copyleft exposure.", "id": "findings.F-09.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's id from /workspace/documents/04_debt_security/025_debt_security_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_real_property/073_real_property_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's issue from /workspace/documents/04_debt_security/025_debt_security_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_real_property/073_real_property_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's severity from /workspace/documents/04_debt_security/025_debt_security_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_real_property/073_real_property_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's primary_source from /workspace/documents/04_debt_security/025_debt_security_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_real_property/073_real_property_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/04_debt_security/025_debt_security_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_real_property/073_real_property_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-09 using the exact controlled facts ['2025-11-12', 'CB-MA-2403-I833', '2025-11-27', 'CB-MA-2403-R641'].", "id": "findings.F-09.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-09's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-09.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-11', 'Owen Delgado'] for F-09.", "id": "findings.F-09.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-10 exception for unreported security incident.", "id": "findings.F-10.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's id from /workspace/documents/04_debt_security/028_debt_security_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_real_property/076_real_property_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's issue from /workspace/documents/04_debt_security/028_debt_security_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_real_property/076_real_property_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's severity from /workspace/documents/04_debt_security/028_debt_security_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_real_property/076_real_property_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's primary_source from /workspace/documents/04_debt_security/028_debt_security_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_real_property/076_real_property_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/04_debt_security/028_debt_security_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_real_property/076_real_property_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-10 using the exact controlled facts ['$3,895,322.00', '$3,997,144.00'].", "id": "findings.F-10.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-10's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-10.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-11', 'Lena Varga'] for F-10.", "id": "findings.F-10.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-11 exception for permit transfer restriction.", "id": "findings.F-11.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's id from /workspace/documents/04_debt_security/031_debt_security_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_real_property/079_real_property_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's issue from /workspace/documents/04_debt_security/031_debt_security_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_real_property/079_real_property_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's severity from /workspace/documents/04_debt_security/031_debt_security_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_real_property/079_real_property_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's primary_source from /workspace/documents/04_debt_security/031_debt_security_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_real_property/079_real_property_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/04_debt_security/031_debt_security_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_real_property/079_real_property_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-11 using the exact controlled facts ['Mei Whitaker', 'Adrian Mensah'].", "id": "findings.F-11.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-11's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-11.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-11', 'Samuel Kim'] for F-11.", "id": "findings.F-11.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-12 exception for threatened customer dispute.", "id": "findings.F-12.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's id from /workspace/documents/05_employment/034_employment_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_tax_insurance/082_tax_insurance_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's issue from /workspace/documents/05_employment/034_employment_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_tax_insurance/082_tax_insurance_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's severity from /workspace/documents/05_employment/034_employment_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_tax_insurance/082_tax_insurance_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's primary_source from /workspace/documents/05_employment/034_employment_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_tax_insurance/082_tax_insurance_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/05_employment/034_employment_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_tax_insurance/082_tax_insurance_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-12 using the exact controlled facts ['closed without exception', 'CB-MA-2403-L175', 'open and escalated', 'CB-MA-2403-U728'].", "id": "findings.F-12.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-12's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-12.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-11', 'Maya Ellison'] for F-12.", "id": "findings.F-12.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-13 exception for facility title exception.", "id": "findings.F-13.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's id from /workspace/documents/05_employment/037_employment_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_tax_insurance/085_tax_insurance_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's issue from /workspace/documents/05_employment/037_employment_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_tax_insurance/085_tax_insurance_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's severity from /workspace/documents/05_employment/037_employment_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_tax_insurance/085_tax_insurance_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's primary_source from /workspace/documents/05_employment/037_employment_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_tax_insurance/085_tax_insurance_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/05_employment/037_employment_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_tax_insurance/085_tax_insurance_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-13 using the exact controlled facts ['Kings County, New York', 'New York'].", "id": "findings.F-13.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-13's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-13.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-11', 'Rafael Okafor'] for F-13.", "id": "findings.F-13.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-14 exception for sales-tax nexus gap.", "id": "findings.F-14.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's id from /workspace/documents/05_employment/040_employment_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_tax_insurance/088_tax_insurance_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's issue from /workspace/documents/05_employment/040_employment_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_tax_insurance/088_tax_insurance_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's severity from /workspace/documents/05_employment/040_employment_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_tax_insurance/088_tax_insurance_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's primary_source from /workspace/documents/05_employment/040_employment_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_tax_insurance/088_tax_insurance_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/05_employment/040_employment_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_tax_insurance/088_tax_insurance_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-14 using the exact controlled facts ['6%', '12%'].", "id": "findings.F-14.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-14's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-14.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-11', 'Nora Chen'] for F-14.", "id": "findings.F-14.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-15 exception for claims-made insurance tail.", "id": "findings.F-15.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's id from /workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/043_ip_technology_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_financials/091_financials_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's issue from /workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/043_ip_technology_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_financials/091_financials_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's severity from /workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/043_ip_technology_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_financials/091_financials_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's primary_source from /workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/043_ip_technology_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_financials/091_financials_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/043_ip_technology_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_financials/091_financials_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-15 using the exact controlled facts ['notices-lumen_health_partners@example.test', 'archive-orchardbridge_clinical_systems_inc@example.test'].", "id": "findings.F-15.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-15's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-15.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-11', 'Dominic Alvarez'] for F-15.", "id": "findings.F-15.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-16 exception for revenue recognition exception.", "id": "findings.F-16.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's id from /workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/046_ip_technology_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_financials/094_financials_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's issue from /workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/046_ip_technology_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_financials/094_financials_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's severity from /workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/046_ip_technology_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_financials/094_financials_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's primary_source from /workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/046_ip_technology_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_financials/094_financials_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/046_ip_technology_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_financials/094_financials_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-16 using the exact controlled facts ['131 records', '2025-08-14', '37 records', '2025-08-23'].", "id": "findings.F-16.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-16's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-16.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-11', 'Priya Raman'] for F-16.", "id": "findings.F-16.action_anchors"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Executive assessment' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Executive assessment"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Method and record coverage' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Method and record coverage"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Findings' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Findings"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Recommended next actions' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Recommended next actions"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Assumptions and limitations' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Assumptions and limitations"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-01 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-01"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-02 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-02"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-03 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-03"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-04 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-04"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-05 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-05"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-06 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-06"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-07 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-07"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-08 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-08"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-09 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-09"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-10 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-10"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-11 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-11"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-12 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-12"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-13 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-13"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-14 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-14"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-15 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-15"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-16 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-16"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Do not claim the production has no issues or that every record is consistent.", "id": "memo.forbidden_claims_absent"}], "decision_options": [{"id": "cross-source-reconciliation", "label": "Reconcile controlling and corroborating records", "reason": "The CB-MA-2403 production contains independently maintained records; a defensible answer must preserve each supported conflict and its cure owner.", "selected": true}, {"id": "latest-record-controls", "label": "Treat the latest record as controlling", "reason": "Timestamp recency does not establish legal priority, execution, or approval authority.", "selected": false}, {"id": "primary-records-only", "label": "Report primary records without reconciliation", "reason": "Primary records alone conceal the operational conflicts that create the actionable exceptions.", "selected": false}], "gates": ["all_evidence_read_in_full", "chain_of_custody_metadata_checked", "findings_criteria_complete", "memo_criteria_complete", "deliverables_written_through_mcp"], "metadata_checks": 8, "metric": "weighted_criteria_score", "minimum_tool_calls": 46, "required_deliverables": ["findings.json", "advice.md"], "required_document_reads": 33, "type": "deterministic", "weights": {"findings": 0.55, "memo": 0.2, "procedure": 0.25}}, "task_id": "cb100-003-lumen-health", "task_name": "Project Orchard clinic platform purchase", "world_id": "counselbench-filesystem-mcp-v2"}
-{"context_files": ["task_files/cb100-004-tamarack-foods/01_corporate/001_corporate_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-004-tamarack-foods/01_corporate/002_corporate_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-004-tamarack-foods/01_corporate/003_corporate_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-004-tamarack-foods/01_corporate/004_corporate_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-004-tamarack-foods/01_corporate/005_corporate_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-004-tamarack-foods/01_corporate/006_corporate_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-004-tamarack-foods/01_corporate/007_corporate_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-004-tamarack-foods/01_corporate/008_corporate_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-004-tamarack-foods/02_capitalization/009_capitalization_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-004-tamarack-foods/02_capitalization/010_capitalization_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-004-tamarack-foods/02_capitalization/011_capitalization_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-004-tamarack-foods/02_capitalization/012_capitalization_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-004-tamarack-foods/02_capitalization/013_capitalization_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-004-tamarack-foods/02_capitalization/014_capitalization_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-004-tamarack-foods/02_capitalization/015_capitalization_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-004-tamarack-foods/02_capitalization/016_capitalization_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-004-tamarack-foods/03_material_contracts/017_material_contracts_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-004-tamarack-foods/03_material_contracts/018_material_contracts_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-004-tamarack-foods/03_material_contracts/019_material_contracts_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-004-tamarack-foods/03_material_contracts/020_material_contracts_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-004-tamarack-foods/03_material_contracts/021_material_contracts_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-004-tamarack-foods/03_material_contracts/022_material_contracts_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-004-tamarack-foods/03_material_contracts/023_material_contracts_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-004-tamarack-foods/03_material_contracts/024_material_contracts_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-004-tamarack-foods/04_debt_security/025_debt_security_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-004-tamarack-foods/04_debt_security/026_debt_security_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-004-tamarack-foods/04_debt_security/027_debt_security_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-004-tamarack-foods/04_debt_security/028_debt_security_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-004-tamarack-foods/04_debt_security/029_debt_security_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-004-tamarack-foods/04_debt_security/030_debt_security_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-004-tamarack-foods/04_debt_security/031_debt_security_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-004-tamarack-foods/04_debt_security/032_debt_security_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-004-tamarack-foods/05_employment/033_employment_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-004-tamarack-foods/05_employment/034_employment_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-004-tamarack-foods/05_employment/035_employment_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-004-tamarack-foods/05_employment/036_employment_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-004-tamarack-foods/05_employment/037_employment_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-004-tamarack-foods/05_employment/038_employment_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-004-tamarack-foods/05_employment/039_employment_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-004-tamarack-foods/05_employment/040_employment_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-004-tamarack-foods/06_ip_technology/041_ip_technology_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-004-tamarack-foods/06_ip_technology/042_ip_technology_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-004-tamarack-foods/06_ip_technology/043_ip_technology_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-004-tamarack-foods/06_ip_technology/044_ip_technology_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-004-tamarack-foods/06_ip_technology/045_ip_technology_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-004-tamarack-foods/06_ip_technology/046_ip_technology_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-004-tamarack-foods/06_ip_technology/047_ip_technology_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-004-tamarack-foods/06_ip_technology/048_ip_technology_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-004-tamarack-foods/07_privacy_security/049_privacy_security_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-004-tamarack-foods/07_privacy_security/050_privacy_security_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-004-tamarack-foods/07_privacy_security/051_privacy_security_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-004-tamarack-foods/07_privacy_security/052_privacy_security_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-004-tamarack-foods/07_privacy_security/053_privacy_security_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-004-tamarack-foods/07_privacy_security/054_privacy_security_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-004-tamarack-foods/07_privacy_security/055_privacy_security_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-004-tamarack-foods/07_privacy_security/056_privacy_security_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-004-tamarack-foods/08_regulatory/057_regulatory_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-004-tamarack-foods/08_regulatory/058_regulatory_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-004-tamarack-foods/08_regulatory/059_regulatory_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-004-tamarack-foods/08_regulatory/060_regulatory_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-004-tamarack-foods/08_regulatory/061_regulatory_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-004-tamarack-foods/08_regulatory/062_regulatory_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-004-tamarack-foods/08_regulatory/063_regulatory_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-004-tamarack-foods/08_regulatory/064_regulatory_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-004-tamarack-foods/09_litigation/065_litigation_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-004-tamarack-foods/09_litigation/066_litigation_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-004-tamarack-foods/09_litigation/067_litigation_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-004-tamarack-foods/09_litigation/068_litigation_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-004-tamarack-foods/09_litigation/069_litigation_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-004-tamarack-foods/09_litigation/070_litigation_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-004-tamarack-foods/09_litigation/071_litigation_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-004-tamarack-foods/09_litigation/072_litigation_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-004-tamarack-foods/10_real_property/073_real_property_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-004-tamarack-foods/10_real_property/074_real_property_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-004-tamarack-foods/10_real_property/075_real_property_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-004-tamarack-foods/10_real_property/076_real_property_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-004-tamarack-foods/10_real_property/077_real_property_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-004-tamarack-foods/10_real_property/078_real_property_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-004-tamarack-foods/10_real_property/079_real_property_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-004-tamarack-foods/10_real_property/080_real_property_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-004-tamarack-foods/11_tax_insurance/081_tax_insurance_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-004-tamarack-foods/11_tax_insurance/082_tax_insurance_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-004-tamarack-foods/11_tax_insurance/083_tax_insurance_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-004-tamarack-foods/11_tax_insurance/084_tax_insurance_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-004-tamarack-foods/11_tax_insurance/085_tax_insurance_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-004-tamarack-foods/11_tax_insurance/086_tax_insurance_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-004-tamarack-foods/11_tax_insurance/087_tax_insurance_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-004-tamarack-foods/11_tax_insurance/088_tax_insurance_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-004-tamarack-foods/12_financials/089_financials_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-004-tamarack-foods/12_financials/090_financials_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-004-tamarack-foods/12_financials/091_financials_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-004-tamarack-foods/12_financials/092_financials_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-004-tamarack-foods/12_financials/093_financials_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-004-tamarack-foods/12_financials/094_financials_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-004-tamarack-foods/12_financials/095_financials_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-004-tamarack-foods/12_financials/096_financials_status_report.md"], "gold_output": {"advice_markdown": "# Counsel advice — Project Copper Kettle food plant divestiture\n\n## Executive assessment\n\nFor Tamarack Foods Group matter CB-MA-2404, the review identified 16 source-supported exceptions requiring action before 2026-09-15. The assessment concerns Copper Kettle Nutrition Co. and the supplied record for Illinois.\n\n## Method and record coverage\n\nThe review inventoried all 96 production files, read the 33 controlling, corroborating, and control records, searched the email exports, and checked metadata for the designated chain-of-custody sample. Conclusions are limited to the synthetic production supplied for this benchmark matter.\n\n## Findings\n\n### F-01 — charter authorization mismatch (critical)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for charter authorization mismatch: one source states the operative date is 2026-02-24 under control reference CB-MA-2404-A577, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2026-04-02 under response reference CB-MA-2404-J482.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/01_corporate/001_corporate_control_register.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/07_privacy_security/049_privacy_security_control_register.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-15, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Willa Novak.\n\n### F-02 — unrecorded option grant (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for unrecorded option grant: one source states the controlling amount is $3,751,023.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $4,058,546.00.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/01_corporate/004_corporate_ledger_export.csv`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/07_privacy_security/052_privacy_security_ledger_export.csv`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-15, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Theo Laurent.\n\n### F-03 — change-of-control consent (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for change-of-control consent: one source states approval is attributed to Caleb Hassan as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Samuel Kim and contains no entry for Caleb Hassan.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/01_corporate/007_corporate_officer_certificate.html`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/07_privacy_security/055_privacy_security_officer_certificate.html`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-15, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Amara Patel.\n\n### F-04 — anti-assignment restriction (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for anti-assignment restriction: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-MA-2404-D906, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-MA-2404-M508.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/02_capitalization/010_capitalization_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/08_regulatory/058_regulatory_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-15, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Henry Cho.\n\n### F-05 — most-favored-customer exposure (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for most-favored-customer exposure: one source states the applicable location is Cook County, Illinois, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to Illinois operations outside Cook County, Illinois.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/02_capitalization/013_capitalization_review_memorandum.json`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/08_regulatory/061_regulatory_review_memorandum.json`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-15, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Nadine Flores.\n\n### F-06 �� financial covenant breach (low)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for financial covenant breach: one source states the threshold is 11% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 18% and produced a different exception result.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/02_capitalization/016_capitalization_status_report.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/08_regulatory/064_regulatory_status_report.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-15, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Micah Sullivan.\n\n### F-07 — key-person retention gap (critical)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for key-person retention gap: one source states formal notice must use notices-tamarack_foods_group@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-copper_kettle_nutrition_co@example.test.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/019_material_contracts_correspondence.eml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/09_litigation/067_litigation_correspondence.eml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-15, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Farah Ibrahim.\n\n### F-08 — invention assignment defect (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for invention assignment defect: one source states the governed population contains 175 records through 2026-02-14, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 69 records through 2026-03-27.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/022_material_contracts_formal_notice.xml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/09_litigation/070_litigation_formal_notice.xml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-15, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Owen Delgado.\n\n### F-09 — open-source copyleft exposure (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for open-source copyleft exposure: one source states the operative date is 2025-09-21 under control reference CB-MA-2404-I961, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2025-10-27 under response reference CB-MA-2404-R789.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/04_debt_security/025_debt_security_control_register.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/10_real_property/073_real_property_control_register.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-15, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Lena Varga.\n\n### F-10 — unreported security incident (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for unreported security incident: one source states the controlling amount is $5,553,159.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $5,712,818.00.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/04_debt_security/028_debt_security_ledger_export.csv`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/10_real_property/076_real_property_ledger_export.csv`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-15, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Samuel Kim.\n\n### F-11 — permit transfer restriction (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for permit transfer restriction: one source states approval is attributed to Caleb Hassan as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Theo Laurent and contains no entry for Caleb Hassan.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/04_debt_security/031_debt_security_officer_certificate.html`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/10_real_property/079_real_property_officer_certificate.html`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-15, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Maya Ellison.\n\n### F-12 — threatened customer dispute (low)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for threatened customer dispute: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-MA-2404-L192, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-MA-2404-U384.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/05_employment/034_employment_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/11_tax_insurance/082_tax_insurance_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-15, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Rafael Okafor.\n\n### F-13 — facility title exception (critical)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for facility title exception: one source states the applicable location is Cook County, Illinois, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to Illinois operations outside Cook County, Illinois.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/05_employment/037_employment_review_memorandum.json`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/11_tax_insurance/085_tax_insurance_review_memorandum.json`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-15, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Nora Chen.\n\n### F-14 — sales-tax nexus gap (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for sales-tax nexus gap: one source states the threshold is 8% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 10% and produced a different exception result.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/05_employment/040_employment_status_report.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/11_tax_insurance/088_tax_insurance_status_report.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-15, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Dominic Alvarez.\n\n### F-15 — claims-made insurance tail (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for claims-made insurance tail: one source states formal notice must use notices-tamarack_foods_group@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-copper_kettle_nutrition_co@example.test.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/043_ip_technology_correspondence.eml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/12_financials/091_financials_correspondence.eml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-15, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Priya Raman.\n\n### F-16 — revenue recognition exception (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for revenue recognition exception: one source states the governed population contains 97 records through 2025-07-11, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 73 records through 2025-08-25.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/046_ip_technology_formal_notice.xml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/12_financials/094_financials_formal_notice.xml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-15, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Elliot Mercer.\n\n## Recommended next actions\n\nSequence the critical and high findings first, assign the named owners, preserve the cited records, and document any resolution in the controlling matter register before the stated deadline.\n\n## Assumptions and limitations\n\nThis analysis is confined to task cb100-004-tamarack-foods and the supplied synthetic evidence. It does not rely on external facts, does not resolve disputed law, and is not legal advice for a real person or entity.\n", "findings": {"as_of": "2026-09-15", "findings": [{"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/07_privacy_security/049_privacy_security_control_register.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for charter authorization mismatch: one source states the operative date is 2026-02-24 under control reference CB-MA-2404-A577, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2026-04-02 under response reference CB-MA-2404-J482.", "id": "F-01", "issue": "charter authorization mismatch", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/01_corporate/001_corporate_control_register.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-15, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Willa Novak.", "severity": "critical"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/07_privacy_security/052_privacy_security_ledger_export.csv", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for unrecorded option grant: one source states the controlling amount is $3,751,023.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $4,058,546.00.", "id": "F-02", "issue": "unrecorded option grant", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/01_corporate/004_corporate_ledger_export.csv", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-15, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Theo Laurent.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/07_privacy_security/055_privacy_security_officer_certificate.html", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for change-of-control consent: one source states approval is attributed to Caleb Hassan as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Samuel Kim and contains no entry for Caleb Hassan.", "id": "F-03", "issue": "change-of-control consent", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/01_corporate/007_corporate_officer_certificate.html", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-15, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Amara Patel.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/08_regulatory/058_regulatory_executed_instrument.txt", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for anti-assignment restriction: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-MA-2404-D906, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-MA-2404-M508.", "id": "F-04", "issue": "anti-assignment restriction", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/02_capitalization/010_capitalization_executed_instrument.txt", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-15, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Henry Cho.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/08_regulatory/061_regulatory_review_memorandum.json", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for most-favored-customer exposure: one source states the applicable location is Cook County, Illinois, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to Illinois operations outside Cook County, Illinois.", "id": "F-05", "issue": "most-favored-customer exposure", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/02_capitalization/013_capitalization_review_memorandum.json", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-15, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Nadine Flores.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/08_regulatory/064_regulatory_status_report.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for financial covenant breach: one source states the threshold is 11% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 18% and produced a different exception result.", "id": "F-06", "issue": "financial covenant breach", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/02_capitalization/016_capitalization_status_report.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-15, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Micah Sullivan.", "severity": "low"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/09_litigation/067_litigation_correspondence.eml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for key-person retention gap: one source states formal notice must use notices-tamarack_foods_group@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-copper_kettle_nutrition_co@example.test.", "id": "F-07", "issue": "key-person retention gap", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/019_material_contracts_correspondence.eml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-15, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Farah Ibrahim.", "severity": "critical"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/09_litigation/070_litigation_formal_notice.xml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for invention assignment defect: one source states the governed population contains 175 records through 2026-02-14, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 69 records through 2026-03-27.", "id": "F-08", "issue": "invention assignment defect", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/022_material_contracts_formal_notice.xml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-15, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Owen Delgado.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/10_real_property/073_real_property_control_register.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for open-source copyleft exposure: one source states the operative date is 2025-09-21 under control reference CB-MA-2404-I961, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2025-10-27 under response reference CB-MA-2404-R789.", "id": "F-09", "issue": "open-source copyleft exposure", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/04_debt_security/025_debt_security_control_register.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-15, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Lena Varga.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/10_real_property/076_real_property_ledger_export.csv", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for unreported security incident: one source states the controlling amount is $5,553,159.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $5,712,818.00.", "id": "F-10", "issue": "unreported security incident", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/04_debt_security/028_debt_security_ledger_export.csv", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-15, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Samuel Kim.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/10_real_property/079_real_property_officer_certificate.html", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for permit transfer restriction: one source states approval is attributed to Caleb Hassan as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Theo Laurent and contains no entry for Caleb Hassan.", "id": "F-11", "issue": "permit transfer restriction", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/04_debt_security/031_debt_security_officer_certificate.html", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-15, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Maya Ellison.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/11_tax_insurance/082_tax_insurance_executed_instrument.txt", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for threatened customer dispute: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-MA-2404-L192, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-MA-2404-U384.", "id": "F-12", "issue": "threatened customer dispute", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/05_employment/034_employment_executed_instrument.txt", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-15, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Rafael Okafor.", "severity": "low"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/11_tax_insurance/085_tax_insurance_review_memorandum.json", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for facility title exception: one source states the applicable location is Cook County, Illinois, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to Illinois operations outside Cook County, Illinois.", "id": "F-13", "issue": "facility title exception", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/05_employment/037_employment_review_memorandum.json", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-15, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Nora Chen.", "severity": "critical"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/11_tax_insurance/088_tax_insurance_status_report.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for sales-tax nexus gap: one source states the threshold is 8% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 10% and produced a different exception result.", "id": "F-14", "issue": "sales-tax nexus gap", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/05_employment/040_employment_status_report.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-15, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Dominic Alvarez.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/12_financials/091_financials_correspondence.eml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for claims-made insurance tail: one source states formal notice must use notices-tamarack_foods_group@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-copper_kettle_nutrition_co@example.test.", "id": "F-15", "issue": "claims-made insurance tail", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/043_ip_technology_correspondence.eml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-15, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Priya Raman.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/12_financials/094_financials_formal_notice.xml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for revenue recognition exception: one source states the governed population contains 97 records through 2025-07-11, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 73 records through 2025-08-25.", "id": "F-16", "issue": "revenue recognition exception", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/046_ip_technology_formal_notice.xml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-15, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Elliot Mercer.", "severity": "medium"}], "matter_number": "CB-MA-2404", "prepared_for": "Tamarack Foods Group", "schema_version": "1.0", "task_id": "cb100-004-tamarack-foods"}}, "metadata": {"benchmark": "CounselBench-100", "code_license": "Apache-2.0", "data_license": "CC-BY-4.0", "deadline": "2026-09-15", "document_count": 96, "jurisdiction": "Illinois", "matter_number": "CB-MA-2404", "mcp_commit": "9a96ea6e5913736f92b88345bf51caeaaa8e719f", "mcp_package": "@modelcontextprotocol/server-filesystem@2026.7.10", "practice_area": "corporate-ma", "reference_tool_calls": 46, "required_evidence_reads": 33, "synthetic": true, "venue": "Cook County, Illinois", "version": "2.0.0"}, "prompt": "You are buyer-side transactions counsel for Tamarack Foods Group. Several workstreams have maintained separate versions of the truth; your assignment is to produce one auditable legal view. The divested nutrition plant has private-label commitments, shared wastewater permits, a union successorship clause, and disputed promotional accruals. Decision due 2026-09-15. Illinois law governs; Cook County, Illinois is the forum. Distinguish a missing document from an affirmative contradiction in the documents that are present. Work out the defensible position from the matter production and leave an audit-ready exception tracker and concise advice for the supervising lawyer. Keep confirmed conflicts separate from open questions, cite the records that actually control each conclusion, and do not fill gaps with outside facts.", "rubric": {"criteria": [{"category": "procedure", "description": "Complete at least 46 successful, argument-specific evidence and output calls.", "id": "procedure.minimum_successful_tool_calls"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Find and read the 33 controlling, corroborating, and work-product-control records in full.", "id": "procedure.all_evidence_read_in_full"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Inspect file metadata for the eight designated critical primary records before relying on them.", "id": "procedure.chain_of_custody_metadata_checked"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Confirm the sandbox's allowed document and output roots.", "id": "procedure.allowed_directories_checked"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Inventory all 96 records so the relevant sources are discovered among the context records.", "id": "procedure.recursive_inventory_completed"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Search the production for email evidence that may corroborate or contradict formal records.", "id": "procedure.targeted_search_completed"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Leave only findings.json and advice.md in the output workspace.", "id": "procedure.exact_deliverable_set"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Create both final work products through the sandbox MCP surface.", "id": "procedure.deliverables_written_through_mcp"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Produce findings.json as a valid JSON object.", "id": "findings.findings_is_object"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Report exactly 16 confirmed exceptions.", "id": "findings.findings_exact_count"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Use each stable finding ID exactly once.", "id": "findings.finding_ids_unique"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set schema_version to the released matter value '1.0'.", "id": "findings.top_level_schema_version"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set task_id to the released matter value 'cb100-004-tamarack-foods'.", "id": "findings.top_level_task_id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set matter_number to the released matter value 'CB-MA-2404'.", "id": "findings.top_level_matter_number"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set prepared_for to the released matter value 'Tamarack Foods Group'.", "id": "findings.top_level_prepared_for"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set as_of to the released matter value '2026-09-15'.", "id": "findings.top_level_as_of"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-01 exception for charter authorization mismatch.", "id": "findings.F-01.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's id from /workspace/documents/01_corporate/001_corporate_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_privacy_security/049_privacy_security_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's issue from /workspace/documents/01_corporate/001_corporate_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_privacy_security/049_privacy_security_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's severity from /workspace/documents/01_corporate/001_corporate_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_privacy_security/049_privacy_security_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's primary_source from /workspace/documents/01_corporate/001_corporate_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_privacy_security/049_privacy_security_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/01_corporate/001_corporate_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_privacy_security/049_privacy_security_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-01 using the exact controlled facts ['2026-02-24', 'CB-MA-2404-A577', '2026-04-02', 'CB-MA-2404-J482'].", "id": "findings.F-01.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-01's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-01.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-15', 'Willa Novak'] for F-01.", "id": "findings.F-01.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-02 exception for unrecorded option grant.", "id": "findings.F-02.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's id from /workspace/documents/01_corporate/004_corporate_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_privacy_security/052_privacy_security_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's issue from /workspace/documents/01_corporate/004_corporate_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_privacy_security/052_privacy_security_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's severity from /workspace/documents/01_corporate/004_corporate_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_privacy_security/052_privacy_security_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's primary_source from /workspace/documents/01_corporate/004_corporate_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_privacy_security/052_privacy_security_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/01_corporate/004_corporate_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_privacy_security/052_privacy_security_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-02 using the exact controlled facts ['$3,751,023.00', '$4,058,546.00'].", "id": "findings.F-02.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-02's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-02.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-15', 'Theo Laurent'] for F-02.", "id": "findings.F-02.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-03 exception for change-of-control consent.", "id": "findings.F-03.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's id from /workspace/documents/01_corporate/007_corporate_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_privacy_security/055_privacy_security_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's issue from /workspace/documents/01_corporate/007_corporate_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_privacy_security/055_privacy_security_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's severity from /workspace/documents/01_corporate/007_corporate_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_privacy_security/055_privacy_security_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's primary_source from /workspace/documents/01_corporate/007_corporate_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_privacy_security/055_privacy_security_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/01_corporate/007_corporate_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_privacy_security/055_privacy_security_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-03 using the exact controlled facts ['Caleb Hassan', 'Samuel Kim'].", "id": "findings.F-03.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-03's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-03.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-15', 'Amara Patel'] for F-03.", "id": "findings.F-03.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-04 exception for anti-assignment restriction.", "id": "findings.F-04.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's id from /workspace/documents/02_capitalization/010_capitalization_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_regulatory/058_regulatory_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's issue from /workspace/documents/02_capitalization/010_capitalization_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_regulatory/058_regulatory_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's severity from /workspace/documents/02_capitalization/010_capitalization_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_regulatory/058_regulatory_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's primary_source from /workspace/documents/02_capitalization/010_capitalization_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_regulatory/058_regulatory_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/02_capitalization/010_capitalization_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_regulatory/058_regulatory_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-04 using the exact controlled facts ['closed without exception', 'CB-MA-2404-D906', 'open and escalated', 'CB-MA-2404-M508'].", "id": "findings.F-04.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-04's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-04.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-15', 'Henry Cho'] for F-04.", "id": "findings.F-04.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-05 exception for most-favored-customer exposure.", "id": "findings.F-05.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's id from /workspace/documents/02_capitalization/013_capitalization_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_regulatory/061_regulatory_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's issue from /workspace/documents/02_capitalization/013_capitalization_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_regulatory/061_regulatory_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's severity from /workspace/documents/02_capitalization/013_capitalization_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_regulatory/061_regulatory_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's primary_source from /workspace/documents/02_capitalization/013_capitalization_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_regulatory/061_regulatory_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/02_capitalization/013_capitalization_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_regulatory/061_regulatory_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-05 using the exact controlled facts ['Cook County, Illinois', 'Illinois'].", "id": "findings.F-05.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-05's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-05.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-15', 'Nadine Flores'] for F-05.", "id": "findings.F-05.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-06 exception for financial covenant breach.", "id": "findings.F-06.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's id from /workspace/documents/02_capitalization/016_capitalization_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_regulatory/064_regulatory_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's issue from /workspace/documents/02_capitalization/016_capitalization_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_regulatory/064_regulatory_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's severity from /workspace/documents/02_capitalization/016_capitalization_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_regulatory/064_regulatory_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's primary_source from /workspace/documents/02_capitalization/016_capitalization_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_regulatory/064_regulatory_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/02_capitalization/016_capitalization_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_regulatory/064_regulatory_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-06 using the exact controlled facts ['11%', '18%'].", "id": "findings.F-06.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-06's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-06.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-15', 'Micah Sullivan'] for F-06.", "id": "findings.F-06.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-07 exception for key-person retention gap.", "id": "findings.F-07.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's id from /workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/019_material_contracts_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_litigation/067_litigation_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's issue from /workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/019_material_contracts_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_litigation/067_litigation_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's severity from /workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/019_material_contracts_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_litigation/067_litigation_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's primary_source from /workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/019_material_contracts_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_litigation/067_litigation_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/019_material_contracts_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_litigation/067_litigation_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-07 using the exact controlled facts ['notices-tamarack_foods_group@example.test', 'archive-copper_kettle_nutrition_co@example.test'].", "id": "findings.F-07.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-07's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-07.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-15', 'Farah Ibrahim'] for F-07.", "id": "findings.F-07.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-08 exception for invention assignment defect.", "id": "findings.F-08.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's id from /workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/022_material_contracts_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_litigation/070_litigation_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's issue from /workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/022_material_contracts_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_litigation/070_litigation_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's severity from /workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/022_material_contracts_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_litigation/070_litigation_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's primary_source from /workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/022_material_contracts_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_litigation/070_litigation_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/022_material_contracts_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_litigation/070_litigation_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-08 using the exact controlled facts ['175 records', '2026-02-14', '69 records', '2026-03-27'].", "id": "findings.F-08.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-08's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-08.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-15', 'Owen Delgado'] for F-08.", "id": "findings.F-08.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-09 exception for open-source copyleft exposure.", "id": "findings.F-09.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's id from /workspace/documents/04_debt_security/025_debt_security_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_real_property/073_real_property_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's issue from /workspace/documents/04_debt_security/025_debt_security_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_real_property/073_real_property_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's severity from /workspace/documents/04_debt_security/025_debt_security_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_real_property/073_real_property_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's primary_source from /workspace/documents/04_debt_security/025_debt_security_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_real_property/073_real_property_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/04_debt_security/025_debt_security_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_real_property/073_real_property_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-09 using the exact controlled facts ['2025-09-21', 'CB-MA-2404-I961', '2025-10-27', 'CB-MA-2404-R789'].", "id": "findings.F-09.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-09's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-09.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-15', 'Lena Varga'] for F-09.", "id": "findings.F-09.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-10 exception for unreported security incident.", "id": "findings.F-10.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's id from /workspace/documents/04_debt_security/028_debt_security_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_real_property/076_real_property_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's issue from /workspace/documents/04_debt_security/028_debt_security_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_real_property/076_real_property_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's severity from /workspace/documents/04_debt_security/028_debt_security_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_real_property/076_real_property_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's primary_source from /workspace/documents/04_debt_security/028_debt_security_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_real_property/076_real_property_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/04_debt_security/028_debt_security_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_real_property/076_real_property_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-10 using the exact controlled facts ['$5,553,159.00', '$5,712,818.00'].", "id": "findings.F-10.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-10's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-10.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-15', 'Samuel Kim'] for F-10.", "id": "findings.F-10.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-11 exception for permit transfer restriction.", "id": "findings.F-11.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's id from /workspace/documents/04_debt_security/031_debt_security_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_real_property/079_real_property_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's issue from /workspace/documents/04_debt_security/031_debt_security_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_real_property/079_real_property_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's severity from /workspace/documents/04_debt_security/031_debt_security_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_real_property/079_real_property_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's primary_source from /workspace/documents/04_debt_security/031_debt_security_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_real_property/079_real_property_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/04_debt_security/031_debt_security_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_real_property/079_real_property_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-11 using the exact controlled facts ['Caleb Hassan', 'Theo Laurent'].", "id": "findings.F-11.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-11's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-11.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-15', 'Maya Ellison'] for F-11.", "id": "findings.F-11.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-12 exception for threatened customer dispute.", "id": "findings.F-12.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's id from /workspace/documents/05_employment/034_employment_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_tax_insurance/082_tax_insurance_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's issue from /workspace/documents/05_employment/034_employment_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_tax_insurance/082_tax_insurance_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's severity from /workspace/documents/05_employment/034_employment_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_tax_insurance/082_tax_insurance_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's primary_source from /workspace/documents/05_employment/034_employment_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_tax_insurance/082_tax_insurance_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/05_employment/034_employment_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_tax_insurance/082_tax_insurance_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-12 using the exact controlled facts ['closed without exception', 'CB-MA-2404-L192', 'open and escalated', 'CB-MA-2404-U384'].", "id": "findings.F-12.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-12's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-12.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-15', 'Rafael Okafor'] for F-12.", "id": "findings.F-12.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-13 exception for facility title exception.", "id": "findings.F-13.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's id from /workspace/documents/05_employment/037_employment_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_tax_insurance/085_tax_insurance_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's issue from /workspace/documents/05_employment/037_employment_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_tax_insurance/085_tax_insurance_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's severity from /workspace/documents/05_employment/037_employment_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_tax_insurance/085_tax_insurance_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's primary_source from /workspace/documents/05_employment/037_employment_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_tax_insurance/085_tax_insurance_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/05_employment/037_employment_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_tax_insurance/085_tax_insurance_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-13 using the exact controlled facts ['Cook County, Illinois', 'Illinois'].", "id": "findings.F-13.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-13's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-13.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-15', 'Nora Chen'] for F-13.", "id": "findings.F-13.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-14 exception for sales-tax nexus gap.", "id": "findings.F-14.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's id from /workspace/documents/05_employment/040_employment_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_tax_insurance/088_tax_insurance_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's issue from /workspace/documents/05_employment/040_employment_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_tax_insurance/088_tax_insurance_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's severity from /workspace/documents/05_employment/040_employment_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_tax_insurance/088_tax_insurance_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's primary_source from /workspace/documents/05_employment/040_employment_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_tax_insurance/088_tax_insurance_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/05_employment/040_employment_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_tax_insurance/088_tax_insurance_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-14 using the exact controlled facts ['8%', '10%'].", "id": "findings.F-14.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-14's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-14.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-15', 'Dominic Alvarez'] for F-14.", "id": "findings.F-14.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-15 exception for claims-made insurance tail.", "id": "findings.F-15.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's id from /workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/043_ip_technology_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_financials/091_financials_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's issue from /workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/043_ip_technology_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_financials/091_financials_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's severity from /workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/043_ip_technology_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_financials/091_financials_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's primary_source from /workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/043_ip_technology_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_financials/091_financials_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/043_ip_technology_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_financials/091_financials_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-15 using the exact controlled facts ['notices-tamarack_foods_group@example.test', 'archive-copper_kettle_nutrition_co@example.test'].", "id": "findings.F-15.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-15's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-15.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-15', 'Priya Raman'] for F-15.", "id": "findings.F-15.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-16 exception for revenue recognition exception.", "id": "findings.F-16.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's id from /workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/046_ip_technology_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_financials/094_financials_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's issue from /workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/046_ip_technology_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_financials/094_financials_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's severity from /workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/046_ip_technology_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_financials/094_financials_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's primary_source from /workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/046_ip_technology_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_financials/094_financials_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/046_ip_technology_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_financials/094_financials_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-16 using the exact controlled facts ['97 records', '2025-07-11', '73 records', '2025-08-25'].", "id": "findings.F-16.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-16's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-16.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-15', 'Elliot Mercer'] for F-16.", "id": "findings.F-16.action_anchors"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Executive assessment' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Executive assessment"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Method and record coverage' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Method and record coverage"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Findings' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Findings"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Recommended next actions' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Recommended next actions"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Assumptions and limitations' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Assumptions and limitations"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-01 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-01"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-02 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-02"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-03 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-03"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-04 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-04"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-05 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-05"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-06 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-06"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-07 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-07"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-08 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-08"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-09 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-09"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-10 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-10"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-11 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-11"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-12 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-12"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-13 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-13"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-14 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-14"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-15 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-15"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-16 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-16"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Do not claim the production has no issues or that every record is consistent.", "id": "memo.forbidden_claims_absent"}], "decision_options": [{"id": "cross-source-reconciliation", "label": "Reconcile controlling and corroborating records", "reason": "The CB-MA-2404 production contains independently maintained records; a defensible answer must preserve each supported conflict and its cure owner.", "selected": true}, {"id": "latest-record-controls", "label": "Treat the latest record as controlling", "reason": "Timestamp recency does not establish legal priority, execution, or approval authority.", "selected": false}, {"id": "primary-records-only", "label": "Report primary records without reconciliation", "reason": "Primary records alone conceal the operational conflicts that create the actionable exceptions.", "selected": false}], "gates": ["all_evidence_read_in_full", "chain_of_custody_metadata_checked", "findings_criteria_complete", "memo_criteria_complete", "deliverables_written_through_mcp"], "metadata_checks": 8, "metric": "weighted_criteria_score", "minimum_tool_calls": 46, "required_deliverables": ["findings.json", "advice.md"], "required_document_reads": 33, "type": "deterministic", "weights": {"findings": 0.55, "memo": 0.2, "procedure": 0.25}}, "task_id": "cb100-004-tamarack-foods", "task_name": "Project Copper Kettle food plant divestiture", "world_id": "counselbench-filesystem-mcp-v2"}
-{"context_files": ["task_files/cb100-005-solace-mobility/01_corporate/001_corporate_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-005-solace-mobility/01_corporate/002_corporate_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-005-solace-mobility/01_corporate/003_corporate_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-005-solace-mobility/01_corporate/004_corporate_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-005-solace-mobility/01_corporate/005_corporate_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-005-solace-mobility/01_corporate/006_corporate_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-005-solace-mobility/01_corporate/007_corporate_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-005-solace-mobility/01_corporate/008_corporate_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-005-solace-mobility/02_capitalization/009_capitalization_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-005-solace-mobility/02_capitalization/010_capitalization_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-005-solace-mobility/02_capitalization/011_capitalization_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-005-solace-mobility/02_capitalization/012_capitalization_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-005-solace-mobility/02_capitalization/013_capitalization_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-005-solace-mobility/02_capitalization/014_capitalization_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-005-solace-mobility/02_capitalization/015_capitalization_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-005-solace-mobility/02_capitalization/016_capitalization_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-005-solace-mobility/03_material_contracts/017_material_contracts_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-005-solace-mobility/03_material_contracts/018_material_contracts_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-005-solace-mobility/03_material_contracts/019_material_contracts_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-005-solace-mobility/03_material_contracts/020_material_contracts_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-005-solace-mobility/03_material_contracts/021_material_contracts_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-005-solace-mobility/03_material_contracts/022_material_contracts_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-005-solace-mobility/03_material_contracts/023_material_contracts_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-005-solace-mobility/03_material_contracts/024_material_contracts_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-005-solace-mobility/04_debt_security/025_debt_security_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-005-solace-mobility/04_debt_security/026_debt_security_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-005-solace-mobility/04_debt_security/027_debt_security_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-005-solace-mobility/04_debt_security/028_debt_security_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-005-solace-mobility/04_debt_security/029_debt_security_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-005-solace-mobility/04_debt_security/030_debt_security_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-005-solace-mobility/04_debt_security/031_debt_security_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-005-solace-mobility/04_debt_security/032_debt_security_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-005-solace-mobility/05_employment/033_employment_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-005-solace-mobility/05_employment/034_employment_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-005-solace-mobility/05_employment/035_employment_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-005-solace-mobility/05_employment/036_employment_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-005-solace-mobility/05_employment/037_employment_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-005-solace-mobility/05_employment/038_employment_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-005-solace-mobility/05_employment/039_employment_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-005-solace-mobility/05_employment/040_employment_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-005-solace-mobility/06_ip_technology/041_ip_technology_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-005-solace-mobility/06_ip_technology/042_ip_technology_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-005-solace-mobility/06_ip_technology/043_ip_technology_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-005-solace-mobility/06_ip_technology/044_ip_technology_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-005-solace-mobility/06_ip_technology/045_ip_technology_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-005-solace-mobility/06_ip_technology/046_ip_technology_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-005-solace-mobility/06_ip_technology/047_ip_technology_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-005-solace-mobility/06_ip_technology/048_ip_technology_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-005-solace-mobility/07_privacy_security/049_privacy_security_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-005-solace-mobility/07_privacy_security/050_privacy_security_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-005-solace-mobility/07_privacy_security/051_privacy_security_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-005-solace-mobility/07_privacy_security/052_privacy_security_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-005-solace-mobility/07_privacy_security/053_privacy_security_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-005-solace-mobility/07_privacy_security/054_privacy_security_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-005-solace-mobility/07_privacy_security/055_privacy_security_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-005-solace-mobility/07_privacy_security/056_privacy_security_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-005-solace-mobility/08_regulatory/057_regulatory_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-005-solace-mobility/08_regulatory/058_regulatory_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-005-solace-mobility/08_regulatory/059_regulatory_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-005-solace-mobility/08_regulatory/060_regulatory_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-005-solace-mobility/08_regulatory/061_regulatory_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-005-solace-mobility/08_regulatory/062_regulatory_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-005-solace-mobility/08_regulatory/063_regulatory_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-005-solace-mobility/08_regulatory/064_regulatory_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-005-solace-mobility/09_litigation/065_litigation_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-005-solace-mobility/09_litigation/066_litigation_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-005-solace-mobility/09_litigation/067_litigation_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-005-solace-mobility/09_litigation/068_litigation_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-005-solace-mobility/09_litigation/069_litigation_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-005-solace-mobility/09_litigation/070_litigation_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-005-solace-mobility/09_litigation/071_litigation_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-005-solace-mobility/09_litigation/072_litigation_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-005-solace-mobility/10_real_property/073_real_property_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-005-solace-mobility/10_real_property/074_real_property_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-005-solace-mobility/10_real_property/075_real_property_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-005-solace-mobility/10_real_property/076_real_property_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-005-solace-mobility/10_real_property/077_real_property_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-005-solace-mobility/10_real_property/078_real_property_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-005-solace-mobility/10_real_property/079_real_property_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-005-solace-mobility/10_real_property/080_real_property_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-005-solace-mobility/11_tax_insurance/081_tax_insurance_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-005-solace-mobility/11_tax_insurance/082_tax_insurance_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-005-solace-mobility/11_tax_insurance/083_tax_insurance_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-005-solace-mobility/11_tax_insurance/084_tax_insurance_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-005-solace-mobility/11_tax_insurance/085_tax_insurance_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-005-solace-mobility/11_tax_insurance/086_tax_insurance_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-005-solace-mobility/11_tax_insurance/087_tax_insurance_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-005-solace-mobility/11_tax_insurance/088_tax_insurance_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-005-solace-mobility/12_financials/089_financials_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-005-solace-mobility/12_financials/090_financials_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-005-solace-mobility/12_financials/091_financials_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-005-solace-mobility/12_financials/092_financials_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-005-solace-mobility/12_financials/093_financials_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-005-solace-mobility/12_financials/094_financials_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-005-solace-mobility/12_financials/095_financials_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-005-solace-mobility/12_financials/096_financials_status_report.md"], "gold_output": {"advice_markdown": "# Counsel advice — Project Lantern fleet technology acquisition\n\n## Executive assessment\n\nFor Solace Mobility Holdings matter CB-MA-2405, the review identified 16 source-supported exceptions requiring action before 2026-09-18. The assessment concerns Lantern Route Analytics, Inc. and the supplied record for California.\n\n## Method and record coverage\n\nThe review inventoried all 96 production files, read the 33 controlling, corroborating, and control records, searched the email exports, and checked metadata for the designated chain-of-custody sample. Conclusions are limited to the synthetic production supplied for this benchmark matter.\n\n## Findings\n\n### F-01 — charter authorization mismatch (critical)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for charter authorization mismatch: one source states the operative date is 2025-08-07 under control reference CB-MA-2405-A856, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2025-08-17 under response reference CB-MA-2405-J365.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/01_corporate/001_corporate_control_register.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/07_privacy_security/049_privacy_security_control_register.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-18, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Theo Laurent.\n\n### F-02 — unrecorded option grant (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for unrecorded option grant: one source states the controlling amount is $5,062,786.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $5,092,072.00.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/01_corporate/004_corporate_ledger_export.csv`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/07_privacy_security/052_privacy_security_ledger_export.csv`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-18, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Amara Patel.\n\n### F-03 — change-of-control consent (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for change-of-control consent: one source states approval is attributed to Leona Park as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Rafael Okafor and contains no entry for Leona Park.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/01_corporate/007_corporate_officer_certificate.html`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/07_privacy_security/055_privacy_security_officer_certificate.html`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-18, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Henry Cho.\n\n### F-04 — anti-assignment restriction (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for anti-assignment restriction: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-MA-2405-D735, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-MA-2405-M148.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/02_capitalization/010_capitalization_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/08_regulatory/058_regulatory_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-18, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Nadine Flores.\n\n### F-05 — most-favored-customer exposure (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for most-favored-customer exposure: one source states the applicable location is Santa Clara County, California, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to California operations outside Santa Clara County, California.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/02_capitalization/013_capitalization_review_memorandum.json`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/08_regulatory/061_regulatory_review_memorandum.json`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-18, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Micah Sullivan.\n\n### F-06 — financial covenant breach (low)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for financial covenant breach: one source states the threshold is 3% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 10% and produced a different exception result.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/02_capitalization/016_capitalization_status_report.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/08_regulatory/064_regulatory_status_report.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-18, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Farah Ibrahim.\n\n### F-07 — key-person retention gap (critical)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for key-person retention gap: one source states formal notice must use notices-solace_mobility_holdings@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-lantern_route_analytics_inc@example.test.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/019_material_contracts_correspondence.eml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/09_litigation/067_litigation_correspondence.eml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-18, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Owen Delgado.\n\n### F-08 — invention assignment defect (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for invention assignment defect: one source states the governed population contains 167 records through 2025-09-19, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 74 records through 2025-11-04.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/022_material_contracts_formal_notice.xml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/09_litigation/070_litigation_formal_notice.xml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-18, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Lena Varga.\n\n### F-09 — open-source copyleft exposure (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for open-source copyleft exposure: one source states the operative date is 2025-07-12 under control reference CB-MA-2405-I410, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2025-08-24 under response reference CB-MA-2405-R262.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/04_debt_security/025_debt_security_control_register.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/10_real_property/073_real_property_control_register.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-18, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Samuel Kim.\n\n### F-10 — unreported security incident (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for unreported security incident: one source states the controlling amount is $5,698,842.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $5,784,184.00.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/04_debt_security/028_debt_security_ledger_export.csv`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/10_real_property/076_real_property_ledger_export.csv`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-18, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Maya Ellison.\n\n### F-11 — permit transfer restriction (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for permit transfer restriction: one source states approval is attributed to Leona Park as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Henry Cho and contains no entry for Leona Park.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/04_debt_security/031_debt_security_officer_certificate.html`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/10_real_property/079_real_property_officer_certificate.html`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-18, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Rafael Okafor.\n\n### F-12 — threatened customer dispute (low)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for threatened customer dispute: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-MA-2405-L744, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-MA-2405-U911.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/05_employment/034_employment_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/11_tax_insurance/082_tax_insurance_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-18, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Nora Chen.\n\n### F-13 — facility title exception (critical)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for facility title exception: one source states the applicable location is Santa Clara County, California, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to California operations outside Santa Clara County, California.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/05_employment/037_employment_review_memorandum.json`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/11_tax_insurance/085_tax_insurance_review_memorandum.json`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-18, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Dominic Alvarez.\n\n### F-14 — sales-tax nexus gap (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for sales-tax nexus gap: one source states the threshold is 6% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 10% and produced a different exception result.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/05_employment/040_employment_status_report.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/11_tax_insurance/088_tax_insurance_status_report.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-18, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Priya Raman.\n\n### F-15 — claims-made insurance tail (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for claims-made insurance tail: one source states formal notice must use notices-solace_mobility_holdings@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-lantern_route_analytics_inc@example.test.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/043_ip_technology_correspondence.eml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/12_financials/091_financials_correspondence.eml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-18, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Elliot Mercer.\n\n### F-16 — revenue recognition exception (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for revenue recognition exception: one source states the governed population contains 59 records through 2025-06-03, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 41 records through 2025-06-16.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/046_ip_technology_formal_notice.xml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/12_financials/094_financials_formal_notice.xml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-18, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Talia Brooks.\n\n## Recommended next actions\n\nSequence the critical and high findings first, assign the named owners, preserve the cited records, and document any resolution in the controlling matter register before the stated deadline.\n\n## Assumptions and limitations\n\nThis analysis is confined to task cb100-005-solace-mobility and the supplied synthetic evidence. It does not rely on external facts, does not resolve disputed law, and is not legal advice for a real person or entity.\n", "findings": {"as_of": "2026-09-18", "findings": [{"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/07_privacy_security/049_privacy_security_control_register.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for charter authorization mismatch: one source states the operative date is 2025-08-07 under control reference CB-MA-2405-A856, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2025-08-17 under response reference CB-MA-2405-J365.", "id": "F-01", "issue": "charter authorization mismatch", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/01_corporate/001_corporate_control_register.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-18, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Theo Laurent.", "severity": "critical"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/07_privacy_security/052_privacy_security_ledger_export.csv", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for unrecorded option grant: one source states the controlling amount is $5,062,786.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $5,092,072.00.", "id": "F-02", "issue": "unrecorded option grant", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/01_corporate/004_corporate_ledger_export.csv", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-18, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Amara Patel.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/07_privacy_security/055_privacy_security_officer_certificate.html", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for change-of-control consent: one source states approval is attributed to Leona Park as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Rafael Okafor and contains no entry for Leona Park.", "id": "F-03", "issue": "change-of-control consent", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/01_corporate/007_corporate_officer_certificate.html", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-18, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Henry Cho.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/08_regulatory/058_regulatory_executed_instrument.txt", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for anti-assignment restriction: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-MA-2405-D735, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-MA-2405-M148.", "id": "F-04", "issue": "anti-assignment restriction", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/02_capitalization/010_capitalization_executed_instrument.txt", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-18, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Nadine Flores.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/08_regulatory/061_regulatory_review_memorandum.json", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for most-favored-customer exposure: one source states the applicable location is Santa Clara County, California, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to California operations outside Santa Clara County, California.", "id": "F-05", "issue": "most-favored-customer exposure", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/02_capitalization/013_capitalization_review_memorandum.json", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-18, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Micah Sullivan.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/08_regulatory/064_regulatory_status_report.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for financial covenant breach: one source states the threshold is 3% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 10% and produced a different exception result.", "id": "F-06", "issue": "financial covenant breach", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/02_capitalization/016_capitalization_status_report.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-18, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Farah Ibrahim.", "severity": "low"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/09_litigation/067_litigation_correspondence.eml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for key-person retention gap: one source states formal notice must use notices-solace_mobility_holdings@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-lantern_route_analytics_inc@example.test.", "id": "F-07", "issue": "key-person retention gap", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/019_material_contracts_correspondence.eml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-18, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Owen Delgado.", "severity": "critical"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/09_litigation/070_litigation_formal_notice.xml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for invention assignment defect: one source states the governed population contains 167 records through 2025-09-19, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 74 records through 2025-11-04.", "id": "F-08", "issue": "invention assignment defect", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/022_material_contracts_formal_notice.xml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-18, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Lena Varga.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/10_real_property/073_real_property_control_register.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for open-source copyleft exposure: one source states the operative date is 2025-07-12 under control reference CB-MA-2405-I410, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2025-08-24 under response reference CB-MA-2405-R262.", "id": "F-09", "issue": "open-source copyleft exposure", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/04_debt_security/025_debt_security_control_register.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-18, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Samuel Kim.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/10_real_property/076_real_property_ledger_export.csv", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for unreported security incident: one source states the controlling amount is $5,698,842.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $5,784,184.00.", "id": "F-10", "issue": "unreported security incident", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/04_debt_security/028_debt_security_ledger_export.csv", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-18, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Maya Ellison.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/10_real_property/079_real_property_officer_certificate.html", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for permit transfer restriction: one source states approval is attributed to Leona Park as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Henry Cho and contains no entry for Leona Park.", "id": "F-11", "issue": "permit transfer restriction", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/04_debt_security/031_debt_security_officer_certificate.html", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-18, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Rafael Okafor.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/11_tax_insurance/082_tax_insurance_executed_instrument.txt", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for threatened customer dispute: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-MA-2405-L744, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-MA-2405-U911.", "id": "F-12", "issue": "threatened customer dispute", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/05_employment/034_employment_executed_instrument.txt", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-18, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Nora Chen.", "severity": "low"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/11_tax_insurance/085_tax_insurance_review_memorandum.json", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for facility title exception: one source states the applicable location is Santa Clara County, California, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to California operations outside Santa Clara County, California.", "id": "F-13", "issue": "facility title exception", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/05_employment/037_employment_review_memorandum.json", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-18, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Dominic Alvarez.", "severity": "critical"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/11_tax_insurance/088_tax_insurance_status_report.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for sales-tax nexus gap: one source states the threshold is 6% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 10% and produced a different exception result.", "id": "F-14", "issue": "sales-tax nexus gap", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/05_employment/040_employment_status_report.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-18, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Priya Raman.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/12_financials/091_financials_correspondence.eml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for claims-made insurance tail: one source states formal notice must use notices-solace_mobility_holdings@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-lantern_route_analytics_inc@example.test.", "id": "F-15", "issue": "claims-made insurance tail", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/043_ip_technology_correspondence.eml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-18, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Elliot Mercer.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/12_financials/094_financials_formal_notice.xml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for revenue recognition exception: one source states the governed population contains 59 records through 2025-06-03, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 41 records through 2025-06-16.", "id": "F-16", "issue": "revenue recognition exception", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/046_ip_technology_formal_notice.xml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-18, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Talia Brooks.", "severity": "medium"}], "matter_number": "CB-MA-2405", "prepared_for": "Solace Mobility Holdings", "schema_version": "1.0", "task_id": "cb100-005-solace-mobility"}}, "metadata": {"benchmark": "CounselBench-100", "code_license": "Apache-2.0", "data_license": "CC-BY-4.0", "deadline": "2026-09-18", "document_count": 96, "jurisdiction": "California", "matter_number": "CB-MA-2405", "mcp_commit": "9a96ea6e5913736f92b88345bf51caeaaa8e719f", "mcp_package": "@modelcontextprotocol/server-filesystem@2026.7.10", "practice_area": "corporate-ma", "reference_tool_calls": 46, "required_evidence_reads": 33, "synthetic": true, "venue": "Santa Clara County, California", "version": "2.0.0"}, "prompt": "You are buyer-side transactions counsel for Solace Mobility Holdings. Outside counsel inherited this file after turnover on the client team and must validate every operative record before advising. The route-optimization target relies on contractor-created models, municipal fleet data, and a customer letter that changes the pricing floor after closing. Decision due 2026-09-18. California law governs; Santa Clara County, California is the forum. Evaluate both legal consequence and the practical owner needed to cure each exception. Work out the defensible position from the matter production and leave an audit-ready exception tracker and concise advice for the supervising lawyer. Keep confirmed conflicts separate from open questions, cite the records that actually control each conclusion, and do not fill gaps with outside facts.", "rubric": {"criteria": [{"category": "procedure", "description": "Complete at least 46 successful, argument-specific evidence and output calls.", "id": "procedure.minimum_successful_tool_calls"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Find and read the 33 controlling, corroborating, and work-product-control records in full.", "id": "procedure.all_evidence_read_in_full"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Inspect file metadata for the eight designated critical primary records before relying on them.", "id": "procedure.chain_of_custody_metadata_checked"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Confirm the sandbox's allowed document and output roots.", "id": "procedure.allowed_directories_checked"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Inventory all 96 records so the relevant sources are discovered among the context records.", "id": "procedure.recursive_inventory_completed"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Search the production for email evidence that may corroborate or contradict formal records.", "id": "procedure.targeted_search_completed"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Leave only findings.json and advice.md in the output workspace.", "id": "procedure.exact_deliverable_set"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Create both final work products through the sandbox MCP surface.", "id": "procedure.deliverables_written_through_mcp"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Produce findings.json as a valid JSON object.", "id": "findings.findings_is_object"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Report exactly 16 confirmed exceptions.", "id": "findings.findings_exact_count"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Use each stable finding ID exactly once.", "id": "findings.finding_ids_unique"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set schema_version to the released matter value '1.0'.", "id": "findings.top_level_schema_version"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set task_id to the released matter value 'cb100-005-solace-mobility'.", "id": "findings.top_level_task_id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set matter_number to the released matter value 'CB-MA-2405'.", "id": "findings.top_level_matter_number"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set prepared_for to the released matter value 'Solace Mobility Holdings'.", "id": "findings.top_level_prepared_for"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set as_of to the released matter value '2026-09-18'.", "id": "findings.top_level_as_of"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-01 exception for charter authorization mismatch.", "id": "findings.F-01.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's id from /workspace/documents/01_corporate/001_corporate_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_privacy_security/049_privacy_security_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's issue from /workspace/documents/01_corporate/001_corporate_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_privacy_security/049_privacy_security_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's severity from /workspace/documents/01_corporate/001_corporate_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_privacy_security/049_privacy_security_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's primary_source from /workspace/documents/01_corporate/001_corporate_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_privacy_security/049_privacy_security_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/01_corporate/001_corporate_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_privacy_security/049_privacy_security_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-01 using the exact controlled facts ['2025-08-07', 'CB-MA-2405-A856', '2025-08-17', 'CB-MA-2405-J365'].", "id": "findings.F-01.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-01's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-01.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-18', 'Theo Laurent'] for F-01.", "id": "findings.F-01.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-02 exception for unrecorded option grant.", "id": "findings.F-02.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's id from /workspace/documents/01_corporate/004_corporate_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_privacy_security/052_privacy_security_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's issue from /workspace/documents/01_corporate/004_corporate_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_privacy_security/052_privacy_security_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's severity from /workspace/documents/01_corporate/004_corporate_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_privacy_security/052_privacy_security_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's primary_source from /workspace/documents/01_corporate/004_corporate_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_privacy_security/052_privacy_security_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/01_corporate/004_corporate_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_privacy_security/052_privacy_security_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-02 using the exact controlled facts ['$5,062,786.00', '$5,092,072.00'].", "id": "findings.F-02.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-02's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-02.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-18', 'Amara Patel'] for F-02.", "id": "findings.F-02.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-03 exception for change-of-control consent.", "id": "findings.F-03.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's id from /workspace/documents/01_corporate/007_corporate_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_privacy_security/055_privacy_security_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's issue from /workspace/documents/01_corporate/007_corporate_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_privacy_security/055_privacy_security_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's severity from /workspace/documents/01_corporate/007_corporate_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_privacy_security/055_privacy_security_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's primary_source from /workspace/documents/01_corporate/007_corporate_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_privacy_security/055_privacy_security_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/01_corporate/007_corporate_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_privacy_security/055_privacy_security_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-03 using the exact controlled facts ['Leona Park', 'Rafael Okafor'].", "id": "findings.F-03.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-03's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-03.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-18', 'Henry Cho'] for F-03.", "id": "findings.F-03.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-04 exception for anti-assignment restriction.", "id": "findings.F-04.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's id from /workspace/documents/02_capitalization/010_capitalization_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_regulatory/058_regulatory_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's issue from /workspace/documents/02_capitalization/010_capitalization_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_regulatory/058_regulatory_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's severity from /workspace/documents/02_capitalization/010_capitalization_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_regulatory/058_regulatory_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's primary_source from /workspace/documents/02_capitalization/010_capitalization_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_regulatory/058_regulatory_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/02_capitalization/010_capitalization_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_regulatory/058_regulatory_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-04 using the exact controlled facts ['closed without exception', 'CB-MA-2405-D735', 'open and escalated', 'CB-MA-2405-M148'].", "id": "findings.F-04.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-04's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-04.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-18', 'Nadine Flores'] for F-04.", "id": "findings.F-04.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-05 exception for most-favored-customer exposure.", "id": "findings.F-05.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's id from /workspace/documents/02_capitalization/013_capitalization_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_regulatory/061_regulatory_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's issue from /workspace/documents/02_capitalization/013_capitalization_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_regulatory/061_regulatory_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's severity from /workspace/documents/02_capitalization/013_capitalization_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_regulatory/061_regulatory_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's primary_source from /workspace/documents/02_capitalization/013_capitalization_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_regulatory/061_regulatory_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/02_capitalization/013_capitalization_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_regulatory/061_regulatory_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-05 using the exact controlled facts ['Santa Clara County, California', 'California'].", "id": "findings.F-05.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-05's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-05.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-18', 'Micah Sullivan'] for F-05.", "id": "findings.F-05.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-06 exception for financial covenant breach.", "id": "findings.F-06.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's id from /workspace/documents/02_capitalization/016_capitalization_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_regulatory/064_regulatory_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's issue from /workspace/documents/02_capitalization/016_capitalization_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_regulatory/064_regulatory_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's severity from /workspace/documents/02_capitalization/016_capitalization_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_regulatory/064_regulatory_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's primary_source from /workspace/documents/02_capitalization/016_capitalization_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_regulatory/064_regulatory_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/02_capitalization/016_capitalization_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_regulatory/064_regulatory_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-06 using the exact controlled facts ['3%', '10%'].", "id": "findings.F-06.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-06's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-06.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-18', 'Farah Ibrahim'] for F-06.", "id": "findings.F-06.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-07 exception for key-person retention gap.", "id": "findings.F-07.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's id from /workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/019_material_contracts_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_litigation/067_litigation_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's issue from /workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/019_material_contracts_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_litigation/067_litigation_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's severity from /workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/019_material_contracts_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_litigation/067_litigation_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's primary_source from /workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/019_material_contracts_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_litigation/067_litigation_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/019_material_contracts_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_litigation/067_litigation_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-07 using the exact controlled facts ['notices-solace_mobility_holdings@example.test', 'archive-lantern_route_analytics_inc@example.test'].", "id": "findings.F-07.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-07's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-07.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-18', 'Owen Delgado'] for F-07.", "id": "findings.F-07.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-08 exception for invention assignment defect.", "id": "findings.F-08.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's id from /workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/022_material_contracts_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_litigation/070_litigation_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's issue from /workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/022_material_contracts_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_litigation/070_litigation_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's severity from /workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/022_material_contracts_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_litigation/070_litigation_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's primary_source from /workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/022_material_contracts_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_litigation/070_litigation_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/022_material_contracts_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_litigation/070_litigation_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-08 using the exact controlled facts ['167 records', '2025-09-19', '74 records', '2025-11-04'].", "id": "findings.F-08.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-08's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-08.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-18', 'Lena Varga'] for F-08.", "id": "findings.F-08.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-09 exception for open-source copyleft exposure.", "id": "findings.F-09.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's id from /workspace/documents/04_debt_security/025_debt_security_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_real_property/073_real_property_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's issue from /workspace/documents/04_debt_security/025_debt_security_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_real_property/073_real_property_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's severity from /workspace/documents/04_debt_security/025_debt_security_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_real_property/073_real_property_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's primary_source from /workspace/documents/04_debt_security/025_debt_security_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_real_property/073_real_property_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/04_debt_security/025_debt_security_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_real_property/073_real_property_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-09 using the exact controlled facts ['2025-07-12', 'CB-MA-2405-I410', '2025-08-24', 'CB-MA-2405-R262'].", "id": "findings.F-09.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-09's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-09.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-18', 'Samuel Kim'] for F-09.", "id": "findings.F-09.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-10 exception for unreported security incident.", "id": "findings.F-10.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's id from /workspace/documents/04_debt_security/028_debt_security_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_real_property/076_real_property_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's issue from /workspace/documents/04_debt_security/028_debt_security_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_real_property/076_real_property_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's severity from /workspace/documents/04_debt_security/028_debt_security_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_real_property/076_real_property_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's primary_source from /workspace/documents/04_debt_security/028_debt_security_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_real_property/076_real_property_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/04_debt_security/028_debt_security_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_real_property/076_real_property_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-10 using the exact controlled facts ['$5,698,842.00', '$5,784,184.00'].", "id": "findings.F-10.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-10's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-10.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-18', 'Maya Ellison'] for F-10.", "id": "findings.F-10.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-11 exception for permit transfer restriction.", "id": "findings.F-11.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's id from /workspace/documents/04_debt_security/031_debt_security_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_real_property/079_real_property_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's issue from /workspace/documents/04_debt_security/031_debt_security_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_real_property/079_real_property_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's severity from /workspace/documents/04_debt_security/031_debt_security_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_real_property/079_real_property_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's primary_source from /workspace/documents/04_debt_security/031_debt_security_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_real_property/079_real_property_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/04_debt_security/031_debt_security_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_real_property/079_real_property_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-11 using the exact controlled facts ['Leona Park', 'Henry Cho'].", "id": "findings.F-11.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-11's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-11.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-18', 'Rafael Okafor'] for F-11.", "id": "findings.F-11.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-12 exception for threatened customer dispute.", "id": "findings.F-12.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's id from /workspace/documents/05_employment/034_employment_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_tax_insurance/082_tax_insurance_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's issue from /workspace/documents/05_employment/034_employment_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_tax_insurance/082_tax_insurance_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's severity from /workspace/documents/05_employment/034_employment_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_tax_insurance/082_tax_insurance_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's primary_source from /workspace/documents/05_employment/034_employment_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_tax_insurance/082_tax_insurance_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/05_employment/034_employment_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_tax_insurance/082_tax_insurance_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-12 using the exact controlled facts ['closed without exception', 'CB-MA-2405-L744', 'open and escalated', 'CB-MA-2405-U911'].", "id": "findings.F-12.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-12's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-12.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-18', 'Nora Chen'] for F-12.", "id": "findings.F-12.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-13 exception for facility title exception.", "id": "findings.F-13.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's id from /workspace/documents/05_employment/037_employment_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_tax_insurance/085_tax_insurance_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's issue from /workspace/documents/05_employment/037_employment_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_tax_insurance/085_tax_insurance_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's severity from /workspace/documents/05_employment/037_employment_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_tax_insurance/085_tax_insurance_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's primary_source from /workspace/documents/05_employment/037_employment_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_tax_insurance/085_tax_insurance_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/05_employment/037_employment_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_tax_insurance/085_tax_insurance_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-13 using the exact controlled facts ['Santa Clara County, California', 'California'].", "id": "findings.F-13.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-13's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-13.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-18', 'Dominic Alvarez'] for F-13.", "id": "findings.F-13.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-14 exception for sales-tax nexus gap.", "id": "findings.F-14.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's id from /workspace/documents/05_employment/040_employment_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_tax_insurance/088_tax_insurance_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's issue from /workspace/documents/05_employment/040_employment_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_tax_insurance/088_tax_insurance_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's severity from /workspace/documents/05_employment/040_employment_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_tax_insurance/088_tax_insurance_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's primary_source from /workspace/documents/05_employment/040_employment_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_tax_insurance/088_tax_insurance_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/05_employment/040_employment_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_tax_insurance/088_tax_insurance_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-14 using the exact controlled facts ['6%', '10%'].", "id": "findings.F-14.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-14's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-14.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-18', 'Priya Raman'] for F-14.", "id": "findings.F-14.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-15 exception for claims-made insurance tail.", "id": "findings.F-15.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's id from /workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/043_ip_technology_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_financials/091_financials_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's issue from /workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/043_ip_technology_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_financials/091_financials_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's severity from /workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/043_ip_technology_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_financials/091_financials_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's primary_source from /workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/043_ip_technology_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_financials/091_financials_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/043_ip_technology_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_financials/091_financials_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-15 using the exact controlled facts ['notices-solace_mobility_holdings@example.test', 'archive-lantern_route_analytics_inc@example.test'].", "id": "findings.F-15.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-15's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-15.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-18', 'Elliot Mercer'] for F-15.", "id": "findings.F-15.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-16 exception for revenue recognition exception.", "id": "findings.F-16.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's id from /workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/046_ip_technology_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_financials/094_financials_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's issue from /workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/046_ip_technology_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_financials/094_financials_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's severity from /workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/046_ip_technology_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_financials/094_financials_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's primary_source from /workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/046_ip_technology_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_financials/094_financials_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/046_ip_technology_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_financials/094_financials_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-16 using the exact controlled facts ['59 records', '2025-06-03', '41 records', '2025-06-16'].", "id": "findings.F-16.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-16's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-16.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-18', 'Talia Brooks'] for F-16.", "id": "findings.F-16.action_anchors"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Executive assessment' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Executive assessment"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Method and record coverage' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Method and record coverage"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Findings' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Findings"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Recommended next actions' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Recommended next actions"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Assumptions and limitations' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Assumptions and limitations"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-01 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-01"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-02 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-02"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-03 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-03"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-04 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-04"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-05 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-05"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-06 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-06"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-07 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-07"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-08 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-08"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-09 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-09"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-10 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-10"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-11 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-11"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-12 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-12"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-13 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-13"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-14 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-14"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-15 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-15"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-16 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-16"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Do not claim the production has no issues or that every record is consistent.", "id": "memo.forbidden_claims_absent"}], "decision_options": [{"id": "cross-source-reconciliation", "label": "Reconcile controlling and corroborating records", "reason": "The CB-MA-2405 production contains independently maintained records; a defensible answer must preserve each supported conflict and its cure owner.", "selected": true}, {"id": "latest-record-controls", "label": "Treat the latest record as controlling", "reason": "Timestamp recency does not establish legal priority, execution, or approval authority.", "selected": false}, {"id": "primary-records-only", "label": "Report primary records without reconciliation", "reason": "Primary records alone conceal the operational conflicts that create the actionable exceptions.", "selected": false}], "gates": ["all_evidence_read_in_full", "chain_of_custody_metadata_checked", "findings_criteria_complete", "memo_criteria_complete", "deliverables_written_through_mcp"], "metadata_checks": 8, "metric": "weighted_criteria_score", "minimum_tool_calls": 46, "required_deliverables": ["findings.json", "advice.md"], "required_document_reads": 33, "type": "deterministic", "weights": {"findings": 0.55, "memo": 0.2, "procedure": 0.25}}, "task_id": "cb100-005-solace-mobility", "task_name": "Project Lantern fleet technology acquisition", "world_id": "counselbench-filesystem-mcp-v2"}
-{"context_files": ["task_files/cb100-006-meridian-water/01_corporate/001_corporate_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-006-meridian-water/01_corporate/002_corporate_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-006-meridian-water/01_corporate/003_corporate_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-006-meridian-water/01_corporate/004_corporate_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-006-meridian-water/01_corporate/005_corporate_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-006-meridian-water/01_corporate/006_corporate_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-006-meridian-water/01_corporate/007_corporate_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-006-meridian-water/01_corporate/008_corporate_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-006-meridian-water/02_capitalization/009_capitalization_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-006-meridian-water/02_capitalization/010_capitalization_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-006-meridian-water/02_capitalization/011_capitalization_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-006-meridian-water/02_capitalization/012_capitalization_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-006-meridian-water/02_capitalization/013_capitalization_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-006-meridian-water/02_capitalization/014_capitalization_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-006-meridian-water/02_capitalization/015_capitalization_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-006-meridian-water/02_capitalization/016_capitalization_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-006-meridian-water/03_material_contracts/017_material_contracts_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-006-meridian-water/03_material_contracts/018_material_contracts_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-006-meridian-water/03_material_contracts/019_material_contracts_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-006-meridian-water/03_material_contracts/020_material_contracts_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-006-meridian-water/03_material_contracts/021_material_contracts_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-006-meridian-water/03_material_contracts/022_material_contracts_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-006-meridian-water/03_material_contracts/023_material_contracts_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-006-meridian-water/03_material_contracts/024_material_contracts_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-006-meridian-water/04_debt_security/025_debt_security_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-006-meridian-water/04_debt_security/026_debt_security_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-006-meridian-water/04_debt_security/027_debt_security_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-006-meridian-water/04_debt_security/028_debt_security_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-006-meridian-water/04_debt_security/029_debt_security_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-006-meridian-water/04_debt_security/030_debt_security_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-006-meridian-water/04_debt_security/031_debt_security_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-006-meridian-water/04_debt_security/032_debt_security_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-006-meridian-water/05_employment/033_employment_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-006-meridian-water/05_employment/034_employment_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-006-meridian-water/05_employment/035_employment_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-006-meridian-water/05_employment/036_employment_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-006-meridian-water/05_employment/037_employment_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-006-meridian-water/05_employment/038_employment_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-006-meridian-water/05_employment/039_employment_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-006-meridian-water/05_employment/040_employment_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-006-meridian-water/06_ip_technology/041_ip_technology_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-006-meridian-water/06_ip_technology/042_ip_technology_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-006-meridian-water/06_ip_technology/043_ip_technology_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-006-meridian-water/06_ip_technology/044_ip_technology_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-006-meridian-water/06_ip_technology/045_ip_technology_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-006-meridian-water/06_ip_technology/046_ip_technology_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-006-meridian-water/06_ip_technology/047_ip_technology_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-006-meridian-water/06_ip_technology/048_ip_technology_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-006-meridian-water/07_privacy_security/049_privacy_security_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-006-meridian-water/07_privacy_security/050_privacy_security_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-006-meridian-water/07_privacy_security/051_privacy_security_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-006-meridian-water/07_privacy_security/052_privacy_security_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-006-meridian-water/07_privacy_security/053_privacy_security_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-006-meridian-water/07_privacy_security/054_privacy_security_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-006-meridian-water/07_privacy_security/055_privacy_security_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-006-meridian-water/07_privacy_security/056_privacy_security_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-006-meridian-water/08_regulatory/057_regulatory_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-006-meridian-water/08_regulatory/058_regulatory_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-006-meridian-water/08_regulatory/059_regulatory_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-006-meridian-water/08_regulatory/060_regulatory_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-006-meridian-water/08_regulatory/061_regulatory_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-006-meridian-water/08_regulatory/062_regulatory_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-006-meridian-water/08_regulatory/063_regulatory_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-006-meridian-water/08_regulatory/064_regulatory_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-006-meridian-water/09_litigation/065_litigation_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-006-meridian-water/09_litigation/066_litigation_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-006-meridian-water/09_litigation/067_litigation_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-006-meridian-water/09_litigation/068_litigation_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-006-meridian-water/09_litigation/069_litigation_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-006-meridian-water/09_litigation/070_litigation_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-006-meridian-water/09_litigation/071_litigation_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-006-meridian-water/09_litigation/072_litigation_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-006-meridian-water/10_real_property/073_real_property_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-006-meridian-water/10_real_property/074_real_property_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-006-meridian-water/10_real_property/075_real_property_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-006-meridian-water/10_real_property/076_real_property_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-006-meridian-water/10_real_property/077_real_property_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-006-meridian-water/10_real_property/078_real_property_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-006-meridian-water/10_real_property/079_real_property_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-006-meridian-water/10_real_property/080_real_property_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-006-meridian-water/11_tax_insurance/081_tax_insurance_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-006-meridian-water/11_tax_insurance/082_tax_insurance_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-006-meridian-water/11_tax_insurance/083_tax_insurance_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-006-meridian-water/11_tax_insurance/084_tax_insurance_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-006-meridian-water/11_tax_insurance/085_tax_insurance_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-006-meridian-water/11_tax_insurance/086_tax_insurance_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-006-meridian-water/11_tax_insurance/087_tax_insurance_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-006-meridian-water/11_tax_insurance/088_tax_insurance_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-006-meridian-water/12_financials/089_financials_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-006-meridian-water/12_financials/090_financials_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-006-meridian-water/12_financials/091_financials_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-006-meridian-water/12_financials/092_financials_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-006-meridian-water/12_financials/093_financials_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-006-meridian-water/12_financials/094_financials_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-006-meridian-water/12_financials/095_financials_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-006-meridian-water/12_financials/096_financials_status_report.md"], "gold_output": {"advice_markdown": "# Counsel advice — Project Spillway treatment business acquisition\n\n## Executive assessment\n\nFor Meridian Water Infrastructure matter CB-MA-2406, the review identified 16 source-supported exceptions requiring action before 2026-09-22. The assessment concerns Spillway Process Controls, LLC and the supplied record for Texas.\n\n## Method and record coverage\n\nThe review inventoried all 96 production files, read the 33 controlling, corroborating, and control records, searched the email exports, and checked metadata for the designated chain-of-custody sample. Conclusions are limited to the synthetic production supplied for this benchmark matter.\n\n## Findings\n\n### F-01 — charter authorization mismatch (critical)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for charter authorization mismatch: one source states the operative date is 2026-01-10 under control reference CB-MA-2406-A532, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2026-01-23 under response reference CB-MA-2406-J133.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/01_corporate/001_corporate_control_register.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/07_privacy_security/049_privacy_security_control_register.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-22, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Amara Patel.\n\n### F-02 — unrecorded option grant (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for unrecorded option grant: one source states the controlling amount is $4,689,139.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $4,794,778.00.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/01_corporate/004_corporate_ledger_export.csv`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/07_privacy_security/052_privacy_security_ledger_export.csv`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-22, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Henry Cho.\n\n### F-03 — change-of-control consent (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for change-of-control consent: one source states approval is attributed to Isaac Romero as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Dominic Alvarez and contains no entry for Isaac Romero.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/01_corporate/007_corporate_officer_certificate.html`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/07_privacy_security/055_privacy_security_officer_certificate.html`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-22, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Nadine Flores.\n\n### F-04 — anti-assignment restriction (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for anti-assignment restriction: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-MA-2406-D567, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-MA-2406-M205.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/02_capitalization/010_capitalization_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/08_regulatory/058_regulatory_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-22, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Micah Sullivan.\n\n### F-05 — most-favored-customer exposure (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for most-favored-customer exposure: one source states the applicable location is Harris County, Texas, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to Texas operations outside Harris County, Texas.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/02_capitalization/013_capitalization_review_memorandum.json`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/08_regulatory/061_regulatory_review_memorandum.json`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-22, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Farah Ibrahim.\n\n### F-06 — financial covenant breach (low)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for financial covenant breach: one source states the threshold is 15% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 22% and produced a different exception result.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/02_capitalization/016_capitalization_status_report.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/08_regulatory/064_regulatory_status_report.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-22, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Owen Delgado.\n\n### F-07 — key-person retention gap (critical)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for key-person retention gap: one source states formal notice must use notices-meridian_water_infrastructure@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-spillway_process_controls_llc@example.test.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/019_material_contracts_correspondence.eml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/09_litigation/067_litigation_correspondence.eml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-22, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Lena Varga.\n\n### F-08 — invention assignment defect (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for invention assignment defect: one source states the governed population contains 69 records through 2025-01-24, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 54 records through 2025-02-19.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/022_material_contracts_formal_notice.xml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/09_litigation/070_litigation_formal_notice.xml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-22, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Samuel Kim.\n\n### F-09 — open-source copyleft exposure (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for open-source copyleft exposure: one source states the operative date is 2025-05-03 under control reference CB-MA-2406-I760, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2025-05-10 under response reference CB-MA-2406-R566.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/04_debt_security/025_debt_security_control_register.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/10_real_property/073_real_property_control_register.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-22, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Maya Ellison.\n\n### F-10 — unreported security incident (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for unreported security incident: one source states the controlling amount is $3,598,392.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $3,793,284.00.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/04_debt_security/028_debt_security_ledger_export.csv`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/10_real_property/076_real_property_ledger_export.csv`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-22, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Rafael Okafor.\n\n### F-11 — permit transfer restriction (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for permit transfer restriction: one source states approval is attributed to Isaac Romero as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Micah Sullivan and contains no entry for Isaac Romero.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/04_debt_security/031_debt_security_officer_certificate.html`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/10_real_property/079_real_property_officer_certificate.html`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-22, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Nora Chen.\n\n### F-12 — threatened customer dispute (low)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for threatened customer dispute: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-MA-2406-L341, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-MA-2406-U257.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/05_employment/034_employment_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/11_tax_insurance/082_tax_insurance_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-22, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Dominic Alvarez.\n\n### F-13 — facility title exception (critical)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for facility title exception: one source states the applicable location is Harris County, Texas, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to Texas operations outside Harris County, Texas.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/05_employment/037_employment_review_memorandum.json`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/11_tax_insurance/085_tax_insurance_review_memorandum.json`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-22, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Priya Raman.\n\n### F-14 — sales-tax nexus gap (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for sales-tax nexus gap: one source states the threshold is 4% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 10% and produced a different exception result.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/05_employment/040_employment_status_report.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/11_tax_insurance/088_tax_insurance_status_report.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-22, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Elliot Mercer.\n\n### F-15 — claims-made insurance tail (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for claims-made insurance tail: one source states formal notice must use notices-meridian_water_infrastructure@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-spillway_process_controls_llc@example.test.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/043_ip_technology_correspondence.eml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/12_financials/091_financials_correspondence.eml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-22, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Talia Brooks.\n\n### F-16 — revenue recognition exception (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for revenue recognition exception: one source states the governed population contains 124 records through 2025-12-25, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 41 records through 2026-01-07.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/046_ip_technology_formal_notice.xml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/12_financials/094_financials_formal_notice.xml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-22, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Jonas Feld.\n\n## Recommended next actions\n\nSequence the critical and high findings first, assign the named owners, preserve the cited records, and document any resolution in the controlling matter register before the stated deadline.\n\n## Assumptions and limitations\n\nThis analysis is confined to task cb100-006-meridian-water and the supplied synthetic evidence. It does not rely on external facts, does not resolve disputed law, and is not legal advice for a real person or entity.\n", "findings": {"as_of": "2026-09-22", "findings": [{"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/07_privacy_security/049_privacy_security_control_register.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for charter authorization mismatch: one source states the operative date is 2026-01-10 under control reference CB-MA-2406-A532, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2026-01-23 under response reference CB-MA-2406-J133.", "id": "F-01", "issue": "charter authorization mismatch", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/01_corporate/001_corporate_control_register.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-22, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Amara Patel.", "severity": "critical"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/07_privacy_security/052_privacy_security_ledger_export.csv", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for unrecorded option grant: one source states the controlling amount is $4,689,139.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $4,794,778.00.", "id": "F-02", "issue": "unrecorded option grant", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/01_corporate/004_corporate_ledger_export.csv", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-22, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Henry Cho.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/07_privacy_security/055_privacy_security_officer_certificate.html", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for change-of-control consent: one source states approval is attributed to Isaac Romero as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Dominic Alvarez and contains no entry for Isaac Romero.", "id": "F-03", "issue": "change-of-control consent", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/01_corporate/007_corporate_officer_certificate.html", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-22, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Nadine Flores.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/08_regulatory/058_regulatory_executed_instrument.txt", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for anti-assignment restriction: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-MA-2406-D567, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-MA-2406-M205.", "id": "F-04", "issue": "anti-assignment restriction", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/02_capitalization/010_capitalization_executed_instrument.txt", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-22, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Micah Sullivan.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/08_regulatory/061_regulatory_review_memorandum.json", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for most-favored-customer exposure: one source states the applicable location is Harris County, Texas, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to Texas operations outside Harris County, Texas.", "id": "F-05", "issue": "most-favored-customer exposure", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/02_capitalization/013_capitalization_review_memorandum.json", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-22, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Farah Ibrahim.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/08_regulatory/064_regulatory_status_report.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for financial covenant breach: one source states the threshold is 15% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 22% and produced a different exception result.", "id": "F-06", "issue": "financial covenant breach", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/02_capitalization/016_capitalization_status_report.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-22, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Owen Delgado.", "severity": "low"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/09_litigation/067_litigation_correspondence.eml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for key-person retention gap: one source states formal notice must use notices-meridian_water_infrastructure@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-spillway_process_controls_llc@example.test.", "id": "F-07", "issue": "key-person retention gap", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/019_material_contracts_correspondence.eml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-22, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Lena Varga.", "severity": "critical"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/09_litigation/070_litigation_formal_notice.xml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for invention assignment defect: one source states the governed population contains 69 records through 2025-01-24, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 54 records through 2025-02-19.", "id": "F-08", "issue": "invention assignment defect", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/022_material_contracts_formal_notice.xml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-22, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Samuel Kim.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/10_real_property/073_real_property_control_register.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for open-source copyleft exposure: one source states the operative date is 2025-05-03 under control reference CB-MA-2406-I760, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2025-05-10 under response reference CB-MA-2406-R566.", "id": "F-09", "issue": "open-source copyleft exposure", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/04_debt_security/025_debt_security_control_register.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-22, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Maya Ellison.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/10_real_property/076_real_property_ledger_export.csv", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for unreported security incident: one source states the controlling amount is $3,598,392.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $3,793,284.00.", "id": "F-10", "issue": "unreported security incident", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/04_debt_security/028_debt_security_ledger_export.csv", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-22, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Rafael Okafor.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/10_real_property/079_real_property_officer_certificate.html", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for permit transfer restriction: one source states approval is attributed to Isaac Romero as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Micah Sullivan and contains no entry for Isaac Romero.", "id": "F-11", "issue": "permit transfer restriction", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/04_debt_security/031_debt_security_officer_certificate.html", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-22, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Nora Chen.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/11_tax_insurance/082_tax_insurance_executed_instrument.txt", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for threatened customer dispute: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-MA-2406-L341, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-MA-2406-U257.", "id": "F-12", "issue": "threatened customer dispute", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/05_employment/034_employment_executed_instrument.txt", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-22, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Dominic Alvarez.", "severity": "low"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/11_tax_insurance/085_tax_insurance_review_memorandum.json", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for facility title exception: one source states the applicable location is Harris County, Texas, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to Texas operations outside Harris County, Texas.", "id": "F-13", "issue": "facility title exception", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/05_employment/037_employment_review_memorandum.json", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-22, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Priya Raman.", "severity": "critical"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/11_tax_insurance/088_tax_insurance_status_report.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for sales-tax nexus gap: one source states the threshold is 4% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 10% and produced a different exception result.", "id": "F-14", "issue": "sales-tax nexus gap", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/05_employment/040_employment_status_report.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-22, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Elliot Mercer.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/12_financials/091_financials_correspondence.eml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for claims-made insurance tail: one source states formal notice must use notices-meridian_water_infrastructure@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-spillway_process_controls_llc@example.test.", "id": "F-15", "issue": "claims-made insurance tail", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/043_ip_technology_correspondence.eml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-22, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Talia Brooks.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/12_financials/094_financials_formal_notice.xml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for revenue recognition exception: one source states the governed population contains 124 records through 2025-12-25, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 41 records through 2026-01-07.", "id": "F-16", "issue": "revenue recognition exception", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/046_ip_technology_formal_notice.xml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-22, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Jonas Feld.", "severity": "medium"}], "matter_number": "CB-MA-2406", "prepared_for": "Meridian Water Infrastructure", "schema_version": "1.0", "task_id": "cb100-006-meridian-water"}}, "metadata": {"benchmark": "CounselBench-100", "code_license": "Apache-2.0", "data_license": "CC-BY-4.0", "deadline": "2026-09-22", "document_count": 96, "jurisdiction": "Texas", "matter_number": "CB-MA-2406", "mcp_commit": "9a96ea6e5913736f92b88345bf51caeaaa8e719f", "mcp_package": "@modelcontextprotocol/server-filesystem@2026.7.10", "practice_area": "corporate-ma", "reference_tool_calls": 46, "required_evidence_reads": 33, "synthetic": true, "venue": "Harris County, Texas", "version": "2.0.0"}, "prompt": "You are buyer-side transactions counsel for Meridian Water Infrastructure. The upcoming deadline leaves no room for unsupported assumptions, so every conclusion must trace to the supplied production. A process-controls business has municipal framework contracts, source-code escrow obligations, and a legacy explosion claim excluded from current insurance. Decision due 2026-09-22. Texas law governs; Harris County, Texas is the forum. Give controlling documents precedence only when the record supports that hierarchy. Work out the defensible position from the matter production and leave an audit-ready exception tracker and concise advice for the supervising lawyer. Keep confirmed conflicts separate from open questions, cite the records that actually control each conclusion, and do not fill gaps with outside facts.", "rubric": {"criteria": [{"category": "procedure", "description": "Complete at least 46 successful, argument-specific evidence and output calls.", "id": "procedure.minimum_successful_tool_calls"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Find and read the 33 controlling, corroborating, and work-product-control records in full.", "id": "procedure.all_evidence_read_in_full"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Inspect file metadata for the eight designated critical primary records before relying on them.", "id": "procedure.chain_of_custody_metadata_checked"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Confirm the sandbox's allowed document and output roots.", "id": "procedure.allowed_directories_checked"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Inventory all 96 records so the relevant sources are discovered among the context records.", "id": "procedure.recursive_inventory_completed"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Search the production for email evidence that may corroborate or contradict formal records.", "id": "procedure.targeted_search_completed"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Leave only findings.json and advice.md in the output workspace.", "id": "procedure.exact_deliverable_set"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Create both final work products through the sandbox MCP surface.", "id": "procedure.deliverables_written_through_mcp"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Produce findings.json as a valid JSON object.", "id": "findings.findings_is_object"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Report exactly 16 confirmed exceptions.", "id": "findings.findings_exact_count"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Use each stable finding ID exactly once.", "id": "findings.finding_ids_unique"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set schema_version to the released matter value '1.0'.", "id": "findings.top_level_schema_version"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set task_id to the released matter value 'cb100-006-meridian-water'.", "id": "findings.top_level_task_id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set matter_number to the released matter value 'CB-MA-2406'.", "id": "findings.top_level_matter_number"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set prepared_for to the released matter value 'Meridian Water Infrastructure'.", "id": "findings.top_level_prepared_for"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set as_of to the released matter value '2026-09-22'.", "id": "findings.top_level_as_of"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-01 exception for charter authorization mismatch.", "id": "findings.F-01.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's id from /workspace/documents/01_corporate/001_corporate_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_privacy_security/049_privacy_security_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's issue from /workspace/documents/01_corporate/001_corporate_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_privacy_security/049_privacy_security_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's severity from /workspace/documents/01_corporate/001_corporate_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_privacy_security/049_privacy_security_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's primary_source from /workspace/documents/01_corporate/001_corporate_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_privacy_security/049_privacy_security_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/01_corporate/001_corporate_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_privacy_security/049_privacy_security_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-01 using the exact controlled facts ['2026-01-10', 'CB-MA-2406-A532', '2026-01-23', 'CB-MA-2406-J133'].", "id": "findings.F-01.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-01's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-01.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-22', 'Amara Patel'] for F-01.", "id": "findings.F-01.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-02 exception for unrecorded option grant.", "id": "findings.F-02.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's id from /workspace/documents/01_corporate/004_corporate_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_privacy_security/052_privacy_security_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's issue from /workspace/documents/01_corporate/004_corporate_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_privacy_security/052_privacy_security_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's severity from /workspace/documents/01_corporate/004_corporate_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_privacy_security/052_privacy_security_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's primary_source from /workspace/documents/01_corporate/004_corporate_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_privacy_security/052_privacy_security_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/01_corporate/004_corporate_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_privacy_security/052_privacy_security_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-02 using the exact controlled facts ['$4,689,139.00', '$4,794,778.00'].", "id": "findings.F-02.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-02's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-02.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-22', 'Henry Cho'] for F-02.", "id": "findings.F-02.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-03 exception for change-of-control consent.", "id": "findings.F-03.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's id from /workspace/documents/01_corporate/007_corporate_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_privacy_security/055_privacy_security_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's issue from /workspace/documents/01_corporate/007_corporate_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_privacy_security/055_privacy_security_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's severity from /workspace/documents/01_corporate/007_corporate_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_privacy_security/055_privacy_security_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's primary_source from /workspace/documents/01_corporate/007_corporate_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_privacy_security/055_privacy_security_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/01_corporate/007_corporate_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_privacy_security/055_privacy_security_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-03 using the exact controlled facts ['Isaac Romero', 'Dominic Alvarez'].", "id": "findings.F-03.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-03's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-03.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-22', 'Nadine Flores'] for F-03.", "id": "findings.F-03.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-04 exception for anti-assignment restriction.", "id": "findings.F-04.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's id from /workspace/documents/02_capitalization/010_capitalization_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_regulatory/058_regulatory_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's issue from /workspace/documents/02_capitalization/010_capitalization_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_regulatory/058_regulatory_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's severity from /workspace/documents/02_capitalization/010_capitalization_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_regulatory/058_regulatory_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's primary_source from /workspace/documents/02_capitalization/010_capitalization_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_regulatory/058_regulatory_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/02_capitalization/010_capitalization_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_regulatory/058_regulatory_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-04 using the exact controlled facts ['closed without exception', 'CB-MA-2406-D567', 'open and escalated', 'CB-MA-2406-M205'].", "id": "findings.F-04.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-04's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-04.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-22', 'Micah Sullivan'] for F-04.", "id": "findings.F-04.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-05 exception for most-favored-customer exposure.", "id": "findings.F-05.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's id from /workspace/documents/02_capitalization/013_capitalization_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_regulatory/061_regulatory_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's issue from /workspace/documents/02_capitalization/013_capitalization_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_regulatory/061_regulatory_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's severity from /workspace/documents/02_capitalization/013_capitalization_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_regulatory/061_regulatory_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's primary_source from /workspace/documents/02_capitalization/013_capitalization_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_regulatory/061_regulatory_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/02_capitalization/013_capitalization_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_regulatory/061_regulatory_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-05 using the exact controlled facts ['Harris County, Texas', 'Texas'].", "id": "findings.F-05.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-05's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-05.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-22', 'Farah Ibrahim'] for F-05.", "id": "findings.F-05.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-06 exception for financial covenant breach.", "id": "findings.F-06.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's id from /workspace/documents/02_capitalization/016_capitalization_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_regulatory/064_regulatory_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's issue from /workspace/documents/02_capitalization/016_capitalization_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_regulatory/064_regulatory_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's severity from /workspace/documents/02_capitalization/016_capitalization_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_regulatory/064_regulatory_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's primary_source from /workspace/documents/02_capitalization/016_capitalization_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_regulatory/064_regulatory_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/02_capitalization/016_capitalization_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_regulatory/064_regulatory_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-06 using the exact controlled facts ['15%', '22%'].", "id": "findings.F-06.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-06's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-06.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-22', 'Owen Delgado'] for F-06.", "id": "findings.F-06.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-07 exception for key-person retention gap.", "id": "findings.F-07.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's id from /workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/019_material_contracts_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_litigation/067_litigation_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's issue from /workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/019_material_contracts_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_litigation/067_litigation_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's severity from /workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/019_material_contracts_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_litigation/067_litigation_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's primary_source from /workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/019_material_contracts_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_litigation/067_litigation_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/019_material_contracts_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_litigation/067_litigation_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-07 using the exact controlled facts ['notices-meridian_water_infrastructure@example.test', 'archive-spillway_process_controls_llc@example.test'].", "id": "findings.F-07.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-07's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-07.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-22', 'Lena Varga'] for F-07.", "id": "findings.F-07.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-08 exception for invention assignment defect.", "id": "findings.F-08.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's id from /workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/022_material_contracts_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_litigation/070_litigation_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's issue from /workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/022_material_contracts_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_litigation/070_litigation_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's severity from /workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/022_material_contracts_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_litigation/070_litigation_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's primary_source from /workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/022_material_contracts_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_litigation/070_litigation_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/022_material_contracts_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_litigation/070_litigation_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-08 using the exact controlled facts ['69 records', '2025-01-24', '54 records', '2025-02-19'].", "id": "findings.F-08.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-08's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-08.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-22', 'Samuel Kim'] for F-08.", "id": "findings.F-08.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-09 exception for open-source copyleft exposure.", "id": "findings.F-09.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's id from /workspace/documents/04_debt_security/025_debt_security_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_real_property/073_real_property_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's issue from /workspace/documents/04_debt_security/025_debt_security_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_real_property/073_real_property_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's severity from /workspace/documents/04_debt_security/025_debt_security_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_real_property/073_real_property_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's primary_source from /workspace/documents/04_debt_security/025_debt_security_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_real_property/073_real_property_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/04_debt_security/025_debt_security_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_real_property/073_real_property_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-09 using the exact controlled facts ['2025-05-03', 'CB-MA-2406-I760', '2025-05-10', 'CB-MA-2406-R566'].", "id": "findings.F-09.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-09's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-09.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-22', 'Maya Ellison'] for F-09.", "id": "findings.F-09.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-10 exception for unreported security incident.", "id": "findings.F-10.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's id from /workspace/documents/04_debt_security/028_debt_security_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_real_property/076_real_property_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's issue from /workspace/documents/04_debt_security/028_debt_security_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_real_property/076_real_property_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's severity from /workspace/documents/04_debt_security/028_debt_security_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_real_property/076_real_property_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's primary_source from /workspace/documents/04_debt_security/028_debt_security_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_real_property/076_real_property_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/04_debt_security/028_debt_security_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_real_property/076_real_property_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-10 using the exact controlled facts ['$3,598,392.00', '$3,793,284.00'].", "id": "findings.F-10.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-10's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-10.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-22', 'Rafael Okafor'] for F-10.", "id": "findings.F-10.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-11 exception for permit transfer restriction.", "id": "findings.F-11.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's id from /workspace/documents/04_debt_security/031_debt_security_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_real_property/079_real_property_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's issue from /workspace/documents/04_debt_security/031_debt_security_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_real_property/079_real_property_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's severity from /workspace/documents/04_debt_security/031_debt_security_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_real_property/079_real_property_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's primary_source from /workspace/documents/04_debt_security/031_debt_security_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_real_property/079_real_property_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/04_debt_security/031_debt_security_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_real_property/079_real_property_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-11 using the exact controlled facts ['Isaac Romero', 'Micah Sullivan'].", "id": "findings.F-11.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-11's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-11.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-22', 'Nora Chen'] for F-11.", "id": "findings.F-11.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-12 exception for threatened customer dispute.", "id": "findings.F-12.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's id from /workspace/documents/05_employment/034_employment_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_tax_insurance/082_tax_insurance_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's issue from /workspace/documents/05_employment/034_employment_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_tax_insurance/082_tax_insurance_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's severity from /workspace/documents/05_employment/034_employment_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_tax_insurance/082_tax_insurance_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's primary_source from /workspace/documents/05_employment/034_employment_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_tax_insurance/082_tax_insurance_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/05_employment/034_employment_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_tax_insurance/082_tax_insurance_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-12 using the exact controlled facts ['closed without exception', 'CB-MA-2406-L341', 'open and escalated', 'CB-MA-2406-U257'].", "id": "findings.F-12.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-12's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-12.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-22', 'Dominic Alvarez'] for F-12.", "id": "findings.F-12.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-13 exception for facility title exception.", "id": "findings.F-13.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's id from /workspace/documents/05_employment/037_employment_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_tax_insurance/085_tax_insurance_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's issue from /workspace/documents/05_employment/037_employment_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_tax_insurance/085_tax_insurance_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's severity from /workspace/documents/05_employment/037_employment_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_tax_insurance/085_tax_insurance_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's primary_source from /workspace/documents/05_employment/037_employment_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_tax_insurance/085_tax_insurance_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/05_employment/037_employment_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_tax_insurance/085_tax_insurance_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-13 using the exact controlled facts ['Harris County, Texas', 'Texas'].", "id": "findings.F-13.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-13's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-13.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-22', 'Priya Raman'] for F-13.", "id": "findings.F-13.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-14 exception for sales-tax nexus gap.", "id": "findings.F-14.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's id from /workspace/documents/05_employment/040_employment_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_tax_insurance/088_tax_insurance_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's issue from /workspace/documents/05_employment/040_employment_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_tax_insurance/088_tax_insurance_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's severity from /workspace/documents/05_employment/040_employment_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_tax_insurance/088_tax_insurance_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's primary_source from /workspace/documents/05_employment/040_employment_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_tax_insurance/088_tax_insurance_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/05_employment/040_employment_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_tax_insurance/088_tax_insurance_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-14 using the exact controlled facts ['4%', '10%'].", "id": "findings.F-14.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-14's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-14.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-22', 'Elliot Mercer'] for F-14.", "id": "findings.F-14.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-15 exception for claims-made insurance tail.", "id": "findings.F-15.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's id from /workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/043_ip_technology_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_financials/091_financials_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's issue from /workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/043_ip_technology_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_financials/091_financials_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's severity from /workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/043_ip_technology_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_financials/091_financials_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's primary_source from /workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/043_ip_technology_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_financials/091_financials_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/043_ip_technology_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_financials/091_financials_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-15 using the exact controlled facts ['notices-meridian_water_infrastructure@example.test', 'archive-spillway_process_controls_llc@example.test'].", "id": "findings.F-15.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-15's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-15.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-22', 'Talia Brooks'] for F-15.", "id": "findings.F-15.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-16 exception for revenue recognition exception.", "id": "findings.F-16.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's id from /workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/046_ip_technology_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_financials/094_financials_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's issue from /workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/046_ip_technology_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_financials/094_financials_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's severity from /workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/046_ip_technology_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_financials/094_financials_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's primary_source from /workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/046_ip_technology_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_financials/094_financials_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/046_ip_technology_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_financials/094_financials_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-16 using the exact controlled facts ['124 records', '2025-12-25', '41 records', '2026-01-07'].", "id": "findings.F-16.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-16's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-16.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-22', 'Jonas Feld'] for F-16.", "id": "findings.F-16.action_anchors"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Executive assessment' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Executive assessment"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Method and record coverage' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Method and record coverage"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Findings' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Findings"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Recommended next actions' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Recommended next actions"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Assumptions and limitations' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Assumptions and limitations"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-01 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-01"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-02 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-02"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-03 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-03"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-04 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-04"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-05 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-05"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-06 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-06"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-07 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-07"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-08 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-08"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-09 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-09"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-10 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-10"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-11 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-11"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-12 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-12"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-13 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-13"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-14 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-14"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-15 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-15"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-16 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-16"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Do not claim the production has no issues or that every record is consistent.", "id": "memo.forbidden_claims_absent"}], "decision_options": [{"id": "cross-source-reconciliation", "label": "Reconcile controlling and corroborating records", "reason": "The CB-MA-2406 production contains independently maintained records; a defensible answer must preserve each supported conflict and its cure owner.", "selected": true}, {"id": "latest-record-controls", "label": "Treat the latest record as controlling", "reason": "Timestamp recency does not establish legal priority, execution, or approval authority.", "selected": false}, {"id": "primary-records-only", "label": "Report primary records without reconciliation", "reason": "Primary records alone conceal the operational conflicts that create the actionable exceptions.", "selected": false}], "gates": ["all_evidence_read_in_full", "chain_of_custody_metadata_checked", "findings_criteria_complete", "memo_criteria_complete", "deliverables_written_through_mcp"], "metadata_checks": 8, "metric": "weighted_criteria_score", "minimum_tool_calls": 46, "required_deliverables": ["findings.json", "advice.md"], "required_document_reads": 33, "type": "deterministic", "weights": {"findings": 0.55, "memo": 0.2, "procedure": 0.25}}, "task_id": "cb100-006-meridian-water", "task_name": "Project Spillway treatment business acquisition", "world_id": "counselbench-filesystem-mcp-v2"}
-{"context_files": ["task_files/cb100-007-bracken-home/01_corporate/001_corporate_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-007-bracken-home/01_corporate/002_corporate_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-007-bracken-home/01_corporate/003_corporate_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-007-bracken-home/01_corporate/004_corporate_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-007-bracken-home/01_corporate/005_corporate_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-007-bracken-home/01_corporate/006_corporate_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-007-bracken-home/01_corporate/007_corporate_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-007-bracken-home/01_corporate/008_corporate_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-007-bracken-home/02_capitalization/009_capitalization_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-007-bracken-home/02_capitalization/010_capitalization_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-007-bracken-home/02_capitalization/011_capitalization_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-007-bracken-home/02_capitalization/012_capitalization_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-007-bracken-home/02_capitalization/013_capitalization_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-007-bracken-home/02_capitalization/014_capitalization_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-007-bracken-home/02_capitalization/015_capitalization_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-007-bracken-home/02_capitalization/016_capitalization_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-007-bracken-home/03_material_contracts/017_material_contracts_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-007-bracken-home/03_material_contracts/018_material_contracts_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-007-bracken-home/03_material_contracts/019_material_contracts_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-007-bracken-home/03_material_contracts/020_material_contracts_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-007-bracken-home/03_material_contracts/021_material_contracts_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-007-bracken-home/03_material_contracts/022_material_contracts_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-007-bracken-home/03_material_contracts/023_material_contracts_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-007-bracken-home/03_material_contracts/024_material_contracts_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-007-bracken-home/04_debt_security/025_debt_security_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-007-bracken-home/04_debt_security/026_debt_security_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-007-bracken-home/04_debt_security/027_debt_security_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-007-bracken-home/04_debt_security/028_debt_security_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-007-bracken-home/04_debt_security/029_debt_security_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-007-bracken-home/04_debt_security/030_debt_security_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-007-bracken-home/04_debt_security/031_debt_security_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-007-bracken-home/04_debt_security/032_debt_security_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-007-bracken-home/05_employment/033_employment_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-007-bracken-home/05_employment/034_employment_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-007-bracken-home/05_employment/035_employment_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-007-bracken-home/05_employment/036_employment_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-007-bracken-home/05_employment/037_employment_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-007-bracken-home/05_employment/038_employment_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-007-bracken-home/05_employment/039_employment_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-007-bracken-home/05_employment/040_employment_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-007-bracken-home/06_ip_technology/041_ip_technology_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-007-bracken-home/06_ip_technology/042_ip_technology_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-007-bracken-home/06_ip_technology/043_ip_technology_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-007-bracken-home/06_ip_technology/044_ip_technology_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-007-bracken-home/06_ip_technology/045_ip_technology_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-007-bracken-home/06_ip_technology/046_ip_technology_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-007-bracken-home/06_ip_technology/047_ip_technology_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-007-bracken-home/06_ip_technology/048_ip_technology_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-007-bracken-home/07_privacy_security/049_privacy_security_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-007-bracken-home/07_privacy_security/050_privacy_security_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-007-bracken-home/07_privacy_security/051_privacy_security_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-007-bracken-home/07_privacy_security/052_privacy_security_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-007-bracken-home/07_privacy_security/053_privacy_security_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-007-bracken-home/07_privacy_security/054_privacy_security_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-007-bracken-home/07_privacy_security/055_privacy_security_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-007-bracken-home/07_privacy_security/056_privacy_security_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-007-bracken-home/08_regulatory/057_regulatory_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-007-bracken-home/08_regulatory/058_regulatory_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-007-bracken-home/08_regulatory/059_regulatory_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-007-bracken-home/08_regulatory/060_regulatory_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-007-bracken-home/08_regulatory/061_regulatory_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-007-bracken-home/08_regulatory/062_regulatory_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-007-bracken-home/08_regulatory/063_regulatory_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-007-bracken-home/08_regulatory/064_regulatory_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-007-bracken-home/09_litigation/065_litigation_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-007-bracken-home/09_litigation/066_litigation_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-007-bracken-home/09_litigation/067_litigation_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-007-bracken-home/09_litigation/068_litigation_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-007-bracken-home/09_litigation/069_litigation_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-007-bracken-home/09_litigation/070_litigation_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-007-bracken-home/09_litigation/071_litigation_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-007-bracken-home/09_litigation/072_litigation_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-007-bracken-home/10_real_property/073_real_property_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-007-bracken-home/10_real_property/074_real_property_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-007-bracken-home/10_real_property/075_real_property_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-007-bracken-home/10_real_property/076_real_property_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-007-bracken-home/10_real_property/077_real_property_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-007-bracken-home/10_real_property/078_real_property_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-007-bracken-home/10_real_property/079_real_property_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-007-bracken-home/10_real_property/080_real_property_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-007-bracken-home/11_tax_insurance/081_tax_insurance_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-007-bracken-home/11_tax_insurance/082_tax_insurance_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-007-bracken-home/11_tax_insurance/083_tax_insurance_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-007-bracken-home/11_tax_insurance/084_tax_insurance_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-007-bracken-home/11_tax_insurance/085_tax_insurance_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-007-bracken-home/11_tax_insurance/086_tax_insurance_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-007-bracken-home/11_tax_insurance/087_tax_insurance_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-007-bracken-home/11_tax_insurance/088_tax_insurance_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-007-bracken-home/12_financials/089_financials_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-007-bracken-home/12_financials/090_financials_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-007-bracken-home/12_financials/091_financials_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-007-bracken-home/12_financials/092_financials_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-007-bracken-home/12_financials/093_financials_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-007-bracken-home/12_financials/094_financials_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-007-bracken-home/12_financials/095_financials_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-007-bracken-home/12_financials/096_financials_status_report.md"], "gold_output": {"advice_markdown": "# Counsel advice — Project Hearth consumer products merger\n\n## Executive assessment\n\nFor Bracken Home Brands matter CB-MA-2407, the review identified 16 source-supported exceptions requiring action before 2026-09-25. The assessment concerns Hearth & Reed Appliances Corp. and the supplied record for Ohio.\n\n## Method and record coverage\n\nThe review inventoried all 96 production files, read the 33 controlling, corroborating, and control records, searched the email exports, and checked metadata for the designated chain-of-custody sample. Conclusions are limited to the synthetic production supplied for this benchmark matter.\n\n## Findings\n\n### F-01 — charter authorization mismatch (critical)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for charter authorization mismatch: one source states the operative date is 2025-04-20 under control reference CB-MA-2407-A987, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2025-05-24 under response reference CB-MA-2407-J445.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/01_corporate/001_corporate_control_register.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/07_privacy_security/049_privacy_security_control_register.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-25, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Henry Cho.\n\n### F-02 — unrecorded option grant (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for unrecorded option grant: one source states the controlling amount is $6,181,034.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $6,368,568.00.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/01_corporate/004_corporate_ledger_export.csv`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/07_privacy_security/052_privacy_security_ledger_export.csv`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-25, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Nadine Flores.\n\n### F-03 — change-of-control consent (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for change-of-control consent: one source states approval is attributed to Sofia Bennett as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Elliot Mercer and contains no entry for Sofia Bennett.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/01_corporate/007_corporate_officer_certificate.html`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/07_privacy_security/055_privacy_security_officer_certificate.html`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-25, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Micah Sullivan.\n\n### F-04 — anti-assignment restriction (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for anti-assignment restriction: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-MA-2407-D537, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-MA-2407-M895.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/02_capitalization/010_capitalization_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/08_regulatory/058_regulatory_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-25, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Farah Ibrahim.\n\n### F-05 — most-favored-customer exposure (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for most-favored-customer exposure: one source states the applicable location is Franklin County, Ohio, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to Ohio operations outside Franklin County, Ohio.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/02_capitalization/013_capitalization_review_memorandum.json`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/08_regulatory/061_regulatory_review_memorandum.json`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-25, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Owen Delgado.\n\n### F-06 — financial covenant breach (low)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for financial covenant breach: one source states the threshold is 2% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 8% and produced a different exception result.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/02_capitalization/016_capitalization_status_report.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/08_regulatory/064_regulatory_status_report.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-25, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Lena Varga.\n\n### F-07 — key-person retention gap (critical)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for key-person retention gap: one source states formal notice must use notices-bracken_home_brands@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-hearth_reed_appliances_corp@example.test.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/019_material_contracts_correspondence.eml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/09_litigation/067_litigation_correspondence.eml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-25, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Samuel Kim.\n\n### F-08 — invention assignment defect (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for invention assignment defect: one source states the governed population contains 146 records through 2025-04-11, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 45 records through 2025-04-28.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/022_material_contracts_formal_notice.xml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/09_litigation/070_litigation_formal_notice.xml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-25, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Maya Ellison.\n\n### F-09 — open-source copyleft exposure (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for open-source copyleft exposure: one source states the operative date is 2025-08-24 under control reference CB-MA-2407-I213, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2025-09-20 under response reference CB-MA-2407-R108.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/04_debt_security/025_debt_security_control_register.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/10_real_property/073_real_property_control_register.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-25, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Rafael Okafor.\n\n### F-10 — unreported security incident (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for unreported security incident: one source states the controlling amount is $4,189,619.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $4,295,738.00.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/04_debt_security/028_debt_security_ledger_export.csv`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/10_real_property/076_real_property_ledger_export.csv`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-25, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Nora Chen.\n\n### F-11 — permit transfer restriction (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for permit transfer restriction: one source states approval is attributed to Sofia Bennett as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Owen Delgado and contains no entry for Sofia Bennett.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/04_debt_security/031_debt_security_officer_certificate.html`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/10_real_property/079_real_property_officer_certificate.html`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-25, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Dominic Alvarez.\n\n### F-12 — threatened customer dispute (low)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for threatened customer dispute: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-MA-2407-L301, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-MA-2407-U461.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/05_employment/034_employment_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/11_tax_insurance/082_tax_insurance_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-25, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Priya Raman.\n\n### F-13 — facility title exception (critical)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for facility title exception: one source states the applicable location is Franklin County, Ohio, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to Ohio operations outside Franklin County, Ohio.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/05_employment/037_employment_review_memorandum.json`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/11_tax_insurance/085_tax_insurance_review_memorandum.json`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-25, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Elliot Mercer.\n\n### F-14 — sales-tax nexus gap (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for sales-tax nexus gap: one source states the threshold is 2% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 4% and produced a different exception result.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/05_employment/040_employment_status_report.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/11_tax_insurance/088_tax_insurance_status_report.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-25, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Talia Brooks.\n\n### F-15 — claims-made insurance tail (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for claims-made insurance tail: one source states formal notice must use notices-bracken_home_brands@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-hearth_reed_appliances_corp@example.test.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/043_ip_technology_correspondence.eml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/12_financials/091_financials_correspondence.eml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-25, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Jonas Feld.\n\n### F-16 — revenue recognition exception (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for revenue recognition exception: one source states the governed population contains 58 records through 2025-10-20, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 49 records through 2025-11-10.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/046_ip_technology_formal_notice.xml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/12_financials/094_financials_formal_notice.xml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-25, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Mei Whitaker.\n\n## Recommended next actions\n\nSequence the critical and high findings first, assign the named owners, preserve the cited records, and document any resolution in the controlling matter register before the stated deadline.\n\n## Assumptions and limitations\n\nThis analysis is confined to task cb100-007-bracken-home and the supplied synthetic evidence. It does not rely on external facts, does not resolve disputed law, and is not legal advice for a real person or entity.\n", "findings": {"as_of": "2026-09-25", "findings": [{"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/07_privacy_security/049_privacy_security_control_register.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for charter authorization mismatch: one source states the operative date is 2025-04-20 under control reference CB-MA-2407-A987, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2025-05-24 under response reference CB-MA-2407-J445.", "id": "F-01", "issue": "charter authorization mismatch", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/01_corporate/001_corporate_control_register.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-25, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Henry Cho.", "severity": "critical"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/07_privacy_security/052_privacy_security_ledger_export.csv", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for unrecorded option grant: one source states the controlling amount is $6,181,034.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $6,368,568.00.", "id": "F-02", "issue": "unrecorded option grant", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/01_corporate/004_corporate_ledger_export.csv", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-25, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Nadine Flores.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/07_privacy_security/055_privacy_security_officer_certificate.html", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for change-of-control consent: one source states approval is attributed to Sofia Bennett as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Elliot Mercer and contains no entry for Sofia Bennett.", "id": "F-03", "issue": "change-of-control consent", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/01_corporate/007_corporate_officer_certificate.html", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-25, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Micah Sullivan.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/08_regulatory/058_regulatory_executed_instrument.txt", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for anti-assignment restriction: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-MA-2407-D537, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-MA-2407-M895.", "id": "F-04", "issue": "anti-assignment restriction", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/02_capitalization/010_capitalization_executed_instrument.txt", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-25, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Farah Ibrahim.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/08_regulatory/061_regulatory_review_memorandum.json", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for most-favored-customer exposure: one source states the applicable location is Franklin County, Ohio, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to Ohio operations outside Franklin County, Ohio.", "id": "F-05", "issue": "most-favored-customer exposure", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/02_capitalization/013_capitalization_review_memorandum.json", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-25, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Owen Delgado.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/08_regulatory/064_regulatory_status_report.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for financial covenant breach: one source states the threshold is 2% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 8% and produced a different exception result.", "id": "F-06", "issue": "financial covenant breach", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/02_capitalization/016_capitalization_status_report.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-25, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Lena Varga.", "severity": "low"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/09_litigation/067_litigation_correspondence.eml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for key-person retention gap: one source states formal notice must use notices-bracken_home_brands@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-hearth_reed_appliances_corp@example.test.", "id": "F-07", "issue": "key-person retention gap", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/019_material_contracts_correspondence.eml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-25, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Samuel Kim.", "severity": "critical"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/09_litigation/070_litigation_formal_notice.xml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for invention assignment defect: one source states the governed population contains 146 records through 2025-04-11, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 45 records through 2025-04-28.", "id": "F-08", "issue": "invention assignment defect", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/022_material_contracts_formal_notice.xml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-25, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Maya Ellison.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/10_real_property/073_real_property_control_register.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for open-source copyleft exposure: one source states the operative date is 2025-08-24 under control reference CB-MA-2407-I213, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2025-09-20 under response reference CB-MA-2407-R108.", "id": "F-09", "issue": "open-source copyleft exposure", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/04_debt_security/025_debt_security_control_register.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-25, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Rafael Okafor.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/10_real_property/076_real_property_ledger_export.csv", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for unreported security incident: one source states the controlling amount is $4,189,619.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $4,295,738.00.", "id": "F-10", "issue": "unreported security incident", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/04_debt_security/028_debt_security_ledger_export.csv", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-25, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Nora Chen.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/10_real_property/079_real_property_officer_certificate.html", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for permit transfer restriction: one source states approval is attributed to Sofia Bennett as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Owen Delgado and contains no entry for Sofia Bennett.", "id": "F-11", "issue": "permit transfer restriction", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/04_debt_security/031_debt_security_officer_certificate.html", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-25, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Dominic Alvarez.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/11_tax_insurance/082_tax_insurance_executed_instrument.txt", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for threatened customer dispute: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-MA-2407-L301, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-MA-2407-U461.", "id": "F-12", "issue": "threatened customer dispute", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/05_employment/034_employment_executed_instrument.txt", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-25, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Priya Raman.", "severity": "low"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/11_tax_insurance/085_tax_insurance_review_memorandum.json", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for facility title exception: one source states the applicable location is Franklin County, Ohio, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to Ohio operations outside Franklin County, Ohio.", "id": "F-13", "issue": "facility title exception", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/05_employment/037_employment_review_memorandum.json", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-25, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Elliot Mercer.", "severity": "critical"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/11_tax_insurance/088_tax_insurance_status_report.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for sales-tax nexus gap: one source states the threshold is 2% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 4% and produced a different exception result.", "id": "F-14", "issue": "sales-tax nexus gap", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/05_employment/040_employment_status_report.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-25, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Talia Brooks.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/12_financials/091_financials_correspondence.eml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for claims-made insurance tail: one source states formal notice must use notices-bracken_home_brands@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-hearth_reed_appliances_corp@example.test.", "id": "F-15", "issue": "claims-made insurance tail", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/043_ip_technology_correspondence.eml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-25, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Jonas Feld.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/12_financials/094_financials_formal_notice.xml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for revenue recognition exception: one source states the governed population contains 58 records through 2025-10-20, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 49 records through 2025-11-10.", "id": "F-16", "issue": "revenue recognition exception", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/046_ip_technology_formal_notice.xml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-25, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Mei Whitaker.", "severity": "medium"}], "matter_number": "CB-MA-2407", "prepared_for": "Bracken Home Brands", "schema_version": "1.0", "task_id": "cb100-007-bracken-home"}}, "metadata": {"benchmark": "CounselBench-100", "code_license": "Apache-2.0", "data_license": "CC-BY-4.0", "deadline": "2026-09-25", "document_count": 96, "jurisdiction": "Ohio", "matter_number": "CB-MA-2407", "mcp_commit": "9a96ea6e5913736f92b88345bf51caeaaa8e719f", "mcp_package": "@modelcontextprotocol/server-filesystem@2026.7.10", "practice_area": "corporate-ma", "reference_tool_calls": 46, "required_evidence_reads": 33, "synthetic": true, "venue": "Franklin County, Ohio", "version": "2.0.0"}, "prompt": "You are buyer-side transactions counsel for Bracken Home Brands. A counterparty challenged the client's internal summary, making cross-document reconciliation and precise citations essential. A connected-appliance company changed component suppliers after a recall, pledged inventory under a revolver, and promised one retailer price parity. Decision due 2026-09-25. Ohio law governs; Franklin County, Ohio is the forum. Flag cross-folder dependencies that would be invisible in a single-document review. Work out the defensible position from the matter production and leave an audit-ready exception tracker and concise advice for the supervising lawyer. Keep confirmed conflicts separate from open questions, cite the records that actually control each conclusion, and do not fill gaps with outside facts.", "rubric": {"criteria": [{"category": "procedure", "description": "Complete at least 46 successful, argument-specific evidence and output calls.", "id": "procedure.minimum_successful_tool_calls"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Find and read the 33 controlling, corroborating, and work-product-control records in full.", "id": "procedure.all_evidence_read_in_full"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Inspect file metadata for the eight designated critical primary records before relying on them.", "id": "procedure.chain_of_custody_metadata_checked"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Confirm the sandbox's allowed document and output roots.", "id": "procedure.allowed_directories_checked"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Inventory all 96 records so the relevant sources are discovered among the context records.", "id": "procedure.recursive_inventory_completed"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Search the production for email evidence that may corroborate or contradict formal records.", "id": "procedure.targeted_search_completed"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Leave only findings.json and advice.md in the output workspace.", "id": "procedure.exact_deliverable_set"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Create both final work products through the sandbox MCP surface.", "id": "procedure.deliverables_written_through_mcp"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Produce findings.json as a valid JSON object.", "id": "findings.findings_is_object"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Report exactly 16 confirmed exceptions.", "id": "findings.findings_exact_count"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Use each stable finding ID exactly once.", "id": "findings.finding_ids_unique"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set schema_version to the released matter value '1.0'.", "id": "findings.top_level_schema_version"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set task_id to the released matter value 'cb100-007-bracken-home'.", "id": "findings.top_level_task_id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set matter_number to the released matter value 'CB-MA-2407'.", "id": "findings.top_level_matter_number"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set prepared_for to the released matter value 'Bracken Home Brands'.", "id": "findings.top_level_prepared_for"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set as_of to the released matter value '2026-09-25'.", "id": "findings.top_level_as_of"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-01 exception for charter authorization mismatch.", "id": "findings.F-01.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's id from /workspace/documents/01_corporate/001_corporate_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_privacy_security/049_privacy_security_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's issue from /workspace/documents/01_corporate/001_corporate_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_privacy_security/049_privacy_security_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's severity from /workspace/documents/01_corporate/001_corporate_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_privacy_security/049_privacy_security_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's primary_source from /workspace/documents/01_corporate/001_corporate_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_privacy_security/049_privacy_security_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/01_corporate/001_corporate_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_privacy_security/049_privacy_security_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-01 using the exact controlled facts ['2025-04-20', 'CB-MA-2407-A987', '2025-05-24', 'CB-MA-2407-J445'].", "id": "findings.F-01.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-01's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-01.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-25', 'Henry Cho'] for F-01.", "id": "findings.F-01.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-02 exception for unrecorded option grant.", "id": "findings.F-02.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's id from /workspace/documents/01_corporate/004_corporate_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_privacy_security/052_privacy_security_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's issue from /workspace/documents/01_corporate/004_corporate_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_privacy_security/052_privacy_security_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's severity from /workspace/documents/01_corporate/004_corporate_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_privacy_security/052_privacy_security_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's primary_source from /workspace/documents/01_corporate/004_corporate_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_privacy_security/052_privacy_security_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/01_corporate/004_corporate_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_privacy_security/052_privacy_security_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-02 using the exact controlled facts ['$6,181,034.00', '$6,368,568.00'].", "id": "findings.F-02.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-02's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-02.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-25', 'Nadine Flores'] for F-02.", "id": "findings.F-02.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-03 exception for change-of-control consent.", "id": "findings.F-03.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's id from /workspace/documents/01_corporate/007_corporate_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_privacy_security/055_privacy_security_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's issue from /workspace/documents/01_corporate/007_corporate_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_privacy_security/055_privacy_security_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's severity from /workspace/documents/01_corporate/007_corporate_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_privacy_security/055_privacy_security_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's primary_source from /workspace/documents/01_corporate/007_corporate_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_privacy_security/055_privacy_security_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/01_corporate/007_corporate_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_privacy_security/055_privacy_security_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-03 using the exact controlled facts ['Sofia Bennett', 'Elliot Mercer'].", "id": "findings.F-03.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-03's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-03.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-25', 'Micah Sullivan'] for F-03.", "id": "findings.F-03.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-04 exception for anti-assignment restriction.", "id": "findings.F-04.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's id from /workspace/documents/02_capitalization/010_capitalization_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_regulatory/058_regulatory_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's issue from /workspace/documents/02_capitalization/010_capitalization_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_regulatory/058_regulatory_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's severity from /workspace/documents/02_capitalization/010_capitalization_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_regulatory/058_regulatory_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's primary_source from /workspace/documents/02_capitalization/010_capitalization_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_regulatory/058_regulatory_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/02_capitalization/010_capitalization_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_regulatory/058_regulatory_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-04 using the exact controlled facts ['closed without exception', 'CB-MA-2407-D537', 'open and escalated', 'CB-MA-2407-M895'].", "id": "findings.F-04.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-04's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-04.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-25', 'Farah Ibrahim'] for F-04.", "id": "findings.F-04.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-05 exception for most-favored-customer exposure.", "id": "findings.F-05.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's id from /workspace/documents/02_capitalization/013_capitalization_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_regulatory/061_regulatory_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's issue from /workspace/documents/02_capitalization/013_capitalization_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_regulatory/061_regulatory_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's severity from /workspace/documents/02_capitalization/013_capitalization_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_regulatory/061_regulatory_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's primary_source from /workspace/documents/02_capitalization/013_capitalization_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_regulatory/061_regulatory_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/02_capitalization/013_capitalization_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_regulatory/061_regulatory_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-05 using the exact controlled facts ['Franklin County, Ohio', 'Ohio'].", "id": "findings.F-05.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-05's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-05.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-25', 'Owen Delgado'] for F-05.", "id": "findings.F-05.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-06 exception for financial covenant breach.", "id": "findings.F-06.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's id from /workspace/documents/02_capitalization/016_capitalization_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_regulatory/064_regulatory_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's issue from /workspace/documents/02_capitalization/016_capitalization_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_regulatory/064_regulatory_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's severity from /workspace/documents/02_capitalization/016_capitalization_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_regulatory/064_regulatory_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's primary_source from /workspace/documents/02_capitalization/016_capitalization_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_regulatory/064_regulatory_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/02_capitalization/016_capitalization_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_regulatory/064_regulatory_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-06 using the exact controlled facts ['2%', '8%'].", "id": "findings.F-06.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-06's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-06.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-25', 'Lena Varga'] for F-06.", "id": "findings.F-06.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-07 exception for key-person retention gap.", "id": "findings.F-07.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's id from /workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/019_material_contracts_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_litigation/067_litigation_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's issue from /workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/019_material_contracts_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_litigation/067_litigation_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's severity from /workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/019_material_contracts_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_litigation/067_litigation_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's primary_source from /workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/019_material_contracts_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_litigation/067_litigation_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/019_material_contracts_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_litigation/067_litigation_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-07 using the exact controlled facts ['notices-bracken_home_brands@example.test', 'archive-hearth_reed_appliances_corp@example.test'].", "id": "findings.F-07.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-07's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-07.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-25', 'Samuel Kim'] for F-07.", "id": "findings.F-07.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-08 exception for invention assignment defect.", "id": "findings.F-08.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's id from /workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/022_material_contracts_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_litigation/070_litigation_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's issue from /workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/022_material_contracts_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_litigation/070_litigation_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's severity from /workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/022_material_contracts_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_litigation/070_litigation_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's primary_source from /workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/022_material_contracts_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_litigation/070_litigation_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/022_material_contracts_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_litigation/070_litigation_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-08 using the exact controlled facts ['146 records', '2025-04-11', '45 records', '2025-04-28'].", "id": "findings.F-08.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-08's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-08.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-25', 'Maya Ellison'] for F-08.", "id": "findings.F-08.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-09 exception for open-source copyleft exposure.", "id": "findings.F-09.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's id from /workspace/documents/04_debt_security/025_debt_security_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_real_property/073_real_property_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's issue from /workspace/documents/04_debt_security/025_debt_security_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_real_property/073_real_property_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's severity from /workspace/documents/04_debt_security/025_debt_security_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_real_property/073_real_property_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's primary_source from /workspace/documents/04_debt_security/025_debt_security_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_real_property/073_real_property_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/04_debt_security/025_debt_security_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_real_property/073_real_property_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-09 using the exact controlled facts ['2025-08-24', 'CB-MA-2407-I213', '2025-09-20', 'CB-MA-2407-R108'].", "id": "findings.F-09.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-09's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-09.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-25', 'Rafael Okafor'] for F-09.", "id": "findings.F-09.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-10 exception for unreported security incident.", "id": "findings.F-10.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's id from /workspace/documents/04_debt_security/028_debt_security_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_real_property/076_real_property_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's issue from /workspace/documents/04_debt_security/028_debt_security_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_real_property/076_real_property_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's severity from /workspace/documents/04_debt_security/028_debt_security_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_real_property/076_real_property_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's primary_source from /workspace/documents/04_debt_security/028_debt_security_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_real_property/076_real_property_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/04_debt_security/028_debt_security_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_real_property/076_real_property_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-10 using the exact controlled facts ['$4,189,619.00', '$4,295,738.00'].", "id": "findings.F-10.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-10's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-10.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-25', 'Nora Chen'] for F-10.", "id": "findings.F-10.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-11 exception for permit transfer restriction.", "id": "findings.F-11.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's id from /workspace/documents/04_debt_security/031_debt_security_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_real_property/079_real_property_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's issue from /workspace/documents/04_debt_security/031_debt_security_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_real_property/079_real_property_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's severity from /workspace/documents/04_debt_security/031_debt_security_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_real_property/079_real_property_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's primary_source from /workspace/documents/04_debt_security/031_debt_security_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_real_property/079_real_property_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/04_debt_security/031_debt_security_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_real_property/079_real_property_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-11 using the exact controlled facts ['Sofia Bennett', 'Owen Delgado'].", "id": "findings.F-11.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-11's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-11.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-25', 'Dominic Alvarez'] for F-11.", "id": "findings.F-11.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-12 exception for threatened customer dispute.", "id": "findings.F-12.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's id from /workspace/documents/05_employment/034_employment_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_tax_insurance/082_tax_insurance_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's issue from /workspace/documents/05_employment/034_employment_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_tax_insurance/082_tax_insurance_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's severity from /workspace/documents/05_employment/034_employment_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_tax_insurance/082_tax_insurance_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's primary_source from /workspace/documents/05_employment/034_employment_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_tax_insurance/082_tax_insurance_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/05_employment/034_employment_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_tax_insurance/082_tax_insurance_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-12 using the exact controlled facts ['closed without exception', 'CB-MA-2407-L301', 'open and escalated', 'CB-MA-2407-U461'].", "id": "findings.F-12.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-12's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-12.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-25', 'Priya Raman'] for F-12.", "id": "findings.F-12.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-13 exception for facility title exception.", "id": "findings.F-13.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's id from /workspace/documents/05_employment/037_employment_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_tax_insurance/085_tax_insurance_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's issue from /workspace/documents/05_employment/037_employment_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_tax_insurance/085_tax_insurance_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's severity from /workspace/documents/05_employment/037_employment_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_tax_insurance/085_tax_insurance_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's primary_source from /workspace/documents/05_employment/037_employment_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_tax_insurance/085_tax_insurance_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/05_employment/037_employment_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_tax_insurance/085_tax_insurance_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-13 using the exact controlled facts ['Franklin County, Ohio', 'Ohio'].", "id": "findings.F-13.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-13's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-13.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-25', 'Elliot Mercer'] for F-13.", "id": "findings.F-13.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-14 exception for sales-tax nexus gap.", "id": "findings.F-14.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's id from /workspace/documents/05_employment/040_employment_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_tax_insurance/088_tax_insurance_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's issue from /workspace/documents/05_employment/040_employment_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_tax_insurance/088_tax_insurance_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's severity from /workspace/documents/05_employment/040_employment_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_tax_insurance/088_tax_insurance_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's primary_source from /workspace/documents/05_employment/040_employment_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_tax_insurance/088_tax_insurance_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/05_employment/040_employment_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_tax_insurance/088_tax_insurance_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-14 using the exact controlled facts ['2%', '4%'].", "id": "findings.F-14.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-14's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-14.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-25', 'Talia Brooks'] for F-14.", "id": "findings.F-14.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-15 exception for claims-made insurance tail.", "id": "findings.F-15.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's id from /workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/043_ip_technology_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_financials/091_financials_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's issue from /workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/043_ip_technology_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_financials/091_financials_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's severity from /workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/043_ip_technology_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_financials/091_financials_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's primary_source from /workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/043_ip_technology_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_financials/091_financials_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/043_ip_technology_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_financials/091_financials_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-15 using the exact controlled facts ['notices-bracken_home_brands@example.test', 'archive-hearth_reed_appliances_corp@example.test'].", "id": "findings.F-15.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-15's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-15.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-25', 'Jonas Feld'] for F-15.", "id": "findings.F-15.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-16 exception for revenue recognition exception.", "id": "findings.F-16.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's id from /workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/046_ip_technology_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_financials/094_financials_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's issue from /workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/046_ip_technology_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_financials/094_financials_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's severity from /workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/046_ip_technology_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_financials/094_financials_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's primary_source from /workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/046_ip_technology_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_financials/094_financials_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/046_ip_technology_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_financials/094_financials_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-16 using the exact controlled facts ['58 records', '2025-10-20', '49 records', '2025-11-10'].", "id": "findings.F-16.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-16's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-16.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-25', 'Mei Whitaker'] for F-16.", "id": "findings.F-16.action_anchors"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Executive assessment' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Executive assessment"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Method and record coverage' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Method and record coverage"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Findings' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Findings"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Recommended next actions' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Recommended next actions"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Assumptions and limitations' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Assumptions and limitations"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-01 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-01"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-02 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-02"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-03 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-03"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-04 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-04"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-05 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-05"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-06 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-06"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-07 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-07"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-08 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-08"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-09 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-09"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-10 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-10"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-11 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-11"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-12 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-12"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-13 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-13"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-14 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-14"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-15 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-15"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-16 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-16"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Do not claim the production has no issues or that every record is consistent.", "id": "memo.forbidden_claims_absent"}], "decision_options": [{"id": "cross-source-reconciliation", "label": "Reconcile controlling and corroborating records", "reason": "The CB-MA-2407 production contains independently maintained records; a defensible answer must preserve each supported conflict and its cure owner.", "selected": true}, {"id": "latest-record-controls", "label": "Treat the latest record as controlling", "reason": "Timestamp recency does not establish legal priority, execution, or approval authority.", "selected": false}, {"id": "primary-records-only", "label": "Report primary records without reconciliation", "reason": "Primary records alone conceal the operational conflicts that create the actionable exceptions.", "selected": false}], "gates": ["all_evidence_read_in_full", "chain_of_custody_metadata_checked", "findings_criteria_complete", "memo_criteria_complete", "deliverables_written_through_mcp"], "metadata_checks": 8, "metric": "weighted_criteria_score", "minimum_tool_calls": 46, "required_deliverables": ["findings.json", "advice.md"], "required_document_reads": 33, "type": "deterministic", "weights": {"findings": 0.55, "memo": 0.2, "procedure": 0.25}}, "task_id": "cb100-007-bracken-home", "task_name": "Project Hearth consumer products merger", "world_id": "counselbench-filesystem-mcp-v2"}
-{"context_files": ["task_files/cb100-008-cobalt-learning/01_corporate/001_corporate_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-008-cobalt-learning/01_corporate/002_corporate_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-008-cobalt-learning/01_corporate/003_corporate_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-008-cobalt-learning/01_corporate/004_corporate_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-008-cobalt-learning/01_corporate/005_corporate_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-008-cobalt-learning/01_corporate/006_corporate_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-008-cobalt-learning/01_corporate/007_corporate_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-008-cobalt-learning/01_corporate/008_corporate_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-008-cobalt-learning/02_capitalization/009_capitalization_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-008-cobalt-learning/02_capitalization/010_capitalization_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-008-cobalt-learning/02_capitalization/011_capitalization_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-008-cobalt-learning/02_capitalization/012_capitalization_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-008-cobalt-learning/02_capitalization/013_capitalization_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-008-cobalt-learning/02_capitalization/014_capitalization_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-008-cobalt-learning/02_capitalization/015_capitalization_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-008-cobalt-learning/02_capitalization/016_capitalization_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-008-cobalt-learning/03_material_contracts/017_material_contracts_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-008-cobalt-learning/03_material_contracts/018_material_contracts_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-008-cobalt-learning/03_material_contracts/019_material_contracts_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-008-cobalt-learning/03_material_contracts/020_material_contracts_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-008-cobalt-learning/03_material_contracts/021_material_contracts_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-008-cobalt-learning/03_material_contracts/022_material_contracts_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-008-cobalt-learning/03_material_contracts/023_material_contracts_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-008-cobalt-learning/03_material_contracts/024_material_contracts_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-008-cobalt-learning/04_debt_security/025_debt_security_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-008-cobalt-learning/04_debt_security/026_debt_security_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-008-cobalt-learning/04_debt_security/027_debt_security_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-008-cobalt-learning/04_debt_security/028_debt_security_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-008-cobalt-learning/04_debt_security/029_debt_security_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-008-cobalt-learning/04_debt_security/030_debt_security_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-008-cobalt-learning/04_debt_security/031_debt_security_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-008-cobalt-learning/04_debt_security/032_debt_security_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-008-cobalt-learning/05_employment/033_employment_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-008-cobalt-learning/05_employment/034_employment_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-008-cobalt-learning/05_employment/035_employment_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-008-cobalt-learning/05_employment/036_employment_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-008-cobalt-learning/05_employment/037_employment_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-008-cobalt-learning/05_employment/038_employment_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-008-cobalt-learning/05_employment/039_employment_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-008-cobalt-learning/05_employment/040_employment_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-008-cobalt-learning/06_ip_technology/041_ip_technology_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-008-cobalt-learning/06_ip_technology/042_ip_technology_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-008-cobalt-learning/06_ip_technology/043_ip_technology_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-008-cobalt-learning/06_ip_technology/044_ip_technology_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-008-cobalt-learning/06_ip_technology/045_ip_technology_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-008-cobalt-learning/06_ip_technology/046_ip_technology_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-008-cobalt-learning/06_ip_technology/047_ip_technology_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-008-cobalt-learning/06_ip_technology/048_ip_technology_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-008-cobalt-learning/07_privacy_security/049_privacy_security_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-008-cobalt-learning/07_privacy_security/050_privacy_security_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-008-cobalt-learning/07_privacy_security/051_privacy_security_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-008-cobalt-learning/07_privacy_security/052_privacy_security_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-008-cobalt-learning/07_privacy_security/053_privacy_security_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-008-cobalt-learning/07_privacy_security/054_privacy_security_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-008-cobalt-learning/07_privacy_security/055_privacy_security_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-008-cobalt-learning/07_privacy_security/056_privacy_security_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-008-cobalt-learning/08_regulatory/057_regulatory_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-008-cobalt-learning/08_regulatory/058_regulatory_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-008-cobalt-learning/08_regulatory/059_regulatory_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-008-cobalt-learning/08_regulatory/060_regulatory_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-008-cobalt-learning/08_regulatory/061_regulatory_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-008-cobalt-learning/08_regulatory/062_regulatory_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-008-cobalt-learning/08_regulatory/063_regulatory_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-008-cobalt-learning/08_regulatory/064_regulatory_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-008-cobalt-learning/09_litigation/065_litigation_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-008-cobalt-learning/09_litigation/066_litigation_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-008-cobalt-learning/09_litigation/067_litigation_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-008-cobalt-learning/09_litigation/068_litigation_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-008-cobalt-learning/09_litigation/069_litigation_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-008-cobalt-learning/09_litigation/070_litigation_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-008-cobalt-learning/09_litigation/071_litigation_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-008-cobalt-learning/09_litigation/072_litigation_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-008-cobalt-learning/10_real_property/073_real_property_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-008-cobalt-learning/10_real_property/074_real_property_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-008-cobalt-learning/10_real_property/075_real_property_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-008-cobalt-learning/10_real_property/076_real_property_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-008-cobalt-learning/10_real_property/077_real_property_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-008-cobalt-learning/10_real_property/078_real_property_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-008-cobalt-learning/10_real_property/079_real_property_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-008-cobalt-learning/10_real_property/080_real_property_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-008-cobalt-learning/11_tax_insurance/081_tax_insurance_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-008-cobalt-learning/11_tax_insurance/082_tax_insurance_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-008-cobalt-learning/11_tax_insurance/083_tax_insurance_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-008-cobalt-learning/11_tax_insurance/084_tax_insurance_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-008-cobalt-learning/11_tax_insurance/085_tax_insurance_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-008-cobalt-learning/11_tax_insurance/086_tax_insurance_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-008-cobalt-learning/11_tax_insurance/087_tax_insurance_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-008-cobalt-learning/11_tax_insurance/088_tax_insurance_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-008-cobalt-learning/12_financials/089_financials_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-008-cobalt-learning/12_financials/090_financials_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-008-cobalt-learning/12_financials/091_financials_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-008-cobalt-learning/12_financials/092_financials_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-008-cobalt-learning/12_financials/093_financials_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-008-cobalt-learning/12_financials/094_financials_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-008-cobalt-learning/12_financials/095_financials_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-008-cobalt-learning/12_financials/096_financials_status_report.md"], "gold_output": {"advice_markdown": "# Counsel advice — Project Chalkboard education platform purchase\n\n## Executive assessment\n\nFor Cobalt Learning Cooperative matter CB-MA-2408, the review identified 16 source-supported exceptions requiring action before 2026-09-29. The assessment concerns Chalkboard Metrics PBC and the supplied record for Massachusetts.\n\n## Method and record coverage\n\nThe review inventoried all 96 production files, read the 33 controlling, corroborating, and control records, searched the email exports, and checked metadata for the designated chain-of-custody sample. Conclusions are limited to the synthetic production supplied for this benchmark matter.\n\n## Findings\n\n### F-01 — charter authorization mismatch (critical)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for charter authorization mismatch: one source states the operative date is 2025-07-08 under control reference CB-MA-2408-A706, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2025-07-17 under response reference CB-MA-2408-J977.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/01_corporate/001_corporate_control_register.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/07_privacy_security/049_privacy_security_control_register.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-29, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Nadine Flores.\n\n### F-02 — unrecorded option grant (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for unrecorded option grant: one source states the controlling amount is $7,144,308.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $7,415,116.00.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/01_corporate/004_corporate_ledger_export.csv`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/07_privacy_security/052_privacy_security_ledger_export.csv`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-29, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Micah Sullivan.\n\n### F-03 — change-of-control consent (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for change-of-control consent: one source states approval is attributed to Adrian Mensah as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Jonas Feld and contains no entry for Adrian Mensah.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/01_corporate/007_corporate_officer_certificate.html`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/07_privacy_security/055_privacy_security_officer_certificate.html`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-29, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Farah Ibrahim.\n\n### F-04 — anti-assignment restriction (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for anti-assignment restriction: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-MA-2408-D890, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-MA-2408-M299.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/02_capitalization/010_capitalization_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/08_regulatory/058_regulatory_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-29, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Owen Delgado.\n\n### F-05 — most-favored-customer exposure (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for most-favored-customer exposure: one source states the applicable location is Suffolk County, Massachusetts, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to Massachusetts operations outside Suffolk County, Massachusetts.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/02_capitalization/013_capitalization_review_memorandum.json`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/08_regulatory/061_regulatory_review_memorandum.json`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-29, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Lena Varga.\n\n### F-06 — financial covenant breach (low)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for financial covenant breach: one source states the threshold is 6% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 12% and produced a different exception result.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/02_capitalization/016_capitalization_status_report.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/08_regulatory/064_regulatory_status_report.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-29, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Samuel Kim.\n\n### F-07 — key-person retention gap (critical)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for key-person retention gap: one source states formal notice must use notices-cobalt_learning_cooperative@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-chalkboard_metrics_pbc@example.test.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/019_material_contracts_correspondence.eml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/09_litigation/067_litigation_correspondence.eml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-29, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Maya Ellison.\n\n### F-08 — invention assignment defect (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for invention assignment defect: one source states the governed population contains 73 records through 2025-01-28, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 46 records through 2025-02-15.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/022_material_contracts_formal_notice.xml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/09_litigation/070_litigation_formal_notice.xml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-29, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Rafael Okafor.\n\n### F-09 — open-source copyleft exposure (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for open-source copyleft exposure: one source states the operative date is 2025-07-25 under control reference CB-MA-2408-I963, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2025-08-20 under response reference CB-MA-2408-R581.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/04_debt_security/025_debt_security_control_register.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/10_real_property/073_real_property_control_register.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-29, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Nora Chen.\n\n### F-10 — unreported security incident (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for unreported security incident: one source states the controlling amount is $5,524,421.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $5,545,342.00.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/04_debt_security/028_debt_security_ledger_export.csv`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/10_real_property/076_real_property_ledger_export.csv`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-29, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Dominic Alvarez.\n\n### F-11 — permit transfer restriction (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for permit transfer restriction: one source states approval is attributed to Adrian Mensah as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Samuel Kim and contains no entry for Adrian Mensah.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/04_debt_security/031_debt_security_officer_certificate.html`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/10_real_property/079_real_property_officer_certificate.html`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-29, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Priya Raman.\n\n### F-12 — threatened customer dispute (low)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for threatened customer dispute: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-MA-2408-L905, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-MA-2408-U508.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/05_employment/034_employment_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/11_tax_insurance/082_tax_insurance_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-29, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Elliot Mercer.\n\n### F-13 — facility title exception (critical)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for facility title exception: one source states the applicable location is Suffolk County, Massachusetts, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to Massachusetts operations outside Suffolk County, Massachusetts.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/05_employment/037_employment_review_memorandum.json`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/11_tax_insurance/085_tax_insurance_review_memorandum.json`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-29, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Talia Brooks.\n\n### F-14 — sales-tax nexus gap (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for sales-tax nexus gap: one source states the threshold is 15% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 22% and produced a different exception result.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/05_employment/040_employment_status_report.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/11_tax_insurance/088_tax_insurance_status_report.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-29, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Jonas Feld.\n\n### F-15 — claims-made insurance tail (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for claims-made insurance tail: one source states formal notice must use notices-cobalt_learning_cooperative@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-chalkboard_metrics_pbc@example.test.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/043_ip_technology_correspondence.eml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/12_financials/091_financials_correspondence.eml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-29, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Mei Whitaker.\n\n### F-16 — revenue recognition exception (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for revenue recognition exception: one source states the governed population contains 112 records through 2025-12-13, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 41 records through 2025-12-26.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/046_ip_technology_formal_notice.xml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/12_financials/094_financials_formal_notice.xml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-29, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Caleb Hassan.\n\n## Recommended next actions\n\nSequence the critical and high findings first, assign the named owners, preserve the cited records, and document any resolution in the controlling matter register before the stated deadline.\n\n## Assumptions and limitations\n\nThis analysis is confined to task cb100-008-cobalt-learning and the supplied synthetic evidence. It does not rely on external facts, does not resolve disputed law, and is not legal advice for a real person or entity.\n", "findings": {"as_of": "2026-09-29", "findings": [{"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/07_privacy_security/049_privacy_security_control_register.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for charter authorization mismatch: one source states the operative date is 2025-07-08 under control reference CB-MA-2408-A706, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2025-07-17 under response reference CB-MA-2408-J977.", "id": "F-01", "issue": "charter authorization mismatch", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/01_corporate/001_corporate_control_register.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-29, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Nadine Flores.", "severity": "critical"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/07_privacy_security/052_privacy_security_ledger_export.csv", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for unrecorded option grant: one source states the controlling amount is $7,144,308.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $7,415,116.00.", "id": "F-02", "issue": "unrecorded option grant", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/01_corporate/004_corporate_ledger_export.csv", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-29, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Micah Sullivan.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/07_privacy_security/055_privacy_security_officer_certificate.html", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for change-of-control consent: one source states approval is attributed to Adrian Mensah as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Jonas Feld and contains no entry for Adrian Mensah.", "id": "F-03", "issue": "change-of-control consent", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/01_corporate/007_corporate_officer_certificate.html", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-29, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Farah Ibrahim.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/08_regulatory/058_regulatory_executed_instrument.txt", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for anti-assignment restriction: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-MA-2408-D890, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-MA-2408-M299.", "id": "F-04", "issue": "anti-assignment restriction", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/02_capitalization/010_capitalization_executed_instrument.txt", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-29, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Owen Delgado.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/08_regulatory/061_regulatory_review_memorandum.json", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for most-favored-customer exposure: one source states the applicable location is Suffolk County, Massachusetts, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to Massachusetts operations outside Suffolk County, Massachusetts.", "id": "F-05", "issue": "most-favored-customer exposure", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/02_capitalization/013_capitalization_review_memorandum.json", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-29, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Lena Varga.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/08_regulatory/064_regulatory_status_report.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for financial covenant breach: one source states the threshold is 6% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 12% and produced a different exception result.", "id": "F-06", "issue": "financial covenant breach", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/02_capitalization/016_capitalization_status_report.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-29, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Samuel Kim.", "severity": "low"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/09_litigation/067_litigation_correspondence.eml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for key-person retention gap: one source states formal notice must use notices-cobalt_learning_cooperative@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-chalkboard_metrics_pbc@example.test.", "id": "F-07", "issue": "key-person retention gap", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/019_material_contracts_correspondence.eml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-29, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Maya Ellison.", "severity": "critical"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/09_litigation/070_litigation_formal_notice.xml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for invention assignment defect: one source states the governed population contains 73 records through 2025-01-28, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 46 records through 2025-02-15.", "id": "F-08", "issue": "invention assignment defect", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/022_material_contracts_formal_notice.xml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-29, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Rafael Okafor.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/10_real_property/073_real_property_control_register.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for open-source copyleft exposure: one source states the operative date is 2025-07-25 under control reference CB-MA-2408-I963, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2025-08-20 under response reference CB-MA-2408-R581.", "id": "F-09", "issue": "open-source copyleft exposure", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/04_debt_security/025_debt_security_control_register.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-29, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Nora Chen.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/10_real_property/076_real_property_ledger_export.csv", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for unreported security incident: one source states the controlling amount is $5,524,421.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $5,545,342.00.", "id": "F-10", "issue": "unreported security incident", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/04_debt_security/028_debt_security_ledger_export.csv", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-29, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Dominic Alvarez.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/10_real_property/079_real_property_officer_certificate.html", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for permit transfer restriction: one source states approval is attributed to Adrian Mensah as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Samuel Kim and contains no entry for Adrian Mensah.", "id": "F-11", "issue": "permit transfer restriction", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/04_debt_security/031_debt_security_officer_certificate.html", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-29, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Priya Raman.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/11_tax_insurance/082_tax_insurance_executed_instrument.txt", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for threatened customer dispute: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-MA-2408-L905, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-MA-2408-U508.", "id": "F-12", "issue": "threatened customer dispute", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/05_employment/034_employment_executed_instrument.txt", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-29, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Elliot Mercer.", "severity": "low"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/11_tax_insurance/085_tax_insurance_review_memorandum.json", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for facility title exception: one source states the applicable location is Suffolk County, Massachusetts, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to Massachusetts operations outside Suffolk County, Massachusetts.", "id": "F-13", "issue": "facility title exception", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/05_employment/037_employment_review_memorandum.json", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-29, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Talia Brooks.", "severity": "critical"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/11_tax_insurance/088_tax_insurance_status_report.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for sales-tax nexus gap: one source states the threshold is 15% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 22% and produced a different exception result.", "id": "F-14", "issue": "sales-tax nexus gap", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/05_employment/040_employment_status_report.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-29, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Jonas Feld.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/12_financials/091_financials_correspondence.eml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for claims-made insurance tail: one source states formal notice must use notices-cobalt_learning_cooperative@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-chalkboard_metrics_pbc@example.test.", "id": "F-15", "issue": "claims-made insurance tail", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/043_ip_technology_correspondence.eml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-29, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Mei Whitaker.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/12_financials/094_financials_formal_notice.xml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for revenue recognition exception: one source states the governed population contains 112 records through 2025-12-13, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 41 records through 2025-12-26.", "id": "F-16", "issue": "revenue recognition exception", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/046_ip_technology_formal_notice.xml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-29, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Caleb Hassan.", "severity": "medium"}], "matter_number": "CB-MA-2408", "prepared_for": "Cobalt Learning Cooperative", "schema_version": "1.0", "task_id": "cb100-008-cobalt-learning"}}, "metadata": {"benchmark": "CounselBench-100", "code_license": "Apache-2.0", "data_license": "CC-BY-4.0", "deadline": "2026-09-29", "document_count": 96, "jurisdiction": "Massachusetts", "matter_number": "CB-MA-2408", "mcp_commit": "9a96ea6e5913736f92b88345bf51caeaaa8e719f", "mcp_package": "@modelcontextprotocol/server-filesystem@2026.7.10", "practice_area": "corporate-ma", "reference_tool_calls": 46, "required_evidence_reads": 33, "synthetic": true, "venue": "Suffolk County, Massachusetts", "version": "2.0.0"}, "prompt": "You are buyer-side transactions counsel for Cobalt Learning Cooperative. The supervising attorney wants an exception-focused review that still demonstrates complete coverage of the data room. The target processes school records, sublicenses assessment content, and issued advisor warrants that never reached the formal capitalization schedule. Decision due 2026-09-29. Massachusetts law governs; Suffolk County, Massachusetts is the forum. Preserve the difference between the client's position, the counterparty's position, and an objective record conflict. Work out the defensible position from the matter production and leave an audit-ready exception tracker and concise advice for the supervising lawyer. Keep confirmed conflicts separate from open questions, cite the records that actually control each conclusion, and do not fill gaps with outside facts.", "rubric": {"criteria": [{"category": "procedure", "description": "Complete at least 46 successful, argument-specific evidence and output calls.", "id": "procedure.minimum_successful_tool_calls"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Find and read the 33 controlling, corroborating, and work-product-control records in full.", "id": "procedure.all_evidence_read_in_full"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Inspect file metadata for the eight designated critical primary records before relying on them.", "id": "procedure.chain_of_custody_metadata_checked"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Confirm the sandbox's allowed document and output roots.", "id": "procedure.allowed_directories_checked"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Inventory all 96 records so the relevant sources are discovered among the context records.", "id": "procedure.recursive_inventory_completed"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Search the production for email evidence that may corroborate or contradict formal records.", "id": "procedure.targeted_search_completed"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Leave only findings.json and advice.md in the output workspace.", "id": "procedure.exact_deliverable_set"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Create both final work products through the sandbox MCP surface.", "id": "procedure.deliverables_written_through_mcp"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Produce findings.json as a valid JSON object.", "id": "findings.findings_is_object"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Report exactly 16 confirmed exceptions.", "id": "findings.findings_exact_count"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Use each stable finding ID exactly once.", "id": "findings.finding_ids_unique"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set schema_version to the released matter value '1.0'.", "id": "findings.top_level_schema_version"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set task_id to the released matter value 'cb100-008-cobalt-learning'.", "id": "findings.top_level_task_id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set matter_number to the released matter value 'CB-MA-2408'.", "id": "findings.top_level_matter_number"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set prepared_for to the released matter value 'Cobalt Learning Cooperative'.", "id": "findings.top_level_prepared_for"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set as_of to the released matter value '2026-09-29'.", "id": "findings.top_level_as_of"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-01 exception for charter authorization mismatch.", "id": "findings.F-01.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's id from /workspace/documents/01_corporate/001_corporate_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_privacy_security/049_privacy_security_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's issue from /workspace/documents/01_corporate/001_corporate_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_privacy_security/049_privacy_security_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's severity from /workspace/documents/01_corporate/001_corporate_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_privacy_security/049_privacy_security_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's primary_source from /workspace/documents/01_corporate/001_corporate_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_privacy_security/049_privacy_security_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/01_corporate/001_corporate_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_privacy_security/049_privacy_security_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-01 using the exact controlled facts ['2025-07-08', 'CB-MA-2408-A706', '2025-07-17', 'CB-MA-2408-J977'].", "id": "findings.F-01.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-01's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-01.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-29', 'Nadine Flores'] for F-01.", "id": "findings.F-01.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-02 exception for unrecorded option grant.", "id": "findings.F-02.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's id from /workspace/documents/01_corporate/004_corporate_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_privacy_security/052_privacy_security_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's issue from /workspace/documents/01_corporate/004_corporate_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_privacy_security/052_privacy_security_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's severity from /workspace/documents/01_corporate/004_corporate_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_privacy_security/052_privacy_security_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's primary_source from /workspace/documents/01_corporate/004_corporate_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_privacy_security/052_privacy_security_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/01_corporate/004_corporate_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_privacy_security/052_privacy_security_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-02 using the exact controlled facts ['$7,144,308.00', '$7,415,116.00'].", "id": "findings.F-02.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-02's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-02.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-29', 'Micah Sullivan'] for F-02.", "id": "findings.F-02.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-03 exception for change-of-control consent.", "id": "findings.F-03.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's id from /workspace/documents/01_corporate/007_corporate_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_privacy_security/055_privacy_security_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's issue from /workspace/documents/01_corporate/007_corporate_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_privacy_security/055_privacy_security_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's severity from /workspace/documents/01_corporate/007_corporate_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_privacy_security/055_privacy_security_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's primary_source from /workspace/documents/01_corporate/007_corporate_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_privacy_security/055_privacy_security_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/01_corporate/007_corporate_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_privacy_security/055_privacy_security_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-03 using the exact controlled facts ['Adrian Mensah', 'Jonas Feld'].", "id": "findings.F-03.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-03's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-03.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-29', 'Farah Ibrahim'] for F-03.", "id": "findings.F-03.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-04 exception for anti-assignment restriction.", "id": "findings.F-04.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's id from /workspace/documents/02_capitalization/010_capitalization_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_regulatory/058_regulatory_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's issue from /workspace/documents/02_capitalization/010_capitalization_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_regulatory/058_regulatory_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's severity from /workspace/documents/02_capitalization/010_capitalization_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_regulatory/058_regulatory_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's primary_source from /workspace/documents/02_capitalization/010_capitalization_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_regulatory/058_regulatory_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/02_capitalization/010_capitalization_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_regulatory/058_regulatory_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-04 using the exact controlled facts ['closed without exception', 'CB-MA-2408-D890', 'open and escalated', 'CB-MA-2408-M299'].", "id": "findings.F-04.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-04's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-04.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-29', 'Owen Delgado'] for F-04.", "id": "findings.F-04.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-05 exception for most-favored-customer exposure.", "id": "findings.F-05.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's id from /workspace/documents/02_capitalization/013_capitalization_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_regulatory/061_regulatory_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's issue from /workspace/documents/02_capitalization/013_capitalization_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_regulatory/061_regulatory_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's severity from /workspace/documents/02_capitalization/013_capitalization_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_regulatory/061_regulatory_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's primary_source from /workspace/documents/02_capitalization/013_capitalization_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_regulatory/061_regulatory_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/02_capitalization/013_capitalization_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_regulatory/061_regulatory_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-05 using the exact controlled facts ['Suffolk County, Massachusetts', 'Massachusetts'].", "id": "findings.F-05.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-05's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-05.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-29', 'Lena Varga'] for F-05.", "id": "findings.F-05.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-06 exception for financial covenant breach.", "id": "findings.F-06.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's id from /workspace/documents/02_capitalization/016_capitalization_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_regulatory/064_regulatory_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's issue from /workspace/documents/02_capitalization/016_capitalization_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_regulatory/064_regulatory_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's severity from /workspace/documents/02_capitalization/016_capitalization_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_regulatory/064_regulatory_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's primary_source from /workspace/documents/02_capitalization/016_capitalization_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_regulatory/064_regulatory_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/02_capitalization/016_capitalization_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_regulatory/064_regulatory_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-06 using the exact controlled facts ['6%', '12%'].", "id": "findings.F-06.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-06's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-06.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-29', 'Samuel Kim'] for F-06.", "id": "findings.F-06.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-07 exception for key-person retention gap.", "id": "findings.F-07.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's id from /workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/019_material_contracts_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_litigation/067_litigation_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's issue from /workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/019_material_contracts_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_litigation/067_litigation_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's severity from /workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/019_material_contracts_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_litigation/067_litigation_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's primary_source from /workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/019_material_contracts_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_litigation/067_litigation_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/019_material_contracts_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_litigation/067_litigation_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-07 using the exact controlled facts ['notices-cobalt_learning_cooperative@example.test', 'archive-chalkboard_metrics_pbc@example.test'].", "id": "findings.F-07.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-07's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-07.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-29', 'Maya Ellison'] for F-07.", "id": "findings.F-07.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-08 exception for invention assignment defect.", "id": "findings.F-08.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's id from /workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/022_material_contracts_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_litigation/070_litigation_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's issue from /workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/022_material_contracts_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_litigation/070_litigation_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's severity from /workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/022_material_contracts_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_litigation/070_litigation_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's primary_source from /workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/022_material_contracts_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_litigation/070_litigation_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/022_material_contracts_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_litigation/070_litigation_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-08 using the exact controlled facts ['73 records', '2025-01-28', '46 records', '2025-02-15'].", "id": "findings.F-08.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-08's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-08.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-29', 'Rafael Okafor'] for F-08.", "id": "findings.F-08.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-09 exception for open-source copyleft exposure.", "id": "findings.F-09.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's id from /workspace/documents/04_debt_security/025_debt_security_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_real_property/073_real_property_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's issue from /workspace/documents/04_debt_security/025_debt_security_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_real_property/073_real_property_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's severity from /workspace/documents/04_debt_security/025_debt_security_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_real_property/073_real_property_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's primary_source from /workspace/documents/04_debt_security/025_debt_security_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_real_property/073_real_property_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/04_debt_security/025_debt_security_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_real_property/073_real_property_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-09 using the exact controlled facts ['2025-07-25', 'CB-MA-2408-I963', '2025-08-20', 'CB-MA-2408-R581'].", "id": "findings.F-09.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-09's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-09.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-29', 'Nora Chen'] for F-09.", "id": "findings.F-09.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-10 exception for unreported security incident.", "id": "findings.F-10.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's id from /workspace/documents/04_debt_security/028_debt_security_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_real_property/076_real_property_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's issue from /workspace/documents/04_debt_security/028_debt_security_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_real_property/076_real_property_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's severity from /workspace/documents/04_debt_security/028_debt_security_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_real_property/076_real_property_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's primary_source from /workspace/documents/04_debt_security/028_debt_security_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_real_property/076_real_property_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/04_debt_security/028_debt_security_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_real_property/076_real_property_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-10 using the exact controlled facts ['$5,524,421.00', '$5,545,342.00'].", "id": "findings.F-10.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-10's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-10.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-29', 'Dominic Alvarez'] for F-10.", "id": "findings.F-10.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-11 exception for permit transfer restriction.", "id": "findings.F-11.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's id from /workspace/documents/04_debt_security/031_debt_security_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_real_property/079_real_property_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's issue from /workspace/documents/04_debt_security/031_debt_security_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_real_property/079_real_property_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's severity from /workspace/documents/04_debt_security/031_debt_security_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_real_property/079_real_property_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's primary_source from /workspace/documents/04_debt_security/031_debt_security_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_real_property/079_real_property_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/04_debt_security/031_debt_security_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_real_property/079_real_property_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-11 using the exact controlled facts ['Adrian Mensah', 'Samuel Kim'].", "id": "findings.F-11.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-11's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-11.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-29', 'Priya Raman'] for F-11.", "id": "findings.F-11.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-12 exception for threatened customer dispute.", "id": "findings.F-12.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's id from /workspace/documents/05_employment/034_employment_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_tax_insurance/082_tax_insurance_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's issue from /workspace/documents/05_employment/034_employment_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_tax_insurance/082_tax_insurance_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's severity from /workspace/documents/05_employment/034_employment_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_tax_insurance/082_tax_insurance_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's primary_source from /workspace/documents/05_employment/034_employment_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_tax_insurance/082_tax_insurance_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/05_employment/034_employment_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_tax_insurance/082_tax_insurance_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-12 using the exact controlled facts ['closed without exception', 'CB-MA-2408-L905', 'open and escalated', 'CB-MA-2408-U508'].", "id": "findings.F-12.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-12's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-12.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-29', 'Elliot Mercer'] for F-12.", "id": "findings.F-12.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-13 exception for facility title exception.", "id": "findings.F-13.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's id from /workspace/documents/05_employment/037_employment_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_tax_insurance/085_tax_insurance_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's issue from /workspace/documents/05_employment/037_employment_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_tax_insurance/085_tax_insurance_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's severity from /workspace/documents/05_employment/037_employment_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_tax_insurance/085_tax_insurance_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's primary_source from /workspace/documents/05_employment/037_employment_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_tax_insurance/085_tax_insurance_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/05_employment/037_employment_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_tax_insurance/085_tax_insurance_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-13 using the exact controlled facts ['Suffolk County, Massachusetts', 'Massachusetts'].", "id": "findings.F-13.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-13's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-13.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-29', 'Talia Brooks'] for F-13.", "id": "findings.F-13.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-14 exception for sales-tax nexus gap.", "id": "findings.F-14.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's id from /workspace/documents/05_employment/040_employment_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_tax_insurance/088_tax_insurance_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's issue from /workspace/documents/05_employment/040_employment_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_tax_insurance/088_tax_insurance_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's severity from /workspace/documents/05_employment/040_employment_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_tax_insurance/088_tax_insurance_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's primary_source from /workspace/documents/05_employment/040_employment_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_tax_insurance/088_tax_insurance_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/05_employment/040_employment_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_tax_insurance/088_tax_insurance_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-14 using the exact controlled facts ['15%', '22%'].", "id": "findings.F-14.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-14's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-14.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-29', 'Jonas Feld'] for F-14.", "id": "findings.F-14.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-15 exception for claims-made insurance tail.", "id": "findings.F-15.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's id from /workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/043_ip_technology_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_financials/091_financials_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's issue from /workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/043_ip_technology_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_financials/091_financials_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's severity from /workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/043_ip_technology_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_financials/091_financials_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's primary_source from /workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/043_ip_technology_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_financials/091_financials_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/043_ip_technology_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_financials/091_financials_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-15 using the exact controlled facts ['notices-cobalt_learning_cooperative@example.test', 'archive-chalkboard_metrics_pbc@example.test'].", "id": "findings.F-15.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-15's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-15.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-29', 'Mei Whitaker'] for F-15.", "id": "findings.F-15.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-16 exception for revenue recognition exception.", "id": "findings.F-16.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's id from /workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/046_ip_technology_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_financials/094_financials_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's issue from /workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/046_ip_technology_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_financials/094_financials_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's severity from /workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/046_ip_technology_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_financials/094_financials_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's primary_source from /workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/046_ip_technology_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_financials/094_financials_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/046_ip_technology_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_financials/094_financials_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-16 using the exact controlled facts ['112 records', '2025-12-13', '41 records', '2025-12-26'].", "id": "findings.F-16.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-16's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-16.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-29', 'Caleb Hassan'] for F-16.", "id": "findings.F-16.action_anchors"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Executive assessment' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Executive assessment"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Method and record coverage' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Method and record coverage"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Findings' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Findings"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Recommended next actions' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Recommended next actions"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Assumptions and limitations' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Assumptions and limitations"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-01 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-01"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-02 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-02"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-03 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-03"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-04 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-04"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-05 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-05"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-06 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-06"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-07 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-07"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-08 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-08"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-09 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-09"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-10 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-10"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-11 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-11"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-12 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-12"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-13 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-13"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-14 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-14"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-15 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-15"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-16 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-16"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Do not claim the production has no issues or that every record is consistent.", "id": "memo.forbidden_claims_absent"}], "decision_options": [{"id": "cross-source-reconciliation", "label": "Reconcile controlling and corroborating records", "reason": "The CB-MA-2408 production contains independently maintained records; a defensible answer must preserve each supported conflict and its cure owner.", "selected": true}, {"id": "latest-record-controls", "label": "Treat the latest record as controlling", "reason": "Timestamp recency does not establish legal priority, execution, or approval authority.", "selected": false}, {"id": "primary-records-only", "label": "Report primary records without reconciliation", "reason": "Primary records alone conceal the operational conflicts that create the actionable exceptions.", "selected": false}], "gates": ["all_evidence_read_in_full", "chain_of_custody_metadata_checked", "findings_criteria_complete", "memo_criteria_complete", "deliverables_written_through_mcp"], "metadata_checks": 8, "metric": "weighted_criteria_score", "minimum_tool_calls": 46, "required_deliverables": ["findings.json", "advice.md"], "required_document_reads": 33, "type": "deterministic", "weights": {"findings": 0.55, "memo": 0.2, "procedure": 0.25}}, "task_id": "cb100-008-cobalt-learning", "task_name": "Project Chalkboard education platform purchase", "world_id": "counselbench-filesystem-mcp-v2"}
-{"context_files": ["task_files/cb100-009-silverline-logistics/01_corporate/001_corporate_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-009-silverline-logistics/01_corporate/002_corporate_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-009-silverline-logistics/01_corporate/003_corporate_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-009-silverline-logistics/01_corporate/004_corporate_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-009-silverline-logistics/01_corporate/005_corporate_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-009-silverline-logistics/01_corporate/006_corporate_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-009-silverline-logistics/01_corporate/007_corporate_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-009-silverline-logistics/01_corporate/008_corporate_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-009-silverline-logistics/02_capitalization/009_capitalization_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-009-silverline-logistics/02_capitalization/010_capitalization_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-009-silverline-logistics/02_capitalization/011_capitalization_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-009-silverline-logistics/02_capitalization/012_capitalization_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-009-silverline-logistics/02_capitalization/013_capitalization_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-009-silverline-logistics/02_capitalization/014_capitalization_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-009-silverline-logistics/02_capitalization/015_capitalization_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-009-silverline-logistics/02_capitalization/016_capitalization_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-009-silverline-logistics/03_material_contracts/017_material_contracts_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-009-silverline-logistics/03_material_contracts/018_material_contracts_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-009-silverline-logistics/03_material_contracts/019_material_contracts_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-009-silverline-logistics/03_material_contracts/020_material_contracts_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-009-silverline-logistics/03_material_contracts/021_material_contracts_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-009-silverline-logistics/03_material_contracts/022_material_contracts_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-009-silverline-logistics/03_material_contracts/023_material_contracts_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-009-silverline-logistics/03_material_contracts/024_material_contracts_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-009-silverline-logistics/04_debt_security/025_debt_security_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-009-silverline-logistics/04_debt_security/026_debt_security_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-009-silverline-logistics/04_debt_security/027_debt_security_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-009-silverline-logistics/04_debt_security/028_debt_security_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-009-silverline-logistics/04_debt_security/029_debt_security_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-009-silverline-logistics/04_debt_security/030_debt_security_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-009-silverline-logistics/04_debt_security/031_debt_security_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-009-silverline-logistics/04_debt_security/032_debt_security_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-009-silverline-logistics/05_employment/033_employment_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-009-silverline-logistics/05_employment/034_employment_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-009-silverline-logistics/05_employment/035_employment_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-009-silverline-logistics/05_employment/036_employment_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-009-silverline-logistics/05_employment/037_employment_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-009-silverline-logistics/05_employment/038_employment_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-009-silverline-logistics/05_employment/039_employment_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-009-silverline-logistics/05_employment/040_employment_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-009-silverline-logistics/06_ip_technology/041_ip_technology_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-009-silverline-logistics/06_ip_technology/042_ip_technology_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-009-silverline-logistics/06_ip_technology/043_ip_technology_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-009-silverline-logistics/06_ip_technology/044_ip_technology_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-009-silverline-logistics/06_ip_technology/045_ip_technology_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-009-silverline-logistics/06_ip_technology/046_ip_technology_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-009-silverline-logistics/06_ip_technology/047_ip_technology_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-009-silverline-logistics/06_ip_technology/048_ip_technology_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-009-silverline-logistics/07_privacy_security/049_privacy_security_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-009-silverline-logistics/07_privacy_security/050_privacy_security_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-009-silverline-logistics/07_privacy_security/051_privacy_security_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-009-silverline-logistics/07_privacy_security/052_privacy_security_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-009-silverline-logistics/07_privacy_security/053_privacy_security_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-009-silverline-logistics/07_privacy_security/054_privacy_security_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-009-silverline-logistics/07_privacy_security/055_privacy_security_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-009-silverline-logistics/07_privacy_security/056_privacy_security_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-009-silverline-logistics/08_regulatory/057_regulatory_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-009-silverline-logistics/08_regulatory/058_regulatory_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-009-silverline-logistics/08_regulatory/059_regulatory_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-009-silverline-logistics/08_regulatory/060_regulatory_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-009-silverline-logistics/08_regulatory/061_regulatory_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-009-silverline-logistics/08_regulatory/062_regulatory_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-009-silverline-logistics/08_regulatory/063_regulatory_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-009-silverline-logistics/08_regulatory/064_regulatory_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-009-silverline-logistics/09_litigation/065_litigation_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-009-silverline-logistics/09_litigation/066_litigation_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-009-silverline-logistics/09_litigation/067_litigation_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-009-silverline-logistics/09_litigation/068_litigation_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-009-silverline-logistics/09_litigation/069_litigation_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-009-silverline-logistics/09_litigation/070_litigation_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-009-silverline-logistics/09_litigation/071_litigation_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-009-silverline-logistics/09_litigation/072_litigation_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-009-silverline-logistics/10_real_property/073_real_property_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-009-silverline-logistics/10_real_property/074_real_property_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-009-silverline-logistics/10_real_property/075_real_property_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-009-silverline-logistics/10_real_property/076_real_property_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-009-silverline-logistics/10_real_property/077_real_property_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-009-silverline-logistics/10_real_property/078_real_property_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-009-silverline-logistics/10_real_property/079_real_property_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-009-silverline-logistics/10_real_property/080_real_property_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-009-silverline-logistics/11_tax_insurance/081_tax_insurance_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-009-silverline-logistics/11_tax_insurance/082_tax_insurance_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-009-silverline-logistics/11_tax_insurance/083_tax_insurance_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-009-silverline-logistics/11_tax_insurance/084_tax_insurance_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-009-silverline-logistics/11_tax_insurance/085_tax_insurance_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-009-silverline-logistics/11_tax_insurance/086_tax_insurance_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-009-silverline-logistics/11_tax_insurance/087_tax_insurance_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-009-silverline-logistics/11_tax_insurance/088_tax_insurance_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-009-silverline-logistics/12_financials/089_financials_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-009-silverline-logistics/12_financials/090_financials_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-009-silverline-logistics/12_financials/091_financials_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-009-silverline-logistics/12_financials/092_financials_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-009-silverline-logistics/12_financials/093_financials_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-009-silverline-logistics/12_financials/094_financials_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-009-silverline-logistics/12_financials/095_financials_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-009-silverline-logistics/12_financials/096_financials_status_report.md"], "gold_output": {"advice_markdown": "# Counsel advice — Project Switchyard logistics roll-up\n\n## Executive assessment\n\nFor Silverline Logistics LP matter CB-MA-2409, the review identified 16 source-supported exceptions requiring action before 2026-10-02. The assessment concerns Switchyard Freight Intelligence, LLC and the supplied record for Georgia.\n\n## Method and record coverage\n\nThe review inventoried all 96 production files, read the 33 controlling, corroborating, and control records, searched the email exports, and checked metadata for the designated chain-of-custody sample. Conclusions are limited to the synthetic production supplied for this benchmark matter.\n\n## Findings\n\n### F-01 — charter authorization mismatch (critical)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for charter authorization mismatch: one source states the operative date is 2025-06-05 under control reference CB-MA-2409-A553, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2025-07-10 under response reference CB-MA-2409-J827.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/01_corporate/001_corporate_control_register.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/07_privacy_security/049_privacy_security_control_register.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-10-02, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Micah Sullivan.\n\n### F-02 — unrecorded option grant (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for unrecorded option grant: one source states the controlling amount is $6,923,119.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $6,942,738.00.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/01_corporate/004_corporate_ledger_export.csv`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/07_privacy_security/052_privacy_security_ledger_export.csv`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-10-02, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Farah Ibrahim.\n\n### F-03 — change-of-control consent (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for change-of-control consent: one source states approval is attributed to Willa Novak as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Caleb Hassan and contains no entry for Willa Novak.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/01_corporate/007_corporate_officer_certificate.html`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/07_privacy_security/055_privacy_security_officer_certificate.html`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-10-02, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Owen Delgado.\n\n### F-04 — anti-assignment restriction (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for anti-assignment restriction: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-MA-2409-D389, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-MA-2409-M606.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/02_capitalization/010_capitalization_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/08_regulatory/058_regulatory_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-10-02, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Lena Varga.\n\n### F-05 — most-favored-customer exposure (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for most-favored-customer exposure: one source states the applicable location is Fulton County, Georgia, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to Georgia operations outside Fulton County, Georgia.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/02_capitalization/013_capitalization_review_memorandum.json`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/08_regulatory/061_regulatory_review_memorandum.json`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-10-02, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Samuel Kim.\n\n### F-06 — financial covenant breach (low)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for financial covenant breach: one source states the threshold is 6% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 10% and produced a different exception result.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/02_capitalization/016_capitalization_status_report.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/08_regulatory/064_regulatory_status_report.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-10-02, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Maya Ellison.\n\n### F-07 — key-person retention gap (critical)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for key-person retention gap: one source states formal notice must use notices-silverline_logistics_lp@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-switchyard_freight_intelligence_llc@example.test.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/019_material_contracts_correspondence.eml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/09_litigation/067_litigation_correspondence.eml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-10-02, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Rafael Okafor.\n\n### F-08 — invention assignment defect (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for invention assignment defect: one source states the governed population contains 137 records through 2025-08-20, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 70 records through 2025-10-01.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/022_material_contracts_formal_notice.xml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/09_litigation/070_litigation_formal_notice.xml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-10-02, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Nora Chen.\n\n### F-09 — open-source copyleft exposure (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for open-source copyleft exposure: one source states the operative date is 2025-02-18 under control reference CB-MA-2409-I326, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2025-03-04 under response reference CB-MA-2409-R878.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/04_debt_security/025_debt_security_control_register.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/10_real_property/073_real_property_control_register.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-10-02, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Dominic Alvarez.\n\n### F-10 — unreported security incident (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for unreported security incident: one source states the controlling amount is $2,423,977.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $2,634,454.00.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/04_debt_security/028_debt_security_ledger_export.csv`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/10_real_property/076_real_property_ledger_export.csv`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-10-02, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Priya Raman.\n\n### F-11 — permit transfer restriction (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for permit transfer restriction: one source states approval is attributed to Willa Novak as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Rafael Okafor and contains no entry for Willa Novak.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/04_debt_security/031_debt_security_officer_certificate.html`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/10_real_property/079_real_property_officer_certificate.html`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-10-02, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Elliot Mercer.\n\n### F-12 — threatened customer dispute (low)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for threatened customer dispute: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-MA-2409-L287, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-MA-2409-U875.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/05_employment/034_employment_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/11_tax_insurance/082_tax_insurance_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-10-02, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Talia Brooks.\n\n### F-13 — facility title exception (critical)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for facility title exception: one source states the applicable location is Fulton County, Georgia, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to Georgia operations outside Fulton County, Georgia.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/05_employment/037_employment_review_memorandum.json`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/11_tax_insurance/085_tax_insurance_review_memorandum.json`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-10-02, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Jonas Feld.\n\n### F-14 — sales-tax nexus gap (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for sales-tax nexus gap: one source states the threshold is 6% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 8% and produced a different exception result.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/05_employment/040_employment_status_report.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/11_tax_insurance/088_tax_insurance_status_report.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-10-02, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Mei Whitaker.\n\n### F-15 — claims-made insurance tail (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for claims-made insurance tail: one source states formal notice must use notices-silverline_logistics_lp@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-switchyard_freight_intelligence_llc@example.test.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/043_ip_technology_correspondence.eml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/12_financials/091_financials_correspondence.eml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-10-02, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Caleb Hassan.\n\n### F-16 — revenue recognition exception (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for revenue recognition exception: one source states the governed population contains 82 records through 2025-11-13, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 59 records through 2025-12-14.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/046_ip_technology_formal_notice.xml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/12_financials/094_financials_formal_notice.xml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-10-02, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Leona Park.\n\n## Recommended next actions\n\nSequence the critical and high findings first, assign the named owners, preserve the cited records, and document any resolution in the controlling matter register before the stated deadline.\n\n## Assumptions and limitations\n\nThis analysis is confined to task cb100-009-silverline-logistics and the supplied synthetic evidence. It does not rely on external facts, does not resolve disputed law, and is not legal advice for a real person or entity.\n", "findings": {"as_of": "2026-10-02", "findings": [{"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/07_privacy_security/049_privacy_security_control_register.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for charter authorization mismatch: one source states the operative date is 2025-06-05 under control reference CB-MA-2409-A553, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2025-07-10 under response reference CB-MA-2409-J827.", "id": "F-01", "issue": "charter authorization mismatch", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/01_corporate/001_corporate_control_register.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-10-02, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Micah Sullivan.", "severity": "critical"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/07_privacy_security/052_privacy_security_ledger_export.csv", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for unrecorded option grant: one source states the controlling amount is $6,923,119.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $6,942,738.00.", "id": "F-02", "issue": "unrecorded option grant", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/01_corporate/004_corporate_ledger_export.csv", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-10-02, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Farah Ibrahim.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/07_privacy_security/055_privacy_security_officer_certificate.html", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for change-of-control consent: one source states approval is attributed to Willa Novak as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Caleb Hassan and contains no entry for Willa Novak.", "id": "F-03", "issue": "change-of-control consent", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/01_corporate/007_corporate_officer_certificate.html", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-10-02, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Owen Delgado.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/08_regulatory/058_regulatory_executed_instrument.txt", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for anti-assignment restriction: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-MA-2409-D389, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-MA-2409-M606.", "id": "F-04", "issue": "anti-assignment restriction", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/02_capitalization/010_capitalization_executed_instrument.txt", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-10-02, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Lena Varga.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/08_regulatory/061_regulatory_review_memorandum.json", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for most-favored-customer exposure: one source states the applicable location is Fulton County, Georgia, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to Georgia operations outside Fulton County, Georgia.", "id": "F-05", "issue": "most-favored-customer exposure", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/02_capitalization/013_capitalization_review_memorandum.json", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-10-02, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Samuel Kim.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/08_regulatory/064_regulatory_status_report.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for financial covenant breach: one source states the threshold is 6% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 10% and produced a different exception result.", "id": "F-06", "issue": "financial covenant breach", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/02_capitalization/016_capitalization_status_report.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-10-02, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Maya Ellison.", "severity": "low"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/09_litigation/067_litigation_correspondence.eml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for key-person retention gap: one source states formal notice must use notices-silverline_logistics_lp@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-switchyard_freight_intelligence_llc@example.test.", "id": "F-07", "issue": "key-person retention gap", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/019_material_contracts_correspondence.eml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-10-02, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Rafael Okafor.", "severity": "critical"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/09_litigation/070_litigation_formal_notice.xml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for invention assignment defect: one source states the governed population contains 137 records through 2025-08-20, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 70 records through 2025-10-01.", "id": "F-08", "issue": "invention assignment defect", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/022_material_contracts_formal_notice.xml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-10-02, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Nora Chen.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/10_real_property/073_real_property_control_register.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for open-source copyleft exposure: one source states the operative date is 2025-02-18 under control reference CB-MA-2409-I326, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2025-03-04 under response reference CB-MA-2409-R878.", "id": "F-09", "issue": "open-source copyleft exposure", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/04_debt_security/025_debt_security_control_register.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-10-02, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Dominic Alvarez.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/10_real_property/076_real_property_ledger_export.csv", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for unreported security incident: one source states the controlling amount is $2,423,977.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $2,634,454.00.", "id": "F-10", "issue": "unreported security incident", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/04_debt_security/028_debt_security_ledger_export.csv", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-10-02, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Priya Raman.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/10_real_property/079_real_property_officer_certificate.html", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for permit transfer restriction: one source states approval is attributed to Willa Novak as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Rafael Okafor and contains no entry for Willa Novak.", "id": "F-11", "issue": "permit transfer restriction", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/04_debt_security/031_debt_security_officer_certificate.html", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-10-02, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Elliot Mercer.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/11_tax_insurance/082_tax_insurance_executed_instrument.txt", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for threatened customer dispute: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-MA-2409-L287, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-MA-2409-U875.", "id": "F-12", "issue": "threatened customer dispute", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/05_employment/034_employment_executed_instrument.txt", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-10-02, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Talia Brooks.", "severity": "low"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/11_tax_insurance/085_tax_insurance_review_memorandum.json", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for facility title exception: one source states the applicable location is Fulton County, Georgia, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to Georgia operations outside Fulton County, Georgia.", "id": "F-13", "issue": "facility title exception", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/05_employment/037_employment_review_memorandum.json", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-10-02, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Jonas Feld.", "severity": "critical"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/11_tax_insurance/088_tax_insurance_status_report.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for sales-tax nexus gap: one source states the threshold is 6% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 8% and produced a different exception result.", "id": "F-14", "issue": "sales-tax nexus gap", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/05_employment/040_employment_status_report.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-10-02, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Mei Whitaker.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/12_financials/091_financials_correspondence.eml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for claims-made insurance tail: one source states formal notice must use notices-silverline_logistics_lp@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-switchyard_freight_intelligence_llc@example.test.", "id": "F-15", "issue": "claims-made insurance tail", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/043_ip_technology_correspondence.eml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-10-02, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Caleb Hassan.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/12_financials/094_financials_formal_notice.xml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for revenue recognition exception: one source states the governed population contains 82 records through 2025-11-13, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 59 records through 2025-12-14.", "id": "F-16", "issue": "revenue recognition exception", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/046_ip_technology_formal_notice.xml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-10-02, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Leona Park.", "severity": "medium"}], "matter_number": "CB-MA-2409", "prepared_for": "Silverline Logistics LP", "schema_version": "1.0", "task_id": "cb100-009-silverline-logistics"}}, "metadata": {"benchmark": "CounselBench-100", "code_license": "Apache-2.0", "data_license": "CC-BY-4.0", "deadline": "2026-10-02", "document_count": 96, "jurisdiction": "Georgia", "matter_number": "CB-MA-2409", "mcp_commit": "9a96ea6e5913736f92b88345bf51caeaaa8e719f", "mcp_package": "@modelcontextprotocol/server-filesystem@2026.7.10", "practice_area": "corporate-ma", "reference_tool_calls": 46, "required_evidence_reads": 33, "synthetic": true, "venue": "Fulton County, Georgia", "version": "2.0.0"}, "prompt": "You are buyer-side transactions counsel for Silverline Logistics LP. This matter will be reviewed by legal, finance, and compliance stakeholders who need a single source-grounded output. A freight analytics add-on uses carrier fuel data, occupies a rail-adjacent facility, and disputes a customer offset against implementation invoices. Decision due 2026-10-02. Georgia law governs; Fulton County, Georgia is the forum. Use the production as of the stated deadline; do not assume facts outside the supplied files. Work out the defensible position from the matter production and leave an audit-ready exception tracker and concise advice for the supervising lawyer. Keep confirmed conflicts separate from open questions, cite the records that actually control each conclusion, and do not fill gaps with outside facts.", "rubric": {"criteria": [{"category": "procedure", "description": "Complete at least 46 successful, argument-specific evidence and output calls.", "id": "procedure.minimum_successful_tool_calls"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Find and read the 33 controlling, corroborating, and work-product-control records in full.", "id": "procedure.all_evidence_read_in_full"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Inspect file metadata for the eight designated critical primary records before relying on them.", "id": "procedure.chain_of_custody_metadata_checked"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Confirm the sandbox's allowed document and output roots.", "id": "procedure.allowed_directories_checked"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Inventory all 96 records so the relevant sources are discovered among the context records.", "id": "procedure.recursive_inventory_completed"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Search the production for email evidence that may corroborate or contradict formal records.", "id": "procedure.targeted_search_completed"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Leave only findings.json and advice.md in the output workspace.", "id": "procedure.exact_deliverable_set"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Create both final work products through the sandbox MCP surface.", "id": "procedure.deliverables_written_through_mcp"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Produce findings.json as a valid JSON object.", "id": "findings.findings_is_object"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Report exactly 16 confirmed exceptions.", "id": "findings.findings_exact_count"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Use each stable finding ID exactly once.", "id": "findings.finding_ids_unique"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set schema_version to the released matter value '1.0'.", "id": "findings.top_level_schema_version"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set task_id to the released matter value 'cb100-009-silverline-logistics'.", "id": "findings.top_level_task_id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set matter_number to the released matter value 'CB-MA-2409'.", "id": "findings.top_level_matter_number"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set prepared_for to the released matter value 'Silverline Logistics LP'.", "id": "findings.top_level_prepared_for"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set as_of to the released matter value '2026-10-02'.", "id": "findings.top_level_as_of"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-01 exception for charter authorization mismatch.", "id": "findings.F-01.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's id from /workspace/documents/01_corporate/001_corporate_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_privacy_security/049_privacy_security_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's issue from /workspace/documents/01_corporate/001_corporate_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_privacy_security/049_privacy_security_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's severity from /workspace/documents/01_corporate/001_corporate_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_privacy_security/049_privacy_security_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's primary_source from /workspace/documents/01_corporate/001_corporate_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_privacy_security/049_privacy_security_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/01_corporate/001_corporate_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_privacy_security/049_privacy_security_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-01 using the exact controlled facts ['2025-06-05', 'CB-MA-2409-A553', '2025-07-10', 'CB-MA-2409-J827'].", "id": "findings.F-01.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-01's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-01.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-10-02', 'Micah Sullivan'] for F-01.", "id": "findings.F-01.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-02 exception for unrecorded option grant.", "id": "findings.F-02.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's id from /workspace/documents/01_corporate/004_corporate_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_privacy_security/052_privacy_security_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's issue from /workspace/documents/01_corporate/004_corporate_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_privacy_security/052_privacy_security_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's severity from /workspace/documents/01_corporate/004_corporate_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_privacy_security/052_privacy_security_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's primary_source from /workspace/documents/01_corporate/004_corporate_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_privacy_security/052_privacy_security_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/01_corporate/004_corporate_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_privacy_security/052_privacy_security_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-02 using the exact controlled facts ['$6,923,119.00', '$6,942,738.00'].", "id": "findings.F-02.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-02's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-02.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-10-02', 'Farah Ibrahim'] for F-02.", "id": "findings.F-02.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-03 exception for change-of-control consent.", "id": "findings.F-03.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's id from /workspace/documents/01_corporate/007_corporate_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_privacy_security/055_privacy_security_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's issue from /workspace/documents/01_corporate/007_corporate_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_privacy_security/055_privacy_security_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's severity from /workspace/documents/01_corporate/007_corporate_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_privacy_security/055_privacy_security_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's primary_source from /workspace/documents/01_corporate/007_corporate_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_privacy_security/055_privacy_security_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/01_corporate/007_corporate_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_privacy_security/055_privacy_security_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-03 using the exact controlled facts ['Willa Novak', 'Caleb Hassan'].", "id": "findings.F-03.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-03's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-03.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-10-02', 'Owen Delgado'] for F-03.", "id": "findings.F-03.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-04 exception for anti-assignment restriction.", "id": "findings.F-04.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's id from /workspace/documents/02_capitalization/010_capitalization_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_regulatory/058_regulatory_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's issue from /workspace/documents/02_capitalization/010_capitalization_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_regulatory/058_regulatory_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's severity from /workspace/documents/02_capitalization/010_capitalization_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_regulatory/058_regulatory_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's primary_source from /workspace/documents/02_capitalization/010_capitalization_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_regulatory/058_regulatory_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/02_capitalization/010_capitalization_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_regulatory/058_regulatory_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-04 using the exact controlled facts ['closed without exception', 'CB-MA-2409-D389', 'open and escalated', 'CB-MA-2409-M606'].", "id": "findings.F-04.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-04's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-04.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-10-02', 'Lena Varga'] for F-04.", "id": "findings.F-04.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-05 exception for most-favored-customer exposure.", "id": "findings.F-05.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's id from /workspace/documents/02_capitalization/013_capitalization_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_regulatory/061_regulatory_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's issue from /workspace/documents/02_capitalization/013_capitalization_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_regulatory/061_regulatory_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's severity from /workspace/documents/02_capitalization/013_capitalization_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_regulatory/061_regulatory_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's primary_source from /workspace/documents/02_capitalization/013_capitalization_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_regulatory/061_regulatory_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/02_capitalization/013_capitalization_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_regulatory/061_regulatory_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-05 using the exact controlled facts ['Fulton County, Georgia', 'Georgia'].", "id": "findings.F-05.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-05's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-05.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-10-02', 'Samuel Kim'] for F-05.", "id": "findings.F-05.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-06 exception for financial covenant breach.", "id": "findings.F-06.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's id from /workspace/documents/02_capitalization/016_capitalization_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_regulatory/064_regulatory_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's issue from /workspace/documents/02_capitalization/016_capitalization_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_regulatory/064_regulatory_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's severity from /workspace/documents/02_capitalization/016_capitalization_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_regulatory/064_regulatory_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's primary_source from /workspace/documents/02_capitalization/016_capitalization_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_regulatory/064_regulatory_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/02_capitalization/016_capitalization_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_regulatory/064_regulatory_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-06 using the exact controlled facts ['6%', '10%'].", "id": "findings.F-06.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-06's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-06.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-10-02', 'Maya Ellison'] for F-06.", "id": "findings.F-06.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-07 exception for key-person retention gap.", "id": "findings.F-07.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's id from /workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/019_material_contracts_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_litigation/067_litigation_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's issue from /workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/019_material_contracts_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_litigation/067_litigation_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's severity from /workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/019_material_contracts_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_litigation/067_litigation_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's primary_source from /workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/019_material_contracts_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_litigation/067_litigation_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/019_material_contracts_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_litigation/067_litigation_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-07 using the exact controlled facts ['notices-silverline_logistics_lp@example.test', 'archive-switchyard_freight_intelligence_llc@example.test'].", "id": "findings.F-07.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-07's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-07.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-10-02', 'Rafael Okafor'] for F-07.", "id": "findings.F-07.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-08 exception for invention assignment defect.", "id": "findings.F-08.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's id from /workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/022_material_contracts_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_litigation/070_litigation_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's issue from /workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/022_material_contracts_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_litigation/070_litigation_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's severity from /workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/022_material_contracts_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_litigation/070_litigation_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's primary_source from /workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/022_material_contracts_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_litigation/070_litigation_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/022_material_contracts_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_litigation/070_litigation_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-08 using the exact controlled facts ['137 records', '2025-08-20', '70 records', '2025-10-01'].", "id": "findings.F-08.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-08's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-08.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-10-02', 'Nora Chen'] for F-08.", "id": "findings.F-08.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-09 exception for open-source copyleft exposure.", "id": "findings.F-09.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's id from /workspace/documents/04_debt_security/025_debt_security_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_real_property/073_real_property_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's issue from /workspace/documents/04_debt_security/025_debt_security_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_real_property/073_real_property_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's severity from /workspace/documents/04_debt_security/025_debt_security_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_real_property/073_real_property_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's primary_source from /workspace/documents/04_debt_security/025_debt_security_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_real_property/073_real_property_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/04_debt_security/025_debt_security_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_real_property/073_real_property_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-09 using the exact controlled facts ['2025-02-18', 'CB-MA-2409-I326', '2025-03-04', 'CB-MA-2409-R878'].", "id": "findings.F-09.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-09's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-09.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-10-02', 'Dominic Alvarez'] for F-09.", "id": "findings.F-09.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-10 exception for unreported security incident.", "id": "findings.F-10.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's id from /workspace/documents/04_debt_security/028_debt_security_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_real_property/076_real_property_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's issue from /workspace/documents/04_debt_security/028_debt_security_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_real_property/076_real_property_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's severity from /workspace/documents/04_debt_security/028_debt_security_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_real_property/076_real_property_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's primary_source from /workspace/documents/04_debt_security/028_debt_security_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_real_property/076_real_property_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/04_debt_security/028_debt_security_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_real_property/076_real_property_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-10 using the exact controlled facts ['$2,423,977.00', '$2,634,454.00'].", "id": "findings.F-10.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-10's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-10.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-10-02', 'Priya Raman'] for F-10.", "id": "findings.F-10.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-11 exception for permit transfer restriction.", "id": "findings.F-11.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's id from /workspace/documents/04_debt_security/031_debt_security_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_real_property/079_real_property_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's issue from /workspace/documents/04_debt_security/031_debt_security_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_real_property/079_real_property_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's severity from /workspace/documents/04_debt_security/031_debt_security_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_real_property/079_real_property_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's primary_source from /workspace/documents/04_debt_security/031_debt_security_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_real_property/079_real_property_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/04_debt_security/031_debt_security_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_real_property/079_real_property_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-11 using the exact controlled facts ['Willa Novak', 'Rafael Okafor'].", "id": "findings.F-11.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-11's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-11.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-10-02', 'Elliot Mercer'] for F-11.", "id": "findings.F-11.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-12 exception for threatened customer dispute.", "id": "findings.F-12.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's id from /workspace/documents/05_employment/034_employment_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_tax_insurance/082_tax_insurance_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's issue from /workspace/documents/05_employment/034_employment_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_tax_insurance/082_tax_insurance_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's severity from /workspace/documents/05_employment/034_employment_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_tax_insurance/082_tax_insurance_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's primary_source from /workspace/documents/05_employment/034_employment_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_tax_insurance/082_tax_insurance_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/05_employment/034_employment_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_tax_insurance/082_tax_insurance_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-12 using the exact controlled facts ['closed without exception', 'CB-MA-2409-L287', 'open and escalated', 'CB-MA-2409-U875'].", "id": "findings.F-12.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-12's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-12.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-10-02', 'Talia Brooks'] for F-12.", "id": "findings.F-12.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-13 exception for facility title exception.", "id": "findings.F-13.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's id from /workspace/documents/05_employment/037_employment_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_tax_insurance/085_tax_insurance_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's issue from /workspace/documents/05_employment/037_employment_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_tax_insurance/085_tax_insurance_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's severity from /workspace/documents/05_employment/037_employment_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_tax_insurance/085_tax_insurance_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's primary_source from /workspace/documents/05_employment/037_employment_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_tax_insurance/085_tax_insurance_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/05_employment/037_employment_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_tax_insurance/085_tax_insurance_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-13 using the exact controlled facts ['Fulton County, Georgia', 'Georgia'].", "id": "findings.F-13.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-13's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-13.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-10-02', 'Jonas Feld'] for F-13.", "id": "findings.F-13.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-14 exception for sales-tax nexus gap.", "id": "findings.F-14.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's id from /workspace/documents/05_employment/040_employment_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_tax_insurance/088_tax_insurance_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's issue from /workspace/documents/05_employment/040_employment_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_tax_insurance/088_tax_insurance_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's severity from /workspace/documents/05_employment/040_employment_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_tax_insurance/088_tax_insurance_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's primary_source from /workspace/documents/05_employment/040_employment_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_tax_insurance/088_tax_insurance_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/05_employment/040_employment_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_tax_insurance/088_tax_insurance_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-14 using the exact controlled facts ['6%', '8%'].", "id": "findings.F-14.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-14's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-14.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-10-02', 'Mei Whitaker'] for F-14.", "id": "findings.F-14.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-15 exception for claims-made insurance tail.", "id": "findings.F-15.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's id from /workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/043_ip_technology_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_financials/091_financials_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's issue from /workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/043_ip_technology_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_financials/091_financials_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's severity from /workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/043_ip_technology_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_financials/091_financials_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's primary_source from /workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/043_ip_technology_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_financials/091_financials_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/043_ip_technology_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_financials/091_financials_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-15 using the exact controlled facts ['notices-silverline_logistics_lp@example.test', 'archive-switchyard_freight_intelligence_llc@example.test'].", "id": "findings.F-15.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-15's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-15.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-10-02', 'Caleb Hassan'] for F-15.", "id": "findings.F-15.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-16 exception for revenue recognition exception.", "id": "findings.F-16.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's id from /workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/046_ip_technology_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_financials/094_financials_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's issue from /workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/046_ip_technology_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_financials/094_financials_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's severity from /workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/046_ip_technology_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_financials/094_financials_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's primary_source from /workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/046_ip_technology_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_financials/094_financials_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/046_ip_technology_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_financials/094_financials_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-16 using the exact controlled facts ['82 records', '2025-11-13', '59 records', '2025-12-14'].", "id": "findings.F-16.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-16's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-16.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-10-02', 'Leona Park'] for F-16.", "id": "findings.F-16.action_anchors"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Executive assessment' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Executive assessment"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Method and record coverage' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Method and record coverage"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Findings' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Findings"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Recommended next actions' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Recommended next actions"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Assumptions and limitations' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Assumptions and limitations"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-01 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-01"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-02 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-02"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-03 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-03"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-04 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-04"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-05 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-05"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-06 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-06"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-07 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-07"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-08 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-08"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-09 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-09"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-10 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-10"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-11 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-11"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-12 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-12"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-13 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-13"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-14 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-14"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-15 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-15"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-16 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-16"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Do not claim the production has no issues or that every record is consistent.", "id": "memo.forbidden_claims_absent"}], "decision_options": [{"id": "cross-source-reconciliation", "label": "Reconcile controlling and corroborating records", "reason": "The CB-MA-2409 production contains independently maintained records; a defensible answer must preserve each supported conflict and its cure owner.", "selected": true}, {"id": "latest-record-controls", "label": "Treat the latest record as controlling", "reason": "Timestamp recency does not establish legal priority, execution, or approval authority.", "selected": false}, {"id": "primary-records-only", "label": "Report primary records without reconciliation", "reason": "Primary records alone conceal the operational conflicts that create the actionable exceptions.", "selected": false}], "gates": ["all_evidence_read_in_full", "chain_of_custody_metadata_checked", "findings_criteria_complete", "memo_criteria_complete", "deliverables_written_through_mcp"], "metadata_checks": 8, "metric": "weighted_criteria_score", "minimum_tool_calls": 46, "required_deliverables": ["findings.json", "advice.md"], "required_document_reads": 33, "type": "deterministic", "weights": {"findings": 0.55, "memo": 0.2, "procedure": 0.25}}, "task_id": "cb100-009-silverline-logistics", "task_name": "Project Switchyard logistics roll-up", "world_id": "counselbench-filesystem-mcp-v2"}
-{"context_files": ["task_files/cb100-010-verdant-grid/01_corporate/001_corporate_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-010-verdant-grid/01_corporate/002_corporate_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-010-verdant-grid/01_corporate/003_corporate_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-010-verdant-grid/01_corporate/004_corporate_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-010-verdant-grid/01_corporate/005_corporate_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-010-verdant-grid/01_corporate/006_corporate_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-010-verdant-grid/01_corporate/007_corporate_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-010-verdant-grid/01_corporate/008_corporate_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-010-verdant-grid/02_capitalization/009_capitalization_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-010-verdant-grid/02_capitalization/010_capitalization_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-010-verdant-grid/02_capitalization/011_capitalization_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-010-verdant-grid/02_capitalization/012_capitalization_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-010-verdant-grid/02_capitalization/013_capitalization_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-010-verdant-grid/02_capitalization/014_capitalization_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-010-verdant-grid/02_capitalization/015_capitalization_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-010-verdant-grid/02_capitalization/016_capitalization_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-010-verdant-grid/03_material_contracts/017_material_contracts_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-010-verdant-grid/03_material_contracts/018_material_contracts_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-010-verdant-grid/03_material_contracts/019_material_contracts_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-010-verdant-grid/03_material_contracts/020_material_contracts_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-010-verdant-grid/03_material_contracts/021_material_contracts_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-010-verdant-grid/03_material_contracts/022_material_contracts_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-010-verdant-grid/03_material_contracts/023_material_contracts_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-010-verdant-grid/03_material_contracts/024_material_contracts_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-010-verdant-grid/04_debt_security/025_debt_security_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-010-verdant-grid/04_debt_security/026_debt_security_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-010-verdant-grid/04_debt_security/027_debt_security_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-010-verdant-grid/04_debt_security/028_debt_security_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-010-verdant-grid/04_debt_security/029_debt_security_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-010-verdant-grid/04_debt_security/030_debt_security_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-010-verdant-grid/04_debt_security/031_debt_security_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-010-verdant-grid/04_debt_security/032_debt_security_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-010-verdant-grid/05_employment/033_employment_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-010-verdant-grid/05_employment/034_employment_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-010-verdant-grid/05_employment/035_employment_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-010-verdant-grid/05_employment/036_employment_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-010-verdant-grid/05_employment/037_employment_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-010-verdant-grid/05_employment/038_employment_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-010-verdant-grid/05_employment/039_employment_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-010-verdant-grid/05_employment/040_employment_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-010-verdant-grid/06_ip_technology/041_ip_technology_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-010-verdant-grid/06_ip_technology/042_ip_technology_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-010-verdant-grid/06_ip_technology/043_ip_technology_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-010-verdant-grid/06_ip_technology/044_ip_technology_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-010-verdant-grid/06_ip_technology/045_ip_technology_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-010-verdant-grid/06_ip_technology/046_ip_technology_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-010-verdant-grid/06_ip_technology/047_ip_technology_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-010-verdant-grid/06_ip_technology/048_ip_technology_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-010-verdant-grid/07_privacy_security/049_privacy_security_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-010-verdant-grid/07_privacy_security/050_privacy_security_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-010-verdant-grid/07_privacy_security/051_privacy_security_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-010-verdant-grid/07_privacy_security/052_privacy_security_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-010-verdant-grid/07_privacy_security/053_privacy_security_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-010-verdant-grid/07_privacy_security/054_privacy_security_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-010-verdant-grid/07_privacy_security/055_privacy_security_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-010-verdant-grid/07_privacy_security/056_privacy_security_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-010-verdant-grid/08_regulatory/057_regulatory_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-010-verdant-grid/08_regulatory/058_regulatory_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-010-verdant-grid/08_regulatory/059_regulatory_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-010-verdant-grid/08_regulatory/060_regulatory_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-010-verdant-grid/08_regulatory/061_regulatory_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-010-verdant-grid/08_regulatory/062_regulatory_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-010-verdant-grid/08_regulatory/063_regulatory_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-010-verdant-grid/08_regulatory/064_regulatory_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-010-verdant-grid/09_litigation/065_litigation_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-010-verdant-grid/09_litigation/066_litigation_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-010-verdant-grid/09_litigation/067_litigation_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-010-verdant-grid/09_litigation/068_litigation_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-010-verdant-grid/09_litigation/069_litigation_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-010-verdant-grid/09_litigation/070_litigation_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-010-verdant-grid/09_litigation/071_litigation_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-010-verdant-grid/09_litigation/072_litigation_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-010-verdant-grid/10_real_property/073_real_property_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-010-verdant-grid/10_real_property/074_real_property_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-010-verdant-grid/10_real_property/075_real_property_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-010-verdant-grid/10_real_property/076_real_property_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-010-verdant-grid/10_real_property/077_real_property_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-010-verdant-grid/10_real_property/078_real_property_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-010-verdant-grid/10_real_property/079_real_property_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-010-verdant-grid/10_real_property/080_real_property_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-010-verdant-grid/11_tax_insurance/081_tax_insurance_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-010-verdant-grid/11_tax_insurance/082_tax_insurance_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-010-verdant-grid/11_tax_insurance/083_tax_insurance_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-010-verdant-grid/11_tax_insurance/084_tax_insurance_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-010-verdant-grid/11_tax_insurance/085_tax_insurance_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-010-verdant-grid/11_tax_insurance/086_tax_insurance_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-010-verdant-grid/11_tax_insurance/087_tax_insurance_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-010-verdant-grid/11_tax_insurance/088_tax_insurance_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-010-verdant-grid/12_financials/089_financials_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-010-verdant-grid/12_financials/090_financials_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-010-verdant-grid/12_financials/091_financials_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-010-verdant-grid/12_financials/092_financials_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-010-verdant-grid/12_financials/093_financials_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-010-verdant-grid/12_financials/094_financials_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-010-verdant-grid/12_financials/095_financials_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-010-verdant-grid/12_financials/096_financials_status_report.md"], "gold_output": {"advice_markdown": "# Counsel advice — Project Canopy microgrid acquisition\n\n## Executive assessment\n\nFor Verdant Grid Holdings matter CB-MA-2410, the review identified 16 source-supported exceptions requiring action before 2026-10-06. The assessment concerns Canopy Storage Works, Inc. and the supplied record for Delaware.\n\n## Method and record coverage\n\nThe review inventoried all 96 production files, read the 33 controlling, corroborating, and control records, searched the email exports, and checked metadata for the designated chain-of-custody sample. Conclusions are limited to the synthetic production supplied for this benchmark matter.\n\n## Findings\n\n### F-01 — charter authorization mismatch (critical)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for charter authorization mismatch: one source states the operative date is 2025-05-10 under control reference CB-MA-2410-A227, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2025-06-10 under response reference CB-MA-2410-J663.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/01_corporate/001_corporate_control_register.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/07_privacy_security/049_privacy_security_control_register.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-10-06, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Farah Ibrahim.\n\n### F-02 — unrecorded option grant (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for unrecorded option grant: one source states the controlling amount is $4,751,146.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $4,818,792.00.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/01_corporate/004_corporate_ledger_export.csv`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/07_privacy_security/052_privacy_security_ledger_export.csv`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-10-06, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Owen Delgado.\n\n### F-03 — change-of-control consent (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for change-of-control consent: one source states approval is attributed to Theo Laurent as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Isaac Romero and contains no entry for Theo Laurent.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/01_corporate/007_corporate_officer_certificate.html`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/07_privacy_security/055_privacy_security_officer_certificate.html`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-10-06, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Lena Varga.\n\n### F-04 — anti-assignment restriction (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for anti-assignment restriction: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-MA-2410-D102, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-MA-2410-M584.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/02_capitalization/010_capitalization_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/08_regulatory/058_regulatory_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-10-06, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Samuel Kim.\n\n### F-05 — most-favored-customer exposure (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for most-favored-customer exposure: one source states the applicable location is Maricopa County, Arizona, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to Delaware operations outside Maricopa County, Arizona.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/02_capitalization/013_capitalization_review_memorandum.json`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/08_regulatory/061_regulatory_review_memorandum.json`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-10-06, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Maya Ellison.\n\n### F-06 — financial covenant breach (low)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for financial covenant breach: one source states the threshold is 14% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 20% and produced a different exception result.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/02_capitalization/016_capitalization_status_report.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/08_regulatory/064_regulatory_status_report.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-10-06, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Rafael Okafor.\n\n### F-07 — key-person retention gap (critical)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for key-person retention gap: one source states formal notice must use notices-verdant_grid_holdings@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-canopy_storage_works_inc@example.test.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/019_material_contracts_correspondence.eml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/09_litigation/067_litigation_correspondence.eml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-10-06, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Nora Chen.\n\n### F-08 — invention assignment defect (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for invention assignment defect: one source states the governed population contains 185 records through 2025-10-07, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 65 records through 2025-11-13.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/022_material_contracts_formal_notice.xml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/09_litigation/070_litigation_formal_notice.xml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-10-06, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Dominic Alvarez.\n\n### F-09 — open-source copyleft exposure (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for open-source copyleft exposure: one source states the operative date is 2025-01-07 under control reference CB-MA-2410-I464, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2025-01-19 under response reference CB-MA-2410-R266.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/04_debt_security/025_debt_security_control_register.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/10_real_property/073_real_property_control_register.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-10-06, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Priya Raman.\n\n### F-10 — unreported security incident (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for unreported security incident: one source states the controlling amount is $2,831,676.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $2,889,852.00.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/04_debt_security/028_debt_security_ledger_export.csv`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/10_real_property/076_real_property_ledger_export.csv`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-10-06, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Elliot Mercer.\n\n### F-11 — permit transfer restriction (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for permit transfer restriction: one source states approval is attributed to Theo Laurent as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Dominic Alvarez and contains no entry for Theo Laurent.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/04_debt_security/031_debt_security_officer_certificate.html`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/10_real_property/079_real_property_officer_certificate.html`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-10-06, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Talia Brooks.\n\n### F-12 — threatened customer dispute (low)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for threatened customer dispute: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-MA-2410-L852, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-MA-2410-U365.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/05_employment/034_employment_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/11_tax_insurance/082_tax_insurance_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-10-06, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Jonas Feld.\n\n### F-13 — facility title exception (critical)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for facility title exception: one source states the applicable location is Maricopa County, Arizona, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to Delaware operations outside Maricopa County, Arizona.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/05_employment/037_employment_review_memorandum.json`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/11_tax_insurance/085_tax_insurance_review_memorandum.json`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-10-06, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Mei Whitaker.\n\n### F-14 — sales-tax nexus gap (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for sales-tax nexus gap: one source states the threshold is 4% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 10% and produced a different exception result.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/05_employment/040_employment_status_report.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/11_tax_insurance/088_tax_insurance_status_report.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-10-06, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Caleb Hassan.\n\n### F-15 — claims-made insurance tail (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for claims-made insurance tail: one source states formal notice must use notices-verdant_grid_holdings@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-canopy_storage_works_inc@example.test.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/043_ip_technology_correspondence.eml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/12_financials/091_financials_correspondence.eml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-10-06, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Leona Park.\n\n### F-16 — revenue recognition exception (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for revenue recognition exception: one source states the governed population contains 138 records through 2025-08-21, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 61 records through 2025-09-23.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/046_ip_technology_formal_notice.xml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/12_financials/094_financials_formal_notice.xml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-10-06, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Isaac Romero.\n\n## Recommended next actions\n\nSequence the critical and high findings first, assign the named owners, preserve the cited records, and document any resolution in the controlling matter register before the stated deadline.\n\n## Assumptions and limitations\n\nThis analysis is confined to task cb100-010-verdant-grid and the supplied synthetic evidence. It does not rely on external facts, does not resolve disputed law, and is not legal advice for a real person or entity.\n", "findings": {"as_of": "2026-10-06", "findings": [{"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/07_privacy_security/049_privacy_security_control_register.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for charter authorization mismatch: one source states the operative date is 2025-05-10 under control reference CB-MA-2410-A227, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2025-06-10 under response reference CB-MA-2410-J663.", "id": "F-01", "issue": "charter authorization mismatch", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/01_corporate/001_corporate_control_register.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-10-06, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Farah Ibrahim.", "severity": "critical"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/07_privacy_security/052_privacy_security_ledger_export.csv", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for unrecorded option grant: one source states the controlling amount is $4,751,146.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $4,818,792.00.", "id": "F-02", "issue": "unrecorded option grant", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/01_corporate/004_corporate_ledger_export.csv", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-10-06, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Owen Delgado.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/07_privacy_security/055_privacy_security_officer_certificate.html", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for change-of-control consent: one source states approval is attributed to Theo Laurent as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Isaac Romero and contains no entry for Theo Laurent.", "id": "F-03", "issue": "change-of-control consent", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/01_corporate/007_corporate_officer_certificate.html", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-10-06, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Lena Varga.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/08_regulatory/058_regulatory_executed_instrument.txt", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for anti-assignment restriction: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-MA-2410-D102, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-MA-2410-M584.", "id": "F-04", "issue": "anti-assignment restriction", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/02_capitalization/010_capitalization_executed_instrument.txt", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-10-06, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Samuel Kim.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/08_regulatory/061_regulatory_review_memorandum.json", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for most-favored-customer exposure: one source states the applicable location is Maricopa County, Arizona, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to Delaware operations outside Maricopa County, Arizona.", "id": "F-05", "issue": "most-favored-customer exposure", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/02_capitalization/013_capitalization_review_memorandum.json", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-10-06, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Maya Ellison.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/08_regulatory/064_regulatory_status_report.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for financial covenant breach: one source states the threshold is 14% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 20% and produced a different exception result.", "id": "F-06", "issue": "financial covenant breach", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/02_capitalization/016_capitalization_status_report.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-10-06, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Rafael Okafor.", "severity": "low"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/09_litigation/067_litigation_correspondence.eml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for key-person retention gap: one source states formal notice must use notices-verdant_grid_holdings@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-canopy_storage_works_inc@example.test.", "id": "F-07", "issue": "key-person retention gap", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/019_material_contracts_correspondence.eml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-10-06, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Nora Chen.", "severity": "critical"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/09_litigation/070_litigation_formal_notice.xml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for invention assignment defect: one source states the governed population contains 185 records through 2025-10-07, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 65 records through 2025-11-13.", "id": "F-08", "issue": "invention assignment defect", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/022_material_contracts_formal_notice.xml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-10-06, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Dominic Alvarez.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/10_real_property/073_real_property_control_register.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for open-source copyleft exposure: one source states the operative date is 2025-01-07 under control reference CB-MA-2410-I464, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2025-01-19 under response reference CB-MA-2410-R266.", "id": "F-09", "issue": "open-source copyleft exposure", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/04_debt_security/025_debt_security_control_register.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-10-06, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Priya Raman.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/10_real_property/076_real_property_ledger_export.csv", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for unreported security incident: one source states the controlling amount is $2,831,676.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $2,889,852.00.", "id": "F-10", "issue": "unreported security incident", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/04_debt_security/028_debt_security_ledger_export.csv", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-10-06, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Elliot Mercer.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/10_real_property/079_real_property_officer_certificate.html", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for permit transfer restriction: one source states approval is attributed to Theo Laurent as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Dominic Alvarez and contains no entry for Theo Laurent.", "id": "F-11", "issue": "permit transfer restriction", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/04_debt_security/031_debt_security_officer_certificate.html", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-10-06, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Talia Brooks.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/11_tax_insurance/082_tax_insurance_executed_instrument.txt", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for threatened customer dispute: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-MA-2410-L852, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-MA-2410-U365.", "id": "F-12", "issue": "threatened customer dispute", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/05_employment/034_employment_executed_instrument.txt", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-10-06, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Jonas Feld.", "severity": "low"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/11_tax_insurance/085_tax_insurance_review_memorandum.json", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for facility title exception: one source states the applicable location is Maricopa County, Arizona, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to Delaware operations outside Maricopa County, Arizona.", "id": "F-13", "issue": "facility title exception", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/05_employment/037_employment_review_memorandum.json", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-10-06, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Mei Whitaker.", "severity": "critical"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/11_tax_insurance/088_tax_insurance_status_report.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for sales-tax nexus gap: one source states the threshold is 4% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 10% and produced a different exception result.", "id": "F-14", "issue": "sales-tax nexus gap", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/05_employment/040_employment_status_report.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-10-06, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Caleb Hassan.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/12_financials/091_financials_correspondence.eml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for claims-made insurance tail: one source states formal notice must use notices-verdant_grid_holdings@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-canopy_storage_works_inc@example.test.", "id": "F-15", "issue": "claims-made insurance tail", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/043_ip_technology_correspondence.eml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-10-06, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Leona Park.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/12_financials/094_financials_formal_notice.xml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for revenue recognition exception: one source states the governed population contains 138 records through 2025-08-21, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 61 records through 2025-09-23.", "id": "F-16", "issue": "revenue recognition exception", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/046_ip_technology_formal_notice.xml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-10-06, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Isaac Romero.", "severity": "medium"}], "matter_number": "CB-MA-2410", "prepared_for": "Verdant Grid Holdings", "schema_version": "1.0", "task_id": "cb100-010-verdant-grid"}}, "metadata": {"benchmark": "CounselBench-100", "code_license": "Apache-2.0", "data_license": "CC-BY-4.0", "deadline": "2026-10-06", "document_count": 96, "jurisdiction": "Delaware", "matter_number": "CB-MA-2410", "mcp_commit": "9a96ea6e5913736f92b88345bf51caeaaa8e719f", "mcp_package": "@modelcontextprotocol/server-filesystem@2026.7.10", "practice_area": "corporate-ma", "reference_tool_calls": 46, "required_evidence_reads": 33, "synthetic": true, "venue": "Maricopa County, Arizona", "version": "2.0.0"}, "prompt": "You are buyer-side transactions counsel for Verdant Grid Holdings. The record contains amendments, exports, and correspondence from different custodians; reconcile them into an actionable counsel work product. The target assembles storage systems under state incentives, leases desert test acreage, and may have recognized milestone revenue before customer acceptance. Decision due 2026-10-06. Delaware law governs; Maricopa County, Arizona is the forum. Write for a supervising lawyer who will spot-check source paths and exact values. Work out the defensible position from the matter production and leave an audit-ready exception tracker and concise advice for the supervising lawyer. Keep confirmed conflicts separate from open questions, cite the records that actually control each conclusion, and do not fill gaps with outside facts.", "rubric": {"criteria": [{"category": "procedure", "description": "Complete at least 46 successful, argument-specific evidence and output calls.", "id": "procedure.minimum_successful_tool_calls"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Find and read the 33 controlling, corroborating, and work-product-control records in full.", "id": "procedure.all_evidence_read_in_full"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Inspect file metadata for the eight designated critical primary records before relying on them.", "id": "procedure.chain_of_custody_metadata_checked"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Confirm the sandbox's allowed document and output roots.", "id": "procedure.allowed_directories_checked"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Inventory all 96 records so the relevant sources are discovered among the context records.", "id": "procedure.recursive_inventory_completed"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Search the production for email evidence that may corroborate or contradict formal records.", "id": "procedure.targeted_search_completed"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Leave only findings.json and advice.md in the output workspace.", "id": "procedure.exact_deliverable_set"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Create both final work products through the sandbox MCP surface.", "id": "procedure.deliverables_written_through_mcp"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Produce findings.json as a valid JSON object.", "id": "findings.findings_is_object"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Report exactly 16 confirmed exceptions.", "id": "findings.findings_exact_count"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Use each stable finding ID exactly once.", "id": "findings.finding_ids_unique"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set schema_version to the released matter value '1.0'.", "id": "findings.top_level_schema_version"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set task_id to the released matter value 'cb100-010-verdant-grid'.", "id": "findings.top_level_task_id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set matter_number to the released matter value 'CB-MA-2410'.", "id": "findings.top_level_matter_number"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set prepared_for to the released matter value 'Verdant Grid Holdings'.", "id": "findings.top_level_prepared_for"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set as_of to the released matter value '2026-10-06'.", "id": "findings.top_level_as_of"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-01 exception for charter authorization mismatch.", "id": "findings.F-01.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's id from /workspace/documents/01_corporate/001_corporate_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_privacy_security/049_privacy_security_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's issue from /workspace/documents/01_corporate/001_corporate_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_privacy_security/049_privacy_security_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's severity from /workspace/documents/01_corporate/001_corporate_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_privacy_security/049_privacy_security_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's primary_source from /workspace/documents/01_corporate/001_corporate_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_privacy_security/049_privacy_security_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/01_corporate/001_corporate_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_privacy_security/049_privacy_security_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-01 using the exact controlled facts ['2025-05-10', 'CB-MA-2410-A227', '2025-06-10', 'CB-MA-2410-J663'].", "id": "findings.F-01.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-01's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-01.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-10-06', 'Farah Ibrahim'] for F-01.", "id": "findings.F-01.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-02 exception for unrecorded option grant.", "id": "findings.F-02.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's id from /workspace/documents/01_corporate/004_corporate_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_privacy_security/052_privacy_security_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's issue from /workspace/documents/01_corporate/004_corporate_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_privacy_security/052_privacy_security_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's severity from /workspace/documents/01_corporate/004_corporate_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_privacy_security/052_privacy_security_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's primary_source from /workspace/documents/01_corporate/004_corporate_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_privacy_security/052_privacy_security_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/01_corporate/004_corporate_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_privacy_security/052_privacy_security_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-02 using the exact controlled facts ['$4,751,146.00', '$4,818,792.00'].", "id": "findings.F-02.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-02's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-02.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-10-06', 'Owen Delgado'] for F-02.", "id": "findings.F-02.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-03 exception for change-of-control consent.", "id": "findings.F-03.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's id from /workspace/documents/01_corporate/007_corporate_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_privacy_security/055_privacy_security_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's issue from /workspace/documents/01_corporate/007_corporate_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_privacy_security/055_privacy_security_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's severity from /workspace/documents/01_corporate/007_corporate_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_privacy_security/055_privacy_security_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's primary_source from /workspace/documents/01_corporate/007_corporate_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_privacy_security/055_privacy_security_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/01_corporate/007_corporate_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_privacy_security/055_privacy_security_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-03 using the exact controlled facts ['Theo Laurent', 'Isaac Romero'].", "id": "findings.F-03.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-03's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-03.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-10-06', 'Lena Varga'] for F-03.", "id": "findings.F-03.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-04 exception for anti-assignment restriction.", "id": "findings.F-04.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's id from /workspace/documents/02_capitalization/010_capitalization_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_regulatory/058_regulatory_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's issue from /workspace/documents/02_capitalization/010_capitalization_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_regulatory/058_regulatory_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's severity from /workspace/documents/02_capitalization/010_capitalization_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_regulatory/058_regulatory_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's primary_source from /workspace/documents/02_capitalization/010_capitalization_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_regulatory/058_regulatory_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/02_capitalization/010_capitalization_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_regulatory/058_regulatory_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-04 using the exact controlled facts ['closed without exception', 'CB-MA-2410-D102', 'open and escalated', 'CB-MA-2410-M584'].", "id": "findings.F-04.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-04's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-04.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-10-06', 'Samuel Kim'] for F-04.", "id": "findings.F-04.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-05 exception for most-favored-customer exposure.", "id": "findings.F-05.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's id from /workspace/documents/02_capitalization/013_capitalization_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_regulatory/061_regulatory_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's issue from /workspace/documents/02_capitalization/013_capitalization_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_regulatory/061_regulatory_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's severity from /workspace/documents/02_capitalization/013_capitalization_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_regulatory/061_regulatory_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's primary_source from /workspace/documents/02_capitalization/013_capitalization_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_regulatory/061_regulatory_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/02_capitalization/013_capitalization_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_regulatory/061_regulatory_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-05 using the exact controlled facts ['Maricopa County, Arizona', 'Delaware'].", "id": "findings.F-05.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-05's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-05.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-10-06', 'Maya Ellison'] for F-05.", "id": "findings.F-05.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-06 exception for financial covenant breach.", "id": "findings.F-06.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's id from /workspace/documents/02_capitalization/016_capitalization_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_regulatory/064_regulatory_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's issue from /workspace/documents/02_capitalization/016_capitalization_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_regulatory/064_regulatory_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's severity from /workspace/documents/02_capitalization/016_capitalization_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_regulatory/064_regulatory_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's primary_source from /workspace/documents/02_capitalization/016_capitalization_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_regulatory/064_regulatory_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/02_capitalization/016_capitalization_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_regulatory/064_regulatory_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-06 using the exact controlled facts ['14%', '20%'].", "id": "findings.F-06.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-06's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-06.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-10-06', 'Rafael Okafor'] for F-06.", "id": "findings.F-06.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-07 exception for key-person retention gap.", "id": "findings.F-07.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's id from /workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/019_material_contracts_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_litigation/067_litigation_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's issue from /workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/019_material_contracts_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_litigation/067_litigation_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's severity from /workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/019_material_contracts_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_litigation/067_litigation_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's primary_source from /workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/019_material_contracts_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_litigation/067_litigation_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/019_material_contracts_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_litigation/067_litigation_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-07 using the exact controlled facts ['notices-verdant_grid_holdings@example.test', 'archive-canopy_storage_works_inc@example.test'].", "id": "findings.F-07.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-07's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-07.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-10-06', 'Nora Chen'] for F-07.", "id": "findings.F-07.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-08 exception for invention assignment defect.", "id": "findings.F-08.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's id from /workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/022_material_contracts_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_litigation/070_litigation_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's issue from /workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/022_material_contracts_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_litigation/070_litigation_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's severity from /workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/022_material_contracts_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_litigation/070_litigation_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's primary_source from /workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/022_material_contracts_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_litigation/070_litigation_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/022_material_contracts_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_litigation/070_litigation_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-08 using the exact controlled facts ['185 records', '2025-10-07', '65 records', '2025-11-13'].", "id": "findings.F-08.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-08's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-08.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-10-06', 'Dominic Alvarez'] for F-08.", "id": "findings.F-08.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-09 exception for open-source copyleft exposure.", "id": "findings.F-09.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's id from /workspace/documents/04_debt_security/025_debt_security_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_real_property/073_real_property_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's issue from /workspace/documents/04_debt_security/025_debt_security_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_real_property/073_real_property_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's severity from /workspace/documents/04_debt_security/025_debt_security_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_real_property/073_real_property_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's primary_source from /workspace/documents/04_debt_security/025_debt_security_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_real_property/073_real_property_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/04_debt_security/025_debt_security_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_real_property/073_real_property_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-09 using the exact controlled facts ['2025-01-07', 'CB-MA-2410-I464', '2025-01-19', 'CB-MA-2410-R266'].", "id": "findings.F-09.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-09's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-09.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-10-06', 'Priya Raman'] for F-09.", "id": "findings.F-09.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-10 exception for unreported security incident.", "id": "findings.F-10.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's id from /workspace/documents/04_debt_security/028_debt_security_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_real_property/076_real_property_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's issue from /workspace/documents/04_debt_security/028_debt_security_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_real_property/076_real_property_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's severity from /workspace/documents/04_debt_security/028_debt_security_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_real_property/076_real_property_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's primary_source from /workspace/documents/04_debt_security/028_debt_security_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_real_property/076_real_property_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/04_debt_security/028_debt_security_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_real_property/076_real_property_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-10 using the exact controlled facts ['$2,831,676.00', '$2,889,852.00'].", "id": "findings.F-10.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-10's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-10.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-10-06', 'Elliot Mercer'] for F-10.", "id": "findings.F-10.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-11 exception for permit transfer restriction.", "id": "findings.F-11.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's id from /workspace/documents/04_debt_security/031_debt_security_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_real_property/079_real_property_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's issue from /workspace/documents/04_debt_security/031_debt_security_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_real_property/079_real_property_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's severity from /workspace/documents/04_debt_security/031_debt_security_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_real_property/079_real_property_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's primary_source from /workspace/documents/04_debt_security/031_debt_security_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_real_property/079_real_property_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/04_debt_security/031_debt_security_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_real_property/079_real_property_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-11 using the exact controlled facts ['Theo Laurent', 'Dominic Alvarez'].", "id": "findings.F-11.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-11's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-11.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-10-06', 'Talia Brooks'] for F-11.", "id": "findings.F-11.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-12 exception for threatened customer dispute.", "id": "findings.F-12.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's id from /workspace/documents/05_employment/034_employment_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_tax_insurance/082_tax_insurance_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's issue from /workspace/documents/05_employment/034_employment_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_tax_insurance/082_tax_insurance_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's severity from /workspace/documents/05_employment/034_employment_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_tax_insurance/082_tax_insurance_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's primary_source from /workspace/documents/05_employment/034_employment_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_tax_insurance/082_tax_insurance_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/05_employment/034_employment_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_tax_insurance/082_tax_insurance_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-12 using the exact controlled facts ['closed without exception', 'CB-MA-2410-L852', 'open and escalated', 'CB-MA-2410-U365'].", "id": "findings.F-12.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-12's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-12.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-10-06', 'Jonas Feld'] for F-12.", "id": "findings.F-12.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-13 exception for facility title exception.", "id": "findings.F-13.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's id from /workspace/documents/05_employment/037_employment_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_tax_insurance/085_tax_insurance_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's issue from /workspace/documents/05_employment/037_employment_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_tax_insurance/085_tax_insurance_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's severity from /workspace/documents/05_employment/037_employment_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_tax_insurance/085_tax_insurance_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's primary_source from /workspace/documents/05_employment/037_employment_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_tax_insurance/085_tax_insurance_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/05_employment/037_employment_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_tax_insurance/085_tax_insurance_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-13 using the exact controlled facts ['Maricopa County, Arizona', 'Delaware'].", "id": "findings.F-13.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-13's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-13.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-10-06', 'Mei Whitaker'] for F-13.", "id": "findings.F-13.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-14 exception for sales-tax nexus gap.", "id": "findings.F-14.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's id from /workspace/documents/05_employment/040_employment_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_tax_insurance/088_tax_insurance_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's issue from /workspace/documents/05_employment/040_employment_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_tax_insurance/088_tax_insurance_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's severity from /workspace/documents/05_employment/040_employment_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_tax_insurance/088_tax_insurance_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's primary_source from /workspace/documents/05_employment/040_employment_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_tax_insurance/088_tax_insurance_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/05_employment/040_employment_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_tax_insurance/088_tax_insurance_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-14 using the exact controlled facts ['4%', '10%'].", "id": "findings.F-14.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-14's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-14.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-10-06', 'Caleb Hassan'] for F-14.", "id": "findings.F-14.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-15 exception for claims-made insurance tail.", "id": "findings.F-15.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's id from /workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/043_ip_technology_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_financials/091_financials_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's issue from /workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/043_ip_technology_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_financials/091_financials_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's severity from /workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/043_ip_technology_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_financials/091_financials_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's primary_source from /workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/043_ip_technology_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_financials/091_financials_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/043_ip_technology_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_financials/091_financials_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-15 using the exact controlled facts ['notices-verdant_grid_holdings@example.test', 'archive-canopy_storage_works_inc@example.test'].", "id": "findings.F-15.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-15's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-15.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-10-06', 'Leona Park'] for F-15.", "id": "findings.F-15.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-16 exception for revenue recognition exception.", "id": "findings.F-16.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's id from /workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/046_ip_technology_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_financials/094_financials_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's issue from /workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/046_ip_technology_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_financials/094_financials_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's severity from /workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/046_ip_technology_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_financials/094_financials_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's primary_source from /workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/046_ip_technology_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_financials/094_financials_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/046_ip_technology_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_financials/094_financials_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-16 using the exact controlled facts ['138 records', '2025-08-21', '61 records', '2025-09-23'].", "id": "findings.F-16.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-16's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-16.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-10-06', 'Isaac Romero'] for F-16.", "id": "findings.F-16.action_anchors"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Executive assessment' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Executive assessment"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Method and record coverage' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Method and record coverage"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Findings' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Findings"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Recommended next actions' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Recommended next actions"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Assumptions and limitations' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Assumptions and limitations"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-01 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-01"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-02 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-02"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-03 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-03"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-04 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-04"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-05 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-05"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-06 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-06"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-07 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-07"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-08 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-08"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-09 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-09"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-10 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-10"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-11 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-11"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-12 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-12"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-13 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-13"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-14 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-14"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-15 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-15"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-16 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-16"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Do not claim the production has no issues or that every record is consistent.", "id": "memo.forbidden_claims_absent"}], "decision_options": [{"id": "cross-source-reconciliation", "label": "Reconcile controlling and corroborating records", "reason": "The CB-MA-2410 production contains independently maintained records; a defensible answer must preserve each supported conflict and its cure owner.", "selected": true}, {"id": "latest-record-controls", "label": "Treat the latest record as controlling", "reason": "Timestamp recency does not establish legal priority, execution, or approval authority.", "selected": false}, {"id": "primary-records-only", "label": "Report primary records without reconciliation", "reason": "Primary records alone conceal the operational conflicts that create the actionable exceptions.", "selected": false}], "gates": ["all_evidence_read_in_full", "chain_of_custody_metadata_checked", "findings_criteria_complete", "memo_criteria_complete", "deliverables_written_through_mcp"], "metadata_checks": 8, "metric": "weighted_criteria_score", "minimum_tool_calls": 46, "required_deliverables": ["findings.json", "advice.md"], "required_document_reads": 33, "type": "deterministic", "weights": {"findings": 0.55, "memo": 0.2, "procedure": 0.25}}, "task_id": "cb100-010-verdant-grid", "task_name": "Project Canopy microgrid acquisition", "world_id": "counselbench-filesystem-mcp-v2"}
-{"context_files": ["task_files/cb100-011-atlas-fiber/01_master_agreements/001_master_agreements_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-011-atlas-fiber/01_master_agreements/002_master_agreements_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-011-atlas-fiber/01_master_agreements/003_master_agreements_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-011-atlas-fiber/01_master_agreements/004_master_agreements_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-011-atlas-fiber/01_master_agreements/005_master_agreements_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-011-atlas-fiber/01_master_agreements/006_master_agreements_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-011-atlas-fiber/01_master_agreements/007_master_agreements_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-011-atlas-fiber/01_master_agreements/008_master_agreements_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-011-atlas-fiber/02_order_forms/009_order_forms_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-011-atlas-fiber/02_order_forms/010_order_forms_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-011-atlas-fiber/02_order_forms/011_order_forms_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-011-atlas-fiber/02_order_forms/012_order_forms_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-011-atlas-fiber/02_order_forms/013_order_forms_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-011-atlas-fiber/02_order_forms/014_order_forms_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-011-atlas-fiber/02_order_forms/015_order_forms_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-011-atlas-fiber/02_order_forms/016_order_forms_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-011-atlas-fiber/03_amendments/017_amendments_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-011-atlas-fiber/03_amendments/018_amendments_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-011-atlas-fiber/03_amendments/019_amendments_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-011-atlas-fiber/03_amendments/020_amendments_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-011-atlas-fiber/03_amendments/021_amendments_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-011-atlas-fiber/03_amendments/022_amendments_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-011-atlas-fiber/03_amendments/023_amendments_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-011-atlas-fiber/03_amendments/024_amendments_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-011-atlas-fiber/04_statements_of_work/025_statements_of_work_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-011-atlas-fiber/04_statements_of_work/026_statements_of_work_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-011-atlas-fiber/04_statements_of_work/027_statements_of_work_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-011-atlas-fiber/04_statements_of_work/028_statements_of_work_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-011-atlas-fiber/04_statements_of_work/029_statements_of_work_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-011-atlas-fiber/04_statements_of_work/030_statements_of_work_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-011-atlas-fiber/04_statements_of_work/031_statements_of_work_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-011-atlas-fiber/04_statements_of_work/032_statements_of_work_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-011-atlas-fiber/05_pricing/033_pricing_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-011-atlas-fiber/05_pricing/034_pricing_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-011-atlas-fiber/05_pricing/035_pricing_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-011-atlas-fiber/05_pricing/036_pricing_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-011-atlas-fiber/05_pricing/037_pricing_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-011-atlas-fiber/05_pricing/038_pricing_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-011-atlas-fiber/05_pricing/039_pricing_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-011-atlas-fiber/05_pricing/040_pricing_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-011-atlas-fiber/06_service_levels/041_service_levels_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-011-atlas-fiber/06_service_levels/042_service_levels_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-011-atlas-fiber/06_service_levels/043_service_levels_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-011-atlas-fiber/06_service_levels/044_service_levels_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-011-atlas-fiber/06_service_levels/045_service_levels_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-011-atlas-fiber/06_service_levels/046_service_levels_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-011-atlas-fiber/06_service_levels/047_service_levels_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-011-atlas-fiber/06_service_levels/048_service_levels_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-011-atlas-fiber/07_security_privacy/049_security_privacy_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-011-atlas-fiber/07_security_privacy/050_security_privacy_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-011-atlas-fiber/07_security_privacy/051_security_privacy_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-011-atlas-fiber/07_security_privacy/052_security_privacy_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-011-atlas-fiber/07_security_privacy/053_security_privacy_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-011-atlas-fiber/07_security_privacy/054_security_privacy_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-011-atlas-fiber/07_security_privacy/055_security_privacy_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-011-atlas-fiber/07_security_privacy/056_security_privacy_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-011-atlas-fiber/08_notices/057_notices_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-011-atlas-fiber/08_notices/058_notices_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-011-atlas-fiber/08_notices/059_notices_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-011-atlas-fiber/08_notices/060_notices_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-011-atlas-fiber/08_notices/061_notices_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-011-atlas-fiber/08_notices/062_notices_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-011-atlas-fiber/08_notices/063_notices_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-011-atlas-fiber/08_notices/064_notices_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-011-atlas-fiber/09_invoices/065_invoices_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-011-atlas-fiber/09_invoices/066_invoices_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-011-atlas-fiber/09_invoices/067_invoices_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-011-atlas-fiber/09_invoices/068_invoices_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-011-atlas-fiber/09_invoices/069_invoices_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-011-atlas-fiber/09_invoices/070_invoices_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-011-atlas-fiber/09_invoices/071_invoices_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-011-atlas-fiber/09_invoices/072_invoices_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-011-atlas-fiber/10_correspondence/073_correspondence_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-011-atlas-fiber/10_correspondence/074_correspondence_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-011-atlas-fiber/10_correspondence/075_correspondence_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-011-atlas-fiber/10_correspondence/076_correspondence_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-011-atlas-fiber/10_correspondence/077_correspondence_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-011-atlas-fiber/10_correspondence/078_correspondence_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-011-atlas-fiber/10_correspondence/079_correspondence_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-011-atlas-fiber/10_correspondence/080_correspondence_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-011-atlas-fiber/11_policies/081_policies_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-011-atlas-fiber/11_policies/082_policies_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-011-atlas-fiber/11_policies/083_policies_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-011-atlas-fiber/11_policies/084_policies_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-011-atlas-fiber/11_policies/085_policies_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-011-atlas-fiber/11_policies/086_policies_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-011-atlas-fiber/11_policies/087_policies_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-011-atlas-fiber/11_policies/088_policies_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-011-atlas-fiber/12_renewal_records/089_renewal_records_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-011-atlas-fiber/12_renewal_records/090_renewal_records_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-011-atlas-fiber/12_renewal_records/091_renewal_records_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-011-atlas-fiber/12_renewal_records/092_renewal_records_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-011-atlas-fiber/12_renewal_records/093_renewal_records_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-011-atlas-fiber/12_renewal_records/094_renewal_records_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-011-atlas-fiber/12_renewal_records/095_renewal_records_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-011-atlas-fiber/12_renewal_records/096_renewal_records_status_report.md"], "gold_output": {"advice_markdown": "# Counsel advice — Atlas Fiber enterprise customer reset\n\n## Executive assessment\n\nFor Atlas Fiber Networks matter CB-CC-2501, the review identified 16 source-supported exceptions requiring action before 2026-09-03. The assessment concerns Juniper Peak Retail Group and the supplied record for Colorado.\n\n## Method and record coverage\n\nThe review inventoried all 96 production files, read the 33 controlling, corroborating, and control records, searched the email exports, and checked metadata for the designated chain-of-custody sample. Conclusions are limited to the synthetic production supplied for this benchmark matter.\n\n## Findings\n\n### F-01 — renewal date conflict (critical)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for renewal date conflict: one source states the operative date is 2025-06-24 under control reference CB-CC-2501-A872, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2025-08-09 under response reference CB-CC-2501-J920.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/001_master_agreements_control_register.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/07_security_privacy/049_security_privacy_control_register.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-03, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Owen Delgado.\n\n### F-02 — pricing-escalator mismatch (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for pricing-escalator mismatch: one source states the controlling amount is $1,233,052.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $1,432,604.00.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/004_master_agreements_ledger_export.csv`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/07_security_privacy/052_security_privacy_ledger_export.csv`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-03, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Lena Varga.\n\n### F-03 — minimum-commit shortfall (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for minimum-commit shortfall: one source states approval is attributed to Amara Patel as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Adrian Mensah and contains no entry for Amara Patel.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/007_master_agreements_officer_certificate.html`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/07_security_privacy/055_security_privacy_officer_certificate.html`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-03, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Samuel Kim.\n\n### F-04 — service-credit underpayment (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for service-credit underpayment: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-CC-2501-D376, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-CC-2501-M744.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/02_order_forms/010_order_forms_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/08_notices/058_notices_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-03, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Maya Ellison.\n\n### F-05 — termination notice defect (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for termination notice defect: one source states the applicable location is Denver, Colorado, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to Colorado operations outside Denver, Colorado.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/02_order_forms/013_order_forms_review_memorandum.json`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/08_notices/061_notices_review_memorandum.json`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-03, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Rafael Okafor.\n\n### F-06 — assignment consent requirement (low)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for assignment consent requirement: one source states the threshold is 10% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 14% and produced a different exception result.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/02_order_forms/016_order_forms_status_report.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/08_notices/064_notices_status_report.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-03, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Nora Chen.\n\n### F-07 — data-localization conflict (critical)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for data-localization conflict: one source states formal notice must use notices-atlas_fiber_networks@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-juniper_peak_retail_group@example.test.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/03_amendments/019_amendments_correspondence.eml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/09_invoices/067_invoices_correspondence.eml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-03, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Dominic Alvarez.\n\n### F-08 — subprocessor notice lapse (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for subprocessor notice lapse: one source states the governed population contains 181 records through 2025-05-16, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 46 records through 2025-06-03.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/03_amendments/022_amendments_formal_notice.xml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/09_invoices/070_invoices_formal_notice.xml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-03, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Priya Raman.\n\n### F-09 — insurance-limit deficiency (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for insurance-limit deficiency: one source states the operative date is 2025-11-14 under control reference CB-CC-2501-I655, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2025-12-13 under response reference CB-CC-2501-R696.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/025_statements_of_work_control_register.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/10_correspondence/073_correspondence_control_register.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-03, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Elliot Mercer.\n\n### F-10 — audit-right deadline (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for audit-right deadline: one source states the controlling amount is $1,553,045.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $1,652,590.00.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/028_statements_of_work_ledger_export.csv`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/10_correspondence/076_correspondence_ledger_export.csv`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-03, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Talia Brooks.\n\n### F-11 — exclusivity carveout breach (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for exclusivity carveout breach: one source states approval is attributed to Amara Patel as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Elliot Mercer and contains no entry for Amara Patel.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/031_statements_of_work_officer_certificate.html`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/10_correspondence/079_correspondence_officer_certificate.html`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-03, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Jonas Feld.\n\n### F-12 — benchmarking right omission (low)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for benchmarking right omission: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-CC-2501-L353, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-CC-2501-U534.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/05_pricing/034_pricing_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/11_policies/082_policies_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-03, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Mei Whitaker.\n\n### F-13 — invoice currency discrepancy (critical)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for invoice currency discrepancy: one source states the applicable location is Denver, Colorado, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to Colorado operations outside Denver, Colorado.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/05_pricing/037_pricing_review_memorandum.json`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/11_policies/085_policies_review_memorandum.json`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-03, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Caleb Hassan.\n\n### F-14 — usage-report inconsistency (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for usage-report inconsistency: one source states the threshold is 6% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 12% and produced a different exception result.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/05_pricing/040_pricing_status_report.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/11_policies/088_policies_status_report.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-03, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Leona Park.\n\n### F-15 — order-form precedence conflict (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for order-form precedence conflict: one source states formal notice must use notices-atlas_fiber_networks@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-juniper_peak_retail_group@example.test.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/06_service_levels/043_service_levels_correspondence.eml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/091_renewal_records_correspondence.eml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-03, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Isaac Romero.\n\n### F-16 — survival-clause ambiguity (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for survival-clause ambiguity: one source states the governed population contains 126 records through 2025-12-27, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 50 records through 2026-01-18.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/06_service_levels/046_service_levels_formal_notice.xml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/094_renewal_records_formal_notice.xml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-03, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Sofia Bennett.\n\n## Recommended next actions\n\nSequence the critical and high findings first, assign the named owners, preserve the cited records, and document any resolution in the controlling matter register before the stated deadline.\n\n## Assumptions and limitations\n\nThis analysis is confined to task cb100-011-atlas-fiber and the supplied synthetic evidence. It does not rely on external facts, does not resolve disputed law, and is not legal advice for a real person or entity.\n", "findings": {"as_of": "2026-09-03", "findings": [{"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/07_security_privacy/049_security_privacy_control_register.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for renewal date conflict: one source states the operative date is 2025-06-24 under control reference CB-CC-2501-A872, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2025-08-09 under response reference CB-CC-2501-J920.", "id": "F-01", "issue": "renewal date conflict", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/001_master_agreements_control_register.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-03, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Owen Delgado.", "severity": "critical"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/07_security_privacy/052_security_privacy_ledger_export.csv", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for pricing-escalator mismatch: one source states the controlling amount is $1,233,052.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $1,432,604.00.", "id": "F-02", "issue": "pricing-escalator mismatch", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/004_master_agreements_ledger_export.csv", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-03, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Lena Varga.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/07_security_privacy/055_security_privacy_officer_certificate.html", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for minimum-commit shortfall: one source states approval is attributed to Amara Patel as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Adrian Mensah and contains no entry for Amara Patel.", "id": "F-03", "issue": "minimum-commit shortfall", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/007_master_agreements_officer_certificate.html", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-03, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Samuel Kim.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/08_notices/058_notices_executed_instrument.txt", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for service-credit underpayment: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-CC-2501-D376, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-CC-2501-M744.", "id": "F-04", "issue": "service-credit underpayment", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/02_order_forms/010_order_forms_executed_instrument.txt", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-03, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Maya Ellison.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/08_notices/061_notices_review_memorandum.json", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for termination notice defect: one source states the applicable location is Denver, Colorado, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to Colorado operations outside Denver, Colorado.", "id": "F-05", "issue": "termination notice defect", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/02_order_forms/013_order_forms_review_memorandum.json", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-03, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Rafael Okafor.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/08_notices/064_notices_status_report.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for assignment consent requirement: one source states the threshold is 10% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 14% and produced a different exception result.", "id": "F-06", "issue": "assignment consent requirement", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/02_order_forms/016_order_forms_status_report.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-03, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Nora Chen.", "severity": "low"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/09_invoices/067_invoices_correspondence.eml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for data-localization conflict: one source states formal notice must use notices-atlas_fiber_networks@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-juniper_peak_retail_group@example.test.", "id": "F-07", "issue": "data-localization conflict", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/03_amendments/019_amendments_correspondence.eml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-03, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Dominic Alvarez.", "severity": "critical"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/09_invoices/070_invoices_formal_notice.xml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for subprocessor notice lapse: one source states the governed population contains 181 records through 2025-05-16, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 46 records through 2025-06-03.", "id": "F-08", "issue": "subprocessor notice lapse", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/03_amendments/022_amendments_formal_notice.xml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-03, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Priya Raman.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/10_correspondence/073_correspondence_control_register.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for insurance-limit deficiency: one source states the operative date is 2025-11-14 under control reference CB-CC-2501-I655, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2025-12-13 under response reference CB-CC-2501-R696.", "id": "F-09", "issue": "insurance-limit deficiency", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/025_statements_of_work_control_register.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-03, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Elliot Mercer.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/10_correspondence/076_correspondence_ledger_export.csv", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for audit-right deadline: one source states the controlling amount is $1,553,045.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $1,652,590.00.", "id": "F-10", "issue": "audit-right deadline", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/028_statements_of_work_ledger_export.csv", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-03, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Talia Brooks.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/10_correspondence/079_correspondence_officer_certificate.html", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for exclusivity carveout breach: one source states approval is attributed to Amara Patel as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Elliot Mercer and contains no entry for Amara Patel.", "id": "F-11", "issue": "exclusivity carveout breach", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/031_statements_of_work_officer_certificate.html", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-03, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Jonas Feld.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/11_policies/082_policies_executed_instrument.txt", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for benchmarking right omission: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-CC-2501-L353, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-CC-2501-U534.", "id": "F-12", "issue": "benchmarking right omission", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/05_pricing/034_pricing_executed_instrument.txt", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-03, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Mei Whitaker.", "severity": "low"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/11_policies/085_policies_review_memorandum.json", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for invoice currency discrepancy: one source states the applicable location is Denver, Colorado, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to Colorado operations outside Denver, Colorado.", "id": "F-13", "issue": "invoice currency discrepancy", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/05_pricing/037_pricing_review_memorandum.json", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-03, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Caleb Hassan.", "severity": "critical"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/11_policies/088_policies_status_report.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for usage-report inconsistency: one source states the threshold is 6% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 12% and produced a different exception result.", "id": "F-14", "issue": "usage-report inconsistency", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/05_pricing/040_pricing_status_report.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-03, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Leona Park.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/091_renewal_records_correspondence.eml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for order-form precedence conflict: one source states formal notice must use notices-atlas_fiber_networks@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-juniper_peak_retail_group@example.test.", "id": "F-15", "issue": "order-form precedence conflict", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/06_service_levels/043_service_levels_correspondence.eml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-03, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Isaac Romero.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/094_renewal_records_formal_notice.xml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for survival-clause ambiguity: one source states the governed population contains 126 records through 2025-12-27, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 50 records through 2026-01-18.", "id": "F-16", "issue": "survival-clause ambiguity", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/06_service_levels/046_service_levels_formal_notice.xml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-03, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Sofia Bennett.", "severity": "medium"}], "matter_number": "CB-CC-2501", "prepared_for": "Atlas Fiber Networks", "schema_version": "1.0", "task_id": "cb100-011-atlas-fiber"}}, "metadata": {"benchmark": "CounselBench-100", "code_license": "Apache-2.0", "data_license": "CC-BY-4.0", "deadline": "2026-09-03", "document_count": 96, "jurisdiction": "Colorado", "matter_number": "CB-CC-2501", "mcp_commit": "9a96ea6e5913736f92b88345bf51caeaaa8e719f", "mcp_package": "@modelcontextprotocol/server-filesystem@2026.7.10", "practice_area": "commercial-contracts", "reference_tool_calls": 46, "required_evidence_reads": 33, "synthetic": true, "venue": "Denver, Colorado", "version": "2.0.0"}, "prompt": "You are commercial contracts counsel for Atlas Fiber Networks. The partner responsible for this matter needs a defensible decision record before the next client call. A five-year network agreement has three order forms, disputed uptime credits, and competing renewal dates created by a migration amendment. Decision due 2026-09-03. Colorado law governs; Denver, Colorado is the forum. Prioritize conflicts between signed instruments and later operational records. Work out the defensible position from the matter production and leave an audit-ready exception tracker and concise advice for the supervising lawyer. Keep confirmed conflicts separate from open questions, cite the records that actually control each conclusion, and do not fill gaps with outside facts.", "rubric": {"criteria": [{"category": "procedure", "description": "Complete at least 46 successful, argument-specific evidence and output calls.", "id": "procedure.minimum_successful_tool_calls"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Find and read the 33 controlling, corroborating, and work-product-control records in full.", "id": "procedure.all_evidence_read_in_full"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Inspect file metadata for the eight designated critical primary records before relying on them.", "id": "procedure.chain_of_custody_metadata_checked"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Confirm the sandbox's allowed document and output roots.", "id": "procedure.allowed_directories_checked"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Inventory all 96 records so the relevant sources are discovered among the context records.", "id": "procedure.recursive_inventory_completed"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Search the production for email evidence that may corroborate or contradict formal records.", "id": "procedure.targeted_search_completed"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Leave only findings.json and advice.md in the output workspace.", "id": "procedure.exact_deliverable_set"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Create both final work products through the sandbox MCP surface.", "id": "procedure.deliverables_written_through_mcp"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Produce findings.json as a valid JSON object.", "id": "findings.findings_is_object"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Report exactly 16 confirmed exceptions.", "id": "findings.findings_exact_count"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Use each stable finding ID exactly once.", "id": "findings.finding_ids_unique"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set schema_version to the released matter value '1.0'.", "id": "findings.top_level_schema_version"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set task_id to the released matter value 'cb100-011-atlas-fiber'.", "id": "findings.top_level_task_id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set matter_number to the released matter value 'CB-CC-2501'.", "id": "findings.top_level_matter_number"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set prepared_for to the released matter value 'Atlas Fiber Networks'.", "id": "findings.top_level_prepared_for"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set as_of to the released matter value '2026-09-03'.", "id": "findings.top_level_as_of"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-01 exception for renewal date conflict.", "id": "findings.F-01.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's id from /workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/001_master_agreements_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_security_privacy/049_security_privacy_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's issue from /workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/001_master_agreements_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_security_privacy/049_security_privacy_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's severity from /workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/001_master_agreements_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_security_privacy/049_security_privacy_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's primary_source from /workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/001_master_agreements_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_security_privacy/049_security_privacy_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/001_master_agreements_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_security_privacy/049_security_privacy_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-01 using the exact controlled facts ['2025-06-24', 'CB-CC-2501-A872', '2025-08-09', 'CB-CC-2501-J920'].", "id": "findings.F-01.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-01's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-01.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-03', 'Owen Delgado'] for F-01.", "id": "findings.F-01.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-02 exception for pricing-escalator mismatch.", "id": "findings.F-02.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's id from /workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/004_master_agreements_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_security_privacy/052_security_privacy_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's issue from /workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/004_master_agreements_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_security_privacy/052_security_privacy_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's severity from /workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/004_master_agreements_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_security_privacy/052_security_privacy_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's primary_source from /workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/004_master_agreements_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_security_privacy/052_security_privacy_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/004_master_agreements_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_security_privacy/052_security_privacy_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-02 using the exact controlled facts ['$1,233,052.00', '$1,432,604.00'].", "id": "findings.F-02.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-02's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-02.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-03', 'Lena Varga'] for F-02.", "id": "findings.F-02.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-03 exception for minimum-commit shortfall.", "id": "findings.F-03.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's id from /workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/007_master_agreements_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_security_privacy/055_security_privacy_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's issue from /workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/007_master_agreements_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_security_privacy/055_security_privacy_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's severity from /workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/007_master_agreements_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_security_privacy/055_security_privacy_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's primary_source from /workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/007_master_agreements_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_security_privacy/055_security_privacy_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/007_master_agreements_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_security_privacy/055_security_privacy_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-03 using the exact controlled facts ['Amara Patel', 'Adrian Mensah'].", "id": "findings.F-03.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-03's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-03.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-03', 'Samuel Kim'] for F-03.", "id": "findings.F-03.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-04 exception for service-credit underpayment.", "id": "findings.F-04.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's id from /workspace/documents/02_order_forms/010_order_forms_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_notices/058_notices_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's issue from /workspace/documents/02_order_forms/010_order_forms_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_notices/058_notices_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's severity from /workspace/documents/02_order_forms/010_order_forms_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_notices/058_notices_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's primary_source from /workspace/documents/02_order_forms/010_order_forms_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_notices/058_notices_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/02_order_forms/010_order_forms_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_notices/058_notices_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-04 using the exact controlled facts ['closed without exception', 'CB-CC-2501-D376', 'open and escalated', 'CB-CC-2501-M744'].", "id": "findings.F-04.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-04's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-04.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-03', 'Maya Ellison'] for F-04.", "id": "findings.F-04.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-05 exception for termination notice defect.", "id": "findings.F-05.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's id from /workspace/documents/02_order_forms/013_order_forms_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_notices/061_notices_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's issue from /workspace/documents/02_order_forms/013_order_forms_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_notices/061_notices_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's severity from /workspace/documents/02_order_forms/013_order_forms_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_notices/061_notices_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's primary_source from /workspace/documents/02_order_forms/013_order_forms_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_notices/061_notices_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/02_order_forms/013_order_forms_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_notices/061_notices_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-05 using the exact controlled facts ['Denver, Colorado', 'Colorado'].", "id": "findings.F-05.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-05's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-05.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-03', 'Rafael Okafor'] for F-05.", "id": "findings.F-05.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-06 exception for assignment consent requirement.", "id": "findings.F-06.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's id from /workspace/documents/02_order_forms/016_order_forms_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_notices/064_notices_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's issue from /workspace/documents/02_order_forms/016_order_forms_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_notices/064_notices_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's severity from /workspace/documents/02_order_forms/016_order_forms_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_notices/064_notices_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's primary_source from /workspace/documents/02_order_forms/016_order_forms_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_notices/064_notices_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/02_order_forms/016_order_forms_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_notices/064_notices_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-06 using the exact controlled facts ['10%', '14%'].", "id": "findings.F-06.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-06's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-06.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-03', 'Nora Chen'] for F-06.", "id": "findings.F-06.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-07 exception for data-localization conflict.", "id": "findings.F-07.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's id from /workspace/documents/03_amendments/019_amendments_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_invoices/067_invoices_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's issue from /workspace/documents/03_amendments/019_amendments_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_invoices/067_invoices_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's severity from /workspace/documents/03_amendments/019_amendments_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_invoices/067_invoices_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's primary_source from /workspace/documents/03_amendments/019_amendments_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_invoices/067_invoices_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/03_amendments/019_amendments_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_invoices/067_invoices_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-07 using the exact controlled facts ['notices-atlas_fiber_networks@example.test', 'archive-juniper_peak_retail_group@example.test'].", "id": "findings.F-07.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-07's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-07.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-03', 'Dominic Alvarez'] for F-07.", "id": "findings.F-07.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-08 exception for subprocessor notice lapse.", "id": "findings.F-08.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's id from /workspace/documents/03_amendments/022_amendments_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_invoices/070_invoices_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's issue from /workspace/documents/03_amendments/022_amendments_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_invoices/070_invoices_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's severity from /workspace/documents/03_amendments/022_amendments_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_invoices/070_invoices_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's primary_source from /workspace/documents/03_amendments/022_amendments_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_invoices/070_invoices_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/03_amendments/022_amendments_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_invoices/070_invoices_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-08 using the exact controlled facts ['181 records', '2025-05-16', '46 records', '2025-06-03'].", "id": "findings.F-08.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-08's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-08.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-03', 'Priya Raman'] for F-08.", "id": "findings.F-08.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-09 exception for insurance-limit deficiency.", "id": "findings.F-09.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's id from /workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/025_statements_of_work_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_correspondence/073_correspondence_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's issue from /workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/025_statements_of_work_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_correspondence/073_correspondence_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's severity from /workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/025_statements_of_work_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_correspondence/073_correspondence_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's primary_source from /workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/025_statements_of_work_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_correspondence/073_correspondence_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/025_statements_of_work_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_correspondence/073_correspondence_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-09 using the exact controlled facts ['2025-11-14', 'CB-CC-2501-I655', '2025-12-13', 'CB-CC-2501-R696'].", "id": "findings.F-09.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-09's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-09.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-03', 'Elliot Mercer'] for F-09.", "id": "findings.F-09.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-10 exception for audit-right deadline.", "id": "findings.F-10.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's id from /workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/028_statements_of_work_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_correspondence/076_correspondence_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's issue from /workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/028_statements_of_work_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_correspondence/076_correspondence_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's severity from /workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/028_statements_of_work_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_correspondence/076_correspondence_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's primary_source from /workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/028_statements_of_work_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_correspondence/076_correspondence_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/028_statements_of_work_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_correspondence/076_correspondence_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-10 using the exact controlled facts ['$1,553,045.00', '$1,652,590.00'].", "id": "findings.F-10.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-10's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-10.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-03', 'Talia Brooks'] for F-10.", "id": "findings.F-10.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-11 exception for exclusivity carveout breach.", "id": "findings.F-11.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's id from /workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/031_statements_of_work_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_correspondence/079_correspondence_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's issue from /workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/031_statements_of_work_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_correspondence/079_correspondence_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's severity from /workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/031_statements_of_work_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_correspondence/079_correspondence_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's primary_source from /workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/031_statements_of_work_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_correspondence/079_correspondence_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/031_statements_of_work_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_correspondence/079_correspondence_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-11 using the exact controlled facts ['Amara Patel', 'Elliot Mercer'].", "id": "findings.F-11.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-11's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-11.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-03', 'Jonas Feld'] for F-11.", "id": "findings.F-11.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-12 exception for benchmarking right omission.", "id": "findings.F-12.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's id from /workspace/documents/05_pricing/034_pricing_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_policies/082_policies_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's issue from /workspace/documents/05_pricing/034_pricing_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_policies/082_policies_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's severity from /workspace/documents/05_pricing/034_pricing_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_policies/082_policies_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's primary_source from /workspace/documents/05_pricing/034_pricing_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_policies/082_policies_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/05_pricing/034_pricing_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_policies/082_policies_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-12 using the exact controlled facts ['closed without exception', 'CB-CC-2501-L353', 'open and escalated', 'CB-CC-2501-U534'].", "id": "findings.F-12.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-12's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-12.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-03', 'Mei Whitaker'] for F-12.", "id": "findings.F-12.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-13 exception for invoice currency discrepancy.", "id": "findings.F-13.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's id from /workspace/documents/05_pricing/037_pricing_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_policies/085_policies_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's issue from /workspace/documents/05_pricing/037_pricing_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_policies/085_policies_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's severity from /workspace/documents/05_pricing/037_pricing_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_policies/085_policies_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's primary_source from /workspace/documents/05_pricing/037_pricing_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_policies/085_policies_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/05_pricing/037_pricing_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_policies/085_policies_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-13 using the exact controlled facts ['Denver, Colorado', 'Colorado'].", "id": "findings.F-13.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-13's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-13.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-03', 'Caleb Hassan'] for F-13.", "id": "findings.F-13.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-14 exception for usage-report inconsistency.", "id": "findings.F-14.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's id from /workspace/documents/05_pricing/040_pricing_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_policies/088_policies_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's issue from /workspace/documents/05_pricing/040_pricing_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_policies/088_policies_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's severity from /workspace/documents/05_pricing/040_pricing_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_policies/088_policies_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's primary_source from /workspace/documents/05_pricing/040_pricing_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_policies/088_policies_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/05_pricing/040_pricing_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_policies/088_policies_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-14 using the exact controlled facts ['6%', '12%'].", "id": "findings.F-14.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-14's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-14.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-03', 'Leona Park'] for F-14.", "id": "findings.F-14.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-15 exception for order-form precedence conflict.", "id": "findings.F-15.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's id from /workspace/documents/06_service_levels/043_service_levels_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/091_renewal_records_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's issue from /workspace/documents/06_service_levels/043_service_levels_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/091_renewal_records_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's severity from /workspace/documents/06_service_levels/043_service_levels_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/091_renewal_records_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's primary_source from /workspace/documents/06_service_levels/043_service_levels_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/091_renewal_records_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/06_service_levels/043_service_levels_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/091_renewal_records_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-15 using the exact controlled facts ['notices-atlas_fiber_networks@example.test', 'archive-juniper_peak_retail_group@example.test'].", "id": "findings.F-15.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-15's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-15.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-03', 'Isaac Romero'] for F-15.", "id": "findings.F-15.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-16 exception for survival-clause ambiguity.", "id": "findings.F-16.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's id from /workspace/documents/06_service_levels/046_service_levels_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/094_renewal_records_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's issue from /workspace/documents/06_service_levels/046_service_levels_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/094_renewal_records_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's severity from /workspace/documents/06_service_levels/046_service_levels_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/094_renewal_records_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's primary_source from /workspace/documents/06_service_levels/046_service_levels_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/094_renewal_records_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/06_service_levels/046_service_levels_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/094_renewal_records_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-16 using the exact controlled facts ['126 records', '2025-12-27', '50 records', '2026-01-18'].", "id": "findings.F-16.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-16's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-16.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-03', 'Sofia Bennett'] for F-16.", "id": "findings.F-16.action_anchors"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Executive assessment' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Executive assessment"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Method and record coverage' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Method and record coverage"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Findings' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Findings"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Recommended next actions' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Recommended next actions"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Assumptions and limitations' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Assumptions and limitations"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-01 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-01"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-02 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-02"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-03 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-03"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-04 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-04"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-05 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-05"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-06 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-06"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-07 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-07"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-08 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-08"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-09 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-09"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-10 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-10"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-11 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-11"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-12 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-12"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-13 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-13"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-14 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-14"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-15 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-15"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-16 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-16"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Do not claim the production has no issues or that every record is consistent.", "id": "memo.forbidden_claims_absent"}], "decision_options": [{"id": "cross-source-reconciliation", "label": "Reconcile controlling and corroborating records", "reason": "The CB-CC-2501 production contains independently maintained records; a defensible answer must preserve each supported conflict and its cure owner.", "selected": true}, {"id": "latest-record-controls", "label": "Treat the latest record as controlling", "reason": "Timestamp recency does not establish legal priority, execution, or approval authority.", "selected": false}, {"id": "primary-records-only", "label": "Report primary records without reconciliation", "reason": "Primary records alone conceal the operational conflicts that create the actionable exceptions.", "selected": false}], "gates": ["all_evidence_read_in_full", "chain_of_custody_metadata_checked", "findings_criteria_complete", "memo_criteria_complete", "deliverables_written_through_mcp"], "metadata_checks": 8, "metric": "weighted_criteria_score", "minimum_tool_calls": 46, "required_deliverables": ["findings.json", "advice.md"], "required_document_reads": 33, "type": "deterministic", "weights": {"findings": 0.55, "memo": 0.2, "procedure": 0.25}}, "task_id": "cb100-011-atlas-fiber", "task_name": "Atlas Fiber enterprise customer reset", "world_id": "counselbench-filesystem-mcp-v2"}
-{"context_files": ["task_files/cb100-012-banyan-payments/01_master_agreements/001_master_agreements_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-012-banyan-payments/01_master_agreements/002_master_agreements_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-012-banyan-payments/01_master_agreements/003_master_agreements_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-012-banyan-payments/01_master_agreements/004_master_agreements_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-012-banyan-payments/01_master_agreements/005_master_agreements_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-012-banyan-payments/01_master_agreements/006_master_agreements_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-012-banyan-payments/01_master_agreements/007_master_agreements_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-012-banyan-payments/01_master_agreements/008_master_agreements_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-012-banyan-payments/02_order_forms/009_order_forms_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-012-banyan-payments/02_order_forms/010_order_forms_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-012-banyan-payments/02_order_forms/011_order_forms_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-012-banyan-payments/02_order_forms/012_order_forms_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-012-banyan-payments/02_order_forms/013_order_forms_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-012-banyan-payments/02_order_forms/014_order_forms_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-012-banyan-payments/02_order_forms/015_order_forms_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-012-banyan-payments/02_order_forms/016_order_forms_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-012-banyan-payments/03_amendments/017_amendments_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-012-banyan-payments/03_amendments/018_amendments_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-012-banyan-payments/03_amendments/019_amendments_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-012-banyan-payments/03_amendments/020_amendments_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-012-banyan-payments/03_amendments/021_amendments_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-012-banyan-payments/03_amendments/022_amendments_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-012-banyan-payments/03_amendments/023_amendments_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-012-banyan-payments/03_amendments/024_amendments_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-012-banyan-payments/04_statements_of_work/025_statements_of_work_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-012-banyan-payments/04_statements_of_work/026_statements_of_work_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-012-banyan-payments/04_statements_of_work/027_statements_of_work_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-012-banyan-payments/04_statements_of_work/028_statements_of_work_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-012-banyan-payments/04_statements_of_work/029_statements_of_work_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-012-banyan-payments/04_statements_of_work/030_statements_of_work_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-012-banyan-payments/04_statements_of_work/031_statements_of_work_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-012-banyan-payments/04_statements_of_work/032_statements_of_work_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-012-banyan-payments/05_pricing/033_pricing_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-012-banyan-payments/05_pricing/034_pricing_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-012-banyan-payments/05_pricing/035_pricing_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-012-banyan-payments/05_pricing/036_pricing_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-012-banyan-payments/05_pricing/037_pricing_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-012-banyan-payments/05_pricing/038_pricing_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-012-banyan-payments/05_pricing/039_pricing_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-012-banyan-payments/05_pricing/040_pricing_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-012-banyan-payments/06_service_levels/041_service_levels_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-012-banyan-payments/06_service_levels/042_service_levels_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-012-banyan-payments/06_service_levels/043_service_levels_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-012-banyan-payments/06_service_levels/044_service_levels_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-012-banyan-payments/06_service_levels/045_service_levels_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-012-banyan-payments/06_service_levels/046_service_levels_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-012-banyan-payments/06_service_levels/047_service_levels_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-012-banyan-payments/06_service_levels/048_service_levels_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-012-banyan-payments/07_security_privacy/049_security_privacy_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-012-banyan-payments/07_security_privacy/050_security_privacy_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-012-banyan-payments/07_security_privacy/051_security_privacy_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-012-banyan-payments/07_security_privacy/052_security_privacy_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-012-banyan-payments/07_security_privacy/053_security_privacy_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-012-banyan-payments/07_security_privacy/054_security_privacy_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-012-banyan-payments/07_security_privacy/055_security_privacy_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-012-banyan-payments/07_security_privacy/056_security_privacy_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-012-banyan-payments/08_notices/057_notices_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-012-banyan-payments/08_notices/058_notices_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-012-banyan-payments/08_notices/059_notices_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-012-banyan-payments/08_notices/060_notices_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-012-banyan-payments/08_notices/061_notices_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-012-banyan-payments/08_notices/062_notices_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-012-banyan-payments/08_notices/063_notices_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-012-banyan-payments/08_notices/064_notices_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-012-banyan-payments/09_invoices/065_invoices_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-012-banyan-payments/09_invoices/066_invoices_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-012-banyan-payments/09_invoices/067_invoices_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-012-banyan-payments/09_invoices/068_invoices_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-012-banyan-payments/09_invoices/069_invoices_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-012-banyan-payments/09_invoices/070_invoices_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-012-banyan-payments/09_invoices/071_invoices_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-012-banyan-payments/09_invoices/072_invoices_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-012-banyan-payments/10_correspondence/073_correspondence_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-012-banyan-payments/10_correspondence/074_correspondence_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-012-banyan-payments/10_correspondence/075_correspondence_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-012-banyan-payments/10_correspondence/076_correspondence_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-012-banyan-payments/10_correspondence/077_correspondence_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-012-banyan-payments/10_correspondence/078_correspondence_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-012-banyan-payments/10_correspondence/079_correspondence_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-012-banyan-payments/10_correspondence/080_correspondence_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-012-banyan-payments/11_policies/081_policies_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-012-banyan-payments/11_policies/082_policies_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-012-banyan-payments/11_policies/083_policies_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-012-banyan-payments/11_policies/084_policies_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-012-banyan-payments/11_policies/085_policies_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-012-banyan-payments/11_policies/086_policies_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-012-banyan-payments/11_policies/087_policies_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-012-banyan-payments/11_policies/088_policies_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-012-banyan-payments/12_renewal_records/089_renewal_records_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-012-banyan-payments/12_renewal_records/090_renewal_records_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-012-banyan-payments/12_renewal_records/091_renewal_records_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-012-banyan-payments/12_renewal_records/092_renewal_records_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-012-banyan-payments/12_renewal_records/093_renewal_records_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-012-banyan-payments/12_renewal_records/094_renewal_records_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-012-banyan-payments/12_renewal_records/095_renewal_records_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-012-banyan-payments/12_renewal_records/096_renewal_records_status_report.md"], "gold_output": {"advice_markdown": "# Counsel advice — Banyan acquiring-bank portfolio review\n\n## Executive assessment\n\nFor Banyan Payments, Inc. matter CB-CC-2502, the review identified 16 source-supported exceptions requiring action before 2026-09-07. The assessment concerns Red Harbor Bank, N.A. and the supplied record for New York.\n\n## Method and record coverage\n\nThe review inventoried all 96 production files, read the 33 controlling, corroborating, and control records, searched the email exports, and checked metadata for the designated chain-of-custody sample. Conclusions are limited to the synthetic production supplied for this benchmark matter.\n\n## Findings\n\n### F-01 — renewal date conflict (critical)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for renewal date conflict: one source states the operative date is 2025-04-20 under control reference CB-CC-2502-A507, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2025-05-12 under response reference CB-CC-2502-J200.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/001_master_agreements_control_register.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/07_security_privacy/049_security_privacy_control_register.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-07, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Lena Varga.\n\n### F-02 — pricing-escalator mismatch (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for pricing-escalator mismatch: one source states the controlling amount is $6,754,477.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $7,035,454.00.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/004_master_agreements_ledger_export.csv`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/07_security_privacy/052_security_privacy_ledger_export.csv`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-07, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Samuel Kim.\n\n### F-03 — minimum-commit shortfall (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for minimum-commit shortfall: one source states approval is attributed to Henry Cho as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Theo Laurent and contains no entry for Henry Cho.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/007_master_agreements_officer_certificate.html`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/07_security_privacy/055_security_privacy_officer_certificate.html`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-07, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Maya Ellison.\n\n### F-04 — service-credit underpayment (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for service-credit underpayment: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-CC-2502-D308, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-CC-2502-M392.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/02_order_forms/010_order_forms_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/08_notices/058_notices_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-07, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Rafael Okafor.\n\n### F-05 — termination notice defect (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for termination notice defect: one source states the applicable location is New York County, New York, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to New York operations outside New York County, New York.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/02_order_forms/013_order_forms_review_memorandum.json`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/08_notices/061_notices_review_memorandum.json`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-07, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Nora Chen.\n\n### F-06 — assignment consent requirement (low)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for assignment consent requirement: one source states the threshold is 2% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 8% and produced a different exception result.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/02_order_forms/016_order_forms_status_report.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/08_notices/064_notices_status_report.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-07, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Dominic Alvarez.\n\n### F-07 — data-localization conflict (critical)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for data-localization conflict: one source states formal notice must use notices-banyan_payments_inc@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-red_harbor_bank_n_a@example.test.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/03_amendments/019_amendments_correspondence.eml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/09_invoices/067_invoices_correspondence.eml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-07, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Priya Raman.\n\n### F-08 — subprocessor notice lapse (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for subprocessor notice lapse: one source states the governed population contains 97 records through 2025-07-11, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 54 records through 2025-08-06.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/03_amendments/022_amendments_formal_notice.xml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/09_invoices/070_invoices_formal_notice.xml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-07, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Elliot Mercer.\n\n### F-09 — insurance-limit deficiency (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for insurance-limit deficiency: one source states the operative date is 2026-01-18 under control reference CB-CC-2502-I840, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2026-02-06 under response reference CB-CC-2502-R918.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/025_statements_of_work_control_register.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/10_correspondence/073_correspondence_control_register.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-07, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Talia Brooks.\n\n### F-10 — audit-right deadline (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for audit-right deadline: one source states the controlling amount is $6,370,483.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $6,417,466.00.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/028_statements_of_work_ledger_export.csv`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/10_correspondence/076_correspondence_ledger_export.csv`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-07, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Jonas Feld.\n\n### F-11 — exclusivity carveout breach (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for exclusivity carveout breach: one source states approval is attributed to Henry Cho as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Jonas Feld and contains no entry for Henry Cho.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/031_statements_of_work_officer_certificate.html`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/10_correspondence/079_correspondence_officer_certificate.html`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-07, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Mei Whitaker.\n\n### F-12 — benchmarking right omission (low)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for benchmarking right omission: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-CC-2502-L706, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-CC-2502-U838.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/05_pricing/034_pricing_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/11_policies/082_policies_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-07, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Caleb Hassan.\n\n### F-13 — invoice currency discrepancy (critical)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for invoice currency discrepancy: one source states the applicable location is New York County, New York, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to New York operations outside New York County, New York.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/05_pricing/037_pricing_review_memorandum.json`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/11_policies/085_policies_review_memorandum.json`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-07, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Leona Park.\n\n### F-14 — usage-report inconsistency (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for usage-report inconsistency: one source states the threshold is 12% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 18% and produced a different exception result.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/05_pricing/040_pricing_status_report.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/11_policies/088_policies_status_report.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-07, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Isaac Romero.\n\n### F-15 — order-form precedence conflict (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for order-form precedence conflict: one source states formal notice must use notices-banyan_payments_inc@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-red_harbor_bank_n_a@example.test.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/06_service_levels/043_service_levels_correspondence.eml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/091_renewal_records_correspondence.eml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-07, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Sofia Bennett.\n\n### F-16 — survival-clause ambiguity (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for survival-clause ambiguity: one source states the governed population contains 59 records through 2025-10-21, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 38 records through 2025-10-31.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/06_service_levels/046_service_levels_formal_notice.xml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/094_renewal_records_formal_notice.xml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-07, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Adrian Mensah.\n\n## Recommended next actions\n\nSequence the critical and high findings first, assign the named owners, preserve the cited records, and document any resolution in the controlling matter register before the stated deadline.\n\n## Assumptions and limitations\n\nThis analysis is confined to task cb100-012-banyan-payments and the supplied synthetic evidence. It does not rely on external facts, does not resolve disputed law, and is not legal advice for a real person or entity.\n", "findings": {"as_of": "2026-09-07", "findings": [{"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/07_security_privacy/049_security_privacy_control_register.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for renewal date conflict: one source states the operative date is 2025-04-20 under control reference CB-CC-2502-A507, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2025-05-12 under response reference CB-CC-2502-J200.", "id": "F-01", "issue": "renewal date conflict", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/001_master_agreements_control_register.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-07, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Lena Varga.", "severity": "critical"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/07_security_privacy/052_security_privacy_ledger_export.csv", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for pricing-escalator mismatch: one source states the controlling amount is $6,754,477.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $7,035,454.00.", "id": "F-02", "issue": "pricing-escalator mismatch", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/004_master_agreements_ledger_export.csv", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-07, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Samuel Kim.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/07_security_privacy/055_security_privacy_officer_certificate.html", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for minimum-commit shortfall: one source states approval is attributed to Henry Cho as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Theo Laurent and contains no entry for Henry Cho.", "id": "F-03", "issue": "minimum-commit shortfall", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/007_master_agreements_officer_certificate.html", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-07, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Maya Ellison.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/08_notices/058_notices_executed_instrument.txt", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for service-credit underpayment: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-CC-2502-D308, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-CC-2502-M392.", "id": "F-04", "issue": "service-credit underpayment", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/02_order_forms/010_order_forms_executed_instrument.txt", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-07, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Rafael Okafor.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/08_notices/061_notices_review_memorandum.json", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for termination notice defect: one source states the applicable location is New York County, New York, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to New York operations outside New York County, New York.", "id": "F-05", "issue": "termination notice defect", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/02_order_forms/013_order_forms_review_memorandum.json", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-07, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Nora Chen.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/08_notices/064_notices_status_report.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for assignment consent requirement: one source states the threshold is 2% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 8% and produced a different exception result.", "id": "F-06", "issue": "assignment consent requirement", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/02_order_forms/016_order_forms_status_report.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-07, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Dominic Alvarez.", "severity": "low"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/09_invoices/067_invoices_correspondence.eml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for data-localization conflict: one source states formal notice must use notices-banyan_payments_inc@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-red_harbor_bank_n_a@example.test.", "id": "F-07", "issue": "data-localization conflict", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/03_amendments/019_amendments_correspondence.eml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-07, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Priya Raman.", "severity": "critical"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/09_invoices/070_invoices_formal_notice.xml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for subprocessor notice lapse: one source states the governed population contains 97 records through 2025-07-11, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 54 records through 2025-08-06.", "id": "F-08", "issue": "subprocessor notice lapse", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/03_amendments/022_amendments_formal_notice.xml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-07, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Elliot Mercer.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/10_correspondence/073_correspondence_control_register.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for insurance-limit deficiency: one source states the operative date is 2026-01-18 under control reference CB-CC-2502-I840, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2026-02-06 under response reference CB-CC-2502-R918.", "id": "F-09", "issue": "insurance-limit deficiency", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/025_statements_of_work_control_register.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-07, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Talia Brooks.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/10_correspondence/076_correspondence_ledger_export.csv", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for audit-right deadline: one source states the controlling amount is $6,370,483.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $6,417,466.00.", "id": "F-10", "issue": "audit-right deadline", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/028_statements_of_work_ledger_export.csv", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-07, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Jonas Feld.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/10_correspondence/079_correspondence_officer_certificate.html", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for exclusivity carveout breach: one source states approval is attributed to Henry Cho as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Jonas Feld and contains no entry for Henry Cho.", "id": "F-11", "issue": "exclusivity carveout breach", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/031_statements_of_work_officer_certificate.html", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-07, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Mei Whitaker.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/11_policies/082_policies_executed_instrument.txt", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for benchmarking right omission: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-CC-2502-L706, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-CC-2502-U838.", "id": "F-12", "issue": "benchmarking right omission", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/05_pricing/034_pricing_executed_instrument.txt", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-07, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Caleb Hassan.", "severity": "low"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/11_policies/085_policies_review_memorandum.json", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for invoice currency discrepancy: one source states the applicable location is New York County, New York, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to New York operations outside New York County, New York.", "id": "F-13", "issue": "invoice currency discrepancy", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/05_pricing/037_pricing_review_memorandum.json", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-07, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Leona Park.", "severity": "critical"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/11_policies/088_policies_status_report.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for usage-report inconsistency: one source states the threshold is 12% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 18% and produced a different exception result.", "id": "F-14", "issue": "usage-report inconsistency", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/05_pricing/040_pricing_status_report.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-07, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Isaac Romero.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/091_renewal_records_correspondence.eml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for order-form precedence conflict: one source states formal notice must use notices-banyan_payments_inc@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-red_harbor_bank_n_a@example.test.", "id": "F-15", "issue": "order-form precedence conflict", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/06_service_levels/043_service_levels_correspondence.eml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-07, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Sofia Bennett.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/094_renewal_records_formal_notice.xml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for survival-clause ambiguity: one source states the governed population contains 59 records through 2025-10-21, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 38 records through 2025-10-31.", "id": "F-16", "issue": "survival-clause ambiguity", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/06_service_levels/046_service_levels_formal_notice.xml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-07, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Adrian Mensah.", "severity": "medium"}], "matter_number": "CB-CC-2502", "prepared_for": "Banyan Payments, Inc.", "schema_version": "1.0", "task_id": "cb100-012-banyan-payments"}}, "metadata": {"benchmark": "CounselBench-100", "code_license": "Apache-2.0", "data_license": "CC-BY-4.0", "deadline": "2026-09-07", "document_count": 96, "jurisdiction": "New York", "matter_number": "CB-CC-2502", "mcp_commit": "9a96ea6e5913736f92b88345bf51caeaaa8e719f", "mcp_package": "@modelcontextprotocol/server-filesystem@2026.7.10", "practice_area": "commercial-contracts", "reference_tool_calls": 46, "required_evidence_reads": 33, "synthetic": true, "venue": "New York County, New York", "version": "2.0.0"}, "prompt": "You are commercial contracts counsel for Banyan Payments, Inc. A late document production changed the factual picture, and the matter team needs the entire record reconciled from first principles. Processing volume dropped below an annual floor while a security addendum and pricing schedule assign different consequences to the same shortfall. Decision due 2026-09-07. New York law governs; New York County, New York is the forum. Separate confirmed exceptions from items that merely require follow-up. Work out the defensible position from the matter production and leave an audit-ready exception tracker and concise advice for the supervising lawyer. Keep confirmed conflicts separate from open questions, cite the records that actually control each conclusion, and do not fill gaps with outside facts.", "rubric": {"criteria": [{"category": "procedure", "description": "Complete at least 46 successful, argument-specific evidence and output calls.", "id": "procedure.minimum_successful_tool_calls"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Find and read the 33 controlling, corroborating, and work-product-control records in full.", "id": "procedure.all_evidence_read_in_full"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Inspect file metadata for the eight designated critical primary records before relying on them.", "id": "procedure.chain_of_custody_metadata_checked"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Confirm the sandbox's allowed document and output roots.", "id": "procedure.allowed_directories_checked"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Inventory all 96 records so the relevant sources are discovered among the context records.", "id": "procedure.recursive_inventory_completed"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Search the production for email evidence that may corroborate or contradict formal records.", "id": "procedure.targeted_search_completed"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Leave only findings.json and advice.md in the output workspace.", "id": "procedure.exact_deliverable_set"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Create both final work products through the sandbox MCP surface.", "id": "procedure.deliverables_written_through_mcp"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Produce findings.json as a valid JSON object.", "id": "findings.findings_is_object"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Report exactly 16 confirmed exceptions.", "id": "findings.findings_exact_count"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Use each stable finding ID exactly once.", "id": "findings.finding_ids_unique"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set schema_version to the released matter value '1.0'.", "id": "findings.top_level_schema_version"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set task_id to the released matter value 'cb100-012-banyan-payments'.", "id": "findings.top_level_task_id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set matter_number to the released matter value 'CB-CC-2502'.", "id": "findings.top_level_matter_number"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set prepared_for to the released matter value 'Banyan Payments, Inc.'.", "id": "findings.top_level_prepared_for"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set as_of to the released matter value '2026-09-07'.", "id": "findings.top_level_as_of"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-01 exception for renewal date conflict.", "id": "findings.F-01.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's id from /workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/001_master_agreements_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_security_privacy/049_security_privacy_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's issue from /workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/001_master_agreements_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_security_privacy/049_security_privacy_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's severity from /workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/001_master_agreements_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_security_privacy/049_security_privacy_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's primary_source from /workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/001_master_agreements_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_security_privacy/049_security_privacy_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/001_master_agreements_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_security_privacy/049_security_privacy_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-01 using the exact controlled facts ['2025-04-20', 'CB-CC-2502-A507', '2025-05-12', 'CB-CC-2502-J200'].", "id": "findings.F-01.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-01's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-01.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-07', 'Lena Varga'] for F-01.", "id": "findings.F-01.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-02 exception for pricing-escalator mismatch.", "id": "findings.F-02.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's id from /workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/004_master_agreements_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_security_privacy/052_security_privacy_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's issue from /workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/004_master_agreements_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_security_privacy/052_security_privacy_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's severity from /workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/004_master_agreements_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_security_privacy/052_security_privacy_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's primary_source from /workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/004_master_agreements_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_security_privacy/052_security_privacy_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/004_master_agreements_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_security_privacy/052_security_privacy_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-02 using the exact controlled facts ['$6,754,477.00', '$7,035,454.00'].", "id": "findings.F-02.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-02's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-02.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-07', 'Samuel Kim'] for F-02.", "id": "findings.F-02.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-03 exception for minimum-commit shortfall.", "id": "findings.F-03.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's id from /workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/007_master_agreements_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_security_privacy/055_security_privacy_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's issue from /workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/007_master_agreements_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_security_privacy/055_security_privacy_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's severity from /workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/007_master_agreements_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_security_privacy/055_security_privacy_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's primary_source from /workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/007_master_agreements_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_security_privacy/055_security_privacy_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/007_master_agreements_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_security_privacy/055_security_privacy_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-03 using the exact controlled facts ['Henry Cho', 'Theo Laurent'].", "id": "findings.F-03.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-03's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-03.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-07', 'Maya Ellison'] for F-03.", "id": "findings.F-03.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-04 exception for service-credit underpayment.", "id": "findings.F-04.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's id from /workspace/documents/02_order_forms/010_order_forms_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_notices/058_notices_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's issue from /workspace/documents/02_order_forms/010_order_forms_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_notices/058_notices_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's severity from /workspace/documents/02_order_forms/010_order_forms_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_notices/058_notices_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's primary_source from /workspace/documents/02_order_forms/010_order_forms_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_notices/058_notices_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/02_order_forms/010_order_forms_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_notices/058_notices_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-04 using the exact controlled facts ['closed without exception', 'CB-CC-2502-D308', 'open and escalated', 'CB-CC-2502-M392'].", "id": "findings.F-04.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-04's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-04.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-07', 'Rafael Okafor'] for F-04.", "id": "findings.F-04.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-05 exception for termination notice defect.", "id": "findings.F-05.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's id from /workspace/documents/02_order_forms/013_order_forms_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_notices/061_notices_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's issue from /workspace/documents/02_order_forms/013_order_forms_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_notices/061_notices_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's severity from /workspace/documents/02_order_forms/013_order_forms_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_notices/061_notices_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's primary_source from /workspace/documents/02_order_forms/013_order_forms_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_notices/061_notices_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/02_order_forms/013_order_forms_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_notices/061_notices_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-05 using the exact controlled facts ['New York County, New York', 'New York'].", "id": "findings.F-05.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-05's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-05.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-07', 'Nora Chen'] for F-05.", "id": "findings.F-05.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-06 exception for assignment consent requirement.", "id": "findings.F-06.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's id from /workspace/documents/02_order_forms/016_order_forms_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_notices/064_notices_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's issue from /workspace/documents/02_order_forms/016_order_forms_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_notices/064_notices_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's severity from /workspace/documents/02_order_forms/016_order_forms_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_notices/064_notices_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's primary_source from /workspace/documents/02_order_forms/016_order_forms_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_notices/064_notices_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/02_order_forms/016_order_forms_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_notices/064_notices_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-06 using the exact controlled facts ['2%', '8%'].", "id": "findings.F-06.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-06's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-06.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-07', 'Dominic Alvarez'] for F-06.", "id": "findings.F-06.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-07 exception for data-localization conflict.", "id": "findings.F-07.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's id from /workspace/documents/03_amendments/019_amendments_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_invoices/067_invoices_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's issue from /workspace/documents/03_amendments/019_amendments_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_invoices/067_invoices_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's severity from /workspace/documents/03_amendments/019_amendments_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_invoices/067_invoices_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's primary_source from /workspace/documents/03_amendments/019_amendments_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_invoices/067_invoices_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/03_amendments/019_amendments_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_invoices/067_invoices_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-07 using the exact controlled facts ['notices-banyan_payments_inc@example.test', 'archive-red_harbor_bank_n_a@example.test'].", "id": "findings.F-07.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-07's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-07.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-07', 'Priya Raman'] for F-07.", "id": "findings.F-07.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-08 exception for subprocessor notice lapse.", "id": "findings.F-08.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's id from /workspace/documents/03_amendments/022_amendments_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_invoices/070_invoices_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's issue from /workspace/documents/03_amendments/022_amendments_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_invoices/070_invoices_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's severity from /workspace/documents/03_amendments/022_amendments_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_invoices/070_invoices_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's primary_source from /workspace/documents/03_amendments/022_amendments_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_invoices/070_invoices_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/03_amendments/022_amendments_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_invoices/070_invoices_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-08 using the exact controlled facts ['97 records', '2025-07-11', '54 records', '2025-08-06'].", "id": "findings.F-08.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-08's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-08.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-07', 'Elliot Mercer'] for F-08.", "id": "findings.F-08.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-09 exception for insurance-limit deficiency.", "id": "findings.F-09.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's id from /workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/025_statements_of_work_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_correspondence/073_correspondence_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's issue from /workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/025_statements_of_work_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_correspondence/073_correspondence_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's severity from /workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/025_statements_of_work_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_correspondence/073_correspondence_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's primary_source from /workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/025_statements_of_work_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_correspondence/073_correspondence_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/025_statements_of_work_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_correspondence/073_correspondence_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-09 using the exact controlled facts ['2026-01-18', 'CB-CC-2502-I840', '2026-02-06', 'CB-CC-2502-R918'].", "id": "findings.F-09.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-09's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-09.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-07', 'Talia Brooks'] for F-09.", "id": "findings.F-09.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-10 exception for audit-right deadline.", "id": "findings.F-10.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's id from /workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/028_statements_of_work_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_correspondence/076_correspondence_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's issue from /workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/028_statements_of_work_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_correspondence/076_correspondence_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's severity from /workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/028_statements_of_work_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_correspondence/076_correspondence_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's primary_source from /workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/028_statements_of_work_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_correspondence/076_correspondence_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/028_statements_of_work_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_correspondence/076_correspondence_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-10 using the exact controlled facts ['$6,370,483.00', '$6,417,466.00'].", "id": "findings.F-10.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-10's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-10.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-07', 'Jonas Feld'] for F-10.", "id": "findings.F-10.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-11 exception for exclusivity carveout breach.", "id": "findings.F-11.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's id from /workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/031_statements_of_work_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_correspondence/079_correspondence_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's issue from /workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/031_statements_of_work_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_correspondence/079_correspondence_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's severity from /workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/031_statements_of_work_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_correspondence/079_correspondence_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's primary_source from /workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/031_statements_of_work_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_correspondence/079_correspondence_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/031_statements_of_work_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_correspondence/079_correspondence_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-11 using the exact controlled facts ['Henry Cho', 'Jonas Feld'].", "id": "findings.F-11.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-11's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-11.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-07', 'Mei Whitaker'] for F-11.", "id": "findings.F-11.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-12 exception for benchmarking right omission.", "id": "findings.F-12.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's id from /workspace/documents/05_pricing/034_pricing_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_policies/082_policies_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's issue from /workspace/documents/05_pricing/034_pricing_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_policies/082_policies_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's severity from /workspace/documents/05_pricing/034_pricing_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_policies/082_policies_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's primary_source from /workspace/documents/05_pricing/034_pricing_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_policies/082_policies_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/05_pricing/034_pricing_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_policies/082_policies_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-12 using the exact controlled facts ['closed without exception', 'CB-CC-2502-L706', 'open and escalated', 'CB-CC-2502-U838'].", "id": "findings.F-12.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-12's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-12.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-07', 'Caleb Hassan'] for F-12.", "id": "findings.F-12.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-13 exception for invoice currency discrepancy.", "id": "findings.F-13.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's id from /workspace/documents/05_pricing/037_pricing_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_policies/085_policies_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's issue from /workspace/documents/05_pricing/037_pricing_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_policies/085_policies_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's severity from /workspace/documents/05_pricing/037_pricing_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_policies/085_policies_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's primary_source from /workspace/documents/05_pricing/037_pricing_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_policies/085_policies_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/05_pricing/037_pricing_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_policies/085_policies_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-13 using the exact controlled facts ['New York County, New York', 'New York'].", "id": "findings.F-13.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-13's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-13.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-07', 'Leona Park'] for F-13.", "id": "findings.F-13.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-14 exception for usage-report inconsistency.", "id": "findings.F-14.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's id from /workspace/documents/05_pricing/040_pricing_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_policies/088_policies_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's issue from /workspace/documents/05_pricing/040_pricing_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_policies/088_policies_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's severity from /workspace/documents/05_pricing/040_pricing_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_policies/088_policies_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's primary_source from /workspace/documents/05_pricing/040_pricing_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_policies/088_policies_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/05_pricing/040_pricing_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_policies/088_policies_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-14 using the exact controlled facts ['12%', '18%'].", "id": "findings.F-14.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-14's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-14.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-07', 'Isaac Romero'] for F-14.", "id": "findings.F-14.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-15 exception for order-form precedence conflict.", "id": "findings.F-15.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's id from /workspace/documents/06_service_levels/043_service_levels_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/091_renewal_records_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's issue from /workspace/documents/06_service_levels/043_service_levels_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/091_renewal_records_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's severity from /workspace/documents/06_service_levels/043_service_levels_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/091_renewal_records_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's primary_source from /workspace/documents/06_service_levels/043_service_levels_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/091_renewal_records_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/06_service_levels/043_service_levels_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/091_renewal_records_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-15 using the exact controlled facts ['notices-banyan_payments_inc@example.test', 'archive-red_harbor_bank_n_a@example.test'].", "id": "findings.F-15.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-15's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-15.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-07', 'Sofia Bennett'] for F-15.", "id": "findings.F-15.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-16 exception for survival-clause ambiguity.", "id": "findings.F-16.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's id from /workspace/documents/06_service_levels/046_service_levels_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/094_renewal_records_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's issue from /workspace/documents/06_service_levels/046_service_levels_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/094_renewal_records_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's severity from /workspace/documents/06_service_levels/046_service_levels_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/094_renewal_records_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's primary_source from /workspace/documents/06_service_levels/046_service_levels_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/094_renewal_records_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/06_service_levels/046_service_levels_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/094_renewal_records_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-16 using the exact controlled facts ['59 records', '2025-10-21', '38 records', '2025-10-31'].", "id": "findings.F-16.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-16's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-16.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-07', 'Adrian Mensah'] for F-16.", "id": "findings.F-16.action_anchors"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Executive assessment' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Executive assessment"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Method and record coverage' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Method and record coverage"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Findings' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Findings"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Recommended next actions' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Recommended next actions"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Assumptions and limitations' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Assumptions and limitations"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-01 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-01"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-02 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-02"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-03 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-03"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-04 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-04"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-05 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-05"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-06 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-06"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-07 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-07"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-08 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-08"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-09 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-09"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-10 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-10"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-11 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-11"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-12 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-12"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-13 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-13"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-14 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-14"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-15 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-15"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-16 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-16"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Do not claim the production has no issues or that every record is consistent.", "id": "memo.forbidden_claims_absent"}], "decision_options": [{"id": "cross-source-reconciliation", "label": "Reconcile controlling and corroborating records", "reason": "The CB-CC-2502 production contains independently maintained records; a defensible answer must preserve each supported conflict and its cure owner.", "selected": true}, {"id": "latest-record-controls", "label": "Treat the latest record as controlling", "reason": "Timestamp recency does not establish legal priority, execution, or approval authority.", "selected": false}, {"id": "primary-records-only", "label": "Report primary records without reconciliation", "reason": "Primary records alone conceal the operational conflicts that create the actionable exceptions.", "selected": false}], "gates": ["all_evidence_read_in_full", "chain_of_custody_metadata_checked", "findings_criteria_complete", "memo_criteria_complete", "deliverables_written_through_mcp"], "metadata_checks": 8, "metric": "weighted_criteria_score", "minimum_tool_calls": 46, "required_deliverables": ["findings.json", "advice.md"], "required_document_reads": 33, "type": "deterministic", "weights": {"findings": 0.55, "memo": 0.2, "procedure": 0.25}}, "task_id": "cb100-012-banyan-payments", "task_name": "Banyan acquiring-bank portfolio review", "world_id": "counselbench-filesystem-mcp-v2"}
-{"context_files": ["task_files/cb100-013-cirrus-labs/01_master_agreements/001_master_agreements_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-013-cirrus-labs/01_master_agreements/002_master_agreements_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-013-cirrus-labs/01_master_agreements/003_master_agreements_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-013-cirrus-labs/01_master_agreements/004_master_agreements_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-013-cirrus-labs/01_master_agreements/005_master_agreements_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-013-cirrus-labs/01_master_agreements/006_master_agreements_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-013-cirrus-labs/01_master_agreements/007_master_agreements_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-013-cirrus-labs/01_master_agreements/008_master_agreements_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-013-cirrus-labs/02_order_forms/009_order_forms_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-013-cirrus-labs/02_order_forms/010_order_forms_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-013-cirrus-labs/02_order_forms/011_order_forms_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-013-cirrus-labs/02_order_forms/012_order_forms_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-013-cirrus-labs/02_order_forms/013_order_forms_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-013-cirrus-labs/02_order_forms/014_order_forms_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-013-cirrus-labs/02_order_forms/015_order_forms_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-013-cirrus-labs/02_order_forms/016_order_forms_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-013-cirrus-labs/03_amendments/017_amendments_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-013-cirrus-labs/03_amendments/018_amendments_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-013-cirrus-labs/03_amendments/019_amendments_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-013-cirrus-labs/03_amendments/020_amendments_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-013-cirrus-labs/03_amendments/021_amendments_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-013-cirrus-labs/03_amendments/022_amendments_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-013-cirrus-labs/03_amendments/023_amendments_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-013-cirrus-labs/03_amendments/024_amendments_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-013-cirrus-labs/04_statements_of_work/025_statements_of_work_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-013-cirrus-labs/04_statements_of_work/026_statements_of_work_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-013-cirrus-labs/04_statements_of_work/027_statements_of_work_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-013-cirrus-labs/04_statements_of_work/028_statements_of_work_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-013-cirrus-labs/04_statements_of_work/029_statements_of_work_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-013-cirrus-labs/04_statements_of_work/030_statements_of_work_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-013-cirrus-labs/04_statements_of_work/031_statements_of_work_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-013-cirrus-labs/04_statements_of_work/032_statements_of_work_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-013-cirrus-labs/05_pricing/033_pricing_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-013-cirrus-labs/05_pricing/034_pricing_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-013-cirrus-labs/05_pricing/035_pricing_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-013-cirrus-labs/05_pricing/036_pricing_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-013-cirrus-labs/05_pricing/037_pricing_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-013-cirrus-labs/05_pricing/038_pricing_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-013-cirrus-labs/05_pricing/039_pricing_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-013-cirrus-labs/05_pricing/040_pricing_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-013-cirrus-labs/06_service_levels/041_service_levels_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-013-cirrus-labs/06_service_levels/042_service_levels_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-013-cirrus-labs/06_service_levels/043_service_levels_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-013-cirrus-labs/06_service_levels/044_service_levels_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-013-cirrus-labs/06_service_levels/045_service_levels_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-013-cirrus-labs/06_service_levels/046_service_levels_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-013-cirrus-labs/06_service_levels/047_service_levels_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-013-cirrus-labs/06_service_levels/048_service_levels_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-013-cirrus-labs/07_security_privacy/049_security_privacy_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-013-cirrus-labs/07_security_privacy/050_security_privacy_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-013-cirrus-labs/07_security_privacy/051_security_privacy_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-013-cirrus-labs/07_security_privacy/052_security_privacy_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-013-cirrus-labs/07_security_privacy/053_security_privacy_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-013-cirrus-labs/07_security_privacy/054_security_privacy_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-013-cirrus-labs/07_security_privacy/055_security_privacy_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-013-cirrus-labs/07_security_privacy/056_security_privacy_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-013-cirrus-labs/08_notices/057_notices_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-013-cirrus-labs/08_notices/058_notices_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-013-cirrus-labs/08_notices/059_notices_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-013-cirrus-labs/08_notices/060_notices_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-013-cirrus-labs/08_notices/061_notices_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-013-cirrus-labs/08_notices/062_notices_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-013-cirrus-labs/08_notices/063_notices_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-013-cirrus-labs/08_notices/064_notices_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-013-cirrus-labs/09_invoices/065_invoices_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-013-cirrus-labs/09_invoices/066_invoices_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-013-cirrus-labs/09_invoices/067_invoices_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-013-cirrus-labs/09_invoices/068_invoices_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-013-cirrus-labs/09_invoices/069_invoices_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-013-cirrus-labs/09_invoices/070_invoices_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-013-cirrus-labs/09_invoices/071_invoices_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-013-cirrus-labs/09_invoices/072_invoices_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-013-cirrus-labs/10_correspondence/073_correspondence_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-013-cirrus-labs/10_correspondence/074_correspondence_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-013-cirrus-labs/10_correspondence/075_correspondence_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-013-cirrus-labs/10_correspondence/076_correspondence_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-013-cirrus-labs/10_correspondence/077_correspondence_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-013-cirrus-labs/10_correspondence/078_correspondence_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-013-cirrus-labs/10_correspondence/079_correspondence_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-013-cirrus-labs/10_correspondence/080_correspondence_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-013-cirrus-labs/11_policies/081_policies_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-013-cirrus-labs/11_policies/082_policies_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-013-cirrus-labs/11_policies/083_policies_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-013-cirrus-labs/11_policies/084_policies_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-013-cirrus-labs/11_policies/085_policies_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-013-cirrus-labs/11_policies/086_policies_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-013-cirrus-labs/11_policies/087_policies_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-013-cirrus-labs/11_policies/088_policies_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-013-cirrus-labs/12_renewal_records/089_renewal_records_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-013-cirrus-labs/12_renewal_records/090_renewal_records_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-013-cirrus-labs/12_renewal_records/091_renewal_records_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-013-cirrus-labs/12_renewal_records/092_renewal_records_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-013-cirrus-labs/12_renewal_records/093_renewal_records_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-013-cirrus-labs/12_renewal_records/094_renewal_records_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-013-cirrus-labs/12_renewal_records/095_renewal_records_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-013-cirrus-labs/12_renewal_records/096_renewal_records_status_report.md"], "gold_output": {"advice_markdown": "# Counsel advice — Cirrus cloud-reseller reconciliation\n\n## Executive assessment\n\nFor Cirrus Laboratory Cloud LLC matter CB-CC-2503, the review identified 16 source-supported exceptions requiring action before 2026-09-10. The assessment concerns Quartzline Resellers Ltd. and the supplied record for Washington.\n\n## Method and record coverage\n\nThe review inventoried all 96 production files, read the 33 controlling, corroborating, and control records, searched the email exports, and checked metadata for the designated chain-of-custody sample. Conclusions are limited to the synthetic production supplied for this benchmark matter.\n\n## Findings\n\n### F-01 — renewal date conflict (critical)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for renewal date conflict: one source states the operative date is 2025-05-18 under control reference CB-CC-2503-A655, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2025-05-28 under response reference CB-CC-2503-J350.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/001_master_agreements_control_register.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/07_security_privacy/049_security_privacy_control_register.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-10, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Samuel Kim.\n\n### F-02 — pricing-escalator mismatch (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for pricing-escalator mismatch: one source states the controlling amount is $7,378,732.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $7,403,964.00.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/004_master_agreements_ledger_export.csv`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/07_security_privacy/052_security_privacy_ledger_export.csv`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-10, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Maya Ellison.\n\n### F-03 — minimum-commit shortfall (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for minimum-commit shortfall: one source states approval is attributed to Nadine Flores as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Henry Cho and contains no entry for Nadine Flores.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/007_master_agreements_officer_certificate.html`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/07_security_privacy/055_security_privacy_officer_certificate.html`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-10, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Rafael Okafor.\n\n### F-04 — service-credit underpayment (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for service-credit underpayment: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-CC-2503-D591, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-CC-2503-M137.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/02_order_forms/010_order_forms_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/08_notices/058_notices_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-10, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Nora Chen.\n\n### F-05 — termination notice defect (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for termination notice defect: one source states the applicable location is King County, Washington, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to Washington operations outside King County, Washington.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/02_order_forms/013_order_forms_review_memorandum.json`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/08_notices/061_notices_review_memorandum.json`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-10, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Dominic Alvarez.\n\n### F-06 — assignment consent requirement (low)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for assignment consent requirement: one source states the threshold is 12% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 16% and produced a different exception result.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/02_order_forms/016_order_forms_status_report.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/08_notices/064_notices_status_report.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-10, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Priya Raman.\n\n### F-07 — data-localization conflict (critical)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for data-localization conflict: one source states formal notice must use notices-cirrus_laboratory_cloud_llc@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-quartzline_resellers_ltd@example.test.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/03_amendments/019_amendments_correspondence.eml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/09_invoices/067_invoices_correspondence.eml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-10, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Elliot Mercer.\n\n### F-08 — subprocessor notice lapse (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for subprocessor notice lapse: one source states the governed population contains 162 records through 2025-04-27, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 62 records through 2025-05-31.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/03_amendments/022_amendments_formal_notice.xml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/09_invoices/070_invoices_formal_notice.xml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-10, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Talia Brooks.\n\n### F-09 — insurance-limit deficiency (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for insurance-limit deficiency: one source states the operative date is 2025-12-22 under control reference CB-CC-2503-I933, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2026-02-07 under response reference CB-CC-2503-R648.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/025_statements_of_work_control_register.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/10_correspondence/073_correspondence_control_register.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-10, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Jonas Feld.\n\n### F-10 — audit-right deadline (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for audit-right deadline: one source states the controlling amount is $5,503,820.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $5,754,140.00.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/028_statements_of_work_ledger_export.csv`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/10_correspondence/076_correspondence_ledger_export.csv`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-10, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Mei Whitaker.\n\n### F-11 — exclusivity carveout breach (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for exclusivity carveout breach: one source states approval is attributed to Nadine Flores as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Caleb Hassan and contains no entry for Nadine Flores.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/031_statements_of_work_officer_certificate.html`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/10_correspondence/079_correspondence_officer_certificate.html`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-10, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Caleb Hassan.\n\n### F-12 — benchmarking right omission (low)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for benchmarking right omission: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-CC-2503-L398, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-CC-2503-U261.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/05_pricing/034_pricing_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/11_policies/082_policies_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-10, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Leona Park.\n\n### F-13 — invoice currency discrepancy (critical)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for invoice currency discrepancy: one source states the applicable location is King County, Washington, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to Washington operations outside King County, Washington.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/05_pricing/037_pricing_review_memorandum.json`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/11_policies/085_policies_review_memorandum.json`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-10, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Isaac Romero.\n\n### F-14 — usage-report inconsistency (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for usage-report inconsistency: one source states the threshold is 7% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 10% and produced a different exception result.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/05_pricing/040_pricing_status_report.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/11_policies/088_policies_status_report.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-10, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Sofia Bennett.\n\n### F-15 — order-form precedence conflict (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for order-form precedence conflict: one source states formal notice must use notices-cirrus_laboratory_cloud_llc@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-quartzline_resellers_ltd@example.test.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/06_service_levels/043_service_levels_correspondence.eml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/091_renewal_records_correspondence.eml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-10, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Adrian Mensah.\n\n### F-16 — survival-clause ambiguity (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for survival-clause ambiguity: one source states the governed population contains 53 records through 2025-05-28, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 59 records through 2025-06-28.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/06_service_levels/046_service_levels_formal_notice.xml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/094_renewal_records_formal_notice.xml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-10, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Willa Novak.\n\n## Recommended next actions\n\nSequence the critical and high findings first, assign the named owners, preserve the cited records, and document any resolution in the controlling matter register before the stated deadline.\n\n## Assumptions and limitations\n\nThis analysis is confined to task cb100-013-cirrus-labs and the supplied synthetic evidence. It does not rely on external facts, does not resolve disputed law, and is not legal advice for a real person or entity.\n", "findings": {"as_of": "2026-09-10", "findings": [{"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/07_security_privacy/049_security_privacy_control_register.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for renewal date conflict: one source states the operative date is 2025-05-18 under control reference CB-CC-2503-A655, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2025-05-28 under response reference CB-CC-2503-J350.", "id": "F-01", "issue": "renewal date conflict", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/001_master_agreements_control_register.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-10, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Samuel Kim.", "severity": "critical"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/07_security_privacy/052_security_privacy_ledger_export.csv", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for pricing-escalator mismatch: one source states the controlling amount is $7,378,732.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $7,403,964.00.", "id": "F-02", "issue": "pricing-escalator mismatch", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/004_master_agreements_ledger_export.csv", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-10, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Maya Ellison.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/07_security_privacy/055_security_privacy_officer_certificate.html", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for minimum-commit shortfall: one source states approval is attributed to Nadine Flores as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Henry Cho and contains no entry for Nadine Flores.", "id": "F-03", "issue": "minimum-commit shortfall", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/007_master_agreements_officer_certificate.html", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-10, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Rafael Okafor.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/08_notices/058_notices_executed_instrument.txt", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for service-credit underpayment: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-CC-2503-D591, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-CC-2503-M137.", "id": "F-04", "issue": "service-credit underpayment", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/02_order_forms/010_order_forms_executed_instrument.txt", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-10, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Nora Chen.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/08_notices/061_notices_review_memorandum.json", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for termination notice defect: one source states the applicable location is King County, Washington, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to Washington operations outside King County, Washington.", "id": "F-05", "issue": "termination notice defect", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/02_order_forms/013_order_forms_review_memorandum.json", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-10, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Dominic Alvarez.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/08_notices/064_notices_status_report.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for assignment consent requirement: one source states the threshold is 12% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 16% and produced a different exception result.", "id": "F-06", "issue": "assignment consent requirement", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/02_order_forms/016_order_forms_status_report.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-10, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Priya Raman.", "severity": "low"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/09_invoices/067_invoices_correspondence.eml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for data-localization conflict: one source states formal notice must use notices-cirrus_laboratory_cloud_llc@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-quartzline_resellers_ltd@example.test.", "id": "F-07", "issue": "data-localization conflict", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/03_amendments/019_amendments_correspondence.eml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-10, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Elliot Mercer.", "severity": "critical"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/09_invoices/070_invoices_formal_notice.xml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for subprocessor notice lapse: one source states the governed population contains 162 records through 2025-04-27, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 62 records through 2025-05-31.", "id": "F-08", "issue": "subprocessor notice lapse", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/03_amendments/022_amendments_formal_notice.xml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-10, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Talia Brooks.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/10_correspondence/073_correspondence_control_register.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for insurance-limit deficiency: one source states the operative date is 2025-12-22 under control reference CB-CC-2503-I933, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2026-02-07 under response reference CB-CC-2503-R648.", "id": "F-09", "issue": "insurance-limit deficiency", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/025_statements_of_work_control_register.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-10, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Jonas Feld.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/10_correspondence/076_correspondence_ledger_export.csv", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for audit-right deadline: one source states the controlling amount is $5,503,820.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $5,754,140.00.", "id": "F-10", "issue": "audit-right deadline", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/028_statements_of_work_ledger_export.csv", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-10, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Mei Whitaker.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/10_correspondence/079_correspondence_officer_certificate.html", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for exclusivity carveout breach: one source states approval is attributed to Nadine Flores as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Caleb Hassan and contains no entry for Nadine Flores.", "id": "F-11", "issue": "exclusivity carveout breach", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/031_statements_of_work_officer_certificate.html", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-10, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Caleb Hassan.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/11_policies/082_policies_executed_instrument.txt", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for benchmarking right omission: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-CC-2503-L398, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-CC-2503-U261.", "id": "F-12", "issue": "benchmarking right omission", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/05_pricing/034_pricing_executed_instrument.txt", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-10, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Leona Park.", "severity": "low"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/11_policies/085_policies_review_memorandum.json", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for invoice currency discrepancy: one source states the applicable location is King County, Washington, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to Washington operations outside King County, Washington.", "id": "F-13", "issue": "invoice currency discrepancy", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/05_pricing/037_pricing_review_memorandum.json", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-10, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Isaac Romero.", "severity": "critical"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/11_policies/088_policies_status_report.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for usage-report inconsistency: one source states the threshold is 7% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 10% and produced a different exception result.", "id": "F-14", "issue": "usage-report inconsistency", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/05_pricing/040_pricing_status_report.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-10, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Sofia Bennett.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/091_renewal_records_correspondence.eml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for order-form precedence conflict: one source states formal notice must use notices-cirrus_laboratory_cloud_llc@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-quartzline_resellers_ltd@example.test.", "id": "F-15", "issue": "order-form precedence conflict", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/06_service_levels/043_service_levels_correspondence.eml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-10, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Adrian Mensah.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/094_renewal_records_formal_notice.xml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for survival-clause ambiguity: one source states the governed population contains 53 records through 2025-05-28, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 59 records through 2025-06-28.", "id": "F-16", "issue": "survival-clause ambiguity", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/06_service_levels/046_service_levels_formal_notice.xml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-10, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Willa Novak.", "severity": "medium"}], "matter_number": "CB-CC-2503", "prepared_for": "Cirrus Laboratory Cloud LLC", "schema_version": "1.0", "task_id": "cb100-013-cirrus-labs"}}, "metadata": {"benchmark": "CounselBench-100", "code_license": "Apache-2.0", "data_license": "CC-BY-4.0", "deadline": "2026-09-10", "document_count": 96, "jurisdiction": "Washington", "matter_number": "CB-CC-2503", "mcp_commit": "9a96ea6e5913736f92b88345bf51caeaaa8e719f", "mcp_package": "@modelcontextprotocol/server-filesystem@2026.7.10", "practice_area": "commercial-contracts", "reference_tool_calls": 46, "required_evidence_reads": 33, "synthetic": true, "venue": "King County, Washington", "version": "2.0.0"}, "prompt": "You are commercial contracts counsel for Cirrus Laboratory Cloud LLC. The client has asked for a board-ready risk assessment supported by a source-level tracker rather than a narrative-only summary. A reseller claims exclusivity in public-sector accounts and relies on an unsigned order form that changed usage reporting and audit mechanics. Decision due 2026-09-10. Washington law governs; King County, Washington is the forum. Treat dates, notice mechanics, approval evidence, and numerical reconciliations as independent controls. Work out the defensible position from the matter production and leave an audit-ready exception tracker and concise advice for the supervising lawyer. Keep confirmed conflicts separate from open questions, cite the records that actually control each conclusion, and do not fill gaps with outside facts.", "rubric": {"criteria": [{"category": "procedure", "description": "Complete at least 46 successful, argument-specific evidence and output calls.", "id": "procedure.minimum_successful_tool_calls"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Find and read the 33 controlling, corroborating, and work-product-control records in full.", "id": "procedure.all_evidence_read_in_full"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Inspect file metadata for the eight designated critical primary records before relying on them.", "id": "procedure.chain_of_custody_metadata_checked"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Confirm the sandbox's allowed document and output roots.", "id": "procedure.allowed_directories_checked"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Inventory all 96 records so the relevant sources are discovered among the context records.", "id": "procedure.recursive_inventory_completed"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Search the production for email evidence that may corroborate or contradict formal records.", "id": "procedure.targeted_search_completed"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Leave only findings.json and advice.md in the output workspace.", "id": "procedure.exact_deliverable_set"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Create both final work products through the sandbox MCP surface.", "id": "procedure.deliverables_written_through_mcp"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Produce findings.json as a valid JSON object.", "id": "findings.findings_is_object"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Report exactly 16 confirmed exceptions.", "id": "findings.findings_exact_count"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Use each stable finding ID exactly once.", "id": "findings.finding_ids_unique"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set schema_version to the released matter value '1.0'.", "id": "findings.top_level_schema_version"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set task_id to the released matter value 'cb100-013-cirrus-labs'.", "id": "findings.top_level_task_id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set matter_number to the released matter value 'CB-CC-2503'.", "id": "findings.top_level_matter_number"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set prepared_for to the released matter value 'Cirrus Laboratory Cloud LLC'.", "id": "findings.top_level_prepared_for"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set as_of to the released matter value '2026-09-10'.", "id": "findings.top_level_as_of"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-01 exception for renewal date conflict.", "id": "findings.F-01.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's id from /workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/001_master_agreements_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_security_privacy/049_security_privacy_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's issue from /workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/001_master_agreements_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_security_privacy/049_security_privacy_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's severity from /workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/001_master_agreements_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_security_privacy/049_security_privacy_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's primary_source from /workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/001_master_agreements_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_security_privacy/049_security_privacy_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/001_master_agreements_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_security_privacy/049_security_privacy_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-01 using the exact controlled facts ['2025-05-18', 'CB-CC-2503-A655', '2025-05-28', 'CB-CC-2503-J350'].", "id": "findings.F-01.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-01's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-01.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-10', 'Samuel Kim'] for F-01.", "id": "findings.F-01.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-02 exception for pricing-escalator mismatch.", "id": "findings.F-02.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's id from /workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/004_master_agreements_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_security_privacy/052_security_privacy_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's issue from /workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/004_master_agreements_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_security_privacy/052_security_privacy_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's severity from /workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/004_master_agreements_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_security_privacy/052_security_privacy_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's primary_source from /workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/004_master_agreements_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_security_privacy/052_security_privacy_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/004_master_agreements_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_security_privacy/052_security_privacy_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-02 using the exact controlled facts ['$7,378,732.00', '$7,403,964.00'].", "id": "findings.F-02.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-02's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-02.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-10', 'Maya Ellison'] for F-02.", "id": "findings.F-02.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-03 exception for minimum-commit shortfall.", "id": "findings.F-03.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's id from /workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/007_master_agreements_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_security_privacy/055_security_privacy_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's issue from /workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/007_master_agreements_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_security_privacy/055_security_privacy_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's severity from /workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/007_master_agreements_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_security_privacy/055_security_privacy_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's primary_source from /workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/007_master_agreements_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_security_privacy/055_security_privacy_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/007_master_agreements_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_security_privacy/055_security_privacy_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-03 using the exact controlled facts ['Nadine Flores', 'Henry Cho'].", "id": "findings.F-03.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-03's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-03.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-10', 'Rafael Okafor'] for F-03.", "id": "findings.F-03.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-04 exception for service-credit underpayment.", "id": "findings.F-04.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's id from /workspace/documents/02_order_forms/010_order_forms_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_notices/058_notices_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's issue from /workspace/documents/02_order_forms/010_order_forms_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_notices/058_notices_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's severity from /workspace/documents/02_order_forms/010_order_forms_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_notices/058_notices_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's primary_source from /workspace/documents/02_order_forms/010_order_forms_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_notices/058_notices_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/02_order_forms/010_order_forms_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_notices/058_notices_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-04 using the exact controlled facts ['closed without exception', 'CB-CC-2503-D591', 'open and escalated', 'CB-CC-2503-M137'].", "id": "findings.F-04.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-04's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-04.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-10', 'Nora Chen'] for F-04.", "id": "findings.F-04.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-05 exception for termination notice defect.", "id": "findings.F-05.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's id from /workspace/documents/02_order_forms/013_order_forms_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_notices/061_notices_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's issue from /workspace/documents/02_order_forms/013_order_forms_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_notices/061_notices_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's severity from /workspace/documents/02_order_forms/013_order_forms_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_notices/061_notices_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's primary_source from /workspace/documents/02_order_forms/013_order_forms_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_notices/061_notices_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/02_order_forms/013_order_forms_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_notices/061_notices_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-05 using the exact controlled facts ['King County, Washington', 'Washington'].", "id": "findings.F-05.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-05's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-05.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-10', 'Dominic Alvarez'] for F-05.", "id": "findings.F-05.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-06 exception for assignment consent requirement.", "id": "findings.F-06.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's id from /workspace/documents/02_order_forms/016_order_forms_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_notices/064_notices_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's issue from /workspace/documents/02_order_forms/016_order_forms_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_notices/064_notices_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's severity from /workspace/documents/02_order_forms/016_order_forms_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_notices/064_notices_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's primary_source from /workspace/documents/02_order_forms/016_order_forms_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_notices/064_notices_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/02_order_forms/016_order_forms_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_notices/064_notices_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-06 using the exact controlled facts ['12%', '16%'].", "id": "findings.F-06.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-06's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-06.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-10', 'Priya Raman'] for F-06.", "id": "findings.F-06.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-07 exception for data-localization conflict.", "id": "findings.F-07.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's id from /workspace/documents/03_amendments/019_amendments_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_invoices/067_invoices_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's issue from /workspace/documents/03_amendments/019_amendments_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_invoices/067_invoices_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's severity from /workspace/documents/03_amendments/019_amendments_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_invoices/067_invoices_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's primary_source from /workspace/documents/03_amendments/019_amendments_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_invoices/067_invoices_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/03_amendments/019_amendments_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_invoices/067_invoices_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-07 using the exact controlled facts ['notices-cirrus_laboratory_cloud_llc@example.test', 'archive-quartzline_resellers_ltd@example.test'].", "id": "findings.F-07.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-07's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-07.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-10', 'Elliot Mercer'] for F-07.", "id": "findings.F-07.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-08 exception for subprocessor notice lapse.", "id": "findings.F-08.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's id from /workspace/documents/03_amendments/022_amendments_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_invoices/070_invoices_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's issue from /workspace/documents/03_amendments/022_amendments_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_invoices/070_invoices_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's severity from /workspace/documents/03_amendments/022_amendments_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_invoices/070_invoices_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's primary_source from /workspace/documents/03_amendments/022_amendments_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_invoices/070_invoices_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/03_amendments/022_amendments_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_invoices/070_invoices_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-08 using the exact controlled facts ['162 records', '2025-04-27', '62 records', '2025-05-31'].", "id": "findings.F-08.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-08's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-08.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-10', 'Talia Brooks'] for F-08.", "id": "findings.F-08.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-09 exception for insurance-limit deficiency.", "id": "findings.F-09.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's id from /workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/025_statements_of_work_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_correspondence/073_correspondence_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's issue from /workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/025_statements_of_work_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_correspondence/073_correspondence_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's severity from /workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/025_statements_of_work_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_correspondence/073_correspondence_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's primary_source from /workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/025_statements_of_work_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_correspondence/073_correspondence_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/025_statements_of_work_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_correspondence/073_correspondence_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-09 using the exact controlled facts ['2025-12-22', 'CB-CC-2503-I933', '2026-02-07', 'CB-CC-2503-R648'].", "id": "findings.F-09.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-09's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-09.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-10', 'Jonas Feld'] for F-09.", "id": "findings.F-09.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-10 exception for audit-right deadline.", "id": "findings.F-10.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's id from /workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/028_statements_of_work_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_correspondence/076_correspondence_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's issue from /workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/028_statements_of_work_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_correspondence/076_correspondence_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's severity from /workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/028_statements_of_work_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_correspondence/076_correspondence_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's primary_source from /workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/028_statements_of_work_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_correspondence/076_correspondence_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/028_statements_of_work_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_correspondence/076_correspondence_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-10 using the exact controlled facts ['$5,503,820.00', '$5,754,140.00'].", "id": "findings.F-10.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-10's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-10.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-10', 'Mei Whitaker'] for F-10.", "id": "findings.F-10.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-11 exception for exclusivity carveout breach.", "id": "findings.F-11.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's id from /workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/031_statements_of_work_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_correspondence/079_correspondence_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's issue from /workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/031_statements_of_work_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_correspondence/079_correspondence_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's severity from /workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/031_statements_of_work_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_correspondence/079_correspondence_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's primary_source from /workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/031_statements_of_work_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_correspondence/079_correspondence_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/031_statements_of_work_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_correspondence/079_correspondence_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-11 using the exact controlled facts ['Nadine Flores', 'Caleb Hassan'].", "id": "findings.F-11.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-11's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-11.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-10', 'Caleb Hassan'] for F-11.", "id": "findings.F-11.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-12 exception for benchmarking right omission.", "id": "findings.F-12.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's id from /workspace/documents/05_pricing/034_pricing_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_policies/082_policies_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's issue from /workspace/documents/05_pricing/034_pricing_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_policies/082_policies_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's severity from /workspace/documents/05_pricing/034_pricing_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_policies/082_policies_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's primary_source from /workspace/documents/05_pricing/034_pricing_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_policies/082_policies_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/05_pricing/034_pricing_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_policies/082_policies_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-12 using the exact controlled facts ['closed without exception', 'CB-CC-2503-L398', 'open and escalated', 'CB-CC-2503-U261'].", "id": "findings.F-12.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-12's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-12.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-10', 'Leona Park'] for F-12.", "id": "findings.F-12.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-13 exception for invoice currency discrepancy.", "id": "findings.F-13.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's id from /workspace/documents/05_pricing/037_pricing_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_policies/085_policies_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's issue from /workspace/documents/05_pricing/037_pricing_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_policies/085_policies_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's severity from /workspace/documents/05_pricing/037_pricing_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_policies/085_policies_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's primary_source from /workspace/documents/05_pricing/037_pricing_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_policies/085_policies_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/05_pricing/037_pricing_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_policies/085_policies_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-13 using the exact controlled facts ['King County, Washington', 'Washington'].", "id": "findings.F-13.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-13's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-13.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-10', 'Isaac Romero'] for F-13.", "id": "findings.F-13.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-14 exception for usage-report inconsistency.", "id": "findings.F-14.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's id from /workspace/documents/05_pricing/040_pricing_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_policies/088_policies_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's issue from /workspace/documents/05_pricing/040_pricing_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_policies/088_policies_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's severity from /workspace/documents/05_pricing/040_pricing_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_policies/088_policies_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's primary_source from /workspace/documents/05_pricing/040_pricing_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_policies/088_policies_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/05_pricing/040_pricing_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_policies/088_policies_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-14 using the exact controlled facts ['7%', '10%'].", "id": "findings.F-14.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-14's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-14.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-10', 'Sofia Bennett'] for F-14.", "id": "findings.F-14.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-15 exception for order-form precedence conflict.", "id": "findings.F-15.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's id from /workspace/documents/06_service_levels/043_service_levels_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/091_renewal_records_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's issue from /workspace/documents/06_service_levels/043_service_levels_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/091_renewal_records_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's severity from /workspace/documents/06_service_levels/043_service_levels_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/091_renewal_records_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's primary_source from /workspace/documents/06_service_levels/043_service_levels_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/091_renewal_records_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/06_service_levels/043_service_levels_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/091_renewal_records_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-15 using the exact controlled facts ['notices-cirrus_laboratory_cloud_llc@example.test', 'archive-quartzline_resellers_ltd@example.test'].", "id": "findings.F-15.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-15's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-15.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-10', 'Adrian Mensah'] for F-15.", "id": "findings.F-15.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-16 exception for survival-clause ambiguity.", "id": "findings.F-16.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's id from /workspace/documents/06_service_levels/046_service_levels_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/094_renewal_records_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's issue from /workspace/documents/06_service_levels/046_service_levels_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/094_renewal_records_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's severity from /workspace/documents/06_service_levels/046_service_levels_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/094_renewal_records_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's primary_source from /workspace/documents/06_service_levels/046_service_levels_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/094_renewal_records_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/06_service_levels/046_service_levels_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/094_renewal_records_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-16 using the exact controlled facts ['53 records', '2025-05-28', '59 records', '2025-06-28'].", "id": "findings.F-16.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-16's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-16.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-10', 'Willa Novak'] for F-16.", "id": "findings.F-16.action_anchors"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Executive assessment' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Executive assessment"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Method and record coverage' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Method and record coverage"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Findings' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Findings"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Recommended next actions' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Recommended next actions"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Assumptions and limitations' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Assumptions and limitations"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-01 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-01"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-02 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-02"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-03 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-03"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-04 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-04"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-05 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-05"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-06 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-06"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-07 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-07"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-08 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-08"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-09 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-09"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-10 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-10"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-11 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-11"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-12 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-12"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-13 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-13"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-14 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-14"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-15 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-15"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-16 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-16"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Do not claim the production has no issues or that every record is consistent.", "id": "memo.forbidden_claims_absent"}], "decision_options": [{"id": "cross-source-reconciliation", "label": "Reconcile controlling and corroborating records", "reason": "The CB-CC-2503 production contains independently maintained records; a defensible answer must preserve each supported conflict and its cure owner.", "selected": true}, {"id": "latest-record-controls", "label": "Treat the latest record as controlling", "reason": "Timestamp recency does not establish legal priority, execution, or approval authority.", "selected": false}, {"id": "primary-records-only", "label": "Report primary records without reconciliation", "reason": "Primary records alone conceal the operational conflicts that create the actionable exceptions.", "selected": false}], "gates": ["all_evidence_read_in_full", "chain_of_custody_metadata_checked", "findings_criteria_complete", "memo_criteria_complete", "deliverables_written_through_mcp"], "metadata_checks": 8, "metric": "weighted_criteria_score", "minimum_tool_calls": 46, "required_deliverables": ["findings.json", "advice.md"], "required_document_reads": 33, "type": "deterministic", "weights": {"findings": 0.55, "memo": 0.2, "procedure": 0.25}}, "task_id": "cb100-013-cirrus-labs", "task_name": "Cirrus cloud-reseller reconciliation", "world_id": "counselbench-filesystem-mcp-v2"}
-{"context_files": ["task_files/cb100-014-driftwood-media/01_master_agreements/001_master_agreements_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-014-driftwood-media/01_master_agreements/002_master_agreements_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-014-driftwood-media/01_master_agreements/003_master_agreements_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-014-driftwood-media/01_master_agreements/004_master_agreements_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-014-driftwood-media/01_master_agreements/005_master_agreements_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-014-driftwood-media/01_master_agreements/006_master_agreements_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-014-driftwood-media/01_master_agreements/007_master_agreements_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-014-driftwood-media/01_master_agreements/008_master_agreements_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-014-driftwood-media/02_order_forms/009_order_forms_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-014-driftwood-media/02_order_forms/010_order_forms_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-014-driftwood-media/02_order_forms/011_order_forms_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-014-driftwood-media/02_order_forms/012_order_forms_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-014-driftwood-media/02_order_forms/013_order_forms_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-014-driftwood-media/02_order_forms/014_order_forms_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-014-driftwood-media/02_order_forms/015_order_forms_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-014-driftwood-media/02_order_forms/016_order_forms_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-014-driftwood-media/03_amendments/017_amendments_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-014-driftwood-media/03_amendments/018_amendments_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-014-driftwood-media/03_amendments/019_amendments_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-014-driftwood-media/03_amendments/020_amendments_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-014-driftwood-media/03_amendments/021_amendments_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-014-driftwood-media/03_amendments/022_amendments_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-014-driftwood-media/03_amendments/023_amendments_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-014-driftwood-media/03_amendments/024_amendments_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-014-driftwood-media/04_statements_of_work/025_statements_of_work_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-014-driftwood-media/04_statements_of_work/026_statements_of_work_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-014-driftwood-media/04_statements_of_work/027_statements_of_work_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-014-driftwood-media/04_statements_of_work/028_statements_of_work_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-014-driftwood-media/04_statements_of_work/029_statements_of_work_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-014-driftwood-media/04_statements_of_work/030_statements_of_work_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-014-driftwood-media/04_statements_of_work/031_statements_of_work_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-014-driftwood-media/04_statements_of_work/032_statements_of_work_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-014-driftwood-media/05_pricing/033_pricing_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-014-driftwood-media/05_pricing/034_pricing_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-014-driftwood-media/05_pricing/035_pricing_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-014-driftwood-media/05_pricing/036_pricing_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-014-driftwood-media/05_pricing/037_pricing_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-014-driftwood-media/05_pricing/038_pricing_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-014-driftwood-media/05_pricing/039_pricing_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-014-driftwood-media/05_pricing/040_pricing_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-014-driftwood-media/06_service_levels/041_service_levels_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-014-driftwood-media/06_service_levels/042_service_levels_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-014-driftwood-media/06_service_levels/043_service_levels_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-014-driftwood-media/06_service_levels/044_service_levels_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-014-driftwood-media/06_service_levels/045_service_levels_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-014-driftwood-media/06_service_levels/046_service_levels_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-014-driftwood-media/06_service_levels/047_service_levels_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-014-driftwood-media/06_service_levels/048_service_levels_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-014-driftwood-media/07_security_privacy/049_security_privacy_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-014-driftwood-media/07_security_privacy/050_security_privacy_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-014-driftwood-media/07_security_privacy/051_security_privacy_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-014-driftwood-media/07_security_privacy/052_security_privacy_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-014-driftwood-media/07_security_privacy/053_security_privacy_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-014-driftwood-media/07_security_privacy/054_security_privacy_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-014-driftwood-media/07_security_privacy/055_security_privacy_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-014-driftwood-media/07_security_privacy/056_security_privacy_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-014-driftwood-media/08_notices/057_notices_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-014-driftwood-media/08_notices/058_notices_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-014-driftwood-media/08_notices/059_notices_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-014-driftwood-media/08_notices/060_notices_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-014-driftwood-media/08_notices/061_notices_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-014-driftwood-media/08_notices/062_notices_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-014-driftwood-media/08_notices/063_notices_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-014-driftwood-media/08_notices/064_notices_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-014-driftwood-media/09_invoices/065_invoices_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-014-driftwood-media/09_invoices/066_invoices_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-014-driftwood-media/09_invoices/067_invoices_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-014-driftwood-media/09_invoices/068_invoices_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-014-driftwood-media/09_invoices/069_invoices_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-014-driftwood-media/09_invoices/070_invoices_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-014-driftwood-media/09_invoices/071_invoices_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-014-driftwood-media/09_invoices/072_invoices_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-014-driftwood-media/10_correspondence/073_correspondence_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-014-driftwood-media/10_correspondence/074_correspondence_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-014-driftwood-media/10_correspondence/075_correspondence_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-014-driftwood-media/10_correspondence/076_correspondence_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-014-driftwood-media/10_correspondence/077_correspondence_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-014-driftwood-media/10_correspondence/078_correspondence_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-014-driftwood-media/10_correspondence/079_correspondence_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-014-driftwood-media/10_correspondence/080_correspondence_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-014-driftwood-media/11_policies/081_policies_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-014-driftwood-media/11_policies/082_policies_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-014-driftwood-media/11_policies/083_policies_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-014-driftwood-media/11_policies/084_policies_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-014-driftwood-media/11_policies/085_policies_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-014-driftwood-media/11_policies/086_policies_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-014-driftwood-media/11_policies/087_policies_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-014-driftwood-media/11_policies/088_policies_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-014-driftwood-media/12_renewal_records/089_renewal_records_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-014-driftwood-media/12_renewal_records/090_renewal_records_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-014-driftwood-media/12_renewal_records/091_renewal_records_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-014-driftwood-media/12_renewal_records/092_renewal_records_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-014-driftwood-media/12_renewal_records/093_renewal_records_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-014-driftwood-media/12_renewal_records/094_renewal_records_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-014-driftwood-media/12_renewal_records/095_renewal_records_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-014-driftwood-media/12_renewal_records/096_renewal_records_status_report.md"], "gold_output": {"advice_markdown": "# Counsel advice — Driftwood content-delivery renewal audit\n\n## Executive assessment\n\nFor Driftwood Media Studios matter CB-CC-2504, the review identified 16 source-supported exceptions requiring action before 2026-09-14. The assessment concerns Palisade Stream Services, Inc. and the supplied record for California.\n\n## Method and record coverage\n\nThe review inventoried all 96 production files, read the 33 controlling, corroborating, and control records, searched the email exports, and checked metadata for the designated chain-of-custody sample. Conclusions are limited to the synthetic production supplied for this benchmark matter.\n\n## Findings\n\n### F-01 — renewal date conflict (critical)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for renewal date conflict: one source states the operative date is 2025-01-31 under control reference CB-CC-2504-A428, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2025-03-12 under response reference CB-CC-2504-J402.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/001_master_agreements_control_register.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/07_security_privacy/049_security_privacy_control_register.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-14, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Maya Ellison.\n\n### F-02 — pricing-escalator mismatch (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for pricing-escalator mismatch: one source states the controlling amount is $4,159,225.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $4,354,950.00.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/004_master_agreements_ledger_export.csv`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/07_security_privacy/052_security_privacy_ledger_export.csv`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-14, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Rafael Okafor.\n\n### F-03 — minimum-commit shortfall (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for minimum-commit shortfall: one source states approval is attributed to Micah Sullivan as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Micah Sullivan and contains no entry for Micah Sullivan.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/007_master_agreements_officer_certificate.html`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/07_security_privacy/055_security_privacy_officer_certificate.html`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-14, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Nora Chen.\n\n### F-04 — service-credit underpayment (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for service-credit underpayment: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-CC-2504-D899, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-CC-2504-M161.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/02_order_forms/010_order_forms_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/08_notices/058_notices_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-14, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Dominic Alvarez.\n\n### F-05 — termination notice defect (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for termination notice defect: one source states the applicable location is Los Angeles County, California, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to California operations outside Los Angeles County, California.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/02_order_forms/013_order_forms_review_memorandum.json`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/08_notices/061_notices_review_memorandum.json`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-14, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Priya Raman.\n\n### F-06 — assignment consent requirement (low)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for assignment consent requirement: one source states the threshold is 2% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 4% and produced a different exception result.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/02_order_forms/016_order_forms_status_report.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/08_notices/064_notices_status_report.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-14, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Elliot Mercer.\n\n### F-07 — data-localization conflict (critical)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for data-localization conflict: one source states formal notice must use notices-driftwood_media_studios@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-palisade_stream_services_inc@example.test.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/03_amendments/019_amendments_correspondence.eml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/09_invoices/067_invoices_correspondence.eml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-14, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Talia Brooks.\n\n### F-08 — subprocessor notice lapse (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for subprocessor notice lapse: one source states the governed population contains 56 records through 2025-05-31, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 59 records through 2025-07-01.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/03_amendments/022_amendments_formal_notice.xml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/09_invoices/070_invoices_formal_notice.xml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-14, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Jonas Feld.\n\n### F-09 — insurance-limit deficiency (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for insurance-limit deficiency: one source states the operative date is 2025-08-22 under control reference CB-CC-2504-I871, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2025-09-12 under response reference CB-CC-2504-R159.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/025_statements_of_work_control_register.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/10_correspondence/073_correspondence_control_register.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-14, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Mei Whitaker.\n\n### F-10 — audit-right deadline (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for audit-right deadline: one source states the controlling amount is $5,137,924.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $5,432,348.00.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/028_statements_of_work_ledger_export.csv`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/10_correspondence/076_correspondence_ledger_export.csv`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-14, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Caleb Hassan.\n\n### F-11 — exclusivity carveout breach (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for exclusivity carveout breach: one source states approval is attributed to Micah Sullivan as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Isaac Romero and contains no entry for Micah Sullivan.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/031_statements_of_work_officer_certificate.html`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/10_correspondence/079_correspondence_officer_certificate.html`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-14, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Leona Park.\n\n### F-12 — benchmarking right omission (low)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for benchmarking right omission: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-CC-2504-L800, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-CC-2504-U569.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/05_pricing/034_pricing_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/11_policies/082_policies_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-14, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Isaac Romero.\n\n### F-13 — invoice currency discrepancy (critical)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for invoice currency discrepancy: one source states the applicable location is Los Angeles County, California, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to California operations outside Los Angeles County, California.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/05_pricing/037_pricing_review_memorandum.json`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/11_policies/085_policies_review_memorandum.json`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-14, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Sofia Bennett.\n\n### F-14 — usage-report inconsistency (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for usage-report inconsistency: one source states the threshold is 13% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 18% and produced a different exception result.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/05_pricing/040_pricing_status_report.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/11_policies/088_policies_status_report.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-14, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Adrian Mensah.\n\n### F-15 — order-form precedence conflict (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for order-form precedence conflict: one source states formal notice must use notices-driftwood_media_studios@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-palisade_stream_services_inc@example.test.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/06_service_levels/043_service_levels_correspondence.eml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/091_renewal_records_correspondence.eml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-14, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Willa Novak.\n\n### F-16 — survival-clause ambiguity (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for survival-clause ambiguity: one source states the governed population contains 176 records through 2025-09-28, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 68 records through 2025-11-07.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/06_service_levels/046_service_levels_formal_notice.xml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/094_renewal_records_formal_notice.xml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-14, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Theo Laurent.\n\n## Recommended next actions\n\nSequence the critical and high findings first, assign the named owners, preserve the cited records, and document any resolution in the controlling matter register before the stated deadline.\n\n## Assumptions and limitations\n\nThis analysis is confined to task cb100-014-driftwood-media and the supplied synthetic evidence. It does not rely on external facts, does not resolve disputed law, and is not legal advice for a real person or entity.\n", "findings": {"as_of": "2026-09-14", "findings": [{"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/07_security_privacy/049_security_privacy_control_register.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for renewal date conflict: one source states the operative date is 2025-01-31 under control reference CB-CC-2504-A428, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2025-03-12 under response reference CB-CC-2504-J402.", "id": "F-01", "issue": "renewal date conflict", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/001_master_agreements_control_register.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-14, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Maya Ellison.", "severity": "critical"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/07_security_privacy/052_security_privacy_ledger_export.csv", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for pricing-escalator mismatch: one source states the controlling amount is $4,159,225.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $4,354,950.00.", "id": "F-02", "issue": "pricing-escalator mismatch", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/004_master_agreements_ledger_export.csv", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-14, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Rafael Okafor.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/07_security_privacy/055_security_privacy_officer_certificate.html", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for minimum-commit shortfall: one source states approval is attributed to Micah Sullivan as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Micah Sullivan and contains no entry for Micah Sullivan.", "id": "F-03", "issue": "minimum-commit shortfall", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/007_master_agreements_officer_certificate.html", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-14, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Nora Chen.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/08_notices/058_notices_executed_instrument.txt", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for service-credit underpayment: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-CC-2504-D899, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-CC-2504-M161.", "id": "F-04", "issue": "service-credit underpayment", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/02_order_forms/010_order_forms_executed_instrument.txt", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-14, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Dominic Alvarez.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/08_notices/061_notices_review_memorandum.json", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for termination notice defect: one source states the applicable location is Los Angeles County, California, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to California operations outside Los Angeles County, California.", "id": "F-05", "issue": "termination notice defect", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/02_order_forms/013_order_forms_review_memorandum.json", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-14, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Priya Raman.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/08_notices/064_notices_status_report.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for assignment consent requirement: one source states the threshold is 2% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 4% and produced a different exception result.", "id": "F-06", "issue": "assignment consent requirement", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/02_order_forms/016_order_forms_status_report.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-14, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Elliot Mercer.", "severity": "low"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/09_invoices/067_invoices_correspondence.eml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for data-localization conflict: one source states formal notice must use notices-driftwood_media_studios@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-palisade_stream_services_inc@example.test.", "id": "F-07", "issue": "data-localization conflict", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/03_amendments/019_amendments_correspondence.eml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-14, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Talia Brooks.", "severity": "critical"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/09_invoices/070_invoices_formal_notice.xml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for subprocessor notice lapse: one source states the governed population contains 56 records through 2025-05-31, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 59 records through 2025-07-01.", "id": "F-08", "issue": "subprocessor notice lapse", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/03_amendments/022_amendments_formal_notice.xml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-14, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Jonas Feld.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/10_correspondence/073_correspondence_control_register.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for insurance-limit deficiency: one source states the operative date is 2025-08-22 under control reference CB-CC-2504-I871, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2025-09-12 under response reference CB-CC-2504-R159.", "id": "F-09", "issue": "insurance-limit deficiency", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/025_statements_of_work_control_register.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-14, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Mei Whitaker.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/10_correspondence/076_correspondence_ledger_export.csv", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for audit-right deadline: one source states the controlling amount is $5,137,924.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $5,432,348.00.", "id": "F-10", "issue": "audit-right deadline", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/028_statements_of_work_ledger_export.csv", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-14, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Caleb Hassan.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/10_correspondence/079_correspondence_officer_certificate.html", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for exclusivity carveout breach: one source states approval is attributed to Micah Sullivan as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Isaac Romero and contains no entry for Micah Sullivan.", "id": "F-11", "issue": "exclusivity carveout breach", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/031_statements_of_work_officer_certificate.html", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-14, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Leona Park.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/11_policies/082_policies_executed_instrument.txt", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for benchmarking right omission: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-CC-2504-L800, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-CC-2504-U569.", "id": "F-12", "issue": "benchmarking right omission", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/05_pricing/034_pricing_executed_instrument.txt", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-14, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Isaac Romero.", "severity": "low"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/11_policies/085_policies_review_memorandum.json", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for invoice currency discrepancy: one source states the applicable location is Los Angeles County, California, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to California operations outside Los Angeles County, California.", "id": "F-13", "issue": "invoice currency discrepancy", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/05_pricing/037_pricing_review_memorandum.json", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-14, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Sofia Bennett.", "severity": "critical"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/11_policies/088_policies_status_report.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for usage-report inconsistency: one source states the threshold is 13% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 18% and produced a different exception result.", "id": "F-14", "issue": "usage-report inconsistency", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/05_pricing/040_pricing_status_report.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-14, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Adrian Mensah.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/091_renewal_records_correspondence.eml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for order-form precedence conflict: one source states formal notice must use notices-driftwood_media_studios@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-palisade_stream_services_inc@example.test.", "id": "F-15", "issue": "order-form precedence conflict", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/06_service_levels/043_service_levels_correspondence.eml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-14, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Willa Novak.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/094_renewal_records_formal_notice.xml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for survival-clause ambiguity: one source states the governed population contains 176 records through 2025-09-28, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 68 records through 2025-11-07.", "id": "F-16", "issue": "survival-clause ambiguity", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/06_service_levels/046_service_levels_formal_notice.xml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-14, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Theo Laurent.", "severity": "medium"}], "matter_number": "CB-CC-2504", "prepared_for": "Driftwood Media Studios", "schema_version": "1.0", "task_id": "cb100-014-driftwood-media"}}, "metadata": {"benchmark": "CounselBench-100", "code_license": "Apache-2.0", "data_license": "CC-BY-4.0", "deadline": "2026-09-14", "document_count": 96, "jurisdiction": "California", "matter_number": "CB-CC-2504", "mcp_commit": "9a96ea6e5913736f92b88345bf51caeaaa8e719f", "mcp_package": "@modelcontextprotocol/server-filesystem@2026.7.10", "practice_area": "commercial-contracts", "reference_tool_calls": 46, "required_evidence_reads": 33, "synthetic": true, "venue": "Los Angeles County, California", "version": "2.0.0"}, "prompt": "You are commercial contracts counsel for Driftwood Media Studios. Several workstreams have maintained separate versions of the truth; your assignment is to produce one auditable legal view. Delivery charges, localization commitments, and service credits diverge across a master agreement, two amendments, and eighteen months of invoices. Decision due 2026-09-14. California law governs; Los Angeles County, California is the forum. Distinguish a missing document from an affirmative contradiction in the documents that are present. Work out the defensible position from the matter production and leave an audit-ready exception tracker and concise advice for the supervising lawyer. Keep confirmed conflicts separate from open questions, cite the records that actually control each conclusion, and do not fill gaps with outside facts.", "rubric": {"criteria": [{"category": "procedure", "description": "Complete at least 46 successful, argument-specific evidence and output calls.", "id": "procedure.minimum_successful_tool_calls"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Find and read the 33 controlling, corroborating, and work-product-control records in full.", "id": "procedure.all_evidence_read_in_full"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Inspect file metadata for the eight designated critical primary records before relying on them.", "id": "procedure.chain_of_custody_metadata_checked"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Confirm the sandbox's allowed document and output roots.", "id": "procedure.allowed_directories_checked"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Inventory all 96 records so the relevant sources are discovered among the context records.", "id": "procedure.recursive_inventory_completed"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Search the production for email evidence that may corroborate or contradict formal records.", "id": "procedure.targeted_search_completed"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Leave only findings.json and advice.md in the output workspace.", "id": "procedure.exact_deliverable_set"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Create both final work products through the sandbox MCP surface.", "id": "procedure.deliverables_written_through_mcp"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Produce findings.json as a valid JSON object.", "id": "findings.findings_is_object"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Report exactly 16 confirmed exceptions.", "id": "findings.findings_exact_count"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Use each stable finding ID exactly once.", "id": "findings.finding_ids_unique"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set schema_version to the released matter value '1.0'.", "id": "findings.top_level_schema_version"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set task_id to the released matter value 'cb100-014-driftwood-media'.", "id": "findings.top_level_task_id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set matter_number to the released matter value 'CB-CC-2504'.", "id": "findings.top_level_matter_number"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set prepared_for to the released matter value 'Driftwood Media Studios'.", "id": "findings.top_level_prepared_for"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set as_of to the released matter value '2026-09-14'.", "id": "findings.top_level_as_of"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-01 exception for renewal date conflict.", "id": "findings.F-01.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's id from /workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/001_master_agreements_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_security_privacy/049_security_privacy_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's issue from /workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/001_master_agreements_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_security_privacy/049_security_privacy_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's severity from /workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/001_master_agreements_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_security_privacy/049_security_privacy_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's primary_source from /workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/001_master_agreements_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_security_privacy/049_security_privacy_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/001_master_agreements_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_security_privacy/049_security_privacy_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-01 using the exact controlled facts ['2025-01-31', 'CB-CC-2504-A428', '2025-03-12', 'CB-CC-2504-J402'].", "id": "findings.F-01.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-01's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-01.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-14', 'Maya Ellison'] for F-01.", "id": "findings.F-01.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-02 exception for pricing-escalator mismatch.", "id": "findings.F-02.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's id from /workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/004_master_agreements_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_security_privacy/052_security_privacy_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's issue from /workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/004_master_agreements_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_security_privacy/052_security_privacy_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's severity from /workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/004_master_agreements_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_security_privacy/052_security_privacy_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's primary_source from /workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/004_master_agreements_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_security_privacy/052_security_privacy_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/004_master_agreements_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_security_privacy/052_security_privacy_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-02 using the exact controlled facts ['$4,159,225.00', '$4,354,950.00'].", "id": "findings.F-02.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-02's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-02.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-14', 'Rafael Okafor'] for F-02.", "id": "findings.F-02.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-03 exception for minimum-commit shortfall.", "id": "findings.F-03.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's id from /workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/007_master_agreements_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_security_privacy/055_security_privacy_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's issue from /workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/007_master_agreements_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_security_privacy/055_security_privacy_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's severity from /workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/007_master_agreements_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_security_privacy/055_security_privacy_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's primary_source from /workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/007_master_agreements_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_security_privacy/055_security_privacy_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/007_master_agreements_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_security_privacy/055_security_privacy_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-03 using the exact controlled facts ['Micah Sullivan', 'Micah Sullivan'].", "id": "findings.F-03.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-03's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-03.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-14', 'Nora Chen'] for F-03.", "id": "findings.F-03.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-04 exception for service-credit underpayment.", "id": "findings.F-04.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's id from /workspace/documents/02_order_forms/010_order_forms_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_notices/058_notices_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's issue from /workspace/documents/02_order_forms/010_order_forms_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_notices/058_notices_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's severity from /workspace/documents/02_order_forms/010_order_forms_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_notices/058_notices_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's primary_source from /workspace/documents/02_order_forms/010_order_forms_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_notices/058_notices_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/02_order_forms/010_order_forms_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_notices/058_notices_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-04 using the exact controlled facts ['closed without exception', 'CB-CC-2504-D899', 'open and escalated', 'CB-CC-2504-M161'].", "id": "findings.F-04.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-04's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-04.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-14', 'Dominic Alvarez'] for F-04.", "id": "findings.F-04.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-05 exception for termination notice defect.", "id": "findings.F-05.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's id from /workspace/documents/02_order_forms/013_order_forms_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_notices/061_notices_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's issue from /workspace/documents/02_order_forms/013_order_forms_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_notices/061_notices_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's severity from /workspace/documents/02_order_forms/013_order_forms_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_notices/061_notices_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's primary_source from /workspace/documents/02_order_forms/013_order_forms_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_notices/061_notices_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/02_order_forms/013_order_forms_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_notices/061_notices_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-05 using the exact controlled facts ['Los Angeles County, California', 'California'].", "id": "findings.F-05.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-05's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-05.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-14', 'Priya Raman'] for F-05.", "id": "findings.F-05.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-06 exception for assignment consent requirement.", "id": "findings.F-06.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's id from /workspace/documents/02_order_forms/016_order_forms_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_notices/064_notices_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's issue from /workspace/documents/02_order_forms/016_order_forms_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_notices/064_notices_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's severity from /workspace/documents/02_order_forms/016_order_forms_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_notices/064_notices_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's primary_source from /workspace/documents/02_order_forms/016_order_forms_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_notices/064_notices_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/02_order_forms/016_order_forms_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_notices/064_notices_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-06 using the exact controlled facts ['2%', '4%'].", "id": "findings.F-06.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-06's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-06.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-14', 'Elliot Mercer'] for F-06.", "id": "findings.F-06.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-07 exception for data-localization conflict.", "id": "findings.F-07.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's id from /workspace/documents/03_amendments/019_amendments_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_invoices/067_invoices_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's issue from /workspace/documents/03_amendments/019_amendments_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_invoices/067_invoices_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's severity from /workspace/documents/03_amendments/019_amendments_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_invoices/067_invoices_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's primary_source from /workspace/documents/03_amendments/019_amendments_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_invoices/067_invoices_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/03_amendments/019_amendments_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_invoices/067_invoices_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-07 using the exact controlled facts ['notices-driftwood_media_studios@example.test', 'archive-palisade_stream_services_inc@example.test'].", "id": "findings.F-07.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-07's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-07.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-14', 'Talia Brooks'] for F-07.", "id": "findings.F-07.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-08 exception for subprocessor notice lapse.", "id": "findings.F-08.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's id from /workspace/documents/03_amendments/022_amendments_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_invoices/070_invoices_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's issue from /workspace/documents/03_amendments/022_amendments_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_invoices/070_invoices_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's severity from /workspace/documents/03_amendments/022_amendments_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_invoices/070_invoices_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's primary_source from /workspace/documents/03_amendments/022_amendments_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_invoices/070_invoices_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/03_amendments/022_amendments_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_invoices/070_invoices_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-08 using the exact controlled facts ['56 records', '2025-05-31', '59 records', '2025-07-01'].", "id": "findings.F-08.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-08's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-08.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-14', 'Jonas Feld'] for F-08.", "id": "findings.F-08.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-09 exception for insurance-limit deficiency.", "id": "findings.F-09.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's id from /workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/025_statements_of_work_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_correspondence/073_correspondence_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's issue from /workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/025_statements_of_work_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_correspondence/073_correspondence_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's severity from /workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/025_statements_of_work_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_correspondence/073_correspondence_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's primary_source from /workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/025_statements_of_work_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_correspondence/073_correspondence_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/025_statements_of_work_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_correspondence/073_correspondence_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-09 using the exact controlled facts ['2025-08-22', 'CB-CC-2504-I871', '2025-09-12', 'CB-CC-2504-R159'].", "id": "findings.F-09.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-09's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-09.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-14', 'Mei Whitaker'] for F-09.", "id": "findings.F-09.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-10 exception for audit-right deadline.", "id": "findings.F-10.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's id from /workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/028_statements_of_work_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_correspondence/076_correspondence_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's issue from /workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/028_statements_of_work_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_correspondence/076_correspondence_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's severity from /workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/028_statements_of_work_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_correspondence/076_correspondence_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's primary_source from /workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/028_statements_of_work_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_correspondence/076_correspondence_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/028_statements_of_work_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_correspondence/076_correspondence_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-10 using the exact controlled facts ['$5,137,924.00', '$5,432,348.00'].", "id": "findings.F-10.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-10's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-10.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-14', 'Caleb Hassan'] for F-10.", "id": "findings.F-10.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-11 exception for exclusivity carveout breach.", "id": "findings.F-11.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's id from /workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/031_statements_of_work_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_correspondence/079_correspondence_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's issue from /workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/031_statements_of_work_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_correspondence/079_correspondence_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's severity from /workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/031_statements_of_work_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_correspondence/079_correspondence_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's primary_source from /workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/031_statements_of_work_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_correspondence/079_correspondence_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/031_statements_of_work_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_correspondence/079_correspondence_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-11 using the exact controlled facts ['Micah Sullivan', 'Isaac Romero'].", "id": "findings.F-11.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-11's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-11.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-14', 'Leona Park'] for F-11.", "id": "findings.F-11.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-12 exception for benchmarking right omission.", "id": "findings.F-12.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's id from /workspace/documents/05_pricing/034_pricing_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_policies/082_policies_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's issue from /workspace/documents/05_pricing/034_pricing_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_policies/082_policies_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's severity from /workspace/documents/05_pricing/034_pricing_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_policies/082_policies_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's primary_source from /workspace/documents/05_pricing/034_pricing_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_policies/082_policies_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/05_pricing/034_pricing_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_policies/082_policies_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-12 using the exact controlled facts ['closed without exception', 'CB-CC-2504-L800', 'open and escalated', 'CB-CC-2504-U569'].", "id": "findings.F-12.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-12's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-12.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-14', 'Isaac Romero'] for F-12.", "id": "findings.F-12.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-13 exception for invoice currency discrepancy.", "id": "findings.F-13.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's id from /workspace/documents/05_pricing/037_pricing_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_policies/085_policies_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's issue from /workspace/documents/05_pricing/037_pricing_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_policies/085_policies_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's severity from /workspace/documents/05_pricing/037_pricing_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_policies/085_policies_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's primary_source from /workspace/documents/05_pricing/037_pricing_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_policies/085_policies_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/05_pricing/037_pricing_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_policies/085_policies_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-13 using the exact controlled facts ['Los Angeles County, California', 'California'].", "id": "findings.F-13.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-13's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-13.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-14', 'Sofia Bennett'] for F-13.", "id": "findings.F-13.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-14 exception for usage-report inconsistency.", "id": "findings.F-14.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's id from /workspace/documents/05_pricing/040_pricing_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_policies/088_policies_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's issue from /workspace/documents/05_pricing/040_pricing_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_policies/088_policies_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's severity from /workspace/documents/05_pricing/040_pricing_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_policies/088_policies_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's primary_source from /workspace/documents/05_pricing/040_pricing_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_policies/088_policies_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/05_pricing/040_pricing_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_policies/088_policies_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-14 using the exact controlled facts ['13%', '18%'].", "id": "findings.F-14.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-14's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-14.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-14', 'Adrian Mensah'] for F-14.", "id": "findings.F-14.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-15 exception for order-form precedence conflict.", "id": "findings.F-15.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's id from /workspace/documents/06_service_levels/043_service_levels_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/091_renewal_records_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's issue from /workspace/documents/06_service_levels/043_service_levels_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/091_renewal_records_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's severity from /workspace/documents/06_service_levels/043_service_levels_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/091_renewal_records_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's primary_source from /workspace/documents/06_service_levels/043_service_levels_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/091_renewal_records_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/06_service_levels/043_service_levels_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/091_renewal_records_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-15 using the exact controlled facts ['notices-driftwood_media_studios@example.test', 'archive-palisade_stream_services_inc@example.test'].", "id": "findings.F-15.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-15's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-15.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-14', 'Willa Novak'] for F-15.", "id": "findings.F-15.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-16 exception for survival-clause ambiguity.", "id": "findings.F-16.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's id from /workspace/documents/06_service_levels/046_service_levels_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/094_renewal_records_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's issue from /workspace/documents/06_service_levels/046_service_levels_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/094_renewal_records_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's severity from /workspace/documents/06_service_levels/046_service_levels_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/094_renewal_records_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's primary_source from /workspace/documents/06_service_levels/046_service_levels_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/094_renewal_records_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/06_service_levels/046_service_levels_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/094_renewal_records_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-16 using the exact controlled facts ['176 records', '2025-09-28', '68 records', '2025-11-07'].", "id": "findings.F-16.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-16's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-16.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-14', 'Theo Laurent'] for F-16.", "id": "findings.F-16.action_anchors"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Executive assessment' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Executive assessment"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Method and record coverage' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Method and record coverage"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Findings' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Findings"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Recommended next actions' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Recommended next actions"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Assumptions and limitations' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Assumptions and limitations"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-01 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-01"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-02 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-02"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-03 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-03"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-04 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-04"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-05 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-05"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-06 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-06"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-07 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-07"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-08 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-08"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-09 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-09"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-10 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-10"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-11 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-11"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-12 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-12"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-13 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-13"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-14 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-14"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-15 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-15"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-16 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-16"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Do not claim the production has no issues or that every record is consistent.", "id": "memo.forbidden_claims_absent"}], "decision_options": [{"id": "cross-source-reconciliation", "label": "Reconcile controlling and corroborating records", "reason": "The CB-CC-2504 production contains independently maintained records; a defensible answer must preserve each supported conflict and its cure owner.", "selected": true}, {"id": "latest-record-controls", "label": "Treat the latest record as controlling", "reason": "Timestamp recency does not establish legal priority, execution, or approval authority.", "selected": false}, {"id": "primary-records-only", "label": "Report primary records without reconciliation", "reason": "Primary records alone conceal the operational conflicts that create the actionable exceptions.", "selected": false}], "gates": ["all_evidence_read_in_full", "chain_of_custody_metadata_checked", "findings_criteria_complete", "memo_criteria_complete", "deliverables_written_through_mcp"], "metadata_checks": 8, "metric": "weighted_criteria_score", "minimum_tool_calls": 46, "required_deliverables": ["findings.json", "advice.md"], "required_document_reads": 33, "type": "deterministic", "weights": {"findings": 0.55, "memo": 0.2, "procedure": 0.25}}, "task_id": "cb100-014-driftwood-media", "task_name": "Driftwood content-delivery renewal audit", "world_id": "counselbench-filesystem-mcp-v2"}
-{"context_files": ["task_files/cb100-015-ember-medical/01_master_agreements/001_master_agreements_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-015-ember-medical/01_master_agreements/002_master_agreements_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-015-ember-medical/01_master_agreements/003_master_agreements_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-015-ember-medical/01_master_agreements/004_master_agreements_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-015-ember-medical/01_master_agreements/005_master_agreements_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-015-ember-medical/01_master_agreements/006_master_agreements_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-015-ember-medical/01_master_agreements/007_master_agreements_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-015-ember-medical/01_master_agreements/008_master_agreements_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-015-ember-medical/02_order_forms/009_order_forms_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-015-ember-medical/02_order_forms/010_order_forms_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-015-ember-medical/02_order_forms/011_order_forms_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-015-ember-medical/02_order_forms/012_order_forms_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-015-ember-medical/02_order_forms/013_order_forms_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-015-ember-medical/02_order_forms/014_order_forms_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-015-ember-medical/02_order_forms/015_order_forms_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-015-ember-medical/02_order_forms/016_order_forms_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-015-ember-medical/03_amendments/017_amendments_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-015-ember-medical/03_amendments/018_amendments_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-015-ember-medical/03_amendments/019_amendments_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-015-ember-medical/03_amendments/020_amendments_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-015-ember-medical/03_amendments/021_amendments_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-015-ember-medical/03_amendments/022_amendments_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-015-ember-medical/03_amendments/023_amendments_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-015-ember-medical/03_amendments/024_amendments_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-015-ember-medical/04_statements_of_work/025_statements_of_work_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-015-ember-medical/04_statements_of_work/026_statements_of_work_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-015-ember-medical/04_statements_of_work/027_statements_of_work_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-015-ember-medical/04_statements_of_work/028_statements_of_work_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-015-ember-medical/04_statements_of_work/029_statements_of_work_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-015-ember-medical/04_statements_of_work/030_statements_of_work_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-015-ember-medical/04_statements_of_work/031_statements_of_work_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-015-ember-medical/04_statements_of_work/032_statements_of_work_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-015-ember-medical/05_pricing/033_pricing_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-015-ember-medical/05_pricing/034_pricing_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-015-ember-medical/05_pricing/035_pricing_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-015-ember-medical/05_pricing/036_pricing_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-015-ember-medical/05_pricing/037_pricing_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-015-ember-medical/05_pricing/038_pricing_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-015-ember-medical/05_pricing/039_pricing_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-015-ember-medical/05_pricing/040_pricing_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-015-ember-medical/06_service_levels/041_service_levels_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-015-ember-medical/06_service_levels/042_service_levels_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-015-ember-medical/06_service_levels/043_service_levels_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-015-ember-medical/06_service_levels/044_service_levels_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-015-ember-medical/06_service_levels/045_service_levels_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-015-ember-medical/06_service_levels/046_service_levels_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-015-ember-medical/06_service_levels/047_service_levels_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-015-ember-medical/06_service_levels/048_service_levels_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-015-ember-medical/07_security_privacy/049_security_privacy_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-015-ember-medical/07_security_privacy/050_security_privacy_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-015-ember-medical/07_security_privacy/051_security_privacy_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-015-ember-medical/07_security_privacy/052_security_privacy_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-015-ember-medical/07_security_privacy/053_security_privacy_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-015-ember-medical/07_security_privacy/054_security_privacy_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-015-ember-medical/07_security_privacy/055_security_privacy_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-015-ember-medical/07_security_privacy/056_security_privacy_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-015-ember-medical/08_notices/057_notices_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-015-ember-medical/08_notices/058_notices_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-015-ember-medical/08_notices/059_notices_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-015-ember-medical/08_notices/060_notices_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-015-ember-medical/08_notices/061_notices_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-015-ember-medical/08_notices/062_notices_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-015-ember-medical/08_notices/063_notices_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-015-ember-medical/08_notices/064_notices_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-015-ember-medical/09_invoices/065_invoices_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-015-ember-medical/09_invoices/066_invoices_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-015-ember-medical/09_invoices/067_invoices_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-015-ember-medical/09_invoices/068_invoices_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-015-ember-medical/09_invoices/069_invoices_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-015-ember-medical/09_invoices/070_invoices_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-015-ember-medical/09_invoices/071_invoices_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-015-ember-medical/09_invoices/072_invoices_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-015-ember-medical/10_correspondence/073_correspondence_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-015-ember-medical/10_correspondence/074_correspondence_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-015-ember-medical/10_correspondence/075_correspondence_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-015-ember-medical/10_correspondence/076_correspondence_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-015-ember-medical/10_correspondence/077_correspondence_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-015-ember-medical/10_correspondence/078_correspondence_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-015-ember-medical/10_correspondence/079_correspondence_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-015-ember-medical/10_correspondence/080_correspondence_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-015-ember-medical/11_policies/081_policies_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-015-ember-medical/11_policies/082_policies_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-015-ember-medical/11_policies/083_policies_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-015-ember-medical/11_policies/084_policies_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-015-ember-medical/11_policies/085_policies_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-015-ember-medical/11_policies/086_policies_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-015-ember-medical/11_policies/087_policies_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-015-ember-medical/11_policies/088_policies_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-015-ember-medical/12_renewal_records/089_renewal_records_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-015-ember-medical/12_renewal_records/090_renewal_records_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-015-ember-medical/12_renewal_records/091_renewal_records_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-015-ember-medical/12_renewal_records/092_renewal_records_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-015-ember-medical/12_renewal_records/093_renewal_records_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-015-ember-medical/12_renewal_records/094_renewal_records_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-015-ember-medical/12_renewal_records/095_renewal_records_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-015-ember-medical/12_renewal_records/096_renewal_records_status_report.md"], "gold_output": {"advice_markdown": "# Counsel advice — Ember device-support contract triage\n\n## Executive assessment\n\nFor Ember Medical Devices matter CB-CC-2505, the review identified 16 source-supported exceptions requiring action before 2026-09-17. The assessment concerns Keystone Field Support LLC and the supplied record for Minnesota.\n\n## Method and record coverage\n\nThe review inventoried all 96 production files, read the 33 controlling, corroborating, and control records, searched the email exports, and checked metadata for the designated chain-of-custody sample. Conclusions are limited to the synthetic production supplied for this benchmark matter.\n\n## Findings\n\n### F-01 — renewal date conflict (critical)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for renewal date conflict: one source states the operative date is 2025-07-29 under control reference CB-CC-2505-A187, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2025-08-31 under response reference CB-CC-2505-J175.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/001_master_agreements_control_register.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/07_security_privacy/049_security_privacy_control_register.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-17, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Rafael Okafor.\n\n### F-02 — pricing-escalator mismatch (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for pricing-escalator mismatch: one source states the controlling amount is $3,795,369.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $3,997,238.00.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/004_master_agreements_ledger_export.csv`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/07_security_privacy/052_security_privacy_ledger_export.csv`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-17, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Nora Chen.\n\n### F-03 — minimum-commit shortfall (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for minimum-commit shortfall: one source states approval is attributed to Farah Ibrahim as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Owen Delgado and contains no entry for Farah Ibrahim.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/007_master_agreements_officer_certificate.html`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/07_security_privacy/055_security_privacy_officer_certificate.html`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-17, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Dominic Alvarez.\n\n### F-04 — service-credit underpayment (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for service-credit underpayment: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-CC-2505-D720, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-CC-2505-M286.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/02_order_forms/010_order_forms_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/08_notices/058_notices_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-17, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Priya Raman.\n\n### F-05 — termination notice defect (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for termination notice defect: one source states the applicable location is Hennepin County, Minnesota, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to Minnesota operations outside Hennepin County, Minnesota.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/02_order_forms/013_order_forms_review_memorandum.json`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/08_notices/061_notices_review_memorandum.json`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-17, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Elliot Mercer.\n\n### F-06 — assignment consent requirement (low)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for assignment consent requirement: one source states the threshold is 6% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 10% and produced a different exception result.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/02_order_forms/016_order_forms_status_report.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/08_notices/064_notices_status_report.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-17, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Talia Brooks.\n\n### F-07 — data-localization conflict (critical)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for data-localization conflict: one source states formal notice must use notices-ember_medical_devices@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-keystone_field_support_llc@example.test.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/03_amendments/019_amendments_correspondence.eml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/09_invoices/067_invoices_correspondence.eml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-17, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Jonas Feld.\n\n### F-08 — subprocessor notice lapse (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for subprocessor notice lapse: one source states the governed population contains 62 records through 2025-01-17, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 57 records through 2025-02-15.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/03_amendments/022_amendments_formal_notice.xml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/09_invoices/070_invoices_formal_notice.xml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-17, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Mei Whitaker.\n\n### F-09 — insurance-limit deficiency (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for insurance-limit deficiency: one source states the operative date is 2025-03-16 under control reference CB-CC-2505-I832, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2025-03-28 under response reference CB-CC-2505-R156.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/025_statements_of_work_control_register.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/10_correspondence/073_correspondence_control_register.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-17, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Caleb Hassan.\n\n### F-10 — audit-right deadline (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for audit-right deadline: one source states the controlling amount is $5,379,100.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $5,564,700.00.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/028_statements_of_work_ledger_export.csv`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/10_correspondence/076_correspondence_ledger_export.csv`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-17, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Leona Park.\n\n### F-11 — exclusivity carveout breach (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for exclusivity carveout breach: one source states approval is attributed to Farah Ibrahim as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Adrian Mensah and contains no entry for Farah Ibrahim.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/031_statements_of_work_officer_certificate.html`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/10_correspondence/079_correspondence_officer_certificate.html`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-17, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Isaac Romero.\n\n### F-12 — benchmarking right omission (low)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for benchmarking right omission: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-CC-2505-L186, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-CC-2505-U591.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/05_pricing/034_pricing_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/11_policies/082_policies_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-17, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Sofia Bennett.\n\n### F-13 — invoice currency discrepancy (critical)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for invoice currency discrepancy: one source states the applicable location is Hennepin County, Minnesota, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to Minnesota operations outside Hennepin County, Minnesota.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/05_pricing/037_pricing_review_memorandum.json`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/11_policies/085_policies_review_memorandum.json`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-17, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Adrian Mensah.\n\n### F-14 — usage-report inconsistency (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for usage-report inconsistency: one source states the threshold is 7% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 14% and produced a different exception result.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/05_pricing/040_pricing_status_report.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/11_policies/088_policies_status_report.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-17, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Willa Novak.\n\n### F-15 — order-form precedence conflict (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for order-form precedence conflict: one source states formal notice must use notices-ember_medical_devices@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-keystone_field_support_llc@example.test.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/06_service_levels/043_service_levels_correspondence.eml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/091_renewal_records_correspondence.eml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-17, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Theo Laurent.\n\n### F-16 — survival-clause ambiguity (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for survival-clause ambiguity: one source states the governed population contains 171 records through 2025-05-06, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 65 records through 2025-06-12.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/06_service_levels/046_service_levels_formal_notice.xml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/094_renewal_records_formal_notice.xml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-17, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Amara Patel.\n\n## Recommended next actions\n\nSequence the critical and high findings first, assign the named owners, preserve the cited records, and document any resolution in the controlling matter register before the stated deadline.\n\n## Assumptions and limitations\n\nThis analysis is confined to task cb100-015-ember-medical and the supplied synthetic evidence. It does not rely on external facts, does not resolve disputed law, and is not legal advice for a real person or entity.\n", "findings": {"as_of": "2026-09-17", "findings": [{"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/07_security_privacy/049_security_privacy_control_register.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for renewal date conflict: one source states the operative date is 2025-07-29 under control reference CB-CC-2505-A187, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2025-08-31 under response reference CB-CC-2505-J175.", "id": "F-01", "issue": "renewal date conflict", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/001_master_agreements_control_register.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-17, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Rafael Okafor.", "severity": "critical"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/07_security_privacy/052_security_privacy_ledger_export.csv", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for pricing-escalator mismatch: one source states the controlling amount is $3,795,369.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $3,997,238.00.", "id": "F-02", "issue": "pricing-escalator mismatch", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/004_master_agreements_ledger_export.csv", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-17, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Nora Chen.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/07_security_privacy/055_security_privacy_officer_certificate.html", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for minimum-commit shortfall: one source states approval is attributed to Farah Ibrahim as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Owen Delgado and contains no entry for Farah Ibrahim.", "id": "F-03", "issue": "minimum-commit shortfall", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/007_master_agreements_officer_certificate.html", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-17, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Dominic Alvarez.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/08_notices/058_notices_executed_instrument.txt", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for service-credit underpayment: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-CC-2505-D720, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-CC-2505-M286.", "id": "F-04", "issue": "service-credit underpayment", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/02_order_forms/010_order_forms_executed_instrument.txt", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-17, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Priya Raman.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/08_notices/061_notices_review_memorandum.json", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for termination notice defect: one source states the applicable location is Hennepin County, Minnesota, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to Minnesota operations outside Hennepin County, Minnesota.", "id": "F-05", "issue": "termination notice defect", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/02_order_forms/013_order_forms_review_memorandum.json", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-17, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Elliot Mercer.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/08_notices/064_notices_status_report.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for assignment consent requirement: one source states the threshold is 6% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 10% and produced a different exception result.", "id": "F-06", "issue": "assignment consent requirement", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/02_order_forms/016_order_forms_status_report.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-17, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Talia Brooks.", "severity": "low"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/09_invoices/067_invoices_correspondence.eml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for data-localization conflict: one source states formal notice must use notices-ember_medical_devices@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-keystone_field_support_llc@example.test.", "id": "F-07", "issue": "data-localization conflict", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/03_amendments/019_amendments_correspondence.eml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-17, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Jonas Feld.", "severity": "critical"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/09_invoices/070_invoices_formal_notice.xml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for subprocessor notice lapse: one source states the governed population contains 62 records through 2025-01-17, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 57 records through 2025-02-15.", "id": "F-08", "issue": "subprocessor notice lapse", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/03_amendments/022_amendments_formal_notice.xml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-17, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Mei Whitaker.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/10_correspondence/073_correspondence_control_register.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for insurance-limit deficiency: one source states the operative date is 2025-03-16 under control reference CB-CC-2505-I832, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2025-03-28 under response reference CB-CC-2505-R156.", "id": "F-09", "issue": "insurance-limit deficiency", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/025_statements_of_work_control_register.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-17, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Caleb Hassan.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/10_correspondence/076_correspondence_ledger_export.csv", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for audit-right deadline: one source states the controlling amount is $5,379,100.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $5,564,700.00.", "id": "F-10", "issue": "audit-right deadline", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/028_statements_of_work_ledger_export.csv", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-17, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Leona Park.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/10_correspondence/079_correspondence_officer_certificate.html", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for exclusivity carveout breach: one source states approval is attributed to Farah Ibrahim as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Adrian Mensah and contains no entry for Farah Ibrahim.", "id": "F-11", "issue": "exclusivity carveout breach", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/031_statements_of_work_officer_certificate.html", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-17, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Isaac Romero.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/11_policies/082_policies_executed_instrument.txt", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for benchmarking right omission: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-CC-2505-L186, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-CC-2505-U591.", "id": "F-12", "issue": "benchmarking right omission", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/05_pricing/034_pricing_executed_instrument.txt", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-17, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Sofia Bennett.", "severity": "low"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/11_policies/085_policies_review_memorandum.json", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for invoice currency discrepancy: one source states the applicable location is Hennepin County, Minnesota, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to Minnesota operations outside Hennepin County, Minnesota.", "id": "F-13", "issue": "invoice currency discrepancy", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/05_pricing/037_pricing_review_memorandum.json", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-17, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Adrian Mensah.", "severity": "critical"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/11_policies/088_policies_status_report.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for usage-report inconsistency: one source states the threshold is 7% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 14% and produced a different exception result.", "id": "F-14", "issue": "usage-report inconsistency", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/05_pricing/040_pricing_status_report.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-17, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Willa Novak.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/091_renewal_records_correspondence.eml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for order-form precedence conflict: one source states formal notice must use notices-ember_medical_devices@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-keystone_field_support_llc@example.test.", "id": "F-15", "issue": "order-form precedence conflict", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/06_service_levels/043_service_levels_correspondence.eml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-17, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Theo Laurent.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/094_renewal_records_formal_notice.xml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for survival-clause ambiguity: one source states the governed population contains 171 records through 2025-05-06, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 65 records through 2025-06-12.", "id": "F-16", "issue": "survival-clause ambiguity", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/06_service_levels/046_service_levels_formal_notice.xml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-17, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Amara Patel.", "severity": "medium"}], "matter_number": "CB-CC-2505", "prepared_for": "Ember Medical Devices", "schema_version": "1.0", "task_id": "cb100-015-ember-medical"}}, "metadata": {"benchmark": "CounselBench-100", "code_license": "Apache-2.0", "data_license": "CC-BY-4.0", "deadline": "2026-09-17", "document_count": 96, "jurisdiction": "Minnesota", "matter_number": "CB-CC-2505", "mcp_commit": "9a96ea6e5913736f92b88345bf51caeaaa8e719f", "mcp_package": "@modelcontextprotocol/server-filesystem@2026.7.10", "practice_area": "commercial-contracts", "reference_tool_calls": 46, "required_evidence_reads": 33, "synthetic": true, "venue": "Hennepin County, Minnesota", "version": "2.0.0"}, "prompt": "You are commercial contracts counsel for Ember Medical Devices. Outside counsel inherited this file after turnover on the client team and must validate every operative record before advising. A national maintenance vendor missed response targets and added subcontractors without completing required background or insurance documentation. Decision due 2026-09-17. Minnesota law governs; Hennepin County, Minnesota is the forum. Evaluate both legal consequence and the practical owner needed to cure each exception. Work out the defensible position from the matter production and leave an audit-ready exception tracker and concise advice for the supervising lawyer. Keep confirmed conflicts separate from open questions, cite the records that actually control each conclusion, and do not fill gaps with outside facts.", "rubric": {"criteria": [{"category": "procedure", "description": "Complete at least 46 successful, argument-specific evidence and output calls.", "id": "procedure.minimum_successful_tool_calls"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Find and read the 33 controlling, corroborating, and work-product-control records in full.", "id": "procedure.all_evidence_read_in_full"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Inspect file metadata for the eight designated critical primary records before relying on them.", "id": "procedure.chain_of_custody_metadata_checked"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Confirm the sandbox's allowed document and output roots.", "id": "procedure.allowed_directories_checked"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Inventory all 96 records so the relevant sources are discovered among the context records.", "id": "procedure.recursive_inventory_completed"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Search the production for email evidence that may corroborate or contradict formal records.", "id": "procedure.targeted_search_completed"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Leave only findings.json and advice.md in the output workspace.", "id": "procedure.exact_deliverable_set"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Create both final work products through the sandbox MCP surface.", "id": "procedure.deliverables_written_through_mcp"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Produce findings.json as a valid JSON object.", "id": "findings.findings_is_object"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Report exactly 16 confirmed exceptions.", "id": "findings.findings_exact_count"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Use each stable finding ID exactly once.", "id": "findings.finding_ids_unique"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set schema_version to the released matter value '1.0'.", "id": "findings.top_level_schema_version"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set task_id to the released matter value 'cb100-015-ember-medical'.", "id": "findings.top_level_task_id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set matter_number to the released matter value 'CB-CC-2505'.", "id": "findings.top_level_matter_number"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set prepared_for to the released matter value 'Ember Medical Devices'.", "id": "findings.top_level_prepared_for"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set as_of to the released matter value '2026-09-17'.", "id": "findings.top_level_as_of"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-01 exception for renewal date conflict.", "id": "findings.F-01.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's id from /workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/001_master_agreements_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_security_privacy/049_security_privacy_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's issue from /workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/001_master_agreements_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_security_privacy/049_security_privacy_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's severity from /workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/001_master_agreements_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_security_privacy/049_security_privacy_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's primary_source from /workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/001_master_agreements_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_security_privacy/049_security_privacy_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/001_master_agreements_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_security_privacy/049_security_privacy_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-01 using the exact controlled facts ['2025-07-29', 'CB-CC-2505-A187', '2025-08-31', 'CB-CC-2505-J175'].", "id": "findings.F-01.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-01's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-01.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-17', 'Rafael Okafor'] for F-01.", "id": "findings.F-01.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-02 exception for pricing-escalator mismatch.", "id": "findings.F-02.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's id from /workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/004_master_agreements_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_security_privacy/052_security_privacy_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's issue from /workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/004_master_agreements_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_security_privacy/052_security_privacy_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's severity from /workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/004_master_agreements_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_security_privacy/052_security_privacy_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's primary_source from /workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/004_master_agreements_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_security_privacy/052_security_privacy_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/004_master_agreements_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_security_privacy/052_security_privacy_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-02 using the exact controlled facts ['$3,795,369.00', '$3,997,238.00'].", "id": "findings.F-02.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-02's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-02.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-17', 'Nora Chen'] for F-02.", "id": "findings.F-02.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-03 exception for minimum-commit shortfall.", "id": "findings.F-03.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's id from /workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/007_master_agreements_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_security_privacy/055_security_privacy_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's issue from /workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/007_master_agreements_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_security_privacy/055_security_privacy_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's severity from /workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/007_master_agreements_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_security_privacy/055_security_privacy_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's primary_source from /workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/007_master_agreements_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_security_privacy/055_security_privacy_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/007_master_agreements_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_security_privacy/055_security_privacy_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-03 using the exact controlled facts ['Farah Ibrahim', 'Owen Delgado'].", "id": "findings.F-03.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-03's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-03.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-17', 'Dominic Alvarez'] for F-03.", "id": "findings.F-03.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-04 exception for service-credit underpayment.", "id": "findings.F-04.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's id from /workspace/documents/02_order_forms/010_order_forms_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_notices/058_notices_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's issue from /workspace/documents/02_order_forms/010_order_forms_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_notices/058_notices_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's severity from /workspace/documents/02_order_forms/010_order_forms_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_notices/058_notices_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's primary_source from /workspace/documents/02_order_forms/010_order_forms_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_notices/058_notices_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/02_order_forms/010_order_forms_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_notices/058_notices_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-04 using the exact controlled facts ['closed without exception', 'CB-CC-2505-D720', 'open and escalated', 'CB-CC-2505-M286'].", "id": "findings.F-04.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-04's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-04.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-17', 'Priya Raman'] for F-04.", "id": "findings.F-04.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-05 exception for termination notice defect.", "id": "findings.F-05.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's id from /workspace/documents/02_order_forms/013_order_forms_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_notices/061_notices_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's issue from /workspace/documents/02_order_forms/013_order_forms_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_notices/061_notices_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's severity from /workspace/documents/02_order_forms/013_order_forms_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_notices/061_notices_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's primary_source from /workspace/documents/02_order_forms/013_order_forms_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_notices/061_notices_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/02_order_forms/013_order_forms_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_notices/061_notices_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-05 using the exact controlled facts ['Hennepin County, Minnesota', 'Minnesota'].", "id": "findings.F-05.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-05's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-05.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-17', 'Elliot Mercer'] for F-05.", "id": "findings.F-05.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-06 exception for assignment consent requirement.", "id": "findings.F-06.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's id from /workspace/documents/02_order_forms/016_order_forms_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_notices/064_notices_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's issue from /workspace/documents/02_order_forms/016_order_forms_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_notices/064_notices_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's severity from /workspace/documents/02_order_forms/016_order_forms_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_notices/064_notices_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's primary_source from /workspace/documents/02_order_forms/016_order_forms_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_notices/064_notices_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/02_order_forms/016_order_forms_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_notices/064_notices_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-06 using the exact controlled facts ['6%', '10%'].", "id": "findings.F-06.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-06's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-06.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-17', 'Talia Brooks'] for F-06.", "id": "findings.F-06.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-07 exception for data-localization conflict.", "id": "findings.F-07.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's id from /workspace/documents/03_amendments/019_amendments_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_invoices/067_invoices_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's issue from /workspace/documents/03_amendments/019_amendments_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_invoices/067_invoices_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's severity from /workspace/documents/03_amendments/019_amendments_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_invoices/067_invoices_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's primary_source from /workspace/documents/03_amendments/019_amendments_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_invoices/067_invoices_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/03_amendments/019_amendments_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_invoices/067_invoices_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-07 using the exact controlled facts ['notices-ember_medical_devices@example.test', 'archive-keystone_field_support_llc@example.test'].", "id": "findings.F-07.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-07's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-07.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-17', 'Jonas Feld'] for F-07.", "id": "findings.F-07.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-08 exception for subprocessor notice lapse.", "id": "findings.F-08.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's id from /workspace/documents/03_amendments/022_amendments_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_invoices/070_invoices_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's issue from /workspace/documents/03_amendments/022_amendments_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_invoices/070_invoices_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's severity from /workspace/documents/03_amendments/022_amendments_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_invoices/070_invoices_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's primary_source from /workspace/documents/03_amendments/022_amendments_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_invoices/070_invoices_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/03_amendments/022_amendments_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_invoices/070_invoices_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-08 using the exact controlled facts ['62 records', '2025-01-17', '57 records', '2025-02-15'].", "id": "findings.F-08.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-08's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-08.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-17', 'Mei Whitaker'] for F-08.", "id": "findings.F-08.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-09 exception for insurance-limit deficiency.", "id": "findings.F-09.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's id from /workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/025_statements_of_work_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_correspondence/073_correspondence_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's issue from /workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/025_statements_of_work_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_correspondence/073_correspondence_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's severity from /workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/025_statements_of_work_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_correspondence/073_correspondence_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's primary_source from /workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/025_statements_of_work_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_correspondence/073_correspondence_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/025_statements_of_work_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_correspondence/073_correspondence_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-09 using the exact controlled facts ['2025-03-16', 'CB-CC-2505-I832', '2025-03-28', 'CB-CC-2505-R156'].", "id": "findings.F-09.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-09's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-09.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-17', 'Caleb Hassan'] for F-09.", "id": "findings.F-09.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-10 exception for audit-right deadline.", "id": "findings.F-10.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's id from /workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/028_statements_of_work_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_correspondence/076_correspondence_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's issue from /workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/028_statements_of_work_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_correspondence/076_correspondence_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's severity from /workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/028_statements_of_work_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_correspondence/076_correspondence_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's primary_source from /workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/028_statements_of_work_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_correspondence/076_correspondence_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/028_statements_of_work_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_correspondence/076_correspondence_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-10 using the exact controlled facts ['$5,379,100.00', '$5,564,700.00'].", "id": "findings.F-10.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-10's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-10.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-17', 'Leona Park'] for F-10.", "id": "findings.F-10.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-11 exception for exclusivity carveout breach.", "id": "findings.F-11.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's id from /workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/031_statements_of_work_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_correspondence/079_correspondence_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's issue from /workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/031_statements_of_work_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_correspondence/079_correspondence_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's severity from /workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/031_statements_of_work_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_correspondence/079_correspondence_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's primary_source from /workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/031_statements_of_work_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_correspondence/079_correspondence_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/031_statements_of_work_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_correspondence/079_correspondence_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-11 using the exact controlled facts ['Farah Ibrahim', 'Adrian Mensah'].", "id": "findings.F-11.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-11's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-11.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-17', 'Isaac Romero'] for F-11.", "id": "findings.F-11.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-12 exception for benchmarking right omission.", "id": "findings.F-12.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's id from /workspace/documents/05_pricing/034_pricing_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_policies/082_policies_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's issue from /workspace/documents/05_pricing/034_pricing_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_policies/082_policies_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's severity from /workspace/documents/05_pricing/034_pricing_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_policies/082_policies_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's primary_source from /workspace/documents/05_pricing/034_pricing_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_policies/082_policies_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/05_pricing/034_pricing_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_policies/082_policies_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-12 using the exact controlled facts ['closed without exception', 'CB-CC-2505-L186', 'open and escalated', 'CB-CC-2505-U591'].", "id": "findings.F-12.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-12's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-12.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-17', 'Sofia Bennett'] for F-12.", "id": "findings.F-12.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-13 exception for invoice currency discrepancy.", "id": "findings.F-13.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's id from /workspace/documents/05_pricing/037_pricing_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_policies/085_policies_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's issue from /workspace/documents/05_pricing/037_pricing_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_policies/085_policies_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's severity from /workspace/documents/05_pricing/037_pricing_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_policies/085_policies_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's primary_source from /workspace/documents/05_pricing/037_pricing_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_policies/085_policies_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/05_pricing/037_pricing_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_policies/085_policies_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-13 using the exact controlled facts ['Hennepin County, Minnesota', 'Minnesota'].", "id": "findings.F-13.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-13's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-13.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-17', 'Adrian Mensah'] for F-13.", "id": "findings.F-13.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-14 exception for usage-report inconsistency.", "id": "findings.F-14.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's id from /workspace/documents/05_pricing/040_pricing_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_policies/088_policies_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's issue from /workspace/documents/05_pricing/040_pricing_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_policies/088_policies_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's severity from /workspace/documents/05_pricing/040_pricing_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_policies/088_policies_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's primary_source from /workspace/documents/05_pricing/040_pricing_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_policies/088_policies_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/05_pricing/040_pricing_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_policies/088_policies_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-14 using the exact controlled facts ['7%', '14%'].", "id": "findings.F-14.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-14's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-14.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-17', 'Willa Novak'] for F-14.", "id": "findings.F-14.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-15 exception for order-form precedence conflict.", "id": "findings.F-15.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's id from /workspace/documents/06_service_levels/043_service_levels_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/091_renewal_records_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's issue from /workspace/documents/06_service_levels/043_service_levels_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/091_renewal_records_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's severity from /workspace/documents/06_service_levels/043_service_levels_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/091_renewal_records_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's primary_source from /workspace/documents/06_service_levels/043_service_levels_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/091_renewal_records_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/06_service_levels/043_service_levels_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/091_renewal_records_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-15 using the exact controlled facts ['notices-ember_medical_devices@example.test', 'archive-keystone_field_support_llc@example.test'].", "id": "findings.F-15.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-15's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-15.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-17', 'Theo Laurent'] for F-15.", "id": "findings.F-15.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-16 exception for survival-clause ambiguity.", "id": "findings.F-16.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's id from /workspace/documents/06_service_levels/046_service_levels_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/094_renewal_records_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's issue from /workspace/documents/06_service_levels/046_service_levels_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/094_renewal_records_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's severity from /workspace/documents/06_service_levels/046_service_levels_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/094_renewal_records_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's primary_source from /workspace/documents/06_service_levels/046_service_levels_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/094_renewal_records_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/06_service_levels/046_service_levels_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/094_renewal_records_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-16 using the exact controlled facts ['171 records', '2025-05-06', '65 records', '2025-06-12'].", "id": "findings.F-16.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-16's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-16.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-17', 'Amara Patel'] for F-16.", "id": "findings.F-16.action_anchors"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Executive assessment' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Executive assessment"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Method and record coverage' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Method and record coverage"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Findings' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Findings"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Recommended next actions' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Recommended next actions"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Assumptions and limitations' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Assumptions and limitations"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-01 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-01"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-02 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-02"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-03 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-03"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-04 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-04"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-05 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-05"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-06 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-06"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-07 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-07"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-08 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-08"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-09 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-09"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-10 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-10"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-11 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-11"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-12 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-12"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-13 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-13"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-14 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-14"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-15 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-15"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-16 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-16"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Do not claim the production has no issues or that every record is consistent.", "id": "memo.forbidden_claims_absent"}], "decision_options": [{"id": "cross-source-reconciliation", "label": "Reconcile controlling and corroborating records", "reason": "The CB-CC-2505 production contains independently maintained records; a defensible answer must preserve each supported conflict and its cure owner.", "selected": true}, {"id": "latest-record-controls", "label": "Treat the latest record as controlling", "reason": "Timestamp recency does not establish legal priority, execution, or approval authority.", "selected": false}, {"id": "primary-records-only", "label": "Report primary records without reconciliation", "reason": "Primary records alone conceal the operational conflicts that create the actionable exceptions.", "selected": false}], "gates": ["all_evidence_read_in_full", "chain_of_custody_metadata_checked", "findings_criteria_complete", "memo_criteria_complete", "deliverables_written_through_mcp"], "metadata_checks": 8, "metric": "weighted_criteria_score", "minimum_tool_calls": 46, "required_deliverables": ["findings.json", "advice.md"], "required_document_reads": 33, "type": "deterministic", "weights": {"findings": 0.55, "memo": 0.2, "procedure": 0.25}}, "task_id": "cb100-015-ember-medical", "task_name": "Ember device-support contract triage", "world_id": "counselbench-filesystem-mcp-v2"}
-{"context_files": ["task_files/cb100-016-fathom-retail/01_master_agreements/001_master_agreements_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-016-fathom-retail/01_master_agreements/002_master_agreements_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-016-fathom-retail/01_master_agreements/003_master_agreements_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-016-fathom-retail/01_master_agreements/004_master_agreements_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-016-fathom-retail/01_master_agreements/005_master_agreements_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-016-fathom-retail/01_master_agreements/006_master_agreements_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-016-fathom-retail/01_master_agreements/007_master_agreements_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-016-fathom-retail/01_master_agreements/008_master_agreements_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-016-fathom-retail/02_order_forms/009_order_forms_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-016-fathom-retail/02_order_forms/010_order_forms_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-016-fathom-retail/02_order_forms/011_order_forms_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-016-fathom-retail/02_order_forms/012_order_forms_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-016-fathom-retail/02_order_forms/013_order_forms_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-016-fathom-retail/02_order_forms/014_order_forms_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-016-fathom-retail/02_order_forms/015_order_forms_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-016-fathom-retail/02_order_forms/016_order_forms_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-016-fathom-retail/03_amendments/017_amendments_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-016-fathom-retail/03_amendments/018_amendments_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-016-fathom-retail/03_amendments/019_amendments_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-016-fathom-retail/03_amendments/020_amendments_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-016-fathom-retail/03_amendments/021_amendments_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-016-fathom-retail/03_amendments/022_amendments_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-016-fathom-retail/03_amendments/023_amendments_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-016-fathom-retail/03_amendments/024_amendments_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-016-fathom-retail/04_statements_of_work/025_statements_of_work_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-016-fathom-retail/04_statements_of_work/026_statements_of_work_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-016-fathom-retail/04_statements_of_work/027_statements_of_work_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-016-fathom-retail/04_statements_of_work/028_statements_of_work_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-016-fathom-retail/04_statements_of_work/029_statements_of_work_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-016-fathom-retail/04_statements_of_work/030_statements_of_work_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-016-fathom-retail/04_statements_of_work/031_statements_of_work_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-016-fathom-retail/04_statements_of_work/032_statements_of_work_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-016-fathom-retail/05_pricing/033_pricing_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-016-fathom-retail/05_pricing/034_pricing_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-016-fathom-retail/05_pricing/035_pricing_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-016-fathom-retail/05_pricing/036_pricing_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-016-fathom-retail/05_pricing/037_pricing_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-016-fathom-retail/05_pricing/038_pricing_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-016-fathom-retail/05_pricing/039_pricing_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-016-fathom-retail/05_pricing/040_pricing_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-016-fathom-retail/06_service_levels/041_service_levels_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-016-fathom-retail/06_service_levels/042_service_levels_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-016-fathom-retail/06_service_levels/043_service_levels_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-016-fathom-retail/06_service_levels/044_service_levels_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-016-fathom-retail/06_service_levels/045_service_levels_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-016-fathom-retail/06_service_levels/046_service_levels_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-016-fathom-retail/06_service_levels/047_service_levels_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-016-fathom-retail/06_service_levels/048_service_levels_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-016-fathom-retail/07_security_privacy/049_security_privacy_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-016-fathom-retail/07_security_privacy/050_security_privacy_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-016-fathom-retail/07_security_privacy/051_security_privacy_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-016-fathom-retail/07_security_privacy/052_security_privacy_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-016-fathom-retail/07_security_privacy/053_security_privacy_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-016-fathom-retail/07_security_privacy/054_security_privacy_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-016-fathom-retail/07_security_privacy/055_security_privacy_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-016-fathom-retail/07_security_privacy/056_security_privacy_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-016-fathom-retail/08_notices/057_notices_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-016-fathom-retail/08_notices/058_notices_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-016-fathom-retail/08_notices/059_notices_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-016-fathom-retail/08_notices/060_notices_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-016-fathom-retail/08_notices/061_notices_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-016-fathom-retail/08_notices/062_notices_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-016-fathom-retail/08_notices/063_notices_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-016-fathom-retail/08_notices/064_notices_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-016-fathom-retail/09_invoices/065_invoices_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-016-fathom-retail/09_invoices/066_invoices_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-016-fathom-retail/09_invoices/067_invoices_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-016-fathom-retail/09_invoices/068_invoices_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-016-fathom-retail/09_invoices/069_invoices_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-016-fathom-retail/09_invoices/070_invoices_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-016-fathom-retail/09_invoices/071_invoices_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-016-fathom-retail/09_invoices/072_invoices_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-016-fathom-retail/10_correspondence/073_correspondence_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-016-fathom-retail/10_correspondence/074_correspondence_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-016-fathom-retail/10_correspondence/075_correspondence_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-016-fathom-retail/10_correspondence/076_correspondence_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-016-fathom-retail/10_correspondence/077_correspondence_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-016-fathom-retail/10_correspondence/078_correspondence_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-016-fathom-retail/10_correspondence/079_correspondence_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-016-fathom-retail/10_correspondence/080_correspondence_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-016-fathom-retail/11_policies/081_policies_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-016-fathom-retail/11_policies/082_policies_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-016-fathom-retail/11_policies/083_policies_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-016-fathom-retail/11_policies/084_policies_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-016-fathom-retail/11_policies/085_policies_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-016-fathom-retail/11_policies/086_policies_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-016-fathom-retail/11_policies/087_policies_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-016-fathom-retail/11_policies/088_policies_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-016-fathom-retail/12_renewal_records/089_renewal_records_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-016-fathom-retail/12_renewal_records/090_renewal_records_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-016-fathom-retail/12_renewal_records/091_renewal_records_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-016-fathom-retail/12_renewal_records/092_renewal_records_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-016-fathom-retail/12_renewal_records/093_renewal_records_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-016-fathom-retail/12_renewal_records/094_renewal_records_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-016-fathom-retail/12_renewal_records/095_renewal_records_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-016-fathom-retail/12_renewal_records/096_renewal_records_status_report.md"], "gold_output": {"advice_markdown": "# Counsel advice — Fathom marketplace vendor audit\n\n## Executive assessment\n\nFor Fathom Retail Markets matter CB-CC-2506, the review identified 16 source-supported exceptions requiring action before 2026-09-21. The assessment concerns North Cove Merchandising Corp. and the supplied record for Illinois.\n\n## Method and record coverage\n\nThe review inventoried all 96 production files, read the 33 controlling, corroborating, and control records, searched the email exports, and checked metadata for the designated chain-of-custody sample. Conclusions are limited to the synthetic production supplied for this benchmark matter.\n\n## Findings\n\n### F-01 — renewal date conflict (critical)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for renewal date conflict: one source states the operative date is 2025-05-30 under control reference CB-CC-2506-A847, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2025-06-30 under response reference CB-CC-2506-J711.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/001_master_agreements_control_register.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/07_security_privacy/049_security_privacy_control_register.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-21, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Nora Chen.\n\n### F-02 — pricing-escalator mismatch (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for pricing-escalator mismatch: one source states the controlling amount is $4,693,533.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $4,873,566.00.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/004_master_agreements_ledger_export.csv`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/07_security_privacy/052_security_privacy_ledger_export.csv`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-21, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Dominic Alvarez.\n\n### F-03 — minimum-commit shortfall (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for minimum-commit shortfall: one source states approval is attributed to Owen Delgado as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Samuel Kim and contains no entry for Owen Delgado.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/007_master_agreements_officer_certificate.html`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/07_security_privacy/055_security_privacy_officer_certificate.html`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-21, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Priya Raman.\n\n### F-04 — service-credit underpayment (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for service-credit underpayment: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-CC-2506-D970, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-CC-2506-M928.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/02_order_forms/010_order_forms_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/08_notices/058_notices_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-21, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Elliot Mercer.\n\n### F-05 — termination notice defect (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for termination notice defect: one source states the applicable location is Cook County, Illinois, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to Illinois operations outside Cook County, Illinois.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/02_order_forms/013_order_forms_review_memorandum.json`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/08_notices/061_notices_review_memorandum.json`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-21, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Talia Brooks.\n\n### F-06 — assignment consent requirement (low)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for assignment consent requirement: one source states the threshold is 3% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 10% and produced a different exception result.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/02_order_forms/016_order_forms_status_report.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/08_notices/064_notices_status_report.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-21, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Jonas Feld.\n\n### F-07 — data-localization conflict (critical)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for data-localization conflict: one source states formal notice must use notices-fathom_retail_markets@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-north_cove_merchandising_corp@example.test.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/03_amendments/019_amendments_correspondence.eml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/09_invoices/067_invoices_correspondence.eml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-21, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Mei Whitaker.\n\n### F-08 — subprocessor notice lapse (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for subprocessor notice lapse: one source states the governed population contains 139 records through 2026-01-09, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 54 records through 2026-02-04.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/03_amendments/022_amendments_formal_notice.xml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/09_invoices/070_invoices_formal_notice.xml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-21, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Caleb Hassan.\n\n### F-09 — insurance-limit deficiency (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for insurance-limit deficiency: one source states the operative date is 2025-07-06 under control reference CB-CC-2506-I464, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2025-07-23 under response reference CB-CC-2506-R404.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/025_statements_of_work_control_register.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/10_correspondence/073_correspondence_control_register.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-21, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Leona Park.\n\n### F-10 — audit-right deadline (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for audit-right deadline: one source states the controlling amount is $6,959,109.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $7,064,718.00.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/028_statements_of_work_ledger_export.csv`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/10_correspondence/076_correspondence_ledger_export.csv`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-21, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Isaac Romero.\n\n### F-11 — exclusivity carveout breach (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for exclusivity carveout breach: one source states approval is attributed to Owen Delgado as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Theo Laurent and contains no entry for Owen Delgado.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/031_statements_of_work_officer_certificate.html`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/10_correspondence/079_correspondence_officer_certificate.html`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-21, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Sofia Bennett.\n\n### F-12 — benchmarking right omission (low)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for benchmarking right omission: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-CC-2506-L886, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-CC-2506-U506.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/05_pricing/034_pricing_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/11_policies/082_policies_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-21, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Adrian Mensah.\n\n### F-13 — invoice currency discrepancy (critical)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for invoice currency discrepancy: one source states the applicable location is Cook County, Illinois, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to Illinois operations outside Cook County, Illinois.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/05_pricing/037_pricing_review_memorandum.json`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/11_policies/085_policies_review_memorandum.json`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-21, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Willa Novak.\n\n### F-14 — usage-report inconsistency (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for usage-report inconsistency: one source states the threshold is 4% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 10% and produced a different exception result.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/05_pricing/040_pricing_status_report.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/11_policies/088_policies_status_report.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-21, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Theo Laurent.\n\n### F-15 — order-form precedence conflict (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for order-form precedence conflict: one source states formal notice must use notices-fathom_retail_markets@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-north_cove_merchandising_corp@example.test.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/06_service_levels/043_service_levels_correspondence.eml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/091_renewal_records_correspondence.eml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-21, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Amara Patel.\n\n### F-16 — survival-clause ambiguity (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for survival-clause ambiguity: one source states the governed population contains 106 records through 2025-12-07, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 70 records through 2026-01-18.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/06_service_levels/046_service_levels_formal_notice.xml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/094_renewal_records_formal_notice.xml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-21, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Henry Cho.\n\n## Recommended next actions\n\nSequence the critical and high findings first, assign the named owners, preserve the cited records, and document any resolution in the controlling matter register before the stated deadline.\n\n## Assumptions and limitations\n\nThis analysis is confined to task cb100-016-fathom-retail and the supplied synthetic evidence. It does not rely on external facts, does not resolve disputed law, and is not legal advice for a real person or entity.\n", "findings": {"as_of": "2026-09-21", "findings": [{"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/07_security_privacy/049_security_privacy_control_register.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for renewal date conflict: one source states the operative date is 2025-05-30 under control reference CB-CC-2506-A847, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2025-06-30 under response reference CB-CC-2506-J711.", "id": "F-01", "issue": "renewal date conflict", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/001_master_agreements_control_register.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-21, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Nora Chen.", "severity": "critical"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/07_security_privacy/052_security_privacy_ledger_export.csv", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for pricing-escalator mismatch: one source states the controlling amount is $4,693,533.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $4,873,566.00.", "id": "F-02", "issue": "pricing-escalator mismatch", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/004_master_agreements_ledger_export.csv", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-21, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Dominic Alvarez.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/07_security_privacy/055_security_privacy_officer_certificate.html", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for minimum-commit shortfall: one source states approval is attributed to Owen Delgado as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Samuel Kim and contains no entry for Owen Delgado.", "id": "F-03", "issue": "minimum-commit shortfall", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/007_master_agreements_officer_certificate.html", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-21, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Priya Raman.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/08_notices/058_notices_executed_instrument.txt", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for service-credit underpayment: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-CC-2506-D970, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-CC-2506-M928.", "id": "F-04", "issue": "service-credit underpayment", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/02_order_forms/010_order_forms_executed_instrument.txt", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-21, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Elliot Mercer.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/08_notices/061_notices_review_memorandum.json", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for termination notice defect: one source states the applicable location is Cook County, Illinois, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to Illinois operations outside Cook County, Illinois.", "id": "F-05", "issue": "termination notice defect", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/02_order_forms/013_order_forms_review_memorandum.json", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-21, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Talia Brooks.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/08_notices/064_notices_status_report.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for assignment consent requirement: one source states the threshold is 3% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 10% and produced a different exception result.", "id": "F-06", "issue": "assignment consent requirement", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/02_order_forms/016_order_forms_status_report.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-21, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Jonas Feld.", "severity": "low"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/09_invoices/067_invoices_correspondence.eml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for data-localization conflict: one source states formal notice must use notices-fathom_retail_markets@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-north_cove_merchandising_corp@example.test.", "id": "F-07", "issue": "data-localization conflict", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/03_amendments/019_amendments_correspondence.eml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-21, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Mei Whitaker.", "severity": "critical"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/09_invoices/070_invoices_formal_notice.xml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for subprocessor notice lapse: one source states the governed population contains 139 records through 2026-01-09, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 54 records through 2026-02-04.", "id": "F-08", "issue": "subprocessor notice lapse", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/03_amendments/022_amendments_formal_notice.xml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-21, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Caleb Hassan.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/10_correspondence/073_correspondence_control_register.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for insurance-limit deficiency: one source states the operative date is 2025-07-06 under control reference CB-CC-2506-I464, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2025-07-23 under response reference CB-CC-2506-R404.", "id": "F-09", "issue": "insurance-limit deficiency", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/025_statements_of_work_control_register.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-21, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Leona Park.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/10_correspondence/076_correspondence_ledger_export.csv", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for audit-right deadline: one source states the controlling amount is $6,959,109.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $7,064,718.00.", "id": "F-10", "issue": "audit-right deadline", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/028_statements_of_work_ledger_export.csv", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-21, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Isaac Romero.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/10_correspondence/079_correspondence_officer_certificate.html", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for exclusivity carveout breach: one source states approval is attributed to Owen Delgado as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Theo Laurent and contains no entry for Owen Delgado.", "id": "F-11", "issue": "exclusivity carveout breach", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/031_statements_of_work_officer_certificate.html", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-21, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Sofia Bennett.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/11_policies/082_policies_executed_instrument.txt", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for benchmarking right omission: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-CC-2506-L886, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-CC-2506-U506.", "id": "F-12", "issue": "benchmarking right omission", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/05_pricing/034_pricing_executed_instrument.txt", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-21, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Adrian Mensah.", "severity": "low"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/11_policies/085_policies_review_memorandum.json", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for invoice currency discrepancy: one source states the applicable location is Cook County, Illinois, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to Illinois operations outside Cook County, Illinois.", "id": "F-13", "issue": "invoice currency discrepancy", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/05_pricing/037_pricing_review_memorandum.json", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-21, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Willa Novak.", "severity": "critical"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/11_policies/088_policies_status_report.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for usage-report inconsistency: one source states the threshold is 4% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 10% and produced a different exception result.", "id": "F-14", "issue": "usage-report inconsistency", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/05_pricing/040_pricing_status_report.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-21, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Theo Laurent.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/091_renewal_records_correspondence.eml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for order-form precedence conflict: one source states formal notice must use notices-fathom_retail_markets@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-north_cove_merchandising_corp@example.test.", "id": "F-15", "issue": "order-form precedence conflict", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/06_service_levels/043_service_levels_correspondence.eml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-21, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Amara Patel.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/094_renewal_records_formal_notice.xml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for survival-clause ambiguity: one source states the governed population contains 106 records through 2025-12-07, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 70 records through 2026-01-18.", "id": "F-16", "issue": "survival-clause ambiguity", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/06_service_levels/046_service_levels_formal_notice.xml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-21, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Henry Cho.", "severity": "medium"}], "matter_number": "CB-CC-2506", "prepared_for": "Fathom Retail Markets", "schema_version": "1.0", "task_id": "cb100-016-fathom-retail"}}, "metadata": {"benchmark": "CounselBench-100", "code_license": "Apache-2.0", "data_license": "CC-BY-4.0", "deadline": "2026-09-21", "document_count": 96, "jurisdiction": "Illinois", "matter_number": "CB-CC-2506", "mcp_commit": "9a96ea6e5913736f92b88345bf51caeaaa8e719f", "mcp_package": "@modelcontextprotocol/server-filesystem@2026.7.10", "practice_area": "commercial-contracts", "reference_tool_calls": 46, "required_evidence_reads": 33, "synthetic": true, "venue": "Cook County, Illinois", "version": "2.0.0"}, "prompt": "You are commercial contracts counsel for Fathom Retail Markets. The upcoming deadline leaves no room for unsupported assumptions, so every conclusion must trace to the supplied production. Marketplace fees changed mid-quarter, returns data moved offshore, and the parties disagree whether an email modified the category exclusivity provision. Decision due 2026-09-21. Illinois law governs; Cook County, Illinois is the forum. Give controlling documents precedence only when the record supports that hierarchy. Work out the defensible position from the matter production and leave an audit-ready exception tracker and concise advice for the supervising lawyer. Keep confirmed conflicts separate from open questions, cite the records that actually control each conclusion, and do not fill gaps with outside facts.", "rubric": {"criteria": [{"category": "procedure", "description": "Complete at least 46 successful, argument-specific evidence and output calls.", "id": "procedure.minimum_successful_tool_calls"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Find and read the 33 controlling, corroborating, and work-product-control records in full.", "id": "procedure.all_evidence_read_in_full"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Inspect file metadata for the eight designated critical primary records before relying on them.", "id": "procedure.chain_of_custody_metadata_checked"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Confirm the sandbox's allowed document and output roots.", "id": "procedure.allowed_directories_checked"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Inventory all 96 records so the relevant sources are discovered among the context records.", "id": "procedure.recursive_inventory_completed"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Search the production for email evidence that may corroborate or contradict formal records.", "id": "procedure.targeted_search_completed"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Leave only findings.json and advice.md in the output workspace.", "id": "procedure.exact_deliverable_set"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Create both final work products through the sandbox MCP surface.", "id": "procedure.deliverables_written_through_mcp"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Produce findings.json as a valid JSON object.", "id": "findings.findings_is_object"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Report exactly 16 confirmed exceptions.", "id": "findings.findings_exact_count"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Use each stable finding ID exactly once.", "id": "findings.finding_ids_unique"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set schema_version to the released matter value '1.0'.", "id": "findings.top_level_schema_version"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set task_id to the released matter value 'cb100-016-fathom-retail'.", "id": "findings.top_level_task_id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set matter_number to the released matter value 'CB-CC-2506'.", "id": "findings.top_level_matter_number"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set prepared_for to the released matter value 'Fathom Retail Markets'.", "id": "findings.top_level_prepared_for"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set as_of to the released matter value '2026-09-21'.", "id": "findings.top_level_as_of"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-01 exception for renewal date conflict.", "id": "findings.F-01.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's id from /workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/001_master_agreements_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_security_privacy/049_security_privacy_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's issue from /workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/001_master_agreements_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_security_privacy/049_security_privacy_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's severity from /workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/001_master_agreements_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_security_privacy/049_security_privacy_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's primary_source from /workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/001_master_agreements_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_security_privacy/049_security_privacy_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/001_master_agreements_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_security_privacy/049_security_privacy_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-01 using the exact controlled facts ['2025-05-30', 'CB-CC-2506-A847', '2025-06-30', 'CB-CC-2506-J711'].", "id": "findings.F-01.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-01's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-01.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-21', 'Nora Chen'] for F-01.", "id": "findings.F-01.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-02 exception for pricing-escalator mismatch.", "id": "findings.F-02.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's id from /workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/004_master_agreements_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_security_privacy/052_security_privacy_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's issue from /workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/004_master_agreements_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_security_privacy/052_security_privacy_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's severity from /workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/004_master_agreements_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_security_privacy/052_security_privacy_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's primary_source from /workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/004_master_agreements_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_security_privacy/052_security_privacy_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/004_master_agreements_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_security_privacy/052_security_privacy_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-02 using the exact controlled facts ['$4,693,533.00', '$4,873,566.00'].", "id": "findings.F-02.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-02's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-02.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-21', 'Dominic Alvarez'] for F-02.", "id": "findings.F-02.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-03 exception for minimum-commit shortfall.", "id": "findings.F-03.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's id from /workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/007_master_agreements_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_security_privacy/055_security_privacy_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's issue from /workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/007_master_agreements_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_security_privacy/055_security_privacy_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's severity from /workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/007_master_agreements_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_security_privacy/055_security_privacy_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's primary_source from /workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/007_master_agreements_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_security_privacy/055_security_privacy_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/007_master_agreements_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_security_privacy/055_security_privacy_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-03 using the exact controlled facts ['Owen Delgado', 'Samuel Kim'].", "id": "findings.F-03.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-03's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-03.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-21', 'Priya Raman'] for F-03.", "id": "findings.F-03.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-04 exception for service-credit underpayment.", "id": "findings.F-04.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's id from /workspace/documents/02_order_forms/010_order_forms_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_notices/058_notices_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's issue from /workspace/documents/02_order_forms/010_order_forms_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_notices/058_notices_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's severity from /workspace/documents/02_order_forms/010_order_forms_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_notices/058_notices_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's primary_source from /workspace/documents/02_order_forms/010_order_forms_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_notices/058_notices_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/02_order_forms/010_order_forms_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_notices/058_notices_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-04 using the exact controlled facts ['closed without exception', 'CB-CC-2506-D970', 'open and escalated', 'CB-CC-2506-M928'].", "id": "findings.F-04.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-04's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-04.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-21', 'Elliot Mercer'] for F-04.", "id": "findings.F-04.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-05 exception for termination notice defect.", "id": "findings.F-05.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's id from /workspace/documents/02_order_forms/013_order_forms_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_notices/061_notices_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's issue from /workspace/documents/02_order_forms/013_order_forms_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_notices/061_notices_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's severity from /workspace/documents/02_order_forms/013_order_forms_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_notices/061_notices_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's primary_source from /workspace/documents/02_order_forms/013_order_forms_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_notices/061_notices_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/02_order_forms/013_order_forms_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_notices/061_notices_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-05 using the exact controlled facts ['Cook County, Illinois', 'Illinois'].", "id": "findings.F-05.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-05's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-05.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-21', 'Talia Brooks'] for F-05.", "id": "findings.F-05.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-06 exception for assignment consent requirement.", "id": "findings.F-06.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's id from /workspace/documents/02_order_forms/016_order_forms_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_notices/064_notices_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's issue from /workspace/documents/02_order_forms/016_order_forms_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_notices/064_notices_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's severity from /workspace/documents/02_order_forms/016_order_forms_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_notices/064_notices_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's primary_source from /workspace/documents/02_order_forms/016_order_forms_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_notices/064_notices_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/02_order_forms/016_order_forms_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_notices/064_notices_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-06 using the exact controlled facts ['3%', '10%'].", "id": "findings.F-06.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-06's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-06.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-21', 'Jonas Feld'] for F-06.", "id": "findings.F-06.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-07 exception for data-localization conflict.", "id": "findings.F-07.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's id from /workspace/documents/03_amendments/019_amendments_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_invoices/067_invoices_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's issue from /workspace/documents/03_amendments/019_amendments_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_invoices/067_invoices_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's severity from /workspace/documents/03_amendments/019_amendments_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_invoices/067_invoices_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's primary_source from /workspace/documents/03_amendments/019_amendments_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_invoices/067_invoices_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/03_amendments/019_amendments_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_invoices/067_invoices_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-07 using the exact controlled facts ['notices-fathom_retail_markets@example.test', 'archive-north_cove_merchandising_corp@example.test'].", "id": "findings.F-07.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-07's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-07.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-21', 'Mei Whitaker'] for F-07.", "id": "findings.F-07.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-08 exception for subprocessor notice lapse.", "id": "findings.F-08.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's id from /workspace/documents/03_amendments/022_amendments_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_invoices/070_invoices_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's issue from /workspace/documents/03_amendments/022_amendments_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_invoices/070_invoices_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's severity from /workspace/documents/03_amendments/022_amendments_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_invoices/070_invoices_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's primary_source from /workspace/documents/03_amendments/022_amendments_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_invoices/070_invoices_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/03_amendments/022_amendments_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_invoices/070_invoices_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-08 using the exact controlled facts ['139 records', '2026-01-09', '54 records', '2026-02-04'].", "id": "findings.F-08.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-08's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-08.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-21', 'Caleb Hassan'] for F-08.", "id": "findings.F-08.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-09 exception for insurance-limit deficiency.", "id": "findings.F-09.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's id from /workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/025_statements_of_work_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_correspondence/073_correspondence_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's issue from /workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/025_statements_of_work_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_correspondence/073_correspondence_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's severity from /workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/025_statements_of_work_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_correspondence/073_correspondence_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's primary_source from /workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/025_statements_of_work_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_correspondence/073_correspondence_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/025_statements_of_work_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_correspondence/073_correspondence_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-09 using the exact controlled facts ['2025-07-06', 'CB-CC-2506-I464', '2025-07-23', 'CB-CC-2506-R404'].", "id": "findings.F-09.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-09's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-09.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-21', 'Leona Park'] for F-09.", "id": "findings.F-09.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-10 exception for audit-right deadline.", "id": "findings.F-10.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's id from /workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/028_statements_of_work_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_correspondence/076_correspondence_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's issue from /workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/028_statements_of_work_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_correspondence/076_correspondence_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's severity from /workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/028_statements_of_work_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_correspondence/076_correspondence_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's primary_source from /workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/028_statements_of_work_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_correspondence/076_correspondence_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/028_statements_of_work_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_correspondence/076_correspondence_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-10 using the exact controlled facts ['$6,959,109.00', '$7,064,718.00'].", "id": "findings.F-10.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-10's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-10.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-21', 'Isaac Romero'] for F-10.", "id": "findings.F-10.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-11 exception for exclusivity carveout breach.", "id": "findings.F-11.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's id from /workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/031_statements_of_work_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_correspondence/079_correspondence_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's issue from /workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/031_statements_of_work_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_correspondence/079_correspondence_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's severity from /workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/031_statements_of_work_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_correspondence/079_correspondence_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's primary_source from /workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/031_statements_of_work_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_correspondence/079_correspondence_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/031_statements_of_work_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_correspondence/079_correspondence_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-11 using the exact controlled facts ['Owen Delgado', 'Theo Laurent'].", "id": "findings.F-11.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-11's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-11.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-21', 'Sofia Bennett'] for F-11.", "id": "findings.F-11.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-12 exception for benchmarking right omission.", "id": "findings.F-12.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's id from /workspace/documents/05_pricing/034_pricing_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_policies/082_policies_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's issue from /workspace/documents/05_pricing/034_pricing_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_policies/082_policies_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's severity from /workspace/documents/05_pricing/034_pricing_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_policies/082_policies_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's primary_source from /workspace/documents/05_pricing/034_pricing_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_policies/082_policies_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/05_pricing/034_pricing_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_policies/082_policies_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-12 using the exact controlled facts ['closed without exception', 'CB-CC-2506-L886', 'open and escalated', 'CB-CC-2506-U506'].", "id": "findings.F-12.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-12's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-12.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-21', 'Adrian Mensah'] for F-12.", "id": "findings.F-12.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-13 exception for invoice currency discrepancy.", "id": "findings.F-13.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's id from /workspace/documents/05_pricing/037_pricing_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_policies/085_policies_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's issue from /workspace/documents/05_pricing/037_pricing_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_policies/085_policies_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's severity from /workspace/documents/05_pricing/037_pricing_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_policies/085_policies_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's primary_source from /workspace/documents/05_pricing/037_pricing_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_policies/085_policies_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/05_pricing/037_pricing_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_policies/085_policies_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-13 using the exact controlled facts ['Cook County, Illinois', 'Illinois'].", "id": "findings.F-13.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-13's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-13.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-21', 'Willa Novak'] for F-13.", "id": "findings.F-13.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-14 exception for usage-report inconsistency.", "id": "findings.F-14.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's id from /workspace/documents/05_pricing/040_pricing_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_policies/088_policies_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's issue from /workspace/documents/05_pricing/040_pricing_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_policies/088_policies_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's severity from /workspace/documents/05_pricing/040_pricing_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_policies/088_policies_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's primary_source from /workspace/documents/05_pricing/040_pricing_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_policies/088_policies_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/05_pricing/040_pricing_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_policies/088_policies_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-14 using the exact controlled facts ['4%', '10%'].", "id": "findings.F-14.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-14's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-14.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-21', 'Theo Laurent'] for F-14.", "id": "findings.F-14.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-15 exception for order-form precedence conflict.", "id": "findings.F-15.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's id from /workspace/documents/06_service_levels/043_service_levels_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/091_renewal_records_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's issue from /workspace/documents/06_service_levels/043_service_levels_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/091_renewal_records_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's severity from /workspace/documents/06_service_levels/043_service_levels_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/091_renewal_records_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's primary_source from /workspace/documents/06_service_levels/043_service_levels_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/091_renewal_records_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/06_service_levels/043_service_levels_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/091_renewal_records_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-15 using the exact controlled facts ['notices-fathom_retail_markets@example.test', 'archive-north_cove_merchandising_corp@example.test'].", "id": "findings.F-15.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-15's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-15.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-21', 'Amara Patel'] for F-15.", "id": "findings.F-15.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-16 exception for survival-clause ambiguity.", "id": "findings.F-16.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's id from /workspace/documents/06_service_levels/046_service_levels_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/094_renewal_records_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's issue from /workspace/documents/06_service_levels/046_service_levels_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/094_renewal_records_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's severity from /workspace/documents/06_service_levels/046_service_levels_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/094_renewal_records_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's primary_source from /workspace/documents/06_service_levels/046_service_levels_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/094_renewal_records_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/06_service_levels/046_service_levels_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/094_renewal_records_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-16 using the exact controlled facts ['106 records', '2025-12-07', '70 records', '2026-01-18'].", "id": "findings.F-16.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-16's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-16.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-21', 'Henry Cho'] for F-16.", "id": "findings.F-16.action_anchors"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Executive assessment' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Executive assessment"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Method and record coverage' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Method and record coverage"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Findings' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Findings"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Recommended next actions' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Recommended next actions"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Assumptions and limitations' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Assumptions and limitations"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-01 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-01"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-02 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-02"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-03 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-03"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-04 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-04"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-05 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-05"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-06 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-06"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-07 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-07"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-08 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-08"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-09 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-09"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-10 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-10"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-11 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-11"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-12 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-12"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-13 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-13"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-14 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-14"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-15 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-15"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-16 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-16"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Do not claim the production has no issues or that every record is consistent.", "id": "memo.forbidden_claims_absent"}], "decision_options": [{"id": "cross-source-reconciliation", "label": "Reconcile controlling and corroborating records", "reason": "The CB-CC-2506 production contains independently maintained records; a defensible answer must preserve each supported conflict and its cure owner.", "selected": true}, {"id": "latest-record-controls", "label": "Treat the latest record as controlling", "reason": "Timestamp recency does not establish legal priority, execution, or approval authority.", "selected": false}, {"id": "primary-records-only", "label": "Report primary records without reconciliation", "reason": "Primary records alone conceal the operational conflicts that create the actionable exceptions.", "selected": false}], "gates": ["all_evidence_read_in_full", "chain_of_custody_metadata_checked", "findings_criteria_complete", "memo_criteria_complete", "deliverables_written_through_mcp"], "metadata_checks": 8, "metric": "weighted_criteria_score", "minimum_tool_calls": 46, "required_deliverables": ["findings.json", "advice.md"], "required_document_reads": 33, "type": "deterministic", "weights": {"findings": 0.55, "memo": 0.2, "procedure": 0.25}}, "task_id": "cb100-016-fathom-retail", "task_name": "Fathom marketplace vendor audit", "world_id": "counselbench-filesystem-mcp-v2"}
-{"context_files": ["task_files/cb100-017-garnet-energy/01_master_agreements/001_master_agreements_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-017-garnet-energy/01_master_agreements/002_master_agreements_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-017-garnet-energy/01_master_agreements/003_master_agreements_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-017-garnet-energy/01_master_agreements/004_master_agreements_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-017-garnet-energy/01_master_agreements/005_master_agreements_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-017-garnet-energy/01_master_agreements/006_master_agreements_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-017-garnet-energy/01_master_agreements/007_master_agreements_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-017-garnet-energy/01_master_agreements/008_master_agreements_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-017-garnet-energy/02_order_forms/009_order_forms_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-017-garnet-energy/02_order_forms/010_order_forms_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-017-garnet-energy/02_order_forms/011_order_forms_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-017-garnet-energy/02_order_forms/012_order_forms_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-017-garnet-energy/02_order_forms/013_order_forms_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-017-garnet-energy/02_order_forms/014_order_forms_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-017-garnet-energy/02_order_forms/015_order_forms_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-017-garnet-energy/02_order_forms/016_order_forms_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-017-garnet-energy/03_amendments/017_amendments_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-017-garnet-energy/03_amendments/018_amendments_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-017-garnet-energy/03_amendments/019_amendments_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-017-garnet-energy/03_amendments/020_amendments_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-017-garnet-energy/03_amendments/021_amendments_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-017-garnet-energy/03_amendments/022_amendments_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-017-garnet-energy/03_amendments/023_amendments_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-017-garnet-energy/03_amendments/024_amendments_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-017-garnet-energy/04_statements_of_work/025_statements_of_work_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-017-garnet-energy/04_statements_of_work/026_statements_of_work_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-017-garnet-energy/04_statements_of_work/027_statements_of_work_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-017-garnet-energy/04_statements_of_work/028_statements_of_work_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-017-garnet-energy/04_statements_of_work/029_statements_of_work_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-017-garnet-energy/04_statements_of_work/030_statements_of_work_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-017-garnet-energy/04_statements_of_work/031_statements_of_work_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-017-garnet-energy/04_statements_of_work/032_statements_of_work_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-017-garnet-energy/05_pricing/033_pricing_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-017-garnet-energy/05_pricing/034_pricing_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-017-garnet-energy/05_pricing/035_pricing_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-017-garnet-energy/05_pricing/036_pricing_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-017-garnet-energy/05_pricing/037_pricing_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-017-garnet-energy/05_pricing/038_pricing_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-017-garnet-energy/05_pricing/039_pricing_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-017-garnet-energy/05_pricing/040_pricing_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-017-garnet-energy/06_service_levels/041_service_levels_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-017-garnet-energy/06_service_levels/042_service_levels_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-017-garnet-energy/06_service_levels/043_service_levels_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-017-garnet-energy/06_service_levels/044_service_levels_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-017-garnet-energy/06_service_levels/045_service_levels_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-017-garnet-energy/06_service_levels/046_service_levels_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-017-garnet-energy/06_service_levels/047_service_levels_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-017-garnet-energy/06_service_levels/048_service_levels_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-017-garnet-energy/07_security_privacy/049_security_privacy_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-017-garnet-energy/07_security_privacy/050_security_privacy_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-017-garnet-energy/07_security_privacy/051_security_privacy_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-017-garnet-energy/07_security_privacy/052_security_privacy_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-017-garnet-energy/07_security_privacy/053_security_privacy_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-017-garnet-energy/07_security_privacy/054_security_privacy_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-017-garnet-energy/07_security_privacy/055_security_privacy_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-017-garnet-energy/07_security_privacy/056_security_privacy_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-017-garnet-energy/08_notices/057_notices_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-017-garnet-energy/08_notices/058_notices_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-017-garnet-energy/08_notices/059_notices_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-017-garnet-energy/08_notices/060_notices_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-017-garnet-energy/08_notices/061_notices_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-017-garnet-energy/08_notices/062_notices_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-017-garnet-energy/08_notices/063_notices_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-017-garnet-energy/08_notices/064_notices_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-017-garnet-energy/09_invoices/065_invoices_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-017-garnet-energy/09_invoices/066_invoices_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-017-garnet-energy/09_invoices/067_invoices_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-017-garnet-energy/09_invoices/068_invoices_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-017-garnet-energy/09_invoices/069_invoices_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-017-garnet-energy/09_invoices/070_invoices_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-017-garnet-energy/09_invoices/071_invoices_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-017-garnet-energy/09_invoices/072_invoices_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-017-garnet-energy/10_correspondence/073_correspondence_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-017-garnet-energy/10_correspondence/074_correspondence_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-017-garnet-energy/10_correspondence/075_correspondence_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-017-garnet-energy/10_correspondence/076_correspondence_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-017-garnet-energy/10_correspondence/077_correspondence_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-017-garnet-energy/10_correspondence/078_correspondence_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-017-garnet-energy/10_correspondence/079_correspondence_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-017-garnet-energy/10_correspondence/080_correspondence_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-017-garnet-energy/11_policies/081_policies_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-017-garnet-energy/11_policies/082_policies_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-017-garnet-energy/11_policies/083_policies_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-017-garnet-energy/11_policies/084_policies_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-017-garnet-energy/11_policies/085_policies_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-017-garnet-energy/11_policies/086_policies_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-017-garnet-energy/11_policies/087_policies_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-017-garnet-energy/11_policies/088_policies_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-017-garnet-energy/12_renewal_records/089_renewal_records_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-017-garnet-energy/12_renewal_records/090_renewal_records_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-017-garnet-energy/12_renewal_records/091_renewal_records_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-017-garnet-energy/12_renewal_records/092_renewal_records_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-017-garnet-energy/12_renewal_records/093_renewal_records_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-017-garnet-energy/12_renewal_records/094_renewal_records_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-017-garnet-energy/12_renewal_records/095_renewal_records_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-017-garnet-energy/12_renewal_records/096_renewal_records_status_report.md"], "gold_output": {"advice_markdown": "# Counsel advice — Garnet offtake agreement review\n\n## Executive assessment\n\nFor Garnet Renewable Energy matter CB-CC-2507, the review identified 16 source-supported exceptions requiring action before 2026-09-24. The assessment concerns Mesa Crown Utilities and the supplied record for Texas.\n\n## Method and record coverage\n\nThe review inventoried all 96 production files, read the 33 controlling, corroborating, and control records, searched the email exports, and checked metadata for the designated chain-of-custody sample. Conclusions are limited to the synthetic production supplied for this benchmark matter.\n\n## Findings\n\n### F-01 — renewal date conflict (critical)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for renewal date conflict: one source states the operative date is 2025-06-19 under control reference CB-CC-2507-A507, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2025-08-04 under response reference CB-CC-2507-J823.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/001_master_agreements_control_register.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/07_security_privacy/049_security_privacy_control_register.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-24, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Dominic Alvarez.\n\n### F-02 — pricing-escalator mismatch (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for pricing-escalator mismatch: one source states the controlling amount is $1,213,778.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $1,464,056.00.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/004_master_agreements_ledger_export.csv`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/07_security_privacy/052_security_privacy_ledger_export.csv`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-24, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Priya Raman.\n\n### F-03 — minimum-commit shortfall (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for minimum-commit shortfall: one source states approval is attributed to Lena Varga as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Rafael Okafor and contains no entry for Lena Varga.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/007_master_agreements_officer_certificate.html`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/07_security_privacy/055_security_privacy_officer_certificate.html`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-24, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Elliot Mercer.\n\n### F-04 — service-credit underpayment (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for service-credit underpayment: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-CC-2507-D780, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-CC-2507-M913.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/02_order_forms/010_order_forms_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/08_notices/058_notices_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-24, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Talia Brooks.\n\n### F-05 — termination notice defect (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for termination notice defect: one source states the applicable location is Travis County, Texas, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to Texas operations outside Travis County, Texas.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/02_order_forms/013_order_forms_review_memorandum.json`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/08_notices/061_notices_review_memorandum.json`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-24, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Jonas Feld.\n\n### F-06 — assignment consent requirement (low)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for assignment consent requirement: one source states the threshold is 4% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 6% and produced a different exception result.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/02_order_forms/016_order_forms_status_report.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/08_notices/064_notices_status_report.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-24, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Mei Whitaker.\n\n### F-07 — data-localization conflict (critical)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for data-localization conflict: one source states formal notice must use notices-garnet_renewable_energy@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-mesa_crown_utilities@example.test.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/03_amendments/019_amendments_correspondence.eml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/09_invoices/067_invoices_correspondence.eml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-24, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Caleb Hassan.\n\n### F-08 — subprocessor notice lapse (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for subprocessor notice lapse: one source states the governed population contains 64 records through 2025-10-26, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 64 records through 2025-12-01.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/03_amendments/022_amendments_formal_notice.xml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/09_invoices/070_invoices_formal_notice.xml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-24, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Leona Park.\n\n### F-09 — insurance-limit deficiency (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for insurance-limit deficiency: one source states the operative date is 2025-06-12 under control reference CB-CC-2507-I500, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2025-07-13 under response reference CB-CC-2507-R200.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/025_statements_of_work_control_register.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/10_correspondence/073_correspondence_control_register.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-24, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Isaac Romero.\n\n### F-10 — audit-right deadline (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for audit-right deadline: one source states the controlling amount is $3,802,426.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $3,961,352.00.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/028_statements_of_work_ledger_export.csv`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/10_correspondence/076_correspondence_ledger_export.csv`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-24, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Sofia Bennett.\n\n### F-11 — exclusivity carveout breach (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for exclusivity carveout breach: one source states approval is attributed to Lena Varga as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Henry Cho and contains no entry for Lena Varga.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/031_statements_of_work_officer_certificate.html`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/10_correspondence/079_correspondence_officer_certificate.html`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-24, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Adrian Mensah.\n\n### F-12 — benchmarking right omission (low)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for benchmarking right omission: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-CC-2507-L715, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-CC-2507-U978.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/05_pricing/034_pricing_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/11_policies/082_policies_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-24, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Willa Novak.\n\n### F-13 — invoice currency discrepancy (critical)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for invoice currency discrepancy: one source states the applicable location is Travis County, Texas, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to Texas operations outside Travis County, Texas.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/05_pricing/037_pricing_review_memorandum.json`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/11_policies/085_policies_review_memorandum.json`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-24, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Theo Laurent.\n\n### F-14 — usage-report inconsistency (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for usage-report inconsistency: one source states the threshold is 5% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 8% and produced a different exception result.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/05_pricing/040_pricing_status_report.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/11_policies/088_policies_status_report.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-24, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Amara Patel.\n\n### F-15 — order-form precedence conflict (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for order-form precedence conflict: one source states formal notice must use notices-garnet_renewable_energy@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-mesa_crown_utilities@example.test.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/06_service_levels/043_service_levels_correspondence.eml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/091_renewal_records_correspondence.eml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-24, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Henry Cho.\n\n### F-16 — survival-clause ambiguity (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for survival-clause ambiguity: one source states the governed population contains 95 records through 2025-02-19, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 36 records through 2025-02-27.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/06_service_levels/046_service_levels_formal_notice.xml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/094_renewal_records_formal_notice.xml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-24, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Nadine Flores.\n\n## Recommended next actions\n\nSequence the critical and high findings first, assign the named owners, preserve the cited records, and document any resolution in the controlling matter register before the stated deadline.\n\n## Assumptions and limitations\n\nThis analysis is confined to task cb100-017-garnet-energy and the supplied synthetic evidence. It does not rely on external facts, does not resolve disputed law, and is not legal advice for a real person or entity.\n", "findings": {"as_of": "2026-09-24", "findings": [{"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/07_security_privacy/049_security_privacy_control_register.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for renewal date conflict: one source states the operative date is 2025-06-19 under control reference CB-CC-2507-A507, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2025-08-04 under response reference CB-CC-2507-J823.", "id": "F-01", "issue": "renewal date conflict", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/001_master_agreements_control_register.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-24, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Dominic Alvarez.", "severity": "critical"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/07_security_privacy/052_security_privacy_ledger_export.csv", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for pricing-escalator mismatch: one source states the controlling amount is $1,213,778.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $1,464,056.00.", "id": "F-02", "issue": "pricing-escalator mismatch", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/004_master_agreements_ledger_export.csv", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-24, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Priya Raman.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/07_security_privacy/055_security_privacy_officer_certificate.html", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for minimum-commit shortfall: one source states approval is attributed to Lena Varga as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Rafael Okafor and contains no entry for Lena Varga.", "id": "F-03", "issue": "minimum-commit shortfall", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/007_master_agreements_officer_certificate.html", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-24, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Elliot Mercer.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/08_notices/058_notices_executed_instrument.txt", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for service-credit underpayment: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-CC-2507-D780, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-CC-2507-M913.", "id": "F-04", "issue": "service-credit underpayment", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/02_order_forms/010_order_forms_executed_instrument.txt", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-24, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Talia Brooks.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/08_notices/061_notices_review_memorandum.json", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for termination notice defect: one source states the applicable location is Travis County, Texas, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to Texas operations outside Travis County, Texas.", "id": "F-05", "issue": "termination notice defect", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/02_order_forms/013_order_forms_review_memorandum.json", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-24, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Jonas Feld.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/08_notices/064_notices_status_report.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for assignment consent requirement: one source states the threshold is 4% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 6% and produced a different exception result.", "id": "F-06", "issue": "assignment consent requirement", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/02_order_forms/016_order_forms_status_report.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-24, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Mei Whitaker.", "severity": "low"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/09_invoices/067_invoices_correspondence.eml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for data-localization conflict: one source states formal notice must use notices-garnet_renewable_energy@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-mesa_crown_utilities@example.test.", "id": "F-07", "issue": "data-localization conflict", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/03_amendments/019_amendments_correspondence.eml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-24, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Caleb Hassan.", "severity": "critical"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/09_invoices/070_invoices_formal_notice.xml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for subprocessor notice lapse: one source states the governed population contains 64 records through 2025-10-26, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 64 records through 2025-12-01.", "id": "F-08", "issue": "subprocessor notice lapse", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/03_amendments/022_amendments_formal_notice.xml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-24, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Leona Park.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/10_correspondence/073_correspondence_control_register.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for insurance-limit deficiency: one source states the operative date is 2025-06-12 under control reference CB-CC-2507-I500, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2025-07-13 under response reference CB-CC-2507-R200.", "id": "F-09", "issue": "insurance-limit deficiency", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/025_statements_of_work_control_register.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-24, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Isaac Romero.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/10_correspondence/076_correspondence_ledger_export.csv", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for audit-right deadline: one source states the controlling amount is $3,802,426.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $3,961,352.00.", "id": "F-10", "issue": "audit-right deadline", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/028_statements_of_work_ledger_export.csv", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-24, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Sofia Bennett.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/10_correspondence/079_correspondence_officer_certificate.html", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for exclusivity carveout breach: one source states approval is attributed to Lena Varga as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Henry Cho and contains no entry for Lena Varga.", "id": "F-11", "issue": "exclusivity carveout breach", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/031_statements_of_work_officer_certificate.html", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-24, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Adrian Mensah.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/11_policies/082_policies_executed_instrument.txt", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for benchmarking right omission: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-CC-2507-L715, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-CC-2507-U978.", "id": "F-12", "issue": "benchmarking right omission", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/05_pricing/034_pricing_executed_instrument.txt", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-24, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Willa Novak.", "severity": "low"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/11_policies/085_policies_review_memorandum.json", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for invoice currency discrepancy: one source states the applicable location is Travis County, Texas, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to Texas operations outside Travis County, Texas.", "id": "F-13", "issue": "invoice currency discrepancy", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/05_pricing/037_pricing_review_memorandum.json", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-24, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Theo Laurent.", "severity": "critical"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/11_policies/088_policies_status_report.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for usage-report inconsistency: one source states the threshold is 5% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 8% and produced a different exception result.", "id": "F-14", "issue": "usage-report inconsistency", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/05_pricing/040_pricing_status_report.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-24, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Amara Patel.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/091_renewal_records_correspondence.eml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for order-form precedence conflict: one source states formal notice must use notices-garnet_renewable_energy@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-mesa_crown_utilities@example.test.", "id": "F-15", "issue": "order-form precedence conflict", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/06_service_levels/043_service_levels_correspondence.eml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-24, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Henry Cho.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/094_renewal_records_formal_notice.xml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for survival-clause ambiguity: one source states the governed population contains 95 records through 2025-02-19, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 36 records through 2025-02-27.", "id": "F-16", "issue": "survival-clause ambiguity", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/06_service_levels/046_service_levels_formal_notice.xml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-24, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Nadine Flores.", "severity": "medium"}], "matter_number": "CB-CC-2507", "prepared_for": "Garnet Renewable Energy", "schema_version": "1.0", "task_id": "cb100-017-garnet-energy"}}, "metadata": {"benchmark": "CounselBench-100", "code_license": "Apache-2.0", "data_license": "CC-BY-4.0", "deadline": "2026-09-24", "document_count": 96, "jurisdiction": "Texas", "matter_number": "CB-CC-2507", "mcp_commit": "9a96ea6e5913736f92b88345bf51caeaaa8e719f", "mcp_package": "@modelcontextprotocol/server-filesystem@2026.7.10", "practice_area": "commercial-contracts", "reference_tool_calls": 46, "required_evidence_reads": 33, "synthetic": true, "venue": "Travis County, Texas", "version": "2.0.0"}, "prompt": "You are commercial contracts counsel for Garnet Renewable Energy. A counterparty challenged the client's internal summary, making cross-document reconciliation and precise citations essential. An energy offtake portfolio contains metering disputes, a change-in-law pass-through, and notice records sent to an address deleted by amendment. Decision due 2026-09-24. Texas law governs; Travis County, Texas is the forum. Flag cross-folder dependencies that would be invisible in a single-document review. Work out the defensible position from the matter production and leave an audit-ready exception tracker and concise advice for the supervising lawyer. Keep confirmed conflicts separate from open questions, cite the records that actually control each conclusion, and do not fill gaps with outside facts.", "rubric": {"criteria": [{"category": "procedure", "description": "Complete at least 46 successful, argument-specific evidence and output calls.", "id": "procedure.minimum_successful_tool_calls"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Find and read the 33 controlling, corroborating, and work-product-control records in full.", "id": "procedure.all_evidence_read_in_full"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Inspect file metadata for the eight designated critical primary records before relying on them.", "id": "procedure.chain_of_custody_metadata_checked"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Confirm the sandbox's allowed document and output roots.", "id": "procedure.allowed_directories_checked"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Inventory all 96 records so the relevant sources are discovered among the context records.", "id": "procedure.recursive_inventory_completed"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Search the production for email evidence that may corroborate or contradict formal records.", "id": "procedure.targeted_search_completed"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Leave only findings.json and advice.md in the output workspace.", "id": "procedure.exact_deliverable_set"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Create both final work products through the sandbox MCP surface.", "id": "procedure.deliverables_written_through_mcp"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Produce findings.json as a valid JSON object.", "id": "findings.findings_is_object"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Report exactly 16 confirmed exceptions.", "id": "findings.findings_exact_count"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Use each stable finding ID exactly once.", "id": "findings.finding_ids_unique"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set schema_version to the released matter value '1.0'.", "id": "findings.top_level_schema_version"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set task_id to the released matter value 'cb100-017-garnet-energy'.", "id": "findings.top_level_task_id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set matter_number to the released matter value 'CB-CC-2507'.", "id": "findings.top_level_matter_number"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set prepared_for to the released matter value 'Garnet Renewable Energy'.", "id": "findings.top_level_prepared_for"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set as_of to the released matter value '2026-09-24'.", "id": "findings.top_level_as_of"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-01 exception for renewal date conflict.", "id": "findings.F-01.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's id from /workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/001_master_agreements_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_security_privacy/049_security_privacy_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's issue from /workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/001_master_agreements_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_security_privacy/049_security_privacy_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's severity from /workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/001_master_agreements_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_security_privacy/049_security_privacy_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's primary_source from /workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/001_master_agreements_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_security_privacy/049_security_privacy_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/001_master_agreements_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_security_privacy/049_security_privacy_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-01 using the exact controlled facts ['2025-06-19', 'CB-CC-2507-A507', '2025-08-04', 'CB-CC-2507-J823'].", "id": "findings.F-01.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-01's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-01.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-24', 'Dominic Alvarez'] for F-01.", "id": "findings.F-01.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-02 exception for pricing-escalator mismatch.", "id": "findings.F-02.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's id from /workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/004_master_agreements_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_security_privacy/052_security_privacy_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's issue from /workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/004_master_agreements_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_security_privacy/052_security_privacy_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's severity from /workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/004_master_agreements_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_security_privacy/052_security_privacy_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's primary_source from /workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/004_master_agreements_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_security_privacy/052_security_privacy_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/004_master_agreements_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_security_privacy/052_security_privacy_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-02 using the exact controlled facts ['$1,213,778.00', '$1,464,056.00'].", "id": "findings.F-02.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-02's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-02.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-24', 'Priya Raman'] for F-02.", "id": "findings.F-02.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-03 exception for minimum-commit shortfall.", "id": "findings.F-03.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's id from /workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/007_master_agreements_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_security_privacy/055_security_privacy_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's issue from /workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/007_master_agreements_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_security_privacy/055_security_privacy_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's severity from /workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/007_master_agreements_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_security_privacy/055_security_privacy_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's primary_source from /workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/007_master_agreements_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_security_privacy/055_security_privacy_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/007_master_agreements_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_security_privacy/055_security_privacy_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-03 using the exact controlled facts ['Lena Varga', 'Rafael Okafor'].", "id": "findings.F-03.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-03's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-03.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-24', 'Elliot Mercer'] for F-03.", "id": "findings.F-03.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-04 exception for service-credit underpayment.", "id": "findings.F-04.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's id from /workspace/documents/02_order_forms/010_order_forms_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_notices/058_notices_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's issue from /workspace/documents/02_order_forms/010_order_forms_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_notices/058_notices_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's severity from /workspace/documents/02_order_forms/010_order_forms_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_notices/058_notices_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's primary_source from /workspace/documents/02_order_forms/010_order_forms_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_notices/058_notices_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/02_order_forms/010_order_forms_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_notices/058_notices_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-04 using the exact controlled facts ['closed without exception', 'CB-CC-2507-D780', 'open and escalated', 'CB-CC-2507-M913'].", "id": "findings.F-04.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-04's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-04.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-24', 'Talia Brooks'] for F-04.", "id": "findings.F-04.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-05 exception for termination notice defect.", "id": "findings.F-05.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's id from /workspace/documents/02_order_forms/013_order_forms_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_notices/061_notices_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's issue from /workspace/documents/02_order_forms/013_order_forms_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_notices/061_notices_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's severity from /workspace/documents/02_order_forms/013_order_forms_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_notices/061_notices_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's primary_source from /workspace/documents/02_order_forms/013_order_forms_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_notices/061_notices_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/02_order_forms/013_order_forms_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_notices/061_notices_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-05 using the exact controlled facts ['Travis County, Texas', 'Texas'].", "id": "findings.F-05.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-05's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-05.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-24', 'Jonas Feld'] for F-05.", "id": "findings.F-05.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-06 exception for assignment consent requirement.", "id": "findings.F-06.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's id from /workspace/documents/02_order_forms/016_order_forms_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_notices/064_notices_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's issue from /workspace/documents/02_order_forms/016_order_forms_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_notices/064_notices_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's severity from /workspace/documents/02_order_forms/016_order_forms_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_notices/064_notices_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's primary_source from /workspace/documents/02_order_forms/016_order_forms_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_notices/064_notices_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/02_order_forms/016_order_forms_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_notices/064_notices_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-06 using the exact controlled facts ['4%', '6%'].", "id": "findings.F-06.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-06's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-06.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-24', 'Mei Whitaker'] for F-06.", "id": "findings.F-06.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-07 exception for data-localization conflict.", "id": "findings.F-07.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's id from /workspace/documents/03_amendments/019_amendments_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_invoices/067_invoices_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's issue from /workspace/documents/03_amendments/019_amendments_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_invoices/067_invoices_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's severity from /workspace/documents/03_amendments/019_amendments_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_invoices/067_invoices_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's primary_source from /workspace/documents/03_amendments/019_amendments_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_invoices/067_invoices_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/03_amendments/019_amendments_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_invoices/067_invoices_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-07 using the exact controlled facts ['notices-garnet_renewable_energy@example.test', 'archive-mesa_crown_utilities@example.test'].", "id": "findings.F-07.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-07's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-07.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-24', 'Caleb Hassan'] for F-07.", "id": "findings.F-07.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-08 exception for subprocessor notice lapse.", "id": "findings.F-08.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's id from /workspace/documents/03_amendments/022_amendments_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_invoices/070_invoices_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's issue from /workspace/documents/03_amendments/022_amendments_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_invoices/070_invoices_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's severity from /workspace/documents/03_amendments/022_amendments_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_invoices/070_invoices_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's primary_source from /workspace/documents/03_amendments/022_amendments_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_invoices/070_invoices_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/03_amendments/022_amendments_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_invoices/070_invoices_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-08 using the exact controlled facts ['64 records', '2025-10-26', '64 records', '2025-12-01'].", "id": "findings.F-08.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-08's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-08.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-24', 'Leona Park'] for F-08.", "id": "findings.F-08.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-09 exception for insurance-limit deficiency.", "id": "findings.F-09.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's id from /workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/025_statements_of_work_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_correspondence/073_correspondence_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's issue from /workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/025_statements_of_work_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_correspondence/073_correspondence_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's severity from /workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/025_statements_of_work_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_correspondence/073_correspondence_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's primary_source from /workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/025_statements_of_work_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_correspondence/073_correspondence_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/025_statements_of_work_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_correspondence/073_correspondence_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-09 using the exact controlled facts ['2025-06-12', 'CB-CC-2507-I500', '2025-07-13', 'CB-CC-2507-R200'].", "id": "findings.F-09.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-09's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-09.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-24', 'Isaac Romero'] for F-09.", "id": "findings.F-09.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-10 exception for audit-right deadline.", "id": "findings.F-10.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's id from /workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/028_statements_of_work_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_correspondence/076_correspondence_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's issue from /workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/028_statements_of_work_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_correspondence/076_correspondence_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's severity from /workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/028_statements_of_work_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_correspondence/076_correspondence_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's primary_source from /workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/028_statements_of_work_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_correspondence/076_correspondence_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/028_statements_of_work_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_correspondence/076_correspondence_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-10 using the exact controlled facts ['$3,802,426.00', '$3,961,352.00'].", "id": "findings.F-10.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-10's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-10.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-24', 'Sofia Bennett'] for F-10.", "id": "findings.F-10.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-11 exception for exclusivity carveout breach.", "id": "findings.F-11.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's id from /workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/031_statements_of_work_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_correspondence/079_correspondence_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's issue from /workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/031_statements_of_work_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_correspondence/079_correspondence_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's severity from /workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/031_statements_of_work_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_correspondence/079_correspondence_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's primary_source from /workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/031_statements_of_work_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_correspondence/079_correspondence_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/031_statements_of_work_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_correspondence/079_correspondence_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-11 using the exact controlled facts ['Lena Varga', 'Henry Cho'].", "id": "findings.F-11.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-11's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-11.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-24', 'Adrian Mensah'] for F-11.", "id": "findings.F-11.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-12 exception for benchmarking right omission.", "id": "findings.F-12.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's id from /workspace/documents/05_pricing/034_pricing_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_policies/082_policies_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's issue from /workspace/documents/05_pricing/034_pricing_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_policies/082_policies_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's severity from /workspace/documents/05_pricing/034_pricing_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_policies/082_policies_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's primary_source from /workspace/documents/05_pricing/034_pricing_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_policies/082_policies_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/05_pricing/034_pricing_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_policies/082_policies_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-12 using the exact controlled facts ['closed without exception', 'CB-CC-2507-L715', 'open and escalated', 'CB-CC-2507-U978'].", "id": "findings.F-12.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-12's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-12.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-24', 'Willa Novak'] for F-12.", "id": "findings.F-12.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-13 exception for invoice currency discrepancy.", "id": "findings.F-13.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's id from /workspace/documents/05_pricing/037_pricing_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_policies/085_policies_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's issue from /workspace/documents/05_pricing/037_pricing_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_policies/085_policies_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's severity from /workspace/documents/05_pricing/037_pricing_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_policies/085_policies_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's primary_source from /workspace/documents/05_pricing/037_pricing_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_policies/085_policies_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/05_pricing/037_pricing_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_policies/085_policies_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-13 using the exact controlled facts ['Travis County, Texas', 'Texas'].", "id": "findings.F-13.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-13's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-13.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-24', 'Theo Laurent'] for F-13.", "id": "findings.F-13.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-14 exception for usage-report inconsistency.", "id": "findings.F-14.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's id from /workspace/documents/05_pricing/040_pricing_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_policies/088_policies_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's issue from /workspace/documents/05_pricing/040_pricing_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_policies/088_policies_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's severity from /workspace/documents/05_pricing/040_pricing_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_policies/088_policies_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's primary_source from /workspace/documents/05_pricing/040_pricing_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_policies/088_policies_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/05_pricing/040_pricing_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_policies/088_policies_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-14 using the exact controlled facts ['5%', '8%'].", "id": "findings.F-14.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-14's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-14.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-24', 'Amara Patel'] for F-14.", "id": "findings.F-14.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-15 exception for order-form precedence conflict.", "id": "findings.F-15.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's id from /workspace/documents/06_service_levels/043_service_levels_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/091_renewal_records_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's issue from /workspace/documents/06_service_levels/043_service_levels_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/091_renewal_records_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's severity from /workspace/documents/06_service_levels/043_service_levels_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/091_renewal_records_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's primary_source from /workspace/documents/06_service_levels/043_service_levels_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/091_renewal_records_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/06_service_levels/043_service_levels_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/091_renewal_records_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-15 using the exact controlled facts ['notices-garnet_renewable_energy@example.test', 'archive-mesa_crown_utilities@example.test'].", "id": "findings.F-15.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-15's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-15.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-24', 'Henry Cho'] for F-15.", "id": "findings.F-15.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-16 exception for survival-clause ambiguity.", "id": "findings.F-16.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's id from /workspace/documents/06_service_levels/046_service_levels_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/094_renewal_records_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's issue from /workspace/documents/06_service_levels/046_service_levels_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/094_renewal_records_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's severity from /workspace/documents/06_service_levels/046_service_levels_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/094_renewal_records_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's primary_source from /workspace/documents/06_service_levels/046_service_levels_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/094_renewal_records_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/06_service_levels/046_service_levels_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/094_renewal_records_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-16 using the exact controlled facts ['95 records', '2025-02-19', '36 records', '2025-02-27'].", "id": "findings.F-16.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-16's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-16.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-24', 'Nadine Flores'] for F-16.", "id": "findings.F-16.action_anchors"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Executive assessment' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Executive assessment"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Method and record coverage' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Method and record coverage"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Findings' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Findings"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Recommended next actions' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Recommended next actions"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Assumptions and limitations' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Assumptions and limitations"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-01 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-01"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-02 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-02"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-03 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-03"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-04 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-04"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-05 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-05"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-06 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-06"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-07 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-07"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-08 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-08"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-09 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-09"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-10 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-10"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-11 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-11"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-12 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-12"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-13 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-13"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-14 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-14"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-15 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-15"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-16 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-16"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Do not claim the production has no issues or that every record is consistent.", "id": "memo.forbidden_claims_absent"}], "decision_options": [{"id": "cross-source-reconciliation", "label": "Reconcile controlling and corroborating records", "reason": "The CB-CC-2507 production contains independently maintained records; a defensible answer must preserve each supported conflict and its cure owner.", "selected": true}, {"id": "latest-record-controls", "label": "Treat the latest record as controlling", "reason": "Timestamp recency does not establish legal priority, execution, or approval authority.", "selected": false}, {"id": "primary-records-only", "label": "Report primary records without reconciliation", "reason": "Primary records alone conceal the operational conflicts that create the actionable exceptions.", "selected": false}], "gates": ["all_evidence_read_in_full", "chain_of_custody_metadata_checked", "findings_criteria_complete", "memo_criteria_complete", "deliverables_written_through_mcp"], "metadata_checks": 8, "metric": "weighted_criteria_score", "minimum_tool_calls": 46, "required_deliverables": ["findings.json", "advice.md"], "required_document_reads": 33, "type": "deterministic", "weights": {"findings": 0.55, "memo": 0.2, "procedure": 0.25}}, "task_id": "cb100-017-garnet-energy", "task_name": "Garnet offtake agreement review", "world_id": "counselbench-filesystem-mcp-v2"}
-{"context_files": ["task_files/cb100-018-harborlight-ai/01_master_agreements/001_master_agreements_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-018-harborlight-ai/01_master_agreements/002_master_agreements_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-018-harborlight-ai/01_master_agreements/003_master_agreements_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-018-harborlight-ai/01_master_agreements/004_master_agreements_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-018-harborlight-ai/01_master_agreements/005_master_agreements_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-018-harborlight-ai/01_master_agreements/006_master_agreements_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-018-harborlight-ai/01_master_agreements/007_master_agreements_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-018-harborlight-ai/01_master_agreements/008_master_agreements_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-018-harborlight-ai/02_order_forms/009_order_forms_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-018-harborlight-ai/02_order_forms/010_order_forms_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-018-harborlight-ai/02_order_forms/011_order_forms_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-018-harborlight-ai/02_order_forms/012_order_forms_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-018-harborlight-ai/02_order_forms/013_order_forms_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-018-harborlight-ai/02_order_forms/014_order_forms_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-018-harborlight-ai/02_order_forms/015_order_forms_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-018-harborlight-ai/02_order_forms/016_order_forms_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-018-harborlight-ai/03_amendments/017_amendments_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-018-harborlight-ai/03_amendments/018_amendments_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-018-harborlight-ai/03_amendments/019_amendments_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-018-harborlight-ai/03_amendments/020_amendments_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-018-harborlight-ai/03_amendments/021_amendments_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-018-harborlight-ai/03_amendments/022_amendments_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-018-harborlight-ai/03_amendments/023_amendments_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-018-harborlight-ai/03_amendments/024_amendments_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-018-harborlight-ai/04_statements_of_work/025_statements_of_work_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-018-harborlight-ai/04_statements_of_work/026_statements_of_work_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-018-harborlight-ai/04_statements_of_work/027_statements_of_work_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-018-harborlight-ai/04_statements_of_work/028_statements_of_work_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-018-harborlight-ai/04_statements_of_work/029_statements_of_work_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-018-harborlight-ai/04_statements_of_work/030_statements_of_work_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-018-harborlight-ai/04_statements_of_work/031_statements_of_work_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-018-harborlight-ai/04_statements_of_work/032_statements_of_work_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-018-harborlight-ai/05_pricing/033_pricing_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-018-harborlight-ai/05_pricing/034_pricing_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-018-harborlight-ai/05_pricing/035_pricing_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-018-harborlight-ai/05_pricing/036_pricing_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-018-harborlight-ai/05_pricing/037_pricing_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-018-harborlight-ai/05_pricing/038_pricing_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-018-harborlight-ai/05_pricing/039_pricing_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-018-harborlight-ai/05_pricing/040_pricing_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-018-harborlight-ai/06_service_levels/041_service_levels_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-018-harborlight-ai/06_service_levels/042_service_levels_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-018-harborlight-ai/06_service_levels/043_service_levels_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-018-harborlight-ai/06_service_levels/044_service_levels_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-018-harborlight-ai/06_service_levels/045_service_levels_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-018-harborlight-ai/06_service_levels/046_service_levels_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-018-harborlight-ai/06_service_levels/047_service_levels_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-018-harborlight-ai/06_service_levels/048_service_levels_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-018-harborlight-ai/07_security_privacy/049_security_privacy_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-018-harborlight-ai/07_security_privacy/050_security_privacy_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-018-harborlight-ai/07_security_privacy/051_security_privacy_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-018-harborlight-ai/07_security_privacy/052_security_privacy_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-018-harborlight-ai/07_security_privacy/053_security_privacy_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-018-harborlight-ai/07_security_privacy/054_security_privacy_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-018-harborlight-ai/07_security_privacy/055_security_privacy_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-018-harborlight-ai/07_security_privacy/056_security_privacy_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-018-harborlight-ai/08_notices/057_notices_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-018-harborlight-ai/08_notices/058_notices_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-018-harborlight-ai/08_notices/059_notices_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-018-harborlight-ai/08_notices/060_notices_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-018-harborlight-ai/08_notices/061_notices_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-018-harborlight-ai/08_notices/062_notices_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-018-harborlight-ai/08_notices/063_notices_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-018-harborlight-ai/08_notices/064_notices_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-018-harborlight-ai/09_invoices/065_invoices_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-018-harborlight-ai/09_invoices/066_invoices_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-018-harborlight-ai/09_invoices/067_invoices_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-018-harborlight-ai/09_invoices/068_invoices_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-018-harborlight-ai/09_invoices/069_invoices_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-018-harborlight-ai/09_invoices/070_invoices_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-018-harborlight-ai/09_invoices/071_invoices_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-018-harborlight-ai/09_invoices/072_invoices_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-018-harborlight-ai/10_correspondence/073_correspondence_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-018-harborlight-ai/10_correspondence/074_correspondence_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-018-harborlight-ai/10_correspondence/075_correspondence_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-018-harborlight-ai/10_correspondence/076_correspondence_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-018-harborlight-ai/10_correspondence/077_correspondence_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-018-harborlight-ai/10_correspondence/078_correspondence_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-018-harborlight-ai/10_correspondence/079_correspondence_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-018-harborlight-ai/10_correspondence/080_correspondence_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-018-harborlight-ai/11_policies/081_policies_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-018-harborlight-ai/11_policies/082_policies_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-018-harborlight-ai/11_policies/083_policies_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-018-harborlight-ai/11_policies/084_policies_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-018-harborlight-ai/11_policies/085_policies_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-018-harborlight-ai/11_policies/086_policies_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-018-harborlight-ai/11_policies/087_policies_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-018-harborlight-ai/11_policies/088_policies_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-018-harborlight-ai/12_renewal_records/089_renewal_records_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-018-harborlight-ai/12_renewal_records/090_renewal_records_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-018-harborlight-ai/12_renewal_records/091_renewal_records_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-018-harborlight-ai/12_renewal_records/092_renewal_records_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-018-harborlight-ai/12_renewal_records/093_renewal_records_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-018-harborlight-ai/12_renewal_records/094_renewal_records_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-018-harborlight-ai/12_renewal_records/095_renewal_records_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-018-harborlight-ai/12_renewal_records/096_renewal_records_status_report.md"], "gold_output": {"advice_markdown": "# Counsel advice — Harborlight AI procurement reconciliation\n\n## Executive assessment\n\nFor Harborlight AI Systems matter CB-CC-2508, the review identified 16 source-supported exceptions requiring action before 2026-09-28. The assessment concerns Westmere Insurance Cooperative and the supplied record for Connecticut.\n\n## Method and record coverage\n\nThe review inventoried all 96 production files, read the 33 controlling, corroborating, and control records, searched the email exports, and checked metadata for the designated chain-of-custody sample. Conclusions are limited to the synthetic production supplied for this benchmark matter.\n\n## Findings\n\n### F-01 — renewal date conflict (critical)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for renewal date conflict: one source states the operative date is 2025-05-05 under control reference CB-CC-2508-A642, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2025-05-30 under response reference CB-CC-2508-J557.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/001_master_agreements_control_register.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/07_security_privacy/049_security_privacy_control_register.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-28, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Priya Raman.\n\n### F-02 — pricing-escalator mismatch (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for pricing-escalator mismatch: one source states the controlling amount is $1,383,509.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $1,603,518.00.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/004_master_agreements_ledger_export.csv`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/07_security_privacy/052_security_privacy_ledger_export.csv`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-28, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Elliot Mercer.\n\n### F-03 — minimum-commit shortfall (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for minimum-commit shortfall: one source states approval is attributed to Samuel Kim as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Dominic Alvarez and contains no entry for Samuel Kim.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/007_master_agreements_officer_certificate.html`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/07_security_privacy/055_security_privacy_officer_certificate.html`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-28, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Talia Brooks.\n\n### F-04 — service-credit underpayment (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for service-credit underpayment: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-CC-2508-D419, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-CC-2508-M539.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/02_order_forms/010_order_forms_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/08_notices/058_notices_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-28, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Jonas Feld.\n\n### F-05 — termination notice defect (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for termination notice defect: one source states the applicable location is Hartford County, Connecticut, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to Connecticut operations outside Hartford County, Connecticut.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/02_order_forms/013_order_forms_review_memorandum.json`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/08_notices/061_notices_review_memorandum.json`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-28, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Mei Whitaker.\n\n### F-06 — assignment consent requirement (low)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for assignment consent requirement: one source states the threshold is 7% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 10% and produced a different exception result.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/02_order_forms/016_order_forms_status_report.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/08_notices/064_notices_status_report.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-28, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Caleb Hassan.\n\n### F-07 — data-localization conflict (critical)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for data-localization conflict: one source states formal notice must use notices-harborlight_ai_systems@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-westmere_insurance_cooperative@example.test.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/03_amendments/019_amendments_correspondence.eml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/09_invoices/067_invoices_correspondence.eml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-28, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Leona Park.\n\n### F-08 — subprocessor notice lapse (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for subprocessor notice lapse: one source states the governed population contains 86 records through 2025-02-10, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 53 records through 2025-03-07.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/03_amendments/022_amendments_formal_notice.xml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/09_invoices/070_invoices_formal_notice.xml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-28, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Isaac Romero.\n\n### F-09 — insurance-limit deficiency (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for insurance-limit deficiency: one source states the operative date is 2026-01-05 under control reference CB-CC-2508-I887, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2026-01-16 under response reference CB-CC-2508-R299.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/025_statements_of_work_control_register.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/10_correspondence/073_correspondence_control_register.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-28, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Sofia Bennett.\n\n### F-10 — audit-right deadline (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for audit-right deadline: one source states the controlling amount is $4,464,571.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $4,775,642.00.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/028_statements_of_work_ledger_export.csv`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/10_correspondence/076_correspondence_ledger_export.csv`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-28, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Adrian Mensah.\n\n### F-11 — exclusivity carveout breach (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for exclusivity carveout breach: one source states approval is attributed to Samuel Kim as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Micah Sullivan and contains no entry for Samuel Kim.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/031_statements_of_work_officer_certificate.html`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/10_correspondence/079_correspondence_officer_certificate.html`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-28, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Willa Novak.\n\n### F-12 — benchmarking right omission (low)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for benchmarking right omission: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-CC-2508-L855, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-CC-2508-U573.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/05_pricing/034_pricing_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/11_policies/082_policies_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-28, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Theo Laurent.\n\n### F-13 — invoice currency discrepancy (critical)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for invoice currency discrepancy: one source states the applicable location is Hartford County, Connecticut, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to Connecticut operations outside Hartford County, Connecticut.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/05_pricing/037_pricing_review_memorandum.json`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/11_policies/085_policies_review_memorandum.json`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-28, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Amara Patel.\n\n### F-14 — usage-report inconsistency (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for usage-report inconsistency: one source states the threshold is 4% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 10% and produced a different exception result.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/05_pricing/040_pricing_status_report.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/11_policies/088_policies_status_report.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-28, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Henry Cho.\n\n### F-15 — order-form precedence conflict (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for order-form precedence conflict: one source states formal notice must use notices-harborlight_ai_systems@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-westmere_insurance_cooperative@example.test.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/06_service_levels/043_service_levels_correspondence.eml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/091_renewal_records_correspondence.eml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-28, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Nadine Flores.\n\n### F-16 — survival-clause ambiguity (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for survival-clause ambiguity: one source states the governed population contains 125 records through 2025-03-21, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 38 records through 2025-03-31.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/06_service_levels/046_service_levels_formal_notice.xml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/094_renewal_records_formal_notice.xml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-28, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Micah Sullivan.\n\n## Recommended next actions\n\nSequence the critical and high findings first, assign the named owners, preserve the cited records, and document any resolution in the controlling matter register before the stated deadline.\n\n## Assumptions and limitations\n\nThis analysis is confined to task cb100-018-harborlight-ai and the supplied synthetic evidence. It does not rely on external facts, does not resolve disputed law, and is not legal advice for a real person or entity.\n", "findings": {"as_of": "2026-09-28", "findings": [{"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/07_security_privacy/049_security_privacy_control_register.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for renewal date conflict: one source states the operative date is 2025-05-05 under control reference CB-CC-2508-A642, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2025-05-30 under response reference CB-CC-2508-J557.", "id": "F-01", "issue": "renewal date conflict", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/001_master_agreements_control_register.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-28, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Priya Raman.", "severity": "critical"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/07_security_privacy/052_security_privacy_ledger_export.csv", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for pricing-escalator mismatch: one source states the controlling amount is $1,383,509.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $1,603,518.00.", "id": "F-02", "issue": "pricing-escalator mismatch", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/004_master_agreements_ledger_export.csv", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-28, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Elliot Mercer.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/07_security_privacy/055_security_privacy_officer_certificate.html", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for minimum-commit shortfall: one source states approval is attributed to Samuel Kim as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Dominic Alvarez and contains no entry for Samuel Kim.", "id": "F-03", "issue": "minimum-commit shortfall", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/007_master_agreements_officer_certificate.html", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-28, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Talia Brooks.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/08_notices/058_notices_executed_instrument.txt", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for service-credit underpayment: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-CC-2508-D419, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-CC-2508-M539.", "id": "F-04", "issue": "service-credit underpayment", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/02_order_forms/010_order_forms_executed_instrument.txt", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-28, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Jonas Feld.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/08_notices/061_notices_review_memorandum.json", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for termination notice defect: one source states the applicable location is Hartford County, Connecticut, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to Connecticut operations outside Hartford County, Connecticut.", "id": "F-05", "issue": "termination notice defect", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/02_order_forms/013_order_forms_review_memorandum.json", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-28, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Mei Whitaker.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/08_notices/064_notices_status_report.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for assignment consent requirement: one source states the threshold is 7% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 10% and produced a different exception result.", "id": "F-06", "issue": "assignment consent requirement", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/02_order_forms/016_order_forms_status_report.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-28, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Caleb Hassan.", "severity": "low"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/09_invoices/067_invoices_correspondence.eml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for data-localization conflict: one source states formal notice must use notices-harborlight_ai_systems@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-westmere_insurance_cooperative@example.test.", "id": "F-07", "issue": "data-localization conflict", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/03_amendments/019_amendments_correspondence.eml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-28, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Leona Park.", "severity": "critical"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/09_invoices/070_invoices_formal_notice.xml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for subprocessor notice lapse: one source states the governed population contains 86 records through 2025-02-10, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 53 records through 2025-03-07.", "id": "F-08", "issue": "subprocessor notice lapse", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/03_amendments/022_amendments_formal_notice.xml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-28, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Isaac Romero.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/10_correspondence/073_correspondence_control_register.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for insurance-limit deficiency: one source states the operative date is 2026-01-05 under control reference CB-CC-2508-I887, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2026-01-16 under response reference CB-CC-2508-R299.", "id": "F-09", "issue": "insurance-limit deficiency", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/025_statements_of_work_control_register.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-28, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Sofia Bennett.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/10_correspondence/076_correspondence_ledger_export.csv", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for audit-right deadline: one source states the controlling amount is $4,464,571.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $4,775,642.00.", "id": "F-10", "issue": "audit-right deadline", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/028_statements_of_work_ledger_export.csv", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-28, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Adrian Mensah.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/10_correspondence/079_correspondence_officer_certificate.html", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for exclusivity carveout breach: one source states approval is attributed to Samuel Kim as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Micah Sullivan and contains no entry for Samuel Kim.", "id": "F-11", "issue": "exclusivity carveout breach", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/031_statements_of_work_officer_certificate.html", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-28, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Willa Novak.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/11_policies/082_policies_executed_instrument.txt", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for benchmarking right omission: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-CC-2508-L855, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-CC-2508-U573.", "id": "F-12", "issue": "benchmarking right omission", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/05_pricing/034_pricing_executed_instrument.txt", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-28, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Theo Laurent.", "severity": "low"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/11_policies/085_policies_review_memorandum.json", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for invoice currency discrepancy: one source states the applicable location is Hartford County, Connecticut, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to Connecticut operations outside Hartford County, Connecticut.", "id": "F-13", "issue": "invoice currency discrepancy", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/05_pricing/037_pricing_review_memorandum.json", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-28, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Amara Patel.", "severity": "critical"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/11_policies/088_policies_status_report.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for usage-report inconsistency: one source states the threshold is 4% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 10% and produced a different exception result.", "id": "F-14", "issue": "usage-report inconsistency", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/05_pricing/040_pricing_status_report.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-28, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Henry Cho.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/091_renewal_records_correspondence.eml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for order-form precedence conflict: one source states formal notice must use notices-harborlight_ai_systems@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-westmere_insurance_cooperative@example.test.", "id": "F-15", "issue": "order-form precedence conflict", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/06_service_levels/043_service_levels_correspondence.eml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-28, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Nadine Flores.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/094_renewal_records_formal_notice.xml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for survival-clause ambiguity: one source states the governed population contains 125 records through 2025-03-21, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 38 records through 2025-03-31.", "id": "F-16", "issue": "survival-clause ambiguity", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/06_service_levels/046_service_levels_formal_notice.xml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-28, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Micah Sullivan.", "severity": "medium"}], "matter_number": "CB-CC-2508", "prepared_for": "Harborlight AI Systems", "schema_version": "1.0", "task_id": "cb100-018-harborlight-ai"}}, "metadata": {"benchmark": "CounselBench-100", "code_license": "Apache-2.0", "data_license": "CC-BY-4.0", "deadline": "2026-09-28", "document_count": 96, "jurisdiction": "Connecticut", "matter_number": "CB-CC-2508", "mcp_commit": "9a96ea6e5913736f92b88345bf51caeaaa8e719f", "mcp_package": "@modelcontextprotocol/server-filesystem@2026.7.10", "practice_area": "commercial-contracts", "reference_tool_calls": 46, "required_evidence_reads": 33, "synthetic": true, "venue": "Hartford County, Connecticut", "version": "2.0.0"}, "prompt": "You are commercial contracts counsel for Harborlight AI Systems. The supervising attorney wants an exception-focused review that still demonstrates complete coverage of the data room. An AI services deal combines outcome benchmarks, model-training restrictions, and contradictory schedules for data deletion and incident notice. Decision due 2026-09-28. Connecticut law governs; Hartford County, Connecticut is the forum. Preserve the difference between the client's position, the counterparty's position, and an objective record conflict. Work out the defensible position from the matter production and leave an audit-ready exception tracker and concise advice for the supervising lawyer. Keep confirmed conflicts separate from open questions, cite the records that actually control each conclusion, and do not fill gaps with outside facts.", "rubric": {"criteria": [{"category": "procedure", "description": "Complete at least 46 successful, argument-specific evidence and output calls.", "id": "procedure.minimum_successful_tool_calls"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Find and read the 33 controlling, corroborating, and work-product-control records in full.", "id": "procedure.all_evidence_read_in_full"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Inspect file metadata for the eight designated critical primary records before relying on them.", "id": "procedure.chain_of_custody_metadata_checked"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Confirm the sandbox's allowed document and output roots.", "id": "procedure.allowed_directories_checked"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Inventory all 96 records so the relevant sources are discovered among the context records.", "id": "procedure.recursive_inventory_completed"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Search the production for email evidence that may corroborate or contradict formal records.", "id": "procedure.targeted_search_completed"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Leave only findings.json and advice.md in the output workspace.", "id": "procedure.exact_deliverable_set"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Create both final work products through the sandbox MCP surface.", "id": "procedure.deliverables_written_through_mcp"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Produce findings.json as a valid JSON object.", "id": "findings.findings_is_object"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Report exactly 16 confirmed exceptions.", "id": "findings.findings_exact_count"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Use each stable finding ID exactly once.", "id": "findings.finding_ids_unique"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set schema_version to the released matter value '1.0'.", "id": "findings.top_level_schema_version"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set task_id to the released matter value 'cb100-018-harborlight-ai'.", "id": "findings.top_level_task_id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set matter_number to the released matter value 'CB-CC-2508'.", "id": "findings.top_level_matter_number"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set prepared_for to the released matter value 'Harborlight AI Systems'.", "id": "findings.top_level_prepared_for"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set as_of to the released matter value '2026-09-28'.", "id": "findings.top_level_as_of"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-01 exception for renewal date conflict.", "id": "findings.F-01.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's id from /workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/001_master_agreements_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_security_privacy/049_security_privacy_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's issue from /workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/001_master_agreements_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_security_privacy/049_security_privacy_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's severity from /workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/001_master_agreements_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_security_privacy/049_security_privacy_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's primary_source from /workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/001_master_agreements_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_security_privacy/049_security_privacy_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/001_master_agreements_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_security_privacy/049_security_privacy_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-01 using the exact controlled facts ['2025-05-05', 'CB-CC-2508-A642', '2025-05-30', 'CB-CC-2508-J557'].", "id": "findings.F-01.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-01's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-01.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-28', 'Priya Raman'] for F-01.", "id": "findings.F-01.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-02 exception for pricing-escalator mismatch.", "id": "findings.F-02.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's id from /workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/004_master_agreements_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_security_privacy/052_security_privacy_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's issue from /workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/004_master_agreements_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_security_privacy/052_security_privacy_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's severity from /workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/004_master_agreements_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_security_privacy/052_security_privacy_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's primary_source from /workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/004_master_agreements_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_security_privacy/052_security_privacy_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/004_master_agreements_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_security_privacy/052_security_privacy_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-02 using the exact controlled facts ['$1,383,509.00', '$1,603,518.00'].", "id": "findings.F-02.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-02's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-02.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-28', 'Elliot Mercer'] for F-02.", "id": "findings.F-02.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-03 exception for minimum-commit shortfall.", "id": "findings.F-03.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's id from /workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/007_master_agreements_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_security_privacy/055_security_privacy_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's issue from /workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/007_master_agreements_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_security_privacy/055_security_privacy_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's severity from /workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/007_master_agreements_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_security_privacy/055_security_privacy_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's primary_source from /workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/007_master_agreements_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_security_privacy/055_security_privacy_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/007_master_agreements_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_security_privacy/055_security_privacy_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-03 using the exact controlled facts ['Samuel Kim', 'Dominic Alvarez'].", "id": "findings.F-03.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-03's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-03.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-28', 'Talia Brooks'] for F-03.", "id": "findings.F-03.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-04 exception for service-credit underpayment.", "id": "findings.F-04.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's id from /workspace/documents/02_order_forms/010_order_forms_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_notices/058_notices_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's issue from /workspace/documents/02_order_forms/010_order_forms_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_notices/058_notices_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's severity from /workspace/documents/02_order_forms/010_order_forms_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_notices/058_notices_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's primary_source from /workspace/documents/02_order_forms/010_order_forms_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_notices/058_notices_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/02_order_forms/010_order_forms_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_notices/058_notices_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-04 using the exact controlled facts ['closed without exception', 'CB-CC-2508-D419', 'open and escalated', 'CB-CC-2508-M539'].", "id": "findings.F-04.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-04's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-04.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-28', 'Jonas Feld'] for F-04.", "id": "findings.F-04.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-05 exception for termination notice defect.", "id": "findings.F-05.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's id from /workspace/documents/02_order_forms/013_order_forms_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_notices/061_notices_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's issue from /workspace/documents/02_order_forms/013_order_forms_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_notices/061_notices_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's severity from /workspace/documents/02_order_forms/013_order_forms_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_notices/061_notices_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's primary_source from /workspace/documents/02_order_forms/013_order_forms_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_notices/061_notices_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/02_order_forms/013_order_forms_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_notices/061_notices_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-05 using the exact controlled facts ['Hartford County, Connecticut', 'Connecticut'].", "id": "findings.F-05.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-05's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-05.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-28', 'Mei Whitaker'] for F-05.", "id": "findings.F-05.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-06 exception for assignment consent requirement.", "id": "findings.F-06.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's id from /workspace/documents/02_order_forms/016_order_forms_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_notices/064_notices_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's issue from /workspace/documents/02_order_forms/016_order_forms_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_notices/064_notices_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's severity from /workspace/documents/02_order_forms/016_order_forms_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_notices/064_notices_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's primary_source from /workspace/documents/02_order_forms/016_order_forms_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_notices/064_notices_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/02_order_forms/016_order_forms_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_notices/064_notices_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-06 using the exact controlled facts ['7%', '10%'].", "id": "findings.F-06.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-06's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-06.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-28', 'Caleb Hassan'] for F-06.", "id": "findings.F-06.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-07 exception for data-localization conflict.", "id": "findings.F-07.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's id from /workspace/documents/03_amendments/019_amendments_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_invoices/067_invoices_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's issue from /workspace/documents/03_amendments/019_amendments_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_invoices/067_invoices_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's severity from /workspace/documents/03_amendments/019_amendments_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_invoices/067_invoices_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's primary_source from /workspace/documents/03_amendments/019_amendments_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_invoices/067_invoices_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/03_amendments/019_amendments_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_invoices/067_invoices_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-07 using the exact controlled facts ['notices-harborlight_ai_systems@example.test', 'archive-westmere_insurance_cooperative@example.test'].", "id": "findings.F-07.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-07's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-07.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-28', 'Leona Park'] for F-07.", "id": "findings.F-07.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-08 exception for subprocessor notice lapse.", "id": "findings.F-08.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's id from /workspace/documents/03_amendments/022_amendments_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_invoices/070_invoices_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's issue from /workspace/documents/03_amendments/022_amendments_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_invoices/070_invoices_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's severity from /workspace/documents/03_amendments/022_amendments_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_invoices/070_invoices_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's primary_source from /workspace/documents/03_amendments/022_amendments_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_invoices/070_invoices_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/03_amendments/022_amendments_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_invoices/070_invoices_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-08 using the exact controlled facts ['86 records', '2025-02-10', '53 records', '2025-03-07'].", "id": "findings.F-08.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-08's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-08.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-28', 'Isaac Romero'] for F-08.", "id": "findings.F-08.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-09 exception for insurance-limit deficiency.", "id": "findings.F-09.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's id from /workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/025_statements_of_work_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_correspondence/073_correspondence_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's issue from /workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/025_statements_of_work_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_correspondence/073_correspondence_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's severity from /workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/025_statements_of_work_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_correspondence/073_correspondence_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's primary_source from /workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/025_statements_of_work_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_correspondence/073_correspondence_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/025_statements_of_work_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_correspondence/073_correspondence_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-09 using the exact controlled facts ['2026-01-05', 'CB-CC-2508-I887', '2026-01-16', 'CB-CC-2508-R299'].", "id": "findings.F-09.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-09's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-09.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-28', 'Sofia Bennett'] for F-09.", "id": "findings.F-09.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-10 exception for audit-right deadline.", "id": "findings.F-10.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's id from /workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/028_statements_of_work_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_correspondence/076_correspondence_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's issue from /workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/028_statements_of_work_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_correspondence/076_correspondence_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's severity from /workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/028_statements_of_work_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_correspondence/076_correspondence_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's primary_source from /workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/028_statements_of_work_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_correspondence/076_correspondence_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/028_statements_of_work_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_correspondence/076_correspondence_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-10 using the exact controlled facts ['$4,464,571.00', '$4,775,642.00'].", "id": "findings.F-10.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-10's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-10.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-28', 'Adrian Mensah'] for F-10.", "id": "findings.F-10.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-11 exception for exclusivity carveout breach.", "id": "findings.F-11.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's id from /workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/031_statements_of_work_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_correspondence/079_correspondence_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's issue from /workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/031_statements_of_work_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_correspondence/079_correspondence_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's severity from /workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/031_statements_of_work_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_correspondence/079_correspondence_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's primary_source from /workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/031_statements_of_work_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_correspondence/079_correspondence_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/031_statements_of_work_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_correspondence/079_correspondence_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-11 using the exact controlled facts ['Samuel Kim', 'Micah Sullivan'].", "id": "findings.F-11.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-11's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-11.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-28', 'Willa Novak'] for F-11.", "id": "findings.F-11.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-12 exception for benchmarking right omission.", "id": "findings.F-12.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's id from /workspace/documents/05_pricing/034_pricing_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_policies/082_policies_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's issue from /workspace/documents/05_pricing/034_pricing_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_policies/082_policies_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's severity from /workspace/documents/05_pricing/034_pricing_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_policies/082_policies_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's primary_source from /workspace/documents/05_pricing/034_pricing_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_policies/082_policies_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/05_pricing/034_pricing_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_policies/082_policies_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-12 using the exact controlled facts ['closed without exception', 'CB-CC-2508-L855', 'open and escalated', 'CB-CC-2508-U573'].", "id": "findings.F-12.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-12's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-12.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-28', 'Theo Laurent'] for F-12.", "id": "findings.F-12.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-13 exception for invoice currency discrepancy.", "id": "findings.F-13.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's id from /workspace/documents/05_pricing/037_pricing_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_policies/085_policies_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's issue from /workspace/documents/05_pricing/037_pricing_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_policies/085_policies_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's severity from /workspace/documents/05_pricing/037_pricing_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_policies/085_policies_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's primary_source from /workspace/documents/05_pricing/037_pricing_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_policies/085_policies_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/05_pricing/037_pricing_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_policies/085_policies_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-13 using the exact controlled facts ['Hartford County, Connecticut', 'Connecticut'].", "id": "findings.F-13.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-13's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-13.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-28', 'Amara Patel'] for F-13.", "id": "findings.F-13.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-14 exception for usage-report inconsistency.", "id": "findings.F-14.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's id from /workspace/documents/05_pricing/040_pricing_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_policies/088_policies_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's issue from /workspace/documents/05_pricing/040_pricing_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_policies/088_policies_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's severity from /workspace/documents/05_pricing/040_pricing_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_policies/088_policies_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's primary_source from /workspace/documents/05_pricing/040_pricing_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_policies/088_policies_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/05_pricing/040_pricing_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_policies/088_policies_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-14 using the exact controlled facts ['4%', '10%'].", "id": "findings.F-14.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-14's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-14.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-28', 'Henry Cho'] for F-14.", "id": "findings.F-14.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-15 exception for order-form precedence conflict.", "id": "findings.F-15.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's id from /workspace/documents/06_service_levels/043_service_levels_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/091_renewal_records_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's issue from /workspace/documents/06_service_levels/043_service_levels_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/091_renewal_records_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's severity from /workspace/documents/06_service_levels/043_service_levels_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/091_renewal_records_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's primary_source from /workspace/documents/06_service_levels/043_service_levels_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/091_renewal_records_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/06_service_levels/043_service_levels_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/091_renewal_records_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-15 using the exact controlled facts ['notices-harborlight_ai_systems@example.test', 'archive-westmere_insurance_cooperative@example.test'].", "id": "findings.F-15.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-15's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-15.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-28', 'Nadine Flores'] for F-15.", "id": "findings.F-15.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-16 exception for survival-clause ambiguity.", "id": "findings.F-16.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's id from /workspace/documents/06_service_levels/046_service_levels_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/094_renewal_records_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's issue from /workspace/documents/06_service_levels/046_service_levels_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/094_renewal_records_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's severity from /workspace/documents/06_service_levels/046_service_levels_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/094_renewal_records_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's primary_source from /workspace/documents/06_service_levels/046_service_levels_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/094_renewal_records_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/06_service_levels/046_service_levels_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/094_renewal_records_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-16 using the exact controlled facts ['125 records', '2025-03-21', '38 records', '2025-03-31'].", "id": "findings.F-16.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-16's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-16.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-28', 'Micah Sullivan'] for F-16.", "id": "findings.F-16.action_anchors"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Executive assessment' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Executive assessment"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Method and record coverage' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Method and record coverage"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Findings' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Findings"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Recommended next actions' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Recommended next actions"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Assumptions and limitations' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Assumptions and limitations"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-01 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-01"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-02 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-02"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-03 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-03"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-04 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-04"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-05 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-05"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-06 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-06"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-07 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-07"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-08 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-08"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-09 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-09"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-10 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-10"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-11 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-11"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-12 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-12"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-13 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-13"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-14 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-14"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-15 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-15"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-16 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-16"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Do not claim the production has no issues or that every record is consistent.", "id": "memo.forbidden_claims_absent"}], "decision_options": [{"id": "cross-source-reconciliation", "label": "Reconcile controlling and corroborating records", "reason": "The CB-CC-2508 production contains independently maintained records; a defensible answer must preserve each supported conflict and its cure owner.", "selected": true}, {"id": "latest-record-controls", "label": "Treat the latest record as controlling", "reason": "Timestamp recency does not establish legal priority, execution, or approval authority.", "selected": false}, {"id": "primary-records-only", "label": "Report primary records without reconciliation", "reason": "Primary records alone conceal the operational conflicts that create the actionable exceptions.", "selected": false}], "gates": ["all_evidence_read_in_full", "chain_of_custody_metadata_checked", "findings_criteria_complete", "memo_criteria_complete", "deliverables_written_through_mcp"], "metadata_checks": 8, "metric": "weighted_criteria_score", "minimum_tool_calls": 46, "required_deliverables": ["findings.json", "advice.md"], "required_document_reads": 33, "type": "deterministic", "weights": {"findings": 0.55, "memo": 0.2, "procedure": 0.25}}, "task_id": "cb100-018-harborlight-ai", "task_name": "Harborlight AI procurement reconciliation", "world_id": "counselbench-filesystem-mcp-v2"}
-{"context_files": ["task_files/cb100-019-ironwood-agri/01_master_agreements/001_master_agreements_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-019-ironwood-agri/01_master_agreements/002_master_agreements_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-019-ironwood-agri/01_master_agreements/003_master_agreements_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-019-ironwood-agri/01_master_agreements/004_master_agreements_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-019-ironwood-agri/01_master_agreements/005_master_agreements_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-019-ironwood-agri/01_master_agreements/006_master_agreements_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-019-ironwood-agri/01_master_agreements/007_master_agreements_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-019-ironwood-agri/01_master_agreements/008_master_agreements_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-019-ironwood-agri/02_order_forms/009_order_forms_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-019-ironwood-agri/02_order_forms/010_order_forms_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-019-ironwood-agri/02_order_forms/011_order_forms_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-019-ironwood-agri/02_order_forms/012_order_forms_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-019-ironwood-agri/02_order_forms/013_order_forms_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-019-ironwood-agri/02_order_forms/014_order_forms_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-019-ironwood-agri/02_order_forms/015_order_forms_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-019-ironwood-agri/02_order_forms/016_order_forms_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-019-ironwood-agri/03_amendments/017_amendments_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-019-ironwood-agri/03_amendments/018_amendments_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-019-ironwood-agri/03_amendments/019_amendments_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-019-ironwood-agri/03_amendments/020_amendments_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-019-ironwood-agri/03_amendments/021_amendments_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-019-ironwood-agri/03_amendments/022_amendments_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-019-ironwood-agri/03_amendments/023_amendments_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-019-ironwood-agri/03_amendments/024_amendments_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-019-ironwood-agri/04_statements_of_work/025_statements_of_work_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-019-ironwood-agri/04_statements_of_work/026_statements_of_work_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-019-ironwood-agri/04_statements_of_work/027_statements_of_work_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-019-ironwood-agri/04_statements_of_work/028_statements_of_work_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-019-ironwood-agri/04_statements_of_work/029_statements_of_work_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-019-ironwood-agri/04_statements_of_work/030_statements_of_work_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-019-ironwood-agri/04_statements_of_work/031_statements_of_work_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-019-ironwood-agri/04_statements_of_work/032_statements_of_work_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-019-ironwood-agri/05_pricing/033_pricing_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-019-ironwood-agri/05_pricing/034_pricing_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-019-ironwood-agri/05_pricing/035_pricing_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-019-ironwood-agri/05_pricing/036_pricing_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-019-ironwood-agri/05_pricing/037_pricing_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-019-ironwood-agri/05_pricing/038_pricing_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-019-ironwood-agri/05_pricing/039_pricing_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-019-ironwood-agri/05_pricing/040_pricing_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-019-ironwood-agri/06_service_levels/041_service_levels_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-019-ironwood-agri/06_service_levels/042_service_levels_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-019-ironwood-agri/06_service_levels/043_service_levels_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-019-ironwood-agri/06_service_levels/044_service_levels_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-019-ironwood-agri/06_service_levels/045_service_levels_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-019-ironwood-agri/06_service_levels/046_service_levels_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-019-ironwood-agri/06_service_levels/047_service_levels_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-019-ironwood-agri/06_service_levels/048_service_levels_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-019-ironwood-agri/07_security_privacy/049_security_privacy_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-019-ironwood-agri/07_security_privacy/050_security_privacy_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-019-ironwood-agri/07_security_privacy/051_security_privacy_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-019-ironwood-agri/07_security_privacy/052_security_privacy_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-019-ironwood-agri/07_security_privacy/053_security_privacy_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-019-ironwood-agri/07_security_privacy/054_security_privacy_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-019-ironwood-agri/07_security_privacy/055_security_privacy_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-019-ironwood-agri/07_security_privacy/056_security_privacy_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-019-ironwood-agri/08_notices/057_notices_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-019-ironwood-agri/08_notices/058_notices_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-019-ironwood-agri/08_notices/059_notices_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-019-ironwood-agri/08_notices/060_notices_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-019-ironwood-agri/08_notices/061_notices_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-019-ironwood-agri/08_notices/062_notices_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-019-ironwood-agri/08_notices/063_notices_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-019-ironwood-agri/08_notices/064_notices_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-019-ironwood-agri/09_invoices/065_invoices_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-019-ironwood-agri/09_invoices/066_invoices_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-019-ironwood-agri/09_invoices/067_invoices_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-019-ironwood-agri/09_invoices/068_invoices_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-019-ironwood-agri/09_invoices/069_invoices_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-019-ironwood-agri/09_invoices/070_invoices_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-019-ironwood-agri/09_invoices/071_invoices_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-019-ironwood-agri/09_invoices/072_invoices_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-019-ironwood-agri/10_correspondence/073_correspondence_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-019-ironwood-agri/10_correspondence/074_correspondence_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-019-ironwood-agri/10_correspondence/075_correspondence_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-019-ironwood-agri/10_correspondence/076_correspondence_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-019-ironwood-agri/10_correspondence/077_correspondence_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-019-ironwood-agri/10_correspondence/078_correspondence_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-019-ironwood-agri/10_correspondence/079_correspondence_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-019-ironwood-agri/10_correspondence/080_correspondence_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-019-ironwood-agri/11_policies/081_policies_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-019-ironwood-agri/11_policies/082_policies_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-019-ironwood-agri/11_policies/083_policies_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-019-ironwood-agri/11_policies/084_policies_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-019-ironwood-agri/11_policies/085_policies_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-019-ironwood-agri/11_policies/086_policies_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-019-ironwood-agri/11_policies/087_policies_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-019-ironwood-agri/11_policies/088_policies_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-019-ironwood-agri/12_renewal_records/089_renewal_records_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-019-ironwood-agri/12_renewal_records/090_renewal_records_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-019-ironwood-agri/12_renewal_records/091_renewal_records_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-019-ironwood-agri/12_renewal_records/092_renewal_records_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-019-ironwood-agri/12_renewal_records/093_renewal_records_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-019-ironwood-agri/12_renewal_records/094_renewal_records_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-019-ironwood-agri/12_renewal_records/095_renewal_records_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-019-ironwood-agri/12_renewal_records/096_renewal_records_status_report.md"], "gold_output": {"advice_markdown": "# Counsel advice — Ironwood distribution portfolio review\n\n## Executive assessment\n\nFor Ironwood Agricultural Supply matter CB-CC-2509, the review identified 16 source-supported exceptions requiring action before 2026-10-01. The assessment concerns Blue Fen Distribution, Inc. and the supplied record for Iowa.\n\n## Method and record coverage\n\nThe review inventoried all 96 production files, read the 33 controlling, corroborating, and control records, searched the email exports, and checked metadata for the designated chain-of-custody sample. Conclusions are limited to the synthetic production supplied for this benchmark matter.\n\n## Findings\n\n### F-01 — renewal date conflict (critical)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for renewal date conflict: one source states the operative date is 2025-09-06 under control reference CB-CC-2509-A886, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2025-10-10 under response reference CB-CC-2509-J645.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/001_master_agreements_control_register.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/07_security_privacy/049_security_privacy_control_register.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-10-01, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Elliot Mercer.\n\n### F-02 — pricing-escalator mismatch (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for pricing-escalator mismatch: one source states the controlling amount is $1,943,841.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $2,134,182.00.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/004_master_agreements_ledger_export.csv`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/07_security_privacy/052_security_privacy_ledger_export.csv`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-10-01, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Talia Brooks.\n\n### F-03 — minimum-commit shortfall (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for minimum-commit shortfall: one source states approval is attributed to Maya Ellison as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Elliot Mercer and contains no entry for Maya Ellison.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/007_master_agreements_officer_certificate.html`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/07_security_privacy/055_security_privacy_officer_certificate.html`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-10-01, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Jonas Feld.\n\n### F-04 — service-credit underpayment (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for service-credit underpayment: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-CC-2509-D214, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-CC-2509-M247.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/02_order_forms/010_order_forms_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/08_notices/058_notices_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-10-01, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Mei Whitaker.\n\n### F-05 — termination notice defect (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for termination notice defect: one source states the applicable location is Polk County, Iowa, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to Iowa operations outside Polk County, Iowa.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/02_order_forms/013_order_forms_review_memorandum.json`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/08_notices/061_notices_review_memorandum.json`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-10-01, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Caleb Hassan.\n\n### F-06 — assignment consent requirement (low)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for assignment consent requirement: one source states the threshold is 13% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 20% and produced a different exception result.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/02_order_forms/016_order_forms_status_report.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/08_notices/064_notices_status_report.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-10-01, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Leona Park.\n\n### F-07 — data-localization conflict (critical)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for data-localization conflict: one source states formal notice must use notices-ironwood_agricultural_supply@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-blue_fen_distribution_inc@example.test.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/03_amendments/019_amendments_correspondence.eml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/09_invoices/067_invoices_correspondence.eml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-10-01, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Isaac Romero.\n\n### F-08 — subprocessor notice lapse (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for subprocessor notice lapse: one source states the governed population contains 119 records through 2025-08-02, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 39 records through 2025-08-13.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/03_amendments/022_amendments_formal_notice.xml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/09_invoices/070_invoices_formal_notice.xml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-10-01, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Sofia Bennett.\n\n### F-09 — insurance-limit deficiency (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for insurance-limit deficiency: one source states the operative date is 2025-10-17 under control reference CB-CC-2509-I747, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2025-10-25 under response reference CB-CC-2509-R426.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/025_statements_of_work_control_register.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/10_correspondence/073_correspondence_control_register.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-10-01, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Adrian Mensah.\n\n### F-10 — audit-right deadline (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for audit-right deadline: one source states the controlling amount is $864,364.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $1,085,228.00.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/028_statements_of_work_ledger_export.csv`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/10_correspondence/076_correspondence_ledger_export.csv`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-10-01, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Willa Novak.\n\n### F-11 — exclusivity carveout breach (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for exclusivity carveout breach: one source states approval is attributed to Maya Ellison as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Owen Delgado and contains no entry for Maya Ellison.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/031_statements_of_work_officer_certificate.html`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/10_correspondence/079_correspondence_officer_certificate.html`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-10-01, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Theo Laurent.\n\n### F-12 — benchmarking right omission (low)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for benchmarking right omission: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-CC-2509-L809, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-CC-2509-U846.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/05_pricing/034_pricing_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/11_policies/082_policies_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-10-01, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Amara Patel.\n\n### F-13 — invoice currency discrepancy (critical)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for invoice currency discrepancy: one source states the applicable location is Polk County, Iowa, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to Iowa operations outside Polk County, Iowa.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/05_pricing/037_pricing_review_memorandum.json`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/11_policies/085_policies_review_memorandum.json`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-10-01, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Henry Cho.\n\n### F-14 — usage-report inconsistency (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for usage-report inconsistency: one source states the threshold is 14% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 16% and produced a different exception result.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/05_pricing/040_pricing_status_report.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/11_policies/088_policies_status_report.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-10-01, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Nadine Flores.\n\n### F-15 — order-form precedence conflict (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for order-form precedence conflict: one source states formal notice must use notices-ironwood_agricultural_supply@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-blue_fen_distribution_inc@example.test.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/06_service_levels/043_service_levels_correspondence.eml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/091_renewal_records_correspondence.eml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-10-01, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Micah Sullivan.\n\n### F-16 — survival-clause ambiguity (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for survival-clause ambiguity: one source states the governed population contains 140 records through 2025-08-23, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 44 records through 2025-09-08.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/06_service_levels/046_service_levels_formal_notice.xml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/094_renewal_records_formal_notice.xml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-10-01, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Farah Ibrahim.\n\n## Recommended next actions\n\nSequence the critical and high findings first, assign the named owners, preserve the cited records, and document any resolution in the controlling matter register before the stated deadline.\n\n## Assumptions and limitations\n\nThis analysis is confined to task cb100-019-ironwood-agri and the supplied synthetic evidence. It does not rely on external facts, does not resolve disputed law, and is not legal advice for a real person or entity.\n", "findings": {"as_of": "2026-10-01", "findings": [{"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/07_security_privacy/049_security_privacy_control_register.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for renewal date conflict: one source states the operative date is 2025-09-06 under control reference CB-CC-2509-A886, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2025-10-10 under response reference CB-CC-2509-J645.", "id": "F-01", "issue": "renewal date conflict", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/001_master_agreements_control_register.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-10-01, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Elliot Mercer.", "severity": "critical"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/07_security_privacy/052_security_privacy_ledger_export.csv", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for pricing-escalator mismatch: one source states the controlling amount is $1,943,841.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $2,134,182.00.", "id": "F-02", "issue": "pricing-escalator mismatch", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/004_master_agreements_ledger_export.csv", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-10-01, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Talia Brooks.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/07_security_privacy/055_security_privacy_officer_certificate.html", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for minimum-commit shortfall: one source states approval is attributed to Maya Ellison as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Elliot Mercer and contains no entry for Maya Ellison.", "id": "F-03", "issue": "minimum-commit shortfall", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/007_master_agreements_officer_certificate.html", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-10-01, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Jonas Feld.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/08_notices/058_notices_executed_instrument.txt", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for service-credit underpayment: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-CC-2509-D214, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-CC-2509-M247.", "id": "F-04", "issue": "service-credit underpayment", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/02_order_forms/010_order_forms_executed_instrument.txt", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-10-01, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Mei Whitaker.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/08_notices/061_notices_review_memorandum.json", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for termination notice defect: one source states the applicable location is Polk County, Iowa, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to Iowa operations outside Polk County, Iowa.", "id": "F-05", "issue": "termination notice defect", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/02_order_forms/013_order_forms_review_memorandum.json", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-10-01, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Caleb Hassan.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/08_notices/064_notices_status_report.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for assignment consent requirement: one source states the threshold is 13% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 20% and produced a different exception result.", "id": "F-06", "issue": "assignment consent requirement", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/02_order_forms/016_order_forms_status_report.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-10-01, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Leona Park.", "severity": "low"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/09_invoices/067_invoices_correspondence.eml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for data-localization conflict: one source states formal notice must use notices-ironwood_agricultural_supply@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-blue_fen_distribution_inc@example.test.", "id": "F-07", "issue": "data-localization conflict", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/03_amendments/019_amendments_correspondence.eml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-10-01, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Isaac Romero.", "severity": "critical"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/09_invoices/070_invoices_formal_notice.xml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for subprocessor notice lapse: one source states the governed population contains 119 records through 2025-08-02, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 39 records through 2025-08-13.", "id": "F-08", "issue": "subprocessor notice lapse", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/03_amendments/022_amendments_formal_notice.xml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-10-01, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Sofia Bennett.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/10_correspondence/073_correspondence_control_register.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for insurance-limit deficiency: one source states the operative date is 2025-10-17 under control reference CB-CC-2509-I747, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2025-10-25 under response reference CB-CC-2509-R426.", "id": "F-09", "issue": "insurance-limit deficiency", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/025_statements_of_work_control_register.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-10-01, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Adrian Mensah.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/10_correspondence/076_correspondence_ledger_export.csv", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for audit-right deadline: one source states the controlling amount is $864,364.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $1,085,228.00.", "id": "F-10", "issue": "audit-right deadline", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/028_statements_of_work_ledger_export.csv", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-10-01, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Willa Novak.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/10_correspondence/079_correspondence_officer_certificate.html", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for exclusivity carveout breach: one source states approval is attributed to Maya Ellison as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Owen Delgado and contains no entry for Maya Ellison.", "id": "F-11", "issue": "exclusivity carveout breach", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/031_statements_of_work_officer_certificate.html", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-10-01, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Theo Laurent.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/11_policies/082_policies_executed_instrument.txt", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for benchmarking right omission: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-CC-2509-L809, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-CC-2509-U846.", "id": "F-12", "issue": "benchmarking right omission", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/05_pricing/034_pricing_executed_instrument.txt", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-10-01, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Amara Patel.", "severity": "low"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/11_policies/085_policies_review_memorandum.json", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for invoice currency discrepancy: one source states the applicable location is Polk County, Iowa, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to Iowa operations outside Polk County, Iowa.", "id": "F-13", "issue": "invoice currency discrepancy", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/05_pricing/037_pricing_review_memorandum.json", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-10-01, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Henry Cho.", "severity": "critical"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/11_policies/088_policies_status_report.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for usage-report inconsistency: one source states the threshold is 14% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 16% and produced a different exception result.", "id": "F-14", "issue": "usage-report inconsistency", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/05_pricing/040_pricing_status_report.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-10-01, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Nadine Flores.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/091_renewal_records_correspondence.eml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for order-form precedence conflict: one source states formal notice must use notices-ironwood_agricultural_supply@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-blue_fen_distribution_inc@example.test.", "id": "F-15", "issue": "order-form precedence conflict", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/06_service_levels/043_service_levels_correspondence.eml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-10-01, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Micah Sullivan.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/094_renewal_records_formal_notice.xml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for survival-clause ambiguity: one source states the governed population contains 140 records through 2025-08-23, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 44 records through 2025-09-08.", "id": "F-16", "issue": "survival-clause ambiguity", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/06_service_levels/046_service_levels_formal_notice.xml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-10-01, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Farah Ibrahim.", "severity": "medium"}], "matter_number": "CB-CC-2509", "prepared_for": "Ironwood Agricultural Supply", "schema_version": "1.0", "task_id": "cb100-019-ironwood-agri"}}, "metadata": {"benchmark": "CounselBench-100", "code_license": "Apache-2.0", "data_license": "CC-BY-4.0", "deadline": "2026-10-01", "document_count": 96, "jurisdiction": "Iowa", "matter_number": "CB-CC-2509", "mcp_commit": "9a96ea6e5913736f92b88345bf51caeaaa8e719f", "mcp_package": "@modelcontextprotocol/server-filesystem@2026.7.10", "practice_area": "commercial-contracts", "reference_tool_calls": 46, "required_evidence_reads": 33, "synthetic": true, "venue": "Polk County, Iowa", "version": "2.0.0"}, "prompt": "You are commercial contracts counsel for Ironwood Agricultural Supply. This matter will be reviewed by legal, finance, and compliance stakeholders who need a single source-grounded output. A regional distributor invokes price protection and territorial exclusivity despite dealer reports showing sales outside the assigned states. Decision due 2026-10-01. Iowa law governs; Polk County, Iowa is the forum. Use the production as of the stated deadline; do not assume facts outside the supplied files. Work out the defensible position from the matter production and leave an audit-ready exception tracker and concise advice for the supervising lawyer. Keep confirmed conflicts separate from open questions, cite the records that actually control each conclusion, and do not fill gaps with outside facts.", "rubric": {"criteria": [{"category": "procedure", "description": "Complete at least 46 successful, argument-specific evidence and output calls.", "id": "procedure.minimum_successful_tool_calls"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Find and read the 33 controlling, corroborating, and work-product-control records in full.", "id": "procedure.all_evidence_read_in_full"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Inspect file metadata for the eight designated critical primary records before relying on them.", "id": "procedure.chain_of_custody_metadata_checked"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Confirm the sandbox's allowed document and output roots.", "id": "procedure.allowed_directories_checked"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Inventory all 96 records so the relevant sources are discovered among the context records.", "id": "procedure.recursive_inventory_completed"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Search the production for email evidence that may corroborate or contradict formal records.", "id": "procedure.targeted_search_completed"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Leave only findings.json and advice.md in the output workspace.", "id": "procedure.exact_deliverable_set"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Create both final work products through the sandbox MCP surface.", "id": "procedure.deliverables_written_through_mcp"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Produce findings.json as a valid JSON object.", "id": "findings.findings_is_object"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Report exactly 16 confirmed exceptions.", "id": "findings.findings_exact_count"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Use each stable finding ID exactly once.", "id": "findings.finding_ids_unique"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set schema_version to the released matter value '1.0'.", "id": "findings.top_level_schema_version"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set task_id to the released matter value 'cb100-019-ironwood-agri'.", "id": "findings.top_level_task_id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set matter_number to the released matter value 'CB-CC-2509'.", "id": "findings.top_level_matter_number"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set prepared_for to the released matter value 'Ironwood Agricultural Supply'.", "id": "findings.top_level_prepared_for"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set as_of to the released matter value '2026-10-01'.", "id": "findings.top_level_as_of"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-01 exception for renewal date conflict.", "id": "findings.F-01.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's id from /workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/001_master_agreements_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_security_privacy/049_security_privacy_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's issue from /workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/001_master_agreements_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_security_privacy/049_security_privacy_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's severity from /workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/001_master_agreements_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_security_privacy/049_security_privacy_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's primary_source from /workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/001_master_agreements_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_security_privacy/049_security_privacy_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/001_master_agreements_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_security_privacy/049_security_privacy_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-01 using the exact controlled facts ['2025-09-06', 'CB-CC-2509-A886', '2025-10-10', 'CB-CC-2509-J645'].", "id": "findings.F-01.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-01's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-01.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-10-01', 'Elliot Mercer'] for F-01.", "id": "findings.F-01.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-02 exception for pricing-escalator mismatch.", "id": "findings.F-02.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's id from /workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/004_master_agreements_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_security_privacy/052_security_privacy_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's issue from /workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/004_master_agreements_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_security_privacy/052_security_privacy_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's severity from /workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/004_master_agreements_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_security_privacy/052_security_privacy_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's primary_source from /workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/004_master_agreements_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_security_privacy/052_security_privacy_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/004_master_agreements_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_security_privacy/052_security_privacy_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-02 using the exact controlled facts ['$1,943,841.00', '$2,134,182.00'].", "id": "findings.F-02.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-02's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-02.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-10-01', 'Talia Brooks'] for F-02.", "id": "findings.F-02.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-03 exception for minimum-commit shortfall.", "id": "findings.F-03.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's id from /workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/007_master_agreements_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_security_privacy/055_security_privacy_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's issue from /workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/007_master_agreements_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_security_privacy/055_security_privacy_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's severity from /workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/007_master_agreements_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_security_privacy/055_security_privacy_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's primary_source from /workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/007_master_agreements_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_security_privacy/055_security_privacy_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/007_master_agreements_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_security_privacy/055_security_privacy_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-03 using the exact controlled facts ['Maya Ellison', 'Elliot Mercer'].", "id": "findings.F-03.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-03's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-03.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-10-01', 'Jonas Feld'] for F-03.", "id": "findings.F-03.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-04 exception for service-credit underpayment.", "id": "findings.F-04.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's id from /workspace/documents/02_order_forms/010_order_forms_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_notices/058_notices_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's issue from /workspace/documents/02_order_forms/010_order_forms_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_notices/058_notices_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's severity from /workspace/documents/02_order_forms/010_order_forms_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_notices/058_notices_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's primary_source from /workspace/documents/02_order_forms/010_order_forms_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_notices/058_notices_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/02_order_forms/010_order_forms_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_notices/058_notices_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-04 using the exact controlled facts ['closed without exception', 'CB-CC-2509-D214', 'open and escalated', 'CB-CC-2509-M247'].", "id": "findings.F-04.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-04's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-04.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-10-01', 'Mei Whitaker'] for F-04.", "id": "findings.F-04.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-05 exception for termination notice defect.", "id": "findings.F-05.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's id from /workspace/documents/02_order_forms/013_order_forms_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_notices/061_notices_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's issue from /workspace/documents/02_order_forms/013_order_forms_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_notices/061_notices_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's severity from /workspace/documents/02_order_forms/013_order_forms_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_notices/061_notices_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's primary_source from /workspace/documents/02_order_forms/013_order_forms_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_notices/061_notices_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/02_order_forms/013_order_forms_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_notices/061_notices_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-05 using the exact controlled facts ['Polk County, Iowa', 'Iowa'].", "id": "findings.F-05.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-05's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-05.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-10-01', 'Caleb Hassan'] for F-05.", "id": "findings.F-05.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-06 exception for assignment consent requirement.", "id": "findings.F-06.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's id from /workspace/documents/02_order_forms/016_order_forms_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_notices/064_notices_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's issue from /workspace/documents/02_order_forms/016_order_forms_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_notices/064_notices_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's severity from /workspace/documents/02_order_forms/016_order_forms_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_notices/064_notices_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's primary_source from /workspace/documents/02_order_forms/016_order_forms_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_notices/064_notices_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/02_order_forms/016_order_forms_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_notices/064_notices_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-06 using the exact controlled facts ['13%', '20%'].", "id": "findings.F-06.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-06's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-06.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-10-01', 'Leona Park'] for F-06.", "id": "findings.F-06.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-07 exception for data-localization conflict.", "id": "findings.F-07.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's id from /workspace/documents/03_amendments/019_amendments_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_invoices/067_invoices_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's issue from /workspace/documents/03_amendments/019_amendments_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_invoices/067_invoices_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's severity from /workspace/documents/03_amendments/019_amendments_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_invoices/067_invoices_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's primary_source from /workspace/documents/03_amendments/019_amendments_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_invoices/067_invoices_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/03_amendments/019_amendments_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_invoices/067_invoices_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-07 using the exact controlled facts ['notices-ironwood_agricultural_supply@example.test', 'archive-blue_fen_distribution_inc@example.test'].", "id": "findings.F-07.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-07's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-07.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-10-01', 'Isaac Romero'] for F-07.", "id": "findings.F-07.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-08 exception for subprocessor notice lapse.", "id": "findings.F-08.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's id from /workspace/documents/03_amendments/022_amendments_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_invoices/070_invoices_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's issue from /workspace/documents/03_amendments/022_amendments_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_invoices/070_invoices_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's severity from /workspace/documents/03_amendments/022_amendments_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_invoices/070_invoices_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's primary_source from /workspace/documents/03_amendments/022_amendments_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_invoices/070_invoices_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/03_amendments/022_amendments_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_invoices/070_invoices_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-08 using the exact controlled facts ['119 records', '2025-08-02', '39 records', '2025-08-13'].", "id": "findings.F-08.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-08's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-08.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-10-01', 'Sofia Bennett'] for F-08.", "id": "findings.F-08.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-09 exception for insurance-limit deficiency.", "id": "findings.F-09.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's id from /workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/025_statements_of_work_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_correspondence/073_correspondence_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's issue from /workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/025_statements_of_work_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_correspondence/073_correspondence_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's severity from /workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/025_statements_of_work_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_correspondence/073_correspondence_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's primary_source from /workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/025_statements_of_work_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_correspondence/073_correspondence_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/025_statements_of_work_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_correspondence/073_correspondence_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-09 using the exact controlled facts ['2025-10-17', 'CB-CC-2509-I747', '2025-10-25', 'CB-CC-2509-R426'].", "id": "findings.F-09.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-09's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-09.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-10-01', 'Adrian Mensah'] for F-09.", "id": "findings.F-09.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-10 exception for audit-right deadline.", "id": "findings.F-10.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's id from /workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/028_statements_of_work_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_correspondence/076_correspondence_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's issue from /workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/028_statements_of_work_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_correspondence/076_correspondence_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's severity from /workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/028_statements_of_work_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_correspondence/076_correspondence_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's primary_source from /workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/028_statements_of_work_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_correspondence/076_correspondence_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/028_statements_of_work_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_correspondence/076_correspondence_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-10 using the exact controlled facts ['$864,364.00', '$1,085,228.00'].", "id": "findings.F-10.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-10's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-10.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-10-01', 'Willa Novak'] for F-10.", "id": "findings.F-10.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-11 exception for exclusivity carveout breach.", "id": "findings.F-11.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's id from /workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/031_statements_of_work_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_correspondence/079_correspondence_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's issue from /workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/031_statements_of_work_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_correspondence/079_correspondence_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's severity from /workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/031_statements_of_work_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_correspondence/079_correspondence_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's primary_source from /workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/031_statements_of_work_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_correspondence/079_correspondence_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/031_statements_of_work_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_correspondence/079_correspondence_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-11 using the exact controlled facts ['Maya Ellison', 'Owen Delgado'].", "id": "findings.F-11.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-11's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-11.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-10-01', 'Theo Laurent'] for F-11.", "id": "findings.F-11.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-12 exception for benchmarking right omission.", "id": "findings.F-12.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's id from /workspace/documents/05_pricing/034_pricing_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_policies/082_policies_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's issue from /workspace/documents/05_pricing/034_pricing_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_policies/082_policies_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's severity from /workspace/documents/05_pricing/034_pricing_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_policies/082_policies_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's primary_source from /workspace/documents/05_pricing/034_pricing_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_policies/082_policies_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/05_pricing/034_pricing_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_policies/082_policies_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-12 using the exact controlled facts ['closed without exception', 'CB-CC-2509-L809', 'open and escalated', 'CB-CC-2509-U846'].", "id": "findings.F-12.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-12's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-12.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-10-01', 'Amara Patel'] for F-12.", "id": "findings.F-12.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-13 exception for invoice currency discrepancy.", "id": "findings.F-13.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's id from /workspace/documents/05_pricing/037_pricing_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_policies/085_policies_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's issue from /workspace/documents/05_pricing/037_pricing_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_policies/085_policies_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's severity from /workspace/documents/05_pricing/037_pricing_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_policies/085_policies_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's primary_source from /workspace/documents/05_pricing/037_pricing_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_policies/085_policies_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/05_pricing/037_pricing_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_policies/085_policies_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-13 using the exact controlled facts ['Polk County, Iowa', 'Iowa'].", "id": "findings.F-13.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-13's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-13.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-10-01', 'Henry Cho'] for F-13.", "id": "findings.F-13.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-14 exception for usage-report inconsistency.", "id": "findings.F-14.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's id from /workspace/documents/05_pricing/040_pricing_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_policies/088_policies_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's issue from /workspace/documents/05_pricing/040_pricing_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_policies/088_policies_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's severity from /workspace/documents/05_pricing/040_pricing_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_policies/088_policies_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's primary_source from /workspace/documents/05_pricing/040_pricing_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_policies/088_policies_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/05_pricing/040_pricing_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_policies/088_policies_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-14 using the exact controlled facts ['14%', '16%'].", "id": "findings.F-14.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-14's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-14.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-10-01', 'Nadine Flores'] for F-14.", "id": "findings.F-14.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-15 exception for order-form precedence conflict.", "id": "findings.F-15.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's id from /workspace/documents/06_service_levels/043_service_levels_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/091_renewal_records_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's issue from /workspace/documents/06_service_levels/043_service_levels_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/091_renewal_records_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's severity from /workspace/documents/06_service_levels/043_service_levels_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/091_renewal_records_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's primary_source from /workspace/documents/06_service_levels/043_service_levels_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/091_renewal_records_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/06_service_levels/043_service_levels_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/091_renewal_records_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-15 using the exact controlled facts ['notices-ironwood_agricultural_supply@example.test', 'archive-blue_fen_distribution_inc@example.test'].", "id": "findings.F-15.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-15's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-15.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-10-01', 'Micah Sullivan'] for F-15.", "id": "findings.F-15.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-16 exception for survival-clause ambiguity.", "id": "findings.F-16.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's id from /workspace/documents/06_service_levels/046_service_levels_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/094_renewal_records_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's issue from /workspace/documents/06_service_levels/046_service_levels_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/094_renewal_records_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's severity from /workspace/documents/06_service_levels/046_service_levels_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/094_renewal_records_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's primary_source from /workspace/documents/06_service_levels/046_service_levels_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/094_renewal_records_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/06_service_levels/046_service_levels_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/094_renewal_records_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-16 using the exact controlled facts ['140 records', '2025-08-23', '44 records', '2025-09-08'].", "id": "findings.F-16.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-16's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-16.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-10-01', 'Farah Ibrahim'] for F-16.", "id": "findings.F-16.action_anchors"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Executive assessment' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Executive assessment"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Method and record coverage' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Method and record coverage"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Findings' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Findings"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Recommended next actions' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Recommended next actions"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Assumptions and limitations' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Assumptions and limitations"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-01 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-01"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-02 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-02"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-03 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-03"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-04 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-04"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-05 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-05"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-06 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-06"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-07 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-07"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-08 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-08"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-09 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-09"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-10 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-10"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-11 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-11"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-12 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-12"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-13 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-13"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-14 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-14"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-15 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-15"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-16 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-16"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Do not claim the production has no issues or that every record is consistent.", "id": "memo.forbidden_claims_absent"}], "decision_options": [{"id": "cross-source-reconciliation", "label": "Reconcile controlling and corroborating records", "reason": "The CB-CC-2509 production contains independently maintained records; a defensible answer must preserve each supported conflict and its cure owner.", "selected": true}, {"id": "latest-record-controls", "label": "Treat the latest record as controlling", "reason": "Timestamp recency does not establish legal priority, execution, or approval authority.", "selected": false}, {"id": "primary-records-only", "label": "Report primary records without reconciliation", "reason": "Primary records alone conceal the operational conflicts that create the actionable exceptions.", "selected": false}], "gates": ["all_evidence_read_in_full", "chain_of_custody_metadata_checked", "findings_criteria_complete", "memo_criteria_complete", "deliverables_written_through_mcp"], "metadata_checks": 8, "metric": "weighted_criteria_score", "minimum_tool_calls": 46, "required_deliverables": ["findings.json", "advice.md"], "required_document_reads": 33, "type": "deterministic", "weights": {"findings": 0.55, "memo": 0.2, "procedure": 0.25}}, "task_id": "cb100-019-ironwood-agri", "task_name": "Ironwood distribution portfolio review", "world_id": "counselbench-filesystem-mcp-v2"}
-{"context_files": ["task_files/cb100-020-juno-travel/01_master_agreements/001_master_agreements_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-020-juno-travel/01_master_agreements/002_master_agreements_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-020-juno-travel/01_master_agreements/003_master_agreements_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-020-juno-travel/01_master_agreements/004_master_agreements_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-020-juno-travel/01_master_agreements/005_master_agreements_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-020-juno-travel/01_master_agreements/006_master_agreements_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-020-juno-travel/01_master_agreements/007_master_agreements_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-020-juno-travel/01_master_agreements/008_master_agreements_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-020-juno-travel/02_order_forms/009_order_forms_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-020-juno-travel/02_order_forms/010_order_forms_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-020-juno-travel/02_order_forms/011_order_forms_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-020-juno-travel/02_order_forms/012_order_forms_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-020-juno-travel/02_order_forms/013_order_forms_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-020-juno-travel/02_order_forms/014_order_forms_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-020-juno-travel/02_order_forms/015_order_forms_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-020-juno-travel/02_order_forms/016_order_forms_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-020-juno-travel/03_amendments/017_amendments_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-020-juno-travel/03_amendments/018_amendments_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-020-juno-travel/03_amendments/019_amendments_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-020-juno-travel/03_amendments/020_amendments_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-020-juno-travel/03_amendments/021_amendments_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-020-juno-travel/03_amendments/022_amendments_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-020-juno-travel/03_amendments/023_amendments_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-020-juno-travel/03_amendments/024_amendments_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-020-juno-travel/04_statements_of_work/025_statements_of_work_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-020-juno-travel/04_statements_of_work/026_statements_of_work_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-020-juno-travel/04_statements_of_work/027_statements_of_work_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-020-juno-travel/04_statements_of_work/028_statements_of_work_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-020-juno-travel/04_statements_of_work/029_statements_of_work_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-020-juno-travel/04_statements_of_work/030_statements_of_work_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-020-juno-travel/04_statements_of_work/031_statements_of_work_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-020-juno-travel/04_statements_of_work/032_statements_of_work_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-020-juno-travel/05_pricing/033_pricing_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-020-juno-travel/05_pricing/034_pricing_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-020-juno-travel/05_pricing/035_pricing_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-020-juno-travel/05_pricing/036_pricing_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-020-juno-travel/05_pricing/037_pricing_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-020-juno-travel/05_pricing/038_pricing_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-020-juno-travel/05_pricing/039_pricing_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-020-juno-travel/05_pricing/040_pricing_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-020-juno-travel/06_service_levels/041_service_levels_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-020-juno-travel/06_service_levels/042_service_levels_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-020-juno-travel/06_service_levels/043_service_levels_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-020-juno-travel/06_service_levels/044_service_levels_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-020-juno-travel/06_service_levels/045_service_levels_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-020-juno-travel/06_service_levels/046_service_levels_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-020-juno-travel/06_service_levels/047_service_levels_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-020-juno-travel/06_service_levels/048_service_levels_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-020-juno-travel/07_security_privacy/049_security_privacy_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-020-juno-travel/07_security_privacy/050_security_privacy_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-020-juno-travel/07_security_privacy/051_security_privacy_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-020-juno-travel/07_security_privacy/052_security_privacy_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-020-juno-travel/07_security_privacy/053_security_privacy_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-020-juno-travel/07_security_privacy/054_security_privacy_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-020-juno-travel/07_security_privacy/055_security_privacy_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-020-juno-travel/07_security_privacy/056_security_privacy_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-020-juno-travel/08_notices/057_notices_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-020-juno-travel/08_notices/058_notices_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-020-juno-travel/08_notices/059_notices_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-020-juno-travel/08_notices/060_notices_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-020-juno-travel/08_notices/061_notices_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-020-juno-travel/08_notices/062_notices_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-020-juno-travel/08_notices/063_notices_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-020-juno-travel/08_notices/064_notices_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-020-juno-travel/09_invoices/065_invoices_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-020-juno-travel/09_invoices/066_invoices_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-020-juno-travel/09_invoices/067_invoices_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-020-juno-travel/09_invoices/068_invoices_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-020-juno-travel/09_invoices/069_invoices_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-020-juno-travel/09_invoices/070_invoices_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-020-juno-travel/09_invoices/071_invoices_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-020-juno-travel/09_invoices/072_invoices_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-020-juno-travel/10_correspondence/073_correspondence_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-020-juno-travel/10_correspondence/074_correspondence_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-020-juno-travel/10_correspondence/075_correspondence_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-020-juno-travel/10_correspondence/076_correspondence_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-020-juno-travel/10_correspondence/077_correspondence_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-020-juno-travel/10_correspondence/078_correspondence_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-020-juno-travel/10_correspondence/079_correspondence_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-020-juno-travel/10_correspondence/080_correspondence_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-020-juno-travel/11_policies/081_policies_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-020-juno-travel/11_policies/082_policies_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-020-juno-travel/11_policies/083_policies_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-020-juno-travel/11_policies/084_policies_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-020-juno-travel/11_policies/085_policies_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-020-juno-travel/11_policies/086_policies_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-020-juno-travel/11_policies/087_policies_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-020-juno-travel/11_policies/088_policies_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-020-juno-travel/12_renewal_records/089_renewal_records_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-020-juno-travel/12_renewal_records/090_renewal_records_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-020-juno-travel/12_renewal_records/091_renewal_records_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-020-juno-travel/12_renewal_records/092_renewal_records_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-020-juno-travel/12_renewal_records/093_renewal_records_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-020-juno-travel/12_renewal_records/094_renewal_records_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-020-juno-travel/12_renewal_records/095_renewal_records_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-020-juno-travel/12_renewal_records/096_renewal_records_status_report.md"], "gold_output": {"advice_markdown": "# Counsel advice — Juno reservation platform exit analysis\n\n## Executive assessment\n\nFor Juno Travel Technologies matter CB-CC-2510, the review identified 16 source-supported exceptions requiring action before 2026-10-05. The assessment concerns Crescent Hotel Consortium and the supplied record for Florida.\n\n## Method and record coverage\n\nThe review inventoried all 96 production files, read the 33 controlling, corroborating, and control records, searched the email exports, and checked metadata for the designated chain-of-custody sample. Conclusions are limited to the synthetic production supplied for this benchmark matter.\n\n## Findings\n\n### F-01 — renewal date conflict (critical)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for renewal date conflict: one source states the operative date is 2025-12-17 under control reference CB-CC-2510-A868, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2026-01-18 under response reference CB-CC-2510-J574.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/001_master_agreements_control_register.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/07_security_privacy/049_security_privacy_control_register.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-10-05, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Talia Brooks.\n\n### F-02 — pricing-escalator mismatch (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for pricing-escalator mismatch: one source states the controlling amount is $1,464,708.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $1,545,916.00.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/004_master_agreements_ledger_export.csv`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/07_security_privacy/052_security_privacy_ledger_export.csv`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-10-05, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Jonas Feld.\n\n### F-03 — minimum-commit shortfall (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for minimum-commit shortfall: one source states approval is attributed to Rafael Okafor as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Jonas Feld and contains no entry for Rafael Okafor.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/007_master_agreements_officer_certificate.html`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/07_security_privacy/055_security_privacy_officer_certificate.html`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-10-05, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Mei Whitaker.\n\n### F-04 — service-credit underpayment (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for service-credit underpayment: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-CC-2510-D608, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-CC-2510-M208.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/02_order_forms/010_order_forms_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/08_notices/058_notices_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-10-05, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Caleb Hassan.\n\n### F-05 — termination notice defect (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for termination notice defect: one source states the applicable location is Miami-Dade County, Florida, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to Florida operations outside Miami-Dade County, Florida.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/02_order_forms/013_order_forms_review_memorandum.json`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/08_notices/061_notices_review_memorandum.json`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-10-05, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Leona Park.\n\n### F-06 — assignment consent requirement (low)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for assignment consent requirement: one source states the threshold is 13% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 18% and produced a different exception result.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/02_order_forms/016_order_forms_status_report.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/08_notices/064_notices_status_report.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-10-05, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Isaac Romero.\n\n### F-07 — data-localization conflict (critical)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for data-localization conflict: one source states formal notice must use notices-juno_travel_technologies@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-crescent_hotel_consortium@example.test.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/03_amendments/019_amendments_correspondence.eml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/09_invoices/067_invoices_correspondence.eml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-10-05, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Sofia Bennett.\n\n### F-08 — subprocessor notice lapse (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for subprocessor notice lapse: one source states the governed population contains 175 records through 2025-05-10, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 61 records through 2025-06-12.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/03_amendments/022_amendments_formal_notice.xml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/09_invoices/070_invoices_formal_notice.xml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-10-05, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Adrian Mensah.\n\n### F-09 — insurance-limit deficiency (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for insurance-limit deficiency: one source states the operative date is 2025-02-22 under control reference CB-CC-2510-I630, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2025-03-10 under response reference CB-CC-2510-R833.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/025_statements_of_work_control_register.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/10_correspondence/073_correspondence_control_register.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-10-05, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Willa Novak.\n\n### F-10 — audit-right deadline (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for audit-right deadline: one source states the controlling amount is $6,653,759.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $6,934,018.00.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/028_statements_of_work_ledger_export.csv`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/10_correspondence/076_correspondence_ledger_export.csv`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-10-05, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Theo Laurent.\n\n### F-11 — exclusivity carveout breach (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for exclusivity carveout breach: one source states approval is attributed to Rafael Okafor as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Samuel Kim and contains no entry for Rafael Okafor.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/031_statements_of_work_officer_certificate.html`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/10_correspondence/079_correspondence_officer_certificate.html`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-10-05, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Amara Patel.\n\n### F-12 — benchmarking right omission (low)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for benchmarking right omission: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-CC-2510-L597, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-CC-2510-U484.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/05_pricing/034_pricing_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/11_policies/082_policies_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-10-05, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Henry Cho.\n\n### F-13 — invoice currency discrepancy (critical)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for invoice currency discrepancy: one source states the applicable location is Miami-Dade County, Florida, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to Florida operations outside Miami-Dade County, Florida.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/05_pricing/037_pricing_review_memorandum.json`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/11_policies/085_policies_review_memorandum.json`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-10-05, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Nadine Flores.\n\n### F-14 — usage-report inconsistency (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for usage-report inconsistency: one source states the threshold is 7% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 14% and produced a different exception result.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/05_pricing/040_pricing_status_report.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/11_policies/088_policies_status_report.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-10-05, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Micah Sullivan.\n\n### F-15 — order-form precedence conflict (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for order-form precedence conflict: one source states formal notice must use notices-juno_travel_technologies@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-crescent_hotel_consortium@example.test.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/06_service_levels/043_service_levels_correspondence.eml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/091_renewal_records_correspondence.eml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-10-05, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Farah Ibrahim.\n\n### F-16 — survival-clause ambiguity (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for survival-clause ambiguity: one source states the governed population contains 163 records through 2025-09-15, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 63 records through 2025-10-20.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/06_service_levels/046_service_levels_formal_notice.xml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/094_renewal_records_formal_notice.xml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-10-05, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Owen Delgado.\n\n## Recommended next actions\n\nSequence the critical and high findings first, assign the named owners, preserve the cited records, and document any resolution in the controlling matter register before the stated deadline.\n\n## Assumptions and limitations\n\nThis analysis is confined to task cb100-020-juno-travel and the supplied synthetic evidence. It does not rely on external facts, does not resolve disputed law, and is not legal advice for a real person or entity.\n", "findings": {"as_of": "2026-10-05", "findings": [{"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/07_security_privacy/049_security_privacy_control_register.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for renewal date conflict: one source states the operative date is 2025-12-17 under control reference CB-CC-2510-A868, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2026-01-18 under response reference CB-CC-2510-J574.", "id": "F-01", "issue": "renewal date conflict", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/001_master_agreements_control_register.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-10-05, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Talia Brooks.", "severity": "critical"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/07_security_privacy/052_security_privacy_ledger_export.csv", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for pricing-escalator mismatch: one source states the controlling amount is $1,464,708.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $1,545,916.00.", "id": "F-02", "issue": "pricing-escalator mismatch", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/004_master_agreements_ledger_export.csv", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-10-05, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Jonas Feld.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/07_security_privacy/055_security_privacy_officer_certificate.html", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for minimum-commit shortfall: one source states approval is attributed to Rafael Okafor as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Jonas Feld and contains no entry for Rafael Okafor.", "id": "F-03", "issue": "minimum-commit shortfall", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/007_master_agreements_officer_certificate.html", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-10-05, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Mei Whitaker.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/08_notices/058_notices_executed_instrument.txt", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for service-credit underpayment: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-CC-2510-D608, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-CC-2510-M208.", "id": "F-04", "issue": "service-credit underpayment", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/02_order_forms/010_order_forms_executed_instrument.txt", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-10-05, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Caleb Hassan.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/08_notices/061_notices_review_memorandum.json", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for termination notice defect: one source states the applicable location is Miami-Dade County, Florida, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to Florida operations outside Miami-Dade County, Florida.", "id": "F-05", "issue": "termination notice defect", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/02_order_forms/013_order_forms_review_memorandum.json", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-10-05, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Leona Park.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/08_notices/064_notices_status_report.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for assignment consent requirement: one source states the threshold is 13% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 18% and produced a different exception result.", "id": "F-06", "issue": "assignment consent requirement", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/02_order_forms/016_order_forms_status_report.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-10-05, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Isaac Romero.", "severity": "low"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/09_invoices/067_invoices_correspondence.eml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for data-localization conflict: one source states formal notice must use notices-juno_travel_technologies@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-crescent_hotel_consortium@example.test.", "id": "F-07", "issue": "data-localization conflict", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/03_amendments/019_amendments_correspondence.eml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-10-05, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Sofia Bennett.", "severity": "critical"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/09_invoices/070_invoices_formal_notice.xml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for subprocessor notice lapse: one source states the governed population contains 175 records through 2025-05-10, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 61 records through 2025-06-12.", "id": "F-08", "issue": "subprocessor notice lapse", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/03_amendments/022_amendments_formal_notice.xml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-10-05, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Adrian Mensah.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/10_correspondence/073_correspondence_control_register.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for insurance-limit deficiency: one source states the operative date is 2025-02-22 under control reference CB-CC-2510-I630, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2025-03-10 under response reference CB-CC-2510-R833.", "id": "F-09", "issue": "insurance-limit deficiency", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/025_statements_of_work_control_register.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-10-05, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Willa Novak.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/10_correspondence/076_correspondence_ledger_export.csv", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for audit-right deadline: one source states the controlling amount is $6,653,759.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $6,934,018.00.", "id": "F-10", "issue": "audit-right deadline", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/028_statements_of_work_ledger_export.csv", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-10-05, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Theo Laurent.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/10_correspondence/079_correspondence_officer_certificate.html", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for exclusivity carveout breach: one source states approval is attributed to Rafael Okafor as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Samuel Kim and contains no entry for Rafael Okafor.", "id": "F-11", "issue": "exclusivity carveout breach", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/031_statements_of_work_officer_certificate.html", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-10-05, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Amara Patel.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/11_policies/082_policies_executed_instrument.txt", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for benchmarking right omission: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-CC-2510-L597, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-CC-2510-U484.", "id": "F-12", "issue": "benchmarking right omission", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/05_pricing/034_pricing_executed_instrument.txt", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-10-05, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Henry Cho.", "severity": "low"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/11_policies/085_policies_review_memorandum.json", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for invoice currency discrepancy: one source states the applicable location is Miami-Dade County, Florida, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to Florida operations outside Miami-Dade County, Florida.", "id": "F-13", "issue": "invoice currency discrepancy", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/05_pricing/037_pricing_review_memorandum.json", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-10-05, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Nadine Flores.", "severity": "critical"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/11_policies/088_policies_status_report.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for usage-report inconsistency: one source states the threshold is 7% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 14% and produced a different exception result.", "id": "F-14", "issue": "usage-report inconsistency", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/05_pricing/040_pricing_status_report.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-10-05, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Micah Sullivan.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/091_renewal_records_correspondence.eml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for order-form precedence conflict: one source states formal notice must use notices-juno_travel_technologies@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-crescent_hotel_consortium@example.test.", "id": "F-15", "issue": "order-form precedence conflict", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/06_service_levels/043_service_levels_correspondence.eml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-10-05, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Farah Ibrahim.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/094_renewal_records_formal_notice.xml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for survival-clause ambiguity: one source states the governed population contains 163 records through 2025-09-15, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 63 records through 2025-10-20.", "id": "F-16", "issue": "survival-clause ambiguity", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/06_service_levels/046_service_levels_formal_notice.xml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-10-05, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Owen Delgado.", "severity": "medium"}], "matter_number": "CB-CC-2510", "prepared_for": "Juno Travel Technologies", "schema_version": "1.0", "task_id": "cb100-020-juno-travel"}}, "metadata": {"benchmark": "CounselBench-100", "code_license": "Apache-2.0", "data_license": "CC-BY-4.0", "deadline": "2026-10-05", "document_count": 96, "jurisdiction": "Florida", "matter_number": "CB-CC-2510", "mcp_commit": "9a96ea6e5913736f92b88345bf51caeaaa8e719f", "mcp_package": "@modelcontextprotocol/server-filesystem@2026.7.10", "practice_area": "commercial-contracts", "reference_tool_calls": 46, "required_evidence_reads": 33, "synthetic": true, "venue": "Miami-Dade County, Florida", "version": "2.0.0"}, "prompt": "You are commercial contracts counsel for Juno Travel Technologies. The record contains amendments, exports, and correspondence from different custodians; reconcile them into an actionable counsel work product. The customer seeks an early exit after repeated outages, but separate documents disagree about cure periods, transition services, and prepaid credits. Decision due 2026-10-05. Florida law governs; Miami-Dade County, Florida is the forum. Write for a supervising lawyer who will spot-check source paths and exact values. Work out the defensible position from the matter production and leave an audit-ready exception tracker and concise advice for the supervising lawyer. Keep confirmed conflicts separate from open questions, cite the records that actually control each conclusion, and do not fill gaps with outside facts.", "rubric": {"criteria": [{"category": "procedure", "description": "Complete at least 46 successful, argument-specific evidence and output calls.", "id": "procedure.minimum_successful_tool_calls"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Find and read the 33 controlling, corroborating, and work-product-control records in full.", "id": "procedure.all_evidence_read_in_full"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Inspect file metadata for the eight designated critical primary records before relying on them.", "id": "procedure.chain_of_custody_metadata_checked"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Confirm the sandbox's allowed document and output roots.", "id": "procedure.allowed_directories_checked"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Inventory all 96 records so the relevant sources are discovered among the context records.", "id": "procedure.recursive_inventory_completed"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Search the production for email evidence that may corroborate or contradict formal records.", "id": "procedure.targeted_search_completed"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Leave only findings.json and advice.md in the output workspace.", "id": "procedure.exact_deliverable_set"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Create both final work products through the sandbox MCP surface.", "id": "procedure.deliverables_written_through_mcp"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Produce findings.json as a valid JSON object.", "id": "findings.findings_is_object"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Report exactly 16 confirmed exceptions.", "id": "findings.findings_exact_count"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Use each stable finding ID exactly once.", "id": "findings.finding_ids_unique"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set schema_version to the released matter value '1.0'.", "id": "findings.top_level_schema_version"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set task_id to the released matter value 'cb100-020-juno-travel'.", "id": "findings.top_level_task_id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set matter_number to the released matter value 'CB-CC-2510'.", "id": "findings.top_level_matter_number"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set prepared_for to the released matter value 'Juno Travel Technologies'.", "id": "findings.top_level_prepared_for"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set as_of to the released matter value '2026-10-05'.", "id": "findings.top_level_as_of"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-01 exception for renewal date conflict.", "id": "findings.F-01.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's id from /workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/001_master_agreements_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_security_privacy/049_security_privacy_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's issue from /workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/001_master_agreements_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_security_privacy/049_security_privacy_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's severity from /workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/001_master_agreements_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_security_privacy/049_security_privacy_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's primary_source from /workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/001_master_agreements_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_security_privacy/049_security_privacy_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/001_master_agreements_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_security_privacy/049_security_privacy_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-01 using the exact controlled facts ['2025-12-17', 'CB-CC-2510-A868', '2026-01-18', 'CB-CC-2510-J574'].", "id": "findings.F-01.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-01's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-01.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-10-05', 'Talia Brooks'] for F-01.", "id": "findings.F-01.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-02 exception for pricing-escalator mismatch.", "id": "findings.F-02.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's id from /workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/004_master_agreements_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_security_privacy/052_security_privacy_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's issue from /workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/004_master_agreements_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_security_privacy/052_security_privacy_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's severity from /workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/004_master_agreements_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_security_privacy/052_security_privacy_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's primary_source from /workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/004_master_agreements_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_security_privacy/052_security_privacy_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/004_master_agreements_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_security_privacy/052_security_privacy_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-02 using the exact controlled facts ['$1,464,708.00', '$1,545,916.00'].", "id": "findings.F-02.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-02's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-02.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-10-05', 'Jonas Feld'] for F-02.", "id": "findings.F-02.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-03 exception for minimum-commit shortfall.", "id": "findings.F-03.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's id from /workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/007_master_agreements_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_security_privacy/055_security_privacy_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's issue from /workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/007_master_agreements_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_security_privacy/055_security_privacy_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's severity from /workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/007_master_agreements_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_security_privacy/055_security_privacy_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's primary_source from /workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/007_master_agreements_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_security_privacy/055_security_privacy_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/007_master_agreements_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_security_privacy/055_security_privacy_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-03 using the exact controlled facts ['Rafael Okafor', 'Jonas Feld'].", "id": "findings.F-03.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-03's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-03.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-10-05', 'Mei Whitaker'] for F-03.", "id": "findings.F-03.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-04 exception for service-credit underpayment.", "id": "findings.F-04.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's id from /workspace/documents/02_order_forms/010_order_forms_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_notices/058_notices_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's issue from /workspace/documents/02_order_forms/010_order_forms_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_notices/058_notices_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's severity from /workspace/documents/02_order_forms/010_order_forms_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_notices/058_notices_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's primary_source from /workspace/documents/02_order_forms/010_order_forms_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_notices/058_notices_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/02_order_forms/010_order_forms_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_notices/058_notices_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-04 using the exact controlled facts ['closed without exception', 'CB-CC-2510-D608', 'open and escalated', 'CB-CC-2510-M208'].", "id": "findings.F-04.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-04's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-04.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-10-05', 'Caleb Hassan'] for F-04.", "id": "findings.F-04.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-05 exception for termination notice defect.", "id": "findings.F-05.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's id from /workspace/documents/02_order_forms/013_order_forms_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_notices/061_notices_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's issue from /workspace/documents/02_order_forms/013_order_forms_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_notices/061_notices_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's severity from /workspace/documents/02_order_forms/013_order_forms_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_notices/061_notices_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's primary_source from /workspace/documents/02_order_forms/013_order_forms_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_notices/061_notices_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/02_order_forms/013_order_forms_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_notices/061_notices_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-05 using the exact controlled facts ['Miami-Dade County, Florida', 'Florida'].", "id": "findings.F-05.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-05's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-05.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-10-05', 'Leona Park'] for F-05.", "id": "findings.F-05.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-06 exception for assignment consent requirement.", "id": "findings.F-06.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's id from /workspace/documents/02_order_forms/016_order_forms_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_notices/064_notices_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's issue from /workspace/documents/02_order_forms/016_order_forms_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_notices/064_notices_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's severity from /workspace/documents/02_order_forms/016_order_forms_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_notices/064_notices_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's primary_source from /workspace/documents/02_order_forms/016_order_forms_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_notices/064_notices_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/02_order_forms/016_order_forms_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_notices/064_notices_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-06 using the exact controlled facts ['13%', '18%'].", "id": "findings.F-06.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-06's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-06.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-10-05', 'Isaac Romero'] for F-06.", "id": "findings.F-06.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-07 exception for data-localization conflict.", "id": "findings.F-07.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's id from /workspace/documents/03_amendments/019_amendments_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_invoices/067_invoices_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's issue from /workspace/documents/03_amendments/019_amendments_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_invoices/067_invoices_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's severity from /workspace/documents/03_amendments/019_amendments_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_invoices/067_invoices_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's primary_source from /workspace/documents/03_amendments/019_amendments_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_invoices/067_invoices_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/03_amendments/019_amendments_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_invoices/067_invoices_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-07 using the exact controlled facts ['notices-juno_travel_technologies@example.test', 'archive-crescent_hotel_consortium@example.test'].", "id": "findings.F-07.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-07's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-07.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-10-05', 'Sofia Bennett'] for F-07.", "id": "findings.F-07.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-08 exception for subprocessor notice lapse.", "id": "findings.F-08.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's id from /workspace/documents/03_amendments/022_amendments_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_invoices/070_invoices_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's issue from /workspace/documents/03_amendments/022_amendments_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_invoices/070_invoices_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's severity from /workspace/documents/03_amendments/022_amendments_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_invoices/070_invoices_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's primary_source from /workspace/documents/03_amendments/022_amendments_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_invoices/070_invoices_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/03_amendments/022_amendments_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_invoices/070_invoices_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-08 using the exact controlled facts ['175 records', '2025-05-10', '61 records', '2025-06-12'].", "id": "findings.F-08.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-08's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-08.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-10-05', 'Adrian Mensah'] for F-08.", "id": "findings.F-08.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-09 exception for insurance-limit deficiency.", "id": "findings.F-09.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's id from /workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/025_statements_of_work_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_correspondence/073_correspondence_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's issue from /workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/025_statements_of_work_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_correspondence/073_correspondence_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's severity from /workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/025_statements_of_work_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_correspondence/073_correspondence_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's primary_source from /workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/025_statements_of_work_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_correspondence/073_correspondence_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/025_statements_of_work_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_correspondence/073_correspondence_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-09 using the exact controlled facts ['2025-02-22', 'CB-CC-2510-I630', '2025-03-10', 'CB-CC-2510-R833'].", "id": "findings.F-09.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-09's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-09.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-10-05', 'Willa Novak'] for F-09.", "id": "findings.F-09.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-10 exception for audit-right deadline.", "id": "findings.F-10.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's id from /workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/028_statements_of_work_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_correspondence/076_correspondence_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's issue from /workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/028_statements_of_work_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_correspondence/076_correspondence_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's severity from /workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/028_statements_of_work_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_correspondence/076_correspondence_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's primary_source from /workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/028_statements_of_work_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_correspondence/076_correspondence_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/028_statements_of_work_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_correspondence/076_correspondence_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-10 using the exact controlled facts ['$6,653,759.00', '$6,934,018.00'].", "id": "findings.F-10.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-10's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-10.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-10-05', 'Theo Laurent'] for F-10.", "id": "findings.F-10.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-11 exception for exclusivity carveout breach.", "id": "findings.F-11.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's id from /workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/031_statements_of_work_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_correspondence/079_correspondence_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's issue from /workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/031_statements_of_work_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_correspondence/079_correspondence_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's severity from /workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/031_statements_of_work_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_correspondence/079_correspondence_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's primary_source from /workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/031_statements_of_work_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_correspondence/079_correspondence_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/031_statements_of_work_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_correspondence/079_correspondence_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-11 using the exact controlled facts ['Rafael Okafor', 'Samuel Kim'].", "id": "findings.F-11.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-11's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-11.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-10-05', 'Amara Patel'] for F-11.", "id": "findings.F-11.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-12 exception for benchmarking right omission.", "id": "findings.F-12.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's id from /workspace/documents/05_pricing/034_pricing_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_policies/082_policies_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's issue from /workspace/documents/05_pricing/034_pricing_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_policies/082_policies_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's severity from /workspace/documents/05_pricing/034_pricing_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_policies/082_policies_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's primary_source from /workspace/documents/05_pricing/034_pricing_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_policies/082_policies_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/05_pricing/034_pricing_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_policies/082_policies_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-12 using the exact controlled facts ['closed without exception', 'CB-CC-2510-L597', 'open and escalated', 'CB-CC-2510-U484'].", "id": "findings.F-12.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-12's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-12.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-10-05', 'Henry Cho'] for F-12.", "id": "findings.F-12.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-13 exception for invoice currency discrepancy.", "id": "findings.F-13.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's id from /workspace/documents/05_pricing/037_pricing_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_policies/085_policies_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's issue from /workspace/documents/05_pricing/037_pricing_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_policies/085_policies_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's severity from /workspace/documents/05_pricing/037_pricing_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_policies/085_policies_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's primary_source from /workspace/documents/05_pricing/037_pricing_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_policies/085_policies_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/05_pricing/037_pricing_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_policies/085_policies_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-13 using the exact controlled facts ['Miami-Dade County, Florida', 'Florida'].", "id": "findings.F-13.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-13's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-13.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-10-05', 'Nadine Flores'] for F-13.", "id": "findings.F-13.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-14 exception for usage-report inconsistency.", "id": "findings.F-14.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's id from /workspace/documents/05_pricing/040_pricing_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_policies/088_policies_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's issue from /workspace/documents/05_pricing/040_pricing_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_policies/088_policies_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's severity from /workspace/documents/05_pricing/040_pricing_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_policies/088_policies_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's primary_source from /workspace/documents/05_pricing/040_pricing_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_policies/088_policies_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/05_pricing/040_pricing_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_policies/088_policies_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-14 using the exact controlled facts ['7%', '14%'].", "id": "findings.F-14.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-14's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-14.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-10-05', 'Micah Sullivan'] for F-14.", "id": "findings.F-14.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-15 exception for order-form precedence conflict.", "id": "findings.F-15.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's id from /workspace/documents/06_service_levels/043_service_levels_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/091_renewal_records_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's issue from /workspace/documents/06_service_levels/043_service_levels_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/091_renewal_records_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's severity from /workspace/documents/06_service_levels/043_service_levels_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/091_renewal_records_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's primary_source from /workspace/documents/06_service_levels/043_service_levels_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/091_renewal_records_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/06_service_levels/043_service_levels_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/091_renewal_records_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-15 using the exact controlled facts ['notices-juno_travel_technologies@example.test', 'archive-crescent_hotel_consortium@example.test'].", "id": "findings.F-15.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-15's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-15.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-10-05', 'Farah Ibrahim'] for F-15.", "id": "findings.F-15.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-16 exception for survival-clause ambiguity.", "id": "findings.F-16.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's id from /workspace/documents/06_service_levels/046_service_levels_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/094_renewal_records_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's issue from /workspace/documents/06_service_levels/046_service_levels_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/094_renewal_records_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's severity from /workspace/documents/06_service_levels/046_service_levels_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/094_renewal_records_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's primary_source from /workspace/documents/06_service_levels/046_service_levels_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/094_renewal_records_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/06_service_levels/046_service_levels_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/094_renewal_records_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-16 using the exact controlled facts ['163 records', '2025-09-15', '63 records', '2025-10-20'].", "id": "findings.F-16.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-16's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-16.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-10-05', 'Owen Delgado'] for F-16.", "id": "findings.F-16.action_anchors"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Executive assessment' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Executive assessment"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Method and record coverage' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Method and record coverage"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Findings' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Findings"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Recommended next actions' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Recommended next actions"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Assumptions and limitations' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Assumptions and limitations"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-01 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-01"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-02 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-02"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-03 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-03"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-04 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-04"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-05 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-05"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-06 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-06"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-07 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-07"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-08 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-08"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-09 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-09"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-10 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-10"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-11 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-11"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-12 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-12"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-13 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-13"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-14 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-14"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-15 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-15"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-16 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-16"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Do not claim the production has no issues or that every record is consistent.", "id": "memo.forbidden_claims_absent"}], "decision_options": [{"id": "cross-source-reconciliation", "label": "Reconcile controlling and corroborating records", "reason": "The CB-CC-2510 production contains independently maintained records; a defensible answer must preserve each supported conflict and its cure owner.", "selected": true}, {"id": "latest-record-controls", "label": "Treat the latest record as controlling", "reason": "Timestamp recency does not establish legal priority, execution, or approval authority.", "selected": false}, {"id": "primary-records-only", "label": "Report primary records without reconciliation", "reason": "Primary records alone conceal the operational conflicts that create the actionable exceptions.", "selected": false}], "gates": ["all_evidence_read_in_full", "chain_of_custody_metadata_checked", "findings_criteria_complete", "memo_criteria_complete", "deliverables_written_through_mcp"], "metadata_checks": 8, "metric": "weighted_criteria_score", "minimum_tool_calls": 46, "required_deliverables": ["findings.json", "advice.md"], "required_document_reads": 33, "type": "deterministic", "weights": {"findings": 0.55, "memo": 0.2, "procedure": 0.25}}, "task_id": "cb100-020-juno-travel", "task_name": "Juno reservation platform exit analysis", "world_id": "counselbench-filesystem-mcp-v2"}
-{"context_files": ["task_files/cb100-021-alder-biotech/01_intake/001_intake_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-021-alder-biotech/01_intake/002_intake_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-021-alder-biotech/01_intake/003_intake_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-021-alder-biotech/01_intake/004_intake_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-021-alder-biotech/01_intake/005_intake_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-021-alder-biotech/01_intake/006_intake_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-021-alder-biotech/01_intake/007_intake_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-021-alder-biotech/01_intake/008_intake_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-021-alder-biotech/02_preservation/009_preservation_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-021-alder-biotech/02_preservation/010_preservation_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-021-alder-biotech/02_preservation/011_preservation_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-021-alder-biotech/02_preservation/012_preservation_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-021-alder-biotech/02_preservation/013_preservation_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-021-alder-biotech/02_preservation/014_preservation_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-021-alder-biotech/02_preservation/015_preservation_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-021-alder-biotech/02_preservation/016_preservation_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-021-alder-biotech/03_interviews/017_interviews_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-021-alder-biotech/03_interviews/018_interviews_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-021-alder-biotech/03_interviews/019_interviews_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-021-alder-biotech/03_interviews/020_interviews_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-021-alder-biotech/03_interviews/021_interviews_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-021-alder-biotech/03_interviews/022_interviews_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-021-alder-biotech/03_interviews/023_interviews_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-021-alder-biotech/03_interviews/024_interviews_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-021-alder-biotech/04_email_exports/025_email_exports_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-021-alder-biotech/04_email_exports/026_email_exports_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-021-alder-biotech/04_email_exports/027_email_exports_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-021-alder-biotech/04_email_exports/028_email_exports_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-021-alder-biotech/04_email_exports/029_email_exports_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-021-alder-biotech/04_email_exports/030_email_exports_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-021-alder-biotech/04_email_exports/031_email_exports_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-021-alder-biotech/04_email_exports/032_email_exports_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-021-alder-biotech/05_chat_exports/033_chat_exports_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-021-alder-biotech/05_chat_exports/034_chat_exports_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-021-alder-biotech/05_chat_exports/035_chat_exports_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-021-alder-biotech/05_chat_exports/036_chat_exports_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-021-alder-biotech/05_chat_exports/037_chat_exports_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-021-alder-biotech/05_chat_exports/038_chat_exports_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-021-alder-biotech/05_chat_exports/039_chat_exports_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-021-alder-biotech/05_chat_exports/040_chat_exports_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-021-alder-biotech/06_expenses/041_expenses_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-021-alder-biotech/06_expenses/042_expenses_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-021-alder-biotech/06_expenses/043_expenses_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-021-alder-biotech/06_expenses/044_expenses_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-021-alder-biotech/06_expenses/045_expenses_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-021-alder-biotech/06_expenses/046_expenses_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-021-alder-biotech/06_expenses/047_expenses_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-021-alder-biotech/06_expenses/048_expenses_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-021-alder-biotech/07_access_logs/049_access_logs_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-021-alder-biotech/07_access_logs/050_access_logs_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-021-alder-biotech/07_access_logs/051_access_logs_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-021-alder-biotech/07_access_logs/052_access_logs_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-021-alder-biotech/07_access_logs/053_access_logs_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-021-alder-biotech/07_access_logs/054_access_logs_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-021-alder-biotech/07_access_logs/055_access_logs_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-021-alder-biotech/07_access_logs/056_access_logs_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-021-alder-biotech/08_vendor_files/057_vendor_files_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-021-alder-biotech/08_vendor_files/058_vendor_files_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-021-alder-biotech/08_vendor_files/059_vendor_files_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-021-alder-biotech/08_vendor_files/060_vendor_files_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-021-alder-biotech/08_vendor_files/061_vendor_files_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-021-alder-biotech/08_vendor_files/062_vendor_files_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-021-alder-biotech/08_vendor_files/063_vendor_files_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-021-alder-biotech/08_vendor_files/064_vendor_files_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-021-alder-biotech/09_policies/065_policies_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-021-alder-biotech/09_policies/066_policies_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-021-alder-biotech/09_policies/067_policies_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-021-alder-biotech/09_policies/068_policies_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-021-alder-biotech/09_policies/069_policies_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-021-alder-biotech/09_policies/070_policies_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-021-alder-biotech/09_policies/071_policies_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-021-alder-biotech/09_policies/072_policies_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-021-alder-biotech/10_hr_records/073_hr_records_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-021-alder-biotech/10_hr_records/074_hr_records_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-021-alder-biotech/10_hr_records/075_hr_records_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-021-alder-biotech/10_hr_records/076_hr_records_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-021-alder-biotech/10_hr_records/077_hr_records_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-021-alder-biotech/10_hr_records/078_hr_records_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-021-alder-biotech/10_hr_records/079_hr_records_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-021-alder-biotech/10_hr_records/080_hr_records_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-021-alder-biotech/11_board_reporting/081_board_reporting_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-021-alder-biotech/11_board_reporting/082_board_reporting_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-021-alder-biotech/11_board_reporting/083_board_reporting_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-021-alder-biotech/11_board_reporting/084_board_reporting_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-021-alder-biotech/11_board_reporting/085_board_reporting_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-021-alder-biotech/11_board_reporting/086_board_reporting_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-021-alder-biotech/11_board_reporting/087_board_reporting_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-021-alder-biotech/11_board_reporting/088_board_reporting_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-021-alder-biotech/12_remediation/089_remediation_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-021-alder-biotech/12_remediation/090_remediation_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-021-alder-biotech/12_remediation/091_remediation_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-021-alder-biotech/12_remediation/092_remediation_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-021-alder-biotech/12_remediation/093_remediation_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-021-alder-biotech/12_remediation/094_remediation_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-021-alder-biotech/12_remediation/095_remediation_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-021-alder-biotech/12_remediation/096_remediation_status_report.md"], "gold_output": {"advice_markdown": "# Counsel advice — Alder clinical-vendor payment inquiry\n\n## Executive assessment\n\nFor Alder Biotherapeutics matter CB-IV-2601, the review identified 16 source-supported exceptions requiring action before 2026-09-02. The assessment concerns Morrow Trial Services LLC and the supplied record for Massachusetts.\n\n## Method and record coverage\n\nThe review inventoried all 96 production files, read the 33 controlling, corroborating, and control records, searched the email exports, and checked metadata for the designated chain-of-custody sample. Conclusions are limited to the synthetic production supplied for this benchmark matter.\n\n## Findings\n\n### F-01 — preservation delay (critical)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for preservation delay: one source states the operative date is 2025-04-03 under control reference CB-IV-2601-A670, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2025-04-14 under response reference CB-IV-2601-J282.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/01_intake/001_intake_control_register.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/07_access_logs/049_access_logs_control_register.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-02, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Jonas Feld.\n\n### F-02 — interview timeline conflict (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for interview timeline conflict: one source states the controlling amount is $5,289,818.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $5,566,136.00.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/01_intake/004_intake_ledger_export.csv`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/07_access_logs/052_access_logs_ledger_export.csv`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-02, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Mei Whitaker.\n\n### F-03 — undisclosed related party (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for undisclosed related party: one source states approval is attributed to Nora Chen as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Caleb Hassan and contains no entry for Nora Chen.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/01_intake/007_intake_officer_certificate.html`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/07_access_logs/055_access_logs_officer_certificate.html`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-02, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Caleb Hassan.\n\n### F-04 — split-purchase pattern (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for split-purchase pattern: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-IV-2601-D261, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-IV-2601-M666.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/02_preservation/010_preservation_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/08_vendor_files/058_vendor_files_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-02, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Leona Park.\n\n### F-05 — approval override (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for approval override: one source states the applicable location is Cambridge, Massachusetts, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to Massachusetts operations outside Cambridge, Massachusetts.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/02_preservation/013_preservation_review_memorandum.json`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/08_vendor_files/061_vendor_files_review_memorandum.json`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-02, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Isaac Romero.\n\n### F-06 — gift-policy threshold breach (low)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for gift-policy threshold breach: one source states the threshold is 9% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 12% and produced a different exception result.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/02_preservation/016_preservation_status_report.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/08_vendor_files/064_vendor_files_status_report.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-02, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Sofia Bennett.\n\n### F-07 — off-channel communication (critical)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for off-channel communication: one source states formal notice must use notices-alder_biotherapeutics@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-morrow_trial_services_llc@example.test.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/03_interviews/019_interviews_correspondence.eml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/09_policies/067_policies_correspondence.eml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-02, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Adrian Mensah.\n\n### F-08 — deleted-message anomaly (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for deleted-message anomaly: one source states the governed population contains 64 records through 2025-01-19, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 74 records through 2025-03-06.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/03_interviews/022_interviews_formal_notice.xml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/09_policies/070_policies_formal_notice.xml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-02, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Willa Novak.\n\n### F-09 — badge-log inconsistency (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for badge-log inconsistency: one source states the operative date is 2025-04-15 under control reference CB-IV-2601-I922, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2025-05-04 under response reference CB-IV-2601-R717.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/04_email_exports/025_email_exports_control_register.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/10_hr_records/073_hr_records_control_register.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-02, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Theo Laurent.\n\n### F-10 — vendor due-diligence gap (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for vendor due-diligence gap: one source states the controlling amount is $2,653,985.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $2,814,470.00.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/04_email_exports/028_email_exports_ledger_export.csv`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/10_hr_records/076_hr_records_ledger_export.csv`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-02, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Amara Patel.\n\n### F-11 — retaliation concern (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for retaliation concern: one source states approval is attributed to Nora Chen as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Rafael Okafor and contains no entry for Nora Chen.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/04_email_exports/031_email_exports_officer_certificate.html`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/10_hr_records/079_hr_records_officer_certificate.html`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-02, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Henry Cho.\n\n### F-12 — policy training lapse (low)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for policy training lapse: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-IV-2601-L813, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-IV-2601-U154.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/034_chat_exports_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/11_board_reporting/082_board_reporting_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-02, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Nadine Flores.\n\n### F-13 — board-reporting omission (critical)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for board-reporting omission: one source states the applicable location is Cambridge, Massachusetts, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to Massachusetts operations outside Cambridge, Massachusetts.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/037_chat_exports_review_memorandum.json`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/11_board_reporting/085_board_reporting_review_memorandum.json`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-02, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Micah Sullivan.\n\n### F-14 — hotline classification error (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for hotline classification error: one source states the threshold is 7% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 14% and produced a different exception result.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/040_chat_exports_status_report.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/11_board_reporting/088_board_reporting_status_report.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-02, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Farah Ibrahim.\n\n### F-15 — expense support deficiency (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for expense support deficiency: one source states formal notice must use notices-alder_biotherapeutics@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-morrow_trial_services_llc@example.test.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/06_expenses/043_expenses_correspondence.eml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/12_remediation/091_remediation_correspondence.eml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-02, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Owen Delgado.\n\n### F-16 — remediation ownership gap (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for remediation ownership gap: one source states the governed population contains 164 records through 2025-04-29, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 60 records through 2025-05-31.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/06_expenses/046_expenses_formal_notice.xml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/12_remediation/094_remediation_formal_notice.xml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-02, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Lena Varga.\n\n## Recommended next actions\n\nSequence the critical and high findings first, assign the named owners, preserve the cited records, and document any resolution in the controlling matter register before the stated deadline.\n\n## Assumptions and limitations\n\nThis analysis is confined to task cb100-021-alder-biotech and the supplied synthetic evidence. It does not rely on external facts, does not resolve disputed law, and is not legal advice for a real person or entity.\n", "findings": {"as_of": "2026-09-02", "findings": [{"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/07_access_logs/049_access_logs_control_register.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for preservation delay: one source states the operative date is 2025-04-03 under control reference CB-IV-2601-A670, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2025-04-14 under response reference CB-IV-2601-J282.", "id": "F-01", "issue": "preservation delay", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/01_intake/001_intake_control_register.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-02, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Jonas Feld.", "severity": "critical"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/07_access_logs/052_access_logs_ledger_export.csv", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for interview timeline conflict: one source states the controlling amount is $5,289,818.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $5,566,136.00.", "id": "F-02", "issue": "interview timeline conflict", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/01_intake/004_intake_ledger_export.csv", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-02, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Mei Whitaker.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/07_access_logs/055_access_logs_officer_certificate.html", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for undisclosed related party: one source states approval is attributed to Nora Chen as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Caleb Hassan and contains no entry for Nora Chen.", "id": "F-03", "issue": "undisclosed related party", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/01_intake/007_intake_officer_certificate.html", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-02, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Caleb Hassan.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/08_vendor_files/058_vendor_files_executed_instrument.txt", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for split-purchase pattern: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-IV-2601-D261, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-IV-2601-M666.", "id": "F-04", "issue": "split-purchase pattern", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/02_preservation/010_preservation_executed_instrument.txt", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-02, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Leona Park.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/08_vendor_files/061_vendor_files_review_memorandum.json", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for approval override: one source states the applicable location is Cambridge, Massachusetts, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to Massachusetts operations outside Cambridge, Massachusetts.", "id": "F-05", "issue": "approval override", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/02_preservation/013_preservation_review_memorandum.json", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-02, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Isaac Romero.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/08_vendor_files/064_vendor_files_status_report.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for gift-policy threshold breach: one source states the threshold is 9% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 12% and produced a different exception result.", "id": "F-06", "issue": "gift-policy threshold breach", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/02_preservation/016_preservation_status_report.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-02, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Sofia Bennett.", "severity": "low"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/09_policies/067_policies_correspondence.eml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for off-channel communication: one source states formal notice must use notices-alder_biotherapeutics@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-morrow_trial_services_llc@example.test.", "id": "F-07", "issue": "off-channel communication", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/03_interviews/019_interviews_correspondence.eml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-02, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Adrian Mensah.", "severity": "critical"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/09_policies/070_policies_formal_notice.xml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for deleted-message anomaly: one source states the governed population contains 64 records through 2025-01-19, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 74 records through 2025-03-06.", "id": "F-08", "issue": "deleted-message anomaly", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/03_interviews/022_interviews_formal_notice.xml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-02, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Willa Novak.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/10_hr_records/073_hr_records_control_register.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for badge-log inconsistency: one source states the operative date is 2025-04-15 under control reference CB-IV-2601-I922, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2025-05-04 under response reference CB-IV-2601-R717.", "id": "F-09", "issue": "badge-log inconsistency", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/04_email_exports/025_email_exports_control_register.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-02, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Theo Laurent.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/10_hr_records/076_hr_records_ledger_export.csv", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for vendor due-diligence gap: one source states the controlling amount is $2,653,985.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $2,814,470.00.", "id": "F-10", "issue": "vendor due-diligence gap", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/04_email_exports/028_email_exports_ledger_export.csv", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-02, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Amara Patel.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/10_hr_records/079_hr_records_officer_certificate.html", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for retaliation concern: one source states approval is attributed to Nora Chen as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Rafael Okafor and contains no entry for Nora Chen.", "id": "F-11", "issue": "retaliation concern", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/04_email_exports/031_email_exports_officer_certificate.html", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-02, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Henry Cho.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/11_board_reporting/082_board_reporting_executed_instrument.txt", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for policy training lapse: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-IV-2601-L813, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-IV-2601-U154.", "id": "F-12", "issue": "policy training lapse", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/034_chat_exports_executed_instrument.txt", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-02, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Nadine Flores.", "severity": "low"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/11_board_reporting/085_board_reporting_review_memorandum.json", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for board-reporting omission: one source states the applicable location is Cambridge, Massachusetts, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to Massachusetts operations outside Cambridge, Massachusetts.", "id": "F-13", "issue": "board-reporting omission", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/037_chat_exports_review_memorandum.json", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-02, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Micah Sullivan.", "severity": "critical"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/11_board_reporting/088_board_reporting_status_report.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for hotline classification error: one source states the threshold is 7% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 14% and produced a different exception result.", "id": "F-14", "issue": "hotline classification error", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/040_chat_exports_status_report.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-02, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Farah Ibrahim.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/091_remediation_correspondence.eml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for expense support deficiency: one source states formal notice must use notices-alder_biotherapeutics@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-morrow_trial_services_llc@example.test.", "id": "F-15", "issue": "expense support deficiency", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/06_expenses/043_expenses_correspondence.eml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-02, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Owen Delgado.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/094_remediation_formal_notice.xml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for remediation ownership gap: one source states the governed population contains 164 records through 2025-04-29, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 60 records through 2025-05-31.", "id": "F-16", "issue": "remediation ownership gap", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/06_expenses/046_expenses_formal_notice.xml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-02, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Lena Varga.", "severity": "medium"}], "matter_number": "CB-IV-2601", "prepared_for": "Alder Biotherapeutics", "schema_version": "1.0", "task_id": "cb100-021-alder-biotech"}}, "metadata": {"benchmark": "CounselBench-100", "code_license": "Apache-2.0", "data_license": "CC-BY-4.0", "deadline": "2026-09-02", "document_count": 96, "jurisdiction": "Massachusetts", "matter_number": "CB-IV-2601", "mcp_commit": "9a96ea6e5913736f92b88345bf51caeaaa8e719f", "mcp_package": "@modelcontextprotocol/server-filesystem@2026.7.10", "practice_area": "internal-investigations", "reference_tool_calls": 46, "required_evidence_reads": 33, "synthetic": true, "venue": "Cambridge, Massachusetts", "version": "2.0.0"}, "prompt": "You are independent investigations counsel for Alder Biotherapeutics. The partner responsible for this matter needs a defensible decision record before the next client call. A hotline report alleges that a study manager split vendor invoices after accepting travel from a firm owned by a former colleague. Decision due 2026-09-02. Massachusetts law governs; Cambridge, Massachusetts is the forum. Prioritize conflicts between signed instruments and later operational records. Work out the defensible position from the matter production and leave an audit-ready exception tracker and concise advice for the supervising lawyer. Keep confirmed conflicts separate from open questions, cite the records that actually control each conclusion, and do not fill gaps with outside facts.", "rubric": {"criteria": [{"category": "procedure", "description": "Complete at least 46 successful, argument-specific evidence and output calls.", "id": "procedure.minimum_successful_tool_calls"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Find and read the 33 controlling, corroborating, and work-product-control records in full.", "id": "procedure.all_evidence_read_in_full"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Inspect file metadata for the eight designated critical primary records before relying on them.", "id": "procedure.chain_of_custody_metadata_checked"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Confirm the sandbox's allowed document and output roots.", "id": "procedure.allowed_directories_checked"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Inventory all 96 records so the relevant sources are discovered among the context records.", "id": "procedure.recursive_inventory_completed"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Search the production for email evidence that may corroborate or contradict formal records.", "id": "procedure.targeted_search_completed"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Leave only findings.json and advice.md in the output workspace.", "id": "procedure.exact_deliverable_set"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Create both final work products through the sandbox MCP surface.", "id": "procedure.deliverables_written_through_mcp"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Produce findings.json as a valid JSON object.", "id": "findings.findings_is_object"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Report exactly 16 confirmed exceptions.", "id": "findings.findings_exact_count"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Use each stable finding ID exactly once.", "id": "findings.finding_ids_unique"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set schema_version to the released matter value '1.0'.", "id": "findings.top_level_schema_version"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set task_id to the released matter value 'cb100-021-alder-biotech'.", "id": "findings.top_level_task_id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set matter_number to the released matter value 'CB-IV-2601'.", "id": "findings.top_level_matter_number"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set prepared_for to the released matter value 'Alder Biotherapeutics'.", "id": "findings.top_level_prepared_for"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set as_of to the released matter value '2026-09-02'.", "id": "findings.top_level_as_of"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-01 exception for preservation delay.", "id": "findings.F-01.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's id from /workspace/documents/01_intake/001_intake_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_access_logs/049_access_logs_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's issue from /workspace/documents/01_intake/001_intake_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_access_logs/049_access_logs_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's severity from /workspace/documents/01_intake/001_intake_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_access_logs/049_access_logs_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's primary_source from /workspace/documents/01_intake/001_intake_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_access_logs/049_access_logs_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/01_intake/001_intake_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_access_logs/049_access_logs_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-01 using the exact controlled facts ['2025-04-03', 'CB-IV-2601-A670', '2025-04-14', 'CB-IV-2601-J282'].", "id": "findings.F-01.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-01's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-01.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-02', 'Jonas Feld'] for F-01.", "id": "findings.F-01.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-02 exception for interview timeline conflict.", "id": "findings.F-02.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's id from /workspace/documents/01_intake/004_intake_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_access_logs/052_access_logs_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's issue from /workspace/documents/01_intake/004_intake_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_access_logs/052_access_logs_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's severity from /workspace/documents/01_intake/004_intake_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_access_logs/052_access_logs_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's primary_source from /workspace/documents/01_intake/004_intake_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_access_logs/052_access_logs_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/01_intake/004_intake_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_access_logs/052_access_logs_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-02 using the exact controlled facts ['$5,289,818.00', '$5,566,136.00'].", "id": "findings.F-02.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-02's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-02.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-02', 'Mei Whitaker'] for F-02.", "id": "findings.F-02.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-03 exception for undisclosed related party.", "id": "findings.F-03.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's id from /workspace/documents/01_intake/007_intake_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_access_logs/055_access_logs_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's issue from /workspace/documents/01_intake/007_intake_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_access_logs/055_access_logs_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's severity from /workspace/documents/01_intake/007_intake_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_access_logs/055_access_logs_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's primary_source from /workspace/documents/01_intake/007_intake_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_access_logs/055_access_logs_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/01_intake/007_intake_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_access_logs/055_access_logs_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-03 using the exact controlled facts ['Nora Chen', 'Caleb Hassan'].", "id": "findings.F-03.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-03's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-03.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-02', 'Caleb Hassan'] for F-03.", "id": "findings.F-03.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-04 exception for split-purchase pattern.", "id": "findings.F-04.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's id from /workspace/documents/02_preservation/010_preservation_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_vendor_files/058_vendor_files_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's issue from /workspace/documents/02_preservation/010_preservation_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_vendor_files/058_vendor_files_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's severity from /workspace/documents/02_preservation/010_preservation_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_vendor_files/058_vendor_files_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's primary_source from /workspace/documents/02_preservation/010_preservation_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_vendor_files/058_vendor_files_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/02_preservation/010_preservation_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_vendor_files/058_vendor_files_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-04 using the exact controlled facts ['closed without exception', 'CB-IV-2601-D261', 'open and escalated', 'CB-IV-2601-M666'].", "id": "findings.F-04.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-04's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-04.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-02', 'Leona Park'] for F-04.", "id": "findings.F-04.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-05 exception for approval override.", "id": "findings.F-05.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's id from /workspace/documents/02_preservation/013_preservation_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_vendor_files/061_vendor_files_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's issue from /workspace/documents/02_preservation/013_preservation_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_vendor_files/061_vendor_files_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's severity from /workspace/documents/02_preservation/013_preservation_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_vendor_files/061_vendor_files_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's primary_source from /workspace/documents/02_preservation/013_preservation_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_vendor_files/061_vendor_files_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/02_preservation/013_preservation_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_vendor_files/061_vendor_files_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-05 using the exact controlled facts ['Cambridge, Massachusetts', 'Massachusetts'].", "id": "findings.F-05.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-05's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-05.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-02', 'Isaac Romero'] for F-05.", "id": "findings.F-05.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-06 exception for gift-policy threshold breach.", "id": "findings.F-06.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's id from /workspace/documents/02_preservation/016_preservation_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_vendor_files/064_vendor_files_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's issue from /workspace/documents/02_preservation/016_preservation_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_vendor_files/064_vendor_files_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's severity from /workspace/documents/02_preservation/016_preservation_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_vendor_files/064_vendor_files_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's primary_source from /workspace/documents/02_preservation/016_preservation_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_vendor_files/064_vendor_files_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/02_preservation/016_preservation_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_vendor_files/064_vendor_files_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-06 using the exact controlled facts ['9%', '12%'].", "id": "findings.F-06.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-06's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-06.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-02', 'Sofia Bennett'] for F-06.", "id": "findings.F-06.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-07 exception for off-channel communication.", "id": "findings.F-07.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's id from /workspace/documents/03_interviews/019_interviews_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_policies/067_policies_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's issue from /workspace/documents/03_interviews/019_interviews_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_policies/067_policies_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's severity from /workspace/documents/03_interviews/019_interviews_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_policies/067_policies_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's primary_source from /workspace/documents/03_interviews/019_interviews_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_policies/067_policies_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/03_interviews/019_interviews_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_policies/067_policies_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-07 using the exact controlled facts ['notices-alder_biotherapeutics@example.test', 'archive-morrow_trial_services_llc@example.test'].", "id": "findings.F-07.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-07's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-07.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-02', 'Adrian Mensah'] for F-07.", "id": "findings.F-07.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-08 exception for deleted-message anomaly.", "id": "findings.F-08.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's id from /workspace/documents/03_interviews/022_interviews_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_policies/070_policies_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's issue from /workspace/documents/03_interviews/022_interviews_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_policies/070_policies_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's severity from /workspace/documents/03_interviews/022_interviews_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_policies/070_policies_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's primary_source from /workspace/documents/03_interviews/022_interviews_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_policies/070_policies_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/03_interviews/022_interviews_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_policies/070_policies_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-08 using the exact controlled facts ['64 records', '2025-01-19', '74 records', '2025-03-06'].", "id": "findings.F-08.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-08's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-08.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-02', 'Willa Novak'] for F-08.", "id": "findings.F-08.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-09 exception for badge-log inconsistency.", "id": "findings.F-09.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's id from /workspace/documents/04_email_exports/025_email_exports_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_hr_records/073_hr_records_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's issue from /workspace/documents/04_email_exports/025_email_exports_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_hr_records/073_hr_records_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's severity from /workspace/documents/04_email_exports/025_email_exports_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_hr_records/073_hr_records_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's primary_source from /workspace/documents/04_email_exports/025_email_exports_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_hr_records/073_hr_records_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/04_email_exports/025_email_exports_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_hr_records/073_hr_records_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-09 using the exact controlled facts ['2025-04-15', 'CB-IV-2601-I922', '2025-05-04', 'CB-IV-2601-R717'].", "id": "findings.F-09.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-09's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-09.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-02', 'Theo Laurent'] for F-09.", "id": "findings.F-09.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-10 exception for vendor due-diligence gap.", "id": "findings.F-10.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's id from /workspace/documents/04_email_exports/028_email_exports_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_hr_records/076_hr_records_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's issue from /workspace/documents/04_email_exports/028_email_exports_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_hr_records/076_hr_records_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's severity from /workspace/documents/04_email_exports/028_email_exports_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_hr_records/076_hr_records_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's primary_source from /workspace/documents/04_email_exports/028_email_exports_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_hr_records/076_hr_records_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/04_email_exports/028_email_exports_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_hr_records/076_hr_records_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-10 using the exact controlled facts ['$2,653,985.00', '$2,814,470.00'].", "id": "findings.F-10.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-10's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-10.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-02', 'Amara Patel'] for F-10.", "id": "findings.F-10.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-11 exception for retaliation concern.", "id": "findings.F-11.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's id from /workspace/documents/04_email_exports/031_email_exports_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_hr_records/079_hr_records_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's issue from /workspace/documents/04_email_exports/031_email_exports_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_hr_records/079_hr_records_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's severity from /workspace/documents/04_email_exports/031_email_exports_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_hr_records/079_hr_records_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's primary_source from /workspace/documents/04_email_exports/031_email_exports_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_hr_records/079_hr_records_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/04_email_exports/031_email_exports_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_hr_records/079_hr_records_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-11 using the exact controlled facts ['Nora Chen', 'Rafael Okafor'].", "id": "findings.F-11.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-11's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-11.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-02', 'Henry Cho'] for F-11.", "id": "findings.F-11.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-12 exception for policy training lapse.", "id": "findings.F-12.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's id from /workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/034_chat_exports_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_board_reporting/082_board_reporting_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's issue from /workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/034_chat_exports_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_board_reporting/082_board_reporting_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's severity from /workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/034_chat_exports_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_board_reporting/082_board_reporting_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's primary_source from /workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/034_chat_exports_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_board_reporting/082_board_reporting_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/034_chat_exports_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_board_reporting/082_board_reporting_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-12 using the exact controlled facts ['closed without exception', 'CB-IV-2601-L813', 'open and escalated', 'CB-IV-2601-U154'].", "id": "findings.F-12.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-12's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-12.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-02', 'Nadine Flores'] for F-12.", "id": "findings.F-12.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-13 exception for board-reporting omission.", "id": "findings.F-13.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's id from /workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/037_chat_exports_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_board_reporting/085_board_reporting_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's issue from /workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/037_chat_exports_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_board_reporting/085_board_reporting_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's severity from /workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/037_chat_exports_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_board_reporting/085_board_reporting_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's primary_source from /workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/037_chat_exports_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_board_reporting/085_board_reporting_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/037_chat_exports_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_board_reporting/085_board_reporting_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-13 using the exact controlled facts ['Cambridge, Massachusetts', 'Massachusetts'].", "id": "findings.F-13.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-13's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-13.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-02', 'Micah Sullivan'] for F-13.", "id": "findings.F-13.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-14 exception for hotline classification error.", "id": "findings.F-14.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's id from /workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/040_chat_exports_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_board_reporting/088_board_reporting_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's issue from /workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/040_chat_exports_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_board_reporting/088_board_reporting_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's severity from /workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/040_chat_exports_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_board_reporting/088_board_reporting_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's primary_source from /workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/040_chat_exports_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_board_reporting/088_board_reporting_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/040_chat_exports_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_board_reporting/088_board_reporting_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-14 using the exact controlled facts ['7%', '14%'].", "id": "findings.F-14.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-14's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-14.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-02', 'Farah Ibrahim'] for F-14.", "id": "findings.F-14.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-15 exception for expense support deficiency.", "id": "findings.F-15.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's id from /workspace/documents/06_expenses/043_expenses_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_remediation/091_remediation_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's issue from /workspace/documents/06_expenses/043_expenses_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_remediation/091_remediation_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's severity from /workspace/documents/06_expenses/043_expenses_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_remediation/091_remediation_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's primary_source from /workspace/documents/06_expenses/043_expenses_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_remediation/091_remediation_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/06_expenses/043_expenses_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_remediation/091_remediation_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-15 using the exact controlled facts ['notices-alder_biotherapeutics@example.test', 'archive-morrow_trial_services_llc@example.test'].", "id": "findings.F-15.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-15's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-15.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-02', 'Owen Delgado'] for F-15.", "id": "findings.F-15.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-16 exception for remediation ownership gap.", "id": "findings.F-16.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's id from /workspace/documents/06_expenses/046_expenses_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_remediation/094_remediation_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's issue from /workspace/documents/06_expenses/046_expenses_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_remediation/094_remediation_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's severity from /workspace/documents/06_expenses/046_expenses_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_remediation/094_remediation_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's primary_source from /workspace/documents/06_expenses/046_expenses_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_remediation/094_remediation_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/06_expenses/046_expenses_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_remediation/094_remediation_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-16 using the exact controlled facts ['164 records', '2025-04-29', '60 records', '2025-05-31'].", "id": "findings.F-16.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-16's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-16.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-02', 'Lena Varga'] for F-16.", "id": "findings.F-16.action_anchors"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Executive assessment' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Executive assessment"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Method and record coverage' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Method and record coverage"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Findings' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Findings"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Recommended next actions' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Recommended next actions"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Assumptions and limitations' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Assumptions and limitations"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-01 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-01"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-02 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-02"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-03 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-03"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-04 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-04"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-05 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-05"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-06 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-06"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-07 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-07"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-08 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-08"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-09 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-09"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-10 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-10"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-11 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-11"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-12 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-12"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-13 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-13"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-14 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-14"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-15 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-15"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-16 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-16"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Do not claim the production has no issues or that every record is consistent.", "id": "memo.forbidden_claims_absent"}], "decision_options": [{"id": "cross-source-reconciliation", "label": "Reconcile controlling and corroborating records", "reason": "The CB-IV-2601 production contains independently maintained records; a defensible answer must preserve each supported conflict and its cure owner.", "selected": true}, {"id": "latest-record-controls", "label": "Treat the latest record as controlling", "reason": "Timestamp recency does not establish legal priority, execution, or approval authority.", "selected": false}, {"id": "primary-records-only", "label": "Report primary records without reconciliation", "reason": "Primary records alone conceal the operational conflicts that create the actionable exceptions.", "selected": false}], "gates": ["all_evidence_read_in_full", "chain_of_custody_metadata_checked", "findings_criteria_complete", "memo_criteria_complete", "deliverables_written_through_mcp"], "metadata_checks": 8, "metric": "weighted_criteria_score", "minimum_tool_calls": 46, "required_deliverables": ["findings.json", "advice.md"], "required_document_reads": 33, "type": "deterministic", "weights": {"findings": 0.55, "memo": 0.2, "procedure": 0.25}}, "task_id": "cb100-021-alder-biotech", "task_name": "Alder clinical-vendor payment inquiry", "world_id": "counselbench-filesystem-mcp-v2"}
-{"context_files": ["task_files/cb100-022-beacon-mining/01_intake/001_intake_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-022-beacon-mining/01_intake/002_intake_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-022-beacon-mining/01_intake/003_intake_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-022-beacon-mining/01_intake/004_intake_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-022-beacon-mining/01_intake/005_intake_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-022-beacon-mining/01_intake/006_intake_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-022-beacon-mining/01_intake/007_intake_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-022-beacon-mining/01_intake/008_intake_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-022-beacon-mining/02_preservation/009_preservation_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-022-beacon-mining/02_preservation/010_preservation_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-022-beacon-mining/02_preservation/011_preservation_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-022-beacon-mining/02_preservation/012_preservation_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-022-beacon-mining/02_preservation/013_preservation_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-022-beacon-mining/02_preservation/014_preservation_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-022-beacon-mining/02_preservation/015_preservation_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-022-beacon-mining/02_preservation/016_preservation_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-022-beacon-mining/03_interviews/017_interviews_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-022-beacon-mining/03_interviews/018_interviews_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-022-beacon-mining/03_interviews/019_interviews_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-022-beacon-mining/03_interviews/020_interviews_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-022-beacon-mining/03_interviews/021_interviews_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-022-beacon-mining/03_interviews/022_interviews_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-022-beacon-mining/03_interviews/023_interviews_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-022-beacon-mining/03_interviews/024_interviews_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-022-beacon-mining/04_email_exports/025_email_exports_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-022-beacon-mining/04_email_exports/026_email_exports_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-022-beacon-mining/04_email_exports/027_email_exports_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-022-beacon-mining/04_email_exports/028_email_exports_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-022-beacon-mining/04_email_exports/029_email_exports_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-022-beacon-mining/04_email_exports/030_email_exports_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-022-beacon-mining/04_email_exports/031_email_exports_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-022-beacon-mining/04_email_exports/032_email_exports_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-022-beacon-mining/05_chat_exports/033_chat_exports_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-022-beacon-mining/05_chat_exports/034_chat_exports_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-022-beacon-mining/05_chat_exports/035_chat_exports_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-022-beacon-mining/05_chat_exports/036_chat_exports_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-022-beacon-mining/05_chat_exports/037_chat_exports_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-022-beacon-mining/05_chat_exports/038_chat_exports_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-022-beacon-mining/05_chat_exports/039_chat_exports_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-022-beacon-mining/05_chat_exports/040_chat_exports_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-022-beacon-mining/06_expenses/041_expenses_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-022-beacon-mining/06_expenses/042_expenses_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-022-beacon-mining/06_expenses/043_expenses_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-022-beacon-mining/06_expenses/044_expenses_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-022-beacon-mining/06_expenses/045_expenses_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-022-beacon-mining/06_expenses/046_expenses_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-022-beacon-mining/06_expenses/047_expenses_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-022-beacon-mining/06_expenses/048_expenses_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-022-beacon-mining/07_access_logs/049_access_logs_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-022-beacon-mining/07_access_logs/050_access_logs_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-022-beacon-mining/07_access_logs/051_access_logs_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-022-beacon-mining/07_access_logs/052_access_logs_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-022-beacon-mining/07_access_logs/053_access_logs_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-022-beacon-mining/07_access_logs/054_access_logs_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-022-beacon-mining/07_access_logs/055_access_logs_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-022-beacon-mining/07_access_logs/056_access_logs_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-022-beacon-mining/08_vendor_files/057_vendor_files_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-022-beacon-mining/08_vendor_files/058_vendor_files_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-022-beacon-mining/08_vendor_files/059_vendor_files_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-022-beacon-mining/08_vendor_files/060_vendor_files_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-022-beacon-mining/08_vendor_files/061_vendor_files_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-022-beacon-mining/08_vendor_files/062_vendor_files_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-022-beacon-mining/08_vendor_files/063_vendor_files_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-022-beacon-mining/08_vendor_files/064_vendor_files_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-022-beacon-mining/09_policies/065_policies_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-022-beacon-mining/09_policies/066_policies_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-022-beacon-mining/09_policies/067_policies_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-022-beacon-mining/09_policies/068_policies_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-022-beacon-mining/09_policies/069_policies_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-022-beacon-mining/09_policies/070_policies_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-022-beacon-mining/09_policies/071_policies_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-022-beacon-mining/09_policies/072_policies_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-022-beacon-mining/10_hr_records/073_hr_records_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-022-beacon-mining/10_hr_records/074_hr_records_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-022-beacon-mining/10_hr_records/075_hr_records_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-022-beacon-mining/10_hr_records/076_hr_records_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-022-beacon-mining/10_hr_records/077_hr_records_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-022-beacon-mining/10_hr_records/078_hr_records_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-022-beacon-mining/10_hr_records/079_hr_records_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-022-beacon-mining/10_hr_records/080_hr_records_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-022-beacon-mining/11_board_reporting/081_board_reporting_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-022-beacon-mining/11_board_reporting/082_board_reporting_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-022-beacon-mining/11_board_reporting/083_board_reporting_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-022-beacon-mining/11_board_reporting/084_board_reporting_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-022-beacon-mining/11_board_reporting/085_board_reporting_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-022-beacon-mining/11_board_reporting/086_board_reporting_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-022-beacon-mining/11_board_reporting/087_board_reporting_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-022-beacon-mining/11_board_reporting/088_board_reporting_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-022-beacon-mining/12_remediation/089_remediation_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-022-beacon-mining/12_remediation/090_remediation_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-022-beacon-mining/12_remediation/091_remediation_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-022-beacon-mining/12_remediation/092_remediation_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-022-beacon-mining/12_remediation/093_remediation_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-022-beacon-mining/12_remediation/094_remediation_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-022-beacon-mining/12_remediation/095_remediation_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-022-beacon-mining/12_remediation/096_remediation_status_report.md"], "gold_output": {"advice_markdown": "# Counsel advice — Beacon procurement integrity review\n\n## Executive assessment\n\nFor Beacon Mineral Resources matter CB-IV-2602, the review identified 16 source-supported exceptions requiring action before 2026-09-06. The assessment concerns Red Mesa Hauling Co. and the supplied record for Arizona.\n\n## Method and record coverage\n\nThe review inventoried all 96 production files, read the 33 controlling, corroborating, and control records, searched the email exports, and checked metadata for the designated chain-of-custody sample. Conclusions are limited to the synthetic production supplied for this benchmark matter.\n\n## Findings\n\n### F-01 — preservation delay (critical)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for preservation delay: one source states the operative date is 2026-02-23 under control reference CB-IV-2602-A876, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2026-03-24 under response reference CB-IV-2602-J298.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/01_intake/001_intake_control_register.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/07_access_logs/049_access_logs_control_register.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-06, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Mei Whitaker.\n\n### F-02 — interview timeline conflict (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for interview timeline conflict: one source states the controlling amount is $4,051,442.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $4,139,384.00.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/01_intake/004_intake_ledger_export.csv`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/07_access_logs/052_access_logs_ledger_export.csv`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-06, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Caleb Hassan.\n\n### F-03 — undisclosed related party (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for undisclosed related party: one source states approval is attributed to Dominic Alvarez as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Isaac Romero and contains no entry for Dominic Alvarez.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/01_intake/007_intake_officer_certificate.html`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/07_access_logs/055_access_logs_officer_certificate.html`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-06, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Leona Park.\n\n### F-04 — split-purchase pattern (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for split-purchase pattern: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-IV-2602-D711, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-IV-2602-M631.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/02_preservation/010_preservation_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/08_vendor_files/058_vendor_files_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-06, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Isaac Romero.\n\n### F-05 — approval override (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for approval override: one source states the applicable location is Pima County, Arizona, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to Arizona operations outside Pima County, Arizona.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/02_preservation/013_preservation_review_memorandum.json`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/08_vendor_files/061_vendor_files_review_memorandum.json`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-06, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Sofia Bennett.\n\n### F-06 — gift-policy threshold breach (low)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for gift-policy threshold breach: one source states the threshold is 3% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 10% and produced a different exception result.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/02_preservation/016_preservation_status_report.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/08_vendor_files/064_vendor_files_status_report.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-06, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Adrian Mensah.\n\n### F-07 — off-channel communication (critical)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for off-channel communication: one source states formal notice must use notices-beacon_mineral_resources@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-red_mesa_hauling_co@example.test.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/03_interviews/019_interviews_correspondence.eml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/09_policies/067_policies_correspondence.eml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-06, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Willa Novak.\n\n### F-08 — deleted-message anomaly (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for deleted-message anomaly: one source states the governed population contains 132 records through 2026-01-02, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 48 records through 2026-01-22.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/03_interviews/022_interviews_formal_notice.xml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/09_policies/070_policies_formal_notice.xml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-06, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Theo Laurent.\n\n### F-09 — badge-log inconsistency (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for badge-log inconsistency: one source states the operative date is 2025-02-07 under control reference CB-IV-2602-I975, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2025-03-08 under response reference CB-IV-2602-R859.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/04_email_exports/025_email_exports_control_register.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/10_hr_records/073_hr_records_control_register.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-06, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Amara Patel.\n\n### F-10 — vendor due-diligence gap (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for vendor due-diligence gap: one source states the controlling amount is $5,739,664.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $6,055,828.00.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/04_email_exports/028_email_exports_ledger_export.csv`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/10_hr_records/076_hr_records_ledger_export.csv`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-06, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Henry Cho.\n\n### F-11 — retaliation concern (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for retaliation concern: one source states approval is attributed to Dominic Alvarez as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Dominic Alvarez and contains no entry for Dominic Alvarez.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/04_email_exports/031_email_exports_officer_certificate.html`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/10_hr_records/079_hr_records_officer_certificate.html`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-06, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Nadine Flores.\n\n### F-12 — policy training lapse (low)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for policy training lapse: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-IV-2602-L794, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-IV-2602-U914.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/034_chat_exports_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/11_board_reporting/082_board_reporting_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-06, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Micah Sullivan.\n\n### F-13 — board-reporting omission (critical)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for board-reporting omission: one source states the applicable location is Pima County, Arizona, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to Arizona operations outside Pima County, Arizona.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/037_chat_exports_review_memorandum.json`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/11_board_reporting/085_board_reporting_review_memorandum.json`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-06, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Farah Ibrahim.\n\n### F-14 — hotline classification error (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for hotline classification error: one source states the threshold is 12% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 16% and produced a different exception result.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/040_chat_exports_status_report.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/11_board_reporting/088_board_reporting_status_report.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-06, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Owen Delgado.\n\n### F-15 — expense support deficiency (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for expense support deficiency: one source states formal notice must use notices-beacon_mineral_resources@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-red_mesa_hauling_co@example.test.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/06_expenses/043_expenses_correspondence.eml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/12_remediation/091_remediation_correspondence.eml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-06, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Lena Varga.\n\n### F-16 — remediation ownership gap (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for remediation ownership gap: one source states the governed population contains 75 records through 2025-06-19, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 60 records through 2025-07-21.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/06_expenses/046_expenses_formal_notice.xml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/12_remediation/094_remediation_formal_notice.xml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-06, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Samuel Kim.\n\n## Recommended next actions\n\nSequence the critical and high findings first, assign the named owners, preserve the cited records, and document any resolution in the controlling matter register before the stated deadline.\n\n## Assumptions and limitations\n\nThis analysis is confined to task cb100-022-beacon-mining and the supplied synthetic evidence. It does not rely on external facts, does not resolve disputed law, and is not legal advice for a real person or entity.\n", "findings": {"as_of": "2026-09-06", "findings": [{"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/07_access_logs/049_access_logs_control_register.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for preservation delay: one source states the operative date is 2026-02-23 under control reference CB-IV-2602-A876, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2026-03-24 under response reference CB-IV-2602-J298.", "id": "F-01", "issue": "preservation delay", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/01_intake/001_intake_control_register.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-06, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Mei Whitaker.", "severity": "critical"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/07_access_logs/052_access_logs_ledger_export.csv", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for interview timeline conflict: one source states the controlling amount is $4,051,442.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $4,139,384.00.", "id": "F-02", "issue": "interview timeline conflict", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/01_intake/004_intake_ledger_export.csv", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-06, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Caleb Hassan.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/07_access_logs/055_access_logs_officer_certificate.html", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for undisclosed related party: one source states approval is attributed to Dominic Alvarez as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Isaac Romero and contains no entry for Dominic Alvarez.", "id": "F-03", "issue": "undisclosed related party", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/01_intake/007_intake_officer_certificate.html", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-06, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Leona Park.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/08_vendor_files/058_vendor_files_executed_instrument.txt", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for split-purchase pattern: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-IV-2602-D711, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-IV-2602-M631.", "id": "F-04", "issue": "split-purchase pattern", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/02_preservation/010_preservation_executed_instrument.txt", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-06, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Isaac Romero.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/08_vendor_files/061_vendor_files_review_memorandum.json", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for approval override: one source states the applicable location is Pima County, Arizona, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to Arizona operations outside Pima County, Arizona.", "id": "F-05", "issue": "approval override", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/02_preservation/013_preservation_review_memorandum.json", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-06, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Sofia Bennett.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/08_vendor_files/064_vendor_files_status_report.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for gift-policy threshold breach: one source states the threshold is 3% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 10% and produced a different exception result.", "id": "F-06", "issue": "gift-policy threshold breach", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/02_preservation/016_preservation_status_report.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-06, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Adrian Mensah.", "severity": "low"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/09_policies/067_policies_correspondence.eml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for off-channel communication: one source states formal notice must use notices-beacon_mineral_resources@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-red_mesa_hauling_co@example.test.", "id": "F-07", "issue": "off-channel communication", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/03_interviews/019_interviews_correspondence.eml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-06, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Willa Novak.", "severity": "critical"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/09_policies/070_policies_formal_notice.xml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for deleted-message anomaly: one source states the governed population contains 132 records through 2026-01-02, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 48 records through 2026-01-22.", "id": "F-08", "issue": "deleted-message anomaly", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/03_interviews/022_interviews_formal_notice.xml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-06, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Theo Laurent.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/10_hr_records/073_hr_records_control_register.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for badge-log inconsistency: one source states the operative date is 2025-02-07 under control reference CB-IV-2602-I975, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2025-03-08 under response reference CB-IV-2602-R859.", "id": "F-09", "issue": "badge-log inconsistency", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/04_email_exports/025_email_exports_control_register.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-06, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Amara Patel.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/10_hr_records/076_hr_records_ledger_export.csv", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for vendor due-diligence gap: one source states the controlling amount is $5,739,664.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $6,055,828.00.", "id": "F-10", "issue": "vendor due-diligence gap", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/04_email_exports/028_email_exports_ledger_export.csv", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-06, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Henry Cho.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/10_hr_records/079_hr_records_officer_certificate.html", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for retaliation concern: one source states approval is attributed to Dominic Alvarez as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Dominic Alvarez and contains no entry for Dominic Alvarez.", "id": "F-11", "issue": "retaliation concern", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/04_email_exports/031_email_exports_officer_certificate.html", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-06, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Nadine Flores.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/11_board_reporting/082_board_reporting_executed_instrument.txt", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for policy training lapse: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-IV-2602-L794, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-IV-2602-U914.", "id": "F-12", "issue": "policy training lapse", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/034_chat_exports_executed_instrument.txt", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-06, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Micah Sullivan.", "severity": "low"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/11_board_reporting/085_board_reporting_review_memorandum.json", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for board-reporting omission: one source states the applicable location is Pima County, Arizona, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to Arizona operations outside Pima County, Arizona.", "id": "F-13", "issue": "board-reporting omission", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/037_chat_exports_review_memorandum.json", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-06, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Farah Ibrahim.", "severity": "critical"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/11_board_reporting/088_board_reporting_status_report.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for hotline classification error: one source states the threshold is 12% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 16% and produced a different exception result.", "id": "F-14", "issue": "hotline classification error", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/040_chat_exports_status_report.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-06, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Owen Delgado.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/091_remediation_correspondence.eml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for expense support deficiency: one source states formal notice must use notices-beacon_mineral_resources@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-red_mesa_hauling_co@example.test.", "id": "F-15", "issue": "expense support deficiency", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/06_expenses/043_expenses_correspondence.eml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-06, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Lena Varga.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/094_remediation_formal_notice.xml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for remediation ownership gap: one source states the governed population contains 75 records through 2025-06-19, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 60 records through 2025-07-21.", "id": "F-16", "issue": "remediation ownership gap", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/06_expenses/046_expenses_formal_notice.xml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-06, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Samuel Kim.", "severity": "medium"}], "matter_number": "CB-IV-2602", "prepared_for": "Beacon Mineral Resources", "schema_version": "1.0", "task_id": "cb100-022-beacon-mining"}}, "metadata": {"benchmark": "CounselBench-100", "code_license": "Apache-2.0", "data_license": "CC-BY-4.0", "deadline": "2026-09-06", "document_count": 96, "jurisdiction": "Arizona", "matter_number": "CB-IV-2602", "mcp_commit": "9a96ea6e5913736f92b88345bf51caeaaa8e719f", "mcp_package": "@modelcontextprotocol/server-filesystem@2026.7.10", "practice_area": "internal-investigations", "reference_tool_calls": 46, "required_evidence_reads": 33, "synthetic": true, "venue": "Pima County, Arizona", "version": "2.0.0"}, "prompt": "You are independent investigations counsel for Beacon Mineral Resources. A late document production changed the factual picture, and the matter team needs the entire record reconciled from first principles. Anonymous allegations connect emergency hauling awards to off-channel messages, badge visits, and an undeclared family relationship. Decision due 2026-09-06. Arizona law governs; Pima County, Arizona is the forum. Separate confirmed exceptions from items that merely require follow-up. Work out the defensible position from the matter production and leave an audit-ready exception tracker and concise advice for the supervising lawyer. Keep confirmed conflicts separate from open questions, cite the records that actually control each conclusion, and do not fill gaps with outside facts.", "rubric": {"criteria": [{"category": "procedure", "description": "Complete at least 46 successful, argument-specific evidence and output calls.", "id": "procedure.minimum_successful_tool_calls"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Find and read the 33 controlling, corroborating, and work-product-control records in full.", "id": "procedure.all_evidence_read_in_full"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Inspect file metadata for the eight designated critical primary records before relying on them.", "id": "procedure.chain_of_custody_metadata_checked"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Confirm the sandbox's allowed document and output roots.", "id": "procedure.allowed_directories_checked"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Inventory all 96 records so the relevant sources are discovered among the context records.", "id": "procedure.recursive_inventory_completed"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Search the production for email evidence that may corroborate or contradict formal records.", "id": "procedure.targeted_search_completed"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Leave only findings.json and advice.md in the output workspace.", "id": "procedure.exact_deliverable_set"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Create both final work products through the sandbox MCP surface.", "id": "procedure.deliverables_written_through_mcp"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Produce findings.json as a valid JSON object.", "id": "findings.findings_is_object"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Report exactly 16 confirmed exceptions.", "id": "findings.findings_exact_count"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Use each stable finding ID exactly once.", "id": "findings.finding_ids_unique"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set schema_version to the released matter value '1.0'.", "id": "findings.top_level_schema_version"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set task_id to the released matter value 'cb100-022-beacon-mining'.", "id": "findings.top_level_task_id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set matter_number to the released matter value 'CB-IV-2602'.", "id": "findings.top_level_matter_number"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set prepared_for to the released matter value 'Beacon Mineral Resources'.", "id": "findings.top_level_prepared_for"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set as_of to the released matter value '2026-09-06'.", "id": "findings.top_level_as_of"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-01 exception for preservation delay.", "id": "findings.F-01.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's id from /workspace/documents/01_intake/001_intake_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_access_logs/049_access_logs_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's issue from /workspace/documents/01_intake/001_intake_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_access_logs/049_access_logs_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's severity from /workspace/documents/01_intake/001_intake_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_access_logs/049_access_logs_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's primary_source from /workspace/documents/01_intake/001_intake_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_access_logs/049_access_logs_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/01_intake/001_intake_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_access_logs/049_access_logs_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-01 using the exact controlled facts ['2026-02-23', 'CB-IV-2602-A876', '2026-03-24', 'CB-IV-2602-J298'].", "id": "findings.F-01.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-01's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-01.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-06', 'Mei Whitaker'] for F-01.", "id": "findings.F-01.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-02 exception for interview timeline conflict.", "id": "findings.F-02.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's id from /workspace/documents/01_intake/004_intake_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_access_logs/052_access_logs_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's issue from /workspace/documents/01_intake/004_intake_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_access_logs/052_access_logs_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's severity from /workspace/documents/01_intake/004_intake_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_access_logs/052_access_logs_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's primary_source from /workspace/documents/01_intake/004_intake_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_access_logs/052_access_logs_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/01_intake/004_intake_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_access_logs/052_access_logs_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-02 using the exact controlled facts ['$4,051,442.00', '$4,139,384.00'].", "id": "findings.F-02.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-02's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-02.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-06', 'Caleb Hassan'] for F-02.", "id": "findings.F-02.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-03 exception for undisclosed related party.", "id": "findings.F-03.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's id from /workspace/documents/01_intake/007_intake_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_access_logs/055_access_logs_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's issue from /workspace/documents/01_intake/007_intake_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_access_logs/055_access_logs_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's severity from /workspace/documents/01_intake/007_intake_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_access_logs/055_access_logs_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's primary_source from /workspace/documents/01_intake/007_intake_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_access_logs/055_access_logs_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/01_intake/007_intake_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_access_logs/055_access_logs_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-03 using the exact controlled facts ['Dominic Alvarez', 'Isaac Romero'].", "id": "findings.F-03.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-03's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-03.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-06', 'Leona Park'] for F-03.", "id": "findings.F-03.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-04 exception for split-purchase pattern.", "id": "findings.F-04.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's id from /workspace/documents/02_preservation/010_preservation_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_vendor_files/058_vendor_files_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's issue from /workspace/documents/02_preservation/010_preservation_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_vendor_files/058_vendor_files_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's severity from /workspace/documents/02_preservation/010_preservation_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_vendor_files/058_vendor_files_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's primary_source from /workspace/documents/02_preservation/010_preservation_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_vendor_files/058_vendor_files_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/02_preservation/010_preservation_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_vendor_files/058_vendor_files_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-04 using the exact controlled facts ['closed without exception', 'CB-IV-2602-D711', 'open and escalated', 'CB-IV-2602-M631'].", "id": "findings.F-04.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-04's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-04.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-06', 'Isaac Romero'] for F-04.", "id": "findings.F-04.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-05 exception for approval override.", "id": "findings.F-05.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's id from /workspace/documents/02_preservation/013_preservation_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_vendor_files/061_vendor_files_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's issue from /workspace/documents/02_preservation/013_preservation_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_vendor_files/061_vendor_files_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's severity from /workspace/documents/02_preservation/013_preservation_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_vendor_files/061_vendor_files_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's primary_source from /workspace/documents/02_preservation/013_preservation_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_vendor_files/061_vendor_files_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/02_preservation/013_preservation_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_vendor_files/061_vendor_files_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-05 using the exact controlled facts ['Pima County, Arizona', 'Arizona'].", "id": "findings.F-05.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-05's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-05.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-06', 'Sofia Bennett'] for F-05.", "id": "findings.F-05.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-06 exception for gift-policy threshold breach.", "id": "findings.F-06.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's id from /workspace/documents/02_preservation/016_preservation_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_vendor_files/064_vendor_files_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's issue from /workspace/documents/02_preservation/016_preservation_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_vendor_files/064_vendor_files_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's severity from /workspace/documents/02_preservation/016_preservation_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_vendor_files/064_vendor_files_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's primary_source from /workspace/documents/02_preservation/016_preservation_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_vendor_files/064_vendor_files_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/02_preservation/016_preservation_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_vendor_files/064_vendor_files_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-06 using the exact controlled facts ['3%', '10%'].", "id": "findings.F-06.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-06's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-06.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-06', 'Adrian Mensah'] for F-06.", "id": "findings.F-06.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-07 exception for off-channel communication.", "id": "findings.F-07.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's id from /workspace/documents/03_interviews/019_interviews_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_policies/067_policies_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's issue from /workspace/documents/03_interviews/019_interviews_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_policies/067_policies_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's severity from /workspace/documents/03_interviews/019_interviews_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_policies/067_policies_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's primary_source from /workspace/documents/03_interviews/019_interviews_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_policies/067_policies_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/03_interviews/019_interviews_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_policies/067_policies_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-07 using the exact controlled facts ['notices-beacon_mineral_resources@example.test', 'archive-red_mesa_hauling_co@example.test'].", "id": "findings.F-07.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-07's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-07.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-06', 'Willa Novak'] for F-07.", "id": "findings.F-07.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-08 exception for deleted-message anomaly.", "id": "findings.F-08.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's id from /workspace/documents/03_interviews/022_interviews_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_policies/070_policies_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's issue from /workspace/documents/03_interviews/022_interviews_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_policies/070_policies_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's severity from /workspace/documents/03_interviews/022_interviews_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_policies/070_policies_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's primary_source from /workspace/documents/03_interviews/022_interviews_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_policies/070_policies_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/03_interviews/022_interviews_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_policies/070_policies_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-08 using the exact controlled facts ['132 records', '2026-01-02', '48 records', '2026-01-22'].", "id": "findings.F-08.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-08's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-08.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-06', 'Theo Laurent'] for F-08.", "id": "findings.F-08.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-09 exception for badge-log inconsistency.", "id": "findings.F-09.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's id from /workspace/documents/04_email_exports/025_email_exports_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_hr_records/073_hr_records_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's issue from /workspace/documents/04_email_exports/025_email_exports_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_hr_records/073_hr_records_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's severity from /workspace/documents/04_email_exports/025_email_exports_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_hr_records/073_hr_records_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's primary_source from /workspace/documents/04_email_exports/025_email_exports_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_hr_records/073_hr_records_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/04_email_exports/025_email_exports_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_hr_records/073_hr_records_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-09 using the exact controlled facts ['2025-02-07', 'CB-IV-2602-I975', '2025-03-08', 'CB-IV-2602-R859'].", "id": "findings.F-09.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-09's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-09.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-06', 'Amara Patel'] for F-09.", "id": "findings.F-09.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-10 exception for vendor due-diligence gap.", "id": "findings.F-10.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's id from /workspace/documents/04_email_exports/028_email_exports_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_hr_records/076_hr_records_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's issue from /workspace/documents/04_email_exports/028_email_exports_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_hr_records/076_hr_records_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's severity from /workspace/documents/04_email_exports/028_email_exports_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_hr_records/076_hr_records_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's primary_source from /workspace/documents/04_email_exports/028_email_exports_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_hr_records/076_hr_records_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/04_email_exports/028_email_exports_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_hr_records/076_hr_records_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-10 using the exact controlled facts ['$5,739,664.00', '$6,055,828.00'].", "id": "findings.F-10.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-10's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-10.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-06', 'Henry Cho'] for F-10.", "id": "findings.F-10.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-11 exception for retaliation concern.", "id": "findings.F-11.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's id from /workspace/documents/04_email_exports/031_email_exports_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_hr_records/079_hr_records_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's issue from /workspace/documents/04_email_exports/031_email_exports_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_hr_records/079_hr_records_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's severity from /workspace/documents/04_email_exports/031_email_exports_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_hr_records/079_hr_records_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's primary_source from /workspace/documents/04_email_exports/031_email_exports_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_hr_records/079_hr_records_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/04_email_exports/031_email_exports_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_hr_records/079_hr_records_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-11 using the exact controlled facts ['Dominic Alvarez', 'Dominic Alvarez'].", "id": "findings.F-11.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-11's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-11.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-06', 'Nadine Flores'] for F-11.", "id": "findings.F-11.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-12 exception for policy training lapse.", "id": "findings.F-12.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's id from /workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/034_chat_exports_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_board_reporting/082_board_reporting_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's issue from /workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/034_chat_exports_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_board_reporting/082_board_reporting_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's severity from /workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/034_chat_exports_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_board_reporting/082_board_reporting_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's primary_source from /workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/034_chat_exports_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_board_reporting/082_board_reporting_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/034_chat_exports_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_board_reporting/082_board_reporting_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-12 using the exact controlled facts ['closed without exception', 'CB-IV-2602-L794', 'open and escalated', 'CB-IV-2602-U914'].", "id": "findings.F-12.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-12's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-12.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-06', 'Micah Sullivan'] for F-12.", "id": "findings.F-12.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-13 exception for board-reporting omission.", "id": "findings.F-13.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's id from /workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/037_chat_exports_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_board_reporting/085_board_reporting_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's issue from /workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/037_chat_exports_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_board_reporting/085_board_reporting_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's severity from /workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/037_chat_exports_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_board_reporting/085_board_reporting_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's primary_source from /workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/037_chat_exports_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_board_reporting/085_board_reporting_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/037_chat_exports_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_board_reporting/085_board_reporting_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-13 using the exact controlled facts ['Pima County, Arizona', 'Arizona'].", "id": "findings.F-13.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-13's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-13.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-06', 'Farah Ibrahim'] for F-13.", "id": "findings.F-13.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-14 exception for hotline classification error.", "id": "findings.F-14.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's id from /workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/040_chat_exports_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_board_reporting/088_board_reporting_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's issue from /workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/040_chat_exports_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_board_reporting/088_board_reporting_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's severity from /workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/040_chat_exports_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_board_reporting/088_board_reporting_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's primary_source from /workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/040_chat_exports_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_board_reporting/088_board_reporting_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/040_chat_exports_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_board_reporting/088_board_reporting_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-14 using the exact controlled facts ['12%', '16%'].", "id": "findings.F-14.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-14's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-14.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-06', 'Owen Delgado'] for F-14.", "id": "findings.F-14.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-15 exception for expense support deficiency.", "id": "findings.F-15.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's id from /workspace/documents/06_expenses/043_expenses_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_remediation/091_remediation_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's issue from /workspace/documents/06_expenses/043_expenses_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_remediation/091_remediation_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's severity from /workspace/documents/06_expenses/043_expenses_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_remediation/091_remediation_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's primary_source from /workspace/documents/06_expenses/043_expenses_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_remediation/091_remediation_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/06_expenses/043_expenses_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_remediation/091_remediation_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-15 using the exact controlled facts ['notices-beacon_mineral_resources@example.test', 'archive-red_mesa_hauling_co@example.test'].", "id": "findings.F-15.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-15's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-15.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-06', 'Lena Varga'] for F-15.", "id": "findings.F-15.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-16 exception for remediation ownership gap.", "id": "findings.F-16.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's id from /workspace/documents/06_expenses/046_expenses_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_remediation/094_remediation_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's issue from /workspace/documents/06_expenses/046_expenses_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_remediation/094_remediation_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's severity from /workspace/documents/06_expenses/046_expenses_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_remediation/094_remediation_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's primary_source from /workspace/documents/06_expenses/046_expenses_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_remediation/094_remediation_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/06_expenses/046_expenses_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_remediation/094_remediation_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-16 using the exact controlled facts ['75 records', '2025-06-19', '60 records', '2025-07-21'].", "id": "findings.F-16.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-16's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-16.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-06', 'Samuel Kim'] for F-16.", "id": "findings.F-16.action_anchors"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Executive assessment' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Executive assessment"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Method and record coverage' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Method and record coverage"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Findings' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Findings"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Recommended next actions' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Recommended next actions"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Assumptions and limitations' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Assumptions and limitations"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-01 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-01"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-02 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-02"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-03 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-03"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-04 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-04"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-05 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-05"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-06 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-06"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-07 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-07"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-08 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-08"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-09 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-09"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-10 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-10"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-11 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-11"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-12 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-12"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-13 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-13"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-14 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-14"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-15 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-15"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-16 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-16"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Do not claim the production has no issues or that every record is consistent.", "id": "memo.forbidden_claims_absent"}], "decision_options": [{"id": "cross-source-reconciliation", "label": "Reconcile controlling and corroborating records", "reason": "The CB-IV-2602 production contains independently maintained records; a defensible answer must preserve each supported conflict and its cure owner.", "selected": true}, {"id": "latest-record-controls", "label": "Treat the latest record as controlling", "reason": "Timestamp recency does not establish legal priority, execution, or approval authority.", "selected": false}, {"id": "primary-records-only", "label": "Report primary records without reconciliation", "reason": "Primary records alone conceal the operational conflicts that create the actionable exceptions.", "selected": false}], "gates": ["all_evidence_read_in_full", "chain_of_custody_metadata_checked", "findings_criteria_complete", "memo_criteria_complete", "deliverables_written_through_mcp"], "metadata_checks": 8, "metric": "weighted_criteria_score", "minimum_tool_calls": 46, "required_deliverables": ["findings.json", "advice.md"], "required_document_reads": 33, "type": "deterministic", "weights": {"findings": 0.55, "memo": 0.2, "procedure": 0.25}}, "task_id": "cb100-022-beacon-mining", "task_name": "Beacon procurement integrity review", "world_id": "counselbench-filesystem-mcp-v2"}
-{"context_files": ["task_files/cb100-023-cedar-finance/01_intake/001_intake_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-023-cedar-finance/01_intake/002_intake_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-023-cedar-finance/01_intake/003_intake_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-023-cedar-finance/01_intake/004_intake_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-023-cedar-finance/01_intake/005_intake_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-023-cedar-finance/01_intake/006_intake_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-023-cedar-finance/01_intake/007_intake_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-023-cedar-finance/01_intake/008_intake_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-023-cedar-finance/02_preservation/009_preservation_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-023-cedar-finance/02_preservation/010_preservation_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-023-cedar-finance/02_preservation/011_preservation_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-023-cedar-finance/02_preservation/012_preservation_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-023-cedar-finance/02_preservation/013_preservation_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-023-cedar-finance/02_preservation/014_preservation_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-023-cedar-finance/02_preservation/015_preservation_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-023-cedar-finance/02_preservation/016_preservation_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-023-cedar-finance/03_interviews/017_interviews_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-023-cedar-finance/03_interviews/018_interviews_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-023-cedar-finance/03_interviews/019_interviews_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-023-cedar-finance/03_interviews/020_interviews_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-023-cedar-finance/03_interviews/021_interviews_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-023-cedar-finance/03_interviews/022_interviews_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-023-cedar-finance/03_interviews/023_interviews_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-023-cedar-finance/03_interviews/024_interviews_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-023-cedar-finance/04_email_exports/025_email_exports_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-023-cedar-finance/04_email_exports/026_email_exports_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-023-cedar-finance/04_email_exports/027_email_exports_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-023-cedar-finance/04_email_exports/028_email_exports_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-023-cedar-finance/04_email_exports/029_email_exports_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-023-cedar-finance/04_email_exports/030_email_exports_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-023-cedar-finance/04_email_exports/031_email_exports_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-023-cedar-finance/04_email_exports/032_email_exports_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-023-cedar-finance/05_chat_exports/033_chat_exports_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-023-cedar-finance/05_chat_exports/034_chat_exports_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-023-cedar-finance/05_chat_exports/035_chat_exports_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-023-cedar-finance/05_chat_exports/036_chat_exports_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-023-cedar-finance/05_chat_exports/037_chat_exports_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-023-cedar-finance/05_chat_exports/038_chat_exports_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-023-cedar-finance/05_chat_exports/039_chat_exports_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-023-cedar-finance/05_chat_exports/040_chat_exports_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-023-cedar-finance/06_expenses/041_expenses_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-023-cedar-finance/06_expenses/042_expenses_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-023-cedar-finance/06_expenses/043_expenses_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-023-cedar-finance/06_expenses/044_expenses_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-023-cedar-finance/06_expenses/045_expenses_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-023-cedar-finance/06_expenses/046_expenses_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-023-cedar-finance/06_expenses/047_expenses_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-023-cedar-finance/06_expenses/048_expenses_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-023-cedar-finance/07_access_logs/049_access_logs_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-023-cedar-finance/07_access_logs/050_access_logs_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-023-cedar-finance/07_access_logs/051_access_logs_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-023-cedar-finance/07_access_logs/052_access_logs_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-023-cedar-finance/07_access_logs/053_access_logs_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-023-cedar-finance/07_access_logs/054_access_logs_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-023-cedar-finance/07_access_logs/055_access_logs_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-023-cedar-finance/07_access_logs/056_access_logs_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-023-cedar-finance/08_vendor_files/057_vendor_files_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-023-cedar-finance/08_vendor_files/058_vendor_files_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-023-cedar-finance/08_vendor_files/059_vendor_files_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-023-cedar-finance/08_vendor_files/060_vendor_files_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-023-cedar-finance/08_vendor_files/061_vendor_files_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-023-cedar-finance/08_vendor_files/062_vendor_files_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-023-cedar-finance/08_vendor_files/063_vendor_files_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-023-cedar-finance/08_vendor_files/064_vendor_files_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-023-cedar-finance/09_policies/065_policies_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-023-cedar-finance/09_policies/066_policies_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-023-cedar-finance/09_policies/067_policies_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-023-cedar-finance/09_policies/068_policies_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-023-cedar-finance/09_policies/069_policies_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-023-cedar-finance/09_policies/070_policies_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-023-cedar-finance/09_policies/071_policies_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-023-cedar-finance/09_policies/072_policies_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-023-cedar-finance/10_hr_records/073_hr_records_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-023-cedar-finance/10_hr_records/074_hr_records_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-023-cedar-finance/10_hr_records/075_hr_records_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-023-cedar-finance/10_hr_records/076_hr_records_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-023-cedar-finance/10_hr_records/077_hr_records_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-023-cedar-finance/10_hr_records/078_hr_records_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-023-cedar-finance/10_hr_records/079_hr_records_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-023-cedar-finance/10_hr_records/080_hr_records_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-023-cedar-finance/11_board_reporting/081_board_reporting_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-023-cedar-finance/11_board_reporting/082_board_reporting_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-023-cedar-finance/11_board_reporting/083_board_reporting_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-023-cedar-finance/11_board_reporting/084_board_reporting_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-023-cedar-finance/11_board_reporting/085_board_reporting_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-023-cedar-finance/11_board_reporting/086_board_reporting_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-023-cedar-finance/11_board_reporting/087_board_reporting_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-023-cedar-finance/11_board_reporting/088_board_reporting_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-023-cedar-finance/12_remediation/089_remediation_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-023-cedar-finance/12_remediation/090_remediation_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-023-cedar-finance/12_remediation/091_remediation_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-023-cedar-finance/12_remediation/092_remediation_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-023-cedar-finance/12_remediation/093_remediation_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-023-cedar-finance/12_remediation/094_remediation_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-023-cedar-finance/12_remediation/095_remediation_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-023-cedar-finance/12_remediation/096_remediation_status_report.md"], "gold_output": {"advice_markdown": "# Counsel advice — Cedar branch incentive investigation\n\n## Executive assessment\n\nFor Cedar Community Finance matter CB-IV-2603, the review identified 16 source-supported exceptions requiring action before 2026-09-09. The assessment concerns Lakefront Referral Partners and the supplied record for Wisconsin.\n\n## Method and record coverage\n\nThe review inventoried all 96 production files, read the 33 controlling, corroborating, and control records, searched the email exports, and checked metadata for the designated chain-of-custody sample. Conclusions are limited to the synthetic production supplied for this benchmark matter.\n\n## Findings\n\n### F-01 — preservation delay (critical)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for preservation delay: one source states the operative date is 2025-01-16 under control reference CB-IV-2603-A473, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2025-03-02 under response reference CB-IV-2603-J405.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/01_intake/001_intake_control_register.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/07_access_logs/049_access_logs_control_register.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-09, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Caleb Hassan.\n\n### F-02 — interview timeline conflict (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for interview timeline conflict: one source states the controlling amount is $2,993,271.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $3,293,042.00.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/01_intake/004_intake_ledger_export.csv`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/07_access_logs/052_access_logs_ledger_export.csv`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-09, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Leona Park.\n\n### F-03 — undisclosed related party (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for undisclosed related party: one source states approval is attributed to Priya Raman as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Adrian Mensah and contains no entry for Priya Raman.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/01_intake/007_intake_officer_certificate.html`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/07_access_logs/055_access_logs_officer_certificate.html`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-09, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Isaac Romero.\n\n### F-04 — split-purchase pattern (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for split-purchase pattern: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-IV-2603-D923, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-IV-2603-M232.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/02_preservation/010_preservation_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/08_vendor_files/058_vendor_files_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-09, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Sofia Bennett.\n\n### F-05 — approval override (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for approval override: one source states the applicable location is Milwaukee County, Wisconsin, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to Wisconsin operations outside Milwaukee County, Wisconsin.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/02_preservation/013_preservation_review_memorandum.json`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/08_vendor_files/061_vendor_files_review_memorandum.json`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-09, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Adrian Mensah.\n\n### F-06 — gift-policy threshold breach (low)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for gift-policy threshold breach: one source states the threshold is 13% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 18% and produced a different exception result.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/02_preservation/016_preservation_status_report.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/08_vendor_files/064_vendor_files_status_report.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-09, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Willa Novak.\n\n### F-07 — off-channel communication (critical)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for off-channel communication: one source states formal notice must use notices-cedar_community_finance@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-lakefront_referral_partners@example.test.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/03_interviews/019_interviews_correspondence.eml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/09_policies/067_policies_correspondence.eml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-09, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Theo Laurent.\n\n### F-08 — deleted-message anomaly (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for deleted-message anomaly: one source states the governed population contains 75 records through 2025-01-30, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 71 records through 2025-03-14.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/03_interviews/022_interviews_formal_notice.xml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/09_policies/070_policies_formal_notice.xml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-09, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Amara Patel.\n\n### F-09 — badge-log inconsistency (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for badge-log inconsistency: one source states the operative date is 2025-08-08 under control reference CB-IV-2603-I497, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2025-09-15 under response reference CB-IV-2603-R615.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/04_email_exports/025_email_exports_control_register.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/10_hr_records/073_hr_records_control_register.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-09, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Henry Cho.\n\n### F-10 — vendor due-diligence gap (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for vendor due-diligence gap: one source states the controlling amount is $1,503,795.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $1,714,090.00.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/04_email_exports/028_email_exports_ledger_export.csv`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/10_hr_records/076_hr_records_ledger_export.csv`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-09, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Nadine Flores.\n\n### F-11 — retaliation concern (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for retaliation concern: one source states approval is attributed to Priya Raman as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Elliot Mercer and contains no entry for Priya Raman.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/04_email_exports/031_email_exports_officer_certificate.html`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/10_hr_records/079_hr_records_officer_certificate.html`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-09, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Micah Sullivan.\n\n### F-12 — policy training lapse (low)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for policy training lapse: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-IV-2603-L337, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-IV-2603-U879.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/034_chat_exports_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/11_board_reporting/082_board_reporting_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-09, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Farah Ibrahim.\n\n### F-13 — board-reporting omission (critical)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for board-reporting omission: one source states the applicable location is Milwaukee County, Wisconsin, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to Wisconsin operations outside Milwaukee County, Wisconsin.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/037_chat_exports_review_memorandum.json`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/11_board_reporting/085_board_reporting_review_memorandum.json`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-09, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Owen Delgado.\n\n### F-14 — hotline classification error (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for hotline classification error: one source states the threshold is 15% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 22% and produced a different exception result.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/040_chat_exports_status_report.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/11_board_reporting/088_board_reporting_status_report.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-09, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Lena Varga.\n\n### F-15 — expense support deficiency (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for expense support deficiency: one source states formal notice must use notices-cedar_community_finance@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-lakefront_referral_partners@example.test.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/06_expenses/043_expenses_correspondence.eml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/12_remediation/091_remediation_correspondence.eml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-09, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Samuel Kim.\n\n### F-16 — remediation ownership gap (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for remediation ownership gap: one source states the governed population contains 58 records through 2025-01-13, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 60 records through 2025-02-14.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/06_expenses/046_expenses_formal_notice.xml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/12_remediation/094_remediation_formal_notice.xml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-09, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Maya Ellison.\n\n## Recommended next actions\n\nSequence the critical and high findings first, assign the named owners, preserve the cited records, and document any resolution in the controlling matter register before the stated deadline.\n\n## Assumptions and limitations\n\nThis analysis is confined to task cb100-023-cedar-finance and the supplied synthetic evidence. It does not rely on external facts, does not resolve disputed law, and is not legal advice for a real person or entity.\n", "findings": {"as_of": "2026-09-09", "findings": [{"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/07_access_logs/049_access_logs_control_register.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for preservation delay: one source states the operative date is 2025-01-16 under control reference CB-IV-2603-A473, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2025-03-02 under response reference CB-IV-2603-J405.", "id": "F-01", "issue": "preservation delay", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/01_intake/001_intake_control_register.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-09, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Caleb Hassan.", "severity": "critical"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/07_access_logs/052_access_logs_ledger_export.csv", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for interview timeline conflict: one source states the controlling amount is $2,993,271.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $3,293,042.00.", "id": "F-02", "issue": "interview timeline conflict", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/01_intake/004_intake_ledger_export.csv", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-09, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Leona Park.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/07_access_logs/055_access_logs_officer_certificate.html", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for undisclosed related party: one source states approval is attributed to Priya Raman as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Adrian Mensah and contains no entry for Priya Raman.", "id": "F-03", "issue": "undisclosed related party", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/01_intake/007_intake_officer_certificate.html", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-09, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Isaac Romero.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/08_vendor_files/058_vendor_files_executed_instrument.txt", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for split-purchase pattern: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-IV-2603-D923, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-IV-2603-M232.", "id": "F-04", "issue": "split-purchase pattern", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/02_preservation/010_preservation_executed_instrument.txt", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-09, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Sofia Bennett.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/08_vendor_files/061_vendor_files_review_memorandum.json", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for approval override: one source states the applicable location is Milwaukee County, Wisconsin, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to Wisconsin operations outside Milwaukee County, Wisconsin.", "id": "F-05", "issue": "approval override", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/02_preservation/013_preservation_review_memorandum.json", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-09, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Adrian Mensah.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/08_vendor_files/064_vendor_files_status_report.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for gift-policy threshold breach: one source states the threshold is 13% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 18% and produced a different exception result.", "id": "F-06", "issue": "gift-policy threshold breach", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/02_preservation/016_preservation_status_report.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-09, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Willa Novak.", "severity": "low"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/09_policies/067_policies_correspondence.eml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for off-channel communication: one source states formal notice must use notices-cedar_community_finance@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-lakefront_referral_partners@example.test.", "id": "F-07", "issue": "off-channel communication", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/03_interviews/019_interviews_correspondence.eml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-09, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Theo Laurent.", "severity": "critical"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/09_policies/070_policies_formal_notice.xml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for deleted-message anomaly: one source states the governed population contains 75 records through 2025-01-30, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 71 records through 2025-03-14.", "id": "F-08", "issue": "deleted-message anomaly", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/03_interviews/022_interviews_formal_notice.xml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-09, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Amara Patel.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/10_hr_records/073_hr_records_control_register.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for badge-log inconsistency: one source states the operative date is 2025-08-08 under control reference CB-IV-2603-I497, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2025-09-15 under response reference CB-IV-2603-R615.", "id": "F-09", "issue": "badge-log inconsistency", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/04_email_exports/025_email_exports_control_register.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-09, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Henry Cho.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/10_hr_records/076_hr_records_ledger_export.csv", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for vendor due-diligence gap: one source states the controlling amount is $1,503,795.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $1,714,090.00.", "id": "F-10", "issue": "vendor due-diligence gap", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/04_email_exports/028_email_exports_ledger_export.csv", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-09, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Nadine Flores.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/10_hr_records/079_hr_records_officer_certificate.html", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for retaliation concern: one source states approval is attributed to Priya Raman as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Elliot Mercer and contains no entry for Priya Raman.", "id": "F-11", "issue": "retaliation concern", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/04_email_exports/031_email_exports_officer_certificate.html", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-09, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Micah Sullivan.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/11_board_reporting/082_board_reporting_executed_instrument.txt", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for policy training lapse: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-IV-2603-L337, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-IV-2603-U879.", "id": "F-12", "issue": "policy training lapse", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/034_chat_exports_executed_instrument.txt", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-09, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Farah Ibrahim.", "severity": "low"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/11_board_reporting/085_board_reporting_review_memorandum.json", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for board-reporting omission: one source states the applicable location is Milwaukee County, Wisconsin, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to Wisconsin operations outside Milwaukee County, Wisconsin.", "id": "F-13", "issue": "board-reporting omission", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/037_chat_exports_review_memorandum.json", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-09, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Owen Delgado.", "severity": "critical"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/11_board_reporting/088_board_reporting_status_report.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for hotline classification error: one source states the threshold is 15% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 22% and produced a different exception result.", "id": "F-14", "issue": "hotline classification error", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/040_chat_exports_status_report.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-09, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Lena Varga.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/091_remediation_correspondence.eml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for expense support deficiency: one source states formal notice must use notices-cedar_community_finance@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-lakefront_referral_partners@example.test.", "id": "F-15", "issue": "expense support deficiency", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/06_expenses/043_expenses_correspondence.eml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-09, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Samuel Kim.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/094_remediation_formal_notice.xml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for remediation ownership gap: one source states the governed population contains 58 records through 2025-01-13, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 60 records through 2025-02-14.", "id": "F-16", "issue": "remediation ownership gap", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/06_expenses/046_expenses_formal_notice.xml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-09, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Maya Ellison.", "severity": "medium"}], "matter_number": "CB-IV-2603", "prepared_for": "Cedar Community Finance", "schema_version": "1.0", "task_id": "cb100-023-cedar-finance"}}, "metadata": {"benchmark": "CounselBench-100", "code_license": "Apache-2.0", "data_license": "CC-BY-4.0", "deadline": "2026-09-09", "document_count": 96, "jurisdiction": "Wisconsin", "matter_number": "CB-IV-2603", "mcp_commit": "9a96ea6e5913736f92b88345bf51caeaaa8e719f", "mcp_package": "@modelcontextprotocol/server-filesystem@2026.7.10", "practice_area": "internal-investigations", "reference_tool_calls": 46, "required_evidence_reads": 33, "synthetic": true, "venue": "Milwaukee County, Wisconsin", "version": "2.0.0"}, "prompt": "You are independent investigations counsel for Cedar Community Finance. The client has asked for a board-ready risk assessment supported by a source-level tracker rather than a narrative-only summary. A branch posted referral bonuses just below secondary-approval thresholds while employee interviews conflict with access and expense records. Decision due 2026-09-09. Wisconsin law governs; Milwaukee County, Wisconsin is the forum. Treat dates, notice mechanics, approval evidence, and numerical reconciliations as independent controls. Work out the defensible position from the matter production and leave an audit-ready exception tracker and concise advice for the supervising lawyer. Keep confirmed conflicts separate from open questions, cite the records that actually control each conclusion, and do not fill gaps with outside facts.", "rubric": {"criteria": [{"category": "procedure", "description": "Complete at least 46 successful, argument-specific evidence and output calls.", "id": "procedure.minimum_successful_tool_calls"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Find and read the 33 controlling, corroborating, and work-product-control records in full.", "id": "procedure.all_evidence_read_in_full"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Inspect file metadata for the eight designated critical primary records before relying on them.", "id": "procedure.chain_of_custody_metadata_checked"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Confirm the sandbox's allowed document and output roots.", "id": "procedure.allowed_directories_checked"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Inventory all 96 records so the relevant sources are discovered among the context records.", "id": "procedure.recursive_inventory_completed"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Search the production for email evidence that may corroborate or contradict formal records.", "id": "procedure.targeted_search_completed"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Leave only findings.json and advice.md in the output workspace.", "id": "procedure.exact_deliverable_set"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Create both final work products through the sandbox MCP surface.", "id": "procedure.deliverables_written_through_mcp"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Produce findings.json as a valid JSON object.", "id": "findings.findings_is_object"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Report exactly 16 confirmed exceptions.", "id": "findings.findings_exact_count"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Use each stable finding ID exactly once.", "id": "findings.finding_ids_unique"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set schema_version to the released matter value '1.0'.", "id": "findings.top_level_schema_version"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set task_id to the released matter value 'cb100-023-cedar-finance'.", "id": "findings.top_level_task_id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set matter_number to the released matter value 'CB-IV-2603'.", "id": "findings.top_level_matter_number"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set prepared_for to the released matter value 'Cedar Community Finance'.", "id": "findings.top_level_prepared_for"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set as_of to the released matter value '2026-09-09'.", "id": "findings.top_level_as_of"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-01 exception for preservation delay.", "id": "findings.F-01.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's id from /workspace/documents/01_intake/001_intake_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_access_logs/049_access_logs_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's issue from /workspace/documents/01_intake/001_intake_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_access_logs/049_access_logs_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's severity from /workspace/documents/01_intake/001_intake_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_access_logs/049_access_logs_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's primary_source from /workspace/documents/01_intake/001_intake_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_access_logs/049_access_logs_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/01_intake/001_intake_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_access_logs/049_access_logs_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-01 using the exact controlled facts ['2025-01-16', 'CB-IV-2603-A473', '2025-03-02', 'CB-IV-2603-J405'].", "id": "findings.F-01.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-01's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-01.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-09', 'Caleb Hassan'] for F-01.", "id": "findings.F-01.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-02 exception for interview timeline conflict.", "id": "findings.F-02.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's id from /workspace/documents/01_intake/004_intake_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_access_logs/052_access_logs_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's issue from /workspace/documents/01_intake/004_intake_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_access_logs/052_access_logs_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's severity from /workspace/documents/01_intake/004_intake_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_access_logs/052_access_logs_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's primary_source from /workspace/documents/01_intake/004_intake_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_access_logs/052_access_logs_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/01_intake/004_intake_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_access_logs/052_access_logs_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-02 using the exact controlled facts ['$2,993,271.00', '$3,293,042.00'].", "id": "findings.F-02.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-02's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-02.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-09', 'Leona Park'] for F-02.", "id": "findings.F-02.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-03 exception for undisclosed related party.", "id": "findings.F-03.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's id from /workspace/documents/01_intake/007_intake_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_access_logs/055_access_logs_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's issue from /workspace/documents/01_intake/007_intake_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_access_logs/055_access_logs_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's severity from /workspace/documents/01_intake/007_intake_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_access_logs/055_access_logs_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's primary_source from /workspace/documents/01_intake/007_intake_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_access_logs/055_access_logs_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/01_intake/007_intake_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_access_logs/055_access_logs_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-03 using the exact controlled facts ['Priya Raman', 'Adrian Mensah'].", "id": "findings.F-03.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-03's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-03.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-09', 'Isaac Romero'] for F-03.", "id": "findings.F-03.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-04 exception for split-purchase pattern.", "id": "findings.F-04.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's id from /workspace/documents/02_preservation/010_preservation_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_vendor_files/058_vendor_files_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's issue from /workspace/documents/02_preservation/010_preservation_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_vendor_files/058_vendor_files_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's severity from /workspace/documents/02_preservation/010_preservation_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_vendor_files/058_vendor_files_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's primary_source from /workspace/documents/02_preservation/010_preservation_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_vendor_files/058_vendor_files_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/02_preservation/010_preservation_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_vendor_files/058_vendor_files_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-04 using the exact controlled facts ['closed without exception', 'CB-IV-2603-D923', 'open and escalated', 'CB-IV-2603-M232'].", "id": "findings.F-04.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-04's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-04.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-09', 'Sofia Bennett'] for F-04.", "id": "findings.F-04.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-05 exception for approval override.", "id": "findings.F-05.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's id from /workspace/documents/02_preservation/013_preservation_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_vendor_files/061_vendor_files_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's issue from /workspace/documents/02_preservation/013_preservation_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_vendor_files/061_vendor_files_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's severity from /workspace/documents/02_preservation/013_preservation_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_vendor_files/061_vendor_files_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's primary_source from /workspace/documents/02_preservation/013_preservation_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_vendor_files/061_vendor_files_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/02_preservation/013_preservation_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_vendor_files/061_vendor_files_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-05 using the exact controlled facts ['Milwaukee County, Wisconsin', 'Wisconsin'].", "id": "findings.F-05.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-05's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-05.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-09', 'Adrian Mensah'] for F-05.", "id": "findings.F-05.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-06 exception for gift-policy threshold breach.", "id": "findings.F-06.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's id from /workspace/documents/02_preservation/016_preservation_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_vendor_files/064_vendor_files_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's issue from /workspace/documents/02_preservation/016_preservation_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_vendor_files/064_vendor_files_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's severity from /workspace/documents/02_preservation/016_preservation_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_vendor_files/064_vendor_files_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's primary_source from /workspace/documents/02_preservation/016_preservation_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_vendor_files/064_vendor_files_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/02_preservation/016_preservation_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_vendor_files/064_vendor_files_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-06 using the exact controlled facts ['13%', '18%'].", "id": "findings.F-06.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-06's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-06.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-09', 'Willa Novak'] for F-06.", "id": "findings.F-06.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-07 exception for off-channel communication.", "id": "findings.F-07.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's id from /workspace/documents/03_interviews/019_interviews_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_policies/067_policies_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's issue from /workspace/documents/03_interviews/019_interviews_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_policies/067_policies_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's severity from /workspace/documents/03_interviews/019_interviews_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_policies/067_policies_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's primary_source from /workspace/documents/03_interviews/019_interviews_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_policies/067_policies_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/03_interviews/019_interviews_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_policies/067_policies_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-07 using the exact controlled facts ['notices-cedar_community_finance@example.test', 'archive-lakefront_referral_partners@example.test'].", "id": "findings.F-07.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-07's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-07.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-09', 'Theo Laurent'] for F-07.", "id": "findings.F-07.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-08 exception for deleted-message anomaly.", "id": "findings.F-08.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's id from /workspace/documents/03_interviews/022_interviews_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_policies/070_policies_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's issue from /workspace/documents/03_interviews/022_interviews_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_policies/070_policies_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's severity from /workspace/documents/03_interviews/022_interviews_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_policies/070_policies_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's primary_source from /workspace/documents/03_interviews/022_interviews_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_policies/070_policies_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/03_interviews/022_interviews_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_policies/070_policies_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-08 using the exact controlled facts ['75 records', '2025-01-30', '71 records', '2025-03-14'].", "id": "findings.F-08.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-08's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-08.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-09', 'Amara Patel'] for F-08.", "id": "findings.F-08.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-09 exception for badge-log inconsistency.", "id": "findings.F-09.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's id from /workspace/documents/04_email_exports/025_email_exports_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_hr_records/073_hr_records_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's issue from /workspace/documents/04_email_exports/025_email_exports_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_hr_records/073_hr_records_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's severity from /workspace/documents/04_email_exports/025_email_exports_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_hr_records/073_hr_records_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's primary_source from /workspace/documents/04_email_exports/025_email_exports_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_hr_records/073_hr_records_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/04_email_exports/025_email_exports_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_hr_records/073_hr_records_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-09 using the exact controlled facts ['2025-08-08', 'CB-IV-2603-I497', '2025-09-15', 'CB-IV-2603-R615'].", "id": "findings.F-09.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-09's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-09.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-09', 'Henry Cho'] for F-09.", "id": "findings.F-09.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-10 exception for vendor due-diligence gap.", "id": "findings.F-10.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's id from /workspace/documents/04_email_exports/028_email_exports_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_hr_records/076_hr_records_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's issue from /workspace/documents/04_email_exports/028_email_exports_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_hr_records/076_hr_records_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's severity from /workspace/documents/04_email_exports/028_email_exports_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_hr_records/076_hr_records_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's primary_source from /workspace/documents/04_email_exports/028_email_exports_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_hr_records/076_hr_records_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/04_email_exports/028_email_exports_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_hr_records/076_hr_records_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-10 using the exact controlled facts ['$1,503,795.00', '$1,714,090.00'].", "id": "findings.F-10.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-10's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-10.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-09', 'Nadine Flores'] for F-10.", "id": "findings.F-10.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-11 exception for retaliation concern.", "id": "findings.F-11.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's id from /workspace/documents/04_email_exports/031_email_exports_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_hr_records/079_hr_records_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's issue from /workspace/documents/04_email_exports/031_email_exports_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_hr_records/079_hr_records_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's severity from /workspace/documents/04_email_exports/031_email_exports_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_hr_records/079_hr_records_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's primary_source from /workspace/documents/04_email_exports/031_email_exports_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_hr_records/079_hr_records_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/04_email_exports/031_email_exports_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_hr_records/079_hr_records_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-11 using the exact controlled facts ['Priya Raman', 'Elliot Mercer'].", "id": "findings.F-11.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-11's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-11.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-09', 'Micah Sullivan'] for F-11.", "id": "findings.F-11.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-12 exception for policy training lapse.", "id": "findings.F-12.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's id from /workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/034_chat_exports_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_board_reporting/082_board_reporting_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's issue from /workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/034_chat_exports_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_board_reporting/082_board_reporting_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's severity from /workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/034_chat_exports_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_board_reporting/082_board_reporting_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's primary_source from /workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/034_chat_exports_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_board_reporting/082_board_reporting_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/034_chat_exports_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_board_reporting/082_board_reporting_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-12 using the exact controlled facts ['closed without exception', 'CB-IV-2603-L337', 'open and escalated', 'CB-IV-2603-U879'].", "id": "findings.F-12.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-12's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-12.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-09', 'Farah Ibrahim'] for F-12.", "id": "findings.F-12.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-13 exception for board-reporting omission.", "id": "findings.F-13.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's id from /workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/037_chat_exports_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_board_reporting/085_board_reporting_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's issue from /workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/037_chat_exports_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_board_reporting/085_board_reporting_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's severity from /workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/037_chat_exports_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_board_reporting/085_board_reporting_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's primary_source from /workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/037_chat_exports_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_board_reporting/085_board_reporting_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/037_chat_exports_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_board_reporting/085_board_reporting_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-13 using the exact controlled facts ['Milwaukee County, Wisconsin', 'Wisconsin'].", "id": "findings.F-13.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-13's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-13.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-09', 'Owen Delgado'] for F-13.", "id": "findings.F-13.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-14 exception for hotline classification error.", "id": "findings.F-14.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's id from /workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/040_chat_exports_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_board_reporting/088_board_reporting_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's issue from /workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/040_chat_exports_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_board_reporting/088_board_reporting_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's severity from /workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/040_chat_exports_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_board_reporting/088_board_reporting_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's primary_source from /workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/040_chat_exports_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_board_reporting/088_board_reporting_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/040_chat_exports_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_board_reporting/088_board_reporting_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-14 using the exact controlled facts ['15%', '22%'].", "id": "findings.F-14.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-14's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-14.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-09', 'Lena Varga'] for F-14.", "id": "findings.F-14.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-15 exception for expense support deficiency.", "id": "findings.F-15.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's id from /workspace/documents/06_expenses/043_expenses_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_remediation/091_remediation_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's issue from /workspace/documents/06_expenses/043_expenses_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_remediation/091_remediation_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's severity from /workspace/documents/06_expenses/043_expenses_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_remediation/091_remediation_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's primary_source from /workspace/documents/06_expenses/043_expenses_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_remediation/091_remediation_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/06_expenses/043_expenses_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_remediation/091_remediation_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-15 using the exact controlled facts ['notices-cedar_community_finance@example.test', 'archive-lakefront_referral_partners@example.test'].", "id": "findings.F-15.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-15's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-15.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-09', 'Samuel Kim'] for F-15.", "id": "findings.F-15.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-16 exception for remediation ownership gap.", "id": "findings.F-16.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's id from /workspace/documents/06_expenses/046_expenses_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_remediation/094_remediation_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's issue from /workspace/documents/06_expenses/046_expenses_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_remediation/094_remediation_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's severity from /workspace/documents/06_expenses/046_expenses_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_remediation/094_remediation_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's primary_source from /workspace/documents/06_expenses/046_expenses_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_remediation/094_remediation_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/06_expenses/046_expenses_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_remediation/094_remediation_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-16 using the exact controlled facts ['58 records', '2025-01-13', '60 records', '2025-02-14'].", "id": "findings.F-16.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-16's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-16.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-09', 'Maya Ellison'] for F-16.", "id": "findings.F-16.action_anchors"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Executive assessment' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Executive assessment"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Method and record coverage' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Method and record coverage"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Findings' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Findings"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Recommended next actions' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Recommended next actions"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Assumptions and limitations' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Assumptions and limitations"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-01 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-01"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-02 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-02"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-03 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-03"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-04 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-04"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-05 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-05"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-06 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-06"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-07 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-07"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-08 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-08"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-09 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-09"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-10 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-10"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-11 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-11"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-12 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-12"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-13 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-13"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-14 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-14"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-15 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-15"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-16 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-16"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Do not claim the production has no issues or that every record is consistent.", "id": "memo.forbidden_claims_absent"}], "decision_options": [{"id": "cross-source-reconciliation", "label": "Reconcile controlling and corroborating records", "reason": "The CB-IV-2603 production contains independently maintained records; a defensible answer must preserve each supported conflict and its cure owner.", "selected": true}, {"id": "latest-record-controls", "label": "Treat the latest record as controlling", "reason": "Timestamp recency does not establish legal priority, execution, or approval authority.", "selected": false}, {"id": "primary-records-only", "label": "Report primary records without reconciliation", "reason": "Primary records alone conceal the operational conflicts that create the actionable exceptions.", "selected": false}], "gates": ["all_evidence_read_in_full", "chain_of_custody_metadata_checked", "findings_criteria_complete", "memo_criteria_complete", "deliverables_written_through_mcp"], "metadata_checks": 8, "metric": "weighted_criteria_score", "minimum_tool_calls": 46, "required_deliverables": ["findings.json", "advice.md"], "required_document_reads": 33, "type": "deterministic", "weights": {"findings": 0.55, "memo": 0.2, "procedure": 0.25}}, "task_id": "cb100-023-cedar-finance", "task_name": "Cedar branch incentive investigation", "world_id": "counselbench-filesystem-mcp-v2"}
-{"context_files": ["task_files/cb100-024-dovetail-aerospace/01_intake/001_intake_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-024-dovetail-aerospace/01_intake/002_intake_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-024-dovetail-aerospace/01_intake/003_intake_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-024-dovetail-aerospace/01_intake/004_intake_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-024-dovetail-aerospace/01_intake/005_intake_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-024-dovetail-aerospace/01_intake/006_intake_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-024-dovetail-aerospace/01_intake/007_intake_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-024-dovetail-aerospace/01_intake/008_intake_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-024-dovetail-aerospace/02_preservation/009_preservation_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-024-dovetail-aerospace/02_preservation/010_preservation_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-024-dovetail-aerospace/02_preservation/011_preservation_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-024-dovetail-aerospace/02_preservation/012_preservation_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-024-dovetail-aerospace/02_preservation/013_preservation_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-024-dovetail-aerospace/02_preservation/014_preservation_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-024-dovetail-aerospace/02_preservation/015_preservation_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-024-dovetail-aerospace/02_preservation/016_preservation_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-024-dovetail-aerospace/03_interviews/017_interviews_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-024-dovetail-aerospace/03_interviews/018_interviews_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-024-dovetail-aerospace/03_interviews/019_interviews_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-024-dovetail-aerospace/03_interviews/020_interviews_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-024-dovetail-aerospace/03_interviews/021_interviews_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-024-dovetail-aerospace/03_interviews/022_interviews_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-024-dovetail-aerospace/03_interviews/023_interviews_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-024-dovetail-aerospace/03_interviews/024_interviews_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-024-dovetail-aerospace/04_email_exports/025_email_exports_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-024-dovetail-aerospace/04_email_exports/026_email_exports_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-024-dovetail-aerospace/04_email_exports/027_email_exports_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-024-dovetail-aerospace/04_email_exports/028_email_exports_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-024-dovetail-aerospace/04_email_exports/029_email_exports_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-024-dovetail-aerospace/04_email_exports/030_email_exports_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-024-dovetail-aerospace/04_email_exports/031_email_exports_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-024-dovetail-aerospace/04_email_exports/032_email_exports_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-024-dovetail-aerospace/05_chat_exports/033_chat_exports_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-024-dovetail-aerospace/05_chat_exports/034_chat_exports_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-024-dovetail-aerospace/05_chat_exports/035_chat_exports_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-024-dovetail-aerospace/05_chat_exports/036_chat_exports_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-024-dovetail-aerospace/05_chat_exports/037_chat_exports_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-024-dovetail-aerospace/05_chat_exports/038_chat_exports_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-024-dovetail-aerospace/05_chat_exports/039_chat_exports_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-024-dovetail-aerospace/05_chat_exports/040_chat_exports_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-024-dovetail-aerospace/06_expenses/041_expenses_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-024-dovetail-aerospace/06_expenses/042_expenses_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-024-dovetail-aerospace/06_expenses/043_expenses_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-024-dovetail-aerospace/06_expenses/044_expenses_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-024-dovetail-aerospace/06_expenses/045_expenses_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-024-dovetail-aerospace/06_expenses/046_expenses_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-024-dovetail-aerospace/06_expenses/047_expenses_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-024-dovetail-aerospace/06_expenses/048_expenses_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-024-dovetail-aerospace/07_access_logs/049_access_logs_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-024-dovetail-aerospace/07_access_logs/050_access_logs_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-024-dovetail-aerospace/07_access_logs/051_access_logs_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-024-dovetail-aerospace/07_access_logs/052_access_logs_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-024-dovetail-aerospace/07_access_logs/053_access_logs_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-024-dovetail-aerospace/07_access_logs/054_access_logs_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-024-dovetail-aerospace/07_access_logs/055_access_logs_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-024-dovetail-aerospace/07_access_logs/056_access_logs_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-024-dovetail-aerospace/08_vendor_files/057_vendor_files_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-024-dovetail-aerospace/08_vendor_files/058_vendor_files_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-024-dovetail-aerospace/08_vendor_files/059_vendor_files_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-024-dovetail-aerospace/08_vendor_files/060_vendor_files_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-024-dovetail-aerospace/08_vendor_files/061_vendor_files_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-024-dovetail-aerospace/08_vendor_files/062_vendor_files_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-024-dovetail-aerospace/08_vendor_files/063_vendor_files_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-024-dovetail-aerospace/08_vendor_files/064_vendor_files_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-024-dovetail-aerospace/09_policies/065_policies_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-024-dovetail-aerospace/09_policies/066_policies_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-024-dovetail-aerospace/09_policies/067_policies_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-024-dovetail-aerospace/09_policies/068_policies_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-024-dovetail-aerospace/09_policies/069_policies_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-024-dovetail-aerospace/09_policies/070_policies_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-024-dovetail-aerospace/09_policies/071_policies_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-024-dovetail-aerospace/09_policies/072_policies_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-024-dovetail-aerospace/10_hr_records/073_hr_records_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-024-dovetail-aerospace/10_hr_records/074_hr_records_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-024-dovetail-aerospace/10_hr_records/075_hr_records_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-024-dovetail-aerospace/10_hr_records/076_hr_records_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-024-dovetail-aerospace/10_hr_records/077_hr_records_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-024-dovetail-aerospace/10_hr_records/078_hr_records_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-024-dovetail-aerospace/10_hr_records/079_hr_records_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-024-dovetail-aerospace/10_hr_records/080_hr_records_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-024-dovetail-aerospace/11_board_reporting/081_board_reporting_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-024-dovetail-aerospace/11_board_reporting/082_board_reporting_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-024-dovetail-aerospace/11_board_reporting/083_board_reporting_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-024-dovetail-aerospace/11_board_reporting/084_board_reporting_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-024-dovetail-aerospace/11_board_reporting/085_board_reporting_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-024-dovetail-aerospace/11_board_reporting/086_board_reporting_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-024-dovetail-aerospace/11_board_reporting/087_board_reporting_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-024-dovetail-aerospace/11_board_reporting/088_board_reporting_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-024-dovetail-aerospace/12_remediation/089_remediation_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-024-dovetail-aerospace/12_remediation/090_remediation_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-024-dovetail-aerospace/12_remediation/091_remediation_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-024-dovetail-aerospace/12_remediation/092_remediation_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-024-dovetail-aerospace/12_remediation/093_remediation_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-024-dovetail-aerospace/12_remediation/094_remediation_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-024-dovetail-aerospace/12_remediation/095_remediation_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-024-dovetail-aerospace/12_remediation/096_remediation_status_report.md"], "gold_output": {"advice_markdown": "# Counsel advice — Dovetail export-controls inquiry\n\n## Executive assessment\n\nFor Dovetail Aerospace Components matter CB-IV-2604, the review identified 16 source-supported exceptions requiring action before 2026-09-13. The assessment concerns Orion Bridge Consulting and the supplied record for Virginia.\n\n## Method and record coverage\n\nThe review inventoried all 96 production files, read the 33 controlling, corroborating, and control records, searched the email exports, and checked metadata for the designated chain-of-custody sample. Conclusions are limited to the synthetic production supplied for this benchmark matter.\n\n## Findings\n\n### F-01 — preservation delay (critical)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for preservation delay: one source states the operative date is 2025-09-08 under control reference CB-IV-2604-A888, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2025-09-15 under response reference CB-IV-2604-J576.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/01_intake/001_intake_control_register.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/07_access_logs/049_access_logs_control_register.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-13, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Leona Park.\n\n### F-02 — interview timeline conflict (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for interview timeline conflict: one source states the controlling amount is $7,271,053.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $7,298,606.00.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/01_intake/004_intake_ledger_export.csv`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/07_access_logs/052_access_logs_ledger_export.csv`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-13, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Isaac Romero.\n\n### F-03 — undisclosed related party (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for undisclosed related party: one source states approval is attributed to Elliot Mercer as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Theo Laurent and contains no entry for Elliot Mercer.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/01_intake/007_intake_officer_certificate.html`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/07_access_logs/055_access_logs_officer_certificate.html`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-13, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Sofia Bennett.\n\n### F-04 — split-purchase pattern (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for split-purchase pattern: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-IV-2604-D575, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-IV-2604-M967.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/02_preservation/010_preservation_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/08_vendor_files/058_vendor_files_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-13, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Adrian Mensah.\n\n### F-05 — approval override (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for approval override: one source states the applicable location is Fairfax County, Virginia, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to Virginia operations outside Fairfax County, Virginia.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/02_preservation/013_preservation_review_memorandum.json`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/08_vendor_files/061_vendor_files_review_memorandum.json`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-13, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Willa Novak.\n\n### F-06 — gift-policy threshold breach (low)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for gift-policy threshold breach: one source states the threshold is 14% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 20% and produced a different exception result.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/02_preservation/016_preservation_status_report.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/08_vendor_files/064_vendor_files_status_report.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-13, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Theo Laurent.\n\n### F-07 — off-channel communication (critical)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for off-channel communication: one source states formal notice must use notices-dovetail_aerospace_components@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-orion_bridge_consulting@example.test.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/03_interviews/019_interviews_correspondence.eml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/09_policies/067_policies_correspondence.eml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-13, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Amara Patel.\n\n### F-08 — deleted-message anomaly (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for deleted-message anomaly: one source states the governed population contains 93 records through 2025-02-17, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 53 records through 2025-03-14.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/03_interviews/022_interviews_formal_notice.xml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/09_policies/070_policies_formal_notice.xml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-13, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Henry Cho.\n\n### F-09 — badge-log inconsistency (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for badge-log inconsistency: one source states the operative date is 2026-02-13 under control reference CB-IV-2604-I326, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2026-03-24 under response reference CB-IV-2604-R671.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/04_email_exports/025_email_exports_control_register.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/10_hr_records/073_hr_records_control_register.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-13, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Nadine Flores.\n\n### F-10 — vendor due-diligence gap (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for vendor due-diligence gap: one source states the controlling amount is $2,854,559.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $3,015,618.00.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/04_email_exports/028_email_exports_ledger_export.csv`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/10_hr_records/076_hr_records_ledger_export.csv`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-13, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Micah Sullivan.\n\n### F-11 — retaliation concern (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for retaliation concern: one source states approval is attributed to Elliot Mercer as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Jonas Feld and contains no entry for Elliot Mercer.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/04_email_exports/031_email_exports_officer_certificate.html`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/10_hr_records/079_hr_records_officer_certificate.html`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-13, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Farah Ibrahim.\n\n### F-12 — policy training lapse (low)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for policy training lapse: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-IV-2604-L704, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-IV-2604-U700.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/034_chat_exports_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/11_board_reporting/082_board_reporting_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-13, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Owen Delgado.\n\n### F-13 — board-reporting omission (critical)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for board-reporting omission: one source states the applicable location is Fairfax County, Virginia, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to Virginia operations outside Fairfax County, Virginia.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/037_chat_exports_review_memorandum.json`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/11_board_reporting/085_board_reporting_review_memorandum.json`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-13, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Lena Varga.\n\n### F-14 — hotline classification error (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for hotline classification error: one source states the threshold is 8% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 14% and produced a different exception result.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/040_chat_exports_status_report.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/11_board_reporting/088_board_reporting_status_report.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-13, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Samuel Kim.\n\n### F-15 — expense support deficiency (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for expense support deficiency: one source states formal notice must use notices-dovetail_aerospace_components@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-orion_bridge_consulting@example.test.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/06_expenses/043_expenses_correspondence.eml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/12_remediation/091_remediation_correspondence.eml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-13, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Maya Ellison.\n\n### F-16 — remediation ownership gap (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for remediation ownership gap: one source states the governed population contains 49 records through 2025-10-11, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 44 records through 2025-10-27.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/06_expenses/046_expenses_formal_notice.xml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/12_remediation/094_remediation_formal_notice.xml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-13, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Rafael Okafor.\n\n## Recommended next actions\n\nSequence the critical and high findings first, assign the named owners, preserve the cited records, and document any resolution in the controlling matter register before the stated deadline.\n\n## Assumptions and limitations\n\nThis analysis is confined to task cb100-024-dovetail-aerospace and the supplied synthetic evidence. It does not rely on external facts, does not resolve disputed law, and is not legal advice for a real person or entity.\n", "findings": {"as_of": "2026-09-13", "findings": [{"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/07_access_logs/049_access_logs_control_register.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for preservation delay: one source states the operative date is 2025-09-08 under control reference CB-IV-2604-A888, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2025-09-15 under response reference CB-IV-2604-J576.", "id": "F-01", "issue": "preservation delay", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/01_intake/001_intake_control_register.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-13, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Leona Park.", "severity": "critical"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/07_access_logs/052_access_logs_ledger_export.csv", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for interview timeline conflict: one source states the controlling amount is $7,271,053.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $7,298,606.00.", "id": "F-02", "issue": "interview timeline conflict", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/01_intake/004_intake_ledger_export.csv", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-13, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Isaac Romero.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/07_access_logs/055_access_logs_officer_certificate.html", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for undisclosed related party: one source states approval is attributed to Elliot Mercer as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Theo Laurent and contains no entry for Elliot Mercer.", "id": "F-03", "issue": "undisclosed related party", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/01_intake/007_intake_officer_certificate.html", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-13, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Sofia Bennett.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/08_vendor_files/058_vendor_files_executed_instrument.txt", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for split-purchase pattern: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-IV-2604-D575, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-IV-2604-M967.", "id": "F-04", "issue": "split-purchase pattern", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/02_preservation/010_preservation_executed_instrument.txt", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-13, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Adrian Mensah.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/08_vendor_files/061_vendor_files_review_memorandum.json", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for approval override: one source states the applicable location is Fairfax County, Virginia, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to Virginia operations outside Fairfax County, Virginia.", "id": "F-05", "issue": "approval override", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/02_preservation/013_preservation_review_memorandum.json", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-13, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Willa Novak.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/08_vendor_files/064_vendor_files_status_report.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for gift-policy threshold breach: one source states the threshold is 14% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 20% and produced a different exception result.", "id": "F-06", "issue": "gift-policy threshold breach", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/02_preservation/016_preservation_status_report.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-13, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Theo Laurent.", "severity": "low"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/09_policies/067_policies_correspondence.eml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for off-channel communication: one source states formal notice must use notices-dovetail_aerospace_components@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-orion_bridge_consulting@example.test.", "id": "F-07", "issue": "off-channel communication", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/03_interviews/019_interviews_correspondence.eml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-13, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Amara Patel.", "severity": "critical"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/09_policies/070_policies_formal_notice.xml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for deleted-message anomaly: one source states the governed population contains 93 records through 2025-02-17, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 53 records through 2025-03-14.", "id": "F-08", "issue": "deleted-message anomaly", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/03_interviews/022_interviews_formal_notice.xml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-13, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Henry Cho.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/10_hr_records/073_hr_records_control_register.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for badge-log inconsistency: one source states the operative date is 2026-02-13 under control reference CB-IV-2604-I326, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2026-03-24 under response reference CB-IV-2604-R671.", "id": "F-09", "issue": "badge-log inconsistency", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/04_email_exports/025_email_exports_control_register.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-13, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Nadine Flores.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/10_hr_records/076_hr_records_ledger_export.csv", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for vendor due-diligence gap: one source states the controlling amount is $2,854,559.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $3,015,618.00.", "id": "F-10", "issue": "vendor due-diligence gap", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/04_email_exports/028_email_exports_ledger_export.csv", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-13, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Micah Sullivan.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/10_hr_records/079_hr_records_officer_certificate.html", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for retaliation concern: one source states approval is attributed to Elliot Mercer as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Jonas Feld and contains no entry for Elliot Mercer.", "id": "F-11", "issue": "retaliation concern", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/04_email_exports/031_email_exports_officer_certificate.html", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-13, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Farah Ibrahim.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/11_board_reporting/082_board_reporting_executed_instrument.txt", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for policy training lapse: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-IV-2604-L704, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-IV-2604-U700.", "id": "F-12", "issue": "policy training lapse", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/034_chat_exports_executed_instrument.txt", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-13, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Owen Delgado.", "severity": "low"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/11_board_reporting/085_board_reporting_review_memorandum.json", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for board-reporting omission: one source states the applicable location is Fairfax County, Virginia, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to Virginia operations outside Fairfax County, Virginia.", "id": "F-13", "issue": "board-reporting omission", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/037_chat_exports_review_memorandum.json", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-13, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Lena Varga.", "severity": "critical"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/11_board_reporting/088_board_reporting_status_report.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for hotline classification error: one source states the threshold is 8% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 14% and produced a different exception result.", "id": "F-14", "issue": "hotline classification error", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/040_chat_exports_status_report.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-13, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Samuel Kim.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/091_remediation_correspondence.eml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for expense support deficiency: one source states formal notice must use notices-dovetail_aerospace_components@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-orion_bridge_consulting@example.test.", "id": "F-15", "issue": "expense support deficiency", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/06_expenses/043_expenses_correspondence.eml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-13, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Maya Ellison.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/094_remediation_formal_notice.xml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for remediation ownership gap: one source states the governed population contains 49 records through 2025-10-11, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 44 records through 2025-10-27.", "id": "F-16", "issue": "remediation ownership gap", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/06_expenses/046_expenses_formal_notice.xml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-13, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Rafael Okafor.", "severity": "medium"}], "matter_number": "CB-IV-2604", "prepared_for": "Dovetail Aerospace Components", "schema_version": "1.0", "task_id": "cb100-024-dovetail-aerospace"}}, "metadata": {"benchmark": "CounselBench-100", "code_license": "Apache-2.0", "data_license": "CC-BY-4.0", "deadline": "2026-09-13", "document_count": 96, "jurisdiction": "Virginia", "matter_number": "CB-IV-2604", "mcp_commit": "9a96ea6e5913736f92b88345bf51caeaaa8e719f", "mcp_package": "@modelcontextprotocol/server-filesystem@2026.7.10", "practice_area": "internal-investigations", "reference_tool_calls": 46, "required_evidence_reads": 33, "synthetic": true, "venue": "Fairfax County, Virginia", "version": "2.0.0"}, "prompt": "You are independent investigations counsel for Dovetail Aerospace Components. Several workstreams have maintained separate versions of the truth; your assignment is to produce one auditable legal view. Engineering files may have been shared with an overseas consultant before screening, and preservation began after an account was deactivated. Decision due 2026-09-13. Virginia law governs; Fairfax County, Virginia is the forum. Distinguish a missing document from an affirmative contradiction in the documents that are present. Work out the defensible position from the matter production and leave an audit-ready exception tracker and concise advice for the supervising lawyer. Keep confirmed conflicts separate from open questions, cite the records that actually control each conclusion, and do not fill gaps with outside facts.", "rubric": {"criteria": [{"category": "procedure", "description": "Complete at least 46 successful, argument-specific evidence and output calls.", "id": "procedure.minimum_successful_tool_calls"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Find and read the 33 controlling, corroborating, and work-product-control records in full.", "id": "procedure.all_evidence_read_in_full"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Inspect file metadata for the eight designated critical primary records before relying on them.", "id": "procedure.chain_of_custody_metadata_checked"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Confirm the sandbox's allowed document and output roots.", "id": "procedure.allowed_directories_checked"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Inventory all 96 records so the relevant sources are discovered among the context records.", "id": "procedure.recursive_inventory_completed"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Search the production for email evidence that may corroborate or contradict formal records.", "id": "procedure.targeted_search_completed"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Leave only findings.json and advice.md in the output workspace.", "id": "procedure.exact_deliverable_set"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Create both final work products through the sandbox MCP surface.", "id": "procedure.deliverables_written_through_mcp"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Produce findings.json as a valid JSON object.", "id": "findings.findings_is_object"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Report exactly 16 confirmed exceptions.", "id": "findings.findings_exact_count"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Use each stable finding ID exactly once.", "id": "findings.finding_ids_unique"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set schema_version to the released matter value '1.0'.", "id": "findings.top_level_schema_version"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set task_id to the released matter value 'cb100-024-dovetail-aerospace'.", "id": "findings.top_level_task_id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set matter_number to the released matter value 'CB-IV-2604'.", "id": "findings.top_level_matter_number"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set prepared_for to the released matter value 'Dovetail Aerospace Components'.", "id": "findings.top_level_prepared_for"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set as_of to the released matter value '2026-09-13'.", "id": "findings.top_level_as_of"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-01 exception for preservation delay.", "id": "findings.F-01.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's id from /workspace/documents/01_intake/001_intake_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_access_logs/049_access_logs_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's issue from /workspace/documents/01_intake/001_intake_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_access_logs/049_access_logs_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's severity from /workspace/documents/01_intake/001_intake_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_access_logs/049_access_logs_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's primary_source from /workspace/documents/01_intake/001_intake_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_access_logs/049_access_logs_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/01_intake/001_intake_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_access_logs/049_access_logs_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-01 using the exact controlled facts ['2025-09-08', 'CB-IV-2604-A888', '2025-09-15', 'CB-IV-2604-J576'].", "id": "findings.F-01.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-01's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-01.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-13', 'Leona Park'] for F-01.", "id": "findings.F-01.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-02 exception for interview timeline conflict.", "id": "findings.F-02.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's id from /workspace/documents/01_intake/004_intake_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_access_logs/052_access_logs_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's issue from /workspace/documents/01_intake/004_intake_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_access_logs/052_access_logs_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's severity from /workspace/documents/01_intake/004_intake_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_access_logs/052_access_logs_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's primary_source from /workspace/documents/01_intake/004_intake_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_access_logs/052_access_logs_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/01_intake/004_intake_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_access_logs/052_access_logs_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-02 using the exact controlled facts ['$7,271,053.00', '$7,298,606.00'].", "id": "findings.F-02.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-02's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-02.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-13', 'Isaac Romero'] for F-02.", "id": "findings.F-02.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-03 exception for undisclosed related party.", "id": "findings.F-03.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's id from /workspace/documents/01_intake/007_intake_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_access_logs/055_access_logs_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's issue from /workspace/documents/01_intake/007_intake_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_access_logs/055_access_logs_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's severity from /workspace/documents/01_intake/007_intake_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_access_logs/055_access_logs_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's primary_source from /workspace/documents/01_intake/007_intake_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_access_logs/055_access_logs_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/01_intake/007_intake_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_access_logs/055_access_logs_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-03 using the exact controlled facts ['Elliot Mercer', 'Theo Laurent'].", "id": "findings.F-03.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-03's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-03.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-13', 'Sofia Bennett'] for F-03.", "id": "findings.F-03.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-04 exception for split-purchase pattern.", "id": "findings.F-04.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's id from /workspace/documents/02_preservation/010_preservation_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_vendor_files/058_vendor_files_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's issue from /workspace/documents/02_preservation/010_preservation_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_vendor_files/058_vendor_files_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's severity from /workspace/documents/02_preservation/010_preservation_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_vendor_files/058_vendor_files_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's primary_source from /workspace/documents/02_preservation/010_preservation_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_vendor_files/058_vendor_files_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/02_preservation/010_preservation_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_vendor_files/058_vendor_files_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-04 using the exact controlled facts ['closed without exception', 'CB-IV-2604-D575', 'open and escalated', 'CB-IV-2604-M967'].", "id": "findings.F-04.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-04's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-04.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-13', 'Adrian Mensah'] for F-04.", "id": "findings.F-04.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-05 exception for approval override.", "id": "findings.F-05.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's id from /workspace/documents/02_preservation/013_preservation_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_vendor_files/061_vendor_files_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's issue from /workspace/documents/02_preservation/013_preservation_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_vendor_files/061_vendor_files_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's severity from /workspace/documents/02_preservation/013_preservation_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_vendor_files/061_vendor_files_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's primary_source from /workspace/documents/02_preservation/013_preservation_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_vendor_files/061_vendor_files_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/02_preservation/013_preservation_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_vendor_files/061_vendor_files_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-05 using the exact controlled facts ['Fairfax County, Virginia', 'Virginia'].", "id": "findings.F-05.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-05's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-05.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-13', 'Willa Novak'] for F-05.", "id": "findings.F-05.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-06 exception for gift-policy threshold breach.", "id": "findings.F-06.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's id from /workspace/documents/02_preservation/016_preservation_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_vendor_files/064_vendor_files_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's issue from /workspace/documents/02_preservation/016_preservation_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_vendor_files/064_vendor_files_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's severity from /workspace/documents/02_preservation/016_preservation_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_vendor_files/064_vendor_files_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's primary_source from /workspace/documents/02_preservation/016_preservation_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_vendor_files/064_vendor_files_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/02_preservation/016_preservation_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_vendor_files/064_vendor_files_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-06 using the exact controlled facts ['14%', '20%'].", "id": "findings.F-06.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-06's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-06.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-13', 'Theo Laurent'] for F-06.", "id": "findings.F-06.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-07 exception for off-channel communication.", "id": "findings.F-07.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's id from /workspace/documents/03_interviews/019_interviews_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_policies/067_policies_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's issue from /workspace/documents/03_interviews/019_interviews_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_policies/067_policies_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's severity from /workspace/documents/03_interviews/019_interviews_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_policies/067_policies_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's primary_source from /workspace/documents/03_interviews/019_interviews_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_policies/067_policies_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/03_interviews/019_interviews_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_policies/067_policies_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-07 using the exact controlled facts ['notices-dovetail_aerospace_components@example.test', 'archive-orion_bridge_consulting@example.test'].", "id": "findings.F-07.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-07's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-07.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-13', 'Amara Patel'] for F-07.", "id": "findings.F-07.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-08 exception for deleted-message anomaly.", "id": "findings.F-08.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's id from /workspace/documents/03_interviews/022_interviews_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_policies/070_policies_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's issue from /workspace/documents/03_interviews/022_interviews_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_policies/070_policies_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's severity from /workspace/documents/03_interviews/022_interviews_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_policies/070_policies_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's primary_source from /workspace/documents/03_interviews/022_interviews_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_policies/070_policies_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/03_interviews/022_interviews_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_policies/070_policies_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-08 using the exact controlled facts ['93 records', '2025-02-17', '53 records', '2025-03-14'].", "id": "findings.F-08.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-08's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-08.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-13', 'Henry Cho'] for F-08.", "id": "findings.F-08.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-09 exception for badge-log inconsistency.", "id": "findings.F-09.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's id from /workspace/documents/04_email_exports/025_email_exports_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_hr_records/073_hr_records_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's issue from /workspace/documents/04_email_exports/025_email_exports_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_hr_records/073_hr_records_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's severity from /workspace/documents/04_email_exports/025_email_exports_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_hr_records/073_hr_records_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's primary_source from /workspace/documents/04_email_exports/025_email_exports_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_hr_records/073_hr_records_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/04_email_exports/025_email_exports_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_hr_records/073_hr_records_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-09 using the exact controlled facts ['2026-02-13', 'CB-IV-2604-I326', '2026-03-24', 'CB-IV-2604-R671'].", "id": "findings.F-09.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-09's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-09.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-13', 'Nadine Flores'] for F-09.", "id": "findings.F-09.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-10 exception for vendor due-diligence gap.", "id": "findings.F-10.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's id from /workspace/documents/04_email_exports/028_email_exports_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_hr_records/076_hr_records_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's issue from /workspace/documents/04_email_exports/028_email_exports_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_hr_records/076_hr_records_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's severity from /workspace/documents/04_email_exports/028_email_exports_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_hr_records/076_hr_records_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's primary_source from /workspace/documents/04_email_exports/028_email_exports_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_hr_records/076_hr_records_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/04_email_exports/028_email_exports_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_hr_records/076_hr_records_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-10 using the exact controlled facts ['$2,854,559.00', '$3,015,618.00'].", "id": "findings.F-10.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-10's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-10.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-13', 'Micah Sullivan'] for F-10.", "id": "findings.F-10.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-11 exception for retaliation concern.", "id": "findings.F-11.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's id from /workspace/documents/04_email_exports/031_email_exports_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_hr_records/079_hr_records_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's issue from /workspace/documents/04_email_exports/031_email_exports_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_hr_records/079_hr_records_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's severity from /workspace/documents/04_email_exports/031_email_exports_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_hr_records/079_hr_records_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's primary_source from /workspace/documents/04_email_exports/031_email_exports_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_hr_records/079_hr_records_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/04_email_exports/031_email_exports_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_hr_records/079_hr_records_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-11 using the exact controlled facts ['Elliot Mercer', 'Jonas Feld'].", "id": "findings.F-11.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-11's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-11.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-13', 'Farah Ibrahim'] for F-11.", "id": "findings.F-11.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-12 exception for policy training lapse.", "id": "findings.F-12.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's id from /workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/034_chat_exports_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_board_reporting/082_board_reporting_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's issue from /workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/034_chat_exports_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_board_reporting/082_board_reporting_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's severity from /workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/034_chat_exports_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_board_reporting/082_board_reporting_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's primary_source from /workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/034_chat_exports_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_board_reporting/082_board_reporting_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/034_chat_exports_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_board_reporting/082_board_reporting_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-12 using the exact controlled facts ['closed without exception', 'CB-IV-2604-L704', 'open and escalated', 'CB-IV-2604-U700'].", "id": "findings.F-12.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-12's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-12.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-13', 'Owen Delgado'] for F-12.", "id": "findings.F-12.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-13 exception for board-reporting omission.", "id": "findings.F-13.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's id from /workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/037_chat_exports_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_board_reporting/085_board_reporting_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's issue from /workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/037_chat_exports_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_board_reporting/085_board_reporting_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's severity from /workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/037_chat_exports_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_board_reporting/085_board_reporting_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's primary_source from /workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/037_chat_exports_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_board_reporting/085_board_reporting_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/037_chat_exports_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_board_reporting/085_board_reporting_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-13 using the exact controlled facts ['Fairfax County, Virginia', 'Virginia'].", "id": "findings.F-13.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-13's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-13.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-13', 'Lena Varga'] for F-13.", "id": "findings.F-13.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-14 exception for hotline classification error.", "id": "findings.F-14.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's id from /workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/040_chat_exports_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_board_reporting/088_board_reporting_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's issue from /workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/040_chat_exports_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_board_reporting/088_board_reporting_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's severity from /workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/040_chat_exports_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_board_reporting/088_board_reporting_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's primary_source from /workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/040_chat_exports_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_board_reporting/088_board_reporting_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/040_chat_exports_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_board_reporting/088_board_reporting_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-14 using the exact controlled facts ['8%', '14%'].", "id": "findings.F-14.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-14's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-14.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-13', 'Samuel Kim'] for F-14.", "id": "findings.F-14.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-15 exception for expense support deficiency.", "id": "findings.F-15.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's id from /workspace/documents/06_expenses/043_expenses_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_remediation/091_remediation_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's issue from /workspace/documents/06_expenses/043_expenses_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_remediation/091_remediation_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's severity from /workspace/documents/06_expenses/043_expenses_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_remediation/091_remediation_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's primary_source from /workspace/documents/06_expenses/043_expenses_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_remediation/091_remediation_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/06_expenses/043_expenses_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_remediation/091_remediation_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-15 using the exact controlled facts ['notices-dovetail_aerospace_components@example.test', 'archive-orion_bridge_consulting@example.test'].", "id": "findings.F-15.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-15's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-15.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-13', 'Maya Ellison'] for F-15.", "id": "findings.F-15.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-16 exception for remediation ownership gap.", "id": "findings.F-16.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's id from /workspace/documents/06_expenses/046_expenses_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_remediation/094_remediation_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's issue from /workspace/documents/06_expenses/046_expenses_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_remediation/094_remediation_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's severity from /workspace/documents/06_expenses/046_expenses_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_remediation/094_remediation_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's primary_source from /workspace/documents/06_expenses/046_expenses_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_remediation/094_remediation_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/06_expenses/046_expenses_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_remediation/094_remediation_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-16 using the exact controlled facts ['49 records', '2025-10-11', '44 records', '2025-10-27'].", "id": "findings.F-16.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-16's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-16.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-13', 'Rafael Okafor'] for F-16.", "id": "findings.F-16.action_anchors"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Executive assessment' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Executive assessment"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Method and record coverage' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Method and record coverage"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Findings' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Findings"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Recommended next actions' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Recommended next actions"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Assumptions and limitations' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Assumptions and limitations"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-01 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-01"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-02 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-02"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-03 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-03"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-04 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-04"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-05 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-05"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-06 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-06"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-07 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-07"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-08 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-08"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-09 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-09"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-10 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-10"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-11 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-11"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-12 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-12"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-13 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-13"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-14 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-14"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-15 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-15"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-16 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-16"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Do not claim the production has no issues or that every record is consistent.", "id": "memo.forbidden_claims_absent"}], "decision_options": [{"id": "cross-source-reconciliation", "label": "Reconcile controlling and corroborating records", "reason": "The CB-IV-2604 production contains independently maintained records; a defensible answer must preserve each supported conflict and its cure owner.", "selected": true}, {"id": "latest-record-controls", "label": "Treat the latest record as controlling", "reason": "Timestamp recency does not establish legal priority, execution, or approval authority.", "selected": false}, {"id": "primary-records-only", "label": "Report primary records without reconciliation", "reason": "Primary records alone conceal the operational conflicts that create the actionable exceptions.", "selected": false}], "gates": ["all_evidence_read_in_full", "chain_of_custody_metadata_checked", "findings_criteria_complete", "memo_criteria_complete", "deliverables_written_through_mcp"], "metadata_checks": 8, "metric": "weighted_criteria_score", "minimum_tool_calls": 46, "required_deliverables": ["findings.json", "advice.md"], "required_document_reads": 33, "type": "deterministic", "weights": {"findings": 0.55, "memo": 0.2, "procedure": 0.25}}, "task_id": "cb100-024-dovetail-aerospace", "task_name": "Dovetail export-controls inquiry", "world_id": "counselbench-filesystem-mcp-v2"}
-{"context_files": ["task_files/cb100-025-evergreen-charter/01_intake/001_intake_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-025-evergreen-charter/01_intake/002_intake_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-025-evergreen-charter/01_intake/003_intake_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-025-evergreen-charter/01_intake/004_intake_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-025-evergreen-charter/01_intake/005_intake_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-025-evergreen-charter/01_intake/006_intake_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-025-evergreen-charter/01_intake/007_intake_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-025-evergreen-charter/01_intake/008_intake_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-025-evergreen-charter/02_preservation/009_preservation_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-025-evergreen-charter/02_preservation/010_preservation_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-025-evergreen-charter/02_preservation/011_preservation_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-025-evergreen-charter/02_preservation/012_preservation_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-025-evergreen-charter/02_preservation/013_preservation_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-025-evergreen-charter/02_preservation/014_preservation_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-025-evergreen-charter/02_preservation/015_preservation_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-025-evergreen-charter/02_preservation/016_preservation_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-025-evergreen-charter/03_interviews/017_interviews_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-025-evergreen-charter/03_interviews/018_interviews_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-025-evergreen-charter/03_interviews/019_interviews_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-025-evergreen-charter/03_interviews/020_interviews_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-025-evergreen-charter/03_interviews/021_interviews_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-025-evergreen-charter/03_interviews/022_interviews_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-025-evergreen-charter/03_interviews/023_interviews_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-025-evergreen-charter/03_interviews/024_interviews_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-025-evergreen-charter/04_email_exports/025_email_exports_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-025-evergreen-charter/04_email_exports/026_email_exports_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-025-evergreen-charter/04_email_exports/027_email_exports_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-025-evergreen-charter/04_email_exports/028_email_exports_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-025-evergreen-charter/04_email_exports/029_email_exports_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-025-evergreen-charter/04_email_exports/030_email_exports_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-025-evergreen-charter/04_email_exports/031_email_exports_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-025-evergreen-charter/04_email_exports/032_email_exports_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-025-evergreen-charter/05_chat_exports/033_chat_exports_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-025-evergreen-charter/05_chat_exports/034_chat_exports_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-025-evergreen-charter/05_chat_exports/035_chat_exports_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-025-evergreen-charter/05_chat_exports/036_chat_exports_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-025-evergreen-charter/05_chat_exports/037_chat_exports_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-025-evergreen-charter/05_chat_exports/038_chat_exports_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-025-evergreen-charter/05_chat_exports/039_chat_exports_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-025-evergreen-charter/05_chat_exports/040_chat_exports_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-025-evergreen-charter/06_expenses/041_expenses_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-025-evergreen-charter/06_expenses/042_expenses_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-025-evergreen-charter/06_expenses/043_expenses_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-025-evergreen-charter/06_expenses/044_expenses_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-025-evergreen-charter/06_expenses/045_expenses_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-025-evergreen-charter/06_expenses/046_expenses_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-025-evergreen-charter/06_expenses/047_expenses_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-025-evergreen-charter/06_expenses/048_expenses_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-025-evergreen-charter/07_access_logs/049_access_logs_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-025-evergreen-charter/07_access_logs/050_access_logs_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-025-evergreen-charter/07_access_logs/051_access_logs_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-025-evergreen-charter/07_access_logs/052_access_logs_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-025-evergreen-charter/07_access_logs/053_access_logs_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-025-evergreen-charter/07_access_logs/054_access_logs_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-025-evergreen-charter/07_access_logs/055_access_logs_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-025-evergreen-charter/07_access_logs/056_access_logs_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-025-evergreen-charter/08_vendor_files/057_vendor_files_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-025-evergreen-charter/08_vendor_files/058_vendor_files_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-025-evergreen-charter/08_vendor_files/059_vendor_files_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-025-evergreen-charter/08_vendor_files/060_vendor_files_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-025-evergreen-charter/08_vendor_files/061_vendor_files_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-025-evergreen-charter/08_vendor_files/062_vendor_files_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-025-evergreen-charter/08_vendor_files/063_vendor_files_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-025-evergreen-charter/08_vendor_files/064_vendor_files_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-025-evergreen-charter/09_policies/065_policies_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-025-evergreen-charter/09_policies/066_policies_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-025-evergreen-charter/09_policies/067_policies_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-025-evergreen-charter/09_policies/068_policies_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-025-evergreen-charter/09_policies/069_policies_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-025-evergreen-charter/09_policies/070_policies_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-025-evergreen-charter/09_policies/071_policies_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-025-evergreen-charter/09_policies/072_policies_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-025-evergreen-charter/10_hr_records/073_hr_records_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-025-evergreen-charter/10_hr_records/074_hr_records_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-025-evergreen-charter/10_hr_records/075_hr_records_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-025-evergreen-charter/10_hr_records/076_hr_records_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-025-evergreen-charter/10_hr_records/077_hr_records_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-025-evergreen-charter/10_hr_records/078_hr_records_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-025-evergreen-charter/10_hr_records/079_hr_records_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-025-evergreen-charter/10_hr_records/080_hr_records_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-025-evergreen-charter/11_board_reporting/081_board_reporting_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-025-evergreen-charter/11_board_reporting/082_board_reporting_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-025-evergreen-charter/11_board_reporting/083_board_reporting_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-025-evergreen-charter/11_board_reporting/084_board_reporting_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-025-evergreen-charter/11_board_reporting/085_board_reporting_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-025-evergreen-charter/11_board_reporting/086_board_reporting_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-025-evergreen-charter/11_board_reporting/087_board_reporting_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-025-evergreen-charter/11_board_reporting/088_board_reporting_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-025-evergreen-charter/12_remediation/089_remediation_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-025-evergreen-charter/12_remediation/090_remediation_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-025-evergreen-charter/12_remediation/091_remediation_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-025-evergreen-charter/12_remediation/092_remediation_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-025-evergreen-charter/12_remediation/093_remediation_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-025-evergreen-charter/12_remediation/094_remediation_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-025-evergreen-charter/12_remediation/095_remediation_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-025-evergreen-charter/12_remediation/096_remediation_status_report.md"], "gold_output": {"advice_markdown": "# Counsel advice — Evergreen enrollment complaint review\n\n## Executive assessment\n\nFor Evergreen Charter Network matter CB-IV-2605, the review identified 16 source-supported exceptions requiring action before 2026-09-16. The assessment concerns Summit Enrollment Advisors and the supplied record for Oregon.\n\n## Method and record coverage\n\nThe review inventoried all 96 production files, read the 33 controlling, corroborating, and control records, searched the email exports, and checked metadata for the designated chain-of-custody sample. Conclusions are limited to the synthetic production supplied for this benchmark matter.\n\n## Findings\n\n### F-01 — preservation delay (critical)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for preservation delay: one source states the operative date is 2025-12-22 under control reference CB-IV-2605-A693, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2026-01-09 under response reference CB-IV-2605-J284.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/01_intake/001_intake_control_register.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/07_access_logs/049_access_logs_control_register.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-16, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Isaac Romero.\n\n### F-02 — interview timeline conflict (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for interview timeline conflict: one source states the controlling amount is $274,788.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $396,076.00.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/01_intake/004_intake_ledger_export.csv`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/07_access_logs/052_access_logs_ledger_export.csv`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-16, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Sofia Bennett.\n\n### F-03 — undisclosed related party (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for undisclosed related party: one source states approval is attributed to Talia Brooks as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Henry Cho and contains no entry for Talia Brooks.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/01_intake/007_intake_officer_certificate.html`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/07_access_logs/055_access_logs_officer_certificate.html`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-16, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Adrian Mensah.\n\n### F-04 — split-purchase pattern (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for split-purchase pattern: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-IV-2605-D705, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-IV-2605-M908.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/02_preservation/010_preservation_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/08_vendor_files/058_vendor_files_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-16, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Willa Novak.\n\n### F-05 — approval override (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for approval override: one source states the applicable location is Multnomah County, Oregon, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to Oregon operations outside Multnomah County, Oregon.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/02_preservation/013_preservation_review_memorandum.json`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/08_vendor_files/061_vendor_files_review_memorandum.json`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-16, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Theo Laurent.\n\n### F-06 — gift-policy threshold breach (low)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for gift-policy threshold breach: one source states the threshold is 7% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 12% and produced a different exception result.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/02_preservation/016_preservation_status_report.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/08_vendor_files/064_vendor_files_status_report.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-16, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Amara Patel.\n\n### F-07 — off-channel communication (critical)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for off-channel communication: one source states formal notice must use notices-evergreen_charter_network@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-summit_enrollment_advisors@example.test.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/03_interviews/019_interviews_correspondence.eml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/09_policies/067_policies_correspondence.eml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-16, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Henry Cho.\n\n### F-08 — deleted-message anomaly (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for deleted-message anomaly: one source states the governed population contains 119 records through 2025-03-15, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 42 records through 2025-03-29.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/03_interviews/022_interviews_formal_notice.xml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/09_policies/070_policies_formal_notice.xml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-16, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Nadine Flores.\n\n### F-09 — badge-log inconsistency (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for badge-log inconsistency: one source states the operative date is 2025-05-28 under control reference CB-IV-2605-I605, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2025-06-08 under response reference CB-IV-2605-R900.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/04_email_exports/025_email_exports_control_register.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/10_hr_records/073_hr_records_control_register.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-16, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Micah Sullivan.\n\n### F-10 — vendor due-diligence gap (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for vendor due-diligence gap: one source states the controlling amount is $3,484,082.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $3,534,664.00.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/04_email_exports/028_email_exports_ledger_export.csv`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/10_hr_records/076_hr_records_ledger_export.csv`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-16, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Farah Ibrahim.\n\n### F-11 — retaliation concern (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for retaliation concern: one source states approval is attributed to Talia Brooks as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Caleb Hassan and contains no entry for Talia Brooks.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/04_email_exports/031_email_exports_officer_certificate.html`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/10_hr_records/079_hr_records_officer_certificate.html`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-16, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Owen Delgado.\n\n### F-12 — policy training lapse (low)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for policy training lapse: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-IV-2605-L855, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-IV-2605-U642.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/034_chat_exports_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/11_board_reporting/082_board_reporting_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-16, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Lena Varga.\n\n### F-13 — board-reporting omission (critical)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for board-reporting omission: one source states the applicable location is Multnomah County, Oregon, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to Oregon operations outside Multnomah County, Oregon.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/037_chat_exports_review_memorandum.json`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/11_board_reporting/085_board_reporting_review_memorandum.json`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-16, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Samuel Kim.\n\n### F-14 — hotline classification error (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for hotline classification error: one source states the threshold is 9% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 14% and produced a different exception result.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/040_chat_exports_status_report.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/11_board_reporting/088_board_reporting_status_report.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-16, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Maya Ellison.\n\n### F-15 — expense support deficiency (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for expense support deficiency: one source states formal notice must use notices-evergreen_charter_network@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-summit_enrollment_advisors@example.test.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/06_expenses/043_expenses_correspondence.eml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/12_remediation/091_remediation_correspondence.eml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-16, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Rafael Okafor.\n\n### F-16 — remediation ownership gap (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for remediation ownership gap: one source states the governed population contains 88 records through 2025-07-02, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 38 records through 2025-07-12.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/06_expenses/046_expenses_formal_notice.xml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/12_remediation/094_remediation_formal_notice.xml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-16, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Nora Chen.\n\n## Recommended next actions\n\nSequence the critical and high findings first, assign the named owners, preserve the cited records, and document any resolution in the controlling matter register before the stated deadline.\n\n## Assumptions and limitations\n\nThis analysis is confined to task cb100-025-evergreen-charter and the supplied synthetic evidence. It does not rely on external facts, does not resolve disputed law, and is not legal advice for a real person or entity.\n", "findings": {"as_of": "2026-09-16", "findings": [{"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/07_access_logs/049_access_logs_control_register.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for preservation delay: one source states the operative date is 2025-12-22 under control reference CB-IV-2605-A693, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2026-01-09 under response reference CB-IV-2605-J284.", "id": "F-01", "issue": "preservation delay", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/01_intake/001_intake_control_register.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-16, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Isaac Romero.", "severity": "critical"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/07_access_logs/052_access_logs_ledger_export.csv", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for interview timeline conflict: one source states the controlling amount is $274,788.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $396,076.00.", "id": "F-02", "issue": "interview timeline conflict", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/01_intake/004_intake_ledger_export.csv", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-16, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Sofia Bennett.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/07_access_logs/055_access_logs_officer_certificate.html", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for undisclosed related party: one source states approval is attributed to Talia Brooks as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Henry Cho and contains no entry for Talia Brooks.", "id": "F-03", "issue": "undisclosed related party", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/01_intake/007_intake_officer_certificate.html", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-16, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Adrian Mensah.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/08_vendor_files/058_vendor_files_executed_instrument.txt", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for split-purchase pattern: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-IV-2605-D705, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-IV-2605-M908.", "id": "F-04", "issue": "split-purchase pattern", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/02_preservation/010_preservation_executed_instrument.txt", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-16, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Willa Novak.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/08_vendor_files/061_vendor_files_review_memorandum.json", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for approval override: one source states the applicable location is Multnomah County, Oregon, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to Oregon operations outside Multnomah County, Oregon.", "id": "F-05", "issue": "approval override", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/02_preservation/013_preservation_review_memorandum.json", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-16, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Theo Laurent.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/08_vendor_files/064_vendor_files_status_report.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for gift-policy threshold breach: one source states the threshold is 7% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 12% and produced a different exception result.", "id": "F-06", "issue": "gift-policy threshold breach", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/02_preservation/016_preservation_status_report.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-16, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Amara Patel.", "severity": "low"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/09_policies/067_policies_correspondence.eml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for off-channel communication: one source states formal notice must use notices-evergreen_charter_network@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-summit_enrollment_advisors@example.test.", "id": "F-07", "issue": "off-channel communication", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/03_interviews/019_interviews_correspondence.eml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-16, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Henry Cho.", "severity": "critical"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/09_policies/070_policies_formal_notice.xml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for deleted-message anomaly: one source states the governed population contains 119 records through 2025-03-15, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 42 records through 2025-03-29.", "id": "F-08", "issue": "deleted-message anomaly", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/03_interviews/022_interviews_formal_notice.xml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-16, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Nadine Flores.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/10_hr_records/073_hr_records_control_register.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for badge-log inconsistency: one source states the operative date is 2025-05-28 under control reference CB-IV-2605-I605, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2025-06-08 under response reference CB-IV-2605-R900.", "id": "F-09", "issue": "badge-log inconsistency", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/04_email_exports/025_email_exports_control_register.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-16, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Micah Sullivan.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/10_hr_records/076_hr_records_ledger_export.csv", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for vendor due-diligence gap: one source states the controlling amount is $3,484,082.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $3,534,664.00.", "id": "F-10", "issue": "vendor due-diligence gap", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/04_email_exports/028_email_exports_ledger_export.csv", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-16, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Farah Ibrahim.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/10_hr_records/079_hr_records_officer_certificate.html", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for retaliation concern: one source states approval is attributed to Talia Brooks as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Caleb Hassan and contains no entry for Talia Brooks.", "id": "F-11", "issue": "retaliation concern", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/04_email_exports/031_email_exports_officer_certificate.html", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-16, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Owen Delgado.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/11_board_reporting/082_board_reporting_executed_instrument.txt", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for policy training lapse: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-IV-2605-L855, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-IV-2605-U642.", "id": "F-12", "issue": "policy training lapse", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/034_chat_exports_executed_instrument.txt", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-16, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Lena Varga.", "severity": "low"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/11_board_reporting/085_board_reporting_review_memorandum.json", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for board-reporting omission: one source states the applicable location is Multnomah County, Oregon, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to Oregon operations outside Multnomah County, Oregon.", "id": "F-13", "issue": "board-reporting omission", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/037_chat_exports_review_memorandum.json", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-16, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Samuel Kim.", "severity": "critical"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/11_board_reporting/088_board_reporting_status_report.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for hotline classification error: one source states the threshold is 9% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 14% and produced a different exception result.", "id": "F-14", "issue": "hotline classification error", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/040_chat_exports_status_report.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-16, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Maya Ellison.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/091_remediation_correspondence.eml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for expense support deficiency: one source states formal notice must use notices-evergreen_charter_network@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-summit_enrollment_advisors@example.test.", "id": "F-15", "issue": "expense support deficiency", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/06_expenses/043_expenses_correspondence.eml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-16, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Rafael Okafor.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/094_remediation_formal_notice.xml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for remediation ownership gap: one source states the governed population contains 88 records through 2025-07-02, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 38 records through 2025-07-12.", "id": "F-16", "issue": "remediation ownership gap", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/06_expenses/046_expenses_formal_notice.xml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-16, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Nora Chen.", "severity": "medium"}], "matter_number": "CB-IV-2605", "prepared_for": "Evergreen Charter Network", "schema_version": "1.0", "task_id": "cb100-025-evergreen-charter"}}, "metadata": {"benchmark": "CounselBench-100", "code_license": "Apache-2.0", "data_license": "CC-BY-4.0", "deadline": "2026-09-16", "document_count": 96, "jurisdiction": "Oregon", "matter_number": "CB-IV-2605", "mcp_commit": "9a96ea6e5913736f92b88345bf51caeaaa8e719f", "mcp_package": "@modelcontextprotocol/server-filesystem@2026.7.10", "practice_area": "internal-investigations", "reference_tool_calls": 46, "required_evidence_reads": 33, "synthetic": true, "venue": "Multnomah County, Oregon", "version": "2.0.0"}, "prompt": "You are independent investigations counsel for Evergreen Charter Network. Outside counsel inherited this file after turnover on the client team and must validate every operative record before advising. A complaint alleges manipulated wait-list entries, consultant gifts, and retaliation against the registrar who questioned manual overrides. Decision due 2026-09-16. Oregon law governs; Multnomah County, Oregon is the forum. Evaluate both legal consequence and the practical owner needed to cure each exception. Work out the defensible position from the matter production and leave an audit-ready exception tracker and concise advice for the supervising lawyer. Keep confirmed conflicts separate from open questions, cite the records that actually control each conclusion, and do not fill gaps with outside facts.", "rubric": {"criteria": [{"category": "procedure", "description": "Complete at least 46 successful, argument-specific evidence and output calls.", "id": "procedure.minimum_successful_tool_calls"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Find and read the 33 controlling, corroborating, and work-product-control records in full.", "id": "procedure.all_evidence_read_in_full"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Inspect file metadata for the eight designated critical primary records before relying on them.", "id": "procedure.chain_of_custody_metadata_checked"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Confirm the sandbox's allowed document and output roots.", "id": "procedure.allowed_directories_checked"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Inventory all 96 records so the relevant sources are discovered among the context records.", "id": "procedure.recursive_inventory_completed"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Search the production for email evidence that may corroborate or contradict formal records.", "id": "procedure.targeted_search_completed"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Leave only findings.json and advice.md in the output workspace.", "id": "procedure.exact_deliverable_set"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Create both final work products through the sandbox MCP surface.", "id": "procedure.deliverables_written_through_mcp"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Produce findings.json as a valid JSON object.", "id": "findings.findings_is_object"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Report exactly 16 confirmed exceptions.", "id": "findings.findings_exact_count"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Use each stable finding ID exactly once.", "id": "findings.finding_ids_unique"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set schema_version to the released matter value '1.0'.", "id": "findings.top_level_schema_version"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set task_id to the released matter value 'cb100-025-evergreen-charter'.", "id": "findings.top_level_task_id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set matter_number to the released matter value 'CB-IV-2605'.", "id": "findings.top_level_matter_number"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set prepared_for to the released matter value 'Evergreen Charter Network'.", "id": "findings.top_level_prepared_for"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set as_of to the released matter value '2026-09-16'.", "id": "findings.top_level_as_of"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-01 exception for preservation delay.", "id": "findings.F-01.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's id from /workspace/documents/01_intake/001_intake_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_access_logs/049_access_logs_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's issue from /workspace/documents/01_intake/001_intake_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_access_logs/049_access_logs_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's severity from /workspace/documents/01_intake/001_intake_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_access_logs/049_access_logs_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's primary_source from /workspace/documents/01_intake/001_intake_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_access_logs/049_access_logs_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/01_intake/001_intake_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_access_logs/049_access_logs_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-01 using the exact controlled facts ['2025-12-22', 'CB-IV-2605-A693', '2026-01-09', 'CB-IV-2605-J284'].", "id": "findings.F-01.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-01's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-01.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-16', 'Isaac Romero'] for F-01.", "id": "findings.F-01.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-02 exception for interview timeline conflict.", "id": "findings.F-02.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's id from /workspace/documents/01_intake/004_intake_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_access_logs/052_access_logs_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's issue from /workspace/documents/01_intake/004_intake_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_access_logs/052_access_logs_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's severity from /workspace/documents/01_intake/004_intake_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_access_logs/052_access_logs_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's primary_source from /workspace/documents/01_intake/004_intake_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_access_logs/052_access_logs_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/01_intake/004_intake_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_access_logs/052_access_logs_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-02 using the exact controlled facts ['$274,788.00', '$396,076.00'].", "id": "findings.F-02.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-02's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-02.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-16', 'Sofia Bennett'] for F-02.", "id": "findings.F-02.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-03 exception for undisclosed related party.", "id": "findings.F-03.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's id from /workspace/documents/01_intake/007_intake_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_access_logs/055_access_logs_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's issue from /workspace/documents/01_intake/007_intake_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_access_logs/055_access_logs_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's severity from /workspace/documents/01_intake/007_intake_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_access_logs/055_access_logs_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's primary_source from /workspace/documents/01_intake/007_intake_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_access_logs/055_access_logs_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/01_intake/007_intake_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_access_logs/055_access_logs_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-03 using the exact controlled facts ['Talia Brooks', 'Henry Cho'].", "id": "findings.F-03.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-03's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-03.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-16', 'Adrian Mensah'] for F-03.", "id": "findings.F-03.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-04 exception for split-purchase pattern.", "id": "findings.F-04.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's id from /workspace/documents/02_preservation/010_preservation_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_vendor_files/058_vendor_files_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's issue from /workspace/documents/02_preservation/010_preservation_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_vendor_files/058_vendor_files_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's severity from /workspace/documents/02_preservation/010_preservation_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_vendor_files/058_vendor_files_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's primary_source from /workspace/documents/02_preservation/010_preservation_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_vendor_files/058_vendor_files_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/02_preservation/010_preservation_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_vendor_files/058_vendor_files_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-04 using the exact controlled facts ['closed without exception', 'CB-IV-2605-D705', 'open and escalated', 'CB-IV-2605-M908'].", "id": "findings.F-04.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-04's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-04.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-16', 'Willa Novak'] for F-04.", "id": "findings.F-04.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-05 exception for approval override.", "id": "findings.F-05.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's id from /workspace/documents/02_preservation/013_preservation_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_vendor_files/061_vendor_files_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's issue from /workspace/documents/02_preservation/013_preservation_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_vendor_files/061_vendor_files_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's severity from /workspace/documents/02_preservation/013_preservation_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_vendor_files/061_vendor_files_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's primary_source from /workspace/documents/02_preservation/013_preservation_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_vendor_files/061_vendor_files_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/02_preservation/013_preservation_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_vendor_files/061_vendor_files_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-05 using the exact controlled facts ['Multnomah County, Oregon', 'Oregon'].", "id": "findings.F-05.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-05's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-05.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-16', 'Theo Laurent'] for F-05.", "id": "findings.F-05.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-06 exception for gift-policy threshold breach.", "id": "findings.F-06.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's id from /workspace/documents/02_preservation/016_preservation_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_vendor_files/064_vendor_files_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's issue from /workspace/documents/02_preservation/016_preservation_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_vendor_files/064_vendor_files_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's severity from /workspace/documents/02_preservation/016_preservation_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_vendor_files/064_vendor_files_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's primary_source from /workspace/documents/02_preservation/016_preservation_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_vendor_files/064_vendor_files_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/02_preservation/016_preservation_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_vendor_files/064_vendor_files_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-06 using the exact controlled facts ['7%', '12%'].", "id": "findings.F-06.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-06's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-06.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-16', 'Amara Patel'] for F-06.", "id": "findings.F-06.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-07 exception for off-channel communication.", "id": "findings.F-07.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's id from /workspace/documents/03_interviews/019_interviews_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_policies/067_policies_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's issue from /workspace/documents/03_interviews/019_interviews_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_policies/067_policies_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's severity from /workspace/documents/03_interviews/019_interviews_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_policies/067_policies_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's primary_source from /workspace/documents/03_interviews/019_interviews_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_policies/067_policies_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/03_interviews/019_interviews_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_policies/067_policies_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-07 using the exact controlled facts ['notices-evergreen_charter_network@example.test', 'archive-summit_enrollment_advisors@example.test'].", "id": "findings.F-07.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-07's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-07.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-16', 'Henry Cho'] for F-07.", "id": "findings.F-07.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-08 exception for deleted-message anomaly.", "id": "findings.F-08.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's id from /workspace/documents/03_interviews/022_interviews_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_policies/070_policies_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's issue from /workspace/documents/03_interviews/022_interviews_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_policies/070_policies_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's severity from /workspace/documents/03_interviews/022_interviews_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_policies/070_policies_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's primary_source from /workspace/documents/03_interviews/022_interviews_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_policies/070_policies_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/03_interviews/022_interviews_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_policies/070_policies_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-08 using the exact controlled facts ['119 records', '2025-03-15', '42 records', '2025-03-29'].", "id": "findings.F-08.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-08's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-08.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-16', 'Nadine Flores'] for F-08.", "id": "findings.F-08.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-09 exception for badge-log inconsistency.", "id": "findings.F-09.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's id from /workspace/documents/04_email_exports/025_email_exports_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_hr_records/073_hr_records_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's issue from /workspace/documents/04_email_exports/025_email_exports_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_hr_records/073_hr_records_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's severity from /workspace/documents/04_email_exports/025_email_exports_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_hr_records/073_hr_records_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's primary_source from /workspace/documents/04_email_exports/025_email_exports_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_hr_records/073_hr_records_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/04_email_exports/025_email_exports_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_hr_records/073_hr_records_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-09 using the exact controlled facts ['2025-05-28', 'CB-IV-2605-I605', '2025-06-08', 'CB-IV-2605-R900'].", "id": "findings.F-09.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-09's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-09.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-16', 'Micah Sullivan'] for F-09.", "id": "findings.F-09.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-10 exception for vendor due-diligence gap.", "id": "findings.F-10.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's id from /workspace/documents/04_email_exports/028_email_exports_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_hr_records/076_hr_records_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's issue from /workspace/documents/04_email_exports/028_email_exports_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_hr_records/076_hr_records_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's severity from /workspace/documents/04_email_exports/028_email_exports_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_hr_records/076_hr_records_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's primary_source from /workspace/documents/04_email_exports/028_email_exports_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_hr_records/076_hr_records_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/04_email_exports/028_email_exports_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_hr_records/076_hr_records_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-10 using the exact controlled facts ['$3,484,082.00', '$3,534,664.00'].", "id": "findings.F-10.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-10's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-10.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-16', 'Farah Ibrahim'] for F-10.", "id": "findings.F-10.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-11 exception for retaliation concern.", "id": "findings.F-11.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's id from /workspace/documents/04_email_exports/031_email_exports_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_hr_records/079_hr_records_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's issue from /workspace/documents/04_email_exports/031_email_exports_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_hr_records/079_hr_records_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's severity from /workspace/documents/04_email_exports/031_email_exports_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_hr_records/079_hr_records_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's primary_source from /workspace/documents/04_email_exports/031_email_exports_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_hr_records/079_hr_records_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/04_email_exports/031_email_exports_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_hr_records/079_hr_records_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-11 using the exact controlled facts ['Talia Brooks', 'Caleb Hassan'].", "id": "findings.F-11.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-11's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-11.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-16', 'Owen Delgado'] for F-11.", "id": "findings.F-11.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-12 exception for policy training lapse.", "id": "findings.F-12.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's id from /workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/034_chat_exports_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_board_reporting/082_board_reporting_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's issue from /workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/034_chat_exports_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_board_reporting/082_board_reporting_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's severity from /workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/034_chat_exports_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_board_reporting/082_board_reporting_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's primary_source from /workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/034_chat_exports_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_board_reporting/082_board_reporting_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/034_chat_exports_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_board_reporting/082_board_reporting_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-12 using the exact controlled facts ['closed without exception', 'CB-IV-2605-L855', 'open and escalated', 'CB-IV-2605-U642'].", "id": "findings.F-12.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-12's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-12.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-16', 'Lena Varga'] for F-12.", "id": "findings.F-12.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-13 exception for board-reporting omission.", "id": "findings.F-13.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's id from /workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/037_chat_exports_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_board_reporting/085_board_reporting_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's issue from /workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/037_chat_exports_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_board_reporting/085_board_reporting_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's severity from /workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/037_chat_exports_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_board_reporting/085_board_reporting_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's primary_source from /workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/037_chat_exports_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_board_reporting/085_board_reporting_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/037_chat_exports_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_board_reporting/085_board_reporting_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-13 using the exact controlled facts ['Multnomah County, Oregon', 'Oregon'].", "id": "findings.F-13.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-13's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-13.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-16', 'Samuel Kim'] for F-13.", "id": "findings.F-13.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-14 exception for hotline classification error.", "id": "findings.F-14.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's id from /workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/040_chat_exports_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_board_reporting/088_board_reporting_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's issue from /workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/040_chat_exports_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_board_reporting/088_board_reporting_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's severity from /workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/040_chat_exports_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_board_reporting/088_board_reporting_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's primary_source from /workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/040_chat_exports_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_board_reporting/088_board_reporting_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/040_chat_exports_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_board_reporting/088_board_reporting_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-14 using the exact controlled facts ['9%', '14%'].", "id": "findings.F-14.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-14's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-14.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-16', 'Maya Ellison'] for F-14.", "id": "findings.F-14.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-15 exception for expense support deficiency.", "id": "findings.F-15.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's id from /workspace/documents/06_expenses/043_expenses_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_remediation/091_remediation_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's issue from /workspace/documents/06_expenses/043_expenses_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_remediation/091_remediation_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's severity from /workspace/documents/06_expenses/043_expenses_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_remediation/091_remediation_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's primary_source from /workspace/documents/06_expenses/043_expenses_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_remediation/091_remediation_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/06_expenses/043_expenses_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_remediation/091_remediation_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-15 using the exact controlled facts ['notices-evergreen_charter_network@example.test', 'archive-summit_enrollment_advisors@example.test'].", "id": "findings.F-15.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-15's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-15.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-16', 'Rafael Okafor'] for F-15.", "id": "findings.F-15.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-16 exception for remediation ownership gap.", "id": "findings.F-16.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's id from /workspace/documents/06_expenses/046_expenses_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_remediation/094_remediation_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's issue from /workspace/documents/06_expenses/046_expenses_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_remediation/094_remediation_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's severity from /workspace/documents/06_expenses/046_expenses_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_remediation/094_remediation_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's primary_source from /workspace/documents/06_expenses/046_expenses_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_remediation/094_remediation_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/06_expenses/046_expenses_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_remediation/094_remediation_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-16 using the exact controlled facts ['88 records', '2025-07-02', '38 records', '2025-07-12'].", "id": "findings.F-16.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-16's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-16.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-16', 'Nora Chen'] for F-16.", "id": "findings.F-16.action_anchors"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Executive assessment' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Executive assessment"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Method and record coverage' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Method and record coverage"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Findings' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Findings"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Recommended next actions' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Recommended next actions"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Assumptions and limitations' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Assumptions and limitations"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-01 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-01"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-02 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-02"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-03 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-03"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-04 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-04"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-05 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-05"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-06 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-06"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-07 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-07"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-08 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-08"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-09 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-09"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-10 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-10"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-11 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-11"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-12 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-12"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-13 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-13"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-14 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-14"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-15 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-15"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-16 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-16"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Do not claim the production has no issues or that every record is consistent.", "id": "memo.forbidden_claims_absent"}], "decision_options": [{"id": "cross-source-reconciliation", "label": "Reconcile controlling and corroborating records", "reason": "The CB-IV-2605 production contains independently maintained records; a defensible answer must preserve each supported conflict and its cure owner.", "selected": true}, {"id": "latest-record-controls", "label": "Treat the latest record as controlling", "reason": "Timestamp recency does not establish legal priority, execution, or approval authority.", "selected": false}, {"id": "primary-records-only", "label": "Report primary records without reconciliation", "reason": "Primary records alone conceal the operational conflicts that create the actionable exceptions.", "selected": false}], "gates": ["all_evidence_read_in_full", "chain_of_custody_metadata_checked", "findings_criteria_complete", "memo_criteria_complete", "deliverables_written_through_mcp"], "metadata_checks": 8, "metric": "weighted_criteria_score", "minimum_tool_calls": 46, "required_deliverables": ["findings.json", "advice.md"], "required_document_reads": 33, "type": "deterministic", "weights": {"findings": 0.55, "memo": 0.2, "procedure": 0.25}}, "task_id": "cb100-025-evergreen-charter", "task_name": "Evergreen enrollment complaint review", "world_id": "counselbench-filesystem-mcp-v2"}
-{"context_files": ["task_files/cb100-026-foxglove-pharma/01_intake/001_intake_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-026-foxglove-pharma/01_intake/002_intake_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-026-foxglove-pharma/01_intake/003_intake_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-026-foxglove-pharma/01_intake/004_intake_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-026-foxglove-pharma/01_intake/005_intake_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-026-foxglove-pharma/01_intake/006_intake_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-026-foxglove-pharma/01_intake/007_intake_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-026-foxglove-pharma/01_intake/008_intake_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-026-foxglove-pharma/02_preservation/009_preservation_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-026-foxglove-pharma/02_preservation/010_preservation_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-026-foxglove-pharma/02_preservation/011_preservation_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-026-foxglove-pharma/02_preservation/012_preservation_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-026-foxglove-pharma/02_preservation/013_preservation_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-026-foxglove-pharma/02_preservation/014_preservation_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-026-foxglove-pharma/02_preservation/015_preservation_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-026-foxglove-pharma/02_preservation/016_preservation_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-026-foxglove-pharma/03_interviews/017_interviews_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-026-foxglove-pharma/03_interviews/018_interviews_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-026-foxglove-pharma/03_interviews/019_interviews_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-026-foxglove-pharma/03_interviews/020_interviews_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-026-foxglove-pharma/03_interviews/021_interviews_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-026-foxglove-pharma/03_interviews/022_interviews_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-026-foxglove-pharma/03_interviews/023_interviews_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-026-foxglove-pharma/03_interviews/024_interviews_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-026-foxglove-pharma/04_email_exports/025_email_exports_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-026-foxglove-pharma/04_email_exports/026_email_exports_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-026-foxglove-pharma/04_email_exports/027_email_exports_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-026-foxglove-pharma/04_email_exports/028_email_exports_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-026-foxglove-pharma/04_email_exports/029_email_exports_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-026-foxglove-pharma/04_email_exports/030_email_exports_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-026-foxglove-pharma/04_email_exports/031_email_exports_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-026-foxglove-pharma/04_email_exports/032_email_exports_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-026-foxglove-pharma/05_chat_exports/033_chat_exports_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-026-foxglove-pharma/05_chat_exports/034_chat_exports_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-026-foxglove-pharma/05_chat_exports/035_chat_exports_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-026-foxglove-pharma/05_chat_exports/036_chat_exports_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-026-foxglove-pharma/05_chat_exports/037_chat_exports_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-026-foxglove-pharma/05_chat_exports/038_chat_exports_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-026-foxglove-pharma/05_chat_exports/039_chat_exports_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-026-foxglove-pharma/05_chat_exports/040_chat_exports_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-026-foxglove-pharma/06_expenses/041_expenses_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-026-foxglove-pharma/06_expenses/042_expenses_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-026-foxglove-pharma/06_expenses/043_expenses_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-026-foxglove-pharma/06_expenses/044_expenses_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-026-foxglove-pharma/06_expenses/045_expenses_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-026-foxglove-pharma/06_expenses/046_expenses_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-026-foxglove-pharma/06_expenses/047_expenses_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-026-foxglove-pharma/06_expenses/048_expenses_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-026-foxglove-pharma/07_access_logs/049_access_logs_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-026-foxglove-pharma/07_access_logs/050_access_logs_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-026-foxglove-pharma/07_access_logs/051_access_logs_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-026-foxglove-pharma/07_access_logs/052_access_logs_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-026-foxglove-pharma/07_access_logs/053_access_logs_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-026-foxglove-pharma/07_access_logs/054_access_logs_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-026-foxglove-pharma/07_access_logs/055_access_logs_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-026-foxglove-pharma/07_access_logs/056_access_logs_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-026-foxglove-pharma/08_vendor_files/057_vendor_files_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-026-foxglove-pharma/08_vendor_files/058_vendor_files_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-026-foxglove-pharma/08_vendor_files/059_vendor_files_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-026-foxglove-pharma/08_vendor_files/060_vendor_files_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-026-foxglove-pharma/08_vendor_files/061_vendor_files_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-026-foxglove-pharma/08_vendor_files/062_vendor_files_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-026-foxglove-pharma/08_vendor_files/063_vendor_files_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-026-foxglove-pharma/08_vendor_files/064_vendor_files_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-026-foxglove-pharma/09_policies/065_policies_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-026-foxglove-pharma/09_policies/066_policies_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-026-foxglove-pharma/09_policies/067_policies_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-026-foxglove-pharma/09_policies/068_policies_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-026-foxglove-pharma/09_policies/069_policies_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-026-foxglove-pharma/09_policies/070_policies_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-026-foxglove-pharma/09_policies/071_policies_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-026-foxglove-pharma/09_policies/072_policies_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-026-foxglove-pharma/10_hr_records/073_hr_records_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-026-foxglove-pharma/10_hr_records/074_hr_records_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-026-foxglove-pharma/10_hr_records/075_hr_records_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-026-foxglove-pharma/10_hr_records/076_hr_records_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-026-foxglove-pharma/10_hr_records/077_hr_records_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-026-foxglove-pharma/10_hr_records/078_hr_records_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-026-foxglove-pharma/10_hr_records/079_hr_records_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-026-foxglove-pharma/10_hr_records/080_hr_records_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-026-foxglove-pharma/11_board_reporting/081_board_reporting_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-026-foxglove-pharma/11_board_reporting/082_board_reporting_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-026-foxglove-pharma/11_board_reporting/083_board_reporting_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-026-foxglove-pharma/11_board_reporting/084_board_reporting_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-026-foxglove-pharma/11_board_reporting/085_board_reporting_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-026-foxglove-pharma/11_board_reporting/086_board_reporting_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-026-foxglove-pharma/11_board_reporting/087_board_reporting_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-026-foxglove-pharma/11_board_reporting/088_board_reporting_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-026-foxglove-pharma/12_remediation/089_remediation_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-026-foxglove-pharma/12_remediation/090_remediation_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-026-foxglove-pharma/12_remediation/091_remediation_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-026-foxglove-pharma/12_remediation/092_remediation_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-026-foxglove-pharma/12_remediation/093_remediation_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-026-foxglove-pharma/12_remediation/094_remediation_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-026-foxglove-pharma/12_remediation/095_remediation_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-026-foxglove-pharma/12_remediation/096_remediation_status_report.md"], "gold_output": {"advice_markdown": "# Counsel advice — Foxglove speaker-program investigation\n\n## Executive assessment\n\nFor Foxglove Pharmaceuticals matter CB-IV-2606, the review identified 16 source-supported exceptions requiring action before 2026-09-20. The assessment concerns Clearwater Medical Events and the supplied record for New Jersey.\n\n## Method and record coverage\n\nThe review inventoried all 96 production files, read the 33 controlling, corroborating, and control records, searched the email exports, and checked metadata for the designated chain-of-custody sample. Conclusions are limited to the synthetic production supplied for this benchmark matter.\n\n## Findings\n\n### F-01 — preservation delay (critical)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for preservation delay: one source states the operative date is 2025-02-06 under control reference CB-IV-2606-A134, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2025-03-25 under response reference CB-IV-2606-J171.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/01_intake/001_intake_control_register.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/07_access_logs/049_access_logs_control_register.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-20, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Sofia Bennett.\n\n### F-02 — interview timeline conflict (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for interview timeline conflict: one source states the controlling amount is $5,420,710.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $5,497,920.00.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/01_intake/004_intake_ledger_export.csv`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/07_access_logs/052_access_logs_ledger_export.csv`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-20, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Adrian Mensah.\n\n### F-03 — undisclosed related party (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for undisclosed related party: one source states approval is attributed to Jonas Feld as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Micah Sullivan and contains no entry for Jonas Feld.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/01_intake/007_intake_officer_certificate.html`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/07_access_logs/055_access_logs_officer_certificate.html`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-20, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Willa Novak.\n\n### F-04 — split-purchase pattern (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for split-purchase pattern: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-IV-2606-D242, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-IV-2606-M318.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/02_preservation/010_preservation_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/08_vendor_files/058_vendor_files_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-20, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Theo Laurent.\n\n### F-05 — approval override (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for approval override: one source states the applicable location is Middlesex County, New Jersey, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to New Jersey operations outside Middlesex County, New Jersey.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/02_preservation/013_preservation_review_memorandum.json`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/08_vendor_files/061_vendor_files_review_memorandum.json`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-20, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Amara Patel.\n\n### F-06 — gift-policy threshold breach (low)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for gift-policy threshold breach: one source states the threshold is 6% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 10% and produced a different exception result.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/02_preservation/016_preservation_status_report.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/08_vendor_files/064_vendor_files_status_report.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-20, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Henry Cho.\n\n### F-07 — off-channel communication (critical)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for off-channel communication: one source states formal notice must use notices-foxglove_pharmaceuticals@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-clearwater_medical_events@example.test.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/03_interviews/019_interviews_correspondence.eml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/09_policies/067_policies_correspondence.eml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-20, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Nadine Flores.\n\n### F-08 — deleted-message anomaly (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for deleted-message anomaly: one source states the governed population contains 68 records through 2025-06-12, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 68 records through 2025-07-22.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/03_interviews/022_interviews_formal_notice.xml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/09_policies/070_policies_formal_notice.xml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-20, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Micah Sullivan.\n\n### F-09 — badge-log inconsistency (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for badge-log inconsistency: one source states the operative date is 2025-05-06 under control reference CB-IV-2606-I283, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2025-05-15 under response reference CB-IV-2606-R737.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/04_email_exports/025_email_exports_control_register.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/10_hr_records/073_hr_records_control_register.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-20, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Farah Ibrahim.\n\n### F-10 — vendor due-diligence gap (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for vendor due-diligence gap: one source states the controlling amount is $4,654,279.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $4,825,058.00.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/04_email_exports/028_email_exports_ledger_export.csv`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/10_hr_records/076_hr_records_ledger_export.csv`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-20, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Owen Delgado.\n\n### F-11 — retaliation concern (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for retaliation concern: one source states approval is attributed to Jonas Feld as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Isaac Romero and contains no entry for Jonas Feld.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/04_email_exports/031_email_exports_officer_certificate.html`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/10_hr_records/079_hr_records_officer_certificate.html`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-20, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Lena Varga.\n\n### F-12 — policy training lapse (low)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for policy training lapse: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-IV-2606-L643, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-IV-2606-U764.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/034_chat_exports_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/11_board_reporting/082_board_reporting_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-20, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Samuel Kim.\n\n### F-13 — board-reporting omission (critical)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for board-reporting omission: one source states the applicable location is Middlesex County, New Jersey, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to New Jersey operations outside Middlesex County, New Jersey.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/037_chat_exports_review_memorandum.json`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/11_board_reporting/085_board_reporting_review_memorandum.json`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-20, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Maya Ellison.\n\n### F-14 — hotline classification error (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for hotline classification error: one source states the threshold is 15% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 18% and produced a different exception result.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/040_chat_exports_status_report.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/11_board_reporting/088_board_reporting_status_report.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-20, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Rafael Okafor.\n\n### F-15 — expense support deficiency (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for expense support deficiency: one source states formal notice must use notices-foxglove_pharmaceuticals@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-clearwater_medical_events@example.test.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/06_expenses/043_expenses_correspondence.eml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/12_remediation/091_remediation_correspondence.eml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-20, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Nora Chen.\n\n### F-16 — remediation ownership gap (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for remediation ownership gap: one source states the governed population contains 136 records through 2025-04-01, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 44 records through 2025-04-17.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/06_expenses/046_expenses_formal_notice.xml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/12_remediation/094_remediation_formal_notice.xml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-20, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Dominic Alvarez.\n\n## Recommended next actions\n\nSequence the critical and high findings first, assign the named owners, preserve the cited records, and document any resolution in the controlling matter register before the stated deadline.\n\n## Assumptions and limitations\n\nThis analysis is confined to task cb100-026-foxglove-pharma and the supplied synthetic evidence. It does not rely on external facts, does not resolve disputed law, and is not legal advice for a real person or entity.\n", "findings": {"as_of": "2026-09-20", "findings": [{"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/07_access_logs/049_access_logs_control_register.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for preservation delay: one source states the operative date is 2025-02-06 under control reference CB-IV-2606-A134, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2025-03-25 under response reference CB-IV-2606-J171.", "id": "F-01", "issue": "preservation delay", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/01_intake/001_intake_control_register.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-20, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Sofia Bennett.", "severity": "critical"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/07_access_logs/052_access_logs_ledger_export.csv", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for interview timeline conflict: one source states the controlling amount is $5,420,710.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $5,497,920.00.", "id": "F-02", "issue": "interview timeline conflict", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/01_intake/004_intake_ledger_export.csv", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-20, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Adrian Mensah.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/07_access_logs/055_access_logs_officer_certificate.html", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for undisclosed related party: one source states approval is attributed to Jonas Feld as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Micah Sullivan and contains no entry for Jonas Feld.", "id": "F-03", "issue": "undisclosed related party", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/01_intake/007_intake_officer_certificate.html", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-20, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Willa Novak.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/08_vendor_files/058_vendor_files_executed_instrument.txt", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for split-purchase pattern: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-IV-2606-D242, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-IV-2606-M318.", "id": "F-04", "issue": "split-purchase pattern", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/02_preservation/010_preservation_executed_instrument.txt", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-20, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Theo Laurent.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/08_vendor_files/061_vendor_files_review_memorandum.json", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for approval override: one source states the applicable location is Middlesex County, New Jersey, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to New Jersey operations outside Middlesex County, New Jersey.", "id": "F-05", "issue": "approval override", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/02_preservation/013_preservation_review_memorandum.json", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-20, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Amara Patel.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/08_vendor_files/064_vendor_files_status_report.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for gift-policy threshold breach: one source states the threshold is 6% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 10% and produced a different exception result.", "id": "F-06", "issue": "gift-policy threshold breach", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/02_preservation/016_preservation_status_report.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-20, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Henry Cho.", "severity": "low"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/09_policies/067_policies_correspondence.eml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for off-channel communication: one source states formal notice must use notices-foxglove_pharmaceuticals@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-clearwater_medical_events@example.test.", "id": "F-07", "issue": "off-channel communication", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/03_interviews/019_interviews_correspondence.eml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-20, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Nadine Flores.", "severity": "critical"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/09_policies/070_policies_formal_notice.xml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for deleted-message anomaly: one source states the governed population contains 68 records through 2025-06-12, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 68 records through 2025-07-22.", "id": "F-08", "issue": "deleted-message anomaly", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/03_interviews/022_interviews_formal_notice.xml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-20, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Micah Sullivan.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/10_hr_records/073_hr_records_control_register.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for badge-log inconsistency: one source states the operative date is 2025-05-06 under control reference CB-IV-2606-I283, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2025-05-15 under response reference CB-IV-2606-R737.", "id": "F-09", "issue": "badge-log inconsistency", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/04_email_exports/025_email_exports_control_register.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-20, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Farah Ibrahim.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/10_hr_records/076_hr_records_ledger_export.csv", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for vendor due-diligence gap: one source states the controlling amount is $4,654,279.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $4,825,058.00.", "id": "F-10", "issue": "vendor due-diligence gap", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/04_email_exports/028_email_exports_ledger_export.csv", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-20, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Owen Delgado.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/10_hr_records/079_hr_records_officer_certificate.html", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for retaliation concern: one source states approval is attributed to Jonas Feld as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Isaac Romero and contains no entry for Jonas Feld.", "id": "F-11", "issue": "retaliation concern", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/04_email_exports/031_email_exports_officer_certificate.html", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-20, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Lena Varga.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/11_board_reporting/082_board_reporting_executed_instrument.txt", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for policy training lapse: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-IV-2606-L643, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-IV-2606-U764.", "id": "F-12", "issue": "policy training lapse", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/034_chat_exports_executed_instrument.txt", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-20, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Samuel Kim.", "severity": "low"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/11_board_reporting/085_board_reporting_review_memorandum.json", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for board-reporting omission: one source states the applicable location is Middlesex County, New Jersey, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to New Jersey operations outside Middlesex County, New Jersey.", "id": "F-13", "issue": "board-reporting omission", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/037_chat_exports_review_memorandum.json", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-20, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Maya Ellison.", "severity": "critical"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/11_board_reporting/088_board_reporting_status_report.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for hotline classification error: one source states the threshold is 15% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 18% and produced a different exception result.", "id": "F-14", "issue": "hotline classification error", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/040_chat_exports_status_report.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-20, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Rafael Okafor.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/091_remediation_correspondence.eml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for expense support deficiency: one source states formal notice must use notices-foxglove_pharmaceuticals@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-clearwater_medical_events@example.test.", "id": "F-15", "issue": "expense support deficiency", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/06_expenses/043_expenses_correspondence.eml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-20, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Nora Chen.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/094_remediation_formal_notice.xml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for remediation ownership gap: one source states the governed population contains 136 records through 2025-04-01, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 44 records through 2025-04-17.", "id": "F-16", "issue": "remediation ownership gap", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/06_expenses/046_expenses_formal_notice.xml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-20, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Dominic Alvarez.", "severity": "medium"}], "matter_number": "CB-IV-2606", "prepared_for": "Foxglove Pharmaceuticals", "schema_version": "1.0", "task_id": "cb100-026-foxglove-pharma"}}, "metadata": {"benchmark": "CounselBench-100", "code_license": "Apache-2.0", "data_license": "CC-BY-4.0", "deadline": "2026-09-20", "document_count": 96, "jurisdiction": "New Jersey", "matter_number": "CB-IV-2606", "mcp_commit": "9a96ea6e5913736f92b88345bf51caeaaa8e719f", "mcp_package": "@modelcontextprotocol/server-filesystem@2026.7.10", "practice_area": "internal-investigations", "reference_tool_calls": 46, "required_evidence_reads": 33, "synthetic": true, "venue": "Middlesex County, New Jersey", "version": "2.0.0"}, "prompt": "You are independent investigations counsel for Foxglove Pharmaceuticals. The upcoming deadline leaves no room for unsupported assumptions, so every conclusion must trace to the supplied production. Attendance logs, meal receipts, and speaker agreements suggest repeat programs with missing educational content and incomplete escalation. Decision due 2026-09-20. New Jersey law governs; Middlesex County, New Jersey is the forum. Give controlling documents precedence only when the record supports that hierarchy. Work out the defensible position from the matter production and leave an audit-ready exception tracker and concise advice for the supervising lawyer. Keep confirmed conflicts separate from open questions, cite the records that actually control each conclusion, and do not fill gaps with outside facts.", "rubric": {"criteria": [{"category": "procedure", "description": "Complete at least 46 successful, argument-specific evidence and output calls.", "id": "procedure.minimum_successful_tool_calls"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Find and read the 33 controlling, corroborating, and work-product-control records in full.", "id": "procedure.all_evidence_read_in_full"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Inspect file metadata for the eight designated critical primary records before relying on them.", "id": "procedure.chain_of_custody_metadata_checked"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Confirm the sandbox's allowed document and output roots.", "id": "procedure.allowed_directories_checked"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Inventory all 96 records so the relevant sources are discovered among the context records.", "id": "procedure.recursive_inventory_completed"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Search the production for email evidence that may corroborate or contradict formal records.", "id": "procedure.targeted_search_completed"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Leave only findings.json and advice.md in the output workspace.", "id": "procedure.exact_deliverable_set"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Create both final work products through the sandbox MCP surface.", "id": "procedure.deliverables_written_through_mcp"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Produce findings.json as a valid JSON object.", "id": "findings.findings_is_object"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Report exactly 16 confirmed exceptions.", "id": "findings.findings_exact_count"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Use each stable finding ID exactly once.", "id": "findings.finding_ids_unique"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set schema_version to the released matter value '1.0'.", "id": "findings.top_level_schema_version"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set task_id to the released matter value 'cb100-026-foxglove-pharma'.", "id": "findings.top_level_task_id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set matter_number to the released matter value 'CB-IV-2606'.", "id": "findings.top_level_matter_number"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set prepared_for to the released matter value 'Foxglove Pharmaceuticals'.", "id": "findings.top_level_prepared_for"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set as_of to the released matter value '2026-09-20'.", "id": "findings.top_level_as_of"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-01 exception for preservation delay.", "id": "findings.F-01.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's id from /workspace/documents/01_intake/001_intake_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_access_logs/049_access_logs_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's issue from /workspace/documents/01_intake/001_intake_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_access_logs/049_access_logs_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's severity from /workspace/documents/01_intake/001_intake_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_access_logs/049_access_logs_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's primary_source from /workspace/documents/01_intake/001_intake_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_access_logs/049_access_logs_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/01_intake/001_intake_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_access_logs/049_access_logs_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-01 using the exact controlled facts ['2025-02-06', 'CB-IV-2606-A134', '2025-03-25', 'CB-IV-2606-J171'].", "id": "findings.F-01.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-01's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-01.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-20', 'Sofia Bennett'] for F-01.", "id": "findings.F-01.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-02 exception for interview timeline conflict.", "id": "findings.F-02.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's id from /workspace/documents/01_intake/004_intake_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_access_logs/052_access_logs_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's issue from /workspace/documents/01_intake/004_intake_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_access_logs/052_access_logs_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's severity from /workspace/documents/01_intake/004_intake_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_access_logs/052_access_logs_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's primary_source from /workspace/documents/01_intake/004_intake_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_access_logs/052_access_logs_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/01_intake/004_intake_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_access_logs/052_access_logs_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-02 using the exact controlled facts ['$5,420,710.00', '$5,497,920.00'].", "id": "findings.F-02.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-02's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-02.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-20', 'Adrian Mensah'] for F-02.", "id": "findings.F-02.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-03 exception for undisclosed related party.", "id": "findings.F-03.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's id from /workspace/documents/01_intake/007_intake_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_access_logs/055_access_logs_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's issue from /workspace/documents/01_intake/007_intake_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_access_logs/055_access_logs_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's severity from /workspace/documents/01_intake/007_intake_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_access_logs/055_access_logs_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's primary_source from /workspace/documents/01_intake/007_intake_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_access_logs/055_access_logs_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/01_intake/007_intake_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_access_logs/055_access_logs_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-03 using the exact controlled facts ['Jonas Feld', 'Micah Sullivan'].", "id": "findings.F-03.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-03's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-03.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-20', 'Willa Novak'] for F-03.", "id": "findings.F-03.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-04 exception for split-purchase pattern.", "id": "findings.F-04.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's id from /workspace/documents/02_preservation/010_preservation_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_vendor_files/058_vendor_files_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's issue from /workspace/documents/02_preservation/010_preservation_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_vendor_files/058_vendor_files_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's severity from /workspace/documents/02_preservation/010_preservation_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_vendor_files/058_vendor_files_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's primary_source from /workspace/documents/02_preservation/010_preservation_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_vendor_files/058_vendor_files_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/02_preservation/010_preservation_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_vendor_files/058_vendor_files_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-04 using the exact controlled facts ['closed without exception', 'CB-IV-2606-D242', 'open and escalated', 'CB-IV-2606-M318'].", "id": "findings.F-04.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-04's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-04.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-20', 'Theo Laurent'] for F-04.", "id": "findings.F-04.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-05 exception for approval override.", "id": "findings.F-05.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's id from /workspace/documents/02_preservation/013_preservation_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_vendor_files/061_vendor_files_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's issue from /workspace/documents/02_preservation/013_preservation_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_vendor_files/061_vendor_files_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's severity from /workspace/documents/02_preservation/013_preservation_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_vendor_files/061_vendor_files_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's primary_source from /workspace/documents/02_preservation/013_preservation_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_vendor_files/061_vendor_files_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/02_preservation/013_preservation_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_vendor_files/061_vendor_files_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-05 using the exact controlled facts ['Middlesex County, New Jersey', 'New Jersey'].", "id": "findings.F-05.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-05's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-05.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-20', 'Amara Patel'] for F-05.", "id": "findings.F-05.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-06 exception for gift-policy threshold breach.", "id": "findings.F-06.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's id from /workspace/documents/02_preservation/016_preservation_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_vendor_files/064_vendor_files_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's issue from /workspace/documents/02_preservation/016_preservation_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_vendor_files/064_vendor_files_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's severity from /workspace/documents/02_preservation/016_preservation_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_vendor_files/064_vendor_files_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's primary_source from /workspace/documents/02_preservation/016_preservation_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_vendor_files/064_vendor_files_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/02_preservation/016_preservation_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_vendor_files/064_vendor_files_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-06 using the exact controlled facts ['6%', '10%'].", "id": "findings.F-06.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-06's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-06.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-20', 'Henry Cho'] for F-06.", "id": "findings.F-06.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-07 exception for off-channel communication.", "id": "findings.F-07.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's id from /workspace/documents/03_interviews/019_interviews_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_policies/067_policies_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's issue from /workspace/documents/03_interviews/019_interviews_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_policies/067_policies_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's severity from /workspace/documents/03_interviews/019_interviews_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_policies/067_policies_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's primary_source from /workspace/documents/03_interviews/019_interviews_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_policies/067_policies_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/03_interviews/019_interviews_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_policies/067_policies_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-07 using the exact controlled facts ['notices-foxglove_pharmaceuticals@example.test', 'archive-clearwater_medical_events@example.test'].", "id": "findings.F-07.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-07's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-07.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-20', 'Nadine Flores'] for F-07.", "id": "findings.F-07.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-08 exception for deleted-message anomaly.", "id": "findings.F-08.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's id from /workspace/documents/03_interviews/022_interviews_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_policies/070_policies_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's issue from /workspace/documents/03_interviews/022_interviews_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_policies/070_policies_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's severity from /workspace/documents/03_interviews/022_interviews_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_policies/070_policies_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's primary_source from /workspace/documents/03_interviews/022_interviews_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_policies/070_policies_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/03_interviews/022_interviews_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_policies/070_policies_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-08 using the exact controlled facts ['68 records', '2025-06-12', '68 records', '2025-07-22'].", "id": "findings.F-08.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-08's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-08.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-20', 'Micah Sullivan'] for F-08.", "id": "findings.F-08.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-09 exception for badge-log inconsistency.", "id": "findings.F-09.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's id from /workspace/documents/04_email_exports/025_email_exports_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_hr_records/073_hr_records_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's issue from /workspace/documents/04_email_exports/025_email_exports_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_hr_records/073_hr_records_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's severity from /workspace/documents/04_email_exports/025_email_exports_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_hr_records/073_hr_records_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's primary_source from /workspace/documents/04_email_exports/025_email_exports_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_hr_records/073_hr_records_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/04_email_exports/025_email_exports_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_hr_records/073_hr_records_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-09 using the exact controlled facts ['2025-05-06', 'CB-IV-2606-I283', '2025-05-15', 'CB-IV-2606-R737'].", "id": "findings.F-09.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-09's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-09.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-20', 'Farah Ibrahim'] for F-09.", "id": "findings.F-09.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-10 exception for vendor due-diligence gap.", "id": "findings.F-10.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's id from /workspace/documents/04_email_exports/028_email_exports_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_hr_records/076_hr_records_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's issue from /workspace/documents/04_email_exports/028_email_exports_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_hr_records/076_hr_records_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's severity from /workspace/documents/04_email_exports/028_email_exports_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_hr_records/076_hr_records_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's primary_source from /workspace/documents/04_email_exports/028_email_exports_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_hr_records/076_hr_records_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/04_email_exports/028_email_exports_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_hr_records/076_hr_records_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-10 using the exact controlled facts ['$4,654,279.00', '$4,825,058.00'].", "id": "findings.F-10.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-10's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-10.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-20', 'Owen Delgado'] for F-10.", "id": "findings.F-10.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-11 exception for retaliation concern.", "id": "findings.F-11.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's id from /workspace/documents/04_email_exports/031_email_exports_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_hr_records/079_hr_records_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's issue from /workspace/documents/04_email_exports/031_email_exports_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_hr_records/079_hr_records_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's severity from /workspace/documents/04_email_exports/031_email_exports_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_hr_records/079_hr_records_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's primary_source from /workspace/documents/04_email_exports/031_email_exports_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_hr_records/079_hr_records_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/04_email_exports/031_email_exports_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_hr_records/079_hr_records_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-11 using the exact controlled facts ['Jonas Feld', 'Isaac Romero'].", "id": "findings.F-11.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-11's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-11.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-20', 'Lena Varga'] for F-11.", "id": "findings.F-11.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-12 exception for policy training lapse.", "id": "findings.F-12.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's id from /workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/034_chat_exports_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_board_reporting/082_board_reporting_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's issue from /workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/034_chat_exports_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_board_reporting/082_board_reporting_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's severity from /workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/034_chat_exports_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_board_reporting/082_board_reporting_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's primary_source from /workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/034_chat_exports_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_board_reporting/082_board_reporting_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/034_chat_exports_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_board_reporting/082_board_reporting_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-12 using the exact controlled facts ['closed without exception', 'CB-IV-2606-L643', 'open and escalated', 'CB-IV-2606-U764'].", "id": "findings.F-12.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-12's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-12.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-20', 'Samuel Kim'] for F-12.", "id": "findings.F-12.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-13 exception for board-reporting omission.", "id": "findings.F-13.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's id from /workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/037_chat_exports_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_board_reporting/085_board_reporting_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's issue from /workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/037_chat_exports_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_board_reporting/085_board_reporting_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's severity from /workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/037_chat_exports_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_board_reporting/085_board_reporting_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's primary_source from /workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/037_chat_exports_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_board_reporting/085_board_reporting_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/037_chat_exports_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_board_reporting/085_board_reporting_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-13 using the exact controlled facts ['Middlesex County, New Jersey', 'New Jersey'].", "id": "findings.F-13.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-13's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-13.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-20', 'Maya Ellison'] for F-13.", "id": "findings.F-13.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-14 exception for hotline classification error.", "id": "findings.F-14.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's id from /workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/040_chat_exports_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_board_reporting/088_board_reporting_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's issue from /workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/040_chat_exports_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_board_reporting/088_board_reporting_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's severity from /workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/040_chat_exports_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_board_reporting/088_board_reporting_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's primary_source from /workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/040_chat_exports_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_board_reporting/088_board_reporting_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/040_chat_exports_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_board_reporting/088_board_reporting_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-14 using the exact controlled facts ['15%', '18%'].", "id": "findings.F-14.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-14's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-14.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-20', 'Rafael Okafor'] for F-14.", "id": "findings.F-14.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-15 exception for expense support deficiency.", "id": "findings.F-15.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's id from /workspace/documents/06_expenses/043_expenses_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_remediation/091_remediation_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's issue from /workspace/documents/06_expenses/043_expenses_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_remediation/091_remediation_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's severity from /workspace/documents/06_expenses/043_expenses_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_remediation/091_remediation_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's primary_source from /workspace/documents/06_expenses/043_expenses_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_remediation/091_remediation_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/06_expenses/043_expenses_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_remediation/091_remediation_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-15 using the exact controlled facts ['notices-foxglove_pharmaceuticals@example.test', 'archive-clearwater_medical_events@example.test'].", "id": "findings.F-15.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-15's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-15.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-20', 'Nora Chen'] for F-15.", "id": "findings.F-15.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-16 exception for remediation ownership gap.", "id": "findings.F-16.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's id from /workspace/documents/06_expenses/046_expenses_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_remediation/094_remediation_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's issue from /workspace/documents/06_expenses/046_expenses_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_remediation/094_remediation_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's severity from /workspace/documents/06_expenses/046_expenses_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_remediation/094_remediation_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's primary_source from /workspace/documents/06_expenses/046_expenses_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_remediation/094_remediation_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/06_expenses/046_expenses_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_remediation/094_remediation_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-16 using the exact controlled facts ['136 records', '2025-04-01', '44 records', '2025-04-17'].", "id": "findings.F-16.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-16's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-16.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-20', 'Dominic Alvarez'] for F-16.", "id": "findings.F-16.action_anchors"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Executive assessment' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Executive assessment"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Method and record coverage' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Method and record coverage"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Findings' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Findings"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Recommended next actions' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Recommended next actions"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Assumptions and limitations' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Assumptions and limitations"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-01 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-01"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-02 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-02"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-03 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-03"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-04 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-04"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-05 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-05"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-06 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-06"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-07 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-07"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-08 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-08"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-09 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-09"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-10 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-10"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-11 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-11"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-12 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-12"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-13 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-13"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-14 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-14"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-15 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-15"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-16 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-16"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Do not claim the production has no issues or that every record is consistent.", "id": "memo.forbidden_claims_absent"}], "decision_options": [{"id": "cross-source-reconciliation", "label": "Reconcile controlling and corroborating records", "reason": "The CB-IV-2606 production contains independently maintained records; a defensible answer must preserve each supported conflict and its cure owner.", "selected": true}, {"id": "latest-record-controls", "label": "Treat the latest record as controlling", "reason": "Timestamp recency does not establish legal priority, execution, or approval authority.", "selected": false}, {"id": "primary-records-only", "label": "Report primary records without reconciliation", "reason": "Primary records alone conceal the operational conflicts that create the actionable exceptions.", "selected": false}], "gates": ["all_evidence_read_in_full", "chain_of_custody_metadata_checked", "findings_criteria_complete", "memo_criteria_complete", "deliverables_written_through_mcp"], "metadata_checks": 8, "metric": "weighted_criteria_score", "minimum_tool_calls": 46, "required_deliverables": ["findings.json", "advice.md"], "required_document_reads": 33, "type": "deterministic", "weights": {"findings": 0.55, "memo": 0.2, "procedure": 0.25}}, "task_id": "cb100-026-foxglove-pharma", "task_name": "Foxglove speaker-program investigation", "world_id": "counselbench-filesystem-mcp-v2"}
-{"context_files": ["task_files/cb100-027-granite-hospitality/01_intake/001_intake_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-027-granite-hospitality/01_intake/002_intake_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-027-granite-hospitality/01_intake/003_intake_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-027-granite-hospitality/01_intake/004_intake_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-027-granite-hospitality/01_intake/005_intake_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-027-granite-hospitality/01_intake/006_intake_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-027-granite-hospitality/01_intake/007_intake_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-027-granite-hospitality/01_intake/008_intake_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-027-granite-hospitality/02_preservation/009_preservation_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-027-granite-hospitality/02_preservation/010_preservation_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-027-granite-hospitality/02_preservation/011_preservation_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-027-granite-hospitality/02_preservation/012_preservation_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-027-granite-hospitality/02_preservation/013_preservation_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-027-granite-hospitality/02_preservation/014_preservation_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-027-granite-hospitality/02_preservation/015_preservation_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-027-granite-hospitality/02_preservation/016_preservation_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-027-granite-hospitality/03_interviews/017_interviews_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-027-granite-hospitality/03_interviews/018_interviews_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-027-granite-hospitality/03_interviews/019_interviews_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-027-granite-hospitality/03_interviews/020_interviews_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-027-granite-hospitality/03_interviews/021_interviews_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-027-granite-hospitality/03_interviews/022_interviews_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-027-granite-hospitality/03_interviews/023_interviews_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-027-granite-hospitality/03_interviews/024_interviews_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-027-granite-hospitality/04_email_exports/025_email_exports_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-027-granite-hospitality/04_email_exports/026_email_exports_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-027-granite-hospitality/04_email_exports/027_email_exports_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-027-granite-hospitality/04_email_exports/028_email_exports_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-027-granite-hospitality/04_email_exports/029_email_exports_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-027-granite-hospitality/04_email_exports/030_email_exports_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-027-granite-hospitality/04_email_exports/031_email_exports_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-027-granite-hospitality/04_email_exports/032_email_exports_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-027-granite-hospitality/05_chat_exports/033_chat_exports_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-027-granite-hospitality/05_chat_exports/034_chat_exports_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-027-granite-hospitality/05_chat_exports/035_chat_exports_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-027-granite-hospitality/05_chat_exports/036_chat_exports_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-027-granite-hospitality/05_chat_exports/037_chat_exports_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-027-granite-hospitality/05_chat_exports/038_chat_exports_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-027-granite-hospitality/05_chat_exports/039_chat_exports_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-027-granite-hospitality/05_chat_exports/040_chat_exports_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-027-granite-hospitality/06_expenses/041_expenses_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-027-granite-hospitality/06_expenses/042_expenses_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-027-granite-hospitality/06_expenses/043_expenses_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-027-granite-hospitality/06_expenses/044_expenses_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-027-granite-hospitality/06_expenses/045_expenses_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-027-granite-hospitality/06_expenses/046_expenses_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-027-granite-hospitality/06_expenses/047_expenses_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-027-granite-hospitality/06_expenses/048_expenses_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-027-granite-hospitality/07_access_logs/049_access_logs_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-027-granite-hospitality/07_access_logs/050_access_logs_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-027-granite-hospitality/07_access_logs/051_access_logs_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-027-granite-hospitality/07_access_logs/052_access_logs_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-027-granite-hospitality/07_access_logs/053_access_logs_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-027-granite-hospitality/07_access_logs/054_access_logs_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-027-granite-hospitality/07_access_logs/055_access_logs_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-027-granite-hospitality/07_access_logs/056_access_logs_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-027-granite-hospitality/08_vendor_files/057_vendor_files_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-027-granite-hospitality/08_vendor_files/058_vendor_files_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-027-granite-hospitality/08_vendor_files/059_vendor_files_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-027-granite-hospitality/08_vendor_files/060_vendor_files_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-027-granite-hospitality/08_vendor_files/061_vendor_files_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-027-granite-hospitality/08_vendor_files/062_vendor_files_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-027-granite-hospitality/08_vendor_files/063_vendor_files_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-027-granite-hospitality/08_vendor_files/064_vendor_files_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-027-granite-hospitality/09_policies/065_policies_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-027-granite-hospitality/09_policies/066_policies_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-027-granite-hospitality/09_policies/067_policies_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-027-granite-hospitality/09_policies/068_policies_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-027-granite-hospitality/09_policies/069_policies_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-027-granite-hospitality/09_policies/070_policies_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-027-granite-hospitality/09_policies/071_policies_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-027-granite-hospitality/09_policies/072_policies_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-027-granite-hospitality/10_hr_records/073_hr_records_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-027-granite-hospitality/10_hr_records/074_hr_records_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-027-granite-hospitality/10_hr_records/075_hr_records_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-027-granite-hospitality/10_hr_records/076_hr_records_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-027-granite-hospitality/10_hr_records/077_hr_records_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-027-granite-hospitality/10_hr_records/078_hr_records_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-027-granite-hospitality/10_hr_records/079_hr_records_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-027-granite-hospitality/10_hr_records/080_hr_records_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-027-granite-hospitality/11_board_reporting/081_board_reporting_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-027-granite-hospitality/11_board_reporting/082_board_reporting_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-027-granite-hospitality/11_board_reporting/083_board_reporting_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-027-granite-hospitality/11_board_reporting/084_board_reporting_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-027-granite-hospitality/11_board_reporting/085_board_reporting_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-027-granite-hospitality/11_board_reporting/086_board_reporting_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-027-granite-hospitality/11_board_reporting/087_board_reporting_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-027-granite-hospitality/11_board_reporting/088_board_reporting_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-027-granite-hospitality/12_remediation/089_remediation_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-027-granite-hospitality/12_remediation/090_remediation_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-027-granite-hospitality/12_remediation/091_remediation_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-027-granite-hospitality/12_remediation/092_remediation_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-027-granite-hospitality/12_remediation/093_remediation_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-027-granite-hospitality/12_remediation/094_remediation_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-027-granite-hospitality/12_remediation/095_remediation_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-027-granite-hospitality/12_remediation/096_remediation_status_report.md"], "gold_output": {"advice_markdown": "# Counsel advice — Granite hotel renovation inquiry\n\n## Executive assessment\n\nFor Granite Hospitality Trust matter CB-IV-2607, the review identified 16 source-supported exceptions requiring action before 2026-09-23. The assessment concerns Sable Ridge Interiors and the supplied record for Nevada.\n\n## Method and record coverage\n\nThe review inventoried all 96 production files, read the 33 controlling, corroborating, and control records, searched the email exports, and checked metadata for the designated chain-of-custody sample. Conclusions are limited to the synthetic production supplied for this benchmark matter.\n\n## Findings\n\n### F-01 — preservation delay (critical)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for preservation delay: one source states the operative date is 2025-04-08 under control reference CB-IV-2607-A915, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2025-05-12 under response reference CB-IV-2607-J508.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/01_intake/001_intake_control_register.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/07_access_logs/049_access_logs_control_register.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-23, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Adrian Mensah.\n\n### F-02 — interview timeline conflict (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for interview timeline conflict: one source states the controlling amount is $6,029,209.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $6,324,918.00.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/01_intake/004_intake_ledger_export.csv`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/07_access_logs/052_access_logs_ledger_export.csv`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-23, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Willa Novak.\n\n### F-03 — undisclosed related party (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for undisclosed related party: one source states approval is attributed to Mei Whitaker as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Owen Delgado and contains no entry for Mei Whitaker.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/01_intake/007_intake_officer_certificate.html`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/07_access_logs/055_access_logs_officer_certificate.html`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-23, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Theo Laurent.\n\n### F-04 — split-purchase pattern (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for split-purchase pattern: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-IV-2607-D999, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-IV-2607-M792.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/02_preservation/010_preservation_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/08_vendor_files/058_vendor_files_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-23, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Amara Patel.\n\n### F-05 — approval override (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for approval override: one source states the applicable location is Clark County, Nevada, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to Nevada operations outside Clark County, Nevada.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/02_preservation/013_preservation_review_memorandum.json`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/08_vendor_files/061_vendor_files_review_memorandum.json`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-23, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Henry Cho.\n\n### F-06 — gift-policy threshold breach (low)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for gift-policy threshold breach: one source states the threshold is 15% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 22% and produced a different exception result.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/02_preservation/016_preservation_status_report.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/08_vendor_files/064_vendor_files_status_report.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-23, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Nadine Flores.\n\n### F-07 — off-channel communication (critical)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for off-channel communication: one source states formal notice must use notices-granite_hospitality_trust@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-sable_ridge_interiors@example.test.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/03_interviews/019_interviews_correspondence.eml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/09_policies/067_policies_correspondence.eml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-23, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Micah Sullivan.\n\n### F-08 — deleted-message anomaly (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for deleted-message anomaly: one source states the governed population contains 82 records through 2025-06-26, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 75 records through 2025-08-12.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/03_interviews/022_interviews_formal_notice.xml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/09_policies/070_policies_formal_notice.xml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-23, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Farah Ibrahim.\n\n### F-09 — badge-log inconsistency (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for badge-log inconsistency: one source states the operative date is 2025-01-17 under control reference CB-IV-2607-I954, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2025-02-19 under response reference CB-IV-2607-R996.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/04_email_exports/025_email_exports_control_register.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/10_hr_records/073_hr_records_control_register.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-23, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Owen Delgado.\n\n### F-10 — vendor due-diligence gap (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for vendor due-diligence gap: one source states the controlling amount is $4,308,947.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $4,344,394.00.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/04_email_exports/028_email_exports_ledger_export.csv`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/10_hr_records/076_hr_records_ledger_export.csv`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-23, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Lena Varga.\n\n### F-11 — retaliation concern (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for retaliation concern: one source states approval is attributed to Mei Whitaker as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Adrian Mensah and contains no entry for Mei Whitaker.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/04_email_exports/031_email_exports_officer_certificate.html`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/10_hr_records/079_hr_records_officer_certificate.html`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-23, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Samuel Kim.\n\n### F-12 — policy training lapse (low)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for policy training lapse: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-IV-2607-L399, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-IV-2607-U469.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/034_chat_exports_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/11_board_reporting/082_board_reporting_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-23, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Maya Ellison.\n\n### F-13 — board-reporting omission (critical)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for board-reporting omission: one source states the applicable location is Clark County, Nevada, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to Nevada operations outside Clark County, Nevada.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/037_chat_exports_review_memorandum.json`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/11_board_reporting/085_board_reporting_review_memorandum.json`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-23, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Rafael Okafor.\n\n### F-14 — hotline classification error (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for hotline classification error: one source states the threshold is 12% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 18% and produced a different exception result.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/040_chat_exports_status_report.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/11_board_reporting/088_board_reporting_status_report.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-23, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Nora Chen.\n\n### F-15 — expense support deficiency (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for expense support deficiency: one source states formal notice must use notices-granite_hospitality_trust@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-sable_ridge_interiors@example.test.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/06_expenses/043_expenses_correspondence.eml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/12_remediation/091_remediation_correspondence.eml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-23, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Dominic Alvarez.\n\n### F-16 — remediation ownership gap (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for remediation ownership gap: one source states the governed population contains 61 records through 2025-01-16, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 54 records through 2025-02-11.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/06_expenses/046_expenses_formal_notice.xml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/12_remediation/094_remediation_formal_notice.xml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-23, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Priya Raman.\n\n## Recommended next actions\n\nSequence the critical and high findings first, assign the named owners, preserve the cited records, and document any resolution in the controlling matter register before the stated deadline.\n\n## Assumptions and limitations\n\nThis analysis is confined to task cb100-027-granite-hospitality and the supplied synthetic evidence. It does not rely on external facts, does not resolve disputed law, and is not legal advice for a real person or entity.\n", "findings": {"as_of": "2026-09-23", "findings": [{"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/07_access_logs/049_access_logs_control_register.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for preservation delay: one source states the operative date is 2025-04-08 under control reference CB-IV-2607-A915, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2025-05-12 under response reference CB-IV-2607-J508.", "id": "F-01", "issue": "preservation delay", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/01_intake/001_intake_control_register.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-23, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Adrian Mensah.", "severity": "critical"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/07_access_logs/052_access_logs_ledger_export.csv", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for interview timeline conflict: one source states the controlling amount is $6,029,209.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $6,324,918.00.", "id": "F-02", "issue": "interview timeline conflict", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/01_intake/004_intake_ledger_export.csv", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-23, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Willa Novak.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/07_access_logs/055_access_logs_officer_certificate.html", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for undisclosed related party: one source states approval is attributed to Mei Whitaker as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Owen Delgado and contains no entry for Mei Whitaker.", "id": "F-03", "issue": "undisclosed related party", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/01_intake/007_intake_officer_certificate.html", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-23, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Theo Laurent.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/08_vendor_files/058_vendor_files_executed_instrument.txt", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for split-purchase pattern: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-IV-2607-D999, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-IV-2607-M792.", "id": "F-04", "issue": "split-purchase pattern", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/02_preservation/010_preservation_executed_instrument.txt", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-23, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Amara Patel.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/08_vendor_files/061_vendor_files_review_memorandum.json", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for approval override: one source states the applicable location is Clark County, Nevada, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to Nevada operations outside Clark County, Nevada.", "id": "F-05", "issue": "approval override", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/02_preservation/013_preservation_review_memorandum.json", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-23, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Henry Cho.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/08_vendor_files/064_vendor_files_status_report.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for gift-policy threshold breach: one source states the threshold is 15% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 22% and produced a different exception result.", "id": "F-06", "issue": "gift-policy threshold breach", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/02_preservation/016_preservation_status_report.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-23, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Nadine Flores.", "severity": "low"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/09_policies/067_policies_correspondence.eml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for off-channel communication: one source states formal notice must use notices-granite_hospitality_trust@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-sable_ridge_interiors@example.test.", "id": "F-07", "issue": "off-channel communication", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/03_interviews/019_interviews_correspondence.eml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-23, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Micah Sullivan.", "severity": "critical"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/09_policies/070_policies_formal_notice.xml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for deleted-message anomaly: one source states the governed population contains 82 records through 2025-06-26, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 75 records through 2025-08-12.", "id": "F-08", "issue": "deleted-message anomaly", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/03_interviews/022_interviews_formal_notice.xml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-23, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Farah Ibrahim.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/10_hr_records/073_hr_records_control_register.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for badge-log inconsistency: one source states the operative date is 2025-01-17 under control reference CB-IV-2607-I954, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2025-02-19 under response reference CB-IV-2607-R996.", "id": "F-09", "issue": "badge-log inconsistency", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/04_email_exports/025_email_exports_control_register.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-23, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Owen Delgado.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/10_hr_records/076_hr_records_ledger_export.csv", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for vendor due-diligence gap: one source states the controlling amount is $4,308,947.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $4,344,394.00.", "id": "F-10", "issue": "vendor due-diligence gap", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/04_email_exports/028_email_exports_ledger_export.csv", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-23, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Lena Varga.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/10_hr_records/079_hr_records_officer_certificate.html", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for retaliation concern: one source states approval is attributed to Mei Whitaker as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Adrian Mensah and contains no entry for Mei Whitaker.", "id": "F-11", "issue": "retaliation concern", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/04_email_exports/031_email_exports_officer_certificate.html", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-23, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Samuel Kim.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/11_board_reporting/082_board_reporting_executed_instrument.txt", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for policy training lapse: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-IV-2607-L399, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-IV-2607-U469.", "id": "F-12", "issue": "policy training lapse", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/034_chat_exports_executed_instrument.txt", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-23, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Maya Ellison.", "severity": "low"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/11_board_reporting/085_board_reporting_review_memorandum.json", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for board-reporting omission: one source states the applicable location is Clark County, Nevada, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to Nevada operations outside Clark County, Nevada.", "id": "F-13", "issue": "board-reporting omission", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/037_chat_exports_review_memorandum.json", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-23, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Rafael Okafor.", "severity": "critical"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/11_board_reporting/088_board_reporting_status_report.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for hotline classification error: one source states the threshold is 12% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 18% and produced a different exception result.", "id": "F-14", "issue": "hotline classification error", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/040_chat_exports_status_report.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-23, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Nora Chen.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/091_remediation_correspondence.eml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for expense support deficiency: one source states formal notice must use notices-granite_hospitality_trust@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-sable_ridge_interiors@example.test.", "id": "F-15", "issue": "expense support deficiency", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/06_expenses/043_expenses_correspondence.eml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-23, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Dominic Alvarez.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/094_remediation_formal_notice.xml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for remediation ownership gap: one source states the governed population contains 61 records through 2025-01-16, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 54 records through 2025-02-11.", "id": "F-16", "issue": "remediation ownership gap", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/06_expenses/046_expenses_formal_notice.xml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-23, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Priya Raman.", "severity": "medium"}], "matter_number": "CB-IV-2607", "prepared_for": "Granite Hospitality Trust", "schema_version": "1.0", "task_id": "cb100-027-granite-hospitality"}}, "metadata": {"benchmark": "CounselBench-100", "code_license": "Apache-2.0", "data_license": "CC-BY-4.0", "deadline": "2026-09-23", "document_count": 96, "jurisdiction": "Nevada", "matter_number": "CB-IV-2607", "mcp_commit": "9a96ea6e5913736f92b88345bf51caeaaa8e719f", "mcp_package": "@modelcontextprotocol/server-filesystem@2026.7.10", "practice_area": "internal-investigations", "reference_tool_calls": 46, "required_evidence_reads": 33, "synthetic": true, "venue": "Clark County, Nevada", "version": "2.0.0"}, "prompt": "You are independent investigations counsel for Granite Hospitality Trust. A counterparty challenged the client's internal summary, making cross-document reconciliation and precise citations essential. A renovation executive approved change orders for a related vendor while project chats and board reporting omit key ownership information. Decision due 2026-09-23. Nevada law governs; Clark County, Nevada is the forum. Flag cross-folder dependencies that would be invisible in a single-document review. Work out the defensible position from the matter production and leave an audit-ready exception tracker and concise advice for the supervising lawyer. Keep confirmed conflicts separate from open questions, cite the records that actually control each conclusion, and do not fill gaps with outside facts.", "rubric": {"criteria": [{"category": "procedure", "description": "Complete at least 46 successful, argument-specific evidence and output calls.", "id": "procedure.minimum_successful_tool_calls"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Find and read the 33 controlling, corroborating, and work-product-control records in full.", "id": "procedure.all_evidence_read_in_full"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Inspect file metadata for the eight designated critical primary records before relying on them.", "id": "procedure.chain_of_custody_metadata_checked"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Confirm the sandbox's allowed document and output roots.", "id": "procedure.allowed_directories_checked"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Inventory all 96 records so the relevant sources are discovered among the context records.", "id": "procedure.recursive_inventory_completed"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Search the production for email evidence that may corroborate or contradict formal records.", "id": "procedure.targeted_search_completed"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Leave only findings.json and advice.md in the output workspace.", "id": "procedure.exact_deliverable_set"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Create both final work products through the sandbox MCP surface.", "id": "procedure.deliverables_written_through_mcp"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Produce findings.json as a valid JSON object.", "id": "findings.findings_is_object"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Report exactly 16 confirmed exceptions.", "id": "findings.findings_exact_count"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Use each stable finding ID exactly once.", "id": "findings.finding_ids_unique"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set schema_version to the released matter value '1.0'.", "id": "findings.top_level_schema_version"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set task_id to the released matter value 'cb100-027-granite-hospitality'.", "id": "findings.top_level_task_id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set matter_number to the released matter value 'CB-IV-2607'.", "id": "findings.top_level_matter_number"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set prepared_for to the released matter value 'Granite Hospitality Trust'.", "id": "findings.top_level_prepared_for"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set as_of to the released matter value '2026-09-23'.", "id": "findings.top_level_as_of"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-01 exception for preservation delay.", "id": "findings.F-01.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's id from /workspace/documents/01_intake/001_intake_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_access_logs/049_access_logs_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's issue from /workspace/documents/01_intake/001_intake_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_access_logs/049_access_logs_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's severity from /workspace/documents/01_intake/001_intake_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_access_logs/049_access_logs_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's primary_source from /workspace/documents/01_intake/001_intake_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_access_logs/049_access_logs_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/01_intake/001_intake_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_access_logs/049_access_logs_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-01 using the exact controlled facts ['2025-04-08', 'CB-IV-2607-A915', '2025-05-12', 'CB-IV-2607-J508'].", "id": "findings.F-01.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-01's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-01.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-23', 'Adrian Mensah'] for F-01.", "id": "findings.F-01.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-02 exception for interview timeline conflict.", "id": "findings.F-02.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's id from /workspace/documents/01_intake/004_intake_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_access_logs/052_access_logs_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's issue from /workspace/documents/01_intake/004_intake_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_access_logs/052_access_logs_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's severity from /workspace/documents/01_intake/004_intake_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_access_logs/052_access_logs_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's primary_source from /workspace/documents/01_intake/004_intake_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_access_logs/052_access_logs_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/01_intake/004_intake_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_access_logs/052_access_logs_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-02 using the exact controlled facts ['$6,029,209.00', '$6,324,918.00'].", "id": "findings.F-02.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-02's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-02.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-23', 'Willa Novak'] for F-02.", "id": "findings.F-02.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-03 exception for undisclosed related party.", "id": "findings.F-03.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's id from /workspace/documents/01_intake/007_intake_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_access_logs/055_access_logs_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's issue from /workspace/documents/01_intake/007_intake_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_access_logs/055_access_logs_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's severity from /workspace/documents/01_intake/007_intake_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_access_logs/055_access_logs_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's primary_source from /workspace/documents/01_intake/007_intake_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_access_logs/055_access_logs_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/01_intake/007_intake_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_access_logs/055_access_logs_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-03 using the exact controlled facts ['Mei Whitaker', 'Owen Delgado'].", "id": "findings.F-03.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-03's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-03.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-23', 'Theo Laurent'] for F-03.", "id": "findings.F-03.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-04 exception for split-purchase pattern.", "id": "findings.F-04.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's id from /workspace/documents/02_preservation/010_preservation_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_vendor_files/058_vendor_files_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's issue from /workspace/documents/02_preservation/010_preservation_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_vendor_files/058_vendor_files_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's severity from /workspace/documents/02_preservation/010_preservation_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_vendor_files/058_vendor_files_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's primary_source from /workspace/documents/02_preservation/010_preservation_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_vendor_files/058_vendor_files_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/02_preservation/010_preservation_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_vendor_files/058_vendor_files_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-04 using the exact controlled facts ['closed without exception', 'CB-IV-2607-D999', 'open and escalated', 'CB-IV-2607-M792'].", "id": "findings.F-04.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-04's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-04.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-23', 'Amara Patel'] for F-04.", "id": "findings.F-04.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-05 exception for approval override.", "id": "findings.F-05.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's id from /workspace/documents/02_preservation/013_preservation_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_vendor_files/061_vendor_files_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's issue from /workspace/documents/02_preservation/013_preservation_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_vendor_files/061_vendor_files_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's severity from /workspace/documents/02_preservation/013_preservation_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_vendor_files/061_vendor_files_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's primary_source from /workspace/documents/02_preservation/013_preservation_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_vendor_files/061_vendor_files_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/02_preservation/013_preservation_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_vendor_files/061_vendor_files_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-05 using the exact controlled facts ['Clark County, Nevada', 'Nevada'].", "id": "findings.F-05.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-05's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-05.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-23', 'Henry Cho'] for F-05.", "id": "findings.F-05.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-06 exception for gift-policy threshold breach.", "id": "findings.F-06.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's id from /workspace/documents/02_preservation/016_preservation_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_vendor_files/064_vendor_files_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's issue from /workspace/documents/02_preservation/016_preservation_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_vendor_files/064_vendor_files_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's severity from /workspace/documents/02_preservation/016_preservation_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_vendor_files/064_vendor_files_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's primary_source from /workspace/documents/02_preservation/016_preservation_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_vendor_files/064_vendor_files_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/02_preservation/016_preservation_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_vendor_files/064_vendor_files_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-06 using the exact controlled facts ['15%', '22%'].", "id": "findings.F-06.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-06's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-06.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-23', 'Nadine Flores'] for F-06.", "id": "findings.F-06.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-07 exception for off-channel communication.", "id": "findings.F-07.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's id from /workspace/documents/03_interviews/019_interviews_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_policies/067_policies_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's issue from /workspace/documents/03_interviews/019_interviews_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_policies/067_policies_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's severity from /workspace/documents/03_interviews/019_interviews_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_policies/067_policies_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's primary_source from /workspace/documents/03_interviews/019_interviews_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_policies/067_policies_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/03_interviews/019_interviews_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_policies/067_policies_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-07 using the exact controlled facts ['notices-granite_hospitality_trust@example.test', 'archive-sable_ridge_interiors@example.test'].", "id": "findings.F-07.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-07's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-07.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-23', 'Micah Sullivan'] for F-07.", "id": "findings.F-07.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-08 exception for deleted-message anomaly.", "id": "findings.F-08.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's id from /workspace/documents/03_interviews/022_interviews_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_policies/070_policies_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's issue from /workspace/documents/03_interviews/022_interviews_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_policies/070_policies_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's severity from /workspace/documents/03_interviews/022_interviews_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_policies/070_policies_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's primary_source from /workspace/documents/03_interviews/022_interviews_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_policies/070_policies_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/03_interviews/022_interviews_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_policies/070_policies_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-08 using the exact controlled facts ['82 records', '2025-06-26', '75 records', '2025-08-12'].", "id": "findings.F-08.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-08's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-08.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-23', 'Farah Ibrahim'] for F-08.", "id": "findings.F-08.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-09 exception for badge-log inconsistency.", "id": "findings.F-09.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's id from /workspace/documents/04_email_exports/025_email_exports_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_hr_records/073_hr_records_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's issue from /workspace/documents/04_email_exports/025_email_exports_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_hr_records/073_hr_records_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's severity from /workspace/documents/04_email_exports/025_email_exports_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_hr_records/073_hr_records_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's primary_source from /workspace/documents/04_email_exports/025_email_exports_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_hr_records/073_hr_records_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/04_email_exports/025_email_exports_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_hr_records/073_hr_records_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-09 using the exact controlled facts ['2025-01-17', 'CB-IV-2607-I954', '2025-02-19', 'CB-IV-2607-R996'].", "id": "findings.F-09.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-09's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-09.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-23', 'Owen Delgado'] for F-09.", "id": "findings.F-09.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-10 exception for vendor due-diligence gap.", "id": "findings.F-10.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's id from /workspace/documents/04_email_exports/028_email_exports_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_hr_records/076_hr_records_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's issue from /workspace/documents/04_email_exports/028_email_exports_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_hr_records/076_hr_records_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's severity from /workspace/documents/04_email_exports/028_email_exports_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_hr_records/076_hr_records_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's primary_source from /workspace/documents/04_email_exports/028_email_exports_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_hr_records/076_hr_records_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/04_email_exports/028_email_exports_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_hr_records/076_hr_records_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-10 using the exact controlled facts ['$4,308,947.00', '$4,344,394.00'].", "id": "findings.F-10.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-10's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-10.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-23', 'Lena Varga'] for F-10.", "id": "findings.F-10.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-11 exception for retaliation concern.", "id": "findings.F-11.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's id from /workspace/documents/04_email_exports/031_email_exports_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_hr_records/079_hr_records_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's issue from /workspace/documents/04_email_exports/031_email_exports_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_hr_records/079_hr_records_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's severity from /workspace/documents/04_email_exports/031_email_exports_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_hr_records/079_hr_records_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's primary_source from /workspace/documents/04_email_exports/031_email_exports_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_hr_records/079_hr_records_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/04_email_exports/031_email_exports_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_hr_records/079_hr_records_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-11 using the exact controlled facts ['Mei Whitaker', 'Adrian Mensah'].", "id": "findings.F-11.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-11's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-11.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-23', 'Samuel Kim'] for F-11.", "id": "findings.F-11.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-12 exception for policy training lapse.", "id": "findings.F-12.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's id from /workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/034_chat_exports_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_board_reporting/082_board_reporting_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's issue from /workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/034_chat_exports_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_board_reporting/082_board_reporting_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's severity from /workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/034_chat_exports_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_board_reporting/082_board_reporting_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's primary_source from /workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/034_chat_exports_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_board_reporting/082_board_reporting_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/034_chat_exports_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_board_reporting/082_board_reporting_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-12 using the exact controlled facts ['closed without exception', 'CB-IV-2607-L399', 'open and escalated', 'CB-IV-2607-U469'].", "id": "findings.F-12.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-12's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-12.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-23', 'Maya Ellison'] for F-12.", "id": "findings.F-12.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-13 exception for board-reporting omission.", "id": "findings.F-13.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's id from /workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/037_chat_exports_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_board_reporting/085_board_reporting_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's issue from /workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/037_chat_exports_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_board_reporting/085_board_reporting_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's severity from /workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/037_chat_exports_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_board_reporting/085_board_reporting_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's primary_source from /workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/037_chat_exports_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_board_reporting/085_board_reporting_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/037_chat_exports_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_board_reporting/085_board_reporting_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-13 using the exact controlled facts ['Clark County, Nevada', 'Nevada'].", "id": "findings.F-13.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-13's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-13.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-23', 'Rafael Okafor'] for F-13.", "id": "findings.F-13.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-14 exception for hotline classification error.", "id": "findings.F-14.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's id from /workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/040_chat_exports_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_board_reporting/088_board_reporting_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's issue from /workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/040_chat_exports_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_board_reporting/088_board_reporting_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's severity from /workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/040_chat_exports_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_board_reporting/088_board_reporting_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's primary_source from /workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/040_chat_exports_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_board_reporting/088_board_reporting_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/040_chat_exports_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_board_reporting/088_board_reporting_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-14 using the exact controlled facts ['12%', '18%'].", "id": "findings.F-14.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-14's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-14.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-23', 'Nora Chen'] for F-14.", "id": "findings.F-14.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-15 exception for expense support deficiency.", "id": "findings.F-15.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's id from /workspace/documents/06_expenses/043_expenses_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_remediation/091_remediation_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's issue from /workspace/documents/06_expenses/043_expenses_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_remediation/091_remediation_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's severity from /workspace/documents/06_expenses/043_expenses_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_remediation/091_remediation_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's primary_source from /workspace/documents/06_expenses/043_expenses_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_remediation/091_remediation_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/06_expenses/043_expenses_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_remediation/091_remediation_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-15 using the exact controlled facts ['notices-granite_hospitality_trust@example.test', 'archive-sable_ridge_interiors@example.test'].", "id": "findings.F-15.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-15's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-15.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-23', 'Dominic Alvarez'] for F-15.", "id": "findings.F-15.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-16 exception for remediation ownership gap.", "id": "findings.F-16.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's id from /workspace/documents/06_expenses/046_expenses_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_remediation/094_remediation_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's issue from /workspace/documents/06_expenses/046_expenses_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_remediation/094_remediation_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's severity from /workspace/documents/06_expenses/046_expenses_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_remediation/094_remediation_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's primary_source from /workspace/documents/06_expenses/046_expenses_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_remediation/094_remediation_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/06_expenses/046_expenses_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_remediation/094_remediation_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-16 using the exact controlled facts ['61 records', '2025-01-16', '54 records', '2025-02-11'].", "id": "findings.F-16.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-16's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-16.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-23', 'Priya Raman'] for F-16.", "id": "findings.F-16.action_anchors"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Executive assessment' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Executive assessment"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Method and record coverage' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Method and record coverage"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Findings' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Findings"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Recommended next actions' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Recommended next actions"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Assumptions and limitations' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Assumptions and limitations"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-01 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-01"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-02 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-02"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-03 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-03"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-04 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-04"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-05 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-05"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-06 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-06"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-07 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-07"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-08 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-08"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-09 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-09"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-10 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-10"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-11 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-11"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-12 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-12"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-13 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-13"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-14 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-14"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-15 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-15"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-16 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-16"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Do not claim the production has no issues or that every record is consistent.", "id": "memo.forbidden_claims_absent"}], "decision_options": [{"id": "cross-source-reconciliation", "label": "Reconcile controlling and corroborating records", "reason": "The CB-IV-2607 production contains independently maintained records; a defensible answer must preserve each supported conflict and its cure owner.", "selected": true}, {"id": "latest-record-controls", "label": "Treat the latest record as controlling", "reason": "Timestamp recency does not establish legal priority, execution, or approval authority.", "selected": false}, {"id": "primary-records-only", "label": "Report primary records without reconciliation", "reason": "Primary records alone conceal the operational conflicts that create the actionable exceptions.", "selected": false}], "gates": ["all_evidence_read_in_full", "chain_of_custody_metadata_checked", "findings_criteria_complete", "memo_criteria_complete", "deliverables_written_through_mcp"], "metadata_checks": 8, "metric": "weighted_criteria_score", "minimum_tool_calls": 46, "required_deliverables": ["findings.json", "advice.md"], "required_document_reads": 33, "type": "deterministic", "weights": {"findings": 0.55, "memo": 0.2, "procedure": 0.25}}, "task_id": "cb100-027-granite-hospitality", "task_name": "Granite hotel renovation inquiry", "world_id": "counselbench-filesystem-mcp-v2"}
-{"context_files": ["task_files/cb100-028-horizon-relief/01_intake/001_intake_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-028-horizon-relief/01_intake/002_intake_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-028-horizon-relief/01_intake/003_intake_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-028-horizon-relief/01_intake/004_intake_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-028-horizon-relief/01_intake/005_intake_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-028-horizon-relief/01_intake/006_intake_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-028-horizon-relief/01_intake/007_intake_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-028-horizon-relief/01_intake/008_intake_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-028-horizon-relief/02_preservation/009_preservation_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-028-horizon-relief/02_preservation/010_preservation_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-028-horizon-relief/02_preservation/011_preservation_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-028-horizon-relief/02_preservation/012_preservation_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-028-horizon-relief/02_preservation/013_preservation_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-028-horizon-relief/02_preservation/014_preservation_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-028-horizon-relief/02_preservation/015_preservation_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-028-horizon-relief/02_preservation/016_preservation_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-028-horizon-relief/03_interviews/017_interviews_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-028-horizon-relief/03_interviews/018_interviews_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-028-horizon-relief/03_interviews/019_interviews_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-028-horizon-relief/03_interviews/020_interviews_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-028-horizon-relief/03_interviews/021_interviews_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-028-horizon-relief/03_interviews/022_interviews_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-028-horizon-relief/03_interviews/023_interviews_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-028-horizon-relief/03_interviews/024_interviews_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-028-horizon-relief/04_email_exports/025_email_exports_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-028-horizon-relief/04_email_exports/026_email_exports_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-028-horizon-relief/04_email_exports/027_email_exports_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-028-horizon-relief/04_email_exports/028_email_exports_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-028-horizon-relief/04_email_exports/029_email_exports_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-028-horizon-relief/04_email_exports/030_email_exports_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-028-horizon-relief/04_email_exports/031_email_exports_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-028-horizon-relief/04_email_exports/032_email_exports_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-028-horizon-relief/05_chat_exports/033_chat_exports_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-028-horizon-relief/05_chat_exports/034_chat_exports_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-028-horizon-relief/05_chat_exports/035_chat_exports_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-028-horizon-relief/05_chat_exports/036_chat_exports_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-028-horizon-relief/05_chat_exports/037_chat_exports_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-028-horizon-relief/05_chat_exports/038_chat_exports_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-028-horizon-relief/05_chat_exports/039_chat_exports_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-028-horizon-relief/05_chat_exports/040_chat_exports_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-028-horizon-relief/06_expenses/041_expenses_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-028-horizon-relief/06_expenses/042_expenses_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-028-horizon-relief/06_expenses/043_expenses_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-028-horizon-relief/06_expenses/044_expenses_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-028-horizon-relief/06_expenses/045_expenses_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-028-horizon-relief/06_expenses/046_expenses_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-028-horizon-relief/06_expenses/047_expenses_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-028-horizon-relief/06_expenses/048_expenses_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-028-horizon-relief/07_access_logs/049_access_logs_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-028-horizon-relief/07_access_logs/050_access_logs_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-028-horizon-relief/07_access_logs/051_access_logs_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-028-horizon-relief/07_access_logs/052_access_logs_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-028-horizon-relief/07_access_logs/053_access_logs_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-028-horizon-relief/07_access_logs/054_access_logs_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-028-horizon-relief/07_access_logs/055_access_logs_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-028-horizon-relief/07_access_logs/056_access_logs_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-028-horizon-relief/08_vendor_files/057_vendor_files_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-028-horizon-relief/08_vendor_files/058_vendor_files_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-028-horizon-relief/08_vendor_files/059_vendor_files_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-028-horizon-relief/08_vendor_files/060_vendor_files_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-028-horizon-relief/08_vendor_files/061_vendor_files_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-028-horizon-relief/08_vendor_files/062_vendor_files_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-028-horizon-relief/08_vendor_files/063_vendor_files_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-028-horizon-relief/08_vendor_files/064_vendor_files_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-028-horizon-relief/09_policies/065_policies_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-028-horizon-relief/09_policies/066_policies_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-028-horizon-relief/09_policies/067_policies_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-028-horizon-relief/09_policies/068_policies_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-028-horizon-relief/09_policies/069_policies_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-028-horizon-relief/09_policies/070_policies_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-028-horizon-relief/09_policies/071_policies_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-028-horizon-relief/09_policies/072_policies_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-028-horizon-relief/10_hr_records/073_hr_records_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-028-horizon-relief/10_hr_records/074_hr_records_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-028-horizon-relief/10_hr_records/075_hr_records_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-028-horizon-relief/10_hr_records/076_hr_records_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-028-horizon-relief/10_hr_records/077_hr_records_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-028-horizon-relief/10_hr_records/078_hr_records_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-028-horizon-relief/10_hr_records/079_hr_records_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-028-horizon-relief/10_hr_records/080_hr_records_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-028-horizon-relief/11_board_reporting/081_board_reporting_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-028-horizon-relief/11_board_reporting/082_board_reporting_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-028-horizon-relief/11_board_reporting/083_board_reporting_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-028-horizon-relief/11_board_reporting/084_board_reporting_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-028-horizon-relief/11_board_reporting/085_board_reporting_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-028-horizon-relief/11_board_reporting/086_board_reporting_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-028-horizon-relief/11_board_reporting/087_board_reporting_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-028-horizon-relief/11_board_reporting/088_board_reporting_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-028-horizon-relief/12_remediation/089_remediation_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-028-horizon-relief/12_remediation/090_remediation_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-028-horizon-relief/12_remediation/091_remediation_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-028-horizon-relief/12_remediation/092_remediation_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-028-horizon-relief/12_remediation/093_remediation_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-028-horizon-relief/12_remediation/094_remediation_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-028-horizon-relief/12_remediation/095_remediation_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-028-horizon-relief/12_remediation/096_remediation_status_report.md"], "gold_output": {"advice_markdown": "# Counsel advice — Horizon grant-use investigation\n\n## Executive assessment\n\nFor Horizon Relief Foundation matter CB-IV-2608, the review identified 16 source-supported exceptions requiring action before 2026-09-27. The assessment concerns Fieldstone Logistics NGO and the supplied record for District of Columbia.\n\n## Method and record coverage\n\nThe review inventoried all 96 production files, read the 33 controlling, corroborating, and control records, searched the email exports, and checked metadata for the designated chain-of-custody sample. Conclusions are limited to the synthetic production supplied for this benchmark matter.\n\n## Findings\n\n### F-01 — preservation delay (critical)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for preservation delay: one source states the operative date is 2025-04-10 under control reference CB-IV-2608-A377, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2025-05-17 under response reference CB-IV-2608-J675.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/01_intake/001_intake_control_register.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/07_access_logs/049_access_logs_control_register.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-27, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Willa Novak.\n\n### F-02 — interview timeline conflict (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for interview timeline conflict: one source states the controlling amount is $2,317,641.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $2,441,782.00.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/01_intake/004_intake_ledger_export.csv`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/07_access_logs/052_access_logs_ledger_export.csv`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-27, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Theo Laurent.\n\n### F-03 — undisclosed related party (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for undisclosed related party: one source states approval is attributed to Caleb Hassan as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Samuel Kim and contains no entry for Caleb Hassan.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/01_intake/007_intake_officer_certificate.html`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/07_access_logs/055_access_logs_officer_certificate.html`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-27, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Amara Patel.\n\n### F-04 — split-purchase pattern (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for split-purchase pattern: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-IV-2608-D296, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-IV-2608-M461.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/02_preservation/010_preservation_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/08_vendor_files/058_vendor_files_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-27, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Henry Cho.\n\n### F-05 — approval override (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for approval override: one source states the applicable location is Washington, District of Columbia, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to District of Columbia operations outside Washington, District of Columbia.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/02_preservation/013_preservation_review_memorandum.json`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/08_vendor_files/061_vendor_files_review_memorandum.json`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-27, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Nadine Flores.\n\n### F-06 — gift-policy threshold breach (low)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for gift-policy threshold breach: one source states the threshold is 3% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 10% and produced a different exception result.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/02_preservation/016_preservation_status_report.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/08_vendor_files/064_vendor_files_status_report.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-27, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Micah Sullivan.\n\n### F-07 — off-channel communication (critical)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for off-channel communication: one source states formal notice must use notices-horizon_relief_foundation@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-fieldstone_logistics_ngo@example.test.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/03_interviews/019_interviews_correspondence.eml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/09_policies/067_policies_correspondence.eml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-27, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Farah Ibrahim.\n\n### F-08 — deleted-message anomaly (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for deleted-message anomaly: one source states the governed population contains 86 records through 2025-06-30, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 60 records through 2025-08-01.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/03_interviews/022_interviews_formal_notice.xml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/09_policies/070_policies_formal_notice.xml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-27, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Owen Delgado.\n\n### F-09 — badge-log inconsistency (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for badge-log inconsistency: one source states the operative date is 2025-05-03 under control reference CB-IV-2608-I580, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2025-05-22 under response reference CB-IV-2608-R829.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/04_email_exports/025_email_exports_control_register.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/10_hr_records/073_hr_records_control_register.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-27, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Lena Varga.\n\n### F-10 — vendor due-diligence gap (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for vendor due-diligence gap: one source states the controlling amount is $4,410,406.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $4,477,312.00.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/04_email_exports/028_email_exports_ledger_export.csv`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/10_hr_records/076_hr_records_ledger_export.csv`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-27, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Samuel Kim.\n\n### F-11 — retaliation concern (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for retaliation concern: one source states approval is attributed to Caleb Hassan as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Theo Laurent and contains no entry for Caleb Hassan.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/04_email_exports/031_email_exports_officer_certificate.html`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/10_hr_records/079_hr_records_officer_certificate.html`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-27, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Maya Ellison.\n\n### F-12 — policy training lapse (low)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for policy training lapse: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-IV-2608-L401, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-IV-2608-U884.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/034_chat_exports_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/11_board_reporting/082_board_reporting_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-27, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Rafael Okafor.\n\n### F-13 — board-reporting omission (critical)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for board-reporting omission: one source states the applicable location is Washington, District of Columbia, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to District of Columbia operations outside Washington, District of Columbia.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/037_chat_exports_review_memorandum.json`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/11_board_reporting/085_board_reporting_review_memorandum.json`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-27, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Nora Chen.\n\n### F-14 — hotline classification error (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for hotline classification error: one source states the threshold is 4% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 6% and produced a different exception result.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/040_chat_exports_status_report.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/11_board_reporting/088_board_reporting_status_report.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-27, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Dominic Alvarez.\n\n### F-15 — expense support deficiency (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for expense support deficiency: one source states formal notice must use notices-horizon_relief_foundation@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-fieldstone_logistics_ngo@example.test.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/06_expenses/043_expenses_correspondence.eml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/12_remediation/091_remediation_correspondence.eml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-27, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Priya Raman.\n\n### F-16 — remediation ownership gap (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for remediation ownership gap: one source states the governed population contains 176 records through 2026-02-15, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 53 records through 2026-03-12.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/06_expenses/046_expenses_formal_notice.xml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/12_remediation/094_remediation_formal_notice.xml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-27, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Elliot Mercer.\n\n## Recommended next actions\n\nSequence the critical and high findings first, assign the named owners, preserve the cited records, and document any resolution in the controlling matter register before the stated deadline.\n\n## Assumptions and limitations\n\nThis analysis is confined to task cb100-028-horizon-relief and the supplied synthetic evidence. It does not rely on external facts, does not resolve disputed law, and is not legal advice for a real person or entity.\n", "findings": {"as_of": "2026-09-27", "findings": [{"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/07_access_logs/049_access_logs_control_register.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for preservation delay: one source states the operative date is 2025-04-10 under control reference CB-IV-2608-A377, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2025-05-17 under response reference CB-IV-2608-J675.", "id": "F-01", "issue": "preservation delay", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/01_intake/001_intake_control_register.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-27, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Willa Novak.", "severity": "critical"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/07_access_logs/052_access_logs_ledger_export.csv", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for interview timeline conflict: one source states the controlling amount is $2,317,641.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $2,441,782.00.", "id": "F-02", "issue": "interview timeline conflict", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/01_intake/004_intake_ledger_export.csv", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-27, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Theo Laurent.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/07_access_logs/055_access_logs_officer_certificate.html", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for undisclosed related party: one source states approval is attributed to Caleb Hassan as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Samuel Kim and contains no entry for Caleb Hassan.", "id": "F-03", "issue": "undisclosed related party", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/01_intake/007_intake_officer_certificate.html", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-27, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Amara Patel.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/08_vendor_files/058_vendor_files_executed_instrument.txt", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for split-purchase pattern: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-IV-2608-D296, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-IV-2608-M461.", "id": "F-04", "issue": "split-purchase pattern", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/02_preservation/010_preservation_executed_instrument.txt", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-27, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Henry Cho.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/08_vendor_files/061_vendor_files_review_memorandum.json", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for approval override: one source states the applicable location is Washington, District of Columbia, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to District of Columbia operations outside Washington, District of Columbia.", "id": "F-05", "issue": "approval override", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/02_preservation/013_preservation_review_memorandum.json", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-27, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Nadine Flores.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/08_vendor_files/064_vendor_files_status_report.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for gift-policy threshold breach: one source states the threshold is 3% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 10% and produced a different exception result.", "id": "F-06", "issue": "gift-policy threshold breach", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/02_preservation/016_preservation_status_report.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-27, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Micah Sullivan.", "severity": "low"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/09_policies/067_policies_correspondence.eml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for off-channel communication: one source states formal notice must use notices-horizon_relief_foundation@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-fieldstone_logistics_ngo@example.test.", "id": "F-07", "issue": "off-channel communication", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/03_interviews/019_interviews_correspondence.eml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-27, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Farah Ibrahim.", "severity": "critical"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/09_policies/070_policies_formal_notice.xml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for deleted-message anomaly: one source states the governed population contains 86 records through 2025-06-30, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 60 records through 2025-08-01.", "id": "F-08", "issue": "deleted-message anomaly", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/03_interviews/022_interviews_formal_notice.xml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-27, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Owen Delgado.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/10_hr_records/073_hr_records_control_register.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for badge-log inconsistency: one source states the operative date is 2025-05-03 under control reference CB-IV-2608-I580, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2025-05-22 under response reference CB-IV-2608-R829.", "id": "F-09", "issue": "badge-log inconsistency", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/04_email_exports/025_email_exports_control_register.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-27, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Lena Varga.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/10_hr_records/076_hr_records_ledger_export.csv", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for vendor due-diligence gap: one source states the controlling amount is $4,410,406.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $4,477,312.00.", "id": "F-10", "issue": "vendor due-diligence gap", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/04_email_exports/028_email_exports_ledger_export.csv", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-27, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Samuel Kim.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/10_hr_records/079_hr_records_officer_certificate.html", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for retaliation concern: one source states approval is attributed to Caleb Hassan as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Theo Laurent and contains no entry for Caleb Hassan.", "id": "F-11", "issue": "retaliation concern", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/04_email_exports/031_email_exports_officer_certificate.html", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-27, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Maya Ellison.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/11_board_reporting/082_board_reporting_executed_instrument.txt", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for policy training lapse: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-IV-2608-L401, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-IV-2608-U884.", "id": "F-12", "issue": "policy training lapse", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/034_chat_exports_executed_instrument.txt", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-27, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Rafael Okafor.", "severity": "low"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/11_board_reporting/085_board_reporting_review_memorandum.json", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for board-reporting omission: one source states the applicable location is Washington, District of Columbia, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to District of Columbia operations outside Washington, District of Columbia.", "id": "F-13", "issue": "board-reporting omission", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/037_chat_exports_review_memorandum.json", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-27, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Nora Chen.", "severity": "critical"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/11_board_reporting/088_board_reporting_status_report.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for hotline classification error: one source states the threshold is 4% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 6% and produced a different exception result.", "id": "F-14", "issue": "hotline classification error", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/040_chat_exports_status_report.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-27, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Dominic Alvarez.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/091_remediation_correspondence.eml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for expense support deficiency: one source states formal notice must use notices-horizon_relief_foundation@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-fieldstone_logistics_ngo@example.test.", "id": "F-15", "issue": "expense support deficiency", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/06_expenses/043_expenses_correspondence.eml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-27, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Priya Raman.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/094_remediation_formal_notice.xml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for remediation ownership gap: one source states the governed population contains 176 records through 2026-02-15, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 53 records through 2026-03-12.", "id": "F-16", "issue": "remediation ownership gap", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/06_expenses/046_expenses_formal_notice.xml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-27, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Elliot Mercer.", "severity": "medium"}], "matter_number": "CB-IV-2608", "prepared_for": "Horizon Relief Foundation", "schema_version": "1.0", "task_id": "cb100-028-horizon-relief"}}, "metadata": {"benchmark": "CounselBench-100", "code_license": "Apache-2.0", "data_license": "CC-BY-4.0", "deadline": "2026-09-27", "document_count": 96, "jurisdiction": "District of Columbia", "matter_number": "CB-IV-2608", "mcp_commit": "9a96ea6e5913736f92b88345bf51caeaaa8e719f", "mcp_package": "@modelcontextprotocol/server-filesystem@2026.7.10", "practice_area": "internal-investigations", "reference_tool_calls": 46, "required_evidence_reads": 33, "synthetic": true, "venue": "Washington, District of Columbia", "version": "2.0.0"}, "prompt": "You are independent investigations counsel for Horizon Relief Foundation. The supervising attorney wants an exception-focused review that still demonstrates complete coverage of the data room. Grant funds were rerouted through emergency vendors, with inconsistent delivery evidence and delayed reports to the audit committee. Decision due 2026-09-27. District of Columbia law governs; Washington, District of Columbia is the forum. Preserve the difference between the client's position, the counterparty's position, and an objective record conflict. Work out the defensible position from the matter production and leave an audit-ready exception tracker and concise advice for the supervising lawyer. Keep confirmed conflicts separate from open questions, cite the records that actually control each conclusion, and do not fill gaps with outside facts.", "rubric": {"criteria": [{"category": "procedure", "description": "Complete at least 46 successful, argument-specific evidence and output calls.", "id": "procedure.minimum_successful_tool_calls"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Find and read the 33 controlling, corroborating, and work-product-control records in full.", "id": "procedure.all_evidence_read_in_full"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Inspect file metadata for the eight designated critical primary records before relying on them.", "id": "procedure.chain_of_custody_metadata_checked"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Confirm the sandbox's allowed document and output roots.", "id": "procedure.allowed_directories_checked"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Inventory all 96 records so the relevant sources are discovered among the context records.", "id": "procedure.recursive_inventory_completed"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Search the production for email evidence that may corroborate or contradict formal records.", "id": "procedure.targeted_search_completed"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Leave only findings.json and advice.md in the output workspace.", "id": "procedure.exact_deliverable_set"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Create both final work products through the sandbox MCP surface.", "id": "procedure.deliverables_written_through_mcp"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Produce findings.json as a valid JSON object.", "id": "findings.findings_is_object"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Report exactly 16 confirmed exceptions.", "id": "findings.findings_exact_count"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Use each stable finding ID exactly once.", "id": "findings.finding_ids_unique"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set schema_version to the released matter value '1.0'.", "id": "findings.top_level_schema_version"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set task_id to the released matter value 'cb100-028-horizon-relief'.", "id": "findings.top_level_task_id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set matter_number to the released matter value 'CB-IV-2608'.", "id": "findings.top_level_matter_number"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set prepared_for to the released matter value 'Horizon Relief Foundation'.", "id": "findings.top_level_prepared_for"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set as_of to the released matter value '2026-09-27'.", "id": "findings.top_level_as_of"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-01 exception for preservation delay.", "id": "findings.F-01.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's id from /workspace/documents/01_intake/001_intake_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_access_logs/049_access_logs_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's issue from /workspace/documents/01_intake/001_intake_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_access_logs/049_access_logs_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's severity from /workspace/documents/01_intake/001_intake_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_access_logs/049_access_logs_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's primary_source from /workspace/documents/01_intake/001_intake_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_access_logs/049_access_logs_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/01_intake/001_intake_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_access_logs/049_access_logs_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-01 using the exact controlled facts ['2025-04-10', 'CB-IV-2608-A377', '2025-05-17', 'CB-IV-2608-J675'].", "id": "findings.F-01.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-01's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-01.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-27', 'Willa Novak'] for F-01.", "id": "findings.F-01.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-02 exception for interview timeline conflict.", "id": "findings.F-02.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's id from /workspace/documents/01_intake/004_intake_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_access_logs/052_access_logs_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's issue from /workspace/documents/01_intake/004_intake_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_access_logs/052_access_logs_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's severity from /workspace/documents/01_intake/004_intake_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_access_logs/052_access_logs_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's primary_source from /workspace/documents/01_intake/004_intake_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_access_logs/052_access_logs_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/01_intake/004_intake_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_access_logs/052_access_logs_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-02 using the exact controlled facts ['$2,317,641.00', '$2,441,782.00'].", "id": "findings.F-02.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-02's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-02.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-27', 'Theo Laurent'] for F-02.", "id": "findings.F-02.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-03 exception for undisclosed related party.", "id": "findings.F-03.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's id from /workspace/documents/01_intake/007_intake_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_access_logs/055_access_logs_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's issue from /workspace/documents/01_intake/007_intake_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_access_logs/055_access_logs_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's severity from /workspace/documents/01_intake/007_intake_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_access_logs/055_access_logs_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's primary_source from /workspace/documents/01_intake/007_intake_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_access_logs/055_access_logs_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/01_intake/007_intake_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_access_logs/055_access_logs_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-03 using the exact controlled facts ['Caleb Hassan', 'Samuel Kim'].", "id": "findings.F-03.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-03's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-03.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-27', 'Amara Patel'] for F-03.", "id": "findings.F-03.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-04 exception for split-purchase pattern.", "id": "findings.F-04.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's id from /workspace/documents/02_preservation/010_preservation_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_vendor_files/058_vendor_files_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's issue from /workspace/documents/02_preservation/010_preservation_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_vendor_files/058_vendor_files_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's severity from /workspace/documents/02_preservation/010_preservation_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_vendor_files/058_vendor_files_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's primary_source from /workspace/documents/02_preservation/010_preservation_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_vendor_files/058_vendor_files_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/02_preservation/010_preservation_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_vendor_files/058_vendor_files_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-04 using the exact controlled facts ['closed without exception', 'CB-IV-2608-D296', 'open and escalated', 'CB-IV-2608-M461'].", "id": "findings.F-04.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-04's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-04.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-27', 'Henry Cho'] for F-04.", "id": "findings.F-04.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-05 exception for approval override.", "id": "findings.F-05.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's id from /workspace/documents/02_preservation/013_preservation_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_vendor_files/061_vendor_files_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's issue from /workspace/documents/02_preservation/013_preservation_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_vendor_files/061_vendor_files_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's severity from /workspace/documents/02_preservation/013_preservation_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_vendor_files/061_vendor_files_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's primary_source from /workspace/documents/02_preservation/013_preservation_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_vendor_files/061_vendor_files_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/02_preservation/013_preservation_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_vendor_files/061_vendor_files_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-05 using the exact controlled facts ['Washington, District of Columbia', 'District of Columbia'].", "id": "findings.F-05.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-05's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-05.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-27', 'Nadine Flores'] for F-05.", "id": "findings.F-05.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-06 exception for gift-policy threshold breach.", "id": "findings.F-06.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's id from /workspace/documents/02_preservation/016_preservation_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_vendor_files/064_vendor_files_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's issue from /workspace/documents/02_preservation/016_preservation_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_vendor_files/064_vendor_files_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's severity from /workspace/documents/02_preservation/016_preservation_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_vendor_files/064_vendor_files_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's primary_source from /workspace/documents/02_preservation/016_preservation_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_vendor_files/064_vendor_files_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/02_preservation/016_preservation_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_vendor_files/064_vendor_files_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-06 using the exact controlled facts ['3%', '10%'].", "id": "findings.F-06.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-06's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-06.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-27', 'Micah Sullivan'] for F-06.", "id": "findings.F-06.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-07 exception for off-channel communication.", "id": "findings.F-07.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's id from /workspace/documents/03_interviews/019_interviews_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_policies/067_policies_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's issue from /workspace/documents/03_interviews/019_interviews_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_policies/067_policies_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's severity from /workspace/documents/03_interviews/019_interviews_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_policies/067_policies_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's primary_source from /workspace/documents/03_interviews/019_interviews_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_policies/067_policies_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/03_interviews/019_interviews_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_policies/067_policies_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-07 using the exact controlled facts ['notices-horizon_relief_foundation@example.test', 'archive-fieldstone_logistics_ngo@example.test'].", "id": "findings.F-07.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-07's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-07.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-27', 'Farah Ibrahim'] for F-07.", "id": "findings.F-07.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-08 exception for deleted-message anomaly.", "id": "findings.F-08.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's id from /workspace/documents/03_interviews/022_interviews_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_policies/070_policies_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's issue from /workspace/documents/03_interviews/022_interviews_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_policies/070_policies_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's severity from /workspace/documents/03_interviews/022_interviews_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_policies/070_policies_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's primary_source from /workspace/documents/03_interviews/022_interviews_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_policies/070_policies_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/03_interviews/022_interviews_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_policies/070_policies_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-08 using the exact controlled facts ['86 records', '2025-06-30', '60 records', '2025-08-01'].", "id": "findings.F-08.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-08's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-08.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-27', 'Owen Delgado'] for F-08.", "id": "findings.F-08.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-09 exception for badge-log inconsistency.", "id": "findings.F-09.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's id from /workspace/documents/04_email_exports/025_email_exports_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_hr_records/073_hr_records_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's issue from /workspace/documents/04_email_exports/025_email_exports_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_hr_records/073_hr_records_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's severity from /workspace/documents/04_email_exports/025_email_exports_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_hr_records/073_hr_records_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's primary_source from /workspace/documents/04_email_exports/025_email_exports_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_hr_records/073_hr_records_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/04_email_exports/025_email_exports_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_hr_records/073_hr_records_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-09 using the exact controlled facts ['2025-05-03', 'CB-IV-2608-I580', '2025-05-22', 'CB-IV-2608-R829'].", "id": "findings.F-09.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-09's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-09.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-27', 'Lena Varga'] for F-09.", "id": "findings.F-09.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-10 exception for vendor due-diligence gap.", "id": "findings.F-10.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's id from /workspace/documents/04_email_exports/028_email_exports_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_hr_records/076_hr_records_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's issue from /workspace/documents/04_email_exports/028_email_exports_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_hr_records/076_hr_records_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's severity from /workspace/documents/04_email_exports/028_email_exports_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_hr_records/076_hr_records_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's primary_source from /workspace/documents/04_email_exports/028_email_exports_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_hr_records/076_hr_records_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/04_email_exports/028_email_exports_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_hr_records/076_hr_records_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-10 using the exact controlled facts ['$4,410,406.00', '$4,477,312.00'].", "id": "findings.F-10.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-10's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-10.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-27', 'Samuel Kim'] for F-10.", "id": "findings.F-10.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-11 exception for retaliation concern.", "id": "findings.F-11.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's id from /workspace/documents/04_email_exports/031_email_exports_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_hr_records/079_hr_records_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's issue from /workspace/documents/04_email_exports/031_email_exports_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_hr_records/079_hr_records_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's severity from /workspace/documents/04_email_exports/031_email_exports_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_hr_records/079_hr_records_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's primary_source from /workspace/documents/04_email_exports/031_email_exports_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_hr_records/079_hr_records_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/04_email_exports/031_email_exports_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_hr_records/079_hr_records_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-11 using the exact controlled facts ['Caleb Hassan', 'Theo Laurent'].", "id": "findings.F-11.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-11's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-11.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-27', 'Maya Ellison'] for F-11.", "id": "findings.F-11.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-12 exception for policy training lapse.", "id": "findings.F-12.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's id from /workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/034_chat_exports_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_board_reporting/082_board_reporting_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's issue from /workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/034_chat_exports_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_board_reporting/082_board_reporting_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's severity from /workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/034_chat_exports_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_board_reporting/082_board_reporting_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's primary_source from /workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/034_chat_exports_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_board_reporting/082_board_reporting_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/034_chat_exports_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_board_reporting/082_board_reporting_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-12 using the exact controlled facts ['closed without exception', 'CB-IV-2608-L401', 'open and escalated', 'CB-IV-2608-U884'].", "id": "findings.F-12.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-12's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-12.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-27', 'Rafael Okafor'] for F-12.", "id": "findings.F-12.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-13 exception for board-reporting omission.", "id": "findings.F-13.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's id from /workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/037_chat_exports_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_board_reporting/085_board_reporting_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's issue from /workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/037_chat_exports_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_board_reporting/085_board_reporting_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's severity from /workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/037_chat_exports_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_board_reporting/085_board_reporting_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's primary_source from /workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/037_chat_exports_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_board_reporting/085_board_reporting_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/037_chat_exports_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_board_reporting/085_board_reporting_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-13 using the exact controlled facts ['Washington, District of Columbia', 'District of Columbia'].", "id": "findings.F-13.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-13's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-13.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-27', 'Nora Chen'] for F-13.", "id": "findings.F-13.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-14 exception for hotline classification error.", "id": "findings.F-14.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's id from /workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/040_chat_exports_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_board_reporting/088_board_reporting_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's issue from /workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/040_chat_exports_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_board_reporting/088_board_reporting_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's severity from /workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/040_chat_exports_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_board_reporting/088_board_reporting_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's primary_source from /workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/040_chat_exports_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_board_reporting/088_board_reporting_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/040_chat_exports_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_board_reporting/088_board_reporting_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-14 using the exact controlled facts ['4%', '6%'].", "id": "findings.F-14.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-14's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-14.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-27', 'Dominic Alvarez'] for F-14.", "id": "findings.F-14.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-15 exception for expense support deficiency.", "id": "findings.F-15.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's id from /workspace/documents/06_expenses/043_expenses_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_remediation/091_remediation_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's issue from /workspace/documents/06_expenses/043_expenses_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_remediation/091_remediation_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's severity from /workspace/documents/06_expenses/043_expenses_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_remediation/091_remediation_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's primary_source from /workspace/documents/06_expenses/043_expenses_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_remediation/091_remediation_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/06_expenses/043_expenses_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_remediation/091_remediation_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-15 using the exact controlled facts ['notices-horizon_relief_foundation@example.test', 'archive-fieldstone_logistics_ngo@example.test'].", "id": "findings.F-15.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-15's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-15.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-27', 'Priya Raman'] for F-15.", "id": "findings.F-15.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-16 exception for remediation ownership gap.", "id": "findings.F-16.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's id from /workspace/documents/06_expenses/046_expenses_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_remediation/094_remediation_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's issue from /workspace/documents/06_expenses/046_expenses_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_remediation/094_remediation_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's severity from /workspace/documents/06_expenses/046_expenses_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_remediation/094_remediation_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's primary_source from /workspace/documents/06_expenses/046_expenses_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_remediation/094_remediation_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/06_expenses/046_expenses_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_remediation/094_remediation_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-16 using the exact controlled facts ['176 records', '2026-02-15', '53 records', '2026-03-12'].", "id": "findings.F-16.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-16's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-16.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-27', 'Elliot Mercer'] for F-16.", "id": "findings.F-16.action_anchors"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Executive assessment' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Executive assessment"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Method and record coverage' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Method and record coverage"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Findings' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Findings"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Recommended next actions' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Recommended next actions"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Assumptions and limitations' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Assumptions and limitations"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-01 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-01"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-02 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-02"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-03 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-03"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-04 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-04"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-05 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-05"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-06 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-06"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-07 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-07"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-08 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-08"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-09 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-09"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-10 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-10"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-11 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-11"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-12 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-12"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-13 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-13"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-14 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-14"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-15 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-15"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-16 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-16"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Do not claim the production has no issues or that every record is consistent.", "id": "memo.forbidden_claims_absent"}], "decision_options": [{"id": "cross-source-reconciliation", "label": "Reconcile controlling and corroborating records", "reason": "The CB-IV-2608 production contains independently maintained records; a defensible answer must preserve each supported conflict and its cure owner.", "selected": true}, {"id": "latest-record-controls", "label": "Treat the latest record as controlling", "reason": "Timestamp recency does not establish legal priority, execution, or approval authority.", "selected": false}, {"id": "primary-records-only", "label": "Report primary records without reconciliation", "reason": "Primary records alone conceal the operational conflicts that create the actionable exceptions.", "selected": false}], "gates": ["all_evidence_read_in_full", "chain_of_custody_metadata_checked", "findings_criteria_complete", "memo_criteria_complete", "deliverables_written_through_mcp"], "metadata_checks": 8, "metric": "weighted_criteria_score", "minimum_tool_calls": 46, "required_deliverables": ["findings.json", "advice.md"], "required_document_reads": 33, "type": "deterministic", "weights": {"findings": 0.55, "memo": 0.2, "procedure": 0.25}}, "task_id": "cb100-028-horizon-relief", "task_name": "Horizon grant-use investigation", "world_id": "counselbench-filesystem-mcp-v2"}
-{"context_files": ["task_files/cb100-029-indigo-telecom/01_intake/001_intake_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-029-indigo-telecom/01_intake/002_intake_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-029-indigo-telecom/01_intake/003_intake_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-029-indigo-telecom/01_intake/004_intake_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-029-indigo-telecom/01_intake/005_intake_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-029-indigo-telecom/01_intake/006_intake_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-029-indigo-telecom/01_intake/007_intake_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-029-indigo-telecom/01_intake/008_intake_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-029-indigo-telecom/02_preservation/009_preservation_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-029-indigo-telecom/02_preservation/010_preservation_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-029-indigo-telecom/02_preservation/011_preservation_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-029-indigo-telecom/02_preservation/012_preservation_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-029-indigo-telecom/02_preservation/013_preservation_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-029-indigo-telecom/02_preservation/014_preservation_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-029-indigo-telecom/02_preservation/015_preservation_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-029-indigo-telecom/02_preservation/016_preservation_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-029-indigo-telecom/03_interviews/017_interviews_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-029-indigo-telecom/03_interviews/018_interviews_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-029-indigo-telecom/03_interviews/019_interviews_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-029-indigo-telecom/03_interviews/020_interviews_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-029-indigo-telecom/03_interviews/021_interviews_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-029-indigo-telecom/03_interviews/022_interviews_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-029-indigo-telecom/03_interviews/023_interviews_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-029-indigo-telecom/03_interviews/024_interviews_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-029-indigo-telecom/04_email_exports/025_email_exports_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-029-indigo-telecom/04_email_exports/026_email_exports_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-029-indigo-telecom/04_email_exports/027_email_exports_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-029-indigo-telecom/04_email_exports/028_email_exports_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-029-indigo-telecom/04_email_exports/029_email_exports_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-029-indigo-telecom/04_email_exports/030_email_exports_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-029-indigo-telecom/04_email_exports/031_email_exports_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-029-indigo-telecom/04_email_exports/032_email_exports_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-029-indigo-telecom/05_chat_exports/033_chat_exports_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-029-indigo-telecom/05_chat_exports/034_chat_exports_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-029-indigo-telecom/05_chat_exports/035_chat_exports_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-029-indigo-telecom/05_chat_exports/036_chat_exports_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-029-indigo-telecom/05_chat_exports/037_chat_exports_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-029-indigo-telecom/05_chat_exports/038_chat_exports_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-029-indigo-telecom/05_chat_exports/039_chat_exports_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-029-indigo-telecom/05_chat_exports/040_chat_exports_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-029-indigo-telecom/06_expenses/041_expenses_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-029-indigo-telecom/06_expenses/042_expenses_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-029-indigo-telecom/06_expenses/043_expenses_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-029-indigo-telecom/06_expenses/044_expenses_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-029-indigo-telecom/06_expenses/045_expenses_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-029-indigo-telecom/06_expenses/046_expenses_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-029-indigo-telecom/06_expenses/047_expenses_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-029-indigo-telecom/06_expenses/048_expenses_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-029-indigo-telecom/07_access_logs/049_access_logs_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-029-indigo-telecom/07_access_logs/050_access_logs_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-029-indigo-telecom/07_access_logs/051_access_logs_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-029-indigo-telecom/07_access_logs/052_access_logs_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-029-indigo-telecom/07_access_logs/053_access_logs_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-029-indigo-telecom/07_access_logs/054_access_logs_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-029-indigo-telecom/07_access_logs/055_access_logs_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-029-indigo-telecom/07_access_logs/056_access_logs_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-029-indigo-telecom/08_vendor_files/057_vendor_files_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-029-indigo-telecom/08_vendor_files/058_vendor_files_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-029-indigo-telecom/08_vendor_files/059_vendor_files_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-029-indigo-telecom/08_vendor_files/060_vendor_files_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-029-indigo-telecom/08_vendor_files/061_vendor_files_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-029-indigo-telecom/08_vendor_files/062_vendor_files_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-029-indigo-telecom/08_vendor_files/063_vendor_files_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-029-indigo-telecom/08_vendor_files/064_vendor_files_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-029-indigo-telecom/09_policies/065_policies_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-029-indigo-telecom/09_policies/066_policies_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-029-indigo-telecom/09_policies/067_policies_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-029-indigo-telecom/09_policies/068_policies_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-029-indigo-telecom/09_policies/069_policies_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-029-indigo-telecom/09_policies/070_policies_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-029-indigo-telecom/09_policies/071_policies_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-029-indigo-telecom/09_policies/072_policies_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-029-indigo-telecom/10_hr_records/073_hr_records_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-029-indigo-telecom/10_hr_records/074_hr_records_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-029-indigo-telecom/10_hr_records/075_hr_records_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-029-indigo-telecom/10_hr_records/076_hr_records_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-029-indigo-telecom/10_hr_records/077_hr_records_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-029-indigo-telecom/10_hr_records/078_hr_records_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-029-indigo-telecom/10_hr_records/079_hr_records_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-029-indigo-telecom/10_hr_records/080_hr_records_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-029-indigo-telecom/11_board_reporting/081_board_reporting_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-029-indigo-telecom/11_board_reporting/082_board_reporting_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-029-indigo-telecom/11_board_reporting/083_board_reporting_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-029-indigo-telecom/11_board_reporting/084_board_reporting_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-029-indigo-telecom/11_board_reporting/085_board_reporting_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-029-indigo-telecom/11_board_reporting/086_board_reporting_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-029-indigo-telecom/11_board_reporting/087_board_reporting_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-029-indigo-telecom/11_board_reporting/088_board_reporting_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-029-indigo-telecom/12_remediation/089_remediation_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-029-indigo-telecom/12_remediation/090_remediation_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-029-indigo-telecom/12_remediation/091_remediation_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-029-indigo-telecom/12_remediation/092_remediation_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-029-indigo-telecom/12_remediation/093_remediation_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-029-indigo-telecom/12_remediation/094_remediation_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-029-indigo-telecom/12_remediation/095_remediation_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-029-indigo-telecom/12_remediation/096_remediation_status_report.md"], "gold_output": {"advice_markdown": "# Counsel advice — Indigo channel-rebate inquiry\n\n## Executive assessment\n\nFor Indigo Telecom Americas matter CB-IV-2609, the review identified 16 source-supported exceptions requiring action before 2026-09-30. The assessment concerns Prairie Link Solutions and the supplied record for Texas.\n\n## Method and record coverage\n\nThe review inventoried all 96 production files, read the 33 controlling, corroborating, and control records, searched the email exports, and checked metadata for the designated chain-of-custody sample. Conclusions are limited to the synthetic production supplied for this benchmark matter.\n\n## Findings\n\n### F-01 — preservation delay (critical)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for preservation delay: one source states the operative date is 2025-05-18 under control reference CB-IV-2609-A175, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2025-06-24 under response reference CB-IV-2609-J451.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/01_intake/001_intake_control_register.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/07_access_logs/049_access_logs_control_register.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-30, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Theo Laurent.\n\n### F-02 — interview timeline conflict (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for interview timeline conflict: one source states the controlling amount is $1,625,347.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $1,717,194.00.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/01_intake/004_intake_ledger_export.csv`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/07_access_logs/052_access_logs_ledger_export.csv`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-30, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Amara Patel.\n\n### F-03 — undisclosed related party (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for undisclosed related party: one source states approval is attributed to Leona Park as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Rafael Okafor and contains no entry for Leona Park.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/01_intake/007_intake_officer_certificate.html`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/07_access_logs/055_access_logs_officer_certificate.html`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-30, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Henry Cho.\n\n### F-04 — split-purchase pattern (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for split-purchase pattern: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-IV-2609-D800, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-IV-2609-M707.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/02_preservation/010_preservation_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/08_vendor_files/058_vendor_files_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-30, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Nadine Flores.\n\n### F-05 — approval override (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for approval override: one source states the applicable location is Dallas County, Texas, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to Texas operations outside Dallas County, Texas.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/02_preservation/013_preservation_review_memorandum.json`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/08_vendor_files/061_vendor_files_review_memorandum.json`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-30, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Micah Sullivan.\n\n### F-06 — gift-policy threshold breach (low)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for gift-policy threshold breach: one source states the threshold is 3% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 6% and produced a different exception result.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/02_preservation/016_preservation_status_report.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/08_vendor_files/064_vendor_files_status_report.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-30, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Farah Ibrahim.\n\n### F-07 — off-channel communication (critical)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for off-channel communication: one source states formal notice must use notices-indigo_telecom_americas@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-prairie_link_solutions@example.test.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/03_interviews/019_interviews_correspondence.eml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/09_policies/067_policies_correspondence.eml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-30, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Owen Delgado.\n\n### F-08 — deleted-message anomaly (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for deleted-message anomaly: one source states the governed population contains 129 records through 2025-12-30, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 75 records through 2026-02-15.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/03_interviews/022_interviews_formal_notice.xml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/09_policies/070_policies_formal_notice.xml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-30, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Lena Varga.\n\n### F-09 — badge-log inconsistency (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for badge-log inconsistency: one source states the operative date is 2025-01-03 under control reference CB-IV-2609-I640, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2025-01-15 under response reference CB-IV-2609-R556.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/04_email_exports/025_email_exports_control_register.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/10_hr_records/073_hr_records_control_register.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-30, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Samuel Kim.\n\n### F-10 — vendor due-diligence gap (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for vendor due-diligence gap: one source states the controlling amount is $345,095.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $356,690.00.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/04_email_exports/028_email_exports_ledger_export.csv`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/10_hr_records/076_hr_records_ledger_export.csv`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-30, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Maya Ellison.\n\n### F-11 — retaliation concern (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for retaliation concern: one source states approval is attributed to Leona Park as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Henry Cho and contains no entry for Leona Park.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/04_email_exports/031_email_exports_officer_certificate.html`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/10_hr_records/079_hr_records_officer_certificate.html`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-30, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Rafael Okafor.\n\n### F-12 — policy training lapse (low)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for policy training lapse: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-IV-2609-L385, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-IV-2609-U537.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/034_chat_exports_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/11_board_reporting/082_board_reporting_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-30, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Nora Chen.\n\n### F-13 — board-reporting omission (critical)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for board-reporting omission: one source states the applicable location is Dallas County, Texas, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to Texas operations outside Dallas County, Texas.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/037_chat_exports_review_memorandum.json`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/11_board_reporting/085_board_reporting_review_memorandum.json`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-30, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Dominic Alvarez.\n\n### F-14 — hotline classification error (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for hotline classification error: one source states the threshold is 13% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 16% and produced a different exception result.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/040_chat_exports_status_report.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/11_board_reporting/088_board_reporting_status_report.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-30, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Priya Raman.\n\n### F-15 — expense support deficiency (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for expense support deficiency: one source states formal notice must use notices-indigo_telecom_americas@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-prairie_link_solutions@example.test.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/06_expenses/043_expenses_correspondence.eml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/12_remediation/091_remediation_correspondence.eml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-30, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Elliot Mercer.\n\n### F-16 — remediation ownership gap (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for remediation ownership gap: one source states the governed population contains 184 records through 2026-02-23, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 50 records through 2026-03-17.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/06_expenses/046_expenses_formal_notice.xml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/12_remediation/094_remediation_formal_notice.xml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-30, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Talia Brooks.\n\n## Recommended next actions\n\nSequence the critical and high findings first, assign the named owners, preserve the cited records, and document any resolution in the controlling matter register before the stated deadline.\n\n## Assumptions and limitations\n\nThis analysis is confined to task cb100-029-indigo-telecom and the supplied synthetic evidence. It does not rely on external facts, does not resolve disputed law, and is not legal advice for a real person or entity.\n", "findings": {"as_of": "2026-09-30", "findings": [{"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/07_access_logs/049_access_logs_control_register.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for preservation delay: one source states the operative date is 2025-05-18 under control reference CB-IV-2609-A175, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2025-06-24 under response reference CB-IV-2609-J451.", "id": "F-01", "issue": "preservation delay", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/01_intake/001_intake_control_register.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-30, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Theo Laurent.", "severity": "critical"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/07_access_logs/052_access_logs_ledger_export.csv", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for interview timeline conflict: one source states the controlling amount is $1,625,347.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $1,717,194.00.", "id": "F-02", "issue": "interview timeline conflict", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/01_intake/004_intake_ledger_export.csv", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-30, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Amara Patel.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/07_access_logs/055_access_logs_officer_certificate.html", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for undisclosed related party: one source states approval is attributed to Leona Park as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Rafael Okafor and contains no entry for Leona Park.", "id": "F-03", "issue": "undisclosed related party", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/01_intake/007_intake_officer_certificate.html", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-30, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Henry Cho.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/08_vendor_files/058_vendor_files_executed_instrument.txt", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for split-purchase pattern: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-IV-2609-D800, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-IV-2609-M707.", "id": "F-04", "issue": "split-purchase pattern", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/02_preservation/010_preservation_executed_instrument.txt", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-30, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Nadine Flores.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/08_vendor_files/061_vendor_files_review_memorandum.json", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for approval override: one source states the applicable location is Dallas County, Texas, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to Texas operations outside Dallas County, Texas.", "id": "F-05", "issue": "approval override", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/02_preservation/013_preservation_review_memorandum.json", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-30, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Micah Sullivan.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/08_vendor_files/064_vendor_files_status_report.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for gift-policy threshold breach: one source states the threshold is 3% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 6% and produced a different exception result.", "id": "F-06", "issue": "gift-policy threshold breach", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/02_preservation/016_preservation_status_report.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-30, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Farah Ibrahim.", "severity": "low"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/09_policies/067_policies_correspondence.eml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for off-channel communication: one source states formal notice must use notices-indigo_telecom_americas@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-prairie_link_solutions@example.test.", "id": "F-07", "issue": "off-channel communication", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/03_interviews/019_interviews_correspondence.eml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-30, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Owen Delgado.", "severity": "critical"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/09_policies/070_policies_formal_notice.xml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for deleted-message anomaly: one source states the governed population contains 129 records through 2025-12-30, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 75 records through 2026-02-15.", "id": "F-08", "issue": "deleted-message anomaly", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/03_interviews/022_interviews_formal_notice.xml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-30, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Lena Varga.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/10_hr_records/073_hr_records_control_register.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for badge-log inconsistency: one source states the operative date is 2025-01-03 under control reference CB-IV-2609-I640, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2025-01-15 under response reference CB-IV-2609-R556.", "id": "F-09", "issue": "badge-log inconsistency", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/04_email_exports/025_email_exports_control_register.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-30, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Samuel Kim.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/10_hr_records/076_hr_records_ledger_export.csv", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for vendor due-diligence gap: one source states the controlling amount is $345,095.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $356,690.00.", "id": "F-10", "issue": "vendor due-diligence gap", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/04_email_exports/028_email_exports_ledger_export.csv", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-30, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Maya Ellison.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/10_hr_records/079_hr_records_officer_certificate.html", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for retaliation concern: one source states approval is attributed to Leona Park as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Henry Cho and contains no entry for Leona Park.", "id": "F-11", "issue": "retaliation concern", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/04_email_exports/031_email_exports_officer_certificate.html", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-30, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Rafael Okafor.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/11_board_reporting/082_board_reporting_executed_instrument.txt", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for policy training lapse: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-IV-2609-L385, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-IV-2609-U537.", "id": "F-12", "issue": "policy training lapse", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/034_chat_exports_executed_instrument.txt", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-30, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Nora Chen.", "severity": "low"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/11_board_reporting/085_board_reporting_review_memorandum.json", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for board-reporting omission: one source states the applicable location is Dallas County, Texas, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to Texas operations outside Dallas County, Texas.", "id": "F-13", "issue": "board-reporting omission", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/037_chat_exports_review_memorandum.json", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-30, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Dominic Alvarez.", "severity": "critical"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/11_board_reporting/088_board_reporting_status_report.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for hotline classification error: one source states the threshold is 13% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 16% and produced a different exception result.", "id": "F-14", "issue": "hotline classification error", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/040_chat_exports_status_report.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-30, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Priya Raman.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/091_remediation_correspondence.eml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for expense support deficiency: one source states formal notice must use notices-indigo_telecom_americas@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-prairie_link_solutions@example.test.", "id": "F-15", "issue": "expense support deficiency", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/06_expenses/043_expenses_correspondence.eml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-30, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Elliot Mercer.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/094_remediation_formal_notice.xml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for remediation ownership gap: one source states the governed population contains 184 records through 2026-02-23, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 50 records through 2026-03-17.", "id": "F-16", "issue": "remediation ownership gap", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/06_expenses/046_expenses_formal_notice.xml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-30, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Talia Brooks.", "severity": "medium"}], "matter_number": "CB-IV-2609", "prepared_for": "Indigo Telecom Americas", "schema_version": "1.0", "task_id": "cb100-029-indigo-telecom"}}, "metadata": {"benchmark": "CounselBench-100", "code_license": "Apache-2.0", "data_license": "CC-BY-4.0", "deadline": "2026-09-30", "document_count": 96, "jurisdiction": "Texas", "matter_number": "CB-IV-2609", "mcp_commit": "9a96ea6e5913736f92b88345bf51caeaaa8e719f", "mcp_package": "@modelcontextprotocol/server-filesystem@2026.7.10", "practice_area": "internal-investigations", "reference_tool_calls": 46, "required_evidence_reads": 33, "synthetic": true, "venue": "Dallas County, Texas", "version": "2.0.0"}, "prompt": "You are independent investigations counsel for Indigo Telecom Americas. This matter will be reviewed by legal, finance, and compliance stakeholders who need a single source-grounded output. Quarter-end rebates were approved through overrides after unusual chats, duplicate support, and a vendor diligence file that omits beneficial ownership. Decision due 2026-09-30. Texas law governs; Dallas County, Texas is the forum. Use the production as of the stated deadline; do not assume facts outside the supplied files. Work out the defensible position from the matter production and leave an audit-ready exception tracker and concise advice for the supervising lawyer. Keep confirmed conflicts separate from open questions, cite the records that actually control each conclusion, and do not fill gaps with outside facts.", "rubric": {"criteria": [{"category": "procedure", "description": "Complete at least 46 successful, argument-specific evidence and output calls.", "id": "procedure.minimum_successful_tool_calls"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Find and read the 33 controlling, corroborating, and work-product-control records in full.", "id": "procedure.all_evidence_read_in_full"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Inspect file metadata for the eight designated critical primary records before relying on them.", "id": "procedure.chain_of_custody_metadata_checked"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Confirm the sandbox's allowed document and output roots.", "id": "procedure.allowed_directories_checked"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Inventory all 96 records so the relevant sources are discovered among the context records.", "id": "procedure.recursive_inventory_completed"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Search the production for email evidence that may corroborate or contradict formal records.", "id": "procedure.targeted_search_completed"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Leave only findings.json and advice.md in the output workspace.", "id": "procedure.exact_deliverable_set"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Create both final work products through the sandbox MCP surface.", "id": "procedure.deliverables_written_through_mcp"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Produce findings.json as a valid JSON object.", "id": "findings.findings_is_object"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Report exactly 16 confirmed exceptions.", "id": "findings.findings_exact_count"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Use each stable finding ID exactly once.", "id": "findings.finding_ids_unique"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set schema_version to the released matter value '1.0'.", "id": "findings.top_level_schema_version"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set task_id to the released matter value 'cb100-029-indigo-telecom'.", "id": "findings.top_level_task_id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set matter_number to the released matter value 'CB-IV-2609'.", "id": "findings.top_level_matter_number"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set prepared_for to the released matter value 'Indigo Telecom Americas'.", "id": "findings.top_level_prepared_for"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set as_of to the released matter value '2026-09-30'.", "id": "findings.top_level_as_of"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-01 exception for preservation delay.", "id": "findings.F-01.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's id from /workspace/documents/01_intake/001_intake_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_access_logs/049_access_logs_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's issue from /workspace/documents/01_intake/001_intake_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_access_logs/049_access_logs_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's severity from /workspace/documents/01_intake/001_intake_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_access_logs/049_access_logs_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's primary_source from /workspace/documents/01_intake/001_intake_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_access_logs/049_access_logs_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/01_intake/001_intake_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_access_logs/049_access_logs_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-01 using the exact controlled facts ['2025-05-18', 'CB-IV-2609-A175', '2025-06-24', 'CB-IV-2609-J451'].", "id": "findings.F-01.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-01's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-01.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-30', 'Theo Laurent'] for F-01.", "id": "findings.F-01.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-02 exception for interview timeline conflict.", "id": "findings.F-02.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's id from /workspace/documents/01_intake/004_intake_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_access_logs/052_access_logs_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's issue from /workspace/documents/01_intake/004_intake_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_access_logs/052_access_logs_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's severity from /workspace/documents/01_intake/004_intake_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_access_logs/052_access_logs_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's primary_source from /workspace/documents/01_intake/004_intake_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_access_logs/052_access_logs_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/01_intake/004_intake_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_access_logs/052_access_logs_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-02 using the exact controlled facts ['$1,625,347.00', '$1,717,194.00'].", "id": "findings.F-02.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-02's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-02.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-30', 'Amara Patel'] for F-02.", "id": "findings.F-02.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-03 exception for undisclosed related party.", "id": "findings.F-03.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's id from /workspace/documents/01_intake/007_intake_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_access_logs/055_access_logs_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's issue from /workspace/documents/01_intake/007_intake_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_access_logs/055_access_logs_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's severity from /workspace/documents/01_intake/007_intake_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_access_logs/055_access_logs_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's primary_source from /workspace/documents/01_intake/007_intake_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_access_logs/055_access_logs_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/01_intake/007_intake_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_access_logs/055_access_logs_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-03 using the exact controlled facts ['Leona Park', 'Rafael Okafor'].", "id": "findings.F-03.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-03's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-03.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-30', 'Henry Cho'] for F-03.", "id": "findings.F-03.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-04 exception for split-purchase pattern.", "id": "findings.F-04.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's id from /workspace/documents/02_preservation/010_preservation_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_vendor_files/058_vendor_files_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's issue from /workspace/documents/02_preservation/010_preservation_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_vendor_files/058_vendor_files_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's severity from /workspace/documents/02_preservation/010_preservation_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_vendor_files/058_vendor_files_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's primary_source from /workspace/documents/02_preservation/010_preservation_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_vendor_files/058_vendor_files_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/02_preservation/010_preservation_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_vendor_files/058_vendor_files_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-04 using the exact controlled facts ['closed without exception', 'CB-IV-2609-D800', 'open and escalated', 'CB-IV-2609-M707'].", "id": "findings.F-04.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-04's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-04.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-30', 'Nadine Flores'] for F-04.", "id": "findings.F-04.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-05 exception for approval override.", "id": "findings.F-05.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's id from /workspace/documents/02_preservation/013_preservation_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_vendor_files/061_vendor_files_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's issue from /workspace/documents/02_preservation/013_preservation_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_vendor_files/061_vendor_files_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's severity from /workspace/documents/02_preservation/013_preservation_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_vendor_files/061_vendor_files_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's primary_source from /workspace/documents/02_preservation/013_preservation_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_vendor_files/061_vendor_files_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/02_preservation/013_preservation_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_vendor_files/061_vendor_files_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-05 using the exact controlled facts ['Dallas County, Texas', 'Texas'].", "id": "findings.F-05.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-05's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-05.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-30', 'Micah Sullivan'] for F-05.", "id": "findings.F-05.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-06 exception for gift-policy threshold breach.", "id": "findings.F-06.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's id from /workspace/documents/02_preservation/016_preservation_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_vendor_files/064_vendor_files_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's issue from /workspace/documents/02_preservation/016_preservation_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_vendor_files/064_vendor_files_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's severity from /workspace/documents/02_preservation/016_preservation_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_vendor_files/064_vendor_files_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's primary_source from /workspace/documents/02_preservation/016_preservation_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_vendor_files/064_vendor_files_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/02_preservation/016_preservation_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_vendor_files/064_vendor_files_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-06 using the exact controlled facts ['3%', '6%'].", "id": "findings.F-06.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-06's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-06.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-30', 'Farah Ibrahim'] for F-06.", "id": "findings.F-06.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-07 exception for off-channel communication.", "id": "findings.F-07.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's id from /workspace/documents/03_interviews/019_interviews_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_policies/067_policies_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's issue from /workspace/documents/03_interviews/019_interviews_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_policies/067_policies_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's severity from /workspace/documents/03_interviews/019_interviews_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_policies/067_policies_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's primary_source from /workspace/documents/03_interviews/019_interviews_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_policies/067_policies_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/03_interviews/019_interviews_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_policies/067_policies_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-07 using the exact controlled facts ['notices-indigo_telecom_americas@example.test', 'archive-prairie_link_solutions@example.test'].", "id": "findings.F-07.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-07's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-07.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-30', 'Owen Delgado'] for F-07.", "id": "findings.F-07.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-08 exception for deleted-message anomaly.", "id": "findings.F-08.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's id from /workspace/documents/03_interviews/022_interviews_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_policies/070_policies_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's issue from /workspace/documents/03_interviews/022_interviews_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_policies/070_policies_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's severity from /workspace/documents/03_interviews/022_interviews_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_policies/070_policies_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's primary_source from /workspace/documents/03_interviews/022_interviews_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_policies/070_policies_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/03_interviews/022_interviews_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_policies/070_policies_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-08 using the exact controlled facts ['129 records', '2025-12-30', '75 records', '2026-02-15'].", "id": "findings.F-08.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-08's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-08.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-30', 'Lena Varga'] for F-08.", "id": "findings.F-08.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-09 exception for badge-log inconsistency.", "id": "findings.F-09.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's id from /workspace/documents/04_email_exports/025_email_exports_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_hr_records/073_hr_records_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's issue from /workspace/documents/04_email_exports/025_email_exports_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_hr_records/073_hr_records_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's severity from /workspace/documents/04_email_exports/025_email_exports_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_hr_records/073_hr_records_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's primary_source from /workspace/documents/04_email_exports/025_email_exports_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_hr_records/073_hr_records_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/04_email_exports/025_email_exports_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_hr_records/073_hr_records_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-09 using the exact controlled facts ['2025-01-03', 'CB-IV-2609-I640', '2025-01-15', 'CB-IV-2609-R556'].", "id": "findings.F-09.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-09's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-09.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-30', 'Samuel Kim'] for F-09.", "id": "findings.F-09.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-10 exception for vendor due-diligence gap.", "id": "findings.F-10.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's id from /workspace/documents/04_email_exports/028_email_exports_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_hr_records/076_hr_records_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's issue from /workspace/documents/04_email_exports/028_email_exports_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_hr_records/076_hr_records_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's severity from /workspace/documents/04_email_exports/028_email_exports_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_hr_records/076_hr_records_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's primary_source from /workspace/documents/04_email_exports/028_email_exports_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_hr_records/076_hr_records_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/04_email_exports/028_email_exports_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_hr_records/076_hr_records_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-10 using the exact controlled facts ['$345,095.00', '$356,690.00'].", "id": "findings.F-10.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-10's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-10.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-30', 'Maya Ellison'] for F-10.", "id": "findings.F-10.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-11 exception for retaliation concern.", "id": "findings.F-11.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's id from /workspace/documents/04_email_exports/031_email_exports_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_hr_records/079_hr_records_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's issue from /workspace/documents/04_email_exports/031_email_exports_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_hr_records/079_hr_records_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's severity from /workspace/documents/04_email_exports/031_email_exports_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_hr_records/079_hr_records_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's primary_source from /workspace/documents/04_email_exports/031_email_exports_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_hr_records/079_hr_records_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/04_email_exports/031_email_exports_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_hr_records/079_hr_records_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-11 using the exact controlled facts ['Leona Park', 'Henry Cho'].", "id": "findings.F-11.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-11's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-11.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-30', 'Rafael Okafor'] for F-11.", "id": "findings.F-11.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-12 exception for policy training lapse.", "id": "findings.F-12.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's id from /workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/034_chat_exports_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_board_reporting/082_board_reporting_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's issue from /workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/034_chat_exports_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_board_reporting/082_board_reporting_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's severity from /workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/034_chat_exports_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_board_reporting/082_board_reporting_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's primary_source from /workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/034_chat_exports_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_board_reporting/082_board_reporting_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/034_chat_exports_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_board_reporting/082_board_reporting_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-12 using the exact controlled facts ['closed without exception', 'CB-IV-2609-L385', 'open and escalated', 'CB-IV-2609-U537'].", "id": "findings.F-12.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-12's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-12.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-30', 'Nora Chen'] for F-12.", "id": "findings.F-12.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-13 exception for board-reporting omission.", "id": "findings.F-13.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's id from /workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/037_chat_exports_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_board_reporting/085_board_reporting_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's issue from /workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/037_chat_exports_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_board_reporting/085_board_reporting_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's severity from /workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/037_chat_exports_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_board_reporting/085_board_reporting_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's primary_source from /workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/037_chat_exports_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_board_reporting/085_board_reporting_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/037_chat_exports_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_board_reporting/085_board_reporting_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-13 using the exact controlled facts ['Dallas County, Texas', 'Texas'].", "id": "findings.F-13.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-13's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-13.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-30', 'Dominic Alvarez'] for F-13.", "id": "findings.F-13.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-14 exception for hotline classification error.", "id": "findings.F-14.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's id from /workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/040_chat_exports_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_board_reporting/088_board_reporting_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's issue from /workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/040_chat_exports_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_board_reporting/088_board_reporting_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's severity from /workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/040_chat_exports_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_board_reporting/088_board_reporting_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's primary_source from /workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/040_chat_exports_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_board_reporting/088_board_reporting_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/040_chat_exports_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_board_reporting/088_board_reporting_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-14 using the exact controlled facts ['13%', '16%'].", "id": "findings.F-14.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-14's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-14.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-30', 'Priya Raman'] for F-14.", "id": "findings.F-14.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-15 exception for expense support deficiency.", "id": "findings.F-15.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's id from /workspace/documents/06_expenses/043_expenses_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_remediation/091_remediation_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's issue from /workspace/documents/06_expenses/043_expenses_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_remediation/091_remediation_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's severity from /workspace/documents/06_expenses/043_expenses_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_remediation/091_remediation_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's primary_source from /workspace/documents/06_expenses/043_expenses_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_remediation/091_remediation_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/06_expenses/043_expenses_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_remediation/091_remediation_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-15 using the exact controlled facts ['notices-indigo_telecom_americas@example.test', 'archive-prairie_link_solutions@example.test'].", "id": "findings.F-15.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-15's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-15.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-30', 'Elliot Mercer'] for F-15.", "id": "findings.F-15.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-16 exception for remediation ownership gap.", "id": "findings.F-16.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's id from /workspace/documents/06_expenses/046_expenses_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_remediation/094_remediation_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's issue from /workspace/documents/06_expenses/046_expenses_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_remediation/094_remediation_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's severity from /workspace/documents/06_expenses/046_expenses_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_remediation/094_remediation_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's primary_source from /workspace/documents/06_expenses/046_expenses_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_remediation/094_remediation_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/06_expenses/046_expenses_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_remediation/094_remediation_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-16 using the exact controlled facts ['184 records', '2026-02-23', '50 records', '2026-03-17'].", "id": "findings.F-16.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-16's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-16.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-30', 'Talia Brooks'] for F-16.", "id": "findings.F-16.action_anchors"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Executive assessment' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Executive assessment"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Method and record coverage' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Method and record coverage"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Findings' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Findings"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Recommended next actions' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Recommended next actions"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Assumptions and limitations' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Assumptions and limitations"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-01 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-01"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-02 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-02"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-03 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-03"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-04 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-04"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-05 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-05"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-06 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-06"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-07 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-07"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-08 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-08"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-09 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-09"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-10 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-10"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-11 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-11"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-12 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-12"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-13 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-13"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-14 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-14"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-15 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-15"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-16 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-16"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Do not claim the production has no issues or that every record is consistent.", "id": "memo.forbidden_claims_absent"}], "decision_options": [{"id": "cross-source-reconciliation", "label": "Reconcile controlling and corroborating records", "reason": "The CB-IV-2609 production contains independently maintained records; a defensible answer must preserve each supported conflict and its cure owner.", "selected": true}, {"id": "latest-record-controls", "label": "Treat the latest record as controlling", "reason": "Timestamp recency does not establish legal priority, execution, or approval authority.", "selected": false}, {"id": "primary-records-only", "label": "Report primary records without reconciliation", "reason": "Primary records alone conceal the operational conflicts that create the actionable exceptions.", "selected": false}], "gates": ["all_evidence_read_in_full", "chain_of_custody_metadata_checked", "findings_criteria_complete", "memo_criteria_complete", "deliverables_written_through_mcp"], "metadata_checks": 8, "metric": "weighted_criteria_score", "minimum_tool_calls": 46, "required_deliverables": ["findings.json", "advice.md"], "required_document_reads": 33, "type": "deterministic", "weights": {"findings": 0.55, "memo": 0.2, "procedure": 0.25}}, "task_id": "cb100-029-indigo-telecom", "task_name": "Indigo channel-rebate inquiry", "world_id": "counselbench-filesystem-mcp-v2"}
-{"context_files": ["task_files/cb100-030-jasper-university/01_intake/001_intake_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-030-jasper-university/01_intake/002_intake_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-030-jasper-university/01_intake/003_intake_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-030-jasper-university/01_intake/004_intake_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-030-jasper-university/01_intake/005_intake_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-030-jasper-university/01_intake/006_intake_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-030-jasper-university/01_intake/007_intake_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-030-jasper-university/01_intake/008_intake_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-030-jasper-university/02_preservation/009_preservation_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-030-jasper-university/02_preservation/010_preservation_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-030-jasper-university/02_preservation/011_preservation_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-030-jasper-university/02_preservation/012_preservation_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-030-jasper-university/02_preservation/013_preservation_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-030-jasper-university/02_preservation/014_preservation_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-030-jasper-university/02_preservation/015_preservation_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-030-jasper-university/02_preservation/016_preservation_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-030-jasper-university/03_interviews/017_interviews_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-030-jasper-university/03_interviews/018_interviews_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-030-jasper-university/03_interviews/019_interviews_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-030-jasper-university/03_interviews/020_interviews_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-030-jasper-university/03_interviews/021_interviews_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-030-jasper-university/03_interviews/022_interviews_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-030-jasper-university/03_interviews/023_interviews_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-030-jasper-university/03_interviews/024_interviews_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-030-jasper-university/04_email_exports/025_email_exports_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-030-jasper-university/04_email_exports/026_email_exports_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-030-jasper-university/04_email_exports/027_email_exports_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-030-jasper-university/04_email_exports/028_email_exports_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-030-jasper-university/04_email_exports/029_email_exports_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-030-jasper-university/04_email_exports/030_email_exports_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-030-jasper-university/04_email_exports/031_email_exports_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-030-jasper-university/04_email_exports/032_email_exports_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-030-jasper-university/05_chat_exports/033_chat_exports_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-030-jasper-university/05_chat_exports/034_chat_exports_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-030-jasper-university/05_chat_exports/035_chat_exports_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-030-jasper-university/05_chat_exports/036_chat_exports_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-030-jasper-university/05_chat_exports/037_chat_exports_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-030-jasper-university/05_chat_exports/038_chat_exports_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-030-jasper-university/05_chat_exports/039_chat_exports_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-030-jasper-university/05_chat_exports/040_chat_exports_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-030-jasper-university/06_expenses/041_expenses_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-030-jasper-university/06_expenses/042_expenses_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-030-jasper-university/06_expenses/043_expenses_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-030-jasper-university/06_expenses/044_expenses_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-030-jasper-university/06_expenses/045_expenses_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-030-jasper-university/06_expenses/046_expenses_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-030-jasper-university/06_expenses/047_expenses_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-030-jasper-university/06_expenses/048_expenses_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-030-jasper-university/07_access_logs/049_access_logs_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-030-jasper-university/07_access_logs/050_access_logs_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-030-jasper-university/07_access_logs/051_access_logs_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-030-jasper-university/07_access_logs/052_access_logs_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-030-jasper-university/07_access_logs/053_access_logs_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-030-jasper-university/07_access_logs/054_access_logs_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-030-jasper-university/07_access_logs/055_access_logs_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-030-jasper-university/07_access_logs/056_access_logs_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-030-jasper-university/08_vendor_files/057_vendor_files_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-030-jasper-university/08_vendor_files/058_vendor_files_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-030-jasper-university/08_vendor_files/059_vendor_files_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-030-jasper-university/08_vendor_files/060_vendor_files_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-030-jasper-university/08_vendor_files/061_vendor_files_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-030-jasper-university/08_vendor_files/062_vendor_files_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-030-jasper-university/08_vendor_files/063_vendor_files_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-030-jasper-university/08_vendor_files/064_vendor_files_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-030-jasper-university/09_policies/065_policies_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-030-jasper-university/09_policies/066_policies_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-030-jasper-university/09_policies/067_policies_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-030-jasper-university/09_policies/068_policies_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-030-jasper-university/09_policies/069_policies_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-030-jasper-university/09_policies/070_policies_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-030-jasper-university/09_policies/071_policies_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-030-jasper-university/09_policies/072_policies_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-030-jasper-university/10_hr_records/073_hr_records_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-030-jasper-university/10_hr_records/074_hr_records_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-030-jasper-university/10_hr_records/075_hr_records_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-030-jasper-university/10_hr_records/076_hr_records_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-030-jasper-university/10_hr_records/077_hr_records_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-030-jasper-university/10_hr_records/078_hr_records_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-030-jasper-university/10_hr_records/079_hr_records_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-030-jasper-university/10_hr_records/080_hr_records_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-030-jasper-university/11_board_reporting/081_board_reporting_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-030-jasper-university/11_board_reporting/082_board_reporting_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-030-jasper-university/11_board_reporting/083_board_reporting_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-030-jasper-university/11_board_reporting/084_board_reporting_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-030-jasper-university/11_board_reporting/085_board_reporting_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-030-jasper-university/11_board_reporting/086_board_reporting_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-030-jasper-university/11_board_reporting/087_board_reporting_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-030-jasper-university/11_board_reporting/088_board_reporting_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-030-jasper-university/12_remediation/089_remediation_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-030-jasper-university/12_remediation/090_remediation_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-030-jasper-university/12_remediation/091_remediation_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-030-jasper-university/12_remediation/092_remediation_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-030-jasper-university/12_remediation/093_remediation_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-030-jasper-university/12_remediation/094_remediation_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-030-jasper-university/12_remediation/095_remediation_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-030-jasper-university/12_remediation/096_remediation_status_report.md"], "gold_output": {"advice_markdown": "# Counsel advice — Jasper research-fund inquiry\n\n## Executive assessment\n\nFor Jasper University Research Institute matter CB-IV-2610, the review identified 16 source-supported exceptions requiring action before 2026-10-04. The assessment concerns Nova Bench Analytics and the supplied record for Pennsylvania.\n\n## Method and record coverage\n\nThe review inventoried all 96 production files, read the 33 controlling, corroborating, and control records, searched the email exports, and checked metadata for the designated chain-of-custody sample. Conclusions are limited to the synthetic production supplied for this benchmark matter.\n\n## Findings\n\n### F-01 — preservation delay (critical)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for preservation delay: one source states the operative date is 2026-02-12 under control reference CB-IV-2610-A145, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2026-03-05 under response reference CB-IV-2610-J103.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/01_intake/001_intake_control_register.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/07_access_logs/049_access_logs_control_register.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-10-04, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Amara Patel.\n\n### F-02 — interview timeline conflict (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for interview timeline conflict: one source states the controlling amount is $4,934,726.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $5,155,952.00.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/01_intake/004_intake_ledger_export.csv`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/07_access_logs/052_access_logs_ledger_export.csv`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-10-04, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Henry Cho.\n\n### F-03 — undisclosed related party (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for undisclosed related party: one source states approval is attributed to Isaac Romero as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Dominic Alvarez and contains no entry for Isaac Romero.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/01_intake/007_intake_officer_certificate.html`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/07_access_logs/055_access_logs_officer_certificate.html`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-10-04, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Nadine Flores.\n\n### F-04 — split-purchase pattern (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for split-purchase pattern: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-IV-2610-D808, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-IV-2610-M846.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/02_preservation/010_preservation_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/08_vendor_files/058_vendor_files_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-10-04, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Micah Sullivan.\n\n### F-05 — approval override (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for approval override: one source states the applicable location is Allegheny County, Pennsylvania, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to Pennsylvania operations outside Allegheny County, Pennsylvania.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/02_preservation/013_preservation_review_memorandum.json`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/08_vendor_files/061_vendor_files_review_memorandum.json`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-10-04, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Farah Ibrahim.\n\n### F-06 — gift-policy threshold breach (low)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for gift-policy threshold breach: one source states the threshold is 11% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 18% and produced a different exception result.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/02_preservation/016_preservation_status_report.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/08_vendor_files/064_vendor_files_status_report.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-10-04, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Owen Delgado.\n\n### F-07 — off-channel communication (critical)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for off-channel communication: one source states formal notice must use notices-jasper_university_research_institute@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-nova_bench_analytics@example.test.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/03_interviews/019_interviews_correspondence.eml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/09_policies/067_policies_correspondence.eml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-10-04, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Lena Varga.\n\n### F-08 — deleted-message anomaly (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for deleted-message anomaly: one source states the governed population contains 149 records through 2026-01-19, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 36 records through 2026-01-27.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/03_interviews/022_interviews_formal_notice.xml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/09_policies/070_policies_formal_notice.xml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-10-04, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Samuel Kim.\n\n### F-09 — badge-log inconsistency (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for badge-log inconsistency: one source states the operative date is 2025-07-25 under control reference CB-IV-2610-I243, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2025-08-03 under response reference CB-IV-2610-R111.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/04_email_exports/025_email_exports_control_register.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/10_hr_records/073_hr_records_control_register.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-10-04, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Maya Ellison.\n\n### F-10 — vendor due-diligence gap (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for vendor due-diligence gap: one source states the controlling amount is $2,467,221.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $2,540,942.00.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/04_email_exports/028_email_exports_ledger_export.csv`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/10_hr_records/076_hr_records_ledger_export.csv`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-10-04, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Rafael Okafor.\n\n### F-11 — retaliation concern (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for retaliation concern: one source states approval is attributed to Isaac Romero as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Micah Sullivan and contains no entry for Isaac Romero.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/04_email_exports/031_email_exports_officer_certificate.html`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/10_hr_records/079_hr_records_officer_certificate.html`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-10-04, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Nora Chen.\n\n### F-12 — policy training lapse (low)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for policy training lapse: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-IV-2610-L630, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-IV-2610-U417.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/034_chat_exports_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/11_board_reporting/082_board_reporting_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-10-04, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Dominic Alvarez.\n\n### F-13 — board-reporting omission (critical)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for board-reporting omission: one source states the applicable location is Allegheny County, Pennsylvania, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to Pennsylvania operations outside Allegheny County, Pennsylvania.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/037_chat_exports_review_memorandum.json`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/11_board_reporting/085_board_reporting_review_memorandum.json`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-10-04, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Priya Raman.\n\n### F-14 — hotline classification error (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for hotline classification error: one source states the threshold is 11% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 18% and produced a different exception result.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/040_chat_exports_status_report.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/11_board_reporting/088_board_reporting_status_report.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-10-04, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Elliot Mercer.\n\n### F-15 — expense support deficiency (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for expense support deficiency: one source states formal notice must use notices-jasper_university_research_institute@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-nova_bench_analytics@example.test.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/06_expenses/043_expenses_correspondence.eml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/12_remediation/091_remediation_correspondence.eml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-10-04, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Talia Brooks.\n\n### F-16 — remediation ownership gap (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for remediation ownership gap: one source states the governed population contains 77 records through 2025-02-01, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 67 records through 2025-03-12.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/06_expenses/046_expenses_formal_notice.xml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/12_remediation/094_remediation_formal_notice.xml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-10-04, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Jonas Feld.\n\n## Recommended next actions\n\nSequence the critical and high findings first, assign the named owners, preserve the cited records, and document any resolution in the controlling matter register before the stated deadline.\n\n## Assumptions and limitations\n\nThis analysis is confined to task cb100-030-jasper-university and the supplied synthetic evidence. It does not rely on external facts, does not resolve disputed law, and is not legal advice for a real person or entity.\n", "findings": {"as_of": "2026-10-04", "findings": [{"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/07_access_logs/049_access_logs_control_register.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for preservation delay: one source states the operative date is 2026-02-12 under control reference CB-IV-2610-A145, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2026-03-05 under response reference CB-IV-2610-J103.", "id": "F-01", "issue": "preservation delay", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/01_intake/001_intake_control_register.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-10-04, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Amara Patel.", "severity": "critical"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/07_access_logs/052_access_logs_ledger_export.csv", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for interview timeline conflict: one source states the controlling amount is $4,934,726.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $5,155,952.00.", "id": "F-02", "issue": "interview timeline conflict", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/01_intake/004_intake_ledger_export.csv", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-10-04, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Henry Cho.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/07_access_logs/055_access_logs_officer_certificate.html", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for undisclosed related party: one source states approval is attributed to Isaac Romero as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Dominic Alvarez and contains no entry for Isaac Romero.", "id": "F-03", "issue": "undisclosed related party", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/01_intake/007_intake_officer_certificate.html", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-10-04, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Nadine Flores.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/08_vendor_files/058_vendor_files_executed_instrument.txt", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for split-purchase pattern: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-IV-2610-D808, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-IV-2610-M846.", "id": "F-04", "issue": "split-purchase pattern", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/02_preservation/010_preservation_executed_instrument.txt", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-10-04, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Micah Sullivan.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/08_vendor_files/061_vendor_files_review_memorandum.json", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for approval override: one source states the applicable location is Allegheny County, Pennsylvania, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to Pennsylvania operations outside Allegheny County, Pennsylvania.", "id": "F-05", "issue": "approval override", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/02_preservation/013_preservation_review_memorandum.json", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-10-04, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Farah Ibrahim.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/08_vendor_files/064_vendor_files_status_report.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for gift-policy threshold breach: one source states the threshold is 11% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 18% and produced a different exception result.", "id": "F-06", "issue": "gift-policy threshold breach", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/02_preservation/016_preservation_status_report.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-10-04, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Owen Delgado.", "severity": "low"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/09_policies/067_policies_correspondence.eml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for off-channel communication: one source states formal notice must use notices-jasper_university_research_institute@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-nova_bench_analytics@example.test.", "id": "F-07", "issue": "off-channel communication", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/03_interviews/019_interviews_correspondence.eml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-10-04, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Lena Varga.", "severity": "critical"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/09_policies/070_policies_formal_notice.xml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for deleted-message anomaly: one source states the governed population contains 149 records through 2026-01-19, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 36 records through 2026-01-27.", "id": "F-08", "issue": "deleted-message anomaly", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/03_interviews/022_interviews_formal_notice.xml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-10-04, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Samuel Kim.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/10_hr_records/073_hr_records_control_register.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for badge-log inconsistency: one source states the operative date is 2025-07-25 under control reference CB-IV-2610-I243, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2025-08-03 under response reference CB-IV-2610-R111.", "id": "F-09", "issue": "badge-log inconsistency", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/04_email_exports/025_email_exports_control_register.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-10-04, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Maya Ellison.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/10_hr_records/076_hr_records_ledger_export.csv", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for vendor due-diligence gap: one source states the controlling amount is $2,467,221.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $2,540,942.00.", "id": "F-10", "issue": "vendor due-diligence gap", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/04_email_exports/028_email_exports_ledger_export.csv", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-10-04, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Rafael Okafor.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/10_hr_records/079_hr_records_officer_certificate.html", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for retaliation concern: one source states approval is attributed to Isaac Romero as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Micah Sullivan and contains no entry for Isaac Romero.", "id": "F-11", "issue": "retaliation concern", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/04_email_exports/031_email_exports_officer_certificate.html", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-10-04, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Nora Chen.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/11_board_reporting/082_board_reporting_executed_instrument.txt", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for policy training lapse: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-IV-2610-L630, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-IV-2610-U417.", "id": "F-12", "issue": "policy training lapse", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/034_chat_exports_executed_instrument.txt", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-10-04, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Dominic Alvarez.", "severity": "low"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/11_board_reporting/085_board_reporting_review_memorandum.json", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for board-reporting omission: one source states the applicable location is Allegheny County, Pennsylvania, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to Pennsylvania operations outside Allegheny County, Pennsylvania.", "id": "F-13", "issue": "board-reporting omission", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/037_chat_exports_review_memorandum.json", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-10-04, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Priya Raman.", "severity": "critical"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/11_board_reporting/088_board_reporting_status_report.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for hotline classification error: one source states the threshold is 11% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 18% and produced a different exception result.", "id": "F-14", "issue": "hotline classification error", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/040_chat_exports_status_report.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-10-04, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Elliot Mercer.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/091_remediation_correspondence.eml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for expense support deficiency: one source states formal notice must use notices-jasper_university_research_institute@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-nova_bench_analytics@example.test.", "id": "F-15", "issue": "expense support deficiency", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/06_expenses/043_expenses_correspondence.eml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-10-04, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Talia Brooks.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/094_remediation_formal_notice.xml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for remediation ownership gap: one source states the governed population contains 77 records through 2025-02-01, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 67 records through 2025-03-12.", "id": "F-16", "issue": "remediation ownership gap", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/06_expenses/046_expenses_formal_notice.xml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-10-04, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Jonas Feld.", "severity": "medium"}], "matter_number": "CB-IV-2610", "prepared_for": "Jasper University Research Institute", "schema_version": "1.0", "task_id": "cb100-030-jasper-university"}}, "metadata": {"benchmark": "CounselBench-100", "code_license": "Apache-2.0", "data_license": "CC-BY-4.0", "deadline": "2026-10-04", "document_count": 96, "jurisdiction": "Pennsylvania", "matter_number": "CB-IV-2610", "mcp_commit": "9a96ea6e5913736f92b88345bf51caeaaa8e719f", "mcp_package": "@modelcontextprotocol/server-filesystem@2026.7.10", "practice_area": "internal-investigations", "reference_tool_calls": 46, "required_evidence_reads": 33, "synthetic": true, "venue": "Allegheny County, Pennsylvania", "version": "2.0.0"}, "prompt": "You are independent investigations counsel for Jasper University Research Institute. The record contains amendments, exports, and correspondence from different custodians; reconcile them into an actionable counsel work product. A principal investigator directed purchases to a startup owned by a former student while training, disclosure, and expense records diverge. Decision due 2026-10-04. Pennsylvania law governs; Allegheny County, Pennsylvania is the forum. Write for a supervising lawyer who will spot-check source paths and exact values. Work out the defensible position from the matter production and leave an audit-ready exception tracker and concise advice for the supervising lawyer. Keep confirmed conflicts separate from open questions, cite the records that actually control each conclusion, and do not fill gaps with outside facts.", "rubric": {"criteria": [{"category": "procedure", "description": "Complete at least 46 successful, argument-specific evidence and output calls.", "id": "procedure.minimum_successful_tool_calls"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Find and read the 33 controlling, corroborating, and work-product-control records in full.", "id": "procedure.all_evidence_read_in_full"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Inspect file metadata for the eight designated critical primary records before relying on them.", "id": "procedure.chain_of_custody_metadata_checked"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Confirm the sandbox's allowed document and output roots.", "id": "procedure.allowed_directories_checked"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Inventory all 96 records so the relevant sources are discovered among the context records.", "id": "procedure.recursive_inventory_completed"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Search the production for email evidence that may corroborate or contradict formal records.", "id": "procedure.targeted_search_completed"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Leave only findings.json and advice.md in the output workspace.", "id": "procedure.exact_deliverable_set"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Create both final work products through the sandbox MCP surface.", "id": "procedure.deliverables_written_through_mcp"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Produce findings.json as a valid JSON object.", "id": "findings.findings_is_object"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Report exactly 16 confirmed exceptions.", "id": "findings.findings_exact_count"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Use each stable finding ID exactly once.", "id": "findings.finding_ids_unique"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set schema_version to the released matter value '1.0'.", "id": "findings.top_level_schema_version"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set task_id to the released matter value 'cb100-030-jasper-university'.", "id": "findings.top_level_task_id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set matter_number to the released matter value 'CB-IV-2610'.", "id": "findings.top_level_matter_number"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set prepared_for to the released matter value 'Jasper University Research Institute'.", "id": "findings.top_level_prepared_for"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set as_of to the released matter value '2026-10-04'.", "id": "findings.top_level_as_of"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-01 exception for preservation delay.", "id": "findings.F-01.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's id from /workspace/documents/01_intake/001_intake_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_access_logs/049_access_logs_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's issue from /workspace/documents/01_intake/001_intake_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_access_logs/049_access_logs_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's severity from /workspace/documents/01_intake/001_intake_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_access_logs/049_access_logs_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's primary_source from /workspace/documents/01_intake/001_intake_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_access_logs/049_access_logs_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/01_intake/001_intake_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_access_logs/049_access_logs_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-01 using the exact controlled facts ['2026-02-12', 'CB-IV-2610-A145', '2026-03-05', 'CB-IV-2610-J103'].", "id": "findings.F-01.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-01's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-01.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-10-04', 'Amara Patel'] for F-01.", "id": "findings.F-01.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-02 exception for interview timeline conflict.", "id": "findings.F-02.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's id from /workspace/documents/01_intake/004_intake_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_access_logs/052_access_logs_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's issue from /workspace/documents/01_intake/004_intake_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_access_logs/052_access_logs_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's severity from /workspace/documents/01_intake/004_intake_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_access_logs/052_access_logs_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's primary_source from /workspace/documents/01_intake/004_intake_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_access_logs/052_access_logs_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/01_intake/004_intake_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_access_logs/052_access_logs_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-02 using the exact controlled facts ['$4,934,726.00', '$5,155,952.00'].", "id": "findings.F-02.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-02's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-02.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-10-04', 'Henry Cho'] for F-02.", "id": "findings.F-02.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-03 exception for undisclosed related party.", "id": "findings.F-03.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's id from /workspace/documents/01_intake/007_intake_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_access_logs/055_access_logs_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's issue from /workspace/documents/01_intake/007_intake_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_access_logs/055_access_logs_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's severity from /workspace/documents/01_intake/007_intake_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_access_logs/055_access_logs_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's primary_source from /workspace/documents/01_intake/007_intake_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_access_logs/055_access_logs_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/01_intake/007_intake_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_access_logs/055_access_logs_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-03 using the exact controlled facts ['Isaac Romero', 'Dominic Alvarez'].", "id": "findings.F-03.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-03's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-03.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-10-04', 'Nadine Flores'] for F-03.", "id": "findings.F-03.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-04 exception for split-purchase pattern.", "id": "findings.F-04.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's id from /workspace/documents/02_preservation/010_preservation_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_vendor_files/058_vendor_files_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's issue from /workspace/documents/02_preservation/010_preservation_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_vendor_files/058_vendor_files_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's severity from /workspace/documents/02_preservation/010_preservation_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_vendor_files/058_vendor_files_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's primary_source from /workspace/documents/02_preservation/010_preservation_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_vendor_files/058_vendor_files_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/02_preservation/010_preservation_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_vendor_files/058_vendor_files_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-04 using the exact controlled facts ['closed without exception', 'CB-IV-2610-D808', 'open and escalated', 'CB-IV-2610-M846'].", "id": "findings.F-04.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-04's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-04.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-10-04', 'Micah Sullivan'] for F-04.", "id": "findings.F-04.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-05 exception for approval override.", "id": "findings.F-05.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's id from /workspace/documents/02_preservation/013_preservation_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_vendor_files/061_vendor_files_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's issue from /workspace/documents/02_preservation/013_preservation_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_vendor_files/061_vendor_files_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's severity from /workspace/documents/02_preservation/013_preservation_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_vendor_files/061_vendor_files_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's primary_source from /workspace/documents/02_preservation/013_preservation_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_vendor_files/061_vendor_files_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/02_preservation/013_preservation_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_vendor_files/061_vendor_files_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-05 using the exact controlled facts ['Allegheny County, Pennsylvania', 'Pennsylvania'].", "id": "findings.F-05.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-05's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-05.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-10-04', 'Farah Ibrahim'] for F-05.", "id": "findings.F-05.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-06 exception for gift-policy threshold breach.", "id": "findings.F-06.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's id from /workspace/documents/02_preservation/016_preservation_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_vendor_files/064_vendor_files_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's issue from /workspace/documents/02_preservation/016_preservation_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_vendor_files/064_vendor_files_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's severity from /workspace/documents/02_preservation/016_preservation_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_vendor_files/064_vendor_files_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's primary_source from /workspace/documents/02_preservation/016_preservation_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_vendor_files/064_vendor_files_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/02_preservation/016_preservation_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_vendor_files/064_vendor_files_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-06 using the exact controlled facts ['11%', '18%'].", "id": "findings.F-06.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-06's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-06.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-10-04', 'Owen Delgado'] for F-06.", "id": "findings.F-06.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-07 exception for off-channel communication.", "id": "findings.F-07.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's id from /workspace/documents/03_interviews/019_interviews_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_policies/067_policies_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's issue from /workspace/documents/03_interviews/019_interviews_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_policies/067_policies_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's severity from /workspace/documents/03_interviews/019_interviews_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_policies/067_policies_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's primary_source from /workspace/documents/03_interviews/019_interviews_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_policies/067_policies_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/03_interviews/019_interviews_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_policies/067_policies_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-07 using the exact controlled facts ['notices-jasper_university_research_institute@example.test', 'archive-nova_bench_analytics@example.test'].", "id": "findings.F-07.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-07's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-07.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-10-04', 'Lena Varga'] for F-07.", "id": "findings.F-07.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-08 exception for deleted-message anomaly.", "id": "findings.F-08.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's id from /workspace/documents/03_interviews/022_interviews_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_policies/070_policies_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's issue from /workspace/documents/03_interviews/022_interviews_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_policies/070_policies_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's severity from /workspace/documents/03_interviews/022_interviews_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_policies/070_policies_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's primary_source from /workspace/documents/03_interviews/022_interviews_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_policies/070_policies_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/03_interviews/022_interviews_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_policies/070_policies_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-08 using the exact controlled facts ['149 records', '2026-01-19', '36 records', '2026-01-27'].", "id": "findings.F-08.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-08's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-08.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-10-04', 'Samuel Kim'] for F-08.", "id": "findings.F-08.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-09 exception for badge-log inconsistency.", "id": "findings.F-09.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's id from /workspace/documents/04_email_exports/025_email_exports_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_hr_records/073_hr_records_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's issue from /workspace/documents/04_email_exports/025_email_exports_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_hr_records/073_hr_records_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's severity from /workspace/documents/04_email_exports/025_email_exports_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_hr_records/073_hr_records_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's primary_source from /workspace/documents/04_email_exports/025_email_exports_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_hr_records/073_hr_records_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/04_email_exports/025_email_exports_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_hr_records/073_hr_records_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-09 using the exact controlled facts ['2025-07-25', 'CB-IV-2610-I243', '2025-08-03', 'CB-IV-2610-R111'].", "id": "findings.F-09.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-09's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-09.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-10-04', 'Maya Ellison'] for F-09.", "id": "findings.F-09.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-10 exception for vendor due-diligence gap.", "id": "findings.F-10.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's id from /workspace/documents/04_email_exports/028_email_exports_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_hr_records/076_hr_records_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's issue from /workspace/documents/04_email_exports/028_email_exports_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_hr_records/076_hr_records_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's severity from /workspace/documents/04_email_exports/028_email_exports_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_hr_records/076_hr_records_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's primary_source from /workspace/documents/04_email_exports/028_email_exports_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_hr_records/076_hr_records_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/04_email_exports/028_email_exports_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_hr_records/076_hr_records_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-10 using the exact controlled facts ['$2,467,221.00', '$2,540,942.00'].", "id": "findings.F-10.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-10's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-10.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-10-04', 'Rafael Okafor'] for F-10.", "id": "findings.F-10.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-11 exception for retaliation concern.", "id": "findings.F-11.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's id from /workspace/documents/04_email_exports/031_email_exports_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_hr_records/079_hr_records_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's issue from /workspace/documents/04_email_exports/031_email_exports_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_hr_records/079_hr_records_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's severity from /workspace/documents/04_email_exports/031_email_exports_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_hr_records/079_hr_records_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's primary_source from /workspace/documents/04_email_exports/031_email_exports_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_hr_records/079_hr_records_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/04_email_exports/031_email_exports_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_hr_records/079_hr_records_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-11 using the exact controlled facts ['Isaac Romero', 'Micah Sullivan'].", "id": "findings.F-11.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-11's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-11.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-10-04', 'Nora Chen'] for F-11.", "id": "findings.F-11.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-12 exception for policy training lapse.", "id": "findings.F-12.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's id from /workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/034_chat_exports_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_board_reporting/082_board_reporting_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's issue from /workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/034_chat_exports_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_board_reporting/082_board_reporting_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's severity from /workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/034_chat_exports_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_board_reporting/082_board_reporting_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's primary_source from /workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/034_chat_exports_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_board_reporting/082_board_reporting_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/034_chat_exports_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_board_reporting/082_board_reporting_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-12 using the exact controlled facts ['closed without exception', 'CB-IV-2610-L630', 'open and escalated', 'CB-IV-2610-U417'].", "id": "findings.F-12.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-12's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-12.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-10-04', 'Dominic Alvarez'] for F-12.", "id": "findings.F-12.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-13 exception for board-reporting omission.", "id": "findings.F-13.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's id from /workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/037_chat_exports_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_board_reporting/085_board_reporting_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's issue from /workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/037_chat_exports_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_board_reporting/085_board_reporting_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's severity from /workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/037_chat_exports_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_board_reporting/085_board_reporting_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's primary_source from /workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/037_chat_exports_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_board_reporting/085_board_reporting_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/037_chat_exports_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_board_reporting/085_board_reporting_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-13 using the exact controlled facts ['Allegheny County, Pennsylvania', 'Pennsylvania'].", "id": "findings.F-13.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-13's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-13.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-10-04', 'Priya Raman'] for F-13.", "id": "findings.F-13.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-14 exception for hotline classification error.", "id": "findings.F-14.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's id from /workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/040_chat_exports_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_board_reporting/088_board_reporting_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's issue from /workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/040_chat_exports_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_board_reporting/088_board_reporting_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's severity from /workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/040_chat_exports_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_board_reporting/088_board_reporting_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's primary_source from /workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/040_chat_exports_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_board_reporting/088_board_reporting_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/040_chat_exports_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_board_reporting/088_board_reporting_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-14 using the exact controlled facts ['11%', '18%'].", "id": "findings.F-14.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-14's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-14.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-10-04', 'Elliot Mercer'] for F-14.", "id": "findings.F-14.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-15 exception for expense support deficiency.", "id": "findings.F-15.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's id from /workspace/documents/06_expenses/043_expenses_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_remediation/091_remediation_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's issue from /workspace/documents/06_expenses/043_expenses_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_remediation/091_remediation_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's severity from /workspace/documents/06_expenses/043_expenses_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_remediation/091_remediation_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's primary_source from /workspace/documents/06_expenses/043_expenses_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_remediation/091_remediation_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/06_expenses/043_expenses_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_remediation/091_remediation_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-15 using the exact controlled facts ['notices-jasper_university_research_institute@example.test', 'archive-nova_bench_analytics@example.test'].", "id": "findings.F-15.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-15's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-15.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-10-04', 'Talia Brooks'] for F-15.", "id": "findings.F-15.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-16 exception for remediation ownership gap.", "id": "findings.F-16.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's id from /workspace/documents/06_expenses/046_expenses_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_remediation/094_remediation_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's issue from /workspace/documents/06_expenses/046_expenses_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_remediation/094_remediation_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's severity from /workspace/documents/06_expenses/046_expenses_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_remediation/094_remediation_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's primary_source from /workspace/documents/06_expenses/046_expenses_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_remediation/094_remediation_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/06_expenses/046_expenses_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_remediation/094_remediation_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-16 using the exact controlled facts ['77 records', '2025-02-01', '67 records', '2025-03-12'].", "id": "findings.F-16.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-16's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-16.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-10-04', 'Jonas Feld'] for F-16.", "id": "findings.F-16.action_anchors"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Executive assessment' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Executive assessment"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Method and record coverage' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Method and record coverage"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Findings' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Findings"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Recommended next actions' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Recommended next actions"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Assumptions and limitations' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Assumptions and limitations"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-01 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-01"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-02 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-02"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-03 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-03"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-04 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-04"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-05 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-05"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-06 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-06"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-07 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-07"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-08 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-08"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-09 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-09"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-10 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-10"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-11 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-11"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-12 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-12"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-13 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-13"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-14 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-14"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-15 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-15"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-16 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-16"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Do not claim the production has no issues or that every record is consistent.", "id": "memo.forbidden_claims_absent"}], "decision_options": [{"id": "cross-source-reconciliation", "label": "Reconcile controlling and corroborating records", "reason": "The CB-IV-2610 production contains independently maintained records; a defensible answer must preserve each supported conflict and its cure owner.", "selected": true}, {"id": "latest-record-controls", "label": "Treat the latest record as controlling", "reason": "Timestamp recency does not establish legal priority, execution, or approval authority.", "selected": false}, {"id": "primary-records-only", "label": "Report primary records without reconciliation", "reason": "Primary records alone conceal the operational conflicts that create the actionable exceptions.", "selected": false}], "gates": ["all_evidence_read_in_full", "chain_of_custody_metadata_checked", "findings_criteria_complete", "memo_criteria_complete", "deliverables_written_through_mcp"], "metadata_checks": 8, "metric": "weighted_criteria_score", "minimum_tool_calls": 46, "required_deliverables": ["findings.json", "advice.md"], "required_document_reads": 33, "type": "deterministic", "weights": {"findings": 0.55, "memo": 0.2, "procedure": 0.25}}, "task_id": "cb100-030-jasper-university", "task_name": "Jasper research-fund inquiry", "world_id": "counselbench-filesystem-mcp-v2"}
-{"context_files": ["task_files/cb100-031-aurora-antitrust/01_pleadings/001_pleadings_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-031-aurora-antitrust/01_pleadings/002_pleadings_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-031-aurora-antitrust/01_pleadings/003_pleadings_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-031-aurora-antitrust/01_pleadings/004_pleadings_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-031-aurora-antitrust/01_pleadings/005_pleadings_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-031-aurora-antitrust/01_pleadings/006_pleadings_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-031-aurora-antitrust/01_pleadings/007_pleadings_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-031-aurora-antitrust/01_pleadings/008_pleadings_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-031-aurora-antitrust/02_orders/009_orders_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-031-aurora-antitrust/02_orders/010_orders_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-031-aurora-antitrust/02_orders/011_orders_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-031-aurora-antitrust/02_orders/012_orders_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-031-aurora-antitrust/02_orders/013_orders_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-031-aurora-antitrust/02_orders/014_orders_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-031-aurora-antitrust/02_orders/015_orders_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-031-aurora-antitrust/02_orders/016_orders_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-031-aurora-antitrust/03_requests_responses/017_requests_responses_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-031-aurora-antitrust/03_requests_responses/018_requests_responses_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-031-aurora-antitrust/03_requests_responses/019_requests_responses_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-031-aurora-antitrust/03_requests_responses/020_requests_responses_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-031-aurora-antitrust/03_requests_responses/021_requests_responses_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-031-aurora-antitrust/03_requests_responses/022_requests_responses_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-031-aurora-antitrust/03_requests_responses/023_requests_responses_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-031-aurora-antitrust/03_requests_responses/024_requests_responses_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-031-aurora-antitrust/04_custodian_files/025_custodian_files_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-031-aurora-antitrust/04_custodian_files/026_custodian_files_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-031-aurora-antitrust/04_custodian_files/027_custodian_files_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-031-aurora-antitrust/04_custodian_files/028_custodian_files_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-031-aurora-antitrust/04_custodian_files/029_custodian_files_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-031-aurora-antitrust/04_custodian_files/030_custodian_files_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-031-aurora-antitrust/04_custodian_files/031_custodian_files_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-031-aurora-antitrust/04_custodian_files/032_custodian_files_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-031-aurora-antitrust/05_email_families/033_email_families_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-031-aurora-antitrust/05_email_families/034_email_families_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-031-aurora-antitrust/05_email_families/035_email_families_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-031-aurora-antitrust/05_email_families/036_email_families_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-031-aurora-antitrust/05_email_families/037_email_families_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-031-aurora-antitrust/05_email_families/038_email_families_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-031-aurora-antitrust/05_email_families/039_email_families_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-031-aurora-antitrust/05_email_families/040_email_families_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-031-aurora-antitrust/06_chat_exports/041_chat_exports_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-031-aurora-antitrust/06_chat_exports/042_chat_exports_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-031-aurora-antitrust/06_chat_exports/043_chat_exports_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-031-aurora-antitrust/06_chat_exports/044_chat_exports_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-031-aurora-antitrust/06_chat_exports/045_chat_exports_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-031-aurora-antitrust/06_chat_exports/046_chat_exports_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-031-aurora-antitrust/06_chat_exports/047_chat_exports_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-031-aurora-antitrust/06_chat_exports/048_chat_exports_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-031-aurora-antitrust/07_privilege_material/049_privilege_material_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-031-aurora-antitrust/07_privilege_material/050_privilege_material_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-031-aurora-antitrust/07_privilege_material/051_privilege_material_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-031-aurora-antitrust/07_privilege_material/052_privilege_material_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-031-aurora-antitrust/07_privilege_material/053_privilege_material_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-031-aurora-antitrust/07_privilege_material/054_privilege_material_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-031-aurora-antitrust/07_privilege_material/055_privilege_material_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-031-aurora-antitrust/07_privilege_material/056_privilege_material_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-031-aurora-antitrust/08_production_logs/057_production_logs_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-031-aurora-antitrust/08_production_logs/058_production_logs_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-031-aurora-antitrust/08_production_logs/059_production_logs_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-031-aurora-antitrust/08_production_logs/060_production_logs_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-031-aurora-antitrust/08_production_logs/061_production_logs_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-031-aurora-antitrust/08_production_logs/062_production_logs_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-031-aurora-antitrust/08_production_logs/063_production_logs_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-031-aurora-antitrust/08_production_logs/064_production_logs_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-031-aurora-antitrust/09_depositions/065_depositions_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-031-aurora-antitrust/09_depositions/066_depositions_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-031-aurora-antitrust/09_depositions/067_depositions_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-031-aurora-antitrust/09_depositions/068_depositions_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-031-aurora-antitrust/09_depositions/069_depositions_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-031-aurora-antitrust/09_depositions/070_depositions_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-031-aurora-antitrust/09_depositions/071_depositions_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-031-aurora-antitrust/09_depositions/072_depositions_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-031-aurora-antitrust/10_expert_material/073_expert_material_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-031-aurora-antitrust/10_expert_material/074_expert_material_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-031-aurora-antitrust/10_expert_material/075_expert_material_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-031-aurora-antitrust/10_expert_material/076_expert_material_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-031-aurora-antitrust/10_expert_material/077_expert_material_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-031-aurora-antitrust/10_expert_material/078_expert_material_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-031-aurora-antitrust/10_expert_material/079_expert_material_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-031-aurora-antitrust/10_expert_material/080_expert_material_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-031-aurora-antitrust/11_third_party/081_third_party_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-031-aurora-antitrust/11_third_party/082_third_party_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-031-aurora-antitrust/11_third_party/083_third_party_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-031-aurora-antitrust/11_third_party/084_third_party_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-031-aurora-antitrust/11_third_party/085_third_party_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-031-aurora-antitrust/11_third_party/086_third_party_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-031-aurora-antitrust/11_third_party/087_third_party_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-031-aurora-antitrust/11_third_party/088_third_party_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-031-aurora-antitrust/12_case_management/089_case_management_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-031-aurora-antitrust/12_case_management/090_case_management_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-031-aurora-antitrust/12_case_management/091_case_management_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-031-aurora-antitrust/12_case_management/092_case_management_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-031-aurora-antitrust/12_case_management/093_case_management_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-031-aurora-antitrust/12_case_management/094_case_management_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-031-aurora-antitrust/12_case_management/095_case_management_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-031-aurora-antitrust/12_case_management/096_case_management_status_report.md"], "gold_output": {"advice_markdown": "# Counsel advice — Aurora pricing MDL discovery audit\n\n## Executive assessment\n\nFor Aurora Home Supply Co. matter CB-LD-2701, the review identified 16 source-supported exceptions requiring action before 2026-09-05. The assessment concerns In re Residential Fixture Pricing and the supplied record for Illinois.\n\n## Method and record coverage\n\nThe review inventoried all 96 production files, read the 33 controlling, corroborating, and control records, searched the email exports, and checked metadata for the designated chain-of-custody sample. Conclusions are limited to the synthetic production supplied for this benchmark matter.\n\n## Findings\n\n### F-01 — custodian omission (critical)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for custodian omission: one source states the operative date is 2025-05-01 under control reference CB-LD-2701-A158, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2025-06-11 under response reference CB-LD-2701-J935.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/01_pleadings/001_pleadings_control_register.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/07_privilege_material/049_privilege_material_control_register.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-05, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Henry Cho.\n\n### F-02 — legal-hold delivery gap (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for legal-hold delivery gap: one source states the controlling amount is $4,769,198.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $4,954,896.00.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/01_pleadings/004_pleadings_ledger_export.csv`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/07_privilege_material/052_privilege_material_ledger_export.csv`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-05, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Nadine Flores.\n\n### F-03 — collection-date inconsistency (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for collection-date inconsistency: one source states approval is attributed to Sofia Bennett as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Elliot Mercer and contains no entry for Sofia Bennett.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/01_pleadings/007_pleadings_officer_certificate.html`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/07_privilege_material/055_privilege_material_officer_certificate.html`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-05, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Micah Sullivan.\n\n### F-04 — email-family separation (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for email-family separation: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-LD-2701-D305, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-LD-2701-M115.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/02_orders/010_orders_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/08_production_logs/058_production_logs_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-05, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Farah Ibrahim.\n\n### F-05 — privilege-log description defect (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for privilege-log description defect: one source states the applicable location is Northern District of Illinois, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to Illinois operations outside Northern District of Illinois.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/02_orders/013_orders_review_memorandum.json`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/08_production_logs/061_production_logs_review_memorandum.json`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-05, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Owen Delgado.\n\n### F-06 — common-interest support gap (low)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for common-interest support gap: one source states the threshold is 12% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 14% and produced a different exception result.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/02_orders/016_orders_status_report.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/08_production_logs/064_production_logs_status_report.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-05, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Lena Varga.\n\n### F-07 — clawback deadline (critical)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for clawback deadline: one source states formal notice must use notices-aurora_home_supply_co@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-in_re_residential_fixture_pricing@example.test.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/019_requests_responses_correspondence.eml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/09_depositions/067_depositions_correspondence.eml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-05, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Samuel Kim.\n\n### F-08 — protective-order designation error (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for protective-order designation error: one source states the governed population contains 72 records through 2025-11-03, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 73 records through 2025-12-18.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/022_requests_responses_formal_notice.xml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/09_depositions/070_depositions_formal_notice.xml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-05, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Maya Ellison.\n\n### F-09 — request-response mismatch (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for request-response mismatch: one source states the operative date is 2025-08-11 under control reference CB-LD-2701-I680, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2025-09-09 under response reference CB-LD-2701-R836.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/025_custodian_files_control_register.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/10_expert_material/073_expert_material_control_register.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-05, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Rafael Okafor.\n\n### F-10 — deposition exhibit omission (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for deposition exhibit omission: one source states the controlling amount is $1,072,503.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $1,211,506.00.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/028_custodian_files_ledger_export.csv`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/10_expert_material/076_expert_material_ledger_export.csv`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-05, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Nora Chen.\n\n### F-11 — expert draft segregation (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for expert draft segregation: one source states approval is attributed to Sofia Bennett as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Owen Delgado and contains no entry for Sofia Bennett.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/031_custodian_files_officer_certificate.html`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/10_expert_material/079_expert_material_officer_certificate.html`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-05, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Dominic Alvarez.\n\n### F-12 — third-party subpoena deadline (low)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for third-party subpoena deadline: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-LD-2701-L422, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-LD-2701-U955.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/05_email_families/034_email_families_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/11_third_party/082_third_party_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-05, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Priya Raman.\n\n### F-13 — production gap (critical)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for production gap: one source states the applicable location is Northern District of Illinois, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to Illinois operations outside Northern District of Illinois.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/05_email_families/037_email_families_review_memorandum.json`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/11_third_party/085_third_party_review_memorandum.json`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-05, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Elliot Mercer.\n\n### F-14 — metadata field loss (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for metadata field loss: one source states the threshold is 3% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 6% and produced a different exception result.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/05_email_families/040_email_families_status_report.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/11_third_party/088_third_party_status_report.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-05, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Talia Brooks.\n\n### F-15 — Bates-range overlap (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for Bates-range overlap: one source states formal notice must use notices-aurora_home_supply_co@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-in_re_residential_fixture_pricing@example.test.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/043_chat_exports_correspondence.eml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/12_case_management/091_case_management_correspondence.eml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-05, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Jonas Feld.\n\n### F-16 — meet-and-confer commitment (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for meet-and-confer commitment: one source states the governed population contains 101 records through 2025-07-15, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 56 records through 2025-08-12.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/046_chat_exports_formal_notice.xml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/12_case_management/094_case_management_formal_notice.xml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-05, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Mei Whitaker.\n\n## Recommended next actions\n\nSequence the critical and high findings first, assign the named owners, preserve the cited records, and document any resolution in the controlling matter register before the stated deadline.\n\n## Assumptions and limitations\n\nThis analysis is confined to task cb100-031-aurora-antitrust and the supplied synthetic evidence. It does not rely on external facts, does not resolve disputed law, and is not legal advice for a real person or entity.\n", "findings": {"as_of": "2026-09-05", "findings": [{"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/07_privilege_material/049_privilege_material_control_register.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for custodian omission: one source states the operative date is 2025-05-01 under control reference CB-LD-2701-A158, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2025-06-11 under response reference CB-LD-2701-J935.", "id": "F-01", "issue": "custodian omission", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/01_pleadings/001_pleadings_control_register.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-05, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Henry Cho.", "severity": "critical"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/07_privilege_material/052_privilege_material_ledger_export.csv", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for legal-hold delivery gap: one source states the controlling amount is $4,769,198.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $4,954,896.00.", "id": "F-02", "issue": "legal-hold delivery gap", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/01_pleadings/004_pleadings_ledger_export.csv", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-05, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Nadine Flores.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/07_privilege_material/055_privilege_material_officer_certificate.html", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for collection-date inconsistency: one source states approval is attributed to Sofia Bennett as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Elliot Mercer and contains no entry for Sofia Bennett.", "id": "F-03", "issue": "collection-date inconsistency", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/01_pleadings/007_pleadings_officer_certificate.html", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-05, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Micah Sullivan.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/08_production_logs/058_production_logs_executed_instrument.txt", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for email-family separation: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-LD-2701-D305, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-LD-2701-M115.", "id": "F-04", "issue": "email-family separation", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/02_orders/010_orders_executed_instrument.txt", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-05, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Farah Ibrahim.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/08_production_logs/061_production_logs_review_memorandum.json", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for privilege-log description defect: one source states the applicable location is Northern District of Illinois, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to Illinois operations outside Northern District of Illinois.", "id": "F-05", "issue": "privilege-log description defect", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/02_orders/013_orders_review_memorandum.json", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-05, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Owen Delgado.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/08_production_logs/064_production_logs_status_report.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for common-interest support gap: one source states the threshold is 12% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 14% and produced a different exception result.", "id": "F-06", "issue": "common-interest support gap", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/02_orders/016_orders_status_report.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-05, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Lena Varga.", "severity": "low"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/09_depositions/067_depositions_correspondence.eml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for clawback deadline: one source states formal notice must use notices-aurora_home_supply_co@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-in_re_residential_fixture_pricing@example.test.", "id": "F-07", "issue": "clawback deadline", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/019_requests_responses_correspondence.eml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-05, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Samuel Kim.", "severity": "critical"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/09_depositions/070_depositions_formal_notice.xml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for protective-order designation error: one source states the governed population contains 72 records through 2025-11-03, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 73 records through 2025-12-18.", "id": "F-08", "issue": "protective-order designation error", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/022_requests_responses_formal_notice.xml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-05, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Maya Ellison.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/10_expert_material/073_expert_material_control_register.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for request-response mismatch: one source states the operative date is 2025-08-11 under control reference CB-LD-2701-I680, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2025-09-09 under response reference CB-LD-2701-R836.", "id": "F-09", "issue": "request-response mismatch", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/025_custodian_files_control_register.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-05, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Rafael Okafor.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/10_expert_material/076_expert_material_ledger_export.csv", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for deposition exhibit omission: one source states the controlling amount is $1,072,503.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $1,211,506.00.", "id": "F-10", "issue": "deposition exhibit omission", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/028_custodian_files_ledger_export.csv", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-05, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Nora Chen.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/10_expert_material/079_expert_material_officer_certificate.html", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for expert draft segregation: one source states approval is attributed to Sofia Bennett as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Owen Delgado and contains no entry for Sofia Bennett.", "id": "F-11", "issue": "expert draft segregation", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/031_custodian_files_officer_certificate.html", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-05, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Dominic Alvarez.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/11_third_party/082_third_party_executed_instrument.txt", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for third-party subpoena deadline: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-LD-2701-L422, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-LD-2701-U955.", "id": "F-12", "issue": "third-party subpoena deadline", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/05_email_families/034_email_families_executed_instrument.txt", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-05, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Priya Raman.", "severity": "low"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/11_third_party/085_third_party_review_memorandum.json", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for production gap: one source states the applicable location is Northern District of Illinois, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to Illinois operations outside Northern District of Illinois.", "id": "F-13", "issue": "production gap", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/05_email_families/037_email_families_review_memorandum.json", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-05, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Elliot Mercer.", "severity": "critical"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/11_third_party/088_third_party_status_report.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for metadata field loss: one source states the threshold is 3% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 6% and produced a different exception result.", "id": "F-14", "issue": "metadata field loss", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/05_email_families/040_email_families_status_report.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-05, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Talia Brooks.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/12_case_management/091_case_management_correspondence.eml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for Bates-range overlap: one source states formal notice must use notices-aurora_home_supply_co@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-in_re_residential_fixture_pricing@example.test.", "id": "F-15", "issue": "Bates-range overlap", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/043_chat_exports_correspondence.eml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-05, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Jonas Feld.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/12_case_management/094_case_management_formal_notice.xml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for meet-and-confer commitment: one source states the governed population contains 101 records through 2025-07-15, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 56 records through 2025-08-12.", "id": "F-16", "issue": "meet-and-confer commitment", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/046_chat_exports_formal_notice.xml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-05, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Mei Whitaker.", "severity": "medium"}], "matter_number": "CB-LD-2701", "prepared_for": "Aurora Home Supply Co.", "schema_version": "1.0", "task_id": "cb100-031-aurora-antitrust"}}, "metadata": {"benchmark": "CounselBench-100", "code_license": "Apache-2.0", "data_license": "CC-BY-4.0", "deadline": "2026-09-05", "document_count": 96, "jurisdiction": "Illinois", "matter_number": "CB-LD-2701", "mcp_commit": "9a96ea6e5913736f92b88345bf51caeaaa8e719f", "mcp_package": "@modelcontextprotocol/server-filesystem@2026.7.10", "practice_area": "litigation-discovery", "reference_tool_calls": 46, "required_evidence_reads": 33, "synthetic": true, "venue": "Northern District of Illinois", "version": "2.0.0"}, "prompt": "You are discovery counsel for Aurora Home Supply Co. The partner responsible for this matter needs a defensible decision record before the next client call. A multidistrict antitrust production must reconcile mobile chats, departed custodians, overlapping Bates ranges, and a pending privilege challenge. Decision due 2026-09-05. Illinois law governs; Northern District of Illinois is the forum. Prioritize conflicts between signed instruments and later operational records. Work out the defensible position from the matter production and leave an audit-ready exception tracker and concise advice for the supervising lawyer. Keep confirmed conflicts separate from open questions, cite the records that actually control each conclusion, and do not fill gaps with outside facts.", "rubric": {"criteria": [{"category": "procedure", "description": "Complete at least 46 successful, argument-specific evidence and output calls.", "id": "procedure.minimum_successful_tool_calls"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Find and read the 33 controlling, corroborating, and work-product-control records in full.", "id": "procedure.all_evidence_read_in_full"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Inspect file metadata for the eight designated critical primary records before relying on them.", "id": "procedure.chain_of_custody_metadata_checked"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Confirm the sandbox's allowed document and output roots.", "id": "procedure.allowed_directories_checked"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Inventory all 96 records so the relevant sources are discovered among the context records.", "id": "procedure.recursive_inventory_completed"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Search the production for email evidence that may corroborate or contradict formal records.", "id": "procedure.targeted_search_completed"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Leave only findings.json and advice.md in the output workspace.", "id": "procedure.exact_deliverable_set"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Create both final work products through the sandbox MCP surface.", "id": "procedure.deliverables_written_through_mcp"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Produce findings.json as a valid JSON object.", "id": "findings.findings_is_object"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Report exactly 16 confirmed exceptions.", "id": "findings.findings_exact_count"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Use each stable finding ID exactly once.", "id": "findings.finding_ids_unique"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set schema_version to the released matter value '1.0'.", "id": "findings.top_level_schema_version"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set task_id to the released matter value 'cb100-031-aurora-antitrust'.", "id": "findings.top_level_task_id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set matter_number to the released matter value 'CB-LD-2701'.", "id": "findings.top_level_matter_number"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set prepared_for to the released matter value 'Aurora Home Supply Co.'.", "id": "findings.top_level_prepared_for"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set as_of to the released matter value '2026-09-05'.", "id": "findings.top_level_as_of"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-01 exception for custodian omission.", "id": "findings.F-01.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's id from /workspace/documents/01_pleadings/001_pleadings_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_privilege_material/049_privilege_material_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's issue from /workspace/documents/01_pleadings/001_pleadings_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_privilege_material/049_privilege_material_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's severity from /workspace/documents/01_pleadings/001_pleadings_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_privilege_material/049_privilege_material_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's primary_source from /workspace/documents/01_pleadings/001_pleadings_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_privilege_material/049_privilege_material_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/01_pleadings/001_pleadings_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_privilege_material/049_privilege_material_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-01 using the exact controlled facts ['2025-05-01', 'CB-LD-2701-A158', '2025-06-11', 'CB-LD-2701-J935'].", "id": "findings.F-01.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-01's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-01.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-05', 'Henry Cho'] for F-01.", "id": "findings.F-01.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-02 exception for legal-hold delivery gap.", "id": "findings.F-02.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's id from /workspace/documents/01_pleadings/004_pleadings_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_privilege_material/052_privilege_material_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's issue from /workspace/documents/01_pleadings/004_pleadings_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_privilege_material/052_privilege_material_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's severity from /workspace/documents/01_pleadings/004_pleadings_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_privilege_material/052_privilege_material_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's primary_source from /workspace/documents/01_pleadings/004_pleadings_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_privilege_material/052_privilege_material_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/01_pleadings/004_pleadings_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_privilege_material/052_privilege_material_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-02 using the exact controlled facts ['$4,769,198.00', '$4,954,896.00'].", "id": "findings.F-02.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-02's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-02.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-05', 'Nadine Flores'] for F-02.", "id": "findings.F-02.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-03 exception for collection-date inconsistency.", "id": "findings.F-03.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's id from /workspace/documents/01_pleadings/007_pleadings_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_privilege_material/055_privilege_material_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's issue from /workspace/documents/01_pleadings/007_pleadings_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_privilege_material/055_privilege_material_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's severity from /workspace/documents/01_pleadings/007_pleadings_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_privilege_material/055_privilege_material_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's primary_source from /workspace/documents/01_pleadings/007_pleadings_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_privilege_material/055_privilege_material_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/01_pleadings/007_pleadings_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_privilege_material/055_privilege_material_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-03 using the exact controlled facts ['Sofia Bennett', 'Elliot Mercer'].", "id": "findings.F-03.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-03's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-03.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-05', 'Micah Sullivan'] for F-03.", "id": "findings.F-03.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-04 exception for email-family separation.", "id": "findings.F-04.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's id from /workspace/documents/02_orders/010_orders_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_production_logs/058_production_logs_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's issue from /workspace/documents/02_orders/010_orders_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_production_logs/058_production_logs_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's severity from /workspace/documents/02_orders/010_orders_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_production_logs/058_production_logs_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's primary_source from /workspace/documents/02_orders/010_orders_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_production_logs/058_production_logs_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/02_orders/010_orders_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_production_logs/058_production_logs_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-04 using the exact controlled facts ['closed without exception', 'CB-LD-2701-D305', 'open and escalated', 'CB-LD-2701-M115'].", "id": "findings.F-04.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-04's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-04.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-05', 'Farah Ibrahim'] for F-04.", "id": "findings.F-04.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-05 exception for privilege-log description defect.", "id": "findings.F-05.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's id from /workspace/documents/02_orders/013_orders_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_production_logs/061_production_logs_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's issue from /workspace/documents/02_orders/013_orders_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_production_logs/061_production_logs_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's severity from /workspace/documents/02_orders/013_orders_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_production_logs/061_production_logs_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's primary_source from /workspace/documents/02_orders/013_orders_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_production_logs/061_production_logs_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/02_orders/013_orders_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_production_logs/061_production_logs_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-05 using the exact controlled facts ['Northern District of Illinois', 'Illinois'].", "id": "findings.F-05.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-05's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-05.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-05', 'Owen Delgado'] for F-05.", "id": "findings.F-05.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-06 exception for common-interest support gap.", "id": "findings.F-06.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's id from /workspace/documents/02_orders/016_orders_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_production_logs/064_production_logs_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's issue from /workspace/documents/02_orders/016_orders_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_production_logs/064_production_logs_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's severity from /workspace/documents/02_orders/016_orders_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_production_logs/064_production_logs_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's primary_source from /workspace/documents/02_orders/016_orders_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_production_logs/064_production_logs_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/02_orders/016_orders_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_production_logs/064_production_logs_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-06 using the exact controlled facts ['12%', '14%'].", "id": "findings.F-06.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-06's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-06.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-05', 'Lena Varga'] for F-06.", "id": "findings.F-06.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-07 exception for clawback deadline.", "id": "findings.F-07.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's id from /workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/019_requests_responses_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_depositions/067_depositions_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's issue from /workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/019_requests_responses_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_depositions/067_depositions_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's severity from /workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/019_requests_responses_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_depositions/067_depositions_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's primary_source from /workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/019_requests_responses_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_depositions/067_depositions_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/019_requests_responses_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_depositions/067_depositions_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-07 using the exact controlled facts ['notices-aurora_home_supply_co@example.test', 'archive-in_re_residential_fixture_pricing@example.test'].", "id": "findings.F-07.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-07's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-07.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-05', 'Samuel Kim'] for F-07.", "id": "findings.F-07.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-08 exception for protective-order designation error.", "id": "findings.F-08.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's id from /workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/022_requests_responses_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_depositions/070_depositions_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's issue from /workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/022_requests_responses_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_depositions/070_depositions_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's severity from /workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/022_requests_responses_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_depositions/070_depositions_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's primary_source from /workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/022_requests_responses_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_depositions/070_depositions_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/022_requests_responses_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_depositions/070_depositions_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-08 using the exact controlled facts ['72 records', '2025-11-03', '73 records', '2025-12-18'].", "id": "findings.F-08.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-08's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-08.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-05', 'Maya Ellison'] for F-08.", "id": "findings.F-08.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-09 exception for request-response mismatch.", "id": "findings.F-09.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's id from /workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/025_custodian_files_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_expert_material/073_expert_material_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's issue from /workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/025_custodian_files_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_expert_material/073_expert_material_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's severity from /workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/025_custodian_files_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_expert_material/073_expert_material_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's primary_source from /workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/025_custodian_files_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_expert_material/073_expert_material_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/025_custodian_files_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_expert_material/073_expert_material_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-09 using the exact controlled facts ['2025-08-11', 'CB-LD-2701-I680', '2025-09-09', 'CB-LD-2701-R836'].", "id": "findings.F-09.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-09's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-09.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-05', 'Rafael Okafor'] for F-09.", "id": "findings.F-09.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-10 exception for deposition exhibit omission.", "id": "findings.F-10.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's id from /workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/028_custodian_files_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_expert_material/076_expert_material_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's issue from /workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/028_custodian_files_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_expert_material/076_expert_material_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's severity from /workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/028_custodian_files_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_expert_material/076_expert_material_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's primary_source from /workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/028_custodian_files_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_expert_material/076_expert_material_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/028_custodian_files_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_expert_material/076_expert_material_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-10 using the exact controlled facts ['$1,072,503.00', '$1,211,506.00'].", "id": "findings.F-10.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-10's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-10.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-05', 'Nora Chen'] for F-10.", "id": "findings.F-10.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-11 exception for expert draft segregation.", "id": "findings.F-11.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's id from /workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/031_custodian_files_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_expert_material/079_expert_material_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's issue from /workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/031_custodian_files_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_expert_material/079_expert_material_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's severity from /workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/031_custodian_files_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_expert_material/079_expert_material_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's primary_source from /workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/031_custodian_files_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_expert_material/079_expert_material_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/031_custodian_files_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_expert_material/079_expert_material_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-11 using the exact controlled facts ['Sofia Bennett', 'Owen Delgado'].", "id": "findings.F-11.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-11's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-11.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-05', 'Dominic Alvarez'] for F-11.", "id": "findings.F-11.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-12 exception for third-party subpoena deadline.", "id": "findings.F-12.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's id from /workspace/documents/05_email_families/034_email_families_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_third_party/082_third_party_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's issue from /workspace/documents/05_email_families/034_email_families_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_third_party/082_third_party_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's severity from /workspace/documents/05_email_families/034_email_families_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_third_party/082_third_party_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's primary_source from /workspace/documents/05_email_families/034_email_families_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_third_party/082_third_party_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/05_email_families/034_email_families_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_third_party/082_third_party_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-12 using the exact controlled facts ['closed without exception', 'CB-LD-2701-L422', 'open and escalated', 'CB-LD-2701-U955'].", "id": "findings.F-12.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-12's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-12.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-05', 'Priya Raman'] for F-12.", "id": "findings.F-12.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-13 exception for production gap.", "id": "findings.F-13.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's id from /workspace/documents/05_email_families/037_email_families_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_third_party/085_third_party_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's issue from /workspace/documents/05_email_families/037_email_families_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_third_party/085_third_party_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's severity from /workspace/documents/05_email_families/037_email_families_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_third_party/085_third_party_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's primary_source from /workspace/documents/05_email_families/037_email_families_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_third_party/085_third_party_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/05_email_families/037_email_families_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_third_party/085_third_party_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-13 using the exact controlled facts ['Northern District of Illinois', 'Illinois'].", "id": "findings.F-13.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-13's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-13.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-05', 'Elliot Mercer'] for F-13.", "id": "findings.F-13.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-14 exception for metadata field loss.", "id": "findings.F-14.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's id from /workspace/documents/05_email_families/040_email_families_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_third_party/088_third_party_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's issue from /workspace/documents/05_email_families/040_email_families_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_third_party/088_third_party_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's severity from /workspace/documents/05_email_families/040_email_families_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_third_party/088_third_party_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's primary_source from /workspace/documents/05_email_families/040_email_families_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_third_party/088_third_party_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/05_email_families/040_email_families_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_third_party/088_third_party_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-14 using the exact controlled facts ['3%', '6%'].", "id": "findings.F-14.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-14's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-14.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-05', 'Talia Brooks'] for F-14.", "id": "findings.F-14.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-15 exception for Bates-range overlap.", "id": "findings.F-15.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's id from /workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/043_chat_exports_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_case_management/091_case_management_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's issue from /workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/043_chat_exports_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_case_management/091_case_management_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's severity from /workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/043_chat_exports_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_case_management/091_case_management_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's primary_source from /workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/043_chat_exports_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_case_management/091_case_management_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/043_chat_exports_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_case_management/091_case_management_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-15 using the exact controlled facts ['notices-aurora_home_supply_co@example.test', 'archive-in_re_residential_fixture_pricing@example.test'].", "id": "findings.F-15.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-15's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-15.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-05', 'Jonas Feld'] for F-15.", "id": "findings.F-15.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-16 exception for meet-and-confer commitment.", "id": "findings.F-16.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's id from /workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/046_chat_exports_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_case_management/094_case_management_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's issue from /workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/046_chat_exports_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_case_management/094_case_management_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's severity from /workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/046_chat_exports_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_case_management/094_case_management_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's primary_source from /workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/046_chat_exports_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_case_management/094_case_management_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/046_chat_exports_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_case_management/094_case_management_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-16 using the exact controlled facts ['101 records', '2025-07-15', '56 records', '2025-08-12'].", "id": "findings.F-16.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-16's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-16.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-05', 'Mei Whitaker'] for F-16.", "id": "findings.F-16.action_anchors"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Executive assessment' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Executive assessment"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Method and record coverage' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Method and record coverage"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Findings' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Findings"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Recommended next actions' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Recommended next actions"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Assumptions and limitations' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Assumptions and limitations"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-01 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-01"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-02 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-02"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-03 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-03"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-04 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-04"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-05 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-05"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-06 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-06"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-07 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-07"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-08 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-08"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-09 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-09"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-10 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-10"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-11 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-11"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-12 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-12"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-13 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-13"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-14 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-14"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-15 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-15"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-16 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-16"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Do not claim the production has no issues or that every record is consistent.", "id": "memo.forbidden_claims_absent"}], "decision_options": [{"id": "cross-source-reconciliation", "label": "Reconcile controlling and corroborating records", "reason": "The CB-LD-2701 production contains independently maintained records; a defensible answer must preserve each supported conflict and its cure owner.", "selected": true}, {"id": "latest-record-controls", "label": "Treat the latest record as controlling", "reason": "Timestamp recency does not establish legal priority, execution, or approval authority.", "selected": false}, {"id": "primary-records-only", "label": "Report primary records without reconciliation", "reason": "Primary records alone conceal the operational conflicts that create the actionable exceptions.", "selected": false}], "gates": ["all_evidence_read_in_full", "chain_of_custody_metadata_checked", "findings_criteria_complete", "memo_criteria_complete", "deliverables_written_through_mcp"], "metadata_checks": 8, "metric": "weighted_criteria_score", "minimum_tool_calls": 46, "required_deliverables": ["findings.json", "advice.md"], "required_document_reads": 33, "type": "deterministic", "weights": {"findings": 0.55, "memo": 0.2, "procedure": 0.25}}, "task_id": "cb100-031-aurora-antitrust", "task_name": "Aurora pricing MDL discovery audit", "world_id": "counselbench-filesystem-mcp-v2"}
-{"context_files": ["task_files/cb100-032-bayfield-patent/01_pleadings/001_pleadings_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-032-bayfield-patent/01_pleadings/002_pleadings_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-032-bayfield-patent/01_pleadings/003_pleadings_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-032-bayfield-patent/01_pleadings/004_pleadings_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-032-bayfield-patent/01_pleadings/005_pleadings_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-032-bayfield-patent/01_pleadings/006_pleadings_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-032-bayfield-patent/01_pleadings/007_pleadings_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-032-bayfield-patent/01_pleadings/008_pleadings_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-032-bayfield-patent/02_orders/009_orders_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-032-bayfield-patent/02_orders/010_orders_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-032-bayfield-patent/02_orders/011_orders_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-032-bayfield-patent/02_orders/012_orders_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-032-bayfield-patent/02_orders/013_orders_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-032-bayfield-patent/02_orders/014_orders_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-032-bayfield-patent/02_orders/015_orders_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-032-bayfield-patent/02_orders/016_orders_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-032-bayfield-patent/03_requests_responses/017_requests_responses_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-032-bayfield-patent/03_requests_responses/018_requests_responses_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-032-bayfield-patent/03_requests_responses/019_requests_responses_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-032-bayfield-patent/03_requests_responses/020_requests_responses_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-032-bayfield-patent/03_requests_responses/021_requests_responses_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-032-bayfield-patent/03_requests_responses/022_requests_responses_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-032-bayfield-patent/03_requests_responses/023_requests_responses_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-032-bayfield-patent/03_requests_responses/024_requests_responses_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-032-bayfield-patent/04_custodian_files/025_custodian_files_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-032-bayfield-patent/04_custodian_files/026_custodian_files_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-032-bayfield-patent/04_custodian_files/027_custodian_files_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-032-bayfield-patent/04_custodian_files/028_custodian_files_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-032-bayfield-patent/04_custodian_files/029_custodian_files_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-032-bayfield-patent/04_custodian_files/030_custodian_files_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-032-bayfield-patent/04_custodian_files/031_custodian_files_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-032-bayfield-patent/04_custodian_files/032_custodian_files_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-032-bayfield-patent/05_email_families/033_email_families_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-032-bayfield-patent/05_email_families/034_email_families_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-032-bayfield-patent/05_email_families/035_email_families_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-032-bayfield-patent/05_email_families/036_email_families_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-032-bayfield-patent/05_email_families/037_email_families_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-032-bayfield-patent/05_email_families/038_email_families_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-032-bayfield-patent/05_email_families/039_email_families_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-032-bayfield-patent/05_email_families/040_email_families_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-032-bayfield-patent/06_chat_exports/041_chat_exports_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-032-bayfield-patent/06_chat_exports/042_chat_exports_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-032-bayfield-patent/06_chat_exports/043_chat_exports_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-032-bayfield-patent/06_chat_exports/044_chat_exports_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-032-bayfield-patent/06_chat_exports/045_chat_exports_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-032-bayfield-patent/06_chat_exports/046_chat_exports_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-032-bayfield-patent/06_chat_exports/047_chat_exports_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-032-bayfield-patent/06_chat_exports/048_chat_exports_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-032-bayfield-patent/07_privilege_material/049_privilege_material_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-032-bayfield-patent/07_privilege_material/050_privilege_material_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-032-bayfield-patent/07_privilege_material/051_privilege_material_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-032-bayfield-patent/07_privilege_material/052_privilege_material_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-032-bayfield-patent/07_privilege_material/053_privilege_material_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-032-bayfield-patent/07_privilege_material/054_privilege_material_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-032-bayfield-patent/07_privilege_material/055_privilege_material_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-032-bayfield-patent/07_privilege_material/056_privilege_material_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-032-bayfield-patent/08_production_logs/057_production_logs_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-032-bayfield-patent/08_production_logs/058_production_logs_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-032-bayfield-patent/08_production_logs/059_production_logs_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-032-bayfield-patent/08_production_logs/060_production_logs_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-032-bayfield-patent/08_production_logs/061_production_logs_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-032-bayfield-patent/08_production_logs/062_production_logs_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-032-bayfield-patent/08_production_logs/063_production_logs_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-032-bayfield-patent/08_production_logs/064_production_logs_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-032-bayfield-patent/09_depositions/065_depositions_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-032-bayfield-patent/09_depositions/066_depositions_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-032-bayfield-patent/09_depositions/067_depositions_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-032-bayfield-patent/09_depositions/068_depositions_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-032-bayfield-patent/09_depositions/069_depositions_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-032-bayfield-patent/09_depositions/070_depositions_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-032-bayfield-patent/09_depositions/071_depositions_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-032-bayfield-patent/09_depositions/072_depositions_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-032-bayfield-patent/10_expert_material/073_expert_material_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-032-bayfield-patent/10_expert_material/074_expert_material_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-032-bayfield-patent/10_expert_material/075_expert_material_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-032-bayfield-patent/10_expert_material/076_expert_material_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-032-bayfield-patent/10_expert_material/077_expert_material_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-032-bayfield-patent/10_expert_material/078_expert_material_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-032-bayfield-patent/10_expert_material/079_expert_material_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-032-bayfield-patent/10_expert_material/080_expert_material_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-032-bayfield-patent/11_third_party/081_third_party_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-032-bayfield-patent/11_third_party/082_third_party_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-032-bayfield-patent/11_third_party/083_third_party_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-032-bayfield-patent/11_third_party/084_third_party_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-032-bayfield-patent/11_third_party/085_third_party_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-032-bayfield-patent/11_third_party/086_third_party_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-032-bayfield-patent/11_third_party/087_third_party_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-032-bayfield-patent/11_third_party/088_third_party_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-032-bayfield-patent/12_case_management/089_case_management_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-032-bayfield-patent/12_case_management/090_case_management_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-032-bayfield-patent/12_case_management/091_case_management_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-032-bayfield-patent/12_case_management/092_case_management_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-032-bayfield-patent/12_case_management/093_case_management_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-032-bayfield-patent/12_case_management/094_case_management_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-032-bayfield-patent/12_case_management/095_case_management_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-032-bayfield-patent/12_case_management/096_case_management_status_report.md"], "gold_output": {"advice_markdown": "# Counsel advice — Bayfield patent case production review\n\n## Executive assessment\n\nFor Bayfield Sensorics, Inc. matter CB-LD-2702, the review identified 16 source-supported exceptions requiring action before 2026-09-09. The assessment concerns Kestrel Vision Systems LLC and the supplied record for Delaware.\n\n## Method and record coverage\n\nThe review inventoried all 96 production files, read the 33 controlling, corroborating, and control records, searched the email exports, and checked metadata for the designated chain-of-custody sample. Conclusions are limited to the synthetic production supplied for this benchmark matter.\n\n## Findings\n\n### F-01 — custodian omission (critical)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for custodian omission: one source states the operative date is 2025-07-26 under control reference CB-LD-2702-A784, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2025-08-31 under response reference CB-LD-2702-J568.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/01_pleadings/001_pleadings_control_register.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/07_privilege_material/049_privilege_material_control_register.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-09, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Nadine Flores.\n\n### F-02 — legal-hold delivery gap (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for legal-hold delivery gap: one source states the controlling amount is $1,419,361.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $1,675,222.00.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/01_pleadings/004_pleadings_ledger_export.csv`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/07_privilege_material/052_privilege_material_ledger_export.csv`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-09, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Micah Sullivan.\n\n### F-03 — collection-date inconsistency (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for collection-date inconsistency: one source states approval is attributed to Adrian Mensah as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Jonas Feld and contains no entry for Adrian Mensah.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/01_pleadings/007_pleadings_officer_certificate.html`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/07_privilege_material/055_privilege_material_officer_certificate.html`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-09, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Farah Ibrahim.\n\n### F-04 — email-family separation (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for email-family separation: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-LD-2702-D803, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-LD-2702-M846.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/02_orders/010_orders_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/08_production_logs/058_production_logs_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-09, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Owen Delgado.\n\n### F-05 — privilege-log description defect (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for privilege-log description defect: one source states the applicable location is District of Delaware, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to Delaware operations outside District of Delaware.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/02_orders/013_orders_review_memorandum.json`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/08_production_logs/061_production_logs_review_memorandum.json`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-09, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Lena Varga.\n\n### F-06 — common-interest support gap (low)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for common-interest support gap: one source states the threshold is 6% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 10% and produced a different exception result.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/02_orders/016_orders_status_report.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/08_production_logs/064_production_logs_status_report.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-09, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Samuel Kim.\n\n### F-07 — clawback deadline (critical)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for clawback deadline: one source states formal notice must use notices-bayfield_sensorics_inc@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-kestrel_vision_systems_llc@example.test.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/019_requests_responses_correspondence.eml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/09_depositions/067_depositions_correspondence.eml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-09, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Maya Ellison.\n\n### F-08 — protective-order designation error (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for protective-order designation error: one source states the governed population contains 171 records through 2025-05-06, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 38 records through 2025-05-16.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/022_requests_responses_formal_notice.xml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/09_depositions/070_depositions_formal_notice.xml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-09, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Rafael Okafor.\n\n### F-09 — request-response mismatch (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for request-response mismatch: one source states the operative date is 2025-06-03 under control reference CB-LD-2702-I551, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2025-06-25 under response reference CB-LD-2702-R480.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/025_custodian_files_control_register.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/10_expert_material/073_expert_material_control_register.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-09, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Nora Chen.\n\n### F-10 — deposition exhibit omission (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for deposition exhibit omission: one source states the controlling amount is $568,666.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $863,832.00.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/028_custodian_files_ledger_export.csv`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/10_expert_material/076_expert_material_ledger_export.csv`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-09, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Dominic Alvarez.\n\n### F-11 — expert draft segregation (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for expert draft segregation: one source states approval is attributed to Adrian Mensah as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Samuel Kim and contains no entry for Adrian Mensah.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/031_custodian_files_officer_certificate.html`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/10_expert_material/079_expert_material_officer_certificate.html`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-09, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Priya Raman.\n\n### F-12 — third-party subpoena deadline (low)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for third-party subpoena deadline: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-LD-2702-L418, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-LD-2702-U886.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/05_email_families/034_email_families_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/11_third_party/082_third_party_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-09, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Elliot Mercer.\n\n### F-13 — production gap (critical)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for production gap: one source states the applicable location is District of Delaware, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to Delaware operations outside District of Delaware.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/05_email_families/037_email_families_review_memorandum.json`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/11_third_party/085_third_party_review_memorandum.json`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-09, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Talia Brooks.\n\n### F-14 — metadata field loss (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for metadata field loss: one source states the threshold is 3% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 8% and produced a different exception result.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/05_email_families/040_email_families_status_report.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/11_third_party/088_third_party_status_report.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-09, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Jonas Feld.\n\n### F-15 — Bates-range overlap (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for Bates-range overlap: one source states formal notice must use notices-bayfield_sensorics_inc@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-kestrel_vision_systems_llc@example.test.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/043_chat_exports_correspondence.eml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/12_case_management/091_case_management_correspondence.eml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-09, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Mei Whitaker.\n\n### F-16 — meet-and-confer commitment (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for meet-and-confer commitment: one source states the governed population contains 113 records through 2025-03-09, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 72 records through 2025-04-22.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/046_chat_exports_formal_notice.xml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/12_case_management/094_case_management_formal_notice.xml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-09, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Caleb Hassan.\n\n## Recommended next actions\n\nSequence the critical and high findings first, assign the named owners, preserve the cited records, and document any resolution in the controlling matter register before the stated deadline.\n\n## Assumptions and limitations\n\nThis analysis is confined to task cb100-032-bayfield-patent and the supplied synthetic evidence. It does not rely on external facts, does not resolve disputed law, and is not legal advice for a real person or entity.\n", "findings": {"as_of": "2026-09-09", "findings": [{"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/07_privilege_material/049_privilege_material_control_register.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for custodian omission: one source states the operative date is 2025-07-26 under control reference CB-LD-2702-A784, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2025-08-31 under response reference CB-LD-2702-J568.", "id": "F-01", "issue": "custodian omission", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/01_pleadings/001_pleadings_control_register.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-09, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Nadine Flores.", "severity": "critical"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/07_privilege_material/052_privilege_material_ledger_export.csv", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for legal-hold delivery gap: one source states the controlling amount is $1,419,361.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $1,675,222.00.", "id": "F-02", "issue": "legal-hold delivery gap", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/01_pleadings/004_pleadings_ledger_export.csv", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-09, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Micah Sullivan.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/07_privilege_material/055_privilege_material_officer_certificate.html", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for collection-date inconsistency: one source states approval is attributed to Adrian Mensah as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Jonas Feld and contains no entry for Adrian Mensah.", "id": "F-03", "issue": "collection-date inconsistency", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/01_pleadings/007_pleadings_officer_certificate.html", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-09, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Farah Ibrahim.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/08_production_logs/058_production_logs_executed_instrument.txt", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for email-family separation: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-LD-2702-D803, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-LD-2702-M846.", "id": "F-04", "issue": "email-family separation", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/02_orders/010_orders_executed_instrument.txt", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-09, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Owen Delgado.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/08_production_logs/061_production_logs_review_memorandum.json", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for privilege-log description defect: one source states the applicable location is District of Delaware, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to Delaware operations outside District of Delaware.", "id": "F-05", "issue": "privilege-log description defect", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/02_orders/013_orders_review_memorandum.json", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-09, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Lena Varga.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/08_production_logs/064_production_logs_status_report.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for common-interest support gap: one source states the threshold is 6% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 10% and produced a different exception result.", "id": "F-06", "issue": "common-interest support gap", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/02_orders/016_orders_status_report.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-09, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Samuel Kim.", "severity": "low"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/09_depositions/067_depositions_correspondence.eml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for clawback deadline: one source states formal notice must use notices-bayfield_sensorics_inc@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-kestrel_vision_systems_llc@example.test.", "id": "F-07", "issue": "clawback deadline", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/019_requests_responses_correspondence.eml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-09, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Maya Ellison.", "severity": "critical"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/09_depositions/070_depositions_formal_notice.xml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for protective-order designation error: one source states the governed population contains 171 records through 2025-05-06, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 38 records through 2025-05-16.", "id": "F-08", "issue": "protective-order designation error", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/022_requests_responses_formal_notice.xml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-09, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Rafael Okafor.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/10_expert_material/073_expert_material_control_register.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for request-response mismatch: one source states the operative date is 2025-06-03 under control reference CB-LD-2702-I551, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2025-06-25 under response reference CB-LD-2702-R480.", "id": "F-09", "issue": "request-response mismatch", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/025_custodian_files_control_register.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-09, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Nora Chen.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/10_expert_material/076_expert_material_ledger_export.csv", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for deposition exhibit omission: one source states the controlling amount is $568,666.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $863,832.00.", "id": "F-10", "issue": "deposition exhibit omission", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/028_custodian_files_ledger_export.csv", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-09, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Dominic Alvarez.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/10_expert_material/079_expert_material_officer_certificate.html", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for expert draft segregation: one source states approval is attributed to Adrian Mensah as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Samuel Kim and contains no entry for Adrian Mensah.", "id": "F-11", "issue": "expert draft segregation", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/031_custodian_files_officer_certificate.html", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-09, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Priya Raman.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/11_third_party/082_third_party_executed_instrument.txt", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for third-party subpoena deadline: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-LD-2702-L418, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-LD-2702-U886.", "id": "F-12", "issue": "third-party subpoena deadline", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/05_email_families/034_email_families_executed_instrument.txt", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-09, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Elliot Mercer.", "severity": "low"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/11_third_party/085_third_party_review_memorandum.json", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for production gap: one source states the applicable location is District of Delaware, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to Delaware operations outside District of Delaware.", "id": "F-13", "issue": "production gap", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/05_email_families/037_email_families_review_memorandum.json", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-09, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Talia Brooks.", "severity": "critical"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/11_third_party/088_third_party_status_report.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for metadata field loss: one source states the threshold is 3% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 8% and produced a different exception result.", "id": "F-14", "issue": "metadata field loss", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/05_email_families/040_email_families_status_report.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-09, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Jonas Feld.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/12_case_management/091_case_management_correspondence.eml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for Bates-range overlap: one source states formal notice must use notices-bayfield_sensorics_inc@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-kestrel_vision_systems_llc@example.test.", "id": "F-15", "issue": "Bates-range overlap", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/043_chat_exports_correspondence.eml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-09, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Mei Whitaker.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/12_case_management/094_case_management_formal_notice.xml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for meet-and-confer commitment: one source states the governed population contains 113 records through 2025-03-09, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 72 records through 2025-04-22.", "id": "F-16", "issue": "meet-and-confer commitment", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/046_chat_exports_formal_notice.xml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-09, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Caleb Hassan.", "severity": "medium"}], "matter_number": "CB-LD-2702", "prepared_for": "Bayfield Sensorics, Inc.", "schema_version": "1.0", "task_id": "cb100-032-bayfield-patent"}}, "metadata": {"benchmark": "CounselBench-100", "code_license": "Apache-2.0", "data_license": "CC-BY-4.0", "deadline": "2026-09-09", "document_count": 96, "jurisdiction": "Delaware", "matter_number": "CB-LD-2702", "mcp_commit": "9a96ea6e5913736f92b88345bf51caeaaa8e719f", "mcp_package": "@modelcontextprotocol/server-filesystem@2026.7.10", "practice_area": "litigation-discovery", "reference_tool_calls": 46, "required_evidence_reads": 33, "synthetic": true, "venue": "District of Delaware", "version": "2.0.0"}, "prompt": "You are discovery counsel for Bayfield Sensorics, Inc. A late document production changed the factual picture, and the matter team needs the entire record reconciled from first principles. Source-code collections and inventor communications were produced under a protective order, but family links and designation fields are inconsistent. Decision due 2026-09-09. Delaware law governs; District of Delaware is the forum. Separate confirmed exceptions from items that merely require follow-up. Work out the defensible position from the matter production and leave an audit-ready exception tracker and concise advice for the supervising lawyer. Keep confirmed conflicts separate from open questions, cite the records that actually control each conclusion, and do not fill gaps with outside facts.", "rubric": {"criteria": [{"category": "procedure", "description": "Complete at least 46 successful, argument-specific evidence and output calls.", "id": "procedure.minimum_successful_tool_calls"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Find and read the 33 controlling, corroborating, and work-product-control records in full.", "id": "procedure.all_evidence_read_in_full"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Inspect file metadata for the eight designated critical primary records before relying on them.", "id": "procedure.chain_of_custody_metadata_checked"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Confirm the sandbox's allowed document and output roots.", "id": "procedure.allowed_directories_checked"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Inventory all 96 records so the relevant sources are discovered among the context records.", "id": "procedure.recursive_inventory_completed"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Search the production for email evidence that may corroborate or contradict formal records.", "id": "procedure.targeted_search_completed"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Leave only findings.json and advice.md in the output workspace.", "id": "procedure.exact_deliverable_set"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Create both final work products through the sandbox MCP surface.", "id": "procedure.deliverables_written_through_mcp"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Produce findings.json as a valid JSON object.", "id": "findings.findings_is_object"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Report exactly 16 confirmed exceptions.", "id": "findings.findings_exact_count"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Use each stable finding ID exactly once.", "id": "findings.finding_ids_unique"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set schema_version to the released matter value '1.0'.", "id": "findings.top_level_schema_version"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set task_id to the released matter value 'cb100-032-bayfield-patent'.", "id": "findings.top_level_task_id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set matter_number to the released matter value 'CB-LD-2702'.", "id": "findings.top_level_matter_number"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set prepared_for to the released matter value 'Bayfield Sensorics, Inc.'.", "id": "findings.top_level_prepared_for"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set as_of to the released matter value '2026-09-09'.", "id": "findings.top_level_as_of"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-01 exception for custodian omission.", "id": "findings.F-01.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's id from /workspace/documents/01_pleadings/001_pleadings_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_privilege_material/049_privilege_material_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's issue from /workspace/documents/01_pleadings/001_pleadings_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_privilege_material/049_privilege_material_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's severity from /workspace/documents/01_pleadings/001_pleadings_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_privilege_material/049_privilege_material_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's primary_source from /workspace/documents/01_pleadings/001_pleadings_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_privilege_material/049_privilege_material_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/01_pleadings/001_pleadings_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_privilege_material/049_privilege_material_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-01 using the exact controlled facts ['2025-07-26', 'CB-LD-2702-A784', '2025-08-31', 'CB-LD-2702-J568'].", "id": "findings.F-01.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-01's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-01.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-09', 'Nadine Flores'] for F-01.", "id": "findings.F-01.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-02 exception for legal-hold delivery gap.", "id": "findings.F-02.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's id from /workspace/documents/01_pleadings/004_pleadings_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_privilege_material/052_privilege_material_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's issue from /workspace/documents/01_pleadings/004_pleadings_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_privilege_material/052_privilege_material_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's severity from /workspace/documents/01_pleadings/004_pleadings_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_privilege_material/052_privilege_material_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's primary_source from /workspace/documents/01_pleadings/004_pleadings_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_privilege_material/052_privilege_material_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/01_pleadings/004_pleadings_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_privilege_material/052_privilege_material_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-02 using the exact controlled facts ['$1,419,361.00', '$1,675,222.00'].", "id": "findings.F-02.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-02's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-02.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-09', 'Micah Sullivan'] for F-02.", "id": "findings.F-02.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-03 exception for collection-date inconsistency.", "id": "findings.F-03.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's id from /workspace/documents/01_pleadings/007_pleadings_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_privilege_material/055_privilege_material_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's issue from /workspace/documents/01_pleadings/007_pleadings_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_privilege_material/055_privilege_material_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's severity from /workspace/documents/01_pleadings/007_pleadings_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_privilege_material/055_privilege_material_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's primary_source from /workspace/documents/01_pleadings/007_pleadings_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_privilege_material/055_privilege_material_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/01_pleadings/007_pleadings_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_privilege_material/055_privilege_material_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-03 using the exact controlled facts ['Adrian Mensah', 'Jonas Feld'].", "id": "findings.F-03.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-03's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-03.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-09', 'Farah Ibrahim'] for F-03.", "id": "findings.F-03.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-04 exception for email-family separation.", "id": "findings.F-04.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's id from /workspace/documents/02_orders/010_orders_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_production_logs/058_production_logs_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's issue from /workspace/documents/02_orders/010_orders_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_production_logs/058_production_logs_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's severity from /workspace/documents/02_orders/010_orders_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_production_logs/058_production_logs_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's primary_source from /workspace/documents/02_orders/010_orders_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_production_logs/058_production_logs_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/02_orders/010_orders_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_production_logs/058_production_logs_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-04 using the exact controlled facts ['closed without exception', 'CB-LD-2702-D803', 'open and escalated', 'CB-LD-2702-M846'].", "id": "findings.F-04.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-04's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-04.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-09', 'Owen Delgado'] for F-04.", "id": "findings.F-04.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-05 exception for privilege-log description defect.", "id": "findings.F-05.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's id from /workspace/documents/02_orders/013_orders_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_production_logs/061_production_logs_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's issue from /workspace/documents/02_orders/013_orders_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_production_logs/061_production_logs_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's severity from /workspace/documents/02_orders/013_orders_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_production_logs/061_production_logs_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's primary_source from /workspace/documents/02_orders/013_orders_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_production_logs/061_production_logs_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/02_orders/013_orders_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_production_logs/061_production_logs_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-05 using the exact controlled facts ['District of Delaware', 'Delaware'].", "id": "findings.F-05.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-05's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-05.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-09', 'Lena Varga'] for F-05.", "id": "findings.F-05.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-06 exception for common-interest support gap.", "id": "findings.F-06.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's id from /workspace/documents/02_orders/016_orders_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_production_logs/064_production_logs_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's issue from /workspace/documents/02_orders/016_orders_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_production_logs/064_production_logs_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's severity from /workspace/documents/02_orders/016_orders_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_production_logs/064_production_logs_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's primary_source from /workspace/documents/02_orders/016_orders_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_production_logs/064_production_logs_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/02_orders/016_orders_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_production_logs/064_production_logs_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-06 using the exact controlled facts ['6%', '10%'].", "id": "findings.F-06.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-06's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-06.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-09', 'Samuel Kim'] for F-06.", "id": "findings.F-06.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-07 exception for clawback deadline.", "id": "findings.F-07.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's id from /workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/019_requests_responses_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_depositions/067_depositions_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's issue from /workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/019_requests_responses_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_depositions/067_depositions_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's severity from /workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/019_requests_responses_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_depositions/067_depositions_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's primary_source from /workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/019_requests_responses_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_depositions/067_depositions_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/019_requests_responses_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_depositions/067_depositions_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-07 using the exact controlled facts ['notices-bayfield_sensorics_inc@example.test', 'archive-kestrel_vision_systems_llc@example.test'].", "id": "findings.F-07.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-07's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-07.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-09', 'Maya Ellison'] for F-07.", "id": "findings.F-07.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-08 exception for protective-order designation error.", "id": "findings.F-08.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's id from /workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/022_requests_responses_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_depositions/070_depositions_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's issue from /workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/022_requests_responses_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_depositions/070_depositions_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's severity from /workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/022_requests_responses_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_depositions/070_depositions_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's primary_source from /workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/022_requests_responses_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_depositions/070_depositions_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/022_requests_responses_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_depositions/070_depositions_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-08 using the exact controlled facts ['171 records', '2025-05-06', '38 records', '2025-05-16'].", "id": "findings.F-08.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-08's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-08.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-09', 'Rafael Okafor'] for F-08.", "id": "findings.F-08.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-09 exception for request-response mismatch.", "id": "findings.F-09.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's id from /workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/025_custodian_files_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_expert_material/073_expert_material_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's issue from /workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/025_custodian_files_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_expert_material/073_expert_material_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's severity from /workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/025_custodian_files_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_expert_material/073_expert_material_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's primary_source from /workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/025_custodian_files_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_expert_material/073_expert_material_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/025_custodian_files_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_expert_material/073_expert_material_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-09 using the exact controlled facts ['2025-06-03', 'CB-LD-2702-I551', '2025-06-25', 'CB-LD-2702-R480'].", "id": "findings.F-09.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-09's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-09.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-09', 'Nora Chen'] for F-09.", "id": "findings.F-09.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-10 exception for deposition exhibit omission.", "id": "findings.F-10.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's id from /workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/028_custodian_files_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_expert_material/076_expert_material_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's issue from /workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/028_custodian_files_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_expert_material/076_expert_material_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's severity from /workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/028_custodian_files_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_expert_material/076_expert_material_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's primary_source from /workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/028_custodian_files_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_expert_material/076_expert_material_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/028_custodian_files_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_expert_material/076_expert_material_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-10 using the exact controlled facts ['$568,666.00', '$863,832.00'].", "id": "findings.F-10.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-10's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-10.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-09', 'Dominic Alvarez'] for F-10.", "id": "findings.F-10.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-11 exception for expert draft segregation.", "id": "findings.F-11.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's id from /workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/031_custodian_files_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_expert_material/079_expert_material_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's issue from /workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/031_custodian_files_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_expert_material/079_expert_material_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's severity from /workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/031_custodian_files_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_expert_material/079_expert_material_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's primary_source from /workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/031_custodian_files_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_expert_material/079_expert_material_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/031_custodian_files_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_expert_material/079_expert_material_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-11 using the exact controlled facts ['Adrian Mensah', 'Samuel Kim'].", "id": "findings.F-11.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-11's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-11.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-09', 'Priya Raman'] for F-11.", "id": "findings.F-11.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-12 exception for third-party subpoena deadline.", "id": "findings.F-12.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's id from /workspace/documents/05_email_families/034_email_families_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_third_party/082_third_party_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's issue from /workspace/documents/05_email_families/034_email_families_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_third_party/082_third_party_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's severity from /workspace/documents/05_email_families/034_email_families_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_third_party/082_third_party_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's primary_source from /workspace/documents/05_email_families/034_email_families_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_third_party/082_third_party_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/05_email_families/034_email_families_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_third_party/082_third_party_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-12 using the exact controlled facts ['closed without exception', 'CB-LD-2702-L418', 'open and escalated', 'CB-LD-2702-U886'].", "id": "findings.F-12.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-12's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-12.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-09', 'Elliot Mercer'] for F-12.", "id": "findings.F-12.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-13 exception for production gap.", "id": "findings.F-13.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's id from /workspace/documents/05_email_families/037_email_families_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_third_party/085_third_party_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's issue from /workspace/documents/05_email_families/037_email_families_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_third_party/085_third_party_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's severity from /workspace/documents/05_email_families/037_email_families_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_third_party/085_third_party_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's primary_source from /workspace/documents/05_email_families/037_email_families_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_third_party/085_third_party_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/05_email_families/037_email_families_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_third_party/085_third_party_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-13 using the exact controlled facts ['District of Delaware', 'Delaware'].", "id": "findings.F-13.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-13's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-13.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-09', 'Talia Brooks'] for F-13.", "id": "findings.F-13.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-14 exception for metadata field loss.", "id": "findings.F-14.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's id from /workspace/documents/05_email_families/040_email_families_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_third_party/088_third_party_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's issue from /workspace/documents/05_email_families/040_email_families_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_third_party/088_third_party_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's severity from /workspace/documents/05_email_families/040_email_families_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_third_party/088_third_party_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's primary_source from /workspace/documents/05_email_families/040_email_families_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_third_party/088_third_party_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/05_email_families/040_email_families_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_third_party/088_third_party_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-14 using the exact controlled facts ['3%', '8%'].", "id": "findings.F-14.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-14's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-14.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-09', 'Jonas Feld'] for F-14.", "id": "findings.F-14.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-15 exception for Bates-range overlap.", "id": "findings.F-15.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's id from /workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/043_chat_exports_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_case_management/091_case_management_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's issue from /workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/043_chat_exports_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_case_management/091_case_management_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's severity from /workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/043_chat_exports_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_case_management/091_case_management_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's primary_source from /workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/043_chat_exports_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_case_management/091_case_management_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/043_chat_exports_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_case_management/091_case_management_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-15 using the exact controlled facts ['notices-bayfield_sensorics_inc@example.test', 'archive-kestrel_vision_systems_llc@example.test'].", "id": "findings.F-15.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-15's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-15.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-09', 'Mei Whitaker'] for F-15.", "id": "findings.F-15.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-16 exception for meet-and-confer commitment.", "id": "findings.F-16.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's id from /workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/046_chat_exports_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_case_management/094_case_management_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's issue from /workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/046_chat_exports_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_case_management/094_case_management_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's severity from /workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/046_chat_exports_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_case_management/094_case_management_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's primary_source from /workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/046_chat_exports_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_case_management/094_case_management_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/046_chat_exports_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_case_management/094_case_management_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-16 using the exact controlled facts ['113 records', '2025-03-09', '72 records', '2025-04-22'].", "id": "findings.F-16.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-16's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-16.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-09', 'Caleb Hassan'] for F-16.", "id": "findings.F-16.action_anchors"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Executive assessment' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Executive assessment"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Method and record coverage' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Method and record coverage"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Findings' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Findings"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Recommended next actions' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Recommended next actions"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Assumptions and limitations' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Assumptions and limitations"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-01 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-01"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-02 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-02"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-03 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-03"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-04 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-04"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-05 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-05"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-06 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-06"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-07 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-07"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-08 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-08"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-09 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-09"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-10 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-10"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-11 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-11"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-12 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-12"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-13 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-13"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-14 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-14"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-15 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-15"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-16 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-16"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Do not claim the production has no issues or that every record is consistent.", "id": "memo.forbidden_claims_absent"}], "decision_options": [{"id": "cross-source-reconciliation", "label": "Reconcile controlling and corroborating records", "reason": "The CB-LD-2702 production contains independently maintained records; a defensible answer must preserve each supported conflict and its cure owner.", "selected": true}, {"id": "latest-record-controls", "label": "Treat the latest record as controlling", "reason": "Timestamp recency does not establish legal priority, execution, or approval authority.", "selected": false}, {"id": "primary-records-only", "label": "Report primary records without reconciliation", "reason": "Primary records alone conceal the operational conflicts that create the actionable exceptions.", "selected": false}], "gates": ["all_evidence_read_in_full", "chain_of_custody_metadata_checked", "findings_criteria_complete", "memo_criteria_complete", "deliverables_written_through_mcp"], "metadata_checks": 8, "metric": "weighted_criteria_score", "minimum_tool_calls": 46, "required_deliverables": ["findings.json", "advice.md"], "required_document_reads": 33, "type": "deterministic", "weights": {"findings": 0.55, "memo": 0.2, "procedure": 0.25}}, "task_id": "cb100-032-bayfield-patent", "task_name": "Bayfield patent case production review", "world_id": "counselbench-filesystem-mcp-v2"}
-{"context_files": ["task_files/cb100-033-crown-employment/01_pleadings/001_pleadings_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-033-crown-employment/01_pleadings/002_pleadings_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-033-crown-employment/01_pleadings/003_pleadings_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-033-crown-employment/01_pleadings/004_pleadings_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-033-crown-employment/01_pleadings/005_pleadings_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-033-crown-employment/01_pleadings/006_pleadings_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-033-crown-employment/01_pleadings/007_pleadings_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-033-crown-employment/01_pleadings/008_pleadings_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-033-crown-employment/02_orders/009_orders_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-033-crown-employment/02_orders/010_orders_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-033-crown-employment/02_orders/011_orders_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-033-crown-employment/02_orders/012_orders_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-033-crown-employment/02_orders/013_orders_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-033-crown-employment/02_orders/014_orders_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-033-crown-employment/02_orders/015_orders_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-033-crown-employment/02_orders/016_orders_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-033-crown-employment/03_requests_responses/017_requests_responses_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-033-crown-employment/03_requests_responses/018_requests_responses_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-033-crown-employment/03_requests_responses/019_requests_responses_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-033-crown-employment/03_requests_responses/020_requests_responses_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-033-crown-employment/03_requests_responses/021_requests_responses_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-033-crown-employment/03_requests_responses/022_requests_responses_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-033-crown-employment/03_requests_responses/023_requests_responses_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-033-crown-employment/03_requests_responses/024_requests_responses_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-033-crown-employment/04_custodian_files/025_custodian_files_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-033-crown-employment/04_custodian_files/026_custodian_files_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-033-crown-employment/04_custodian_files/027_custodian_files_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-033-crown-employment/04_custodian_files/028_custodian_files_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-033-crown-employment/04_custodian_files/029_custodian_files_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-033-crown-employment/04_custodian_files/030_custodian_files_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-033-crown-employment/04_custodian_files/031_custodian_files_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-033-crown-employment/04_custodian_files/032_custodian_files_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-033-crown-employment/05_email_families/033_email_families_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-033-crown-employment/05_email_families/034_email_families_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-033-crown-employment/05_email_families/035_email_families_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-033-crown-employment/05_email_families/036_email_families_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-033-crown-employment/05_email_families/037_email_families_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-033-crown-employment/05_email_families/038_email_families_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-033-crown-employment/05_email_families/039_email_families_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-033-crown-employment/05_email_families/040_email_families_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-033-crown-employment/06_chat_exports/041_chat_exports_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-033-crown-employment/06_chat_exports/042_chat_exports_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-033-crown-employment/06_chat_exports/043_chat_exports_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-033-crown-employment/06_chat_exports/044_chat_exports_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-033-crown-employment/06_chat_exports/045_chat_exports_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-033-crown-employment/06_chat_exports/046_chat_exports_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-033-crown-employment/06_chat_exports/047_chat_exports_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-033-crown-employment/06_chat_exports/048_chat_exports_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-033-crown-employment/07_privilege_material/049_privilege_material_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-033-crown-employment/07_privilege_material/050_privilege_material_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-033-crown-employment/07_privilege_material/051_privilege_material_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-033-crown-employment/07_privilege_material/052_privilege_material_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-033-crown-employment/07_privilege_material/053_privilege_material_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-033-crown-employment/07_privilege_material/054_privilege_material_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-033-crown-employment/07_privilege_material/055_privilege_material_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-033-crown-employment/07_privilege_material/056_privilege_material_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-033-crown-employment/08_production_logs/057_production_logs_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-033-crown-employment/08_production_logs/058_production_logs_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-033-crown-employment/08_production_logs/059_production_logs_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-033-crown-employment/08_production_logs/060_production_logs_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-033-crown-employment/08_production_logs/061_production_logs_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-033-crown-employment/08_production_logs/062_production_logs_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-033-crown-employment/08_production_logs/063_production_logs_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-033-crown-employment/08_production_logs/064_production_logs_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-033-crown-employment/09_depositions/065_depositions_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-033-crown-employment/09_depositions/066_depositions_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-033-crown-employment/09_depositions/067_depositions_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-033-crown-employment/09_depositions/068_depositions_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-033-crown-employment/09_depositions/069_depositions_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-033-crown-employment/09_depositions/070_depositions_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-033-crown-employment/09_depositions/071_depositions_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-033-crown-employment/09_depositions/072_depositions_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-033-crown-employment/10_expert_material/073_expert_material_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-033-crown-employment/10_expert_material/074_expert_material_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-033-crown-employment/10_expert_material/075_expert_material_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-033-crown-employment/10_expert_material/076_expert_material_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-033-crown-employment/10_expert_material/077_expert_material_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-033-crown-employment/10_expert_material/078_expert_material_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-033-crown-employment/10_expert_material/079_expert_material_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-033-crown-employment/10_expert_material/080_expert_material_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-033-crown-employment/11_third_party/081_third_party_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-033-crown-employment/11_third_party/082_third_party_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-033-crown-employment/11_third_party/083_third_party_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-033-crown-employment/11_third_party/084_third_party_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-033-crown-employment/11_third_party/085_third_party_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-033-crown-employment/11_third_party/086_third_party_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-033-crown-employment/11_third_party/087_third_party_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-033-crown-employment/11_third_party/088_third_party_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-033-crown-employment/12_case_management/089_case_management_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-033-crown-employment/12_case_management/090_case_management_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-033-crown-employment/12_case_management/091_case_management_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-033-crown-employment/12_case_management/092_case_management_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-033-crown-employment/12_case_management/093_case_management_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-033-crown-employment/12_case_management/094_case_management_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-033-crown-employment/12_case_management/095_case_management_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-033-crown-employment/12_case_management/096_case_management_status_report.md"], "gold_output": {"advice_markdown": "# Counsel advice — Crown wage action discovery check\n\n## Executive assessment\n\nFor Crown Kitchen Group matter CB-LD-2703, the review identified 16 source-supported exceptions requiring action before 2026-09-12. The assessment concerns Martinez et al. and the supplied record for California.\n\n## Method and record coverage\n\nThe review inventoried all 96 production files, read the 33 controlling, corroborating, and control records, searched the email exports, and checked metadata for the designated chain-of-custody sample. Conclusions are limited to the synthetic production supplied for this benchmark matter.\n\n## Findings\n\n### F-01 — custodian omission (critical)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for custodian omission: one source states the operative date is 2025-04-03 under control reference CB-LD-2703-A610, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2025-04-16 under response reference CB-LD-2703-J208.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/01_pleadings/001_pleadings_control_register.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/07_privilege_material/049_privilege_material_control_register.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-12, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Micah Sullivan.\n\n### F-02 — legal-hold delivery gap (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for legal-hold delivery gap: one source states the controlling amount is $7,217,663.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $7,381,826.00.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/01_pleadings/004_pleadings_ledger_export.csv`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/07_privilege_material/052_privilege_material_ledger_export.csv`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-12, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Farah Ibrahim.\n\n### F-03 — collection-date inconsistency (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for collection-date inconsistency: one source states approval is attributed to Willa Novak as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Caleb Hassan and contains no entry for Willa Novak.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/01_pleadings/007_pleadings_officer_certificate.html`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/07_privilege_material/055_privilege_material_officer_certificate.html`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-12, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Owen Delgado.\n\n### F-04 — email-family separation (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for email-family separation: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-LD-2703-D908, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-LD-2703-M923.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/02_orders/010_orders_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/08_production_logs/058_production_logs_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-12, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Lena Varga.\n\n### F-05 — privilege-log description defect (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for privilege-log description defect: one source states the applicable location is Central District of California, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to California operations outside Central District of California.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/02_orders/013_orders_review_memorandum.json`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/08_production_logs/061_production_logs_review_memorandum.json`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-12, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Samuel Kim.\n\n### F-06 — common-interest support gap (low)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for common-interest support gap: one source states the threshold is 11% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 18% and produced a different exception result.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/02_orders/016_orders_status_report.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/08_production_logs/064_production_logs_status_report.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-12, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Maya Ellison.\n\n### F-07 — clawback deadline (critical)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for clawback deadline: one source states formal notice must use notices-crown_kitchen_group@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-martinez_et_al@example.test.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/019_requests_responses_correspondence.eml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/09_depositions/067_depositions_correspondence.eml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-12, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Rafael Okafor.\n\n### F-08 — protective-order designation error (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for protective-order designation error: one source states the governed population contains 154 records through 2025-04-19, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 52 records through 2025-05-13.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/022_requests_responses_formal_notice.xml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/09_depositions/070_depositions_formal_notice.xml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-12, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Nora Chen.\n\n### F-09 — request-response mismatch (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for request-response mismatch: one source states the operative date is 2025-10-18 under control reference CB-LD-2703-I448, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2025-11-12 under response reference CB-LD-2703-R749.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/025_custodian_files_control_register.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/10_expert_material/073_expert_material_control_register.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-12, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Dominic Alvarez.\n\n### F-10 — deposition exhibit omission (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for deposition exhibit omission: one source states the controlling amount is $3,781,478.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $3,939,456.00.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/028_custodian_files_ledger_export.csv`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/10_expert_material/076_expert_material_ledger_export.csv`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-12, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Priya Raman.\n\n### F-11 — expert draft segregation (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for expert draft segregation: one source states approval is attributed to Willa Novak as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Rafael Okafor and contains no entry for Willa Novak.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/031_custodian_files_officer_certificate.html`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/10_expert_material/079_expert_material_officer_certificate.html`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-12, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Elliot Mercer.\n\n### F-12 — third-party subpoena deadline (low)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for third-party subpoena deadline: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-LD-2703-L342, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-LD-2703-U949.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/05_email_families/034_email_families_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/11_third_party/082_third_party_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-12, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Talia Brooks.\n\n### F-13 — production gap (critical)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for production gap: one source states the applicable location is Central District of California, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to California operations outside Central District of California.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/05_email_families/037_email_families_review_memorandum.json`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/11_third_party/085_third_party_review_memorandum.json`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-12, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Jonas Feld.\n\n### F-14 — metadata field loss (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for metadata field loss: one source states the threshold is 8% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 12% and produced a different exception result.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/05_email_families/040_email_families_status_report.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/11_third_party/088_third_party_status_report.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-12, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Mei Whitaker.\n\n### F-15 — Bates-range overlap (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for Bates-range overlap: one source states formal notice must use notices-crown_kitchen_group@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-martinez_et_al@example.test.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/043_chat_exports_correspondence.eml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/12_case_management/091_case_management_correspondence.eml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-12, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Caleb Hassan.\n\n### F-16 — meet-and-confer commitment (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for meet-and-confer commitment: one source states the governed population contains 180 records through 2025-05-15, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 74 records through 2025-06-30.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/046_chat_exports_formal_notice.xml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/12_case_management/094_case_management_formal_notice.xml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-12, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Leona Park.\n\n## Recommended next actions\n\nSequence the critical and high findings first, assign the named owners, preserve the cited records, and document any resolution in the controlling matter register before the stated deadline.\n\n## Assumptions and limitations\n\nThis analysis is confined to task cb100-033-crown-employment and the supplied synthetic evidence. It does not rely on external facts, does not resolve disputed law, and is not legal advice for a real person or entity.\n", "findings": {"as_of": "2026-09-12", "findings": [{"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/07_privilege_material/049_privilege_material_control_register.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for custodian omission: one source states the operative date is 2025-04-03 under control reference CB-LD-2703-A610, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2025-04-16 under response reference CB-LD-2703-J208.", "id": "F-01", "issue": "custodian omission", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/01_pleadings/001_pleadings_control_register.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-12, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Micah Sullivan.", "severity": "critical"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/07_privilege_material/052_privilege_material_ledger_export.csv", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for legal-hold delivery gap: one source states the controlling amount is $7,217,663.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $7,381,826.00.", "id": "F-02", "issue": "legal-hold delivery gap", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/01_pleadings/004_pleadings_ledger_export.csv", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-12, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Farah Ibrahim.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/07_privilege_material/055_privilege_material_officer_certificate.html", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for collection-date inconsistency: one source states approval is attributed to Willa Novak as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Caleb Hassan and contains no entry for Willa Novak.", "id": "F-03", "issue": "collection-date inconsistency", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/01_pleadings/007_pleadings_officer_certificate.html", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-12, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Owen Delgado.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/08_production_logs/058_production_logs_executed_instrument.txt", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for email-family separation: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-LD-2703-D908, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-LD-2703-M923.", "id": "F-04", "issue": "email-family separation", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/02_orders/010_orders_executed_instrument.txt", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-12, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Lena Varga.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/08_production_logs/061_production_logs_review_memorandum.json", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for privilege-log description defect: one source states the applicable location is Central District of California, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to California operations outside Central District of California.", "id": "F-05", "issue": "privilege-log description defect", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/02_orders/013_orders_review_memorandum.json", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-12, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Samuel Kim.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/08_production_logs/064_production_logs_status_report.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for common-interest support gap: one source states the threshold is 11% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 18% and produced a different exception result.", "id": "F-06", "issue": "common-interest support gap", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/02_orders/016_orders_status_report.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-12, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Maya Ellison.", "severity": "low"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/09_depositions/067_depositions_correspondence.eml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for clawback deadline: one source states formal notice must use notices-crown_kitchen_group@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-martinez_et_al@example.test.", "id": "F-07", "issue": "clawback deadline", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/019_requests_responses_correspondence.eml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-12, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Rafael Okafor.", "severity": "critical"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/09_depositions/070_depositions_formal_notice.xml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for protective-order designation error: one source states the governed population contains 154 records through 2025-04-19, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 52 records through 2025-05-13.", "id": "F-08", "issue": "protective-order designation error", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/022_requests_responses_formal_notice.xml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-12, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Nora Chen.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/10_expert_material/073_expert_material_control_register.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for request-response mismatch: one source states the operative date is 2025-10-18 under control reference CB-LD-2703-I448, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2025-11-12 under response reference CB-LD-2703-R749.", "id": "F-09", "issue": "request-response mismatch", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/025_custodian_files_control_register.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-12, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Dominic Alvarez.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/10_expert_material/076_expert_material_ledger_export.csv", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for deposition exhibit omission: one source states the controlling amount is $3,781,478.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $3,939,456.00.", "id": "F-10", "issue": "deposition exhibit omission", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/028_custodian_files_ledger_export.csv", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-12, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Priya Raman.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/10_expert_material/079_expert_material_officer_certificate.html", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for expert draft segregation: one source states approval is attributed to Willa Novak as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Rafael Okafor and contains no entry for Willa Novak.", "id": "F-11", "issue": "expert draft segregation", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/031_custodian_files_officer_certificate.html", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-12, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Elliot Mercer.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/11_third_party/082_third_party_executed_instrument.txt", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for third-party subpoena deadline: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-LD-2703-L342, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-LD-2703-U949.", "id": "F-12", "issue": "third-party subpoena deadline", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/05_email_families/034_email_families_executed_instrument.txt", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-12, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Talia Brooks.", "severity": "low"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/11_third_party/085_third_party_review_memorandum.json", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for production gap: one source states the applicable location is Central District of California, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to California operations outside Central District of California.", "id": "F-13", "issue": "production gap", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/05_email_families/037_email_families_review_memorandum.json", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-12, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Jonas Feld.", "severity": "critical"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/11_third_party/088_third_party_status_report.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for metadata field loss: one source states the threshold is 8% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 12% and produced a different exception result.", "id": "F-14", "issue": "metadata field loss", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/05_email_families/040_email_families_status_report.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-12, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Mei Whitaker.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/12_case_management/091_case_management_correspondence.eml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for Bates-range overlap: one source states formal notice must use notices-crown_kitchen_group@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-martinez_et_al@example.test.", "id": "F-15", "issue": "Bates-range overlap", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/043_chat_exports_correspondence.eml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-12, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Caleb Hassan.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/12_case_management/094_case_management_formal_notice.xml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for meet-and-confer commitment: one source states the governed population contains 180 records through 2025-05-15, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 74 records through 2025-06-30.", "id": "F-16", "issue": "meet-and-confer commitment", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/046_chat_exports_formal_notice.xml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-12, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Leona Park.", "severity": "medium"}], "matter_number": "CB-LD-2703", "prepared_for": "Crown Kitchen Group", "schema_version": "1.0", "task_id": "cb100-033-crown-employment"}}, "metadata": {"benchmark": "CounselBench-100", "code_license": "Apache-2.0", "data_license": "CC-BY-4.0", "deadline": "2026-09-12", "document_count": 96, "jurisdiction": "California", "matter_number": "CB-LD-2703", "mcp_commit": "9a96ea6e5913736f92b88345bf51caeaaa8e719f", "mcp_package": "@modelcontextprotocol/server-filesystem@2026.7.10", "practice_area": "litigation-discovery", "reference_tool_calls": 46, "required_evidence_reads": 33, "synthetic": true, "venue": "Central District of California", "version": "2.0.0"}, "prompt": "You are discovery counsel for Crown Kitchen Group. The client has asked for a board-ready risk assessment supported by a source-level tracker rather than a narrative-only summary. A wage class action involves manager texts, scheduling exports, late legal holds, and commitments made during two meet-and-confer sessions. Decision due 2026-09-12. California law governs; Central District of California is the forum. Treat dates, notice mechanics, approval evidence, and numerical reconciliations as independent controls. Work out the defensible position from the matter production and leave an audit-ready exception tracker and concise advice for the supervising lawyer. Keep confirmed conflicts separate from open questions, cite the records that actually control each conclusion, and do not fill gaps with outside facts.", "rubric": {"criteria": [{"category": "procedure", "description": "Complete at least 46 successful, argument-specific evidence and output calls.", "id": "procedure.minimum_successful_tool_calls"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Find and read the 33 controlling, corroborating, and work-product-control records in full.", "id": "procedure.all_evidence_read_in_full"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Inspect file metadata for the eight designated critical primary records before relying on them.", "id": "procedure.chain_of_custody_metadata_checked"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Confirm the sandbox's allowed document and output roots.", "id": "procedure.allowed_directories_checked"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Inventory all 96 records so the relevant sources are discovered among the context records.", "id": "procedure.recursive_inventory_completed"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Search the production for email evidence that may corroborate or contradict formal records.", "id": "procedure.targeted_search_completed"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Leave only findings.json and advice.md in the output workspace.", "id": "procedure.exact_deliverable_set"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Create both final work products through the sandbox MCP surface.", "id": "procedure.deliverables_written_through_mcp"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Produce findings.json as a valid JSON object.", "id": "findings.findings_is_object"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Report exactly 16 confirmed exceptions.", "id": "findings.findings_exact_count"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Use each stable finding ID exactly once.", "id": "findings.finding_ids_unique"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set schema_version to the released matter value '1.0'.", "id": "findings.top_level_schema_version"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set task_id to the released matter value 'cb100-033-crown-employment'.", "id": "findings.top_level_task_id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set matter_number to the released matter value 'CB-LD-2703'.", "id": "findings.top_level_matter_number"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set prepared_for to the released matter value 'Crown Kitchen Group'.", "id": "findings.top_level_prepared_for"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set as_of to the released matter value '2026-09-12'.", "id": "findings.top_level_as_of"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-01 exception for custodian omission.", "id": "findings.F-01.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's id from /workspace/documents/01_pleadings/001_pleadings_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_privilege_material/049_privilege_material_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's issue from /workspace/documents/01_pleadings/001_pleadings_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_privilege_material/049_privilege_material_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's severity from /workspace/documents/01_pleadings/001_pleadings_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_privilege_material/049_privilege_material_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's primary_source from /workspace/documents/01_pleadings/001_pleadings_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_privilege_material/049_privilege_material_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/01_pleadings/001_pleadings_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_privilege_material/049_privilege_material_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-01 using the exact controlled facts ['2025-04-03', 'CB-LD-2703-A610', '2025-04-16', 'CB-LD-2703-J208'].", "id": "findings.F-01.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-01's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-01.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-12', 'Micah Sullivan'] for F-01.", "id": "findings.F-01.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-02 exception for legal-hold delivery gap.", "id": "findings.F-02.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's id from /workspace/documents/01_pleadings/004_pleadings_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_privilege_material/052_privilege_material_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's issue from /workspace/documents/01_pleadings/004_pleadings_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_privilege_material/052_privilege_material_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's severity from /workspace/documents/01_pleadings/004_pleadings_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_privilege_material/052_privilege_material_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's primary_source from /workspace/documents/01_pleadings/004_pleadings_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_privilege_material/052_privilege_material_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/01_pleadings/004_pleadings_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_privilege_material/052_privilege_material_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-02 using the exact controlled facts ['$7,217,663.00', '$7,381,826.00'].", "id": "findings.F-02.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-02's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-02.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-12', 'Farah Ibrahim'] for F-02.", "id": "findings.F-02.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-03 exception for collection-date inconsistency.", "id": "findings.F-03.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's id from /workspace/documents/01_pleadings/007_pleadings_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_privilege_material/055_privilege_material_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's issue from /workspace/documents/01_pleadings/007_pleadings_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_privilege_material/055_privilege_material_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's severity from /workspace/documents/01_pleadings/007_pleadings_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_privilege_material/055_privilege_material_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's primary_source from /workspace/documents/01_pleadings/007_pleadings_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_privilege_material/055_privilege_material_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/01_pleadings/007_pleadings_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_privilege_material/055_privilege_material_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-03 using the exact controlled facts ['Willa Novak', 'Caleb Hassan'].", "id": "findings.F-03.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-03's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-03.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-12', 'Owen Delgado'] for F-03.", "id": "findings.F-03.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-04 exception for email-family separation.", "id": "findings.F-04.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's id from /workspace/documents/02_orders/010_orders_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_production_logs/058_production_logs_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's issue from /workspace/documents/02_orders/010_orders_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_production_logs/058_production_logs_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's severity from /workspace/documents/02_orders/010_orders_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_production_logs/058_production_logs_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's primary_source from /workspace/documents/02_orders/010_orders_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_production_logs/058_production_logs_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/02_orders/010_orders_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_production_logs/058_production_logs_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-04 using the exact controlled facts ['closed without exception', 'CB-LD-2703-D908', 'open and escalated', 'CB-LD-2703-M923'].", "id": "findings.F-04.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-04's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-04.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-12', 'Lena Varga'] for F-04.", "id": "findings.F-04.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-05 exception for privilege-log description defect.", "id": "findings.F-05.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's id from /workspace/documents/02_orders/013_orders_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_production_logs/061_production_logs_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's issue from /workspace/documents/02_orders/013_orders_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_production_logs/061_production_logs_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's severity from /workspace/documents/02_orders/013_orders_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_production_logs/061_production_logs_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's primary_source from /workspace/documents/02_orders/013_orders_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_production_logs/061_production_logs_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/02_orders/013_orders_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_production_logs/061_production_logs_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-05 using the exact controlled facts ['Central District of California', 'California'].", "id": "findings.F-05.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-05's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-05.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-12', 'Samuel Kim'] for F-05.", "id": "findings.F-05.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-06 exception for common-interest support gap.", "id": "findings.F-06.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's id from /workspace/documents/02_orders/016_orders_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_production_logs/064_production_logs_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's issue from /workspace/documents/02_orders/016_orders_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_production_logs/064_production_logs_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's severity from /workspace/documents/02_orders/016_orders_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_production_logs/064_production_logs_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's primary_source from /workspace/documents/02_orders/016_orders_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_production_logs/064_production_logs_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/02_orders/016_orders_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_production_logs/064_production_logs_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-06 using the exact controlled facts ['11%', '18%'].", "id": "findings.F-06.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-06's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-06.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-12', 'Maya Ellison'] for F-06.", "id": "findings.F-06.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-07 exception for clawback deadline.", "id": "findings.F-07.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's id from /workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/019_requests_responses_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_depositions/067_depositions_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's issue from /workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/019_requests_responses_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_depositions/067_depositions_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's severity from /workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/019_requests_responses_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_depositions/067_depositions_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's primary_source from /workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/019_requests_responses_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_depositions/067_depositions_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/019_requests_responses_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_depositions/067_depositions_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-07 using the exact controlled facts ['notices-crown_kitchen_group@example.test', 'archive-martinez_et_al@example.test'].", "id": "findings.F-07.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-07's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-07.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-12', 'Rafael Okafor'] for F-07.", "id": "findings.F-07.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-08 exception for protective-order designation error.", "id": "findings.F-08.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's id from /workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/022_requests_responses_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_depositions/070_depositions_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's issue from /workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/022_requests_responses_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_depositions/070_depositions_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's severity from /workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/022_requests_responses_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_depositions/070_depositions_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's primary_source from /workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/022_requests_responses_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_depositions/070_depositions_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/022_requests_responses_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_depositions/070_depositions_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-08 using the exact controlled facts ['154 records', '2025-04-19', '52 records', '2025-05-13'].", "id": "findings.F-08.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-08's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-08.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-12', 'Nora Chen'] for F-08.", "id": "findings.F-08.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-09 exception for request-response mismatch.", "id": "findings.F-09.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's id from /workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/025_custodian_files_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_expert_material/073_expert_material_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's issue from /workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/025_custodian_files_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_expert_material/073_expert_material_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's severity from /workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/025_custodian_files_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_expert_material/073_expert_material_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's primary_source from /workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/025_custodian_files_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_expert_material/073_expert_material_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/025_custodian_files_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_expert_material/073_expert_material_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-09 using the exact controlled facts ['2025-10-18', 'CB-LD-2703-I448', '2025-11-12', 'CB-LD-2703-R749'].", "id": "findings.F-09.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-09's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-09.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-12', 'Dominic Alvarez'] for F-09.", "id": "findings.F-09.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-10 exception for deposition exhibit omission.", "id": "findings.F-10.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's id from /workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/028_custodian_files_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_expert_material/076_expert_material_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's issue from /workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/028_custodian_files_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_expert_material/076_expert_material_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's severity from /workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/028_custodian_files_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_expert_material/076_expert_material_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's primary_source from /workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/028_custodian_files_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_expert_material/076_expert_material_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/028_custodian_files_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_expert_material/076_expert_material_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-10 using the exact controlled facts ['$3,781,478.00', '$3,939,456.00'].", "id": "findings.F-10.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-10's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-10.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-12', 'Priya Raman'] for F-10.", "id": "findings.F-10.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-11 exception for expert draft segregation.", "id": "findings.F-11.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's id from /workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/031_custodian_files_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_expert_material/079_expert_material_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's issue from /workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/031_custodian_files_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_expert_material/079_expert_material_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's severity from /workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/031_custodian_files_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_expert_material/079_expert_material_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's primary_source from /workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/031_custodian_files_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_expert_material/079_expert_material_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/031_custodian_files_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_expert_material/079_expert_material_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-11 using the exact controlled facts ['Willa Novak', 'Rafael Okafor'].", "id": "findings.F-11.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-11's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-11.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-12', 'Elliot Mercer'] for F-11.", "id": "findings.F-11.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-12 exception for third-party subpoena deadline.", "id": "findings.F-12.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's id from /workspace/documents/05_email_families/034_email_families_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_third_party/082_third_party_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's issue from /workspace/documents/05_email_families/034_email_families_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_third_party/082_third_party_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's severity from /workspace/documents/05_email_families/034_email_families_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_third_party/082_third_party_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's primary_source from /workspace/documents/05_email_families/034_email_families_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_third_party/082_third_party_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/05_email_families/034_email_families_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_third_party/082_third_party_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-12 using the exact controlled facts ['closed without exception', 'CB-LD-2703-L342', 'open and escalated', 'CB-LD-2703-U949'].", "id": "findings.F-12.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-12's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-12.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-12', 'Talia Brooks'] for F-12.", "id": "findings.F-12.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-13 exception for production gap.", "id": "findings.F-13.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's id from /workspace/documents/05_email_families/037_email_families_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_third_party/085_third_party_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's issue from /workspace/documents/05_email_families/037_email_families_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_third_party/085_third_party_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's severity from /workspace/documents/05_email_families/037_email_families_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_third_party/085_third_party_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's primary_source from /workspace/documents/05_email_families/037_email_families_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_third_party/085_third_party_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/05_email_families/037_email_families_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_third_party/085_third_party_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-13 using the exact controlled facts ['Central District of California', 'California'].", "id": "findings.F-13.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-13's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-13.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-12', 'Jonas Feld'] for F-13.", "id": "findings.F-13.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-14 exception for metadata field loss.", "id": "findings.F-14.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's id from /workspace/documents/05_email_families/040_email_families_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_third_party/088_third_party_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's issue from /workspace/documents/05_email_families/040_email_families_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_third_party/088_third_party_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's severity from /workspace/documents/05_email_families/040_email_families_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_third_party/088_third_party_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's primary_source from /workspace/documents/05_email_families/040_email_families_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_third_party/088_third_party_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/05_email_families/040_email_families_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_third_party/088_third_party_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-14 using the exact controlled facts ['8%', '12%'].", "id": "findings.F-14.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-14's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-14.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-12', 'Mei Whitaker'] for F-14.", "id": "findings.F-14.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-15 exception for Bates-range overlap.", "id": "findings.F-15.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's id from /workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/043_chat_exports_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_case_management/091_case_management_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's issue from /workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/043_chat_exports_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_case_management/091_case_management_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's severity from /workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/043_chat_exports_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_case_management/091_case_management_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's primary_source from /workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/043_chat_exports_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_case_management/091_case_management_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/043_chat_exports_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_case_management/091_case_management_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-15 using the exact controlled facts ['notices-crown_kitchen_group@example.test', 'archive-martinez_et_al@example.test'].", "id": "findings.F-15.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-15's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-15.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-12', 'Caleb Hassan'] for F-15.", "id": "findings.F-15.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-16 exception for meet-and-confer commitment.", "id": "findings.F-16.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's id from /workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/046_chat_exports_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_case_management/094_case_management_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's issue from /workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/046_chat_exports_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_case_management/094_case_management_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's severity from /workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/046_chat_exports_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_case_management/094_case_management_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's primary_source from /workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/046_chat_exports_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_case_management/094_case_management_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/046_chat_exports_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_case_management/094_case_management_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-16 using the exact controlled facts ['180 records', '2025-05-15', '74 records', '2025-06-30'].", "id": "findings.F-16.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-16's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-16.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-12', 'Leona Park'] for F-16.", "id": "findings.F-16.action_anchors"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Executive assessment' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Executive assessment"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Method and record coverage' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Method and record coverage"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Findings' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Findings"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Recommended next actions' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Recommended next actions"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Assumptions and limitations' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Assumptions and limitations"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-01 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-01"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-02 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-02"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-03 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-03"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-04 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-04"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-05 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-05"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-06 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-06"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-07 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-07"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-08 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-08"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-09 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-09"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-10 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-10"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-11 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-11"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-12 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-12"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-13 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-13"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-14 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-14"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-15 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-15"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-16 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-16"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Do not claim the production has no issues or that every record is consistent.", "id": "memo.forbidden_claims_absent"}], "decision_options": [{"id": "cross-source-reconciliation", "label": "Reconcile controlling and corroborating records", "reason": "The CB-LD-2703 production contains independently maintained records; a defensible answer must preserve each supported conflict and its cure owner.", "selected": true}, {"id": "latest-record-controls", "label": "Treat the latest record as controlling", "reason": "Timestamp recency does not establish legal priority, execution, or approval authority.", "selected": false}, {"id": "primary-records-only", "label": "Report primary records without reconciliation", "reason": "Primary records alone conceal the operational conflicts that create the actionable exceptions.", "selected": false}], "gates": ["all_evidence_read_in_full", "chain_of_custody_metadata_checked", "findings_criteria_complete", "memo_criteria_complete", "deliverables_written_through_mcp"], "metadata_checks": 8, "metric": "weighted_criteria_score", "minimum_tool_calls": 46, "required_deliverables": ["findings.json", "advice.md"], "required_document_reads": 33, "type": "deterministic", "weights": {"findings": 0.55, "memo": 0.2, "procedure": 0.25}}, "task_id": "cb100-033-crown-employment", "task_name": "Crown wage action discovery check", "world_id": "counselbench-filesystem-mcp-v2"}
-{"context_files": ["task_files/cb100-034-delta-products/01_pleadings/001_pleadings_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-034-delta-products/01_pleadings/002_pleadings_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-034-delta-products/01_pleadings/003_pleadings_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-034-delta-products/01_pleadings/004_pleadings_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-034-delta-products/01_pleadings/005_pleadings_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-034-delta-products/01_pleadings/006_pleadings_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-034-delta-products/01_pleadings/007_pleadings_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-034-delta-products/01_pleadings/008_pleadings_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-034-delta-products/02_orders/009_orders_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-034-delta-products/02_orders/010_orders_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-034-delta-products/02_orders/011_orders_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-034-delta-products/02_orders/012_orders_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-034-delta-products/02_orders/013_orders_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-034-delta-products/02_orders/014_orders_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-034-delta-products/02_orders/015_orders_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-034-delta-products/02_orders/016_orders_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-034-delta-products/03_requests_responses/017_requests_responses_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-034-delta-products/03_requests_responses/018_requests_responses_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-034-delta-products/03_requests_responses/019_requests_responses_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-034-delta-products/03_requests_responses/020_requests_responses_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-034-delta-products/03_requests_responses/021_requests_responses_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-034-delta-products/03_requests_responses/022_requests_responses_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-034-delta-products/03_requests_responses/023_requests_responses_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-034-delta-products/03_requests_responses/024_requests_responses_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-034-delta-products/04_custodian_files/025_custodian_files_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-034-delta-products/04_custodian_files/026_custodian_files_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-034-delta-products/04_custodian_files/027_custodian_files_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-034-delta-products/04_custodian_files/028_custodian_files_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-034-delta-products/04_custodian_files/029_custodian_files_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-034-delta-products/04_custodian_files/030_custodian_files_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-034-delta-products/04_custodian_files/031_custodian_files_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-034-delta-products/04_custodian_files/032_custodian_files_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-034-delta-products/05_email_families/033_email_families_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-034-delta-products/05_email_families/034_email_families_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-034-delta-products/05_email_families/035_email_families_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-034-delta-products/05_email_families/036_email_families_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-034-delta-products/05_email_families/037_email_families_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-034-delta-products/05_email_families/038_email_families_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-034-delta-products/05_email_families/039_email_families_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-034-delta-products/05_email_families/040_email_families_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-034-delta-products/06_chat_exports/041_chat_exports_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-034-delta-products/06_chat_exports/042_chat_exports_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-034-delta-products/06_chat_exports/043_chat_exports_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-034-delta-products/06_chat_exports/044_chat_exports_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-034-delta-products/06_chat_exports/045_chat_exports_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-034-delta-products/06_chat_exports/046_chat_exports_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-034-delta-products/06_chat_exports/047_chat_exports_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-034-delta-products/06_chat_exports/048_chat_exports_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-034-delta-products/07_privilege_material/049_privilege_material_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-034-delta-products/07_privilege_material/050_privilege_material_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-034-delta-products/07_privilege_material/051_privilege_material_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-034-delta-products/07_privilege_material/052_privilege_material_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-034-delta-products/07_privilege_material/053_privilege_material_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-034-delta-products/07_privilege_material/054_privilege_material_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-034-delta-products/07_privilege_material/055_privilege_material_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-034-delta-products/07_privilege_material/056_privilege_material_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-034-delta-products/08_production_logs/057_production_logs_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-034-delta-products/08_production_logs/058_production_logs_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-034-delta-products/08_production_logs/059_production_logs_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-034-delta-products/08_production_logs/060_production_logs_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-034-delta-products/08_production_logs/061_production_logs_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-034-delta-products/08_production_logs/062_production_logs_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-034-delta-products/08_production_logs/063_production_logs_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-034-delta-products/08_production_logs/064_production_logs_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-034-delta-products/09_depositions/065_depositions_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-034-delta-products/09_depositions/066_depositions_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-034-delta-products/09_depositions/067_depositions_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-034-delta-products/09_depositions/068_depositions_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-034-delta-products/09_depositions/069_depositions_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-034-delta-products/09_depositions/070_depositions_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-034-delta-products/09_depositions/071_depositions_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-034-delta-products/09_depositions/072_depositions_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-034-delta-products/10_expert_material/073_expert_material_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-034-delta-products/10_expert_material/074_expert_material_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-034-delta-products/10_expert_material/075_expert_material_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-034-delta-products/10_expert_material/076_expert_material_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-034-delta-products/10_expert_material/077_expert_material_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-034-delta-products/10_expert_material/078_expert_material_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-034-delta-products/10_expert_material/079_expert_material_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-034-delta-products/10_expert_material/080_expert_material_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-034-delta-products/11_third_party/081_third_party_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-034-delta-products/11_third_party/082_third_party_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-034-delta-products/11_third_party/083_third_party_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-034-delta-products/11_third_party/084_third_party_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-034-delta-products/11_third_party/085_third_party_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-034-delta-products/11_third_party/086_third_party_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-034-delta-products/11_third_party/087_third_party_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-034-delta-products/11_third_party/088_third_party_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-034-delta-products/12_case_management/089_case_management_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-034-delta-products/12_case_management/090_case_management_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-034-delta-products/12_case_management/091_case_management_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-034-delta-products/12_case_management/092_case_management_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-034-delta-products/12_case_management/093_case_management_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-034-delta-products/12_case_management/094_case_management_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-034-delta-products/12_case_management/095_case_management_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-034-delta-products/12_case_management/096_case_management_status_report.md"], "gold_output": {"advice_markdown": "# Counsel advice — Delta product-liability collection audit\n\n## Executive assessment\n\nFor Delta Infant Products matter CB-LD-2704, the review identified 16 source-supported exceptions requiring action before 2026-09-16. The assessment concerns Reed v. Delta Infant Products and the supplied record for Georgia.\n\n## Method and record coverage\n\nThe review inventoried all 96 production files, read the 33 controlling, corroborating, and control records, searched the email exports, and checked metadata for the designated chain-of-custody sample. Conclusions are limited to the synthetic production supplied for this benchmark matter.\n\n## Findings\n\n### F-01 — custodian omission (critical)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for custodian omission: one source states the operative date is 2025-09-01 under control reference CB-LD-2704-A101, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2025-09-24 under response reference CB-LD-2704-J861.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/01_pleadings/001_pleadings_control_register.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/07_privilege_material/049_privilege_material_control_register.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-16, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Farah Ibrahim.\n\n### F-02 — legal-hold delivery gap (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for legal-hold delivery gap: one source states the controlling amount is $4,423,565.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $4,713,630.00.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/01_pleadings/004_pleadings_ledger_export.csv`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/07_privilege_material/052_privilege_material_ledger_export.csv`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-16, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Owen Delgado.\n\n### F-03 — collection-date inconsistency (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for collection-date inconsistency: one source states approval is attributed to Theo Laurent as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Isaac Romero and contains no entry for Theo Laurent.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/01_pleadings/007_pleadings_officer_certificate.html`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/07_privilege_material/055_privilege_material_officer_certificate.html`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-16, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Lena Varga.\n\n### F-04 — email-family separation (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for email-family separation: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-LD-2704-D805, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-LD-2704-M985.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/02_orders/010_orders_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/08_production_logs/058_production_logs_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-16, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Samuel Kim.\n\n### F-05 — privilege-log description defect (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for privilege-log description defect: one source states the applicable location is Northern District of Georgia, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to Georgia operations outside Northern District of Georgia.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/02_orders/013_orders_review_memorandum.json`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/08_production_logs/061_production_logs_review_memorandum.json`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-16, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Maya Ellison.\n\n### F-06 — common-interest support gap (low)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for common-interest support gap: one source states the threshold is 4% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 8% and produced a different exception result.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/02_orders/016_orders_status_report.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/08_production_logs/064_production_logs_status_report.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-16, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Rafael Okafor.\n\n### F-07 — clawback deadline (critical)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for clawback deadline: one source states formal notice must use notices-delta_infant_products@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-reed_v_delta_infant_products@example.test.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/019_requests_responses_correspondence.eml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/09_depositions/067_depositions_correspondence.eml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-16, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Nora Chen.\n\n### F-08 — protective-order designation error (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for protective-order designation error: one source states the governed population contains 132 records through 2026-01-02, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 47 records through 2026-01-21.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/022_requests_responses_formal_notice.xml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/09_depositions/070_depositions_formal_notice.xml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-16, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Dominic Alvarez.\n\n### F-09 — request-response mismatch (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for request-response mismatch: one source states the operative date is 2025-11-01 under control reference CB-LD-2704-I582, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2025-11-27 under response reference CB-LD-2704-R690.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/025_custodian_files_control_register.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/10_expert_material/073_expert_material_control_register.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-16, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Priya Raman.\n\n### F-10 — deposition exhibit omission (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for deposition exhibit omission: one source states the controlling amount is $5,154,262.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $5,445,024.00.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/028_custodian_files_ledger_export.csv`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/10_expert_material/076_expert_material_ledger_export.csv`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-16, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Elliot Mercer.\n\n### F-11 — expert draft segregation (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for expert draft segregation: one source states approval is attributed to Theo Laurent as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Dominic Alvarez and contains no entry for Theo Laurent.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/031_custodian_files_officer_certificate.html`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/10_expert_material/079_expert_material_officer_certificate.html`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-16, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Talia Brooks.\n\n### F-12 — third-party subpoena deadline (low)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for third-party subpoena deadline: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-LD-2704-L830, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-LD-2704-U779.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/05_email_families/034_email_families_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/11_third_party/082_third_party_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-16, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Jonas Feld.\n\n### F-13 — production gap (critical)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for production gap: one source states the applicable location is Northern District of Georgia, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to Georgia operations outside Northern District of Georgia.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/05_email_families/037_email_families_review_memorandum.json`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/11_third_party/085_third_party_review_memorandum.json`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-16, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Mei Whitaker.\n\n### F-14 — metadata field loss (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for metadata field loss: one source states the threshold is 5% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 10% and produced a different exception result.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/05_email_families/040_email_families_status_report.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/11_third_party/088_third_party_status_report.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-16, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Caleb Hassan.\n\n### F-15 — Bates-range overlap (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for Bates-range overlap: one source states formal notice must use notices-delta_infant_products@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-reed_v_delta_infant_products@example.test.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/043_chat_exports_correspondence.eml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/12_case_management/091_case_management_correspondence.eml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-16, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Leona Park.\n\n### F-16 — meet-and-confer commitment (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for meet-and-confer commitment: one source states the governed population contains 91 records through 2025-11-22, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 71 records through 2026-01-04.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/046_chat_exports_formal_notice.xml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/12_case_management/094_case_management_formal_notice.xml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-16, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Isaac Romero.\n\n## Recommended next actions\n\nSequence the critical and high findings first, assign the named owners, preserve the cited records, and document any resolution in the controlling matter register before the stated deadline.\n\n## Assumptions and limitations\n\nThis analysis is confined to task cb100-034-delta-products and the supplied synthetic evidence. It does not rely on external facts, does not resolve disputed law, and is not legal advice for a real person or entity.\n", "findings": {"as_of": "2026-09-16", "findings": [{"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/07_privilege_material/049_privilege_material_control_register.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for custodian omission: one source states the operative date is 2025-09-01 under control reference CB-LD-2704-A101, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2025-09-24 under response reference CB-LD-2704-J861.", "id": "F-01", "issue": "custodian omission", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/01_pleadings/001_pleadings_control_register.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-16, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Farah Ibrahim.", "severity": "critical"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/07_privilege_material/052_privilege_material_ledger_export.csv", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for legal-hold delivery gap: one source states the controlling amount is $4,423,565.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $4,713,630.00.", "id": "F-02", "issue": "legal-hold delivery gap", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/01_pleadings/004_pleadings_ledger_export.csv", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-16, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Owen Delgado.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/07_privilege_material/055_privilege_material_officer_certificate.html", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for collection-date inconsistency: one source states approval is attributed to Theo Laurent as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Isaac Romero and contains no entry for Theo Laurent.", "id": "F-03", "issue": "collection-date inconsistency", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/01_pleadings/007_pleadings_officer_certificate.html", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-16, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Lena Varga.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/08_production_logs/058_production_logs_executed_instrument.txt", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for email-family separation: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-LD-2704-D805, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-LD-2704-M985.", "id": "F-04", "issue": "email-family separation", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/02_orders/010_orders_executed_instrument.txt", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-16, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Samuel Kim.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/08_production_logs/061_production_logs_review_memorandum.json", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for privilege-log description defect: one source states the applicable location is Northern District of Georgia, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to Georgia operations outside Northern District of Georgia.", "id": "F-05", "issue": "privilege-log description defect", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/02_orders/013_orders_review_memorandum.json", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-16, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Maya Ellison.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/08_production_logs/064_production_logs_status_report.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for common-interest support gap: one source states the threshold is 4% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 8% and produced a different exception result.", "id": "F-06", "issue": "common-interest support gap", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/02_orders/016_orders_status_report.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-16, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Rafael Okafor.", "severity": "low"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/09_depositions/067_depositions_correspondence.eml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for clawback deadline: one source states formal notice must use notices-delta_infant_products@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-reed_v_delta_infant_products@example.test.", "id": "F-07", "issue": "clawback deadline", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/019_requests_responses_correspondence.eml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-16, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Nora Chen.", "severity": "critical"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/09_depositions/070_depositions_formal_notice.xml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for protective-order designation error: one source states the governed population contains 132 records through 2026-01-02, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 47 records through 2026-01-21.", "id": "F-08", "issue": "protective-order designation error", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/022_requests_responses_formal_notice.xml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-16, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Dominic Alvarez.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/10_expert_material/073_expert_material_control_register.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for request-response mismatch: one source states the operative date is 2025-11-01 under control reference CB-LD-2704-I582, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2025-11-27 under response reference CB-LD-2704-R690.", "id": "F-09", "issue": "request-response mismatch", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/025_custodian_files_control_register.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-16, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Priya Raman.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/10_expert_material/076_expert_material_ledger_export.csv", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for deposition exhibit omission: one source states the controlling amount is $5,154,262.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $5,445,024.00.", "id": "F-10", "issue": "deposition exhibit omission", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/028_custodian_files_ledger_export.csv", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-16, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Elliot Mercer.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/10_expert_material/079_expert_material_officer_certificate.html", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for expert draft segregation: one source states approval is attributed to Theo Laurent as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Dominic Alvarez and contains no entry for Theo Laurent.", "id": "F-11", "issue": "expert draft segregation", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/031_custodian_files_officer_certificate.html", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-16, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Talia Brooks.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/11_third_party/082_third_party_executed_instrument.txt", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for third-party subpoena deadline: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-LD-2704-L830, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-LD-2704-U779.", "id": "F-12", "issue": "third-party subpoena deadline", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/05_email_families/034_email_families_executed_instrument.txt", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-16, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Jonas Feld.", "severity": "low"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/11_third_party/085_third_party_review_memorandum.json", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for production gap: one source states the applicable location is Northern District of Georgia, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to Georgia operations outside Northern District of Georgia.", "id": "F-13", "issue": "production gap", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/05_email_families/037_email_families_review_memorandum.json", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-16, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Mei Whitaker.", "severity": "critical"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/11_third_party/088_third_party_status_report.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for metadata field loss: one source states the threshold is 5% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 10% and produced a different exception result.", "id": "F-14", "issue": "metadata field loss", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/05_email_families/040_email_families_status_report.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-16, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Caleb Hassan.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/12_case_management/091_case_management_correspondence.eml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for Bates-range overlap: one source states formal notice must use notices-delta_infant_products@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-reed_v_delta_infant_products@example.test.", "id": "F-15", "issue": "Bates-range overlap", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/043_chat_exports_correspondence.eml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-16, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Leona Park.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/12_case_management/094_case_management_formal_notice.xml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for meet-and-confer commitment: one source states the governed population contains 91 records through 2025-11-22, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 71 records through 2026-01-04.", "id": "F-16", "issue": "meet-and-confer commitment", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/046_chat_exports_formal_notice.xml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-16, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Isaac Romero.", "severity": "medium"}], "matter_number": "CB-LD-2704", "prepared_for": "Delta Infant Products", "schema_version": "1.0", "task_id": "cb100-034-delta-products"}}, "metadata": {"benchmark": "CounselBench-100", "code_license": "Apache-2.0", "data_license": "CC-BY-4.0", "deadline": "2026-09-16", "document_count": 96, "jurisdiction": "Georgia", "matter_number": "CB-LD-2704", "mcp_commit": "9a96ea6e5913736f92b88345bf51caeaaa8e719f", "mcp_package": "@modelcontextprotocol/server-filesystem@2026.7.10", "practice_area": "litigation-discovery", "reference_tool_calls": 46, "required_evidence_reads": 33, "synthetic": true, "venue": "Northern District of Georgia", "version": "2.0.0"}, "prompt": "You are discovery counsel for Delta Infant Products. Several workstreams have maintained separate versions of the truth; your assignment is to produce one auditable legal view. Design-history files, overseas supplier emails, and expert materials have inconsistent collection dates and an unresolved third-party subpoena. Decision due 2026-09-16. Georgia law governs; Northern District of Georgia is the forum. Distinguish a missing document from an affirmative contradiction in the documents that are present. Work out the defensible position from the matter production and leave an audit-ready exception tracker and concise advice for the supervising lawyer. Keep confirmed conflicts separate from open questions, cite the records that actually control each conclusion, and do not fill gaps with outside facts.", "rubric": {"criteria": [{"category": "procedure", "description": "Complete at least 46 successful, argument-specific evidence and output calls.", "id": "procedure.minimum_successful_tool_calls"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Find and read the 33 controlling, corroborating, and work-product-control records in full.", "id": "procedure.all_evidence_read_in_full"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Inspect file metadata for the eight designated critical primary records before relying on them.", "id": "procedure.chain_of_custody_metadata_checked"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Confirm the sandbox's allowed document and output roots.", "id": "procedure.allowed_directories_checked"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Inventory all 96 records so the relevant sources are discovered among the context records.", "id": "procedure.recursive_inventory_completed"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Search the production for email evidence that may corroborate or contradict formal records.", "id": "procedure.targeted_search_completed"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Leave only findings.json and advice.md in the output workspace.", "id": "procedure.exact_deliverable_set"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Create both final work products through the sandbox MCP surface.", "id": "procedure.deliverables_written_through_mcp"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Produce findings.json as a valid JSON object.", "id": "findings.findings_is_object"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Report exactly 16 confirmed exceptions.", "id": "findings.findings_exact_count"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Use each stable finding ID exactly once.", "id": "findings.finding_ids_unique"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set schema_version to the released matter value '1.0'.", "id": "findings.top_level_schema_version"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set task_id to the released matter value 'cb100-034-delta-products'.", "id": "findings.top_level_task_id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set matter_number to the released matter value 'CB-LD-2704'.", "id": "findings.top_level_matter_number"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set prepared_for to the released matter value 'Delta Infant Products'.", "id": "findings.top_level_prepared_for"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set as_of to the released matter value '2026-09-16'.", "id": "findings.top_level_as_of"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-01 exception for custodian omission.", "id": "findings.F-01.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's id from /workspace/documents/01_pleadings/001_pleadings_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_privilege_material/049_privilege_material_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's issue from /workspace/documents/01_pleadings/001_pleadings_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_privilege_material/049_privilege_material_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's severity from /workspace/documents/01_pleadings/001_pleadings_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_privilege_material/049_privilege_material_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's primary_source from /workspace/documents/01_pleadings/001_pleadings_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_privilege_material/049_privilege_material_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/01_pleadings/001_pleadings_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_privilege_material/049_privilege_material_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-01 using the exact controlled facts ['2025-09-01', 'CB-LD-2704-A101', '2025-09-24', 'CB-LD-2704-J861'].", "id": "findings.F-01.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-01's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-01.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-16', 'Farah Ibrahim'] for F-01.", "id": "findings.F-01.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-02 exception for legal-hold delivery gap.", "id": "findings.F-02.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's id from /workspace/documents/01_pleadings/004_pleadings_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_privilege_material/052_privilege_material_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's issue from /workspace/documents/01_pleadings/004_pleadings_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_privilege_material/052_privilege_material_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's severity from /workspace/documents/01_pleadings/004_pleadings_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_privilege_material/052_privilege_material_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's primary_source from /workspace/documents/01_pleadings/004_pleadings_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_privilege_material/052_privilege_material_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/01_pleadings/004_pleadings_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_privilege_material/052_privilege_material_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-02 using the exact controlled facts ['$4,423,565.00', '$4,713,630.00'].", "id": "findings.F-02.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-02's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-02.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-16', 'Owen Delgado'] for F-02.", "id": "findings.F-02.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-03 exception for collection-date inconsistency.", "id": "findings.F-03.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's id from /workspace/documents/01_pleadings/007_pleadings_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_privilege_material/055_privilege_material_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's issue from /workspace/documents/01_pleadings/007_pleadings_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_privilege_material/055_privilege_material_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's severity from /workspace/documents/01_pleadings/007_pleadings_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_privilege_material/055_privilege_material_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's primary_source from /workspace/documents/01_pleadings/007_pleadings_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_privilege_material/055_privilege_material_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/01_pleadings/007_pleadings_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_privilege_material/055_privilege_material_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-03 using the exact controlled facts ['Theo Laurent', 'Isaac Romero'].", "id": "findings.F-03.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-03's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-03.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-16', 'Lena Varga'] for F-03.", "id": "findings.F-03.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-04 exception for email-family separation.", "id": "findings.F-04.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's id from /workspace/documents/02_orders/010_orders_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_production_logs/058_production_logs_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's issue from /workspace/documents/02_orders/010_orders_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_production_logs/058_production_logs_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's severity from /workspace/documents/02_orders/010_orders_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_production_logs/058_production_logs_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's primary_source from /workspace/documents/02_orders/010_orders_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_production_logs/058_production_logs_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/02_orders/010_orders_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_production_logs/058_production_logs_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-04 using the exact controlled facts ['closed without exception', 'CB-LD-2704-D805', 'open and escalated', 'CB-LD-2704-M985'].", "id": "findings.F-04.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-04's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-04.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-16', 'Samuel Kim'] for F-04.", "id": "findings.F-04.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-05 exception for privilege-log description defect.", "id": "findings.F-05.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's id from /workspace/documents/02_orders/013_orders_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_production_logs/061_production_logs_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's issue from /workspace/documents/02_orders/013_orders_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_production_logs/061_production_logs_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's severity from /workspace/documents/02_orders/013_orders_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_production_logs/061_production_logs_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's primary_source from /workspace/documents/02_orders/013_orders_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_production_logs/061_production_logs_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/02_orders/013_orders_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_production_logs/061_production_logs_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-05 using the exact controlled facts ['Northern District of Georgia', 'Georgia'].", "id": "findings.F-05.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-05's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-05.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-16', 'Maya Ellison'] for F-05.", "id": "findings.F-05.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-06 exception for common-interest support gap.", "id": "findings.F-06.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's id from /workspace/documents/02_orders/016_orders_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_production_logs/064_production_logs_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's issue from /workspace/documents/02_orders/016_orders_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_production_logs/064_production_logs_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's severity from /workspace/documents/02_orders/016_orders_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_production_logs/064_production_logs_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's primary_source from /workspace/documents/02_orders/016_orders_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_production_logs/064_production_logs_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/02_orders/016_orders_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_production_logs/064_production_logs_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-06 using the exact controlled facts ['4%', '8%'].", "id": "findings.F-06.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-06's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-06.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-16', 'Rafael Okafor'] for F-06.", "id": "findings.F-06.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-07 exception for clawback deadline.", "id": "findings.F-07.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's id from /workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/019_requests_responses_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_depositions/067_depositions_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's issue from /workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/019_requests_responses_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_depositions/067_depositions_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's severity from /workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/019_requests_responses_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_depositions/067_depositions_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's primary_source from /workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/019_requests_responses_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_depositions/067_depositions_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/019_requests_responses_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_depositions/067_depositions_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-07 using the exact controlled facts ['notices-delta_infant_products@example.test', 'archive-reed_v_delta_infant_products@example.test'].", "id": "findings.F-07.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-07's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-07.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-16', 'Nora Chen'] for F-07.", "id": "findings.F-07.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-08 exception for protective-order designation error.", "id": "findings.F-08.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's id from /workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/022_requests_responses_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_depositions/070_depositions_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's issue from /workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/022_requests_responses_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_depositions/070_depositions_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's severity from /workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/022_requests_responses_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_depositions/070_depositions_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's primary_source from /workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/022_requests_responses_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_depositions/070_depositions_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/022_requests_responses_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_depositions/070_depositions_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-08 using the exact controlled facts ['132 records', '2026-01-02', '47 records', '2026-01-21'].", "id": "findings.F-08.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-08's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-08.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-16', 'Dominic Alvarez'] for F-08.", "id": "findings.F-08.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-09 exception for request-response mismatch.", "id": "findings.F-09.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's id from /workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/025_custodian_files_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_expert_material/073_expert_material_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's issue from /workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/025_custodian_files_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_expert_material/073_expert_material_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's severity from /workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/025_custodian_files_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_expert_material/073_expert_material_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's primary_source from /workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/025_custodian_files_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_expert_material/073_expert_material_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/025_custodian_files_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_expert_material/073_expert_material_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-09 using the exact controlled facts ['2025-11-01', 'CB-LD-2704-I582', '2025-11-27', 'CB-LD-2704-R690'].", "id": "findings.F-09.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-09's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-09.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-16', 'Priya Raman'] for F-09.", "id": "findings.F-09.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-10 exception for deposition exhibit omission.", "id": "findings.F-10.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's id from /workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/028_custodian_files_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_expert_material/076_expert_material_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's issue from /workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/028_custodian_files_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_expert_material/076_expert_material_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's severity from /workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/028_custodian_files_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_expert_material/076_expert_material_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's primary_source from /workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/028_custodian_files_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_expert_material/076_expert_material_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/028_custodian_files_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_expert_material/076_expert_material_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-10 using the exact controlled facts ['$5,154,262.00', '$5,445,024.00'].", "id": "findings.F-10.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-10's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-10.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-16', 'Elliot Mercer'] for F-10.", "id": "findings.F-10.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-11 exception for expert draft segregation.", "id": "findings.F-11.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's id from /workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/031_custodian_files_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_expert_material/079_expert_material_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's issue from /workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/031_custodian_files_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_expert_material/079_expert_material_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's severity from /workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/031_custodian_files_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_expert_material/079_expert_material_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's primary_source from /workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/031_custodian_files_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_expert_material/079_expert_material_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/031_custodian_files_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_expert_material/079_expert_material_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-11 using the exact controlled facts ['Theo Laurent', 'Dominic Alvarez'].", "id": "findings.F-11.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-11's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-11.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-16', 'Talia Brooks'] for F-11.", "id": "findings.F-11.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-12 exception for third-party subpoena deadline.", "id": "findings.F-12.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's id from /workspace/documents/05_email_families/034_email_families_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_third_party/082_third_party_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's issue from /workspace/documents/05_email_families/034_email_families_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_third_party/082_third_party_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's severity from /workspace/documents/05_email_families/034_email_families_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_third_party/082_third_party_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's primary_source from /workspace/documents/05_email_families/034_email_families_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_third_party/082_third_party_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/05_email_families/034_email_families_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_third_party/082_third_party_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-12 using the exact controlled facts ['closed without exception', 'CB-LD-2704-L830', 'open and escalated', 'CB-LD-2704-U779'].", "id": "findings.F-12.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-12's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-12.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-16', 'Jonas Feld'] for F-12.", "id": "findings.F-12.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-13 exception for production gap.", "id": "findings.F-13.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's id from /workspace/documents/05_email_families/037_email_families_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_third_party/085_third_party_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's issue from /workspace/documents/05_email_families/037_email_families_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_third_party/085_third_party_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's severity from /workspace/documents/05_email_families/037_email_families_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_third_party/085_third_party_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's primary_source from /workspace/documents/05_email_families/037_email_families_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_third_party/085_third_party_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/05_email_families/037_email_families_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_third_party/085_third_party_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-13 using the exact controlled facts ['Northern District of Georgia', 'Georgia'].", "id": "findings.F-13.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-13's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-13.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-16', 'Mei Whitaker'] for F-13.", "id": "findings.F-13.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-14 exception for metadata field loss.", "id": "findings.F-14.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's id from /workspace/documents/05_email_families/040_email_families_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_third_party/088_third_party_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's issue from /workspace/documents/05_email_families/040_email_families_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_third_party/088_third_party_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's severity from /workspace/documents/05_email_families/040_email_families_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_third_party/088_third_party_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's primary_source from /workspace/documents/05_email_families/040_email_families_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_third_party/088_third_party_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/05_email_families/040_email_families_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_third_party/088_third_party_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-14 using the exact controlled facts ['5%', '10%'].", "id": "findings.F-14.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-14's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-14.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-16', 'Caleb Hassan'] for F-14.", "id": "findings.F-14.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-15 exception for Bates-range overlap.", "id": "findings.F-15.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's id from /workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/043_chat_exports_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_case_management/091_case_management_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's issue from /workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/043_chat_exports_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_case_management/091_case_management_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's severity from /workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/043_chat_exports_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_case_management/091_case_management_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's primary_source from /workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/043_chat_exports_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_case_management/091_case_management_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/043_chat_exports_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_case_management/091_case_management_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-15 using the exact controlled facts ['notices-delta_infant_products@example.test', 'archive-reed_v_delta_infant_products@example.test'].", "id": "findings.F-15.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-15's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-15.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-16', 'Leona Park'] for F-15.", "id": "findings.F-15.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-16 exception for meet-and-confer commitment.", "id": "findings.F-16.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's id from /workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/046_chat_exports_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_case_management/094_case_management_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's issue from /workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/046_chat_exports_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_case_management/094_case_management_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's severity from /workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/046_chat_exports_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_case_management/094_case_management_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's primary_source from /workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/046_chat_exports_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_case_management/094_case_management_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/046_chat_exports_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_case_management/094_case_management_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-16 using the exact controlled facts ['91 records', '2025-11-22', '71 records', '2026-01-04'].", "id": "findings.F-16.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-16's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-16.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-16', 'Isaac Romero'] for F-16.", "id": "findings.F-16.action_anchors"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Executive assessment' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Executive assessment"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Method and record coverage' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Method and record coverage"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Findings' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Findings"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Recommended next actions' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Recommended next actions"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Assumptions and limitations' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Assumptions and limitations"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-01 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-01"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-02 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-02"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-03 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-03"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-04 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-04"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-05 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-05"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-06 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-06"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-07 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-07"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-08 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-08"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-09 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-09"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-10 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-10"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-11 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-11"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-12 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-12"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-13 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-13"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-14 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-14"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-15 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-15"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-16 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-16"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Do not claim the production has no issues or that every record is consistent.", "id": "memo.forbidden_claims_absent"}], "decision_options": [{"id": "cross-source-reconciliation", "label": "Reconcile controlling and corroborating records", "reason": "The CB-LD-2704 production contains independently maintained records; a defensible answer must preserve each supported conflict and its cure owner.", "selected": true}, {"id": "latest-record-controls", "label": "Treat the latest record as controlling", "reason": "Timestamp recency does not establish legal priority, execution, or approval authority.", "selected": false}, {"id": "primary-records-only", "label": "Report primary records without reconciliation", "reason": "Primary records alone conceal the operational conflicts that create the actionable exceptions.", "selected": false}], "gates": ["all_evidence_read_in_full", "chain_of_custody_metadata_checked", "findings_criteria_complete", "memo_criteria_complete", "deliverables_written_through_mcp"], "metadata_checks": 8, "metric": "weighted_criteria_score", "minimum_tool_calls": 46, "required_deliverables": ["findings.json", "advice.md"], "required_document_reads": 33, "type": "deterministic", "weights": {"findings": 0.55, "memo": 0.2, "procedure": 0.25}}, "task_id": "cb100-034-delta-products", "task_name": "Delta product-liability collection audit", "world_id": "counselbench-filesystem-mcp-v2"}
-{"context_files": ["task_files/cb100-035-elm-river/01_pleadings/001_pleadings_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-035-elm-river/01_pleadings/002_pleadings_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-035-elm-river/01_pleadings/003_pleadings_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-035-elm-river/01_pleadings/004_pleadings_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-035-elm-river/01_pleadings/005_pleadings_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-035-elm-river/01_pleadings/006_pleadings_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-035-elm-river/01_pleadings/007_pleadings_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-035-elm-river/01_pleadings/008_pleadings_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-035-elm-river/02_orders/009_orders_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-035-elm-river/02_orders/010_orders_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-035-elm-river/02_orders/011_orders_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-035-elm-river/02_orders/012_orders_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-035-elm-river/02_orders/013_orders_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-035-elm-river/02_orders/014_orders_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-035-elm-river/02_orders/015_orders_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-035-elm-river/02_orders/016_orders_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-035-elm-river/03_requests_responses/017_requests_responses_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-035-elm-river/03_requests_responses/018_requests_responses_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-035-elm-river/03_requests_responses/019_requests_responses_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-035-elm-river/03_requests_responses/020_requests_responses_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-035-elm-river/03_requests_responses/021_requests_responses_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-035-elm-river/03_requests_responses/022_requests_responses_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-035-elm-river/03_requests_responses/023_requests_responses_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-035-elm-river/03_requests_responses/024_requests_responses_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-035-elm-river/04_custodian_files/025_custodian_files_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-035-elm-river/04_custodian_files/026_custodian_files_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-035-elm-river/04_custodian_files/027_custodian_files_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-035-elm-river/04_custodian_files/028_custodian_files_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-035-elm-river/04_custodian_files/029_custodian_files_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-035-elm-river/04_custodian_files/030_custodian_files_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-035-elm-river/04_custodian_files/031_custodian_files_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-035-elm-river/04_custodian_files/032_custodian_files_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-035-elm-river/05_email_families/033_email_families_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-035-elm-river/05_email_families/034_email_families_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-035-elm-river/05_email_families/035_email_families_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-035-elm-river/05_email_families/036_email_families_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-035-elm-river/05_email_families/037_email_families_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-035-elm-river/05_email_families/038_email_families_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-035-elm-river/05_email_families/039_email_families_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-035-elm-river/05_email_families/040_email_families_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-035-elm-river/06_chat_exports/041_chat_exports_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-035-elm-river/06_chat_exports/042_chat_exports_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-035-elm-river/06_chat_exports/043_chat_exports_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-035-elm-river/06_chat_exports/044_chat_exports_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-035-elm-river/06_chat_exports/045_chat_exports_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-035-elm-river/06_chat_exports/046_chat_exports_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-035-elm-river/06_chat_exports/047_chat_exports_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-035-elm-river/06_chat_exports/048_chat_exports_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-035-elm-river/07_privilege_material/049_privilege_material_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-035-elm-river/07_privilege_material/050_privilege_material_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-035-elm-river/07_privilege_material/051_privilege_material_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-035-elm-river/07_privilege_material/052_privilege_material_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-035-elm-river/07_privilege_material/053_privilege_material_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-035-elm-river/07_privilege_material/054_privilege_material_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-035-elm-river/07_privilege_material/055_privilege_material_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-035-elm-river/07_privilege_material/056_privilege_material_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-035-elm-river/08_production_logs/057_production_logs_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-035-elm-river/08_production_logs/058_production_logs_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-035-elm-river/08_production_logs/059_production_logs_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-035-elm-river/08_production_logs/060_production_logs_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-035-elm-river/08_production_logs/061_production_logs_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-035-elm-river/08_production_logs/062_production_logs_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-035-elm-river/08_production_logs/063_production_logs_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-035-elm-river/08_production_logs/064_production_logs_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-035-elm-river/09_depositions/065_depositions_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-035-elm-river/09_depositions/066_depositions_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-035-elm-river/09_depositions/067_depositions_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-035-elm-river/09_depositions/068_depositions_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-035-elm-river/09_depositions/069_depositions_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-035-elm-river/09_depositions/070_depositions_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-035-elm-river/09_depositions/071_depositions_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-035-elm-river/09_depositions/072_depositions_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-035-elm-river/10_expert_material/073_expert_material_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-035-elm-river/10_expert_material/074_expert_material_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-035-elm-river/10_expert_material/075_expert_material_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-035-elm-river/10_expert_material/076_expert_material_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-035-elm-river/10_expert_material/077_expert_material_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-035-elm-river/10_expert_material/078_expert_material_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-035-elm-river/10_expert_material/079_expert_material_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-035-elm-river/10_expert_material/080_expert_material_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-035-elm-river/11_third_party/081_third_party_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-035-elm-river/11_third_party/082_third_party_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-035-elm-river/11_third_party/083_third_party_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-035-elm-river/11_third_party/084_third_party_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-035-elm-river/11_third_party/085_third_party_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-035-elm-river/11_third_party/086_third_party_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-035-elm-river/11_third_party/087_third_party_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-035-elm-river/11_third_party/088_third_party_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-035-elm-river/12_case_management/089_case_management_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-035-elm-river/12_case_management/090_case_management_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-035-elm-river/12_case_management/091_case_management_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-035-elm-river/12_case_management/092_case_management_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-035-elm-river/12_case_management/093_case_management_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-035-elm-river/12_case_management/094_case_management_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-035-elm-river/12_case_management/095_case_management_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-035-elm-river/12_case_management/096_case_management_status_report.md"], "gold_output": {"advice_markdown": "# Counsel advice — Elm River trade-secret privilege audit\n\n## Executive assessment\n\nFor Elm River Robotics matter CB-LD-2705, the review identified 16 source-supported exceptions requiring action before 2026-09-19. The assessment concerns Former engineers and Nacre Automation and the supplied record for Massachusetts.\n\n## Method and record coverage\n\nThe review inventoried all 96 production files, read the 33 controlling, corroborating, and control records, searched the email exports, and checked metadata for the designated chain-of-custody sample. Conclusions are limited to the synthetic production supplied for this benchmark matter.\n\n## Findings\n\n### F-01 — custodian omission (critical)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for custodian omission: one source states the operative date is 2025-04-14 under control reference CB-LD-2705-A141, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2025-04-23 under response reference CB-LD-2705-J380.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/01_pleadings/001_pleadings_control_register.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/07_privilege_material/049_privilege_material_control_register.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-19, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Owen Delgado.\n\n### F-02 — legal-hold delivery gap (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for legal-hold delivery gap: one source states the controlling amount is $4,396,491.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $4,699,482.00.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/01_pleadings/004_pleadings_ledger_export.csv`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/07_privilege_material/052_privilege_material_ledger_export.csv`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-19, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Lena Varga.\n\n### F-03 — collection-date inconsistency (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for collection-date inconsistency: one source states approval is attributed to Amara Patel as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Adrian Mensah and contains no entry for Amara Patel.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/01_pleadings/007_pleadings_officer_certificate.html`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/07_privilege_material/055_privilege_material_officer_certificate.html`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-19, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Samuel Kim.\n\n### F-04 — email-family separation (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for email-family separation: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-LD-2705-D458, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-LD-2705-M958.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/02_orders/010_orders_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/08_production_logs/058_production_logs_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-19, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Maya Ellison.\n\n### F-05 — privilege-log description defect (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for privilege-log description defect: one source states the applicable location is District of Massachusetts, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to Massachusetts operations outside District of Massachusetts.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/02_orders/013_orders_review_memorandum.json`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/08_production_logs/061_production_logs_review_memorandum.json`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-19, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Rafael Okafor.\n\n### F-06 — common-interest support gap (low)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for common-interest support gap: one source states the threshold is 6% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 8% and produced a different exception result.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/02_orders/016_orders_status_report.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/08_production_logs/064_production_logs_status_report.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-19, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Nora Chen.\n\n### F-07 — clawback deadline (critical)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for clawback deadline: one source states formal notice must use notices-elm_river_robotics@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-former_engineers_and_nacre_automation@example.test.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/019_requests_responses_correspondence.eml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/09_depositions/067_depositions_correspondence.eml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-19, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Dominic Alvarez.\n\n### F-08 — protective-order designation error (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for protective-order designation error: one source states the governed population contains 163 records through 2025-04-28, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 66 records through 2025-06-05.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/022_requests_responses_formal_notice.xml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/09_depositions/070_depositions_formal_notice.xml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-19, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Priya Raman.\n\n### F-09 — request-response mismatch (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for request-response mismatch: one source states the operative date is 2025-10-02 under control reference CB-LD-2705-I612, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2025-11-01 under response reference CB-LD-2705-R693.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/025_custodian_files_control_register.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/10_expert_material/073_expert_material_control_register.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-19, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Elliot Mercer.\n\n### F-10 — deposition exhibit omission (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for deposition exhibit omission: one source states the controlling amount is $1,923,735.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $2,053,970.00.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/028_custodian_files_ledger_export.csv`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/10_expert_material/076_expert_material_ledger_export.csv`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-19, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Talia Brooks.\n\n### F-11 — expert draft segregation (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for expert draft segregation: one source states approval is attributed to Amara Patel as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Elliot Mercer and contains no entry for Amara Patel.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/031_custodian_files_officer_certificate.html`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/10_expert_material/079_expert_material_officer_certificate.html`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-19, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Jonas Feld.\n\n### F-12 — third-party subpoena deadline (low)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for third-party subpoena deadline: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-LD-2705-L880, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-LD-2705-U298.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/05_email_families/034_email_families_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/11_third_party/082_third_party_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-19, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Mei Whitaker.\n\n### F-13 — production gap (critical)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for production gap: one source states the applicable location is District of Massachusetts, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to Massachusetts operations outside District of Massachusetts.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/05_email_families/037_email_families_review_memorandum.json`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/11_third_party/085_third_party_review_memorandum.json`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-19, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Caleb Hassan.\n\n### F-14 — metadata field loss (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for metadata field loss: one source states the threshold is 12% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 14% and produced a different exception result.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/05_email_families/040_email_families_status_report.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/11_third_party/088_third_party_status_report.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-19, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Leona Park.\n\n### F-15 — Bates-range overlap (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for Bates-range overlap: one source states formal notice must use notices-elm_river_robotics@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-former_engineers_and_nacre_automation@example.test.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/043_chat_exports_correspondence.eml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/12_case_management/091_case_management_correspondence.eml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-19, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Isaac Romero.\n\n### F-16 — meet-and-confer commitment (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for meet-and-confer commitment: one source states the governed population contains 120 records through 2025-08-03, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 49 records through 2025-08-24.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/046_chat_exports_formal_notice.xml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/12_case_management/094_case_management_formal_notice.xml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-19, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Sofia Bennett.\n\n## Recommended next actions\n\nSequence the critical and high findings first, assign the named owners, preserve the cited records, and document any resolution in the controlling matter register before the stated deadline.\n\n## Assumptions and limitations\n\nThis analysis is confined to task cb100-035-elm-river and the supplied synthetic evidence. It does not rely on external facts, does not resolve disputed law, and is not legal advice for a real person or entity.\n", "findings": {"as_of": "2026-09-19", "findings": [{"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/07_privilege_material/049_privilege_material_control_register.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for custodian omission: one source states the operative date is 2025-04-14 under control reference CB-LD-2705-A141, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2025-04-23 under response reference CB-LD-2705-J380.", "id": "F-01", "issue": "custodian omission", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/01_pleadings/001_pleadings_control_register.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-19, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Owen Delgado.", "severity": "critical"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/07_privilege_material/052_privilege_material_ledger_export.csv", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for legal-hold delivery gap: one source states the controlling amount is $4,396,491.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $4,699,482.00.", "id": "F-02", "issue": "legal-hold delivery gap", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/01_pleadings/004_pleadings_ledger_export.csv", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-19, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Lena Varga.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/07_privilege_material/055_privilege_material_officer_certificate.html", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for collection-date inconsistency: one source states approval is attributed to Amara Patel as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Adrian Mensah and contains no entry for Amara Patel.", "id": "F-03", "issue": "collection-date inconsistency", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/01_pleadings/007_pleadings_officer_certificate.html", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-19, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Samuel Kim.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/08_production_logs/058_production_logs_executed_instrument.txt", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for email-family separation: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-LD-2705-D458, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-LD-2705-M958.", "id": "F-04", "issue": "email-family separation", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/02_orders/010_orders_executed_instrument.txt", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-19, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Maya Ellison.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/08_production_logs/061_production_logs_review_memorandum.json", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for privilege-log description defect: one source states the applicable location is District of Massachusetts, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to Massachusetts operations outside District of Massachusetts.", "id": "F-05", "issue": "privilege-log description defect", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/02_orders/013_orders_review_memorandum.json", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-19, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Rafael Okafor.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/08_production_logs/064_production_logs_status_report.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for common-interest support gap: one source states the threshold is 6% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 8% and produced a different exception result.", "id": "F-06", "issue": "common-interest support gap", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/02_orders/016_orders_status_report.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-19, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Nora Chen.", "severity": "low"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/09_depositions/067_depositions_correspondence.eml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for clawback deadline: one source states formal notice must use notices-elm_river_robotics@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-former_engineers_and_nacre_automation@example.test.", "id": "F-07", "issue": "clawback deadline", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/019_requests_responses_correspondence.eml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-19, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Dominic Alvarez.", "severity": "critical"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/09_depositions/070_depositions_formal_notice.xml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for protective-order designation error: one source states the governed population contains 163 records through 2025-04-28, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 66 records through 2025-06-05.", "id": "F-08", "issue": "protective-order designation error", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/022_requests_responses_formal_notice.xml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-19, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Priya Raman.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/10_expert_material/073_expert_material_control_register.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for request-response mismatch: one source states the operative date is 2025-10-02 under control reference CB-LD-2705-I612, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2025-11-01 under response reference CB-LD-2705-R693.", "id": "F-09", "issue": "request-response mismatch", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/025_custodian_files_control_register.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-19, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Elliot Mercer.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/10_expert_material/076_expert_material_ledger_export.csv", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for deposition exhibit omission: one source states the controlling amount is $1,923,735.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $2,053,970.00.", "id": "F-10", "issue": "deposition exhibit omission", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/028_custodian_files_ledger_export.csv", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-19, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Talia Brooks.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/10_expert_material/079_expert_material_officer_certificate.html", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for expert draft segregation: one source states approval is attributed to Amara Patel as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Elliot Mercer and contains no entry for Amara Patel.", "id": "F-11", "issue": "expert draft segregation", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/031_custodian_files_officer_certificate.html", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-19, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Jonas Feld.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/11_third_party/082_third_party_executed_instrument.txt", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for third-party subpoena deadline: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-LD-2705-L880, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-LD-2705-U298.", "id": "F-12", "issue": "third-party subpoena deadline", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/05_email_families/034_email_families_executed_instrument.txt", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-19, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Mei Whitaker.", "severity": "low"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/11_third_party/085_third_party_review_memorandum.json", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for production gap: one source states the applicable location is District of Massachusetts, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to Massachusetts operations outside District of Massachusetts.", "id": "F-13", "issue": "production gap", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/05_email_families/037_email_families_review_memorandum.json", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-19, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Caleb Hassan.", "severity": "critical"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/11_third_party/088_third_party_status_report.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for metadata field loss: one source states the threshold is 12% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 14% and produced a different exception result.", "id": "F-14", "issue": "metadata field loss", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/05_email_families/040_email_families_status_report.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-19, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Leona Park.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/12_case_management/091_case_management_correspondence.eml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for Bates-range overlap: one source states formal notice must use notices-elm_river_robotics@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-former_engineers_and_nacre_automation@example.test.", "id": "F-15", "issue": "Bates-range overlap", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/043_chat_exports_correspondence.eml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-19, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Isaac Romero.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/12_case_management/094_case_management_formal_notice.xml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for meet-and-confer commitment: one source states the governed population contains 120 records through 2025-08-03, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 49 records through 2025-08-24.", "id": "F-16", "issue": "meet-and-confer commitment", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/046_chat_exports_formal_notice.xml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-19, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Sofia Bennett.", "severity": "medium"}], "matter_number": "CB-LD-2705", "prepared_for": "Elm River Robotics", "schema_version": "1.0", "task_id": "cb100-035-elm-river"}}, "metadata": {"benchmark": "CounselBench-100", "code_license": "Apache-2.0", "data_license": "CC-BY-4.0", "deadline": "2026-09-19", "document_count": 96, "jurisdiction": "Massachusetts", "matter_number": "CB-LD-2705", "mcp_commit": "9a96ea6e5913736f92b88345bf51caeaaa8e719f", "mcp_package": "@modelcontextprotocol/server-filesystem@2026.7.10", "practice_area": "litigation-discovery", "reference_tool_calls": 46, "required_evidence_reads": 33, "synthetic": true, "venue": "District of Massachusetts", "version": "2.0.0"}, "prompt": "You are discovery counsel for Elm River Robotics. Outside counsel inherited this file after turnover on the client team and must validate every operative record before advising. The production mixes counsel-directed forensic reports with ordinary-course analyses and omits attachments from several high-value email families. Decision due 2026-09-19. Massachusetts law governs; District of Massachusetts is the forum. Evaluate both legal consequence and the practical owner needed to cure each exception. Work out the defensible position from the matter production and leave an audit-ready exception tracker and concise advice for the supervising lawyer. Keep confirmed conflicts separate from open questions, cite the records that actually control each conclusion, and do not fill gaps with outside facts.", "rubric": {"criteria": [{"category": "procedure", "description": "Complete at least 46 successful, argument-specific evidence and output calls.", "id": "procedure.minimum_successful_tool_calls"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Find and read the 33 controlling, corroborating, and work-product-control records in full.", "id": "procedure.all_evidence_read_in_full"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Inspect file metadata for the eight designated critical primary records before relying on them.", "id": "procedure.chain_of_custody_metadata_checked"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Confirm the sandbox's allowed document and output roots.", "id": "procedure.allowed_directories_checked"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Inventory all 96 records so the relevant sources are discovered among the context records.", "id": "procedure.recursive_inventory_completed"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Search the production for email evidence that may corroborate or contradict formal records.", "id": "procedure.targeted_search_completed"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Leave only findings.json and advice.md in the output workspace.", "id": "procedure.exact_deliverable_set"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Create both final work products through the sandbox MCP surface.", "id": "procedure.deliverables_written_through_mcp"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Produce findings.json as a valid JSON object.", "id": "findings.findings_is_object"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Report exactly 16 confirmed exceptions.", "id": "findings.findings_exact_count"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Use each stable finding ID exactly once.", "id": "findings.finding_ids_unique"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set schema_version to the released matter value '1.0'.", "id": "findings.top_level_schema_version"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set task_id to the released matter value 'cb100-035-elm-river'.", "id": "findings.top_level_task_id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set matter_number to the released matter value 'CB-LD-2705'.", "id": "findings.top_level_matter_number"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set prepared_for to the released matter value 'Elm River Robotics'.", "id": "findings.top_level_prepared_for"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set as_of to the released matter value '2026-09-19'.", "id": "findings.top_level_as_of"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-01 exception for custodian omission.", "id": "findings.F-01.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's id from /workspace/documents/01_pleadings/001_pleadings_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_privilege_material/049_privilege_material_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's issue from /workspace/documents/01_pleadings/001_pleadings_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_privilege_material/049_privilege_material_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's severity from /workspace/documents/01_pleadings/001_pleadings_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_privilege_material/049_privilege_material_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's primary_source from /workspace/documents/01_pleadings/001_pleadings_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_privilege_material/049_privilege_material_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/01_pleadings/001_pleadings_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_privilege_material/049_privilege_material_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-01 using the exact controlled facts ['2025-04-14', 'CB-LD-2705-A141', '2025-04-23', 'CB-LD-2705-J380'].", "id": "findings.F-01.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-01's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-01.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-19', 'Owen Delgado'] for F-01.", "id": "findings.F-01.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-02 exception for legal-hold delivery gap.", "id": "findings.F-02.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's id from /workspace/documents/01_pleadings/004_pleadings_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_privilege_material/052_privilege_material_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's issue from /workspace/documents/01_pleadings/004_pleadings_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_privilege_material/052_privilege_material_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's severity from /workspace/documents/01_pleadings/004_pleadings_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_privilege_material/052_privilege_material_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's primary_source from /workspace/documents/01_pleadings/004_pleadings_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_privilege_material/052_privilege_material_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/01_pleadings/004_pleadings_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_privilege_material/052_privilege_material_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-02 using the exact controlled facts ['$4,396,491.00', '$4,699,482.00'].", "id": "findings.F-02.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-02's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-02.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-19', 'Lena Varga'] for F-02.", "id": "findings.F-02.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-03 exception for collection-date inconsistency.", "id": "findings.F-03.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's id from /workspace/documents/01_pleadings/007_pleadings_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_privilege_material/055_privilege_material_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's issue from /workspace/documents/01_pleadings/007_pleadings_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_privilege_material/055_privilege_material_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's severity from /workspace/documents/01_pleadings/007_pleadings_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_privilege_material/055_privilege_material_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's primary_source from /workspace/documents/01_pleadings/007_pleadings_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_privilege_material/055_privilege_material_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/01_pleadings/007_pleadings_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_privilege_material/055_privilege_material_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-03 using the exact controlled facts ['Amara Patel', 'Adrian Mensah'].", "id": "findings.F-03.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-03's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-03.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-19', 'Samuel Kim'] for F-03.", "id": "findings.F-03.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-04 exception for email-family separation.", "id": "findings.F-04.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's id from /workspace/documents/02_orders/010_orders_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_production_logs/058_production_logs_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's issue from /workspace/documents/02_orders/010_orders_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_production_logs/058_production_logs_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's severity from /workspace/documents/02_orders/010_orders_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_production_logs/058_production_logs_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's primary_source from /workspace/documents/02_orders/010_orders_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_production_logs/058_production_logs_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/02_orders/010_orders_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_production_logs/058_production_logs_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-04 using the exact controlled facts ['closed without exception', 'CB-LD-2705-D458', 'open and escalated', 'CB-LD-2705-M958'].", "id": "findings.F-04.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-04's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-04.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-19', 'Maya Ellison'] for F-04.", "id": "findings.F-04.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-05 exception for privilege-log description defect.", "id": "findings.F-05.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's id from /workspace/documents/02_orders/013_orders_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_production_logs/061_production_logs_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's issue from /workspace/documents/02_orders/013_orders_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_production_logs/061_production_logs_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's severity from /workspace/documents/02_orders/013_orders_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_production_logs/061_production_logs_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's primary_source from /workspace/documents/02_orders/013_orders_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_production_logs/061_production_logs_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/02_orders/013_orders_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_production_logs/061_production_logs_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-05 using the exact controlled facts ['District of Massachusetts', 'Massachusetts'].", "id": "findings.F-05.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-05's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-05.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-19', 'Rafael Okafor'] for F-05.", "id": "findings.F-05.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-06 exception for common-interest support gap.", "id": "findings.F-06.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's id from /workspace/documents/02_orders/016_orders_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_production_logs/064_production_logs_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's issue from /workspace/documents/02_orders/016_orders_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_production_logs/064_production_logs_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's severity from /workspace/documents/02_orders/016_orders_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_production_logs/064_production_logs_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's primary_source from /workspace/documents/02_orders/016_orders_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_production_logs/064_production_logs_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/02_orders/016_orders_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_production_logs/064_production_logs_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-06 using the exact controlled facts ['6%', '8%'].", "id": "findings.F-06.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-06's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-06.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-19', 'Nora Chen'] for F-06.", "id": "findings.F-06.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-07 exception for clawback deadline.", "id": "findings.F-07.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's id from /workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/019_requests_responses_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_depositions/067_depositions_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's issue from /workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/019_requests_responses_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_depositions/067_depositions_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's severity from /workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/019_requests_responses_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_depositions/067_depositions_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's primary_source from /workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/019_requests_responses_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_depositions/067_depositions_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/019_requests_responses_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_depositions/067_depositions_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-07 using the exact controlled facts ['notices-elm_river_robotics@example.test', 'archive-former_engineers_and_nacre_automation@example.test'].", "id": "findings.F-07.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-07's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-07.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-19', 'Dominic Alvarez'] for F-07.", "id": "findings.F-07.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-08 exception for protective-order designation error.", "id": "findings.F-08.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's id from /workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/022_requests_responses_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_depositions/070_depositions_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's issue from /workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/022_requests_responses_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_depositions/070_depositions_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's severity from /workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/022_requests_responses_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_depositions/070_depositions_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's primary_source from /workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/022_requests_responses_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_depositions/070_depositions_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/022_requests_responses_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_depositions/070_depositions_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-08 using the exact controlled facts ['163 records', '2025-04-28', '66 records', '2025-06-05'].", "id": "findings.F-08.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-08's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-08.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-19', 'Priya Raman'] for F-08.", "id": "findings.F-08.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-09 exception for request-response mismatch.", "id": "findings.F-09.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's id from /workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/025_custodian_files_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_expert_material/073_expert_material_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's issue from /workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/025_custodian_files_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_expert_material/073_expert_material_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's severity from /workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/025_custodian_files_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_expert_material/073_expert_material_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's primary_source from /workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/025_custodian_files_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_expert_material/073_expert_material_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/025_custodian_files_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_expert_material/073_expert_material_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-09 using the exact controlled facts ['2025-10-02', 'CB-LD-2705-I612', '2025-11-01', 'CB-LD-2705-R693'].", "id": "findings.F-09.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-09's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-09.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-19', 'Elliot Mercer'] for F-09.", "id": "findings.F-09.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-10 exception for deposition exhibit omission.", "id": "findings.F-10.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's id from /workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/028_custodian_files_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_expert_material/076_expert_material_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's issue from /workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/028_custodian_files_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_expert_material/076_expert_material_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's severity from /workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/028_custodian_files_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_expert_material/076_expert_material_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's primary_source from /workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/028_custodian_files_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_expert_material/076_expert_material_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/028_custodian_files_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_expert_material/076_expert_material_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-10 using the exact controlled facts ['$1,923,735.00', '$2,053,970.00'].", "id": "findings.F-10.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-10's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-10.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-19', 'Talia Brooks'] for F-10.", "id": "findings.F-10.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-11 exception for expert draft segregation.", "id": "findings.F-11.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's id from /workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/031_custodian_files_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_expert_material/079_expert_material_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's issue from /workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/031_custodian_files_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_expert_material/079_expert_material_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's severity from /workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/031_custodian_files_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_expert_material/079_expert_material_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's primary_source from /workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/031_custodian_files_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_expert_material/079_expert_material_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/031_custodian_files_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_expert_material/079_expert_material_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-11 using the exact controlled facts ['Amara Patel', 'Elliot Mercer'].", "id": "findings.F-11.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-11's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-11.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-19', 'Jonas Feld'] for F-11.", "id": "findings.F-11.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-12 exception for third-party subpoena deadline.", "id": "findings.F-12.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's id from /workspace/documents/05_email_families/034_email_families_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_third_party/082_third_party_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's issue from /workspace/documents/05_email_families/034_email_families_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_third_party/082_third_party_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's severity from /workspace/documents/05_email_families/034_email_families_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_third_party/082_third_party_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's primary_source from /workspace/documents/05_email_families/034_email_families_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_third_party/082_third_party_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/05_email_families/034_email_families_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_third_party/082_third_party_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-12 using the exact controlled facts ['closed without exception', 'CB-LD-2705-L880', 'open and escalated', 'CB-LD-2705-U298'].", "id": "findings.F-12.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-12's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-12.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-19', 'Mei Whitaker'] for F-12.", "id": "findings.F-12.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-13 exception for production gap.", "id": "findings.F-13.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's id from /workspace/documents/05_email_families/037_email_families_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_third_party/085_third_party_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's issue from /workspace/documents/05_email_families/037_email_families_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_third_party/085_third_party_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's severity from /workspace/documents/05_email_families/037_email_families_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_third_party/085_third_party_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's primary_source from /workspace/documents/05_email_families/037_email_families_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_third_party/085_third_party_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/05_email_families/037_email_families_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_third_party/085_third_party_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-13 using the exact controlled facts ['District of Massachusetts', 'Massachusetts'].", "id": "findings.F-13.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-13's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-13.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-19', 'Caleb Hassan'] for F-13.", "id": "findings.F-13.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-14 exception for metadata field loss.", "id": "findings.F-14.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's id from /workspace/documents/05_email_families/040_email_families_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_third_party/088_third_party_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's issue from /workspace/documents/05_email_families/040_email_families_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_third_party/088_third_party_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's severity from /workspace/documents/05_email_families/040_email_families_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_third_party/088_third_party_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's primary_source from /workspace/documents/05_email_families/040_email_families_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_third_party/088_third_party_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/05_email_families/040_email_families_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_third_party/088_third_party_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-14 using the exact controlled facts ['12%', '14%'].", "id": "findings.F-14.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-14's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-14.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-19', 'Leona Park'] for F-14.", "id": "findings.F-14.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-15 exception for Bates-range overlap.", "id": "findings.F-15.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's id from /workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/043_chat_exports_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_case_management/091_case_management_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's issue from /workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/043_chat_exports_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_case_management/091_case_management_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's severity from /workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/043_chat_exports_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_case_management/091_case_management_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's primary_source from /workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/043_chat_exports_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_case_management/091_case_management_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/043_chat_exports_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_case_management/091_case_management_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-15 using the exact controlled facts ['notices-elm_river_robotics@example.test', 'archive-former_engineers_and_nacre_automation@example.test'].", "id": "findings.F-15.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-15's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-15.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-19', 'Isaac Romero'] for F-15.", "id": "findings.F-15.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-16 exception for meet-and-confer commitment.", "id": "findings.F-16.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's id from /workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/046_chat_exports_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_case_management/094_case_management_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's issue from /workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/046_chat_exports_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_case_management/094_case_management_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's severity from /workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/046_chat_exports_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_case_management/094_case_management_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's primary_source from /workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/046_chat_exports_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_case_management/094_case_management_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/046_chat_exports_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_case_management/094_case_management_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-16 using the exact controlled facts ['120 records', '2025-08-03', '49 records', '2025-08-24'].", "id": "findings.F-16.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-16's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-16.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-19', 'Sofia Bennett'] for F-16.", "id": "findings.F-16.action_anchors"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Executive assessment' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Executive assessment"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Method and record coverage' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Method and record coverage"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Findings' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Findings"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Recommended next actions' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Recommended next actions"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Assumptions and limitations' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Assumptions and limitations"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-01 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-01"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-02 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-02"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-03 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-03"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-04 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-04"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-05 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-05"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-06 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-06"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-07 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-07"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-08 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-08"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-09 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-09"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-10 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-10"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-11 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-11"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-12 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-12"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-13 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-13"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-14 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-14"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-15 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-15"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-16 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-16"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Do not claim the production has no issues or that every record is consistent.", "id": "memo.forbidden_claims_absent"}], "decision_options": [{"id": "cross-source-reconciliation", "label": "Reconcile controlling and corroborating records", "reason": "The CB-LD-2705 production contains independently maintained records; a defensible answer must preserve each supported conflict and its cure owner.", "selected": true}, {"id": "latest-record-controls", "label": "Treat the latest record as controlling", "reason": "Timestamp recency does not establish legal priority, execution, or approval authority.", "selected": false}, {"id": "primary-records-only", "label": "Report primary records without reconciliation", "reason": "Primary records alone conceal the operational conflicts that create the actionable exceptions.", "selected": false}], "gates": ["all_evidence_read_in_full", "chain_of_custody_metadata_checked", "findings_criteria_complete", "memo_criteria_complete", "deliverables_written_through_mcp"], "metadata_checks": 8, "metric": "weighted_criteria_score", "minimum_tool_calls": 46, "required_deliverables": ["findings.json", "advice.md"], "required_document_reads": 33, "type": "deterministic", "weights": {"findings": 0.55, "memo": 0.2, "procedure": 0.25}}, "task_id": "cb100-035-elm-river", "task_name": "Elm River trade-secret privilege audit", "world_id": "counselbench-filesystem-mcp-v2"}
-{"context_files": ["task_files/cb100-036-federal-basin/01_pleadings/001_pleadings_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-036-federal-basin/01_pleadings/002_pleadings_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-036-federal-basin/01_pleadings/003_pleadings_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-036-federal-basin/01_pleadings/004_pleadings_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-036-federal-basin/01_pleadings/005_pleadings_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-036-federal-basin/01_pleadings/006_pleadings_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-036-federal-basin/01_pleadings/007_pleadings_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-036-federal-basin/01_pleadings/008_pleadings_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-036-federal-basin/02_orders/009_orders_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-036-federal-basin/02_orders/010_orders_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-036-federal-basin/02_orders/011_orders_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-036-federal-basin/02_orders/012_orders_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-036-federal-basin/02_orders/013_orders_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-036-federal-basin/02_orders/014_orders_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-036-federal-basin/02_orders/015_orders_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-036-federal-basin/02_orders/016_orders_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-036-federal-basin/03_requests_responses/017_requests_responses_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-036-federal-basin/03_requests_responses/018_requests_responses_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-036-federal-basin/03_requests_responses/019_requests_responses_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-036-federal-basin/03_requests_responses/020_requests_responses_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-036-federal-basin/03_requests_responses/021_requests_responses_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-036-federal-basin/03_requests_responses/022_requests_responses_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-036-federal-basin/03_requests_responses/023_requests_responses_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-036-federal-basin/03_requests_responses/024_requests_responses_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-036-federal-basin/04_custodian_files/025_custodian_files_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-036-federal-basin/04_custodian_files/026_custodian_files_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-036-federal-basin/04_custodian_files/027_custodian_files_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-036-federal-basin/04_custodian_files/028_custodian_files_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-036-federal-basin/04_custodian_files/029_custodian_files_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-036-federal-basin/04_custodian_files/030_custodian_files_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-036-federal-basin/04_custodian_files/031_custodian_files_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-036-federal-basin/04_custodian_files/032_custodian_files_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-036-federal-basin/05_email_families/033_email_families_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-036-federal-basin/05_email_families/034_email_families_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-036-federal-basin/05_email_families/035_email_families_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-036-federal-basin/05_email_families/036_email_families_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-036-federal-basin/05_email_families/037_email_families_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-036-federal-basin/05_email_families/038_email_families_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-036-federal-basin/05_email_families/039_email_families_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-036-federal-basin/05_email_families/040_email_families_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-036-federal-basin/06_chat_exports/041_chat_exports_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-036-federal-basin/06_chat_exports/042_chat_exports_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-036-federal-basin/06_chat_exports/043_chat_exports_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-036-federal-basin/06_chat_exports/044_chat_exports_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-036-federal-basin/06_chat_exports/045_chat_exports_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-036-federal-basin/06_chat_exports/046_chat_exports_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-036-federal-basin/06_chat_exports/047_chat_exports_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-036-federal-basin/06_chat_exports/048_chat_exports_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-036-federal-basin/07_privilege_material/049_privilege_material_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-036-federal-basin/07_privilege_material/050_privilege_material_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-036-federal-basin/07_privilege_material/051_privilege_material_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-036-federal-basin/07_privilege_material/052_privilege_material_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-036-federal-basin/07_privilege_material/053_privilege_material_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-036-federal-basin/07_privilege_material/054_privilege_material_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-036-federal-basin/07_privilege_material/055_privilege_material_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-036-federal-basin/07_privilege_material/056_privilege_material_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-036-federal-basin/08_production_logs/057_production_logs_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-036-federal-basin/08_production_logs/058_production_logs_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-036-federal-basin/08_production_logs/059_production_logs_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-036-federal-basin/08_production_logs/060_production_logs_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-036-federal-basin/08_production_logs/061_production_logs_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-036-federal-basin/08_production_logs/062_production_logs_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-036-federal-basin/08_production_logs/063_production_logs_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-036-federal-basin/08_production_logs/064_production_logs_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-036-federal-basin/09_depositions/065_depositions_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-036-federal-basin/09_depositions/066_depositions_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-036-federal-basin/09_depositions/067_depositions_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-036-federal-basin/09_depositions/068_depositions_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-036-federal-basin/09_depositions/069_depositions_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-036-federal-basin/09_depositions/070_depositions_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-036-federal-basin/09_depositions/071_depositions_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-036-federal-basin/09_depositions/072_depositions_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-036-federal-basin/10_expert_material/073_expert_material_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-036-federal-basin/10_expert_material/074_expert_material_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-036-federal-basin/10_expert_material/075_expert_material_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-036-federal-basin/10_expert_material/076_expert_material_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-036-federal-basin/10_expert_material/077_expert_material_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-036-federal-basin/10_expert_material/078_expert_material_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-036-federal-basin/10_expert_material/079_expert_material_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-036-federal-basin/10_expert_material/080_expert_material_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-036-federal-basin/11_third_party/081_third_party_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-036-federal-basin/11_third_party/082_third_party_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-036-federal-basin/11_third_party/083_third_party_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-036-federal-basin/11_third_party/084_third_party_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-036-federal-basin/11_third_party/085_third_party_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-036-federal-basin/11_third_party/086_third_party_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-036-federal-basin/11_third_party/087_third_party_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-036-federal-basin/11_third_party/088_third_party_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-036-federal-basin/12_case_management/089_case_management_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-036-federal-basin/12_case_management/090_case_management_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-036-federal-basin/12_case_management/091_case_management_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-036-federal-basin/12_case_management/092_case_management_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-036-federal-basin/12_case_management/093_case_management_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-036-federal-basin/12_case_management/094_case_management_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-036-federal-basin/12_case_management/095_case_management_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-036-federal-basin/12_case_management/096_case_management_status_report.md"], "gold_output": {"advice_markdown": "# Counsel advice — Federal Basin royalty dispute production\n\n## Executive assessment\n\nFor Federal Basin Resources matter CB-LD-2706, the review identified 16 source-supported exceptions requiring action before 2026-09-23. The assessment concerns Osage Crest Minerals LLC and the supplied record for Oklahoma.\n\n## Method and record coverage\n\nThe review inventoried all 96 production files, read the 33 controlling, corroborating, and control records, searched the email exports, and checked metadata for the designated chain-of-custody sample. Conclusions are limited to the synthetic production supplied for this benchmark matter.\n\n## Findings\n\n### F-01 — custodian omission (critical)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for custodian omission: one source states the operative date is 2025-05-15 under control reference CB-LD-2706-A532, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2025-06-25 under response reference CB-LD-2706-J825.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/01_pleadings/001_pleadings_control_register.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/07_privilege_material/049_privilege_material_control_register.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-23, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Lena Varga.\n\n### F-02 — legal-hold delivery gap (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for legal-hold delivery gap: one source states the controlling amount is $2,524,550.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $2,745,600.00.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/01_pleadings/004_pleadings_ledger_export.csv`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/07_privilege_material/052_privilege_material_ledger_export.csv`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-23, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Samuel Kim.\n\n### F-03 — collection-date inconsistency (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for collection-date inconsistency: one source states approval is attributed to Henry Cho as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Theo Laurent and contains no entry for Henry Cho.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/01_pleadings/007_pleadings_officer_certificate.html`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/07_privilege_material/055_privilege_material_officer_certificate.html`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-23, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Maya Ellison.\n\n### F-04 — email-family separation (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for email-family separation: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-LD-2706-D180, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-LD-2706-M521.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/02_orders/010_orders_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/08_production_logs/058_production_logs_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-23, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Rafael Okafor.\n\n### F-05 — privilege-log description defect (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for privilege-log description defect: one source states the applicable location is Western District of Oklahoma, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to Oklahoma operations outside Western District of Oklahoma.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/02_orders/013_orders_review_memorandum.json`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/08_production_logs/061_production_logs_review_memorandum.json`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-23, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Nora Chen.\n\n### F-06 — common-interest support gap (low)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for common-interest support gap: one source states the threshold is 13% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 20% and produced a different exception result.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/02_orders/016_orders_status_report.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/08_production_logs/064_production_logs_status_report.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-23, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Dominic Alvarez.\n\n### F-07 — clawback deadline (critical)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for clawback deadline: one source states formal notice must use notices-federal_basin_resources@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-osage_crest_minerals_llc@example.test.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/019_requests_responses_correspondence.eml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/09_depositions/067_depositions_correspondence.eml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-23, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Priya Raman.\n\n### F-08 — protective-order designation error (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for protective-order designation error: one source states the governed population contains 51 records through 2025-10-13, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 56 records through 2025-11-10.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/022_requests_responses_formal_notice.xml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/09_depositions/070_depositions_formal_notice.xml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-23, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Elliot Mercer.\n\n### F-09 — request-response mismatch (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for request-response mismatch: one source states the operative date is 2025-12-09 under control reference CB-LD-2706-I140, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2025-12-26 under response reference CB-LD-2706-R241.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/025_custodian_files_control_register.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/10_expert_material/073_expert_material_control_register.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-23, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Talia Brooks.\n\n### F-10 — deposition exhibit omission (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for deposition exhibit omission: one source states the controlling amount is $4,428,127.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $4,522,754.00.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/028_custodian_files_ledger_export.csv`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/10_expert_material/076_expert_material_ledger_export.csv`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-23, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Jonas Feld.\n\n### F-11 — expert draft segregation (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for expert draft segregation: one source states approval is attributed to Henry Cho as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Jonas Feld and contains no entry for Henry Cho.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/031_custodian_files_officer_certificate.html`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/10_expert_material/079_expert_material_officer_certificate.html`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-23, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Mei Whitaker.\n\n### F-12 — third-party subpoena deadline (low)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for third-party subpoena deadline: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-LD-2706-L370, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-LD-2706-U397.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/05_email_families/034_email_families_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/11_third_party/082_third_party_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-23, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Caleb Hassan.\n\n### F-13 — production gap (critical)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for production gap: one source states the applicable location is Western District of Oklahoma, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to Oklahoma operations outside Western District of Oklahoma.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/05_email_families/037_email_families_review_memorandum.json`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/11_third_party/085_third_party_review_memorandum.json`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-23, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Leona Park.\n\n### F-14 — metadata field loss (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for metadata field loss: one source states the threshold is 3% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 10% and produced a different exception result.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/05_email_families/040_email_families_status_report.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/11_third_party/088_third_party_status_report.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-23, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Isaac Romero.\n\n### F-15 — Bates-range overlap (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for Bates-range overlap: one source states formal notice must use notices-federal_basin_resources@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-osage_crest_minerals_llc@example.test.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/043_chat_exports_correspondence.eml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/12_case_management/091_case_management_correspondence.eml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-23, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Sofia Bennett.\n\n### F-16 — meet-and-confer commitment (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for meet-and-confer commitment: one source states the governed population contains 51 records through 2025-01-06, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 75 records through 2025-02-22.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/046_chat_exports_formal_notice.xml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/12_case_management/094_case_management_formal_notice.xml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-23, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Adrian Mensah.\n\n## Recommended next actions\n\nSequence the critical and high findings first, assign the named owners, preserve the cited records, and document any resolution in the controlling matter register before the stated deadline.\n\n## Assumptions and limitations\n\nThis analysis is confined to task cb100-036-federal-basin and the supplied synthetic evidence. It does not rely on external facts, does not resolve disputed law, and is not legal advice for a real person or entity.\n", "findings": {"as_of": "2026-09-23", "findings": [{"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/07_privilege_material/049_privilege_material_control_register.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for custodian omission: one source states the operative date is 2025-05-15 under control reference CB-LD-2706-A532, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2025-06-25 under response reference CB-LD-2706-J825.", "id": "F-01", "issue": "custodian omission", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/01_pleadings/001_pleadings_control_register.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-23, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Lena Varga.", "severity": "critical"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/07_privilege_material/052_privilege_material_ledger_export.csv", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for legal-hold delivery gap: one source states the controlling amount is $2,524,550.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $2,745,600.00.", "id": "F-02", "issue": "legal-hold delivery gap", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/01_pleadings/004_pleadings_ledger_export.csv", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-23, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Samuel Kim.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/07_privilege_material/055_privilege_material_officer_certificate.html", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for collection-date inconsistency: one source states approval is attributed to Henry Cho as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Theo Laurent and contains no entry for Henry Cho.", "id": "F-03", "issue": "collection-date inconsistency", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/01_pleadings/007_pleadings_officer_certificate.html", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-23, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Maya Ellison.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/08_production_logs/058_production_logs_executed_instrument.txt", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for email-family separation: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-LD-2706-D180, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-LD-2706-M521.", "id": "F-04", "issue": "email-family separation", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/02_orders/010_orders_executed_instrument.txt", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-23, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Rafael Okafor.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/08_production_logs/061_production_logs_review_memorandum.json", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for privilege-log description defect: one source states the applicable location is Western District of Oklahoma, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to Oklahoma operations outside Western District of Oklahoma.", "id": "F-05", "issue": "privilege-log description defect", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/02_orders/013_orders_review_memorandum.json", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-23, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Nora Chen.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/08_production_logs/064_production_logs_status_report.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for common-interest support gap: one source states the threshold is 13% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 20% and produced a different exception result.", "id": "F-06", "issue": "common-interest support gap", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/02_orders/016_orders_status_report.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-23, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Dominic Alvarez.", "severity": "low"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/09_depositions/067_depositions_correspondence.eml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for clawback deadline: one source states formal notice must use notices-federal_basin_resources@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-osage_crest_minerals_llc@example.test.", "id": "F-07", "issue": "clawback deadline", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/019_requests_responses_correspondence.eml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-23, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Priya Raman.", "severity": "critical"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/09_depositions/070_depositions_formal_notice.xml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for protective-order designation error: one source states the governed population contains 51 records through 2025-10-13, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 56 records through 2025-11-10.", "id": "F-08", "issue": "protective-order designation error", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/022_requests_responses_formal_notice.xml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-23, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Elliot Mercer.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/10_expert_material/073_expert_material_control_register.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for request-response mismatch: one source states the operative date is 2025-12-09 under control reference CB-LD-2706-I140, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2025-12-26 under response reference CB-LD-2706-R241.", "id": "F-09", "issue": "request-response mismatch", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/025_custodian_files_control_register.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-23, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Talia Brooks.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/10_expert_material/076_expert_material_ledger_export.csv", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for deposition exhibit omission: one source states the controlling amount is $4,428,127.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $4,522,754.00.", "id": "F-10", "issue": "deposition exhibit omission", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/028_custodian_files_ledger_export.csv", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-23, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Jonas Feld.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/10_expert_material/079_expert_material_officer_certificate.html", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for expert draft segregation: one source states approval is attributed to Henry Cho as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Jonas Feld and contains no entry for Henry Cho.", "id": "F-11", "issue": "expert draft segregation", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/031_custodian_files_officer_certificate.html", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-23, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Mei Whitaker.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/11_third_party/082_third_party_executed_instrument.txt", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for third-party subpoena deadline: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-LD-2706-L370, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-LD-2706-U397.", "id": "F-12", "issue": "third-party subpoena deadline", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/05_email_families/034_email_families_executed_instrument.txt", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-23, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Caleb Hassan.", "severity": "low"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/11_third_party/085_third_party_review_memorandum.json", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for production gap: one source states the applicable location is Western District of Oklahoma, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to Oklahoma operations outside Western District of Oklahoma.", "id": "F-13", "issue": "production gap", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/05_email_families/037_email_families_review_memorandum.json", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-23, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Leona Park.", "severity": "critical"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/11_third_party/088_third_party_status_report.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for metadata field loss: one source states the threshold is 3% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 10% and produced a different exception result.", "id": "F-14", "issue": "metadata field loss", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/05_email_families/040_email_families_status_report.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-23, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Isaac Romero.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/12_case_management/091_case_management_correspondence.eml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for Bates-range overlap: one source states formal notice must use notices-federal_basin_resources@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-osage_crest_minerals_llc@example.test.", "id": "F-15", "issue": "Bates-range overlap", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/043_chat_exports_correspondence.eml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-23, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Sofia Bennett.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/12_case_management/094_case_management_formal_notice.xml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for meet-and-confer commitment: one source states the governed population contains 51 records through 2025-01-06, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 75 records through 2025-02-22.", "id": "F-16", "issue": "meet-and-confer commitment", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/046_chat_exports_formal_notice.xml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-23, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Adrian Mensah.", "severity": "medium"}], "matter_number": "CB-LD-2706", "prepared_for": "Federal Basin Resources", "schema_version": "1.0", "task_id": "cb100-036-federal-basin"}}, "metadata": {"benchmark": "CounselBench-100", "code_license": "Apache-2.0", "data_license": "CC-BY-4.0", "deadline": "2026-09-23", "document_count": 96, "jurisdiction": "Oklahoma", "matter_number": "CB-LD-2706", "mcp_commit": "9a96ea6e5913736f92b88345bf51caeaaa8e719f", "mcp_package": "@modelcontextprotocol/server-filesystem@2026.7.10", "practice_area": "litigation-discovery", "reference_tool_calls": 46, "required_evidence_reads": 33, "synthetic": true, "venue": "Western District of Oklahoma", "version": "2.0.0"}, "prompt": "You are discovery counsel for Federal Basin Resources. The upcoming deadline leaves no room for unsupported assumptions, so every conclusion must trace to the supplied production. Lease-accounting exports, title opinions, and executive messages must be mapped to document requests before a court-ordered certification. Decision due 2026-09-23. Oklahoma law governs; Western District of Oklahoma is the forum. Give controlling documents precedence only when the record supports that hierarchy. Work out the defensible position from the matter production and leave an audit-ready exception tracker and concise advice for the supervising lawyer. Keep confirmed conflicts separate from open questions, cite the records that actually control each conclusion, and do not fill gaps with outside facts.", "rubric": {"criteria": [{"category": "procedure", "description": "Complete at least 46 successful, argument-specific evidence and output calls.", "id": "procedure.minimum_successful_tool_calls"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Find and read the 33 controlling, corroborating, and work-product-control records in full.", "id": "procedure.all_evidence_read_in_full"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Inspect file metadata for the eight designated critical primary records before relying on them.", "id": "procedure.chain_of_custody_metadata_checked"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Confirm the sandbox's allowed document and output roots.", "id": "procedure.allowed_directories_checked"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Inventory all 96 records so the relevant sources are discovered among the context records.", "id": "procedure.recursive_inventory_completed"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Search the production for email evidence that may corroborate or contradict formal records.", "id": "procedure.targeted_search_completed"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Leave only findings.json and advice.md in the output workspace.", "id": "procedure.exact_deliverable_set"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Create both final work products through the sandbox MCP surface.", "id": "procedure.deliverables_written_through_mcp"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Produce findings.json as a valid JSON object.", "id": "findings.findings_is_object"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Report exactly 16 confirmed exceptions.", "id": "findings.findings_exact_count"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Use each stable finding ID exactly once.", "id": "findings.finding_ids_unique"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set schema_version to the released matter value '1.0'.", "id": "findings.top_level_schema_version"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set task_id to the released matter value 'cb100-036-federal-basin'.", "id": "findings.top_level_task_id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set matter_number to the released matter value 'CB-LD-2706'.", "id": "findings.top_level_matter_number"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set prepared_for to the released matter value 'Federal Basin Resources'.", "id": "findings.top_level_prepared_for"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set as_of to the released matter value '2026-09-23'.", "id": "findings.top_level_as_of"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-01 exception for custodian omission.", "id": "findings.F-01.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's id from /workspace/documents/01_pleadings/001_pleadings_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_privilege_material/049_privilege_material_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's issue from /workspace/documents/01_pleadings/001_pleadings_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_privilege_material/049_privilege_material_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's severity from /workspace/documents/01_pleadings/001_pleadings_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_privilege_material/049_privilege_material_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's primary_source from /workspace/documents/01_pleadings/001_pleadings_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_privilege_material/049_privilege_material_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/01_pleadings/001_pleadings_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_privilege_material/049_privilege_material_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-01 using the exact controlled facts ['2025-05-15', 'CB-LD-2706-A532', '2025-06-25', 'CB-LD-2706-J825'].", "id": "findings.F-01.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-01's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-01.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-23', 'Lena Varga'] for F-01.", "id": "findings.F-01.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-02 exception for legal-hold delivery gap.", "id": "findings.F-02.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's id from /workspace/documents/01_pleadings/004_pleadings_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_privilege_material/052_privilege_material_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's issue from /workspace/documents/01_pleadings/004_pleadings_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_privilege_material/052_privilege_material_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's severity from /workspace/documents/01_pleadings/004_pleadings_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_privilege_material/052_privilege_material_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's primary_source from /workspace/documents/01_pleadings/004_pleadings_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_privilege_material/052_privilege_material_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/01_pleadings/004_pleadings_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_privilege_material/052_privilege_material_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-02 using the exact controlled facts ['$2,524,550.00', '$2,745,600.00'].", "id": "findings.F-02.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-02's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-02.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-23', 'Samuel Kim'] for F-02.", "id": "findings.F-02.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-03 exception for collection-date inconsistency.", "id": "findings.F-03.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's id from /workspace/documents/01_pleadings/007_pleadings_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_privilege_material/055_privilege_material_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's issue from /workspace/documents/01_pleadings/007_pleadings_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_privilege_material/055_privilege_material_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's severity from /workspace/documents/01_pleadings/007_pleadings_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_privilege_material/055_privilege_material_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's primary_source from /workspace/documents/01_pleadings/007_pleadings_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_privilege_material/055_privilege_material_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/01_pleadings/007_pleadings_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_privilege_material/055_privilege_material_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-03 using the exact controlled facts ['Henry Cho', 'Theo Laurent'].", "id": "findings.F-03.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-03's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-03.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-23', 'Maya Ellison'] for F-03.", "id": "findings.F-03.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-04 exception for email-family separation.", "id": "findings.F-04.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's id from /workspace/documents/02_orders/010_orders_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_production_logs/058_production_logs_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's issue from /workspace/documents/02_orders/010_orders_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_production_logs/058_production_logs_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's severity from /workspace/documents/02_orders/010_orders_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_production_logs/058_production_logs_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's primary_source from /workspace/documents/02_orders/010_orders_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_production_logs/058_production_logs_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/02_orders/010_orders_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_production_logs/058_production_logs_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-04 using the exact controlled facts ['closed without exception', 'CB-LD-2706-D180', 'open and escalated', 'CB-LD-2706-M521'].", "id": "findings.F-04.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-04's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-04.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-23', 'Rafael Okafor'] for F-04.", "id": "findings.F-04.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-05 exception for privilege-log description defect.", "id": "findings.F-05.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's id from /workspace/documents/02_orders/013_orders_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_production_logs/061_production_logs_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's issue from /workspace/documents/02_orders/013_orders_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_production_logs/061_production_logs_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's severity from /workspace/documents/02_orders/013_orders_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_production_logs/061_production_logs_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's primary_source from /workspace/documents/02_orders/013_orders_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_production_logs/061_production_logs_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/02_orders/013_orders_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_production_logs/061_production_logs_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-05 using the exact controlled facts ['Western District of Oklahoma', 'Oklahoma'].", "id": "findings.F-05.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-05's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-05.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-23', 'Nora Chen'] for F-05.", "id": "findings.F-05.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-06 exception for common-interest support gap.", "id": "findings.F-06.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's id from /workspace/documents/02_orders/016_orders_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_production_logs/064_production_logs_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's issue from /workspace/documents/02_orders/016_orders_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_production_logs/064_production_logs_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's severity from /workspace/documents/02_orders/016_orders_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_production_logs/064_production_logs_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's primary_source from /workspace/documents/02_orders/016_orders_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_production_logs/064_production_logs_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/02_orders/016_orders_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_production_logs/064_production_logs_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-06 using the exact controlled facts ['13%', '20%'].", "id": "findings.F-06.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-06's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-06.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-23', 'Dominic Alvarez'] for F-06.", "id": "findings.F-06.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-07 exception for clawback deadline.", "id": "findings.F-07.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's id from /workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/019_requests_responses_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_depositions/067_depositions_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's issue from /workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/019_requests_responses_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_depositions/067_depositions_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's severity from /workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/019_requests_responses_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_depositions/067_depositions_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's primary_source from /workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/019_requests_responses_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_depositions/067_depositions_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/019_requests_responses_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_depositions/067_depositions_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-07 using the exact controlled facts ['notices-federal_basin_resources@example.test', 'archive-osage_crest_minerals_llc@example.test'].", "id": "findings.F-07.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-07's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-07.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-23', 'Priya Raman'] for F-07.", "id": "findings.F-07.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-08 exception for protective-order designation error.", "id": "findings.F-08.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's id from /workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/022_requests_responses_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_depositions/070_depositions_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's issue from /workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/022_requests_responses_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_depositions/070_depositions_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's severity from /workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/022_requests_responses_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_depositions/070_depositions_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's primary_source from /workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/022_requests_responses_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_depositions/070_depositions_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/022_requests_responses_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_depositions/070_depositions_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-08 using the exact controlled facts ['51 records', '2025-10-13', '56 records', '2025-11-10'].", "id": "findings.F-08.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-08's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-08.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-23', 'Elliot Mercer'] for F-08.", "id": "findings.F-08.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-09 exception for request-response mismatch.", "id": "findings.F-09.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's id from /workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/025_custodian_files_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_expert_material/073_expert_material_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's issue from /workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/025_custodian_files_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_expert_material/073_expert_material_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's severity from /workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/025_custodian_files_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_expert_material/073_expert_material_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's primary_source from /workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/025_custodian_files_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_expert_material/073_expert_material_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/025_custodian_files_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_expert_material/073_expert_material_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-09 using the exact controlled facts ['2025-12-09', 'CB-LD-2706-I140', '2025-12-26', 'CB-LD-2706-R241'].", "id": "findings.F-09.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-09's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-09.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-23', 'Talia Brooks'] for F-09.", "id": "findings.F-09.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-10 exception for deposition exhibit omission.", "id": "findings.F-10.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's id from /workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/028_custodian_files_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_expert_material/076_expert_material_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's issue from /workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/028_custodian_files_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_expert_material/076_expert_material_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's severity from /workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/028_custodian_files_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_expert_material/076_expert_material_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's primary_source from /workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/028_custodian_files_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_expert_material/076_expert_material_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/028_custodian_files_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_expert_material/076_expert_material_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-10 using the exact controlled facts ['$4,428,127.00', '$4,522,754.00'].", "id": "findings.F-10.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-10's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-10.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-23', 'Jonas Feld'] for F-10.", "id": "findings.F-10.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-11 exception for expert draft segregation.", "id": "findings.F-11.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's id from /workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/031_custodian_files_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_expert_material/079_expert_material_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's issue from /workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/031_custodian_files_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_expert_material/079_expert_material_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's severity from /workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/031_custodian_files_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_expert_material/079_expert_material_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's primary_source from /workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/031_custodian_files_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_expert_material/079_expert_material_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/031_custodian_files_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_expert_material/079_expert_material_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-11 using the exact controlled facts ['Henry Cho', 'Jonas Feld'].", "id": "findings.F-11.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-11's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-11.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-23', 'Mei Whitaker'] for F-11.", "id": "findings.F-11.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-12 exception for third-party subpoena deadline.", "id": "findings.F-12.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's id from /workspace/documents/05_email_families/034_email_families_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_third_party/082_third_party_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's issue from /workspace/documents/05_email_families/034_email_families_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_third_party/082_third_party_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's severity from /workspace/documents/05_email_families/034_email_families_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_third_party/082_third_party_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's primary_source from /workspace/documents/05_email_families/034_email_families_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_third_party/082_third_party_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/05_email_families/034_email_families_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_third_party/082_third_party_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-12 using the exact controlled facts ['closed without exception', 'CB-LD-2706-L370', 'open and escalated', 'CB-LD-2706-U397'].", "id": "findings.F-12.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-12's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-12.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-23', 'Caleb Hassan'] for F-12.", "id": "findings.F-12.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-13 exception for production gap.", "id": "findings.F-13.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's id from /workspace/documents/05_email_families/037_email_families_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_third_party/085_third_party_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's issue from /workspace/documents/05_email_families/037_email_families_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_third_party/085_third_party_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's severity from /workspace/documents/05_email_families/037_email_families_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_third_party/085_third_party_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's primary_source from /workspace/documents/05_email_families/037_email_families_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_third_party/085_third_party_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/05_email_families/037_email_families_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_third_party/085_third_party_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-13 using the exact controlled facts ['Western District of Oklahoma', 'Oklahoma'].", "id": "findings.F-13.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-13's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-13.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-23', 'Leona Park'] for F-13.", "id": "findings.F-13.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-14 exception for metadata field loss.", "id": "findings.F-14.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's id from /workspace/documents/05_email_families/040_email_families_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_third_party/088_third_party_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's issue from /workspace/documents/05_email_families/040_email_families_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_third_party/088_third_party_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's severity from /workspace/documents/05_email_families/040_email_families_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_third_party/088_third_party_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's primary_source from /workspace/documents/05_email_families/040_email_families_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_third_party/088_third_party_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/05_email_families/040_email_families_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_third_party/088_third_party_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-14 using the exact controlled facts ['3%', '10%'].", "id": "findings.F-14.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-14's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-14.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-23', 'Isaac Romero'] for F-14.", "id": "findings.F-14.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-15 exception for Bates-range overlap.", "id": "findings.F-15.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's id from /workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/043_chat_exports_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_case_management/091_case_management_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's issue from /workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/043_chat_exports_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_case_management/091_case_management_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's severity from /workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/043_chat_exports_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_case_management/091_case_management_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's primary_source from /workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/043_chat_exports_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_case_management/091_case_management_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/043_chat_exports_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_case_management/091_case_management_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-15 using the exact controlled facts ['notices-federal_basin_resources@example.test', 'archive-osage_crest_minerals_llc@example.test'].", "id": "findings.F-15.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-15's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-15.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-23', 'Sofia Bennett'] for F-15.", "id": "findings.F-15.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-16 exception for meet-and-confer commitment.", "id": "findings.F-16.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's id from /workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/046_chat_exports_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_case_management/094_case_management_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's issue from /workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/046_chat_exports_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_case_management/094_case_management_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's severity from /workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/046_chat_exports_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_case_management/094_case_management_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's primary_source from /workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/046_chat_exports_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_case_management/094_case_management_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/046_chat_exports_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_case_management/094_case_management_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-16 using the exact controlled facts ['51 records', '2025-01-06', '75 records', '2025-02-22'].", "id": "findings.F-16.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-16's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-16.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-23', 'Adrian Mensah'] for F-16.", "id": "findings.F-16.action_anchors"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Executive assessment' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Executive assessment"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Method and record coverage' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Method and record coverage"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Findings' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Findings"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Recommended next actions' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Recommended next actions"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Assumptions and limitations' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Assumptions and limitations"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-01 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-01"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-02 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-02"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-03 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-03"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-04 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-04"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-05 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-05"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-06 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-06"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-07 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-07"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-08 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-08"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-09 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-09"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-10 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-10"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-11 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-11"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-12 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-12"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-13 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-13"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-14 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-14"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-15 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-15"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-16 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-16"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Do not claim the production has no issues or that every record is consistent.", "id": "memo.forbidden_claims_absent"}], "decision_options": [{"id": "cross-source-reconciliation", "label": "Reconcile controlling and corroborating records", "reason": "The CB-LD-2706 production contains independently maintained records; a defensible answer must preserve each supported conflict and its cure owner.", "selected": true}, {"id": "latest-record-controls", "label": "Treat the latest record as controlling", "reason": "Timestamp recency does not establish legal priority, execution, or approval authority.", "selected": false}, {"id": "primary-records-only", "label": "Report primary records without reconciliation", "reason": "Primary records alone conceal the operational conflicts that create the actionable exceptions.", "selected": false}], "gates": ["all_evidence_read_in_full", "chain_of_custody_metadata_checked", "findings_criteria_complete", "memo_criteria_complete", "deliverables_written_through_mcp"], "metadata_checks": 8, "metric": "weighted_criteria_score", "minimum_tool_calls": 46, "required_deliverables": ["findings.json", "advice.md"], "required_document_reads": 33, "type": "deterministic", "weights": {"findings": 0.55, "memo": 0.2, "procedure": 0.25}}, "task_id": "cb100-036-federal-basin", "task_name": "Federal Basin royalty dispute production", "world_id": "counselbench-filesystem-mcp-v2"}
-{"context_files": ["task_files/cb100-037-glacier-insurance/01_pleadings/001_pleadings_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-037-glacier-insurance/01_pleadings/002_pleadings_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-037-glacier-insurance/01_pleadings/003_pleadings_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-037-glacier-insurance/01_pleadings/004_pleadings_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-037-glacier-insurance/01_pleadings/005_pleadings_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-037-glacier-insurance/01_pleadings/006_pleadings_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-037-glacier-insurance/01_pleadings/007_pleadings_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-037-glacier-insurance/01_pleadings/008_pleadings_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-037-glacier-insurance/02_orders/009_orders_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-037-glacier-insurance/02_orders/010_orders_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-037-glacier-insurance/02_orders/011_orders_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-037-glacier-insurance/02_orders/012_orders_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-037-glacier-insurance/02_orders/013_orders_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-037-glacier-insurance/02_orders/014_orders_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-037-glacier-insurance/02_orders/015_orders_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-037-glacier-insurance/02_orders/016_orders_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-037-glacier-insurance/03_requests_responses/017_requests_responses_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-037-glacier-insurance/03_requests_responses/018_requests_responses_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-037-glacier-insurance/03_requests_responses/019_requests_responses_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-037-glacier-insurance/03_requests_responses/020_requests_responses_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-037-glacier-insurance/03_requests_responses/021_requests_responses_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-037-glacier-insurance/03_requests_responses/022_requests_responses_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-037-glacier-insurance/03_requests_responses/023_requests_responses_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-037-glacier-insurance/03_requests_responses/024_requests_responses_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-037-glacier-insurance/04_custodian_files/025_custodian_files_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-037-glacier-insurance/04_custodian_files/026_custodian_files_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-037-glacier-insurance/04_custodian_files/027_custodian_files_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-037-glacier-insurance/04_custodian_files/028_custodian_files_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-037-glacier-insurance/04_custodian_files/029_custodian_files_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-037-glacier-insurance/04_custodian_files/030_custodian_files_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-037-glacier-insurance/04_custodian_files/031_custodian_files_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-037-glacier-insurance/04_custodian_files/032_custodian_files_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-037-glacier-insurance/05_email_families/033_email_families_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-037-glacier-insurance/05_email_families/034_email_families_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-037-glacier-insurance/05_email_families/035_email_families_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-037-glacier-insurance/05_email_families/036_email_families_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-037-glacier-insurance/05_email_families/037_email_families_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-037-glacier-insurance/05_email_families/038_email_families_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-037-glacier-insurance/05_email_families/039_email_families_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-037-glacier-insurance/05_email_families/040_email_families_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-037-glacier-insurance/06_chat_exports/041_chat_exports_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-037-glacier-insurance/06_chat_exports/042_chat_exports_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-037-glacier-insurance/06_chat_exports/043_chat_exports_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-037-glacier-insurance/06_chat_exports/044_chat_exports_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-037-glacier-insurance/06_chat_exports/045_chat_exports_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-037-glacier-insurance/06_chat_exports/046_chat_exports_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-037-glacier-insurance/06_chat_exports/047_chat_exports_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-037-glacier-insurance/06_chat_exports/048_chat_exports_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-037-glacier-insurance/07_privilege_material/049_privilege_material_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-037-glacier-insurance/07_privilege_material/050_privilege_material_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-037-glacier-insurance/07_privilege_material/051_privilege_material_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-037-glacier-insurance/07_privilege_material/052_privilege_material_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-037-glacier-insurance/07_privilege_material/053_privilege_material_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-037-glacier-insurance/07_privilege_material/054_privilege_material_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-037-glacier-insurance/07_privilege_material/055_privilege_material_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-037-glacier-insurance/07_privilege_material/056_privilege_material_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-037-glacier-insurance/08_production_logs/057_production_logs_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-037-glacier-insurance/08_production_logs/058_production_logs_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-037-glacier-insurance/08_production_logs/059_production_logs_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-037-glacier-insurance/08_production_logs/060_production_logs_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-037-glacier-insurance/08_production_logs/061_production_logs_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-037-glacier-insurance/08_production_logs/062_production_logs_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-037-glacier-insurance/08_production_logs/063_production_logs_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-037-glacier-insurance/08_production_logs/064_production_logs_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-037-glacier-insurance/09_depositions/065_depositions_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-037-glacier-insurance/09_depositions/066_depositions_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-037-glacier-insurance/09_depositions/067_depositions_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-037-glacier-insurance/09_depositions/068_depositions_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-037-glacier-insurance/09_depositions/069_depositions_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-037-glacier-insurance/09_depositions/070_depositions_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-037-glacier-insurance/09_depositions/071_depositions_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-037-glacier-insurance/09_depositions/072_depositions_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-037-glacier-insurance/10_expert_material/073_expert_material_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-037-glacier-insurance/10_expert_material/074_expert_material_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-037-glacier-insurance/10_expert_material/075_expert_material_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-037-glacier-insurance/10_expert_material/076_expert_material_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-037-glacier-insurance/10_expert_material/077_expert_material_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-037-glacier-insurance/10_expert_material/078_expert_material_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-037-glacier-insurance/10_expert_material/079_expert_material_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-037-glacier-insurance/10_expert_material/080_expert_material_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-037-glacier-insurance/11_third_party/081_third_party_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-037-glacier-insurance/11_third_party/082_third_party_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-037-glacier-insurance/11_third_party/083_third_party_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-037-glacier-insurance/11_third_party/084_third_party_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-037-glacier-insurance/11_third_party/085_third_party_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-037-glacier-insurance/11_third_party/086_third_party_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-037-glacier-insurance/11_third_party/087_third_party_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-037-glacier-insurance/11_third_party/088_third_party_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-037-glacier-insurance/12_case_management/089_case_management_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-037-glacier-insurance/12_case_management/090_case_management_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-037-glacier-insurance/12_case_management/091_case_management_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-037-glacier-insurance/12_case_management/092_case_management_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-037-glacier-insurance/12_case_management/093_case_management_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-037-glacier-insurance/12_case_management/094_case_management_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-037-glacier-insurance/12_case_management/095_case_management_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-037-glacier-insurance/12_case_management/096_case_management_status_report.md"], "gold_output": {"advice_markdown": "# Counsel advice — Glacier coverage action discovery review\n\n## Executive assessment\n\nFor Glacier Mutual Insurance matter CB-LD-2707, the review identified 16 source-supported exceptions requiring action before 2026-09-26. The assessment concerns Moraine Data Centers, Inc. and the supplied record for New York.\n\n## Method and record coverage\n\nThe review inventoried all 96 production files, read the 33 controlling, corroborating, and control records, searched the email exports, and checked metadata for the designated chain-of-custody sample. Conclusions are limited to the synthetic production supplied for this benchmark matter.\n\n## Findings\n\n### F-01 — custodian omission (critical)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for custodian omission: one source states the operative date is 2025-10-19 under control reference CB-LD-2707-A329, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2025-11-11 under response reference CB-LD-2707-J809.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/01_pleadings/001_pleadings_control_register.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/07_privilege_material/049_privilege_material_control_register.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-26, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Samuel Kim.\n\n### F-02 — legal-hold delivery gap (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for legal-hold delivery gap: one source states the controlling amount is $5,843,447.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $5,903,394.00.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/01_pleadings/004_pleadings_ledger_export.csv`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/07_privilege_material/052_privilege_material_ledger_export.csv`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-26, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Maya Ellison.\n\n### F-03 — collection-date inconsistency (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for collection-date inconsistency: one source states approval is attributed to Nadine Flores as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Henry Cho and contains no entry for Nadine Flores.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/01_pleadings/007_pleadings_officer_certificate.html`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/07_privilege_material/055_privilege_material_officer_certificate.html`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-26, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Rafael Okafor.\n\n### F-04 — email-family separation (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for email-family separation: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-LD-2707-D496, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-LD-2707-M130.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/02_orders/010_orders_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/08_production_logs/058_production_logs_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-26, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Nora Chen.\n\n### F-05 — privilege-log description defect (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for privilege-log description defect: one source states the applicable location is Southern District of New York, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to New York operations outside Southern District of New York.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/02_orders/013_orders_review_memorandum.json`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/08_production_logs/061_production_logs_review_memorandum.json`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-26, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Dominic Alvarez.\n\n### F-06 — common-interest support gap (low)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for common-interest support gap: one source states the threshold is 9% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 14% and produced a different exception result.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/02_orders/016_orders_status_report.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/08_production_logs/064_production_logs_status_report.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-26, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Priya Raman.\n\n### F-07 — clawback deadline (critical)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for clawback deadline: one source states formal notice must use notices-glacier_mutual_insurance@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-moraine_data_centers_inc@example.test.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/019_requests_responses_correspondence.eml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/09_depositions/067_depositions_correspondence.eml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-26, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Elliot Mercer.\n\n### F-08 — protective-order designation error (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for protective-order designation error: one source states the governed population contains 104 records through 2025-12-05, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 75 records through 2026-01-21.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/022_requests_responses_formal_notice.xml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/09_depositions/070_depositions_formal_notice.xml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-26, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Talia Brooks.\n\n### F-09 — request-response mismatch (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for request-response mismatch: one source states the operative date is 2025-11-27 under control reference CB-LD-2707-I728, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2026-01-01 under response reference CB-LD-2707-R286.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/025_custodian_files_control_register.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/10_expert_material/073_expert_material_control_register.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-26, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Jonas Feld.\n\n### F-10 — deposition exhibit omission (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for deposition exhibit omission: one source states the controlling amount is $5,006,541.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $5,089,582.00.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/028_custodian_files_ledger_export.csv`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/10_expert_material/076_expert_material_ledger_export.csv`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-26, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Mei Whitaker.\n\n### F-11 — expert draft segregation (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for expert draft segregation: one source states approval is attributed to Nadine Flores as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Caleb Hassan and contains no entry for Nadine Flores.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/031_custodian_files_officer_certificate.html`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/10_expert_material/079_expert_material_officer_certificate.html`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-26, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Caleb Hassan.\n\n### F-12 — third-party subpoena deadline (low)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for third-party subpoena deadline: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-LD-2707-L621, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-LD-2707-U486.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/05_email_families/034_email_families_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/11_third_party/082_third_party_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-26, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Leona Park.\n\n### F-13 — production gap (critical)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for production gap: one source states the applicable location is Southern District of New York, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to New York operations outside Southern District of New York.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/05_email_families/037_email_families_review_memorandum.json`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/11_third_party/085_third_party_review_memorandum.json`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-26, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Isaac Romero.\n\n### F-14 — metadata field loss (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for metadata field loss: one source states the threshold is 15% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 18% and produced a different exception result.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/05_email_families/040_email_families_status_report.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/11_third_party/088_third_party_status_report.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-26, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Sofia Bennett.\n\n### F-15 — Bates-range overlap (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for Bates-range overlap: one source states formal notice must use notices-glacier_mutual_insurance@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-moraine_data_centers_inc@example.test.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/043_chat_exports_correspondence.eml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/12_case_management/091_case_management_correspondence.eml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-26, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Adrian Mensah.\n\n### F-16 — meet-and-confer commitment (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for meet-and-confer commitment: one source states the governed population contains 92 records through 2025-07-06, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 64 records through 2025-08-11.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/046_chat_exports_formal_notice.xml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/12_case_management/094_case_management_formal_notice.xml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-26, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Willa Novak.\n\n## Recommended next actions\n\nSequence the critical and high findings first, assign the named owners, preserve the cited records, and document any resolution in the controlling matter register before the stated deadline.\n\n## Assumptions and limitations\n\nThis analysis is confined to task cb100-037-glacier-insurance and the supplied synthetic evidence. It does not rely on external facts, does not resolve disputed law, and is not legal advice for a real person or entity.\n", "findings": {"as_of": "2026-09-26", "findings": [{"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/07_privilege_material/049_privilege_material_control_register.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for custodian omission: one source states the operative date is 2025-10-19 under control reference CB-LD-2707-A329, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2025-11-11 under response reference CB-LD-2707-J809.", "id": "F-01", "issue": "custodian omission", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/01_pleadings/001_pleadings_control_register.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-26, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Samuel Kim.", "severity": "critical"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/07_privilege_material/052_privilege_material_ledger_export.csv", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for legal-hold delivery gap: one source states the controlling amount is $5,843,447.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $5,903,394.00.", "id": "F-02", "issue": "legal-hold delivery gap", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/01_pleadings/004_pleadings_ledger_export.csv", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-26, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Maya Ellison.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/07_privilege_material/055_privilege_material_officer_certificate.html", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for collection-date inconsistency: one source states approval is attributed to Nadine Flores as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Henry Cho and contains no entry for Nadine Flores.", "id": "F-03", "issue": "collection-date inconsistency", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/01_pleadings/007_pleadings_officer_certificate.html", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-26, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Rafael Okafor.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/08_production_logs/058_production_logs_executed_instrument.txt", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for email-family separation: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-LD-2707-D496, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-LD-2707-M130.", "id": "F-04", "issue": "email-family separation", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/02_orders/010_orders_executed_instrument.txt", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-26, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Nora Chen.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/08_production_logs/061_production_logs_review_memorandum.json", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for privilege-log description defect: one source states the applicable location is Southern District of New York, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to New York operations outside Southern District of New York.", "id": "F-05", "issue": "privilege-log description defect", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/02_orders/013_orders_review_memorandum.json", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-26, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Dominic Alvarez.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/08_production_logs/064_production_logs_status_report.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for common-interest support gap: one source states the threshold is 9% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 14% and produced a different exception result.", "id": "F-06", "issue": "common-interest support gap", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/02_orders/016_orders_status_report.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-26, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Priya Raman.", "severity": "low"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/09_depositions/067_depositions_correspondence.eml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for clawback deadline: one source states formal notice must use notices-glacier_mutual_insurance@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-moraine_data_centers_inc@example.test.", "id": "F-07", "issue": "clawback deadline", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/019_requests_responses_correspondence.eml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-26, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Elliot Mercer.", "severity": "critical"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/09_depositions/070_depositions_formal_notice.xml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for protective-order designation error: one source states the governed population contains 104 records through 2025-12-05, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 75 records through 2026-01-21.", "id": "F-08", "issue": "protective-order designation error", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/022_requests_responses_formal_notice.xml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-26, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Talia Brooks.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/10_expert_material/073_expert_material_control_register.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for request-response mismatch: one source states the operative date is 2025-11-27 under control reference CB-LD-2707-I728, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2026-01-01 under response reference CB-LD-2707-R286.", "id": "F-09", "issue": "request-response mismatch", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/025_custodian_files_control_register.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-26, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Jonas Feld.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/10_expert_material/076_expert_material_ledger_export.csv", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for deposition exhibit omission: one source states the controlling amount is $5,006,541.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $5,089,582.00.", "id": "F-10", "issue": "deposition exhibit omission", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/028_custodian_files_ledger_export.csv", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-26, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Mei Whitaker.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/10_expert_material/079_expert_material_officer_certificate.html", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for expert draft segregation: one source states approval is attributed to Nadine Flores as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Caleb Hassan and contains no entry for Nadine Flores.", "id": "F-11", "issue": "expert draft segregation", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/031_custodian_files_officer_certificate.html", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-26, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Caleb Hassan.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/11_third_party/082_third_party_executed_instrument.txt", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for third-party subpoena deadline: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-LD-2707-L621, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-LD-2707-U486.", "id": "F-12", "issue": "third-party subpoena deadline", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/05_email_families/034_email_families_executed_instrument.txt", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-26, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Leona Park.", "severity": "low"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/11_third_party/085_third_party_review_memorandum.json", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for production gap: one source states the applicable location is Southern District of New York, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to New York operations outside Southern District of New York.", "id": "F-13", "issue": "production gap", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/05_email_families/037_email_families_review_memorandum.json", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-26, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Isaac Romero.", "severity": "critical"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/11_third_party/088_third_party_status_report.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for metadata field loss: one source states the threshold is 15% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 18% and produced a different exception result.", "id": "F-14", "issue": "metadata field loss", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/05_email_families/040_email_families_status_report.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-26, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Sofia Bennett.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/12_case_management/091_case_management_correspondence.eml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for Bates-range overlap: one source states formal notice must use notices-glacier_mutual_insurance@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-moraine_data_centers_inc@example.test.", "id": "F-15", "issue": "Bates-range overlap", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/043_chat_exports_correspondence.eml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-26, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Adrian Mensah.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/12_case_management/094_case_management_formal_notice.xml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for meet-and-confer commitment: one source states the governed population contains 92 records through 2025-07-06, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 64 records through 2025-08-11.", "id": "F-16", "issue": "meet-and-confer commitment", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/046_chat_exports_formal_notice.xml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-26, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Willa Novak.", "severity": "medium"}], "matter_number": "CB-LD-2707", "prepared_for": "Glacier Mutual Insurance", "schema_version": "1.0", "task_id": "cb100-037-glacier-insurance"}}, "metadata": {"benchmark": "CounselBench-100", "code_license": "Apache-2.0", "data_license": "CC-BY-4.0", "deadline": "2026-09-26", "document_count": 96, "jurisdiction": "New York", "matter_number": "CB-LD-2707", "mcp_commit": "9a96ea6e5913736f92b88345bf51caeaaa8e719f", "mcp_package": "@modelcontextprotocol/server-filesystem@2026.7.10", "practice_area": "litigation-discovery", "reference_tool_calls": 46, "required_evidence_reads": 33, "synthetic": true, "venue": "Southern District of New York", "version": "2.0.0"}, "prompt": "You are discovery counsel for Glacier Mutual Insurance. A counterparty challenged the client's internal summary, making cross-document reconciliation and precise citations essential. Claims files contain mixed business and legal communications, redaction inconsistencies, and a disputed clawback notice date. Decision due 2026-09-26. New York law governs; Southern District of New York is the forum. Flag cross-folder dependencies that would be invisible in a single-document review. Work out the defensible position from the matter production and leave an audit-ready exception tracker and concise advice for the supervising lawyer. Keep confirmed conflicts separate from open questions, cite the records that actually control each conclusion, and do not fill gaps with outside facts.", "rubric": {"criteria": [{"category": "procedure", "description": "Complete at least 46 successful, argument-specific evidence and output calls.", "id": "procedure.minimum_successful_tool_calls"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Find and read the 33 controlling, corroborating, and work-product-control records in full.", "id": "procedure.all_evidence_read_in_full"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Inspect file metadata for the eight designated critical primary records before relying on them.", "id": "procedure.chain_of_custody_metadata_checked"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Confirm the sandbox's allowed document and output roots.", "id": "procedure.allowed_directories_checked"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Inventory all 96 records so the relevant sources are discovered among the context records.", "id": "procedure.recursive_inventory_completed"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Search the production for email evidence that may corroborate or contradict formal records.", "id": "procedure.targeted_search_completed"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Leave only findings.json and advice.md in the output workspace.", "id": "procedure.exact_deliverable_set"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Create both final work products through the sandbox MCP surface.", "id": "procedure.deliverables_written_through_mcp"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Produce findings.json as a valid JSON object.", "id": "findings.findings_is_object"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Report exactly 16 confirmed exceptions.", "id": "findings.findings_exact_count"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Use each stable finding ID exactly once.", "id": "findings.finding_ids_unique"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set schema_version to the released matter value '1.0'.", "id": "findings.top_level_schema_version"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set task_id to the released matter value 'cb100-037-glacier-insurance'.", "id": "findings.top_level_task_id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set matter_number to the released matter value 'CB-LD-2707'.", "id": "findings.top_level_matter_number"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set prepared_for to the released matter value 'Glacier Mutual Insurance'.", "id": "findings.top_level_prepared_for"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set as_of to the released matter value '2026-09-26'.", "id": "findings.top_level_as_of"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-01 exception for custodian omission.", "id": "findings.F-01.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's id from /workspace/documents/01_pleadings/001_pleadings_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_privilege_material/049_privilege_material_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's issue from /workspace/documents/01_pleadings/001_pleadings_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_privilege_material/049_privilege_material_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's severity from /workspace/documents/01_pleadings/001_pleadings_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_privilege_material/049_privilege_material_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's primary_source from /workspace/documents/01_pleadings/001_pleadings_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_privilege_material/049_privilege_material_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/01_pleadings/001_pleadings_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_privilege_material/049_privilege_material_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-01 using the exact controlled facts ['2025-10-19', 'CB-LD-2707-A329', '2025-11-11', 'CB-LD-2707-J809'].", "id": "findings.F-01.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-01's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-01.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-26', 'Samuel Kim'] for F-01.", "id": "findings.F-01.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-02 exception for legal-hold delivery gap.", "id": "findings.F-02.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's id from /workspace/documents/01_pleadings/004_pleadings_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_privilege_material/052_privilege_material_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's issue from /workspace/documents/01_pleadings/004_pleadings_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_privilege_material/052_privilege_material_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's severity from /workspace/documents/01_pleadings/004_pleadings_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_privilege_material/052_privilege_material_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's primary_source from /workspace/documents/01_pleadings/004_pleadings_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_privilege_material/052_privilege_material_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/01_pleadings/004_pleadings_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_privilege_material/052_privilege_material_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-02 using the exact controlled facts ['$5,843,447.00', '$5,903,394.00'].", "id": "findings.F-02.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-02's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-02.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-26', 'Maya Ellison'] for F-02.", "id": "findings.F-02.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-03 exception for collection-date inconsistency.", "id": "findings.F-03.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's id from /workspace/documents/01_pleadings/007_pleadings_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_privilege_material/055_privilege_material_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's issue from /workspace/documents/01_pleadings/007_pleadings_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_privilege_material/055_privilege_material_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's severity from /workspace/documents/01_pleadings/007_pleadings_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_privilege_material/055_privilege_material_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's primary_source from /workspace/documents/01_pleadings/007_pleadings_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_privilege_material/055_privilege_material_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/01_pleadings/007_pleadings_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_privilege_material/055_privilege_material_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-03 using the exact controlled facts ['Nadine Flores', 'Henry Cho'].", "id": "findings.F-03.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-03's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-03.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-26', 'Rafael Okafor'] for F-03.", "id": "findings.F-03.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-04 exception for email-family separation.", "id": "findings.F-04.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's id from /workspace/documents/02_orders/010_orders_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_production_logs/058_production_logs_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's issue from /workspace/documents/02_orders/010_orders_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_production_logs/058_production_logs_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's severity from /workspace/documents/02_orders/010_orders_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_production_logs/058_production_logs_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's primary_source from /workspace/documents/02_orders/010_orders_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_production_logs/058_production_logs_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/02_orders/010_orders_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_production_logs/058_production_logs_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-04 using the exact controlled facts ['closed without exception', 'CB-LD-2707-D496', 'open and escalated', 'CB-LD-2707-M130'].", "id": "findings.F-04.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-04's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-04.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-26', 'Nora Chen'] for F-04.", "id": "findings.F-04.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-05 exception for privilege-log description defect.", "id": "findings.F-05.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's id from /workspace/documents/02_orders/013_orders_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_production_logs/061_production_logs_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's issue from /workspace/documents/02_orders/013_orders_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_production_logs/061_production_logs_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's severity from /workspace/documents/02_orders/013_orders_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_production_logs/061_production_logs_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's primary_source from /workspace/documents/02_orders/013_orders_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_production_logs/061_production_logs_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/02_orders/013_orders_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_production_logs/061_production_logs_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-05 using the exact controlled facts ['Southern District of New York', 'New York'].", "id": "findings.F-05.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-05's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-05.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-26', 'Dominic Alvarez'] for F-05.", "id": "findings.F-05.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-06 exception for common-interest support gap.", "id": "findings.F-06.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's id from /workspace/documents/02_orders/016_orders_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_production_logs/064_production_logs_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's issue from /workspace/documents/02_orders/016_orders_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_production_logs/064_production_logs_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's severity from /workspace/documents/02_orders/016_orders_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_production_logs/064_production_logs_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's primary_source from /workspace/documents/02_orders/016_orders_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_production_logs/064_production_logs_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/02_orders/016_orders_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_production_logs/064_production_logs_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-06 using the exact controlled facts ['9%', '14%'].", "id": "findings.F-06.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-06's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-06.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-26', 'Priya Raman'] for F-06.", "id": "findings.F-06.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-07 exception for clawback deadline.", "id": "findings.F-07.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's id from /workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/019_requests_responses_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_depositions/067_depositions_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's issue from /workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/019_requests_responses_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_depositions/067_depositions_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's severity from /workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/019_requests_responses_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_depositions/067_depositions_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's primary_source from /workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/019_requests_responses_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_depositions/067_depositions_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/019_requests_responses_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_depositions/067_depositions_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-07 using the exact controlled facts ['notices-glacier_mutual_insurance@example.test', 'archive-moraine_data_centers_inc@example.test'].", "id": "findings.F-07.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-07's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-07.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-26', 'Elliot Mercer'] for F-07.", "id": "findings.F-07.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-08 exception for protective-order designation error.", "id": "findings.F-08.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's id from /workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/022_requests_responses_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_depositions/070_depositions_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's issue from /workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/022_requests_responses_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_depositions/070_depositions_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's severity from /workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/022_requests_responses_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_depositions/070_depositions_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's primary_source from /workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/022_requests_responses_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_depositions/070_depositions_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/022_requests_responses_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_depositions/070_depositions_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-08 using the exact controlled facts ['104 records', '2025-12-05', '75 records', '2026-01-21'].", "id": "findings.F-08.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-08's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-08.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-26', 'Talia Brooks'] for F-08.", "id": "findings.F-08.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-09 exception for request-response mismatch.", "id": "findings.F-09.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's id from /workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/025_custodian_files_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_expert_material/073_expert_material_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's issue from /workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/025_custodian_files_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_expert_material/073_expert_material_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's severity from /workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/025_custodian_files_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_expert_material/073_expert_material_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's primary_source from /workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/025_custodian_files_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_expert_material/073_expert_material_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/025_custodian_files_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_expert_material/073_expert_material_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-09 using the exact controlled facts ['2025-11-27', 'CB-LD-2707-I728', '2026-01-01', 'CB-LD-2707-R286'].", "id": "findings.F-09.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-09's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-09.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-26', 'Jonas Feld'] for F-09.", "id": "findings.F-09.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-10 exception for deposition exhibit omission.", "id": "findings.F-10.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's id from /workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/028_custodian_files_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_expert_material/076_expert_material_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's issue from /workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/028_custodian_files_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_expert_material/076_expert_material_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's severity from /workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/028_custodian_files_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_expert_material/076_expert_material_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's primary_source from /workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/028_custodian_files_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_expert_material/076_expert_material_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/028_custodian_files_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_expert_material/076_expert_material_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-10 using the exact controlled facts ['$5,006,541.00', '$5,089,582.00'].", "id": "findings.F-10.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-10's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-10.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-26', 'Mei Whitaker'] for F-10.", "id": "findings.F-10.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-11 exception for expert draft segregation.", "id": "findings.F-11.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's id from /workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/031_custodian_files_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_expert_material/079_expert_material_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's issue from /workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/031_custodian_files_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_expert_material/079_expert_material_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's severity from /workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/031_custodian_files_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_expert_material/079_expert_material_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's primary_source from /workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/031_custodian_files_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_expert_material/079_expert_material_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/031_custodian_files_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_expert_material/079_expert_material_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-11 using the exact controlled facts ['Nadine Flores', 'Caleb Hassan'].", "id": "findings.F-11.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-11's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-11.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-26', 'Caleb Hassan'] for F-11.", "id": "findings.F-11.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-12 exception for third-party subpoena deadline.", "id": "findings.F-12.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's id from /workspace/documents/05_email_families/034_email_families_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_third_party/082_third_party_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's issue from /workspace/documents/05_email_families/034_email_families_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_third_party/082_third_party_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's severity from /workspace/documents/05_email_families/034_email_families_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_third_party/082_third_party_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's primary_source from /workspace/documents/05_email_families/034_email_families_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_third_party/082_third_party_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/05_email_families/034_email_families_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_third_party/082_third_party_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-12 using the exact controlled facts ['closed without exception', 'CB-LD-2707-L621', 'open and escalated', 'CB-LD-2707-U486'].", "id": "findings.F-12.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-12's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-12.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-26', 'Leona Park'] for F-12.", "id": "findings.F-12.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-13 exception for production gap.", "id": "findings.F-13.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's id from /workspace/documents/05_email_families/037_email_families_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_third_party/085_third_party_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's issue from /workspace/documents/05_email_families/037_email_families_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_third_party/085_third_party_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's severity from /workspace/documents/05_email_families/037_email_families_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_third_party/085_third_party_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's primary_source from /workspace/documents/05_email_families/037_email_families_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_third_party/085_third_party_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/05_email_families/037_email_families_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_third_party/085_third_party_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-13 using the exact controlled facts ['Southern District of New York', 'New York'].", "id": "findings.F-13.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-13's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-13.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-26', 'Isaac Romero'] for F-13.", "id": "findings.F-13.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-14 exception for metadata field loss.", "id": "findings.F-14.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's id from /workspace/documents/05_email_families/040_email_families_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_third_party/088_third_party_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's issue from /workspace/documents/05_email_families/040_email_families_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_third_party/088_third_party_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's severity from /workspace/documents/05_email_families/040_email_families_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_third_party/088_third_party_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's primary_source from /workspace/documents/05_email_families/040_email_families_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_third_party/088_third_party_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/05_email_families/040_email_families_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_third_party/088_third_party_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-14 using the exact controlled facts ['15%', '18%'].", "id": "findings.F-14.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-14's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-14.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-26', 'Sofia Bennett'] for F-14.", "id": "findings.F-14.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-15 exception for Bates-range overlap.", "id": "findings.F-15.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's id from /workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/043_chat_exports_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_case_management/091_case_management_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's issue from /workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/043_chat_exports_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_case_management/091_case_management_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's severity from /workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/043_chat_exports_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_case_management/091_case_management_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's primary_source from /workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/043_chat_exports_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_case_management/091_case_management_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/043_chat_exports_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_case_management/091_case_management_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-15 using the exact controlled facts ['notices-glacier_mutual_insurance@example.test', 'archive-moraine_data_centers_inc@example.test'].", "id": "findings.F-15.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-15's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-15.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-26', 'Adrian Mensah'] for F-15.", "id": "findings.F-15.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-16 exception for meet-and-confer commitment.", "id": "findings.F-16.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's id from /workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/046_chat_exports_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_case_management/094_case_management_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's issue from /workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/046_chat_exports_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_case_management/094_case_management_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's severity from /workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/046_chat_exports_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_case_management/094_case_management_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's primary_source from /workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/046_chat_exports_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_case_management/094_case_management_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/046_chat_exports_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_case_management/094_case_management_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-16 using the exact controlled facts ['92 records', '2025-07-06', '64 records', '2025-08-11'].", "id": "findings.F-16.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-16's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-16.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-26', 'Willa Novak'] for F-16.", "id": "findings.F-16.action_anchors"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Executive assessment' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Executive assessment"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Method and record coverage' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Method and record coverage"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Findings' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Findings"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Recommended next actions' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Recommended next actions"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Assumptions and limitations' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Assumptions and limitations"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-01 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-01"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-02 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-02"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-03 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-03"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-04 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-04"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-05 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-05"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-06 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-06"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-07 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-07"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-08 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-08"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-09 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-09"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-10 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-10"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-11 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-11"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-12 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-12"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-13 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-13"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-14 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-14"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-15 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-15"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-16 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-16"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Do not claim the production has no issues or that every record is consistent.", "id": "memo.forbidden_claims_absent"}], "decision_options": [{"id": "cross-source-reconciliation", "label": "Reconcile controlling and corroborating records", "reason": "The CB-LD-2707 production contains independently maintained records; a defensible answer must preserve each supported conflict and its cure owner.", "selected": true}, {"id": "latest-record-controls", "label": "Treat the latest record as controlling", "reason": "Timestamp recency does not establish legal priority, execution, or approval authority.", "selected": false}, {"id": "primary-records-only", "label": "Report primary records without reconciliation", "reason": "Primary records alone conceal the operational conflicts that create the actionable exceptions.", "selected": false}], "gates": ["all_evidence_read_in_full", "chain_of_custody_metadata_checked", "findings_criteria_complete", "memo_criteria_complete", "deliverables_written_through_mcp"], "metadata_checks": 8, "metric": "weighted_criteria_score", "minimum_tool_calls": 46, "required_deliverables": ["findings.json", "advice.md"], "required_document_reads": 33, "type": "deterministic", "weights": {"findings": 0.55, "memo": 0.2, "procedure": 0.25}}, "task_id": "cb100-037-glacier-insurance", "task_name": "Glacier coverage action discovery review", "world_id": "counselbench-filesystem-mcp-v2"}
-{"context_files": ["task_files/cb100-038-highland-securities/01_pleadings/001_pleadings_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-038-highland-securities/01_pleadings/002_pleadings_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-038-highland-securities/01_pleadings/003_pleadings_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-038-highland-securities/01_pleadings/004_pleadings_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-038-highland-securities/01_pleadings/005_pleadings_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-038-highland-securities/01_pleadings/006_pleadings_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-038-highland-securities/01_pleadings/007_pleadings_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-038-highland-securities/01_pleadings/008_pleadings_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-038-highland-securities/02_orders/009_orders_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-038-highland-securities/02_orders/010_orders_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-038-highland-securities/02_orders/011_orders_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-038-highland-securities/02_orders/012_orders_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-038-highland-securities/02_orders/013_orders_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-038-highland-securities/02_orders/014_orders_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-038-highland-securities/02_orders/015_orders_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-038-highland-securities/02_orders/016_orders_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-038-highland-securities/03_requests_responses/017_requests_responses_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-038-highland-securities/03_requests_responses/018_requests_responses_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-038-highland-securities/03_requests_responses/019_requests_responses_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-038-highland-securities/03_requests_responses/020_requests_responses_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-038-highland-securities/03_requests_responses/021_requests_responses_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-038-highland-securities/03_requests_responses/022_requests_responses_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-038-highland-securities/03_requests_responses/023_requests_responses_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-038-highland-securities/03_requests_responses/024_requests_responses_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-038-highland-securities/04_custodian_files/025_custodian_files_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-038-highland-securities/04_custodian_files/026_custodian_files_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-038-highland-securities/04_custodian_files/027_custodian_files_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-038-highland-securities/04_custodian_files/028_custodian_files_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-038-highland-securities/04_custodian_files/029_custodian_files_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-038-highland-securities/04_custodian_files/030_custodian_files_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-038-highland-securities/04_custodian_files/031_custodian_files_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-038-highland-securities/04_custodian_files/032_custodian_files_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-038-highland-securities/05_email_families/033_email_families_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-038-highland-securities/05_email_families/034_email_families_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-038-highland-securities/05_email_families/035_email_families_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-038-highland-securities/05_email_families/036_email_families_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-038-highland-securities/05_email_families/037_email_families_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-038-highland-securities/05_email_families/038_email_families_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-038-highland-securities/05_email_families/039_email_families_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-038-highland-securities/05_email_families/040_email_families_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-038-highland-securities/06_chat_exports/041_chat_exports_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-038-highland-securities/06_chat_exports/042_chat_exports_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-038-highland-securities/06_chat_exports/043_chat_exports_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-038-highland-securities/06_chat_exports/044_chat_exports_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-038-highland-securities/06_chat_exports/045_chat_exports_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-038-highland-securities/06_chat_exports/046_chat_exports_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-038-highland-securities/06_chat_exports/047_chat_exports_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-038-highland-securities/06_chat_exports/048_chat_exports_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-038-highland-securities/07_privilege_material/049_privilege_material_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-038-highland-securities/07_privilege_material/050_privilege_material_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-038-highland-securities/07_privilege_material/051_privilege_material_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-038-highland-securities/07_privilege_material/052_privilege_material_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-038-highland-securities/07_privilege_material/053_privilege_material_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-038-highland-securities/07_privilege_material/054_privilege_material_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-038-highland-securities/07_privilege_material/055_privilege_material_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-038-highland-securities/07_privilege_material/056_privilege_material_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-038-highland-securities/08_production_logs/057_production_logs_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-038-highland-securities/08_production_logs/058_production_logs_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-038-highland-securities/08_production_logs/059_production_logs_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-038-highland-securities/08_production_logs/060_production_logs_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-038-highland-securities/08_production_logs/061_production_logs_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-038-highland-securities/08_production_logs/062_production_logs_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-038-highland-securities/08_production_logs/063_production_logs_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-038-highland-securities/08_production_logs/064_production_logs_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-038-highland-securities/09_depositions/065_depositions_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-038-highland-securities/09_depositions/066_depositions_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-038-highland-securities/09_depositions/067_depositions_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-038-highland-securities/09_depositions/068_depositions_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-038-highland-securities/09_depositions/069_depositions_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-038-highland-securities/09_depositions/070_depositions_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-038-highland-securities/09_depositions/071_depositions_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-038-highland-securities/09_depositions/072_depositions_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-038-highland-securities/10_expert_material/073_expert_material_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-038-highland-securities/10_expert_material/074_expert_material_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-038-highland-securities/10_expert_material/075_expert_material_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-038-highland-securities/10_expert_material/076_expert_material_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-038-highland-securities/10_expert_material/077_expert_material_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-038-highland-securities/10_expert_material/078_expert_material_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-038-highland-securities/10_expert_material/079_expert_material_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-038-highland-securities/10_expert_material/080_expert_material_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-038-highland-securities/11_third_party/081_third_party_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-038-highland-securities/11_third_party/082_third_party_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-038-highland-securities/11_third_party/083_third_party_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-038-highland-securities/11_third_party/084_third_party_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-038-highland-securities/11_third_party/085_third_party_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-038-highland-securities/11_third_party/086_third_party_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-038-highland-securities/11_third_party/087_third_party_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-038-highland-securities/11_third_party/088_third_party_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-038-highland-securities/12_case_management/089_case_management_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-038-highland-securities/12_case_management/090_case_management_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-038-highland-securities/12_case_management/091_case_management_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-038-highland-securities/12_case_management/092_case_management_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-038-highland-securities/12_case_management/093_case_management_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-038-highland-securities/12_case_management/094_case_management_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-038-highland-securities/12_case_management/095_case_management_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-038-highland-securities/12_case_management/096_case_management_status_report.md"], "gold_output": {"advice_markdown": "# Counsel advice — Highland securities case hold audit\n\n## Executive assessment\n\nFor Highland Medical Analytics matter CB-LD-2708, the review identified 16 source-supported exceptions requiring action before 2026-09-30. The assessment concerns Patel Securities Action and the supplied record for Tennessee.\n\n## Method and record coverage\n\nThe review inventoried all 96 production files, read the 33 controlling, corroborating, and control records, searched the email exports, and checked metadata for the designated chain-of-custody sample. Conclusions are limited to the synthetic production supplied for this benchmark matter.\n\n## Findings\n\n### F-01 — custodian omission (critical)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for custodian omission: one source states the operative date is 2025-07-28 under control reference CB-LD-2708-A366, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2025-08-08 under response reference CB-LD-2708-J951.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/01_pleadings/001_pleadings_control_register.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/07_privilege_material/049_privilege_material_control_register.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-30, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Maya Ellison.\n\n### F-02 — legal-hold delivery gap (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for legal-hold delivery gap: one source states the controlling amount is $330,535.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $587,570.00.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/01_pleadings/004_pleadings_ledger_export.csv`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/07_privilege_material/052_privilege_material_ledger_export.csv`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-30, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Rafael Okafor.\n\n### F-03 — collection-date inconsistency (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for collection-date inconsistency: one source states approval is attributed to Micah Sullivan as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Micah Sullivan and contains no entry for Micah Sullivan.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/01_pleadings/007_pleadings_officer_certificate.html`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/07_privilege_material/055_privilege_material_officer_certificate.html`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-30, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Nora Chen.\n\n### F-04 — email-family separation (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for email-family separation: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-LD-2708-D650, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-LD-2708-M557.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/02_orders/010_orders_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/08_production_logs/058_production_logs_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-30, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Dominic Alvarez.\n\n### F-05 — privilege-log description defect (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for privilege-log description defect: one source states the applicable location is Middle District of Tennessee, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to Tennessee operations outside Middle District of Tennessee.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/02_orders/013_orders_review_memorandum.json`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/08_production_logs/061_production_logs_review_memorandum.json`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-30, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Priya Raman.\n\n### F-06 — common-interest support gap (low)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for common-interest support gap: one source states the threshold is 12% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 18% and produced a different exception result.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/02_orders/016_orders_status_report.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/08_production_logs/064_production_logs_status_report.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-30, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Elliot Mercer.\n\n### F-07 — clawback deadline (critical)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for clawback deadline: one source states formal notice must use notices-highland_medical_analytics@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-patel_securities_action@example.test.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/019_requests_responses_correspondence.eml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/09_depositions/067_depositions_correspondence.eml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-30, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Talia Brooks.\n\n### F-08 — protective-order designation error (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for protective-order designation error: one source states the governed population contains 170 records through 2026-02-09, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 65 records through 2026-03-18.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/022_requests_responses_formal_notice.xml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/09_depositions/070_depositions_formal_notice.xml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-30, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Jonas Feld.\n\n### F-09 — request-response mismatch (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for request-response mismatch: one source states the operative date is 2025-07-02 under control reference CB-LD-2708-I820, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2025-08-09 under response reference CB-LD-2708-R432.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/025_custodian_files_control_register.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/10_expert_material/073_expert_material_control_register.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-30, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Mei Whitaker.\n\n### F-10 — deposition exhibit omission (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for deposition exhibit omission: one source states the controlling amount is $4,164,240.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $4,394,980.00.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/028_custodian_files_ledger_export.csv`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/10_expert_material/076_expert_material_ledger_export.csv`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-30, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Caleb Hassan.\n\n### F-11 — expert draft segregation (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for expert draft segregation: one source states approval is attributed to Micah Sullivan as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Isaac Romero and contains no entry for Micah Sullivan.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/031_custodian_files_officer_certificate.html`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/10_expert_material/079_expert_material_officer_certificate.html`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-30, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Leona Park.\n\n### F-12 — third-party subpoena deadline (low)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for third-party subpoena deadline: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-LD-2708-L872, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-LD-2708-U159.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/05_email_families/034_email_families_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/11_third_party/082_third_party_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-30, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Isaac Romero.\n\n### F-13 — production gap (critical)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for production gap: one source states the applicable location is Middle District of Tennessee, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to Tennessee operations outside Middle District of Tennessee.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/05_email_families/037_email_families_review_memorandum.json`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/11_third_party/085_third_party_review_memorandum.json`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-30, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Sofia Bennett.\n\n### F-14 — metadata field loss (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for metadata field loss: one source states the threshold is 9% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 12% and produced a different exception result.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/05_email_families/040_email_families_status_report.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/11_third_party/088_third_party_status_report.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-30, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Adrian Mensah.\n\n### F-15 — Bates-range overlap (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for Bates-range overlap: one source states formal notice must use notices-highland_medical_analytics@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-patel_securities_action@example.test.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/043_chat_exports_correspondence.eml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/12_case_management/091_case_management_correspondence.eml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-30, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Willa Novak.\n\n### F-16 — meet-and-confer commitment (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for meet-and-confer commitment: one source states the governed population contains 102 records through 2025-12-03, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 65 records through 2026-01-09.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/046_chat_exports_formal_notice.xml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/12_case_management/094_case_management_formal_notice.xml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-30, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Theo Laurent.\n\n## Recommended next actions\n\nSequence the critical and high findings first, assign the named owners, preserve the cited records, and document any resolution in the controlling matter register before the stated deadline.\n\n## Assumptions and limitations\n\nThis analysis is confined to task cb100-038-highland-securities and the supplied synthetic evidence. It does not rely on external facts, does not resolve disputed law, and is not legal advice for a real person or entity.\n", "findings": {"as_of": "2026-09-30", "findings": [{"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/07_privilege_material/049_privilege_material_control_register.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for custodian omission: one source states the operative date is 2025-07-28 under control reference CB-LD-2708-A366, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2025-08-08 under response reference CB-LD-2708-J951.", "id": "F-01", "issue": "custodian omission", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/01_pleadings/001_pleadings_control_register.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-30, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Maya Ellison.", "severity": "critical"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/07_privilege_material/052_privilege_material_ledger_export.csv", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for legal-hold delivery gap: one source states the controlling amount is $330,535.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $587,570.00.", "id": "F-02", "issue": "legal-hold delivery gap", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/01_pleadings/004_pleadings_ledger_export.csv", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-30, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Rafael Okafor.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/07_privilege_material/055_privilege_material_officer_certificate.html", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for collection-date inconsistency: one source states approval is attributed to Micah Sullivan as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Micah Sullivan and contains no entry for Micah Sullivan.", "id": "F-03", "issue": "collection-date inconsistency", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/01_pleadings/007_pleadings_officer_certificate.html", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-30, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Nora Chen.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/08_production_logs/058_production_logs_executed_instrument.txt", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for email-family separation: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-LD-2708-D650, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-LD-2708-M557.", "id": "F-04", "issue": "email-family separation", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/02_orders/010_orders_executed_instrument.txt", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-30, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Dominic Alvarez.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/08_production_logs/061_production_logs_review_memorandum.json", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for privilege-log description defect: one source states the applicable location is Middle District of Tennessee, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to Tennessee operations outside Middle District of Tennessee.", "id": "F-05", "issue": "privilege-log description defect", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/02_orders/013_orders_review_memorandum.json", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-30, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Priya Raman.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/08_production_logs/064_production_logs_status_report.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for common-interest support gap: one source states the threshold is 12% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 18% and produced a different exception result.", "id": "F-06", "issue": "common-interest support gap", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/02_orders/016_orders_status_report.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-30, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Elliot Mercer.", "severity": "low"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/09_depositions/067_depositions_correspondence.eml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for clawback deadline: one source states formal notice must use notices-highland_medical_analytics@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-patel_securities_action@example.test.", "id": "F-07", "issue": "clawback deadline", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/019_requests_responses_correspondence.eml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-30, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Talia Brooks.", "severity": "critical"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/09_depositions/070_depositions_formal_notice.xml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for protective-order designation error: one source states the governed population contains 170 records through 2026-02-09, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 65 records through 2026-03-18.", "id": "F-08", "issue": "protective-order designation error", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/022_requests_responses_formal_notice.xml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-30, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Jonas Feld.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/10_expert_material/073_expert_material_control_register.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for request-response mismatch: one source states the operative date is 2025-07-02 under control reference CB-LD-2708-I820, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2025-08-09 under response reference CB-LD-2708-R432.", "id": "F-09", "issue": "request-response mismatch", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/025_custodian_files_control_register.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-30, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Mei Whitaker.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/10_expert_material/076_expert_material_ledger_export.csv", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for deposition exhibit omission: one source states the controlling amount is $4,164,240.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $4,394,980.00.", "id": "F-10", "issue": "deposition exhibit omission", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/028_custodian_files_ledger_export.csv", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-30, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Caleb Hassan.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/10_expert_material/079_expert_material_officer_certificate.html", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for expert draft segregation: one source states approval is attributed to Micah Sullivan as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Isaac Romero and contains no entry for Micah Sullivan.", "id": "F-11", "issue": "expert draft segregation", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/031_custodian_files_officer_certificate.html", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-30, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Leona Park.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/11_third_party/082_third_party_executed_instrument.txt", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for third-party subpoena deadline: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-LD-2708-L872, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-LD-2708-U159.", "id": "F-12", "issue": "third-party subpoena deadline", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/05_email_families/034_email_families_executed_instrument.txt", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-30, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Isaac Romero.", "severity": "low"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/11_third_party/085_third_party_review_memorandum.json", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for production gap: one source states the applicable location is Middle District of Tennessee, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to Tennessee operations outside Middle District of Tennessee.", "id": "F-13", "issue": "production gap", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/05_email_families/037_email_families_review_memorandum.json", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-30, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Sofia Bennett.", "severity": "critical"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/11_third_party/088_third_party_status_report.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for metadata field loss: one source states the threshold is 9% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 12% and produced a different exception result.", "id": "F-14", "issue": "metadata field loss", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/05_email_families/040_email_families_status_report.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-30, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Adrian Mensah.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/12_case_management/091_case_management_correspondence.eml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for Bates-range overlap: one source states formal notice must use notices-highland_medical_analytics@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-patel_securities_action@example.test.", "id": "F-15", "issue": "Bates-range overlap", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/043_chat_exports_correspondence.eml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-30, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Willa Novak.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/12_case_management/094_case_management_formal_notice.xml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for meet-and-confer commitment: one source states the governed population contains 102 records through 2025-12-03, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 65 records through 2026-01-09.", "id": "F-16", "issue": "meet-and-confer commitment", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/046_chat_exports_formal_notice.xml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-30, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Theo Laurent.", "severity": "medium"}], "matter_number": "CB-LD-2708", "prepared_for": "Highland Medical Analytics", "schema_version": "1.0", "task_id": "cb100-038-highland-securities"}}, "metadata": {"benchmark": "CounselBench-100", "code_license": "Apache-2.0", "data_license": "CC-BY-4.0", "deadline": "2026-09-30", "document_count": 96, "jurisdiction": "Tennessee", "matter_number": "CB-LD-2708", "mcp_commit": "9a96ea6e5913736f92b88345bf51caeaaa8e719f", "mcp_package": "@modelcontextprotocol/server-filesystem@2026.7.10", "practice_area": "litigation-discovery", "reference_tool_calls": 46, "required_evidence_reads": 33, "synthetic": true, "venue": "Middle District of Tennessee", "version": "2.0.0"}, "prompt": "You are discovery counsel for Highland Medical Analytics. The supervising attorney wants an exception-focused review that still demonstrates complete coverage of the data room. A securities action requires collection from executives, messaging platforms, and board portals after an acquisition changed account ownership. Decision due 2026-09-30. Tennessee law governs; Middle District of Tennessee is the forum. Preserve the difference between the client's position, the counterparty's position, and an objective record conflict. Work out the defensible position from the matter production and leave an audit-ready exception tracker and concise advice for the supervising lawyer. Keep confirmed conflicts separate from open questions, cite the records that actually control each conclusion, and do not fill gaps with outside facts.", "rubric": {"criteria": [{"category": "procedure", "description": "Complete at least 46 successful, argument-specific evidence and output calls.", "id": "procedure.minimum_successful_tool_calls"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Find and read the 33 controlling, corroborating, and work-product-control records in full.", "id": "procedure.all_evidence_read_in_full"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Inspect file metadata for the eight designated critical primary records before relying on them.", "id": "procedure.chain_of_custody_metadata_checked"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Confirm the sandbox's allowed document and output roots.", "id": "procedure.allowed_directories_checked"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Inventory all 96 records so the relevant sources are discovered among the context records.", "id": "procedure.recursive_inventory_completed"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Search the production for email evidence that may corroborate or contradict formal records.", "id": "procedure.targeted_search_completed"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Leave only findings.json and advice.md in the output workspace.", "id": "procedure.exact_deliverable_set"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Create both final work products through the sandbox MCP surface.", "id": "procedure.deliverables_written_through_mcp"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Produce findings.json as a valid JSON object.", "id": "findings.findings_is_object"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Report exactly 16 confirmed exceptions.", "id": "findings.findings_exact_count"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Use each stable finding ID exactly once.", "id": "findings.finding_ids_unique"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set schema_version to the released matter value '1.0'.", "id": "findings.top_level_schema_version"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set task_id to the released matter value 'cb100-038-highland-securities'.", "id": "findings.top_level_task_id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set matter_number to the released matter value 'CB-LD-2708'.", "id": "findings.top_level_matter_number"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set prepared_for to the released matter value 'Highland Medical Analytics'.", "id": "findings.top_level_prepared_for"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set as_of to the released matter value '2026-09-30'.", "id": "findings.top_level_as_of"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-01 exception for custodian omission.", "id": "findings.F-01.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's id from /workspace/documents/01_pleadings/001_pleadings_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_privilege_material/049_privilege_material_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's issue from /workspace/documents/01_pleadings/001_pleadings_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_privilege_material/049_privilege_material_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's severity from /workspace/documents/01_pleadings/001_pleadings_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_privilege_material/049_privilege_material_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's primary_source from /workspace/documents/01_pleadings/001_pleadings_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_privilege_material/049_privilege_material_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/01_pleadings/001_pleadings_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_privilege_material/049_privilege_material_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-01 using the exact controlled facts ['2025-07-28', 'CB-LD-2708-A366', '2025-08-08', 'CB-LD-2708-J951'].", "id": "findings.F-01.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-01's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-01.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-30', 'Maya Ellison'] for F-01.", "id": "findings.F-01.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-02 exception for legal-hold delivery gap.", "id": "findings.F-02.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's id from /workspace/documents/01_pleadings/004_pleadings_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_privilege_material/052_privilege_material_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's issue from /workspace/documents/01_pleadings/004_pleadings_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_privilege_material/052_privilege_material_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's severity from /workspace/documents/01_pleadings/004_pleadings_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_privilege_material/052_privilege_material_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's primary_source from /workspace/documents/01_pleadings/004_pleadings_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_privilege_material/052_privilege_material_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/01_pleadings/004_pleadings_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_privilege_material/052_privilege_material_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-02 using the exact controlled facts ['$330,535.00', '$587,570.00'].", "id": "findings.F-02.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-02's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-02.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-30', 'Rafael Okafor'] for F-02.", "id": "findings.F-02.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-03 exception for collection-date inconsistency.", "id": "findings.F-03.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's id from /workspace/documents/01_pleadings/007_pleadings_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_privilege_material/055_privilege_material_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's issue from /workspace/documents/01_pleadings/007_pleadings_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_privilege_material/055_privilege_material_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's severity from /workspace/documents/01_pleadings/007_pleadings_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_privilege_material/055_privilege_material_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's primary_source from /workspace/documents/01_pleadings/007_pleadings_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_privilege_material/055_privilege_material_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/01_pleadings/007_pleadings_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_privilege_material/055_privilege_material_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-03 using the exact controlled facts ['Micah Sullivan', 'Micah Sullivan'].", "id": "findings.F-03.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-03's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-03.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-30', 'Nora Chen'] for F-03.", "id": "findings.F-03.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-04 exception for email-family separation.", "id": "findings.F-04.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's id from /workspace/documents/02_orders/010_orders_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_production_logs/058_production_logs_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's issue from /workspace/documents/02_orders/010_orders_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_production_logs/058_production_logs_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's severity from /workspace/documents/02_orders/010_orders_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_production_logs/058_production_logs_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's primary_source from /workspace/documents/02_orders/010_orders_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_production_logs/058_production_logs_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/02_orders/010_orders_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_production_logs/058_production_logs_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-04 using the exact controlled facts ['closed without exception', 'CB-LD-2708-D650', 'open and escalated', 'CB-LD-2708-M557'].", "id": "findings.F-04.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-04's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-04.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-30', 'Dominic Alvarez'] for F-04.", "id": "findings.F-04.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-05 exception for privilege-log description defect.", "id": "findings.F-05.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's id from /workspace/documents/02_orders/013_orders_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_production_logs/061_production_logs_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's issue from /workspace/documents/02_orders/013_orders_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_production_logs/061_production_logs_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's severity from /workspace/documents/02_orders/013_orders_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_production_logs/061_production_logs_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's primary_source from /workspace/documents/02_orders/013_orders_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_production_logs/061_production_logs_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/02_orders/013_orders_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_production_logs/061_production_logs_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-05 using the exact controlled facts ['Middle District of Tennessee', 'Tennessee'].", "id": "findings.F-05.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-05's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-05.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-30', 'Priya Raman'] for F-05.", "id": "findings.F-05.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-06 exception for common-interest support gap.", "id": "findings.F-06.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's id from /workspace/documents/02_orders/016_orders_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_production_logs/064_production_logs_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's issue from /workspace/documents/02_orders/016_orders_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_production_logs/064_production_logs_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's severity from /workspace/documents/02_orders/016_orders_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_production_logs/064_production_logs_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's primary_source from /workspace/documents/02_orders/016_orders_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_production_logs/064_production_logs_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/02_orders/016_orders_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_production_logs/064_production_logs_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-06 using the exact controlled facts ['12%', '18%'].", "id": "findings.F-06.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-06's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-06.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-30', 'Elliot Mercer'] for F-06.", "id": "findings.F-06.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-07 exception for clawback deadline.", "id": "findings.F-07.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's id from /workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/019_requests_responses_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_depositions/067_depositions_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's issue from /workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/019_requests_responses_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_depositions/067_depositions_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's severity from /workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/019_requests_responses_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_depositions/067_depositions_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's primary_source from /workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/019_requests_responses_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_depositions/067_depositions_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/019_requests_responses_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_depositions/067_depositions_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-07 using the exact controlled facts ['notices-highland_medical_analytics@example.test', 'archive-patel_securities_action@example.test'].", "id": "findings.F-07.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-07's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-07.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-30', 'Talia Brooks'] for F-07.", "id": "findings.F-07.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-08 exception for protective-order designation error.", "id": "findings.F-08.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's id from /workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/022_requests_responses_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_depositions/070_depositions_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's issue from /workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/022_requests_responses_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_depositions/070_depositions_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's severity from /workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/022_requests_responses_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_depositions/070_depositions_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's primary_source from /workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/022_requests_responses_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_depositions/070_depositions_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/022_requests_responses_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_depositions/070_depositions_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-08 using the exact controlled facts ['170 records', '2026-02-09', '65 records', '2026-03-18'].", "id": "findings.F-08.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-08's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-08.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-30', 'Jonas Feld'] for F-08.", "id": "findings.F-08.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-09 exception for request-response mismatch.", "id": "findings.F-09.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's id from /workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/025_custodian_files_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_expert_material/073_expert_material_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's issue from /workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/025_custodian_files_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_expert_material/073_expert_material_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's severity from /workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/025_custodian_files_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_expert_material/073_expert_material_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's primary_source from /workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/025_custodian_files_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_expert_material/073_expert_material_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/025_custodian_files_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_expert_material/073_expert_material_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-09 using the exact controlled facts ['2025-07-02', 'CB-LD-2708-I820', '2025-08-09', 'CB-LD-2708-R432'].", "id": "findings.F-09.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-09's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-09.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-30', 'Mei Whitaker'] for F-09.", "id": "findings.F-09.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-10 exception for deposition exhibit omission.", "id": "findings.F-10.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's id from /workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/028_custodian_files_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_expert_material/076_expert_material_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's issue from /workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/028_custodian_files_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_expert_material/076_expert_material_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's severity from /workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/028_custodian_files_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_expert_material/076_expert_material_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's primary_source from /workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/028_custodian_files_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_expert_material/076_expert_material_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/028_custodian_files_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_expert_material/076_expert_material_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-10 using the exact controlled facts ['$4,164,240.00', '$4,394,980.00'].", "id": "findings.F-10.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-10's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-10.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-30', 'Caleb Hassan'] for F-10.", "id": "findings.F-10.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-11 exception for expert draft segregation.", "id": "findings.F-11.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's id from /workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/031_custodian_files_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_expert_material/079_expert_material_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's issue from /workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/031_custodian_files_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_expert_material/079_expert_material_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's severity from /workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/031_custodian_files_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_expert_material/079_expert_material_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's primary_source from /workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/031_custodian_files_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_expert_material/079_expert_material_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/031_custodian_files_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_expert_material/079_expert_material_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-11 using the exact controlled facts ['Micah Sullivan', 'Isaac Romero'].", "id": "findings.F-11.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-11's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-11.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-30', 'Leona Park'] for F-11.", "id": "findings.F-11.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-12 exception for third-party subpoena deadline.", "id": "findings.F-12.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's id from /workspace/documents/05_email_families/034_email_families_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_third_party/082_third_party_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's issue from /workspace/documents/05_email_families/034_email_families_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_third_party/082_third_party_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's severity from /workspace/documents/05_email_families/034_email_families_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_third_party/082_third_party_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's primary_source from /workspace/documents/05_email_families/034_email_families_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_third_party/082_third_party_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/05_email_families/034_email_families_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_third_party/082_third_party_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-12 using the exact controlled facts ['closed without exception', 'CB-LD-2708-L872', 'open and escalated', 'CB-LD-2708-U159'].", "id": "findings.F-12.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-12's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-12.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-30', 'Isaac Romero'] for F-12.", "id": "findings.F-12.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-13 exception for production gap.", "id": "findings.F-13.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's id from /workspace/documents/05_email_families/037_email_families_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_third_party/085_third_party_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's issue from /workspace/documents/05_email_families/037_email_families_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_third_party/085_third_party_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's severity from /workspace/documents/05_email_families/037_email_families_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_third_party/085_third_party_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's primary_source from /workspace/documents/05_email_families/037_email_families_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_third_party/085_third_party_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/05_email_families/037_email_families_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_third_party/085_third_party_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-13 using the exact controlled facts ['Middle District of Tennessee', 'Tennessee'].", "id": "findings.F-13.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-13's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-13.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-30', 'Sofia Bennett'] for F-13.", "id": "findings.F-13.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-14 exception for metadata field loss.", "id": "findings.F-14.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's id from /workspace/documents/05_email_families/040_email_families_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_third_party/088_third_party_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's issue from /workspace/documents/05_email_families/040_email_families_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_third_party/088_third_party_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's severity from /workspace/documents/05_email_families/040_email_families_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_third_party/088_third_party_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's primary_source from /workspace/documents/05_email_families/040_email_families_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_third_party/088_third_party_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/05_email_families/040_email_families_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_third_party/088_third_party_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-14 using the exact controlled facts ['9%', '12%'].", "id": "findings.F-14.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-14's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-14.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-30', 'Adrian Mensah'] for F-14.", "id": "findings.F-14.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-15 exception for Bates-range overlap.", "id": "findings.F-15.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's id from /workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/043_chat_exports_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_case_management/091_case_management_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's issue from /workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/043_chat_exports_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_case_management/091_case_management_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's severity from /workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/043_chat_exports_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_case_management/091_case_management_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's primary_source from /workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/043_chat_exports_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_case_management/091_case_management_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/043_chat_exports_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_case_management/091_case_management_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-15 using the exact controlled facts ['notices-highland_medical_analytics@example.test', 'archive-patel_securities_action@example.test'].", "id": "findings.F-15.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-15's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-15.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-30', 'Willa Novak'] for F-15.", "id": "findings.F-15.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-16 exception for meet-and-confer commitment.", "id": "findings.F-16.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's id from /workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/046_chat_exports_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_case_management/094_case_management_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's issue from /workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/046_chat_exports_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_case_management/094_case_management_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's severity from /workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/046_chat_exports_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_case_management/094_case_management_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's primary_source from /workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/046_chat_exports_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_case_management/094_case_management_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/046_chat_exports_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_case_management/094_case_management_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-16 using the exact controlled facts ['102 records', '2025-12-03', '65 records', '2026-01-09'].", "id": "findings.F-16.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-16's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-16.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-30', 'Theo Laurent'] for F-16.", "id": "findings.F-16.action_anchors"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Executive assessment' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Executive assessment"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Method and record coverage' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Method and record coverage"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Findings' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Findings"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Recommended next actions' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Recommended next actions"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Assumptions and limitations' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Assumptions and limitations"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-01 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-01"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-02 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-02"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-03 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-03"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-04 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-04"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-05 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-05"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-06 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-06"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-07 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-07"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-08 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-08"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-09 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-09"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-10 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-10"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-11 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-11"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-12 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-12"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-13 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-13"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-14 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-14"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-15 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-15"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-16 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-16"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Do not claim the production has no issues or that every record is consistent.", "id": "memo.forbidden_claims_absent"}], "decision_options": [{"id": "cross-source-reconciliation", "label": "Reconcile controlling and corroborating records", "reason": "The CB-LD-2708 production contains independently maintained records; a defensible answer must preserve each supported conflict and its cure owner.", "selected": true}, {"id": "latest-record-controls", "label": "Treat the latest record as controlling", "reason": "Timestamp recency does not establish legal priority, execution, or approval authority.", "selected": false}, {"id": "primary-records-only", "label": "Report primary records without reconciliation", "reason": "Primary records alone conceal the operational conflicts that create the actionable exceptions.", "selected": false}], "gates": ["all_evidence_read_in_full", "chain_of_custody_metadata_checked", "findings_criteria_complete", "memo_criteria_complete", "deliverables_written_through_mcp"], "metadata_checks": 8, "metric": "weighted_criteria_score", "minimum_tool_calls": 46, "required_deliverables": ["findings.json", "advice.md"], "required_document_reads": 33, "type": "deterministic", "weights": {"findings": 0.55, "memo": 0.2, "procedure": 0.25}}, "task_id": "cb100-038-highland-securities", "task_name": "Highland securities case hold audit", "world_id": "counselbench-filesystem-mcp-v2"}
-{"context_files": ["task_files/cb100-039-isotope-environmental/01_pleadings/001_pleadings_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-039-isotope-environmental/01_pleadings/002_pleadings_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-039-isotope-environmental/01_pleadings/003_pleadings_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-039-isotope-environmental/01_pleadings/004_pleadings_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-039-isotope-environmental/01_pleadings/005_pleadings_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-039-isotope-environmental/01_pleadings/006_pleadings_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-039-isotope-environmental/01_pleadings/007_pleadings_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-039-isotope-environmental/01_pleadings/008_pleadings_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-039-isotope-environmental/02_orders/009_orders_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-039-isotope-environmental/02_orders/010_orders_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-039-isotope-environmental/02_orders/011_orders_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-039-isotope-environmental/02_orders/012_orders_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-039-isotope-environmental/02_orders/013_orders_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-039-isotope-environmental/02_orders/014_orders_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-039-isotope-environmental/02_orders/015_orders_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-039-isotope-environmental/02_orders/016_orders_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-039-isotope-environmental/03_requests_responses/017_requests_responses_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-039-isotope-environmental/03_requests_responses/018_requests_responses_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-039-isotope-environmental/03_requests_responses/019_requests_responses_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-039-isotope-environmental/03_requests_responses/020_requests_responses_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-039-isotope-environmental/03_requests_responses/021_requests_responses_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-039-isotope-environmental/03_requests_responses/022_requests_responses_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-039-isotope-environmental/03_requests_responses/023_requests_responses_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-039-isotope-environmental/03_requests_responses/024_requests_responses_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-039-isotope-environmental/04_custodian_files/025_custodian_files_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-039-isotope-environmental/04_custodian_files/026_custodian_files_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-039-isotope-environmental/04_custodian_files/027_custodian_files_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-039-isotope-environmental/04_custodian_files/028_custodian_files_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-039-isotope-environmental/04_custodian_files/029_custodian_files_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-039-isotope-environmental/04_custodian_files/030_custodian_files_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-039-isotope-environmental/04_custodian_files/031_custodian_files_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-039-isotope-environmental/04_custodian_files/032_custodian_files_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-039-isotope-environmental/05_email_families/033_email_families_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-039-isotope-environmental/05_email_families/034_email_families_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-039-isotope-environmental/05_email_families/035_email_families_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-039-isotope-environmental/05_email_families/036_email_families_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-039-isotope-environmental/05_email_families/037_email_families_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-039-isotope-environmental/05_email_families/038_email_families_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-039-isotope-environmental/05_email_families/039_email_families_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-039-isotope-environmental/05_email_families/040_email_families_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-039-isotope-environmental/06_chat_exports/041_chat_exports_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-039-isotope-environmental/06_chat_exports/042_chat_exports_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-039-isotope-environmental/06_chat_exports/043_chat_exports_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-039-isotope-environmental/06_chat_exports/044_chat_exports_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-039-isotope-environmental/06_chat_exports/045_chat_exports_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-039-isotope-environmental/06_chat_exports/046_chat_exports_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-039-isotope-environmental/06_chat_exports/047_chat_exports_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-039-isotope-environmental/06_chat_exports/048_chat_exports_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-039-isotope-environmental/07_privilege_material/049_privilege_material_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-039-isotope-environmental/07_privilege_material/050_privilege_material_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-039-isotope-environmental/07_privilege_material/051_privilege_material_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-039-isotope-environmental/07_privilege_material/052_privilege_material_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-039-isotope-environmental/07_privilege_material/053_privilege_material_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-039-isotope-environmental/07_privilege_material/054_privilege_material_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-039-isotope-environmental/07_privilege_material/055_privilege_material_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-039-isotope-environmental/07_privilege_material/056_privilege_material_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-039-isotope-environmental/08_production_logs/057_production_logs_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-039-isotope-environmental/08_production_logs/058_production_logs_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-039-isotope-environmental/08_production_logs/059_production_logs_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-039-isotope-environmental/08_production_logs/060_production_logs_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-039-isotope-environmental/08_production_logs/061_production_logs_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-039-isotope-environmental/08_production_logs/062_production_logs_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-039-isotope-environmental/08_production_logs/063_production_logs_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-039-isotope-environmental/08_production_logs/064_production_logs_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-039-isotope-environmental/09_depositions/065_depositions_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-039-isotope-environmental/09_depositions/066_depositions_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-039-isotope-environmental/09_depositions/067_depositions_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-039-isotope-environmental/09_depositions/068_depositions_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-039-isotope-environmental/09_depositions/069_depositions_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-039-isotope-environmental/09_depositions/070_depositions_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-039-isotope-environmental/09_depositions/071_depositions_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-039-isotope-environmental/09_depositions/072_depositions_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-039-isotope-environmental/10_expert_material/073_expert_material_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-039-isotope-environmental/10_expert_material/074_expert_material_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-039-isotope-environmental/10_expert_material/075_expert_material_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-039-isotope-environmental/10_expert_material/076_expert_material_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-039-isotope-environmental/10_expert_material/077_expert_material_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-039-isotope-environmental/10_expert_material/078_expert_material_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-039-isotope-environmental/10_expert_material/079_expert_material_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-039-isotope-environmental/10_expert_material/080_expert_material_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-039-isotope-environmental/11_third_party/081_third_party_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-039-isotope-environmental/11_third_party/082_third_party_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-039-isotope-environmental/11_third_party/083_third_party_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-039-isotope-environmental/11_third_party/084_third_party_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-039-isotope-environmental/11_third_party/085_third_party_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-039-isotope-environmental/11_third_party/086_third_party_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-039-isotope-environmental/11_third_party/087_third_party_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-039-isotope-environmental/11_third_party/088_third_party_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-039-isotope-environmental/12_case_management/089_case_management_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-039-isotope-environmental/12_case_management/090_case_management_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-039-isotope-environmental/12_case_management/091_case_management_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-039-isotope-environmental/12_case_management/092_case_management_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-039-isotope-environmental/12_case_management/093_case_management_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-039-isotope-environmental/12_case_management/094_case_management_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-039-isotope-environmental/12_case_management/095_case_management_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-039-isotope-environmental/12_case_management/096_case_management_status_report.md"], "gold_output": {"advice_markdown": "# Counsel advice — Isotope contamination case production check\n\n## Executive assessment\n\nFor Isotope Specialty Chemicals matter CB-LD-2709, the review identified 16 source-supported exceptions requiring action before 2026-10-03. The assessment concerns County of Briar v. Isotope and the supplied record for Louisiana.\n\n## Method and record coverage\n\nThe review inventoried all 96 production files, read the 33 controlling, corroborating, and control records, searched the email exports, and checked metadata for the designated chain-of-custody sample. Conclusions are limited to the synthetic production supplied for this benchmark matter.\n\n## Findings\n\n### F-01 — custodian omission (critical)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for custodian omission: one source states the operative date is 2025-01-08 under control reference CB-LD-2709-A465, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2025-02-02 under response reference CB-LD-2709-J751.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/01_pleadings/001_pleadings_control_register.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/07_privilege_material/049_privilege_material_control_register.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-10-03, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Rafael Okafor.\n\n### F-02 — legal-hold delivery gap (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for legal-hold delivery gap: one source states the controlling amount is $2,947,027.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $2,960,554.00.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/01_pleadings/004_pleadings_ledger_export.csv`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/07_privilege_material/052_privilege_material_ledger_export.csv`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-10-03, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Nora Chen.\n\n### F-03 — collection-date inconsistency (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for collection-date inconsistency: one source states approval is attributed to Farah Ibrahim as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Owen Delgado and contains no entry for Farah Ibrahim.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/01_pleadings/007_pleadings_officer_certificate.html`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/07_privilege_material/055_privilege_material_officer_certificate.html`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-10-03, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Dominic Alvarez.\n\n### F-04 — email-family separation (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for email-family separation: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-LD-2709-D284, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-LD-2709-M460.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/02_orders/010_orders_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/08_production_logs/058_production_logs_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-10-03, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Priya Raman.\n\n### F-05 — privilege-log description defect (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for privilege-log description defect: one source states the applicable location is Eastern District of Louisiana, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to Louisiana operations outside Eastern District of Louisiana.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/02_orders/013_orders_review_memorandum.json`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/08_production_logs/061_production_logs_review_memorandum.json`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-10-03, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Elliot Mercer.\n\n### F-06 — common-interest support gap (low)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for common-interest support gap: one source states the threshold is 13% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 20% and produced a different exception result.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/02_orders/016_orders_status_report.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/08_production_logs/064_production_logs_status_report.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-10-03, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Talia Brooks.\n\n### F-07 — clawback deadline (critical)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for clawback deadline: one source states formal notice must use notices-isotope_specialty_chemicals@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-county_of_briar_v_isotope@example.test.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/019_requests_responses_correspondence.eml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/09_depositions/067_depositions_correspondence.eml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-10-03, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Jonas Feld.\n\n### F-08 — protective-order designation error (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for protective-order designation error: one source states the governed population contains 105 records through 2025-07-19, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 61 records through 2025-08-21.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/022_requests_responses_formal_notice.xml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/09_depositions/070_depositions_formal_notice.xml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-10-03, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Mei Whitaker.\n\n### F-09 — request-response mismatch (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for request-response mismatch: one source states the operative date is 2025-01-03 under control reference CB-LD-2709-I760, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2025-02-12 under response reference CB-LD-2709-R981.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/025_custodian_files_control_register.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/10_expert_material/073_expert_material_control_register.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-10-03, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Caleb Hassan.\n\n### F-10 — deposition exhibit omission (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for deposition exhibit omission: one source states the controlling amount is $325,716.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $437,932.00.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/028_custodian_files_ledger_export.csv`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/10_expert_material/076_expert_material_ledger_export.csv`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-10-03, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Leona Park.\n\n### F-11 — expert draft segregation (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for expert draft segregation: one source states approval is attributed to Farah Ibrahim as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Adrian Mensah and contains no entry for Farah Ibrahim.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/031_custodian_files_officer_certificate.html`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/10_expert_material/079_expert_material_officer_certificate.html`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-10-03, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Isaac Romero.\n\n### F-12 — third-party subpoena deadline (low)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for third-party subpoena deadline: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-LD-2709-L580, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-LD-2709-U760.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/05_email_families/034_email_families_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/11_third_party/082_third_party_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-10-03, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Sofia Bennett.\n\n### F-13 — production gap (critical)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for production gap: one source states the applicable location is Eastern District of Louisiana, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to Louisiana operations outside Eastern District of Louisiana.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/05_email_families/037_email_families_review_memorandum.json`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/11_third_party/085_third_party_review_memorandum.json`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-10-03, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Adrian Mensah.\n\n### F-14 — metadata field loss (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for metadata field loss: one source states the threshold is 10% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 16% and produced a different exception result.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/05_email_families/040_email_families_status_report.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/11_third_party/088_third_party_status_report.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-10-03, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Willa Novak.\n\n### F-15 — Bates-range overlap (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for Bates-range overlap: one source states formal notice must use notices-isotope_specialty_chemicals@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-county_of_briar_v_isotope@example.test.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/043_chat_exports_correspondence.eml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/12_case_management/091_case_management_correspondence.eml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-10-03, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Theo Laurent.\n\n### F-16 — meet-and-confer commitment (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for meet-and-confer commitment: one source states the governed population contains 171 records through 2025-09-23, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 63 records through 2025-10-28.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/046_chat_exports_formal_notice.xml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/12_case_management/094_case_management_formal_notice.xml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-10-03, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Amara Patel.\n\n## Recommended next actions\n\nSequence the critical and high findings first, assign the named owners, preserve the cited records, and document any resolution in the controlling matter register before the stated deadline.\n\n## Assumptions and limitations\n\nThis analysis is confined to task cb100-039-isotope-environmental and the supplied synthetic evidence. It does not rely on external facts, does not resolve disputed law, and is not legal advice for a real person or entity.\n", "findings": {"as_of": "2026-10-03", "findings": [{"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/07_privilege_material/049_privilege_material_control_register.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for custodian omission: one source states the operative date is 2025-01-08 under control reference CB-LD-2709-A465, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2025-02-02 under response reference CB-LD-2709-J751.", "id": "F-01", "issue": "custodian omission", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/01_pleadings/001_pleadings_control_register.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-10-03, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Rafael Okafor.", "severity": "critical"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/07_privilege_material/052_privilege_material_ledger_export.csv", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for legal-hold delivery gap: one source states the controlling amount is $2,947,027.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $2,960,554.00.", "id": "F-02", "issue": "legal-hold delivery gap", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/01_pleadings/004_pleadings_ledger_export.csv", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-10-03, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Nora Chen.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/07_privilege_material/055_privilege_material_officer_certificate.html", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for collection-date inconsistency: one source states approval is attributed to Farah Ibrahim as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Owen Delgado and contains no entry for Farah Ibrahim.", "id": "F-03", "issue": "collection-date inconsistency", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/01_pleadings/007_pleadings_officer_certificate.html", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-10-03, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Dominic Alvarez.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/08_production_logs/058_production_logs_executed_instrument.txt", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for email-family separation: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-LD-2709-D284, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-LD-2709-M460.", "id": "F-04", "issue": "email-family separation", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/02_orders/010_orders_executed_instrument.txt", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-10-03, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Priya Raman.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/08_production_logs/061_production_logs_review_memorandum.json", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for privilege-log description defect: one source states the applicable location is Eastern District of Louisiana, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to Louisiana operations outside Eastern District of Louisiana.", "id": "F-05", "issue": "privilege-log description defect", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/02_orders/013_orders_review_memorandum.json", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-10-03, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Elliot Mercer.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/08_production_logs/064_production_logs_status_report.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for common-interest support gap: one source states the threshold is 13% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 20% and produced a different exception result.", "id": "F-06", "issue": "common-interest support gap", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/02_orders/016_orders_status_report.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-10-03, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Talia Brooks.", "severity": "low"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/09_depositions/067_depositions_correspondence.eml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for clawback deadline: one source states formal notice must use notices-isotope_specialty_chemicals@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-county_of_briar_v_isotope@example.test.", "id": "F-07", "issue": "clawback deadline", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/019_requests_responses_correspondence.eml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-10-03, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Jonas Feld.", "severity": "critical"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/09_depositions/070_depositions_formal_notice.xml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for protective-order designation error: one source states the governed population contains 105 records through 2025-07-19, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 61 records through 2025-08-21.", "id": "F-08", "issue": "protective-order designation error", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/022_requests_responses_formal_notice.xml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-10-03, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Mei Whitaker.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/10_expert_material/073_expert_material_control_register.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for request-response mismatch: one source states the operative date is 2025-01-03 under control reference CB-LD-2709-I760, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2025-02-12 under response reference CB-LD-2709-R981.", "id": "F-09", "issue": "request-response mismatch", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/025_custodian_files_control_register.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-10-03, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Caleb Hassan.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/10_expert_material/076_expert_material_ledger_export.csv", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for deposition exhibit omission: one source states the controlling amount is $325,716.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $437,932.00.", "id": "F-10", "issue": "deposition exhibit omission", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/028_custodian_files_ledger_export.csv", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-10-03, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Leona Park.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/10_expert_material/079_expert_material_officer_certificate.html", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for expert draft segregation: one source states approval is attributed to Farah Ibrahim as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Adrian Mensah and contains no entry for Farah Ibrahim.", "id": "F-11", "issue": "expert draft segregation", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/031_custodian_files_officer_certificate.html", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-10-03, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Isaac Romero.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/11_third_party/082_third_party_executed_instrument.txt", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for third-party subpoena deadline: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-LD-2709-L580, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-LD-2709-U760.", "id": "F-12", "issue": "third-party subpoena deadline", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/05_email_families/034_email_families_executed_instrument.txt", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-10-03, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Sofia Bennett.", "severity": "low"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/11_third_party/085_third_party_review_memorandum.json", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for production gap: one source states the applicable location is Eastern District of Louisiana, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to Louisiana operations outside Eastern District of Louisiana.", "id": "F-13", "issue": "production gap", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/05_email_families/037_email_families_review_memorandum.json", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-10-03, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Adrian Mensah.", "severity": "critical"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/11_third_party/088_third_party_status_report.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for metadata field loss: one source states the threshold is 10% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 16% and produced a different exception result.", "id": "F-14", "issue": "metadata field loss", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/05_email_families/040_email_families_status_report.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-10-03, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Willa Novak.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/12_case_management/091_case_management_correspondence.eml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for Bates-range overlap: one source states formal notice must use notices-isotope_specialty_chemicals@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-county_of_briar_v_isotope@example.test.", "id": "F-15", "issue": "Bates-range overlap", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/043_chat_exports_correspondence.eml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-10-03, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Theo Laurent.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/12_case_management/094_case_management_formal_notice.xml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for meet-and-confer commitment: one source states the governed population contains 171 records through 2025-09-23, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 63 records through 2025-10-28.", "id": "F-16", "issue": "meet-and-confer commitment", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/046_chat_exports_formal_notice.xml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-10-03, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Amara Patel.", "severity": "medium"}], "matter_number": "CB-LD-2709", "prepared_for": "Isotope Specialty Chemicals", "schema_version": "1.0", "task_id": "cb100-039-isotope-environmental"}}, "metadata": {"benchmark": "CounselBench-100", "code_license": "Apache-2.0", "data_license": "CC-BY-4.0", "deadline": "2026-10-03", "document_count": 96, "jurisdiction": "Louisiana", "matter_number": "CB-LD-2709", "mcp_commit": "9a96ea6e5913736f92b88345bf51caeaaa8e719f", "mcp_package": "@modelcontextprotocol/server-filesystem@2026.7.10", "practice_area": "litigation-discovery", "reference_tool_calls": 46, "required_evidence_reads": 33, "synthetic": true, "venue": "Eastern District of Louisiana", "version": "2.0.0"}, "prompt": "You are discovery counsel for Isotope Specialty Chemicals. This matter will be reviewed by legal, finance, and compliance stakeholders who need a single source-grounded output. Environmental sampling, consultant drafts, and regulator correspondence present designation, metadata, and expert-discovery questions. Decision due 2026-10-03. Louisiana law governs; Eastern District of Louisiana is the forum. Use the production as of the stated deadline; do not assume facts outside the supplied files. Work out the defensible position from the matter production and leave an audit-ready exception tracker and concise advice for the supervising lawyer. Keep confirmed conflicts separate from open questions, cite the records that actually control each conclusion, and do not fill gaps with outside facts.", "rubric": {"criteria": [{"category": "procedure", "description": "Complete at least 46 successful, argument-specific evidence and output calls.", "id": "procedure.minimum_successful_tool_calls"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Find and read the 33 controlling, corroborating, and work-product-control records in full.", "id": "procedure.all_evidence_read_in_full"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Inspect file metadata for the eight designated critical primary records before relying on them.", "id": "procedure.chain_of_custody_metadata_checked"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Confirm the sandbox's allowed document and output roots.", "id": "procedure.allowed_directories_checked"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Inventory all 96 records so the relevant sources are discovered among the context records.", "id": "procedure.recursive_inventory_completed"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Search the production for email evidence that may corroborate or contradict formal records.", "id": "procedure.targeted_search_completed"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Leave only findings.json and advice.md in the output workspace.", "id": "procedure.exact_deliverable_set"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Create both final work products through the sandbox MCP surface.", "id": "procedure.deliverables_written_through_mcp"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Produce findings.json as a valid JSON object.", "id": "findings.findings_is_object"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Report exactly 16 confirmed exceptions.", "id": "findings.findings_exact_count"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Use each stable finding ID exactly once.", "id": "findings.finding_ids_unique"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set schema_version to the released matter value '1.0'.", "id": "findings.top_level_schema_version"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set task_id to the released matter value 'cb100-039-isotope-environmental'.", "id": "findings.top_level_task_id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set matter_number to the released matter value 'CB-LD-2709'.", "id": "findings.top_level_matter_number"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set prepared_for to the released matter value 'Isotope Specialty Chemicals'.", "id": "findings.top_level_prepared_for"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set as_of to the released matter value '2026-10-03'.", "id": "findings.top_level_as_of"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-01 exception for custodian omission.", "id": "findings.F-01.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's id from /workspace/documents/01_pleadings/001_pleadings_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_privilege_material/049_privilege_material_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's issue from /workspace/documents/01_pleadings/001_pleadings_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_privilege_material/049_privilege_material_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's severity from /workspace/documents/01_pleadings/001_pleadings_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_privilege_material/049_privilege_material_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's primary_source from /workspace/documents/01_pleadings/001_pleadings_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_privilege_material/049_privilege_material_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/01_pleadings/001_pleadings_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_privilege_material/049_privilege_material_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-01 using the exact controlled facts ['2025-01-08', 'CB-LD-2709-A465', '2025-02-02', 'CB-LD-2709-J751'].", "id": "findings.F-01.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-01's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-01.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-10-03', 'Rafael Okafor'] for F-01.", "id": "findings.F-01.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-02 exception for legal-hold delivery gap.", "id": "findings.F-02.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's id from /workspace/documents/01_pleadings/004_pleadings_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_privilege_material/052_privilege_material_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's issue from /workspace/documents/01_pleadings/004_pleadings_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_privilege_material/052_privilege_material_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's severity from /workspace/documents/01_pleadings/004_pleadings_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_privilege_material/052_privilege_material_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's primary_source from /workspace/documents/01_pleadings/004_pleadings_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_privilege_material/052_privilege_material_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/01_pleadings/004_pleadings_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_privilege_material/052_privilege_material_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-02 using the exact controlled facts ['$2,947,027.00', '$2,960,554.00'].", "id": "findings.F-02.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-02's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-02.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-10-03', 'Nora Chen'] for F-02.", "id": "findings.F-02.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-03 exception for collection-date inconsistency.", "id": "findings.F-03.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's id from /workspace/documents/01_pleadings/007_pleadings_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_privilege_material/055_privilege_material_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's issue from /workspace/documents/01_pleadings/007_pleadings_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_privilege_material/055_privilege_material_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's severity from /workspace/documents/01_pleadings/007_pleadings_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_privilege_material/055_privilege_material_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's primary_source from /workspace/documents/01_pleadings/007_pleadings_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_privilege_material/055_privilege_material_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/01_pleadings/007_pleadings_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_privilege_material/055_privilege_material_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-03 using the exact controlled facts ['Farah Ibrahim', 'Owen Delgado'].", "id": "findings.F-03.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-03's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-03.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-10-03', 'Dominic Alvarez'] for F-03.", "id": "findings.F-03.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-04 exception for email-family separation.", "id": "findings.F-04.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's id from /workspace/documents/02_orders/010_orders_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_production_logs/058_production_logs_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's issue from /workspace/documents/02_orders/010_orders_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_production_logs/058_production_logs_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's severity from /workspace/documents/02_orders/010_orders_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_production_logs/058_production_logs_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's primary_source from /workspace/documents/02_orders/010_orders_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_production_logs/058_production_logs_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/02_orders/010_orders_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_production_logs/058_production_logs_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-04 using the exact controlled facts ['closed without exception', 'CB-LD-2709-D284', 'open and escalated', 'CB-LD-2709-M460'].", "id": "findings.F-04.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-04's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-04.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-10-03', 'Priya Raman'] for F-04.", "id": "findings.F-04.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-05 exception for privilege-log description defect.", "id": "findings.F-05.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's id from /workspace/documents/02_orders/013_orders_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_production_logs/061_production_logs_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's issue from /workspace/documents/02_orders/013_orders_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_production_logs/061_production_logs_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's severity from /workspace/documents/02_orders/013_orders_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_production_logs/061_production_logs_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's primary_source from /workspace/documents/02_orders/013_orders_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_production_logs/061_production_logs_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/02_orders/013_orders_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_production_logs/061_production_logs_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-05 using the exact controlled facts ['Eastern District of Louisiana', 'Louisiana'].", "id": "findings.F-05.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-05's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-05.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-10-03', 'Elliot Mercer'] for F-05.", "id": "findings.F-05.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-06 exception for common-interest support gap.", "id": "findings.F-06.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's id from /workspace/documents/02_orders/016_orders_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_production_logs/064_production_logs_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's issue from /workspace/documents/02_orders/016_orders_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_production_logs/064_production_logs_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's severity from /workspace/documents/02_orders/016_orders_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_production_logs/064_production_logs_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's primary_source from /workspace/documents/02_orders/016_orders_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_production_logs/064_production_logs_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/02_orders/016_orders_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_production_logs/064_production_logs_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-06 using the exact controlled facts ['13%', '20%'].", "id": "findings.F-06.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-06's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-06.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-10-03', 'Talia Brooks'] for F-06.", "id": "findings.F-06.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-07 exception for clawback deadline.", "id": "findings.F-07.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's id from /workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/019_requests_responses_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_depositions/067_depositions_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's issue from /workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/019_requests_responses_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_depositions/067_depositions_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's severity from /workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/019_requests_responses_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_depositions/067_depositions_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's primary_source from /workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/019_requests_responses_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_depositions/067_depositions_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/019_requests_responses_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_depositions/067_depositions_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-07 using the exact controlled facts ['notices-isotope_specialty_chemicals@example.test', 'archive-county_of_briar_v_isotope@example.test'].", "id": "findings.F-07.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-07's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-07.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-10-03', 'Jonas Feld'] for F-07.", "id": "findings.F-07.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-08 exception for protective-order designation error.", "id": "findings.F-08.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's id from /workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/022_requests_responses_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_depositions/070_depositions_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's issue from /workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/022_requests_responses_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_depositions/070_depositions_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's severity from /workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/022_requests_responses_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_depositions/070_depositions_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's primary_source from /workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/022_requests_responses_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_depositions/070_depositions_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/022_requests_responses_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_depositions/070_depositions_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-08 using the exact controlled facts ['105 records', '2025-07-19', '61 records', '2025-08-21'].", "id": "findings.F-08.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-08's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-08.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-10-03', 'Mei Whitaker'] for F-08.", "id": "findings.F-08.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-09 exception for request-response mismatch.", "id": "findings.F-09.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's id from /workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/025_custodian_files_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_expert_material/073_expert_material_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's issue from /workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/025_custodian_files_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_expert_material/073_expert_material_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's severity from /workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/025_custodian_files_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_expert_material/073_expert_material_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's primary_source from /workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/025_custodian_files_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_expert_material/073_expert_material_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/025_custodian_files_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_expert_material/073_expert_material_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-09 using the exact controlled facts ['2025-01-03', 'CB-LD-2709-I760', '2025-02-12', 'CB-LD-2709-R981'].", "id": "findings.F-09.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-09's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-09.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-10-03', 'Caleb Hassan'] for F-09.", "id": "findings.F-09.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-10 exception for deposition exhibit omission.", "id": "findings.F-10.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's id from /workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/028_custodian_files_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_expert_material/076_expert_material_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's issue from /workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/028_custodian_files_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_expert_material/076_expert_material_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's severity from /workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/028_custodian_files_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_expert_material/076_expert_material_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's primary_source from /workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/028_custodian_files_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_expert_material/076_expert_material_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/028_custodian_files_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_expert_material/076_expert_material_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-10 using the exact controlled facts ['$325,716.00', '$437,932.00'].", "id": "findings.F-10.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-10's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-10.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-10-03', 'Leona Park'] for F-10.", "id": "findings.F-10.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-11 exception for expert draft segregation.", "id": "findings.F-11.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's id from /workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/031_custodian_files_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_expert_material/079_expert_material_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's issue from /workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/031_custodian_files_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_expert_material/079_expert_material_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's severity from /workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/031_custodian_files_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_expert_material/079_expert_material_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's primary_source from /workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/031_custodian_files_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_expert_material/079_expert_material_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/031_custodian_files_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_expert_material/079_expert_material_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-11 using the exact controlled facts ['Farah Ibrahim', 'Adrian Mensah'].", "id": "findings.F-11.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-11's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-11.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-10-03', 'Isaac Romero'] for F-11.", "id": "findings.F-11.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-12 exception for third-party subpoena deadline.", "id": "findings.F-12.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's id from /workspace/documents/05_email_families/034_email_families_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_third_party/082_third_party_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's issue from /workspace/documents/05_email_families/034_email_families_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_third_party/082_third_party_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's severity from /workspace/documents/05_email_families/034_email_families_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_third_party/082_third_party_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's primary_source from /workspace/documents/05_email_families/034_email_families_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_third_party/082_third_party_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/05_email_families/034_email_families_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_third_party/082_third_party_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-12 using the exact controlled facts ['closed without exception', 'CB-LD-2709-L580', 'open and escalated', 'CB-LD-2709-U760'].", "id": "findings.F-12.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-12's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-12.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-10-03', 'Sofia Bennett'] for F-12.", "id": "findings.F-12.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-13 exception for production gap.", "id": "findings.F-13.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's id from /workspace/documents/05_email_families/037_email_families_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_third_party/085_third_party_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's issue from /workspace/documents/05_email_families/037_email_families_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_third_party/085_third_party_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's severity from /workspace/documents/05_email_families/037_email_families_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_third_party/085_third_party_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's primary_source from /workspace/documents/05_email_families/037_email_families_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_third_party/085_third_party_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/05_email_families/037_email_families_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_third_party/085_third_party_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-13 using the exact controlled facts ['Eastern District of Louisiana', 'Louisiana'].", "id": "findings.F-13.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-13's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-13.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-10-03', 'Adrian Mensah'] for F-13.", "id": "findings.F-13.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-14 exception for metadata field loss.", "id": "findings.F-14.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's id from /workspace/documents/05_email_families/040_email_families_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_third_party/088_third_party_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's issue from /workspace/documents/05_email_families/040_email_families_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_third_party/088_third_party_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's severity from /workspace/documents/05_email_families/040_email_families_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_third_party/088_third_party_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's primary_source from /workspace/documents/05_email_families/040_email_families_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_third_party/088_third_party_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/05_email_families/040_email_families_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_third_party/088_third_party_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-14 using the exact controlled facts ['10%', '16%'].", "id": "findings.F-14.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-14's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-14.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-10-03', 'Willa Novak'] for F-14.", "id": "findings.F-14.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-15 exception for Bates-range overlap.", "id": "findings.F-15.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's id from /workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/043_chat_exports_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_case_management/091_case_management_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's issue from /workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/043_chat_exports_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_case_management/091_case_management_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's severity from /workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/043_chat_exports_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_case_management/091_case_management_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's primary_source from /workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/043_chat_exports_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_case_management/091_case_management_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/043_chat_exports_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_case_management/091_case_management_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-15 using the exact controlled facts ['notices-isotope_specialty_chemicals@example.test', 'archive-county_of_briar_v_isotope@example.test'].", "id": "findings.F-15.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-15's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-15.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-10-03', 'Theo Laurent'] for F-15.", "id": "findings.F-15.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-16 exception for meet-and-confer commitment.", "id": "findings.F-16.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's id from /workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/046_chat_exports_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_case_management/094_case_management_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's issue from /workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/046_chat_exports_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_case_management/094_case_management_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's severity from /workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/046_chat_exports_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_case_management/094_case_management_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's primary_source from /workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/046_chat_exports_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_case_management/094_case_management_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/046_chat_exports_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_case_management/094_case_management_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-16 using the exact controlled facts ['171 records', '2025-09-23', '63 records', '2025-10-28'].", "id": "findings.F-16.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-16's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-16.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-10-03', 'Amara Patel'] for F-16.", "id": "findings.F-16.action_anchors"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Executive assessment' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Executive assessment"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Method and record coverage' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Method and record coverage"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Findings' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Findings"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Recommended next actions' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Recommended next actions"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Assumptions and limitations' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Assumptions and limitations"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-01 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-01"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-02 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-02"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-03 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-03"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-04 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-04"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-05 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-05"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-06 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-06"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-07 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-07"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-08 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-08"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-09 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-09"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-10 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-10"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-11 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-11"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-12 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-12"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-13 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-13"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-14 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-14"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-15 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-15"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-16 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-16"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Do not claim the production has no issues or that every record is consistent.", "id": "memo.forbidden_claims_absent"}], "decision_options": [{"id": "cross-source-reconciliation", "label": "Reconcile controlling and corroborating records", "reason": "The CB-LD-2709 production contains independently maintained records; a defensible answer must preserve each supported conflict and its cure owner.", "selected": true}, {"id": "latest-record-controls", "label": "Treat the latest record as controlling", "reason": "Timestamp recency does not establish legal priority, execution, or approval authority.", "selected": false}, {"id": "primary-records-only", "label": "Report primary records without reconciliation", "reason": "Primary records alone conceal the operational conflicts that create the actionable exceptions.", "selected": false}], "gates": ["all_evidence_read_in_full", "chain_of_custody_metadata_checked", "findings_criteria_complete", "memo_criteria_complete", "deliverables_written_through_mcp"], "metadata_checks": 8, "metric": "weighted_criteria_score", "minimum_tool_calls": 46, "required_deliverables": ["findings.json", "advice.md"], "required_document_reads": 33, "type": "deterministic", "weights": {"findings": 0.55, "memo": 0.2, "procedure": 0.25}}, "task_id": "cb100-039-isotope-environmental", "task_name": "Isotope contamination case production check", "world_id": "counselbench-filesystem-mcp-v2"}
-{"context_files": ["task_files/cb100-040-juniper-franchise/01_pleadings/001_pleadings_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-040-juniper-franchise/01_pleadings/002_pleadings_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-040-juniper-franchise/01_pleadings/003_pleadings_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-040-juniper-franchise/01_pleadings/004_pleadings_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-040-juniper-franchise/01_pleadings/005_pleadings_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-040-juniper-franchise/01_pleadings/006_pleadings_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-040-juniper-franchise/01_pleadings/007_pleadings_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-040-juniper-franchise/01_pleadings/008_pleadings_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-040-juniper-franchise/02_orders/009_orders_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-040-juniper-franchise/02_orders/010_orders_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-040-juniper-franchise/02_orders/011_orders_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-040-juniper-franchise/02_orders/012_orders_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-040-juniper-franchise/02_orders/013_orders_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-040-juniper-franchise/02_orders/014_orders_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-040-juniper-franchise/02_orders/015_orders_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-040-juniper-franchise/02_orders/016_orders_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-040-juniper-franchise/03_requests_responses/017_requests_responses_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-040-juniper-franchise/03_requests_responses/018_requests_responses_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-040-juniper-franchise/03_requests_responses/019_requests_responses_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-040-juniper-franchise/03_requests_responses/020_requests_responses_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-040-juniper-franchise/03_requests_responses/021_requests_responses_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-040-juniper-franchise/03_requests_responses/022_requests_responses_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-040-juniper-franchise/03_requests_responses/023_requests_responses_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-040-juniper-franchise/03_requests_responses/024_requests_responses_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-040-juniper-franchise/04_custodian_files/025_custodian_files_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-040-juniper-franchise/04_custodian_files/026_custodian_files_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-040-juniper-franchise/04_custodian_files/027_custodian_files_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-040-juniper-franchise/04_custodian_files/028_custodian_files_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-040-juniper-franchise/04_custodian_files/029_custodian_files_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-040-juniper-franchise/04_custodian_files/030_custodian_files_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-040-juniper-franchise/04_custodian_files/031_custodian_files_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-040-juniper-franchise/04_custodian_files/032_custodian_files_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-040-juniper-franchise/05_email_families/033_email_families_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-040-juniper-franchise/05_email_families/034_email_families_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-040-juniper-franchise/05_email_families/035_email_families_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-040-juniper-franchise/05_email_families/036_email_families_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-040-juniper-franchise/05_email_families/037_email_families_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-040-juniper-franchise/05_email_families/038_email_families_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-040-juniper-franchise/05_email_families/039_email_families_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-040-juniper-franchise/05_email_families/040_email_families_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-040-juniper-franchise/06_chat_exports/041_chat_exports_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-040-juniper-franchise/06_chat_exports/042_chat_exports_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-040-juniper-franchise/06_chat_exports/043_chat_exports_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-040-juniper-franchise/06_chat_exports/044_chat_exports_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-040-juniper-franchise/06_chat_exports/045_chat_exports_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-040-juniper-franchise/06_chat_exports/046_chat_exports_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-040-juniper-franchise/06_chat_exports/047_chat_exports_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-040-juniper-franchise/06_chat_exports/048_chat_exports_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-040-juniper-franchise/07_privilege_material/049_privilege_material_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-040-juniper-franchise/07_privilege_material/050_privilege_material_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-040-juniper-franchise/07_privilege_material/051_privilege_material_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-040-juniper-franchise/07_privilege_material/052_privilege_material_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-040-juniper-franchise/07_privilege_material/053_privilege_material_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-040-juniper-franchise/07_privilege_material/054_privilege_material_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-040-juniper-franchise/07_privilege_material/055_privilege_material_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-040-juniper-franchise/07_privilege_material/056_privilege_material_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-040-juniper-franchise/08_production_logs/057_production_logs_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-040-juniper-franchise/08_production_logs/058_production_logs_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-040-juniper-franchise/08_production_logs/059_production_logs_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-040-juniper-franchise/08_production_logs/060_production_logs_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-040-juniper-franchise/08_production_logs/061_production_logs_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-040-juniper-franchise/08_production_logs/062_production_logs_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-040-juniper-franchise/08_production_logs/063_production_logs_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-040-juniper-franchise/08_production_logs/064_production_logs_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-040-juniper-franchise/09_depositions/065_depositions_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-040-juniper-franchise/09_depositions/066_depositions_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-040-juniper-franchise/09_depositions/067_depositions_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-040-juniper-franchise/09_depositions/068_depositions_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-040-juniper-franchise/09_depositions/069_depositions_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-040-juniper-franchise/09_depositions/070_depositions_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-040-juniper-franchise/09_depositions/071_depositions_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-040-juniper-franchise/09_depositions/072_depositions_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-040-juniper-franchise/10_expert_material/073_expert_material_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-040-juniper-franchise/10_expert_material/074_expert_material_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-040-juniper-franchise/10_expert_material/075_expert_material_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-040-juniper-franchise/10_expert_material/076_expert_material_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-040-juniper-franchise/10_expert_material/077_expert_material_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-040-juniper-franchise/10_expert_material/078_expert_material_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-040-juniper-franchise/10_expert_material/079_expert_material_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-040-juniper-franchise/10_expert_material/080_expert_material_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-040-juniper-franchise/11_third_party/081_third_party_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-040-juniper-franchise/11_third_party/082_third_party_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-040-juniper-franchise/11_third_party/083_third_party_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-040-juniper-franchise/11_third_party/084_third_party_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-040-juniper-franchise/11_third_party/085_third_party_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-040-juniper-franchise/11_third_party/086_third_party_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-040-juniper-franchise/11_third_party/087_third_party_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-040-juniper-franchise/11_third_party/088_third_party_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-040-juniper-franchise/12_case_management/089_case_management_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-040-juniper-franchise/12_case_management/090_case_management_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-040-juniper-franchise/12_case_management/091_case_management_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-040-juniper-franchise/12_case_management/092_case_management_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-040-juniper-franchise/12_case_management/093_case_management_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-040-juniper-franchise/12_case_management/094_case_management_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-040-juniper-franchise/12_case_management/095_case_management_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-040-juniper-franchise/12_case_management/096_case_management_status_report.md"], "gold_output": {"advice_markdown": "# Counsel advice — Juniper franchise dispute discovery audit\n\n## Executive assessment\n\nFor Juniper Table Restaurants matter CB-LD-2710, the review identified 16 source-supported exceptions requiring action before 2026-10-07. The assessment concerns Oak Street Franchisees Association and the supplied record for Florida.\n\n## Method and record coverage\n\nThe review inventoried all 96 production files, read the 33 controlling, corroborating, and control records, searched the email exports, and checked metadata for the designated chain-of-custody sample. Conclusions are limited to the synthetic production supplied for this benchmark matter.\n\n## Findings\n\n### F-01 — custodian omission (critical)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for custodian omission: one source states the operative date is 2025-03-10 under control reference CB-LD-2710-A946, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2025-04-06 under response reference CB-LD-2710-J372.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/01_pleadings/001_pleadings_control_register.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/07_privilege_material/049_privilege_material_control_register.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-10-07, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Nora Chen.\n\n### F-02 — legal-hold delivery gap (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for legal-hold delivery gap: one source states the controlling amount is $4,239,624.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $4,425,748.00.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/01_pleadings/004_pleadings_ledger_export.csv`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/07_privilege_material/052_privilege_material_ledger_export.csv`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-10-07, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Dominic Alvarez.\n\n### F-03 — collection-date inconsistency (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for collection-date inconsistency: one source states approval is attributed to Owen Delgado as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Samuel Kim and contains no entry for Owen Delgado.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/01_pleadings/007_pleadings_officer_certificate.html`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/07_privilege_material/055_privilege_material_officer_certificate.html`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-10-07, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Priya Raman.\n\n### F-04 — email-family separation (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for email-family separation: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-LD-2710-D938, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-LD-2710-M302.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/02_orders/010_orders_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/08_production_logs/058_production_logs_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-10-07, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Elliot Mercer.\n\n### F-05 — privilege-log description defect (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for privilege-log description defect: one source states the applicable location is Middle District of Florida, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to Florida operations outside Middle District of Florida.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/02_orders/013_orders_review_memorandum.json`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/08_production_logs/061_production_logs_review_memorandum.json`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-10-07, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Talia Brooks.\n\n### F-06 — common-interest support gap (low)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for common-interest support gap: one source states the threshold is 14% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 16% and produced a different exception result.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/02_orders/016_orders_status_report.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/08_production_logs/064_production_logs_status_report.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-10-07, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Jonas Feld.\n\n### F-07 — clawback deadline (critical)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for clawback deadline: one source states formal notice must use notices-juniper_table_restaurants@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-oak_street_franchisees_association@example.test.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/019_requests_responses_correspondence.eml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/09_depositions/067_depositions_correspondence.eml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-10-07, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Mei Whitaker.\n\n### F-08 — protective-order designation error (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for protective-order designation error: one source states the governed population contains 78 records through 2025-11-09, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 72 records through 2025-12-23.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/022_requests_responses_formal_notice.xml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/09_depositions/070_depositions_formal_notice.xml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-10-07, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Caleb Hassan.\n\n### F-09 — request-response mismatch (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for request-response mismatch: one source states the operative date is 2025-10-11 under control reference CB-LD-2710-I621, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2025-11-18 under response reference CB-LD-2710-R763.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/025_custodian_files_control_register.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/10_expert_material/073_expert_material_control_register.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-10-07, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Leona Park.\n\n### F-10 — deposition exhibit omission (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for deposition exhibit omission: one source states the controlling amount is $3,655,911.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $3,848,322.00.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/028_custodian_files_ledger_export.csv`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/10_expert_material/076_expert_material_ledger_export.csv`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-10-07, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Isaac Romero.\n\n### F-11 — expert draft segregation (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for expert draft segregation: one source states approval is attributed to Owen Delgado as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Theo Laurent and contains no entry for Owen Delgado.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/031_custodian_files_officer_certificate.html`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/10_expert_material/079_expert_material_officer_certificate.html`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-10-07, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Sofia Bennett.\n\n### F-12 — third-party subpoena deadline (low)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for third-party subpoena deadline: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-LD-2710-L314, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-LD-2710-U254.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/05_email_families/034_email_families_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/11_third_party/082_third_party_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-10-07, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Adrian Mensah.\n\n### F-13 — production gap (critical)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for production gap: one source states the applicable location is Middle District of Florida, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to Florida operations outside Middle District of Florida.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/05_email_families/037_email_families_review_memorandum.json`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/11_third_party/085_third_party_review_memorandum.json`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-10-07, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Willa Novak.\n\n### F-14 — metadata field loss (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for metadata field loss: one source states the threshold is 8% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 14% and produced a different exception result.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/05_email_families/040_email_families_status_report.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/11_third_party/088_third_party_status_report.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-10-07, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Theo Laurent.\n\n### F-15 — Bates-range overlap (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for Bates-range overlap: one source states formal notice must use notices-juniper_table_restaurants@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-oak_street_franchisees_association@example.test.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/043_chat_exports_correspondence.eml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/12_case_management/091_case_management_correspondence.eml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-10-07, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Amara Patel.\n\n### F-16 — meet-and-confer commitment (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for meet-and-confer commitment: one source states the governed population contains 165 records through 2025-09-17, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 74 records through 2025-11-02.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/046_chat_exports_formal_notice.xml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/12_case_management/094_case_management_formal_notice.xml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-10-07, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Henry Cho.\n\n## Recommended next actions\n\nSequence the critical and high findings first, assign the named owners, preserve the cited records, and document any resolution in the controlling matter register before the stated deadline.\n\n## Assumptions and limitations\n\nThis analysis is confined to task cb100-040-juniper-franchise and the supplied synthetic evidence. It does not rely on external facts, does not resolve disputed law, and is not legal advice for a real person or entity.\n", "findings": {"as_of": "2026-10-07", "findings": [{"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/07_privilege_material/049_privilege_material_control_register.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for custodian omission: one source states the operative date is 2025-03-10 under control reference CB-LD-2710-A946, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2025-04-06 under response reference CB-LD-2710-J372.", "id": "F-01", "issue": "custodian omission", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/01_pleadings/001_pleadings_control_register.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-10-07, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Nora Chen.", "severity": "critical"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/07_privilege_material/052_privilege_material_ledger_export.csv", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for legal-hold delivery gap: one source states the controlling amount is $4,239,624.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $4,425,748.00.", "id": "F-02", "issue": "legal-hold delivery gap", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/01_pleadings/004_pleadings_ledger_export.csv", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-10-07, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Dominic Alvarez.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/07_privilege_material/055_privilege_material_officer_certificate.html", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for collection-date inconsistency: one source states approval is attributed to Owen Delgado as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Samuel Kim and contains no entry for Owen Delgado.", "id": "F-03", "issue": "collection-date inconsistency", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/01_pleadings/007_pleadings_officer_certificate.html", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-10-07, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Priya Raman.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/08_production_logs/058_production_logs_executed_instrument.txt", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for email-family separation: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-LD-2710-D938, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-LD-2710-M302.", "id": "F-04", "issue": "email-family separation", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/02_orders/010_orders_executed_instrument.txt", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-10-07, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Elliot Mercer.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/08_production_logs/061_production_logs_review_memorandum.json", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for privilege-log description defect: one source states the applicable location is Middle District of Florida, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to Florida operations outside Middle District of Florida.", "id": "F-05", "issue": "privilege-log description defect", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/02_orders/013_orders_review_memorandum.json", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-10-07, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Talia Brooks.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/08_production_logs/064_production_logs_status_report.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for common-interest support gap: one source states the threshold is 14% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 16% and produced a different exception result.", "id": "F-06", "issue": "common-interest support gap", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/02_orders/016_orders_status_report.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-10-07, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Jonas Feld.", "severity": "low"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/09_depositions/067_depositions_correspondence.eml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for clawback deadline: one source states formal notice must use notices-juniper_table_restaurants@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-oak_street_franchisees_association@example.test.", "id": "F-07", "issue": "clawback deadline", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/019_requests_responses_correspondence.eml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-10-07, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Mei Whitaker.", "severity": "critical"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/09_depositions/070_depositions_formal_notice.xml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for protective-order designation error: one source states the governed population contains 78 records through 2025-11-09, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 72 records through 2025-12-23.", "id": "F-08", "issue": "protective-order designation error", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/022_requests_responses_formal_notice.xml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-10-07, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Caleb Hassan.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/10_expert_material/073_expert_material_control_register.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for request-response mismatch: one source states the operative date is 2025-10-11 under control reference CB-LD-2710-I621, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2025-11-18 under response reference CB-LD-2710-R763.", "id": "F-09", "issue": "request-response mismatch", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/025_custodian_files_control_register.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-10-07, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Leona Park.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/10_expert_material/076_expert_material_ledger_export.csv", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for deposition exhibit omission: one source states the controlling amount is $3,655,911.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $3,848,322.00.", "id": "F-10", "issue": "deposition exhibit omission", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/028_custodian_files_ledger_export.csv", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-10-07, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Isaac Romero.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/10_expert_material/079_expert_material_officer_certificate.html", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for expert draft segregation: one source states approval is attributed to Owen Delgado as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Theo Laurent and contains no entry for Owen Delgado.", "id": "F-11", "issue": "expert draft segregation", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/031_custodian_files_officer_certificate.html", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-10-07, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Sofia Bennett.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/11_third_party/082_third_party_executed_instrument.txt", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for third-party subpoena deadline: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-LD-2710-L314, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-LD-2710-U254.", "id": "F-12", "issue": "third-party subpoena deadline", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/05_email_families/034_email_families_executed_instrument.txt", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-10-07, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Adrian Mensah.", "severity": "low"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/11_third_party/085_third_party_review_memorandum.json", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for production gap: one source states the applicable location is Middle District of Florida, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to Florida operations outside Middle District of Florida.", "id": "F-13", "issue": "production gap", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/05_email_families/037_email_families_review_memorandum.json", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-10-07, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Willa Novak.", "severity": "critical"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/11_third_party/088_third_party_status_report.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for metadata field loss: one source states the threshold is 8% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 14% and produced a different exception result.", "id": "F-14", "issue": "metadata field loss", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/05_email_families/040_email_families_status_report.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-10-07, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Theo Laurent.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/12_case_management/091_case_management_correspondence.eml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for Bates-range overlap: one source states formal notice must use notices-juniper_table_restaurants@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-oak_street_franchisees_association@example.test.", "id": "F-15", "issue": "Bates-range overlap", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/043_chat_exports_correspondence.eml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-10-07, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Amara Patel.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/12_case_management/094_case_management_formal_notice.xml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for meet-and-confer commitment: one source states the governed population contains 165 records through 2025-09-17, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 74 records through 2025-11-02.", "id": "F-16", "issue": "meet-and-confer commitment", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/046_chat_exports_formal_notice.xml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-10-07, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Henry Cho.", "severity": "medium"}], "matter_number": "CB-LD-2710", "prepared_for": "Juniper Table Restaurants", "schema_version": "1.0", "task_id": "cb100-040-juniper-franchise"}}, "metadata": {"benchmark": "CounselBench-100", "code_license": "Apache-2.0", "data_license": "CC-BY-4.0", "deadline": "2026-10-07", "document_count": 96, "jurisdiction": "Florida", "matter_number": "CB-LD-2710", "mcp_commit": "9a96ea6e5913736f92b88345bf51caeaaa8e719f", "mcp_package": "@modelcontextprotocol/server-filesystem@2026.7.10", "practice_area": "litigation-discovery", "reference_tool_calls": 46, "required_evidence_reads": 33, "synthetic": true, "venue": "Middle District of Florida", "version": "2.0.0"}, "prompt": "You are discovery counsel for Juniper Table Restaurants. The record contains amendments, exports, and correspondence from different custodians; reconcile them into an actionable counsel work product. A franchise production has custodian scope gaps, incomplete chat threads, and order-form attachments missing from key email families. Decision due 2026-10-07. Florida law governs; Middle District of Florida is the forum. Write for a supervising lawyer who will spot-check source paths and exact values. Work out the defensible position from the matter production and leave an audit-ready exception tracker and concise advice for the supervising lawyer. Keep confirmed conflicts separate from open questions, cite the records that actually control each conclusion, and do not fill gaps with outside facts.", "rubric": {"criteria": [{"category": "procedure", "description": "Complete at least 46 successful, argument-specific evidence and output calls.", "id": "procedure.minimum_successful_tool_calls"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Find and read the 33 controlling, corroborating, and work-product-control records in full.", "id": "procedure.all_evidence_read_in_full"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Inspect file metadata for the eight designated critical primary records before relying on them.", "id": "procedure.chain_of_custody_metadata_checked"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Confirm the sandbox's allowed document and output roots.", "id": "procedure.allowed_directories_checked"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Inventory all 96 records so the relevant sources are discovered among the context records.", "id": "procedure.recursive_inventory_completed"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Search the production for email evidence that may corroborate or contradict formal records.", "id": "procedure.targeted_search_completed"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Leave only findings.json and advice.md in the output workspace.", "id": "procedure.exact_deliverable_set"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Create both final work products through the sandbox MCP surface.", "id": "procedure.deliverables_written_through_mcp"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Produce findings.json as a valid JSON object.", "id": "findings.findings_is_object"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Report exactly 16 confirmed exceptions.", "id": "findings.findings_exact_count"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Use each stable finding ID exactly once.", "id": "findings.finding_ids_unique"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set schema_version to the released matter value '1.0'.", "id": "findings.top_level_schema_version"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set task_id to the released matter value 'cb100-040-juniper-franchise'.", "id": "findings.top_level_task_id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set matter_number to the released matter value 'CB-LD-2710'.", "id": "findings.top_level_matter_number"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set prepared_for to the released matter value 'Juniper Table Restaurants'.", "id": "findings.top_level_prepared_for"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set as_of to the released matter value '2026-10-07'.", "id": "findings.top_level_as_of"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-01 exception for custodian omission.", "id": "findings.F-01.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's id from /workspace/documents/01_pleadings/001_pleadings_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_privilege_material/049_privilege_material_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's issue from /workspace/documents/01_pleadings/001_pleadings_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_privilege_material/049_privilege_material_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's severity from /workspace/documents/01_pleadings/001_pleadings_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_privilege_material/049_privilege_material_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's primary_source from /workspace/documents/01_pleadings/001_pleadings_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_privilege_material/049_privilege_material_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/01_pleadings/001_pleadings_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_privilege_material/049_privilege_material_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-01 using the exact controlled facts ['2025-03-10', 'CB-LD-2710-A946', '2025-04-06', 'CB-LD-2710-J372'].", "id": "findings.F-01.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-01's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-01.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-10-07', 'Nora Chen'] for F-01.", "id": "findings.F-01.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-02 exception for legal-hold delivery gap.", "id": "findings.F-02.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's id from /workspace/documents/01_pleadings/004_pleadings_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_privilege_material/052_privilege_material_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's issue from /workspace/documents/01_pleadings/004_pleadings_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_privilege_material/052_privilege_material_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's severity from /workspace/documents/01_pleadings/004_pleadings_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_privilege_material/052_privilege_material_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's primary_source from /workspace/documents/01_pleadings/004_pleadings_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_privilege_material/052_privilege_material_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/01_pleadings/004_pleadings_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_privilege_material/052_privilege_material_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-02 using the exact controlled facts ['$4,239,624.00', '$4,425,748.00'].", "id": "findings.F-02.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-02's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-02.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-10-07', 'Dominic Alvarez'] for F-02.", "id": "findings.F-02.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-03 exception for collection-date inconsistency.", "id": "findings.F-03.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's id from /workspace/documents/01_pleadings/007_pleadings_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_privilege_material/055_privilege_material_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's issue from /workspace/documents/01_pleadings/007_pleadings_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_privilege_material/055_privilege_material_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's severity from /workspace/documents/01_pleadings/007_pleadings_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_privilege_material/055_privilege_material_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's primary_source from /workspace/documents/01_pleadings/007_pleadings_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_privilege_material/055_privilege_material_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/01_pleadings/007_pleadings_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_privilege_material/055_privilege_material_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-03 using the exact controlled facts ['Owen Delgado', 'Samuel Kim'].", "id": "findings.F-03.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-03's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-03.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-10-07', 'Priya Raman'] for F-03.", "id": "findings.F-03.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-04 exception for email-family separation.", "id": "findings.F-04.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's id from /workspace/documents/02_orders/010_orders_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_production_logs/058_production_logs_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's issue from /workspace/documents/02_orders/010_orders_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_production_logs/058_production_logs_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's severity from /workspace/documents/02_orders/010_orders_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_production_logs/058_production_logs_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's primary_source from /workspace/documents/02_orders/010_orders_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_production_logs/058_production_logs_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/02_orders/010_orders_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_production_logs/058_production_logs_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-04 using the exact controlled facts ['closed without exception', 'CB-LD-2710-D938', 'open and escalated', 'CB-LD-2710-M302'].", "id": "findings.F-04.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-04's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-04.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-10-07', 'Elliot Mercer'] for F-04.", "id": "findings.F-04.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-05 exception for privilege-log description defect.", "id": "findings.F-05.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's id from /workspace/documents/02_orders/013_orders_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_production_logs/061_production_logs_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's issue from /workspace/documents/02_orders/013_orders_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_production_logs/061_production_logs_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's severity from /workspace/documents/02_orders/013_orders_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_production_logs/061_production_logs_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's primary_source from /workspace/documents/02_orders/013_orders_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_production_logs/061_production_logs_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/02_orders/013_orders_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_production_logs/061_production_logs_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-05 using the exact controlled facts ['Middle District of Florida', 'Florida'].", "id": "findings.F-05.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-05's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-05.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-10-07', 'Talia Brooks'] for F-05.", "id": "findings.F-05.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-06 exception for common-interest support gap.", "id": "findings.F-06.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's id from /workspace/documents/02_orders/016_orders_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_production_logs/064_production_logs_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's issue from /workspace/documents/02_orders/016_orders_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_production_logs/064_production_logs_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's severity from /workspace/documents/02_orders/016_orders_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_production_logs/064_production_logs_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's primary_source from /workspace/documents/02_orders/016_orders_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_production_logs/064_production_logs_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/02_orders/016_orders_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_production_logs/064_production_logs_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-06 using the exact controlled facts ['14%', '16%'].", "id": "findings.F-06.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-06's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-06.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-10-07', 'Jonas Feld'] for F-06.", "id": "findings.F-06.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-07 exception for clawback deadline.", "id": "findings.F-07.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's id from /workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/019_requests_responses_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_depositions/067_depositions_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's issue from /workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/019_requests_responses_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_depositions/067_depositions_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's severity from /workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/019_requests_responses_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_depositions/067_depositions_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's primary_source from /workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/019_requests_responses_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_depositions/067_depositions_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/019_requests_responses_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_depositions/067_depositions_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-07 using the exact controlled facts ['notices-juniper_table_restaurants@example.test', 'archive-oak_street_franchisees_association@example.test'].", "id": "findings.F-07.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-07's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-07.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-10-07', 'Mei Whitaker'] for F-07.", "id": "findings.F-07.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-08 exception for protective-order designation error.", "id": "findings.F-08.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's id from /workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/022_requests_responses_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_depositions/070_depositions_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's issue from /workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/022_requests_responses_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_depositions/070_depositions_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's severity from /workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/022_requests_responses_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_depositions/070_depositions_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's primary_source from /workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/022_requests_responses_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_depositions/070_depositions_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/022_requests_responses_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_depositions/070_depositions_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-08 using the exact controlled facts ['78 records', '2025-11-09', '72 records', '2025-12-23'].", "id": "findings.F-08.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-08's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-08.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-10-07', 'Caleb Hassan'] for F-08.", "id": "findings.F-08.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-09 exception for request-response mismatch.", "id": "findings.F-09.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's id from /workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/025_custodian_files_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_expert_material/073_expert_material_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's issue from /workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/025_custodian_files_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_expert_material/073_expert_material_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's severity from /workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/025_custodian_files_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_expert_material/073_expert_material_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's primary_source from /workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/025_custodian_files_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_expert_material/073_expert_material_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/025_custodian_files_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_expert_material/073_expert_material_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-09 using the exact controlled facts ['2025-10-11', 'CB-LD-2710-I621', '2025-11-18', 'CB-LD-2710-R763'].", "id": "findings.F-09.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-09's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-09.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-10-07', 'Leona Park'] for F-09.", "id": "findings.F-09.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-10 exception for deposition exhibit omission.", "id": "findings.F-10.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's id from /workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/028_custodian_files_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_expert_material/076_expert_material_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's issue from /workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/028_custodian_files_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_expert_material/076_expert_material_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's severity from /workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/028_custodian_files_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_expert_material/076_expert_material_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's primary_source from /workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/028_custodian_files_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_expert_material/076_expert_material_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/028_custodian_files_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_expert_material/076_expert_material_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-10 using the exact controlled facts ['$3,655,911.00', '$3,848,322.00'].", "id": "findings.F-10.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-10's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-10.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-10-07', 'Isaac Romero'] for F-10.", "id": "findings.F-10.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-11 exception for expert draft segregation.", "id": "findings.F-11.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's id from /workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/031_custodian_files_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_expert_material/079_expert_material_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's issue from /workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/031_custodian_files_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_expert_material/079_expert_material_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's severity from /workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/031_custodian_files_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_expert_material/079_expert_material_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's primary_source from /workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/031_custodian_files_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_expert_material/079_expert_material_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/031_custodian_files_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_expert_material/079_expert_material_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-11 using the exact controlled facts ['Owen Delgado', 'Theo Laurent'].", "id": "findings.F-11.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-11's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-11.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-10-07', 'Sofia Bennett'] for F-11.", "id": "findings.F-11.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-12 exception for third-party subpoena deadline.", "id": "findings.F-12.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's id from /workspace/documents/05_email_families/034_email_families_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_third_party/082_third_party_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's issue from /workspace/documents/05_email_families/034_email_families_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_third_party/082_third_party_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's severity from /workspace/documents/05_email_families/034_email_families_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_third_party/082_third_party_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's primary_source from /workspace/documents/05_email_families/034_email_families_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_third_party/082_third_party_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/05_email_families/034_email_families_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_third_party/082_third_party_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-12 using the exact controlled facts ['closed without exception', 'CB-LD-2710-L314', 'open and escalated', 'CB-LD-2710-U254'].", "id": "findings.F-12.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-12's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-12.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-10-07', 'Adrian Mensah'] for F-12.", "id": "findings.F-12.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-13 exception for production gap.", "id": "findings.F-13.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's id from /workspace/documents/05_email_families/037_email_families_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_third_party/085_third_party_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's issue from /workspace/documents/05_email_families/037_email_families_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_third_party/085_third_party_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's severity from /workspace/documents/05_email_families/037_email_families_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_third_party/085_third_party_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's primary_source from /workspace/documents/05_email_families/037_email_families_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_third_party/085_third_party_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/05_email_families/037_email_families_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_third_party/085_third_party_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-13 using the exact controlled facts ['Middle District of Florida', 'Florida'].", "id": "findings.F-13.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-13's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-13.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-10-07', 'Willa Novak'] for F-13.", "id": "findings.F-13.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-14 exception for metadata field loss.", "id": "findings.F-14.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's id from /workspace/documents/05_email_families/040_email_families_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_third_party/088_third_party_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's issue from /workspace/documents/05_email_families/040_email_families_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_third_party/088_third_party_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's severity from /workspace/documents/05_email_families/040_email_families_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_third_party/088_third_party_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's primary_source from /workspace/documents/05_email_families/040_email_families_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_third_party/088_third_party_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/05_email_families/040_email_families_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_third_party/088_third_party_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-14 using the exact controlled facts ['8%', '14%'].", "id": "findings.F-14.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-14's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-14.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-10-07', 'Theo Laurent'] for F-14.", "id": "findings.F-14.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-15 exception for Bates-range overlap.", "id": "findings.F-15.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's id from /workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/043_chat_exports_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_case_management/091_case_management_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's issue from /workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/043_chat_exports_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_case_management/091_case_management_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's severity from /workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/043_chat_exports_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_case_management/091_case_management_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's primary_source from /workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/043_chat_exports_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_case_management/091_case_management_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/043_chat_exports_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_case_management/091_case_management_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-15 using the exact controlled facts ['notices-juniper_table_restaurants@example.test', 'archive-oak_street_franchisees_association@example.test'].", "id": "findings.F-15.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-15's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-15.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-10-07', 'Amara Patel'] for F-15.", "id": "findings.F-15.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-16 exception for meet-and-confer commitment.", "id": "findings.F-16.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's id from /workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/046_chat_exports_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_case_management/094_case_management_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's issue from /workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/046_chat_exports_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_case_management/094_case_management_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's severity from /workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/046_chat_exports_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_case_management/094_case_management_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's primary_source from /workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/046_chat_exports_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_case_management/094_case_management_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/046_chat_exports_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_case_management/094_case_management_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-16 using the exact controlled facts ['165 records', '2025-09-17', '74 records', '2025-11-02'].", "id": "findings.F-16.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-16's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-16.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-10-07', 'Henry Cho'] for F-16.", "id": "findings.F-16.action_anchors"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Executive assessment' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Executive assessment"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Method and record coverage' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Method and record coverage"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Findings' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Findings"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Recommended next actions' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Recommended next actions"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Assumptions and limitations' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Assumptions and limitations"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-01 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-01"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-02 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-02"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-03 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-03"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-04 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-04"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-05 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-05"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-06 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-06"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-07 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-07"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-08 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-08"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-09 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-09"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-10 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-10"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-11 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-11"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-12 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-12"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-13 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-13"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-14 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-14"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-15 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-15"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-16 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-16"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Do not claim the production has no issues or that every record is consistent.", "id": "memo.forbidden_claims_absent"}], "decision_options": [{"id": "cross-source-reconciliation", "label": "Reconcile controlling and corroborating records", "reason": "The CB-LD-2710 production contains independently maintained records; a defensible answer must preserve each supported conflict and its cure owner.", "selected": true}, {"id": "latest-record-controls", "label": "Treat the latest record as controlling", "reason": "Timestamp recency does not establish legal priority, execution, or approval authority.", "selected": false}, {"id": "primary-records-only", "label": "Report primary records without reconciliation", "reason": "Primary records alone conceal the operational conflicts that create the actionable exceptions.", "selected": false}], "gates": ["all_evidence_read_in_full", "chain_of_custody_metadata_checked", "findings_criteria_complete", "memo_criteria_complete", "deliverables_written_through_mcp"], "metadata_checks": 8, "metric": "weighted_criteria_score", "minimum_tool_calls": 46, "required_deliverables": ["findings.json", "advice.md"], "required_document_reads": 33, "type": "deterministic", "weights": {"findings": 0.55, "memo": 0.2, "procedure": 0.25}}, "task_id": "cb100-040-juniper-franchise", "task_name": "Juniper franchise dispute discovery audit", "world_id": "counselbench-filesystem-mcp-v2"}
-{"context_files": ["task_files/cb100-041-anchor-marine/01_petition_schedules/001_petition_schedules_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-041-anchor-marine/01_petition_schedules/002_petition_schedules_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-041-anchor-marine/01_petition_schedules/003_petition_schedules_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-041-anchor-marine/01_petition_schedules/004_petition_schedules_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-041-anchor-marine/01_petition_schedules/005_petition_schedules_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-041-anchor-marine/01_petition_schedules/006_petition_schedules_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-041-anchor-marine/01_petition_schedules/007_petition_schedules_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-041-anchor-marine/01_petition_schedules/008_petition_schedules_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-041-anchor-marine/02_claims_register/009_claims_register_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-041-anchor-marine/02_claims_register/010_claims_register_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-041-anchor-marine/02_claims_register/011_claims_register_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-041-anchor-marine/02_claims_register/012_claims_register_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-041-anchor-marine/02_claims_register/013_claims_register_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-041-anchor-marine/02_claims_register/014_claims_register_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-041-anchor-marine/02_claims_register/015_claims_register_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-041-anchor-marine/02_claims_register/016_claims_register_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-041-anchor-marine/03_proofs_of_claim/017_proofs_of_claim_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-041-anchor-marine/03_proofs_of_claim/018_proofs_of_claim_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-041-anchor-marine/03_proofs_of_claim/019_proofs_of_claim_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-041-anchor-marine/03_proofs_of_claim/020_proofs_of_claim_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-041-anchor-marine/03_proofs_of_claim/021_proofs_of_claim_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-041-anchor-marine/03_proofs_of_claim/022_proofs_of_claim_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-041-anchor-marine/03_proofs_of_claim/023_proofs_of_claim_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-041-anchor-marine/03_proofs_of_claim/024_proofs_of_claim_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-041-anchor-marine/04_contracts_leases/025_contracts_leases_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-041-anchor-marine/04_contracts_leases/026_contracts_leases_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-041-anchor-marine/04_contracts_leases/027_contracts_leases_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-041-anchor-marine/04_contracts_leases/028_contracts_leases_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-041-anchor-marine/04_contracts_leases/029_contracts_leases_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-041-anchor-marine/04_contracts_leases/030_contracts_leases_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-041-anchor-marine/04_contracts_leases/031_contracts_leases_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-041-anchor-marine/04_contracts_leases/032_contracts_leases_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-041-anchor-marine/05_cash_management/033_cash_management_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-041-anchor-marine/05_cash_management/034_cash_management_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-041-anchor-marine/05_cash_management/035_cash_management_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-041-anchor-marine/05_cash_management/036_cash_management_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-041-anchor-marine/05_cash_management/037_cash_management_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-041-anchor-marine/05_cash_management/038_cash_management_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-041-anchor-marine/05_cash_management/039_cash_management_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-041-anchor-marine/05_cash_management/040_cash_management_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-041-anchor-marine/06_financing/041_financing_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-041-anchor-marine/06_financing/042_financing_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-041-anchor-marine/06_financing/043_financing_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-041-anchor-marine/06_financing/044_financing_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-041-anchor-marine/06_financing/045_financing_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-041-anchor-marine/06_financing/046_financing_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-041-anchor-marine/06_financing/047_financing_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-041-anchor-marine/06_financing/048_financing_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-041-anchor-marine/07_critical_vendors/049_critical_vendors_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-041-anchor-marine/07_critical_vendors/050_critical_vendors_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-041-anchor-marine/07_critical_vendors/051_critical_vendors_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-041-anchor-marine/07_critical_vendors/052_critical_vendors_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-041-anchor-marine/07_critical_vendors/053_critical_vendors_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-041-anchor-marine/07_critical_vendors/054_critical_vendors_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-041-anchor-marine/07_critical_vendors/055_critical_vendors_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-041-anchor-marine/07_critical_vendors/056_critical_vendors_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-041-anchor-marine/08_tax/057_tax_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-041-anchor-marine/08_tax/058_tax_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-041-anchor-marine/08_tax/059_tax_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-041-anchor-marine/08_tax/060_tax_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-041-anchor-marine/08_tax/061_tax_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-041-anchor-marine/08_tax/062_tax_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-041-anchor-marine/08_tax/063_tax_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-041-anchor-marine/08_tax/064_tax_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-041-anchor-marine/09_litigation/065_litigation_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-041-anchor-marine/09_litigation/066_litigation_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-041-anchor-marine/09_litigation/067_litigation_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-041-anchor-marine/09_litigation/068_litigation_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-041-anchor-marine/09_litigation/069_litigation_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-041-anchor-marine/09_litigation/070_litigation_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-041-anchor-marine/09_litigation/071_litigation_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-041-anchor-marine/09_litigation/072_litigation_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-041-anchor-marine/10_plan_disclosure/073_plan_disclosure_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-041-anchor-marine/10_plan_disclosure/074_plan_disclosure_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-041-anchor-marine/10_plan_disclosure/075_plan_disclosure_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-041-anchor-marine/10_plan_disclosure/076_plan_disclosure_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-041-anchor-marine/10_plan_disclosure/077_plan_disclosure_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-041-anchor-marine/10_plan_disclosure/078_plan_disclosure_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-041-anchor-marine/10_plan_disclosure/079_plan_disclosure_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-041-anchor-marine/10_plan_disclosure/080_plan_disclosure_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-041-anchor-marine/11_notices_ballots/081_notices_ballots_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-041-anchor-marine/11_notices_ballots/082_notices_ballots_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-041-anchor-marine/11_notices_ballots/083_notices_ballots_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-041-anchor-marine/11_notices_ballots/084_notices_ballots_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-041-anchor-marine/11_notices_ballots/085_notices_ballots_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-041-anchor-marine/11_notices_ballots/086_notices_ballots_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-041-anchor-marine/11_notices_ballots/087_notices_ballots_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-041-anchor-marine/11_notices_ballots/088_notices_ballots_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-041-anchor-marine/12_reconciliations/089_reconciliations_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-041-anchor-marine/12_reconciliations/090_reconciliations_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-041-anchor-marine/12_reconciliations/091_reconciliations_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-041-anchor-marine/12_reconciliations/092_reconciliations_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-041-anchor-marine/12_reconciliations/093_reconciliations_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-041-anchor-marine/12_reconciliations/094_reconciliations_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-041-anchor-marine/12_reconciliations/095_reconciliations_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-041-anchor-marine/12_reconciliations/096_reconciliations_status_report.md"], "gold_output": {"advice_markdown": "# Counsel advice — Anchor Marine chapter 11 claim review\n\n## Executive assessment\n\nFor Anchor Marine Fabrication, Inc. matter CB-RS-2801, the review identified 16 source-supported exceptions requiring action before 2026-09-04. The assessment concerns Gulfline Steel Supply and the supplied record for Texas.\n\n## Method and record coverage\n\nThe review inventoried all 96 production files, read the 33 controlling, corroborating, and control records, searched the email exports, and checked metadata for the designated chain-of-custody sample. Conclusions are limited to the synthetic production supplied for this benchmark matter.\n\n## Findings\n\n### F-01 — scheduled-claim mismatch (critical)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for scheduled-claim mismatch: one source states the operative date is 2025-11-26 under control reference CB-RS-2801-A547, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2025-12-05 under response reference CB-RS-2801-J688.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/001_petition_schedules_control_register.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/07_critical_vendors/049_critical_vendors_control_register.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-04, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Dominic Alvarez.\n\n### F-02 — duplicate proof of claim (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for duplicate proof of claim: one source states the controlling amount is $2,105,139.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $2,126,778.00.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/004_petition_schedules_ledger_export.csv`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/07_critical_vendors/052_critical_vendors_ledger_export.csv`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-04, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Priya Raman.\n\n### F-03 — secured-status defect (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for secured-status defect: one source states approval is attributed to Lena Varga as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Rafael Okafor and contains no entry for Lena Varga.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/007_petition_schedules_officer_certificate.html`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/07_critical_vendors/055_critical_vendors_officer_certificate.html`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-04, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Elliot Mercer.\n\n### F-04 — priority classification error (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for priority classification error: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-RS-2801-D356, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-RS-2801-M604.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/02_claims_register/010_claims_register_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/08_tax/058_tax_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-04, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Talia Brooks.\n\n### F-05 — executory-contract cure dispute (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for executory-contract cure dispute: one source states the applicable location is Southern District of Texas Bankruptcy Court, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to Texas operations outside Southern District of Texas Bankruptcy Court.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/02_claims_register/013_claims_register_review_memorandum.json`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/08_tax/061_tax_review_memorandum.json`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-04, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Jonas Feld.\n\n### F-06 — lease rejection deadline (low)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for lease rejection deadline: one source states the threshold is 2% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 8% and produced a different exception result.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/02_claims_register/016_claims_register_status_report.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/08_tax/064_tax_status_report.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-04, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Mei Whitaker.\n\n### F-07 — postpetition invoice (critical)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for postpetition invoice: one source states formal notice must use notices-anchor_marine_fabrication_inc@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-gulfline_steel_supply@example.test.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/019_proofs_of_claim_correspondence.eml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/09_litigation/067_litigation_correspondence.eml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-04, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Caleb Hassan.\n\n### F-08 — critical-vendor overstatement (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for critical-vendor overstatement: one source states the governed population contains 144 records through 2025-08-27, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 58 records through 2025-09-26.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/022_proofs_of_claim_formal_notice.xml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/09_litigation/070_litigation_formal_notice.xml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-04, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Leona Park.\n\n### F-09 — setoff assertion (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for setoff assertion: one source states the operative date is 2025-10-29 under control reference CB-RS-2801-I639, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2025-12-03 under response reference CB-RS-2801-R764.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/025_contracts_leases_control_register.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/10_plan_disclosure/073_plan_disclosure_control_register.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-04, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Isaac Romero.\n\n### F-10 — guaranty overlap (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for guaranty overlap: one source states the controlling amount is $1,133,027.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $1,292,554.00.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/028_contracts_leases_ledger_export.csv`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/10_plan_disclosure/076_plan_disclosure_ledger_export.csv`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-04, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Sofia Bennett.\n\n### F-11 — tax priority period (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for tax priority period: one source states approval is attributed to Lena Varga as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Henry Cho and contains no entry for Lena Varga.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/031_contracts_leases_officer_certificate.html`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/10_plan_disclosure/079_plan_disclosure_officer_certificate.html`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-04, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Adrian Mensah.\n\n### F-12 — DIP budget variance (low)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for DIP budget variance: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-RS-2801-L863, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-RS-2801-U781.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/05_cash_management/034_cash_management_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/11_notices_ballots/082_notices_ballots_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-04, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Willa Novak.\n\n### F-13 — cash-collateral reporting gap (critical)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for cash-collateral reporting gap: one source states the applicable location is Southern District of Texas Bankruptcy Court, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to Texas operations outside Southern District of Texas Bankruptcy Court.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/05_cash_management/037_cash_management_review_memorandum.json`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/11_notices_ballots/085_notices_ballots_review_memorandum.json`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-04, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Theo Laurent.\n\n### F-14 — ballot amount discrepancy (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for ballot amount discrepancy: one source states the threshold is 15% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 22% and produced a different exception result.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/05_cash_management/040_cash_management_status_report.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/11_notices_ballots/088_notices_ballots_status_report.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-04, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Amara Patel.\n\n### F-15 — notice-address defect (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for notice-address defect: one source states formal notice must use notices-anchor_marine_fabrication_inc@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-gulfline_steel_supply@example.test.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/06_financing/043_financing_correspondence.eml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/091_reconciliations_correspondence.eml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-04, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Henry Cho.\n\n### F-16 — reserve calculation error (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for reserve calculation error: one source states the governed population contains 186 records through 2026-02-25, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 56 records through 2026-03-25.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/06_financing/046_financing_formal_notice.xml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/094_reconciliations_formal_notice.xml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-04, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Nadine Flores.\n\n## Recommended next actions\n\nSequence the critical and high findings first, assign the named owners, preserve the cited records, and document any resolution in the controlling matter register before the stated deadline.\n\n## Assumptions and limitations\n\nThis analysis is confined to task cb100-041-anchor-marine and the supplied synthetic evidence. It does not rely on external facts, does not resolve disputed law, and is not legal advice for a real person or entity.\n", "findings": {"as_of": "2026-09-04", "findings": [{"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/07_critical_vendors/049_critical_vendors_control_register.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for scheduled-claim mismatch: one source states the operative date is 2025-11-26 under control reference CB-RS-2801-A547, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2025-12-05 under response reference CB-RS-2801-J688.", "id": "F-01", "issue": "scheduled-claim mismatch", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/001_petition_schedules_control_register.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-04, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Dominic Alvarez.", "severity": "critical"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/07_critical_vendors/052_critical_vendors_ledger_export.csv", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for duplicate proof of claim: one source states the controlling amount is $2,105,139.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $2,126,778.00.", "id": "F-02", "issue": "duplicate proof of claim", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/004_petition_schedules_ledger_export.csv", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-04, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Priya Raman.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/07_critical_vendors/055_critical_vendors_officer_certificate.html", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for secured-status defect: one source states approval is attributed to Lena Varga as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Rafael Okafor and contains no entry for Lena Varga.", "id": "F-03", "issue": "secured-status defect", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/007_petition_schedules_officer_certificate.html", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-04, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Elliot Mercer.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/08_tax/058_tax_executed_instrument.txt", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for priority classification error: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-RS-2801-D356, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-RS-2801-M604.", "id": "F-04", "issue": "priority classification error", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/02_claims_register/010_claims_register_executed_instrument.txt", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-04, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Talia Brooks.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/08_tax/061_tax_review_memorandum.json", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for executory-contract cure dispute: one source states the applicable location is Southern District of Texas Bankruptcy Court, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to Texas operations outside Southern District of Texas Bankruptcy Court.", "id": "F-05", "issue": "executory-contract cure dispute", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/02_claims_register/013_claims_register_review_memorandum.json", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-04, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Jonas Feld.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/08_tax/064_tax_status_report.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for lease rejection deadline: one source states the threshold is 2% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 8% and produced a different exception result.", "id": "F-06", "issue": "lease rejection deadline", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/02_claims_register/016_claims_register_status_report.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-04, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Mei Whitaker.", "severity": "low"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/09_litigation/067_litigation_correspondence.eml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for postpetition invoice: one source states formal notice must use notices-anchor_marine_fabrication_inc@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-gulfline_steel_supply@example.test.", "id": "F-07", "issue": "postpetition invoice", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/019_proofs_of_claim_correspondence.eml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-04, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Caleb Hassan.", "severity": "critical"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/09_litigation/070_litigation_formal_notice.xml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for critical-vendor overstatement: one source states the governed population contains 144 records through 2025-08-27, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 58 records through 2025-09-26.", "id": "F-08", "issue": "critical-vendor overstatement", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/022_proofs_of_claim_formal_notice.xml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-04, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Leona Park.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/10_plan_disclosure/073_plan_disclosure_control_register.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for setoff assertion: one source states the operative date is 2025-10-29 under control reference CB-RS-2801-I639, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2025-12-03 under response reference CB-RS-2801-R764.", "id": "F-09", "issue": "setoff assertion", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/025_contracts_leases_control_register.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-04, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Isaac Romero.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/10_plan_disclosure/076_plan_disclosure_ledger_export.csv", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for guaranty overlap: one source states the controlling amount is $1,133,027.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $1,292,554.00.", "id": "F-10", "issue": "guaranty overlap", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/028_contracts_leases_ledger_export.csv", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-04, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Sofia Bennett.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/10_plan_disclosure/079_plan_disclosure_officer_certificate.html", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for tax priority period: one source states approval is attributed to Lena Varga as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Henry Cho and contains no entry for Lena Varga.", "id": "F-11", "issue": "tax priority period", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/031_contracts_leases_officer_certificate.html", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-04, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Adrian Mensah.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/11_notices_ballots/082_notices_ballots_executed_instrument.txt", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for DIP budget variance: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-RS-2801-L863, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-RS-2801-U781.", "id": "F-12", "issue": "DIP budget variance", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/05_cash_management/034_cash_management_executed_instrument.txt", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-04, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Willa Novak.", "severity": "low"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/11_notices_ballots/085_notices_ballots_review_memorandum.json", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for cash-collateral reporting gap: one source states the applicable location is Southern District of Texas Bankruptcy Court, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to Texas operations outside Southern District of Texas Bankruptcy Court.", "id": "F-13", "issue": "cash-collateral reporting gap", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/05_cash_management/037_cash_management_review_memorandum.json", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-04, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Theo Laurent.", "severity": "critical"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/11_notices_ballots/088_notices_ballots_status_report.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for ballot amount discrepancy: one source states the threshold is 15% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 22% and produced a different exception result.", "id": "F-14", "issue": "ballot amount discrepancy", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/05_cash_management/040_cash_management_status_report.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-04, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Amara Patel.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/091_reconciliations_correspondence.eml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for notice-address defect: one source states formal notice must use notices-anchor_marine_fabrication_inc@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-gulfline_steel_supply@example.test.", "id": "F-15", "issue": "notice-address defect", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/06_financing/043_financing_correspondence.eml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-04, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Henry Cho.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/094_reconciliations_formal_notice.xml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for reserve calculation error: one source states the governed population contains 186 records through 2026-02-25, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 56 records through 2026-03-25.", "id": "F-16", "issue": "reserve calculation error", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/06_financing/046_financing_formal_notice.xml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-04, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Nadine Flores.", "severity": "medium"}], "matter_number": "CB-RS-2801", "prepared_for": "Anchor Marine Fabrication, Inc.", "schema_version": "1.0", "task_id": "cb100-041-anchor-marine"}}, "metadata": {"benchmark": "CounselBench-100", "code_license": "Apache-2.0", "data_license": "CC-BY-4.0", "deadline": "2026-09-04", "document_count": 96, "jurisdiction": "Texas", "matter_number": "CB-RS-2801", "mcp_commit": "9a96ea6e5913736f92b88345bf51caeaaa8e719f", "mcp_package": "@modelcontextprotocol/server-filesystem@2026.7.10", "practice_area": "restructuring", "reference_tool_calls": 46, "required_evidence_reads": 33, "synthetic": true, "venue": "Southern District of Texas Bankruptcy Court", "version": "2.0.0"}, "prompt": "You are debtor-side restructuring counsel for Anchor Marine Fabrication, Inc. The partner responsible for this matter needs a defensible decision record before the next client call. A vessel fabricator must reconcile steel claims, lien assertions, postpetition deliveries, and disputed critical-vendor payments. Decision due 2026-09-04. Texas law governs; Southern District of Texas Bankruptcy Court is the forum. Prioritize conflicts between signed instruments and later operational records. Work out the defensible position from the matter production and leave an audit-ready exception tracker and concise advice for the supervising lawyer. Keep confirmed conflicts separate from open questions, cite the records that actually control each conclusion, and do not fill gaps with outside facts.", "rubric": {"criteria": [{"category": "procedure", "description": "Complete at least 46 successful, argument-specific evidence and output calls.", "id": "procedure.minimum_successful_tool_calls"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Find and read the 33 controlling, corroborating, and work-product-control records in full.", "id": "procedure.all_evidence_read_in_full"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Inspect file metadata for the eight designated critical primary records before relying on them.", "id": "procedure.chain_of_custody_metadata_checked"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Confirm the sandbox's allowed document and output roots.", "id": "procedure.allowed_directories_checked"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Inventory all 96 records so the relevant sources are discovered among the context records.", "id": "procedure.recursive_inventory_completed"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Search the production for email evidence that may corroborate or contradict formal records.", "id": "procedure.targeted_search_completed"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Leave only findings.json and advice.md in the output workspace.", "id": "procedure.exact_deliverable_set"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Create both final work products through the sandbox MCP surface.", "id": "procedure.deliverables_written_through_mcp"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Produce findings.json as a valid JSON object.", "id": "findings.findings_is_object"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Report exactly 16 confirmed exceptions.", "id": "findings.findings_exact_count"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Use each stable finding ID exactly once.", "id": "findings.finding_ids_unique"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set schema_version to the released matter value '1.0'.", "id": "findings.top_level_schema_version"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set task_id to the released matter value 'cb100-041-anchor-marine'.", "id": "findings.top_level_task_id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set matter_number to the released matter value 'CB-RS-2801'.", "id": "findings.top_level_matter_number"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set prepared_for to the released matter value 'Anchor Marine Fabrication, Inc.'.", "id": "findings.top_level_prepared_for"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set as_of to the released matter value '2026-09-04'.", "id": "findings.top_level_as_of"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-01 exception for scheduled-claim mismatch.", "id": "findings.F-01.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's id from /workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/001_petition_schedules_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_critical_vendors/049_critical_vendors_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's issue from /workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/001_petition_schedules_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_critical_vendors/049_critical_vendors_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's severity from /workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/001_petition_schedules_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_critical_vendors/049_critical_vendors_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's primary_source from /workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/001_petition_schedules_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_critical_vendors/049_critical_vendors_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/001_petition_schedules_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_critical_vendors/049_critical_vendors_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-01 using the exact controlled facts ['2025-11-26', 'CB-RS-2801-A547', '2025-12-05', 'CB-RS-2801-J688'].", "id": "findings.F-01.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-01's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-01.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-04', 'Dominic Alvarez'] for F-01.", "id": "findings.F-01.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-02 exception for duplicate proof of claim.", "id": "findings.F-02.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's id from /workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/004_petition_schedules_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_critical_vendors/052_critical_vendors_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's issue from /workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/004_petition_schedules_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_critical_vendors/052_critical_vendors_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's severity from /workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/004_petition_schedules_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_critical_vendors/052_critical_vendors_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's primary_source from /workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/004_petition_schedules_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_critical_vendors/052_critical_vendors_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/004_petition_schedules_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_critical_vendors/052_critical_vendors_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-02 using the exact controlled facts ['$2,105,139.00', '$2,126,778.00'].", "id": "findings.F-02.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-02's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-02.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-04', 'Priya Raman'] for F-02.", "id": "findings.F-02.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-03 exception for secured-status defect.", "id": "findings.F-03.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's id from /workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/007_petition_schedules_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_critical_vendors/055_critical_vendors_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's issue from /workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/007_petition_schedules_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_critical_vendors/055_critical_vendors_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's severity from /workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/007_petition_schedules_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_critical_vendors/055_critical_vendors_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's primary_source from /workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/007_petition_schedules_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_critical_vendors/055_critical_vendors_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/007_petition_schedules_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_critical_vendors/055_critical_vendors_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-03 using the exact controlled facts ['Lena Varga', 'Rafael Okafor'].", "id": "findings.F-03.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-03's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-03.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-04', 'Elliot Mercer'] for F-03.", "id": "findings.F-03.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-04 exception for priority classification error.", "id": "findings.F-04.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's id from /workspace/documents/02_claims_register/010_claims_register_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_tax/058_tax_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's issue from /workspace/documents/02_claims_register/010_claims_register_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_tax/058_tax_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's severity from /workspace/documents/02_claims_register/010_claims_register_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_tax/058_tax_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's primary_source from /workspace/documents/02_claims_register/010_claims_register_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_tax/058_tax_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/02_claims_register/010_claims_register_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_tax/058_tax_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-04 using the exact controlled facts ['closed without exception', 'CB-RS-2801-D356', 'open and escalated', 'CB-RS-2801-M604'].", "id": "findings.F-04.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-04's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-04.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-04', 'Talia Brooks'] for F-04.", "id": "findings.F-04.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-05 exception for executory-contract cure dispute.", "id": "findings.F-05.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's id from /workspace/documents/02_claims_register/013_claims_register_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_tax/061_tax_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's issue from /workspace/documents/02_claims_register/013_claims_register_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_tax/061_tax_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's severity from /workspace/documents/02_claims_register/013_claims_register_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_tax/061_tax_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's primary_source from /workspace/documents/02_claims_register/013_claims_register_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_tax/061_tax_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/02_claims_register/013_claims_register_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_tax/061_tax_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-05 using the exact controlled facts ['Southern District of Texas Bankruptcy Court', 'Texas'].", "id": "findings.F-05.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-05's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-05.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-04', 'Jonas Feld'] for F-05.", "id": "findings.F-05.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-06 exception for lease rejection deadline.", "id": "findings.F-06.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's id from /workspace/documents/02_claims_register/016_claims_register_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_tax/064_tax_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's issue from /workspace/documents/02_claims_register/016_claims_register_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_tax/064_tax_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's severity from /workspace/documents/02_claims_register/016_claims_register_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_tax/064_tax_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's primary_source from /workspace/documents/02_claims_register/016_claims_register_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_tax/064_tax_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/02_claims_register/016_claims_register_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_tax/064_tax_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-06 using the exact controlled facts ['2%', '8%'].", "id": "findings.F-06.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-06's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-06.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-04', 'Mei Whitaker'] for F-06.", "id": "findings.F-06.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-07 exception for postpetition invoice.", "id": "findings.F-07.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's id from /workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/019_proofs_of_claim_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_litigation/067_litigation_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's issue from /workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/019_proofs_of_claim_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_litigation/067_litigation_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's severity from /workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/019_proofs_of_claim_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_litigation/067_litigation_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's primary_source from /workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/019_proofs_of_claim_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_litigation/067_litigation_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/019_proofs_of_claim_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_litigation/067_litigation_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-07 using the exact controlled facts ['notices-anchor_marine_fabrication_inc@example.test', 'archive-gulfline_steel_supply@example.test'].", "id": "findings.F-07.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-07's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-07.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-04', 'Caleb Hassan'] for F-07.", "id": "findings.F-07.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-08 exception for critical-vendor overstatement.", "id": "findings.F-08.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's id from /workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/022_proofs_of_claim_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_litigation/070_litigation_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's issue from /workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/022_proofs_of_claim_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_litigation/070_litigation_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's severity from /workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/022_proofs_of_claim_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_litigation/070_litigation_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's primary_source from /workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/022_proofs_of_claim_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_litigation/070_litigation_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/022_proofs_of_claim_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_litigation/070_litigation_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-08 using the exact controlled facts ['144 records', '2025-08-27', '58 records', '2025-09-26'].", "id": "findings.F-08.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-08's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-08.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-04', 'Leona Park'] for F-08.", "id": "findings.F-08.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-09 exception for setoff assertion.", "id": "findings.F-09.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's id from /workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/025_contracts_leases_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_plan_disclosure/073_plan_disclosure_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's issue from /workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/025_contracts_leases_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_plan_disclosure/073_plan_disclosure_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's severity from /workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/025_contracts_leases_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_plan_disclosure/073_plan_disclosure_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's primary_source from /workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/025_contracts_leases_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_plan_disclosure/073_plan_disclosure_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/025_contracts_leases_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_plan_disclosure/073_plan_disclosure_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-09 using the exact controlled facts ['2025-10-29', 'CB-RS-2801-I639', '2025-12-03', 'CB-RS-2801-R764'].", "id": "findings.F-09.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-09's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-09.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-04', 'Isaac Romero'] for F-09.", "id": "findings.F-09.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-10 exception for guaranty overlap.", "id": "findings.F-10.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's id from /workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/028_contracts_leases_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_plan_disclosure/076_plan_disclosure_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's issue from /workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/028_contracts_leases_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_plan_disclosure/076_plan_disclosure_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's severity from /workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/028_contracts_leases_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_plan_disclosure/076_plan_disclosure_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's primary_source from /workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/028_contracts_leases_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_plan_disclosure/076_plan_disclosure_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/028_contracts_leases_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_plan_disclosure/076_plan_disclosure_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-10 using the exact controlled facts ['$1,133,027.00', '$1,292,554.00'].", "id": "findings.F-10.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-10's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-10.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-04', 'Sofia Bennett'] for F-10.", "id": "findings.F-10.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-11 exception for tax priority period.", "id": "findings.F-11.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's id from /workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/031_contracts_leases_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_plan_disclosure/079_plan_disclosure_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's issue from /workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/031_contracts_leases_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_plan_disclosure/079_plan_disclosure_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's severity from /workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/031_contracts_leases_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_plan_disclosure/079_plan_disclosure_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's primary_source from /workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/031_contracts_leases_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_plan_disclosure/079_plan_disclosure_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/031_contracts_leases_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_plan_disclosure/079_plan_disclosure_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-11 using the exact controlled facts ['Lena Varga', 'Henry Cho'].", "id": "findings.F-11.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-11's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-11.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-04', 'Adrian Mensah'] for F-11.", "id": "findings.F-11.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-12 exception for DIP budget variance.", "id": "findings.F-12.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's id from /workspace/documents/05_cash_management/034_cash_management_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_notices_ballots/082_notices_ballots_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's issue from /workspace/documents/05_cash_management/034_cash_management_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_notices_ballots/082_notices_ballots_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's severity from /workspace/documents/05_cash_management/034_cash_management_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_notices_ballots/082_notices_ballots_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's primary_source from /workspace/documents/05_cash_management/034_cash_management_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_notices_ballots/082_notices_ballots_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/05_cash_management/034_cash_management_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_notices_ballots/082_notices_ballots_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-12 using the exact controlled facts ['closed without exception', 'CB-RS-2801-L863', 'open and escalated', 'CB-RS-2801-U781'].", "id": "findings.F-12.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-12's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-12.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-04', 'Willa Novak'] for F-12.", "id": "findings.F-12.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-13 exception for cash-collateral reporting gap.", "id": "findings.F-13.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's id from /workspace/documents/05_cash_management/037_cash_management_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_notices_ballots/085_notices_ballots_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's issue from /workspace/documents/05_cash_management/037_cash_management_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_notices_ballots/085_notices_ballots_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's severity from /workspace/documents/05_cash_management/037_cash_management_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_notices_ballots/085_notices_ballots_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's primary_source from /workspace/documents/05_cash_management/037_cash_management_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_notices_ballots/085_notices_ballots_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/05_cash_management/037_cash_management_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_notices_ballots/085_notices_ballots_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-13 using the exact controlled facts ['Southern District of Texas Bankruptcy Court', 'Texas'].", "id": "findings.F-13.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-13's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-13.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-04', 'Theo Laurent'] for F-13.", "id": "findings.F-13.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-14 exception for ballot amount discrepancy.", "id": "findings.F-14.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's id from /workspace/documents/05_cash_management/040_cash_management_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_notices_ballots/088_notices_ballots_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's issue from /workspace/documents/05_cash_management/040_cash_management_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_notices_ballots/088_notices_ballots_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's severity from /workspace/documents/05_cash_management/040_cash_management_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_notices_ballots/088_notices_ballots_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's primary_source from /workspace/documents/05_cash_management/040_cash_management_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_notices_ballots/088_notices_ballots_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/05_cash_management/040_cash_management_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_notices_ballots/088_notices_ballots_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-14 using the exact controlled facts ['15%', '22%'].", "id": "findings.F-14.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-14's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-14.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-04', 'Amara Patel'] for F-14.", "id": "findings.F-14.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-15 exception for notice-address defect.", "id": "findings.F-15.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's id from /workspace/documents/06_financing/043_financing_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/091_reconciliations_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's issue from /workspace/documents/06_financing/043_financing_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/091_reconciliations_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's severity from /workspace/documents/06_financing/043_financing_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/091_reconciliations_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's primary_source from /workspace/documents/06_financing/043_financing_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/091_reconciliations_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/06_financing/043_financing_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/091_reconciliations_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-15 using the exact controlled facts ['notices-anchor_marine_fabrication_inc@example.test', 'archive-gulfline_steel_supply@example.test'].", "id": "findings.F-15.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-15's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-15.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-04', 'Henry Cho'] for F-15.", "id": "findings.F-15.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-16 exception for reserve calculation error.", "id": "findings.F-16.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's id from /workspace/documents/06_financing/046_financing_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/094_reconciliations_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's issue from /workspace/documents/06_financing/046_financing_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/094_reconciliations_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's severity from /workspace/documents/06_financing/046_financing_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/094_reconciliations_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's primary_source from /workspace/documents/06_financing/046_financing_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/094_reconciliations_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/06_financing/046_financing_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/094_reconciliations_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-16 using the exact controlled facts ['186 records', '2026-02-25', '56 records', '2026-03-25'].", "id": "findings.F-16.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-16's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-16.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-04', 'Nadine Flores'] for F-16.", "id": "findings.F-16.action_anchors"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Executive assessment' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Executive assessment"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Method and record coverage' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Method and record coverage"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Findings' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Findings"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Recommended next actions' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Recommended next actions"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Assumptions and limitations' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Assumptions and limitations"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-01 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-01"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-02 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-02"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-03 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-03"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-04 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-04"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-05 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-05"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-06 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-06"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-07 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-07"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-08 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-08"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-09 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-09"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-10 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-10"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-11 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-11"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-12 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-12"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-13 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-13"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-14 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-14"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-15 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-15"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-16 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-16"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Do not claim the production has no issues or that every record is consistent.", "id": "memo.forbidden_claims_absent"}], "decision_options": [{"id": "cross-source-reconciliation", "label": "Reconcile controlling and corroborating records", "reason": "The CB-RS-2801 production contains independently maintained records; a defensible answer must preserve each supported conflict and its cure owner.", "selected": true}, {"id": "latest-record-controls", "label": "Treat the latest record as controlling", "reason": "Timestamp recency does not establish legal priority, execution, or approval authority.", "selected": false}, {"id": "primary-records-only", "label": "Report primary records without reconciliation", "reason": "Primary records alone conceal the operational conflicts that create the actionable exceptions.", "selected": false}], "gates": ["all_evidence_read_in_full", "chain_of_custody_metadata_checked", "findings_criteria_complete", "memo_criteria_complete", "deliverables_written_through_mcp"], "metadata_checks": 8, "metric": "weighted_criteria_score", "minimum_tool_calls": 46, "required_deliverables": ["findings.json", "advice.md"], "required_document_reads": 33, "type": "deterministic", "weights": {"findings": 0.55, "memo": 0.2, "procedure": 0.25}}, "task_id": "cb100-041-anchor-marine", "task_name": "Anchor Marine chapter 11 claim review", "world_id": "counselbench-filesystem-mcp-v2"}
-{"context_files": ["task_files/cb100-042-birch-aviation/01_petition_schedules/001_petition_schedules_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-042-birch-aviation/01_petition_schedules/002_petition_schedules_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-042-birch-aviation/01_petition_schedules/003_petition_schedules_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-042-birch-aviation/01_petition_schedules/004_petition_schedules_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-042-birch-aviation/01_petition_schedules/005_petition_schedules_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-042-birch-aviation/01_petition_schedules/006_petition_schedules_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-042-birch-aviation/01_petition_schedules/007_petition_schedules_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-042-birch-aviation/01_petition_schedules/008_petition_schedules_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-042-birch-aviation/02_claims_register/009_claims_register_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-042-birch-aviation/02_claims_register/010_claims_register_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-042-birch-aviation/02_claims_register/011_claims_register_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-042-birch-aviation/02_claims_register/012_claims_register_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-042-birch-aviation/02_claims_register/013_claims_register_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-042-birch-aviation/02_claims_register/014_claims_register_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-042-birch-aviation/02_claims_register/015_claims_register_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-042-birch-aviation/02_claims_register/016_claims_register_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-042-birch-aviation/03_proofs_of_claim/017_proofs_of_claim_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-042-birch-aviation/03_proofs_of_claim/018_proofs_of_claim_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-042-birch-aviation/03_proofs_of_claim/019_proofs_of_claim_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-042-birch-aviation/03_proofs_of_claim/020_proofs_of_claim_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-042-birch-aviation/03_proofs_of_claim/021_proofs_of_claim_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-042-birch-aviation/03_proofs_of_claim/022_proofs_of_claim_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-042-birch-aviation/03_proofs_of_claim/023_proofs_of_claim_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-042-birch-aviation/03_proofs_of_claim/024_proofs_of_claim_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-042-birch-aviation/04_contracts_leases/025_contracts_leases_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-042-birch-aviation/04_contracts_leases/026_contracts_leases_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-042-birch-aviation/04_contracts_leases/027_contracts_leases_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-042-birch-aviation/04_contracts_leases/028_contracts_leases_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-042-birch-aviation/04_contracts_leases/029_contracts_leases_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-042-birch-aviation/04_contracts_leases/030_contracts_leases_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-042-birch-aviation/04_contracts_leases/031_contracts_leases_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-042-birch-aviation/04_contracts_leases/032_contracts_leases_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-042-birch-aviation/05_cash_management/033_cash_management_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-042-birch-aviation/05_cash_management/034_cash_management_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-042-birch-aviation/05_cash_management/035_cash_management_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-042-birch-aviation/05_cash_management/036_cash_management_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-042-birch-aviation/05_cash_management/037_cash_management_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-042-birch-aviation/05_cash_management/038_cash_management_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-042-birch-aviation/05_cash_management/039_cash_management_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-042-birch-aviation/05_cash_management/040_cash_management_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-042-birch-aviation/06_financing/041_financing_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-042-birch-aviation/06_financing/042_financing_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-042-birch-aviation/06_financing/043_financing_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-042-birch-aviation/06_financing/044_financing_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-042-birch-aviation/06_financing/045_financing_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-042-birch-aviation/06_financing/046_financing_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-042-birch-aviation/06_financing/047_financing_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-042-birch-aviation/06_financing/048_financing_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-042-birch-aviation/07_critical_vendors/049_critical_vendors_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-042-birch-aviation/07_critical_vendors/050_critical_vendors_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-042-birch-aviation/07_critical_vendors/051_critical_vendors_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-042-birch-aviation/07_critical_vendors/052_critical_vendors_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-042-birch-aviation/07_critical_vendors/053_critical_vendors_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-042-birch-aviation/07_critical_vendors/054_critical_vendors_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-042-birch-aviation/07_critical_vendors/055_critical_vendors_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-042-birch-aviation/07_critical_vendors/056_critical_vendors_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-042-birch-aviation/08_tax/057_tax_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-042-birch-aviation/08_tax/058_tax_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-042-birch-aviation/08_tax/059_tax_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-042-birch-aviation/08_tax/060_tax_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-042-birch-aviation/08_tax/061_tax_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-042-birch-aviation/08_tax/062_tax_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-042-birch-aviation/08_tax/063_tax_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-042-birch-aviation/08_tax/064_tax_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-042-birch-aviation/09_litigation/065_litigation_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-042-birch-aviation/09_litigation/066_litigation_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-042-birch-aviation/09_litigation/067_litigation_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-042-birch-aviation/09_litigation/068_litigation_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-042-birch-aviation/09_litigation/069_litigation_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-042-birch-aviation/09_litigation/070_litigation_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-042-birch-aviation/09_litigation/071_litigation_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-042-birch-aviation/09_litigation/072_litigation_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-042-birch-aviation/10_plan_disclosure/073_plan_disclosure_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-042-birch-aviation/10_plan_disclosure/074_plan_disclosure_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-042-birch-aviation/10_plan_disclosure/075_plan_disclosure_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-042-birch-aviation/10_plan_disclosure/076_plan_disclosure_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-042-birch-aviation/10_plan_disclosure/077_plan_disclosure_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-042-birch-aviation/10_plan_disclosure/078_plan_disclosure_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-042-birch-aviation/10_plan_disclosure/079_plan_disclosure_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-042-birch-aviation/10_plan_disclosure/080_plan_disclosure_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-042-birch-aviation/11_notices_ballots/081_notices_ballots_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-042-birch-aviation/11_notices_ballots/082_notices_ballots_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-042-birch-aviation/11_notices_ballots/083_notices_ballots_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-042-birch-aviation/11_notices_ballots/084_notices_ballots_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-042-birch-aviation/11_notices_ballots/085_notices_ballots_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-042-birch-aviation/11_notices_ballots/086_notices_ballots_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-042-birch-aviation/11_notices_ballots/087_notices_ballots_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-042-birch-aviation/11_notices_ballots/088_notices_ballots_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-042-birch-aviation/12_reconciliations/089_reconciliations_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-042-birch-aviation/12_reconciliations/090_reconciliations_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-042-birch-aviation/12_reconciliations/091_reconciliations_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-042-birch-aviation/12_reconciliations/092_reconciliations_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-042-birch-aviation/12_reconciliations/093_reconciliations_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-042-birch-aviation/12_reconciliations/094_reconciliations_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-042-birch-aviation/12_reconciliations/095_reconciliations_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-042-birch-aviation/12_reconciliations/096_reconciliations_status_report.md"], "gold_output": {"advice_markdown": "# Counsel advice — Birch Aviation lease reconciliation\n\n## Executive assessment\n\nFor Birch Regional Aviation LLC matter CB-RS-2802, the review identified 16 source-supported exceptions requiring action before 2026-09-08. The assessment concerns Skyframe Aircraft Leasing and the supplied record for Virginia.\n\n## Method and record coverage\n\nThe review inventoried all 96 production files, read the 33 controlling, corroborating, and control records, searched the email exports, and checked metadata for the designated chain-of-custody sample. Conclusions are limited to the synthetic production supplied for this benchmark matter.\n\n## Findings\n\n### F-01 — scheduled-claim mismatch (critical)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for scheduled-claim mismatch: one source states the operative date is 2025-09-10 under control reference CB-RS-2802-A350, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2025-10-04 under response reference CB-RS-2802-J257.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/001_petition_schedules_control_register.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/07_critical_vendors/049_critical_vendors_control_register.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-08, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Priya Raman.\n\n### F-02 — duplicate proof of claim (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for duplicate proof of claim: one source states the controlling amount is $3,295,696.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $3,587,892.00.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/004_petition_schedules_ledger_export.csv`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/07_critical_vendors/052_critical_vendors_ledger_export.csv`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-08, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Elliot Mercer.\n\n### F-03 — secured-status defect (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for secured-status defect: one source states approval is attributed to Samuel Kim as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Dominic Alvarez and contains no entry for Samuel Kim.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/007_petition_schedules_officer_certificate.html`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/07_critical_vendors/055_critical_vendors_officer_certificate.html`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-08, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Talia Brooks.\n\n### F-04 — priority classification error (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for priority classification error: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-RS-2802-D750, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-RS-2802-M634.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/02_claims_register/010_claims_register_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/08_tax/058_tax_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-08, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Jonas Feld.\n\n### F-05 — executory-contract cure dispute (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for executory-contract cure dispute: one source states the applicable location is Eastern District of Virginia Bankruptcy Court, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to Virginia operations outside Eastern District of Virginia Bankruptcy Court.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/02_claims_register/013_claims_register_review_memorandum.json`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/08_tax/061_tax_review_memorandum.json`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-08, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Mei Whitaker.\n\n### F-06 — lease rejection deadline (low)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for lease rejection deadline: one source states the threshold is 15% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 22% and produced a different exception result.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/02_claims_register/016_claims_register_status_report.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/08_tax/064_tax_status_report.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-08, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Caleb Hassan.\n\n### F-07 — postpetition invoice (critical)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for postpetition invoice: one source states formal notice must use notices-birch_regional_aviation_llc@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-skyframe_aircraft_leasing@example.test.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/019_proofs_of_claim_correspondence.eml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/09_litigation/067_litigation_correspondence.eml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-08, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Leona Park.\n\n### F-08 — critical-vendor overstatement (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for critical-vendor overstatement: one source states the governed population contains 148 records through 2025-08-31, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 48 records through 2025-09-20.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/022_proofs_of_claim_formal_notice.xml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/09_litigation/070_litigation_formal_notice.xml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-08, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Isaac Romero.\n\n### F-09 — setoff assertion (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for setoff assertion: one source states the operative date is 2026-01-11 under control reference CB-RS-2802-I833, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2026-02-09 under response reference CB-RS-2802-R917.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/025_contracts_leases_control_register.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/10_plan_disclosure/073_plan_disclosure_control_register.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-08, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Sofia Bennett.\n\n### F-10 — guaranty overlap (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for guaranty overlap: one source states the controlling amount is $5,991,033.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $6,068,566.00.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/028_contracts_leases_ledger_export.csv`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/10_plan_disclosure/076_plan_disclosure_ledger_export.csv`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-08, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Adrian Mensah.\n\n### F-11 — tax priority period (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for tax priority period: one source states approval is attributed to Samuel Kim as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Micah Sullivan and contains no entry for Samuel Kim.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/031_contracts_leases_officer_certificate.html`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/10_plan_disclosure/079_plan_disclosure_officer_certificate.html`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-08, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Willa Novak.\n\n### F-12 — DIP budget variance (low)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for DIP budget variance: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-RS-2802-L633, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-RS-2802-U764.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/05_cash_management/034_cash_management_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/11_notices_ballots/082_notices_ballots_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-08, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Theo Laurent.\n\n### F-13 — cash-collateral reporting gap (critical)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for cash-collateral reporting gap: one source states the applicable location is Eastern District of Virginia Bankruptcy Court, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to Virginia operations outside Eastern District of Virginia Bankruptcy Court.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/05_cash_management/037_cash_management_review_memorandum.json`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/11_notices_ballots/085_notices_ballots_review_memorandum.json`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-08, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Amara Patel.\n\n### F-14 — ballot amount discrepancy (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for ballot amount discrepancy: one source states the threshold is 2% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 8% and produced a different exception result.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/05_cash_management/040_cash_management_status_report.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/11_notices_ballots/088_notices_ballots_status_report.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-08, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Henry Cho.\n\n### F-15 — notice-address defect (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for notice-address defect: one source states formal notice must use notices-birch_regional_aviation_llc@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-skyframe_aircraft_leasing@example.test.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/06_financing/043_financing_correspondence.eml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/091_reconciliations_correspondence.eml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-08, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Nadine Flores.\n\n### F-16 — reserve calculation error (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for reserve calculation error: one source states the governed population contains 171 records through 2025-05-06, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 47 records through 2025-05-25.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/06_financing/046_financing_formal_notice.xml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/094_reconciliations_formal_notice.xml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-08, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Micah Sullivan.\n\n## Recommended next actions\n\nSequence the critical and high findings first, assign the named owners, preserve the cited records, and document any resolution in the controlling matter register before the stated deadline.\n\n## Assumptions and limitations\n\nThis analysis is confined to task cb100-042-birch-aviation and the supplied synthetic evidence. It does not rely on external facts, does not resolve disputed law, and is not legal advice for a real person or entity.\n", "findings": {"as_of": "2026-09-08", "findings": [{"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/07_critical_vendors/049_critical_vendors_control_register.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for scheduled-claim mismatch: one source states the operative date is 2025-09-10 under control reference CB-RS-2802-A350, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2025-10-04 under response reference CB-RS-2802-J257.", "id": "F-01", "issue": "scheduled-claim mismatch", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/001_petition_schedules_control_register.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-08, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Priya Raman.", "severity": "critical"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/07_critical_vendors/052_critical_vendors_ledger_export.csv", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for duplicate proof of claim: one source states the controlling amount is $3,295,696.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $3,587,892.00.", "id": "F-02", "issue": "duplicate proof of claim", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/004_petition_schedules_ledger_export.csv", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-08, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Elliot Mercer.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/07_critical_vendors/055_critical_vendors_officer_certificate.html", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for secured-status defect: one source states approval is attributed to Samuel Kim as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Dominic Alvarez and contains no entry for Samuel Kim.", "id": "F-03", "issue": "secured-status defect", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/007_petition_schedules_officer_certificate.html", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-08, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Talia Brooks.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/08_tax/058_tax_executed_instrument.txt", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for priority classification error: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-RS-2802-D750, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-RS-2802-M634.", "id": "F-04", "issue": "priority classification error", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/02_claims_register/010_claims_register_executed_instrument.txt", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-08, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Jonas Feld.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/08_tax/061_tax_review_memorandum.json", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for executory-contract cure dispute: one source states the applicable location is Eastern District of Virginia Bankruptcy Court, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to Virginia operations outside Eastern District of Virginia Bankruptcy Court.", "id": "F-05", "issue": "executory-contract cure dispute", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/02_claims_register/013_claims_register_review_memorandum.json", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-08, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Mei Whitaker.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/08_tax/064_tax_status_report.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for lease rejection deadline: one source states the threshold is 15% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 22% and produced a different exception result.", "id": "F-06", "issue": "lease rejection deadline", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/02_claims_register/016_claims_register_status_report.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-08, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Caleb Hassan.", "severity": "low"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/09_litigation/067_litigation_correspondence.eml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for postpetition invoice: one source states formal notice must use notices-birch_regional_aviation_llc@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-skyframe_aircraft_leasing@example.test.", "id": "F-07", "issue": "postpetition invoice", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/019_proofs_of_claim_correspondence.eml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-08, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Leona Park.", "severity": "critical"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/09_litigation/070_litigation_formal_notice.xml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for critical-vendor overstatement: one source states the governed population contains 148 records through 2025-08-31, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 48 records through 2025-09-20.", "id": "F-08", "issue": "critical-vendor overstatement", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/022_proofs_of_claim_formal_notice.xml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-08, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Isaac Romero.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/10_plan_disclosure/073_plan_disclosure_control_register.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for setoff assertion: one source states the operative date is 2026-01-11 under control reference CB-RS-2802-I833, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2026-02-09 under response reference CB-RS-2802-R917.", "id": "F-09", "issue": "setoff assertion", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/025_contracts_leases_control_register.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-08, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Sofia Bennett.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/10_plan_disclosure/076_plan_disclosure_ledger_export.csv", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for guaranty overlap: one source states the controlling amount is $5,991,033.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $6,068,566.00.", "id": "F-10", "issue": "guaranty overlap", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/028_contracts_leases_ledger_export.csv", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-08, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Adrian Mensah.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/10_plan_disclosure/079_plan_disclosure_officer_certificate.html", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for tax priority period: one source states approval is attributed to Samuel Kim as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Micah Sullivan and contains no entry for Samuel Kim.", "id": "F-11", "issue": "tax priority period", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/031_contracts_leases_officer_certificate.html", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-08, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Willa Novak.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/11_notices_ballots/082_notices_ballots_executed_instrument.txt", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for DIP budget variance: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-RS-2802-L633, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-RS-2802-U764.", "id": "F-12", "issue": "DIP budget variance", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/05_cash_management/034_cash_management_executed_instrument.txt", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-08, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Theo Laurent.", "severity": "low"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/11_notices_ballots/085_notices_ballots_review_memorandum.json", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for cash-collateral reporting gap: one source states the applicable location is Eastern District of Virginia Bankruptcy Court, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to Virginia operations outside Eastern District of Virginia Bankruptcy Court.", "id": "F-13", "issue": "cash-collateral reporting gap", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/05_cash_management/037_cash_management_review_memorandum.json", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-08, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Amara Patel.", "severity": "critical"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/11_notices_ballots/088_notices_ballots_status_report.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for ballot amount discrepancy: one source states the threshold is 2% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 8% and produced a different exception result.", "id": "F-14", "issue": "ballot amount discrepancy", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/05_cash_management/040_cash_management_status_report.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-08, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Henry Cho.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/091_reconciliations_correspondence.eml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for notice-address defect: one source states formal notice must use notices-birch_regional_aviation_llc@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-skyframe_aircraft_leasing@example.test.", "id": "F-15", "issue": "notice-address defect", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/06_financing/043_financing_correspondence.eml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-08, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Nadine Flores.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/094_reconciliations_formal_notice.xml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for reserve calculation error: one source states the governed population contains 171 records through 2025-05-06, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 47 records through 2025-05-25.", "id": "F-16", "issue": "reserve calculation error", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/06_financing/046_financing_formal_notice.xml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-08, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Micah Sullivan.", "severity": "medium"}], "matter_number": "CB-RS-2802", "prepared_for": "Birch Regional Aviation LLC", "schema_version": "1.0", "task_id": "cb100-042-birch-aviation"}}, "metadata": {"benchmark": "CounselBench-100", "code_license": "Apache-2.0", "data_license": "CC-BY-4.0", "deadline": "2026-09-08", "document_count": 96, "jurisdiction": "Virginia", "matter_number": "CB-RS-2802", "mcp_commit": "9a96ea6e5913736f92b88345bf51caeaaa8e719f", "mcp_package": "@modelcontextprotocol/server-filesystem@2026.7.10", "practice_area": "restructuring", "reference_tool_calls": 46, "required_evidence_reads": 33, "synthetic": true, "venue": "Eastern District of Virginia Bankruptcy Court", "version": "2.0.0"}, "prompt": "You are debtor-side restructuring counsel for Birch Regional Aviation LLC. A late document production changed the factual picture, and the matter team needs the entire record reconciled from first principles. Aircraft and gate leases carry cure disputes, guaranties, and notice addresses that changed shortly before the petition date. Decision due 2026-09-08. Virginia law governs; Eastern District of Virginia Bankruptcy Court is the forum. Separate confirmed exceptions from items that merely require follow-up. Work out the defensible position from the matter production and leave an audit-ready exception tracker and concise advice for the supervising lawyer. Keep confirmed conflicts separate from open questions, cite the records that actually control each conclusion, and do not fill gaps with outside facts.", "rubric": {"criteria": [{"category": "procedure", "description": "Complete at least 46 successful, argument-specific evidence and output calls.", "id": "procedure.minimum_successful_tool_calls"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Find and read the 33 controlling, corroborating, and work-product-control records in full.", "id": "procedure.all_evidence_read_in_full"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Inspect file metadata for the eight designated critical primary records before relying on them.", "id": "procedure.chain_of_custody_metadata_checked"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Confirm the sandbox's allowed document and output roots.", "id": "procedure.allowed_directories_checked"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Inventory all 96 records so the relevant sources are discovered among the context records.", "id": "procedure.recursive_inventory_completed"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Search the production for email evidence that may corroborate or contradict formal records.", "id": "procedure.targeted_search_completed"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Leave only findings.json and advice.md in the output workspace.", "id": "procedure.exact_deliverable_set"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Create both final work products through the sandbox MCP surface.", "id": "procedure.deliverables_written_through_mcp"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Produce findings.json as a valid JSON object.", "id": "findings.findings_is_object"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Report exactly 16 confirmed exceptions.", "id": "findings.findings_exact_count"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Use each stable finding ID exactly once.", "id": "findings.finding_ids_unique"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set schema_version to the released matter value '1.0'.", "id": "findings.top_level_schema_version"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set task_id to the released matter value 'cb100-042-birch-aviation'.", "id": "findings.top_level_task_id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set matter_number to the released matter value 'CB-RS-2802'.", "id": "findings.top_level_matter_number"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set prepared_for to the released matter value 'Birch Regional Aviation LLC'.", "id": "findings.top_level_prepared_for"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set as_of to the released matter value '2026-09-08'.", "id": "findings.top_level_as_of"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-01 exception for scheduled-claim mismatch.", "id": "findings.F-01.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's id from /workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/001_petition_schedules_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_critical_vendors/049_critical_vendors_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's issue from /workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/001_petition_schedules_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_critical_vendors/049_critical_vendors_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's severity from /workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/001_petition_schedules_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_critical_vendors/049_critical_vendors_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's primary_source from /workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/001_petition_schedules_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_critical_vendors/049_critical_vendors_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/001_petition_schedules_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_critical_vendors/049_critical_vendors_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-01 using the exact controlled facts ['2025-09-10', 'CB-RS-2802-A350', '2025-10-04', 'CB-RS-2802-J257'].", "id": "findings.F-01.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-01's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-01.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-08', 'Priya Raman'] for F-01.", "id": "findings.F-01.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-02 exception for duplicate proof of claim.", "id": "findings.F-02.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's id from /workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/004_petition_schedules_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_critical_vendors/052_critical_vendors_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's issue from /workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/004_petition_schedules_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_critical_vendors/052_critical_vendors_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's severity from /workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/004_petition_schedules_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_critical_vendors/052_critical_vendors_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's primary_source from /workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/004_petition_schedules_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_critical_vendors/052_critical_vendors_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/004_petition_schedules_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_critical_vendors/052_critical_vendors_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-02 using the exact controlled facts ['$3,295,696.00', '$3,587,892.00'].", "id": "findings.F-02.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-02's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-02.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-08', 'Elliot Mercer'] for F-02.", "id": "findings.F-02.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-03 exception for secured-status defect.", "id": "findings.F-03.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's id from /workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/007_petition_schedules_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_critical_vendors/055_critical_vendors_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's issue from /workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/007_petition_schedules_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_critical_vendors/055_critical_vendors_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's severity from /workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/007_petition_schedules_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_critical_vendors/055_critical_vendors_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's primary_source from /workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/007_petition_schedules_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_critical_vendors/055_critical_vendors_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/007_petition_schedules_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_critical_vendors/055_critical_vendors_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-03 using the exact controlled facts ['Samuel Kim', 'Dominic Alvarez'].", "id": "findings.F-03.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-03's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-03.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-08', 'Talia Brooks'] for F-03.", "id": "findings.F-03.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-04 exception for priority classification error.", "id": "findings.F-04.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's id from /workspace/documents/02_claims_register/010_claims_register_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_tax/058_tax_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's issue from /workspace/documents/02_claims_register/010_claims_register_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_tax/058_tax_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's severity from /workspace/documents/02_claims_register/010_claims_register_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_tax/058_tax_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's primary_source from /workspace/documents/02_claims_register/010_claims_register_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_tax/058_tax_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/02_claims_register/010_claims_register_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_tax/058_tax_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-04 using the exact controlled facts ['closed without exception', 'CB-RS-2802-D750', 'open and escalated', 'CB-RS-2802-M634'].", "id": "findings.F-04.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-04's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-04.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-08', 'Jonas Feld'] for F-04.", "id": "findings.F-04.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-05 exception for executory-contract cure dispute.", "id": "findings.F-05.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's id from /workspace/documents/02_claims_register/013_claims_register_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_tax/061_tax_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's issue from /workspace/documents/02_claims_register/013_claims_register_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_tax/061_tax_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's severity from /workspace/documents/02_claims_register/013_claims_register_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_tax/061_tax_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's primary_source from /workspace/documents/02_claims_register/013_claims_register_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_tax/061_tax_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/02_claims_register/013_claims_register_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_tax/061_tax_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-05 using the exact controlled facts ['Eastern District of Virginia Bankruptcy Court', 'Virginia'].", "id": "findings.F-05.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-05's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-05.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-08', 'Mei Whitaker'] for F-05.", "id": "findings.F-05.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-06 exception for lease rejection deadline.", "id": "findings.F-06.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's id from /workspace/documents/02_claims_register/016_claims_register_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_tax/064_tax_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's issue from /workspace/documents/02_claims_register/016_claims_register_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_tax/064_tax_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's severity from /workspace/documents/02_claims_register/016_claims_register_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_tax/064_tax_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's primary_source from /workspace/documents/02_claims_register/016_claims_register_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_tax/064_tax_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/02_claims_register/016_claims_register_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_tax/064_tax_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-06 using the exact controlled facts ['15%', '22%'].", "id": "findings.F-06.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-06's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-06.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-08', 'Caleb Hassan'] for F-06.", "id": "findings.F-06.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-07 exception for postpetition invoice.", "id": "findings.F-07.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's id from /workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/019_proofs_of_claim_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_litigation/067_litigation_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's issue from /workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/019_proofs_of_claim_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_litigation/067_litigation_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's severity from /workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/019_proofs_of_claim_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_litigation/067_litigation_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's primary_source from /workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/019_proofs_of_claim_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_litigation/067_litigation_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/019_proofs_of_claim_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_litigation/067_litigation_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-07 using the exact controlled facts ['notices-birch_regional_aviation_llc@example.test', 'archive-skyframe_aircraft_leasing@example.test'].", "id": "findings.F-07.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-07's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-07.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-08', 'Leona Park'] for F-07.", "id": "findings.F-07.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-08 exception for critical-vendor overstatement.", "id": "findings.F-08.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's id from /workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/022_proofs_of_claim_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_litigation/070_litigation_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's issue from /workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/022_proofs_of_claim_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_litigation/070_litigation_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's severity from /workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/022_proofs_of_claim_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_litigation/070_litigation_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's primary_source from /workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/022_proofs_of_claim_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_litigation/070_litigation_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/022_proofs_of_claim_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_litigation/070_litigation_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-08 using the exact controlled facts ['148 records', '2025-08-31', '48 records', '2025-09-20'].", "id": "findings.F-08.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-08's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-08.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-08', 'Isaac Romero'] for F-08.", "id": "findings.F-08.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-09 exception for setoff assertion.", "id": "findings.F-09.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's id from /workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/025_contracts_leases_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_plan_disclosure/073_plan_disclosure_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's issue from /workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/025_contracts_leases_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_plan_disclosure/073_plan_disclosure_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's severity from /workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/025_contracts_leases_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_plan_disclosure/073_plan_disclosure_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's primary_source from /workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/025_contracts_leases_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_plan_disclosure/073_plan_disclosure_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/025_contracts_leases_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_plan_disclosure/073_plan_disclosure_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-09 using the exact controlled facts ['2026-01-11', 'CB-RS-2802-I833', '2026-02-09', 'CB-RS-2802-R917'].", "id": "findings.F-09.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-09's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-09.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-08', 'Sofia Bennett'] for F-09.", "id": "findings.F-09.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-10 exception for guaranty overlap.", "id": "findings.F-10.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's id from /workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/028_contracts_leases_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_plan_disclosure/076_plan_disclosure_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's issue from /workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/028_contracts_leases_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_plan_disclosure/076_plan_disclosure_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's severity from /workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/028_contracts_leases_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_plan_disclosure/076_plan_disclosure_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's primary_source from /workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/028_contracts_leases_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_plan_disclosure/076_plan_disclosure_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/028_contracts_leases_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_plan_disclosure/076_plan_disclosure_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-10 using the exact controlled facts ['$5,991,033.00', '$6,068,566.00'].", "id": "findings.F-10.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-10's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-10.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-08', 'Adrian Mensah'] for F-10.", "id": "findings.F-10.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-11 exception for tax priority period.", "id": "findings.F-11.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's id from /workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/031_contracts_leases_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_plan_disclosure/079_plan_disclosure_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's issue from /workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/031_contracts_leases_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_plan_disclosure/079_plan_disclosure_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's severity from /workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/031_contracts_leases_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_plan_disclosure/079_plan_disclosure_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's primary_source from /workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/031_contracts_leases_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_plan_disclosure/079_plan_disclosure_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/031_contracts_leases_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_plan_disclosure/079_plan_disclosure_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-11 using the exact controlled facts ['Samuel Kim', 'Micah Sullivan'].", "id": "findings.F-11.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-11's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-11.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-08', 'Willa Novak'] for F-11.", "id": "findings.F-11.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-12 exception for DIP budget variance.", "id": "findings.F-12.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's id from /workspace/documents/05_cash_management/034_cash_management_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_notices_ballots/082_notices_ballots_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's issue from /workspace/documents/05_cash_management/034_cash_management_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_notices_ballots/082_notices_ballots_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's severity from /workspace/documents/05_cash_management/034_cash_management_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_notices_ballots/082_notices_ballots_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's primary_source from /workspace/documents/05_cash_management/034_cash_management_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_notices_ballots/082_notices_ballots_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/05_cash_management/034_cash_management_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_notices_ballots/082_notices_ballots_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-12 using the exact controlled facts ['closed without exception', 'CB-RS-2802-L633', 'open and escalated', 'CB-RS-2802-U764'].", "id": "findings.F-12.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-12's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-12.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-08', 'Theo Laurent'] for F-12.", "id": "findings.F-12.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-13 exception for cash-collateral reporting gap.", "id": "findings.F-13.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's id from /workspace/documents/05_cash_management/037_cash_management_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_notices_ballots/085_notices_ballots_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's issue from /workspace/documents/05_cash_management/037_cash_management_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_notices_ballots/085_notices_ballots_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's severity from /workspace/documents/05_cash_management/037_cash_management_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_notices_ballots/085_notices_ballots_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's primary_source from /workspace/documents/05_cash_management/037_cash_management_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_notices_ballots/085_notices_ballots_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/05_cash_management/037_cash_management_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_notices_ballots/085_notices_ballots_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-13 using the exact controlled facts ['Eastern District of Virginia Bankruptcy Court', 'Virginia'].", "id": "findings.F-13.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-13's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-13.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-08', 'Amara Patel'] for F-13.", "id": "findings.F-13.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-14 exception for ballot amount discrepancy.", "id": "findings.F-14.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's id from /workspace/documents/05_cash_management/040_cash_management_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_notices_ballots/088_notices_ballots_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's issue from /workspace/documents/05_cash_management/040_cash_management_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_notices_ballots/088_notices_ballots_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's severity from /workspace/documents/05_cash_management/040_cash_management_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_notices_ballots/088_notices_ballots_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's primary_source from /workspace/documents/05_cash_management/040_cash_management_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_notices_ballots/088_notices_ballots_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/05_cash_management/040_cash_management_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_notices_ballots/088_notices_ballots_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-14 using the exact controlled facts ['2%', '8%'].", "id": "findings.F-14.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-14's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-14.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-08', 'Henry Cho'] for F-14.", "id": "findings.F-14.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-15 exception for notice-address defect.", "id": "findings.F-15.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's id from /workspace/documents/06_financing/043_financing_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/091_reconciliations_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's issue from /workspace/documents/06_financing/043_financing_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/091_reconciliations_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's severity from /workspace/documents/06_financing/043_financing_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/091_reconciliations_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's primary_source from /workspace/documents/06_financing/043_financing_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/091_reconciliations_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/06_financing/043_financing_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/091_reconciliations_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-15 using the exact controlled facts ['notices-birch_regional_aviation_llc@example.test', 'archive-skyframe_aircraft_leasing@example.test'].", "id": "findings.F-15.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-15's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-15.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-08', 'Nadine Flores'] for F-15.", "id": "findings.F-15.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-16 exception for reserve calculation error.", "id": "findings.F-16.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's id from /workspace/documents/06_financing/046_financing_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/094_reconciliations_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's issue from /workspace/documents/06_financing/046_financing_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/094_reconciliations_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's severity from /workspace/documents/06_financing/046_financing_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/094_reconciliations_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's primary_source from /workspace/documents/06_financing/046_financing_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/094_reconciliations_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/06_financing/046_financing_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/094_reconciliations_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-16 using the exact controlled facts ['171 records', '2025-05-06', '47 records', '2025-05-25'].", "id": "findings.F-16.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-16's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-16.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-08', 'Micah Sullivan'] for F-16.", "id": "findings.F-16.action_anchors"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Executive assessment' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Executive assessment"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Method and record coverage' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Method and record coverage"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Findings' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Findings"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Recommended next actions' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Recommended next actions"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Assumptions and limitations' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Assumptions and limitations"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-01 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-01"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-02 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-02"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-03 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-03"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-04 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-04"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-05 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-05"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-06 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-06"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-07 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-07"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-08 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-08"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-09 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-09"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-10 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-10"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-11 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-11"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-12 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-12"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-13 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-13"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-14 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-14"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-15 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-15"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-16 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-16"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Do not claim the production has no issues or that every record is consistent.", "id": "memo.forbidden_claims_absent"}], "decision_options": [{"id": "cross-source-reconciliation", "label": "Reconcile controlling and corroborating records", "reason": "The CB-RS-2802 production contains independently maintained records; a defensible answer must preserve each supported conflict and its cure owner.", "selected": true}, {"id": "latest-record-controls", "label": "Treat the latest record as controlling", "reason": "Timestamp recency does not establish legal priority, execution, or approval authority.", "selected": false}, {"id": "primary-records-only", "label": "Report primary records without reconciliation", "reason": "Primary records alone conceal the operational conflicts that create the actionable exceptions.", "selected": false}], "gates": ["all_evidence_read_in_full", "chain_of_custody_metadata_checked", "findings_criteria_complete", "memo_criteria_complete", "deliverables_written_through_mcp"], "metadata_checks": 8, "metric": "weighted_criteria_score", "minimum_tool_calls": 46, "required_deliverables": ["findings.json", "advice.md"], "required_document_reads": 33, "type": "deterministic", "weights": {"findings": 0.55, "memo": 0.2, "procedure": 0.25}}, "task_id": "cb100-042-birch-aviation", "task_name": "Birch Aviation lease reconciliation", "world_id": "counselbench-filesystem-mcp-v2"}
-{"context_files": ["task_files/cb100-043-cascade-retail/01_petition_schedules/001_petition_schedules_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-043-cascade-retail/01_petition_schedules/002_petition_schedules_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-043-cascade-retail/01_petition_schedules/003_petition_schedules_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-043-cascade-retail/01_petition_schedules/004_petition_schedules_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-043-cascade-retail/01_petition_schedules/005_petition_schedules_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-043-cascade-retail/01_petition_schedules/006_petition_schedules_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-043-cascade-retail/01_petition_schedules/007_petition_schedules_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-043-cascade-retail/01_petition_schedules/008_petition_schedules_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-043-cascade-retail/02_claims_register/009_claims_register_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-043-cascade-retail/02_claims_register/010_claims_register_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-043-cascade-retail/02_claims_register/011_claims_register_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-043-cascade-retail/02_claims_register/012_claims_register_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-043-cascade-retail/02_claims_register/013_claims_register_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-043-cascade-retail/02_claims_register/014_claims_register_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-043-cascade-retail/02_claims_register/015_claims_register_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-043-cascade-retail/02_claims_register/016_claims_register_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-043-cascade-retail/03_proofs_of_claim/017_proofs_of_claim_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-043-cascade-retail/03_proofs_of_claim/018_proofs_of_claim_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-043-cascade-retail/03_proofs_of_claim/019_proofs_of_claim_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-043-cascade-retail/03_proofs_of_claim/020_proofs_of_claim_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-043-cascade-retail/03_proofs_of_claim/021_proofs_of_claim_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-043-cascade-retail/03_proofs_of_claim/022_proofs_of_claim_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-043-cascade-retail/03_proofs_of_claim/023_proofs_of_claim_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-043-cascade-retail/03_proofs_of_claim/024_proofs_of_claim_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-043-cascade-retail/04_contracts_leases/025_contracts_leases_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-043-cascade-retail/04_contracts_leases/026_contracts_leases_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-043-cascade-retail/04_contracts_leases/027_contracts_leases_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-043-cascade-retail/04_contracts_leases/028_contracts_leases_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-043-cascade-retail/04_contracts_leases/029_contracts_leases_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-043-cascade-retail/04_contracts_leases/030_contracts_leases_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-043-cascade-retail/04_contracts_leases/031_contracts_leases_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-043-cascade-retail/04_contracts_leases/032_contracts_leases_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-043-cascade-retail/05_cash_management/033_cash_management_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-043-cascade-retail/05_cash_management/034_cash_management_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-043-cascade-retail/05_cash_management/035_cash_management_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-043-cascade-retail/05_cash_management/036_cash_management_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-043-cascade-retail/05_cash_management/037_cash_management_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-043-cascade-retail/05_cash_management/038_cash_management_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-043-cascade-retail/05_cash_management/039_cash_management_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-043-cascade-retail/05_cash_management/040_cash_management_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-043-cascade-retail/06_financing/041_financing_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-043-cascade-retail/06_financing/042_financing_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-043-cascade-retail/06_financing/043_financing_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-043-cascade-retail/06_financing/044_financing_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-043-cascade-retail/06_financing/045_financing_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-043-cascade-retail/06_financing/046_financing_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-043-cascade-retail/06_financing/047_financing_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-043-cascade-retail/06_financing/048_financing_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-043-cascade-retail/07_critical_vendors/049_critical_vendors_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-043-cascade-retail/07_critical_vendors/050_critical_vendors_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-043-cascade-retail/07_critical_vendors/051_critical_vendors_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-043-cascade-retail/07_critical_vendors/052_critical_vendors_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-043-cascade-retail/07_critical_vendors/053_critical_vendors_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-043-cascade-retail/07_critical_vendors/054_critical_vendors_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-043-cascade-retail/07_critical_vendors/055_critical_vendors_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-043-cascade-retail/07_critical_vendors/056_critical_vendors_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-043-cascade-retail/08_tax/057_tax_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-043-cascade-retail/08_tax/058_tax_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-043-cascade-retail/08_tax/059_tax_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-043-cascade-retail/08_tax/060_tax_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-043-cascade-retail/08_tax/061_tax_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-043-cascade-retail/08_tax/062_tax_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-043-cascade-retail/08_tax/063_tax_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-043-cascade-retail/08_tax/064_tax_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-043-cascade-retail/09_litigation/065_litigation_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-043-cascade-retail/09_litigation/066_litigation_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-043-cascade-retail/09_litigation/067_litigation_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-043-cascade-retail/09_litigation/068_litigation_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-043-cascade-retail/09_litigation/069_litigation_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-043-cascade-retail/09_litigation/070_litigation_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-043-cascade-retail/09_litigation/071_litigation_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-043-cascade-retail/09_litigation/072_litigation_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-043-cascade-retail/10_plan_disclosure/073_plan_disclosure_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-043-cascade-retail/10_plan_disclosure/074_plan_disclosure_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-043-cascade-retail/10_plan_disclosure/075_plan_disclosure_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-043-cascade-retail/10_plan_disclosure/076_plan_disclosure_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-043-cascade-retail/10_plan_disclosure/077_plan_disclosure_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-043-cascade-retail/10_plan_disclosure/078_plan_disclosure_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-043-cascade-retail/10_plan_disclosure/079_plan_disclosure_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-043-cascade-retail/10_plan_disclosure/080_plan_disclosure_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-043-cascade-retail/11_notices_ballots/081_notices_ballots_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-043-cascade-retail/11_notices_ballots/082_notices_ballots_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-043-cascade-retail/11_notices_ballots/083_notices_ballots_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-043-cascade-retail/11_notices_ballots/084_notices_ballots_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-043-cascade-retail/11_notices_ballots/085_notices_ballots_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-043-cascade-retail/11_notices_ballots/086_notices_ballots_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-043-cascade-retail/11_notices_ballots/087_notices_ballots_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-043-cascade-retail/11_notices_ballots/088_notices_ballots_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-043-cascade-retail/12_reconciliations/089_reconciliations_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-043-cascade-retail/12_reconciliations/090_reconciliations_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-043-cascade-retail/12_reconciliations/091_reconciliations_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-043-cascade-retail/12_reconciliations/092_reconciliations_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-043-cascade-retail/12_reconciliations/093_reconciliations_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-043-cascade-retail/12_reconciliations/094_reconciliations_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-043-cascade-retail/12_reconciliations/095_reconciliations_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-043-cascade-retail/12_reconciliations/096_reconciliations_status_report.md"], "gold_output": {"advice_markdown": "# Counsel advice — Cascade Retail claims reserve audit\n\n## Executive assessment\n\nFor Cascade Outdoor Retail Corp. matter CB-RS-2803, the review identified 16 source-supported exceptions requiring action before 2026-09-11. The assessment concerns Multiple merchandise vendors and the supplied record for Delaware.\n\n## Method and record coverage\n\nThe review inventoried all 96 production files, read the 33 controlling, corroborating, and control records, searched the email exports, and checked metadata for the designated chain-of-custody sample. Conclusions are limited to the synthetic production supplied for this benchmark matter.\n\n## Findings\n\n### F-01 — scheduled-claim mismatch (critical)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for scheduled-claim mismatch: one source states the operative date is 2025-08-28 under control reference CB-RS-2803-A757, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2025-09-17 under response reference CB-RS-2803-J427.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/001_petition_schedules_control_register.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/07_critical_vendors/049_critical_vendors_control_register.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-11, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Elliot Mercer.\n\n### F-02 — duplicate proof of claim (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for duplicate proof of claim: one source states the controlling amount is $1,613,158.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $1,912,816.00.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/004_petition_schedules_ledger_export.csv`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/07_critical_vendors/052_critical_vendors_ledger_export.csv`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-11, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Talia Brooks.\n\n### F-03 — secured-status defect (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for secured-status defect: one source states approval is attributed to Maya Ellison as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Elliot Mercer and contains no entry for Maya Ellison.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/007_petition_schedules_officer_certificate.html`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/07_critical_vendors/055_critical_vendors_officer_certificate.html`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-11, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Jonas Feld.\n\n### F-04 — priority classification error (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for priority classification error: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-RS-2803-D976, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-RS-2803-M444.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/02_claims_register/010_claims_register_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/08_tax/058_tax_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-11, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Mei Whitaker.\n\n### F-05 — executory-contract cure dispute (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for executory-contract cure dispute: one source states the applicable location is District of Delaware Bankruptcy Court, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to Delaware operations outside District of Delaware Bankruptcy Court.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/02_claims_register/013_claims_register_review_memorandum.json`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/08_tax/061_tax_review_memorandum.json`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-11, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Caleb Hassan.\n\n### F-06 — lease rejection deadline (low)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for lease rejection deadline: one source states the threshold is 15% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 20% and produced a different exception result.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/02_claims_register/016_claims_register_status_report.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/08_tax/064_tax_status_report.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-11, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Leona Park.\n\n### F-07 — postpetition invoice (critical)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for postpetition invoice: one source states formal notice must use notices-cascade_outdoor_retail_corp@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-multiple_merchandise_vendors@example.test.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/019_proofs_of_claim_correspondence.eml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/09_litigation/067_litigation_correspondence.eml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-11, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Isaac Romero.\n\n### F-08 — critical-vendor overstatement (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for critical-vendor overstatement: one source states the governed population contains 66 records through 2025-10-28, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 44 records through 2025-11-13.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/022_proofs_of_claim_formal_notice.xml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/09_litigation/070_litigation_formal_notice.xml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-11, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Sofia Bennett.\n\n### F-09 — setoff assertion (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for setoff assertion: one source states the operative date is 2025-08-05 under control reference CB-RS-2803-I494, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2025-09-10 under response reference CB-RS-2803-R199.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/025_contracts_leases_control_register.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/10_plan_disclosure/073_plan_disclosure_control_register.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-11, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Adrian Mensah.\n\n### F-10 — guaranty overlap (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for guaranty overlap: one source states the controlling amount is $2,239,484.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $2,375,468.00.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/028_contracts_leases_ledger_export.csv`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/10_plan_disclosure/076_plan_disclosure_ledger_export.csv`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-11, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Willa Novak.\n\n### F-11 — tax priority period (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for tax priority period: one source states approval is attributed to Maya Ellison as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Owen Delgado and contains no entry for Maya Ellison.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/031_contracts_leases_officer_certificate.html`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/10_plan_disclosure/079_plan_disclosure_officer_certificate.html`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-11, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Theo Laurent.\n\n### F-12 — DIP budget variance (low)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for DIP budget variance: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-RS-2803-L533, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-RS-2803-U617.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/05_cash_management/034_cash_management_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/11_notices_ballots/082_notices_ballots_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-11, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Amara Patel.\n\n### F-13 — cash-collateral reporting gap (critical)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for cash-collateral reporting gap: one source states the applicable location is District of Delaware Bankruptcy Court, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to Delaware operations outside District of Delaware Bankruptcy Court.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/05_cash_management/037_cash_management_review_memorandum.json`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/11_notices_ballots/085_notices_ballots_review_memorandum.json`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-11, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Henry Cho.\n\n### F-14 — ballot amount discrepancy (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for ballot amount discrepancy: one source states the threshold is 5% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 8% and produced a different exception result.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/05_cash_management/040_cash_management_status_report.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/11_notices_ballots/088_notices_ballots_status_report.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-11, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Nadine Flores.\n\n### F-15 — notice-address defect (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for notice-address defect: one source states formal notice must use notices-cascade_outdoor_retail_corp@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-multiple_merchandise_vendors@example.test.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/06_financing/043_financing_correspondence.eml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/091_reconciliations_correspondence.eml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-11, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Micah Sullivan.\n\n### F-16 — reserve calculation error (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for reserve calculation error: one source states the governed population contains 115 records through 2025-03-11, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 58 records through 2025-04-10.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/06_financing/046_financing_formal_notice.xml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/094_reconciliations_formal_notice.xml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-11, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Farah Ibrahim.\n\n## Recommended next actions\n\nSequence the critical and high findings first, assign the named owners, preserve the cited records, and document any resolution in the controlling matter register before the stated deadline.\n\n## Assumptions and limitations\n\nThis analysis is confined to task cb100-043-cascade-retail and the supplied synthetic evidence. It does not rely on external facts, does not resolve disputed law, and is not legal advice for a real person or entity.\n", "findings": {"as_of": "2026-09-11", "findings": [{"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/07_critical_vendors/049_critical_vendors_control_register.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for scheduled-claim mismatch: one source states the operative date is 2025-08-28 under control reference CB-RS-2803-A757, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2025-09-17 under response reference CB-RS-2803-J427.", "id": "F-01", "issue": "scheduled-claim mismatch", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/001_petition_schedules_control_register.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-11, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Elliot Mercer.", "severity": "critical"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/07_critical_vendors/052_critical_vendors_ledger_export.csv", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for duplicate proof of claim: one source states the controlling amount is $1,613,158.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $1,912,816.00.", "id": "F-02", "issue": "duplicate proof of claim", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/004_petition_schedules_ledger_export.csv", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-11, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Talia Brooks.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/07_critical_vendors/055_critical_vendors_officer_certificate.html", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for secured-status defect: one source states approval is attributed to Maya Ellison as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Elliot Mercer and contains no entry for Maya Ellison.", "id": "F-03", "issue": "secured-status defect", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/007_petition_schedules_officer_certificate.html", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-11, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Jonas Feld.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/08_tax/058_tax_executed_instrument.txt", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for priority classification error: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-RS-2803-D976, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-RS-2803-M444.", "id": "F-04", "issue": "priority classification error", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/02_claims_register/010_claims_register_executed_instrument.txt", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-11, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Mei Whitaker.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/08_tax/061_tax_review_memorandum.json", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for executory-contract cure dispute: one source states the applicable location is District of Delaware Bankruptcy Court, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to Delaware operations outside District of Delaware Bankruptcy Court.", "id": "F-05", "issue": "executory-contract cure dispute", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/02_claims_register/013_claims_register_review_memorandum.json", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-11, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Caleb Hassan.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/08_tax/064_tax_status_report.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for lease rejection deadline: one source states the threshold is 15% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 20% and produced a different exception result.", "id": "F-06", "issue": "lease rejection deadline", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/02_claims_register/016_claims_register_status_report.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-11, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Leona Park.", "severity": "low"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/09_litigation/067_litigation_correspondence.eml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for postpetition invoice: one source states formal notice must use notices-cascade_outdoor_retail_corp@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-multiple_merchandise_vendors@example.test.", "id": "F-07", "issue": "postpetition invoice", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/019_proofs_of_claim_correspondence.eml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-11, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Isaac Romero.", "severity": "critical"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/09_litigation/070_litigation_formal_notice.xml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for critical-vendor overstatement: one source states the governed population contains 66 records through 2025-10-28, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 44 records through 2025-11-13.", "id": "F-08", "issue": "critical-vendor overstatement", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/022_proofs_of_claim_formal_notice.xml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-11, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Sofia Bennett.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/10_plan_disclosure/073_plan_disclosure_control_register.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for setoff assertion: one source states the operative date is 2025-08-05 under control reference CB-RS-2803-I494, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2025-09-10 under response reference CB-RS-2803-R199.", "id": "F-09", "issue": "setoff assertion", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/025_contracts_leases_control_register.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-11, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Adrian Mensah.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/10_plan_disclosure/076_plan_disclosure_ledger_export.csv", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for guaranty overlap: one source states the controlling amount is $2,239,484.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $2,375,468.00.", "id": "F-10", "issue": "guaranty overlap", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/028_contracts_leases_ledger_export.csv", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-11, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Willa Novak.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/10_plan_disclosure/079_plan_disclosure_officer_certificate.html", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for tax priority period: one source states approval is attributed to Maya Ellison as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Owen Delgado and contains no entry for Maya Ellison.", "id": "F-11", "issue": "tax priority period", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/031_contracts_leases_officer_certificate.html", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-11, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Theo Laurent.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/11_notices_ballots/082_notices_ballots_executed_instrument.txt", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for DIP budget variance: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-RS-2803-L533, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-RS-2803-U617.", "id": "F-12", "issue": "DIP budget variance", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/05_cash_management/034_cash_management_executed_instrument.txt", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-11, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Amara Patel.", "severity": "low"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/11_notices_ballots/085_notices_ballots_review_memorandum.json", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for cash-collateral reporting gap: one source states the applicable location is District of Delaware Bankruptcy Court, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to Delaware operations outside District of Delaware Bankruptcy Court.", "id": "F-13", "issue": "cash-collateral reporting gap", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/05_cash_management/037_cash_management_review_memorandum.json", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-11, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Henry Cho.", "severity": "critical"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/11_notices_ballots/088_notices_ballots_status_report.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for ballot amount discrepancy: one source states the threshold is 5% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 8% and produced a different exception result.", "id": "F-14", "issue": "ballot amount discrepancy", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/05_cash_management/040_cash_management_status_report.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-11, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Nadine Flores.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/091_reconciliations_correspondence.eml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for notice-address defect: one source states formal notice must use notices-cascade_outdoor_retail_corp@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-multiple_merchandise_vendors@example.test.", "id": "F-15", "issue": "notice-address defect", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/06_financing/043_financing_correspondence.eml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-11, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Micah Sullivan.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/094_reconciliations_formal_notice.xml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for reserve calculation error: one source states the governed population contains 115 records through 2025-03-11, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 58 records through 2025-04-10.", "id": "F-16", "issue": "reserve calculation error", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/06_financing/046_financing_formal_notice.xml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-11, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Farah Ibrahim.", "severity": "medium"}], "matter_number": "CB-RS-2803", "prepared_for": "Cascade Outdoor Retail Corp.", "schema_version": "1.0", "task_id": "cb100-043-cascade-retail"}}, "metadata": {"benchmark": "CounselBench-100", "code_license": "Apache-2.0", "data_license": "CC-BY-4.0", "deadline": "2026-09-11", "document_count": 96, "jurisdiction": "Delaware", "matter_number": "CB-RS-2803", "mcp_commit": "9a96ea6e5913736f92b88345bf51caeaaa8e719f", "mcp_package": "@modelcontextprotocol/server-filesystem@2026.7.10", "practice_area": "restructuring", "reference_tool_calls": 46, "required_evidence_reads": 33, "synthetic": true, "venue": "District of Delaware Bankruptcy Court", "version": "2.0.0"}, "prompt": "You are debtor-side restructuring counsel for Cascade Outdoor Retail Corp. The client has asked for a board-ready risk assessment supported by a source-level tracker rather than a narrative-only summary. A retail debtor faces duplicate claims, returned-goods offsets, rejected store leases, and inconsistent ballot amounts. Decision due 2026-09-11. Delaware law governs; District of Delaware Bankruptcy Court is the forum. Treat dates, notice mechanics, approval evidence, and numerical reconciliations as independent controls. Work out the defensible position from the matter production and leave an audit-ready exception tracker and concise advice for the supervising lawyer. Keep confirmed conflicts separate from open questions, cite the records that actually control each conclusion, and do not fill gaps with outside facts.", "rubric": {"criteria": [{"category": "procedure", "description": "Complete at least 46 successful, argument-specific evidence and output calls.", "id": "procedure.minimum_successful_tool_calls"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Find and read the 33 controlling, corroborating, and work-product-control records in full.", "id": "procedure.all_evidence_read_in_full"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Inspect file metadata for the eight designated critical primary records before relying on them.", "id": "procedure.chain_of_custody_metadata_checked"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Confirm the sandbox's allowed document and output roots.", "id": "procedure.allowed_directories_checked"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Inventory all 96 records so the relevant sources are discovered among the context records.", "id": "procedure.recursive_inventory_completed"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Search the production for email evidence that may corroborate or contradict formal records.", "id": "procedure.targeted_search_completed"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Leave only findings.json and advice.md in the output workspace.", "id": "procedure.exact_deliverable_set"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Create both final work products through the sandbox MCP surface.", "id": "procedure.deliverables_written_through_mcp"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Produce findings.json as a valid JSON object.", "id": "findings.findings_is_object"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Report exactly 16 confirmed exceptions.", "id": "findings.findings_exact_count"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Use each stable finding ID exactly once.", "id": "findings.finding_ids_unique"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set schema_version to the released matter value '1.0'.", "id": "findings.top_level_schema_version"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set task_id to the released matter value 'cb100-043-cascade-retail'.", "id": "findings.top_level_task_id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set matter_number to the released matter value 'CB-RS-2803'.", "id": "findings.top_level_matter_number"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set prepared_for to the released matter value 'Cascade Outdoor Retail Corp.'.", "id": "findings.top_level_prepared_for"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set as_of to the released matter value '2026-09-11'.", "id": "findings.top_level_as_of"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-01 exception for scheduled-claim mismatch.", "id": "findings.F-01.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's id from /workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/001_petition_schedules_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_critical_vendors/049_critical_vendors_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's issue from /workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/001_petition_schedules_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_critical_vendors/049_critical_vendors_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's severity from /workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/001_petition_schedules_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_critical_vendors/049_critical_vendors_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's primary_source from /workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/001_petition_schedules_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_critical_vendors/049_critical_vendors_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/001_petition_schedules_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_critical_vendors/049_critical_vendors_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-01 using the exact controlled facts ['2025-08-28', 'CB-RS-2803-A757', '2025-09-17', 'CB-RS-2803-J427'].", "id": "findings.F-01.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-01's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-01.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-11', 'Elliot Mercer'] for F-01.", "id": "findings.F-01.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-02 exception for duplicate proof of claim.", "id": "findings.F-02.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's id from /workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/004_petition_schedules_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_critical_vendors/052_critical_vendors_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's issue from /workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/004_petition_schedules_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_critical_vendors/052_critical_vendors_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's severity from /workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/004_petition_schedules_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_critical_vendors/052_critical_vendors_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's primary_source from /workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/004_petition_schedules_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_critical_vendors/052_critical_vendors_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/004_petition_schedules_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_critical_vendors/052_critical_vendors_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-02 using the exact controlled facts ['$1,613,158.00', '$1,912,816.00'].", "id": "findings.F-02.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-02's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-02.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-11', 'Talia Brooks'] for F-02.", "id": "findings.F-02.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-03 exception for secured-status defect.", "id": "findings.F-03.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's id from /workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/007_petition_schedules_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_critical_vendors/055_critical_vendors_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's issue from /workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/007_petition_schedules_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_critical_vendors/055_critical_vendors_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's severity from /workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/007_petition_schedules_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_critical_vendors/055_critical_vendors_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's primary_source from /workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/007_petition_schedules_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_critical_vendors/055_critical_vendors_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/007_petition_schedules_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_critical_vendors/055_critical_vendors_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-03 using the exact controlled facts ['Maya Ellison', 'Elliot Mercer'].", "id": "findings.F-03.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-03's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-03.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-11', 'Jonas Feld'] for F-03.", "id": "findings.F-03.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-04 exception for priority classification error.", "id": "findings.F-04.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's id from /workspace/documents/02_claims_register/010_claims_register_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_tax/058_tax_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's issue from /workspace/documents/02_claims_register/010_claims_register_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_tax/058_tax_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's severity from /workspace/documents/02_claims_register/010_claims_register_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_tax/058_tax_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's primary_source from /workspace/documents/02_claims_register/010_claims_register_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_tax/058_tax_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/02_claims_register/010_claims_register_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_tax/058_tax_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-04 using the exact controlled facts ['closed without exception', 'CB-RS-2803-D976', 'open and escalated', 'CB-RS-2803-M444'].", "id": "findings.F-04.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-04's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-04.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-11', 'Mei Whitaker'] for F-04.", "id": "findings.F-04.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-05 exception for executory-contract cure dispute.", "id": "findings.F-05.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's id from /workspace/documents/02_claims_register/013_claims_register_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_tax/061_tax_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's issue from /workspace/documents/02_claims_register/013_claims_register_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_tax/061_tax_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's severity from /workspace/documents/02_claims_register/013_claims_register_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_tax/061_tax_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's primary_source from /workspace/documents/02_claims_register/013_claims_register_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_tax/061_tax_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/02_claims_register/013_claims_register_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_tax/061_tax_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-05 using the exact controlled facts ['District of Delaware Bankruptcy Court', 'Delaware'].", "id": "findings.F-05.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-05's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-05.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-11', 'Caleb Hassan'] for F-05.", "id": "findings.F-05.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-06 exception for lease rejection deadline.", "id": "findings.F-06.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's id from /workspace/documents/02_claims_register/016_claims_register_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_tax/064_tax_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's issue from /workspace/documents/02_claims_register/016_claims_register_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_tax/064_tax_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's severity from /workspace/documents/02_claims_register/016_claims_register_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_tax/064_tax_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's primary_source from /workspace/documents/02_claims_register/016_claims_register_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_tax/064_tax_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/02_claims_register/016_claims_register_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_tax/064_tax_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-06 using the exact controlled facts ['15%', '20%'].", "id": "findings.F-06.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-06's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-06.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-11', 'Leona Park'] for F-06.", "id": "findings.F-06.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-07 exception for postpetition invoice.", "id": "findings.F-07.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's id from /workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/019_proofs_of_claim_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_litigation/067_litigation_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's issue from /workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/019_proofs_of_claim_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_litigation/067_litigation_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's severity from /workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/019_proofs_of_claim_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_litigation/067_litigation_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's primary_source from /workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/019_proofs_of_claim_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_litigation/067_litigation_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/019_proofs_of_claim_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_litigation/067_litigation_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-07 using the exact controlled facts ['notices-cascade_outdoor_retail_corp@example.test', 'archive-multiple_merchandise_vendors@example.test'].", "id": "findings.F-07.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-07's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-07.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-11', 'Isaac Romero'] for F-07.", "id": "findings.F-07.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-08 exception for critical-vendor overstatement.", "id": "findings.F-08.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's id from /workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/022_proofs_of_claim_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_litigation/070_litigation_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's issue from /workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/022_proofs_of_claim_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_litigation/070_litigation_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's severity from /workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/022_proofs_of_claim_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_litigation/070_litigation_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's primary_source from /workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/022_proofs_of_claim_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_litigation/070_litigation_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/022_proofs_of_claim_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_litigation/070_litigation_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-08 using the exact controlled facts ['66 records', '2025-10-28', '44 records', '2025-11-13'].", "id": "findings.F-08.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-08's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-08.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-11', 'Sofia Bennett'] for F-08.", "id": "findings.F-08.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-09 exception for setoff assertion.", "id": "findings.F-09.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's id from /workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/025_contracts_leases_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_plan_disclosure/073_plan_disclosure_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's issue from /workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/025_contracts_leases_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_plan_disclosure/073_plan_disclosure_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's severity from /workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/025_contracts_leases_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_plan_disclosure/073_plan_disclosure_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's primary_source from /workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/025_contracts_leases_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_plan_disclosure/073_plan_disclosure_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/025_contracts_leases_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_plan_disclosure/073_plan_disclosure_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-09 using the exact controlled facts ['2025-08-05', 'CB-RS-2803-I494', '2025-09-10', 'CB-RS-2803-R199'].", "id": "findings.F-09.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-09's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-09.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-11', 'Adrian Mensah'] for F-09.", "id": "findings.F-09.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-10 exception for guaranty overlap.", "id": "findings.F-10.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's id from /workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/028_contracts_leases_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_plan_disclosure/076_plan_disclosure_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's issue from /workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/028_contracts_leases_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_plan_disclosure/076_plan_disclosure_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's severity from /workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/028_contracts_leases_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_plan_disclosure/076_plan_disclosure_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's primary_source from /workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/028_contracts_leases_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_plan_disclosure/076_plan_disclosure_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/028_contracts_leases_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_plan_disclosure/076_plan_disclosure_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-10 using the exact controlled facts ['$2,239,484.00', '$2,375,468.00'].", "id": "findings.F-10.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-10's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-10.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-11', 'Willa Novak'] for F-10.", "id": "findings.F-10.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-11 exception for tax priority period.", "id": "findings.F-11.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's id from /workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/031_contracts_leases_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_plan_disclosure/079_plan_disclosure_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's issue from /workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/031_contracts_leases_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_plan_disclosure/079_plan_disclosure_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's severity from /workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/031_contracts_leases_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_plan_disclosure/079_plan_disclosure_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's primary_source from /workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/031_contracts_leases_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_plan_disclosure/079_plan_disclosure_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/031_contracts_leases_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_plan_disclosure/079_plan_disclosure_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-11 using the exact controlled facts ['Maya Ellison', 'Owen Delgado'].", "id": "findings.F-11.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-11's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-11.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-11', 'Theo Laurent'] for F-11.", "id": "findings.F-11.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-12 exception for DIP budget variance.", "id": "findings.F-12.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's id from /workspace/documents/05_cash_management/034_cash_management_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_notices_ballots/082_notices_ballots_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's issue from /workspace/documents/05_cash_management/034_cash_management_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_notices_ballots/082_notices_ballots_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's severity from /workspace/documents/05_cash_management/034_cash_management_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_notices_ballots/082_notices_ballots_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's primary_source from /workspace/documents/05_cash_management/034_cash_management_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_notices_ballots/082_notices_ballots_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/05_cash_management/034_cash_management_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_notices_ballots/082_notices_ballots_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-12 using the exact controlled facts ['closed without exception', 'CB-RS-2803-L533', 'open and escalated', 'CB-RS-2803-U617'].", "id": "findings.F-12.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-12's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-12.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-11', 'Amara Patel'] for F-12.", "id": "findings.F-12.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-13 exception for cash-collateral reporting gap.", "id": "findings.F-13.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's id from /workspace/documents/05_cash_management/037_cash_management_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_notices_ballots/085_notices_ballots_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's issue from /workspace/documents/05_cash_management/037_cash_management_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_notices_ballots/085_notices_ballots_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's severity from /workspace/documents/05_cash_management/037_cash_management_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_notices_ballots/085_notices_ballots_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's primary_source from /workspace/documents/05_cash_management/037_cash_management_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_notices_ballots/085_notices_ballots_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/05_cash_management/037_cash_management_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_notices_ballots/085_notices_ballots_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-13 using the exact controlled facts ['District of Delaware Bankruptcy Court', 'Delaware'].", "id": "findings.F-13.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-13's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-13.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-11', 'Henry Cho'] for F-13.", "id": "findings.F-13.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-14 exception for ballot amount discrepancy.", "id": "findings.F-14.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's id from /workspace/documents/05_cash_management/040_cash_management_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_notices_ballots/088_notices_ballots_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's issue from /workspace/documents/05_cash_management/040_cash_management_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_notices_ballots/088_notices_ballots_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's severity from /workspace/documents/05_cash_management/040_cash_management_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_notices_ballots/088_notices_ballots_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's primary_source from /workspace/documents/05_cash_management/040_cash_management_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_notices_ballots/088_notices_ballots_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/05_cash_management/040_cash_management_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_notices_ballots/088_notices_ballots_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-14 using the exact controlled facts ['5%', '8%'].", "id": "findings.F-14.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-14's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-14.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-11', 'Nadine Flores'] for F-14.", "id": "findings.F-14.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-15 exception for notice-address defect.", "id": "findings.F-15.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's id from /workspace/documents/06_financing/043_financing_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/091_reconciliations_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's issue from /workspace/documents/06_financing/043_financing_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/091_reconciliations_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's severity from /workspace/documents/06_financing/043_financing_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/091_reconciliations_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's primary_source from /workspace/documents/06_financing/043_financing_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/091_reconciliations_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/06_financing/043_financing_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/091_reconciliations_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-15 using the exact controlled facts ['notices-cascade_outdoor_retail_corp@example.test', 'archive-multiple_merchandise_vendors@example.test'].", "id": "findings.F-15.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-15's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-15.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-11', 'Micah Sullivan'] for F-15.", "id": "findings.F-15.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-16 exception for reserve calculation error.", "id": "findings.F-16.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's id from /workspace/documents/06_financing/046_financing_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/094_reconciliations_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's issue from /workspace/documents/06_financing/046_financing_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/094_reconciliations_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's severity from /workspace/documents/06_financing/046_financing_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/094_reconciliations_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's primary_source from /workspace/documents/06_financing/046_financing_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/094_reconciliations_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/06_financing/046_financing_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/094_reconciliations_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-16 using the exact controlled facts ['115 records', '2025-03-11', '58 records', '2025-04-10'].", "id": "findings.F-16.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-16's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-16.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-11', 'Farah Ibrahim'] for F-16.", "id": "findings.F-16.action_anchors"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Executive assessment' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Executive assessment"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Method and record coverage' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Method and record coverage"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Findings' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Findings"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Recommended next actions' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Recommended next actions"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Assumptions and limitations' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Assumptions and limitations"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-01 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-01"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-02 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-02"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-03 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-03"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-04 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-04"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-05 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-05"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-06 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-06"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-07 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-07"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-08 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-08"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-09 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-09"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-10 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-10"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-11 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-11"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-12 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-12"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-13 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-13"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-14 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-14"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-15 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-15"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-16 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-16"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Do not claim the production has no issues or that every record is consistent.", "id": "memo.forbidden_claims_absent"}], "decision_options": [{"id": "cross-source-reconciliation", "label": "Reconcile controlling and corroborating records", "reason": "The CB-RS-2803 production contains independently maintained records; a defensible answer must preserve each supported conflict and its cure owner.", "selected": true}, {"id": "latest-record-controls", "label": "Treat the latest record as controlling", "reason": "Timestamp recency does not establish legal priority, execution, or approval authority.", "selected": false}, {"id": "primary-records-only", "label": "Report primary records without reconciliation", "reason": "Primary records alone conceal the operational conflicts that create the actionable exceptions.", "selected": false}], "gates": ["all_evidence_read_in_full", "chain_of_custody_metadata_checked", "findings_criteria_complete", "memo_criteria_complete", "deliverables_written_through_mcp"], "metadata_checks": 8, "metric": "weighted_criteria_score", "minimum_tool_calls": 46, "required_deliverables": ["findings.json", "advice.md"], "required_document_reads": 33, "type": "deterministic", "weights": {"findings": 0.55, "memo": 0.2, "procedure": 0.25}}, "task_id": "cb100-043-cascade-retail", "task_name": "Cascade Retail claims reserve audit", "world_id": "counselbench-filesystem-mcp-v2"}
-{"context_files": ["task_files/cb100-044-drummond-care/01_petition_schedules/001_petition_schedules_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-044-drummond-care/01_petition_schedules/002_petition_schedules_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-044-drummond-care/01_petition_schedules/003_petition_schedules_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-044-drummond-care/01_petition_schedules/004_petition_schedules_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-044-drummond-care/01_petition_schedules/005_petition_schedules_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-044-drummond-care/01_petition_schedules/006_petition_schedules_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-044-drummond-care/01_petition_schedules/007_petition_schedules_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-044-drummond-care/01_petition_schedules/008_petition_schedules_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-044-drummond-care/02_claims_register/009_claims_register_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-044-drummond-care/02_claims_register/010_claims_register_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-044-drummond-care/02_claims_register/011_claims_register_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-044-drummond-care/02_claims_register/012_claims_register_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-044-drummond-care/02_claims_register/013_claims_register_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-044-drummond-care/02_claims_register/014_claims_register_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-044-drummond-care/02_claims_register/015_claims_register_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-044-drummond-care/02_claims_register/016_claims_register_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-044-drummond-care/03_proofs_of_claim/017_proofs_of_claim_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-044-drummond-care/03_proofs_of_claim/018_proofs_of_claim_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-044-drummond-care/03_proofs_of_claim/019_proofs_of_claim_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-044-drummond-care/03_proofs_of_claim/020_proofs_of_claim_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-044-drummond-care/03_proofs_of_claim/021_proofs_of_claim_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-044-drummond-care/03_proofs_of_claim/022_proofs_of_claim_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-044-drummond-care/03_proofs_of_claim/023_proofs_of_claim_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-044-drummond-care/03_proofs_of_claim/024_proofs_of_claim_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-044-drummond-care/04_contracts_leases/025_contracts_leases_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-044-drummond-care/04_contracts_leases/026_contracts_leases_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-044-drummond-care/04_contracts_leases/027_contracts_leases_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-044-drummond-care/04_contracts_leases/028_contracts_leases_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-044-drummond-care/04_contracts_leases/029_contracts_leases_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-044-drummond-care/04_contracts_leases/030_contracts_leases_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-044-drummond-care/04_contracts_leases/031_contracts_leases_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-044-drummond-care/04_contracts_leases/032_contracts_leases_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-044-drummond-care/05_cash_management/033_cash_management_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-044-drummond-care/05_cash_management/034_cash_management_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-044-drummond-care/05_cash_management/035_cash_management_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-044-drummond-care/05_cash_management/036_cash_management_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-044-drummond-care/05_cash_management/037_cash_management_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-044-drummond-care/05_cash_management/038_cash_management_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-044-drummond-care/05_cash_management/039_cash_management_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-044-drummond-care/05_cash_management/040_cash_management_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-044-drummond-care/06_financing/041_financing_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-044-drummond-care/06_financing/042_financing_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-044-drummond-care/06_financing/043_financing_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-044-drummond-care/06_financing/044_financing_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-044-drummond-care/06_financing/045_financing_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-044-drummond-care/06_financing/046_financing_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-044-drummond-care/06_financing/047_financing_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-044-drummond-care/06_financing/048_financing_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-044-drummond-care/07_critical_vendors/049_critical_vendors_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-044-drummond-care/07_critical_vendors/050_critical_vendors_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-044-drummond-care/07_critical_vendors/051_critical_vendors_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-044-drummond-care/07_critical_vendors/052_critical_vendors_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-044-drummond-care/07_critical_vendors/053_critical_vendors_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-044-drummond-care/07_critical_vendors/054_critical_vendors_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-044-drummond-care/07_critical_vendors/055_critical_vendors_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-044-drummond-care/07_critical_vendors/056_critical_vendors_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-044-drummond-care/08_tax/057_tax_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-044-drummond-care/08_tax/058_tax_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-044-drummond-care/08_tax/059_tax_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-044-drummond-care/08_tax/060_tax_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-044-drummond-care/08_tax/061_tax_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-044-drummond-care/08_tax/062_tax_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-044-drummond-care/08_tax/063_tax_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-044-drummond-care/08_tax/064_tax_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-044-drummond-care/09_litigation/065_litigation_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-044-drummond-care/09_litigation/066_litigation_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-044-drummond-care/09_litigation/067_litigation_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-044-drummond-care/09_litigation/068_litigation_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-044-drummond-care/09_litigation/069_litigation_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-044-drummond-care/09_litigation/070_litigation_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-044-drummond-care/09_litigation/071_litigation_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-044-drummond-care/09_litigation/072_litigation_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-044-drummond-care/10_plan_disclosure/073_plan_disclosure_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-044-drummond-care/10_plan_disclosure/074_plan_disclosure_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-044-drummond-care/10_plan_disclosure/075_plan_disclosure_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-044-drummond-care/10_plan_disclosure/076_plan_disclosure_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-044-drummond-care/10_plan_disclosure/077_plan_disclosure_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-044-drummond-care/10_plan_disclosure/078_plan_disclosure_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-044-drummond-care/10_plan_disclosure/079_plan_disclosure_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-044-drummond-care/10_plan_disclosure/080_plan_disclosure_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-044-drummond-care/11_notices_ballots/081_notices_ballots_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-044-drummond-care/11_notices_ballots/082_notices_ballots_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-044-drummond-care/11_notices_ballots/083_notices_ballots_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-044-drummond-care/11_notices_ballots/084_notices_ballots_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-044-drummond-care/11_notices_ballots/085_notices_ballots_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-044-drummond-care/11_notices_ballots/086_notices_ballots_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-044-drummond-care/11_notices_ballots/087_notices_ballots_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-044-drummond-care/11_notices_ballots/088_notices_ballots_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-044-drummond-care/12_reconciliations/089_reconciliations_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-044-drummond-care/12_reconciliations/090_reconciliations_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-044-drummond-care/12_reconciliations/091_reconciliations_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-044-drummond-care/12_reconciliations/092_reconciliations_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-044-drummond-care/12_reconciliations/093_reconciliations_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-044-drummond-care/12_reconciliations/094_reconciliations_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-044-drummond-care/12_reconciliations/095_reconciliations_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-044-drummond-care/12_reconciliations/096_reconciliations_status_report.md"], "gold_output": {"advice_markdown": "# Counsel advice — Drummond Care restructuring schedule check\n\n## Executive assessment\n\nFor Drummond Senior Care Group matter CB-RS-2804, the review identified 16 source-supported exceptions requiring action before 2026-09-15. The assessment concerns Pinecrest Medical Staffing and the supplied record for New Jersey.\n\n## Method and record coverage\n\nThe review inventoried all 96 production files, read the 33 controlling, corroborating, and control records, searched the email exports, and checked metadata for the designated chain-of-custody sample. Conclusions are limited to the synthetic production supplied for this benchmark matter.\n\n## Findings\n\n### F-01 — scheduled-claim mismatch (critical)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for scheduled-claim mismatch: one source states the operative date is 2025-09-22 under control reference CB-RS-2804-A542, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2025-10-19 under response reference CB-RS-2804-J687.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/001_petition_schedules_control_register.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/07_critical_vendors/049_critical_vendors_control_register.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-15, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Talia Brooks.\n\n### F-02 — duplicate proof of claim (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for duplicate proof of claim: one source states the controlling amount is $930,193.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $1,206,886.00.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/004_petition_schedules_ledger_export.csv`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/07_critical_vendors/052_critical_vendors_ledger_export.csv`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-15, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Jonas Feld.\n\n### F-03 — secured-status defect (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for secured-status defect: one source states approval is attributed to Rafael Okafor as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Jonas Feld and contains no entry for Rafael Okafor.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/007_petition_schedules_officer_certificate.html`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/07_critical_vendors/055_critical_vendors_officer_certificate.html`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-15, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Mei Whitaker.\n\n### F-04 — priority classification error (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for priority classification error: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-RS-2804-D280, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-RS-2804-M736.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/02_claims_register/010_claims_register_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/08_tax/058_tax_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-15, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Caleb Hassan.\n\n### F-05 — executory-contract cure dispute (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for executory-contract cure dispute: one source states the applicable location is District of New Jersey Bankruptcy Court, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to New Jersey operations outside District of New Jersey Bankruptcy Court.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/02_claims_register/013_claims_register_review_memorandum.json`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/08_tax/061_tax_review_memorandum.json`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-15, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Leona Park.\n\n### F-06 — lease rejection deadline (low)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for lease rejection deadline: one source states the threshold is 5% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 12% and produced a different exception result.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/02_claims_register/016_claims_register_status_report.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/08_tax/064_tax_status_report.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-15, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Isaac Romero.\n\n### F-07 — postpetition invoice (critical)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for postpetition invoice: one source states formal notice must use notices-drummond_senior_care_group@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-pinecrest_medical_staffing@example.test.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/019_proofs_of_claim_correspondence.eml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/09_litigation/067_litigation_correspondence.eml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-15, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Sofia Bennett.\n\n### F-08 — critical-vendor overstatement (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for critical-vendor overstatement: one source states the governed population contains 76 records through 2025-06-20, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 44 records through 2025-07-06.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/022_proofs_of_claim_formal_notice.xml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/09_litigation/070_litigation_formal_notice.xml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-15, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Adrian Mensah.\n\n### F-09 — setoff assertion (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for setoff assertion: one source states the operative date is 2025-04-14 under control reference CB-RS-2804-I141, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2025-05-13 under response reference CB-RS-2804-R518.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/025_contracts_leases_control_register.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/10_plan_disclosure/073_plan_disclosure_control_register.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-15, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Willa Novak.\n\n### F-10 — guaranty overlap (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for guaranty overlap: one source states the controlling amount is $3,357,767.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $3,542,034.00.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/028_contracts_leases_ledger_export.csv`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/10_plan_disclosure/076_plan_disclosure_ledger_export.csv`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-15, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Theo Laurent.\n\n### F-11 — tax priority period (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for tax priority period: one source states approval is attributed to Rafael Okafor as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Samuel Kim and contains no entry for Rafael Okafor.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/031_contracts_leases_officer_certificate.html`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/10_plan_disclosure/079_plan_disclosure_officer_certificate.html`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-15, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Amara Patel.\n\n### F-12 — DIP budget variance (low)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for DIP budget variance: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-RS-2804-L412, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-RS-2804-U677.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/05_cash_management/034_cash_management_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/11_notices_ballots/082_notices_ballots_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-15, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Henry Cho.\n\n### F-13 — cash-collateral reporting gap (critical)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for cash-collateral reporting gap: one source states the applicable location is District of New Jersey Bankruptcy Court, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to New Jersey operations outside District of New Jersey Bankruptcy Court.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/05_cash_management/037_cash_management_review_memorandum.json`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/11_notices_ballots/085_notices_ballots_review_memorandum.json`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-15, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Nadine Flores.\n\n### F-14 — ballot amount discrepancy (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for ballot amount discrepancy: one source states the threshold is 4% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 8% and produced a different exception result.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/05_cash_management/040_cash_management_status_report.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/11_notices_ballots/088_notices_ballots_status_report.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-15, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Micah Sullivan.\n\n### F-15 — notice-address defect (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for notice-address defect: one source states formal notice must use notices-drummond_senior_care_group@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-pinecrest_medical_staffing@example.test.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/06_financing/043_financing_correspondence.eml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/091_reconciliations_correspondence.eml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-15, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Farah Ibrahim.\n\n### F-16 — reserve calculation error (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for reserve calculation error: one source states the governed population contains 180 records through 2026-02-19, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 44 records through 2026-03-07.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/06_financing/046_financing_formal_notice.xml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/094_reconciliations_formal_notice.xml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-15, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Owen Delgado.\n\n## Recommended next actions\n\nSequence the critical and high findings first, assign the named owners, preserve the cited records, and document any resolution in the controlling matter register before the stated deadline.\n\n## Assumptions and limitations\n\nThis analysis is confined to task cb100-044-drummond-care and the supplied synthetic evidence. It does not rely on external facts, does not resolve disputed law, and is not legal advice for a real person or entity.\n", "findings": {"as_of": "2026-09-15", "findings": [{"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/07_critical_vendors/049_critical_vendors_control_register.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for scheduled-claim mismatch: one source states the operative date is 2025-09-22 under control reference CB-RS-2804-A542, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2025-10-19 under response reference CB-RS-2804-J687.", "id": "F-01", "issue": "scheduled-claim mismatch", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/001_petition_schedules_control_register.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-15, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Talia Brooks.", "severity": "critical"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/07_critical_vendors/052_critical_vendors_ledger_export.csv", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for duplicate proof of claim: one source states the controlling amount is $930,193.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $1,206,886.00.", "id": "F-02", "issue": "duplicate proof of claim", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/004_petition_schedules_ledger_export.csv", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-15, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Jonas Feld.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/07_critical_vendors/055_critical_vendors_officer_certificate.html", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for secured-status defect: one source states approval is attributed to Rafael Okafor as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Jonas Feld and contains no entry for Rafael Okafor.", "id": "F-03", "issue": "secured-status defect", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/007_petition_schedules_officer_certificate.html", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-15, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Mei Whitaker.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/08_tax/058_tax_executed_instrument.txt", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for priority classification error: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-RS-2804-D280, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-RS-2804-M736.", "id": "F-04", "issue": "priority classification error", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/02_claims_register/010_claims_register_executed_instrument.txt", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-15, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Caleb Hassan.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/08_tax/061_tax_review_memorandum.json", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for executory-contract cure dispute: one source states the applicable location is District of New Jersey Bankruptcy Court, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to New Jersey operations outside District of New Jersey Bankruptcy Court.", "id": "F-05", "issue": "executory-contract cure dispute", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/02_claims_register/013_claims_register_review_memorandum.json", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-15, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Leona Park.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/08_tax/064_tax_status_report.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for lease rejection deadline: one source states the threshold is 5% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 12% and produced a different exception result.", "id": "F-06", "issue": "lease rejection deadline", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/02_claims_register/016_claims_register_status_report.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-15, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Isaac Romero.", "severity": "low"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/09_litigation/067_litigation_correspondence.eml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for postpetition invoice: one source states formal notice must use notices-drummond_senior_care_group@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-pinecrest_medical_staffing@example.test.", "id": "F-07", "issue": "postpetition invoice", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/019_proofs_of_claim_correspondence.eml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-15, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Sofia Bennett.", "severity": "critical"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/09_litigation/070_litigation_formal_notice.xml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for critical-vendor overstatement: one source states the governed population contains 76 records through 2025-06-20, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 44 records through 2025-07-06.", "id": "F-08", "issue": "critical-vendor overstatement", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/022_proofs_of_claim_formal_notice.xml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-15, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Adrian Mensah.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/10_plan_disclosure/073_plan_disclosure_control_register.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for setoff assertion: one source states the operative date is 2025-04-14 under control reference CB-RS-2804-I141, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2025-05-13 under response reference CB-RS-2804-R518.", "id": "F-09", "issue": "setoff assertion", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/025_contracts_leases_control_register.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-15, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Willa Novak.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/10_plan_disclosure/076_plan_disclosure_ledger_export.csv", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for guaranty overlap: one source states the controlling amount is $3,357,767.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $3,542,034.00.", "id": "F-10", "issue": "guaranty overlap", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/028_contracts_leases_ledger_export.csv", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-15, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Theo Laurent.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/10_plan_disclosure/079_plan_disclosure_officer_certificate.html", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for tax priority period: one source states approval is attributed to Rafael Okafor as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Samuel Kim and contains no entry for Rafael Okafor.", "id": "F-11", "issue": "tax priority period", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/031_contracts_leases_officer_certificate.html", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-15, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Amara Patel.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/11_notices_ballots/082_notices_ballots_executed_instrument.txt", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for DIP budget variance: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-RS-2804-L412, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-RS-2804-U677.", "id": "F-12", "issue": "DIP budget variance", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/05_cash_management/034_cash_management_executed_instrument.txt", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-15, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Henry Cho.", "severity": "low"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/11_notices_ballots/085_notices_ballots_review_memorandum.json", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for cash-collateral reporting gap: one source states the applicable location is District of New Jersey Bankruptcy Court, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to New Jersey operations outside District of New Jersey Bankruptcy Court.", "id": "F-13", "issue": "cash-collateral reporting gap", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/05_cash_management/037_cash_management_review_memorandum.json", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-15, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Nadine Flores.", "severity": "critical"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/11_notices_ballots/088_notices_ballots_status_report.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for ballot amount discrepancy: one source states the threshold is 4% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 8% and produced a different exception result.", "id": "F-14", "issue": "ballot amount discrepancy", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/05_cash_management/040_cash_management_status_report.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-15, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Micah Sullivan.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/091_reconciliations_correspondence.eml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for notice-address defect: one source states formal notice must use notices-drummond_senior_care_group@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-pinecrest_medical_staffing@example.test.", "id": "F-15", "issue": "notice-address defect", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/06_financing/043_financing_correspondence.eml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-15, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Farah Ibrahim.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/094_reconciliations_formal_notice.xml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for reserve calculation error: one source states the governed population contains 180 records through 2026-02-19, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 44 records through 2026-03-07.", "id": "F-16", "issue": "reserve calculation error", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/06_financing/046_financing_formal_notice.xml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-15, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Owen Delgado.", "severity": "medium"}], "matter_number": "CB-RS-2804", "prepared_for": "Drummond Senior Care Group", "schema_version": "1.0", "task_id": "cb100-044-drummond-care"}}, "metadata": {"benchmark": "CounselBench-100", "code_license": "Apache-2.0", "data_license": "CC-BY-4.0", "deadline": "2026-09-15", "document_count": 96, "jurisdiction": "New Jersey", "matter_number": "CB-RS-2804", "mcp_commit": "9a96ea6e5913736f92b88345bf51caeaaa8e719f", "mcp_package": "@modelcontextprotocol/server-filesystem@2026.7.10", "practice_area": "restructuring", "reference_tool_calls": 46, "required_evidence_reads": 33, "synthetic": true, "venue": "District of New Jersey Bankruptcy Court", "version": "2.0.0"}, "prompt": "You are debtor-side restructuring counsel for Drummond Senior Care Group. Several workstreams have maintained separate versions of the truth; your assignment is to produce one auditable legal view. Healthcare staffing, tax, and landlord claims conflict with schedules while cash-collateral reports omit a disputed receivable reserve. Decision due 2026-09-15. New Jersey law governs; District of New Jersey Bankruptcy Court is the forum. Distinguish a missing document from an affirmative contradiction in the documents that are present. Work out the defensible position from the matter production and leave an audit-ready exception tracker and concise advice for the supervising lawyer. Keep confirmed conflicts separate from open questions, cite the records that actually control each conclusion, and do not fill gaps with outside facts.", "rubric": {"criteria": [{"category": "procedure", "description": "Complete at least 46 successful, argument-specific evidence and output calls.", "id": "procedure.minimum_successful_tool_calls"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Find and read the 33 controlling, corroborating, and work-product-control records in full.", "id": "procedure.all_evidence_read_in_full"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Inspect file metadata for the eight designated critical primary records before relying on them.", "id": "procedure.chain_of_custody_metadata_checked"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Confirm the sandbox's allowed document and output roots.", "id": "procedure.allowed_directories_checked"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Inventory all 96 records so the relevant sources are discovered among the context records.", "id": "procedure.recursive_inventory_completed"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Search the production for email evidence that may corroborate or contradict formal records.", "id": "procedure.targeted_search_completed"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Leave only findings.json and advice.md in the output workspace.", "id": "procedure.exact_deliverable_set"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Create both final work products through the sandbox MCP surface.", "id": "procedure.deliverables_written_through_mcp"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Produce findings.json as a valid JSON object.", "id": "findings.findings_is_object"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Report exactly 16 confirmed exceptions.", "id": "findings.findings_exact_count"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Use each stable finding ID exactly once.", "id": "findings.finding_ids_unique"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set schema_version to the released matter value '1.0'.", "id": "findings.top_level_schema_version"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set task_id to the released matter value 'cb100-044-drummond-care'.", "id": "findings.top_level_task_id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set matter_number to the released matter value 'CB-RS-2804'.", "id": "findings.top_level_matter_number"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set prepared_for to the released matter value 'Drummond Senior Care Group'.", "id": "findings.top_level_prepared_for"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set as_of to the released matter value '2026-09-15'.", "id": "findings.top_level_as_of"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-01 exception for scheduled-claim mismatch.", "id": "findings.F-01.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's id from /workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/001_petition_schedules_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_critical_vendors/049_critical_vendors_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's issue from /workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/001_petition_schedules_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_critical_vendors/049_critical_vendors_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's severity from /workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/001_petition_schedules_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_critical_vendors/049_critical_vendors_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's primary_source from /workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/001_petition_schedules_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_critical_vendors/049_critical_vendors_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/001_petition_schedules_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_critical_vendors/049_critical_vendors_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-01 using the exact controlled facts ['2025-09-22', 'CB-RS-2804-A542', '2025-10-19', 'CB-RS-2804-J687'].", "id": "findings.F-01.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-01's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-01.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-15', 'Talia Brooks'] for F-01.", "id": "findings.F-01.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-02 exception for duplicate proof of claim.", "id": "findings.F-02.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's id from /workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/004_petition_schedules_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_critical_vendors/052_critical_vendors_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's issue from /workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/004_petition_schedules_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_critical_vendors/052_critical_vendors_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's severity from /workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/004_petition_schedules_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_critical_vendors/052_critical_vendors_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's primary_source from /workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/004_petition_schedules_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_critical_vendors/052_critical_vendors_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/004_petition_schedules_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_critical_vendors/052_critical_vendors_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-02 using the exact controlled facts ['$930,193.00', '$1,206,886.00'].", "id": "findings.F-02.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-02's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-02.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-15', 'Jonas Feld'] for F-02.", "id": "findings.F-02.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-03 exception for secured-status defect.", "id": "findings.F-03.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's id from /workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/007_petition_schedules_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_critical_vendors/055_critical_vendors_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's issue from /workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/007_petition_schedules_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_critical_vendors/055_critical_vendors_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's severity from /workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/007_petition_schedules_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_critical_vendors/055_critical_vendors_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's primary_source from /workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/007_petition_schedules_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_critical_vendors/055_critical_vendors_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/007_petition_schedules_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_critical_vendors/055_critical_vendors_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-03 using the exact controlled facts ['Rafael Okafor', 'Jonas Feld'].", "id": "findings.F-03.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-03's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-03.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-15', 'Mei Whitaker'] for F-03.", "id": "findings.F-03.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-04 exception for priority classification error.", "id": "findings.F-04.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's id from /workspace/documents/02_claims_register/010_claims_register_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_tax/058_tax_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's issue from /workspace/documents/02_claims_register/010_claims_register_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_tax/058_tax_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's severity from /workspace/documents/02_claims_register/010_claims_register_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_tax/058_tax_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's primary_source from /workspace/documents/02_claims_register/010_claims_register_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_tax/058_tax_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/02_claims_register/010_claims_register_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_tax/058_tax_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-04 using the exact controlled facts ['closed without exception', 'CB-RS-2804-D280', 'open and escalated', 'CB-RS-2804-M736'].", "id": "findings.F-04.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-04's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-04.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-15', 'Caleb Hassan'] for F-04.", "id": "findings.F-04.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-05 exception for executory-contract cure dispute.", "id": "findings.F-05.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's id from /workspace/documents/02_claims_register/013_claims_register_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_tax/061_tax_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's issue from /workspace/documents/02_claims_register/013_claims_register_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_tax/061_tax_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's severity from /workspace/documents/02_claims_register/013_claims_register_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_tax/061_tax_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's primary_source from /workspace/documents/02_claims_register/013_claims_register_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_tax/061_tax_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/02_claims_register/013_claims_register_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_tax/061_tax_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-05 using the exact controlled facts ['District of New Jersey Bankruptcy Court', 'New Jersey'].", "id": "findings.F-05.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-05's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-05.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-15', 'Leona Park'] for F-05.", "id": "findings.F-05.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-06 exception for lease rejection deadline.", "id": "findings.F-06.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's id from /workspace/documents/02_claims_register/016_claims_register_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_tax/064_tax_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's issue from /workspace/documents/02_claims_register/016_claims_register_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_tax/064_tax_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's severity from /workspace/documents/02_claims_register/016_claims_register_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_tax/064_tax_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's primary_source from /workspace/documents/02_claims_register/016_claims_register_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_tax/064_tax_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/02_claims_register/016_claims_register_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_tax/064_tax_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-06 using the exact controlled facts ['5%', '12%'].", "id": "findings.F-06.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-06's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-06.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-15', 'Isaac Romero'] for F-06.", "id": "findings.F-06.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-07 exception for postpetition invoice.", "id": "findings.F-07.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's id from /workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/019_proofs_of_claim_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_litigation/067_litigation_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's issue from /workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/019_proofs_of_claim_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_litigation/067_litigation_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's severity from /workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/019_proofs_of_claim_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_litigation/067_litigation_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's primary_source from /workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/019_proofs_of_claim_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_litigation/067_litigation_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/019_proofs_of_claim_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_litigation/067_litigation_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-07 using the exact controlled facts ['notices-drummond_senior_care_group@example.test', 'archive-pinecrest_medical_staffing@example.test'].", "id": "findings.F-07.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-07's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-07.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-15', 'Sofia Bennett'] for F-07.", "id": "findings.F-07.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-08 exception for critical-vendor overstatement.", "id": "findings.F-08.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's id from /workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/022_proofs_of_claim_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_litigation/070_litigation_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's issue from /workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/022_proofs_of_claim_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_litigation/070_litigation_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's severity from /workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/022_proofs_of_claim_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_litigation/070_litigation_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's primary_source from /workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/022_proofs_of_claim_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_litigation/070_litigation_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/022_proofs_of_claim_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_litigation/070_litigation_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-08 using the exact controlled facts ['76 records', '2025-06-20', '44 records', '2025-07-06'].", "id": "findings.F-08.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-08's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-08.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-15', 'Adrian Mensah'] for F-08.", "id": "findings.F-08.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-09 exception for setoff assertion.", "id": "findings.F-09.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's id from /workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/025_contracts_leases_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_plan_disclosure/073_plan_disclosure_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's issue from /workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/025_contracts_leases_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_plan_disclosure/073_plan_disclosure_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's severity from /workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/025_contracts_leases_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_plan_disclosure/073_plan_disclosure_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's primary_source from /workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/025_contracts_leases_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_plan_disclosure/073_plan_disclosure_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/025_contracts_leases_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_plan_disclosure/073_plan_disclosure_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-09 using the exact controlled facts ['2025-04-14', 'CB-RS-2804-I141', '2025-05-13', 'CB-RS-2804-R518'].", "id": "findings.F-09.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-09's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-09.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-15', 'Willa Novak'] for F-09.", "id": "findings.F-09.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-10 exception for guaranty overlap.", "id": "findings.F-10.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's id from /workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/028_contracts_leases_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_plan_disclosure/076_plan_disclosure_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's issue from /workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/028_contracts_leases_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_plan_disclosure/076_plan_disclosure_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's severity from /workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/028_contracts_leases_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_plan_disclosure/076_plan_disclosure_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's primary_source from /workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/028_contracts_leases_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_plan_disclosure/076_plan_disclosure_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/028_contracts_leases_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_plan_disclosure/076_plan_disclosure_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-10 using the exact controlled facts ['$3,357,767.00', '$3,542,034.00'].", "id": "findings.F-10.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-10's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-10.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-15', 'Theo Laurent'] for F-10.", "id": "findings.F-10.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-11 exception for tax priority period.", "id": "findings.F-11.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's id from /workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/031_contracts_leases_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_plan_disclosure/079_plan_disclosure_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's issue from /workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/031_contracts_leases_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_plan_disclosure/079_plan_disclosure_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's severity from /workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/031_contracts_leases_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_plan_disclosure/079_plan_disclosure_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's primary_source from /workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/031_contracts_leases_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_plan_disclosure/079_plan_disclosure_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/031_contracts_leases_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_plan_disclosure/079_plan_disclosure_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-11 using the exact controlled facts ['Rafael Okafor', 'Samuel Kim'].", "id": "findings.F-11.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-11's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-11.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-15', 'Amara Patel'] for F-11.", "id": "findings.F-11.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-12 exception for DIP budget variance.", "id": "findings.F-12.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's id from /workspace/documents/05_cash_management/034_cash_management_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_notices_ballots/082_notices_ballots_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's issue from /workspace/documents/05_cash_management/034_cash_management_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_notices_ballots/082_notices_ballots_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's severity from /workspace/documents/05_cash_management/034_cash_management_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_notices_ballots/082_notices_ballots_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's primary_source from /workspace/documents/05_cash_management/034_cash_management_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_notices_ballots/082_notices_ballots_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/05_cash_management/034_cash_management_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_notices_ballots/082_notices_ballots_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-12 using the exact controlled facts ['closed without exception', 'CB-RS-2804-L412', 'open and escalated', 'CB-RS-2804-U677'].", "id": "findings.F-12.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-12's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-12.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-15', 'Henry Cho'] for F-12.", "id": "findings.F-12.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-13 exception for cash-collateral reporting gap.", "id": "findings.F-13.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's id from /workspace/documents/05_cash_management/037_cash_management_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_notices_ballots/085_notices_ballots_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's issue from /workspace/documents/05_cash_management/037_cash_management_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_notices_ballots/085_notices_ballots_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's severity from /workspace/documents/05_cash_management/037_cash_management_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_notices_ballots/085_notices_ballots_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's primary_source from /workspace/documents/05_cash_management/037_cash_management_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_notices_ballots/085_notices_ballots_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/05_cash_management/037_cash_management_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_notices_ballots/085_notices_ballots_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-13 using the exact controlled facts ['District of New Jersey Bankruptcy Court', 'New Jersey'].", "id": "findings.F-13.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-13's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-13.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-15', 'Nadine Flores'] for F-13.", "id": "findings.F-13.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-14 exception for ballot amount discrepancy.", "id": "findings.F-14.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's id from /workspace/documents/05_cash_management/040_cash_management_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_notices_ballots/088_notices_ballots_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's issue from /workspace/documents/05_cash_management/040_cash_management_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_notices_ballots/088_notices_ballots_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's severity from /workspace/documents/05_cash_management/040_cash_management_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_notices_ballots/088_notices_ballots_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's primary_source from /workspace/documents/05_cash_management/040_cash_management_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_notices_ballots/088_notices_ballots_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/05_cash_management/040_cash_management_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_notices_ballots/088_notices_ballots_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-14 using the exact controlled facts ['4%', '8%'].", "id": "findings.F-14.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-14's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-14.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-15', 'Micah Sullivan'] for F-14.", "id": "findings.F-14.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-15 exception for notice-address defect.", "id": "findings.F-15.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's id from /workspace/documents/06_financing/043_financing_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/091_reconciliations_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's issue from /workspace/documents/06_financing/043_financing_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/091_reconciliations_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's severity from /workspace/documents/06_financing/043_financing_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/091_reconciliations_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's primary_source from /workspace/documents/06_financing/043_financing_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/091_reconciliations_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/06_financing/043_financing_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/091_reconciliations_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-15 using the exact controlled facts ['notices-drummond_senior_care_group@example.test', 'archive-pinecrest_medical_staffing@example.test'].", "id": "findings.F-15.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-15's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-15.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-15', 'Farah Ibrahim'] for F-15.", "id": "findings.F-15.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-16 exception for reserve calculation error.", "id": "findings.F-16.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's id from /workspace/documents/06_financing/046_financing_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/094_reconciliations_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's issue from /workspace/documents/06_financing/046_financing_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/094_reconciliations_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's severity from /workspace/documents/06_financing/046_financing_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/094_reconciliations_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's primary_source from /workspace/documents/06_financing/046_financing_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/094_reconciliations_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/06_financing/046_financing_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/094_reconciliations_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-16 using the exact controlled facts ['180 records', '2026-02-19', '44 records', '2026-03-07'].", "id": "findings.F-16.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-16's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-16.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-15', 'Owen Delgado'] for F-16.", "id": "findings.F-16.action_anchors"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Executive assessment' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Executive assessment"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Method and record coverage' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Method and record coverage"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Findings' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Findings"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Recommended next actions' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Recommended next actions"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Assumptions and limitations' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Assumptions and limitations"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-01 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-01"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-02 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-02"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-03 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-03"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-04 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-04"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-05 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-05"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-06 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-06"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-07 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-07"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-08 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-08"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-09 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-09"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-10 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-10"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-11 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-11"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-12 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-12"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-13 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-13"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-14 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-14"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-15 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-15"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-16 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-16"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Do not claim the production has no issues or that every record is consistent.", "id": "memo.forbidden_claims_absent"}], "decision_options": [{"id": "cross-source-reconciliation", "label": "Reconcile controlling and corroborating records", "reason": "The CB-RS-2804 production contains independently maintained records; a defensible answer must preserve each supported conflict and its cure owner.", "selected": true}, {"id": "latest-record-controls", "label": "Treat the latest record as controlling", "reason": "Timestamp recency does not establish legal priority, execution, or approval authority.", "selected": false}, {"id": "primary-records-only", "label": "Report primary records without reconciliation", "reason": "Primary records alone conceal the operational conflicts that create the actionable exceptions.", "selected": false}], "gates": ["all_evidence_read_in_full", "chain_of_custody_metadata_checked", "findings_criteria_complete", "memo_criteria_complete", "deliverables_written_through_mcp"], "metadata_checks": 8, "metric": "weighted_criteria_score", "minimum_tool_calls": 46, "required_deliverables": ["findings.json", "advice.md"], "required_document_reads": 33, "type": "deterministic", "weights": {"findings": 0.55, "memo": 0.2, "procedure": 0.25}}, "task_id": "cb100-044-drummond-care", "task_name": "Drummond Care restructuring schedule check", "world_id": "counselbench-filesystem-mcp-v2"}
-{"context_files": ["task_files/cb100-045-equinox-solar/01_petition_schedules/001_petition_schedules_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-045-equinox-solar/01_petition_schedules/002_petition_schedules_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-045-equinox-solar/01_petition_schedules/003_petition_schedules_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-045-equinox-solar/01_petition_schedules/004_petition_schedules_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-045-equinox-solar/01_petition_schedules/005_petition_schedules_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-045-equinox-solar/01_petition_schedules/006_petition_schedules_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-045-equinox-solar/01_petition_schedules/007_petition_schedules_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-045-equinox-solar/01_petition_schedules/008_petition_schedules_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-045-equinox-solar/02_claims_register/009_claims_register_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-045-equinox-solar/02_claims_register/010_claims_register_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-045-equinox-solar/02_claims_register/011_claims_register_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-045-equinox-solar/02_claims_register/012_claims_register_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-045-equinox-solar/02_claims_register/013_claims_register_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-045-equinox-solar/02_claims_register/014_claims_register_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-045-equinox-solar/02_claims_register/015_claims_register_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-045-equinox-solar/02_claims_register/016_claims_register_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-045-equinox-solar/03_proofs_of_claim/017_proofs_of_claim_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-045-equinox-solar/03_proofs_of_claim/018_proofs_of_claim_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-045-equinox-solar/03_proofs_of_claim/019_proofs_of_claim_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-045-equinox-solar/03_proofs_of_claim/020_proofs_of_claim_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-045-equinox-solar/03_proofs_of_claim/021_proofs_of_claim_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-045-equinox-solar/03_proofs_of_claim/022_proofs_of_claim_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-045-equinox-solar/03_proofs_of_claim/023_proofs_of_claim_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-045-equinox-solar/03_proofs_of_claim/024_proofs_of_claim_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-045-equinox-solar/04_contracts_leases/025_contracts_leases_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-045-equinox-solar/04_contracts_leases/026_contracts_leases_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-045-equinox-solar/04_contracts_leases/027_contracts_leases_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-045-equinox-solar/04_contracts_leases/028_contracts_leases_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-045-equinox-solar/04_contracts_leases/029_contracts_leases_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-045-equinox-solar/04_contracts_leases/030_contracts_leases_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-045-equinox-solar/04_contracts_leases/031_contracts_leases_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-045-equinox-solar/04_contracts_leases/032_contracts_leases_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-045-equinox-solar/05_cash_management/033_cash_management_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-045-equinox-solar/05_cash_management/034_cash_management_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-045-equinox-solar/05_cash_management/035_cash_management_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-045-equinox-solar/05_cash_management/036_cash_management_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-045-equinox-solar/05_cash_management/037_cash_management_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-045-equinox-solar/05_cash_management/038_cash_management_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-045-equinox-solar/05_cash_management/039_cash_management_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-045-equinox-solar/05_cash_management/040_cash_management_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-045-equinox-solar/06_financing/041_financing_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-045-equinox-solar/06_financing/042_financing_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-045-equinox-solar/06_financing/043_financing_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-045-equinox-solar/06_financing/044_financing_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-045-equinox-solar/06_financing/045_financing_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-045-equinox-solar/06_financing/046_financing_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-045-equinox-solar/06_financing/047_financing_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-045-equinox-solar/06_financing/048_financing_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-045-equinox-solar/07_critical_vendors/049_critical_vendors_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-045-equinox-solar/07_critical_vendors/050_critical_vendors_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-045-equinox-solar/07_critical_vendors/051_critical_vendors_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-045-equinox-solar/07_critical_vendors/052_critical_vendors_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-045-equinox-solar/07_critical_vendors/053_critical_vendors_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-045-equinox-solar/07_critical_vendors/054_critical_vendors_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-045-equinox-solar/07_critical_vendors/055_critical_vendors_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-045-equinox-solar/07_critical_vendors/056_critical_vendors_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-045-equinox-solar/08_tax/057_tax_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-045-equinox-solar/08_tax/058_tax_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-045-equinox-solar/08_tax/059_tax_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-045-equinox-solar/08_tax/060_tax_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-045-equinox-solar/08_tax/061_tax_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-045-equinox-solar/08_tax/062_tax_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-045-equinox-solar/08_tax/063_tax_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-045-equinox-solar/08_tax/064_tax_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-045-equinox-solar/09_litigation/065_litigation_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-045-equinox-solar/09_litigation/066_litigation_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-045-equinox-solar/09_litigation/067_litigation_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-045-equinox-solar/09_litigation/068_litigation_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-045-equinox-solar/09_litigation/069_litigation_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-045-equinox-solar/09_litigation/070_litigation_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-045-equinox-solar/09_litigation/071_litigation_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-045-equinox-solar/09_litigation/072_litigation_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-045-equinox-solar/10_plan_disclosure/073_plan_disclosure_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-045-equinox-solar/10_plan_disclosure/074_plan_disclosure_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-045-equinox-solar/10_plan_disclosure/075_plan_disclosure_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-045-equinox-solar/10_plan_disclosure/076_plan_disclosure_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-045-equinox-solar/10_plan_disclosure/077_plan_disclosure_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-045-equinox-solar/10_plan_disclosure/078_plan_disclosure_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-045-equinox-solar/10_plan_disclosure/079_plan_disclosure_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-045-equinox-solar/10_plan_disclosure/080_plan_disclosure_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-045-equinox-solar/11_notices_ballots/081_notices_ballots_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-045-equinox-solar/11_notices_ballots/082_notices_ballots_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-045-equinox-solar/11_notices_ballots/083_notices_ballots_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-045-equinox-solar/11_notices_ballots/084_notices_ballots_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-045-equinox-solar/11_notices_ballots/085_notices_ballots_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-045-equinox-solar/11_notices_ballots/086_notices_ballots_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-045-equinox-solar/11_notices_ballots/087_notices_ballots_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-045-equinox-solar/11_notices_ballots/088_notices_ballots_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-045-equinox-solar/12_reconciliations/089_reconciliations_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-045-equinox-solar/12_reconciliations/090_reconciliations_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-045-equinox-solar/12_reconciliations/091_reconciliations_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-045-equinox-solar/12_reconciliations/092_reconciliations_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-045-equinox-solar/12_reconciliations/093_reconciliations_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-045-equinox-solar/12_reconciliations/094_reconciliations_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-045-equinox-solar/12_reconciliations/095_reconciliations_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-045-equinox-solar/12_reconciliations/096_reconciliations_status_report.md"], "gold_output": {"advice_markdown": "# Counsel advice — Equinox Solar project claim reconciliation\n\n## Executive assessment\n\nFor Equinox Solar Development matter CB-RS-2805, the review identified 16 source-supported exceptions requiring action before 2026-09-18. The assessment concerns Mesa Array Contractors and the supplied record for Arizona.\n\n## Method and record coverage\n\nThe review inventoried all 96 production files, read the 33 controlling, corroborating, and control records, searched the email exports, and checked metadata for the designated chain-of-custody sample. Conclusions are limited to the synthetic production supplied for this benchmark matter.\n\n## Findings\n\n### F-01 — scheduled-claim mismatch (critical)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for scheduled-claim mismatch: one source states the operative date is 2025-03-26 under control reference CB-RS-2805-A542, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2025-04-30 under response reference CB-RS-2805-J895.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/001_petition_schedules_control_register.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/07_critical_vendors/049_critical_vendors_control_register.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-18, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Jonas Feld.\n\n### F-02 — duplicate proof of claim (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for duplicate proof of claim: one source states the controlling amount is $3,381,717.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $3,589,934.00.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/004_petition_schedules_ledger_export.csv`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/07_critical_vendors/052_critical_vendors_ledger_export.csv`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-18, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Mei Whitaker.\n\n### F-03 — secured-status defect (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for secured-status defect: one source states approval is attributed to Nora Chen as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Caleb Hassan and contains no entry for Nora Chen.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/007_petition_schedules_officer_certificate.html`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/07_critical_vendors/055_critical_vendors_officer_certificate.html`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-18, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Caleb Hassan.\n\n### F-04 — priority classification error (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for priority classification error: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-RS-2805-D650, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-RS-2805-M765.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/02_claims_register/010_claims_register_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/08_tax/058_tax_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-18, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Leona Park.\n\n### F-05 — executory-contract cure dispute (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for executory-contract cure dispute: one source states the applicable location is District of Arizona Bankruptcy Court, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to Arizona operations outside District of Arizona Bankruptcy Court.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/02_claims_register/013_claims_register_review_memorandum.json`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/08_tax/061_tax_review_memorandum.json`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-18, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Isaac Romero.\n\n### F-06 — lease rejection deadline (low)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for lease rejection deadline: one source states the threshold is 10% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 12% and produced a different exception result.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/02_claims_register/016_claims_register_status_report.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/08_tax/064_tax_status_report.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-18, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Sofia Bennett.\n\n### F-07 — postpetition invoice (critical)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for postpetition invoice: one source states formal notice must use notices-equinox_solar_development@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-mesa_array_contractors@example.test.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/019_proofs_of_claim_correspondence.eml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/09_litigation/067_litigation_correspondence.eml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-18, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Adrian Mensah.\n\n### F-08 — critical-vendor overstatement (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for critical-vendor overstatement: one source states the governed population contains 139 records through 2025-08-22, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 60 records through 2025-09-23.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/022_proofs_of_claim_formal_notice.xml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/09_litigation/070_litigation_formal_notice.xml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-18, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Willa Novak.\n\n### F-09 — setoff assertion (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for setoff assertion: one source states the operative date is 2025-03-07 under control reference CB-RS-2805-I223, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2025-03-22 under response reference CB-RS-2805-R455.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/025_contracts_leases_control_register.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/10_plan_disclosure/073_plan_disclosure_control_register.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-18, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Theo Laurent.\n\n### F-10 — guaranty overlap (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for guaranty overlap: one source states the controlling amount is $3,039,447.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $3,245,394.00.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/028_contracts_leases_ledger_export.csv`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/10_plan_disclosure/076_plan_disclosure_ledger_export.csv`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-18, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Amara Patel.\n\n### F-11 — tax priority period (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for tax priority period: one source states approval is attributed to Nora Chen as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Rafael Okafor and contains no entry for Nora Chen.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/031_contracts_leases_officer_certificate.html`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/10_plan_disclosure/079_plan_disclosure_officer_certificate.html`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-18, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Henry Cho.\n\n### F-12 — DIP budget variance (low)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for DIP budget variance: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-RS-2805-L960, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-RS-2805-U996.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/05_cash_management/034_cash_management_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/11_notices_ballots/082_notices_ballots_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-18, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Nadine Flores.\n\n### F-13 — cash-collateral reporting gap (critical)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for cash-collateral reporting gap: one source states the applicable location is District of Arizona Bankruptcy Court, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to Arizona operations outside District of Arizona Bankruptcy Court.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/05_cash_management/037_cash_management_review_memorandum.json`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/11_notices_ballots/085_notices_ballots_review_memorandum.json`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-18, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Micah Sullivan.\n\n### F-14 — ballot amount discrepancy (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for ballot amount discrepancy: one source states the threshold is 6% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 10% and produced a different exception result.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/05_cash_management/040_cash_management_status_report.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/11_notices_ballots/088_notices_ballots_status_report.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-18, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Farah Ibrahim.\n\n### F-15 — notice-address defect (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for notice-address defect: one source states formal notice must use notices-equinox_solar_development@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-mesa_array_contractors@example.test.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/06_financing/043_financing_correspondence.eml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/091_reconciliations_correspondence.eml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-18, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Owen Delgado.\n\n### F-16 — reserve calculation error (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for reserve calculation error: one source states the governed population contains 91 records through 2025-02-15, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 44 records through 2025-03-03.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/06_financing/046_financing_formal_notice.xml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/094_reconciliations_formal_notice.xml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-18, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Lena Varga.\n\n## Recommended next actions\n\nSequence the critical and high findings first, assign the named owners, preserve the cited records, and document any resolution in the controlling matter register before the stated deadline.\n\n## Assumptions and limitations\n\nThis analysis is confined to task cb100-045-equinox-solar and the supplied synthetic evidence. It does not rely on external facts, does not resolve disputed law, and is not legal advice for a real person or entity.\n", "findings": {"as_of": "2026-09-18", "findings": [{"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/07_critical_vendors/049_critical_vendors_control_register.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for scheduled-claim mismatch: one source states the operative date is 2025-03-26 under control reference CB-RS-2805-A542, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2025-04-30 under response reference CB-RS-2805-J895.", "id": "F-01", "issue": "scheduled-claim mismatch", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/001_petition_schedules_control_register.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-18, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Jonas Feld.", "severity": "critical"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/07_critical_vendors/052_critical_vendors_ledger_export.csv", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for duplicate proof of claim: one source states the controlling amount is $3,381,717.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $3,589,934.00.", "id": "F-02", "issue": "duplicate proof of claim", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/004_petition_schedules_ledger_export.csv", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-18, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Mei Whitaker.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/07_critical_vendors/055_critical_vendors_officer_certificate.html", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for secured-status defect: one source states approval is attributed to Nora Chen as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Caleb Hassan and contains no entry for Nora Chen.", "id": "F-03", "issue": "secured-status defect", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/007_petition_schedules_officer_certificate.html", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-18, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Caleb Hassan.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/08_tax/058_tax_executed_instrument.txt", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for priority classification error: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-RS-2805-D650, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-RS-2805-M765.", "id": "F-04", "issue": "priority classification error", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/02_claims_register/010_claims_register_executed_instrument.txt", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-18, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Leona Park.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/08_tax/061_tax_review_memorandum.json", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for executory-contract cure dispute: one source states the applicable location is District of Arizona Bankruptcy Court, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to Arizona operations outside District of Arizona Bankruptcy Court.", "id": "F-05", "issue": "executory-contract cure dispute", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/02_claims_register/013_claims_register_review_memorandum.json", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-18, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Isaac Romero.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/08_tax/064_tax_status_report.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for lease rejection deadline: one source states the threshold is 10% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 12% and produced a different exception result.", "id": "F-06", "issue": "lease rejection deadline", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/02_claims_register/016_claims_register_status_report.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-18, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Sofia Bennett.", "severity": "low"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/09_litigation/067_litigation_correspondence.eml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for postpetition invoice: one source states formal notice must use notices-equinox_solar_development@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-mesa_array_contractors@example.test.", "id": "F-07", "issue": "postpetition invoice", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/019_proofs_of_claim_correspondence.eml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-18, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Adrian Mensah.", "severity": "critical"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/09_litigation/070_litigation_formal_notice.xml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for critical-vendor overstatement: one source states the governed population contains 139 records through 2025-08-22, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 60 records through 2025-09-23.", "id": "F-08", "issue": "critical-vendor overstatement", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/022_proofs_of_claim_formal_notice.xml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-18, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Willa Novak.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/10_plan_disclosure/073_plan_disclosure_control_register.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for setoff assertion: one source states the operative date is 2025-03-07 under control reference CB-RS-2805-I223, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2025-03-22 under response reference CB-RS-2805-R455.", "id": "F-09", "issue": "setoff assertion", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/025_contracts_leases_control_register.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-18, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Theo Laurent.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/10_plan_disclosure/076_plan_disclosure_ledger_export.csv", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for guaranty overlap: one source states the controlling amount is $3,039,447.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $3,245,394.00.", "id": "F-10", "issue": "guaranty overlap", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/028_contracts_leases_ledger_export.csv", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-18, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Amara Patel.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/10_plan_disclosure/079_plan_disclosure_officer_certificate.html", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for tax priority period: one source states approval is attributed to Nora Chen as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Rafael Okafor and contains no entry for Nora Chen.", "id": "F-11", "issue": "tax priority period", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/031_contracts_leases_officer_certificate.html", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-18, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Henry Cho.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/11_notices_ballots/082_notices_ballots_executed_instrument.txt", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for DIP budget variance: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-RS-2805-L960, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-RS-2805-U996.", "id": "F-12", "issue": "DIP budget variance", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/05_cash_management/034_cash_management_executed_instrument.txt", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-18, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Nadine Flores.", "severity": "low"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/11_notices_ballots/085_notices_ballots_review_memorandum.json", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for cash-collateral reporting gap: one source states the applicable location is District of Arizona Bankruptcy Court, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to Arizona operations outside District of Arizona Bankruptcy Court.", "id": "F-13", "issue": "cash-collateral reporting gap", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/05_cash_management/037_cash_management_review_memorandum.json", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-18, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Micah Sullivan.", "severity": "critical"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/11_notices_ballots/088_notices_ballots_status_report.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for ballot amount discrepancy: one source states the threshold is 6% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 10% and produced a different exception result.", "id": "F-14", "issue": "ballot amount discrepancy", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/05_cash_management/040_cash_management_status_report.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-18, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Farah Ibrahim.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/091_reconciliations_correspondence.eml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for notice-address defect: one source states formal notice must use notices-equinox_solar_development@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-mesa_array_contractors@example.test.", "id": "F-15", "issue": "notice-address defect", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/06_financing/043_financing_correspondence.eml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-18, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Owen Delgado.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/094_reconciliations_formal_notice.xml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for reserve calculation error: one source states the governed population contains 91 records through 2025-02-15, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 44 records through 2025-03-03.", "id": "F-16", "issue": "reserve calculation error", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/06_financing/046_financing_formal_notice.xml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-18, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Lena Varga.", "severity": "medium"}], "matter_number": "CB-RS-2805", "prepared_for": "Equinox Solar Development", "schema_version": "1.0", "task_id": "cb100-045-equinox-solar"}}, "metadata": {"benchmark": "CounselBench-100", "code_license": "Apache-2.0", "data_license": "CC-BY-4.0", "deadline": "2026-09-18", "document_count": 96, "jurisdiction": "Arizona", "matter_number": "CB-RS-2805", "mcp_commit": "9a96ea6e5913736f92b88345bf51caeaaa8e719f", "mcp_package": "@modelcontextprotocol/server-filesystem@2026.7.10", "practice_area": "restructuring", "reference_tool_calls": 46, "required_evidence_reads": 33, "synthetic": true, "venue": "District of Arizona Bankruptcy Court", "version": "2.0.0"}, "prompt": "You are debtor-side restructuring counsel for Equinox Solar Development. Outside counsel inherited this file after turnover on the client team and must validate every operative record before advising. Construction claims assert secured and priority treatment across partially completed projects with overlapping guaranties. Decision due 2026-09-18. Arizona law governs; District of Arizona Bankruptcy Court is the forum. Evaluate both legal consequence and the practical owner needed to cure each exception. Work out the defensible position from the matter production and leave an audit-ready exception tracker and concise advice for the supervising lawyer. Keep confirmed conflicts separate from open questions, cite the records that actually control each conclusion, and do not fill gaps with outside facts.", "rubric": {"criteria": [{"category": "procedure", "description": "Complete at least 46 successful, argument-specific evidence and output calls.", "id": "procedure.minimum_successful_tool_calls"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Find and read the 33 controlling, corroborating, and work-product-control records in full.", "id": "procedure.all_evidence_read_in_full"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Inspect file metadata for the eight designated critical primary records before relying on them.", "id": "procedure.chain_of_custody_metadata_checked"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Confirm the sandbox's allowed document and output roots.", "id": "procedure.allowed_directories_checked"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Inventory all 96 records so the relevant sources are discovered among the context records.", "id": "procedure.recursive_inventory_completed"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Search the production for email evidence that may corroborate or contradict formal records.", "id": "procedure.targeted_search_completed"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Leave only findings.json and advice.md in the output workspace.", "id": "procedure.exact_deliverable_set"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Create both final work products through the sandbox MCP surface.", "id": "procedure.deliverables_written_through_mcp"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Produce findings.json as a valid JSON object.", "id": "findings.findings_is_object"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Report exactly 16 confirmed exceptions.", "id": "findings.findings_exact_count"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Use each stable finding ID exactly once.", "id": "findings.finding_ids_unique"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set schema_version to the released matter value '1.0'.", "id": "findings.top_level_schema_version"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set task_id to the released matter value 'cb100-045-equinox-solar'.", "id": "findings.top_level_task_id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set matter_number to the released matter value 'CB-RS-2805'.", "id": "findings.top_level_matter_number"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set prepared_for to the released matter value 'Equinox Solar Development'.", "id": "findings.top_level_prepared_for"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set as_of to the released matter value '2026-09-18'.", "id": "findings.top_level_as_of"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-01 exception for scheduled-claim mismatch.", "id": "findings.F-01.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's id from /workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/001_petition_schedules_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_critical_vendors/049_critical_vendors_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's issue from /workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/001_petition_schedules_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_critical_vendors/049_critical_vendors_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's severity from /workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/001_petition_schedules_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_critical_vendors/049_critical_vendors_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's primary_source from /workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/001_petition_schedules_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_critical_vendors/049_critical_vendors_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/001_petition_schedules_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_critical_vendors/049_critical_vendors_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-01 using the exact controlled facts ['2025-03-26', 'CB-RS-2805-A542', '2025-04-30', 'CB-RS-2805-J895'].", "id": "findings.F-01.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-01's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-01.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-18', 'Jonas Feld'] for F-01.", "id": "findings.F-01.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-02 exception for duplicate proof of claim.", "id": "findings.F-02.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's id from /workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/004_petition_schedules_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_critical_vendors/052_critical_vendors_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's issue from /workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/004_petition_schedules_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_critical_vendors/052_critical_vendors_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's severity from /workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/004_petition_schedules_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_critical_vendors/052_critical_vendors_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's primary_source from /workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/004_petition_schedules_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_critical_vendors/052_critical_vendors_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/004_petition_schedules_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_critical_vendors/052_critical_vendors_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-02 using the exact controlled facts ['$3,381,717.00', '$3,589,934.00'].", "id": "findings.F-02.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-02's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-02.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-18', 'Mei Whitaker'] for F-02.", "id": "findings.F-02.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-03 exception for secured-status defect.", "id": "findings.F-03.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's id from /workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/007_petition_schedules_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_critical_vendors/055_critical_vendors_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's issue from /workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/007_petition_schedules_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_critical_vendors/055_critical_vendors_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's severity from /workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/007_petition_schedules_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_critical_vendors/055_critical_vendors_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's primary_source from /workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/007_petition_schedules_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_critical_vendors/055_critical_vendors_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/007_petition_schedules_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_critical_vendors/055_critical_vendors_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-03 using the exact controlled facts ['Nora Chen', 'Caleb Hassan'].", "id": "findings.F-03.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-03's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-03.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-18', 'Caleb Hassan'] for F-03.", "id": "findings.F-03.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-04 exception for priority classification error.", "id": "findings.F-04.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's id from /workspace/documents/02_claims_register/010_claims_register_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_tax/058_tax_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's issue from /workspace/documents/02_claims_register/010_claims_register_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_tax/058_tax_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's severity from /workspace/documents/02_claims_register/010_claims_register_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_tax/058_tax_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's primary_source from /workspace/documents/02_claims_register/010_claims_register_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_tax/058_tax_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/02_claims_register/010_claims_register_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_tax/058_tax_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-04 using the exact controlled facts ['closed without exception', 'CB-RS-2805-D650', 'open and escalated', 'CB-RS-2805-M765'].", "id": "findings.F-04.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-04's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-04.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-18', 'Leona Park'] for F-04.", "id": "findings.F-04.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-05 exception for executory-contract cure dispute.", "id": "findings.F-05.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's id from /workspace/documents/02_claims_register/013_claims_register_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_tax/061_tax_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's issue from /workspace/documents/02_claims_register/013_claims_register_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_tax/061_tax_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's severity from /workspace/documents/02_claims_register/013_claims_register_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_tax/061_tax_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's primary_source from /workspace/documents/02_claims_register/013_claims_register_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_tax/061_tax_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/02_claims_register/013_claims_register_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_tax/061_tax_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-05 using the exact controlled facts ['District of Arizona Bankruptcy Court', 'Arizona'].", "id": "findings.F-05.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-05's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-05.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-18', 'Isaac Romero'] for F-05.", "id": "findings.F-05.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-06 exception for lease rejection deadline.", "id": "findings.F-06.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's id from /workspace/documents/02_claims_register/016_claims_register_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_tax/064_tax_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's issue from /workspace/documents/02_claims_register/016_claims_register_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_tax/064_tax_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's severity from /workspace/documents/02_claims_register/016_claims_register_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_tax/064_tax_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's primary_source from /workspace/documents/02_claims_register/016_claims_register_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_tax/064_tax_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/02_claims_register/016_claims_register_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_tax/064_tax_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-06 using the exact controlled facts ['10%', '12%'].", "id": "findings.F-06.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-06's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-06.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-18', 'Sofia Bennett'] for F-06.", "id": "findings.F-06.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-07 exception for postpetition invoice.", "id": "findings.F-07.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's id from /workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/019_proofs_of_claim_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_litigation/067_litigation_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's issue from /workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/019_proofs_of_claim_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_litigation/067_litigation_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's severity from /workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/019_proofs_of_claim_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_litigation/067_litigation_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's primary_source from /workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/019_proofs_of_claim_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_litigation/067_litigation_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/019_proofs_of_claim_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_litigation/067_litigation_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-07 using the exact controlled facts ['notices-equinox_solar_development@example.test', 'archive-mesa_array_contractors@example.test'].", "id": "findings.F-07.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-07's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-07.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-18', 'Adrian Mensah'] for F-07.", "id": "findings.F-07.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-08 exception for critical-vendor overstatement.", "id": "findings.F-08.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's id from /workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/022_proofs_of_claim_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_litigation/070_litigation_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's issue from /workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/022_proofs_of_claim_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_litigation/070_litigation_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's severity from /workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/022_proofs_of_claim_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_litigation/070_litigation_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's primary_source from /workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/022_proofs_of_claim_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_litigation/070_litigation_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/022_proofs_of_claim_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_litigation/070_litigation_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-08 using the exact controlled facts ['139 records', '2025-08-22', '60 records', '2025-09-23'].", "id": "findings.F-08.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-08's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-08.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-18', 'Willa Novak'] for F-08.", "id": "findings.F-08.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-09 exception for setoff assertion.", "id": "findings.F-09.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's id from /workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/025_contracts_leases_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_plan_disclosure/073_plan_disclosure_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's issue from /workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/025_contracts_leases_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_plan_disclosure/073_plan_disclosure_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's severity from /workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/025_contracts_leases_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_plan_disclosure/073_plan_disclosure_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's primary_source from /workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/025_contracts_leases_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_plan_disclosure/073_plan_disclosure_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/025_contracts_leases_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_plan_disclosure/073_plan_disclosure_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-09 using the exact controlled facts ['2025-03-07', 'CB-RS-2805-I223', '2025-03-22', 'CB-RS-2805-R455'].", "id": "findings.F-09.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-09's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-09.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-18', 'Theo Laurent'] for F-09.", "id": "findings.F-09.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-10 exception for guaranty overlap.", "id": "findings.F-10.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's id from /workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/028_contracts_leases_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_plan_disclosure/076_plan_disclosure_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's issue from /workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/028_contracts_leases_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_plan_disclosure/076_plan_disclosure_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's severity from /workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/028_contracts_leases_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_plan_disclosure/076_plan_disclosure_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's primary_source from /workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/028_contracts_leases_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_plan_disclosure/076_plan_disclosure_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/028_contracts_leases_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_plan_disclosure/076_plan_disclosure_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-10 using the exact controlled facts ['$3,039,447.00', '$3,245,394.00'].", "id": "findings.F-10.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-10's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-10.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-18', 'Amara Patel'] for F-10.", "id": "findings.F-10.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-11 exception for tax priority period.", "id": "findings.F-11.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's id from /workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/031_contracts_leases_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_plan_disclosure/079_plan_disclosure_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's issue from /workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/031_contracts_leases_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_plan_disclosure/079_plan_disclosure_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's severity from /workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/031_contracts_leases_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_plan_disclosure/079_plan_disclosure_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's primary_source from /workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/031_contracts_leases_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_plan_disclosure/079_plan_disclosure_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/031_contracts_leases_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_plan_disclosure/079_plan_disclosure_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-11 using the exact controlled facts ['Nora Chen', 'Rafael Okafor'].", "id": "findings.F-11.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-11's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-11.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-18', 'Henry Cho'] for F-11.", "id": "findings.F-11.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-12 exception for DIP budget variance.", "id": "findings.F-12.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's id from /workspace/documents/05_cash_management/034_cash_management_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_notices_ballots/082_notices_ballots_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's issue from /workspace/documents/05_cash_management/034_cash_management_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_notices_ballots/082_notices_ballots_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's severity from /workspace/documents/05_cash_management/034_cash_management_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_notices_ballots/082_notices_ballots_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's primary_source from /workspace/documents/05_cash_management/034_cash_management_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_notices_ballots/082_notices_ballots_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/05_cash_management/034_cash_management_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_notices_ballots/082_notices_ballots_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-12 using the exact controlled facts ['closed without exception', 'CB-RS-2805-L960', 'open and escalated', 'CB-RS-2805-U996'].", "id": "findings.F-12.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-12's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-12.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-18', 'Nadine Flores'] for F-12.", "id": "findings.F-12.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-13 exception for cash-collateral reporting gap.", "id": "findings.F-13.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's id from /workspace/documents/05_cash_management/037_cash_management_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_notices_ballots/085_notices_ballots_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's issue from /workspace/documents/05_cash_management/037_cash_management_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_notices_ballots/085_notices_ballots_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's severity from /workspace/documents/05_cash_management/037_cash_management_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_notices_ballots/085_notices_ballots_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's primary_source from /workspace/documents/05_cash_management/037_cash_management_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_notices_ballots/085_notices_ballots_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/05_cash_management/037_cash_management_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_notices_ballots/085_notices_ballots_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-13 using the exact controlled facts ['District of Arizona Bankruptcy Court', 'Arizona'].", "id": "findings.F-13.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-13's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-13.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-18', 'Micah Sullivan'] for F-13.", "id": "findings.F-13.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-14 exception for ballot amount discrepancy.", "id": "findings.F-14.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's id from /workspace/documents/05_cash_management/040_cash_management_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_notices_ballots/088_notices_ballots_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's issue from /workspace/documents/05_cash_management/040_cash_management_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_notices_ballots/088_notices_ballots_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's severity from /workspace/documents/05_cash_management/040_cash_management_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_notices_ballots/088_notices_ballots_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's primary_source from /workspace/documents/05_cash_management/040_cash_management_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_notices_ballots/088_notices_ballots_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/05_cash_management/040_cash_management_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_notices_ballots/088_notices_ballots_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-14 using the exact controlled facts ['6%', '10%'].", "id": "findings.F-14.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-14's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-14.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-18', 'Farah Ibrahim'] for F-14.", "id": "findings.F-14.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-15 exception for notice-address defect.", "id": "findings.F-15.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's id from /workspace/documents/06_financing/043_financing_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/091_reconciliations_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's issue from /workspace/documents/06_financing/043_financing_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/091_reconciliations_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's severity from /workspace/documents/06_financing/043_financing_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/091_reconciliations_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's primary_source from /workspace/documents/06_financing/043_financing_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/091_reconciliations_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/06_financing/043_financing_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/091_reconciliations_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-15 using the exact controlled facts ['notices-equinox_solar_development@example.test', 'archive-mesa_array_contractors@example.test'].", "id": "findings.F-15.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-15's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-15.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-18', 'Owen Delgado'] for F-15.", "id": "findings.F-15.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-16 exception for reserve calculation error.", "id": "findings.F-16.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's id from /workspace/documents/06_financing/046_financing_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/094_reconciliations_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's issue from /workspace/documents/06_financing/046_financing_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/094_reconciliations_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's severity from /workspace/documents/06_financing/046_financing_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/094_reconciliations_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's primary_source from /workspace/documents/06_financing/046_financing_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/094_reconciliations_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/06_financing/046_financing_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/094_reconciliations_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-16 using the exact controlled facts ['91 records', '2025-02-15', '44 records', '2025-03-03'].", "id": "findings.F-16.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-16's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-16.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-18', 'Lena Varga'] for F-16.", "id": "findings.F-16.action_anchors"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Executive assessment' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Executive assessment"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Method and record coverage' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Method and record coverage"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Findings' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Findings"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Recommended next actions' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Recommended next actions"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Assumptions and limitations' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Assumptions and limitations"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-01 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-01"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-02 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-02"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-03 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-03"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-04 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-04"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-05 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-05"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-06 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-06"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-07 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-07"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-08 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-08"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-09 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-09"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-10 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-10"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-11 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-11"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-12 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-12"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-13 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-13"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-14 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-14"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-15 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-15"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-16 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-16"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Do not claim the production has no issues or that every record is consistent.", "id": "memo.forbidden_claims_absent"}], "decision_options": [{"id": "cross-source-reconciliation", "label": "Reconcile controlling and corroborating records", "reason": "The CB-RS-2805 production contains independently maintained records; a defensible answer must preserve each supported conflict and its cure owner.", "selected": true}, {"id": "latest-record-controls", "label": "Treat the latest record as controlling", "reason": "Timestamp recency does not establish legal priority, execution, or approval authority.", "selected": false}, {"id": "primary-records-only", "label": "Report primary records without reconciliation", "reason": "Primary records alone conceal the operational conflicts that create the actionable exceptions.", "selected": false}], "gates": ["all_evidence_read_in_full", "chain_of_custody_metadata_checked", "findings_criteria_complete", "memo_criteria_complete", "deliverables_written_through_mcp"], "metadata_checks": 8, "metric": "weighted_criteria_score", "minimum_tool_calls": 46, "required_deliverables": ["findings.json", "advice.md"], "required_document_reads": 33, "type": "deterministic", "weights": {"findings": 0.55, "memo": 0.2, "procedure": 0.25}}, "task_id": "cb100-045-equinox-solar", "task_name": "Equinox Solar project claim reconciliation", "world_id": "counselbench-filesystem-mcp-v2"}
-{"context_files": ["task_files/cb100-046-foundry-foods/01_petition_schedules/001_petition_schedules_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-046-foundry-foods/01_petition_schedules/002_petition_schedules_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-046-foundry-foods/01_petition_schedules/003_petition_schedules_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-046-foundry-foods/01_petition_schedules/004_petition_schedules_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-046-foundry-foods/01_petition_schedules/005_petition_schedules_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-046-foundry-foods/01_petition_schedules/006_petition_schedules_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-046-foundry-foods/01_petition_schedules/007_petition_schedules_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-046-foundry-foods/01_petition_schedules/008_petition_schedules_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-046-foundry-foods/02_claims_register/009_claims_register_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-046-foundry-foods/02_claims_register/010_claims_register_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-046-foundry-foods/02_claims_register/011_claims_register_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-046-foundry-foods/02_claims_register/012_claims_register_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-046-foundry-foods/02_claims_register/013_claims_register_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-046-foundry-foods/02_claims_register/014_claims_register_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-046-foundry-foods/02_claims_register/015_claims_register_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-046-foundry-foods/02_claims_register/016_claims_register_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-046-foundry-foods/03_proofs_of_claim/017_proofs_of_claim_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-046-foundry-foods/03_proofs_of_claim/018_proofs_of_claim_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-046-foundry-foods/03_proofs_of_claim/019_proofs_of_claim_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-046-foundry-foods/03_proofs_of_claim/020_proofs_of_claim_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-046-foundry-foods/03_proofs_of_claim/021_proofs_of_claim_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-046-foundry-foods/03_proofs_of_claim/022_proofs_of_claim_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-046-foundry-foods/03_proofs_of_claim/023_proofs_of_claim_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-046-foundry-foods/03_proofs_of_claim/024_proofs_of_claim_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-046-foundry-foods/04_contracts_leases/025_contracts_leases_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-046-foundry-foods/04_contracts_leases/026_contracts_leases_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-046-foundry-foods/04_contracts_leases/027_contracts_leases_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-046-foundry-foods/04_contracts_leases/028_contracts_leases_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-046-foundry-foods/04_contracts_leases/029_contracts_leases_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-046-foundry-foods/04_contracts_leases/030_contracts_leases_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-046-foundry-foods/04_contracts_leases/031_contracts_leases_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-046-foundry-foods/04_contracts_leases/032_contracts_leases_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-046-foundry-foods/05_cash_management/033_cash_management_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-046-foundry-foods/05_cash_management/034_cash_management_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-046-foundry-foods/05_cash_management/035_cash_management_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-046-foundry-foods/05_cash_management/036_cash_management_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-046-foundry-foods/05_cash_management/037_cash_management_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-046-foundry-foods/05_cash_management/038_cash_management_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-046-foundry-foods/05_cash_management/039_cash_management_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-046-foundry-foods/05_cash_management/040_cash_management_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-046-foundry-foods/06_financing/041_financing_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-046-foundry-foods/06_financing/042_financing_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-046-foundry-foods/06_financing/043_financing_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-046-foundry-foods/06_financing/044_financing_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-046-foundry-foods/06_financing/045_financing_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-046-foundry-foods/06_financing/046_financing_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-046-foundry-foods/06_financing/047_financing_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-046-foundry-foods/06_financing/048_financing_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-046-foundry-foods/07_critical_vendors/049_critical_vendors_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-046-foundry-foods/07_critical_vendors/050_critical_vendors_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-046-foundry-foods/07_critical_vendors/051_critical_vendors_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-046-foundry-foods/07_critical_vendors/052_critical_vendors_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-046-foundry-foods/07_critical_vendors/053_critical_vendors_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-046-foundry-foods/07_critical_vendors/054_critical_vendors_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-046-foundry-foods/07_critical_vendors/055_critical_vendors_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-046-foundry-foods/07_critical_vendors/056_critical_vendors_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-046-foundry-foods/08_tax/057_tax_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-046-foundry-foods/08_tax/058_tax_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-046-foundry-foods/08_tax/059_tax_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-046-foundry-foods/08_tax/060_tax_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-046-foundry-foods/08_tax/061_tax_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-046-foundry-foods/08_tax/062_tax_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-046-foundry-foods/08_tax/063_tax_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-046-foundry-foods/08_tax/064_tax_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-046-foundry-foods/09_litigation/065_litigation_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-046-foundry-foods/09_litigation/066_litigation_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-046-foundry-foods/09_litigation/067_litigation_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-046-foundry-foods/09_litigation/068_litigation_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-046-foundry-foods/09_litigation/069_litigation_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-046-foundry-foods/09_litigation/070_litigation_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-046-foundry-foods/09_litigation/071_litigation_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-046-foundry-foods/09_litigation/072_litigation_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-046-foundry-foods/10_plan_disclosure/073_plan_disclosure_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-046-foundry-foods/10_plan_disclosure/074_plan_disclosure_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-046-foundry-foods/10_plan_disclosure/075_plan_disclosure_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-046-foundry-foods/10_plan_disclosure/076_plan_disclosure_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-046-foundry-foods/10_plan_disclosure/077_plan_disclosure_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-046-foundry-foods/10_plan_disclosure/078_plan_disclosure_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-046-foundry-foods/10_plan_disclosure/079_plan_disclosure_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-046-foundry-foods/10_plan_disclosure/080_plan_disclosure_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-046-foundry-foods/11_notices_ballots/081_notices_ballots_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-046-foundry-foods/11_notices_ballots/082_notices_ballots_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-046-foundry-foods/11_notices_ballots/083_notices_ballots_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-046-foundry-foods/11_notices_ballots/084_notices_ballots_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-046-foundry-foods/11_notices_ballots/085_notices_ballots_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-046-foundry-foods/11_notices_ballots/086_notices_ballots_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-046-foundry-foods/11_notices_ballots/087_notices_ballots_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-046-foundry-foods/11_notices_ballots/088_notices_ballots_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-046-foundry-foods/12_reconciliations/089_reconciliations_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-046-foundry-foods/12_reconciliations/090_reconciliations_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-046-foundry-foods/12_reconciliations/091_reconciliations_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-046-foundry-foods/12_reconciliations/092_reconciliations_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-046-foundry-foods/12_reconciliations/093_reconciliations_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-046-foundry-foods/12_reconciliations/094_reconciliations_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-046-foundry-foods/12_reconciliations/095_reconciliations_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-046-foundry-foods/12_reconciliations/096_reconciliations_status_report.md"], "gold_output": {"advice_markdown": "# Counsel advice — Foundry Foods vendor claim audit\n\n## Executive assessment\n\nFor Foundry Prepared Foods, Inc. matter CB-RS-2806, the review identified 16 source-supported exceptions requiring action before 2026-09-22. The assessment concerns Northland Cold Chain LLC and the supplied record for Minnesota.\n\n## Method and record coverage\n\nThe review inventoried all 96 production files, read the 33 controlling, corroborating, and control records, searched the email exports, and checked metadata for the designated chain-of-custody sample. Conclusions are limited to the synthetic production supplied for this benchmark matter.\n\n## Findings\n\n### F-01 — scheduled-claim mismatch (critical)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for scheduled-claim mismatch: one source states the operative date is 2026-02-09 under control reference CB-RS-2806-A142, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2026-02-25 under response reference CB-RS-2806-J103.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/001_petition_schedules_control_register.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/07_critical_vendors/049_critical_vendors_control_register.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-22, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Mei Whitaker.\n\n### F-02 — duplicate proof of claim (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for duplicate proof of claim: one source states the controlling amount is $6,060,563.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $6,307,626.00.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/004_petition_schedules_ledger_export.csv`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/07_critical_vendors/052_critical_vendors_ledger_export.csv`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-22, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Caleb Hassan.\n\n### F-03 — secured-status defect (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for secured-status defect: one source states approval is attributed to Dominic Alvarez as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Isaac Romero and contains no entry for Dominic Alvarez.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/007_petition_schedules_officer_certificate.html`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/07_critical_vendors/055_critical_vendors_officer_certificate.html`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-22, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Leona Park.\n\n### F-04 — priority classification error (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for priority classification error: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-RS-2806-D493, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-RS-2806-M476.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/02_claims_register/010_claims_register_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/08_tax/058_tax_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-22, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Isaac Romero.\n\n### F-05 — executory-contract cure dispute (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for executory-contract cure dispute: one source states the applicable location is District of Minnesota Bankruptcy Court, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to Minnesota operations outside District of Minnesota Bankruptcy Court.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/02_claims_register/013_claims_register_review_memorandum.json`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/08_tax/061_tax_review_memorandum.json`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-22, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Sofia Bennett.\n\n### F-06 — lease rejection deadline (low)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for lease rejection deadline: one source states the threshold is 14% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 18% and produced a different exception result.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/02_claims_register/016_claims_register_status_report.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/08_tax/064_tax_status_report.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-22, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Adrian Mensah.\n\n### F-07 — postpetition invoice (critical)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for postpetition invoice: one source states formal notice must use notices-foundry_prepared_foods_inc@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-northland_cold_chain_llc@example.test.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/019_proofs_of_claim_correspondence.eml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/09_litigation/067_litigation_correspondence.eml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-22, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Willa Novak.\n\n### F-08 — critical-vendor overstatement (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for critical-vendor overstatement: one source states the governed population contains 90 records through 2025-11-21, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 62 records through 2025-12-25.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/022_proofs_of_claim_formal_notice.xml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/09_litigation/070_litigation_formal_notice.xml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-22, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Theo Laurent.\n\n### F-09 — setoff assertion (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for setoff assertion: one source states the operative date is 2025-07-19 under control reference CB-RS-2806-I237, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2025-08-02 under response reference CB-RS-2806-R872.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/025_contracts_leases_control_register.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/10_plan_disclosure/073_plan_disclosure_control_register.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-22, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Amara Patel.\n\n### F-10 — guaranty overlap (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for guaranty overlap: one source states the controlling amount is $5,753,135.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $5,982,770.00.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/028_contracts_leases_ledger_export.csv`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/10_plan_disclosure/076_plan_disclosure_ledger_export.csv`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-22, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Henry Cho.\n\n### F-11 — tax priority period (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for tax priority period: one source states approval is attributed to Dominic Alvarez as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Dominic Alvarez and contains no entry for Dominic Alvarez.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/031_contracts_leases_officer_certificate.html`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/10_plan_disclosure/079_plan_disclosure_officer_certificate.html`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-22, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Nadine Flores.\n\n### F-12 — DIP budget variance (low)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for DIP budget variance: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-RS-2806-L298, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-RS-2806-U738.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/05_cash_management/034_cash_management_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/11_notices_ballots/082_notices_ballots_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-22, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Micah Sullivan.\n\n### F-13 — cash-collateral reporting gap (critical)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for cash-collateral reporting gap: one source states the applicable location is District of Minnesota Bankruptcy Court, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to Minnesota operations outside District of Minnesota Bankruptcy Court.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/05_cash_management/037_cash_management_review_memorandum.json`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/11_notices_ballots/085_notices_ballots_review_memorandum.json`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-22, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Farah Ibrahim.\n\n### F-14 — ballot amount discrepancy (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for ballot amount discrepancy: one source states the threshold is 2% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 4% and produced a different exception result.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/05_cash_management/040_cash_management_status_report.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/11_notices_ballots/088_notices_ballots_status_report.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-22, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Owen Delgado.\n\n### F-15 — notice-address defect (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for notice-address defect: one source states formal notice must use notices-foundry_prepared_foods_inc@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-northland_cold_chain_llc@example.test.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/06_financing/043_financing_correspondence.eml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/091_reconciliations_correspondence.eml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-22, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Lena Varga.\n\n### F-16 — reserve calculation error (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for reserve calculation error: one source states the governed population contains 136 records through 2025-08-19, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 57 records through 2025-09-17.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/06_financing/046_financing_formal_notice.xml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/094_reconciliations_formal_notice.xml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-22, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Samuel Kim.\n\n## Recommended next actions\n\nSequence the critical and high findings first, assign the named owners, preserve the cited records, and document any resolution in the controlling matter register before the stated deadline.\n\n## Assumptions and limitations\n\nThis analysis is confined to task cb100-046-foundry-foods and the supplied synthetic evidence. It does not rely on external facts, does not resolve disputed law, and is not legal advice for a real person or entity.\n", "findings": {"as_of": "2026-09-22", "findings": [{"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/07_critical_vendors/049_critical_vendors_control_register.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for scheduled-claim mismatch: one source states the operative date is 2026-02-09 under control reference CB-RS-2806-A142, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2026-02-25 under response reference CB-RS-2806-J103.", "id": "F-01", "issue": "scheduled-claim mismatch", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/001_petition_schedules_control_register.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-22, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Mei Whitaker.", "severity": "critical"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/07_critical_vendors/052_critical_vendors_ledger_export.csv", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for duplicate proof of claim: one source states the controlling amount is $6,060,563.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $6,307,626.00.", "id": "F-02", "issue": "duplicate proof of claim", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/004_petition_schedules_ledger_export.csv", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-22, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Caleb Hassan.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/07_critical_vendors/055_critical_vendors_officer_certificate.html", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for secured-status defect: one source states approval is attributed to Dominic Alvarez as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Isaac Romero and contains no entry for Dominic Alvarez.", "id": "F-03", "issue": "secured-status defect", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/007_petition_schedules_officer_certificate.html", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-22, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Leona Park.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/08_tax/058_tax_executed_instrument.txt", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for priority classification error: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-RS-2806-D493, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-RS-2806-M476.", "id": "F-04", "issue": "priority classification error", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/02_claims_register/010_claims_register_executed_instrument.txt", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-22, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Isaac Romero.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/08_tax/061_tax_review_memorandum.json", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for executory-contract cure dispute: one source states the applicable location is District of Minnesota Bankruptcy Court, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to Minnesota operations outside District of Minnesota Bankruptcy Court.", "id": "F-05", "issue": "executory-contract cure dispute", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/02_claims_register/013_claims_register_review_memorandum.json", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-22, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Sofia Bennett.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/08_tax/064_tax_status_report.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for lease rejection deadline: one source states the threshold is 14% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 18% and produced a different exception result.", "id": "F-06", "issue": "lease rejection deadline", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/02_claims_register/016_claims_register_status_report.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-22, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Adrian Mensah.", "severity": "low"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/09_litigation/067_litigation_correspondence.eml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for postpetition invoice: one source states formal notice must use notices-foundry_prepared_foods_inc@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-northland_cold_chain_llc@example.test.", "id": "F-07", "issue": "postpetition invoice", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/019_proofs_of_claim_correspondence.eml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-22, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Willa Novak.", "severity": "critical"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/09_litigation/070_litigation_formal_notice.xml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for critical-vendor overstatement: one source states the governed population contains 90 records through 2025-11-21, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 62 records through 2025-12-25.", "id": "F-08", "issue": "critical-vendor overstatement", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/022_proofs_of_claim_formal_notice.xml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-22, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Theo Laurent.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/10_plan_disclosure/073_plan_disclosure_control_register.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for setoff assertion: one source states the operative date is 2025-07-19 under control reference CB-RS-2806-I237, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2025-08-02 under response reference CB-RS-2806-R872.", "id": "F-09", "issue": "setoff assertion", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/025_contracts_leases_control_register.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-22, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Amara Patel.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/10_plan_disclosure/076_plan_disclosure_ledger_export.csv", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for guaranty overlap: one source states the controlling amount is $5,753,135.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $5,982,770.00.", "id": "F-10", "issue": "guaranty overlap", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/028_contracts_leases_ledger_export.csv", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-22, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Henry Cho.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/10_plan_disclosure/079_plan_disclosure_officer_certificate.html", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for tax priority period: one source states approval is attributed to Dominic Alvarez as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Dominic Alvarez and contains no entry for Dominic Alvarez.", "id": "F-11", "issue": "tax priority period", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/031_contracts_leases_officer_certificate.html", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-22, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Nadine Flores.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/11_notices_ballots/082_notices_ballots_executed_instrument.txt", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for DIP budget variance: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-RS-2806-L298, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-RS-2806-U738.", "id": "F-12", "issue": "DIP budget variance", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/05_cash_management/034_cash_management_executed_instrument.txt", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-22, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Micah Sullivan.", "severity": "low"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/11_notices_ballots/085_notices_ballots_review_memorandum.json", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for cash-collateral reporting gap: one source states the applicable location is District of Minnesota Bankruptcy Court, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to Minnesota operations outside District of Minnesota Bankruptcy Court.", "id": "F-13", "issue": "cash-collateral reporting gap", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/05_cash_management/037_cash_management_review_memorandum.json", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-22, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Farah Ibrahim.", "severity": "critical"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/11_notices_ballots/088_notices_ballots_status_report.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for ballot amount discrepancy: one source states the threshold is 2% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 4% and produced a different exception result.", "id": "F-14", "issue": "ballot amount discrepancy", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/05_cash_management/040_cash_management_status_report.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-22, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Owen Delgado.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/091_reconciliations_correspondence.eml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for notice-address defect: one source states formal notice must use notices-foundry_prepared_foods_inc@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-northland_cold_chain_llc@example.test.", "id": "F-15", "issue": "notice-address defect", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/06_financing/043_financing_correspondence.eml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-22, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Lena Varga.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/094_reconciliations_formal_notice.xml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for reserve calculation error: one source states the governed population contains 136 records through 2025-08-19, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 57 records through 2025-09-17.", "id": "F-16", "issue": "reserve calculation error", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/06_financing/046_financing_formal_notice.xml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-22, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Samuel Kim.", "severity": "medium"}], "matter_number": "CB-RS-2806", "prepared_for": "Foundry Prepared Foods, Inc.", "schema_version": "1.0", "task_id": "cb100-046-foundry-foods"}}, "metadata": {"benchmark": "CounselBench-100", "code_license": "Apache-2.0", "data_license": "CC-BY-4.0", "deadline": "2026-09-22", "document_count": 96, "jurisdiction": "Minnesota", "matter_number": "CB-RS-2806", "mcp_commit": "9a96ea6e5913736f92b88345bf51caeaaa8e719f", "mcp_package": "@modelcontextprotocol/server-filesystem@2026.7.10", "practice_area": "restructuring", "reference_tool_calls": 46, "required_evidence_reads": 33, "synthetic": true, "venue": "District of Minnesota Bankruptcy Court", "version": "2.0.0"}, "prompt": "You are debtor-side restructuring counsel for Foundry Prepared Foods, Inc. The upcoming deadline leaves no room for unsupported assumptions, so every conclusion must trace to the supplied production. Cold-storage invoices straddle the petition date, critical-vendor payments overlap claims, and cure schedules use stale balances. Decision due 2026-09-22. Minnesota law governs; District of Minnesota Bankruptcy Court is the forum. Give controlling documents precedence only when the record supports that hierarchy. Work out the defensible position from the matter production and leave an audit-ready exception tracker and concise advice for the supervising lawyer. Keep confirmed conflicts separate from open questions, cite the records that actually control each conclusion, and do not fill gaps with outside facts.", "rubric": {"criteria": [{"category": "procedure", "description": "Complete at least 46 successful, argument-specific evidence and output calls.", "id": "procedure.minimum_successful_tool_calls"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Find and read the 33 controlling, corroborating, and work-product-control records in full.", "id": "procedure.all_evidence_read_in_full"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Inspect file metadata for the eight designated critical primary records before relying on them.", "id": "procedure.chain_of_custody_metadata_checked"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Confirm the sandbox's allowed document and output roots.", "id": "procedure.allowed_directories_checked"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Inventory all 96 records so the relevant sources are discovered among the context records.", "id": "procedure.recursive_inventory_completed"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Search the production for email evidence that may corroborate or contradict formal records.", "id": "procedure.targeted_search_completed"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Leave only findings.json and advice.md in the output workspace.", "id": "procedure.exact_deliverable_set"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Create both final work products through the sandbox MCP surface.", "id": "procedure.deliverables_written_through_mcp"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Produce findings.json as a valid JSON object.", "id": "findings.findings_is_object"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Report exactly 16 confirmed exceptions.", "id": "findings.findings_exact_count"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Use each stable finding ID exactly once.", "id": "findings.finding_ids_unique"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set schema_version to the released matter value '1.0'.", "id": "findings.top_level_schema_version"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set task_id to the released matter value 'cb100-046-foundry-foods'.", "id": "findings.top_level_task_id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set matter_number to the released matter value 'CB-RS-2806'.", "id": "findings.top_level_matter_number"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set prepared_for to the released matter value 'Foundry Prepared Foods, Inc.'.", "id": "findings.top_level_prepared_for"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set as_of to the released matter value '2026-09-22'.", "id": "findings.top_level_as_of"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-01 exception for scheduled-claim mismatch.", "id": "findings.F-01.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's id from /workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/001_petition_schedules_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_critical_vendors/049_critical_vendors_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's issue from /workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/001_petition_schedules_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_critical_vendors/049_critical_vendors_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's severity from /workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/001_petition_schedules_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_critical_vendors/049_critical_vendors_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's primary_source from /workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/001_petition_schedules_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_critical_vendors/049_critical_vendors_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/001_petition_schedules_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_critical_vendors/049_critical_vendors_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-01 using the exact controlled facts ['2026-02-09', 'CB-RS-2806-A142', '2026-02-25', 'CB-RS-2806-J103'].", "id": "findings.F-01.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-01's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-01.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-22', 'Mei Whitaker'] for F-01.", "id": "findings.F-01.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-02 exception for duplicate proof of claim.", "id": "findings.F-02.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's id from /workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/004_petition_schedules_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_critical_vendors/052_critical_vendors_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's issue from /workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/004_petition_schedules_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_critical_vendors/052_critical_vendors_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's severity from /workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/004_petition_schedules_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_critical_vendors/052_critical_vendors_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's primary_source from /workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/004_petition_schedules_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_critical_vendors/052_critical_vendors_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/004_petition_schedules_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_critical_vendors/052_critical_vendors_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-02 using the exact controlled facts ['$6,060,563.00', '$6,307,626.00'].", "id": "findings.F-02.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-02's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-02.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-22', 'Caleb Hassan'] for F-02.", "id": "findings.F-02.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-03 exception for secured-status defect.", "id": "findings.F-03.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's id from /workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/007_petition_schedules_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_critical_vendors/055_critical_vendors_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's issue from /workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/007_petition_schedules_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_critical_vendors/055_critical_vendors_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's severity from /workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/007_petition_schedules_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_critical_vendors/055_critical_vendors_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's primary_source from /workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/007_petition_schedules_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_critical_vendors/055_critical_vendors_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/007_petition_schedules_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_critical_vendors/055_critical_vendors_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-03 using the exact controlled facts ['Dominic Alvarez', 'Isaac Romero'].", "id": "findings.F-03.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-03's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-03.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-22', 'Leona Park'] for F-03.", "id": "findings.F-03.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-04 exception for priority classification error.", "id": "findings.F-04.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's id from /workspace/documents/02_claims_register/010_claims_register_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_tax/058_tax_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's issue from /workspace/documents/02_claims_register/010_claims_register_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_tax/058_tax_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's severity from /workspace/documents/02_claims_register/010_claims_register_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_tax/058_tax_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's primary_source from /workspace/documents/02_claims_register/010_claims_register_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_tax/058_tax_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/02_claims_register/010_claims_register_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_tax/058_tax_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-04 using the exact controlled facts ['closed without exception', 'CB-RS-2806-D493', 'open and escalated', 'CB-RS-2806-M476'].", "id": "findings.F-04.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-04's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-04.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-22', 'Isaac Romero'] for F-04.", "id": "findings.F-04.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-05 exception for executory-contract cure dispute.", "id": "findings.F-05.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's id from /workspace/documents/02_claims_register/013_claims_register_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_tax/061_tax_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's issue from /workspace/documents/02_claims_register/013_claims_register_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_tax/061_tax_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's severity from /workspace/documents/02_claims_register/013_claims_register_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_tax/061_tax_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's primary_source from /workspace/documents/02_claims_register/013_claims_register_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_tax/061_tax_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/02_claims_register/013_claims_register_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_tax/061_tax_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-05 using the exact controlled facts ['District of Minnesota Bankruptcy Court', 'Minnesota'].", "id": "findings.F-05.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-05's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-05.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-22', 'Sofia Bennett'] for F-05.", "id": "findings.F-05.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-06 exception for lease rejection deadline.", "id": "findings.F-06.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's id from /workspace/documents/02_claims_register/016_claims_register_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_tax/064_tax_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's issue from /workspace/documents/02_claims_register/016_claims_register_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_tax/064_tax_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's severity from /workspace/documents/02_claims_register/016_claims_register_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_tax/064_tax_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's primary_source from /workspace/documents/02_claims_register/016_claims_register_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_tax/064_tax_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/02_claims_register/016_claims_register_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_tax/064_tax_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-06 using the exact controlled facts ['14%', '18%'].", "id": "findings.F-06.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-06's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-06.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-22', 'Adrian Mensah'] for F-06.", "id": "findings.F-06.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-07 exception for postpetition invoice.", "id": "findings.F-07.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's id from /workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/019_proofs_of_claim_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_litigation/067_litigation_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's issue from /workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/019_proofs_of_claim_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_litigation/067_litigation_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's severity from /workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/019_proofs_of_claim_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_litigation/067_litigation_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's primary_source from /workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/019_proofs_of_claim_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_litigation/067_litigation_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/019_proofs_of_claim_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_litigation/067_litigation_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-07 using the exact controlled facts ['notices-foundry_prepared_foods_inc@example.test', 'archive-northland_cold_chain_llc@example.test'].", "id": "findings.F-07.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-07's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-07.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-22', 'Willa Novak'] for F-07.", "id": "findings.F-07.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-08 exception for critical-vendor overstatement.", "id": "findings.F-08.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's id from /workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/022_proofs_of_claim_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_litigation/070_litigation_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's issue from /workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/022_proofs_of_claim_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_litigation/070_litigation_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's severity from /workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/022_proofs_of_claim_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_litigation/070_litigation_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's primary_source from /workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/022_proofs_of_claim_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_litigation/070_litigation_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/022_proofs_of_claim_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_litigation/070_litigation_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-08 using the exact controlled facts ['90 records', '2025-11-21', '62 records', '2025-12-25'].", "id": "findings.F-08.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-08's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-08.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-22', 'Theo Laurent'] for F-08.", "id": "findings.F-08.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-09 exception for setoff assertion.", "id": "findings.F-09.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's id from /workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/025_contracts_leases_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_plan_disclosure/073_plan_disclosure_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's issue from /workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/025_contracts_leases_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_plan_disclosure/073_plan_disclosure_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's severity from /workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/025_contracts_leases_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_plan_disclosure/073_plan_disclosure_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's primary_source from /workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/025_contracts_leases_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_plan_disclosure/073_plan_disclosure_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/025_contracts_leases_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_plan_disclosure/073_plan_disclosure_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-09 using the exact controlled facts ['2025-07-19', 'CB-RS-2806-I237', '2025-08-02', 'CB-RS-2806-R872'].", "id": "findings.F-09.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-09's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-09.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-22', 'Amara Patel'] for F-09.", "id": "findings.F-09.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-10 exception for guaranty overlap.", "id": "findings.F-10.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's id from /workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/028_contracts_leases_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_plan_disclosure/076_plan_disclosure_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's issue from /workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/028_contracts_leases_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_plan_disclosure/076_plan_disclosure_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's severity from /workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/028_contracts_leases_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_plan_disclosure/076_plan_disclosure_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's primary_source from /workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/028_contracts_leases_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_plan_disclosure/076_plan_disclosure_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/028_contracts_leases_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_plan_disclosure/076_plan_disclosure_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-10 using the exact controlled facts ['$5,753,135.00', '$5,982,770.00'].", "id": "findings.F-10.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-10's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-10.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-22', 'Henry Cho'] for F-10.", "id": "findings.F-10.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-11 exception for tax priority period.", "id": "findings.F-11.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's id from /workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/031_contracts_leases_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_plan_disclosure/079_plan_disclosure_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's issue from /workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/031_contracts_leases_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_plan_disclosure/079_plan_disclosure_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's severity from /workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/031_contracts_leases_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_plan_disclosure/079_plan_disclosure_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's primary_source from /workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/031_contracts_leases_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_plan_disclosure/079_plan_disclosure_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/031_contracts_leases_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_plan_disclosure/079_plan_disclosure_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-11 using the exact controlled facts ['Dominic Alvarez', 'Dominic Alvarez'].", "id": "findings.F-11.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-11's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-11.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-22', 'Nadine Flores'] for F-11.", "id": "findings.F-11.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-12 exception for DIP budget variance.", "id": "findings.F-12.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's id from /workspace/documents/05_cash_management/034_cash_management_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_notices_ballots/082_notices_ballots_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's issue from /workspace/documents/05_cash_management/034_cash_management_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_notices_ballots/082_notices_ballots_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's severity from /workspace/documents/05_cash_management/034_cash_management_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_notices_ballots/082_notices_ballots_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's primary_source from /workspace/documents/05_cash_management/034_cash_management_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_notices_ballots/082_notices_ballots_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/05_cash_management/034_cash_management_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_notices_ballots/082_notices_ballots_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-12 using the exact controlled facts ['closed without exception', 'CB-RS-2806-L298', 'open and escalated', 'CB-RS-2806-U738'].", "id": "findings.F-12.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-12's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-12.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-22', 'Micah Sullivan'] for F-12.", "id": "findings.F-12.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-13 exception for cash-collateral reporting gap.", "id": "findings.F-13.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's id from /workspace/documents/05_cash_management/037_cash_management_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_notices_ballots/085_notices_ballots_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's issue from /workspace/documents/05_cash_management/037_cash_management_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_notices_ballots/085_notices_ballots_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's severity from /workspace/documents/05_cash_management/037_cash_management_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_notices_ballots/085_notices_ballots_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's primary_source from /workspace/documents/05_cash_management/037_cash_management_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_notices_ballots/085_notices_ballots_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/05_cash_management/037_cash_management_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_notices_ballots/085_notices_ballots_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-13 using the exact controlled facts ['District of Minnesota Bankruptcy Court', 'Minnesota'].", "id": "findings.F-13.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-13's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-13.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-22', 'Farah Ibrahim'] for F-13.", "id": "findings.F-13.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-14 exception for ballot amount discrepancy.", "id": "findings.F-14.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's id from /workspace/documents/05_cash_management/040_cash_management_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_notices_ballots/088_notices_ballots_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's issue from /workspace/documents/05_cash_management/040_cash_management_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_notices_ballots/088_notices_ballots_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's severity from /workspace/documents/05_cash_management/040_cash_management_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_notices_ballots/088_notices_ballots_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's primary_source from /workspace/documents/05_cash_management/040_cash_management_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_notices_ballots/088_notices_ballots_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/05_cash_management/040_cash_management_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_notices_ballots/088_notices_ballots_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-14 using the exact controlled facts ['2%', '4%'].", "id": "findings.F-14.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-14's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-14.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-22', 'Owen Delgado'] for F-14.", "id": "findings.F-14.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-15 exception for notice-address defect.", "id": "findings.F-15.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's id from /workspace/documents/06_financing/043_financing_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/091_reconciliations_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's issue from /workspace/documents/06_financing/043_financing_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/091_reconciliations_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's severity from /workspace/documents/06_financing/043_financing_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/091_reconciliations_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's primary_source from /workspace/documents/06_financing/043_financing_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/091_reconciliations_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/06_financing/043_financing_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/091_reconciliations_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-15 using the exact controlled facts ['notices-foundry_prepared_foods_inc@example.test', 'archive-northland_cold_chain_llc@example.test'].", "id": "findings.F-15.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-15's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-15.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-22', 'Lena Varga'] for F-15.", "id": "findings.F-15.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-16 exception for reserve calculation error.", "id": "findings.F-16.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's id from /workspace/documents/06_financing/046_financing_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/094_reconciliations_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's issue from /workspace/documents/06_financing/046_financing_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/094_reconciliations_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's severity from /workspace/documents/06_financing/046_financing_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/094_reconciliations_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's primary_source from /workspace/documents/06_financing/046_financing_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/094_reconciliations_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/06_financing/046_financing_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/094_reconciliations_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-16 using the exact controlled facts ['136 records', '2025-08-19', '57 records', '2025-09-17'].", "id": "findings.F-16.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-16's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-16.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-22', 'Samuel Kim'] for F-16.", "id": "findings.F-16.action_anchors"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Executive assessment' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Executive assessment"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Method and record coverage' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Method and record coverage"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Findings' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Findings"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Recommended next actions' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Recommended next actions"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Assumptions and limitations' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Assumptions and limitations"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-01 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-01"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-02 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-02"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-03 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-03"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-04 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-04"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-05 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-05"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-06 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-06"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-07 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-07"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-08 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-08"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-09 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-09"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-10 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-10"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-11 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-11"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-12 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-12"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-13 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-13"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-14 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-14"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-15 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-15"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-16 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-16"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Do not claim the production has no issues or that every record is consistent.", "id": "memo.forbidden_claims_absent"}], "decision_options": [{"id": "cross-source-reconciliation", "label": "Reconcile controlling and corroborating records", "reason": "The CB-RS-2806 production contains independently maintained records; a defensible answer must preserve each supported conflict and its cure owner.", "selected": true}, {"id": "latest-record-controls", "label": "Treat the latest record as controlling", "reason": "Timestamp recency does not establish legal priority, execution, or approval authority.", "selected": false}, {"id": "primary-records-only", "label": "Report primary records without reconciliation", "reason": "Primary records alone conceal the operational conflicts that create the actionable exceptions.", "selected": false}], "gates": ["all_evidence_read_in_full", "chain_of_custody_metadata_checked", "findings_criteria_complete", "memo_criteria_complete", "deliverables_written_through_mcp"], "metadata_checks": 8, "metric": "weighted_criteria_score", "minimum_tool_calls": 46, "required_deliverables": ["findings.json", "advice.md"], "required_document_reads": 33, "type": "deterministic", "weights": {"findings": 0.55, "memo": 0.2, "procedure": 0.25}}, "task_id": "cb100-046-foundry-foods", "task_name": "Foundry Foods vendor claim audit", "world_id": "counselbench-filesystem-mcp-v2"}
-{"context_files": ["task_files/cb100-047-greenway-transit/01_petition_schedules/001_petition_schedules_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-047-greenway-transit/01_petition_schedules/002_petition_schedules_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-047-greenway-transit/01_petition_schedules/003_petition_schedules_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-047-greenway-transit/01_petition_schedules/004_petition_schedules_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-047-greenway-transit/01_petition_schedules/005_petition_schedules_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-047-greenway-transit/01_petition_schedules/006_petition_schedules_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-047-greenway-transit/01_petition_schedules/007_petition_schedules_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-047-greenway-transit/01_petition_schedules/008_petition_schedules_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-047-greenway-transit/02_claims_register/009_claims_register_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-047-greenway-transit/02_claims_register/010_claims_register_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-047-greenway-transit/02_claims_register/011_claims_register_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-047-greenway-transit/02_claims_register/012_claims_register_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-047-greenway-transit/02_claims_register/013_claims_register_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-047-greenway-transit/02_claims_register/014_claims_register_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-047-greenway-transit/02_claims_register/015_claims_register_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-047-greenway-transit/02_claims_register/016_claims_register_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-047-greenway-transit/03_proofs_of_claim/017_proofs_of_claim_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-047-greenway-transit/03_proofs_of_claim/018_proofs_of_claim_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-047-greenway-transit/03_proofs_of_claim/019_proofs_of_claim_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-047-greenway-transit/03_proofs_of_claim/020_proofs_of_claim_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-047-greenway-transit/03_proofs_of_claim/021_proofs_of_claim_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-047-greenway-transit/03_proofs_of_claim/022_proofs_of_claim_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-047-greenway-transit/03_proofs_of_claim/023_proofs_of_claim_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-047-greenway-transit/03_proofs_of_claim/024_proofs_of_claim_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-047-greenway-transit/04_contracts_leases/025_contracts_leases_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-047-greenway-transit/04_contracts_leases/026_contracts_leases_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-047-greenway-transit/04_contracts_leases/027_contracts_leases_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-047-greenway-transit/04_contracts_leases/028_contracts_leases_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-047-greenway-transit/04_contracts_leases/029_contracts_leases_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-047-greenway-transit/04_contracts_leases/030_contracts_leases_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-047-greenway-transit/04_contracts_leases/031_contracts_leases_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-047-greenway-transit/04_contracts_leases/032_contracts_leases_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-047-greenway-transit/05_cash_management/033_cash_management_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-047-greenway-transit/05_cash_management/034_cash_management_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-047-greenway-transit/05_cash_management/035_cash_management_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-047-greenway-transit/05_cash_management/036_cash_management_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-047-greenway-transit/05_cash_management/037_cash_management_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-047-greenway-transit/05_cash_management/038_cash_management_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-047-greenway-transit/05_cash_management/039_cash_management_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-047-greenway-transit/05_cash_management/040_cash_management_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-047-greenway-transit/06_financing/041_financing_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-047-greenway-transit/06_financing/042_financing_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-047-greenway-transit/06_financing/043_financing_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-047-greenway-transit/06_financing/044_financing_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-047-greenway-transit/06_financing/045_financing_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-047-greenway-transit/06_financing/046_financing_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-047-greenway-transit/06_financing/047_financing_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-047-greenway-transit/06_financing/048_financing_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-047-greenway-transit/07_critical_vendors/049_critical_vendors_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-047-greenway-transit/07_critical_vendors/050_critical_vendors_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-047-greenway-transit/07_critical_vendors/051_critical_vendors_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-047-greenway-transit/07_critical_vendors/052_critical_vendors_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-047-greenway-transit/07_critical_vendors/053_critical_vendors_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-047-greenway-transit/07_critical_vendors/054_critical_vendors_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-047-greenway-transit/07_critical_vendors/055_critical_vendors_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-047-greenway-transit/07_critical_vendors/056_critical_vendors_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-047-greenway-transit/08_tax/057_tax_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-047-greenway-transit/08_tax/058_tax_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-047-greenway-transit/08_tax/059_tax_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-047-greenway-transit/08_tax/060_tax_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-047-greenway-transit/08_tax/061_tax_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-047-greenway-transit/08_tax/062_tax_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-047-greenway-transit/08_tax/063_tax_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-047-greenway-transit/08_tax/064_tax_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-047-greenway-transit/09_litigation/065_litigation_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-047-greenway-transit/09_litigation/066_litigation_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-047-greenway-transit/09_litigation/067_litigation_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-047-greenway-transit/09_litigation/068_litigation_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-047-greenway-transit/09_litigation/069_litigation_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-047-greenway-transit/09_litigation/070_litigation_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-047-greenway-transit/09_litigation/071_litigation_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-047-greenway-transit/09_litigation/072_litigation_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-047-greenway-transit/10_plan_disclosure/073_plan_disclosure_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-047-greenway-transit/10_plan_disclosure/074_plan_disclosure_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-047-greenway-transit/10_plan_disclosure/075_plan_disclosure_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-047-greenway-transit/10_plan_disclosure/076_plan_disclosure_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-047-greenway-transit/10_plan_disclosure/077_plan_disclosure_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-047-greenway-transit/10_plan_disclosure/078_plan_disclosure_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-047-greenway-transit/10_plan_disclosure/079_plan_disclosure_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-047-greenway-transit/10_plan_disclosure/080_plan_disclosure_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-047-greenway-transit/11_notices_ballots/081_notices_ballots_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-047-greenway-transit/11_notices_ballots/082_notices_ballots_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-047-greenway-transit/11_notices_ballots/083_notices_ballots_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-047-greenway-transit/11_notices_ballots/084_notices_ballots_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-047-greenway-transit/11_notices_ballots/085_notices_ballots_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-047-greenway-transit/11_notices_ballots/086_notices_ballots_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-047-greenway-transit/11_notices_ballots/087_notices_ballots_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-047-greenway-transit/11_notices_ballots/088_notices_ballots_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-047-greenway-transit/12_reconciliations/089_reconciliations_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-047-greenway-transit/12_reconciliations/090_reconciliations_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-047-greenway-transit/12_reconciliations/091_reconciliations_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-047-greenway-transit/12_reconciliations/092_reconciliations_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-047-greenway-transit/12_reconciliations/093_reconciliations_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-047-greenway-transit/12_reconciliations/094_reconciliations_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-047-greenway-transit/12_reconciliations/095_reconciliations_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-047-greenway-transit/12_reconciliations/096_reconciliations_status_report.md"], "gold_output": {"advice_markdown": "# Counsel advice — Greenway Transit plan claim review\n\n## Executive assessment\n\nFor Greenway Transit Services matter CB-RS-2807, the review identified 16 source-supported exceptions requiring action before 2026-09-25. The assessment concerns Metro Fleet Finance and the supplied record for Illinois.\n\n## Method and record coverage\n\nThe review inventoried all 96 production files, read the 33 controlling, corroborating, and control records, searched the email exports, and checked metadata for the designated chain-of-custody sample. Conclusions are limited to the synthetic production supplied for this benchmark matter.\n\n## Findings\n\n### F-01 — scheduled-claim mismatch (critical)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for scheduled-claim mismatch: one source states the operative date is 2025-07-18 under control reference CB-RS-2807-A956, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2025-08-07 under response reference CB-RS-2807-J650.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/001_petition_schedules_control_register.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/07_critical_vendors/049_critical_vendors_control_register.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-25, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Caleb Hassan.\n\n### F-02 — duplicate proof of claim (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for duplicate proof of claim: one source states the controlling amount is $1,782,168.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $1,850,836.00.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/004_petition_schedules_ledger_export.csv`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/07_critical_vendors/052_critical_vendors_ledger_export.csv`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-25, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Leona Park.\n\n### F-03 — secured-status defect (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for secured-status defect: one source states approval is attributed to Priya Raman as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Adrian Mensah and contains no entry for Priya Raman.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/007_petition_schedules_officer_certificate.html`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/07_critical_vendors/055_critical_vendors_officer_certificate.html`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-25, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Isaac Romero.\n\n### F-04 — priority classification error (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for priority classification error: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-RS-2807-D733, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-RS-2807-M564.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/02_claims_register/010_claims_register_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/08_tax/058_tax_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-25, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Sofia Bennett.\n\n### F-05 — executory-contract cure dispute (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for executory-contract cure dispute: one source states the applicable location is Northern District of Illinois Bankruptcy Court, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to Illinois operations outside Northern District of Illinois Bankruptcy Court.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/02_claims_register/013_claims_register_review_memorandum.json`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/08_tax/061_tax_review_memorandum.json`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-25, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Adrian Mensah.\n\n### F-06 — lease rejection deadline (low)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for lease rejection deadline: one source states the threshold is 8% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 10% and produced a different exception result.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/02_claims_register/016_claims_register_status_report.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/08_tax/064_tax_status_report.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-25, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Willa Novak.\n\n### F-07 — postpetition invoice (critical)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for postpetition invoice: one source states formal notice must use notices-greenway_transit_services@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-metro_fleet_finance@example.test.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/019_proofs_of_claim_correspondence.eml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/09_litigation/067_litigation_correspondence.eml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-25, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Theo Laurent.\n\n### F-08 — critical-vendor overstatement (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for critical-vendor overstatement: one source states the governed population contains 129 records through 2025-12-30, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 49 records through 2026-01-20.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/022_proofs_of_claim_formal_notice.xml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/09_litigation/070_litigation_formal_notice.xml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-25, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Amara Patel.\n\n### F-09 — setoff assertion (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for setoff assertion: one source states the operative date is 2025-04-17 under control reference CB-RS-2807-I444, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2025-05-20 under response reference CB-RS-2807-R334.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/025_contracts_leases_control_register.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/10_plan_disclosure/073_plan_disclosure_control_register.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-25, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Henry Cho.\n\n### F-10 — guaranty overlap (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for guaranty overlap: one source states the controlling amount is $5,098,056.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $5,202,612.00.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/028_contracts_leases_ledger_export.csv`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/10_plan_disclosure/076_plan_disclosure_ledger_export.csv`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-25, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Nadine Flores.\n\n### F-11 — tax priority period (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for tax priority period: one source states approval is attributed to Priya Raman as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Elliot Mercer and contains no entry for Priya Raman.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/031_contracts_leases_officer_certificate.html`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/10_plan_disclosure/079_plan_disclosure_officer_certificate.html`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-25, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Micah Sullivan.\n\n### F-12 — DIP budget variance (low)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for DIP budget variance: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-RS-2807-L767, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-RS-2807-U151.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/05_cash_management/034_cash_management_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/11_notices_ballots/082_notices_ballots_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-25, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Farah Ibrahim.\n\n### F-13 — cash-collateral reporting gap (critical)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for cash-collateral reporting gap: one source states the applicable location is Northern District of Illinois Bankruptcy Court, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to Illinois operations outside Northern District of Illinois Bankruptcy Court.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/05_cash_management/037_cash_management_review_memorandum.json`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/11_notices_ballots/085_notices_ballots_review_memorandum.json`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-25, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Owen Delgado.\n\n### F-14 — ballot amount discrepancy (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for ballot amount discrepancy: one source states the threshold is 11% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 14% and produced a different exception result.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/05_cash_management/040_cash_management_status_report.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/11_notices_ballots/088_notices_ballots_status_report.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-25, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Lena Varga.\n\n### F-15 — notice-address defect (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for notice-address defect: one source states formal notice must use notices-greenway_transit_services@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-metro_fleet_finance@example.test.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/06_financing/043_financing_correspondence.eml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/091_reconciliations_correspondence.eml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-25, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Samuel Kim.\n\n### F-16 — reserve calculation error (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for reserve calculation error: one source states the governed population contains 163 records through 2026-02-02, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 63 records through 2026-03-09.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/06_financing/046_financing_formal_notice.xml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/094_reconciliations_formal_notice.xml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-25, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Maya Ellison.\n\n## Recommended next actions\n\nSequence the critical and high findings first, assign the named owners, preserve the cited records, and document any resolution in the controlling matter register before the stated deadline.\n\n## Assumptions and limitations\n\nThis analysis is confined to task cb100-047-greenway-transit and the supplied synthetic evidence. It does not rely on external facts, does not resolve disputed law, and is not legal advice for a real person or entity.\n", "findings": {"as_of": "2026-09-25", "findings": [{"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/07_critical_vendors/049_critical_vendors_control_register.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for scheduled-claim mismatch: one source states the operative date is 2025-07-18 under control reference CB-RS-2807-A956, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2025-08-07 under response reference CB-RS-2807-J650.", "id": "F-01", "issue": "scheduled-claim mismatch", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/001_petition_schedules_control_register.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-25, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Caleb Hassan.", "severity": "critical"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/07_critical_vendors/052_critical_vendors_ledger_export.csv", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for duplicate proof of claim: one source states the controlling amount is $1,782,168.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $1,850,836.00.", "id": "F-02", "issue": "duplicate proof of claim", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/004_petition_schedules_ledger_export.csv", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-25, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Leona Park.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/07_critical_vendors/055_critical_vendors_officer_certificate.html", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for secured-status defect: one source states approval is attributed to Priya Raman as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Adrian Mensah and contains no entry for Priya Raman.", "id": "F-03", "issue": "secured-status defect", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/007_petition_schedules_officer_certificate.html", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-25, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Isaac Romero.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/08_tax/058_tax_executed_instrument.txt", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for priority classification error: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-RS-2807-D733, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-RS-2807-M564.", "id": "F-04", "issue": "priority classification error", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/02_claims_register/010_claims_register_executed_instrument.txt", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-25, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Sofia Bennett.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/08_tax/061_tax_review_memorandum.json", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for executory-contract cure dispute: one source states the applicable location is Northern District of Illinois Bankruptcy Court, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to Illinois operations outside Northern District of Illinois Bankruptcy Court.", "id": "F-05", "issue": "executory-contract cure dispute", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/02_claims_register/013_claims_register_review_memorandum.json", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-25, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Adrian Mensah.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/08_tax/064_tax_status_report.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for lease rejection deadline: one source states the threshold is 8% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 10% and produced a different exception result.", "id": "F-06", "issue": "lease rejection deadline", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/02_claims_register/016_claims_register_status_report.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-25, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Willa Novak.", "severity": "low"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/09_litigation/067_litigation_correspondence.eml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for postpetition invoice: one source states formal notice must use notices-greenway_transit_services@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-metro_fleet_finance@example.test.", "id": "F-07", "issue": "postpetition invoice", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/019_proofs_of_claim_correspondence.eml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-25, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Theo Laurent.", "severity": "critical"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/09_litigation/070_litigation_formal_notice.xml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for critical-vendor overstatement: one source states the governed population contains 129 records through 2025-12-30, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 49 records through 2026-01-20.", "id": "F-08", "issue": "critical-vendor overstatement", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/022_proofs_of_claim_formal_notice.xml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-25, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Amara Patel.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/10_plan_disclosure/073_plan_disclosure_control_register.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for setoff assertion: one source states the operative date is 2025-04-17 under control reference CB-RS-2807-I444, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2025-05-20 under response reference CB-RS-2807-R334.", "id": "F-09", "issue": "setoff assertion", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/025_contracts_leases_control_register.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-25, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Henry Cho.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/10_plan_disclosure/076_plan_disclosure_ledger_export.csv", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for guaranty overlap: one source states the controlling amount is $5,098,056.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $5,202,612.00.", "id": "F-10", "issue": "guaranty overlap", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/028_contracts_leases_ledger_export.csv", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-25, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Nadine Flores.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/10_plan_disclosure/079_plan_disclosure_officer_certificate.html", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for tax priority period: one source states approval is attributed to Priya Raman as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Elliot Mercer and contains no entry for Priya Raman.", "id": "F-11", "issue": "tax priority period", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/031_contracts_leases_officer_certificate.html", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-25, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Micah Sullivan.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/11_notices_ballots/082_notices_ballots_executed_instrument.txt", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for DIP budget variance: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-RS-2807-L767, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-RS-2807-U151.", "id": "F-12", "issue": "DIP budget variance", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/05_cash_management/034_cash_management_executed_instrument.txt", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-25, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Farah Ibrahim.", "severity": "low"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/11_notices_ballots/085_notices_ballots_review_memorandum.json", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for cash-collateral reporting gap: one source states the applicable location is Northern District of Illinois Bankruptcy Court, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to Illinois operations outside Northern District of Illinois Bankruptcy Court.", "id": "F-13", "issue": "cash-collateral reporting gap", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/05_cash_management/037_cash_management_review_memorandum.json", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-25, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Owen Delgado.", "severity": "critical"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/11_notices_ballots/088_notices_ballots_status_report.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for ballot amount discrepancy: one source states the threshold is 11% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 14% and produced a different exception result.", "id": "F-14", "issue": "ballot amount discrepancy", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/05_cash_management/040_cash_management_status_report.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-25, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Lena Varga.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/091_reconciliations_correspondence.eml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for notice-address defect: one source states formal notice must use notices-greenway_transit_services@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-metro_fleet_finance@example.test.", "id": "F-15", "issue": "notice-address defect", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/06_financing/043_financing_correspondence.eml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-25, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Samuel Kim.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/094_reconciliations_formal_notice.xml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for reserve calculation error: one source states the governed population contains 163 records through 2026-02-02, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 63 records through 2026-03-09.", "id": "F-16", "issue": "reserve calculation error", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/06_financing/046_financing_formal_notice.xml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-25, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Maya Ellison.", "severity": "medium"}], "matter_number": "CB-RS-2807", "prepared_for": "Greenway Transit Services", "schema_version": "1.0", "task_id": "cb100-047-greenway-transit"}}, "metadata": {"benchmark": "CounselBench-100", "code_license": "Apache-2.0", "data_license": "CC-BY-4.0", "deadline": "2026-09-25", "document_count": 96, "jurisdiction": "Illinois", "matter_number": "CB-RS-2807", "mcp_commit": "9a96ea6e5913736f92b88345bf51caeaaa8e719f", "mcp_package": "@modelcontextprotocol/server-filesystem@2026.7.10", "practice_area": "restructuring", "reference_tool_calls": 46, "required_evidence_reads": 33, "synthetic": true, "venue": "Northern District of Illinois Bankruptcy Court", "version": "2.0.0"}, "prompt": "You are debtor-side restructuring counsel for Greenway Transit Services. A counterparty challenged the client's internal summary, making cross-document reconciliation and precise citations essential. Fleet liens, tax claims, rejection damages, and a DIP variance affect voting and reserve recommendations. Decision due 2026-09-25. Illinois law governs; Northern District of Illinois Bankruptcy Court is the forum. Flag cross-folder dependencies that would be invisible in a single-document review. Work out the defensible position from the matter production and leave an audit-ready exception tracker and concise advice for the supervising lawyer. Keep confirmed conflicts separate from open questions, cite the records that actually control each conclusion, and do not fill gaps with outside facts.", "rubric": {"criteria": [{"category": "procedure", "description": "Complete at least 46 successful, argument-specific evidence and output calls.", "id": "procedure.minimum_successful_tool_calls"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Find and read the 33 controlling, corroborating, and work-product-control records in full.", "id": "procedure.all_evidence_read_in_full"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Inspect file metadata for the eight designated critical primary records before relying on them.", "id": "procedure.chain_of_custody_metadata_checked"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Confirm the sandbox's allowed document and output roots.", "id": "procedure.allowed_directories_checked"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Inventory all 96 records so the relevant sources are discovered among the context records.", "id": "procedure.recursive_inventory_completed"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Search the production for email evidence that may corroborate or contradict formal records.", "id": "procedure.targeted_search_completed"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Leave only findings.json and advice.md in the output workspace.", "id": "procedure.exact_deliverable_set"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Create both final work products through the sandbox MCP surface.", "id": "procedure.deliverables_written_through_mcp"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Produce findings.json as a valid JSON object.", "id": "findings.findings_is_object"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Report exactly 16 confirmed exceptions.", "id": "findings.findings_exact_count"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Use each stable finding ID exactly once.", "id": "findings.finding_ids_unique"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set schema_version to the released matter value '1.0'.", "id": "findings.top_level_schema_version"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set task_id to the released matter value 'cb100-047-greenway-transit'.", "id": "findings.top_level_task_id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set matter_number to the released matter value 'CB-RS-2807'.", "id": "findings.top_level_matter_number"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set prepared_for to the released matter value 'Greenway Transit Services'.", "id": "findings.top_level_prepared_for"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set as_of to the released matter value '2026-09-25'.", "id": "findings.top_level_as_of"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-01 exception for scheduled-claim mismatch.", "id": "findings.F-01.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's id from /workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/001_petition_schedules_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_critical_vendors/049_critical_vendors_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's issue from /workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/001_petition_schedules_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_critical_vendors/049_critical_vendors_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's severity from /workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/001_petition_schedules_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_critical_vendors/049_critical_vendors_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's primary_source from /workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/001_petition_schedules_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_critical_vendors/049_critical_vendors_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/001_petition_schedules_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_critical_vendors/049_critical_vendors_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-01 using the exact controlled facts ['2025-07-18', 'CB-RS-2807-A956', '2025-08-07', 'CB-RS-2807-J650'].", "id": "findings.F-01.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-01's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-01.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-25', 'Caleb Hassan'] for F-01.", "id": "findings.F-01.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-02 exception for duplicate proof of claim.", "id": "findings.F-02.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's id from /workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/004_petition_schedules_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_critical_vendors/052_critical_vendors_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's issue from /workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/004_petition_schedules_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_critical_vendors/052_critical_vendors_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's severity from /workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/004_petition_schedules_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_critical_vendors/052_critical_vendors_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's primary_source from /workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/004_petition_schedules_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_critical_vendors/052_critical_vendors_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/004_petition_schedules_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_critical_vendors/052_critical_vendors_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-02 using the exact controlled facts ['$1,782,168.00', '$1,850,836.00'].", "id": "findings.F-02.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-02's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-02.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-25', 'Leona Park'] for F-02.", "id": "findings.F-02.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-03 exception for secured-status defect.", "id": "findings.F-03.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's id from /workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/007_petition_schedules_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_critical_vendors/055_critical_vendors_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's issue from /workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/007_petition_schedules_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_critical_vendors/055_critical_vendors_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's severity from /workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/007_petition_schedules_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_critical_vendors/055_critical_vendors_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's primary_source from /workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/007_petition_schedules_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_critical_vendors/055_critical_vendors_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/007_petition_schedules_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_critical_vendors/055_critical_vendors_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-03 using the exact controlled facts ['Priya Raman', 'Adrian Mensah'].", "id": "findings.F-03.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-03's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-03.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-25', 'Isaac Romero'] for F-03.", "id": "findings.F-03.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-04 exception for priority classification error.", "id": "findings.F-04.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's id from /workspace/documents/02_claims_register/010_claims_register_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_tax/058_tax_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's issue from /workspace/documents/02_claims_register/010_claims_register_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_tax/058_tax_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's severity from /workspace/documents/02_claims_register/010_claims_register_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_tax/058_tax_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's primary_source from /workspace/documents/02_claims_register/010_claims_register_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_tax/058_tax_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/02_claims_register/010_claims_register_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_tax/058_tax_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-04 using the exact controlled facts ['closed without exception', 'CB-RS-2807-D733', 'open and escalated', 'CB-RS-2807-M564'].", "id": "findings.F-04.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-04's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-04.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-25', 'Sofia Bennett'] for F-04.", "id": "findings.F-04.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-05 exception for executory-contract cure dispute.", "id": "findings.F-05.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's id from /workspace/documents/02_claims_register/013_claims_register_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_tax/061_tax_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's issue from /workspace/documents/02_claims_register/013_claims_register_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_tax/061_tax_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's severity from /workspace/documents/02_claims_register/013_claims_register_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_tax/061_tax_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's primary_source from /workspace/documents/02_claims_register/013_claims_register_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_tax/061_tax_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/02_claims_register/013_claims_register_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_tax/061_tax_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-05 using the exact controlled facts ['Northern District of Illinois Bankruptcy Court', 'Illinois'].", "id": "findings.F-05.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-05's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-05.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-25', 'Adrian Mensah'] for F-05.", "id": "findings.F-05.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-06 exception for lease rejection deadline.", "id": "findings.F-06.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's id from /workspace/documents/02_claims_register/016_claims_register_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_tax/064_tax_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's issue from /workspace/documents/02_claims_register/016_claims_register_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_tax/064_tax_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's severity from /workspace/documents/02_claims_register/016_claims_register_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_tax/064_tax_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's primary_source from /workspace/documents/02_claims_register/016_claims_register_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_tax/064_tax_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/02_claims_register/016_claims_register_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_tax/064_tax_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-06 using the exact controlled facts ['8%', '10%'].", "id": "findings.F-06.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-06's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-06.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-25', 'Willa Novak'] for F-06.", "id": "findings.F-06.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-07 exception for postpetition invoice.", "id": "findings.F-07.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's id from /workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/019_proofs_of_claim_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_litigation/067_litigation_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's issue from /workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/019_proofs_of_claim_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_litigation/067_litigation_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's severity from /workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/019_proofs_of_claim_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_litigation/067_litigation_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's primary_source from /workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/019_proofs_of_claim_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_litigation/067_litigation_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/019_proofs_of_claim_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_litigation/067_litigation_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-07 using the exact controlled facts ['notices-greenway_transit_services@example.test', 'archive-metro_fleet_finance@example.test'].", "id": "findings.F-07.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-07's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-07.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-25', 'Theo Laurent'] for F-07.", "id": "findings.F-07.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-08 exception for critical-vendor overstatement.", "id": "findings.F-08.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's id from /workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/022_proofs_of_claim_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_litigation/070_litigation_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's issue from /workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/022_proofs_of_claim_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_litigation/070_litigation_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's severity from /workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/022_proofs_of_claim_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_litigation/070_litigation_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's primary_source from /workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/022_proofs_of_claim_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_litigation/070_litigation_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/022_proofs_of_claim_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_litigation/070_litigation_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-08 using the exact controlled facts ['129 records', '2025-12-30', '49 records', '2026-01-20'].", "id": "findings.F-08.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-08's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-08.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-25', 'Amara Patel'] for F-08.", "id": "findings.F-08.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-09 exception for setoff assertion.", "id": "findings.F-09.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's id from /workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/025_contracts_leases_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_plan_disclosure/073_plan_disclosure_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's issue from /workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/025_contracts_leases_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_plan_disclosure/073_plan_disclosure_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's severity from /workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/025_contracts_leases_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_plan_disclosure/073_plan_disclosure_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's primary_source from /workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/025_contracts_leases_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_plan_disclosure/073_plan_disclosure_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/025_contracts_leases_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_plan_disclosure/073_plan_disclosure_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-09 using the exact controlled facts ['2025-04-17', 'CB-RS-2807-I444', '2025-05-20', 'CB-RS-2807-R334'].", "id": "findings.F-09.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-09's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-09.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-25', 'Henry Cho'] for F-09.", "id": "findings.F-09.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-10 exception for guaranty overlap.", "id": "findings.F-10.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's id from /workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/028_contracts_leases_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_plan_disclosure/076_plan_disclosure_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's issue from /workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/028_contracts_leases_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_plan_disclosure/076_plan_disclosure_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's severity from /workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/028_contracts_leases_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_plan_disclosure/076_plan_disclosure_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's primary_source from /workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/028_contracts_leases_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_plan_disclosure/076_plan_disclosure_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/028_contracts_leases_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_plan_disclosure/076_plan_disclosure_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-10 using the exact controlled facts ['$5,098,056.00', '$5,202,612.00'].", "id": "findings.F-10.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-10's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-10.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-25', 'Nadine Flores'] for F-10.", "id": "findings.F-10.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-11 exception for tax priority period.", "id": "findings.F-11.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's id from /workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/031_contracts_leases_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_plan_disclosure/079_plan_disclosure_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's issue from /workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/031_contracts_leases_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_plan_disclosure/079_plan_disclosure_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's severity from /workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/031_contracts_leases_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_plan_disclosure/079_plan_disclosure_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's primary_source from /workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/031_contracts_leases_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_plan_disclosure/079_plan_disclosure_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/031_contracts_leases_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_plan_disclosure/079_plan_disclosure_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-11 using the exact controlled facts ['Priya Raman', 'Elliot Mercer'].", "id": "findings.F-11.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-11's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-11.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-25', 'Micah Sullivan'] for F-11.", "id": "findings.F-11.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-12 exception for DIP budget variance.", "id": "findings.F-12.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's id from /workspace/documents/05_cash_management/034_cash_management_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_notices_ballots/082_notices_ballots_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's issue from /workspace/documents/05_cash_management/034_cash_management_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_notices_ballots/082_notices_ballots_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's severity from /workspace/documents/05_cash_management/034_cash_management_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_notices_ballots/082_notices_ballots_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's primary_source from /workspace/documents/05_cash_management/034_cash_management_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_notices_ballots/082_notices_ballots_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/05_cash_management/034_cash_management_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_notices_ballots/082_notices_ballots_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-12 using the exact controlled facts ['closed without exception', 'CB-RS-2807-L767', 'open and escalated', 'CB-RS-2807-U151'].", "id": "findings.F-12.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-12's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-12.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-25', 'Farah Ibrahim'] for F-12.", "id": "findings.F-12.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-13 exception for cash-collateral reporting gap.", "id": "findings.F-13.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's id from /workspace/documents/05_cash_management/037_cash_management_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_notices_ballots/085_notices_ballots_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's issue from /workspace/documents/05_cash_management/037_cash_management_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_notices_ballots/085_notices_ballots_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's severity from /workspace/documents/05_cash_management/037_cash_management_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_notices_ballots/085_notices_ballots_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's primary_source from /workspace/documents/05_cash_management/037_cash_management_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_notices_ballots/085_notices_ballots_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/05_cash_management/037_cash_management_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_notices_ballots/085_notices_ballots_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-13 using the exact controlled facts ['Northern District of Illinois Bankruptcy Court', 'Illinois'].", "id": "findings.F-13.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-13's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-13.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-25', 'Owen Delgado'] for F-13.", "id": "findings.F-13.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-14 exception for ballot amount discrepancy.", "id": "findings.F-14.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's id from /workspace/documents/05_cash_management/040_cash_management_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_notices_ballots/088_notices_ballots_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's issue from /workspace/documents/05_cash_management/040_cash_management_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_notices_ballots/088_notices_ballots_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's severity from /workspace/documents/05_cash_management/040_cash_management_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_notices_ballots/088_notices_ballots_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's primary_source from /workspace/documents/05_cash_management/040_cash_management_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_notices_ballots/088_notices_ballots_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/05_cash_management/040_cash_management_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_notices_ballots/088_notices_ballots_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-14 using the exact controlled facts ['11%', '14%'].", "id": "findings.F-14.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-14's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-14.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-25', 'Lena Varga'] for F-14.", "id": "findings.F-14.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-15 exception for notice-address defect.", "id": "findings.F-15.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's id from /workspace/documents/06_financing/043_financing_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/091_reconciliations_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's issue from /workspace/documents/06_financing/043_financing_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/091_reconciliations_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's severity from /workspace/documents/06_financing/043_financing_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/091_reconciliations_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's primary_source from /workspace/documents/06_financing/043_financing_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/091_reconciliations_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/06_financing/043_financing_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/091_reconciliations_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-15 using the exact controlled facts ['notices-greenway_transit_services@example.test', 'archive-metro_fleet_finance@example.test'].", "id": "findings.F-15.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-15's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-15.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-25', 'Samuel Kim'] for F-15.", "id": "findings.F-15.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-16 exception for reserve calculation error.", "id": "findings.F-16.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's id from /workspace/documents/06_financing/046_financing_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/094_reconciliations_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's issue from /workspace/documents/06_financing/046_financing_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/094_reconciliations_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's severity from /workspace/documents/06_financing/046_financing_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/094_reconciliations_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's primary_source from /workspace/documents/06_financing/046_financing_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/094_reconciliations_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/06_financing/046_financing_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/094_reconciliations_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-16 using the exact controlled facts ['163 records', '2026-02-02', '63 records', '2026-03-09'].", "id": "findings.F-16.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-16's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-16.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-25', 'Maya Ellison'] for F-16.", "id": "findings.F-16.action_anchors"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Executive assessment' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Executive assessment"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Method and record coverage' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Method and record coverage"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Findings' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Findings"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Recommended next actions' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Recommended next actions"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Assumptions and limitations' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Assumptions and limitations"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-01 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-01"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-02 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-02"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-03 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-03"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-04 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-04"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-05 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-05"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-06 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-06"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-07 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-07"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-08 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-08"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-09 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-09"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-10 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-10"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-11 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-11"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-12 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-12"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-13 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-13"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-14 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-14"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-15 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-15"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-16 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-16"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Do not claim the production has no issues or that every record is consistent.", "id": "memo.forbidden_claims_absent"}], "decision_options": [{"id": "cross-source-reconciliation", "label": "Reconcile controlling and corroborating records", "reason": "The CB-RS-2807 production contains independently maintained records; a defensible answer must preserve each supported conflict and its cure owner.", "selected": true}, {"id": "latest-record-controls", "label": "Treat the latest record as controlling", "reason": "Timestamp recency does not establish legal priority, execution, or approval authority.", "selected": false}, {"id": "primary-records-only", "label": "Report primary records without reconciliation", "reason": "Primary records alone conceal the operational conflicts that create the actionable exceptions.", "selected": false}], "gates": ["all_evidence_read_in_full", "chain_of_custody_metadata_checked", "findings_criteria_complete", "memo_criteria_complete", "deliverables_written_through_mcp"], "metadata_checks": 8, "metric": "weighted_criteria_score", "minimum_tool_calls": 46, "required_deliverables": ["findings.json", "advice.md"], "required_document_reads": 33, "type": "deterministic", "weights": {"findings": 0.55, "memo": 0.2, "procedure": 0.25}}, "task_id": "cb100-047-greenway-transit", "task_name": "Greenway Transit plan claim review", "world_id": "counselbench-filesystem-mcp-v2"}
-{"context_files": ["task_files/cb100-048-harvest-paper/01_petition_schedules/001_petition_schedules_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-048-harvest-paper/01_petition_schedules/002_petition_schedules_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-048-harvest-paper/01_petition_schedules/003_petition_schedules_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-048-harvest-paper/01_petition_schedules/004_petition_schedules_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-048-harvest-paper/01_petition_schedules/005_petition_schedules_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-048-harvest-paper/01_petition_schedules/006_petition_schedules_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-048-harvest-paper/01_petition_schedules/007_petition_schedules_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-048-harvest-paper/01_petition_schedules/008_petition_schedules_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-048-harvest-paper/02_claims_register/009_claims_register_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-048-harvest-paper/02_claims_register/010_claims_register_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-048-harvest-paper/02_claims_register/011_claims_register_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-048-harvest-paper/02_claims_register/012_claims_register_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-048-harvest-paper/02_claims_register/013_claims_register_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-048-harvest-paper/02_claims_register/014_claims_register_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-048-harvest-paper/02_claims_register/015_claims_register_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-048-harvest-paper/02_claims_register/016_claims_register_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-048-harvest-paper/03_proofs_of_claim/017_proofs_of_claim_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-048-harvest-paper/03_proofs_of_claim/018_proofs_of_claim_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-048-harvest-paper/03_proofs_of_claim/019_proofs_of_claim_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-048-harvest-paper/03_proofs_of_claim/020_proofs_of_claim_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-048-harvest-paper/03_proofs_of_claim/021_proofs_of_claim_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-048-harvest-paper/03_proofs_of_claim/022_proofs_of_claim_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-048-harvest-paper/03_proofs_of_claim/023_proofs_of_claim_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-048-harvest-paper/03_proofs_of_claim/024_proofs_of_claim_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-048-harvest-paper/04_contracts_leases/025_contracts_leases_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-048-harvest-paper/04_contracts_leases/026_contracts_leases_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-048-harvest-paper/04_contracts_leases/027_contracts_leases_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-048-harvest-paper/04_contracts_leases/028_contracts_leases_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-048-harvest-paper/04_contracts_leases/029_contracts_leases_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-048-harvest-paper/04_contracts_leases/030_contracts_leases_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-048-harvest-paper/04_contracts_leases/031_contracts_leases_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-048-harvest-paper/04_contracts_leases/032_contracts_leases_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-048-harvest-paper/05_cash_management/033_cash_management_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-048-harvest-paper/05_cash_management/034_cash_management_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-048-harvest-paper/05_cash_management/035_cash_management_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-048-harvest-paper/05_cash_management/036_cash_management_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-048-harvest-paper/05_cash_management/037_cash_management_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-048-harvest-paper/05_cash_management/038_cash_management_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-048-harvest-paper/05_cash_management/039_cash_management_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-048-harvest-paper/05_cash_management/040_cash_management_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-048-harvest-paper/06_financing/041_financing_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-048-harvest-paper/06_financing/042_financing_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-048-harvest-paper/06_financing/043_financing_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-048-harvest-paper/06_financing/044_financing_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-048-harvest-paper/06_financing/045_financing_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-048-harvest-paper/06_financing/046_financing_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-048-harvest-paper/06_financing/047_financing_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-048-harvest-paper/06_financing/048_financing_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-048-harvest-paper/07_critical_vendors/049_critical_vendors_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-048-harvest-paper/07_critical_vendors/050_critical_vendors_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-048-harvest-paper/07_critical_vendors/051_critical_vendors_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-048-harvest-paper/07_critical_vendors/052_critical_vendors_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-048-harvest-paper/07_critical_vendors/053_critical_vendors_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-048-harvest-paper/07_critical_vendors/054_critical_vendors_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-048-harvest-paper/07_critical_vendors/055_critical_vendors_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-048-harvest-paper/07_critical_vendors/056_critical_vendors_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-048-harvest-paper/08_tax/057_tax_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-048-harvest-paper/08_tax/058_tax_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-048-harvest-paper/08_tax/059_tax_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-048-harvest-paper/08_tax/060_tax_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-048-harvest-paper/08_tax/061_tax_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-048-harvest-paper/08_tax/062_tax_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-048-harvest-paper/08_tax/063_tax_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-048-harvest-paper/08_tax/064_tax_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-048-harvest-paper/09_litigation/065_litigation_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-048-harvest-paper/09_litigation/066_litigation_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-048-harvest-paper/09_litigation/067_litigation_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-048-harvest-paper/09_litigation/068_litigation_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-048-harvest-paper/09_litigation/069_litigation_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-048-harvest-paper/09_litigation/070_litigation_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-048-harvest-paper/09_litigation/071_litigation_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-048-harvest-paper/09_litigation/072_litigation_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-048-harvest-paper/10_plan_disclosure/073_plan_disclosure_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-048-harvest-paper/10_plan_disclosure/074_plan_disclosure_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-048-harvest-paper/10_plan_disclosure/075_plan_disclosure_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-048-harvest-paper/10_plan_disclosure/076_plan_disclosure_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-048-harvest-paper/10_plan_disclosure/077_plan_disclosure_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-048-harvest-paper/10_plan_disclosure/078_plan_disclosure_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-048-harvest-paper/10_plan_disclosure/079_plan_disclosure_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-048-harvest-paper/10_plan_disclosure/080_plan_disclosure_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-048-harvest-paper/11_notices_ballots/081_notices_ballots_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-048-harvest-paper/11_notices_ballots/082_notices_ballots_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-048-harvest-paper/11_notices_ballots/083_notices_ballots_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-048-harvest-paper/11_notices_ballots/084_notices_ballots_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-048-harvest-paper/11_notices_ballots/085_notices_ballots_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-048-harvest-paper/11_notices_ballots/086_notices_ballots_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-048-harvest-paper/11_notices_ballots/087_notices_ballots_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-048-harvest-paper/11_notices_ballots/088_notices_ballots_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-048-harvest-paper/12_reconciliations/089_reconciliations_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-048-harvest-paper/12_reconciliations/090_reconciliations_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-048-harvest-paper/12_reconciliations/091_reconciliations_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-048-harvest-paper/12_reconciliations/092_reconciliations_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-048-harvest-paper/12_reconciliations/093_reconciliations_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-048-harvest-paper/12_reconciliations/094_reconciliations_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-048-harvest-paper/12_reconciliations/095_reconciliations_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-048-harvest-paper/12_reconciliations/096_reconciliations_status_report.md"], "gold_output": {"advice_markdown": "# Counsel advice — Harvest Paper mill restructuring audit\n\n## Executive assessment\n\nFor Harvest Paper Mills LLC matter CB-RS-2808, the review identified 16 source-supported exceptions requiring action before 2026-09-29. The assessment concerns Timber Run Energy Cooperative and the supplied record for Maine.\n\n## Method and record coverage\n\nThe review inventoried all 96 production files, read the 33 controlling, corroborating, and control records, searched the email exports, and checked metadata for the designated chain-of-custody sample. Conclusions are limited to the synthetic production supplied for this benchmark matter.\n\n## Findings\n\n### F-01 — scheduled-claim mismatch (critical)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for scheduled-claim mismatch: one source states the operative date is 2025-08-23 under control reference CB-RS-2808-A332, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2025-10-01 under response reference CB-RS-2808-J533.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/001_petition_schedules_control_register.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/07_critical_vendors/049_critical_vendors_control_register.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-29, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Leona Park.\n\n### F-02 — duplicate proof of claim (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for duplicate proof of claim: one source states the controlling amount is $1,487,127.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $1,670,754.00.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/004_petition_schedules_ledger_export.csv`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/07_critical_vendors/052_critical_vendors_ledger_export.csv`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-29, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Isaac Romero.\n\n### F-03 — secured-status defect (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for secured-status defect: one source states approval is attributed to Elliot Mercer as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Theo Laurent and contains no entry for Elliot Mercer.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/007_petition_schedules_officer_certificate.html`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/07_critical_vendors/055_critical_vendors_officer_certificate.html`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-29, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Sofia Bennett.\n\n### F-04 — priority classification error (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for priority classification error: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-RS-2808-D525, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-RS-2808-M755.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/02_claims_register/010_claims_register_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/08_tax/058_tax_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-29, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Adrian Mensah.\n\n### F-05 — executory-contract cure dispute (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for executory-contract cure dispute: one source states the applicable location is District of Maine Bankruptcy Court, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to Maine operations outside District of Maine Bankruptcy Court.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/02_claims_register/013_claims_register_review_memorandum.json`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/08_tax/061_tax_review_memorandum.json`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-29, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Willa Novak.\n\n### F-06 — lease rejection deadline (low)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for lease rejection deadline: one source states the threshold is 13% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 16% and produced a different exception result.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/02_claims_register/016_claims_register_status_report.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/08_tax/064_tax_status_report.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-29, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Theo Laurent.\n\n### F-07 — postpetition invoice (critical)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for postpetition invoice: one source states formal notice must use notices-harvest_paper_mills_llc@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-timber_run_energy_cooperative@example.test.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/019_proofs_of_claim_correspondence.eml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/09_litigation/067_litigation_correspondence.eml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-29, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Amara Patel.\n\n### F-08 — critical-vendor overstatement (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for critical-vendor overstatement: one source states the governed population contains 170 records through 2025-09-22, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 72 records through 2025-11-05.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/022_proofs_of_claim_formal_notice.xml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/09_litigation/070_litigation_formal_notice.xml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-29, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Henry Cho.\n\n### F-09 — setoff assertion (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for setoff assertion: one source states the operative date is 2025-03-23 under control reference CB-RS-2808-I419, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2025-05-08 under response reference CB-RS-2808-R332.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/025_contracts_leases_control_register.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/10_plan_disclosure/073_plan_disclosure_control_register.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-29, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Nadine Flores.\n\n### F-10 — guaranty overlap (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for guaranty overlap: one source states the controlling amount is $2,037,145.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $2,200,790.00.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/028_contracts_leases_ledger_export.csv`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/10_plan_disclosure/076_plan_disclosure_ledger_export.csv`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-29, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Micah Sullivan.\n\n### F-11 — tax priority period (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for tax priority period: one source states approval is attributed to Elliot Mercer as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Jonas Feld and contains no entry for Elliot Mercer.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/031_contracts_leases_officer_certificate.html`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/10_plan_disclosure/079_plan_disclosure_officer_certificate.html`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-29, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Farah Ibrahim.\n\n### F-12 — DIP budget variance (low)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for DIP budget variance: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-RS-2808-L670, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-RS-2808-U836.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/05_cash_management/034_cash_management_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/11_notices_ballots/082_notices_ballots_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-29, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Owen Delgado.\n\n### F-13 — cash-collateral reporting gap (critical)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for cash-collateral reporting gap: one source states the applicable location is District of Maine Bankruptcy Court, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to Maine operations outside District of Maine Bankruptcy Court.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/05_cash_management/037_cash_management_review_memorandum.json`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/11_notices_ballots/085_notices_ballots_review_memorandum.json`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-29, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Lena Varga.\n\n### F-14 — ballot amount discrepancy (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for ballot amount discrepancy: one source states the threshold is 3% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 8% and produced a different exception result.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/05_cash_management/040_cash_management_status_report.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/11_notices_ballots/088_notices_ballots_status_report.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-29, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Samuel Kim.\n\n### F-15 — notice-address defect (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for notice-address defect: one source states formal notice must use notices-harvest_paper_mills_llc@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-timber_run_energy_cooperative@example.test.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/06_financing/043_financing_correspondence.eml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/091_reconciliations_correspondence.eml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-29, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Maya Ellison.\n\n### F-16 — reserve calculation error (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for reserve calculation error: one source states the governed population contains 114 records through 2025-12-15, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 48 records through 2026-01-04.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/06_financing/046_financing_formal_notice.xml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/094_reconciliations_formal_notice.xml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-29, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Rafael Okafor.\n\n## Recommended next actions\n\nSequence the critical and high findings first, assign the named owners, preserve the cited records, and document any resolution in the controlling matter register before the stated deadline.\n\n## Assumptions and limitations\n\nThis analysis is confined to task cb100-048-harvest-paper and the supplied synthetic evidence. It does not rely on external facts, does not resolve disputed law, and is not legal advice for a real person or entity.\n", "findings": {"as_of": "2026-09-29", "findings": [{"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/07_critical_vendors/049_critical_vendors_control_register.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for scheduled-claim mismatch: one source states the operative date is 2025-08-23 under control reference CB-RS-2808-A332, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2025-10-01 under response reference CB-RS-2808-J533.", "id": "F-01", "issue": "scheduled-claim mismatch", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/001_petition_schedules_control_register.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-29, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Leona Park.", "severity": "critical"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/07_critical_vendors/052_critical_vendors_ledger_export.csv", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for duplicate proof of claim: one source states the controlling amount is $1,487,127.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $1,670,754.00.", "id": "F-02", "issue": "duplicate proof of claim", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/004_petition_schedules_ledger_export.csv", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-29, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Isaac Romero.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/07_critical_vendors/055_critical_vendors_officer_certificate.html", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for secured-status defect: one source states approval is attributed to Elliot Mercer as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Theo Laurent and contains no entry for Elliot Mercer.", "id": "F-03", "issue": "secured-status defect", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/007_petition_schedules_officer_certificate.html", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-29, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Sofia Bennett.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/08_tax/058_tax_executed_instrument.txt", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for priority classification error: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-RS-2808-D525, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-RS-2808-M755.", "id": "F-04", "issue": "priority classification error", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/02_claims_register/010_claims_register_executed_instrument.txt", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-29, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Adrian Mensah.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/08_tax/061_tax_review_memorandum.json", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for executory-contract cure dispute: one source states the applicable location is District of Maine Bankruptcy Court, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to Maine operations outside District of Maine Bankruptcy Court.", "id": "F-05", "issue": "executory-contract cure dispute", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/02_claims_register/013_claims_register_review_memorandum.json", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-29, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Willa Novak.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/08_tax/064_tax_status_report.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for lease rejection deadline: one source states the threshold is 13% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 16% and produced a different exception result.", "id": "F-06", "issue": "lease rejection deadline", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/02_claims_register/016_claims_register_status_report.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-29, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Theo Laurent.", "severity": "low"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/09_litigation/067_litigation_correspondence.eml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for postpetition invoice: one source states formal notice must use notices-harvest_paper_mills_llc@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-timber_run_energy_cooperative@example.test.", "id": "F-07", "issue": "postpetition invoice", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/019_proofs_of_claim_correspondence.eml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-29, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Amara Patel.", "severity": "critical"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/09_litigation/070_litigation_formal_notice.xml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for critical-vendor overstatement: one source states the governed population contains 170 records through 2025-09-22, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 72 records through 2025-11-05.", "id": "F-08", "issue": "critical-vendor overstatement", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/022_proofs_of_claim_formal_notice.xml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-29, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Henry Cho.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/10_plan_disclosure/073_plan_disclosure_control_register.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for setoff assertion: one source states the operative date is 2025-03-23 under control reference CB-RS-2808-I419, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2025-05-08 under response reference CB-RS-2808-R332.", "id": "F-09", "issue": "setoff assertion", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/025_contracts_leases_control_register.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-29, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Nadine Flores.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/10_plan_disclosure/076_plan_disclosure_ledger_export.csv", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for guaranty overlap: one source states the controlling amount is $2,037,145.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $2,200,790.00.", "id": "F-10", "issue": "guaranty overlap", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/028_contracts_leases_ledger_export.csv", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-29, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Micah Sullivan.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/10_plan_disclosure/079_plan_disclosure_officer_certificate.html", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for tax priority period: one source states approval is attributed to Elliot Mercer as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Jonas Feld and contains no entry for Elliot Mercer.", "id": "F-11", "issue": "tax priority period", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/031_contracts_leases_officer_certificate.html", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-29, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Farah Ibrahim.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/11_notices_ballots/082_notices_ballots_executed_instrument.txt", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for DIP budget variance: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-RS-2808-L670, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-RS-2808-U836.", "id": "F-12", "issue": "DIP budget variance", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/05_cash_management/034_cash_management_executed_instrument.txt", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-29, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Owen Delgado.", "severity": "low"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/11_notices_ballots/085_notices_ballots_review_memorandum.json", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for cash-collateral reporting gap: one source states the applicable location is District of Maine Bankruptcy Court, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to Maine operations outside District of Maine Bankruptcy Court.", "id": "F-13", "issue": "cash-collateral reporting gap", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/05_cash_management/037_cash_management_review_memorandum.json", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-29, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Lena Varga.", "severity": "critical"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/11_notices_ballots/088_notices_ballots_status_report.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for ballot amount discrepancy: one source states the threshold is 3% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 8% and produced a different exception result.", "id": "F-14", "issue": "ballot amount discrepancy", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/05_cash_management/040_cash_management_status_report.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-29, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Samuel Kim.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/091_reconciliations_correspondence.eml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for notice-address defect: one source states formal notice must use notices-harvest_paper_mills_llc@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-timber_run_energy_cooperative@example.test.", "id": "F-15", "issue": "notice-address defect", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/06_financing/043_financing_correspondence.eml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-29, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Maya Ellison.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/094_reconciliations_formal_notice.xml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for reserve calculation error: one source states the governed population contains 114 records through 2025-12-15, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 48 records through 2026-01-04.", "id": "F-16", "issue": "reserve calculation error", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/06_financing/046_financing_formal_notice.xml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-29, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Rafael Okafor.", "severity": "medium"}], "matter_number": "CB-RS-2808", "prepared_for": "Harvest Paper Mills LLC", "schema_version": "1.0", "task_id": "cb100-048-harvest-paper"}}, "metadata": {"benchmark": "CounselBench-100", "code_license": "Apache-2.0", "data_license": "CC-BY-4.0", "deadline": "2026-09-29", "document_count": 96, "jurisdiction": "Maine", "matter_number": "CB-RS-2808", "mcp_commit": "9a96ea6e5913736f92b88345bf51caeaaa8e719f", "mcp_package": "@modelcontextprotocol/server-filesystem@2026.7.10", "practice_area": "restructuring", "reference_tool_calls": 46, "required_evidence_reads": 33, "synthetic": true, "venue": "District of Maine Bankruptcy Court", "version": "2.0.0"}, "prompt": "You are debtor-side restructuring counsel for Harvest Paper Mills LLC. The supervising attorney wants an exception-focused review that still demonstrates complete coverage of the data room. Energy and timber contracts have contested cure amounts, setoff claims, and address defects in solicitation records. Decision due 2026-09-29. Maine law governs; District of Maine Bankruptcy Court is the forum. Preserve the difference between the client's position, the counterparty's position, and an objective record conflict. Work out the defensible position from the matter production and leave an audit-ready exception tracker and concise advice for the supervising lawyer. Keep confirmed conflicts separate from open questions, cite the records that actually control each conclusion, and do not fill gaps with outside facts.", "rubric": {"criteria": [{"category": "procedure", "description": "Complete at least 46 successful, argument-specific evidence and output calls.", "id": "procedure.minimum_successful_tool_calls"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Find and read the 33 controlling, corroborating, and work-product-control records in full.", "id": "procedure.all_evidence_read_in_full"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Inspect file metadata for the eight designated critical primary records before relying on them.", "id": "procedure.chain_of_custody_metadata_checked"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Confirm the sandbox's allowed document and output roots.", "id": "procedure.allowed_directories_checked"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Inventory all 96 records so the relevant sources are discovered among the context records.", "id": "procedure.recursive_inventory_completed"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Search the production for email evidence that may corroborate or contradict formal records.", "id": "procedure.targeted_search_completed"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Leave only findings.json and advice.md in the output workspace.", "id": "procedure.exact_deliverable_set"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Create both final work products through the sandbox MCP surface.", "id": "procedure.deliverables_written_through_mcp"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Produce findings.json as a valid JSON object.", "id": "findings.findings_is_object"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Report exactly 16 confirmed exceptions.", "id": "findings.findings_exact_count"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Use each stable finding ID exactly once.", "id": "findings.finding_ids_unique"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set schema_version to the released matter value '1.0'.", "id": "findings.top_level_schema_version"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set task_id to the released matter value 'cb100-048-harvest-paper'.", "id": "findings.top_level_task_id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set matter_number to the released matter value 'CB-RS-2808'.", "id": "findings.top_level_matter_number"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set prepared_for to the released matter value 'Harvest Paper Mills LLC'.", "id": "findings.top_level_prepared_for"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set as_of to the released matter value '2026-09-29'.", "id": "findings.top_level_as_of"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-01 exception for scheduled-claim mismatch.", "id": "findings.F-01.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's id from /workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/001_petition_schedules_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_critical_vendors/049_critical_vendors_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's issue from /workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/001_petition_schedules_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_critical_vendors/049_critical_vendors_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's severity from /workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/001_petition_schedules_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_critical_vendors/049_critical_vendors_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's primary_source from /workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/001_petition_schedules_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_critical_vendors/049_critical_vendors_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/001_petition_schedules_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_critical_vendors/049_critical_vendors_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-01 using the exact controlled facts ['2025-08-23', 'CB-RS-2808-A332', '2025-10-01', 'CB-RS-2808-J533'].", "id": "findings.F-01.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-01's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-01.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-29', 'Leona Park'] for F-01.", "id": "findings.F-01.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-02 exception for duplicate proof of claim.", "id": "findings.F-02.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's id from /workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/004_petition_schedules_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_critical_vendors/052_critical_vendors_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's issue from /workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/004_petition_schedules_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_critical_vendors/052_critical_vendors_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's severity from /workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/004_petition_schedules_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_critical_vendors/052_critical_vendors_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's primary_source from /workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/004_petition_schedules_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_critical_vendors/052_critical_vendors_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/004_petition_schedules_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_critical_vendors/052_critical_vendors_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-02 using the exact controlled facts ['$1,487,127.00', '$1,670,754.00'].", "id": "findings.F-02.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-02's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-02.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-29', 'Isaac Romero'] for F-02.", "id": "findings.F-02.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-03 exception for secured-status defect.", "id": "findings.F-03.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's id from /workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/007_petition_schedules_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_critical_vendors/055_critical_vendors_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's issue from /workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/007_petition_schedules_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_critical_vendors/055_critical_vendors_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's severity from /workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/007_petition_schedules_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_critical_vendors/055_critical_vendors_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's primary_source from /workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/007_petition_schedules_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_critical_vendors/055_critical_vendors_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/007_petition_schedules_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_critical_vendors/055_critical_vendors_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-03 using the exact controlled facts ['Elliot Mercer', 'Theo Laurent'].", "id": "findings.F-03.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-03's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-03.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-29', 'Sofia Bennett'] for F-03.", "id": "findings.F-03.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-04 exception for priority classification error.", "id": "findings.F-04.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's id from /workspace/documents/02_claims_register/010_claims_register_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_tax/058_tax_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's issue from /workspace/documents/02_claims_register/010_claims_register_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_tax/058_tax_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's severity from /workspace/documents/02_claims_register/010_claims_register_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_tax/058_tax_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's primary_source from /workspace/documents/02_claims_register/010_claims_register_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_tax/058_tax_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/02_claims_register/010_claims_register_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_tax/058_tax_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-04 using the exact controlled facts ['closed without exception', 'CB-RS-2808-D525', 'open and escalated', 'CB-RS-2808-M755'].", "id": "findings.F-04.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-04's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-04.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-29', 'Adrian Mensah'] for F-04.", "id": "findings.F-04.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-05 exception for executory-contract cure dispute.", "id": "findings.F-05.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's id from /workspace/documents/02_claims_register/013_claims_register_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_tax/061_tax_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's issue from /workspace/documents/02_claims_register/013_claims_register_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_tax/061_tax_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's severity from /workspace/documents/02_claims_register/013_claims_register_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_tax/061_tax_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's primary_source from /workspace/documents/02_claims_register/013_claims_register_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_tax/061_tax_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/02_claims_register/013_claims_register_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_tax/061_tax_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-05 using the exact controlled facts ['District of Maine Bankruptcy Court', 'Maine'].", "id": "findings.F-05.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-05's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-05.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-29', 'Willa Novak'] for F-05.", "id": "findings.F-05.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-06 exception for lease rejection deadline.", "id": "findings.F-06.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's id from /workspace/documents/02_claims_register/016_claims_register_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_tax/064_tax_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's issue from /workspace/documents/02_claims_register/016_claims_register_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_tax/064_tax_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's severity from /workspace/documents/02_claims_register/016_claims_register_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_tax/064_tax_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's primary_source from /workspace/documents/02_claims_register/016_claims_register_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_tax/064_tax_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/02_claims_register/016_claims_register_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_tax/064_tax_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-06 using the exact controlled facts ['13%', '16%'].", "id": "findings.F-06.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-06's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-06.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-29', 'Theo Laurent'] for F-06.", "id": "findings.F-06.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-07 exception for postpetition invoice.", "id": "findings.F-07.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's id from /workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/019_proofs_of_claim_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_litigation/067_litigation_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's issue from /workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/019_proofs_of_claim_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_litigation/067_litigation_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's severity from /workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/019_proofs_of_claim_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_litigation/067_litigation_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's primary_source from /workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/019_proofs_of_claim_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_litigation/067_litigation_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/019_proofs_of_claim_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_litigation/067_litigation_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-07 using the exact controlled facts ['notices-harvest_paper_mills_llc@example.test', 'archive-timber_run_energy_cooperative@example.test'].", "id": "findings.F-07.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-07's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-07.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-29', 'Amara Patel'] for F-07.", "id": "findings.F-07.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-08 exception for critical-vendor overstatement.", "id": "findings.F-08.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's id from /workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/022_proofs_of_claim_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_litigation/070_litigation_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's issue from /workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/022_proofs_of_claim_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_litigation/070_litigation_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's severity from /workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/022_proofs_of_claim_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_litigation/070_litigation_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's primary_source from /workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/022_proofs_of_claim_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_litigation/070_litigation_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/022_proofs_of_claim_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_litigation/070_litigation_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-08 using the exact controlled facts ['170 records', '2025-09-22', '72 records', '2025-11-05'].", "id": "findings.F-08.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-08's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-08.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-29', 'Henry Cho'] for F-08.", "id": "findings.F-08.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-09 exception for setoff assertion.", "id": "findings.F-09.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's id from /workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/025_contracts_leases_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_plan_disclosure/073_plan_disclosure_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's issue from /workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/025_contracts_leases_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_plan_disclosure/073_plan_disclosure_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's severity from /workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/025_contracts_leases_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_plan_disclosure/073_plan_disclosure_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's primary_source from /workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/025_contracts_leases_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_plan_disclosure/073_plan_disclosure_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/025_contracts_leases_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_plan_disclosure/073_plan_disclosure_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-09 using the exact controlled facts ['2025-03-23', 'CB-RS-2808-I419', '2025-05-08', 'CB-RS-2808-R332'].", "id": "findings.F-09.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-09's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-09.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-29', 'Nadine Flores'] for F-09.", "id": "findings.F-09.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-10 exception for guaranty overlap.", "id": "findings.F-10.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's id from /workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/028_contracts_leases_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_plan_disclosure/076_plan_disclosure_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's issue from /workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/028_contracts_leases_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_plan_disclosure/076_plan_disclosure_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's severity from /workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/028_contracts_leases_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_plan_disclosure/076_plan_disclosure_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's primary_source from /workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/028_contracts_leases_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_plan_disclosure/076_plan_disclosure_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/028_contracts_leases_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_plan_disclosure/076_plan_disclosure_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-10 using the exact controlled facts ['$2,037,145.00', '$2,200,790.00'].", "id": "findings.F-10.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-10's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-10.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-29', 'Micah Sullivan'] for F-10.", "id": "findings.F-10.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-11 exception for tax priority period.", "id": "findings.F-11.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's id from /workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/031_contracts_leases_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_plan_disclosure/079_plan_disclosure_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's issue from /workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/031_contracts_leases_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_plan_disclosure/079_plan_disclosure_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's severity from /workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/031_contracts_leases_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_plan_disclosure/079_plan_disclosure_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's primary_source from /workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/031_contracts_leases_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_plan_disclosure/079_plan_disclosure_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/031_contracts_leases_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_plan_disclosure/079_plan_disclosure_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-11 using the exact controlled facts ['Elliot Mercer', 'Jonas Feld'].", "id": "findings.F-11.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-11's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-11.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-29', 'Farah Ibrahim'] for F-11.", "id": "findings.F-11.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-12 exception for DIP budget variance.", "id": "findings.F-12.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's id from /workspace/documents/05_cash_management/034_cash_management_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_notices_ballots/082_notices_ballots_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's issue from /workspace/documents/05_cash_management/034_cash_management_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_notices_ballots/082_notices_ballots_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's severity from /workspace/documents/05_cash_management/034_cash_management_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_notices_ballots/082_notices_ballots_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's primary_source from /workspace/documents/05_cash_management/034_cash_management_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_notices_ballots/082_notices_ballots_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/05_cash_management/034_cash_management_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_notices_ballots/082_notices_ballots_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-12 using the exact controlled facts ['closed without exception', 'CB-RS-2808-L670', 'open and escalated', 'CB-RS-2808-U836'].", "id": "findings.F-12.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-12's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-12.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-29', 'Owen Delgado'] for F-12.", "id": "findings.F-12.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-13 exception for cash-collateral reporting gap.", "id": "findings.F-13.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's id from /workspace/documents/05_cash_management/037_cash_management_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_notices_ballots/085_notices_ballots_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's issue from /workspace/documents/05_cash_management/037_cash_management_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_notices_ballots/085_notices_ballots_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's severity from /workspace/documents/05_cash_management/037_cash_management_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_notices_ballots/085_notices_ballots_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's primary_source from /workspace/documents/05_cash_management/037_cash_management_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_notices_ballots/085_notices_ballots_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/05_cash_management/037_cash_management_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_notices_ballots/085_notices_ballots_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-13 using the exact controlled facts ['District of Maine Bankruptcy Court', 'Maine'].", "id": "findings.F-13.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-13's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-13.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-29', 'Lena Varga'] for F-13.", "id": "findings.F-13.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-14 exception for ballot amount discrepancy.", "id": "findings.F-14.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's id from /workspace/documents/05_cash_management/040_cash_management_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_notices_ballots/088_notices_ballots_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's issue from /workspace/documents/05_cash_management/040_cash_management_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_notices_ballots/088_notices_ballots_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's severity from /workspace/documents/05_cash_management/040_cash_management_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_notices_ballots/088_notices_ballots_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's primary_source from /workspace/documents/05_cash_management/040_cash_management_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_notices_ballots/088_notices_ballots_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/05_cash_management/040_cash_management_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_notices_ballots/088_notices_ballots_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-14 using the exact controlled facts ['3%', '8%'].", "id": "findings.F-14.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-14's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-14.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-29', 'Samuel Kim'] for F-14.", "id": "findings.F-14.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-15 exception for notice-address defect.", "id": "findings.F-15.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's id from /workspace/documents/06_financing/043_financing_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/091_reconciliations_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's issue from /workspace/documents/06_financing/043_financing_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/091_reconciliations_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's severity from /workspace/documents/06_financing/043_financing_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/091_reconciliations_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's primary_source from /workspace/documents/06_financing/043_financing_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/091_reconciliations_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/06_financing/043_financing_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/091_reconciliations_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-15 using the exact controlled facts ['notices-harvest_paper_mills_llc@example.test', 'archive-timber_run_energy_cooperative@example.test'].", "id": "findings.F-15.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-15's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-15.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-29', 'Maya Ellison'] for F-15.", "id": "findings.F-15.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-16 exception for reserve calculation error.", "id": "findings.F-16.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's id from /workspace/documents/06_financing/046_financing_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/094_reconciliations_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's issue from /workspace/documents/06_financing/046_financing_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/094_reconciliations_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's severity from /workspace/documents/06_financing/046_financing_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/094_reconciliations_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's primary_source from /workspace/documents/06_financing/046_financing_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/094_reconciliations_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/06_financing/046_financing_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/094_reconciliations_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-16 using the exact controlled facts ['114 records', '2025-12-15', '48 records', '2026-01-04'].", "id": "findings.F-16.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-16's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-16.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-29', 'Rafael Okafor'] for F-16.", "id": "findings.F-16.action_anchors"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Executive assessment' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Executive assessment"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Method and record coverage' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Method and record coverage"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Findings' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Findings"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Recommended next actions' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Recommended next actions"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Assumptions and limitations' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Assumptions and limitations"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-01 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-01"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-02 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-02"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-03 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-03"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-04 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-04"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-05 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-05"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-06 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-06"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-07 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-07"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-08 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-08"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-09 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-09"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-10 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-10"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-11 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-11"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-12 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-12"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-13 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-13"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-14 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-14"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-15 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-15"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-16 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-16"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Do not claim the production has no issues or that every record is consistent.", "id": "memo.forbidden_claims_absent"}], "decision_options": [{"id": "cross-source-reconciliation", "label": "Reconcile controlling and corroborating records", "reason": "The CB-RS-2808 production contains independently maintained records; a defensible answer must preserve each supported conflict and its cure owner.", "selected": true}, {"id": "latest-record-controls", "label": "Treat the latest record as controlling", "reason": "Timestamp recency does not establish legal priority, execution, or approval authority.", "selected": false}, {"id": "primary-records-only", "label": "Report primary records without reconciliation", "reason": "Primary records alone conceal the operational conflicts that create the actionable exceptions.", "selected": false}], "gates": ["all_evidence_read_in_full", "chain_of_custody_metadata_checked", "findings_criteria_complete", "memo_criteria_complete", "deliverables_written_through_mcp"], "metadata_checks": 8, "metric": "weighted_criteria_score", "minimum_tool_calls": 46, "required_deliverables": ["findings.json", "advice.md"], "required_document_reads": 33, "type": "deterministic", "weights": {"findings": 0.55, "memo": 0.2, "procedure": 0.25}}, "task_id": "cb100-048-harvest-paper", "task_name": "Harvest Paper mill restructuring audit", "world_id": "counselbench-filesystem-mcp-v2"}
-{"context_files": ["task_files/cb100-049-inlet-fitness/01_petition_schedules/001_petition_schedules_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-049-inlet-fitness/01_petition_schedules/002_petition_schedules_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-049-inlet-fitness/01_petition_schedules/003_petition_schedules_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-049-inlet-fitness/01_petition_schedules/004_petition_schedules_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-049-inlet-fitness/01_petition_schedules/005_petition_schedules_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-049-inlet-fitness/01_petition_schedules/006_petition_schedules_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-049-inlet-fitness/01_petition_schedules/007_petition_schedules_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-049-inlet-fitness/01_petition_schedules/008_petition_schedules_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-049-inlet-fitness/02_claims_register/009_claims_register_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-049-inlet-fitness/02_claims_register/010_claims_register_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-049-inlet-fitness/02_claims_register/011_claims_register_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-049-inlet-fitness/02_claims_register/012_claims_register_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-049-inlet-fitness/02_claims_register/013_claims_register_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-049-inlet-fitness/02_claims_register/014_claims_register_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-049-inlet-fitness/02_claims_register/015_claims_register_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-049-inlet-fitness/02_claims_register/016_claims_register_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-049-inlet-fitness/03_proofs_of_claim/017_proofs_of_claim_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-049-inlet-fitness/03_proofs_of_claim/018_proofs_of_claim_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-049-inlet-fitness/03_proofs_of_claim/019_proofs_of_claim_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-049-inlet-fitness/03_proofs_of_claim/020_proofs_of_claim_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-049-inlet-fitness/03_proofs_of_claim/021_proofs_of_claim_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-049-inlet-fitness/03_proofs_of_claim/022_proofs_of_claim_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-049-inlet-fitness/03_proofs_of_claim/023_proofs_of_claim_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-049-inlet-fitness/03_proofs_of_claim/024_proofs_of_claim_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-049-inlet-fitness/04_contracts_leases/025_contracts_leases_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-049-inlet-fitness/04_contracts_leases/026_contracts_leases_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-049-inlet-fitness/04_contracts_leases/027_contracts_leases_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-049-inlet-fitness/04_contracts_leases/028_contracts_leases_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-049-inlet-fitness/04_contracts_leases/029_contracts_leases_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-049-inlet-fitness/04_contracts_leases/030_contracts_leases_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-049-inlet-fitness/04_contracts_leases/031_contracts_leases_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-049-inlet-fitness/04_contracts_leases/032_contracts_leases_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-049-inlet-fitness/05_cash_management/033_cash_management_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-049-inlet-fitness/05_cash_management/034_cash_management_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-049-inlet-fitness/05_cash_management/035_cash_management_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-049-inlet-fitness/05_cash_management/036_cash_management_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-049-inlet-fitness/05_cash_management/037_cash_management_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-049-inlet-fitness/05_cash_management/038_cash_management_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-049-inlet-fitness/05_cash_management/039_cash_management_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-049-inlet-fitness/05_cash_management/040_cash_management_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-049-inlet-fitness/06_financing/041_financing_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-049-inlet-fitness/06_financing/042_financing_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-049-inlet-fitness/06_financing/043_financing_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-049-inlet-fitness/06_financing/044_financing_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-049-inlet-fitness/06_financing/045_financing_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-049-inlet-fitness/06_financing/046_financing_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-049-inlet-fitness/06_financing/047_financing_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-049-inlet-fitness/06_financing/048_financing_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-049-inlet-fitness/07_critical_vendors/049_critical_vendors_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-049-inlet-fitness/07_critical_vendors/050_critical_vendors_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-049-inlet-fitness/07_critical_vendors/051_critical_vendors_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-049-inlet-fitness/07_critical_vendors/052_critical_vendors_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-049-inlet-fitness/07_critical_vendors/053_critical_vendors_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-049-inlet-fitness/07_critical_vendors/054_critical_vendors_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-049-inlet-fitness/07_critical_vendors/055_critical_vendors_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-049-inlet-fitness/07_critical_vendors/056_critical_vendors_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-049-inlet-fitness/08_tax/057_tax_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-049-inlet-fitness/08_tax/058_tax_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-049-inlet-fitness/08_tax/059_tax_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-049-inlet-fitness/08_tax/060_tax_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-049-inlet-fitness/08_tax/061_tax_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-049-inlet-fitness/08_tax/062_tax_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-049-inlet-fitness/08_tax/063_tax_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-049-inlet-fitness/08_tax/064_tax_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-049-inlet-fitness/09_litigation/065_litigation_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-049-inlet-fitness/09_litigation/066_litigation_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-049-inlet-fitness/09_litigation/067_litigation_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-049-inlet-fitness/09_litigation/068_litigation_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-049-inlet-fitness/09_litigation/069_litigation_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-049-inlet-fitness/09_litigation/070_litigation_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-049-inlet-fitness/09_litigation/071_litigation_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-049-inlet-fitness/09_litigation/072_litigation_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-049-inlet-fitness/10_plan_disclosure/073_plan_disclosure_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-049-inlet-fitness/10_plan_disclosure/074_plan_disclosure_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-049-inlet-fitness/10_plan_disclosure/075_plan_disclosure_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-049-inlet-fitness/10_plan_disclosure/076_plan_disclosure_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-049-inlet-fitness/10_plan_disclosure/077_plan_disclosure_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-049-inlet-fitness/10_plan_disclosure/078_plan_disclosure_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-049-inlet-fitness/10_plan_disclosure/079_plan_disclosure_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-049-inlet-fitness/10_plan_disclosure/080_plan_disclosure_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-049-inlet-fitness/11_notices_ballots/081_notices_ballots_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-049-inlet-fitness/11_notices_ballots/082_notices_ballots_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-049-inlet-fitness/11_notices_ballots/083_notices_ballots_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-049-inlet-fitness/11_notices_ballots/084_notices_ballots_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-049-inlet-fitness/11_notices_ballots/085_notices_ballots_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-049-inlet-fitness/11_notices_ballots/086_notices_ballots_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-049-inlet-fitness/11_notices_ballots/087_notices_ballots_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-049-inlet-fitness/11_notices_ballots/088_notices_ballots_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-049-inlet-fitness/12_reconciliations/089_reconciliations_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-049-inlet-fitness/12_reconciliations/090_reconciliations_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-049-inlet-fitness/12_reconciliations/091_reconciliations_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-049-inlet-fitness/12_reconciliations/092_reconciliations_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-049-inlet-fitness/12_reconciliations/093_reconciliations_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-049-inlet-fitness/12_reconciliations/094_reconciliations_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-049-inlet-fitness/12_reconciliations/095_reconciliations_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-049-inlet-fitness/12_reconciliations/096_reconciliations_status_report.md"], "gold_output": {"advice_markdown": "# Counsel advice — Inlet Fitness lease claims review\n\n## Executive assessment\n\nFor Inlet Fitness Studios matter CB-RS-2809, the review identified 16 source-supported exceptions requiring action before 2026-10-02. The assessment concerns Urban Square Properties and the supplied record for California.\n\n## Method and record coverage\n\nThe review inventoried all 96 production files, read the 33 controlling, corroborating, and control records, searched the email exports, and checked metadata for the designated chain-of-custody sample. Conclusions are limited to the synthetic production supplied for this benchmark matter.\n\n## Findings\n\n### F-01 — scheduled-claim mismatch (critical)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for scheduled-claim mismatch: one source states the operative date is 2025-04-22 under control reference CB-RS-2809-A869, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2025-05-09 under response reference CB-RS-2809-J228.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/001_petition_schedules_control_register.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/07_critical_vendors/049_critical_vendors_control_register.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-10-02, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Isaac Romero.\n\n### F-02 — duplicate proof of claim (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for duplicate proof of claim: one source states the controlling amount is $6,029,913.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $6,136,326.00.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/004_petition_schedules_ledger_export.csv`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/07_critical_vendors/052_critical_vendors_ledger_export.csv`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-10-02, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Sofia Bennett.\n\n### F-03 — secured-status defect (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for secured-status defect: one source states approval is attributed to Talia Brooks as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Henry Cho and contains no entry for Talia Brooks.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/007_petition_schedules_officer_certificate.html`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/07_critical_vendors/055_critical_vendors_officer_certificate.html`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-10-02, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Adrian Mensah.\n\n### F-04 — priority classification error (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for priority classification error: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-RS-2809-D623, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-RS-2809-M901.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/02_claims_register/010_claims_register_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/08_tax/058_tax_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-10-02, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Willa Novak.\n\n### F-05 — executory-contract cure dispute (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for executory-contract cure dispute: one source states the applicable location is Central District of California Bankruptcy Court, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to California operations outside Central District of California Bankruptcy Court.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/02_claims_register/013_claims_register_review_memorandum.json`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/08_tax/061_tax_review_memorandum.json`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-10-02, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Theo Laurent.\n\n### F-06 — lease rejection deadline (low)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for lease rejection deadline: one source states the threshold is 6% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 10% and produced a different exception result.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/02_claims_register/016_claims_register_status_report.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/08_tax/064_tax_status_report.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-10-02, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Amara Patel.\n\n### F-07 — postpetition invoice (critical)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for postpetition invoice: one source states formal notice must use notices-inlet_fitness_studios@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-urban_square_properties@example.test.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/019_proofs_of_claim_correspondence.eml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/09_litigation/067_litigation_correspondence.eml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-10-02, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Henry Cho.\n\n### F-08 — critical-vendor overstatement (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for critical-vendor overstatement: one source states the governed population contains 105 records through 2025-03-01, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 52 records through 2025-03-25.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/022_proofs_of_claim_formal_notice.xml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/09_litigation/070_litigation_formal_notice.xml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-10-02, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Nadine Flores.\n\n### F-09 — setoff assertion (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for setoff assertion: one source states the operative date is 2025-01-27 under control reference CB-RS-2809-I904, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2025-02-17 under response reference CB-RS-2809-R161.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/025_contracts_leases_control_register.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/10_plan_disclosure/073_plan_disclosure_control_register.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-10-02, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Micah Sullivan.\n\n### F-10 — guaranty overlap (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for guaranty overlap: one source states the controlling amount is $1,992,353.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $2,231,206.00.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/028_contracts_leases_ledger_export.csv`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/10_plan_disclosure/076_plan_disclosure_ledger_export.csv`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-10-02, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Farah Ibrahim.\n\n### F-11 — tax priority period (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for tax priority period: one source states approval is attributed to Talia Brooks as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Caleb Hassan and contains no entry for Talia Brooks.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/031_contracts_leases_officer_certificate.html`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/10_plan_disclosure/079_plan_disclosure_officer_certificate.html`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-10-02, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Owen Delgado.\n\n### F-12 — DIP budget variance (low)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for DIP budget variance: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-RS-2809-L736, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-RS-2809-U841.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/05_cash_management/034_cash_management_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/11_notices_ballots/082_notices_ballots_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-10-02, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Lena Varga.\n\n### F-13 — cash-collateral reporting gap (critical)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for cash-collateral reporting gap: one source states the applicable location is Central District of California Bankruptcy Court, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to California operations outside Central District of California Bankruptcy Court.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/05_cash_management/037_cash_management_review_memorandum.json`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/11_notices_ballots/085_notices_ballots_review_memorandum.json`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-10-02, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Samuel Kim.\n\n### F-14 — ballot amount discrepancy (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for ballot amount discrepancy: one source states the threshold is 6% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 8% and produced a different exception result.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/05_cash_management/040_cash_management_status_report.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/11_notices_ballots/088_notices_ballots_status_report.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-10-02, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Maya Ellison.\n\n### F-15 — notice-address defect (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for notice-address defect: one source states formal notice must use notices-inlet_fitness_studios@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-urban_square_properties@example.test.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/06_financing/043_financing_correspondence.eml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/091_reconciliations_correspondence.eml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-10-02, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Rafael Okafor.\n\n### F-16 — reserve calculation error (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for reserve calculation error: one source states the governed population contains 128 records through 2025-03-24, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 52 records through 2025-04-17.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/06_financing/046_financing_formal_notice.xml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/094_reconciliations_formal_notice.xml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-10-02, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Nora Chen.\n\n## Recommended next actions\n\nSequence the critical and high findings first, assign the named owners, preserve the cited records, and document any resolution in the controlling matter register before the stated deadline.\n\n## Assumptions and limitations\n\nThis analysis is confined to task cb100-049-inlet-fitness and the supplied synthetic evidence. It does not rely on external facts, does not resolve disputed law, and is not legal advice for a real person or entity.\n", "findings": {"as_of": "2026-10-02", "findings": [{"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/07_critical_vendors/049_critical_vendors_control_register.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for scheduled-claim mismatch: one source states the operative date is 2025-04-22 under control reference CB-RS-2809-A869, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2025-05-09 under response reference CB-RS-2809-J228.", "id": "F-01", "issue": "scheduled-claim mismatch", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/001_petition_schedules_control_register.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-10-02, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Isaac Romero.", "severity": "critical"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/07_critical_vendors/052_critical_vendors_ledger_export.csv", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for duplicate proof of claim: one source states the controlling amount is $6,029,913.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $6,136,326.00.", "id": "F-02", "issue": "duplicate proof of claim", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/004_petition_schedules_ledger_export.csv", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-10-02, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Sofia Bennett.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/07_critical_vendors/055_critical_vendors_officer_certificate.html", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for secured-status defect: one source states approval is attributed to Talia Brooks as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Henry Cho and contains no entry for Talia Brooks.", "id": "F-03", "issue": "secured-status defect", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/007_petition_schedules_officer_certificate.html", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-10-02, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Adrian Mensah.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/08_tax/058_tax_executed_instrument.txt", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for priority classification error: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-RS-2809-D623, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-RS-2809-M901.", "id": "F-04", "issue": "priority classification error", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/02_claims_register/010_claims_register_executed_instrument.txt", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-10-02, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Willa Novak.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/08_tax/061_tax_review_memorandum.json", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for executory-contract cure dispute: one source states the applicable location is Central District of California Bankruptcy Court, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to California operations outside Central District of California Bankruptcy Court.", "id": "F-05", "issue": "executory-contract cure dispute", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/02_claims_register/013_claims_register_review_memorandum.json", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-10-02, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Theo Laurent.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/08_tax/064_tax_status_report.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for lease rejection deadline: one source states the threshold is 6% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 10% and produced a different exception result.", "id": "F-06", "issue": "lease rejection deadline", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/02_claims_register/016_claims_register_status_report.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-10-02, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Amara Patel.", "severity": "low"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/09_litigation/067_litigation_correspondence.eml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for postpetition invoice: one source states formal notice must use notices-inlet_fitness_studios@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-urban_square_properties@example.test.", "id": "F-07", "issue": "postpetition invoice", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/019_proofs_of_claim_correspondence.eml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-10-02, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Henry Cho.", "severity": "critical"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/09_litigation/070_litigation_formal_notice.xml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for critical-vendor overstatement: one source states the governed population contains 105 records through 2025-03-01, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 52 records through 2025-03-25.", "id": "F-08", "issue": "critical-vendor overstatement", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/022_proofs_of_claim_formal_notice.xml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-10-02, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Nadine Flores.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/10_plan_disclosure/073_plan_disclosure_control_register.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for setoff assertion: one source states the operative date is 2025-01-27 under control reference CB-RS-2809-I904, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2025-02-17 under response reference CB-RS-2809-R161.", "id": "F-09", "issue": "setoff assertion", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/025_contracts_leases_control_register.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-10-02, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Micah Sullivan.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/10_plan_disclosure/076_plan_disclosure_ledger_export.csv", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for guaranty overlap: one source states the controlling amount is $1,992,353.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $2,231,206.00.", "id": "F-10", "issue": "guaranty overlap", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/028_contracts_leases_ledger_export.csv", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-10-02, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Farah Ibrahim.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/10_plan_disclosure/079_plan_disclosure_officer_certificate.html", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for tax priority period: one source states approval is attributed to Talia Brooks as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Caleb Hassan and contains no entry for Talia Brooks.", "id": "F-11", "issue": "tax priority period", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/031_contracts_leases_officer_certificate.html", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-10-02, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Owen Delgado.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/11_notices_ballots/082_notices_ballots_executed_instrument.txt", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for DIP budget variance: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-RS-2809-L736, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-RS-2809-U841.", "id": "F-12", "issue": "DIP budget variance", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/05_cash_management/034_cash_management_executed_instrument.txt", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-10-02, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Lena Varga.", "severity": "low"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/11_notices_ballots/085_notices_ballots_review_memorandum.json", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for cash-collateral reporting gap: one source states the applicable location is Central District of California Bankruptcy Court, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to California operations outside Central District of California Bankruptcy Court.", "id": "F-13", "issue": "cash-collateral reporting gap", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/05_cash_management/037_cash_management_review_memorandum.json", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-10-02, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Samuel Kim.", "severity": "critical"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/11_notices_ballots/088_notices_ballots_status_report.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for ballot amount discrepancy: one source states the threshold is 6% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 8% and produced a different exception result.", "id": "F-14", "issue": "ballot amount discrepancy", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/05_cash_management/040_cash_management_status_report.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-10-02, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Maya Ellison.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/091_reconciliations_correspondence.eml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for notice-address defect: one source states formal notice must use notices-inlet_fitness_studios@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-urban_square_properties@example.test.", "id": "F-15", "issue": "notice-address defect", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/06_financing/043_financing_correspondence.eml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-10-02, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Rafael Okafor.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/094_reconciliations_formal_notice.xml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for reserve calculation error: one source states the governed population contains 128 records through 2025-03-24, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 52 records through 2025-04-17.", "id": "F-16", "issue": "reserve calculation error", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/06_financing/046_financing_formal_notice.xml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-10-02, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Nora Chen.", "severity": "medium"}], "matter_number": "CB-RS-2809", "prepared_for": "Inlet Fitness Studios", "schema_version": "1.0", "task_id": "cb100-049-inlet-fitness"}}, "metadata": {"benchmark": "CounselBench-100", "code_license": "Apache-2.0", "data_license": "CC-BY-4.0", "deadline": "2026-10-02", "document_count": 96, "jurisdiction": "California", "matter_number": "CB-RS-2809", "mcp_commit": "9a96ea6e5913736f92b88345bf51caeaaa8e719f", "mcp_package": "@modelcontextprotocol/server-filesystem@2026.7.10", "practice_area": "restructuring", "reference_tool_calls": 46, "required_evidence_reads": 33, "synthetic": true, "venue": "Central District of California Bankruptcy Court", "version": "2.0.0"}, "prompt": "You are debtor-side restructuring counsel for Inlet Fitness Studios. This matter will be reviewed by legal, finance, and compliance stakeholders who need a single source-grounded output. Studio leases, member refunds, and franchise obligations create duplicate and misclassified claims across the register. Decision due 2026-10-02. California law governs; Central District of California Bankruptcy Court is the forum. Use the production as of the stated deadline; do not assume facts outside the supplied files. Work out the defensible position from the matter production and leave an audit-ready exception tracker and concise advice for the supervising lawyer. Keep confirmed conflicts separate from open questions, cite the records that actually control each conclusion, and do not fill gaps with outside facts.", "rubric": {"criteria": [{"category": "procedure", "description": "Complete at least 46 successful, argument-specific evidence and output calls.", "id": "procedure.minimum_successful_tool_calls"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Find and read the 33 controlling, corroborating, and work-product-control records in full.", "id": "procedure.all_evidence_read_in_full"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Inspect file metadata for the eight designated critical primary records before relying on them.", "id": "procedure.chain_of_custody_metadata_checked"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Confirm the sandbox's allowed document and output roots.", "id": "procedure.allowed_directories_checked"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Inventory all 96 records so the relevant sources are discovered among the context records.", "id": "procedure.recursive_inventory_completed"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Search the production for email evidence that may corroborate or contradict formal records.", "id": "procedure.targeted_search_completed"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Leave only findings.json and advice.md in the output workspace.", "id": "procedure.exact_deliverable_set"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Create both final work products through the sandbox MCP surface.", "id": "procedure.deliverables_written_through_mcp"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Produce findings.json as a valid JSON object.", "id": "findings.findings_is_object"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Report exactly 16 confirmed exceptions.", "id": "findings.findings_exact_count"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Use each stable finding ID exactly once.", "id": "findings.finding_ids_unique"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set schema_version to the released matter value '1.0'.", "id": "findings.top_level_schema_version"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set task_id to the released matter value 'cb100-049-inlet-fitness'.", "id": "findings.top_level_task_id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set matter_number to the released matter value 'CB-RS-2809'.", "id": "findings.top_level_matter_number"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set prepared_for to the released matter value 'Inlet Fitness Studios'.", "id": "findings.top_level_prepared_for"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set as_of to the released matter value '2026-10-02'.", "id": "findings.top_level_as_of"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-01 exception for scheduled-claim mismatch.", "id": "findings.F-01.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's id from /workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/001_petition_schedules_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_critical_vendors/049_critical_vendors_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's issue from /workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/001_petition_schedules_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_critical_vendors/049_critical_vendors_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's severity from /workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/001_petition_schedules_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_critical_vendors/049_critical_vendors_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's primary_source from /workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/001_petition_schedules_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_critical_vendors/049_critical_vendors_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/001_petition_schedules_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_critical_vendors/049_critical_vendors_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-01 using the exact controlled facts ['2025-04-22', 'CB-RS-2809-A869', '2025-05-09', 'CB-RS-2809-J228'].", "id": "findings.F-01.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-01's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-01.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-10-02', 'Isaac Romero'] for F-01.", "id": "findings.F-01.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-02 exception for duplicate proof of claim.", "id": "findings.F-02.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's id from /workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/004_petition_schedules_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_critical_vendors/052_critical_vendors_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's issue from /workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/004_petition_schedules_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_critical_vendors/052_critical_vendors_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's severity from /workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/004_petition_schedules_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_critical_vendors/052_critical_vendors_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's primary_source from /workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/004_petition_schedules_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_critical_vendors/052_critical_vendors_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/004_petition_schedules_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_critical_vendors/052_critical_vendors_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-02 using the exact controlled facts ['$6,029,913.00', '$6,136,326.00'].", "id": "findings.F-02.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-02's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-02.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-10-02', 'Sofia Bennett'] for F-02.", "id": "findings.F-02.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-03 exception for secured-status defect.", "id": "findings.F-03.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's id from /workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/007_petition_schedules_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_critical_vendors/055_critical_vendors_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's issue from /workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/007_petition_schedules_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_critical_vendors/055_critical_vendors_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's severity from /workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/007_petition_schedules_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_critical_vendors/055_critical_vendors_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's primary_source from /workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/007_petition_schedules_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_critical_vendors/055_critical_vendors_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/007_petition_schedules_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_critical_vendors/055_critical_vendors_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-03 using the exact controlled facts ['Talia Brooks', 'Henry Cho'].", "id": "findings.F-03.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-03's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-03.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-10-02', 'Adrian Mensah'] for F-03.", "id": "findings.F-03.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-04 exception for priority classification error.", "id": "findings.F-04.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's id from /workspace/documents/02_claims_register/010_claims_register_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_tax/058_tax_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's issue from /workspace/documents/02_claims_register/010_claims_register_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_tax/058_tax_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's severity from /workspace/documents/02_claims_register/010_claims_register_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_tax/058_tax_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's primary_source from /workspace/documents/02_claims_register/010_claims_register_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_tax/058_tax_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/02_claims_register/010_claims_register_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_tax/058_tax_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-04 using the exact controlled facts ['closed without exception', 'CB-RS-2809-D623', 'open and escalated', 'CB-RS-2809-M901'].", "id": "findings.F-04.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-04's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-04.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-10-02', 'Willa Novak'] for F-04.", "id": "findings.F-04.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-05 exception for executory-contract cure dispute.", "id": "findings.F-05.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's id from /workspace/documents/02_claims_register/013_claims_register_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_tax/061_tax_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's issue from /workspace/documents/02_claims_register/013_claims_register_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_tax/061_tax_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's severity from /workspace/documents/02_claims_register/013_claims_register_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_tax/061_tax_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's primary_source from /workspace/documents/02_claims_register/013_claims_register_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_tax/061_tax_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/02_claims_register/013_claims_register_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_tax/061_tax_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-05 using the exact controlled facts ['Central District of California Bankruptcy Court', 'California'].", "id": "findings.F-05.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-05's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-05.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-10-02', 'Theo Laurent'] for F-05.", "id": "findings.F-05.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-06 exception for lease rejection deadline.", "id": "findings.F-06.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's id from /workspace/documents/02_claims_register/016_claims_register_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_tax/064_tax_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's issue from /workspace/documents/02_claims_register/016_claims_register_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_tax/064_tax_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's severity from /workspace/documents/02_claims_register/016_claims_register_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_tax/064_tax_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's primary_source from /workspace/documents/02_claims_register/016_claims_register_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_tax/064_tax_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/02_claims_register/016_claims_register_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_tax/064_tax_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-06 using the exact controlled facts ['6%', '10%'].", "id": "findings.F-06.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-06's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-06.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-10-02', 'Amara Patel'] for F-06.", "id": "findings.F-06.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-07 exception for postpetition invoice.", "id": "findings.F-07.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's id from /workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/019_proofs_of_claim_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_litigation/067_litigation_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's issue from /workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/019_proofs_of_claim_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_litigation/067_litigation_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's severity from /workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/019_proofs_of_claim_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_litigation/067_litigation_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's primary_source from /workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/019_proofs_of_claim_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_litigation/067_litigation_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/019_proofs_of_claim_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_litigation/067_litigation_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-07 using the exact controlled facts ['notices-inlet_fitness_studios@example.test', 'archive-urban_square_properties@example.test'].", "id": "findings.F-07.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-07's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-07.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-10-02', 'Henry Cho'] for F-07.", "id": "findings.F-07.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-08 exception for critical-vendor overstatement.", "id": "findings.F-08.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's id from /workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/022_proofs_of_claim_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_litigation/070_litigation_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's issue from /workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/022_proofs_of_claim_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_litigation/070_litigation_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's severity from /workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/022_proofs_of_claim_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_litigation/070_litigation_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's primary_source from /workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/022_proofs_of_claim_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_litigation/070_litigation_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/022_proofs_of_claim_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_litigation/070_litigation_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-08 using the exact controlled facts ['105 records', '2025-03-01', '52 records', '2025-03-25'].", "id": "findings.F-08.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-08's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-08.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-10-02', 'Nadine Flores'] for F-08.", "id": "findings.F-08.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-09 exception for setoff assertion.", "id": "findings.F-09.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's id from /workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/025_contracts_leases_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_plan_disclosure/073_plan_disclosure_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's issue from /workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/025_contracts_leases_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_plan_disclosure/073_plan_disclosure_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's severity from /workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/025_contracts_leases_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_plan_disclosure/073_plan_disclosure_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's primary_source from /workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/025_contracts_leases_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_plan_disclosure/073_plan_disclosure_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/025_contracts_leases_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_plan_disclosure/073_plan_disclosure_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-09 using the exact controlled facts ['2025-01-27', 'CB-RS-2809-I904', '2025-02-17', 'CB-RS-2809-R161'].", "id": "findings.F-09.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-09's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-09.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-10-02', 'Micah Sullivan'] for F-09.", "id": "findings.F-09.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-10 exception for guaranty overlap.", "id": "findings.F-10.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's id from /workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/028_contracts_leases_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_plan_disclosure/076_plan_disclosure_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's issue from /workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/028_contracts_leases_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_plan_disclosure/076_plan_disclosure_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's severity from /workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/028_contracts_leases_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_plan_disclosure/076_plan_disclosure_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's primary_source from /workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/028_contracts_leases_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_plan_disclosure/076_plan_disclosure_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/028_contracts_leases_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_plan_disclosure/076_plan_disclosure_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-10 using the exact controlled facts ['$1,992,353.00', '$2,231,206.00'].", "id": "findings.F-10.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-10's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-10.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-10-02', 'Farah Ibrahim'] for F-10.", "id": "findings.F-10.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-11 exception for tax priority period.", "id": "findings.F-11.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's id from /workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/031_contracts_leases_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_plan_disclosure/079_plan_disclosure_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's issue from /workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/031_contracts_leases_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_plan_disclosure/079_plan_disclosure_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's severity from /workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/031_contracts_leases_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_plan_disclosure/079_plan_disclosure_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's primary_source from /workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/031_contracts_leases_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_plan_disclosure/079_plan_disclosure_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/031_contracts_leases_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_plan_disclosure/079_plan_disclosure_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-11 using the exact controlled facts ['Talia Brooks', 'Caleb Hassan'].", "id": "findings.F-11.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-11's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-11.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-10-02', 'Owen Delgado'] for F-11.", "id": "findings.F-11.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-12 exception for DIP budget variance.", "id": "findings.F-12.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's id from /workspace/documents/05_cash_management/034_cash_management_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_notices_ballots/082_notices_ballots_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's issue from /workspace/documents/05_cash_management/034_cash_management_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_notices_ballots/082_notices_ballots_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's severity from /workspace/documents/05_cash_management/034_cash_management_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_notices_ballots/082_notices_ballots_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's primary_source from /workspace/documents/05_cash_management/034_cash_management_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_notices_ballots/082_notices_ballots_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/05_cash_management/034_cash_management_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_notices_ballots/082_notices_ballots_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-12 using the exact controlled facts ['closed without exception', 'CB-RS-2809-L736', 'open and escalated', 'CB-RS-2809-U841'].", "id": "findings.F-12.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-12's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-12.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-10-02', 'Lena Varga'] for F-12.", "id": "findings.F-12.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-13 exception for cash-collateral reporting gap.", "id": "findings.F-13.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's id from /workspace/documents/05_cash_management/037_cash_management_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_notices_ballots/085_notices_ballots_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's issue from /workspace/documents/05_cash_management/037_cash_management_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_notices_ballots/085_notices_ballots_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's severity from /workspace/documents/05_cash_management/037_cash_management_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_notices_ballots/085_notices_ballots_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's primary_source from /workspace/documents/05_cash_management/037_cash_management_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_notices_ballots/085_notices_ballots_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/05_cash_management/037_cash_management_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_notices_ballots/085_notices_ballots_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-13 using the exact controlled facts ['Central District of California Bankruptcy Court', 'California'].", "id": "findings.F-13.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-13's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-13.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-10-02', 'Samuel Kim'] for F-13.", "id": "findings.F-13.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-14 exception for ballot amount discrepancy.", "id": "findings.F-14.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's id from /workspace/documents/05_cash_management/040_cash_management_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_notices_ballots/088_notices_ballots_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's issue from /workspace/documents/05_cash_management/040_cash_management_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_notices_ballots/088_notices_ballots_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's severity from /workspace/documents/05_cash_management/040_cash_management_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_notices_ballots/088_notices_ballots_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's primary_source from /workspace/documents/05_cash_management/040_cash_management_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_notices_ballots/088_notices_ballots_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/05_cash_management/040_cash_management_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_notices_ballots/088_notices_ballots_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-14 using the exact controlled facts ['6%', '8%'].", "id": "findings.F-14.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-14's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-14.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-10-02', 'Maya Ellison'] for F-14.", "id": "findings.F-14.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-15 exception for notice-address defect.", "id": "findings.F-15.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's id from /workspace/documents/06_financing/043_financing_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/091_reconciliations_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's issue from /workspace/documents/06_financing/043_financing_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/091_reconciliations_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's severity from /workspace/documents/06_financing/043_financing_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/091_reconciliations_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's primary_source from /workspace/documents/06_financing/043_financing_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/091_reconciliations_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/06_financing/043_financing_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/091_reconciliations_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-15 using the exact controlled facts ['notices-inlet_fitness_studios@example.test', 'archive-urban_square_properties@example.test'].", "id": "findings.F-15.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-15's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-15.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-10-02', 'Rafael Okafor'] for F-15.", "id": "findings.F-15.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-16 exception for reserve calculation error.", "id": "findings.F-16.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's id from /workspace/documents/06_financing/046_financing_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/094_reconciliations_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's issue from /workspace/documents/06_financing/046_financing_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/094_reconciliations_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's severity from /workspace/documents/06_financing/046_financing_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/094_reconciliations_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's primary_source from /workspace/documents/06_financing/046_financing_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/094_reconciliations_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/06_financing/046_financing_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/094_reconciliations_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-16 using the exact controlled facts ['128 records', '2025-03-24', '52 records', '2025-04-17'].", "id": "findings.F-16.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-16's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-16.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-10-02', 'Nora Chen'] for F-16.", "id": "findings.F-16.action_anchors"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Executive assessment' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Executive assessment"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Method and record coverage' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Method and record coverage"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Findings' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Findings"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Recommended next actions' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Recommended next actions"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Assumptions and limitations' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Assumptions and limitations"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-01 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-01"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-02 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-02"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-03 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-03"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-04 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-04"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-05 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-05"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-06 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-06"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-07 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-07"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-08 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-08"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-09 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-09"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-10 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-10"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-11 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-11"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-12 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-12"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-13 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-13"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-14 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-14"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-15 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-15"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-16 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-16"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Do not claim the production has no issues or that every record is consistent.", "id": "memo.forbidden_claims_absent"}], "decision_options": [{"id": "cross-source-reconciliation", "label": "Reconcile controlling and corroborating records", "reason": "The CB-RS-2809 production contains independently maintained records; a defensible answer must preserve each supported conflict and its cure owner.", "selected": true}, {"id": "latest-record-controls", "label": "Treat the latest record as controlling", "reason": "Timestamp recency does not establish legal priority, execution, or approval authority.", "selected": false}, {"id": "primary-records-only", "label": "Report primary records without reconciliation", "reason": "Primary records alone conceal the operational conflicts that create the actionable exceptions.", "selected": false}], "gates": ["all_evidence_read_in_full", "chain_of_custody_metadata_checked", "findings_criteria_complete", "memo_criteria_complete", "deliverables_written_through_mcp"], "metadata_checks": 8, "metric": "weighted_criteria_score", "minimum_tool_calls": 46, "required_deliverables": ["findings.json", "advice.md"], "required_document_reads": 33, "type": "deterministic", "weights": {"findings": 0.55, "memo": 0.2, "procedure": 0.25}}, "task_id": "cb100-049-inlet-fitness", "task_name": "Inlet Fitness lease claims review", "world_id": "counselbench-filesystem-mcp-v2"}
-{"context_files": ["task_files/cb100-050-keystone-press/01_petition_schedules/001_petition_schedules_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-050-keystone-press/01_petition_schedules/002_petition_schedules_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-050-keystone-press/01_petition_schedules/003_petition_schedules_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-050-keystone-press/01_petition_schedules/004_petition_schedules_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-050-keystone-press/01_petition_schedules/005_petition_schedules_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-050-keystone-press/01_petition_schedules/006_petition_schedules_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-050-keystone-press/01_petition_schedules/007_petition_schedules_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-050-keystone-press/01_petition_schedules/008_petition_schedules_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-050-keystone-press/02_claims_register/009_claims_register_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-050-keystone-press/02_claims_register/010_claims_register_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-050-keystone-press/02_claims_register/011_claims_register_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-050-keystone-press/02_claims_register/012_claims_register_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-050-keystone-press/02_claims_register/013_claims_register_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-050-keystone-press/02_claims_register/014_claims_register_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-050-keystone-press/02_claims_register/015_claims_register_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-050-keystone-press/02_claims_register/016_claims_register_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-050-keystone-press/03_proofs_of_claim/017_proofs_of_claim_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-050-keystone-press/03_proofs_of_claim/018_proofs_of_claim_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-050-keystone-press/03_proofs_of_claim/019_proofs_of_claim_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-050-keystone-press/03_proofs_of_claim/020_proofs_of_claim_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-050-keystone-press/03_proofs_of_claim/021_proofs_of_claim_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-050-keystone-press/03_proofs_of_claim/022_proofs_of_claim_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-050-keystone-press/03_proofs_of_claim/023_proofs_of_claim_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-050-keystone-press/03_proofs_of_claim/024_proofs_of_claim_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-050-keystone-press/04_contracts_leases/025_contracts_leases_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-050-keystone-press/04_contracts_leases/026_contracts_leases_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-050-keystone-press/04_contracts_leases/027_contracts_leases_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-050-keystone-press/04_contracts_leases/028_contracts_leases_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-050-keystone-press/04_contracts_leases/029_contracts_leases_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-050-keystone-press/04_contracts_leases/030_contracts_leases_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-050-keystone-press/04_contracts_leases/031_contracts_leases_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-050-keystone-press/04_contracts_leases/032_contracts_leases_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-050-keystone-press/05_cash_management/033_cash_management_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-050-keystone-press/05_cash_management/034_cash_management_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-050-keystone-press/05_cash_management/035_cash_management_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-050-keystone-press/05_cash_management/036_cash_management_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-050-keystone-press/05_cash_management/037_cash_management_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-050-keystone-press/05_cash_management/038_cash_management_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-050-keystone-press/05_cash_management/039_cash_management_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-050-keystone-press/05_cash_management/040_cash_management_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-050-keystone-press/06_financing/041_financing_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-050-keystone-press/06_financing/042_financing_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-050-keystone-press/06_financing/043_financing_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-050-keystone-press/06_financing/044_financing_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-050-keystone-press/06_financing/045_financing_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-050-keystone-press/06_financing/046_financing_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-050-keystone-press/06_financing/047_financing_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-050-keystone-press/06_financing/048_financing_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-050-keystone-press/07_critical_vendors/049_critical_vendors_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-050-keystone-press/07_critical_vendors/050_critical_vendors_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-050-keystone-press/07_critical_vendors/051_critical_vendors_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-050-keystone-press/07_critical_vendors/052_critical_vendors_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-050-keystone-press/07_critical_vendors/053_critical_vendors_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-050-keystone-press/07_critical_vendors/054_critical_vendors_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-050-keystone-press/07_critical_vendors/055_critical_vendors_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-050-keystone-press/07_critical_vendors/056_critical_vendors_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-050-keystone-press/08_tax/057_tax_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-050-keystone-press/08_tax/058_tax_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-050-keystone-press/08_tax/059_tax_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-050-keystone-press/08_tax/060_tax_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-050-keystone-press/08_tax/061_tax_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-050-keystone-press/08_tax/062_tax_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-050-keystone-press/08_tax/063_tax_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-050-keystone-press/08_tax/064_tax_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-050-keystone-press/09_litigation/065_litigation_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-050-keystone-press/09_litigation/066_litigation_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-050-keystone-press/09_litigation/067_litigation_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-050-keystone-press/09_litigation/068_litigation_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-050-keystone-press/09_litigation/069_litigation_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-050-keystone-press/09_litigation/070_litigation_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-050-keystone-press/09_litigation/071_litigation_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-050-keystone-press/09_litigation/072_litigation_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-050-keystone-press/10_plan_disclosure/073_plan_disclosure_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-050-keystone-press/10_plan_disclosure/074_plan_disclosure_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-050-keystone-press/10_plan_disclosure/075_plan_disclosure_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-050-keystone-press/10_plan_disclosure/076_plan_disclosure_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-050-keystone-press/10_plan_disclosure/077_plan_disclosure_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-050-keystone-press/10_plan_disclosure/078_plan_disclosure_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-050-keystone-press/10_plan_disclosure/079_plan_disclosure_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-050-keystone-press/10_plan_disclosure/080_plan_disclosure_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-050-keystone-press/11_notices_ballots/081_notices_ballots_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-050-keystone-press/11_notices_ballots/082_notices_ballots_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-050-keystone-press/11_notices_ballots/083_notices_ballots_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-050-keystone-press/11_notices_ballots/084_notices_ballots_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-050-keystone-press/11_notices_ballots/085_notices_ballots_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-050-keystone-press/11_notices_ballots/086_notices_ballots_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-050-keystone-press/11_notices_ballots/087_notices_ballots_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-050-keystone-press/11_notices_ballots/088_notices_ballots_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-050-keystone-press/12_reconciliations/089_reconciliations_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-050-keystone-press/12_reconciliations/090_reconciliations_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-050-keystone-press/12_reconciliations/091_reconciliations_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-050-keystone-press/12_reconciliations/092_reconciliations_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-050-keystone-press/12_reconciliations/093_reconciliations_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-050-keystone-press/12_reconciliations/094_reconciliations_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-050-keystone-press/12_reconciliations/095_reconciliations_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-050-keystone-press/12_reconciliations/096_reconciliations_status_report.md"], "gold_output": {"advice_markdown": "# Counsel advice — Keystone Press disclosure reconciliation\n\n## Executive assessment\n\nFor Keystone Regional Press matter CB-RS-2810, the review identified 16 source-supported exceptions requiring action before 2026-10-06. The assessment concerns Commonwealth Newsprint Pension Trust and the supplied record for Pennsylvania.\n\n## Method and record coverage\n\nThe review inventoried all 96 production files, read the 33 controlling, corroborating, and control records, searched the email exports, and checked metadata for the designated chain-of-custody sample. Conclusions are limited to the synthetic production supplied for this benchmark matter.\n\n## Findings\n\n### F-01 — scheduled-claim mismatch (critical)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for scheduled-claim mismatch: one source states the operative date is 2025-08-30 under control reference CB-RS-2810-A759, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2025-09-11 under response reference CB-RS-2810-J496.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/001_petition_schedules_control_register.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/07_critical_vendors/049_critical_vendors_control_register.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-10-06, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Sofia Bennett.\n\n### F-02 — duplicate proof of claim (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for duplicate proof of claim: one source states the controlling amount is $5,383,273.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $5,603,046.00.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/004_petition_schedules_ledger_export.csv`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/07_critical_vendors/052_critical_vendors_ledger_export.csv`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-10-06, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Adrian Mensah.\n\n### F-03 — secured-status defect (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for secured-status defect: one source states approval is attributed to Jonas Feld as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Micah Sullivan and contains no entry for Jonas Feld.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/007_petition_schedules_officer_certificate.html`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/07_critical_vendors/055_critical_vendors_officer_certificate.html`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-10-06, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Willa Novak.\n\n### F-04 — priority classification error (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for priority classification error: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-RS-2810-D802, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-RS-2810-M500.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/02_claims_register/010_claims_register_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/08_tax/058_tax_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-10-06, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Theo Laurent.\n\n### F-05 — executory-contract cure dispute (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for executory-contract cure dispute: one source states the applicable location is Eastern District of Pennsylvania Bankruptcy Court, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to Pennsylvania operations outside Eastern District of Pennsylvania Bankruptcy Court.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/02_claims_register/013_claims_register_review_memorandum.json`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/08_tax/061_tax_review_memorandum.json`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-10-06, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Amara Patel.\n\n### F-06 — lease rejection deadline (low)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for lease rejection deadline: one source states the threshold is 10% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 16% and produced a different exception result.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/02_claims_register/016_claims_register_status_report.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/08_tax/064_tax_status_report.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-10-06, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Henry Cho.\n\n### F-07 — postpetition invoice (critical)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for postpetition invoice: one source states formal notice must use notices-keystone_regional_press@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-commonwealth_newsprint_pension_trust@example.test.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/019_proofs_of_claim_correspondence.eml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/09_litigation/067_litigation_correspondence.eml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-10-06, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Nadine Flores.\n\n### F-08 — critical-vendor overstatement (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for critical-vendor overstatement: one source states the governed population contains 104 records through 2025-12-05, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 70 records through 2026-01-16.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/022_proofs_of_claim_formal_notice.xml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/09_litigation/070_litigation_formal_notice.xml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-10-06, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Micah Sullivan.\n\n### F-09 — setoff assertion (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for setoff assertion: one source states the operative date is 2025-01-28 under control reference CB-RS-2810-I245, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2025-03-02 under response reference CB-RS-2810-R526.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/025_contracts_leases_control_register.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/10_plan_disclosure/073_plan_disclosure_control_register.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-10-06, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Farah Ibrahim.\n\n### F-10 — guaranty overlap (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for guaranty overlap: one source states the controlling amount is $5,539,571.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $5,705,642.00.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/028_contracts_leases_ledger_export.csv`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/10_plan_disclosure/076_plan_disclosure_ledger_export.csv`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-10-06, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Owen Delgado.\n\n### F-11 — tax priority period (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for tax priority period: one source states approval is attributed to Jonas Feld as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Isaac Romero and contains no entry for Jonas Feld.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/031_contracts_leases_officer_certificate.html`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/10_plan_disclosure/079_plan_disclosure_officer_certificate.html`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-10-06, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Lena Varga.\n\n### F-12 — DIP budget variance (low)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for DIP budget variance: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-RS-2810-L744, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-RS-2810-U841.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/05_cash_management/034_cash_management_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/11_notices_ballots/082_notices_ballots_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-10-06, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Samuel Kim.\n\n### F-13 — cash-collateral reporting gap (critical)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for cash-collateral reporting gap: one source states the applicable location is Eastern District of Pennsylvania Bankruptcy Court, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to Pennsylvania operations outside Eastern District of Pennsylvania Bankruptcy Court.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/05_cash_management/037_cash_management_review_memorandum.json`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/11_notices_ballots/085_notices_ballots_review_memorandum.json`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-10-06, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Maya Ellison.\n\n### F-14 — ballot amount discrepancy (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for ballot amount discrepancy: one source states the threshold is 10% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 16% and produced a different exception result.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/05_cash_management/040_cash_management_status_report.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/11_notices_ballots/088_notices_ballots_status_report.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-10-06, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Rafael Okafor.\n\n### F-15 — notice-address defect (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for notice-address defect: one source states formal notice must use notices-keystone_regional_press@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-commonwealth_newsprint_pension_trust@example.test.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/06_financing/043_financing_correspondence.eml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/091_reconciliations_correspondence.eml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-10-06, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Nora Chen.\n\n### F-16 — reserve calculation error (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for reserve calculation error: one source states the governed population contains 65 records through 2025-01-20, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 56 records through 2025-02-17.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/06_financing/046_financing_formal_notice.xml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/094_reconciliations_formal_notice.xml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-10-06, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Dominic Alvarez.\n\n## Recommended next actions\n\nSequence the critical and high findings first, assign the named owners, preserve the cited records, and document any resolution in the controlling matter register before the stated deadline.\n\n## Assumptions and limitations\n\nThis analysis is confined to task cb100-050-keystone-press and the supplied synthetic evidence. It does not rely on external facts, does not resolve disputed law, and is not legal advice for a real person or entity.\n", "findings": {"as_of": "2026-10-06", "findings": [{"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/07_critical_vendors/049_critical_vendors_control_register.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for scheduled-claim mismatch: one source states the operative date is 2025-08-30 under control reference CB-RS-2810-A759, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2025-09-11 under response reference CB-RS-2810-J496.", "id": "F-01", "issue": "scheduled-claim mismatch", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/001_petition_schedules_control_register.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-10-06, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Sofia Bennett.", "severity": "critical"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/07_critical_vendors/052_critical_vendors_ledger_export.csv", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for duplicate proof of claim: one source states the controlling amount is $5,383,273.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $5,603,046.00.", "id": "F-02", "issue": "duplicate proof of claim", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/004_petition_schedules_ledger_export.csv", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-10-06, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Adrian Mensah.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/07_critical_vendors/055_critical_vendors_officer_certificate.html", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for secured-status defect: one source states approval is attributed to Jonas Feld as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Micah Sullivan and contains no entry for Jonas Feld.", "id": "F-03", "issue": "secured-status defect", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/007_petition_schedules_officer_certificate.html", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-10-06, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Willa Novak.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/08_tax/058_tax_executed_instrument.txt", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for priority classification error: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-RS-2810-D802, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-RS-2810-M500.", "id": "F-04", "issue": "priority classification error", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/02_claims_register/010_claims_register_executed_instrument.txt", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-10-06, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Theo Laurent.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/08_tax/061_tax_review_memorandum.json", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for executory-contract cure dispute: one source states the applicable location is Eastern District of Pennsylvania Bankruptcy Court, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to Pennsylvania operations outside Eastern District of Pennsylvania Bankruptcy Court.", "id": "F-05", "issue": "executory-contract cure dispute", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/02_claims_register/013_claims_register_review_memorandum.json", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-10-06, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Amara Patel.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/08_tax/064_tax_status_report.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for lease rejection deadline: one source states the threshold is 10% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 16% and produced a different exception result.", "id": "F-06", "issue": "lease rejection deadline", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/02_claims_register/016_claims_register_status_report.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-10-06, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Henry Cho.", "severity": "low"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/09_litigation/067_litigation_correspondence.eml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for postpetition invoice: one source states formal notice must use notices-keystone_regional_press@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-commonwealth_newsprint_pension_trust@example.test.", "id": "F-07", "issue": "postpetition invoice", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/019_proofs_of_claim_correspondence.eml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-10-06, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Nadine Flores.", "severity": "critical"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/09_litigation/070_litigation_formal_notice.xml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for critical-vendor overstatement: one source states the governed population contains 104 records through 2025-12-05, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 70 records through 2026-01-16.", "id": "F-08", "issue": "critical-vendor overstatement", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/022_proofs_of_claim_formal_notice.xml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-10-06, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Micah Sullivan.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/10_plan_disclosure/073_plan_disclosure_control_register.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for setoff assertion: one source states the operative date is 2025-01-28 under control reference CB-RS-2810-I245, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2025-03-02 under response reference CB-RS-2810-R526.", "id": "F-09", "issue": "setoff assertion", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/025_contracts_leases_control_register.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-10-06, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Farah Ibrahim.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/10_plan_disclosure/076_plan_disclosure_ledger_export.csv", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for guaranty overlap: one source states the controlling amount is $5,539,571.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $5,705,642.00.", "id": "F-10", "issue": "guaranty overlap", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/028_contracts_leases_ledger_export.csv", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-10-06, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Owen Delgado.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/10_plan_disclosure/079_plan_disclosure_officer_certificate.html", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for tax priority period: one source states approval is attributed to Jonas Feld as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Isaac Romero and contains no entry for Jonas Feld.", "id": "F-11", "issue": "tax priority period", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/031_contracts_leases_officer_certificate.html", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-10-06, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Lena Varga.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/11_notices_ballots/082_notices_ballots_executed_instrument.txt", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for DIP budget variance: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-RS-2810-L744, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-RS-2810-U841.", "id": "F-12", "issue": "DIP budget variance", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/05_cash_management/034_cash_management_executed_instrument.txt", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-10-06, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Samuel Kim.", "severity": "low"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/11_notices_ballots/085_notices_ballots_review_memorandum.json", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for cash-collateral reporting gap: one source states the applicable location is Eastern District of Pennsylvania Bankruptcy Court, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to Pennsylvania operations outside Eastern District of Pennsylvania Bankruptcy Court.", "id": "F-13", "issue": "cash-collateral reporting gap", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/05_cash_management/037_cash_management_review_memorandum.json", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-10-06, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Maya Ellison.", "severity": "critical"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/11_notices_ballots/088_notices_ballots_status_report.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for ballot amount discrepancy: one source states the threshold is 10% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 16% and produced a different exception result.", "id": "F-14", "issue": "ballot amount discrepancy", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/05_cash_management/040_cash_management_status_report.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-10-06, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Rafael Okafor.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/091_reconciliations_correspondence.eml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for notice-address defect: one source states formal notice must use notices-keystone_regional_press@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-commonwealth_newsprint_pension_trust@example.test.", "id": "F-15", "issue": "notice-address defect", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/06_financing/043_financing_correspondence.eml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-10-06, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Nora Chen.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/094_reconciliations_formal_notice.xml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for reserve calculation error: one source states the governed population contains 65 records through 2025-01-20, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 56 records through 2025-02-17.", "id": "F-16", "issue": "reserve calculation error", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/06_financing/046_financing_formal_notice.xml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-10-06, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Dominic Alvarez.", "severity": "medium"}], "matter_number": "CB-RS-2810", "prepared_for": "Keystone Regional Press", "schema_version": "1.0", "task_id": "cb100-050-keystone-press"}}, "metadata": {"benchmark": "CounselBench-100", "code_license": "Apache-2.0", "data_license": "CC-BY-4.0", "deadline": "2026-10-06", "document_count": 96, "jurisdiction": "Pennsylvania", "matter_number": "CB-RS-2810", "mcp_commit": "9a96ea6e5913736f92b88345bf51caeaaa8e719f", "mcp_package": "@modelcontextprotocol/server-filesystem@2026.7.10", "practice_area": "restructuring", "reference_tool_calls": 46, "required_evidence_reads": 33, "synthetic": true, "venue": "Eastern District of Pennsylvania Bankruptcy Court", "version": "2.0.0"}, "prompt": "You are debtor-side restructuring counsel for Keystone Regional Press. The record contains amendments, exports, and correspondence from different custodians; reconcile them into an actionable counsel work product. Pension, newsprint, tax, and litigation claims must be reconciled before disclosure-statement and ballot deadlines. Decision due 2026-10-06. Pennsylvania law governs; Eastern District of Pennsylvania Bankruptcy Court is the forum. Write for a supervising lawyer who will spot-check source paths and exact values. Work out the defensible position from the matter production and leave an audit-ready exception tracker and concise advice for the supervising lawyer. Keep confirmed conflicts separate from open questions, cite the records that actually control each conclusion, and do not fill gaps with outside facts.", "rubric": {"criteria": [{"category": "procedure", "description": "Complete at least 46 successful, argument-specific evidence and output calls.", "id": "procedure.minimum_successful_tool_calls"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Find and read the 33 controlling, corroborating, and work-product-control records in full.", "id": "procedure.all_evidence_read_in_full"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Inspect file metadata for the eight designated critical primary records before relying on them.", "id": "procedure.chain_of_custody_metadata_checked"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Confirm the sandbox's allowed document and output roots.", "id": "procedure.allowed_directories_checked"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Inventory all 96 records so the relevant sources are discovered among the context records.", "id": "procedure.recursive_inventory_completed"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Search the production for email evidence that may corroborate or contradict formal records.", "id": "procedure.targeted_search_completed"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Leave only findings.json and advice.md in the output workspace.", "id": "procedure.exact_deliverable_set"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Create both final work products through the sandbox MCP surface.", "id": "procedure.deliverables_written_through_mcp"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Produce findings.json as a valid JSON object.", "id": "findings.findings_is_object"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Report exactly 16 confirmed exceptions.", "id": "findings.findings_exact_count"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Use each stable finding ID exactly once.", "id": "findings.finding_ids_unique"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set schema_version to the released matter value '1.0'.", "id": "findings.top_level_schema_version"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set task_id to the released matter value 'cb100-050-keystone-press'.", "id": "findings.top_level_task_id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set matter_number to the released matter value 'CB-RS-2810'.", "id": "findings.top_level_matter_number"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set prepared_for to the released matter value 'Keystone Regional Press'.", "id": "findings.top_level_prepared_for"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set as_of to the released matter value '2026-10-06'.", "id": "findings.top_level_as_of"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-01 exception for scheduled-claim mismatch.", "id": "findings.F-01.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's id from /workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/001_petition_schedules_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_critical_vendors/049_critical_vendors_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's issue from /workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/001_petition_schedules_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_critical_vendors/049_critical_vendors_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's severity from /workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/001_petition_schedules_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_critical_vendors/049_critical_vendors_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's primary_source from /workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/001_petition_schedules_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_critical_vendors/049_critical_vendors_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/001_petition_schedules_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_critical_vendors/049_critical_vendors_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-01 using the exact controlled facts ['2025-08-30', 'CB-RS-2810-A759', '2025-09-11', 'CB-RS-2810-J496'].", "id": "findings.F-01.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-01's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-01.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-10-06', 'Sofia Bennett'] for F-01.", "id": "findings.F-01.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-02 exception for duplicate proof of claim.", "id": "findings.F-02.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's id from /workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/004_petition_schedules_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_critical_vendors/052_critical_vendors_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's issue from /workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/004_petition_schedules_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_critical_vendors/052_critical_vendors_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's severity from /workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/004_petition_schedules_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_critical_vendors/052_critical_vendors_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's primary_source from /workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/004_petition_schedules_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_critical_vendors/052_critical_vendors_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/004_petition_schedules_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_critical_vendors/052_critical_vendors_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-02 using the exact controlled facts ['$5,383,273.00', '$5,603,046.00'].", "id": "findings.F-02.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-02's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-02.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-10-06', 'Adrian Mensah'] for F-02.", "id": "findings.F-02.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-03 exception for secured-status defect.", "id": "findings.F-03.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's id from /workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/007_petition_schedules_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_critical_vendors/055_critical_vendors_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's issue from /workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/007_petition_schedules_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_critical_vendors/055_critical_vendors_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's severity from /workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/007_petition_schedules_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_critical_vendors/055_critical_vendors_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's primary_source from /workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/007_petition_schedules_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_critical_vendors/055_critical_vendors_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/007_petition_schedules_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_critical_vendors/055_critical_vendors_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-03 using the exact controlled facts ['Jonas Feld', 'Micah Sullivan'].", "id": "findings.F-03.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-03's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-03.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-10-06', 'Willa Novak'] for F-03.", "id": "findings.F-03.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-04 exception for priority classification error.", "id": "findings.F-04.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's id from /workspace/documents/02_claims_register/010_claims_register_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_tax/058_tax_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's issue from /workspace/documents/02_claims_register/010_claims_register_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_tax/058_tax_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's severity from /workspace/documents/02_claims_register/010_claims_register_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_tax/058_tax_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's primary_source from /workspace/documents/02_claims_register/010_claims_register_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_tax/058_tax_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/02_claims_register/010_claims_register_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_tax/058_tax_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-04 using the exact controlled facts ['closed without exception', 'CB-RS-2810-D802', 'open and escalated', 'CB-RS-2810-M500'].", "id": "findings.F-04.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-04's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-04.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-10-06', 'Theo Laurent'] for F-04.", "id": "findings.F-04.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-05 exception for executory-contract cure dispute.", "id": "findings.F-05.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's id from /workspace/documents/02_claims_register/013_claims_register_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_tax/061_tax_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's issue from /workspace/documents/02_claims_register/013_claims_register_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_tax/061_tax_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's severity from /workspace/documents/02_claims_register/013_claims_register_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_tax/061_tax_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's primary_source from /workspace/documents/02_claims_register/013_claims_register_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_tax/061_tax_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/02_claims_register/013_claims_register_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_tax/061_tax_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-05 using the exact controlled facts ['Eastern District of Pennsylvania Bankruptcy Court', 'Pennsylvania'].", "id": "findings.F-05.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-05's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-05.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-10-06', 'Amara Patel'] for F-05.", "id": "findings.F-05.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-06 exception for lease rejection deadline.", "id": "findings.F-06.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's id from /workspace/documents/02_claims_register/016_claims_register_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_tax/064_tax_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's issue from /workspace/documents/02_claims_register/016_claims_register_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_tax/064_tax_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's severity from /workspace/documents/02_claims_register/016_claims_register_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_tax/064_tax_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's primary_source from /workspace/documents/02_claims_register/016_claims_register_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_tax/064_tax_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/02_claims_register/016_claims_register_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_tax/064_tax_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-06 using the exact controlled facts ['10%', '16%'].", "id": "findings.F-06.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-06's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-06.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-10-06', 'Henry Cho'] for F-06.", "id": "findings.F-06.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-07 exception for postpetition invoice.", "id": "findings.F-07.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's id from /workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/019_proofs_of_claim_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_litigation/067_litigation_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's issue from /workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/019_proofs_of_claim_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_litigation/067_litigation_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's severity from /workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/019_proofs_of_claim_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_litigation/067_litigation_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's primary_source from /workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/019_proofs_of_claim_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_litigation/067_litigation_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/019_proofs_of_claim_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_litigation/067_litigation_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-07 using the exact controlled facts ['notices-keystone_regional_press@example.test', 'archive-commonwealth_newsprint_pension_trust@example.test'].", "id": "findings.F-07.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-07's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-07.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-10-06', 'Nadine Flores'] for F-07.", "id": "findings.F-07.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-08 exception for critical-vendor overstatement.", "id": "findings.F-08.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's id from /workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/022_proofs_of_claim_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_litigation/070_litigation_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's issue from /workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/022_proofs_of_claim_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_litigation/070_litigation_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's severity from /workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/022_proofs_of_claim_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_litigation/070_litigation_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's primary_source from /workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/022_proofs_of_claim_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_litigation/070_litigation_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/022_proofs_of_claim_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_litigation/070_litigation_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-08 using the exact controlled facts ['104 records', '2025-12-05', '70 records', '2026-01-16'].", "id": "findings.F-08.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-08's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-08.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-10-06', 'Micah Sullivan'] for F-08.", "id": "findings.F-08.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-09 exception for setoff assertion.", "id": "findings.F-09.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's id from /workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/025_contracts_leases_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_plan_disclosure/073_plan_disclosure_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's issue from /workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/025_contracts_leases_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_plan_disclosure/073_plan_disclosure_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's severity from /workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/025_contracts_leases_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_plan_disclosure/073_plan_disclosure_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's primary_source from /workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/025_contracts_leases_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_plan_disclosure/073_plan_disclosure_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/025_contracts_leases_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_plan_disclosure/073_plan_disclosure_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-09 using the exact controlled facts ['2025-01-28', 'CB-RS-2810-I245', '2025-03-02', 'CB-RS-2810-R526'].", "id": "findings.F-09.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-09's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-09.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-10-06', 'Farah Ibrahim'] for F-09.", "id": "findings.F-09.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-10 exception for guaranty overlap.", "id": "findings.F-10.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's id from /workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/028_contracts_leases_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_plan_disclosure/076_plan_disclosure_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's issue from /workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/028_contracts_leases_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_plan_disclosure/076_plan_disclosure_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's severity from /workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/028_contracts_leases_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_plan_disclosure/076_plan_disclosure_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's primary_source from /workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/028_contracts_leases_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_plan_disclosure/076_plan_disclosure_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/028_contracts_leases_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_plan_disclosure/076_plan_disclosure_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-10 using the exact controlled facts ['$5,539,571.00', '$5,705,642.00'].", "id": "findings.F-10.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-10's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-10.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-10-06', 'Owen Delgado'] for F-10.", "id": "findings.F-10.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-11 exception for tax priority period.", "id": "findings.F-11.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's id from /workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/031_contracts_leases_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_plan_disclosure/079_plan_disclosure_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's issue from /workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/031_contracts_leases_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_plan_disclosure/079_plan_disclosure_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's severity from /workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/031_contracts_leases_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_plan_disclosure/079_plan_disclosure_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's primary_source from /workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/031_contracts_leases_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_plan_disclosure/079_plan_disclosure_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/031_contracts_leases_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_plan_disclosure/079_plan_disclosure_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-11 using the exact controlled facts ['Jonas Feld', 'Isaac Romero'].", "id": "findings.F-11.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-11's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-11.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-10-06', 'Lena Varga'] for F-11.", "id": "findings.F-11.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-12 exception for DIP budget variance.", "id": "findings.F-12.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's id from /workspace/documents/05_cash_management/034_cash_management_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_notices_ballots/082_notices_ballots_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's issue from /workspace/documents/05_cash_management/034_cash_management_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_notices_ballots/082_notices_ballots_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's severity from /workspace/documents/05_cash_management/034_cash_management_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_notices_ballots/082_notices_ballots_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's primary_source from /workspace/documents/05_cash_management/034_cash_management_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_notices_ballots/082_notices_ballots_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/05_cash_management/034_cash_management_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_notices_ballots/082_notices_ballots_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-12 using the exact controlled facts ['closed without exception', 'CB-RS-2810-L744', 'open and escalated', 'CB-RS-2810-U841'].", "id": "findings.F-12.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-12's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-12.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-10-06', 'Samuel Kim'] for F-12.", "id": "findings.F-12.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-13 exception for cash-collateral reporting gap.", "id": "findings.F-13.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's id from /workspace/documents/05_cash_management/037_cash_management_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_notices_ballots/085_notices_ballots_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's issue from /workspace/documents/05_cash_management/037_cash_management_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_notices_ballots/085_notices_ballots_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's severity from /workspace/documents/05_cash_management/037_cash_management_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_notices_ballots/085_notices_ballots_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's primary_source from /workspace/documents/05_cash_management/037_cash_management_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_notices_ballots/085_notices_ballots_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/05_cash_management/037_cash_management_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_notices_ballots/085_notices_ballots_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-13 using the exact controlled facts ['Eastern District of Pennsylvania Bankruptcy Court', 'Pennsylvania'].", "id": "findings.F-13.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-13's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-13.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-10-06', 'Maya Ellison'] for F-13.", "id": "findings.F-13.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-14 exception for ballot amount discrepancy.", "id": "findings.F-14.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's id from /workspace/documents/05_cash_management/040_cash_management_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_notices_ballots/088_notices_ballots_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's issue from /workspace/documents/05_cash_management/040_cash_management_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_notices_ballots/088_notices_ballots_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's severity from /workspace/documents/05_cash_management/040_cash_management_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_notices_ballots/088_notices_ballots_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's primary_source from /workspace/documents/05_cash_management/040_cash_management_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_notices_ballots/088_notices_ballots_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/05_cash_management/040_cash_management_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_notices_ballots/088_notices_ballots_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-14 using the exact controlled facts ['10%', '16%'].", "id": "findings.F-14.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-14's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-14.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-10-06', 'Rafael Okafor'] for F-14.", "id": "findings.F-14.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-15 exception for notice-address defect.", "id": "findings.F-15.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's id from /workspace/documents/06_financing/043_financing_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/091_reconciliations_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's issue from /workspace/documents/06_financing/043_financing_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/091_reconciliations_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's severity from /workspace/documents/06_financing/043_financing_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/091_reconciliations_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's primary_source from /workspace/documents/06_financing/043_financing_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/091_reconciliations_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/06_financing/043_financing_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/091_reconciliations_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-15 using the exact controlled facts ['notices-keystone_regional_press@example.test', 'archive-commonwealth_newsprint_pension_trust@example.test'].", "id": "findings.F-15.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-15's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-15.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-10-06', 'Nora Chen'] for F-15.", "id": "findings.F-15.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-16 exception for reserve calculation error.", "id": "findings.F-16.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's id from /workspace/documents/06_financing/046_financing_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/094_reconciliations_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's issue from /workspace/documents/06_financing/046_financing_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/094_reconciliations_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's severity from /workspace/documents/06_financing/046_financing_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/094_reconciliations_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's primary_source from /workspace/documents/06_financing/046_financing_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/094_reconciliations_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/06_financing/046_financing_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/094_reconciliations_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-16 using the exact controlled facts ['65 records', '2025-01-20', '56 records', '2025-02-17'].", "id": "findings.F-16.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-16's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-16.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-10-06', 'Dominic Alvarez'] for F-16.", "id": "findings.F-16.action_anchors"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Executive assessment' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Executive assessment"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Method and record coverage' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Method and record coverage"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Findings' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Findings"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Recommended next actions' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Recommended next actions"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Assumptions and limitations' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Assumptions and limitations"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-01 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-01"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-02 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-02"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-03 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-03"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-04 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-04"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-05 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-05"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-06 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-06"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-07 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-07"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-08 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-08"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-09 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-09"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-10 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-10"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-11 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-11"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-12 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-12"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-13 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-13"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-14 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-14"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-15 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-15"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-16 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-16"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Do not claim the production has no issues or that every record is consistent.", "id": "memo.forbidden_claims_absent"}], "decision_options": [{"id": "cross-source-reconciliation", "label": "Reconcile controlling and corroborating records", "reason": "The CB-RS-2810 production contains independently maintained records; a defensible answer must preserve each supported conflict and its cure owner.", "selected": true}, {"id": "latest-record-controls", "label": "Treat the latest record as controlling", "reason": "Timestamp recency does not establish legal priority, execution, or approval authority.", "selected": false}, {"id": "primary-records-only", "label": "Report primary records without reconciliation", "reason": "Primary records alone conceal the operational conflicts that create the actionable exceptions.", "selected": false}], "gates": ["all_evidence_read_in_full", "chain_of_custody_metadata_checked", "findings_criteria_complete", "memo_criteria_complete", "deliverables_written_through_mcp"], "metadata_checks": 8, "metric": "weighted_criteria_score", "minimum_tool_calls": 46, "required_deliverables": ["findings.json", "advice.md"], "required_document_reads": 33, "type": "deterministic", "weights": {"findings": 0.55, "memo": 0.2, "procedure": 0.25}}, "task_id": "cb100-050-keystone-press", "task_name": "Keystone Press disclosure reconciliation", "world_id": "counselbench-filesystem-mcp-v2"}
-{"context_files": ["task_files/cb100-051-acorn-logistics/01_leases/001_leases_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-051-acorn-logistics/01_leases/002_leases_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-051-acorn-logistics/01_leases/003_leases_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-051-acorn-logistics/01_leases/004_leases_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-051-acorn-logistics/01_leases/005_leases_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-051-acorn-logistics/01_leases/006_leases_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-051-acorn-logistics/01_leases/007_leases_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-051-acorn-logistics/01_leases/008_leases_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-051-acorn-logistics/02_amendments/009_amendments_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-051-acorn-logistics/02_amendments/010_amendments_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-051-acorn-logistics/02_amendments/011_amendments_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-051-acorn-logistics/02_amendments/012_amendments_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-051-acorn-logistics/02_amendments/013_amendments_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-051-acorn-logistics/02_amendments/014_amendments_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-051-acorn-logistics/02_amendments/015_amendments_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-051-acorn-logistics/02_amendments/016_amendments_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-051-acorn-logistics/03_estoppels/017_estoppels_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-051-acorn-logistics/03_estoppels/018_estoppels_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-051-acorn-logistics/03_estoppels/019_estoppels_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-051-acorn-logistics/03_estoppels/020_estoppels_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-051-acorn-logistics/03_estoppels/021_estoppels_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-051-acorn-logistics/03_estoppels/022_estoppels_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-051-acorn-logistics/03_estoppels/023_estoppels_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-051-acorn-logistics/03_estoppels/024_estoppels_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-051-acorn-logistics/04_title_survey/025_title_survey_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-051-acorn-logistics/04_title_survey/026_title_survey_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-051-acorn-logistics/04_title_survey/027_title_survey_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-051-acorn-logistics/04_title_survey/028_title_survey_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-051-acorn-logistics/04_title_survey/029_title_survey_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-051-acorn-logistics/04_title_survey/030_title_survey_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-051-acorn-logistics/04_title_survey/031_title_survey_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-051-acorn-logistics/04_title_survey/032_title_survey_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-051-acorn-logistics/05_environmental/033_environmental_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-051-acorn-logistics/05_environmental/034_environmental_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-051-acorn-logistics/05_environmental/035_environmental_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-051-acorn-logistics/05_environmental/036_environmental_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-051-acorn-logistics/05_environmental/037_environmental_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-051-acorn-logistics/05_environmental/038_environmental_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-051-acorn-logistics/05_environmental/039_environmental_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-051-acorn-logistics/05_environmental/040_environmental_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-051-acorn-logistics/06_zoning_permits/041_zoning_permits_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-051-acorn-logistics/06_zoning_permits/042_zoning_permits_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-051-acorn-logistics/06_zoning_permits/043_zoning_permits_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-051-acorn-logistics/06_zoning_permits/044_zoning_permits_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-051-acorn-logistics/06_zoning_permits/045_zoning_permits_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-051-acorn-logistics/06_zoning_permits/046_zoning_permits_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-051-acorn-logistics/06_zoning_permits/047_zoning_permits_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-051-acorn-logistics/06_zoning_permits/048_zoning_permits_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-051-acorn-logistics/07_operating_expenses/049_operating_expenses_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-051-acorn-logistics/07_operating_expenses/050_operating_expenses_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-051-acorn-logistics/07_operating_expenses/051_operating_expenses_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-051-acorn-logistics/07_operating_expenses/052_operating_expenses_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-051-acorn-logistics/07_operating_expenses/053_operating_expenses_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-051-acorn-logistics/07_operating_expenses/054_operating_expenses_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-051-acorn-logistics/07_operating_expenses/055_operating_expenses_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-051-acorn-logistics/07_operating_expenses/056_operating_expenses_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-051-acorn-logistics/08_insurance/057_insurance_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-051-acorn-logistics/08_insurance/058_insurance_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-051-acorn-logistics/08_insurance/059_insurance_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-051-acorn-logistics/08_insurance/060_insurance_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-051-acorn-logistics/08_insurance/061_insurance_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-051-acorn-logistics/08_insurance/062_insurance_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-051-acorn-logistics/08_insurance/063_insurance_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-051-acorn-logistics/08_insurance/064_insurance_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-051-acorn-logistics/09_notices/065_notices_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-051-acorn-logistics/09_notices/066_notices_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-051-acorn-logistics/09_notices/067_notices_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-051-acorn-logistics/09_notices/068_notices_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-051-acorn-logistics/09_notices/069_notices_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-051-acorn-logistics/09_notices/070_notices_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-051-acorn-logistics/09_notices/071_notices_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-051-acorn-logistics/09_notices/072_notices_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-051-acorn-logistics/10_construction/073_construction_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-051-acorn-logistics/10_construction/074_construction_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-051-acorn-logistics/10_construction/075_construction_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-051-acorn-logistics/10_construction/076_construction_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-051-acorn-logistics/10_construction/077_construction_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-051-acorn-logistics/10_construction/078_construction_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-051-acorn-logistics/10_construction/079_construction_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-051-acorn-logistics/10_construction/080_construction_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-051-acorn-logistics/11_financing/081_financing_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-051-acorn-logistics/11_financing/082_financing_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-051-acorn-logistics/11_financing/083_financing_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-051-acorn-logistics/11_financing/084_financing_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-051-acorn-logistics/11_financing/085_financing_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-051-acorn-logistics/11_financing/086_financing_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-051-acorn-logistics/11_financing/087_financing_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-051-acorn-logistics/11_financing/088_financing_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-051-acorn-logistics/12_property_management/089_property_management_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-051-acorn-logistics/12_property_management/090_property_management_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-051-acorn-logistics/12_property_management/091_property_management_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-051-acorn-logistics/12_property_management/092_property_management_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-051-acorn-logistics/12_property_management/093_property_management_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-051-acorn-logistics/12_property_management/094_property_management_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-051-acorn-logistics/12_property_management/095_property_management_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-051-acorn-logistics/12_property_management/096_property_management_status_report.md"], "gold_output": {"advice_markdown": "# Counsel advice — Acorn industrial portfolio lease audit\n\n## Executive assessment\n\nFor Acorn Logistics REIT matter CB-RE-2901, the review identified 16 source-supported exceptions requiring action before 2026-09-03. The assessment concerns Redwood Fulfillment Services and the supplied record for California.\n\n## Method and record coverage\n\nThe review inventoried all 96 production files, read the 33 controlling, corroborating, and control records, searched the email exports, and checked metadata for the designated chain-of-custody sample. Conclusions are limited to the synthetic production supplied for this benchmark matter.\n\n## Findings\n\n### F-01 — rent schedule inconsistency (critical)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for rent schedule inconsistency: one source states the operative date is 2025-07-29 under control reference CB-RE-2901-A547, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2025-08-31 under response reference CB-RE-2901-J272.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/01_leases/001_leases_control_register.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/07_operating_expenses/049_operating_expenses_control_register.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-03, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Adrian Mensah.\n\n### F-02 — renewal-option notice (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for renewal-option notice: one source states the controlling amount is $5,272,918.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $5,412,336.00.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/01_leases/004_leases_ledger_export.csv`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/07_operating_expenses/052_operating_expenses_ledger_export.csv`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-03, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Willa Novak.\n\n### F-03 — exclusive-use conflict (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for exclusive-use conflict: one source states approval is attributed to Mei Whitaker as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Owen Delgado and contains no entry for Mei Whitaker.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/01_leases/007_leases_officer_certificate.html`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/07_operating_expenses/055_operating_expenses_officer_certificate.html`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-03, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Theo Laurent.\n\n### F-04 — assignment consent (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for assignment consent: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-RE-2901-D449, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-RE-2901-M403.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/02_amendments/010_amendments_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/08_insurance/058_insurance_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-03, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Amara Patel.\n\n### F-05 — estoppel discrepancy (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for estoppel discrepancy: one source states the applicable location is San Bernardino County, California, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to California operations outside San Bernardino County, California.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/02_amendments/013_amendments_review_memorandum.json`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/08_insurance/061_insurance_review_memorandum.json`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-03, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Henry Cho.\n\n### F-06 — survey encroachment (low)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for survey encroachment: one source states the threshold is 14% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 16% and produced a different exception result.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/02_amendments/016_amendments_status_report.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/08_insurance/064_insurance_status_report.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-03, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Nadine Flores.\n\n### F-07 — title exception (critical)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for title exception: one source states formal notice must use notices-acorn_logistics_reit@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-redwood_fulfillment_services@example.test.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/03_estoppels/019_estoppels_correspondence.eml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/09_notices/067_notices_correspondence.eml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-03, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Micah Sullivan.\n\n### F-08 — environmental recognized condition (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for environmental recognized condition: one source states the governed population contains 107 records through 2025-07-21, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 50 records through 2025-08-12.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/03_estoppels/022_estoppels_formal_notice.xml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/09_notices/070_notices_formal_notice.xml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-03, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Farah Ibrahim.\n\n### F-09 — zoning nonconformity (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for zoning nonconformity: one source states the operative date is 2026-02-08 under control reference CB-RE-2901-I381, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2026-02-27 under response reference CB-RE-2901-R606.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/04_title_survey/025_title_survey_control_register.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/10_construction/073_construction_control_register.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-03, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Owen Delgado.\n\n### F-10 — permit closeout gap (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for permit closeout gap: one source states the controlling amount is $5,811,206.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $5,828,912.00.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/04_title_survey/028_title_survey_ledger_export.csv`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/10_construction/076_construction_ledger_export.csv`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-03, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Lena Varga.\n\n### F-11 — CAM reconciliation error (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for CAM reconciliation error: one source states approval is attributed to Mei Whitaker as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Adrian Mensah and contains no entry for Mei Whitaker.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/04_title_survey/031_title_survey_officer_certificate.html`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/10_construction/079_construction_officer_certificate.html`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-03, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Samuel Kim.\n\n### F-12 — insurance endorsement deficiency (low)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for insurance endorsement deficiency: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-RE-2901-L966, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-RE-2901-U928.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/05_environmental/034_environmental_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/11_financing/082_financing_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-03, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Maya Ellison.\n\n### F-13 — casualty restoration deadline (critical)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for casualty restoration deadline: one source states the applicable location is San Bernardino County, California, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to California operations outside San Bernardino County, California.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/05_environmental/037_environmental_review_memorandum.json`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/11_financing/085_financing_review_memorandum.json`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-03, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Rafael Okafor.\n\n### F-14 — construction lien notice (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for construction lien notice: one source states the threshold is 11% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 14% and produced a different exception result.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/05_environmental/040_environmental_status_report.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/11_financing/088_financing_status_report.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-03, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Nora Chen.\n\n### F-15 — lender SNDA omission (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for lender SNDA omission: one source states formal notice must use notices-acorn_logistics_reit@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-redwood_fulfillment_services@example.test.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/043_zoning_permits_correspondence.eml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/12_property_management/091_property_management_correspondence.eml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-03, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Dominic Alvarez.\n\n### F-16 — security-deposit mismatch (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for security-deposit mismatch: one source states the governed population contains 175 records through 2025-09-27, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 67 records through 2025-11-05.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/046_zoning_permits_formal_notice.xml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/12_property_management/094_property_management_formal_notice.xml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-03, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Priya Raman.\n\n## Recommended next actions\n\nSequence the critical and high findings first, assign the named owners, preserve the cited records, and document any resolution in the controlling matter register before the stated deadline.\n\n## Assumptions and limitations\n\nThis analysis is confined to task cb100-051-acorn-logistics and the supplied synthetic evidence. It does not rely on external facts, does not resolve disputed law, and is not legal advice for a real person or entity.\n", "findings": {"as_of": "2026-09-03", "findings": [{"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/07_operating_expenses/049_operating_expenses_control_register.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for rent schedule inconsistency: one source states the operative date is 2025-07-29 under control reference CB-RE-2901-A547, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2025-08-31 under response reference CB-RE-2901-J272.", "id": "F-01", "issue": "rent schedule inconsistency", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/01_leases/001_leases_control_register.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-03, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Adrian Mensah.", "severity": "critical"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/07_operating_expenses/052_operating_expenses_ledger_export.csv", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for renewal-option notice: one source states the controlling amount is $5,272,918.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $5,412,336.00.", "id": "F-02", "issue": "renewal-option notice", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/01_leases/004_leases_ledger_export.csv", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-03, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Willa Novak.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/07_operating_expenses/055_operating_expenses_officer_certificate.html", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for exclusive-use conflict: one source states approval is attributed to Mei Whitaker as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Owen Delgado and contains no entry for Mei Whitaker.", "id": "F-03", "issue": "exclusive-use conflict", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/01_leases/007_leases_officer_certificate.html", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-03, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Theo Laurent.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/08_insurance/058_insurance_executed_instrument.txt", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for assignment consent: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-RE-2901-D449, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-RE-2901-M403.", "id": "F-04", "issue": "assignment consent", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/02_amendments/010_amendments_executed_instrument.txt", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-03, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Amara Patel.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/08_insurance/061_insurance_review_memorandum.json", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for estoppel discrepancy: one source states the applicable location is San Bernardino County, California, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to California operations outside San Bernardino County, California.", "id": "F-05", "issue": "estoppel discrepancy", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/02_amendments/013_amendments_review_memorandum.json", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-03, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Henry Cho.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/08_insurance/064_insurance_status_report.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for survey encroachment: one source states the threshold is 14% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 16% and produced a different exception result.", "id": "F-06", "issue": "survey encroachment", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/02_amendments/016_amendments_status_report.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-03, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Nadine Flores.", "severity": "low"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/09_notices/067_notices_correspondence.eml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for title exception: one source states formal notice must use notices-acorn_logistics_reit@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-redwood_fulfillment_services@example.test.", "id": "F-07", "issue": "title exception", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/03_estoppels/019_estoppels_correspondence.eml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-03, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Micah Sullivan.", "severity": "critical"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/09_notices/070_notices_formal_notice.xml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for environmental recognized condition: one source states the governed population contains 107 records through 2025-07-21, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 50 records through 2025-08-12.", "id": "F-08", "issue": "environmental recognized condition", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/03_estoppels/022_estoppels_formal_notice.xml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-03, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Farah Ibrahim.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/10_construction/073_construction_control_register.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for zoning nonconformity: one source states the operative date is 2026-02-08 under control reference CB-RE-2901-I381, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2026-02-27 under response reference CB-RE-2901-R606.", "id": "F-09", "issue": "zoning nonconformity", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/04_title_survey/025_title_survey_control_register.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-03, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Owen Delgado.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/10_construction/076_construction_ledger_export.csv", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for permit closeout gap: one source states the controlling amount is $5,811,206.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $5,828,912.00.", "id": "F-10", "issue": "permit closeout gap", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/04_title_survey/028_title_survey_ledger_export.csv", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-03, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Lena Varga.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/10_construction/079_construction_officer_certificate.html", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for CAM reconciliation error: one source states approval is attributed to Mei Whitaker as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Adrian Mensah and contains no entry for Mei Whitaker.", "id": "F-11", "issue": "CAM reconciliation error", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/04_title_survey/031_title_survey_officer_certificate.html", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-03, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Samuel Kim.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/11_financing/082_financing_executed_instrument.txt", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for insurance endorsement deficiency: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-RE-2901-L966, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-RE-2901-U928.", "id": "F-12", "issue": "insurance endorsement deficiency", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/05_environmental/034_environmental_executed_instrument.txt", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-03, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Maya Ellison.", "severity": "low"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/11_financing/085_financing_review_memorandum.json", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for casualty restoration deadline: one source states the applicable location is San Bernardino County, California, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to California operations outside San Bernardino County, California.", "id": "F-13", "issue": "casualty restoration deadline", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/05_environmental/037_environmental_review_memorandum.json", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-03, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Rafael Okafor.", "severity": "critical"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/11_financing/088_financing_status_report.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for construction lien notice: one source states the threshold is 11% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 14% and produced a different exception result.", "id": "F-14", "issue": "construction lien notice", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/05_environmental/040_environmental_status_report.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-03, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Nora Chen.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/12_property_management/091_property_management_correspondence.eml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for lender SNDA omission: one source states formal notice must use notices-acorn_logistics_reit@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-redwood_fulfillment_services@example.test.", "id": "F-15", "issue": "lender SNDA omission", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/043_zoning_permits_correspondence.eml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-03, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Dominic Alvarez.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/12_property_management/094_property_management_formal_notice.xml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for security-deposit mismatch: one source states the governed population contains 175 records through 2025-09-27, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 67 records through 2025-11-05.", "id": "F-16", "issue": "security-deposit mismatch", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/046_zoning_permits_formal_notice.xml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-03, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Priya Raman.", "severity": "medium"}], "matter_number": "CB-RE-2901", "prepared_for": "Acorn Logistics REIT", "schema_version": "1.0", "task_id": "cb100-051-acorn-logistics"}}, "metadata": {"benchmark": "CounselBench-100", "code_license": "Apache-2.0", "data_license": "CC-BY-4.0", "deadline": "2026-09-03", "document_count": 96, "jurisdiction": "California", "matter_number": "CB-RE-2901", "mcp_commit": "9a96ea6e5913736f92b88345bf51caeaaa8e719f", "mcp_package": "@modelcontextprotocol/server-filesystem@2026.7.10", "practice_area": "real-estate", "reference_tool_calls": 46, "required_evidence_reads": 33, "synthetic": true, "venue": "San Bernardino County, California", "version": "2.0.0"}, "prompt": "You are real-estate transactions counsel for Acorn Logistics REIT. The partner responsible for this matter needs a defensible decision record before the next client call. Three warehouses have conflicting rent schedules, an unclosed solar permit, and an estoppel that excludes a disputed CAM credit. Decision due 2026-09-03. California law governs; San Bernardino County, California is the forum. Prioritize conflicts between signed instruments and later operational records. Work out the defensible position from the matter production and leave an audit-ready exception tracker and concise advice for the supervising lawyer. Keep confirmed conflicts separate from open questions, cite the records that actually control each conclusion, and do not fill gaps with outside facts.", "rubric": {"criteria": [{"category": "procedure", "description": "Complete at least 46 successful, argument-specific evidence and output calls.", "id": "procedure.minimum_successful_tool_calls"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Find and read the 33 controlling, corroborating, and work-product-control records in full.", "id": "procedure.all_evidence_read_in_full"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Inspect file metadata for the eight designated critical primary records before relying on them.", "id": "procedure.chain_of_custody_metadata_checked"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Confirm the sandbox's allowed document and output roots.", "id": "procedure.allowed_directories_checked"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Inventory all 96 records so the relevant sources are discovered among the context records.", "id": "procedure.recursive_inventory_completed"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Search the production for email evidence that may corroborate or contradict formal records.", "id": "procedure.targeted_search_completed"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Leave only findings.json and advice.md in the output workspace.", "id": "procedure.exact_deliverable_set"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Create both final work products through the sandbox MCP surface.", "id": "procedure.deliverables_written_through_mcp"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Produce findings.json as a valid JSON object.", "id": "findings.findings_is_object"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Report exactly 16 confirmed exceptions.", "id": "findings.findings_exact_count"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Use each stable finding ID exactly once.", "id": "findings.finding_ids_unique"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set schema_version to the released matter value '1.0'.", "id": "findings.top_level_schema_version"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set task_id to the released matter value 'cb100-051-acorn-logistics'.", "id": "findings.top_level_task_id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set matter_number to the released matter value 'CB-RE-2901'.", "id": "findings.top_level_matter_number"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set prepared_for to the released matter value 'Acorn Logistics REIT'.", "id": "findings.top_level_prepared_for"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set as_of to the released matter value '2026-09-03'.", "id": "findings.top_level_as_of"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-01 exception for rent schedule inconsistency.", "id": "findings.F-01.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's id from /workspace/documents/01_leases/001_leases_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_operating_expenses/049_operating_expenses_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's issue from /workspace/documents/01_leases/001_leases_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_operating_expenses/049_operating_expenses_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's severity from /workspace/documents/01_leases/001_leases_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_operating_expenses/049_operating_expenses_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's primary_source from /workspace/documents/01_leases/001_leases_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_operating_expenses/049_operating_expenses_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/01_leases/001_leases_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_operating_expenses/049_operating_expenses_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-01 using the exact controlled facts ['2025-07-29', 'CB-RE-2901-A547', '2025-08-31', 'CB-RE-2901-J272'].", "id": "findings.F-01.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-01's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-01.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-03', 'Adrian Mensah'] for F-01.", "id": "findings.F-01.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-02 exception for renewal-option notice.", "id": "findings.F-02.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's id from /workspace/documents/01_leases/004_leases_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_operating_expenses/052_operating_expenses_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's issue from /workspace/documents/01_leases/004_leases_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_operating_expenses/052_operating_expenses_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's severity from /workspace/documents/01_leases/004_leases_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_operating_expenses/052_operating_expenses_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's primary_source from /workspace/documents/01_leases/004_leases_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_operating_expenses/052_operating_expenses_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/01_leases/004_leases_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_operating_expenses/052_operating_expenses_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-02 using the exact controlled facts ['$5,272,918.00', '$5,412,336.00'].", "id": "findings.F-02.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-02's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-02.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-03', 'Willa Novak'] for F-02.", "id": "findings.F-02.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-03 exception for exclusive-use conflict.", "id": "findings.F-03.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's id from /workspace/documents/01_leases/007_leases_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_operating_expenses/055_operating_expenses_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's issue from /workspace/documents/01_leases/007_leases_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_operating_expenses/055_operating_expenses_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's severity from /workspace/documents/01_leases/007_leases_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_operating_expenses/055_operating_expenses_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's primary_source from /workspace/documents/01_leases/007_leases_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_operating_expenses/055_operating_expenses_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/01_leases/007_leases_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_operating_expenses/055_operating_expenses_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-03 using the exact controlled facts ['Mei Whitaker', 'Owen Delgado'].", "id": "findings.F-03.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-03's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-03.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-03', 'Theo Laurent'] for F-03.", "id": "findings.F-03.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-04 exception for assignment consent.", "id": "findings.F-04.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's id from /workspace/documents/02_amendments/010_amendments_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_insurance/058_insurance_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's issue from /workspace/documents/02_amendments/010_amendments_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_insurance/058_insurance_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's severity from /workspace/documents/02_amendments/010_amendments_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_insurance/058_insurance_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's primary_source from /workspace/documents/02_amendments/010_amendments_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_insurance/058_insurance_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/02_amendments/010_amendments_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_insurance/058_insurance_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-04 using the exact controlled facts ['closed without exception', 'CB-RE-2901-D449', 'open and escalated', 'CB-RE-2901-M403'].", "id": "findings.F-04.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-04's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-04.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-03', 'Amara Patel'] for F-04.", "id": "findings.F-04.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-05 exception for estoppel discrepancy.", "id": "findings.F-05.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's id from /workspace/documents/02_amendments/013_amendments_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_insurance/061_insurance_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's issue from /workspace/documents/02_amendments/013_amendments_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_insurance/061_insurance_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's severity from /workspace/documents/02_amendments/013_amendments_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_insurance/061_insurance_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's primary_source from /workspace/documents/02_amendments/013_amendments_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_insurance/061_insurance_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/02_amendments/013_amendments_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_insurance/061_insurance_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-05 using the exact controlled facts ['San Bernardino County, California', 'California'].", "id": "findings.F-05.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-05's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-05.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-03', 'Henry Cho'] for F-05.", "id": "findings.F-05.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-06 exception for survey encroachment.", "id": "findings.F-06.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's id from /workspace/documents/02_amendments/016_amendments_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_insurance/064_insurance_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's issue from /workspace/documents/02_amendments/016_amendments_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_insurance/064_insurance_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's severity from /workspace/documents/02_amendments/016_amendments_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_insurance/064_insurance_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's primary_source from /workspace/documents/02_amendments/016_amendments_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_insurance/064_insurance_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/02_amendments/016_amendments_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_insurance/064_insurance_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-06 using the exact controlled facts ['14%', '16%'].", "id": "findings.F-06.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-06's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-06.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-03', 'Nadine Flores'] for F-06.", "id": "findings.F-06.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-07 exception for title exception.", "id": "findings.F-07.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's id from /workspace/documents/03_estoppels/019_estoppels_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_notices/067_notices_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's issue from /workspace/documents/03_estoppels/019_estoppels_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_notices/067_notices_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's severity from /workspace/documents/03_estoppels/019_estoppels_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_notices/067_notices_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's primary_source from /workspace/documents/03_estoppels/019_estoppels_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_notices/067_notices_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/03_estoppels/019_estoppels_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_notices/067_notices_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-07 using the exact controlled facts ['notices-acorn_logistics_reit@example.test', 'archive-redwood_fulfillment_services@example.test'].", "id": "findings.F-07.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-07's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-07.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-03', 'Micah Sullivan'] for F-07.", "id": "findings.F-07.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-08 exception for environmental recognized condition.", "id": "findings.F-08.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's id from /workspace/documents/03_estoppels/022_estoppels_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_notices/070_notices_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's issue from /workspace/documents/03_estoppels/022_estoppels_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_notices/070_notices_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's severity from /workspace/documents/03_estoppels/022_estoppels_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_notices/070_notices_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's primary_source from /workspace/documents/03_estoppels/022_estoppels_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_notices/070_notices_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/03_estoppels/022_estoppels_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_notices/070_notices_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-08 using the exact controlled facts ['107 records', '2025-07-21', '50 records', '2025-08-12'].", "id": "findings.F-08.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-08's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-08.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-03', 'Farah Ibrahim'] for F-08.", "id": "findings.F-08.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-09 exception for zoning nonconformity.", "id": "findings.F-09.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's id from /workspace/documents/04_title_survey/025_title_survey_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_construction/073_construction_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's issue from /workspace/documents/04_title_survey/025_title_survey_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_construction/073_construction_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's severity from /workspace/documents/04_title_survey/025_title_survey_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_construction/073_construction_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's primary_source from /workspace/documents/04_title_survey/025_title_survey_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_construction/073_construction_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/04_title_survey/025_title_survey_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_construction/073_construction_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-09 using the exact controlled facts ['2026-02-08', 'CB-RE-2901-I381', '2026-02-27', 'CB-RE-2901-R606'].", "id": "findings.F-09.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-09's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-09.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-03', 'Owen Delgado'] for F-09.", "id": "findings.F-09.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-10 exception for permit closeout gap.", "id": "findings.F-10.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's id from /workspace/documents/04_title_survey/028_title_survey_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_construction/076_construction_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's issue from /workspace/documents/04_title_survey/028_title_survey_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_construction/076_construction_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's severity from /workspace/documents/04_title_survey/028_title_survey_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_construction/076_construction_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's primary_source from /workspace/documents/04_title_survey/028_title_survey_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_construction/076_construction_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/04_title_survey/028_title_survey_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_construction/076_construction_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-10 using the exact controlled facts ['$5,811,206.00', '$5,828,912.00'].", "id": "findings.F-10.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-10's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-10.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-03', 'Lena Varga'] for F-10.", "id": "findings.F-10.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-11 exception for CAM reconciliation error.", "id": "findings.F-11.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's id from /workspace/documents/04_title_survey/031_title_survey_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_construction/079_construction_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's issue from /workspace/documents/04_title_survey/031_title_survey_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_construction/079_construction_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's severity from /workspace/documents/04_title_survey/031_title_survey_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_construction/079_construction_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's primary_source from /workspace/documents/04_title_survey/031_title_survey_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_construction/079_construction_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/04_title_survey/031_title_survey_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_construction/079_construction_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-11 using the exact controlled facts ['Mei Whitaker', 'Adrian Mensah'].", "id": "findings.F-11.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-11's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-11.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-03', 'Samuel Kim'] for F-11.", "id": "findings.F-11.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-12 exception for insurance endorsement deficiency.", "id": "findings.F-12.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's id from /workspace/documents/05_environmental/034_environmental_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_financing/082_financing_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's issue from /workspace/documents/05_environmental/034_environmental_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_financing/082_financing_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's severity from /workspace/documents/05_environmental/034_environmental_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_financing/082_financing_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's primary_source from /workspace/documents/05_environmental/034_environmental_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_financing/082_financing_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/05_environmental/034_environmental_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_financing/082_financing_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-12 using the exact controlled facts ['closed without exception', 'CB-RE-2901-L966', 'open and escalated', 'CB-RE-2901-U928'].", "id": "findings.F-12.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-12's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-12.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-03', 'Maya Ellison'] for F-12.", "id": "findings.F-12.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-13 exception for casualty restoration deadline.", "id": "findings.F-13.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's id from /workspace/documents/05_environmental/037_environmental_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_financing/085_financing_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's issue from /workspace/documents/05_environmental/037_environmental_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_financing/085_financing_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's severity from /workspace/documents/05_environmental/037_environmental_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_financing/085_financing_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's primary_source from /workspace/documents/05_environmental/037_environmental_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_financing/085_financing_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/05_environmental/037_environmental_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_financing/085_financing_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-13 using the exact controlled facts ['San Bernardino County, California', 'California'].", "id": "findings.F-13.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-13's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-13.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-03', 'Rafael Okafor'] for F-13.", "id": "findings.F-13.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-14 exception for construction lien notice.", "id": "findings.F-14.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's id from /workspace/documents/05_environmental/040_environmental_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_financing/088_financing_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's issue from /workspace/documents/05_environmental/040_environmental_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_financing/088_financing_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's severity from /workspace/documents/05_environmental/040_environmental_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_financing/088_financing_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's primary_source from /workspace/documents/05_environmental/040_environmental_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_financing/088_financing_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/05_environmental/040_environmental_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_financing/088_financing_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-14 using the exact controlled facts ['11%', '14%'].", "id": "findings.F-14.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-14's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-14.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-03', 'Nora Chen'] for F-14.", "id": "findings.F-14.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-15 exception for lender SNDA omission.", "id": "findings.F-15.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's id from /workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/043_zoning_permits_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_property_management/091_property_management_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's issue from /workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/043_zoning_permits_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_property_management/091_property_management_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's severity from /workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/043_zoning_permits_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_property_management/091_property_management_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's primary_source from /workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/043_zoning_permits_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_property_management/091_property_management_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/043_zoning_permits_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_property_management/091_property_management_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-15 using the exact controlled facts ['notices-acorn_logistics_reit@example.test', 'archive-redwood_fulfillment_services@example.test'].", "id": "findings.F-15.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-15's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-15.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-03', 'Dominic Alvarez'] for F-15.", "id": "findings.F-15.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-16 exception for security-deposit mismatch.", "id": "findings.F-16.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's id from /workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/046_zoning_permits_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_property_management/094_property_management_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's issue from /workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/046_zoning_permits_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_property_management/094_property_management_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's severity from /workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/046_zoning_permits_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_property_management/094_property_management_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's primary_source from /workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/046_zoning_permits_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_property_management/094_property_management_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/046_zoning_permits_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_property_management/094_property_management_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-16 using the exact controlled facts ['175 records', '2025-09-27', '67 records', '2025-11-05'].", "id": "findings.F-16.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-16's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-16.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-03', 'Priya Raman'] for F-16.", "id": "findings.F-16.action_anchors"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Executive assessment' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Executive assessment"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Method and record coverage' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Method and record coverage"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Findings' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Findings"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Recommended next actions' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Recommended next actions"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Assumptions and limitations' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Assumptions and limitations"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-01 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-01"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-02 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-02"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-03 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-03"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-04 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-04"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-05 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-05"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-06 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-06"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-07 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-07"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-08 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-08"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-09 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-09"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-10 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-10"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-11 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-11"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-12 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-12"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-13 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-13"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-14 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-14"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-15 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-15"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-16 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-16"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Do not claim the production has no issues or that every record is consistent.", "id": "memo.forbidden_claims_absent"}], "decision_options": [{"id": "cross-source-reconciliation", "label": "Reconcile controlling and corroborating records", "reason": "The CB-RE-2901 production contains independently maintained records; a defensible answer must preserve each supported conflict and its cure owner.", "selected": true}, {"id": "latest-record-controls", "label": "Treat the latest record as controlling", "reason": "Timestamp recency does not establish legal priority, execution, or approval authority.", "selected": false}, {"id": "primary-records-only", "label": "Report primary records without reconciliation", "reason": "Primary records alone conceal the operational conflicts that create the actionable exceptions.", "selected": false}], "gates": ["all_evidence_read_in_full", "chain_of_custody_metadata_checked", "findings_criteria_complete", "memo_criteria_complete", "deliverables_written_through_mcp"], "metadata_checks": 8, "metric": "weighted_criteria_score", "minimum_tool_calls": 46, "required_deliverables": ["findings.json", "advice.md"], "required_document_reads": 33, "type": "deterministic", "weights": {"findings": 0.55, "memo": 0.2, "procedure": 0.25}}, "task_id": "cb100-051-acorn-logistics", "task_name": "Acorn industrial portfolio lease audit", "world_id": "counselbench-filesystem-mcp-v2"}
-{"context_files": ["task_files/cb100-052-brookline-clinic/01_leases/001_leases_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-052-brookline-clinic/01_leases/002_leases_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-052-brookline-clinic/01_leases/003_leases_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-052-brookline-clinic/01_leases/004_leases_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-052-brookline-clinic/01_leases/005_leases_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-052-brookline-clinic/01_leases/006_leases_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-052-brookline-clinic/01_leases/007_leases_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-052-brookline-clinic/01_leases/008_leases_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-052-brookline-clinic/02_amendments/009_amendments_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-052-brookline-clinic/02_amendments/010_amendments_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-052-brookline-clinic/02_amendments/011_amendments_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-052-brookline-clinic/02_amendments/012_amendments_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-052-brookline-clinic/02_amendments/013_amendments_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-052-brookline-clinic/02_amendments/014_amendments_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-052-brookline-clinic/02_amendments/015_amendments_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-052-brookline-clinic/02_amendments/016_amendments_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-052-brookline-clinic/03_estoppels/017_estoppels_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-052-brookline-clinic/03_estoppels/018_estoppels_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-052-brookline-clinic/03_estoppels/019_estoppels_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-052-brookline-clinic/03_estoppels/020_estoppels_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-052-brookline-clinic/03_estoppels/021_estoppels_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-052-brookline-clinic/03_estoppels/022_estoppels_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-052-brookline-clinic/03_estoppels/023_estoppels_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-052-brookline-clinic/03_estoppels/024_estoppels_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-052-brookline-clinic/04_title_survey/025_title_survey_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-052-brookline-clinic/04_title_survey/026_title_survey_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-052-brookline-clinic/04_title_survey/027_title_survey_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-052-brookline-clinic/04_title_survey/028_title_survey_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-052-brookline-clinic/04_title_survey/029_title_survey_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-052-brookline-clinic/04_title_survey/030_title_survey_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-052-brookline-clinic/04_title_survey/031_title_survey_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-052-brookline-clinic/04_title_survey/032_title_survey_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-052-brookline-clinic/05_environmental/033_environmental_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-052-brookline-clinic/05_environmental/034_environmental_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-052-brookline-clinic/05_environmental/035_environmental_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-052-brookline-clinic/05_environmental/036_environmental_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-052-brookline-clinic/05_environmental/037_environmental_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-052-brookline-clinic/05_environmental/038_environmental_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-052-brookline-clinic/05_environmental/039_environmental_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-052-brookline-clinic/05_environmental/040_environmental_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-052-brookline-clinic/06_zoning_permits/041_zoning_permits_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-052-brookline-clinic/06_zoning_permits/042_zoning_permits_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-052-brookline-clinic/06_zoning_permits/043_zoning_permits_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-052-brookline-clinic/06_zoning_permits/044_zoning_permits_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-052-brookline-clinic/06_zoning_permits/045_zoning_permits_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-052-brookline-clinic/06_zoning_permits/046_zoning_permits_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-052-brookline-clinic/06_zoning_permits/047_zoning_permits_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-052-brookline-clinic/06_zoning_permits/048_zoning_permits_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-052-brookline-clinic/07_operating_expenses/049_operating_expenses_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-052-brookline-clinic/07_operating_expenses/050_operating_expenses_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-052-brookline-clinic/07_operating_expenses/051_operating_expenses_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-052-brookline-clinic/07_operating_expenses/052_operating_expenses_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-052-brookline-clinic/07_operating_expenses/053_operating_expenses_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-052-brookline-clinic/07_operating_expenses/054_operating_expenses_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-052-brookline-clinic/07_operating_expenses/055_operating_expenses_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-052-brookline-clinic/07_operating_expenses/056_operating_expenses_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-052-brookline-clinic/08_insurance/057_insurance_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-052-brookline-clinic/08_insurance/058_insurance_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-052-brookline-clinic/08_insurance/059_insurance_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-052-brookline-clinic/08_insurance/060_insurance_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-052-brookline-clinic/08_insurance/061_insurance_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-052-brookline-clinic/08_insurance/062_insurance_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-052-brookline-clinic/08_insurance/063_insurance_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-052-brookline-clinic/08_insurance/064_insurance_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-052-brookline-clinic/09_notices/065_notices_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-052-brookline-clinic/09_notices/066_notices_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-052-brookline-clinic/09_notices/067_notices_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-052-brookline-clinic/09_notices/068_notices_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-052-brookline-clinic/09_notices/069_notices_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-052-brookline-clinic/09_notices/070_notices_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-052-brookline-clinic/09_notices/071_notices_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-052-brookline-clinic/09_notices/072_notices_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-052-brookline-clinic/10_construction/073_construction_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-052-brookline-clinic/10_construction/074_construction_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-052-brookline-clinic/10_construction/075_construction_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-052-brookline-clinic/10_construction/076_construction_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-052-brookline-clinic/10_construction/077_construction_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-052-brookline-clinic/10_construction/078_construction_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-052-brookline-clinic/10_construction/079_construction_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-052-brookline-clinic/10_construction/080_construction_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-052-brookline-clinic/11_financing/081_financing_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-052-brookline-clinic/11_financing/082_financing_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-052-brookline-clinic/11_financing/083_financing_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-052-brookline-clinic/11_financing/084_financing_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-052-brookline-clinic/11_financing/085_financing_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-052-brookline-clinic/11_financing/086_financing_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-052-brookline-clinic/11_financing/087_financing_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-052-brookline-clinic/11_financing/088_financing_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-052-brookline-clinic/12_property_management/089_property_management_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-052-brookline-clinic/12_property_management/090_property_management_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-052-brookline-clinic/12_property_management/091_property_management_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-052-brookline-clinic/12_property_management/092_property_management_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-052-brookline-clinic/12_property_management/093_property_management_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-052-brookline-clinic/12_property_management/094_property_management_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-052-brookline-clinic/12_property_management/095_property_management_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-052-brookline-clinic/12_property_management/096_property_management_status_report.md"], "gold_output": {"advice_markdown": "# Counsel advice — Brookline clinic acquisition property review\n\n## Executive assessment\n\nFor Brookline Care Partners matter CB-RE-2902, the review identified 16 source-supported exceptions requiring action before 2026-09-07. The assessment concerns Elm Street Medical Properties and the supplied record for Massachusetts.\n\n## Method and record coverage\n\nThe review inventoried all 96 production files, read the 33 controlling, corroborating, and control records, searched the email exports, and checked metadata for the designated chain-of-custody sample. Conclusions are limited to the synthetic production supplied for this benchmark matter.\n\n## Findings\n\n### F-01 — rent schedule inconsistency (critical)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for rent schedule inconsistency: one source states the operative date is 2025-03-13 under control reference CB-RE-2902-A529, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2025-04-12 under response reference CB-RE-2902-J963.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/01_leases/001_leases_control_register.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/07_operating_expenses/049_operating_expenses_control_register.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-07, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Willa Novak.\n\n### F-02 — renewal-option notice (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for renewal-option notice: one source states the controlling amount is $6,281,118.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $6,588,736.00.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/01_leases/004_leases_ledger_export.csv`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/07_operating_expenses/052_operating_expenses_ledger_export.csv`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-07, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Theo Laurent.\n\n### F-03 — exclusive-use conflict (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for exclusive-use conflict: one source states approval is attributed to Caleb Hassan as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Samuel Kim and contains no entry for Caleb Hassan.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/01_leases/007_leases_officer_certificate.html`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/07_operating_expenses/055_operating_expenses_officer_certificate.html`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-07, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Amara Patel.\n\n### F-04 — assignment consent (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for assignment consent: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-RE-2902-D775, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-RE-2902-M636.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/02_amendments/010_amendments_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/08_insurance/058_insurance_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-07, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Henry Cho.\n\n### F-05 — estoppel discrepancy (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for estoppel discrepancy: one source states the applicable location is Middlesex County, Massachusetts, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to Massachusetts operations outside Middlesex County, Massachusetts.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/02_amendments/013_amendments_review_memorandum.json`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/08_insurance/061_insurance_review_memorandum.json`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-07, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Nadine Flores.\n\n### F-06 — survey encroachment (low)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for survey encroachment: one source states the threshold is 11% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 14% and produced a different exception result.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/02_amendments/016_amendments_status_report.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/08_insurance/064_insurance_status_report.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-07, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Micah Sullivan.\n\n### F-07 — title exception (critical)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for title exception: one source states formal notice must use notices-brookline_care_partners@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-elm_street_medical_properties@example.test.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/03_estoppels/019_estoppels_correspondence.eml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/09_notices/067_notices_correspondence.eml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-07, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Farah Ibrahim.\n\n### F-08 — environmental recognized condition (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for environmental recognized condition: one source states the governed population contains 115 records through 2025-07-29, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 68 records through 2025-09-07.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/03_estoppels/022_estoppels_formal_notice.xml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/09_notices/070_notices_formal_notice.xml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-07, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Owen Delgado.\n\n### F-09 — zoning nonconformity (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for zoning nonconformity: one source states the operative date is 2025-06-19 under control reference CB-RE-2902-I987, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2025-08-02 under response reference CB-RE-2902-R445.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/04_title_survey/025_title_survey_control_register.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/10_construction/073_construction_control_register.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-07, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Lena Varga.\n\n### F-10 — permit closeout gap (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for permit closeout gap: one source states the controlling amount is $2,478,858.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $2,754,216.00.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/04_title_survey/028_title_survey_ledger_export.csv`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/10_construction/076_construction_ledger_export.csv`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-07, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Samuel Kim.\n\n### F-11 — CAM reconciliation error (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for CAM reconciliation error: one source states approval is attributed to Caleb Hassan as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Theo Laurent and contains no entry for Caleb Hassan.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/04_title_survey/031_title_survey_officer_certificate.html`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/10_construction/079_construction_officer_certificate.html`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-07, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Maya Ellison.\n\n### F-12 — insurance endorsement deficiency (low)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for insurance endorsement deficiency: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-RE-2902-L157, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-RE-2902-U658.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/05_environmental/034_environmental_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/11_financing/082_financing_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-07, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Rafael Okafor.\n\n### F-13 — casualty restoration deadline (critical)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for casualty restoration deadline: one source states the applicable location is Middlesex County, Massachusetts, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to Massachusetts operations outside Middlesex County, Massachusetts.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/05_environmental/037_environmental_review_memorandum.json`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/11_financing/085_financing_review_memorandum.json`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-07, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Nora Chen.\n\n### F-14 — construction lien notice (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for construction lien notice: one source states the threshold is 2% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 8% and produced a different exception result.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/05_environmental/040_environmental_status_report.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/11_financing/088_financing_status_report.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-07, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Dominic Alvarez.\n\n### F-15 — lender SNDA omission (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for lender SNDA omission: one source states formal notice must use notices-brookline_care_partners@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-elm_street_medical_properties@example.test.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/043_zoning_permits_correspondence.eml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/12_property_management/091_property_management_correspondence.eml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-07, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Priya Raman.\n\n### F-16 — security-deposit mismatch (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for security-deposit mismatch: one source states the governed population contains 91 records through 2025-07-05, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 43 records through 2025-07-20.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/046_zoning_permits_formal_notice.xml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/12_property_management/094_property_management_formal_notice.xml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-07, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Elliot Mercer.\n\n## Recommended next actions\n\nSequence the critical and high findings first, assign the named owners, preserve the cited records, and document any resolution in the controlling matter register before the stated deadline.\n\n## Assumptions and limitations\n\nThis analysis is confined to task cb100-052-brookline-clinic and the supplied synthetic evidence. It does not rely on external facts, does not resolve disputed law, and is not legal advice for a real person or entity.\n", "findings": {"as_of": "2026-09-07", "findings": [{"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/07_operating_expenses/049_operating_expenses_control_register.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for rent schedule inconsistency: one source states the operative date is 2025-03-13 under control reference CB-RE-2902-A529, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2025-04-12 under response reference CB-RE-2902-J963.", "id": "F-01", "issue": "rent schedule inconsistency", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/01_leases/001_leases_control_register.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-07, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Willa Novak.", "severity": "critical"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/07_operating_expenses/052_operating_expenses_ledger_export.csv", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for renewal-option notice: one source states the controlling amount is $6,281,118.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $6,588,736.00.", "id": "F-02", "issue": "renewal-option notice", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/01_leases/004_leases_ledger_export.csv", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-07, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Theo Laurent.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/07_operating_expenses/055_operating_expenses_officer_certificate.html", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for exclusive-use conflict: one source states approval is attributed to Caleb Hassan as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Samuel Kim and contains no entry for Caleb Hassan.", "id": "F-03", "issue": "exclusive-use conflict", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/01_leases/007_leases_officer_certificate.html", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-07, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Amara Patel.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/08_insurance/058_insurance_executed_instrument.txt", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for assignment consent: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-RE-2902-D775, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-RE-2902-M636.", "id": "F-04", "issue": "assignment consent", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/02_amendments/010_amendments_executed_instrument.txt", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-07, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Henry Cho.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/08_insurance/061_insurance_review_memorandum.json", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for estoppel discrepancy: one source states the applicable location is Middlesex County, Massachusetts, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to Massachusetts operations outside Middlesex County, Massachusetts.", "id": "F-05", "issue": "estoppel discrepancy", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/02_amendments/013_amendments_review_memorandum.json", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-07, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Nadine Flores.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/08_insurance/064_insurance_status_report.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for survey encroachment: one source states the threshold is 11% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 14% and produced a different exception result.", "id": "F-06", "issue": "survey encroachment", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/02_amendments/016_amendments_status_report.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-07, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Micah Sullivan.", "severity": "low"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/09_notices/067_notices_correspondence.eml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for title exception: one source states formal notice must use notices-brookline_care_partners@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-elm_street_medical_properties@example.test.", "id": "F-07", "issue": "title exception", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/03_estoppels/019_estoppels_correspondence.eml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-07, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Farah Ibrahim.", "severity": "critical"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/09_notices/070_notices_formal_notice.xml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for environmental recognized condition: one source states the governed population contains 115 records through 2025-07-29, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 68 records through 2025-09-07.", "id": "F-08", "issue": "environmental recognized condition", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/03_estoppels/022_estoppels_formal_notice.xml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-07, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Owen Delgado.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/10_construction/073_construction_control_register.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for zoning nonconformity: one source states the operative date is 2025-06-19 under control reference CB-RE-2902-I987, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2025-08-02 under response reference CB-RE-2902-R445.", "id": "F-09", "issue": "zoning nonconformity", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/04_title_survey/025_title_survey_control_register.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-07, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Lena Varga.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/10_construction/076_construction_ledger_export.csv", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for permit closeout gap: one source states the controlling amount is $2,478,858.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $2,754,216.00.", "id": "F-10", "issue": "permit closeout gap", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/04_title_survey/028_title_survey_ledger_export.csv", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-07, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Samuel Kim.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/10_construction/079_construction_officer_certificate.html", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for CAM reconciliation error: one source states approval is attributed to Caleb Hassan as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Theo Laurent and contains no entry for Caleb Hassan.", "id": "F-11", "issue": "CAM reconciliation error", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/04_title_survey/031_title_survey_officer_certificate.html", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-07, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Maya Ellison.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/11_financing/082_financing_executed_instrument.txt", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for insurance endorsement deficiency: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-RE-2902-L157, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-RE-2902-U658.", "id": "F-12", "issue": "insurance endorsement deficiency", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/05_environmental/034_environmental_executed_instrument.txt", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-07, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Rafael Okafor.", "severity": "low"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/11_financing/085_financing_review_memorandum.json", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for casualty restoration deadline: one source states the applicable location is Middlesex County, Massachusetts, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to Massachusetts operations outside Middlesex County, Massachusetts.", "id": "F-13", "issue": "casualty restoration deadline", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/05_environmental/037_environmental_review_memorandum.json", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-07, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Nora Chen.", "severity": "critical"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/11_financing/088_financing_status_report.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for construction lien notice: one source states the threshold is 2% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 8% and produced a different exception result.", "id": "F-14", "issue": "construction lien notice", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/05_environmental/040_environmental_status_report.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-07, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Dominic Alvarez.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/12_property_management/091_property_management_correspondence.eml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for lender SNDA omission: one source states formal notice must use notices-brookline_care_partners@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-elm_street_medical_properties@example.test.", "id": "F-15", "issue": "lender SNDA omission", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/043_zoning_permits_correspondence.eml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-07, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Priya Raman.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/12_property_management/094_property_management_formal_notice.xml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for security-deposit mismatch: one source states the governed population contains 91 records through 2025-07-05, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 43 records through 2025-07-20.", "id": "F-16", "issue": "security-deposit mismatch", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/046_zoning_permits_formal_notice.xml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-07, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Elliot Mercer.", "severity": "medium"}], "matter_number": "CB-RE-2902", "prepared_for": "Brookline Care Partners", "schema_version": "1.0", "task_id": "cb100-052-brookline-clinic"}}, "metadata": {"benchmark": "CounselBench-100", "code_license": "Apache-2.0", "data_license": "CC-BY-4.0", "deadline": "2026-09-07", "document_count": 96, "jurisdiction": "Massachusetts", "matter_number": "CB-RE-2902", "mcp_commit": "9a96ea6e5913736f92b88345bf51caeaaa8e719f", "mcp_package": "@modelcontextprotocol/server-filesystem@2026.7.10", "practice_area": "real-estate", "reference_tool_calls": 46, "required_evidence_reads": 33, "synthetic": true, "venue": "Middlesex County, Massachusetts", "version": "2.0.0"}, "prompt": "You are real-estate transactions counsel for Brookline Care Partners. A late document production changed the factual picture, and the matter team needs the entire record reconciled from first principles. A medical-office portfolio presents zoning, assignment, lender consent, and environmental records that do not align with seller certificates. Decision due 2026-09-07. Massachusetts law governs; Middlesex County, Massachusetts is the forum. Separate confirmed exceptions from items that merely require follow-up. Work out the defensible position from the matter production and leave an audit-ready exception tracker and concise advice for the supervising lawyer. Keep confirmed conflicts separate from open questions, cite the records that actually control each conclusion, and do not fill gaps with outside facts.", "rubric": {"criteria": [{"category": "procedure", "description": "Complete at least 46 successful, argument-specific evidence and output calls.", "id": "procedure.minimum_successful_tool_calls"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Find and read the 33 controlling, corroborating, and work-product-control records in full.", "id": "procedure.all_evidence_read_in_full"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Inspect file metadata for the eight designated critical primary records before relying on them.", "id": "procedure.chain_of_custody_metadata_checked"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Confirm the sandbox's allowed document and output roots.", "id": "procedure.allowed_directories_checked"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Inventory all 96 records so the relevant sources are discovered among the context records.", "id": "procedure.recursive_inventory_completed"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Search the production for email evidence that may corroborate or contradict formal records.", "id": "procedure.targeted_search_completed"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Leave only findings.json and advice.md in the output workspace.", "id": "procedure.exact_deliverable_set"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Create both final work products through the sandbox MCP surface.", "id": "procedure.deliverables_written_through_mcp"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Produce findings.json as a valid JSON object.", "id": "findings.findings_is_object"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Report exactly 16 confirmed exceptions.", "id": "findings.findings_exact_count"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Use each stable finding ID exactly once.", "id": "findings.finding_ids_unique"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set schema_version to the released matter value '1.0'.", "id": "findings.top_level_schema_version"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set task_id to the released matter value 'cb100-052-brookline-clinic'.", "id": "findings.top_level_task_id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set matter_number to the released matter value 'CB-RE-2902'.", "id": "findings.top_level_matter_number"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set prepared_for to the released matter value 'Brookline Care Partners'.", "id": "findings.top_level_prepared_for"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set as_of to the released matter value '2026-09-07'.", "id": "findings.top_level_as_of"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-01 exception for rent schedule inconsistency.", "id": "findings.F-01.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's id from /workspace/documents/01_leases/001_leases_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_operating_expenses/049_operating_expenses_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's issue from /workspace/documents/01_leases/001_leases_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_operating_expenses/049_operating_expenses_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's severity from /workspace/documents/01_leases/001_leases_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_operating_expenses/049_operating_expenses_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's primary_source from /workspace/documents/01_leases/001_leases_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_operating_expenses/049_operating_expenses_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/01_leases/001_leases_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_operating_expenses/049_operating_expenses_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-01 using the exact controlled facts ['2025-03-13', 'CB-RE-2902-A529', '2025-04-12', 'CB-RE-2902-J963'].", "id": "findings.F-01.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-01's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-01.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-07', 'Willa Novak'] for F-01.", "id": "findings.F-01.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-02 exception for renewal-option notice.", "id": "findings.F-02.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's id from /workspace/documents/01_leases/004_leases_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_operating_expenses/052_operating_expenses_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's issue from /workspace/documents/01_leases/004_leases_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_operating_expenses/052_operating_expenses_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's severity from /workspace/documents/01_leases/004_leases_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_operating_expenses/052_operating_expenses_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's primary_source from /workspace/documents/01_leases/004_leases_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_operating_expenses/052_operating_expenses_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/01_leases/004_leases_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_operating_expenses/052_operating_expenses_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-02 using the exact controlled facts ['$6,281,118.00', '$6,588,736.00'].", "id": "findings.F-02.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-02's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-02.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-07', 'Theo Laurent'] for F-02.", "id": "findings.F-02.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-03 exception for exclusive-use conflict.", "id": "findings.F-03.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's id from /workspace/documents/01_leases/007_leases_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_operating_expenses/055_operating_expenses_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's issue from /workspace/documents/01_leases/007_leases_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_operating_expenses/055_operating_expenses_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's severity from /workspace/documents/01_leases/007_leases_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_operating_expenses/055_operating_expenses_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's primary_source from /workspace/documents/01_leases/007_leases_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_operating_expenses/055_operating_expenses_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/01_leases/007_leases_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_operating_expenses/055_operating_expenses_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-03 using the exact controlled facts ['Caleb Hassan', 'Samuel Kim'].", "id": "findings.F-03.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-03's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-03.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-07', 'Amara Patel'] for F-03.", "id": "findings.F-03.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-04 exception for assignment consent.", "id": "findings.F-04.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's id from /workspace/documents/02_amendments/010_amendments_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_insurance/058_insurance_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's issue from /workspace/documents/02_amendments/010_amendments_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_insurance/058_insurance_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's severity from /workspace/documents/02_amendments/010_amendments_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_insurance/058_insurance_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's primary_source from /workspace/documents/02_amendments/010_amendments_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_insurance/058_insurance_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/02_amendments/010_amendments_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_insurance/058_insurance_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-04 using the exact controlled facts ['closed without exception', 'CB-RE-2902-D775', 'open and escalated', 'CB-RE-2902-M636'].", "id": "findings.F-04.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-04's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-04.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-07', 'Henry Cho'] for F-04.", "id": "findings.F-04.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-05 exception for estoppel discrepancy.", "id": "findings.F-05.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's id from /workspace/documents/02_amendments/013_amendments_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_insurance/061_insurance_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's issue from /workspace/documents/02_amendments/013_amendments_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_insurance/061_insurance_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's severity from /workspace/documents/02_amendments/013_amendments_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_insurance/061_insurance_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's primary_source from /workspace/documents/02_amendments/013_amendments_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_insurance/061_insurance_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/02_amendments/013_amendments_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_insurance/061_insurance_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-05 using the exact controlled facts ['Middlesex County, Massachusetts', 'Massachusetts'].", "id": "findings.F-05.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-05's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-05.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-07', 'Nadine Flores'] for F-05.", "id": "findings.F-05.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-06 exception for survey encroachment.", "id": "findings.F-06.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's id from /workspace/documents/02_amendments/016_amendments_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_insurance/064_insurance_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's issue from /workspace/documents/02_amendments/016_amendments_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_insurance/064_insurance_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's severity from /workspace/documents/02_amendments/016_amendments_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_insurance/064_insurance_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's primary_source from /workspace/documents/02_amendments/016_amendments_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_insurance/064_insurance_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/02_amendments/016_amendments_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_insurance/064_insurance_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-06 using the exact controlled facts ['11%', '14%'].", "id": "findings.F-06.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-06's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-06.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-07', 'Micah Sullivan'] for F-06.", "id": "findings.F-06.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-07 exception for title exception.", "id": "findings.F-07.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's id from /workspace/documents/03_estoppels/019_estoppels_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_notices/067_notices_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's issue from /workspace/documents/03_estoppels/019_estoppels_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_notices/067_notices_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's severity from /workspace/documents/03_estoppels/019_estoppels_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_notices/067_notices_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's primary_source from /workspace/documents/03_estoppels/019_estoppels_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_notices/067_notices_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/03_estoppels/019_estoppels_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_notices/067_notices_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-07 using the exact controlled facts ['notices-brookline_care_partners@example.test', 'archive-elm_street_medical_properties@example.test'].", "id": "findings.F-07.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-07's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-07.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-07', 'Farah Ibrahim'] for F-07.", "id": "findings.F-07.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-08 exception for environmental recognized condition.", "id": "findings.F-08.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's id from /workspace/documents/03_estoppels/022_estoppels_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_notices/070_notices_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's issue from /workspace/documents/03_estoppels/022_estoppels_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_notices/070_notices_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's severity from /workspace/documents/03_estoppels/022_estoppels_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_notices/070_notices_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's primary_source from /workspace/documents/03_estoppels/022_estoppels_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_notices/070_notices_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/03_estoppels/022_estoppels_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_notices/070_notices_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-08 using the exact controlled facts ['115 records', '2025-07-29', '68 records', '2025-09-07'].", "id": "findings.F-08.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-08's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-08.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-07', 'Owen Delgado'] for F-08.", "id": "findings.F-08.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-09 exception for zoning nonconformity.", "id": "findings.F-09.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's id from /workspace/documents/04_title_survey/025_title_survey_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_construction/073_construction_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's issue from /workspace/documents/04_title_survey/025_title_survey_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_construction/073_construction_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's severity from /workspace/documents/04_title_survey/025_title_survey_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_construction/073_construction_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's primary_source from /workspace/documents/04_title_survey/025_title_survey_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_construction/073_construction_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/04_title_survey/025_title_survey_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_construction/073_construction_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-09 using the exact controlled facts ['2025-06-19', 'CB-RE-2902-I987', '2025-08-02', 'CB-RE-2902-R445'].", "id": "findings.F-09.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-09's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-09.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-07', 'Lena Varga'] for F-09.", "id": "findings.F-09.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-10 exception for permit closeout gap.", "id": "findings.F-10.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's id from /workspace/documents/04_title_survey/028_title_survey_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_construction/076_construction_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's issue from /workspace/documents/04_title_survey/028_title_survey_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_construction/076_construction_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's severity from /workspace/documents/04_title_survey/028_title_survey_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_construction/076_construction_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's primary_source from /workspace/documents/04_title_survey/028_title_survey_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_construction/076_construction_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/04_title_survey/028_title_survey_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_construction/076_construction_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-10 using the exact controlled facts ['$2,478,858.00', '$2,754,216.00'].", "id": "findings.F-10.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-10's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-10.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-07', 'Samuel Kim'] for F-10.", "id": "findings.F-10.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-11 exception for CAM reconciliation error.", "id": "findings.F-11.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's id from /workspace/documents/04_title_survey/031_title_survey_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_construction/079_construction_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's issue from /workspace/documents/04_title_survey/031_title_survey_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_construction/079_construction_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's severity from /workspace/documents/04_title_survey/031_title_survey_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_construction/079_construction_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's primary_source from /workspace/documents/04_title_survey/031_title_survey_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_construction/079_construction_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/04_title_survey/031_title_survey_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_construction/079_construction_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-11 using the exact controlled facts ['Caleb Hassan', 'Theo Laurent'].", "id": "findings.F-11.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-11's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-11.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-07', 'Maya Ellison'] for F-11.", "id": "findings.F-11.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-12 exception for insurance endorsement deficiency.", "id": "findings.F-12.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's id from /workspace/documents/05_environmental/034_environmental_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_financing/082_financing_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's issue from /workspace/documents/05_environmental/034_environmental_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_financing/082_financing_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's severity from /workspace/documents/05_environmental/034_environmental_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_financing/082_financing_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's primary_source from /workspace/documents/05_environmental/034_environmental_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_financing/082_financing_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/05_environmental/034_environmental_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_financing/082_financing_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-12 using the exact controlled facts ['closed without exception', 'CB-RE-2902-L157', 'open and escalated', 'CB-RE-2902-U658'].", "id": "findings.F-12.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-12's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-12.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-07', 'Rafael Okafor'] for F-12.", "id": "findings.F-12.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-13 exception for casualty restoration deadline.", "id": "findings.F-13.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's id from /workspace/documents/05_environmental/037_environmental_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_financing/085_financing_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's issue from /workspace/documents/05_environmental/037_environmental_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_financing/085_financing_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's severity from /workspace/documents/05_environmental/037_environmental_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_financing/085_financing_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's primary_source from /workspace/documents/05_environmental/037_environmental_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_financing/085_financing_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/05_environmental/037_environmental_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_financing/085_financing_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-13 using the exact controlled facts ['Middlesex County, Massachusetts', 'Massachusetts'].", "id": "findings.F-13.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-13's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-13.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-07', 'Nora Chen'] for F-13.", "id": "findings.F-13.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-14 exception for construction lien notice.", "id": "findings.F-14.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's id from /workspace/documents/05_environmental/040_environmental_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_financing/088_financing_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's issue from /workspace/documents/05_environmental/040_environmental_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_financing/088_financing_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's severity from /workspace/documents/05_environmental/040_environmental_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_financing/088_financing_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's primary_source from /workspace/documents/05_environmental/040_environmental_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_financing/088_financing_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/05_environmental/040_environmental_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_financing/088_financing_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-14 using the exact controlled facts ['2%', '8%'].", "id": "findings.F-14.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-14's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-14.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-07', 'Dominic Alvarez'] for F-14.", "id": "findings.F-14.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-15 exception for lender SNDA omission.", "id": "findings.F-15.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's id from /workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/043_zoning_permits_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_property_management/091_property_management_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's issue from /workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/043_zoning_permits_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_property_management/091_property_management_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's severity from /workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/043_zoning_permits_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_property_management/091_property_management_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's primary_source from /workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/043_zoning_permits_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_property_management/091_property_management_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/043_zoning_permits_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_property_management/091_property_management_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-15 using the exact controlled facts ['notices-brookline_care_partners@example.test', 'archive-elm_street_medical_properties@example.test'].", "id": "findings.F-15.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-15's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-15.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-07', 'Priya Raman'] for F-15.", "id": "findings.F-15.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-16 exception for security-deposit mismatch.", "id": "findings.F-16.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's id from /workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/046_zoning_permits_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_property_management/094_property_management_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's issue from /workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/046_zoning_permits_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_property_management/094_property_management_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's severity from /workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/046_zoning_permits_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_property_management/094_property_management_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's primary_source from /workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/046_zoning_permits_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_property_management/094_property_management_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/046_zoning_permits_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_property_management/094_property_management_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-16 using the exact controlled facts ['91 records', '2025-07-05', '43 records', '2025-07-20'].", "id": "findings.F-16.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-16's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-16.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-07', 'Elliot Mercer'] for F-16.", "id": "findings.F-16.action_anchors"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Executive assessment' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Executive assessment"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Method and record coverage' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Method and record coverage"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Findings' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Findings"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Recommended next actions' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Recommended next actions"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Assumptions and limitations' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Assumptions and limitations"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-01 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-01"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-02 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-02"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-03 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-03"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-04 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-04"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-05 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-05"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-06 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-06"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-07 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-07"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-08 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-08"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-09 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-09"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-10 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-10"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-11 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-11"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-12 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-12"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-13 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-13"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-14 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-14"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-15 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-15"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-16 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-16"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Do not claim the production has no issues or that every record is consistent.", "id": "memo.forbidden_claims_absent"}], "decision_options": [{"id": "cross-source-reconciliation", "label": "Reconcile controlling and corroborating records", "reason": "The CB-RE-2902 production contains independently maintained records; a defensible answer must preserve each supported conflict and its cure owner.", "selected": true}, {"id": "latest-record-controls", "label": "Treat the latest record as controlling", "reason": "Timestamp recency does not establish legal priority, execution, or approval authority.", "selected": false}, {"id": "primary-records-only", "label": "Report primary records without reconciliation", "reason": "Primary records alone conceal the operational conflicts that create the actionable exceptions.", "selected": false}], "gates": ["all_evidence_read_in_full", "chain_of_custody_metadata_checked", "findings_criteria_complete", "memo_criteria_complete", "deliverables_written_through_mcp"], "metadata_checks": 8, "metric": "weighted_criteria_score", "minimum_tool_calls": 46, "required_deliverables": ["findings.json", "advice.md"], "required_document_reads": 33, "type": "deterministic", "weights": {"findings": 0.55, "memo": 0.2, "procedure": 0.25}}, "task_id": "cb100-052-brookline-clinic", "task_name": "Brookline clinic acquisition property review", "world_id": "counselbench-filesystem-mcp-v2"}
-{"context_files": ["task_files/cb100-053-canyon-grocery/01_leases/001_leases_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-053-canyon-grocery/01_leases/002_leases_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-053-canyon-grocery/01_leases/003_leases_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-053-canyon-grocery/01_leases/004_leases_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-053-canyon-grocery/01_leases/005_leases_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-053-canyon-grocery/01_leases/006_leases_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-053-canyon-grocery/01_leases/007_leases_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-053-canyon-grocery/01_leases/008_leases_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-053-canyon-grocery/02_amendments/009_amendments_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-053-canyon-grocery/02_amendments/010_amendments_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-053-canyon-grocery/02_amendments/011_amendments_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-053-canyon-grocery/02_amendments/012_amendments_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-053-canyon-grocery/02_amendments/013_amendments_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-053-canyon-grocery/02_amendments/014_amendments_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-053-canyon-grocery/02_amendments/015_amendments_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-053-canyon-grocery/02_amendments/016_amendments_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-053-canyon-grocery/03_estoppels/017_estoppels_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-053-canyon-grocery/03_estoppels/018_estoppels_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-053-canyon-grocery/03_estoppels/019_estoppels_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-053-canyon-grocery/03_estoppels/020_estoppels_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-053-canyon-grocery/03_estoppels/021_estoppels_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-053-canyon-grocery/03_estoppels/022_estoppels_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-053-canyon-grocery/03_estoppels/023_estoppels_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-053-canyon-grocery/03_estoppels/024_estoppels_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-053-canyon-grocery/04_title_survey/025_title_survey_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-053-canyon-grocery/04_title_survey/026_title_survey_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-053-canyon-grocery/04_title_survey/027_title_survey_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-053-canyon-grocery/04_title_survey/028_title_survey_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-053-canyon-grocery/04_title_survey/029_title_survey_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-053-canyon-grocery/04_title_survey/030_title_survey_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-053-canyon-grocery/04_title_survey/031_title_survey_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-053-canyon-grocery/04_title_survey/032_title_survey_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-053-canyon-grocery/05_environmental/033_environmental_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-053-canyon-grocery/05_environmental/034_environmental_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-053-canyon-grocery/05_environmental/035_environmental_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-053-canyon-grocery/05_environmental/036_environmental_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-053-canyon-grocery/05_environmental/037_environmental_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-053-canyon-grocery/05_environmental/038_environmental_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-053-canyon-grocery/05_environmental/039_environmental_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-053-canyon-grocery/05_environmental/040_environmental_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-053-canyon-grocery/06_zoning_permits/041_zoning_permits_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-053-canyon-grocery/06_zoning_permits/042_zoning_permits_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-053-canyon-grocery/06_zoning_permits/043_zoning_permits_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-053-canyon-grocery/06_zoning_permits/044_zoning_permits_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-053-canyon-grocery/06_zoning_permits/045_zoning_permits_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-053-canyon-grocery/06_zoning_permits/046_zoning_permits_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-053-canyon-grocery/06_zoning_permits/047_zoning_permits_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-053-canyon-grocery/06_zoning_permits/048_zoning_permits_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-053-canyon-grocery/07_operating_expenses/049_operating_expenses_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-053-canyon-grocery/07_operating_expenses/050_operating_expenses_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-053-canyon-grocery/07_operating_expenses/051_operating_expenses_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-053-canyon-grocery/07_operating_expenses/052_operating_expenses_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-053-canyon-grocery/07_operating_expenses/053_operating_expenses_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-053-canyon-grocery/07_operating_expenses/054_operating_expenses_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-053-canyon-grocery/07_operating_expenses/055_operating_expenses_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-053-canyon-grocery/07_operating_expenses/056_operating_expenses_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-053-canyon-grocery/08_insurance/057_insurance_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-053-canyon-grocery/08_insurance/058_insurance_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-053-canyon-grocery/08_insurance/059_insurance_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-053-canyon-grocery/08_insurance/060_insurance_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-053-canyon-grocery/08_insurance/061_insurance_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-053-canyon-grocery/08_insurance/062_insurance_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-053-canyon-grocery/08_insurance/063_insurance_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-053-canyon-grocery/08_insurance/064_insurance_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-053-canyon-grocery/09_notices/065_notices_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-053-canyon-grocery/09_notices/066_notices_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-053-canyon-grocery/09_notices/067_notices_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-053-canyon-grocery/09_notices/068_notices_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-053-canyon-grocery/09_notices/069_notices_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-053-canyon-grocery/09_notices/070_notices_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-053-canyon-grocery/09_notices/071_notices_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-053-canyon-grocery/09_notices/072_notices_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-053-canyon-grocery/10_construction/073_construction_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-053-canyon-grocery/10_construction/074_construction_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-053-canyon-grocery/10_construction/075_construction_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-053-canyon-grocery/10_construction/076_construction_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-053-canyon-grocery/10_construction/077_construction_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-053-canyon-grocery/10_construction/078_construction_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-053-canyon-grocery/10_construction/079_construction_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-053-canyon-grocery/10_construction/080_construction_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-053-canyon-grocery/11_financing/081_financing_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-053-canyon-grocery/11_financing/082_financing_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-053-canyon-grocery/11_financing/083_financing_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-053-canyon-grocery/11_financing/084_financing_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-053-canyon-grocery/11_financing/085_financing_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-053-canyon-grocery/11_financing/086_financing_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-053-canyon-grocery/11_financing/087_financing_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-053-canyon-grocery/11_financing/088_financing_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-053-canyon-grocery/12_property_management/089_property_management_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-053-canyon-grocery/12_property_management/090_property_management_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-053-canyon-grocery/12_property_management/091_property_management_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-053-canyon-grocery/12_property_management/092_property_management_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-053-canyon-grocery/12_property_management/093_property_management_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-053-canyon-grocery/12_property_management/094_property_management_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-053-canyon-grocery/12_property_management/095_property_management_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-053-canyon-grocery/12_property_management/096_property_management_status_report.md"], "gold_output": {"advice_markdown": "# Counsel advice — Canyon grocery lease portfolio audit\n\n## Executive assessment\n\nFor Canyon Fresh Markets matter CB-RE-2903, the review identified 16 source-supported exceptions requiring action before 2026-09-10. The assessment concerns Mesa Vista Shopping Centers and the supplied record for Arizona.\n\n## Method and record coverage\n\nThe review inventoried all 96 production files, read the 33 controlling, corroborating, and control records, searched the email exports, and checked metadata for the designated chain-of-custody sample. Conclusions are limited to the synthetic production supplied for this benchmark matter.\n\n## Findings\n\n### F-01 — rent schedule inconsistency (critical)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for rent schedule inconsistency: one source states the operative date is 2025-06-20 under control reference CB-RE-2903-A568, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2025-08-05 under response reference CB-RE-2903-J897.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/01_leases/001_leases_control_register.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/07_operating_expenses/049_operating_expenses_control_register.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-10, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Theo Laurent.\n\n### F-02 — renewal-option notice (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for renewal-option notice: one source states the controlling amount is $3,321,197.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $3,378,894.00.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/01_leases/004_leases_ledger_export.csv`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/07_operating_expenses/052_operating_expenses_ledger_export.csv`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-10, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Amara Patel.\n\n### F-03 — exclusive-use conflict (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for exclusive-use conflict: one source states approval is attributed to Leona Park as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Rafael Okafor and contains no entry for Leona Park.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/01_leases/007_leases_officer_certificate.html`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/07_operating_expenses/055_operating_expenses_officer_certificate.html`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-10, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Henry Cho.\n\n### F-04 — assignment consent (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for assignment consent: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-RE-2903-D311, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-RE-2903-M531.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/02_amendments/010_amendments_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/08_insurance/058_insurance_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-10, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Nadine Flores.\n\n### F-05 — estoppel discrepancy (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for estoppel discrepancy: one source states the applicable location is Maricopa County, Arizona, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to Arizona operations outside Maricopa County, Arizona.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/02_amendments/013_amendments_review_memorandum.json`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/08_insurance/061_insurance_review_memorandum.json`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-10, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Micah Sullivan.\n\n### F-06 — survey encroachment (low)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for survey encroachment: one source states the threshold is 4% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 10% and produced a different exception result.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/02_amendments/016_amendments_status_report.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/08_insurance/064_insurance_status_report.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-10, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Farah Ibrahim.\n\n### F-07 — title exception (critical)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for title exception: one source states formal notice must use notices-canyon_fresh_markets@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-mesa_vista_shopping_centers@example.test.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/03_estoppels/019_estoppels_correspondence.eml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/09_notices/067_notices_correspondence.eml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-10, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Owen Delgado.\n\n### F-08 — environmental recognized condition (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for environmental recognized condition: one source states the governed population contains 95 records through 2025-02-19, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 40 records through 2025-03-03.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/03_estoppels/022_estoppels_formal_notice.xml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/09_notices/070_notices_formal_notice.xml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-10, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Lena Varga.\n\n### F-09 — zoning nonconformity (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for zoning nonconformity: one source states the operative date is 2026-02-18 under control reference CB-RE-2903-I871, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2026-03-28 under response reference CB-RE-2903-R643.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/04_title_survey/025_title_survey_control_register.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/10_construction/073_construction_control_register.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-10, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Samuel Kim.\n\n### F-10 — permit closeout gap (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for permit closeout gap: one source states the controlling amount is $6,232,836.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $6,412,172.00.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/04_title_survey/028_title_survey_ledger_export.csv`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/10_construction/076_construction_ledger_export.csv`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-10, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Maya Ellison.\n\n### F-11 — CAM reconciliation error (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for CAM reconciliation error: one source states approval is attributed to Leona Park as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Henry Cho and contains no entry for Leona Park.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/04_title_survey/031_title_survey_officer_certificate.html`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/10_construction/079_construction_officer_certificate.html`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-10, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Rafael Okafor.\n\n### F-12 — insurance endorsement deficiency (low)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for insurance endorsement deficiency: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-RE-2903-L255, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-RE-2903-U388.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/05_environmental/034_environmental_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/11_financing/082_financing_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-10, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Nora Chen.\n\n### F-13 — casualty restoration deadline (critical)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for casualty restoration deadline: one source states the applicable location is Maricopa County, Arizona, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to Arizona operations outside Maricopa County, Arizona.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/05_environmental/037_environmental_review_memorandum.json`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/11_financing/085_financing_review_memorandum.json`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-10, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Dominic Alvarez.\n\n### F-14 — construction lien notice (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for construction lien notice: one source states the threshold is 14% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 18% and produced a different exception result.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/05_environmental/040_environmental_status_report.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/11_financing/088_financing_status_report.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-10, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Priya Raman.\n\n### F-15 — lender SNDA omission (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for lender SNDA omission: one source states formal notice must use notices-canyon_fresh_markets@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-mesa_vista_shopping_centers@example.test.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/043_zoning_permits_correspondence.eml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/12_property_management/091_property_management_correspondence.eml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-10, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Elliot Mercer.\n\n### F-16 — security-deposit mismatch (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for security-deposit mismatch: one source states the governed population contains 103 records through 2025-02-27, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 54 records through 2025-03-25.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/046_zoning_permits_formal_notice.xml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/12_property_management/094_property_management_formal_notice.xml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-10, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Talia Brooks.\n\n## Recommended next actions\n\nSequence the critical and high findings first, assign the named owners, preserve the cited records, and document any resolution in the controlling matter register before the stated deadline.\n\n## Assumptions and limitations\n\nThis analysis is confined to task cb100-053-canyon-grocery and the supplied synthetic evidence. It does not rely on external facts, does not resolve disputed law, and is not legal advice for a real person or entity.\n", "findings": {"as_of": "2026-09-10", "findings": [{"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/07_operating_expenses/049_operating_expenses_control_register.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for rent schedule inconsistency: one source states the operative date is 2025-06-20 under control reference CB-RE-2903-A568, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2025-08-05 under response reference CB-RE-2903-J897.", "id": "F-01", "issue": "rent schedule inconsistency", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/01_leases/001_leases_control_register.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-10, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Theo Laurent.", "severity": "critical"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/07_operating_expenses/052_operating_expenses_ledger_export.csv", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for renewal-option notice: one source states the controlling amount is $3,321,197.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $3,378,894.00.", "id": "F-02", "issue": "renewal-option notice", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/01_leases/004_leases_ledger_export.csv", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-10, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Amara Patel.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/07_operating_expenses/055_operating_expenses_officer_certificate.html", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for exclusive-use conflict: one source states approval is attributed to Leona Park as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Rafael Okafor and contains no entry for Leona Park.", "id": "F-03", "issue": "exclusive-use conflict", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/01_leases/007_leases_officer_certificate.html", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-10, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Henry Cho.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/08_insurance/058_insurance_executed_instrument.txt", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for assignment consent: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-RE-2903-D311, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-RE-2903-M531.", "id": "F-04", "issue": "assignment consent", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/02_amendments/010_amendments_executed_instrument.txt", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-10, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Nadine Flores.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/08_insurance/061_insurance_review_memorandum.json", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for estoppel discrepancy: one source states the applicable location is Maricopa County, Arizona, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to Arizona operations outside Maricopa County, Arizona.", "id": "F-05", "issue": "estoppel discrepancy", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/02_amendments/013_amendments_review_memorandum.json", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-10, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Micah Sullivan.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/08_insurance/064_insurance_status_report.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for survey encroachment: one source states the threshold is 4% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 10% and produced a different exception result.", "id": "F-06", "issue": "survey encroachment", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/02_amendments/016_amendments_status_report.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-10, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Farah Ibrahim.", "severity": "low"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/09_notices/067_notices_correspondence.eml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for title exception: one source states formal notice must use notices-canyon_fresh_markets@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-mesa_vista_shopping_centers@example.test.", "id": "F-07", "issue": "title exception", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/03_estoppels/019_estoppels_correspondence.eml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-10, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Owen Delgado.", "severity": "critical"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/09_notices/070_notices_formal_notice.xml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for environmental recognized condition: one source states the governed population contains 95 records through 2025-02-19, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 40 records through 2025-03-03.", "id": "F-08", "issue": "environmental recognized condition", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/03_estoppels/022_estoppels_formal_notice.xml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-10, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Lena Varga.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/10_construction/073_construction_control_register.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for zoning nonconformity: one source states the operative date is 2026-02-18 under control reference CB-RE-2903-I871, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2026-03-28 under response reference CB-RE-2903-R643.", "id": "F-09", "issue": "zoning nonconformity", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/04_title_survey/025_title_survey_control_register.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-10, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Samuel Kim.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/10_construction/076_construction_ledger_export.csv", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for permit closeout gap: one source states the controlling amount is $6,232,836.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $6,412,172.00.", "id": "F-10", "issue": "permit closeout gap", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/04_title_survey/028_title_survey_ledger_export.csv", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-10, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Maya Ellison.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/10_construction/079_construction_officer_certificate.html", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for CAM reconciliation error: one source states approval is attributed to Leona Park as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Henry Cho and contains no entry for Leona Park.", "id": "F-11", "issue": "CAM reconciliation error", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/04_title_survey/031_title_survey_officer_certificate.html", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-10, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Rafael Okafor.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/11_financing/082_financing_executed_instrument.txt", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for insurance endorsement deficiency: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-RE-2903-L255, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-RE-2903-U388.", "id": "F-12", "issue": "insurance endorsement deficiency", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/05_environmental/034_environmental_executed_instrument.txt", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-10, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Nora Chen.", "severity": "low"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/11_financing/085_financing_review_memorandum.json", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for casualty restoration deadline: one source states the applicable location is Maricopa County, Arizona, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to Arizona operations outside Maricopa County, Arizona.", "id": "F-13", "issue": "casualty restoration deadline", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/05_environmental/037_environmental_review_memorandum.json", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-10, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Dominic Alvarez.", "severity": "critical"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/11_financing/088_financing_status_report.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for construction lien notice: one source states the threshold is 14% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 18% and produced a different exception result.", "id": "F-14", "issue": "construction lien notice", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/05_environmental/040_environmental_status_report.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-10, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Priya Raman.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/12_property_management/091_property_management_correspondence.eml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for lender SNDA omission: one source states formal notice must use notices-canyon_fresh_markets@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-mesa_vista_shopping_centers@example.test.", "id": "F-15", "issue": "lender SNDA omission", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/043_zoning_permits_correspondence.eml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-10, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Elliot Mercer.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/12_property_management/094_property_management_formal_notice.xml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for security-deposit mismatch: one source states the governed population contains 103 records through 2025-02-27, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 54 records through 2025-03-25.", "id": "F-16", "issue": "security-deposit mismatch", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/046_zoning_permits_formal_notice.xml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-10, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Talia Brooks.", "severity": "medium"}], "matter_number": "CB-RE-2903", "prepared_for": "Canyon Fresh Markets", "schema_version": "1.0", "task_id": "cb100-053-canyon-grocery"}}, "metadata": {"benchmark": "CounselBench-100", "code_license": "Apache-2.0", "data_license": "CC-BY-4.0", "deadline": "2026-09-10", "document_count": 96, "jurisdiction": "Arizona", "matter_number": "CB-RE-2903", "mcp_commit": "9a96ea6e5913736f92b88345bf51caeaaa8e719f", "mcp_package": "@modelcontextprotocol/server-filesystem@2026.7.10", "practice_area": "real-estate", "reference_tool_calls": 46, "required_evidence_reads": 33, "synthetic": true, "venue": "Maricopa County, Arizona", "version": "2.0.0"}, "prompt": "You are real-estate transactions counsel for Canyon Fresh Markets. The client has asked for a board-ready risk assessment supported by a source-level tracker rather than a narrative-only summary. Store leases contain exclusives, renewal options, and percentage-rent provisions that conflict with landlord statements and payment records. Decision due 2026-09-10. Arizona law governs; Maricopa County, Arizona is the forum. Treat dates, notice mechanics, approval evidence, and numerical reconciliations as independent controls. Work out the defensible position from the matter production and leave an audit-ready exception tracker and concise advice for the supervising lawyer. Keep confirmed conflicts separate from open questions, cite the records that actually control each conclusion, and do not fill gaps with outside facts.", "rubric": {"criteria": [{"category": "procedure", "description": "Complete at least 46 successful, argument-specific evidence and output calls.", "id": "procedure.minimum_successful_tool_calls"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Find and read the 33 controlling, corroborating, and work-product-control records in full.", "id": "procedure.all_evidence_read_in_full"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Inspect file metadata for the eight designated critical primary records before relying on them.", "id": "procedure.chain_of_custody_metadata_checked"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Confirm the sandbox's allowed document and output roots.", "id": "procedure.allowed_directories_checked"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Inventory all 96 records so the relevant sources are discovered among the context records.", "id": "procedure.recursive_inventory_completed"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Search the production for email evidence that may corroborate or contradict formal records.", "id": "procedure.targeted_search_completed"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Leave only findings.json and advice.md in the output workspace.", "id": "procedure.exact_deliverable_set"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Create both final work products through the sandbox MCP surface.", "id": "procedure.deliverables_written_through_mcp"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Produce findings.json as a valid JSON object.", "id": "findings.findings_is_object"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Report exactly 16 confirmed exceptions.", "id": "findings.findings_exact_count"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Use each stable finding ID exactly once.", "id": "findings.finding_ids_unique"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set schema_version to the released matter value '1.0'.", "id": "findings.top_level_schema_version"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set task_id to the released matter value 'cb100-053-canyon-grocery'.", "id": "findings.top_level_task_id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set matter_number to the released matter value 'CB-RE-2903'.", "id": "findings.top_level_matter_number"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set prepared_for to the released matter value 'Canyon Fresh Markets'.", "id": "findings.top_level_prepared_for"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set as_of to the released matter value '2026-09-10'.", "id": "findings.top_level_as_of"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-01 exception for rent schedule inconsistency.", "id": "findings.F-01.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's id from /workspace/documents/01_leases/001_leases_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_operating_expenses/049_operating_expenses_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's issue from /workspace/documents/01_leases/001_leases_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_operating_expenses/049_operating_expenses_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's severity from /workspace/documents/01_leases/001_leases_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_operating_expenses/049_operating_expenses_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's primary_source from /workspace/documents/01_leases/001_leases_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_operating_expenses/049_operating_expenses_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/01_leases/001_leases_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_operating_expenses/049_operating_expenses_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-01 using the exact controlled facts ['2025-06-20', 'CB-RE-2903-A568', '2025-08-05', 'CB-RE-2903-J897'].", "id": "findings.F-01.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-01's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-01.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-10', 'Theo Laurent'] for F-01.", "id": "findings.F-01.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-02 exception for renewal-option notice.", "id": "findings.F-02.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's id from /workspace/documents/01_leases/004_leases_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_operating_expenses/052_operating_expenses_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's issue from /workspace/documents/01_leases/004_leases_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_operating_expenses/052_operating_expenses_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's severity from /workspace/documents/01_leases/004_leases_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_operating_expenses/052_operating_expenses_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's primary_source from /workspace/documents/01_leases/004_leases_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_operating_expenses/052_operating_expenses_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/01_leases/004_leases_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_operating_expenses/052_operating_expenses_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-02 using the exact controlled facts ['$3,321,197.00', '$3,378,894.00'].", "id": "findings.F-02.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-02's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-02.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-10', 'Amara Patel'] for F-02.", "id": "findings.F-02.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-03 exception for exclusive-use conflict.", "id": "findings.F-03.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's id from /workspace/documents/01_leases/007_leases_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_operating_expenses/055_operating_expenses_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's issue from /workspace/documents/01_leases/007_leases_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_operating_expenses/055_operating_expenses_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's severity from /workspace/documents/01_leases/007_leases_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_operating_expenses/055_operating_expenses_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's primary_source from /workspace/documents/01_leases/007_leases_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_operating_expenses/055_operating_expenses_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/01_leases/007_leases_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_operating_expenses/055_operating_expenses_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-03 using the exact controlled facts ['Leona Park', 'Rafael Okafor'].", "id": "findings.F-03.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-03's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-03.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-10', 'Henry Cho'] for F-03.", "id": "findings.F-03.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-04 exception for assignment consent.", "id": "findings.F-04.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's id from /workspace/documents/02_amendments/010_amendments_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_insurance/058_insurance_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's issue from /workspace/documents/02_amendments/010_amendments_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_insurance/058_insurance_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's severity from /workspace/documents/02_amendments/010_amendments_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_insurance/058_insurance_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's primary_source from /workspace/documents/02_amendments/010_amendments_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_insurance/058_insurance_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/02_amendments/010_amendments_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_insurance/058_insurance_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-04 using the exact controlled facts ['closed without exception', 'CB-RE-2903-D311', 'open and escalated', 'CB-RE-2903-M531'].", "id": "findings.F-04.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-04's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-04.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-10', 'Nadine Flores'] for F-04.", "id": "findings.F-04.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-05 exception for estoppel discrepancy.", "id": "findings.F-05.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's id from /workspace/documents/02_amendments/013_amendments_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_insurance/061_insurance_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's issue from /workspace/documents/02_amendments/013_amendments_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_insurance/061_insurance_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's severity from /workspace/documents/02_amendments/013_amendments_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_insurance/061_insurance_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's primary_source from /workspace/documents/02_amendments/013_amendments_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_insurance/061_insurance_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/02_amendments/013_amendments_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_insurance/061_insurance_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-05 using the exact controlled facts ['Maricopa County, Arizona', 'Arizona'].", "id": "findings.F-05.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-05's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-05.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-10', 'Micah Sullivan'] for F-05.", "id": "findings.F-05.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-06 exception for survey encroachment.", "id": "findings.F-06.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's id from /workspace/documents/02_amendments/016_amendments_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_insurance/064_insurance_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's issue from /workspace/documents/02_amendments/016_amendments_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_insurance/064_insurance_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's severity from /workspace/documents/02_amendments/016_amendments_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_insurance/064_insurance_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's primary_source from /workspace/documents/02_amendments/016_amendments_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_insurance/064_insurance_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/02_amendments/016_amendments_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_insurance/064_insurance_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-06 using the exact controlled facts ['4%', '10%'].", "id": "findings.F-06.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-06's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-06.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-10', 'Farah Ibrahim'] for F-06.", "id": "findings.F-06.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-07 exception for title exception.", "id": "findings.F-07.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's id from /workspace/documents/03_estoppels/019_estoppels_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_notices/067_notices_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's issue from /workspace/documents/03_estoppels/019_estoppels_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_notices/067_notices_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's severity from /workspace/documents/03_estoppels/019_estoppels_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_notices/067_notices_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's primary_source from /workspace/documents/03_estoppels/019_estoppels_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_notices/067_notices_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/03_estoppels/019_estoppels_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_notices/067_notices_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-07 using the exact controlled facts ['notices-canyon_fresh_markets@example.test', 'archive-mesa_vista_shopping_centers@example.test'].", "id": "findings.F-07.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-07's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-07.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-10', 'Owen Delgado'] for F-07.", "id": "findings.F-07.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-08 exception for environmental recognized condition.", "id": "findings.F-08.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's id from /workspace/documents/03_estoppels/022_estoppels_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_notices/070_notices_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's issue from /workspace/documents/03_estoppels/022_estoppels_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_notices/070_notices_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's severity from /workspace/documents/03_estoppels/022_estoppels_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_notices/070_notices_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's primary_source from /workspace/documents/03_estoppels/022_estoppels_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_notices/070_notices_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/03_estoppels/022_estoppels_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_notices/070_notices_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-08 using the exact controlled facts ['95 records', '2025-02-19', '40 records', '2025-03-03'].", "id": "findings.F-08.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-08's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-08.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-10', 'Lena Varga'] for F-08.", "id": "findings.F-08.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-09 exception for zoning nonconformity.", "id": "findings.F-09.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's id from /workspace/documents/04_title_survey/025_title_survey_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_construction/073_construction_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's issue from /workspace/documents/04_title_survey/025_title_survey_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_construction/073_construction_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's severity from /workspace/documents/04_title_survey/025_title_survey_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_construction/073_construction_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's primary_source from /workspace/documents/04_title_survey/025_title_survey_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_construction/073_construction_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/04_title_survey/025_title_survey_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_construction/073_construction_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-09 using the exact controlled facts ['2026-02-18', 'CB-RE-2903-I871', '2026-03-28', 'CB-RE-2903-R643'].", "id": "findings.F-09.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-09's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-09.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-10', 'Samuel Kim'] for F-09.", "id": "findings.F-09.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-10 exception for permit closeout gap.", "id": "findings.F-10.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's id from /workspace/documents/04_title_survey/028_title_survey_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_construction/076_construction_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's issue from /workspace/documents/04_title_survey/028_title_survey_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_construction/076_construction_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's severity from /workspace/documents/04_title_survey/028_title_survey_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_construction/076_construction_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's primary_source from /workspace/documents/04_title_survey/028_title_survey_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_construction/076_construction_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/04_title_survey/028_title_survey_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_construction/076_construction_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-10 using the exact controlled facts ['$6,232,836.00', '$6,412,172.00'].", "id": "findings.F-10.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-10's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-10.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-10', 'Maya Ellison'] for F-10.", "id": "findings.F-10.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-11 exception for CAM reconciliation error.", "id": "findings.F-11.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's id from /workspace/documents/04_title_survey/031_title_survey_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_construction/079_construction_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's issue from /workspace/documents/04_title_survey/031_title_survey_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_construction/079_construction_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's severity from /workspace/documents/04_title_survey/031_title_survey_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_construction/079_construction_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's primary_source from /workspace/documents/04_title_survey/031_title_survey_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_construction/079_construction_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/04_title_survey/031_title_survey_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_construction/079_construction_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-11 using the exact controlled facts ['Leona Park', 'Henry Cho'].", "id": "findings.F-11.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-11's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-11.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-10', 'Rafael Okafor'] for F-11.", "id": "findings.F-11.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-12 exception for insurance endorsement deficiency.", "id": "findings.F-12.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's id from /workspace/documents/05_environmental/034_environmental_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_financing/082_financing_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's issue from /workspace/documents/05_environmental/034_environmental_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_financing/082_financing_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's severity from /workspace/documents/05_environmental/034_environmental_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_financing/082_financing_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's primary_source from /workspace/documents/05_environmental/034_environmental_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_financing/082_financing_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/05_environmental/034_environmental_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_financing/082_financing_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-12 using the exact controlled facts ['closed without exception', 'CB-RE-2903-L255', 'open and escalated', 'CB-RE-2903-U388'].", "id": "findings.F-12.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-12's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-12.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-10', 'Nora Chen'] for F-12.", "id": "findings.F-12.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-13 exception for casualty restoration deadline.", "id": "findings.F-13.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's id from /workspace/documents/05_environmental/037_environmental_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_financing/085_financing_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's issue from /workspace/documents/05_environmental/037_environmental_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_financing/085_financing_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's severity from /workspace/documents/05_environmental/037_environmental_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_financing/085_financing_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's primary_source from /workspace/documents/05_environmental/037_environmental_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_financing/085_financing_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/05_environmental/037_environmental_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_financing/085_financing_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-13 using the exact controlled facts ['Maricopa County, Arizona', 'Arizona'].", "id": "findings.F-13.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-13's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-13.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-10', 'Dominic Alvarez'] for F-13.", "id": "findings.F-13.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-14 exception for construction lien notice.", "id": "findings.F-14.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's id from /workspace/documents/05_environmental/040_environmental_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_financing/088_financing_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's issue from /workspace/documents/05_environmental/040_environmental_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_financing/088_financing_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's severity from /workspace/documents/05_environmental/040_environmental_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_financing/088_financing_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's primary_source from /workspace/documents/05_environmental/040_environmental_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_financing/088_financing_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/05_environmental/040_environmental_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_financing/088_financing_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-14 using the exact controlled facts ['14%', '18%'].", "id": "findings.F-14.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-14's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-14.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-10', 'Priya Raman'] for F-14.", "id": "findings.F-14.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-15 exception for lender SNDA omission.", "id": "findings.F-15.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's id from /workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/043_zoning_permits_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_property_management/091_property_management_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's issue from /workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/043_zoning_permits_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_property_management/091_property_management_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's severity from /workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/043_zoning_permits_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_property_management/091_property_management_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's primary_source from /workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/043_zoning_permits_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_property_management/091_property_management_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/043_zoning_permits_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_property_management/091_property_management_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-15 using the exact controlled facts ['notices-canyon_fresh_markets@example.test', 'archive-mesa_vista_shopping_centers@example.test'].", "id": "findings.F-15.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-15's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-15.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-10', 'Elliot Mercer'] for F-15.", "id": "findings.F-15.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-16 exception for security-deposit mismatch.", "id": "findings.F-16.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's id from /workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/046_zoning_permits_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_property_management/094_property_management_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's issue from /workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/046_zoning_permits_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_property_management/094_property_management_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's severity from /workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/046_zoning_permits_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_property_management/094_property_management_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's primary_source from /workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/046_zoning_permits_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_property_management/094_property_management_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/046_zoning_permits_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_property_management/094_property_management_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-16 using the exact controlled facts ['103 records', '2025-02-27', '54 records', '2025-03-25'].", "id": "findings.F-16.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-16's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-16.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-10', 'Talia Brooks'] for F-16.", "id": "findings.F-16.action_anchors"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Executive assessment' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Executive assessment"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Method and record coverage' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Method and record coverage"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Findings' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Findings"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Recommended next actions' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Recommended next actions"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Assumptions and limitations' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Assumptions and limitations"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-01 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-01"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-02 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-02"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-03 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-03"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-04 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-04"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-05 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-05"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-06 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-06"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-07 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-07"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-08 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-08"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-09 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-09"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-10 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-10"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-11 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-11"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-12 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-12"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-13 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-13"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-14 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-14"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-15 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-15"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-16 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-16"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Do not claim the production has no issues or that every record is consistent.", "id": "memo.forbidden_claims_absent"}], "decision_options": [{"id": "cross-source-reconciliation", "label": "Reconcile controlling and corroborating records", "reason": "The CB-RE-2903 production contains independently maintained records; a defensible answer must preserve each supported conflict and its cure owner.", "selected": true}, {"id": "latest-record-controls", "label": "Treat the latest record as controlling", "reason": "Timestamp recency does not establish legal priority, execution, or approval authority.", "selected": false}, {"id": "primary-records-only", "label": "Report primary records without reconciliation", "reason": "Primary records alone conceal the operational conflicts that create the actionable exceptions.", "selected": false}], "gates": ["all_evidence_read_in_full", "chain_of_custody_metadata_checked", "findings_criteria_complete", "memo_criteria_complete", "deliverables_written_through_mcp"], "metadata_checks": 8, "metric": "weighted_criteria_score", "minimum_tool_calls": 46, "required_deliverables": ["findings.json", "advice.md"], "required_document_reads": 33, "type": "deterministic", "weights": {"findings": 0.55, "memo": 0.2, "procedure": 0.25}}, "task_id": "cb100-053-canyon-grocery", "task_name": "Canyon grocery lease portfolio audit", "world_id": "counselbench-filesystem-mcp-v2"}
-{"context_files": ["task_files/cb100-054-dockside-hotel/01_leases/001_leases_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-054-dockside-hotel/01_leases/002_leases_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-054-dockside-hotel/01_leases/003_leases_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-054-dockside-hotel/01_leases/004_leases_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-054-dockside-hotel/01_leases/005_leases_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-054-dockside-hotel/01_leases/006_leases_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-054-dockside-hotel/01_leases/007_leases_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-054-dockside-hotel/01_leases/008_leases_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-054-dockside-hotel/02_amendments/009_amendments_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-054-dockside-hotel/02_amendments/010_amendments_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-054-dockside-hotel/02_amendments/011_amendments_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-054-dockside-hotel/02_amendments/012_amendments_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-054-dockside-hotel/02_amendments/013_amendments_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-054-dockside-hotel/02_amendments/014_amendments_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-054-dockside-hotel/02_amendments/015_amendments_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-054-dockside-hotel/02_amendments/016_amendments_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-054-dockside-hotel/03_estoppels/017_estoppels_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-054-dockside-hotel/03_estoppels/018_estoppels_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-054-dockside-hotel/03_estoppels/019_estoppels_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-054-dockside-hotel/03_estoppels/020_estoppels_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-054-dockside-hotel/03_estoppels/021_estoppels_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-054-dockside-hotel/03_estoppels/022_estoppels_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-054-dockside-hotel/03_estoppels/023_estoppels_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-054-dockside-hotel/03_estoppels/024_estoppels_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-054-dockside-hotel/04_title_survey/025_title_survey_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-054-dockside-hotel/04_title_survey/026_title_survey_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-054-dockside-hotel/04_title_survey/027_title_survey_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-054-dockside-hotel/04_title_survey/028_title_survey_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-054-dockside-hotel/04_title_survey/029_title_survey_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-054-dockside-hotel/04_title_survey/030_title_survey_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-054-dockside-hotel/04_title_survey/031_title_survey_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-054-dockside-hotel/04_title_survey/032_title_survey_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-054-dockside-hotel/05_environmental/033_environmental_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-054-dockside-hotel/05_environmental/034_environmental_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-054-dockside-hotel/05_environmental/035_environmental_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-054-dockside-hotel/05_environmental/036_environmental_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-054-dockside-hotel/05_environmental/037_environmental_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-054-dockside-hotel/05_environmental/038_environmental_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-054-dockside-hotel/05_environmental/039_environmental_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-054-dockside-hotel/05_environmental/040_environmental_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-054-dockside-hotel/06_zoning_permits/041_zoning_permits_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-054-dockside-hotel/06_zoning_permits/042_zoning_permits_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-054-dockside-hotel/06_zoning_permits/043_zoning_permits_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-054-dockside-hotel/06_zoning_permits/044_zoning_permits_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-054-dockside-hotel/06_zoning_permits/045_zoning_permits_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-054-dockside-hotel/06_zoning_permits/046_zoning_permits_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-054-dockside-hotel/06_zoning_permits/047_zoning_permits_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-054-dockside-hotel/06_zoning_permits/048_zoning_permits_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-054-dockside-hotel/07_operating_expenses/049_operating_expenses_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-054-dockside-hotel/07_operating_expenses/050_operating_expenses_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-054-dockside-hotel/07_operating_expenses/051_operating_expenses_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-054-dockside-hotel/07_operating_expenses/052_operating_expenses_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-054-dockside-hotel/07_operating_expenses/053_operating_expenses_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-054-dockside-hotel/07_operating_expenses/054_operating_expenses_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-054-dockside-hotel/07_operating_expenses/055_operating_expenses_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-054-dockside-hotel/07_operating_expenses/056_operating_expenses_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-054-dockside-hotel/08_insurance/057_insurance_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-054-dockside-hotel/08_insurance/058_insurance_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-054-dockside-hotel/08_insurance/059_insurance_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-054-dockside-hotel/08_insurance/060_insurance_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-054-dockside-hotel/08_insurance/061_insurance_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-054-dockside-hotel/08_insurance/062_insurance_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-054-dockside-hotel/08_insurance/063_insurance_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-054-dockside-hotel/08_insurance/064_insurance_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-054-dockside-hotel/09_notices/065_notices_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-054-dockside-hotel/09_notices/066_notices_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-054-dockside-hotel/09_notices/067_notices_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-054-dockside-hotel/09_notices/068_notices_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-054-dockside-hotel/09_notices/069_notices_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-054-dockside-hotel/09_notices/070_notices_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-054-dockside-hotel/09_notices/071_notices_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-054-dockside-hotel/09_notices/072_notices_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-054-dockside-hotel/10_construction/073_construction_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-054-dockside-hotel/10_construction/074_construction_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-054-dockside-hotel/10_construction/075_construction_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-054-dockside-hotel/10_construction/076_construction_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-054-dockside-hotel/10_construction/077_construction_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-054-dockside-hotel/10_construction/078_construction_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-054-dockside-hotel/10_construction/079_construction_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-054-dockside-hotel/10_construction/080_construction_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-054-dockside-hotel/11_financing/081_financing_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-054-dockside-hotel/11_financing/082_financing_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-054-dockside-hotel/11_financing/083_financing_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-054-dockside-hotel/11_financing/084_financing_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-054-dockside-hotel/11_financing/085_financing_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-054-dockside-hotel/11_financing/086_financing_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-054-dockside-hotel/11_financing/087_financing_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-054-dockside-hotel/11_financing/088_financing_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-054-dockside-hotel/12_property_management/089_property_management_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-054-dockside-hotel/12_property_management/090_property_management_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-054-dockside-hotel/12_property_management/091_property_management_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-054-dockside-hotel/12_property_management/092_property_management_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-054-dockside-hotel/12_property_management/093_property_management_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-054-dockside-hotel/12_property_management/094_property_management_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-054-dockside-hotel/12_property_management/095_property_management_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-054-dockside-hotel/12_property_management/096_property_management_status_report.md"], "gold_output": {"advice_markdown": "# Counsel advice — Dockside hotel financing property audit\n\n## Executive assessment\n\nFor Dockside Hospitality LLC matter CB-RE-2904, the review identified 16 source-supported exceptions requiring action before 2026-09-14. The assessment concerns Harbor Quay Lending and the supplied record for Florida.\n\n## Method and record coverage\n\nThe review inventoried all 96 production files, read the 33 controlling, corroborating, and control records, searched the email exports, and checked metadata for the designated chain-of-custody sample. Conclusions are limited to the synthetic production supplied for this benchmark matter.\n\n## Findings\n\n### F-01 — rent schedule inconsistency (critical)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for rent schedule inconsistency: one source states the operative date is 2025-01-03 under control reference CB-RE-2904-A580, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2025-01-24 under response reference CB-RE-2904-J206.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/01_leases/001_leases_control_register.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/07_operating_expenses/049_operating_expenses_control_register.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-14, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Amara Patel.\n\n### F-02 — renewal-option notice (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for renewal-option notice: one source states the controlling amount is $3,913,020.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $3,962,540.00.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/01_leases/004_leases_ledger_export.csv`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/07_operating_expenses/052_operating_expenses_ledger_export.csv`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-14, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Henry Cho.\n\n### F-03 — exclusive-use conflict (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for exclusive-use conflict: one source states approval is attributed to Isaac Romero as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Dominic Alvarez and contains no entry for Isaac Romero.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/01_leases/007_leases_officer_certificate.html`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/07_operating_expenses/055_operating_expenses_officer_certificate.html`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-14, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Nadine Flores.\n\n### F-04 — assignment consent (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for assignment consent: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-RE-2904-D427, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-RE-2904-M886.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/02_amendments/010_amendments_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/08_insurance/058_insurance_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-14, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Micah Sullivan.\n\n### F-05 — estoppel discrepancy (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for estoppel discrepancy: one source states the applicable location is Duval County, Florida, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to Florida operations outside Duval County, Florida.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/02_amendments/013_amendments_review_memorandum.json`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/08_insurance/061_insurance_review_memorandum.json`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-14, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Farah Ibrahim.\n\n### F-06 — survey encroachment (low)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for survey encroachment: one source states the threshold is 12% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 14% and produced a different exception result.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/02_amendments/016_amendments_status_report.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/08_insurance/064_insurance_status_report.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-14, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Owen Delgado.\n\n### F-07 — title exception (critical)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for title exception: one source states formal notice must use notices-dockside_hospitality_llc@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-harbor_quay_lending@example.test.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/03_estoppels/019_estoppels_correspondence.eml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/09_notices/067_notices_correspondence.eml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-14, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Lena Varga.\n\n### F-08 — environmental recognized condition (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for environmental recognized condition: one source states the governed population contains 186 records through 2025-10-08, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 42 records through 2025-10-22.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/03_estoppels/022_estoppels_formal_notice.xml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/09_notices/070_notices_formal_notice.xml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-14, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Samuel Kim.\n\n### F-09 — zoning nonconformity (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for zoning nonconformity: one source states the operative date is 2025-11-24 under control reference CB-RE-2904-I125, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2025-12-02 under response reference CB-RE-2904-R517.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/04_title_survey/025_title_survey_control_register.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/10_construction/073_construction_control_register.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-14, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Maya Ellison.\n\n### F-10 — permit closeout gap (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for permit closeout gap: one source states the controlling amount is $3,418,658.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $3,693,816.00.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/04_title_survey/028_title_survey_ledger_export.csv`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/10_construction/076_construction_ledger_export.csv`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-14, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Rafael Okafor.\n\n### F-11 — CAM reconciliation error (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for CAM reconciliation error: one source states approval is attributed to Isaac Romero as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Micah Sullivan and contains no entry for Isaac Romero.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/04_title_survey/031_title_survey_officer_certificate.html`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/10_construction/079_construction_officer_certificate.html`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-14, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Nora Chen.\n\n### F-12 — insurance endorsement deficiency (low)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for insurance endorsement deficiency: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-RE-2904-L144, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-RE-2904-U864.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/05_environmental/034_environmental_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/11_financing/082_financing_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-14, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Dominic Alvarez.\n\n### F-13 — casualty restoration deadline (critical)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for casualty restoration deadline: one source states the applicable location is Duval County, Florida, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to Florida operations outside Duval County, Florida.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/05_environmental/037_environmental_review_memorandum.json`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/11_financing/085_financing_review_memorandum.json`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-14, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Priya Raman.\n\n### F-14 — construction lien notice (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for construction lien notice: one source states the threshold is 3% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 8% and produced a different exception result.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/05_environmental/040_environmental_status_report.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/11_financing/088_financing_status_report.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-14, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Elliot Mercer.\n\n### F-15 — lender SNDA omission (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for lender SNDA omission: one source states formal notice must use notices-dockside_hospitality_llc@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-harbor_quay_lending@example.test.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/043_zoning_permits_correspondence.eml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/12_property_management/091_property_management_correspondence.eml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-14, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Talia Brooks.\n\n### F-16 — security-deposit mismatch (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for security-deposit mismatch: one source states the governed population contains 85 records through 2025-02-09, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 39 records through 2025-02-20.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/046_zoning_permits_formal_notice.xml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/12_property_management/094_property_management_formal_notice.xml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-14, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Jonas Feld.\n\n## Recommended next actions\n\nSequence the critical and high findings first, assign the named owners, preserve the cited records, and document any resolution in the controlling matter register before the stated deadline.\n\n## Assumptions and limitations\n\nThis analysis is confined to task cb100-054-dockside-hotel and the supplied synthetic evidence. It does not rely on external facts, does not resolve disputed law, and is not legal advice for a real person or entity.\n", "findings": {"as_of": "2026-09-14", "findings": [{"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/07_operating_expenses/049_operating_expenses_control_register.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for rent schedule inconsistency: one source states the operative date is 2025-01-03 under control reference CB-RE-2904-A580, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2025-01-24 under response reference CB-RE-2904-J206.", "id": "F-01", "issue": "rent schedule inconsistency", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/01_leases/001_leases_control_register.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-14, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Amara Patel.", "severity": "critical"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/07_operating_expenses/052_operating_expenses_ledger_export.csv", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for renewal-option notice: one source states the controlling amount is $3,913,020.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $3,962,540.00.", "id": "F-02", "issue": "renewal-option notice", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/01_leases/004_leases_ledger_export.csv", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-14, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Henry Cho.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/07_operating_expenses/055_operating_expenses_officer_certificate.html", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for exclusive-use conflict: one source states approval is attributed to Isaac Romero as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Dominic Alvarez and contains no entry for Isaac Romero.", "id": "F-03", "issue": "exclusive-use conflict", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/01_leases/007_leases_officer_certificate.html", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-14, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Nadine Flores.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/08_insurance/058_insurance_executed_instrument.txt", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for assignment consent: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-RE-2904-D427, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-RE-2904-M886.", "id": "F-04", "issue": "assignment consent", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/02_amendments/010_amendments_executed_instrument.txt", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-14, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Micah Sullivan.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/08_insurance/061_insurance_review_memorandum.json", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for estoppel discrepancy: one source states the applicable location is Duval County, Florida, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to Florida operations outside Duval County, Florida.", "id": "F-05", "issue": "estoppel discrepancy", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/02_amendments/013_amendments_review_memorandum.json", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-14, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Farah Ibrahim.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/08_insurance/064_insurance_status_report.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for survey encroachment: one source states the threshold is 12% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 14% and produced a different exception result.", "id": "F-06", "issue": "survey encroachment", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/02_amendments/016_amendments_status_report.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-14, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Owen Delgado.", "severity": "low"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/09_notices/067_notices_correspondence.eml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for title exception: one source states formal notice must use notices-dockside_hospitality_llc@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-harbor_quay_lending@example.test.", "id": "F-07", "issue": "title exception", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/03_estoppels/019_estoppels_correspondence.eml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-14, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Lena Varga.", "severity": "critical"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/09_notices/070_notices_formal_notice.xml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for environmental recognized condition: one source states the governed population contains 186 records through 2025-10-08, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 42 records through 2025-10-22.", "id": "F-08", "issue": "environmental recognized condition", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/03_estoppels/022_estoppels_formal_notice.xml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-14, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Samuel Kim.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/10_construction/073_construction_control_register.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for zoning nonconformity: one source states the operative date is 2025-11-24 under control reference CB-RE-2904-I125, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2025-12-02 under response reference CB-RE-2904-R517.", "id": "F-09", "issue": "zoning nonconformity", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/04_title_survey/025_title_survey_control_register.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-14, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Maya Ellison.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/10_construction/076_construction_ledger_export.csv", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for permit closeout gap: one source states the controlling amount is $3,418,658.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $3,693,816.00.", "id": "F-10", "issue": "permit closeout gap", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/04_title_survey/028_title_survey_ledger_export.csv", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-14, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Rafael Okafor.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/10_construction/079_construction_officer_certificate.html", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for CAM reconciliation error: one source states approval is attributed to Isaac Romero as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Micah Sullivan and contains no entry for Isaac Romero.", "id": "F-11", "issue": "CAM reconciliation error", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/04_title_survey/031_title_survey_officer_certificate.html", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-14, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Nora Chen.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/11_financing/082_financing_executed_instrument.txt", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for insurance endorsement deficiency: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-RE-2904-L144, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-RE-2904-U864.", "id": "F-12", "issue": "insurance endorsement deficiency", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/05_environmental/034_environmental_executed_instrument.txt", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-14, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Dominic Alvarez.", "severity": "low"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/11_financing/085_financing_review_memorandum.json", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for casualty restoration deadline: one source states the applicable location is Duval County, Florida, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to Florida operations outside Duval County, Florida.", "id": "F-13", "issue": "casualty restoration deadline", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/05_environmental/037_environmental_review_memorandum.json", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-14, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Priya Raman.", "severity": "critical"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/11_financing/088_financing_status_report.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for construction lien notice: one source states the threshold is 3% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 8% and produced a different exception result.", "id": "F-14", "issue": "construction lien notice", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/05_environmental/040_environmental_status_report.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-14, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Elliot Mercer.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/12_property_management/091_property_management_correspondence.eml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for lender SNDA omission: one source states formal notice must use notices-dockside_hospitality_llc@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-harbor_quay_lending@example.test.", "id": "F-15", "issue": "lender SNDA omission", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/043_zoning_permits_correspondence.eml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-14, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Talia Brooks.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/12_property_management/094_property_management_formal_notice.xml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for security-deposit mismatch: one source states the governed population contains 85 records through 2025-02-09, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 39 records through 2025-02-20.", "id": "F-16", "issue": "security-deposit mismatch", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/046_zoning_permits_formal_notice.xml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-14, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Jonas Feld.", "severity": "medium"}], "matter_number": "CB-RE-2904", "prepared_for": "Dockside Hospitality LLC", "schema_version": "1.0", "task_id": "cb100-054-dockside-hotel"}}, "metadata": {"benchmark": "CounselBench-100", "code_license": "Apache-2.0", "data_license": "CC-BY-4.0", "deadline": "2026-09-14", "document_count": 96, "jurisdiction": "Florida", "matter_number": "CB-RE-2904", "mcp_commit": "9a96ea6e5913736f92b88345bf51caeaaa8e719f", "mcp_package": "@modelcontextprotocol/server-filesystem@2026.7.10", "practice_area": "real-estate", "reference_tool_calls": 46, "required_evidence_reads": 33, "synthetic": true, "venue": "Duval County, Florida", "version": "2.0.0"}, "prompt": "You are real-estate transactions counsel for Dockside Hospitality LLC. Several workstreams have maintained separate versions of the truth; your assignment is to produce one auditable legal view. A waterfront hotel has a survey encroachment, restoration deadline, construction lien notice, and missing insurance endorsement. Decision due 2026-09-14. Florida law governs; Duval County, Florida is the forum. Distinguish a missing document from an affirmative contradiction in the documents that are present. Work out the defensible position from the matter production and leave an audit-ready exception tracker and concise advice for the supervising lawyer. Keep confirmed conflicts separate from open questions, cite the records that actually control each conclusion, and do not fill gaps with outside facts.", "rubric": {"criteria": [{"category": "procedure", "description": "Complete at least 46 successful, argument-specific evidence and output calls.", "id": "procedure.minimum_successful_tool_calls"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Find and read the 33 controlling, corroborating, and work-product-control records in full.", "id": "procedure.all_evidence_read_in_full"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Inspect file metadata for the eight designated critical primary records before relying on them.", "id": "procedure.chain_of_custody_metadata_checked"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Confirm the sandbox's allowed document and output roots.", "id": "procedure.allowed_directories_checked"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Inventory all 96 records so the relevant sources are discovered among the context records.", "id": "procedure.recursive_inventory_completed"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Search the production for email evidence that may corroborate or contradict formal records.", "id": "procedure.targeted_search_completed"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Leave only findings.json and advice.md in the output workspace.", "id": "procedure.exact_deliverable_set"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Create both final work products through the sandbox MCP surface.", "id": "procedure.deliverables_written_through_mcp"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Produce findings.json as a valid JSON object.", "id": "findings.findings_is_object"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Report exactly 16 confirmed exceptions.", "id": "findings.findings_exact_count"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Use each stable finding ID exactly once.", "id": "findings.finding_ids_unique"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set schema_version to the released matter value '1.0'.", "id": "findings.top_level_schema_version"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set task_id to the released matter value 'cb100-054-dockside-hotel'.", "id": "findings.top_level_task_id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set matter_number to the released matter value 'CB-RE-2904'.", "id": "findings.top_level_matter_number"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set prepared_for to the released matter value 'Dockside Hospitality LLC'.", "id": "findings.top_level_prepared_for"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set as_of to the released matter value '2026-09-14'.", "id": "findings.top_level_as_of"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-01 exception for rent schedule inconsistency.", "id": "findings.F-01.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's id from /workspace/documents/01_leases/001_leases_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_operating_expenses/049_operating_expenses_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's issue from /workspace/documents/01_leases/001_leases_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_operating_expenses/049_operating_expenses_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's severity from /workspace/documents/01_leases/001_leases_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_operating_expenses/049_operating_expenses_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's primary_source from /workspace/documents/01_leases/001_leases_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_operating_expenses/049_operating_expenses_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/01_leases/001_leases_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_operating_expenses/049_operating_expenses_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-01 using the exact controlled facts ['2025-01-03', 'CB-RE-2904-A580', '2025-01-24', 'CB-RE-2904-J206'].", "id": "findings.F-01.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-01's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-01.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-14', 'Amara Patel'] for F-01.", "id": "findings.F-01.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-02 exception for renewal-option notice.", "id": "findings.F-02.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's id from /workspace/documents/01_leases/004_leases_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_operating_expenses/052_operating_expenses_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's issue from /workspace/documents/01_leases/004_leases_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_operating_expenses/052_operating_expenses_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's severity from /workspace/documents/01_leases/004_leases_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_operating_expenses/052_operating_expenses_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's primary_source from /workspace/documents/01_leases/004_leases_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_operating_expenses/052_operating_expenses_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/01_leases/004_leases_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_operating_expenses/052_operating_expenses_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-02 using the exact controlled facts ['$3,913,020.00', '$3,962,540.00'].", "id": "findings.F-02.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-02's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-02.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-14', 'Henry Cho'] for F-02.", "id": "findings.F-02.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-03 exception for exclusive-use conflict.", "id": "findings.F-03.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's id from /workspace/documents/01_leases/007_leases_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_operating_expenses/055_operating_expenses_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's issue from /workspace/documents/01_leases/007_leases_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_operating_expenses/055_operating_expenses_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's severity from /workspace/documents/01_leases/007_leases_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_operating_expenses/055_operating_expenses_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's primary_source from /workspace/documents/01_leases/007_leases_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_operating_expenses/055_operating_expenses_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/01_leases/007_leases_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_operating_expenses/055_operating_expenses_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-03 using the exact controlled facts ['Isaac Romero', 'Dominic Alvarez'].", "id": "findings.F-03.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-03's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-03.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-14', 'Nadine Flores'] for F-03.", "id": "findings.F-03.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-04 exception for assignment consent.", "id": "findings.F-04.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's id from /workspace/documents/02_amendments/010_amendments_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_insurance/058_insurance_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's issue from /workspace/documents/02_amendments/010_amendments_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_insurance/058_insurance_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's severity from /workspace/documents/02_amendments/010_amendments_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_insurance/058_insurance_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's primary_source from /workspace/documents/02_amendments/010_amendments_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_insurance/058_insurance_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/02_amendments/010_amendments_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_insurance/058_insurance_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-04 using the exact controlled facts ['closed without exception', 'CB-RE-2904-D427', 'open and escalated', 'CB-RE-2904-M886'].", "id": "findings.F-04.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-04's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-04.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-14', 'Micah Sullivan'] for F-04.", "id": "findings.F-04.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-05 exception for estoppel discrepancy.", "id": "findings.F-05.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's id from /workspace/documents/02_amendments/013_amendments_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_insurance/061_insurance_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's issue from /workspace/documents/02_amendments/013_amendments_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_insurance/061_insurance_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's severity from /workspace/documents/02_amendments/013_amendments_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_insurance/061_insurance_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's primary_source from /workspace/documents/02_amendments/013_amendments_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_insurance/061_insurance_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/02_amendments/013_amendments_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_insurance/061_insurance_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-05 using the exact controlled facts ['Duval County, Florida', 'Florida'].", "id": "findings.F-05.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-05's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-05.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-14', 'Farah Ibrahim'] for F-05.", "id": "findings.F-05.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-06 exception for survey encroachment.", "id": "findings.F-06.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's id from /workspace/documents/02_amendments/016_amendments_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_insurance/064_insurance_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's issue from /workspace/documents/02_amendments/016_amendments_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_insurance/064_insurance_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's severity from /workspace/documents/02_amendments/016_amendments_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_insurance/064_insurance_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's primary_source from /workspace/documents/02_amendments/016_amendments_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_insurance/064_insurance_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/02_amendments/016_amendments_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_insurance/064_insurance_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-06 using the exact controlled facts ['12%', '14%'].", "id": "findings.F-06.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-06's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-06.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-14', 'Owen Delgado'] for F-06.", "id": "findings.F-06.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-07 exception for title exception.", "id": "findings.F-07.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's id from /workspace/documents/03_estoppels/019_estoppels_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_notices/067_notices_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's issue from /workspace/documents/03_estoppels/019_estoppels_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_notices/067_notices_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's severity from /workspace/documents/03_estoppels/019_estoppels_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_notices/067_notices_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's primary_source from /workspace/documents/03_estoppels/019_estoppels_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_notices/067_notices_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/03_estoppels/019_estoppels_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_notices/067_notices_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-07 using the exact controlled facts ['notices-dockside_hospitality_llc@example.test', 'archive-harbor_quay_lending@example.test'].", "id": "findings.F-07.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-07's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-07.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-14', 'Lena Varga'] for F-07.", "id": "findings.F-07.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-08 exception for environmental recognized condition.", "id": "findings.F-08.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's id from /workspace/documents/03_estoppels/022_estoppels_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_notices/070_notices_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's issue from /workspace/documents/03_estoppels/022_estoppels_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_notices/070_notices_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's severity from /workspace/documents/03_estoppels/022_estoppels_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_notices/070_notices_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's primary_source from /workspace/documents/03_estoppels/022_estoppels_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_notices/070_notices_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/03_estoppels/022_estoppels_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_notices/070_notices_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-08 using the exact controlled facts ['186 records', '2025-10-08', '42 records', '2025-10-22'].", "id": "findings.F-08.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-08's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-08.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-14', 'Samuel Kim'] for F-08.", "id": "findings.F-08.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-09 exception for zoning nonconformity.", "id": "findings.F-09.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's id from /workspace/documents/04_title_survey/025_title_survey_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_construction/073_construction_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's issue from /workspace/documents/04_title_survey/025_title_survey_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_construction/073_construction_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's severity from /workspace/documents/04_title_survey/025_title_survey_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_construction/073_construction_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's primary_source from /workspace/documents/04_title_survey/025_title_survey_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_construction/073_construction_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/04_title_survey/025_title_survey_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_construction/073_construction_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-09 using the exact controlled facts ['2025-11-24', 'CB-RE-2904-I125', '2025-12-02', 'CB-RE-2904-R517'].", "id": "findings.F-09.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-09's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-09.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-14', 'Maya Ellison'] for F-09.", "id": "findings.F-09.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-10 exception for permit closeout gap.", "id": "findings.F-10.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's id from /workspace/documents/04_title_survey/028_title_survey_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_construction/076_construction_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's issue from /workspace/documents/04_title_survey/028_title_survey_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_construction/076_construction_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's severity from /workspace/documents/04_title_survey/028_title_survey_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_construction/076_construction_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's primary_source from /workspace/documents/04_title_survey/028_title_survey_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_construction/076_construction_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/04_title_survey/028_title_survey_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_construction/076_construction_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-10 using the exact controlled facts ['$3,418,658.00', '$3,693,816.00'].", "id": "findings.F-10.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-10's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-10.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-14', 'Rafael Okafor'] for F-10.", "id": "findings.F-10.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-11 exception for CAM reconciliation error.", "id": "findings.F-11.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's id from /workspace/documents/04_title_survey/031_title_survey_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_construction/079_construction_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's issue from /workspace/documents/04_title_survey/031_title_survey_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_construction/079_construction_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's severity from /workspace/documents/04_title_survey/031_title_survey_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_construction/079_construction_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's primary_source from /workspace/documents/04_title_survey/031_title_survey_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_construction/079_construction_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/04_title_survey/031_title_survey_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_construction/079_construction_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-11 using the exact controlled facts ['Isaac Romero', 'Micah Sullivan'].", "id": "findings.F-11.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-11's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-11.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-14', 'Nora Chen'] for F-11.", "id": "findings.F-11.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-12 exception for insurance endorsement deficiency.", "id": "findings.F-12.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's id from /workspace/documents/05_environmental/034_environmental_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_financing/082_financing_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's issue from /workspace/documents/05_environmental/034_environmental_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_financing/082_financing_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's severity from /workspace/documents/05_environmental/034_environmental_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_financing/082_financing_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's primary_source from /workspace/documents/05_environmental/034_environmental_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_financing/082_financing_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/05_environmental/034_environmental_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_financing/082_financing_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-12 using the exact controlled facts ['closed without exception', 'CB-RE-2904-L144', 'open and escalated', 'CB-RE-2904-U864'].", "id": "findings.F-12.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-12's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-12.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-14', 'Dominic Alvarez'] for F-12.", "id": "findings.F-12.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-13 exception for casualty restoration deadline.", "id": "findings.F-13.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's id from /workspace/documents/05_environmental/037_environmental_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_financing/085_financing_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's issue from /workspace/documents/05_environmental/037_environmental_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_financing/085_financing_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's severity from /workspace/documents/05_environmental/037_environmental_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_financing/085_financing_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's primary_source from /workspace/documents/05_environmental/037_environmental_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_financing/085_financing_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/05_environmental/037_environmental_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_financing/085_financing_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-13 using the exact controlled facts ['Duval County, Florida', 'Florida'].", "id": "findings.F-13.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-13's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-13.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-14', 'Priya Raman'] for F-13.", "id": "findings.F-13.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-14 exception for construction lien notice.", "id": "findings.F-14.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's id from /workspace/documents/05_environmental/040_environmental_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_financing/088_financing_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's issue from /workspace/documents/05_environmental/040_environmental_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_financing/088_financing_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's severity from /workspace/documents/05_environmental/040_environmental_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_financing/088_financing_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's primary_source from /workspace/documents/05_environmental/040_environmental_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_financing/088_financing_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/05_environmental/040_environmental_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_financing/088_financing_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-14 using the exact controlled facts ['3%', '8%'].", "id": "findings.F-14.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-14's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-14.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-14', 'Elliot Mercer'] for F-14.", "id": "findings.F-14.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-15 exception for lender SNDA omission.", "id": "findings.F-15.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's id from /workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/043_zoning_permits_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_property_management/091_property_management_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's issue from /workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/043_zoning_permits_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_property_management/091_property_management_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's severity from /workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/043_zoning_permits_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_property_management/091_property_management_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's primary_source from /workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/043_zoning_permits_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_property_management/091_property_management_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/043_zoning_permits_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_property_management/091_property_management_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-15 using the exact controlled facts ['notices-dockside_hospitality_llc@example.test', 'archive-harbor_quay_lending@example.test'].", "id": "findings.F-15.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-15's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-15.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-14', 'Talia Brooks'] for F-15.", "id": "findings.F-15.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-16 exception for security-deposit mismatch.", "id": "findings.F-16.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's id from /workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/046_zoning_permits_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_property_management/094_property_management_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's issue from /workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/046_zoning_permits_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_property_management/094_property_management_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's severity from /workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/046_zoning_permits_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_property_management/094_property_management_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's primary_source from /workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/046_zoning_permits_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_property_management/094_property_management_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/046_zoning_permits_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_property_management/094_property_management_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-16 using the exact controlled facts ['85 records', '2025-02-09', '39 records', '2025-02-20'].", "id": "findings.F-16.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-16's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-16.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-14', 'Jonas Feld'] for F-16.", "id": "findings.F-16.action_anchors"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Executive assessment' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Executive assessment"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Method and record coverage' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Method and record coverage"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Findings' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Findings"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Recommended next actions' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Recommended next actions"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Assumptions and limitations' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Assumptions and limitations"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-01 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-01"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-02 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-02"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-03 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-03"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-04 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-04"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-05 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-05"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-06 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-06"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-07 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-07"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-08 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-08"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-09 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-09"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-10 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-10"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-11 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-11"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-12 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-12"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-13 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-13"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-14 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-14"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-15 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-15"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-16 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-16"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Do not claim the production has no issues or that every record is consistent.", "id": "memo.forbidden_claims_absent"}], "decision_options": [{"id": "cross-source-reconciliation", "label": "Reconcile controlling and corroborating records", "reason": "The CB-RE-2904 production contains independently maintained records; a defensible answer must preserve each supported conflict and its cure owner.", "selected": true}, {"id": "latest-record-controls", "label": "Treat the latest record as controlling", "reason": "Timestamp recency does not establish legal priority, execution, or approval authority.", "selected": false}, {"id": "primary-records-only", "label": "Report primary records without reconciliation", "reason": "Primary records alone conceal the operational conflicts that create the actionable exceptions.", "selected": false}], "gates": ["all_evidence_read_in_full", "chain_of_custody_metadata_checked", "findings_criteria_complete", "memo_criteria_complete", "deliverables_written_through_mcp"], "metadata_checks": 8, "metric": "weighted_criteria_score", "minimum_tool_calls": 46, "required_deliverables": ["findings.json", "advice.md"], "required_document_reads": 33, "type": "deterministic", "weights": {"findings": 0.55, "memo": 0.2, "procedure": 0.25}}, "task_id": "cb100-054-dockside-hotel", "task_name": "Dockside hotel financing property audit", "world_id": "counselbench-filesystem-mcp-v2"}
-{"context_files": ["task_files/cb100-055-eastgate-labs/01_leases/001_leases_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-055-eastgate-labs/01_leases/002_leases_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-055-eastgate-labs/01_leases/003_leases_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-055-eastgate-labs/01_leases/004_leases_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-055-eastgate-labs/01_leases/005_leases_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-055-eastgate-labs/01_leases/006_leases_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-055-eastgate-labs/01_leases/007_leases_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-055-eastgate-labs/01_leases/008_leases_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-055-eastgate-labs/02_amendments/009_amendments_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-055-eastgate-labs/02_amendments/010_amendments_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-055-eastgate-labs/02_amendments/011_amendments_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-055-eastgate-labs/02_amendments/012_amendments_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-055-eastgate-labs/02_amendments/013_amendments_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-055-eastgate-labs/02_amendments/014_amendments_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-055-eastgate-labs/02_amendments/015_amendments_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-055-eastgate-labs/02_amendments/016_amendments_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-055-eastgate-labs/03_estoppels/017_estoppels_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-055-eastgate-labs/03_estoppels/018_estoppels_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-055-eastgate-labs/03_estoppels/019_estoppels_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-055-eastgate-labs/03_estoppels/020_estoppels_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-055-eastgate-labs/03_estoppels/021_estoppels_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-055-eastgate-labs/03_estoppels/022_estoppels_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-055-eastgate-labs/03_estoppels/023_estoppels_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-055-eastgate-labs/03_estoppels/024_estoppels_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-055-eastgate-labs/04_title_survey/025_title_survey_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-055-eastgate-labs/04_title_survey/026_title_survey_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-055-eastgate-labs/04_title_survey/027_title_survey_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-055-eastgate-labs/04_title_survey/028_title_survey_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-055-eastgate-labs/04_title_survey/029_title_survey_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-055-eastgate-labs/04_title_survey/030_title_survey_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-055-eastgate-labs/04_title_survey/031_title_survey_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-055-eastgate-labs/04_title_survey/032_title_survey_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-055-eastgate-labs/05_environmental/033_environmental_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-055-eastgate-labs/05_environmental/034_environmental_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-055-eastgate-labs/05_environmental/035_environmental_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-055-eastgate-labs/05_environmental/036_environmental_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-055-eastgate-labs/05_environmental/037_environmental_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-055-eastgate-labs/05_environmental/038_environmental_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-055-eastgate-labs/05_environmental/039_environmental_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-055-eastgate-labs/05_environmental/040_environmental_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-055-eastgate-labs/06_zoning_permits/041_zoning_permits_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-055-eastgate-labs/06_zoning_permits/042_zoning_permits_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-055-eastgate-labs/06_zoning_permits/043_zoning_permits_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-055-eastgate-labs/06_zoning_permits/044_zoning_permits_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-055-eastgate-labs/06_zoning_permits/045_zoning_permits_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-055-eastgate-labs/06_zoning_permits/046_zoning_permits_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-055-eastgate-labs/06_zoning_permits/047_zoning_permits_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-055-eastgate-labs/06_zoning_permits/048_zoning_permits_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-055-eastgate-labs/07_operating_expenses/049_operating_expenses_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-055-eastgate-labs/07_operating_expenses/050_operating_expenses_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-055-eastgate-labs/07_operating_expenses/051_operating_expenses_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-055-eastgate-labs/07_operating_expenses/052_operating_expenses_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-055-eastgate-labs/07_operating_expenses/053_operating_expenses_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-055-eastgate-labs/07_operating_expenses/054_operating_expenses_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-055-eastgate-labs/07_operating_expenses/055_operating_expenses_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-055-eastgate-labs/07_operating_expenses/056_operating_expenses_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-055-eastgate-labs/08_insurance/057_insurance_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-055-eastgate-labs/08_insurance/058_insurance_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-055-eastgate-labs/08_insurance/059_insurance_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-055-eastgate-labs/08_insurance/060_insurance_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-055-eastgate-labs/08_insurance/061_insurance_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-055-eastgate-labs/08_insurance/062_insurance_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-055-eastgate-labs/08_insurance/063_insurance_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-055-eastgate-labs/08_insurance/064_insurance_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-055-eastgate-labs/09_notices/065_notices_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-055-eastgate-labs/09_notices/066_notices_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-055-eastgate-labs/09_notices/067_notices_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-055-eastgate-labs/09_notices/068_notices_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-055-eastgate-labs/09_notices/069_notices_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-055-eastgate-labs/09_notices/070_notices_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-055-eastgate-labs/09_notices/071_notices_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-055-eastgate-labs/09_notices/072_notices_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-055-eastgate-labs/10_construction/073_construction_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-055-eastgate-labs/10_construction/074_construction_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-055-eastgate-labs/10_construction/075_construction_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-055-eastgate-labs/10_construction/076_construction_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-055-eastgate-labs/10_construction/077_construction_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-055-eastgate-labs/10_construction/078_construction_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-055-eastgate-labs/10_construction/079_construction_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-055-eastgate-labs/10_construction/080_construction_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-055-eastgate-labs/11_financing/081_financing_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-055-eastgate-labs/11_financing/082_financing_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-055-eastgate-labs/11_financing/083_financing_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-055-eastgate-labs/11_financing/084_financing_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-055-eastgate-labs/11_financing/085_financing_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-055-eastgate-labs/11_financing/086_financing_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-055-eastgate-labs/11_financing/087_financing_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-055-eastgate-labs/11_financing/088_financing_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-055-eastgate-labs/12_property_management/089_property_management_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-055-eastgate-labs/12_property_management/090_property_management_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-055-eastgate-labs/12_property_management/091_property_management_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-055-eastgate-labs/12_property_management/092_property_management_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-055-eastgate-labs/12_property_management/093_property_management_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-055-eastgate-labs/12_property_management/094_property_management_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-055-eastgate-labs/12_property_management/095_property_management_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-055-eastgate-labs/12_property_management/096_property_management_status_report.md"], "gold_output": {"advice_markdown": "# Counsel advice — Eastgate laboratory campus diligence\n\n## Executive assessment\n\nFor Eastgate Life Sciences matter CB-RE-2905, the review identified 16 source-supported exceptions requiring action before 2026-09-17. The assessment concerns Polymer Park Properties and the supplied record for North Carolina.\n\n## Method and record coverage\n\nThe review inventoried all 96 production files, read the 33 controlling, corroborating, and control records, searched the email exports, and checked metadata for the designated chain-of-custody sample. Conclusions are limited to the synthetic production supplied for this benchmark matter.\n\n## Findings\n\n### F-01 — rent schedule inconsistency (critical)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for rent schedule inconsistency: one source states the operative date is 2025-03-19 under control reference CB-RE-2905-A775, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2025-04-09 under response reference CB-RE-2905-J982.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/01_leases/001_leases_control_register.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/07_operating_expenses/049_operating_expenses_control_register.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-17, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Henry Cho.\n\n### F-02 — renewal-option notice (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for renewal-option notice: one source states the controlling amount is $2,449,972.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $2,496,444.00.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/01_leases/004_leases_ledger_export.csv`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/07_operating_expenses/052_operating_expenses_ledger_export.csv`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-17, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Nadine Flores.\n\n### F-03 — exclusive-use conflict (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for exclusive-use conflict: one source states approval is attributed to Sofia Bennett as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Elliot Mercer and contains no entry for Sofia Bennett.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/01_leases/007_leases_officer_certificate.html`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/07_operating_expenses/055_operating_expenses_officer_certificate.html`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-17, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Micah Sullivan.\n\n### F-04 — assignment consent (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for assignment consent: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-RE-2905-D501, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-RE-2905-M200.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/02_amendments/010_amendments_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/08_insurance/058_insurance_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-17, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Farah Ibrahim.\n\n### F-05 — estoppel discrepancy (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for estoppel discrepancy: one source states the applicable location is Wake County, North Carolina, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to North Carolina operations outside Wake County, North Carolina.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/02_amendments/013_amendments_review_memorandum.json`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/08_insurance/061_insurance_review_memorandum.json`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-17, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Owen Delgado.\n\n### F-06 — survey encroachment (low)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for survey encroachment: one source states the threshold is 6% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 8% and produced a different exception result.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/02_amendments/016_amendments_status_report.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/08_insurance/064_insurance_status_report.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-17, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Lena Varga.\n\n### F-07 — title exception (critical)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for title exception: one source states formal notice must use notices-eastgate_life_sciences@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-polymer_park_properties@example.test.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/03_estoppels/019_estoppels_correspondence.eml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/09_notices/067_notices_correspondence.eml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-17, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Samuel Kim.\n\n### F-08 — environmental recognized condition (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for environmental recognized condition: one source states the governed population contains 116 records through 2025-07-30, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 45 records through 2025-08-16.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/03_estoppels/022_estoppels_formal_notice.xml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/09_notices/070_notices_formal_notice.xml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-17, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Maya Ellison.\n\n### F-09 — zoning nonconformity (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for zoning nonconformity: one source states the operative date is 2025-09-23 under control reference CB-RE-2905-I363, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2025-10-06 under response reference CB-RE-2905-R120.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/04_title_survey/025_title_survey_control_register.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/10_construction/073_construction_control_register.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-17, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Rafael Okafor.\n\n### F-10 — permit closeout gap (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for permit closeout gap: one source states the controlling amount is $7,538,393.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $7,703,286.00.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/04_title_survey/028_title_survey_ledger_export.csv`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/10_construction/076_construction_ledger_export.csv`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-17, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Nora Chen.\n\n### F-11 — CAM reconciliation error (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for CAM reconciliation error: one source states approval is attributed to Sofia Bennett as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Owen Delgado and contains no entry for Sofia Bennett.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/04_title_survey/031_title_survey_officer_certificate.html`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/10_construction/079_construction_officer_certificate.html`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-17, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Dominic Alvarez.\n\n### F-12 — insurance endorsement deficiency (low)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for insurance endorsement deficiency: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-RE-2905-L264, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-RE-2905-U735.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/05_environmental/034_environmental_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/11_financing/082_financing_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-17, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Priya Raman.\n\n### F-13 — casualty restoration deadline (critical)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for casualty restoration deadline: one source states the applicable location is Wake County, North Carolina, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to North Carolina operations outside Wake County, North Carolina.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/05_environmental/037_environmental_review_memorandum.json`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/11_financing/085_financing_review_memorandum.json`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-17, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Elliot Mercer.\n\n### F-14 — construction lien notice (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for construction lien notice: one source states the threshold is 14% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 20% and produced a different exception result.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/05_environmental/040_environmental_status_report.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/11_financing/088_financing_status_report.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-17, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Talia Brooks.\n\n### F-15 — lender SNDA omission (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for lender SNDA omission: one source states formal notice must use notices-eastgate_life_sciences@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-polymer_park_properties@example.test.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/043_zoning_permits_correspondence.eml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/12_property_management/091_property_management_correspondence.eml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-17, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Jonas Feld.\n\n### F-16 — security-deposit mismatch (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for security-deposit mismatch: one source states the governed population contains 145 records through 2025-08-28, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 38 records through 2025-09-07.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/046_zoning_permits_formal_notice.xml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/12_property_management/094_property_management_formal_notice.xml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-17, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Mei Whitaker.\n\n## Recommended next actions\n\nSequence the critical and high findings first, assign the named owners, preserve the cited records, and document any resolution in the controlling matter register before the stated deadline.\n\n## Assumptions and limitations\n\nThis analysis is confined to task cb100-055-eastgate-labs and the supplied synthetic evidence. It does not rely on external facts, does not resolve disputed law, and is not legal advice for a real person or entity.\n", "findings": {"as_of": "2026-09-17", "findings": [{"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/07_operating_expenses/049_operating_expenses_control_register.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for rent schedule inconsistency: one source states the operative date is 2025-03-19 under control reference CB-RE-2905-A775, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2025-04-09 under response reference CB-RE-2905-J982.", "id": "F-01", "issue": "rent schedule inconsistency", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/01_leases/001_leases_control_register.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-17, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Henry Cho.", "severity": "critical"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/07_operating_expenses/052_operating_expenses_ledger_export.csv", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for renewal-option notice: one source states the controlling amount is $2,449,972.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $2,496,444.00.", "id": "F-02", "issue": "renewal-option notice", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/01_leases/004_leases_ledger_export.csv", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-17, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Nadine Flores.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/07_operating_expenses/055_operating_expenses_officer_certificate.html", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for exclusive-use conflict: one source states approval is attributed to Sofia Bennett as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Elliot Mercer and contains no entry for Sofia Bennett.", "id": "F-03", "issue": "exclusive-use conflict", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/01_leases/007_leases_officer_certificate.html", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-17, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Micah Sullivan.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/08_insurance/058_insurance_executed_instrument.txt", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for assignment consent: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-RE-2905-D501, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-RE-2905-M200.", "id": "F-04", "issue": "assignment consent", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/02_amendments/010_amendments_executed_instrument.txt", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-17, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Farah Ibrahim.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/08_insurance/061_insurance_review_memorandum.json", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for estoppel discrepancy: one source states the applicable location is Wake County, North Carolina, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to North Carolina operations outside Wake County, North Carolina.", "id": "F-05", "issue": "estoppel discrepancy", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/02_amendments/013_amendments_review_memorandum.json", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-17, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Owen Delgado.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/08_insurance/064_insurance_status_report.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for survey encroachment: one source states the threshold is 6% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 8% and produced a different exception result.", "id": "F-06", "issue": "survey encroachment", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/02_amendments/016_amendments_status_report.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-17, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Lena Varga.", "severity": "low"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/09_notices/067_notices_correspondence.eml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for title exception: one source states formal notice must use notices-eastgate_life_sciences@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-polymer_park_properties@example.test.", "id": "F-07", "issue": "title exception", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/03_estoppels/019_estoppels_correspondence.eml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-17, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Samuel Kim.", "severity": "critical"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/09_notices/070_notices_formal_notice.xml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for environmental recognized condition: one source states the governed population contains 116 records through 2025-07-30, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 45 records through 2025-08-16.", "id": "F-08", "issue": "environmental recognized condition", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/03_estoppels/022_estoppels_formal_notice.xml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-17, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Maya Ellison.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/10_construction/073_construction_control_register.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for zoning nonconformity: one source states the operative date is 2025-09-23 under control reference CB-RE-2905-I363, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2025-10-06 under response reference CB-RE-2905-R120.", "id": "F-09", "issue": "zoning nonconformity", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/04_title_survey/025_title_survey_control_register.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-17, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Rafael Okafor.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/10_construction/076_construction_ledger_export.csv", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for permit closeout gap: one source states the controlling amount is $7,538,393.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $7,703,286.00.", "id": "F-10", "issue": "permit closeout gap", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/04_title_survey/028_title_survey_ledger_export.csv", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-17, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Nora Chen.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/10_construction/079_construction_officer_certificate.html", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for CAM reconciliation error: one source states approval is attributed to Sofia Bennett as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Owen Delgado and contains no entry for Sofia Bennett.", "id": "F-11", "issue": "CAM reconciliation error", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/04_title_survey/031_title_survey_officer_certificate.html", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-17, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Dominic Alvarez.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/11_financing/082_financing_executed_instrument.txt", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for insurance endorsement deficiency: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-RE-2905-L264, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-RE-2905-U735.", "id": "F-12", "issue": "insurance endorsement deficiency", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/05_environmental/034_environmental_executed_instrument.txt", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-17, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Priya Raman.", "severity": "low"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/11_financing/085_financing_review_memorandum.json", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for casualty restoration deadline: one source states the applicable location is Wake County, North Carolina, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to North Carolina operations outside Wake County, North Carolina.", "id": "F-13", "issue": "casualty restoration deadline", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/05_environmental/037_environmental_review_memorandum.json", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-17, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Elliot Mercer.", "severity": "critical"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/11_financing/088_financing_status_report.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for construction lien notice: one source states the threshold is 14% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 20% and produced a different exception result.", "id": "F-14", "issue": "construction lien notice", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/05_environmental/040_environmental_status_report.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-17, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Talia Brooks.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/12_property_management/091_property_management_correspondence.eml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for lender SNDA omission: one source states formal notice must use notices-eastgate_life_sciences@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-polymer_park_properties@example.test.", "id": "F-15", "issue": "lender SNDA omission", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/043_zoning_permits_correspondence.eml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-17, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Jonas Feld.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/12_property_management/094_property_management_formal_notice.xml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for security-deposit mismatch: one source states the governed population contains 145 records through 2025-08-28, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 38 records through 2025-09-07.", "id": "F-16", "issue": "security-deposit mismatch", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/046_zoning_permits_formal_notice.xml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-17, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Mei Whitaker.", "severity": "medium"}], "matter_number": "CB-RE-2905", "prepared_for": "Eastgate Life Sciences", "schema_version": "1.0", "task_id": "cb100-055-eastgate-labs"}}, "metadata": {"benchmark": "CounselBench-100", "code_license": "Apache-2.0", "data_license": "CC-BY-4.0", "deadline": "2026-09-17", "document_count": 96, "jurisdiction": "North Carolina", "matter_number": "CB-RE-2905", "mcp_commit": "9a96ea6e5913736f92b88345bf51caeaaa8e719f", "mcp_package": "@modelcontextprotocol/server-filesystem@2026.7.10", "practice_area": "real-estate", "reference_tool_calls": 46, "required_evidence_reads": 33, "synthetic": true, "venue": "Wake County, North Carolina", "version": "2.0.0"}, "prompt": "You are real-estate transactions counsel for Eastgate Life Sciences. Outside counsel inherited this file after turnover on the client team and must validate every operative record before advising. Wet-lab leases, hazardous-material records, and expansion permits differ across amendments, estoppels, and property-manager files. Decision due 2026-09-17. North Carolina law governs; Wake County, North Carolina is the forum. Evaluate both legal consequence and the practical owner needed to cure each exception. Work out the defensible position from the matter production and leave an audit-ready exception tracker and concise advice for the supervising lawyer. Keep confirmed conflicts separate from open questions, cite the records that actually control each conclusion, and do not fill gaps with outside facts.", "rubric": {"criteria": [{"category": "procedure", "description": "Complete at least 46 successful, argument-specific evidence and output calls.", "id": "procedure.minimum_successful_tool_calls"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Find and read the 33 controlling, corroborating, and work-product-control records in full.", "id": "procedure.all_evidence_read_in_full"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Inspect file metadata for the eight designated critical primary records before relying on them.", "id": "procedure.chain_of_custody_metadata_checked"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Confirm the sandbox's allowed document and output roots.", "id": "procedure.allowed_directories_checked"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Inventory all 96 records so the relevant sources are discovered among the context records.", "id": "procedure.recursive_inventory_completed"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Search the production for email evidence that may corroborate or contradict formal records.", "id": "procedure.targeted_search_completed"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Leave only findings.json and advice.md in the output workspace.", "id": "procedure.exact_deliverable_set"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Create both final work products through the sandbox MCP surface.", "id": "procedure.deliverables_written_through_mcp"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Produce findings.json as a valid JSON object.", "id": "findings.findings_is_object"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Report exactly 16 confirmed exceptions.", "id": "findings.findings_exact_count"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Use each stable finding ID exactly once.", "id": "findings.finding_ids_unique"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set schema_version to the released matter value '1.0'.", "id": "findings.top_level_schema_version"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set task_id to the released matter value 'cb100-055-eastgate-labs'.", "id": "findings.top_level_task_id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set matter_number to the released matter value 'CB-RE-2905'.", "id": "findings.top_level_matter_number"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set prepared_for to the released matter value 'Eastgate Life Sciences'.", "id": "findings.top_level_prepared_for"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set as_of to the released matter value '2026-09-17'.", "id": "findings.top_level_as_of"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-01 exception for rent schedule inconsistency.", "id": "findings.F-01.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's id from /workspace/documents/01_leases/001_leases_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_operating_expenses/049_operating_expenses_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's issue from /workspace/documents/01_leases/001_leases_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_operating_expenses/049_operating_expenses_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's severity from /workspace/documents/01_leases/001_leases_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_operating_expenses/049_operating_expenses_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's primary_source from /workspace/documents/01_leases/001_leases_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_operating_expenses/049_operating_expenses_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/01_leases/001_leases_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_operating_expenses/049_operating_expenses_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-01 using the exact controlled facts ['2025-03-19', 'CB-RE-2905-A775', '2025-04-09', 'CB-RE-2905-J982'].", "id": "findings.F-01.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-01's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-01.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-17', 'Henry Cho'] for F-01.", "id": "findings.F-01.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-02 exception for renewal-option notice.", "id": "findings.F-02.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's id from /workspace/documents/01_leases/004_leases_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_operating_expenses/052_operating_expenses_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's issue from /workspace/documents/01_leases/004_leases_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_operating_expenses/052_operating_expenses_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's severity from /workspace/documents/01_leases/004_leases_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_operating_expenses/052_operating_expenses_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's primary_source from /workspace/documents/01_leases/004_leases_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_operating_expenses/052_operating_expenses_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/01_leases/004_leases_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_operating_expenses/052_operating_expenses_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-02 using the exact controlled facts ['$2,449,972.00', '$2,496,444.00'].", "id": "findings.F-02.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-02's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-02.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-17', 'Nadine Flores'] for F-02.", "id": "findings.F-02.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-03 exception for exclusive-use conflict.", "id": "findings.F-03.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's id from /workspace/documents/01_leases/007_leases_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_operating_expenses/055_operating_expenses_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's issue from /workspace/documents/01_leases/007_leases_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_operating_expenses/055_operating_expenses_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's severity from /workspace/documents/01_leases/007_leases_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_operating_expenses/055_operating_expenses_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's primary_source from /workspace/documents/01_leases/007_leases_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_operating_expenses/055_operating_expenses_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/01_leases/007_leases_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_operating_expenses/055_operating_expenses_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-03 using the exact controlled facts ['Sofia Bennett', 'Elliot Mercer'].", "id": "findings.F-03.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-03's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-03.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-17', 'Micah Sullivan'] for F-03.", "id": "findings.F-03.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-04 exception for assignment consent.", "id": "findings.F-04.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's id from /workspace/documents/02_amendments/010_amendments_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_insurance/058_insurance_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's issue from /workspace/documents/02_amendments/010_amendments_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_insurance/058_insurance_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's severity from /workspace/documents/02_amendments/010_amendments_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_insurance/058_insurance_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's primary_source from /workspace/documents/02_amendments/010_amendments_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_insurance/058_insurance_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/02_amendments/010_amendments_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_insurance/058_insurance_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-04 using the exact controlled facts ['closed without exception', 'CB-RE-2905-D501', 'open and escalated', 'CB-RE-2905-M200'].", "id": "findings.F-04.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-04's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-04.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-17', 'Farah Ibrahim'] for F-04.", "id": "findings.F-04.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-05 exception for estoppel discrepancy.", "id": "findings.F-05.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's id from /workspace/documents/02_amendments/013_amendments_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_insurance/061_insurance_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's issue from /workspace/documents/02_amendments/013_amendments_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_insurance/061_insurance_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's severity from /workspace/documents/02_amendments/013_amendments_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_insurance/061_insurance_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's primary_source from /workspace/documents/02_amendments/013_amendments_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_insurance/061_insurance_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/02_amendments/013_amendments_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_insurance/061_insurance_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-05 using the exact controlled facts ['Wake County, North Carolina', 'North Carolina'].", "id": "findings.F-05.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-05's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-05.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-17', 'Owen Delgado'] for F-05.", "id": "findings.F-05.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-06 exception for survey encroachment.", "id": "findings.F-06.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's id from /workspace/documents/02_amendments/016_amendments_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_insurance/064_insurance_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's issue from /workspace/documents/02_amendments/016_amendments_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_insurance/064_insurance_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's severity from /workspace/documents/02_amendments/016_amendments_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_insurance/064_insurance_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's primary_source from /workspace/documents/02_amendments/016_amendments_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_insurance/064_insurance_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/02_amendments/016_amendments_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_insurance/064_insurance_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-06 using the exact controlled facts ['6%', '8%'].", "id": "findings.F-06.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-06's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-06.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-17', 'Lena Varga'] for F-06.", "id": "findings.F-06.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-07 exception for title exception.", "id": "findings.F-07.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's id from /workspace/documents/03_estoppels/019_estoppels_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_notices/067_notices_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's issue from /workspace/documents/03_estoppels/019_estoppels_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_notices/067_notices_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's severity from /workspace/documents/03_estoppels/019_estoppels_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_notices/067_notices_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's primary_source from /workspace/documents/03_estoppels/019_estoppels_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_notices/067_notices_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/03_estoppels/019_estoppels_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_notices/067_notices_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-07 using the exact controlled facts ['notices-eastgate_life_sciences@example.test', 'archive-polymer_park_properties@example.test'].", "id": "findings.F-07.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-07's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-07.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-17', 'Samuel Kim'] for F-07.", "id": "findings.F-07.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-08 exception for environmental recognized condition.", "id": "findings.F-08.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's id from /workspace/documents/03_estoppels/022_estoppels_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_notices/070_notices_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's issue from /workspace/documents/03_estoppels/022_estoppels_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_notices/070_notices_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's severity from /workspace/documents/03_estoppels/022_estoppels_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_notices/070_notices_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's primary_source from /workspace/documents/03_estoppels/022_estoppels_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_notices/070_notices_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/03_estoppels/022_estoppels_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_notices/070_notices_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-08 using the exact controlled facts ['116 records', '2025-07-30', '45 records', '2025-08-16'].", "id": "findings.F-08.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-08's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-08.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-17', 'Maya Ellison'] for F-08.", "id": "findings.F-08.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-09 exception for zoning nonconformity.", "id": "findings.F-09.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's id from /workspace/documents/04_title_survey/025_title_survey_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_construction/073_construction_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's issue from /workspace/documents/04_title_survey/025_title_survey_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_construction/073_construction_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's severity from /workspace/documents/04_title_survey/025_title_survey_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_construction/073_construction_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's primary_source from /workspace/documents/04_title_survey/025_title_survey_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_construction/073_construction_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/04_title_survey/025_title_survey_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_construction/073_construction_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-09 using the exact controlled facts ['2025-09-23', 'CB-RE-2905-I363', '2025-10-06', 'CB-RE-2905-R120'].", "id": "findings.F-09.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-09's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-09.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-17', 'Rafael Okafor'] for F-09.", "id": "findings.F-09.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-10 exception for permit closeout gap.", "id": "findings.F-10.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's id from /workspace/documents/04_title_survey/028_title_survey_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_construction/076_construction_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's issue from /workspace/documents/04_title_survey/028_title_survey_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_construction/076_construction_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's severity from /workspace/documents/04_title_survey/028_title_survey_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_construction/076_construction_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's primary_source from /workspace/documents/04_title_survey/028_title_survey_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_construction/076_construction_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/04_title_survey/028_title_survey_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_construction/076_construction_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-10 using the exact controlled facts ['$7,538,393.00', '$7,703,286.00'].", "id": "findings.F-10.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-10's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-10.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-17', 'Nora Chen'] for F-10.", "id": "findings.F-10.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-11 exception for CAM reconciliation error.", "id": "findings.F-11.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's id from /workspace/documents/04_title_survey/031_title_survey_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_construction/079_construction_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's issue from /workspace/documents/04_title_survey/031_title_survey_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_construction/079_construction_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's severity from /workspace/documents/04_title_survey/031_title_survey_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_construction/079_construction_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's primary_source from /workspace/documents/04_title_survey/031_title_survey_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_construction/079_construction_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/04_title_survey/031_title_survey_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_construction/079_construction_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-11 using the exact controlled facts ['Sofia Bennett', 'Owen Delgado'].", "id": "findings.F-11.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-11's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-11.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-17', 'Dominic Alvarez'] for F-11.", "id": "findings.F-11.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-12 exception for insurance endorsement deficiency.", "id": "findings.F-12.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's id from /workspace/documents/05_environmental/034_environmental_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_financing/082_financing_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's issue from /workspace/documents/05_environmental/034_environmental_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_financing/082_financing_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's severity from /workspace/documents/05_environmental/034_environmental_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_financing/082_financing_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's primary_source from /workspace/documents/05_environmental/034_environmental_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_financing/082_financing_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/05_environmental/034_environmental_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_financing/082_financing_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-12 using the exact controlled facts ['closed without exception', 'CB-RE-2905-L264', 'open and escalated', 'CB-RE-2905-U735'].", "id": "findings.F-12.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-12's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-12.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-17', 'Priya Raman'] for F-12.", "id": "findings.F-12.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-13 exception for casualty restoration deadline.", "id": "findings.F-13.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's id from /workspace/documents/05_environmental/037_environmental_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_financing/085_financing_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's issue from /workspace/documents/05_environmental/037_environmental_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_financing/085_financing_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's severity from /workspace/documents/05_environmental/037_environmental_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_financing/085_financing_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's primary_source from /workspace/documents/05_environmental/037_environmental_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_financing/085_financing_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/05_environmental/037_environmental_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_financing/085_financing_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-13 using the exact controlled facts ['Wake County, North Carolina', 'North Carolina'].", "id": "findings.F-13.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-13's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-13.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-17', 'Elliot Mercer'] for F-13.", "id": "findings.F-13.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-14 exception for construction lien notice.", "id": "findings.F-14.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's id from /workspace/documents/05_environmental/040_environmental_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_financing/088_financing_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's issue from /workspace/documents/05_environmental/040_environmental_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_financing/088_financing_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's severity from /workspace/documents/05_environmental/040_environmental_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_financing/088_financing_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's primary_source from /workspace/documents/05_environmental/040_environmental_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_financing/088_financing_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/05_environmental/040_environmental_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_financing/088_financing_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-14 using the exact controlled facts ['14%', '20%'].", "id": "findings.F-14.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-14's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-14.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-17', 'Talia Brooks'] for F-14.", "id": "findings.F-14.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-15 exception for lender SNDA omission.", "id": "findings.F-15.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's id from /workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/043_zoning_permits_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_property_management/091_property_management_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's issue from /workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/043_zoning_permits_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_property_management/091_property_management_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's severity from /workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/043_zoning_permits_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_property_management/091_property_management_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's primary_source from /workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/043_zoning_permits_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_property_management/091_property_management_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/043_zoning_permits_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_property_management/091_property_management_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-15 using the exact controlled facts ['notices-eastgate_life_sciences@example.test', 'archive-polymer_park_properties@example.test'].", "id": "findings.F-15.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-15's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-15.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-17', 'Jonas Feld'] for F-15.", "id": "findings.F-15.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-16 exception for security-deposit mismatch.", "id": "findings.F-16.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's id from /workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/046_zoning_permits_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_property_management/094_property_management_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's issue from /workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/046_zoning_permits_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_property_management/094_property_management_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's severity from /workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/046_zoning_permits_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_property_management/094_property_management_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's primary_source from /workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/046_zoning_permits_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_property_management/094_property_management_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/046_zoning_permits_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_property_management/094_property_management_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-16 using the exact controlled facts ['145 records', '2025-08-28', '38 records', '2025-09-07'].", "id": "findings.F-16.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-16's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-16.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-17', 'Mei Whitaker'] for F-16.", "id": "findings.F-16.action_anchors"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Executive assessment' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Executive assessment"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Method and record coverage' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Method and record coverage"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Findings' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Findings"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Recommended next actions' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Recommended next actions"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Assumptions and limitations' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Assumptions and limitations"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-01 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-01"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-02 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-02"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-03 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-03"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-04 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-04"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-05 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-05"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-06 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-06"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-07 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-07"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-08 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-08"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-09 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-09"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-10 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-10"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-11 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-11"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-12 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-12"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-13 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-13"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-14 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-14"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-15 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-15"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-16 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-16"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Do not claim the production has no issues or that every record is consistent.", "id": "memo.forbidden_claims_absent"}], "decision_options": [{"id": "cross-source-reconciliation", "label": "Reconcile controlling and corroborating records", "reason": "The CB-RE-2905 production contains independently maintained records; a defensible answer must preserve each supported conflict and its cure owner.", "selected": true}, {"id": "latest-record-controls", "label": "Treat the latest record as controlling", "reason": "Timestamp recency does not establish legal priority, execution, or approval authority.", "selected": false}, {"id": "primary-records-only", "label": "Report primary records without reconciliation", "reason": "Primary records alone conceal the operational conflicts that create the actionable exceptions.", "selected": false}], "gates": ["all_evidence_read_in_full", "chain_of_custody_metadata_checked", "findings_criteria_complete", "memo_criteria_complete", "deliverables_written_through_mcp"], "metadata_checks": 8, "metric": "weighted_criteria_score", "minimum_tool_calls": 46, "required_deliverables": ["findings.json", "advice.md"], "required_document_reads": 33, "type": "deterministic", "weights": {"findings": 0.55, "memo": 0.2, "procedure": 0.25}}, "task_id": "cb100-055-eastgate-labs", "task_name": "Eastgate laboratory campus diligence", "world_id": "counselbench-filesystem-mcp-v2"}
-{"context_files": ["task_files/cb100-056-fairhaven-storage/01_leases/001_leases_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-056-fairhaven-storage/01_leases/002_leases_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-056-fairhaven-storage/01_leases/003_leases_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-056-fairhaven-storage/01_leases/004_leases_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-056-fairhaven-storage/01_leases/005_leases_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-056-fairhaven-storage/01_leases/006_leases_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-056-fairhaven-storage/01_leases/007_leases_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-056-fairhaven-storage/01_leases/008_leases_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-056-fairhaven-storage/02_amendments/009_amendments_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-056-fairhaven-storage/02_amendments/010_amendments_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-056-fairhaven-storage/02_amendments/011_amendments_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-056-fairhaven-storage/02_amendments/012_amendments_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-056-fairhaven-storage/02_amendments/013_amendments_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-056-fairhaven-storage/02_amendments/014_amendments_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-056-fairhaven-storage/02_amendments/015_amendments_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-056-fairhaven-storage/02_amendments/016_amendments_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-056-fairhaven-storage/03_estoppels/017_estoppels_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-056-fairhaven-storage/03_estoppels/018_estoppels_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-056-fairhaven-storage/03_estoppels/019_estoppels_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-056-fairhaven-storage/03_estoppels/020_estoppels_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-056-fairhaven-storage/03_estoppels/021_estoppels_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-056-fairhaven-storage/03_estoppels/022_estoppels_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-056-fairhaven-storage/03_estoppels/023_estoppels_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-056-fairhaven-storage/03_estoppels/024_estoppels_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-056-fairhaven-storage/04_title_survey/025_title_survey_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-056-fairhaven-storage/04_title_survey/026_title_survey_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-056-fairhaven-storage/04_title_survey/027_title_survey_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-056-fairhaven-storage/04_title_survey/028_title_survey_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-056-fairhaven-storage/04_title_survey/029_title_survey_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-056-fairhaven-storage/04_title_survey/030_title_survey_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-056-fairhaven-storage/04_title_survey/031_title_survey_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-056-fairhaven-storage/04_title_survey/032_title_survey_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-056-fairhaven-storage/05_environmental/033_environmental_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-056-fairhaven-storage/05_environmental/034_environmental_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-056-fairhaven-storage/05_environmental/035_environmental_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-056-fairhaven-storage/05_environmental/036_environmental_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-056-fairhaven-storage/05_environmental/037_environmental_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-056-fairhaven-storage/05_environmental/038_environmental_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-056-fairhaven-storage/05_environmental/039_environmental_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-056-fairhaven-storage/05_environmental/040_environmental_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-056-fairhaven-storage/06_zoning_permits/041_zoning_permits_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-056-fairhaven-storage/06_zoning_permits/042_zoning_permits_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-056-fairhaven-storage/06_zoning_permits/043_zoning_permits_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-056-fairhaven-storage/06_zoning_permits/044_zoning_permits_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-056-fairhaven-storage/06_zoning_permits/045_zoning_permits_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-056-fairhaven-storage/06_zoning_permits/046_zoning_permits_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-056-fairhaven-storage/06_zoning_permits/047_zoning_permits_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-056-fairhaven-storage/06_zoning_permits/048_zoning_permits_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-056-fairhaven-storage/07_operating_expenses/049_operating_expenses_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-056-fairhaven-storage/07_operating_expenses/050_operating_expenses_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-056-fairhaven-storage/07_operating_expenses/051_operating_expenses_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-056-fairhaven-storage/07_operating_expenses/052_operating_expenses_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-056-fairhaven-storage/07_operating_expenses/053_operating_expenses_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-056-fairhaven-storage/07_operating_expenses/054_operating_expenses_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-056-fairhaven-storage/07_operating_expenses/055_operating_expenses_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-056-fairhaven-storage/07_operating_expenses/056_operating_expenses_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-056-fairhaven-storage/08_insurance/057_insurance_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-056-fairhaven-storage/08_insurance/058_insurance_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-056-fairhaven-storage/08_insurance/059_insurance_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-056-fairhaven-storage/08_insurance/060_insurance_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-056-fairhaven-storage/08_insurance/061_insurance_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-056-fairhaven-storage/08_insurance/062_insurance_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-056-fairhaven-storage/08_insurance/063_insurance_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-056-fairhaven-storage/08_insurance/064_insurance_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-056-fairhaven-storage/09_notices/065_notices_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-056-fairhaven-storage/09_notices/066_notices_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-056-fairhaven-storage/09_notices/067_notices_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-056-fairhaven-storage/09_notices/068_notices_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-056-fairhaven-storage/09_notices/069_notices_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-056-fairhaven-storage/09_notices/070_notices_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-056-fairhaven-storage/09_notices/071_notices_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-056-fairhaven-storage/09_notices/072_notices_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-056-fairhaven-storage/10_construction/073_construction_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-056-fairhaven-storage/10_construction/074_construction_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-056-fairhaven-storage/10_construction/075_construction_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-056-fairhaven-storage/10_construction/076_construction_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-056-fairhaven-storage/10_construction/077_construction_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-056-fairhaven-storage/10_construction/078_construction_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-056-fairhaven-storage/10_construction/079_construction_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-056-fairhaven-storage/10_construction/080_construction_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-056-fairhaven-storage/11_financing/081_financing_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-056-fairhaven-storage/11_financing/082_financing_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-056-fairhaven-storage/11_financing/083_financing_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-056-fairhaven-storage/11_financing/084_financing_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-056-fairhaven-storage/11_financing/085_financing_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-056-fairhaven-storage/11_financing/086_financing_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-056-fairhaven-storage/11_financing/087_financing_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-056-fairhaven-storage/11_financing/088_financing_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-056-fairhaven-storage/12_property_management/089_property_management_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-056-fairhaven-storage/12_property_management/090_property_management_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-056-fairhaven-storage/12_property_management/091_property_management_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-056-fairhaven-storage/12_property_management/092_property_management_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-056-fairhaven-storage/12_property_management/093_property_management_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-056-fairhaven-storage/12_property_management/094_property_management_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-056-fairhaven-storage/12_property_management/095_property_management_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-056-fairhaven-storage/12_property_management/096_property_management_status_report.md"], "gold_output": {"advice_markdown": "# Counsel advice — Fairhaven self-storage portfolio review\n\n## Executive assessment\n\nFor Fairhaven Storage Partners matter CB-RE-2906, the review identified 16 source-supported exceptions requiring action before 2026-09-21. The assessment concerns Cobalt Door Management and the supplied record for Texas.\n\n## Method and record coverage\n\nThe review inventoried all 96 production files, read the 33 controlling, corroborating, and control records, searched the email exports, and checked metadata for the designated chain-of-custody sample. Conclusions are limited to the synthetic production supplied for this benchmark matter.\n\n## Findings\n\n### F-01 — rent schedule inconsistency (critical)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for rent schedule inconsistency: one source states the operative date is 2025-03-24 under control reference CB-RE-2906-A480, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2025-04-22 under response reference CB-RE-2906-J198.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/01_leases/001_leases_control_register.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/07_operating_expenses/049_operating_expenses_control_register.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-21, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Nadine Flores.\n\n### F-02 — renewal-option notice (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for renewal-option notice: one source states the controlling amount is $2,237,880.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $2,292,260.00.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/01_leases/004_leases_ledger_export.csv`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/07_operating_expenses/052_operating_expenses_ledger_export.csv`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-21, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Micah Sullivan.\n\n### F-03 — exclusive-use conflict (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for exclusive-use conflict: one source states approval is attributed to Adrian Mensah as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Jonas Feld and contains no entry for Adrian Mensah.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/01_leases/007_leases_officer_certificate.html`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/07_operating_expenses/055_operating_expenses_officer_certificate.html`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-21, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Farah Ibrahim.\n\n### F-04 — assignment consent (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for assignment consent: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-RE-2906-D682, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-RE-2906-M975.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/02_amendments/010_amendments_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/08_insurance/058_insurance_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-21, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Owen Delgado.\n\n### F-05 — estoppel discrepancy (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for estoppel discrepancy: one source states the applicable location is Bexar County, Texas, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to Texas operations outside Bexar County, Texas.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/02_amendments/013_amendments_review_memorandum.json`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/08_insurance/061_insurance_review_memorandum.json`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-21, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Lena Varga.\n\n### F-06 — survey encroachment (low)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for survey encroachment: one source states the threshold is 9% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 16% and produced a different exception result.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/02_amendments/016_amendments_status_report.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/08_insurance/064_insurance_status_report.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-21, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Samuel Kim.\n\n### F-07 — title exception (critical)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for title exception: one source states formal notice must use notices-fairhaven_storage_partners@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-cobalt_door_management@example.test.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/03_estoppels/019_estoppels_correspondence.eml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/09_notices/067_notices_correspondence.eml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-21, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Maya Ellison.\n\n### F-08 — environmental recognized condition (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for environmental recognized condition: one source states the governed population contains 172 records through 2025-05-07, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 66 records through 2025-06-14.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/03_estoppels/022_estoppels_formal_notice.xml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/09_notices/070_notices_formal_notice.xml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-21, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Rafael Okafor.\n\n### F-09 — zoning nonconformity (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for zoning nonconformity: one source states the operative date is 2026-02-23 under control reference CB-RE-2906-I576, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2026-03-29 under response reference CB-RE-2906-R828.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/04_title_survey/025_title_survey_control_register.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/10_construction/073_construction_control_register.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-21, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Nora Chen.\n\n### F-10 — permit closeout gap (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for permit closeout gap: one source states the controlling amount is $3,488,786.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $3,744,072.00.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/04_title_survey/028_title_survey_ledger_export.csv`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/10_construction/076_construction_ledger_export.csv`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-21, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Dominic Alvarez.\n\n### F-11 — CAM reconciliation error (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for CAM reconciliation error: one source states approval is attributed to Adrian Mensah as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Samuel Kim and contains no entry for Adrian Mensah.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/04_title_survey/031_title_survey_officer_certificate.html`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/10_construction/079_construction_officer_certificate.html`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-21, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Priya Raman.\n\n### F-12 — insurance endorsement deficiency (low)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for insurance endorsement deficiency: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-RE-2906-L691, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-RE-2906-U907.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/05_environmental/034_environmental_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/11_financing/082_financing_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-21, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Elliot Mercer.\n\n### F-13 — casualty restoration deadline (critical)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for casualty restoration deadline: one source states the applicable location is Bexar County, Texas, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to Texas operations outside Bexar County, Texas.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/05_environmental/037_environmental_review_memorandum.json`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/11_financing/085_financing_review_memorandum.json`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-21, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Talia Brooks.\n\n### F-14 — construction lien notice (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for construction lien notice: one source states the threshold is 11% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 14% and produced a different exception result.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/05_environmental/040_environmental_status_report.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/11_financing/088_financing_status_report.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-21, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Jonas Feld.\n\n### F-15 — lender SNDA omission (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for lender SNDA omission: one source states formal notice must use notices-fairhaven_storage_partners@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-cobalt_door_management@example.test.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/043_zoning_permits_correspondence.eml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/12_property_management/091_property_management_correspondence.eml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-21, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Mei Whitaker.\n\n### F-16 — security-deposit mismatch (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for security-deposit mismatch: one source states the governed population contains 178 records through 2025-05-13, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 43 records through 2025-05-28.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/046_zoning_permits_formal_notice.xml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/12_property_management/094_property_management_formal_notice.xml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-21, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Caleb Hassan.\n\n## Recommended next actions\n\nSequence the critical and high findings first, assign the named owners, preserve the cited records, and document any resolution in the controlling matter register before the stated deadline.\n\n## Assumptions and limitations\n\nThis analysis is confined to task cb100-056-fairhaven-storage and the supplied synthetic evidence. It does not rely on external facts, does not resolve disputed law, and is not legal advice for a real person or entity.\n", "findings": {"as_of": "2026-09-21", "findings": [{"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/07_operating_expenses/049_operating_expenses_control_register.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for rent schedule inconsistency: one source states the operative date is 2025-03-24 under control reference CB-RE-2906-A480, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2025-04-22 under response reference CB-RE-2906-J198.", "id": "F-01", "issue": "rent schedule inconsistency", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/01_leases/001_leases_control_register.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-21, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Nadine Flores.", "severity": "critical"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/07_operating_expenses/052_operating_expenses_ledger_export.csv", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for renewal-option notice: one source states the controlling amount is $2,237,880.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $2,292,260.00.", "id": "F-02", "issue": "renewal-option notice", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/01_leases/004_leases_ledger_export.csv", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-21, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Micah Sullivan.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/07_operating_expenses/055_operating_expenses_officer_certificate.html", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for exclusive-use conflict: one source states approval is attributed to Adrian Mensah as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Jonas Feld and contains no entry for Adrian Mensah.", "id": "F-03", "issue": "exclusive-use conflict", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/01_leases/007_leases_officer_certificate.html", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-21, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Farah Ibrahim.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/08_insurance/058_insurance_executed_instrument.txt", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for assignment consent: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-RE-2906-D682, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-RE-2906-M975.", "id": "F-04", "issue": "assignment consent", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/02_amendments/010_amendments_executed_instrument.txt", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-21, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Owen Delgado.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/08_insurance/061_insurance_review_memorandum.json", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for estoppel discrepancy: one source states the applicable location is Bexar County, Texas, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to Texas operations outside Bexar County, Texas.", "id": "F-05", "issue": "estoppel discrepancy", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/02_amendments/013_amendments_review_memorandum.json", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-21, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Lena Varga.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/08_insurance/064_insurance_status_report.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for survey encroachment: one source states the threshold is 9% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 16% and produced a different exception result.", "id": "F-06", "issue": "survey encroachment", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/02_amendments/016_amendments_status_report.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-21, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Samuel Kim.", "severity": "low"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/09_notices/067_notices_correspondence.eml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for title exception: one source states formal notice must use notices-fairhaven_storage_partners@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-cobalt_door_management@example.test.", "id": "F-07", "issue": "title exception", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/03_estoppels/019_estoppels_correspondence.eml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-21, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Maya Ellison.", "severity": "critical"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/09_notices/070_notices_formal_notice.xml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for environmental recognized condition: one source states the governed population contains 172 records through 2025-05-07, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 66 records through 2025-06-14.", "id": "F-08", "issue": "environmental recognized condition", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/03_estoppels/022_estoppels_formal_notice.xml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-21, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Rafael Okafor.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/10_construction/073_construction_control_register.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for zoning nonconformity: one source states the operative date is 2026-02-23 under control reference CB-RE-2906-I576, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2026-03-29 under response reference CB-RE-2906-R828.", "id": "F-09", "issue": "zoning nonconformity", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/04_title_survey/025_title_survey_control_register.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-21, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Nora Chen.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/10_construction/076_construction_ledger_export.csv", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for permit closeout gap: one source states the controlling amount is $3,488,786.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $3,744,072.00.", "id": "F-10", "issue": "permit closeout gap", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/04_title_survey/028_title_survey_ledger_export.csv", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-21, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Dominic Alvarez.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/10_construction/079_construction_officer_certificate.html", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for CAM reconciliation error: one source states approval is attributed to Adrian Mensah as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Samuel Kim and contains no entry for Adrian Mensah.", "id": "F-11", "issue": "CAM reconciliation error", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/04_title_survey/031_title_survey_officer_certificate.html", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-21, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Priya Raman.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/11_financing/082_financing_executed_instrument.txt", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for insurance endorsement deficiency: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-RE-2906-L691, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-RE-2906-U907.", "id": "F-12", "issue": "insurance endorsement deficiency", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/05_environmental/034_environmental_executed_instrument.txt", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-21, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Elliot Mercer.", "severity": "low"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/11_financing/085_financing_review_memorandum.json", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for casualty restoration deadline: one source states the applicable location is Bexar County, Texas, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to Texas operations outside Bexar County, Texas.", "id": "F-13", "issue": "casualty restoration deadline", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/05_environmental/037_environmental_review_memorandum.json", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-21, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Talia Brooks.", "severity": "critical"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/11_financing/088_financing_status_report.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for construction lien notice: one source states the threshold is 11% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 14% and produced a different exception result.", "id": "F-14", "issue": "construction lien notice", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/05_environmental/040_environmental_status_report.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-21, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Jonas Feld.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/12_property_management/091_property_management_correspondence.eml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for lender SNDA omission: one source states formal notice must use notices-fairhaven_storage_partners@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-cobalt_door_management@example.test.", "id": "F-15", "issue": "lender SNDA omission", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/043_zoning_permits_correspondence.eml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-21, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Mei Whitaker.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/12_property_management/094_property_management_formal_notice.xml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for security-deposit mismatch: one source states the governed population contains 178 records through 2025-05-13, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 43 records through 2025-05-28.", "id": "F-16", "issue": "security-deposit mismatch", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/046_zoning_permits_formal_notice.xml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-21, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Caleb Hassan.", "severity": "medium"}], "matter_number": "CB-RE-2906", "prepared_for": "Fairhaven Storage Partners", "schema_version": "1.0", "task_id": "cb100-056-fairhaven-storage"}}, "metadata": {"benchmark": "CounselBench-100", "code_license": "Apache-2.0", "data_license": "CC-BY-4.0", "deadline": "2026-09-21", "document_count": 96, "jurisdiction": "Texas", "matter_number": "CB-RE-2906", "mcp_commit": "9a96ea6e5913736f92b88345bf51caeaaa8e719f", "mcp_package": "@modelcontextprotocol/server-filesystem@2026.7.10", "practice_area": "real-estate", "reference_tool_calls": 46, "required_evidence_reads": 33, "synthetic": true, "venue": "Bexar County, Texas", "version": "2.0.0"}, "prompt": "You are real-estate transactions counsel for Fairhaven Storage Partners. The upcoming deadline leaves no room for unsupported assumptions, so every conclusion must trace to the supplied production. A storage portfolio has title exceptions, rent-roll discrepancies, security deposits, and management charges inconsistent with governing documents. Decision due 2026-09-21. Texas law governs; Bexar County, Texas is the forum. Give controlling documents precedence only when the record supports that hierarchy. Work out the defensible position from the matter production and leave an audit-ready exception tracker and concise advice for the supervising lawyer. Keep confirmed conflicts separate from open questions, cite the records that actually control each conclusion, and do not fill gaps with outside facts.", "rubric": {"criteria": [{"category": "procedure", "description": "Complete at least 46 successful, argument-specific evidence and output calls.", "id": "procedure.minimum_successful_tool_calls"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Find and read the 33 controlling, corroborating, and work-product-control records in full.", "id": "procedure.all_evidence_read_in_full"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Inspect file metadata for the eight designated critical primary records before relying on them.", "id": "procedure.chain_of_custody_metadata_checked"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Confirm the sandbox's allowed document and output roots.", "id": "procedure.allowed_directories_checked"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Inventory all 96 records so the relevant sources are discovered among the context records.", "id": "procedure.recursive_inventory_completed"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Search the production for email evidence that may corroborate or contradict formal records.", "id": "procedure.targeted_search_completed"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Leave only findings.json and advice.md in the output workspace.", "id": "procedure.exact_deliverable_set"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Create both final work products through the sandbox MCP surface.", "id": "procedure.deliverables_written_through_mcp"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Produce findings.json as a valid JSON object.", "id": "findings.findings_is_object"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Report exactly 16 confirmed exceptions.", "id": "findings.findings_exact_count"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Use each stable finding ID exactly once.", "id": "findings.finding_ids_unique"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set schema_version to the released matter value '1.0'.", "id": "findings.top_level_schema_version"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set task_id to the released matter value 'cb100-056-fairhaven-storage'.", "id": "findings.top_level_task_id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set matter_number to the released matter value 'CB-RE-2906'.", "id": "findings.top_level_matter_number"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set prepared_for to the released matter value 'Fairhaven Storage Partners'.", "id": "findings.top_level_prepared_for"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set as_of to the released matter value '2026-09-21'.", "id": "findings.top_level_as_of"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-01 exception for rent schedule inconsistency.", "id": "findings.F-01.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's id from /workspace/documents/01_leases/001_leases_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_operating_expenses/049_operating_expenses_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's issue from /workspace/documents/01_leases/001_leases_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_operating_expenses/049_operating_expenses_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's severity from /workspace/documents/01_leases/001_leases_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_operating_expenses/049_operating_expenses_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's primary_source from /workspace/documents/01_leases/001_leases_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_operating_expenses/049_operating_expenses_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/01_leases/001_leases_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_operating_expenses/049_operating_expenses_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-01 using the exact controlled facts ['2025-03-24', 'CB-RE-2906-A480', '2025-04-22', 'CB-RE-2906-J198'].", "id": "findings.F-01.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-01's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-01.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-21', 'Nadine Flores'] for F-01.", "id": "findings.F-01.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-02 exception for renewal-option notice.", "id": "findings.F-02.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's id from /workspace/documents/01_leases/004_leases_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_operating_expenses/052_operating_expenses_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's issue from /workspace/documents/01_leases/004_leases_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_operating_expenses/052_operating_expenses_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's severity from /workspace/documents/01_leases/004_leases_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_operating_expenses/052_operating_expenses_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's primary_source from /workspace/documents/01_leases/004_leases_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_operating_expenses/052_operating_expenses_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/01_leases/004_leases_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_operating_expenses/052_operating_expenses_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-02 using the exact controlled facts ['$2,237,880.00', '$2,292,260.00'].", "id": "findings.F-02.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-02's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-02.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-21', 'Micah Sullivan'] for F-02.", "id": "findings.F-02.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-03 exception for exclusive-use conflict.", "id": "findings.F-03.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's id from /workspace/documents/01_leases/007_leases_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_operating_expenses/055_operating_expenses_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's issue from /workspace/documents/01_leases/007_leases_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_operating_expenses/055_operating_expenses_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's severity from /workspace/documents/01_leases/007_leases_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_operating_expenses/055_operating_expenses_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's primary_source from /workspace/documents/01_leases/007_leases_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_operating_expenses/055_operating_expenses_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/01_leases/007_leases_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_operating_expenses/055_operating_expenses_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-03 using the exact controlled facts ['Adrian Mensah', 'Jonas Feld'].", "id": "findings.F-03.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-03's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-03.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-21', 'Farah Ibrahim'] for F-03.", "id": "findings.F-03.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-04 exception for assignment consent.", "id": "findings.F-04.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's id from /workspace/documents/02_amendments/010_amendments_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_insurance/058_insurance_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's issue from /workspace/documents/02_amendments/010_amendments_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_insurance/058_insurance_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's severity from /workspace/documents/02_amendments/010_amendments_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_insurance/058_insurance_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's primary_source from /workspace/documents/02_amendments/010_amendments_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_insurance/058_insurance_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/02_amendments/010_amendments_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_insurance/058_insurance_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-04 using the exact controlled facts ['closed without exception', 'CB-RE-2906-D682', 'open and escalated', 'CB-RE-2906-M975'].", "id": "findings.F-04.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-04's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-04.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-21', 'Owen Delgado'] for F-04.", "id": "findings.F-04.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-05 exception for estoppel discrepancy.", "id": "findings.F-05.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's id from /workspace/documents/02_amendments/013_amendments_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_insurance/061_insurance_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's issue from /workspace/documents/02_amendments/013_amendments_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_insurance/061_insurance_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's severity from /workspace/documents/02_amendments/013_amendments_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_insurance/061_insurance_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's primary_source from /workspace/documents/02_amendments/013_amendments_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_insurance/061_insurance_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/02_amendments/013_amendments_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_insurance/061_insurance_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-05 using the exact controlled facts ['Bexar County, Texas', 'Texas'].", "id": "findings.F-05.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-05's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-05.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-21', 'Lena Varga'] for F-05.", "id": "findings.F-05.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-06 exception for survey encroachment.", "id": "findings.F-06.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's id from /workspace/documents/02_amendments/016_amendments_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_insurance/064_insurance_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's issue from /workspace/documents/02_amendments/016_amendments_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_insurance/064_insurance_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's severity from /workspace/documents/02_amendments/016_amendments_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_insurance/064_insurance_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's primary_source from /workspace/documents/02_amendments/016_amendments_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_insurance/064_insurance_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/02_amendments/016_amendments_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_insurance/064_insurance_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-06 using the exact controlled facts ['9%', '16%'].", "id": "findings.F-06.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-06's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-06.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-21', 'Samuel Kim'] for F-06.", "id": "findings.F-06.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-07 exception for title exception.", "id": "findings.F-07.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's id from /workspace/documents/03_estoppels/019_estoppels_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_notices/067_notices_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's issue from /workspace/documents/03_estoppels/019_estoppels_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_notices/067_notices_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's severity from /workspace/documents/03_estoppels/019_estoppels_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_notices/067_notices_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's primary_source from /workspace/documents/03_estoppels/019_estoppels_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_notices/067_notices_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/03_estoppels/019_estoppels_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_notices/067_notices_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-07 using the exact controlled facts ['notices-fairhaven_storage_partners@example.test', 'archive-cobalt_door_management@example.test'].", "id": "findings.F-07.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-07's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-07.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-21', 'Maya Ellison'] for F-07.", "id": "findings.F-07.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-08 exception for environmental recognized condition.", "id": "findings.F-08.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's id from /workspace/documents/03_estoppels/022_estoppels_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_notices/070_notices_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's issue from /workspace/documents/03_estoppels/022_estoppels_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_notices/070_notices_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's severity from /workspace/documents/03_estoppels/022_estoppels_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_notices/070_notices_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's primary_source from /workspace/documents/03_estoppels/022_estoppels_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_notices/070_notices_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/03_estoppels/022_estoppels_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_notices/070_notices_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-08 using the exact controlled facts ['172 records', '2025-05-07', '66 records', '2025-06-14'].", "id": "findings.F-08.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-08's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-08.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-21', 'Rafael Okafor'] for F-08.", "id": "findings.F-08.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-09 exception for zoning nonconformity.", "id": "findings.F-09.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's id from /workspace/documents/04_title_survey/025_title_survey_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_construction/073_construction_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's issue from /workspace/documents/04_title_survey/025_title_survey_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_construction/073_construction_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's severity from /workspace/documents/04_title_survey/025_title_survey_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_construction/073_construction_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's primary_source from /workspace/documents/04_title_survey/025_title_survey_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_construction/073_construction_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/04_title_survey/025_title_survey_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_construction/073_construction_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-09 using the exact controlled facts ['2026-02-23', 'CB-RE-2906-I576', '2026-03-29', 'CB-RE-2906-R828'].", "id": "findings.F-09.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-09's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-09.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-21', 'Nora Chen'] for F-09.", "id": "findings.F-09.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-10 exception for permit closeout gap.", "id": "findings.F-10.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's id from /workspace/documents/04_title_survey/028_title_survey_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_construction/076_construction_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's issue from /workspace/documents/04_title_survey/028_title_survey_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_construction/076_construction_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's severity from /workspace/documents/04_title_survey/028_title_survey_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_construction/076_construction_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's primary_source from /workspace/documents/04_title_survey/028_title_survey_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_construction/076_construction_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/04_title_survey/028_title_survey_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_construction/076_construction_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-10 using the exact controlled facts ['$3,488,786.00', '$3,744,072.00'].", "id": "findings.F-10.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-10's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-10.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-21', 'Dominic Alvarez'] for F-10.", "id": "findings.F-10.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-11 exception for CAM reconciliation error.", "id": "findings.F-11.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's id from /workspace/documents/04_title_survey/031_title_survey_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_construction/079_construction_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's issue from /workspace/documents/04_title_survey/031_title_survey_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_construction/079_construction_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's severity from /workspace/documents/04_title_survey/031_title_survey_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_construction/079_construction_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's primary_source from /workspace/documents/04_title_survey/031_title_survey_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_construction/079_construction_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/04_title_survey/031_title_survey_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_construction/079_construction_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-11 using the exact controlled facts ['Adrian Mensah', 'Samuel Kim'].", "id": "findings.F-11.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-11's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-11.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-21', 'Priya Raman'] for F-11.", "id": "findings.F-11.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-12 exception for insurance endorsement deficiency.", "id": "findings.F-12.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's id from /workspace/documents/05_environmental/034_environmental_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_financing/082_financing_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's issue from /workspace/documents/05_environmental/034_environmental_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_financing/082_financing_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's severity from /workspace/documents/05_environmental/034_environmental_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_financing/082_financing_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's primary_source from /workspace/documents/05_environmental/034_environmental_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_financing/082_financing_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/05_environmental/034_environmental_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_financing/082_financing_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-12 using the exact controlled facts ['closed without exception', 'CB-RE-2906-L691', 'open and escalated', 'CB-RE-2906-U907'].", "id": "findings.F-12.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-12's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-12.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-21', 'Elliot Mercer'] for F-12.", "id": "findings.F-12.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-13 exception for casualty restoration deadline.", "id": "findings.F-13.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's id from /workspace/documents/05_environmental/037_environmental_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_financing/085_financing_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's issue from /workspace/documents/05_environmental/037_environmental_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_financing/085_financing_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's severity from /workspace/documents/05_environmental/037_environmental_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_financing/085_financing_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's primary_source from /workspace/documents/05_environmental/037_environmental_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_financing/085_financing_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/05_environmental/037_environmental_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_financing/085_financing_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-13 using the exact controlled facts ['Bexar County, Texas', 'Texas'].", "id": "findings.F-13.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-13's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-13.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-21', 'Talia Brooks'] for F-13.", "id": "findings.F-13.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-14 exception for construction lien notice.", "id": "findings.F-14.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's id from /workspace/documents/05_environmental/040_environmental_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_financing/088_financing_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's issue from /workspace/documents/05_environmental/040_environmental_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_financing/088_financing_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's severity from /workspace/documents/05_environmental/040_environmental_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_financing/088_financing_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's primary_source from /workspace/documents/05_environmental/040_environmental_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_financing/088_financing_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/05_environmental/040_environmental_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_financing/088_financing_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-14 using the exact controlled facts ['11%', '14%'].", "id": "findings.F-14.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-14's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-14.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-21', 'Jonas Feld'] for F-14.", "id": "findings.F-14.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-15 exception for lender SNDA omission.", "id": "findings.F-15.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's id from /workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/043_zoning_permits_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_property_management/091_property_management_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's issue from /workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/043_zoning_permits_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_property_management/091_property_management_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's severity from /workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/043_zoning_permits_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_property_management/091_property_management_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's primary_source from /workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/043_zoning_permits_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_property_management/091_property_management_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/043_zoning_permits_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_property_management/091_property_management_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-15 using the exact controlled facts ['notices-fairhaven_storage_partners@example.test', 'archive-cobalt_door_management@example.test'].", "id": "findings.F-15.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-15's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-15.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-21', 'Mei Whitaker'] for F-15.", "id": "findings.F-15.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-16 exception for security-deposit mismatch.", "id": "findings.F-16.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's id from /workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/046_zoning_permits_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_property_management/094_property_management_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's issue from /workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/046_zoning_permits_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_property_management/094_property_management_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's severity from /workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/046_zoning_permits_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_property_management/094_property_management_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's primary_source from /workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/046_zoning_permits_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_property_management/094_property_management_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/046_zoning_permits_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_property_management/094_property_management_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-16 using the exact controlled facts ['178 records', '2025-05-13', '43 records', '2025-05-28'].", "id": "findings.F-16.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-16's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-16.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-21', 'Caleb Hassan'] for F-16.", "id": "findings.F-16.action_anchors"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Executive assessment' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Executive assessment"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Method and record coverage' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Method and record coverage"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Findings' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Findings"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Recommended next actions' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Recommended next actions"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Assumptions and limitations' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Assumptions and limitations"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-01 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-01"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-02 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-02"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-03 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-03"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-04 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-04"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-05 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-05"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-06 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-06"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-07 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-07"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-08 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-08"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-09 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-09"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-10 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-10"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-11 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-11"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-12 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-12"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-13 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-13"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-14 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-14"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-15 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-15"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-16 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-16"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Do not claim the production has no issues or that every record is consistent.", "id": "memo.forbidden_claims_absent"}], "decision_options": [{"id": "cross-source-reconciliation", "label": "Reconcile controlling and corroborating records", "reason": "The CB-RE-2906 production contains independently maintained records; a defensible answer must preserve each supported conflict and its cure owner.", "selected": true}, {"id": "latest-record-controls", "label": "Treat the latest record as controlling", "reason": "Timestamp recency does not establish legal priority, execution, or approval authority.", "selected": false}, {"id": "primary-records-only", "label": "Report primary records without reconciliation", "reason": "Primary records alone conceal the operational conflicts that create the actionable exceptions.", "selected": false}], "gates": ["all_evidence_read_in_full", "chain_of_custody_metadata_checked", "findings_criteria_complete", "memo_criteria_complete", "deliverables_written_through_mcp"], "metadata_checks": 8, "metric": "weighted_criteria_score", "minimum_tool_calls": 46, "required_deliverables": ["findings.json", "advice.md"], "required_document_reads": 33, "type": "deterministic", "weights": {"findings": 0.55, "memo": 0.2, "procedure": 0.25}}, "task_id": "cb100-056-fairhaven-storage", "task_name": "Fairhaven self-storage portfolio review", "world_id": "counselbench-filesystem-mcp-v2"}
-{"context_files": ["task_files/cb100-057-glenridge-school/01_leases/001_leases_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-057-glenridge-school/01_leases/002_leases_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-057-glenridge-school/01_leases/003_leases_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-057-glenridge-school/01_leases/004_leases_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-057-glenridge-school/01_leases/005_leases_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-057-glenridge-school/01_leases/006_leases_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-057-glenridge-school/01_leases/007_leases_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-057-glenridge-school/01_leases/008_leases_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-057-glenridge-school/02_amendments/009_amendments_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-057-glenridge-school/02_amendments/010_amendments_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-057-glenridge-school/02_amendments/011_amendments_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-057-glenridge-school/02_amendments/012_amendments_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-057-glenridge-school/02_amendments/013_amendments_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-057-glenridge-school/02_amendments/014_amendments_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-057-glenridge-school/02_amendments/015_amendments_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-057-glenridge-school/02_amendments/016_amendments_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-057-glenridge-school/03_estoppels/017_estoppels_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-057-glenridge-school/03_estoppels/018_estoppels_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-057-glenridge-school/03_estoppels/019_estoppels_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-057-glenridge-school/03_estoppels/020_estoppels_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-057-glenridge-school/03_estoppels/021_estoppels_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-057-glenridge-school/03_estoppels/022_estoppels_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-057-glenridge-school/03_estoppels/023_estoppels_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-057-glenridge-school/03_estoppels/024_estoppels_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-057-glenridge-school/04_title_survey/025_title_survey_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-057-glenridge-school/04_title_survey/026_title_survey_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-057-glenridge-school/04_title_survey/027_title_survey_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-057-glenridge-school/04_title_survey/028_title_survey_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-057-glenridge-school/04_title_survey/029_title_survey_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-057-glenridge-school/04_title_survey/030_title_survey_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-057-glenridge-school/04_title_survey/031_title_survey_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-057-glenridge-school/04_title_survey/032_title_survey_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-057-glenridge-school/05_environmental/033_environmental_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-057-glenridge-school/05_environmental/034_environmental_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-057-glenridge-school/05_environmental/035_environmental_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-057-glenridge-school/05_environmental/036_environmental_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-057-glenridge-school/05_environmental/037_environmental_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-057-glenridge-school/05_environmental/038_environmental_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-057-glenridge-school/05_environmental/039_environmental_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-057-glenridge-school/05_environmental/040_environmental_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-057-glenridge-school/06_zoning_permits/041_zoning_permits_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-057-glenridge-school/06_zoning_permits/042_zoning_permits_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-057-glenridge-school/06_zoning_permits/043_zoning_permits_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-057-glenridge-school/06_zoning_permits/044_zoning_permits_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-057-glenridge-school/06_zoning_permits/045_zoning_permits_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-057-glenridge-school/06_zoning_permits/046_zoning_permits_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-057-glenridge-school/06_zoning_permits/047_zoning_permits_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-057-glenridge-school/06_zoning_permits/048_zoning_permits_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-057-glenridge-school/07_operating_expenses/049_operating_expenses_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-057-glenridge-school/07_operating_expenses/050_operating_expenses_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-057-glenridge-school/07_operating_expenses/051_operating_expenses_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-057-glenridge-school/07_operating_expenses/052_operating_expenses_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-057-glenridge-school/07_operating_expenses/053_operating_expenses_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-057-glenridge-school/07_operating_expenses/054_operating_expenses_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-057-glenridge-school/07_operating_expenses/055_operating_expenses_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-057-glenridge-school/07_operating_expenses/056_operating_expenses_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-057-glenridge-school/08_insurance/057_insurance_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-057-glenridge-school/08_insurance/058_insurance_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-057-glenridge-school/08_insurance/059_insurance_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-057-glenridge-school/08_insurance/060_insurance_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-057-glenridge-school/08_insurance/061_insurance_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-057-glenridge-school/08_insurance/062_insurance_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-057-glenridge-school/08_insurance/063_insurance_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-057-glenridge-school/08_insurance/064_insurance_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-057-glenridge-school/09_notices/065_notices_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-057-glenridge-school/09_notices/066_notices_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-057-glenridge-school/09_notices/067_notices_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-057-glenridge-school/09_notices/068_notices_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-057-glenridge-school/09_notices/069_notices_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-057-glenridge-school/09_notices/070_notices_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-057-glenridge-school/09_notices/071_notices_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-057-glenridge-school/09_notices/072_notices_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-057-glenridge-school/10_construction/073_construction_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-057-glenridge-school/10_construction/074_construction_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-057-glenridge-school/10_construction/075_construction_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-057-glenridge-school/10_construction/076_construction_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-057-glenridge-school/10_construction/077_construction_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-057-glenridge-school/10_construction/078_construction_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-057-glenridge-school/10_construction/079_construction_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-057-glenridge-school/10_construction/080_construction_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-057-glenridge-school/11_financing/081_financing_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-057-glenridge-school/11_financing/082_financing_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-057-glenridge-school/11_financing/083_financing_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-057-glenridge-school/11_financing/084_financing_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-057-glenridge-school/11_financing/085_financing_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-057-glenridge-school/11_financing/086_financing_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-057-glenridge-school/11_financing/087_financing_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-057-glenridge-school/11_financing/088_financing_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-057-glenridge-school/12_property_management/089_property_management_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-057-glenridge-school/12_property_management/090_property_management_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-057-glenridge-school/12_property_management/091_property_management_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-057-glenridge-school/12_property_management/092_property_management_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-057-glenridge-school/12_property_management/093_property_management_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-057-glenridge-school/12_property_management/094_property_management_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-057-glenridge-school/12_property_management/095_property_management_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-057-glenridge-school/12_property_management/096_property_management_status_report.md"], "gold_output": {"advice_markdown": "# Counsel advice — Glenridge charter campus lease review\n\n## Executive assessment\n\nFor Glenridge Education Network matter CB-RE-2907, the review identified 16 source-supported exceptions requiring action before 2026-09-24. The assessment concerns Cedar Hall Development and the supplied record for Colorado.\n\n## Method and record coverage\n\nThe review inventoried all 96 production files, read the 33 controlling, corroborating, and control records, searched the email exports, and checked metadata for the designated chain-of-custody sample. Conclusions are limited to the synthetic production supplied for this benchmark matter.\n\n## Findings\n\n### F-01 — rent schedule inconsistency (critical)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for rent schedule inconsistency: one source states the operative date is 2025-12-01 under control reference CB-RE-2907-A372, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2025-12-09 under response reference CB-RE-2907-J120.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/01_leases/001_leases_control_register.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/07_operating_expenses/049_operating_expenses_control_register.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-24, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Micah Sullivan.\n\n### F-02 — renewal-option notice (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for renewal-option notice: one source states the controlling amount is $2,387,819.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $2,452,138.00.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/01_leases/004_leases_ledger_export.csv`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/07_operating_expenses/052_operating_expenses_ledger_export.csv`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-24, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Farah Ibrahim.\n\n### F-03 — exclusive-use conflict (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for exclusive-use conflict: one source states approval is attributed to Willa Novak as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Caleb Hassan and contains no entry for Willa Novak.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/01_leases/007_leases_officer_certificate.html`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/07_operating_expenses/055_operating_expenses_officer_certificate.html`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-24, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Owen Delgado.\n\n### F-04 — assignment consent (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for assignment consent: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-RE-2907-D571, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-RE-2907-M967.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/02_amendments/010_amendments_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/08_insurance/058_insurance_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-24, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Lena Varga.\n\n### F-05 — estoppel discrepancy (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for estoppel discrepancy: one source states the applicable location is Arapahoe County, Colorado, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to Colorado operations outside Arapahoe County, Colorado.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/02_amendments/013_amendments_review_memorandum.json`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/08_insurance/061_insurance_review_memorandum.json`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-24, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Samuel Kim.\n\n### F-06 — survey encroachment (low)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for survey encroachment: one source states the threshold is 13% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 16% and produced a different exception result.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/02_amendments/016_amendments_status_report.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/08_insurance/064_insurance_status_report.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-24, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Maya Ellison.\n\n### F-07 — title exception (critical)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for title exception: one source states formal notice must use notices-glenridge_education_network@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-cedar_hall_development@example.test.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/03_estoppels/019_estoppels_correspondence.eml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/09_notices/067_notices_correspondence.eml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-24, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Rafael Okafor.\n\n### F-08 — environmental recognized condition (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for environmental recognized condition: one source states the governed population contains 72 records through 2025-06-16, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 69 records through 2025-07-27.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/03_estoppels/022_estoppels_formal_notice.xml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/09_notices/070_notices_formal_notice.xml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-24, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Nora Chen.\n\n### F-09 — zoning nonconformity (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for zoning nonconformity: one source states the operative date is 2025-06-14 under control reference CB-RE-2907-I202, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2025-07-05 under response reference CB-RE-2907-R315.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/04_title_survey/025_title_survey_control_register.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/10_construction/073_construction_control_register.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-24, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Dominic Alvarez.\n\n### F-10 — permit closeout gap (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for permit closeout gap: one source states the controlling amount is $3,552,294.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $3,581,088.00.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/04_title_survey/028_title_survey_ledger_export.csv`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/10_construction/076_construction_ledger_export.csv`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-24, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Priya Raman.\n\n### F-11 — CAM reconciliation error (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for CAM reconciliation error: one source states approval is attributed to Willa Novak as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Rafael Okafor and contains no entry for Willa Novak.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/04_title_survey/031_title_survey_officer_certificate.html`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/10_construction/079_construction_officer_certificate.html`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-24, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Elliot Mercer.\n\n### F-12 — insurance endorsement deficiency (low)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for insurance endorsement deficiency: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-RE-2907-L292, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-RE-2907-U184.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/05_environmental/034_environmental_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/11_financing/082_financing_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-24, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Talia Brooks.\n\n### F-13 — casualty restoration deadline (critical)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for casualty restoration deadline: one source states the applicable location is Arapahoe County, Colorado, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to Colorado operations outside Arapahoe County, Colorado.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/05_environmental/037_environmental_review_memorandum.json`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/11_financing/085_financing_review_memorandum.json`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-24, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Jonas Feld.\n\n### F-14 — construction lien notice (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for construction lien notice: one source states the threshold is 12% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 18% and produced a different exception result.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/05_environmental/040_environmental_status_report.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/11_financing/088_financing_status_report.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-24, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Mei Whitaker.\n\n### F-15 — lender SNDA omission (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for lender SNDA omission: one source states formal notice must use notices-glenridge_education_network@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-cedar_hall_development@example.test.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/043_zoning_permits_correspondence.eml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/12_property_management/091_property_management_correspondence.eml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-24, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Caleb Hassan.\n\n### F-16 — security-deposit mismatch (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for security-deposit mismatch: one source states the governed population contains 76 records through 2025-01-31, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 49 records through 2025-02-21.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/046_zoning_permits_formal_notice.xml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/12_property_management/094_property_management_formal_notice.xml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-24, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Leona Park.\n\n## Recommended next actions\n\nSequence the critical and high findings first, assign the named owners, preserve the cited records, and document any resolution in the controlling matter register before the stated deadline.\n\n## Assumptions and limitations\n\nThis analysis is confined to task cb100-057-glenridge-school and the supplied synthetic evidence. It does not rely on external facts, does not resolve disputed law, and is not legal advice for a real person or entity.\n", "findings": {"as_of": "2026-09-24", "findings": [{"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/07_operating_expenses/049_operating_expenses_control_register.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for rent schedule inconsistency: one source states the operative date is 2025-12-01 under control reference CB-RE-2907-A372, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2025-12-09 under response reference CB-RE-2907-J120.", "id": "F-01", "issue": "rent schedule inconsistency", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/01_leases/001_leases_control_register.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-24, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Micah Sullivan.", "severity": "critical"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/07_operating_expenses/052_operating_expenses_ledger_export.csv", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for renewal-option notice: one source states the controlling amount is $2,387,819.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $2,452,138.00.", "id": "F-02", "issue": "renewal-option notice", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/01_leases/004_leases_ledger_export.csv", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-24, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Farah Ibrahim.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/07_operating_expenses/055_operating_expenses_officer_certificate.html", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for exclusive-use conflict: one source states approval is attributed to Willa Novak as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Caleb Hassan and contains no entry for Willa Novak.", "id": "F-03", "issue": "exclusive-use conflict", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/01_leases/007_leases_officer_certificate.html", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-24, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Owen Delgado.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/08_insurance/058_insurance_executed_instrument.txt", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for assignment consent: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-RE-2907-D571, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-RE-2907-M967.", "id": "F-04", "issue": "assignment consent", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/02_amendments/010_amendments_executed_instrument.txt", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-24, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Lena Varga.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/08_insurance/061_insurance_review_memorandum.json", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for estoppel discrepancy: one source states the applicable location is Arapahoe County, Colorado, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to Colorado operations outside Arapahoe County, Colorado.", "id": "F-05", "issue": "estoppel discrepancy", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/02_amendments/013_amendments_review_memorandum.json", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-24, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Samuel Kim.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/08_insurance/064_insurance_status_report.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for survey encroachment: one source states the threshold is 13% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 16% and produced a different exception result.", "id": "F-06", "issue": "survey encroachment", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/02_amendments/016_amendments_status_report.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-24, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Maya Ellison.", "severity": "low"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/09_notices/067_notices_correspondence.eml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for title exception: one source states formal notice must use notices-glenridge_education_network@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-cedar_hall_development@example.test.", "id": "F-07", "issue": "title exception", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/03_estoppels/019_estoppels_correspondence.eml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-24, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Rafael Okafor.", "severity": "critical"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/09_notices/070_notices_formal_notice.xml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for environmental recognized condition: one source states the governed population contains 72 records through 2025-06-16, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 69 records through 2025-07-27.", "id": "F-08", "issue": "environmental recognized condition", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/03_estoppels/022_estoppels_formal_notice.xml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-24, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Nora Chen.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/10_construction/073_construction_control_register.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for zoning nonconformity: one source states the operative date is 2025-06-14 under control reference CB-RE-2907-I202, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2025-07-05 under response reference CB-RE-2907-R315.", "id": "F-09", "issue": "zoning nonconformity", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/04_title_survey/025_title_survey_control_register.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-24, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Dominic Alvarez.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/10_construction/076_construction_ledger_export.csv", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for permit closeout gap: one source states the controlling amount is $3,552,294.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $3,581,088.00.", "id": "F-10", "issue": "permit closeout gap", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/04_title_survey/028_title_survey_ledger_export.csv", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-24, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Priya Raman.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/10_construction/079_construction_officer_certificate.html", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for CAM reconciliation error: one source states approval is attributed to Willa Novak as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Rafael Okafor and contains no entry for Willa Novak.", "id": "F-11", "issue": "CAM reconciliation error", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/04_title_survey/031_title_survey_officer_certificate.html", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-24, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Elliot Mercer.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/11_financing/082_financing_executed_instrument.txt", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for insurance endorsement deficiency: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-RE-2907-L292, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-RE-2907-U184.", "id": "F-12", "issue": "insurance endorsement deficiency", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/05_environmental/034_environmental_executed_instrument.txt", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-24, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Talia Brooks.", "severity": "low"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/11_financing/085_financing_review_memorandum.json", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for casualty restoration deadline: one source states the applicable location is Arapahoe County, Colorado, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to Colorado operations outside Arapahoe County, Colorado.", "id": "F-13", "issue": "casualty restoration deadline", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/05_environmental/037_environmental_review_memorandum.json", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-24, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Jonas Feld.", "severity": "critical"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/11_financing/088_financing_status_report.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for construction lien notice: one source states the threshold is 12% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 18% and produced a different exception result.", "id": "F-14", "issue": "construction lien notice", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/05_environmental/040_environmental_status_report.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-24, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Mei Whitaker.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/12_property_management/091_property_management_correspondence.eml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for lender SNDA omission: one source states formal notice must use notices-glenridge_education_network@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-cedar_hall_development@example.test.", "id": "F-15", "issue": "lender SNDA omission", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/043_zoning_permits_correspondence.eml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-24, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Caleb Hassan.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/12_property_management/094_property_management_formal_notice.xml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for security-deposit mismatch: one source states the governed population contains 76 records through 2025-01-31, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 49 records through 2025-02-21.", "id": "F-16", "issue": "security-deposit mismatch", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/046_zoning_permits_formal_notice.xml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-24, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Leona Park.", "severity": "medium"}], "matter_number": "CB-RE-2907", "prepared_for": "Glenridge Education Network", "schema_version": "1.0", "task_id": "cb100-057-glenridge-school"}}, "metadata": {"benchmark": "CounselBench-100", "code_license": "Apache-2.0", "data_license": "CC-BY-4.0", "deadline": "2026-09-24", "document_count": 96, "jurisdiction": "Colorado", "matter_number": "CB-RE-2907", "mcp_commit": "9a96ea6e5913736f92b88345bf51caeaaa8e719f", "mcp_package": "@modelcontextprotocol/server-filesystem@2026.7.10", "practice_area": "real-estate", "reference_tool_calls": 46, "required_evidence_reads": 33, "synthetic": true, "venue": "Arapahoe County, Colorado", "version": "2.0.0"}, "prompt": "You are real-estate transactions counsel for Glenridge Education Network. A counterparty challenged the client's internal summary, making cross-document reconciliation and precise citations essential. A school campus faces use restrictions, renewal notices, accessibility work, and an SNDA missing from lender records. Decision due 2026-09-24. Colorado law governs; Arapahoe County, Colorado is the forum. Flag cross-folder dependencies that would be invisible in a single-document review. Work out the defensible position from the matter production and leave an audit-ready exception tracker and concise advice for the supervising lawyer. Keep confirmed conflicts separate from open questions, cite the records that actually control each conclusion, and do not fill gaps with outside facts.", "rubric": {"criteria": [{"category": "procedure", "description": "Complete at least 46 successful, argument-specific evidence and output calls.", "id": "procedure.minimum_successful_tool_calls"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Find and read the 33 controlling, corroborating, and work-product-control records in full.", "id": "procedure.all_evidence_read_in_full"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Inspect file metadata for the eight designated critical primary records before relying on them.", "id": "procedure.chain_of_custody_metadata_checked"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Confirm the sandbox's allowed document and output roots.", "id": "procedure.allowed_directories_checked"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Inventory all 96 records so the relevant sources are discovered among the context records.", "id": "procedure.recursive_inventory_completed"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Search the production for email evidence that may corroborate or contradict formal records.", "id": "procedure.targeted_search_completed"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Leave only findings.json and advice.md in the output workspace.", "id": "procedure.exact_deliverable_set"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Create both final work products through the sandbox MCP surface.", "id": "procedure.deliverables_written_through_mcp"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Produce findings.json as a valid JSON object.", "id": "findings.findings_is_object"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Report exactly 16 confirmed exceptions.", "id": "findings.findings_exact_count"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Use each stable finding ID exactly once.", "id": "findings.finding_ids_unique"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set schema_version to the released matter value '1.0'.", "id": "findings.top_level_schema_version"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set task_id to the released matter value 'cb100-057-glenridge-school'.", "id": "findings.top_level_task_id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set matter_number to the released matter value 'CB-RE-2907'.", "id": "findings.top_level_matter_number"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set prepared_for to the released matter value 'Glenridge Education Network'.", "id": "findings.top_level_prepared_for"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set as_of to the released matter value '2026-09-24'.", "id": "findings.top_level_as_of"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-01 exception for rent schedule inconsistency.", "id": "findings.F-01.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's id from /workspace/documents/01_leases/001_leases_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_operating_expenses/049_operating_expenses_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's issue from /workspace/documents/01_leases/001_leases_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_operating_expenses/049_operating_expenses_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's severity from /workspace/documents/01_leases/001_leases_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_operating_expenses/049_operating_expenses_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's primary_source from /workspace/documents/01_leases/001_leases_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_operating_expenses/049_operating_expenses_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/01_leases/001_leases_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_operating_expenses/049_operating_expenses_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-01 using the exact controlled facts ['2025-12-01', 'CB-RE-2907-A372', '2025-12-09', 'CB-RE-2907-J120'].", "id": "findings.F-01.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-01's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-01.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-24', 'Micah Sullivan'] for F-01.", "id": "findings.F-01.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-02 exception for renewal-option notice.", "id": "findings.F-02.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's id from /workspace/documents/01_leases/004_leases_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_operating_expenses/052_operating_expenses_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's issue from /workspace/documents/01_leases/004_leases_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_operating_expenses/052_operating_expenses_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's severity from /workspace/documents/01_leases/004_leases_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_operating_expenses/052_operating_expenses_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's primary_source from /workspace/documents/01_leases/004_leases_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_operating_expenses/052_operating_expenses_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/01_leases/004_leases_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_operating_expenses/052_operating_expenses_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-02 using the exact controlled facts ['$2,387,819.00', '$2,452,138.00'].", "id": "findings.F-02.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-02's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-02.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-24', 'Farah Ibrahim'] for F-02.", "id": "findings.F-02.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-03 exception for exclusive-use conflict.", "id": "findings.F-03.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's id from /workspace/documents/01_leases/007_leases_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_operating_expenses/055_operating_expenses_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's issue from /workspace/documents/01_leases/007_leases_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_operating_expenses/055_operating_expenses_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's severity from /workspace/documents/01_leases/007_leases_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_operating_expenses/055_operating_expenses_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's primary_source from /workspace/documents/01_leases/007_leases_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_operating_expenses/055_operating_expenses_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/01_leases/007_leases_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_operating_expenses/055_operating_expenses_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-03 using the exact controlled facts ['Willa Novak', 'Caleb Hassan'].", "id": "findings.F-03.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-03's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-03.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-24', 'Owen Delgado'] for F-03.", "id": "findings.F-03.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-04 exception for assignment consent.", "id": "findings.F-04.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's id from /workspace/documents/02_amendments/010_amendments_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_insurance/058_insurance_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's issue from /workspace/documents/02_amendments/010_amendments_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_insurance/058_insurance_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's severity from /workspace/documents/02_amendments/010_amendments_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_insurance/058_insurance_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's primary_source from /workspace/documents/02_amendments/010_amendments_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_insurance/058_insurance_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/02_amendments/010_amendments_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_insurance/058_insurance_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-04 using the exact controlled facts ['closed without exception', 'CB-RE-2907-D571', 'open and escalated', 'CB-RE-2907-M967'].", "id": "findings.F-04.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-04's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-04.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-24', 'Lena Varga'] for F-04.", "id": "findings.F-04.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-05 exception for estoppel discrepancy.", "id": "findings.F-05.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's id from /workspace/documents/02_amendments/013_amendments_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_insurance/061_insurance_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's issue from /workspace/documents/02_amendments/013_amendments_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_insurance/061_insurance_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's severity from /workspace/documents/02_amendments/013_amendments_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_insurance/061_insurance_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's primary_source from /workspace/documents/02_amendments/013_amendments_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_insurance/061_insurance_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/02_amendments/013_amendments_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_insurance/061_insurance_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-05 using the exact controlled facts ['Arapahoe County, Colorado', 'Colorado'].", "id": "findings.F-05.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-05's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-05.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-24', 'Samuel Kim'] for F-05.", "id": "findings.F-05.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-06 exception for survey encroachment.", "id": "findings.F-06.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's id from /workspace/documents/02_amendments/016_amendments_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_insurance/064_insurance_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's issue from /workspace/documents/02_amendments/016_amendments_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_insurance/064_insurance_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's severity from /workspace/documents/02_amendments/016_amendments_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_insurance/064_insurance_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's primary_source from /workspace/documents/02_amendments/016_amendments_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_insurance/064_insurance_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/02_amendments/016_amendments_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_insurance/064_insurance_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-06 using the exact controlled facts ['13%', '16%'].", "id": "findings.F-06.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-06's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-06.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-24', 'Maya Ellison'] for F-06.", "id": "findings.F-06.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-07 exception for title exception.", "id": "findings.F-07.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's id from /workspace/documents/03_estoppels/019_estoppels_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_notices/067_notices_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's issue from /workspace/documents/03_estoppels/019_estoppels_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_notices/067_notices_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's severity from /workspace/documents/03_estoppels/019_estoppels_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_notices/067_notices_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's primary_source from /workspace/documents/03_estoppels/019_estoppels_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_notices/067_notices_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/03_estoppels/019_estoppels_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_notices/067_notices_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-07 using the exact controlled facts ['notices-glenridge_education_network@example.test', 'archive-cedar_hall_development@example.test'].", "id": "findings.F-07.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-07's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-07.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-24', 'Rafael Okafor'] for F-07.", "id": "findings.F-07.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-08 exception for environmental recognized condition.", "id": "findings.F-08.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's id from /workspace/documents/03_estoppels/022_estoppels_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_notices/070_notices_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's issue from /workspace/documents/03_estoppels/022_estoppels_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_notices/070_notices_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's severity from /workspace/documents/03_estoppels/022_estoppels_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_notices/070_notices_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's primary_source from /workspace/documents/03_estoppels/022_estoppels_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_notices/070_notices_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/03_estoppels/022_estoppels_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_notices/070_notices_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-08 using the exact controlled facts ['72 records', '2025-06-16', '69 records', '2025-07-27'].", "id": "findings.F-08.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-08's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-08.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-24', 'Nora Chen'] for F-08.", "id": "findings.F-08.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-09 exception for zoning nonconformity.", "id": "findings.F-09.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's id from /workspace/documents/04_title_survey/025_title_survey_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_construction/073_construction_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's issue from /workspace/documents/04_title_survey/025_title_survey_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_construction/073_construction_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's severity from /workspace/documents/04_title_survey/025_title_survey_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_construction/073_construction_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's primary_source from /workspace/documents/04_title_survey/025_title_survey_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_construction/073_construction_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/04_title_survey/025_title_survey_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_construction/073_construction_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-09 using the exact controlled facts ['2025-06-14', 'CB-RE-2907-I202', '2025-07-05', 'CB-RE-2907-R315'].", "id": "findings.F-09.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-09's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-09.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-24', 'Dominic Alvarez'] for F-09.", "id": "findings.F-09.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-10 exception for permit closeout gap.", "id": "findings.F-10.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's id from /workspace/documents/04_title_survey/028_title_survey_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_construction/076_construction_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's issue from /workspace/documents/04_title_survey/028_title_survey_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_construction/076_construction_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's severity from /workspace/documents/04_title_survey/028_title_survey_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_construction/076_construction_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's primary_source from /workspace/documents/04_title_survey/028_title_survey_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_construction/076_construction_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/04_title_survey/028_title_survey_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_construction/076_construction_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-10 using the exact controlled facts ['$3,552,294.00', '$3,581,088.00'].", "id": "findings.F-10.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-10's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-10.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-24', 'Priya Raman'] for F-10.", "id": "findings.F-10.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-11 exception for CAM reconciliation error.", "id": "findings.F-11.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's id from /workspace/documents/04_title_survey/031_title_survey_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_construction/079_construction_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's issue from /workspace/documents/04_title_survey/031_title_survey_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_construction/079_construction_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's severity from /workspace/documents/04_title_survey/031_title_survey_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_construction/079_construction_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's primary_source from /workspace/documents/04_title_survey/031_title_survey_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_construction/079_construction_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/04_title_survey/031_title_survey_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_construction/079_construction_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-11 using the exact controlled facts ['Willa Novak', 'Rafael Okafor'].", "id": "findings.F-11.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-11's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-11.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-24', 'Elliot Mercer'] for F-11.", "id": "findings.F-11.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-12 exception for insurance endorsement deficiency.", "id": "findings.F-12.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's id from /workspace/documents/05_environmental/034_environmental_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_financing/082_financing_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's issue from /workspace/documents/05_environmental/034_environmental_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_financing/082_financing_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's severity from /workspace/documents/05_environmental/034_environmental_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_financing/082_financing_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's primary_source from /workspace/documents/05_environmental/034_environmental_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_financing/082_financing_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/05_environmental/034_environmental_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_financing/082_financing_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-12 using the exact controlled facts ['closed without exception', 'CB-RE-2907-L292', 'open and escalated', 'CB-RE-2907-U184'].", "id": "findings.F-12.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-12's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-12.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-24', 'Talia Brooks'] for F-12.", "id": "findings.F-12.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-13 exception for casualty restoration deadline.", "id": "findings.F-13.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's id from /workspace/documents/05_environmental/037_environmental_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_financing/085_financing_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's issue from /workspace/documents/05_environmental/037_environmental_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_financing/085_financing_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's severity from /workspace/documents/05_environmental/037_environmental_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_financing/085_financing_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's primary_source from /workspace/documents/05_environmental/037_environmental_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_financing/085_financing_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/05_environmental/037_environmental_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_financing/085_financing_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-13 using the exact controlled facts ['Arapahoe County, Colorado', 'Colorado'].", "id": "findings.F-13.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-13's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-13.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-24', 'Jonas Feld'] for F-13.", "id": "findings.F-13.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-14 exception for construction lien notice.", "id": "findings.F-14.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's id from /workspace/documents/05_environmental/040_environmental_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_financing/088_financing_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's issue from /workspace/documents/05_environmental/040_environmental_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_financing/088_financing_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's severity from /workspace/documents/05_environmental/040_environmental_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_financing/088_financing_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's primary_source from /workspace/documents/05_environmental/040_environmental_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_financing/088_financing_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/05_environmental/040_environmental_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_financing/088_financing_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-14 using the exact controlled facts ['12%', '18%'].", "id": "findings.F-14.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-14's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-14.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-24', 'Mei Whitaker'] for F-14.", "id": "findings.F-14.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-15 exception for lender SNDA omission.", "id": "findings.F-15.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's id from /workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/043_zoning_permits_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_property_management/091_property_management_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's issue from /workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/043_zoning_permits_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_property_management/091_property_management_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's severity from /workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/043_zoning_permits_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_property_management/091_property_management_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's primary_source from /workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/043_zoning_permits_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_property_management/091_property_management_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/043_zoning_permits_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_property_management/091_property_management_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-15 using the exact controlled facts ['notices-glenridge_education_network@example.test', 'archive-cedar_hall_development@example.test'].", "id": "findings.F-15.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-15's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-15.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-24', 'Caleb Hassan'] for F-15.", "id": "findings.F-15.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-16 exception for security-deposit mismatch.", "id": "findings.F-16.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's id from /workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/046_zoning_permits_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_property_management/094_property_management_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's issue from /workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/046_zoning_permits_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_property_management/094_property_management_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's severity from /workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/046_zoning_permits_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_property_management/094_property_management_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's primary_source from /workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/046_zoning_permits_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_property_management/094_property_management_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/046_zoning_permits_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_property_management/094_property_management_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-16 using the exact controlled facts ['76 records', '2025-01-31', '49 records', '2025-02-21'].", "id": "findings.F-16.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-16's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-16.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-24', 'Leona Park'] for F-16.", "id": "findings.F-16.action_anchors"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Executive assessment' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Executive assessment"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Method and record coverage' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Method and record coverage"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Findings' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Findings"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Recommended next actions' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Recommended next actions"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Assumptions and limitations' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Assumptions and limitations"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-01 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-01"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-02 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-02"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-03 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-03"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-04 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-04"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-05 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-05"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-06 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-06"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-07 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-07"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-08 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-08"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-09 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-09"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-10 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-10"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-11 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-11"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-12 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-12"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-13 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-13"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-14 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-14"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-15 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-15"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-16 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-16"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Do not claim the production has no issues or that every record is consistent.", "id": "memo.forbidden_claims_absent"}], "decision_options": [{"id": "cross-source-reconciliation", "label": "Reconcile controlling and corroborating records", "reason": "The CB-RE-2907 production contains independently maintained records; a defensible answer must preserve each supported conflict and its cure owner.", "selected": true}, {"id": "latest-record-controls", "label": "Treat the latest record as controlling", "reason": "Timestamp recency does not establish legal priority, execution, or approval authority.", "selected": false}, {"id": "primary-records-only", "label": "Report primary records without reconciliation", "reason": "Primary records alone conceal the operational conflicts that create the actionable exceptions.", "selected": false}], "gates": ["all_evidence_read_in_full", "chain_of_custody_metadata_checked", "findings_criteria_complete", "memo_criteria_complete", "deliverables_written_through_mcp"], "metadata_checks": 8, "metric": "weighted_criteria_score", "minimum_tool_calls": 46, "required_deliverables": ["findings.json", "advice.md"], "required_document_reads": 33, "type": "deterministic", "weights": {"findings": 0.55, "memo": 0.2, "procedure": 0.25}}, "task_id": "cb100-057-glenridge-school", "task_name": "Glenridge charter campus lease review", "world_id": "counselbench-filesystem-mcp-v2"}
-{"context_files": ["task_files/cb100-058-hemlock-manufacturing/01_leases/001_leases_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-058-hemlock-manufacturing/01_leases/002_leases_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-058-hemlock-manufacturing/01_leases/003_leases_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-058-hemlock-manufacturing/01_leases/004_leases_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-058-hemlock-manufacturing/01_leases/005_leases_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-058-hemlock-manufacturing/01_leases/006_leases_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-058-hemlock-manufacturing/01_leases/007_leases_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-058-hemlock-manufacturing/01_leases/008_leases_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-058-hemlock-manufacturing/02_amendments/009_amendments_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-058-hemlock-manufacturing/02_amendments/010_amendments_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-058-hemlock-manufacturing/02_amendments/011_amendments_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-058-hemlock-manufacturing/02_amendments/012_amendments_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-058-hemlock-manufacturing/02_amendments/013_amendments_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-058-hemlock-manufacturing/02_amendments/014_amendments_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-058-hemlock-manufacturing/02_amendments/015_amendments_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-058-hemlock-manufacturing/02_amendments/016_amendments_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-058-hemlock-manufacturing/03_estoppels/017_estoppels_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-058-hemlock-manufacturing/03_estoppels/018_estoppels_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-058-hemlock-manufacturing/03_estoppels/019_estoppels_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-058-hemlock-manufacturing/03_estoppels/020_estoppels_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-058-hemlock-manufacturing/03_estoppels/021_estoppels_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-058-hemlock-manufacturing/03_estoppels/022_estoppels_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-058-hemlock-manufacturing/03_estoppels/023_estoppels_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-058-hemlock-manufacturing/03_estoppels/024_estoppels_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-058-hemlock-manufacturing/04_title_survey/025_title_survey_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-058-hemlock-manufacturing/04_title_survey/026_title_survey_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-058-hemlock-manufacturing/04_title_survey/027_title_survey_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-058-hemlock-manufacturing/04_title_survey/028_title_survey_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-058-hemlock-manufacturing/04_title_survey/029_title_survey_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-058-hemlock-manufacturing/04_title_survey/030_title_survey_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-058-hemlock-manufacturing/04_title_survey/031_title_survey_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-058-hemlock-manufacturing/04_title_survey/032_title_survey_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-058-hemlock-manufacturing/05_environmental/033_environmental_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-058-hemlock-manufacturing/05_environmental/034_environmental_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-058-hemlock-manufacturing/05_environmental/035_environmental_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-058-hemlock-manufacturing/05_environmental/036_environmental_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-058-hemlock-manufacturing/05_environmental/037_environmental_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-058-hemlock-manufacturing/05_environmental/038_environmental_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-058-hemlock-manufacturing/05_environmental/039_environmental_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-058-hemlock-manufacturing/05_environmental/040_environmental_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-058-hemlock-manufacturing/06_zoning_permits/041_zoning_permits_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-058-hemlock-manufacturing/06_zoning_permits/042_zoning_permits_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-058-hemlock-manufacturing/06_zoning_permits/043_zoning_permits_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-058-hemlock-manufacturing/06_zoning_permits/044_zoning_permits_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-058-hemlock-manufacturing/06_zoning_permits/045_zoning_permits_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-058-hemlock-manufacturing/06_zoning_permits/046_zoning_permits_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-058-hemlock-manufacturing/06_zoning_permits/047_zoning_permits_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-058-hemlock-manufacturing/06_zoning_permits/048_zoning_permits_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-058-hemlock-manufacturing/07_operating_expenses/049_operating_expenses_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-058-hemlock-manufacturing/07_operating_expenses/050_operating_expenses_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-058-hemlock-manufacturing/07_operating_expenses/051_operating_expenses_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-058-hemlock-manufacturing/07_operating_expenses/052_operating_expenses_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-058-hemlock-manufacturing/07_operating_expenses/053_operating_expenses_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-058-hemlock-manufacturing/07_operating_expenses/054_operating_expenses_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-058-hemlock-manufacturing/07_operating_expenses/055_operating_expenses_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-058-hemlock-manufacturing/07_operating_expenses/056_operating_expenses_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-058-hemlock-manufacturing/08_insurance/057_insurance_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-058-hemlock-manufacturing/08_insurance/058_insurance_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-058-hemlock-manufacturing/08_insurance/059_insurance_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-058-hemlock-manufacturing/08_insurance/060_insurance_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-058-hemlock-manufacturing/08_insurance/061_insurance_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-058-hemlock-manufacturing/08_insurance/062_insurance_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-058-hemlock-manufacturing/08_insurance/063_insurance_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-058-hemlock-manufacturing/08_insurance/064_insurance_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-058-hemlock-manufacturing/09_notices/065_notices_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-058-hemlock-manufacturing/09_notices/066_notices_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-058-hemlock-manufacturing/09_notices/067_notices_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-058-hemlock-manufacturing/09_notices/068_notices_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-058-hemlock-manufacturing/09_notices/069_notices_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-058-hemlock-manufacturing/09_notices/070_notices_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-058-hemlock-manufacturing/09_notices/071_notices_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-058-hemlock-manufacturing/09_notices/072_notices_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-058-hemlock-manufacturing/10_construction/073_construction_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-058-hemlock-manufacturing/10_construction/074_construction_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-058-hemlock-manufacturing/10_construction/075_construction_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-058-hemlock-manufacturing/10_construction/076_construction_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-058-hemlock-manufacturing/10_construction/077_construction_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-058-hemlock-manufacturing/10_construction/078_construction_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-058-hemlock-manufacturing/10_construction/079_construction_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-058-hemlock-manufacturing/10_construction/080_construction_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-058-hemlock-manufacturing/11_financing/081_financing_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-058-hemlock-manufacturing/11_financing/082_financing_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-058-hemlock-manufacturing/11_financing/083_financing_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-058-hemlock-manufacturing/11_financing/084_financing_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-058-hemlock-manufacturing/11_financing/085_financing_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-058-hemlock-manufacturing/11_financing/086_financing_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-058-hemlock-manufacturing/11_financing/087_financing_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-058-hemlock-manufacturing/11_financing/088_financing_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-058-hemlock-manufacturing/12_property_management/089_property_management_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-058-hemlock-manufacturing/12_property_management/090_property_management_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-058-hemlock-manufacturing/12_property_management/091_property_management_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-058-hemlock-manufacturing/12_property_management/092_property_management_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-058-hemlock-manufacturing/12_property_management/093_property_management_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-058-hemlock-manufacturing/12_property_management/094_property_management_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-058-hemlock-manufacturing/12_property_management/095_property_management_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-058-hemlock-manufacturing/12_property_management/096_property_management_status_report.md"], "gold_output": {"advice_markdown": "# Counsel advice — Hemlock plant sale-leaseback audit\n\n## Executive assessment\n\nFor Hemlock Precision Works matter CB-RE-2908, the review identified 16 source-supported exceptions requiring action before 2026-09-28. The assessment concerns Iron Gate Capital and the supplied record for Michigan.\n\n## Method and record coverage\n\nThe review inventoried all 96 production files, read the 33 controlling, corroborating, and control records, searched the email exports, and checked metadata for the designated chain-of-custody sample. Conclusions are limited to the synthetic production supplied for this benchmark matter.\n\n## Findings\n\n### F-01 — rent schedule inconsistency (critical)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for rent schedule inconsistency: one source states the operative date is 2025-02-15 under control reference CB-RE-2908-A983, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2025-04-03 under response reference CB-RE-2908-J444.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/01_leases/001_leases_control_register.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/07_operating_expenses/049_operating_expenses_control_register.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-28, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Farah Ibrahim.\n\n### F-02 — renewal-option notice (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for renewal-option notice: one source states the controlling amount is $3,400,699.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $3,647,898.00.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/01_leases/004_leases_ledger_export.csv`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/07_operating_expenses/052_operating_expenses_ledger_export.csv`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-28, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Owen Delgado.\n\n### F-03 — exclusive-use conflict (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for exclusive-use conflict: one source states approval is attributed to Theo Laurent as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Isaac Romero and contains no entry for Theo Laurent.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/01_leases/007_leases_officer_certificate.html`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/07_operating_expenses/055_operating_expenses_officer_certificate.html`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-28, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Lena Varga.\n\n### F-04 — assignment consent (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for assignment consent: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-RE-2908-D354, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-RE-2908-M188.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/02_amendments/010_amendments_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/08_insurance/058_insurance_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-28, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Samuel Kim.\n\n### F-05 — estoppel discrepancy (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for estoppel discrepancy: one source states the applicable location is Oakland County, Michigan, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to Michigan operations outside Oakland County, Michigan.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/02_amendments/013_amendments_review_memorandum.json`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/08_insurance/061_insurance_review_memorandum.json`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-28, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Maya Ellison.\n\n### F-06 — survey encroachment (low)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for survey encroachment: one source states the threshold is 2% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 8% and produced a different exception result.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/02_amendments/016_amendments_status_report.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/08_insurance/064_insurance_status_report.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-28, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Rafael Okafor.\n\n### F-07 — title exception (critical)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for title exception: one source states formal notice must use notices-hemlock_precision_works@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-iron_gate_capital@example.test.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/03_estoppels/019_estoppels_correspondence.eml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/09_notices/067_notices_correspondence.eml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-28, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Nora Chen.\n\n### F-08 — environmental recognized condition (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for environmental recognized condition: one source states the governed population contains 108 records through 2025-12-09, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 52 records through 2026-01-02.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/03_estoppels/022_estoppels_formal_notice.xml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/09_notices/070_notices_formal_notice.xml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-28, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Dominic Alvarez.\n\n### F-09 — zoning nonconformity (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for zoning nonconformity: one source states the operative date is 2025-07-07 under control reference CB-RE-2908-I585, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2025-08-03 under response reference CB-RE-2908-R760.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/04_title_survey/025_title_survey_control_register.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/10_construction/073_construction_control_register.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-28, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Priya Raman.\n\n### F-10 — permit closeout gap (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for permit closeout gap: one source states the controlling amount is $1,879,081.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $1,904,662.00.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/04_title_survey/028_title_survey_ledger_export.csv`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/10_construction/076_construction_ledger_export.csv`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-28, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Elliot Mercer.\n\n### F-11 — CAM reconciliation error (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for CAM reconciliation error: one source states approval is attributed to Theo Laurent as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Dominic Alvarez and contains no entry for Theo Laurent.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/04_title_survey/031_title_survey_officer_certificate.html`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/10_construction/079_construction_officer_certificate.html`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-28, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Talia Brooks.\n\n### F-12 — insurance endorsement deficiency (low)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for insurance endorsement deficiency: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-RE-2908-L553, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-RE-2908-U757.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/05_environmental/034_environmental_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/11_financing/082_financing_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-28, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Jonas Feld.\n\n### F-13 — casualty restoration deadline (critical)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for casualty restoration deadline: one source states the applicable location is Oakland County, Michigan, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to Michigan operations outside Oakland County, Michigan.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/05_environmental/037_environmental_review_memorandum.json`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/11_financing/085_financing_review_memorandum.json`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-28, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Mei Whitaker.\n\n### F-14 — construction lien notice (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for construction lien notice: one source states the threshold is 14% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 20% and produced a different exception result.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/05_environmental/040_environmental_status_report.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/11_financing/088_financing_status_report.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-28, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Caleb Hassan.\n\n### F-15 — lender SNDA omission (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for lender SNDA omission: one source states formal notice must use notices-hemlock_precision_works@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-iron_gate_capital@example.test.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/043_zoning_permits_correspondence.eml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/12_property_management/091_property_management_correspondence.eml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-28, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Leona Park.\n\n### F-16 — security-deposit mismatch (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for security-deposit mismatch: one source states the governed population contains 129 records through 2025-03-25, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 69 records through 2025-05-05.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/046_zoning_permits_formal_notice.xml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/12_property_management/094_property_management_formal_notice.xml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-28, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Isaac Romero.\n\n## Recommended next actions\n\nSequence the critical and high findings first, assign the named owners, preserve the cited records, and document any resolution in the controlling matter register before the stated deadline.\n\n## Assumptions and limitations\n\nThis analysis is confined to task cb100-058-hemlock-manufacturing and the supplied synthetic evidence. It does not rely on external facts, does not resolve disputed law, and is not legal advice for a real person or entity.\n", "findings": {"as_of": "2026-09-28", "findings": [{"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/07_operating_expenses/049_operating_expenses_control_register.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for rent schedule inconsistency: one source states the operative date is 2025-02-15 under control reference CB-RE-2908-A983, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2025-04-03 under response reference CB-RE-2908-J444.", "id": "F-01", "issue": "rent schedule inconsistency", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/01_leases/001_leases_control_register.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-28, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Farah Ibrahim.", "severity": "critical"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/07_operating_expenses/052_operating_expenses_ledger_export.csv", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for renewal-option notice: one source states the controlling amount is $3,400,699.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $3,647,898.00.", "id": "F-02", "issue": "renewal-option notice", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/01_leases/004_leases_ledger_export.csv", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-28, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Owen Delgado.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/07_operating_expenses/055_operating_expenses_officer_certificate.html", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for exclusive-use conflict: one source states approval is attributed to Theo Laurent as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Isaac Romero and contains no entry for Theo Laurent.", "id": "F-03", "issue": "exclusive-use conflict", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/01_leases/007_leases_officer_certificate.html", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-28, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Lena Varga.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/08_insurance/058_insurance_executed_instrument.txt", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for assignment consent: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-RE-2908-D354, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-RE-2908-M188.", "id": "F-04", "issue": "assignment consent", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/02_amendments/010_amendments_executed_instrument.txt", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-28, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Samuel Kim.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/08_insurance/061_insurance_review_memorandum.json", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for estoppel discrepancy: one source states the applicable location is Oakland County, Michigan, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to Michigan operations outside Oakland County, Michigan.", "id": "F-05", "issue": "estoppel discrepancy", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/02_amendments/013_amendments_review_memorandum.json", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-28, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Maya Ellison.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/08_insurance/064_insurance_status_report.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for survey encroachment: one source states the threshold is 2% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 8% and produced a different exception result.", "id": "F-06", "issue": "survey encroachment", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/02_amendments/016_amendments_status_report.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-28, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Rafael Okafor.", "severity": "low"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/09_notices/067_notices_correspondence.eml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for title exception: one source states formal notice must use notices-hemlock_precision_works@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-iron_gate_capital@example.test.", "id": "F-07", "issue": "title exception", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/03_estoppels/019_estoppels_correspondence.eml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-28, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Nora Chen.", "severity": "critical"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/09_notices/070_notices_formal_notice.xml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for environmental recognized condition: one source states the governed population contains 108 records through 2025-12-09, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 52 records through 2026-01-02.", "id": "F-08", "issue": "environmental recognized condition", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/03_estoppels/022_estoppels_formal_notice.xml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-28, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Dominic Alvarez.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/10_construction/073_construction_control_register.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for zoning nonconformity: one source states the operative date is 2025-07-07 under control reference CB-RE-2908-I585, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2025-08-03 under response reference CB-RE-2908-R760.", "id": "F-09", "issue": "zoning nonconformity", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/04_title_survey/025_title_survey_control_register.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-28, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Priya Raman.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/10_construction/076_construction_ledger_export.csv", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for permit closeout gap: one source states the controlling amount is $1,879,081.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $1,904,662.00.", "id": "F-10", "issue": "permit closeout gap", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/04_title_survey/028_title_survey_ledger_export.csv", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-28, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Elliot Mercer.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/10_construction/079_construction_officer_certificate.html", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for CAM reconciliation error: one source states approval is attributed to Theo Laurent as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Dominic Alvarez and contains no entry for Theo Laurent.", "id": "F-11", "issue": "CAM reconciliation error", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/04_title_survey/031_title_survey_officer_certificate.html", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-28, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Talia Brooks.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/11_financing/082_financing_executed_instrument.txt", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for insurance endorsement deficiency: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-RE-2908-L553, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-RE-2908-U757.", "id": "F-12", "issue": "insurance endorsement deficiency", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/05_environmental/034_environmental_executed_instrument.txt", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-28, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Jonas Feld.", "severity": "low"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/11_financing/085_financing_review_memorandum.json", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for casualty restoration deadline: one source states the applicable location is Oakland County, Michigan, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to Michigan operations outside Oakland County, Michigan.", "id": "F-13", "issue": "casualty restoration deadline", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/05_environmental/037_environmental_review_memorandum.json", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-28, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Mei Whitaker.", "severity": "critical"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/11_financing/088_financing_status_report.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for construction lien notice: one source states the threshold is 14% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 20% and produced a different exception result.", "id": "F-14", "issue": "construction lien notice", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/05_environmental/040_environmental_status_report.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-28, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Caleb Hassan.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/12_property_management/091_property_management_correspondence.eml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for lender SNDA omission: one source states formal notice must use notices-hemlock_precision_works@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-iron_gate_capital@example.test.", "id": "F-15", "issue": "lender SNDA omission", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/043_zoning_permits_correspondence.eml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-28, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Leona Park.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/12_property_management/094_property_management_formal_notice.xml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for security-deposit mismatch: one source states the governed population contains 129 records through 2025-03-25, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 69 records through 2025-05-05.", "id": "F-16", "issue": "security-deposit mismatch", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/046_zoning_permits_formal_notice.xml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-28, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Isaac Romero.", "severity": "medium"}], "matter_number": "CB-RE-2908", "prepared_for": "Hemlock Precision Works", "schema_version": "1.0", "task_id": "cb100-058-hemlock-manufacturing"}}, "metadata": {"benchmark": "CounselBench-100", "code_license": "Apache-2.0", "data_license": "CC-BY-4.0", "deadline": "2026-09-28", "document_count": 96, "jurisdiction": "Michigan", "matter_number": "CB-RE-2908", "mcp_commit": "9a96ea6e5913736f92b88345bf51caeaaa8e719f", "mcp_package": "@modelcontextprotocol/server-filesystem@2026.7.10", "practice_area": "real-estate", "reference_tool_calls": 46, "required_evidence_reads": 33, "synthetic": true, "venue": "Oakland County, Michigan", "version": "2.0.0"}, "prompt": "You are real-estate transactions counsel for Hemlock Precision Works. The supervising attorney wants an exception-focused review that still demonstrates complete coverage of the data room. A manufacturing sale-leaseback includes an environmental condition, equipment liens, roof obligations, and unresolved permit closeout. Decision due 2026-09-28. Michigan law governs; Oakland County, Michigan is the forum. Preserve the difference between the client's position, the counterparty's position, and an objective record conflict. Work out the defensible position from the matter production and leave an audit-ready exception tracker and concise advice for the supervising lawyer. Keep confirmed conflicts separate from open questions, cite the records that actually control each conclusion, and do not fill gaps with outside facts.", "rubric": {"criteria": [{"category": "procedure", "description": "Complete at least 46 successful, argument-specific evidence and output calls.", "id": "procedure.minimum_successful_tool_calls"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Find and read the 33 controlling, corroborating, and work-product-control records in full.", "id": "procedure.all_evidence_read_in_full"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Inspect file metadata for the eight designated critical primary records before relying on them.", "id": "procedure.chain_of_custody_metadata_checked"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Confirm the sandbox's allowed document and output roots.", "id": "procedure.allowed_directories_checked"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Inventory all 96 records so the relevant sources are discovered among the context records.", "id": "procedure.recursive_inventory_completed"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Search the production for email evidence that may corroborate or contradict formal records.", "id": "procedure.targeted_search_completed"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Leave only findings.json and advice.md in the output workspace.", "id": "procedure.exact_deliverable_set"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Create both final work products through the sandbox MCP surface.", "id": "procedure.deliverables_written_through_mcp"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Produce findings.json as a valid JSON object.", "id": "findings.findings_is_object"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Report exactly 16 confirmed exceptions.", "id": "findings.findings_exact_count"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Use each stable finding ID exactly once.", "id": "findings.finding_ids_unique"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set schema_version to the released matter value '1.0'.", "id": "findings.top_level_schema_version"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set task_id to the released matter value 'cb100-058-hemlock-manufacturing'.", "id": "findings.top_level_task_id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set matter_number to the released matter value 'CB-RE-2908'.", "id": "findings.top_level_matter_number"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set prepared_for to the released matter value 'Hemlock Precision Works'.", "id": "findings.top_level_prepared_for"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set as_of to the released matter value '2026-09-28'.", "id": "findings.top_level_as_of"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-01 exception for rent schedule inconsistency.", "id": "findings.F-01.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's id from /workspace/documents/01_leases/001_leases_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_operating_expenses/049_operating_expenses_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's issue from /workspace/documents/01_leases/001_leases_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_operating_expenses/049_operating_expenses_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's severity from /workspace/documents/01_leases/001_leases_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_operating_expenses/049_operating_expenses_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's primary_source from /workspace/documents/01_leases/001_leases_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_operating_expenses/049_operating_expenses_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/01_leases/001_leases_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_operating_expenses/049_operating_expenses_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-01 using the exact controlled facts ['2025-02-15', 'CB-RE-2908-A983', '2025-04-03', 'CB-RE-2908-J444'].", "id": "findings.F-01.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-01's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-01.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-28', 'Farah Ibrahim'] for F-01.", "id": "findings.F-01.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-02 exception for renewal-option notice.", "id": "findings.F-02.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's id from /workspace/documents/01_leases/004_leases_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_operating_expenses/052_operating_expenses_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's issue from /workspace/documents/01_leases/004_leases_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_operating_expenses/052_operating_expenses_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's severity from /workspace/documents/01_leases/004_leases_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_operating_expenses/052_operating_expenses_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's primary_source from /workspace/documents/01_leases/004_leases_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_operating_expenses/052_operating_expenses_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/01_leases/004_leases_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_operating_expenses/052_operating_expenses_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-02 using the exact controlled facts ['$3,400,699.00', '$3,647,898.00'].", "id": "findings.F-02.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-02's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-02.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-28', 'Owen Delgado'] for F-02.", "id": "findings.F-02.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-03 exception for exclusive-use conflict.", "id": "findings.F-03.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's id from /workspace/documents/01_leases/007_leases_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_operating_expenses/055_operating_expenses_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's issue from /workspace/documents/01_leases/007_leases_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_operating_expenses/055_operating_expenses_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's severity from /workspace/documents/01_leases/007_leases_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_operating_expenses/055_operating_expenses_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's primary_source from /workspace/documents/01_leases/007_leases_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_operating_expenses/055_operating_expenses_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/01_leases/007_leases_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_operating_expenses/055_operating_expenses_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-03 using the exact controlled facts ['Theo Laurent', 'Isaac Romero'].", "id": "findings.F-03.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-03's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-03.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-28', 'Lena Varga'] for F-03.", "id": "findings.F-03.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-04 exception for assignment consent.", "id": "findings.F-04.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's id from /workspace/documents/02_amendments/010_amendments_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_insurance/058_insurance_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's issue from /workspace/documents/02_amendments/010_amendments_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_insurance/058_insurance_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's severity from /workspace/documents/02_amendments/010_amendments_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_insurance/058_insurance_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's primary_source from /workspace/documents/02_amendments/010_amendments_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_insurance/058_insurance_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/02_amendments/010_amendments_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_insurance/058_insurance_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-04 using the exact controlled facts ['closed without exception', 'CB-RE-2908-D354', 'open and escalated', 'CB-RE-2908-M188'].", "id": "findings.F-04.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-04's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-04.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-28', 'Samuel Kim'] for F-04.", "id": "findings.F-04.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-05 exception for estoppel discrepancy.", "id": "findings.F-05.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's id from /workspace/documents/02_amendments/013_amendments_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_insurance/061_insurance_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's issue from /workspace/documents/02_amendments/013_amendments_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_insurance/061_insurance_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's severity from /workspace/documents/02_amendments/013_amendments_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_insurance/061_insurance_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's primary_source from /workspace/documents/02_amendments/013_amendments_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_insurance/061_insurance_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/02_amendments/013_amendments_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_insurance/061_insurance_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-05 using the exact controlled facts ['Oakland County, Michigan', 'Michigan'].", "id": "findings.F-05.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-05's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-05.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-28', 'Maya Ellison'] for F-05.", "id": "findings.F-05.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-06 exception for survey encroachment.", "id": "findings.F-06.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's id from /workspace/documents/02_amendments/016_amendments_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_insurance/064_insurance_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's issue from /workspace/documents/02_amendments/016_amendments_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_insurance/064_insurance_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's severity from /workspace/documents/02_amendments/016_amendments_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_insurance/064_insurance_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's primary_source from /workspace/documents/02_amendments/016_amendments_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_insurance/064_insurance_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/02_amendments/016_amendments_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_insurance/064_insurance_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-06 using the exact controlled facts ['2%', '8%'].", "id": "findings.F-06.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-06's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-06.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-28', 'Rafael Okafor'] for F-06.", "id": "findings.F-06.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-07 exception for title exception.", "id": "findings.F-07.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's id from /workspace/documents/03_estoppels/019_estoppels_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_notices/067_notices_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's issue from /workspace/documents/03_estoppels/019_estoppels_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_notices/067_notices_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's severity from /workspace/documents/03_estoppels/019_estoppels_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_notices/067_notices_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's primary_source from /workspace/documents/03_estoppels/019_estoppels_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_notices/067_notices_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/03_estoppels/019_estoppels_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_notices/067_notices_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-07 using the exact controlled facts ['notices-hemlock_precision_works@example.test', 'archive-iron_gate_capital@example.test'].", "id": "findings.F-07.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-07's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-07.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-28', 'Nora Chen'] for F-07.", "id": "findings.F-07.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-08 exception for environmental recognized condition.", "id": "findings.F-08.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's id from /workspace/documents/03_estoppels/022_estoppels_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_notices/070_notices_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's issue from /workspace/documents/03_estoppels/022_estoppels_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_notices/070_notices_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's severity from /workspace/documents/03_estoppels/022_estoppels_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_notices/070_notices_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's primary_source from /workspace/documents/03_estoppels/022_estoppels_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_notices/070_notices_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/03_estoppels/022_estoppels_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_notices/070_notices_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-08 using the exact controlled facts ['108 records', '2025-12-09', '52 records', '2026-01-02'].", "id": "findings.F-08.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-08's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-08.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-28', 'Dominic Alvarez'] for F-08.", "id": "findings.F-08.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-09 exception for zoning nonconformity.", "id": "findings.F-09.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's id from /workspace/documents/04_title_survey/025_title_survey_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_construction/073_construction_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's issue from /workspace/documents/04_title_survey/025_title_survey_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_construction/073_construction_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's severity from /workspace/documents/04_title_survey/025_title_survey_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_construction/073_construction_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's primary_source from /workspace/documents/04_title_survey/025_title_survey_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_construction/073_construction_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/04_title_survey/025_title_survey_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_construction/073_construction_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-09 using the exact controlled facts ['2025-07-07', 'CB-RE-2908-I585', '2025-08-03', 'CB-RE-2908-R760'].", "id": "findings.F-09.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-09's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-09.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-28', 'Priya Raman'] for F-09.", "id": "findings.F-09.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-10 exception for permit closeout gap.", "id": "findings.F-10.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's id from /workspace/documents/04_title_survey/028_title_survey_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_construction/076_construction_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's issue from /workspace/documents/04_title_survey/028_title_survey_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_construction/076_construction_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's severity from /workspace/documents/04_title_survey/028_title_survey_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_construction/076_construction_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's primary_source from /workspace/documents/04_title_survey/028_title_survey_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_construction/076_construction_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/04_title_survey/028_title_survey_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_construction/076_construction_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-10 using the exact controlled facts ['$1,879,081.00', '$1,904,662.00'].", "id": "findings.F-10.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-10's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-10.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-28', 'Elliot Mercer'] for F-10.", "id": "findings.F-10.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-11 exception for CAM reconciliation error.", "id": "findings.F-11.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's id from /workspace/documents/04_title_survey/031_title_survey_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_construction/079_construction_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's issue from /workspace/documents/04_title_survey/031_title_survey_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_construction/079_construction_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's severity from /workspace/documents/04_title_survey/031_title_survey_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_construction/079_construction_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's primary_source from /workspace/documents/04_title_survey/031_title_survey_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_construction/079_construction_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/04_title_survey/031_title_survey_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_construction/079_construction_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-11 using the exact controlled facts ['Theo Laurent', 'Dominic Alvarez'].", "id": "findings.F-11.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-11's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-11.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-28', 'Talia Brooks'] for F-11.", "id": "findings.F-11.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-12 exception for insurance endorsement deficiency.", "id": "findings.F-12.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's id from /workspace/documents/05_environmental/034_environmental_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_financing/082_financing_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's issue from /workspace/documents/05_environmental/034_environmental_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_financing/082_financing_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's severity from /workspace/documents/05_environmental/034_environmental_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_financing/082_financing_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's primary_source from /workspace/documents/05_environmental/034_environmental_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_financing/082_financing_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/05_environmental/034_environmental_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_financing/082_financing_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-12 using the exact controlled facts ['closed without exception', 'CB-RE-2908-L553', 'open and escalated', 'CB-RE-2908-U757'].", "id": "findings.F-12.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-12's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-12.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-28', 'Jonas Feld'] for F-12.", "id": "findings.F-12.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-13 exception for casualty restoration deadline.", "id": "findings.F-13.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's id from /workspace/documents/05_environmental/037_environmental_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_financing/085_financing_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's issue from /workspace/documents/05_environmental/037_environmental_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_financing/085_financing_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's severity from /workspace/documents/05_environmental/037_environmental_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_financing/085_financing_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's primary_source from /workspace/documents/05_environmental/037_environmental_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_financing/085_financing_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/05_environmental/037_environmental_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_financing/085_financing_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-13 using the exact controlled facts ['Oakland County, Michigan', 'Michigan'].", "id": "findings.F-13.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-13's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-13.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-28', 'Mei Whitaker'] for F-13.", "id": "findings.F-13.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-14 exception for construction lien notice.", "id": "findings.F-14.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's id from /workspace/documents/05_environmental/040_environmental_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_financing/088_financing_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's issue from /workspace/documents/05_environmental/040_environmental_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_financing/088_financing_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's severity from /workspace/documents/05_environmental/040_environmental_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_financing/088_financing_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's primary_source from /workspace/documents/05_environmental/040_environmental_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_financing/088_financing_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/05_environmental/040_environmental_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_financing/088_financing_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-14 using the exact controlled facts ['14%', '20%'].", "id": "findings.F-14.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-14's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-14.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-28', 'Caleb Hassan'] for F-14.", "id": "findings.F-14.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-15 exception for lender SNDA omission.", "id": "findings.F-15.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's id from /workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/043_zoning_permits_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_property_management/091_property_management_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's issue from /workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/043_zoning_permits_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_property_management/091_property_management_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's severity from /workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/043_zoning_permits_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_property_management/091_property_management_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's primary_source from /workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/043_zoning_permits_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_property_management/091_property_management_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/043_zoning_permits_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_property_management/091_property_management_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-15 using the exact controlled facts ['notices-hemlock_precision_works@example.test', 'archive-iron_gate_capital@example.test'].", "id": "findings.F-15.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-15's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-15.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-28', 'Leona Park'] for F-15.", "id": "findings.F-15.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-16 exception for security-deposit mismatch.", "id": "findings.F-16.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's id from /workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/046_zoning_permits_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_property_management/094_property_management_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's issue from /workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/046_zoning_permits_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_property_management/094_property_management_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's severity from /workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/046_zoning_permits_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_property_management/094_property_management_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's primary_source from /workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/046_zoning_permits_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_property_management/094_property_management_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/046_zoning_permits_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_property_management/094_property_management_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-16 using the exact controlled facts ['129 records', '2025-03-25', '69 records', '2025-05-05'].", "id": "findings.F-16.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-16's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-16.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-28', 'Isaac Romero'] for F-16.", "id": "findings.F-16.action_anchors"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Executive assessment' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Executive assessment"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Method and record coverage' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Method and record coverage"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Findings' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Findings"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Recommended next actions' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Recommended next actions"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Assumptions and limitations' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Assumptions and limitations"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-01 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-01"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-02 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-02"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-03 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-03"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-04 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-04"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-05 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-05"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-06 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-06"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-07 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-07"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-08 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-08"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-09 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-09"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-10 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-10"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-11 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-11"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-12 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-12"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-13 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-13"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-14 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-14"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-15 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-15"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-16 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-16"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Do not claim the production has no issues or that every record is consistent.", "id": "memo.forbidden_claims_absent"}], "decision_options": [{"id": "cross-source-reconciliation", "label": "Reconcile controlling and corroborating records", "reason": "The CB-RE-2908 production contains independently maintained records; a defensible answer must preserve each supported conflict and its cure owner.", "selected": true}, {"id": "latest-record-controls", "label": "Treat the latest record as controlling", "reason": "Timestamp recency does not establish legal priority, execution, or approval authority.", "selected": false}, {"id": "primary-records-only", "label": "Report primary records without reconciliation", "reason": "Primary records alone conceal the operational conflicts that create the actionable exceptions.", "selected": false}], "gates": ["all_evidence_read_in_full", "chain_of_custody_metadata_checked", "findings_criteria_complete", "memo_criteria_complete", "deliverables_written_through_mcp"], "metadata_checks": 8, "metric": "weighted_criteria_score", "minimum_tool_calls": 46, "required_deliverables": ["findings.json", "advice.md"], "required_document_reads": 33, "type": "deterministic", "weights": {"findings": 0.55, "memo": 0.2, "procedure": 0.25}}, "task_id": "cb100-058-hemlock-manufacturing", "task_name": "Hemlock plant sale-leaseback audit", "world_id": "counselbench-filesystem-mcp-v2"}
-{"context_files": ["task_files/cb100-059-ivory-tower/01_leases/001_leases_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-059-ivory-tower/01_leases/002_leases_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-059-ivory-tower/01_leases/003_leases_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-059-ivory-tower/01_leases/004_leases_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-059-ivory-tower/01_leases/005_leases_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-059-ivory-tower/01_leases/006_leases_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-059-ivory-tower/01_leases/007_leases_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-059-ivory-tower/01_leases/008_leases_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-059-ivory-tower/02_amendments/009_amendments_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-059-ivory-tower/02_amendments/010_amendments_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-059-ivory-tower/02_amendments/011_amendments_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-059-ivory-tower/02_amendments/012_amendments_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-059-ivory-tower/02_amendments/013_amendments_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-059-ivory-tower/02_amendments/014_amendments_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-059-ivory-tower/02_amendments/015_amendments_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-059-ivory-tower/02_amendments/016_amendments_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-059-ivory-tower/03_estoppels/017_estoppels_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-059-ivory-tower/03_estoppels/018_estoppels_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-059-ivory-tower/03_estoppels/019_estoppels_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-059-ivory-tower/03_estoppels/020_estoppels_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-059-ivory-tower/03_estoppels/021_estoppels_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-059-ivory-tower/03_estoppels/022_estoppels_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-059-ivory-tower/03_estoppels/023_estoppels_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-059-ivory-tower/03_estoppels/024_estoppels_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-059-ivory-tower/04_title_survey/025_title_survey_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-059-ivory-tower/04_title_survey/026_title_survey_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-059-ivory-tower/04_title_survey/027_title_survey_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-059-ivory-tower/04_title_survey/028_title_survey_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-059-ivory-tower/04_title_survey/029_title_survey_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-059-ivory-tower/04_title_survey/030_title_survey_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-059-ivory-tower/04_title_survey/031_title_survey_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-059-ivory-tower/04_title_survey/032_title_survey_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-059-ivory-tower/05_environmental/033_environmental_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-059-ivory-tower/05_environmental/034_environmental_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-059-ivory-tower/05_environmental/035_environmental_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-059-ivory-tower/05_environmental/036_environmental_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-059-ivory-tower/05_environmental/037_environmental_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-059-ivory-tower/05_environmental/038_environmental_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-059-ivory-tower/05_environmental/039_environmental_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-059-ivory-tower/05_environmental/040_environmental_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-059-ivory-tower/06_zoning_permits/041_zoning_permits_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-059-ivory-tower/06_zoning_permits/042_zoning_permits_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-059-ivory-tower/06_zoning_permits/043_zoning_permits_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-059-ivory-tower/06_zoning_permits/044_zoning_permits_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-059-ivory-tower/06_zoning_permits/045_zoning_permits_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-059-ivory-tower/06_zoning_permits/046_zoning_permits_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-059-ivory-tower/06_zoning_permits/047_zoning_permits_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-059-ivory-tower/06_zoning_permits/048_zoning_permits_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-059-ivory-tower/07_operating_expenses/049_operating_expenses_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-059-ivory-tower/07_operating_expenses/050_operating_expenses_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-059-ivory-tower/07_operating_expenses/051_operating_expenses_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-059-ivory-tower/07_operating_expenses/052_operating_expenses_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-059-ivory-tower/07_operating_expenses/053_operating_expenses_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-059-ivory-tower/07_operating_expenses/054_operating_expenses_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-059-ivory-tower/07_operating_expenses/055_operating_expenses_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-059-ivory-tower/07_operating_expenses/056_operating_expenses_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-059-ivory-tower/08_insurance/057_insurance_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-059-ivory-tower/08_insurance/058_insurance_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-059-ivory-tower/08_insurance/059_insurance_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-059-ivory-tower/08_insurance/060_insurance_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-059-ivory-tower/08_insurance/061_insurance_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-059-ivory-tower/08_insurance/062_insurance_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-059-ivory-tower/08_insurance/063_insurance_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-059-ivory-tower/08_insurance/064_insurance_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-059-ivory-tower/09_notices/065_notices_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-059-ivory-tower/09_notices/066_notices_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-059-ivory-tower/09_notices/067_notices_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-059-ivory-tower/09_notices/068_notices_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-059-ivory-tower/09_notices/069_notices_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-059-ivory-tower/09_notices/070_notices_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-059-ivory-tower/09_notices/071_notices_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-059-ivory-tower/09_notices/072_notices_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-059-ivory-tower/10_construction/073_construction_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-059-ivory-tower/10_construction/074_construction_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-059-ivory-tower/10_construction/075_construction_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-059-ivory-tower/10_construction/076_construction_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-059-ivory-tower/10_construction/077_construction_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-059-ivory-tower/10_construction/078_construction_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-059-ivory-tower/10_construction/079_construction_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-059-ivory-tower/10_construction/080_construction_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-059-ivory-tower/11_financing/081_financing_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-059-ivory-tower/11_financing/082_financing_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-059-ivory-tower/11_financing/083_financing_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-059-ivory-tower/11_financing/084_financing_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-059-ivory-tower/11_financing/085_financing_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-059-ivory-tower/11_financing/086_financing_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-059-ivory-tower/11_financing/087_financing_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-059-ivory-tower/11_financing/088_financing_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-059-ivory-tower/12_property_management/089_property_management_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-059-ivory-tower/12_property_management/090_property_management_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-059-ivory-tower/12_property_management/091_property_management_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-059-ivory-tower/12_property_management/092_property_management_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-059-ivory-tower/12_property_management/093_property_management_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-059-ivory-tower/12_property_management/094_property_management_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-059-ivory-tower/12_property_management/095_property_management_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-059-ivory-tower/12_property_management/096_property_management_status_report.md"], "gold_output": {"advice_markdown": "# Counsel advice — Ivory Tower office sublease reconciliation\n\n## Executive assessment\n\nFor Ivory Tower Software matter CB-RE-2909, the review identified 16 source-supported exceptions requiring action before 2026-10-01. The assessment concerns Metropolitan Workspace Holdings and the supplied record for New York.\n\n## Method and record coverage\n\nThe review inventoried all 96 production files, read the 33 controlling, corroborating, and control records, searched the email exports, and checked metadata for the designated chain-of-custody sample. Conclusions are limited to the synthetic production supplied for this benchmark matter.\n\n## Findings\n\n### F-01 — rent schedule inconsistency (critical)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for rent schedule inconsistency: one source states the operative date is 2025-08-31 under control reference CB-RE-2909-A940, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2025-09-20 under response reference CB-RE-2909-J510.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/01_leases/001_leases_control_register.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/07_operating_expenses/049_operating_expenses_control_register.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-10-01, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Owen Delgado.\n\n### F-02 — renewal-option notice (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for renewal-option notice: one source states the controlling amount is $6,260,914.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $6,488,328.00.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/01_leases/004_leases_ledger_export.csv`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/07_operating_expenses/052_operating_expenses_ledger_export.csv`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-10-01, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Lena Varga.\n\n### F-03 — exclusive-use conflict (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for exclusive-use conflict: one source states approval is attributed to Amara Patel as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Adrian Mensah and contains no entry for Amara Patel.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/01_leases/007_leases_officer_certificate.html`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/07_operating_expenses/055_operating_expenses_officer_certificate.html`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-10-01, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Samuel Kim.\n\n### F-04 — assignment consent (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for assignment consent: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-RE-2909-D516, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-RE-2909-M270.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/02_amendments/010_amendments_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/08_insurance/058_insurance_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-10-01, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Maya Ellison.\n\n### F-05 — estoppel discrepancy (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for estoppel discrepancy: one source states the applicable location is New York County, New York, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to New York operations outside New York County, New York.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/02_amendments/013_amendments_review_memorandum.json`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/08_insurance/061_insurance_review_memorandum.json`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-10-01, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Rafael Okafor.\n\n### F-06 — survey encroachment (low)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for survey encroachment: one source states the threshold is 15% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 18% and produced a different exception result.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/02_amendments/016_amendments_status_report.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/08_insurance/064_insurance_status_report.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-10-01, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Nora Chen.\n\n### F-07 — title exception (critical)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for title exception: one source states formal notice must use notices-ivory_tower_software@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-metropolitan_workspace_holdings@example.test.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/03_estoppels/019_estoppels_correspondence.eml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/09_notices/067_notices_correspondence.eml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-10-01, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Dominic Alvarez.\n\n### F-08 — environmental recognized condition (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for environmental recognized condition: one source states the governed population contains 178 records through 2025-05-13, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 59 records through 2025-06-13.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/03_estoppels/022_estoppels_formal_notice.xml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/09_notices/070_notices_formal_notice.xml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-10-01, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Priya Raman.\n\n### F-09 — zoning nonconformity (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for zoning nonconformity: one source states the operative date is 2025-08-12 under control reference CB-RE-2909-I441, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2025-09-11 under response reference CB-RE-2909-R403.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/04_title_survey/025_title_survey_control_register.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/10_construction/073_construction_control_register.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-10-01, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Elliot Mercer.\n\n### F-10 — permit closeout gap (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for permit closeout gap: one source states the controlling amount is $6,432,470.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $6,751,440.00.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/04_title_survey/028_title_survey_ledger_export.csv`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/10_construction/076_construction_ledger_export.csv`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-10-01, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Talia Brooks.\n\n### F-11 — CAM reconciliation error (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for CAM reconciliation error: one source states approval is attributed to Amara Patel as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Elliot Mercer and contains no entry for Amara Patel.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/04_title_survey/031_title_survey_officer_certificate.html`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/10_construction/079_construction_officer_certificate.html`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-10-01, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Jonas Feld.\n\n### F-12 — insurance endorsement deficiency (low)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for insurance endorsement deficiency: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-RE-2909-L790, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-RE-2909-U291.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/05_environmental/034_environmental_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/11_financing/082_financing_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-10-01, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Mei Whitaker.\n\n### F-13 — casualty restoration deadline (critical)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for casualty restoration deadline: one source states the applicable location is New York County, New York, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to New York operations outside New York County, New York.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/05_environmental/037_environmental_review_memorandum.json`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/11_financing/085_financing_review_memorandum.json`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-10-01, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Caleb Hassan.\n\n### F-14 — construction lien notice (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for construction lien notice: one source states the threshold is 6% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 8% and produced a different exception result.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/05_environmental/040_environmental_status_report.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/11_financing/088_financing_status_report.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-10-01, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Leona Park.\n\n### F-15 — lender SNDA omission (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for lender SNDA omission: one source states formal notice must use notices-ivory_tower_software@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-metropolitan_workspace_holdings@example.test.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/043_zoning_permits_correspondence.eml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/12_property_management/091_property_management_correspondence.eml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-10-01, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Isaac Romero.\n\n### F-16 — security-deposit mismatch (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for security-deposit mismatch: one source states the governed population contains 113 records through 2025-12-14, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 68 records through 2026-01-23.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/046_zoning_permits_formal_notice.xml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/12_property_management/094_property_management_formal_notice.xml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-10-01, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Sofia Bennett.\n\n## Recommended next actions\n\nSequence the critical and high findings first, assign the named owners, preserve the cited records, and document any resolution in the controlling matter register before the stated deadline.\n\n## Assumptions and limitations\n\nThis analysis is confined to task cb100-059-ivory-tower and the supplied synthetic evidence. It does not rely on external facts, does not resolve disputed law, and is not legal advice for a real person or entity.\n", "findings": {"as_of": "2026-10-01", "findings": [{"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/07_operating_expenses/049_operating_expenses_control_register.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for rent schedule inconsistency: one source states the operative date is 2025-08-31 under control reference CB-RE-2909-A940, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2025-09-20 under response reference CB-RE-2909-J510.", "id": "F-01", "issue": "rent schedule inconsistency", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/01_leases/001_leases_control_register.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-10-01, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Owen Delgado.", "severity": "critical"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/07_operating_expenses/052_operating_expenses_ledger_export.csv", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for renewal-option notice: one source states the controlling amount is $6,260,914.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $6,488,328.00.", "id": "F-02", "issue": "renewal-option notice", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/01_leases/004_leases_ledger_export.csv", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-10-01, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Lena Varga.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/07_operating_expenses/055_operating_expenses_officer_certificate.html", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for exclusive-use conflict: one source states approval is attributed to Amara Patel as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Adrian Mensah and contains no entry for Amara Patel.", "id": "F-03", "issue": "exclusive-use conflict", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/01_leases/007_leases_officer_certificate.html", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-10-01, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Samuel Kim.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/08_insurance/058_insurance_executed_instrument.txt", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for assignment consent: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-RE-2909-D516, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-RE-2909-M270.", "id": "F-04", "issue": "assignment consent", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/02_amendments/010_amendments_executed_instrument.txt", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-10-01, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Maya Ellison.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/08_insurance/061_insurance_review_memorandum.json", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for estoppel discrepancy: one source states the applicable location is New York County, New York, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to New York operations outside New York County, New York.", "id": "F-05", "issue": "estoppel discrepancy", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/02_amendments/013_amendments_review_memorandum.json", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-10-01, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Rafael Okafor.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/08_insurance/064_insurance_status_report.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for survey encroachment: one source states the threshold is 15% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 18% and produced a different exception result.", "id": "F-06", "issue": "survey encroachment", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/02_amendments/016_amendments_status_report.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-10-01, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Nora Chen.", "severity": "low"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/09_notices/067_notices_correspondence.eml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for title exception: one source states formal notice must use notices-ivory_tower_software@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-metropolitan_workspace_holdings@example.test.", "id": "F-07", "issue": "title exception", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/03_estoppels/019_estoppels_correspondence.eml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-10-01, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Dominic Alvarez.", "severity": "critical"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/09_notices/070_notices_formal_notice.xml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for environmental recognized condition: one source states the governed population contains 178 records through 2025-05-13, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 59 records through 2025-06-13.", "id": "F-08", "issue": "environmental recognized condition", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/03_estoppels/022_estoppels_formal_notice.xml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-10-01, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Priya Raman.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/10_construction/073_construction_control_register.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for zoning nonconformity: one source states the operative date is 2025-08-12 under control reference CB-RE-2909-I441, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2025-09-11 under response reference CB-RE-2909-R403.", "id": "F-09", "issue": "zoning nonconformity", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/04_title_survey/025_title_survey_control_register.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-10-01, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Elliot Mercer.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/10_construction/076_construction_ledger_export.csv", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for permit closeout gap: one source states the controlling amount is $6,432,470.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $6,751,440.00.", "id": "F-10", "issue": "permit closeout gap", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/04_title_survey/028_title_survey_ledger_export.csv", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-10-01, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Talia Brooks.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/10_construction/079_construction_officer_certificate.html", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for CAM reconciliation error: one source states approval is attributed to Amara Patel as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Elliot Mercer and contains no entry for Amara Patel.", "id": "F-11", "issue": "CAM reconciliation error", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/04_title_survey/031_title_survey_officer_certificate.html", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-10-01, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Jonas Feld.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/11_financing/082_financing_executed_instrument.txt", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for insurance endorsement deficiency: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-RE-2909-L790, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-RE-2909-U291.", "id": "F-12", "issue": "insurance endorsement deficiency", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/05_environmental/034_environmental_executed_instrument.txt", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-10-01, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Mei Whitaker.", "severity": "low"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/11_financing/085_financing_review_memorandum.json", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for casualty restoration deadline: one source states the applicable location is New York County, New York, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to New York operations outside New York County, New York.", "id": "F-13", "issue": "casualty restoration deadline", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/05_environmental/037_environmental_review_memorandum.json", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-10-01, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Caleb Hassan.", "severity": "critical"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/11_financing/088_financing_status_report.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for construction lien notice: one source states the threshold is 6% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 8% and produced a different exception result.", "id": "F-14", "issue": "construction lien notice", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/05_environmental/040_environmental_status_report.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-10-01, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Leona Park.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/12_property_management/091_property_management_correspondence.eml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for lender SNDA omission: one source states formal notice must use notices-ivory_tower_software@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-metropolitan_workspace_holdings@example.test.", "id": "F-15", "issue": "lender SNDA omission", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/043_zoning_permits_correspondence.eml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-10-01, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Isaac Romero.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/12_property_management/094_property_management_formal_notice.xml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for security-deposit mismatch: one source states the governed population contains 113 records through 2025-12-14, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 68 records through 2026-01-23.", "id": "F-16", "issue": "security-deposit mismatch", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/046_zoning_permits_formal_notice.xml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-10-01, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Sofia Bennett.", "severity": "medium"}], "matter_number": "CB-RE-2909", "prepared_for": "Ivory Tower Software", "schema_version": "1.0", "task_id": "cb100-059-ivory-tower"}}, "metadata": {"benchmark": "CounselBench-100", "code_license": "Apache-2.0", "data_license": "CC-BY-4.0", "deadline": "2026-10-01", "document_count": 96, "jurisdiction": "New York", "matter_number": "CB-RE-2909", "mcp_commit": "9a96ea6e5913736f92b88345bf51caeaaa8e719f", "mcp_package": "@modelcontextprotocol/server-filesystem@2026.7.10", "practice_area": "real-estate", "reference_tool_calls": 46, "required_evidence_reads": 33, "synthetic": true, "venue": "New York County, New York", "version": "2.0.0"}, "prompt": "You are real-estate transactions counsel for Ivory Tower Software. This matter will be reviewed by legal, finance, and compliance stakeholders who need a single source-grounded output. A headquarters sublease has consent conditions, restoration obligations, rent abatements, and notices delivered under obsolete instructions. Decision due 2026-10-01. New York law governs; New York County, New York is the forum. Use the production as of the stated deadline; do not assume facts outside the supplied files. Work out the defensible position from the matter production and leave an audit-ready exception tracker and concise advice for the supervising lawyer. Keep confirmed conflicts separate from open questions, cite the records that actually control each conclusion, and do not fill gaps with outside facts.", "rubric": {"criteria": [{"category": "procedure", "description": "Complete at least 46 successful, argument-specific evidence and output calls.", "id": "procedure.minimum_successful_tool_calls"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Find and read the 33 controlling, corroborating, and work-product-control records in full.", "id": "procedure.all_evidence_read_in_full"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Inspect file metadata for the eight designated critical primary records before relying on them.", "id": "procedure.chain_of_custody_metadata_checked"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Confirm the sandbox's allowed document and output roots.", "id": "procedure.allowed_directories_checked"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Inventory all 96 records so the relevant sources are discovered among the context records.", "id": "procedure.recursive_inventory_completed"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Search the production for email evidence that may corroborate or contradict formal records.", "id": "procedure.targeted_search_completed"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Leave only findings.json and advice.md in the output workspace.", "id": "procedure.exact_deliverable_set"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Create both final work products through the sandbox MCP surface.", "id": "procedure.deliverables_written_through_mcp"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Produce findings.json as a valid JSON object.", "id": "findings.findings_is_object"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Report exactly 16 confirmed exceptions.", "id": "findings.findings_exact_count"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Use each stable finding ID exactly once.", "id": "findings.finding_ids_unique"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set schema_version to the released matter value '1.0'.", "id": "findings.top_level_schema_version"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set task_id to the released matter value 'cb100-059-ivory-tower'.", "id": "findings.top_level_task_id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set matter_number to the released matter value 'CB-RE-2909'.", "id": "findings.top_level_matter_number"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set prepared_for to the released matter value 'Ivory Tower Software'.", "id": "findings.top_level_prepared_for"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set as_of to the released matter value '2026-10-01'.", "id": "findings.top_level_as_of"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-01 exception for rent schedule inconsistency.", "id": "findings.F-01.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's id from /workspace/documents/01_leases/001_leases_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_operating_expenses/049_operating_expenses_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's issue from /workspace/documents/01_leases/001_leases_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_operating_expenses/049_operating_expenses_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's severity from /workspace/documents/01_leases/001_leases_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_operating_expenses/049_operating_expenses_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's primary_source from /workspace/documents/01_leases/001_leases_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_operating_expenses/049_operating_expenses_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/01_leases/001_leases_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_operating_expenses/049_operating_expenses_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-01 using the exact controlled facts ['2025-08-31', 'CB-RE-2909-A940', '2025-09-20', 'CB-RE-2909-J510'].", "id": "findings.F-01.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-01's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-01.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-10-01', 'Owen Delgado'] for F-01.", "id": "findings.F-01.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-02 exception for renewal-option notice.", "id": "findings.F-02.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's id from /workspace/documents/01_leases/004_leases_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_operating_expenses/052_operating_expenses_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's issue from /workspace/documents/01_leases/004_leases_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_operating_expenses/052_operating_expenses_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's severity from /workspace/documents/01_leases/004_leases_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_operating_expenses/052_operating_expenses_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's primary_source from /workspace/documents/01_leases/004_leases_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_operating_expenses/052_operating_expenses_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/01_leases/004_leases_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_operating_expenses/052_operating_expenses_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-02 using the exact controlled facts ['$6,260,914.00', '$6,488,328.00'].", "id": "findings.F-02.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-02's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-02.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-10-01', 'Lena Varga'] for F-02.", "id": "findings.F-02.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-03 exception for exclusive-use conflict.", "id": "findings.F-03.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's id from /workspace/documents/01_leases/007_leases_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_operating_expenses/055_operating_expenses_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's issue from /workspace/documents/01_leases/007_leases_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_operating_expenses/055_operating_expenses_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's severity from /workspace/documents/01_leases/007_leases_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_operating_expenses/055_operating_expenses_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's primary_source from /workspace/documents/01_leases/007_leases_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_operating_expenses/055_operating_expenses_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/01_leases/007_leases_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_operating_expenses/055_operating_expenses_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-03 using the exact controlled facts ['Amara Patel', 'Adrian Mensah'].", "id": "findings.F-03.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-03's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-03.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-10-01', 'Samuel Kim'] for F-03.", "id": "findings.F-03.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-04 exception for assignment consent.", "id": "findings.F-04.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's id from /workspace/documents/02_amendments/010_amendments_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_insurance/058_insurance_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's issue from /workspace/documents/02_amendments/010_amendments_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_insurance/058_insurance_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's severity from /workspace/documents/02_amendments/010_amendments_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_insurance/058_insurance_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's primary_source from /workspace/documents/02_amendments/010_amendments_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_insurance/058_insurance_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/02_amendments/010_amendments_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_insurance/058_insurance_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-04 using the exact controlled facts ['closed without exception', 'CB-RE-2909-D516', 'open and escalated', 'CB-RE-2909-M270'].", "id": "findings.F-04.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-04's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-04.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-10-01', 'Maya Ellison'] for F-04.", "id": "findings.F-04.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-05 exception for estoppel discrepancy.", "id": "findings.F-05.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's id from /workspace/documents/02_amendments/013_amendments_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_insurance/061_insurance_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's issue from /workspace/documents/02_amendments/013_amendments_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_insurance/061_insurance_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's severity from /workspace/documents/02_amendments/013_amendments_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_insurance/061_insurance_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's primary_source from /workspace/documents/02_amendments/013_amendments_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_insurance/061_insurance_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/02_amendments/013_amendments_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_insurance/061_insurance_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-05 using the exact controlled facts ['New York County, New York', 'New York'].", "id": "findings.F-05.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-05's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-05.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-10-01', 'Rafael Okafor'] for F-05.", "id": "findings.F-05.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-06 exception for survey encroachment.", "id": "findings.F-06.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's id from /workspace/documents/02_amendments/016_amendments_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_insurance/064_insurance_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's issue from /workspace/documents/02_amendments/016_amendments_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_insurance/064_insurance_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's severity from /workspace/documents/02_amendments/016_amendments_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_insurance/064_insurance_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's primary_source from /workspace/documents/02_amendments/016_amendments_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_insurance/064_insurance_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/02_amendments/016_amendments_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_insurance/064_insurance_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-06 using the exact controlled facts ['15%', '18%'].", "id": "findings.F-06.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-06's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-06.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-10-01', 'Nora Chen'] for F-06.", "id": "findings.F-06.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-07 exception for title exception.", "id": "findings.F-07.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's id from /workspace/documents/03_estoppels/019_estoppels_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_notices/067_notices_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's issue from /workspace/documents/03_estoppels/019_estoppels_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_notices/067_notices_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's severity from /workspace/documents/03_estoppels/019_estoppels_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_notices/067_notices_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's primary_source from /workspace/documents/03_estoppels/019_estoppels_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_notices/067_notices_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/03_estoppels/019_estoppels_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_notices/067_notices_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-07 using the exact controlled facts ['notices-ivory_tower_software@example.test', 'archive-metropolitan_workspace_holdings@example.test'].", "id": "findings.F-07.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-07's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-07.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-10-01', 'Dominic Alvarez'] for F-07.", "id": "findings.F-07.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-08 exception for environmental recognized condition.", "id": "findings.F-08.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's id from /workspace/documents/03_estoppels/022_estoppels_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_notices/070_notices_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's issue from /workspace/documents/03_estoppels/022_estoppels_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_notices/070_notices_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's severity from /workspace/documents/03_estoppels/022_estoppels_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_notices/070_notices_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's primary_source from /workspace/documents/03_estoppels/022_estoppels_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_notices/070_notices_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/03_estoppels/022_estoppels_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_notices/070_notices_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-08 using the exact controlled facts ['178 records', '2025-05-13', '59 records', '2025-06-13'].", "id": "findings.F-08.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-08's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-08.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-10-01', 'Priya Raman'] for F-08.", "id": "findings.F-08.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-09 exception for zoning nonconformity.", "id": "findings.F-09.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's id from /workspace/documents/04_title_survey/025_title_survey_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_construction/073_construction_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's issue from /workspace/documents/04_title_survey/025_title_survey_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_construction/073_construction_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's severity from /workspace/documents/04_title_survey/025_title_survey_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_construction/073_construction_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's primary_source from /workspace/documents/04_title_survey/025_title_survey_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_construction/073_construction_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/04_title_survey/025_title_survey_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_construction/073_construction_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-09 using the exact controlled facts ['2025-08-12', 'CB-RE-2909-I441', '2025-09-11', 'CB-RE-2909-R403'].", "id": "findings.F-09.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-09's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-09.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-10-01', 'Elliot Mercer'] for F-09.", "id": "findings.F-09.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-10 exception for permit closeout gap.", "id": "findings.F-10.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's id from /workspace/documents/04_title_survey/028_title_survey_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_construction/076_construction_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's issue from /workspace/documents/04_title_survey/028_title_survey_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_construction/076_construction_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's severity from /workspace/documents/04_title_survey/028_title_survey_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_construction/076_construction_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's primary_source from /workspace/documents/04_title_survey/028_title_survey_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_construction/076_construction_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/04_title_survey/028_title_survey_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_construction/076_construction_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-10 using the exact controlled facts ['$6,432,470.00', '$6,751,440.00'].", "id": "findings.F-10.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-10's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-10.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-10-01', 'Talia Brooks'] for F-10.", "id": "findings.F-10.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-11 exception for CAM reconciliation error.", "id": "findings.F-11.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's id from /workspace/documents/04_title_survey/031_title_survey_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_construction/079_construction_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's issue from /workspace/documents/04_title_survey/031_title_survey_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_construction/079_construction_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's severity from /workspace/documents/04_title_survey/031_title_survey_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_construction/079_construction_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's primary_source from /workspace/documents/04_title_survey/031_title_survey_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_construction/079_construction_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/04_title_survey/031_title_survey_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_construction/079_construction_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-11 using the exact controlled facts ['Amara Patel', 'Elliot Mercer'].", "id": "findings.F-11.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-11's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-11.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-10-01', 'Jonas Feld'] for F-11.", "id": "findings.F-11.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-12 exception for insurance endorsement deficiency.", "id": "findings.F-12.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's id from /workspace/documents/05_environmental/034_environmental_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_financing/082_financing_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's issue from /workspace/documents/05_environmental/034_environmental_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_financing/082_financing_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's severity from /workspace/documents/05_environmental/034_environmental_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_financing/082_financing_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's primary_source from /workspace/documents/05_environmental/034_environmental_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_financing/082_financing_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/05_environmental/034_environmental_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_financing/082_financing_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-12 using the exact controlled facts ['closed without exception', 'CB-RE-2909-L790', 'open and escalated', 'CB-RE-2909-U291'].", "id": "findings.F-12.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-12's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-12.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-10-01', 'Mei Whitaker'] for F-12.", "id": "findings.F-12.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-13 exception for casualty restoration deadline.", "id": "findings.F-13.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's id from /workspace/documents/05_environmental/037_environmental_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_financing/085_financing_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's issue from /workspace/documents/05_environmental/037_environmental_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_financing/085_financing_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's severity from /workspace/documents/05_environmental/037_environmental_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_financing/085_financing_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's primary_source from /workspace/documents/05_environmental/037_environmental_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_financing/085_financing_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/05_environmental/037_environmental_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_financing/085_financing_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-13 using the exact controlled facts ['New York County, New York', 'New York'].", "id": "findings.F-13.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-13's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-13.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-10-01', 'Caleb Hassan'] for F-13.", "id": "findings.F-13.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-14 exception for construction lien notice.", "id": "findings.F-14.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's id from /workspace/documents/05_environmental/040_environmental_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_financing/088_financing_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's issue from /workspace/documents/05_environmental/040_environmental_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_financing/088_financing_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's severity from /workspace/documents/05_environmental/040_environmental_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_financing/088_financing_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's primary_source from /workspace/documents/05_environmental/040_environmental_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_financing/088_financing_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/05_environmental/040_environmental_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_financing/088_financing_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-14 using the exact controlled facts ['6%', '8%'].", "id": "findings.F-14.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-14's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-14.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-10-01', 'Leona Park'] for F-14.", "id": "findings.F-14.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-15 exception for lender SNDA omission.", "id": "findings.F-15.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's id from /workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/043_zoning_permits_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_property_management/091_property_management_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's issue from /workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/043_zoning_permits_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_property_management/091_property_management_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's severity from /workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/043_zoning_permits_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_property_management/091_property_management_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's primary_source from /workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/043_zoning_permits_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_property_management/091_property_management_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/043_zoning_permits_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_property_management/091_property_management_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-15 using the exact controlled facts ['notices-ivory_tower_software@example.test', 'archive-metropolitan_workspace_holdings@example.test'].", "id": "findings.F-15.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-15's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-15.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-10-01', 'Isaac Romero'] for F-15.", "id": "findings.F-15.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-16 exception for security-deposit mismatch.", "id": "findings.F-16.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's id from /workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/046_zoning_permits_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_property_management/094_property_management_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's issue from /workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/046_zoning_permits_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_property_management/094_property_management_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's severity from /workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/046_zoning_permits_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_property_management/094_property_management_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's primary_source from /workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/046_zoning_permits_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_property_management/094_property_management_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/046_zoning_permits_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_property_management/094_property_management_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-16 using the exact controlled facts ['113 records', '2025-12-14', '68 records', '2026-01-23'].", "id": "findings.F-16.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-16's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-16.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-10-01', 'Sofia Bennett'] for F-16.", "id": "findings.F-16.action_anchors"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Executive assessment' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Executive assessment"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Method and record coverage' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Method and record coverage"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Findings' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Findings"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Recommended next actions' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Recommended next actions"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Assumptions and limitations' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Assumptions and limitations"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-01 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-01"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-02 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-02"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-03 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-03"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-04 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-04"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-05 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-05"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-06 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-06"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-07 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-07"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-08 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-08"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-09 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-09"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-10 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-10"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-11 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-11"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-12 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-12"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-13 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-13"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-14 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-14"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-15 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-15"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-16 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-16"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Do not claim the production has no issues or that every record is consistent.", "id": "memo.forbidden_claims_absent"}], "decision_options": [{"id": "cross-source-reconciliation", "label": "Reconcile controlling and corroborating records", "reason": "The CB-RE-2909 production contains independently maintained records; a defensible answer must preserve each supported conflict and its cure owner.", "selected": true}, {"id": "latest-record-controls", "label": "Treat the latest record as controlling", "reason": "Timestamp recency does not establish legal priority, execution, or approval authority.", "selected": false}, {"id": "primary-records-only", "label": "Report primary records without reconciliation", "reason": "Primary records alone conceal the operational conflicts that create the actionable exceptions.", "selected": false}], "gates": ["all_evidence_read_in_full", "chain_of_custody_metadata_checked", "findings_criteria_complete", "memo_criteria_complete", "deliverables_written_through_mcp"], "metadata_checks": 8, "metric": "weighted_criteria_score", "minimum_tool_calls": 46, "required_deliverables": ["findings.json", "advice.md"], "required_document_reads": 33, "type": "deterministic", "weights": {"findings": 0.55, "memo": 0.2, "procedure": 0.25}}, "task_id": "cb100-059-ivory-tower", "task_name": "Ivory Tower office sublease reconciliation", "world_id": "counselbench-filesystem-mcp-v2"}
-{"context_files": ["task_files/cb100-060-kestrel-farms/01_leases/001_leases_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-060-kestrel-farms/01_leases/002_leases_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-060-kestrel-farms/01_leases/003_leases_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-060-kestrel-farms/01_leases/004_leases_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-060-kestrel-farms/01_leases/005_leases_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-060-kestrel-farms/01_leases/006_leases_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-060-kestrel-farms/01_leases/007_leases_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-060-kestrel-farms/01_leases/008_leases_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-060-kestrel-farms/02_amendments/009_amendments_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-060-kestrel-farms/02_amendments/010_amendments_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-060-kestrel-farms/02_amendments/011_amendments_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-060-kestrel-farms/02_amendments/012_amendments_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-060-kestrel-farms/02_amendments/013_amendments_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-060-kestrel-farms/02_amendments/014_amendments_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-060-kestrel-farms/02_amendments/015_amendments_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-060-kestrel-farms/02_amendments/016_amendments_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-060-kestrel-farms/03_estoppels/017_estoppels_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-060-kestrel-farms/03_estoppels/018_estoppels_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-060-kestrel-farms/03_estoppels/019_estoppels_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-060-kestrel-farms/03_estoppels/020_estoppels_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-060-kestrel-farms/03_estoppels/021_estoppels_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-060-kestrel-farms/03_estoppels/022_estoppels_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-060-kestrel-farms/03_estoppels/023_estoppels_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-060-kestrel-farms/03_estoppels/024_estoppels_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-060-kestrel-farms/04_title_survey/025_title_survey_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-060-kestrel-farms/04_title_survey/026_title_survey_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-060-kestrel-farms/04_title_survey/027_title_survey_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-060-kestrel-farms/04_title_survey/028_title_survey_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-060-kestrel-farms/04_title_survey/029_title_survey_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-060-kestrel-farms/04_title_survey/030_title_survey_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-060-kestrel-farms/04_title_survey/031_title_survey_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-060-kestrel-farms/04_title_survey/032_title_survey_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-060-kestrel-farms/05_environmental/033_environmental_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-060-kestrel-farms/05_environmental/034_environmental_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-060-kestrel-farms/05_environmental/035_environmental_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-060-kestrel-farms/05_environmental/036_environmental_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-060-kestrel-farms/05_environmental/037_environmental_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-060-kestrel-farms/05_environmental/038_environmental_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-060-kestrel-farms/05_environmental/039_environmental_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-060-kestrel-farms/05_environmental/040_environmental_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-060-kestrel-farms/06_zoning_permits/041_zoning_permits_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-060-kestrel-farms/06_zoning_permits/042_zoning_permits_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-060-kestrel-farms/06_zoning_permits/043_zoning_permits_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-060-kestrel-farms/06_zoning_permits/044_zoning_permits_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-060-kestrel-farms/06_zoning_permits/045_zoning_permits_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-060-kestrel-farms/06_zoning_permits/046_zoning_permits_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-060-kestrel-farms/06_zoning_permits/047_zoning_permits_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-060-kestrel-farms/06_zoning_permits/048_zoning_permits_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-060-kestrel-farms/07_operating_expenses/049_operating_expenses_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-060-kestrel-farms/07_operating_expenses/050_operating_expenses_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-060-kestrel-farms/07_operating_expenses/051_operating_expenses_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-060-kestrel-farms/07_operating_expenses/052_operating_expenses_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-060-kestrel-farms/07_operating_expenses/053_operating_expenses_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-060-kestrel-farms/07_operating_expenses/054_operating_expenses_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-060-kestrel-farms/07_operating_expenses/055_operating_expenses_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-060-kestrel-farms/07_operating_expenses/056_operating_expenses_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-060-kestrel-farms/08_insurance/057_insurance_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-060-kestrel-farms/08_insurance/058_insurance_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-060-kestrel-farms/08_insurance/059_insurance_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-060-kestrel-farms/08_insurance/060_insurance_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-060-kestrel-farms/08_insurance/061_insurance_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-060-kestrel-farms/08_insurance/062_insurance_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-060-kestrel-farms/08_insurance/063_insurance_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-060-kestrel-farms/08_insurance/064_insurance_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-060-kestrel-farms/09_notices/065_notices_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-060-kestrel-farms/09_notices/066_notices_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-060-kestrel-farms/09_notices/067_notices_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-060-kestrel-farms/09_notices/068_notices_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-060-kestrel-farms/09_notices/069_notices_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-060-kestrel-farms/09_notices/070_notices_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-060-kestrel-farms/09_notices/071_notices_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-060-kestrel-farms/09_notices/072_notices_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-060-kestrel-farms/10_construction/073_construction_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-060-kestrel-farms/10_construction/074_construction_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-060-kestrel-farms/10_construction/075_construction_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-060-kestrel-farms/10_construction/076_construction_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-060-kestrel-farms/10_construction/077_construction_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-060-kestrel-farms/10_construction/078_construction_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-060-kestrel-farms/10_construction/079_construction_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-060-kestrel-farms/10_construction/080_construction_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-060-kestrel-farms/11_financing/081_financing_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-060-kestrel-farms/11_financing/082_financing_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-060-kestrel-farms/11_financing/083_financing_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-060-kestrel-farms/11_financing/084_financing_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-060-kestrel-farms/11_financing/085_financing_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-060-kestrel-farms/11_financing/086_financing_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-060-kestrel-farms/11_financing/087_financing_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-060-kestrel-farms/11_financing/088_financing_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-060-kestrel-farms/12_property_management/089_property_management_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-060-kestrel-farms/12_property_management/090_property_management_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-060-kestrel-farms/12_property_management/091_property_management_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-060-kestrel-farms/12_property_management/092_property_management_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-060-kestrel-farms/12_property_management/093_property_management_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-060-kestrel-farms/12_property_management/094_property_management_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-060-kestrel-farms/12_property_management/095_property_management_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-060-kestrel-farms/12_property_management/096_property_management_status_report.md"], "gold_output": {"advice_markdown": "# Counsel advice — Kestrel agricultural land portfolio audit\n\n## Executive assessment\n\nFor Kestrel Farms Cooperative matter CB-RE-2910, the review identified 16 source-supported exceptions requiring action before 2026-10-05. The assessment concerns Rainshadow Land Trust and the supplied record for Washington.\n\n## Method and record coverage\n\nThe review inventoried all 96 production files, read the 33 controlling, corroborating, and control records, searched the email exports, and checked metadata for the designated chain-of-custody sample. Conclusions are limited to the synthetic production supplied for this benchmark matter.\n\n## Findings\n\n### F-01 — rent schedule inconsistency (critical)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for rent schedule inconsistency: one source states the operative date is 2025-08-27 under control reference CB-RE-2910-A516, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2025-10-13 under response reference CB-RE-2910-J755.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/01_leases/001_leases_control_register.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/07_operating_expenses/049_operating_expenses_control_register.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-10-05, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Lena Varga.\n\n### F-02 — renewal-option notice (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for renewal-option notice: one source states the controlling amount is $4,358,042.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $4,622,584.00.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/01_leases/004_leases_ledger_export.csv`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/07_operating_expenses/052_operating_expenses_ledger_export.csv`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-10-05, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Samuel Kim.\n\n### F-03 — exclusive-use conflict (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for exclusive-use conflict: one source states approval is attributed to Henry Cho as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Theo Laurent and contains no entry for Henry Cho.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/01_leases/007_leases_officer_certificate.html`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/07_operating_expenses/055_operating_expenses_officer_certificate.html`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-10-05, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Maya Ellison.\n\n### F-04 — assignment consent (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for assignment consent: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-RE-2910-D733, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-RE-2910-M979.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/02_amendments/010_amendments_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/08_insurance/058_insurance_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-10-05, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Rafael Okafor.\n\n### F-05 — estoppel discrepancy (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for estoppel discrepancy: one source states the applicable location is Yakima County, Washington, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to Washington operations outside Yakima County, Washington.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/02_amendments/013_amendments_review_memorandum.json`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/08_insurance/061_insurance_review_memorandum.json`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-10-05, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Nora Chen.\n\n### F-06 — survey encroachment (low)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for survey encroachment: one source states the threshold is 9% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 16% and produced a different exception result.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/02_amendments/016_amendments_status_report.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/08_insurance/064_insurance_status_report.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-10-05, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Dominic Alvarez.\n\n### F-07 — title exception (critical)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for title exception: one source states formal notice must use notices-kestrel_farms_cooperative@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-rainshadow_land_trust@example.test.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/03_estoppels/019_estoppels_correspondence.eml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/09_notices/067_notices_correspondence.eml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-10-05, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Priya Raman.\n\n### F-08 — environmental recognized condition (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for environmental recognized condition: one source states the governed population contains 161 records through 2026-01-31, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 45 records through 2026-02-17.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/03_estoppels/022_estoppels_formal_notice.xml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/09_notices/070_notices_formal_notice.xml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-10-05, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Elliot Mercer.\n\n### F-09 — zoning nonconformity (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for zoning nonconformity: one source states the operative date is 2025-04-24 under control reference CB-RE-2910-I511, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2025-05-15 under response reference CB-RE-2910-R616.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/04_title_survey/025_title_survey_control_register.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/10_construction/073_construction_control_register.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-10-05, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Talia Brooks.\n\n### F-10 — permit closeout gap (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for permit closeout gap: one source states the controlling amount is $3,584,649.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $3,745,798.00.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/04_title_survey/028_title_survey_ledger_export.csv`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/10_construction/076_construction_ledger_export.csv`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-10-05, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Jonas Feld.\n\n### F-11 — CAM reconciliation error (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for CAM reconciliation error: one source states approval is attributed to Henry Cho as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Jonas Feld and contains no entry for Henry Cho.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/04_title_survey/031_title_survey_officer_certificate.html`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/10_construction/079_construction_officer_certificate.html`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-10-05, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Mei Whitaker.\n\n### F-12 — insurance endorsement deficiency (low)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for insurance endorsement deficiency: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-RE-2910-L455, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-RE-2910-U958.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/05_environmental/034_environmental_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/11_financing/082_financing_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-10-05, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Caleb Hassan.\n\n### F-13 — casualty restoration deadline (critical)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for casualty restoration deadline: one source states the applicable location is Yakima County, Washington, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to Washington operations outside Yakima County, Washington.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/05_environmental/037_environmental_review_memorandum.json`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/11_financing/085_financing_review_memorandum.json`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-10-05, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Leona Park.\n\n### F-14 — construction lien notice (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for construction lien notice: one source states the threshold is 8% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 14% and produced a different exception result.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/05_environmental/040_environmental_status_report.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/11_financing/088_financing_status_report.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-10-05, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Isaac Romero.\n\n### F-15 — lender SNDA omission (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for lender SNDA omission: one source states formal notice must use notices-kestrel_farms_cooperative@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-rainshadow_land_trust@example.test.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/043_zoning_permits_correspondence.eml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/12_property_management/091_property_management_correspondence.eml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-10-05, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Sofia Bennett.\n\n### F-16 — security-deposit mismatch (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for security-deposit mismatch: one source states the governed population contains 180 records through 2026-02-19, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 57 records through 2026-03-20.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/046_zoning_permits_formal_notice.xml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/12_property_management/094_property_management_formal_notice.xml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-10-05, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Adrian Mensah.\n\n## Recommended next actions\n\nSequence the critical and high findings first, assign the named owners, preserve the cited records, and document any resolution in the controlling matter register before the stated deadline.\n\n## Assumptions and limitations\n\nThis analysis is confined to task cb100-060-kestrel-farms and the supplied synthetic evidence. It does not rely on external facts, does not resolve disputed law, and is not legal advice for a real person or entity.\n", "findings": {"as_of": "2026-10-05", "findings": [{"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/07_operating_expenses/049_operating_expenses_control_register.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for rent schedule inconsistency: one source states the operative date is 2025-08-27 under control reference CB-RE-2910-A516, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2025-10-13 under response reference CB-RE-2910-J755.", "id": "F-01", "issue": "rent schedule inconsistency", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/01_leases/001_leases_control_register.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-10-05, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Lena Varga.", "severity": "critical"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/07_operating_expenses/052_operating_expenses_ledger_export.csv", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for renewal-option notice: one source states the controlling amount is $4,358,042.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $4,622,584.00.", "id": "F-02", "issue": "renewal-option notice", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/01_leases/004_leases_ledger_export.csv", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-10-05, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Samuel Kim.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/07_operating_expenses/055_operating_expenses_officer_certificate.html", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for exclusive-use conflict: one source states approval is attributed to Henry Cho as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Theo Laurent and contains no entry for Henry Cho.", "id": "F-03", "issue": "exclusive-use conflict", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/01_leases/007_leases_officer_certificate.html", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-10-05, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Maya Ellison.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/08_insurance/058_insurance_executed_instrument.txt", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for assignment consent: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-RE-2910-D733, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-RE-2910-M979.", "id": "F-04", "issue": "assignment consent", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/02_amendments/010_amendments_executed_instrument.txt", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-10-05, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Rafael Okafor.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/08_insurance/061_insurance_review_memorandum.json", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for estoppel discrepancy: one source states the applicable location is Yakima County, Washington, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to Washington operations outside Yakima County, Washington.", "id": "F-05", "issue": "estoppel discrepancy", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/02_amendments/013_amendments_review_memorandum.json", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-10-05, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Nora Chen.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/08_insurance/064_insurance_status_report.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for survey encroachment: one source states the threshold is 9% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 16% and produced a different exception result.", "id": "F-06", "issue": "survey encroachment", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/02_amendments/016_amendments_status_report.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-10-05, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Dominic Alvarez.", "severity": "low"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/09_notices/067_notices_correspondence.eml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for title exception: one source states formal notice must use notices-kestrel_farms_cooperative@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-rainshadow_land_trust@example.test.", "id": "F-07", "issue": "title exception", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/03_estoppels/019_estoppels_correspondence.eml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-10-05, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Priya Raman.", "severity": "critical"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/09_notices/070_notices_formal_notice.xml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for environmental recognized condition: one source states the governed population contains 161 records through 2026-01-31, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 45 records through 2026-02-17.", "id": "F-08", "issue": "environmental recognized condition", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/03_estoppels/022_estoppels_formal_notice.xml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-10-05, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Elliot Mercer.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/10_construction/073_construction_control_register.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for zoning nonconformity: one source states the operative date is 2025-04-24 under control reference CB-RE-2910-I511, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2025-05-15 under response reference CB-RE-2910-R616.", "id": "F-09", "issue": "zoning nonconformity", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/04_title_survey/025_title_survey_control_register.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-10-05, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Talia Brooks.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/10_construction/076_construction_ledger_export.csv", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for permit closeout gap: one source states the controlling amount is $3,584,649.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $3,745,798.00.", "id": "F-10", "issue": "permit closeout gap", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/04_title_survey/028_title_survey_ledger_export.csv", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-10-05, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Jonas Feld.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/10_construction/079_construction_officer_certificate.html", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for CAM reconciliation error: one source states approval is attributed to Henry Cho as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Jonas Feld and contains no entry for Henry Cho.", "id": "F-11", "issue": "CAM reconciliation error", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/04_title_survey/031_title_survey_officer_certificate.html", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-10-05, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Mei Whitaker.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/11_financing/082_financing_executed_instrument.txt", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for insurance endorsement deficiency: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-RE-2910-L455, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-RE-2910-U958.", "id": "F-12", "issue": "insurance endorsement deficiency", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/05_environmental/034_environmental_executed_instrument.txt", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-10-05, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Caleb Hassan.", "severity": "low"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/11_financing/085_financing_review_memorandum.json", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for casualty restoration deadline: one source states the applicable location is Yakima County, Washington, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to Washington operations outside Yakima County, Washington.", "id": "F-13", "issue": "casualty restoration deadline", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/05_environmental/037_environmental_review_memorandum.json", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-10-05, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Leona Park.", "severity": "critical"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/11_financing/088_financing_status_report.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for construction lien notice: one source states the threshold is 8% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 14% and produced a different exception result.", "id": "F-14", "issue": "construction lien notice", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/05_environmental/040_environmental_status_report.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-10-05, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Isaac Romero.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/12_property_management/091_property_management_correspondence.eml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for lender SNDA omission: one source states formal notice must use notices-kestrel_farms_cooperative@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-rainshadow_land_trust@example.test.", "id": "F-15", "issue": "lender SNDA omission", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/043_zoning_permits_correspondence.eml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-10-05, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Sofia Bennett.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/12_property_management/094_property_management_formal_notice.xml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for security-deposit mismatch: one source states the governed population contains 180 records through 2026-02-19, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 57 records through 2026-03-20.", "id": "F-16", "issue": "security-deposit mismatch", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/046_zoning_permits_formal_notice.xml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-10-05, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Adrian Mensah.", "severity": "medium"}], "matter_number": "CB-RE-2910", "prepared_for": "Kestrel Farms Cooperative", "schema_version": "1.0", "task_id": "cb100-060-kestrel-farms"}}, "metadata": {"benchmark": "CounselBench-100", "code_license": "Apache-2.0", "data_license": "CC-BY-4.0", "deadline": "2026-10-05", "document_count": 96, "jurisdiction": "Washington", "matter_number": "CB-RE-2910", "mcp_commit": "9a96ea6e5913736f92b88345bf51caeaaa8e719f", "mcp_package": "@modelcontextprotocol/server-filesystem@2026.7.10", "practice_area": "real-estate", "reference_tool_calls": 46, "required_evidence_reads": 33, "synthetic": true, "venue": "Yakima County, Washington", "version": "2.0.0"}, "prompt": "You are real-estate transactions counsel for Kestrel Farms Cooperative. The record contains amendments, exports, and correspondence from different custodians; reconcile them into an actionable counsel work product. Irrigated parcels carry water-right questions, access encroachments, crop leases, and insurance records inconsistent with loan covenants. Decision due 2026-10-05. Washington law governs; Yakima County, Washington is the forum. Write for a supervising lawyer who will spot-check source paths and exact values. Work out the defensible position from the matter production and leave an audit-ready exception tracker and concise advice for the supervising lawyer. Keep confirmed conflicts separate from open questions, cite the records that actually control each conclusion, and do not fill gaps with outside facts.", "rubric": {"criteria": [{"category": "procedure", "description": "Complete at least 46 successful, argument-specific evidence and output calls.", "id": "procedure.minimum_successful_tool_calls"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Find and read the 33 controlling, corroborating, and work-product-control records in full.", "id": "procedure.all_evidence_read_in_full"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Inspect file metadata for the eight designated critical primary records before relying on them.", "id": "procedure.chain_of_custody_metadata_checked"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Confirm the sandbox's allowed document and output roots.", "id": "procedure.allowed_directories_checked"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Inventory all 96 records so the relevant sources are discovered among the context records.", "id": "procedure.recursive_inventory_completed"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Search the production for email evidence that may corroborate or contradict formal records.", "id": "procedure.targeted_search_completed"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Leave only findings.json and advice.md in the output workspace.", "id": "procedure.exact_deliverable_set"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Create both final work products through the sandbox MCP surface.", "id": "procedure.deliverables_written_through_mcp"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Produce findings.json as a valid JSON object.", "id": "findings.findings_is_object"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Report exactly 16 confirmed exceptions.", "id": "findings.findings_exact_count"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Use each stable finding ID exactly once.", "id": "findings.finding_ids_unique"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set schema_version to the released matter value '1.0'.", "id": "findings.top_level_schema_version"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set task_id to the released matter value 'cb100-060-kestrel-farms'.", "id": "findings.top_level_task_id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set matter_number to the released matter value 'CB-RE-2910'.", "id": "findings.top_level_matter_number"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set prepared_for to the released matter value 'Kestrel Farms Cooperative'.", "id": "findings.top_level_prepared_for"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set as_of to the released matter value '2026-10-05'.", "id": "findings.top_level_as_of"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-01 exception for rent schedule inconsistency.", "id": "findings.F-01.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's id from /workspace/documents/01_leases/001_leases_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_operating_expenses/049_operating_expenses_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's issue from /workspace/documents/01_leases/001_leases_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_operating_expenses/049_operating_expenses_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's severity from /workspace/documents/01_leases/001_leases_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_operating_expenses/049_operating_expenses_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's primary_source from /workspace/documents/01_leases/001_leases_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_operating_expenses/049_operating_expenses_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/01_leases/001_leases_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_operating_expenses/049_operating_expenses_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-01 using the exact controlled facts ['2025-08-27', 'CB-RE-2910-A516', '2025-10-13', 'CB-RE-2910-J755'].", "id": "findings.F-01.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-01's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-01.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-10-05', 'Lena Varga'] for F-01.", "id": "findings.F-01.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-02 exception for renewal-option notice.", "id": "findings.F-02.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's id from /workspace/documents/01_leases/004_leases_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_operating_expenses/052_operating_expenses_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's issue from /workspace/documents/01_leases/004_leases_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_operating_expenses/052_operating_expenses_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's severity from /workspace/documents/01_leases/004_leases_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_operating_expenses/052_operating_expenses_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's primary_source from /workspace/documents/01_leases/004_leases_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_operating_expenses/052_operating_expenses_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/01_leases/004_leases_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_operating_expenses/052_operating_expenses_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-02 using the exact controlled facts ['$4,358,042.00', '$4,622,584.00'].", "id": "findings.F-02.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-02's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-02.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-10-05', 'Samuel Kim'] for F-02.", "id": "findings.F-02.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-03 exception for exclusive-use conflict.", "id": "findings.F-03.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's id from /workspace/documents/01_leases/007_leases_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_operating_expenses/055_operating_expenses_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's issue from /workspace/documents/01_leases/007_leases_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_operating_expenses/055_operating_expenses_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's severity from /workspace/documents/01_leases/007_leases_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_operating_expenses/055_operating_expenses_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's primary_source from /workspace/documents/01_leases/007_leases_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_operating_expenses/055_operating_expenses_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/01_leases/007_leases_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_operating_expenses/055_operating_expenses_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-03 using the exact controlled facts ['Henry Cho', 'Theo Laurent'].", "id": "findings.F-03.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-03's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-03.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-10-05', 'Maya Ellison'] for F-03.", "id": "findings.F-03.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-04 exception for assignment consent.", "id": "findings.F-04.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's id from /workspace/documents/02_amendments/010_amendments_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_insurance/058_insurance_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's issue from /workspace/documents/02_amendments/010_amendments_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_insurance/058_insurance_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's severity from /workspace/documents/02_amendments/010_amendments_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_insurance/058_insurance_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's primary_source from /workspace/documents/02_amendments/010_amendments_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_insurance/058_insurance_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/02_amendments/010_amendments_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_insurance/058_insurance_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-04 using the exact controlled facts ['closed without exception', 'CB-RE-2910-D733', 'open and escalated', 'CB-RE-2910-M979'].", "id": "findings.F-04.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-04's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-04.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-10-05', 'Rafael Okafor'] for F-04.", "id": "findings.F-04.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-05 exception for estoppel discrepancy.", "id": "findings.F-05.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's id from /workspace/documents/02_amendments/013_amendments_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_insurance/061_insurance_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's issue from /workspace/documents/02_amendments/013_amendments_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_insurance/061_insurance_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's severity from /workspace/documents/02_amendments/013_amendments_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_insurance/061_insurance_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's primary_source from /workspace/documents/02_amendments/013_amendments_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_insurance/061_insurance_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/02_amendments/013_amendments_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_insurance/061_insurance_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-05 using the exact controlled facts ['Yakima County, Washington', 'Washington'].", "id": "findings.F-05.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-05's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-05.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-10-05', 'Nora Chen'] for F-05.", "id": "findings.F-05.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-06 exception for survey encroachment.", "id": "findings.F-06.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's id from /workspace/documents/02_amendments/016_amendments_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_insurance/064_insurance_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's issue from /workspace/documents/02_amendments/016_amendments_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_insurance/064_insurance_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's severity from /workspace/documents/02_amendments/016_amendments_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_insurance/064_insurance_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's primary_source from /workspace/documents/02_amendments/016_amendments_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_insurance/064_insurance_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/02_amendments/016_amendments_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_insurance/064_insurance_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-06 using the exact controlled facts ['9%', '16%'].", "id": "findings.F-06.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-06's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-06.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-10-05', 'Dominic Alvarez'] for F-06.", "id": "findings.F-06.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-07 exception for title exception.", "id": "findings.F-07.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's id from /workspace/documents/03_estoppels/019_estoppels_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_notices/067_notices_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's issue from /workspace/documents/03_estoppels/019_estoppels_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_notices/067_notices_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's severity from /workspace/documents/03_estoppels/019_estoppels_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_notices/067_notices_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's primary_source from /workspace/documents/03_estoppels/019_estoppels_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_notices/067_notices_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/03_estoppels/019_estoppels_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_notices/067_notices_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-07 using the exact controlled facts ['notices-kestrel_farms_cooperative@example.test', 'archive-rainshadow_land_trust@example.test'].", "id": "findings.F-07.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-07's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-07.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-10-05', 'Priya Raman'] for F-07.", "id": "findings.F-07.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-08 exception for environmental recognized condition.", "id": "findings.F-08.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's id from /workspace/documents/03_estoppels/022_estoppels_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_notices/070_notices_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's issue from /workspace/documents/03_estoppels/022_estoppels_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_notices/070_notices_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's severity from /workspace/documents/03_estoppels/022_estoppels_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_notices/070_notices_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's primary_source from /workspace/documents/03_estoppels/022_estoppels_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_notices/070_notices_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/03_estoppels/022_estoppels_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_notices/070_notices_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-08 using the exact controlled facts ['161 records', '2026-01-31', '45 records', '2026-02-17'].", "id": "findings.F-08.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-08's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-08.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-10-05', 'Elliot Mercer'] for F-08.", "id": "findings.F-08.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-09 exception for zoning nonconformity.", "id": "findings.F-09.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's id from /workspace/documents/04_title_survey/025_title_survey_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_construction/073_construction_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's issue from /workspace/documents/04_title_survey/025_title_survey_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_construction/073_construction_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's severity from /workspace/documents/04_title_survey/025_title_survey_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_construction/073_construction_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's primary_source from /workspace/documents/04_title_survey/025_title_survey_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_construction/073_construction_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/04_title_survey/025_title_survey_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_construction/073_construction_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-09 using the exact controlled facts ['2025-04-24', 'CB-RE-2910-I511', '2025-05-15', 'CB-RE-2910-R616'].", "id": "findings.F-09.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-09's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-09.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-10-05', 'Talia Brooks'] for F-09.", "id": "findings.F-09.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-10 exception for permit closeout gap.", "id": "findings.F-10.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's id from /workspace/documents/04_title_survey/028_title_survey_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_construction/076_construction_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's issue from /workspace/documents/04_title_survey/028_title_survey_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_construction/076_construction_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's severity from /workspace/documents/04_title_survey/028_title_survey_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_construction/076_construction_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's primary_source from /workspace/documents/04_title_survey/028_title_survey_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_construction/076_construction_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/04_title_survey/028_title_survey_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_construction/076_construction_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-10 using the exact controlled facts ['$3,584,649.00', '$3,745,798.00'].", "id": "findings.F-10.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-10's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-10.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-10-05', 'Jonas Feld'] for F-10.", "id": "findings.F-10.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-11 exception for CAM reconciliation error.", "id": "findings.F-11.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's id from /workspace/documents/04_title_survey/031_title_survey_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_construction/079_construction_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's issue from /workspace/documents/04_title_survey/031_title_survey_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_construction/079_construction_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's severity from /workspace/documents/04_title_survey/031_title_survey_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_construction/079_construction_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's primary_source from /workspace/documents/04_title_survey/031_title_survey_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_construction/079_construction_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/04_title_survey/031_title_survey_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_construction/079_construction_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-11 using the exact controlled facts ['Henry Cho', 'Jonas Feld'].", "id": "findings.F-11.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-11's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-11.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-10-05', 'Mei Whitaker'] for F-11.", "id": "findings.F-11.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-12 exception for insurance endorsement deficiency.", "id": "findings.F-12.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's id from /workspace/documents/05_environmental/034_environmental_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_financing/082_financing_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's issue from /workspace/documents/05_environmental/034_environmental_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_financing/082_financing_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's severity from /workspace/documents/05_environmental/034_environmental_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_financing/082_financing_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's primary_source from /workspace/documents/05_environmental/034_environmental_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_financing/082_financing_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/05_environmental/034_environmental_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_financing/082_financing_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-12 using the exact controlled facts ['closed without exception', 'CB-RE-2910-L455', 'open and escalated', 'CB-RE-2910-U958'].", "id": "findings.F-12.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-12's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-12.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-10-05', 'Caleb Hassan'] for F-12.", "id": "findings.F-12.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-13 exception for casualty restoration deadline.", "id": "findings.F-13.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's id from /workspace/documents/05_environmental/037_environmental_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_financing/085_financing_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's issue from /workspace/documents/05_environmental/037_environmental_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_financing/085_financing_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's severity from /workspace/documents/05_environmental/037_environmental_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_financing/085_financing_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's primary_source from /workspace/documents/05_environmental/037_environmental_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_financing/085_financing_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/05_environmental/037_environmental_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_financing/085_financing_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-13 using the exact controlled facts ['Yakima County, Washington', 'Washington'].", "id": "findings.F-13.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-13's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-13.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-10-05', 'Leona Park'] for F-13.", "id": "findings.F-13.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-14 exception for construction lien notice.", "id": "findings.F-14.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's id from /workspace/documents/05_environmental/040_environmental_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_financing/088_financing_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's issue from /workspace/documents/05_environmental/040_environmental_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_financing/088_financing_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's severity from /workspace/documents/05_environmental/040_environmental_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_financing/088_financing_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's primary_source from /workspace/documents/05_environmental/040_environmental_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_financing/088_financing_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/05_environmental/040_environmental_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_financing/088_financing_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-14 using the exact controlled facts ['8%', '14%'].", "id": "findings.F-14.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-14's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-14.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-10-05', 'Isaac Romero'] for F-14.", "id": "findings.F-14.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-15 exception for lender SNDA omission.", "id": "findings.F-15.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's id from /workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/043_zoning_permits_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_property_management/091_property_management_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's issue from /workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/043_zoning_permits_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_property_management/091_property_management_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's severity from /workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/043_zoning_permits_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_property_management/091_property_management_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's primary_source from /workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/043_zoning_permits_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_property_management/091_property_management_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/043_zoning_permits_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_property_management/091_property_management_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-15 using the exact controlled facts ['notices-kestrel_farms_cooperative@example.test', 'archive-rainshadow_land_trust@example.test'].", "id": "findings.F-15.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-15's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-15.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-10-05', 'Sofia Bennett'] for F-15.", "id": "findings.F-15.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-16 exception for security-deposit mismatch.", "id": "findings.F-16.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's id from /workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/046_zoning_permits_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_property_management/094_property_management_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's issue from /workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/046_zoning_permits_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_property_management/094_property_management_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's severity from /workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/046_zoning_permits_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_property_management/094_property_management_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's primary_source from /workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/046_zoning_permits_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_property_management/094_property_management_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/046_zoning_permits_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_property_management/094_property_management_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-16 using the exact controlled facts ['180 records', '2026-02-19', '57 records', '2026-03-20'].", "id": "findings.F-16.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-16's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-16.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-10-05', 'Adrian Mensah'] for F-16.", "id": "findings.F-16.action_anchors"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Executive assessment' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Executive assessment"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Method and record coverage' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Method and record coverage"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Findings' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Findings"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Recommended next actions' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Recommended next actions"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Assumptions and limitations' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Assumptions and limitations"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-01 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-01"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-02 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-02"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-03 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-03"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-04 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-04"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-05 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-05"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-06 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-06"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-07 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-07"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-08 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-08"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-09 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-09"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-10 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-10"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-11 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-11"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-12 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-12"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-13 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-13"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-14 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-14"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-15 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-15"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-16 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-16"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Do not claim the production has no issues or that every record is consistent.", "id": "memo.forbidden_claims_absent"}], "decision_options": [{"id": "cross-source-reconciliation", "label": "Reconcile controlling and corroborating records", "reason": "The CB-RE-2910 production contains independently maintained records; a defensible answer must preserve each supported conflict and its cure owner.", "selected": true}, {"id": "latest-record-controls", "label": "Treat the latest record as controlling", "reason": "Timestamp recency does not establish legal priority, execution, or approval authority.", "selected": false}, {"id": "primary-records-only", "label": "Report primary records without reconciliation", "reason": "Primary records alone conceal the operational conflicts that create the actionable exceptions.", "selected": false}], "gates": ["all_evidence_read_in_full", "chain_of_custody_metadata_checked", "findings_criteria_complete", "memo_criteria_complete", "deliverables_written_through_mcp"], "metadata_checks": 8, "metric": "weighted_criteria_score", "minimum_tool_calls": 46, "required_deliverables": ["findings.json", "advice.md"], "required_document_reads": 33, "type": "deterministic", "weights": {"findings": 0.55, "memo": 0.2, "procedure": 0.25}}, "task_id": "cb100-060-kestrel-farms", "task_name": "Kestrel agricultural land portfolio audit", "world_id": "counselbench-filesystem-mcp-v2"}
-{"context_files": ["task_files/cb100-061-arcadia-genomics/01_data_inventory/001_data_inventory_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-061-arcadia-genomics/01_data_inventory/002_data_inventory_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-061-arcadia-genomics/01_data_inventory/003_data_inventory_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-061-arcadia-genomics/01_data_inventory/004_data_inventory_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-061-arcadia-genomics/01_data_inventory/005_data_inventory_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-061-arcadia-genomics/01_data_inventory/006_data_inventory_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-061-arcadia-genomics/01_data_inventory/007_data_inventory_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-061-arcadia-genomics/01_data_inventory/008_data_inventory_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-061-arcadia-genomics/02_processing_records/009_processing_records_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-061-arcadia-genomics/02_processing_records/010_processing_records_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-061-arcadia-genomics/02_processing_records/011_processing_records_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-061-arcadia-genomics/02_processing_records/012_processing_records_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-061-arcadia-genomics/02_processing_records/013_processing_records_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-061-arcadia-genomics/02_processing_records/014_processing_records_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-061-arcadia-genomics/02_processing_records/015_processing_records_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-061-arcadia-genomics/02_processing_records/016_processing_records_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-061-arcadia-genomics/03_vendor_reviews/017_vendor_reviews_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-061-arcadia-genomics/03_vendor_reviews/018_vendor_reviews_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-061-arcadia-genomics/03_vendor_reviews/019_vendor_reviews_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-061-arcadia-genomics/03_vendor_reviews/020_vendor_reviews_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-061-arcadia-genomics/03_vendor_reviews/021_vendor_reviews_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-061-arcadia-genomics/03_vendor_reviews/022_vendor_reviews_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-061-arcadia-genomics/03_vendor_reviews/023_vendor_reviews_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-061-arcadia-genomics/03_vendor_reviews/024_vendor_reviews_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-061-arcadia-genomics/04_security_incidents/025_security_incidents_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-061-arcadia-genomics/04_security_incidents/026_security_incidents_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-061-arcadia-genomics/04_security_incidents/027_security_incidents_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-061-arcadia-genomics/04_security_incidents/028_security_incidents_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-061-arcadia-genomics/04_security_incidents/029_security_incidents_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-061-arcadia-genomics/04_security_incidents/030_security_incidents_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-061-arcadia-genomics/04_security_incidents/031_security_incidents_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-061-arcadia-genomics/04_security_incidents/032_security_incidents_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-061-arcadia-genomics/05_consumer_requests/033_consumer_requests_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-061-arcadia-genomics/05_consumer_requests/034_consumer_requests_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-061-arcadia-genomics/05_consumer_requests/035_consumer_requests_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-061-arcadia-genomics/05_consumer_requests/036_consumer_requests_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-061-arcadia-genomics/05_consumer_requests/037_consumer_requests_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-061-arcadia-genomics/05_consumer_requests/038_consumer_requests_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-061-arcadia-genomics/05_consumer_requests/039_consumer_requests_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-061-arcadia-genomics/05_consumer_requests/040_consumer_requests_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-061-arcadia-genomics/06_notices_consents/041_notices_consents_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-061-arcadia-genomics/06_notices_consents/042_notices_consents_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-061-arcadia-genomics/06_notices_consents/043_notices_consents_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-061-arcadia-genomics/06_notices_consents/044_notices_consents_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-061-arcadia-genomics/06_notices_consents/045_notices_consents_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-061-arcadia-genomics/06_notices_consents/046_notices_consents_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-061-arcadia-genomics/06_notices_consents/047_notices_consents_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-061-arcadia-genomics/06_notices_consents/048_notices_consents_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-061-arcadia-genomics/07_transfer_mechanisms/049_transfer_mechanisms_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-061-arcadia-genomics/07_transfer_mechanisms/050_transfer_mechanisms_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-061-arcadia-genomics/07_transfer_mechanisms/051_transfer_mechanisms_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-061-arcadia-genomics/07_transfer_mechanisms/052_transfer_mechanisms_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-061-arcadia-genomics/07_transfer_mechanisms/053_transfer_mechanisms_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-061-arcadia-genomics/07_transfer_mechanisms/054_transfer_mechanisms_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-061-arcadia-genomics/07_transfer_mechanisms/055_transfer_mechanisms_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-061-arcadia-genomics/07_transfer_mechanisms/056_transfer_mechanisms_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-061-arcadia-genomics/08_retention_deletion/057_retention_deletion_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-061-arcadia-genomics/08_retention_deletion/058_retention_deletion_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-061-arcadia-genomics/08_retention_deletion/059_retention_deletion_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-061-arcadia-genomics/08_retention_deletion/060_retention_deletion_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-061-arcadia-genomics/08_retention_deletion/061_retention_deletion_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-061-arcadia-genomics/08_retention_deletion/062_retention_deletion_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-061-arcadia-genomics/08_retention_deletion/063_retention_deletion_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-061-arcadia-genomics/08_retention_deletion/064_retention_deletion_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-061-arcadia-genomics/09_training/065_training_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-061-arcadia-genomics/09_training/066_training_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-061-arcadia-genomics/09_training/067_training_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-061-arcadia-genomics/09_training/068_training_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-061-arcadia-genomics/09_training/069_training_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-061-arcadia-genomics/09_training/070_training_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-061-arcadia-genomics/09_training/071_training_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-061-arcadia-genomics/09_training/072_training_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-061-arcadia-genomics/10_regulator_correspondence/073_regulator_correspondence_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-061-arcadia-genomics/10_regulator_correspondence/074_regulator_correspondence_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-061-arcadia-genomics/10_regulator_correspondence/075_regulator_correspondence_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-061-arcadia-genomics/10_regulator_correspondence/076_regulator_correspondence_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-061-arcadia-genomics/10_regulator_correspondence/077_regulator_correspondence_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-061-arcadia-genomics/10_regulator_correspondence/078_regulator_correspondence_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-061-arcadia-genomics/10_regulator_correspondence/079_regulator_correspondence_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-061-arcadia-genomics/10_regulator_correspondence/080_regulator_correspondence_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-061-arcadia-genomics/11_risk_assessments/081_risk_assessments_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-061-arcadia-genomics/11_risk_assessments/082_risk_assessments_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-061-arcadia-genomics/11_risk_assessments/083_risk_assessments_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-061-arcadia-genomics/11_risk_assessments/084_risk_assessments_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-061-arcadia-genomics/11_risk_assessments/085_risk_assessments_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-061-arcadia-genomics/11_risk_assessments/086_risk_assessments_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-061-arcadia-genomics/11_risk_assessments/087_risk_assessments_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-061-arcadia-genomics/11_risk_assessments/088_risk_assessments_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-061-arcadia-genomics/12_remediation/089_remediation_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-061-arcadia-genomics/12_remediation/090_remediation_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-061-arcadia-genomics/12_remediation/091_remediation_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-061-arcadia-genomics/12_remediation/092_remediation_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-061-arcadia-genomics/12_remediation/093_remediation_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-061-arcadia-genomics/12_remediation/094_remediation_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-061-arcadia-genomics/12_remediation/095_remediation_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-061-arcadia-genomics/12_remediation/096_remediation_status_report.md"], "gold_output": {"advice_markdown": "# Counsel advice — Arcadia genomic data response audit\n\n## Executive assessment\n\nFor Arcadia Genomics, Inc. matter CB-PR-3001, the review identified 16 source-supported exceptions requiring action before 2026-09-02. The assessment concerns North Coast Sequencing Network and the supplied record for California.\n\n## Method and record coverage\n\nThe review inventoried all 96 production files, read the 33 controlling, corroborating, and control records, searched the email exports, and checked metadata for the designated chain-of-custody sample. Conclusions are limited to the synthetic production supplied for this benchmark matter.\n\n## Findings\n\n### F-01 — processing-purpose gap (critical)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for processing-purpose gap: one source states the operative date is 2025-02-24 under control reference CB-PR-3001-A932, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2025-03-06 under response reference CB-PR-3001-J440.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/001_data_inventory_control_register.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/07_transfer_mechanisms/049_transfer_mechanisms_control_register.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-02, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Samuel Kim.\n\n### F-02 — notice-practice mismatch (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for notice-practice mismatch: one source states the controlling amount is $3,431,788.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $3,750,076.00.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/004_data_inventory_ledger_export.csv`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/07_transfer_mechanisms/052_transfer_mechanisms_ledger_export.csv`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-02, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Maya Ellison.\n\n### F-03 — consent-record deficiency (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for consent-record deficiency: one source states approval is attributed to Nadine Flores as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Henry Cho and contains no entry for Nadine Flores.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/007_data_inventory_officer_certificate.html`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/07_transfer_mechanisms/055_transfer_mechanisms_officer_certificate.html`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-02, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Rafael Okafor.\n\n### F-04 — processor-contract omission (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for processor-contract omission: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-PR-3001-D806, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-PR-3001-M915.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/02_processing_records/010_processing_records_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/08_retention_deletion/058_retention_deletion_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-02, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Nora Chen.\n\n### F-05 — subprocessor inventory mismatch (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for subprocessor inventory mismatch: one source states the applicable location is California Privacy Protection Agency, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to California operations outside California Privacy Protection Agency.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/02_processing_records/013_processing_records_review_memorandum.json`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/08_retention_deletion/061_retention_deletion_review_memorandum.json`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-02, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Dominic Alvarez.\n\n### F-06 — cross-border transfer gap (low)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for cross-border transfer gap: one source states the threshold is 13% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 18% and produced a different exception result.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/02_processing_records/016_processing_records_status_report.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/08_retention_deletion/064_retention_deletion_status_report.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-02, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Priya Raman.\n\n### F-07 — retention schedule conflict (critical)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for retention schedule conflict: one source states formal notice must use notices-arcadia_genomics_inc@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-north_coast_sequencing_network@example.test.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/019_vendor_reviews_correspondence.eml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/09_training/067_training_correspondence.eml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-02, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Elliot Mercer.\n\n### F-08 — deletion-job failure (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for deletion-job failure: one source states the governed population contains 90 records through 2025-07-04, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 71 records through 2025-08-16.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/022_vendor_reviews_formal_notice.xml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/09_training/070_training_formal_notice.xml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-02, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Talia Brooks.\n\n### F-09 — access-request deadline (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for access-request deadline: one source states the operative date is 2025-01-19 under control reference CB-PR-3001-I596, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2025-02-07 under response reference CB-PR-3001-R899.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/025_security_incidents_control_register.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/10_regulator_correspondence/073_regulator_correspondence_control_register.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-02, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Jonas Feld.\n\n### F-10 — identity-verification inconsistency (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for identity-verification inconsistency: one source states the controlling amount is $2,054,266.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $2,215,032.00.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/028_security_incidents_ledger_export.csv`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/10_regulator_correspondence/076_regulator_correspondence_ledger_export.csv`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-02, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Mei Whitaker.\n\n### F-11 — incident-notification clock (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for incident-notification clock: one source states approval is attributed to Nadine Flores as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Caleb Hassan and contains no entry for Nadine Flores.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/031_security_incidents_officer_certificate.html`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/10_regulator_correspondence/079_regulator_correspondence_officer_certificate.html`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-02, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Caleb Hassan.\n\n### F-12 — risk-assessment omission (low)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for risk-assessment omission: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-PR-3001-L450, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-PR-3001-U334.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/034_consumer_requests_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/11_risk_assessments/082_risk_assessments_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-02, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Leona Park.\n\n### F-13 — sensitive-data classification (critical)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for sensitive-data classification: one source states the applicable location is California Privacy Protection Agency, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to California operations outside California Privacy Protection Agency.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/037_consumer_requests_review_memorandum.json`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/11_risk_assessments/085_risk_assessments_review_memorandum.json`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-02, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Isaac Romero.\n\n### F-14 — minor-consent issue (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for minor-consent issue: one source states the threshold is 5% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 10% and produced a different exception result.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/040_consumer_requests_status_report.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/11_risk_assessments/088_risk_assessments_status_report.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-02, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Sofia Bennett.\n\n### F-15 — training completion gap (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for training completion gap: one source states formal notice must use notices-arcadia_genomics_inc@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-north_coast_sequencing_network@example.test.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/043_notices_consents_correspondence.eml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/12_remediation/091_remediation_correspondence.eml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-02, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Adrian Mensah.\n\n### F-16 — regulator commitment overdue (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for regulator commitment overdue: one source states the governed population contains 174 records through 2025-09-26, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 43 records through 2025-10-11.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/046_notices_consents_formal_notice.xml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/12_remediation/094_remediation_formal_notice.xml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-02, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Willa Novak.\n\n## Recommended next actions\n\nSequence the critical and high findings first, assign the named owners, preserve the cited records, and document any resolution in the controlling matter register before the stated deadline.\n\n## Assumptions and limitations\n\nThis analysis is confined to task cb100-061-arcadia-genomics and the supplied synthetic evidence. It does not rely on external facts, does not resolve disputed law, and is not legal advice for a real person or entity.\n", "findings": {"as_of": "2026-09-02", "findings": [{"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/07_transfer_mechanisms/049_transfer_mechanisms_control_register.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for processing-purpose gap: one source states the operative date is 2025-02-24 under control reference CB-PR-3001-A932, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2025-03-06 under response reference CB-PR-3001-J440.", "id": "F-01", "issue": "processing-purpose gap", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/001_data_inventory_control_register.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-02, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Samuel Kim.", "severity": "critical"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/07_transfer_mechanisms/052_transfer_mechanisms_ledger_export.csv", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for notice-practice mismatch: one source states the controlling amount is $3,431,788.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $3,750,076.00.", "id": "F-02", "issue": "notice-practice mismatch", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/004_data_inventory_ledger_export.csv", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-02, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Maya Ellison.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/07_transfer_mechanisms/055_transfer_mechanisms_officer_certificate.html", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for consent-record deficiency: one source states approval is attributed to Nadine Flores as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Henry Cho and contains no entry for Nadine Flores.", "id": "F-03", "issue": "consent-record deficiency", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/007_data_inventory_officer_certificate.html", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-02, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Rafael Okafor.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/08_retention_deletion/058_retention_deletion_executed_instrument.txt", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for processor-contract omission: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-PR-3001-D806, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-PR-3001-M915.", "id": "F-04", "issue": "processor-contract omission", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/02_processing_records/010_processing_records_executed_instrument.txt", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-02, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Nora Chen.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/08_retention_deletion/061_retention_deletion_review_memorandum.json", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for subprocessor inventory mismatch: one source states the applicable location is California Privacy Protection Agency, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to California operations outside California Privacy Protection Agency.", "id": "F-05", "issue": "subprocessor inventory mismatch", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/02_processing_records/013_processing_records_review_memorandum.json", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-02, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Dominic Alvarez.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/08_retention_deletion/064_retention_deletion_status_report.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for cross-border transfer gap: one source states the threshold is 13% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 18% and produced a different exception result.", "id": "F-06", "issue": "cross-border transfer gap", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/02_processing_records/016_processing_records_status_report.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-02, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Priya Raman.", "severity": "low"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/09_training/067_training_correspondence.eml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for retention schedule conflict: one source states formal notice must use notices-arcadia_genomics_inc@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-north_coast_sequencing_network@example.test.", "id": "F-07", "issue": "retention schedule conflict", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/019_vendor_reviews_correspondence.eml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-02, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Elliot Mercer.", "severity": "critical"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/09_training/070_training_formal_notice.xml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for deletion-job failure: one source states the governed population contains 90 records through 2025-07-04, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 71 records through 2025-08-16.", "id": "F-08", "issue": "deletion-job failure", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/022_vendor_reviews_formal_notice.xml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-02, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Talia Brooks.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/10_regulator_correspondence/073_regulator_correspondence_control_register.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for access-request deadline: one source states the operative date is 2025-01-19 under control reference CB-PR-3001-I596, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2025-02-07 under response reference CB-PR-3001-R899.", "id": "F-09", "issue": "access-request deadline", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/025_security_incidents_control_register.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-02, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Jonas Feld.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/10_regulator_correspondence/076_regulator_correspondence_ledger_export.csv", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for identity-verification inconsistency: one source states the controlling amount is $2,054,266.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $2,215,032.00.", "id": "F-10", "issue": "identity-verification inconsistency", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/028_security_incidents_ledger_export.csv", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-02, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Mei Whitaker.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/10_regulator_correspondence/079_regulator_correspondence_officer_certificate.html", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for incident-notification clock: one source states approval is attributed to Nadine Flores as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Caleb Hassan and contains no entry for Nadine Flores.", "id": "F-11", "issue": "incident-notification clock", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/031_security_incidents_officer_certificate.html", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-02, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Caleb Hassan.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/11_risk_assessments/082_risk_assessments_executed_instrument.txt", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for risk-assessment omission: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-PR-3001-L450, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-PR-3001-U334.", "id": "F-12", "issue": "risk-assessment omission", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/034_consumer_requests_executed_instrument.txt", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-02, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Leona Park.", "severity": "low"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/11_risk_assessments/085_risk_assessments_review_memorandum.json", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for sensitive-data classification: one source states the applicable location is California Privacy Protection Agency, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to California operations outside California Privacy Protection Agency.", "id": "F-13", "issue": "sensitive-data classification", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/037_consumer_requests_review_memorandum.json", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-02, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Isaac Romero.", "severity": "critical"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/11_risk_assessments/088_risk_assessments_status_report.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for minor-consent issue: one source states the threshold is 5% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 10% and produced a different exception result.", "id": "F-14", "issue": "minor-consent issue", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/040_consumer_requests_status_report.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-02, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Sofia Bennett.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/091_remediation_correspondence.eml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for training completion gap: one source states formal notice must use notices-arcadia_genomics_inc@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-north_coast_sequencing_network@example.test.", "id": "F-15", "issue": "training completion gap", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/043_notices_consents_correspondence.eml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-02, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Adrian Mensah.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/094_remediation_formal_notice.xml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for regulator commitment overdue: one source states the governed population contains 174 records through 2025-09-26, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 43 records through 2025-10-11.", "id": "F-16", "issue": "regulator commitment overdue", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/046_notices_consents_formal_notice.xml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-02, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Willa Novak.", "severity": "medium"}], "matter_number": "CB-PR-3001", "prepared_for": "Arcadia Genomics, Inc.", "schema_version": "1.0", "task_id": "cb100-061-arcadia-genomics"}}, "metadata": {"benchmark": "CounselBench-100", "code_license": "Apache-2.0", "data_license": "CC-BY-4.0", "deadline": "2026-09-02", "document_count": 96, "jurisdiction": "California", "matter_number": "CB-PR-3001", "mcp_commit": "9a96ea6e5913736f92b88345bf51caeaaa8e719f", "mcp_package": "@modelcontextprotocol/server-filesystem@2026.7.10", "practice_area": "privacy-regulatory", "reference_tool_calls": 46, "required_evidence_reads": 33, "synthetic": true, "venue": "California Privacy Protection Agency", "version": "2.0.0"}, "prompt": "You are privacy and regulatory counsel for Arcadia Genomics, Inc. The partner responsible for this matter needs a defensible decision record before the next client call. A consumer access request exposes inconsistencies among genomic-data notices, deletion jobs, vendors, and overseas research transfers. Decision due 2026-09-02. California law governs; California Privacy Protection Agency is the forum. Prioritize conflicts between signed instruments and later operational records. Work out the defensible position from the matter production and leave an audit-ready exception tracker and concise advice for the supervising lawyer. Keep confirmed conflicts separate from open questions, cite the records that actually control each conclusion, and do not fill gaps with outside facts.", "rubric": {"criteria": [{"category": "procedure", "description": "Complete at least 46 successful, argument-specific evidence and output calls.", "id": "procedure.minimum_successful_tool_calls"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Find and read the 33 controlling, corroborating, and work-product-control records in full.", "id": "procedure.all_evidence_read_in_full"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Inspect file metadata for the eight designated critical primary records before relying on them.", "id": "procedure.chain_of_custody_metadata_checked"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Confirm the sandbox's allowed document and output roots.", "id": "procedure.allowed_directories_checked"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Inventory all 96 records so the relevant sources are discovered among the context records.", "id": "procedure.recursive_inventory_completed"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Search the production for email evidence that may corroborate or contradict formal records.", "id": "procedure.targeted_search_completed"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Leave only findings.json and advice.md in the output workspace.", "id": "procedure.exact_deliverable_set"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Create both final work products through the sandbox MCP surface.", "id": "procedure.deliverables_written_through_mcp"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Produce findings.json as a valid JSON object.", "id": "findings.findings_is_object"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Report exactly 16 confirmed exceptions.", "id": "findings.findings_exact_count"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Use each stable finding ID exactly once.", "id": "findings.finding_ids_unique"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set schema_version to the released matter value '1.0'.", "id": "findings.top_level_schema_version"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set task_id to the released matter value 'cb100-061-arcadia-genomics'.", "id": "findings.top_level_task_id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set matter_number to the released matter value 'CB-PR-3001'.", "id": "findings.top_level_matter_number"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set prepared_for to the released matter value 'Arcadia Genomics, Inc.'.", "id": "findings.top_level_prepared_for"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set as_of to the released matter value '2026-09-02'.", "id": "findings.top_level_as_of"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-01 exception for processing-purpose gap.", "id": "findings.F-01.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's id from /workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/001_data_inventory_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_transfer_mechanisms/049_transfer_mechanisms_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's issue from /workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/001_data_inventory_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_transfer_mechanisms/049_transfer_mechanisms_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's severity from /workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/001_data_inventory_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_transfer_mechanisms/049_transfer_mechanisms_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's primary_source from /workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/001_data_inventory_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_transfer_mechanisms/049_transfer_mechanisms_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/001_data_inventory_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_transfer_mechanisms/049_transfer_mechanisms_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-01 using the exact controlled facts ['2025-02-24', 'CB-PR-3001-A932', '2025-03-06', 'CB-PR-3001-J440'].", "id": "findings.F-01.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-01's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-01.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-02', 'Samuel Kim'] for F-01.", "id": "findings.F-01.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-02 exception for notice-practice mismatch.", "id": "findings.F-02.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's id from /workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/004_data_inventory_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_transfer_mechanisms/052_transfer_mechanisms_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's issue from /workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/004_data_inventory_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_transfer_mechanisms/052_transfer_mechanisms_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's severity from /workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/004_data_inventory_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_transfer_mechanisms/052_transfer_mechanisms_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's primary_source from /workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/004_data_inventory_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_transfer_mechanisms/052_transfer_mechanisms_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/004_data_inventory_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_transfer_mechanisms/052_transfer_mechanisms_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-02 using the exact controlled facts ['$3,431,788.00', '$3,750,076.00'].", "id": "findings.F-02.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-02's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-02.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-02', 'Maya Ellison'] for F-02.", "id": "findings.F-02.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-03 exception for consent-record deficiency.", "id": "findings.F-03.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's id from /workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/007_data_inventory_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_transfer_mechanisms/055_transfer_mechanisms_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's issue from /workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/007_data_inventory_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_transfer_mechanisms/055_transfer_mechanisms_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's severity from /workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/007_data_inventory_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_transfer_mechanisms/055_transfer_mechanisms_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's primary_source from /workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/007_data_inventory_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_transfer_mechanisms/055_transfer_mechanisms_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/007_data_inventory_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_transfer_mechanisms/055_transfer_mechanisms_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-03 using the exact controlled facts ['Nadine Flores', 'Henry Cho'].", "id": "findings.F-03.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-03's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-03.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-02', 'Rafael Okafor'] for F-03.", "id": "findings.F-03.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-04 exception for processor-contract omission.", "id": "findings.F-04.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's id from /workspace/documents/02_processing_records/010_processing_records_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_retention_deletion/058_retention_deletion_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's issue from /workspace/documents/02_processing_records/010_processing_records_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_retention_deletion/058_retention_deletion_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's severity from /workspace/documents/02_processing_records/010_processing_records_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_retention_deletion/058_retention_deletion_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's primary_source from /workspace/documents/02_processing_records/010_processing_records_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_retention_deletion/058_retention_deletion_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/02_processing_records/010_processing_records_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_retention_deletion/058_retention_deletion_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-04 using the exact controlled facts ['closed without exception', 'CB-PR-3001-D806', 'open and escalated', 'CB-PR-3001-M915'].", "id": "findings.F-04.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-04's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-04.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-02', 'Nora Chen'] for F-04.", "id": "findings.F-04.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-05 exception for subprocessor inventory mismatch.", "id": "findings.F-05.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's id from /workspace/documents/02_processing_records/013_processing_records_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_retention_deletion/061_retention_deletion_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's issue from /workspace/documents/02_processing_records/013_processing_records_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_retention_deletion/061_retention_deletion_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's severity from /workspace/documents/02_processing_records/013_processing_records_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_retention_deletion/061_retention_deletion_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's primary_source from /workspace/documents/02_processing_records/013_processing_records_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_retention_deletion/061_retention_deletion_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/02_processing_records/013_processing_records_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_retention_deletion/061_retention_deletion_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-05 using the exact controlled facts ['California Privacy Protection Agency', 'California'].", "id": "findings.F-05.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-05's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-05.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-02', 'Dominic Alvarez'] for F-05.", "id": "findings.F-05.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-06 exception for cross-border transfer gap.", "id": "findings.F-06.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's id from /workspace/documents/02_processing_records/016_processing_records_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_retention_deletion/064_retention_deletion_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's issue from /workspace/documents/02_processing_records/016_processing_records_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_retention_deletion/064_retention_deletion_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's severity from /workspace/documents/02_processing_records/016_processing_records_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_retention_deletion/064_retention_deletion_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's primary_source from /workspace/documents/02_processing_records/016_processing_records_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_retention_deletion/064_retention_deletion_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/02_processing_records/016_processing_records_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_retention_deletion/064_retention_deletion_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-06 using the exact controlled facts ['13%', '18%'].", "id": "findings.F-06.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-06's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-06.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-02', 'Priya Raman'] for F-06.", "id": "findings.F-06.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-07 exception for retention schedule conflict.", "id": "findings.F-07.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's id from /workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/019_vendor_reviews_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_training/067_training_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's issue from /workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/019_vendor_reviews_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_training/067_training_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's severity from /workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/019_vendor_reviews_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_training/067_training_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's primary_source from /workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/019_vendor_reviews_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_training/067_training_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/019_vendor_reviews_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_training/067_training_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-07 using the exact controlled facts ['notices-arcadia_genomics_inc@example.test', 'archive-north_coast_sequencing_network@example.test'].", "id": "findings.F-07.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-07's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-07.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-02', 'Elliot Mercer'] for F-07.", "id": "findings.F-07.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-08 exception for deletion-job failure.", "id": "findings.F-08.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's id from /workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/022_vendor_reviews_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_training/070_training_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's issue from /workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/022_vendor_reviews_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_training/070_training_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's severity from /workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/022_vendor_reviews_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_training/070_training_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's primary_source from /workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/022_vendor_reviews_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_training/070_training_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/022_vendor_reviews_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_training/070_training_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-08 using the exact controlled facts ['90 records', '2025-07-04', '71 records', '2025-08-16'].", "id": "findings.F-08.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-08's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-08.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-02', 'Talia Brooks'] for F-08.", "id": "findings.F-08.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-09 exception for access-request deadline.", "id": "findings.F-09.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's id from /workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/025_security_incidents_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_regulator_correspondence/073_regulator_correspondence_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's issue from /workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/025_security_incidents_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_regulator_correspondence/073_regulator_correspondence_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's severity from /workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/025_security_incidents_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_regulator_correspondence/073_regulator_correspondence_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's primary_source from /workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/025_security_incidents_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_regulator_correspondence/073_regulator_correspondence_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/025_security_incidents_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_regulator_correspondence/073_regulator_correspondence_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-09 using the exact controlled facts ['2025-01-19', 'CB-PR-3001-I596', '2025-02-07', 'CB-PR-3001-R899'].", "id": "findings.F-09.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-09's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-09.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-02', 'Jonas Feld'] for F-09.", "id": "findings.F-09.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-10 exception for identity-verification inconsistency.", "id": "findings.F-10.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's id from /workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/028_security_incidents_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_regulator_correspondence/076_regulator_correspondence_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's issue from /workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/028_security_incidents_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_regulator_correspondence/076_regulator_correspondence_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's severity from /workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/028_security_incidents_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_regulator_correspondence/076_regulator_correspondence_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's primary_source from /workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/028_security_incidents_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_regulator_correspondence/076_regulator_correspondence_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/028_security_incidents_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_regulator_correspondence/076_regulator_correspondence_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-10 using the exact controlled facts ['$2,054,266.00', '$2,215,032.00'].", "id": "findings.F-10.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-10's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-10.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-02', 'Mei Whitaker'] for F-10.", "id": "findings.F-10.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-11 exception for incident-notification clock.", "id": "findings.F-11.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's id from /workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/031_security_incidents_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_regulator_correspondence/079_regulator_correspondence_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's issue from /workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/031_security_incidents_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_regulator_correspondence/079_regulator_correspondence_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's severity from /workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/031_security_incidents_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_regulator_correspondence/079_regulator_correspondence_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's primary_source from /workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/031_security_incidents_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_regulator_correspondence/079_regulator_correspondence_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/031_security_incidents_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_regulator_correspondence/079_regulator_correspondence_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-11 using the exact controlled facts ['Nadine Flores', 'Caleb Hassan'].", "id": "findings.F-11.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-11's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-11.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-02', 'Caleb Hassan'] for F-11.", "id": "findings.F-11.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-12 exception for risk-assessment omission.", "id": "findings.F-12.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's id from /workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/034_consumer_requests_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_risk_assessments/082_risk_assessments_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's issue from /workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/034_consumer_requests_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_risk_assessments/082_risk_assessments_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's severity from /workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/034_consumer_requests_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_risk_assessments/082_risk_assessments_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's primary_source from /workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/034_consumer_requests_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_risk_assessments/082_risk_assessments_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/034_consumer_requests_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_risk_assessments/082_risk_assessments_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-12 using the exact controlled facts ['closed without exception', 'CB-PR-3001-L450', 'open and escalated', 'CB-PR-3001-U334'].", "id": "findings.F-12.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-12's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-12.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-02', 'Leona Park'] for F-12.", "id": "findings.F-12.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-13 exception for sensitive-data classification.", "id": "findings.F-13.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's id from /workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/037_consumer_requests_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_risk_assessments/085_risk_assessments_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's issue from /workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/037_consumer_requests_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_risk_assessments/085_risk_assessments_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's severity from /workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/037_consumer_requests_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_risk_assessments/085_risk_assessments_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's primary_source from /workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/037_consumer_requests_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_risk_assessments/085_risk_assessments_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/037_consumer_requests_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_risk_assessments/085_risk_assessments_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-13 using the exact controlled facts ['California Privacy Protection Agency', 'California'].", "id": "findings.F-13.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-13's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-13.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-02', 'Isaac Romero'] for F-13.", "id": "findings.F-13.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-14 exception for minor-consent issue.", "id": "findings.F-14.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's id from /workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/040_consumer_requests_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_risk_assessments/088_risk_assessments_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's issue from /workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/040_consumer_requests_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_risk_assessments/088_risk_assessments_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's severity from /workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/040_consumer_requests_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_risk_assessments/088_risk_assessments_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's primary_source from /workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/040_consumer_requests_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_risk_assessments/088_risk_assessments_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/040_consumer_requests_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_risk_assessments/088_risk_assessments_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-14 using the exact controlled facts ['5%', '10%'].", "id": "findings.F-14.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-14's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-14.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-02', 'Sofia Bennett'] for F-14.", "id": "findings.F-14.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-15 exception for training completion gap.", "id": "findings.F-15.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's id from /workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/043_notices_consents_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_remediation/091_remediation_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's issue from /workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/043_notices_consents_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_remediation/091_remediation_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's severity from /workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/043_notices_consents_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_remediation/091_remediation_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's primary_source from /workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/043_notices_consents_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_remediation/091_remediation_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/043_notices_consents_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_remediation/091_remediation_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-15 using the exact controlled facts ['notices-arcadia_genomics_inc@example.test', 'archive-north_coast_sequencing_network@example.test'].", "id": "findings.F-15.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-15's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-15.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-02', 'Adrian Mensah'] for F-15.", "id": "findings.F-15.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-16 exception for regulator commitment overdue.", "id": "findings.F-16.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's id from /workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/046_notices_consents_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_remediation/094_remediation_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's issue from /workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/046_notices_consents_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_remediation/094_remediation_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's severity from /workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/046_notices_consents_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_remediation/094_remediation_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's primary_source from /workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/046_notices_consents_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_remediation/094_remediation_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/046_notices_consents_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_remediation/094_remediation_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-16 using the exact controlled facts ['174 records', '2025-09-26', '43 records', '2025-10-11'].", "id": "findings.F-16.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-16's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-16.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-02', 'Willa Novak'] for F-16.", "id": "findings.F-16.action_anchors"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Executive assessment' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Executive assessment"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Method and record coverage' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Method and record coverage"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Findings' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Findings"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Recommended next actions' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Recommended next actions"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Assumptions and limitations' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Assumptions and limitations"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-01 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-01"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-02 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-02"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-03 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-03"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-04 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-04"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-05 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-05"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-06 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-06"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-07 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-07"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-08 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-08"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-09 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-09"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-10 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-10"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-11 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-11"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-12 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-12"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-13 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-13"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-14 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-14"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-15 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-15"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-16 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-16"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Do not claim the production has no issues or that every record is consistent.", "id": "memo.forbidden_claims_absent"}], "decision_options": [{"id": "cross-source-reconciliation", "label": "Reconcile controlling and corroborating records", "reason": "The CB-PR-3001 production contains independently maintained records; a defensible answer must preserve each supported conflict and its cure owner.", "selected": true}, {"id": "latest-record-controls", "label": "Treat the latest record as controlling", "reason": "Timestamp recency does not establish legal priority, execution, or approval authority.", "selected": false}, {"id": "primary-records-only", "label": "Report primary records without reconciliation", "reason": "Primary records alone conceal the operational conflicts that create the actionable exceptions.", "selected": false}], "gates": ["all_evidence_read_in_full", "chain_of_custody_metadata_checked", "findings_criteria_complete", "memo_criteria_complete", "deliverables_written_through_mcp"], "metadata_checks": 8, "metric": "weighted_criteria_score", "minimum_tool_calls": 46, "required_deliverables": ["findings.json", "advice.md"], "required_document_reads": 33, "type": "deterministic", "weights": {"findings": 0.55, "memo": 0.2, "procedure": 0.25}}, "task_id": "cb100-061-arcadia-genomics", "task_name": "Arcadia genomic data response audit", "world_id": "counselbench-filesystem-mcp-v2"}
-{"context_files": ["task_files/cb100-062-brightpath-kids/01_data_inventory/001_data_inventory_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-062-brightpath-kids/01_data_inventory/002_data_inventory_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-062-brightpath-kids/01_data_inventory/003_data_inventory_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-062-brightpath-kids/01_data_inventory/004_data_inventory_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-062-brightpath-kids/01_data_inventory/005_data_inventory_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-062-brightpath-kids/01_data_inventory/006_data_inventory_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-062-brightpath-kids/01_data_inventory/007_data_inventory_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-062-brightpath-kids/01_data_inventory/008_data_inventory_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-062-brightpath-kids/02_processing_records/009_processing_records_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-062-brightpath-kids/02_processing_records/010_processing_records_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-062-brightpath-kids/02_processing_records/011_processing_records_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-062-brightpath-kids/02_processing_records/012_processing_records_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-062-brightpath-kids/02_processing_records/013_processing_records_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-062-brightpath-kids/02_processing_records/014_processing_records_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-062-brightpath-kids/02_processing_records/015_processing_records_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-062-brightpath-kids/02_processing_records/016_processing_records_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-062-brightpath-kids/03_vendor_reviews/017_vendor_reviews_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-062-brightpath-kids/03_vendor_reviews/018_vendor_reviews_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-062-brightpath-kids/03_vendor_reviews/019_vendor_reviews_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-062-brightpath-kids/03_vendor_reviews/020_vendor_reviews_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-062-brightpath-kids/03_vendor_reviews/021_vendor_reviews_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-062-brightpath-kids/03_vendor_reviews/022_vendor_reviews_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-062-brightpath-kids/03_vendor_reviews/023_vendor_reviews_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-062-brightpath-kids/03_vendor_reviews/024_vendor_reviews_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-062-brightpath-kids/04_security_incidents/025_security_incidents_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-062-brightpath-kids/04_security_incidents/026_security_incidents_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-062-brightpath-kids/04_security_incidents/027_security_incidents_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-062-brightpath-kids/04_security_incidents/028_security_incidents_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-062-brightpath-kids/04_security_incidents/029_security_incidents_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-062-brightpath-kids/04_security_incidents/030_security_incidents_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-062-brightpath-kids/04_security_incidents/031_security_incidents_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-062-brightpath-kids/04_security_incidents/032_security_incidents_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-062-brightpath-kids/05_consumer_requests/033_consumer_requests_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-062-brightpath-kids/05_consumer_requests/034_consumer_requests_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-062-brightpath-kids/05_consumer_requests/035_consumer_requests_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-062-brightpath-kids/05_consumer_requests/036_consumer_requests_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-062-brightpath-kids/05_consumer_requests/037_consumer_requests_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-062-brightpath-kids/05_consumer_requests/038_consumer_requests_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-062-brightpath-kids/05_consumer_requests/039_consumer_requests_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-062-brightpath-kids/05_consumer_requests/040_consumer_requests_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-062-brightpath-kids/06_notices_consents/041_notices_consents_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-062-brightpath-kids/06_notices_consents/042_notices_consents_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-062-brightpath-kids/06_notices_consents/043_notices_consents_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-062-brightpath-kids/06_notices_consents/044_notices_consents_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-062-brightpath-kids/06_notices_consents/045_notices_consents_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-062-brightpath-kids/06_notices_consents/046_notices_consents_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-062-brightpath-kids/06_notices_consents/047_notices_consents_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-062-brightpath-kids/06_notices_consents/048_notices_consents_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-062-brightpath-kids/07_transfer_mechanisms/049_transfer_mechanisms_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-062-brightpath-kids/07_transfer_mechanisms/050_transfer_mechanisms_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-062-brightpath-kids/07_transfer_mechanisms/051_transfer_mechanisms_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-062-brightpath-kids/07_transfer_mechanisms/052_transfer_mechanisms_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-062-brightpath-kids/07_transfer_mechanisms/053_transfer_mechanisms_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-062-brightpath-kids/07_transfer_mechanisms/054_transfer_mechanisms_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-062-brightpath-kids/07_transfer_mechanisms/055_transfer_mechanisms_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-062-brightpath-kids/07_transfer_mechanisms/056_transfer_mechanisms_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-062-brightpath-kids/08_retention_deletion/057_retention_deletion_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-062-brightpath-kids/08_retention_deletion/058_retention_deletion_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-062-brightpath-kids/08_retention_deletion/059_retention_deletion_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-062-brightpath-kids/08_retention_deletion/060_retention_deletion_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-062-brightpath-kids/08_retention_deletion/061_retention_deletion_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-062-brightpath-kids/08_retention_deletion/062_retention_deletion_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-062-brightpath-kids/08_retention_deletion/063_retention_deletion_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-062-brightpath-kids/08_retention_deletion/064_retention_deletion_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-062-brightpath-kids/09_training/065_training_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-062-brightpath-kids/09_training/066_training_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-062-brightpath-kids/09_training/067_training_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-062-brightpath-kids/09_training/068_training_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-062-brightpath-kids/09_training/069_training_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-062-brightpath-kids/09_training/070_training_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-062-brightpath-kids/09_training/071_training_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-062-brightpath-kids/09_training/072_training_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-062-brightpath-kids/10_regulator_correspondence/073_regulator_correspondence_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-062-brightpath-kids/10_regulator_correspondence/074_regulator_correspondence_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-062-brightpath-kids/10_regulator_correspondence/075_regulator_correspondence_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-062-brightpath-kids/10_regulator_correspondence/076_regulator_correspondence_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-062-brightpath-kids/10_regulator_correspondence/077_regulator_correspondence_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-062-brightpath-kids/10_regulator_correspondence/078_regulator_correspondence_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-062-brightpath-kids/10_regulator_correspondence/079_regulator_correspondence_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-062-brightpath-kids/10_regulator_correspondence/080_regulator_correspondence_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-062-brightpath-kids/11_risk_assessments/081_risk_assessments_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-062-brightpath-kids/11_risk_assessments/082_risk_assessments_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-062-brightpath-kids/11_risk_assessments/083_risk_assessments_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-062-brightpath-kids/11_risk_assessments/084_risk_assessments_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-062-brightpath-kids/11_risk_assessments/085_risk_assessments_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-062-brightpath-kids/11_risk_assessments/086_risk_assessments_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-062-brightpath-kids/11_risk_assessments/087_risk_assessments_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-062-brightpath-kids/11_risk_assessments/088_risk_assessments_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-062-brightpath-kids/12_remediation/089_remediation_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-062-brightpath-kids/12_remediation/090_remediation_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-062-brightpath-kids/12_remediation/091_remediation_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-062-brightpath-kids/12_remediation/092_remediation_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-062-brightpath-kids/12_remediation/093_remediation_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-062-brightpath-kids/12_remediation/094_remediation_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-062-brightpath-kids/12_remediation/095_remediation_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-062-brightpath-kids/12_remediation/096_remediation_status_report.md"], "gold_output": {"advice_markdown": "# Counsel advice — BrightPath child-privacy compliance review\n\n## Executive assessment\n\nFor BrightPath Learning Apps matter CB-PR-3002, the review identified 16 source-supported exceptions requiring action before 2026-09-06. The assessment concerns Lighthouse School District and the supplied record for Connecticut.\n\n## Method and record coverage\n\nThe review inventoried all 96 production files, read the 33 controlling, corroborating, and control records, searched the email exports, and checked metadata for the designated chain-of-custody sample. Conclusions are limited to the synthetic production supplied for this benchmark matter.\n\n## Findings\n\n### F-01 — processing-purpose gap (critical)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for processing-purpose gap: one source states the operative date is 2025-02-14 under control reference CB-PR-3002-A202, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2025-03-27 under response reference CB-PR-3002-J661.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/001_data_inventory_control_register.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/07_transfer_mechanisms/049_transfer_mechanisms_control_register.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-06, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Maya Ellison.\n\n### F-02 — notice-practice mismatch (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for notice-practice mismatch: one source states the controlling amount is $4,766,642.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $4,979,784.00.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/004_data_inventory_ledger_export.csv`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/07_transfer_mechanisms/052_transfer_mechanisms_ledger_export.csv`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-06, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Rafael Okafor.\n\n### F-03 — consent-record deficiency (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for consent-record deficiency: one source states approval is attributed to Micah Sullivan as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Micah Sullivan and contains no entry for Micah Sullivan.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/007_data_inventory_officer_certificate.html`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/07_transfer_mechanisms/055_transfer_mechanisms_officer_certificate.html`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-06, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Nora Chen.\n\n### F-04 — processor-contract omission (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for processor-contract omission: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-PR-3002-D667, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-PR-3002-M143.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/02_processing_records/010_processing_records_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/08_retention_deletion/058_retention_deletion_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-06, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Dominic Alvarez.\n\n### F-05 — subprocessor inventory mismatch (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for subprocessor inventory mismatch: one source states the applicable location is Connecticut Attorney General, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to Connecticut operations outside Connecticut Attorney General.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/02_processing_records/013_processing_records_review_memorandum.json`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/08_retention_deletion/061_retention_deletion_review_memorandum.json`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-06, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Priya Raman.\n\n### F-06 — cross-border transfer gap (low)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for cross-border transfer gap: one source states the threshold is 8% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 14% and produced a different exception result.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/02_processing_records/016_processing_records_status_report.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/08_retention_deletion/064_retention_deletion_status_report.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-06, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Elliot Mercer.\n\n### F-07 — retention schedule conflict (critical)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for retention schedule conflict: one source states formal notice must use notices-brightpath_learning_apps@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-lighthouse_school_district@example.test.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/019_vendor_reviews_correspondence.eml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/09_training/067_training_correspondence.eml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-06, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Talia Brooks.\n\n### F-08 — deletion-job failure (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for deletion-job failure: one source states the governed population contains 105 records through 2025-07-19, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 35 records through 2025-07-26.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/022_vendor_reviews_formal_notice.xml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/09_training/070_training_formal_notice.xml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-06, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Jonas Feld.\n\n### F-09 — access-request deadline (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for access-request deadline: one source states the operative date is 2026-01-27 under control reference CB-PR-3002-I129, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2026-03-15 under response reference CB-PR-3002-R102.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/025_security_incidents_control_register.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/10_regulator_correspondence/073_regulator_correspondence_control_register.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-06, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Mei Whitaker.\n\n### F-10 — identity-verification inconsistency (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for identity-verification inconsistency: one source states the controlling amount is $1,537,903.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $1,702,306.00.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/028_security_incidents_ledger_export.csv`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/10_regulator_correspondence/076_regulator_correspondence_ledger_export.csv`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-06, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Caleb Hassan.\n\n### F-11 — incident-notification clock (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for incident-notification clock: one source states approval is attributed to Micah Sullivan as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Isaac Romero and contains no entry for Micah Sullivan.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/031_security_incidents_officer_certificate.html`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/10_regulator_correspondence/079_regulator_correspondence_officer_certificate.html`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-06, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Leona Park.\n\n### F-12 — risk-assessment omission (low)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for risk-assessment omission: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-PR-3002-L535, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-PR-3002-U548.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/034_consumer_requests_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/11_risk_assessments/082_risk_assessments_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-06, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Isaac Romero.\n\n### F-13 — sensitive-data classification (critical)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for sensitive-data classification: one source states the applicable location is Connecticut Attorney General, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to Connecticut operations outside Connecticut Attorney General.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/037_consumer_requests_review_memorandum.json`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/11_risk_assessments/085_risk_assessments_review_memorandum.json`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-06, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Sofia Bennett.\n\n### F-14 — minor-consent issue (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for minor-consent issue: one source states the threshold is 2% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 4% and produced a different exception result.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/040_consumer_requests_status_report.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/11_risk_assessments/088_risk_assessments_status_report.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-06, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Adrian Mensah.\n\n### F-15 — training completion gap (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for training completion gap: one source states formal notice must use notices-brightpath_learning_apps@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-lighthouse_school_district@example.test.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/043_notices_consents_correspondence.eml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/12_remediation/091_remediation_correspondence.eml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-06, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Willa Novak.\n\n### F-16 — regulator commitment overdue (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for regulator commitment overdue: one source states the governed population contains 88 records through 2025-11-19, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 36 records through 2025-11-27.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/046_notices_consents_formal_notice.xml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/12_remediation/094_remediation_formal_notice.xml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-06, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Theo Laurent.\n\n## Recommended next actions\n\nSequence the critical and high findings first, assign the named owners, preserve the cited records, and document any resolution in the controlling matter register before the stated deadline.\n\n## Assumptions and limitations\n\nThis analysis is confined to task cb100-062-brightpath-kids and the supplied synthetic evidence. It does not rely on external facts, does not resolve disputed law, and is not legal advice for a real person or entity.\n", "findings": {"as_of": "2026-09-06", "findings": [{"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/07_transfer_mechanisms/049_transfer_mechanisms_control_register.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for processing-purpose gap: one source states the operative date is 2025-02-14 under control reference CB-PR-3002-A202, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2025-03-27 under response reference CB-PR-3002-J661.", "id": "F-01", "issue": "processing-purpose gap", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/001_data_inventory_control_register.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-06, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Maya Ellison.", "severity": "critical"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/07_transfer_mechanisms/052_transfer_mechanisms_ledger_export.csv", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for notice-practice mismatch: one source states the controlling amount is $4,766,642.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $4,979,784.00.", "id": "F-02", "issue": "notice-practice mismatch", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/004_data_inventory_ledger_export.csv", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-06, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Rafael Okafor.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/07_transfer_mechanisms/055_transfer_mechanisms_officer_certificate.html", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for consent-record deficiency: one source states approval is attributed to Micah Sullivan as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Micah Sullivan and contains no entry for Micah Sullivan.", "id": "F-03", "issue": "consent-record deficiency", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/007_data_inventory_officer_certificate.html", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-06, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Nora Chen.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/08_retention_deletion/058_retention_deletion_executed_instrument.txt", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for processor-contract omission: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-PR-3002-D667, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-PR-3002-M143.", "id": "F-04", "issue": "processor-contract omission", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/02_processing_records/010_processing_records_executed_instrument.txt", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-06, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Dominic Alvarez.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/08_retention_deletion/061_retention_deletion_review_memorandum.json", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for subprocessor inventory mismatch: one source states the applicable location is Connecticut Attorney General, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to Connecticut operations outside Connecticut Attorney General.", "id": "F-05", "issue": "subprocessor inventory mismatch", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/02_processing_records/013_processing_records_review_memorandum.json", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-06, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Priya Raman.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/08_retention_deletion/064_retention_deletion_status_report.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for cross-border transfer gap: one source states the threshold is 8% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 14% and produced a different exception result.", "id": "F-06", "issue": "cross-border transfer gap", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/02_processing_records/016_processing_records_status_report.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-06, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Elliot Mercer.", "severity": "low"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/09_training/067_training_correspondence.eml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for retention schedule conflict: one source states formal notice must use notices-brightpath_learning_apps@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-lighthouse_school_district@example.test.", "id": "F-07", "issue": "retention schedule conflict", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/019_vendor_reviews_correspondence.eml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-06, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Talia Brooks.", "severity": "critical"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/09_training/070_training_formal_notice.xml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for deletion-job failure: one source states the governed population contains 105 records through 2025-07-19, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 35 records through 2025-07-26.", "id": "F-08", "issue": "deletion-job failure", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/022_vendor_reviews_formal_notice.xml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-06, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Jonas Feld.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/10_regulator_correspondence/073_regulator_correspondence_control_register.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for access-request deadline: one source states the operative date is 2026-01-27 under control reference CB-PR-3002-I129, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2026-03-15 under response reference CB-PR-3002-R102.", "id": "F-09", "issue": "access-request deadline", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/025_security_incidents_control_register.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-06, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Mei Whitaker.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/10_regulator_correspondence/076_regulator_correspondence_ledger_export.csv", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for identity-verification inconsistency: one source states the controlling amount is $1,537,903.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $1,702,306.00.", "id": "F-10", "issue": "identity-verification inconsistency", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/028_security_incidents_ledger_export.csv", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-06, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Caleb Hassan.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/10_regulator_correspondence/079_regulator_correspondence_officer_certificate.html", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for incident-notification clock: one source states approval is attributed to Micah Sullivan as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Isaac Romero and contains no entry for Micah Sullivan.", "id": "F-11", "issue": "incident-notification clock", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/031_security_incidents_officer_certificate.html", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-06, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Leona Park.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/11_risk_assessments/082_risk_assessments_executed_instrument.txt", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for risk-assessment omission: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-PR-3002-L535, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-PR-3002-U548.", "id": "F-12", "issue": "risk-assessment omission", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/034_consumer_requests_executed_instrument.txt", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-06, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Isaac Romero.", "severity": "low"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/11_risk_assessments/085_risk_assessments_review_memorandum.json", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for sensitive-data classification: one source states the applicable location is Connecticut Attorney General, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to Connecticut operations outside Connecticut Attorney General.", "id": "F-13", "issue": "sensitive-data classification", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/037_consumer_requests_review_memorandum.json", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-06, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Sofia Bennett.", "severity": "critical"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/11_risk_assessments/088_risk_assessments_status_report.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for minor-consent issue: one source states the threshold is 2% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 4% and produced a different exception result.", "id": "F-14", "issue": "minor-consent issue", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/040_consumer_requests_status_report.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-06, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Adrian Mensah.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/091_remediation_correspondence.eml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for training completion gap: one source states formal notice must use notices-brightpath_learning_apps@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-lighthouse_school_district@example.test.", "id": "F-15", "issue": "training completion gap", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/043_notices_consents_correspondence.eml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-06, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Willa Novak.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/094_remediation_formal_notice.xml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for regulator commitment overdue: one source states the governed population contains 88 records through 2025-11-19, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 36 records through 2025-11-27.", "id": "F-16", "issue": "regulator commitment overdue", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/046_notices_consents_formal_notice.xml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-06, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Theo Laurent.", "severity": "medium"}], "matter_number": "CB-PR-3002", "prepared_for": "BrightPath Learning Apps", "schema_version": "1.0", "task_id": "cb100-062-brightpath-kids"}}, "metadata": {"benchmark": "CounselBench-100", "code_license": "Apache-2.0", "data_license": "CC-BY-4.0", "deadline": "2026-09-06", "document_count": 96, "jurisdiction": "Connecticut", "matter_number": "CB-PR-3002", "mcp_commit": "9a96ea6e5913736f92b88345bf51caeaaa8e719f", "mcp_package": "@modelcontextprotocol/server-filesystem@2026.7.10", "practice_area": "privacy-regulatory", "reference_tool_calls": 46, "required_evidence_reads": 33, "synthetic": true, "venue": "Connecticut Attorney General", "version": "2.0.0"}, "prompt": "You are privacy and regulatory counsel for BrightPath Learning Apps. A late document production changed the factual picture, and the matter team needs the entire record reconciled from first principles. An education app collected voice samples under school consent while subprocessor and deletion records lagged product changes. Decision due 2026-09-06. Connecticut law governs; Connecticut Attorney General is the forum. Separate confirmed exceptions from items that merely require follow-up. Work out the defensible position from the matter production and leave an audit-ready exception tracker and concise advice for the supervising lawyer. Keep confirmed conflicts separate from open questions, cite the records that actually control each conclusion, and do not fill gaps with outside facts.", "rubric": {"criteria": [{"category": "procedure", "description": "Complete at least 46 successful, argument-specific evidence and output calls.", "id": "procedure.minimum_successful_tool_calls"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Find and read the 33 controlling, corroborating, and work-product-control records in full.", "id": "procedure.all_evidence_read_in_full"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Inspect file metadata for the eight designated critical primary records before relying on them.", "id": "procedure.chain_of_custody_metadata_checked"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Confirm the sandbox's allowed document and output roots.", "id": "procedure.allowed_directories_checked"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Inventory all 96 records so the relevant sources are discovered among the context records.", "id": "procedure.recursive_inventory_completed"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Search the production for email evidence that may corroborate or contradict formal records.", "id": "procedure.targeted_search_completed"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Leave only findings.json and advice.md in the output workspace.", "id": "procedure.exact_deliverable_set"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Create both final work products through the sandbox MCP surface.", "id": "procedure.deliverables_written_through_mcp"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Produce findings.json as a valid JSON object.", "id": "findings.findings_is_object"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Report exactly 16 confirmed exceptions.", "id": "findings.findings_exact_count"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Use each stable finding ID exactly once.", "id": "findings.finding_ids_unique"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set schema_version to the released matter value '1.0'.", "id": "findings.top_level_schema_version"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set task_id to the released matter value 'cb100-062-brightpath-kids'.", "id": "findings.top_level_task_id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set matter_number to the released matter value 'CB-PR-3002'.", "id": "findings.top_level_matter_number"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set prepared_for to the released matter value 'BrightPath Learning Apps'.", "id": "findings.top_level_prepared_for"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set as_of to the released matter value '2026-09-06'.", "id": "findings.top_level_as_of"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-01 exception for processing-purpose gap.", "id": "findings.F-01.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's id from /workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/001_data_inventory_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_transfer_mechanisms/049_transfer_mechanisms_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's issue from /workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/001_data_inventory_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_transfer_mechanisms/049_transfer_mechanisms_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's severity from /workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/001_data_inventory_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_transfer_mechanisms/049_transfer_mechanisms_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's primary_source from /workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/001_data_inventory_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_transfer_mechanisms/049_transfer_mechanisms_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/001_data_inventory_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_transfer_mechanisms/049_transfer_mechanisms_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-01 using the exact controlled facts ['2025-02-14', 'CB-PR-3002-A202', '2025-03-27', 'CB-PR-3002-J661'].", "id": "findings.F-01.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-01's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-01.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-06', 'Maya Ellison'] for F-01.", "id": "findings.F-01.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-02 exception for notice-practice mismatch.", "id": "findings.F-02.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's id from /workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/004_data_inventory_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_transfer_mechanisms/052_transfer_mechanisms_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's issue from /workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/004_data_inventory_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_transfer_mechanisms/052_transfer_mechanisms_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's severity from /workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/004_data_inventory_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_transfer_mechanisms/052_transfer_mechanisms_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's primary_source from /workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/004_data_inventory_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_transfer_mechanisms/052_transfer_mechanisms_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/004_data_inventory_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_transfer_mechanisms/052_transfer_mechanisms_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-02 using the exact controlled facts ['$4,766,642.00', '$4,979,784.00'].", "id": "findings.F-02.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-02's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-02.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-06', 'Rafael Okafor'] for F-02.", "id": "findings.F-02.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-03 exception for consent-record deficiency.", "id": "findings.F-03.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's id from /workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/007_data_inventory_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_transfer_mechanisms/055_transfer_mechanisms_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's issue from /workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/007_data_inventory_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_transfer_mechanisms/055_transfer_mechanisms_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's severity from /workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/007_data_inventory_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_transfer_mechanisms/055_transfer_mechanisms_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's primary_source from /workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/007_data_inventory_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_transfer_mechanisms/055_transfer_mechanisms_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/007_data_inventory_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_transfer_mechanisms/055_transfer_mechanisms_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-03 using the exact controlled facts ['Micah Sullivan', 'Micah Sullivan'].", "id": "findings.F-03.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-03's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-03.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-06', 'Nora Chen'] for F-03.", "id": "findings.F-03.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-04 exception for processor-contract omission.", "id": "findings.F-04.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's id from /workspace/documents/02_processing_records/010_processing_records_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_retention_deletion/058_retention_deletion_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's issue from /workspace/documents/02_processing_records/010_processing_records_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_retention_deletion/058_retention_deletion_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's severity from /workspace/documents/02_processing_records/010_processing_records_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_retention_deletion/058_retention_deletion_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's primary_source from /workspace/documents/02_processing_records/010_processing_records_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_retention_deletion/058_retention_deletion_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/02_processing_records/010_processing_records_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_retention_deletion/058_retention_deletion_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-04 using the exact controlled facts ['closed without exception', 'CB-PR-3002-D667', 'open and escalated', 'CB-PR-3002-M143'].", "id": "findings.F-04.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-04's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-04.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-06', 'Dominic Alvarez'] for F-04.", "id": "findings.F-04.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-05 exception for subprocessor inventory mismatch.", "id": "findings.F-05.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's id from /workspace/documents/02_processing_records/013_processing_records_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_retention_deletion/061_retention_deletion_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's issue from /workspace/documents/02_processing_records/013_processing_records_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_retention_deletion/061_retention_deletion_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's severity from /workspace/documents/02_processing_records/013_processing_records_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_retention_deletion/061_retention_deletion_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's primary_source from /workspace/documents/02_processing_records/013_processing_records_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_retention_deletion/061_retention_deletion_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/02_processing_records/013_processing_records_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_retention_deletion/061_retention_deletion_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-05 using the exact controlled facts ['Connecticut Attorney General', 'Connecticut'].", "id": "findings.F-05.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-05's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-05.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-06', 'Priya Raman'] for F-05.", "id": "findings.F-05.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-06 exception for cross-border transfer gap.", "id": "findings.F-06.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's id from /workspace/documents/02_processing_records/016_processing_records_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_retention_deletion/064_retention_deletion_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's issue from /workspace/documents/02_processing_records/016_processing_records_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_retention_deletion/064_retention_deletion_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's severity from /workspace/documents/02_processing_records/016_processing_records_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_retention_deletion/064_retention_deletion_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's primary_source from /workspace/documents/02_processing_records/016_processing_records_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_retention_deletion/064_retention_deletion_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/02_processing_records/016_processing_records_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_retention_deletion/064_retention_deletion_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-06 using the exact controlled facts ['8%', '14%'].", "id": "findings.F-06.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-06's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-06.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-06', 'Elliot Mercer'] for F-06.", "id": "findings.F-06.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-07 exception for retention schedule conflict.", "id": "findings.F-07.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's id from /workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/019_vendor_reviews_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_training/067_training_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's issue from /workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/019_vendor_reviews_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_training/067_training_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's severity from /workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/019_vendor_reviews_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_training/067_training_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's primary_source from /workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/019_vendor_reviews_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_training/067_training_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/019_vendor_reviews_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_training/067_training_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-07 using the exact controlled facts ['notices-brightpath_learning_apps@example.test', 'archive-lighthouse_school_district@example.test'].", "id": "findings.F-07.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-07's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-07.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-06', 'Talia Brooks'] for F-07.", "id": "findings.F-07.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-08 exception for deletion-job failure.", "id": "findings.F-08.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's id from /workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/022_vendor_reviews_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_training/070_training_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's issue from /workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/022_vendor_reviews_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_training/070_training_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's severity from /workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/022_vendor_reviews_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_training/070_training_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's primary_source from /workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/022_vendor_reviews_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_training/070_training_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/022_vendor_reviews_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_training/070_training_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-08 using the exact controlled facts ['105 records', '2025-07-19', '35 records', '2025-07-26'].", "id": "findings.F-08.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-08's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-08.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-06', 'Jonas Feld'] for F-08.", "id": "findings.F-08.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-09 exception for access-request deadline.", "id": "findings.F-09.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's id from /workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/025_security_incidents_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_regulator_correspondence/073_regulator_correspondence_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's issue from /workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/025_security_incidents_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_regulator_correspondence/073_regulator_correspondence_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's severity from /workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/025_security_incidents_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_regulator_correspondence/073_regulator_correspondence_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's primary_source from /workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/025_security_incidents_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_regulator_correspondence/073_regulator_correspondence_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/025_security_incidents_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_regulator_correspondence/073_regulator_correspondence_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-09 using the exact controlled facts ['2026-01-27', 'CB-PR-3002-I129', '2026-03-15', 'CB-PR-3002-R102'].", "id": "findings.F-09.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-09's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-09.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-06', 'Mei Whitaker'] for F-09.", "id": "findings.F-09.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-10 exception for identity-verification inconsistency.", "id": "findings.F-10.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's id from /workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/028_security_incidents_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_regulator_correspondence/076_regulator_correspondence_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's issue from /workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/028_security_incidents_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_regulator_correspondence/076_regulator_correspondence_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's severity from /workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/028_security_incidents_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_regulator_correspondence/076_regulator_correspondence_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's primary_source from /workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/028_security_incidents_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_regulator_correspondence/076_regulator_correspondence_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/028_security_incidents_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_regulator_correspondence/076_regulator_correspondence_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-10 using the exact controlled facts ['$1,537,903.00', '$1,702,306.00'].", "id": "findings.F-10.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-10's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-10.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-06', 'Caleb Hassan'] for F-10.", "id": "findings.F-10.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-11 exception for incident-notification clock.", "id": "findings.F-11.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's id from /workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/031_security_incidents_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_regulator_correspondence/079_regulator_correspondence_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's issue from /workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/031_security_incidents_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_regulator_correspondence/079_regulator_correspondence_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's severity from /workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/031_security_incidents_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_regulator_correspondence/079_regulator_correspondence_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's primary_source from /workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/031_security_incidents_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_regulator_correspondence/079_regulator_correspondence_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/031_security_incidents_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_regulator_correspondence/079_regulator_correspondence_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-11 using the exact controlled facts ['Micah Sullivan', 'Isaac Romero'].", "id": "findings.F-11.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-11's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-11.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-06', 'Leona Park'] for F-11.", "id": "findings.F-11.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-12 exception for risk-assessment omission.", "id": "findings.F-12.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's id from /workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/034_consumer_requests_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_risk_assessments/082_risk_assessments_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's issue from /workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/034_consumer_requests_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_risk_assessments/082_risk_assessments_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's severity from /workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/034_consumer_requests_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_risk_assessments/082_risk_assessments_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's primary_source from /workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/034_consumer_requests_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_risk_assessments/082_risk_assessments_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/034_consumer_requests_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_risk_assessments/082_risk_assessments_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-12 using the exact controlled facts ['closed without exception', 'CB-PR-3002-L535', 'open and escalated', 'CB-PR-3002-U548'].", "id": "findings.F-12.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-12's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-12.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-06', 'Isaac Romero'] for F-12.", "id": "findings.F-12.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-13 exception for sensitive-data classification.", "id": "findings.F-13.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's id from /workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/037_consumer_requests_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_risk_assessments/085_risk_assessments_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's issue from /workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/037_consumer_requests_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_risk_assessments/085_risk_assessments_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's severity from /workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/037_consumer_requests_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_risk_assessments/085_risk_assessments_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's primary_source from /workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/037_consumer_requests_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_risk_assessments/085_risk_assessments_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/037_consumer_requests_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_risk_assessments/085_risk_assessments_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-13 using the exact controlled facts ['Connecticut Attorney General', 'Connecticut'].", "id": "findings.F-13.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-13's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-13.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-06', 'Sofia Bennett'] for F-13.", "id": "findings.F-13.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-14 exception for minor-consent issue.", "id": "findings.F-14.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's id from /workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/040_consumer_requests_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_risk_assessments/088_risk_assessments_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's issue from /workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/040_consumer_requests_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_risk_assessments/088_risk_assessments_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's severity from /workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/040_consumer_requests_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_risk_assessments/088_risk_assessments_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's primary_source from /workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/040_consumer_requests_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_risk_assessments/088_risk_assessments_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/040_consumer_requests_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_risk_assessments/088_risk_assessments_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-14 using the exact controlled facts ['2%', '4%'].", "id": "findings.F-14.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-14's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-14.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-06', 'Adrian Mensah'] for F-14.", "id": "findings.F-14.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-15 exception for training completion gap.", "id": "findings.F-15.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's id from /workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/043_notices_consents_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_remediation/091_remediation_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's issue from /workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/043_notices_consents_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_remediation/091_remediation_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's severity from /workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/043_notices_consents_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_remediation/091_remediation_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's primary_source from /workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/043_notices_consents_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_remediation/091_remediation_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/043_notices_consents_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_remediation/091_remediation_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-15 using the exact controlled facts ['notices-brightpath_learning_apps@example.test', 'archive-lighthouse_school_district@example.test'].", "id": "findings.F-15.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-15's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-15.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-06', 'Willa Novak'] for F-15.", "id": "findings.F-15.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-16 exception for regulator commitment overdue.", "id": "findings.F-16.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's id from /workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/046_notices_consents_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_remediation/094_remediation_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's issue from /workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/046_notices_consents_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_remediation/094_remediation_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's severity from /workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/046_notices_consents_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_remediation/094_remediation_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's primary_source from /workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/046_notices_consents_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_remediation/094_remediation_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/046_notices_consents_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_remediation/094_remediation_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-16 using the exact controlled facts ['88 records', '2025-11-19', '36 records', '2025-11-27'].", "id": "findings.F-16.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-16's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-16.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-06', 'Theo Laurent'] for F-16.", "id": "findings.F-16.action_anchors"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Executive assessment' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Executive assessment"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Method and record coverage' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Method and record coverage"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Findings' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Findings"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Recommended next actions' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Recommended next actions"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Assumptions and limitations' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Assumptions and limitations"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-01 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-01"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-02 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-02"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-03 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-03"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-04 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-04"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-05 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-05"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-06 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-06"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-07 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-07"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-08 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-08"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-09 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-09"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-10 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-10"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-11 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-11"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-12 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-12"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-13 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-13"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-14 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-14"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-15 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-15"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-16 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-16"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Do not claim the production has no issues or that every record is consistent.", "id": "memo.forbidden_claims_absent"}], "decision_options": [{"id": "cross-source-reconciliation", "label": "Reconcile controlling and corroborating records", "reason": "The CB-PR-3002 production contains independently maintained records; a defensible answer must preserve each supported conflict and its cure owner.", "selected": true}, {"id": "latest-record-controls", "label": "Treat the latest record as controlling", "reason": "Timestamp recency does not establish legal priority, execution, or approval authority.", "selected": false}, {"id": "primary-records-only", "label": "Report primary records without reconciliation", "reason": "Primary records alone conceal the operational conflicts that create the actionable exceptions.", "selected": false}], "gates": ["all_evidence_read_in_full", "chain_of_custody_metadata_checked", "findings_criteria_complete", "memo_criteria_complete", "deliverables_written_through_mcp"], "metadata_checks": 8, "metric": "weighted_criteria_score", "minimum_tool_calls": 46, "required_deliverables": ["findings.json", "advice.md"], "required_document_reads": 33, "type": "deterministic", "weights": {"findings": 0.55, "memo": 0.2, "procedure": 0.25}}, "task_id": "cb100-062-brightpath-kids", "task_name": "BrightPath child-privacy compliance review", "world_id": "counselbench-filesystem-mcp-v2"}
-{"context_files": ["task_files/cb100-063-civic-route/01_data_inventory/001_data_inventory_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-063-civic-route/01_data_inventory/002_data_inventory_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-063-civic-route/01_data_inventory/003_data_inventory_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-063-civic-route/01_data_inventory/004_data_inventory_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-063-civic-route/01_data_inventory/005_data_inventory_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-063-civic-route/01_data_inventory/006_data_inventory_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-063-civic-route/01_data_inventory/007_data_inventory_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-063-civic-route/01_data_inventory/008_data_inventory_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-063-civic-route/02_processing_records/009_processing_records_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-063-civic-route/02_processing_records/010_processing_records_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-063-civic-route/02_processing_records/011_processing_records_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-063-civic-route/02_processing_records/012_processing_records_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-063-civic-route/02_processing_records/013_processing_records_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-063-civic-route/02_processing_records/014_processing_records_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-063-civic-route/02_processing_records/015_processing_records_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-063-civic-route/02_processing_records/016_processing_records_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-063-civic-route/03_vendor_reviews/017_vendor_reviews_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-063-civic-route/03_vendor_reviews/018_vendor_reviews_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-063-civic-route/03_vendor_reviews/019_vendor_reviews_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-063-civic-route/03_vendor_reviews/020_vendor_reviews_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-063-civic-route/03_vendor_reviews/021_vendor_reviews_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-063-civic-route/03_vendor_reviews/022_vendor_reviews_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-063-civic-route/03_vendor_reviews/023_vendor_reviews_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-063-civic-route/03_vendor_reviews/024_vendor_reviews_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-063-civic-route/04_security_incidents/025_security_incidents_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-063-civic-route/04_security_incidents/026_security_incidents_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-063-civic-route/04_security_incidents/027_security_incidents_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-063-civic-route/04_security_incidents/028_security_incidents_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-063-civic-route/04_security_incidents/029_security_incidents_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-063-civic-route/04_security_incidents/030_security_incidents_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-063-civic-route/04_security_incidents/031_security_incidents_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-063-civic-route/04_security_incidents/032_security_incidents_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-063-civic-route/05_consumer_requests/033_consumer_requests_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-063-civic-route/05_consumer_requests/034_consumer_requests_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-063-civic-route/05_consumer_requests/035_consumer_requests_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-063-civic-route/05_consumer_requests/036_consumer_requests_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-063-civic-route/05_consumer_requests/037_consumer_requests_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-063-civic-route/05_consumer_requests/038_consumer_requests_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-063-civic-route/05_consumer_requests/039_consumer_requests_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-063-civic-route/05_consumer_requests/040_consumer_requests_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-063-civic-route/06_notices_consents/041_notices_consents_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-063-civic-route/06_notices_consents/042_notices_consents_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-063-civic-route/06_notices_consents/043_notices_consents_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-063-civic-route/06_notices_consents/044_notices_consents_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-063-civic-route/06_notices_consents/045_notices_consents_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-063-civic-route/06_notices_consents/046_notices_consents_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-063-civic-route/06_notices_consents/047_notices_consents_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-063-civic-route/06_notices_consents/048_notices_consents_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-063-civic-route/07_transfer_mechanisms/049_transfer_mechanisms_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-063-civic-route/07_transfer_mechanisms/050_transfer_mechanisms_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-063-civic-route/07_transfer_mechanisms/051_transfer_mechanisms_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-063-civic-route/07_transfer_mechanisms/052_transfer_mechanisms_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-063-civic-route/07_transfer_mechanisms/053_transfer_mechanisms_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-063-civic-route/07_transfer_mechanisms/054_transfer_mechanisms_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-063-civic-route/07_transfer_mechanisms/055_transfer_mechanisms_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-063-civic-route/07_transfer_mechanisms/056_transfer_mechanisms_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-063-civic-route/08_retention_deletion/057_retention_deletion_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-063-civic-route/08_retention_deletion/058_retention_deletion_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-063-civic-route/08_retention_deletion/059_retention_deletion_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-063-civic-route/08_retention_deletion/060_retention_deletion_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-063-civic-route/08_retention_deletion/061_retention_deletion_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-063-civic-route/08_retention_deletion/062_retention_deletion_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-063-civic-route/08_retention_deletion/063_retention_deletion_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-063-civic-route/08_retention_deletion/064_retention_deletion_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-063-civic-route/09_training/065_training_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-063-civic-route/09_training/066_training_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-063-civic-route/09_training/067_training_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-063-civic-route/09_training/068_training_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-063-civic-route/09_training/069_training_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-063-civic-route/09_training/070_training_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-063-civic-route/09_training/071_training_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-063-civic-route/09_training/072_training_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-063-civic-route/10_regulator_correspondence/073_regulator_correspondence_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-063-civic-route/10_regulator_correspondence/074_regulator_correspondence_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-063-civic-route/10_regulator_correspondence/075_regulator_correspondence_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-063-civic-route/10_regulator_correspondence/076_regulator_correspondence_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-063-civic-route/10_regulator_correspondence/077_regulator_correspondence_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-063-civic-route/10_regulator_correspondence/078_regulator_correspondence_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-063-civic-route/10_regulator_correspondence/079_regulator_correspondence_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-063-civic-route/10_regulator_correspondence/080_regulator_correspondence_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-063-civic-route/11_risk_assessments/081_risk_assessments_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-063-civic-route/11_risk_assessments/082_risk_assessments_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-063-civic-route/11_risk_assessments/083_risk_assessments_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-063-civic-route/11_risk_assessments/084_risk_assessments_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-063-civic-route/11_risk_assessments/085_risk_assessments_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-063-civic-route/11_risk_assessments/086_risk_assessments_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-063-civic-route/11_risk_assessments/087_risk_assessments_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-063-civic-route/11_risk_assessments/088_risk_assessments_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-063-civic-route/12_remediation/089_remediation_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-063-civic-route/12_remediation/090_remediation_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-063-civic-route/12_remediation/091_remediation_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-063-civic-route/12_remediation/092_remediation_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-063-civic-route/12_remediation/093_remediation_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-063-civic-route/12_remediation/094_remediation_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-063-civic-route/12_remediation/095_remediation_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-063-civic-route/12_remediation/096_remediation_status_report.md"], "gold_output": {"advice_markdown": "# Counsel advice — CivicRoute location-data inquiry\n\n## Executive assessment\n\nFor CivicRoute Mobility matter CB-PR-3003, the review identified 16 source-supported exceptions requiring action before 2026-09-09. The assessment concerns MetroPulse Advertising LLC and the supplied record for Colorado.\n\n## Method and record coverage\n\nThe review inventoried all 96 production files, read the 33 controlling, corroborating, and control records, searched the email exports, and checked metadata for the designated chain-of-custody sample. Conclusions are limited to the synthetic production supplied for this benchmark matter.\n\n## Findings\n\n### F-01 — processing-purpose gap (critical)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for processing-purpose gap: one source states the operative date is 2025-10-15 under control reference CB-PR-3003-A505, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2025-11-29 under response reference CB-PR-3003-J961.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/001_data_inventory_control_register.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/07_transfer_mechanisms/049_transfer_mechanisms_control_register.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-09, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Rafael Okafor.\n\n### F-02 — notice-practice mismatch (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for notice-practice mismatch: one source states the controlling amount is $4,168,080.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $4,342,660.00.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/004_data_inventory_ledger_export.csv`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/07_transfer_mechanisms/052_transfer_mechanisms_ledger_export.csv`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-09, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Nora Chen.\n\n### F-03 — consent-record deficiency (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for consent-record deficiency: one source states approval is attributed to Farah Ibrahim as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Owen Delgado and contains no entry for Farah Ibrahim.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/007_data_inventory_officer_certificate.html`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/07_transfer_mechanisms/055_transfer_mechanisms_officer_certificate.html`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-09, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Dominic Alvarez.\n\n### F-04 — processor-contract omission (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for processor-contract omission: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-PR-3003-D509, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-PR-3003-M962.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/02_processing_records/010_processing_records_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/08_retention_deletion/058_retention_deletion_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-09, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Priya Raman.\n\n### F-05 — subprocessor inventory mismatch (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for subprocessor inventory mismatch: one source states the applicable location is Colorado Attorney General, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to Colorado operations outside Colorado Attorney General.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/02_processing_records/013_processing_records_review_memorandum.json`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/08_retention_deletion/061_retention_deletion_review_memorandum.json`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-09, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Elliot Mercer.\n\n### F-06 — cross-border transfer gap (low)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for cross-border transfer gap: one source states the threshold is 9% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 14% and produced a different exception result.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/02_processing_records/016_processing_records_status_report.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/08_retention_deletion/064_retention_deletion_status_report.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-09, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Talia Brooks.\n\n### F-07 — retention schedule conflict (critical)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for retention schedule conflict: one source states formal notice must use notices-civicroute_mobility@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-metropulse_advertising_llc@example.test.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/019_vendor_reviews_correspondence.eml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/09_training/067_training_correspondence.eml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-09, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Jonas Feld.\n\n### F-08 — deletion-job failure (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for deletion-job failure: one source states the governed population contains 118 records through 2025-03-14, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 42 records through 2025-03-28.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/022_vendor_reviews_formal_notice.xml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/09_training/070_training_formal_notice.xml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-09, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Mei Whitaker.\n\n### F-09 — access-request deadline (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for access-request deadline: one source states the operative date is 2025-11-08 under control reference CB-PR-3003-I529, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2025-12-19 under response reference CB-PR-3003-R825.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/025_security_incidents_control_register.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/10_regulator_correspondence/073_regulator_correspondence_control_register.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-09, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Caleb Hassan.\n\n### F-10 — identity-verification inconsistency (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for identity-verification inconsistency: one source states the controlling amount is $4,478,117.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $4,702,734.00.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/028_security_incidents_ledger_export.csv`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/10_regulator_correspondence/076_regulator_correspondence_ledger_export.csv`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-09, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Leona Park.\n\n### F-11 — incident-notification clock (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for incident-notification clock: one source states approval is attributed to Farah Ibrahim as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Adrian Mensah and contains no entry for Farah Ibrahim.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/031_security_incidents_officer_certificate.html`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/10_regulator_correspondence/079_regulator_correspondence_officer_certificate.html`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-09, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Isaac Romero.\n\n### F-12 — risk-assessment omission (low)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for risk-assessment omission: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-PR-3003-L657, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-PR-3003-U350.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/034_consumer_requests_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/11_risk_assessments/082_risk_assessments_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-09, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Sofia Bennett.\n\n### F-13 — sensitive-data classification (critical)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for sensitive-data classification: one source states the applicable location is Colorado Attorney General, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to Colorado operations outside Colorado Attorney General.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/037_consumer_requests_review_memorandum.json`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/11_risk_assessments/085_risk_assessments_review_memorandum.json`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-09, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Adrian Mensah.\n\n### F-14 — minor-consent issue (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for minor-consent issue: one source states the threshold is 15% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 18% and produced a different exception result.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/040_consumer_requests_status_report.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/11_risk_assessments/088_risk_assessments_status_report.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-09, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Willa Novak.\n\n### F-15 — training completion gap (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for training completion gap: one source states formal notice must use notices-civicroute_mobility@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-metropulse_advertising_llc@example.test.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/043_notices_consents_correspondence.eml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/12_remediation/091_remediation_correspondence.eml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-09, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Theo Laurent.\n\n### F-16 — regulator commitment overdue (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for regulator commitment overdue: one source states the governed population contains 94 records through 2025-07-08, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 59 records through 2025-08-08.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/046_notices_consents_formal_notice.xml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/12_remediation/094_remediation_formal_notice.xml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-09, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Amara Patel.\n\n## Recommended next actions\n\nSequence the critical and high findings first, assign the named owners, preserve the cited records, and document any resolution in the controlling matter register before the stated deadline.\n\n## Assumptions and limitations\n\nThis analysis is confined to task cb100-063-civic-route and the supplied synthetic evidence. It does not rely on external facts, does not resolve disputed law, and is not legal advice for a real person or entity.\n", "findings": {"as_of": "2026-09-09", "findings": [{"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/07_transfer_mechanisms/049_transfer_mechanisms_control_register.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for processing-purpose gap: one source states the operative date is 2025-10-15 under control reference CB-PR-3003-A505, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2025-11-29 under response reference CB-PR-3003-J961.", "id": "F-01", "issue": "processing-purpose gap", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/001_data_inventory_control_register.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-09, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Rafael Okafor.", "severity": "critical"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/07_transfer_mechanisms/052_transfer_mechanisms_ledger_export.csv", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for notice-practice mismatch: one source states the controlling amount is $4,168,080.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $4,342,660.00.", "id": "F-02", "issue": "notice-practice mismatch", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/004_data_inventory_ledger_export.csv", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-09, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Nora Chen.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/07_transfer_mechanisms/055_transfer_mechanisms_officer_certificate.html", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for consent-record deficiency: one source states approval is attributed to Farah Ibrahim as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Owen Delgado and contains no entry for Farah Ibrahim.", "id": "F-03", "issue": "consent-record deficiency", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/007_data_inventory_officer_certificate.html", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-09, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Dominic Alvarez.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/08_retention_deletion/058_retention_deletion_executed_instrument.txt", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for processor-contract omission: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-PR-3003-D509, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-PR-3003-M962.", "id": "F-04", "issue": "processor-contract omission", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/02_processing_records/010_processing_records_executed_instrument.txt", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-09, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Priya Raman.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/08_retention_deletion/061_retention_deletion_review_memorandum.json", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for subprocessor inventory mismatch: one source states the applicable location is Colorado Attorney General, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to Colorado operations outside Colorado Attorney General.", "id": "F-05", "issue": "subprocessor inventory mismatch", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/02_processing_records/013_processing_records_review_memorandum.json", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-09, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Elliot Mercer.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/08_retention_deletion/064_retention_deletion_status_report.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for cross-border transfer gap: one source states the threshold is 9% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 14% and produced a different exception result.", "id": "F-06", "issue": "cross-border transfer gap", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/02_processing_records/016_processing_records_status_report.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-09, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Talia Brooks.", "severity": "low"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/09_training/067_training_correspondence.eml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for retention schedule conflict: one source states formal notice must use notices-civicroute_mobility@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-metropulse_advertising_llc@example.test.", "id": "F-07", "issue": "retention schedule conflict", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/019_vendor_reviews_correspondence.eml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-09, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Jonas Feld.", "severity": "critical"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/09_training/070_training_formal_notice.xml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for deletion-job failure: one source states the governed population contains 118 records through 2025-03-14, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 42 records through 2025-03-28.", "id": "F-08", "issue": "deletion-job failure", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/022_vendor_reviews_formal_notice.xml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-09, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Mei Whitaker.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/10_regulator_correspondence/073_regulator_correspondence_control_register.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for access-request deadline: one source states the operative date is 2025-11-08 under control reference CB-PR-3003-I529, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2025-12-19 under response reference CB-PR-3003-R825.", "id": "F-09", "issue": "access-request deadline", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/025_security_incidents_control_register.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-09, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Caleb Hassan.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/10_regulator_correspondence/076_regulator_correspondence_ledger_export.csv", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for identity-verification inconsistency: one source states the controlling amount is $4,478,117.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $4,702,734.00.", "id": "F-10", "issue": "identity-verification inconsistency", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/028_security_incidents_ledger_export.csv", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-09, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Leona Park.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/10_regulator_correspondence/079_regulator_correspondence_officer_certificate.html", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for incident-notification clock: one source states approval is attributed to Farah Ibrahim as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Adrian Mensah and contains no entry for Farah Ibrahim.", "id": "F-11", "issue": "incident-notification clock", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/031_security_incidents_officer_certificate.html", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-09, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Isaac Romero.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/11_risk_assessments/082_risk_assessments_executed_instrument.txt", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for risk-assessment omission: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-PR-3003-L657, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-PR-3003-U350.", "id": "F-12", "issue": "risk-assessment omission", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/034_consumer_requests_executed_instrument.txt", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-09, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Sofia Bennett.", "severity": "low"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/11_risk_assessments/085_risk_assessments_review_memorandum.json", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for sensitive-data classification: one source states the applicable location is Colorado Attorney General, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to Colorado operations outside Colorado Attorney General.", "id": "F-13", "issue": "sensitive-data classification", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/037_consumer_requests_review_memorandum.json", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-09, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Adrian Mensah.", "severity": "critical"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/11_risk_assessments/088_risk_assessments_status_report.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for minor-consent issue: one source states the threshold is 15% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 18% and produced a different exception result.", "id": "F-14", "issue": "minor-consent issue", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/040_consumer_requests_status_report.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-09, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Willa Novak.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/091_remediation_correspondence.eml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for training completion gap: one source states formal notice must use notices-civicroute_mobility@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-metropulse_advertising_llc@example.test.", "id": "F-15", "issue": "training completion gap", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/043_notices_consents_correspondence.eml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-09, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Theo Laurent.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/094_remediation_formal_notice.xml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for regulator commitment overdue: one source states the governed population contains 94 records through 2025-07-08, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 59 records through 2025-08-08.", "id": "F-16", "issue": "regulator commitment overdue", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/046_notices_consents_formal_notice.xml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-09, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Amara Patel.", "severity": "medium"}], "matter_number": "CB-PR-3003", "prepared_for": "CivicRoute Mobility", "schema_version": "1.0", "task_id": "cb100-063-civic-route"}}, "metadata": {"benchmark": "CounselBench-100", "code_license": "Apache-2.0", "data_license": "CC-BY-4.0", "deadline": "2026-09-09", "document_count": 96, "jurisdiction": "Colorado", "matter_number": "CB-PR-3003", "mcp_commit": "9a96ea6e5913736f92b88345bf51caeaaa8e719f", "mcp_package": "@modelcontextprotocol/server-filesystem@2026.7.10", "practice_area": "privacy-regulatory", "reference_tool_calls": 46, "required_evidence_reads": 33, "synthetic": true, "venue": "Colorado Attorney General", "version": "2.0.0"}, "prompt": "You are privacy and regulatory counsel for CivicRoute Mobility. The client has asked for a board-ready risk assessment supported by a source-level tracker rather than a narrative-only summary. A mobility app shared precise location segments through an advertising integration not reflected in its processing inventory or opt-out flow. Decision due 2026-09-09. Colorado law governs; Colorado Attorney General is the forum. Treat dates, notice mechanics, approval evidence, and numerical reconciliations as independent controls. Work out the defensible position from the matter production and leave an audit-ready exception tracker and concise advice for the supervising lawyer. Keep confirmed conflicts separate from open questions, cite the records that actually control each conclusion, and do not fill gaps with outside facts.", "rubric": {"criteria": [{"category": "procedure", "description": "Complete at least 46 successful, argument-specific evidence and output calls.", "id": "procedure.minimum_successful_tool_calls"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Find and read the 33 controlling, corroborating, and work-product-control records in full.", "id": "procedure.all_evidence_read_in_full"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Inspect file metadata for the eight designated critical primary records before relying on them.", "id": "procedure.chain_of_custody_metadata_checked"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Confirm the sandbox's allowed document and output roots.", "id": "procedure.allowed_directories_checked"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Inventory all 96 records so the relevant sources are discovered among the context records.", "id": "procedure.recursive_inventory_completed"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Search the production for email evidence that may corroborate or contradict formal records.", "id": "procedure.targeted_search_completed"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Leave only findings.json and advice.md in the output workspace.", "id": "procedure.exact_deliverable_set"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Create both final work products through the sandbox MCP surface.", "id": "procedure.deliverables_written_through_mcp"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Produce findings.json as a valid JSON object.", "id": "findings.findings_is_object"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Report exactly 16 confirmed exceptions.", "id": "findings.findings_exact_count"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Use each stable finding ID exactly once.", "id": "findings.finding_ids_unique"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set schema_version to the released matter value '1.0'.", "id": "findings.top_level_schema_version"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set task_id to the released matter value 'cb100-063-civic-route'.", "id": "findings.top_level_task_id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set matter_number to the released matter value 'CB-PR-3003'.", "id": "findings.top_level_matter_number"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set prepared_for to the released matter value 'CivicRoute Mobility'.", "id": "findings.top_level_prepared_for"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set as_of to the released matter value '2026-09-09'.", "id": "findings.top_level_as_of"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-01 exception for processing-purpose gap.", "id": "findings.F-01.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's id from /workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/001_data_inventory_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_transfer_mechanisms/049_transfer_mechanisms_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's issue from /workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/001_data_inventory_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_transfer_mechanisms/049_transfer_mechanisms_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's severity from /workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/001_data_inventory_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_transfer_mechanisms/049_transfer_mechanisms_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's primary_source from /workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/001_data_inventory_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_transfer_mechanisms/049_transfer_mechanisms_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/001_data_inventory_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_transfer_mechanisms/049_transfer_mechanisms_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-01 using the exact controlled facts ['2025-10-15', 'CB-PR-3003-A505', '2025-11-29', 'CB-PR-3003-J961'].", "id": "findings.F-01.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-01's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-01.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-09', 'Rafael Okafor'] for F-01.", "id": "findings.F-01.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-02 exception for notice-practice mismatch.", "id": "findings.F-02.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's id from /workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/004_data_inventory_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_transfer_mechanisms/052_transfer_mechanisms_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's issue from /workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/004_data_inventory_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_transfer_mechanisms/052_transfer_mechanisms_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's severity from /workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/004_data_inventory_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_transfer_mechanisms/052_transfer_mechanisms_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's primary_source from /workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/004_data_inventory_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_transfer_mechanisms/052_transfer_mechanisms_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/004_data_inventory_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_transfer_mechanisms/052_transfer_mechanisms_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-02 using the exact controlled facts ['$4,168,080.00', '$4,342,660.00'].", "id": "findings.F-02.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-02's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-02.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-09', 'Nora Chen'] for F-02.", "id": "findings.F-02.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-03 exception for consent-record deficiency.", "id": "findings.F-03.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's id from /workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/007_data_inventory_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_transfer_mechanisms/055_transfer_mechanisms_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's issue from /workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/007_data_inventory_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_transfer_mechanisms/055_transfer_mechanisms_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's severity from /workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/007_data_inventory_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_transfer_mechanisms/055_transfer_mechanisms_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's primary_source from /workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/007_data_inventory_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_transfer_mechanisms/055_transfer_mechanisms_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/007_data_inventory_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_transfer_mechanisms/055_transfer_mechanisms_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-03 using the exact controlled facts ['Farah Ibrahim', 'Owen Delgado'].", "id": "findings.F-03.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-03's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-03.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-09', 'Dominic Alvarez'] for F-03.", "id": "findings.F-03.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-04 exception for processor-contract omission.", "id": "findings.F-04.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's id from /workspace/documents/02_processing_records/010_processing_records_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_retention_deletion/058_retention_deletion_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's issue from /workspace/documents/02_processing_records/010_processing_records_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_retention_deletion/058_retention_deletion_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's severity from /workspace/documents/02_processing_records/010_processing_records_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_retention_deletion/058_retention_deletion_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's primary_source from /workspace/documents/02_processing_records/010_processing_records_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_retention_deletion/058_retention_deletion_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/02_processing_records/010_processing_records_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_retention_deletion/058_retention_deletion_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-04 using the exact controlled facts ['closed without exception', 'CB-PR-3003-D509', 'open and escalated', 'CB-PR-3003-M962'].", "id": "findings.F-04.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-04's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-04.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-09', 'Priya Raman'] for F-04.", "id": "findings.F-04.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-05 exception for subprocessor inventory mismatch.", "id": "findings.F-05.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's id from /workspace/documents/02_processing_records/013_processing_records_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_retention_deletion/061_retention_deletion_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's issue from /workspace/documents/02_processing_records/013_processing_records_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_retention_deletion/061_retention_deletion_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's severity from /workspace/documents/02_processing_records/013_processing_records_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_retention_deletion/061_retention_deletion_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's primary_source from /workspace/documents/02_processing_records/013_processing_records_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_retention_deletion/061_retention_deletion_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/02_processing_records/013_processing_records_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_retention_deletion/061_retention_deletion_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-05 using the exact controlled facts ['Colorado Attorney General', 'Colorado'].", "id": "findings.F-05.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-05's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-05.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-09', 'Elliot Mercer'] for F-05.", "id": "findings.F-05.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-06 exception for cross-border transfer gap.", "id": "findings.F-06.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's id from /workspace/documents/02_processing_records/016_processing_records_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_retention_deletion/064_retention_deletion_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's issue from /workspace/documents/02_processing_records/016_processing_records_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_retention_deletion/064_retention_deletion_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's severity from /workspace/documents/02_processing_records/016_processing_records_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_retention_deletion/064_retention_deletion_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's primary_source from /workspace/documents/02_processing_records/016_processing_records_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_retention_deletion/064_retention_deletion_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/02_processing_records/016_processing_records_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_retention_deletion/064_retention_deletion_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-06 using the exact controlled facts ['9%', '14%'].", "id": "findings.F-06.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-06's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-06.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-09', 'Talia Brooks'] for F-06.", "id": "findings.F-06.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-07 exception for retention schedule conflict.", "id": "findings.F-07.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's id from /workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/019_vendor_reviews_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_training/067_training_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's issue from /workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/019_vendor_reviews_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_training/067_training_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's severity from /workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/019_vendor_reviews_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_training/067_training_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's primary_source from /workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/019_vendor_reviews_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_training/067_training_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/019_vendor_reviews_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_training/067_training_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-07 using the exact controlled facts ['notices-civicroute_mobility@example.test', 'archive-metropulse_advertising_llc@example.test'].", "id": "findings.F-07.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-07's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-07.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-09', 'Jonas Feld'] for F-07.", "id": "findings.F-07.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-08 exception for deletion-job failure.", "id": "findings.F-08.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's id from /workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/022_vendor_reviews_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_training/070_training_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's issue from /workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/022_vendor_reviews_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_training/070_training_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's severity from /workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/022_vendor_reviews_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_training/070_training_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's primary_source from /workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/022_vendor_reviews_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_training/070_training_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/022_vendor_reviews_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_training/070_training_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-08 using the exact controlled facts ['118 records', '2025-03-14', '42 records', '2025-03-28'].", "id": "findings.F-08.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-08's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-08.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-09', 'Mei Whitaker'] for F-08.", "id": "findings.F-08.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-09 exception for access-request deadline.", "id": "findings.F-09.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's id from /workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/025_security_incidents_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_regulator_correspondence/073_regulator_correspondence_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's issue from /workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/025_security_incidents_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_regulator_correspondence/073_regulator_correspondence_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's severity from /workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/025_security_incidents_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_regulator_correspondence/073_regulator_correspondence_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's primary_source from /workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/025_security_incidents_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_regulator_correspondence/073_regulator_correspondence_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/025_security_incidents_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_regulator_correspondence/073_regulator_correspondence_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-09 using the exact controlled facts ['2025-11-08', 'CB-PR-3003-I529', '2025-12-19', 'CB-PR-3003-R825'].", "id": "findings.F-09.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-09's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-09.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-09', 'Caleb Hassan'] for F-09.", "id": "findings.F-09.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-10 exception for identity-verification inconsistency.", "id": "findings.F-10.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's id from /workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/028_security_incidents_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_regulator_correspondence/076_regulator_correspondence_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's issue from /workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/028_security_incidents_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_regulator_correspondence/076_regulator_correspondence_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's severity from /workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/028_security_incidents_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_regulator_correspondence/076_regulator_correspondence_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's primary_source from /workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/028_security_incidents_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_regulator_correspondence/076_regulator_correspondence_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/028_security_incidents_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_regulator_correspondence/076_regulator_correspondence_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-10 using the exact controlled facts ['$4,478,117.00', '$4,702,734.00'].", "id": "findings.F-10.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-10's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-10.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-09', 'Leona Park'] for F-10.", "id": "findings.F-10.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-11 exception for incident-notification clock.", "id": "findings.F-11.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's id from /workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/031_security_incidents_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_regulator_correspondence/079_regulator_correspondence_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's issue from /workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/031_security_incidents_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_regulator_correspondence/079_regulator_correspondence_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's severity from /workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/031_security_incidents_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_regulator_correspondence/079_regulator_correspondence_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's primary_source from /workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/031_security_incidents_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_regulator_correspondence/079_regulator_correspondence_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/031_security_incidents_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_regulator_correspondence/079_regulator_correspondence_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-11 using the exact controlled facts ['Farah Ibrahim', 'Adrian Mensah'].", "id": "findings.F-11.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-11's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-11.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-09', 'Isaac Romero'] for F-11.", "id": "findings.F-11.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-12 exception for risk-assessment omission.", "id": "findings.F-12.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's id from /workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/034_consumer_requests_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_risk_assessments/082_risk_assessments_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's issue from /workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/034_consumer_requests_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_risk_assessments/082_risk_assessments_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's severity from /workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/034_consumer_requests_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_risk_assessments/082_risk_assessments_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's primary_source from /workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/034_consumer_requests_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_risk_assessments/082_risk_assessments_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/034_consumer_requests_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_risk_assessments/082_risk_assessments_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-12 using the exact controlled facts ['closed without exception', 'CB-PR-3003-L657', 'open and escalated', 'CB-PR-3003-U350'].", "id": "findings.F-12.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-12's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-12.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-09', 'Sofia Bennett'] for F-12.", "id": "findings.F-12.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-13 exception for sensitive-data classification.", "id": "findings.F-13.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's id from /workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/037_consumer_requests_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_risk_assessments/085_risk_assessments_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's issue from /workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/037_consumer_requests_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_risk_assessments/085_risk_assessments_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's severity from /workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/037_consumer_requests_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_risk_assessments/085_risk_assessments_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's primary_source from /workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/037_consumer_requests_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_risk_assessments/085_risk_assessments_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/037_consumer_requests_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_risk_assessments/085_risk_assessments_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-13 using the exact controlled facts ['Colorado Attorney General', 'Colorado'].", "id": "findings.F-13.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-13's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-13.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-09', 'Adrian Mensah'] for F-13.", "id": "findings.F-13.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-14 exception for minor-consent issue.", "id": "findings.F-14.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's id from /workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/040_consumer_requests_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_risk_assessments/088_risk_assessments_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's issue from /workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/040_consumer_requests_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_risk_assessments/088_risk_assessments_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's severity from /workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/040_consumer_requests_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_risk_assessments/088_risk_assessments_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's primary_source from /workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/040_consumer_requests_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_risk_assessments/088_risk_assessments_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/040_consumer_requests_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_risk_assessments/088_risk_assessments_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-14 using the exact controlled facts ['15%', '18%'].", "id": "findings.F-14.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-14's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-14.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-09', 'Willa Novak'] for F-14.", "id": "findings.F-14.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-15 exception for training completion gap.", "id": "findings.F-15.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's id from /workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/043_notices_consents_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_remediation/091_remediation_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's issue from /workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/043_notices_consents_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_remediation/091_remediation_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's severity from /workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/043_notices_consents_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_remediation/091_remediation_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's primary_source from /workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/043_notices_consents_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_remediation/091_remediation_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/043_notices_consents_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_remediation/091_remediation_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-15 using the exact controlled facts ['notices-civicroute_mobility@example.test', 'archive-metropulse_advertising_llc@example.test'].", "id": "findings.F-15.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-15's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-15.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-09', 'Theo Laurent'] for F-15.", "id": "findings.F-15.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-16 exception for regulator commitment overdue.", "id": "findings.F-16.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's id from /workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/046_notices_consents_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_remediation/094_remediation_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's issue from /workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/046_notices_consents_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_remediation/094_remediation_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's severity from /workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/046_notices_consents_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_remediation/094_remediation_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's primary_source from /workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/046_notices_consents_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_remediation/094_remediation_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/046_notices_consents_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_remediation/094_remediation_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-16 using the exact controlled facts ['94 records', '2025-07-08', '59 records', '2025-08-08'].", "id": "findings.F-16.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-16's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-16.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-09', 'Amara Patel'] for F-16.", "id": "findings.F-16.action_anchors"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Executive assessment' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Executive assessment"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Method and record coverage' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Method and record coverage"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Findings' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Findings"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Recommended next actions' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Recommended next actions"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Assumptions and limitations' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Assumptions and limitations"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-01 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-01"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-02 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-02"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-03 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-03"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-04 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-04"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-05 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-05"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-06 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-06"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-07 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-07"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-08 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-08"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-09 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-09"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-10 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-10"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-11 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-11"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-12 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-12"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-13 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-13"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-14 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-14"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-15 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-15"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-16 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-16"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Do not claim the production has no issues or that every record is consistent.", "id": "memo.forbidden_claims_absent"}], "decision_options": [{"id": "cross-source-reconciliation", "label": "Reconcile controlling and corroborating records", "reason": "The CB-PR-3003 production contains independently maintained records; a defensible answer must preserve each supported conflict and its cure owner.", "selected": true}, {"id": "latest-record-controls", "label": "Treat the latest record as controlling", "reason": "Timestamp recency does not establish legal priority, execution, or approval authority.", "selected": false}, {"id": "primary-records-only", "label": "Report primary records without reconciliation", "reason": "Primary records alone conceal the operational conflicts that create the actionable exceptions.", "selected": false}], "gates": ["all_evidence_read_in_full", "chain_of_custody_metadata_checked", "findings_criteria_complete", "memo_criteria_complete", "deliverables_written_through_mcp"], "metadata_checks": 8, "metric": "weighted_criteria_score", "minimum_tool_calls": 46, "required_deliverables": ["findings.json", "advice.md"], "required_document_reads": 33, "type": "deterministic", "weights": {"findings": 0.55, "memo": 0.2, "procedure": 0.25}}, "task_id": "cb100-063-civic-route", "task_name": "CivicRoute location-data inquiry", "world_id": "counselbench-filesystem-mcp-v2"}
-{"context_files": ["task_files/cb100-064-deepwell-health/01_data_inventory/001_data_inventory_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-064-deepwell-health/01_data_inventory/002_data_inventory_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-064-deepwell-health/01_data_inventory/003_data_inventory_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-064-deepwell-health/01_data_inventory/004_data_inventory_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-064-deepwell-health/01_data_inventory/005_data_inventory_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-064-deepwell-health/01_data_inventory/006_data_inventory_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-064-deepwell-health/01_data_inventory/007_data_inventory_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-064-deepwell-health/01_data_inventory/008_data_inventory_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-064-deepwell-health/02_processing_records/009_processing_records_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-064-deepwell-health/02_processing_records/010_processing_records_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-064-deepwell-health/02_processing_records/011_processing_records_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-064-deepwell-health/02_processing_records/012_processing_records_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-064-deepwell-health/02_processing_records/013_processing_records_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-064-deepwell-health/02_processing_records/014_processing_records_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-064-deepwell-health/02_processing_records/015_processing_records_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-064-deepwell-health/02_processing_records/016_processing_records_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-064-deepwell-health/03_vendor_reviews/017_vendor_reviews_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-064-deepwell-health/03_vendor_reviews/018_vendor_reviews_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-064-deepwell-health/03_vendor_reviews/019_vendor_reviews_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-064-deepwell-health/03_vendor_reviews/020_vendor_reviews_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-064-deepwell-health/03_vendor_reviews/021_vendor_reviews_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-064-deepwell-health/03_vendor_reviews/022_vendor_reviews_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-064-deepwell-health/03_vendor_reviews/023_vendor_reviews_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-064-deepwell-health/03_vendor_reviews/024_vendor_reviews_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-064-deepwell-health/04_security_incidents/025_security_incidents_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-064-deepwell-health/04_security_incidents/026_security_incidents_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-064-deepwell-health/04_security_incidents/027_security_incidents_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-064-deepwell-health/04_security_incidents/028_security_incidents_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-064-deepwell-health/04_security_incidents/029_security_incidents_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-064-deepwell-health/04_security_incidents/030_security_incidents_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-064-deepwell-health/04_security_incidents/031_security_incidents_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-064-deepwell-health/04_security_incidents/032_security_incidents_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-064-deepwell-health/05_consumer_requests/033_consumer_requests_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-064-deepwell-health/05_consumer_requests/034_consumer_requests_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-064-deepwell-health/05_consumer_requests/035_consumer_requests_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-064-deepwell-health/05_consumer_requests/036_consumer_requests_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-064-deepwell-health/05_consumer_requests/037_consumer_requests_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-064-deepwell-health/05_consumer_requests/038_consumer_requests_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-064-deepwell-health/05_consumer_requests/039_consumer_requests_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-064-deepwell-health/05_consumer_requests/040_consumer_requests_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-064-deepwell-health/06_notices_consents/041_notices_consents_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-064-deepwell-health/06_notices_consents/042_notices_consents_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-064-deepwell-health/06_notices_consents/043_notices_consents_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-064-deepwell-health/06_notices_consents/044_notices_consents_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-064-deepwell-health/06_notices_consents/045_notices_consents_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-064-deepwell-health/06_notices_consents/046_notices_consents_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-064-deepwell-health/06_notices_consents/047_notices_consents_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-064-deepwell-health/06_notices_consents/048_notices_consents_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-064-deepwell-health/07_transfer_mechanisms/049_transfer_mechanisms_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-064-deepwell-health/07_transfer_mechanisms/050_transfer_mechanisms_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-064-deepwell-health/07_transfer_mechanisms/051_transfer_mechanisms_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-064-deepwell-health/07_transfer_mechanisms/052_transfer_mechanisms_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-064-deepwell-health/07_transfer_mechanisms/053_transfer_mechanisms_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-064-deepwell-health/07_transfer_mechanisms/054_transfer_mechanisms_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-064-deepwell-health/07_transfer_mechanisms/055_transfer_mechanisms_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-064-deepwell-health/07_transfer_mechanisms/056_transfer_mechanisms_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-064-deepwell-health/08_retention_deletion/057_retention_deletion_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-064-deepwell-health/08_retention_deletion/058_retention_deletion_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-064-deepwell-health/08_retention_deletion/059_retention_deletion_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-064-deepwell-health/08_retention_deletion/060_retention_deletion_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-064-deepwell-health/08_retention_deletion/061_retention_deletion_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-064-deepwell-health/08_retention_deletion/062_retention_deletion_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-064-deepwell-health/08_retention_deletion/063_retention_deletion_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-064-deepwell-health/08_retention_deletion/064_retention_deletion_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-064-deepwell-health/09_training/065_training_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-064-deepwell-health/09_training/066_training_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-064-deepwell-health/09_training/067_training_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-064-deepwell-health/09_training/068_training_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-064-deepwell-health/09_training/069_training_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-064-deepwell-health/09_training/070_training_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-064-deepwell-health/09_training/071_training_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-064-deepwell-health/09_training/072_training_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-064-deepwell-health/10_regulator_correspondence/073_regulator_correspondence_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-064-deepwell-health/10_regulator_correspondence/074_regulator_correspondence_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-064-deepwell-health/10_regulator_correspondence/075_regulator_correspondence_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-064-deepwell-health/10_regulator_correspondence/076_regulator_correspondence_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-064-deepwell-health/10_regulator_correspondence/077_regulator_correspondence_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-064-deepwell-health/10_regulator_correspondence/078_regulator_correspondence_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-064-deepwell-health/10_regulator_correspondence/079_regulator_correspondence_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-064-deepwell-health/10_regulator_correspondence/080_regulator_correspondence_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-064-deepwell-health/11_risk_assessments/081_risk_assessments_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-064-deepwell-health/11_risk_assessments/082_risk_assessments_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-064-deepwell-health/11_risk_assessments/083_risk_assessments_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-064-deepwell-health/11_risk_assessments/084_risk_assessments_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-064-deepwell-health/11_risk_assessments/085_risk_assessments_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-064-deepwell-health/11_risk_assessments/086_risk_assessments_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-064-deepwell-health/11_risk_assessments/087_risk_assessments_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-064-deepwell-health/11_risk_assessments/088_risk_assessments_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-064-deepwell-health/12_remediation/089_remediation_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-064-deepwell-health/12_remediation/090_remediation_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-064-deepwell-health/12_remediation/091_remediation_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-064-deepwell-health/12_remediation/092_remediation_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-064-deepwell-health/12_remediation/093_remediation_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-064-deepwell-health/12_remediation/094_remediation_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-064-deepwell-health/12_remediation/095_remediation_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-064-deepwell-health/12_remediation/096_remediation_status_report.md"], "gold_output": {"advice_markdown": "# Counsel advice — Deepwell breach-notice audit\n\n## Executive assessment\n\nFor Deepwell Health Services matter CB-PR-3004, the review identified 16 source-supported exceptions requiring action before 2026-09-13. The assessment concerns Morrow Claims Clearinghouse and the supplied record for New York.\n\n## Method and record coverage\n\nThe review inventoried all 96 production files, read the 33 controlling, corroborating, and control records, searched the email exports, and checked metadata for the designated chain-of-custody sample. Conclusions are limited to the synthetic production supplied for this benchmark matter.\n\n## Findings\n\n### F-01 — processing-purpose gap (critical)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for processing-purpose gap: one source states the operative date is 2026-02-26 under control reference CB-PR-3004-A699, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2026-03-07 under response reference CB-PR-3004-J630.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/001_data_inventory_control_register.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/07_transfer_mechanisms/049_transfer_mechanisms_control_register.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-13, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Nora Chen.\n\n### F-02 — notice-practice mismatch (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for notice-practice mismatch: one source states the controlling amount is $4,351,229.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $4,528,958.00.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/004_data_inventory_ledger_export.csv`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/07_transfer_mechanisms/052_transfer_mechanisms_ledger_export.csv`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-13, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Dominic Alvarez.\n\n### F-03 — consent-record deficiency (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for consent-record deficiency: one source states approval is attributed to Owen Delgado as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Samuel Kim and contains no entry for Owen Delgado.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/007_data_inventory_officer_certificate.html`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/07_transfer_mechanisms/055_transfer_mechanisms_officer_certificate.html`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-13, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Priya Raman.\n\n### F-04 — processor-contract omission (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for processor-contract omission: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-PR-3004-D832, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-PR-3004-M571.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/02_processing_records/010_processing_records_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/08_retention_deletion/058_retention_deletion_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-13, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Elliot Mercer.\n\n### F-05 — subprocessor inventory mismatch (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for subprocessor inventory mismatch: one source states the applicable location is New York Department of Financial Services, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to New York operations outside New York Department of Financial Services.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/02_processing_records/013_processing_records_review_memorandum.json`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/08_retention_deletion/061_retention_deletion_review_memorandum.json`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-13, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Talia Brooks.\n\n### F-06 — cross-border transfer gap (low)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for cross-border transfer gap: one source states the threshold is 14% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 20% and produced a different exception result.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/02_processing_records/016_processing_records_status_report.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/08_retention_deletion/064_retention_deletion_status_report.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-13, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Jonas Feld.\n\n### F-07 — retention schedule conflict (critical)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for retention schedule conflict: one source states formal notice must use notices-deepwell_health_services@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-morrow_claims_clearinghouse@example.test.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/019_vendor_reviews_correspondence.eml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/09_training/067_training_correspondence.eml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-13, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Mei Whitaker.\n\n### F-08 — deletion-job failure (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for deletion-job failure: one source states the governed population contains 148 records through 2025-04-13, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 65 records through 2025-05-20.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/022_vendor_reviews_formal_notice.xml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/09_training/070_training_formal_notice.xml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-13, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Caleb Hassan.\n\n### F-09 — access-request deadline (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for access-request deadline: one source states the operative date is 2026-02-11 under control reference CB-PR-3004-I864, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2026-02-27 under response reference CB-PR-3004-R366.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/025_security_incidents_control_register.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/10_regulator_correspondence/073_regulator_correspondence_control_register.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-13, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Leona Park.\n\n### F-10 — identity-verification inconsistency (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for identity-verification inconsistency: one source states the controlling amount is $3,389,530.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $3,565,560.00.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/028_security_incidents_ledger_export.csv`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/10_regulator_correspondence/076_regulator_correspondence_ledger_export.csv`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-13, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Isaac Romero.\n\n### F-11 — incident-notification clock (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for incident-notification clock: one source states approval is attributed to Owen Delgado as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Theo Laurent and contains no entry for Owen Delgado.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/031_security_incidents_officer_certificate.html`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/10_regulator_correspondence/079_regulator_correspondence_officer_certificate.html`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-13, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Sofia Bennett.\n\n### F-12 — risk-assessment omission (low)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for risk-assessment omission: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-PR-3004-L208, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-PR-3004-U662.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/034_consumer_requests_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/11_risk_assessments/082_risk_assessments_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-13, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Adrian Mensah.\n\n### F-13 — sensitive-data classification (critical)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for sensitive-data classification: one source states the applicable location is New York Department of Financial Services, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to New York operations outside New York Department of Financial Services.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/037_consumer_requests_review_memorandum.json`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/11_risk_assessments/085_risk_assessments_review_memorandum.json`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-13, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Willa Novak.\n\n### F-14 — minor-consent issue (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for minor-consent issue: one source states the threshold is 15% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 22% and produced a different exception result.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/040_consumer_requests_status_report.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/11_risk_assessments/088_risk_assessments_status_report.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-13, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Theo Laurent.\n\n### F-15 — training completion gap (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for training completion gap: one source states formal notice must use notices-deepwell_health_services@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-morrow_claims_clearinghouse@example.test.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/043_notices_consents_correspondence.eml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/12_remediation/091_remediation_correspondence.eml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-13, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Amara Patel.\n\n### F-16 — regulator commitment overdue (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for regulator commitment overdue: one source states the governed population contains 56 records through 2025-10-18, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 66 records through 2025-11-25.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/046_notices_consents_formal_notice.xml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/12_remediation/094_remediation_formal_notice.xml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-13, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Henry Cho.\n\n## Recommended next actions\n\nSequence the critical and high findings first, assign the named owners, preserve the cited records, and document any resolution in the controlling matter register before the stated deadline.\n\n## Assumptions and limitations\n\nThis analysis is confined to task cb100-064-deepwell-health and the supplied synthetic evidence. It does not rely on external facts, does not resolve disputed law, and is not legal advice for a real person or entity.\n", "findings": {"as_of": "2026-09-13", "findings": [{"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/07_transfer_mechanisms/049_transfer_mechanisms_control_register.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for processing-purpose gap: one source states the operative date is 2026-02-26 under control reference CB-PR-3004-A699, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2026-03-07 under response reference CB-PR-3004-J630.", "id": "F-01", "issue": "processing-purpose gap", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/001_data_inventory_control_register.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-13, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Nora Chen.", "severity": "critical"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/07_transfer_mechanisms/052_transfer_mechanisms_ledger_export.csv", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for notice-practice mismatch: one source states the controlling amount is $4,351,229.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $4,528,958.00.", "id": "F-02", "issue": "notice-practice mismatch", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/004_data_inventory_ledger_export.csv", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-13, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Dominic Alvarez.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/07_transfer_mechanisms/055_transfer_mechanisms_officer_certificate.html", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for consent-record deficiency: one source states approval is attributed to Owen Delgado as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Samuel Kim and contains no entry for Owen Delgado.", "id": "F-03", "issue": "consent-record deficiency", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/007_data_inventory_officer_certificate.html", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-13, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Priya Raman.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/08_retention_deletion/058_retention_deletion_executed_instrument.txt", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for processor-contract omission: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-PR-3004-D832, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-PR-3004-M571.", "id": "F-04", "issue": "processor-contract omission", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/02_processing_records/010_processing_records_executed_instrument.txt", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-13, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Elliot Mercer.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/08_retention_deletion/061_retention_deletion_review_memorandum.json", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for subprocessor inventory mismatch: one source states the applicable location is New York Department of Financial Services, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to New York operations outside New York Department of Financial Services.", "id": "F-05", "issue": "subprocessor inventory mismatch", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/02_processing_records/013_processing_records_review_memorandum.json", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-13, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Talia Brooks.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/08_retention_deletion/064_retention_deletion_status_report.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for cross-border transfer gap: one source states the threshold is 14% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 20% and produced a different exception result.", "id": "F-06", "issue": "cross-border transfer gap", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/02_processing_records/016_processing_records_status_report.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-13, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Jonas Feld.", "severity": "low"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/09_training/067_training_correspondence.eml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for retention schedule conflict: one source states formal notice must use notices-deepwell_health_services@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-morrow_claims_clearinghouse@example.test.", "id": "F-07", "issue": "retention schedule conflict", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/019_vendor_reviews_correspondence.eml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-13, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Mei Whitaker.", "severity": "critical"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/09_training/070_training_formal_notice.xml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for deletion-job failure: one source states the governed population contains 148 records through 2025-04-13, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 65 records through 2025-05-20.", "id": "F-08", "issue": "deletion-job failure", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/022_vendor_reviews_formal_notice.xml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-13, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Caleb Hassan.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/10_regulator_correspondence/073_regulator_correspondence_control_register.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for access-request deadline: one source states the operative date is 2026-02-11 under control reference CB-PR-3004-I864, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2026-02-27 under response reference CB-PR-3004-R366.", "id": "F-09", "issue": "access-request deadline", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/025_security_incidents_control_register.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-13, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Leona Park.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/10_regulator_correspondence/076_regulator_correspondence_ledger_export.csv", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for identity-verification inconsistency: one source states the controlling amount is $3,389,530.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $3,565,560.00.", "id": "F-10", "issue": "identity-verification inconsistency", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/028_security_incidents_ledger_export.csv", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-13, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Isaac Romero.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/10_regulator_correspondence/079_regulator_correspondence_officer_certificate.html", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for incident-notification clock: one source states approval is attributed to Owen Delgado as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Theo Laurent and contains no entry for Owen Delgado.", "id": "F-11", "issue": "incident-notification clock", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/031_security_incidents_officer_certificate.html", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-13, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Sofia Bennett.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/11_risk_assessments/082_risk_assessments_executed_instrument.txt", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for risk-assessment omission: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-PR-3004-L208, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-PR-3004-U662.", "id": "F-12", "issue": "risk-assessment omission", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/034_consumer_requests_executed_instrument.txt", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-13, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Adrian Mensah.", "severity": "low"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/11_risk_assessments/085_risk_assessments_review_memorandum.json", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for sensitive-data classification: one source states the applicable location is New York Department of Financial Services, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to New York operations outside New York Department of Financial Services.", "id": "F-13", "issue": "sensitive-data classification", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/037_consumer_requests_review_memorandum.json", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-13, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Willa Novak.", "severity": "critical"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/11_risk_assessments/088_risk_assessments_status_report.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for minor-consent issue: one source states the threshold is 15% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 22% and produced a different exception result.", "id": "F-14", "issue": "minor-consent issue", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/040_consumer_requests_status_report.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-13, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Theo Laurent.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/091_remediation_correspondence.eml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for training completion gap: one source states formal notice must use notices-deepwell_health_services@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-morrow_claims_clearinghouse@example.test.", "id": "F-15", "issue": "training completion gap", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/043_notices_consents_correspondence.eml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-13, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Amara Patel.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/094_remediation_formal_notice.xml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for regulator commitment overdue: one source states the governed population contains 56 records through 2025-10-18, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 66 records through 2025-11-25.", "id": "F-16", "issue": "regulator commitment overdue", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/046_notices_consents_formal_notice.xml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-13, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Henry Cho.", "severity": "medium"}], "matter_number": "CB-PR-3004", "prepared_for": "Deepwell Health Services", "schema_version": "1.0", "task_id": "cb100-064-deepwell-health"}}, "metadata": {"benchmark": "CounselBench-100", "code_license": "Apache-2.0", "data_license": "CC-BY-4.0", "deadline": "2026-09-13", "document_count": 96, "jurisdiction": "New York", "matter_number": "CB-PR-3004", "mcp_commit": "9a96ea6e5913736f92b88345bf51caeaaa8e719f", "mcp_package": "@modelcontextprotocol/server-filesystem@2026.7.10", "practice_area": "privacy-regulatory", "reference_tool_calls": 46, "required_evidence_reads": 33, "synthetic": true, "venue": "New York Department of Financial Services", "version": "2.0.0"}, "prompt": "You are privacy and regulatory counsel for Deepwell Health Services. Several workstreams have maintained separate versions of the truth; your assignment is to produce one auditable legal view. A credential incident moved through multiple vendors, creating disputed discovery dates and incomplete regulator commitments. Decision due 2026-09-13. New York law governs; New York Department of Financial Services is the forum. Distinguish a missing document from an affirmative contradiction in the documents that are present. Work out the defensible position from the matter production and leave an audit-ready exception tracker and concise advice for the supervising lawyer. Keep confirmed conflicts separate from open questions, cite the records that actually control each conclusion, and do not fill gaps with outside facts.", "rubric": {"criteria": [{"category": "procedure", "description": "Complete at least 46 successful, argument-specific evidence and output calls.", "id": "procedure.minimum_successful_tool_calls"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Find and read the 33 controlling, corroborating, and work-product-control records in full.", "id": "procedure.all_evidence_read_in_full"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Inspect file metadata for the eight designated critical primary records before relying on them.", "id": "procedure.chain_of_custody_metadata_checked"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Confirm the sandbox's allowed document and output roots.", "id": "procedure.allowed_directories_checked"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Inventory all 96 records so the relevant sources are discovered among the context records.", "id": "procedure.recursive_inventory_completed"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Search the production for email evidence that may corroborate or contradict formal records.", "id": "procedure.targeted_search_completed"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Leave only findings.json and advice.md in the output workspace.", "id": "procedure.exact_deliverable_set"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Create both final work products through the sandbox MCP surface.", "id": "procedure.deliverables_written_through_mcp"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Produce findings.json as a valid JSON object.", "id": "findings.findings_is_object"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Report exactly 16 confirmed exceptions.", "id": "findings.findings_exact_count"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Use each stable finding ID exactly once.", "id": "findings.finding_ids_unique"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set schema_version to the released matter value '1.0'.", "id": "findings.top_level_schema_version"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set task_id to the released matter value 'cb100-064-deepwell-health'.", "id": "findings.top_level_task_id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set matter_number to the released matter value 'CB-PR-3004'.", "id": "findings.top_level_matter_number"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set prepared_for to the released matter value 'Deepwell Health Services'.", "id": "findings.top_level_prepared_for"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set as_of to the released matter value '2026-09-13'.", "id": "findings.top_level_as_of"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-01 exception for processing-purpose gap.", "id": "findings.F-01.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's id from /workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/001_data_inventory_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_transfer_mechanisms/049_transfer_mechanisms_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's issue from /workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/001_data_inventory_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_transfer_mechanisms/049_transfer_mechanisms_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's severity from /workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/001_data_inventory_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_transfer_mechanisms/049_transfer_mechanisms_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's primary_source from /workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/001_data_inventory_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_transfer_mechanisms/049_transfer_mechanisms_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/001_data_inventory_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_transfer_mechanisms/049_transfer_mechanisms_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-01 using the exact controlled facts ['2026-02-26', 'CB-PR-3004-A699', '2026-03-07', 'CB-PR-3004-J630'].", "id": "findings.F-01.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-01's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-01.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-13', 'Nora Chen'] for F-01.", "id": "findings.F-01.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-02 exception for notice-practice mismatch.", "id": "findings.F-02.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's id from /workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/004_data_inventory_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_transfer_mechanisms/052_transfer_mechanisms_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's issue from /workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/004_data_inventory_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_transfer_mechanisms/052_transfer_mechanisms_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's severity from /workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/004_data_inventory_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_transfer_mechanisms/052_transfer_mechanisms_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's primary_source from /workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/004_data_inventory_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_transfer_mechanisms/052_transfer_mechanisms_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/004_data_inventory_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_transfer_mechanisms/052_transfer_mechanisms_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-02 using the exact controlled facts ['$4,351,229.00', '$4,528,958.00'].", "id": "findings.F-02.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-02's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-02.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-13', 'Dominic Alvarez'] for F-02.", "id": "findings.F-02.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-03 exception for consent-record deficiency.", "id": "findings.F-03.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's id from /workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/007_data_inventory_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_transfer_mechanisms/055_transfer_mechanisms_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's issue from /workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/007_data_inventory_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_transfer_mechanisms/055_transfer_mechanisms_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's severity from /workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/007_data_inventory_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_transfer_mechanisms/055_transfer_mechanisms_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's primary_source from /workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/007_data_inventory_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_transfer_mechanisms/055_transfer_mechanisms_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/007_data_inventory_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_transfer_mechanisms/055_transfer_mechanisms_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-03 using the exact controlled facts ['Owen Delgado', 'Samuel Kim'].", "id": "findings.F-03.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-03's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-03.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-13', 'Priya Raman'] for F-03.", "id": "findings.F-03.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-04 exception for processor-contract omission.", "id": "findings.F-04.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's id from /workspace/documents/02_processing_records/010_processing_records_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_retention_deletion/058_retention_deletion_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's issue from /workspace/documents/02_processing_records/010_processing_records_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_retention_deletion/058_retention_deletion_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's severity from /workspace/documents/02_processing_records/010_processing_records_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_retention_deletion/058_retention_deletion_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's primary_source from /workspace/documents/02_processing_records/010_processing_records_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_retention_deletion/058_retention_deletion_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/02_processing_records/010_processing_records_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_retention_deletion/058_retention_deletion_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-04 using the exact controlled facts ['closed without exception', 'CB-PR-3004-D832', 'open and escalated', 'CB-PR-3004-M571'].", "id": "findings.F-04.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-04's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-04.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-13', 'Elliot Mercer'] for F-04.", "id": "findings.F-04.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-05 exception for subprocessor inventory mismatch.", "id": "findings.F-05.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's id from /workspace/documents/02_processing_records/013_processing_records_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_retention_deletion/061_retention_deletion_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's issue from /workspace/documents/02_processing_records/013_processing_records_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_retention_deletion/061_retention_deletion_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's severity from /workspace/documents/02_processing_records/013_processing_records_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_retention_deletion/061_retention_deletion_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's primary_source from /workspace/documents/02_processing_records/013_processing_records_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_retention_deletion/061_retention_deletion_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/02_processing_records/013_processing_records_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_retention_deletion/061_retention_deletion_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-05 using the exact controlled facts ['New York Department of Financial Services', 'New York'].", "id": "findings.F-05.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-05's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-05.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-13', 'Talia Brooks'] for F-05.", "id": "findings.F-05.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-06 exception for cross-border transfer gap.", "id": "findings.F-06.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's id from /workspace/documents/02_processing_records/016_processing_records_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_retention_deletion/064_retention_deletion_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's issue from /workspace/documents/02_processing_records/016_processing_records_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_retention_deletion/064_retention_deletion_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's severity from /workspace/documents/02_processing_records/016_processing_records_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_retention_deletion/064_retention_deletion_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's primary_source from /workspace/documents/02_processing_records/016_processing_records_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_retention_deletion/064_retention_deletion_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/02_processing_records/016_processing_records_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_retention_deletion/064_retention_deletion_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-06 using the exact controlled facts ['14%', '20%'].", "id": "findings.F-06.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-06's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-06.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-13', 'Jonas Feld'] for F-06.", "id": "findings.F-06.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-07 exception for retention schedule conflict.", "id": "findings.F-07.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's id from /workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/019_vendor_reviews_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_training/067_training_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's issue from /workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/019_vendor_reviews_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_training/067_training_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's severity from /workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/019_vendor_reviews_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_training/067_training_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's primary_source from /workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/019_vendor_reviews_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_training/067_training_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/019_vendor_reviews_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_training/067_training_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-07 using the exact controlled facts ['notices-deepwell_health_services@example.test', 'archive-morrow_claims_clearinghouse@example.test'].", "id": "findings.F-07.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-07's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-07.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-13', 'Mei Whitaker'] for F-07.", "id": "findings.F-07.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-08 exception for deletion-job failure.", "id": "findings.F-08.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's id from /workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/022_vendor_reviews_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_training/070_training_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's issue from /workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/022_vendor_reviews_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_training/070_training_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's severity from /workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/022_vendor_reviews_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_training/070_training_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's primary_source from /workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/022_vendor_reviews_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_training/070_training_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/022_vendor_reviews_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_training/070_training_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-08 using the exact controlled facts ['148 records', '2025-04-13', '65 records', '2025-05-20'].", "id": "findings.F-08.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-08's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-08.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-13', 'Caleb Hassan'] for F-08.", "id": "findings.F-08.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-09 exception for access-request deadline.", "id": "findings.F-09.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's id from /workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/025_security_incidents_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_regulator_correspondence/073_regulator_correspondence_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's issue from /workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/025_security_incidents_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_regulator_correspondence/073_regulator_correspondence_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's severity from /workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/025_security_incidents_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_regulator_correspondence/073_regulator_correspondence_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's primary_source from /workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/025_security_incidents_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_regulator_correspondence/073_regulator_correspondence_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/025_security_incidents_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_regulator_correspondence/073_regulator_correspondence_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-09 using the exact controlled facts ['2026-02-11', 'CB-PR-3004-I864', '2026-02-27', 'CB-PR-3004-R366'].", "id": "findings.F-09.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-09's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-09.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-13', 'Leona Park'] for F-09.", "id": "findings.F-09.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-10 exception for identity-verification inconsistency.", "id": "findings.F-10.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's id from /workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/028_security_incidents_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_regulator_correspondence/076_regulator_correspondence_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's issue from /workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/028_security_incidents_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_regulator_correspondence/076_regulator_correspondence_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's severity from /workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/028_security_incidents_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_regulator_correspondence/076_regulator_correspondence_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's primary_source from /workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/028_security_incidents_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_regulator_correspondence/076_regulator_correspondence_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/028_security_incidents_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_regulator_correspondence/076_regulator_correspondence_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-10 using the exact controlled facts ['$3,389,530.00', '$3,565,560.00'].", "id": "findings.F-10.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-10's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-10.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-13', 'Isaac Romero'] for F-10.", "id": "findings.F-10.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-11 exception for incident-notification clock.", "id": "findings.F-11.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's id from /workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/031_security_incidents_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_regulator_correspondence/079_regulator_correspondence_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's issue from /workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/031_security_incidents_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_regulator_correspondence/079_regulator_correspondence_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's severity from /workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/031_security_incidents_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_regulator_correspondence/079_regulator_correspondence_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's primary_source from /workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/031_security_incidents_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_regulator_correspondence/079_regulator_correspondence_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/031_security_incidents_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_regulator_correspondence/079_regulator_correspondence_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-11 using the exact controlled facts ['Owen Delgado', 'Theo Laurent'].", "id": "findings.F-11.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-11's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-11.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-13', 'Sofia Bennett'] for F-11.", "id": "findings.F-11.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-12 exception for risk-assessment omission.", "id": "findings.F-12.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's id from /workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/034_consumer_requests_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_risk_assessments/082_risk_assessments_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's issue from /workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/034_consumer_requests_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_risk_assessments/082_risk_assessments_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's severity from /workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/034_consumer_requests_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_risk_assessments/082_risk_assessments_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's primary_source from /workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/034_consumer_requests_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_risk_assessments/082_risk_assessments_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/034_consumer_requests_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_risk_assessments/082_risk_assessments_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-12 using the exact controlled facts ['closed without exception', 'CB-PR-3004-L208', 'open and escalated', 'CB-PR-3004-U662'].", "id": "findings.F-12.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-12's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-12.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-13', 'Adrian Mensah'] for F-12.", "id": "findings.F-12.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-13 exception for sensitive-data classification.", "id": "findings.F-13.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's id from /workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/037_consumer_requests_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_risk_assessments/085_risk_assessments_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's issue from /workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/037_consumer_requests_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_risk_assessments/085_risk_assessments_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's severity from /workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/037_consumer_requests_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_risk_assessments/085_risk_assessments_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's primary_source from /workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/037_consumer_requests_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_risk_assessments/085_risk_assessments_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/037_consumer_requests_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_risk_assessments/085_risk_assessments_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-13 using the exact controlled facts ['New York Department of Financial Services', 'New York'].", "id": "findings.F-13.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-13's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-13.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-13', 'Willa Novak'] for F-13.", "id": "findings.F-13.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-14 exception for minor-consent issue.", "id": "findings.F-14.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's id from /workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/040_consumer_requests_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_risk_assessments/088_risk_assessments_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's issue from /workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/040_consumer_requests_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_risk_assessments/088_risk_assessments_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's severity from /workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/040_consumer_requests_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_risk_assessments/088_risk_assessments_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's primary_source from /workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/040_consumer_requests_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_risk_assessments/088_risk_assessments_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/040_consumer_requests_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_risk_assessments/088_risk_assessments_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-14 using the exact controlled facts ['15%', '22%'].", "id": "findings.F-14.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-14's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-14.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-13', 'Theo Laurent'] for F-14.", "id": "findings.F-14.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-15 exception for training completion gap.", "id": "findings.F-15.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's id from /workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/043_notices_consents_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_remediation/091_remediation_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's issue from /workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/043_notices_consents_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_remediation/091_remediation_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's severity from /workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/043_notices_consents_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_remediation/091_remediation_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's primary_source from /workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/043_notices_consents_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_remediation/091_remediation_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/043_notices_consents_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_remediation/091_remediation_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-15 using the exact controlled facts ['notices-deepwell_health_services@example.test', 'archive-morrow_claims_clearinghouse@example.test'].", "id": "findings.F-15.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-15's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-15.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-13', 'Amara Patel'] for F-15.", "id": "findings.F-15.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-16 exception for regulator commitment overdue.", "id": "findings.F-16.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's id from /workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/046_notices_consents_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_remediation/094_remediation_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's issue from /workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/046_notices_consents_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_remediation/094_remediation_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's severity from /workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/046_notices_consents_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_remediation/094_remediation_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's primary_source from /workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/046_notices_consents_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_remediation/094_remediation_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/046_notices_consents_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_remediation/094_remediation_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-16 using the exact controlled facts ['56 records', '2025-10-18', '66 records', '2025-11-25'].", "id": "findings.F-16.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-16's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-16.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-13', 'Henry Cho'] for F-16.", "id": "findings.F-16.action_anchors"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Executive assessment' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Executive assessment"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Method and record coverage' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Method and record coverage"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Findings' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Findings"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Recommended next actions' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Recommended next actions"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Assumptions and limitations' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Assumptions and limitations"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-01 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-01"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-02 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-02"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-03 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-03"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-04 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-04"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-05 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-05"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-06 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-06"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-07 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-07"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-08 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-08"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-09 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-09"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-10 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-10"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-11 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-11"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-12 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-12"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-13 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-13"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-14 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-14"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-15 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-15"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-16 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-16"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Do not claim the production has no issues or that every record is consistent.", "id": "memo.forbidden_claims_absent"}], "decision_options": [{"id": "cross-source-reconciliation", "label": "Reconcile controlling and corroborating records", "reason": "The CB-PR-3004 production contains independently maintained records; a defensible answer must preserve each supported conflict and its cure owner.", "selected": true}, {"id": "latest-record-controls", "label": "Treat the latest record as controlling", "reason": "Timestamp recency does not establish legal priority, execution, or approval authority.", "selected": false}, {"id": "primary-records-only", "label": "Report primary records without reconciliation", "reason": "Primary records alone conceal the operational conflicts that create the actionable exceptions.", "selected": false}], "gates": ["all_evidence_read_in_full", "chain_of_custody_metadata_checked", "findings_criteria_complete", "memo_criteria_complete", "deliverables_written_through_mcp"], "metadata_checks": 8, "metric": "weighted_criteria_score", "minimum_tool_calls": 46, "required_deliverables": ["findings.json", "advice.md"], "required_document_reads": 33, "type": "deterministic", "weights": {"findings": 0.55, "memo": 0.2, "procedure": 0.25}}, "task_id": "cb100-064-deepwell-health", "task_name": "Deepwell breach-notice audit", "world_id": "counselbench-filesystem-mcp-v2"}
-{"context_files": ["task_files/cb100-065-everfield-market/01_data_inventory/001_data_inventory_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-065-everfield-market/01_data_inventory/002_data_inventory_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-065-everfield-market/01_data_inventory/003_data_inventory_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-065-everfield-market/01_data_inventory/004_data_inventory_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-065-everfield-market/01_data_inventory/005_data_inventory_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-065-everfield-market/01_data_inventory/006_data_inventory_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-065-everfield-market/01_data_inventory/007_data_inventory_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-065-everfield-market/01_data_inventory/008_data_inventory_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-065-everfield-market/02_processing_records/009_processing_records_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-065-everfield-market/02_processing_records/010_processing_records_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-065-everfield-market/02_processing_records/011_processing_records_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-065-everfield-market/02_processing_records/012_processing_records_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-065-everfield-market/02_processing_records/013_processing_records_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-065-everfield-market/02_processing_records/014_processing_records_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-065-everfield-market/02_processing_records/015_processing_records_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-065-everfield-market/02_processing_records/016_processing_records_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-065-everfield-market/03_vendor_reviews/017_vendor_reviews_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-065-everfield-market/03_vendor_reviews/018_vendor_reviews_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-065-everfield-market/03_vendor_reviews/019_vendor_reviews_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-065-everfield-market/03_vendor_reviews/020_vendor_reviews_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-065-everfield-market/03_vendor_reviews/021_vendor_reviews_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-065-everfield-market/03_vendor_reviews/022_vendor_reviews_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-065-everfield-market/03_vendor_reviews/023_vendor_reviews_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-065-everfield-market/03_vendor_reviews/024_vendor_reviews_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-065-everfield-market/04_security_incidents/025_security_incidents_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-065-everfield-market/04_security_incidents/026_security_incidents_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-065-everfield-market/04_security_incidents/027_security_incidents_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-065-everfield-market/04_security_incidents/028_security_incidents_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-065-everfield-market/04_security_incidents/029_security_incidents_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-065-everfield-market/04_security_incidents/030_security_incidents_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-065-everfield-market/04_security_incidents/031_security_incidents_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-065-everfield-market/04_security_incidents/032_security_incidents_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-065-everfield-market/05_consumer_requests/033_consumer_requests_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-065-everfield-market/05_consumer_requests/034_consumer_requests_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-065-everfield-market/05_consumer_requests/035_consumer_requests_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-065-everfield-market/05_consumer_requests/036_consumer_requests_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-065-everfield-market/05_consumer_requests/037_consumer_requests_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-065-everfield-market/05_consumer_requests/038_consumer_requests_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-065-everfield-market/05_consumer_requests/039_consumer_requests_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-065-everfield-market/05_consumer_requests/040_consumer_requests_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-065-everfield-market/06_notices_consents/041_notices_consents_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-065-everfield-market/06_notices_consents/042_notices_consents_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-065-everfield-market/06_notices_consents/043_notices_consents_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-065-everfield-market/06_notices_consents/044_notices_consents_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-065-everfield-market/06_notices_consents/045_notices_consents_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-065-everfield-market/06_notices_consents/046_notices_consents_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-065-everfield-market/06_notices_consents/047_notices_consents_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-065-everfield-market/06_notices_consents/048_notices_consents_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-065-everfield-market/07_transfer_mechanisms/049_transfer_mechanisms_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-065-everfield-market/07_transfer_mechanisms/050_transfer_mechanisms_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-065-everfield-market/07_transfer_mechanisms/051_transfer_mechanisms_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-065-everfield-market/07_transfer_mechanisms/052_transfer_mechanisms_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-065-everfield-market/07_transfer_mechanisms/053_transfer_mechanisms_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-065-everfield-market/07_transfer_mechanisms/054_transfer_mechanisms_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-065-everfield-market/07_transfer_mechanisms/055_transfer_mechanisms_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-065-everfield-market/07_transfer_mechanisms/056_transfer_mechanisms_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-065-everfield-market/08_retention_deletion/057_retention_deletion_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-065-everfield-market/08_retention_deletion/058_retention_deletion_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-065-everfield-market/08_retention_deletion/059_retention_deletion_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-065-everfield-market/08_retention_deletion/060_retention_deletion_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-065-everfield-market/08_retention_deletion/061_retention_deletion_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-065-everfield-market/08_retention_deletion/062_retention_deletion_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-065-everfield-market/08_retention_deletion/063_retention_deletion_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-065-everfield-market/08_retention_deletion/064_retention_deletion_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-065-everfield-market/09_training/065_training_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-065-everfield-market/09_training/066_training_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-065-everfield-market/09_training/067_training_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-065-everfield-market/09_training/068_training_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-065-everfield-market/09_training/069_training_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-065-everfield-market/09_training/070_training_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-065-everfield-market/09_training/071_training_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-065-everfield-market/09_training/072_training_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-065-everfield-market/10_regulator_correspondence/073_regulator_correspondence_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-065-everfield-market/10_regulator_correspondence/074_regulator_correspondence_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-065-everfield-market/10_regulator_correspondence/075_regulator_correspondence_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-065-everfield-market/10_regulator_correspondence/076_regulator_correspondence_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-065-everfield-market/10_regulator_correspondence/077_regulator_correspondence_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-065-everfield-market/10_regulator_correspondence/078_regulator_correspondence_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-065-everfield-market/10_regulator_correspondence/079_regulator_correspondence_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-065-everfield-market/10_regulator_correspondence/080_regulator_correspondence_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-065-everfield-market/11_risk_assessments/081_risk_assessments_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-065-everfield-market/11_risk_assessments/082_risk_assessments_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-065-everfield-market/11_risk_assessments/083_risk_assessments_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-065-everfield-market/11_risk_assessments/084_risk_assessments_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-065-everfield-market/11_risk_assessments/085_risk_assessments_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-065-everfield-market/11_risk_assessments/086_risk_assessments_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-065-everfield-market/11_risk_assessments/087_risk_assessments_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-065-everfield-market/11_risk_assessments/088_risk_assessments_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-065-everfield-market/12_remediation/089_remediation_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-065-everfield-market/12_remediation/090_remediation_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-065-everfield-market/12_remediation/091_remediation_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-065-everfield-market/12_remediation/092_remediation_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-065-everfield-market/12_remediation/093_remediation_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-065-everfield-market/12_remediation/094_remediation_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-065-everfield-market/12_remediation/095_remediation_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-065-everfield-market/12_remediation/096_remediation_status_report.md"], "gold_output": {"advice_markdown": "# Counsel advice — Everfield loyalty-data assessment\n\n## Executive assessment\n\nFor Everfield Markets matter CB-PR-3005, the review identified 16 source-supported exceptions requiring action before 2026-09-16. The assessment concerns Poppy Loyalty Cloud and the supplied record for Virginia.\n\n## Method and record coverage\n\nThe review inventoried all 96 production files, read the 33 controlling, corroborating, and control records, searched the email exports, and checked metadata for the designated chain-of-custody sample. Conclusions are limited to the synthetic production supplied for this benchmark matter.\n\n## Findings\n\n### F-01 — processing-purpose gap (critical)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for processing-purpose gap: one source states the operative date is 2026-01-01 under control reference CB-PR-3005-A223, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2026-02-07 under response reference CB-PR-3005-J663.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/001_data_inventory_control_register.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/07_transfer_mechanisms/049_transfer_mechanisms_control_register.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-16, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Dominic Alvarez.\n\n### F-02 — notice-practice mismatch (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for notice-practice mismatch: one source states the controlling amount is $2,345,239.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $2,496,978.00.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/004_data_inventory_ledger_export.csv`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/07_transfer_mechanisms/052_transfer_mechanisms_ledger_export.csv`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-16, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Priya Raman.\n\n### F-03 — consent-record deficiency (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for consent-record deficiency: one source states approval is attributed to Lena Varga as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Rafael Okafor and contains no entry for Lena Varga.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/007_data_inventory_officer_certificate.html`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/07_transfer_mechanisms/055_transfer_mechanisms_officer_certificate.html`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-16, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Elliot Mercer.\n\n### F-04 — processor-contract omission (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for processor-contract omission: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-PR-3005-D275, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-PR-3005-M182.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/02_processing_records/010_processing_records_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/08_retention_deletion/058_retention_deletion_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-16, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Talia Brooks.\n\n### F-05 — subprocessor inventory mismatch (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for subprocessor inventory mismatch: one source states the applicable location is Virginia Attorney General, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to Virginia operations outside Virginia Attorney General.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/02_processing_records/013_processing_records_review_memorandum.json`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/08_retention_deletion/061_retention_deletion_review_memorandum.json`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-16, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Jonas Feld.\n\n### F-06 — cross-border transfer gap (low)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for cross-border transfer gap: one source states the threshold is 5% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 10% and produced a different exception result.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/02_processing_records/016_processing_records_status_report.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/08_retention_deletion/064_retention_deletion_status_report.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-16, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Mei Whitaker.\n\n### F-07 — retention schedule conflict (critical)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for retention schedule conflict: one source states formal notice must use notices-everfield_markets@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-poppy_loyalty_cloud@example.test.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/019_vendor_reviews_correspondence.eml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/09_training/067_training_correspondence.eml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-16, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Caleb Hassan.\n\n### F-08 — deletion-job failure (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for deletion-job failure: one source states the governed population contains 157 records through 2026-01-27, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 59 records through 2026-02-27.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/022_vendor_reviews_formal_notice.xml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/09_training/070_training_formal_notice.xml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-16, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Leona Park.\n\n### F-09 — access-request deadline (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for access-request deadline: one source states the operative date is 2025-09-23 under control reference CB-PR-3005-I423, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2025-10-04 under response reference CB-PR-3005-R540.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/025_security_incidents_control_register.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/10_regulator_correspondence/073_regulator_correspondence_control_register.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-16, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Isaac Romero.\n\n### F-10 — identity-verification inconsistency (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for identity-verification inconsistency: one source states the controlling amount is $1,806,343.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $2,119,186.00.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/028_security_incidents_ledger_export.csv`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/10_regulator_correspondence/076_regulator_correspondence_ledger_export.csv`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-16, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Sofia Bennett.\n\n### F-11 — incident-notification clock (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for incident-notification clock: one source states approval is attributed to Lena Varga as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Henry Cho and contains no entry for Lena Varga.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/031_security_incidents_officer_certificate.html`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/10_regulator_correspondence/079_regulator_correspondence_officer_certificate.html`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-16, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Adrian Mensah.\n\n### F-12 — risk-assessment omission (low)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for risk-assessment omission: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-PR-3005-L694, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-PR-3005-U907.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/034_consumer_requests_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/11_risk_assessments/082_risk_assessments_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-16, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Willa Novak.\n\n### F-13 — sensitive-data classification (critical)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for sensitive-data classification: one source states the applicable location is Virginia Attorney General, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to Virginia operations outside Virginia Attorney General.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/037_consumer_requests_review_memorandum.json`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/11_risk_assessments/085_risk_assessments_review_memorandum.json`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-16, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Theo Laurent.\n\n### F-14 — minor-consent issue (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for minor-consent issue: one source states the threshold is 14% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 16% and produced a different exception result.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/040_consumer_requests_status_report.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/11_risk_assessments/088_risk_assessments_status_report.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-16, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Amara Patel.\n\n### F-15 — training completion gap (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for training completion gap: one source states formal notice must use notices-everfield_markets@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-poppy_loyalty_cloud@example.test.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/043_notices_consents_correspondence.eml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/12_remediation/091_remediation_correspondence.eml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-16, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Henry Cho.\n\n### F-16 — regulator commitment overdue (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for regulator commitment overdue: one source states the governed population contains 83 records through 2025-11-14, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 36 records through 2025-11-22.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/046_notices_consents_formal_notice.xml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/12_remediation/094_remediation_formal_notice.xml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-16, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Nadine Flores.\n\n## Recommended next actions\n\nSequence the critical and high findings first, assign the named owners, preserve the cited records, and document any resolution in the controlling matter register before the stated deadline.\n\n## Assumptions and limitations\n\nThis analysis is confined to task cb100-065-everfield-market and the supplied synthetic evidence. It does not rely on external facts, does not resolve disputed law, and is not legal advice for a real person or entity.\n", "findings": {"as_of": "2026-09-16", "findings": [{"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/07_transfer_mechanisms/049_transfer_mechanisms_control_register.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for processing-purpose gap: one source states the operative date is 2026-01-01 under control reference CB-PR-3005-A223, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2026-02-07 under response reference CB-PR-3005-J663.", "id": "F-01", "issue": "processing-purpose gap", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/001_data_inventory_control_register.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-16, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Dominic Alvarez.", "severity": "critical"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/07_transfer_mechanisms/052_transfer_mechanisms_ledger_export.csv", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for notice-practice mismatch: one source states the controlling amount is $2,345,239.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $2,496,978.00.", "id": "F-02", "issue": "notice-practice mismatch", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/004_data_inventory_ledger_export.csv", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-16, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Priya Raman.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/07_transfer_mechanisms/055_transfer_mechanisms_officer_certificate.html", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for consent-record deficiency: one source states approval is attributed to Lena Varga as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Rafael Okafor and contains no entry for Lena Varga.", "id": "F-03", "issue": "consent-record deficiency", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/007_data_inventory_officer_certificate.html", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-16, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Elliot Mercer.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/08_retention_deletion/058_retention_deletion_executed_instrument.txt", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for processor-contract omission: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-PR-3005-D275, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-PR-3005-M182.", "id": "F-04", "issue": "processor-contract omission", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/02_processing_records/010_processing_records_executed_instrument.txt", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-16, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Talia Brooks.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/08_retention_deletion/061_retention_deletion_review_memorandum.json", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for subprocessor inventory mismatch: one source states the applicable location is Virginia Attorney General, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to Virginia operations outside Virginia Attorney General.", "id": "F-05", "issue": "subprocessor inventory mismatch", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/02_processing_records/013_processing_records_review_memorandum.json", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-16, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Jonas Feld.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/08_retention_deletion/064_retention_deletion_status_report.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for cross-border transfer gap: one source states the threshold is 5% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 10% and produced a different exception result.", "id": "F-06", "issue": "cross-border transfer gap", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/02_processing_records/016_processing_records_status_report.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-16, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Mei Whitaker.", "severity": "low"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/09_training/067_training_correspondence.eml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for retention schedule conflict: one source states formal notice must use notices-everfield_markets@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-poppy_loyalty_cloud@example.test.", "id": "F-07", "issue": "retention schedule conflict", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/019_vendor_reviews_correspondence.eml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-16, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Caleb Hassan.", "severity": "critical"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/09_training/070_training_formal_notice.xml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for deletion-job failure: one source states the governed population contains 157 records through 2026-01-27, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 59 records through 2026-02-27.", "id": "F-08", "issue": "deletion-job failure", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/022_vendor_reviews_formal_notice.xml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-16, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Leona Park.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/10_regulator_correspondence/073_regulator_correspondence_control_register.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for access-request deadline: one source states the operative date is 2025-09-23 under control reference CB-PR-3005-I423, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2025-10-04 under response reference CB-PR-3005-R540.", "id": "F-09", "issue": "access-request deadline", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/025_security_incidents_control_register.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-16, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Isaac Romero.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/10_regulator_correspondence/076_regulator_correspondence_ledger_export.csv", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for identity-verification inconsistency: one source states the controlling amount is $1,806,343.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $2,119,186.00.", "id": "F-10", "issue": "identity-verification inconsistency", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/028_security_incidents_ledger_export.csv", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-16, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Sofia Bennett.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/10_regulator_correspondence/079_regulator_correspondence_officer_certificate.html", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for incident-notification clock: one source states approval is attributed to Lena Varga as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Henry Cho and contains no entry for Lena Varga.", "id": "F-11", "issue": "incident-notification clock", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/031_security_incidents_officer_certificate.html", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-16, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Adrian Mensah.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/11_risk_assessments/082_risk_assessments_executed_instrument.txt", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for risk-assessment omission: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-PR-3005-L694, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-PR-3005-U907.", "id": "F-12", "issue": "risk-assessment omission", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/034_consumer_requests_executed_instrument.txt", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-16, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Willa Novak.", "severity": "low"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/11_risk_assessments/085_risk_assessments_review_memorandum.json", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for sensitive-data classification: one source states the applicable location is Virginia Attorney General, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to Virginia operations outside Virginia Attorney General.", "id": "F-13", "issue": "sensitive-data classification", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/037_consumer_requests_review_memorandum.json", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-16, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Theo Laurent.", "severity": "critical"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/11_risk_assessments/088_risk_assessments_status_report.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for minor-consent issue: one source states the threshold is 14% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 16% and produced a different exception result.", "id": "F-14", "issue": "minor-consent issue", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/040_consumer_requests_status_report.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-16, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Amara Patel.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/091_remediation_correspondence.eml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for training completion gap: one source states formal notice must use notices-everfield_markets@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-poppy_loyalty_cloud@example.test.", "id": "F-15", "issue": "training completion gap", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/043_notices_consents_correspondence.eml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-16, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Henry Cho.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/094_remediation_formal_notice.xml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for regulator commitment overdue: one source states the governed population contains 83 records through 2025-11-14, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 36 records through 2025-11-22.", "id": "F-16", "issue": "regulator commitment overdue", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/046_notices_consents_formal_notice.xml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-16, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Nadine Flores.", "severity": "medium"}], "matter_number": "CB-PR-3005", "prepared_for": "Everfield Markets", "schema_version": "1.0", "task_id": "cb100-065-everfield-market"}}, "metadata": {"benchmark": "CounselBench-100", "code_license": "Apache-2.0", "data_license": "CC-BY-4.0", "deadline": "2026-09-16", "document_count": 96, "jurisdiction": "Virginia", "matter_number": "CB-PR-3005", "mcp_commit": "9a96ea6e5913736f92b88345bf51caeaaa8e719f", "mcp_package": "@modelcontextprotocol/server-filesystem@2026.7.10", "practice_area": "privacy-regulatory", "reference_tool_calls": 46, "required_evidence_reads": 33, "synthetic": true, "venue": "Virginia Attorney General", "version": "2.0.0"}, "prompt": "You are privacy and regulatory counsel for Everfield Markets. Outside counsel inherited this file after turnover on the client team and must validate every operative record before advising. Loyalty profiles combine purchase and inferred health data with consent, retention, and processor terms that differ by system. Decision due 2026-09-16. Virginia law governs; Virginia Attorney General is the forum. Evaluate both legal consequence and the practical owner needed to cure each exception. Work out the defensible position from the matter production and leave an audit-ready exception tracker and concise advice for the supervising lawyer. Keep confirmed conflicts separate from open questions, cite the records that actually control each conclusion, and do not fill gaps with outside facts.", "rubric": {"criteria": [{"category": "procedure", "description": "Complete at least 46 successful, argument-specific evidence and output calls.", "id": "procedure.minimum_successful_tool_calls"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Find and read the 33 controlling, corroborating, and work-product-control records in full.", "id": "procedure.all_evidence_read_in_full"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Inspect file metadata for the eight designated critical primary records before relying on them.", "id": "procedure.chain_of_custody_metadata_checked"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Confirm the sandbox's allowed document and output roots.", "id": "procedure.allowed_directories_checked"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Inventory all 96 records so the relevant sources are discovered among the context records.", "id": "procedure.recursive_inventory_completed"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Search the production for email evidence that may corroborate or contradict formal records.", "id": "procedure.targeted_search_completed"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Leave only findings.json and advice.md in the output workspace.", "id": "procedure.exact_deliverable_set"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Create both final work products through the sandbox MCP surface.", "id": "procedure.deliverables_written_through_mcp"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Produce findings.json as a valid JSON object.", "id": "findings.findings_is_object"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Report exactly 16 confirmed exceptions.", "id": "findings.findings_exact_count"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Use each stable finding ID exactly once.", "id": "findings.finding_ids_unique"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set schema_version to the released matter value '1.0'.", "id": "findings.top_level_schema_version"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set task_id to the released matter value 'cb100-065-everfield-market'.", "id": "findings.top_level_task_id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set matter_number to the released matter value 'CB-PR-3005'.", "id": "findings.top_level_matter_number"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set prepared_for to the released matter value 'Everfield Markets'.", "id": "findings.top_level_prepared_for"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set as_of to the released matter value '2026-09-16'.", "id": "findings.top_level_as_of"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-01 exception for processing-purpose gap.", "id": "findings.F-01.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's id from /workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/001_data_inventory_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_transfer_mechanisms/049_transfer_mechanisms_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's issue from /workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/001_data_inventory_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_transfer_mechanisms/049_transfer_mechanisms_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's severity from /workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/001_data_inventory_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_transfer_mechanisms/049_transfer_mechanisms_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's primary_source from /workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/001_data_inventory_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_transfer_mechanisms/049_transfer_mechanisms_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/001_data_inventory_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_transfer_mechanisms/049_transfer_mechanisms_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-01 using the exact controlled facts ['2026-01-01', 'CB-PR-3005-A223', '2026-02-07', 'CB-PR-3005-J663'].", "id": "findings.F-01.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-01's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-01.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-16', 'Dominic Alvarez'] for F-01.", "id": "findings.F-01.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-02 exception for notice-practice mismatch.", "id": "findings.F-02.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's id from /workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/004_data_inventory_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_transfer_mechanisms/052_transfer_mechanisms_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's issue from /workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/004_data_inventory_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_transfer_mechanisms/052_transfer_mechanisms_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's severity from /workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/004_data_inventory_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_transfer_mechanisms/052_transfer_mechanisms_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's primary_source from /workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/004_data_inventory_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_transfer_mechanisms/052_transfer_mechanisms_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/004_data_inventory_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_transfer_mechanisms/052_transfer_mechanisms_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-02 using the exact controlled facts ['$2,345,239.00', '$2,496,978.00'].", "id": "findings.F-02.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-02's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-02.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-16', 'Priya Raman'] for F-02.", "id": "findings.F-02.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-03 exception for consent-record deficiency.", "id": "findings.F-03.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's id from /workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/007_data_inventory_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_transfer_mechanisms/055_transfer_mechanisms_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's issue from /workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/007_data_inventory_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_transfer_mechanisms/055_transfer_mechanisms_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's severity from /workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/007_data_inventory_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_transfer_mechanisms/055_transfer_mechanisms_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's primary_source from /workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/007_data_inventory_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_transfer_mechanisms/055_transfer_mechanisms_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/007_data_inventory_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_transfer_mechanisms/055_transfer_mechanisms_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-03 using the exact controlled facts ['Lena Varga', 'Rafael Okafor'].", "id": "findings.F-03.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-03's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-03.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-16', 'Elliot Mercer'] for F-03.", "id": "findings.F-03.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-04 exception for processor-contract omission.", "id": "findings.F-04.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's id from /workspace/documents/02_processing_records/010_processing_records_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_retention_deletion/058_retention_deletion_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's issue from /workspace/documents/02_processing_records/010_processing_records_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_retention_deletion/058_retention_deletion_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's severity from /workspace/documents/02_processing_records/010_processing_records_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_retention_deletion/058_retention_deletion_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's primary_source from /workspace/documents/02_processing_records/010_processing_records_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_retention_deletion/058_retention_deletion_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/02_processing_records/010_processing_records_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_retention_deletion/058_retention_deletion_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-04 using the exact controlled facts ['closed without exception', 'CB-PR-3005-D275', 'open and escalated', 'CB-PR-3005-M182'].", "id": "findings.F-04.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-04's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-04.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-16', 'Talia Brooks'] for F-04.", "id": "findings.F-04.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-05 exception for subprocessor inventory mismatch.", "id": "findings.F-05.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's id from /workspace/documents/02_processing_records/013_processing_records_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_retention_deletion/061_retention_deletion_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's issue from /workspace/documents/02_processing_records/013_processing_records_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_retention_deletion/061_retention_deletion_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's severity from /workspace/documents/02_processing_records/013_processing_records_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_retention_deletion/061_retention_deletion_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's primary_source from /workspace/documents/02_processing_records/013_processing_records_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_retention_deletion/061_retention_deletion_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/02_processing_records/013_processing_records_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_retention_deletion/061_retention_deletion_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-05 using the exact controlled facts ['Virginia Attorney General', 'Virginia'].", "id": "findings.F-05.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-05's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-05.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-16', 'Jonas Feld'] for F-05.", "id": "findings.F-05.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-06 exception for cross-border transfer gap.", "id": "findings.F-06.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's id from /workspace/documents/02_processing_records/016_processing_records_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_retention_deletion/064_retention_deletion_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's issue from /workspace/documents/02_processing_records/016_processing_records_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_retention_deletion/064_retention_deletion_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's severity from /workspace/documents/02_processing_records/016_processing_records_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_retention_deletion/064_retention_deletion_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's primary_source from /workspace/documents/02_processing_records/016_processing_records_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_retention_deletion/064_retention_deletion_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/02_processing_records/016_processing_records_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_retention_deletion/064_retention_deletion_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-06 using the exact controlled facts ['5%', '10%'].", "id": "findings.F-06.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-06's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-06.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-16', 'Mei Whitaker'] for F-06.", "id": "findings.F-06.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-07 exception for retention schedule conflict.", "id": "findings.F-07.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's id from /workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/019_vendor_reviews_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_training/067_training_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's issue from /workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/019_vendor_reviews_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_training/067_training_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's severity from /workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/019_vendor_reviews_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_training/067_training_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's primary_source from /workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/019_vendor_reviews_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_training/067_training_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/019_vendor_reviews_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_training/067_training_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-07 using the exact controlled facts ['notices-everfield_markets@example.test', 'archive-poppy_loyalty_cloud@example.test'].", "id": "findings.F-07.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-07's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-07.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-16', 'Caleb Hassan'] for F-07.", "id": "findings.F-07.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-08 exception for deletion-job failure.", "id": "findings.F-08.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's id from /workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/022_vendor_reviews_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_training/070_training_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's issue from /workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/022_vendor_reviews_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_training/070_training_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's severity from /workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/022_vendor_reviews_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_training/070_training_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's primary_source from /workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/022_vendor_reviews_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_training/070_training_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/022_vendor_reviews_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_training/070_training_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-08 using the exact controlled facts ['157 records', '2026-01-27', '59 records', '2026-02-27'].", "id": "findings.F-08.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-08's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-08.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-16', 'Leona Park'] for F-08.", "id": "findings.F-08.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-09 exception for access-request deadline.", "id": "findings.F-09.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's id from /workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/025_security_incidents_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_regulator_correspondence/073_regulator_correspondence_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's issue from /workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/025_security_incidents_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_regulator_correspondence/073_regulator_correspondence_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's severity from /workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/025_security_incidents_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_regulator_correspondence/073_regulator_correspondence_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's primary_source from /workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/025_security_incidents_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_regulator_correspondence/073_regulator_correspondence_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/025_security_incidents_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_regulator_correspondence/073_regulator_correspondence_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-09 using the exact controlled facts ['2025-09-23', 'CB-PR-3005-I423', '2025-10-04', 'CB-PR-3005-R540'].", "id": "findings.F-09.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-09's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-09.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-16', 'Isaac Romero'] for F-09.", "id": "findings.F-09.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-10 exception for identity-verification inconsistency.", "id": "findings.F-10.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's id from /workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/028_security_incidents_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_regulator_correspondence/076_regulator_correspondence_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's issue from /workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/028_security_incidents_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_regulator_correspondence/076_regulator_correspondence_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's severity from /workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/028_security_incidents_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_regulator_correspondence/076_regulator_correspondence_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's primary_source from /workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/028_security_incidents_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_regulator_correspondence/076_regulator_correspondence_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/028_security_incidents_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_regulator_correspondence/076_regulator_correspondence_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-10 using the exact controlled facts ['$1,806,343.00', '$2,119,186.00'].", "id": "findings.F-10.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-10's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-10.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-16', 'Sofia Bennett'] for F-10.", "id": "findings.F-10.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-11 exception for incident-notification clock.", "id": "findings.F-11.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's id from /workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/031_security_incidents_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_regulator_correspondence/079_regulator_correspondence_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's issue from /workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/031_security_incidents_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_regulator_correspondence/079_regulator_correspondence_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's severity from /workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/031_security_incidents_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_regulator_correspondence/079_regulator_correspondence_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's primary_source from /workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/031_security_incidents_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_regulator_correspondence/079_regulator_correspondence_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/031_security_incidents_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_regulator_correspondence/079_regulator_correspondence_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-11 using the exact controlled facts ['Lena Varga', 'Henry Cho'].", "id": "findings.F-11.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-11's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-11.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-16', 'Adrian Mensah'] for F-11.", "id": "findings.F-11.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-12 exception for risk-assessment omission.", "id": "findings.F-12.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's id from /workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/034_consumer_requests_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_risk_assessments/082_risk_assessments_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's issue from /workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/034_consumer_requests_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_risk_assessments/082_risk_assessments_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's severity from /workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/034_consumer_requests_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_risk_assessments/082_risk_assessments_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's primary_source from /workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/034_consumer_requests_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_risk_assessments/082_risk_assessments_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/034_consumer_requests_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_risk_assessments/082_risk_assessments_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-12 using the exact controlled facts ['closed without exception', 'CB-PR-3005-L694', 'open and escalated', 'CB-PR-3005-U907'].", "id": "findings.F-12.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-12's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-12.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-16', 'Willa Novak'] for F-12.", "id": "findings.F-12.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-13 exception for sensitive-data classification.", "id": "findings.F-13.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's id from /workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/037_consumer_requests_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_risk_assessments/085_risk_assessments_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's issue from /workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/037_consumer_requests_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_risk_assessments/085_risk_assessments_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's severity from /workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/037_consumer_requests_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_risk_assessments/085_risk_assessments_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's primary_source from /workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/037_consumer_requests_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_risk_assessments/085_risk_assessments_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/037_consumer_requests_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_risk_assessments/085_risk_assessments_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-13 using the exact controlled facts ['Virginia Attorney General', 'Virginia'].", "id": "findings.F-13.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-13's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-13.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-16', 'Theo Laurent'] for F-13.", "id": "findings.F-13.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-14 exception for minor-consent issue.", "id": "findings.F-14.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's id from /workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/040_consumer_requests_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_risk_assessments/088_risk_assessments_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's issue from /workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/040_consumer_requests_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_risk_assessments/088_risk_assessments_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's severity from /workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/040_consumer_requests_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_risk_assessments/088_risk_assessments_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's primary_source from /workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/040_consumer_requests_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_risk_assessments/088_risk_assessments_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/040_consumer_requests_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_risk_assessments/088_risk_assessments_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-14 using the exact controlled facts ['14%', '16%'].", "id": "findings.F-14.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-14's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-14.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-16', 'Amara Patel'] for F-14.", "id": "findings.F-14.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-15 exception for training completion gap.", "id": "findings.F-15.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's id from /workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/043_notices_consents_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_remediation/091_remediation_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's issue from /workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/043_notices_consents_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_remediation/091_remediation_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's severity from /workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/043_notices_consents_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_remediation/091_remediation_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's primary_source from /workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/043_notices_consents_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_remediation/091_remediation_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/043_notices_consents_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_remediation/091_remediation_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-15 using the exact controlled facts ['notices-everfield_markets@example.test', 'archive-poppy_loyalty_cloud@example.test'].", "id": "findings.F-15.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-15's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-15.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-16', 'Henry Cho'] for F-15.", "id": "findings.F-15.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-16 exception for regulator commitment overdue.", "id": "findings.F-16.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's id from /workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/046_notices_consents_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_remediation/094_remediation_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's issue from /workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/046_notices_consents_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_remediation/094_remediation_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's severity from /workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/046_notices_consents_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_remediation/094_remediation_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's primary_source from /workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/046_notices_consents_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_remediation/094_remediation_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/046_notices_consents_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_remediation/094_remediation_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-16 using the exact controlled facts ['83 records', '2025-11-14', '36 records', '2025-11-22'].", "id": "findings.F-16.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-16's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-16.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-16', 'Nadine Flores'] for F-16.", "id": "findings.F-16.action_anchors"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Executive assessment' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Executive assessment"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Method and record coverage' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Method and record coverage"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Findings' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Findings"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Recommended next actions' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Recommended next actions"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Assumptions and limitations' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Assumptions and limitations"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-01 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-01"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-02 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-02"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-03 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-03"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-04 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-04"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-05 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-05"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-06 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-06"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-07 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-07"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-08 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-08"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-09 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-09"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-10 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-10"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-11 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-11"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-12 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-12"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-13 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-13"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-14 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-14"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-15 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-15"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-16 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-16"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Do not claim the production has no issues or that every record is consistent.", "id": "memo.forbidden_claims_absent"}], "decision_options": [{"id": "cross-source-reconciliation", "label": "Reconcile controlling and corroborating records", "reason": "The CB-PR-3005 production contains independently maintained records; a defensible answer must preserve each supported conflict and its cure owner.", "selected": true}, {"id": "latest-record-controls", "label": "Treat the latest record as controlling", "reason": "Timestamp recency does not establish legal priority, execution, or approval authority.", "selected": false}, {"id": "primary-records-only", "label": "Report primary records without reconciliation", "reason": "Primary records alone conceal the operational conflicts that create the actionable exceptions.", "selected": false}], "gates": ["all_evidence_read_in_full", "chain_of_custody_metadata_checked", "findings_criteria_complete", "memo_criteria_complete", "deliverables_written_through_mcp"], "metadata_checks": 8, "metric": "weighted_criteria_score", "minimum_tool_calls": 46, "required_deliverables": ["findings.json", "advice.md"], "required_document_reads": 33, "type": "deterministic", "weights": {"findings": 0.55, "memo": 0.2, "procedure": 0.25}}, "task_id": "cb100-065-everfield-market", "task_name": "Everfield loyalty-data assessment", "world_id": "counselbench-filesystem-mcp-v2"}
-{"context_files": ["task_files/cb100-066-fable-fintech/01_data_inventory/001_data_inventory_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-066-fable-fintech/01_data_inventory/002_data_inventory_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-066-fable-fintech/01_data_inventory/003_data_inventory_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-066-fable-fintech/01_data_inventory/004_data_inventory_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-066-fable-fintech/01_data_inventory/005_data_inventory_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-066-fable-fintech/01_data_inventory/006_data_inventory_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-066-fable-fintech/01_data_inventory/007_data_inventory_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-066-fable-fintech/01_data_inventory/008_data_inventory_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-066-fable-fintech/02_processing_records/009_processing_records_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-066-fable-fintech/02_processing_records/010_processing_records_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-066-fable-fintech/02_processing_records/011_processing_records_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-066-fable-fintech/02_processing_records/012_processing_records_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-066-fable-fintech/02_processing_records/013_processing_records_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-066-fable-fintech/02_processing_records/014_processing_records_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-066-fable-fintech/02_processing_records/015_processing_records_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-066-fable-fintech/02_processing_records/016_processing_records_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-066-fable-fintech/03_vendor_reviews/017_vendor_reviews_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-066-fable-fintech/03_vendor_reviews/018_vendor_reviews_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-066-fable-fintech/03_vendor_reviews/019_vendor_reviews_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-066-fable-fintech/03_vendor_reviews/020_vendor_reviews_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-066-fable-fintech/03_vendor_reviews/021_vendor_reviews_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-066-fable-fintech/03_vendor_reviews/022_vendor_reviews_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-066-fable-fintech/03_vendor_reviews/023_vendor_reviews_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-066-fable-fintech/03_vendor_reviews/024_vendor_reviews_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-066-fable-fintech/04_security_incidents/025_security_incidents_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-066-fable-fintech/04_security_incidents/026_security_incidents_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-066-fable-fintech/04_security_incidents/027_security_incidents_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-066-fable-fintech/04_security_incidents/028_security_incidents_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-066-fable-fintech/04_security_incidents/029_security_incidents_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-066-fable-fintech/04_security_incidents/030_security_incidents_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-066-fable-fintech/04_security_incidents/031_security_incidents_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-066-fable-fintech/04_security_incidents/032_security_incidents_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-066-fable-fintech/05_consumer_requests/033_consumer_requests_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-066-fable-fintech/05_consumer_requests/034_consumer_requests_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-066-fable-fintech/05_consumer_requests/035_consumer_requests_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-066-fable-fintech/05_consumer_requests/036_consumer_requests_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-066-fable-fintech/05_consumer_requests/037_consumer_requests_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-066-fable-fintech/05_consumer_requests/038_consumer_requests_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-066-fable-fintech/05_consumer_requests/039_consumer_requests_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-066-fable-fintech/05_consumer_requests/040_consumer_requests_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-066-fable-fintech/06_notices_consents/041_notices_consents_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-066-fable-fintech/06_notices_consents/042_notices_consents_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-066-fable-fintech/06_notices_consents/043_notices_consents_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-066-fable-fintech/06_notices_consents/044_notices_consents_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-066-fable-fintech/06_notices_consents/045_notices_consents_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-066-fable-fintech/06_notices_consents/046_notices_consents_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-066-fable-fintech/06_notices_consents/047_notices_consents_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-066-fable-fintech/06_notices_consents/048_notices_consents_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-066-fable-fintech/07_transfer_mechanisms/049_transfer_mechanisms_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-066-fable-fintech/07_transfer_mechanisms/050_transfer_mechanisms_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-066-fable-fintech/07_transfer_mechanisms/051_transfer_mechanisms_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-066-fable-fintech/07_transfer_mechanisms/052_transfer_mechanisms_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-066-fable-fintech/07_transfer_mechanisms/053_transfer_mechanisms_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-066-fable-fintech/07_transfer_mechanisms/054_transfer_mechanisms_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-066-fable-fintech/07_transfer_mechanisms/055_transfer_mechanisms_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-066-fable-fintech/07_transfer_mechanisms/056_transfer_mechanisms_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-066-fable-fintech/08_retention_deletion/057_retention_deletion_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-066-fable-fintech/08_retention_deletion/058_retention_deletion_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-066-fable-fintech/08_retention_deletion/059_retention_deletion_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-066-fable-fintech/08_retention_deletion/060_retention_deletion_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-066-fable-fintech/08_retention_deletion/061_retention_deletion_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-066-fable-fintech/08_retention_deletion/062_retention_deletion_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-066-fable-fintech/08_retention_deletion/063_retention_deletion_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-066-fable-fintech/08_retention_deletion/064_retention_deletion_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-066-fable-fintech/09_training/065_training_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-066-fable-fintech/09_training/066_training_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-066-fable-fintech/09_training/067_training_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-066-fable-fintech/09_training/068_training_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-066-fable-fintech/09_training/069_training_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-066-fable-fintech/09_training/070_training_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-066-fable-fintech/09_training/071_training_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-066-fable-fintech/09_training/072_training_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-066-fable-fintech/10_regulator_correspondence/073_regulator_correspondence_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-066-fable-fintech/10_regulator_correspondence/074_regulator_correspondence_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-066-fable-fintech/10_regulator_correspondence/075_regulator_correspondence_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-066-fable-fintech/10_regulator_correspondence/076_regulator_correspondence_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-066-fable-fintech/10_regulator_correspondence/077_regulator_correspondence_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-066-fable-fintech/10_regulator_correspondence/078_regulator_correspondence_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-066-fable-fintech/10_regulator_correspondence/079_regulator_correspondence_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-066-fable-fintech/10_regulator_correspondence/080_regulator_correspondence_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-066-fable-fintech/11_risk_assessments/081_risk_assessments_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-066-fable-fintech/11_risk_assessments/082_risk_assessments_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-066-fable-fintech/11_risk_assessments/083_risk_assessments_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-066-fable-fintech/11_risk_assessments/084_risk_assessments_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-066-fable-fintech/11_risk_assessments/085_risk_assessments_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-066-fable-fintech/11_risk_assessments/086_risk_assessments_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-066-fable-fintech/11_risk_assessments/087_risk_assessments_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-066-fable-fintech/11_risk_assessments/088_risk_assessments_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-066-fable-fintech/12_remediation/089_remediation_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-066-fable-fintech/12_remediation/090_remediation_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-066-fable-fintech/12_remediation/091_remediation_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-066-fable-fintech/12_remediation/092_remediation_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-066-fable-fintech/12_remediation/093_remediation_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-066-fable-fintech/12_remediation/094_remediation_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-066-fable-fintech/12_remediation/095_remediation_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-066-fable-fintech/12_remediation/096_remediation_status_report.md"], "gold_output": {"advice_markdown": "# Counsel advice — Fable automated-decision privacy review\n\n## Executive assessment\n\nFor Fable Financial Technologies matter CB-PR-3006, the review identified 16 source-supported exceptions requiring action before 2026-09-20. The assessment concerns Northbridge Model Services and the supplied record for Illinois.\n\n## Method and record coverage\n\nThe review inventoried all 96 production files, read the 33 controlling, corroborating, and control records, searched the email exports, and checked metadata for the designated chain-of-custody sample. Conclusions are limited to the synthetic production supplied for this benchmark matter.\n\n## Findings\n\n### F-01 — processing-purpose gap (critical)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for processing-purpose gap: one source states the operative date is 2025-06-11 under control reference CB-PR-3006-A619, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2025-07-26 under response reference CB-PR-3006-J763.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/001_data_inventory_control_register.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/07_transfer_mechanisms/049_transfer_mechanisms_control_register.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-20, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Priya Raman.\n\n### F-02 — notice-practice mismatch (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for notice-practice mismatch: one source states the controlling amount is $4,380,820.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $4,478,140.00.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/004_data_inventory_ledger_export.csv`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/07_transfer_mechanisms/052_transfer_mechanisms_ledger_export.csv`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-20, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Elliot Mercer.\n\n### F-03 — consent-record deficiency (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for consent-record deficiency: one source states approval is attributed to Samuel Kim as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Dominic Alvarez and contains no entry for Samuel Kim.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/007_data_inventory_officer_certificate.html`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/07_transfer_mechanisms/055_transfer_mechanisms_officer_certificate.html`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-20, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Talia Brooks.\n\n### F-04 — processor-contract omission (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for processor-contract omission: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-PR-3006-D560, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-PR-3006-M204.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/02_processing_records/010_processing_records_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/08_retention_deletion/058_retention_deletion_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-20, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Jonas Feld.\n\n### F-05 — subprocessor inventory mismatch (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for subprocessor inventory mismatch: one source states the applicable location is Illinois Department of Financial and Professional Regulation, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to Illinois operations outside Illinois Department of Financial and Professional Regulation.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/02_processing_records/013_processing_records_review_memorandum.json`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/08_retention_deletion/061_retention_deletion_review_memorandum.json`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-20, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Mei Whitaker.\n\n### F-06 — cross-border transfer gap (low)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for cross-border transfer gap: one source states the threshold is 5% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 8% and produced a different exception result.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/02_processing_records/016_processing_records_status_report.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/08_retention_deletion/064_retention_deletion_status_report.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-20, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Caleb Hassan.\n\n### F-07 — retention schedule conflict (critical)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for retention schedule conflict: one source states formal notice must use notices-fable_financial_technologies@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-northbridge_model_services@example.test.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/019_vendor_reviews_correspondence.eml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/09_training/067_training_correspondence.eml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-20, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Leona Park.\n\n### F-08 — deletion-job failure (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for deletion-job failure: one source states the governed population contains 110 records through 2025-03-06, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 73 records through 2025-04-20.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/022_vendor_reviews_formal_notice.xml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/09_training/070_training_formal_notice.xml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-20, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Isaac Romero.\n\n### F-09 — access-request deadline (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for access-request deadline: one source states the operative date is 2025-03-25 under control reference CB-PR-3006-I301, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2025-05-04 under response reference CB-PR-3006-R738.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/025_security_incidents_control_register.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/10_regulator_correspondence/073_regulator_correspondence_control_register.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-20, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Sofia Bennett.\n\n### F-10 — identity-verification inconsistency (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for identity-verification inconsistency: one source states the controlling amount is $1,361,019.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $1,378,538.00.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/028_security_incidents_ledger_export.csv`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/10_regulator_correspondence/076_regulator_correspondence_ledger_export.csv`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-20, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Adrian Mensah.\n\n### F-11 — incident-notification clock (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for incident-notification clock: one source states approval is attributed to Samuel Kim as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Micah Sullivan and contains no entry for Samuel Kim.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/031_security_incidents_officer_certificate.html`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/10_regulator_correspondence/079_regulator_correspondence_officer_certificate.html`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-20, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Willa Novak.\n\n### F-12 — risk-assessment omission (low)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for risk-assessment omission: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-PR-3006-L857, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-PR-3006-U642.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/034_consumer_requests_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/11_risk_assessments/082_risk_assessments_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-20, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Theo Laurent.\n\n### F-13 — sensitive-data classification (critical)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for sensitive-data classification: one source states the applicable location is Illinois Department of Financial and Professional Regulation, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to Illinois operations outside Illinois Department of Financial and Professional Regulation.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/037_consumer_requests_review_memorandum.json`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/11_risk_assessments/085_risk_assessments_review_memorandum.json`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-20, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Amara Patel.\n\n### F-14 — minor-consent issue (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for minor-consent issue: one source states the threshold is 10% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 16% and produced a different exception result.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/040_consumer_requests_status_report.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/11_risk_assessments/088_risk_assessments_status_report.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-20, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Henry Cho.\n\n### F-15 — training completion gap (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for training completion gap: one source states formal notice must use notices-fable_financial_technologies@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-northbridge_model_services@example.test.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/043_notices_consents_correspondence.eml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/12_remediation/091_remediation_correspondence.eml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-20, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Nadine Flores.\n\n### F-16 — regulator commitment overdue (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for regulator commitment overdue: one source states the governed population contains 141 records through 2026-01-11, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 47 records through 2026-01-30.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/046_notices_consents_formal_notice.xml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/12_remediation/094_remediation_formal_notice.xml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-20, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Micah Sullivan.\n\n## Recommended next actions\n\nSequence the critical and high findings first, assign the named owners, preserve the cited records, and document any resolution in the controlling matter register before the stated deadline.\n\n## Assumptions and limitations\n\nThis analysis is confined to task cb100-066-fable-fintech and the supplied synthetic evidence. It does not rely on external facts, does not resolve disputed law, and is not legal advice for a real person or entity.\n", "findings": {"as_of": "2026-09-20", "findings": [{"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/07_transfer_mechanisms/049_transfer_mechanisms_control_register.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for processing-purpose gap: one source states the operative date is 2025-06-11 under control reference CB-PR-3006-A619, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2025-07-26 under response reference CB-PR-3006-J763.", "id": "F-01", "issue": "processing-purpose gap", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/001_data_inventory_control_register.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-20, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Priya Raman.", "severity": "critical"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/07_transfer_mechanisms/052_transfer_mechanisms_ledger_export.csv", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for notice-practice mismatch: one source states the controlling amount is $4,380,820.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $4,478,140.00.", "id": "F-02", "issue": "notice-practice mismatch", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/004_data_inventory_ledger_export.csv", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-20, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Elliot Mercer.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/07_transfer_mechanisms/055_transfer_mechanisms_officer_certificate.html", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for consent-record deficiency: one source states approval is attributed to Samuel Kim as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Dominic Alvarez and contains no entry for Samuel Kim.", "id": "F-03", "issue": "consent-record deficiency", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/007_data_inventory_officer_certificate.html", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-20, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Talia Brooks.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/08_retention_deletion/058_retention_deletion_executed_instrument.txt", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for processor-contract omission: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-PR-3006-D560, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-PR-3006-M204.", "id": "F-04", "issue": "processor-contract omission", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/02_processing_records/010_processing_records_executed_instrument.txt", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-20, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Jonas Feld.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/08_retention_deletion/061_retention_deletion_review_memorandum.json", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for subprocessor inventory mismatch: one source states the applicable location is Illinois Department of Financial and Professional Regulation, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to Illinois operations outside Illinois Department of Financial and Professional Regulation.", "id": "F-05", "issue": "subprocessor inventory mismatch", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/02_processing_records/013_processing_records_review_memorandum.json", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-20, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Mei Whitaker.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/08_retention_deletion/064_retention_deletion_status_report.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for cross-border transfer gap: one source states the threshold is 5% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 8% and produced a different exception result.", "id": "F-06", "issue": "cross-border transfer gap", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/02_processing_records/016_processing_records_status_report.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-20, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Caleb Hassan.", "severity": "low"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/09_training/067_training_correspondence.eml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for retention schedule conflict: one source states formal notice must use notices-fable_financial_technologies@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-northbridge_model_services@example.test.", "id": "F-07", "issue": "retention schedule conflict", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/019_vendor_reviews_correspondence.eml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-20, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Leona Park.", "severity": "critical"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/09_training/070_training_formal_notice.xml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for deletion-job failure: one source states the governed population contains 110 records through 2025-03-06, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 73 records through 2025-04-20.", "id": "F-08", "issue": "deletion-job failure", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/022_vendor_reviews_formal_notice.xml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-20, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Isaac Romero.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/10_regulator_correspondence/073_regulator_correspondence_control_register.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for access-request deadline: one source states the operative date is 2025-03-25 under control reference CB-PR-3006-I301, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2025-05-04 under response reference CB-PR-3006-R738.", "id": "F-09", "issue": "access-request deadline", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/025_security_incidents_control_register.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-20, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Sofia Bennett.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/10_regulator_correspondence/076_regulator_correspondence_ledger_export.csv", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for identity-verification inconsistency: one source states the controlling amount is $1,361,019.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $1,378,538.00.", "id": "F-10", "issue": "identity-verification inconsistency", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/028_security_incidents_ledger_export.csv", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-20, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Adrian Mensah.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/10_regulator_correspondence/079_regulator_correspondence_officer_certificate.html", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for incident-notification clock: one source states approval is attributed to Samuel Kim as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Micah Sullivan and contains no entry for Samuel Kim.", "id": "F-11", "issue": "incident-notification clock", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/031_security_incidents_officer_certificate.html", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-20, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Willa Novak.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/11_risk_assessments/082_risk_assessments_executed_instrument.txt", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for risk-assessment omission: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-PR-3006-L857, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-PR-3006-U642.", "id": "F-12", "issue": "risk-assessment omission", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/034_consumer_requests_executed_instrument.txt", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-20, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Theo Laurent.", "severity": "low"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/11_risk_assessments/085_risk_assessments_review_memorandum.json", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for sensitive-data classification: one source states the applicable location is Illinois Department of Financial and Professional Regulation, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to Illinois operations outside Illinois Department of Financial and Professional Regulation.", "id": "F-13", "issue": "sensitive-data classification", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/037_consumer_requests_review_memorandum.json", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-20, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Amara Patel.", "severity": "critical"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/11_risk_assessments/088_risk_assessments_status_report.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for minor-consent issue: one source states the threshold is 10% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 16% and produced a different exception result.", "id": "F-14", "issue": "minor-consent issue", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/040_consumer_requests_status_report.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-20, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Henry Cho.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/091_remediation_correspondence.eml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for training completion gap: one source states formal notice must use notices-fable_financial_technologies@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-northbridge_model_services@example.test.", "id": "F-15", "issue": "training completion gap", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/043_notices_consents_correspondence.eml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-20, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Nadine Flores.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/094_remediation_formal_notice.xml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for regulator commitment overdue: one source states the governed population contains 141 records through 2026-01-11, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 47 records through 2026-01-30.", "id": "F-16", "issue": "regulator commitment overdue", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/046_notices_consents_formal_notice.xml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-20, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Micah Sullivan.", "severity": "medium"}], "matter_number": "CB-PR-3006", "prepared_for": "Fable Financial Technologies", "schema_version": "1.0", "task_id": "cb100-066-fable-fintech"}}, "metadata": {"benchmark": "CounselBench-100", "code_license": "Apache-2.0", "data_license": "CC-BY-4.0", "deadline": "2026-09-20", "document_count": 96, "jurisdiction": "Illinois", "matter_number": "CB-PR-3006", "mcp_commit": "9a96ea6e5913736f92b88345bf51caeaaa8e719f", "mcp_package": "@modelcontextprotocol/server-filesystem@2026.7.10", "practice_area": "privacy-regulatory", "reference_tool_calls": 46, "required_evidence_reads": 33, "synthetic": true, "venue": "Illinois Department of Financial and Professional Regulation", "version": "2.0.0"}, "prompt": "You are privacy and regulatory counsel for Fable Financial Technologies. The upcoming deadline leaves no room for unsupported assumptions, so every conclusion must trace to the supplied production. A credit prequalification workflow uses third-party model features while notices, assessments, deletion records, and complaint responses conflict. Decision due 2026-09-20. Illinois law governs; Illinois Department of Financial and Professional Regulation is the forum. Give controlling documents precedence only when the record supports that hierarchy. Work out the defensible position from the matter production and leave an audit-ready exception tracker and concise advice for the supervising lawyer. Keep confirmed conflicts separate from open questions, cite the records that actually control each conclusion, and do not fill gaps with outside facts.", "rubric": {"criteria": [{"category": "procedure", "description": "Complete at least 46 successful, argument-specific evidence and output calls.", "id": "procedure.minimum_successful_tool_calls"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Find and read the 33 controlling, corroborating, and work-product-control records in full.", "id": "procedure.all_evidence_read_in_full"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Inspect file metadata for the eight designated critical primary records before relying on them.", "id": "procedure.chain_of_custody_metadata_checked"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Confirm the sandbox's allowed document and output roots.", "id": "procedure.allowed_directories_checked"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Inventory all 96 records so the relevant sources are discovered among the context records.", "id": "procedure.recursive_inventory_completed"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Search the production for email evidence that may corroborate or contradict formal records.", "id": "procedure.targeted_search_completed"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Leave only findings.json and advice.md in the output workspace.", "id": "procedure.exact_deliverable_set"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Create both final work products through the sandbox MCP surface.", "id": "procedure.deliverables_written_through_mcp"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Produce findings.json as a valid JSON object.", "id": "findings.findings_is_object"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Report exactly 16 confirmed exceptions.", "id": "findings.findings_exact_count"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Use each stable finding ID exactly once.", "id": "findings.finding_ids_unique"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set schema_version to the released matter value '1.0'.", "id": "findings.top_level_schema_version"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set task_id to the released matter value 'cb100-066-fable-fintech'.", "id": "findings.top_level_task_id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set matter_number to the released matter value 'CB-PR-3006'.", "id": "findings.top_level_matter_number"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set prepared_for to the released matter value 'Fable Financial Technologies'.", "id": "findings.top_level_prepared_for"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set as_of to the released matter value '2026-09-20'.", "id": "findings.top_level_as_of"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-01 exception for processing-purpose gap.", "id": "findings.F-01.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's id from /workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/001_data_inventory_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_transfer_mechanisms/049_transfer_mechanisms_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's issue from /workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/001_data_inventory_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_transfer_mechanisms/049_transfer_mechanisms_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's severity from /workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/001_data_inventory_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_transfer_mechanisms/049_transfer_mechanisms_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's primary_source from /workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/001_data_inventory_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_transfer_mechanisms/049_transfer_mechanisms_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/001_data_inventory_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_transfer_mechanisms/049_transfer_mechanisms_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-01 using the exact controlled facts ['2025-06-11', 'CB-PR-3006-A619', '2025-07-26', 'CB-PR-3006-J763'].", "id": "findings.F-01.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-01's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-01.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-20', 'Priya Raman'] for F-01.", "id": "findings.F-01.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-02 exception for notice-practice mismatch.", "id": "findings.F-02.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's id from /workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/004_data_inventory_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_transfer_mechanisms/052_transfer_mechanisms_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's issue from /workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/004_data_inventory_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_transfer_mechanisms/052_transfer_mechanisms_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's severity from /workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/004_data_inventory_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_transfer_mechanisms/052_transfer_mechanisms_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's primary_source from /workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/004_data_inventory_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_transfer_mechanisms/052_transfer_mechanisms_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/004_data_inventory_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_transfer_mechanisms/052_transfer_mechanisms_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-02 using the exact controlled facts ['$4,380,820.00', '$4,478,140.00'].", "id": "findings.F-02.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-02's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-02.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-20', 'Elliot Mercer'] for F-02.", "id": "findings.F-02.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-03 exception for consent-record deficiency.", "id": "findings.F-03.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's id from /workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/007_data_inventory_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_transfer_mechanisms/055_transfer_mechanisms_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's issue from /workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/007_data_inventory_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_transfer_mechanisms/055_transfer_mechanisms_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's severity from /workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/007_data_inventory_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_transfer_mechanisms/055_transfer_mechanisms_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's primary_source from /workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/007_data_inventory_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_transfer_mechanisms/055_transfer_mechanisms_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/007_data_inventory_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_transfer_mechanisms/055_transfer_mechanisms_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-03 using the exact controlled facts ['Samuel Kim', 'Dominic Alvarez'].", "id": "findings.F-03.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-03's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-03.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-20', 'Talia Brooks'] for F-03.", "id": "findings.F-03.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-04 exception for processor-contract omission.", "id": "findings.F-04.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's id from /workspace/documents/02_processing_records/010_processing_records_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_retention_deletion/058_retention_deletion_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's issue from /workspace/documents/02_processing_records/010_processing_records_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_retention_deletion/058_retention_deletion_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's severity from /workspace/documents/02_processing_records/010_processing_records_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_retention_deletion/058_retention_deletion_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's primary_source from /workspace/documents/02_processing_records/010_processing_records_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_retention_deletion/058_retention_deletion_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/02_processing_records/010_processing_records_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_retention_deletion/058_retention_deletion_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-04 using the exact controlled facts ['closed without exception', 'CB-PR-3006-D560', 'open and escalated', 'CB-PR-3006-M204'].", "id": "findings.F-04.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-04's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-04.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-20', 'Jonas Feld'] for F-04.", "id": "findings.F-04.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-05 exception for subprocessor inventory mismatch.", "id": "findings.F-05.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's id from /workspace/documents/02_processing_records/013_processing_records_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_retention_deletion/061_retention_deletion_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's issue from /workspace/documents/02_processing_records/013_processing_records_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_retention_deletion/061_retention_deletion_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's severity from /workspace/documents/02_processing_records/013_processing_records_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_retention_deletion/061_retention_deletion_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's primary_source from /workspace/documents/02_processing_records/013_processing_records_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_retention_deletion/061_retention_deletion_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/02_processing_records/013_processing_records_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_retention_deletion/061_retention_deletion_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-05 using the exact controlled facts ['Illinois Department of Financial and Professional Regulation', 'Illinois'].", "id": "findings.F-05.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-05's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-05.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-20', 'Mei Whitaker'] for F-05.", "id": "findings.F-05.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-06 exception for cross-border transfer gap.", "id": "findings.F-06.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's id from /workspace/documents/02_processing_records/016_processing_records_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_retention_deletion/064_retention_deletion_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's issue from /workspace/documents/02_processing_records/016_processing_records_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_retention_deletion/064_retention_deletion_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's severity from /workspace/documents/02_processing_records/016_processing_records_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_retention_deletion/064_retention_deletion_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's primary_source from /workspace/documents/02_processing_records/016_processing_records_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_retention_deletion/064_retention_deletion_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/02_processing_records/016_processing_records_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_retention_deletion/064_retention_deletion_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-06 using the exact controlled facts ['5%', '8%'].", "id": "findings.F-06.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-06's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-06.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-20', 'Caleb Hassan'] for F-06.", "id": "findings.F-06.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-07 exception for retention schedule conflict.", "id": "findings.F-07.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's id from /workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/019_vendor_reviews_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_training/067_training_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's issue from /workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/019_vendor_reviews_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_training/067_training_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's severity from /workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/019_vendor_reviews_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_training/067_training_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's primary_source from /workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/019_vendor_reviews_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_training/067_training_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/019_vendor_reviews_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_training/067_training_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-07 using the exact controlled facts ['notices-fable_financial_technologies@example.test', 'archive-northbridge_model_services@example.test'].", "id": "findings.F-07.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-07's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-07.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-20', 'Leona Park'] for F-07.", "id": "findings.F-07.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-08 exception for deletion-job failure.", "id": "findings.F-08.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's id from /workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/022_vendor_reviews_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_training/070_training_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's issue from /workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/022_vendor_reviews_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_training/070_training_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's severity from /workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/022_vendor_reviews_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_training/070_training_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's primary_source from /workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/022_vendor_reviews_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_training/070_training_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/022_vendor_reviews_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_training/070_training_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-08 using the exact controlled facts ['110 records', '2025-03-06', '73 records', '2025-04-20'].", "id": "findings.F-08.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-08's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-08.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-20', 'Isaac Romero'] for F-08.", "id": "findings.F-08.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-09 exception for access-request deadline.", "id": "findings.F-09.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's id from /workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/025_security_incidents_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_regulator_correspondence/073_regulator_correspondence_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's issue from /workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/025_security_incidents_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_regulator_correspondence/073_regulator_correspondence_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's severity from /workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/025_security_incidents_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_regulator_correspondence/073_regulator_correspondence_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's primary_source from /workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/025_security_incidents_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_regulator_correspondence/073_regulator_correspondence_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/025_security_incidents_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_regulator_correspondence/073_regulator_correspondence_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-09 using the exact controlled facts ['2025-03-25', 'CB-PR-3006-I301', '2025-05-04', 'CB-PR-3006-R738'].", "id": "findings.F-09.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-09's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-09.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-20', 'Sofia Bennett'] for F-09.", "id": "findings.F-09.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-10 exception for identity-verification inconsistency.", "id": "findings.F-10.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's id from /workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/028_security_incidents_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_regulator_correspondence/076_regulator_correspondence_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's issue from /workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/028_security_incidents_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_regulator_correspondence/076_regulator_correspondence_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's severity from /workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/028_security_incidents_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_regulator_correspondence/076_regulator_correspondence_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's primary_source from /workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/028_security_incidents_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_regulator_correspondence/076_regulator_correspondence_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/028_security_incidents_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_regulator_correspondence/076_regulator_correspondence_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-10 using the exact controlled facts ['$1,361,019.00', '$1,378,538.00'].", "id": "findings.F-10.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-10's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-10.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-20', 'Adrian Mensah'] for F-10.", "id": "findings.F-10.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-11 exception for incident-notification clock.", "id": "findings.F-11.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's id from /workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/031_security_incidents_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_regulator_correspondence/079_regulator_correspondence_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's issue from /workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/031_security_incidents_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_regulator_correspondence/079_regulator_correspondence_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's severity from /workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/031_security_incidents_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_regulator_correspondence/079_regulator_correspondence_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's primary_source from /workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/031_security_incidents_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_regulator_correspondence/079_regulator_correspondence_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/031_security_incidents_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_regulator_correspondence/079_regulator_correspondence_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-11 using the exact controlled facts ['Samuel Kim', 'Micah Sullivan'].", "id": "findings.F-11.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-11's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-11.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-20', 'Willa Novak'] for F-11.", "id": "findings.F-11.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-12 exception for risk-assessment omission.", "id": "findings.F-12.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's id from /workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/034_consumer_requests_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_risk_assessments/082_risk_assessments_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's issue from /workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/034_consumer_requests_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_risk_assessments/082_risk_assessments_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's severity from /workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/034_consumer_requests_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_risk_assessments/082_risk_assessments_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's primary_source from /workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/034_consumer_requests_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_risk_assessments/082_risk_assessments_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/034_consumer_requests_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_risk_assessments/082_risk_assessments_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-12 using the exact controlled facts ['closed without exception', 'CB-PR-3006-L857', 'open and escalated', 'CB-PR-3006-U642'].", "id": "findings.F-12.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-12's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-12.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-20', 'Theo Laurent'] for F-12.", "id": "findings.F-12.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-13 exception for sensitive-data classification.", "id": "findings.F-13.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's id from /workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/037_consumer_requests_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_risk_assessments/085_risk_assessments_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's issue from /workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/037_consumer_requests_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_risk_assessments/085_risk_assessments_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's severity from /workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/037_consumer_requests_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_risk_assessments/085_risk_assessments_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's primary_source from /workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/037_consumer_requests_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_risk_assessments/085_risk_assessments_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/037_consumer_requests_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_risk_assessments/085_risk_assessments_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-13 using the exact controlled facts ['Illinois Department of Financial and Professional Regulation', 'Illinois'].", "id": "findings.F-13.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-13's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-13.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-20', 'Amara Patel'] for F-13.", "id": "findings.F-13.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-14 exception for minor-consent issue.", "id": "findings.F-14.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's id from /workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/040_consumer_requests_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_risk_assessments/088_risk_assessments_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's issue from /workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/040_consumer_requests_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_risk_assessments/088_risk_assessments_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's severity from /workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/040_consumer_requests_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_risk_assessments/088_risk_assessments_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's primary_source from /workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/040_consumer_requests_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_risk_assessments/088_risk_assessments_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/040_consumer_requests_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_risk_assessments/088_risk_assessments_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-14 using the exact controlled facts ['10%', '16%'].", "id": "findings.F-14.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-14's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-14.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-20', 'Henry Cho'] for F-14.", "id": "findings.F-14.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-15 exception for training completion gap.", "id": "findings.F-15.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's id from /workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/043_notices_consents_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_remediation/091_remediation_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's issue from /workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/043_notices_consents_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_remediation/091_remediation_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's severity from /workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/043_notices_consents_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_remediation/091_remediation_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's primary_source from /workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/043_notices_consents_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_remediation/091_remediation_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/043_notices_consents_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_remediation/091_remediation_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-15 using the exact controlled facts ['notices-fable_financial_technologies@example.test', 'archive-northbridge_model_services@example.test'].", "id": "findings.F-15.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-15's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-15.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-20', 'Nadine Flores'] for F-15.", "id": "findings.F-15.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-16 exception for regulator commitment overdue.", "id": "findings.F-16.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's id from /workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/046_notices_consents_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_remediation/094_remediation_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's issue from /workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/046_notices_consents_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_remediation/094_remediation_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's severity from /workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/046_notices_consents_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_remediation/094_remediation_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's primary_source from /workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/046_notices_consents_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_remediation/094_remediation_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/046_notices_consents_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_remediation/094_remediation_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-16 using the exact controlled facts ['141 records', '2026-01-11', '47 records', '2026-01-30'].", "id": "findings.F-16.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-16's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-16.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-20', 'Micah Sullivan'] for F-16.", "id": "findings.F-16.action_anchors"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Executive assessment' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Executive assessment"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Method and record coverage' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Method and record coverage"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Findings' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Findings"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Recommended next actions' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Recommended next actions"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Assumptions and limitations' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Assumptions and limitations"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-01 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-01"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-02 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-02"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-03 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-03"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-04 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-04"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-05 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-05"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-06 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-06"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-07 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-07"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-08 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-08"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-09 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-09"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-10 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-10"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-11 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-11"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-12 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-12"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-13 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-13"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-14 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-14"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-15 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-15"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-16 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-16"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Do not claim the production has no issues or that every record is consistent.", "id": "memo.forbidden_claims_absent"}], "decision_options": [{"id": "cross-source-reconciliation", "label": "Reconcile controlling and corroborating records", "reason": "The CB-PR-3006 production contains independently maintained records; a defensible answer must preserve each supported conflict and its cure owner.", "selected": true}, {"id": "latest-record-controls", "label": "Treat the latest record as controlling", "reason": "Timestamp recency does not establish legal priority, execution, or approval authority.", "selected": false}, {"id": "primary-records-only", "label": "Report primary records without reconciliation", "reason": "Primary records alone conceal the operational conflicts that create the actionable exceptions.", "selected": false}], "gates": ["all_evidence_read_in_full", "chain_of_custody_metadata_checked", "findings_criteria_complete", "memo_criteria_complete", "deliverables_written_through_mcp"], "metadata_checks": 8, "metric": "weighted_criteria_score", "minimum_tool_calls": 46, "required_deliverables": ["findings.json", "advice.md"], "required_document_reads": 33, "type": "deterministic", "weights": {"findings": 0.55, "memo": 0.2, "procedure": 0.25}}, "task_id": "cb100-066-fable-fintech", "task_name": "Fable automated-decision privacy review", "world_id": "counselbench-filesystem-mcp-v2"}
-{"context_files": ["task_files/cb100-067-grove-hospitality/01_data_inventory/001_data_inventory_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-067-grove-hospitality/01_data_inventory/002_data_inventory_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-067-grove-hospitality/01_data_inventory/003_data_inventory_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-067-grove-hospitality/01_data_inventory/004_data_inventory_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-067-grove-hospitality/01_data_inventory/005_data_inventory_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-067-grove-hospitality/01_data_inventory/006_data_inventory_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-067-grove-hospitality/01_data_inventory/007_data_inventory_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-067-grove-hospitality/01_data_inventory/008_data_inventory_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-067-grove-hospitality/02_processing_records/009_processing_records_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-067-grove-hospitality/02_processing_records/010_processing_records_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-067-grove-hospitality/02_processing_records/011_processing_records_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-067-grove-hospitality/02_processing_records/012_processing_records_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-067-grove-hospitality/02_processing_records/013_processing_records_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-067-grove-hospitality/02_processing_records/014_processing_records_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-067-grove-hospitality/02_processing_records/015_processing_records_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-067-grove-hospitality/02_processing_records/016_processing_records_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-067-grove-hospitality/03_vendor_reviews/017_vendor_reviews_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-067-grove-hospitality/03_vendor_reviews/018_vendor_reviews_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-067-grove-hospitality/03_vendor_reviews/019_vendor_reviews_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-067-grove-hospitality/03_vendor_reviews/020_vendor_reviews_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-067-grove-hospitality/03_vendor_reviews/021_vendor_reviews_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-067-grove-hospitality/03_vendor_reviews/022_vendor_reviews_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-067-grove-hospitality/03_vendor_reviews/023_vendor_reviews_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-067-grove-hospitality/03_vendor_reviews/024_vendor_reviews_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-067-grove-hospitality/04_security_incidents/025_security_incidents_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-067-grove-hospitality/04_security_incidents/026_security_incidents_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-067-grove-hospitality/04_security_incidents/027_security_incidents_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-067-grove-hospitality/04_security_incidents/028_security_incidents_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-067-grove-hospitality/04_security_incidents/029_security_incidents_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-067-grove-hospitality/04_security_incidents/030_security_incidents_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-067-grove-hospitality/04_security_incidents/031_security_incidents_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-067-grove-hospitality/04_security_incidents/032_security_incidents_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-067-grove-hospitality/05_consumer_requests/033_consumer_requests_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-067-grove-hospitality/05_consumer_requests/034_consumer_requests_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-067-grove-hospitality/05_consumer_requests/035_consumer_requests_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-067-grove-hospitality/05_consumer_requests/036_consumer_requests_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-067-grove-hospitality/05_consumer_requests/037_consumer_requests_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-067-grove-hospitality/05_consumer_requests/038_consumer_requests_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-067-grove-hospitality/05_consumer_requests/039_consumer_requests_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-067-grove-hospitality/05_consumer_requests/040_consumer_requests_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-067-grove-hospitality/06_notices_consents/041_notices_consents_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-067-grove-hospitality/06_notices_consents/042_notices_consents_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-067-grove-hospitality/06_notices_consents/043_notices_consents_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-067-grove-hospitality/06_notices_consents/044_notices_consents_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-067-grove-hospitality/06_notices_consents/045_notices_consents_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-067-grove-hospitality/06_notices_consents/046_notices_consents_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-067-grove-hospitality/06_notices_consents/047_notices_consents_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-067-grove-hospitality/06_notices_consents/048_notices_consents_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-067-grove-hospitality/07_transfer_mechanisms/049_transfer_mechanisms_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-067-grove-hospitality/07_transfer_mechanisms/050_transfer_mechanisms_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-067-grove-hospitality/07_transfer_mechanisms/051_transfer_mechanisms_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-067-grove-hospitality/07_transfer_mechanisms/052_transfer_mechanisms_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-067-grove-hospitality/07_transfer_mechanisms/053_transfer_mechanisms_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-067-grove-hospitality/07_transfer_mechanisms/054_transfer_mechanisms_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-067-grove-hospitality/07_transfer_mechanisms/055_transfer_mechanisms_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-067-grove-hospitality/07_transfer_mechanisms/056_transfer_mechanisms_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-067-grove-hospitality/08_retention_deletion/057_retention_deletion_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-067-grove-hospitality/08_retention_deletion/058_retention_deletion_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-067-grove-hospitality/08_retention_deletion/059_retention_deletion_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-067-grove-hospitality/08_retention_deletion/060_retention_deletion_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-067-grove-hospitality/08_retention_deletion/061_retention_deletion_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-067-grove-hospitality/08_retention_deletion/062_retention_deletion_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-067-grove-hospitality/08_retention_deletion/063_retention_deletion_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-067-grove-hospitality/08_retention_deletion/064_retention_deletion_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-067-grove-hospitality/09_training/065_training_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-067-grove-hospitality/09_training/066_training_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-067-grove-hospitality/09_training/067_training_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-067-grove-hospitality/09_training/068_training_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-067-grove-hospitality/09_training/069_training_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-067-grove-hospitality/09_training/070_training_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-067-grove-hospitality/09_training/071_training_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-067-grove-hospitality/09_training/072_training_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-067-grove-hospitality/10_regulator_correspondence/073_regulator_correspondence_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-067-grove-hospitality/10_regulator_correspondence/074_regulator_correspondence_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-067-grove-hospitality/10_regulator_correspondence/075_regulator_correspondence_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-067-grove-hospitality/10_regulator_correspondence/076_regulator_correspondence_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-067-grove-hospitality/10_regulator_correspondence/077_regulator_correspondence_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-067-grove-hospitality/10_regulator_correspondence/078_regulator_correspondence_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-067-grove-hospitality/10_regulator_correspondence/079_regulator_correspondence_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-067-grove-hospitality/10_regulator_correspondence/080_regulator_correspondence_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-067-grove-hospitality/11_risk_assessments/081_risk_assessments_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-067-grove-hospitality/11_risk_assessments/082_risk_assessments_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-067-grove-hospitality/11_risk_assessments/083_risk_assessments_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-067-grove-hospitality/11_risk_assessments/084_risk_assessments_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-067-grove-hospitality/11_risk_assessments/085_risk_assessments_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-067-grove-hospitality/11_risk_assessments/086_risk_assessments_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-067-grove-hospitality/11_risk_assessments/087_risk_assessments_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-067-grove-hospitality/11_risk_assessments/088_risk_assessments_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-067-grove-hospitality/12_remediation/089_remediation_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-067-grove-hospitality/12_remediation/090_remediation_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-067-grove-hospitality/12_remediation/091_remediation_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-067-grove-hospitality/12_remediation/092_remediation_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-067-grove-hospitality/12_remediation/093_remediation_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-067-grove-hospitality/12_remediation/094_remediation_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-067-grove-hospitality/12_remediation/095_remediation_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-067-grove-hospitality/12_remediation/096_remediation_status_report.md"], "gold_output": {"advice_markdown": "# Counsel advice — Grove guest-data transfer audit\n\n## Executive assessment\n\nFor Grove Hospitality Group matter CB-PR-3007, the review identified 16 source-supported exceptions requiring action before 2026-09-23. The assessment concerns GlobalStay Reservation Services and the supplied record for Florida.\n\n## Method and record coverage\n\nThe review inventoried all 96 production files, read the 33 controlling, corroborating, and control records, searched the email exports, and checked metadata for the designated chain-of-custody sample. Conclusions are limited to the synthetic production supplied for this benchmark matter.\n\n## Findings\n\n### F-01 — processing-purpose gap (critical)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for processing-purpose gap: one source states the operative date is 2025-02-22 under control reference CB-PR-3007-A930, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2025-04-05 under response reference CB-PR-3007-J994.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/001_data_inventory_control_register.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/07_transfer_mechanisms/049_transfer_mechanisms_control_register.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-23, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Elliot Mercer.\n\n### F-02 — notice-practice mismatch (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for notice-practice mismatch: one source states the controlling amount is $5,486,776.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $5,500,052.00.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/004_data_inventory_ledger_export.csv`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/07_transfer_mechanisms/052_transfer_mechanisms_ledger_export.csv`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-23, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Talia Brooks.\n\n### F-03 — consent-record deficiency (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for consent-record deficiency: one source states approval is attributed to Maya Ellison as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Elliot Mercer and contains no entry for Maya Ellison.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/007_data_inventory_officer_certificate.html`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/07_transfer_mechanisms/055_transfer_mechanisms_officer_certificate.html`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-23, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Jonas Feld.\n\n### F-04 — processor-contract omission (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for processor-contract omission: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-PR-3007-D692, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-PR-3007-M491.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/02_processing_records/010_processing_records_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/08_retention_deletion/058_retention_deletion_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-23, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Mei Whitaker.\n\n### F-05 — subprocessor inventory mismatch (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for subprocessor inventory mismatch: one source states the applicable location is Federal Trade Commission, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to Florida operations outside Federal Trade Commission.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/02_processing_records/013_processing_records_review_memorandum.json`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/08_retention_deletion/061_retention_deletion_review_memorandum.json`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-23, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Caleb Hassan.\n\n### F-06 — cross-border transfer gap (low)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for cross-border transfer gap: one source states the threshold is 14% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 18% and produced a different exception result.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/02_processing_records/016_processing_records_status_report.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/08_retention_deletion/064_retention_deletion_status_report.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-23, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Leona Park.\n\n### F-07 — retention schedule conflict (critical)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for retention schedule conflict: one source states formal notice must use notices-grove_hospitality_group@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-globalstay_reservation_services@example.test.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/019_vendor_reviews_correspondence.eml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/09_training/067_training_correspondence.eml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-23, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Isaac Romero.\n\n### F-08 — deletion-job failure (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for deletion-job failure: one source states the governed population contains 183 records through 2025-05-18, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 75 records through 2025-07-04.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/022_vendor_reviews_formal_notice.xml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/09_training/070_training_formal_notice.xml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-23, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Sofia Bennett.\n\n### F-09 — access-request deadline (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for access-request deadline: one source states the operative date is 2025-08-30 under control reference CB-PR-3007-I159, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2025-09-12 under response reference CB-PR-3007-R658.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/025_security_incidents_control_register.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/10_regulator_correspondence/073_regulator_correspondence_control_register.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-23, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Adrian Mensah.\n\n### F-10 — identity-verification inconsistency (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for identity-verification inconsistency: one source states the controlling amount is $3,172,627.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $3,291,754.00.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/028_security_incidents_ledger_export.csv`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/10_regulator_correspondence/076_regulator_correspondence_ledger_export.csv`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-23, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Willa Novak.\n\n### F-11 — incident-notification clock (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for incident-notification clock: one source states approval is attributed to Maya Ellison as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Owen Delgado and contains no entry for Maya Ellison.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/031_security_incidents_officer_certificate.html`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/10_regulator_correspondence/079_regulator_correspondence_officer_certificate.html`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-23, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Theo Laurent.\n\n### F-12 — risk-assessment omission (low)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for risk-assessment omission: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-PR-3007-L878, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-PR-3007-U575.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/034_consumer_requests_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/11_risk_assessments/082_risk_assessments_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-23, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Amara Patel.\n\n### F-13 — sensitive-data classification (critical)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for sensitive-data classification: one source states the applicable location is Federal Trade Commission, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to Florida operations outside Federal Trade Commission.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/037_consumer_requests_review_memorandum.json`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/11_risk_assessments/085_risk_assessments_review_memorandum.json`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-23, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Henry Cho.\n\n### F-14 — minor-consent issue (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for minor-consent issue: one source states the threshold is 10% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 14% and produced a different exception result.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/040_consumer_requests_status_report.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/11_risk_assessments/088_risk_assessments_status_report.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-23, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Nadine Flores.\n\n### F-15 — training completion gap (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for training completion gap: one source states formal notice must use notices-grove_hospitality_group@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-globalstay_reservation_services@example.test.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/043_notices_consents_correspondence.eml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/12_remediation/091_remediation_correspondence.eml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-23, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Micah Sullivan.\n\n### F-16 — regulator commitment overdue (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for regulator commitment overdue: one source states the governed population contains 134 records through 2025-03-30, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 46 records through 2025-04-17.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/046_notices_consents_formal_notice.xml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/12_remediation/094_remediation_formal_notice.xml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-23, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Farah Ibrahim.\n\n## Recommended next actions\n\nSequence the critical and high findings first, assign the named owners, preserve the cited records, and document any resolution in the controlling matter register before the stated deadline.\n\n## Assumptions and limitations\n\nThis analysis is confined to task cb100-067-grove-hospitality and the supplied synthetic evidence. It does not rely on external facts, does not resolve disputed law, and is not legal advice for a real person or entity.\n", "findings": {"as_of": "2026-09-23", "findings": [{"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/07_transfer_mechanisms/049_transfer_mechanisms_control_register.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for processing-purpose gap: one source states the operative date is 2025-02-22 under control reference CB-PR-3007-A930, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2025-04-05 under response reference CB-PR-3007-J994.", "id": "F-01", "issue": "processing-purpose gap", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/001_data_inventory_control_register.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-23, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Elliot Mercer.", "severity": "critical"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/07_transfer_mechanisms/052_transfer_mechanisms_ledger_export.csv", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for notice-practice mismatch: one source states the controlling amount is $5,486,776.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $5,500,052.00.", "id": "F-02", "issue": "notice-practice mismatch", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/004_data_inventory_ledger_export.csv", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-23, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Talia Brooks.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/07_transfer_mechanisms/055_transfer_mechanisms_officer_certificate.html", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for consent-record deficiency: one source states approval is attributed to Maya Ellison as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Elliot Mercer and contains no entry for Maya Ellison.", "id": "F-03", "issue": "consent-record deficiency", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/007_data_inventory_officer_certificate.html", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-23, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Jonas Feld.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/08_retention_deletion/058_retention_deletion_executed_instrument.txt", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for processor-contract omission: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-PR-3007-D692, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-PR-3007-M491.", "id": "F-04", "issue": "processor-contract omission", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/02_processing_records/010_processing_records_executed_instrument.txt", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-23, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Mei Whitaker.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/08_retention_deletion/061_retention_deletion_review_memorandum.json", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for subprocessor inventory mismatch: one source states the applicable location is Federal Trade Commission, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to Florida operations outside Federal Trade Commission.", "id": "F-05", "issue": "subprocessor inventory mismatch", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/02_processing_records/013_processing_records_review_memorandum.json", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-23, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Caleb Hassan.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/08_retention_deletion/064_retention_deletion_status_report.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for cross-border transfer gap: one source states the threshold is 14% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 18% and produced a different exception result.", "id": "F-06", "issue": "cross-border transfer gap", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/02_processing_records/016_processing_records_status_report.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-23, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Leona Park.", "severity": "low"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/09_training/067_training_correspondence.eml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for retention schedule conflict: one source states formal notice must use notices-grove_hospitality_group@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-globalstay_reservation_services@example.test.", "id": "F-07", "issue": "retention schedule conflict", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/019_vendor_reviews_correspondence.eml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-23, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Isaac Romero.", "severity": "critical"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/09_training/070_training_formal_notice.xml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for deletion-job failure: one source states the governed population contains 183 records through 2025-05-18, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 75 records through 2025-07-04.", "id": "F-08", "issue": "deletion-job failure", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/022_vendor_reviews_formal_notice.xml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-23, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Sofia Bennett.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/10_regulator_correspondence/073_regulator_correspondence_control_register.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for access-request deadline: one source states the operative date is 2025-08-30 under control reference CB-PR-3007-I159, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2025-09-12 under response reference CB-PR-3007-R658.", "id": "F-09", "issue": "access-request deadline", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/025_security_incidents_control_register.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-23, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Adrian Mensah.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/10_regulator_correspondence/076_regulator_correspondence_ledger_export.csv", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for identity-verification inconsistency: one source states the controlling amount is $3,172,627.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $3,291,754.00.", "id": "F-10", "issue": "identity-verification inconsistency", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/028_security_incidents_ledger_export.csv", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-23, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Willa Novak.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/10_regulator_correspondence/079_regulator_correspondence_officer_certificate.html", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for incident-notification clock: one source states approval is attributed to Maya Ellison as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Owen Delgado and contains no entry for Maya Ellison.", "id": "F-11", "issue": "incident-notification clock", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/031_security_incidents_officer_certificate.html", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-23, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Theo Laurent.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/11_risk_assessments/082_risk_assessments_executed_instrument.txt", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for risk-assessment omission: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-PR-3007-L878, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-PR-3007-U575.", "id": "F-12", "issue": "risk-assessment omission", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/034_consumer_requests_executed_instrument.txt", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-23, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Amara Patel.", "severity": "low"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/11_risk_assessments/085_risk_assessments_review_memorandum.json", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for sensitive-data classification: one source states the applicable location is Federal Trade Commission, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to Florida operations outside Federal Trade Commission.", "id": "F-13", "issue": "sensitive-data classification", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/037_consumer_requests_review_memorandum.json", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-23, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Henry Cho.", "severity": "critical"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/11_risk_assessments/088_risk_assessments_status_report.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for minor-consent issue: one source states the threshold is 10% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 14% and produced a different exception result.", "id": "F-14", "issue": "minor-consent issue", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/040_consumer_requests_status_report.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-23, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Nadine Flores.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/091_remediation_correspondence.eml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for training completion gap: one source states formal notice must use notices-grove_hospitality_group@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-globalstay_reservation_services@example.test.", "id": "F-15", "issue": "training completion gap", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/043_notices_consents_correspondence.eml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-23, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Micah Sullivan.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/094_remediation_formal_notice.xml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for regulator commitment overdue: one source states the governed population contains 134 records through 2025-03-30, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 46 records through 2025-04-17.", "id": "F-16", "issue": "regulator commitment overdue", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/046_notices_consents_formal_notice.xml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-23, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Farah Ibrahim.", "severity": "medium"}], "matter_number": "CB-PR-3007", "prepared_for": "Grove Hospitality Group", "schema_version": "1.0", "task_id": "cb100-067-grove-hospitality"}}, "metadata": {"benchmark": "CounselBench-100", "code_license": "Apache-2.0", "data_license": "CC-BY-4.0", "deadline": "2026-09-23", "document_count": 96, "jurisdiction": "Florida", "matter_number": "CB-PR-3007", "mcp_commit": "9a96ea6e5913736f92b88345bf51caeaaa8e719f", "mcp_package": "@modelcontextprotocol/server-filesystem@2026.7.10", "practice_area": "privacy-regulatory", "reference_tool_calls": 46, "required_evidence_reads": 33, "synthetic": true, "venue": "Federal Trade Commission", "version": "2.0.0"}, "prompt": "You are privacy and regulatory counsel for Grove Hospitality Group. A counterparty challenged the client's internal summary, making cross-document reconciliation and precise citations essential. Reservation data crosses regions through undocumented subprocessors and a failed retention job identified during a regulator response. Decision due 2026-09-23. Florida law governs; Federal Trade Commission is the forum. Flag cross-folder dependencies that would be invisible in a single-document review. Work out the defensible position from the matter production and leave an audit-ready exception tracker and concise advice for the supervising lawyer. Keep confirmed conflicts separate from open questions, cite the records that actually control each conclusion, and do not fill gaps with outside facts.", "rubric": {"criteria": [{"category": "procedure", "description": "Complete at least 46 successful, argument-specific evidence and output calls.", "id": "procedure.minimum_successful_tool_calls"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Find and read the 33 controlling, corroborating, and work-product-control records in full.", "id": "procedure.all_evidence_read_in_full"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Inspect file metadata for the eight designated critical primary records before relying on them.", "id": "procedure.chain_of_custody_metadata_checked"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Confirm the sandbox's allowed document and output roots.", "id": "procedure.allowed_directories_checked"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Inventory all 96 records so the relevant sources are discovered among the context records.", "id": "procedure.recursive_inventory_completed"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Search the production for email evidence that may corroborate or contradict formal records.", "id": "procedure.targeted_search_completed"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Leave only findings.json and advice.md in the output workspace.", "id": "procedure.exact_deliverable_set"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Create both final work products through the sandbox MCP surface.", "id": "procedure.deliverables_written_through_mcp"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Produce findings.json as a valid JSON object.", "id": "findings.findings_is_object"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Report exactly 16 confirmed exceptions.", "id": "findings.findings_exact_count"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Use each stable finding ID exactly once.", "id": "findings.finding_ids_unique"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set schema_version to the released matter value '1.0'.", "id": "findings.top_level_schema_version"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set task_id to the released matter value 'cb100-067-grove-hospitality'.", "id": "findings.top_level_task_id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set matter_number to the released matter value 'CB-PR-3007'.", "id": "findings.top_level_matter_number"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set prepared_for to the released matter value 'Grove Hospitality Group'.", "id": "findings.top_level_prepared_for"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set as_of to the released matter value '2026-09-23'.", "id": "findings.top_level_as_of"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-01 exception for processing-purpose gap.", "id": "findings.F-01.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's id from /workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/001_data_inventory_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_transfer_mechanisms/049_transfer_mechanisms_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's issue from /workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/001_data_inventory_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_transfer_mechanisms/049_transfer_mechanisms_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's severity from /workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/001_data_inventory_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_transfer_mechanisms/049_transfer_mechanisms_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's primary_source from /workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/001_data_inventory_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_transfer_mechanisms/049_transfer_mechanisms_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/001_data_inventory_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_transfer_mechanisms/049_transfer_mechanisms_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-01 using the exact controlled facts ['2025-02-22', 'CB-PR-3007-A930', '2025-04-05', 'CB-PR-3007-J994'].", "id": "findings.F-01.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-01's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-01.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-23', 'Elliot Mercer'] for F-01.", "id": "findings.F-01.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-02 exception for notice-practice mismatch.", "id": "findings.F-02.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's id from /workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/004_data_inventory_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_transfer_mechanisms/052_transfer_mechanisms_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's issue from /workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/004_data_inventory_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_transfer_mechanisms/052_transfer_mechanisms_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's severity from /workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/004_data_inventory_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_transfer_mechanisms/052_transfer_mechanisms_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's primary_source from /workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/004_data_inventory_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_transfer_mechanisms/052_transfer_mechanisms_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/004_data_inventory_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_transfer_mechanisms/052_transfer_mechanisms_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-02 using the exact controlled facts ['$5,486,776.00', '$5,500,052.00'].", "id": "findings.F-02.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-02's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-02.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-23', 'Talia Brooks'] for F-02.", "id": "findings.F-02.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-03 exception for consent-record deficiency.", "id": "findings.F-03.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's id from /workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/007_data_inventory_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_transfer_mechanisms/055_transfer_mechanisms_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's issue from /workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/007_data_inventory_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_transfer_mechanisms/055_transfer_mechanisms_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's severity from /workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/007_data_inventory_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_transfer_mechanisms/055_transfer_mechanisms_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's primary_source from /workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/007_data_inventory_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_transfer_mechanisms/055_transfer_mechanisms_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/007_data_inventory_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_transfer_mechanisms/055_transfer_mechanisms_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-03 using the exact controlled facts ['Maya Ellison', 'Elliot Mercer'].", "id": "findings.F-03.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-03's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-03.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-23', 'Jonas Feld'] for F-03.", "id": "findings.F-03.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-04 exception for processor-contract omission.", "id": "findings.F-04.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's id from /workspace/documents/02_processing_records/010_processing_records_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_retention_deletion/058_retention_deletion_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's issue from /workspace/documents/02_processing_records/010_processing_records_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_retention_deletion/058_retention_deletion_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's severity from /workspace/documents/02_processing_records/010_processing_records_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_retention_deletion/058_retention_deletion_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's primary_source from /workspace/documents/02_processing_records/010_processing_records_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_retention_deletion/058_retention_deletion_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/02_processing_records/010_processing_records_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_retention_deletion/058_retention_deletion_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-04 using the exact controlled facts ['closed without exception', 'CB-PR-3007-D692', 'open and escalated', 'CB-PR-3007-M491'].", "id": "findings.F-04.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-04's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-04.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-23', 'Mei Whitaker'] for F-04.", "id": "findings.F-04.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-05 exception for subprocessor inventory mismatch.", "id": "findings.F-05.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's id from /workspace/documents/02_processing_records/013_processing_records_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_retention_deletion/061_retention_deletion_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's issue from /workspace/documents/02_processing_records/013_processing_records_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_retention_deletion/061_retention_deletion_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's severity from /workspace/documents/02_processing_records/013_processing_records_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_retention_deletion/061_retention_deletion_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's primary_source from /workspace/documents/02_processing_records/013_processing_records_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_retention_deletion/061_retention_deletion_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/02_processing_records/013_processing_records_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_retention_deletion/061_retention_deletion_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-05 using the exact controlled facts ['Federal Trade Commission', 'Florida'].", "id": "findings.F-05.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-05's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-05.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-23', 'Caleb Hassan'] for F-05.", "id": "findings.F-05.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-06 exception for cross-border transfer gap.", "id": "findings.F-06.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's id from /workspace/documents/02_processing_records/016_processing_records_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_retention_deletion/064_retention_deletion_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's issue from /workspace/documents/02_processing_records/016_processing_records_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_retention_deletion/064_retention_deletion_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's severity from /workspace/documents/02_processing_records/016_processing_records_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_retention_deletion/064_retention_deletion_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's primary_source from /workspace/documents/02_processing_records/016_processing_records_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_retention_deletion/064_retention_deletion_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/02_processing_records/016_processing_records_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_retention_deletion/064_retention_deletion_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-06 using the exact controlled facts ['14%', '18%'].", "id": "findings.F-06.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-06's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-06.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-23', 'Leona Park'] for F-06.", "id": "findings.F-06.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-07 exception for retention schedule conflict.", "id": "findings.F-07.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's id from /workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/019_vendor_reviews_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_training/067_training_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's issue from /workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/019_vendor_reviews_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_training/067_training_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's severity from /workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/019_vendor_reviews_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_training/067_training_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's primary_source from /workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/019_vendor_reviews_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_training/067_training_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/019_vendor_reviews_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_training/067_training_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-07 using the exact controlled facts ['notices-grove_hospitality_group@example.test', 'archive-globalstay_reservation_services@example.test'].", "id": "findings.F-07.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-07's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-07.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-23', 'Isaac Romero'] for F-07.", "id": "findings.F-07.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-08 exception for deletion-job failure.", "id": "findings.F-08.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's id from /workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/022_vendor_reviews_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_training/070_training_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's issue from /workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/022_vendor_reviews_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_training/070_training_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's severity from /workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/022_vendor_reviews_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_training/070_training_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's primary_source from /workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/022_vendor_reviews_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_training/070_training_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/022_vendor_reviews_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_training/070_training_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-08 using the exact controlled facts ['183 records', '2025-05-18', '75 records', '2025-07-04'].", "id": "findings.F-08.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-08's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-08.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-23', 'Sofia Bennett'] for F-08.", "id": "findings.F-08.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-09 exception for access-request deadline.", "id": "findings.F-09.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's id from /workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/025_security_incidents_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_regulator_correspondence/073_regulator_correspondence_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's issue from /workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/025_security_incidents_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_regulator_correspondence/073_regulator_correspondence_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's severity from /workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/025_security_incidents_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_regulator_correspondence/073_regulator_correspondence_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's primary_source from /workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/025_security_incidents_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_regulator_correspondence/073_regulator_correspondence_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/025_security_incidents_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_regulator_correspondence/073_regulator_correspondence_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-09 using the exact controlled facts ['2025-08-30', 'CB-PR-3007-I159', '2025-09-12', 'CB-PR-3007-R658'].", "id": "findings.F-09.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-09's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-09.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-23', 'Adrian Mensah'] for F-09.", "id": "findings.F-09.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-10 exception for identity-verification inconsistency.", "id": "findings.F-10.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's id from /workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/028_security_incidents_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_regulator_correspondence/076_regulator_correspondence_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's issue from /workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/028_security_incidents_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_regulator_correspondence/076_regulator_correspondence_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's severity from /workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/028_security_incidents_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_regulator_correspondence/076_regulator_correspondence_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's primary_source from /workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/028_security_incidents_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_regulator_correspondence/076_regulator_correspondence_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/028_security_incidents_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_regulator_correspondence/076_regulator_correspondence_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-10 using the exact controlled facts ['$3,172,627.00', '$3,291,754.00'].", "id": "findings.F-10.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-10's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-10.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-23', 'Willa Novak'] for F-10.", "id": "findings.F-10.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-11 exception for incident-notification clock.", "id": "findings.F-11.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's id from /workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/031_security_incidents_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_regulator_correspondence/079_regulator_correspondence_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's issue from /workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/031_security_incidents_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_regulator_correspondence/079_regulator_correspondence_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's severity from /workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/031_security_incidents_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_regulator_correspondence/079_regulator_correspondence_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's primary_source from /workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/031_security_incidents_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_regulator_correspondence/079_regulator_correspondence_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/031_security_incidents_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_regulator_correspondence/079_regulator_correspondence_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-11 using the exact controlled facts ['Maya Ellison', 'Owen Delgado'].", "id": "findings.F-11.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-11's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-11.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-23', 'Theo Laurent'] for F-11.", "id": "findings.F-11.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-12 exception for risk-assessment omission.", "id": "findings.F-12.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's id from /workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/034_consumer_requests_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_risk_assessments/082_risk_assessments_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's issue from /workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/034_consumer_requests_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_risk_assessments/082_risk_assessments_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's severity from /workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/034_consumer_requests_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_risk_assessments/082_risk_assessments_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's primary_source from /workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/034_consumer_requests_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_risk_assessments/082_risk_assessments_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/034_consumer_requests_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_risk_assessments/082_risk_assessments_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-12 using the exact controlled facts ['closed without exception', 'CB-PR-3007-L878', 'open and escalated', 'CB-PR-3007-U575'].", "id": "findings.F-12.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-12's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-12.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-23', 'Amara Patel'] for F-12.", "id": "findings.F-12.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-13 exception for sensitive-data classification.", "id": "findings.F-13.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's id from /workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/037_consumer_requests_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_risk_assessments/085_risk_assessments_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's issue from /workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/037_consumer_requests_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_risk_assessments/085_risk_assessments_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's severity from /workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/037_consumer_requests_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_risk_assessments/085_risk_assessments_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's primary_source from /workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/037_consumer_requests_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_risk_assessments/085_risk_assessments_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/037_consumer_requests_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_risk_assessments/085_risk_assessments_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-13 using the exact controlled facts ['Federal Trade Commission', 'Florida'].", "id": "findings.F-13.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-13's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-13.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-23', 'Henry Cho'] for F-13.", "id": "findings.F-13.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-14 exception for minor-consent issue.", "id": "findings.F-14.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's id from /workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/040_consumer_requests_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_risk_assessments/088_risk_assessments_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's issue from /workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/040_consumer_requests_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_risk_assessments/088_risk_assessments_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's severity from /workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/040_consumer_requests_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_risk_assessments/088_risk_assessments_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's primary_source from /workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/040_consumer_requests_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_risk_assessments/088_risk_assessments_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/040_consumer_requests_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_risk_assessments/088_risk_assessments_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-14 using the exact controlled facts ['10%', '14%'].", "id": "findings.F-14.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-14's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-14.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-23', 'Nadine Flores'] for F-14.", "id": "findings.F-14.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-15 exception for training completion gap.", "id": "findings.F-15.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's id from /workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/043_notices_consents_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_remediation/091_remediation_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's issue from /workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/043_notices_consents_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_remediation/091_remediation_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's severity from /workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/043_notices_consents_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_remediation/091_remediation_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's primary_source from /workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/043_notices_consents_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_remediation/091_remediation_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/043_notices_consents_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_remediation/091_remediation_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-15 using the exact controlled facts ['notices-grove_hospitality_group@example.test', 'archive-globalstay_reservation_services@example.test'].", "id": "findings.F-15.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-15's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-15.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-23', 'Micah Sullivan'] for F-15.", "id": "findings.F-15.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-16 exception for regulator commitment overdue.", "id": "findings.F-16.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's id from /workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/046_notices_consents_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_remediation/094_remediation_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's issue from /workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/046_notices_consents_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_remediation/094_remediation_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's severity from /workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/046_notices_consents_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_remediation/094_remediation_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's primary_source from /workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/046_notices_consents_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_remediation/094_remediation_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/046_notices_consents_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_remediation/094_remediation_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-16 using the exact controlled facts ['134 records', '2025-03-30', '46 records', '2025-04-17'].", "id": "findings.F-16.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-16's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-16.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-23', 'Farah Ibrahim'] for F-16.", "id": "findings.F-16.action_anchors"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Executive assessment' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Executive assessment"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Method and record coverage' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Method and record coverage"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Findings' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Findings"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Recommended next actions' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Recommended next actions"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Assumptions and limitations' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Assumptions and limitations"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-01 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-01"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-02 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-02"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-03 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-03"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-04 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-04"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-05 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-05"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-06 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-06"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-07 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-07"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-08 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-08"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-09 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-09"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-10 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-10"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-11 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-11"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-12 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-12"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-13 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-13"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-14 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-14"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-15 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-15"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-16 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-16"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Do not claim the production has no issues or that every record is consistent.", "id": "memo.forbidden_claims_absent"}], "decision_options": [{"id": "cross-source-reconciliation", "label": "Reconcile controlling and corroborating records", "reason": "The CB-PR-3007 production contains independently maintained records; a defensible answer must preserve each supported conflict and its cure owner.", "selected": true}, {"id": "latest-record-controls", "label": "Treat the latest record as controlling", "reason": "Timestamp recency does not establish legal priority, execution, or approval authority.", "selected": false}, {"id": "primary-records-only", "label": "Report primary records without reconciliation", "reason": "Primary records alone conceal the operational conflicts that create the actionable exceptions.", "selected": false}], "gates": ["all_evidence_read_in_full", "chain_of_custody_metadata_checked", "findings_criteria_complete", "memo_criteria_complete", "deliverables_written_through_mcp"], "metadata_checks": 8, "metric": "weighted_criteria_score", "minimum_tool_calls": 46, "required_deliverables": ["findings.json", "advice.md"], "required_document_reads": 33, "type": "deterministic", "weights": {"findings": 0.55, "memo": 0.2, "procedure": 0.25}}, "task_id": "cb100-067-grove-hospitality", "task_name": "Grove guest-data transfer audit", "world_id": "counselbench-filesystem-mcp-v2"}
-{"context_files": ["task_files/cb100-068-highline-wearables/01_data_inventory/001_data_inventory_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-068-highline-wearables/01_data_inventory/002_data_inventory_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-068-highline-wearables/01_data_inventory/003_data_inventory_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-068-highline-wearables/01_data_inventory/004_data_inventory_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-068-highline-wearables/01_data_inventory/005_data_inventory_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-068-highline-wearables/01_data_inventory/006_data_inventory_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-068-highline-wearables/01_data_inventory/007_data_inventory_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-068-highline-wearables/01_data_inventory/008_data_inventory_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-068-highline-wearables/02_processing_records/009_processing_records_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-068-highline-wearables/02_processing_records/010_processing_records_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-068-highline-wearables/02_processing_records/011_processing_records_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-068-highline-wearables/02_processing_records/012_processing_records_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-068-highline-wearables/02_processing_records/013_processing_records_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-068-highline-wearables/02_processing_records/014_processing_records_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-068-highline-wearables/02_processing_records/015_processing_records_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-068-highline-wearables/02_processing_records/016_processing_records_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-068-highline-wearables/03_vendor_reviews/017_vendor_reviews_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-068-highline-wearables/03_vendor_reviews/018_vendor_reviews_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-068-highline-wearables/03_vendor_reviews/019_vendor_reviews_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-068-highline-wearables/03_vendor_reviews/020_vendor_reviews_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-068-highline-wearables/03_vendor_reviews/021_vendor_reviews_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-068-highline-wearables/03_vendor_reviews/022_vendor_reviews_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-068-highline-wearables/03_vendor_reviews/023_vendor_reviews_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-068-highline-wearables/03_vendor_reviews/024_vendor_reviews_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-068-highline-wearables/04_security_incidents/025_security_incidents_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-068-highline-wearables/04_security_incidents/026_security_incidents_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-068-highline-wearables/04_security_incidents/027_security_incidents_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-068-highline-wearables/04_security_incidents/028_security_incidents_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-068-highline-wearables/04_security_incidents/029_security_incidents_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-068-highline-wearables/04_security_incidents/030_security_incidents_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-068-highline-wearables/04_security_incidents/031_security_incidents_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-068-highline-wearables/04_security_incidents/032_security_incidents_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-068-highline-wearables/05_consumer_requests/033_consumer_requests_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-068-highline-wearables/05_consumer_requests/034_consumer_requests_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-068-highline-wearables/05_consumer_requests/035_consumer_requests_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-068-highline-wearables/05_consumer_requests/036_consumer_requests_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-068-highline-wearables/05_consumer_requests/037_consumer_requests_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-068-highline-wearables/05_consumer_requests/038_consumer_requests_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-068-highline-wearables/05_consumer_requests/039_consumer_requests_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-068-highline-wearables/05_consumer_requests/040_consumer_requests_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-068-highline-wearables/06_notices_consents/041_notices_consents_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-068-highline-wearables/06_notices_consents/042_notices_consents_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-068-highline-wearables/06_notices_consents/043_notices_consents_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-068-highline-wearables/06_notices_consents/044_notices_consents_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-068-highline-wearables/06_notices_consents/045_notices_consents_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-068-highline-wearables/06_notices_consents/046_notices_consents_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-068-highline-wearables/06_notices_consents/047_notices_consents_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-068-highline-wearables/06_notices_consents/048_notices_consents_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-068-highline-wearables/07_transfer_mechanisms/049_transfer_mechanisms_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-068-highline-wearables/07_transfer_mechanisms/050_transfer_mechanisms_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-068-highline-wearables/07_transfer_mechanisms/051_transfer_mechanisms_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-068-highline-wearables/07_transfer_mechanisms/052_transfer_mechanisms_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-068-highline-wearables/07_transfer_mechanisms/053_transfer_mechanisms_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-068-highline-wearables/07_transfer_mechanisms/054_transfer_mechanisms_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-068-highline-wearables/07_transfer_mechanisms/055_transfer_mechanisms_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-068-highline-wearables/07_transfer_mechanisms/056_transfer_mechanisms_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-068-highline-wearables/08_retention_deletion/057_retention_deletion_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-068-highline-wearables/08_retention_deletion/058_retention_deletion_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-068-highline-wearables/08_retention_deletion/059_retention_deletion_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-068-highline-wearables/08_retention_deletion/060_retention_deletion_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-068-highline-wearables/08_retention_deletion/061_retention_deletion_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-068-highline-wearables/08_retention_deletion/062_retention_deletion_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-068-highline-wearables/08_retention_deletion/063_retention_deletion_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-068-highline-wearables/08_retention_deletion/064_retention_deletion_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-068-highline-wearables/09_training/065_training_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-068-highline-wearables/09_training/066_training_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-068-highline-wearables/09_training/067_training_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-068-highline-wearables/09_training/068_training_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-068-highline-wearables/09_training/069_training_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-068-highline-wearables/09_training/070_training_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-068-highline-wearables/09_training/071_training_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-068-highline-wearables/09_training/072_training_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-068-highline-wearables/10_regulator_correspondence/073_regulator_correspondence_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-068-highline-wearables/10_regulator_correspondence/074_regulator_correspondence_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-068-highline-wearables/10_regulator_correspondence/075_regulator_correspondence_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-068-highline-wearables/10_regulator_correspondence/076_regulator_correspondence_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-068-highline-wearables/10_regulator_correspondence/077_regulator_correspondence_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-068-highline-wearables/10_regulator_correspondence/078_regulator_correspondence_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-068-highline-wearables/10_regulator_correspondence/079_regulator_correspondence_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-068-highline-wearables/10_regulator_correspondence/080_regulator_correspondence_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-068-highline-wearables/11_risk_assessments/081_risk_assessments_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-068-highline-wearables/11_risk_assessments/082_risk_assessments_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-068-highline-wearables/11_risk_assessments/083_risk_assessments_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-068-highline-wearables/11_risk_assessments/084_risk_assessments_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-068-highline-wearables/11_risk_assessments/085_risk_assessments_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-068-highline-wearables/11_risk_assessments/086_risk_assessments_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-068-highline-wearables/11_risk_assessments/087_risk_assessments_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-068-highline-wearables/11_risk_assessments/088_risk_assessments_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-068-highline-wearables/12_remediation/089_remediation_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-068-highline-wearables/12_remediation/090_remediation_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-068-highline-wearables/12_remediation/091_remediation_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-068-highline-wearables/12_remediation/092_remediation_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-068-highline-wearables/12_remediation/093_remediation_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-068-highline-wearables/12_remediation/094_remediation_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-068-highline-wearables/12_remediation/095_remediation_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-068-highline-wearables/12_remediation/096_remediation_status_report.md"], "gold_output": {"advice_markdown": "# Counsel advice — Highline biometric-data review\n\n## Executive assessment\n\nFor Highline Wearables, Inc. matter CB-PR-3008, the review identified 16 source-supported exceptions requiring action before 2026-09-27. The assessment concerns MotionKey Analytics and the supplied record for Texas.\n\n## Method and record coverage\n\nThe review inventoried all 96 production files, read the 33 controlling, corroborating, and control records, searched the email exports, and checked metadata for the designated chain-of-custody sample. Conclusions are limited to the synthetic production supplied for this benchmark matter.\n\n## Findings\n\n### F-01 — processing-purpose gap (critical)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for processing-purpose gap: one source states the operative date is 2025-12-29 under control reference CB-PR-3008-A700, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2026-01-26 under response reference CB-PR-3008-J769.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/001_data_inventory_control_register.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/07_transfer_mechanisms/049_transfer_mechanisms_control_register.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-27, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Talia Brooks.\n\n### F-02 — notice-practice mismatch (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for notice-practice mismatch: one source states the controlling amount is $948,771.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $1,204,042.00.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/004_data_inventory_ledger_export.csv`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/07_transfer_mechanisms/052_transfer_mechanisms_ledger_export.csv`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-27, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Jonas Feld.\n\n### F-03 — consent-record deficiency (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for consent-record deficiency: one source states approval is attributed to Rafael Okafor as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Jonas Feld and contains no entry for Rafael Okafor.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/007_data_inventory_officer_certificate.html`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/07_transfer_mechanisms/055_transfer_mechanisms_officer_certificate.html`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-27, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Mei Whitaker.\n\n### F-04 — processor-contract omission (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for processor-contract omission: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-PR-3008-D963, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-PR-3008-M304.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/02_processing_records/010_processing_records_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/08_retention_deletion/058_retention_deletion_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-27, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Caleb Hassan.\n\n### F-05 — subprocessor inventory mismatch (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for subprocessor inventory mismatch: one source states the applicable location is Texas Attorney General, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to Texas operations outside Texas Attorney General.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/02_processing_records/013_processing_records_review_memorandum.json`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/08_retention_deletion/061_retention_deletion_review_memorandum.json`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-27, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Leona Park.\n\n### F-06 — cross-border transfer gap (low)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for cross-border transfer gap: one source states the threshold is 10% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 16% and produced a different exception result.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/02_processing_records/016_processing_records_status_report.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/08_retention_deletion/064_retention_deletion_status_report.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-27, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Isaac Romero.\n\n### F-07 — retention schedule conflict (critical)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for retention schedule conflict: one source states formal notice must use notices-highline_wearables_inc@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-motionkey_analytics@example.test.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/019_vendor_reviews_correspondence.eml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/09_training/067_training_correspondence.eml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-27, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Sofia Bennett.\n\n### F-08 — deletion-job failure (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for deletion-job failure: one source states the governed population contains 50 records through 2025-05-25, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 66 records through 2025-07-02.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/022_vendor_reviews_formal_notice.xml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/09_training/070_training_formal_notice.xml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-27, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Adrian Mensah.\n\n### F-09 — access-request deadline (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for access-request deadline: one source states the operative date is 2025-05-23 under control reference CB-PR-3008-I360, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2025-06-27 under response reference CB-PR-3008-R466.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/025_security_incidents_control_register.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/10_regulator_correspondence/073_regulator_correspondence_control_register.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-27, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Willa Novak.\n\n### F-10 — identity-verification inconsistency (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for identity-verification inconsistency: one source states the controlling amount is $6,823,676.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $6,983,852.00.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/028_security_incidents_ledger_export.csv`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/10_regulator_correspondence/076_regulator_correspondence_ledger_export.csv`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-27, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Theo Laurent.\n\n### F-11 — incident-notification clock (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for incident-notification clock: one source states approval is attributed to Rafael Okafor as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Samuel Kim and contains no entry for Rafael Okafor.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/031_security_incidents_officer_certificate.html`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/10_regulator_correspondence/079_regulator_correspondence_officer_certificate.html`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-27, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Amara Patel.\n\n### F-12 — risk-assessment omission (low)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for risk-assessment omission: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-PR-3008-L976, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-PR-3008-U513.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/034_consumer_requests_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/11_risk_assessments/082_risk_assessments_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-27, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Henry Cho.\n\n### F-13 — sensitive-data classification (critical)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for sensitive-data classification: one source states the applicable location is Texas Attorney General, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to Texas operations outside Texas Attorney General.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/037_consumer_requests_review_memorandum.json`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/11_risk_assessments/085_risk_assessments_review_memorandum.json`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-27, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Nadine Flores.\n\n### F-14 — minor-consent issue (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for minor-consent issue: one source states the threshold is 15% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 18% and produced a different exception result.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/040_consumer_requests_status_report.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/11_risk_assessments/088_risk_assessments_status_report.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-27, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Micah Sullivan.\n\n### F-15 — training completion gap (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for training completion gap: one source states formal notice must use notices-highline_wearables_inc@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-motionkey_analytics@example.test.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/043_notices_consents_correspondence.eml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/12_remediation/091_remediation_correspondence.eml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-27, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Farah Ibrahim.\n\n### F-16 — regulator commitment overdue (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for regulator commitment overdue: one source states the governed population contains 131 records through 2026-01-01, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 37 records through 2026-01-10.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/046_notices_consents_formal_notice.xml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/12_remediation/094_remediation_formal_notice.xml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-27, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Owen Delgado.\n\n## Recommended next actions\n\nSequence the critical and high findings first, assign the named owners, preserve the cited records, and document any resolution in the controlling matter register before the stated deadline.\n\n## Assumptions and limitations\n\nThis analysis is confined to task cb100-068-highline-wearables and the supplied synthetic evidence. It does not rely on external facts, does not resolve disputed law, and is not legal advice for a real person or entity.\n", "findings": {"as_of": "2026-09-27", "findings": [{"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/07_transfer_mechanisms/049_transfer_mechanisms_control_register.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for processing-purpose gap: one source states the operative date is 2025-12-29 under control reference CB-PR-3008-A700, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2026-01-26 under response reference CB-PR-3008-J769.", "id": "F-01", "issue": "processing-purpose gap", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/001_data_inventory_control_register.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-27, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Talia Brooks.", "severity": "critical"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/07_transfer_mechanisms/052_transfer_mechanisms_ledger_export.csv", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for notice-practice mismatch: one source states the controlling amount is $948,771.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $1,204,042.00.", "id": "F-02", "issue": "notice-practice mismatch", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/004_data_inventory_ledger_export.csv", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-27, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Jonas Feld.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/07_transfer_mechanisms/055_transfer_mechanisms_officer_certificate.html", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for consent-record deficiency: one source states approval is attributed to Rafael Okafor as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Jonas Feld and contains no entry for Rafael Okafor.", "id": "F-03", "issue": "consent-record deficiency", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/007_data_inventory_officer_certificate.html", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-27, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Mei Whitaker.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/08_retention_deletion/058_retention_deletion_executed_instrument.txt", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for processor-contract omission: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-PR-3008-D963, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-PR-3008-M304.", "id": "F-04", "issue": "processor-contract omission", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/02_processing_records/010_processing_records_executed_instrument.txt", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-27, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Caleb Hassan.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/08_retention_deletion/061_retention_deletion_review_memorandum.json", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for subprocessor inventory mismatch: one source states the applicable location is Texas Attorney General, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to Texas operations outside Texas Attorney General.", "id": "F-05", "issue": "subprocessor inventory mismatch", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/02_processing_records/013_processing_records_review_memorandum.json", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-27, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Leona Park.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/08_retention_deletion/064_retention_deletion_status_report.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for cross-border transfer gap: one source states the threshold is 10% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 16% and produced a different exception result.", "id": "F-06", "issue": "cross-border transfer gap", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/02_processing_records/016_processing_records_status_report.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-27, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Isaac Romero.", "severity": "low"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/09_training/067_training_correspondence.eml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for retention schedule conflict: one source states formal notice must use notices-highline_wearables_inc@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-motionkey_analytics@example.test.", "id": "F-07", "issue": "retention schedule conflict", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/019_vendor_reviews_correspondence.eml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-27, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Sofia Bennett.", "severity": "critical"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/09_training/070_training_formal_notice.xml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for deletion-job failure: one source states the governed population contains 50 records through 2025-05-25, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 66 records through 2025-07-02.", "id": "F-08", "issue": "deletion-job failure", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/022_vendor_reviews_formal_notice.xml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-27, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Adrian Mensah.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/10_regulator_correspondence/073_regulator_correspondence_control_register.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for access-request deadline: one source states the operative date is 2025-05-23 under control reference CB-PR-3008-I360, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2025-06-27 under response reference CB-PR-3008-R466.", "id": "F-09", "issue": "access-request deadline", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/025_security_incidents_control_register.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-27, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Willa Novak.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/10_regulator_correspondence/076_regulator_correspondence_ledger_export.csv", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for identity-verification inconsistency: one source states the controlling amount is $6,823,676.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $6,983,852.00.", "id": "F-10", "issue": "identity-verification inconsistency", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/028_security_incidents_ledger_export.csv", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-27, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Theo Laurent.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/10_regulator_correspondence/079_regulator_correspondence_officer_certificate.html", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for incident-notification clock: one source states approval is attributed to Rafael Okafor as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Samuel Kim and contains no entry for Rafael Okafor.", "id": "F-11", "issue": "incident-notification clock", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/031_security_incidents_officer_certificate.html", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-27, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Amara Patel.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/11_risk_assessments/082_risk_assessments_executed_instrument.txt", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for risk-assessment omission: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-PR-3008-L976, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-PR-3008-U513.", "id": "F-12", "issue": "risk-assessment omission", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/034_consumer_requests_executed_instrument.txt", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-27, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Henry Cho.", "severity": "low"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/11_risk_assessments/085_risk_assessments_review_memorandum.json", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for sensitive-data classification: one source states the applicable location is Texas Attorney General, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to Texas operations outside Texas Attorney General.", "id": "F-13", "issue": "sensitive-data classification", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/037_consumer_requests_review_memorandum.json", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-27, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Nadine Flores.", "severity": "critical"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/11_risk_assessments/088_risk_assessments_status_report.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for minor-consent issue: one source states the threshold is 15% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 18% and produced a different exception result.", "id": "F-14", "issue": "minor-consent issue", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/040_consumer_requests_status_report.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-27, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Micah Sullivan.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/091_remediation_correspondence.eml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for training completion gap: one source states formal notice must use notices-highline_wearables_inc@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-motionkey_analytics@example.test.", "id": "F-15", "issue": "training completion gap", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/043_notices_consents_correspondence.eml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-27, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Farah Ibrahim.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/094_remediation_formal_notice.xml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for regulator commitment overdue: one source states the governed population contains 131 records through 2026-01-01, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 37 records through 2026-01-10.", "id": "F-16", "issue": "regulator commitment overdue", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/046_notices_consents_formal_notice.xml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-27, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Owen Delgado.", "severity": "medium"}], "matter_number": "CB-PR-3008", "prepared_for": "Highline Wearables, Inc.", "schema_version": "1.0", "task_id": "cb100-068-highline-wearables"}}, "metadata": {"benchmark": "CounselBench-100", "code_license": "Apache-2.0", "data_license": "CC-BY-4.0", "deadline": "2026-09-27", "document_count": 96, "jurisdiction": "Texas", "matter_number": "CB-PR-3008", "mcp_commit": "9a96ea6e5913736f92b88345bf51caeaaa8e719f", "mcp_package": "@modelcontextprotocol/server-filesystem@2026.7.10", "practice_area": "privacy-regulatory", "reference_tool_calls": 46, "required_evidence_reads": 33, "synthetic": true, "venue": "Texas Attorney General", "version": "2.0.0"}, "prompt": "You are privacy and regulatory counsel for Highline Wearables, Inc. The supervising attorney wants an exception-focused review that still demonstrates complete coverage of the data room. Wearable telemetry and voice features launched before updated consents, assessments, and vendor deletion controls were complete. Decision due 2026-09-27. Texas law governs; Texas Attorney General is the forum. Preserve the difference between the client's position, the counterparty's position, and an objective record conflict. Work out the defensible position from the matter production and leave an audit-ready exception tracker and concise advice for the supervising lawyer. Keep confirmed conflicts separate from open questions, cite the records that actually control each conclusion, and do not fill gaps with outside facts.", "rubric": {"criteria": [{"category": "procedure", "description": "Complete at least 46 successful, argument-specific evidence and output calls.", "id": "procedure.minimum_successful_tool_calls"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Find and read the 33 controlling, corroborating, and work-product-control records in full.", "id": "procedure.all_evidence_read_in_full"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Inspect file metadata for the eight designated critical primary records before relying on them.", "id": "procedure.chain_of_custody_metadata_checked"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Confirm the sandbox's allowed document and output roots.", "id": "procedure.allowed_directories_checked"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Inventory all 96 records so the relevant sources are discovered among the context records.", "id": "procedure.recursive_inventory_completed"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Search the production for email evidence that may corroborate or contradict formal records.", "id": "procedure.targeted_search_completed"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Leave only findings.json and advice.md in the output workspace.", "id": "procedure.exact_deliverable_set"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Create both final work products through the sandbox MCP surface.", "id": "procedure.deliverables_written_through_mcp"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Produce findings.json as a valid JSON object.", "id": "findings.findings_is_object"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Report exactly 16 confirmed exceptions.", "id": "findings.findings_exact_count"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Use each stable finding ID exactly once.", "id": "findings.finding_ids_unique"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set schema_version to the released matter value '1.0'.", "id": "findings.top_level_schema_version"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set task_id to the released matter value 'cb100-068-highline-wearables'.", "id": "findings.top_level_task_id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set matter_number to the released matter value 'CB-PR-3008'.", "id": "findings.top_level_matter_number"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set prepared_for to the released matter value 'Highline Wearables, Inc.'.", "id": "findings.top_level_prepared_for"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set as_of to the released matter value '2026-09-27'.", "id": "findings.top_level_as_of"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-01 exception for processing-purpose gap.", "id": "findings.F-01.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's id from /workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/001_data_inventory_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_transfer_mechanisms/049_transfer_mechanisms_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's issue from /workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/001_data_inventory_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_transfer_mechanisms/049_transfer_mechanisms_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's severity from /workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/001_data_inventory_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_transfer_mechanisms/049_transfer_mechanisms_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's primary_source from /workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/001_data_inventory_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_transfer_mechanisms/049_transfer_mechanisms_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/001_data_inventory_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_transfer_mechanisms/049_transfer_mechanisms_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-01 using the exact controlled facts ['2025-12-29', 'CB-PR-3008-A700', '2026-01-26', 'CB-PR-3008-J769'].", "id": "findings.F-01.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-01's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-01.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-27', 'Talia Brooks'] for F-01.", "id": "findings.F-01.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-02 exception for notice-practice mismatch.", "id": "findings.F-02.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's id from /workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/004_data_inventory_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_transfer_mechanisms/052_transfer_mechanisms_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's issue from /workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/004_data_inventory_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_transfer_mechanisms/052_transfer_mechanisms_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's severity from /workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/004_data_inventory_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_transfer_mechanisms/052_transfer_mechanisms_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's primary_source from /workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/004_data_inventory_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_transfer_mechanisms/052_transfer_mechanisms_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/004_data_inventory_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_transfer_mechanisms/052_transfer_mechanisms_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-02 using the exact controlled facts ['$948,771.00', '$1,204,042.00'].", "id": "findings.F-02.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-02's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-02.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-27', 'Jonas Feld'] for F-02.", "id": "findings.F-02.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-03 exception for consent-record deficiency.", "id": "findings.F-03.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's id from /workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/007_data_inventory_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_transfer_mechanisms/055_transfer_mechanisms_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's issue from /workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/007_data_inventory_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_transfer_mechanisms/055_transfer_mechanisms_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's severity from /workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/007_data_inventory_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_transfer_mechanisms/055_transfer_mechanisms_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's primary_source from /workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/007_data_inventory_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_transfer_mechanisms/055_transfer_mechanisms_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/007_data_inventory_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_transfer_mechanisms/055_transfer_mechanisms_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-03 using the exact controlled facts ['Rafael Okafor', 'Jonas Feld'].", "id": "findings.F-03.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-03's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-03.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-27', 'Mei Whitaker'] for F-03.", "id": "findings.F-03.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-04 exception for processor-contract omission.", "id": "findings.F-04.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's id from /workspace/documents/02_processing_records/010_processing_records_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_retention_deletion/058_retention_deletion_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's issue from /workspace/documents/02_processing_records/010_processing_records_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_retention_deletion/058_retention_deletion_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's severity from /workspace/documents/02_processing_records/010_processing_records_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_retention_deletion/058_retention_deletion_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's primary_source from /workspace/documents/02_processing_records/010_processing_records_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_retention_deletion/058_retention_deletion_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/02_processing_records/010_processing_records_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_retention_deletion/058_retention_deletion_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-04 using the exact controlled facts ['closed without exception', 'CB-PR-3008-D963', 'open and escalated', 'CB-PR-3008-M304'].", "id": "findings.F-04.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-04's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-04.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-27', 'Caleb Hassan'] for F-04.", "id": "findings.F-04.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-05 exception for subprocessor inventory mismatch.", "id": "findings.F-05.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's id from /workspace/documents/02_processing_records/013_processing_records_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_retention_deletion/061_retention_deletion_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's issue from /workspace/documents/02_processing_records/013_processing_records_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_retention_deletion/061_retention_deletion_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's severity from /workspace/documents/02_processing_records/013_processing_records_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_retention_deletion/061_retention_deletion_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's primary_source from /workspace/documents/02_processing_records/013_processing_records_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_retention_deletion/061_retention_deletion_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/02_processing_records/013_processing_records_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_retention_deletion/061_retention_deletion_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-05 using the exact controlled facts ['Texas Attorney General', 'Texas'].", "id": "findings.F-05.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-05's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-05.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-27', 'Leona Park'] for F-05.", "id": "findings.F-05.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-06 exception for cross-border transfer gap.", "id": "findings.F-06.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's id from /workspace/documents/02_processing_records/016_processing_records_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_retention_deletion/064_retention_deletion_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's issue from /workspace/documents/02_processing_records/016_processing_records_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_retention_deletion/064_retention_deletion_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's severity from /workspace/documents/02_processing_records/016_processing_records_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_retention_deletion/064_retention_deletion_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's primary_source from /workspace/documents/02_processing_records/016_processing_records_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_retention_deletion/064_retention_deletion_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/02_processing_records/016_processing_records_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_retention_deletion/064_retention_deletion_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-06 using the exact controlled facts ['10%', '16%'].", "id": "findings.F-06.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-06's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-06.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-27', 'Isaac Romero'] for F-06.", "id": "findings.F-06.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-07 exception for retention schedule conflict.", "id": "findings.F-07.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's id from /workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/019_vendor_reviews_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_training/067_training_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's issue from /workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/019_vendor_reviews_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_training/067_training_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's severity from /workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/019_vendor_reviews_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_training/067_training_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's primary_source from /workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/019_vendor_reviews_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_training/067_training_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/019_vendor_reviews_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_training/067_training_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-07 using the exact controlled facts ['notices-highline_wearables_inc@example.test', 'archive-motionkey_analytics@example.test'].", "id": "findings.F-07.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-07's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-07.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-27', 'Sofia Bennett'] for F-07.", "id": "findings.F-07.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-08 exception for deletion-job failure.", "id": "findings.F-08.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's id from /workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/022_vendor_reviews_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_training/070_training_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's issue from /workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/022_vendor_reviews_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_training/070_training_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's severity from /workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/022_vendor_reviews_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_training/070_training_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's primary_source from /workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/022_vendor_reviews_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_training/070_training_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/022_vendor_reviews_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_training/070_training_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-08 using the exact controlled facts ['50 records', '2025-05-25', '66 records', '2025-07-02'].", "id": "findings.F-08.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-08's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-08.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-27', 'Adrian Mensah'] for F-08.", "id": "findings.F-08.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-09 exception for access-request deadline.", "id": "findings.F-09.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's id from /workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/025_security_incidents_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_regulator_correspondence/073_regulator_correspondence_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's issue from /workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/025_security_incidents_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_regulator_correspondence/073_regulator_correspondence_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's severity from /workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/025_security_incidents_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_regulator_correspondence/073_regulator_correspondence_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's primary_source from /workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/025_security_incidents_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_regulator_correspondence/073_regulator_correspondence_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/025_security_incidents_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_regulator_correspondence/073_regulator_correspondence_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-09 using the exact controlled facts ['2025-05-23', 'CB-PR-3008-I360', '2025-06-27', 'CB-PR-3008-R466'].", "id": "findings.F-09.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-09's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-09.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-27', 'Willa Novak'] for F-09.", "id": "findings.F-09.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-10 exception for identity-verification inconsistency.", "id": "findings.F-10.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's id from /workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/028_security_incidents_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_regulator_correspondence/076_regulator_correspondence_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's issue from /workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/028_security_incidents_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_regulator_correspondence/076_regulator_correspondence_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's severity from /workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/028_security_incidents_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_regulator_correspondence/076_regulator_correspondence_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's primary_source from /workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/028_security_incidents_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_regulator_correspondence/076_regulator_correspondence_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/028_security_incidents_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_regulator_correspondence/076_regulator_correspondence_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-10 using the exact controlled facts ['$6,823,676.00', '$6,983,852.00'].", "id": "findings.F-10.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-10's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-10.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-27', 'Theo Laurent'] for F-10.", "id": "findings.F-10.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-11 exception for incident-notification clock.", "id": "findings.F-11.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's id from /workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/031_security_incidents_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_regulator_correspondence/079_regulator_correspondence_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's issue from /workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/031_security_incidents_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_regulator_correspondence/079_regulator_correspondence_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's severity from /workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/031_security_incidents_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_regulator_correspondence/079_regulator_correspondence_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's primary_source from /workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/031_security_incidents_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_regulator_correspondence/079_regulator_correspondence_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/031_security_incidents_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_regulator_correspondence/079_regulator_correspondence_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-11 using the exact controlled facts ['Rafael Okafor', 'Samuel Kim'].", "id": "findings.F-11.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-11's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-11.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-27', 'Amara Patel'] for F-11.", "id": "findings.F-11.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-12 exception for risk-assessment omission.", "id": "findings.F-12.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's id from /workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/034_consumer_requests_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_risk_assessments/082_risk_assessments_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's issue from /workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/034_consumer_requests_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_risk_assessments/082_risk_assessments_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's severity from /workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/034_consumer_requests_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_risk_assessments/082_risk_assessments_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's primary_source from /workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/034_consumer_requests_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_risk_assessments/082_risk_assessments_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/034_consumer_requests_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_risk_assessments/082_risk_assessments_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-12 using the exact controlled facts ['closed without exception', 'CB-PR-3008-L976', 'open and escalated', 'CB-PR-3008-U513'].", "id": "findings.F-12.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-12's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-12.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-27', 'Henry Cho'] for F-12.", "id": "findings.F-12.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-13 exception for sensitive-data classification.", "id": "findings.F-13.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's id from /workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/037_consumer_requests_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_risk_assessments/085_risk_assessments_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's issue from /workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/037_consumer_requests_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_risk_assessments/085_risk_assessments_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's severity from /workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/037_consumer_requests_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_risk_assessments/085_risk_assessments_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's primary_source from /workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/037_consumer_requests_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_risk_assessments/085_risk_assessments_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/037_consumer_requests_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_risk_assessments/085_risk_assessments_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-13 using the exact controlled facts ['Texas Attorney General', 'Texas'].", "id": "findings.F-13.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-13's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-13.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-27', 'Nadine Flores'] for F-13.", "id": "findings.F-13.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-14 exception for minor-consent issue.", "id": "findings.F-14.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's id from /workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/040_consumer_requests_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_risk_assessments/088_risk_assessments_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's issue from /workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/040_consumer_requests_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_risk_assessments/088_risk_assessments_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's severity from /workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/040_consumer_requests_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_risk_assessments/088_risk_assessments_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's primary_source from /workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/040_consumer_requests_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_risk_assessments/088_risk_assessments_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/040_consumer_requests_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_risk_assessments/088_risk_assessments_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-14 using the exact controlled facts ['15%', '18%'].", "id": "findings.F-14.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-14's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-14.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-27', 'Micah Sullivan'] for F-14.", "id": "findings.F-14.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-15 exception for training completion gap.", "id": "findings.F-15.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's id from /workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/043_notices_consents_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_remediation/091_remediation_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's issue from /workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/043_notices_consents_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_remediation/091_remediation_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's severity from /workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/043_notices_consents_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_remediation/091_remediation_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's primary_source from /workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/043_notices_consents_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_remediation/091_remediation_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/043_notices_consents_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_remediation/091_remediation_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-15 using the exact controlled facts ['notices-highline_wearables_inc@example.test', 'archive-motionkey_analytics@example.test'].", "id": "findings.F-15.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-15's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-15.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-27', 'Farah Ibrahim'] for F-15.", "id": "findings.F-15.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-16 exception for regulator commitment overdue.", "id": "findings.F-16.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's id from /workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/046_notices_consents_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_remediation/094_remediation_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's issue from /workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/046_notices_consents_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_remediation/094_remediation_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's severity from /workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/046_notices_consents_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_remediation/094_remediation_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's primary_source from /workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/046_notices_consents_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_remediation/094_remediation_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/046_notices_consents_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_remediation/094_remediation_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-16 using the exact controlled facts ['131 records', '2026-01-01', '37 records', '2026-01-10'].", "id": "findings.F-16.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-16's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-16.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-27', 'Owen Delgado'] for F-16.", "id": "findings.F-16.action_anchors"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Executive assessment' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Executive assessment"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Method and record coverage' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Method and record coverage"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Findings' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Findings"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Recommended next actions' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Recommended next actions"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Assumptions and limitations' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Assumptions and limitations"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-01 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-01"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-02 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-02"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-03 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-03"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-04 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-04"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-05 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-05"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-06 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-06"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-07 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-07"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-08 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-08"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-09 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-09"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-10 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-10"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-11 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-11"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-12 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-12"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-13 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-13"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-14 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-14"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-15 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-15"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-16 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-16"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Do not claim the production has no issues or that every record is consistent.", "id": "memo.forbidden_claims_absent"}], "decision_options": [{"id": "cross-source-reconciliation", "label": "Reconcile controlling and corroborating records", "reason": "The CB-PR-3008 production contains independently maintained records; a defensible answer must preserve each supported conflict and its cure owner.", "selected": true}, {"id": "latest-record-controls", "label": "Treat the latest record as controlling", "reason": "Timestamp recency does not establish legal priority, execution, or approval authority.", "selected": false}, {"id": "primary-records-only", "label": "Report primary records without reconciliation", "reason": "Primary records alone conceal the operational conflicts that create the actionable exceptions.", "selected": false}], "gates": ["all_evidence_read_in_full", "chain_of_custody_metadata_checked", "findings_criteria_complete", "memo_criteria_complete", "deliverables_written_through_mcp"], "metadata_checks": 8, "metric": "weighted_criteria_score", "minimum_tool_calls": 46, "required_deliverables": ["findings.json", "advice.md"], "required_document_reads": 33, "type": "deterministic", "weights": {"findings": 0.55, "memo": 0.2, "procedure": 0.25}}, "task_id": "cb100-068-highline-wearables", "task_name": "Highline biometric-data review", "world_id": "counselbench-filesystem-mcp-v2"}
-{"context_files": ["task_files/cb100-069-inkwell-publishing/01_data_inventory/001_data_inventory_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-069-inkwell-publishing/01_data_inventory/002_data_inventory_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-069-inkwell-publishing/01_data_inventory/003_data_inventory_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-069-inkwell-publishing/01_data_inventory/004_data_inventory_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-069-inkwell-publishing/01_data_inventory/005_data_inventory_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-069-inkwell-publishing/01_data_inventory/006_data_inventory_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-069-inkwell-publishing/01_data_inventory/007_data_inventory_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-069-inkwell-publishing/01_data_inventory/008_data_inventory_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-069-inkwell-publishing/02_processing_records/009_processing_records_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-069-inkwell-publishing/02_processing_records/010_processing_records_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-069-inkwell-publishing/02_processing_records/011_processing_records_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-069-inkwell-publishing/02_processing_records/012_processing_records_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-069-inkwell-publishing/02_processing_records/013_processing_records_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-069-inkwell-publishing/02_processing_records/014_processing_records_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-069-inkwell-publishing/02_processing_records/015_processing_records_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-069-inkwell-publishing/02_processing_records/016_processing_records_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-069-inkwell-publishing/03_vendor_reviews/017_vendor_reviews_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-069-inkwell-publishing/03_vendor_reviews/018_vendor_reviews_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-069-inkwell-publishing/03_vendor_reviews/019_vendor_reviews_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-069-inkwell-publishing/03_vendor_reviews/020_vendor_reviews_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-069-inkwell-publishing/03_vendor_reviews/021_vendor_reviews_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-069-inkwell-publishing/03_vendor_reviews/022_vendor_reviews_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-069-inkwell-publishing/03_vendor_reviews/023_vendor_reviews_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-069-inkwell-publishing/03_vendor_reviews/024_vendor_reviews_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-069-inkwell-publishing/04_security_incidents/025_security_incidents_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-069-inkwell-publishing/04_security_incidents/026_security_incidents_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-069-inkwell-publishing/04_security_incidents/027_security_incidents_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-069-inkwell-publishing/04_security_incidents/028_security_incidents_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-069-inkwell-publishing/04_security_incidents/029_security_incidents_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-069-inkwell-publishing/04_security_incidents/030_security_incidents_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-069-inkwell-publishing/04_security_incidents/031_security_incidents_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-069-inkwell-publishing/04_security_incidents/032_security_incidents_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-069-inkwell-publishing/05_consumer_requests/033_consumer_requests_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-069-inkwell-publishing/05_consumer_requests/034_consumer_requests_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-069-inkwell-publishing/05_consumer_requests/035_consumer_requests_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-069-inkwell-publishing/05_consumer_requests/036_consumer_requests_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-069-inkwell-publishing/05_consumer_requests/037_consumer_requests_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-069-inkwell-publishing/05_consumer_requests/038_consumer_requests_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-069-inkwell-publishing/05_consumer_requests/039_consumer_requests_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-069-inkwell-publishing/05_consumer_requests/040_consumer_requests_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-069-inkwell-publishing/06_notices_consents/041_notices_consents_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-069-inkwell-publishing/06_notices_consents/042_notices_consents_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-069-inkwell-publishing/06_notices_consents/043_notices_consents_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-069-inkwell-publishing/06_notices_consents/044_notices_consents_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-069-inkwell-publishing/06_notices_consents/045_notices_consents_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-069-inkwell-publishing/06_notices_consents/046_notices_consents_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-069-inkwell-publishing/06_notices_consents/047_notices_consents_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-069-inkwell-publishing/06_notices_consents/048_notices_consents_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-069-inkwell-publishing/07_transfer_mechanisms/049_transfer_mechanisms_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-069-inkwell-publishing/07_transfer_mechanisms/050_transfer_mechanisms_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-069-inkwell-publishing/07_transfer_mechanisms/051_transfer_mechanisms_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-069-inkwell-publishing/07_transfer_mechanisms/052_transfer_mechanisms_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-069-inkwell-publishing/07_transfer_mechanisms/053_transfer_mechanisms_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-069-inkwell-publishing/07_transfer_mechanisms/054_transfer_mechanisms_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-069-inkwell-publishing/07_transfer_mechanisms/055_transfer_mechanisms_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-069-inkwell-publishing/07_transfer_mechanisms/056_transfer_mechanisms_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-069-inkwell-publishing/08_retention_deletion/057_retention_deletion_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-069-inkwell-publishing/08_retention_deletion/058_retention_deletion_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-069-inkwell-publishing/08_retention_deletion/059_retention_deletion_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-069-inkwell-publishing/08_retention_deletion/060_retention_deletion_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-069-inkwell-publishing/08_retention_deletion/061_retention_deletion_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-069-inkwell-publishing/08_retention_deletion/062_retention_deletion_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-069-inkwell-publishing/08_retention_deletion/063_retention_deletion_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-069-inkwell-publishing/08_retention_deletion/064_retention_deletion_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-069-inkwell-publishing/09_training/065_training_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-069-inkwell-publishing/09_training/066_training_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-069-inkwell-publishing/09_training/067_training_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-069-inkwell-publishing/09_training/068_training_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-069-inkwell-publishing/09_training/069_training_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-069-inkwell-publishing/09_training/070_training_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-069-inkwell-publishing/09_training/071_training_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-069-inkwell-publishing/09_training/072_training_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-069-inkwell-publishing/10_regulator_correspondence/073_regulator_correspondence_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-069-inkwell-publishing/10_regulator_correspondence/074_regulator_correspondence_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-069-inkwell-publishing/10_regulator_correspondence/075_regulator_correspondence_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-069-inkwell-publishing/10_regulator_correspondence/076_regulator_correspondence_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-069-inkwell-publishing/10_regulator_correspondence/077_regulator_correspondence_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-069-inkwell-publishing/10_regulator_correspondence/078_regulator_correspondence_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-069-inkwell-publishing/10_regulator_correspondence/079_regulator_correspondence_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-069-inkwell-publishing/10_regulator_correspondence/080_regulator_correspondence_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-069-inkwell-publishing/11_risk_assessments/081_risk_assessments_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-069-inkwell-publishing/11_risk_assessments/082_risk_assessments_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-069-inkwell-publishing/11_risk_assessments/083_risk_assessments_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-069-inkwell-publishing/11_risk_assessments/084_risk_assessments_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-069-inkwell-publishing/11_risk_assessments/085_risk_assessments_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-069-inkwell-publishing/11_risk_assessments/086_risk_assessments_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-069-inkwell-publishing/11_risk_assessments/087_risk_assessments_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-069-inkwell-publishing/11_risk_assessments/088_risk_assessments_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-069-inkwell-publishing/12_remediation/089_remediation_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-069-inkwell-publishing/12_remediation/090_remediation_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-069-inkwell-publishing/12_remediation/091_remediation_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-069-inkwell-publishing/12_remediation/092_remediation_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-069-inkwell-publishing/12_remediation/093_remediation_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-069-inkwell-publishing/12_remediation/094_remediation_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-069-inkwell-publishing/12_remediation/095_remediation_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-069-inkwell-publishing/12_remediation/096_remediation_status_report.md"], "gold_output": {"advice_markdown": "# Counsel advice — Inkwell subscriber request audit\n\n## Executive assessment\n\nFor Inkwell Digital Publishing matter CB-PR-3009, the review identified 16 source-supported exceptions requiring action before 2026-09-30. The assessment concerns Blue Quill Audience Systems and the supplied record for Oregon.\n\n## Method and record coverage\n\nThe review inventoried all 96 production files, read the 33 controlling, corroborating, and control records, searched the email exports, and checked metadata for the designated chain-of-custody sample. Conclusions are limited to the synthetic production supplied for this benchmark matter.\n\n## Findings\n\n### F-01 — processing-purpose gap (critical)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for processing-purpose gap: one source states the operative date is 2025-11-15 under control reference CB-PR-3009-A716, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2025-12-18 under response reference CB-PR-3009-J562.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/001_data_inventory_control_register.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/07_transfer_mechanisms/049_transfer_mechanisms_control_register.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-30, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Jonas Feld.\n\n### F-02 — notice-practice mismatch (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for notice-practice mismatch: one source states the controlling amount is $1,521,067.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $1,658,634.00.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/004_data_inventory_ledger_export.csv`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/07_transfer_mechanisms/052_transfer_mechanisms_ledger_export.csv`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-30, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Mei Whitaker.\n\n### F-03 — consent-record deficiency (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for consent-record deficiency: one source states approval is attributed to Nora Chen as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Caleb Hassan and contains no entry for Nora Chen.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/007_data_inventory_officer_certificate.html`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/07_transfer_mechanisms/055_transfer_mechanisms_officer_certificate.html`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-30, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Caleb Hassan.\n\n### F-04 — processor-contract omission (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for processor-contract omission: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-PR-3009-D404, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-PR-3009-M884.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/02_processing_records/010_processing_records_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/08_retention_deletion/058_retention_deletion_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-30, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Leona Park.\n\n### F-05 — subprocessor inventory mismatch (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for subprocessor inventory mismatch: one source states the applicable location is Oregon Attorney General, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to Oregon operations outside Oregon Attorney General.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/02_processing_records/013_processing_records_review_memorandum.json`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/08_retention_deletion/061_retention_deletion_review_memorandum.json`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-30, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Isaac Romero.\n\n### F-06 — cross-border transfer gap (low)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for cross-border transfer gap: one source states the threshold is 7% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 10% and produced a different exception result.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/02_processing_records/016_processing_records_status_report.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/08_retention_deletion/064_retention_deletion_status_report.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-30, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Sofia Bennett.\n\n### F-07 — retention schedule conflict (critical)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for retention schedule conflict: one source states formal notice must use notices-inkwell_digital_publishing@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-blue_quill_audience_systems@example.test.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/019_vendor_reviews_correspondence.eml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/09_training/067_training_correspondence.eml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-30, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Adrian Mensah.\n\n### F-08 — deletion-job failure (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for deletion-job failure: one source states the governed population contains 70 records through 2025-11-01, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 36 records through 2025-11-09.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/022_vendor_reviews_formal_notice.xml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/09_training/070_training_formal_notice.xml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-30, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Willa Novak.\n\n### F-09 — access-request deadline (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for access-request deadline: one source states the operative date is 2026-02-05 under control reference CB-PR-3009-I258, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2026-03-20 under response reference CB-PR-3009-R250.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/025_security_incidents_control_register.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/10_regulator_correspondence/073_regulator_correspondence_control_register.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-30, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Theo Laurent.\n\n### F-10 — identity-verification inconsistency (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for identity-verification inconsistency: one source states the controlling amount is $986,589.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $1,149,678.00.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/028_security_incidents_ledger_export.csv`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/10_regulator_correspondence/076_regulator_correspondence_ledger_export.csv`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-30, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Amara Patel.\n\n### F-11 — incident-notification clock (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for incident-notification clock: one source states approval is attributed to Nora Chen as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Rafael Okafor and contains no entry for Nora Chen.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/031_security_incidents_officer_certificate.html`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/10_regulator_correspondence/079_regulator_correspondence_officer_certificate.html`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-30, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Henry Cho.\n\n### F-12 — risk-assessment omission (low)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for risk-assessment omission: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-PR-3009-L860, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-PR-3009-U227.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/034_consumer_requests_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/11_risk_assessments/082_risk_assessments_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-30, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Nadine Flores.\n\n### F-13 — sensitive-data classification (critical)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for sensitive-data classification: one source states the applicable location is Oregon Attorney General, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to Oregon operations outside Oregon Attorney General.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/037_consumer_requests_review_memorandum.json`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/11_risk_assessments/085_risk_assessments_review_memorandum.json`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-30, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Micah Sullivan.\n\n### F-14 — minor-consent issue (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for minor-consent issue: one source states the threshold is 5% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 12% and produced a different exception result.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/040_consumer_requests_status_report.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/11_risk_assessments/088_risk_assessments_status_report.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-30, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Farah Ibrahim.\n\n### F-15 — training completion gap (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for training completion gap: one source states formal notice must use notices-inkwell_digital_publishing@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-blue_quill_audience_systems@example.test.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/043_notices_consents_correspondence.eml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/12_remediation/091_remediation_correspondence.eml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-30, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Owen Delgado.\n\n### F-16 — regulator commitment overdue (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for regulator commitment overdue: one source states the governed population contains 113 records through 2025-03-09, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 45 records through 2025-03-26.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/046_notices_consents_formal_notice.xml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/12_remediation/094_remediation_formal_notice.xml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-30, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Lena Varga.\n\n## Recommended next actions\n\nSequence the critical and high findings first, assign the named owners, preserve the cited records, and document any resolution in the controlling matter register before the stated deadline.\n\n## Assumptions and limitations\n\nThis analysis is confined to task cb100-069-inkwell-publishing and the supplied synthetic evidence. It does not rely on external facts, does not resolve disputed law, and is not legal advice for a real person or entity.\n", "findings": {"as_of": "2026-09-30", "findings": [{"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/07_transfer_mechanisms/049_transfer_mechanisms_control_register.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for processing-purpose gap: one source states the operative date is 2025-11-15 under control reference CB-PR-3009-A716, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2025-12-18 under response reference CB-PR-3009-J562.", "id": "F-01", "issue": "processing-purpose gap", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/001_data_inventory_control_register.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-30, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Jonas Feld.", "severity": "critical"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/07_transfer_mechanisms/052_transfer_mechanisms_ledger_export.csv", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for notice-practice mismatch: one source states the controlling amount is $1,521,067.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $1,658,634.00.", "id": "F-02", "issue": "notice-practice mismatch", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/004_data_inventory_ledger_export.csv", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-30, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Mei Whitaker.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/07_transfer_mechanisms/055_transfer_mechanisms_officer_certificate.html", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for consent-record deficiency: one source states approval is attributed to Nora Chen as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Caleb Hassan and contains no entry for Nora Chen.", "id": "F-03", "issue": "consent-record deficiency", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/007_data_inventory_officer_certificate.html", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-30, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Caleb Hassan.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/08_retention_deletion/058_retention_deletion_executed_instrument.txt", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for processor-contract omission: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-PR-3009-D404, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-PR-3009-M884.", "id": "F-04", "issue": "processor-contract omission", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/02_processing_records/010_processing_records_executed_instrument.txt", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-30, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Leona Park.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/08_retention_deletion/061_retention_deletion_review_memorandum.json", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for subprocessor inventory mismatch: one source states the applicable location is Oregon Attorney General, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to Oregon operations outside Oregon Attorney General.", "id": "F-05", "issue": "subprocessor inventory mismatch", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/02_processing_records/013_processing_records_review_memorandum.json", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-30, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Isaac Romero.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/08_retention_deletion/064_retention_deletion_status_report.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for cross-border transfer gap: one source states the threshold is 7% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 10% and produced a different exception result.", "id": "F-06", "issue": "cross-border transfer gap", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/02_processing_records/016_processing_records_status_report.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-30, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Sofia Bennett.", "severity": "low"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/09_training/067_training_correspondence.eml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for retention schedule conflict: one source states formal notice must use notices-inkwell_digital_publishing@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-blue_quill_audience_systems@example.test.", "id": "F-07", "issue": "retention schedule conflict", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/019_vendor_reviews_correspondence.eml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-30, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Adrian Mensah.", "severity": "critical"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/09_training/070_training_formal_notice.xml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for deletion-job failure: one source states the governed population contains 70 records through 2025-11-01, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 36 records through 2025-11-09.", "id": "F-08", "issue": "deletion-job failure", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/022_vendor_reviews_formal_notice.xml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-30, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Willa Novak.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/10_regulator_correspondence/073_regulator_correspondence_control_register.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for access-request deadline: one source states the operative date is 2026-02-05 under control reference CB-PR-3009-I258, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2026-03-20 under response reference CB-PR-3009-R250.", "id": "F-09", "issue": "access-request deadline", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/025_security_incidents_control_register.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-30, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Theo Laurent.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/10_regulator_correspondence/076_regulator_correspondence_ledger_export.csv", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for identity-verification inconsistency: one source states the controlling amount is $986,589.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $1,149,678.00.", "id": "F-10", "issue": "identity-verification inconsistency", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/028_security_incidents_ledger_export.csv", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-30, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Amara Patel.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/10_regulator_correspondence/079_regulator_correspondence_officer_certificate.html", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for incident-notification clock: one source states approval is attributed to Nora Chen as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Rafael Okafor and contains no entry for Nora Chen.", "id": "F-11", "issue": "incident-notification clock", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/031_security_incidents_officer_certificate.html", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-30, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Henry Cho.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/11_risk_assessments/082_risk_assessments_executed_instrument.txt", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for risk-assessment omission: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-PR-3009-L860, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-PR-3009-U227.", "id": "F-12", "issue": "risk-assessment omission", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/034_consumer_requests_executed_instrument.txt", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-30, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Nadine Flores.", "severity": "low"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/11_risk_assessments/085_risk_assessments_review_memorandum.json", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for sensitive-data classification: one source states the applicable location is Oregon Attorney General, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to Oregon operations outside Oregon Attorney General.", "id": "F-13", "issue": "sensitive-data classification", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/037_consumer_requests_review_memorandum.json", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-30, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Micah Sullivan.", "severity": "critical"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/11_risk_assessments/088_risk_assessments_status_report.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for minor-consent issue: one source states the threshold is 5% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 12% and produced a different exception result.", "id": "F-14", "issue": "minor-consent issue", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/040_consumer_requests_status_report.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-30, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Farah Ibrahim.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/091_remediation_correspondence.eml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for training completion gap: one source states formal notice must use notices-inkwell_digital_publishing@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-blue_quill_audience_systems@example.test.", "id": "F-15", "issue": "training completion gap", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/043_notices_consents_correspondence.eml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-30, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Owen Delgado.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/094_remediation_formal_notice.xml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for regulator commitment overdue: one source states the governed population contains 113 records through 2025-03-09, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 45 records through 2025-03-26.", "id": "F-16", "issue": "regulator commitment overdue", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/046_notices_consents_formal_notice.xml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-30, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Lena Varga.", "severity": "medium"}], "matter_number": "CB-PR-3009", "prepared_for": "Inkwell Digital Publishing", "schema_version": "1.0", "task_id": "cb100-069-inkwell-publishing"}}, "metadata": {"benchmark": "CounselBench-100", "code_license": "Apache-2.0", "data_license": "CC-BY-4.0", "deadline": "2026-09-30", "document_count": 96, "jurisdiction": "Oregon", "matter_number": "CB-PR-3009", "mcp_commit": "9a96ea6e5913736f92b88345bf51caeaaa8e719f", "mcp_package": "@modelcontextprotocol/server-filesystem@2026.7.10", "practice_area": "privacy-regulatory", "reference_tool_calls": 46, "required_evidence_reads": 33, "synthetic": true, "venue": "Oregon Attorney General", "version": "2.0.0"}, "prompt": "You are privacy and regulatory counsel for Inkwell Digital Publishing. This matter will be reviewed by legal, finance, and compliance stakeholders who need a single source-grounded output. Subscriber access and deletion requests reveal identity-verification, advertising disclosure, and data-retention inconsistencies. Decision due 2026-09-30. Oregon law governs; Oregon Attorney General is the forum. Use the production as of the stated deadline; do not assume facts outside the supplied files. Work out the defensible position from the matter production and leave an audit-ready exception tracker and concise advice for the supervising lawyer. Keep confirmed conflicts separate from open questions, cite the records that actually control each conclusion, and do not fill gaps with outside facts.", "rubric": {"criteria": [{"category": "procedure", "description": "Complete at least 46 successful, argument-specific evidence and output calls.", "id": "procedure.minimum_successful_tool_calls"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Find and read the 33 controlling, corroborating, and work-product-control records in full.", "id": "procedure.all_evidence_read_in_full"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Inspect file metadata for the eight designated critical primary records before relying on them.", "id": "procedure.chain_of_custody_metadata_checked"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Confirm the sandbox's allowed document and output roots.", "id": "procedure.allowed_directories_checked"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Inventory all 96 records so the relevant sources are discovered among the context records.", "id": "procedure.recursive_inventory_completed"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Search the production for email evidence that may corroborate or contradict formal records.", "id": "procedure.targeted_search_completed"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Leave only findings.json and advice.md in the output workspace.", "id": "procedure.exact_deliverable_set"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Create both final work products through the sandbox MCP surface.", "id": "procedure.deliverables_written_through_mcp"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Produce findings.json as a valid JSON object.", "id": "findings.findings_is_object"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Report exactly 16 confirmed exceptions.", "id": "findings.findings_exact_count"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Use each stable finding ID exactly once.", "id": "findings.finding_ids_unique"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set schema_version to the released matter value '1.0'.", "id": "findings.top_level_schema_version"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set task_id to the released matter value 'cb100-069-inkwell-publishing'.", "id": "findings.top_level_task_id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set matter_number to the released matter value 'CB-PR-3009'.", "id": "findings.top_level_matter_number"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set prepared_for to the released matter value 'Inkwell Digital Publishing'.", "id": "findings.top_level_prepared_for"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set as_of to the released matter value '2026-09-30'.", "id": "findings.top_level_as_of"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-01 exception for processing-purpose gap.", "id": "findings.F-01.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's id from /workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/001_data_inventory_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_transfer_mechanisms/049_transfer_mechanisms_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's issue from /workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/001_data_inventory_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_transfer_mechanisms/049_transfer_mechanisms_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's severity from /workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/001_data_inventory_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_transfer_mechanisms/049_transfer_mechanisms_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's primary_source from /workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/001_data_inventory_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_transfer_mechanisms/049_transfer_mechanisms_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/001_data_inventory_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_transfer_mechanisms/049_transfer_mechanisms_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-01 using the exact controlled facts ['2025-11-15', 'CB-PR-3009-A716', '2025-12-18', 'CB-PR-3009-J562'].", "id": "findings.F-01.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-01's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-01.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-30', 'Jonas Feld'] for F-01.", "id": "findings.F-01.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-02 exception for notice-practice mismatch.", "id": "findings.F-02.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's id from /workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/004_data_inventory_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_transfer_mechanisms/052_transfer_mechanisms_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's issue from /workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/004_data_inventory_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_transfer_mechanisms/052_transfer_mechanisms_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's severity from /workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/004_data_inventory_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_transfer_mechanisms/052_transfer_mechanisms_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's primary_source from /workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/004_data_inventory_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_transfer_mechanisms/052_transfer_mechanisms_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/004_data_inventory_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_transfer_mechanisms/052_transfer_mechanisms_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-02 using the exact controlled facts ['$1,521,067.00', '$1,658,634.00'].", "id": "findings.F-02.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-02's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-02.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-30', 'Mei Whitaker'] for F-02.", "id": "findings.F-02.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-03 exception for consent-record deficiency.", "id": "findings.F-03.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's id from /workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/007_data_inventory_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_transfer_mechanisms/055_transfer_mechanisms_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's issue from /workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/007_data_inventory_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_transfer_mechanisms/055_transfer_mechanisms_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's severity from /workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/007_data_inventory_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_transfer_mechanisms/055_transfer_mechanisms_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's primary_source from /workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/007_data_inventory_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_transfer_mechanisms/055_transfer_mechanisms_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/007_data_inventory_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_transfer_mechanisms/055_transfer_mechanisms_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-03 using the exact controlled facts ['Nora Chen', 'Caleb Hassan'].", "id": "findings.F-03.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-03's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-03.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-30', 'Caleb Hassan'] for F-03.", "id": "findings.F-03.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-04 exception for processor-contract omission.", "id": "findings.F-04.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's id from /workspace/documents/02_processing_records/010_processing_records_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_retention_deletion/058_retention_deletion_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's issue from /workspace/documents/02_processing_records/010_processing_records_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_retention_deletion/058_retention_deletion_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's severity from /workspace/documents/02_processing_records/010_processing_records_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_retention_deletion/058_retention_deletion_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's primary_source from /workspace/documents/02_processing_records/010_processing_records_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_retention_deletion/058_retention_deletion_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/02_processing_records/010_processing_records_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_retention_deletion/058_retention_deletion_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-04 using the exact controlled facts ['closed without exception', 'CB-PR-3009-D404', 'open and escalated', 'CB-PR-3009-M884'].", "id": "findings.F-04.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-04's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-04.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-30', 'Leona Park'] for F-04.", "id": "findings.F-04.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-05 exception for subprocessor inventory mismatch.", "id": "findings.F-05.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's id from /workspace/documents/02_processing_records/013_processing_records_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_retention_deletion/061_retention_deletion_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's issue from /workspace/documents/02_processing_records/013_processing_records_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_retention_deletion/061_retention_deletion_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's severity from /workspace/documents/02_processing_records/013_processing_records_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_retention_deletion/061_retention_deletion_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's primary_source from /workspace/documents/02_processing_records/013_processing_records_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_retention_deletion/061_retention_deletion_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/02_processing_records/013_processing_records_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_retention_deletion/061_retention_deletion_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-05 using the exact controlled facts ['Oregon Attorney General', 'Oregon'].", "id": "findings.F-05.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-05's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-05.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-30', 'Isaac Romero'] for F-05.", "id": "findings.F-05.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-06 exception for cross-border transfer gap.", "id": "findings.F-06.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's id from /workspace/documents/02_processing_records/016_processing_records_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_retention_deletion/064_retention_deletion_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's issue from /workspace/documents/02_processing_records/016_processing_records_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_retention_deletion/064_retention_deletion_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's severity from /workspace/documents/02_processing_records/016_processing_records_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_retention_deletion/064_retention_deletion_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's primary_source from /workspace/documents/02_processing_records/016_processing_records_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_retention_deletion/064_retention_deletion_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/02_processing_records/016_processing_records_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_retention_deletion/064_retention_deletion_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-06 using the exact controlled facts ['7%', '10%'].", "id": "findings.F-06.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-06's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-06.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-30', 'Sofia Bennett'] for F-06.", "id": "findings.F-06.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-07 exception for retention schedule conflict.", "id": "findings.F-07.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's id from /workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/019_vendor_reviews_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_training/067_training_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's issue from /workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/019_vendor_reviews_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_training/067_training_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's severity from /workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/019_vendor_reviews_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_training/067_training_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's primary_source from /workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/019_vendor_reviews_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_training/067_training_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/019_vendor_reviews_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_training/067_training_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-07 using the exact controlled facts ['notices-inkwell_digital_publishing@example.test', 'archive-blue_quill_audience_systems@example.test'].", "id": "findings.F-07.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-07's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-07.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-30', 'Adrian Mensah'] for F-07.", "id": "findings.F-07.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-08 exception for deletion-job failure.", "id": "findings.F-08.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's id from /workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/022_vendor_reviews_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_training/070_training_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's issue from /workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/022_vendor_reviews_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_training/070_training_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's severity from /workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/022_vendor_reviews_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_training/070_training_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's primary_source from /workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/022_vendor_reviews_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_training/070_training_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/022_vendor_reviews_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_training/070_training_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-08 using the exact controlled facts ['70 records', '2025-11-01', '36 records', '2025-11-09'].", "id": "findings.F-08.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-08's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-08.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-30', 'Willa Novak'] for F-08.", "id": "findings.F-08.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-09 exception for access-request deadline.", "id": "findings.F-09.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's id from /workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/025_security_incidents_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_regulator_correspondence/073_regulator_correspondence_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's issue from /workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/025_security_incidents_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_regulator_correspondence/073_regulator_correspondence_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's severity from /workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/025_security_incidents_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_regulator_correspondence/073_regulator_correspondence_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's primary_source from /workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/025_security_incidents_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_regulator_correspondence/073_regulator_correspondence_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/025_security_incidents_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_regulator_correspondence/073_regulator_correspondence_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-09 using the exact controlled facts ['2026-02-05', 'CB-PR-3009-I258', '2026-03-20', 'CB-PR-3009-R250'].", "id": "findings.F-09.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-09's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-09.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-30', 'Theo Laurent'] for F-09.", "id": "findings.F-09.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-10 exception for identity-verification inconsistency.", "id": "findings.F-10.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's id from /workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/028_security_incidents_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_regulator_correspondence/076_regulator_correspondence_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's issue from /workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/028_security_incidents_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_regulator_correspondence/076_regulator_correspondence_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's severity from /workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/028_security_incidents_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_regulator_correspondence/076_regulator_correspondence_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's primary_source from /workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/028_security_incidents_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_regulator_correspondence/076_regulator_correspondence_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/028_security_incidents_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_regulator_correspondence/076_regulator_correspondence_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-10 using the exact controlled facts ['$986,589.00', '$1,149,678.00'].", "id": "findings.F-10.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-10's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-10.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-30', 'Amara Patel'] for F-10.", "id": "findings.F-10.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-11 exception for incident-notification clock.", "id": "findings.F-11.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's id from /workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/031_security_incidents_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_regulator_correspondence/079_regulator_correspondence_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's issue from /workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/031_security_incidents_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_regulator_correspondence/079_regulator_correspondence_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's severity from /workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/031_security_incidents_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_regulator_correspondence/079_regulator_correspondence_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's primary_source from /workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/031_security_incidents_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_regulator_correspondence/079_regulator_correspondence_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/031_security_incidents_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_regulator_correspondence/079_regulator_correspondence_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-11 using the exact controlled facts ['Nora Chen', 'Rafael Okafor'].", "id": "findings.F-11.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-11's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-11.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-30', 'Henry Cho'] for F-11.", "id": "findings.F-11.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-12 exception for risk-assessment omission.", "id": "findings.F-12.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's id from /workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/034_consumer_requests_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_risk_assessments/082_risk_assessments_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's issue from /workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/034_consumer_requests_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_risk_assessments/082_risk_assessments_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's severity from /workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/034_consumer_requests_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_risk_assessments/082_risk_assessments_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's primary_source from /workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/034_consumer_requests_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_risk_assessments/082_risk_assessments_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/034_consumer_requests_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_risk_assessments/082_risk_assessments_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-12 using the exact controlled facts ['closed without exception', 'CB-PR-3009-L860', 'open and escalated', 'CB-PR-3009-U227'].", "id": "findings.F-12.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-12's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-12.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-30', 'Nadine Flores'] for F-12.", "id": "findings.F-12.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-13 exception for sensitive-data classification.", "id": "findings.F-13.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's id from /workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/037_consumer_requests_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_risk_assessments/085_risk_assessments_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's issue from /workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/037_consumer_requests_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_risk_assessments/085_risk_assessments_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's severity from /workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/037_consumer_requests_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_risk_assessments/085_risk_assessments_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's primary_source from /workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/037_consumer_requests_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_risk_assessments/085_risk_assessments_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/037_consumer_requests_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_risk_assessments/085_risk_assessments_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-13 using the exact controlled facts ['Oregon Attorney General', 'Oregon'].", "id": "findings.F-13.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-13's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-13.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-30', 'Micah Sullivan'] for F-13.", "id": "findings.F-13.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-14 exception for minor-consent issue.", "id": "findings.F-14.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's id from /workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/040_consumer_requests_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_risk_assessments/088_risk_assessments_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's issue from /workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/040_consumer_requests_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_risk_assessments/088_risk_assessments_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's severity from /workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/040_consumer_requests_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_risk_assessments/088_risk_assessments_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's primary_source from /workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/040_consumer_requests_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_risk_assessments/088_risk_assessments_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/040_consumer_requests_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_risk_assessments/088_risk_assessments_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-14 using the exact controlled facts ['5%', '12%'].", "id": "findings.F-14.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-14's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-14.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-30', 'Farah Ibrahim'] for F-14.", "id": "findings.F-14.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-15 exception for training completion gap.", "id": "findings.F-15.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's id from /workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/043_notices_consents_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_remediation/091_remediation_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's issue from /workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/043_notices_consents_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_remediation/091_remediation_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's severity from /workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/043_notices_consents_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_remediation/091_remediation_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's primary_source from /workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/043_notices_consents_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_remediation/091_remediation_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/043_notices_consents_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_remediation/091_remediation_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-15 using the exact controlled facts ['notices-inkwell_digital_publishing@example.test', 'archive-blue_quill_audience_systems@example.test'].", "id": "findings.F-15.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-15's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-15.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-30', 'Owen Delgado'] for F-15.", "id": "findings.F-15.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-16 exception for regulator commitment overdue.", "id": "findings.F-16.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's id from /workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/046_notices_consents_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_remediation/094_remediation_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's issue from /workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/046_notices_consents_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_remediation/094_remediation_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's severity from /workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/046_notices_consents_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_remediation/094_remediation_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's primary_source from /workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/046_notices_consents_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_remediation/094_remediation_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/046_notices_consents_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_remediation/094_remediation_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-16 using the exact controlled facts ['113 records', '2025-03-09', '45 records', '2025-03-26'].", "id": "findings.F-16.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-16's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-16.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-30', 'Lena Varga'] for F-16.", "id": "findings.F-16.action_anchors"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Executive assessment' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Executive assessment"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Method and record coverage' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Method and record coverage"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Findings' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Findings"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Recommended next actions' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Recommended next actions"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Assumptions and limitations' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Assumptions and limitations"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-01 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-01"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-02 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-02"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-03 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-03"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-04 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-04"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-05 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-05"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-06 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-06"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-07 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-07"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-08 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-08"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-09 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-09"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-10 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-10"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-11 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-11"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-12 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-12"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-13 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-13"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-14 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-14"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-15 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-15"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-16 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-16"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Do not claim the production has no issues or that every record is consistent.", "id": "memo.forbidden_claims_absent"}], "decision_options": [{"id": "cross-source-reconciliation", "label": "Reconcile controlling and corroborating records", "reason": "The CB-PR-3009 production contains independently maintained records; a defensible answer must preserve each supported conflict and its cure owner.", "selected": true}, {"id": "latest-record-controls", "label": "Treat the latest record as controlling", "reason": "Timestamp recency does not establish legal priority, execution, or approval authority.", "selected": false}, {"id": "primary-records-only", "label": "Report primary records without reconciliation", "reason": "Primary records alone conceal the operational conflicts that create the actionable exceptions.", "selected": false}], "gates": ["all_evidence_read_in_full", "chain_of_custody_metadata_checked", "findings_criteria_complete", "memo_criteria_complete", "deliverables_written_through_mcp"], "metadata_checks": 8, "metric": "weighted_criteria_score", "minimum_tool_calls": 46, "required_deliverables": ["findings.json", "advice.md"], "required_document_reads": 33, "type": "deterministic", "weights": {"findings": 0.55, "memo": 0.2, "procedure": 0.25}}, "task_id": "cb100-069-inkwell-publishing", "task_name": "Inkwell subscriber request audit", "world_id": "counselbench-filesystem-mcp-v2"}
-{"context_files": ["task_files/cb100-070-jetstream-saas/01_data_inventory/001_data_inventory_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-070-jetstream-saas/01_data_inventory/002_data_inventory_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-070-jetstream-saas/01_data_inventory/003_data_inventory_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-070-jetstream-saas/01_data_inventory/004_data_inventory_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-070-jetstream-saas/01_data_inventory/005_data_inventory_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-070-jetstream-saas/01_data_inventory/006_data_inventory_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-070-jetstream-saas/01_data_inventory/007_data_inventory_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-070-jetstream-saas/01_data_inventory/008_data_inventory_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-070-jetstream-saas/02_processing_records/009_processing_records_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-070-jetstream-saas/02_processing_records/010_processing_records_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-070-jetstream-saas/02_processing_records/011_processing_records_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-070-jetstream-saas/02_processing_records/012_processing_records_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-070-jetstream-saas/02_processing_records/013_processing_records_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-070-jetstream-saas/02_processing_records/014_processing_records_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-070-jetstream-saas/02_processing_records/015_processing_records_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-070-jetstream-saas/02_processing_records/016_processing_records_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-070-jetstream-saas/03_vendor_reviews/017_vendor_reviews_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-070-jetstream-saas/03_vendor_reviews/018_vendor_reviews_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-070-jetstream-saas/03_vendor_reviews/019_vendor_reviews_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-070-jetstream-saas/03_vendor_reviews/020_vendor_reviews_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-070-jetstream-saas/03_vendor_reviews/021_vendor_reviews_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-070-jetstream-saas/03_vendor_reviews/022_vendor_reviews_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-070-jetstream-saas/03_vendor_reviews/023_vendor_reviews_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-070-jetstream-saas/03_vendor_reviews/024_vendor_reviews_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-070-jetstream-saas/04_security_incidents/025_security_incidents_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-070-jetstream-saas/04_security_incidents/026_security_incidents_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-070-jetstream-saas/04_security_incidents/027_security_incidents_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-070-jetstream-saas/04_security_incidents/028_security_incidents_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-070-jetstream-saas/04_security_incidents/029_security_incidents_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-070-jetstream-saas/04_security_incidents/030_security_incidents_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-070-jetstream-saas/04_security_incidents/031_security_incidents_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-070-jetstream-saas/04_security_incidents/032_security_incidents_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-070-jetstream-saas/05_consumer_requests/033_consumer_requests_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-070-jetstream-saas/05_consumer_requests/034_consumer_requests_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-070-jetstream-saas/05_consumer_requests/035_consumer_requests_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-070-jetstream-saas/05_consumer_requests/036_consumer_requests_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-070-jetstream-saas/05_consumer_requests/037_consumer_requests_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-070-jetstream-saas/05_consumer_requests/038_consumer_requests_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-070-jetstream-saas/05_consumer_requests/039_consumer_requests_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-070-jetstream-saas/05_consumer_requests/040_consumer_requests_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-070-jetstream-saas/06_notices_consents/041_notices_consents_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-070-jetstream-saas/06_notices_consents/042_notices_consents_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-070-jetstream-saas/06_notices_consents/043_notices_consents_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-070-jetstream-saas/06_notices_consents/044_notices_consents_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-070-jetstream-saas/06_notices_consents/045_notices_consents_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-070-jetstream-saas/06_notices_consents/046_notices_consents_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-070-jetstream-saas/06_notices_consents/047_notices_consents_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-070-jetstream-saas/06_notices_consents/048_notices_consents_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-070-jetstream-saas/07_transfer_mechanisms/049_transfer_mechanisms_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-070-jetstream-saas/07_transfer_mechanisms/050_transfer_mechanisms_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-070-jetstream-saas/07_transfer_mechanisms/051_transfer_mechanisms_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-070-jetstream-saas/07_transfer_mechanisms/052_transfer_mechanisms_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-070-jetstream-saas/07_transfer_mechanisms/053_transfer_mechanisms_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-070-jetstream-saas/07_transfer_mechanisms/054_transfer_mechanisms_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-070-jetstream-saas/07_transfer_mechanisms/055_transfer_mechanisms_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-070-jetstream-saas/07_transfer_mechanisms/056_transfer_mechanisms_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-070-jetstream-saas/08_retention_deletion/057_retention_deletion_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-070-jetstream-saas/08_retention_deletion/058_retention_deletion_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-070-jetstream-saas/08_retention_deletion/059_retention_deletion_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-070-jetstream-saas/08_retention_deletion/060_retention_deletion_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-070-jetstream-saas/08_retention_deletion/061_retention_deletion_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-070-jetstream-saas/08_retention_deletion/062_retention_deletion_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-070-jetstream-saas/08_retention_deletion/063_retention_deletion_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-070-jetstream-saas/08_retention_deletion/064_retention_deletion_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-070-jetstream-saas/09_training/065_training_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-070-jetstream-saas/09_training/066_training_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-070-jetstream-saas/09_training/067_training_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-070-jetstream-saas/09_training/068_training_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-070-jetstream-saas/09_training/069_training_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-070-jetstream-saas/09_training/070_training_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-070-jetstream-saas/09_training/071_training_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-070-jetstream-saas/09_training/072_training_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-070-jetstream-saas/10_regulator_correspondence/073_regulator_correspondence_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-070-jetstream-saas/10_regulator_correspondence/074_regulator_correspondence_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-070-jetstream-saas/10_regulator_correspondence/075_regulator_correspondence_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-070-jetstream-saas/10_regulator_correspondence/076_regulator_correspondence_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-070-jetstream-saas/10_regulator_correspondence/077_regulator_correspondence_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-070-jetstream-saas/10_regulator_correspondence/078_regulator_correspondence_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-070-jetstream-saas/10_regulator_correspondence/079_regulator_correspondence_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-070-jetstream-saas/10_regulator_correspondence/080_regulator_correspondence_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-070-jetstream-saas/11_risk_assessments/081_risk_assessments_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-070-jetstream-saas/11_risk_assessments/082_risk_assessments_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-070-jetstream-saas/11_risk_assessments/083_risk_assessments_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-070-jetstream-saas/11_risk_assessments/084_risk_assessments_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-070-jetstream-saas/11_risk_assessments/085_risk_assessments_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-070-jetstream-saas/11_risk_assessments/086_risk_assessments_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-070-jetstream-saas/11_risk_assessments/087_risk_assessments_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-070-jetstream-saas/11_risk_assessments/088_risk_assessments_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-070-jetstream-saas/12_remediation/089_remediation_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-070-jetstream-saas/12_remediation/090_remediation_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-070-jetstream-saas/12_remediation/091_remediation_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-070-jetstream-saas/12_remediation/092_remediation_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-070-jetstream-saas/12_remediation/093_remediation_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-070-jetstream-saas/12_remediation/094_remediation_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-070-jetstream-saas/12_remediation/095_remediation_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-070-jetstream-saas/12_remediation/096_remediation_status_report.md"], "gold_output": {"advice_markdown": "# Counsel advice — Jetstream regulator commitment check\n\n## Executive assessment\n\nFor Jetstream Enterprise SaaS matter CB-PR-3010, the review identified 16 source-supported exceptions requiring action before 2026-10-04. The assessment concerns Nimbus Hosting Europe GmbH and the supplied record for Utah.\n\n## Method and record coverage\n\nThe review inventoried all 96 production files, read the 33 controlling, corroborating, and control records, searched the email exports, and checked metadata for the designated chain-of-custody sample. Conclusions are limited to the synthetic production supplied for this benchmark matter.\n\n## Findings\n\n### F-01 — processing-purpose gap (critical)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for processing-purpose gap: one source states the operative date is 2025-10-21 under control reference CB-PR-3010-A631, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2025-11-29 under response reference CB-PR-3010-J279.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/001_data_inventory_control_register.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/07_transfer_mechanisms/049_transfer_mechanisms_control_register.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-10-04, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Mei Whitaker.\n\n### F-02 — notice-practice mismatch (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for notice-practice mismatch: one source states the controlling amount is $1,112,131.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $1,350,762.00.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/004_data_inventory_ledger_export.csv`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/07_transfer_mechanisms/052_transfer_mechanisms_ledger_export.csv`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-10-04, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Caleb Hassan.\n\n### F-03 — consent-record deficiency (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for consent-record deficiency: one source states approval is attributed to Dominic Alvarez as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Isaac Romero and contains no entry for Dominic Alvarez.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/007_data_inventory_officer_certificate.html`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/07_transfer_mechanisms/055_transfer_mechanisms_officer_certificate.html`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-10-04, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Leona Park.\n\n### F-04 — processor-contract omission (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for processor-contract omission: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-PR-3010-D617, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-PR-3010-M970.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/02_processing_records/010_processing_records_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/08_retention_deletion/058_retention_deletion_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-10-04, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Isaac Romero.\n\n### F-05 — subprocessor inventory mismatch (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for subprocessor inventory mismatch: one source states the applicable location is Utah Division of Consumer Protection, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to Utah operations outside Utah Division of Consumer Protection.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/02_processing_records/013_processing_records_review_memorandum.json`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/08_retention_deletion/061_retention_deletion_review_memorandum.json`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-10-04, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Sofia Bennett.\n\n### F-06 — cross-border transfer gap (low)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for cross-border transfer gap: one source states the threshold is 3% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 6% and produced a different exception result.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/02_processing_records/016_processing_records_status_report.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/08_retention_deletion/064_retention_deletion_status_report.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-10-04, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Adrian Mensah.\n\n### F-07 — retention schedule conflict (critical)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for retention schedule conflict: one source states formal notice must use notices-jetstream_enterprise_saas@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-nimbus_hosting_europe_gmbh@example.test.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/019_vendor_reviews_correspondence.eml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/09_training/067_training_correspondence.eml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-10-04, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Willa Novak.\n\n### F-08 — deletion-job failure (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for deletion-job failure: one source states the governed population contains 186 records through 2026-02-25, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 49 records through 2026-03-18.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/022_vendor_reviews_formal_notice.xml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/09_training/070_training_formal_notice.xml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-10-04, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Theo Laurent.\n\n### F-09 — access-request deadline (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for access-request deadline: one source states the operative date is 2025-03-24 under control reference CB-PR-3010-I960, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2025-04-01 under response reference CB-PR-3010-R304.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/025_security_incidents_control_register.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/10_regulator_correspondence/073_regulator_correspondence_control_register.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-10-04, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Amara Patel.\n\n### F-10 — identity-verification inconsistency (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for identity-verification inconsistency: one source states the controlling amount is $6,537,186.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $6,770,872.00.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/028_security_incidents_ledger_export.csv`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/10_regulator_correspondence/076_regulator_correspondence_ledger_export.csv`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-10-04, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Henry Cho.\n\n### F-11 — incident-notification clock (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for incident-notification clock: one source states approval is attributed to Dominic Alvarez as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Dominic Alvarez and contains no entry for Dominic Alvarez.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/031_security_incidents_officer_certificate.html`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/10_regulator_correspondence/079_regulator_correspondence_officer_certificate.html`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-10-04, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Nadine Flores.\n\n### F-12 — risk-assessment omission (low)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for risk-assessment omission: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-PR-3010-L978, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-PR-3010-U859.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/034_consumer_requests_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/11_risk_assessments/082_risk_assessments_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-10-04, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Micah Sullivan.\n\n### F-13 — sensitive-data classification (critical)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for sensitive-data classification: one source states the applicable location is Utah Division of Consumer Protection, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to Utah operations outside Utah Division of Consumer Protection.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/037_consumer_requests_review_memorandum.json`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/11_risk_assessments/085_risk_assessments_review_memorandum.json`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-10-04, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Farah Ibrahim.\n\n### F-14 — minor-consent issue (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for minor-consent issue: one source states the threshold is 4% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 10% and produced a different exception result.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/040_consumer_requests_status_report.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/11_risk_assessments/088_risk_assessments_status_report.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-10-04, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Owen Delgado.\n\n### F-15 — training completion gap (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for training completion gap: one source states formal notice must use notices-jetstream_enterprise_saas@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-nimbus_hosting_europe_gmbh@example.test.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/043_notices_consents_correspondence.eml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/12_remediation/091_remediation_correspondence.eml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-10-04, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Lena Varga.\n\n### F-16 — regulator commitment overdue (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for regulator commitment overdue: one source states the governed population contains 152 records through 2026-01-22, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 61 records through 2026-02-24.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/046_notices_consents_formal_notice.xml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/12_remediation/094_remediation_formal_notice.xml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-10-04, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Samuel Kim.\n\n## Recommended next actions\n\nSequence the critical and high findings first, assign the named owners, preserve the cited records, and document any resolution in the controlling matter register before the stated deadline.\n\n## Assumptions and limitations\n\nThis analysis is confined to task cb100-070-jetstream-saas and the supplied synthetic evidence. It does not rely on external facts, does not resolve disputed law, and is not legal advice for a real person or entity.\n", "findings": {"as_of": "2026-10-04", "findings": [{"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/07_transfer_mechanisms/049_transfer_mechanisms_control_register.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for processing-purpose gap: one source states the operative date is 2025-10-21 under control reference CB-PR-3010-A631, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2025-11-29 under response reference CB-PR-3010-J279.", "id": "F-01", "issue": "processing-purpose gap", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/001_data_inventory_control_register.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-10-04, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Mei Whitaker.", "severity": "critical"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/07_transfer_mechanisms/052_transfer_mechanisms_ledger_export.csv", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for notice-practice mismatch: one source states the controlling amount is $1,112,131.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $1,350,762.00.", "id": "F-02", "issue": "notice-practice mismatch", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/004_data_inventory_ledger_export.csv", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-10-04, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Caleb Hassan.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/07_transfer_mechanisms/055_transfer_mechanisms_officer_certificate.html", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for consent-record deficiency: one source states approval is attributed to Dominic Alvarez as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Isaac Romero and contains no entry for Dominic Alvarez.", "id": "F-03", "issue": "consent-record deficiency", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/007_data_inventory_officer_certificate.html", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-10-04, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Leona Park.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/08_retention_deletion/058_retention_deletion_executed_instrument.txt", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for processor-contract omission: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-PR-3010-D617, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-PR-3010-M970.", "id": "F-04", "issue": "processor-contract omission", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/02_processing_records/010_processing_records_executed_instrument.txt", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-10-04, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Isaac Romero.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/08_retention_deletion/061_retention_deletion_review_memorandum.json", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for subprocessor inventory mismatch: one source states the applicable location is Utah Division of Consumer Protection, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to Utah operations outside Utah Division of Consumer Protection.", "id": "F-05", "issue": "subprocessor inventory mismatch", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/02_processing_records/013_processing_records_review_memorandum.json", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-10-04, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Sofia Bennett.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/08_retention_deletion/064_retention_deletion_status_report.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for cross-border transfer gap: one source states the threshold is 3% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 6% and produced a different exception result.", "id": "F-06", "issue": "cross-border transfer gap", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/02_processing_records/016_processing_records_status_report.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-10-04, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Adrian Mensah.", "severity": "low"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/09_training/067_training_correspondence.eml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for retention schedule conflict: one source states formal notice must use notices-jetstream_enterprise_saas@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-nimbus_hosting_europe_gmbh@example.test.", "id": "F-07", "issue": "retention schedule conflict", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/019_vendor_reviews_correspondence.eml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-10-04, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Willa Novak.", "severity": "critical"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/09_training/070_training_formal_notice.xml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for deletion-job failure: one source states the governed population contains 186 records through 2026-02-25, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 49 records through 2026-03-18.", "id": "F-08", "issue": "deletion-job failure", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/022_vendor_reviews_formal_notice.xml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-10-04, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Theo Laurent.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/10_regulator_correspondence/073_regulator_correspondence_control_register.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for access-request deadline: one source states the operative date is 2025-03-24 under control reference CB-PR-3010-I960, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2025-04-01 under response reference CB-PR-3010-R304.", "id": "F-09", "issue": "access-request deadline", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/025_security_incidents_control_register.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-10-04, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Amara Patel.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/10_regulator_correspondence/076_regulator_correspondence_ledger_export.csv", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for identity-verification inconsistency: one source states the controlling amount is $6,537,186.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $6,770,872.00.", "id": "F-10", "issue": "identity-verification inconsistency", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/028_security_incidents_ledger_export.csv", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-10-04, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Henry Cho.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/10_regulator_correspondence/079_regulator_correspondence_officer_certificate.html", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for incident-notification clock: one source states approval is attributed to Dominic Alvarez as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Dominic Alvarez and contains no entry for Dominic Alvarez.", "id": "F-11", "issue": "incident-notification clock", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/031_security_incidents_officer_certificate.html", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-10-04, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Nadine Flores.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/11_risk_assessments/082_risk_assessments_executed_instrument.txt", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for risk-assessment omission: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-PR-3010-L978, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-PR-3010-U859.", "id": "F-12", "issue": "risk-assessment omission", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/034_consumer_requests_executed_instrument.txt", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-10-04, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Micah Sullivan.", "severity": "low"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/11_risk_assessments/085_risk_assessments_review_memorandum.json", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for sensitive-data classification: one source states the applicable location is Utah Division of Consumer Protection, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to Utah operations outside Utah Division of Consumer Protection.", "id": "F-13", "issue": "sensitive-data classification", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/037_consumer_requests_review_memorandum.json", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-10-04, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Farah Ibrahim.", "severity": "critical"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/11_risk_assessments/088_risk_assessments_status_report.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for minor-consent issue: one source states the threshold is 4% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 10% and produced a different exception result.", "id": "F-14", "issue": "minor-consent issue", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/040_consumer_requests_status_report.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-10-04, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Owen Delgado.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/091_remediation_correspondence.eml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for training completion gap: one source states formal notice must use notices-jetstream_enterprise_saas@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-nimbus_hosting_europe_gmbh@example.test.", "id": "F-15", "issue": "training completion gap", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/043_notices_consents_correspondence.eml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-10-04, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Lena Varga.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/094_remediation_formal_notice.xml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for regulator commitment overdue: one source states the governed population contains 152 records through 2026-01-22, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 61 records through 2026-02-24.", "id": "F-16", "issue": "regulator commitment overdue", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/046_notices_consents_formal_notice.xml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-10-04, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Samuel Kim.", "severity": "medium"}], "matter_number": "CB-PR-3010", "prepared_for": "Jetstream Enterprise SaaS", "schema_version": "1.0", "task_id": "cb100-070-jetstream-saas"}}, "metadata": {"benchmark": "CounselBench-100", "code_license": "Apache-2.0", "data_license": "CC-BY-4.0", "deadline": "2026-10-04", "document_count": 96, "jurisdiction": "Utah", "matter_number": "CB-PR-3010", "mcp_commit": "9a96ea6e5913736f92b88345bf51caeaaa8e719f", "mcp_package": "@modelcontextprotocol/server-filesystem@2026.7.10", "practice_area": "privacy-regulatory", "reference_tool_calls": 46, "required_evidence_reads": 33, "synthetic": true, "venue": "Utah Division of Consumer Protection", "version": "2.0.0"}, "prompt": "You are privacy and regulatory counsel for Jetstream Enterprise SaaS. The record contains amendments, exports, and correspondence from different custodians; reconcile them into an actionable counsel work product. A prior assurance requires vendor reviews and training that do not match current transfer, incident, and completion records. Decision due 2026-10-04. Utah law governs; Utah Division of Consumer Protection is the forum. Write for a supervising lawyer who will spot-check source paths and exact values. Work out the defensible position from the matter production and leave an audit-ready exception tracker and concise advice for the supervising lawyer. Keep confirmed conflicts separate from open questions, cite the records that actually control each conclusion, and do not fill gaps with outside facts.", "rubric": {"criteria": [{"category": "procedure", "description": "Complete at least 46 successful, argument-specific evidence and output calls.", "id": "procedure.minimum_successful_tool_calls"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Find and read the 33 controlling, corroborating, and work-product-control records in full.", "id": "procedure.all_evidence_read_in_full"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Inspect file metadata for the eight designated critical primary records before relying on them.", "id": "procedure.chain_of_custody_metadata_checked"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Confirm the sandbox's allowed document and output roots.", "id": "procedure.allowed_directories_checked"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Inventory all 96 records so the relevant sources are discovered among the context records.", "id": "procedure.recursive_inventory_completed"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Search the production for email evidence that may corroborate or contradict formal records.", "id": "procedure.targeted_search_completed"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Leave only findings.json and advice.md in the output workspace.", "id": "procedure.exact_deliverable_set"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Create both final work products through the sandbox MCP surface.", "id": "procedure.deliverables_written_through_mcp"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Produce findings.json as a valid JSON object.", "id": "findings.findings_is_object"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Report exactly 16 confirmed exceptions.", "id": "findings.findings_exact_count"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Use each stable finding ID exactly once.", "id": "findings.finding_ids_unique"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set schema_version to the released matter value '1.0'.", "id": "findings.top_level_schema_version"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set task_id to the released matter value 'cb100-070-jetstream-saas'.", "id": "findings.top_level_task_id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set matter_number to the released matter value 'CB-PR-3010'.", "id": "findings.top_level_matter_number"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set prepared_for to the released matter value 'Jetstream Enterprise SaaS'.", "id": "findings.top_level_prepared_for"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set as_of to the released matter value '2026-10-04'.", "id": "findings.top_level_as_of"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-01 exception for processing-purpose gap.", "id": "findings.F-01.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's id from /workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/001_data_inventory_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_transfer_mechanisms/049_transfer_mechanisms_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's issue from /workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/001_data_inventory_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_transfer_mechanisms/049_transfer_mechanisms_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's severity from /workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/001_data_inventory_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_transfer_mechanisms/049_transfer_mechanisms_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's primary_source from /workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/001_data_inventory_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_transfer_mechanisms/049_transfer_mechanisms_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/001_data_inventory_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_transfer_mechanisms/049_transfer_mechanisms_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-01 using the exact controlled facts ['2025-10-21', 'CB-PR-3010-A631', '2025-11-29', 'CB-PR-3010-J279'].", "id": "findings.F-01.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-01's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-01.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-10-04', 'Mei Whitaker'] for F-01.", "id": "findings.F-01.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-02 exception for notice-practice mismatch.", "id": "findings.F-02.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's id from /workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/004_data_inventory_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_transfer_mechanisms/052_transfer_mechanisms_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's issue from /workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/004_data_inventory_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_transfer_mechanisms/052_transfer_mechanisms_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's severity from /workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/004_data_inventory_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_transfer_mechanisms/052_transfer_mechanisms_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's primary_source from /workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/004_data_inventory_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_transfer_mechanisms/052_transfer_mechanisms_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/004_data_inventory_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_transfer_mechanisms/052_transfer_mechanisms_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-02 using the exact controlled facts ['$1,112,131.00', '$1,350,762.00'].", "id": "findings.F-02.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-02's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-02.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-10-04', 'Caleb Hassan'] for F-02.", "id": "findings.F-02.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-03 exception for consent-record deficiency.", "id": "findings.F-03.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's id from /workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/007_data_inventory_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_transfer_mechanisms/055_transfer_mechanisms_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's issue from /workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/007_data_inventory_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_transfer_mechanisms/055_transfer_mechanisms_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's severity from /workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/007_data_inventory_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_transfer_mechanisms/055_transfer_mechanisms_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's primary_source from /workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/007_data_inventory_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_transfer_mechanisms/055_transfer_mechanisms_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/007_data_inventory_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_transfer_mechanisms/055_transfer_mechanisms_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-03 using the exact controlled facts ['Dominic Alvarez', 'Isaac Romero'].", "id": "findings.F-03.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-03's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-03.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-10-04', 'Leona Park'] for F-03.", "id": "findings.F-03.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-04 exception for processor-contract omission.", "id": "findings.F-04.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's id from /workspace/documents/02_processing_records/010_processing_records_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_retention_deletion/058_retention_deletion_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's issue from /workspace/documents/02_processing_records/010_processing_records_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_retention_deletion/058_retention_deletion_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's severity from /workspace/documents/02_processing_records/010_processing_records_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_retention_deletion/058_retention_deletion_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's primary_source from /workspace/documents/02_processing_records/010_processing_records_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_retention_deletion/058_retention_deletion_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/02_processing_records/010_processing_records_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_retention_deletion/058_retention_deletion_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-04 using the exact controlled facts ['closed without exception', 'CB-PR-3010-D617', 'open and escalated', 'CB-PR-3010-M970'].", "id": "findings.F-04.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-04's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-04.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-10-04', 'Isaac Romero'] for F-04.", "id": "findings.F-04.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-05 exception for subprocessor inventory mismatch.", "id": "findings.F-05.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's id from /workspace/documents/02_processing_records/013_processing_records_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_retention_deletion/061_retention_deletion_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's issue from /workspace/documents/02_processing_records/013_processing_records_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_retention_deletion/061_retention_deletion_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's severity from /workspace/documents/02_processing_records/013_processing_records_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_retention_deletion/061_retention_deletion_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's primary_source from /workspace/documents/02_processing_records/013_processing_records_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_retention_deletion/061_retention_deletion_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/02_processing_records/013_processing_records_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_retention_deletion/061_retention_deletion_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-05 using the exact controlled facts ['Utah Division of Consumer Protection', 'Utah'].", "id": "findings.F-05.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-05's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-05.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-10-04', 'Sofia Bennett'] for F-05.", "id": "findings.F-05.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-06 exception for cross-border transfer gap.", "id": "findings.F-06.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's id from /workspace/documents/02_processing_records/016_processing_records_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_retention_deletion/064_retention_deletion_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's issue from /workspace/documents/02_processing_records/016_processing_records_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_retention_deletion/064_retention_deletion_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's severity from /workspace/documents/02_processing_records/016_processing_records_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_retention_deletion/064_retention_deletion_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's primary_source from /workspace/documents/02_processing_records/016_processing_records_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_retention_deletion/064_retention_deletion_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/02_processing_records/016_processing_records_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_retention_deletion/064_retention_deletion_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-06 using the exact controlled facts ['3%', '6%'].", "id": "findings.F-06.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-06's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-06.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-10-04', 'Adrian Mensah'] for F-06.", "id": "findings.F-06.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-07 exception for retention schedule conflict.", "id": "findings.F-07.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's id from /workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/019_vendor_reviews_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_training/067_training_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's issue from /workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/019_vendor_reviews_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_training/067_training_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's severity from /workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/019_vendor_reviews_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_training/067_training_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's primary_source from /workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/019_vendor_reviews_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_training/067_training_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/019_vendor_reviews_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_training/067_training_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-07 using the exact controlled facts ['notices-jetstream_enterprise_saas@example.test', 'archive-nimbus_hosting_europe_gmbh@example.test'].", "id": "findings.F-07.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-07's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-07.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-10-04', 'Willa Novak'] for F-07.", "id": "findings.F-07.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-08 exception for deletion-job failure.", "id": "findings.F-08.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's id from /workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/022_vendor_reviews_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_training/070_training_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's issue from /workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/022_vendor_reviews_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_training/070_training_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's severity from /workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/022_vendor_reviews_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_training/070_training_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's primary_source from /workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/022_vendor_reviews_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_training/070_training_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/022_vendor_reviews_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_training/070_training_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-08 using the exact controlled facts ['186 records', '2026-02-25', '49 records', '2026-03-18'].", "id": "findings.F-08.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-08's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-08.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-10-04', 'Theo Laurent'] for F-08.", "id": "findings.F-08.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-09 exception for access-request deadline.", "id": "findings.F-09.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's id from /workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/025_security_incidents_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_regulator_correspondence/073_regulator_correspondence_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's issue from /workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/025_security_incidents_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_regulator_correspondence/073_regulator_correspondence_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's severity from /workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/025_security_incidents_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_regulator_correspondence/073_regulator_correspondence_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's primary_source from /workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/025_security_incidents_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_regulator_correspondence/073_regulator_correspondence_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/025_security_incidents_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_regulator_correspondence/073_regulator_correspondence_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-09 using the exact controlled facts ['2025-03-24', 'CB-PR-3010-I960', '2025-04-01', 'CB-PR-3010-R304'].", "id": "findings.F-09.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-09's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-09.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-10-04', 'Amara Patel'] for F-09.", "id": "findings.F-09.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-10 exception for identity-verification inconsistency.", "id": "findings.F-10.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's id from /workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/028_security_incidents_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_regulator_correspondence/076_regulator_correspondence_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's issue from /workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/028_security_incidents_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_regulator_correspondence/076_regulator_correspondence_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's severity from /workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/028_security_incidents_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_regulator_correspondence/076_regulator_correspondence_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's primary_source from /workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/028_security_incidents_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_regulator_correspondence/076_regulator_correspondence_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/028_security_incidents_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_regulator_correspondence/076_regulator_correspondence_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-10 using the exact controlled facts ['$6,537,186.00', '$6,770,872.00'].", "id": "findings.F-10.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-10's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-10.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-10-04', 'Henry Cho'] for F-10.", "id": "findings.F-10.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-11 exception for incident-notification clock.", "id": "findings.F-11.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's id from /workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/031_security_incidents_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_regulator_correspondence/079_regulator_correspondence_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's issue from /workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/031_security_incidents_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_regulator_correspondence/079_regulator_correspondence_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's severity from /workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/031_security_incidents_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_regulator_correspondence/079_regulator_correspondence_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's primary_source from /workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/031_security_incidents_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_regulator_correspondence/079_regulator_correspondence_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/031_security_incidents_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_regulator_correspondence/079_regulator_correspondence_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-11 using the exact controlled facts ['Dominic Alvarez', 'Dominic Alvarez'].", "id": "findings.F-11.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-11's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-11.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-10-04', 'Nadine Flores'] for F-11.", "id": "findings.F-11.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-12 exception for risk-assessment omission.", "id": "findings.F-12.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's id from /workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/034_consumer_requests_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_risk_assessments/082_risk_assessments_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's issue from /workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/034_consumer_requests_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_risk_assessments/082_risk_assessments_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's severity from /workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/034_consumer_requests_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_risk_assessments/082_risk_assessments_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's primary_source from /workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/034_consumer_requests_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_risk_assessments/082_risk_assessments_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/034_consumer_requests_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_risk_assessments/082_risk_assessments_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-12 using the exact controlled facts ['closed without exception', 'CB-PR-3010-L978', 'open and escalated', 'CB-PR-3010-U859'].", "id": "findings.F-12.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-12's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-12.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-10-04', 'Micah Sullivan'] for F-12.", "id": "findings.F-12.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-13 exception for sensitive-data classification.", "id": "findings.F-13.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's id from /workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/037_consumer_requests_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_risk_assessments/085_risk_assessments_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's issue from /workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/037_consumer_requests_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_risk_assessments/085_risk_assessments_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's severity from /workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/037_consumer_requests_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_risk_assessments/085_risk_assessments_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's primary_source from /workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/037_consumer_requests_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_risk_assessments/085_risk_assessments_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/037_consumer_requests_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_risk_assessments/085_risk_assessments_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-13 using the exact controlled facts ['Utah Division of Consumer Protection', 'Utah'].", "id": "findings.F-13.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-13's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-13.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-10-04', 'Farah Ibrahim'] for F-13.", "id": "findings.F-13.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-14 exception for minor-consent issue.", "id": "findings.F-14.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's id from /workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/040_consumer_requests_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_risk_assessments/088_risk_assessments_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's issue from /workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/040_consumer_requests_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_risk_assessments/088_risk_assessments_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's severity from /workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/040_consumer_requests_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_risk_assessments/088_risk_assessments_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's primary_source from /workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/040_consumer_requests_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_risk_assessments/088_risk_assessments_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/040_consumer_requests_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_risk_assessments/088_risk_assessments_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-14 using the exact controlled facts ['4%', '10%'].", "id": "findings.F-14.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-14's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-14.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-10-04', 'Owen Delgado'] for F-14.", "id": "findings.F-14.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-15 exception for training completion gap.", "id": "findings.F-15.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's id from /workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/043_notices_consents_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_remediation/091_remediation_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's issue from /workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/043_notices_consents_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_remediation/091_remediation_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's severity from /workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/043_notices_consents_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_remediation/091_remediation_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's primary_source from /workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/043_notices_consents_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_remediation/091_remediation_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/043_notices_consents_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_remediation/091_remediation_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-15 using the exact controlled facts ['notices-jetstream_enterprise_saas@example.test', 'archive-nimbus_hosting_europe_gmbh@example.test'].", "id": "findings.F-15.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-15's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-15.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-10-04', 'Lena Varga'] for F-15.", "id": "findings.F-15.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-16 exception for regulator commitment overdue.", "id": "findings.F-16.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's id from /workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/046_notices_consents_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_remediation/094_remediation_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's issue from /workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/046_notices_consents_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_remediation/094_remediation_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's severity from /workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/046_notices_consents_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_remediation/094_remediation_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's primary_source from /workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/046_notices_consents_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_remediation/094_remediation_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/046_notices_consents_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_remediation/094_remediation_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-16 using the exact controlled facts ['152 records', '2026-01-22', '61 records', '2026-02-24'].", "id": "findings.F-16.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-16's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-16.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-10-04', 'Samuel Kim'] for F-16.", "id": "findings.F-16.action_anchors"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Executive assessment' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Executive assessment"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Method and record coverage' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Method and record coverage"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Findings' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Findings"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Recommended next actions' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Recommended next actions"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Assumptions and limitations' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Assumptions and limitations"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-01 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-01"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-02 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-02"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-03 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-03"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-04 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-04"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-05 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-05"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-06 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-06"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-07 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-07"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-08 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-08"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-09 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-09"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-10 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-10"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-11 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-11"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-12 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-12"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-13 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-13"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-14 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-14"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-15 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-15"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-16 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-16"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Do not claim the production has no issues or that every record is consistent.", "id": "memo.forbidden_claims_absent"}], "decision_options": [{"id": "cross-source-reconciliation", "label": "Reconcile controlling and corroborating records", "reason": "The CB-PR-3010 production contains independently maintained records; a defensible answer must preserve each supported conflict and its cure owner.", "selected": true}, {"id": "latest-record-controls", "label": "Treat the latest record as controlling", "reason": "Timestamp recency does not establish legal priority, execution, or approval authority.", "selected": false}, {"id": "primary-records-only", "label": "Report primary records without reconciliation", "reason": "Primary records alone conceal the operational conflicts that create the actionable exceptions.", "selected": false}], "gates": ["all_evidence_read_in_full", "chain_of_custody_metadata_checked", "findings_criteria_complete", "memo_criteria_complete", "deliverables_written_through_mcp"], "metadata_checks": 8, "metric": "weighted_criteria_score", "minimum_tool_calls": 46, "required_deliverables": ["findings.json", "advice.md"], "required_document_reads": 33, "type": "deterministic", "weights": {"findings": 0.55, "memo": 0.2, "procedure": 0.25}}, "task_id": "cb100-070-jetstream-saas", "task_name": "Jetstream regulator commitment check", "world_id": "counselbench-filesystem-mcp-v2"}
-{"context_files": ["task_files/cb100-071-alpine-delivery/01_handbooks_policies/001_handbooks_policies_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-071-alpine-delivery/01_handbooks_policies/002_handbooks_policies_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-071-alpine-delivery/01_handbooks_policies/003_handbooks_policies_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-071-alpine-delivery/01_handbooks_policies/004_handbooks_policies_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-071-alpine-delivery/01_handbooks_policies/005_handbooks_policies_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-071-alpine-delivery/01_handbooks_policies/006_handbooks_policies_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-071-alpine-delivery/01_handbooks_policies/007_handbooks_policies_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-071-alpine-delivery/01_handbooks_policies/008_handbooks_policies_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-071-alpine-delivery/02_personnel_records/009_personnel_records_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-071-alpine-delivery/02_personnel_records/010_personnel_records_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-071-alpine-delivery/02_personnel_records/011_personnel_records_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-071-alpine-delivery/02_personnel_records/012_personnel_records_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-071-alpine-delivery/02_personnel_records/013_personnel_records_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-071-alpine-delivery/02_personnel_records/014_personnel_records_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-071-alpine-delivery/02_personnel_records/015_personnel_records_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-071-alpine-delivery/02_personnel_records/016_personnel_records_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-071-alpine-delivery/03_payroll_time/017_payroll_time_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-071-alpine-delivery/03_payroll_time/018_payroll_time_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-071-alpine-delivery/03_payroll_time/019_payroll_time_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-071-alpine-delivery/03_payroll_time/020_payroll_time_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-071-alpine-delivery/03_payroll_time/021_payroll_time_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-071-alpine-delivery/03_payroll_time/022_payroll_time_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-071-alpine-delivery/03_payroll_time/023_payroll_time_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-071-alpine-delivery/03_payroll_time/024_payroll_time_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-071-alpine-delivery/04_compensation_equity/025_compensation_equity_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-071-alpine-delivery/04_compensation_equity/026_compensation_equity_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-071-alpine-delivery/04_compensation_equity/027_compensation_equity_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-071-alpine-delivery/04_compensation_equity/028_compensation_equity_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-071-alpine-delivery/04_compensation_equity/029_compensation_equity_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-071-alpine-delivery/04_compensation_equity/030_compensation_equity_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-071-alpine-delivery/04_compensation_equity/031_compensation_equity_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-071-alpine-delivery/04_compensation_equity/032_compensation_equity_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-071-alpine-delivery/05_leave_accommodation/033_leave_accommodation_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-071-alpine-delivery/05_leave_accommodation/034_leave_accommodation_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-071-alpine-delivery/05_leave_accommodation/035_leave_accommodation_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-071-alpine-delivery/05_leave_accommodation/036_leave_accommodation_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-071-alpine-delivery/05_leave_accommodation/037_leave_accommodation_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-071-alpine-delivery/05_leave_accommodation/038_leave_accommodation_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-071-alpine-delivery/05_leave_accommodation/039_leave_accommodation_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-071-alpine-delivery/05_leave_accommodation/040_leave_accommodation_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-071-alpine-delivery/06_complaints/041_complaints_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-071-alpine-delivery/06_complaints/042_complaints_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-071-alpine-delivery/06_complaints/043_complaints_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-071-alpine-delivery/06_complaints/044_complaints_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-071-alpine-delivery/06_complaints/045_complaints_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-071-alpine-delivery/06_complaints/046_complaints_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-071-alpine-delivery/06_complaints/047_complaints_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-071-alpine-delivery/06_complaints/048_complaints_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-071-alpine-delivery/07_investigations/049_investigations_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-071-alpine-delivery/07_investigations/050_investigations_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-071-alpine-delivery/07_investigations/051_investigations_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-071-alpine-delivery/07_investigations/052_investigations_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-071-alpine-delivery/07_investigations/053_investigations_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-071-alpine-delivery/07_investigations/054_investigations_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-071-alpine-delivery/07_investigations/055_investigations_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-071-alpine-delivery/07_investigations/056_investigations_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-071-alpine-delivery/08_performance_discipline/057_performance_discipline_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-071-alpine-delivery/08_performance_discipline/058_performance_discipline_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-071-alpine-delivery/08_performance_discipline/059_performance_discipline_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-071-alpine-delivery/08_performance_discipline/060_performance_discipline_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-071-alpine-delivery/08_performance_discipline/061_performance_discipline_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-071-alpine-delivery/08_performance_discipline/062_performance_discipline_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-071-alpine-delivery/08_performance_discipline/063_performance_discipline_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-071-alpine-delivery/08_performance_discipline/064_performance_discipline_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-071-alpine-delivery/09_separation/065_separation_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-071-alpine-delivery/09_separation/066_separation_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-071-alpine-delivery/09_separation/067_separation_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-071-alpine-delivery/09_separation/068_separation_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-071-alpine-delivery/09_separation/069_separation_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-071-alpine-delivery/09_separation/070_separation_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-071-alpine-delivery/09_separation/071_separation_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-071-alpine-delivery/09_separation/072_separation_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-071-alpine-delivery/10_contractors/073_contractors_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-071-alpine-delivery/10_contractors/074_contractors_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-071-alpine-delivery/10_contractors/075_contractors_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-071-alpine-delivery/10_contractors/076_contractors_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-071-alpine-delivery/10_contractors/077_contractors_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-071-alpine-delivery/10_contractors/078_contractors_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-071-alpine-delivery/10_contractors/079_contractors_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-071-alpine-delivery/10_contractors/080_contractors_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-071-alpine-delivery/11_training/081_training_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-071-alpine-delivery/11_training/082_training_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-071-alpine-delivery/11_training/083_training_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-071-alpine-delivery/11_training/084_training_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-071-alpine-delivery/11_training/085_training_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-071-alpine-delivery/11_training/086_training_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-071-alpine-delivery/11_training/087_training_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-071-alpine-delivery/11_training/088_training_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-071-alpine-delivery/12_agency_matters/089_agency_matters_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-071-alpine-delivery/12_agency_matters/090_agency_matters_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-071-alpine-delivery/12_agency_matters/091_agency_matters_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-071-alpine-delivery/12_agency_matters/092_agency_matters_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-071-alpine-delivery/12_agency_matters/093_agency_matters_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-071-alpine-delivery/12_agency_matters/094_agency_matters_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-071-alpine-delivery/12_agency_matters/095_agency_matters_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-071-alpine-delivery/12_agency_matters/096_agency_matters_status_report.md"], "gold_output": {"advice_markdown": "# Counsel advice — Alpine courier classification audit\n\n## Executive assessment\n\nFor Alpine Same-Day Delivery matter CB-EL-3101, the review identified 16 source-supported exceptions requiring action before 2026-09-05. The assessment concerns Mountain West Couriers Association and the supplied record for Colorado.\n\n## Method and record coverage\n\nThe review inventoried all 96 production files, read the 33 controlling, corroborating, and control records, searched the email exports, and checked metadata for the designated chain-of-custody sample. Conclusions are limited to the synthetic production supplied for this benchmark matter.\n\n## Findings\n\n### F-01 — classification inconsistency (critical)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for classification inconsistency: one source states the operative date is 2025-05-05 under control reference CB-EL-3101-A942, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2025-06-12 under response reference CB-EL-3101-J510.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/001_handbooks_policies_control_register.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/07_investigations/049_investigations_control_register.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-05, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Caleb Hassan.\n\n### F-02 — overtime calculation error (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for overtime calculation error: one source states the controlling amount is $3,977,034.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $4,080,568.00.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/004_handbooks_policies_ledger_export.csv`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/07_investigations/052_investigations_ledger_export.csv`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-05, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Leona Park.\n\n### F-03 — meal-period premium gap (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for meal-period premium gap: one source states approval is attributed to Priya Raman as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Adrian Mensah and contains no entry for Priya Raman.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/007_handbooks_policies_officer_certificate.html`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/07_investigations/055_investigations_officer_certificate.html`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-05, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Isaac Romero.\n\n### F-04 — pay-equity outlier (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for pay-equity outlier: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-EL-3101-D544, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-EL-3101-M757.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/010_personnel_records_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/08_performance_discipline/058_performance_discipline_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-05, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Sofia Bennett.\n\n### F-05 — leave designation delay (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for leave designation delay: one source states the applicable location is Colorado Department of Labor and Employment, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to Colorado operations outside Colorado Department of Labor and Employment.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/013_personnel_records_review_memorandum.json`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/08_performance_discipline/061_performance_discipline_review_memorandum.json`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-05, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Adrian Mensah.\n\n### F-06 — interactive-process lapse (low)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for interactive-process lapse: one source states the threshold is 6% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 12% and produced a different exception result.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/016_personnel_records_status_report.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/08_performance_discipline/064_performance_discipline_status_report.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-05, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Willa Novak.\n\n### F-07 — complaint escalation gap (critical)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for complaint escalation gap: one source states formal notice must use notices-alpine_same_day_delivery@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-mountain_west_couriers_association@example.test.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/019_payroll_time_correspondence.eml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/09_separation/067_separation_correspondence.eml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-05, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Theo Laurent.\n\n### F-08 — investigation independence concern (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for investigation independence concern: one source states the governed population contains 99 records through 2025-07-13, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 56 records through 2025-08-10.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/022_payroll_time_formal_notice.xml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/09_separation/070_separation_formal_notice.xml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-05, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Amara Patel.\n\n### F-09 — discipline comparator inconsistency (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for discipline comparator inconsistency: one source states the operative date is 2025-09-13 under control reference CB-EL-3101-I113, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2025-09-21 under response reference CB-EL-3101-R516.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/025_compensation_equity_control_register.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/10_contractors/073_contractors_control_register.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-05, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Henry Cho.\n\n### F-10 — retaliation timing (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for retaliation timing: one source states the controlling amount is $7,024,227.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $7,194,954.00.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/028_compensation_equity_ledger_export.csv`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/10_contractors/076_contractors_ledger_export.csv`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-05, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Nadine Flores.\n\n### F-11 — separation pay discrepancy (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for separation pay discrepancy: one source states approval is attributed to Priya Raman as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Elliot Mercer and contains no entry for Priya Raman.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/031_compensation_equity_officer_certificate.html`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/10_contractors/079_contractors_officer_certificate.html`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-05, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Micah Sullivan.\n\n### F-12 — restrictive-covenant conflict (low)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for restrictive-covenant conflict: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-EL-3101-L261, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-EL-3101-U112.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/034_leave_accommodation_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/11_training/082_training_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-05, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Farah Ibrahim.\n\n### F-13 — contractor control evidence (critical)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for contractor control evidence: one source states the applicable location is Colorado Department of Labor and Employment, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to Colorado operations outside Colorado Department of Labor and Employment.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/037_leave_accommodation_review_memorandum.json`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/11_training/085_training_review_memorandum.json`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-05, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Owen Delgado.\n\n### F-14 — training completion gap (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for training completion gap: one source states the threshold is 5% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 10% and produced a different exception result.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/040_leave_accommodation_status_report.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/11_training/088_training_status_report.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-05, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Lena Varga.\n\n### F-15 — personnel-file access deadline (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for personnel-file access deadline: one source states formal notice must use notices-alpine_same_day_delivery@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-mountain_west_couriers_association@example.test.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/06_complaints/043_complaints_correspondence.eml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/091_agency_matters_correspondence.eml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-05, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Samuel Kim.\n\n### F-16 — agency response commitment (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for agency response commitment: one source states the governed population contains 58 records through 2025-10-20, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 64 records through 2025-11-25.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/06_complaints/046_complaints_formal_notice.xml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/094_agency_matters_formal_notice.xml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-05, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Maya Ellison.\n\n## Recommended next actions\n\nSequence the critical and high findings first, assign the named owners, preserve the cited records, and document any resolution in the controlling matter register before the stated deadline.\n\n## Assumptions and limitations\n\nThis analysis is confined to task cb100-071-alpine-delivery and the supplied synthetic evidence. It does not rely on external facts, does not resolve disputed law, and is not legal advice for a real person or entity.\n", "findings": {"as_of": "2026-09-05", "findings": [{"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/07_investigations/049_investigations_control_register.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for classification inconsistency: one source states the operative date is 2025-05-05 under control reference CB-EL-3101-A942, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2025-06-12 under response reference CB-EL-3101-J510.", "id": "F-01", "issue": "classification inconsistency", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/001_handbooks_policies_control_register.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-05, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Caleb Hassan.", "severity": "critical"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/07_investigations/052_investigations_ledger_export.csv", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for overtime calculation error: one source states the controlling amount is $3,977,034.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $4,080,568.00.", "id": "F-02", "issue": "overtime calculation error", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/004_handbooks_policies_ledger_export.csv", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-05, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Leona Park.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/07_investigations/055_investigations_officer_certificate.html", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for meal-period premium gap: one source states approval is attributed to Priya Raman as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Adrian Mensah and contains no entry for Priya Raman.", "id": "F-03", "issue": "meal-period premium gap", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/007_handbooks_policies_officer_certificate.html", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-05, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Isaac Romero.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/08_performance_discipline/058_performance_discipline_executed_instrument.txt", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for pay-equity outlier: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-EL-3101-D544, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-EL-3101-M757.", "id": "F-04", "issue": "pay-equity outlier", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/010_personnel_records_executed_instrument.txt", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-05, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Sofia Bennett.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/08_performance_discipline/061_performance_discipline_review_memorandum.json", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for leave designation delay: one source states the applicable location is Colorado Department of Labor and Employment, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to Colorado operations outside Colorado Department of Labor and Employment.", "id": "F-05", "issue": "leave designation delay", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/013_personnel_records_review_memorandum.json", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-05, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Adrian Mensah.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/08_performance_discipline/064_performance_discipline_status_report.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for interactive-process lapse: one source states the threshold is 6% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 12% and produced a different exception result.", "id": "F-06", "issue": "interactive-process lapse", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/016_personnel_records_status_report.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-05, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Willa Novak.", "severity": "low"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/09_separation/067_separation_correspondence.eml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for complaint escalation gap: one source states formal notice must use notices-alpine_same_day_delivery@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-mountain_west_couriers_association@example.test.", "id": "F-07", "issue": "complaint escalation gap", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/019_payroll_time_correspondence.eml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-05, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Theo Laurent.", "severity": "critical"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/09_separation/070_separation_formal_notice.xml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for investigation independence concern: one source states the governed population contains 99 records through 2025-07-13, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 56 records through 2025-08-10.", "id": "F-08", "issue": "investigation independence concern", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/022_payroll_time_formal_notice.xml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-05, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Amara Patel.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/10_contractors/073_contractors_control_register.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for discipline comparator inconsistency: one source states the operative date is 2025-09-13 under control reference CB-EL-3101-I113, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2025-09-21 under response reference CB-EL-3101-R516.", "id": "F-09", "issue": "discipline comparator inconsistency", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/025_compensation_equity_control_register.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-05, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Henry Cho.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/10_contractors/076_contractors_ledger_export.csv", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for retaliation timing: one source states the controlling amount is $7,024,227.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $7,194,954.00.", "id": "F-10", "issue": "retaliation timing", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/028_compensation_equity_ledger_export.csv", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-05, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Nadine Flores.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/10_contractors/079_contractors_officer_certificate.html", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for separation pay discrepancy: one source states approval is attributed to Priya Raman as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Elliot Mercer and contains no entry for Priya Raman.", "id": "F-11", "issue": "separation pay discrepancy", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/031_compensation_equity_officer_certificate.html", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-05, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Micah Sullivan.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/11_training/082_training_executed_instrument.txt", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for restrictive-covenant conflict: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-EL-3101-L261, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-EL-3101-U112.", "id": "F-12", "issue": "restrictive-covenant conflict", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/034_leave_accommodation_executed_instrument.txt", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-05, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Farah Ibrahim.", "severity": "low"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/11_training/085_training_review_memorandum.json", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for contractor control evidence: one source states the applicable location is Colorado Department of Labor and Employment, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to Colorado operations outside Colorado Department of Labor and Employment.", "id": "F-13", "issue": "contractor control evidence", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/037_leave_accommodation_review_memorandum.json", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-05, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Owen Delgado.", "severity": "critical"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/11_training/088_training_status_report.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for training completion gap: one source states the threshold is 5% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 10% and produced a different exception result.", "id": "F-14", "issue": "training completion gap", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/040_leave_accommodation_status_report.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-05, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Lena Varga.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/091_agency_matters_correspondence.eml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for personnel-file access deadline: one source states formal notice must use notices-alpine_same_day_delivery@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-mountain_west_couriers_association@example.test.", "id": "F-15", "issue": "personnel-file access deadline", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/06_complaints/043_complaints_correspondence.eml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-05, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Samuel Kim.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/094_agency_matters_formal_notice.xml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for agency response commitment: one source states the governed population contains 58 records through 2025-10-20, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 64 records through 2025-11-25.", "id": "F-16", "issue": "agency response commitment", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/06_complaints/046_complaints_formal_notice.xml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-05, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Maya Ellison.", "severity": "medium"}], "matter_number": "CB-EL-3101", "prepared_for": "Alpine Same-Day Delivery", "schema_version": "1.0", "task_id": "cb100-071-alpine-delivery"}}, "metadata": {"benchmark": "CounselBench-100", "code_license": "Apache-2.0", "data_license": "CC-BY-4.0", "deadline": "2026-09-05", "document_count": 96, "jurisdiction": "Colorado", "matter_number": "CB-EL-3101", "mcp_commit": "9a96ea6e5913736f92b88345bf51caeaaa8e719f", "mcp_package": "@modelcontextprotocol/server-filesystem@2026.7.10", "practice_area": "employment", "reference_tool_calls": 46, "required_evidence_reads": 33, "synthetic": true, "venue": "Colorado Department of Labor and Employment", "version": "2.0.0"}, "prompt": "You are employment counsel for Alpine Same-Day Delivery. The partner responsible for this matter needs a defensible decision record before the next client call. Courier contracts describe independence while routing, discipline, time, and equipment records show centralized control. Decision due 2026-09-05. Colorado law governs; Colorado Department of Labor and Employment is the forum. Prioritize conflicts between signed instruments and later operational records. Work out the defensible position from the matter production and leave an audit-ready exception tracker and concise advice for the supervising lawyer. Keep confirmed conflicts separate from open questions, cite the records that actually control each conclusion, and do not fill gaps with outside facts.", "rubric": {"criteria": [{"category": "procedure", "description": "Complete at least 46 successful, argument-specific evidence and output calls.", "id": "procedure.minimum_successful_tool_calls"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Find and read the 33 controlling, corroborating, and work-product-control records in full.", "id": "procedure.all_evidence_read_in_full"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Inspect file metadata for the eight designated critical primary records before relying on them.", "id": "procedure.chain_of_custody_metadata_checked"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Confirm the sandbox's allowed document and output roots.", "id": "procedure.allowed_directories_checked"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Inventory all 96 records so the relevant sources are discovered among the context records.", "id": "procedure.recursive_inventory_completed"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Search the production for email evidence that may corroborate or contradict formal records.", "id": "procedure.targeted_search_completed"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Leave only findings.json and advice.md in the output workspace.", "id": "procedure.exact_deliverable_set"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Create both final work products through the sandbox MCP surface.", "id": "procedure.deliverables_written_through_mcp"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Produce findings.json as a valid JSON object.", "id": "findings.findings_is_object"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Report exactly 16 confirmed exceptions.", "id": "findings.findings_exact_count"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Use each stable finding ID exactly once.", "id": "findings.finding_ids_unique"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set schema_version to the released matter value '1.0'.", "id": "findings.top_level_schema_version"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set task_id to the released matter value 'cb100-071-alpine-delivery'.", "id": "findings.top_level_task_id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set matter_number to the released matter value 'CB-EL-3101'.", "id": "findings.top_level_matter_number"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set prepared_for to the released matter value 'Alpine Same-Day Delivery'.", "id": "findings.top_level_prepared_for"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set as_of to the released matter value '2026-09-05'.", "id": "findings.top_level_as_of"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-01 exception for classification inconsistency.", "id": "findings.F-01.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's id from /workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/001_handbooks_policies_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_investigations/049_investigations_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's issue from /workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/001_handbooks_policies_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_investigations/049_investigations_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's severity from /workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/001_handbooks_policies_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_investigations/049_investigations_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's primary_source from /workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/001_handbooks_policies_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_investigations/049_investigations_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/001_handbooks_policies_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_investigations/049_investigations_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-01 using the exact controlled facts ['2025-05-05', 'CB-EL-3101-A942', '2025-06-12', 'CB-EL-3101-J510'].", "id": "findings.F-01.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-01's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-01.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-05', 'Caleb Hassan'] for F-01.", "id": "findings.F-01.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-02 exception for overtime calculation error.", "id": "findings.F-02.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's id from /workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/004_handbooks_policies_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_investigations/052_investigations_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's issue from /workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/004_handbooks_policies_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_investigations/052_investigations_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's severity from /workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/004_handbooks_policies_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_investigations/052_investigations_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's primary_source from /workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/004_handbooks_policies_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_investigations/052_investigations_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/004_handbooks_policies_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_investigations/052_investigations_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-02 using the exact controlled facts ['$3,977,034.00', '$4,080,568.00'].", "id": "findings.F-02.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-02's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-02.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-05', 'Leona Park'] for F-02.", "id": "findings.F-02.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-03 exception for meal-period premium gap.", "id": "findings.F-03.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's id from /workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/007_handbooks_policies_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_investigations/055_investigations_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's issue from /workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/007_handbooks_policies_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_investigations/055_investigations_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's severity from /workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/007_handbooks_policies_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_investigations/055_investigations_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's primary_source from /workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/007_handbooks_policies_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_investigations/055_investigations_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/007_handbooks_policies_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_investigations/055_investigations_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-03 using the exact controlled facts ['Priya Raman', 'Adrian Mensah'].", "id": "findings.F-03.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-03's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-03.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-05', 'Isaac Romero'] for F-03.", "id": "findings.F-03.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-04 exception for pay-equity outlier.", "id": "findings.F-04.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's id from /workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/010_personnel_records_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_performance_discipline/058_performance_discipline_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's issue from /workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/010_personnel_records_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_performance_discipline/058_performance_discipline_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's severity from /workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/010_personnel_records_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_performance_discipline/058_performance_discipline_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's primary_source from /workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/010_personnel_records_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_performance_discipline/058_performance_discipline_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/010_personnel_records_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_performance_discipline/058_performance_discipline_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-04 using the exact controlled facts ['closed without exception', 'CB-EL-3101-D544', 'open and escalated', 'CB-EL-3101-M757'].", "id": "findings.F-04.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-04's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-04.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-05', 'Sofia Bennett'] for F-04.", "id": "findings.F-04.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-05 exception for leave designation delay.", "id": "findings.F-05.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's id from /workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/013_personnel_records_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_performance_discipline/061_performance_discipline_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's issue from /workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/013_personnel_records_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_performance_discipline/061_performance_discipline_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's severity from /workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/013_personnel_records_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_performance_discipline/061_performance_discipline_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's primary_source from /workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/013_personnel_records_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_performance_discipline/061_performance_discipline_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/013_personnel_records_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_performance_discipline/061_performance_discipline_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-05 using the exact controlled facts ['Colorado Department of Labor and Employment', 'Colorado'].", "id": "findings.F-05.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-05's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-05.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-05', 'Adrian Mensah'] for F-05.", "id": "findings.F-05.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-06 exception for interactive-process lapse.", "id": "findings.F-06.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's id from /workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/016_personnel_records_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_performance_discipline/064_performance_discipline_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's issue from /workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/016_personnel_records_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_performance_discipline/064_performance_discipline_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's severity from /workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/016_personnel_records_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_performance_discipline/064_performance_discipline_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's primary_source from /workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/016_personnel_records_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_performance_discipline/064_performance_discipline_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/016_personnel_records_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_performance_discipline/064_performance_discipline_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-06 using the exact controlled facts ['6%', '12%'].", "id": "findings.F-06.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-06's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-06.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-05', 'Willa Novak'] for F-06.", "id": "findings.F-06.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-07 exception for complaint escalation gap.", "id": "findings.F-07.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's id from /workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/019_payroll_time_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_separation/067_separation_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's issue from /workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/019_payroll_time_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_separation/067_separation_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's severity from /workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/019_payroll_time_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_separation/067_separation_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's primary_source from /workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/019_payroll_time_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_separation/067_separation_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/019_payroll_time_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_separation/067_separation_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-07 using the exact controlled facts ['notices-alpine_same_day_delivery@example.test', 'archive-mountain_west_couriers_association@example.test'].", "id": "findings.F-07.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-07's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-07.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-05', 'Theo Laurent'] for F-07.", "id": "findings.F-07.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-08 exception for investigation independence concern.", "id": "findings.F-08.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's id from /workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/022_payroll_time_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_separation/070_separation_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's issue from /workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/022_payroll_time_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_separation/070_separation_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's severity from /workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/022_payroll_time_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_separation/070_separation_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's primary_source from /workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/022_payroll_time_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_separation/070_separation_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/022_payroll_time_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_separation/070_separation_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-08 using the exact controlled facts ['99 records', '2025-07-13', '56 records', '2025-08-10'].", "id": "findings.F-08.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-08's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-08.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-05', 'Amara Patel'] for F-08.", "id": "findings.F-08.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-09 exception for discipline comparator inconsistency.", "id": "findings.F-09.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's id from /workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/025_compensation_equity_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_contractors/073_contractors_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's issue from /workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/025_compensation_equity_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_contractors/073_contractors_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's severity from /workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/025_compensation_equity_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_contractors/073_contractors_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's primary_source from /workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/025_compensation_equity_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_contractors/073_contractors_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/025_compensation_equity_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_contractors/073_contractors_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-09 using the exact controlled facts ['2025-09-13', 'CB-EL-3101-I113', '2025-09-21', 'CB-EL-3101-R516'].", "id": "findings.F-09.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-09's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-09.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-05', 'Henry Cho'] for F-09.", "id": "findings.F-09.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-10 exception for retaliation timing.", "id": "findings.F-10.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's id from /workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/028_compensation_equity_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_contractors/076_contractors_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's issue from /workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/028_compensation_equity_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_contractors/076_contractors_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's severity from /workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/028_compensation_equity_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_contractors/076_contractors_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's primary_source from /workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/028_compensation_equity_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_contractors/076_contractors_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/028_compensation_equity_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_contractors/076_contractors_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-10 using the exact controlled facts ['$7,024,227.00', '$7,194,954.00'].", "id": "findings.F-10.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-10's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-10.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-05', 'Nadine Flores'] for F-10.", "id": "findings.F-10.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-11 exception for separation pay discrepancy.", "id": "findings.F-11.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's id from /workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/031_compensation_equity_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_contractors/079_contractors_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's issue from /workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/031_compensation_equity_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_contractors/079_contractors_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's severity from /workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/031_compensation_equity_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_contractors/079_contractors_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's primary_source from /workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/031_compensation_equity_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_contractors/079_contractors_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/031_compensation_equity_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_contractors/079_contractors_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-11 using the exact controlled facts ['Priya Raman', 'Elliot Mercer'].", "id": "findings.F-11.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-11's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-11.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-05', 'Micah Sullivan'] for F-11.", "id": "findings.F-11.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-12 exception for restrictive-covenant conflict.", "id": "findings.F-12.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's id from /workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/034_leave_accommodation_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_training/082_training_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's issue from /workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/034_leave_accommodation_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_training/082_training_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's severity from /workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/034_leave_accommodation_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_training/082_training_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's primary_source from /workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/034_leave_accommodation_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_training/082_training_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/034_leave_accommodation_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_training/082_training_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-12 using the exact controlled facts ['closed without exception', 'CB-EL-3101-L261', 'open and escalated', 'CB-EL-3101-U112'].", "id": "findings.F-12.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-12's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-12.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-05', 'Farah Ibrahim'] for F-12.", "id": "findings.F-12.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-13 exception for contractor control evidence.", "id": "findings.F-13.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's id from /workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/037_leave_accommodation_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_training/085_training_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's issue from /workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/037_leave_accommodation_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_training/085_training_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's severity from /workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/037_leave_accommodation_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_training/085_training_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's primary_source from /workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/037_leave_accommodation_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_training/085_training_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/037_leave_accommodation_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_training/085_training_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-13 using the exact controlled facts ['Colorado Department of Labor and Employment', 'Colorado'].", "id": "findings.F-13.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-13's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-13.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-05', 'Owen Delgado'] for F-13.", "id": "findings.F-13.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-14 exception for training completion gap.", "id": "findings.F-14.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's id from /workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/040_leave_accommodation_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_training/088_training_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's issue from /workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/040_leave_accommodation_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_training/088_training_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's severity from /workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/040_leave_accommodation_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_training/088_training_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's primary_source from /workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/040_leave_accommodation_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_training/088_training_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/040_leave_accommodation_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_training/088_training_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-14 using the exact controlled facts ['5%', '10%'].", "id": "findings.F-14.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-14's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-14.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-05', 'Lena Varga'] for F-14.", "id": "findings.F-14.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-15 exception for personnel-file access deadline.", "id": "findings.F-15.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's id from /workspace/documents/06_complaints/043_complaints_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/091_agency_matters_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's issue from /workspace/documents/06_complaints/043_complaints_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/091_agency_matters_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's severity from /workspace/documents/06_complaints/043_complaints_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/091_agency_matters_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's primary_source from /workspace/documents/06_complaints/043_complaints_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/091_agency_matters_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/06_complaints/043_complaints_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/091_agency_matters_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-15 using the exact controlled facts ['notices-alpine_same_day_delivery@example.test', 'archive-mountain_west_couriers_association@example.test'].", "id": "findings.F-15.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-15's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-15.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-05', 'Samuel Kim'] for F-15.", "id": "findings.F-15.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-16 exception for agency response commitment.", "id": "findings.F-16.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's id from /workspace/documents/06_complaints/046_complaints_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/094_agency_matters_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's issue from /workspace/documents/06_complaints/046_complaints_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/094_agency_matters_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's severity from /workspace/documents/06_complaints/046_complaints_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/094_agency_matters_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's primary_source from /workspace/documents/06_complaints/046_complaints_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/094_agency_matters_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/06_complaints/046_complaints_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/094_agency_matters_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-16 using the exact controlled facts ['58 records', '2025-10-20', '64 records', '2025-11-25'].", "id": "findings.F-16.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-16's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-16.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-05', 'Maya Ellison'] for F-16.", "id": "findings.F-16.action_anchors"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Executive assessment' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Executive assessment"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Method and record coverage' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Method and record coverage"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Findings' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Findings"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Recommended next actions' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Recommended next actions"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Assumptions and limitations' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Assumptions and limitations"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-01 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-01"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-02 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-02"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-03 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-03"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-04 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-04"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-05 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-05"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-06 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-06"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-07 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-07"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-08 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-08"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-09 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-09"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-10 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-10"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-11 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-11"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-12 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-12"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-13 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-13"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-14 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-14"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-15 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-15"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-16 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-16"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Do not claim the production has no issues or that every record is consistent.", "id": "memo.forbidden_claims_absent"}], "decision_options": [{"id": "cross-source-reconciliation", "label": "Reconcile controlling and corroborating records", "reason": "The CB-EL-3101 production contains independently maintained records; a defensible answer must preserve each supported conflict and its cure owner.", "selected": true}, {"id": "latest-record-controls", "label": "Treat the latest record as controlling", "reason": "Timestamp recency does not establish legal priority, execution, or approval authority.", "selected": false}, {"id": "primary-records-only", "label": "Report primary records without reconciliation", "reason": "Primary records alone conceal the operational conflicts that create the actionable exceptions.", "selected": false}], "gates": ["all_evidence_read_in_full", "chain_of_custody_metadata_checked", "findings_criteria_complete", "memo_criteria_complete", "deliverables_written_through_mcp"], "metadata_checks": 8, "metric": "weighted_criteria_score", "minimum_tool_calls": 46, "required_deliverables": ["findings.json", "advice.md"], "required_document_reads": 33, "type": "deterministic", "weights": {"findings": 0.55, "memo": 0.2, "procedure": 0.25}}, "task_id": "cb100-071-alpine-delivery", "task_name": "Alpine courier classification audit", "world_id": "counselbench-filesystem-mcp-v2"}
-{"context_files": ["task_files/cb100-072-bluebird-care/01_handbooks_policies/001_handbooks_policies_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-072-bluebird-care/01_handbooks_policies/002_handbooks_policies_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-072-bluebird-care/01_handbooks_policies/003_handbooks_policies_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-072-bluebird-care/01_handbooks_policies/004_handbooks_policies_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-072-bluebird-care/01_handbooks_policies/005_handbooks_policies_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-072-bluebird-care/01_handbooks_policies/006_handbooks_policies_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-072-bluebird-care/01_handbooks_policies/007_handbooks_policies_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-072-bluebird-care/01_handbooks_policies/008_handbooks_policies_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-072-bluebird-care/02_personnel_records/009_personnel_records_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-072-bluebird-care/02_personnel_records/010_personnel_records_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-072-bluebird-care/02_personnel_records/011_personnel_records_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-072-bluebird-care/02_personnel_records/012_personnel_records_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-072-bluebird-care/02_personnel_records/013_personnel_records_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-072-bluebird-care/02_personnel_records/014_personnel_records_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-072-bluebird-care/02_personnel_records/015_personnel_records_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-072-bluebird-care/02_personnel_records/016_personnel_records_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-072-bluebird-care/03_payroll_time/017_payroll_time_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-072-bluebird-care/03_payroll_time/018_payroll_time_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-072-bluebird-care/03_payroll_time/019_payroll_time_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-072-bluebird-care/03_payroll_time/020_payroll_time_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-072-bluebird-care/03_payroll_time/021_payroll_time_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-072-bluebird-care/03_payroll_time/022_payroll_time_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-072-bluebird-care/03_payroll_time/023_payroll_time_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-072-bluebird-care/03_payroll_time/024_payroll_time_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-072-bluebird-care/04_compensation_equity/025_compensation_equity_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-072-bluebird-care/04_compensation_equity/026_compensation_equity_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-072-bluebird-care/04_compensation_equity/027_compensation_equity_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-072-bluebird-care/04_compensation_equity/028_compensation_equity_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-072-bluebird-care/04_compensation_equity/029_compensation_equity_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-072-bluebird-care/04_compensation_equity/030_compensation_equity_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-072-bluebird-care/04_compensation_equity/031_compensation_equity_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-072-bluebird-care/04_compensation_equity/032_compensation_equity_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-072-bluebird-care/05_leave_accommodation/033_leave_accommodation_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-072-bluebird-care/05_leave_accommodation/034_leave_accommodation_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-072-bluebird-care/05_leave_accommodation/035_leave_accommodation_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-072-bluebird-care/05_leave_accommodation/036_leave_accommodation_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-072-bluebird-care/05_leave_accommodation/037_leave_accommodation_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-072-bluebird-care/05_leave_accommodation/038_leave_accommodation_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-072-bluebird-care/05_leave_accommodation/039_leave_accommodation_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-072-bluebird-care/05_leave_accommodation/040_leave_accommodation_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-072-bluebird-care/06_complaints/041_complaints_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-072-bluebird-care/06_complaints/042_complaints_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-072-bluebird-care/06_complaints/043_complaints_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-072-bluebird-care/06_complaints/044_complaints_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-072-bluebird-care/06_complaints/045_complaints_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-072-bluebird-care/06_complaints/046_complaints_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-072-bluebird-care/06_complaints/047_complaints_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-072-bluebird-care/06_complaints/048_complaints_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-072-bluebird-care/07_investigations/049_investigations_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-072-bluebird-care/07_investigations/050_investigations_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-072-bluebird-care/07_investigations/051_investigations_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-072-bluebird-care/07_investigations/052_investigations_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-072-bluebird-care/07_investigations/053_investigations_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-072-bluebird-care/07_investigations/054_investigations_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-072-bluebird-care/07_investigations/055_investigations_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-072-bluebird-care/07_investigations/056_investigations_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-072-bluebird-care/08_performance_discipline/057_performance_discipline_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-072-bluebird-care/08_performance_discipline/058_performance_discipline_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-072-bluebird-care/08_performance_discipline/059_performance_discipline_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-072-bluebird-care/08_performance_discipline/060_performance_discipline_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-072-bluebird-care/08_performance_discipline/061_performance_discipline_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-072-bluebird-care/08_performance_discipline/062_performance_discipline_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-072-bluebird-care/08_performance_discipline/063_performance_discipline_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-072-bluebird-care/08_performance_discipline/064_performance_discipline_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-072-bluebird-care/09_separation/065_separation_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-072-bluebird-care/09_separation/066_separation_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-072-bluebird-care/09_separation/067_separation_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-072-bluebird-care/09_separation/068_separation_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-072-bluebird-care/09_separation/069_separation_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-072-bluebird-care/09_separation/070_separation_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-072-bluebird-care/09_separation/071_separation_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-072-bluebird-care/09_separation/072_separation_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-072-bluebird-care/10_contractors/073_contractors_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-072-bluebird-care/10_contractors/074_contractors_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-072-bluebird-care/10_contractors/075_contractors_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-072-bluebird-care/10_contractors/076_contractors_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-072-bluebird-care/10_contractors/077_contractors_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-072-bluebird-care/10_contractors/078_contractors_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-072-bluebird-care/10_contractors/079_contractors_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-072-bluebird-care/10_contractors/080_contractors_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-072-bluebird-care/11_training/081_training_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-072-bluebird-care/11_training/082_training_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-072-bluebird-care/11_training/083_training_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-072-bluebird-care/11_training/084_training_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-072-bluebird-care/11_training/085_training_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-072-bluebird-care/11_training/086_training_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-072-bluebird-care/11_training/087_training_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-072-bluebird-care/11_training/088_training_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-072-bluebird-care/12_agency_matters/089_agency_matters_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-072-bluebird-care/12_agency_matters/090_agency_matters_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-072-bluebird-care/12_agency_matters/091_agency_matters_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-072-bluebird-care/12_agency_matters/092_agency_matters_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-072-bluebird-care/12_agency_matters/093_agency_matters_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-072-bluebird-care/12_agency_matters/094_agency_matters_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-072-bluebird-care/12_agency_matters/095_agency_matters_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-072-bluebird-care/12_agency_matters/096_agency_matters_status_report.md"], "gold_output": {"advice_markdown": "# Counsel advice — Bluebird caregiver wage review\n\n## Executive assessment\n\nFor Bluebird Home Care Services matter CB-EL-3102, the review identified 16 source-supported exceptions requiring action before 2026-09-09. The assessment concerns Regional caregiver group and the supplied record for California.\n\n## Method and record coverage\n\nThe review inventoried all 96 production files, read the 33 controlling, corroborating, and control records, searched the email exports, and checked metadata for the designated chain-of-custody sample. Conclusions are limited to the synthetic production supplied for this benchmark matter.\n\n## Findings\n\n### F-01 — classification inconsistency (critical)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for classification inconsistency: one source states the operative date is 2025-12-14 under control reference CB-EL-3102-A385, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2026-01-10 under response reference CB-EL-3102-J537.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/001_handbooks_policies_control_register.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/07_investigations/049_investigations_control_register.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-09, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Leona Park.\n\n### F-02 — overtime calculation error (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for overtime calculation error: one source states the controlling amount is $290,269.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $307,038.00.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/004_handbooks_policies_ledger_export.csv`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/07_investigations/052_investigations_ledger_export.csv`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-09, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Isaac Romero.\n\n### F-03 — meal-period premium gap (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for meal-period premium gap: one source states approval is attributed to Elliot Mercer as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Theo Laurent and contains no entry for Elliot Mercer.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/007_handbooks_policies_officer_certificate.html`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/07_investigations/055_investigations_officer_certificate.html`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-09, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Sofia Bennett.\n\n### F-04 — pay-equity outlier (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for pay-equity outlier: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-EL-3102-D467, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-EL-3102-M128.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/010_personnel_records_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/08_performance_discipline/058_performance_discipline_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-09, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Adrian Mensah.\n\n### F-05 — leave designation delay (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for leave designation delay: one source states the applicable location is California Labor Commissioner, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to California operations outside California Labor Commissioner.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/013_personnel_records_review_memorandum.json`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/08_performance_discipline/061_performance_discipline_review_memorandum.json`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-09, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Willa Novak.\n\n### F-06 — interactive-process lapse (low)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for interactive-process lapse: one source states the threshold is 8% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 10% and produced a different exception result.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/016_personnel_records_status_report.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/08_performance_discipline/064_performance_discipline_status_report.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-09, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Theo Laurent.\n\n### F-07 — complaint escalation gap (critical)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for complaint escalation gap: one source states formal notice must use notices-bluebird_home_care_services@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-regional_caregiver_group@example.test.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/019_payroll_time_correspondence.eml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/09_separation/067_separation_correspondence.eml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-09, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Amara Patel.\n\n### F-08 — investigation independence concern (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for investigation independence concern: one source states the governed population contains 164 records through 2026-02-03, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 75 records through 2026-03-22.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/022_payroll_time_formal_notice.xml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/09_separation/070_separation_formal_notice.xml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-09, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Henry Cho.\n\n### F-09 — discipline comparator inconsistency (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for discipline comparator inconsistency: one source states the operative date is 2025-02-09 under control reference CB-EL-3102-I497, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2025-02-27 under response reference CB-EL-3102-R269.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/025_compensation_equity_control_register.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/10_contractors/073_contractors_control_register.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-09, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Nadine Flores.\n\n### F-10 — retaliation timing (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for retaliation timing: one source states the controlling amount is $2,334,915.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $2,606,330.00.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/028_compensation_equity_ledger_export.csv`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/10_contractors/076_contractors_ledger_export.csv`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-09, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Micah Sullivan.\n\n### F-11 — separation pay discrepancy (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for separation pay discrepancy: one source states approval is attributed to Elliot Mercer as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Jonas Feld and contains no entry for Elliot Mercer.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/031_compensation_equity_officer_certificate.html`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/10_contractors/079_contractors_officer_certificate.html`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-09, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Farah Ibrahim.\n\n### F-12 — restrictive-covenant conflict (low)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for restrictive-covenant conflict: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-EL-3102-L613, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-EL-3102-U416.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/034_leave_accommodation_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/11_training/082_training_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-09, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Owen Delgado.\n\n### F-13 — contractor control evidence (critical)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for contractor control evidence: one source states the applicable location is California Labor Commissioner, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to California operations outside California Labor Commissioner.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/037_leave_accommodation_review_memorandum.json`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/11_training/085_training_review_memorandum.json`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-09, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Lena Varga.\n\n### F-14 — training completion gap (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for training completion gap: one source states the threshold is 11% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 16% and produced a different exception result.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/040_leave_accommodation_status_report.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/11_training/088_training_status_report.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-09, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Samuel Kim.\n\n### F-15 — personnel-file access deadline (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for personnel-file access deadline: one source states formal notice must use notices-bluebird_home_care_services@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-regional_caregiver_group@example.test.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/06_complaints/043_complaints_correspondence.eml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/091_agency_matters_correspondence.eml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-09, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Maya Ellison.\n\n### F-16 — agency response commitment (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for agency response commitment: one source states the governed population contains 184 records through 2026-02-23, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 60 records through 2026-03-27.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/06_complaints/046_complaints_formal_notice.xml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/094_agency_matters_formal_notice.xml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-09, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Rafael Okafor.\n\n## Recommended next actions\n\nSequence the critical and high findings first, assign the named owners, preserve the cited records, and document any resolution in the controlling matter register before the stated deadline.\n\n## Assumptions and limitations\n\nThis analysis is confined to task cb100-072-bluebird-care and the supplied synthetic evidence. It does not rely on external facts, does not resolve disputed law, and is not legal advice for a real person or entity.\n", "findings": {"as_of": "2026-09-09", "findings": [{"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/07_investigations/049_investigations_control_register.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for classification inconsistency: one source states the operative date is 2025-12-14 under control reference CB-EL-3102-A385, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2026-01-10 under response reference CB-EL-3102-J537.", "id": "F-01", "issue": "classification inconsistency", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/001_handbooks_policies_control_register.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-09, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Leona Park.", "severity": "critical"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/07_investigations/052_investigations_ledger_export.csv", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for overtime calculation error: one source states the controlling amount is $290,269.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $307,038.00.", "id": "F-02", "issue": "overtime calculation error", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/004_handbooks_policies_ledger_export.csv", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-09, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Isaac Romero.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/07_investigations/055_investigations_officer_certificate.html", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for meal-period premium gap: one source states approval is attributed to Elliot Mercer as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Theo Laurent and contains no entry for Elliot Mercer.", "id": "F-03", "issue": "meal-period premium gap", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/007_handbooks_policies_officer_certificate.html", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-09, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Sofia Bennett.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/08_performance_discipline/058_performance_discipline_executed_instrument.txt", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for pay-equity outlier: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-EL-3102-D467, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-EL-3102-M128.", "id": "F-04", "issue": "pay-equity outlier", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/010_personnel_records_executed_instrument.txt", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-09, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Adrian Mensah.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/08_performance_discipline/061_performance_discipline_review_memorandum.json", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for leave designation delay: one source states the applicable location is California Labor Commissioner, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to California operations outside California Labor Commissioner.", "id": "F-05", "issue": "leave designation delay", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/013_personnel_records_review_memorandum.json", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-09, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Willa Novak.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/08_performance_discipline/064_performance_discipline_status_report.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for interactive-process lapse: one source states the threshold is 8% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 10% and produced a different exception result.", "id": "F-06", "issue": "interactive-process lapse", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/016_personnel_records_status_report.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-09, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Theo Laurent.", "severity": "low"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/09_separation/067_separation_correspondence.eml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for complaint escalation gap: one source states formal notice must use notices-bluebird_home_care_services@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-regional_caregiver_group@example.test.", "id": "F-07", "issue": "complaint escalation gap", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/019_payroll_time_correspondence.eml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-09, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Amara Patel.", "severity": "critical"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/09_separation/070_separation_formal_notice.xml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for investigation independence concern: one source states the governed population contains 164 records through 2026-02-03, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 75 records through 2026-03-22.", "id": "F-08", "issue": "investigation independence concern", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/022_payroll_time_formal_notice.xml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-09, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Henry Cho.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/10_contractors/073_contractors_control_register.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for discipline comparator inconsistency: one source states the operative date is 2025-02-09 under control reference CB-EL-3102-I497, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2025-02-27 under response reference CB-EL-3102-R269.", "id": "F-09", "issue": "discipline comparator inconsistency", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/025_compensation_equity_control_register.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-09, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Nadine Flores.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/10_contractors/076_contractors_ledger_export.csv", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for retaliation timing: one source states the controlling amount is $2,334,915.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $2,606,330.00.", "id": "F-10", "issue": "retaliation timing", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/028_compensation_equity_ledger_export.csv", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-09, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Micah Sullivan.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/10_contractors/079_contractors_officer_certificate.html", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for separation pay discrepancy: one source states approval is attributed to Elliot Mercer as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Jonas Feld and contains no entry for Elliot Mercer.", "id": "F-11", "issue": "separation pay discrepancy", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/031_compensation_equity_officer_certificate.html", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-09, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Farah Ibrahim.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/11_training/082_training_executed_instrument.txt", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for restrictive-covenant conflict: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-EL-3102-L613, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-EL-3102-U416.", "id": "F-12", "issue": "restrictive-covenant conflict", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/034_leave_accommodation_executed_instrument.txt", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-09, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Owen Delgado.", "severity": "low"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/11_training/085_training_review_memorandum.json", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for contractor control evidence: one source states the applicable location is California Labor Commissioner, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to California operations outside California Labor Commissioner.", "id": "F-13", "issue": "contractor control evidence", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/037_leave_accommodation_review_memorandum.json", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-09, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Lena Varga.", "severity": "critical"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/11_training/088_training_status_report.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for training completion gap: one source states the threshold is 11% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 16% and produced a different exception result.", "id": "F-14", "issue": "training completion gap", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/040_leave_accommodation_status_report.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-09, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Samuel Kim.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/091_agency_matters_correspondence.eml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for personnel-file access deadline: one source states formal notice must use notices-bluebird_home_care_services@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-regional_caregiver_group@example.test.", "id": "F-15", "issue": "personnel-file access deadline", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/06_complaints/043_complaints_correspondence.eml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-09, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Maya Ellison.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/094_agency_matters_formal_notice.xml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for agency response commitment: one source states the governed population contains 184 records through 2026-02-23, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 60 records through 2026-03-27.", "id": "F-16", "issue": "agency response commitment", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/06_complaints/046_complaints_formal_notice.xml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-09, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Rafael Okafor.", "severity": "medium"}], "matter_number": "CB-EL-3102", "prepared_for": "Bluebird Home Care Services", "schema_version": "1.0", "task_id": "cb100-072-bluebird-care"}}, "metadata": {"benchmark": "CounselBench-100", "code_license": "Apache-2.0", "data_license": "CC-BY-4.0", "deadline": "2026-09-09", "document_count": 96, "jurisdiction": "California", "matter_number": "CB-EL-3102", "mcp_commit": "9a96ea6e5913736f92b88345bf51caeaaa8e719f", "mcp_package": "@modelcontextprotocol/server-filesystem@2026.7.10", "practice_area": "employment", "reference_tool_calls": 46, "required_evidence_reads": 33, "synthetic": true, "venue": "California Labor Commissioner", "version": "2.0.0"}, "prompt": "You are employment counsel for Bluebird Home Care Services. A late document production changed the factual picture, and the matter team needs the entire record reconciled from first principles. Payroll, visit logs, and policies conflict on travel time, meal premiums, and complaint escalation for mobile caregivers. Decision due 2026-09-09. California law governs; California Labor Commissioner is the forum. Separate confirmed exceptions from items that merely require follow-up. Work out the defensible position from the matter production and leave an audit-ready exception tracker and concise advice for the supervising lawyer. Keep confirmed conflicts separate from open questions, cite the records that actually control each conclusion, and do not fill gaps with outside facts.", "rubric": {"criteria": [{"category": "procedure", "description": "Complete at least 46 successful, argument-specific evidence and output calls.", "id": "procedure.minimum_successful_tool_calls"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Find and read the 33 controlling, corroborating, and work-product-control records in full.", "id": "procedure.all_evidence_read_in_full"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Inspect file metadata for the eight designated critical primary records before relying on them.", "id": "procedure.chain_of_custody_metadata_checked"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Confirm the sandbox's allowed document and output roots.", "id": "procedure.allowed_directories_checked"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Inventory all 96 records so the relevant sources are discovered among the context records.", "id": "procedure.recursive_inventory_completed"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Search the production for email evidence that may corroborate or contradict formal records.", "id": "procedure.targeted_search_completed"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Leave only findings.json and advice.md in the output workspace.", "id": "procedure.exact_deliverable_set"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Create both final work products through the sandbox MCP surface.", "id": "procedure.deliverables_written_through_mcp"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Produce findings.json as a valid JSON object.", "id": "findings.findings_is_object"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Report exactly 16 confirmed exceptions.", "id": "findings.findings_exact_count"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Use each stable finding ID exactly once.", "id": "findings.finding_ids_unique"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set schema_version to the released matter value '1.0'.", "id": "findings.top_level_schema_version"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set task_id to the released matter value 'cb100-072-bluebird-care'.", "id": "findings.top_level_task_id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set matter_number to the released matter value 'CB-EL-3102'.", "id": "findings.top_level_matter_number"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set prepared_for to the released matter value 'Bluebird Home Care Services'.", "id": "findings.top_level_prepared_for"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set as_of to the released matter value '2026-09-09'.", "id": "findings.top_level_as_of"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-01 exception for classification inconsistency.", "id": "findings.F-01.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's id from /workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/001_handbooks_policies_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_investigations/049_investigations_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's issue from /workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/001_handbooks_policies_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_investigations/049_investigations_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's severity from /workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/001_handbooks_policies_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_investigations/049_investigations_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's primary_source from /workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/001_handbooks_policies_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_investigations/049_investigations_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/001_handbooks_policies_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_investigations/049_investigations_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-01 using the exact controlled facts ['2025-12-14', 'CB-EL-3102-A385', '2026-01-10', 'CB-EL-3102-J537'].", "id": "findings.F-01.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-01's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-01.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-09', 'Leona Park'] for F-01.", "id": "findings.F-01.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-02 exception for overtime calculation error.", "id": "findings.F-02.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's id from /workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/004_handbooks_policies_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_investigations/052_investigations_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's issue from /workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/004_handbooks_policies_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_investigations/052_investigations_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's severity from /workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/004_handbooks_policies_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_investigations/052_investigations_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's primary_source from /workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/004_handbooks_policies_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_investigations/052_investigations_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/004_handbooks_policies_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_investigations/052_investigations_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-02 using the exact controlled facts ['$290,269.00', '$307,038.00'].", "id": "findings.F-02.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-02's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-02.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-09', 'Isaac Romero'] for F-02.", "id": "findings.F-02.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-03 exception for meal-period premium gap.", "id": "findings.F-03.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's id from /workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/007_handbooks_policies_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_investigations/055_investigations_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's issue from /workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/007_handbooks_policies_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_investigations/055_investigations_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's severity from /workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/007_handbooks_policies_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_investigations/055_investigations_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's primary_source from /workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/007_handbooks_policies_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_investigations/055_investigations_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/007_handbooks_policies_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_investigations/055_investigations_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-03 using the exact controlled facts ['Elliot Mercer', 'Theo Laurent'].", "id": "findings.F-03.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-03's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-03.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-09', 'Sofia Bennett'] for F-03.", "id": "findings.F-03.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-04 exception for pay-equity outlier.", "id": "findings.F-04.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's id from /workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/010_personnel_records_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_performance_discipline/058_performance_discipline_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's issue from /workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/010_personnel_records_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_performance_discipline/058_performance_discipline_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's severity from /workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/010_personnel_records_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_performance_discipline/058_performance_discipline_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's primary_source from /workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/010_personnel_records_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_performance_discipline/058_performance_discipline_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/010_personnel_records_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_performance_discipline/058_performance_discipline_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-04 using the exact controlled facts ['closed without exception', 'CB-EL-3102-D467', 'open and escalated', 'CB-EL-3102-M128'].", "id": "findings.F-04.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-04's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-04.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-09', 'Adrian Mensah'] for F-04.", "id": "findings.F-04.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-05 exception for leave designation delay.", "id": "findings.F-05.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's id from /workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/013_personnel_records_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_performance_discipline/061_performance_discipline_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's issue from /workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/013_personnel_records_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_performance_discipline/061_performance_discipline_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's severity from /workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/013_personnel_records_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_performance_discipline/061_performance_discipline_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's primary_source from /workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/013_personnel_records_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_performance_discipline/061_performance_discipline_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/013_personnel_records_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_performance_discipline/061_performance_discipline_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-05 using the exact controlled facts ['California Labor Commissioner', 'California'].", "id": "findings.F-05.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-05's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-05.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-09', 'Willa Novak'] for F-05.", "id": "findings.F-05.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-06 exception for interactive-process lapse.", "id": "findings.F-06.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's id from /workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/016_personnel_records_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_performance_discipline/064_performance_discipline_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's issue from /workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/016_personnel_records_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_performance_discipline/064_performance_discipline_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's severity from /workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/016_personnel_records_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_performance_discipline/064_performance_discipline_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's primary_source from /workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/016_personnel_records_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_performance_discipline/064_performance_discipline_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/016_personnel_records_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_performance_discipline/064_performance_discipline_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-06 using the exact controlled facts ['8%', '10%'].", "id": "findings.F-06.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-06's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-06.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-09', 'Theo Laurent'] for F-06.", "id": "findings.F-06.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-07 exception for complaint escalation gap.", "id": "findings.F-07.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's id from /workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/019_payroll_time_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_separation/067_separation_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's issue from /workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/019_payroll_time_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_separation/067_separation_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's severity from /workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/019_payroll_time_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_separation/067_separation_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's primary_source from /workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/019_payroll_time_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_separation/067_separation_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/019_payroll_time_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_separation/067_separation_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-07 using the exact controlled facts ['notices-bluebird_home_care_services@example.test', 'archive-regional_caregiver_group@example.test'].", "id": "findings.F-07.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-07's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-07.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-09', 'Amara Patel'] for F-07.", "id": "findings.F-07.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-08 exception for investigation independence concern.", "id": "findings.F-08.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's id from /workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/022_payroll_time_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_separation/070_separation_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's issue from /workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/022_payroll_time_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_separation/070_separation_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's severity from /workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/022_payroll_time_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_separation/070_separation_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's primary_source from /workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/022_payroll_time_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_separation/070_separation_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/022_payroll_time_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_separation/070_separation_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-08 using the exact controlled facts ['164 records', '2026-02-03', '75 records', '2026-03-22'].", "id": "findings.F-08.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-08's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-08.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-09', 'Henry Cho'] for F-08.", "id": "findings.F-08.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-09 exception for discipline comparator inconsistency.", "id": "findings.F-09.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's id from /workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/025_compensation_equity_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_contractors/073_contractors_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's issue from /workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/025_compensation_equity_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_contractors/073_contractors_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's severity from /workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/025_compensation_equity_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_contractors/073_contractors_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's primary_source from /workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/025_compensation_equity_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_contractors/073_contractors_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/025_compensation_equity_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_contractors/073_contractors_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-09 using the exact controlled facts ['2025-02-09', 'CB-EL-3102-I497', '2025-02-27', 'CB-EL-3102-R269'].", "id": "findings.F-09.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-09's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-09.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-09', 'Nadine Flores'] for F-09.", "id": "findings.F-09.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-10 exception for retaliation timing.", "id": "findings.F-10.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's id from /workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/028_compensation_equity_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_contractors/076_contractors_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's issue from /workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/028_compensation_equity_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_contractors/076_contractors_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's severity from /workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/028_compensation_equity_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_contractors/076_contractors_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's primary_source from /workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/028_compensation_equity_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_contractors/076_contractors_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/028_compensation_equity_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_contractors/076_contractors_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-10 using the exact controlled facts ['$2,334,915.00', '$2,606,330.00'].", "id": "findings.F-10.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-10's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-10.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-09', 'Micah Sullivan'] for F-10.", "id": "findings.F-10.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-11 exception for separation pay discrepancy.", "id": "findings.F-11.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's id from /workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/031_compensation_equity_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_contractors/079_contractors_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's issue from /workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/031_compensation_equity_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_contractors/079_contractors_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's severity from /workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/031_compensation_equity_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_contractors/079_contractors_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's primary_source from /workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/031_compensation_equity_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_contractors/079_contractors_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/031_compensation_equity_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_contractors/079_contractors_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-11 using the exact controlled facts ['Elliot Mercer', 'Jonas Feld'].", "id": "findings.F-11.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-11's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-11.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-09', 'Farah Ibrahim'] for F-11.", "id": "findings.F-11.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-12 exception for restrictive-covenant conflict.", "id": "findings.F-12.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's id from /workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/034_leave_accommodation_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_training/082_training_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's issue from /workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/034_leave_accommodation_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_training/082_training_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's severity from /workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/034_leave_accommodation_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_training/082_training_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's primary_source from /workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/034_leave_accommodation_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_training/082_training_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/034_leave_accommodation_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_training/082_training_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-12 using the exact controlled facts ['closed without exception', 'CB-EL-3102-L613', 'open and escalated', 'CB-EL-3102-U416'].", "id": "findings.F-12.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-12's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-12.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-09', 'Owen Delgado'] for F-12.", "id": "findings.F-12.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-13 exception for contractor control evidence.", "id": "findings.F-13.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's id from /workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/037_leave_accommodation_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_training/085_training_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's issue from /workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/037_leave_accommodation_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_training/085_training_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's severity from /workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/037_leave_accommodation_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_training/085_training_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's primary_source from /workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/037_leave_accommodation_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_training/085_training_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/037_leave_accommodation_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_training/085_training_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-13 using the exact controlled facts ['California Labor Commissioner', 'California'].", "id": "findings.F-13.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-13's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-13.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-09', 'Lena Varga'] for F-13.", "id": "findings.F-13.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-14 exception for training completion gap.", "id": "findings.F-14.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's id from /workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/040_leave_accommodation_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_training/088_training_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's issue from /workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/040_leave_accommodation_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_training/088_training_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's severity from /workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/040_leave_accommodation_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_training/088_training_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's primary_source from /workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/040_leave_accommodation_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_training/088_training_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/040_leave_accommodation_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_training/088_training_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-14 using the exact controlled facts ['11%', '16%'].", "id": "findings.F-14.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-14's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-14.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-09', 'Samuel Kim'] for F-14.", "id": "findings.F-14.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-15 exception for personnel-file access deadline.", "id": "findings.F-15.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's id from /workspace/documents/06_complaints/043_complaints_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/091_agency_matters_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's issue from /workspace/documents/06_complaints/043_complaints_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/091_agency_matters_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's severity from /workspace/documents/06_complaints/043_complaints_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/091_agency_matters_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's primary_source from /workspace/documents/06_complaints/043_complaints_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/091_agency_matters_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/06_complaints/043_complaints_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/091_agency_matters_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-15 using the exact controlled facts ['notices-bluebird_home_care_services@example.test', 'archive-regional_caregiver_group@example.test'].", "id": "findings.F-15.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-15's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-15.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-09', 'Maya Ellison'] for F-15.", "id": "findings.F-15.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-16 exception for agency response commitment.", "id": "findings.F-16.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's id from /workspace/documents/06_complaints/046_complaints_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/094_agency_matters_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's issue from /workspace/documents/06_complaints/046_complaints_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/094_agency_matters_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's severity from /workspace/documents/06_complaints/046_complaints_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/094_agency_matters_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's primary_source from /workspace/documents/06_complaints/046_complaints_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/094_agency_matters_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/06_complaints/046_complaints_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/094_agency_matters_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-16 using the exact controlled facts ['184 records', '2026-02-23', '60 records', '2026-03-27'].", "id": "findings.F-16.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-16's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-16.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-09', 'Rafael Okafor'] for F-16.", "id": "findings.F-16.action_anchors"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Executive assessment' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Executive assessment"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Method and record coverage' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Method and record coverage"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Findings' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Findings"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Recommended next actions' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Recommended next actions"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Assumptions and limitations' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Assumptions and limitations"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-01 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-01"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-02 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-02"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-03 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-03"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-04 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-04"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-05 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-05"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-06 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-06"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-07 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-07"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-08 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-08"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-09 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-09"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-10 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-10"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-11 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-11"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-12 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-12"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-13 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-13"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-14 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-14"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-15 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-15"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-16 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-16"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Do not claim the production has no issues or that every record is consistent.", "id": "memo.forbidden_claims_absent"}], "decision_options": [{"id": "cross-source-reconciliation", "label": "Reconcile controlling and corroborating records", "reason": "The CB-EL-3102 production contains independently maintained records; a defensible answer must preserve each supported conflict and its cure owner.", "selected": true}, {"id": "latest-record-controls", "label": "Treat the latest record as controlling", "reason": "Timestamp recency does not establish legal priority, execution, or approval authority.", "selected": false}, {"id": "primary-records-only", "label": "Report primary records without reconciliation", "reason": "Primary records alone conceal the operational conflicts that create the actionable exceptions.", "selected": false}], "gates": ["all_evidence_read_in_full", "chain_of_custody_metadata_checked", "findings_criteria_complete", "memo_criteria_complete", "deliverables_written_through_mcp"], "metadata_checks": 8, "metric": "weighted_criteria_score", "minimum_tool_calls": 46, "required_deliverables": ["findings.json", "advice.md"], "required_document_reads": 33, "type": "deterministic", "weights": {"findings": 0.55, "memo": 0.2, "procedure": 0.25}}, "task_id": "cb100-072-bluebird-care", "task_name": "Bluebird caregiver wage review", "world_id": "counselbench-filesystem-mcp-v2"}
-{"context_files": ["task_files/cb100-073-copper-state/01_handbooks_policies/001_handbooks_policies_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-073-copper-state/01_handbooks_policies/002_handbooks_policies_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-073-copper-state/01_handbooks_policies/003_handbooks_policies_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-073-copper-state/01_handbooks_policies/004_handbooks_policies_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-073-copper-state/01_handbooks_policies/005_handbooks_policies_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-073-copper-state/01_handbooks_policies/006_handbooks_policies_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-073-copper-state/01_handbooks_policies/007_handbooks_policies_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-073-copper-state/01_handbooks_policies/008_handbooks_policies_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-073-copper-state/02_personnel_records/009_personnel_records_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-073-copper-state/02_personnel_records/010_personnel_records_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-073-copper-state/02_personnel_records/011_personnel_records_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-073-copper-state/02_personnel_records/012_personnel_records_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-073-copper-state/02_personnel_records/013_personnel_records_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-073-copper-state/02_personnel_records/014_personnel_records_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-073-copper-state/02_personnel_records/015_personnel_records_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-073-copper-state/02_personnel_records/016_personnel_records_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-073-copper-state/03_payroll_time/017_payroll_time_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-073-copper-state/03_payroll_time/018_payroll_time_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-073-copper-state/03_payroll_time/019_payroll_time_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-073-copper-state/03_payroll_time/020_payroll_time_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-073-copper-state/03_payroll_time/021_payroll_time_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-073-copper-state/03_payroll_time/022_payroll_time_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-073-copper-state/03_payroll_time/023_payroll_time_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-073-copper-state/03_payroll_time/024_payroll_time_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-073-copper-state/04_compensation_equity/025_compensation_equity_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-073-copper-state/04_compensation_equity/026_compensation_equity_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-073-copper-state/04_compensation_equity/027_compensation_equity_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-073-copper-state/04_compensation_equity/028_compensation_equity_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-073-copper-state/04_compensation_equity/029_compensation_equity_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-073-copper-state/04_compensation_equity/030_compensation_equity_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-073-copper-state/04_compensation_equity/031_compensation_equity_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-073-copper-state/04_compensation_equity/032_compensation_equity_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-073-copper-state/05_leave_accommodation/033_leave_accommodation_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-073-copper-state/05_leave_accommodation/034_leave_accommodation_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-073-copper-state/05_leave_accommodation/035_leave_accommodation_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-073-copper-state/05_leave_accommodation/036_leave_accommodation_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-073-copper-state/05_leave_accommodation/037_leave_accommodation_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-073-copper-state/05_leave_accommodation/038_leave_accommodation_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-073-copper-state/05_leave_accommodation/039_leave_accommodation_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-073-copper-state/05_leave_accommodation/040_leave_accommodation_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-073-copper-state/06_complaints/041_complaints_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-073-copper-state/06_complaints/042_complaints_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-073-copper-state/06_complaints/043_complaints_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-073-copper-state/06_complaints/044_complaints_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-073-copper-state/06_complaints/045_complaints_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-073-copper-state/06_complaints/046_complaints_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-073-copper-state/06_complaints/047_complaints_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-073-copper-state/06_complaints/048_complaints_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-073-copper-state/07_investigations/049_investigations_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-073-copper-state/07_investigations/050_investigations_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-073-copper-state/07_investigations/051_investigations_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-073-copper-state/07_investigations/052_investigations_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-073-copper-state/07_investigations/053_investigations_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-073-copper-state/07_investigations/054_investigations_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-073-copper-state/07_investigations/055_investigations_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-073-copper-state/07_investigations/056_investigations_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-073-copper-state/08_performance_discipline/057_performance_discipline_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-073-copper-state/08_performance_discipline/058_performance_discipline_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-073-copper-state/08_performance_discipline/059_performance_discipline_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-073-copper-state/08_performance_discipline/060_performance_discipline_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-073-copper-state/08_performance_discipline/061_performance_discipline_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-073-copper-state/08_performance_discipline/062_performance_discipline_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-073-copper-state/08_performance_discipline/063_performance_discipline_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-073-copper-state/08_performance_discipline/064_performance_discipline_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-073-copper-state/09_separation/065_separation_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-073-copper-state/09_separation/066_separation_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-073-copper-state/09_separation/067_separation_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-073-copper-state/09_separation/068_separation_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-073-copper-state/09_separation/069_separation_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-073-copper-state/09_separation/070_separation_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-073-copper-state/09_separation/071_separation_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-073-copper-state/09_separation/072_separation_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-073-copper-state/10_contractors/073_contractors_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-073-copper-state/10_contractors/074_contractors_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-073-copper-state/10_contractors/075_contractors_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-073-copper-state/10_contractors/076_contractors_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-073-copper-state/10_contractors/077_contractors_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-073-copper-state/10_contractors/078_contractors_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-073-copper-state/10_contractors/079_contractors_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-073-copper-state/10_contractors/080_contractors_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-073-copper-state/11_training/081_training_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-073-copper-state/11_training/082_training_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-073-copper-state/11_training/083_training_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-073-copper-state/11_training/084_training_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-073-copper-state/11_training/085_training_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-073-copper-state/11_training/086_training_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-073-copper-state/11_training/087_training_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-073-copper-state/11_training/088_training_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-073-copper-state/12_agency_matters/089_agency_matters_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-073-copper-state/12_agency_matters/090_agency_matters_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-073-copper-state/12_agency_matters/091_agency_matters_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-073-copper-state/12_agency_matters/092_agency_matters_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-073-copper-state/12_agency_matters/093_agency_matters_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-073-copper-state/12_agency_matters/094_agency_matters_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-073-copper-state/12_agency_matters/095_agency_matters_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-073-copper-state/12_agency_matters/096_agency_matters_status_report.md"], "gold_output": {"advice_markdown": "# Counsel advice — Copper State accommodation audit\n\n## Executive assessment\n\nFor Copper State Manufacturing matter CB-EL-3103, the review identified 16 source-supported exceptions requiring action before 2026-09-12. The assessment concerns Former quality engineer and the supplied record for Arizona.\n\n## Method and record coverage\n\nThe review inventoried all 96 production files, read the 33 controlling, corroborating, and control records, searched the email exports, and checked metadata for the designated chain-of-custody sample. Conclusions are limited to the synthetic production supplied for this benchmark matter.\n\n## Findings\n\n### F-01 — classification inconsistency (critical)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for classification inconsistency: one source states the operative date is 2025-06-22 under control reference CB-EL-3103-A330, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2025-07-16 under response reference CB-EL-3103-J879.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/001_handbooks_policies_control_register.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/07_investigations/049_investigations_control_register.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-12, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Isaac Romero.\n\n### F-02 — overtime calculation error (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for overtime calculation error: one source states the controlling amount is $1,345,223.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $1,586,946.00.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/004_handbooks_policies_ledger_export.csv`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/07_investigations/052_investigations_ledger_export.csv`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-12, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Sofia Bennett.\n\n### F-03 — meal-period premium gap (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for meal-period premium gap: one source states approval is attributed to Talia Brooks as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Henry Cho and contains no entry for Talia Brooks.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/007_handbooks_policies_officer_certificate.html`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/07_investigations/055_investigations_officer_certificate.html`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-12, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Adrian Mensah.\n\n### F-04 — pay-equity outlier (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for pay-equity outlier: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-EL-3103-D588, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-EL-3103-M691.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/010_personnel_records_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/08_performance_discipline/058_performance_discipline_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-12, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Willa Novak.\n\n### F-05 — leave designation delay (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for leave designation delay: one source states the applicable location is Equal Employment Opportunity Commission, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to Arizona operations outside Equal Employment Opportunity Commission.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/013_personnel_records_review_memorandum.json`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/08_performance_discipline/061_performance_discipline_review_memorandum.json`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-12, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Theo Laurent.\n\n### F-06 — interactive-process lapse (low)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for interactive-process lapse: one source states the threshold is 6% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 8% and produced a different exception result.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/016_personnel_records_status_report.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/08_performance_discipline/064_performance_discipline_status_report.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-12, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Amara Patel.\n\n### F-07 — complaint escalation gap (critical)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for complaint escalation gap: one source states formal notice must use notices-copper_state_manufacturing@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-former_quality_engineer@example.test.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/019_payroll_time_correspondence.eml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/09_separation/067_separation_correspondence.eml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-12, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Henry Cho.\n\n### F-08 — investigation independence concern (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for investigation independence concern: one source states the governed population contains 117 records through 2025-12-18, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 53 records through 2026-01-12.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/022_payroll_time_formal_notice.xml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/09_separation/070_separation_formal_notice.xml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-12, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Nadine Flores.\n\n### F-09 — discipline comparator inconsistency (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for discipline comparator inconsistency: one source states the operative date is 2025-03-09 under control reference CB-EL-3103-I165, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2025-04-13 under response reference CB-EL-3103-R658.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/025_compensation_equity_control_register.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/10_contractors/073_contractors_control_register.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-12, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Micah Sullivan.\n\n### F-10 — retaliation timing (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for retaliation timing: one source states the controlling amount is $1,901,763.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $2,040,026.00.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/028_compensation_equity_ledger_export.csv`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/10_contractors/076_contractors_ledger_export.csv`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-12, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Farah Ibrahim.\n\n### F-11 — separation pay discrepancy (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for separation pay discrepancy: one source states approval is attributed to Talia Brooks as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Caleb Hassan and contains no entry for Talia Brooks.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/031_compensation_equity_officer_certificate.html`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/10_contractors/079_contractors_officer_certificate.html`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-12, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Owen Delgado.\n\n### F-12 — restrictive-covenant conflict (low)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for restrictive-covenant conflict: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-EL-3103-L684, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-EL-3103-U421.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/034_leave_accommodation_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/11_training/082_training_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-12, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Lena Varga.\n\n### F-13 — contractor control evidence (critical)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for contractor control evidence: one source states the applicable location is Equal Employment Opportunity Commission, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to Arizona operations outside Equal Employment Opportunity Commission.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/037_leave_accommodation_review_memorandum.json`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/11_training/085_training_review_memorandum.json`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-12, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Samuel Kim.\n\n### F-14 — training completion gap (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for training completion gap: one source states the threshold is 9% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 16% and produced a different exception result.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/040_leave_accommodation_status_report.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/11_training/088_training_status_report.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-12, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Maya Ellison.\n\n### F-15 — personnel-file access deadline (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for personnel-file access deadline: one source states formal notice must use notices-copper_state_manufacturing@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-former_quality_engineer@example.test.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/06_complaints/043_complaints_correspondence.eml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/091_agency_matters_correspondence.eml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-12, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Rafael Okafor.\n\n### F-16 — agency response commitment (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for agency response commitment: one source states the governed population contains 130 records through 2025-03-26, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 73 records through 2025-05-10.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/06_complaints/046_complaints_formal_notice.xml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/094_agency_matters_formal_notice.xml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-12, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Nora Chen.\n\n## Recommended next actions\n\nSequence the critical and high findings first, assign the named owners, preserve the cited records, and document any resolution in the controlling matter register before the stated deadline.\n\n## Assumptions and limitations\n\nThis analysis is confined to task cb100-073-copper-state and the supplied synthetic evidence. It does not rely on external facts, does not resolve disputed law, and is not legal advice for a real person or entity.\n", "findings": {"as_of": "2026-09-12", "findings": [{"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/07_investigations/049_investigations_control_register.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for classification inconsistency: one source states the operative date is 2025-06-22 under control reference CB-EL-3103-A330, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2025-07-16 under response reference CB-EL-3103-J879.", "id": "F-01", "issue": "classification inconsistency", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/001_handbooks_policies_control_register.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-12, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Isaac Romero.", "severity": "critical"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/07_investigations/052_investigations_ledger_export.csv", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for overtime calculation error: one source states the controlling amount is $1,345,223.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $1,586,946.00.", "id": "F-02", "issue": "overtime calculation error", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/004_handbooks_policies_ledger_export.csv", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-12, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Sofia Bennett.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/07_investigations/055_investigations_officer_certificate.html", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for meal-period premium gap: one source states approval is attributed to Talia Brooks as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Henry Cho and contains no entry for Talia Brooks.", "id": "F-03", "issue": "meal-period premium gap", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/007_handbooks_policies_officer_certificate.html", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-12, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Adrian Mensah.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/08_performance_discipline/058_performance_discipline_executed_instrument.txt", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for pay-equity outlier: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-EL-3103-D588, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-EL-3103-M691.", "id": "F-04", "issue": "pay-equity outlier", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/010_personnel_records_executed_instrument.txt", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-12, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Willa Novak.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/08_performance_discipline/061_performance_discipline_review_memorandum.json", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for leave designation delay: one source states the applicable location is Equal Employment Opportunity Commission, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to Arizona operations outside Equal Employment Opportunity Commission.", "id": "F-05", "issue": "leave designation delay", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/013_personnel_records_review_memorandum.json", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-12, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Theo Laurent.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/08_performance_discipline/064_performance_discipline_status_report.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for interactive-process lapse: one source states the threshold is 6% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 8% and produced a different exception result.", "id": "F-06", "issue": "interactive-process lapse", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/016_personnel_records_status_report.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-12, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Amara Patel.", "severity": "low"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/09_separation/067_separation_correspondence.eml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for complaint escalation gap: one source states formal notice must use notices-copper_state_manufacturing@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-former_quality_engineer@example.test.", "id": "F-07", "issue": "complaint escalation gap", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/019_payroll_time_correspondence.eml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-12, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Henry Cho.", "severity": "critical"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/09_separation/070_separation_formal_notice.xml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for investigation independence concern: one source states the governed population contains 117 records through 2025-12-18, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 53 records through 2026-01-12.", "id": "F-08", "issue": "investigation independence concern", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/022_payroll_time_formal_notice.xml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-12, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Nadine Flores.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/10_contractors/073_contractors_control_register.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for discipline comparator inconsistency: one source states the operative date is 2025-03-09 under control reference CB-EL-3103-I165, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2025-04-13 under response reference CB-EL-3103-R658.", "id": "F-09", "issue": "discipline comparator inconsistency", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/025_compensation_equity_control_register.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-12, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Micah Sullivan.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/10_contractors/076_contractors_ledger_export.csv", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for retaliation timing: one source states the controlling amount is $1,901,763.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $2,040,026.00.", "id": "F-10", "issue": "retaliation timing", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/028_compensation_equity_ledger_export.csv", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-12, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Farah Ibrahim.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/10_contractors/079_contractors_officer_certificate.html", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for separation pay discrepancy: one source states approval is attributed to Talia Brooks as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Caleb Hassan and contains no entry for Talia Brooks.", "id": "F-11", "issue": "separation pay discrepancy", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/031_compensation_equity_officer_certificate.html", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-12, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Owen Delgado.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/11_training/082_training_executed_instrument.txt", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for restrictive-covenant conflict: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-EL-3103-L684, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-EL-3103-U421.", "id": "F-12", "issue": "restrictive-covenant conflict", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/034_leave_accommodation_executed_instrument.txt", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-12, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Lena Varga.", "severity": "low"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/11_training/085_training_review_memorandum.json", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for contractor control evidence: one source states the applicable location is Equal Employment Opportunity Commission, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to Arizona operations outside Equal Employment Opportunity Commission.", "id": "F-13", "issue": "contractor control evidence", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/037_leave_accommodation_review_memorandum.json", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-12, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Samuel Kim.", "severity": "critical"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/11_training/088_training_status_report.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for training completion gap: one source states the threshold is 9% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 16% and produced a different exception result.", "id": "F-14", "issue": "training completion gap", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/040_leave_accommodation_status_report.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-12, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Maya Ellison.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/091_agency_matters_correspondence.eml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for personnel-file access deadline: one source states formal notice must use notices-copper_state_manufacturing@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-former_quality_engineer@example.test.", "id": "F-15", "issue": "personnel-file access deadline", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/06_complaints/043_complaints_correspondence.eml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-12, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Rafael Okafor.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/094_agency_matters_formal_notice.xml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for agency response commitment: one source states the governed population contains 130 records through 2025-03-26, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 73 records through 2025-05-10.", "id": "F-16", "issue": "agency response commitment", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/06_complaints/046_complaints_formal_notice.xml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-12, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Nora Chen.", "severity": "medium"}], "matter_number": "CB-EL-3103", "prepared_for": "Copper State Manufacturing", "schema_version": "1.0", "task_id": "cb100-073-copper-state"}}, "metadata": {"benchmark": "CounselBench-100", "code_license": "Apache-2.0", "data_license": "CC-BY-4.0", "deadline": "2026-09-12", "document_count": 96, "jurisdiction": "Arizona", "matter_number": "CB-EL-3103", "mcp_commit": "9a96ea6e5913736f92b88345bf51caeaaa8e719f", "mcp_package": "@modelcontextprotocol/server-filesystem@2026.7.10", "practice_area": "employment", "reference_tool_calls": 46, "required_evidence_reads": 33, "synthetic": true, "venue": "Equal Employment Opportunity Commission", "version": "2.0.0"}, "prompt": "You are employment counsel for Copper State Manufacturing. The client has asked for a board-ready risk assessment supported by a source-level tracker rather than a narrative-only summary. Leave and accommodation records show delayed follow-up, differing restrictions, comparator discipline, and close termination timing. Decision due 2026-09-12. Arizona law governs; Equal Employment Opportunity Commission is the forum. Treat dates, notice mechanics, approval evidence, and numerical reconciliations as independent controls. Work out the defensible position from the matter production and leave an audit-ready exception tracker and concise advice for the supervising lawyer. Keep confirmed conflicts separate from open questions, cite the records that actually control each conclusion, and do not fill gaps with outside facts.", "rubric": {"criteria": [{"category": "procedure", "description": "Complete at least 46 successful, argument-specific evidence and output calls.", "id": "procedure.minimum_successful_tool_calls"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Find and read the 33 controlling, corroborating, and work-product-control records in full.", "id": "procedure.all_evidence_read_in_full"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Inspect file metadata for the eight designated critical primary records before relying on them.", "id": "procedure.chain_of_custody_metadata_checked"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Confirm the sandbox's allowed document and output roots.", "id": "procedure.allowed_directories_checked"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Inventory all 96 records so the relevant sources are discovered among the context records.", "id": "procedure.recursive_inventory_completed"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Search the production for email evidence that may corroborate or contradict formal records.", "id": "procedure.targeted_search_completed"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Leave only findings.json and advice.md in the output workspace.", "id": "procedure.exact_deliverable_set"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Create both final work products through the sandbox MCP surface.", "id": "procedure.deliverables_written_through_mcp"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Produce findings.json as a valid JSON object.", "id": "findings.findings_is_object"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Report exactly 16 confirmed exceptions.", "id": "findings.findings_exact_count"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Use each stable finding ID exactly once.", "id": "findings.finding_ids_unique"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set schema_version to the released matter value '1.0'.", "id": "findings.top_level_schema_version"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set task_id to the released matter value 'cb100-073-copper-state'.", "id": "findings.top_level_task_id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set matter_number to the released matter value 'CB-EL-3103'.", "id": "findings.top_level_matter_number"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set prepared_for to the released matter value 'Copper State Manufacturing'.", "id": "findings.top_level_prepared_for"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set as_of to the released matter value '2026-09-12'.", "id": "findings.top_level_as_of"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-01 exception for classification inconsistency.", "id": "findings.F-01.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's id from /workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/001_handbooks_policies_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_investigations/049_investigations_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's issue from /workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/001_handbooks_policies_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_investigations/049_investigations_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's severity from /workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/001_handbooks_policies_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_investigations/049_investigations_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's primary_source from /workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/001_handbooks_policies_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_investigations/049_investigations_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/001_handbooks_policies_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_investigations/049_investigations_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-01 using the exact controlled facts ['2025-06-22', 'CB-EL-3103-A330', '2025-07-16', 'CB-EL-3103-J879'].", "id": "findings.F-01.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-01's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-01.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-12', 'Isaac Romero'] for F-01.", "id": "findings.F-01.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-02 exception for overtime calculation error.", "id": "findings.F-02.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's id from /workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/004_handbooks_policies_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_investigations/052_investigations_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's issue from /workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/004_handbooks_policies_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_investigations/052_investigations_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's severity from /workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/004_handbooks_policies_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_investigations/052_investigations_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's primary_source from /workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/004_handbooks_policies_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_investigations/052_investigations_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/004_handbooks_policies_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_investigations/052_investigations_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-02 using the exact controlled facts ['$1,345,223.00', '$1,586,946.00'].", "id": "findings.F-02.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-02's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-02.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-12', 'Sofia Bennett'] for F-02.", "id": "findings.F-02.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-03 exception for meal-period premium gap.", "id": "findings.F-03.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's id from /workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/007_handbooks_policies_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_investigations/055_investigations_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's issue from /workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/007_handbooks_policies_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_investigations/055_investigations_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's severity from /workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/007_handbooks_policies_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_investigations/055_investigations_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's primary_source from /workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/007_handbooks_policies_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_investigations/055_investigations_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/007_handbooks_policies_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_investigations/055_investigations_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-03 using the exact controlled facts ['Talia Brooks', 'Henry Cho'].", "id": "findings.F-03.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-03's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-03.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-12', 'Adrian Mensah'] for F-03.", "id": "findings.F-03.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-04 exception for pay-equity outlier.", "id": "findings.F-04.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's id from /workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/010_personnel_records_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_performance_discipline/058_performance_discipline_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's issue from /workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/010_personnel_records_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_performance_discipline/058_performance_discipline_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's severity from /workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/010_personnel_records_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_performance_discipline/058_performance_discipline_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's primary_source from /workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/010_personnel_records_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_performance_discipline/058_performance_discipline_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/010_personnel_records_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_performance_discipline/058_performance_discipline_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-04 using the exact controlled facts ['closed without exception', 'CB-EL-3103-D588', 'open and escalated', 'CB-EL-3103-M691'].", "id": "findings.F-04.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-04's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-04.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-12', 'Willa Novak'] for F-04.", "id": "findings.F-04.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-05 exception for leave designation delay.", "id": "findings.F-05.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's id from /workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/013_personnel_records_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_performance_discipline/061_performance_discipline_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's issue from /workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/013_personnel_records_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_performance_discipline/061_performance_discipline_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's severity from /workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/013_personnel_records_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_performance_discipline/061_performance_discipline_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's primary_source from /workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/013_personnel_records_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_performance_discipline/061_performance_discipline_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/013_personnel_records_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_performance_discipline/061_performance_discipline_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-05 using the exact controlled facts ['Equal Employment Opportunity Commission', 'Arizona'].", "id": "findings.F-05.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-05's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-05.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-12', 'Theo Laurent'] for F-05.", "id": "findings.F-05.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-06 exception for interactive-process lapse.", "id": "findings.F-06.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's id from /workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/016_personnel_records_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_performance_discipline/064_performance_discipline_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's issue from /workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/016_personnel_records_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_performance_discipline/064_performance_discipline_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's severity from /workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/016_personnel_records_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_performance_discipline/064_performance_discipline_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's primary_source from /workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/016_personnel_records_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_performance_discipline/064_performance_discipline_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/016_personnel_records_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_performance_discipline/064_performance_discipline_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-06 using the exact controlled facts ['6%', '8%'].", "id": "findings.F-06.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-06's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-06.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-12', 'Amara Patel'] for F-06.", "id": "findings.F-06.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-07 exception for complaint escalation gap.", "id": "findings.F-07.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's id from /workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/019_payroll_time_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_separation/067_separation_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's issue from /workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/019_payroll_time_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_separation/067_separation_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's severity from /workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/019_payroll_time_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_separation/067_separation_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's primary_source from /workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/019_payroll_time_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_separation/067_separation_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/019_payroll_time_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_separation/067_separation_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-07 using the exact controlled facts ['notices-copper_state_manufacturing@example.test', 'archive-former_quality_engineer@example.test'].", "id": "findings.F-07.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-07's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-07.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-12', 'Henry Cho'] for F-07.", "id": "findings.F-07.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-08 exception for investigation independence concern.", "id": "findings.F-08.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's id from /workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/022_payroll_time_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_separation/070_separation_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's issue from /workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/022_payroll_time_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_separation/070_separation_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's severity from /workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/022_payroll_time_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_separation/070_separation_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's primary_source from /workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/022_payroll_time_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_separation/070_separation_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/022_payroll_time_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_separation/070_separation_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-08 using the exact controlled facts ['117 records', '2025-12-18', '53 records', '2026-01-12'].", "id": "findings.F-08.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-08's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-08.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-12', 'Nadine Flores'] for F-08.", "id": "findings.F-08.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-09 exception for discipline comparator inconsistency.", "id": "findings.F-09.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's id from /workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/025_compensation_equity_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_contractors/073_contractors_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's issue from /workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/025_compensation_equity_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_contractors/073_contractors_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's severity from /workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/025_compensation_equity_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_contractors/073_contractors_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's primary_source from /workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/025_compensation_equity_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_contractors/073_contractors_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/025_compensation_equity_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_contractors/073_contractors_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-09 using the exact controlled facts ['2025-03-09', 'CB-EL-3103-I165', '2025-04-13', 'CB-EL-3103-R658'].", "id": "findings.F-09.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-09's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-09.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-12', 'Micah Sullivan'] for F-09.", "id": "findings.F-09.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-10 exception for retaliation timing.", "id": "findings.F-10.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's id from /workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/028_compensation_equity_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_contractors/076_contractors_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's issue from /workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/028_compensation_equity_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_contractors/076_contractors_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's severity from /workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/028_compensation_equity_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_contractors/076_contractors_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's primary_source from /workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/028_compensation_equity_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_contractors/076_contractors_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/028_compensation_equity_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_contractors/076_contractors_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-10 using the exact controlled facts ['$1,901,763.00', '$2,040,026.00'].", "id": "findings.F-10.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-10's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-10.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-12', 'Farah Ibrahim'] for F-10.", "id": "findings.F-10.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-11 exception for separation pay discrepancy.", "id": "findings.F-11.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's id from /workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/031_compensation_equity_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_contractors/079_contractors_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's issue from /workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/031_compensation_equity_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_contractors/079_contractors_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's severity from /workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/031_compensation_equity_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_contractors/079_contractors_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's primary_source from /workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/031_compensation_equity_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_contractors/079_contractors_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/031_compensation_equity_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_contractors/079_contractors_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-11 using the exact controlled facts ['Talia Brooks', 'Caleb Hassan'].", "id": "findings.F-11.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-11's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-11.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-12', 'Owen Delgado'] for F-11.", "id": "findings.F-11.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-12 exception for restrictive-covenant conflict.", "id": "findings.F-12.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's id from /workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/034_leave_accommodation_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_training/082_training_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's issue from /workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/034_leave_accommodation_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_training/082_training_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's severity from /workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/034_leave_accommodation_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_training/082_training_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's primary_source from /workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/034_leave_accommodation_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_training/082_training_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/034_leave_accommodation_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_training/082_training_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-12 using the exact controlled facts ['closed without exception', 'CB-EL-3103-L684', 'open and escalated', 'CB-EL-3103-U421'].", "id": "findings.F-12.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-12's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-12.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-12', 'Lena Varga'] for F-12.", "id": "findings.F-12.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-13 exception for contractor control evidence.", "id": "findings.F-13.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's id from /workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/037_leave_accommodation_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_training/085_training_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's issue from /workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/037_leave_accommodation_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_training/085_training_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's severity from /workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/037_leave_accommodation_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_training/085_training_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's primary_source from /workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/037_leave_accommodation_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_training/085_training_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/037_leave_accommodation_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_training/085_training_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-13 using the exact controlled facts ['Equal Employment Opportunity Commission', 'Arizona'].", "id": "findings.F-13.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-13's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-13.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-12', 'Samuel Kim'] for F-13.", "id": "findings.F-13.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-14 exception for training completion gap.", "id": "findings.F-14.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's id from /workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/040_leave_accommodation_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_training/088_training_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's issue from /workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/040_leave_accommodation_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_training/088_training_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's severity from /workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/040_leave_accommodation_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_training/088_training_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's primary_source from /workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/040_leave_accommodation_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_training/088_training_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/040_leave_accommodation_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_training/088_training_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-14 using the exact controlled facts ['9%', '16%'].", "id": "findings.F-14.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-14's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-14.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-12', 'Maya Ellison'] for F-14.", "id": "findings.F-14.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-15 exception for personnel-file access deadline.", "id": "findings.F-15.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's id from /workspace/documents/06_complaints/043_complaints_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/091_agency_matters_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's issue from /workspace/documents/06_complaints/043_complaints_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/091_agency_matters_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's severity from /workspace/documents/06_complaints/043_complaints_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/091_agency_matters_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's primary_source from /workspace/documents/06_complaints/043_complaints_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/091_agency_matters_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/06_complaints/043_complaints_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/091_agency_matters_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-15 using the exact controlled facts ['notices-copper_state_manufacturing@example.test', 'archive-former_quality_engineer@example.test'].", "id": "findings.F-15.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-15's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-15.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-12', 'Rafael Okafor'] for F-15.", "id": "findings.F-15.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-16 exception for agency response commitment.", "id": "findings.F-16.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's id from /workspace/documents/06_complaints/046_complaints_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/094_agency_matters_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's issue from /workspace/documents/06_complaints/046_complaints_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/094_agency_matters_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's severity from /workspace/documents/06_complaints/046_complaints_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/094_agency_matters_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's primary_source from /workspace/documents/06_complaints/046_complaints_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/094_agency_matters_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/06_complaints/046_complaints_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/094_agency_matters_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-16 using the exact controlled facts ['130 records', '2025-03-26', '73 records', '2025-05-10'].", "id": "findings.F-16.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-16's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-16.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-12', 'Nora Chen'] for F-16.", "id": "findings.F-16.action_anchors"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Executive assessment' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Executive assessment"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Method and record coverage' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Method and record coverage"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Findings' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Findings"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Recommended next actions' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Recommended next actions"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Assumptions and limitations' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Assumptions and limitations"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-01 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-01"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-02 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-02"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-03 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-03"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-04 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-04"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-05 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-05"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-06 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-06"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-07 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-07"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-08 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-08"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-09 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-09"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-10 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-10"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-11 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-11"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-12 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-12"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-13 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-13"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-14 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-14"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-15 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-15"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-16 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-16"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Do not claim the production has no issues or that every record is consistent.", "id": "memo.forbidden_claims_absent"}], "decision_options": [{"id": "cross-source-reconciliation", "label": "Reconcile controlling and corroborating records", "reason": "The CB-EL-3103 production contains independently maintained records; a defensible answer must preserve each supported conflict and its cure owner.", "selected": true}, {"id": "latest-record-controls", "label": "Treat the latest record as controlling", "reason": "Timestamp recency does not establish legal priority, execution, or approval authority.", "selected": false}, {"id": "primary-records-only", "label": "Report primary records without reconciliation", "reason": "Primary records alone conceal the operational conflicts that create the actionable exceptions.", "selected": false}], "gates": ["all_evidence_read_in_full", "chain_of_custody_metadata_checked", "findings_criteria_complete", "memo_criteria_complete", "deliverables_written_through_mcp"], "metadata_checks": 8, "metric": "weighted_criteria_score", "minimum_tool_calls": 46, "required_deliverables": ["findings.json", "advice.md"], "required_document_reads": 33, "type": "deterministic", "weights": {"findings": 0.55, "memo": 0.2, "procedure": 0.25}}, "task_id": "cb100-073-copper-state", "task_name": "Copper State accommodation audit", "world_id": "counselbench-filesystem-mcp-v2"}
-{"context_files": ["task_files/cb100-074-daymark-bank/01_handbooks_policies/001_handbooks_policies_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-074-daymark-bank/01_handbooks_policies/002_handbooks_policies_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-074-daymark-bank/01_handbooks_policies/003_handbooks_policies_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-074-daymark-bank/01_handbooks_policies/004_handbooks_policies_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-074-daymark-bank/01_handbooks_policies/005_handbooks_policies_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-074-daymark-bank/01_handbooks_policies/006_handbooks_policies_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-074-daymark-bank/01_handbooks_policies/007_handbooks_policies_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-074-daymark-bank/01_handbooks_policies/008_handbooks_policies_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-074-daymark-bank/02_personnel_records/009_personnel_records_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-074-daymark-bank/02_personnel_records/010_personnel_records_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-074-daymark-bank/02_personnel_records/011_personnel_records_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-074-daymark-bank/02_personnel_records/012_personnel_records_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-074-daymark-bank/02_personnel_records/013_personnel_records_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-074-daymark-bank/02_personnel_records/014_personnel_records_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-074-daymark-bank/02_personnel_records/015_personnel_records_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-074-daymark-bank/02_personnel_records/016_personnel_records_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-074-daymark-bank/03_payroll_time/017_payroll_time_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-074-daymark-bank/03_payroll_time/018_payroll_time_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-074-daymark-bank/03_payroll_time/019_payroll_time_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-074-daymark-bank/03_payroll_time/020_payroll_time_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-074-daymark-bank/03_payroll_time/021_payroll_time_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-074-daymark-bank/03_payroll_time/022_payroll_time_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-074-daymark-bank/03_payroll_time/023_payroll_time_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-074-daymark-bank/03_payroll_time/024_payroll_time_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-074-daymark-bank/04_compensation_equity/025_compensation_equity_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-074-daymark-bank/04_compensation_equity/026_compensation_equity_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-074-daymark-bank/04_compensation_equity/027_compensation_equity_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-074-daymark-bank/04_compensation_equity/028_compensation_equity_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-074-daymark-bank/04_compensation_equity/029_compensation_equity_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-074-daymark-bank/04_compensation_equity/030_compensation_equity_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-074-daymark-bank/04_compensation_equity/031_compensation_equity_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-074-daymark-bank/04_compensation_equity/032_compensation_equity_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-074-daymark-bank/05_leave_accommodation/033_leave_accommodation_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-074-daymark-bank/05_leave_accommodation/034_leave_accommodation_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-074-daymark-bank/05_leave_accommodation/035_leave_accommodation_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-074-daymark-bank/05_leave_accommodation/036_leave_accommodation_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-074-daymark-bank/05_leave_accommodation/037_leave_accommodation_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-074-daymark-bank/05_leave_accommodation/038_leave_accommodation_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-074-daymark-bank/05_leave_accommodation/039_leave_accommodation_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-074-daymark-bank/05_leave_accommodation/040_leave_accommodation_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-074-daymark-bank/06_complaints/041_complaints_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-074-daymark-bank/06_complaints/042_complaints_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-074-daymark-bank/06_complaints/043_complaints_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-074-daymark-bank/06_complaints/044_complaints_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-074-daymark-bank/06_complaints/045_complaints_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-074-daymark-bank/06_complaints/046_complaints_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-074-daymark-bank/06_complaints/047_complaints_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-074-daymark-bank/06_complaints/048_complaints_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-074-daymark-bank/07_investigations/049_investigations_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-074-daymark-bank/07_investigations/050_investigations_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-074-daymark-bank/07_investigations/051_investigations_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-074-daymark-bank/07_investigations/052_investigations_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-074-daymark-bank/07_investigations/053_investigations_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-074-daymark-bank/07_investigations/054_investigations_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-074-daymark-bank/07_investigations/055_investigations_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-074-daymark-bank/07_investigations/056_investigations_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-074-daymark-bank/08_performance_discipline/057_performance_discipline_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-074-daymark-bank/08_performance_discipline/058_performance_discipline_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-074-daymark-bank/08_performance_discipline/059_performance_discipline_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-074-daymark-bank/08_performance_discipline/060_performance_discipline_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-074-daymark-bank/08_performance_discipline/061_performance_discipline_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-074-daymark-bank/08_performance_discipline/062_performance_discipline_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-074-daymark-bank/08_performance_discipline/063_performance_discipline_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-074-daymark-bank/08_performance_discipline/064_performance_discipline_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-074-daymark-bank/09_separation/065_separation_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-074-daymark-bank/09_separation/066_separation_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-074-daymark-bank/09_separation/067_separation_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-074-daymark-bank/09_separation/068_separation_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-074-daymark-bank/09_separation/069_separation_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-074-daymark-bank/09_separation/070_separation_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-074-daymark-bank/09_separation/071_separation_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-074-daymark-bank/09_separation/072_separation_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-074-daymark-bank/10_contractors/073_contractors_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-074-daymark-bank/10_contractors/074_contractors_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-074-daymark-bank/10_contractors/075_contractors_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-074-daymark-bank/10_contractors/076_contractors_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-074-daymark-bank/10_contractors/077_contractors_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-074-daymark-bank/10_contractors/078_contractors_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-074-daymark-bank/10_contractors/079_contractors_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-074-daymark-bank/10_contractors/080_contractors_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-074-daymark-bank/11_training/081_training_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-074-daymark-bank/11_training/082_training_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-074-daymark-bank/11_training/083_training_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-074-daymark-bank/11_training/084_training_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-074-daymark-bank/11_training/085_training_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-074-daymark-bank/11_training/086_training_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-074-daymark-bank/11_training/087_training_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-074-daymark-bank/11_training/088_training_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-074-daymark-bank/12_agency_matters/089_agency_matters_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-074-daymark-bank/12_agency_matters/090_agency_matters_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-074-daymark-bank/12_agency_matters/091_agency_matters_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-074-daymark-bank/12_agency_matters/092_agency_matters_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-074-daymark-bank/12_agency_matters/093_agency_matters_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-074-daymark-bank/12_agency_matters/094_agency_matters_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-074-daymark-bank/12_agency_matters/095_agency_matters_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-074-daymark-bank/12_agency_matters/096_agency_matters_status_report.md"], "gold_output": {"advice_markdown": "# Counsel advice — Daymark pay-equity privileged audit\n\n## Executive assessment\n\nFor Daymark Community Bank matter CB-EL-3104, the review identified 16 source-supported exceptions requiring action before 2026-09-16. The assessment concerns Compensation review group and the supplied record for North Carolina.\n\n## Method and record coverage\n\nThe review inventoried all 96 production files, read the 33 controlling, corroborating, and control records, searched the email exports, and checked metadata for the designated chain-of-custody sample. Conclusions are limited to the synthetic production supplied for this benchmark matter.\n\n## Findings\n\n### F-01 — classification inconsistency (critical)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for classification inconsistency: one source states the operative date is 2026-02-15 under control reference CB-EL-3104-A568, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2026-03-23 under response reference CB-EL-3104-J551.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/001_handbooks_policies_control_register.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/07_investigations/049_investigations_control_register.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-16, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Sofia Bennett.\n\n### F-02 — overtime calculation error (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for overtime calculation error: one source states the controlling amount is $3,142,847.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $3,342,194.00.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/004_handbooks_policies_ledger_export.csv`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/07_investigations/052_investigations_ledger_export.csv`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-16, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Adrian Mensah.\n\n### F-03 — meal-period premium gap (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for meal-period premium gap: one source states approval is attributed to Jonas Feld as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Micah Sullivan and contains no entry for Jonas Feld.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/007_handbooks_policies_officer_certificate.html`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/07_investigations/055_investigations_officer_certificate.html`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-16, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Willa Novak.\n\n### F-04 — pay-equity outlier (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for pay-equity outlier: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-EL-3104-D344, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-EL-3104-M672.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/010_personnel_records_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/08_performance_discipline/058_performance_discipline_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-16, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Theo Laurent.\n\n### F-05 — leave designation delay (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for leave designation delay: one source states the applicable location is United States Department of Labor, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to North Carolina operations outside United States Department of Labor.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/013_personnel_records_review_memorandum.json`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/08_performance_discipline/061_performance_discipline_review_memorandum.json`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-16, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Amara Patel.\n\n### F-06 — interactive-process lapse (low)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for interactive-process lapse: one source states the threshold is 7% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 12% and produced a different exception result.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/016_personnel_records_status_report.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/08_performance_discipline/064_performance_discipline_status_report.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-16, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Henry Cho.\n\n### F-07 — complaint escalation gap (critical)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for complaint escalation gap: one source states formal notice must use notices-daymark_community_bank@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-compensation_review_group@example.test.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/019_payroll_time_correspondence.eml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/09_separation/067_separation_correspondence.eml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-16, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Nadine Flores.\n\n### F-08 — investigation independence concern (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for investigation independence concern: one source states the governed population contains 151 records through 2025-09-03, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 46 records through 2025-09-21.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/022_payroll_time_formal_notice.xml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/09_separation/070_separation_formal_notice.xml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-16, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Micah Sullivan.\n\n### F-09 — discipline comparator inconsistency (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for discipline comparator inconsistency: one source states the operative date is 2025-09-19 under control reference CB-EL-3104-I299, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2025-10-06 under response reference CB-EL-3104-R461.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/025_compensation_equity_control_register.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/10_contractors/073_contractors_control_register.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-16, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Farah Ibrahim.\n\n### F-10 — retaliation timing (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for retaliation timing: one source states the controlling amount is $5,299,666.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $5,555,832.00.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/028_compensation_equity_ledger_export.csv`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/10_contractors/076_contractors_ledger_export.csv`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-16, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Owen Delgado.\n\n### F-11 — separation pay discrepancy (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for separation pay discrepancy: one source states approval is attributed to Jonas Feld as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Isaac Romero and contains no entry for Jonas Feld.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/031_compensation_equity_officer_certificate.html`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/10_contractors/079_contractors_officer_certificate.html`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-16, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Lena Varga.\n\n### F-12 — restrictive-covenant conflict (low)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for restrictive-covenant conflict: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-EL-3104-L957, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-EL-3104-U373.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/034_leave_accommodation_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/11_training/082_training_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-16, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Samuel Kim.\n\n### F-13 — contractor control evidence (critical)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for contractor control evidence: one source states the applicable location is United States Department of Labor, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to North Carolina operations outside United States Department of Labor.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/037_leave_accommodation_review_memorandum.json`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/11_training/085_training_review_memorandum.json`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-16, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Maya Ellison.\n\n### F-14 — training completion gap (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for training completion gap: one source states the threshold is 15% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 22% and produced a different exception result.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/040_leave_accommodation_status_report.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/11_training/088_training_status_report.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-16, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Rafael Okafor.\n\n### F-15 — personnel-file access deadline (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for personnel-file access deadline: one source states formal notice must use notices-daymark_community_bank@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-compensation_review_group@example.test.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/06_complaints/043_complaints_correspondence.eml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/091_agency_matters_correspondence.eml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-16, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Nora Chen.\n\n### F-16 — agency response commitment (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for agency response commitment: one source states the governed population contains 136 records through 2025-08-19, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 63 records through 2025-09-23.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/06_complaints/046_complaints_formal_notice.xml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/094_agency_matters_formal_notice.xml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-16, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Dominic Alvarez.\n\n## Recommended next actions\n\nSequence the critical and high findings first, assign the named owners, preserve the cited records, and document any resolution in the controlling matter register before the stated deadline.\n\n## Assumptions and limitations\n\nThis analysis is confined to task cb100-074-daymark-bank and the supplied synthetic evidence. It does not rely on external facts, does not resolve disputed law, and is not legal advice for a real person or entity.\n", "findings": {"as_of": "2026-09-16", "findings": [{"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/07_investigations/049_investigations_control_register.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for classification inconsistency: one source states the operative date is 2026-02-15 under control reference CB-EL-3104-A568, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2026-03-23 under response reference CB-EL-3104-J551.", "id": "F-01", "issue": "classification inconsistency", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/001_handbooks_policies_control_register.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-16, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Sofia Bennett.", "severity": "critical"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/07_investigations/052_investigations_ledger_export.csv", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for overtime calculation error: one source states the controlling amount is $3,142,847.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $3,342,194.00.", "id": "F-02", "issue": "overtime calculation error", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/004_handbooks_policies_ledger_export.csv", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-16, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Adrian Mensah.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/07_investigations/055_investigations_officer_certificate.html", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for meal-period premium gap: one source states approval is attributed to Jonas Feld as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Micah Sullivan and contains no entry for Jonas Feld.", "id": "F-03", "issue": "meal-period premium gap", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/007_handbooks_policies_officer_certificate.html", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-16, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Willa Novak.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/08_performance_discipline/058_performance_discipline_executed_instrument.txt", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for pay-equity outlier: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-EL-3104-D344, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-EL-3104-M672.", "id": "F-04", "issue": "pay-equity outlier", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/010_personnel_records_executed_instrument.txt", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-16, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Theo Laurent.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/08_performance_discipline/061_performance_discipline_review_memorandum.json", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for leave designation delay: one source states the applicable location is United States Department of Labor, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to North Carolina operations outside United States Department of Labor.", "id": "F-05", "issue": "leave designation delay", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/013_personnel_records_review_memorandum.json", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-16, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Amara Patel.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/08_performance_discipline/064_performance_discipline_status_report.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for interactive-process lapse: one source states the threshold is 7% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 12% and produced a different exception result.", "id": "F-06", "issue": "interactive-process lapse", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/016_personnel_records_status_report.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-16, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Henry Cho.", "severity": "low"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/09_separation/067_separation_correspondence.eml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for complaint escalation gap: one source states formal notice must use notices-daymark_community_bank@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-compensation_review_group@example.test.", "id": "F-07", "issue": "complaint escalation gap", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/019_payroll_time_correspondence.eml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-16, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Nadine Flores.", "severity": "critical"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/09_separation/070_separation_formal_notice.xml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for investigation independence concern: one source states the governed population contains 151 records through 2025-09-03, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 46 records through 2025-09-21.", "id": "F-08", "issue": "investigation independence concern", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/022_payroll_time_formal_notice.xml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-16, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Micah Sullivan.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/10_contractors/073_contractors_control_register.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for discipline comparator inconsistency: one source states the operative date is 2025-09-19 under control reference CB-EL-3104-I299, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2025-10-06 under response reference CB-EL-3104-R461.", "id": "F-09", "issue": "discipline comparator inconsistency", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/025_compensation_equity_control_register.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-16, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Farah Ibrahim.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/10_contractors/076_contractors_ledger_export.csv", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for retaliation timing: one source states the controlling amount is $5,299,666.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $5,555,832.00.", "id": "F-10", "issue": "retaliation timing", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/028_compensation_equity_ledger_export.csv", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-16, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Owen Delgado.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/10_contractors/079_contractors_officer_certificate.html", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for separation pay discrepancy: one source states approval is attributed to Jonas Feld as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Isaac Romero and contains no entry for Jonas Feld.", "id": "F-11", "issue": "separation pay discrepancy", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/031_compensation_equity_officer_certificate.html", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-16, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Lena Varga.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/11_training/082_training_executed_instrument.txt", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for restrictive-covenant conflict: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-EL-3104-L957, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-EL-3104-U373.", "id": "F-12", "issue": "restrictive-covenant conflict", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/034_leave_accommodation_executed_instrument.txt", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-16, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Samuel Kim.", "severity": "low"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/11_training/085_training_review_memorandum.json", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for contractor control evidence: one source states the applicable location is United States Department of Labor, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to North Carolina operations outside United States Department of Labor.", "id": "F-13", "issue": "contractor control evidence", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/037_leave_accommodation_review_memorandum.json", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-16, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Maya Ellison.", "severity": "critical"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/11_training/088_training_status_report.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for training completion gap: one source states the threshold is 15% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 22% and produced a different exception result.", "id": "F-14", "issue": "training completion gap", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/040_leave_accommodation_status_report.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-16, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Rafael Okafor.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/091_agency_matters_correspondence.eml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for personnel-file access deadline: one source states formal notice must use notices-daymark_community_bank@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-compensation_review_group@example.test.", "id": "F-15", "issue": "personnel-file access deadline", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/06_complaints/043_complaints_correspondence.eml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-16, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Nora Chen.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/094_agency_matters_formal_notice.xml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for agency response commitment: one source states the governed population contains 136 records through 2025-08-19, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 63 records through 2025-09-23.", "id": "F-16", "issue": "agency response commitment", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/06_complaints/046_complaints_formal_notice.xml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-16, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Dominic Alvarez.", "severity": "medium"}], "matter_number": "CB-EL-3104", "prepared_for": "Daymark Community Bank", "schema_version": "1.0", "task_id": "cb100-074-daymark-bank"}}, "metadata": {"benchmark": "CounselBench-100", "code_license": "Apache-2.0", "data_license": "CC-BY-4.0", "deadline": "2026-09-16", "document_count": 96, "jurisdiction": "North Carolina", "matter_number": "CB-EL-3104", "mcp_commit": "9a96ea6e5913736f92b88345bf51caeaaa8e719f", "mcp_package": "@modelcontextprotocol/server-filesystem@2026.7.10", "practice_area": "employment", "reference_tool_calls": 46, "required_evidence_reads": 33, "synthetic": true, "venue": "United States Department of Labor", "version": "2.0.0"}, "prompt": "You are employment counsel for Daymark Community Bank. Several workstreams have maintained separate versions of the truth; your assignment is to produce one auditable legal view. Job architecture, bonuses, performance ratings, and manager messages reveal unexplained compensation outliers in two regions. Decision due 2026-09-16. North Carolina law governs; United States Department of Labor is the forum. Distinguish a missing document from an affirmative contradiction in the documents that are present. Work out the defensible position from the matter production and leave an audit-ready exception tracker and concise advice for the supervising lawyer. Keep confirmed conflicts separate from open questions, cite the records that actually control each conclusion, and do not fill gaps with outside facts.", "rubric": {"criteria": [{"category": "procedure", "description": "Complete at least 46 successful, argument-specific evidence and output calls.", "id": "procedure.minimum_successful_tool_calls"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Find and read the 33 controlling, corroborating, and work-product-control records in full.", "id": "procedure.all_evidence_read_in_full"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Inspect file metadata for the eight designated critical primary records before relying on them.", "id": "procedure.chain_of_custody_metadata_checked"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Confirm the sandbox's allowed document and output roots.", "id": "procedure.allowed_directories_checked"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Inventory all 96 records so the relevant sources are discovered among the context records.", "id": "procedure.recursive_inventory_completed"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Search the production for email evidence that may corroborate or contradict formal records.", "id": "procedure.targeted_search_completed"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Leave only findings.json and advice.md in the output workspace.", "id": "procedure.exact_deliverable_set"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Create both final work products through the sandbox MCP surface.", "id": "procedure.deliverables_written_through_mcp"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Produce findings.json as a valid JSON object.", "id": "findings.findings_is_object"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Report exactly 16 confirmed exceptions.", "id": "findings.findings_exact_count"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Use each stable finding ID exactly once.", "id": "findings.finding_ids_unique"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set schema_version to the released matter value '1.0'.", "id": "findings.top_level_schema_version"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set task_id to the released matter value 'cb100-074-daymark-bank'.", "id": "findings.top_level_task_id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set matter_number to the released matter value 'CB-EL-3104'.", "id": "findings.top_level_matter_number"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set prepared_for to the released matter value 'Daymark Community Bank'.", "id": "findings.top_level_prepared_for"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set as_of to the released matter value '2026-09-16'.", "id": "findings.top_level_as_of"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-01 exception for classification inconsistency.", "id": "findings.F-01.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's id from /workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/001_handbooks_policies_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_investigations/049_investigations_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's issue from /workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/001_handbooks_policies_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_investigations/049_investigations_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's severity from /workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/001_handbooks_policies_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_investigations/049_investigations_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's primary_source from /workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/001_handbooks_policies_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_investigations/049_investigations_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/001_handbooks_policies_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_investigations/049_investigations_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-01 using the exact controlled facts ['2026-02-15', 'CB-EL-3104-A568', '2026-03-23', 'CB-EL-3104-J551'].", "id": "findings.F-01.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-01's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-01.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-16', 'Sofia Bennett'] for F-01.", "id": "findings.F-01.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-02 exception for overtime calculation error.", "id": "findings.F-02.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's id from /workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/004_handbooks_policies_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_investigations/052_investigations_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's issue from /workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/004_handbooks_policies_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_investigations/052_investigations_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's severity from /workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/004_handbooks_policies_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_investigations/052_investigations_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's primary_source from /workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/004_handbooks_policies_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_investigations/052_investigations_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/004_handbooks_policies_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_investigations/052_investigations_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-02 using the exact controlled facts ['$3,142,847.00', '$3,342,194.00'].", "id": "findings.F-02.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-02's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-02.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-16', 'Adrian Mensah'] for F-02.", "id": "findings.F-02.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-03 exception for meal-period premium gap.", "id": "findings.F-03.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's id from /workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/007_handbooks_policies_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_investigations/055_investigations_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's issue from /workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/007_handbooks_policies_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_investigations/055_investigations_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's severity from /workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/007_handbooks_policies_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_investigations/055_investigations_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's primary_source from /workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/007_handbooks_policies_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_investigations/055_investigations_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/007_handbooks_policies_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_investigations/055_investigations_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-03 using the exact controlled facts ['Jonas Feld', 'Micah Sullivan'].", "id": "findings.F-03.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-03's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-03.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-16', 'Willa Novak'] for F-03.", "id": "findings.F-03.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-04 exception for pay-equity outlier.", "id": "findings.F-04.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's id from /workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/010_personnel_records_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_performance_discipline/058_performance_discipline_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's issue from /workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/010_personnel_records_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_performance_discipline/058_performance_discipline_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's severity from /workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/010_personnel_records_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_performance_discipline/058_performance_discipline_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's primary_source from /workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/010_personnel_records_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_performance_discipline/058_performance_discipline_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/010_personnel_records_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_performance_discipline/058_performance_discipline_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-04 using the exact controlled facts ['closed without exception', 'CB-EL-3104-D344', 'open and escalated', 'CB-EL-3104-M672'].", "id": "findings.F-04.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-04's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-04.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-16', 'Theo Laurent'] for F-04.", "id": "findings.F-04.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-05 exception for leave designation delay.", "id": "findings.F-05.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's id from /workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/013_personnel_records_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_performance_discipline/061_performance_discipline_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's issue from /workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/013_personnel_records_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_performance_discipline/061_performance_discipline_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's severity from /workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/013_personnel_records_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_performance_discipline/061_performance_discipline_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's primary_source from /workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/013_personnel_records_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_performance_discipline/061_performance_discipline_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/013_personnel_records_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_performance_discipline/061_performance_discipline_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-05 using the exact controlled facts ['United States Department of Labor', 'North Carolina'].", "id": "findings.F-05.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-05's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-05.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-16', 'Amara Patel'] for F-05.", "id": "findings.F-05.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-06 exception for interactive-process lapse.", "id": "findings.F-06.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's id from /workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/016_personnel_records_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_performance_discipline/064_performance_discipline_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's issue from /workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/016_personnel_records_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_performance_discipline/064_performance_discipline_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's severity from /workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/016_personnel_records_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_performance_discipline/064_performance_discipline_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's primary_source from /workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/016_personnel_records_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_performance_discipline/064_performance_discipline_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/016_personnel_records_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_performance_discipline/064_performance_discipline_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-06 using the exact controlled facts ['7%', '12%'].", "id": "findings.F-06.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-06's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-06.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-16', 'Henry Cho'] for F-06.", "id": "findings.F-06.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-07 exception for complaint escalation gap.", "id": "findings.F-07.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's id from /workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/019_payroll_time_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_separation/067_separation_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's issue from /workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/019_payroll_time_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_separation/067_separation_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's severity from /workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/019_payroll_time_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_separation/067_separation_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's primary_source from /workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/019_payroll_time_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_separation/067_separation_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/019_payroll_time_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_separation/067_separation_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-07 using the exact controlled facts ['notices-daymark_community_bank@example.test', 'archive-compensation_review_group@example.test'].", "id": "findings.F-07.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-07's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-07.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-16', 'Nadine Flores'] for F-07.", "id": "findings.F-07.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-08 exception for investigation independence concern.", "id": "findings.F-08.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's id from /workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/022_payroll_time_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_separation/070_separation_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's issue from /workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/022_payroll_time_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_separation/070_separation_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's severity from /workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/022_payroll_time_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_separation/070_separation_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's primary_source from /workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/022_payroll_time_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_separation/070_separation_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/022_payroll_time_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_separation/070_separation_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-08 using the exact controlled facts ['151 records', '2025-09-03', '46 records', '2025-09-21'].", "id": "findings.F-08.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-08's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-08.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-16', 'Micah Sullivan'] for F-08.", "id": "findings.F-08.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-09 exception for discipline comparator inconsistency.", "id": "findings.F-09.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's id from /workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/025_compensation_equity_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_contractors/073_contractors_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's issue from /workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/025_compensation_equity_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_contractors/073_contractors_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's severity from /workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/025_compensation_equity_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_contractors/073_contractors_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's primary_source from /workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/025_compensation_equity_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_contractors/073_contractors_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/025_compensation_equity_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_contractors/073_contractors_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-09 using the exact controlled facts ['2025-09-19', 'CB-EL-3104-I299', '2025-10-06', 'CB-EL-3104-R461'].", "id": "findings.F-09.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-09's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-09.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-16', 'Farah Ibrahim'] for F-09.", "id": "findings.F-09.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-10 exception for retaliation timing.", "id": "findings.F-10.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's id from /workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/028_compensation_equity_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_contractors/076_contractors_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's issue from /workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/028_compensation_equity_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_contractors/076_contractors_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's severity from /workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/028_compensation_equity_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_contractors/076_contractors_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's primary_source from /workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/028_compensation_equity_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_contractors/076_contractors_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/028_compensation_equity_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_contractors/076_contractors_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-10 using the exact controlled facts ['$5,299,666.00', '$5,555,832.00'].", "id": "findings.F-10.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-10's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-10.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-16', 'Owen Delgado'] for F-10.", "id": "findings.F-10.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-11 exception for separation pay discrepancy.", "id": "findings.F-11.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's id from /workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/031_compensation_equity_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_contractors/079_contractors_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's issue from /workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/031_compensation_equity_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_contractors/079_contractors_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's severity from /workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/031_compensation_equity_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_contractors/079_contractors_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's primary_source from /workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/031_compensation_equity_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_contractors/079_contractors_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/031_compensation_equity_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_contractors/079_contractors_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-11 using the exact controlled facts ['Jonas Feld', 'Isaac Romero'].", "id": "findings.F-11.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-11's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-11.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-16', 'Lena Varga'] for F-11.", "id": "findings.F-11.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-12 exception for restrictive-covenant conflict.", "id": "findings.F-12.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's id from /workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/034_leave_accommodation_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_training/082_training_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's issue from /workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/034_leave_accommodation_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_training/082_training_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's severity from /workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/034_leave_accommodation_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_training/082_training_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's primary_source from /workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/034_leave_accommodation_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_training/082_training_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/034_leave_accommodation_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_training/082_training_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-12 using the exact controlled facts ['closed without exception', 'CB-EL-3104-L957', 'open and escalated', 'CB-EL-3104-U373'].", "id": "findings.F-12.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-12's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-12.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-16', 'Samuel Kim'] for F-12.", "id": "findings.F-12.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-13 exception for contractor control evidence.", "id": "findings.F-13.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's id from /workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/037_leave_accommodation_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_training/085_training_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's issue from /workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/037_leave_accommodation_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_training/085_training_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's severity from /workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/037_leave_accommodation_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_training/085_training_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's primary_source from /workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/037_leave_accommodation_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_training/085_training_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/037_leave_accommodation_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_training/085_training_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-13 using the exact controlled facts ['United States Department of Labor', 'North Carolina'].", "id": "findings.F-13.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-13's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-13.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-16', 'Maya Ellison'] for F-13.", "id": "findings.F-13.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-14 exception for training completion gap.", "id": "findings.F-14.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's id from /workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/040_leave_accommodation_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_training/088_training_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's issue from /workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/040_leave_accommodation_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_training/088_training_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's severity from /workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/040_leave_accommodation_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_training/088_training_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's primary_source from /workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/040_leave_accommodation_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_training/088_training_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/040_leave_accommodation_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_training/088_training_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-14 using the exact controlled facts ['15%', '22%'].", "id": "findings.F-14.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-14's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-14.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-16', 'Rafael Okafor'] for F-14.", "id": "findings.F-14.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-15 exception for personnel-file access deadline.", "id": "findings.F-15.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's id from /workspace/documents/06_complaints/043_complaints_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/091_agency_matters_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's issue from /workspace/documents/06_complaints/043_complaints_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/091_agency_matters_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's severity from /workspace/documents/06_complaints/043_complaints_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/091_agency_matters_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's primary_source from /workspace/documents/06_complaints/043_complaints_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/091_agency_matters_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/06_complaints/043_complaints_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/091_agency_matters_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-15 using the exact controlled facts ['notices-daymark_community_bank@example.test', 'archive-compensation_review_group@example.test'].", "id": "findings.F-15.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-15's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-15.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-16', 'Nora Chen'] for F-15.", "id": "findings.F-15.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-16 exception for agency response commitment.", "id": "findings.F-16.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's id from /workspace/documents/06_complaints/046_complaints_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/094_agency_matters_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's issue from /workspace/documents/06_complaints/046_complaints_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/094_agency_matters_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's severity from /workspace/documents/06_complaints/046_complaints_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/094_agency_matters_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's primary_source from /workspace/documents/06_complaints/046_complaints_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/094_agency_matters_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/06_complaints/046_complaints_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/094_agency_matters_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-16 using the exact controlled facts ['136 records', '2025-08-19', '63 records', '2025-09-23'].", "id": "findings.F-16.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-16's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-16.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-16', 'Dominic Alvarez'] for F-16.", "id": "findings.F-16.action_anchors"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Executive assessment' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Executive assessment"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Method and record coverage' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Method and record coverage"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Findings' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Findings"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Recommended next actions' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Recommended next actions"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Assumptions and limitations' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Assumptions and limitations"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-01 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-01"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-02 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-02"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-03 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-03"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-04 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-04"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-05 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-05"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-06 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-06"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-07 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-07"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-08 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-08"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-09 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-09"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-10 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-10"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-11 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-11"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-12 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-12"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-13 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-13"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-14 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-14"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-15 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-15"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-16 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-16"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Do not claim the production has no issues or that every record is consistent.", "id": "memo.forbidden_claims_absent"}], "decision_options": [{"id": "cross-source-reconciliation", "label": "Reconcile controlling and corroborating records", "reason": "The CB-EL-3104 production contains independently maintained records; a defensible answer must preserve each supported conflict and its cure owner.", "selected": true}, {"id": "latest-record-controls", "label": "Treat the latest record as controlling", "reason": "Timestamp recency does not establish legal priority, execution, or approval authority.", "selected": false}, {"id": "primary-records-only", "label": "Report primary records without reconciliation", "reason": "Primary records alone conceal the operational conflicts that create the actionable exceptions.", "selected": false}], "gates": ["all_evidence_read_in_full", "chain_of_custody_metadata_checked", "findings_criteria_complete", "memo_criteria_complete", "deliverables_written_through_mcp"], "metadata_checks": 8, "metric": "weighted_criteria_score", "minimum_tool_calls": 46, "required_deliverables": ["findings.json", "advice.md"], "required_document_reads": 33, "type": "deterministic", "weights": {"findings": 0.55, "memo": 0.2, "procedure": 0.25}}, "task_id": "cb100-074-daymark-bank", "task_name": "Daymark pay-equity privileged audit", "world_id": "counselbench-filesystem-mcp-v2"}
-{"context_files": ["task_files/cb100-075-elmwood-retail/01_handbooks_policies/001_handbooks_policies_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-075-elmwood-retail/01_handbooks_policies/002_handbooks_policies_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-075-elmwood-retail/01_handbooks_policies/003_handbooks_policies_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-075-elmwood-retail/01_handbooks_policies/004_handbooks_policies_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-075-elmwood-retail/01_handbooks_policies/005_handbooks_policies_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-075-elmwood-retail/01_handbooks_policies/006_handbooks_policies_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-075-elmwood-retail/01_handbooks_policies/007_handbooks_policies_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-075-elmwood-retail/01_handbooks_policies/008_handbooks_policies_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-075-elmwood-retail/02_personnel_records/009_personnel_records_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-075-elmwood-retail/02_personnel_records/010_personnel_records_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-075-elmwood-retail/02_personnel_records/011_personnel_records_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-075-elmwood-retail/02_personnel_records/012_personnel_records_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-075-elmwood-retail/02_personnel_records/013_personnel_records_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-075-elmwood-retail/02_personnel_records/014_personnel_records_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-075-elmwood-retail/02_personnel_records/015_personnel_records_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-075-elmwood-retail/02_personnel_records/016_personnel_records_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-075-elmwood-retail/03_payroll_time/017_payroll_time_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-075-elmwood-retail/03_payroll_time/018_payroll_time_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-075-elmwood-retail/03_payroll_time/019_payroll_time_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-075-elmwood-retail/03_payroll_time/020_payroll_time_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-075-elmwood-retail/03_payroll_time/021_payroll_time_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-075-elmwood-retail/03_payroll_time/022_payroll_time_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-075-elmwood-retail/03_payroll_time/023_payroll_time_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-075-elmwood-retail/03_payroll_time/024_payroll_time_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-075-elmwood-retail/04_compensation_equity/025_compensation_equity_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-075-elmwood-retail/04_compensation_equity/026_compensation_equity_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-075-elmwood-retail/04_compensation_equity/027_compensation_equity_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-075-elmwood-retail/04_compensation_equity/028_compensation_equity_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-075-elmwood-retail/04_compensation_equity/029_compensation_equity_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-075-elmwood-retail/04_compensation_equity/030_compensation_equity_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-075-elmwood-retail/04_compensation_equity/031_compensation_equity_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-075-elmwood-retail/04_compensation_equity/032_compensation_equity_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-075-elmwood-retail/05_leave_accommodation/033_leave_accommodation_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-075-elmwood-retail/05_leave_accommodation/034_leave_accommodation_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-075-elmwood-retail/05_leave_accommodation/035_leave_accommodation_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-075-elmwood-retail/05_leave_accommodation/036_leave_accommodation_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-075-elmwood-retail/05_leave_accommodation/037_leave_accommodation_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-075-elmwood-retail/05_leave_accommodation/038_leave_accommodation_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-075-elmwood-retail/05_leave_accommodation/039_leave_accommodation_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-075-elmwood-retail/05_leave_accommodation/040_leave_accommodation_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-075-elmwood-retail/06_complaints/041_complaints_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-075-elmwood-retail/06_complaints/042_complaints_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-075-elmwood-retail/06_complaints/043_complaints_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-075-elmwood-retail/06_complaints/044_complaints_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-075-elmwood-retail/06_complaints/045_complaints_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-075-elmwood-retail/06_complaints/046_complaints_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-075-elmwood-retail/06_complaints/047_complaints_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-075-elmwood-retail/06_complaints/048_complaints_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-075-elmwood-retail/07_investigations/049_investigations_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-075-elmwood-retail/07_investigations/050_investigations_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-075-elmwood-retail/07_investigations/051_investigations_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-075-elmwood-retail/07_investigations/052_investigations_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-075-elmwood-retail/07_investigations/053_investigations_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-075-elmwood-retail/07_investigations/054_investigations_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-075-elmwood-retail/07_investigations/055_investigations_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-075-elmwood-retail/07_investigations/056_investigations_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-075-elmwood-retail/08_performance_discipline/057_performance_discipline_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-075-elmwood-retail/08_performance_discipline/058_performance_discipline_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-075-elmwood-retail/08_performance_discipline/059_performance_discipline_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-075-elmwood-retail/08_performance_discipline/060_performance_discipline_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-075-elmwood-retail/08_performance_discipline/061_performance_discipline_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-075-elmwood-retail/08_performance_discipline/062_performance_discipline_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-075-elmwood-retail/08_performance_discipline/063_performance_discipline_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-075-elmwood-retail/08_performance_discipline/064_performance_discipline_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-075-elmwood-retail/09_separation/065_separation_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-075-elmwood-retail/09_separation/066_separation_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-075-elmwood-retail/09_separation/067_separation_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-075-elmwood-retail/09_separation/068_separation_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-075-elmwood-retail/09_separation/069_separation_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-075-elmwood-retail/09_separation/070_separation_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-075-elmwood-retail/09_separation/071_separation_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-075-elmwood-retail/09_separation/072_separation_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-075-elmwood-retail/10_contractors/073_contractors_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-075-elmwood-retail/10_contractors/074_contractors_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-075-elmwood-retail/10_contractors/075_contractors_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-075-elmwood-retail/10_contractors/076_contractors_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-075-elmwood-retail/10_contractors/077_contractors_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-075-elmwood-retail/10_contractors/078_contractors_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-075-elmwood-retail/10_contractors/079_contractors_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-075-elmwood-retail/10_contractors/080_contractors_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-075-elmwood-retail/11_training/081_training_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-075-elmwood-retail/11_training/082_training_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-075-elmwood-retail/11_training/083_training_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-075-elmwood-retail/11_training/084_training_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-075-elmwood-retail/11_training/085_training_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-075-elmwood-retail/11_training/086_training_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-075-elmwood-retail/11_training/087_training_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-075-elmwood-retail/11_training/088_training_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-075-elmwood-retail/12_agency_matters/089_agency_matters_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-075-elmwood-retail/12_agency_matters/090_agency_matters_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-075-elmwood-retail/12_agency_matters/091_agency_matters_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-075-elmwood-retail/12_agency_matters/092_agency_matters_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-075-elmwood-retail/12_agency_matters/093_agency_matters_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-075-elmwood-retail/12_agency_matters/094_agency_matters_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-075-elmwood-retail/12_agency_matters/095_agency_matters_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-075-elmwood-retail/12_agency_matters/096_agency_matters_status_report.md"], "gold_output": {"advice_markdown": "# Counsel advice — Elmwood scheduling complaint review\n\n## Executive assessment\n\nFor Elmwood Specialty Retail matter CB-EL-3105, the review identified 16 source-supported exceptions requiring action before 2026-09-19. The assessment concerns Store manager collective and the supplied record for Illinois.\n\n## Method and record coverage\n\nThe review inventoried all 96 production files, read the 33 controlling, corroborating, and control records, searched the email exports, and checked metadata for the designated chain-of-custody sample. Conclusions are limited to the synthetic production supplied for this benchmark matter.\n\n## Findings\n\n### F-01 — classification inconsistency (critical)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for classification inconsistency: one source states the operative date is 2025-05-30 under control reference CB-EL-3105-A667, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2025-07-03 under response reference CB-EL-3105-J835.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/001_handbooks_policies_control_register.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/07_investigations/049_investigations_control_register.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-19, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Adrian Mensah.\n\n### F-02 — overtime calculation error (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for overtime calculation error: one source states the controlling amount is $7,249,455.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $7,475,410.00.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/004_handbooks_policies_ledger_export.csv`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/07_investigations/052_investigations_ledger_export.csv`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-19, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Willa Novak.\n\n### F-03 — meal-period premium gap (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for meal-period premium gap: one source states approval is attributed to Mei Whitaker as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Owen Delgado and contains no entry for Mei Whitaker.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/007_handbooks_policies_officer_certificate.html`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/07_investigations/055_investigations_officer_certificate.html`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-19, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Theo Laurent.\n\n### F-04 — pay-equity outlier (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for pay-equity outlier: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-EL-3105-D672, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-EL-3105-M767.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/010_personnel_records_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/08_performance_discipline/058_performance_discipline_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-19, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Amara Patel.\n\n### F-05 — leave designation delay (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for leave designation delay: one source states the applicable location is Illinois Department of Labor, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to Illinois operations outside Illinois Department of Labor.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/013_personnel_records_review_memorandum.json`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/08_performance_discipline/061_performance_discipline_review_memorandum.json`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-19, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Henry Cho.\n\n### F-06 — interactive-process lapse (low)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for interactive-process lapse: one source states the threshold is 6% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 10% and produced a different exception result.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/016_personnel_records_status_report.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/08_performance_discipline/064_performance_discipline_status_report.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-19, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Nadine Flores.\n\n### F-07 — complaint escalation gap (critical)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for complaint escalation gap: one source states formal notice must use notices-elmwood_specialty_retail@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-store_manager_collective@example.test.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/019_payroll_time_correspondence.eml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/09_separation/067_separation_correspondence.eml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-19, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Micah Sullivan.\n\n### F-08 — investigation independence concern (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for investigation independence concern: one source states the governed population contains 64 records through 2025-01-19, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 49 records through 2025-02-09.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/022_payroll_time_formal_notice.xml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/09_separation/070_separation_formal_notice.xml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-19, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Farah Ibrahim.\n\n### F-09 — discipline comparator inconsistency (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for discipline comparator inconsistency: one source states the operative date is 2026-01-17 under control reference CB-EL-3105-I899, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2026-02-17 under response reference CB-EL-3105-R576.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/025_compensation_equity_control_register.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/10_contractors/073_contractors_control_register.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-19, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Owen Delgado.\n\n### F-10 — retaliation timing (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for retaliation timing: one source states the controlling amount is $5,987,708.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $6,221,916.00.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/028_compensation_equity_ledger_export.csv`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/10_contractors/076_contractors_ledger_export.csv`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-19, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Lena Varga.\n\n### F-11 — separation pay discrepancy (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for separation pay discrepancy: one source states approval is attributed to Mei Whitaker as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Adrian Mensah and contains no entry for Mei Whitaker.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/031_compensation_equity_officer_certificate.html`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/10_contractors/079_contractors_officer_certificate.html`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-19, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Samuel Kim.\n\n### F-12 — restrictive-covenant conflict (low)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for restrictive-covenant conflict: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-EL-3105-L433, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-EL-3105-U679.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/034_leave_accommodation_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/11_training/082_training_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-19, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Maya Ellison.\n\n### F-13 — contractor control evidence (critical)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for contractor control evidence: one source states the applicable location is Illinois Department of Labor, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to Illinois operations outside Illinois Department of Labor.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/037_leave_accommodation_review_memorandum.json`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/11_training/085_training_review_memorandum.json`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-19, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Rafael Okafor.\n\n### F-14 — training completion gap (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for training completion gap: one source states the threshold is 8% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 12% and produced a different exception result.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/040_leave_accommodation_status_report.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/11_training/088_training_status_report.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-19, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Nora Chen.\n\n### F-15 — personnel-file access deadline (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for personnel-file access deadline: one source states formal notice must use notices-elmwood_specialty_retail@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-store_manager_collective@example.test.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/06_complaints/043_complaints_correspondence.eml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/091_agency_matters_correspondence.eml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-19, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Dominic Alvarez.\n\n### F-16 — agency response commitment (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for agency response commitment: one source states the governed population contains 48 records through 2025-05-23, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 48 records through 2025-06-12.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/06_complaints/046_complaints_formal_notice.xml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/094_agency_matters_formal_notice.xml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-19, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Priya Raman.\n\n## Recommended next actions\n\nSequence the critical and high findings first, assign the named owners, preserve the cited records, and document any resolution in the controlling matter register before the stated deadline.\n\n## Assumptions and limitations\n\nThis analysis is confined to task cb100-075-elmwood-retail and the supplied synthetic evidence. It does not rely on external facts, does not resolve disputed law, and is not legal advice for a real person or entity.\n", "findings": {"as_of": "2026-09-19", "findings": [{"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/07_investigations/049_investigations_control_register.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for classification inconsistency: one source states the operative date is 2025-05-30 under control reference CB-EL-3105-A667, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2025-07-03 under response reference CB-EL-3105-J835.", "id": "F-01", "issue": "classification inconsistency", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/001_handbooks_policies_control_register.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-19, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Adrian Mensah.", "severity": "critical"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/07_investigations/052_investigations_ledger_export.csv", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for overtime calculation error: one source states the controlling amount is $7,249,455.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $7,475,410.00.", "id": "F-02", "issue": "overtime calculation error", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/004_handbooks_policies_ledger_export.csv", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-19, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Willa Novak.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/07_investigations/055_investigations_officer_certificate.html", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for meal-period premium gap: one source states approval is attributed to Mei Whitaker as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Owen Delgado and contains no entry for Mei Whitaker.", "id": "F-03", "issue": "meal-period premium gap", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/007_handbooks_policies_officer_certificate.html", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-19, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Theo Laurent.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/08_performance_discipline/058_performance_discipline_executed_instrument.txt", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for pay-equity outlier: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-EL-3105-D672, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-EL-3105-M767.", "id": "F-04", "issue": "pay-equity outlier", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/010_personnel_records_executed_instrument.txt", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-19, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Amara Patel.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/08_performance_discipline/061_performance_discipline_review_memorandum.json", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for leave designation delay: one source states the applicable location is Illinois Department of Labor, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to Illinois operations outside Illinois Department of Labor.", "id": "F-05", "issue": "leave designation delay", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/013_personnel_records_review_memorandum.json", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-19, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Henry Cho.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/08_performance_discipline/064_performance_discipline_status_report.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for interactive-process lapse: one source states the threshold is 6% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 10% and produced a different exception result.", "id": "F-06", "issue": "interactive-process lapse", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/016_personnel_records_status_report.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-19, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Nadine Flores.", "severity": "low"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/09_separation/067_separation_correspondence.eml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for complaint escalation gap: one source states formal notice must use notices-elmwood_specialty_retail@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-store_manager_collective@example.test.", "id": "F-07", "issue": "complaint escalation gap", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/019_payroll_time_correspondence.eml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-19, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Micah Sullivan.", "severity": "critical"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/09_separation/070_separation_formal_notice.xml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for investigation independence concern: one source states the governed population contains 64 records through 2025-01-19, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 49 records through 2025-02-09.", "id": "F-08", "issue": "investigation independence concern", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/022_payroll_time_formal_notice.xml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-19, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Farah Ibrahim.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/10_contractors/073_contractors_control_register.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for discipline comparator inconsistency: one source states the operative date is 2026-01-17 under control reference CB-EL-3105-I899, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2026-02-17 under response reference CB-EL-3105-R576.", "id": "F-09", "issue": "discipline comparator inconsistency", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/025_compensation_equity_control_register.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-19, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Owen Delgado.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/10_contractors/076_contractors_ledger_export.csv", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for retaliation timing: one source states the controlling amount is $5,987,708.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $6,221,916.00.", "id": "F-10", "issue": "retaliation timing", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/028_compensation_equity_ledger_export.csv", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-19, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Lena Varga.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/10_contractors/079_contractors_officer_certificate.html", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for separation pay discrepancy: one source states approval is attributed to Mei Whitaker as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Adrian Mensah and contains no entry for Mei Whitaker.", "id": "F-11", "issue": "separation pay discrepancy", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/031_compensation_equity_officer_certificate.html", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-19, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Samuel Kim.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/11_training/082_training_executed_instrument.txt", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for restrictive-covenant conflict: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-EL-3105-L433, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-EL-3105-U679.", "id": "F-12", "issue": "restrictive-covenant conflict", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/034_leave_accommodation_executed_instrument.txt", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-19, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Maya Ellison.", "severity": "low"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/11_training/085_training_review_memorandum.json", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for contractor control evidence: one source states the applicable location is Illinois Department of Labor, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to Illinois operations outside Illinois Department of Labor.", "id": "F-13", "issue": "contractor control evidence", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/037_leave_accommodation_review_memorandum.json", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-19, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Rafael Okafor.", "severity": "critical"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/11_training/088_training_status_report.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for training completion gap: one source states the threshold is 8% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 12% and produced a different exception result.", "id": "F-14", "issue": "training completion gap", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/040_leave_accommodation_status_report.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-19, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Nora Chen.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/091_agency_matters_correspondence.eml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for personnel-file access deadline: one source states formal notice must use notices-elmwood_specialty_retail@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-store_manager_collective@example.test.", "id": "F-15", "issue": "personnel-file access deadline", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/06_complaints/043_complaints_correspondence.eml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-19, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Dominic Alvarez.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/094_agency_matters_formal_notice.xml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for agency response commitment: one source states the governed population contains 48 records through 2025-05-23, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 48 records through 2025-06-12.", "id": "F-16", "issue": "agency response commitment", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/06_complaints/046_complaints_formal_notice.xml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-19, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Priya Raman.", "severity": "medium"}], "matter_number": "CB-EL-3105", "prepared_for": "Elmwood Specialty Retail", "schema_version": "1.0", "task_id": "cb100-075-elmwood-retail"}}, "metadata": {"benchmark": "CounselBench-100", "code_license": "Apache-2.0", "data_license": "CC-BY-4.0", "deadline": "2026-09-19", "document_count": 96, "jurisdiction": "Illinois", "matter_number": "CB-EL-3105", "mcp_commit": "9a96ea6e5913736f92b88345bf51caeaaa8e719f", "mcp_package": "@modelcontextprotocol/server-filesystem@2026.7.10", "practice_area": "employment", "reference_tool_calls": 46, "required_evidence_reads": 33, "synthetic": true, "venue": "Illinois Department of Labor", "version": "2.0.0"}, "prompt": "You are employment counsel for Elmwood Specialty Retail. Outside counsel inherited this file after turnover on the client team and must validate every operative record before advising. Schedule-change records, time punches, policy acknowledgments, and discipline files conflict after a protected complaint. Decision due 2026-09-19. Illinois law governs; Illinois Department of Labor is the forum. Evaluate both legal consequence and the practical owner needed to cure each exception. Work out the defensible position from the matter production and leave an audit-ready exception tracker and concise advice for the supervising lawyer. Keep confirmed conflicts separate from open questions, cite the records that actually control each conclusion, and do not fill gaps with outside facts.", "rubric": {"criteria": [{"category": "procedure", "description": "Complete at least 46 successful, argument-specific evidence and output calls.", "id": "procedure.minimum_successful_tool_calls"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Find and read the 33 controlling, corroborating, and work-product-control records in full.", "id": "procedure.all_evidence_read_in_full"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Inspect file metadata for the eight designated critical primary records before relying on them.", "id": "procedure.chain_of_custody_metadata_checked"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Confirm the sandbox's allowed document and output roots.", "id": "procedure.allowed_directories_checked"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Inventory all 96 records so the relevant sources are discovered among the context records.", "id": "procedure.recursive_inventory_completed"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Search the production for email evidence that may corroborate or contradict formal records.", "id": "procedure.targeted_search_completed"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Leave only findings.json and advice.md in the output workspace.", "id": "procedure.exact_deliverable_set"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Create both final work products through the sandbox MCP surface.", "id": "procedure.deliverables_written_through_mcp"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Produce findings.json as a valid JSON object.", "id": "findings.findings_is_object"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Report exactly 16 confirmed exceptions.", "id": "findings.findings_exact_count"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Use each stable finding ID exactly once.", "id": "findings.finding_ids_unique"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set schema_version to the released matter value '1.0'.", "id": "findings.top_level_schema_version"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set task_id to the released matter value 'cb100-075-elmwood-retail'.", "id": "findings.top_level_task_id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set matter_number to the released matter value 'CB-EL-3105'.", "id": "findings.top_level_matter_number"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set prepared_for to the released matter value 'Elmwood Specialty Retail'.", "id": "findings.top_level_prepared_for"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set as_of to the released matter value '2026-09-19'.", "id": "findings.top_level_as_of"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-01 exception for classification inconsistency.", "id": "findings.F-01.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's id from /workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/001_handbooks_policies_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_investigations/049_investigations_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's issue from /workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/001_handbooks_policies_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_investigations/049_investigations_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's severity from /workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/001_handbooks_policies_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_investigations/049_investigations_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's primary_source from /workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/001_handbooks_policies_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_investigations/049_investigations_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/001_handbooks_policies_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_investigations/049_investigations_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-01 using the exact controlled facts ['2025-05-30', 'CB-EL-3105-A667', '2025-07-03', 'CB-EL-3105-J835'].", "id": "findings.F-01.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-01's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-01.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-19', 'Adrian Mensah'] for F-01.", "id": "findings.F-01.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-02 exception for overtime calculation error.", "id": "findings.F-02.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's id from /workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/004_handbooks_policies_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_investigations/052_investigations_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's issue from /workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/004_handbooks_policies_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_investigations/052_investigations_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's severity from /workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/004_handbooks_policies_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_investigations/052_investigations_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's primary_source from /workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/004_handbooks_policies_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_investigations/052_investigations_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/004_handbooks_policies_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_investigations/052_investigations_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-02 using the exact controlled facts ['$7,249,455.00', '$7,475,410.00'].", "id": "findings.F-02.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-02's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-02.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-19', 'Willa Novak'] for F-02.", "id": "findings.F-02.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-03 exception for meal-period premium gap.", "id": "findings.F-03.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's id from /workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/007_handbooks_policies_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_investigations/055_investigations_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's issue from /workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/007_handbooks_policies_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_investigations/055_investigations_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's severity from /workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/007_handbooks_policies_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_investigations/055_investigations_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's primary_source from /workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/007_handbooks_policies_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_investigations/055_investigations_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/007_handbooks_policies_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_investigations/055_investigations_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-03 using the exact controlled facts ['Mei Whitaker', 'Owen Delgado'].", "id": "findings.F-03.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-03's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-03.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-19', 'Theo Laurent'] for F-03.", "id": "findings.F-03.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-04 exception for pay-equity outlier.", "id": "findings.F-04.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's id from /workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/010_personnel_records_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_performance_discipline/058_performance_discipline_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's issue from /workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/010_personnel_records_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_performance_discipline/058_performance_discipline_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's severity from /workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/010_personnel_records_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_performance_discipline/058_performance_discipline_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's primary_source from /workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/010_personnel_records_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_performance_discipline/058_performance_discipline_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/010_personnel_records_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_performance_discipline/058_performance_discipline_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-04 using the exact controlled facts ['closed without exception', 'CB-EL-3105-D672', 'open and escalated', 'CB-EL-3105-M767'].", "id": "findings.F-04.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-04's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-04.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-19', 'Amara Patel'] for F-04.", "id": "findings.F-04.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-05 exception for leave designation delay.", "id": "findings.F-05.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's id from /workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/013_personnel_records_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_performance_discipline/061_performance_discipline_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's issue from /workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/013_personnel_records_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_performance_discipline/061_performance_discipline_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's severity from /workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/013_personnel_records_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_performance_discipline/061_performance_discipline_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's primary_source from /workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/013_personnel_records_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_performance_discipline/061_performance_discipline_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/013_personnel_records_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_performance_discipline/061_performance_discipline_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-05 using the exact controlled facts ['Illinois Department of Labor', 'Illinois'].", "id": "findings.F-05.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-05's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-05.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-19', 'Henry Cho'] for F-05.", "id": "findings.F-05.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-06 exception for interactive-process lapse.", "id": "findings.F-06.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's id from /workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/016_personnel_records_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_performance_discipline/064_performance_discipline_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's issue from /workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/016_personnel_records_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_performance_discipline/064_performance_discipline_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's severity from /workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/016_personnel_records_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_performance_discipline/064_performance_discipline_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's primary_source from /workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/016_personnel_records_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_performance_discipline/064_performance_discipline_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/016_personnel_records_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_performance_discipline/064_performance_discipline_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-06 using the exact controlled facts ['6%', '10%'].", "id": "findings.F-06.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-06's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-06.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-19', 'Nadine Flores'] for F-06.", "id": "findings.F-06.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-07 exception for complaint escalation gap.", "id": "findings.F-07.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's id from /workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/019_payroll_time_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_separation/067_separation_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's issue from /workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/019_payroll_time_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_separation/067_separation_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's severity from /workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/019_payroll_time_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_separation/067_separation_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's primary_source from /workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/019_payroll_time_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_separation/067_separation_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/019_payroll_time_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_separation/067_separation_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-07 using the exact controlled facts ['notices-elmwood_specialty_retail@example.test', 'archive-store_manager_collective@example.test'].", "id": "findings.F-07.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-07's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-07.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-19', 'Micah Sullivan'] for F-07.", "id": "findings.F-07.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-08 exception for investigation independence concern.", "id": "findings.F-08.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's id from /workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/022_payroll_time_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_separation/070_separation_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's issue from /workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/022_payroll_time_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_separation/070_separation_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's severity from /workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/022_payroll_time_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_separation/070_separation_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's primary_source from /workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/022_payroll_time_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_separation/070_separation_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/022_payroll_time_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_separation/070_separation_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-08 using the exact controlled facts ['64 records', '2025-01-19', '49 records', '2025-02-09'].", "id": "findings.F-08.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-08's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-08.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-19', 'Farah Ibrahim'] for F-08.", "id": "findings.F-08.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-09 exception for discipline comparator inconsistency.", "id": "findings.F-09.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's id from /workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/025_compensation_equity_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_contractors/073_contractors_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's issue from /workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/025_compensation_equity_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_contractors/073_contractors_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's severity from /workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/025_compensation_equity_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_contractors/073_contractors_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's primary_source from /workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/025_compensation_equity_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_contractors/073_contractors_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/025_compensation_equity_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_contractors/073_contractors_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-09 using the exact controlled facts ['2026-01-17', 'CB-EL-3105-I899', '2026-02-17', 'CB-EL-3105-R576'].", "id": "findings.F-09.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-09's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-09.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-19', 'Owen Delgado'] for F-09.", "id": "findings.F-09.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-10 exception for retaliation timing.", "id": "findings.F-10.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's id from /workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/028_compensation_equity_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_contractors/076_contractors_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's issue from /workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/028_compensation_equity_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_contractors/076_contractors_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's severity from /workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/028_compensation_equity_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_contractors/076_contractors_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's primary_source from /workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/028_compensation_equity_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_contractors/076_contractors_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/028_compensation_equity_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_contractors/076_contractors_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-10 using the exact controlled facts ['$5,987,708.00', '$6,221,916.00'].", "id": "findings.F-10.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-10's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-10.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-19', 'Lena Varga'] for F-10.", "id": "findings.F-10.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-11 exception for separation pay discrepancy.", "id": "findings.F-11.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's id from /workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/031_compensation_equity_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_contractors/079_contractors_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's issue from /workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/031_compensation_equity_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_contractors/079_contractors_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's severity from /workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/031_compensation_equity_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_contractors/079_contractors_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's primary_source from /workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/031_compensation_equity_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_contractors/079_contractors_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/031_compensation_equity_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_contractors/079_contractors_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-11 using the exact controlled facts ['Mei Whitaker', 'Adrian Mensah'].", "id": "findings.F-11.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-11's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-11.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-19', 'Samuel Kim'] for F-11.", "id": "findings.F-11.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-12 exception for restrictive-covenant conflict.", "id": "findings.F-12.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's id from /workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/034_leave_accommodation_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_training/082_training_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's issue from /workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/034_leave_accommodation_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_training/082_training_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's severity from /workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/034_leave_accommodation_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_training/082_training_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's primary_source from /workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/034_leave_accommodation_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_training/082_training_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/034_leave_accommodation_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_training/082_training_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-12 using the exact controlled facts ['closed without exception', 'CB-EL-3105-L433', 'open and escalated', 'CB-EL-3105-U679'].", "id": "findings.F-12.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-12's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-12.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-19', 'Maya Ellison'] for F-12.", "id": "findings.F-12.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-13 exception for contractor control evidence.", "id": "findings.F-13.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's id from /workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/037_leave_accommodation_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_training/085_training_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's issue from /workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/037_leave_accommodation_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_training/085_training_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's severity from /workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/037_leave_accommodation_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_training/085_training_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's primary_source from /workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/037_leave_accommodation_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_training/085_training_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/037_leave_accommodation_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_training/085_training_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-13 using the exact controlled facts ['Illinois Department of Labor', 'Illinois'].", "id": "findings.F-13.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-13's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-13.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-19', 'Rafael Okafor'] for F-13.", "id": "findings.F-13.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-14 exception for training completion gap.", "id": "findings.F-14.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's id from /workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/040_leave_accommodation_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_training/088_training_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's issue from /workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/040_leave_accommodation_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_training/088_training_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's severity from /workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/040_leave_accommodation_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_training/088_training_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's primary_source from /workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/040_leave_accommodation_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_training/088_training_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/040_leave_accommodation_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_training/088_training_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-14 using the exact controlled facts ['8%', '12%'].", "id": "findings.F-14.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-14's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-14.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-19', 'Nora Chen'] for F-14.", "id": "findings.F-14.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-15 exception for personnel-file access deadline.", "id": "findings.F-15.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's id from /workspace/documents/06_complaints/043_complaints_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/091_agency_matters_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's issue from /workspace/documents/06_complaints/043_complaints_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/091_agency_matters_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's severity from /workspace/documents/06_complaints/043_complaints_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/091_agency_matters_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's primary_source from /workspace/documents/06_complaints/043_complaints_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/091_agency_matters_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/06_complaints/043_complaints_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/091_agency_matters_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-15 using the exact controlled facts ['notices-elmwood_specialty_retail@example.test', 'archive-store_manager_collective@example.test'].", "id": "findings.F-15.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-15's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-15.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-19', 'Dominic Alvarez'] for F-15.", "id": "findings.F-15.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-16 exception for agency response commitment.", "id": "findings.F-16.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's id from /workspace/documents/06_complaints/046_complaints_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/094_agency_matters_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's issue from /workspace/documents/06_complaints/046_complaints_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/094_agency_matters_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's severity from /workspace/documents/06_complaints/046_complaints_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/094_agency_matters_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's primary_source from /workspace/documents/06_complaints/046_complaints_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/094_agency_matters_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/06_complaints/046_complaints_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/094_agency_matters_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-16 using the exact controlled facts ['48 records', '2025-05-23', '48 records', '2025-06-12'].", "id": "findings.F-16.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-16's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-16.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-19', 'Priya Raman'] for F-16.", "id": "findings.F-16.action_anchors"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Executive assessment' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Executive assessment"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Method and record coverage' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Method and record coverage"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Findings' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Findings"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Recommended next actions' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Recommended next actions"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Assumptions and limitations' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Assumptions and limitations"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-01 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-01"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-02 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-02"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-03 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-03"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-04 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-04"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-05 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-05"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-06 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-06"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-07 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-07"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-08 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-08"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-09 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-09"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-10 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-10"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-11 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-11"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-12 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-12"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-13 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-13"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-14 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-14"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-15 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-15"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-16 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-16"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Do not claim the production has no issues or that every record is consistent.", "id": "memo.forbidden_claims_absent"}], "decision_options": [{"id": "cross-source-reconciliation", "label": "Reconcile controlling and corroborating records", "reason": "The CB-EL-3105 production contains independently maintained records; a defensible answer must preserve each supported conflict and its cure owner.", "selected": true}, {"id": "latest-record-controls", "label": "Treat the latest record as controlling", "reason": "Timestamp recency does not establish legal priority, execution, or approval authority.", "selected": false}, {"id": "primary-records-only", "label": "Report primary records without reconciliation", "reason": "Primary records alone conceal the operational conflicts that create the actionable exceptions.", "selected": false}], "gates": ["all_evidence_read_in_full", "chain_of_custody_metadata_checked", "findings_criteria_complete", "memo_criteria_complete", "deliverables_written_through_mcp"], "metadata_checks": 8, "metric": "weighted_criteria_score", "minimum_tool_calls": 46, "required_deliverables": ["findings.json", "advice.md"], "required_document_reads": 33, "type": "deterministic", "weights": {"findings": 0.55, "memo": 0.2, "procedure": 0.25}}, "task_id": "cb100-075-elmwood-retail", "task_name": "Elmwood scheduling complaint review", "world_id": "counselbench-filesystem-mcp-v2"}
-{"context_files": ["task_files/cb100-076-frontier-games/01_handbooks_policies/001_handbooks_policies_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-076-frontier-games/01_handbooks_policies/002_handbooks_policies_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-076-frontier-games/01_handbooks_policies/003_handbooks_policies_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-076-frontier-games/01_handbooks_policies/004_handbooks_policies_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-076-frontier-games/01_handbooks_policies/005_handbooks_policies_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-076-frontier-games/01_handbooks_policies/006_handbooks_policies_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-076-frontier-games/01_handbooks_policies/007_handbooks_policies_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-076-frontier-games/01_handbooks_policies/008_handbooks_policies_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-076-frontier-games/02_personnel_records/009_personnel_records_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-076-frontier-games/02_personnel_records/010_personnel_records_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-076-frontier-games/02_personnel_records/011_personnel_records_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-076-frontier-games/02_personnel_records/012_personnel_records_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-076-frontier-games/02_personnel_records/013_personnel_records_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-076-frontier-games/02_personnel_records/014_personnel_records_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-076-frontier-games/02_personnel_records/015_personnel_records_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-076-frontier-games/02_personnel_records/016_personnel_records_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-076-frontier-games/03_payroll_time/017_payroll_time_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-076-frontier-games/03_payroll_time/018_payroll_time_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-076-frontier-games/03_payroll_time/019_payroll_time_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-076-frontier-games/03_payroll_time/020_payroll_time_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-076-frontier-games/03_payroll_time/021_payroll_time_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-076-frontier-games/03_payroll_time/022_payroll_time_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-076-frontier-games/03_payroll_time/023_payroll_time_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-076-frontier-games/03_payroll_time/024_payroll_time_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-076-frontier-games/04_compensation_equity/025_compensation_equity_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-076-frontier-games/04_compensation_equity/026_compensation_equity_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-076-frontier-games/04_compensation_equity/027_compensation_equity_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-076-frontier-games/04_compensation_equity/028_compensation_equity_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-076-frontier-games/04_compensation_equity/029_compensation_equity_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-076-frontier-games/04_compensation_equity/030_compensation_equity_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-076-frontier-games/04_compensation_equity/031_compensation_equity_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-076-frontier-games/04_compensation_equity/032_compensation_equity_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-076-frontier-games/05_leave_accommodation/033_leave_accommodation_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-076-frontier-games/05_leave_accommodation/034_leave_accommodation_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-076-frontier-games/05_leave_accommodation/035_leave_accommodation_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-076-frontier-games/05_leave_accommodation/036_leave_accommodation_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-076-frontier-games/05_leave_accommodation/037_leave_accommodation_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-076-frontier-games/05_leave_accommodation/038_leave_accommodation_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-076-frontier-games/05_leave_accommodation/039_leave_accommodation_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-076-frontier-games/05_leave_accommodation/040_leave_accommodation_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-076-frontier-games/06_complaints/041_complaints_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-076-frontier-games/06_complaints/042_complaints_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-076-frontier-games/06_complaints/043_complaints_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-076-frontier-games/06_complaints/044_complaints_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-076-frontier-games/06_complaints/045_complaints_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-076-frontier-games/06_complaints/046_complaints_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-076-frontier-games/06_complaints/047_complaints_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-076-frontier-games/06_complaints/048_complaints_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-076-frontier-games/07_investigations/049_investigations_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-076-frontier-games/07_investigations/050_investigations_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-076-frontier-games/07_investigations/051_investigations_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-076-frontier-games/07_investigations/052_investigations_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-076-frontier-games/07_investigations/053_investigations_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-076-frontier-games/07_investigations/054_investigations_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-076-frontier-games/07_investigations/055_investigations_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-076-frontier-games/07_investigations/056_investigations_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-076-frontier-games/08_performance_discipline/057_performance_discipline_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-076-frontier-games/08_performance_discipline/058_performance_discipline_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-076-frontier-games/08_performance_discipline/059_performance_discipline_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-076-frontier-games/08_performance_discipline/060_performance_discipline_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-076-frontier-games/08_performance_discipline/061_performance_discipline_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-076-frontier-games/08_performance_discipline/062_performance_discipline_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-076-frontier-games/08_performance_discipline/063_performance_discipline_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-076-frontier-games/08_performance_discipline/064_performance_discipline_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-076-frontier-games/09_separation/065_separation_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-076-frontier-games/09_separation/066_separation_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-076-frontier-games/09_separation/067_separation_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-076-frontier-games/09_separation/068_separation_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-076-frontier-games/09_separation/069_separation_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-076-frontier-games/09_separation/070_separation_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-076-frontier-games/09_separation/071_separation_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-076-frontier-games/09_separation/072_separation_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-076-frontier-games/10_contractors/073_contractors_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-076-frontier-games/10_contractors/074_contractors_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-076-frontier-games/10_contractors/075_contractors_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-076-frontier-games/10_contractors/076_contractors_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-076-frontier-games/10_contractors/077_contractors_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-076-frontier-games/10_contractors/078_contractors_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-076-frontier-games/10_contractors/079_contractors_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-076-frontier-games/10_contractors/080_contractors_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-076-frontier-games/11_training/081_training_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-076-frontier-games/11_training/082_training_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-076-frontier-games/11_training/083_training_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-076-frontier-games/11_training/084_training_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-076-frontier-games/11_training/085_training_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-076-frontier-games/11_training/086_training_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-076-frontier-games/11_training/087_training_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-076-frontier-games/11_training/088_training_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-076-frontier-games/12_agency_matters/089_agency_matters_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-076-frontier-games/12_agency_matters/090_agency_matters_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-076-frontier-games/12_agency_matters/091_agency_matters_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-076-frontier-games/12_agency_matters/092_agency_matters_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-076-frontier-games/12_agency_matters/093_agency_matters_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-076-frontier-games/12_agency_matters/094_agency_matters_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-076-frontier-games/12_agency_matters/095_agency_matters_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-076-frontier-games/12_agency_matters/096_agency_matters_status_report.md"], "gold_output": {"advice_markdown": "# Counsel advice — Frontier contractor and IP audit\n\n## Executive assessment\n\nFor Frontier Game Studios matter CB-EL-3106, the review identified 16 source-supported exceptions requiring action before 2026-09-23. The assessment concerns Distributed art contributor group and the supplied record for Washington.\n\n## Method and record coverage\n\nThe review inventoried all 96 production files, read the 33 controlling, corroborating, and control records, searched the email exports, and checked metadata for the designated chain-of-custody sample. Conclusions are limited to the synthetic production supplied for this benchmark matter.\n\n## Findings\n\n### F-01 — classification inconsistency (critical)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for classification inconsistency: one source states the operative date is 2025-01-07 under control reference CB-EL-3106-A524, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2025-02-09 under response reference CB-EL-3106-J271.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/001_handbooks_policies_control_register.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/07_investigations/049_investigations_control_register.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-23, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Willa Novak.\n\n### F-02 — overtime calculation error (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for overtime calculation error: one source states the controlling amount is $7,455,216.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $7,486,932.00.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/004_handbooks_policies_ledger_export.csv`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/07_investigations/052_investigations_ledger_export.csv`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-23, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Theo Laurent.\n\n### F-03 — meal-period premium gap (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for meal-period premium gap: one source states approval is attributed to Caleb Hassan as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Samuel Kim and contains no entry for Caleb Hassan.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/007_handbooks_policies_officer_certificate.html`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/07_investigations/055_investigations_officer_certificate.html`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-23, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Amara Patel.\n\n### F-04 — pay-equity outlier (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for pay-equity outlier: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-EL-3106-D888, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-EL-3106-M160.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/010_personnel_records_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/08_performance_discipline/058_performance_discipline_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-23, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Henry Cho.\n\n### F-05 — leave designation delay (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for leave designation delay: one source states the applicable location is Washington Department of Labor & Industries, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to Washington operations outside Washington Department of Labor & Industries.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/013_personnel_records_review_memorandum.json`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/08_performance_discipline/061_performance_discipline_review_memorandum.json`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-23, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Nadine Flores.\n\n### F-06 — interactive-process lapse (low)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for interactive-process lapse: one source states the threshold is 8% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 12% and produced a different exception result.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/016_personnel_records_status_report.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/08_performance_discipline/064_performance_discipline_status_report.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-23, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Micah Sullivan.\n\n### F-07 — complaint escalation gap (critical)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for complaint escalation gap: one source states formal notice must use notices-frontier_game_studios@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-distributed_art_contributor_group@example.test.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/019_payroll_time_correspondence.eml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/09_separation/067_separation_correspondence.eml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-23, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Farah Ibrahim.\n\n### F-08 — investigation independence concern (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for investigation independence concern: one source states the governed population contains 185 records through 2026-02-24, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 44 records through 2026-03-12.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/022_payroll_time_formal_notice.xml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/09_separation/070_separation_formal_notice.xml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-23, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Owen Delgado.\n\n### F-09 — discipline comparator inconsistency (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for discipline comparator inconsistency: one source states the operative date is 2025-07-21 under control reference CB-EL-3106-I599, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2025-09-01 under response reference CB-EL-3106-R553.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/025_compensation_equity_control_register.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/10_contractors/073_contractors_control_register.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-23, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Lena Varga.\n\n### F-10 — retaliation timing (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for retaliation timing: one source states the controlling amount is $4,304,356.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $4,435,212.00.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/028_compensation_equity_ledger_export.csv`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/10_contractors/076_contractors_ledger_export.csv`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-23, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Samuel Kim.\n\n### F-11 — separation pay discrepancy (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for separation pay discrepancy: one source states approval is attributed to Caleb Hassan as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Theo Laurent and contains no entry for Caleb Hassan.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/031_compensation_equity_officer_certificate.html`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/10_contractors/079_contractors_officer_certificate.html`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-23, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Maya Ellison.\n\n### F-12 — restrictive-covenant conflict (low)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for restrictive-covenant conflict: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-EL-3106-L519, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-EL-3106-U893.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/034_leave_accommodation_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/11_training/082_training_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-23, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Rafael Okafor.\n\n### F-13 — contractor control evidence (critical)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for contractor control evidence: one source states the applicable location is Washington Department of Labor & Industries, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to Washington operations outside Washington Department of Labor & Industries.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/037_leave_accommodation_review_memorandum.json`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/11_training/085_training_review_memorandum.json`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-23, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Nora Chen.\n\n### F-14 — training completion gap (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for training completion gap: one source states the threshold is 5% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 12% and produced a different exception result.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/040_leave_accommodation_status_report.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/11_training/088_training_status_report.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-23, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Dominic Alvarez.\n\n### F-15 — personnel-file access deadline (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for personnel-file access deadline: one source states formal notice must use notices-frontier_game_studios@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-distributed_art_contributor_group@example.test.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/06_complaints/043_complaints_correspondence.eml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/091_agency_matters_correspondence.eml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-23, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Priya Raman.\n\n### F-16 — agency response commitment (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for agency response commitment: one source states the governed population contains 144 records through 2025-08-27, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 67 records through 2025-10-05.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/06_complaints/046_complaints_formal_notice.xml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/094_agency_matters_formal_notice.xml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-23, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Elliot Mercer.\n\n## Recommended next actions\n\nSequence the critical and high findings first, assign the named owners, preserve the cited records, and document any resolution in the controlling matter register before the stated deadline.\n\n## Assumptions and limitations\n\nThis analysis is confined to task cb100-076-frontier-games and the supplied synthetic evidence. It does not rely on external facts, does not resolve disputed law, and is not legal advice for a real person or entity.\n", "findings": {"as_of": "2026-09-23", "findings": [{"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/07_investigations/049_investigations_control_register.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for classification inconsistency: one source states the operative date is 2025-01-07 under control reference CB-EL-3106-A524, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2025-02-09 under response reference CB-EL-3106-J271.", "id": "F-01", "issue": "classification inconsistency", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/001_handbooks_policies_control_register.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-23, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Willa Novak.", "severity": "critical"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/07_investigations/052_investigations_ledger_export.csv", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for overtime calculation error: one source states the controlling amount is $7,455,216.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $7,486,932.00.", "id": "F-02", "issue": "overtime calculation error", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/004_handbooks_policies_ledger_export.csv", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-23, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Theo Laurent.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/07_investigations/055_investigations_officer_certificate.html", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for meal-period premium gap: one source states approval is attributed to Caleb Hassan as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Samuel Kim and contains no entry for Caleb Hassan.", "id": "F-03", "issue": "meal-period premium gap", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/007_handbooks_policies_officer_certificate.html", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-23, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Amara Patel.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/08_performance_discipline/058_performance_discipline_executed_instrument.txt", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for pay-equity outlier: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-EL-3106-D888, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-EL-3106-M160.", "id": "F-04", "issue": "pay-equity outlier", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/010_personnel_records_executed_instrument.txt", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-23, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Henry Cho.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/08_performance_discipline/061_performance_discipline_review_memorandum.json", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for leave designation delay: one source states the applicable location is Washington Department of Labor & Industries, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to Washington operations outside Washington Department of Labor & Industries.", "id": "F-05", "issue": "leave designation delay", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/013_personnel_records_review_memorandum.json", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-23, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Nadine Flores.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/08_performance_discipline/064_performance_discipline_status_report.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for interactive-process lapse: one source states the threshold is 8% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 12% and produced a different exception result.", "id": "F-06", "issue": "interactive-process lapse", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/016_personnel_records_status_report.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-23, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Micah Sullivan.", "severity": "low"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/09_separation/067_separation_correspondence.eml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for complaint escalation gap: one source states formal notice must use notices-frontier_game_studios@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-distributed_art_contributor_group@example.test.", "id": "F-07", "issue": "complaint escalation gap", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/019_payroll_time_correspondence.eml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-23, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Farah Ibrahim.", "severity": "critical"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/09_separation/070_separation_formal_notice.xml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for investigation independence concern: one source states the governed population contains 185 records through 2026-02-24, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 44 records through 2026-03-12.", "id": "F-08", "issue": "investigation independence concern", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/022_payroll_time_formal_notice.xml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-23, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Owen Delgado.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/10_contractors/073_contractors_control_register.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for discipline comparator inconsistency: one source states the operative date is 2025-07-21 under control reference CB-EL-3106-I599, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2025-09-01 under response reference CB-EL-3106-R553.", "id": "F-09", "issue": "discipline comparator inconsistency", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/025_compensation_equity_control_register.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-23, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Lena Varga.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/10_contractors/076_contractors_ledger_export.csv", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for retaliation timing: one source states the controlling amount is $4,304,356.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $4,435,212.00.", "id": "F-10", "issue": "retaliation timing", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/028_compensation_equity_ledger_export.csv", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-23, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Samuel Kim.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/10_contractors/079_contractors_officer_certificate.html", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for separation pay discrepancy: one source states approval is attributed to Caleb Hassan as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Theo Laurent and contains no entry for Caleb Hassan.", "id": "F-11", "issue": "separation pay discrepancy", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/031_compensation_equity_officer_certificate.html", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-23, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Maya Ellison.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/11_training/082_training_executed_instrument.txt", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for restrictive-covenant conflict: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-EL-3106-L519, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-EL-3106-U893.", "id": "F-12", "issue": "restrictive-covenant conflict", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/034_leave_accommodation_executed_instrument.txt", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-23, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Rafael Okafor.", "severity": "low"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/11_training/085_training_review_memorandum.json", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for contractor control evidence: one source states the applicable location is Washington Department of Labor & Industries, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to Washington operations outside Washington Department of Labor & Industries.", "id": "F-13", "issue": "contractor control evidence", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/037_leave_accommodation_review_memorandum.json", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-23, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Nora Chen.", "severity": "critical"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/11_training/088_training_status_report.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for training completion gap: one source states the threshold is 5% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 12% and produced a different exception result.", "id": "F-14", "issue": "training completion gap", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/040_leave_accommodation_status_report.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-23, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Dominic Alvarez.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/091_agency_matters_correspondence.eml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for personnel-file access deadline: one source states formal notice must use notices-frontier_game_studios@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-distributed_art_contributor_group@example.test.", "id": "F-15", "issue": "personnel-file access deadline", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/06_complaints/043_complaints_correspondence.eml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-23, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Priya Raman.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/094_agency_matters_formal_notice.xml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for agency response commitment: one source states the governed population contains 144 records through 2025-08-27, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 67 records through 2025-10-05.", "id": "F-16", "issue": "agency response commitment", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/06_complaints/046_complaints_formal_notice.xml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-23, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Elliot Mercer.", "severity": "medium"}], "matter_number": "CB-EL-3106", "prepared_for": "Frontier Game Studios", "schema_version": "1.0", "task_id": "cb100-076-frontier-games"}}, "metadata": {"benchmark": "CounselBench-100", "code_license": "Apache-2.0", "data_license": "CC-BY-4.0", "deadline": "2026-09-23", "document_count": 96, "jurisdiction": "Washington", "matter_number": "CB-EL-3106", "mcp_commit": "9a96ea6e5913736f92b88345bf51caeaaa8e719f", "mcp_package": "@modelcontextprotocol/server-filesystem@2026.7.10", "practice_area": "employment", "reference_tool_calls": 46, "required_evidence_reads": 33, "synthetic": true, "venue": "Washington Department of Labor & Industries", "version": "2.0.0"}, "prompt": "You are employment counsel for Frontier Game Studios. The upcoming deadline leaves no room for unsupported assumptions, so every conclusion must trace to the supplied production. Remote artists signed varying agreements while access, supervision, invoice, and source-file records support different classifications. Decision due 2026-09-23. Washington law governs; Washington Department of Labor & Industries is the forum. Give controlling documents precedence only when the record supports that hierarchy. Work out the defensible position from the matter production and leave an audit-ready exception tracker and concise advice for the supervising lawyer. Keep confirmed conflicts separate from open questions, cite the records that actually control each conclusion, and do not fill gaps with outside facts.", "rubric": {"criteria": [{"category": "procedure", "description": "Complete at least 46 successful, argument-specific evidence and output calls.", "id": "procedure.minimum_successful_tool_calls"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Find and read the 33 controlling, corroborating, and work-product-control records in full.", "id": "procedure.all_evidence_read_in_full"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Inspect file metadata for the eight designated critical primary records before relying on them.", "id": "procedure.chain_of_custody_metadata_checked"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Confirm the sandbox's allowed document and output roots.", "id": "procedure.allowed_directories_checked"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Inventory all 96 records so the relevant sources are discovered among the context records.", "id": "procedure.recursive_inventory_completed"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Search the production for email evidence that may corroborate or contradict formal records.", "id": "procedure.targeted_search_completed"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Leave only findings.json and advice.md in the output workspace.", "id": "procedure.exact_deliverable_set"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Create both final work products through the sandbox MCP surface.", "id": "procedure.deliverables_written_through_mcp"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Produce findings.json as a valid JSON object.", "id": "findings.findings_is_object"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Report exactly 16 confirmed exceptions.", "id": "findings.findings_exact_count"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Use each stable finding ID exactly once.", "id": "findings.finding_ids_unique"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set schema_version to the released matter value '1.0'.", "id": "findings.top_level_schema_version"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set task_id to the released matter value 'cb100-076-frontier-games'.", "id": "findings.top_level_task_id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set matter_number to the released matter value 'CB-EL-3106'.", "id": "findings.top_level_matter_number"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set prepared_for to the released matter value 'Frontier Game Studios'.", "id": "findings.top_level_prepared_for"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set as_of to the released matter value '2026-09-23'.", "id": "findings.top_level_as_of"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-01 exception for classification inconsistency.", "id": "findings.F-01.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's id from /workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/001_handbooks_policies_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_investigations/049_investigations_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's issue from /workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/001_handbooks_policies_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_investigations/049_investigations_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's severity from /workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/001_handbooks_policies_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_investigations/049_investigations_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's primary_source from /workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/001_handbooks_policies_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_investigations/049_investigations_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/001_handbooks_policies_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_investigations/049_investigations_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-01 using the exact controlled facts ['2025-01-07', 'CB-EL-3106-A524', '2025-02-09', 'CB-EL-3106-J271'].", "id": "findings.F-01.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-01's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-01.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-23', 'Willa Novak'] for F-01.", "id": "findings.F-01.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-02 exception for overtime calculation error.", "id": "findings.F-02.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's id from /workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/004_handbooks_policies_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_investigations/052_investigations_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's issue from /workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/004_handbooks_policies_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_investigations/052_investigations_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's severity from /workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/004_handbooks_policies_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_investigations/052_investigations_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's primary_source from /workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/004_handbooks_policies_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_investigations/052_investigations_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/004_handbooks_policies_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_investigations/052_investigations_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-02 using the exact controlled facts ['$7,455,216.00', '$7,486,932.00'].", "id": "findings.F-02.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-02's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-02.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-23', 'Theo Laurent'] for F-02.", "id": "findings.F-02.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-03 exception for meal-period premium gap.", "id": "findings.F-03.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's id from /workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/007_handbooks_policies_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_investigations/055_investigations_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's issue from /workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/007_handbooks_policies_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_investigations/055_investigations_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's severity from /workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/007_handbooks_policies_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_investigations/055_investigations_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's primary_source from /workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/007_handbooks_policies_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_investigations/055_investigations_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/007_handbooks_policies_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_investigations/055_investigations_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-03 using the exact controlled facts ['Caleb Hassan', 'Samuel Kim'].", "id": "findings.F-03.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-03's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-03.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-23', 'Amara Patel'] for F-03.", "id": "findings.F-03.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-04 exception for pay-equity outlier.", "id": "findings.F-04.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's id from /workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/010_personnel_records_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_performance_discipline/058_performance_discipline_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's issue from /workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/010_personnel_records_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_performance_discipline/058_performance_discipline_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's severity from /workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/010_personnel_records_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_performance_discipline/058_performance_discipline_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's primary_source from /workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/010_personnel_records_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_performance_discipline/058_performance_discipline_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/010_personnel_records_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_performance_discipline/058_performance_discipline_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-04 using the exact controlled facts ['closed without exception', 'CB-EL-3106-D888', 'open and escalated', 'CB-EL-3106-M160'].", "id": "findings.F-04.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-04's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-04.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-23', 'Henry Cho'] for F-04.", "id": "findings.F-04.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-05 exception for leave designation delay.", "id": "findings.F-05.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's id from /workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/013_personnel_records_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_performance_discipline/061_performance_discipline_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's issue from /workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/013_personnel_records_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_performance_discipline/061_performance_discipline_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's severity from /workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/013_personnel_records_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_performance_discipline/061_performance_discipline_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's primary_source from /workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/013_personnel_records_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_performance_discipline/061_performance_discipline_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/013_personnel_records_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_performance_discipline/061_performance_discipline_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-05 using the exact controlled facts ['Washington Department of Labor & Industries', 'Washington'].", "id": "findings.F-05.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-05's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-05.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-23', 'Nadine Flores'] for F-05.", "id": "findings.F-05.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-06 exception for interactive-process lapse.", "id": "findings.F-06.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's id from /workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/016_personnel_records_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_performance_discipline/064_performance_discipline_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's issue from /workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/016_personnel_records_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_performance_discipline/064_performance_discipline_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's severity from /workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/016_personnel_records_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_performance_discipline/064_performance_discipline_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's primary_source from /workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/016_personnel_records_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_performance_discipline/064_performance_discipline_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/016_personnel_records_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_performance_discipline/064_performance_discipline_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-06 using the exact controlled facts ['8%', '12%'].", "id": "findings.F-06.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-06's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-06.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-23', 'Micah Sullivan'] for F-06.", "id": "findings.F-06.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-07 exception for complaint escalation gap.", "id": "findings.F-07.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's id from /workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/019_payroll_time_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_separation/067_separation_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's issue from /workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/019_payroll_time_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_separation/067_separation_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's severity from /workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/019_payroll_time_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_separation/067_separation_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's primary_source from /workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/019_payroll_time_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_separation/067_separation_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/019_payroll_time_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_separation/067_separation_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-07 using the exact controlled facts ['notices-frontier_game_studios@example.test', 'archive-distributed_art_contributor_group@example.test'].", "id": "findings.F-07.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-07's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-07.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-23', 'Farah Ibrahim'] for F-07.", "id": "findings.F-07.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-08 exception for investigation independence concern.", "id": "findings.F-08.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's id from /workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/022_payroll_time_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_separation/070_separation_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's issue from /workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/022_payroll_time_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_separation/070_separation_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's severity from /workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/022_payroll_time_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_separation/070_separation_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's primary_source from /workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/022_payroll_time_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_separation/070_separation_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/022_payroll_time_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_separation/070_separation_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-08 using the exact controlled facts ['185 records', '2026-02-24', '44 records', '2026-03-12'].", "id": "findings.F-08.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-08's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-08.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-23', 'Owen Delgado'] for F-08.", "id": "findings.F-08.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-09 exception for discipline comparator inconsistency.", "id": "findings.F-09.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's id from /workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/025_compensation_equity_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_contractors/073_contractors_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's issue from /workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/025_compensation_equity_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_contractors/073_contractors_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's severity from /workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/025_compensation_equity_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_contractors/073_contractors_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's primary_source from /workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/025_compensation_equity_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_contractors/073_contractors_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/025_compensation_equity_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_contractors/073_contractors_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-09 using the exact controlled facts ['2025-07-21', 'CB-EL-3106-I599', '2025-09-01', 'CB-EL-3106-R553'].", "id": "findings.F-09.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-09's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-09.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-23', 'Lena Varga'] for F-09.", "id": "findings.F-09.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-10 exception for retaliation timing.", "id": "findings.F-10.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's id from /workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/028_compensation_equity_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_contractors/076_contractors_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's issue from /workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/028_compensation_equity_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_contractors/076_contractors_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's severity from /workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/028_compensation_equity_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_contractors/076_contractors_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's primary_source from /workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/028_compensation_equity_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_contractors/076_contractors_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/028_compensation_equity_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_contractors/076_contractors_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-10 using the exact controlled facts ['$4,304,356.00', '$4,435,212.00'].", "id": "findings.F-10.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-10's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-10.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-23', 'Samuel Kim'] for F-10.", "id": "findings.F-10.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-11 exception for separation pay discrepancy.", "id": "findings.F-11.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's id from /workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/031_compensation_equity_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_contractors/079_contractors_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's issue from /workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/031_compensation_equity_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_contractors/079_contractors_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's severity from /workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/031_compensation_equity_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_contractors/079_contractors_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's primary_source from /workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/031_compensation_equity_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_contractors/079_contractors_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/031_compensation_equity_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_contractors/079_contractors_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-11 using the exact controlled facts ['Caleb Hassan', 'Theo Laurent'].", "id": "findings.F-11.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-11's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-11.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-23', 'Maya Ellison'] for F-11.", "id": "findings.F-11.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-12 exception for restrictive-covenant conflict.", "id": "findings.F-12.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's id from /workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/034_leave_accommodation_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_training/082_training_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's issue from /workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/034_leave_accommodation_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_training/082_training_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's severity from /workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/034_leave_accommodation_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_training/082_training_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's primary_source from /workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/034_leave_accommodation_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_training/082_training_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/034_leave_accommodation_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_training/082_training_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-12 using the exact controlled facts ['closed without exception', 'CB-EL-3106-L519', 'open and escalated', 'CB-EL-3106-U893'].", "id": "findings.F-12.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-12's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-12.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-23', 'Rafael Okafor'] for F-12.", "id": "findings.F-12.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-13 exception for contractor control evidence.", "id": "findings.F-13.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's id from /workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/037_leave_accommodation_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_training/085_training_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's issue from /workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/037_leave_accommodation_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_training/085_training_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's severity from /workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/037_leave_accommodation_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_training/085_training_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's primary_source from /workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/037_leave_accommodation_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_training/085_training_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/037_leave_accommodation_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_training/085_training_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-13 using the exact controlled facts ['Washington Department of Labor & Industries', 'Washington'].", "id": "findings.F-13.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-13's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-13.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-23', 'Nora Chen'] for F-13.", "id": "findings.F-13.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-14 exception for training completion gap.", "id": "findings.F-14.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's id from /workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/040_leave_accommodation_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_training/088_training_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's issue from /workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/040_leave_accommodation_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_training/088_training_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's severity from /workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/040_leave_accommodation_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_training/088_training_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's primary_source from /workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/040_leave_accommodation_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_training/088_training_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/040_leave_accommodation_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_training/088_training_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-14 using the exact controlled facts ['5%', '12%'].", "id": "findings.F-14.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-14's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-14.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-23', 'Dominic Alvarez'] for F-14.", "id": "findings.F-14.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-15 exception for personnel-file access deadline.", "id": "findings.F-15.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's id from /workspace/documents/06_complaints/043_complaints_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/091_agency_matters_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's issue from /workspace/documents/06_complaints/043_complaints_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/091_agency_matters_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's severity from /workspace/documents/06_complaints/043_complaints_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/091_agency_matters_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's primary_source from /workspace/documents/06_complaints/043_complaints_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/091_agency_matters_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/06_complaints/043_complaints_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/091_agency_matters_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-15 using the exact controlled facts ['notices-frontier_game_studios@example.test', 'archive-distributed_art_contributor_group@example.test'].", "id": "findings.F-15.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-15's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-15.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-23', 'Priya Raman'] for F-15.", "id": "findings.F-15.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-16 exception for agency response commitment.", "id": "findings.F-16.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's id from /workspace/documents/06_complaints/046_complaints_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/094_agency_matters_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's issue from /workspace/documents/06_complaints/046_complaints_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/094_agency_matters_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's severity from /workspace/documents/06_complaints/046_complaints_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/094_agency_matters_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's primary_source from /workspace/documents/06_complaints/046_complaints_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/094_agency_matters_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/06_complaints/046_complaints_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/094_agency_matters_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-16 using the exact controlled facts ['144 records', '2025-08-27', '67 records', '2025-10-05'].", "id": "findings.F-16.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-16's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-16.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-23', 'Elliot Mercer'] for F-16.", "id": "findings.F-16.action_anchors"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Executive assessment' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Executive assessment"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Method and record coverage' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Method and record coverage"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Findings' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Findings"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Recommended next actions' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Recommended next actions"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Assumptions and limitations' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Assumptions and limitations"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-01 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-01"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-02 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-02"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-03 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-03"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-04 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-04"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-05 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-05"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-06 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-06"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-07 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-07"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-08 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-08"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-09 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-09"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-10 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-10"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-11 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-11"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-12 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-12"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-13 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-13"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-14 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-14"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-15 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-15"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-16 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-16"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Do not claim the production has no issues or that every record is consistent.", "id": "memo.forbidden_claims_absent"}], "decision_options": [{"id": "cross-source-reconciliation", "label": "Reconcile controlling and corroborating records", "reason": "The CB-EL-3106 production contains independently maintained records; a defensible answer must preserve each supported conflict and its cure owner.", "selected": true}, {"id": "latest-record-controls", "label": "Treat the latest record as controlling", "reason": "Timestamp recency does not establish legal priority, execution, or approval authority.", "selected": false}, {"id": "primary-records-only", "label": "Report primary records without reconciliation", "reason": "Primary records alone conceal the operational conflicts that create the actionable exceptions.", "selected": false}], "gates": ["all_evidence_read_in_full", "chain_of_custody_metadata_checked", "findings_criteria_complete", "memo_criteria_complete", "deliverables_written_through_mcp"], "metadata_checks": 8, "metric": "weighted_criteria_score", "minimum_tool_calls": 46, "required_deliverables": ["findings.json", "advice.md"], "required_document_reads": 33, "type": "deterministic", "weights": {"findings": 0.55, "memo": 0.2, "procedure": 0.25}}, "task_id": "cb100-076-frontier-games", "task_name": "Frontier contractor and IP audit", "world_id": "counselbench-filesystem-mcp-v2"}
-{"context_files": ["task_files/cb100-077-goldleaf-hotels/01_handbooks_policies/001_handbooks_policies_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-077-goldleaf-hotels/01_handbooks_policies/002_handbooks_policies_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-077-goldleaf-hotels/01_handbooks_policies/003_handbooks_policies_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-077-goldleaf-hotels/01_handbooks_policies/004_handbooks_policies_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-077-goldleaf-hotels/01_handbooks_policies/005_handbooks_policies_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-077-goldleaf-hotels/01_handbooks_policies/006_handbooks_policies_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-077-goldleaf-hotels/01_handbooks_policies/007_handbooks_policies_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-077-goldleaf-hotels/01_handbooks_policies/008_handbooks_policies_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-077-goldleaf-hotels/02_personnel_records/009_personnel_records_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-077-goldleaf-hotels/02_personnel_records/010_personnel_records_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-077-goldleaf-hotels/02_personnel_records/011_personnel_records_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-077-goldleaf-hotels/02_personnel_records/012_personnel_records_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-077-goldleaf-hotels/02_personnel_records/013_personnel_records_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-077-goldleaf-hotels/02_personnel_records/014_personnel_records_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-077-goldleaf-hotels/02_personnel_records/015_personnel_records_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-077-goldleaf-hotels/02_personnel_records/016_personnel_records_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-077-goldleaf-hotels/03_payroll_time/017_payroll_time_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-077-goldleaf-hotels/03_payroll_time/018_payroll_time_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-077-goldleaf-hotels/03_payroll_time/019_payroll_time_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-077-goldleaf-hotels/03_payroll_time/020_payroll_time_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-077-goldleaf-hotels/03_payroll_time/021_payroll_time_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-077-goldleaf-hotels/03_payroll_time/022_payroll_time_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-077-goldleaf-hotels/03_payroll_time/023_payroll_time_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-077-goldleaf-hotels/03_payroll_time/024_payroll_time_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-077-goldleaf-hotels/04_compensation_equity/025_compensation_equity_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-077-goldleaf-hotels/04_compensation_equity/026_compensation_equity_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-077-goldleaf-hotels/04_compensation_equity/027_compensation_equity_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-077-goldleaf-hotels/04_compensation_equity/028_compensation_equity_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-077-goldleaf-hotels/04_compensation_equity/029_compensation_equity_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-077-goldleaf-hotels/04_compensation_equity/030_compensation_equity_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-077-goldleaf-hotels/04_compensation_equity/031_compensation_equity_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-077-goldleaf-hotels/04_compensation_equity/032_compensation_equity_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-077-goldleaf-hotels/05_leave_accommodation/033_leave_accommodation_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-077-goldleaf-hotels/05_leave_accommodation/034_leave_accommodation_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-077-goldleaf-hotels/05_leave_accommodation/035_leave_accommodation_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-077-goldleaf-hotels/05_leave_accommodation/036_leave_accommodation_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-077-goldleaf-hotels/05_leave_accommodation/037_leave_accommodation_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-077-goldleaf-hotels/05_leave_accommodation/038_leave_accommodation_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-077-goldleaf-hotels/05_leave_accommodation/039_leave_accommodation_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-077-goldleaf-hotels/05_leave_accommodation/040_leave_accommodation_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-077-goldleaf-hotels/06_complaints/041_complaints_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-077-goldleaf-hotels/06_complaints/042_complaints_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-077-goldleaf-hotels/06_complaints/043_complaints_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-077-goldleaf-hotels/06_complaints/044_complaints_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-077-goldleaf-hotels/06_complaints/045_complaints_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-077-goldleaf-hotels/06_complaints/046_complaints_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-077-goldleaf-hotels/06_complaints/047_complaints_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-077-goldleaf-hotels/06_complaints/048_complaints_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-077-goldleaf-hotels/07_investigations/049_investigations_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-077-goldleaf-hotels/07_investigations/050_investigations_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-077-goldleaf-hotels/07_investigations/051_investigations_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-077-goldleaf-hotels/07_investigations/052_investigations_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-077-goldleaf-hotels/07_investigations/053_investigations_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-077-goldleaf-hotels/07_investigations/054_investigations_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-077-goldleaf-hotels/07_investigations/055_investigations_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-077-goldleaf-hotels/07_investigations/056_investigations_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-077-goldleaf-hotels/08_performance_discipline/057_performance_discipline_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-077-goldleaf-hotels/08_performance_discipline/058_performance_discipline_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-077-goldleaf-hotels/08_performance_discipline/059_performance_discipline_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-077-goldleaf-hotels/08_performance_discipline/060_performance_discipline_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-077-goldleaf-hotels/08_performance_discipline/061_performance_discipline_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-077-goldleaf-hotels/08_performance_discipline/062_performance_discipline_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-077-goldleaf-hotels/08_performance_discipline/063_performance_discipline_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-077-goldleaf-hotels/08_performance_discipline/064_performance_discipline_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-077-goldleaf-hotels/09_separation/065_separation_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-077-goldleaf-hotels/09_separation/066_separation_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-077-goldleaf-hotels/09_separation/067_separation_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-077-goldleaf-hotels/09_separation/068_separation_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-077-goldleaf-hotels/09_separation/069_separation_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-077-goldleaf-hotels/09_separation/070_separation_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-077-goldleaf-hotels/09_separation/071_separation_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-077-goldleaf-hotels/09_separation/072_separation_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-077-goldleaf-hotels/10_contractors/073_contractors_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-077-goldleaf-hotels/10_contractors/074_contractors_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-077-goldleaf-hotels/10_contractors/075_contractors_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-077-goldleaf-hotels/10_contractors/076_contractors_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-077-goldleaf-hotels/10_contractors/077_contractors_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-077-goldleaf-hotels/10_contractors/078_contractors_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-077-goldleaf-hotels/10_contractors/079_contractors_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-077-goldleaf-hotels/10_contractors/080_contractors_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-077-goldleaf-hotels/11_training/081_training_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-077-goldleaf-hotels/11_training/082_training_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-077-goldleaf-hotels/11_training/083_training_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-077-goldleaf-hotels/11_training/084_training_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-077-goldleaf-hotels/11_training/085_training_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-077-goldleaf-hotels/11_training/086_training_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-077-goldleaf-hotels/11_training/087_training_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-077-goldleaf-hotels/11_training/088_training_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-077-goldleaf-hotels/12_agency_matters/089_agency_matters_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-077-goldleaf-hotels/12_agency_matters/090_agency_matters_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-077-goldleaf-hotels/12_agency_matters/091_agency_matters_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-077-goldleaf-hotels/12_agency_matters/092_agency_matters_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-077-goldleaf-hotels/12_agency_matters/093_agency_matters_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-077-goldleaf-hotels/12_agency_matters/094_agency_matters_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-077-goldleaf-hotels/12_agency_matters/095_agency_matters_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-077-goldleaf-hotels/12_agency_matters/096_agency_matters_status_report.md"], "gold_output": {"advice_markdown": "# Counsel advice — Goldleaf harassment response audit\n\n## Executive assessment\n\nFor Goldleaf Hotels and Resorts matter CB-EL-3107, the review identified 16 source-supported exceptions requiring action before 2026-09-26. The assessment concerns Former banquet supervisor and the supplied record for Nevada.\n\n## Method and record coverage\n\nThe review inventoried all 96 production files, read the 33 controlling, corroborating, and control records, searched the email exports, and checked metadata for the designated chain-of-custody sample. Conclusions are limited to the synthetic production supplied for this benchmark matter.\n\n## Findings\n\n### F-01 — classification inconsistency (critical)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for classification inconsistency: one source states the operative date is 2025-09-01 under control reference CB-EL-3107-A641, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2025-10-09 under response reference CB-EL-3107-J418.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/001_handbooks_policies_control_register.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/07_investigations/049_investigations_control_register.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-26, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Theo Laurent.\n\n### F-02 — overtime calculation error (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for overtime calculation error: one source states the controlling amount is $4,177,197.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $4,390,894.00.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/004_handbooks_policies_ledger_export.csv`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/07_investigations/052_investigations_ledger_export.csv`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-26, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Amara Patel.\n\n### F-03 — meal-period premium gap (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for meal-period premium gap: one source states approval is attributed to Leona Park as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Rafael Okafor and contains no entry for Leona Park.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/007_handbooks_policies_officer_certificate.html`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/07_investigations/055_investigations_officer_certificate.html`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-26, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Henry Cho.\n\n### F-04 — pay-equity outlier (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for pay-equity outlier: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-EL-3107-D387, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-EL-3107-M745.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/010_personnel_records_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/08_performance_discipline/058_performance_discipline_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-26, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Nadine Flores.\n\n### F-05 — leave designation delay (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for leave designation delay: one source states the applicable location is Nevada Equal Rights Commission, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to Nevada operations outside Nevada Equal Rights Commission.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/013_personnel_records_review_memorandum.json`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/08_performance_discipline/061_performance_discipline_review_memorandum.json`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-26, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Micah Sullivan.\n\n### F-06 — interactive-process lapse (low)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for interactive-process lapse: one source states the threshold is 13% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 18% and produced a different exception result.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/016_personnel_records_status_report.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/08_performance_discipline/064_performance_discipline_status_report.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-26, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Farah Ibrahim.\n\n### F-07 — complaint escalation gap (critical)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for complaint escalation gap: one source states formal notice must use notices-goldleaf_hotels_and_resorts@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-former_banquet_supervisor@example.test.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/019_payroll_time_correspondence.eml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/09_separation/067_separation_correspondence.eml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-26, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Owen Delgado.\n\n### F-08 — investigation independence concern (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for investigation independence concern: one source states the governed population contains 170 records through 2025-05-05, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 46 records through 2025-05-23.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/022_payroll_time_formal_notice.xml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/09_separation/070_separation_formal_notice.xml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-26, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Lena Varga.\n\n### F-09 — discipline comparator inconsistency (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for discipline comparator inconsistency: one source states the operative date is 2025-05-04 under control reference CB-EL-3107-I461, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2025-05-21 under response reference CB-EL-3107-R750.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/025_compensation_equity_control_register.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/10_contractors/073_contractors_control_register.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-26, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Samuel Kim.\n\n### F-10 — retaliation timing (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for retaliation timing: one source states the controlling amount is $5,319,766.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $5,446,032.00.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/028_compensation_equity_ledger_export.csv`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/10_contractors/076_contractors_ledger_export.csv`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-26, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Maya Ellison.\n\n### F-11 — separation pay discrepancy (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for separation pay discrepancy: one source states approval is attributed to Leona Park as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Henry Cho and contains no entry for Leona Park.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/031_compensation_equity_officer_certificate.html`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/10_contractors/079_contractors_officer_certificate.html`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-26, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Rafael Okafor.\n\n### F-12 — restrictive-covenant conflict (low)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for restrictive-covenant conflict: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-EL-3107-L484, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-EL-3107-U960.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/034_leave_accommodation_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/11_training/082_training_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-26, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Nora Chen.\n\n### F-13 — contractor control evidence (critical)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for contractor control evidence: one source states the applicable location is Nevada Equal Rights Commission, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to Nevada operations outside Nevada Equal Rights Commission.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/037_leave_accommodation_review_memorandum.json`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/11_training/085_training_review_memorandum.json`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-26, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Dominic Alvarez.\n\n### F-14 — training completion gap (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for training completion gap: one source states the threshold is 6% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 12% and produced a different exception result.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/040_leave_accommodation_status_report.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/11_training/088_training_status_report.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-26, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Priya Raman.\n\n### F-15 — personnel-file access deadline (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for personnel-file access deadline: one source states formal notice must use notices-goldleaf_hotels_and_resorts@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-former_banquet_supervisor@example.test.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/06_complaints/043_complaints_correspondence.eml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/091_agency_matters_correspondence.eml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-26, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Elliot Mercer.\n\n### F-16 — agency response commitment (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for agency response commitment: one source states the governed population contains 181 records through 2026-02-20, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 72 records through 2026-04-05.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/06_complaints/046_complaints_formal_notice.xml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/094_agency_matters_formal_notice.xml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-26, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Talia Brooks.\n\n## Recommended next actions\n\nSequence the critical and high findings first, assign the named owners, preserve the cited records, and document any resolution in the controlling matter register before the stated deadline.\n\n## Assumptions and limitations\n\nThis analysis is confined to task cb100-077-goldleaf-hotels and the supplied synthetic evidence. It does not rely on external facts, does not resolve disputed law, and is not legal advice for a real person or entity.\n", "findings": {"as_of": "2026-09-26", "findings": [{"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/07_investigations/049_investigations_control_register.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for classification inconsistency: one source states the operative date is 2025-09-01 under control reference CB-EL-3107-A641, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2025-10-09 under response reference CB-EL-3107-J418.", "id": "F-01", "issue": "classification inconsistency", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/001_handbooks_policies_control_register.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-26, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Theo Laurent.", "severity": "critical"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/07_investigations/052_investigations_ledger_export.csv", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for overtime calculation error: one source states the controlling amount is $4,177,197.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $4,390,894.00.", "id": "F-02", "issue": "overtime calculation error", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/004_handbooks_policies_ledger_export.csv", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-26, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Amara Patel.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/07_investigations/055_investigations_officer_certificate.html", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for meal-period premium gap: one source states approval is attributed to Leona Park as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Rafael Okafor and contains no entry for Leona Park.", "id": "F-03", "issue": "meal-period premium gap", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/007_handbooks_policies_officer_certificate.html", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-26, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Henry Cho.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/08_performance_discipline/058_performance_discipline_executed_instrument.txt", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for pay-equity outlier: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-EL-3107-D387, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-EL-3107-M745.", "id": "F-04", "issue": "pay-equity outlier", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/010_personnel_records_executed_instrument.txt", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-26, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Nadine Flores.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/08_performance_discipline/061_performance_discipline_review_memorandum.json", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for leave designation delay: one source states the applicable location is Nevada Equal Rights Commission, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to Nevada operations outside Nevada Equal Rights Commission.", "id": "F-05", "issue": "leave designation delay", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/013_personnel_records_review_memorandum.json", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-26, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Micah Sullivan.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/08_performance_discipline/064_performance_discipline_status_report.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for interactive-process lapse: one source states the threshold is 13% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 18% and produced a different exception result.", "id": "F-06", "issue": "interactive-process lapse", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/016_personnel_records_status_report.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-26, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Farah Ibrahim.", "severity": "low"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/09_separation/067_separation_correspondence.eml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for complaint escalation gap: one source states formal notice must use notices-goldleaf_hotels_and_resorts@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-former_banquet_supervisor@example.test.", "id": "F-07", "issue": "complaint escalation gap", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/019_payroll_time_correspondence.eml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-26, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Owen Delgado.", "severity": "critical"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/09_separation/070_separation_formal_notice.xml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for investigation independence concern: one source states the governed population contains 170 records through 2025-05-05, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 46 records through 2025-05-23.", "id": "F-08", "issue": "investigation independence concern", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/022_payroll_time_formal_notice.xml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-26, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Lena Varga.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/10_contractors/073_contractors_control_register.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for discipline comparator inconsistency: one source states the operative date is 2025-05-04 under control reference CB-EL-3107-I461, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2025-05-21 under response reference CB-EL-3107-R750.", "id": "F-09", "issue": "discipline comparator inconsistency", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/025_compensation_equity_control_register.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-26, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Samuel Kim.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/10_contractors/076_contractors_ledger_export.csv", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for retaliation timing: one source states the controlling amount is $5,319,766.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $5,446,032.00.", "id": "F-10", "issue": "retaliation timing", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/028_compensation_equity_ledger_export.csv", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-26, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Maya Ellison.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/10_contractors/079_contractors_officer_certificate.html", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for separation pay discrepancy: one source states approval is attributed to Leona Park as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Henry Cho and contains no entry for Leona Park.", "id": "F-11", "issue": "separation pay discrepancy", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/031_compensation_equity_officer_certificate.html", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-26, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Rafael Okafor.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/11_training/082_training_executed_instrument.txt", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for restrictive-covenant conflict: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-EL-3107-L484, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-EL-3107-U960.", "id": "F-12", "issue": "restrictive-covenant conflict", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/034_leave_accommodation_executed_instrument.txt", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-26, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Nora Chen.", "severity": "low"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/11_training/085_training_review_memorandum.json", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for contractor control evidence: one source states the applicable location is Nevada Equal Rights Commission, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to Nevada operations outside Nevada Equal Rights Commission.", "id": "F-13", "issue": "contractor control evidence", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/037_leave_accommodation_review_memorandum.json", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-26, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Dominic Alvarez.", "severity": "critical"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/11_training/088_training_status_report.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for training completion gap: one source states the threshold is 6% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 12% and produced a different exception result.", "id": "F-14", "issue": "training completion gap", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/040_leave_accommodation_status_report.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-26, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Priya Raman.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/091_agency_matters_correspondence.eml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for personnel-file access deadline: one source states formal notice must use notices-goldleaf_hotels_and_resorts@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-former_banquet_supervisor@example.test.", "id": "F-15", "issue": "personnel-file access deadline", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/06_complaints/043_complaints_correspondence.eml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-26, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Elliot Mercer.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/094_agency_matters_formal_notice.xml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for agency response commitment: one source states the governed population contains 181 records through 2026-02-20, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 72 records through 2026-04-05.", "id": "F-16", "issue": "agency response commitment", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/06_complaints/046_complaints_formal_notice.xml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-26, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Talia Brooks.", "severity": "medium"}], "matter_number": "CB-EL-3107", "prepared_for": "Goldleaf Hotels and Resorts", "schema_version": "1.0", "task_id": "cb100-077-goldleaf-hotels"}}, "metadata": {"benchmark": "CounselBench-100", "code_license": "Apache-2.0", "data_license": "CC-BY-4.0", "deadline": "2026-09-26", "document_count": 96, "jurisdiction": "Nevada", "matter_number": "CB-EL-3107", "mcp_commit": "9a96ea6e5913736f92b88345bf51caeaaa8e719f", "mcp_package": "@modelcontextprotocol/server-filesystem@2026.7.10", "practice_area": "employment", "reference_tool_calls": 46, "required_evidence_reads": 33, "synthetic": true, "venue": "Nevada Equal Rights Commission", "version": "2.0.0"}, "prompt": "You are employment counsel for Goldleaf Hotels and Resorts. A counterparty challenged the client's internal summary, making cross-document reconciliation and precise citations essential. A complaint moved among HR and operations while witness selection, schedule changes, training, and separation records diverged. Decision due 2026-09-26. Nevada law governs; Nevada Equal Rights Commission is the forum. Flag cross-folder dependencies that would be invisible in a single-document review. Work out the defensible position from the matter production and leave an audit-ready exception tracker and concise advice for the supervising lawyer. Keep confirmed conflicts separate from open questions, cite the records that actually control each conclusion, and do not fill gaps with outside facts.", "rubric": {"criteria": [{"category": "procedure", "description": "Complete at least 46 successful, argument-specific evidence and output calls.", "id": "procedure.minimum_successful_tool_calls"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Find and read the 33 controlling, corroborating, and work-product-control records in full.", "id": "procedure.all_evidence_read_in_full"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Inspect file metadata for the eight designated critical primary records before relying on them.", "id": "procedure.chain_of_custody_metadata_checked"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Confirm the sandbox's allowed document and output roots.", "id": "procedure.allowed_directories_checked"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Inventory all 96 records so the relevant sources are discovered among the context records.", "id": "procedure.recursive_inventory_completed"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Search the production for email evidence that may corroborate or contradict formal records.", "id": "procedure.targeted_search_completed"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Leave only findings.json and advice.md in the output workspace.", "id": "procedure.exact_deliverable_set"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Create both final work products through the sandbox MCP surface.", "id": "procedure.deliverables_written_through_mcp"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Produce findings.json as a valid JSON object.", "id": "findings.findings_is_object"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Report exactly 16 confirmed exceptions.", "id": "findings.findings_exact_count"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Use each stable finding ID exactly once.", "id": "findings.finding_ids_unique"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set schema_version to the released matter value '1.0'.", "id": "findings.top_level_schema_version"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set task_id to the released matter value 'cb100-077-goldleaf-hotels'.", "id": "findings.top_level_task_id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set matter_number to the released matter value 'CB-EL-3107'.", "id": "findings.top_level_matter_number"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set prepared_for to the released matter value 'Goldleaf Hotels and Resorts'.", "id": "findings.top_level_prepared_for"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set as_of to the released matter value '2026-09-26'.", "id": "findings.top_level_as_of"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-01 exception for classification inconsistency.", "id": "findings.F-01.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's id from /workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/001_handbooks_policies_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_investigations/049_investigations_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's issue from /workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/001_handbooks_policies_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_investigations/049_investigations_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's severity from /workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/001_handbooks_policies_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_investigations/049_investigations_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's primary_source from /workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/001_handbooks_policies_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_investigations/049_investigations_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/001_handbooks_policies_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_investigations/049_investigations_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-01 using the exact controlled facts ['2025-09-01', 'CB-EL-3107-A641', '2025-10-09', 'CB-EL-3107-J418'].", "id": "findings.F-01.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-01's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-01.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-26', 'Theo Laurent'] for F-01.", "id": "findings.F-01.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-02 exception for overtime calculation error.", "id": "findings.F-02.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's id from /workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/004_handbooks_policies_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_investigations/052_investigations_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's issue from /workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/004_handbooks_policies_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_investigations/052_investigations_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's severity from /workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/004_handbooks_policies_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_investigations/052_investigations_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's primary_source from /workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/004_handbooks_policies_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_investigations/052_investigations_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/004_handbooks_policies_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_investigations/052_investigations_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-02 using the exact controlled facts ['$4,177,197.00', '$4,390,894.00'].", "id": "findings.F-02.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-02's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-02.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-26', 'Amara Patel'] for F-02.", "id": "findings.F-02.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-03 exception for meal-period premium gap.", "id": "findings.F-03.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's id from /workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/007_handbooks_policies_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_investigations/055_investigations_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's issue from /workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/007_handbooks_policies_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_investigations/055_investigations_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's severity from /workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/007_handbooks_policies_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_investigations/055_investigations_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's primary_source from /workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/007_handbooks_policies_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_investigations/055_investigations_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/007_handbooks_policies_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_investigations/055_investigations_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-03 using the exact controlled facts ['Leona Park', 'Rafael Okafor'].", "id": "findings.F-03.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-03's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-03.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-26', 'Henry Cho'] for F-03.", "id": "findings.F-03.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-04 exception for pay-equity outlier.", "id": "findings.F-04.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's id from /workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/010_personnel_records_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_performance_discipline/058_performance_discipline_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's issue from /workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/010_personnel_records_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_performance_discipline/058_performance_discipline_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's severity from /workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/010_personnel_records_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_performance_discipline/058_performance_discipline_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's primary_source from /workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/010_personnel_records_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_performance_discipline/058_performance_discipline_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/010_personnel_records_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_performance_discipline/058_performance_discipline_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-04 using the exact controlled facts ['closed without exception', 'CB-EL-3107-D387', 'open and escalated', 'CB-EL-3107-M745'].", "id": "findings.F-04.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-04's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-04.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-26', 'Nadine Flores'] for F-04.", "id": "findings.F-04.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-05 exception for leave designation delay.", "id": "findings.F-05.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's id from /workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/013_personnel_records_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_performance_discipline/061_performance_discipline_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's issue from /workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/013_personnel_records_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_performance_discipline/061_performance_discipline_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's severity from /workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/013_personnel_records_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_performance_discipline/061_performance_discipline_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's primary_source from /workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/013_personnel_records_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_performance_discipline/061_performance_discipline_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/013_personnel_records_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_performance_discipline/061_performance_discipline_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-05 using the exact controlled facts ['Nevada Equal Rights Commission', 'Nevada'].", "id": "findings.F-05.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-05's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-05.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-26', 'Micah Sullivan'] for F-05.", "id": "findings.F-05.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-06 exception for interactive-process lapse.", "id": "findings.F-06.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's id from /workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/016_personnel_records_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_performance_discipline/064_performance_discipline_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's issue from /workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/016_personnel_records_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_performance_discipline/064_performance_discipline_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's severity from /workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/016_personnel_records_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_performance_discipline/064_performance_discipline_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's primary_source from /workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/016_personnel_records_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_performance_discipline/064_performance_discipline_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/016_personnel_records_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_performance_discipline/064_performance_discipline_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-06 using the exact controlled facts ['13%', '18%'].", "id": "findings.F-06.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-06's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-06.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-26', 'Farah Ibrahim'] for F-06.", "id": "findings.F-06.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-07 exception for complaint escalation gap.", "id": "findings.F-07.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's id from /workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/019_payroll_time_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_separation/067_separation_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's issue from /workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/019_payroll_time_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_separation/067_separation_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's severity from /workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/019_payroll_time_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_separation/067_separation_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's primary_source from /workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/019_payroll_time_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_separation/067_separation_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/019_payroll_time_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_separation/067_separation_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-07 using the exact controlled facts ['notices-goldleaf_hotels_and_resorts@example.test', 'archive-former_banquet_supervisor@example.test'].", "id": "findings.F-07.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-07's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-07.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-26', 'Owen Delgado'] for F-07.", "id": "findings.F-07.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-08 exception for investigation independence concern.", "id": "findings.F-08.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's id from /workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/022_payroll_time_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_separation/070_separation_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's issue from /workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/022_payroll_time_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_separation/070_separation_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's severity from /workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/022_payroll_time_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_separation/070_separation_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's primary_source from /workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/022_payroll_time_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_separation/070_separation_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/022_payroll_time_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_separation/070_separation_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-08 using the exact controlled facts ['170 records', '2025-05-05', '46 records', '2025-05-23'].", "id": "findings.F-08.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-08's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-08.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-26', 'Lena Varga'] for F-08.", "id": "findings.F-08.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-09 exception for discipline comparator inconsistency.", "id": "findings.F-09.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's id from /workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/025_compensation_equity_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_contractors/073_contractors_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's issue from /workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/025_compensation_equity_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_contractors/073_contractors_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's severity from /workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/025_compensation_equity_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_contractors/073_contractors_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's primary_source from /workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/025_compensation_equity_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_contractors/073_contractors_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/025_compensation_equity_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_contractors/073_contractors_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-09 using the exact controlled facts ['2025-05-04', 'CB-EL-3107-I461', '2025-05-21', 'CB-EL-3107-R750'].", "id": "findings.F-09.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-09's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-09.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-26', 'Samuel Kim'] for F-09.", "id": "findings.F-09.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-10 exception for retaliation timing.", "id": "findings.F-10.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's id from /workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/028_compensation_equity_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_contractors/076_contractors_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's issue from /workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/028_compensation_equity_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_contractors/076_contractors_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's severity from /workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/028_compensation_equity_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_contractors/076_contractors_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's primary_source from /workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/028_compensation_equity_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_contractors/076_contractors_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/028_compensation_equity_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_contractors/076_contractors_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-10 using the exact controlled facts ['$5,319,766.00', '$5,446,032.00'].", "id": "findings.F-10.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-10's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-10.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-26', 'Maya Ellison'] for F-10.", "id": "findings.F-10.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-11 exception for separation pay discrepancy.", "id": "findings.F-11.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's id from /workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/031_compensation_equity_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_contractors/079_contractors_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's issue from /workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/031_compensation_equity_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_contractors/079_contractors_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's severity from /workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/031_compensation_equity_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_contractors/079_contractors_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's primary_source from /workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/031_compensation_equity_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_contractors/079_contractors_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/031_compensation_equity_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_contractors/079_contractors_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-11 using the exact controlled facts ['Leona Park', 'Henry Cho'].", "id": "findings.F-11.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-11's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-11.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-26', 'Rafael Okafor'] for F-11.", "id": "findings.F-11.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-12 exception for restrictive-covenant conflict.", "id": "findings.F-12.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's id from /workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/034_leave_accommodation_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_training/082_training_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's issue from /workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/034_leave_accommodation_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_training/082_training_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's severity from /workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/034_leave_accommodation_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_training/082_training_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's primary_source from /workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/034_leave_accommodation_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_training/082_training_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/034_leave_accommodation_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_training/082_training_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-12 using the exact controlled facts ['closed without exception', 'CB-EL-3107-L484', 'open and escalated', 'CB-EL-3107-U960'].", "id": "findings.F-12.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-12's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-12.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-26', 'Nora Chen'] for F-12.", "id": "findings.F-12.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-13 exception for contractor control evidence.", "id": "findings.F-13.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's id from /workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/037_leave_accommodation_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_training/085_training_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's issue from /workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/037_leave_accommodation_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_training/085_training_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's severity from /workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/037_leave_accommodation_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_training/085_training_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's primary_source from /workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/037_leave_accommodation_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_training/085_training_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/037_leave_accommodation_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_training/085_training_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-13 using the exact controlled facts ['Nevada Equal Rights Commission', 'Nevada'].", "id": "findings.F-13.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-13's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-13.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-26', 'Dominic Alvarez'] for F-13.", "id": "findings.F-13.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-14 exception for training completion gap.", "id": "findings.F-14.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's id from /workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/040_leave_accommodation_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_training/088_training_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's issue from /workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/040_leave_accommodation_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_training/088_training_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's severity from /workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/040_leave_accommodation_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_training/088_training_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's primary_source from /workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/040_leave_accommodation_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_training/088_training_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/040_leave_accommodation_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_training/088_training_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-14 using the exact controlled facts ['6%', '12%'].", "id": "findings.F-14.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-14's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-14.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-26', 'Priya Raman'] for F-14.", "id": "findings.F-14.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-15 exception for personnel-file access deadline.", "id": "findings.F-15.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's id from /workspace/documents/06_complaints/043_complaints_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/091_agency_matters_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's issue from /workspace/documents/06_complaints/043_complaints_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/091_agency_matters_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's severity from /workspace/documents/06_complaints/043_complaints_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/091_agency_matters_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's primary_source from /workspace/documents/06_complaints/043_complaints_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/091_agency_matters_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/06_complaints/043_complaints_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/091_agency_matters_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-15 using the exact controlled facts ['notices-goldleaf_hotels_and_resorts@example.test', 'archive-former_banquet_supervisor@example.test'].", "id": "findings.F-15.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-15's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-15.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-26', 'Elliot Mercer'] for F-15.", "id": "findings.F-15.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-16 exception for agency response commitment.", "id": "findings.F-16.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's id from /workspace/documents/06_complaints/046_complaints_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/094_agency_matters_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's issue from /workspace/documents/06_complaints/046_complaints_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/094_agency_matters_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's severity from /workspace/documents/06_complaints/046_complaints_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/094_agency_matters_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's primary_source from /workspace/documents/06_complaints/046_complaints_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/094_agency_matters_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/06_complaints/046_complaints_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/094_agency_matters_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-16 using the exact controlled facts ['181 records', '2026-02-20', '72 records', '2026-04-05'].", "id": "findings.F-16.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-16's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-16.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-26', 'Talia Brooks'] for F-16.", "id": "findings.F-16.action_anchors"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Executive assessment' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Executive assessment"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Method and record coverage' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Method and record coverage"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Findings' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Findings"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Recommended next actions' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Recommended next actions"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Assumptions and limitations' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Assumptions and limitations"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-01 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-01"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-02 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-02"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-03 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-03"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-04 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-04"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-05 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-05"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-06 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-06"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-07 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-07"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-08 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-08"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-09 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-09"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-10 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-10"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-11 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-11"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-12 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-12"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-13 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-13"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-14 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-14"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-15 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-15"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-16 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-16"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Do not claim the production has no issues or that every record is consistent.", "id": "memo.forbidden_claims_absent"}], "decision_options": [{"id": "cross-source-reconciliation", "label": "Reconcile controlling and corroborating records", "reason": "The CB-EL-3107 production contains independently maintained records; a defensible answer must preserve each supported conflict and its cure owner.", "selected": true}, {"id": "latest-record-controls", "label": "Treat the latest record as controlling", "reason": "Timestamp recency does not establish legal priority, execution, or approval authority.", "selected": false}, {"id": "primary-records-only", "label": "Report primary records without reconciliation", "reason": "Primary records alone conceal the operational conflicts that create the actionable exceptions.", "selected": false}], "gates": ["all_evidence_read_in_full", "chain_of_custody_metadata_checked", "findings_criteria_complete", "memo_criteria_complete", "deliverables_written_through_mcp"], "metadata_checks": 8, "metric": "weighted_criteria_score", "minimum_tool_calls": 46, "required_deliverables": ["findings.json", "advice.md"], "required_document_reads": 33, "type": "deterministic", "weights": {"findings": 0.55, "memo": 0.2, "procedure": 0.25}}, "task_id": "cb100-077-goldleaf-hotels", "task_name": "Goldleaf harassment response audit", "world_id": "counselbench-filesystem-mcp-v2"}
-{"context_files": ["task_files/cb100-078-harbor-transit/01_handbooks_policies/001_handbooks_policies_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-078-harbor-transit/01_handbooks_policies/002_handbooks_policies_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-078-harbor-transit/01_handbooks_policies/003_handbooks_policies_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-078-harbor-transit/01_handbooks_policies/004_handbooks_policies_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-078-harbor-transit/01_handbooks_policies/005_handbooks_policies_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-078-harbor-transit/01_handbooks_policies/006_handbooks_policies_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-078-harbor-transit/01_handbooks_policies/007_handbooks_policies_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-078-harbor-transit/01_handbooks_policies/008_handbooks_policies_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-078-harbor-transit/02_personnel_records/009_personnel_records_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-078-harbor-transit/02_personnel_records/010_personnel_records_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-078-harbor-transit/02_personnel_records/011_personnel_records_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-078-harbor-transit/02_personnel_records/012_personnel_records_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-078-harbor-transit/02_personnel_records/013_personnel_records_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-078-harbor-transit/02_personnel_records/014_personnel_records_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-078-harbor-transit/02_personnel_records/015_personnel_records_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-078-harbor-transit/02_personnel_records/016_personnel_records_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-078-harbor-transit/03_payroll_time/017_payroll_time_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-078-harbor-transit/03_payroll_time/018_payroll_time_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-078-harbor-transit/03_payroll_time/019_payroll_time_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-078-harbor-transit/03_payroll_time/020_payroll_time_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-078-harbor-transit/03_payroll_time/021_payroll_time_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-078-harbor-transit/03_payroll_time/022_payroll_time_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-078-harbor-transit/03_payroll_time/023_payroll_time_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-078-harbor-transit/03_payroll_time/024_payroll_time_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-078-harbor-transit/04_compensation_equity/025_compensation_equity_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-078-harbor-transit/04_compensation_equity/026_compensation_equity_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-078-harbor-transit/04_compensation_equity/027_compensation_equity_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-078-harbor-transit/04_compensation_equity/028_compensation_equity_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-078-harbor-transit/04_compensation_equity/029_compensation_equity_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-078-harbor-transit/04_compensation_equity/030_compensation_equity_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-078-harbor-transit/04_compensation_equity/031_compensation_equity_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-078-harbor-transit/04_compensation_equity/032_compensation_equity_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-078-harbor-transit/05_leave_accommodation/033_leave_accommodation_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-078-harbor-transit/05_leave_accommodation/034_leave_accommodation_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-078-harbor-transit/05_leave_accommodation/035_leave_accommodation_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-078-harbor-transit/05_leave_accommodation/036_leave_accommodation_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-078-harbor-transit/05_leave_accommodation/037_leave_accommodation_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-078-harbor-transit/05_leave_accommodation/038_leave_accommodation_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-078-harbor-transit/05_leave_accommodation/039_leave_accommodation_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-078-harbor-transit/05_leave_accommodation/040_leave_accommodation_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-078-harbor-transit/06_complaints/041_complaints_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-078-harbor-transit/06_complaints/042_complaints_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-078-harbor-transit/06_complaints/043_complaints_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-078-harbor-transit/06_complaints/044_complaints_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-078-harbor-transit/06_complaints/045_complaints_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-078-harbor-transit/06_complaints/046_complaints_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-078-harbor-transit/06_complaints/047_complaints_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-078-harbor-transit/06_complaints/048_complaints_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-078-harbor-transit/07_investigations/049_investigations_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-078-harbor-transit/07_investigations/050_investigations_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-078-harbor-transit/07_investigations/051_investigations_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-078-harbor-transit/07_investigations/052_investigations_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-078-harbor-transit/07_investigations/053_investigations_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-078-harbor-transit/07_investigations/054_investigations_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-078-harbor-transit/07_investigations/055_investigations_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-078-harbor-transit/07_investigations/056_investigations_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-078-harbor-transit/08_performance_discipline/057_performance_discipline_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-078-harbor-transit/08_performance_discipline/058_performance_discipline_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-078-harbor-transit/08_performance_discipline/059_performance_discipline_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-078-harbor-transit/08_performance_discipline/060_performance_discipline_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-078-harbor-transit/08_performance_discipline/061_performance_discipline_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-078-harbor-transit/08_performance_discipline/062_performance_discipline_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-078-harbor-transit/08_performance_discipline/063_performance_discipline_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-078-harbor-transit/08_performance_discipline/064_performance_discipline_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-078-harbor-transit/09_separation/065_separation_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-078-harbor-transit/09_separation/066_separation_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-078-harbor-transit/09_separation/067_separation_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-078-harbor-transit/09_separation/068_separation_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-078-harbor-transit/09_separation/069_separation_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-078-harbor-transit/09_separation/070_separation_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-078-harbor-transit/09_separation/071_separation_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-078-harbor-transit/09_separation/072_separation_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-078-harbor-transit/10_contractors/073_contractors_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-078-harbor-transit/10_contractors/074_contractors_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-078-harbor-transit/10_contractors/075_contractors_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-078-harbor-transit/10_contractors/076_contractors_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-078-harbor-transit/10_contractors/077_contractors_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-078-harbor-transit/10_contractors/078_contractors_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-078-harbor-transit/10_contractors/079_contractors_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-078-harbor-transit/10_contractors/080_contractors_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-078-harbor-transit/11_training/081_training_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-078-harbor-transit/11_training/082_training_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-078-harbor-transit/11_training/083_training_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-078-harbor-transit/11_training/084_training_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-078-harbor-transit/11_training/085_training_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-078-harbor-transit/11_training/086_training_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-078-harbor-transit/11_training/087_training_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-078-harbor-transit/11_training/088_training_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-078-harbor-transit/12_agency_matters/089_agency_matters_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-078-harbor-transit/12_agency_matters/090_agency_matters_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-078-harbor-transit/12_agency_matters/091_agency_matters_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-078-harbor-transit/12_agency_matters/092_agency_matters_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-078-harbor-transit/12_agency_matters/093_agency_matters_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-078-harbor-transit/12_agency_matters/094_agency_matters_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-078-harbor-transit/12_agency_matters/095_agency_matters_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-078-harbor-transit/12_agency_matters/096_agency_matters_status_report.md"], "gold_output": {"advice_markdown": "# Counsel advice — Harbor Transit leave compliance review\n\n## Executive assessment\n\nFor Harbor Regional Transit matter CB-EL-3108, the review identified 16 source-supported exceptions requiring action before 2026-09-30. The assessment concerns Maintenance employee group and the supplied record for Oregon.\n\n## Method and record coverage\n\nThe review inventoried all 96 production files, read the 33 controlling, corroborating, and control records, searched the email exports, and checked metadata for the designated chain-of-custody sample. Conclusions are limited to the synthetic production supplied for this benchmark matter.\n\n## Findings\n\n### F-01 — classification inconsistency (critical)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for classification inconsistency: one source states the operative date is 2026-02-02 under control reference CB-EL-3108-A555, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2026-03-15 under response reference CB-EL-3108-J411.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/001_handbooks_policies_control_register.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/07_investigations/049_investigations_control_register.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-30, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Amara Patel.\n\n### F-02 — overtime calculation error (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for overtime calculation error: one source states the controlling amount is $7,116,741.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $7,349,982.00.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/004_handbooks_policies_ledger_export.csv`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/07_investigations/052_investigations_ledger_export.csv`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-30, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Henry Cho.\n\n### F-03 — meal-period premium gap (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for meal-period premium gap: one source states approval is attributed to Isaac Romero as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Dominic Alvarez and contains no entry for Isaac Romero.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/007_handbooks_policies_officer_certificate.html`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/07_investigations/055_investigations_officer_certificate.html`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-30, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Nadine Flores.\n\n### F-04 — pay-equity outlier (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for pay-equity outlier: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-EL-3108-D121, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-EL-3108-M101.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/010_personnel_records_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/08_performance_discipline/058_performance_discipline_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-30, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Micah Sullivan.\n\n### F-05 — leave designation delay (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for leave designation delay: one source states the applicable location is Oregon Bureau of Labor and Industries, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to Oregon operations outside Oregon Bureau of Labor and Industries.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/013_personnel_records_review_memorandum.json`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/08_performance_discipline/061_performance_discipline_review_memorandum.json`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-30, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Farah Ibrahim.\n\n### F-06 — interactive-process lapse (low)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for interactive-process lapse: one source states the threshold is 14% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 20% and produced a different exception result.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/016_personnel_records_status_report.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/08_performance_discipline/064_performance_discipline_status_report.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-30, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Owen Delgado.\n\n### F-07 — complaint escalation gap (critical)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for complaint escalation gap: one source states formal notice must use notices-harbor_regional_transit@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-maintenance_employee_group@example.test.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/019_payroll_time_correspondence.eml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/09_separation/067_separation_correspondence.eml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-30, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Lena Varga.\n\n### F-08 — investigation independence concern (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for investigation independence concern: one source states the governed population contains 136 records through 2025-08-19, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 61 records through 2025-09-21.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/022_payroll_time_formal_notice.xml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/09_separation/070_separation_formal_notice.xml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-30, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Samuel Kim.\n\n### F-09 — discipline comparator inconsistency (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for discipline comparator inconsistency: one source states the operative date is 2025-05-07 under control reference CB-EL-3108-I824, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2025-06-11 under response reference CB-EL-3108-R501.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/025_compensation_equity_control_register.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/10_contractors/073_contractors_control_register.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-30, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Maya Ellison.\n\n### F-10 — retaliation timing (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for retaliation timing: one source states the controlling amount is $3,806,549.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $4,069,598.00.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/028_compensation_equity_ledger_export.csv`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/10_contractors/076_contractors_ledger_export.csv`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-30, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Rafael Okafor.\n\n### F-11 — separation pay discrepancy (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for separation pay discrepancy: one source states approval is attributed to Isaac Romero as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Micah Sullivan and contains no entry for Isaac Romero.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/031_compensation_equity_officer_certificate.html`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/10_contractors/079_contractors_officer_certificate.html`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-30, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Nora Chen.\n\n### F-12 — restrictive-covenant conflict (low)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for restrictive-covenant conflict: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-EL-3108-L556, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-EL-3108-U758.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/034_leave_accommodation_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/11_training/082_training_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-30, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Dominic Alvarez.\n\n### F-13 — contractor control evidence (critical)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for contractor control evidence: one source states the applicable location is Oregon Bureau of Labor and Industries, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to Oregon operations outside Oregon Bureau of Labor and Industries.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/037_leave_accommodation_review_memorandum.json`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/11_training/085_training_review_memorandum.json`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-30, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Priya Raman.\n\n### F-14 — training completion gap (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for training completion gap: one source states the threshold is 13% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 20% and produced a different exception result.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/040_leave_accommodation_status_report.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/11_training/088_training_status_report.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-30, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Elliot Mercer.\n\n### F-15 — personnel-file access deadline (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for personnel-file access deadline: one source states formal notice must use notices-harbor_regional_transit@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-maintenance_employee_group@example.test.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/06_complaints/043_complaints_correspondence.eml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/091_agency_matters_correspondence.eml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-30, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Talia Brooks.\n\n### F-16 — agency response commitment (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for agency response commitment: one source states the governed population contains 127 records through 2025-03-23, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 35 records through 2025-03-30.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/06_complaints/046_complaints_formal_notice.xml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/094_agency_matters_formal_notice.xml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-30, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Jonas Feld.\n\n## Recommended next actions\n\nSequence the critical and high findings first, assign the named owners, preserve the cited records, and document any resolution in the controlling matter register before the stated deadline.\n\n## Assumptions and limitations\n\nThis analysis is confined to task cb100-078-harbor-transit and the supplied synthetic evidence. It does not rely on external facts, does not resolve disputed law, and is not legal advice for a real person or entity.\n", "findings": {"as_of": "2026-09-30", "findings": [{"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/07_investigations/049_investigations_control_register.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for classification inconsistency: one source states the operative date is 2026-02-02 under control reference CB-EL-3108-A555, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2026-03-15 under response reference CB-EL-3108-J411.", "id": "F-01", "issue": "classification inconsistency", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/001_handbooks_policies_control_register.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-30, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Amara Patel.", "severity": "critical"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/07_investigations/052_investigations_ledger_export.csv", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for overtime calculation error: one source states the controlling amount is $7,116,741.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $7,349,982.00.", "id": "F-02", "issue": "overtime calculation error", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/004_handbooks_policies_ledger_export.csv", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-30, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Henry Cho.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/07_investigations/055_investigations_officer_certificate.html", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for meal-period premium gap: one source states approval is attributed to Isaac Romero as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Dominic Alvarez and contains no entry for Isaac Romero.", "id": "F-03", "issue": "meal-period premium gap", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/007_handbooks_policies_officer_certificate.html", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-30, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Nadine Flores.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/08_performance_discipline/058_performance_discipline_executed_instrument.txt", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for pay-equity outlier: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-EL-3108-D121, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-EL-3108-M101.", "id": "F-04", "issue": "pay-equity outlier", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/010_personnel_records_executed_instrument.txt", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-30, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Micah Sullivan.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/08_performance_discipline/061_performance_discipline_review_memorandum.json", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for leave designation delay: one source states the applicable location is Oregon Bureau of Labor and Industries, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to Oregon operations outside Oregon Bureau of Labor and Industries.", "id": "F-05", "issue": "leave designation delay", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/013_personnel_records_review_memorandum.json", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-30, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Farah Ibrahim.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/08_performance_discipline/064_performance_discipline_status_report.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for interactive-process lapse: one source states the threshold is 14% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 20% and produced a different exception result.", "id": "F-06", "issue": "interactive-process lapse", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/016_personnel_records_status_report.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-30, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Owen Delgado.", "severity": "low"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/09_separation/067_separation_correspondence.eml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for complaint escalation gap: one source states formal notice must use notices-harbor_regional_transit@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-maintenance_employee_group@example.test.", "id": "F-07", "issue": "complaint escalation gap", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/019_payroll_time_correspondence.eml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-30, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Lena Varga.", "severity": "critical"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/09_separation/070_separation_formal_notice.xml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for investigation independence concern: one source states the governed population contains 136 records through 2025-08-19, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 61 records through 2025-09-21.", "id": "F-08", "issue": "investigation independence concern", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/022_payroll_time_formal_notice.xml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-30, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Samuel Kim.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/10_contractors/073_contractors_control_register.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for discipline comparator inconsistency: one source states the operative date is 2025-05-07 under control reference CB-EL-3108-I824, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2025-06-11 under response reference CB-EL-3108-R501.", "id": "F-09", "issue": "discipline comparator inconsistency", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/025_compensation_equity_control_register.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-30, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Maya Ellison.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/10_contractors/076_contractors_ledger_export.csv", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for retaliation timing: one source states the controlling amount is $3,806,549.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $4,069,598.00.", "id": "F-10", "issue": "retaliation timing", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/028_compensation_equity_ledger_export.csv", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-30, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Rafael Okafor.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/10_contractors/079_contractors_officer_certificate.html", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for separation pay discrepancy: one source states approval is attributed to Isaac Romero as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Micah Sullivan and contains no entry for Isaac Romero.", "id": "F-11", "issue": "separation pay discrepancy", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/031_compensation_equity_officer_certificate.html", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-30, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Nora Chen.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/11_training/082_training_executed_instrument.txt", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for restrictive-covenant conflict: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-EL-3108-L556, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-EL-3108-U758.", "id": "F-12", "issue": "restrictive-covenant conflict", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/034_leave_accommodation_executed_instrument.txt", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-30, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Dominic Alvarez.", "severity": "low"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/11_training/085_training_review_memorandum.json", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for contractor control evidence: one source states the applicable location is Oregon Bureau of Labor and Industries, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to Oregon operations outside Oregon Bureau of Labor and Industries.", "id": "F-13", "issue": "contractor control evidence", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/037_leave_accommodation_review_memorandum.json", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-30, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Priya Raman.", "severity": "critical"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/11_training/088_training_status_report.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for training completion gap: one source states the threshold is 13% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 20% and produced a different exception result.", "id": "F-14", "issue": "training completion gap", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/040_leave_accommodation_status_report.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-30, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Elliot Mercer.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/091_agency_matters_correspondence.eml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for personnel-file access deadline: one source states formal notice must use notices-harbor_regional_transit@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-maintenance_employee_group@example.test.", "id": "F-15", "issue": "personnel-file access deadline", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/06_complaints/043_complaints_correspondence.eml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-30, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Talia Brooks.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/094_agency_matters_formal_notice.xml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for agency response commitment: one source states the governed population contains 127 records through 2025-03-23, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 35 records through 2025-03-30.", "id": "F-16", "issue": "agency response commitment", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/06_complaints/046_complaints_formal_notice.xml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-30, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Jonas Feld.", "severity": "medium"}], "matter_number": "CB-EL-3108", "prepared_for": "Harbor Regional Transit", "schema_version": "1.0", "task_id": "cb100-078-harbor-transit"}}, "metadata": {"benchmark": "CounselBench-100", "code_license": "Apache-2.0", "data_license": "CC-BY-4.0", "deadline": "2026-09-30", "document_count": 96, "jurisdiction": "Oregon", "matter_number": "CB-EL-3108", "mcp_commit": "9a96ea6e5913736f92b88345bf51caeaaa8e719f", "mcp_package": "@modelcontextprotocol/server-filesystem@2026.7.10", "practice_area": "employment", "reference_tool_calls": 46, "required_evidence_reads": 33, "synthetic": true, "venue": "Oregon Bureau of Labor and Industries", "version": "2.0.0"}, "prompt": "You are employment counsel for Harbor Regional Transit. The supervising attorney wants an exception-focused review that still demonstrates complete coverage of the data room. Intermittent leave, overtime, fitness-for-duty, and attendance points were administered inconsistently across systems. Decision due 2026-09-30. Oregon law governs; Oregon Bureau of Labor and Industries is the forum. Preserve the difference between the client's position, the counterparty's position, and an objective record conflict. Work out the defensible position from the matter production and leave an audit-ready exception tracker and concise advice for the supervising lawyer. Keep confirmed conflicts separate from open questions, cite the records that actually control each conclusion, and do not fill gaps with outside facts.", "rubric": {"criteria": [{"category": "procedure", "description": "Complete at least 46 successful, argument-specific evidence and output calls.", "id": "procedure.minimum_successful_tool_calls"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Find and read the 33 controlling, corroborating, and work-product-control records in full.", "id": "procedure.all_evidence_read_in_full"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Inspect file metadata for the eight designated critical primary records before relying on them.", "id": "procedure.chain_of_custody_metadata_checked"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Confirm the sandbox's allowed document and output roots.", "id": "procedure.allowed_directories_checked"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Inventory all 96 records so the relevant sources are discovered among the context records.", "id": "procedure.recursive_inventory_completed"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Search the production for email evidence that may corroborate or contradict formal records.", "id": "procedure.targeted_search_completed"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Leave only findings.json and advice.md in the output workspace.", "id": "procedure.exact_deliverable_set"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Create both final work products through the sandbox MCP surface.", "id": "procedure.deliverables_written_through_mcp"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Produce findings.json as a valid JSON object.", "id": "findings.findings_is_object"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Report exactly 16 confirmed exceptions.", "id": "findings.findings_exact_count"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Use each stable finding ID exactly once.", "id": "findings.finding_ids_unique"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set schema_version to the released matter value '1.0'.", "id": "findings.top_level_schema_version"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set task_id to the released matter value 'cb100-078-harbor-transit'.", "id": "findings.top_level_task_id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set matter_number to the released matter value 'CB-EL-3108'.", "id": "findings.top_level_matter_number"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set prepared_for to the released matter value 'Harbor Regional Transit'.", "id": "findings.top_level_prepared_for"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set as_of to the released matter value '2026-09-30'.", "id": "findings.top_level_as_of"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-01 exception for classification inconsistency.", "id": "findings.F-01.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's id from /workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/001_handbooks_policies_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_investigations/049_investigations_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's issue from /workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/001_handbooks_policies_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_investigations/049_investigations_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's severity from /workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/001_handbooks_policies_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_investigations/049_investigations_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's primary_source from /workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/001_handbooks_policies_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_investigations/049_investigations_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/001_handbooks_policies_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_investigations/049_investigations_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-01 using the exact controlled facts ['2026-02-02', 'CB-EL-3108-A555', '2026-03-15', 'CB-EL-3108-J411'].", "id": "findings.F-01.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-01's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-01.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-30', 'Amara Patel'] for F-01.", "id": "findings.F-01.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-02 exception for overtime calculation error.", "id": "findings.F-02.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's id from /workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/004_handbooks_policies_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_investigations/052_investigations_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's issue from /workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/004_handbooks_policies_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_investigations/052_investigations_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's severity from /workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/004_handbooks_policies_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_investigations/052_investigations_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's primary_source from /workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/004_handbooks_policies_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_investigations/052_investigations_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/004_handbooks_policies_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_investigations/052_investigations_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-02 using the exact controlled facts ['$7,116,741.00', '$7,349,982.00'].", "id": "findings.F-02.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-02's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-02.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-30', 'Henry Cho'] for F-02.", "id": "findings.F-02.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-03 exception for meal-period premium gap.", "id": "findings.F-03.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's id from /workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/007_handbooks_policies_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_investigations/055_investigations_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's issue from /workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/007_handbooks_policies_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_investigations/055_investigations_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's severity from /workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/007_handbooks_policies_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_investigations/055_investigations_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's primary_source from /workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/007_handbooks_policies_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_investigations/055_investigations_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/007_handbooks_policies_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_investigations/055_investigations_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-03 using the exact controlled facts ['Isaac Romero', 'Dominic Alvarez'].", "id": "findings.F-03.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-03's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-03.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-30', 'Nadine Flores'] for F-03.", "id": "findings.F-03.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-04 exception for pay-equity outlier.", "id": "findings.F-04.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's id from /workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/010_personnel_records_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_performance_discipline/058_performance_discipline_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's issue from /workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/010_personnel_records_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_performance_discipline/058_performance_discipline_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's severity from /workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/010_personnel_records_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_performance_discipline/058_performance_discipline_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's primary_source from /workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/010_personnel_records_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_performance_discipline/058_performance_discipline_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/010_personnel_records_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_performance_discipline/058_performance_discipline_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-04 using the exact controlled facts ['closed without exception', 'CB-EL-3108-D121', 'open and escalated', 'CB-EL-3108-M101'].", "id": "findings.F-04.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-04's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-04.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-30', 'Micah Sullivan'] for F-04.", "id": "findings.F-04.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-05 exception for leave designation delay.", "id": "findings.F-05.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's id from /workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/013_personnel_records_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_performance_discipline/061_performance_discipline_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's issue from /workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/013_personnel_records_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_performance_discipline/061_performance_discipline_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's severity from /workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/013_personnel_records_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_performance_discipline/061_performance_discipline_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's primary_source from /workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/013_personnel_records_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_performance_discipline/061_performance_discipline_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/013_personnel_records_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_performance_discipline/061_performance_discipline_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-05 using the exact controlled facts ['Oregon Bureau of Labor and Industries', 'Oregon'].", "id": "findings.F-05.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-05's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-05.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-30', 'Farah Ibrahim'] for F-05.", "id": "findings.F-05.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-06 exception for interactive-process lapse.", "id": "findings.F-06.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's id from /workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/016_personnel_records_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_performance_discipline/064_performance_discipline_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's issue from /workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/016_personnel_records_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_performance_discipline/064_performance_discipline_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's severity from /workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/016_personnel_records_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_performance_discipline/064_performance_discipline_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's primary_source from /workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/016_personnel_records_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_performance_discipline/064_performance_discipline_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/016_personnel_records_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_performance_discipline/064_performance_discipline_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-06 using the exact controlled facts ['14%', '20%'].", "id": "findings.F-06.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-06's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-06.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-30', 'Owen Delgado'] for F-06.", "id": "findings.F-06.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-07 exception for complaint escalation gap.", "id": "findings.F-07.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's id from /workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/019_payroll_time_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_separation/067_separation_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's issue from /workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/019_payroll_time_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_separation/067_separation_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's severity from /workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/019_payroll_time_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_separation/067_separation_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's primary_source from /workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/019_payroll_time_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_separation/067_separation_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/019_payroll_time_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_separation/067_separation_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-07 using the exact controlled facts ['notices-harbor_regional_transit@example.test', 'archive-maintenance_employee_group@example.test'].", "id": "findings.F-07.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-07's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-07.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-30', 'Lena Varga'] for F-07.", "id": "findings.F-07.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-08 exception for investigation independence concern.", "id": "findings.F-08.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's id from /workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/022_payroll_time_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_separation/070_separation_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's issue from /workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/022_payroll_time_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_separation/070_separation_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's severity from /workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/022_payroll_time_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_separation/070_separation_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's primary_source from /workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/022_payroll_time_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_separation/070_separation_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/022_payroll_time_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_separation/070_separation_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-08 using the exact controlled facts ['136 records', '2025-08-19', '61 records', '2025-09-21'].", "id": "findings.F-08.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-08's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-08.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-30', 'Samuel Kim'] for F-08.", "id": "findings.F-08.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-09 exception for discipline comparator inconsistency.", "id": "findings.F-09.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's id from /workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/025_compensation_equity_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_contractors/073_contractors_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's issue from /workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/025_compensation_equity_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_contractors/073_contractors_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's severity from /workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/025_compensation_equity_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_contractors/073_contractors_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's primary_source from /workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/025_compensation_equity_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_contractors/073_contractors_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/025_compensation_equity_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_contractors/073_contractors_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-09 using the exact controlled facts ['2025-05-07', 'CB-EL-3108-I824', '2025-06-11', 'CB-EL-3108-R501'].", "id": "findings.F-09.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-09's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-09.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-30', 'Maya Ellison'] for F-09.", "id": "findings.F-09.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-10 exception for retaliation timing.", "id": "findings.F-10.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's id from /workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/028_compensation_equity_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_contractors/076_contractors_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's issue from /workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/028_compensation_equity_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_contractors/076_contractors_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's severity from /workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/028_compensation_equity_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_contractors/076_contractors_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's primary_source from /workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/028_compensation_equity_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_contractors/076_contractors_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/028_compensation_equity_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_contractors/076_contractors_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-10 using the exact controlled facts ['$3,806,549.00', '$4,069,598.00'].", "id": "findings.F-10.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-10's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-10.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-30', 'Rafael Okafor'] for F-10.", "id": "findings.F-10.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-11 exception for separation pay discrepancy.", "id": "findings.F-11.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's id from /workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/031_compensation_equity_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_contractors/079_contractors_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's issue from /workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/031_compensation_equity_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_contractors/079_contractors_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's severity from /workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/031_compensation_equity_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_contractors/079_contractors_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's primary_source from /workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/031_compensation_equity_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_contractors/079_contractors_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/031_compensation_equity_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_contractors/079_contractors_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-11 using the exact controlled facts ['Isaac Romero', 'Micah Sullivan'].", "id": "findings.F-11.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-11's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-11.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-30', 'Nora Chen'] for F-11.", "id": "findings.F-11.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-12 exception for restrictive-covenant conflict.", "id": "findings.F-12.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's id from /workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/034_leave_accommodation_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_training/082_training_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's issue from /workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/034_leave_accommodation_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_training/082_training_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's severity from /workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/034_leave_accommodation_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_training/082_training_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's primary_source from /workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/034_leave_accommodation_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_training/082_training_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/034_leave_accommodation_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_training/082_training_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-12 using the exact controlled facts ['closed without exception', 'CB-EL-3108-L556', 'open and escalated', 'CB-EL-3108-U758'].", "id": "findings.F-12.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-12's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-12.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-30', 'Dominic Alvarez'] for F-12.", "id": "findings.F-12.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-13 exception for contractor control evidence.", "id": "findings.F-13.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's id from /workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/037_leave_accommodation_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_training/085_training_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's issue from /workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/037_leave_accommodation_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_training/085_training_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's severity from /workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/037_leave_accommodation_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_training/085_training_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's primary_source from /workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/037_leave_accommodation_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_training/085_training_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/037_leave_accommodation_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_training/085_training_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-13 using the exact controlled facts ['Oregon Bureau of Labor and Industries', 'Oregon'].", "id": "findings.F-13.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-13's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-13.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-30', 'Priya Raman'] for F-13.", "id": "findings.F-13.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-14 exception for training completion gap.", "id": "findings.F-14.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's id from /workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/040_leave_accommodation_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_training/088_training_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's issue from /workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/040_leave_accommodation_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_training/088_training_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's severity from /workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/040_leave_accommodation_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_training/088_training_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's primary_source from /workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/040_leave_accommodation_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_training/088_training_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/040_leave_accommodation_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_training/088_training_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-14 using the exact controlled facts ['13%', '20%'].", "id": "findings.F-14.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-14's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-14.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-30', 'Elliot Mercer'] for F-14.", "id": "findings.F-14.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-15 exception for personnel-file access deadline.", "id": "findings.F-15.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's id from /workspace/documents/06_complaints/043_complaints_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/091_agency_matters_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's issue from /workspace/documents/06_complaints/043_complaints_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/091_agency_matters_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's severity from /workspace/documents/06_complaints/043_complaints_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/091_agency_matters_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's primary_source from /workspace/documents/06_complaints/043_complaints_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/091_agency_matters_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/06_complaints/043_complaints_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/091_agency_matters_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-15 using the exact controlled facts ['notices-harbor_regional_transit@example.test', 'archive-maintenance_employee_group@example.test'].", "id": "findings.F-15.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-15's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-15.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-30', 'Talia Brooks'] for F-15.", "id": "findings.F-15.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-16 exception for agency response commitment.", "id": "findings.F-16.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's id from /workspace/documents/06_complaints/046_complaints_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/094_agency_matters_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's issue from /workspace/documents/06_complaints/046_complaints_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/094_agency_matters_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's severity from /workspace/documents/06_complaints/046_complaints_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/094_agency_matters_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's primary_source from /workspace/documents/06_complaints/046_complaints_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/094_agency_matters_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/06_complaints/046_complaints_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/094_agency_matters_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-16 using the exact controlled facts ['127 records', '2025-03-23', '35 records', '2025-03-30'].", "id": "findings.F-16.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-16's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-16.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-30', 'Jonas Feld'] for F-16.", "id": "findings.F-16.action_anchors"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Executive assessment' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Executive assessment"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Method and record coverage' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Method and record coverage"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Findings' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Findings"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Recommended next actions' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Recommended next actions"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Assumptions and limitations' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Assumptions and limitations"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-01 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-01"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-02 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-02"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-03 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-03"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-04 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-04"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-05 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-05"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-06 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-06"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-07 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-07"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-08 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-08"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-09 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-09"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-10 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-10"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-11 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-11"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-12 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-12"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-13 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-13"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-14 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-14"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-15 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-15"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-16 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-16"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Do not claim the production has no issues or that every record is consistent.", "id": "memo.forbidden_claims_absent"}], "decision_options": [{"id": "cross-source-reconciliation", "label": "Reconcile controlling and corroborating records", "reason": "The CB-EL-3108 production contains independently maintained records; a defensible answer must preserve each supported conflict and its cure owner.", "selected": true}, {"id": "latest-record-controls", "label": "Treat the latest record as controlling", "reason": "Timestamp recency does not establish legal priority, execution, or approval authority.", "selected": false}, {"id": "primary-records-only", "label": "Report primary records without reconciliation", "reason": "Primary records alone conceal the operational conflicts that create the actionable exceptions.", "selected": false}], "gates": ["all_evidence_read_in_full", "chain_of_custody_metadata_checked", "findings_criteria_complete", "memo_criteria_complete", "deliverables_written_through_mcp"], "metadata_checks": 8, "metric": "weighted_criteria_score", "minimum_tool_calls": 46, "required_deliverables": ["findings.json", "advice.md"], "required_document_reads": 33, "type": "deterministic", "weights": {"findings": 0.55, "memo": 0.2, "procedure": 0.25}}, "task_id": "cb100-078-harbor-transit", "task_name": "Harbor Transit leave compliance review", "world_id": "counselbench-filesystem-mcp-v2"}
-{"context_files": ["task_files/cb100-079-island-biologics/01_handbooks_policies/001_handbooks_policies_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-079-island-biologics/01_handbooks_policies/002_handbooks_policies_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-079-island-biologics/01_handbooks_policies/003_handbooks_policies_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-079-island-biologics/01_handbooks_policies/004_handbooks_policies_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-079-island-biologics/01_handbooks_policies/005_handbooks_policies_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-079-island-biologics/01_handbooks_policies/006_handbooks_policies_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-079-island-biologics/01_handbooks_policies/007_handbooks_policies_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-079-island-biologics/01_handbooks_policies/008_handbooks_policies_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-079-island-biologics/02_personnel_records/009_personnel_records_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-079-island-biologics/02_personnel_records/010_personnel_records_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-079-island-biologics/02_personnel_records/011_personnel_records_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-079-island-biologics/02_personnel_records/012_personnel_records_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-079-island-biologics/02_personnel_records/013_personnel_records_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-079-island-biologics/02_personnel_records/014_personnel_records_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-079-island-biologics/02_personnel_records/015_personnel_records_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-079-island-biologics/02_personnel_records/016_personnel_records_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-079-island-biologics/03_payroll_time/017_payroll_time_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-079-island-biologics/03_payroll_time/018_payroll_time_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-079-island-biologics/03_payroll_time/019_payroll_time_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-079-island-biologics/03_payroll_time/020_payroll_time_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-079-island-biologics/03_payroll_time/021_payroll_time_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-079-island-biologics/03_payroll_time/022_payroll_time_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-079-island-biologics/03_payroll_time/023_payroll_time_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-079-island-biologics/03_payroll_time/024_payroll_time_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-079-island-biologics/04_compensation_equity/025_compensation_equity_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-079-island-biologics/04_compensation_equity/026_compensation_equity_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-079-island-biologics/04_compensation_equity/027_compensation_equity_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-079-island-biologics/04_compensation_equity/028_compensation_equity_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-079-island-biologics/04_compensation_equity/029_compensation_equity_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-079-island-biologics/04_compensation_equity/030_compensation_equity_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-079-island-biologics/04_compensation_equity/031_compensation_equity_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-079-island-biologics/04_compensation_equity/032_compensation_equity_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-079-island-biologics/05_leave_accommodation/033_leave_accommodation_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-079-island-biologics/05_leave_accommodation/034_leave_accommodation_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-079-island-biologics/05_leave_accommodation/035_leave_accommodation_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-079-island-biologics/05_leave_accommodation/036_leave_accommodation_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-079-island-biologics/05_leave_accommodation/037_leave_accommodation_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-079-island-biologics/05_leave_accommodation/038_leave_accommodation_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-079-island-biologics/05_leave_accommodation/039_leave_accommodation_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-079-island-biologics/05_leave_accommodation/040_leave_accommodation_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-079-island-biologics/06_complaints/041_complaints_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-079-island-biologics/06_complaints/042_complaints_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-079-island-biologics/06_complaints/043_complaints_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-079-island-biologics/06_complaints/044_complaints_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-079-island-biologics/06_complaints/045_complaints_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-079-island-biologics/06_complaints/046_complaints_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-079-island-biologics/06_complaints/047_complaints_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-079-island-biologics/06_complaints/048_complaints_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-079-island-biologics/07_investigations/049_investigations_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-079-island-biologics/07_investigations/050_investigations_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-079-island-biologics/07_investigations/051_investigations_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-079-island-biologics/07_investigations/052_investigations_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-079-island-biologics/07_investigations/053_investigations_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-079-island-biologics/07_investigations/054_investigations_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-079-island-biologics/07_investigations/055_investigations_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-079-island-biologics/07_investigations/056_investigations_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-079-island-biologics/08_performance_discipline/057_performance_discipline_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-079-island-biologics/08_performance_discipline/058_performance_discipline_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-079-island-biologics/08_performance_discipline/059_performance_discipline_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-079-island-biologics/08_performance_discipline/060_performance_discipline_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-079-island-biologics/08_performance_discipline/061_performance_discipline_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-079-island-biologics/08_performance_discipline/062_performance_discipline_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-079-island-biologics/08_performance_discipline/063_performance_discipline_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-079-island-biologics/08_performance_discipline/064_performance_discipline_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-079-island-biologics/09_separation/065_separation_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-079-island-biologics/09_separation/066_separation_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-079-island-biologics/09_separation/067_separation_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-079-island-biologics/09_separation/068_separation_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-079-island-biologics/09_separation/069_separation_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-079-island-biologics/09_separation/070_separation_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-079-island-biologics/09_separation/071_separation_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-079-island-biologics/09_separation/072_separation_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-079-island-biologics/10_contractors/073_contractors_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-079-island-biologics/10_contractors/074_contractors_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-079-island-biologics/10_contractors/075_contractors_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-079-island-biologics/10_contractors/076_contractors_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-079-island-biologics/10_contractors/077_contractors_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-079-island-biologics/10_contractors/078_contractors_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-079-island-biologics/10_contractors/079_contractors_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-079-island-biologics/10_contractors/080_contractors_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-079-island-biologics/11_training/081_training_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-079-island-biologics/11_training/082_training_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-079-island-biologics/11_training/083_training_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-079-island-biologics/11_training/084_training_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-079-island-biologics/11_training/085_training_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-079-island-biologics/11_training/086_training_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-079-island-biologics/11_training/087_training_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-079-island-biologics/11_training/088_training_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-079-island-biologics/12_agency_matters/089_agency_matters_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-079-island-biologics/12_agency_matters/090_agency_matters_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-079-island-biologics/12_agency_matters/091_agency_matters_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-079-island-biologics/12_agency_matters/092_agency_matters_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-079-island-biologics/12_agency_matters/093_agency_matters_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-079-island-biologics/12_agency_matters/094_agency_matters_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-079-island-biologics/12_agency_matters/095_agency_matters_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-079-island-biologics/12_agency_matters/096_agency_matters_status_report.md"], "gold_output": {"advice_markdown": "# Counsel advice — Island Biologics separation audit\n\n## Executive assessment\n\nFor Island Biologics Corp. matter CB-EL-3109, the review identified 16 source-supported exceptions requiring action before 2026-10-03. The assessment concerns Former research director and the supplied record for Massachusetts.\n\n## Method and record coverage\n\nThe review inventoried all 96 production files, read the 33 controlling, corroborating, and control records, searched the email exports, and checked metadata for the designated chain-of-custody sample. Conclusions are limited to the synthetic production supplied for this benchmark matter.\n\n## Findings\n\n### F-01 — classification inconsistency (critical)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for classification inconsistency: one source states the operative date is 2025-03-21 under control reference CB-EL-3109-A177, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2025-05-06 under response reference CB-EL-3109-J798.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/001_handbooks_policies_control_register.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/07_investigations/049_investigations_control_register.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-10-03, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Henry Cho.\n\n### F-02 — overtime calculation error (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for overtime calculation error: one source states the controlling amount is $7,164,223.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $7,214,946.00.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/004_handbooks_policies_ledger_export.csv`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/07_investigations/052_investigations_ledger_export.csv`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-10-03, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Nadine Flores.\n\n### F-03 — meal-period premium gap (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for meal-period premium gap: one source states approval is attributed to Sofia Bennett as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Elliot Mercer and contains no entry for Sofia Bennett.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/007_handbooks_policies_officer_certificate.html`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/07_investigations/055_investigations_officer_certificate.html`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-10-03, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Micah Sullivan.\n\n### F-04 — pay-equity outlier (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for pay-equity outlier: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-EL-3109-D830, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-EL-3109-M986.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/010_personnel_records_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/08_performance_discipline/058_performance_discipline_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-10-03, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Farah Ibrahim.\n\n### F-05 — leave designation delay (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for leave designation delay: one source states the applicable location is Massachusetts Commission Against Discrimination, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to Massachusetts operations outside Massachusetts Commission Against Discrimination.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/013_personnel_records_review_memorandum.json`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/08_performance_discipline/061_performance_discipline_review_memorandum.json`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-10-03, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Owen Delgado.\n\n### F-06 — interactive-process lapse (low)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for interactive-process lapse: one source states the threshold is 14% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 20% and produced a different exception result.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/016_personnel_records_status_report.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/08_performance_discipline/064_performance_discipline_status_report.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-10-03, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Lena Varga.\n\n### F-07 — complaint escalation gap (critical)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for complaint escalation gap: one source states formal notice must use notices-island_biologics_corp@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-former_research_director@example.test.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/019_payroll_time_correspondence.eml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/09_separation/067_separation_correspondence.eml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-10-03, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Samuel Kim.\n\n### F-08 — investigation independence concern (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for investigation independence concern: one source states the governed population contains 126 records through 2025-03-22, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 70 records through 2025-05-03.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/022_payroll_time_formal_notice.xml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/09_separation/070_separation_formal_notice.xml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-10-03, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Maya Ellison.\n\n### F-09 — discipline comparator inconsistency (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for discipline comparator inconsistency: one source states the operative date is 2026-02-26 under control reference CB-EL-3109-I339, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2026-03-31 under response reference CB-EL-3109-R741.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/025_compensation_equity_control_register.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/10_contractors/073_contractors_control_register.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-10-03, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Rafael Okafor.\n\n### F-10 — retaliation timing (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for retaliation timing: one source states the controlling amount is $1,923,358.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $2,023,216.00.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/028_compensation_equity_ledger_export.csv`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/10_contractors/076_contractors_ledger_export.csv`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-10-03, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Nora Chen.\n\n### F-11 — separation pay discrepancy (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for separation pay discrepancy: one source states approval is attributed to Sofia Bennett as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Owen Delgado and contains no entry for Sofia Bennett.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/031_compensation_equity_officer_certificate.html`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/10_contractors/079_contractors_officer_certificate.html`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-10-03, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Dominic Alvarez.\n\n### F-12 — restrictive-covenant conflict (low)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for restrictive-covenant conflict: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-EL-3109-L714, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-EL-3109-U631.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/034_leave_accommodation_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/11_training/082_training_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-10-03, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Priya Raman.\n\n### F-13 — contractor control evidence (critical)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for contractor control evidence: one source states the applicable location is Massachusetts Commission Against Discrimination, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to Massachusetts operations outside Massachusetts Commission Against Discrimination.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/037_leave_accommodation_review_memorandum.json`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/11_training/085_training_review_memorandum.json`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-10-03, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Elliot Mercer.\n\n### F-14 — training completion gap (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for training completion gap: one source states the threshold is 2% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 4% and produced a different exception result.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/040_leave_accommodation_status_report.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/11_training/088_training_status_report.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-10-03, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Talia Brooks.\n\n### F-15 — personnel-file access deadline (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for personnel-file access deadline: one source states formal notice must use notices-island_biologics_corp@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-former_research_director@example.test.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/06_complaints/043_complaints_correspondence.eml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/091_agency_matters_correspondence.eml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-10-03, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Jonas Feld.\n\n### F-16 — agency response commitment (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for agency response commitment: one source states the governed population contains 102 records through 2025-12-03, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 50 records through 2025-12-25.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/06_complaints/046_complaints_formal_notice.xml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/094_agency_matters_formal_notice.xml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-10-03, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Mei Whitaker.\n\n## Recommended next actions\n\nSequence the critical and high findings first, assign the named owners, preserve the cited records, and document any resolution in the controlling matter register before the stated deadline.\n\n## Assumptions and limitations\n\nThis analysis is confined to task cb100-079-island-biologics and the supplied synthetic evidence. It does not rely on external facts, does not resolve disputed law, and is not legal advice for a real person or entity.\n", "findings": {"as_of": "2026-10-03", "findings": [{"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/07_investigations/049_investigations_control_register.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for classification inconsistency: one source states the operative date is 2025-03-21 under control reference CB-EL-3109-A177, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2025-05-06 under response reference CB-EL-3109-J798.", "id": "F-01", "issue": "classification inconsistency", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/001_handbooks_policies_control_register.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-10-03, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Henry Cho.", "severity": "critical"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/07_investigations/052_investigations_ledger_export.csv", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for overtime calculation error: one source states the controlling amount is $7,164,223.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $7,214,946.00.", "id": "F-02", "issue": "overtime calculation error", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/004_handbooks_policies_ledger_export.csv", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-10-03, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Nadine Flores.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/07_investigations/055_investigations_officer_certificate.html", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for meal-period premium gap: one source states approval is attributed to Sofia Bennett as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Elliot Mercer and contains no entry for Sofia Bennett.", "id": "F-03", "issue": "meal-period premium gap", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/007_handbooks_policies_officer_certificate.html", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-10-03, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Micah Sullivan.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/08_performance_discipline/058_performance_discipline_executed_instrument.txt", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for pay-equity outlier: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-EL-3109-D830, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-EL-3109-M986.", "id": "F-04", "issue": "pay-equity outlier", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/010_personnel_records_executed_instrument.txt", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-10-03, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Farah Ibrahim.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/08_performance_discipline/061_performance_discipline_review_memorandum.json", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for leave designation delay: one source states the applicable location is Massachusetts Commission Against Discrimination, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to Massachusetts operations outside Massachusetts Commission Against Discrimination.", "id": "F-05", "issue": "leave designation delay", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/013_personnel_records_review_memorandum.json", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-10-03, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Owen Delgado.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/08_performance_discipline/064_performance_discipline_status_report.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for interactive-process lapse: one source states the threshold is 14% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 20% and produced a different exception result.", "id": "F-06", "issue": "interactive-process lapse", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/016_personnel_records_status_report.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-10-03, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Lena Varga.", "severity": "low"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/09_separation/067_separation_correspondence.eml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for complaint escalation gap: one source states formal notice must use notices-island_biologics_corp@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-former_research_director@example.test.", "id": "F-07", "issue": "complaint escalation gap", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/019_payroll_time_correspondence.eml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-10-03, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Samuel Kim.", "severity": "critical"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/09_separation/070_separation_formal_notice.xml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for investigation independence concern: one source states the governed population contains 126 records through 2025-03-22, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 70 records through 2025-05-03.", "id": "F-08", "issue": "investigation independence concern", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/022_payroll_time_formal_notice.xml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-10-03, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Maya Ellison.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/10_contractors/073_contractors_control_register.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for discipline comparator inconsistency: one source states the operative date is 2026-02-26 under control reference CB-EL-3109-I339, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2026-03-31 under response reference CB-EL-3109-R741.", "id": "F-09", "issue": "discipline comparator inconsistency", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/025_compensation_equity_control_register.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-10-03, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Rafael Okafor.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/10_contractors/076_contractors_ledger_export.csv", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for retaliation timing: one source states the controlling amount is $1,923,358.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $2,023,216.00.", "id": "F-10", "issue": "retaliation timing", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/028_compensation_equity_ledger_export.csv", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-10-03, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Nora Chen.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/10_contractors/079_contractors_officer_certificate.html", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for separation pay discrepancy: one source states approval is attributed to Sofia Bennett as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Owen Delgado and contains no entry for Sofia Bennett.", "id": "F-11", "issue": "separation pay discrepancy", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/031_compensation_equity_officer_certificate.html", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-10-03, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Dominic Alvarez.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/11_training/082_training_executed_instrument.txt", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for restrictive-covenant conflict: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-EL-3109-L714, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-EL-3109-U631.", "id": "F-12", "issue": "restrictive-covenant conflict", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/034_leave_accommodation_executed_instrument.txt", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-10-03, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Priya Raman.", "severity": "low"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/11_training/085_training_review_memorandum.json", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for contractor control evidence: one source states the applicable location is Massachusetts Commission Against Discrimination, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to Massachusetts operations outside Massachusetts Commission Against Discrimination.", "id": "F-13", "issue": "contractor control evidence", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/037_leave_accommodation_review_memorandum.json", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-10-03, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Elliot Mercer.", "severity": "critical"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/11_training/088_training_status_report.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for training completion gap: one source states the threshold is 2% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 4% and produced a different exception result.", "id": "F-14", "issue": "training completion gap", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/040_leave_accommodation_status_report.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-10-03, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Talia Brooks.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/091_agency_matters_correspondence.eml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for personnel-file access deadline: one source states formal notice must use notices-island_biologics_corp@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-former_research_director@example.test.", "id": "F-15", "issue": "personnel-file access deadline", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/06_complaints/043_complaints_correspondence.eml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-10-03, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Jonas Feld.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/094_agency_matters_formal_notice.xml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for agency response commitment: one source states the governed population contains 102 records through 2025-12-03, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 50 records through 2025-12-25.", "id": "F-16", "issue": "agency response commitment", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/06_complaints/046_complaints_formal_notice.xml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-10-03, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Mei Whitaker.", "severity": "medium"}], "matter_number": "CB-EL-3109", "prepared_for": "Island Biologics Corp.", "schema_version": "1.0", "task_id": "cb100-079-island-biologics"}}, "metadata": {"benchmark": "CounselBench-100", "code_license": "Apache-2.0", "data_license": "CC-BY-4.0", "deadline": "2026-10-03", "document_count": 96, "jurisdiction": "Massachusetts", "matter_number": "CB-EL-3109", "mcp_commit": "9a96ea6e5913736f92b88345bf51caeaaa8e719f", "mcp_package": "@modelcontextprotocol/server-filesystem@2026.7.10", "practice_area": "employment", "reference_tool_calls": 46, "required_evidence_reads": 33, "synthetic": true, "venue": "Massachusetts Commission Against Discrimination", "version": "2.0.0"}, "prompt": "You are employment counsel for Island Biologics Corp. This matter will be reviewed by legal, finance, and compliance stakeholders who need a single source-grounded output. A research director's complaint, comparator discipline, incentive payment, restrictive covenant, and separation documents require reconciliation. Decision due 2026-10-03. Massachusetts law governs; Massachusetts Commission Against Discrimination is the forum. Use the production as of the stated deadline; do not assume facts outside the supplied files. Work out the defensible position from the matter production and leave an audit-ready exception tracker and concise advice for the supervising lawyer. Keep confirmed conflicts separate from open questions, cite the records that actually control each conclusion, and do not fill gaps with outside facts.", "rubric": {"criteria": [{"category": "procedure", "description": "Complete at least 46 successful, argument-specific evidence and output calls.", "id": "procedure.minimum_successful_tool_calls"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Find and read the 33 controlling, corroborating, and work-product-control records in full.", "id": "procedure.all_evidence_read_in_full"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Inspect file metadata for the eight designated critical primary records before relying on them.", "id": "procedure.chain_of_custody_metadata_checked"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Confirm the sandbox's allowed document and output roots.", "id": "procedure.allowed_directories_checked"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Inventory all 96 records so the relevant sources are discovered among the context records.", "id": "procedure.recursive_inventory_completed"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Search the production for email evidence that may corroborate or contradict formal records.", "id": "procedure.targeted_search_completed"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Leave only findings.json and advice.md in the output workspace.", "id": "procedure.exact_deliverable_set"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Create both final work products through the sandbox MCP surface.", "id": "procedure.deliverables_written_through_mcp"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Produce findings.json as a valid JSON object.", "id": "findings.findings_is_object"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Report exactly 16 confirmed exceptions.", "id": "findings.findings_exact_count"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Use each stable finding ID exactly once.", "id": "findings.finding_ids_unique"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set schema_version to the released matter value '1.0'.", "id": "findings.top_level_schema_version"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set task_id to the released matter value 'cb100-079-island-biologics'.", "id": "findings.top_level_task_id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set matter_number to the released matter value 'CB-EL-3109'.", "id": "findings.top_level_matter_number"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set prepared_for to the released matter value 'Island Biologics Corp.'.", "id": "findings.top_level_prepared_for"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set as_of to the released matter value '2026-10-03'.", "id": "findings.top_level_as_of"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-01 exception for classification inconsistency.", "id": "findings.F-01.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's id from /workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/001_handbooks_policies_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_investigations/049_investigations_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's issue from /workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/001_handbooks_policies_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_investigations/049_investigations_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's severity from /workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/001_handbooks_policies_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_investigations/049_investigations_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's primary_source from /workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/001_handbooks_policies_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_investigations/049_investigations_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/001_handbooks_policies_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_investigations/049_investigations_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-01 using the exact controlled facts ['2025-03-21', 'CB-EL-3109-A177', '2025-05-06', 'CB-EL-3109-J798'].", "id": "findings.F-01.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-01's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-01.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-10-03', 'Henry Cho'] for F-01.", "id": "findings.F-01.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-02 exception for overtime calculation error.", "id": "findings.F-02.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's id from /workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/004_handbooks_policies_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_investigations/052_investigations_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's issue from /workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/004_handbooks_policies_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_investigations/052_investigations_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's severity from /workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/004_handbooks_policies_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_investigations/052_investigations_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's primary_source from /workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/004_handbooks_policies_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_investigations/052_investigations_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/004_handbooks_policies_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_investigations/052_investigations_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-02 using the exact controlled facts ['$7,164,223.00', '$7,214,946.00'].", "id": "findings.F-02.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-02's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-02.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-10-03', 'Nadine Flores'] for F-02.", "id": "findings.F-02.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-03 exception for meal-period premium gap.", "id": "findings.F-03.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's id from /workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/007_handbooks_policies_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_investigations/055_investigations_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's issue from /workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/007_handbooks_policies_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_investigations/055_investigations_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's severity from /workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/007_handbooks_policies_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_investigations/055_investigations_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's primary_source from /workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/007_handbooks_policies_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_investigations/055_investigations_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/007_handbooks_policies_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_investigations/055_investigations_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-03 using the exact controlled facts ['Sofia Bennett', 'Elliot Mercer'].", "id": "findings.F-03.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-03's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-03.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-10-03', 'Micah Sullivan'] for F-03.", "id": "findings.F-03.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-04 exception for pay-equity outlier.", "id": "findings.F-04.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's id from /workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/010_personnel_records_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_performance_discipline/058_performance_discipline_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's issue from /workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/010_personnel_records_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_performance_discipline/058_performance_discipline_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's severity from /workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/010_personnel_records_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_performance_discipline/058_performance_discipline_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's primary_source from /workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/010_personnel_records_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_performance_discipline/058_performance_discipline_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/010_personnel_records_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_performance_discipline/058_performance_discipline_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-04 using the exact controlled facts ['closed without exception', 'CB-EL-3109-D830', 'open and escalated', 'CB-EL-3109-M986'].", "id": "findings.F-04.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-04's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-04.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-10-03', 'Farah Ibrahim'] for F-04.", "id": "findings.F-04.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-05 exception for leave designation delay.", "id": "findings.F-05.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's id from /workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/013_personnel_records_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_performance_discipline/061_performance_discipline_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's issue from /workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/013_personnel_records_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_performance_discipline/061_performance_discipline_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's severity from /workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/013_personnel_records_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_performance_discipline/061_performance_discipline_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's primary_source from /workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/013_personnel_records_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_performance_discipline/061_performance_discipline_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/013_personnel_records_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_performance_discipline/061_performance_discipline_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-05 using the exact controlled facts ['Massachusetts Commission Against Discrimination', 'Massachusetts'].", "id": "findings.F-05.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-05's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-05.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-10-03', 'Owen Delgado'] for F-05.", "id": "findings.F-05.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-06 exception for interactive-process lapse.", "id": "findings.F-06.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's id from /workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/016_personnel_records_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_performance_discipline/064_performance_discipline_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's issue from /workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/016_personnel_records_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_performance_discipline/064_performance_discipline_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's severity from /workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/016_personnel_records_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_performance_discipline/064_performance_discipline_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's primary_source from /workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/016_personnel_records_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_performance_discipline/064_performance_discipline_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/016_personnel_records_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_performance_discipline/064_performance_discipline_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-06 using the exact controlled facts ['14%', '20%'].", "id": "findings.F-06.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-06's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-06.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-10-03', 'Lena Varga'] for F-06.", "id": "findings.F-06.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-07 exception for complaint escalation gap.", "id": "findings.F-07.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's id from /workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/019_payroll_time_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_separation/067_separation_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's issue from /workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/019_payroll_time_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_separation/067_separation_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's severity from /workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/019_payroll_time_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_separation/067_separation_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's primary_source from /workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/019_payroll_time_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_separation/067_separation_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/019_payroll_time_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_separation/067_separation_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-07 using the exact controlled facts ['notices-island_biologics_corp@example.test', 'archive-former_research_director@example.test'].", "id": "findings.F-07.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-07's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-07.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-10-03', 'Samuel Kim'] for F-07.", "id": "findings.F-07.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-08 exception for investigation independence concern.", "id": "findings.F-08.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's id from /workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/022_payroll_time_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_separation/070_separation_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's issue from /workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/022_payroll_time_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_separation/070_separation_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's severity from /workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/022_payroll_time_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_separation/070_separation_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's primary_source from /workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/022_payroll_time_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_separation/070_separation_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/022_payroll_time_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_separation/070_separation_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-08 using the exact controlled facts ['126 records', '2025-03-22', '70 records', '2025-05-03'].", "id": "findings.F-08.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-08's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-08.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-10-03', 'Maya Ellison'] for F-08.", "id": "findings.F-08.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-09 exception for discipline comparator inconsistency.", "id": "findings.F-09.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's id from /workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/025_compensation_equity_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_contractors/073_contractors_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's issue from /workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/025_compensation_equity_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_contractors/073_contractors_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's severity from /workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/025_compensation_equity_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_contractors/073_contractors_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's primary_source from /workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/025_compensation_equity_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_contractors/073_contractors_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/025_compensation_equity_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_contractors/073_contractors_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-09 using the exact controlled facts ['2026-02-26', 'CB-EL-3109-I339', '2026-03-31', 'CB-EL-3109-R741'].", "id": "findings.F-09.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-09's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-09.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-10-03', 'Rafael Okafor'] for F-09.", "id": "findings.F-09.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-10 exception for retaliation timing.", "id": "findings.F-10.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's id from /workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/028_compensation_equity_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_contractors/076_contractors_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's issue from /workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/028_compensation_equity_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_contractors/076_contractors_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's severity from /workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/028_compensation_equity_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_contractors/076_contractors_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's primary_source from /workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/028_compensation_equity_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_contractors/076_contractors_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/028_compensation_equity_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_contractors/076_contractors_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-10 using the exact controlled facts ['$1,923,358.00', '$2,023,216.00'].", "id": "findings.F-10.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-10's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-10.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-10-03', 'Nora Chen'] for F-10.", "id": "findings.F-10.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-11 exception for separation pay discrepancy.", "id": "findings.F-11.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's id from /workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/031_compensation_equity_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_contractors/079_contractors_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's issue from /workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/031_compensation_equity_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_contractors/079_contractors_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's severity from /workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/031_compensation_equity_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_contractors/079_contractors_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's primary_source from /workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/031_compensation_equity_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_contractors/079_contractors_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/031_compensation_equity_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_contractors/079_contractors_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-11 using the exact controlled facts ['Sofia Bennett', 'Owen Delgado'].", "id": "findings.F-11.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-11's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-11.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-10-03', 'Dominic Alvarez'] for F-11.", "id": "findings.F-11.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-12 exception for restrictive-covenant conflict.", "id": "findings.F-12.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's id from /workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/034_leave_accommodation_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_training/082_training_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's issue from /workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/034_leave_accommodation_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_training/082_training_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's severity from /workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/034_leave_accommodation_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_training/082_training_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's primary_source from /workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/034_leave_accommodation_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_training/082_training_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/034_leave_accommodation_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_training/082_training_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-12 using the exact controlled facts ['closed without exception', 'CB-EL-3109-L714', 'open and escalated', 'CB-EL-3109-U631'].", "id": "findings.F-12.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-12's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-12.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-10-03', 'Priya Raman'] for F-12.", "id": "findings.F-12.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-13 exception for contractor control evidence.", "id": "findings.F-13.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's id from /workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/037_leave_accommodation_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_training/085_training_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's issue from /workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/037_leave_accommodation_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_training/085_training_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's severity from /workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/037_leave_accommodation_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_training/085_training_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's primary_source from /workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/037_leave_accommodation_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_training/085_training_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/037_leave_accommodation_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_training/085_training_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-13 using the exact controlled facts ['Massachusetts Commission Against Discrimination', 'Massachusetts'].", "id": "findings.F-13.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-13's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-13.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-10-03', 'Elliot Mercer'] for F-13.", "id": "findings.F-13.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-14 exception for training completion gap.", "id": "findings.F-14.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's id from /workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/040_leave_accommodation_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_training/088_training_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's issue from /workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/040_leave_accommodation_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_training/088_training_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's severity from /workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/040_leave_accommodation_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_training/088_training_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's primary_source from /workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/040_leave_accommodation_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_training/088_training_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/040_leave_accommodation_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_training/088_training_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-14 using the exact controlled facts ['2%', '4%'].", "id": "findings.F-14.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-14's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-14.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-10-03', 'Talia Brooks'] for F-14.", "id": "findings.F-14.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-15 exception for personnel-file access deadline.", "id": "findings.F-15.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's id from /workspace/documents/06_complaints/043_complaints_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/091_agency_matters_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's issue from /workspace/documents/06_complaints/043_complaints_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/091_agency_matters_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's severity from /workspace/documents/06_complaints/043_complaints_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/091_agency_matters_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's primary_source from /workspace/documents/06_complaints/043_complaints_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/091_agency_matters_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/06_complaints/043_complaints_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/091_agency_matters_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-15 using the exact controlled facts ['notices-island_biologics_corp@example.test', 'archive-former_research_director@example.test'].", "id": "findings.F-15.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-15's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-15.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-10-03', 'Jonas Feld'] for F-15.", "id": "findings.F-15.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-16 exception for agency response commitment.", "id": "findings.F-16.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's id from /workspace/documents/06_complaints/046_complaints_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/094_agency_matters_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's issue from /workspace/documents/06_complaints/046_complaints_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/094_agency_matters_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's severity from /workspace/documents/06_complaints/046_complaints_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/094_agency_matters_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's primary_source from /workspace/documents/06_complaints/046_complaints_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/094_agency_matters_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/06_complaints/046_complaints_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/094_agency_matters_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-16 using the exact controlled facts ['102 records', '2025-12-03', '50 records', '2025-12-25'].", "id": "findings.F-16.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-16's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-16.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-10-03', 'Mei Whitaker'] for F-16.", "id": "findings.F-16.action_anchors"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Executive assessment' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Executive assessment"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Method and record coverage' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Method and record coverage"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Findings' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Findings"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Recommended next actions' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Recommended next actions"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Assumptions and limitations' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Assumptions and limitations"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-01 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-01"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-02 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-02"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-03 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-03"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-04 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-04"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-05 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-05"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-06 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-06"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-07 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-07"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-08 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-08"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-09 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-09"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-10 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-10"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-11 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-11"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-12 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-12"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-13 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-13"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-14 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-14"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-15 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-15"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-16 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-16"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Do not claim the production has no issues or that every record is consistent.", "id": "memo.forbidden_claims_absent"}], "decision_options": [{"id": "cross-source-reconciliation", "label": "Reconcile controlling and corroborating records", "reason": "The CB-EL-3109 production contains independently maintained records; a defensible answer must preserve each supported conflict and its cure owner.", "selected": true}, {"id": "latest-record-controls", "label": "Treat the latest record as controlling", "reason": "Timestamp recency does not establish legal priority, execution, or approval authority.", "selected": false}, {"id": "primary-records-only", "label": "Report primary records without reconciliation", "reason": "Primary records alone conceal the operational conflicts that create the actionable exceptions.", "selected": false}], "gates": ["all_evidence_read_in_full", "chain_of_custody_metadata_checked", "findings_criteria_complete", "memo_criteria_complete", "deliverables_written_through_mcp"], "metadata_checks": 8, "metric": "weighted_criteria_score", "minimum_tool_calls": 46, "required_deliverables": ["findings.json", "advice.md"], "required_document_reads": 33, "type": "deterministic", "weights": {"findings": 0.55, "memo": 0.2, "procedure": 0.25}}, "task_id": "cb100-079-island-biologics", "task_name": "Island Biologics separation audit", "world_id": "counselbench-filesystem-mcp-v2"}
-{"context_files": ["task_files/cb100-080-junction-foods/01_handbooks_policies/001_handbooks_policies_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-080-junction-foods/01_handbooks_policies/002_handbooks_policies_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-080-junction-foods/01_handbooks_policies/003_handbooks_policies_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-080-junction-foods/01_handbooks_policies/004_handbooks_policies_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-080-junction-foods/01_handbooks_policies/005_handbooks_policies_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-080-junction-foods/01_handbooks_policies/006_handbooks_policies_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-080-junction-foods/01_handbooks_policies/007_handbooks_policies_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-080-junction-foods/01_handbooks_policies/008_handbooks_policies_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-080-junction-foods/02_personnel_records/009_personnel_records_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-080-junction-foods/02_personnel_records/010_personnel_records_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-080-junction-foods/02_personnel_records/011_personnel_records_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-080-junction-foods/02_personnel_records/012_personnel_records_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-080-junction-foods/02_personnel_records/013_personnel_records_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-080-junction-foods/02_personnel_records/014_personnel_records_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-080-junction-foods/02_personnel_records/015_personnel_records_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-080-junction-foods/02_personnel_records/016_personnel_records_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-080-junction-foods/03_payroll_time/017_payroll_time_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-080-junction-foods/03_payroll_time/018_payroll_time_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-080-junction-foods/03_payroll_time/019_payroll_time_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-080-junction-foods/03_payroll_time/020_payroll_time_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-080-junction-foods/03_payroll_time/021_payroll_time_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-080-junction-foods/03_payroll_time/022_payroll_time_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-080-junction-foods/03_payroll_time/023_payroll_time_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-080-junction-foods/03_payroll_time/024_payroll_time_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-080-junction-foods/04_compensation_equity/025_compensation_equity_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-080-junction-foods/04_compensation_equity/026_compensation_equity_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-080-junction-foods/04_compensation_equity/027_compensation_equity_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-080-junction-foods/04_compensation_equity/028_compensation_equity_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-080-junction-foods/04_compensation_equity/029_compensation_equity_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-080-junction-foods/04_compensation_equity/030_compensation_equity_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-080-junction-foods/04_compensation_equity/031_compensation_equity_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-080-junction-foods/04_compensation_equity/032_compensation_equity_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-080-junction-foods/05_leave_accommodation/033_leave_accommodation_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-080-junction-foods/05_leave_accommodation/034_leave_accommodation_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-080-junction-foods/05_leave_accommodation/035_leave_accommodation_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-080-junction-foods/05_leave_accommodation/036_leave_accommodation_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-080-junction-foods/05_leave_accommodation/037_leave_accommodation_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-080-junction-foods/05_leave_accommodation/038_leave_accommodation_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-080-junction-foods/05_leave_accommodation/039_leave_accommodation_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-080-junction-foods/05_leave_accommodation/040_leave_accommodation_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-080-junction-foods/06_complaints/041_complaints_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-080-junction-foods/06_complaints/042_complaints_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-080-junction-foods/06_complaints/043_complaints_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-080-junction-foods/06_complaints/044_complaints_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-080-junction-foods/06_complaints/045_complaints_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-080-junction-foods/06_complaints/046_complaints_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-080-junction-foods/06_complaints/047_complaints_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-080-junction-foods/06_complaints/048_complaints_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-080-junction-foods/07_investigations/049_investigations_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-080-junction-foods/07_investigations/050_investigations_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-080-junction-foods/07_investigations/051_investigations_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-080-junction-foods/07_investigations/052_investigations_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-080-junction-foods/07_investigations/053_investigations_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-080-junction-foods/07_investigations/054_investigations_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-080-junction-foods/07_investigations/055_investigations_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-080-junction-foods/07_investigations/056_investigations_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-080-junction-foods/08_performance_discipline/057_performance_discipline_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-080-junction-foods/08_performance_discipline/058_performance_discipline_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-080-junction-foods/08_performance_discipline/059_performance_discipline_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-080-junction-foods/08_performance_discipline/060_performance_discipline_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-080-junction-foods/08_performance_discipline/061_performance_discipline_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-080-junction-foods/08_performance_discipline/062_performance_discipline_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-080-junction-foods/08_performance_discipline/063_performance_discipline_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-080-junction-foods/08_performance_discipline/064_performance_discipline_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-080-junction-foods/09_separation/065_separation_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-080-junction-foods/09_separation/066_separation_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-080-junction-foods/09_separation/067_separation_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-080-junction-foods/09_separation/068_separation_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-080-junction-foods/09_separation/069_separation_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-080-junction-foods/09_separation/070_separation_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-080-junction-foods/09_separation/071_separation_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-080-junction-foods/09_separation/072_separation_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-080-junction-foods/10_contractors/073_contractors_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-080-junction-foods/10_contractors/074_contractors_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-080-junction-foods/10_contractors/075_contractors_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-080-junction-foods/10_contractors/076_contractors_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-080-junction-foods/10_contractors/077_contractors_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-080-junction-foods/10_contractors/078_contractors_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-080-junction-foods/10_contractors/079_contractors_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-080-junction-foods/10_contractors/080_contractors_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-080-junction-foods/11_training/081_training_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-080-junction-foods/11_training/082_training_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-080-junction-foods/11_training/083_training_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-080-junction-foods/11_training/084_training_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-080-junction-foods/11_training/085_training_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-080-junction-foods/11_training/086_training_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-080-junction-foods/11_training/087_training_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-080-junction-foods/11_training/088_training_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-080-junction-foods/12_agency_matters/089_agency_matters_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-080-junction-foods/12_agency_matters/090_agency_matters_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-080-junction-foods/12_agency_matters/091_agency_matters_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-080-junction-foods/12_agency_matters/092_agency_matters_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-080-junction-foods/12_agency_matters/093_agency_matters_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-080-junction-foods/12_agency_matters/094_agency_matters_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-080-junction-foods/12_agency_matters/095_agency_matters_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-080-junction-foods/12_agency_matters/096_agency_matters_status_report.md"], "gold_output": {"advice_markdown": "# Counsel advice — Junction Foods agency response check\n\n## Executive assessment\n\nFor Junction Prepared Foods matter CB-EL-3110, the review identified 16 source-supported exceptions requiring action before 2026-10-07. The assessment concerns Packaging-line employee group and the supplied record for Iowa.\n\n## Method and record coverage\n\nThe review inventoried all 96 production files, read the 33 controlling, corroborating, and control records, searched the email exports, and checked metadata for the designated chain-of-custody sample. Conclusions are limited to the synthetic production supplied for this benchmark matter.\n\n## Findings\n\n### F-01 — classification inconsistency (critical)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for classification inconsistency: one source states the operative date is 2025-02-14 under control reference CB-EL-3110-A202, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2025-03-17 under response reference CB-EL-3110-J869.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/001_handbooks_policies_control_register.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/07_investigations/049_investigations_control_register.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-10-07, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Nadine Flores.\n\n### F-02 — overtime calculation error (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for overtime calculation error: one source states the controlling amount is $2,435,925.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $2,678,350.00.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/004_handbooks_policies_ledger_export.csv`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/07_investigations/052_investigations_ledger_export.csv`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-10-07, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Micah Sullivan.\n\n### F-03 — meal-period premium gap (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for meal-period premium gap: one source states approval is attributed to Adrian Mensah as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Jonas Feld and contains no entry for Adrian Mensah.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/007_handbooks_policies_officer_certificate.html`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/07_investigations/055_investigations_officer_certificate.html`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-10-07, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Farah Ibrahim.\n\n### F-04 — pay-equity outlier (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for pay-equity outlier: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-EL-3110-D110, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-EL-3110-M793.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/010_personnel_records_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/08_performance_discipline/058_performance_discipline_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-10-07, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Owen Delgado.\n\n### F-05 — leave designation delay (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for leave designation delay: one source states the applicable location is Iowa Civil Rights Commission, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to Iowa operations outside Iowa Civil Rights Commission.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/013_personnel_records_review_memorandum.json`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/08_performance_discipline/061_performance_discipline_review_memorandum.json`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-10-07, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Lena Varga.\n\n### F-06 — interactive-process lapse (low)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for interactive-process lapse: one source states the threshold is 4% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 8% and produced a different exception result.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/016_personnel_records_status_report.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/08_performance_discipline/064_performance_discipline_status_report.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-10-07, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Samuel Kim.\n\n### F-07 — complaint escalation gap (critical)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for complaint escalation gap: one source states formal notice must use notices-junction_prepared_foods@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-packaging_line_employee_group@example.test.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/019_payroll_time_correspondence.eml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/09_separation/067_separation_correspondence.eml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-10-07, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Maya Ellison.\n\n### F-08 — investigation independence concern (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for investigation independence concern: one source states the governed population contains 102 records through 2025-07-16, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 50 records through 2025-08-07.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/022_payroll_time_formal_notice.xml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/09_separation/070_separation_formal_notice.xml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-10-07, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Rafael Okafor.\n\n### F-09 — discipline comparator inconsistency (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for discipline comparator inconsistency: one source states the operative date is 2026-01-21 under control reference CB-EL-3110-I963, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2026-01-29 under response reference CB-EL-3110-R235.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/025_compensation_equity_control_register.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/10_contractors/073_contractors_control_register.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-10-07, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Nora Chen.\n\n### F-10 — retaliation timing (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for retaliation timing: one source states the controlling amount is $545,999.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $748,498.00.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/028_compensation_equity_ledger_export.csv`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/10_contractors/076_contractors_ledger_export.csv`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-10-07, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Dominic Alvarez.\n\n### F-11 — separation pay discrepancy (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for separation pay discrepancy: one source states approval is attributed to Adrian Mensah as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Samuel Kim and contains no entry for Adrian Mensah.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/031_compensation_equity_officer_certificate.html`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/10_contractors/079_contractors_officer_certificate.html`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-10-07, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Priya Raman.\n\n### F-12 — restrictive-covenant conflict (low)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for restrictive-covenant conflict: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-EL-3110-L785, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-EL-3110-U914.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/034_leave_accommodation_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/11_training/082_training_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-10-07, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Elliot Mercer.\n\n### F-13 — contractor control evidence (critical)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for contractor control evidence: one source states the applicable location is Iowa Civil Rights Commission, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to Iowa operations outside Iowa Civil Rights Commission.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/037_leave_accommodation_review_memorandum.json`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/11_training/085_training_review_memorandum.json`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-10-07, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Talia Brooks.\n\n### F-14 — training completion gap (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for training completion gap: one source states the threshold is 6% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 10% and produced a different exception result.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/040_leave_accommodation_status_report.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/11_training/088_training_status_report.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-10-07, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Jonas Feld.\n\n### F-15 — personnel-file access deadline (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for personnel-file access deadline: one source states formal notice must use notices-junction_prepared_foods@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-packaging_line_employee_group@example.test.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/06_complaints/043_complaints_correspondence.eml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/091_agency_matters_correspondence.eml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-10-07, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Mei Whitaker.\n\n### F-16 — agency response commitment (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for agency response commitment: one source states the governed population contains 49 records through 2025-10-11, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 40 records through 2025-10-23.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/06_complaints/046_complaints_formal_notice.xml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/094_agency_matters_formal_notice.xml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-10-07, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Caleb Hassan.\n\n## Recommended next actions\n\nSequence the critical and high findings first, assign the named owners, preserve the cited records, and document any resolution in the controlling matter register before the stated deadline.\n\n## Assumptions and limitations\n\nThis analysis is confined to task cb100-080-junction-foods and the supplied synthetic evidence. It does not rely on external facts, does not resolve disputed law, and is not legal advice for a real person or entity.\n", "findings": {"as_of": "2026-10-07", "findings": [{"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/07_investigations/049_investigations_control_register.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for classification inconsistency: one source states the operative date is 2025-02-14 under control reference CB-EL-3110-A202, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2025-03-17 under response reference CB-EL-3110-J869.", "id": "F-01", "issue": "classification inconsistency", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/001_handbooks_policies_control_register.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-10-07, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Nadine Flores.", "severity": "critical"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/07_investigations/052_investigations_ledger_export.csv", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for overtime calculation error: one source states the controlling amount is $2,435,925.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $2,678,350.00.", "id": "F-02", "issue": "overtime calculation error", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/004_handbooks_policies_ledger_export.csv", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-10-07, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Micah Sullivan.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/07_investigations/055_investigations_officer_certificate.html", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for meal-period premium gap: one source states approval is attributed to Adrian Mensah as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Jonas Feld and contains no entry for Adrian Mensah.", "id": "F-03", "issue": "meal-period premium gap", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/007_handbooks_policies_officer_certificate.html", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-10-07, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Farah Ibrahim.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/08_performance_discipline/058_performance_discipline_executed_instrument.txt", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for pay-equity outlier: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-EL-3110-D110, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-EL-3110-M793.", "id": "F-04", "issue": "pay-equity outlier", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/010_personnel_records_executed_instrument.txt", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-10-07, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Owen Delgado.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/08_performance_discipline/061_performance_discipline_review_memorandum.json", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for leave designation delay: one source states the applicable location is Iowa Civil Rights Commission, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to Iowa operations outside Iowa Civil Rights Commission.", "id": "F-05", "issue": "leave designation delay", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/013_personnel_records_review_memorandum.json", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-10-07, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Lena Varga.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/08_performance_discipline/064_performance_discipline_status_report.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for interactive-process lapse: one source states the threshold is 4% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 8% and produced a different exception result.", "id": "F-06", "issue": "interactive-process lapse", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/016_personnel_records_status_report.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-10-07, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Samuel Kim.", "severity": "low"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/09_separation/067_separation_correspondence.eml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for complaint escalation gap: one source states formal notice must use notices-junction_prepared_foods@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-packaging_line_employee_group@example.test.", "id": "F-07", "issue": "complaint escalation gap", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/019_payroll_time_correspondence.eml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-10-07, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Maya Ellison.", "severity": "critical"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/09_separation/070_separation_formal_notice.xml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for investigation independence concern: one source states the governed population contains 102 records through 2025-07-16, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 50 records through 2025-08-07.", "id": "F-08", "issue": "investigation independence concern", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/022_payroll_time_formal_notice.xml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-10-07, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Rafael Okafor.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/10_contractors/073_contractors_control_register.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for discipline comparator inconsistency: one source states the operative date is 2026-01-21 under control reference CB-EL-3110-I963, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2026-01-29 under response reference CB-EL-3110-R235.", "id": "F-09", "issue": "discipline comparator inconsistency", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/025_compensation_equity_control_register.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-10-07, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Nora Chen.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/10_contractors/076_contractors_ledger_export.csv", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for retaliation timing: one source states the controlling amount is $545,999.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $748,498.00.", "id": "F-10", "issue": "retaliation timing", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/028_compensation_equity_ledger_export.csv", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-10-07, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Dominic Alvarez.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/10_contractors/079_contractors_officer_certificate.html", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for separation pay discrepancy: one source states approval is attributed to Adrian Mensah as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Samuel Kim and contains no entry for Adrian Mensah.", "id": "F-11", "issue": "separation pay discrepancy", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/031_compensation_equity_officer_certificate.html", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-10-07, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Priya Raman.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/11_training/082_training_executed_instrument.txt", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for restrictive-covenant conflict: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-EL-3110-L785, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-EL-3110-U914.", "id": "F-12", "issue": "restrictive-covenant conflict", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/034_leave_accommodation_executed_instrument.txt", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-10-07, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Elliot Mercer.", "severity": "low"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/11_training/085_training_review_memorandum.json", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for contractor control evidence: one source states the applicable location is Iowa Civil Rights Commission, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to Iowa operations outside Iowa Civil Rights Commission.", "id": "F-13", "issue": "contractor control evidence", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/037_leave_accommodation_review_memorandum.json", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-10-07, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Talia Brooks.", "severity": "critical"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/11_training/088_training_status_report.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for training completion gap: one source states the threshold is 6% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 10% and produced a different exception result.", "id": "F-14", "issue": "training completion gap", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/040_leave_accommodation_status_report.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-10-07, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Jonas Feld.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/091_agency_matters_correspondence.eml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for personnel-file access deadline: one source states formal notice must use notices-junction_prepared_foods@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-packaging_line_employee_group@example.test.", "id": "F-15", "issue": "personnel-file access deadline", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/06_complaints/043_complaints_correspondence.eml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-10-07, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Mei Whitaker.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/094_agency_matters_formal_notice.xml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for agency response commitment: one source states the governed population contains 49 records through 2025-10-11, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 40 records through 2025-10-23.", "id": "F-16", "issue": "agency response commitment", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/06_complaints/046_complaints_formal_notice.xml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-10-07, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Caleb Hassan.", "severity": "medium"}], "matter_number": "CB-EL-3110", "prepared_for": "Junction Prepared Foods", "schema_version": "1.0", "task_id": "cb100-080-junction-foods"}}, "metadata": {"benchmark": "CounselBench-100", "code_license": "Apache-2.0", "data_license": "CC-BY-4.0", "deadline": "2026-10-07", "document_count": 96, "jurisdiction": "Iowa", "matter_number": "CB-EL-3110", "mcp_commit": "9a96ea6e5913736f92b88345bf51caeaaa8e719f", "mcp_package": "@modelcontextprotocol/server-filesystem@2026.7.10", "practice_area": "employment", "reference_tool_calls": 46, "required_evidence_reads": 33, "synthetic": true, "venue": "Iowa Civil Rights Commission", "version": "2.0.0"}, "prompt": "You are employment counsel for Junction Prepared Foods. The record contains amendments, exports, and correspondence from different custodians; reconcile them into an actionable counsel work product. Shift records, accommodations, training, payroll corrections, and agency commitments contain conflicting dates and owners. Decision due 2026-10-07. Iowa law governs; Iowa Civil Rights Commission is the forum. Write for a supervising lawyer who will spot-check source paths and exact values. Work out the defensible position from the matter production and leave an audit-ready exception tracker and concise advice for the supervising lawyer. Keep confirmed conflicts separate from open questions, cite the records that actually control each conclusion, and do not fill gaps with outside facts.", "rubric": {"criteria": [{"category": "procedure", "description": "Complete at least 46 successful, argument-specific evidence and output calls.", "id": "procedure.minimum_successful_tool_calls"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Find and read the 33 controlling, corroborating, and work-product-control records in full.", "id": "procedure.all_evidence_read_in_full"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Inspect file metadata for the eight designated critical primary records before relying on them.", "id": "procedure.chain_of_custody_metadata_checked"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Confirm the sandbox's allowed document and output roots.", "id": "procedure.allowed_directories_checked"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Inventory all 96 records so the relevant sources are discovered among the context records.", "id": "procedure.recursive_inventory_completed"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Search the production for email evidence that may corroborate or contradict formal records.", "id": "procedure.targeted_search_completed"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Leave only findings.json and advice.md in the output workspace.", "id": "procedure.exact_deliverable_set"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Create both final work products through the sandbox MCP surface.", "id": "procedure.deliverables_written_through_mcp"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Produce findings.json as a valid JSON object.", "id": "findings.findings_is_object"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Report exactly 16 confirmed exceptions.", "id": "findings.findings_exact_count"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Use each stable finding ID exactly once.", "id": "findings.finding_ids_unique"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set schema_version to the released matter value '1.0'.", "id": "findings.top_level_schema_version"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set task_id to the released matter value 'cb100-080-junction-foods'.", "id": "findings.top_level_task_id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set matter_number to the released matter value 'CB-EL-3110'.", "id": "findings.top_level_matter_number"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set prepared_for to the released matter value 'Junction Prepared Foods'.", "id": "findings.top_level_prepared_for"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set as_of to the released matter value '2026-10-07'.", "id": "findings.top_level_as_of"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-01 exception for classification inconsistency.", "id": "findings.F-01.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's id from /workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/001_handbooks_policies_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_investigations/049_investigations_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's issue from /workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/001_handbooks_policies_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_investigations/049_investigations_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's severity from /workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/001_handbooks_policies_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_investigations/049_investigations_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's primary_source from /workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/001_handbooks_policies_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_investigations/049_investigations_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/001_handbooks_policies_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_investigations/049_investigations_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-01 using the exact controlled facts ['2025-02-14', 'CB-EL-3110-A202', '2025-03-17', 'CB-EL-3110-J869'].", "id": "findings.F-01.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-01's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-01.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-10-07', 'Nadine Flores'] for F-01.", "id": "findings.F-01.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-02 exception for overtime calculation error.", "id": "findings.F-02.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's id from /workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/004_handbooks_policies_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_investigations/052_investigations_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's issue from /workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/004_handbooks_policies_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_investigations/052_investigations_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's severity from /workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/004_handbooks_policies_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_investigations/052_investigations_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's primary_source from /workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/004_handbooks_policies_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_investigations/052_investigations_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/004_handbooks_policies_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_investigations/052_investigations_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-02 using the exact controlled facts ['$2,435,925.00', '$2,678,350.00'].", "id": "findings.F-02.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-02's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-02.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-10-07', 'Micah Sullivan'] for F-02.", "id": "findings.F-02.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-03 exception for meal-period premium gap.", "id": "findings.F-03.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's id from /workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/007_handbooks_policies_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_investigations/055_investigations_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's issue from /workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/007_handbooks_policies_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_investigations/055_investigations_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's severity from /workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/007_handbooks_policies_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_investigations/055_investigations_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's primary_source from /workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/007_handbooks_policies_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_investigations/055_investigations_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/007_handbooks_policies_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_investigations/055_investigations_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-03 using the exact controlled facts ['Adrian Mensah', 'Jonas Feld'].", "id": "findings.F-03.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-03's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-03.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-10-07', 'Farah Ibrahim'] for F-03.", "id": "findings.F-03.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-04 exception for pay-equity outlier.", "id": "findings.F-04.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's id from /workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/010_personnel_records_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_performance_discipline/058_performance_discipline_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's issue from /workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/010_personnel_records_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_performance_discipline/058_performance_discipline_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's severity from /workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/010_personnel_records_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_performance_discipline/058_performance_discipline_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's primary_source from /workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/010_personnel_records_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_performance_discipline/058_performance_discipline_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/010_personnel_records_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_performance_discipline/058_performance_discipline_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-04 using the exact controlled facts ['closed without exception', 'CB-EL-3110-D110', 'open and escalated', 'CB-EL-3110-M793'].", "id": "findings.F-04.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-04's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-04.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-10-07', 'Owen Delgado'] for F-04.", "id": "findings.F-04.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-05 exception for leave designation delay.", "id": "findings.F-05.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's id from /workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/013_personnel_records_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_performance_discipline/061_performance_discipline_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's issue from /workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/013_personnel_records_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_performance_discipline/061_performance_discipline_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's severity from /workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/013_personnel_records_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_performance_discipline/061_performance_discipline_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's primary_source from /workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/013_personnel_records_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_performance_discipline/061_performance_discipline_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/013_personnel_records_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_performance_discipline/061_performance_discipline_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-05 using the exact controlled facts ['Iowa Civil Rights Commission', 'Iowa'].", "id": "findings.F-05.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-05's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-05.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-10-07', 'Lena Varga'] for F-05.", "id": "findings.F-05.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-06 exception for interactive-process lapse.", "id": "findings.F-06.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's id from /workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/016_personnel_records_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_performance_discipline/064_performance_discipline_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's issue from /workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/016_personnel_records_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_performance_discipline/064_performance_discipline_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's severity from /workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/016_personnel_records_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_performance_discipline/064_performance_discipline_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's primary_source from /workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/016_personnel_records_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_performance_discipline/064_performance_discipline_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/016_personnel_records_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_performance_discipline/064_performance_discipline_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-06 using the exact controlled facts ['4%', '8%'].", "id": "findings.F-06.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-06's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-06.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-10-07', 'Samuel Kim'] for F-06.", "id": "findings.F-06.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-07 exception for complaint escalation gap.", "id": "findings.F-07.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's id from /workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/019_payroll_time_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_separation/067_separation_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's issue from /workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/019_payroll_time_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_separation/067_separation_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's severity from /workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/019_payroll_time_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_separation/067_separation_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's primary_source from /workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/019_payroll_time_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_separation/067_separation_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/019_payroll_time_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_separation/067_separation_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-07 using the exact controlled facts ['notices-junction_prepared_foods@example.test', 'archive-packaging_line_employee_group@example.test'].", "id": "findings.F-07.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-07's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-07.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-10-07', 'Maya Ellison'] for F-07.", "id": "findings.F-07.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-08 exception for investigation independence concern.", "id": "findings.F-08.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's id from /workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/022_payroll_time_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_separation/070_separation_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's issue from /workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/022_payroll_time_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_separation/070_separation_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's severity from /workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/022_payroll_time_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_separation/070_separation_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's primary_source from /workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/022_payroll_time_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_separation/070_separation_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/022_payroll_time_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_separation/070_separation_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-08 using the exact controlled facts ['102 records', '2025-07-16', '50 records', '2025-08-07'].", "id": "findings.F-08.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-08's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-08.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-10-07', 'Rafael Okafor'] for F-08.", "id": "findings.F-08.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-09 exception for discipline comparator inconsistency.", "id": "findings.F-09.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's id from /workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/025_compensation_equity_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_contractors/073_contractors_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's issue from /workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/025_compensation_equity_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_contractors/073_contractors_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's severity from /workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/025_compensation_equity_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_contractors/073_contractors_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's primary_source from /workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/025_compensation_equity_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_contractors/073_contractors_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/025_compensation_equity_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_contractors/073_contractors_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-09 using the exact controlled facts ['2026-01-21', 'CB-EL-3110-I963', '2026-01-29', 'CB-EL-3110-R235'].", "id": "findings.F-09.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-09's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-09.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-10-07', 'Nora Chen'] for F-09.", "id": "findings.F-09.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-10 exception for retaliation timing.", "id": "findings.F-10.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's id from /workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/028_compensation_equity_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_contractors/076_contractors_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's issue from /workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/028_compensation_equity_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_contractors/076_contractors_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's severity from /workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/028_compensation_equity_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_contractors/076_contractors_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's primary_source from /workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/028_compensation_equity_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_contractors/076_contractors_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/028_compensation_equity_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_contractors/076_contractors_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-10 using the exact controlled facts ['$545,999.00', '$748,498.00'].", "id": "findings.F-10.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-10's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-10.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-10-07', 'Dominic Alvarez'] for F-10.", "id": "findings.F-10.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-11 exception for separation pay discrepancy.", "id": "findings.F-11.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's id from /workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/031_compensation_equity_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_contractors/079_contractors_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's issue from /workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/031_compensation_equity_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_contractors/079_contractors_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's severity from /workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/031_compensation_equity_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_contractors/079_contractors_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's primary_source from /workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/031_compensation_equity_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_contractors/079_contractors_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/031_compensation_equity_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_contractors/079_contractors_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-11 using the exact controlled facts ['Adrian Mensah', 'Samuel Kim'].", "id": "findings.F-11.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-11's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-11.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-10-07', 'Priya Raman'] for F-11.", "id": "findings.F-11.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-12 exception for restrictive-covenant conflict.", "id": "findings.F-12.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's id from /workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/034_leave_accommodation_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_training/082_training_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's issue from /workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/034_leave_accommodation_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_training/082_training_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's severity from /workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/034_leave_accommodation_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_training/082_training_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's primary_source from /workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/034_leave_accommodation_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_training/082_training_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/034_leave_accommodation_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_training/082_training_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-12 using the exact controlled facts ['closed without exception', 'CB-EL-3110-L785', 'open and escalated', 'CB-EL-3110-U914'].", "id": "findings.F-12.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-12's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-12.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-10-07', 'Elliot Mercer'] for F-12.", "id": "findings.F-12.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-13 exception for contractor control evidence.", "id": "findings.F-13.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's id from /workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/037_leave_accommodation_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_training/085_training_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's issue from /workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/037_leave_accommodation_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_training/085_training_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's severity from /workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/037_leave_accommodation_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_training/085_training_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's primary_source from /workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/037_leave_accommodation_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_training/085_training_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/037_leave_accommodation_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_training/085_training_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-13 using the exact controlled facts ['Iowa Civil Rights Commission', 'Iowa'].", "id": "findings.F-13.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-13's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-13.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-10-07', 'Talia Brooks'] for F-13.", "id": "findings.F-13.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-14 exception for training completion gap.", "id": "findings.F-14.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's id from /workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/040_leave_accommodation_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_training/088_training_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's issue from /workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/040_leave_accommodation_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_training/088_training_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's severity from /workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/040_leave_accommodation_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_training/088_training_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's primary_source from /workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/040_leave_accommodation_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_training/088_training_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/040_leave_accommodation_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_training/088_training_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-14 using the exact controlled facts ['6%', '10%'].", "id": "findings.F-14.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-14's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-14.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-10-07', 'Jonas Feld'] for F-14.", "id": "findings.F-14.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-15 exception for personnel-file access deadline.", "id": "findings.F-15.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's id from /workspace/documents/06_complaints/043_complaints_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/091_agency_matters_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's issue from /workspace/documents/06_complaints/043_complaints_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/091_agency_matters_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's severity from /workspace/documents/06_complaints/043_complaints_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/091_agency_matters_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's primary_source from /workspace/documents/06_complaints/043_complaints_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/091_agency_matters_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/06_complaints/043_complaints_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/091_agency_matters_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-15 using the exact controlled facts ['notices-junction_prepared_foods@example.test', 'archive-packaging_line_employee_group@example.test'].", "id": "findings.F-15.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-15's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-15.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-10-07', 'Mei Whitaker'] for F-15.", "id": "findings.F-15.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-16 exception for agency response commitment.", "id": "findings.F-16.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's id from /workspace/documents/06_complaints/046_complaints_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/094_agency_matters_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's issue from /workspace/documents/06_complaints/046_complaints_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/094_agency_matters_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's severity from /workspace/documents/06_complaints/046_complaints_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/094_agency_matters_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's primary_source from /workspace/documents/06_complaints/046_complaints_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/094_agency_matters_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/06_complaints/046_complaints_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/094_agency_matters_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-16 using the exact controlled facts ['49 records', '2025-10-11', '40 records', '2025-10-23'].", "id": "findings.F-16.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-16's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-16.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-10-07', 'Caleb Hassan'] for F-16.", "id": "findings.F-16.action_anchors"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Executive assessment' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Executive assessment"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Method and record coverage' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Method and record coverage"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Findings' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Findings"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Recommended next actions' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Recommended next actions"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Assumptions and limitations' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Assumptions and limitations"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-01 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-01"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-02 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-02"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-03 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-03"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-04 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-04"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-05 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-05"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-06 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-06"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-07 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-07"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-08 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-08"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-09 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-09"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-10 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-10"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-11 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-11"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-12 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-12"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-13 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-13"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-14 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-14"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-15 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-15"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-16 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-16"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Do not claim the production has no issues or that every record is consistent.", "id": "memo.forbidden_claims_absent"}], "decision_options": [{"id": "cross-source-reconciliation", "label": "Reconcile controlling and corroborating records", "reason": "The CB-EL-3110 production contains independently maintained records; a defensible answer must preserve each supported conflict and its cure owner.", "selected": true}, {"id": "latest-record-controls", "label": "Treat the latest record as controlling", "reason": "Timestamp recency does not establish legal priority, execution, or approval authority.", "selected": false}, {"id": "primary-records-only", "label": "Report primary records without reconciliation", "reason": "Primary records alone conceal the operational conflicts that create the actionable exceptions.", "selected": false}], "gates": ["all_evidence_read_in_full", "chain_of_custody_metadata_checked", "findings_criteria_complete", "memo_criteria_complete", "deliverables_written_through_mcp"], "metadata_checks": 8, "metric": "weighted_criteria_score", "minimum_tool_calls": 46, "required_deliverables": ["findings.json", "advice.md"], "required_document_reads": 33, "type": "deterministic", "weights": {"findings": 0.55, "memo": 0.2, "procedure": 0.25}}, "task_id": "cb100-080-junction-foods", "task_name": "Junction Foods agency response check", "world_id": "counselbench-filesystem-mcp-v2"}
-{"context_files": ["task_files/cb100-081-aperture-robotics/01_patents/001_patents_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-081-aperture-robotics/01_patents/002_patents_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-081-aperture-robotics/01_patents/003_patents_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-081-aperture-robotics/01_patents/004_patents_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-081-aperture-robotics/01_patents/005_patents_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-081-aperture-robotics/01_patents/006_patents_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-081-aperture-robotics/01_patents/007_patents_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-081-aperture-robotics/01_patents/008_patents_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-081-aperture-robotics/02_trademarks/009_trademarks_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-081-aperture-robotics/02_trademarks/010_trademarks_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-081-aperture-robotics/02_trademarks/011_trademarks_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-081-aperture-robotics/02_trademarks/012_trademarks_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-081-aperture-robotics/02_trademarks/013_trademarks_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-081-aperture-robotics/02_trademarks/014_trademarks_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-081-aperture-robotics/02_trademarks/015_trademarks_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-081-aperture-robotics/02_trademarks/016_trademarks_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-081-aperture-robotics/03_copyrights/017_copyrights_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-081-aperture-robotics/03_copyrights/018_copyrights_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-081-aperture-robotics/03_copyrights/019_copyrights_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-081-aperture-robotics/03_copyrights/020_copyrights_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-081-aperture-robotics/03_copyrights/021_copyrights_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-081-aperture-robotics/03_copyrights/022_copyrights_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-081-aperture-robotics/03_copyrights/023_copyrights_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-081-aperture-robotics/03_copyrights/024_copyrights_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-081-aperture-robotics/04_invention_assignments/025_invention_assignments_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-081-aperture-robotics/04_invention_assignments/026_invention_assignments_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-081-aperture-robotics/04_invention_assignments/027_invention_assignments_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-081-aperture-robotics/04_invention_assignments/028_invention_assignments_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-081-aperture-robotics/04_invention_assignments/029_invention_assignments_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-081-aperture-robotics/04_invention_assignments/030_invention_assignments_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-081-aperture-robotics/04_invention_assignments/031_invention_assignments_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-081-aperture-robotics/04_invention_assignments/032_invention_assignments_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-081-aperture-robotics/05_licenses_in/033_licenses_in_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-081-aperture-robotics/05_licenses_in/034_licenses_in_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-081-aperture-robotics/05_licenses_in/035_licenses_in_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-081-aperture-robotics/05_licenses_in/036_licenses_in_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-081-aperture-robotics/05_licenses_in/037_licenses_in_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-081-aperture-robotics/05_licenses_in/038_licenses_in_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-081-aperture-robotics/05_licenses_in/039_licenses_in_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-081-aperture-robotics/05_licenses_in/040_licenses_in_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-081-aperture-robotics/06_licenses_out/041_licenses_out_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-081-aperture-robotics/06_licenses_out/042_licenses_out_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-081-aperture-robotics/06_licenses_out/043_licenses_out_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-081-aperture-robotics/06_licenses_out/044_licenses_out_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-081-aperture-robotics/06_licenses_out/045_licenses_out_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-081-aperture-robotics/06_licenses_out/046_licenses_out_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-081-aperture-robotics/06_licenses_out/047_licenses_out_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-081-aperture-robotics/06_licenses_out/048_licenses_out_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-081-aperture-robotics/07_open_source/049_open_source_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-081-aperture-robotics/07_open_source/050_open_source_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-081-aperture-robotics/07_open_source/051_open_source_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-081-aperture-robotics/07_open_source/052_open_source_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-081-aperture-robotics/07_open_source/053_open_source_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-081-aperture-robotics/07_open_source/054_open_source_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-081-aperture-robotics/07_open_source/055_open_source_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-081-aperture-robotics/07_open_source/056_open_source_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-081-aperture-robotics/08_domain_accounts/057_domain_accounts_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-081-aperture-robotics/08_domain_accounts/058_domain_accounts_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-081-aperture-robotics/08_domain_accounts/059_domain_accounts_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-081-aperture-robotics/08_domain_accounts/060_domain_accounts_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-081-aperture-robotics/08_domain_accounts/061_domain_accounts_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-081-aperture-robotics/08_domain_accounts/062_domain_accounts_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-081-aperture-robotics/08_domain_accounts/063_domain_accounts_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-081-aperture-robotics/08_domain_accounts/064_domain_accounts_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-081-aperture-robotics/09_development_records/065_development_records_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-081-aperture-robotics/09_development_records/066_development_records_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-081-aperture-robotics/09_development_records/067_development_records_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-081-aperture-robotics/09_development_records/068_development_records_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-081-aperture-robotics/09_development_records/069_development_records_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-081-aperture-robotics/09_development_records/070_development_records_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-081-aperture-robotics/09_development_records/071_development_records_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-081-aperture-robotics/09_development_records/072_development_records_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-081-aperture-robotics/10_disputes/073_disputes_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-081-aperture-robotics/10_disputes/074_disputes_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-081-aperture-robotics/10_disputes/075_disputes_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-081-aperture-robotics/10_disputes/076_disputes_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-081-aperture-robotics/10_disputes/077_disputes_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-081-aperture-robotics/10_disputes/078_disputes_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-081-aperture-robotics/10_disputes/079_disputes_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-081-aperture-robotics/10_disputes/080_disputes_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-081-aperture-robotics/11_maintenance/081_maintenance_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-081-aperture-robotics/11_maintenance/082_maintenance_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-081-aperture-robotics/11_maintenance/083_maintenance_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-081-aperture-robotics/11_maintenance/084_maintenance_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-081-aperture-robotics/11_maintenance/085_maintenance_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-081-aperture-robotics/11_maintenance/086_maintenance_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-081-aperture-robotics/11_maintenance/087_maintenance_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-081-aperture-robotics/11_maintenance/088_maintenance_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-081-aperture-robotics/12_security_interests/089_security_interests_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-081-aperture-robotics/12_security_interests/090_security_interests_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-081-aperture-robotics/12_security_interests/091_security_interests_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-081-aperture-robotics/12_security_interests/092_security_interests_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-081-aperture-robotics/12_security_interests/093_security_interests_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-081-aperture-robotics/12_security_interests/094_security_interests_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-081-aperture-robotics/12_security_interests/095_security_interests_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-081-aperture-robotics/12_security_interests/096_security_interests_status_report.md"], "gold_output": {"advice_markdown": "# Counsel advice — Aperture robotics chain-of-title review\n\n## Executive assessment\n\nFor Aperture Robotics, Inc. matter CB-IP-3201, the review identified 16 source-supported exceptions requiring action before 2026-09-04. The assessment concerns Founding engineer group and the supplied record for Delaware.\n\n## Method and record coverage\n\nThe review inventoried all 96 production files, read the 33 controlling, corroborating, and control records, searched the email exports, and checked metadata for the designated chain-of-custody sample. Conclusions are limited to the synthetic production supplied for this benchmark matter.\n\n## Findings\n\n### F-01 — inventor assignment gap (critical)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for inventor assignment gap: one source states the operative date is 2025-11-05 under control reference CB-IP-3201-A766, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2025-12-12 under response reference CB-IP-3201-J774.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/01_patents/001_patents_control_register.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/07_open_source/049_open_source_control_register.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-04, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Micah Sullivan.\n\n### F-02 — recorded-owner mismatch (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for recorded-owner mismatch: one source states the controlling amount is $5,809,469.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $5,865,438.00.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/01_patents/004_patents_ledger_export.csv`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/07_open_source/052_open_source_ledger_export.csv`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-04, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Farah Ibrahim.\n\n### F-03 — maintenance-fee deadline (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for maintenance-fee deadline: one source states approval is attributed to Willa Novak as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Caleb Hassan and contains no entry for Willa Novak.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/01_patents/007_patents_officer_certificate.html`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/07_open_source/055_open_source_officer_certificate.html`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-04, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Owen Delgado.\n\n### F-04 — foreign-filing restriction (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for foreign-filing restriction: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-IP-3201-D452, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-IP-3201-M404.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/02_trademarks/010_trademarks_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/08_domain_accounts/058_domain_accounts_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-04, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Lena Varga.\n\n### F-05 — trademark specimen issue (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for trademark specimen issue: one source states the applicable location is United States Patent and Trademark Office, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to Delaware operations outside United States Patent and Trademark Office.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/02_trademarks/013_trademarks_review_memorandum.json`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/08_domain_accounts/061_domain_accounts_review_memorandum.json`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-04, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Samuel Kim.\n\n### F-06 — coexistence restriction (low)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for coexistence restriction: one source states the threshold is 10% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 12% and produced a different exception result.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/02_trademarks/016_trademarks_status_report.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/08_domain_accounts/064_domain_accounts_status_report.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-04, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Maya Ellison.\n\n### F-07 — work-for-hire defect (critical)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for work-for-hire defect: one source states formal notice must use notices-aperture_robotics_inc@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-founding_engineer_group@example.test.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/03_copyrights/019_copyrights_correspondence.eml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/09_development_records/067_development_records_correspondence.eml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-04, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Rafael Okafor.\n\n### F-08 — source-code ownership gap (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for source-code ownership gap: one source states the governed population contains 77 records through 2025-06-21, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 64 records through 2025-07-27.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/03_copyrights/022_copyrights_formal_notice.xml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/09_development_records/070_development_records_formal_notice.xml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-04, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Nora Chen.\n\n### F-09 — inbound-license field restriction (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for inbound-license field restriction: one source states the operative date is 2025-05-20 under control reference CB-IP-3201-I357, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2025-06-12 under response reference CB-IP-3201-R535.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/025_invention_assignments_control_register.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/10_disputes/073_disputes_control_register.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-04, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Dominic Alvarez.\n\n### F-10 — outbound sublicense overreach (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for outbound sublicense overreach: one source states the controlling amount is $4,177,342.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $4,211,184.00.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/028_invention_assignments_ledger_export.csv`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/10_disputes/076_disputes_ledger_export.csv`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-04, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Priya Raman.\n\n### F-11 — copyleft distribution trigger (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for copyleft distribution trigger: one source states approval is attributed to Willa Novak as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Rafael Okafor and contains no entry for Willa Novak.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/031_invention_assignments_officer_certificate.html`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/10_disputes/079_disputes_officer_certificate.html`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-04, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Elliot Mercer.\n\n### F-12 — notice-file omission (low)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for notice-file omission: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-IP-3201-L689, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-IP-3201-U283.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/034_licenses_in_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/11_maintenance/082_maintenance_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-04, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Talia Brooks.\n\n### F-13 — domain registrant mismatch (critical)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for domain registrant mismatch: one source states the applicable location is United States Patent and Trademark Office, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to Delaware operations outside United States Patent and Trademark Office.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/037_licenses_in_review_memorandum.json`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/11_maintenance/085_maintenance_review_memorandum.json`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-04, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Jonas Feld.\n\n### F-14 — repository access anomaly (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for repository access anomaly: one source states the threshold is 10% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 14% and produced a different exception result.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/040_licenses_in_status_report.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/11_maintenance/088_maintenance_status_report.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-04, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Mei Whitaker.\n\n### F-15 — cease-and-desist deadline (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for cease-and-desist deadline: one source states formal notice must use notices-aperture_robotics_inc@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-founding_engineer_group@example.test.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/043_licenses_out_correspondence.eml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/091_security_interests_correspondence.eml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-04, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Caleb Hassan.\n\n### F-16 — security-interest release gap (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for security-interest release gap: one source states the governed population contains 94 records through 2025-11-25, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 54 records through 2025-12-21.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/046_licenses_out_formal_notice.xml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/094_security_interests_formal_notice.xml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-04, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Leona Park.\n\n## Recommended next actions\n\nSequence the critical and high findings first, assign the named owners, preserve the cited records, and document any resolution in the controlling matter register before the stated deadline.\n\n## Assumptions and limitations\n\nThis analysis is confined to task cb100-081-aperture-robotics and the supplied synthetic evidence. It does not rely on external facts, does not resolve disputed law, and is not legal advice for a real person or entity.\n", "findings": {"as_of": "2026-09-04", "findings": [{"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/07_open_source/049_open_source_control_register.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for inventor assignment gap: one source states the operative date is 2025-11-05 under control reference CB-IP-3201-A766, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2025-12-12 under response reference CB-IP-3201-J774.", "id": "F-01", "issue": "inventor assignment gap", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/01_patents/001_patents_control_register.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-04, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Micah Sullivan.", "severity": "critical"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/07_open_source/052_open_source_ledger_export.csv", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for recorded-owner mismatch: one source states the controlling amount is $5,809,469.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $5,865,438.00.", "id": "F-02", "issue": "recorded-owner mismatch", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/01_patents/004_patents_ledger_export.csv", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-04, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Farah Ibrahim.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/07_open_source/055_open_source_officer_certificate.html", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for maintenance-fee deadline: one source states approval is attributed to Willa Novak as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Caleb Hassan and contains no entry for Willa Novak.", "id": "F-03", "issue": "maintenance-fee deadline", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/01_patents/007_patents_officer_certificate.html", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-04, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Owen Delgado.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/08_domain_accounts/058_domain_accounts_executed_instrument.txt", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for foreign-filing restriction: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-IP-3201-D452, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-IP-3201-M404.", "id": "F-04", "issue": "foreign-filing restriction", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/02_trademarks/010_trademarks_executed_instrument.txt", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-04, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Lena Varga.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/08_domain_accounts/061_domain_accounts_review_memorandum.json", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for trademark specimen issue: one source states the applicable location is United States Patent and Trademark Office, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to Delaware operations outside United States Patent and Trademark Office.", "id": "F-05", "issue": "trademark specimen issue", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/02_trademarks/013_trademarks_review_memorandum.json", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-04, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Samuel Kim.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/08_domain_accounts/064_domain_accounts_status_report.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for coexistence restriction: one source states the threshold is 10% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 12% and produced a different exception result.", "id": "F-06", "issue": "coexistence restriction", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/02_trademarks/016_trademarks_status_report.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-04, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Maya Ellison.", "severity": "low"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/09_development_records/067_development_records_correspondence.eml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for work-for-hire defect: one source states formal notice must use notices-aperture_robotics_inc@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-founding_engineer_group@example.test.", "id": "F-07", "issue": "work-for-hire defect", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/03_copyrights/019_copyrights_correspondence.eml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-04, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Rafael Okafor.", "severity": "critical"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/09_development_records/070_development_records_formal_notice.xml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for source-code ownership gap: one source states the governed population contains 77 records through 2025-06-21, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 64 records through 2025-07-27.", "id": "F-08", "issue": "source-code ownership gap", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/03_copyrights/022_copyrights_formal_notice.xml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-04, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Nora Chen.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/10_disputes/073_disputes_control_register.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for inbound-license field restriction: one source states the operative date is 2025-05-20 under control reference CB-IP-3201-I357, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2025-06-12 under response reference CB-IP-3201-R535.", "id": "F-09", "issue": "inbound-license field restriction", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/025_invention_assignments_control_register.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-04, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Dominic Alvarez.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/10_disputes/076_disputes_ledger_export.csv", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for outbound sublicense overreach: one source states the controlling amount is $4,177,342.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $4,211,184.00.", "id": "F-10", "issue": "outbound sublicense overreach", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/028_invention_assignments_ledger_export.csv", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-04, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Priya Raman.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/10_disputes/079_disputes_officer_certificate.html", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for copyleft distribution trigger: one source states approval is attributed to Willa Novak as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Rafael Okafor and contains no entry for Willa Novak.", "id": "F-11", "issue": "copyleft distribution trigger", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/031_invention_assignments_officer_certificate.html", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-04, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Elliot Mercer.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/11_maintenance/082_maintenance_executed_instrument.txt", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for notice-file omission: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-IP-3201-L689, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-IP-3201-U283.", "id": "F-12", "issue": "notice-file omission", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/034_licenses_in_executed_instrument.txt", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-04, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Talia Brooks.", "severity": "low"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/11_maintenance/085_maintenance_review_memorandum.json", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for domain registrant mismatch: one source states the applicable location is United States Patent and Trademark Office, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to Delaware operations outside United States Patent and Trademark Office.", "id": "F-13", "issue": "domain registrant mismatch", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/037_licenses_in_review_memorandum.json", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-04, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Jonas Feld.", "severity": "critical"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/11_maintenance/088_maintenance_status_report.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for repository access anomaly: one source states the threshold is 10% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 14% and produced a different exception result.", "id": "F-14", "issue": "repository access anomaly", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/040_licenses_in_status_report.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-04, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Mei Whitaker.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/091_security_interests_correspondence.eml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for cease-and-desist deadline: one source states formal notice must use notices-aperture_robotics_inc@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-founding_engineer_group@example.test.", "id": "F-15", "issue": "cease-and-desist deadline", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/043_licenses_out_correspondence.eml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-04, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Caleb Hassan.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/094_security_interests_formal_notice.xml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for security-interest release gap: one source states the governed population contains 94 records through 2025-11-25, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 54 records through 2025-12-21.", "id": "F-16", "issue": "security-interest release gap", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/046_licenses_out_formal_notice.xml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-04, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Leona Park.", "severity": "medium"}], "matter_number": "CB-IP-3201", "prepared_for": "Aperture Robotics, Inc.", "schema_version": "1.0", "task_id": "cb100-081-aperture-robotics"}}, "metadata": {"benchmark": "CounselBench-100", "code_license": "Apache-2.0", "data_license": "CC-BY-4.0", "deadline": "2026-09-04", "document_count": 96, "jurisdiction": "Delaware", "matter_number": "CB-IP-3201", "mcp_commit": "9a96ea6e5913736f92b88345bf51caeaaa8e719f", "mcp_package": "@modelcontextprotocol/server-filesystem@2026.7.10", "practice_area": "ip-technology", "reference_tool_calls": 46, "required_evidence_reads": 33, "synthetic": true, "venue": "United States Patent and Trademark Office", "version": "2.0.0"}, "prompt": "You are intellectual-property counsel for Aperture Robotics, Inc. The partner responsible for this matter needs a defensible decision record before the next client call. Robotics patents and source repositories include founder, contractor, university, and lender interests that are not consistently recorded. Decision due 2026-09-04. Delaware law governs; United States Patent and Trademark Office is the forum. Prioritize conflicts between signed instruments and later operational records. Work out the defensible position from the matter production and leave an audit-ready exception tracker and concise advice for the supervising lawyer. Keep confirmed conflicts separate from open questions, cite the records that actually control each conclusion, and do not fill gaps with outside facts.", "rubric": {"criteria": [{"category": "procedure", "description": "Complete at least 46 successful, argument-specific evidence and output calls.", "id": "procedure.minimum_successful_tool_calls"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Find and read the 33 controlling, corroborating, and work-product-control records in full.", "id": "procedure.all_evidence_read_in_full"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Inspect file metadata for the eight designated critical primary records before relying on them.", "id": "procedure.chain_of_custody_metadata_checked"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Confirm the sandbox's allowed document and output roots.", "id": "procedure.allowed_directories_checked"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Inventory all 96 records so the relevant sources are discovered among the context records.", "id": "procedure.recursive_inventory_completed"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Search the production for email evidence that may corroborate or contradict formal records.", "id": "procedure.targeted_search_completed"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Leave only findings.json and advice.md in the output workspace.", "id": "procedure.exact_deliverable_set"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Create both final work products through the sandbox MCP surface.", "id": "procedure.deliverables_written_through_mcp"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Produce findings.json as a valid JSON object.", "id": "findings.findings_is_object"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Report exactly 16 confirmed exceptions.", "id": "findings.findings_exact_count"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Use each stable finding ID exactly once.", "id": "findings.finding_ids_unique"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set schema_version to the released matter value '1.0'.", "id": "findings.top_level_schema_version"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set task_id to the released matter value 'cb100-081-aperture-robotics'.", "id": "findings.top_level_task_id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set matter_number to the released matter value 'CB-IP-3201'.", "id": "findings.top_level_matter_number"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set prepared_for to the released matter value 'Aperture Robotics, Inc.'.", "id": "findings.top_level_prepared_for"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set as_of to the released matter value '2026-09-04'.", "id": "findings.top_level_as_of"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-01 exception for inventor assignment gap.", "id": "findings.F-01.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's id from /workspace/documents/01_patents/001_patents_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_open_source/049_open_source_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's issue from /workspace/documents/01_patents/001_patents_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_open_source/049_open_source_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's severity from /workspace/documents/01_patents/001_patents_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_open_source/049_open_source_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's primary_source from /workspace/documents/01_patents/001_patents_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_open_source/049_open_source_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/01_patents/001_patents_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_open_source/049_open_source_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-01 using the exact controlled facts ['2025-11-05', 'CB-IP-3201-A766', '2025-12-12', 'CB-IP-3201-J774'].", "id": "findings.F-01.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-01's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-01.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-04', 'Micah Sullivan'] for F-01.", "id": "findings.F-01.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-02 exception for recorded-owner mismatch.", "id": "findings.F-02.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's id from /workspace/documents/01_patents/004_patents_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_open_source/052_open_source_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's issue from /workspace/documents/01_patents/004_patents_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_open_source/052_open_source_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's severity from /workspace/documents/01_patents/004_patents_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_open_source/052_open_source_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's primary_source from /workspace/documents/01_patents/004_patents_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_open_source/052_open_source_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/01_patents/004_patents_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_open_source/052_open_source_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-02 using the exact controlled facts ['$5,809,469.00', '$5,865,438.00'].", "id": "findings.F-02.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-02's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-02.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-04', 'Farah Ibrahim'] for F-02.", "id": "findings.F-02.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-03 exception for maintenance-fee deadline.", "id": "findings.F-03.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's id from /workspace/documents/01_patents/007_patents_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_open_source/055_open_source_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's issue from /workspace/documents/01_patents/007_patents_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_open_source/055_open_source_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's severity from /workspace/documents/01_patents/007_patents_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_open_source/055_open_source_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's primary_source from /workspace/documents/01_patents/007_patents_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_open_source/055_open_source_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/01_patents/007_patents_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_open_source/055_open_source_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-03 using the exact controlled facts ['Willa Novak', 'Caleb Hassan'].", "id": "findings.F-03.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-03's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-03.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-04', 'Owen Delgado'] for F-03.", "id": "findings.F-03.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-04 exception for foreign-filing restriction.", "id": "findings.F-04.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's id from /workspace/documents/02_trademarks/010_trademarks_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_domain_accounts/058_domain_accounts_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's issue from /workspace/documents/02_trademarks/010_trademarks_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_domain_accounts/058_domain_accounts_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's severity from /workspace/documents/02_trademarks/010_trademarks_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_domain_accounts/058_domain_accounts_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's primary_source from /workspace/documents/02_trademarks/010_trademarks_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_domain_accounts/058_domain_accounts_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/02_trademarks/010_trademarks_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_domain_accounts/058_domain_accounts_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-04 using the exact controlled facts ['closed without exception', 'CB-IP-3201-D452', 'open and escalated', 'CB-IP-3201-M404'].", "id": "findings.F-04.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-04's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-04.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-04', 'Lena Varga'] for F-04.", "id": "findings.F-04.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-05 exception for trademark specimen issue.", "id": "findings.F-05.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's id from /workspace/documents/02_trademarks/013_trademarks_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_domain_accounts/061_domain_accounts_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's issue from /workspace/documents/02_trademarks/013_trademarks_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_domain_accounts/061_domain_accounts_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's severity from /workspace/documents/02_trademarks/013_trademarks_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_domain_accounts/061_domain_accounts_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's primary_source from /workspace/documents/02_trademarks/013_trademarks_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_domain_accounts/061_domain_accounts_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/02_trademarks/013_trademarks_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_domain_accounts/061_domain_accounts_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-05 using the exact controlled facts ['United States Patent and Trademark Office', 'Delaware'].", "id": "findings.F-05.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-05's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-05.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-04', 'Samuel Kim'] for F-05.", "id": "findings.F-05.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-06 exception for coexistence restriction.", "id": "findings.F-06.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's id from /workspace/documents/02_trademarks/016_trademarks_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_domain_accounts/064_domain_accounts_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's issue from /workspace/documents/02_trademarks/016_trademarks_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_domain_accounts/064_domain_accounts_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's severity from /workspace/documents/02_trademarks/016_trademarks_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_domain_accounts/064_domain_accounts_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's primary_source from /workspace/documents/02_trademarks/016_trademarks_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_domain_accounts/064_domain_accounts_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/02_trademarks/016_trademarks_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_domain_accounts/064_domain_accounts_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-06 using the exact controlled facts ['10%', '12%'].", "id": "findings.F-06.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-06's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-06.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-04', 'Maya Ellison'] for F-06.", "id": "findings.F-06.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-07 exception for work-for-hire defect.", "id": "findings.F-07.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's id from /workspace/documents/03_copyrights/019_copyrights_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_development_records/067_development_records_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's issue from /workspace/documents/03_copyrights/019_copyrights_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_development_records/067_development_records_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's severity from /workspace/documents/03_copyrights/019_copyrights_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_development_records/067_development_records_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's primary_source from /workspace/documents/03_copyrights/019_copyrights_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_development_records/067_development_records_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/03_copyrights/019_copyrights_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_development_records/067_development_records_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-07 using the exact controlled facts ['notices-aperture_robotics_inc@example.test', 'archive-founding_engineer_group@example.test'].", "id": "findings.F-07.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-07's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-07.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-04', 'Rafael Okafor'] for F-07.", "id": "findings.F-07.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-08 exception for source-code ownership gap.", "id": "findings.F-08.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's id from /workspace/documents/03_copyrights/022_copyrights_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_development_records/070_development_records_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's issue from /workspace/documents/03_copyrights/022_copyrights_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_development_records/070_development_records_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's severity from /workspace/documents/03_copyrights/022_copyrights_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_development_records/070_development_records_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's primary_source from /workspace/documents/03_copyrights/022_copyrights_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_development_records/070_development_records_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/03_copyrights/022_copyrights_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_development_records/070_development_records_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-08 using the exact controlled facts ['77 records', '2025-06-21', '64 records', '2025-07-27'].", "id": "findings.F-08.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-08's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-08.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-04', 'Nora Chen'] for F-08.", "id": "findings.F-08.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-09 exception for inbound-license field restriction.", "id": "findings.F-09.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's id from /workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/025_invention_assignments_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_disputes/073_disputes_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's issue from /workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/025_invention_assignments_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_disputes/073_disputes_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's severity from /workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/025_invention_assignments_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_disputes/073_disputes_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's primary_source from /workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/025_invention_assignments_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_disputes/073_disputes_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/025_invention_assignments_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_disputes/073_disputes_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-09 using the exact controlled facts ['2025-05-20', 'CB-IP-3201-I357', '2025-06-12', 'CB-IP-3201-R535'].", "id": "findings.F-09.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-09's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-09.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-04', 'Dominic Alvarez'] for F-09.", "id": "findings.F-09.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-10 exception for outbound sublicense overreach.", "id": "findings.F-10.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's id from /workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/028_invention_assignments_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_disputes/076_disputes_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's issue from /workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/028_invention_assignments_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_disputes/076_disputes_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's severity from /workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/028_invention_assignments_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_disputes/076_disputes_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's primary_source from /workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/028_invention_assignments_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_disputes/076_disputes_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/028_invention_assignments_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_disputes/076_disputes_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-10 using the exact controlled facts ['$4,177,342.00', '$4,211,184.00'].", "id": "findings.F-10.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-10's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-10.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-04', 'Priya Raman'] for F-10.", "id": "findings.F-10.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-11 exception for copyleft distribution trigger.", "id": "findings.F-11.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's id from /workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/031_invention_assignments_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_disputes/079_disputes_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's issue from /workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/031_invention_assignments_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_disputes/079_disputes_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's severity from /workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/031_invention_assignments_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_disputes/079_disputes_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's primary_source from /workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/031_invention_assignments_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_disputes/079_disputes_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/031_invention_assignments_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_disputes/079_disputes_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-11 using the exact controlled facts ['Willa Novak', 'Rafael Okafor'].", "id": "findings.F-11.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-11's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-11.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-04', 'Elliot Mercer'] for F-11.", "id": "findings.F-11.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-12 exception for notice-file omission.", "id": "findings.F-12.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's id from /workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/034_licenses_in_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_maintenance/082_maintenance_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's issue from /workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/034_licenses_in_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_maintenance/082_maintenance_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's severity from /workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/034_licenses_in_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_maintenance/082_maintenance_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's primary_source from /workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/034_licenses_in_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_maintenance/082_maintenance_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/034_licenses_in_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_maintenance/082_maintenance_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-12 using the exact controlled facts ['closed without exception', 'CB-IP-3201-L689', 'open and escalated', 'CB-IP-3201-U283'].", "id": "findings.F-12.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-12's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-12.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-04', 'Talia Brooks'] for F-12.", "id": "findings.F-12.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-13 exception for domain registrant mismatch.", "id": "findings.F-13.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's id from /workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/037_licenses_in_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_maintenance/085_maintenance_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's issue from /workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/037_licenses_in_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_maintenance/085_maintenance_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's severity from /workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/037_licenses_in_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_maintenance/085_maintenance_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's primary_source from /workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/037_licenses_in_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_maintenance/085_maintenance_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/037_licenses_in_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_maintenance/085_maintenance_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-13 using the exact controlled facts ['United States Patent and Trademark Office', 'Delaware'].", "id": "findings.F-13.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-13's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-13.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-04', 'Jonas Feld'] for F-13.", "id": "findings.F-13.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-14 exception for repository access anomaly.", "id": "findings.F-14.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's id from /workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/040_licenses_in_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_maintenance/088_maintenance_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's issue from /workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/040_licenses_in_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_maintenance/088_maintenance_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's severity from /workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/040_licenses_in_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_maintenance/088_maintenance_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's primary_source from /workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/040_licenses_in_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_maintenance/088_maintenance_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/040_licenses_in_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_maintenance/088_maintenance_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-14 using the exact controlled facts ['10%', '14%'].", "id": "findings.F-14.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-14's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-14.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-04', 'Mei Whitaker'] for F-14.", "id": "findings.F-14.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-15 exception for cease-and-desist deadline.", "id": "findings.F-15.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's id from /workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/043_licenses_out_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_security_interests/091_security_interests_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's issue from /workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/043_licenses_out_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_security_interests/091_security_interests_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's severity from /workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/043_licenses_out_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_security_interests/091_security_interests_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's primary_source from /workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/043_licenses_out_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_security_interests/091_security_interests_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/043_licenses_out_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_security_interests/091_security_interests_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-15 using the exact controlled facts ['notices-aperture_robotics_inc@example.test', 'archive-founding_engineer_group@example.test'].", "id": "findings.F-15.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-15's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-15.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-04', 'Caleb Hassan'] for F-15.", "id": "findings.F-15.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-16 exception for security-interest release gap.", "id": "findings.F-16.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's id from /workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/046_licenses_out_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_security_interests/094_security_interests_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's issue from /workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/046_licenses_out_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_security_interests/094_security_interests_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's severity from /workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/046_licenses_out_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_security_interests/094_security_interests_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's primary_source from /workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/046_licenses_out_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_security_interests/094_security_interests_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/046_licenses_out_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_security_interests/094_security_interests_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-16 using the exact controlled facts ['94 records', '2025-11-25', '54 records', '2025-12-21'].", "id": "findings.F-16.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-16's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-16.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-04', 'Leona Park'] for F-16.", "id": "findings.F-16.action_anchors"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Executive assessment' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Executive assessment"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Method and record coverage' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Method and record coverage"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Findings' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Findings"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Recommended next actions' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Recommended next actions"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Assumptions and limitations' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Assumptions and limitations"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-01 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-01"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-02 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-02"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-03 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-03"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-04 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-04"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-05 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-05"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-06 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-06"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-07 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-07"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-08 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-08"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-09 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-09"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-10 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-10"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-11 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-11"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-12 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-12"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-13 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-13"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-14 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-14"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-15 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-15"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-16 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-16"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Do not claim the production has no issues or that every record is consistent.", "id": "memo.forbidden_claims_absent"}], "decision_options": [{"id": "cross-source-reconciliation", "label": "Reconcile controlling and corroborating records", "reason": "The CB-IP-3201 production contains independently maintained records; a defensible answer must preserve each supported conflict and its cure owner.", "selected": true}, {"id": "latest-record-controls", "label": "Treat the latest record as controlling", "reason": "Timestamp recency does not establish legal priority, execution, or approval authority.", "selected": false}, {"id": "primary-records-only", "label": "Report primary records without reconciliation", "reason": "Primary records alone conceal the operational conflicts that create the actionable exceptions.", "selected": false}], "gates": ["all_evidence_read_in_full", "chain_of_custody_metadata_checked", "findings_criteria_complete", "memo_criteria_complete", "deliverables_written_through_mcp"], "metadata_checks": 8, "metric": "weighted_criteria_score", "minimum_tool_calls": 46, "required_deliverables": ["findings.json", "advice.md"], "required_document_reads": 33, "type": "deterministic", "weights": {"findings": 0.55, "memo": 0.2, "procedure": 0.25}}, "task_id": "cb100-081-aperture-robotics", "task_name": "Aperture robotics chain-of-title review", "world_id": "counselbench-filesystem-mcp-v2"}
-{"context_files": ["task_files/cb100-082-blue-fern/01_patents/001_patents_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-082-blue-fern/01_patents/002_patents_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-082-blue-fern/01_patents/003_patents_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-082-blue-fern/01_patents/004_patents_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-082-blue-fern/01_patents/005_patents_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-082-blue-fern/01_patents/006_patents_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-082-blue-fern/01_patents/007_patents_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-082-blue-fern/01_patents/008_patents_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-082-blue-fern/02_trademarks/009_trademarks_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-082-blue-fern/02_trademarks/010_trademarks_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-082-blue-fern/02_trademarks/011_trademarks_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-082-blue-fern/02_trademarks/012_trademarks_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-082-blue-fern/02_trademarks/013_trademarks_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-082-blue-fern/02_trademarks/014_trademarks_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-082-blue-fern/02_trademarks/015_trademarks_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-082-blue-fern/02_trademarks/016_trademarks_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-082-blue-fern/03_copyrights/017_copyrights_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-082-blue-fern/03_copyrights/018_copyrights_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-082-blue-fern/03_copyrights/019_copyrights_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-082-blue-fern/03_copyrights/020_copyrights_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-082-blue-fern/03_copyrights/021_copyrights_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-082-blue-fern/03_copyrights/022_copyrights_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-082-blue-fern/03_copyrights/023_copyrights_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-082-blue-fern/03_copyrights/024_copyrights_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-082-blue-fern/04_invention_assignments/025_invention_assignments_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-082-blue-fern/04_invention_assignments/026_invention_assignments_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-082-blue-fern/04_invention_assignments/027_invention_assignments_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-082-blue-fern/04_invention_assignments/028_invention_assignments_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-082-blue-fern/04_invention_assignments/029_invention_assignments_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-082-blue-fern/04_invention_assignments/030_invention_assignments_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-082-blue-fern/04_invention_assignments/031_invention_assignments_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-082-blue-fern/04_invention_assignments/032_invention_assignments_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-082-blue-fern/05_licenses_in/033_licenses_in_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-082-blue-fern/05_licenses_in/034_licenses_in_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-082-blue-fern/05_licenses_in/035_licenses_in_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-082-blue-fern/05_licenses_in/036_licenses_in_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-082-blue-fern/05_licenses_in/037_licenses_in_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-082-blue-fern/05_licenses_in/038_licenses_in_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-082-blue-fern/05_licenses_in/039_licenses_in_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-082-blue-fern/05_licenses_in/040_licenses_in_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-082-blue-fern/06_licenses_out/041_licenses_out_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-082-blue-fern/06_licenses_out/042_licenses_out_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-082-blue-fern/06_licenses_out/043_licenses_out_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-082-blue-fern/06_licenses_out/044_licenses_out_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-082-blue-fern/06_licenses_out/045_licenses_out_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-082-blue-fern/06_licenses_out/046_licenses_out_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-082-blue-fern/06_licenses_out/047_licenses_out_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-082-blue-fern/06_licenses_out/048_licenses_out_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-082-blue-fern/07_open_source/049_open_source_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-082-blue-fern/07_open_source/050_open_source_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-082-blue-fern/07_open_source/051_open_source_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-082-blue-fern/07_open_source/052_open_source_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-082-blue-fern/07_open_source/053_open_source_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-082-blue-fern/07_open_source/054_open_source_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-082-blue-fern/07_open_source/055_open_source_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-082-blue-fern/07_open_source/056_open_source_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-082-blue-fern/08_domain_accounts/057_domain_accounts_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-082-blue-fern/08_domain_accounts/058_domain_accounts_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-082-blue-fern/08_domain_accounts/059_domain_accounts_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-082-blue-fern/08_domain_accounts/060_domain_accounts_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-082-blue-fern/08_domain_accounts/061_domain_accounts_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-082-blue-fern/08_domain_accounts/062_domain_accounts_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-082-blue-fern/08_domain_accounts/063_domain_accounts_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-082-blue-fern/08_domain_accounts/064_domain_accounts_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-082-blue-fern/09_development_records/065_development_records_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-082-blue-fern/09_development_records/066_development_records_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-082-blue-fern/09_development_records/067_development_records_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-082-blue-fern/09_development_records/068_development_records_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-082-blue-fern/09_development_records/069_development_records_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-082-blue-fern/09_development_records/070_development_records_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-082-blue-fern/09_development_records/071_development_records_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-082-blue-fern/09_development_records/072_development_records_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-082-blue-fern/10_disputes/073_disputes_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-082-blue-fern/10_disputes/074_disputes_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-082-blue-fern/10_disputes/075_disputes_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-082-blue-fern/10_disputes/076_disputes_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-082-blue-fern/10_disputes/077_disputes_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-082-blue-fern/10_disputes/078_disputes_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-082-blue-fern/10_disputes/079_disputes_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-082-blue-fern/10_disputes/080_disputes_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-082-blue-fern/11_maintenance/081_maintenance_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-082-blue-fern/11_maintenance/082_maintenance_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-082-blue-fern/11_maintenance/083_maintenance_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-082-blue-fern/11_maintenance/084_maintenance_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-082-blue-fern/11_maintenance/085_maintenance_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-082-blue-fern/11_maintenance/086_maintenance_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-082-blue-fern/11_maintenance/087_maintenance_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-082-blue-fern/11_maintenance/088_maintenance_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-082-blue-fern/12_security_interests/089_security_interests_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-082-blue-fern/12_security_interests/090_security_interests_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-082-blue-fern/12_security_interests/091_security_interests_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-082-blue-fern/12_security_interests/092_security_interests_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-082-blue-fern/12_security_interests/093_security_interests_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-082-blue-fern/12_security_interests/094_security_interests_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-082-blue-fern/12_security_interests/095_security_interests_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-082-blue-fern/12_security_interests/096_security_interests_status_report.md"], "gold_output": {"advice_markdown": "# Counsel advice — Blue Fern brand portfolio audit\n\n## Executive assessment\n\nFor Blue Fern Beverages matter CB-IP-3202, the review identified 16 source-supported exceptions requiring action before 2026-09-08. The assessment concerns Fern & Field Cooperative and the supplied record for California.\n\n## Method and record coverage\n\nThe review inventoried all 96 production files, read the 33 controlling, corroborating, and control records, searched the email exports, and checked metadata for the designated chain-of-custody sample. Conclusions are limited to the synthetic production supplied for this benchmark matter.\n\n## Findings\n\n### F-01 — inventor assignment gap (critical)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for inventor assignment gap: one source states the operative date is 2025-04-05 under control reference CB-IP-3202-A192, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2025-04-28 under response reference CB-IP-3202-J591.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/01_patents/001_patents_control_register.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/07_open_source/049_open_source_control_register.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-08, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Farah Ibrahim.\n\n### F-02 — recorded-owner mismatch (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for recorded-owner mismatch: one source states the controlling amount is $1,542,516.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $1,731,532.00.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/01_patents/004_patents_ledger_export.csv`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/07_open_source/052_open_source_ledger_export.csv`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-08, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Owen Delgado.\n\n### F-03 — maintenance-fee deadline (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for maintenance-fee deadline: one source states approval is attributed to Theo Laurent as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Isaac Romero and contains no entry for Theo Laurent.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/01_patents/007_patents_officer_certificate.html`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/07_open_source/055_open_source_officer_certificate.html`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-08, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Lena Varga.\n\n### F-04 — foreign-filing restriction (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for foreign-filing restriction: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-IP-3202-D537, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-IP-3202-M687.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/02_trademarks/010_trademarks_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/08_domain_accounts/058_domain_accounts_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-08, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Samuel Kim.\n\n### F-05 — trademark specimen issue (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for trademark specimen issue: one source states the applicable location is Trademark Trial and Appeal Board, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to California operations outside Trademark Trial and Appeal Board.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/02_trademarks/013_trademarks_review_memorandum.json`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/08_domain_accounts/061_domain_accounts_review_memorandum.json`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-08, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Maya Ellison.\n\n### F-06 — coexistence restriction (low)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for coexistence restriction: one source states the threshold is 5% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 10% and produced a different exception result.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/02_trademarks/016_trademarks_status_report.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/08_domain_accounts/064_domain_accounts_status_report.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-08, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Rafael Okafor.\n\n### F-07 — work-for-hire defect (critical)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for work-for-hire defect: one source states formal notice must use notices-blue_fern_beverages@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-fern_field_cooperative@example.test.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/03_copyrights/019_copyrights_correspondence.eml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/09_development_records/067_development_records_correspondence.eml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-08, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Nora Chen.\n\n### F-08 — source-code ownership gap (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for source-code ownership gap: one source states the governed population contains 157 records through 2025-09-09, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 46 records through 2025-09-27.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/03_copyrights/022_copyrights_formal_notice.xml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/09_development_records/070_development_records_formal_notice.xml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-08, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Dominic Alvarez.\n\n### F-09 — inbound-license field restriction (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for inbound-license field restriction: one source states the operative date is 2025-01-13 under control reference CB-IP-3202-I590, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2025-02-27 under response reference CB-IP-3202-R137.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/025_invention_assignments_control_register.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/10_disputes/073_disputes_control_register.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-08, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Priya Raman.\n\n### F-10 — outbound sublicense overreach (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for outbound sublicense overreach: one source states the controlling amount is $226,709.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $249,918.00.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/028_invention_assignments_ledger_export.csv`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/10_disputes/076_disputes_ledger_export.csv`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-08, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Elliot Mercer.\n\n### F-11 — copyleft distribution trigger (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for copyleft distribution trigger: one source states approval is attributed to Theo Laurent as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Dominic Alvarez and contains no entry for Theo Laurent.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/031_invention_assignments_officer_certificate.html`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/10_disputes/079_disputes_officer_certificate.html`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-08, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Talia Brooks.\n\n### F-12 — notice-file omission (low)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for notice-file omission: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-IP-3202-L982, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-IP-3202-U167.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/034_licenses_in_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/11_maintenance/082_maintenance_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-08, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Jonas Feld.\n\n### F-13 — domain registrant mismatch (critical)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for domain registrant mismatch: one source states the applicable location is Trademark Trial and Appeal Board, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to California operations outside Trademark Trial and Appeal Board.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/037_licenses_in_review_memorandum.json`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/11_maintenance/085_maintenance_review_memorandum.json`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-08, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Mei Whitaker.\n\n### F-14 — repository access anomaly (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for repository access anomaly: one source states the threshold is 6% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 8% and produced a different exception result.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/040_licenses_in_status_report.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/11_maintenance/088_maintenance_status_report.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-08, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Caleb Hassan.\n\n### F-15 — cease-and-desist deadline (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for cease-and-desist deadline: one source states formal notice must use notices-blue_fern_beverages@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-fern_field_cooperative@example.test.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/043_licenses_out_correspondence.eml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/091_security_interests_correspondence.eml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-08, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Leona Park.\n\n### F-16 — security-interest release gap (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for security-interest release gap: one source states the governed population contains 98 records through 2025-07-12, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 72 records through 2025-08-25.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/046_licenses_out_formal_notice.xml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/094_security_interests_formal_notice.xml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-08, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Isaac Romero.\n\n## Recommended next actions\n\nSequence the critical and high findings first, assign the named owners, preserve the cited records, and document any resolution in the controlling matter register before the stated deadline.\n\n## Assumptions and limitations\n\nThis analysis is confined to task cb100-082-blue-fern and the supplied synthetic evidence. It does not rely on external facts, does not resolve disputed law, and is not legal advice for a real person or entity.\n", "findings": {"as_of": "2026-09-08", "findings": [{"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/07_open_source/049_open_source_control_register.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for inventor assignment gap: one source states the operative date is 2025-04-05 under control reference CB-IP-3202-A192, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2025-04-28 under response reference CB-IP-3202-J591.", "id": "F-01", "issue": "inventor assignment gap", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/01_patents/001_patents_control_register.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-08, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Farah Ibrahim.", "severity": "critical"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/07_open_source/052_open_source_ledger_export.csv", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for recorded-owner mismatch: one source states the controlling amount is $1,542,516.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $1,731,532.00.", "id": "F-02", "issue": "recorded-owner mismatch", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/01_patents/004_patents_ledger_export.csv", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-08, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Owen Delgado.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/07_open_source/055_open_source_officer_certificate.html", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for maintenance-fee deadline: one source states approval is attributed to Theo Laurent as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Isaac Romero and contains no entry for Theo Laurent.", "id": "F-03", "issue": "maintenance-fee deadline", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/01_patents/007_patents_officer_certificate.html", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-08, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Lena Varga.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/08_domain_accounts/058_domain_accounts_executed_instrument.txt", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for foreign-filing restriction: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-IP-3202-D537, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-IP-3202-M687.", "id": "F-04", "issue": "foreign-filing restriction", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/02_trademarks/010_trademarks_executed_instrument.txt", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-08, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Samuel Kim.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/08_domain_accounts/061_domain_accounts_review_memorandum.json", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for trademark specimen issue: one source states the applicable location is Trademark Trial and Appeal Board, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to California operations outside Trademark Trial and Appeal Board.", "id": "F-05", "issue": "trademark specimen issue", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/02_trademarks/013_trademarks_review_memorandum.json", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-08, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Maya Ellison.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/08_domain_accounts/064_domain_accounts_status_report.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for coexistence restriction: one source states the threshold is 5% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 10% and produced a different exception result.", "id": "F-06", "issue": "coexistence restriction", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/02_trademarks/016_trademarks_status_report.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-08, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Rafael Okafor.", "severity": "low"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/09_development_records/067_development_records_correspondence.eml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for work-for-hire defect: one source states formal notice must use notices-blue_fern_beverages@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-fern_field_cooperative@example.test.", "id": "F-07", "issue": "work-for-hire defect", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/03_copyrights/019_copyrights_correspondence.eml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-08, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Nora Chen.", "severity": "critical"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/09_development_records/070_development_records_formal_notice.xml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for source-code ownership gap: one source states the governed population contains 157 records through 2025-09-09, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 46 records through 2025-09-27.", "id": "F-08", "issue": "source-code ownership gap", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/03_copyrights/022_copyrights_formal_notice.xml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-08, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Dominic Alvarez.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/10_disputes/073_disputes_control_register.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for inbound-license field restriction: one source states the operative date is 2025-01-13 under control reference CB-IP-3202-I590, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2025-02-27 under response reference CB-IP-3202-R137.", "id": "F-09", "issue": "inbound-license field restriction", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/025_invention_assignments_control_register.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-08, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Priya Raman.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/10_disputes/076_disputes_ledger_export.csv", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for outbound sublicense overreach: one source states the controlling amount is $226,709.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $249,918.00.", "id": "F-10", "issue": "outbound sublicense overreach", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/028_invention_assignments_ledger_export.csv", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-08, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Elliot Mercer.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/10_disputes/079_disputes_officer_certificate.html", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for copyleft distribution trigger: one source states approval is attributed to Theo Laurent as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Dominic Alvarez and contains no entry for Theo Laurent.", "id": "F-11", "issue": "copyleft distribution trigger", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/031_invention_assignments_officer_certificate.html", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-08, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Talia Brooks.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/11_maintenance/082_maintenance_executed_instrument.txt", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for notice-file omission: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-IP-3202-L982, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-IP-3202-U167.", "id": "F-12", "issue": "notice-file omission", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/034_licenses_in_executed_instrument.txt", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-08, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Jonas Feld.", "severity": "low"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/11_maintenance/085_maintenance_review_memorandum.json", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for domain registrant mismatch: one source states the applicable location is Trademark Trial and Appeal Board, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to California operations outside Trademark Trial and Appeal Board.", "id": "F-13", "issue": "domain registrant mismatch", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/037_licenses_in_review_memorandum.json", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-08, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Mei Whitaker.", "severity": "critical"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/11_maintenance/088_maintenance_status_report.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for repository access anomaly: one source states the threshold is 6% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 8% and produced a different exception result.", "id": "F-14", "issue": "repository access anomaly", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/040_licenses_in_status_report.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-08, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Caleb Hassan.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/091_security_interests_correspondence.eml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for cease-and-desist deadline: one source states formal notice must use notices-blue_fern_beverages@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-fern_field_cooperative@example.test.", "id": "F-15", "issue": "cease-and-desist deadline", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/043_licenses_out_correspondence.eml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-08, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Leona Park.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/094_security_interests_formal_notice.xml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for security-interest release gap: one source states the governed population contains 98 records through 2025-07-12, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 72 records through 2025-08-25.", "id": "F-16", "issue": "security-interest release gap", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/046_licenses_out_formal_notice.xml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-08, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Isaac Romero.", "severity": "medium"}], "matter_number": "CB-IP-3202", "prepared_for": "Blue Fern Beverages", "schema_version": "1.0", "task_id": "cb100-082-blue-fern"}}, "metadata": {"benchmark": "CounselBench-100", "code_license": "Apache-2.0", "data_license": "CC-BY-4.0", "deadline": "2026-09-08", "document_count": 96, "jurisdiction": "California", "matter_number": "CB-IP-3202", "mcp_commit": "9a96ea6e5913736f92b88345bf51caeaaa8e719f", "mcp_package": "@modelcontextprotocol/server-filesystem@2026.7.10", "practice_area": "ip-technology", "reference_tool_calls": 46, "required_evidence_reads": 33, "synthetic": true, "venue": "Trademark Trial and Appeal Board", "version": "2.0.0"}, "prompt": "You are intellectual-property counsel for Blue Fern Beverages. A late document production changed the factual picture, and the matter team needs the entire record reconciled from first principles. A beverage rebrand faces specimen, coexistence, domain, and distributor-license records with conflicting territorial limits. Decision due 2026-09-08. California law governs; Trademark Trial and Appeal Board is the forum. Separate confirmed exceptions from items that merely require follow-up. Work out the defensible position from the matter production and leave an audit-ready exception tracker and concise advice for the supervising lawyer. Keep confirmed conflicts separate from open questions, cite the records that actually control each conclusion, and do not fill gaps with outside facts.", "rubric": {"criteria": [{"category": "procedure", "description": "Complete at least 46 successful, argument-specific evidence and output calls.", "id": "procedure.minimum_successful_tool_calls"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Find and read the 33 controlling, corroborating, and work-product-control records in full.", "id": "procedure.all_evidence_read_in_full"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Inspect file metadata for the eight designated critical primary records before relying on them.", "id": "procedure.chain_of_custody_metadata_checked"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Confirm the sandbox's allowed document and output roots.", "id": "procedure.allowed_directories_checked"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Inventory all 96 records so the relevant sources are discovered among the context records.", "id": "procedure.recursive_inventory_completed"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Search the production for email evidence that may corroborate or contradict formal records.", "id": "procedure.targeted_search_completed"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Leave only findings.json and advice.md in the output workspace.", "id": "procedure.exact_deliverable_set"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Create both final work products through the sandbox MCP surface.", "id": "procedure.deliverables_written_through_mcp"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Produce findings.json as a valid JSON object.", "id": "findings.findings_is_object"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Report exactly 16 confirmed exceptions.", "id": "findings.findings_exact_count"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Use each stable finding ID exactly once.", "id": "findings.finding_ids_unique"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set schema_version to the released matter value '1.0'.", "id": "findings.top_level_schema_version"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set task_id to the released matter value 'cb100-082-blue-fern'.", "id": "findings.top_level_task_id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set matter_number to the released matter value 'CB-IP-3202'.", "id": "findings.top_level_matter_number"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set prepared_for to the released matter value 'Blue Fern Beverages'.", "id": "findings.top_level_prepared_for"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set as_of to the released matter value '2026-09-08'.", "id": "findings.top_level_as_of"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-01 exception for inventor assignment gap.", "id": "findings.F-01.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's id from /workspace/documents/01_patents/001_patents_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_open_source/049_open_source_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's issue from /workspace/documents/01_patents/001_patents_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_open_source/049_open_source_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's severity from /workspace/documents/01_patents/001_patents_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_open_source/049_open_source_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's primary_source from /workspace/documents/01_patents/001_patents_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_open_source/049_open_source_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/01_patents/001_patents_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_open_source/049_open_source_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-01 using the exact controlled facts ['2025-04-05', 'CB-IP-3202-A192', '2025-04-28', 'CB-IP-3202-J591'].", "id": "findings.F-01.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-01's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-01.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-08', 'Farah Ibrahim'] for F-01.", "id": "findings.F-01.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-02 exception for recorded-owner mismatch.", "id": "findings.F-02.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's id from /workspace/documents/01_patents/004_patents_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_open_source/052_open_source_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's issue from /workspace/documents/01_patents/004_patents_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_open_source/052_open_source_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's severity from /workspace/documents/01_patents/004_patents_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_open_source/052_open_source_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's primary_source from /workspace/documents/01_patents/004_patents_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_open_source/052_open_source_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/01_patents/004_patents_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_open_source/052_open_source_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-02 using the exact controlled facts ['$1,542,516.00', '$1,731,532.00'].", "id": "findings.F-02.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-02's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-02.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-08', 'Owen Delgado'] for F-02.", "id": "findings.F-02.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-03 exception for maintenance-fee deadline.", "id": "findings.F-03.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's id from /workspace/documents/01_patents/007_patents_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_open_source/055_open_source_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's issue from /workspace/documents/01_patents/007_patents_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_open_source/055_open_source_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's severity from /workspace/documents/01_patents/007_patents_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_open_source/055_open_source_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's primary_source from /workspace/documents/01_patents/007_patents_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_open_source/055_open_source_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/01_patents/007_patents_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_open_source/055_open_source_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-03 using the exact controlled facts ['Theo Laurent', 'Isaac Romero'].", "id": "findings.F-03.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-03's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-03.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-08', 'Lena Varga'] for F-03.", "id": "findings.F-03.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-04 exception for foreign-filing restriction.", "id": "findings.F-04.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's id from /workspace/documents/02_trademarks/010_trademarks_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_domain_accounts/058_domain_accounts_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's issue from /workspace/documents/02_trademarks/010_trademarks_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_domain_accounts/058_domain_accounts_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's severity from /workspace/documents/02_trademarks/010_trademarks_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_domain_accounts/058_domain_accounts_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's primary_source from /workspace/documents/02_trademarks/010_trademarks_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_domain_accounts/058_domain_accounts_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/02_trademarks/010_trademarks_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_domain_accounts/058_domain_accounts_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-04 using the exact controlled facts ['closed without exception', 'CB-IP-3202-D537', 'open and escalated', 'CB-IP-3202-M687'].", "id": "findings.F-04.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-04's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-04.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-08', 'Samuel Kim'] for F-04.", "id": "findings.F-04.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-05 exception for trademark specimen issue.", "id": "findings.F-05.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's id from /workspace/documents/02_trademarks/013_trademarks_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_domain_accounts/061_domain_accounts_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's issue from /workspace/documents/02_trademarks/013_trademarks_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_domain_accounts/061_domain_accounts_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's severity from /workspace/documents/02_trademarks/013_trademarks_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_domain_accounts/061_domain_accounts_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's primary_source from /workspace/documents/02_trademarks/013_trademarks_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_domain_accounts/061_domain_accounts_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/02_trademarks/013_trademarks_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_domain_accounts/061_domain_accounts_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-05 using the exact controlled facts ['Trademark Trial and Appeal Board', 'California'].", "id": "findings.F-05.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-05's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-05.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-08', 'Maya Ellison'] for F-05.", "id": "findings.F-05.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-06 exception for coexistence restriction.", "id": "findings.F-06.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's id from /workspace/documents/02_trademarks/016_trademarks_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_domain_accounts/064_domain_accounts_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's issue from /workspace/documents/02_trademarks/016_trademarks_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_domain_accounts/064_domain_accounts_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's severity from /workspace/documents/02_trademarks/016_trademarks_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_domain_accounts/064_domain_accounts_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's primary_source from /workspace/documents/02_trademarks/016_trademarks_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_domain_accounts/064_domain_accounts_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/02_trademarks/016_trademarks_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_domain_accounts/064_domain_accounts_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-06 using the exact controlled facts ['5%', '10%'].", "id": "findings.F-06.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-06's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-06.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-08', 'Rafael Okafor'] for F-06.", "id": "findings.F-06.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-07 exception for work-for-hire defect.", "id": "findings.F-07.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's id from /workspace/documents/03_copyrights/019_copyrights_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_development_records/067_development_records_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's issue from /workspace/documents/03_copyrights/019_copyrights_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_development_records/067_development_records_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's severity from /workspace/documents/03_copyrights/019_copyrights_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_development_records/067_development_records_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's primary_source from /workspace/documents/03_copyrights/019_copyrights_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_development_records/067_development_records_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/03_copyrights/019_copyrights_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_development_records/067_development_records_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-07 using the exact controlled facts ['notices-blue_fern_beverages@example.test', 'archive-fern_field_cooperative@example.test'].", "id": "findings.F-07.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-07's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-07.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-08', 'Nora Chen'] for F-07.", "id": "findings.F-07.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-08 exception for source-code ownership gap.", "id": "findings.F-08.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's id from /workspace/documents/03_copyrights/022_copyrights_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_development_records/070_development_records_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's issue from /workspace/documents/03_copyrights/022_copyrights_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_development_records/070_development_records_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's severity from /workspace/documents/03_copyrights/022_copyrights_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_development_records/070_development_records_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's primary_source from /workspace/documents/03_copyrights/022_copyrights_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_development_records/070_development_records_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/03_copyrights/022_copyrights_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_development_records/070_development_records_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-08 using the exact controlled facts ['157 records', '2025-09-09', '46 records', '2025-09-27'].", "id": "findings.F-08.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-08's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-08.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-08', 'Dominic Alvarez'] for F-08.", "id": "findings.F-08.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-09 exception for inbound-license field restriction.", "id": "findings.F-09.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's id from /workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/025_invention_assignments_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_disputes/073_disputes_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's issue from /workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/025_invention_assignments_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_disputes/073_disputes_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's severity from /workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/025_invention_assignments_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_disputes/073_disputes_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's primary_source from /workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/025_invention_assignments_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_disputes/073_disputes_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/025_invention_assignments_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_disputes/073_disputes_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-09 using the exact controlled facts ['2025-01-13', 'CB-IP-3202-I590', '2025-02-27', 'CB-IP-3202-R137'].", "id": "findings.F-09.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-09's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-09.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-08', 'Priya Raman'] for F-09.", "id": "findings.F-09.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-10 exception for outbound sublicense overreach.", "id": "findings.F-10.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's id from /workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/028_invention_assignments_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_disputes/076_disputes_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's issue from /workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/028_invention_assignments_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_disputes/076_disputes_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's severity from /workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/028_invention_assignments_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_disputes/076_disputes_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's primary_source from /workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/028_invention_assignments_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_disputes/076_disputes_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/028_invention_assignments_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_disputes/076_disputes_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-10 using the exact controlled facts ['$226,709.00', '$249,918.00'].", "id": "findings.F-10.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-10's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-10.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-08', 'Elliot Mercer'] for F-10.", "id": "findings.F-10.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-11 exception for copyleft distribution trigger.", "id": "findings.F-11.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's id from /workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/031_invention_assignments_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_disputes/079_disputes_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's issue from /workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/031_invention_assignments_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_disputes/079_disputes_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's severity from /workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/031_invention_assignments_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_disputes/079_disputes_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's primary_source from /workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/031_invention_assignments_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_disputes/079_disputes_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/031_invention_assignments_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_disputes/079_disputes_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-11 using the exact controlled facts ['Theo Laurent', 'Dominic Alvarez'].", "id": "findings.F-11.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-11's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-11.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-08', 'Talia Brooks'] for F-11.", "id": "findings.F-11.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-12 exception for notice-file omission.", "id": "findings.F-12.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's id from /workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/034_licenses_in_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_maintenance/082_maintenance_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's issue from /workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/034_licenses_in_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_maintenance/082_maintenance_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's severity from /workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/034_licenses_in_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_maintenance/082_maintenance_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's primary_source from /workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/034_licenses_in_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_maintenance/082_maintenance_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/034_licenses_in_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_maintenance/082_maintenance_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-12 using the exact controlled facts ['closed without exception', 'CB-IP-3202-L982', 'open and escalated', 'CB-IP-3202-U167'].", "id": "findings.F-12.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-12's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-12.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-08', 'Jonas Feld'] for F-12.", "id": "findings.F-12.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-13 exception for domain registrant mismatch.", "id": "findings.F-13.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's id from /workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/037_licenses_in_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_maintenance/085_maintenance_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's issue from /workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/037_licenses_in_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_maintenance/085_maintenance_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's severity from /workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/037_licenses_in_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_maintenance/085_maintenance_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's primary_source from /workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/037_licenses_in_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_maintenance/085_maintenance_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/037_licenses_in_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_maintenance/085_maintenance_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-13 using the exact controlled facts ['Trademark Trial and Appeal Board', 'California'].", "id": "findings.F-13.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-13's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-13.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-08', 'Mei Whitaker'] for F-13.", "id": "findings.F-13.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-14 exception for repository access anomaly.", "id": "findings.F-14.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's id from /workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/040_licenses_in_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_maintenance/088_maintenance_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's issue from /workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/040_licenses_in_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_maintenance/088_maintenance_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's severity from /workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/040_licenses_in_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_maintenance/088_maintenance_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's primary_source from /workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/040_licenses_in_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_maintenance/088_maintenance_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/040_licenses_in_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_maintenance/088_maintenance_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-14 using the exact controlled facts ['6%', '8%'].", "id": "findings.F-14.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-14's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-14.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-08', 'Caleb Hassan'] for F-14.", "id": "findings.F-14.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-15 exception for cease-and-desist deadline.", "id": "findings.F-15.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's id from /workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/043_licenses_out_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_security_interests/091_security_interests_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's issue from /workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/043_licenses_out_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_security_interests/091_security_interests_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's severity from /workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/043_licenses_out_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_security_interests/091_security_interests_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's primary_source from /workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/043_licenses_out_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_security_interests/091_security_interests_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/043_licenses_out_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_security_interests/091_security_interests_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-15 using the exact controlled facts ['notices-blue_fern_beverages@example.test', 'archive-fern_field_cooperative@example.test'].", "id": "findings.F-15.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-15's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-15.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-08', 'Leona Park'] for F-15.", "id": "findings.F-15.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-16 exception for security-interest release gap.", "id": "findings.F-16.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's id from /workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/046_licenses_out_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_security_interests/094_security_interests_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's issue from /workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/046_licenses_out_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_security_interests/094_security_interests_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's severity from /workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/046_licenses_out_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_security_interests/094_security_interests_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's primary_source from /workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/046_licenses_out_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_security_interests/094_security_interests_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/046_licenses_out_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_security_interests/094_security_interests_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-16 using the exact controlled facts ['98 records', '2025-07-12', '72 records', '2025-08-25'].", "id": "findings.F-16.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-16's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-16.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-08', 'Isaac Romero'] for F-16.", "id": "findings.F-16.action_anchors"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Executive assessment' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Executive assessment"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Method and record coverage' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Method and record coverage"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Findings' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Findings"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Recommended next actions' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Recommended next actions"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Assumptions and limitations' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Assumptions and limitations"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-01 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-01"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-02 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-02"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-03 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-03"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-04 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-04"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-05 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-05"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-06 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-06"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-07 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-07"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-08 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-08"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-09 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-09"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-10 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-10"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-11 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-11"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-12 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-12"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-13 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-13"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-14 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-14"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-15 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-15"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-16 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-16"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Do not claim the production has no issues or that every record is consistent.", "id": "memo.forbidden_claims_absent"}], "decision_options": [{"id": "cross-source-reconciliation", "label": "Reconcile controlling and corroborating records", "reason": "The CB-IP-3202 production contains independently maintained records; a defensible answer must preserve each supported conflict and its cure owner.", "selected": true}, {"id": "latest-record-controls", "label": "Treat the latest record as controlling", "reason": "Timestamp recency does not establish legal priority, execution, or approval authority.", "selected": false}, {"id": "primary-records-only", "label": "Report primary records without reconciliation", "reason": "Primary records alone conceal the operational conflicts that create the actionable exceptions.", "selected": false}], "gates": ["all_evidence_read_in_full", "chain_of_custody_metadata_checked", "findings_criteria_complete", "memo_criteria_complete", "deliverables_written_through_mcp"], "metadata_checks": 8, "metric": "weighted_criteria_score", "minimum_tool_calls": 46, "required_deliverables": ["findings.json", "advice.md"], "required_document_reads": 33, "type": "deterministic", "weights": {"findings": 0.55, "memo": 0.2, "procedure": 0.25}}, "task_id": "cb100-082-blue-fern", "task_name": "Blue Fern brand portfolio audit", "world_id": "counselbench-filesystem-mcp-v2"}
-{"context_files": ["task_files/cb100-083-crux-mapping/01_patents/001_patents_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-083-crux-mapping/01_patents/002_patents_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-083-crux-mapping/01_patents/003_patents_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-083-crux-mapping/01_patents/004_patents_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-083-crux-mapping/01_patents/005_patents_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-083-crux-mapping/01_patents/006_patents_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-083-crux-mapping/01_patents/007_patents_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-083-crux-mapping/01_patents/008_patents_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-083-crux-mapping/02_trademarks/009_trademarks_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-083-crux-mapping/02_trademarks/010_trademarks_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-083-crux-mapping/02_trademarks/011_trademarks_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-083-crux-mapping/02_trademarks/012_trademarks_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-083-crux-mapping/02_trademarks/013_trademarks_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-083-crux-mapping/02_trademarks/014_trademarks_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-083-crux-mapping/02_trademarks/015_trademarks_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-083-crux-mapping/02_trademarks/016_trademarks_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-083-crux-mapping/03_copyrights/017_copyrights_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-083-crux-mapping/03_copyrights/018_copyrights_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-083-crux-mapping/03_copyrights/019_copyrights_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-083-crux-mapping/03_copyrights/020_copyrights_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-083-crux-mapping/03_copyrights/021_copyrights_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-083-crux-mapping/03_copyrights/022_copyrights_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-083-crux-mapping/03_copyrights/023_copyrights_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-083-crux-mapping/03_copyrights/024_copyrights_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-083-crux-mapping/04_invention_assignments/025_invention_assignments_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-083-crux-mapping/04_invention_assignments/026_invention_assignments_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-083-crux-mapping/04_invention_assignments/027_invention_assignments_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-083-crux-mapping/04_invention_assignments/028_invention_assignments_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-083-crux-mapping/04_invention_assignments/029_invention_assignments_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-083-crux-mapping/04_invention_assignments/030_invention_assignments_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-083-crux-mapping/04_invention_assignments/031_invention_assignments_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-083-crux-mapping/04_invention_assignments/032_invention_assignments_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-083-crux-mapping/05_licenses_in/033_licenses_in_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-083-crux-mapping/05_licenses_in/034_licenses_in_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-083-crux-mapping/05_licenses_in/035_licenses_in_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-083-crux-mapping/05_licenses_in/036_licenses_in_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-083-crux-mapping/05_licenses_in/037_licenses_in_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-083-crux-mapping/05_licenses_in/038_licenses_in_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-083-crux-mapping/05_licenses_in/039_licenses_in_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-083-crux-mapping/05_licenses_in/040_licenses_in_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-083-crux-mapping/06_licenses_out/041_licenses_out_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-083-crux-mapping/06_licenses_out/042_licenses_out_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-083-crux-mapping/06_licenses_out/043_licenses_out_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-083-crux-mapping/06_licenses_out/044_licenses_out_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-083-crux-mapping/06_licenses_out/045_licenses_out_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-083-crux-mapping/06_licenses_out/046_licenses_out_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-083-crux-mapping/06_licenses_out/047_licenses_out_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-083-crux-mapping/06_licenses_out/048_licenses_out_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-083-crux-mapping/07_open_source/049_open_source_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-083-crux-mapping/07_open_source/050_open_source_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-083-crux-mapping/07_open_source/051_open_source_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-083-crux-mapping/07_open_source/052_open_source_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-083-crux-mapping/07_open_source/053_open_source_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-083-crux-mapping/07_open_source/054_open_source_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-083-crux-mapping/07_open_source/055_open_source_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-083-crux-mapping/07_open_source/056_open_source_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-083-crux-mapping/08_domain_accounts/057_domain_accounts_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-083-crux-mapping/08_domain_accounts/058_domain_accounts_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-083-crux-mapping/08_domain_accounts/059_domain_accounts_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-083-crux-mapping/08_domain_accounts/060_domain_accounts_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-083-crux-mapping/08_domain_accounts/061_domain_accounts_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-083-crux-mapping/08_domain_accounts/062_domain_accounts_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-083-crux-mapping/08_domain_accounts/063_domain_accounts_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-083-crux-mapping/08_domain_accounts/064_domain_accounts_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-083-crux-mapping/09_development_records/065_development_records_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-083-crux-mapping/09_development_records/066_development_records_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-083-crux-mapping/09_development_records/067_development_records_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-083-crux-mapping/09_development_records/068_development_records_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-083-crux-mapping/09_development_records/069_development_records_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-083-crux-mapping/09_development_records/070_development_records_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-083-crux-mapping/09_development_records/071_development_records_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-083-crux-mapping/09_development_records/072_development_records_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-083-crux-mapping/10_disputes/073_disputes_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-083-crux-mapping/10_disputes/074_disputes_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-083-crux-mapping/10_disputes/075_disputes_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-083-crux-mapping/10_disputes/076_disputes_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-083-crux-mapping/10_disputes/077_disputes_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-083-crux-mapping/10_disputes/078_disputes_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-083-crux-mapping/10_disputes/079_disputes_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-083-crux-mapping/10_disputes/080_disputes_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-083-crux-mapping/11_maintenance/081_maintenance_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-083-crux-mapping/11_maintenance/082_maintenance_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-083-crux-mapping/11_maintenance/083_maintenance_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-083-crux-mapping/11_maintenance/084_maintenance_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-083-crux-mapping/11_maintenance/085_maintenance_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-083-crux-mapping/11_maintenance/086_maintenance_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-083-crux-mapping/11_maintenance/087_maintenance_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-083-crux-mapping/11_maintenance/088_maintenance_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-083-crux-mapping/12_security_interests/089_security_interests_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-083-crux-mapping/12_security_interests/090_security_interests_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-083-crux-mapping/12_security_interests/091_security_interests_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-083-crux-mapping/12_security_interests/092_security_interests_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-083-crux-mapping/12_security_interests/093_security_interests_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-083-crux-mapping/12_security_interests/094_security_interests_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-083-crux-mapping/12_security_interests/095_security_interests_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-083-crux-mapping/12_security_interests/096_security_interests_status_report.md"], "gold_output": {"advice_markdown": "# Counsel advice — Crux geospatial license review\n\n## Executive assessment\n\nFor Crux Mapping Systems matter CB-IP-3203, the review identified 16 source-supported exceptions requiring action before 2026-09-11. The assessment concerns National Terrain Archive and the supplied record for Virginia.\n\n## Method and record coverage\n\nThe review inventoried all 96 production files, read the 33 controlling, corroborating, and control records, searched the email exports, and checked metadata for the designated chain-of-custody sample. Conclusions are limited to the synthetic production supplied for this benchmark matter.\n\n## Findings\n\n### F-01 — inventor assignment gap (critical)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for inventor assignment gap: one source states the operative date is 2025-10-06 under control reference CB-IP-3203-A976, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2025-10-31 under response reference CB-IP-3203-J582.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/01_patents/001_patents_control_register.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/07_open_source/049_open_source_control_register.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-11, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Owen Delgado.\n\n### F-02 — recorded-owner mismatch (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for recorded-owner mismatch: one source states the controlling amount is $4,885,469.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $4,947,438.00.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/01_patents/004_patents_ledger_export.csv`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/07_open_source/052_open_source_ledger_export.csv`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-11, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Lena Varga.\n\n### F-03 — maintenance-fee deadline (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for maintenance-fee deadline: one source states approval is attributed to Amara Patel as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Adrian Mensah and contains no entry for Amara Patel.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/01_patents/007_patents_officer_certificate.html`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/07_open_source/055_open_source_officer_certificate.html`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-11, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Samuel Kim.\n\n### F-04 — foreign-filing restriction (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for foreign-filing restriction: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-IP-3203-D557, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-IP-3203-M689.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/02_trademarks/010_trademarks_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/08_domain_accounts/058_domain_accounts_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-11, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Maya Ellison.\n\n### F-05 — trademark specimen issue (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for trademark specimen issue: one source states the applicable location is Eastern District of Virginia, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to Virginia operations outside Eastern District of Virginia.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/02_trademarks/013_trademarks_review_memorandum.json`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/08_domain_accounts/061_domain_accounts_review_memorandum.json`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-11, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Rafael Okafor.\n\n### F-06 — coexistence restriction (low)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for coexistence restriction: one source states the threshold is 15% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 20% and produced a different exception result.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/02_trademarks/016_trademarks_status_report.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/08_domain_accounts/064_domain_accounts_status_report.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-11, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Nora Chen.\n\n### F-07 — work-for-hire defect (critical)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for work-for-hire defect: one source states formal notice must use notices-crux_mapping_systems@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-national_terrain_archive@example.test.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/03_copyrights/019_copyrights_correspondence.eml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/09_development_records/067_development_records_correspondence.eml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-11, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Dominic Alvarez.\n\n### F-08 — source-code ownership gap (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for source-code ownership gap: one source states the governed population contains 141 records through 2026-01-11, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 49 records through 2026-02-01.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/03_copyrights/022_copyrights_formal_notice.xml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/09_development_records/070_development_records_formal_notice.xml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-11, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Priya Raman.\n\n### F-09 — inbound-license field restriction (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for inbound-license field restriction: one source states the operative date is 2025-09-21 under control reference CB-IP-3203-I781, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2025-10-19 under response reference CB-IP-3203-R221.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/025_invention_assignments_control_register.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/10_disputes/073_disputes_control_register.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-11, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Elliot Mercer.\n\n### F-10 — outbound sublicense overreach (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for outbound sublicense overreach: one source states the controlling amount is $7,264,520.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $7,475,540.00.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/028_invention_assignments_ledger_export.csv`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/10_disputes/076_disputes_ledger_export.csv`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-11, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Talia Brooks.\n\n### F-11 — copyleft distribution trigger (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for copyleft distribution trigger: one source states approval is attributed to Amara Patel as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Elliot Mercer and contains no entry for Amara Patel.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/031_invention_assignments_officer_certificate.html`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/10_disputes/079_disputes_officer_certificate.html`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-11, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Jonas Feld.\n\n### F-12 — notice-file omission (low)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for notice-file omission: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-IP-3203-L203, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-IP-3203-U938.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/034_licenses_in_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/11_maintenance/082_maintenance_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-11, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Mei Whitaker.\n\n### F-13 — domain registrant mismatch (critical)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for domain registrant mismatch: one source states the applicable location is Eastern District of Virginia, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to Virginia operations outside Eastern District of Virginia.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/037_licenses_in_review_memorandum.json`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/11_maintenance/085_maintenance_review_memorandum.json`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-11, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Caleb Hassan.\n\n### F-14 — repository access anomaly (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for repository access anomaly: one source states the threshold is 8% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 14% and produced a different exception result.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/040_licenses_in_status_report.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/11_maintenance/088_maintenance_status_report.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-11, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Leona Park.\n\n### F-15 — cease-and-desist deadline (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for cease-and-desist deadline: one source states formal notice must use notices-crux_mapping_systems@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-national_terrain_archive@example.test.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/043_licenses_out_correspondence.eml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/091_security_interests_correspondence.eml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-11, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Isaac Romero.\n\n### F-16 — security-interest release gap (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for security-interest release gap: one source states the governed population contains 68 records through 2025-01-23, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 47 records through 2025-02-11.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/046_licenses_out_formal_notice.xml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/094_security_interests_formal_notice.xml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-11, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Sofia Bennett.\n\n## Recommended next actions\n\nSequence the critical and high findings first, assign the named owners, preserve the cited records, and document any resolution in the controlling matter register before the stated deadline.\n\n## Assumptions and limitations\n\nThis analysis is confined to task cb100-083-crux-mapping and the supplied synthetic evidence. It does not rely on external facts, does not resolve disputed law, and is not legal advice for a real person or entity.\n", "findings": {"as_of": "2026-09-11", "findings": [{"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/07_open_source/049_open_source_control_register.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for inventor assignment gap: one source states the operative date is 2025-10-06 under control reference CB-IP-3203-A976, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2025-10-31 under response reference CB-IP-3203-J582.", "id": "F-01", "issue": "inventor assignment gap", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/01_patents/001_patents_control_register.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-11, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Owen Delgado.", "severity": "critical"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/07_open_source/052_open_source_ledger_export.csv", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for recorded-owner mismatch: one source states the controlling amount is $4,885,469.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $4,947,438.00.", "id": "F-02", "issue": "recorded-owner mismatch", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/01_patents/004_patents_ledger_export.csv", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-11, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Lena Varga.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/07_open_source/055_open_source_officer_certificate.html", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for maintenance-fee deadline: one source states approval is attributed to Amara Patel as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Adrian Mensah and contains no entry for Amara Patel.", "id": "F-03", "issue": "maintenance-fee deadline", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/01_patents/007_patents_officer_certificate.html", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-11, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Samuel Kim.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/08_domain_accounts/058_domain_accounts_executed_instrument.txt", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for foreign-filing restriction: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-IP-3203-D557, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-IP-3203-M689.", "id": "F-04", "issue": "foreign-filing restriction", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/02_trademarks/010_trademarks_executed_instrument.txt", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-11, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Maya Ellison.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/08_domain_accounts/061_domain_accounts_review_memorandum.json", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for trademark specimen issue: one source states the applicable location is Eastern District of Virginia, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to Virginia operations outside Eastern District of Virginia.", "id": "F-05", "issue": "trademark specimen issue", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/02_trademarks/013_trademarks_review_memorandum.json", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-11, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Rafael Okafor.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/08_domain_accounts/064_domain_accounts_status_report.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for coexistence restriction: one source states the threshold is 15% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 20% and produced a different exception result.", "id": "F-06", "issue": "coexistence restriction", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/02_trademarks/016_trademarks_status_report.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-11, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Nora Chen.", "severity": "low"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/09_development_records/067_development_records_correspondence.eml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for work-for-hire defect: one source states formal notice must use notices-crux_mapping_systems@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-national_terrain_archive@example.test.", "id": "F-07", "issue": "work-for-hire defect", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/03_copyrights/019_copyrights_correspondence.eml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-11, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Dominic Alvarez.", "severity": "critical"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/09_development_records/070_development_records_formal_notice.xml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for source-code ownership gap: one source states the governed population contains 141 records through 2026-01-11, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 49 records through 2026-02-01.", "id": "F-08", "issue": "source-code ownership gap", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/03_copyrights/022_copyrights_formal_notice.xml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-11, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Priya Raman.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/10_disputes/073_disputes_control_register.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for inbound-license field restriction: one source states the operative date is 2025-09-21 under control reference CB-IP-3203-I781, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2025-10-19 under response reference CB-IP-3203-R221.", "id": "F-09", "issue": "inbound-license field restriction", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/025_invention_assignments_control_register.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-11, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Elliot Mercer.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/10_disputes/076_disputes_ledger_export.csv", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for outbound sublicense overreach: one source states the controlling amount is $7,264,520.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $7,475,540.00.", "id": "F-10", "issue": "outbound sublicense overreach", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/028_invention_assignments_ledger_export.csv", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-11, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Talia Brooks.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/10_disputes/079_disputes_officer_certificate.html", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for copyleft distribution trigger: one source states approval is attributed to Amara Patel as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Elliot Mercer and contains no entry for Amara Patel.", "id": "F-11", "issue": "copyleft distribution trigger", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/031_invention_assignments_officer_certificate.html", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-11, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Jonas Feld.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/11_maintenance/082_maintenance_executed_instrument.txt", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for notice-file omission: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-IP-3203-L203, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-IP-3203-U938.", "id": "F-12", "issue": "notice-file omission", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/034_licenses_in_executed_instrument.txt", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-11, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Mei Whitaker.", "severity": "low"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/11_maintenance/085_maintenance_review_memorandum.json", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for domain registrant mismatch: one source states the applicable location is Eastern District of Virginia, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to Virginia operations outside Eastern District of Virginia.", "id": "F-13", "issue": "domain registrant mismatch", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/037_licenses_in_review_memorandum.json", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-11, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Caleb Hassan.", "severity": "critical"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/11_maintenance/088_maintenance_status_report.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for repository access anomaly: one source states the threshold is 8% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 14% and produced a different exception result.", "id": "F-14", "issue": "repository access anomaly", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/040_licenses_in_status_report.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-11, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Leona Park.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/091_security_interests_correspondence.eml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for cease-and-desist deadline: one source states formal notice must use notices-crux_mapping_systems@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-national_terrain_archive@example.test.", "id": "F-15", "issue": "cease-and-desist deadline", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/043_licenses_out_correspondence.eml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-11, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Isaac Romero.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/094_security_interests_formal_notice.xml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for security-interest release gap: one source states the governed population contains 68 records through 2025-01-23, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 47 records through 2025-02-11.", "id": "F-16", "issue": "security-interest release gap", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/046_licenses_out_formal_notice.xml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-11, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Sofia Bennett.", "severity": "medium"}], "matter_number": "CB-IP-3203", "prepared_for": "Crux Mapping Systems", "schema_version": "1.0", "task_id": "cb100-083-crux-mapping"}}, "metadata": {"benchmark": "CounselBench-100", "code_license": "Apache-2.0", "data_license": "CC-BY-4.0", "deadline": "2026-09-11", "document_count": 96, "jurisdiction": "Virginia", "matter_number": "CB-IP-3203", "mcp_commit": "9a96ea6e5913736f92b88345bf51caeaaa8e719f", "mcp_package": "@modelcontextprotocol/server-filesystem@2026.7.10", "practice_area": "ip-technology", "reference_tool_calls": 46, "required_evidence_reads": 33, "synthetic": true, "venue": "Eastern District of Virginia", "version": "2.0.0"}, "prompt": "You are intellectual-property counsel for Crux Mapping Systems. The client has asked for a board-ready risk assessment supported by a source-level tracker rather than a narrative-only summary. Mapping products combine government, university, and open-source inputs subject to attribution, field, and distribution restrictions. Decision due 2026-09-11. Virginia law governs; Eastern District of Virginia is the forum. Treat dates, notice mechanics, approval evidence, and numerical reconciliations as independent controls. Work out the defensible position from the matter production and leave an audit-ready exception tracker and concise advice for the supervising lawyer. Keep confirmed conflicts separate from open questions, cite the records that actually control each conclusion, and do not fill gaps with outside facts.", "rubric": {"criteria": [{"category": "procedure", "description": "Complete at least 46 successful, argument-specific evidence and output calls.", "id": "procedure.minimum_successful_tool_calls"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Find and read the 33 controlling, corroborating, and work-product-control records in full.", "id": "procedure.all_evidence_read_in_full"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Inspect file metadata for the eight designated critical primary records before relying on them.", "id": "procedure.chain_of_custody_metadata_checked"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Confirm the sandbox's allowed document and output roots.", "id": "procedure.allowed_directories_checked"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Inventory all 96 records so the relevant sources are discovered among the context records.", "id": "procedure.recursive_inventory_completed"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Search the production for email evidence that may corroborate or contradict formal records.", "id": "procedure.targeted_search_completed"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Leave only findings.json and advice.md in the output workspace.", "id": "procedure.exact_deliverable_set"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Create both final work products through the sandbox MCP surface.", "id": "procedure.deliverables_written_through_mcp"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Produce findings.json as a valid JSON object.", "id": "findings.findings_is_object"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Report exactly 16 confirmed exceptions.", "id": "findings.findings_exact_count"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Use each stable finding ID exactly once.", "id": "findings.finding_ids_unique"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set schema_version to the released matter value '1.0'.", "id": "findings.top_level_schema_version"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set task_id to the released matter value 'cb100-083-crux-mapping'.", "id": "findings.top_level_task_id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set matter_number to the released matter value 'CB-IP-3203'.", "id": "findings.top_level_matter_number"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set prepared_for to the released matter value 'Crux Mapping Systems'.", "id": "findings.top_level_prepared_for"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set as_of to the released matter value '2026-09-11'.", "id": "findings.top_level_as_of"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-01 exception for inventor assignment gap.", "id": "findings.F-01.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's id from /workspace/documents/01_patents/001_patents_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_open_source/049_open_source_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's issue from /workspace/documents/01_patents/001_patents_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_open_source/049_open_source_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's severity from /workspace/documents/01_patents/001_patents_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_open_source/049_open_source_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's primary_source from /workspace/documents/01_patents/001_patents_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_open_source/049_open_source_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/01_patents/001_patents_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_open_source/049_open_source_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-01 using the exact controlled facts ['2025-10-06', 'CB-IP-3203-A976', '2025-10-31', 'CB-IP-3203-J582'].", "id": "findings.F-01.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-01's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-01.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-11', 'Owen Delgado'] for F-01.", "id": "findings.F-01.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-02 exception for recorded-owner mismatch.", "id": "findings.F-02.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's id from /workspace/documents/01_patents/004_patents_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_open_source/052_open_source_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's issue from /workspace/documents/01_patents/004_patents_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_open_source/052_open_source_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's severity from /workspace/documents/01_patents/004_patents_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_open_source/052_open_source_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's primary_source from /workspace/documents/01_patents/004_patents_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_open_source/052_open_source_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/01_patents/004_patents_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_open_source/052_open_source_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-02 using the exact controlled facts ['$4,885,469.00', '$4,947,438.00'].", "id": "findings.F-02.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-02's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-02.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-11', 'Lena Varga'] for F-02.", "id": "findings.F-02.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-03 exception for maintenance-fee deadline.", "id": "findings.F-03.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's id from /workspace/documents/01_patents/007_patents_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_open_source/055_open_source_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's issue from /workspace/documents/01_patents/007_patents_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_open_source/055_open_source_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's severity from /workspace/documents/01_patents/007_patents_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_open_source/055_open_source_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's primary_source from /workspace/documents/01_patents/007_patents_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_open_source/055_open_source_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/01_patents/007_patents_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_open_source/055_open_source_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-03 using the exact controlled facts ['Amara Patel', 'Adrian Mensah'].", "id": "findings.F-03.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-03's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-03.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-11', 'Samuel Kim'] for F-03.", "id": "findings.F-03.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-04 exception for foreign-filing restriction.", "id": "findings.F-04.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's id from /workspace/documents/02_trademarks/010_trademarks_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_domain_accounts/058_domain_accounts_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's issue from /workspace/documents/02_trademarks/010_trademarks_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_domain_accounts/058_domain_accounts_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's severity from /workspace/documents/02_trademarks/010_trademarks_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_domain_accounts/058_domain_accounts_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's primary_source from /workspace/documents/02_trademarks/010_trademarks_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_domain_accounts/058_domain_accounts_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/02_trademarks/010_trademarks_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_domain_accounts/058_domain_accounts_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-04 using the exact controlled facts ['closed without exception', 'CB-IP-3203-D557', 'open and escalated', 'CB-IP-3203-M689'].", "id": "findings.F-04.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-04's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-04.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-11', 'Maya Ellison'] for F-04.", "id": "findings.F-04.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-05 exception for trademark specimen issue.", "id": "findings.F-05.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's id from /workspace/documents/02_trademarks/013_trademarks_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_domain_accounts/061_domain_accounts_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's issue from /workspace/documents/02_trademarks/013_trademarks_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_domain_accounts/061_domain_accounts_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's severity from /workspace/documents/02_trademarks/013_trademarks_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_domain_accounts/061_domain_accounts_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's primary_source from /workspace/documents/02_trademarks/013_trademarks_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_domain_accounts/061_domain_accounts_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/02_trademarks/013_trademarks_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_domain_accounts/061_domain_accounts_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-05 using the exact controlled facts ['Eastern District of Virginia', 'Virginia'].", "id": "findings.F-05.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-05's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-05.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-11', 'Rafael Okafor'] for F-05.", "id": "findings.F-05.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-06 exception for coexistence restriction.", "id": "findings.F-06.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's id from /workspace/documents/02_trademarks/016_trademarks_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_domain_accounts/064_domain_accounts_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's issue from /workspace/documents/02_trademarks/016_trademarks_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_domain_accounts/064_domain_accounts_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's severity from /workspace/documents/02_trademarks/016_trademarks_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_domain_accounts/064_domain_accounts_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's primary_source from /workspace/documents/02_trademarks/016_trademarks_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_domain_accounts/064_domain_accounts_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/02_trademarks/016_trademarks_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_domain_accounts/064_domain_accounts_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-06 using the exact controlled facts ['15%', '20%'].", "id": "findings.F-06.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-06's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-06.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-11', 'Nora Chen'] for F-06.", "id": "findings.F-06.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-07 exception for work-for-hire defect.", "id": "findings.F-07.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's id from /workspace/documents/03_copyrights/019_copyrights_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_development_records/067_development_records_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's issue from /workspace/documents/03_copyrights/019_copyrights_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_development_records/067_development_records_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's severity from /workspace/documents/03_copyrights/019_copyrights_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_development_records/067_development_records_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's primary_source from /workspace/documents/03_copyrights/019_copyrights_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_development_records/067_development_records_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/03_copyrights/019_copyrights_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_development_records/067_development_records_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-07 using the exact controlled facts ['notices-crux_mapping_systems@example.test', 'archive-national_terrain_archive@example.test'].", "id": "findings.F-07.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-07's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-07.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-11', 'Dominic Alvarez'] for F-07.", "id": "findings.F-07.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-08 exception for source-code ownership gap.", "id": "findings.F-08.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's id from /workspace/documents/03_copyrights/022_copyrights_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_development_records/070_development_records_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's issue from /workspace/documents/03_copyrights/022_copyrights_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_development_records/070_development_records_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's severity from /workspace/documents/03_copyrights/022_copyrights_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_development_records/070_development_records_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's primary_source from /workspace/documents/03_copyrights/022_copyrights_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_development_records/070_development_records_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/03_copyrights/022_copyrights_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_development_records/070_development_records_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-08 using the exact controlled facts ['141 records', '2026-01-11', '49 records', '2026-02-01'].", "id": "findings.F-08.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-08's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-08.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-11', 'Priya Raman'] for F-08.", "id": "findings.F-08.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-09 exception for inbound-license field restriction.", "id": "findings.F-09.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's id from /workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/025_invention_assignments_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_disputes/073_disputes_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's issue from /workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/025_invention_assignments_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_disputes/073_disputes_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's severity from /workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/025_invention_assignments_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_disputes/073_disputes_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's primary_source from /workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/025_invention_assignments_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_disputes/073_disputes_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/025_invention_assignments_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_disputes/073_disputes_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-09 using the exact controlled facts ['2025-09-21', 'CB-IP-3203-I781', '2025-10-19', 'CB-IP-3203-R221'].", "id": "findings.F-09.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-09's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-09.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-11', 'Elliot Mercer'] for F-09.", "id": "findings.F-09.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-10 exception for outbound sublicense overreach.", "id": "findings.F-10.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's id from /workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/028_invention_assignments_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_disputes/076_disputes_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's issue from /workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/028_invention_assignments_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_disputes/076_disputes_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's severity from /workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/028_invention_assignments_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_disputes/076_disputes_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's primary_source from /workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/028_invention_assignments_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_disputes/076_disputes_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/028_invention_assignments_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_disputes/076_disputes_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-10 using the exact controlled facts ['$7,264,520.00', '$7,475,540.00'].", "id": "findings.F-10.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-10's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-10.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-11', 'Talia Brooks'] for F-10.", "id": "findings.F-10.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-11 exception for copyleft distribution trigger.", "id": "findings.F-11.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's id from /workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/031_invention_assignments_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_disputes/079_disputes_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's issue from /workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/031_invention_assignments_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_disputes/079_disputes_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's severity from /workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/031_invention_assignments_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_disputes/079_disputes_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's primary_source from /workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/031_invention_assignments_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_disputes/079_disputes_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/031_invention_assignments_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_disputes/079_disputes_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-11 using the exact controlled facts ['Amara Patel', 'Elliot Mercer'].", "id": "findings.F-11.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-11's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-11.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-11', 'Jonas Feld'] for F-11.", "id": "findings.F-11.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-12 exception for notice-file omission.", "id": "findings.F-12.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's id from /workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/034_licenses_in_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_maintenance/082_maintenance_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's issue from /workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/034_licenses_in_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_maintenance/082_maintenance_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's severity from /workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/034_licenses_in_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_maintenance/082_maintenance_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's primary_source from /workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/034_licenses_in_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_maintenance/082_maintenance_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/034_licenses_in_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_maintenance/082_maintenance_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-12 using the exact controlled facts ['closed without exception', 'CB-IP-3203-L203', 'open and escalated', 'CB-IP-3203-U938'].", "id": "findings.F-12.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-12's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-12.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-11', 'Mei Whitaker'] for F-12.", "id": "findings.F-12.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-13 exception for domain registrant mismatch.", "id": "findings.F-13.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's id from /workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/037_licenses_in_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_maintenance/085_maintenance_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's issue from /workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/037_licenses_in_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_maintenance/085_maintenance_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's severity from /workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/037_licenses_in_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_maintenance/085_maintenance_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's primary_source from /workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/037_licenses_in_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_maintenance/085_maintenance_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/037_licenses_in_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_maintenance/085_maintenance_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-13 using the exact controlled facts ['Eastern District of Virginia', 'Virginia'].", "id": "findings.F-13.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-13's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-13.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-11', 'Caleb Hassan'] for F-13.", "id": "findings.F-13.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-14 exception for repository access anomaly.", "id": "findings.F-14.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's id from /workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/040_licenses_in_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_maintenance/088_maintenance_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's issue from /workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/040_licenses_in_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_maintenance/088_maintenance_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's severity from /workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/040_licenses_in_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_maintenance/088_maintenance_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's primary_source from /workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/040_licenses_in_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_maintenance/088_maintenance_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/040_licenses_in_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_maintenance/088_maintenance_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-14 using the exact controlled facts ['8%', '14%'].", "id": "findings.F-14.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-14's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-14.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-11', 'Leona Park'] for F-14.", "id": "findings.F-14.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-15 exception for cease-and-desist deadline.", "id": "findings.F-15.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's id from /workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/043_licenses_out_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_security_interests/091_security_interests_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's issue from /workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/043_licenses_out_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_security_interests/091_security_interests_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's severity from /workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/043_licenses_out_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_security_interests/091_security_interests_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's primary_source from /workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/043_licenses_out_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_security_interests/091_security_interests_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/043_licenses_out_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_security_interests/091_security_interests_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-15 using the exact controlled facts ['notices-crux_mapping_systems@example.test', 'archive-national_terrain_archive@example.test'].", "id": "findings.F-15.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-15's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-15.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-11', 'Isaac Romero'] for F-15.", "id": "findings.F-15.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-16 exception for security-interest release gap.", "id": "findings.F-16.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's id from /workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/046_licenses_out_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_security_interests/094_security_interests_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's issue from /workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/046_licenses_out_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_security_interests/094_security_interests_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's severity from /workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/046_licenses_out_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_security_interests/094_security_interests_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's primary_source from /workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/046_licenses_out_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_security_interests/094_security_interests_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/046_licenses_out_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_security_interests/094_security_interests_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-16 using the exact controlled facts ['68 records', '2025-01-23', '47 records', '2025-02-11'].", "id": "findings.F-16.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-16's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-16.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-11', 'Sofia Bennett'] for F-16.", "id": "findings.F-16.action_anchors"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Executive assessment' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Executive assessment"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Method and record coverage' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Method and record coverage"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Findings' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Findings"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Recommended next actions' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Recommended next actions"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Assumptions and limitations' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Assumptions and limitations"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-01 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-01"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-02 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-02"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-03 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-03"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-04 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-04"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-05 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-05"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-06 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-06"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-07 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-07"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-08 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-08"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-09 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-09"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-10 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-10"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-11 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-11"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-12 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-12"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-13 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-13"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-14 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-14"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-15 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-15"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-16 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-16"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Do not claim the production has no issues or that every record is consistent.", "id": "memo.forbidden_claims_absent"}], "decision_options": [{"id": "cross-source-reconciliation", "label": "Reconcile controlling and corroborating records", "reason": "The CB-IP-3203 production contains independently maintained records; a defensible answer must preserve each supported conflict and its cure owner.", "selected": true}, {"id": "latest-record-controls", "label": "Treat the latest record as controlling", "reason": "Timestamp recency does not establish legal priority, execution, or approval authority.", "selected": false}, {"id": "primary-records-only", "label": "Report primary records without reconciliation", "reason": "Primary records alone conceal the operational conflicts that create the actionable exceptions.", "selected": false}], "gates": ["all_evidence_read_in_full", "chain_of_custody_metadata_checked", "findings_criteria_complete", "memo_criteria_complete", "deliverables_written_through_mcp"], "metadata_checks": 8, "metric": "weighted_criteria_score", "minimum_tool_calls": 46, "required_deliverables": ["findings.json", "advice.md"], "required_document_reads": 33, "type": "deterministic", "weights": {"findings": 0.55, "memo": 0.2, "procedure": 0.25}}, "task_id": "cb100-083-crux-mapping", "task_name": "Crux geospatial license review", "world_id": "counselbench-filesystem-mcp-v2"}
-{"context_files": ["task_files/cb100-084-drift-audio/01_patents/001_patents_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-084-drift-audio/01_patents/002_patents_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-084-drift-audio/01_patents/003_patents_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-084-drift-audio/01_patents/004_patents_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-084-drift-audio/01_patents/005_patents_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-084-drift-audio/01_patents/006_patents_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-084-drift-audio/01_patents/007_patents_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-084-drift-audio/01_patents/008_patents_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-084-drift-audio/02_trademarks/009_trademarks_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-084-drift-audio/02_trademarks/010_trademarks_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-084-drift-audio/02_trademarks/011_trademarks_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-084-drift-audio/02_trademarks/012_trademarks_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-084-drift-audio/02_trademarks/013_trademarks_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-084-drift-audio/02_trademarks/014_trademarks_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-084-drift-audio/02_trademarks/015_trademarks_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-084-drift-audio/02_trademarks/016_trademarks_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-084-drift-audio/03_copyrights/017_copyrights_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-084-drift-audio/03_copyrights/018_copyrights_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-084-drift-audio/03_copyrights/019_copyrights_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-084-drift-audio/03_copyrights/020_copyrights_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-084-drift-audio/03_copyrights/021_copyrights_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-084-drift-audio/03_copyrights/022_copyrights_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-084-drift-audio/03_copyrights/023_copyrights_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-084-drift-audio/03_copyrights/024_copyrights_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-084-drift-audio/04_invention_assignments/025_invention_assignments_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-084-drift-audio/04_invention_assignments/026_invention_assignments_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-084-drift-audio/04_invention_assignments/027_invention_assignments_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-084-drift-audio/04_invention_assignments/028_invention_assignments_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-084-drift-audio/04_invention_assignments/029_invention_assignments_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-084-drift-audio/04_invention_assignments/030_invention_assignments_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-084-drift-audio/04_invention_assignments/031_invention_assignments_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-084-drift-audio/04_invention_assignments/032_invention_assignments_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-084-drift-audio/05_licenses_in/033_licenses_in_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-084-drift-audio/05_licenses_in/034_licenses_in_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-084-drift-audio/05_licenses_in/035_licenses_in_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-084-drift-audio/05_licenses_in/036_licenses_in_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-084-drift-audio/05_licenses_in/037_licenses_in_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-084-drift-audio/05_licenses_in/038_licenses_in_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-084-drift-audio/05_licenses_in/039_licenses_in_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-084-drift-audio/05_licenses_in/040_licenses_in_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-084-drift-audio/06_licenses_out/041_licenses_out_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-084-drift-audio/06_licenses_out/042_licenses_out_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-084-drift-audio/06_licenses_out/043_licenses_out_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-084-drift-audio/06_licenses_out/044_licenses_out_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-084-drift-audio/06_licenses_out/045_licenses_out_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-084-drift-audio/06_licenses_out/046_licenses_out_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-084-drift-audio/06_licenses_out/047_licenses_out_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-084-drift-audio/06_licenses_out/048_licenses_out_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-084-drift-audio/07_open_source/049_open_source_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-084-drift-audio/07_open_source/050_open_source_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-084-drift-audio/07_open_source/051_open_source_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-084-drift-audio/07_open_source/052_open_source_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-084-drift-audio/07_open_source/053_open_source_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-084-drift-audio/07_open_source/054_open_source_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-084-drift-audio/07_open_source/055_open_source_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-084-drift-audio/07_open_source/056_open_source_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-084-drift-audio/08_domain_accounts/057_domain_accounts_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-084-drift-audio/08_domain_accounts/058_domain_accounts_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-084-drift-audio/08_domain_accounts/059_domain_accounts_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-084-drift-audio/08_domain_accounts/060_domain_accounts_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-084-drift-audio/08_domain_accounts/061_domain_accounts_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-084-drift-audio/08_domain_accounts/062_domain_accounts_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-084-drift-audio/08_domain_accounts/063_domain_accounts_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-084-drift-audio/08_domain_accounts/064_domain_accounts_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-084-drift-audio/09_development_records/065_development_records_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-084-drift-audio/09_development_records/066_development_records_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-084-drift-audio/09_development_records/067_development_records_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-084-drift-audio/09_development_records/068_development_records_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-084-drift-audio/09_development_records/069_development_records_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-084-drift-audio/09_development_records/070_development_records_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-084-drift-audio/09_development_records/071_development_records_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-084-drift-audio/09_development_records/072_development_records_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-084-drift-audio/10_disputes/073_disputes_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-084-drift-audio/10_disputes/074_disputes_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-084-drift-audio/10_disputes/075_disputes_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-084-drift-audio/10_disputes/076_disputes_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-084-drift-audio/10_disputes/077_disputes_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-084-drift-audio/10_disputes/078_disputes_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-084-drift-audio/10_disputes/079_disputes_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-084-drift-audio/10_disputes/080_disputes_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-084-drift-audio/11_maintenance/081_maintenance_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-084-drift-audio/11_maintenance/082_maintenance_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-084-drift-audio/11_maintenance/083_maintenance_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-084-drift-audio/11_maintenance/084_maintenance_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-084-drift-audio/11_maintenance/085_maintenance_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-084-drift-audio/11_maintenance/086_maintenance_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-084-drift-audio/11_maintenance/087_maintenance_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-084-drift-audio/11_maintenance/088_maintenance_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-084-drift-audio/12_security_interests/089_security_interests_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-084-drift-audio/12_security_interests/090_security_interests_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-084-drift-audio/12_security_interests/091_security_interests_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-084-drift-audio/12_security_interests/092_security_interests_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-084-drift-audio/12_security_interests/093_security_interests_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-084-drift-audio/12_security_interests/094_security_interests_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-084-drift-audio/12_security_interests/095_security_interests_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-084-drift-audio/12_security_interests/096_security_interests_status_report.md"], "gold_output": {"advice_markdown": "# Counsel advice — Drift Audio catalog ownership audit\n\n## Executive assessment\n\nFor Drift Audio Labs matter CB-IP-3204, the review identified 16 source-supported exceptions requiring action before 2026-09-15. The assessment concerns Silver Reed Composers LLC and the supplied record for Tennessee.\n\n## Method and record coverage\n\nThe review inventoried all 96 production files, read the 33 controlling, corroborating, and control records, searched the email exports, and checked metadata for the designated chain-of-custody sample. Conclusions are limited to the synthetic production supplied for this benchmark matter.\n\n## Findings\n\n### F-01 — inventor assignment gap (critical)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for inventor assignment gap: one source states the operative date is 2025-05-18 under control reference CB-IP-3204-A295, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2025-06-15 under response reference CB-IP-3204-J807.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/01_patents/001_patents_control_register.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/07_open_source/049_open_source_control_register.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-15, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Lena Varga.\n\n### F-02 — recorded-owner mismatch (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for recorded-owner mismatch: one source states the controlling amount is $4,108,258.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $4,373,016.00.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/01_patents/004_patents_ledger_export.csv`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/07_open_source/052_open_source_ledger_export.csv`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-15, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Samuel Kim.\n\n### F-03 — maintenance-fee deadline (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for maintenance-fee deadline: one source states approval is attributed to Henry Cho as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Theo Laurent and contains no entry for Henry Cho.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/01_patents/007_patents_officer_certificate.html`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/07_open_source/055_open_source_officer_certificate.html`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-15, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Maya Ellison.\n\n### F-04 — foreign-filing restriction (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for foreign-filing restriction: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-IP-3204-D147, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-IP-3204-M103.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/02_trademarks/010_trademarks_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/08_domain_accounts/058_domain_accounts_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-15, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Rafael Okafor.\n\n### F-05 — trademark specimen issue (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for trademark specimen issue: one source states the applicable location is Middle District of Tennessee, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to Tennessee operations outside Middle District of Tennessee.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/02_trademarks/013_trademarks_review_memorandum.json`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/08_domain_accounts/061_domain_accounts_review_memorandum.json`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-15, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Nora Chen.\n\n### F-06 — coexistence restriction (low)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for coexistence restriction: one source states the threshold is 10% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 14% and produced a different exception result.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/02_trademarks/016_trademarks_status_report.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/08_domain_accounts/064_domain_accounts_status_report.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-15, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Dominic Alvarez.\n\n### F-07 — work-for-hire defect (critical)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for work-for-hire defect: one source states formal notice must use notices-drift_audio_labs@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-silver_reed_composers_llc@example.test.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/03_copyrights/019_copyrights_correspondence.eml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/09_development_records/067_development_records_correspondence.eml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-15, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Priya Raman.\n\n### F-08 — source-code ownership gap (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for source-code ownership gap: one source states the governed population contains 138 records through 2025-04-03, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 50 records through 2025-04-25.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/03_copyrights/022_copyrights_formal_notice.xml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/09_development_records/070_development_records_formal_notice.xml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-15, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Elliot Mercer.\n\n### F-09 — inbound-license field restriction (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for inbound-license field restriction: one source states the operative date is 2025-03-26 under control reference CB-IP-3204-I242, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2025-04-05 under response reference CB-IP-3204-R595.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/025_invention_assignments_control_register.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/10_disputes/073_disputes_control_register.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-15, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Talia Brooks.\n\n### F-10 — outbound sublicense overreach (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for outbound sublicense overreach: one source states the controlling amount is $7,446,715.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $7,699,930.00.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/028_invention_assignments_ledger_export.csv`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/10_disputes/076_disputes_ledger_export.csv`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-15, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Jonas Feld.\n\n### F-11 — copyleft distribution trigger (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for copyleft distribution trigger: one source states approval is attributed to Henry Cho as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Jonas Feld and contains no entry for Henry Cho.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/031_invention_assignments_officer_certificate.html`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/10_disputes/079_disputes_officer_certificate.html`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-15, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Mei Whitaker.\n\n### F-12 — notice-file omission (low)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for notice-file omission: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-IP-3204-L223, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-IP-3204-U455.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/034_licenses_in_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/11_maintenance/082_maintenance_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-15, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Caleb Hassan.\n\n### F-13 — domain registrant mismatch (critical)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for domain registrant mismatch: one source states the applicable location is Middle District of Tennessee, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to Tennessee operations outside Middle District of Tennessee.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/037_licenses_in_review_memorandum.json`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/11_maintenance/085_maintenance_review_memorandum.json`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-15, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Leona Park.\n\n### F-14 — repository access anomaly (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for repository access anomaly: one source states the threshold is 11% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 18% and produced a different exception result.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/040_licenses_in_status_report.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/11_maintenance/088_maintenance_status_report.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-15, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Isaac Romero.\n\n### F-15 — cease-and-desist deadline (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for cease-and-desist deadline: one source states formal notice must use notices-drift_audio_labs@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-silver_reed_composers_llc@example.test.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/043_licenses_out_correspondence.eml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/091_security_interests_correspondence.eml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-15, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Sofia Bennett.\n\n### F-16 — security-interest release gap (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for security-interest release gap: one source states the governed population contains 74 records through 2025-06-18, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 69 records through 2025-07-29.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/046_licenses_out_formal_notice.xml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/094_security_interests_formal_notice.xml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-15, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Adrian Mensah.\n\n## Recommended next actions\n\nSequence the critical and high findings first, assign the named owners, preserve the cited records, and document any resolution in the controlling matter register before the stated deadline.\n\n## Assumptions and limitations\n\nThis analysis is confined to task cb100-084-drift-audio and the supplied synthetic evidence. It does not rely on external facts, does not resolve disputed law, and is not legal advice for a real person or entity.\n", "findings": {"as_of": "2026-09-15", "findings": [{"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/07_open_source/049_open_source_control_register.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for inventor assignment gap: one source states the operative date is 2025-05-18 under control reference CB-IP-3204-A295, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2025-06-15 under response reference CB-IP-3204-J807.", "id": "F-01", "issue": "inventor assignment gap", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/01_patents/001_patents_control_register.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-15, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Lena Varga.", "severity": "critical"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/07_open_source/052_open_source_ledger_export.csv", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for recorded-owner mismatch: one source states the controlling amount is $4,108,258.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $4,373,016.00.", "id": "F-02", "issue": "recorded-owner mismatch", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/01_patents/004_patents_ledger_export.csv", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-15, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Samuel Kim.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/07_open_source/055_open_source_officer_certificate.html", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for maintenance-fee deadline: one source states approval is attributed to Henry Cho as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Theo Laurent and contains no entry for Henry Cho.", "id": "F-03", "issue": "maintenance-fee deadline", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/01_patents/007_patents_officer_certificate.html", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-15, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Maya Ellison.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/08_domain_accounts/058_domain_accounts_executed_instrument.txt", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for foreign-filing restriction: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-IP-3204-D147, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-IP-3204-M103.", "id": "F-04", "issue": "foreign-filing restriction", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/02_trademarks/010_trademarks_executed_instrument.txt", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-15, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Rafael Okafor.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/08_domain_accounts/061_domain_accounts_review_memorandum.json", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for trademark specimen issue: one source states the applicable location is Middle District of Tennessee, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to Tennessee operations outside Middle District of Tennessee.", "id": "F-05", "issue": "trademark specimen issue", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/02_trademarks/013_trademarks_review_memorandum.json", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-15, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Nora Chen.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/08_domain_accounts/064_domain_accounts_status_report.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for coexistence restriction: one source states the threshold is 10% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 14% and produced a different exception result.", "id": "F-06", "issue": "coexistence restriction", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/02_trademarks/016_trademarks_status_report.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-15, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Dominic Alvarez.", "severity": "low"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/09_development_records/067_development_records_correspondence.eml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for work-for-hire defect: one source states formal notice must use notices-drift_audio_labs@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-silver_reed_composers_llc@example.test.", "id": "F-07", "issue": "work-for-hire defect", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/03_copyrights/019_copyrights_correspondence.eml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-15, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Priya Raman.", "severity": "critical"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/09_development_records/070_development_records_formal_notice.xml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for source-code ownership gap: one source states the governed population contains 138 records through 2025-04-03, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 50 records through 2025-04-25.", "id": "F-08", "issue": "source-code ownership gap", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/03_copyrights/022_copyrights_formal_notice.xml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-15, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Elliot Mercer.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/10_disputes/073_disputes_control_register.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for inbound-license field restriction: one source states the operative date is 2025-03-26 under control reference CB-IP-3204-I242, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2025-04-05 under response reference CB-IP-3204-R595.", "id": "F-09", "issue": "inbound-license field restriction", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/025_invention_assignments_control_register.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-15, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Talia Brooks.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/10_disputes/076_disputes_ledger_export.csv", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for outbound sublicense overreach: one source states the controlling amount is $7,446,715.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $7,699,930.00.", "id": "F-10", "issue": "outbound sublicense overreach", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/028_invention_assignments_ledger_export.csv", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-15, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Jonas Feld.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/10_disputes/079_disputes_officer_certificate.html", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for copyleft distribution trigger: one source states approval is attributed to Henry Cho as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Jonas Feld and contains no entry for Henry Cho.", "id": "F-11", "issue": "copyleft distribution trigger", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/031_invention_assignments_officer_certificate.html", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-15, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Mei Whitaker.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/11_maintenance/082_maintenance_executed_instrument.txt", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for notice-file omission: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-IP-3204-L223, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-IP-3204-U455.", "id": "F-12", "issue": "notice-file omission", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/034_licenses_in_executed_instrument.txt", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-15, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Caleb Hassan.", "severity": "low"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/11_maintenance/085_maintenance_review_memorandum.json", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for domain registrant mismatch: one source states the applicable location is Middle District of Tennessee, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to Tennessee operations outside Middle District of Tennessee.", "id": "F-13", "issue": "domain registrant mismatch", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/037_licenses_in_review_memorandum.json", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-15, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Leona Park.", "severity": "critical"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/11_maintenance/088_maintenance_status_report.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for repository access anomaly: one source states the threshold is 11% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 18% and produced a different exception result.", "id": "F-14", "issue": "repository access anomaly", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/040_licenses_in_status_report.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-15, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Isaac Romero.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/091_security_interests_correspondence.eml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for cease-and-desist deadline: one source states formal notice must use notices-drift_audio_labs@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-silver_reed_composers_llc@example.test.", "id": "F-15", "issue": "cease-and-desist deadline", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/043_licenses_out_correspondence.eml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-15, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Sofia Bennett.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/094_security_interests_formal_notice.xml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for security-interest release gap: one source states the governed population contains 74 records through 2025-06-18, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 69 records through 2025-07-29.", "id": "F-16", "issue": "security-interest release gap", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/046_licenses_out_formal_notice.xml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-15, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Adrian Mensah.", "severity": "medium"}], "matter_number": "CB-IP-3204", "prepared_for": "Drift Audio Labs", "schema_version": "1.0", "task_id": "cb100-084-drift-audio"}}, "metadata": {"benchmark": "CounselBench-100", "code_license": "Apache-2.0", "data_license": "CC-BY-4.0", "deadline": "2026-09-15", "document_count": 96, "jurisdiction": "Tennessee", "matter_number": "CB-IP-3204", "mcp_commit": "9a96ea6e5913736f92b88345bf51caeaaa8e719f", "mcp_package": "@modelcontextprotocol/server-filesystem@2026.7.10", "practice_area": "ip-technology", "reference_tool_calls": 46, "required_evidence_reads": 33, "synthetic": true, "venue": "Middle District of Tennessee", "version": "2.0.0"}, "prompt": "You are intellectual-property counsel for Drift Audio Labs. Several workstreams have maintained separate versions of the truth; your assignment is to produce one auditable legal view. An audio-model training catalog includes commissioned recordings, performer releases, sample licenses, and takedown correspondence. Decision due 2026-09-15. Tennessee law governs; Middle District of Tennessee is the forum. Distinguish a missing document from an affirmative contradiction in the documents that are present. Work out the defensible position from the matter production and leave an audit-ready exception tracker and concise advice for the supervising lawyer. Keep confirmed conflicts separate from open questions, cite the records that actually control each conclusion, and do not fill gaps with outside facts.", "rubric": {"criteria": [{"category": "procedure", "description": "Complete at least 46 successful, argument-specific evidence and output calls.", "id": "procedure.minimum_successful_tool_calls"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Find and read the 33 controlling, corroborating, and work-product-control records in full.", "id": "procedure.all_evidence_read_in_full"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Inspect file metadata for the eight designated critical primary records before relying on them.", "id": "procedure.chain_of_custody_metadata_checked"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Confirm the sandbox's allowed document and output roots.", "id": "procedure.allowed_directories_checked"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Inventory all 96 records so the relevant sources are discovered among the context records.", "id": "procedure.recursive_inventory_completed"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Search the production for email evidence that may corroborate or contradict formal records.", "id": "procedure.targeted_search_completed"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Leave only findings.json and advice.md in the output workspace.", "id": "procedure.exact_deliverable_set"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Create both final work products through the sandbox MCP surface.", "id": "procedure.deliverables_written_through_mcp"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Produce findings.json as a valid JSON object.", "id": "findings.findings_is_object"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Report exactly 16 confirmed exceptions.", "id": "findings.findings_exact_count"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Use each stable finding ID exactly once.", "id": "findings.finding_ids_unique"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set schema_version to the released matter value '1.0'.", "id": "findings.top_level_schema_version"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set task_id to the released matter value 'cb100-084-drift-audio'.", "id": "findings.top_level_task_id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set matter_number to the released matter value 'CB-IP-3204'.", "id": "findings.top_level_matter_number"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set prepared_for to the released matter value 'Drift Audio Labs'.", "id": "findings.top_level_prepared_for"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set as_of to the released matter value '2026-09-15'.", "id": "findings.top_level_as_of"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-01 exception for inventor assignment gap.", "id": "findings.F-01.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's id from /workspace/documents/01_patents/001_patents_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_open_source/049_open_source_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's issue from /workspace/documents/01_patents/001_patents_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_open_source/049_open_source_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's severity from /workspace/documents/01_patents/001_patents_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_open_source/049_open_source_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's primary_source from /workspace/documents/01_patents/001_patents_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_open_source/049_open_source_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/01_patents/001_patents_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_open_source/049_open_source_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-01 using the exact controlled facts ['2025-05-18', 'CB-IP-3204-A295', '2025-06-15', 'CB-IP-3204-J807'].", "id": "findings.F-01.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-01's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-01.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-15', 'Lena Varga'] for F-01.", "id": "findings.F-01.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-02 exception for recorded-owner mismatch.", "id": "findings.F-02.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's id from /workspace/documents/01_patents/004_patents_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_open_source/052_open_source_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's issue from /workspace/documents/01_patents/004_patents_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_open_source/052_open_source_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's severity from /workspace/documents/01_patents/004_patents_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_open_source/052_open_source_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's primary_source from /workspace/documents/01_patents/004_patents_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_open_source/052_open_source_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/01_patents/004_patents_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_open_source/052_open_source_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-02 using the exact controlled facts ['$4,108,258.00', '$4,373,016.00'].", "id": "findings.F-02.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-02's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-02.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-15', 'Samuel Kim'] for F-02.", "id": "findings.F-02.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-03 exception for maintenance-fee deadline.", "id": "findings.F-03.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's id from /workspace/documents/01_patents/007_patents_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_open_source/055_open_source_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's issue from /workspace/documents/01_patents/007_patents_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_open_source/055_open_source_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's severity from /workspace/documents/01_patents/007_patents_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_open_source/055_open_source_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's primary_source from /workspace/documents/01_patents/007_patents_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_open_source/055_open_source_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/01_patents/007_patents_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_open_source/055_open_source_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-03 using the exact controlled facts ['Henry Cho', 'Theo Laurent'].", "id": "findings.F-03.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-03's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-03.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-15', 'Maya Ellison'] for F-03.", "id": "findings.F-03.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-04 exception for foreign-filing restriction.", "id": "findings.F-04.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's id from /workspace/documents/02_trademarks/010_trademarks_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_domain_accounts/058_domain_accounts_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's issue from /workspace/documents/02_trademarks/010_trademarks_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_domain_accounts/058_domain_accounts_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's severity from /workspace/documents/02_trademarks/010_trademarks_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_domain_accounts/058_domain_accounts_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's primary_source from /workspace/documents/02_trademarks/010_trademarks_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_domain_accounts/058_domain_accounts_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/02_trademarks/010_trademarks_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_domain_accounts/058_domain_accounts_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-04 using the exact controlled facts ['closed without exception', 'CB-IP-3204-D147', 'open and escalated', 'CB-IP-3204-M103'].", "id": "findings.F-04.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-04's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-04.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-15', 'Rafael Okafor'] for F-04.", "id": "findings.F-04.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-05 exception for trademark specimen issue.", "id": "findings.F-05.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's id from /workspace/documents/02_trademarks/013_trademarks_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_domain_accounts/061_domain_accounts_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's issue from /workspace/documents/02_trademarks/013_trademarks_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_domain_accounts/061_domain_accounts_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's severity from /workspace/documents/02_trademarks/013_trademarks_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_domain_accounts/061_domain_accounts_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's primary_source from /workspace/documents/02_trademarks/013_trademarks_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_domain_accounts/061_domain_accounts_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/02_trademarks/013_trademarks_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_domain_accounts/061_domain_accounts_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-05 using the exact controlled facts ['Middle District of Tennessee', 'Tennessee'].", "id": "findings.F-05.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-05's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-05.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-15', 'Nora Chen'] for F-05.", "id": "findings.F-05.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-06 exception for coexistence restriction.", "id": "findings.F-06.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's id from /workspace/documents/02_trademarks/016_trademarks_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_domain_accounts/064_domain_accounts_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's issue from /workspace/documents/02_trademarks/016_trademarks_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_domain_accounts/064_domain_accounts_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's severity from /workspace/documents/02_trademarks/016_trademarks_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_domain_accounts/064_domain_accounts_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's primary_source from /workspace/documents/02_trademarks/016_trademarks_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_domain_accounts/064_domain_accounts_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/02_trademarks/016_trademarks_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_domain_accounts/064_domain_accounts_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-06 using the exact controlled facts ['10%', '14%'].", "id": "findings.F-06.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-06's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-06.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-15', 'Dominic Alvarez'] for F-06.", "id": "findings.F-06.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-07 exception for work-for-hire defect.", "id": "findings.F-07.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's id from /workspace/documents/03_copyrights/019_copyrights_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_development_records/067_development_records_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's issue from /workspace/documents/03_copyrights/019_copyrights_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_development_records/067_development_records_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's severity from /workspace/documents/03_copyrights/019_copyrights_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_development_records/067_development_records_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's primary_source from /workspace/documents/03_copyrights/019_copyrights_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_development_records/067_development_records_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/03_copyrights/019_copyrights_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_development_records/067_development_records_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-07 using the exact controlled facts ['notices-drift_audio_labs@example.test', 'archive-silver_reed_composers_llc@example.test'].", "id": "findings.F-07.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-07's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-07.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-15', 'Priya Raman'] for F-07.", "id": "findings.F-07.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-08 exception for source-code ownership gap.", "id": "findings.F-08.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's id from /workspace/documents/03_copyrights/022_copyrights_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_development_records/070_development_records_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's issue from /workspace/documents/03_copyrights/022_copyrights_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_development_records/070_development_records_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's severity from /workspace/documents/03_copyrights/022_copyrights_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_development_records/070_development_records_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's primary_source from /workspace/documents/03_copyrights/022_copyrights_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_development_records/070_development_records_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/03_copyrights/022_copyrights_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_development_records/070_development_records_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-08 using the exact controlled facts ['138 records', '2025-04-03', '50 records', '2025-04-25'].", "id": "findings.F-08.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-08's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-08.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-15', 'Elliot Mercer'] for F-08.", "id": "findings.F-08.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-09 exception for inbound-license field restriction.", "id": "findings.F-09.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's id from /workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/025_invention_assignments_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_disputes/073_disputes_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's issue from /workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/025_invention_assignments_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_disputes/073_disputes_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's severity from /workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/025_invention_assignments_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_disputes/073_disputes_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's primary_source from /workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/025_invention_assignments_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_disputes/073_disputes_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/025_invention_assignments_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_disputes/073_disputes_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-09 using the exact controlled facts ['2025-03-26', 'CB-IP-3204-I242', '2025-04-05', 'CB-IP-3204-R595'].", "id": "findings.F-09.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-09's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-09.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-15', 'Talia Brooks'] for F-09.", "id": "findings.F-09.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-10 exception for outbound sublicense overreach.", "id": "findings.F-10.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's id from /workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/028_invention_assignments_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_disputes/076_disputes_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's issue from /workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/028_invention_assignments_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_disputes/076_disputes_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's severity from /workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/028_invention_assignments_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_disputes/076_disputes_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's primary_source from /workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/028_invention_assignments_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_disputes/076_disputes_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/028_invention_assignments_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_disputes/076_disputes_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-10 using the exact controlled facts ['$7,446,715.00', '$7,699,930.00'].", "id": "findings.F-10.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-10's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-10.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-15', 'Jonas Feld'] for F-10.", "id": "findings.F-10.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-11 exception for copyleft distribution trigger.", "id": "findings.F-11.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's id from /workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/031_invention_assignments_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_disputes/079_disputes_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's issue from /workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/031_invention_assignments_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_disputes/079_disputes_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's severity from /workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/031_invention_assignments_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_disputes/079_disputes_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's primary_source from /workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/031_invention_assignments_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_disputes/079_disputes_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/031_invention_assignments_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_disputes/079_disputes_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-11 using the exact controlled facts ['Henry Cho', 'Jonas Feld'].", "id": "findings.F-11.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-11's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-11.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-15', 'Mei Whitaker'] for F-11.", "id": "findings.F-11.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-12 exception for notice-file omission.", "id": "findings.F-12.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's id from /workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/034_licenses_in_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_maintenance/082_maintenance_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's issue from /workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/034_licenses_in_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_maintenance/082_maintenance_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's severity from /workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/034_licenses_in_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_maintenance/082_maintenance_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's primary_source from /workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/034_licenses_in_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_maintenance/082_maintenance_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/034_licenses_in_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_maintenance/082_maintenance_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-12 using the exact controlled facts ['closed without exception', 'CB-IP-3204-L223', 'open and escalated', 'CB-IP-3204-U455'].", "id": "findings.F-12.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-12's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-12.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-15', 'Caleb Hassan'] for F-12.", "id": "findings.F-12.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-13 exception for domain registrant mismatch.", "id": "findings.F-13.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's id from /workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/037_licenses_in_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_maintenance/085_maintenance_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's issue from /workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/037_licenses_in_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_maintenance/085_maintenance_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's severity from /workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/037_licenses_in_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_maintenance/085_maintenance_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's primary_source from /workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/037_licenses_in_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_maintenance/085_maintenance_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/037_licenses_in_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_maintenance/085_maintenance_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-13 using the exact controlled facts ['Middle District of Tennessee', 'Tennessee'].", "id": "findings.F-13.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-13's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-13.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-15', 'Leona Park'] for F-13.", "id": "findings.F-13.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-14 exception for repository access anomaly.", "id": "findings.F-14.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's id from /workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/040_licenses_in_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_maintenance/088_maintenance_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's issue from /workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/040_licenses_in_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_maintenance/088_maintenance_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's severity from /workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/040_licenses_in_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_maintenance/088_maintenance_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's primary_source from /workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/040_licenses_in_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_maintenance/088_maintenance_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/040_licenses_in_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_maintenance/088_maintenance_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-14 using the exact controlled facts ['11%', '18%'].", "id": "findings.F-14.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-14's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-14.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-15', 'Isaac Romero'] for F-14.", "id": "findings.F-14.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-15 exception for cease-and-desist deadline.", "id": "findings.F-15.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's id from /workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/043_licenses_out_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_security_interests/091_security_interests_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's issue from /workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/043_licenses_out_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_security_interests/091_security_interests_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's severity from /workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/043_licenses_out_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_security_interests/091_security_interests_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's primary_source from /workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/043_licenses_out_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_security_interests/091_security_interests_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/043_licenses_out_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_security_interests/091_security_interests_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-15 using the exact controlled facts ['notices-drift_audio_labs@example.test', 'archive-silver_reed_composers_llc@example.test'].", "id": "findings.F-15.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-15's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-15.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-15', 'Sofia Bennett'] for F-15.", "id": "findings.F-15.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-16 exception for security-interest release gap.", "id": "findings.F-16.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's id from /workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/046_licenses_out_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_security_interests/094_security_interests_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's issue from /workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/046_licenses_out_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_security_interests/094_security_interests_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's severity from /workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/046_licenses_out_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_security_interests/094_security_interests_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's primary_source from /workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/046_licenses_out_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_security_interests/094_security_interests_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/046_licenses_out_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_security_interests/094_security_interests_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-16 using the exact controlled facts ['74 records', '2025-06-18', '69 records', '2025-07-29'].", "id": "findings.F-16.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-16's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-16.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-15', 'Adrian Mensah'] for F-16.", "id": "findings.F-16.action_anchors"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Executive assessment' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Executive assessment"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Method and record coverage' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Method and record coverage"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Findings' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Findings"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Recommended next actions' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Recommended next actions"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Assumptions and limitations' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Assumptions and limitations"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-01 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-01"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-02 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-02"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-03 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-03"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-04 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-04"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-05 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-05"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-06 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-06"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-07 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-07"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-08 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-08"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-09 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-09"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-10 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-10"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-11 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-11"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-12 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-12"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-13 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-13"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-14 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-14"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-15 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-15"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-16 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-16"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Do not claim the production has no issues or that every record is consistent.", "id": "memo.forbidden_claims_absent"}], "decision_options": [{"id": "cross-source-reconciliation", "label": "Reconcile controlling and corroborating records", "reason": "The CB-IP-3204 production contains independently maintained records; a defensible answer must preserve each supported conflict and its cure owner.", "selected": true}, {"id": "latest-record-controls", "label": "Treat the latest record as controlling", "reason": "Timestamp recency does not establish legal priority, execution, or approval authority.", "selected": false}, {"id": "primary-records-only", "label": "Report primary records without reconciliation", "reason": "Primary records alone conceal the operational conflicts that create the actionable exceptions.", "selected": false}], "gates": ["all_evidence_read_in_full", "chain_of_custody_metadata_checked", "findings_criteria_complete", "memo_criteria_complete", "deliverables_written_through_mcp"], "metadata_checks": 8, "metric": "weighted_criteria_score", "minimum_tool_calls": 46, "required_deliverables": ["findings.json", "advice.md"], "required_document_reads": 33, "type": "deterministic", "weights": {"findings": 0.55, "memo": 0.2, "procedure": 0.25}}, "task_id": "cb100-084-drift-audio", "task_name": "Drift Audio catalog ownership audit", "world_id": "counselbench-filesystem-mcp-v2"}
-{"context_files": ["task_files/cb100-085-everglass-medical/01_patents/001_patents_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-085-everglass-medical/01_patents/002_patents_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-085-everglass-medical/01_patents/003_patents_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-085-everglass-medical/01_patents/004_patents_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-085-everglass-medical/01_patents/005_patents_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-085-everglass-medical/01_patents/006_patents_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-085-everglass-medical/01_patents/007_patents_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-085-everglass-medical/01_patents/008_patents_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-085-everglass-medical/02_trademarks/009_trademarks_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-085-everglass-medical/02_trademarks/010_trademarks_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-085-everglass-medical/02_trademarks/011_trademarks_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-085-everglass-medical/02_trademarks/012_trademarks_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-085-everglass-medical/02_trademarks/013_trademarks_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-085-everglass-medical/02_trademarks/014_trademarks_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-085-everglass-medical/02_trademarks/015_trademarks_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-085-everglass-medical/02_trademarks/016_trademarks_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-085-everglass-medical/03_copyrights/017_copyrights_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-085-everglass-medical/03_copyrights/018_copyrights_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-085-everglass-medical/03_copyrights/019_copyrights_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-085-everglass-medical/03_copyrights/020_copyrights_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-085-everglass-medical/03_copyrights/021_copyrights_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-085-everglass-medical/03_copyrights/022_copyrights_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-085-everglass-medical/03_copyrights/023_copyrights_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-085-everglass-medical/03_copyrights/024_copyrights_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-085-everglass-medical/04_invention_assignments/025_invention_assignments_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-085-everglass-medical/04_invention_assignments/026_invention_assignments_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-085-everglass-medical/04_invention_assignments/027_invention_assignments_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-085-everglass-medical/04_invention_assignments/028_invention_assignments_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-085-everglass-medical/04_invention_assignments/029_invention_assignments_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-085-everglass-medical/04_invention_assignments/030_invention_assignments_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-085-everglass-medical/04_invention_assignments/031_invention_assignments_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-085-everglass-medical/04_invention_assignments/032_invention_assignments_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-085-everglass-medical/05_licenses_in/033_licenses_in_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-085-everglass-medical/05_licenses_in/034_licenses_in_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-085-everglass-medical/05_licenses_in/035_licenses_in_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-085-everglass-medical/05_licenses_in/036_licenses_in_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-085-everglass-medical/05_licenses_in/037_licenses_in_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-085-everglass-medical/05_licenses_in/038_licenses_in_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-085-everglass-medical/05_licenses_in/039_licenses_in_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-085-everglass-medical/05_licenses_in/040_licenses_in_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-085-everglass-medical/06_licenses_out/041_licenses_out_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-085-everglass-medical/06_licenses_out/042_licenses_out_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-085-everglass-medical/06_licenses_out/043_licenses_out_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-085-everglass-medical/06_licenses_out/044_licenses_out_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-085-everglass-medical/06_licenses_out/045_licenses_out_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-085-everglass-medical/06_licenses_out/046_licenses_out_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-085-everglass-medical/06_licenses_out/047_licenses_out_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-085-everglass-medical/06_licenses_out/048_licenses_out_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-085-everglass-medical/07_open_source/049_open_source_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-085-everglass-medical/07_open_source/050_open_source_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-085-everglass-medical/07_open_source/051_open_source_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-085-everglass-medical/07_open_source/052_open_source_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-085-everglass-medical/07_open_source/053_open_source_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-085-everglass-medical/07_open_source/054_open_source_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-085-everglass-medical/07_open_source/055_open_source_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-085-everglass-medical/07_open_source/056_open_source_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-085-everglass-medical/08_domain_accounts/057_domain_accounts_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-085-everglass-medical/08_domain_accounts/058_domain_accounts_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-085-everglass-medical/08_domain_accounts/059_domain_accounts_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-085-everglass-medical/08_domain_accounts/060_domain_accounts_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-085-everglass-medical/08_domain_accounts/061_domain_accounts_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-085-everglass-medical/08_domain_accounts/062_domain_accounts_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-085-everglass-medical/08_domain_accounts/063_domain_accounts_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-085-everglass-medical/08_domain_accounts/064_domain_accounts_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-085-everglass-medical/09_development_records/065_development_records_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-085-everglass-medical/09_development_records/066_development_records_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-085-everglass-medical/09_development_records/067_development_records_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-085-everglass-medical/09_development_records/068_development_records_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-085-everglass-medical/09_development_records/069_development_records_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-085-everglass-medical/09_development_records/070_development_records_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-085-everglass-medical/09_development_records/071_development_records_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-085-everglass-medical/09_development_records/072_development_records_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-085-everglass-medical/10_disputes/073_disputes_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-085-everglass-medical/10_disputes/074_disputes_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-085-everglass-medical/10_disputes/075_disputes_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-085-everglass-medical/10_disputes/076_disputes_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-085-everglass-medical/10_disputes/077_disputes_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-085-everglass-medical/10_disputes/078_disputes_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-085-everglass-medical/10_disputes/079_disputes_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-085-everglass-medical/10_disputes/080_disputes_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-085-everglass-medical/11_maintenance/081_maintenance_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-085-everglass-medical/11_maintenance/082_maintenance_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-085-everglass-medical/11_maintenance/083_maintenance_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-085-everglass-medical/11_maintenance/084_maintenance_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-085-everglass-medical/11_maintenance/085_maintenance_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-085-everglass-medical/11_maintenance/086_maintenance_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-085-everglass-medical/11_maintenance/087_maintenance_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-085-everglass-medical/11_maintenance/088_maintenance_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-085-everglass-medical/12_security_interests/089_security_interests_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-085-everglass-medical/12_security_interests/090_security_interests_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-085-everglass-medical/12_security_interests/091_security_interests_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-085-everglass-medical/12_security_interests/092_security_interests_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-085-everglass-medical/12_security_interests/093_security_interests_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-085-everglass-medical/12_security_interests/094_security_interests_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-085-everglass-medical/12_security_interests/095_security_interests_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-085-everglass-medical/12_security_interests/096_security_interests_status_report.md"], "gold_output": {"advice_markdown": "# Counsel advice — Everglass patent license diligence\n\n## Executive assessment\n\nFor Everglass Medical Optics matter CB-IP-3205, the review identified 16 source-supported exceptions requiring action before 2026-09-18. The assessment concerns Lakeshore Research University and the supplied record for Wisconsin.\n\n## Method and record coverage\n\nThe review inventoried all 96 production files, read the 33 controlling, corroborating, and control records, searched the email exports, and checked metadata for the designated chain-of-custody sample. Conclusions are limited to the synthetic production supplied for this benchmark matter.\n\n## Findings\n\n### F-01 — inventor assignment gap (critical)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for inventor assignment gap: one source states the operative date is 2025-01-09 under control reference CB-IP-3205-A226, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2025-02-01 under response reference CB-IP-3205-J386.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/01_patents/001_patents_control_register.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/07_open_source/049_open_source_control_register.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-18, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Samuel Kim.\n\n### F-02 — recorded-owner mismatch (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for recorded-owner mismatch: one source states the controlling amount is $1,295,466.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $1,457,432.00.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/01_patents/004_patents_ledger_export.csv`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/07_open_source/052_open_source_ledger_export.csv`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-18, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Maya Ellison.\n\n### F-03 — maintenance-fee deadline (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for maintenance-fee deadline: one source states approval is attributed to Nadine Flores as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Henry Cho and contains no entry for Nadine Flores.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/01_patents/007_patents_officer_certificate.html`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/07_open_source/055_open_source_officer_certificate.html`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-18, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Rafael Okafor.\n\n### F-04 — foreign-filing restriction (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for foreign-filing restriction: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-IP-3205-D194, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-IP-3205-M522.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/02_trademarks/010_trademarks_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/08_domain_accounts/058_domain_accounts_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-18, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Nora Chen.\n\n### F-05 — trademark specimen issue (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for trademark specimen issue: one source states the applicable location is Western District of Wisconsin, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to Wisconsin operations outside Western District of Wisconsin.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/02_trademarks/013_trademarks_review_memorandum.json`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/08_domain_accounts/061_domain_accounts_review_memorandum.json`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-18, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Dominic Alvarez.\n\n### F-06 — coexistence restriction (low)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for coexistence restriction: one source states the threshold is 15% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 22% and produced a different exception result.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/02_trademarks/016_trademarks_status_report.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/08_domain_accounts/064_domain_accounts_status_report.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-18, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Priya Raman.\n\n### F-07 — work-for-hire defect (critical)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for work-for-hire defect: one source states formal notice must use notices-everglass_medical_optics@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-lakeshore_research_university@example.test.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/03_copyrights/019_copyrights_correspondence.eml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/09_development_records/067_development_records_correspondence.eml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-18, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Elliot Mercer.\n\n### F-08 — source-code ownership gap (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for source-code ownership gap: one source states the governed population contains 122 records through 2025-12-23, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 52 records through 2026-01-16.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/03_copyrights/022_copyrights_formal_notice.xml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/09_development_records/070_development_records_formal_notice.xml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-18, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Talia Brooks.\n\n### F-09 — inbound-license field restriction (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for inbound-license field restriction: one source states the operative date is 2025-10-18 under control reference CB-IP-3205-I568, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2025-11-13 under response reference CB-IP-3205-R482.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/025_invention_assignments_control_register.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/10_disputes/073_disputes_control_register.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-18, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Jonas Feld.\n\n### F-10 — outbound sublicense overreach (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for outbound sublicense overreach: one source states the controlling amount is $1,546,826.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $1,800,152.00.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/028_invention_assignments_ledger_export.csv`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/10_disputes/076_disputes_ledger_export.csv`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-18, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Mei Whitaker.\n\n### F-11 — copyleft distribution trigger (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for copyleft distribution trigger: one source states approval is attributed to Nadine Flores as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Caleb Hassan and contains no entry for Nadine Flores.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/031_invention_assignments_officer_certificate.html`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/10_disputes/079_disputes_officer_certificate.html`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-18, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Caleb Hassan.\n\n### F-12 — notice-file omission (low)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for notice-file omission: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-IP-3205-L466, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-IP-3205-U889.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/034_licenses_in_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/11_maintenance/082_maintenance_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-18, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Leona Park.\n\n### F-13 — domain registrant mismatch (critical)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for domain registrant mismatch: one source states the applicable location is Western District of Wisconsin, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to Wisconsin operations outside Western District of Wisconsin.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/037_licenses_in_review_memorandum.json`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/11_maintenance/085_maintenance_review_memorandum.json`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-18, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Isaac Romero.\n\n### F-14 — repository access anomaly (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for repository access anomaly: one source states the threshold is 10% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 14% and produced a different exception result.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/040_licenses_in_status_report.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/11_maintenance/088_maintenance_status_report.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-18, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Sofia Bennett.\n\n### F-15 — cease-and-desist deadline (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for cease-and-desist deadline: one source states formal notice must use notices-everglass_medical_optics@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-lakeshore_research_university@example.test.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/043_licenses_out_correspondence.eml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/091_security_interests_correspondence.eml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-18, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Adrian Mensah.\n\n### F-16 — security-interest release gap (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for security-interest release gap: one source states the governed population contains 117 records through 2025-03-13, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 35 records through 2025-03-20.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/046_licenses_out_formal_notice.xml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/094_security_interests_formal_notice.xml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-18, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Willa Novak.\n\n## Recommended next actions\n\nSequence the critical and high findings first, assign the named owners, preserve the cited records, and document any resolution in the controlling matter register before the stated deadline.\n\n## Assumptions and limitations\n\nThis analysis is confined to task cb100-085-everglass-medical and the supplied synthetic evidence. It does not rely on external facts, does not resolve disputed law, and is not legal advice for a real person or entity.\n", "findings": {"as_of": "2026-09-18", "findings": [{"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/07_open_source/049_open_source_control_register.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for inventor assignment gap: one source states the operative date is 2025-01-09 under control reference CB-IP-3205-A226, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2025-02-01 under response reference CB-IP-3205-J386.", "id": "F-01", "issue": "inventor assignment gap", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/01_patents/001_patents_control_register.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-18, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Samuel Kim.", "severity": "critical"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/07_open_source/052_open_source_ledger_export.csv", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for recorded-owner mismatch: one source states the controlling amount is $1,295,466.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $1,457,432.00.", "id": "F-02", "issue": "recorded-owner mismatch", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/01_patents/004_patents_ledger_export.csv", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-18, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Maya Ellison.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/07_open_source/055_open_source_officer_certificate.html", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for maintenance-fee deadline: one source states approval is attributed to Nadine Flores as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Henry Cho and contains no entry for Nadine Flores.", "id": "F-03", "issue": "maintenance-fee deadline", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/01_patents/007_patents_officer_certificate.html", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-18, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Rafael Okafor.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/08_domain_accounts/058_domain_accounts_executed_instrument.txt", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for foreign-filing restriction: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-IP-3205-D194, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-IP-3205-M522.", "id": "F-04", "issue": "foreign-filing restriction", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/02_trademarks/010_trademarks_executed_instrument.txt", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-18, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Nora Chen.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/08_domain_accounts/061_domain_accounts_review_memorandum.json", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for trademark specimen issue: one source states the applicable location is Western District of Wisconsin, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to Wisconsin operations outside Western District of Wisconsin.", "id": "F-05", "issue": "trademark specimen issue", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/02_trademarks/013_trademarks_review_memorandum.json", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-18, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Dominic Alvarez.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/08_domain_accounts/064_domain_accounts_status_report.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for coexistence restriction: one source states the threshold is 15% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 22% and produced a different exception result.", "id": "F-06", "issue": "coexistence restriction", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/02_trademarks/016_trademarks_status_report.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-18, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Priya Raman.", "severity": "low"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/09_development_records/067_development_records_correspondence.eml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for work-for-hire defect: one source states formal notice must use notices-everglass_medical_optics@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-lakeshore_research_university@example.test.", "id": "F-07", "issue": "work-for-hire defect", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/03_copyrights/019_copyrights_correspondence.eml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-18, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Elliot Mercer.", "severity": "critical"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/09_development_records/070_development_records_formal_notice.xml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for source-code ownership gap: one source states the governed population contains 122 records through 2025-12-23, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 52 records through 2026-01-16.", "id": "F-08", "issue": "source-code ownership gap", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/03_copyrights/022_copyrights_formal_notice.xml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-18, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Talia Brooks.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/10_disputes/073_disputes_control_register.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for inbound-license field restriction: one source states the operative date is 2025-10-18 under control reference CB-IP-3205-I568, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2025-11-13 under response reference CB-IP-3205-R482.", "id": "F-09", "issue": "inbound-license field restriction", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/025_invention_assignments_control_register.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-18, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Jonas Feld.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/10_disputes/076_disputes_ledger_export.csv", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for outbound sublicense overreach: one source states the controlling amount is $1,546,826.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $1,800,152.00.", "id": "F-10", "issue": "outbound sublicense overreach", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/028_invention_assignments_ledger_export.csv", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-18, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Mei Whitaker.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/10_disputes/079_disputes_officer_certificate.html", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for copyleft distribution trigger: one source states approval is attributed to Nadine Flores as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Caleb Hassan and contains no entry for Nadine Flores.", "id": "F-11", "issue": "copyleft distribution trigger", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/031_invention_assignments_officer_certificate.html", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-18, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Caleb Hassan.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/11_maintenance/082_maintenance_executed_instrument.txt", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for notice-file omission: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-IP-3205-L466, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-IP-3205-U889.", "id": "F-12", "issue": "notice-file omission", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/034_licenses_in_executed_instrument.txt", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-18, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Leona Park.", "severity": "low"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/11_maintenance/085_maintenance_review_memorandum.json", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for domain registrant mismatch: one source states the applicable location is Western District of Wisconsin, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to Wisconsin operations outside Western District of Wisconsin.", "id": "F-13", "issue": "domain registrant mismatch", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/037_licenses_in_review_memorandum.json", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-18, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Isaac Romero.", "severity": "critical"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/11_maintenance/088_maintenance_status_report.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for repository access anomaly: one source states the threshold is 10% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 14% and produced a different exception result.", "id": "F-14", "issue": "repository access anomaly", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/040_licenses_in_status_report.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-18, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Sofia Bennett.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/091_security_interests_correspondence.eml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for cease-and-desist deadline: one source states formal notice must use notices-everglass_medical_optics@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-lakeshore_research_university@example.test.", "id": "F-15", "issue": "cease-and-desist deadline", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/043_licenses_out_correspondence.eml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-18, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Adrian Mensah.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/094_security_interests_formal_notice.xml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for security-interest release gap: one source states the governed population contains 117 records through 2025-03-13, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 35 records through 2025-03-20.", "id": "F-16", "issue": "security-interest release gap", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/046_licenses_out_formal_notice.xml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-18, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Willa Novak.", "severity": "medium"}], "matter_number": "CB-IP-3205", "prepared_for": "Everglass Medical Optics", "schema_version": "1.0", "task_id": "cb100-085-everglass-medical"}}, "metadata": {"benchmark": "CounselBench-100", "code_license": "Apache-2.0", "data_license": "CC-BY-4.0", "deadline": "2026-09-18", "document_count": 96, "jurisdiction": "Wisconsin", "matter_number": "CB-IP-3205", "mcp_commit": "9a96ea6e5913736f92b88345bf51caeaaa8e719f", "mcp_package": "@modelcontextprotocol/server-filesystem@2026.7.10", "practice_area": "ip-technology", "reference_tool_calls": 46, "required_evidence_reads": 33, "synthetic": true, "venue": "Western District of Wisconsin", "version": "2.0.0"}, "prompt": "You are intellectual-property counsel for Everglass Medical Optics. Outside counsel inherited this file after turnover on the client team and must validate every operative record before advising. University optical patents carry diligence milestones, sublicense economics, government rights, and maintenance obligations. Decision due 2026-09-18. Wisconsin law governs; Western District of Wisconsin is the forum. Evaluate both legal consequence and the practical owner needed to cure each exception. Work out the defensible position from the matter production and leave an audit-ready exception tracker and concise advice for the supervising lawyer. Keep confirmed conflicts separate from open questions, cite the records that actually control each conclusion, and do not fill gaps with outside facts.", "rubric": {"criteria": [{"category": "procedure", "description": "Complete at least 46 successful, argument-specific evidence and output calls.", "id": "procedure.minimum_successful_tool_calls"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Find and read the 33 controlling, corroborating, and work-product-control records in full.", "id": "procedure.all_evidence_read_in_full"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Inspect file metadata for the eight designated critical primary records before relying on them.", "id": "procedure.chain_of_custody_metadata_checked"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Confirm the sandbox's allowed document and output roots.", "id": "procedure.allowed_directories_checked"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Inventory all 96 records so the relevant sources are discovered among the context records.", "id": "procedure.recursive_inventory_completed"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Search the production for email evidence that may corroborate or contradict formal records.", "id": "procedure.targeted_search_completed"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Leave only findings.json and advice.md in the output workspace.", "id": "procedure.exact_deliverable_set"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Create both final work products through the sandbox MCP surface.", "id": "procedure.deliverables_written_through_mcp"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Produce findings.json as a valid JSON object.", "id": "findings.findings_is_object"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Report exactly 16 confirmed exceptions.", "id": "findings.findings_exact_count"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Use each stable finding ID exactly once.", "id": "findings.finding_ids_unique"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set schema_version to the released matter value '1.0'.", "id": "findings.top_level_schema_version"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set task_id to the released matter value 'cb100-085-everglass-medical'.", "id": "findings.top_level_task_id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set matter_number to the released matter value 'CB-IP-3205'.", "id": "findings.top_level_matter_number"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set prepared_for to the released matter value 'Everglass Medical Optics'.", "id": "findings.top_level_prepared_for"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set as_of to the released matter value '2026-09-18'.", "id": "findings.top_level_as_of"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-01 exception for inventor assignment gap.", "id": "findings.F-01.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's id from /workspace/documents/01_patents/001_patents_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_open_source/049_open_source_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's issue from /workspace/documents/01_patents/001_patents_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_open_source/049_open_source_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's severity from /workspace/documents/01_patents/001_patents_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_open_source/049_open_source_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's primary_source from /workspace/documents/01_patents/001_patents_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_open_source/049_open_source_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/01_patents/001_patents_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_open_source/049_open_source_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-01 using the exact controlled facts ['2025-01-09', 'CB-IP-3205-A226', '2025-02-01', 'CB-IP-3205-J386'].", "id": "findings.F-01.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-01's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-01.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-18', 'Samuel Kim'] for F-01.", "id": "findings.F-01.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-02 exception for recorded-owner mismatch.", "id": "findings.F-02.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's id from /workspace/documents/01_patents/004_patents_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_open_source/052_open_source_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's issue from /workspace/documents/01_patents/004_patents_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_open_source/052_open_source_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's severity from /workspace/documents/01_patents/004_patents_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_open_source/052_open_source_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's primary_source from /workspace/documents/01_patents/004_patents_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_open_source/052_open_source_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/01_patents/004_patents_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_open_source/052_open_source_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-02 using the exact controlled facts ['$1,295,466.00', '$1,457,432.00'].", "id": "findings.F-02.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-02's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-02.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-18', 'Maya Ellison'] for F-02.", "id": "findings.F-02.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-03 exception for maintenance-fee deadline.", "id": "findings.F-03.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's id from /workspace/documents/01_patents/007_patents_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_open_source/055_open_source_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's issue from /workspace/documents/01_patents/007_patents_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_open_source/055_open_source_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's severity from /workspace/documents/01_patents/007_patents_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_open_source/055_open_source_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's primary_source from /workspace/documents/01_patents/007_patents_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_open_source/055_open_source_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/01_patents/007_patents_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_open_source/055_open_source_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-03 using the exact controlled facts ['Nadine Flores', 'Henry Cho'].", "id": "findings.F-03.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-03's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-03.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-18', 'Rafael Okafor'] for F-03.", "id": "findings.F-03.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-04 exception for foreign-filing restriction.", "id": "findings.F-04.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's id from /workspace/documents/02_trademarks/010_trademarks_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_domain_accounts/058_domain_accounts_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's issue from /workspace/documents/02_trademarks/010_trademarks_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_domain_accounts/058_domain_accounts_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's severity from /workspace/documents/02_trademarks/010_trademarks_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_domain_accounts/058_domain_accounts_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's primary_source from /workspace/documents/02_trademarks/010_trademarks_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_domain_accounts/058_domain_accounts_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/02_trademarks/010_trademarks_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_domain_accounts/058_domain_accounts_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-04 using the exact controlled facts ['closed without exception', 'CB-IP-3205-D194', 'open and escalated', 'CB-IP-3205-M522'].", "id": "findings.F-04.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-04's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-04.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-18', 'Nora Chen'] for F-04.", "id": "findings.F-04.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-05 exception for trademark specimen issue.", "id": "findings.F-05.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's id from /workspace/documents/02_trademarks/013_trademarks_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_domain_accounts/061_domain_accounts_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's issue from /workspace/documents/02_trademarks/013_trademarks_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_domain_accounts/061_domain_accounts_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's severity from /workspace/documents/02_trademarks/013_trademarks_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_domain_accounts/061_domain_accounts_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's primary_source from /workspace/documents/02_trademarks/013_trademarks_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_domain_accounts/061_domain_accounts_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/02_trademarks/013_trademarks_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_domain_accounts/061_domain_accounts_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-05 using the exact controlled facts ['Western District of Wisconsin', 'Wisconsin'].", "id": "findings.F-05.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-05's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-05.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-18', 'Dominic Alvarez'] for F-05.", "id": "findings.F-05.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-06 exception for coexistence restriction.", "id": "findings.F-06.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's id from /workspace/documents/02_trademarks/016_trademarks_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_domain_accounts/064_domain_accounts_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's issue from /workspace/documents/02_trademarks/016_trademarks_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_domain_accounts/064_domain_accounts_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's severity from /workspace/documents/02_trademarks/016_trademarks_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_domain_accounts/064_domain_accounts_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's primary_source from /workspace/documents/02_trademarks/016_trademarks_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_domain_accounts/064_domain_accounts_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/02_trademarks/016_trademarks_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_domain_accounts/064_domain_accounts_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-06 using the exact controlled facts ['15%', '22%'].", "id": "findings.F-06.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-06's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-06.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-18', 'Priya Raman'] for F-06.", "id": "findings.F-06.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-07 exception for work-for-hire defect.", "id": "findings.F-07.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's id from /workspace/documents/03_copyrights/019_copyrights_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_development_records/067_development_records_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's issue from /workspace/documents/03_copyrights/019_copyrights_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_development_records/067_development_records_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's severity from /workspace/documents/03_copyrights/019_copyrights_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_development_records/067_development_records_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's primary_source from /workspace/documents/03_copyrights/019_copyrights_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_development_records/067_development_records_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/03_copyrights/019_copyrights_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_development_records/067_development_records_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-07 using the exact controlled facts ['notices-everglass_medical_optics@example.test', 'archive-lakeshore_research_university@example.test'].", "id": "findings.F-07.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-07's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-07.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-18', 'Elliot Mercer'] for F-07.", "id": "findings.F-07.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-08 exception for source-code ownership gap.", "id": "findings.F-08.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's id from /workspace/documents/03_copyrights/022_copyrights_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_development_records/070_development_records_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's issue from /workspace/documents/03_copyrights/022_copyrights_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_development_records/070_development_records_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's severity from /workspace/documents/03_copyrights/022_copyrights_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_development_records/070_development_records_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's primary_source from /workspace/documents/03_copyrights/022_copyrights_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_development_records/070_development_records_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/03_copyrights/022_copyrights_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_development_records/070_development_records_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-08 using the exact controlled facts ['122 records', '2025-12-23', '52 records', '2026-01-16'].", "id": "findings.F-08.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-08's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-08.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-18', 'Talia Brooks'] for F-08.", "id": "findings.F-08.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-09 exception for inbound-license field restriction.", "id": "findings.F-09.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's id from /workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/025_invention_assignments_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_disputes/073_disputes_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's issue from /workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/025_invention_assignments_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_disputes/073_disputes_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's severity from /workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/025_invention_assignments_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_disputes/073_disputes_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's primary_source from /workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/025_invention_assignments_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_disputes/073_disputes_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/025_invention_assignments_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_disputes/073_disputes_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-09 using the exact controlled facts ['2025-10-18', 'CB-IP-3205-I568', '2025-11-13', 'CB-IP-3205-R482'].", "id": "findings.F-09.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-09's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-09.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-18', 'Jonas Feld'] for F-09.", "id": "findings.F-09.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-10 exception for outbound sublicense overreach.", "id": "findings.F-10.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's id from /workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/028_invention_assignments_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_disputes/076_disputes_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's issue from /workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/028_invention_assignments_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_disputes/076_disputes_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's severity from /workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/028_invention_assignments_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_disputes/076_disputes_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's primary_source from /workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/028_invention_assignments_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_disputes/076_disputes_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/028_invention_assignments_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_disputes/076_disputes_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-10 using the exact controlled facts ['$1,546,826.00', '$1,800,152.00'].", "id": "findings.F-10.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-10's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-10.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-18', 'Mei Whitaker'] for F-10.", "id": "findings.F-10.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-11 exception for copyleft distribution trigger.", "id": "findings.F-11.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's id from /workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/031_invention_assignments_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_disputes/079_disputes_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's issue from /workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/031_invention_assignments_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_disputes/079_disputes_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's severity from /workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/031_invention_assignments_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_disputes/079_disputes_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's primary_source from /workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/031_invention_assignments_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_disputes/079_disputes_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/031_invention_assignments_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_disputes/079_disputes_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-11 using the exact controlled facts ['Nadine Flores', 'Caleb Hassan'].", "id": "findings.F-11.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-11's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-11.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-18', 'Caleb Hassan'] for F-11.", "id": "findings.F-11.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-12 exception for notice-file omission.", "id": "findings.F-12.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's id from /workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/034_licenses_in_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_maintenance/082_maintenance_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's issue from /workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/034_licenses_in_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_maintenance/082_maintenance_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's severity from /workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/034_licenses_in_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_maintenance/082_maintenance_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's primary_source from /workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/034_licenses_in_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_maintenance/082_maintenance_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/034_licenses_in_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_maintenance/082_maintenance_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-12 using the exact controlled facts ['closed without exception', 'CB-IP-3205-L466', 'open and escalated', 'CB-IP-3205-U889'].", "id": "findings.F-12.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-12's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-12.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-18', 'Leona Park'] for F-12.", "id": "findings.F-12.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-13 exception for domain registrant mismatch.", "id": "findings.F-13.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's id from /workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/037_licenses_in_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_maintenance/085_maintenance_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's issue from /workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/037_licenses_in_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_maintenance/085_maintenance_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's severity from /workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/037_licenses_in_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_maintenance/085_maintenance_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's primary_source from /workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/037_licenses_in_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_maintenance/085_maintenance_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/037_licenses_in_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_maintenance/085_maintenance_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-13 using the exact controlled facts ['Western District of Wisconsin', 'Wisconsin'].", "id": "findings.F-13.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-13's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-13.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-18', 'Isaac Romero'] for F-13.", "id": "findings.F-13.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-14 exception for repository access anomaly.", "id": "findings.F-14.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's id from /workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/040_licenses_in_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_maintenance/088_maintenance_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's issue from /workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/040_licenses_in_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_maintenance/088_maintenance_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's severity from /workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/040_licenses_in_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_maintenance/088_maintenance_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's primary_source from /workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/040_licenses_in_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_maintenance/088_maintenance_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/040_licenses_in_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_maintenance/088_maintenance_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-14 using the exact controlled facts ['10%', '14%'].", "id": "findings.F-14.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-14's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-14.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-18', 'Sofia Bennett'] for F-14.", "id": "findings.F-14.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-15 exception for cease-and-desist deadline.", "id": "findings.F-15.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's id from /workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/043_licenses_out_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_security_interests/091_security_interests_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's issue from /workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/043_licenses_out_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_security_interests/091_security_interests_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's severity from /workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/043_licenses_out_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_security_interests/091_security_interests_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's primary_source from /workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/043_licenses_out_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_security_interests/091_security_interests_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/043_licenses_out_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_security_interests/091_security_interests_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-15 using the exact controlled facts ['notices-everglass_medical_optics@example.test', 'archive-lakeshore_research_university@example.test'].", "id": "findings.F-15.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-15's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-15.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-18', 'Adrian Mensah'] for F-15.", "id": "findings.F-15.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-16 exception for security-interest release gap.", "id": "findings.F-16.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's id from /workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/046_licenses_out_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_security_interests/094_security_interests_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's issue from /workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/046_licenses_out_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_security_interests/094_security_interests_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's severity from /workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/046_licenses_out_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_security_interests/094_security_interests_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's primary_source from /workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/046_licenses_out_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_security_interests/094_security_interests_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/046_licenses_out_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_security_interests/094_security_interests_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-16 using the exact controlled facts ['117 records', '2025-03-13', '35 records', '2025-03-20'].", "id": "findings.F-16.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-16's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-16.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-18', 'Willa Novak'] for F-16.", "id": "findings.F-16.action_anchors"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Executive assessment' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Executive assessment"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Method and record coverage' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Method and record coverage"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Findings' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Findings"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Recommended next actions' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Recommended next actions"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Assumptions and limitations' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Assumptions and limitations"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-01 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-01"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-02 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-02"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-03 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-03"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-04 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-04"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-05 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-05"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-06 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-06"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-07 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-07"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-08 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-08"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-09 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-09"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-10 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-10"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-11 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-11"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-12 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-12"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-13 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-13"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-14 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-14"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-15 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-15"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-16 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-16"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Do not claim the production has no issues or that every record is consistent.", "id": "memo.forbidden_claims_absent"}], "decision_options": [{"id": "cross-source-reconciliation", "label": "Reconcile controlling and corroborating records", "reason": "The CB-IP-3205 production contains independently maintained records; a defensible answer must preserve each supported conflict and its cure owner.", "selected": true}, {"id": "latest-record-controls", "label": "Treat the latest record as controlling", "reason": "Timestamp recency does not establish legal priority, execution, or approval authority.", "selected": false}, {"id": "primary-records-only", "label": "Report primary records without reconciliation", "reason": "Primary records alone conceal the operational conflicts that create the actionable exceptions.", "selected": false}], "gates": ["all_evidence_read_in_full", "chain_of_custody_metadata_checked", "findings_criteria_complete", "memo_criteria_complete", "deliverables_written_through_mcp"], "metadata_checks": 8, "metric": "weighted_criteria_score", "minimum_tool_calls": 46, "required_deliverables": ["findings.json", "advice.md"], "required_document_reads": 33, "type": "deterministic", "weights": {"findings": 0.55, "memo": 0.2, "procedure": 0.25}}, "task_id": "cb100-085-everglass-medical", "task_name": "Everglass patent license diligence", "world_id": "counselbench-filesystem-mcp-v2"}
-{"context_files": ["task_files/cb100-086-frostline-security/01_patents/001_patents_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-086-frostline-security/01_patents/002_patents_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-086-frostline-security/01_patents/003_patents_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-086-frostline-security/01_patents/004_patents_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-086-frostline-security/01_patents/005_patents_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-086-frostline-security/01_patents/006_patents_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-086-frostline-security/01_patents/007_patents_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-086-frostline-security/01_patents/008_patents_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-086-frostline-security/02_trademarks/009_trademarks_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-086-frostline-security/02_trademarks/010_trademarks_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-086-frostline-security/02_trademarks/011_trademarks_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-086-frostline-security/02_trademarks/012_trademarks_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-086-frostline-security/02_trademarks/013_trademarks_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-086-frostline-security/02_trademarks/014_trademarks_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-086-frostline-security/02_trademarks/015_trademarks_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-086-frostline-security/02_trademarks/016_trademarks_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-086-frostline-security/03_copyrights/017_copyrights_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-086-frostline-security/03_copyrights/018_copyrights_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-086-frostline-security/03_copyrights/019_copyrights_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-086-frostline-security/03_copyrights/020_copyrights_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-086-frostline-security/03_copyrights/021_copyrights_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-086-frostline-security/03_copyrights/022_copyrights_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-086-frostline-security/03_copyrights/023_copyrights_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-086-frostline-security/03_copyrights/024_copyrights_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-086-frostline-security/04_invention_assignments/025_invention_assignments_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-086-frostline-security/04_invention_assignments/026_invention_assignments_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-086-frostline-security/04_invention_assignments/027_invention_assignments_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-086-frostline-security/04_invention_assignments/028_invention_assignments_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-086-frostline-security/04_invention_assignments/029_invention_assignments_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-086-frostline-security/04_invention_assignments/030_invention_assignments_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-086-frostline-security/04_invention_assignments/031_invention_assignments_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-086-frostline-security/04_invention_assignments/032_invention_assignments_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-086-frostline-security/05_licenses_in/033_licenses_in_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-086-frostline-security/05_licenses_in/034_licenses_in_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-086-frostline-security/05_licenses_in/035_licenses_in_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-086-frostline-security/05_licenses_in/036_licenses_in_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-086-frostline-security/05_licenses_in/037_licenses_in_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-086-frostline-security/05_licenses_in/038_licenses_in_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-086-frostline-security/05_licenses_in/039_licenses_in_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-086-frostline-security/05_licenses_in/040_licenses_in_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-086-frostline-security/06_licenses_out/041_licenses_out_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-086-frostline-security/06_licenses_out/042_licenses_out_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-086-frostline-security/06_licenses_out/043_licenses_out_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-086-frostline-security/06_licenses_out/044_licenses_out_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-086-frostline-security/06_licenses_out/045_licenses_out_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-086-frostline-security/06_licenses_out/046_licenses_out_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-086-frostline-security/06_licenses_out/047_licenses_out_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-086-frostline-security/06_licenses_out/048_licenses_out_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-086-frostline-security/07_open_source/049_open_source_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-086-frostline-security/07_open_source/050_open_source_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-086-frostline-security/07_open_source/051_open_source_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-086-frostline-security/07_open_source/052_open_source_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-086-frostline-security/07_open_source/053_open_source_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-086-frostline-security/07_open_source/054_open_source_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-086-frostline-security/07_open_source/055_open_source_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-086-frostline-security/07_open_source/056_open_source_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-086-frostline-security/08_domain_accounts/057_domain_accounts_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-086-frostline-security/08_domain_accounts/058_domain_accounts_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-086-frostline-security/08_domain_accounts/059_domain_accounts_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-086-frostline-security/08_domain_accounts/060_domain_accounts_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-086-frostline-security/08_domain_accounts/061_domain_accounts_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-086-frostline-security/08_domain_accounts/062_domain_accounts_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-086-frostline-security/08_domain_accounts/063_domain_accounts_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-086-frostline-security/08_domain_accounts/064_domain_accounts_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-086-frostline-security/09_development_records/065_development_records_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-086-frostline-security/09_development_records/066_development_records_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-086-frostline-security/09_development_records/067_development_records_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-086-frostline-security/09_development_records/068_development_records_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-086-frostline-security/09_development_records/069_development_records_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-086-frostline-security/09_development_records/070_development_records_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-086-frostline-security/09_development_records/071_development_records_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-086-frostline-security/09_development_records/072_development_records_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-086-frostline-security/10_disputes/073_disputes_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-086-frostline-security/10_disputes/074_disputes_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-086-frostline-security/10_disputes/075_disputes_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-086-frostline-security/10_disputes/076_disputes_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-086-frostline-security/10_disputes/077_disputes_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-086-frostline-security/10_disputes/078_disputes_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-086-frostline-security/10_disputes/079_disputes_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-086-frostline-security/10_disputes/080_disputes_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-086-frostline-security/11_maintenance/081_maintenance_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-086-frostline-security/11_maintenance/082_maintenance_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-086-frostline-security/11_maintenance/083_maintenance_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-086-frostline-security/11_maintenance/084_maintenance_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-086-frostline-security/11_maintenance/085_maintenance_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-086-frostline-security/11_maintenance/086_maintenance_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-086-frostline-security/11_maintenance/087_maintenance_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-086-frostline-security/11_maintenance/088_maintenance_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-086-frostline-security/12_security_interests/089_security_interests_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-086-frostline-security/12_security_interests/090_security_interests_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-086-frostline-security/12_security_interests/091_security_interests_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-086-frostline-security/12_security_interests/092_security_interests_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-086-frostline-security/12_security_interests/093_security_interests_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-086-frostline-security/12_security_interests/094_security_interests_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-086-frostline-security/12_security_interests/095_security_interests_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-086-frostline-security/12_security_interests/096_security_interests_status_report.md"], "gold_output": {"advice_markdown": "# Counsel advice — Frostline software provenance audit\n\n## Executive assessment\n\nFor Frostline Security Software matter CB-IP-3206, the review identified 16 source-supported exceptions requiring action before 2026-09-22. The assessment concerns Open Harbor Foundation and the supplied record for Massachusetts.\n\n## Method and record coverage\n\nThe review inventoried all 96 production files, read the 33 controlling, corroborating, and control records, searched the email exports, and checked metadata for the designated chain-of-custody sample. Conclusions are limited to the synthetic production supplied for this benchmark matter.\n\n## Findings\n\n### F-01 — inventor assignment gap (critical)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for inventor assignment gap: one source states the operative date is 2025-02-20 under control reference CB-IP-3206-A748, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2025-03-25 under response reference CB-IP-3206-J426.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/01_patents/001_patents_control_register.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/07_open_source/049_open_source_control_register.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-22, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Maya Ellison.\n\n### F-02 — recorded-owner mismatch (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for recorded-owner mismatch: one source states the controlling amount is $6,766,506.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $7,079,512.00.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/01_patents/004_patents_ledger_export.csv`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/07_open_source/052_open_source_ledger_export.csv`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-22, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Rafael Okafor.\n\n### F-03 — maintenance-fee deadline (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for maintenance-fee deadline: one source states approval is attributed to Micah Sullivan as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Micah Sullivan and contains no entry for Micah Sullivan.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/01_patents/007_patents_officer_certificate.html`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/07_open_source/055_open_source_officer_certificate.html`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-22, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Nora Chen.\n\n### F-04 — foreign-filing restriction (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for foreign-filing restriction: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-IP-3206-D405, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-IP-3206-M608.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/02_trademarks/010_trademarks_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/08_domain_accounts/058_domain_accounts_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-22, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Dominic Alvarez.\n\n### F-05 — trademark specimen issue (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for trademark specimen issue: one source states the applicable location is District of Massachusetts, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to Massachusetts operations outside District of Massachusetts.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/02_trademarks/013_trademarks_review_memorandum.json`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/08_domain_accounts/061_domain_accounts_review_memorandum.json`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-22, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Priya Raman.\n\n### F-06 — coexistence restriction (low)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for coexistence restriction: one source states the threshold is 8% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 10% and produced a different exception result.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/02_trademarks/016_trademarks_status_report.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/08_domain_accounts/064_domain_accounts_status_report.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-22, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Elliot Mercer.\n\n### F-07 — work-for-hire defect (critical)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for work-for-hire defect: one source states formal notice must use notices-frostline_security_software@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-open_harbor_foundation@example.test.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/03_copyrights/019_copyrights_correspondence.eml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/09_development_records/067_development_records_correspondence.eml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-22, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Talia Brooks.\n\n### F-08 — source-code ownership gap (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for source-code ownership gap: one source states the governed population contains 95 records through 2025-11-26, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 62 records through 2025-12-30.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/03_copyrights/022_copyrights_formal_notice.xml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/09_development_records/070_development_records_formal_notice.xml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-22, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Jonas Feld.\n\n### F-09 — inbound-license field restriction (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for inbound-license field restriction: one source states the operative date is 2025-04-03 under control reference CB-IP-3206-I550, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2025-04-27 under response reference CB-IP-3206-R480.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/025_invention_assignments_control_register.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/10_disputes/073_disputes_control_register.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-22, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Mei Whitaker.\n\n### F-10 — outbound sublicense overreach (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for outbound sublicense overreach: one source states the controlling amount is $3,552,773.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $3,632,046.00.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/028_invention_assignments_ledger_export.csv`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/10_disputes/076_disputes_ledger_export.csv`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-22, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Caleb Hassan.\n\n### F-11 — copyleft distribution trigger (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for copyleft distribution trigger: one source states approval is attributed to Micah Sullivan as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Isaac Romero and contains no entry for Micah Sullivan.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/031_invention_assignments_officer_certificate.html`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/10_disputes/079_disputes_officer_certificate.html`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-22, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Leona Park.\n\n### F-12 — notice-file omission (low)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for notice-file omission: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-IP-3206-L117, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-IP-3206-U724.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/034_licenses_in_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/11_maintenance/082_maintenance_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-22, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Isaac Romero.\n\n### F-13 — domain registrant mismatch (critical)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for domain registrant mismatch: one source states the applicable location is District of Massachusetts, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to Massachusetts operations outside District of Massachusetts.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/037_licenses_in_review_memorandum.json`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/11_maintenance/085_maintenance_review_memorandum.json`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-22, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Sofia Bennett.\n\n### F-14 — repository access anomaly (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for repository access anomaly: one source states the threshold is 6% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 8% and produced a different exception result.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/040_licenses_in_status_report.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/11_maintenance/088_maintenance_status_report.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-22, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Adrian Mensah.\n\n### F-15 — cease-and-desist deadline (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for cease-and-desist deadline: one source states formal notice must use notices-frostline_security_software@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-open_harbor_foundation@example.test.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/043_licenses_out_correspondence.eml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/091_security_interests_correspondence.eml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-22, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Willa Novak.\n\n### F-16 — security-interest release gap (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for security-interest release gap: one source states the governed population contains 176 records through 2025-09-28, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 52 records through 2025-10-22.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/046_licenses_out_formal_notice.xml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/094_security_interests_formal_notice.xml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-22, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Theo Laurent.\n\n## Recommended next actions\n\nSequence the critical and high findings first, assign the named owners, preserve the cited records, and document any resolution in the controlling matter register before the stated deadline.\n\n## Assumptions and limitations\n\nThis analysis is confined to task cb100-086-frostline-security and the supplied synthetic evidence. It does not rely on external facts, does not resolve disputed law, and is not legal advice for a real person or entity.\n", "findings": {"as_of": "2026-09-22", "findings": [{"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/07_open_source/049_open_source_control_register.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for inventor assignment gap: one source states the operative date is 2025-02-20 under control reference CB-IP-3206-A748, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2025-03-25 under response reference CB-IP-3206-J426.", "id": "F-01", "issue": "inventor assignment gap", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/01_patents/001_patents_control_register.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-22, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Maya Ellison.", "severity": "critical"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/07_open_source/052_open_source_ledger_export.csv", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for recorded-owner mismatch: one source states the controlling amount is $6,766,506.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $7,079,512.00.", "id": "F-02", "issue": "recorded-owner mismatch", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/01_patents/004_patents_ledger_export.csv", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-22, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Rafael Okafor.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/07_open_source/055_open_source_officer_certificate.html", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for maintenance-fee deadline: one source states approval is attributed to Micah Sullivan as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Micah Sullivan and contains no entry for Micah Sullivan.", "id": "F-03", "issue": "maintenance-fee deadline", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/01_patents/007_patents_officer_certificate.html", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-22, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Nora Chen.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/08_domain_accounts/058_domain_accounts_executed_instrument.txt", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for foreign-filing restriction: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-IP-3206-D405, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-IP-3206-M608.", "id": "F-04", "issue": "foreign-filing restriction", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/02_trademarks/010_trademarks_executed_instrument.txt", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-22, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Dominic Alvarez.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/08_domain_accounts/061_domain_accounts_review_memorandum.json", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for trademark specimen issue: one source states the applicable location is District of Massachusetts, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to Massachusetts operations outside District of Massachusetts.", "id": "F-05", "issue": "trademark specimen issue", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/02_trademarks/013_trademarks_review_memorandum.json", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-22, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Priya Raman.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/08_domain_accounts/064_domain_accounts_status_report.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for coexistence restriction: one source states the threshold is 8% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 10% and produced a different exception result.", "id": "F-06", "issue": "coexistence restriction", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/02_trademarks/016_trademarks_status_report.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-22, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Elliot Mercer.", "severity": "low"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/09_development_records/067_development_records_correspondence.eml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for work-for-hire defect: one source states formal notice must use notices-frostline_security_software@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-open_harbor_foundation@example.test.", "id": "F-07", "issue": "work-for-hire defect", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/03_copyrights/019_copyrights_correspondence.eml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-22, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Talia Brooks.", "severity": "critical"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/09_development_records/070_development_records_formal_notice.xml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for source-code ownership gap: one source states the governed population contains 95 records through 2025-11-26, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 62 records through 2025-12-30.", "id": "F-08", "issue": "source-code ownership gap", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/03_copyrights/022_copyrights_formal_notice.xml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-22, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Jonas Feld.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/10_disputes/073_disputes_control_register.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for inbound-license field restriction: one source states the operative date is 2025-04-03 under control reference CB-IP-3206-I550, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2025-04-27 under response reference CB-IP-3206-R480.", "id": "F-09", "issue": "inbound-license field restriction", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/025_invention_assignments_control_register.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-22, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Mei Whitaker.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/10_disputes/076_disputes_ledger_export.csv", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for outbound sublicense overreach: one source states the controlling amount is $3,552,773.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $3,632,046.00.", "id": "F-10", "issue": "outbound sublicense overreach", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/028_invention_assignments_ledger_export.csv", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-22, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Caleb Hassan.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/10_disputes/079_disputes_officer_certificate.html", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for copyleft distribution trigger: one source states approval is attributed to Micah Sullivan as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Isaac Romero and contains no entry for Micah Sullivan.", "id": "F-11", "issue": "copyleft distribution trigger", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/031_invention_assignments_officer_certificate.html", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-22, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Leona Park.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/11_maintenance/082_maintenance_executed_instrument.txt", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for notice-file omission: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-IP-3206-L117, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-IP-3206-U724.", "id": "F-12", "issue": "notice-file omission", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/034_licenses_in_executed_instrument.txt", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-22, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Isaac Romero.", "severity": "low"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/11_maintenance/085_maintenance_review_memorandum.json", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for domain registrant mismatch: one source states the applicable location is District of Massachusetts, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to Massachusetts operations outside District of Massachusetts.", "id": "F-13", "issue": "domain registrant mismatch", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/037_licenses_in_review_memorandum.json", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-22, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Sofia Bennett.", "severity": "critical"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/11_maintenance/088_maintenance_status_report.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for repository access anomaly: one source states the threshold is 6% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 8% and produced a different exception result.", "id": "F-14", "issue": "repository access anomaly", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/040_licenses_in_status_report.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-22, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Adrian Mensah.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/091_security_interests_correspondence.eml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for cease-and-desist deadline: one source states formal notice must use notices-frostline_security_software@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-open_harbor_foundation@example.test.", "id": "F-15", "issue": "cease-and-desist deadline", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/043_licenses_out_correspondence.eml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-22, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Willa Novak.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/094_security_interests_formal_notice.xml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for security-interest release gap: one source states the governed population contains 176 records through 2025-09-28, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 52 records through 2025-10-22.", "id": "F-16", "issue": "security-interest release gap", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/046_licenses_out_formal_notice.xml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-22, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Theo Laurent.", "severity": "medium"}], "matter_number": "CB-IP-3206", "prepared_for": "Frostline Security Software", "schema_version": "1.0", "task_id": "cb100-086-frostline-security"}}, "metadata": {"benchmark": "CounselBench-100", "code_license": "Apache-2.0", "data_license": "CC-BY-4.0", "deadline": "2026-09-22", "document_count": 96, "jurisdiction": "Massachusetts", "matter_number": "CB-IP-3206", "mcp_commit": "9a96ea6e5913736f92b88345bf51caeaaa8e719f", "mcp_package": "@modelcontextprotocol/server-filesystem@2026.7.10", "practice_area": "ip-technology", "reference_tool_calls": 46, "required_evidence_reads": 33, "synthetic": true, "venue": "District of Massachusetts", "version": "2.0.0"}, "prompt": "You are intellectual-property counsel for Frostline Security Software. The upcoming deadline leaves no room for unsupported assumptions, so every conclusion must trace to the supplied production. A security appliance contains open-source packages, contractor modules, outbound licenses, and incomplete notice files. Decision due 2026-09-22. Massachusetts law governs; District of Massachusetts is the forum. Give controlling documents precedence only when the record supports that hierarchy. Work out the defensible position from the matter production and leave an audit-ready exception tracker and concise advice for the supervising lawyer. Keep confirmed conflicts separate from open questions, cite the records that actually control each conclusion, and do not fill gaps with outside facts.", "rubric": {"criteria": [{"category": "procedure", "description": "Complete at least 46 successful, argument-specific evidence and output calls.", "id": "procedure.minimum_successful_tool_calls"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Find and read the 33 controlling, corroborating, and work-product-control records in full.", "id": "procedure.all_evidence_read_in_full"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Inspect file metadata for the eight designated critical primary records before relying on them.", "id": "procedure.chain_of_custody_metadata_checked"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Confirm the sandbox's allowed document and output roots.", "id": "procedure.allowed_directories_checked"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Inventory all 96 records so the relevant sources are discovered among the context records.", "id": "procedure.recursive_inventory_completed"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Search the production for email evidence that may corroborate or contradict formal records.", "id": "procedure.targeted_search_completed"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Leave only findings.json and advice.md in the output workspace.", "id": "procedure.exact_deliverable_set"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Create both final work products through the sandbox MCP surface.", "id": "procedure.deliverables_written_through_mcp"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Produce findings.json as a valid JSON object.", "id": "findings.findings_is_object"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Report exactly 16 confirmed exceptions.", "id": "findings.findings_exact_count"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Use each stable finding ID exactly once.", "id": "findings.finding_ids_unique"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set schema_version to the released matter value '1.0'.", "id": "findings.top_level_schema_version"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set task_id to the released matter value 'cb100-086-frostline-security'.", "id": "findings.top_level_task_id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set matter_number to the released matter value 'CB-IP-3206'.", "id": "findings.top_level_matter_number"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set prepared_for to the released matter value 'Frostline Security Software'.", "id": "findings.top_level_prepared_for"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set as_of to the released matter value '2026-09-22'.", "id": "findings.top_level_as_of"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-01 exception for inventor assignment gap.", "id": "findings.F-01.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's id from /workspace/documents/01_patents/001_patents_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_open_source/049_open_source_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's issue from /workspace/documents/01_patents/001_patents_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_open_source/049_open_source_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's severity from /workspace/documents/01_patents/001_patents_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_open_source/049_open_source_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's primary_source from /workspace/documents/01_patents/001_patents_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_open_source/049_open_source_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/01_patents/001_patents_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_open_source/049_open_source_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-01 using the exact controlled facts ['2025-02-20', 'CB-IP-3206-A748', '2025-03-25', 'CB-IP-3206-J426'].", "id": "findings.F-01.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-01's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-01.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-22', 'Maya Ellison'] for F-01.", "id": "findings.F-01.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-02 exception for recorded-owner mismatch.", "id": "findings.F-02.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's id from /workspace/documents/01_patents/004_patents_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_open_source/052_open_source_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's issue from /workspace/documents/01_patents/004_patents_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_open_source/052_open_source_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's severity from /workspace/documents/01_patents/004_patents_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_open_source/052_open_source_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's primary_source from /workspace/documents/01_patents/004_patents_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_open_source/052_open_source_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/01_patents/004_patents_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_open_source/052_open_source_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-02 using the exact controlled facts ['$6,766,506.00', '$7,079,512.00'].", "id": "findings.F-02.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-02's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-02.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-22', 'Rafael Okafor'] for F-02.", "id": "findings.F-02.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-03 exception for maintenance-fee deadline.", "id": "findings.F-03.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's id from /workspace/documents/01_patents/007_patents_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_open_source/055_open_source_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's issue from /workspace/documents/01_patents/007_patents_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_open_source/055_open_source_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's severity from /workspace/documents/01_patents/007_patents_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_open_source/055_open_source_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's primary_source from /workspace/documents/01_patents/007_patents_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_open_source/055_open_source_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/01_patents/007_patents_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_open_source/055_open_source_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-03 using the exact controlled facts ['Micah Sullivan', 'Micah Sullivan'].", "id": "findings.F-03.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-03's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-03.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-22', 'Nora Chen'] for F-03.", "id": "findings.F-03.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-04 exception for foreign-filing restriction.", "id": "findings.F-04.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's id from /workspace/documents/02_trademarks/010_trademarks_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_domain_accounts/058_domain_accounts_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's issue from /workspace/documents/02_trademarks/010_trademarks_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_domain_accounts/058_domain_accounts_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's severity from /workspace/documents/02_trademarks/010_trademarks_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_domain_accounts/058_domain_accounts_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's primary_source from /workspace/documents/02_trademarks/010_trademarks_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_domain_accounts/058_domain_accounts_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/02_trademarks/010_trademarks_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_domain_accounts/058_domain_accounts_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-04 using the exact controlled facts ['closed without exception', 'CB-IP-3206-D405', 'open and escalated', 'CB-IP-3206-M608'].", "id": "findings.F-04.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-04's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-04.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-22', 'Dominic Alvarez'] for F-04.", "id": "findings.F-04.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-05 exception for trademark specimen issue.", "id": "findings.F-05.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's id from /workspace/documents/02_trademarks/013_trademarks_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_domain_accounts/061_domain_accounts_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's issue from /workspace/documents/02_trademarks/013_trademarks_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_domain_accounts/061_domain_accounts_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's severity from /workspace/documents/02_trademarks/013_trademarks_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_domain_accounts/061_domain_accounts_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's primary_source from /workspace/documents/02_trademarks/013_trademarks_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_domain_accounts/061_domain_accounts_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/02_trademarks/013_trademarks_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_domain_accounts/061_domain_accounts_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-05 using the exact controlled facts ['District of Massachusetts', 'Massachusetts'].", "id": "findings.F-05.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-05's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-05.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-22', 'Priya Raman'] for F-05.", "id": "findings.F-05.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-06 exception for coexistence restriction.", "id": "findings.F-06.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's id from /workspace/documents/02_trademarks/016_trademarks_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_domain_accounts/064_domain_accounts_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's issue from /workspace/documents/02_trademarks/016_trademarks_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_domain_accounts/064_domain_accounts_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's severity from /workspace/documents/02_trademarks/016_trademarks_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_domain_accounts/064_domain_accounts_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's primary_source from /workspace/documents/02_trademarks/016_trademarks_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_domain_accounts/064_domain_accounts_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/02_trademarks/016_trademarks_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_domain_accounts/064_domain_accounts_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-06 using the exact controlled facts ['8%', '10%'].", "id": "findings.F-06.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-06's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-06.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-22', 'Elliot Mercer'] for F-06.", "id": "findings.F-06.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-07 exception for work-for-hire defect.", "id": "findings.F-07.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's id from /workspace/documents/03_copyrights/019_copyrights_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_development_records/067_development_records_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's issue from /workspace/documents/03_copyrights/019_copyrights_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_development_records/067_development_records_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's severity from /workspace/documents/03_copyrights/019_copyrights_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_development_records/067_development_records_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's primary_source from /workspace/documents/03_copyrights/019_copyrights_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_development_records/067_development_records_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/03_copyrights/019_copyrights_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_development_records/067_development_records_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-07 using the exact controlled facts ['notices-frostline_security_software@example.test', 'archive-open_harbor_foundation@example.test'].", "id": "findings.F-07.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-07's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-07.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-22', 'Talia Brooks'] for F-07.", "id": "findings.F-07.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-08 exception for source-code ownership gap.", "id": "findings.F-08.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's id from /workspace/documents/03_copyrights/022_copyrights_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_development_records/070_development_records_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's issue from /workspace/documents/03_copyrights/022_copyrights_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_development_records/070_development_records_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's severity from /workspace/documents/03_copyrights/022_copyrights_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_development_records/070_development_records_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's primary_source from /workspace/documents/03_copyrights/022_copyrights_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_development_records/070_development_records_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/03_copyrights/022_copyrights_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_development_records/070_development_records_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-08 using the exact controlled facts ['95 records', '2025-11-26', '62 records', '2025-12-30'].", "id": "findings.F-08.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-08's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-08.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-22', 'Jonas Feld'] for F-08.", "id": "findings.F-08.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-09 exception for inbound-license field restriction.", "id": "findings.F-09.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's id from /workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/025_invention_assignments_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_disputes/073_disputes_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's issue from /workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/025_invention_assignments_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_disputes/073_disputes_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's severity from /workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/025_invention_assignments_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_disputes/073_disputes_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's primary_source from /workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/025_invention_assignments_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_disputes/073_disputes_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/025_invention_assignments_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_disputes/073_disputes_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-09 using the exact controlled facts ['2025-04-03', 'CB-IP-3206-I550', '2025-04-27', 'CB-IP-3206-R480'].", "id": "findings.F-09.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-09's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-09.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-22', 'Mei Whitaker'] for F-09.", "id": "findings.F-09.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-10 exception for outbound sublicense overreach.", "id": "findings.F-10.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's id from /workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/028_invention_assignments_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_disputes/076_disputes_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's issue from /workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/028_invention_assignments_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_disputes/076_disputes_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's severity from /workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/028_invention_assignments_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_disputes/076_disputes_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's primary_source from /workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/028_invention_assignments_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_disputes/076_disputes_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/028_invention_assignments_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_disputes/076_disputes_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-10 using the exact controlled facts ['$3,552,773.00', '$3,632,046.00'].", "id": "findings.F-10.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-10's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-10.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-22', 'Caleb Hassan'] for F-10.", "id": "findings.F-10.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-11 exception for copyleft distribution trigger.", "id": "findings.F-11.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's id from /workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/031_invention_assignments_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_disputes/079_disputes_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's issue from /workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/031_invention_assignments_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_disputes/079_disputes_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's severity from /workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/031_invention_assignments_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_disputes/079_disputes_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's primary_source from /workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/031_invention_assignments_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_disputes/079_disputes_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/031_invention_assignments_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_disputes/079_disputes_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-11 using the exact controlled facts ['Micah Sullivan', 'Isaac Romero'].", "id": "findings.F-11.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-11's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-11.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-22', 'Leona Park'] for F-11.", "id": "findings.F-11.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-12 exception for notice-file omission.", "id": "findings.F-12.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's id from /workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/034_licenses_in_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_maintenance/082_maintenance_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's issue from /workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/034_licenses_in_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_maintenance/082_maintenance_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's severity from /workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/034_licenses_in_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_maintenance/082_maintenance_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's primary_source from /workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/034_licenses_in_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_maintenance/082_maintenance_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/034_licenses_in_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_maintenance/082_maintenance_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-12 using the exact controlled facts ['closed without exception', 'CB-IP-3206-L117', 'open and escalated', 'CB-IP-3206-U724'].", "id": "findings.F-12.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-12's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-12.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-22', 'Isaac Romero'] for F-12.", "id": "findings.F-12.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-13 exception for domain registrant mismatch.", "id": "findings.F-13.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's id from /workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/037_licenses_in_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_maintenance/085_maintenance_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's issue from /workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/037_licenses_in_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_maintenance/085_maintenance_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's severity from /workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/037_licenses_in_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_maintenance/085_maintenance_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's primary_source from /workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/037_licenses_in_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_maintenance/085_maintenance_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/037_licenses_in_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_maintenance/085_maintenance_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-13 using the exact controlled facts ['District of Massachusetts', 'Massachusetts'].", "id": "findings.F-13.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-13's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-13.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-22', 'Sofia Bennett'] for F-13.", "id": "findings.F-13.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-14 exception for repository access anomaly.", "id": "findings.F-14.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's id from /workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/040_licenses_in_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_maintenance/088_maintenance_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's issue from /workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/040_licenses_in_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_maintenance/088_maintenance_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's severity from /workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/040_licenses_in_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_maintenance/088_maintenance_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's primary_source from /workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/040_licenses_in_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_maintenance/088_maintenance_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/040_licenses_in_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_maintenance/088_maintenance_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-14 using the exact controlled facts ['6%', '8%'].", "id": "findings.F-14.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-14's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-14.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-22', 'Adrian Mensah'] for F-14.", "id": "findings.F-14.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-15 exception for cease-and-desist deadline.", "id": "findings.F-15.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's id from /workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/043_licenses_out_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_security_interests/091_security_interests_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's issue from /workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/043_licenses_out_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_security_interests/091_security_interests_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's severity from /workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/043_licenses_out_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_security_interests/091_security_interests_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's primary_source from /workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/043_licenses_out_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_security_interests/091_security_interests_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/043_licenses_out_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_security_interests/091_security_interests_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-15 using the exact controlled facts ['notices-frostline_security_software@example.test', 'archive-open_harbor_foundation@example.test'].", "id": "findings.F-15.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-15's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-15.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-22', 'Willa Novak'] for F-15.", "id": "findings.F-15.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-16 exception for security-interest release gap.", "id": "findings.F-16.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's id from /workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/046_licenses_out_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_security_interests/094_security_interests_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's issue from /workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/046_licenses_out_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_security_interests/094_security_interests_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's severity from /workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/046_licenses_out_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_security_interests/094_security_interests_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's primary_source from /workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/046_licenses_out_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_security_interests/094_security_interests_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/046_licenses_out_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_security_interests/094_security_interests_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-16 using the exact controlled facts ['176 records', '2025-09-28', '52 records', '2025-10-22'].", "id": "findings.F-16.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-16's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-16.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-22', 'Theo Laurent'] for F-16.", "id": "findings.F-16.action_anchors"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Executive assessment' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Executive assessment"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Method and record coverage' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Method and record coverage"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Findings' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Findings"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Recommended next actions' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Recommended next actions"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Assumptions and limitations' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Assumptions and limitations"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-01 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-01"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-02 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-02"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-03 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-03"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-04 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-04"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-05 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-05"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-06 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-06"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-07 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-07"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-08 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-08"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-09 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-09"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-10 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-10"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-11 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-11"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-12 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-12"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-13 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-13"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-14 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-14"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-15 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-15"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-16 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-16"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Do not claim the production has no issues or that every record is consistent.", "id": "memo.forbidden_claims_absent"}], "decision_options": [{"id": "cross-source-reconciliation", "label": "Reconcile controlling and corroborating records", "reason": "The CB-IP-3206 production contains independently maintained records; a defensible answer must preserve each supported conflict and its cure owner.", "selected": true}, {"id": "latest-record-controls", "label": "Treat the latest record as controlling", "reason": "Timestamp recency does not establish legal priority, execution, or approval authority.", "selected": false}, {"id": "primary-records-only", "label": "Report primary records without reconciliation", "reason": "Primary records alone conceal the operational conflicts that create the actionable exceptions.", "selected": false}], "gates": ["all_evidence_read_in_full", "chain_of_custody_metadata_checked", "findings_criteria_complete", "memo_criteria_complete", "deliverables_written_through_mcp"], "metadata_checks": 8, "metric": "weighted_criteria_score", "minimum_tool_calls": 46, "required_deliverables": ["findings.json", "advice.md"], "required_document_reads": 33, "type": "deterministic", "weights": {"findings": 0.55, "memo": 0.2, "procedure": 0.25}}, "task_id": "cb100-086-frostline-security", "task_name": "Frostline software provenance audit", "world_id": "counselbench-filesystem-mcp-v2"}
-{"context_files": ["task_files/cb100-087-goldfinch-media/01_patents/001_patents_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-087-goldfinch-media/01_patents/002_patents_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-087-goldfinch-media/01_patents/003_patents_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-087-goldfinch-media/01_patents/004_patents_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-087-goldfinch-media/01_patents/005_patents_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-087-goldfinch-media/01_patents/006_patents_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-087-goldfinch-media/01_patents/007_patents_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-087-goldfinch-media/01_patents/008_patents_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-087-goldfinch-media/02_trademarks/009_trademarks_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-087-goldfinch-media/02_trademarks/010_trademarks_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-087-goldfinch-media/02_trademarks/011_trademarks_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-087-goldfinch-media/02_trademarks/012_trademarks_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-087-goldfinch-media/02_trademarks/013_trademarks_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-087-goldfinch-media/02_trademarks/014_trademarks_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-087-goldfinch-media/02_trademarks/015_trademarks_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-087-goldfinch-media/02_trademarks/016_trademarks_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-087-goldfinch-media/03_copyrights/017_copyrights_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-087-goldfinch-media/03_copyrights/018_copyrights_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-087-goldfinch-media/03_copyrights/019_copyrights_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-087-goldfinch-media/03_copyrights/020_copyrights_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-087-goldfinch-media/03_copyrights/021_copyrights_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-087-goldfinch-media/03_copyrights/022_copyrights_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-087-goldfinch-media/03_copyrights/023_copyrights_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-087-goldfinch-media/03_copyrights/024_copyrights_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-087-goldfinch-media/04_invention_assignments/025_invention_assignments_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-087-goldfinch-media/04_invention_assignments/026_invention_assignments_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-087-goldfinch-media/04_invention_assignments/027_invention_assignments_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-087-goldfinch-media/04_invention_assignments/028_invention_assignments_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-087-goldfinch-media/04_invention_assignments/029_invention_assignments_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-087-goldfinch-media/04_invention_assignments/030_invention_assignments_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-087-goldfinch-media/04_invention_assignments/031_invention_assignments_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-087-goldfinch-media/04_invention_assignments/032_invention_assignments_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-087-goldfinch-media/05_licenses_in/033_licenses_in_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-087-goldfinch-media/05_licenses_in/034_licenses_in_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-087-goldfinch-media/05_licenses_in/035_licenses_in_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-087-goldfinch-media/05_licenses_in/036_licenses_in_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-087-goldfinch-media/05_licenses_in/037_licenses_in_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-087-goldfinch-media/05_licenses_in/038_licenses_in_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-087-goldfinch-media/05_licenses_in/039_licenses_in_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-087-goldfinch-media/05_licenses_in/040_licenses_in_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-087-goldfinch-media/06_licenses_out/041_licenses_out_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-087-goldfinch-media/06_licenses_out/042_licenses_out_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-087-goldfinch-media/06_licenses_out/043_licenses_out_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-087-goldfinch-media/06_licenses_out/044_licenses_out_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-087-goldfinch-media/06_licenses_out/045_licenses_out_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-087-goldfinch-media/06_licenses_out/046_licenses_out_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-087-goldfinch-media/06_licenses_out/047_licenses_out_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-087-goldfinch-media/06_licenses_out/048_licenses_out_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-087-goldfinch-media/07_open_source/049_open_source_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-087-goldfinch-media/07_open_source/050_open_source_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-087-goldfinch-media/07_open_source/051_open_source_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-087-goldfinch-media/07_open_source/052_open_source_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-087-goldfinch-media/07_open_source/053_open_source_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-087-goldfinch-media/07_open_source/054_open_source_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-087-goldfinch-media/07_open_source/055_open_source_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-087-goldfinch-media/07_open_source/056_open_source_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-087-goldfinch-media/08_domain_accounts/057_domain_accounts_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-087-goldfinch-media/08_domain_accounts/058_domain_accounts_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-087-goldfinch-media/08_domain_accounts/059_domain_accounts_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-087-goldfinch-media/08_domain_accounts/060_domain_accounts_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-087-goldfinch-media/08_domain_accounts/061_domain_accounts_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-087-goldfinch-media/08_domain_accounts/062_domain_accounts_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-087-goldfinch-media/08_domain_accounts/063_domain_accounts_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-087-goldfinch-media/08_domain_accounts/064_domain_accounts_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-087-goldfinch-media/09_development_records/065_development_records_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-087-goldfinch-media/09_development_records/066_development_records_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-087-goldfinch-media/09_development_records/067_development_records_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-087-goldfinch-media/09_development_records/068_development_records_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-087-goldfinch-media/09_development_records/069_development_records_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-087-goldfinch-media/09_development_records/070_development_records_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-087-goldfinch-media/09_development_records/071_development_records_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-087-goldfinch-media/09_development_records/072_development_records_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-087-goldfinch-media/10_disputes/073_disputes_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-087-goldfinch-media/10_disputes/074_disputes_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-087-goldfinch-media/10_disputes/075_disputes_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-087-goldfinch-media/10_disputes/076_disputes_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-087-goldfinch-media/10_disputes/077_disputes_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-087-goldfinch-media/10_disputes/078_disputes_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-087-goldfinch-media/10_disputes/079_disputes_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-087-goldfinch-media/10_disputes/080_disputes_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-087-goldfinch-media/11_maintenance/081_maintenance_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-087-goldfinch-media/11_maintenance/082_maintenance_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-087-goldfinch-media/11_maintenance/083_maintenance_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-087-goldfinch-media/11_maintenance/084_maintenance_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-087-goldfinch-media/11_maintenance/085_maintenance_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-087-goldfinch-media/11_maintenance/086_maintenance_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-087-goldfinch-media/11_maintenance/087_maintenance_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-087-goldfinch-media/11_maintenance/088_maintenance_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-087-goldfinch-media/12_security_interests/089_security_interests_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-087-goldfinch-media/12_security_interests/090_security_interests_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-087-goldfinch-media/12_security_interests/091_security_interests_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-087-goldfinch-media/12_security_interests/092_security_interests_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-087-goldfinch-media/12_security_interests/093_security_interests_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-087-goldfinch-media/12_security_interests/094_security_interests_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-087-goldfinch-media/12_security_interests/095_security_interests_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-087-goldfinch-media/12_security_interests/096_security_interests_status_report.md"], "gold_output": {"advice_markdown": "# Counsel advice — Goldfinch content platform IP review\n\n## Executive assessment\n\nFor Goldfinch Media Network matter CB-IP-3207, the review identified 16 source-supported exceptions requiring action before 2026-09-25. The assessment concerns Independent creator collective and the supplied record for New York.\n\n## Method and record coverage\n\nThe review inventoried all 96 production files, read the 33 controlling, corroborating, and control records, searched the email exports, and checked metadata for the designated chain-of-custody sample. Conclusions are limited to the synthetic production supplied for this benchmark matter.\n\n## Findings\n\n### F-01 — inventor assignment gap (critical)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for inventor assignment gap: one source states the operative date is 2025-11-09 under control reference CB-IP-3207-A830, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2025-12-26 under response reference CB-IP-3207-J640.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/01_patents/001_patents_control_register.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/07_open_source/049_open_source_control_register.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-25, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Rafael Okafor.\n\n### F-02 — recorded-owner mismatch (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for recorded-owner mismatch: one source states the controlling amount is $2,197,752.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $2,242,004.00.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/01_patents/004_patents_ledger_export.csv`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/07_open_source/052_open_source_ledger_export.csv`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-25, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Nora Chen.\n\n### F-03 — maintenance-fee deadline (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for maintenance-fee deadline: one source states approval is attributed to Farah Ibrahim as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Owen Delgado and contains no entry for Farah Ibrahim.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/01_patents/007_patents_officer_certificate.html`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/07_open_source/055_open_source_officer_certificate.html`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-25, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Dominic Alvarez.\n\n### F-04 — foreign-filing restriction (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for foreign-filing restriction: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-IP-3207-D850, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-IP-3207-M988.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/02_trademarks/010_trademarks_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/08_domain_accounts/058_domain_accounts_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-25, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Priya Raman.\n\n### F-05 — trademark specimen issue (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for trademark specimen issue: one source states the applicable location is Southern District of New York, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to New York operations outside Southern District of New York.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/02_trademarks/013_trademarks_review_memorandum.json`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/08_domain_accounts/061_domain_accounts_review_memorandum.json`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-25, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Elliot Mercer.\n\n### F-06 — coexistence restriction (low)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for coexistence restriction: one source states the threshold is 2% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 8% and produced a different exception result.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/02_trademarks/016_trademarks_status_report.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/08_domain_accounts/064_domain_accounts_status_report.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-25, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Talia Brooks.\n\n### F-07 — work-for-hire defect (critical)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for work-for-hire defect: one source states formal notice must use notices-goldfinch_media_network@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-independent_creator_collective@example.test.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/03_copyrights/019_copyrights_correspondence.eml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/09_development_records/067_development_records_correspondence.eml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-25, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Jonas Feld.\n\n### F-08 — source-code ownership gap (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for source-code ownership gap: one source states the governed population contains 111 records through 2025-12-12, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 69 records through 2026-01-22.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/03_copyrights/022_copyrights_formal_notice.xml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/09_development_records/070_development_records_formal_notice.xml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-25, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Mei Whitaker.\n\n### F-09 — inbound-license field restriction (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for inbound-license field restriction: one source states the operative date is 2025-12-12 under control reference CB-IP-3207-I503, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2025-12-19 under response reference CB-IP-3207-R477.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/025_invention_assignments_control_register.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/10_disputes/073_disputes_control_register.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-25, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Caleb Hassan.\n\n### F-10 — outbound sublicense overreach (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for outbound sublicense overreach: one source states the controlling amount is $460,578.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $677,656.00.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/028_invention_assignments_ledger_export.csv`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/10_disputes/076_disputes_ledger_export.csv`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-25, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Leona Park.\n\n### F-11 — copyleft distribution trigger (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for copyleft distribution trigger: one source states approval is attributed to Farah Ibrahim as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Adrian Mensah and contains no entry for Farah Ibrahim.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/031_invention_assignments_officer_certificate.html`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/10_disputes/079_disputes_officer_certificate.html`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-25, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Isaac Romero.\n\n### F-12 — notice-file omission (low)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for notice-file omission: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-IP-3207-L896, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-IP-3207-U438.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/034_licenses_in_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/11_maintenance/082_maintenance_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-25, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Sofia Bennett.\n\n### F-13 — domain registrant mismatch (critical)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for domain registrant mismatch: one source states the applicable location is Southern District of New York, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to New York operations outside Southern District of New York.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/037_licenses_in_review_memorandum.json`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/11_maintenance/085_maintenance_review_memorandum.json`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-25, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Adrian Mensah.\n\n### F-14 — repository access anomaly (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for repository access anomaly: one source states the threshold is 4% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 10% and produced a different exception result.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/040_licenses_in_status_report.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/11_maintenance/088_maintenance_status_report.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-25, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Willa Novak.\n\n### F-15 — cease-and-desist deadline (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for cease-and-desist deadline: one source states formal notice must use notices-goldfinch_media_network@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-independent_creator_collective@example.test.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/043_licenses_out_correspondence.eml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/091_security_interests_correspondence.eml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-25, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Theo Laurent.\n\n### F-16 — security-interest release gap (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for security-interest release gap: one source states the governed population contains 116 records through 2025-03-12, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 51 records through 2025-04-04.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/046_licenses_out_formal_notice.xml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/094_security_interests_formal_notice.xml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-25, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Amara Patel.\n\n## Recommended next actions\n\nSequence the critical and high findings first, assign the named owners, preserve the cited records, and document any resolution in the controlling matter register before the stated deadline.\n\n## Assumptions and limitations\n\nThis analysis is confined to task cb100-087-goldfinch-media and the supplied synthetic evidence. It does not rely on external facts, does not resolve disputed law, and is not legal advice for a real person or entity.\n", "findings": {"as_of": "2026-09-25", "findings": [{"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/07_open_source/049_open_source_control_register.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for inventor assignment gap: one source states the operative date is 2025-11-09 under control reference CB-IP-3207-A830, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2025-12-26 under response reference CB-IP-3207-J640.", "id": "F-01", "issue": "inventor assignment gap", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/01_patents/001_patents_control_register.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-25, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Rafael Okafor.", "severity": "critical"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/07_open_source/052_open_source_ledger_export.csv", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for recorded-owner mismatch: one source states the controlling amount is $2,197,752.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $2,242,004.00.", "id": "F-02", "issue": "recorded-owner mismatch", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/01_patents/004_patents_ledger_export.csv", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-25, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Nora Chen.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/07_open_source/055_open_source_officer_certificate.html", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for maintenance-fee deadline: one source states approval is attributed to Farah Ibrahim as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Owen Delgado and contains no entry for Farah Ibrahim.", "id": "F-03", "issue": "maintenance-fee deadline", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/01_patents/007_patents_officer_certificate.html", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-25, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Dominic Alvarez.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/08_domain_accounts/058_domain_accounts_executed_instrument.txt", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for foreign-filing restriction: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-IP-3207-D850, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-IP-3207-M988.", "id": "F-04", "issue": "foreign-filing restriction", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/02_trademarks/010_trademarks_executed_instrument.txt", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-25, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Priya Raman.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/08_domain_accounts/061_domain_accounts_review_memorandum.json", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for trademark specimen issue: one source states the applicable location is Southern District of New York, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to New York operations outside Southern District of New York.", "id": "F-05", "issue": "trademark specimen issue", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/02_trademarks/013_trademarks_review_memorandum.json", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-25, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Elliot Mercer.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/08_domain_accounts/064_domain_accounts_status_report.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for coexistence restriction: one source states the threshold is 2% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 8% and produced a different exception result.", "id": "F-06", "issue": "coexistence restriction", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/02_trademarks/016_trademarks_status_report.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-25, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Talia Brooks.", "severity": "low"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/09_development_records/067_development_records_correspondence.eml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for work-for-hire defect: one source states formal notice must use notices-goldfinch_media_network@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-independent_creator_collective@example.test.", "id": "F-07", "issue": "work-for-hire defect", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/03_copyrights/019_copyrights_correspondence.eml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-25, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Jonas Feld.", "severity": "critical"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/09_development_records/070_development_records_formal_notice.xml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for source-code ownership gap: one source states the governed population contains 111 records through 2025-12-12, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 69 records through 2026-01-22.", "id": "F-08", "issue": "source-code ownership gap", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/03_copyrights/022_copyrights_formal_notice.xml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-25, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Mei Whitaker.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/10_disputes/073_disputes_control_register.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for inbound-license field restriction: one source states the operative date is 2025-12-12 under control reference CB-IP-3207-I503, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2025-12-19 under response reference CB-IP-3207-R477.", "id": "F-09", "issue": "inbound-license field restriction", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/025_invention_assignments_control_register.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-25, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Caleb Hassan.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/10_disputes/076_disputes_ledger_export.csv", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for outbound sublicense overreach: one source states the controlling amount is $460,578.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $677,656.00.", "id": "F-10", "issue": "outbound sublicense overreach", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/028_invention_assignments_ledger_export.csv", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-25, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Leona Park.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/10_disputes/079_disputes_officer_certificate.html", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for copyleft distribution trigger: one source states approval is attributed to Farah Ibrahim as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Adrian Mensah and contains no entry for Farah Ibrahim.", "id": "F-11", "issue": "copyleft distribution trigger", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/031_invention_assignments_officer_certificate.html", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-25, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Isaac Romero.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/11_maintenance/082_maintenance_executed_instrument.txt", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for notice-file omission: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-IP-3207-L896, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-IP-3207-U438.", "id": "F-12", "issue": "notice-file omission", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/034_licenses_in_executed_instrument.txt", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-25, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Sofia Bennett.", "severity": "low"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/11_maintenance/085_maintenance_review_memorandum.json", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for domain registrant mismatch: one source states the applicable location is Southern District of New York, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to New York operations outside Southern District of New York.", "id": "F-13", "issue": "domain registrant mismatch", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/037_licenses_in_review_memorandum.json", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-25, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Adrian Mensah.", "severity": "critical"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/11_maintenance/088_maintenance_status_report.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for repository access anomaly: one source states the threshold is 4% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 10% and produced a different exception result.", "id": "F-14", "issue": "repository access anomaly", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/040_licenses_in_status_report.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-25, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Willa Novak.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/091_security_interests_correspondence.eml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for cease-and-desist deadline: one source states formal notice must use notices-goldfinch_media_network@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-independent_creator_collective@example.test.", "id": "F-15", "issue": "cease-and-desist deadline", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/043_licenses_out_correspondence.eml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-25, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Theo Laurent.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/094_security_interests_formal_notice.xml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for security-interest release gap: one source states the governed population contains 116 records through 2025-03-12, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 51 records through 2025-04-04.", "id": "F-16", "issue": "security-interest release gap", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/046_licenses_out_formal_notice.xml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-25, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Amara Patel.", "severity": "medium"}], "matter_number": "CB-IP-3207", "prepared_for": "Goldfinch Media Network", "schema_version": "1.0", "task_id": "cb100-087-goldfinch-media"}}, "metadata": {"benchmark": "CounselBench-100", "code_license": "Apache-2.0", "data_license": "CC-BY-4.0", "deadline": "2026-09-25", "document_count": 96, "jurisdiction": "New York", "matter_number": "CB-IP-3207", "mcp_commit": "9a96ea6e5913736f92b88345bf51caeaaa8e719f", "mcp_package": "@modelcontextprotocol/server-filesystem@2026.7.10", "practice_area": "ip-technology", "reference_tool_calls": 46, "required_evidence_reads": 33, "synthetic": true, "venue": "Southern District of New York", "version": "2.0.0"}, "prompt": "You are intellectual-property counsel for Goldfinch Media Network. A counterparty challenged the client's internal summary, making cross-document reconciliation and precise citations essential. A creator platform has mismatched work-for-hire, moderation-tool, domain, and copyright registration records. Decision due 2026-09-25. New York law governs; Southern District of New York is the forum. Flag cross-folder dependencies that would be invisible in a single-document review. Work out the defensible position from the matter production and leave an audit-ready exception tracker and concise advice for the supervising lawyer. Keep confirmed conflicts separate from open questions, cite the records that actually control each conclusion, and do not fill gaps with outside facts.", "rubric": {"criteria": [{"category": "procedure", "description": "Complete at least 46 successful, argument-specific evidence and output calls.", "id": "procedure.minimum_successful_tool_calls"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Find and read the 33 controlling, corroborating, and work-product-control records in full.", "id": "procedure.all_evidence_read_in_full"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Inspect file metadata for the eight designated critical primary records before relying on them.", "id": "procedure.chain_of_custody_metadata_checked"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Confirm the sandbox's allowed document and output roots.", "id": "procedure.allowed_directories_checked"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Inventory all 96 records so the relevant sources are discovered among the context records.", "id": "procedure.recursive_inventory_completed"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Search the production for email evidence that may corroborate or contradict formal records.", "id": "procedure.targeted_search_completed"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Leave only findings.json and advice.md in the output workspace.", "id": "procedure.exact_deliverable_set"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Create both final work products through the sandbox MCP surface.", "id": "procedure.deliverables_written_through_mcp"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Produce findings.json as a valid JSON object.", "id": "findings.findings_is_object"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Report exactly 16 confirmed exceptions.", "id": "findings.findings_exact_count"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Use each stable finding ID exactly once.", "id": "findings.finding_ids_unique"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set schema_version to the released matter value '1.0'.", "id": "findings.top_level_schema_version"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set task_id to the released matter value 'cb100-087-goldfinch-media'.", "id": "findings.top_level_task_id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set matter_number to the released matter value 'CB-IP-3207'.", "id": "findings.top_level_matter_number"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set prepared_for to the released matter value 'Goldfinch Media Network'.", "id": "findings.top_level_prepared_for"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set as_of to the released matter value '2026-09-25'.", "id": "findings.top_level_as_of"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-01 exception for inventor assignment gap.", "id": "findings.F-01.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's id from /workspace/documents/01_patents/001_patents_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_open_source/049_open_source_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's issue from /workspace/documents/01_patents/001_patents_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_open_source/049_open_source_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's severity from /workspace/documents/01_patents/001_patents_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_open_source/049_open_source_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's primary_source from /workspace/documents/01_patents/001_patents_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_open_source/049_open_source_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/01_patents/001_patents_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_open_source/049_open_source_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-01 using the exact controlled facts ['2025-11-09', 'CB-IP-3207-A830', '2025-12-26', 'CB-IP-3207-J640'].", "id": "findings.F-01.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-01's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-01.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-25', 'Rafael Okafor'] for F-01.", "id": "findings.F-01.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-02 exception for recorded-owner mismatch.", "id": "findings.F-02.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's id from /workspace/documents/01_patents/004_patents_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_open_source/052_open_source_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's issue from /workspace/documents/01_patents/004_patents_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_open_source/052_open_source_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's severity from /workspace/documents/01_patents/004_patents_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_open_source/052_open_source_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's primary_source from /workspace/documents/01_patents/004_patents_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_open_source/052_open_source_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/01_patents/004_patents_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_open_source/052_open_source_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-02 using the exact controlled facts ['$2,197,752.00', '$2,242,004.00'].", "id": "findings.F-02.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-02's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-02.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-25', 'Nora Chen'] for F-02.", "id": "findings.F-02.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-03 exception for maintenance-fee deadline.", "id": "findings.F-03.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's id from /workspace/documents/01_patents/007_patents_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_open_source/055_open_source_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's issue from /workspace/documents/01_patents/007_patents_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_open_source/055_open_source_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's severity from /workspace/documents/01_patents/007_patents_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_open_source/055_open_source_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's primary_source from /workspace/documents/01_patents/007_patents_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_open_source/055_open_source_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/01_patents/007_patents_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_open_source/055_open_source_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-03 using the exact controlled facts ['Farah Ibrahim', 'Owen Delgado'].", "id": "findings.F-03.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-03's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-03.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-25', 'Dominic Alvarez'] for F-03.", "id": "findings.F-03.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-04 exception for foreign-filing restriction.", "id": "findings.F-04.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's id from /workspace/documents/02_trademarks/010_trademarks_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_domain_accounts/058_domain_accounts_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's issue from /workspace/documents/02_trademarks/010_trademarks_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_domain_accounts/058_domain_accounts_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's severity from /workspace/documents/02_trademarks/010_trademarks_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_domain_accounts/058_domain_accounts_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's primary_source from /workspace/documents/02_trademarks/010_trademarks_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_domain_accounts/058_domain_accounts_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/02_trademarks/010_trademarks_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_domain_accounts/058_domain_accounts_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-04 using the exact controlled facts ['closed without exception', 'CB-IP-3207-D850', 'open and escalated', 'CB-IP-3207-M988'].", "id": "findings.F-04.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-04's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-04.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-25', 'Priya Raman'] for F-04.", "id": "findings.F-04.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-05 exception for trademark specimen issue.", "id": "findings.F-05.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's id from /workspace/documents/02_trademarks/013_trademarks_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_domain_accounts/061_domain_accounts_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's issue from /workspace/documents/02_trademarks/013_trademarks_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_domain_accounts/061_domain_accounts_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's severity from /workspace/documents/02_trademarks/013_trademarks_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_domain_accounts/061_domain_accounts_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's primary_source from /workspace/documents/02_trademarks/013_trademarks_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_domain_accounts/061_domain_accounts_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/02_trademarks/013_trademarks_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_domain_accounts/061_domain_accounts_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-05 using the exact controlled facts ['Southern District of New York', 'New York'].", "id": "findings.F-05.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-05's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-05.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-25', 'Elliot Mercer'] for F-05.", "id": "findings.F-05.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-06 exception for coexistence restriction.", "id": "findings.F-06.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's id from /workspace/documents/02_trademarks/016_trademarks_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_domain_accounts/064_domain_accounts_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's issue from /workspace/documents/02_trademarks/016_trademarks_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_domain_accounts/064_domain_accounts_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's severity from /workspace/documents/02_trademarks/016_trademarks_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_domain_accounts/064_domain_accounts_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's primary_source from /workspace/documents/02_trademarks/016_trademarks_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_domain_accounts/064_domain_accounts_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/02_trademarks/016_trademarks_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_domain_accounts/064_domain_accounts_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-06 using the exact controlled facts ['2%', '8%'].", "id": "findings.F-06.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-06's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-06.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-25', 'Talia Brooks'] for F-06.", "id": "findings.F-06.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-07 exception for work-for-hire defect.", "id": "findings.F-07.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's id from /workspace/documents/03_copyrights/019_copyrights_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_development_records/067_development_records_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's issue from /workspace/documents/03_copyrights/019_copyrights_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_development_records/067_development_records_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's severity from /workspace/documents/03_copyrights/019_copyrights_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_development_records/067_development_records_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's primary_source from /workspace/documents/03_copyrights/019_copyrights_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_development_records/067_development_records_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/03_copyrights/019_copyrights_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_development_records/067_development_records_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-07 using the exact controlled facts ['notices-goldfinch_media_network@example.test', 'archive-independent_creator_collective@example.test'].", "id": "findings.F-07.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-07's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-07.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-25', 'Jonas Feld'] for F-07.", "id": "findings.F-07.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-08 exception for source-code ownership gap.", "id": "findings.F-08.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's id from /workspace/documents/03_copyrights/022_copyrights_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_development_records/070_development_records_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's issue from /workspace/documents/03_copyrights/022_copyrights_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_development_records/070_development_records_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's severity from /workspace/documents/03_copyrights/022_copyrights_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_development_records/070_development_records_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's primary_source from /workspace/documents/03_copyrights/022_copyrights_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_development_records/070_development_records_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/03_copyrights/022_copyrights_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_development_records/070_development_records_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-08 using the exact controlled facts ['111 records', '2025-12-12', '69 records', '2026-01-22'].", "id": "findings.F-08.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-08's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-08.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-25', 'Mei Whitaker'] for F-08.", "id": "findings.F-08.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-09 exception for inbound-license field restriction.", "id": "findings.F-09.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's id from /workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/025_invention_assignments_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_disputes/073_disputes_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's issue from /workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/025_invention_assignments_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_disputes/073_disputes_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's severity from /workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/025_invention_assignments_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_disputes/073_disputes_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's primary_source from /workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/025_invention_assignments_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_disputes/073_disputes_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/025_invention_assignments_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_disputes/073_disputes_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-09 using the exact controlled facts ['2025-12-12', 'CB-IP-3207-I503', '2025-12-19', 'CB-IP-3207-R477'].", "id": "findings.F-09.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-09's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-09.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-25', 'Caleb Hassan'] for F-09.", "id": "findings.F-09.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-10 exception for outbound sublicense overreach.", "id": "findings.F-10.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's id from /workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/028_invention_assignments_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_disputes/076_disputes_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's issue from /workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/028_invention_assignments_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_disputes/076_disputes_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's severity from /workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/028_invention_assignments_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_disputes/076_disputes_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's primary_source from /workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/028_invention_assignments_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_disputes/076_disputes_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/028_invention_assignments_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_disputes/076_disputes_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-10 using the exact controlled facts ['$460,578.00', '$677,656.00'].", "id": "findings.F-10.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-10's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-10.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-25', 'Leona Park'] for F-10.", "id": "findings.F-10.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-11 exception for copyleft distribution trigger.", "id": "findings.F-11.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's id from /workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/031_invention_assignments_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_disputes/079_disputes_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's issue from /workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/031_invention_assignments_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_disputes/079_disputes_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's severity from /workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/031_invention_assignments_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_disputes/079_disputes_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's primary_source from /workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/031_invention_assignments_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_disputes/079_disputes_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/031_invention_assignments_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_disputes/079_disputes_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-11 using the exact controlled facts ['Farah Ibrahim', 'Adrian Mensah'].", "id": "findings.F-11.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-11's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-11.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-25', 'Isaac Romero'] for F-11.", "id": "findings.F-11.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-12 exception for notice-file omission.", "id": "findings.F-12.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's id from /workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/034_licenses_in_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_maintenance/082_maintenance_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's issue from /workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/034_licenses_in_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_maintenance/082_maintenance_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's severity from /workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/034_licenses_in_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_maintenance/082_maintenance_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's primary_source from /workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/034_licenses_in_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_maintenance/082_maintenance_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/034_licenses_in_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_maintenance/082_maintenance_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-12 using the exact controlled facts ['closed without exception', 'CB-IP-3207-L896', 'open and escalated', 'CB-IP-3207-U438'].", "id": "findings.F-12.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-12's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-12.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-25', 'Sofia Bennett'] for F-12.", "id": "findings.F-12.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-13 exception for domain registrant mismatch.", "id": "findings.F-13.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's id from /workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/037_licenses_in_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_maintenance/085_maintenance_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's issue from /workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/037_licenses_in_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_maintenance/085_maintenance_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's severity from /workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/037_licenses_in_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_maintenance/085_maintenance_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's primary_source from /workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/037_licenses_in_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_maintenance/085_maintenance_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/037_licenses_in_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_maintenance/085_maintenance_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-13 using the exact controlled facts ['Southern District of New York', 'New York'].", "id": "findings.F-13.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-13's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-13.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-25', 'Adrian Mensah'] for F-13.", "id": "findings.F-13.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-14 exception for repository access anomaly.", "id": "findings.F-14.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's id from /workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/040_licenses_in_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_maintenance/088_maintenance_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's issue from /workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/040_licenses_in_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_maintenance/088_maintenance_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's severity from /workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/040_licenses_in_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_maintenance/088_maintenance_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's primary_source from /workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/040_licenses_in_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_maintenance/088_maintenance_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/040_licenses_in_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_maintenance/088_maintenance_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-14 using the exact controlled facts ['4%', '10%'].", "id": "findings.F-14.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-14's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-14.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-25', 'Willa Novak'] for F-14.", "id": "findings.F-14.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-15 exception for cease-and-desist deadline.", "id": "findings.F-15.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's id from /workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/043_licenses_out_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_security_interests/091_security_interests_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's issue from /workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/043_licenses_out_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_security_interests/091_security_interests_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's severity from /workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/043_licenses_out_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_security_interests/091_security_interests_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's primary_source from /workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/043_licenses_out_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_security_interests/091_security_interests_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/043_licenses_out_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_security_interests/091_security_interests_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-15 using the exact controlled facts ['notices-goldfinch_media_network@example.test', 'archive-independent_creator_collective@example.test'].", "id": "findings.F-15.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-15's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-15.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-25', 'Theo Laurent'] for F-15.", "id": "findings.F-15.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-16 exception for security-interest release gap.", "id": "findings.F-16.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's id from /workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/046_licenses_out_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_security_interests/094_security_interests_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's issue from /workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/046_licenses_out_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_security_interests/094_security_interests_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's severity from /workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/046_licenses_out_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_security_interests/094_security_interests_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's primary_source from /workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/046_licenses_out_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_security_interests/094_security_interests_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/046_licenses_out_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_security_interests/094_security_interests_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-16 using the exact controlled facts ['116 records', '2025-03-12', '51 records', '2025-04-04'].", "id": "findings.F-16.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-16's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-16.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-25', 'Amara Patel'] for F-16.", "id": "findings.F-16.action_anchors"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Executive assessment' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Executive assessment"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Method and record coverage' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Method and record coverage"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Findings' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Findings"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Recommended next actions' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Recommended next actions"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Assumptions and limitations' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Assumptions and limitations"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-01 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-01"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-02 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-02"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-03 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-03"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-04 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-04"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-05 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-05"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-06 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-06"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-07 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-07"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-08 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-08"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-09 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-09"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-10 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-10"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-11 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-11"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-12 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-12"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-13 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-13"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-14 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-14"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-15 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-15"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-16 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-16"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Do not claim the production has no issues or that every record is consistent.", "id": "memo.forbidden_claims_absent"}], "decision_options": [{"id": "cross-source-reconciliation", "label": "Reconcile controlling and corroborating records", "reason": "The CB-IP-3207 production contains independently maintained records; a defensible answer must preserve each supported conflict and its cure owner.", "selected": true}, {"id": "latest-record-controls", "label": "Treat the latest record as controlling", "reason": "Timestamp recency does not establish legal priority, execution, or approval authority.", "selected": false}, {"id": "primary-records-only", "label": "Report primary records without reconciliation", "reason": "Primary records alone conceal the operational conflicts that create the actionable exceptions.", "selected": false}], "gates": ["all_evidence_read_in_full", "chain_of_custody_metadata_checked", "findings_criteria_complete", "memo_criteria_complete", "deliverables_written_through_mcp"], "metadata_checks": 8, "metric": "weighted_criteria_score", "minimum_tool_calls": 46, "required_deliverables": ["findings.json", "advice.md"], "required_document_reads": 33, "type": "deterministic", "weights": {"findings": 0.55, "memo": 0.2, "procedure": 0.25}}, "task_id": "cb100-087-goldfinch-media", "task_name": "Goldfinch content platform IP review", "world_id": "counselbench-filesystem-mcp-v2"}
-{"context_files": ["task_files/cb100-088-hinterland-agri/01_patents/001_patents_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-088-hinterland-agri/01_patents/002_patents_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-088-hinterland-agri/01_patents/003_patents_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-088-hinterland-agri/01_patents/004_patents_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-088-hinterland-agri/01_patents/005_patents_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-088-hinterland-agri/01_patents/006_patents_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-088-hinterland-agri/01_patents/007_patents_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-088-hinterland-agri/01_patents/008_patents_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-088-hinterland-agri/02_trademarks/009_trademarks_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-088-hinterland-agri/02_trademarks/010_trademarks_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-088-hinterland-agri/02_trademarks/011_trademarks_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-088-hinterland-agri/02_trademarks/012_trademarks_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-088-hinterland-agri/02_trademarks/013_trademarks_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-088-hinterland-agri/02_trademarks/014_trademarks_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-088-hinterland-agri/02_trademarks/015_trademarks_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-088-hinterland-agri/02_trademarks/016_trademarks_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-088-hinterland-agri/03_copyrights/017_copyrights_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-088-hinterland-agri/03_copyrights/018_copyrights_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-088-hinterland-agri/03_copyrights/019_copyrights_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-088-hinterland-agri/03_copyrights/020_copyrights_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-088-hinterland-agri/03_copyrights/021_copyrights_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-088-hinterland-agri/03_copyrights/022_copyrights_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-088-hinterland-agri/03_copyrights/023_copyrights_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-088-hinterland-agri/03_copyrights/024_copyrights_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-088-hinterland-agri/04_invention_assignments/025_invention_assignments_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-088-hinterland-agri/04_invention_assignments/026_invention_assignments_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-088-hinterland-agri/04_invention_assignments/027_invention_assignments_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-088-hinterland-agri/04_invention_assignments/028_invention_assignments_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-088-hinterland-agri/04_invention_assignments/029_invention_assignments_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-088-hinterland-agri/04_invention_assignments/030_invention_assignments_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-088-hinterland-agri/04_invention_assignments/031_invention_assignments_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-088-hinterland-agri/04_invention_assignments/032_invention_assignments_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-088-hinterland-agri/05_licenses_in/033_licenses_in_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-088-hinterland-agri/05_licenses_in/034_licenses_in_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-088-hinterland-agri/05_licenses_in/035_licenses_in_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-088-hinterland-agri/05_licenses_in/036_licenses_in_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-088-hinterland-agri/05_licenses_in/037_licenses_in_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-088-hinterland-agri/05_licenses_in/038_licenses_in_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-088-hinterland-agri/05_licenses_in/039_licenses_in_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-088-hinterland-agri/05_licenses_in/040_licenses_in_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-088-hinterland-agri/06_licenses_out/041_licenses_out_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-088-hinterland-agri/06_licenses_out/042_licenses_out_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-088-hinterland-agri/06_licenses_out/043_licenses_out_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-088-hinterland-agri/06_licenses_out/044_licenses_out_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-088-hinterland-agri/06_licenses_out/045_licenses_out_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-088-hinterland-agri/06_licenses_out/046_licenses_out_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-088-hinterland-agri/06_licenses_out/047_licenses_out_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-088-hinterland-agri/06_licenses_out/048_licenses_out_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-088-hinterland-agri/07_open_source/049_open_source_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-088-hinterland-agri/07_open_source/050_open_source_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-088-hinterland-agri/07_open_source/051_open_source_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-088-hinterland-agri/07_open_source/052_open_source_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-088-hinterland-agri/07_open_source/053_open_source_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-088-hinterland-agri/07_open_source/054_open_source_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-088-hinterland-agri/07_open_source/055_open_source_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-088-hinterland-agri/07_open_source/056_open_source_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-088-hinterland-agri/08_domain_accounts/057_domain_accounts_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-088-hinterland-agri/08_domain_accounts/058_domain_accounts_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-088-hinterland-agri/08_domain_accounts/059_domain_accounts_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-088-hinterland-agri/08_domain_accounts/060_domain_accounts_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-088-hinterland-agri/08_domain_accounts/061_domain_accounts_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-088-hinterland-agri/08_domain_accounts/062_domain_accounts_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-088-hinterland-agri/08_domain_accounts/063_domain_accounts_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-088-hinterland-agri/08_domain_accounts/064_domain_accounts_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-088-hinterland-agri/09_development_records/065_development_records_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-088-hinterland-agri/09_development_records/066_development_records_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-088-hinterland-agri/09_development_records/067_development_records_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-088-hinterland-agri/09_development_records/068_development_records_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-088-hinterland-agri/09_development_records/069_development_records_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-088-hinterland-agri/09_development_records/070_development_records_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-088-hinterland-agri/09_development_records/071_development_records_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-088-hinterland-agri/09_development_records/072_development_records_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-088-hinterland-agri/10_disputes/073_disputes_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-088-hinterland-agri/10_disputes/074_disputes_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-088-hinterland-agri/10_disputes/075_disputes_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-088-hinterland-agri/10_disputes/076_disputes_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-088-hinterland-agri/10_disputes/077_disputes_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-088-hinterland-agri/10_disputes/078_disputes_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-088-hinterland-agri/10_disputes/079_disputes_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-088-hinterland-agri/10_disputes/080_disputes_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-088-hinterland-agri/11_maintenance/081_maintenance_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-088-hinterland-agri/11_maintenance/082_maintenance_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-088-hinterland-agri/11_maintenance/083_maintenance_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-088-hinterland-agri/11_maintenance/084_maintenance_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-088-hinterland-agri/11_maintenance/085_maintenance_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-088-hinterland-agri/11_maintenance/086_maintenance_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-088-hinterland-agri/11_maintenance/087_maintenance_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-088-hinterland-agri/11_maintenance/088_maintenance_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-088-hinterland-agri/12_security_interests/089_security_interests_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-088-hinterland-agri/12_security_interests/090_security_interests_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-088-hinterland-agri/12_security_interests/091_security_interests_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-088-hinterland-agri/12_security_interests/092_security_interests_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-088-hinterland-agri/12_security_interests/093_security_interests_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-088-hinterland-agri/12_security_interests/094_security_interests_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-088-hinterland-agri/12_security_interests/095_security_interests_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-088-hinterland-agri/12_security_interests/096_security_interests_status_report.md"], "gold_output": {"advice_markdown": "# Counsel advice — Hinterland seed technology title audit\n\n## Executive assessment\n\nFor Hinterland Agricultural Science matter CB-IP-3208, the review identified 16 source-supported exceptions requiring action before 2026-09-29. The assessment concerns Prairie State University and the supplied record for Iowa.\n\n## Method and record coverage\n\nThe review inventoried all 96 production files, read the 33 controlling, corroborating, and control records, searched the email exports, and checked metadata for the designated chain-of-custody sample. Conclusions are limited to the synthetic production supplied for this benchmark matter.\n\n## Findings\n\n### F-01 — inventor assignment gap (critical)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for inventor assignment gap: one source states the operative date is 2025-09-02 under control reference CB-IP-3208-A582, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2025-10-07 under response reference CB-IP-3208-J690.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/01_patents/001_patents_control_register.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/07_open_source/049_open_source_control_register.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-29, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Nora Chen.\n\n### F-02 — recorded-owner mismatch (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for recorded-owner mismatch: one source states the controlling amount is $3,400,994.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $3,588,488.00.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/01_patents/004_patents_ledger_export.csv`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/07_open_source/052_open_source_ledger_export.csv`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-29, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Dominic Alvarez.\n\n### F-03 — maintenance-fee deadline (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for maintenance-fee deadline: one source states approval is attributed to Owen Delgado as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Samuel Kim and contains no entry for Owen Delgado.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/01_patents/007_patents_officer_certificate.html`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/07_open_source/055_open_source_officer_certificate.html`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-29, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Priya Raman.\n\n### F-04 — foreign-filing restriction (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for foreign-filing restriction: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-IP-3208-D619, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-IP-3208-M486.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/02_trademarks/010_trademarks_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/08_domain_accounts/058_domain_accounts_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-29, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Elliot Mercer.\n\n### F-05 — trademark specimen issue (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for trademark specimen issue: one source states the applicable location is Southern District of Iowa, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to Iowa operations outside Southern District of Iowa.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/02_trademarks/013_trademarks_review_memorandum.json`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/08_domain_accounts/061_domain_accounts_review_memorandum.json`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-29, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Talia Brooks.\n\n### F-06 — coexistence restriction (low)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for coexistence restriction: one source states the threshold is 15% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 20% and produced a different exception result.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/02_trademarks/016_trademarks_status_report.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/08_domain_accounts/064_domain_accounts_status_report.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-29, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Jonas Feld.\n\n### F-07 — work-for-hire defect (critical)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for work-for-hire defect: one source states formal notice must use notices-hinterland_agricultural_science@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-prairie_state_university@example.test.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/03_copyrights/019_copyrights_correspondence.eml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/09_development_records/067_development_records_correspondence.eml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-29, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Mei Whitaker.\n\n### F-08 — source-code ownership gap (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for source-code ownership gap: one source states the governed population contains 144 records through 2026-01-14, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 61 records through 2026-02-16.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/03_copyrights/022_copyrights_formal_notice.xml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/09_development_records/070_development_records_formal_notice.xml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-29, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Caleb Hassan.\n\n### F-09 — inbound-license field restriction (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for inbound-license field restriction: one source states the operative date is 2026-02-11 under control reference CB-IP-3208-I444, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2026-03-15 under response reference CB-IP-3208-R611.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/025_invention_assignments_control_register.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/10_disputes/073_disputes_control_register.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-29, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Leona Park.\n\n### F-10 — outbound sublicense overreach (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for outbound sublicense overreach: one source states the controlling amount is $2,944,452.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $3,225,404.00.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/028_invention_assignments_ledger_export.csv`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/10_disputes/076_disputes_ledger_export.csv`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-29, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Isaac Romero.\n\n### F-11 — copyleft distribution trigger (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for copyleft distribution trigger: one source states approval is attributed to Owen Delgado as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Theo Laurent and contains no entry for Owen Delgado.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/031_invention_assignments_officer_certificate.html`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/10_disputes/079_disputes_officer_certificate.html`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-29, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Sofia Bennett.\n\n### F-12 — notice-file omission (low)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for notice-file omission: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-IP-3208-L825, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-IP-3208-U155.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/034_licenses_in_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/11_maintenance/082_maintenance_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-29, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Adrian Mensah.\n\n### F-13 — domain registrant mismatch (critical)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for domain registrant mismatch: one source states the applicable location is Southern District of Iowa, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to Iowa operations outside Southern District of Iowa.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/037_licenses_in_review_memorandum.json`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/11_maintenance/085_maintenance_review_memorandum.json`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-29, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Willa Novak.\n\n### F-14 — repository access anomaly (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for repository access anomaly: one source states the threshold is 6% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 10% and produced a different exception result.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/040_licenses_in_status_report.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/11_maintenance/088_maintenance_status_report.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-29, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Theo Laurent.\n\n### F-15 — cease-and-desist deadline (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for cease-and-desist deadline: one source states formal notice must use notices-hinterland_agricultural_science@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-prairie_state_university@example.test.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/043_licenses_out_correspondence.eml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/091_security_interests_correspondence.eml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-29, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Amara Patel.\n\n### F-16 — security-interest release gap (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for security-interest release gap: one source states the governed population contains 83 records through 2025-02-07, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 64 records through 2025-03-15.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/046_licenses_out_formal_notice.xml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/094_security_interests_formal_notice.xml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-29, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Henry Cho.\n\n## Recommended next actions\n\nSequence the critical and high findings first, assign the named owners, preserve the cited records, and document any resolution in the controlling matter register before the stated deadline.\n\n## Assumptions and limitations\n\nThis analysis is confined to task cb100-088-hinterland-agri and the supplied synthetic evidence. It does not rely on external facts, does not resolve disputed law, and is not legal advice for a real person or entity.\n", "findings": {"as_of": "2026-09-29", "findings": [{"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/07_open_source/049_open_source_control_register.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for inventor assignment gap: one source states the operative date is 2025-09-02 under control reference CB-IP-3208-A582, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2025-10-07 under response reference CB-IP-3208-J690.", "id": "F-01", "issue": "inventor assignment gap", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/01_patents/001_patents_control_register.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-29, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Nora Chen.", "severity": "critical"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/07_open_source/052_open_source_ledger_export.csv", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for recorded-owner mismatch: one source states the controlling amount is $3,400,994.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $3,588,488.00.", "id": "F-02", "issue": "recorded-owner mismatch", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/01_patents/004_patents_ledger_export.csv", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-29, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Dominic Alvarez.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/07_open_source/055_open_source_officer_certificate.html", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for maintenance-fee deadline: one source states approval is attributed to Owen Delgado as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Samuel Kim and contains no entry for Owen Delgado.", "id": "F-03", "issue": "maintenance-fee deadline", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/01_patents/007_patents_officer_certificate.html", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-29, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Priya Raman.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/08_domain_accounts/058_domain_accounts_executed_instrument.txt", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for foreign-filing restriction: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-IP-3208-D619, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-IP-3208-M486.", "id": "F-04", "issue": "foreign-filing restriction", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/02_trademarks/010_trademarks_executed_instrument.txt", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-29, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Elliot Mercer.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/08_domain_accounts/061_domain_accounts_review_memorandum.json", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for trademark specimen issue: one source states the applicable location is Southern District of Iowa, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to Iowa operations outside Southern District of Iowa.", "id": "F-05", "issue": "trademark specimen issue", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/02_trademarks/013_trademarks_review_memorandum.json", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-29, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Talia Brooks.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/08_domain_accounts/064_domain_accounts_status_report.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for coexistence restriction: one source states the threshold is 15% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 20% and produced a different exception result.", "id": "F-06", "issue": "coexistence restriction", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/02_trademarks/016_trademarks_status_report.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-29, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Jonas Feld.", "severity": "low"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/09_development_records/067_development_records_correspondence.eml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for work-for-hire defect: one source states formal notice must use notices-hinterland_agricultural_science@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-prairie_state_university@example.test.", "id": "F-07", "issue": "work-for-hire defect", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/03_copyrights/019_copyrights_correspondence.eml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-29, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Mei Whitaker.", "severity": "critical"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/09_development_records/070_development_records_formal_notice.xml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for source-code ownership gap: one source states the governed population contains 144 records through 2026-01-14, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 61 records through 2026-02-16.", "id": "F-08", "issue": "source-code ownership gap", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/03_copyrights/022_copyrights_formal_notice.xml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-29, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Caleb Hassan.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/10_disputes/073_disputes_control_register.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for inbound-license field restriction: one source states the operative date is 2026-02-11 under control reference CB-IP-3208-I444, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2026-03-15 under response reference CB-IP-3208-R611.", "id": "F-09", "issue": "inbound-license field restriction", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/025_invention_assignments_control_register.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-29, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Leona Park.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/10_disputes/076_disputes_ledger_export.csv", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for outbound sublicense overreach: one source states the controlling amount is $2,944,452.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $3,225,404.00.", "id": "F-10", "issue": "outbound sublicense overreach", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/028_invention_assignments_ledger_export.csv", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-29, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Isaac Romero.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/10_disputes/079_disputes_officer_certificate.html", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for copyleft distribution trigger: one source states approval is attributed to Owen Delgado as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Theo Laurent and contains no entry for Owen Delgado.", "id": "F-11", "issue": "copyleft distribution trigger", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/031_invention_assignments_officer_certificate.html", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-29, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Sofia Bennett.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/11_maintenance/082_maintenance_executed_instrument.txt", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for notice-file omission: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-IP-3208-L825, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-IP-3208-U155.", "id": "F-12", "issue": "notice-file omission", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/034_licenses_in_executed_instrument.txt", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-29, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Adrian Mensah.", "severity": "low"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/11_maintenance/085_maintenance_review_memorandum.json", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for domain registrant mismatch: one source states the applicable location is Southern District of Iowa, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to Iowa operations outside Southern District of Iowa.", "id": "F-13", "issue": "domain registrant mismatch", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/037_licenses_in_review_memorandum.json", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-29, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Willa Novak.", "severity": "critical"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/11_maintenance/088_maintenance_status_report.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for repository access anomaly: one source states the threshold is 6% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 10% and produced a different exception result.", "id": "F-14", "issue": "repository access anomaly", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/040_licenses_in_status_report.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-29, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Theo Laurent.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/091_security_interests_correspondence.eml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for cease-and-desist deadline: one source states formal notice must use notices-hinterland_agricultural_science@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-prairie_state_university@example.test.", "id": "F-15", "issue": "cease-and-desist deadline", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/043_licenses_out_correspondence.eml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-29, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Amara Patel.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/094_security_interests_formal_notice.xml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for security-interest release gap: one source states the governed population contains 83 records through 2025-02-07, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 64 records through 2025-03-15.", "id": "F-16", "issue": "security-interest release gap", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/046_licenses_out_formal_notice.xml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-29, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Henry Cho.", "severity": "medium"}], "matter_number": "CB-IP-3208", "prepared_for": "Hinterland Agricultural Science", "schema_version": "1.0", "task_id": "cb100-088-hinterland-agri"}}, "metadata": {"benchmark": "CounselBench-100", "code_license": "Apache-2.0", "data_license": "CC-BY-4.0", "deadline": "2026-09-29", "document_count": 96, "jurisdiction": "Iowa", "matter_number": "CB-IP-3208", "mcp_commit": "9a96ea6e5913736f92b88345bf51caeaaa8e719f", "mcp_package": "@modelcontextprotocol/server-filesystem@2026.7.10", "practice_area": "ip-technology", "reference_tool_calls": 46, "required_evidence_reads": 33, "synthetic": true, "venue": "Southern District of Iowa", "version": "2.0.0"}, "prompt": "You are intellectual-property counsel for Hinterland Agricultural Science. The supervising attorney wants an exception-focused review that still demonstrates complete coverage of the data room. Seed-trait patents, research materials, grant obligations, field restrictions, and recorded security interests do not align. Decision due 2026-09-29. Iowa law governs; Southern District of Iowa is the forum. Preserve the difference between the client's position, the counterparty's position, and an objective record conflict. Work out the defensible position from the matter production and leave an audit-ready exception tracker and concise advice for the supervising lawyer. Keep confirmed conflicts separate from open questions, cite the records that actually control each conclusion, and do not fill gaps with outside facts.", "rubric": {"criteria": [{"category": "procedure", "description": "Complete at least 46 successful, argument-specific evidence and output calls.", "id": "procedure.minimum_successful_tool_calls"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Find and read the 33 controlling, corroborating, and work-product-control records in full.", "id": "procedure.all_evidence_read_in_full"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Inspect file metadata for the eight designated critical primary records before relying on them.", "id": "procedure.chain_of_custody_metadata_checked"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Confirm the sandbox's allowed document and output roots.", "id": "procedure.allowed_directories_checked"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Inventory all 96 records so the relevant sources are discovered among the context records.", "id": "procedure.recursive_inventory_completed"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Search the production for email evidence that may corroborate or contradict formal records.", "id": "procedure.targeted_search_completed"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Leave only findings.json and advice.md in the output workspace.", "id": "procedure.exact_deliverable_set"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Create both final work products through the sandbox MCP surface.", "id": "procedure.deliverables_written_through_mcp"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Produce findings.json as a valid JSON object.", "id": "findings.findings_is_object"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Report exactly 16 confirmed exceptions.", "id": "findings.findings_exact_count"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Use each stable finding ID exactly once.", "id": "findings.finding_ids_unique"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set schema_version to the released matter value '1.0'.", "id": "findings.top_level_schema_version"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set task_id to the released matter value 'cb100-088-hinterland-agri'.", "id": "findings.top_level_task_id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set matter_number to the released matter value 'CB-IP-3208'.", "id": "findings.top_level_matter_number"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set prepared_for to the released matter value 'Hinterland Agricultural Science'.", "id": "findings.top_level_prepared_for"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set as_of to the released matter value '2026-09-29'.", "id": "findings.top_level_as_of"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-01 exception for inventor assignment gap.", "id": "findings.F-01.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's id from /workspace/documents/01_patents/001_patents_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_open_source/049_open_source_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's issue from /workspace/documents/01_patents/001_patents_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_open_source/049_open_source_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's severity from /workspace/documents/01_patents/001_patents_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_open_source/049_open_source_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's primary_source from /workspace/documents/01_patents/001_patents_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_open_source/049_open_source_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/01_patents/001_patents_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_open_source/049_open_source_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-01 using the exact controlled facts ['2025-09-02', 'CB-IP-3208-A582', '2025-10-07', 'CB-IP-3208-J690'].", "id": "findings.F-01.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-01's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-01.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-29', 'Nora Chen'] for F-01.", "id": "findings.F-01.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-02 exception for recorded-owner mismatch.", "id": "findings.F-02.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's id from /workspace/documents/01_patents/004_patents_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_open_source/052_open_source_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's issue from /workspace/documents/01_patents/004_patents_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_open_source/052_open_source_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's severity from /workspace/documents/01_patents/004_patents_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_open_source/052_open_source_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's primary_source from /workspace/documents/01_patents/004_patents_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_open_source/052_open_source_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/01_patents/004_patents_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_open_source/052_open_source_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-02 using the exact controlled facts ['$3,400,994.00', '$3,588,488.00'].", "id": "findings.F-02.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-02's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-02.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-29', 'Dominic Alvarez'] for F-02.", "id": "findings.F-02.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-03 exception for maintenance-fee deadline.", "id": "findings.F-03.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's id from /workspace/documents/01_patents/007_patents_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_open_source/055_open_source_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's issue from /workspace/documents/01_patents/007_patents_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_open_source/055_open_source_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's severity from /workspace/documents/01_patents/007_patents_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_open_source/055_open_source_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's primary_source from /workspace/documents/01_patents/007_patents_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_open_source/055_open_source_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/01_patents/007_patents_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_open_source/055_open_source_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-03 using the exact controlled facts ['Owen Delgado', 'Samuel Kim'].", "id": "findings.F-03.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-03's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-03.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-29', 'Priya Raman'] for F-03.", "id": "findings.F-03.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-04 exception for foreign-filing restriction.", "id": "findings.F-04.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's id from /workspace/documents/02_trademarks/010_trademarks_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_domain_accounts/058_domain_accounts_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's issue from /workspace/documents/02_trademarks/010_trademarks_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_domain_accounts/058_domain_accounts_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's severity from /workspace/documents/02_trademarks/010_trademarks_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_domain_accounts/058_domain_accounts_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's primary_source from /workspace/documents/02_trademarks/010_trademarks_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_domain_accounts/058_domain_accounts_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/02_trademarks/010_trademarks_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_domain_accounts/058_domain_accounts_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-04 using the exact controlled facts ['closed without exception', 'CB-IP-3208-D619', 'open and escalated', 'CB-IP-3208-M486'].", "id": "findings.F-04.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-04's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-04.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-29', 'Elliot Mercer'] for F-04.", "id": "findings.F-04.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-05 exception for trademark specimen issue.", "id": "findings.F-05.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's id from /workspace/documents/02_trademarks/013_trademarks_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_domain_accounts/061_domain_accounts_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's issue from /workspace/documents/02_trademarks/013_trademarks_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_domain_accounts/061_domain_accounts_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's severity from /workspace/documents/02_trademarks/013_trademarks_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_domain_accounts/061_domain_accounts_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's primary_source from /workspace/documents/02_trademarks/013_trademarks_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_domain_accounts/061_domain_accounts_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/02_trademarks/013_trademarks_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_domain_accounts/061_domain_accounts_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-05 using the exact controlled facts ['Southern District of Iowa', 'Iowa'].", "id": "findings.F-05.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-05's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-05.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-29', 'Talia Brooks'] for F-05.", "id": "findings.F-05.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-06 exception for coexistence restriction.", "id": "findings.F-06.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's id from /workspace/documents/02_trademarks/016_trademarks_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_domain_accounts/064_domain_accounts_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's issue from /workspace/documents/02_trademarks/016_trademarks_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_domain_accounts/064_domain_accounts_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's severity from /workspace/documents/02_trademarks/016_trademarks_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_domain_accounts/064_domain_accounts_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's primary_source from /workspace/documents/02_trademarks/016_trademarks_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_domain_accounts/064_domain_accounts_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/02_trademarks/016_trademarks_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_domain_accounts/064_domain_accounts_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-06 using the exact controlled facts ['15%', '20%'].", "id": "findings.F-06.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-06's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-06.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-29', 'Jonas Feld'] for F-06.", "id": "findings.F-06.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-07 exception for work-for-hire defect.", "id": "findings.F-07.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's id from /workspace/documents/03_copyrights/019_copyrights_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_development_records/067_development_records_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's issue from /workspace/documents/03_copyrights/019_copyrights_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_development_records/067_development_records_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's severity from /workspace/documents/03_copyrights/019_copyrights_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_development_records/067_development_records_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's primary_source from /workspace/documents/03_copyrights/019_copyrights_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_development_records/067_development_records_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/03_copyrights/019_copyrights_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_development_records/067_development_records_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-07 using the exact controlled facts ['notices-hinterland_agricultural_science@example.test', 'archive-prairie_state_university@example.test'].", "id": "findings.F-07.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-07's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-07.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-29', 'Mei Whitaker'] for F-07.", "id": "findings.F-07.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-08 exception for source-code ownership gap.", "id": "findings.F-08.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's id from /workspace/documents/03_copyrights/022_copyrights_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_development_records/070_development_records_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's issue from /workspace/documents/03_copyrights/022_copyrights_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_development_records/070_development_records_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's severity from /workspace/documents/03_copyrights/022_copyrights_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_development_records/070_development_records_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's primary_source from /workspace/documents/03_copyrights/022_copyrights_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_development_records/070_development_records_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/03_copyrights/022_copyrights_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_development_records/070_development_records_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-08 using the exact controlled facts ['144 records', '2026-01-14', '61 records', '2026-02-16'].", "id": "findings.F-08.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-08's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-08.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-29', 'Caleb Hassan'] for F-08.", "id": "findings.F-08.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-09 exception for inbound-license field restriction.", "id": "findings.F-09.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's id from /workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/025_invention_assignments_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_disputes/073_disputes_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's issue from /workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/025_invention_assignments_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_disputes/073_disputes_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's severity from /workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/025_invention_assignments_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_disputes/073_disputes_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's primary_source from /workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/025_invention_assignments_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_disputes/073_disputes_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/025_invention_assignments_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_disputes/073_disputes_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-09 using the exact controlled facts ['2026-02-11', 'CB-IP-3208-I444', '2026-03-15', 'CB-IP-3208-R611'].", "id": "findings.F-09.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-09's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-09.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-29', 'Leona Park'] for F-09.", "id": "findings.F-09.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-10 exception for outbound sublicense overreach.", "id": "findings.F-10.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's id from /workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/028_invention_assignments_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_disputes/076_disputes_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's issue from /workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/028_invention_assignments_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_disputes/076_disputes_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's severity from /workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/028_invention_assignments_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_disputes/076_disputes_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's primary_source from /workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/028_invention_assignments_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_disputes/076_disputes_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/028_invention_assignments_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_disputes/076_disputes_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-10 using the exact controlled facts ['$2,944,452.00', '$3,225,404.00'].", "id": "findings.F-10.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-10's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-10.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-29', 'Isaac Romero'] for F-10.", "id": "findings.F-10.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-11 exception for copyleft distribution trigger.", "id": "findings.F-11.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's id from /workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/031_invention_assignments_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_disputes/079_disputes_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's issue from /workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/031_invention_assignments_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_disputes/079_disputes_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's severity from /workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/031_invention_assignments_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_disputes/079_disputes_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's primary_source from /workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/031_invention_assignments_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_disputes/079_disputes_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/031_invention_assignments_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_disputes/079_disputes_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-11 using the exact controlled facts ['Owen Delgado', 'Theo Laurent'].", "id": "findings.F-11.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-11's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-11.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-29', 'Sofia Bennett'] for F-11.", "id": "findings.F-11.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-12 exception for notice-file omission.", "id": "findings.F-12.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's id from /workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/034_licenses_in_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_maintenance/082_maintenance_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's issue from /workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/034_licenses_in_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_maintenance/082_maintenance_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's severity from /workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/034_licenses_in_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_maintenance/082_maintenance_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's primary_source from /workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/034_licenses_in_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_maintenance/082_maintenance_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/034_licenses_in_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_maintenance/082_maintenance_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-12 using the exact controlled facts ['closed without exception', 'CB-IP-3208-L825', 'open and escalated', 'CB-IP-3208-U155'].", "id": "findings.F-12.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-12's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-12.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-29', 'Adrian Mensah'] for F-12.", "id": "findings.F-12.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-13 exception for domain registrant mismatch.", "id": "findings.F-13.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's id from /workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/037_licenses_in_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_maintenance/085_maintenance_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's issue from /workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/037_licenses_in_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_maintenance/085_maintenance_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's severity from /workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/037_licenses_in_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_maintenance/085_maintenance_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's primary_source from /workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/037_licenses_in_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_maintenance/085_maintenance_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/037_licenses_in_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_maintenance/085_maintenance_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-13 using the exact controlled facts ['Southern District of Iowa', 'Iowa'].", "id": "findings.F-13.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-13's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-13.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-29', 'Willa Novak'] for F-13.", "id": "findings.F-13.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-14 exception for repository access anomaly.", "id": "findings.F-14.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's id from /workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/040_licenses_in_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_maintenance/088_maintenance_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's issue from /workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/040_licenses_in_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_maintenance/088_maintenance_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's severity from /workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/040_licenses_in_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_maintenance/088_maintenance_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's primary_source from /workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/040_licenses_in_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_maintenance/088_maintenance_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/040_licenses_in_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_maintenance/088_maintenance_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-14 using the exact controlled facts ['6%', '10%'].", "id": "findings.F-14.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-14's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-14.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-29', 'Theo Laurent'] for F-14.", "id": "findings.F-14.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-15 exception for cease-and-desist deadline.", "id": "findings.F-15.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's id from /workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/043_licenses_out_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_security_interests/091_security_interests_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's issue from /workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/043_licenses_out_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_security_interests/091_security_interests_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's severity from /workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/043_licenses_out_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_security_interests/091_security_interests_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's primary_source from /workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/043_licenses_out_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_security_interests/091_security_interests_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/043_licenses_out_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_security_interests/091_security_interests_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-15 using the exact controlled facts ['notices-hinterland_agricultural_science@example.test', 'archive-prairie_state_university@example.test'].", "id": "findings.F-15.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-15's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-15.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-29', 'Amara Patel'] for F-15.", "id": "findings.F-15.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-16 exception for security-interest release gap.", "id": "findings.F-16.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's id from /workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/046_licenses_out_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_security_interests/094_security_interests_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's issue from /workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/046_licenses_out_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_security_interests/094_security_interests_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's severity from /workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/046_licenses_out_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_security_interests/094_security_interests_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's primary_source from /workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/046_licenses_out_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_security_interests/094_security_interests_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/046_licenses_out_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_security_interests/094_security_interests_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-16 using the exact controlled facts ['83 records', '2025-02-07', '64 records', '2025-03-15'].", "id": "findings.F-16.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-16's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-16.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-29', 'Henry Cho'] for F-16.", "id": "findings.F-16.action_anchors"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Executive assessment' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Executive assessment"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Method and record coverage' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Method and record coverage"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Findings' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Findings"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Recommended next actions' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Recommended next actions"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Assumptions and limitations' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Assumptions and limitations"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-01 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-01"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-02 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-02"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-03 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-03"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-04 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-04"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-05 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-05"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-06 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-06"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-07 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-07"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-08 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-08"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-09 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-09"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-10 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-10"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-11 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-11"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-12 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-12"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-13 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-13"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-14 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-14"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-15 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-15"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-16 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-16"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Do not claim the production has no issues or that every record is consistent.", "id": "memo.forbidden_claims_absent"}], "decision_options": [{"id": "cross-source-reconciliation", "label": "Reconcile controlling and corroborating records", "reason": "The CB-IP-3208 production contains independently maintained records; a defensible answer must preserve each supported conflict and its cure owner.", "selected": true}, {"id": "latest-record-controls", "label": "Treat the latest record as controlling", "reason": "Timestamp recency does not establish legal priority, execution, or approval authority.", "selected": false}, {"id": "primary-records-only", "label": "Report primary records without reconciliation", "reason": "Primary records alone conceal the operational conflicts that create the actionable exceptions.", "selected": false}], "gates": ["all_evidence_read_in_full", "chain_of_custody_metadata_checked", "findings_criteria_complete", "memo_criteria_complete", "deliverables_written_through_mcp"], "metadata_checks": 8, "metric": "weighted_criteria_score", "minimum_tool_calls": 46, "required_deliverables": ["findings.json", "advice.md"], "required_document_reads": 33, "type": "deterministic", "weights": {"findings": 0.55, "memo": 0.2, "procedure": 0.25}}, "task_id": "cb100-088-hinterland-agri", "task_name": "Hinterland seed technology title audit", "world_id": "counselbench-filesystem-mcp-v2"}
-{"context_files": ["task_files/cb100-089-ionwave-semi/01_patents/001_patents_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-089-ionwave-semi/01_patents/002_patents_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-089-ionwave-semi/01_patents/003_patents_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-089-ionwave-semi/01_patents/004_patents_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-089-ionwave-semi/01_patents/005_patents_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-089-ionwave-semi/01_patents/006_patents_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-089-ionwave-semi/01_patents/007_patents_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-089-ionwave-semi/01_patents/008_patents_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-089-ionwave-semi/02_trademarks/009_trademarks_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-089-ionwave-semi/02_trademarks/010_trademarks_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-089-ionwave-semi/02_trademarks/011_trademarks_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-089-ionwave-semi/02_trademarks/012_trademarks_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-089-ionwave-semi/02_trademarks/013_trademarks_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-089-ionwave-semi/02_trademarks/014_trademarks_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-089-ionwave-semi/02_trademarks/015_trademarks_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-089-ionwave-semi/02_trademarks/016_trademarks_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-089-ionwave-semi/03_copyrights/017_copyrights_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-089-ionwave-semi/03_copyrights/018_copyrights_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-089-ionwave-semi/03_copyrights/019_copyrights_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-089-ionwave-semi/03_copyrights/020_copyrights_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-089-ionwave-semi/03_copyrights/021_copyrights_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-089-ionwave-semi/03_copyrights/022_copyrights_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-089-ionwave-semi/03_copyrights/023_copyrights_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-089-ionwave-semi/03_copyrights/024_copyrights_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-089-ionwave-semi/04_invention_assignments/025_invention_assignments_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-089-ionwave-semi/04_invention_assignments/026_invention_assignments_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-089-ionwave-semi/04_invention_assignments/027_invention_assignments_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-089-ionwave-semi/04_invention_assignments/028_invention_assignments_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-089-ionwave-semi/04_invention_assignments/029_invention_assignments_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-089-ionwave-semi/04_invention_assignments/030_invention_assignments_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-089-ionwave-semi/04_invention_assignments/031_invention_assignments_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-089-ionwave-semi/04_invention_assignments/032_invention_assignments_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-089-ionwave-semi/05_licenses_in/033_licenses_in_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-089-ionwave-semi/05_licenses_in/034_licenses_in_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-089-ionwave-semi/05_licenses_in/035_licenses_in_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-089-ionwave-semi/05_licenses_in/036_licenses_in_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-089-ionwave-semi/05_licenses_in/037_licenses_in_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-089-ionwave-semi/05_licenses_in/038_licenses_in_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-089-ionwave-semi/05_licenses_in/039_licenses_in_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-089-ionwave-semi/05_licenses_in/040_licenses_in_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-089-ionwave-semi/06_licenses_out/041_licenses_out_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-089-ionwave-semi/06_licenses_out/042_licenses_out_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-089-ionwave-semi/06_licenses_out/043_licenses_out_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-089-ionwave-semi/06_licenses_out/044_licenses_out_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-089-ionwave-semi/06_licenses_out/045_licenses_out_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-089-ionwave-semi/06_licenses_out/046_licenses_out_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-089-ionwave-semi/06_licenses_out/047_licenses_out_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-089-ionwave-semi/06_licenses_out/048_licenses_out_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-089-ionwave-semi/07_open_source/049_open_source_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-089-ionwave-semi/07_open_source/050_open_source_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-089-ionwave-semi/07_open_source/051_open_source_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-089-ionwave-semi/07_open_source/052_open_source_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-089-ionwave-semi/07_open_source/053_open_source_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-089-ionwave-semi/07_open_source/054_open_source_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-089-ionwave-semi/07_open_source/055_open_source_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-089-ionwave-semi/07_open_source/056_open_source_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-089-ionwave-semi/08_domain_accounts/057_domain_accounts_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-089-ionwave-semi/08_domain_accounts/058_domain_accounts_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-089-ionwave-semi/08_domain_accounts/059_domain_accounts_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-089-ionwave-semi/08_domain_accounts/060_domain_accounts_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-089-ionwave-semi/08_domain_accounts/061_domain_accounts_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-089-ionwave-semi/08_domain_accounts/062_domain_accounts_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-089-ionwave-semi/08_domain_accounts/063_domain_accounts_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-089-ionwave-semi/08_domain_accounts/064_domain_accounts_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-089-ionwave-semi/09_development_records/065_development_records_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-089-ionwave-semi/09_development_records/066_development_records_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-089-ionwave-semi/09_development_records/067_development_records_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-089-ionwave-semi/09_development_records/068_development_records_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-089-ionwave-semi/09_development_records/069_development_records_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-089-ionwave-semi/09_development_records/070_development_records_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-089-ionwave-semi/09_development_records/071_development_records_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-089-ionwave-semi/09_development_records/072_development_records_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-089-ionwave-semi/10_disputes/073_disputes_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-089-ionwave-semi/10_disputes/074_disputes_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-089-ionwave-semi/10_disputes/075_disputes_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-089-ionwave-semi/10_disputes/076_disputes_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-089-ionwave-semi/10_disputes/077_disputes_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-089-ionwave-semi/10_disputes/078_disputes_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-089-ionwave-semi/10_disputes/079_disputes_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-089-ionwave-semi/10_disputes/080_disputes_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-089-ionwave-semi/11_maintenance/081_maintenance_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-089-ionwave-semi/11_maintenance/082_maintenance_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-089-ionwave-semi/11_maintenance/083_maintenance_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-089-ionwave-semi/11_maintenance/084_maintenance_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-089-ionwave-semi/11_maintenance/085_maintenance_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-089-ionwave-semi/11_maintenance/086_maintenance_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-089-ionwave-semi/11_maintenance/087_maintenance_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-089-ionwave-semi/11_maintenance/088_maintenance_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-089-ionwave-semi/12_security_interests/089_security_interests_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-089-ionwave-semi/12_security_interests/090_security_interests_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-089-ionwave-semi/12_security_interests/091_security_interests_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-089-ionwave-semi/12_security_interests/092_security_interests_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-089-ionwave-semi/12_security_interests/093_security_interests_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-089-ionwave-semi/12_security_interests/094_security_interests_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-089-ionwave-semi/12_security_interests/095_security_interests_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-089-ionwave-semi/12_security_interests/096_security_interests_status_report.md"], "gold_output": {"advice_markdown": "# Counsel advice — IonWave semiconductor portfolio check\n\n## Executive assessment\n\nFor IonWave Semiconductor matter CB-IP-3209, the review identified 16 source-supported exceptions requiring action before 2026-10-02. The assessment concerns Kiyomizu Design KK and the supplied record for Texas.\n\n## Method and record coverage\n\nThe review inventoried all 96 production files, read the 33 controlling, corroborating, and control records, searched the email exports, and checked metadata for the designated chain-of-custody sample. Conclusions are limited to the synthetic production supplied for this benchmark matter.\n\n## Findings\n\n### F-01 — inventor assignment gap (critical)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for inventor assignment gap: one source states the operative date is 2026-02-25 under control reference CB-IP-3209-A158, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2026-04-10 under response reference CB-IP-3209-J519.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/01_patents/001_patents_control_register.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/07_open_source/049_open_source_control_register.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-10-02, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Dominic Alvarez.\n\n### F-02 — recorded-owner mismatch (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for recorded-owner mismatch: one source states the controlling amount is $3,781,525.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $3,809,550.00.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/01_patents/004_patents_ledger_export.csv`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/07_open_source/052_open_source_ledger_export.csv`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-10-02, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Priya Raman.\n\n### F-03 — maintenance-fee deadline (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for maintenance-fee deadline: one source states approval is attributed to Lena Varga as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Rafael Okafor and contains no entry for Lena Varga.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/01_patents/007_patents_officer_certificate.html`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/07_open_source/055_open_source_officer_certificate.html`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-10-02, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Elliot Mercer.\n\n### F-04 — foreign-filing restriction (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for foreign-filing restriction: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-IP-3209-D362, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-IP-3209-M327.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/02_trademarks/010_trademarks_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/08_domain_accounts/058_domain_accounts_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-10-02, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Talia Brooks.\n\n### F-05 — trademark specimen issue (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for trademark specimen issue: one source states the applicable location is Western District of Texas, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to Texas operations outside Western District of Texas.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/02_trademarks/013_trademarks_review_memorandum.json`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/08_domain_accounts/061_domain_accounts_review_memorandum.json`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-10-02, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Jonas Feld.\n\n### F-06 — coexistence restriction (low)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for coexistence restriction: one source states the threshold is 10% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 14% and produced a different exception result.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/02_trademarks/016_trademarks_status_report.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/08_domain_accounts/064_domain_accounts_status_report.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-10-02, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Mei Whitaker.\n\n### F-07 — work-for-hire defect (critical)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for work-for-hire defect: one source states formal notice must use notices-ionwave_semiconductor@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-kiyomizu_design_kk@example.test.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/03_copyrights/019_copyrights_correspondence.eml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/09_development_records/067_development_records_correspondence.eml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-10-02, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Caleb Hassan.\n\n### F-08 — source-code ownership gap (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for source-code ownership gap: one source states the governed population contains 156 records through 2025-04-21, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 71 records through 2025-06-03.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/03_copyrights/022_copyrights_formal_notice.xml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/09_development_records/070_development_records_formal_notice.xml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-10-02, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Leona Park.\n\n### F-09 — inbound-license field restriction (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for inbound-license field restriction: one source states the operative date is 2025-12-14 under control reference CB-IP-3209-I505, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2026-01-20 under response reference CB-IP-3209-R961.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/025_invention_assignments_control_register.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/10_disputes/073_disputes_control_register.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-10-02, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Isaac Romero.\n\n### F-10 — outbound sublicense overreach (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for outbound sublicense overreach: one source states the controlling amount is $7,081,159.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $7,368,818.00.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/028_invention_assignments_ledger_export.csv`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/10_disputes/076_disputes_ledger_export.csv`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-10-02, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Sofia Bennett.\n\n### F-11 — copyleft distribution trigger (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for copyleft distribution trigger: one source states approval is attributed to Lena Varga as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Henry Cho and contains no entry for Lena Varga.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/031_invention_assignments_officer_certificate.html`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/10_disputes/079_disputes_officer_certificate.html`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-10-02, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Adrian Mensah.\n\n### F-12 — notice-file omission (low)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for notice-file omission: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-IP-3209-L808, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-IP-3209-U916.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/034_licenses_in_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/11_maintenance/082_maintenance_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-10-02, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Willa Novak.\n\n### F-13 — domain registrant mismatch (critical)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for domain registrant mismatch: one source states the applicable location is Western District of Texas, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to Texas operations outside Western District of Texas.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/037_licenses_in_review_memorandum.json`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/11_maintenance/085_maintenance_review_memorandum.json`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-10-02, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Theo Laurent.\n\n### F-14 — repository access anomaly (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for repository access anomaly: one source states the threshold is 3% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 8% and produced a different exception result.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/040_licenses_in_status_report.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/11_maintenance/088_maintenance_status_report.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-10-02, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Amara Patel.\n\n### F-15 — cease-and-desist deadline (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for cease-and-desist deadline: one source states formal notice must use notices-ionwave_semiconductor@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-kiyomizu_design_kk@example.test.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/043_licenses_out_correspondence.eml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/091_security_interests_correspondence.eml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-10-02, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Henry Cho.\n\n### F-16 — security-interest release gap (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for security-interest release gap: one source states the governed population contains 95 records through 2025-11-26, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 66 records through 2026-01-03.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/046_licenses_out_formal_notice.xml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/094_security_interests_formal_notice.xml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-10-02, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Nadine Flores.\n\n## Recommended next actions\n\nSequence the critical and high findings first, assign the named owners, preserve the cited records, and document any resolution in the controlling matter register before the stated deadline.\n\n## Assumptions and limitations\n\nThis analysis is confined to task cb100-089-ionwave-semi and the supplied synthetic evidence. It does not rely on external facts, does not resolve disputed law, and is not legal advice for a real person or entity.\n", "findings": {"as_of": "2026-10-02", "findings": [{"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/07_open_source/049_open_source_control_register.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for inventor assignment gap: one source states the operative date is 2026-02-25 under control reference CB-IP-3209-A158, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2026-04-10 under response reference CB-IP-3209-J519.", "id": "F-01", "issue": "inventor assignment gap", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/01_patents/001_patents_control_register.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-10-02, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Dominic Alvarez.", "severity": "critical"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/07_open_source/052_open_source_ledger_export.csv", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for recorded-owner mismatch: one source states the controlling amount is $3,781,525.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $3,809,550.00.", "id": "F-02", "issue": "recorded-owner mismatch", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/01_patents/004_patents_ledger_export.csv", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-10-02, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Priya Raman.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/07_open_source/055_open_source_officer_certificate.html", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for maintenance-fee deadline: one source states approval is attributed to Lena Varga as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Rafael Okafor and contains no entry for Lena Varga.", "id": "F-03", "issue": "maintenance-fee deadline", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/01_patents/007_patents_officer_certificate.html", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-10-02, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Elliot Mercer.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/08_domain_accounts/058_domain_accounts_executed_instrument.txt", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for foreign-filing restriction: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-IP-3209-D362, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-IP-3209-M327.", "id": "F-04", "issue": "foreign-filing restriction", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/02_trademarks/010_trademarks_executed_instrument.txt", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-10-02, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Talia Brooks.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/08_domain_accounts/061_domain_accounts_review_memorandum.json", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for trademark specimen issue: one source states the applicable location is Western District of Texas, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to Texas operations outside Western District of Texas.", "id": "F-05", "issue": "trademark specimen issue", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/02_trademarks/013_trademarks_review_memorandum.json", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-10-02, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Jonas Feld.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/08_domain_accounts/064_domain_accounts_status_report.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for coexistence restriction: one source states the threshold is 10% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 14% and produced a different exception result.", "id": "F-06", "issue": "coexistence restriction", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/02_trademarks/016_trademarks_status_report.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-10-02, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Mei Whitaker.", "severity": "low"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/09_development_records/067_development_records_correspondence.eml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for work-for-hire defect: one source states formal notice must use notices-ionwave_semiconductor@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-kiyomizu_design_kk@example.test.", "id": "F-07", "issue": "work-for-hire defect", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/03_copyrights/019_copyrights_correspondence.eml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-10-02, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Caleb Hassan.", "severity": "critical"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/09_development_records/070_development_records_formal_notice.xml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for source-code ownership gap: one source states the governed population contains 156 records through 2025-04-21, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 71 records through 2025-06-03.", "id": "F-08", "issue": "source-code ownership gap", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/03_copyrights/022_copyrights_formal_notice.xml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-10-02, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Leona Park.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/10_disputes/073_disputes_control_register.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for inbound-license field restriction: one source states the operative date is 2025-12-14 under control reference CB-IP-3209-I505, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2026-01-20 under response reference CB-IP-3209-R961.", "id": "F-09", "issue": "inbound-license field restriction", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/025_invention_assignments_control_register.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-10-02, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Isaac Romero.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/10_disputes/076_disputes_ledger_export.csv", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for outbound sublicense overreach: one source states the controlling amount is $7,081,159.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $7,368,818.00.", "id": "F-10", "issue": "outbound sublicense overreach", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/028_invention_assignments_ledger_export.csv", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-10-02, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Sofia Bennett.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/10_disputes/079_disputes_officer_certificate.html", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for copyleft distribution trigger: one source states approval is attributed to Lena Varga as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Henry Cho and contains no entry for Lena Varga.", "id": "F-11", "issue": "copyleft distribution trigger", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/031_invention_assignments_officer_certificate.html", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-10-02, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Adrian Mensah.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/11_maintenance/082_maintenance_executed_instrument.txt", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for notice-file omission: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-IP-3209-L808, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-IP-3209-U916.", "id": "F-12", "issue": "notice-file omission", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/034_licenses_in_executed_instrument.txt", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-10-02, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Willa Novak.", "severity": "low"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/11_maintenance/085_maintenance_review_memorandum.json", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for domain registrant mismatch: one source states the applicable location is Western District of Texas, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to Texas operations outside Western District of Texas.", "id": "F-13", "issue": "domain registrant mismatch", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/037_licenses_in_review_memorandum.json", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-10-02, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Theo Laurent.", "severity": "critical"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/11_maintenance/088_maintenance_status_report.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for repository access anomaly: one source states the threshold is 3% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 8% and produced a different exception result.", "id": "F-14", "issue": "repository access anomaly", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/040_licenses_in_status_report.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-10-02, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Amara Patel.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/091_security_interests_correspondence.eml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for cease-and-desist deadline: one source states formal notice must use notices-ionwave_semiconductor@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-kiyomizu_design_kk@example.test.", "id": "F-15", "issue": "cease-and-desist deadline", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/043_licenses_out_correspondence.eml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-10-02, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Henry Cho.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/094_security_interests_formal_notice.xml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for security-interest release gap: one source states the governed population contains 95 records through 2025-11-26, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 66 records through 2026-01-03.", "id": "F-16", "issue": "security-interest release gap", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/046_licenses_out_formal_notice.xml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-10-02, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Nadine Flores.", "severity": "medium"}], "matter_number": "CB-IP-3209", "prepared_for": "IonWave Semiconductor", "schema_version": "1.0", "task_id": "cb100-089-ionwave-semi"}}, "metadata": {"benchmark": "CounselBench-100", "code_license": "Apache-2.0", "data_license": "CC-BY-4.0", "deadline": "2026-10-02", "document_count": 96, "jurisdiction": "Texas", "matter_number": "CB-IP-3209", "mcp_commit": "9a96ea6e5913736f92b88345bf51caeaaa8e719f", "mcp_package": "@modelcontextprotocol/server-filesystem@2026.7.10", "practice_area": "ip-technology", "reference_tool_calls": 46, "required_evidence_reads": 33, "synthetic": true, "venue": "Western District of Texas", "version": "2.0.0"}, "prompt": "You are intellectual-property counsel for IonWave Semiconductor. This matter will be reviewed by legal, finance, and compliance stakeholders who need a single source-grounded output. Chip designs rely on foreign contractors, foundry licenses, export-controlled files, and patents with approaching maintenance dates. Decision due 2026-10-02. Texas law governs; Western District of Texas is the forum. Use the production as of the stated deadline; do not assume facts outside the supplied files. Work out the defensible position from the matter production and leave an audit-ready exception tracker and concise advice for the supervising lawyer. Keep confirmed conflicts separate from open questions, cite the records that actually control each conclusion, and do not fill gaps with outside facts.", "rubric": {"criteria": [{"category": "procedure", "description": "Complete at least 46 successful, argument-specific evidence and output calls.", "id": "procedure.minimum_successful_tool_calls"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Find and read the 33 controlling, corroborating, and work-product-control records in full.", "id": "procedure.all_evidence_read_in_full"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Inspect file metadata for the eight designated critical primary records before relying on them.", "id": "procedure.chain_of_custody_metadata_checked"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Confirm the sandbox's allowed document and output roots.", "id": "procedure.allowed_directories_checked"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Inventory all 96 records so the relevant sources are discovered among the context records.", "id": "procedure.recursive_inventory_completed"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Search the production for email evidence that may corroborate or contradict formal records.", "id": "procedure.targeted_search_completed"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Leave only findings.json and advice.md in the output workspace.", "id": "procedure.exact_deliverable_set"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Create both final work products through the sandbox MCP surface.", "id": "procedure.deliverables_written_through_mcp"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Produce findings.json as a valid JSON object.", "id": "findings.findings_is_object"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Report exactly 16 confirmed exceptions.", "id": "findings.findings_exact_count"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Use each stable finding ID exactly once.", "id": "findings.finding_ids_unique"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set schema_version to the released matter value '1.0'.", "id": "findings.top_level_schema_version"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set task_id to the released matter value 'cb100-089-ionwave-semi'.", "id": "findings.top_level_task_id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set matter_number to the released matter value 'CB-IP-3209'.", "id": "findings.top_level_matter_number"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set prepared_for to the released matter value 'IonWave Semiconductor'.", "id": "findings.top_level_prepared_for"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set as_of to the released matter value '2026-10-02'.", "id": "findings.top_level_as_of"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-01 exception for inventor assignment gap.", "id": "findings.F-01.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's id from /workspace/documents/01_patents/001_patents_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_open_source/049_open_source_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's issue from /workspace/documents/01_patents/001_patents_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_open_source/049_open_source_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's severity from /workspace/documents/01_patents/001_patents_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_open_source/049_open_source_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's primary_source from /workspace/documents/01_patents/001_patents_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_open_source/049_open_source_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/01_patents/001_patents_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_open_source/049_open_source_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-01 using the exact controlled facts ['2026-02-25', 'CB-IP-3209-A158', '2026-04-10', 'CB-IP-3209-J519'].", "id": "findings.F-01.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-01's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-01.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-10-02', 'Dominic Alvarez'] for F-01.", "id": "findings.F-01.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-02 exception for recorded-owner mismatch.", "id": "findings.F-02.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's id from /workspace/documents/01_patents/004_patents_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_open_source/052_open_source_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's issue from /workspace/documents/01_patents/004_patents_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_open_source/052_open_source_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's severity from /workspace/documents/01_patents/004_patents_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_open_source/052_open_source_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's primary_source from /workspace/documents/01_patents/004_patents_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_open_source/052_open_source_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/01_patents/004_patents_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_open_source/052_open_source_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-02 using the exact controlled facts ['$3,781,525.00', '$3,809,550.00'].", "id": "findings.F-02.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-02's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-02.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-10-02', 'Priya Raman'] for F-02.", "id": "findings.F-02.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-03 exception for maintenance-fee deadline.", "id": "findings.F-03.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's id from /workspace/documents/01_patents/007_patents_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_open_source/055_open_source_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's issue from /workspace/documents/01_patents/007_patents_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_open_source/055_open_source_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's severity from /workspace/documents/01_patents/007_patents_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_open_source/055_open_source_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's primary_source from /workspace/documents/01_patents/007_patents_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_open_source/055_open_source_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/01_patents/007_patents_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_open_source/055_open_source_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-03 using the exact controlled facts ['Lena Varga', 'Rafael Okafor'].", "id": "findings.F-03.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-03's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-03.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-10-02', 'Elliot Mercer'] for F-03.", "id": "findings.F-03.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-04 exception for foreign-filing restriction.", "id": "findings.F-04.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's id from /workspace/documents/02_trademarks/010_trademarks_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_domain_accounts/058_domain_accounts_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's issue from /workspace/documents/02_trademarks/010_trademarks_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_domain_accounts/058_domain_accounts_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's severity from /workspace/documents/02_trademarks/010_trademarks_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_domain_accounts/058_domain_accounts_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's primary_source from /workspace/documents/02_trademarks/010_trademarks_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_domain_accounts/058_domain_accounts_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/02_trademarks/010_trademarks_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_domain_accounts/058_domain_accounts_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-04 using the exact controlled facts ['closed without exception', 'CB-IP-3209-D362', 'open and escalated', 'CB-IP-3209-M327'].", "id": "findings.F-04.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-04's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-04.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-10-02', 'Talia Brooks'] for F-04.", "id": "findings.F-04.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-05 exception for trademark specimen issue.", "id": "findings.F-05.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's id from /workspace/documents/02_trademarks/013_trademarks_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_domain_accounts/061_domain_accounts_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's issue from /workspace/documents/02_trademarks/013_trademarks_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_domain_accounts/061_domain_accounts_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's severity from /workspace/documents/02_trademarks/013_trademarks_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_domain_accounts/061_domain_accounts_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's primary_source from /workspace/documents/02_trademarks/013_trademarks_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_domain_accounts/061_domain_accounts_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/02_trademarks/013_trademarks_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_domain_accounts/061_domain_accounts_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-05 using the exact controlled facts ['Western District of Texas', 'Texas'].", "id": "findings.F-05.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-05's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-05.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-10-02', 'Jonas Feld'] for F-05.", "id": "findings.F-05.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-06 exception for coexistence restriction.", "id": "findings.F-06.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's id from /workspace/documents/02_trademarks/016_trademarks_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_domain_accounts/064_domain_accounts_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's issue from /workspace/documents/02_trademarks/016_trademarks_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_domain_accounts/064_domain_accounts_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's severity from /workspace/documents/02_trademarks/016_trademarks_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_domain_accounts/064_domain_accounts_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's primary_source from /workspace/documents/02_trademarks/016_trademarks_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_domain_accounts/064_domain_accounts_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/02_trademarks/016_trademarks_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_domain_accounts/064_domain_accounts_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-06 using the exact controlled facts ['10%', '14%'].", "id": "findings.F-06.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-06's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-06.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-10-02', 'Mei Whitaker'] for F-06.", "id": "findings.F-06.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-07 exception for work-for-hire defect.", "id": "findings.F-07.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's id from /workspace/documents/03_copyrights/019_copyrights_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_development_records/067_development_records_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's issue from /workspace/documents/03_copyrights/019_copyrights_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_development_records/067_development_records_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's severity from /workspace/documents/03_copyrights/019_copyrights_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_development_records/067_development_records_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's primary_source from /workspace/documents/03_copyrights/019_copyrights_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_development_records/067_development_records_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/03_copyrights/019_copyrights_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_development_records/067_development_records_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-07 using the exact controlled facts ['notices-ionwave_semiconductor@example.test', 'archive-kiyomizu_design_kk@example.test'].", "id": "findings.F-07.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-07's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-07.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-10-02', 'Caleb Hassan'] for F-07.", "id": "findings.F-07.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-08 exception for source-code ownership gap.", "id": "findings.F-08.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's id from /workspace/documents/03_copyrights/022_copyrights_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_development_records/070_development_records_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's issue from /workspace/documents/03_copyrights/022_copyrights_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_development_records/070_development_records_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's severity from /workspace/documents/03_copyrights/022_copyrights_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_development_records/070_development_records_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's primary_source from /workspace/documents/03_copyrights/022_copyrights_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_development_records/070_development_records_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/03_copyrights/022_copyrights_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_development_records/070_development_records_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-08 using the exact controlled facts ['156 records', '2025-04-21', '71 records', '2025-06-03'].", "id": "findings.F-08.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-08's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-08.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-10-02', 'Leona Park'] for F-08.", "id": "findings.F-08.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-09 exception for inbound-license field restriction.", "id": "findings.F-09.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's id from /workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/025_invention_assignments_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_disputes/073_disputes_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's issue from /workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/025_invention_assignments_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_disputes/073_disputes_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's severity from /workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/025_invention_assignments_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_disputes/073_disputes_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's primary_source from /workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/025_invention_assignments_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_disputes/073_disputes_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/025_invention_assignments_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_disputes/073_disputes_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-09 using the exact controlled facts ['2025-12-14', 'CB-IP-3209-I505', '2026-01-20', 'CB-IP-3209-R961'].", "id": "findings.F-09.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-09's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-09.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-10-02', 'Isaac Romero'] for F-09.", "id": "findings.F-09.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-10 exception for outbound sublicense overreach.", "id": "findings.F-10.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's id from /workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/028_invention_assignments_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_disputes/076_disputes_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's issue from /workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/028_invention_assignments_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_disputes/076_disputes_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's severity from /workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/028_invention_assignments_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_disputes/076_disputes_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's primary_source from /workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/028_invention_assignments_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_disputes/076_disputes_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/028_invention_assignments_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_disputes/076_disputes_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-10 using the exact controlled facts ['$7,081,159.00', '$7,368,818.00'].", "id": "findings.F-10.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-10's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-10.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-10-02', 'Sofia Bennett'] for F-10.", "id": "findings.F-10.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-11 exception for copyleft distribution trigger.", "id": "findings.F-11.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's id from /workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/031_invention_assignments_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_disputes/079_disputes_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's issue from /workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/031_invention_assignments_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_disputes/079_disputes_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's severity from /workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/031_invention_assignments_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_disputes/079_disputes_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's primary_source from /workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/031_invention_assignments_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_disputes/079_disputes_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/031_invention_assignments_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_disputes/079_disputes_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-11 using the exact controlled facts ['Lena Varga', 'Henry Cho'].", "id": "findings.F-11.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-11's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-11.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-10-02', 'Adrian Mensah'] for F-11.", "id": "findings.F-11.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-12 exception for notice-file omission.", "id": "findings.F-12.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's id from /workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/034_licenses_in_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_maintenance/082_maintenance_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's issue from /workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/034_licenses_in_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_maintenance/082_maintenance_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's severity from /workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/034_licenses_in_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_maintenance/082_maintenance_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's primary_source from /workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/034_licenses_in_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_maintenance/082_maintenance_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/034_licenses_in_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_maintenance/082_maintenance_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-12 using the exact controlled facts ['closed without exception', 'CB-IP-3209-L808', 'open and escalated', 'CB-IP-3209-U916'].", "id": "findings.F-12.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-12's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-12.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-10-02', 'Willa Novak'] for F-12.", "id": "findings.F-12.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-13 exception for domain registrant mismatch.", "id": "findings.F-13.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's id from /workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/037_licenses_in_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_maintenance/085_maintenance_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's issue from /workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/037_licenses_in_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_maintenance/085_maintenance_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's severity from /workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/037_licenses_in_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_maintenance/085_maintenance_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's primary_source from /workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/037_licenses_in_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_maintenance/085_maintenance_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/037_licenses_in_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_maintenance/085_maintenance_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-13 using the exact controlled facts ['Western District of Texas', 'Texas'].", "id": "findings.F-13.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-13's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-13.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-10-02', 'Theo Laurent'] for F-13.", "id": "findings.F-13.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-14 exception for repository access anomaly.", "id": "findings.F-14.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's id from /workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/040_licenses_in_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_maintenance/088_maintenance_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's issue from /workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/040_licenses_in_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_maintenance/088_maintenance_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's severity from /workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/040_licenses_in_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_maintenance/088_maintenance_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's primary_source from /workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/040_licenses_in_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_maintenance/088_maintenance_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/040_licenses_in_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_maintenance/088_maintenance_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-14 using the exact controlled facts ['3%', '8%'].", "id": "findings.F-14.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-14's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-14.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-10-02', 'Amara Patel'] for F-14.", "id": "findings.F-14.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-15 exception for cease-and-desist deadline.", "id": "findings.F-15.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's id from /workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/043_licenses_out_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_security_interests/091_security_interests_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's issue from /workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/043_licenses_out_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_security_interests/091_security_interests_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's severity from /workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/043_licenses_out_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_security_interests/091_security_interests_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's primary_source from /workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/043_licenses_out_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_security_interests/091_security_interests_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/043_licenses_out_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_security_interests/091_security_interests_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-15 using the exact controlled facts ['notices-ionwave_semiconductor@example.test', 'archive-kiyomizu_design_kk@example.test'].", "id": "findings.F-15.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-15's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-15.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-10-02', 'Henry Cho'] for F-15.", "id": "findings.F-15.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-16 exception for security-interest release gap.", "id": "findings.F-16.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's id from /workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/046_licenses_out_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_security_interests/094_security_interests_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's issue from /workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/046_licenses_out_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_security_interests/094_security_interests_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's severity from /workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/046_licenses_out_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_security_interests/094_security_interests_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's primary_source from /workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/046_licenses_out_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_security_interests/094_security_interests_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/046_licenses_out_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_security_interests/094_security_interests_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-16 using the exact controlled facts ['95 records', '2025-11-26', '66 records', '2026-01-03'].", "id": "findings.F-16.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-16's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-16.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-10-02', 'Nadine Flores'] for F-16.", "id": "findings.F-16.action_anchors"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Executive assessment' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Executive assessment"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Method and record coverage' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Method and record coverage"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Findings' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Findings"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Recommended next actions' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Recommended next actions"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Assumptions and limitations' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Assumptions and limitations"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-01 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-01"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-02 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-02"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-03 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-03"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-04 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-04"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-05 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-05"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-06 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-06"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-07 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-07"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-08 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-08"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-09 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-09"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-10 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-10"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-11 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-11"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-12 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-12"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-13 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-13"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-14 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-14"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-15 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-15"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-16 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-16"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Do not claim the production has no issues or that every record is consistent.", "id": "memo.forbidden_claims_absent"}], "decision_options": [{"id": "cross-source-reconciliation", "label": "Reconcile controlling and corroborating records", "reason": "The CB-IP-3209 production contains independently maintained records; a defensible answer must preserve each supported conflict and its cure owner.", "selected": true}, {"id": "latest-record-controls", "label": "Treat the latest record as controlling", "reason": "Timestamp recency does not establish legal priority, execution, or approval authority.", "selected": false}, {"id": "primary-records-only", "label": "Report primary records without reconciliation", "reason": "Primary records alone conceal the operational conflicts that create the actionable exceptions.", "selected": false}], "gates": ["all_evidence_read_in_full", "chain_of_custody_metadata_checked", "findings_criteria_complete", "memo_criteria_complete", "deliverables_written_through_mcp"], "metadata_checks": 8, "metric": "weighted_criteria_score", "minimum_tool_calls": 46, "required_deliverables": ["findings.json", "advice.md"], "required_document_reads": 33, "type": "deterministic", "weights": {"findings": 0.55, "memo": 0.2, "procedure": 0.25}}, "task_id": "cb100-089-ionwave-semi", "task_name": "IonWave semiconductor portfolio check", "world_id": "counselbench-filesystem-mcp-v2"}
-{"context_files": ["task_files/cb100-090-jagged-cloud/01_patents/001_patents_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-090-jagged-cloud/01_patents/002_patents_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-090-jagged-cloud/01_patents/003_patents_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-090-jagged-cloud/01_patents/004_patents_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-090-jagged-cloud/01_patents/005_patents_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-090-jagged-cloud/01_patents/006_patents_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-090-jagged-cloud/01_patents/007_patents_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-090-jagged-cloud/01_patents/008_patents_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-090-jagged-cloud/02_trademarks/009_trademarks_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-090-jagged-cloud/02_trademarks/010_trademarks_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-090-jagged-cloud/02_trademarks/011_trademarks_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-090-jagged-cloud/02_trademarks/012_trademarks_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-090-jagged-cloud/02_trademarks/013_trademarks_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-090-jagged-cloud/02_trademarks/014_trademarks_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-090-jagged-cloud/02_trademarks/015_trademarks_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-090-jagged-cloud/02_trademarks/016_trademarks_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-090-jagged-cloud/03_copyrights/017_copyrights_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-090-jagged-cloud/03_copyrights/018_copyrights_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-090-jagged-cloud/03_copyrights/019_copyrights_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-090-jagged-cloud/03_copyrights/020_copyrights_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-090-jagged-cloud/03_copyrights/021_copyrights_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-090-jagged-cloud/03_copyrights/022_copyrights_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-090-jagged-cloud/03_copyrights/023_copyrights_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-090-jagged-cloud/03_copyrights/024_copyrights_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-090-jagged-cloud/04_invention_assignments/025_invention_assignments_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-090-jagged-cloud/04_invention_assignments/026_invention_assignments_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-090-jagged-cloud/04_invention_assignments/027_invention_assignments_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-090-jagged-cloud/04_invention_assignments/028_invention_assignments_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-090-jagged-cloud/04_invention_assignments/029_invention_assignments_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-090-jagged-cloud/04_invention_assignments/030_invention_assignments_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-090-jagged-cloud/04_invention_assignments/031_invention_assignments_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-090-jagged-cloud/04_invention_assignments/032_invention_assignments_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-090-jagged-cloud/05_licenses_in/033_licenses_in_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-090-jagged-cloud/05_licenses_in/034_licenses_in_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-090-jagged-cloud/05_licenses_in/035_licenses_in_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-090-jagged-cloud/05_licenses_in/036_licenses_in_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-090-jagged-cloud/05_licenses_in/037_licenses_in_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-090-jagged-cloud/05_licenses_in/038_licenses_in_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-090-jagged-cloud/05_licenses_in/039_licenses_in_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-090-jagged-cloud/05_licenses_in/040_licenses_in_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-090-jagged-cloud/06_licenses_out/041_licenses_out_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-090-jagged-cloud/06_licenses_out/042_licenses_out_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-090-jagged-cloud/06_licenses_out/043_licenses_out_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-090-jagged-cloud/06_licenses_out/044_licenses_out_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-090-jagged-cloud/06_licenses_out/045_licenses_out_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-090-jagged-cloud/06_licenses_out/046_licenses_out_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-090-jagged-cloud/06_licenses_out/047_licenses_out_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-090-jagged-cloud/06_licenses_out/048_licenses_out_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-090-jagged-cloud/07_open_source/049_open_source_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-090-jagged-cloud/07_open_source/050_open_source_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-090-jagged-cloud/07_open_source/051_open_source_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-090-jagged-cloud/07_open_source/052_open_source_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-090-jagged-cloud/07_open_source/053_open_source_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-090-jagged-cloud/07_open_source/054_open_source_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-090-jagged-cloud/07_open_source/055_open_source_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-090-jagged-cloud/07_open_source/056_open_source_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-090-jagged-cloud/08_domain_accounts/057_domain_accounts_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-090-jagged-cloud/08_domain_accounts/058_domain_accounts_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-090-jagged-cloud/08_domain_accounts/059_domain_accounts_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-090-jagged-cloud/08_domain_accounts/060_domain_accounts_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-090-jagged-cloud/08_domain_accounts/061_domain_accounts_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-090-jagged-cloud/08_domain_accounts/062_domain_accounts_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-090-jagged-cloud/08_domain_accounts/063_domain_accounts_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-090-jagged-cloud/08_domain_accounts/064_domain_accounts_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-090-jagged-cloud/09_development_records/065_development_records_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-090-jagged-cloud/09_development_records/066_development_records_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-090-jagged-cloud/09_development_records/067_development_records_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-090-jagged-cloud/09_development_records/068_development_records_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-090-jagged-cloud/09_development_records/069_development_records_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-090-jagged-cloud/09_development_records/070_development_records_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-090-jagged-cloud/09_development_records/071_development_records_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-090-jagged-cloud/09_development_records/072_development_records_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-090-jagged-cloud/10_disputes/073_disputes_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-090-jagged-cloud/10_disputes/074_disputes_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-090-jagged-cloud/10_disputes/075_disputes_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-090-jagged-cloud/10_disputes/076_disputes_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-090-jagged-cloud/10_disputes/077_disputes_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-090-jagged-cloud/10_disputes/078_disputes_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-090-jagged-cloud/10_disputes/079_disputes_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-090-jagged-cloud/10_disputes/080_disputes_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-090-jagged-cloud/11_maintenance/081_maintenance_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-090-jagged-cloud/11_maintenance/082_maintenance_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-090-jagged-cloud/11_maintenance/083_maintenance_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-090-jagged-cloud/11_maintenance/084_maintenance_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-090-jagged-cloud/11_maintenance/085_maintenance_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-090-jagged-cloud/11_maintenance/086_maintenance_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-090-jagged-cloud/11_maintenance/087_maintenance_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-090-jagged-cloud/11_maintenance/088_maintenance_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-090-jagged-cloud/12_security_interests/089_security_interests_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-090-jagged-cloud/12_security_interests/090_security_interests_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-090-jagged-cloud/12_security_interests/091_security_interests_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-090-jagged-cloud/12_security_interests/092_security_interests_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-090-jagged-cloud/12_security_interests/093_security_interests_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-090-jagged-cloud/12_security_interests/094_security_interests_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-090-jagged-cloud/12_security_interests/095_security_interests_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-090-jagged-cloud/12_security_interests/096_security_interests_status_report.md"], "gold_output": {"advice_markdown": "# Counsel advice — Jagged Cloud acquisition IP audit\n\n## Executive assessment\n\nFor Jagged Cloud Infrastructure matter CB-IP-3210, the review identified 16 source-supported exceptions requiring action before 2026-10-06. The assessment concerns Nimbus Fork Technologies and the supplied record for Washington.\n\n## Method and record coverage\n\nThe review inventoried all 96 production files, read the 33 controlling, corroborating, and control records, searched the email exports, and checked metadata for the designated chain-of-custody sample. Conclusions are limited to the synthetic production supplied for this benchmark matter.\n\n## Findings\n\n### F-01 — inventor assignment gap (critical)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for inventor assignment gap: one source states the operative date is 2025-01-21 under control reference CB-IP-3210-A118, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2025-03-06 under response reference CB-IP-3210-J447.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/01_patents/001_patents_control_register.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/07_open_source/049_open_source_control_register.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-10-06, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Priya Raman.\n\n### F-02 — recorded-owner mismatch (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for recorded-owner mismatch: one source states the controlling amount is $3,240,961.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $3,358,422.00.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/01_patents/004_patents_ledger_export.csv`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/07_open_source/052_open_source_ledger_export.csv`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-10-06, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Elliot Mercer.\n\n### F-03 — maintenance-fee deadline (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for maintenance-fee deadline: one source states approval is attributed to Samuel Kim as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Dominic Alvarez and contains no entry for Samuel Kim.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/01_patents/007_patents_officer_certificate.html`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/07_open_source/055_open_source_officer_certificate.html`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-10-06, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Talia Brooks.\n\n### F-04 — foreign-filing restriction (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for foreign-filing restriction: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-IP-3210-D370, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-IP-3210-M328.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/02_trademarks/010_trademarks_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/08_domain_accounts/058_domain_accounts_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-10-06, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Jonas Feld.\n\n### F-05 — trademark specimen issue (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for trademark specimen issue: one source states the applicable location is Western District of Washington, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to Washington operations outside Western District of Washington.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/02_trademarks/013_trademarks_review_memorandum.json`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/08_domain_accounts/061_domain_accounts_review_memorandum.json`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-10-06, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Mei Whitaker.\n\n### F-06 — coexistence restriction (low)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for coexistence restriction: one source states the threshold is 2% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 4% and produced a different exception result.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/02_trademarks/016_trademarks_status_report.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/08_domain_accounts/064_domain_accounts_status_report.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-10-06, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Caleb Hassan.\n\n### F-07 — work-for-hire defect (critical)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for work-for-hire defect: one source states formal notice must use notices-jagged_cloud_infrastructure@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-nimbus_fork_technologies@example.test.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/03_copyrights/019_copyrights_correspondence.eml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/09_development_records/067_development_records_correspondence.eml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-10-06, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Leona Park.\n\n### F-08 — source-code ownership gap (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for source-code ownership gap: one source states the governed population contains 52 records through 2025-05-27, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 48 records through 2025-06-16.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/03_copyrights/022_copyrights_formal_notice.xml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/09_development_records/070_development_records_formal_notice.xml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-10-06, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Isaac Romero.\n\n### F-09 — inbound-license field restriction (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for inbound-license field restriction: one source states the operative date is 2025-01-09 under control reference CB-IP-3210-I286, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2025-02-21 under response reference CB-IP-3210-R460.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/025_invention_assignments_control_register.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/10_disputes/073_disputes_control_register.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-10-06, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Sofia Bennett.\n\n### F-10 — outbound sublicense overreach (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for outbound sublicense overreach: one source states the controlling amount is $5,266,682.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $5,489,864.00.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/028_invention_assignments_ledger_export.csv`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/10_disputes/076_disputes_ledger_export.csv`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-10-06, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Adrian Mensah.\n\n### F-11 — copyleft distribution trigger (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for copyleft distribution trigger: one source states approval is attributed to Samuel Kim as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Micah Sullivan and contains no entry for Samuel Kim.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/031_invention_assignments_officer_certificate.html`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/10_disputes/079_disputes_officer_certificate.html`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-10-06, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Willa Novak.\n\n### F-12 — notice-file omission (low)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for notice-file omission: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-IP-3210-L867, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-IP-3210-U505.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/034_licenses_in_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/11_maintenance/082_maintenance_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-10-06, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Theo Laurent.\n\n### F-13 — domain registrant mismatch (critical)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for domain registrant mismatch: one source states the applicable location is Western District of Washington, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to Washington operations outside Western District of Washington.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/037_licenses_in_review_memorandum.json`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/11_maintenance/085_maintenance_review_memorandum.json`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-10-06, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Amara Patel.\n\n### F-14 — repository access anomaly (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for repository access anomaly: one source states the threshold is 14% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 18% and produced a different exception result.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/040_licenses_in_status_report.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/11_maintenance/088_maintenance_status_report.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-10-06, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Henry Cho.\n\n### F-15 — cease-and-desist deadline (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for cease-and-desist deadline: one source states formal notice must use notices-jagged_cloud_infrastructure@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-nimbus_fork_technologies@example.test.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/043_licenses_out_correspondence.eml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/091_security_interests_correspondence.eml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-10-06, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Nadine Flores.\n\n### F-16 — security-interest release gap (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for security-interest release gap: one source states the governed population contains 79 records through 2025-06-23, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 55 records through 2025-07-20.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/046_licenses_out_formal_notice.xml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/094_security_interests_formal_notice.xml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-10-06, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Micah Sullivan.\n\n## Recommended next actions\n\nSequence the critical and high findings first, assign the named owners, preserve the cited records, and document any resolution in the controlling matter register before the stated deadline.\n\n## Assumptions and limitations\n\nThis analysis is confined to task cb100-090-jagged-cloud and the supplied synthetic evidence. It does not rely on external facts, does not resolve disputed law, and is not legal advice for a real person or entity.\n", "findings": {"as_of": "2026-10-06", "findings": [{"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/07_open_source/049_open_source_control_register.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for inventor assignment gap: one source states the operative date is 2025-01-21 under control reference CB-IP-3210-A118, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2025-03-06 under response reference CB-IP-3210-J447.", "id": "F-01", "issue": "inventor assignment gap", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/01_patents/001_patents_control_register.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-10-06, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Priya Raman.", "severity": "critical"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/07_open_source/052_open_source_ledger_export.csv", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for recorded-owner mismatch: one source states the controlling amount is $3,240,961.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $3,358,422.00.", "id": "F-02", "issue": "recorded-owner mismatch", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/01_patents/004_patents_ledger_export.csv", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-10-06, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Elliot Mercer.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/07_open_source/055_open_source_officer_certificate.html", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for maintenance-fee deadline: one source states approval is attributed to Samuel Kim as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Dominic Alvarez and contains no entry for Samuel Kim.", "id": "F-03", "issue": "maintenance-fee deadline", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/01_patents/007_patents_officer_certificate.html", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-10-06, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Talia Brooks.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/08_domain_accounts/058_domain_accounts_executed_instrument.txt", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for foreign-filing restriction: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-IP-3210-D370, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-IP-3210-M328.", "id": "F-04", "issue": "foreign-filing restriction", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/02_trademarks/010_trademarks_executed_instrument.txt", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-10-06, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Jonas Feld.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/08_domain_accounts/061_domain_accounts_review_memorandum.json", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for trademark specimen issue: one source states the applicable location is Western District of Washington, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to Washington operations outside Western District of Washington.", "id": "F-05", "issue": "trademark specimen issue", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/02_trademarks/013_trademarks_review_memorandum.json", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-10-06, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Mei Whitaker.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/08_domain_accounts/064_domain_accounts_status_report.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for coexistence restriction: one source states the threshold is 2% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 4% and produced a different exception result.", "id": "F-06", "issue": "coexistence restriction", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/02_trademarks/016_trademarks_status_report.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-10-06, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Caleb Hassan.", "severity": "low"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/09_development_records/067_development_records_correspondence.eml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for work-for-hire defect: one source states formal notice must use notices-jagged_cloud_infrastructure@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-nimbus_fork_technologies@example.test.", "id": "F-07", "issue": "work-for-hire defect", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/03_copyrights/019_copyrights_correspondence.eml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-10-06, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Leona Park.", "severity": "critical"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/09_development_records/070_development_records_formal_notice.xml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for source-code ownership gap: one source states the governed population contains 52 records through 2025-05-27, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 48 records through 2025-06-16.", "id": "F-08", "issue": "source-code ownership gap", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/03_copyrights/022_copyrights_formal_notice.xml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-10-06, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Isaac Romero.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/10_disputes/073_disputes_control_register.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for inbound-license field restriction: one source states the operative date is 2025-01-09 under control reference CB-IP-3210-I286, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2025-02-21 under response reference CB-IP-3210-R460.", "id": "F-09", "issue": "inbound-license field restriction", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/025_invention_assignments_control_register.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-10-06, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Sofia Bennett.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/10_disputes/076_disputes_ledger_export.csv", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for outbound sublicense overreach: one source states the controlling amount is $5,266,682.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $5,489,864.00.", "id": "F-10", "issue": "outbound sublicense overreach", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/028_invention_assignments_ledger_export.csv", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-10-06, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Adrian Mensah.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/10_disputes/079_disputes_officer_certificate.html", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for copyleft distribution trigger: one source states approval is attributed to Samuel Kim as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Micah Sullivan and contains no entry for Samuel Kim.", "id": "F-11", "issue": "copyleft distribution trigger", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/031_invention_assignments_officer_certificate.html", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-10-06, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Willa Novak.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/11_maintenance/082_maintenance_executed_instrument.txt", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for notice-file omission: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-IP-3210-L867, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-IP-3210-U505.", "id": "F-12", "issue": "notice-file omission", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/034_licenses_in_executed_instrument.txt", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-10-06, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Theo Laurent.", "severity": "low"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/11_maintenance/085_maintenance_review_memorandum.json", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for domain registrant mismatch: one source states the applicable location is Western District of Washington, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to Washington operations outside Western District of Washington.", "id": "F-13", "issue": "domain registrant mismatch", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/037_licenses_in_review_memorandum.json", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-10-06, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Amara Patel.", "severity": "critical"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/11_maintenance/088_maintenance_status_report.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for repository access anomaly: one source states the threshold is 14% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 18% and produced a different exception result.", "id": "F-14", "issue": "repository access anomaly", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/040_licenses_in_status_report.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-10-06, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Henry Cho.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/091_security_interests_correspondence.eml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for cease-and-desist deadline: one source states formal notice must use notices-jagged_cloud_infrastructure@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-nimbus_fork_technologies@example.test.", "id": "F-15", "issue": "cease-and-desist deadline", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/043_licenses_out_correspondence.eml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-10-06, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Nadine Flores.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/094_security_interests_formal_notice.xml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for security-interest release gap: one source states the governed population contains 79 records through 2025-06-23, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 55 records through 2025-07-20.", "id": "F-16", "issue": "security-interest release gap", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/046_licenses_out_formal_notice.xml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-10-06, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Micah Sullivan.", "severity": "medium"}], "matter_number": "CB-IP-3210", "prepared_for": "Jagged Cloud Infrastructure", "schema_version": "1.0", "task_id": "cb100-090-jagged-cloud"}}, "metadata": {"benchmark": "CounselBench-100", "code_license": "Apache-2.0", "data_license": "CC-BY-4.0", "deadline": "2026-10-06", "document_count": 96, "jurisdiction": "Washington", "matter_number": "CB-IP-3210", "mcp_commit": "9a96ea6e5913736f92b88345bf51caeaaa8e719f", "mcp_package": "@modelcontextprotocol/server-filesystem@2026.7.10", "practice_area": "ip-technology", "reference_tool_calls": 46, "required_evidence_reads": 33, "synthetic": true, "venue": "Western District of Washington", "version": "2.0.0"}, "prompt": "You are intellectual-property counsel for Jagged Cloud Infrastructure. The record contains amendments, exports, and correspondence from different custodians; reconcile them into an actionable counsel work product. A cloud acquisition includes forked code, contributor agreements, patent assertions, registrant mismatches, and lender release questions. Decision due 2026-10-06. Washington law governs; Western District of Washington is the forum. Write for a supervising lawyer who will spot-check source paths and exact values. Work out the defensible position from the matter production and leave an audit-ready exception tracker and concise advice for the supervising lawyer. Keep confirmed conflicts separate from open questions, cite the records that actually control each conclusion, and do not fill gaps with outside facts.", "rubric": {"criteria": [{"category": "procedure", "description": "Complete at least 46 successful, argument-specific evidence and output calls.", "id": "procedure.minimum_successful_tool_calls"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Find and read the 33 controlling, corroborating, and work-product-control records in full.", "id": "procedure.all_evidence_read_in_full"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Inspect file metadata for the eight designated critical primary records before relying on them.", "id": "procedure.chain_of_custody_metadata_checked"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Confirm the sandbox's allowed document and output roots.", "id": "procedure.allowed_directories_checked"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Inventory all 96 records so the relevant sources are discovered among the context records.", "id": "procedure.recursive_inventory_completed"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Search the production for email evidence that may corroborate or contradict formal records.", "id": "procedure.targeted_search_completed"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Leave only findings.json and advice.md in the output workspace.", "id": "procedure.exact_deliverable_set"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Create both final work products through the sandbox MCP surface.", "id": "procedure.deliverables_written_through_mcp"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Produce findings.json as a valid JSON object.", "id": "findings.findings_is_object"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Report exactly 16 confirmed exceptions.", "id": "findings.findings_exact_count"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Use each stable finding ID exactly once.", "id": "findings.finding_ids_unique"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set schema_version to the released matter value '1.0'.", "id": "findings.top_level_schema_version"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set task_id to the released matter value 'cb100-090-jagged-cloud'.", "id": "findings.top_level_task_id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set matter_number to the released matter value 'CB-IP-3210'.", "id": "findings.top_level_matter_number"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set prepared_for to the released matter value 'Jagged Cloud Infrastructure'.", "id": "findings.top_level_prepared_for"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set as_of to the released matter value '2026-10-06'.", "id": "findings.top_level_as_of"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-01 exception for inventor assignment gap.", "id": "findings.F-01.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's id from /workspace/documents/01_patents/001_patents_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_open_source/049_open_source_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's issue from /workspace/documents/01_patents/001_patents_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_open_source/049_open_source_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's severity from /workspace/documents/01_patents/001_patents_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_open_source/049_open_source_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's primary_source from /workspace/documents/01_patents/001_patents_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_open_source/049_open_source_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/01_patents/001_patents_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_open_source/049_open_source_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-01 using the exact controlled facts ['2025-01-21', 'CB-IP-3210-A118', '2025-03-06', 'CB-IP-3210-J447'].", "id": "findings.F-01.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-01's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-01.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-10-06', 'Priya Raman'] for F-01.", "id": "findings.F-01.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-02 exception for recorded-owner mismatch.", "id": "findings.F-02.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's id from /workspace/documents/01_patents/004_patents_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_open_source/052_open_source_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's issue from /workspace/documents/01_patents/004_patents_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_open_source/052_open_source_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's severity from /workspace/documents/01_patents/004_patents_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_open_source/052_open_source_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's primary_source from /workspace/documents/01_patents/004_patents_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_open_source/052_open_source_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/01_patents/004_patents_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_open_source/052_open_source_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-02 using the exact controlled facts ['$3,240,961.00', '$3,358,422.00'].", "id": "findings.F-02.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-02's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-02.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-10-06', 'Elliot Mercer'] for F-02.", "id": "findings.F-02.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-03 exception for maintenance-fee deadline.", "id": "findings.F-03.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's id from /workspace/documents/01_patents/007_patents_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_open_source/055_open_source_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's issue from /workspace/documents/01_patents/007_patents_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_open_source/055_open_source_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's severity from /workspace/documents/01_patents/007_patents_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_open_source/055_open_source_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's primary_source from /workspace/documents/01_patents/007_patents_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_open_source/055_open_source_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/01_patents/007_patents_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_open_source/055_open_source_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-03 using the exact controlled facts ['Samuel Kim', 'Dominic Alvarez'].", "id": "findings.F-03.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-03's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-03.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-10-06', 'Talia Brooks'] for F-03.", "id": "findings.F-03.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-04 exception for foreign-filing restriction.", "id": "findings.F-04.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's id from /workspace/documents/02_trademarks/010_trademarks_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_domain_accounts/058_domain_accounts_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's issue from /workspace/documents/02_trademarks/010_trademarks_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_domain_accounts/058_domain_accounts_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's severity from /workspace/documents/02_trademarks/010_trademarks_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_domain_accounts/058_domain_accounts_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's primary_source from /workspace/documents/02_trademarks/010_trademarks_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_domain_accounts/058_domain_accounts_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/02_trademarks/010_trademarks_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_domain_accounts/058_domain_accounts_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-04 using the exact controlled facts ['closed without exception', 'CB-IP-3210-D370', 'open and escalated', 'CB-IP-3210-M328'].", "id": "findings.F-04.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-04's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-04.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-10-06', 'Jonas Feld'] for F-04.", "id": "findings.F-04.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-05 exception for trademark specimen issue.", "id": "findings.F-05.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's id from /workspace/documents/02_trademarks/013_trademarks_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_domain_accounts/061_domain_accounts_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's issue from /workspace/documents/02_trademarks/013_trademarks_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_domain_accounts/061_domain_accounts_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's severity from /workspace/documents/02_trademarks/013_trademarks_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_domain_accounts/061_domain_accounts_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's primary_source from /workspace/documents/02_trademarks/013_trademarks_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_domain_accounts/061_domain_accounts_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/02_trademarks/013_trademarks_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_domain_accounts/061_domain_accounts_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-05 using the exact controlled facts ['Western District of Washington', 'Washington'].", "id": "findings.F-05.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-05's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-05.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-10-06', 'Mei Whitaker'] for F-05.", "id": "findings.F-05.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-06 exception for coexistence restriction.", "id": "findings.F-06.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's id from /workspace/documents/02_trademarks/016_trademarks_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_domain_accounts/064_domain_accounts_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's issue from /workspace/documents/02_trademarks/016_trademarks_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_domain_accounts/064_domain_accounts_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's severity from /workspace/documents/02_trademarks/016_trademarks_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_domain_accounts/064_domain_accounts_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's primary_source from /workspace/documents/02_trademarks/016_trademarks_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_domain_accounts/064_domain_accounts_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/02_trademarks/016_trademarks_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_domain_accounts/064_domain_accounts_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-06 using the exact controlled facts ['2%', '4%'].", "id": "findings.F-06.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-06's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-06.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-10-06', 'Caleb Hassan'] for F-06.", "id": "findings.F-06.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-07 exception for work-for-hire defect.", "id": "findings.F-07.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's id from /workspace/documents/03_copyrights/019_copyrights_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_development_records/067_development_records_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's issue from /workspace/documents/03_copyrights/019_copyrights_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_development_records/067_development_records_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's severity from /workspace/documents/03_copyrights/019_copyrights_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_development_records/067_development_records_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's primary_source from /workspace/documents/03_copyrights/019_copyrights_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_development_records/067_development_records_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/03_copyrights/019_copyrights_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_development_records/067_development_records_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-07 using the exact controlled facts ['notices-jagged_cloud_infrastructure@example.test', 'archive-nimbus_fork_technologies@example.test'].", "id": "findings.F-07.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-07's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-07.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-10-06', 'Leona Park'] for F-07.", "id": "findings.F-07.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-08 exception for source-code ownership gap.", "id": "findings.F-08.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's id from /workspace/documents/03_copyrights/022_copyrights_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_development_records/070_development_records_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's issue from /workspace/documents/03_copyrights/022_copyrights_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_development_records/070_development_records_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's severity from /workspace/documents/03_copyrights/022_copyrights_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_development_records/070_development_records_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's primary_source from /workspace/documents/03_copyrights/022_copyrights_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_development_records/070_development_records_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/03_copyrights/022_copyrights_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_development_records/070_development_records_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-08 using the exact controlled facts ['52 records', '2025-05-27', '48 records', '2025-06-16'].", "id": "findings.F-08.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-08's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-08.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-10-06', 'Isaac Romero'] for F-08.", "id": "findings.F-08.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-09 exception for inbound-license field restriction.", "id": "findings.F-09.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's id from /workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/025_invention_assignments_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_disputes/073_disputes_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's issue from /workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/025_invention_assignments_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_disputes/073_disputes_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's severity from /workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/025_invention_assignments_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_disputes/073_disputes_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's primary_source from /workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/025_invention_assignments_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_disputes/073_disputes_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/025_invention_assignments_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_disputes/073_disputes_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-09 using the exact controlled facts ['2025-01-09', 'CB-IP-3210-I286', '2025-02-21', 'CB-IP-3210-R460'].", "id": "findings.F-09.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-09's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-09.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-10-06', 'Sofia Bennett'] for F-09.", "id": "findings.F-09.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-10 exception for outbound sublicense overreach.", "id": "findings.F-10.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's id from /workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/028_invention_assignments_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_disputes/076_disputes_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's issue from /workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/028_invention_assignments_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_disputes/076_disputes_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's severity from /workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/028_invention_assignments_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_disputes/076_disputes_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's primary_source from /workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/028_invention_assignments_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_disputes/076_disputes_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/028_invention_assignments_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_disputes/076_disputes_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-10 using the exact controlled facts ['$5,266,682.00', '$5,489,864.00'].", "id": "findings.F-10.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-10's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-10.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-10-06', 'Adrian Mensah'] for F-10.", "id": "findings.F-10.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-11 exception for copyleft distribution trigger.", "id": "findings.F-11.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's id from /workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/031_invention_assignments_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_disputes/079_disputes_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's issue from /workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/031_invention_assignments_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_disputes/079_disputes_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's severity from /workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/031_invention_assignments_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_disputes/079_disputes_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's primary_source from /workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/031_invention_assignments_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_disputes/079_disputes_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/031_invention_assignments_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_disputes/079_disputes_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-11 using the exact controlled facts ['Samuel Kim', 'Micah Sullivan'].", "id": "findings.F-11.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-11's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-11.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-10-06', 'Willa Novak'] for F-11.", "id": "findings.F-11.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-12 exception for notice-file omission.", "id": "findings.F-12.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's id from /workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/034_licenses_in_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_maintenance/082_maintenance_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's issue from /workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/034_licenses_in_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_maintenance/082_maintenance_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's severity from /workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/034_licenses_in_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_maintenance/082_maintenance_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's primary_source from /workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/034_licenses_in_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_maintenance/082_maintenance_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/034_licenses_in_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_maintenance/082_maintenance_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-12 using the exact controlled facts ['closed without exception', 'CB-IP-3210-L867', 'open and escalated', 'CB-IP-3210-U505'].", "id": "findings.F-12.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-12's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-12.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-10-06', 'Theo Laurent'] for F-12.", "id": "findings.F-12.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-13 exception for domain registrant mismatch.", "id": "findings.F-13.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's id from /workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/037_licenses_in_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_maintenance/085_maintenance_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's issue from /workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/037_licenses_in_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_maintenance/085_maintenance_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's severity from /workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/037_licenses_in_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_maintenance/085_maintenance_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's primary_source from /workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/037_licenses_in_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_maintenance/085_maintenance_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/037_licenses_in_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_maintenance/085_maintenance_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-13 using the exact controlled facts ['Western District of Washington', 'Washington'].", "id": "findings.F-13.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-13's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-13.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-10-06', 'Amara Patel'] for F-13.", "id": "findings.F-13.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-14 exception for repository access anomaly.", "id": "findings.F-14.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's id from /workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/040_licenses_in_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_maintenance/088_maintenance_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's issue from /workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/040_licenses_in_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_maintenance/088_maintenance_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's severity from /workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/040_licenses_in_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_maintenance/088_maintenance_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's primary_source from /workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/040_licenses_in_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_maintenance/088_maintenance_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/040_licenses_in_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_maintenance/088_maintenance_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-14 using the exact controlled facts ['14%', '18%'].", "id": "findings.F-14.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-14's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-14.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-10-06', 'Henry Cho'] for F-14.", "id": "findings.F-14.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-15 exception for cease-and-desist deadline.", "id": "findings.F-15.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's id from /workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/043_licenses_out_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_security_interests/091_security_interests_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's issue from /workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/043_licenses_out_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_security_interests/091_security_interests_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's severity from /workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/043_licenses_out_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_security_interests/091_security_interests_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's primary_source from /workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/043_licenses_out_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_security_interests/091_security_interests_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/043_licenses_out_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_security_interests/091_security_interests_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-15 using the exact controlled facts ['notices-jagged_cloud_infrastructure@example.test', 'archive-nimbus_fork_technologies@example.test'].", "id": "findings.F-15.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-15's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-15.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-10-06', 'Nadine Flores'] for F-15.", "id": "findings.F-15.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-16 exception for security-interest release gap.", "id": "findings.F-16.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's id from /workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/046_licenses_out_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_security_interests/094_security_interests_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's issue from /workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/046_licenses_out_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_security_interests/094_security_interests_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's severity from /workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/046_licenses_out_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_security_interests/094_security_interests_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's primary_source from /workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/046_licenses_out_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_security_interests/094_security_interests_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/046_licenses_out_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_security_interests/094_security_interests_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-16 using the exact controlled facts ['79 records', '2025-06-23', '55 records', '2025-07-20'].", "id": "findings.F-16.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-16's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-16.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-10-06', 'Micah Sullivan'] for F-16.", "id": "findings.F-16.action_anchors"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Executive assessment' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Executive assessment"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Method and record coverage' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Method and record coverage"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Findings' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Findings"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Recommended next actions' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Recommended next actions"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Assumptions and limitations' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Assumptions and limitations"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-01 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-01"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-02 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-02"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-03 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-03"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-04 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-04"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-05 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-05"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-06 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-06"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-07 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-07"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-08 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-08"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-09 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-09"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-10 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-10"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-11 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-11"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-12 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-12"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-13 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-13"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-14 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-14"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-15 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-15"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-16 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-16"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Do not claim the production has no issues or that every record is consistent.", "id": "memo.forbidden_claims_absent"}], "decision_options": [{"id": "cross-source-reconciliation", "label": "Reconcile controlling and corroborating records", "reason": "The CB-IP-3210 production contains independently maintained records; a defensible answer must preserve each supported conflict and its cure owner.", "selected": true}, {"id": "latest-record-controls", "label": "Treat the latest record as controlling", "reason": "Timestamp recency does not establish legal priority, execution, or approval authority.", "selected": false}, {"id": "primary-records-only", "label": "Report primary records without reconciliation", "reason": "Primary records alone conceal the operational conflicts that create the actionable exceptions.", "selected": false}], "gates": ["all_evidence_read_in_full", "chain_of_custody_metadata_checked", "findings_criteria_complete", "memo_criteria_complete", "deliverables_written_through_mcp"], "metadata_checks": 8, "metric": "weighted_criteria_score", "minimum_tool_calls": 46, "required_deliverables": ["findings.json", "advice.md"], "required_document_reads": 33, "type": "deterministic", "weights": {"findings": 0.55, "memo": 0.2, "procedure": 0.25}}, "task_id": "cb100-090-jagged-cloud", "task_name": "Jagged Cloud acquisition IP audit", "world_id": "counselbench-filesystem-mcp-v2"}
-{"context_files": ["task_files/cb100-091-alabaster-energy/01_board_committees/001_board_committees_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-091-alabaster-energy/01_board_committees/002_board_committees_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-091-alabaster-energy/01_board_committees/003_board_committees_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-091-alabaster-energy/01_board_committees/004_board_committees_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-091-alabaster-energy/01_board_committees/005_board_committees_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-091-alabaster-energy/01_board_committees/006_board_committees_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-091-alabaster-energy/01_board_committees/007_board_committees_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-091-alabaster-energy/01_board_committees/008_board_committees_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-091-alabaster-energy/02_minutes_materials/009_minutes_materials_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-091-alabaster-energy/02_minutes_materials/010_minutes_materials_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-091-alabaster-energy/02_minutes_materials/011_minutes_materials_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-091-alabaster-energy/02_minutes_materials/012_minutes_materials_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-091-alabaster-energy/02_minutes_materials/013_minutes_materials_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-091-alabaster-energy/02_minutes_materials/014_minutes_materials_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-091-alabaster-energy/02_minutes_materials/015_minutes_materials_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-091-alabaster-energy/02_minutes_materials/016_minutes_materials_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-091-alabaster-energy/03_sec_filings/017_sec_filings_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-091-alabaster-energy/03_sec_filings/018_sec_filings_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-091-alabaster-energy/03_sec_filings/019_sec_filings_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-091-alabaster-energy/03_sec_filings/020_sec_filings_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-091-alabaster-energy/03_sec_filings/021_sec_filings_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-091-alabaster-energy/03_sec_filings/022_sec_filings_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-091-alabaster-energy/03_sec_filings/023_sec_filings_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-091-alabaster-energy/03_sec_filings/024_sec_filings_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-091-alabaster-energy/04_disclosure_controls/025_disclosure_controls_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-091-alabaster-energy/04_disclosure_controls/026_disclosure_controls_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-091-alabaster-energy/04_disclosure_controls/027_disclosure_controls_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-091-alabaster-energy/04_disclosure_controls/028_disclosure_controls_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-091-alabaster-energy/04_disclosure_controls/029_disclosure_controls_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-091-alabaster-energy/04_disclosure_controls/030_disclosure_controls_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-091-alabaster-energy/04_disclosure_controls/031_disclosure_controls_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-091-alabaster-energy/04_disclosure_controls/032_disclosure_controls_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-091-alabaster-energy/05_insider_trading/033_insider_trading_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-091-alabaster-energy/05_insider_trading/034_insider_trading_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-091-alabaster-energy/05_insider_trading/035_insider_trading_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-091-alabaster-energy/05_insider_trading/036_insider_trading_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-091-alabaster-energy/05_insider_trading/037_insider_trading_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-091-alabaster-energy/05_insider_trading/038_insider_trading_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-091-alabaster-energy/05_insider_trading/039_insider_trading_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-091-alabaster-energy/05_insider_trading/040_insider_trading_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-091-alabaster-energy/06_related_parties/041_related_parties_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-091-alabaster-energy/06_related_parties/042_related_parties_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-091-alabaster-energy/06_related_parties/043_related_parties_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-091-alabaster-energy/06_related_parties/044_related_parties_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-091-alabaster-energy/06_related_parties/045_related_parties_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-091-alabaster-energy/06_related_parties/046_related_parties_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-091-alabaster-energy/06_related_parties/047_related_parties_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-091-alabaster-energy/06_related_parties/048_related_parties_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-091-alabaster-energy/07_equity_compensation/049_equity_compensation_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-091-alabaster-energy/07_equity_compensation/050_equity_compensation_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-091-alabaster-energy/07_equity_compensation/051_equity_compensation_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-091-alabaster-energy/07_equity_compensation/052_equity_compensation_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-091-alabaster-energy/07_equity_compensation/053_equity_compensation_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-091-alabaster-energy/07_equity_compensation/054_equity_compensation_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-091-alabaster-energy/07_equity_compensation/055_equity_compensation_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-091-alabaster-energy/07_equity_compensation/056_equity_compensation_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-091-alabaster-energy/08_earnings_guidance/057_earnings_guidance_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-091-alabaster-energy/08_earnings_guidance/058_earnings_guidance_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-091-alabaster-energy/08_earnings_guidance/059_earnings_guidance_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-091-alabaster-energy/08_earnings_guidance/060_earnings_guidance_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-091-alabaster-energy/08_earnings_guidance/061_earnings_guidance_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-091-alabaster-energy/08_earnings_guidance/062_earnings_guidance_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-091-alabaster-energy/08_earnings_guidance/063_earnings_guidance_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-091-alabaster-energy/08_earnings_guidance/064_earnings_guidance_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-091-alabaster-energy/09_whistleblower/065_whistleblower_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-091-alabaster-energy/09_whistleblower/066_whistleblower_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-091-alabaster-energy/09_whistleblower/067_whistleblower_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-091-alabaster-energy/09_whistleblower/068_whistleblower_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-091-alabaster-energy/09_whistleblower/069_whistleblower_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-091-alabaster-energy/09_whistleblower/070_whistleblower_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-091-alabaster-energy/09_whistleblower/071_whistleblower_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-091-alabaster-energy/09_whistleblower/072_whistleblower_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-091-alabaster-energy/10_stock_exchange/073_stock_exchange_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-091-alabaster-energy/10_stock_exchange/074_stock_exchange_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-091-alabaster-energy/10_stock_exchange/075_stock_exchange_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-091-alabaster-energy/10_stock_exchange/076_stock_exchange_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-091-alabaster-energy/10_stock_exchange/077_stock_exchange_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-091-alabaster-energy/10_stock_exchange/078_stock_exchange_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-091-alabaster-energy/10_stock_exchange/079_stock_exchange_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-091-alabaster-energy/10_stock_exchange/080_stock_exchange_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-091-alabaster-energy/11_debt_covenants/081_debt_covenants_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-091-alabaster-energy/11_debt_covenants/082_debt_covenants_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-091-alabaster-energy/11_debt_covenants/083_debt_covenants_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-091-alabaster-energy/11_debt_covenants/084_debt_covenants_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-091-alabaster-energy/11_debt_covenants/085_debt_covenants_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-091-alabaster-energy/11_debt_covenants/086_debt_covenants_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-091-alabaster-energy/11_debt_covenants/087_debt_covenants_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-091-alabaster-energy/11_debt_covenants/088_debt_covenants_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-091-alabaster-energy/12_certifications/089_certifications_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-091-alabaster-energy/12_certifications/090_certifications_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-091-alabaster-energy/12_certifications/091_certifications_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-091-alabaster-energy/12_certifications/092_certifications_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-091-alabaster-energy/12_certifications/093_certifications_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-091-alabaster-energy/12_certifications/094_certifications_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-091-alabaster-energy/12_certifications/095_certifications_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-091-alabaster-energy/12_certifications/096_certifications_status_report.md"], "gold_output": {"advice_markdown": "# Counsel advice — Alabaster disclosure-controls review\n\n## Executive assessment\n\nFor Alabaster Energy Corp. matter CB-PC-3301, the review identified 16 source-supported exceptions requiring action before 2026-09-03. The assessment concerns Audit Committee and the supplied record for Delaware.\n\n## Method and record coverage\n\nThe review inventoried all 96 production files, read the 33 controlling, corroborating, and control records, searched the email exports, and checked metadata for the designated chain-of-custody sample. Conclusions are limited to the synthetic production supplied for this benchmark matter.\n\n## Findings\n\n### F-01 — committee-independence gap (critical)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for committee-independence gap: one source states the operative date is 2026-02-06 under control reference CB-PC-3301-A439, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2026-02-20 under response reference CB-PC-3301-J333.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/01_board_committees/001_board_committees_control_register.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/07_equity_compensation/049_equity_compensation_control_register.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-03, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Elliot Mercer.\n\n### F-02 — minutes-approval omission (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for minutes-approval omission: one source states the controlling amount is $4,108,997.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $4,254,494.00.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/01_board_committees/004_board_committees_ledger_export.csv`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/07_equity_compensation/052_equity_compensation_ledger_export.csv`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-03, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Talia Brooks.\n\n### F-03 — 8-K deadline (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for 8-K deadline: one source states approval is attributed to Maya Ellison as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Elliot Mercer and contains no entry for Maya Ellison.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/01_board_committees/007_board_committees_officer_certificate.html`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/07_equity_compensation/055_equity_compensation_officer_certificate.html`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-03, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Jonas Feld.\n\n### F-04 — risk-factor inconsistency (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for risk-factor inconsistency: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-PC-3301-D118, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-PC-3301-M586.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/010_minutes_materials_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/08_earnings_guidance/058_earnings_guidance_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-03, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Mei Whitaker.\n\n### F-05 — disclosure-control exception (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for disclosure-control exception: one source states the applicable location is New York Stock Exchange, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to Delaware operations outside New York Stock Exchange.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/013_minutes_materials_review_memorandum.json`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/08_earnings_guidance/061_earnings_guidance_review_memorandum.json`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-03, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Caleb Hassan.\n\n### F-06 — trading-window violation (low)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for trading-window violation: one source states the threshold is 13% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 18% and produced a different exception result.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/016_minutes_materials_status_report.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/08_earnings_guidance/064_earnings_guidance_status_report.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-03, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Leona Park.\n\n### F-07 — Section 16 filing delay (critical)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for Section 16 filing delay: one source states formal notice must use notices-alabaster_energy_corp@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-audit_committee@example.test.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/019_sec_filings_correspondence.eml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/09_whistleblower/067_whistleblower_correspondence.eml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-03, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Isaac Romero.\n\n### F-08 — related-party disclosure gap (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for related-party disclosure gap: one source states the governed population contains 145 records through 2025-04-10, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 67 records through 2025-05-19.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/022_sec_filings_formal_notice.xml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/09_whistleblower/070_whistleblower_formal_notice.xml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-03, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Sofia Bennett.\n\n### F-09 — equity-plan share mismatch (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for equity-plan share mismatch: one source states the operative date is 2025-08-20 under control reference CB-PC-3301-I209, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2025-09-05 under response reference CB-PC-3301-R731.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/025_disclosure_controls_control_register.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/10_stock_exchange/073_stock_exchange_control_register.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-03, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Adrian Mensah.\n\n### F-10 — non-GAAP reconciliation issue (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for non-GAAP reconciliation issue: one source states the controlling amount is $1,969,393.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $2,245,286.00.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/028_disclosure_controls_ledger_export.csv`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/10_stock_exchange/076_stock_exchange_ledger_export.csv`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-03, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Willa Novak.\n\n### F-11 — guidance-control failure (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for guidance-control failure: one source states approval is attributed to Maya Ellison as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Owen Delgado and contains no entry for Maya Ellison.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/031_disclosure_controls_officer_certificate.html`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/10_stock_exchange/079_stock_exchange_officer_certificate.html`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-03, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Theo Laurent.\n\n### F-12 — whistleblower escalation delay (low)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for whistleblower escalation delay: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-PC-3301-L598, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-PC-3301-U138.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/034_insider_trading_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/11_debt_covenants/082_debt_covenants_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-03, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Amara Patel.\n\n### F-13 — listing-standard notice (critical)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for listing-standard notice: one source states the applicable location is New York Stock Exchange, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to Delaware operations outside New York Stock Exchange.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/037_insider_trading_review_memorandum.json`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/11_debt_covenants/085_debt_covenants_review_memorandum.json`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-03, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Henry Cho.\n\n### F-14 — debt-covenant disclosure (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for debt-covenant disclosure: one source states the threshold is 11% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 14% and produced a different exception result.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/040_insider_trading_status_report.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/11_debt_covenants/088_debt_covenants_status_report.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-03, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Nadine Flores.\n\n### F-15 — officer certification exception (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for officer certification exception: one source states formal notice must use notices-alabaster_energy_corp@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-audit_committee@example.test.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/06_related_parties/043_related_parties_correspondence.eml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/12_certifications/091_certifications_correspondence.eml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-03, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Micah Sullivan.\n\n### F-16 — board-matrix inconsistency (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for board-matrix inconsistency: one source states the governed population contains 67 records through 2025-10-29, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 73 records through 2025-12-13.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/06_related_parties/046_related_parties_formal_notice.xml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/12_certifications/094_certifications_formal_notice.xml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-03, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Farah Ibrahim.\n\n## Recommended next actions\n\nSequence the critical and high findings first, assign the named owners, preserve the cited records, and document any resolution in the controlling matter register before the stated deadline.\n\n## Assumptions and limitations\n\nThis analysis is confined to task cb100-091-alabaster-energy and the supplied synthetic evidence. It does not rely on external facts, does not resolve disputed law, and is not legal advice for a real person or entity.\n", "findings": {"as_of": "2026-09-03", "findings": [{"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/07_equity_compensation/049_equity_compensation_control_register.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for committee-independence gap: one source states the operative date is 2026-02-06 under control reference CB-PC-3301-A439, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2026-02-20 under response reference CB-PC-3301-J333.", "id": "F-01", "issue": "committee-independence gap", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/01_board_committees/001_board_committees_control_register.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-03, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Elliot Mercer.", "severity": "critical"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/07_equity_compensation/052_equity_compensation_ledger_export.csv", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for minutes-approval omission: one source states the controlling amount is $4,108,997.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $4,254,494.00.", "id": "F-02", "issue": "minutes-approval omission", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/01_board_committees/004_board_committees_ledger_export.csv", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-03, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Talia Brooks.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/07_equity_compensation/055_equity_compensation_officer_certificate.html", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for 8-K deadline: one source states approval is attributed to Maya Ellison as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Elliot Mercer and contains no entry for Maya Ellison.", "id": "F-03", "issue": "8-K deadline", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/01_board_committees/007_board_committees_officer_certificate.html", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-03, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Jonas Feld.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/08_earnings_guidance/058_earnings_guidance_executed_instrument.txt", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for risk-factor inconsistency: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-PC-3301-D118, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-PC-3301-M586.", "id": "F-04", "issue": "risk-factor inconsistency", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/010_minutes_materials_executed_instrument.txt", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-03, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Mei Whitaker.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/08_earnings_guidance/061_earnings_guidance_review_memorandum.json", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for disclosure-control exception: one source states the applicable location is New York Stock Exchange, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to Delaware operations outside New York Stock Exchange.", "id": "F-05", "issue": "disclosure-control exception", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/013_minutes_materials_review_memorandum.json", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-03, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Caleb Hassan.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/08_earnings_guidance/064_earnings_guidance_status_report.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for trading-window violation: one source states the threshold is 13% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 18% and produced a different exception result.", "id": "F-06", "issue": "trading-window violation", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/016_minutes_materials_status_report.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-03, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Leona Park.", "severity": "low"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/09_whistleblower/067_whistleblower_correspondence.eml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for Section 16 filing delay: one source states formal notice must use notices-alabaster_energy_corp@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-audit_committee@example.test.", "id": "F-07", "issue": "Section 16 filing delay", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/019_sec_filings_correspondence.eml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-03, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Isaac Romero.", "severity": "critical"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/09_whistleblower/070_whistleblower_formal_notice.xml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for related-party disclosure gap: one source states the governed population contains 145 records through 2025-04-10, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 67 records through 2025-05-19.", "id": "F-08", "issue": "related-party disclosure gap", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/022_sec_filings_formal_notice.xml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-03, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Sofia Bennett.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/10_stock_exchange/073_stock_exchange_control_register.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for equity-plan share mismatch: one source states the operative date is 2025-08-20 under control reference CB-PC-3301-I209, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2025-09-05 under response reference CB-PC-3301-R731.", "id": "F-09", "issue": "equity-plan share mismatch", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/025_disclosure_controls_control_register.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-03, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Adrian Mensah.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/10_stock_exchange/076_stock_exchange_ledger_export.csv", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for non-GAAP reconciliation issue: one source states the controlling amount is $1,969,393.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $2,245,286.00.", "id": "F-10", "issue": "non-GAAP reconciliation issue", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/028_disclosure_controls_ledger_export.csv", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-03, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Willa Novak.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/10_stock_exchange/079_stock_exchange_officer_certificate.html", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for guidance-control failure: one source states approval is attributed to Maya Ellison as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Owen Delgado and contains no entry for Maya Ellison.", "id": "F-11", "issue": "guidance-control failure", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/031_disclosure_controls_officer_certificate.html", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-03, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Theo Laurent.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/11_debt_covenants/082_debt_covenants_executed_instrument.txt", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for whistleblower escalation delay: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-PC-3301-L598, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-PC-3301-U138.", "id": "F-12", "issue": "whistleblower escalation delay", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/034_insider_trading_executed_instrument.txt", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-03, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Amara Patel.", "severity": "low"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/11_debt_covenants/085_debt_covenants_review_memorandum.json", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for listing-standard notice: one source states the applicable location is New York Stock Exchange, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to Delaware operations outside New York Stock Exchange.", "id": "F-13", "issue": "listing-standard notice", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/037_insider_trading_review_memorandum.json", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-03, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Henry Cho.", "severity": "critical"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/11_debt_covenants/088_debt_covenants_status_report.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for debt-covenant disclosure: one source states the threshold is 11% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 14% and produced a different exception result.", "id": "F-14", "issue": "debt-covenant disclosure", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/040_insider_trading_status_report.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-03, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Nadine Flores.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/12_certifications/091_certifications_correspondence.eml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for officer certification exception: one source states formal notice must use notices-alabaster_energy_corp@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-audit_committee@example.test.", "id": "F-15", "issue": "officer certification exception", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/06_related_parties/043_related_parties_correspondence.eml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-03, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Micah Sullivan.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/12_certifications/094_certifications_formal_notice.xml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for board-matrix inconsistency: one source states the governed population contains 67 records through 2025-10-29, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 73 records through 2025-12-13.", "id": "F-16", "issue": "board-matrix inconsistency", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/06_related_parties/046_related_parties_formal_notice.xml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-03, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Farah Ibrahim.", "severity": "medium"}], "matter_number": "CB-PC-3301", "prepared_for": "Alabaster Energy Corp.", "schema_version": "1.0", "task_id": "cb100-091-alabaster-energy"}}, "metadata": {"benchmark": "CounselBench-100", "code_license": "Apache-2.0", "data_license": "CC-BY-4.0", "deadline": "2026-09-03", "document_count": 96, "jurisdiction": "Delaware", "matter_number": "CB-PC-3301", "mcp_commit": "9a96ea6e5913736f92b88345bf51caeaaa8e719f", "mcp_package": "@modelcontextprotocol/server-filesystem@2026.7.10", "practice_area": "public-company", "reference_tool_calls": 46, "required_evidence_reads": 33, "synthetic": true, "venue": "New York Stock Exchange", "version": "2.0.0"}, "prompt": "You are securities and governance counsel for Alabaster Energy Corp. The partner responsible for this matter needs a defensible decision record before the next client call. A production outage, covenant forecast, and insider trade moved through controls that did not produce consistent board or filing records. Decision due 2026-09-03. Delaware law governs; New York Stock Exchange is the forum. Prioritize conflicts between signed instruments and later operational records. Work out the defensible position from the matter production and leave an audit-ready exception tracker and concise advice for the supervising lawyer. Keep confirmed conflicts separate from open questions, cite the records that actually control each conclusion, and do not fill gaps with outside facts.", "rubric": {"criteria": [{"category": "procedure", "description": "Complete at least 46 successful, argument-specific evidence and output calls.", "id": "procedure.minimum_successful_tool_calls"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Find and read the 33 controlling, corroborating, and work-product-control records in full.", "id": "procedure.all_evidence_read_in_full"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Inspect file metadata for the eight designated critical primary records before relying on them.", "id": "procedure.chain_of_custody_metadata_checked"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Confirm the sandbox's allowed document and output roots.", "id": "procedure.allowed_directories_checked"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Inventory all 96 records so the relevant sources are discovered among the context records.", "id": "procedure.recursive_inventory_completed"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Search the production for email evidence that may corroborate or contradict formal records.", "id": "procedure.targeted_search_completed"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Leave only findings.json and advice.md in the output workspace.", "id": "procedure.exact_deliverable_set"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Create both final work products through the sandbox MCP surface.", "id": "procedure.deliverables_written_through_mcp"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Produce findings.json as a valid JSON object.", "id": "findings.findings_is_object"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Report exactly 16 confirmed exceptions.", "id": "findings.findings_exact_count"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Use each stable finding ID exactly once.", "id": "findings.finding_ids_unique"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set schema_version to the released matter value '1.0'.", "id": "findings.top_level_schema_version"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set task_id to the released matter value 'cb100-091-alabaster-energy'.", "id": "findings.top_level_task_id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set matter_number to the released matter value 'CB-PC-3301'.", "id": "findings.top_level_matter_number"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set prepared_for to the released matter value 'Alabaster Energy Corp.'.", "id": "findings.top_level_prepared_for"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set as_of to the released matter value '2026-09-03'.", "id": "findings.top_level_as_of"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-01 exception for committee-independence gap.", "id": "findings.F-01.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's id from /workspace/documents/01_board_committees/001_board_committees_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_equity_compensation/049_equity_compensation_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's issue from /workspace/documents/01_board_committees/001_board_committees_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_equity_compensation/049_equity_compensation_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's severity from /workspace/documents/01_board_committees/001_board_committees_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_equity_compensation/049_equity_compensation_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's primary_source from /workspace/documents/01_board_committees/001_board_committees_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_equity_compensation/049_equity_compensation_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/01_board_committees/001_board_committees_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_equity_compensation/049_equity_compensation_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-01 using the exact controlled facts ['2026-02-06', 'CB-PC-3301-A439', '2026-02-20', 'CB-PC-3301-J333'].", "id": "findings.F-01.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-01's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-01.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-03', 'Elliot Mercer'] for F-01.", "id": "findings.F-01.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-02 exception for minutes-approval omission.", "id": "findings.F-02.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's id from /workspace/documents/01_board_committees/004_board_committees_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_equity_compensation/052_equity_compensation_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's issue from /workspace/documents/01_board_committees/004_board_committees_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_equity_compensation/052_equity_compensation_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's severity from /workspace/documents/01_board_committees/004_board_committees_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_equity_compensation/052_equity_compensation_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's primary_source from /workspace/documents/01_board_committees/004_board_committees_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_equity_compensation/052_equity_compensation_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/01_board_committees/004_board_committees_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_equity_compensation/052_equity_compensation_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-02 using the exact controlled facts ['$4,108,997.00', '$4,254,494.00'].", "id": "findings.F-02.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-02's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-02.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-03', 'Talia Brooks'] for F-02.", "id": "findings.F-02.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-03 exception for 8-K deadline.", "id": "findings.F-03.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's id from /workspace/documents/01_board_committees/007_board_committees_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_equity_compensation/055_equity_compensation_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's issue from /workspace/documents/01_board_committees/007_board_committees_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_equity_compensation/055_equity_compensation_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's severity from /workspace/documents/01_board_committees/007_board_committees_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_equity_compensation/055_equity_compensation_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's primary_source from /workspace/documents/01_board_committees/007_board_committees_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_equity_compensation/055_equity_compensation_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/01_board_committees/007_board_committees_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_equity_compensation/055_equity_compensation_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-03 using the exact controlled facts ['Maya Ellison', 'Elliot Mercer'].", "id": "findings.F-03.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-03's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-03.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-03', 'Jonas Feld'] for F-03.", "id": "findings.F-03.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-04 exception for risk-factor inconsistency.", "id": "findings.F-04.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's id from /workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/010_minutes_materials_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_earnings_guidance/058_earnings_guidance_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's issue from /workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/010_minutes_materials_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_earnings_guidance/058_earnings_guidance_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's severity from /workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/010_minutes_materials_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_earnings_guidance/058_earnings_guidance_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's primary_source from /workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/010_minutes_materials_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_earnings_guidance/058_earnings_guidance_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/010_minutes_materials_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_earnings_guidance/058_earnings_guidance_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-04 using the exact controlled facts ['closed without exception', 'CB-PC-3301-D118', 'open and escalated', 'CB-PC-3301-M586'].", "id": "findings.F-04.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-04's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-04.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-03', 'Mei Whitaker'] for F-04.", "id": "findings.F-04.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-05 exception for disclosure-control exception.", "id": "findings.F-05.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's id from /workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/013_minutes_materials_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_earnings_guidance/061_earnings_guidance_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's issue from /workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/013_minutes_materials_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_earnings_guidance/061_earnings_guidance_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's severity from /workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/013_minutes_materials_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_earnings_guidance/061_earnings_guidance_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's primary_source from /workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/013_minutes_materials_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_earnings_guidance/061_earnings_guidance_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/013_minutes_materials_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_earnings_guidance/061_earnings_guidance_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-05 using the exact controlled facts ['New York Stock Exchange', 'Delaware'].", "id": "findings.F-05.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-05's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-05.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-03', 'Caleb Hassan'] for F-05.", "id": "findings.F-05.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-06 exception for trading-window violation.", "id": "findings.F-06.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's id from /workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/016_minutes_materials_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_earnings_guidance/064_earnings_guidance_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's issue from /workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/016_minutes_materials_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_earnings_guidance/064_earnings_guidance_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's severity from /workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/016_minutes_materials_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_earnings_guidance/064_earnings_guidance_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's primary_source from /workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/016_minutes_materials_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_earnings_guidance/064_earnings_guidance_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/016_minutes_materials_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_earnings_guidance/064_earnings_guidance_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-06 using the exact controlled facts ['13%', '18%'].", "id": "findings.F-06.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-06's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-06.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-03', 'Leona Park'] for F-06.", "id": "findings.F-06.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-07 exception for Section 16 filing delay.", "id": "findings.F-07.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's id from /workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/019_sec_filings_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_whistleblower/067_whistleblower_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's issue from /workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/019_sec_filings_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_whistleblower/067_whistleblower_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's severity from /workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/019_sec_filings_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_whistleblower/067_whistleblower_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's primary_source from /workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/019_sec_filings_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_whistleblower/067_whistleblower_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/019_sec_filings_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_whistleblower/067_whistleblower_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-07 using the exact controlled facts ['notices-alabaster_energy_corp@example.test', 'archive-audit_committee@example.test'].", "id": "findings.F-07.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-07's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-07.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-03', 'Isaac Romero'] for F-07.", "id": "findings.F-07.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-08 exception for related-party disclosure gap.", "id": "findings.F-08.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's id from /workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/022_sec_filings_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_whistleblower/070_whistleblower_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's issue from /workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/022_sec_filings_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_whistleblower/070_whistleblower_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's severity from /workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/022_sec_filings_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_whistleblower/070_whistleblower_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's primary_source from /workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/022_sec_filings_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_whistleblower/070_whistleblower_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/022_sec_filings_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_whistleblower/070_whistleblower_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-08 using the exact controlled facts ['145 records', '2025-04-10', '67 records', '2025-05-19'].", "id": "findings.F-08.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-08's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-08.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-03', 'Sofia Bennett'] for F-08.", "id": "findings.F-08.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-09 exception for equity-plan share mismatch.", "id": "findings.F-09.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's id from /workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/025_disclosure_controls_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_stock_exchange/073_stock_exchange_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's issue from /workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/025_disclosure_controls_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_stock_exchange/073_stock_exchange_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's severity from /workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/025_disclosure_controls_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_stock_exchange/073_stock_exchange_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's primary_source from /workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/025_disclosure_controls_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_stock_exchange/073_stock_exchange_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/025_disclosure_controls_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_stock_exchange/073_stock_exchange_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-09 using the exact controlled facts ['2025-08-20', 'CB-PC-3301-I209', '2025-09-05', 'CB-PC-3301-R731'].", "id": "findings.F-09.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-09's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-09.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-03', 'Adrian Mensah'] for F-09.", "id": "findings.F-09.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-10 exception for non-GAAP reconciliation issue.", "id": "findings.F-10.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's id from /workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/028_disclosure_controls_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_stock_exchange/076_stock_exchange_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's issue from /workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/028_disclosure_controls_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_stock_exchange/076_stock_exchange_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's severity from /workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/028_disclosure_controls_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_stock_exchange/076_stock_exchange_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's primary_source from /workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/028_disclosure_controls_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_stock_exchange/076_stock_exchange_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/028_disclosure_controls_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_stock_exchange/076_stock_exchange_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-10 using the exact controlled facts ['$1,969,393.00', '$2,245,286.00'].", "id": "findings.F-10.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-10's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-10.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-03', 'Willa Novak'] for F-10.", "id": "findings.F-10.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-11 exception for guidance-control failure.", "id": "findings.F-11.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's id from /workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/031_disclosure_controls_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_stock_exchange/079_stock_exchange_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's issue from /workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/031_disclosure_controls_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_stock_exchange/079_stock_exchange_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's severity from /workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/031_disclosure_controls_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_stock_exchange/079_stock_exchange_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's primary_source from /workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/031_disclosure_controls_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_stock_exchange/079_stock_exchange_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/031_disclosure_controls_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_stock_exchange/079_stock_exchange_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-11 using the exact controlled facts ['Maya Ellison', 'Owen Delgado'].", "id": "findings.F-11.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-11's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-11.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-03', 'Theo Laurent'] for F-11.", "id": "findings.F-11.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-12 exception for whistleblower escalation delay.", "id": "findings.F-12.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's id from /workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/034_insider_trading_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_debt_covenants/082_debt_covenants_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's issue from /workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/034_insider_trading_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_debt_covenants/082_debt_covenants_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's severity from /workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/034_insider_trading_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_debt_covenants/082_debt_covenants_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's primary_source from /workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/034_insider_trading_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_debt_covenants/082_debt_covenants_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/034_insider_trading_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_debt_covenants/082_debt_covenants_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-12 using the exact controlled facts ['closed without exception', 'CB-PC-3301-L598', 'open and escalated', 'CB-PC-3301-U138'].", "id": "findings.F-12.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-12's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-12.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-03', 'Amara Patel'] for F-12.", "id": "findings.F-12.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-13 exception for listing-standard notice.", "id": "findings.F-13.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's id from /workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/037_insider_trading_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_debt_covenants/085_debt_covenants_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's issue from /workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/037_insider_trading_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_debt_covenants/085_debt_covenants_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's severity from /workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/037_insider_trading_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_debt_covenants/085_debt_covenants_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's primary_source from /workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/037_insider_trading_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_debt_covenants/085_debt_covenants_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/037_insider_trading_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_debt_covenants/085_debt_covenants_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-13 using the exact controlled facts ['New York Stock Exchange', 'Delaware'].", "id": "findings.F-13.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-13's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-13.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-03', 'Henry Cho'] for F-13.", "id": "findings.F-13.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-14 exception for debt-covenant disclosure.", "id": "findings.F-14.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's id from /workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/040_insider_trading_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_debt_covenants/088_debt_covenants_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's issue from /workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/040_insider_trading_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_debt_covenants/088_debt_covenants_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's severity from /workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/040_insider_trading_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_debt_covenants/088_debt_covenants_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's primary_source from /workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/040_insider_trading_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_debt_covenants/088_debt_covenants_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/040_insider_trading_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_debt_covenants/088_debt_covenants_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-14 using the exact controlled facts ['11%', '14%'].", "id": "findings.F-14.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-14's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-14.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-03', 'Nadine Flores'] for F-14.", "id": "findings.F-14.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-15 exception for officer certification exception.", "id": "findings.F-15.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's id from /workspace/documents/06_related_parties/043_related_parties_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_certifications/091_certifications_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's issue from /workspace/documents/06_related_parties/043_related_parties_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_certifications/091_certifications_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's severity from /workspace/documents/06_related_parties/043_related_parties_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_certifications/091_certifications_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's primary_source from /workspace/documents/06_related_parties/043_related_parties_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_certifications/091_certifications_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/06_related_parties/043_related_parties_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_certifications/091_certifications_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-15 using the exact controlled facts ['notices-alabaster_energy_corp@example.test', 'archive-audit_committee@example.test'].", "id": "findings.F-15.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-15's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-15.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-03', 'Micah Sullivan'] for F-15.", "id": "findings.F-15.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-16 exception for board-matrix inconsistency.", "id": "findings.F-16.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's id from /workspace/documents/06_related_parties/046_related_parties_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_certifications/094_certifications_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's issue from /workspace/documents/06_related_parties/046_related_parties_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_certifications/094_certifications_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's severity from /workspace/documents/06_related_parties/046_related_parties_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_certifications/094_certifications_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's primary_source from /workspace/documents/06_related_parties/046_related_parties_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_certifications/094_certifications_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/06_related_parties/046_related_parties_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_certifications/094_certifications_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-16 using the exact controlled facts ['67 records', '2025-10-29', '73 records', '2025-12-13'].", "id": "findings.F-16.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-16's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-16.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-03', 'Farah Ibrahim'] for F-16.", "id": "findings.F-16.action_anchors"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Executive assessment' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Executive assessment"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Method and record coverage' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Method and record coverage"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Findings' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Findings"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Recommended next actions' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Recommended next actions"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Assumptions and limitations' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Assumptions and limitations"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-01 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-01"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-02 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-02"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-03 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-03"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-04 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-04"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-05 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-05"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-06 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-06"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-07 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-07"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-08 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-08"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-09 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-09"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-10 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-10"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-11 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-11"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-12 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-12"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-13 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-13"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-14 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-14"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-15 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-15"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-16 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-16"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Do not claim the production has no issues or that every record is consistent.", "id": "memo.forbidden_claims_absent"}], "decision_options": [{"id": "cross-source-reconciliation", "label": "Reconcile controlling and corroborating records", "reason": "The CB-PC-3301 production contains independently maintained records; a defensible answer must preserve each supported conflict and its cure owner.", "selected": true}, {"id": "latest-record-controls", "label": "Treat the latest record as controlling", "reason": "Timestamp recency does not establish legal priority, execution, or approval authority.", "selected": false}, {"id": "primary-records-only", "label": "Report primary records without reconciliation", "reason": "Primary records alone conceal the operational conflicts that create the actionable exceptions.", "selected": false}], "gates": ["all_evidence_read_in_full", "chain_of_custody_metadata_checked", "findings_criteria_complete", "memo_criteria_complete", "deliverables_written_through_mcp"], "metadata_checks": 8, "metric": "weighted_criteria_score", "minimum_tool_calls": 46, "required_deliverables": ["findings.json", "advice.md"], "required_document_reads": 33, "type": "deterministic", "weights": {"findings": 0.55, "memo": 0.2, "procedure": 0.25}}, "task_id": "cb100-091-alabaster-energy", "task_name": "Alabaster disclosure-controls review", "world_id": "counselbench-filesystem-mcp-v2"}
-{"context_files": ["task_files/cb100-092-brightstar-medical/01_board_committees/001_board_committees_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-092-brightstar-medical/01_board_committees/002_board_committees_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-092-brightstar-medical/01_board_committees/003_board_committees_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-092-brightstar-medical/01_board_committees/004_board_committees_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-092-brightstar-medical/01_board_committees/005_board_committees_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-092-brightstar-medical/01_board_committees/006_board_committees_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-092-brightstar-medical/01_board_committees/007_board_committees_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-092-brightstar-medical/01_board_committees/008_board_committees_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-092-brightstar-medical/02_minutes_materials/009_minutes_materials_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-092-brightstar-medical/02_minutes_materials/010_minutes_materials_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-092-brightstar-medical/02_minutes_materials/011_minutes_materials_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-092-brightstar-medical/02_minutes_materials/012_minutes_materials_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-092-brightstar-medical/02_minutes_materials/013_minutes_materials_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-092-brightstar-medical/02_minutes_materials/014_minutes_materials_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-092-brightstar-medical/02_minutes_materials/015_minutes_materials_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-092-brightstar-medical/02_minutes_materials/016_minutes_materials_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-092-brightstar-medical/03_sec_filings/017_sec_filings_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-092-brightstar-medical/03_sec_filings/018_sec_filings_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-092-brightstar-medical/03_sec_filings/019_sec_filings_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-092-brightstar-medical/03_sec_filings/020_sec_filings_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-092-brightstar-medical/03_sec_filings/021_sec_filings_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-092-brightstar-medical/03_sec_filings/022_sec_filings_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-092-brightstar-medical/03_sec_filings/023_sec_filings_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-092-brightstar-medical/03_sec_filings/024_sec_filings_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-092-brightstar-medical/04_disclosure_controls/025_disclosure_controls_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-092-brightstar-medical/04_disclosure_controls/026_disclosure_controls_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-092-brightstar-medical/04_disclosure_controls/027_disclosure_controls_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-092-brightstar-medical/04_disclosure_controls/028_disclosure_controls_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-092-brightstar-medical/04_disclosure_controls/029_disclosure_controls_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-092-brightstar-medical/04_disclosure_controls/030_disclosure_controls_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-092-brightstar-medical/04_disclosure_controls/031_disclosure_controls_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-092-brightstar-medical/04_disclosure_controls/032_disclosure_controls_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-092-brightstar-medical/05_insider_trading/033_insider_trading_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-092-brightstar-medical/05_insider_trading/034_insider_trading_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-092-brightstar-medical/05_insider_trading/035_insider_trading_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-092-brightstar-medical/05_insider_trading/036_insider_trading_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-092-brightstar-medical/05_insider_trading/037_insider_trading_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-092-brightstar-medical/05_insider_trading/038_insider_trading_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-092-brightstar-medical/05_insider_trading/039_insider_trading_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-092-brightstar-medical/05_insider_trading/040_insider_trading_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-092-brightstar-medical/06_related_parties/041_related_parties_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-092-brightstar-medical/06_related_parties/042_related_parties_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-092-brightstar-medical/06_related_parties/043_related_parties_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-092-brightstar-medical/06_related_parties/044_related_parties_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-092-brightstar-medical/06_related_parties/045_related_parties_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-092-brightstar-medical/06_related_parties/046_related_parties_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-092-brightstar-medical/06_related_parties/047_related_parties_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-092-brightstar-medical/06_related_parties/048_related_parties_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-092-brightstar-medical/07_equity_compensation/049_equity_compensation_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-092-brightstar-medical/07_equity_compensation/050_equity_compensation_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-092-brightstar-medical/07_equity_compensation/051_equity_compensation_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-092-brightstar-medical/07_equity_compensation/052_equity_compensation_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-092-brightstar-medical/07_equity_compensation/053_equity_compensation_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-092-brightstar-medical/07_equity_compensation/054_equity_compensation_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-092-brightstar-medical/07_equity_compensation/055_equity_compensation_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-092-brightstar-medical/07_equity_compensation/056_equity_compensation_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-092-brightstar-medical/08_earnings_guidance/057_earnings_guidance_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-092-brightstar-medical/08_earnings_guidance/058_earnings_guidance_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-092-brightstar-medical/08_earnings_guidance/059_earnings_guidance_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-092-brightstar-medical/08_earnings_guidance/060_earnings_guidance_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-092-brightstar-medical/08_earnings_guidance/061_earnings_guidance_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-092-brightstar-medical/08_earnings_guidance/062_earnings_guidance_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-092-brightstar-medical/08_earnings_guidance/063_earnings_guidance_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-092-brightstar-medical/08_earnings_guidance/064_earnings_guidance_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-092-brightstar-medical/09_whistleblower/065_whistleblower_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-092-brightstar-medical/09_whistleblower/066_whistleblower_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-092-brightstar-medical/09_whistleblower/067_whistleblower_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-092-brightstar-medical/09_whistleblower/068_whistleblower_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-092-brightstar-medical/09_whistleblower/069_whistleblower_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-092-brightstar-medical/09_whistleblower/070_whistleblower_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-092-brightstar-medical/09_whistleblower/071_whistleblower_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-092-brightstar-medical/09_whistleblower/072_whistleblower_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-092-brightstar-medical/10_stock_exchange/073_stock_exchange_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-092-brightstar-medical/10_stock_exchange/074_stock_exchange_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-092-brightstar-medical/10_stock_exchange/075_stock_exchange_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-092-brightstar-medical/10_stock_exchange/076_stock_exchange_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-092-brightstar-medical/10_stock_exchange/077_stock_exchange_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-092-brightstar-medical/10_stock_exchange/078_stock_exchange_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-092-brightstar-medical/10_stock_exchange/079_stock_exchange_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-092-brightstar-medical/10_stock_exchange/080_stock_exchange_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-092-brightstar-medical/11_debt_covenants/081_debt_covenants_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-092-brightstar-medical/11_debt_covenants/082_debt_covenants_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-092-brightstar-medical/11_debt_covenants/083_debt_covenants_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-092-brightstar-medical/11_debt_covenants/084_debt_covenants_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-092-brightstar-medical/11_debt_covenants/085_debt_covenants_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-092-brightstar-medical/11_debt_covenants/086_debt_covenants_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-092-brightstar-medical/11_debt_covenants/087_debt_covenants_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-092-brightstar-medical/11_debt_covenants/088_debt_covenants_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-092-brightstar-medical/12_certifications/089_certifications_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-092-brightstar-medical/12_certifications/090_certifications_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-092-brightstar-medical/12_certifications/091_certifications_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-092-brightstar-medical/12_certifications/092_certifications_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-092-brightstar-medical/12_certifications/093_certifications_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-092-brightstar-medical/12_certifications/094_certifications_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-092-brightstar-medical/12_certifications/095_certifications_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-092-brightstar-medical/12_certifications/096_certifications_status_report.md"], "gold_output": {"advice_markdown": "# Counsel advice — Brightstar 8-K and governance audit\n\n## Executive assessment\n\nFor Brightstar Medical Systems matter CB-PC-3302, the review identified 16 source-supported exceptions requiring action before 2026-09-07. The assessment concerns Nominating and Governance Committee and the supplied record for Minnesota.\n\n## Method and record coverage\n\nThe review inventoried all 96 production files, read the 33 controlling, corroborating, and control records, searched the email exports, and checked metadata for the designated chain-of-custody sample. Conclusions are limited to the synthetic production supplied for this benchmark matter.\n\n## Findings\n\n### F-01 — committee-independence gap (critical)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for committee-independence gap: one source states the operative date is 2025-07-28 under control reference CB-PC-3302-A606, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2025-09-10 under response reference CB-PC-3302-J623.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/01_board_committees/001_board_committees_control_register.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/07_equity_compensation/049_equity_compensation_control_register.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-07, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Talia Brooks.\n\n### F-02 — minutes-approval omission (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for minutes-approval omission: one source states the controlling amount is $5,513,770.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $5,624,040.00.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/01_board_committees/004_board_committees_ledger_export.csv`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/07_equity_compensation/052_equity_compensation_ledger_export.csv`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-07, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Jonas Feld.\n\n### F-03 — 8-K deadline (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for 8-K deadline: one source states approval is attributed to Rafael Okafor as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Jonas Feld and contains no entry for Rafael Okafor.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/01_board_committees/007_board_committees_officer_certificate.html`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/07_equity_compensation/055_equity_compensation_officer_certificate.html`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-07, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Mei Whitaker.\n\n### F-04 — risk-factor inconsistency (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for risk-factor inconsistency: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-PC-3302-D387, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-PC-3302-M329.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/010_minutes_materials_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/08_earnings_guidance/058_earnings_guidance_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-07, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Caleb Hassan.\n\n### F-05 — disclosure-control exception (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for disclosure-control exception: one source states the applicable location is Nasdaq Stock Market, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to Minnesota operations outside Nasdaq Stock Market.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/013_minutes_materials_review_memorandum.json`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/08_earnings_guidance/061_earnings_guidance_review_memorandum.json`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-07, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Leona Park.\n\n### F-06 — trading-window violation (low)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for trading-window violation: one source states the threshold is 7% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 10% and produced a different exception result.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/016_minutes_materials_status_report.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/08_earnings_guidance/064_earnings_guidance_status_report.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-07, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Isaac Romero.\n\n### F-07 — Section 16 filing delay (critical)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for Section 16 filing delay: one source states formal notice must use notices-brightstar_medical_systems@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-nominating_and_governance_committee@example.test.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/019_sec_filings_correspondence.eml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/09_whistleblower/067_whistleblower_correspondence.eml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-07, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Sofia Bennett.\n\n### F-08 — related-party disclosure gap (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for related-party disclosure gap: one source states the governed population contains 56 records through 2025-05-31, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 73 records through 2025-07-15.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/022_sec_filings_formal_notice.xml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/09_whistleblower/070_whistleblower_formal_notice.xml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-07, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Adrian Mensah.\n\n### F-09 — equity-plan share mismatch (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for equity-plan share mismatch: one source states the operative date is 2025-10-05 under control reference CB-PC-3302-I555, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2025-11-10 under response reference CB-PC-3302-R896.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/025_disclosure_controls_control_register.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/10_stock_exchange/073_stock_exchange_control_register.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-07, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Willa Novak.\n\n### F-10 — non-GAAP reconciliation issue (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for non-GAAP reconciliation issue: one source states the controlling amount is $3,526,413.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $3,609,326.00.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/028_disclosure_controls_ledger_export.csv`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/10_stock_exchange/076_stock_exchange_ledger_export.csv`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-07, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Theo Laurent.\n\n### F-11 — guidance-control failure (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for guidance-control failure: one source states approval is attributed to Rafael Okafor as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Samuel Kim and contains no entry for Rafael Okafor.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/031_disclosure_controls_officer_certificate.html`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/10_stock_exchange/079_stock_exchange_officer_certificate.html`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-07, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Amara Patel.\n\n### F-12 — whistleblower escalation delay (low)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for whistleblower escalation delay: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-PC-3302-L454, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-PC-3302-U611.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/034_insider_trading_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/11_debt_covenants/082_debt_covenants_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-07, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Henry Cho.\n\n### F-13 — listing-standard notice (critical)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for listing-standard notice: one source states the applicable location is Nasdaq Stock Market, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to Minnesota operations outside Nasdaq Stock Market.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/037_insider_trading_review_memorandum.json`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/11_debt_covenants/085_debt_covenants_review_memorandum.json`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-07, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Nadine Flores.\n\n### F-14 — debt-covenant disclosure (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for debt-covenant disclosure: one source states the threshold is 8% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 14% and produced a different exception result.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/040_insider_trading_status_report.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/11_debt_covenants/088_debt_covenants_status_report.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-07, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Micah Sullivan.\n\n### F-15 — officer certification exception (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for officer certification exception: one source states formal notice must use notices-brightstar_medical_systems@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-nominating_and_governance_committee@example.test.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/06_related_parties/043_related_parties_correspondence.eml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/12_certifications/091_certifications_correspondence.eml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-07, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Farah Ibrahim.\n\n### F-16 — board-matrix inconsistency (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for board-matrix inconsistency: one source states the governed population contains 150 records through 2026-01-20, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 37 records through 2026-01-29.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/06_related_parties/046_related_parties_formal_notice.xml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/12_certifications/094_certifications_formal_notice.xml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-07, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Owen Delgado.\n\n## Recommended next actions\n\nSequence the critical and high findings first, assign the named owners, preserve the cited records, and document any resolution in the controlling matter register before the stated deadline.\n\n## Assumptions and limitations\n\nThis analysis is confined to task cb100-092-brightstar-medical and the supplied synthetic evidence. It does not rely on external facts, does not resolve disputed law, and is not legal advice for a real person or entity.\n", "findings": {"as_of": "2026-09-07", "findings": [{"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/07_equity_compensation/049_equity_compensation_control_register.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for committee-independence gap: one source states the operative date is 2025-07-28 under control reference CB-PC-3302-A606, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2025-09-10 under response reference CB-PC-3302-J623.", "id": "F-01", "issue": "committee-independence gap", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/01_board_committees/001_board_committees_control_register.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-07, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Talia Brooks.", "severity": "critical"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/07_equity_compensation/052_equity_compensation_ledger_export.csv", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for minutes-approval omission: one source states the controlling amount is $5,513,770.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $5,624,040.00.", "id": "F-02", "issue": "minutes-approval omission", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/01_board_committees/004_board_committees_ledger_export.csv", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-07, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Jonas Feld.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/07_equity_compensation/055_equity_compensation_officer_certificate.html", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for 8-K deadline: one source states approval is attributed to Rafael Okafor as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Jonas Feld and contains no entry for Rafael Okafor.", "id": "F-03", "issue": "8-K deadline", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/01_board_committees/007_board_committees_officer_certificate.html", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-07, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Mei Whitaker.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/08_earnings_guidance/058_earnings_guidance_executed_instrument.txt", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for risk-factor inconsistency: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-PC-3302-D387, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-PC-3302-M329.", "id": "F-04", "issue": "risk-factor inconsistency", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/010_minutes_materials_executed_instrument.txt", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-07, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Caleb Hassan.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/08_earnings_guidance/061_earnings_guidance_review_memorandum.json", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for disclosure-control exception: one source states the applicable location is Nasdaq Stock Market, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to Minnesota operations outside Nasdaq Stock Market.", "id": "F-05", "issue": "disclosure-control exception", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/013_minutes_materials_review_memorandum.json", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-07, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Leona Park.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/08_earnings_guidance/064_earnings_guidance_status_report.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for trading-window violation: one source states the threshold is 7% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 10% and produced a different exception result.", "id": "F-06", "issue": "trading-window violation", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/016_minutes_materials_status_report.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-07, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Isaac Romero.", "severity": "low"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/09_whistleblower/067_whistleblower_correspondence.eml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for Section 16 filing delay: one source states formal notice must use notices-brightstar_medical_systems@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-nominating_and_governance_committee@example.test.", "id": "F-07", "issue": "Section 16 filing delay", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/019_sec_filings_correspondence.eml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-07, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Sofia Bennett.", "severity": "critical"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/09_whistleblower/070_whistleblower_formal_notice.xml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for related-party disclosure gap: one source states the governed population contains 56 records through 2025-05-31, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 73 records through 2025-07-15.", "id": "F-08", "issue": "related-party disclosure gap", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/022_sec_filings_formal_notice.xml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-07, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Adrian Mensah.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/10_stock_exchange/073_stock_exchange_control_register.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for equity-plan share mismatch: one source states the operative date is 2025-10-05 under control reference CB-PC-3302-I555, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2025-11-10 under response reference CB-PC-3302-R896.", "id": "F-09", "issue": "equity-plan share mismatch", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/025_disclosure_controls_control_register.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-07, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Willa Novak.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/10_stock_exchange/076_stock_exchange_ledger_export.csv", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for non-GAAP reconciliation issue: one source states the controlling amount is $3,526,413.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $3,609,326.00.", "id": "F-10", "issue": "non-GAAP reconciliation issue", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/028_disclosure_controls_ledger_export.csv", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-07, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Theo Laurent.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/10_stock_exchange/079_stock_exchange_officer_certificate.html", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for guidance-control failure: one source states approval is attributed to Rafael Okafor as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Samuel Kim and contains no entry for Rafael Okafor.", "id": "F-11", "issue": "guidance-control failure", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/031_disclosure_controls_officer_certificate.html", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-07, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Amara Patel.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/11_debt_covenants/082_debt_covenants_executed_instrument.txt", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for whistleblower escalation delay: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-PC-3302-L454, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-PC-3302-U611.", "id": "F-12", "issue": "whistleblower escalation delay", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/034_insider_trading_executed_instrument.txt", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-07, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Henry Cho.", "severity": "low"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/11_debt_covenants/085_debt_covenants_review_memorandum.json", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for listing-standard notice: one source states the applicable location is Nasdaq Stock Market, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to Minnesota operations outside Nasdaq Stock Market.", "id": "F-13", "issue": "listing-standard notice", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/037_insider_trading_review_memorandum.json", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-07, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Nadine Flores.", "severity": "critical"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/11_debt_covenants/088_debt_covenants_status_report.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for debt-covenant disclosure: one source states the threshold is 8% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 14% and produced a different exception result.", "id": "F-14", "issue": "debt-covenant disclosure", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/040_insider_trading_status_report.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-07, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Micah Sullivan.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/12_certifications/091_certifications_correspondence.eml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for officer certification exception: one source states formal notice must use notices-brightstar_medical_systems@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-nominating_and_governance_committee@example.test.", "id": "F-15", "issue": "officer certification exception", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/06_related_parties/043_related_parties_correspondence.eml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-07, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Farah Ibrahim.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/12_certifications/094_certifications_formal_notice.xml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for board-matrix inconsistency: one source states the governed population contains 150 records through 2026-01-20, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 37 records through 2026-01-29.", "id": "F-16", "issue": "board-matrix inconsistency", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/06_related_parties/046_related_parties_formal_notice.xml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-07, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Owen Delgado.", "severity": "medium"}], "matter_number": "CB-PC-3302", "prepared_for": "Brightstar Medical Systems", "schema_version": "1.0", "task_id": "cb100-092-brightstar-medical"}}, "metadata": {"benchmark": "CounselBench-100", "code_license": "Apache-2.0", "data_license": "CC-BY-4.0", "deadline": "2026-09-07", "document_count": 96, "jurisdiction": "Minnesota", "matter_number": "CB-PC-3302", "mcp_commit": "9a96ea6e5913736f92b88345bf51caeaaa8e719f", "mcp_package": "@modelcontextprotocol/server-filesystem@2026.7.10", "practice_area": "public-company", "reference_tool_calls": 46, "required_evidence_reads": 33, "synthetic": true, "venue": "Nasdaq Stock Market", "version": "2.0.0"}, "prompt": "You are securities and governance counsel for Brightstar Medical Systems. A late document production changed the factual picture, and the matter team needs the entire record reconciled from first principles. A director departure, customer loss, equity award, and committee vacancy create overlapping disclosure and listing obligations. Decision due 2026-09-07. Minnesota law governs; Nasdaq Stock Market is the forum. Separate confirmed exceptions from items that merely require follow-up. Work out the defensible position from the matter production and leave an audit-ready exception tracker and concise advice for the supervising lawyer. Keep confirmed conflicts separate from open questions, cite the records that actually control each conclusion, and do not fill gaps with outside facts.", "rubric": {"criteria": [{"category": "procedure", "description": "Complete at least 46 successful, argument-specific evidence and output calls.", "id": "procedure.minimum_successful_tool_calls"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Find and read the 33 controlling, corroborating, and work-product-control records in full.", "id": "procedure.all_evidence_read_in_full"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Inspect file metadata for the eight designated critical primary records before relying on them.", "id": "procedure.chain_of_custody_metadata_checked"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Confirm the sandbox's allowed document and output roots.", "id": "procedure.allowed_directories_checked"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Inventory all 96 records so the relevant sources are discovered among the context records.", "id": "procedure.recursive_inventory_completed"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Search the production for email evidence that may corroborate or contradict formal records.", "id": "procedure.targeted_search_completed"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Leave only findings.json and advice.md in the output workspace.", "id": "procedure.exact_deliverable_set"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Create both final work products through the sandbox MCP surface.", "id": "procedure.deliverables_written_through_mcp"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Produce findings.json as a valid JSON object.", "id": "findings.findings_is_object"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Report exactly 16 confirmed exceptions.", "id": "findings.findings_exact_count"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Use each stable finding ID exactly once.", "id": "findings.finding_ids_unique"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set schema_version to the released matter value '1.0'.", "id": "findings.top_level_schema_version"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set task_id to the released matter value 'cb100-092-brightstar-medical'.", "id": "findings.top_level_task_id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set matter_number to the released matter value 'CB-PC-3302'.", "id": "findings.top_level_matter_number"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set prepared_for to the released matter value 'Brightstar Medical Systems'.", "id": "findings.top_level_prepared_for"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set as_of to the released matter value '2026-09-07'.", "id": "findings.top_level_as_of"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-01 exception for committee-independence gap.", "id": "findings.F-01.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's id from /workspace/documents/01_board_committees/001_board_committees_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_equity_compensation/049_equity_compensation_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's issue from /workspace/documents/01_board_committees/001_board_committees_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_equity_compensation/049_equity_compensation_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's severity from /workspace/documents/01_board_committees/001_board_committees_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_equity_compensation/049_equity_compensation_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's primary_source from /workspace/documents/01_board_committees/001_board_committees_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_equity_compensation/049_equity_compensation_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/01_board_committees/001_board_committees_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_equity_compensation/049_equity_compensation_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-01 using the exact controlled facts ['2025-07-28', 'CB-PC-3302-A606', '2025-09-10', 'CB-PC-3302-J623'].", "id": "findings.F-01.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-01's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-01.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-07', 'Talia Brooks'] for F-01.", "id": "findings.F-01.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-02 exception for minutes-approval omission.", "id": "findings.F-02.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's id from /workspace/documents/01_board_committees/004_board_committees_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_equity_compensation/052_equity_compensation_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's issue from /workspace/documents/01_board_committees/004_board_committees_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_equity_compensation/052_equity_compensation_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's severity from /workspace/documents/01_board_committees/004_board_committees_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_equity_compensation/052_equity_compensation_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's primary_source from /workspace/documents/01_board_committees/004_board_committees_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_equity_compensation/052_equity_compensation_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/01_board_committees/004_board_committees_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_equity_compensation/052_equity_compensation_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-02 using the exact controlled facts ['$5,513,770.00', '$5,624,040.00'].", "id": "findings.F-02.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-02's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-02.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-07', 'Jonas Feld'] for F-02.", "id": "findings.F-02.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-03 exception for 8-K deadline.", "id": "findings.F-03.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's id from /workspace/documents/01_board_committees/007_board_committees_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_equity_compensation/055_equity_compensation_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's issue from /workspace/documents/01_board_committees/007_board_committees_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_equity_compensation/055_equity_compensation_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's severity from /workspace/documents/01_board_committees/007_board_committees_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_equity_compensation/055_equity_compensation_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's primary_source from /workspace/documents/01_board_committees/007_board_committees_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_equity_compensation/055_equity_compensation_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/01_board_committees/007_board_committees_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_equity_compensation/055_equity_compensation_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-03 using the exact controlled facts ['Rafael Okafor', 'Jonas Feld'].", "id": "findings.F-03.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-03's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-03.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-07', 'Mei Whitaker'] for F-03.", "id": "findings.F-03.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-04 exception for risk-factor inconsistency.", "id": "findings.F-04.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's id from /workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/010_minutes_materials_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_earnings_guidance/058_earnings_guidance_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's issue from /workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/010_minutes_materials_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_earnings_guidance/058_earnings_guidance_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's severity from /workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/010_minutes_materials_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_earnings_guidance/058_earnings_guidance_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's primary_source from /workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/010_minutes_materials_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_earnings_guidance/058_earnings_guidance_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/010_minutes_materials_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_earnings_guidance/058_earnings_guidance_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-04 using the exact controlled facts ['closed without exception', 'CB-PC-3302-D387', 'open and escalated', 'CB-PC-3302-M329'].", "id": "findings.F-04.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-04's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-04.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-07', 'Caleb Hassan'] for F-04.", "id": "findings.F-04.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-05 exception for disclosure-control exception.", "id": "findings.F-05.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's id from /workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/013_minutes_materials_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_earnings_guidance/061_earnings_guidance_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's issue from /workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/013_minutes_materials_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_earnings_guidance/061_earnings_guidance_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's severity from /workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/013_minutes_materials_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_earnings_guidance/061_earnings_guidance_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's primary_source from /workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/013_minutes_materials_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_earnings_guidance/061_earnings_guidance_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/013_minutes_materials_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_earnings_guidance/061_earnings_guidance_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-05 using the exact controlled facts ['Nasdaq Stock Market', 'Minnesota'].", "id": "findings.F-05.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-05's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-05.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-07', 'Leona Park'] for F-05.", "id": "findings.F-05.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-06 exception for trading-window violation.", "id": "findings.F-06.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's id from /workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/016_minutes_materials_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_earnings_guidance/064_earnings_guidance_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's issue from /workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/016_minutes_materials_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_earnings_guidance/064_earnings_guidance_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's severity from /workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/016_minutes_materials_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_earnings_guidance/064_earnings_guidance_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's primary_source from /workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/016_minutes_materials_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_earnings_guidance/064_earnings_guidance_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/016_minutes_materials_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_earnings_guidance/064_earnings_guidance_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-06 using the exact controlled facts ['7%', '10%'].", "id": "findings.F-06.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-06's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-06.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-07', 'Isaac Romero'] for F-06.", "id": "findings.F-06.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-07 exception for Section 16 filing delay.", "id": "findings.F-07.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's id from /workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/019_sec_filings_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_whistleblower/067_whistleblower_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's issue from /workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/019_sec_filings_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_whistleblower/067_whistleblower_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's severity from /workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/019_sec_filings_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_whistleblower/067_whistleblower_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's primary_source from /workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/019_sec_filings_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_whistleblower/067_whistleblower_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/019_sec_filings_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_whistleblower/067_whistleblower_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-07 using the exact controlled facts ['notices-brightstar_medical_systems@example.test', 'archive-nominating_and_governance_committee@example.test'].", "id": "findings.F-07.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-07's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-07.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-07', 'Sofia Bennett'] for F-07.", "id": "findings.F-07.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-08 exception for related-party disclosure gap.", "id": "findings.F-08.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's id from /workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/022_sec_filings_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_whistleblower/070_whistleblower_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's issue from /workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/022_sec_filings_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_whistleblower/070_whistleblower_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's severity from /workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/022_sec_filings_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_whistleblower/070_whistleblower_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's primary_source from /workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/022_sec_filings_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_whistleblower/070_whistleblower_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/022_sec_filings_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_whistleblower/070_whistleblower_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-08 using the exact controlled facts ['56 records', '2025-05-31', '73 records', '2025-07-15'].", "id": "findings.F-08.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-08's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-08.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-07', 'Adrian Mensah'] for F-08.", "id": "findings.F-08.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-09 exception for equity-plan share mismatch.", "id": "findings.F-09.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's id from /workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/025_disclosure_controls_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_stock_exchange/073_stock_exchange_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's issue from /workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/025_disclosure_controls_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_stock_exchange/073_stock_exchange_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's severity from /workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/025_disclosure_controls_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_stock_exchange/073_stock_exchange_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's primary_source from /workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/025_disclosure_controls_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_stock_exchange/073_stock_exchange_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/025_disclosure_controls_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_stock_exchange/073_stock_exchange_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-09 using the exact controlled facts ['2025-10-05', 'CB-PC-3302-I555', '2025-11-10', 'CB-PC-3302-R896'].", "id": "findings.F-09.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-09's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-09.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-07', 'Willa Novak'] for F-09.", "id": "findings.F-09.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-10 exception for non-GAAP reconciliation issue.", "id": "findings.F-10.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's id from /workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/028_disclosure_controls_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_stock_exchange/076_stock_exchange_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's issue from /workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/028_disclosure_controls_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_stock_exchange/076_stock_exchange_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's severity from /workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/028_disclosure_controls_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_stock_exchange/076_stock_exchange_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's primary_source from /workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/028_disclosure_controls_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_stock_exchange/076_stock_exchange_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/028_disclosure_controls_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_stock_exchange/076_stock_exchange_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-10 using the exact controlled facts ['$3,526,413.00', '$3,609,326.00'].", "id": "findings.F-10.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-10's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-10.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-07', 'Theo Laurent'] for F-10.", "id": "findings.F-10.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-11 exception for guidance-control failure.", "id": "findings.F-11.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's id from /workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/031_disclosure_controls_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_stock_exchange/079_stock_exchange_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's issue from /workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/031_disclosure_controls_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_stock_exchange/079_stock_exchange_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's severity from /workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/031_disclosure_controls_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_stock_exchange/079_stock_exchange_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's primary_source from /workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/031_disclosure_controls_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_stock_exchange/079_stock_exchange_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/031_disclosure_controls_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_stock_exchange/079_stock_exchange_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-11 using the exact controlled facts ['Rafael Okafor', 'Samuel Kim'].", "id": "findings.F-11.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-11's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-11.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-07', 'Amara Patel'] for F-11.", "id": "findings.F-11.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-12 exception for whistleblower escalation delay.", "id": "findings.F-12.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's id from /workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/034_insider_trading_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_debt_covenants/082_debt_covenants_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's issue from /workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/034_insider_trading_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_debt_covenants/082_debt_covenants_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's severity from /workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/034_insider_trading_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_debt_covenants/082_debt_covenants_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's primary_source from /workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/034_insider_trading_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_debt_covenants/082_debt_covenants_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/034_insider_trading_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_debt_covenants/082_debt_covenants_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-12 using the exact controlled facts ['closed without exception', 'CB-PC-3302-L454', 'open and escalated', 'CB-PC-3302-U611'].", "id": "findings.F-12.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-12's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-12.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-07', 'Henry Cho'] for F-12.", "id": "findings.F-12.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-13 exception for listing-standard notice.", "id": "findings.F-13.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's id from /workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/037_insider_trading_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_debt_covenants/085_debt_covenants_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's issue from /workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/037_insider_trading_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_debt_covenants/085_debt_covenants_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's severity from /workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/037_insider_trading_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_debt_covenants/085_debt_covenants_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's primary_source from /workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/037_insider_trading_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_debt_covenants/085_debt_covenants_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/037_insider_trading_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_debt_covenants/085_debt_covenants_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-13 using the exact controlled facts ['Nasdaq Stock Market', 'Minnesota'].", "id": "findings.F-13.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-13's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-13.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-07', 'Nadine Flores'] for F-13.", "id": "findings.F-13.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-14 exception for debt-covenant disclosure.", "id": "findings.F-14.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's id from /workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/040_insider_trading_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_debt_covenants/088_debt_covenants_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's issue from /workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/040_insider_trading_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_debt_covenants/088_debt_covenants_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's severity from /workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/040_insider_trading_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_debt_covenants/088_debt_covenants_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's primary_source from /workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/040_insider_trading_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_debt_covenants/088_debt_covenants_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/040_insider_trading_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_debt_covenants/088_debt_covenants_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-14 using the exact controlled facts ['8%', '14%'].", "id": "findings.F-14.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-14's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-14.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-07', 'Micah Sullivan'] for F-14.", "id": "findings.F-14.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-15 exception for officer certification exception.", "id": "findings.F-15.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's id from /workspace/documents/06_related_parties/043_related_parties_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_certifications/091_certifications_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's issue from /workspace/documents/06_related_parties/043_related_parties_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_certifications/091_certifications_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's severity from /workspace/documents/06_related_parties/043_related_parties_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_certifications/091_certifications_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's primary_source from /workspace/documents/06_related_parties/043_related_parties_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_certifications/091_certifications_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/06_related_parties/043_related_parties_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_certifications/091_certifications_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-15 using the exact controlled facts ['notices-brightstar_medical_systems@example.test', 'archive-nominating_and_governance_committee@example.test'].", "id": "findings.F-15.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-15's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-15.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-07', 'Farah Ibrahim'] for F-15.", "id": "findings.F-15.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-16 exception for board-matrix inconsistency.", "id": "findings.F-16.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's id from /workspace/documents/06_related_parties/046_related_parties_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_certifications/094_certifications_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's issue from /workspace/documents/06_related_parties/046_related_parties_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_certifications/094_certifications_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's severity from /workspace/documents/06_related_parties/046_related_parties_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_certifications/094_certifications_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's primary_source from /workspace/documents/06_related_parties/046_related_parties_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_certifications/094_certifications_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/06_related_parties/046_related_parties_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_certifications/094_certifications_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-16 using the exact controlled facts ['150 records', '2026-01-20', '37 records', '2026-01-29'].", "id": "findings.F-16.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-16's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-16.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-07', 'Owen Delgado'] for F-16.", "id": "findings.F-16.action_anchors"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Executive assessment' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Executive assessment"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Method and record coverage' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Method and record coverage"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Findings' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Findings"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Recommended next actions' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Recommended next actions"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Assumptions and limitations' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Assumptions and limitations"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-01 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-01"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-02 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-02"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-03 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-03"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-04 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-04"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-05 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-05"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-06 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-06"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-07 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-07"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-08 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-08"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-09 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-09"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-10 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-10"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-11 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-11"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-12 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-12"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-13 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-13"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-14 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-14"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-15 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-15"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-16 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-16"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Do not claim the production has no issues or that every record is consistent.", "id": "memo.forbidden_claims_absent"}], "decision_options": [{"id": "cross-source-reconciliation", "label": "Reconcile controlling and corroborating records", "reason": "The CB-PC-3302 production contains independently maintained records; a defensible answer must preserve each supported conflict and its cure owner.", "selected": true}, {"id": "latest-record-controls", "label": "Treat the latest record as controlling", "reason": "Timestamp recency does not establish legal priority, execution, or approval authority.", "selected": false}, {"id": "primary-records-only", "label": "Report primary records without reconciliation", "reason": "Primary records alone conceal the operational conflicts that create the actionable exceptions.", "selected": false}], "gates": ["all_evidence_read_in_full", "chain_of_custody_metadata_checked", "findings_criteria_complete", "memo_criteria_complete", "deliverables_written_through_mcp"], "metadata_checks": 8, "metric": "weighted_criteria_score", "minimum_tool_calls": 46, "required_deliverables": ["findings.json", "advice.md"], "required_document_reads": 33, "type": "deterministic", "weights": {"findings": 0.55, "memo": 0.2, "procedure": 0.25}}, "task_id": "cb100-092-brightstar-medical", "task_name": "Brightstar 8-K and governance audit", "world_id": "counselbench-filesystem-mcp-v2"}
-{"context_files": ["task_files/cb100-093-cypress-bank/01_board_committees/001_board_committees_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-093-cypress-bank/01_board_committees/002_board_committees_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-093-cypress-bank/01_board_committees/003_board_committees_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-093-cypress-bank/01_board_committees/004_board_committees_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-093-cypress-bank/01_board_committees/005_board_committees_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-093-cypress-bank/01_board_committees/006_board_committees_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-093-cypress-bank/01_board_committees/007_board_committees_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-093-cypress-bank/01_board_committees/008_board_committees_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-093-cypress-bank/02_minutes_materials/009_minutes_materials_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-093-cypress-bank/02_minutes_materials/010_minutes_materials_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-093-cypress-bank/02_minutes_materials/011_minutes_materials_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-093-cypress-bank/02_minutes_materials/012_minutes_materials_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-093-cypress-bank/02_minutes_materials/013_minutes_materials_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-093-cypress-bank/02_minutes_materials/014_minutes_materials_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-093-cypress-bank/02_minutes_materials/015_minutes_materials_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-093-cypress-bank/02_minutes_materials/016_minutes_materials_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-093-cypress-bank/03_sec_filings/017_sec_filings_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-093-cypress-bank/03_sec_filings/018_sec_filings_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-093-cypress-bank/03_sec_filings/019_sec_filings_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-093-cypress-bank/03_sec_filings/020_sec_filings_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-093-cypress-bank/03_sec_filings/021_sec_filings_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-093-cypress-bank/03_sec_filings/022_sec_filings_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-093-cypress-bank/03_sec_filings/023_sec_filings_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-093-cypress-bank/03_sec_filings/024_sec_filings_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-093-cypress-bank/04_disclosure_controls/025_disclosure_controls_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-093-cypress-bank/04_disclosure_controls/026_disclosure_controls_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-093-cypress-bank/04_disclosure_controls/027_disclosure_controls_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-093-cypress-bank/04_disclosure_controls/028_disclosure_controls_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-093-cypress-bank/04_disclosure_controls/029_disclosure_controls_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-093-cypress-bank/04_disclosure_controls/030_disclosure_controls_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-093-cypress-bank/04_disclosure_controls/031_disclosure_controls_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-093-cypress-bank/04_disclosure_controls/032_disclosure_controls_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-093-cypress-bank/05_insider_trading/033_insider_trading_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-093-cypress-bank/05_insider_trading/034_insider_trading_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-093-cypress-bank/05_insider_trading/035_insider_trading_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-093-cypress-bank/05_insider_trading/036_insider_trading_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-093-cypress-bank/05_insider_trading/037_insider_trading_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-093-cypress-bank/05_insider_trading/038_insider_trading_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-093-cypress-bank/05_insider_trading/039_insider_trading_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-093-cypress-bank/05_insider_trading/040_insider_trading_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-093-cypress-bank/06_related_parties/041_related_parties_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-093-cypress-bank/06_related_parties/042_related_parties_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-093-cypress-bank/06_related_parties/043_related_parties_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-093-cypress-bank/06_related_parties/044_related_parties_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-093-cypress-bank/06_related_parties/045_related_parties_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-093-cypress-bank/06_related_parties/046_related_parties_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-093-cypress-bank/06_related_parties/047_related_parties_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-093-cypress-bank/06_related_parties/048_related_parties_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-093-cypress-bank/07_equity_compensation/049_equity_compensation_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-093-cypress-bank/07_equity_compensation/050_equity_compensation_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-093-cypress-bank/07_equity_compensation/051_equity_compensation_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-093-cypress-bank/07_equity_compensation/052_equity_compensation_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-093-cypress-bank/07_equity_compensation/053_equity_compensation_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-093-cypress-bank/07_equity_compensation/054_equity_compensation_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-093-cypress-bank/07_equity_compensation/055_equity_compensation_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-093-cypress-bank/07_equity_compensation/056_equity_compensation_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-093-cypress-bank/08_earnings_guidance/057_earnings_guidance_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-093-cypress-bank/08_earnings_guidance/058_earnings_guidance_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-093-cypress-bank/08_earnings_guidance/059_earnings_guidance_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-093-cypress-bank/08_earnings_guidance/060_earnings_guidance_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-093-cypress-bank/08_earnings_guidance/061_earnings_guidance_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-093-cypress-bank/08_earnings_guidance/062_earnings_guidance_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-093-cypress-bank/08_earnings_guidance/063_earnings_guidance_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-093-cypress-bank/08_earnings_guidance/064_earnings_guidance_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-093-cypress-bank/09_whistleblower/065_whistleblower_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-093-cypress-bank/09_whistleblower/066_whistleblower_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-093-cypress-bank/09_whistleblower/067_whistleblower_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-093-cypress-bank/09_whistleblower/068_whistleblower_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-093-cypress-bank/09_whistleblower/069_whistleblower_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-093-cypress-bank/09_whistleblower/070_whistleblower_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-093-cypress-bank/09_whistleblower/071_whistleblower_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-093-cypress-bank/09_whistleblower/072_whistleblower_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-093-cypress-bank/10_stock_exchange/073_stock_exchange_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-093-cypress-bank/10_stock_exchange/074_stock_exchange_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-093-cypress-bank/10_stock_exchange/075_stock_exchange_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-093-cypress-bank/10_stock_exchange/076_stock_exchange_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-093-cypress-bank/10_stock_exchange/077_stock_exchange_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-093-cypress-bank/10_stock_exchange/078_stock_exchange_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-093-cypress-bank/10_stock_exchange/079_stock_exchange_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-093-cypress-bank/10_stock_exchange/080_stock_exchange_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-093-cypress-bank/11_debt_covenants/081_debt_covenants_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-093-cypress-bank/11_debt_covenants/082_debt_covenants_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-093-cypress-bank/11_debt_covenants/083_debt_covenants_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-093-cypress-bank/11_debt_covenants/084_debt_covenants_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-093-cypress-bank/11_debt_covenants/085_debt_covenants_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-093-cypress-bank/11_debt_covenants/086_debt_covenants_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-093-cypress-bank/11_debt_covenants/087_debt_covenants_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-093-cypress-bank/11_debt_covenants/088_debt_covenants_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-093-cypress-bank/12_certifications/089_certifications_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-093-cypress-bank/12_certifications/090_certifications_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-093-cypress-bank/12_certifications/091_certifications_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-093-cypress-bank/12_certifications/092_certifications_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-093-cypress-bank/12_certifications/093_certifications_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-093-cypress-bank/12_certifications/094_certifications_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-093-cypress-bank/12_certifications/095_certifications_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-093-cypress-bank/12_certifications/096_certifications_status_report.md"], "gold_output": {"advice_markdown": "# Counsel advice — Cypress related-party disclosure review\n\n## Executive assessment\n\nFor Cypress Community Bancorp matter CB-PC-3303, the review identified 16 source-supported exceptions requiring action before 2026-09-10. The assessment concerns Related Party Transactions Committee and the supplied record for Florida.\n\n## Method and record coverage\n\nThe review inventoried all 96 production files, read the 33 controlling, corroborating, and control records, searched the email exports, and checked metadata for the designated chain-of-custody sample. Conclusions are limited to the synthetic production supplied for this benchmark matter.\n\n## Findings\n\n### F-01 — committee-independence gap (critical)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for committee-independence gap: one source states the operative date is 2025-11-04 under control reference CB-PC-3303-A705, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2025-12-01 under response reference CB-PC-3303-J215.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/01_board_committees/001_board_committees_control_register.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/07_equity_compensation/049_equity_compensation_control_register.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-10, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Jonas Feld.\n\n### F-02 — minutes-approval omission (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for minutes-approval omission: one source states the controlling amount is $985,073.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $1,236,646.00.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/01_board_committees/004_board_committees_ledger_export.csv`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/07_equity_compensation/052_equity_compensation_ledger_export.csv`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-10, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Mei Whitaker.\n\n### F-03 — 8-K deadline (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for 8-K deadline: one source states approval is attributed to Nora Chen as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Caleb Hassan and contains no entry for Nora Chen.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/01_board_committees/007_board_committees_officer_certificate.html`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/07_equity_compensation/055_equity_compensation_officer_certificate.html`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-10, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Caleb Hassan.\n\n### F-04 — risk-factor inconsistency (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for risk-factor inconsistency: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-PC-3303-D594, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-PC-3303-M830.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/010_minutes_materials_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/08_earnings_guidance/058_earnings_guidance_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-10, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Leona Park.\n\n### F-05 — disclosure-control exception (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for disclosure-control exception: one source states the applicable location is Nasdaq Stock Market, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to Florida operations outside Nasdaq Stock Market.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/013_minutes_materials_review_memorandum.json`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/08_earnings_guidance/061_earnings_guidance_review_memorandum.json`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-10, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Isaac Romero.\n\n### F-06 — trading-window violation (low)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for trading-window violation: one source states the threshold is 8% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 12% and produced a different exception result.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/016_minutes_materials_status_report.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/08_earnings_guidance/064_earnings_guidance_status_report.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-10, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Sofia Bennett.\n\n### F-07 — Section 16 filing delay (critical)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for Section 16 filing delay: one source states formal notice must use notices-cypress_community_bancorp@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-related_party_transactions_committee@example.test.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/019_sec_filings_correspondence.eml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/09_whistleblower/067_whistleblower_correspondence.eml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-10, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Adrian Mensah.\n\n### F-08 — related-party disclosure gap (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for related-party disclosure gap: one source states the governed population contains 180 records through 2025-05-15, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 54 records through 2025-06-10.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/022_sec_filings_formal_notice.xml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/09_whistleblower/070_whistleblower_formal_notice.xml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-10, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Willa Novak.\n\n### F-09 — equity-plan share mismatch (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for equity-plan share mismatch: one source states the operative date is 2026-01-09 under control reference CB-PC-3303-I171, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2026-01-27 under response reference CB-PC-3303-R590.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/025_disclosure_controls_control_register.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/10_stock_exchange/073_stock_exchange_control_register.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-10, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Theo Laurent.\n\n### F-10 — non-GAAP reconciliation issue (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for non-GAAP reconciliation issue: one source states the controlling amount is $4,399,273.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $4,515,046.00.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/028_disclosure_controls_ledger_export.csv`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/10_stock_exchange/076_stock_exchange_ledger_export.csv`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-10, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Amara Patel.\n\n### F-11 — guidance-control failure (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for guidance-control failure: one source states approval is attributed to Nora Chen as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Rafael Okafor and contains no entry for Nora Chen.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/031_disclosure_controls_officer_certificate.html`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/10_stock_exchange/079_stock_exchange_officer_certificate.html`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-10, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Henry Cho.\n\n### F-12 — whistleblower escalation delay (low)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for whistleblower escalation delay: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-PC-3303-L570, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-PC-3303-U274.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/034_insider_trading_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/11_debt_covenants/082_debt_covenants_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-10, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Nadine Flores.\n\n### F-13 — listing-standard notice (critical)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for listing-standard notice: one source states the applicable location is Nasdaq Stock Market, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to Florida operations outside Nasdaq Stock Market.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/037_insider_trading_review_memorandum.json`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/11_debt_covenants/085_debt_covenants_review_memorandum.json`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-10, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Micah Sullivan.\n\n### F-14 — debt-covenant disclosure (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for debt-covenant disclosure: one source states the threshold is 9% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 14% and produced a different exception result.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/040_insider_trading_status_report.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/11_debt_covenants/088_debt_covenants_status_report.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-10, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Farah Ibrahim.\n\n### F-15 — officer certification exception (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for officer certification exception: one source states formal notice must use notices-cypress_community_bancorp@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-related_party_transactions_committee@example.test.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/06_related_parties/043_related_parties_correspondence.eml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/12_certifications/091_certifications_correspondence.eml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-10, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Owen Delgado.\n\n### F-16 — board-matrix inconsistency (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for board-matrix inconsistency: one source states the governed population contains 80 records through 2025-02-04, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 47 records through 2025-02-23.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/06_related_parties/046_related_parties_formal_notice.xml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/12_certifications/094_certifications_formal_notice.xml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-10, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Lena Varga.\n\n## Recommended next actions\n\nSequence the critical and high findings first, assign the named owners, preserve the cited records, and document any resolution in the controlling matter register before the stated deadline.\n\n## Assumptions and limitations\n\nThis analysis is confined to task cb100-093-cypress-bank and the supplied synthetic evidence. It does not rely on external facts, does not resolve disputed law, and is not legal advice for a real person or entity.\n", "findings": {"as_of": "2026-09-10", "findings": [{"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/07_equity_compensation/049_equity_compensation_control_register.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for committee-independence gap: one source states the operative date is 2025-11-04 under control reference CB-PC-3303-A705, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2025-12-01 under response reference CB-PC-3303-J215.", "id": "F-01", "issue": "committee-independence gap", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/01_board_committees/001_board_committees_control_register.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-10, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Jonas Feld.", "severity": "critical"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/07_equity_compensation/052_equity_compensation_ledger_export.csv", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for minutes-approval omission: one source states the controlling amount is $985,073.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $1,236,646.00.", "id": "F-02", "issue": "minutes-approval omission", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/01_board_committees/004_board_committees_ledger_export.csv", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-10, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Mei Whitaker.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/07_equity_compensation/055_equity_compensation_officer_certificate.html", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for 8-K deadline: one source states approval is attributed to Nora Chen as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Caleb Hassan and contains no entry for Nora Chen.", "id": "F-03", "issue": "8-K deadline", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/01_board_committees/007_board_committees_officer_certificate.html", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-10, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Caleb Hassan.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/08_earnings_guidance/058_earnings_guidance_executed_instrument.txt", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for risk-factor inconsistency: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-PC-3303-D594, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-PC-3303-M830.", "id": "F-04", "issue": "risk-factor inconsistency", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/010_minutes_materials_executed_instrument.txt", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-10, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Leona Park.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/08_earnings_guidance/061_earnings_guidance_review_memorandum.json", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for disclosure-control exception: one source states the applicable location is Nasdaq Stock Market, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to Florida operations outside Nasdaq Stock Market.", "id": "F-05", "issue": "disclosure-control exception", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/013_minutes_materials_review_memorandum.json", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-10, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Isaac Romero.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/08_earnings_guidance/064_earnings_guidance_status_report.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for trading-window violation: one source states the threshold is 8% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 12% and produced a different exception result.", "id": "F-06", "issue": "trading-window violation", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/016_minutes_materials_status_report.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-10, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Sofia Bennett.", "severity": "low"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/09_whistleblower/067_whistleblower_correspondence.eml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for Section 16 filing delay: one source states formal notice must use notices-cypress_community_bancorp@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-related_party_transactions_committee@example.test.", "id": "F-07", "issue": "Section 16 filing delay", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/019_sec_filings_correspondence.eml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-10, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Adrian Mensah.", "severity": "critical"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/09_whistleblower/070_whistleblower_formal_notice.xml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for related-party disclosure gap: one source states the governed population contains 180 records through 2025-05-15, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 54 records through 2025-06-10.", "id": "F-08", "issue": "related-party disclosure gap", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/022_sec_filings_formal_notice.xml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-10, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Willa Novak.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/10_stock_exchange/073_stock_exchange_control_register.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for equity-plan share mismatch: one source states the operative date is 2026-01-09 under control reference CB-PC-3303-I171, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2026-01-27 under response reference CB-PC-3303-R590.", "id": "F-09", "issue": "equity-plan share mismatch", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/025_disclosure_controls_control_register.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-10, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Theo Laurent.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/10_stock_exchange/076_stock_exchange_ledger_export.csv", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for non-GAAP reconciliation issue: one source states the controlling amount is $4,399,273.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $4,515,046.00.", "id": "F-10", "issue": "non-GAAP reconciliation issue", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/028_disclosure_controls_ledger_export.csv", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-10, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Amara Patel.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/10_stock_exchange/079_stock_exchange_officer_certificate.html", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for guidance-control failure: one source states approval is attributed to Nora Chen as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Rafael Okafor and contains no entry for Nora Chen.", "id": "F-11", "issue": "guidance-control failure", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/031_disclosure_controls_officer_certificate.html", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-10, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Henry Cho.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/11_debt_covenants/082_debt_covenants_executed_instrument.txt", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for whistleblower escalation delay: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-PC-3303-L570, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-PC-3303-U274.", "id": "F-12", "issue": "whistleblower escalation delay", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/034_insider_trading_executed_instrument.txt", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-10, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Nadine Flores.", "severity": "low"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/11_debt_covenants/085_debt_covenants_review_memorandum.json", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for listing-standard notice: one source states the applicable location is Nasdaq Stock Market, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to Florida operations outside Nasdaq Stock Market.", "id": "F-13", "issue": "listing-standard notice", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/037_insider_trading_review_memorandum.json", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-10, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Micah Sullivan.", "severity": "critical"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/11_debt_covenants/088_debt_covenants_status_report.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for debt-covenant disclosure: one source states the threshold is 9% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 14% and produced a different exception result.", "id": "F-14", "issue": "debt-covenant disclosure", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/040_insider_trading_status_report.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-10, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Farah Ibrahim.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/12_certifications/091_certifications_correspondence.eml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for officer certification exception: one source states formal notice must use notices-cypress_community_bancorp@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-related_party_transactions_committee@example.test.", "id": "F-15", "issue": "officer certification exception", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/06_related_parties/043_related_parties_correspondence.eml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-10, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Owen Delgado.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/12_certifications/094_certifications_formal_notice.xml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for board-matrix inconsistency: one source states the governed population contains 80 records through 2025-02-04, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 47 records through 2025-02-23.", "id": "F-16", "issue": "board-matrix inconsistency", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/06_related_parties/046_related_parties_formal_notice.xml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-10, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Lena Varga.", "severity": "medium"}], "matter_number": "CB-PC-3303", "prepared_for": "Cypress Community Bancorp", "schema_version": "1.0", "task_id": "cb100-093-cypress-bank"}}, "metadata": {"benchmark": "CounselBench-100", "code_license": "Apache-2.0", "data_license": "CC-BY-4.0", "deadline": "2026-09-10", "document_count": 96, "jurisdiction": "Florida", "matter_number": "CB-PC-3303", "mcp_commit": "9a96ea6e5913736f92b88345bf51caeaaa8e719f", "mcp_package": "@modelcontextprotocol/server-filesystem@2026.7.10", "practice_area": "public-company", "reference_tool_calls": 46, "required_evidence_reads": 33, "synthetic": true, "venue": "Nasdaq Stock Market", "version": "2.0.0"}, "prompt": "You are securities and governance counsel for Cypress Community Bancorp. The client has asked for a board-ready risk assessment supported by a source-level tracker rather than a narrative-only summary. Vendor, loan, family relationship, board approval, and questionnaire records differ before the proxy filing date. Decision due 2026-09-10. Florida law governs; Nasdaq Stock Market is the forum. Treat dates, notice mechanics, approval evidence, and numerical reconciliations as independent controls. Work out the defensible position from the matter production and leave an audit-ready exception tracker and concise advice for the supervising lawyer. Keep confirmed conflicts separate from open questions, cite the records that actually control each conclusion, and do not fill gaps with outside facts.", "rubric": {"criteria": [{"category": "procedure", "description": "Complete at least 46 successful, argument-specific evidence and output calls.", "id": "procedure.minimum_successful_tool_calls"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Find and read the 33 controlling, corroborating, and work-product-control records in full.", "id": "procedure.all_evidence_read_in_full"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Inspect file metadata for the eight designated critical primary records before relying on them.", "id": "procedure.chain_of_custody_metadata_checked"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Confirm the sandbox's allowed document and output roots.", "id": "procedure.allowed_directories_checked"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Inventory all 96 records so the relevant sources are discovered among the context records.", "id": "procedure.recursive_inventory_completed"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Search the production for email evidence that may corroborate or contradict formal records.", "id": "procedure.targeted_search_completed"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Leave only findings.json and advice.md in the output workspace.", "id": "procedure.exact_deliverable_set"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Create both final work products through the sandbox MCP surface.", "id": "procedure.deliverables_written_through_mcp"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Produce findings.json as a valid JSON object.", "id": "findings.findings_is_object"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Report exactly 16 confirmed exceptions.", "id": "findings.findings_exact_count"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Use each stable finding ID exactly once.", "id": "findings.finding_ids_unique"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set schema_version to the released matter value '1.0'.", "id": "findings.top_level_schema_version"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set task_id to the released matter value 'cb100-093-cypress-bank'.", "id": "findings.top_level_task_id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set matter_number to the released matter value 'CB-PC-3303'.", "id": "findings.top_level_matter_number"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set prepared_for to the released matter value 'Cypress Community Bancorp'.", "id": "findings.top_level_prepared_for"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set as_of to the released matter value '2026-09-10'.", "id": "findings.top_level_as_of"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-01 exception for committee-independence gap.", "id": "findings.F-01.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's id from /workspace/documents/01_board_committees/001_board_committees_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_equity_compensation/049_equity_compensation_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's issue from /workspace/documents/01_board_committees/001_board_committees_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_equity_compensation/049_equity_compensation_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's severity from /workspace/documents/01_board_committees/001_board_committees_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_equity_compensation/049_equity_compensation_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's primary_source from /workspace/documents/01_board_committees/001_board_committees_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_equity_compensation/049_equity_compensation_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/01_board_committees/001_board_committees_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_equity_compensation/049_equity_compensation_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-01 using the exact controlled facts ['2025-11-04', 'CB-PC-3303-A705', '2025-12-01', 'CB-PC-3303-J215'].", "id": "findings.F-01.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-01's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-01.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-10', 'Jonas Feld'] for F-01.", "id": "findings.F-01.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-02 exception for minutes-approval omission.", "id": "findings.F-02.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's id from /workspace/documents/01_board_committees/004_board_committees_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_equity_compensation/052_equity_compensation_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's issue from /workspace/documents/01_board_committees/004_board_committees_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_equity_compensation/052_equity_compensation_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's severity from /workspace/documents/01_board_committees/004_board_committees_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_equity_compensation/052_equity_compensation_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's primary_source from /workspace/documents/01_board_committees/004_board_committees_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_equity_compensation/052_equity_compensation_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/01_board_committees/004_board_committees_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_equity_compensation/052_equity_compensation_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-02 using the exact controlled facts ['$985,073.00', '$1,236,646.00'].", "id": "findings.F-02.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-02's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-02.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-10', 'Mei Whitaker'] for F-02.", "id": "findings.F-02.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-03 exception for 8-K deadline.", "id": "findings.F-03.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's id from /workspace/documents/01_board_committees/007_board_committees_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_equity_compensation/055_equity_compensation_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's issue from /workspace/documents/01_board_committees/007_board_committees_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_equity_compensation/055_equity_compensation_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's severity from /workspace/documents/01_board_committees/007_board_committees_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_equity_compensation/055_equity_compensation_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's primary_source from /workspace/documents/01_board_committees/007_board_committees_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_equity_compensation/055_equity_compensation_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/01_board_committees/007_board_committees_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_equity_compensation/055_equity_compensation_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-03 using the exact controlled facts ['Nora Chen', 'Caleb Hassan'].", "id": "findings.F-03.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-03's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-03.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-10', 'Caleb Hassan'] for F-03.", "id": "findings.F-03.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-04 exception for risk-factor inconsistency.", "id": "findings.F-04.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's id from /workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/010_minutes_materials_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_earnings_guidance/058_earnings_guidance_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's issue from /workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/010_minutes_materials_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_earnings_guidance/058_earnings_guidance_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's severity from /workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/010_minutes_materials_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_earnings_guidance/058_earnings_guidance_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's primary_source from /workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/010_minutes_materials_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_earnings_guidance/058_earnings_guidance_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/010_minutes_materials_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_earnings_guidance/058_earnings_guidance_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-04 using the exact controlled facts ['closed without exception', 'CB-PC-3303-D594', 'open and escalated', 'CB-PC-3303-M830'].", "id": "findings.F-04.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-04's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-04.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-10', 'Leona Park'] for F-04.", "id": "findings.F-04.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-05 exception for disclosure-control exception.", "id": "findings.F-05.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's id from /workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/013_minutes_materials_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_earnings_guidance/061_earnings_guidance_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's issue from /workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/013_minutes_materials_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_earnings_guidance/061_earnings_guidance_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's severity from /workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/013_minutes_materials_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_earnings_guidance/061_earnings_guidance_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's primary_source from /workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/013_minutes_materials_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_earnings_guidance/061_earnings_guidance_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/013_minutes_materials_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_earnings_guidance/061_earnings_guidance_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-05 using the exact controlled facts ['Nasdaq Stock Market', 'Florida'].", "id": "findings.F-05.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-05's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-05.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-10', 'Isaac Romero'] for F-05.", "id": "findings.F-05.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-06 exception for trading-window violation.", "id": "findings.F-06.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's id from /workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/016_minutes_materials_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_earnings_guidance/064_earnings_guidance_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's issue from /workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/016_minutes_materials_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_earnings_guidance/064_earnings_guidance_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's severity from /workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/016_minutes_materials_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_earnings_guidance/064_earnings_guidance_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's primary_source from /workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/016_minutes_materials_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_earnings_guidance/064_earnings_guidance_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/016_minutes_materials_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_earnings_guidance/064_earnings_guidance_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-06 using the exact controlled facts ['8%', '12%'].", "id": "findings.F-06.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-06's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-06.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-10', 'Sofia Bennett'] for F-06.", "id": "findings.F-06.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-07 exception for Section 16 filing delay.", "id": "findings.F-07.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's id from /workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/019_sec_filings_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_whistleblower/067_whistleblower_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's issue from /workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/019_sec_filings_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_whistleblower/067_whistleblower_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's severity from /workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/019_sec_filings_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_whistleblower/067_whistleblower_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's primary_source from /workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/019_sec_filings_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_whistleblower/067_whistleblower_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/019_sec_filings_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_whistleblower/067_whistleblower_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-07 using the exact controlled facts ['notices-cypress_community_bancorp@example.test', 'archive-related_party_transactions_committee@example.test'].", "id": "findings.F-07.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-07's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-07.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-10', 'Adrian Mensah'] for F-07.", "id": "findings.F-07.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-08 exception for related-party disclosure gap.", "id": "findings.F-08.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's id from /workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/022_sec_filings_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_whistleblower/070_whistleblower_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's issue from /workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/022_sec_filings_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_whistleblower/070_whistleblower_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's severity from /workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/022_sec_filings_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_whistleblower/070_whistleblower_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's primary_source from /workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/022_sec_filings_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_whistleblower/070_whistleblower_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/022_sec_filings_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_whistleblower/070_whistleblower_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-08 using the exact controlled facts ['180 records', '2025-05-15', '54 records', '2025-06-10'].", "id": "findings.F-08.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-08's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-08.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-10', 'Willa Novak'] for F-08.", "id": "findings.F-08.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-09 exception for equity-plan share mismatch.", "id": "findings.F-09.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's id from /workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/025_disclosure_controls_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_stock_exchange/073_stock_exchange_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's issue from /workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/025_disclosure_controls_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_stock_exchange/073_stock_exchange_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's severity from /workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/025_disclosure_controls_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_stock_exchange/073_stock_exchange_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's primary_source from /workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/025_disclosure_controls_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_stock_exchange/073_stock_exchange_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/025_disclosure_controls_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_stock_exchange/073_stock_exchange_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-09 using the exact controlled facts ['2026-01-09', 'CB-PC-3303-I171', '2026-01-27', 'CB-PC-3303-R590'].", "id": "findings.F-09.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-09's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-09.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-10', 'Theo Laurent'] for F-09.", "id": "findings.F-09.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-10 exception for non-GAAP reconciliation issue.", "id": "findings.F-10.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's id from /workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/028_disclosure_controls_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_stock_exchange/076_stock_exchange_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's issue from /workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/028_disclosure_controls_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_stock_exchange/076_stock_exchange_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's severity from /workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/028_disclosure_controls_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_stock_exchange/076_stock_exchange_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's primary_source from /workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/028_disclosure_controls_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_stock_exchange/076_stock_exchange_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/028_disclosure_controls_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_stock_exchange/076_stock_exchange_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-10 using the exact controlled facts ['$4,399,273.00', '$4,515,046.00'].", "id": "findings.F-10.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-10's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-10.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-10', 'Amara Patel'] for F-10.", "id": "findings.F-10.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-11 exception for guidance-control failure.", "id": "findings.F-11.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's id from /workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/031_disclosure_controls_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_stock_exchange/079_stock_exchange_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's issue from /workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/031_disclosure_controls_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_stock_exchange/079_stock_exchange_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's severity from /workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/031_disclosure_controls_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_stock_exchange/079_stock_exchange_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's primary_source from /workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/031_disclosure_controls_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_stock_exchange/079_stock_exchange_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/031_disclosure_controls_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_stock_exchange/079_stock_exchange_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-11 using the exact controlled facts ['Nora Chen', 'Rafael Okafor'].", "id": "findings.F-11.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-11's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-11.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-10', 'Henry Cho'] for F-11.", "id": "findings.F-11.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-12 exception for whistleblower escalation delay.", "id": "findings.F-12.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's id from /workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/034_insider_trading_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_debt_covenants/082_debt_covenants_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's issue from /workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/034_insider_trading_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_debt_covenants/082_debt_covenants_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's severity from /workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/034_insider_trading_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_debt_covenants/082_debt_covenants_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's primary_source from /workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/034_insider_trading_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_debt_covenants/082_debt_covenants_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/034_insider_trading_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_debt_covenants/082_debt_covenants_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-12 using the exact controlled facts ['closed without exception', 'CB-PC-3303-L570', 'open and escalated', 'CB-PC-3303-U274'].", "id": "findings.F-12.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-12's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-12.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-10', 'Nadine Flores'] for F-12.", "id": "findings.F-12.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-13 exception for listing-standard notice.", "id": "findings.F-13.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's id from /workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/037_insider_trading_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_debt_covenants/085_debt_covenants_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's issue from /workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/037_insider_trading_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_debt_covenants/085_debt_covenants_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's severity from /workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/037_insider_trading_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_debt_covenants/085_debt_covenants_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's primary_source from /workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/037_insider_trading_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_debt_covenants/085_debt_covenants_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/037_insider_trading_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_debt_covenants/085_debt_covenants_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-13 using the exact controlled facts ['Nasdaq Stock Market', 'Florida'].", "id": "findings.F-13.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-13's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-13.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-10', 'Micah Sullivan'] for F-13.", "id": "findings.F-13.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-14 exception for debt-covenant disclosure.", "id": "findings.F-14.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's id from /workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/040_insider_trading_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_debt_covenants/088_debt_covenants_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's issue from /workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/040_insider_trading_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_debt_covenants/088_debt_covenants_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's severity from /workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/040_insider_trading_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_debt_covenants/088_debt_covenants_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's primary_source from /workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/040_insider_trading_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_debt_covenants/088_debt_covenants_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/040_insider_trading_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_debt_covenants/088_debt_covenants_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-14 using the exact controlled facts ['9%', '14%'].", "id": "findings.F-14.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-14's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-14.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-10', 'Farah Ibrahim'] for F-14.", "id": "findings.F-14.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-15 exception for officer certification exception.", "id": "findings.F-15.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's id from /workspace/documents/06_related_parties/043_related_parties_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_certifications/091_certifications_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's issue from /workspace/documents/06_related_parties/043_related_parties_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_certifications/091_certifications_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's severity from /workspace/documents/06_related_parties/043_related_parties_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_certifications/091_certifications_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's primary_source from /workspace/documents/06_related_parties/043_related_parties_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_certifications/091_certifications_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/06_related_parties/043_related_parties_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_certifications/091_certifications_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-15 using the exact controlled facts ['notices-cypress_community_bancorp@example.test', 'archive-related_party_transactions_committee@example.test'].", "id": "findings.F-15.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-15's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-15.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-10', 'Owen Delgado'] for F-15.", "id": "findings.F-15.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-16 exception for board-matrix inconsistency.", "id": "findings.F-16.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's id from /workspace/documents/06_related_parties/046_related_parties_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_certifications/094_certifications_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's issue from /workspace/documents/06_related_parties/046_related_parties_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_certifications/094_certifications_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's severity from /workspace/documents/06_related_parties/046_related_parties_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_certifications/094_certifications_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's primary_source from /workspace/documents/06_related_parties/046_related_parties_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_certifications/094_certifications_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/06_related_parties/046_related_parties_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_certifications/094_certifications_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-16 using the exact controlled facts ['80 records', '2025-02-04', '47 records', '2025-02-23'].", "id": "findings.F-16.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-16's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-16.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-10', 'Lena Varga'] for F-16.", "id": "findings.F-16.action_anchors"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Executive assessment' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Executive assessment"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Method and record coverage' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Method and record coverage"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Findings' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Findings"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Recommended next actions' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Recommended next actions"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Assumptions and limitations' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Assumptions and limitations"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-01 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-01"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-02 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-02"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-03 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-03"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-04 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-04"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-05 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-05"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-06 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-06"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-07 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-07"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-08 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-08"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-09 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-09"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-10 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-10"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-11 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-11"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-12 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-12"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-13 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-13"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-14 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-14"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-15 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-15"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-16 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-16"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Do not claim the production has no issues or that every record is consistent.", "id": "memo.forbidden_claims_absent"}], "decision_options": [{"id": "cross-source-reconciliation", "label": "Reconcile controlling and corroborating records", "reason": "The CB-PC-3303 production contains independently maintained records; a defensible answer must preserve each supported conflict and its cure owner.", "selected": true}, {"id": "latest-record-controls", "label": "Treat the latest record as controlling", "reason": "Timestamp recency does not establish legal priority, execution, or approval authority.", "selected": false}, {"id": "primary-records-only", "label": "Report primary records without reconciliation", "reason": "Primary records alone conceal the operational conflicts that create the actionable exceptions.", "selected": false}], "gates": ["all_evidence_read_in_full", "chain_of_custody_metadata_checked", "findings_criteria_complete", "memo_criteria_complete", "deliverables_written_through_mcp"], "metadata_checks": 8, "metric": "weighted_criteria_score", "minimum_tool_calls": 46, "required_deliverables": ["findings.json", "advice.md"], "required_document_reads": 33, "type": "deterministic", "weights": {"findings": 0.55, "memo": 0.2, "procedure": 0.25}}, "task_id": "cb100-093-cypress-bank", "task_name": "Cypress related-party disclosure review", "world_id": "counselbench-filesystem-mcp-v2"}
-{"context_files": ["task_files/cb100-094-duneworks/01_board_committees/001_board_committees_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-094-duneworks/01_board_committees/002_board_committees_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-094-duneworks/01_board_committees/003_board_committees_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-094-duneworks/01_board_committees/004_board_committees_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-094-duneworks/01_board_committees/005_board_committees_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-094-duneworks/01_board_committees/006_board_committees_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-094-duneworks/01_board_committees/007_board_committees_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-094-duneworks/01_board_committees/008_board_committees_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-094-duneworks/02_minutes_materials/009_minutes_materials_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-094-duneworks/02_minutes_materials/010_minutes_materials_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-094-duneworks/02_minutes_materials/011_minutes_materials_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-094-duneworks/02_minutes_materials/012_minutes_materials_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-094-duneworks/02_minutes_materials/013_minutes_materials_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-094-duneworks/02_minutes_materials/014_minutes_materials_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-094-duneworks/02_minutes_materials/015_minutes_materials_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-094-duneworks/02_minutes_materials/016_minutes_materials_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-094-duneworks/03_sec_filings/017_sec_filings_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-094-duneworks/03_sec_filings/018_sec_filings_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-094-duneworks/03_sec_filings/019_sec_filings_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-094-duneworks/03_sec_filings/020_sec_filings_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-094-duneworks/03_sec_filings/021_sec_filings_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-094-duneworks/03_sec_filings/022_sec_filings_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-094-duneworks/03_sec_filings/023_sec_filings_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-094-duneworks/03_sec_filings/024_sec_filings_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-094-duneworks/04_disclosure_controls/025_disclosure_controls_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-094-duneworks/04_disclosure_controls/026_disclosure_controls_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-094-duneworks/04_disclosure_controls/027_disclosure_controls_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-094-duneworks/04_disclosure_controls/028_disclosure_controls_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-094-duneworks/04_disclosure_controls/029_disclosure_controls_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-094-duneworks/04_disclosure_controls/030_disclosure_controls_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-094-duneworks/04_disclosure_controls/031_disclosure_controls_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-094-duneworks/04_disclosure_controls/032_disclosure_controls_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-094-duneworks/05_insider_trading/033_insider_trading_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-094-duneworks/05_insider_trading/034_insider_trading_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-094-duneworks/05_insider_trading/035_insider_trading_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-094-duneworks/05_insider_trading/036_insider_trading_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-094-duneworks/05_insider_trading/037_insider_trading_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-094-duneworks/05_insider_trading/038_insider_trading_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-094-duneworks/05_insider_trading/039_insider_trading_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-094-duneworks/05_insider_trading/040_insider_trading_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-094-duneworks/06_related_parties/041_related_parties_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-094-duneworks/06_related_parties/042_related_parties_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-094-duneworks/06_related_parties/043_related_parties_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-094-duneworks/06_related_parties/044_related_parties_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-094-duneworks/06_related_parties/045_related_parties_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-094-duneworks/06_related_parties/046_related_parties_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-094-duneworks/06_related_parties/047_related_parties_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-094-duneworks/06_related_parties/048_related_parties_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-094-duneworks/07_equity_compensation/049_equity_compensation_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-094-duneworks/07_equity_compensation/050_equity_compensation_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-094-duneworks/07_equity_compensation/051_equity_compensation_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-094-duneworks/07_equity_compensation/052_equity_compensation_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-094-duneworks/07_equity_compensation/053_equity_compensation_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-094-duneworks/07_equity_compensation/054_equity_compensation_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-094-duneworks/07_equity_compensation/055_equity_compensation_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-094-duneworks/07_equity_compensation/056_equity_compensation_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-094-duneworks/08_earnings_guidance/057_earnings_guidance_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-094-duneworks/08_earnings_guidance/058_earnings_guidance_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-094-duneworks/08_earnings_guidance/059_earnings_guidance_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-094-duneworks/08_earnings_guidance/060_earnings_guidance_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-094-duneworks/08_earnings_guidance/061_earnings_guidance_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-094-duneworks/08_earnings_guidance/062_earnings_guidance_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-094-duneworks/08_earnings_guidance/063_earnings_guidance_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-094-duneworks/08_earnings_guidance/064_earnings_guidance_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-094-duneworks/09_whistleblower/065_whistleblower_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-094-duneworks/09_whistleblower/066_whistleblower_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-094-duneworks/09_whistleblower/067_whistleblower_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-094-duneworks/09_whistleblower/068_whistleblower_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-094-duneworks/09_whistleblower/069_whistleblower_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-094-duneworks/09_whistleblower/070_whistleblower_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-094-duneworks/09_whistleblower/071_whistleblower_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-094-duneworks/09_whistleblower/072_whistleblower_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-094-duneworks/10_stock_exchange/073_stock_exchange_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-094-duneworks/10_stock_exchange/074_stock_exchange_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-094-duneworks/10_stock_exchange/075_stock_exchange_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-094-duneworks/10_stock_exchange/076_stock_exchange_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-094-duneworks/10_stock_exchange/077_stock_exchange_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-094-duneworks/10_stock_exchange/078_stock_exchange_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-094-duneworks/10_stock_exchange/079_stock_exchange_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-094-duneworks/10_stock_exchange/080_stock_exchange_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-094-duneworks/11_debt_covenants/081_debt_covenants_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-094-duneworks/11_debt_covenants/082_debt_covenants_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-094-duneworks/11_debt_covenants/083_debt_covenants_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-094-duneworks/11_debt_covenants/084_debt_covenants_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-094-duneworks/11_debt_covenants/085_debt_covenants_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-094-duneworks/11_debt_covenants/086_debt_covenants_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-094-duneworks/11_debt_covenants/087_debt_covenants_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-094-duneworks/11_debt_covenants/088_debt_covenants_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-094-duneworks/12_certifications/089_certifications_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-094-duneworks/12_certifications/090_certifications_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-094-duneworks/12_certifications/091_certifications_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-094-duneworks/12_certifications/092_certifications_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-094-duneworks/12_certifications/093_certifications_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-094-duneworks/12_certifications/094_certifications_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-094-duneworks/12_certifications/095_certifications_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-094-duneworks/12_certifications/096_certifications_status_report.md"], "gold_output": {"advice_markdown": "# Counsel advice — Duneworks earnings-controls audit\n\n## Executive assessment\n\nFor Duneworks Software, Inc. matter CB-PC-3304, the review identified 16 source-supported exceptions requiring action before 2026-09-14. The assessment concerns Disclosure Committee and the supplied record for California.\n\n## Method and record coverage\n\nThe review inventoried all 96 production files, read the 33 controlling, corroborating, and control records, searched the email exports, and checked metadata for the designated chain-of-custody sample. Conclusions are limited to the synthetic production supplied for this benchmark matter.\n\n## Findings\n\n### F-01 — committee-independence gap (critical)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for committee-independence gap: one source states the operative date is 2025-04-18 under control reference CB-PC-3304-A805, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2025-05-20 under response reference CB-PC-3304-J915.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/01_board_committees/001_board_committees_control_register.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/07_equity_compensation/049_equity_compensation_control_register.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-14, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Mei Whitaker.\n\n### F-02 — minutes-approval omission (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for minutes-approval omission: one source states the controlling amount is $2,818,425.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $2,843,350.00.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/01_board_committees/004_board_committees_ledger_export.csv`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/07_equity_compensation/052_equity_compensation_ledger_export.csv`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-14, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Caleb Hassan.\n\n### F-03 — 8-K deadline (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for 8-K deadline: one source states approval is attributed to Dominic Alvarez as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Isaac Romero and contains no entry for Dominic Alvarez.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/01_board_committees/007_board_committees_officer_certificate.html`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/07_equity_compensation/055_equity_compensation_officer_certificate.html`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-14, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Leona Park.\n\n### F-04 — risk-factor inconsistency (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for risk-factor inconsistency: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-PC-3304-D390, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-PC-3304-M468.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/010_minutes_materials_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/08_earnings_guidance/058_earnings_guidance_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-14, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Isaac Romero.\n\n### F-05 — disclosure-control exception (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for disclosure-control exception: one source states the applicable location is New York Stock Exchange, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to California operations outside New York Stock Exchange.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/013_minutes_materials_review_memorandum.json`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/08_earnings_guidance/061_earnings_guidance_review_memorandum.json`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-14, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Sofia Bennett.\n\n### F-06 — trading-window violation (low)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for trading-window violation: one source states the threshold is 13% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 20% and produced a different exception result.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/016_minutes_materials_status_report.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/08_earnings_guidance/064_earnings_guidance_status_report.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-14, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Adrian Mensah.\n\n### F-07 — Section 16 filing delay (critical)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for Section 16 filing delay: one source states formal notice must use notices-duneworks_software_inc@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-disclosure_committee@example.test.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/019_sec_filings_correspondence.eml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/09_whistleblower/067_whistleblower_correspondence.eml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-14, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Willa Novak.\n\n### F-08 — related-party disclosure gap (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for related-party disclosure gap: one source states the governed population contains 121 records through 2025-03-17, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 42 records through 2025-03-31.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/022_sec_filings_formal_notice.xml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/09_whistleblower/070_whistleblower_formal_notice.xml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-14, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Theo Laurent.\n\n### F-09 — equity-plan share mismatch (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for equity-plan share mismatch: one source states the operative date is 2025-05-29 under control reference CB-PC-3304-I366, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2025-07-10 under response reference CB-PC-3304-R120.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/025_disclosure_controls_control_register.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/10_stock_exchange/073_stock_exchange_control_register.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-14, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Amara Patel.\n\n### F-10 — non-GAAP reconciliation issue (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for non-GAAP reconciliation issue: one source states the controlling amount is $4,154,814.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $4,426,128.00.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/028_disclosure_controls_ledger_export.csv`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/10_stock_exchange/076_stock_exchange_ledger_export.csv`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-14, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Henry Cho.\n\n### F-11 — guidance-control failure (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for guidance-control failure: one source states approval is attributed to Dominic Alvarez as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Dominic Alvarez and contains no entry for Dominic Alvarez.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/031_disclosure_controls_officer_certificate.html`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/10_stock_exchange/079_stock_exchange_officer_certificate.html`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-14, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Nadine Flores.\n\n### F-12 — whistleblower escalation delay (low)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for whistleblower escalation delay: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-PC-3304-L347, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-PC-3304-U188.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/034_insider_trading_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/11_debt_covenants/082_debt_covenants_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-14, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Micah Sullivan.\n\n### F-13 — listing-standard notice (critical)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for listing-standard notice: one source states the applicable location is New York Stock Exchange, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to California operations outside New York Stock Exchange.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/037_insider_trading_review_memorandum.json`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/11_debt_covenants/085_debt_covenants_review_memorandum.json`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-14, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Farah Ibrahim.\n\n### F-14 — debt-covenant disclosure (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for debt-covenant disclosure: one source states the threshold is 2% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 8% and produced a different exception result.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/040_insider_trading_status_report.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/11_debt_covenants/088_debt_covenants_status_report.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-14, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Owen Delgado.\n\n### F-15 — officer certification exception (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for officer certification exception: one source states formal notice must use notices-duneworks_software_inc@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-disclosure_committee@example.test.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/06_related_parties/043_related_parties_correspondence.eml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/12_certifications/091_certifications_correspondence.eml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-14, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Lena Varga.\n\n### F-16 — board-matrix inconsistency (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for board-matrix inconsistency: one source states the governed population contains 48 records through 2025-05-23, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 52 records through 2025-06-16.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/06_related_parties/046_related_parties_formal_notice.xml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/12_certifications/094_certifications_formal_notice.xml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-14, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Samuel Kim.\n\n## Recommended next actions\n\nSequence the critical and high findings first, assign the named owners, preserve the cited records, and document any resolution in the controlling matter register before the stated deadline.\n\n## Assumptions and limitations\n\nThis analysis is confined to task cb100-094-duneworks and the supplied synthetic evidence. It does not rely on external facts, does not resolve disputed law, and is not legal advice for a real person or entity.\n", "findings": {"as_of": "2026-09-14", "findings": [{"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/07_equity_compensation/049_equity_compensation_control_register.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for committee-independence gap: one source states the operative date is 2025-04-18 under control reference CB-PC-3304-A805, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2025-05-20 under response reference CB-PC-3304-J915.", "id": "F-01", "issue": "committee-independence gap", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/01_board_committees/001_board_committees_control_register.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-14, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Mei Whitaker.", "severity": "critical"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/07_equity_compensation/052_equity_compensation_ledger_export.csv", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for minutes-approval omission: one source states the controlling amount is $2,818,425.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $2,843,350.00.", "id": "F-02", "issue": "minutes-approval omission", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/01_board_committees/004_board_committees_ledger_export.csv", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-14, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Caleb Hassan.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/07_equity_compensation/055_equity_compensation_officer_certificate.html", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for 8-K deadline: one source states approval is attributed to Dominic Alvarez as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Isaac Romero and contains no entry for Dominic Alvarez.", "id": "F-03", "issue": "8-K deadline", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/01_board_committees/007_board_committees_officer_certificate.html", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-14, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Leona Park.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/08_earnings_guidance/058_earnings_guidance_executed_instrument.txt", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for risk-factor inconsistency: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-PC-3304-D390, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-PC-3304-M468.", "id": "F-04", "issue": "risk-factor inconsistency", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/010_minutes_materials_executed_instrument.txt", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-14, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Isaac Romero.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/08_earnings_guidance/061_earnings_guidance_review_memorandum.json", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for disclosure-control exception: one source states the applicable location is New York Stock Exchange, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to California operations outside New York Stock Exchange.", "id": "F-05", "issue": "disclosure-control exception", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/013_minutes_materials_review_memorandum.json", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-14, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Sofia Bennett.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/08_earnings_guidance/064_earnings_guidance_status_report.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for trading-window violation: one source states the threshold is 13% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 20% and produced a different exception result.", "id": "F-06", "issue": "trading-window violation", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/016_minutes_materials_status_report.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-14, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Adrian Mensah.", "severity": "low"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/09_whistleblower/067_whistleblower_correspondence.eml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for Section 16 filing delay: one source states formal notice must use notices-duneworks_software_inc@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-disclosure_committee@example.test.", "id": "F-07", "issue": "Section 16 filing delay", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/019_sec_filings_correspondence.eml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-14, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Willa Novak.", "severity": "critical"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/09_whistleblower/070_whistleblower_formal_notice.xml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for related-party disclosure gap: one source states the governed population contains 121 records through 2025-03-17, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 42 records through 2025-03-31.", "id": "F-08", "issue": "related-party disclosure gap", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/022_sec_filings_formal_notice.xml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-14, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Theo Laurent.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/10_stock_exchange/073_stock_exchange_control_register.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for equity-plan share mismatch: one source states the operative date is 2025-05-29 under control reference CB-PC-3304-I366, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2025-07-10 under response reference CB-PC-3304-R120.", "id": "F-09", "issue": "equity-plan share mismatch", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/025_disclosure_controls_control_register.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-14, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Amara Patel.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/10_stock_exchange/076_stock_exchange_ledger_export.csv", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for non-GAAP reconciliation issue: one source states the controlling amount is $4,154,814.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $4,426,128.00.", "id": "F-10", "issue": "non-GAAP reconciliation issue", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/028_disclosure_controls_ledger_export.csv", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-14, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Henry Cho.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/10_stock_exchange/079_stock_exchange_officer_certificate.html", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for guidance-control failure: one source states approval is attributed to Dominic Alvarez as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Dominic Alvarez and contains no entry for Dominic Alvarez.", "id": "F-11", "issue": "guidance-control failure", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/031_disclosure_controls_officer_certificate.html", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-14, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Nadine Flores.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/11_debt_covenants/082_debt_covenants_executed_instrument.txt", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for whistleblower escalation delay: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-PC-3304-L347, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-PC-3304-U188.", "id": "F-12", "issue": "whistleblower escalation delay", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/034_insider_trading_executed_instrument.txt", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-14, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Micah Sullivan.", "severity": "low"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/11_debt_covenants/085_debt_covenants_review_memorandum.json", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for listing-standard notice: one source states the applicable location is New York Stock Exchange, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to California operations outside New York Stock Exchange.", "id": "F-13", "issue": "listing-standard notice", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/037_insider_trading_review_memorandum.json", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-14, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Farah Ibrahim.", "severity": "critical"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/11_debt_covenants/088_debt_covenants_status_report.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for debt-covenant disclosure: one source states the threshold is 2% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 8% and produced a different exception result.", "id": "F-14", "issue": "debt-covenant disclosure", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/040_insider_trading_status_report.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-14, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Owen Delgado.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/12_certifications/091_certifications_correspondence.eml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for officer certification exception: one source states formal notice must use notices-duneworks_software_inc@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-disclosure_committee@example.test.", "id": "F-15", "issue": "officer certification exception", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/06_related_parties/043_related_parties_correspondence.eml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-14, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Lena Varga.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/12_certifications/094_certifications_formal_notice.xml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for board-matrix inconsistency: one source states the governed population contains 48 records through 2025-05-23, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 52 records through 2025-06-16.", "id": "F-16", "issue": "board-matrix inconsistency", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/06_related_parties/046_related_parties_formal_notice.xml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-14, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Samuel Kim.", "severity": "medium"}], "matter_number": "CB-PC-3304", "prepared_for": "Duneworks Software, Inc.", "schema_version": "1.0", "task_id": "cb100-094-duneworks"}}, "metadata": {"benchmark": "CounselBench-100", "code_license": "Apache-2.0", "data_license": "CC-BY-4.0", "deadline": "2026-09-14", "document_count": 96, "jurisdiction": "California", "matter_number": "CB-PC-3304", "mcp_commit": "9a96ea6e5913736f92b88345bf51caeaaa8e719f", "mcp_package": "@modelcontextprotocol/server-filesystem@2026.7.10", "practice_area": "public-company", "reference_tool_calls": 46, "required_evidence_reads": 33, "synthetic": true, "venue": "New York Stock Exchange", "version": "2.0.0"}, "prompt": "You are securities and governance counsel for Duneworks Software, Inc. Several workstreams have maintained separate versions of the truth; your assignment is to produce one auditable legal view. Sales adjustments, non-GAAP metrics, guidance drafts, and certification exceptions were tracked differently across finance and legal files. Decision due 2026-09-14. California law governs; New York Stock Exchange is the forum. Distinguish a missing document from an affirmative contradiction in the documents that are present. Work out the defensible position from the matter production and leave an audit-ready exception tracker and concise advice for the supervising lawyer. Keep confirmed conflicts separate from open questions, cite the records that actually control each conclusion, and do not fill gaps with outside facts.", "rubric": {"criteria": [{"category": "procedure", "description": "Complete at least 46 successful, argument-specific evidence and output calls.", "id": "procedure.minimum_successful_tool_calls"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Find and read the 33 controlling, corroborating, and work-product-control records in full.", "id": "procedure.all_evidence_read_in_full"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Inspect file metadata for the eight designated critical primary records before relying on them.", "id": "procedure.chain_of_custody_metadata_checked"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Confirm the sandbox's allowed document and output roots.", "id": "procedure.allowed_directories_checked"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Inventory all 96 records so the relevant sources are discovered among the context records.", "id": "procedure.recursive_inventory_completed"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Search the production for email evidence that may corroborate or contradict formal records.", "id": "procedure.targeted_search_completed"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Leave only findings.json and advice.md in the output workspace.", "id": "procedure.exact_deliverable_set"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Create both final work products through the sandbox MCP surface.", "id": "procedure.deliverables_written_through_mcp"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Produce findings.json as a valid JSON object.", "id": "findings.findings_is_object"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Report exactly 16 confirmed exceptions.", "id": "findings.findings_exact_count"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Use each stable finding ID exactly once.", "id": "findings.finding_ids_unique"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set schema_version to the released matter value '1.0'.", "id": "findings.top_level_schema_version"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set task_id to the released matter value 'cb100-094-duneworks'.", "id": "findings.top_level_task_id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set matter_number to the released matter value 'CB-PC-3304'.", "id": "findings.top_level_matter_number"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set prepared_for to the released matter value 'Duneworks Software, Inc.'.", "id": "findings.top_level_prepared_for"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set as_of to the released matter value '2026-09-14'.", "id": "findings.top_level_as_of"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-01 exception for committee-independence gap.", "id": "findings.F-01.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's id from /workspace/documents/01_board_committees/001_board_committees_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_equity_compensation/049_equity_compensation_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's issue from /workspace/documents/01_board_committees/001_board_committees_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_equity_compensation/049_equity_compensation_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's severity from /workspace/documents/01_board_committees/001_board_committees_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_equity_compensation/049_equity_compensation_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's primary_source from /workspace/documents/01_board_committees/001_board_committees_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_equity_compensation/049_equity_compensation_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/01_board_committees/001_board_committees_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_equity_compensation/049_equity_compensation_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-01 using the exact controlled facts ['2025-04-18', 'CB-PC-3304-A805', '2025-05-20', 'CB-PC-3304-J915'].", "id": "findings.F-01.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-01's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-01.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-14', 'Mei Whitaker'] for F-01.", "id": "findings.F-01.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-02 exception for minutes-approval omission.", "id": "findings.F-02.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's id from /workspace/documents/01_board_committees/004_board_committees_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_equity_compensation/052_equity_compensation_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's issue from /workspace/documents/01_board_committees/004_board_committees_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_equity_compensation/052_equity_compensation_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's severity from /workspace/documents/01_board_committees/004_board_committees_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_equity_compensation/052_equity_compensation_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's primary_source from /workspace/documents/01_board_committees/004_board_committees_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_equity_compensation/052_equity_compensation_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/01_board_committees/004_board_committees_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_equity_compensation/052_equity_compensation_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-02 using the exact controlled facts ['$2,818,425.00', '$2,843,350.00'].", "id": "findings.F-02.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-02's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-02.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-14', 'Caleb Hassan'] for F-02.", "id": "findings.F-02.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-03 exception for 8-K deadline.", "id": "findings.F-03.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's id from /workspace/documents/01_board_committees/007_board_committees_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_equity_compensation/055_equity_compensation_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's issue from /workspace/documents/01_board_committees/007_board_committees_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_equity_compensation/055_equity_compensation_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's severity from /workspace/documents/01_board_committees/007_board_committees_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_equity_compensation/055_equity_compensation_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's primary_source from /workspace/documents/01_board_committees/007_board_committees_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_equity_compensation/055_equity_compensation_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/01_board_committees/007_board_committees_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_equity_compensation/055_equity_compensation_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-03 using the exact controlled facts ['Dominic Alvarez', 'Isaac Romero'].", "id": "findings.F-03.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-03's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-03.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-14', 'Leona Park'] for F-03.", "id": "findings.F-03.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-04 exception for risk-factor inconsistency.", "id": "findings.F-04.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's id from /workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/010_minutes_materials_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_earnings_guidance/058_earnings_guidance_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's issue from /workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/010_minutes_materials_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_earnings_guidance/058_earnings_guidance_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's severity from /workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/010_minutes_materials_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_earnings_guidance/058_earnings_guidance_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's primary_source from /workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/010_minutes_materials_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_earnings_guidance/058_earnings_guidance_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/010_minutes_materials_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_earnings_guidance/058_earnings_guidance_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-04 using the exact controlled facts ['closed without exception', 'CB-PC-3304-D390', 'open and escalated', 'CB-PC-3304-M468'].", "id": "findings.F-04.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-04's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-04.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-14', 'Isaac Romero'] for F-04.", "id": "findings.F-04.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-05 exception for disclosure-control exception.", "id": "findings.F-05.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's id from /workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/013_minutes_materials_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_earnings_guidance/061_earnings_guidance_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's issue from /workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/013_minutes_materials_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_earnings_guidance/061_earnings_guidance_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's severity from /workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/013_minutes_materials_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_earnings_guidance/061_earnings_guidance_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's primary_source from /workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/013_minutes_materials_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_earnings_guidance/061_earnings_guidance_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/013_minutes_materials_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_earnings_guidance/061_earnings_guidance_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-05 using the exact controlled facts ['New York Stock Exchange', 'California'].", "id": "findings.F-05.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-05's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-05.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-14', 'Sofia Bennett'] for F-05.", "id": "findings.F-05.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-06 exception for trading-window violation.", "id": "findings.F-06.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's id from /workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/016_minutes_materials_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_earnings_guidance/064_earnings_guidance_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's issue from /workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/016_minutes_materials_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_earnings_guidance/064_earnings_guidance_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's severity from /workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/016_minutes_materials_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_earnings_guidance/064_earnings_guidance_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's primary_source from /workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/016_minutes_materials_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_earnings_guidance/064_earnings_guidance_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/016_minutes_materials_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_earnings_guidance/064_earnings_guidance_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-06 using the exact controlled facts ['13%', '20%'].", "id": "findings.F-06.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-06's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-06.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-14', 'Adrian Mensah'] for F-06.", "id": "findings.F-06.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-07 exception for Section 16 filing delay.", "id": "findings.F-07.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's id from /workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/019_sec_filings_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_whistleblower/067_whistleblower_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's issue from /workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/019_sec_filings_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_whistleblower/067_whistleblower_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's severity from /workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/019_sec_filings_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_whistleblower/067_whistleblower_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's primary_source from /workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/019_sec_filings_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_whistleblower/067_whistleblower_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/019_sec_filings_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_whistleblower/067_whistleblower_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-07 using the exact controlled facts ['notices-duneworks_software_inc@example.test', 'archive-disclosure_committee@example.test'].", "id": "findings.F-07.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-07's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-07.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-14', 'Willa Novak'] for F-07.", "id": "findings.F-07.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-08 exception for related-party disclosure gap.", "id": "findings.F-08.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's id from /workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/022_sec_filings_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_whistleblower/070_whistleblower_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's issue from /workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/022_sec_filings_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_whistleblower/070_whistleblower_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's severity from /workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/022_sec_filings_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_whistleblower/070_whistleblower_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's primary_source from /workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/022_sec_filings_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_whistleblower/070_whistleblower_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/022_sec_filings_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_whistleblower/070_whistleblower_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-08 using the exact controlled facts ['121 records', '2025-03-17', '42 records', '2025-03-31'].", "id": "findings.F-08.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-08's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-08.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-14', 'Theo Laurent'] for F-08.", "id": "findings.F-08.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-09 exception for equity-plan share mismatch.", "id": "findings.F-09.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's id from /workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/025_disclosure_controls_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_stock_exchange/073_stock_exchange_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's issue from /workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/025_disclosure_controls_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_stock_exchange/073_stock_exchange_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's severity from /workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/025_disclosure_controls_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_stock_exchange/073_stock_exchange_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's primary_source from /workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/025_disclosure_controls_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_stock_exchange/073_stock_exchange_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/025_disclosure_controls_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_stock_exchange/073_stock_exchange_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-09 using the exact controlled facts ['2025-05-29', 'CB-PC-3304-I366', '2025-07-10', 'CB-PC-3304-R120'].", "id": "findings.F-09.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-09's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-09.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-14', 'Amara Patel'] for F-09.", "id": "findings.F-09.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-10 exception for non-GAAP reconciliation issue.", "id": "findings.F-10.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's id from /workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/028_disclosure_controls_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_stock_exchange/076_stock_exchange_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's issue from /workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/028_disclosure_controls_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_stock_exchange/076_stock_exchange_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's severity from /workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/028_disclosure_controls_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_stock_exchange/076_stock_exchange_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's primary_source from /workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/028_disclosure_controls_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_stock_exchange/076_stock_exchange_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/028_disclosure_controls_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_stock_exchange/076_stock_exchange_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-10 using the exact controlled facts ['$4,154,814.00', '$4,426,128.00'].", "id": "findings.F-10.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-10's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-10.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-14', 'Henry Cho'] for F-10.", "id": "findings.F-10.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-11 exception for guidance-control failure.", "id": "findings.F-11.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's id from /workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/031_disclosure_controls_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_stock_exchange/079_stock_exchange_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's issue from /workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/031_disclosure_controls_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_stock_exchange/079_stock_exchange_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's severity from /workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/031_disclosure_controls_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_stock_exchange/079_stock_exchange_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's primary_source from /workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/031_disclosure_controls_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_stock_exchange/079_stock_exchange_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/031_disclosure_controls_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_stock_exchange/079_stock_exchange_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-11 using the exact controlled facts ['Dominic Alvarez', 'Dominic Alvarez'].", "id": "findings.F-11.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-11's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-11.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-14', 'Nadine Flores'] for F-11.", "id": "findings.F-11.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-12 exception for whistleblower escalation delay.", "id": "findings.F-12.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's id from /workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/034_insider_trading_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_debt_covenants/082_debt_covenants_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's issue from /workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/034_insider_trading_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_debt_covenants/082_debt_covenants_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's severity from /workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/034_insider_trading_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_debt_covenants/082_debt_covenants_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's primary_source from /workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/034_insider_trading_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_debt_covenants/082_debt_covenants_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/034_insider_trading_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_debt_covenants/082_debt_covenants_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-12 using the exact controlled facts ['closed without exception', 'CB-PC-3304-L347', 'open and escalated', 'CB-PC-3304-U188'].", "id": "findings.F-12.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-12's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-12.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-14', 'Micah Sullivan'] for F-12.", "id": "findings.F-12.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-13 exception for listing-standard notice.", "id": "findings.F-13.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's id from /workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/037_insider_trading_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_debt_covenants/085_debt_covenants_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's issue from /workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/037_insider_trading_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_debt_covenants/085_debt_covenants_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's severity from /workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/037_insider_trading_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_debt_covenants/085_debt_covenants_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's primary_source from /workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/037_insider_trading_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_debt_covenants/085_debt_covenants_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/037_insider_trading_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_debt_covenants/085_debt_covenants_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-13 using the exact controlled facts ['New York Stock Exchange', 'California'].", "id": "findings.F-13.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-13's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-13.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-14', 'Farah Ibrahim'] for F-13.", "id": "findings.F-13.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-14 exception for debt-covenant disclosure.", "id": "findings.F-14.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's id from /workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/040_insider_trading_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_debt_covenants/088_debt_covenants_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's issue from /workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/040_insider_trading_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_debt_covenants/088_debt_covenants_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's severity from /workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/040_insider_trading_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_debt_covenants/088_debt_covenants_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's primary_source from /workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/040_insider_trading_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_debt_covenants/088_debt_covenants_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/040_insider_trading_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_debt_covenants/088_debt_covenants_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-14 using the exact controlled facts ['2%', '8%'].", "id": "findings.F-14.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-14's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-14.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-14', 'Owen Delgado'] for F-14.", "id": "findings.F-14.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-15 exception for officer certification exception.", "id": "findings.F-15.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's id from /workspace/documents/06_related_parties/043_related_parties_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_certifications/091_certifications_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's issue from /workspace/documents/06_related_parties/043_related_parties_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_certifications/091_certifications_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's severity from /workspace/documents/06_related_parties/043_related_parties_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_certifications/091_certifications_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's primary_source from /workspace/documents/06_related_parties/043_related_parties_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_certifications/091_certifications_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/06_related_parties/043_related_parties_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_certifications/091_certifications_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-15 using the exact controlled facts ['notices-duneworks_software_inc@example.test', 'archive-disclosure_committee@example.test'].", "id": "findings.F-15.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-15's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-15.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-14', 'Lena Varga'] for F-15.", "id": "findings.F-15.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-16 exception for board-matrix inconsistency.", "id": "findings.F-16.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's id from /workspace/documents/06_related_parties/046_related_parties_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_certifications/094_certifications_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's issue from /workspace/documents/06_related_parties/046_related_parties_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_certifications/094_certifications_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's severity from /workspace/documents/06_related_parties/046_related_parties_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_certifications/094_certifications_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's primary_source from /workspace/documents/06_related_parties/046_related_parties_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_certifications/094_certifications_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/06_related_parties/046_related_parties_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_certifications/094_certifications_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-16 using the exact controlled facts ['48 records', '2025-05-23', '52 records', '2025-06-16'].", "id": "findings.F-16.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-16's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-16.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-14', 'Samuel Kim'] for F-16.", "id": "findings.F-16.action_anchors"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Executive assessment' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Executive assessment"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Method and record coverage' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Method and record coverage"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Findings' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Findings"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Recommended next actions' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Recommended next actions"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Assumptions and limitations' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Assumptions and limitations"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-01 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-01"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-02 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-02"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-03 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-03"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-04 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-04"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-05 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-05"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-06 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-06"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-07 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-07"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-08 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-08"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-09 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-09"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-10 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-10"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-11 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-11"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-12 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-12"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-13 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-13"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-14 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-14"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-15 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-15"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-16 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-16"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Do not claim the production has no issues or that every record is consistent.", "id": "memo.forbidden_claims_absent"}], "decision_options": [{"id": "cross-source-reconciliation", "label": "Reconcile controlling and corroborating records", "reason": "The CB-PC-3304 production contains independently maintained records; a defensible answer must preserve each supported conflict and its cure owner.", "selected": true}, {"id": "latest-record-controls", "label": "Treat the latest record as controlling", "reason": "Timestamp recency does not establish legal priority, execution, or approval authority.", "selected": false}, {"id": "primary-records-only", "label": "Report primary records without reconciliation", "reason": "Primary records alone conceal the operational conflicts that create the actionable exceptions.", "selected": false}], "gates": ["all_evidence_read_in_full", "chain_of_custody_metadata_checked", "findings_criteria_complete", "memo_criteria_complete", "deliverables_written_through_mcp"], "metadata_checks": 8, "metric": "weighted_criteria_score", "minimum_tool_calls": 46, "required_deliverables": ["findings.json", "advice.md"], "required_document_reads": 33, "type": "deterministic", "weights": {"findings": 0.55, "memo": 0.2, "procedure": 0.25}}, "task_id": "cb100-094-duneworks", "task_name": "Duneworks earnings-controls audit", "world_id": "counselbench-filesystem-mcp-v2"}
-{"context_files": ["task_files/cb100-095-eastport-shipping/01_board_committees/001_board_committees_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-095-eastport-shipping/01_board_committees/002_board_committees_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-095-eastport-shipping/01_board_committees/003_board_committees_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-095-eastport-shipping/01_board_committees/004_board_committees_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-095-eastport-shipping/01_board_committees/005_board_committees_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-095-eastport-shipping/01_board_committees/006_board_committees_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-095-eastport-shipping/01_board_committees/007_board_committees_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-095-eastport-shipping/01_board_committees/008_board_committees_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-095-eastport-shipping/02_minutes_materials/009_minutes_materials_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-095-eastport-shipping/02_minutes_materials/010_minutes_materials_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-095-eastport-shipping/02_minutes_materials/011_minutes_materials_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-095-eastport-shipping/02_minutes_materials/012_minutes_materials_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-095-eastport-shipping/02_minutes_materials/013_minutes_materials_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-095-eastport-shipping/02_minutes_materials/014_minutes_materials_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-095-eastport-shipping/02_minutes_materials/015_minutes_materials_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-095-eastport-shipping/02_minutes_materials/016_minutes_materials_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-095-eastport-shipping/03_sec_filings/017_sec_filings_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-095-eastport-shipping/03_sec_filings/018_sec_filings_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-095-eastport-shipping/03_sec_filings/019_sec_filings_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-095-eastport-shipping/03_sec_filings/020_sec_filings_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-095-eastport-shipping/03_sec_filings/021_sec_filings_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-095-eastport-shipping/03_sec_filings/022_sec_filings_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-095-eastport-shipping/03_sec_filings/023_sec_filings_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-095-eastport-shipping/03_sec_filings/024_sec_filings_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-095-eastport-shipping/04_disclosure_controls/025_disclosure_controls_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-095-eastport-shipping/04_disclosure_controls/026_disclosure_controls_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-095-eastport-shipping/04_disclosure_controls/027_disclosure_controls_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-095-eastport-shipping/04_disclosure_controls/028_disclosure_controls_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-095-eastport-shipping/04_disclosure_controls/029_disclosure_controls_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-095-eastport-shipping/04_disclosure_controls/030_disclosure_controls_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-095-eastport-shipping/04_disclosure_controls/031_disclosure_controls_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-095-eastport-shipping/04_disclosure_controls/032_disclosure_controls_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-095-eastport-shipping/05_insider_trading/033_insider_trading_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-095-eastport-shipping/05_insider_trading/034_insider_trading_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-095-eastport-shipping/05_insider_trading/035_insider_trading_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-095-eastport-shipping/05_insider_trading/036_insider_trading_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-095-eastport-shipping/05_insider_trading/037_insider_trading_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-095-eastport-shipping/05_insider_trading/038_insider_trading_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-095-eastport-shipping/05_insider_trading/039_insider_trading_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-095-eastport-shipping/05_insider_trading/040_insider_trading_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-095-eastport-shipping/06_related_parties/041_related_parties_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-095-eastport-shipping/06_related_parties/042_related_parties_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-095-eastport-shipping/06_related_parties/043_related_parties_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-095-eastport-shipping/06_related_parties/044_related_parties_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-095-eastport-shipping/06_related_parties/045_related_parties_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-095-eastport-shipping/06_related_parties/046_related_parties_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-095-eastport-shipping/06_related_parties/047_related_parties_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-095-eastport-shipping/06_related_parties/048_related_parties_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-095-eastport-shipping/07_equity_compensation/049_equity_compensation_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-095-eastport-shipping/07_equity_compensation/050_equity_compensation_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-095-eastport-shipping/07_equity_compensation/051_equity_compensation_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-095-eastport-shipping/07_equity_compensation/052_equity_compensation_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-095-eastport-shipping/07_equity_compensation/053_equity_compensation_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-095-eastport-shipping/07_equity_compensation/054_equity_compensation_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-095-eastport-shipping/07_equity_compensation/055_equity_compensation_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-095-eastport-shipping/07_equity_compensation/056_equity_compensation_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-095-eastport-shipping/08_earnings_guidance/057_earnings_guidance_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-095-eastport-shipping/08_earnings_guidance/058_earnings_guidance_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-095-eastport-shipping/08_earnings_guidance/059_earnings_guidance_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-095-eastport-shipping/08_earnings_guidance/060_earnings_guidance_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-095-eastport-shipping/08_earnings_guidance/061_earnings_guidance_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-095-eastport-shipping/08_earnings_guidance/062_earnings_guidance_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-095-eastport-shipping/08_earnings_guidance/063_earnings_guidance_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-095-eastport-shipping/08_earnings_guidance/064_earnings_guidance_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-095-eastport-shipping/09_whistleblower/065_whistleblower_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-095-eastport-shipping/09_whistleblower/066_whistleblower_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-095-eastport-shipping/09_whistleblower/067_whistleblower_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-095-eastport-shipping/09_whistleblower/068_whistleblower_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-095-eastport-shipping/09_whistleblower/069_whistleblower_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-095-eastport-shipping/09_whistleblower/070_whistleblower_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-095-eastport-shipping/09_whistleblower/071_whistleblower_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-095-eastport-shipping/09_whistleblower/072_whistleblower_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-095-eastport-shipping/10_stock_exchange/073_stock_exchange_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-095-eastport-shipping/10_stock_exchange/074_stock_exchange_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-095-eastport-shipping/10_stock_exchange/075_stock_exchange_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-095-eastport-shipping/10_stock_exchange/076_stock_exchange_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-095-eastport-shipping/10_stock_exchange/077_stock_exchange_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-095-eastport-shipping/10_stock_exchange/078_stock_exchange_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-095-eastport-shipping/10_stock_exchange/079_stock_exchange_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-095-eastport-shipping/10_stock_exchange/080_stock_exchange_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-095-eastport-shipping/11_debt_covenants/081_debt_covenants_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-095-eastport-shipping/11_debt_covenants/082_debt_covenants_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-095-eastport-shipping/11_debt_covenants/083_debt_covenants_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-095-eastport-shipping/11_debt_covenants/084_debt_covenants_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-095-eastport-shipping/11_debt_covenants/085_debt_covenants_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-095-eastport-shipping/11_debt_covenants/086_debt_covenants_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-095-eastport-shipping/11_debt_covenants/087_debt_covenants_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-095-eastport-shipping/11_debt_covenants/088_debt_covenants_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-095-eastport-shipping/12_certifications/089_certifications_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-095-eastport-shipping/12_certifications/090_certifications_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-095-eastport-shipping/12_certifications/091_certifications_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-095-eastport-shipping/12_certifications/092_certifications_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-095-eastport-shipping/12_certifications/093_certifications_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-095-eastport-shipping/12_certifications/094_certifications_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-095-eastport-shipping/12_certifications/095_certifications_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-095-eastport-shipping/12_certifications/096_certifications_status_report.md"], "gold_output": {"advice_markdown": "# Counsel advice — Eastport covenant disclosure check\n\n## Executive assessment\n\nFor Eastport Shipping Lines matter CB-PC-3305, the review identified 16 source-supported exceptions requiring action before 2026-09-17. The assessment concerns Bondholder trustee and the supplied record for New York.\n\n## Method and record coverage\n\nThe review inventoried all 96 production files, read the 33 controlling, corroborating, and control records, searched the email exports, and checked metadata for the designated chain-of-custody sample. Conclusions are limited to the synthetic production supplied for this benchmark matter.\n\n## Findings\n\n### F-01 — committee-independence gap (critical)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for committee-independence gap: one source states the operative date is 2025-08-04 under control reference CB-PC-3305-A493, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2025-08-14 under response reference CB-PC-3305-J407.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/01_board_committees/001_board_committees_control_register.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/07_equity_compensation/049_equity_compensation_control_register.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-17, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Caleb Hassan.\n\n### F-02 — minutes-approval omission (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for minutes-approval omission: one source states the controlling amount is $4,033,854.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $4,304,208.00.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/01_board_committees/004_board_committees_ledger_export.csv`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/07_equity_compensation/052_equity_compensation_ledger_export.csv`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-17, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Leona Park.\n\n### F-03 — 8-K deadline (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for 8-K deadline: one source states approval is attributed to Priya Raman as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Adrian Mensah and contains no entry for Priya Raman.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/01_board_committees/007_board_committees_officer_certificate.html`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/07_equity_compensation/055_equity_compensation_officer_certificate.html`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-17, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Isaac Romero.\n\n### F-04 — risk-factor inconsistency (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for risk-factor inconsistency: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-PC-3305-D528, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-PC-3305-M340.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/010_minutes_materials_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/08_earnings_guidance/058_earnings_guidance_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-17, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Sofia Bennett.\n\n### F-05 — disclosure-control exception (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for disclosure-control exception: one source states the applicable location is New York Stock Exchange, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to New York operations outside New York Stock Exchange.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/013_minutes_materials_review_memorandum.json`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/08_earnings_guidance/061_earnings_guidance_review_memorandum.json`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-17, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Adrian Mensah.\n\n### F-06 — trading-window violation (low)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for trading-window violation: one source states the threshold is 4% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 6% and produced a different exception result.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/016_minutes_materials_status_report.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/08_earnings_guidance/064_earnings_guidance_status_report.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-17, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Willa Novak.\n\n### F-07 — Section 16 filing delay (critical)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for Section 16 filing delay: one source states formal notice must use notices-eastport_shipping_lines@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-bondholder_trustee@example.test.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/019_sec_filings_correspondence.eml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/09_whistleblower/067_whistleblower_correspondence.eml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-17, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Theo Laurent.\n\n### F-08 — related-party disclosure gap (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for related-party disclosure gap: one source states the governed population contains 153 records through 2026-01-23, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 53 records through 2026-02-17.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/022_sec_filings_formal_notice.xml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/09_whistleblower/070_whistleblower_formal_notice.xml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-17, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Amara Patel.\n\n### F-09 — equity-plan share mismatch (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for equity-plan share mismatch: one source states the operative date is 2025-10-30 under control reference CB-PC-3305-I940, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2025-11-10 under response reference CB-PC-3305-R303.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/025_disclosure_controls_control_register.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/10_stock_exchange/073_stock_exchange_control_register.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-17, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Henry Cho.\n\n### F-10 — non-GAAP reconciliation issue (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for non-GAAP reconciliation issue: one source states the controlling amount is $4,400,438.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $4,537,376.00.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/028_disclosure_controls_ledger_export.csv`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/10_stock_exchange/076_stock_exchange_ledger_export.csv`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-17, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Nadine Flores.\n\n### F-11 — guidance-control failure (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for guidance-control failure: one source states approval is attributed to Priya Raman as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Elliot Mercer and contains no entry for Priya Raman.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/031_disclosure_controls_officer_certificate.html`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/10_stock_exchange/079_stock_exchange_officer_certificate.html`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-17, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Micah Sullivan.\n\n### F-12 — whistleblower escalation delay (low)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for whistleblower escalation delay: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-PC-3305-L956, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-PC-3305-U165.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/034_insider_trading_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/11_debt_covenants/082_debt_covenants_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-17, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Farah Ibrahim.\n\n### F-13 — listing-standard notice (critical)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for listing-standard notice: one source states the applicable location is New York Stock Exchange, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to New York operations outside New York Stock Exchange.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/037_insider_trading_review_memorandum.json`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/11_debt_covenants/085_debt_covenants_review_memorandum.json`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-17, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Owen Delgado.\n\n### F-14 — debt-covenant disclosure (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for debt-covenant disclosure: one source states the threshold is 14% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 18% and produced a different exception result.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/040_insider_trading_status_report.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/11_debt_covenants/088_debt_covenants_status_report.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-17, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Lena Varga.\n\n### F-15 — officer certification exception (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for officer certification exception: one source states formal notice must use notices-eastport_shipping_lines@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-bondholder_trustee@example.test.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/06_related_parties/043_related_parties_correspondence.eml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/12_certifications/091_certifications_correspondence.eml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-17, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Samuel Kim.\n\n### F-16 — board-matrix inconsistency (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for board-matrix inconsistency: one source states the governed population contains 163 records through 2025-04-28, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 50 records through 2025-05-20.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/06_related_parties/046_related_parties_formal_notice.xml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/12_certifications/094_certifications_formal_notice.xml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-17, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Maya Ellison.\n\n## Recommended next actions\n\nSequence the critical and high findings first, assign the named owners, preserve the cited records, and document any resolution in the controlling matter register before the stated deadline.\n\n## Assumptions and limitations\n\nThis analysis is confined to task cb100-095-eastport-shipping and the supplied synthetic evidence. It does not rely on external facts, does not resolve disputed law, and is not legal advice for a real person or entity.\n", "findings": {"as_of": "2026-09-17", "findings": [{"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/07_equity_compensation/049_equity_compensation_control_register.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for committee-independence gap: one source states the operative date is 2025-08-04 under control reference CB-PC-3305-A493, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2025-08-14 under response reference CB-PC-3305-J407.", "id": "F-01", "issue": "committee-independence gap", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/01_board_committees/001_board_committees_control_register.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-17, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Caleb Hassan.", "severity": "critical"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/07_equity_compensation/052_equity_compensation_ledger_export.csv", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for minutes-approval omission: one source states the controlling amount is $4,033,854.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $4,304,208.00.", "id": "F-02", "issue": "minutes-approval omission", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/01_board_committees/004_board_committees_ledger_export.csv", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-17, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Leona Park.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/07_equity_compensation/055_equity_compensation_officer_certificate.html", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for 8-K deadline: one source states approval is attributed to Priya Raman as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Adrian Mensah and contains no entry for Priya Raman.", "id": "F-03", "issue": "8-K deadline", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/01_board_committees/007_board_committees_officer_certificate.html", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-17, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Isaac Romero.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/08_earnings_guidance/058_earnings_guidance_executed_instrument.txt", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for risk-factor inconsistency: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-PC-3305-D528, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-PC-3305-M340.", "id": "F-04", "issue": "risk-factor inconsistency", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/010_minutes_materials_executed_instrument.txt", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-17, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Sofia Bennett.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/08_earnings_guidance/061_earnings_guidance_review_memorandum.json", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for disclosure-control exception: one source states the applicable location is New York Stock Exchange, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to New York operations outside New York Stock Exchange.", "id": "F-05", "issue": "disclosure-control exception", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/013_minutes_materials_review_memorandum.json", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-17, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Adrian Mensah.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/08_earnings_guidance/064_earnings_guidance_status_report.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for trading-window violation: one source states the threshold is 4% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 6% and produced a different exception result.", "id": "F-06", "issue": "trading-window violation", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/016_minutes_materials_status_report.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-17, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Willa Novak.", "severity": "low"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/09_whistleblower/067_whistleblower_correspondence.eml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for Section 16 filing delay: one source states formal notice must use notices-eastport_shipping_lines@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-bondholder_trustee@example.test.", "id": "F-07", "issue": "Section 16 filing delay", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/019_sec_filings_correspondence.eml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-17, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Theo Laurent.", "severity": "critical"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/09_whistleblower/070_whistleblower_formal_notice.xml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for related-party disclosure gap: one source states the governed population contains 153 records through 2026-01-23, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 53 records through 2026-02-17.", "id": "F-08", "issue": "related-party disclosure gap", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/022_sec_filings_formal_notice.xml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-17, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Amara Patel.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/10_stock_exchange/073_stock_exchange_control_register.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for equity-plan share mismatch: one source states the operative date is 2025-10-30 under control reference CB-PC-3305-I940, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2025-11-10 under response reference CB-PC-3305-R303.", "id": "F-09", "issue": "equity-plan share mismatch", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/025_disclosure_controls_control_register.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-17, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Henry Cho.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/10_stock_exchange/076_stock_exchange_ledger_export.csv", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for non-GAAP reconciliation issue: one source states the controlling amount is $4,400,438.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $4,537,376.00.", "id": "F-10", "issue": "non-GAAP reconciliation issue", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/028_disclosure_controls_ledger_export.csv", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-17, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Nadine Flores.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/10_stock_exchange/079_stock_exchange_officer_certificate.html", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for guidance-control failure: one source states approval is attributed to Priya Raman as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Elliot Mercer and contains no entry for Priya Raman.", "id": "F-11", "issue": "guidance-control failure", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/031_disclosure_controls_officer_certificate.html", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-17, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Micah Sullivan.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/11_debt_covenants/082_debt_covenants_executed_instrument.txt", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for whistleblower escalation delay: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-PC-3305-L956, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-PC-3305-U165.", "id": "F-12", "issue": "whistleblower escalation delay", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/034_insider_trading_executed_instrument.txt", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-17, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Farah Ibrahim.", "severity": "low"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/11_debt_covenants/085_debt_covenants_review_memorandum.json", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for listing-standard notice: one source states the applicable location is New York Stock Exchange, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to New York operations outside New York Stock Exchange.", "id": "F-13", "issue": "listing-standard notice", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/037_insider_trading_review_memorandum.json", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-17, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Owen Delgado.", "severity": "critical"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/11_debt_covenants/088_debt_covenants_status_report.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for debt-covenant disclosure: one source states the threshold is 14% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 18% and produced a different exception result.", "id": "F-14", "issue": "debt-covenant disclosure", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/040_insider_trading_status_report.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-17, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Lena Varga.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/12_certifications/091_certifications_correspondence.eml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for officer certification exception: one source states formal notice must use notices-eastport_shipping_lines@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-bondholder_trustee@example.test.", "id": "F-15", "issue": "officer certification exception", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/06_related_parties/043_related_parties_correspondence.eml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-17, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Samuel Kim.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/12_certifications/094_certifications_formal_notice.xml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for board-matrix inconsistency: one source states the governed population contains 163 records through 2025-04-28, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 50 records through 2025-05-20.", "id": "F-16", "issue": "board-matrix inconsistency", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/06_related_parties/046_related_parties_formal_notice.xml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-17, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Maya Ellison.", "severity": "medium"}], "matter_number": "CB-PC-3305", "prepared_for": "Eastport Shipping Lines", "schema_version": "1.0", "task_id": "cb100-095-eastport-shipping"}}, "metadata": {"benchmark": "CounselBench-100", "code_license": "Apache-2.0", "data_license": "CC-BY-4.0", "deadline": "2026-09-17", "document_count": 96, "jurisdiction": "New York", "matter_number": "CB-PC-3305", "mcp_commit": "9a96ea6e5913736f92b88345bf51caeaaa8e719f", "mcp_package": "@modelcontextprotocol/server-filesystem@2026.7.10", "practice_area": "public-company", "reference_tool_calls": 46, "required_evidence_reads": 33, "synthetic": true, "venue": "New York Stock Exchange", "version": "2.0.0"}, "prompt": "You are securities and governance counsel for Eastport Shipping Lines. Outside counsel inherited this file after turnover on the client team and must validate every operative record before advising. Fleet impairment, covenant calculations, lender notices, and risk-factor drafts use conflicting assumptions and dates. Decision due 2026-09-17. New York law governs; New York Stock Exchange is the forum. Evaluate both legal consequence and the practical owner needed to cure each exception. Work out the defensible position from the matter production and leave an audit-ready exception tracker and concise advice for the supervising lawyer. Keep confirmed conflicts separate from open questions, cite the records that actually control each conclusion, and do not fill gaps with outside facts.", "rubric": {"criteria": [{"category": "procedure", "description": "Complete at least 46 successful, argument-specific evidence and output calls.", "id": "procedure.minimum_successful_tool_calls"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Find and read the 33 controlling, corroborating, and work-product-control records in full.", "id": "procedure.all_evidence_read_in_full"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Inspect file metadata for the eight designated critical primary records before relying on them.", "id": "procedure.chain_of_custody_metadata_checked"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Confirm the sandbox's allowed document and output roots.", "id": "procedure.allowed_directories_checked"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Inventory all 96 records so the relevant sources are discovered among the context records.", "id": "procedure.recursive_inventory_completed"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Search the production for email evidence that may corroborate or contradict formal records.", "id": "procedure.targeted_search_completed"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Leave only findings.json and advice.md in the output workspace.", "id": "procedure.exact_deliverable_set"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Create both final work products through the sandbox MCP surface.", "id": "procedure.deliverables_written_through_mcp"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Produce findings.json as a valid JSON object.", "id": "findings.findings_is_object"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Report exactly 16 confirmed exceptions.", "id": "findings.findings_exact_count"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Use each stable finding ID exactly once.", "id": "findings.finding_ids_unique"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set schema_version to the released matter value '1.0'.", "id": "findings.top_level_schema_version"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set task_id to the released matter value 'cb100-095-eastport-shipping'.", "id": "findings.top_level_task_id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set matter_number to the released matter value 'CB-PC-3305'.", "id": "findings.top_level_matter_number"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set prepared_for to the released matter value 'Eastport Shipping Lines'.", "id": "findings.top_level_prepared_for"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set as_of to the released matter value '2026-09-17'.", "id": "findings.top_level_as_of"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-01 exception for committee-independence gap.", "id": "findings.F-01.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's id from /workspace/documents/01_board_committees/001_board_committees_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_equity_compensation/049_equity_compensation_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's issue from /workspace/documents/01_board_committees/001_board_committees_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_equity_compensation/049_equity_compensation_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's severity from /workspace/documents/01_board_committees/001_board_committees_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_equity_compensation/049_equity_compensation_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's primary_source from /workspace/documents/01_board_committees/001_board_committees_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_equity_compensation/049_equity_compensation_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/01_board_committees/001_board_committees_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_equity_compensation/049_equity_compensation_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-01 using the exact controlled facts ['2025-08-04', 'CB-PC-3305-A493', '2025-08-14', 'CB-PC-3305-J407'].", "id": "findings.F-01.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-01's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-01.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-17', 'Caleb Hassan'] for F-01.", "id": "findings.F-01.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-02 exception for minutes-approval omission.", "id": "findings.F-02.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's id from /workspace/documents/01_board_committees/004_board_committees_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_equity_compensation/052_equity_compensation_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's issue from /workspace/documents/01_board_committees/004_board_committees_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_equity_compensation/052_equity_compensation_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's severity from /workspace/documents/01_board_committees/004_board_committees_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_equity_compensation/052_equity_compensation_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's primary_source from /workspace/documents/01_board_committees/004_board_committees_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_equity_compensation/052_equity_compensation_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/01_board_committees/004_board_committees_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_equity_compensation/052_equity_compensation_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-02 using the exact controlled facts ['$4,033,854.00', '$4,304,208.00'].", "id": "findings.F-02.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-02's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-02.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-17', 'Leona Park'] for F-02.", "id": "findings.F-02.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-03 exception for 8-K deadline.", "id": "findings.F-03.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's id from /workspace/documents/01_board_committees/007_board_committees_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_equity_compensation/055_equity_compensation_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's issue from /workspace/documents/01_board_committees/007_board_committees_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_equity_compensation/055_equity_compensation_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's severity from /workspace/documents/01_board_committees/007_board_committees_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_equity_compensation/055_equity_compensation_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's primary_source from /workspace/documents/01_board_committees/007_board_committees_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_equity_compensation/055_equity_compensation_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/01_board_committees/007_board_committees_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_equity_compensation/055_equity_compensation_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-03 using the exact controlled facts ['Priya Raman', 'Adrian Mensah'].", "id": "findings.F-03.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-03's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-03.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-17', 'Isaac Romero'] for F-03.", "id": "findings.F-03.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-04 exception for risk-factor inconsistency.", "id": "findings.F-04.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's id from /workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/010_minutes_materials_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_earnings_guidance/058_earnings_guidance_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's issue from /workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/010_minutes_materials_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_earnings_guidance/058_earnings_guidance_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's severity from /workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/010_minutes_materials_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_earnings_guidance/058_earnings_guidance_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's primary_source from /workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/010_minutes_materials_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_earnings_guidance/058_earnings_guidance_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/010_minutes_materials_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_earnings_guidance/058_earnings_guidance_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-04 using the exact controlled facts ['closed without exception', 'CB-PC-3305-D528', 'open and escalated', 'CB-PC-3305-M340'].", "id": "findings.F-04.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-04's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-04.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-17', 'Sofia Bennett'] for F-04.", "id": "findings.F-04.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-05 exception for disclosure-control exception.", "id": "findings.F-05.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's id from /workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/013_minutes_materials_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_earnings_guidance/061_earnings_guidance_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's issue from /workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/013_minutes_materials_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_earnings_guidance/061_earnings_guidance_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's severity from /workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/013_minutes_materials_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_earnings_guidance/061_earnings_guidance_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's primary_source from /workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/013_minutes_materials_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_earnings_guidance/061_earnings_guidance_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/013_minutes_materials_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_earnings_guidance/061_earnings_guidance_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-05 using the exact controlled facts ['New York Stock Exchange', 'New York'].", "id": "findings.F-05.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-05's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-05.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-17', 'Adrian Mensah'] for F-05.", "id": "findings.F-05.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-06 exception for trading-window violation.", "id": "findings.F-06.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's id from /workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/016_minutes_materials_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_earnings_guidance/064_earnings_guidance_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's issue from /workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/016_minutes_materials_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_earnings_guidance/064_earnings_guidance_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's severity from /workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/016_minutes_materials_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_earnings_guidance/064_earnings_guidance_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's primary_source from /workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/016_minutes_materials_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_earnings_guidance/064_earnings_guidance_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/016_minutes_materials_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_earnings_guidance/064_earnings_guidance_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-06 using the exact controlled facts ['4%', '6%'].", "id": "findings.F-06.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-06's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-06.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-17', 'Willa Novak'] for F-06.", "id": "findings.F-06.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-07 exception for Section 16 filing delay.", "id": "findings.F-07.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's id from /workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/019_sec_filings_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_whistleblower/067_whistleblower_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's issue from /workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/019_sec_filings_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_whistleblower/067_whistleblower_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's severity from /workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/019_sec_filings_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_whistleblower/067_whistleblower_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's primary_source from /workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/019_sec_filings_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_whistleblower/067_whistleblower_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/019_sec_filings_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_whistleblower/067_whistleblower_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-07 using the exact controlled facts ['notices-eastport_shipping_lines@example.test', 'archive-bondholder_trustee@example.test'].", "id": "findings.F-07.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-07's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-07.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-17', 'Theo Laurent'] for F-07.", "id": "findings.F-07.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-08 exception for related-party disclosure gap.", "id": "findings.F-08.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's id from /workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/022_sec_filings_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_whistleblower/070_whistleblower_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's issue from /workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/022_sec_filings_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_whistleblower/070_whistleblower_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's severity from /workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/022_sec_filings_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_whistleblower/070_whistleblower_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's primary_source from /workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/022_sec_filings_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_whistleblower/070_whistleblower_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/022_sec_filings_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_whistleblower/070_whistleblower_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-08 using the exact controlled facts ['153 records', '2026-01-23', '53 records', '2026-02-17'].", "id": "findings.F-08.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-08's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-08.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-17', 'Amara Patel'] for F-08.", "id": "findings.F-08.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-09 exception for equity-plan share mismatch.", "id": "findings.F-09.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's id from /workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/025_disclosure_controls_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_stock_exchange/073_stock_exchange_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's issue from /workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/025_disclosure_controls_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_stock_exchange/073_stock_exchange_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's severity from /workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/025_disclosure_controls_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_stock_exchange/073_stock_exchange_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's primary_source from /workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/025_disclosure_controls_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_stock_exchange/073_stock_exchange_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/025_disclosure_controls_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_stock_exchange/073_stock_exchange_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-09 using the exact controlled facts ['2025-10-30', 'CB-PC-3305-I940', '2025-11-10', 'CB-PC-3305-R303'].", "id": "findings.F-09.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-09's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-09.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-17', 'Henry Cho'] for F-09.", "id": "findings.F-09.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-10 exception for non-GAAP reconciliation issue.", "id": "findings.F-10.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's id from /workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/028_disclosure_controls_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_stock_exchange/076_stock_exchange_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's issue from /workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/028_disclosure_controls_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_stock_exchange/076_stock_exchange_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's severity from /workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/028_disclosure_controls_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_stock_exchange/076_stock_exchange_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's primary_source from /workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/028_disclosure_controls_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_stock_exchange/076_stock_exchange_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/028_disclosure_controls_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_stock_exchange/076_stock_exchange_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-10 using the exact controlled facts ['$4,400,438.00', '$4,537,376.00'].", "id": "findings.F-10.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-10's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-10.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-17', 'Nadine Flores'] for F-10.", "id": "findings.F-10.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-11 exception for guidance-control failure.", "id": "findings.F-11.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's id from /workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/031_disclosure_controls_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_stock_exchange/079_stock_exchange_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's issue from /workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/031_disclosure_controls_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_stock_exchange/079_stock_exchange_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's severity from /workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/031_disclosure_controls_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_stock_exchange/079_stock_exchange_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's primary_source from /workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/031_disclosure_controls_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_stock_exchange/079_stock_exchange_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/031_disclosure_controls_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_stock_exchange/079_stock_exchange_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-11 using the exact controlled facts ['Priya Raman', 'Elliot Mercer'].", "id": "findings.F-11.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-11's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-11.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-17', 'Micah Sullivan'] for F-11.", "id": "findings.F-11.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-12 exception for whistleblower escalation delay.", "id": "findings.F-12.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's id from /workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/034_insider_trading_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_debt_covenants/082_debt_covenants_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's issue from /workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/034_insider_trading_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_debt_covenants/082_debt_covenants_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's severity from /workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/034_insider_trading_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_debt_covenants/082_debt_covenants_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's primary_source from /workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/034_insider_trading_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_debt_covenants/082_debt_covenants_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/034_insider_trading_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_debt_covenants/082_debt_covenants_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-12 using the exact controlled facts ['closed without exception', 'CB-PC-3305-L956', 'open and escalated', 'CB-PC-3305-U165'].", "id": "findings.F-12.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-12's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-12.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-17', 'Farah Ibrahim'] for F-12.", "id": "findings.F-12.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-13 exception for listing-standard notice.", "id": "findings.F-13.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's id from /workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/037_insider_trading_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_debt_covenants/085_debt_covenants_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's issue from /workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/037_insider_trading_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_debt_covenants/085_debt_covenants_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's severity from /workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/037_insider_trading_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_debt_covenants/085_debt_covenants_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's primary_source from /workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/037_insider_trading_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_debt_covenants/085_debt_covenants_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/037_insider_trading_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_debt_covenants/085_debt_covenants_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-13 using the exact controlled facts ['New York Stock Exchange', 'New York'].", "id": "findings.F-13.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-13's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-13.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-17', 'Owen Delgado'] for F-13.", "id": "findings.F-13.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-14 exception for debt-covenant disclosure.", "id": "findings.F-14.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's id from /workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/040_insider_trading_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_debt_covenants/088_debt_covenants_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's issue from /workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/040_insider_trading_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_debt_covenants/088_debt_covenants_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's severity from /workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/040_insider_trading_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_debt_covenants/088_debt_covenants_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's primary_source from /workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/040_insider_trading_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_debt_covenants/088_debt_covenants_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/040_insider_trading_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_debt_covenants/088_debt_covenants_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-14 using the exact controlled facts ['14%', '18%'].", "id": "findings.F-14.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-14's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-14.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-17', 'Lena Varga'] for F-14.", "id": "findings.F-14.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-15 exception for officer certification exception.", "id": "findings.F-15.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's id from /workspace/documents/06_related_parties/043_related_parties_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_certifications/091_certifications_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's issue from /workspace/documents/06_related_parties/043_related_parties_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_certifications/091_certifications_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's severity from /workspace/documents/06_related_parties/043_related_parties_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_certifications/091_certifications_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's primary_source from /workspace/documents/06_related_parties/043_related_parties_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_certifications/091_certifications_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/06_related_parties/043_related_parties_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_certifications/091_certifications_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-15 using the exact controlled facts ['notices-eastport_shipping_lines@example.test', 'archive-bondholder_trustee@example.test'].", "id": "findings.F-15.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-15's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-15.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-17', 'Samuel Kim'] for F-15.", "id": "findings.F-15.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-16 exception for board-matrix inconsistency.", "id": "findings.F-16.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's id from /workspace/documents/06_related_parties/046_related_parties_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_certifications/094_certifications_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's issue from /workspace/documents/06_related_parties/046_related_parties_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_certifications/094_certifications_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's severity from /workspace/documents/06_related_parties/046_related_parties_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_certifications/094_certifications_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's primary_source from /workspace/documents/06_related_parties/046_related_parties_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_certifications/094_certifications_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/06_related_parties/046_related_parties_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_certifications/094_certifications_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-16 using the exact controlled facts ['163 records', '2025-04-28', '50 records', '2025-05-20'].", "id": "findings.F-16.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-16's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-16.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-17', 'Maya Ellison'] for F-16.", "id": "findings.F-16.action_anchors"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Executive assessment' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Executive assessment"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Method and record coverage' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Method and record coverage"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Findings' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Findings"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Recommended next actions' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Recommended next actions"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Assumptions and limitations' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Assumptions and limitations"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-01 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-01"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-02 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-02"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-03 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-03"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-04 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-04"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-05 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-05"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-06 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-06"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-07 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-07"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-08 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-08"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-09 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-09"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-10 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-10"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-11 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-11"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-12 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-12"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-13 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-13"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-14 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-14"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-15 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-15"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-16 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-16"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Do not claim the production has no issues or that every record is consistent.", "id": "memo.forbidden_claims_absent"}], "decision_options": [{"id": "cross-source-reconciliation", "label": "Reconcile controlling and corroborating records", "reason": "The CB-PC-3305 production contains independently maintained records; a defensible answer must preserve each supported conflict and its cure owner.", "selected": true}, {"id": "latest-record-controls", "label": "Treat the latest record as controlling", "reason": "Timestamp recency does not establish legal priority, execution, or approval authority.", "selected": false}, {"id": "primary-records-only", "label": "Report primary records without reconciliation", "reason": "Primary records alone conceal the operational conflicts that create the actionable exceptions.", "selected": false}], "gates": ["all_evidence_read_in_full", "chain_of_custody_metadata_checked", "findings_criteria_complete", "memo_criteria_complete", "deliverables_written_through_mcp"], "metadata_checks": 8, "metric": "weighted_criteria_score", "minimum_tool_calls": 46, "required_deliverables": ["findings.json", "advice.md"], "required_document_reads": 33, "type": "deterministic", "weights": {"findings": 0.55, "memo": 0.2, "procedure": 0.25}}, "task_id": "cb100-095-eastport-shipping", "task_name": "Eastport covenant disclosure check", "world_id": "counselbench-filesystem-mcp-v2"}
-{"context_files": ["task_files/cb100-096-fieldstone-foods/01_board_committees/001_board_committees_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-096-fieldstone-foods/01_board_committees/002_board_committees_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-096-fieldstone-foods/01_board_committees/003_board_committees_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-096-fieldstone-foods/01_board_committees/004_board_committees_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-096-fieldstone-foods/01_board_committees/005_board_committees_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-096-fieldstone-foods/01_board_committees/006_board_committees_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-096-fieldstone-foods/01_board_committees/007_board_committees_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-096-fieldstone-foods/01_board_committees/008_board_committees_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-096-fieldstone-foods/02_minutes_materials/009_minutes_materials_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-096-fieldstone-foods/02_minutes_materials/010_minutes_materials_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-096-fieldstone-foods/02_minutes_materials/011_minutes_materials_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-096-fieldstone-foods/02_minutes_materials/012_minutes_materials_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-096-fieldstone-foods/02_minutes_materials/013_minutes_materials_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-096-fieldstone-foods/02_minutes_materials/014_minutes_materials_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-096-fieldstone-foods/02_minutes_materials/015_minutes_materials_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-096-fieldstone-foods/02_minutes_materials/016_minutes_materials_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-096-fieldstone-foods/03_sec_filings/017_sec_filings_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-096-fieldstone-foods/03_sec_filings/018_sec_filings_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-096-fieldstone-foods/03_sec_filings/019_sec_filings_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-096-fieldstone-foods/03_sec_filings/020_sec_filings_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-096-fieldstone-foods/03_sec_filings/021_sec_filings_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-096-fieldstone-foods/03_sec_filings/022_sec_filings_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-096-fieldstone-foods/03_sec_filings/023_sec_filings_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-096-fieldstone-foods/03_sec_filings/024_sec_filings_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-096-fieldstone-foods/04_disclosure_controls/025_disclosure_controls_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-096-fieldstone-foods/04_disclosure_controls/026_disclosure_controls_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-096-fieldstone-foods/04_disclosure_controls/027_disclosure_controls_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-096-fieldstone-foods/04_disclosure_controls/028_disclosure_controls_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-096-fieldstone-foods/04_disclosure_controls/029_disclosure_controls_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-096-fieldstone-foods/04_disclosure_controls/030_disclosure_controls_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-096-fieldstone-foods/04_disclosure_controls/031_disclosure_controls_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-096-fieldstone-foods/04_disclosure_controls/032_disclosure_controls_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-096-fieldstone-foods/05_insider_trading/033_insider_trading_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-096-fieldstone-foods/05_insider_trading/034_insider_trading_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-096-fieldstone-foods/05_insider_trading/035_insider_trading_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-096-fieldstone-foods/05_insider_trading/036_insider_trading_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-096-fieldstone-foods/05_insider_trading/037_insider_trading_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-096-fieldstone-foods/05_insider_trading/038_insider_trading_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-096-fieldstone-foods/05_insider_trading/039_insider_trading_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-096-fieldstone-foods/05_insider_trading/040_insider_trading_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-096-fieldstone-foods/06_related_parties/041_related_parties_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-096-fieldstone-foods/06_related_parties/042_related_parties_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-096-fieldstone-foods/06_related_parties/043_related_parties_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-096-fieldstone-foods/06_related_parties/044_related_parties_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-096-fieldstone-foods/06_related_parties/045_related_parties_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-096-fieldstone-foods/06_related_parties/046_related_parties_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-096-fieldstone-foods/06_related_parties/047_related_parties_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-096-fieldstone-foods/06_related_parties/048_related_parties_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-096-fieldstone-foods/07_equity_compensation/049_equity_compensation_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-096-fieldstone-foods/07_equity_compensation/050_equity_compensation_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-096-fieldstone-foods/07_equity_compensation/051_equity_compensation_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-096-fieldstone-foods/07_equity_compensation/052_equity_compensation_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-096-fieldstone-foods/07_equity_compensation/053_equity_compensation_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-096-fieldstone-foods/07_equity_compensation/054_equity_compensation_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-096-fieldstone-foods/07_equity_compensation/055_equity_compensation_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-096-fieldstone-foods/07_equity_compensation/056_equity_compensation_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-096-fieldstone-foods/08_earnings_guidance/057_earnings_guidance_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-096-fieldstone-foods/08_earnings_guidance/058_earnings_guidance_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-096-fieldstone-foods/08_earnings_guidance/059_earnings_guidance_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-096-fieldstone-foods/08_earnings_guidance/060_earnings_guidance_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-096-fieldstone-foods/08_earnings_guidance/061_earnings_guidance_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-096-fieldstone-foods/08_earnings_guidance/062_earnings_guidance_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-096-fieldstone-foods/08_earnings_guidance/063_earnings_guidance_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-096-fieldstone-foods/08_earnings_guidance/064_earnings_guidance_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-096-fieldstone-foods/09_whistleblower/065_whistleblower_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-096-fieldstone-foods/09_whistleblower/066_whistleblower_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-096-fieldstone-foods/09_whistleblower/067_whistleblower_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-096-fieldstone-foods/09_whistleblower/068_whistleblower_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-096-fieldstone-foods/09_whistleblower/069_whistleblower_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-096-fieldstone-foods/09_whistleblower/070_whistleblower_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-096-fieldstone-foods/09_whistleblower/071_whistleblower_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-096-fieldstone-foods/09_whistleblower/072_whistleblower_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-096-fieldstone-foods/10_stock_exchange/073_stock_exchange_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-096-fieldstone-foods/10_stock_exchange/074_stock_exchange_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-096-fieldstone-foods/10_stock_exchange/075_stock_exchange_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-096-fieldstone-foods/10_stock_exchange/076_stock_exchange_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-096-fieldstone-foods/10_stock_exchange/077_stock_exchange_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-096-fieldstone-foods/10_stock_exchange/078_stock_exchange_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-096-fieldstone-foods/10_stock_exchange/079_stock_exchange_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-096-fieldstone-foods/10_stock_exchange/080_stock_exchange_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-096-fieldstone-foods/11_debt_covenants/081_debt_covenants_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-096-fieldstone-foods/11_debt_covenants/082_debt_covenants_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-096-fieldstone-foods/11_debt_covenants/083_debt_covenants_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-096-fieldstone-foods/11_debt_covenants/084_debt_covenants_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-096-fieldstone-foods/11_debt_covenants/085_debt_covenants_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-096-fieldstone-foods/11_debt_covenants/086_debt_covenants_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-096-fieldstone-foods/11_debt_covenants/087_debt_covenants_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-096-fieldstone-foods/11_debt_covenants/088_debt_covenants_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-096-fieldstone-foods/12_certifications/089_certifications_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-096-fieldstone-foods/12_certifications/090_certifications_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-096-fieldstone-foods/12_certifications/091_certifications_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-096-fieldstone-foods/12_certifications/092_certifications_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-096-fieldstone-foods/12_certifications/093_certifications_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-096-fieldstone-foods/12_certifications/094_certifications_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-096-fieldstone-foods/12_certifications/095_certifications_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-096-fieldstone-foods/12_certifications/096_certifications_status_report.md"], "gold_output": {"advice_markdown": "# Counsel advice — Fieldstone whistleblower escalation audit\n\n## Executive assessment\n\nFor Fieldstone Foods plc matter CB-PC-3306, the review identified 16 source-supported exceptions requiring action before 2026-09-21. The assessment concerns Audit Committee and the supplied record for Illinois.\n\n## Method and record coverage\n\nThe review inventoried all 96 production files, read the 33 controlling, corroborating, and control records, searched the email exports, and checked metadata for the designated chain-of-custody sample. Conclusions are limited to the synthetic production supplied for this benchmark matter.\n\n## Findings\n\n### F-01 — committee-independence gap (critical)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for committee-independence gap: one source states the operative date is 2025-06-23 under control reference CB-PC-3306-A331, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2025-07-09 under response reference CB-PC-3306-J256.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/01_board_committees/001_board_committees_control_register.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/07_equity_compensation/049_equity_compensation_control_register.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-21, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Leona Park.\n\n### F-02 — minutes-approval omission (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for minutes-approval omission: one source states the controlling amount is $3,407,247.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $3,460,994.00.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/01_board_committees/004_board_committees_ledger_export.csv`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/07_equity_compensation/052_equity_compensation_ledger_export.csv`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-21, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Isaac Romero.\n\n### F-03 — 8-K deadline (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for 8-K deadline: one source states approval is attributed to Elliot Mercer as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Theo Laurent and contains no entry for Elliot Mercer.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/01_board_committees/007_board_committees_officer_certificate.html`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/07_equity_compensation/055_equity_compensation_officer_certificate.html`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-21, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Sofia Bennett.\n\n### F-04 — risk-factor inconsistency (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for risk-factor inconsistency: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-PC-3306-D689, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-PC-3306-M906.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/010_minutes_materials_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/08_earnings_guidance/058_earnings_guidance_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-21, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Adrian Mensah.\n\n### F-05 — disclosure-control exception (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for disclosure-control exception: one source states the applicable location is Nasdaq Stock Market, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to Illinois operations outside Nasdaq Stock Market.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/013_minutes_materials_review_memorandum.json`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/08_earnings_guidance/061_earnings_guidance_review_memorandum.json`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-21, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Willa Novak.\n\n### F-06 — trading-window violation (low)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for trading-window violation: one source states the threshold is 7% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 14% and produced a different exception result.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/016_minutes_materials_status_report.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/08_earnings_guidance/064_earnings_guidance_status_report.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-21, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Theo Laurent.\n\n### F-07 — Section 16 filing delay (critical)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for Section 16 filing delay: one source states formal notice must use notices-fieldstone_foods_plc@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-audit_committee@example.test.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/019_sec_filings_correspondence.eml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/09_whistleblower/067_whistleblower_correspondence.eml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-21, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Amara Patel.\n\n### F-08 — related-party disclosure gap (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for related-party disclosure gap: one source states the governed population contains 130 records through 2025-03-26, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 44 records through 2025-04-11.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/022_sec_filings_formal_notice.xml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/09_whistleblower/070_whistleblower_formal_notice.xml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-21, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Henry Cho.\n\n### F-09 — equity-plan share mismatch (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for equity-plan share mismatch: one source states the operative date is 2025-12-28 under control reference CB-PC-3306-I579, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2026-02-07 under response reference CB-PC-3306-R344.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/025_disclosure_controls_control_register.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/10_stock_exchange/073_stock_exchange_control_register.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-21, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Nadine Flores.\n\n### F-10 — non-GAAP reconciliation issue (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for non-GAAP reconciliation issue: one source states the controlling amount is $4,854,355.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $5,055,210.00.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/028_disclosure_controls_ledger_export.csv`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/10_stock_exchange/076_stock_exchange_ledger_export.csv`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-21, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Micah Sullivan.\n\n### F-11 — guidance-control failure (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for guidance-control failure: one source states approval is attributed to Elliot Mercer as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Jonas Feld and contains no entry for Elliot Mercer.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/031_disclosure_controls_officer_certificate.html`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/10_stock_exchange/079_stock_exchange_officer_certificate.html`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-21, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Farah Ibrahim.\n\n### F-12 — whistleblower escalation delay (low)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for whistleblower escalation delay: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-PC-3306-L974, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-PC-3306-U513.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/034_insider_trading_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/11_debt_covenants/082_debt_covenants_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-21, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Owen Delgado.\n\n### F-13 — listing-standard notice (critical)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for listing-standard notice: one source states the applicable location is Nasdaq Stock Market, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to Illinois operations outside Nasdaq Stock Market.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/037_insider_trading_review_memorandum.json`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/11_debt_covenants/085_debt_covenants_review_memorandum.json`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-21, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Lena Varga.\n\n### F-14 — debt-covenant disclosure (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for debt-covenant disclosure: one source states the threshold is 5% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 8% and produced a different exception result.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/040_insider_trading_status_report.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/11_debt_covenants/088_debt_covenants_status_report.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-21, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Samuel Kim.\n\n### F-15 — officer certification exception (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for officer certification exception: one source states formal notice must use notices-fieldstone_foods_plc@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-audit_committee@example.test.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/06_related_parties/043_related_parties_correspondence.eml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/12_certifications/091_certifications_correspondence.eml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-21, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Maya Ellison.\n\n### F-16 — board-matrix inconsistency (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for board-matrix inconsistency: one source states the governed population contains 140 records through 2025-04-05, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 40 records through 2025-04-17.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/06_related_parties/046_related_parties_formal_notice.xml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/12_certifications/094_certifications_formal_notice.xml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-21, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Rafael Okafor.\n\n## Recommended next actions\n\nSequence the critical and high findings first, assign the named owners, preserve the cited records, and document any resolution in the controlling matter register before the stated deadline.\n\n## Assumptions and limitations\n\nThis analysis is confined to task cb100-096-fieldstone-foods and the supplied synthetic evidence. It does not rely on external facts, does not resolve disputed law, and is not legal advice for a real person or entity.\n", "findings": {"as_of": "2026-09-21", "findings": [{"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/07_equity_compensation/049_equity_compensation_control_register.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for committee-independence gap: one source states the operative date is 2025-06-23 under control reference CB-PC-3306-A331, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2025-07-09 under response reference CB-PC-3306-J256.", "id": "F-01", "issue": "committee-independence gap", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/01_board_committees/001_board_committees_control_register.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-21, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Leona Park.", "severity": "critical"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/07_equity_compensation/052_equity_compensation_ledger_export.csv", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for minutes-approval omission: one source states the controlling amount is $3,407,247.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $3,460,994.00.", "id": "F-02", "issue": "minutes-approval omission", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/01_board_committees/004_board_committees_ledger_export.csv", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-21, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Isaac Romero.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/07_equity_compensation/055_equity_compensation_officer_certificate.html", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for 8-K deadline: one source states approval is attributed to Elliot Mercer as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Theo Laurent and contains no entry for Elliot Mercer.", "id": "F-03", "issue": "8-K deadline", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/01_board_committees/007_board_committees_officer_certificate.html", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-21, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Sofia Bennett.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/08_earnings_guidance/058_earnings_guidance_executed_instrument.txt", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for risk-factor inconsistency: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-PC-3306-D689, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-PC-3306-M906.", "id": "F-04", "issue": "risk-factor inconsistency", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/010_minutes_materials_executed_instrument.txt", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-21, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Adrian Mensah.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/08_earnings_guidance/061_earnings_guidance_review_memorandum.json", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for disclosure-control exception: one source states the applicable location is Nasdaq Stock Market, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to Illinois operations outside Nasdaq Stock Market.", "id": "F-05", "issue": "disclosure-control exception", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/013_minutes_materials_review_memorandum.json", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-21, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Willa Novak.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/08_earnings_guidance/064_earnings_guidance_status_report.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for trading-window violation: one source states the threshold is 7% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 14% and produced a different exception result.", "id": "F-06", "issue": "trading-window violation", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/016_minutes_materials_status_report.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-21, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Theo Laurent.", "severity": "low"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/09_whistleblower/067_whistleblower_correspondence.eml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for Section 16 filing delay: one source states formal notice must use notices-fieldstone_foods_plc@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-audit_committee@example.test.", "id": "F-07", "issue": "Section 16 filing delay", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/019_sec_filings_correspondence.eml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-21, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Amara Patel.", "severity": "critical"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/09_whistleblower/070_whistleblower_formal_notice.xml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for related-party disclosure gap: one source states the governed population contains 130 records through 2025-03-26, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 44 records through 2025-04-11.", "id": "F-08", "issue": "related-party disclosure gap", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/022_sec_filings_formal_notice.xml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-21, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Henry Cho.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/10_stock_exchange/073_stock_exchange_control_register.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for equity-plan share mismatch: one source states the operative date is 2025-12-28 under control reference CB-PC-3306-I579, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2026-02-07 under response reference CB-PC-3306-R344.", "id": "F-09", "issue": "equity-plan share mismatch", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/025_disclosure_controls_control_register.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-21, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Nadine Flores.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/10_stock_exchange/076_stock_exchange_ledger_export.csv", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for non-GAAP reconciliation issue: one source states the controlling amount is $4,854,355.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $5,055,210.00.", "id": "F-10", "issue": "non-GAAP reconciliation issue", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/028_disclosure_controls_ledger_export.csv", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-21, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Micah Sullivan.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/10_stock_exchange/079_stock_exchange_officer_certificate.html", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for guidance-control failure: one source states approval is attributed to Elliot Mercer as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Jonas Feld and contains no entry for Elliot Mercer.", "id": "F-11", "issue": "guidance-control failure", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/031_disclosure_controls_officer_certificate.html", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-21, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Farah Ibrahim.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/11_debt_covenants/082_debt_covenants_executed_instrument.txt", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for whistleblower escalation delay: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-PC-3306-L974, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-PC-3306-U513.", "id": "F-12", "issue": "whistleblower escalation delay", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/034_insider_trading_executed_instrument.txt", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-21, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Owen Delgado.", "severity": "low"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/11_debt_covenants/085_debt_covenants_review_memorandum.json", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for listing-standard notice: one source states the applicable location is Nasdaq Stock Market, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to Illinois operations outside Nasdaq Stock Market.", "id": "F-13", "issue": "listing-standard notice", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/037_insider_trading_review_memorandum.json", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-21, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Lena Varga.", "severity": "critical"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/11_debt_covenants/088_debt_covenants_status_report.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for debt-covenant disclosure: one source states the threshold is 5% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 8% and produced a different exception result.", "id": "F-14", "issue": "debt-covenant disclosure", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/040_insider_trading_status_report.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-21, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Samuel Kim.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/12_certifications/091_certifications_correspondence.eml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for officer certification exception: one source states formal notice must use notices-fieldstone_foods_plc@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-audit_committee@example.test.", "id": "F-15", "issue": "officer certification exception", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/06_related_parties/043_related_parties_correspondence.eml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-21, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Maya Ellison.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/12_certifications/094_certifications_formal_notice.xml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for board-matrix inconsistency: one source states the governed population contains 140 records through 2025-04-05, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 40 records through 2025-04-17.", "id": "F-16", "issue": "board-matrix inconsistency", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/06_related_parties/046_related_parties_formal_notice.xml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-21, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Rafael Okafor.", "severity": "medium"}], "matter_number": "CB-PC-3306", "prepared_for": "Fieldstone Foods plc", "schema_version": "1.0", "task_id": "cb100-096-fieldstone-foods"}}, "metadata": {"benchmark": "CounselBench-100", "code_license": "Apache-2.0", "data_license": "CC-BY-4.0", "deadline": "2026-09-21", "document_count": 96, "jurisdiction": "Illinois", "matter_number": "CB-PC-3306", "mcp_commit": "9a96ea6e5913736f92b88345bf51caeaaa8e719f", "mcp_package": "@modelcontextprotocol/server-filesystem@2026.7.10", "practice_area": "public-company", "reference_tool_calls": 46, "required_evidence_reads": 33, "synthetic": true, "venue": "Nasdaq Stock Market", "version": "2.0.0"}, "prompt": "You are securities and governance counsel for Fieldstone Foods plc. The upcoming deadline leaves no room for unsupported assumptions, so every conclusion must trace to the supplied production. A revenue-recognition complaint reached management, the hotline vendor, and directors on different timelines before an earnings release. Decision due 2026-09-21. Illinois law governs; Nasdaq Stock Market is the forum. Give controlling documents precedence only when the record supports that hierarchy. Work out the defensible position from the matter production and leave an audit-ready exception tracker and concise advice for the supervising lawyer. Keep confirmed conflicts separate from open questions, cite the records that actually control each conclusion, and do not fill gaps with outside facts.", "rubric": {"criteria": [{"category": "procedure", "description": "Complete at least 46 successful, argument-specific evidence and output calls.", "id": "procedure.minimum_successful_tool_calls"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Find and read the 33 controlling, corroborating, and work-product-control records in full.", "id": "procedure.all_evidence_read_in_full"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Inspect file metadata for the eight designated critical primary records before relying on them.", "id": "procedure.chain_of_custody_metadata_checked"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Confirm the sandbox's allowed document and output roots.", "id": "procedure.allowed_directories_checked"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Inventory all 96 records so the relevant sources are discovered among the context records.", "id": "procedure.recursive_inventory_completed"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Search the production for email evidence that may corroborate or contradict formal records.", "id": "procedure.targeted_search_completed"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Leave only findings.json and advice.md in the output workspace.", "id": "procedure.exact_deliverable_set"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Create both final work products through the sandbox MCP surface.", "id": "procedure.deliverables_written_through_mcp"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Produce findings.json as a valid JSON object.", "id": "findings.findings_is_object"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Report exactly 16 confirmed exceptions.", "id": "findings.findings_exact_count"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Use each stable finding ID exactly once.", "id": "findings.finding_ids_unique"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set schema_version to the released matter value '1.0'.", "id": "findings.top_level_schema_version"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set task_id to the released matter value 'cb100-096-fieldstone-foods'.", "id": "findings.top_level_task_id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set matter_number to the released matter value 'CB-PC-3306'.", "id": "findings.top_level_matter_number"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set prepared_for to the released matter value 'Fieldstone Foods plc'.", "id": "findings.top_level_prepared_for"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set as_of to the released matter value '2026-09-21'.", "id": "findings.top_level_as_of"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-01 exception for committee-independence gap.", "id": "findings.F-01.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's id from /workspace/documents/01_board_committees/001_board_committees_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_equity_compensation/049_equity_compensation_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's issue from /workspace/documents/01_board_committees/001_board_committees_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_equity_compensation/049_equity_compensation_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's severity from /workspace/documents/01_board_committees/001_board_committees_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_equity_compensation/049_equity_compensation_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's primary_source from /workspace/documents/01_board_committees/001_board_committees_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_equity_compensation/049_equity_compensation_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/01_board_committees/001_board_committees_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_equity_compensation/049_equity_compensation_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-01 using the exact controlled facts ['2025-06-23', 'CB-PC-3306-A331', '2025-07-09', 'CB-PC-3306-J256'].", "id": "findings.F-01.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-01's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-01.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-21', 'Leona Park'] for F-01.", "id": "findings.F-01.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-02 exception for minutes-approval omission.", "id": "findings.F-02.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's id from /workspace/documents/01_board_committees/004_board_committees_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_equity_compensation/052_equity_compensation_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's issue from /workspace/documents/01_board_committees/004_board_committees_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_equity_compensation/052_equity_compensation_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's severity from /workspace/documents/01_board_committees/004_board_committees_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_equity_compensation/052_equity_compensation_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's primary_source from /workspace/documents/01_board_committees/004_board_committees_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_equity_compensation/052_equity_compensation_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/01_board_committees/004_board_committees_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_equity_compensation/052_equity_compensation_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-02 using the exact controlled facts ['$3,407,247.00', '$3,460,994.00'].", "id": "findings.F-02.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-02's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-02.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-21', 'Isaac Romero'] for F-02.", "id": "findings.F-02.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-03 exception for 8-K deadline.", "id": "findings.F-03.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's id from /workspace/documents/01_board_committees/007_board_committees_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_equity_compensation/055_equity_compensation_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's issue from /workspace/documents/01_board_committees/007_board_committees_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_equity_compensation/055_equity_compensation_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's severity from /workspace/documents/01_board_committees/007_board_committees_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_equity_compensation/055_equity_compensation_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's primary_source from /workspace/documents/01_board_committees/007_board_committees_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_equity_compensation/055_equity_compensation_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/01_board_committees/007_board_committees_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_equity_compensation/055_equity_compensation_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-03 using the exact controlled facts ['Elliot Mercer', 'Theo Laurent'].", "id": "findings.F-03.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-03's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-03.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-21', 'Sofia Bennett'] for F-03.", "id": "findings.F-03.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-04 exception for risk-factor inconsistency.", "id": "findings.F-04.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's id from /workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/010_minutes_materials_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_earnings_guidance/058_earnings_guidance_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's issue from /workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/010_minutes_materials_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_earnings_guidance/058_earnings_guidance_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's severity from /workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/010_minutes_materials_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_earnings_guidance/058_earnings_guidance_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's primary_source from /workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/010_minutes_materials_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_earnings_guidance/058_earnings_guidance_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/010_minutes_materials_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_earnings_guidance/058_earnings_guidance_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-04 using the exact controlled facts ['closed without exception', 'CB-PC-3306-D689', 'open and escalated', 'CB-PC-3306-M906'].", "id": "findings.F-04.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-04's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-04.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-21', 'Adrian Mensah'] for F-04.", "id": "findings.F-04.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-05 exception for disclosure-control exception.", "id": "findings.F-05.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's id from /workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/013_minutes_materials_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_earnings_guidance/061_earnings_guidance_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's issue from /workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/013_minutes_materials_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_earnings_guidance/061_earnings_guidance_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's severity from /workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/013_minutes_materials_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_earnings_guidance/061_earnings_guidance_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's primary_source from /workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/013_minutes_materials_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_earnings_guidance/061_earnings_guidance_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/013_minutes_materials_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_earnings_guidance/061_earnings_guidance_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-05 using the exact controlled facts ['Nasdaq Stock Market', 'Illinois'].", "id": "findings.F-05.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-05's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-05.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-21', 'Willa Novak'] for F-05.", "id": "findings.F-05.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-06 exception for trading-window violation.", "id": "findings.F-06.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's id from /workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/016_minutes_materials_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_earnings_guidance/064_earnings_guidance_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's issue from /workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/016_minutes_materials_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_earnings_guidance/064_earnings_guidance_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's severity from /workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/016_minutes_materials_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_earnings_guidance/064_earnings_guidance_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's primary_source from /workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/016_minutes_materials_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_earnings_guidance/064_earnings_guidance_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/016_minutes_materials_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_earnings_guidance/064_earnings_guidance_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-06 using the exact controlled facts ['7%', '14%'].", "id": "findings.F-06.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-06's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-06.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-21', 'Theo Laurent'] for F-06.", "id": "findings.F-06.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-07 exception for Section 16 filing delay.", "id": "findings.F-07.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's id from /workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/019_sec_filings_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_whistleblower/067_whistleblower_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's issue from /workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/019_sec_filings_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_whistleblower/067_whistleblower_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's severity from /workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/019_sec_filings_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_whistleblower/067_whistleblower_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's primary_source from /workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/019_sec_filings_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_whistleblower/067_whistleblower_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/019_sec_filings_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_whistleblower/067_whistleblower_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-07 using the exact controlled facts ['notices-fieldstone_foods_plc@example.test', 'archive-audit_committee@example.test'].", "id": "findings.F-07.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-07's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-07.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-21', 'Amara Patel'] for F-07.", "id": "findings.F-07.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-08 exception for related-party disclosure gap.", "id": "findings.F-08.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's id from /workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/022_sec_filings_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_whistleblower/070_whistleblower_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's issue from /workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/022_sec_filings_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_whistleblower/070_whistleblower_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's severity from /workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/022_sec_filings_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_whistleblower/070_whistleblower_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's primary_source from /workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/022_sec_filings_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_whistleblower/070_whistleblower_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/022_sec_filings_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_whistleblower/070_whistleblower_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-08 using the exact controlled facts ['130 records', '2025-03-26', '44 records', '2025-04-11'].", "id": "findings.F-08.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-08's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-08.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-21', 'Henry Cho'] for F-08.", "id": "findings.F-08.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-09 exception for equity-plan share mismatch.", "id": "findings.F-09.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's id from /workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/025_disclosure_controls_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_stock_exchange/073_stock_exchange_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's issue from /workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/025_disclosure_controls_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_stock_exchange/073_stock_exchange_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's severity from /workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/025_disclosure_controls_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_stock_exchange/073_stock_exchange_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's primary_source from /workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/025_disclosure_controls_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_stock_exchange/073_stock_exchange_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/025_disclosure_controls_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_stock_exchange/073_stock_exchange_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-09 using the exact controlled facts ['2025-12-28', 'CB-PC-3306-I579', '2026-02-07', 'CB-PC-3306-R344'].", "id": "findings.F-09.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-09's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-09.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-21', 'Nadine Flores'] for F-09.", "id": "findings.F-09.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-10 exception for non-GAAP reconciliation issue.", "id": "findings.F-10.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's id from /workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/028_disclosure_controls_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_stock_exchange/076_stock_exchange_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's issue from /workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/028_disclosure_controls_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_stock_exchange/076_stock_exchange_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's severity from /workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/028_disclosure_controls_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_stock_exchange/076_stock_exchange_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's primary_source from /workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/028_disclosure_controls_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_stock_exchange/076_stock_exchange_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/028_disclosure_controls_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_stock_exchange/076_stock_exchange_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-10 using the exact controlled facts ['$4,854,355.00', '$5,055,210.00'].", "id": "findings.F-10.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-10's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-10.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-21', 'Micah Sullivan'] for F-10.", "id": "findings.F-10.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-11 exception for guidance-control failure.", "id": "findings.F-11.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's id from /workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/031_disclosure_controls_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_stock_exchange/079_stock_exchange_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's issue from /workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/031_disclosure_controls_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_stock_exchange/079_stock_exchange_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's severity from /workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/031_disclosure_controls_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_stock_exchange/079_stock_exchange_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's primary_source from /workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/031_disclosure_controls_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_stock_exchange/079_stock_exchange_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/031_disclosure_controls_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_stock_exchange/079_stock_exchange_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-11 using the exact controlled facts ['Elliot Mercer', 'Jonas Feld'].", "id": "findings.F-11.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-11's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-11.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-21', 'Farah Ibrahim'] for F-11.", "id": "findings.F-11.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-12 exception for whistleblower escalation delay.", "id": "findings.F-12.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's id from /workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/034_insider_trading_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_debt_covenants/082_debt_covenants_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's issue from /workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/034_insider_trading_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_debt_covenants/082_debt_covenants_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's severity from /workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/034_insider_trading_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_debt_covenants/082_debt_covenants_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's primary_source from /workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/034_insider_trading_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_debt_covenants/082_debt_covenants_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/034_insider_trading_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_debt_covenants/082_debt_covenants_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-12 using the exact controlled facts ['closed without exception', 'CB-PC-3306-L974', 'open and escalated', 'CB-PC-3306-U513'].", "id": "findings.F-12.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-12's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-12.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-21', 'Owen Delgado'] for F-12.", "id": "findings.F-12.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-13 exception for listing-standard notice.", "id": "findings.F-13.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's id from /workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/037_insider_trading_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_debt_covenants/085_debt_covenants_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's issue from /workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/037_insider_trading_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_debt_covenants/085_debt_covenants_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's severity from /workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/037_insider_trading_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_debt_covenants/085_debt_covenants_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's primary_source from /workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/037_insider_trading_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_debt_covenants/085_debt_covenants_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/037_insider_trading_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_debt_covenants/085_debt_covenants_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-13 using the exact controlled facts ['Nasdaq Stock Market', 'Illinois'].", "id": "findings.F-13.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-13's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-13.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-21', 'Lena Varga'] for F-13.", "id": "findings.F-13.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-14 exception for debt-covenant disclosure.", "id": "findings.F-14.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's id from /workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/040_insider_trading_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_debt_covenants/088_debt_covenants_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's issue from /workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/040_insider_trading_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_debt_covenants/088_debt_covenants_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's severity from /workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/040_insider_trading_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_debt_covenants/088_debt_covenants_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's primary_source from /workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/040_insider_trading_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_debt_covenants/088_debt_covenants_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/040_insider_trading_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_debt_covenants/088_debt_covenants_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-14 using the exact controlled facts ['5%', '8%'].", "id": "findings.F-14.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-14's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-14.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-21', 'Samuel Kim'] for F-14.", "id": "findings.F-14.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-15 exception for officer certification exception.", "id": "findings.F-15.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's id from /workspace/documents/06_related_parties/043_related_parties_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_certifications/091_certifications_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's issue from /workspace/documents/06_related_parties/043_related_parties_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_certifications/091_certifications_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's severity from /workspace/documents/06_related_parties/043_related_parties_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_certifications/091_certifications_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's primary_source from /workspace/documents/06_related_parties/043_related_parties_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_certifications/091_certifications_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/06_related_parties/043_related_parties_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_certifications/091_certifications_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-15 using the exact controlled facts ['notices-fieldstone_foods_plc@example.test', 'archive-audit_committee@example.test'].", "id": "findings.F-15.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-15's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-15.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-21', 'Maya Ellison'] for F-15.", "id": "findings.F-15.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-16 exception for board-matrix inconsistency.", "id": "findings.F-16.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's id from /workspace/documents/06_related_parties/046_related_parties_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_certifications/094_certifications_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's issue from /workspace/documents/06_related_parties/046_related_parties_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_certifications/094_certifications_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's severity from /workspace/documents/06_related_parties/046_related_parties_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_certifications/094_certifications_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's primary_source from /workspace/documents/06_related_parties/046_related_parties_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_certifications/094_certifications_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/06_related_parties/046_related_parties_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_certifications/094_certifications_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-16 using the exact controlled facts ['140 records', '2025-04-05', '40 records', '2025-04-17'].", "id": "findings.F-16.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-16's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-16.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-21', 'Rafael Okafor'] for F-16.", "id": "findings.F-16.action_anchors"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Executive assessment' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Executive assessment"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Method and record coverage' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Method and record coverage"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Findings' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Findings"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Recommended next actions' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Recommended next actions"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Assumptions and limitations' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Assumptions and limitations"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-01 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-01"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-02 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-02"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-03 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-03"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-04 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-04"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-05 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-05"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-06 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-06"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-07 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-07"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-08 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-08"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-09 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-09"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-10 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-10"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-11 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-11"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-12 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-12"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-13 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-13"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-14 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-14"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-15 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-15"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-16 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-16"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Do not claim the production has no issues or that every record is consistent.", "id": "memo.forbidden_claims_absent"}], "decision_options": [{"id": "cross-source-reconciliation", "label": "Reconcile controlling and corroborating records", "reason": "The CB-PC-3306 production contains independently maintained records; a defensible answer must preserve each supported conflict and its cure owner.", "selected": true}, {"id": "latest-record-controls", "label": "Treat the latest record as controlling", "reason": "Timestamp recency does not establish legal priority, execution, or approval authority.", "selected": false}, {"id": "primary-records-only", "label": "Report primary records without reconciliation", "reason": "Primary records alone conceal the operational conflicts that create the actionable exceptions.", "selected": false}], "gates": ["all_evidence_read_in_full", "chain_of_custody_metadata_checked", "findings_criteria_complete", "memo_criteria_complete", "deliverables_written_through_mcp"], "metadata_checks": 8, "metric": "weighted_criteria_score", "minimum_tool_calls": 46, "required_deliverables": ["findings.json", "advice.md"], "required_document_reads": 33, "type": "deterministic", "weights": {"findings": 0.55, "memo": 0.2, "procedure": 0.25}}, "task_id": "cb100-096-fieldstone-foods", "task_name": "Fieldstone whistleblower escalation audit", "world_id": "counselbench-filesystem-mcp-v2"}
-{"context_files": ["task_files/cb100-097-granular-tech/01_board_committees/001_board_committees_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-097-granular-tech/01_board_committees/002_board_committees_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-097-granular-tech/01_board_committees/003_board_committees_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-097-granular-tech/01_board_committees/004_board_committees_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-097-granular-tech/01_board_committees/005_board_committees_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-097-granular-tech/01_board_committees/006_board_committees_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-097-granular-tech/01_board_committees/007_board_committees_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-097-granular-tech/01_board_committees/008_board_committees_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-097-granular-tech/02_minutes_materials/009_minutes_materials_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-097-granular-tech/02_minutes_materials/010_minutes_materials_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-097-granular-tech/02_minutes_materials/011_minutes_materials_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-097-granular-tech/02_minutes_materials/012_minutes_materials_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-097-granular-tech/02_minutes_materials/013_minutes_materials_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-097-granular-tech/02_minutes_materials/014_minutes_materials_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-097-granular-tech/02_minutes_materials/015_minutes_materials_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-097-granular-tech/02_minutes_materials/016_minutes_materials_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-097-granular-tech/03_sec_filings/017_sec_filings_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-097-granular-tech/03_sec_filings/018_sec_filings_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-097-granular-tech/03_sec_filings/019_sec_filings_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-097-granular-tech/03_sec_filings/020_sec_filings_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-097-granular-tech/03_sec_filings/021_sec_filings_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-097-granular-tech/03_sec_filings/022_sec_filings_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-097-granular-tech/03_sec_filings/023_sec_filings_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-097-granular-tech/03_sec_filings/024_sec_filings_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-097-granular-tech/04_disclosure_controls/025_disclosure_controls_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-097-granular-tech/04_disclosure_controls/026_disclosure_controls_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-097-granular-tech/04_disclosure_controls/027_disclosure_controls_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-097-granular-tech/04_disclosure_controls/028_disclosure_controls_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-097-granular-tech/04_disclosure_controls/029_disclosure_controls_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-097-granular-tech/04_disclosure_controls/030_disclosure_controls_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-097-granular-tech/04_disclosure_controls/031_disclosure_controls_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-097-granular-tech/04_disclosure_controls/032_disclosure_controls_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-097-granular-tech/05_insider_trading/033_insider_trading_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-097-granular-tech/05_insider_trading/034_insider_trading_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-097-granular-tech/05_insider_trading/035_insider_trading_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-097-granular-tech/05_insider_trading/036_insider_trading_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-097-granular-tech/05_insider_trading/037_insider_trading_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-097-granular-tech/05_insider_trading/038_insider_trading_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-097-granular-tech/05_insider_trading/039_insider_trading_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-097-granular-tech/05_insider_trading/040_insider_trading_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-097-granular-tech/06_related_parties/041_related_parties_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-097-granular-tech/06_related_parties/042_related_parties_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-097-granular-tech/06_related_parties/043_related_parties_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-097-granular-tech/06_related_parties/044_related_parties_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-097-granular-tech/06_related_parties/045_related_parties_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-097-granular-tech/06_related_parties/046_related_parties_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-097-granular-tech/06_related_parties/047_related_parties_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-097-granular-tech/06_related_parties/048_related_parties_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-097-granular-tech/07_equity_compensation/049_equity_compensation_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-097-granular-tech/07_equity_compensation/050_equity_compensation_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-097-granular-tech/07_equity_compensation/051_equity_compensation_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-097-granular-tech/07_equity_compensation/052_equity_compensation_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-097-granular-tech/07_equity_compensation/053_equity_compensation_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-097-granular-tech/07_equity_compensation/054_equity_compensation_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-097-granular-tech/07_equity_compensation/055_equity_compensation_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-097-granular-tech/07_equity_compensation/056_equity_compensation_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-097-granular-tech/08_earnings_guidance/057_earnings_guidance_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-097-granular-tech/08_earnings_guidance/058_earnings_guidance_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-097-granular-tech/08_earnings_guidance/059_earnings_guidance_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-097-granular-tech/08_earnings_guidance/060_earnings_guidance_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-097-granular-tech/08_earnings_guidance/061_earnings_guidance_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-097-granular-tech/08_earnings_guidance/062_earnings_guidance_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-097-granular-tech/08_earnings_guidance/063_earnings_guidance_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-097-granular-tech/08_earnings_guidance/064_earnings_guidance_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-097-granular-tech/09_whistleblower/065_whistleblower_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-097-granular-tech/09_whistleblower/066_whistleblower_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-097-granular-tech/09_whistleblower/067_whistleblower_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-097-granular-tech/09_whistleblower/068_whistleblower_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-097-granular-tech/09_whistleblower/069_whistleblower_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-097-granular-tech/09_whistleblower/070_whistleblower_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-097-granular-tech/09_whistleblower/071_whistleblower_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-097-granular-tech/09_whistleblower/072_whistleblower_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-097-granular-tech/10_stock_exchange/073_stock_exchange_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-097-granular-tech/10_stock_exchange/074_stock_exchange_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-097-granular-tech/10_stock_exchange/075_stock_exchange_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-097-granular-tech/10_stock_exchange/076_stock_exchange_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-097-granular-tech/10_stock_exchange/077_stock_exchange_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-097-granular-tech/10_stock_exchange/078_stock_exchange_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-097-granular-tech/10_stock_exchange/079_stock_exchange_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-097-granular-tech/10_stock_exchange/080_stock_exchange_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-097-granular-tech/11_debt_covenants/081_debt_covenants_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-097-granular-tech/11_debt_covenants/082_debt_covenants_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-097-granular-tech/11_debt_covenants/083_debt_covenants_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-097-granular-tech/11_debt_covenants/084_debt_covenants_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-097-granular-tech/11_debt_covenants/085_debt_covenants_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-097-granular-tech/11_debt_covenants/086_debt_covenants_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-097-granular-tech/11_debt_covenants/087_debt_covenants_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-097-granular-tech/11_debt_covenants/088_debt_covenants_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-097-granular-tech/12_certifications/089_certifications_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-097-granular-tech/12_certifications/090_certifications_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-097-granular-tech/12_certifications/091_certifications_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-097-granular-tech/12_certifications/092_certifications_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-097-granular-tech/12_certifications/093_certifications_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-097-granular-tech/12_certifications/094_certifications_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-097-granular-tech/12_certifications/095_certifications_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-097-granular-tech/12_certifications/096_certifications_status_report.md"], "gold_output": {"advice_markdown": "# Counsel advice — Granular Section 16 filing review\n\n## Executive assessment\n\nFor Granular Technology Corp. matter CB-PC-3307, the review identified 16 source-supported exceptions requiring action before 2026-09-24. The assessment concerns Executive officer group and the supplied record for Texas.\n\n## Method and record coverage\n\nThe review inventoried all 96 production files, read the 33 controlling, corroborating, and control records, searched the email exports, and checked metadata for the designated chain-of-custody sample. Conclusions are limited to the synthetic production supplied for this benchmark matter.\n\n## Findings\n\n### F-01 — committee-independence gap (critical)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for committee-independence gap: one source states the operative date is 2025-08-17 under control reference CB-PC-3307-A326, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2025-08-26 under response reference CB-PC-3307-J878.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/01_board_committees/001_board_committees_control_register.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/07_equity_compensation/049_equity_compensation_control_register.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-24, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Isaac Romero.\n\n### F-02 — minutes-approval omission (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for minutes-approval omission: one source states the controlling amount is $4,314,491.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $4,585,482.00.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/01_board_committees/004_board_committees_ledger_export.csv`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/07_equity_compensation/052_equity_compensation_ledger_export.csv`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-24, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Sofia Bennett.\n\n### F-03 — 8-K deadline (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for 8-K deadline: one source states approval is attributed to Talia Brooks as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Henry Cho and contains no entry for Talia Brooks.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/01_board_committees/007_board_committees_officer_certificate.html`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/07_equity_compensation/055_equity_compensation_officer_certificate.html`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-24, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Adrian Mensah.\n\n### F-04 — risk-factor inconsistency (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for risk-factor inconsistency: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-PC-3307-D216, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-PC-3307-M178.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/010_minutes_materials_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/08_earnings_guidance/058_earnings_guidance_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-24, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Willa Novak.\n\n### F-05 — disclosure-control exception (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for disclosure-control exception: one source states the applicable location is Nasdaq Stock Market, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to Texas operations outside Nasdaq Stock Market.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/013_minutes_materials_review_memorandum.json`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/08_earnings_guidance/061_earnings_guidance_review_memorandum.json`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-24, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Theo Laurent.\n\n### F-06 — trading-window violation (low)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for trading-window violation: one source states the threshold is 6% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 12% and produced a different exception result.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/016_minutes_materials_status_report.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/08_earnings_guidance/064_earnings_guidance_status_report.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-24, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Amara Patel.\n\n### F-07 — Section 16 filing delay (critical)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for Section 16 filing delay: one source states formal notice must use notices-granular_technology_corp@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-executive_officer_group@example.test.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/019_sec_filings_correspondence.eml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/09_whistleblower/067_whistleblower_correspondence.eml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-24, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Henry Cho.\n\n### F-08 — related-party disclosure gap (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for related-party disclosure gap: one source states the governed population contains 154 records through 2025-09-06, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 74 records through 2025-10-22.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/022_sec_filings_formal_notice.xml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/09_whistleblower/070_whistleblower_formal_notice.xml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-24, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Nadine Flores.\n\n### F-09 — equity-plan share mismatch (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for equity-plan share mismatch: one source states the operative date is 2025-04-04 under control reference CB-PC-3307-I371, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2025-04-13 under response reference CB-PC-3307-R813.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/025_disclosure_controls_control_register.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/10_stock_exchange/073_stock_exchange_control_register.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-24, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Micah Sullivan.\n\n### F-10 — non-GAAP reconciliation issue (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for non-GAAP reconciliation issue: one source states the controlling amount is $7,448,406.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $7,563,312.00.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/028_disclosure_controls_ledger_export.csv`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/10_stock_exchange/076_stock_exchange_ledger_export.csv`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-24, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Farah Ibrahim.\n\n### F-11 — guidance-control failure (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for guidance-control failure: one source states approval is attributed to Talia Brooks as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Caleb Hassan and contains no entry for Talia Brooks.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/031_disclosure_controls_officer_certificate.html`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/10_stock_exchange/079_stock_exchange_officer_certificate.html`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-24, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Owen Delgado.\n\n### F-12 — whistleblower escalation delay (low)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for whistleblower escalation delay: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-PC-3307-L334, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-PC-3307-U394.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/034_insider_trading_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/11_debt_covenants/082_debt_covenants_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-24, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Lena Varga.\n\n### F-13 — listing-standard notice (critical)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for listing-standard notice: one source states the applicable location is Nasdaq Stock Market, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to Texas operations outside Nasdaq Stock Market.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/037_insider_trading_review_memorandum.json`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/11_debt_covenants/085_debt_covenants_review_memorandum.json`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-24, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Samuel Kim.\n\n### F-14 — debt-covenant disclosure (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for debt-covenant disclosure: one source states the threshold is 15% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 20% and produced a different exception result.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/040_insider_trading_status_report.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/11_debt_covenants/088_debt_covenants_status_report.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-24, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Maya Ellison.\n\n### F-15 — officer certification exception (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for officer certification exception: one source states formal notice must use notices-granular_technology_corp@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-executive_officer_group@example.test.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/06_related_parties/043_related_parties_correspondence.eml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/12_certifications/091_certifications_correspondence.eml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-24, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Rafael Okafor.\n\n### F-16 — board-matrix inconsistency (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for board-matrix inconsistency: one source states the governed population contains 89 records through 2025-02-13, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 63 records through 2025-03-20.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/06_related_parties/046_related_parties_formal_notice.xml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/12_certifications/094_certifications_formal_notice.xml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-24, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Nora Chen.\n\n## Recommended next actions\n\nSequence the critical and high findings first, assign the named owners, preserve the cited records, and document any resolution in the controlling matter register before the stated deadline.\n\n## Assumptions and limitations\n\nThis analysis is confined to task cb100-097-granular-tech and the supplied synthetic evidence. It does not rely on external facts, does not resolve disputed law, and is not legal advice for a real person or entity.\n", "findings": {"as_of": "2026-09-24", "findings": [{"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/07_equity_compensation/049_equity_compensation_control_register.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for committee-independence gap: one source states the operative date is 2025-08-17 under control reference CB-PC-3307-A326, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2025-08-26 under response reference CB-PC-3307-J878.", "id": "F-01", "issue": "committee-independence gap", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/01_board_committees/001_board_committees_control_register.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-24, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Isaac Romero.", "severity": "critical"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/07_equity_compensation/052_equity_compensation_ledger_export.csv", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for minutes-approval omission: one source states the controlling amount is $4,314,491.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $4,585,482.00.", "id": "F-02", "issue": "minutes-approval omission", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/01_board_committees/004_board_committees_ledger_export.csv", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-24, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Sofia Bennett.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/07_equity_compensation/055_equity_compensation_officer_certificate.html", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for 8-K deadline: one source states approval is attributed to Talia Brooks as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Henry Cho and contains no entry for Talia Brooks.", "id": "F-03", "issue": "8-K deadline", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/01_board_committees/007_board_committees_officer_certificate.html", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-24, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Adrian Mensah.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/08_earnings_guidance/058_earnings_guidance_executed_instrument.txt", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for risk-factor inconsistency: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-PC-3307-D216, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-PC-3307-M178.", "id": "F-04", "issue": "risk-factor inconsistency", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/010_minutes_materials_executed_instrument.txt", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-24, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Willa Novak.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/08_earnings_guidance/061_earnings_guidance_review_memorandum.json", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for disclosure-control exception: one source states the applicable location is Nasdaq Stock Market, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to Texas operations outside Nasdaq Stock Market.", "id": "F-05", "issue": "disclosure-control exception", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/013_minutes_materials_review_memorandum.json", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-24, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Theo Laurent.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/08_earnings_guidance/064_earnings_guidance_status_report.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for trading-window violation: one source states the threshold is 6% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 12% and produced a different exception result.", "id": "F-06", "issue": "trading-window violation", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/016_minutes_materials_status_report.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-24, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Amara Patel.", "severity": "low"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/09_whistleblower/067_whistleblower_correspondence.eml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for Section 16 filing delay: one source states formal notice must use notices-granular_technology_corp@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-executive_officer_group@example.test.", "id": "F-07", "issue": "Section 16 filing delay", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/019_sec_filings_correspondence.eml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-24, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Henry Cho.", "severity": "critical"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/09_whistleblower/070_whistleblower_formal_notice.xml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for related-party disclosure gap: one source states the governed population contains 154 records through 2025-09-06, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 74 records through 2025-10-22.", "id": "F-08", "issue": "related-party disclosure gap", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/022_sec_filings_formal_notice.xml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-24, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Nadine Flores.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/10_stock_exchange/073_stock_exchange_control_register.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for equity-plan share mismatch: one source states the operative date is 2025-04-04 under control reference CB-PC-3307-I371, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2025-04-13 under response reference CB-PC-3307-R813.", "id": "F-09", "issue": "equity-plan share mismatch", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/025_disclosure_controls_control_register.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-24, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Micah Sullivan.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/10_stock_exchange/076_stock_exchange_ledger_export.csv", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for non-GAAP reconciliation issue: one source states the controlling amount is $7,448,406.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $7,563,312.00.", "id": "F-10", "issue": "non-GAAP reconciliation issue", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/028_disclosure_controls_ledger_export.csv", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-24, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Farah Ibrahim.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/10_stock_exchange/079_stock_exchange_officer_certificate.html", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for guidance-control failure: one source states approval is attributed to Talia Brooks as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Caleb Hassan and contains no entry for Talia Brooks.", "id": "F-11", "issue": "guidance-control failure", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/031_disclosure_controls_officer_certificate.html", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-24, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Owen Delgado.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/11_debt_covenants/082_debt_covenants_executed_instrument.txt", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for whistleblower escalation delay: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-PC-3307-L334, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-PC-3307-U394.", "id": "F-12", "issue": "whistleblower escalation delay", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/034_insider_trading_executed_instrument.txt", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-24, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Lena Varga.", "severity": "low"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/11_debt_covenants/085_debt_covenants_review_memorandum.json", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for listing-standard notice: one source states the applicable location is Nasdaq Stock Market, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to Texas operations outside Nasdaq Stock Market.", "id": "F-13", "issue": "listing-standard notice", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/037_insider_trading_review_memorandum.json", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-24, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Samuel Kim.", "severity": "critical"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/11_debt_covenants/088_debt_covenants_status_report.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for debt-covenant disclosure: one source states the threshold is 15% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 20% and produced a different exception result.", "id": "F-14", "issue": "debt-covenant disclosure", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/040_insider_trading_status_report.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-24, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Maya Ellison.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/12_certifications/091_certifications_correspondence.eml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for officer certification exception: one source states formal notice must use notices-granular_technology_corp@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-executive_officer_group@example.test.", "id": "F-15", "issue": "officer certification exception", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/06_related_parties/043_related_parties_correspondence.eml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-24, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Rafael Okafor.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/12_certifications/094_certifications_formal_notice.xml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for board-matrix inconsistency: one source states the governed population contains 89 records through 2025-02-13, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 63 records through 2025-03-20.", "id": "F-16", "issue": "board-matrix inconsistency", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/06_related_parties/046_related_parties_formal_notice.xml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-24, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Nora Chen.", "severity": "medium"}], "matter_number": "CB-PC-3307", "prepared_for": "Granular Technology Corp.", "schema_version": "1.0", "task_id": "cb100-097-granular-tech"}}, "metadata": {"benchmark": "CounselBench-100", "code_license": "Apache-2.0", "data_license": "CC-BY-4.0", "deadline": "2026-09-24", "document_count": 96, "jurisdiction": "Texas", "matter_number": "CB-PC-3307", "mcp_commit": "9a96ea6e5913736f92b88345bf51caeaaa8e719f", "mcp_package": "@modelcontextprotocol/server-filesystem@2026.7.10", "practice_area": "public-company", "reference_tool_calls": 46, "required_evidence_reads": 33, "synthetic": true, "venue": "Nasdaq Stock Market", "version": "2.0.0"}, "prompt": "You are securities and governance counsel for Granular Technology Corp. A counterparty challenged the client's internal summary, making cross-document reconciliation and precise citations essential. Equity grants, broker confirmations, powers of attorney, and filing records reveal late or inconsistent insider reports. Decision due 2026-09-24. Texas law governs; Nasdaq Stock Market is the forum. Flag cross-folder dependencies that would be invisible in a single-document review. Work out the defensible position from the matter production and leave an audit-ready exception tracker and concise advice for the supervising lawyer. Keep confirmed conflicts separate from open questions, cite the records that actually control each conclusion, and do not fill gaps with outside facts.", "rubric": {"criteria": [{"category": "procedure", "description": "Complete at least 46 successful, argument-specific evidence and output calls.", "id": "procedure.minimum_successful_tool_calls"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Find and read the 33 controlling, corroborating, and work-product-control records in full.", "id": "procedure.all_evidence_read_in_full"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Inspect file metadata for the eight designated critical primary records before relying on them.", "id": "procedure.chain_of_custody_metadata_checked"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Confirm the sandbox's allowed document and output roots.", "id": "procedure.allowed_directories_checked"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Inventory all 96 records so the relevant sources are discovered among the context records.", "id": "procedure.recursive_inventory_completed"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Search the production for email evidence that may corroborate or contradict formal records.", "id": "procedure.targeted_search_completed"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Leave only findings.json and advice.md in the output workspace.", "id": "procedure.exact_deliverable_set"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Create both final work products through the sandbox MCP surface.", "id": "procedure.deliverables_written_through_mcp"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Produce findings.json as a valid JSON object.", "id": "findings.findings_is_object"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Report exactly 16 confirmed exceptions.", "id": "findings.findings_exact_count"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Use each stable finding ID exactly once.", "id": "findings.finding_ids_unique"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set schema_version to the released matter value '1.0'.", "id": "findings.top_level_schema_version"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set task_id to the released matter value 'cb100-097-granular-tech'.", "id": "findings.top_level_task_id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set matter_number to the released matter value 'CB-PC-3307'.", "id": "findings.top_level_matter_number"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set prepared_for to the released matter value 'Granular Technology Corp.'.", "id": "findings.top_level_prepared_for"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set as_of to the released matter value '2026-09-24'.", "id": "findings.top_level_as_of"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-01 exception for committee-independence gap.", "id": "findings.F-01.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's id from /workspace/documents/01_board_committees/001_board_committees_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_equity_compensation/049_equity_compensation_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's issue from /workspace/documents/01_board_committees/001_board_committees_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_equity_compensation/049_equity_compensation_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's severity from /workspace/documents/01_board_committees/001_board_committees_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_equity_compensation/049_equity_compensation_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's primary_source from /workspace/documents/01_board_committees/001_board_committees_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_equity_compensation/049_equity_compensation_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/01_board_committees/001_board_committees_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_equity_compensation/049_equity_compensation_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-01 using the exact controlled facts ['2025-08-17', 'CB-PC-3307-A326', '2025-08-26', 'CB-PC-3307-J878'].", "id": "findings.F-01.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-01's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-01.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-24', 'Isaac Romero'] for F-01.", "id": "findings.F-01.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-02 exception for minutes-approval omission.", "id": "findings.F-02.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's id from /workspace/documents/01_board_committees/004_board_committees_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_equity_compensation/052_equity_compensation_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's issue from /workspace/documents/01_board_committees/004_board_committees_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_equity_compensation/052_equity_compensation_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's severity from /workspace/documents/01_board_committees/004_board_committees_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_equity_compensation/052_equity_compensation_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's primary_source from /workspace/documents/01_board_committees/004_board_committees_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_equity_compensation/052_equity_compensation_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/01_board_committees/004_board_committees_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_equity_compensation/052_equity_compensation_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-02 using the exact controlled facts ['$4,314,491.00', '$4,585,482.00'].", "id": "findings.F-02.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-02's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-02.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-24', 'Sofia Bennett'] for F-02.", "id": "findings.F-02.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-03 exception for 8-K deadline.", "id": "findings.F-03.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's id from /workspace/documents/01_board_committees/007_board_committees_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_equity_compensation/055_equity_compensation_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's issue from /workspace/documents/01_board_committees/007_board_committees_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_equity_compensation/055_equity_compensation_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's severity from /workspace/documents/01_board_committees/007_board_committees_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_equity_compensation/055_equity_compensation_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's primary_source from /workspace/documents/01_board_committees/007_board_committees_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_equity_compensation/055_equity_compensation_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/01_board_committees/007_board_committees_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_equity_compensation/055_equity_compensation_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-03 using the exact controlled facts ['Talia Brooks', 'Henry Cho'].", "id": "findings.F-03.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-03's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-03.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-24', 'Adrian Mensah'] for F-03.", "id": "findings.F-03.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-04 exception for risk-factor inconsistency.", "id": "findings.F-04.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's id from /workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/010_minutes_materials_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_earnings_guidance/058_earnings_guidance_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's issue from /workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/010_minutes_materials_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_earnings_guidance/058_earnings_guidance_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's severity from /workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/010_minutes_materials_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_earnings_guidance/058_earnings_guidance_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's primary_source from /workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/010_minutes_materials_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_earnings_guidance/058_earnings_guidance_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/010_minutes_materials_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_earnings_guidance/058_earnings_guidance_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-04 using the exact controlled facts ['closed without exception', 'CB-PC-3307-D216', 'open and escalated', 'CB-PC-3307-M178'].", "id": "findings.F-04.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-04's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-04.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-24', 'Willa Novak'] for F-04.", "id": "findings.F-04.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-05 exception for disclosure-control exception.", "id": "findings.F-05.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's id from /workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/013_minutes_materials_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_earnings_guidance/061_earnings_guidance_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's issue from /workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/013_minutes_materials_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_earnings_guidance/061_earnings_guidance_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's severity from /workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/013_minutes_materials_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_earnings_guidance/061_earnings_guidance_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's primary_source from /workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/013_minutes_materials_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_earnings_guidance/061_earnings_guidance_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/013_minutes_materials_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_earnings_guidance/061_earnings_guidance_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-05 using the exact controlled facts ['Nasdaq Stock Market', 'Texas'].", "id": "findings.F-05.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-05's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-05.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-24', 'Theo Laurent'] for F-05.", "id": "findings.F-05.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-06 exception for trading-window violation.", "id": "findings.F-06.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's id from /workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/016_minutes_materials_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_earnings_guidance/064_earnings_guidance_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's issue from /workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/016_minutes_materials_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_earnings_guidance/064_earnings_guidance_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's severity from /workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/016_minutes_materials_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_earnings_guidance/064_earnings_guidance_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's primary_source from /workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/016_minutes_materials_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_earnings_guidance/064_earnings_guidance_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/016_minutes_materials_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_earnings_guidance/064_earnings_guidance_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-06 using the exact controlled facts ['6%', '12%'].", "id": "findings.F-06.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-06's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-06.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-24', 'Amara Patel'] for F-06.", "id": "findings.F-06.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-07 exception for Section 16 filing delay.", "id": "findings.F-07.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's id from /workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/019_sec_filings_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_whistleblower/067_whistleblower_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's issue from /workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/019_sec_filings_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_whistleblower/067_whistleblower_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's severity from /workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/019_sec_filings_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_whistleblower/067_whistleblower_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's primary_source from /workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/019_sec_filings_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_whistleblower/067_whistleblower_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/019_sec_filings_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_whistleblower/067_whistleblower_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-07 using the exact controlled facts ['notices-granular_technology_corp@example.test', 'archive-executive_officer_group@example.test'].", "id": "findings.F-07.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-07's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-07.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-24', 'Henry Cho'] for F-07.", "id": "findings.F-07.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-08 exception for related-party disclosure gap.", "id": "findings.F-08.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's id from /workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/022_sec_filings_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_whistleblower/070_whistleblower_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's issue from /workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/022_sec_filings_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_whistleblower/070_whistleblower_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's severity from /workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/022_sec_filings_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_whistleblower/070_whistleblower_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's primary_source from /workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/022_sec_filings_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_whistleblower/070_whistleblower_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/022_sec_filings_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_whistleblower/070_whistleblower_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-08 using the exact controlled facts ['154 records', '2025-09-06', '74 records', '2025-10-22'].", "id": "findings.F-08.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-08's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-08.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-24', 'Nadine Flores'] for F-08.", "id": "findings.F-08.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-09 exception for equity-plan share mismatch.", "id": "findings.F-09.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's id from /workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/025_disclosure_controls_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_stock_exchange/073_stock_exchange_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's issue from /workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/025_disclosure_controls_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_stock_exchange/073_stock_exchange_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's severity from /workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/025_disclosure_controls_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_stock_exchange/073_stock_exchange_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's primary_source from /workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/025_disclosure_controls_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_stock_exchange/073_stock_exchange_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/025_disclosure_controls_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_stock_exchange/073_stock_exchange_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-09 using the exact controlled facts ['2025-04-04', 'CB-PC-3307-I371', '2025-04-13', 'CB-PC-3307-R813'].", "id": "findings.F-09.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-09's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-09.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-24', 'Micah Sullivan'] for F-09.", "id": "findings.F-09.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-10 exception for non-GAAP reconciliation issue.", "id": "findings.F-10.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's id from /workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/028_disclosure_controls_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_stock_exchange/076_stock_exchange_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's issue from /workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/028_disclosure_controls_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_stock_exchange/076_stock_exchange_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's severity from /workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/028_disclosure_controls_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_stock_exchange/076_stock_exchange_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's primary_source from /workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/028_disclosure_controls_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_stock_exchange/076_stock_exchange_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/028_disclosure_controls_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_stock_exchange/076_stock_exchange_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-10 using the exact controlled facts ['$7,448,406.00', '$7,563,312.00'].", "id": "findings.F-10.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-10's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-10.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-24', 'Farah Ibrahim'] for F-10.", "id": "findings.F-10.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-11 exception for guidance-control failure.", "id": "findings.F-11.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's id from /workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/031_disclosure_controls_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_stock_exchange/079_stock_exchange_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's issue from /workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/031_disclosure_controls_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_stock_exchange/079_stock_exchange_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's severity from /workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/031_disclosure_controls_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_stock_exchange/079_stock_exchange_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's primary_source from /workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/031_disclosure_controls_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_stock_exchange/079_stock_exchange_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/031_disclosure_controls_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_stock_exchange/079_stock_exchange_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-11 using the exact controlled facts ['Talia Brooks', 'Caleb Hassan'].", "id": "findings.F-11.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-11's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-11.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-24', 'Owen Delgado'] for F-11.", "id": "findings.F-11.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-12 exception for whistleblower escalation delay.", "id": "findings.F-12.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's id from /workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/034_insider_trading_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_debt_covenants/082_debt_covenants_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's issue from /workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/034_insider_trading_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_debt_covenants/082_debt_covenants_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's severity from /workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/034_insider_trading_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_debt_covenants/082_debt_covenants_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's primary_source from /workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/034_insider_trading_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_debt_covenants/082_debt_covenants_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/034_insider_trading_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_debt_covenants/082_debt_covenants_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-12 using the exact controlled facts ['closed without exception', 'CB-PC-3307-L334', 'open and escalated', 'CB-PC-3307-U394'].", "id": "findings.F-12.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-12's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-12.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-24', 'Lena Varga'] for F-12.", "id": "findings.F-12.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-13 exception for listing-standard notice.", "id": "findings.F-13.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's id from /workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/037_insider_trading_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_debt_covenants/085_debt_covenants_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's issue from /workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/037_insider_trading_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_debt_covenants/085_debt_covenants_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's severity from /workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/037_insider_trading_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_debt_covenants/085_debt_covenants_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's primary_source from /workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/037_insider_trading_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_debt_covenants/085_debt_covenants_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/037_insider_trading_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_debt_covenants/085_debt_covenants_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-13 using the exact controlled facts ['Nasdaq Stock Market', 'Texas'].", "id": "findings.F-13.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-13's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-13.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-24', 'Samuel Kim'] for F-13.", "id": "findings.F-13.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-14 exception for debt-covenant disclosure.", "id": "findings.F-14.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's id from /workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/040_insider_trading_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_debt_covenants/088_debt_covenants_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's issue from /workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/040_insider_trading_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_debt_covenants/088_debt_covenants_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's severity from /workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/040_insider_trading_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_debt_covenants/088_debt_covenants_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's primary_source from /workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/040_insider_trading_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_debt_covenants/088_debt_covenants_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/040_insider_trading_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_debt_covenants/088_debt_covenants_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-14 using the exact controlled facts ['15%', '20%'].", "id": "findings.F-14.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-14's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-14.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-24', 'Maya Ellison'] for F-14.", "id": "findings.F-14.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-15 exception for officer certification exception.", "id": "findings.F-15.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's id from /workspace/documents/06_related_parties/043_related_parties_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_certifications/091_certifications_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's issue from /workspace/documents/06_related_parties/043_related_parties_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_certifications/091_certifications_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's severity from /workspace/documents/06_related_parties/043_related_parties_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_certifications/091_certifications_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's primary_source from /workspace/documents/06_related_parties/043_related_parties_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_certifications/091_certifications_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/06_related_parties/043_related_parties_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_certifications/091_certifications_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-15 using the exact controlled facts ['notices-granular_technology_corp@example.test', 'archive-executive_officer_group@example.test'].", "id": "findings.F-15.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-15's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-15.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-24', 'Rafael Okafor'] for F-15.", "id": "findings.F-15.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-16 exception for board-matrix inconsistency.", "id": "findings.F-16.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's id from /workspace/documents/06_related_parties/046_related_parties_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_certifications/094_certifications_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's issue from /workspace/documents/06_related_parties/046_related_parties_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_certifications/094_certifications_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's severity from /workspace/documents/06_related_parties/046_related_parties_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_certifications/094_certifications_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's primary_source from /workspace/documents/06_related_parties/046_related_parties_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_certifications/094_certifications_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/06_related_parties/046_related_parties_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_certifications/094_certifications_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-16 using the exact controlled facts ['89 records', '2025-02-13', '63 records', '2025-03-20'].", "id": "findings.F-16.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-16's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-16.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-24', 'Nora Chen'] for F-16.", "id": "findings.F-16.action_anchors"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Executive assessment' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Executive assessment"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Method and record coverage' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Method and record coverage"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Findings' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Findings"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Recommended next actions' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Recommended next actions"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Assumptions and limitations' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Assumptions and limitations"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-01 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-01"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-02 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-02"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-03 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-03"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-04 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-04"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-05 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-05"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-06 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-06"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-07 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-07"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-08 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-08"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-09 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-09"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-10 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-10"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-11 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-11"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-12 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-12"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-13 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-13"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-14 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-14"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-15 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-15"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-16 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-16"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Do not claim the production has no issues or that every record is consistent.", "id": "memo.forbidden_claims_absent"}], "decision_options": [{"id": "cross-source-reconciliation", "label": "Reconcile controlling and corroborating records", "reason": "The CB-PC-3307 production contains independently maintained records; a defensible answer must preserve each supported conflict and its cure owner.", "selected": true}, {"id": "latest-record-controls", "label": "Treat the latest record as controlling", "reason": "Timestamp recency does not establish legal priority, execution, or approval authority.", "selected": false}, {"id": "primary-records-only", "label": "Report primary records without reconciliation", "reason": "Primary records alone conceal the operational conflicts that create the actionable exceptions.", "selected": false}], "gates": ["all_evidence_read_in_full", "chain_of_custody_metadata_checked", "findings_criteria_complete", "memo_criteria_complete", "deliverables_written_through_mcp"], "metadata_checks": 8, "metric": "weighted_criteria_score", "minimum_tool_calls": 46, "required_deliverables": ["findings.json", "advice.md"], "required_document_reads": 33, "type": "deterministic", "weights": {"findings": 0.55, "memo": 0.2, "procedure": 0.25}}, "task_id": "cb100-097-granular-tech", "task_name": "Granular Section 16 filing review", "world_id": "counselbench-filesystem-mcp-v2"}
-{"context_files": ["task_files/cb100-098-highwater-utilities/01_board_committees/001_board_committees_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-098-highwater-utilities/01_board_committees/002_board_committees_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-098-highwater-utilities/01_board_committees/003_board_committees_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-098-highwater-utilities/01_board_committees/004_board_committees_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-098-highwater-utilities/01_board_committees/005_board_committees_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-098-highwater-utilities/01_board_committees/006_board_committees_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-098-highwater-utilities/01_board_committees/007_board_committees_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-098-highwater-utilities/01_board_committees/008_board_committees_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-098-highwater-utilities/02_minutes_materials/009_minutes_materials_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-098-highwater-utilities/02_minutes_materials/010_minutes_materials_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-098-highwater-utilities/02_minutes_materials/011_minutes_materials_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-098-highwater-utilities/02_minutes_materials/012_minutes_materials_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-098-highwater-utilities/02_minutes_materials/013_minutes_materials_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-098-highwater-utilities/02_minutes_materials/014_minutes_materials_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-098-highwater-utilities/02_minutes_materials/015_minutes_materials_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-098-highwater-utilities/02_minutes_materials/016_minutes_materials_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-098-highwater-utilities/03_sec_filings/017_sec_filings_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-098-highwater-utilities/03_sec_filings/018_sec_filings_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-098-highwater-utilities/03_sec_filings/019_sec_filings_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-098-highwater-utilities/03_sec_filings/020_sec_filings_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-098-highwater-utilities/03_sec_filings/021_sec_filings_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-098-highwater-utilities/03_sec_filings/022_sec_filings_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-098-highwater-utilities/03_sec_filings/023_sec_filings_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-098-highwater-utilities/03_sec_filings/024_sec_filings_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-098-highwater-utilities/04_disclosure_controls/025_disclosure_controls_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-098-highwater-utilities/04_disclosure_controls/026_disclosure_controls_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-098-highwater-utilities/04_disclosure_controls/027_disclosure_controls_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-098-highwater-utilities/04_disclosure_controls/028_disclosure_controls_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-098-highwater-utilities/04_disclosure_controls/029_disclosure_controls_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-098-highwater-utilities/04_disclosure_controls/030_disclosure_controls_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-098-highwater-utilities/04_disclosure_controls/031_disclosure_controls_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-098-highwater-utilities/04_disclosure_controls/032_disclosure_controls_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-098-highwater-utilities/05_insider_trading/033_insider_trading_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-098-highwater-utilities/05_insider_trading/034_insider_trading_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-098-highwater-utilities/05_insider_trading/035_insider_trading_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-098-highwater-utilities/05_insider_trading/036_insider_trading_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-098-highwater-utilities/05_insider_trading/037_insider_trading_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-098-highwater-utilities/05_insider_trading/038_insider_trading_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-098-highwater-utilities/05_insider_trading/039_insider_trading_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-098-highwater-utilities/05_insider_trading/040_insider_trading_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-098-highwater-utilities/06_related_parties/041_related_parties_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-098-highwater-utilities/06_related_parties/042_related_parties_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-098-highwater-utilities/06_related_parties/043_related_parties_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-098-highwater-utilities/06_related_parties/044_related_parties_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-098-highwater-utilities/06_related_parties/045_related_parties_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-098-highwater-utilities/06_related_parties/046_related_parties_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-098-highwater-utilities/06_related_parties/047_related_parties_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-098-highwater-utilities/06_related_parties/048_related_parties_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-098-highwater-utilities/07_equity_compensation/049_equity_compensation_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-098-highwater-utilities/07_equity_compensation/050_equity_compensation_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-098-highwater-utilities/07_equity_compensation/051_equity_compensation_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-098-highwater-utilities/07_equity_compensation/052_equity_compensation_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-098-highwater-utilities/07_equity_compensation/053_equity_compensation_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-098-highwater-utilities/07_equity_compensation/054_equity_compensation_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-098-highwater-utilities/07_equity_compensation/055_equity_compensation_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-098-highwater-utilities/07_equity_compensation/056_equity_compensation_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-098-highwater-utilities/08_earnings_guidance/057_earnings_guidance_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-098-highwater-utilities/08_earnings_guidance/058_earnings_guidance_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-098-highwater-utilities/08_earnings_guidance/059_earnings_guidance_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-098-highwater-utilities/08_earnings_guidance/060_earnings_guidance_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-098-highwater-utilities/08_earnings_guidance/061_earnings_guidance_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-098-highwater-utilities/08_earnings_guidance/062_earnings_guidance_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-098-highwater-utilities/08_earnings_guidance/063_earnings_guidance_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-098-highwater-utilities/08_earnings_guidance/064_earnings_guidance_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-098-highwater-utilities/09_whistleblower/065_whistleblower_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-098-highwater-utilities/09_whistleblower/066_whistleblower_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-098-highwater-utilities/09_whistleblower/067_whistleblower_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-098-highwater-utilities/09_whistleblower/068_whistleblower_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-098-highwater-utilities/09_whistleblower/069_whistleblower_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-098-highwater-utilities/09_whistleblower/070_whistleblower_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-098-highwater-utilities/09_whistleblower/071_whistleblower_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-098-highwater-utilities/09_whistleblower/072_whistleblower_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-098-highwater-utilities/10_stock_exchange/073_stock_exchange_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-098-highwater-utilities/10_stock_exchange/074_stock_exchange_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-098-highwater-utilities/10_stock_exchange/075_stock_exchange_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-098-highwater-utilities/10_stock_exchange/076_stock_exchange_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-098-highwater-utilities/10_stock_exchange/077_stock_exchange_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-098-highwater-utilities/10_stock_exchange/078_stock_exchange_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-098-highwater-utilities/10_stock_exchange/079_stock_exchange_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-098-highwater-utilities/10_stock_exchange/080_stock_exchange_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-098-highwater-utilities/11_debt_covenants/081_debt_covenants_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-098-highwater-utilities/11_debt_covenants/082_debt_covenants_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-098-highwater-utilities/11_debt_covenants/083_debt_covenants_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-098-highwater-utilities/11_debt_covenants/084_debt_covenants_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-098-highwater-utilities/11_debt_covenants/085_debt_covenants_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-098-highwater-utilities/11_debt_covenants/086_debt_covenants_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-098-highwater-utilities/11_debt_covenants/087_debt_covenants_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-098-highwater-utilities/11_debt_covenants/088_debt_covenants_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-098-highwater-utilities/12_certifications/089_certifications_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-098-highwater-utilities/12_certifications/090_certifications_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-098-highwater-utilities/12_certifications/091_certifications_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-098-highwater-utilities/12_certifications/092_certifications_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-098-highwater-utilities/12_certifications/093_certifications_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-098-highwater-utilities/12_certifications/094_certifications_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-098-highwater-utilities/12_certifications/095_certifications_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-098-highwater-utilities/12_certifications/096_certifications_status_report.md"], "gold_output": {"advice_markdown": "# Counsel advice — Highwater board independence audit\n\n## Executive assessment\n\nFor Highwater Utilities, Inc. matter CB-PC-3308, the review identified 16 source-supported exceptions requiring action before 2026-09-28. The assessment concerns Nominating Committee and the supplied record for Oregon.\n\n## Method and record coverage\n\nThe review inventoried all 96 production files, read the 33 controlling, corroborating, and control records, searched the email exports, and checked metadata for the designated chain-of-custody sample. Conclusions are limited to the synthetic production supplied for this benchmark matter.\n\n## Findings\n\n### F-01 — committee-independence gap (critical)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for committee-independence gap: one source states the operative date is 2025-08-09 under control reference CB-PC-3308-A978, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2025-09-18 under response reference CB-PC-3308-J167.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/01_board_committees/001_board_committees_control_register.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/07_equity_compensation/049_equity_compensation_control_register.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-28, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Sofia Bennett.\n\n### F-02 — minutes-approval omission (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for minutes-approval omission: one source states the controlling amount is $6,049,491.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $6,295,482.00.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/01_board_committees/004_board_committees_ledger_export.csv`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/07_equity_compensation/052_equity_compensation_ledger_export.csv`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-28, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Adrian Mensah.\n\n### F-03 — 8-K deadline (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for 8-K deadline: one source states approval is attributed to Jonas Feld as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Micah Sullivan and contains no entry for Jonas Feld.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/01_board_committees/007_board_committees_officer_certificate.html`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/07_equity_compensation/055_equity_compensation_officer_certificate.html`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-28, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Willa Novak.\n\n### F-04 — risk-factor inconsistency (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for risk-factor inconsistency: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-PC-3308-D521, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-PC-3308-M963.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/010_minutes_materials_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/08_earnings_guidance/058_earnings_guidance_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-28, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Theo Laurent.\n\n### F-05 — disclosure-control exception (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for disclosure-control exception: one source states the applicable location is New York Stock Exchange, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to Oregon operations outside New York Stock Exchange.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/013_minutes_materials_review_memorandum.json`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/08_earnings_guidance/061_earnings_guidance_review_memorandum.json`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-28, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Amara Patel.\n\n### F-06 — trading-window violation (low)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for trading-window violation: one source states the threshold is 2% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 4% and produced a different exception result.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/016_minutes_materials_status_report.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/08_earnings_guidance/064_earnings_guidance_status_report.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-28, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Henry Cho.\n\n### F-07 — Section 16 filing delay (critical)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for Section 16 filing delay: one source states formal notice must use notices-highwater_utilities_inc@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-nominating_committee@example.test.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/019_sec_filings_correspondence.eml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/09_whistleblower/067_whistleblower_correspondence.eml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-28, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Nadine Flores.\n\n### F-08 — related-party disclosure gap (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for related-party disclosure gap: one source states the governed population contains 182 records through 2026-02-21, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 52 records through 2026-03-17.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/022_sec_filings_formal_notice.xml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/09_whistleblower/070_whistleblower_formal_notice.xml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-28, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Micah Sullivan.\n\n### F-09 — equity-plan share mismatch (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for equity-plan share mismatch: one source states the operative date is 2025-12-21 under control reference CB-PC-3308-I692, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2026-01-05 under response reference CB-PC-3308-R422.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/025_disclosure_controls_control_register.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/10_stock_exchange/073_stock_exchange_control_register.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-28, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Farah Ibrahim.\n\n### F-10 — non-GAAP reconciliation issue (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for non-GAAP reconciliation issue: one source states the controlling amount is $3,212,324.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $3,371,148.00.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/028_disclosure_controls_ledger_export.csv`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/10_stock_exchange/076_stock_exchange_ledger_export.csv`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-28, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Owen Delgado.\n\n### F-11 — guidance-control failure (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for guidance-control failure: one source states approval is attributed to Jonas Feld as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Isaac Romero and contains no entry for Jonas Feld.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/031_disclosure_controls_officer_certificate.html`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/10_stock_exchange/079_stock_exchange_officer_certificate.html`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-28, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Lena Varga.\n\n### F-12 — whistleblower escalation delay (low)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for whistleblower escalation delay: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-PC-3308-L594, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-PC-3308-U345.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/034_insider_trading_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/11_debt_covenants/082_debt_covenants_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-28, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Samuel Kim.\n\n### F-13 — listing-standard notice (critical)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for listing-standard notice: one source states the applicable location is New York Stock Exchange, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to Oregon operations outside New York Stock Exchange.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/037_insider_trading_review_memorandum.json`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/11_debt_covenants/085_debt_covenants_review_memorandum.json`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-28, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Maya Ellison.\n\n### F-14 — debt-covenant disclosure (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for debt-covenant disclosure: one source states the threshold is 3% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 10% and produced a different exception result.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/040_insider_trading_status_report.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/11_debt_covenants/088_debt_covenants_status_report.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-28, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Rafael Okafor.\n\n### F-15 — officer certification exception (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for officer certification exception: one source states formal notice must use notices-highwater_utilities_inc@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-nominating_committee@example.test.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/06_related_parties/043_related_parties_correspondence.eml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/12_certifications/091_certifications_correspondence.eml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-28, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Nora Chen.\n\n### F-16 — board-matrix inconsistency (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for board-matrix inconsistency: one source states the governed population contains 145 records through 2026-01-15, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 55 records through 2026-02-11.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/06_related_parties/046_related_parties_formal_notice.xml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/12_certifications/094_certifications_formal_notice.xml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-09-28, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Dominic Alvarez.\n\n## Recommended next actions\n\nSequence the critical and high findings first, assign the named owners, preserve the cited records, and document any resolution in the controlling matter register before the stated deadline.\n\n## Assumptions and limitations\n\nThis analysis is confined to task cb100-098-highwater-utilities and the supplied synthetic evidence. It does not rely on external facts, does not resolve disputed law, and is not legal advice for a real person or entity.\n", "findings": {"as_of": "2026-09-28", "findings": [{"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/07_equity_compensation/049_equity_compensation_control_register.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for committee-independence gap: one source states the operative date is 2025-08-09 under control reference CB-PC-3308-A978, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2025-09-18 under response reference CB-PC-3308-J167.", "id": "F-01", "issue": "committee-independence gap", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/01_board_committees/001_board_committees_control_register.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-28, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Sofia Bennett.", "severity": "critical"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/07_equity_compensation/052_equity_compensation_ledger_export.csv", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for minutes-approval omission: one source states the controlling amount is $6,049,491.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $6,295,482.00.", "id": "F-02", "issue": "minutes-approval omission", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/01_board_committees/004_board_committees_ledger_export.csv", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-28, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Adrian Mensah.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/07_equity_compensation/055_equity_compensation_officer_certificate.html", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for 8-K deadline: one source states approval is attributed to Jonas Feld as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Micah Sullivan and contains no entry for Jonas Feld.", "id": "F-03", "issue": "8-K deadline", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/01_board_committees/007_board_committees_officer_certificate.html", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-28, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Willa Novak.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/08_earnings_guidance/058_earnings_guidance_executed_instrument.txt", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for risk-factor inconsistency: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-PC-3308-D521, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-PC-3308-M963.", "id": "F-04", "issue": "risk-factor inconsistency", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/010_minutes_materials_executed_instrument.txt", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-28, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Theo Laurent.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/08_earnings_guidance/061_earnings_guidance_review_memorandum.json", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for disclosure-control exception: one source states the applicable location is New York Stock Exchange, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to Oregon operations outside New York Stock Exchange.", "id": "F-05", "issue": "disclosure-control exception", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/013_minutes_materials_review_memorandum.json", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-28, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Amara Patel.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/08_earnings_guidance/064_earnings_guidance_status_report.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for trading-window violation: one source states the threshold is 2% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 4% and produced a different exception result.", "id": "F-06", "issue": "trading-window violation", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/016_minutes_materials_status_report.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-28, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Henry Cho.", "severity": "low"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/09_whistleblower/067_whistleblower_correspondence.eml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for Section 16 filing delay: one source states formal notice must use notices-highwater_utilities_inc@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-nominating_committee@example.test.", "id": "F-07", "issue": "Section 16 filing delay", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/019_sec_filings_correspondence.eml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-28, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Nadine Flores.", "severity": "critical"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/09_whistleblower/070_whistleblower_formal_notice.xml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for related-party disclosure gap: one source states the governed population contains 182 records through 2026-02-21, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 52 records through 2026-03-17.", "id": "F-08", "issue": "related-party disclosure gap", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/022_sec_filings_formal_notice.xml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-28, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Micah Sullivan.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/10_stock_exchange/073_stock_exchange_control_register.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for equity-plan share mismatch: one source states the operative date is 2025-12-21 under control reference CB-PC-3308-I692, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2026-01-05 under response reference CB-PC-3308-R422.", "id": "F-09", "issue": "equity-plan share mismatch", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/025_disclosure_controls_control_register.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-28, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Farah Ibrahim.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/10_stock_exchange/076_stock_exchange_ledger_export.csv", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for non-GAAP reconciliation issue: one source states the controlling amount is $3,212,324.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $3,371,148.00.", "id": "F-10", "issue": "non-GAAP reconciliation issue", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/028_disclosure_controls_ledger_export.csv", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-28, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Owen Delgado.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/10_stock_exchange/079_stock_exchange_officer_certificate.html", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for guidance-control failure: one source states approval is attributed to Jonas Feld as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Isaac Romero and contains no entry for Jonas Feld.", "id": "F-11", "issue": "guidance-control failure", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/031_disclosure_controls_officer_certificate.html", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-28, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Lena Varga.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/11_debt_covenants/082_debt_covenants_executed_instrument.txt", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for whistleblower escalation delay: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-PC-3308-L594, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-PC-3308-U345.", "id": "F-12", "issue": "whistleblower escalation delay", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/034_insider_trading_executed_instrument.txt", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-28, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Samuel Kim.", "severity": "low"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/11_debt_covenants/085_debt_covenants_review_memorandum.json", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for listing-standard notice: one source states the applicable location is New York Stock Exchange, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to Oregon operations outside New York Stock Exchange.", "id": "F-13", "issue": "listing-standard notice", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/037_insider_trading_review_memorandum.json", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-28, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Maya Ellison.", "severity": "critical"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/11_debt_covenants/088_debt_covenants_status_report.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for debt-covenant disclosure: one source states the threshold is 3% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 10% and produced a different exception result.", "id": "F-14", "issue": "debt-covenant disclosure", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/040_insider_trading_status_report.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-28, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Rafael Okafor.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/12_certifications/091_certifications_correspondence.eml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for officer certification exception: one source states formal notice must use notices-highwater_utilities_inc@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-nominating_committee@example.test.", "id": "F-15", "issue": "officer certification exception", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/06_related_parties/043_related_parties_correspondence.eml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-28, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Nora Chen.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/12_certifications/094_certifications_formal_notice.xml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for board-matrix inconsistency: one source states the governed population contains 145 records through 2026-01-15, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 55 records through 2026-02-11.", "id": "F-16", "issue": "board-matrix inconsistency", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/06_related_parties/046_related_parties_formal_notice.xml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-09-28, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Dominic Alvarez.", "severity": "medium"}], "matter_number": "CB-PC-3308", "prepared_for": "Highwater Utilities, Inc.", "schema_version": "1.0", "task_id": "cb100-098-highwater-utilities"}}, "metadata": {"benchmark": "CounselBench-100", "code_license": "Apache-2.0", "data_license": "CC-BY-4.0", "deadline": "2026-09-28", "document_count": 96, "jurisdiction": "Oregon", "matter_number": "CB-PC-3308", "mcp_commit": "9a96ea6e5913736f92b88345bf51caeaaa8e719f", "mcp_package": "@modelcontextprotocol/server-filesystem@2026.7.10", "practice_area": "public-company", "reference_tool_calls": 46, "required_evidence_reads": 33, "synthetic": true, "venue": "New York Stock Exchange", "version": "2.0.0"}, "prompt": "You are securities and governance counsel for Highwater Utilities, Inc. The supervising attorney wants an exception-focused review that still demonstrates complete coverage of the data room. Consulting payments, family ties, committee appointments, and questionnaires affect director independence and board-matrix disclosures. Decision due 2026-09-28. Oregon law governs; New York Stock Exchange is the forum. Preserve the difference between the client's position, the counterparty's position, and an objective record conflict. Work out the defensible position from the matter production and leave an audit-ready exception tracker and concise advice for the supervising lawyer. Keep confirmed conflicts separate from open questions, cite the records that actually control each conclusion, and do not fill gaps with outside facts.", "rubric": {"criteria": [{"category": "procedure", "description": "Complete at least 46 successful, argument-specific evidence and output calls.", "id": "procedure.minimum_successful_tool_calls"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Find and read the 33 controlling, corroborating, and work-product-control records in full.", "id": "procedure.all_evidence_read_in_full"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Inspect file metadata for the eight designated critical primary records before relying on them.", "id": "procedure.chain_of_custody_metadata_checked"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Confirm the sandbox's allowed document and output roots.", "id": "procedure.allowed_directories_checked"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Inventory all 96 records so the relevant sources are discovered among the context records.", "id": "procedure.recursive_inventory_completed"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Search the production for email evidence that may corroborate or contradict formal records.", "id": "procedure.targeted_search_completed"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Leave only findings.json and advice.md in the output workspace.", "id": "procedure.exact_deliverable_set"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Create both final work products through the sandbox MCP surface.", "id": "procedure.deliverables_written_through_mcp"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Produce findings.json as a valid JSON object.", "id": "findings.findings_is_object"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Report exactly 16 confirmed exceptions.", "id": "findings.findings_exact_count"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Use each stable finding ID exactly once.", "id": "findings.finding_ids_unique"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set schema_version to the released matter value '1.0'.", "id": "findings.top_level_schema_version"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set task_id to the released matter value 'cb100-098-highwater-utilities'.", "id": "findings.top_level_task_id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set matter_number to the released matter value 'CB-PC-3308'.", "id": "findings.top_level_matter_number"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set prepared_for to the released matter value 'Highwater Utilities, Inc.'.", "id": "findings.top_level_prepared_for"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set as_of to the released matter value '2026-09-28'.", "id": "findings.top_level_as_of"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-01 exception for committee-independence gap.", "id": "findings.F-01.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's id from /workspace/documents/01_board_committees/001_board_committees_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_equity_compensation/049_equity_compensation_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's issue from /workspace/documents/01_board_committees/001_board_committees_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_equity_compensation/049_equity_compensation_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's severity from /workspace/documents/01_board_committees/001_board_committees_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_equity_compensation/049_equity_compensation_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's primary_source from /workspace/documents/01_board_committees/001_board_committees_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_equity_compensation/049_equity_compensation_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/01_board_committees/001_board_committees_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_equity_compensation/049_equity_compensation_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-01 using the exact controlled facts ['2025-08-09', 'CB-PC-3308-A978', '2025-09-18', 'CB-PC-3308-J167'].", "id": "findings.F-01.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-01's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-01.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-28', 'Sofia Bennett'] for F-01.", "id": "findings.F-01.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-02 exception for minutes-approval omission.", "id": "findings.F-02.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's id from /workspace/documents/01_board_committees/004_board_committees_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_equity_compensation/052_equity_compensation_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's issue from /workspace/documents/01_board_committees/004_board_committees_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_equity_compensation/052_equity_compensation_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's severity from /workspace/documents/01_board_committees/004_board_committees_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_equity_compensation/052_equity_compensation_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's primary_source from /workspace/documents/01_board_committees/004_board_committees_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_equity_compensation/052_equity_compensation_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/01_board_committees/004_board_committees_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_equity_compensation/052_equity_compensation_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-02 using the exact controlled facts ['$6,049,491.00', '$6,295,482.00'].", "id": "findings.F-02.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-02's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-02.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-28', 'Adrian Mensah'] for F-02.", "id": "findings.F-02.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-03 exception for 8-K deadline.", "id": "findings.F-03.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's id from /workspace/documents/01_board_committees/007_board_committees_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_equity_compensation/055_equity_compensation_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's issue from /workspace/documents/01_board_committees/007_board_committees_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_equity_compensation/055_equity_compensation_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's severity from /workspace/documents/01_board_committees/007_board_committees_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_equity_compensation/055_equity_compensation_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's primary_source from /workspace/documents/01_board_committees/007_board_committees_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_equity_compensation/055_equity_compensation_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/01_board_committees/007_board_committees_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_equity_compensation/055_equity_compensation_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-03 using the exact controlled facts ['Jonas Feld', 'Micah Sullivan'].", "id": "findings.F-03.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-03's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-03.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-28', 'Willa Novak'] for F-03.", "id": "findings.F-03.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-04 exception for risk-factor inconsistency.", "id": "findings.F-04.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's id from /workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/010_minutes_materials_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_earnings_guidance/058_earnings_guidance_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's issue from /workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/010_minutes_materials_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_earnings_guidance/058_earnings_guidance_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's severity from /workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/010_minutes_materials_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_earnings_guidance/058_earnings_guidance_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's primary_source from /workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/010_minutes_materials_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_earnings_guidance/058_earnings_guidance_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/010_minutes_materials_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_earnings_guidance/058_earnings_guidance_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-04 using the exact controlled facts ['closed without exception', 'CB-PC-3308-D521', 'open and escalated', 'CB-PC-3308-M963'].", "id": "findings.F-04.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-04's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-04.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-28', 'Theo Laurent'] for F-04.", "id": "findings.F-04.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-05 exception for disclosure-control exception.", "id": "findings.F-05.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's id from /workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/013_minutes_materials_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_earnings_guidance/061_earnings_guidance_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's issue from /workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/013_minutes_materials_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_earnings_guidance/061_earnings_guidance_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's severity from /workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/013_minutes_materials_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_earnings_guidance/061_earnings_guidance_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's primary_source from /workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/013_minutes_materials_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_earnings_guidance/061_earnings_guidance_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/013_minutes_materials_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_earnings_guidance/061_earnings_guidance_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-05 using the exact controlled facts ['New York Stock Exchange', 'Oregon'].", "id": "findings.F-05.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-05's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-05.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-28', 'Amara Patel'] for F-05.", "id": "findings.F-05.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-06 exception for trading-window violation.", "id": "findings.F-06.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's id from /workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/016_minutes_materials_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_earnings_guidance/064_earnings_guidance_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's issue from /workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/016_minutes_materials_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_earnings_guidance/064_earnings_guidance_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's severity from /workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/016_minutes_materials_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_earnings_guidance/064_earnings_guidance_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's primary_source from /workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/016_minutes_materials_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_earnings_guidance/064_earnings_guidance_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/016_minutes_materials_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_earnings_guidance/064_earnings_guidance_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-06 using the exact controlled facts ['2%', '4%'].", "id": "findings.F-06.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-06's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-06.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-28', 'Henry Cho'] for F-06.", "id": "findings.F-06.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-07 exception for Section 16 filing delay.", "id": "findings.F-07.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's id from /workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/019_sec_filings_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_whistleblower/067_whistleblower_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's issue from /workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/019_sec_filings_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_whistleblower/067_whistleblower_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's severity from /workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/019_sec_filings_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_whistleblower/067_whistleblower_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's primary_source from /workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/019_sec_filings_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_whistleblower/067_whistleblower_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/019_sec_filings_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_whistleblower/067_whistleblower_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-07 using the exact controlled facts ['notices-highwater_utilities_inc@example.test', 'archive-nominating_committee@example.test'].", "id": "findings.F-07.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-07's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-07.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-28', 'Nadine Flores'] for F-07.", "id": "findings.F-07.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-08 exception for related-party disclosure gap.", "id": "findings.F-08.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's id from /workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/022_sec_filings_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_whistleblower/070_whistleblower_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's issue from /workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/022_sec_filings_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_whistleblower/070_whistleblower_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's severity from /workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/022_sec_filings_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_whistleblower/070_whistleblower_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's primary_source from /workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/022_sec_filings_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_whistleblower/070_whistleblower_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/022_sec_filings_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_whistleblower/070_whistleblower_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-08 using the exact controlled facts ['182 records', '2026-02-21', '52 records', '2026-03-17'].", "id": "findings.F-08.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-08's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-08.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-28', 'Micah Sullivan'] for F-08.", "id": "findings.F-08.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-09 exception for equity-plan share mismatch.", "id": "findings.F-09.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's id from /workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/025_disclosure_controls_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_stock_exchange/073_stock_exchange_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's issue from /workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/025_disclosure_controls_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_stock_exchange/073_stock_exchange_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's severity from /workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/025_disclosure_controls_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_stock_exchange/073_stock_exchange_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's primary_source from /workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/025_disclosure_controls_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_stock_exchange/073_stock_exchange_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/025_disclosure_controls_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_stock_exchange/073_stock_exchange_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-09 using the exact controlled facts ['2025-12-21', 'CB-PC-3308-I692', '2026-01-05', 'CB-PC-3308-R422'].", "id": "findings.F-09.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-09's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-09.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-28', 'Farah Ibrahim'] for F-09.", "id": "findings.F-09.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-10 exception for non-GAAP reconciliation issue.", "id": "findings.F-10.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's id from /workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/028_disclosure_controls_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_stock_exchange/076_stock_exchange_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's issue from /workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/028_disclosure_controls_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_stock_exchange/076_stock_exchange_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's severity from /workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/028_disclosure_controls_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_stock_exchange/076_stock_exchange_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's primary_source from /workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/028_disclosure_controls_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_stock_exchange/076_stock_exchange_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/028_disclosure_controls_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_stock_exchange/076_stock_exchange_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-10 using the exact controlled facts ['$3,212,324.00', '$3,371,148.00'].", "id": "findings.F-10.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-10's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-10.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-28', 'Owen Delgado'] for F-10.", "id": "findings.F-10.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-11 exception for guidance-control failure.", "id": "findings.F-11.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's id from /workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/031_disclosure_controls_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_stock_exchange/079_stock_exchange_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's issue from /workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/031_disclosure_controls_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_stock_exchange/079_stock_exchange_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's severity from /workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/031_disclosure_controls_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_stock_exchange/079_stock_exchange_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's primary_source from /workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/031_disclosure_controls_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_stock_exchange/079_stock_exchange_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/031_disclosure_controls_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_stock_exchange/079_stock_exchange_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-11 using the exact controlled facts ['Jonas Feld', 'Isaac Romero'].", "id": "findings.F-11.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-11's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-11.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-28', 'Lena Varga'] for F-11.", "id": "findings.F-11.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-12 exception for whistleblower escalation delay.", "id": "findings.F-12.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's id from /workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/034_insider_trading_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_debt_covenants/082_debt_covenants_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's issue from /workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/034_insider_trading_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_debt_covenants/082_debt_covenants_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's severity from /workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/034_insider_trading_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_debt_covenants/082_debt_covenants_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's primary_source from /workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/034_insider_trading_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_debt_covenants/082_debt_covenants_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/034_insider_trading_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_debt_covenants/082_debt_covenants_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-12 using the exact controlled facts ['closed without exception', 'CB-PC-3308-L594', 'open and escalated', 'CB-PC-3308-U345'].", "id": "findings.F-12.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-12's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-12.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-28', 'Samuel Kim'] for F-12.", "id": "findings.F-12.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-13 exception for listing-standard notice.", "id": "findings.F-13.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's id from /workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/037_insider_trading_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_debt_covenants/085_debt_covenants_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's issue from /workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/037_insider_trading_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_debt_covenants/085_debt_covenants_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's severity from /workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/037_insider_trading_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_debt_covenants/085_debt_covenants_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's primary_source from /workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/037_insider_trading_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_debt_covenants/085_debt_covenants_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/037_insider_trading_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_debt_covenants/085_debt_covenants_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-13 using the exact controlled facts ['New York Stock Exchange', 'Oregon'].", "id": "findings.F-13.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-13's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-13.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-28', 'Maya Ellison'] for F-13.", "id": "findings.F-13.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-14 exception for debt-covenant disclosure.", "id": "findings.F-14.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's id from /workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/040_insider_trading_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_debt_covenants/088_debt_covenants_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's issue from /workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/040_insider_trading_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_debt_covenants/088_debt_covenants_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's severity from /workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/040_insider_trading_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_debt_covenants/088_debt_covenants_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's primary_source from /workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/040_insider_trading_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_debt_covenants/088_debt_covenants_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/040_insider_trading_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_debt_covenants/088_debt_covenants_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-14 using the exact controlled facts ['3%', '10%'].", "id": "findings.F-14.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-14's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-14.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-28', 'Rafael Okafor'] for F-14.", "id": "findings.F-14.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-15 exception for officer certification exception.", "id": "findings.F-15.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's id from /workspace/documents/06_related_parties/043_related_parties_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_certifications/091_certifications_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's issue from /workspace/documents/06_related_parties/043_related_parties_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_certifications/091_certifications_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's severity from /workspace/documents/06_related_parties/043_related_parties_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_certifications/091_certifications_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's primary_source from /workspace/documents/06_related_parties/043_related_parties_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_certifications/091_certifications_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/06_related_parties/043_related_parties_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_certifications/091_certifications_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-15 using the exact controlled facts ['notices-highwater_utilities_inc@example.test', 'archive-nominating_committee@example.test'].", "id": "findings.F-15.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-15's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-15.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-28', 'Nora Chen'] for F-15.", "id": "findings.F-15.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-16 exception for board-matrix inconsistency.", "id": "findings.F-16.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's id from /workspace/documents/06_related_parties/046_related_parties_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_certifications/094_certifications_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's issue from /workspace/documents/06_related_parties/046_related_parties_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_certifications/094_certifications_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's severity from /workspace/documents/06_related_parties/046_related_parties_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_certifications/094_certifications_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's primary_source from /workspace/documents/06_related_parties/046_related_parties_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_certifications/094_certifications_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/06_related_parties/046_related_parties_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_certifications/094_certifications_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-16 using the exact controlled facts ['145 records', '2026-01-15', '55 records', '2026-02-11'].", "id": "findings.F-16.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-16's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-16.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-09-28', 'Dominic Alvarez'] for F-16.", "id": "findings.F-16.action_anchors"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Executive assessment' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Executive assessment"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Method and record coverage' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Method and record coverage"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Findings' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Findings"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Recommended next actions' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Recommended next actions"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Assumptions and limitations' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Assumptions and limitations"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-01 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-01"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-02 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-02"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-03 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-03"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-04 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-04"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-05 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-05"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-06 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-06"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-07 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-07"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-08 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-08"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-09 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-09"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-10 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-10"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-11 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-11"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-12 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-12"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-13 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-13"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-14 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-14"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-15 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-15"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-16 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-16"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Do not claim the production has no issues or that every record is consistent.", "id": "memo.forbidden_claims_absent"}], "decision_options": [{"id": "cross-source-reconciliation", "label": "Reconcile controlling and corroborating records", "reason": "The CB-PC-3308 production contains independently maintained records; a defensible answer must preserve each supported conflict and its cure owner.", "selected": true}, {"id": "latest-record-controls", "label": "Treat the latest record as controlling", "reason": "Timestamp recency does not establish legal priority, execution, or approval authority.", "selected": false}, {"id": "primary-records-only", "label": "Report primary records without reconciliation", "reason": "Primary records alone conceal the operational conflicts that create the actionable exceptions.", "selected": false}], "gates": ["all_evidence_read_in_full", "chain_of_custody_metadata_checked", "findings_criteria_complete", "memo_criteria_complete", "deliverables_written_through_mcp"], "metadata_checks": 8, "metric": "weighted_criteria_score", "minimum_tool_calls": 46, "required_deliverables": ["findings.json", "advice.md"], "required_document_reads": 33, "type": "deterministic", "weights": {"findings": 0.55, "memo": 0.2, "procedure": 0.25}}, "task_id": "cb100-098-highwater-utilities", "task_name": "Highwater board independence audit", "world_id": "counselbench-filesystem-mcp-v2"}
-{"context_files": ["task_files/cb100-099-ironclad-logistics/01_board_committees/001_board_committees_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-099-ironclad-logistics/01_board_committees/002_board_committees_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-099-ironclad-logistics/01_board_committees/003_board_committees_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-099-ironclad-logistics/01_board_committees/004_board_committees_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-099-ironclad-logistics/01_board_committees/005_board_committees_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-099-ironclad-logistics/01_board_committees/006_board_committees_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-099-ironclad-logistics/01_board_committees/007_board_committees_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-099-ironclad-logistics/01_board_committees/008_board_committees_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-099-ironclad-logistics/02_minutes_materials/009_minutes_materials_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-099-ironclad-logistics/02_minutes_materials/010_minutes_materials_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-099-ironclad-logistics/02_minutes_materials/011_minutes_materials_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-099-ironclad-logistics/02_minutes_materials/012_minutes_materials_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-099-ironclad-logistics/02_minutes_materials/013_minutes_materials_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-099-ironclad-logistics/02_minutes_materials/014_minutes_materials_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-099-ironclad-logistics/02_minutes_materials/015_minutes_materials_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-099-ironclad-logistics/02_minutes_materials/016_minutes_materials_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-099-ironclad-logistics/03_sec_filings/017_sec_filings_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-099-ironclad-logistics/03_sec_filings/018_sec_filings_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-099-ironclad-logistics/03_sec_filings/019_sec_filings_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-099-ironclad-logistics/03_sec_filings/020_sec_filings_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-099-ironclad-logistics/03_sec_filings/021_sec_filings_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-099-ironclad-logistics/03_sec_filings/022_sec_filings_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-099-ironclad-logistics/03_sec_filings/023_sec_filings_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-099-ironclad-logistics/03_sec_filings/024_sec_filings_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-099-ironclad-logistics/04_disclosure_controls/025_disclosure_controls_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-099-ironclad-logistics/04_disclosure_controls/026_disclosure_controls_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-099-ironclad-logistics/04_disclosure_controls/027_disclosure_controls_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-099-ironclad-logistics/04_disclosure_controls/028_disclosure_controls_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-099-ironclad-logistics/04_disclosure_controls/029_disclosure_controls_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-099-ironclad-logistics/04_disclosure_controls/030_disclosure_controls_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-099-ironclad-logistics/04_disclosure_controls/031_disclosure_controls_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-099-ironclad-logistics/04_disclosure_controls/032_disclosure_controls_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-099-ironclad-logistics/05_insider_trading/033_insider_trading_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-099-ironclad-logistics/05_insider_trading/034_insider_trading_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-099-ironclad-logistics/05_insider_trading/035_insider_trading_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-099-ironclad-logistics/05_insider_trading/036_insider_trading_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-099-ironclad-logistics/05_insider_trading/037_insider_trading_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-099-ironclad-logistics/05_insider_trading/038_insider_trading_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-099-ironclad-logistics/05_insider_trading/039_insider_trading_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-099-ironclad-logistics/05_insider_trading/040_insider_trading_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-099-ironclad-logistics/06_related_parties/041_related_parties_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-099-ironclad-logistics/06_related_parties/042_related_parties_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-099-ironclad-logistics/06_related_parties/043_related_parties_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-099-ironclad-logistics/06_related_parties/044_related_parties_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-099-ironclad-logistics/06_related_parties/045_related_parties_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-099-ironclad-logistics/06_related_parties/046_related_parties_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-099-ironclad-logistics/06_related_parties/047_related_parties_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-099-ironclad-logistics/06_related_parties/048_related_parties_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-099-ironclad-logistics/07_equity_compensation/049_equity_compensation_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-099-ironclad-logistics/07_equity_compensation/050_equity_compensation_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-099-ironclad-logistics/07_equity_compensation/051_equity_compensation_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-099-ironclad-logistics/07_equity_compensation/052_equity_compensation_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-099-ironclad-logistics/07_equity_compensation/053_equity_compensation_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-099-ironclad-logistics/07_equity_compensation/054_equity_compensation_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-099-ironclad-logistics/07_equity_compensation/055_equity_compensation_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-099-ironclad-logistics/07_equity_compensation/056_equity_compensation_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-099-ironclad-logistics/08_earnings_guidance/057_earnings_guidance_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-099-ironclad-logistics/08_earnings_guidance/058_earnings_guidance_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-099-ironclad-logistics/08_earnings_guidance/059_earnings_guidance_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-099-ironclad-logistics/08_earnings_guidance/060_earnings_guidance_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-099-ironclad-logistics/08_earnings_guidance/061_earnings_guidance_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-099-ironclad-logistics/08_earnings_guidance/062_earnings_guidance_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-099-ironclad-logistics/08_earnings_guidance/063_earnings_guidance_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-099-ironclad-logistics/08_earnings_guidance/064_earnings_guidance_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-099-ironclad-logistics/09_whistleblower/065_whistleblower_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-099-ironclad-logistics/09_whistleblower/066_whistleblower_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-099-ironclad-logistics/09_whistleblower/067_whistleblower_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-099-ironclad-logistics/09_whistleblower/068_whistleblower_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-099-ironclad-logistics/09_whistleblower/069_whistleblower_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-099-ironclad-logistics/09_whistleblower/070_whistleblower_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-099-ironclad-logistics/09_whistleblower/071_whistleblower_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-099-ironclad-logistics/09_whistleblower/072_whistleblower_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-099-ironclad-logistics/10_stock_exchange/073_stock_exchange_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-099-ironclad-logistics/10_stock_exchange/074_stock_exchange_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-099-ironclad-logistics/10_stock_exchange/075_stock_exchange_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-099-ironclad-logistics/10_stock_exchange/076_stock_exchange_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-099-ironclad-logistics/10_stock_exchange/077_stock_exchange_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-099-ironclad-logistics/10_stock_exchange/078_stock_exchange_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-099-ironclad-logistics/10_stock_exchange/079_stock_exchange_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-099-ironclad-logistics/10_stock_exchange/080_stock_exchange_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-099-ironclad-logistics/11_debt_covenants/081_debt_covenants_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-099-ironclad-logistics/11_debt_covenants/082_debt_covenants_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-099-ironclad-logistics/11_debt_covenants/083_debt_covenants_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-099-ironclad-logistics/11_debt_covenants/084_debt_covenants_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-099-ironclad-logistics/11_debt_covenants/085_debt_covenants_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-099-ironclad-logistics/11_debt_covenants/086_debt_covenants_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-099-ironclad-logistics/11_debt_covenants/087_debt_covenants_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-099-ironclad-logistics/11_debt_covenants/088_debt_covenants_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-099-ironclad-logistics/12_certifications/089_certifications_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-099-ironclad-logistics/12_certifications/090_certifications_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-099-ironclad-logistics/12_certifications/091_certifications_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-099-ironclad-logistics/12_certifications/092_certifications_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-099-ironclad-logistics/12_certifications/093_certifications_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-099-ironclad-logistics/12_certifications/094_certifications_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-099-ironclad-logistics/12_certifications/095_certifications_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-099-ironclad-logistics/12_certifications/096_certifications_status_report.md"], "gold_output": {"advice_markdown": "# Counsel advice — Ironclad trading-window inquiry\n\n## Executive assessment\n\nFor Ironclad Logistics Corp. matter CB-PC-3309, the review identified 16 source-supported exceptions requiring action before 2026-10-01. The assessment concerns Special Committee and the supplied record for Georgia.\n\n## Method and record coverage\n\nThe review inventoried all 96 production files, read the 33 controlling, corroborating, and control records, searched the email exports, and checked metadata for the designated chain-of-custody sample. Conclusions are limited to the synthetic production supplied for this benchmark matter.\n\n## Findings\n\n### F-01 — committee-independence gap (critical)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for committee-independence gap: one source states the operative date is 2025-06-06 under control reference CB-PC-3309-A194, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2025-07-22 under response reference CB-PC-3309-J245.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/01_board_committees/001_board_committees_control_register.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/07_equity_compensation/049_equity_compensation_control_register.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-10-01, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Adrian Mensah.\n\n### F-02 — minutes-approval omission (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for minutes-approval omission: one source states the controlling amount is $834,750.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $1,136,000.00.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/01_board_committees/004_board_committees_ledger_export.csv`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/07_equity_compensation/052_equity_compensation_ledger_export.csv`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-10-01, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Willa Novak.\n\n### F-03 — 8-K deadline (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for 8-K deadline: one source states approval is attributed to Mei Whitaker as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Owen Delgado and contains no entry for Mei Whitaker.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/01_board_committees/007_board_committees_officer_certificate.html`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/07_equity_compensation/055_equity_compensation_officer_certificate.html`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-10-01, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Theo Laurent.\n\n### F-04 — risk-factor inconsistency (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for risk-factor inconsistency: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-PC-3309-D667, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-PC-3309-M351.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/010_minutes_materials_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/08_earnings_guidance/058_earnings_guidance_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-10-01, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Amara Patel.\n\n### F-05 — disclosure-control exception (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for disclosure-control exception: one source states the applicable location is New York Stock Exchange, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to Georgia operations outside New York Stock Exchange.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/013_minutes_materials_review_memorandum.json`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/08_earnings_guidance/061_earnings_guidance_review_memorandum.json`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-10-01, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Henry Cho.\n\n### F-06 — trading-window violation (low)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for trading-window violation: one source states the threshold is 7% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 14% and produced a different exception result.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/016_minutes_materials_status_report.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/08_earnings_guidance/064_earnings_guidance_status_report.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-10-01, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Nadine Flores.\n\n### F-07 — Section 16 filing delay (critical)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for Section 16 filing delay: one source states formal notice must use notices-ironclad_logistics_corp@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-special_committee@example.test.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/019_sec_filings_correspondence.eml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/09_whistleblower/067_whistleblower_correspondence.eml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-10-01, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Micah Sullivan.\n\n### F-08 — related-party disclosure gap (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for related-party disclosure gap: one source states the governed population contains 91 records through 2025-02-15, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 37 records through 2025-02-24.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/022_sec_filings_formal_notice.xml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/09_whistleblower/070_whistleblower_formal_notice.xml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-10-01, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Farah Ibrahim.\n\n### F-09 — equity-plan share mismatch (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for equity-plan share mismatch: one source states the operative date is 2025-09-12 under control reference CB-PC-3309-I532, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2025-10-15 under response reference CB-PC-3309-R756.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/025_disclosure_controls_control_register.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/10_stock_exchange/073_stock_exchange_control_register.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-10-01, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Owen Delgado.\n\n### F-10 — non-GAAP reconciliation issue (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for non-GAAP reconciliation issue: one source states the controlling amount is $4,223,792.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $4,324,084.00.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/028_disclosure_controls_ledger_export.csv`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/10_stock_exchange/076_stock_exchange_ledger_export.csv`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-10-01, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Lena Varga.\n\n### F-11 — guidance-control failure (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for guidance-control failure: one source states approval is attributed to Mei Whitaker as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Adrian Mensah and contains no entry for Mei Whitaker.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/031_disclosure_controls_officer_certificate.html`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/10_stock_exchange/079_stock_exchange_officer_certificate.html`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-10-01, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Samuel Kim.\n\n### F-12 — whistleblower escalation delay (low)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for whistleblower escalation delay: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-PC-3309-L221, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-PC-3309-U109.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/034_insider_trading_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/11_debt_covenants/082_debt_covenants_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-10-01, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Maya Ellison.\n\n### F-13 — listing-standard notice (critical)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for listing-standard notice: one source states the applicable location is New York Stock Exchange, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to Georgia operations outside New York Stock Exchange.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/037_insider_trading_review_memorandum.json`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/11_debt_covenants/085_debt_covenants_review_memorandum.json`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-10-01, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Rafael Okafor.\n\n### F-14 — debt-covenant disclosure (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for debt-covenant disclosure: one source states the threshold is 13% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 20% and produced a different exception result.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/040_insider_trading_status_report.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/11_debt_covenants/088_debt_covenants_status_report.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-10-01, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Nora Chen.\n\n### F-15 — officer certification exception (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for officer certification exception: one source states formal notice must use notices-ironclad_logistics_corp@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-special_committee@example.test.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/06_related_parties/043_related_parties_correspondence.eml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/12_certifications/091_certifications_correspondence.eml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-10-01, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Dominic Alvarez.\n\n### F-16 — board-matrix inconsistency (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for board-matrix inconsistency: one source states the governed population contains 66 records through 2025-10-28, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 36 records through 2025-11-05.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/06_related_parties/046_related_parties_formal_notice.xml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/12_certifications/094_certifications_formal_notice.xml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-10-01, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Priya Raman.\n\n## Recommended next actions\n\nSequence the critical and high findings first, assign the named owners, preserve the cited records, and document any resolution in the controlling matter register before the stated deadline.\n\n## Assumptions and limitations\n\nThis analysis is confined to task cb100-099-ironclad-logistics and the supplied synthetic evidence. It does not rely on external facts, does not resolve disputed law, and is not legal advice for a real person or entity.\n", "findings": {"as_of": "2026-10-01", "findings": [{"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/07_equity_compensation/049_equity_compensation_control_register.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for committee-independence gap: one source states the operative date is 2025-06-06 under control reference CB-PC-3309-A194, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2025-07-22 under response reference CB-PC-3309-J245.", "id": "F-01", "issue": "committee-independence gap", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/01_board_committees/001_board_committees_control_register.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-10-01, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Adrian Mensah.", "severity": "critical"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/07_equity_compensation/052_equity_compensation_ledger_export.csv", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for minutes-approval omission: one source states the controlling amount is $834,750.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $1,136,000.00.", "id": "F-02", "issue": "minutes-approval omission", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/01_board_committees/004_board_committees_ledger_export.csv", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-10-01, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Willa Novak.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/07_equity_compensation/055_equity_compensation_officer_certificate.html", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for 8-K deadline: one source states approval is attributed to Mei Whitaker as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Owen Delgado and contains no entry for Mei Whitaker.", "id": "F-03", "issue": "8-K deadline", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/01_board_committees/007_board_committees_officer_certificate.html", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-10-01, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Theo Laurent.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/08_earnings_guidance/058_earnings_guidance_executed_instrument.txt", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for risk-factor inconsistency: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-PC-3309-D667, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-PC-3309-M351.", "id": "F-04", "issue": "risk-factor inconsistency", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/010_minutes_materials_executed_instrument.txt", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-10-01, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Amara Patel.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/08_earnings_guidance/061_earnings_guidance_review_memorandum.json", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for disclosure-control exception: one source states the applicable location is New York Stock Exchange, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to Georgia operations outside New York Stock Exchange.", "id": "F-05", "issue": "disclosure-control exception", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/013_minutes_materials_review_memorandum.json", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-10-01, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Henry Cho.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/08_earnings_guidance/064_earnings_guidance_status_report.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for trading-window violation: one source states the threshold is 7% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 14% and produced a different exception result.", "id": "F-06", "issue": "trading-window violation", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/016_minutes_materials_status_report.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-10-01, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Nadine Flores.", "severity": "low"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/09_whistleblower/067_whistleblower_correspondence.eml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for Section 16 filing delay: one source states formal notice must use notices-ironclad_logistics_corp@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-special_committee@example.test.", "id": "F-07", "issue": "Section 16 filing delay", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/019_sec_filings_correspondence.eml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-10-01, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Micah Sullivan.", "severity": "critical"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/09_whistleblower/070_whistleblower_formal_notice.xml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for related-party disclosure gap: one source states the governed population contains 91 records through 2025-02-15, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 37 records through 2025-02-24.", "id": "F-08", "issue": "related-party disclosure gap", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/022_sec_filings_formal_notice.xml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-10-01, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Farah Ibrahim.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/10_stock_exchange/073_stock_exchange_control_register.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for equity-plan share mismatch: one source states the operative date is 2025-09-12 under control reference CB-PC-3309-I532, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2025-10-15 under response reference CB-PC-3309-R756.", "id": "F-09", "issue": "equity-plan share mismatch", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/025_disclosure_controls_control_register.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-10-01, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Owen Delgado.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/10_stock_exchange/076_stock_exchange_ledger_export.csv", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for non-GAAP reconciliation issue: one source states the controlling amount is $4,223,792.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $4,324,084.00.", "id": "F-10", "issue": "non-GAAP reconciliation issue", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/028_disclosure_controls_ledger_export.csv", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-10-01, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Lena Varga.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/10_stock_exchange/079_stock_exchange_officer_certificate.html", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for guidance-control failure: one source states approval is attributed to Mei Whitaker as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Adrian Mensah and contains no entry for Mei Whitaker.", "id": "F-11", "issue": "guidance-control failure", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/031_disclosure_controls_officer_certificate.html", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-10-01, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Samuel Kim.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/11_debt_covenants/082_debt_covenants_executed_instrument.txt", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for whistleblower escalation delay: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-PC-3309-L221, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-PC-3309-U109.", "id": "F-12", "issue": "whistleblower escalation delay", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/034_insider_trading_executed_instrument.txt", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-10-01, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Maya Ellison.", "severity": "low"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/11_debt_covenants/085_debt_covenants_review_memorandum.json", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for listing-standard notice: one source states the applicable location is New York Stock Exchange, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to Georgia operations outside New York Stock Exchange.", "id": "F-13", "issue": "listing-standard notice", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/037_insider_trading_review_memorandum.json", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-10-01, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Rafael Okafor.", "severity": "critical"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/11_debt_covenants/088_debt_covenants_status_report.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for debt-covenant disclosure: one source states the threshold is 13% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 20% and produced a different exception result.", "id": "F-14", "issue": "debt-covenant disclosure", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/040_insider_trading_status_report.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-10-01, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Nora Chen.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/12_certifications/091_certifications_correspondence.eml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for officer certification exception: one source states formal notice must use notices-ironclad_logistics_corp@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-special_committee@example.test.", "id": "F-15", "issue": "officer certification exception", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/06_related_parties/043_related_parties_correspondence.eml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-10-01, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Dominic Alvarez.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/12_certifications/094_certifications_formal_notice.xml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for board-matrix inconsistency: one source states the governed population contains 66 records through 2025-10-28, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 36 records through 2025-11-05.", "id": "F-16", "issue": "board-matrix inconsistency", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/06_related_parties/046_related_parties_formal_notice.xml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-10-01, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Priya Raman.", "severity": "medium"}], "matter_number": "CB-PC-3309", "prepared_for": "Ironclad Logistics Corp.", "schema_version": "1.0", "task_id": "cb100-099-ironclad-logistics"}}, "metadata": {"benchmark": "CounselBench-100", "code_license": "Apache-2.0", "data_license": "CC-BY-4.0", "deadline": "2026-10-01", "document_count": 96, "jurisdiction": "Georgia", "matter_number": "CB-PC-3309", "mcp_commit": "9a96ea6e5913736f92b88345bf51caeaaa8e719f", "mcp_package": "@modelcontextprotocol/server-filesystem@2026.7.10", "practice_area": "public-company", "reference_tool_calls": 46, "required_evidence_reads": 33, "synthetic": true, "venue": "New York Stock Exchange", "version": "2.0.0"}, "prompt": "You are securities and governance counsel for Ironclad Logistics Corp. This matter will be reviewed by legal, finance, and compliance stakeholders who need a single source-grounded output. A repurchase update, acquisition talks, executive sale, and preclearance record raise control and disclosure timing questions. Decision due 2026-10-01. Georgia law governs; New York Stock Exchange is the forum. Use the production as of the stated deadline; do not assume facts outside the supplied files. Work out the defensible position from the matter production and leave an audit-ready exception tracker and concise advice for the supervising lawyer. Keep confirmed conflicts separate from open questions, cite the records that actually control each conclusion, and do not fill gaps with outside facts.", "rubric": {"criteria": [{"category": "procedure", "description": "Complete at least 46 successful, argument-specific evidence and output calls.", "id": "procedure.minimum_successful_tool_calls"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Find and read the 33 controlling, corroborating, and work-product-control records in full.", "id": "procedure.all_evidence_read_in_full"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Inspect file metadata for the eight designated critical primary records before relying on them.", "id": "procedure.chain_of_custody_metadata_checked"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Confirm the sandbox's allowed document and output roots.", "id": "procedure.allowed_directories_checked"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Inventory all 96 records so the relevant sources are discovered among the context records.", "id": "procedure.recursive_inventory_completed"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Search the production for email evidence that may corroborate or contradict formal records.", "id": "procedure.targeted_search_completed"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Leave only findings.json and advice.md in the output workspace.", "id": "procedure.exact_deliverable_set"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Create both final work products through the sandbox MCP surface.", "id": "procedure.deliverables_written_through_mcp"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Produce findings.json as a valid JSON object.", "id": "findings.findings_is_object"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Report exactly 16 confirmed exceptions.", "id": "findings.findings_exact_count"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Use each stable finding ID exactly once.", "id": "findings.finding_ids_unique"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set schema_version to the released matter value '1.0'.", "id": "findings.top_level_schema_version"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set task_id to the released matter value 'cb100-099-ironclad-logistics'.", "id": "findings.top_level_task_id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set matter_number to the released matter value 'CB-PC-3309'.", "id": "findings.top_level_matter_number"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set prepared_for to the released matter value 'Ironclad Logistics Corp.'.", "id": "findings.top_level_prepared_for"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set as_of to the released matter value '2026-10-01'.", "id": "findings.top_level_as_of"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-01 exception for committee-independence gap.", "id": "findings.F-01.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's id from /workspace/documents/01_board_committees/001_board_committees_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_equity_compensation/049_equity_compensation_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's issue from /workspace/documents/01_board_committees/001_board_committees_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_equity_compensation/049_equity_compensation_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's severity from /workspace/documents/01_board_committees/001_board_committees_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_equity_compensation/049_equity_compensation_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's primary_source from /workspace/documents/01_board_committees/001_board_committees_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_equity_compensation/049_equity_compensation_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/01_board_committees/001_board_committees_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_equity_compensation/049_equity_compensation_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-01 using the exact controlled facts ['2025-06-06', 'CB-PC-3309-A194', '2025-07-22', 'CB-PC-3309-J245'].", "id": "findings.F-01.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-01's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-01.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-10-01', 'Adrian Mensah'] for F-01.", "id": "findings.F-01.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-02 exception for minutes-approval omission.", "id": "findings.F-02.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's id from /workspace/documents/01_board_committees/004_board_committees_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_equity_compensation/052_equity_compensation_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's issue from /workspace/documents/01_board_committees/004_board_committees_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_equity_compensation/052_equity_compensation_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's severity from /workspace/documents/01_board_committees/004_board_committees_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_equity_compensation/052_equity_compensation_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's primary_source from /workspace/documents/01_board_committees/004_board_committees_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_equity_compensation/052_equity_compensation_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/01_board_committees/004_board_committees_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_equity_compensation/052_equity_compensation_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-02 using the exact controlled facts ['$834,750.00', '$1,136,000.00'].", "id": "findings.F-02.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-02's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-02.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-10-01', 'Willa Novak'] for F-02.", "id": "findings.F-02.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-03 exception for 8-K deadline.", "id": "findings.F-03.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's id from /workspace/documents/01_board_committees/007_board_committees_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_equity_compensation/055_equity_compensation_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's issue from /workspace/documents/01_board_committees/007_board_committees_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_equity_compensation/055_equity_compensation_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's severity from /workspace/documents/01_board_committees/007_board_committees_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_equity_compensation/055_equity_compensation_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's primary_source from /workspace/documents/01_board_committees/007_board_committees_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_equity_compensation/055_equity_compensation_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/01_board_committees/007_board_committees_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_equity_compensation/055_equity_compensation_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-03 using the exact controlled facts ['Mei Whitaker', 'Owen Delgado'].", "id": "findings.F-03.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-03's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-03.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-10-01', 'Theo Laurent'] for F-03.", "id": "findings.F-03.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-04 exception for risk-factor inconsistency.", "id": "findings.F-04.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's id from /workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/010_minutes_materials_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_earnings_guidance/058_earnings_guidance_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's issue from /workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/010_minutes_materials_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_earnings_guidance/058_earnings_guidance_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's severity from /workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/010_minutes_materials_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_earnings_guidance/058_earnings_guidance_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's primary_source from /workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/010_minutes_materials_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_earnings_guidance/058_earnings_guidance_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/010_minutes_materials_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_earnings_guidance/058_earnings_guidance_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-04 using the exact controlled facts ['closed without exception', 'CB-PC-3309-D667', 'open and escalated', 'CB-PC-3309-M351'].", "id": "findings.F-04.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-04's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-04.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-10-01', 'Amara Patel'] for F-04.", "id": "findings.F-04.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-05 exception for disclosure-control exception.", "id": "findings.F-05.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's id from /workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/013_minutes_materials_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_earnings_guidance/061_earnings_guidance_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's issue from /workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/013_minutes_materials_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_earnings_guidance/061_earnings_guidance_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's severity from /workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/013_minutes_materials_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_earnings_guidance/061_earnings_guidance_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's primary_source from /workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/013_minutes_materials_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_earnings_guidance/061_earnings_guidance_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/013_minutes_materials_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_earnings_guidance/061_earnings_guidance_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-05 using the exact controlled facts ['New York Stock Exchange', 'Georgia'].", "id": "findings.F-05.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-05's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-05.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-10-01', 'Henry Cho'] for F-05.", "id": "findings.F-05.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-06 exception for trading-window violation.", "id": "findings.F-06.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's id from /workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/016_minutes_materials_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_earnings_guidance/064_earnings_guidance_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's issue from /workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/016_minutes_materials_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_earnings_guidance/064_earnings_guidance_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's severity from /workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/016_minutes_materials_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_earnings_guidance/064_earnings_guidance_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's primary_source from /workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/016_minutes_materials_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_earnings_guidance/064_earnings_guidance_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/016_minutes_materials_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_earnings_guidance/064_earnings_guidance_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-06 using the exact controlled facts ['7%', '14%'].", "id": "findings.F-06.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-06's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-06.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-10-01', 'Nadine Flores'] for F-06.", "id": "findings.F-06.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-07 exception for Section 16 filing delay.", "id": "findings.F-07.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's id from /workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/019_sec_filings_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_whistleblower/067_whistleblower_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's issue from /workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/019_sec_filings_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_whistleblower/067_whistleblower_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's severity from /workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/019_sec_filings_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_whistleblower/067_whistleblower_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's primary_source from /workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/019_sec_filings_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_whistleblower/067_whistleblower_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/019_sec_filings_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_whistleblower/067_whistleblower_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-07 using the exact controlled facts ['notices-ironclad_logistics_corp@example.test', 'archive-special_committee@example.test'].", "id": "findings.F-07.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-07's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-07.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-10-01', 'Micah Sullivan'] for F-07.", "id": "findings.F-07.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-08 exception for related-party disclosure gap.", "id": "findings.F-08.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's id from /workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/022_sec_filings_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_whistleblower/070_whistleblower_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's issue from /workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/022_sec_filings_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_whistleblower/070_whistleblower_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's severity from /workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/022_sec_filings_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_whistleblower/070_whistleblower_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's primary_source from /workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/022_sec_filings_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_whistleblower/070_whistleblower_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/022_sec_filings_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_whistleblower/070_whistleblower_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-08 using the exact controlled facts ['91 records', '2025-02-15', '37 records', '2025-02-24'].", "id": "findings.F-08.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-08's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-08.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-10-01', 'Farah Ibrahim'] for F-08.", "id": "findings.F-08.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-09 exception for equity-plan share mismatch.", "id": "findings.F-09.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's id from /workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/025_disclosure_controls_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_stock_exchange/073_stock_exchange_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's issue from /workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/025_disclosure_controls_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_stock_exchange/073_stock_exchange_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's severity from /workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/025_disclosure_controls_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_stock_exchange/073_stock_exchange_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's primary_source from /workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/025_disclosure_controls_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_stock_exchange/073_stock_exchange_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/025_disclosure_controls_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_stock_exchange/073_stock_exchange_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-09 using the exact controlled facts ['2025-09-12', 'CB-PC-3309-I532', '2025-10-15', 'CB-PC-3309-R756'].", "id": "findings.F-09.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-09's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-09.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-10-01', 'Owen Delgado'] for F-09.", "id": "findings.F-09.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-10 exception for non-GAAP reconciliation issue.", "id": "findings.F-10.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's id from /workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/028_disclosure_controls_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_stock_exchange/076_stock_exchange_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's issue from /workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/028_disclosure_controls_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_stock_exchange/076_stock_exchange_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's severity from /workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/028_disclosure_controls_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_stock_exchange/076_stock_exchange_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's primary_source from /workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/028_disclosure_controls_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_stock_exchange/076_stock_exchange_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/028_disclosure_controls_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_stock_exchange/076_stock_exchange_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-10 using the exact controlled facts ['$4,223,792.00', '$4,324,084.00'].", "id": "findings.F-10.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-10's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-10.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-10-01', 'Lena Varga'] for F-10.", "id": "findings.F-10.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-11 exception for guidance-control failure.", "id": "findings.F-11.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's id from /workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/031_disclosure_controls_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_stock_exchange/079_stock_exchange_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's issue from /workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/031_disclosure_controls_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_stock_exchange/079_stock_exchange_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's severity from /workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/031_disclosure_controls_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_stock_exchange/079_stock_exchange_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's primary_source from /workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/031_disclosure_controls_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_stock_exchange/079_stock_exchange_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/031_disclosure_controls_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_stock_exchange/079_stock_exchange_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-11 using the exact controlled facts ['Mei Whitaker', 'Adrian Mensah'].", "id": "findings.F-11.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-11's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-11.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-10-01', 'Samuel Kim'] for F-11.", "id": "findings.F-11.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-12 exception for whistleblower escalation delay.", "id": "findings.F-12.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's id from /workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/034_insider_trading_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_debt_covenants/082_debt_covenants_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's issue from /workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/034_insider_trading_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_debt_covenants/082_debt_covenants_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's severity from /workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/034_insider_trading_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_debt_covenants/082_debt_covenants_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's primary_source from /workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/034_insider_trading_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_debt_covenants/082_debt_covenants_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/034_insider_trading_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_debt_covenants/082_debt_covenants_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-12 using the exact controlled facts ['closed without exception', 'CB-PC-3309-L221', 'open and escalated', 'CB-PC-3309-U109'].", "id": "findings.F-12.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-12's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-12.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-10-01', 'Maya Ellison'] for F-12.", "id": "findings.F-12.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-13 exception for listing-standard notice.", "id": "findings.F-13.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's id from /workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/037_insider_trading_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_debt_covenants/085_debt_covenants_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's issue from /workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/037_insider_trading_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_debt_covenants/085_debt_covenants_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's severity from /workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/037_insider_trading_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_debt_covenants/085_debt_covenants_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's primary_source from /workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/037_insider_trading_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_debt_covenants/085_debt_covenants_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/037_insider_trading_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_debt_covenants/085_debt_covenants_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-13 using the exact controlled facts ['New York Stock Exchange', 'Georgia'].", "id": "findings.F-13.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-13's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-13.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-10-01', 'Rafael Okafor'] for F-13.", "id": "findings.F-13.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-14 exception for debt-covenant disclosure.", "id": "findings.F-14.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's id from /workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/040_insider_trading_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_debt_covenants/088_debt_covenants_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's issue from /workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/040_insider_trading_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_debt_covenants/088_debt_covenants_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's severity from /workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/040_insider_trading_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_debt_covenants/088_debt_covenants_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's primary_source from /workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/040_insider_trading_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_debt_covenants/088_debt_covenants_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/040_insider_trading_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_debt_covenants/088_debt_covenants_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-14 using the exact controlled facts ['13%', '20%'].", "id": "findings.F-14.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-14's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-14.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-10-01', 'Nora Chen'] for F-14.", "id": "findings.F-14.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-15 exception for officer certification exception.", "id": "findings.F-15.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's id from /workspace/documents/06_related_parties/043_related_parties_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_certifications/091_certifications_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's issue from /workspace/documents/06_related_parties/043_related_parties_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_certifications/091_certifications_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's severity from /workspace/documents/06_related_parties/043_related_parties_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_certifications/091_certifications_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's primary_source from /workspace/documents/06_related_parties/043_related_parties_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_certifications/091_certifications_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/06_related_parties/043_related_parties_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_certifications/091_certifications_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-15 using the exact controlled facts ['notices-ironclad_logistics_corp@example.test', 'archive-special_committee@example.test'].", "id": "findings.F-15.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-15's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-15.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-10-01', 'Dominic Alvarez'] for F-15.", "id": "findings.F-15.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-16 exception for board-matrix inconsistency.", "id": "findings.F-16.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's id from /workspace/documents/06_related_parties/046_related_parties_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_certifications/094_certifications_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's issue from /workspace/documents/06_related_parties/046_related_parties_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_certifications/094_certifications_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's severity from /workspace/documents/06_related_parties/046_related_parties_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_certifications/094_certifications_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's primary_source from /workspace/documents/06_related_parties/046_related_parties_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_certifications/094_certifications_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/06_related_parties/046_related_parties_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_certifications/094_certifications_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-16 using the exact controlled facts ['66 records', '2025-10-28', '36 records', '2025-11-05'].", "id": "findings.F-16.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-16's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-16.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-10-01', 'Priya Raman'] for F-16.", "id": "findings.F-16.action_anchors"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Executive assessment' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Executive assessment"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Method and record coverage' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Method and record coverage"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Findings' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Findings"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Recommended next actions' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Recommended next actions"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Assumptions and limitations' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Assumptions and limitations"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-01 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-01"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-02 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-02"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-03 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-03"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-04 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-04"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-05 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-05"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-06 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-06"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-07 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-07"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-08 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-08"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-09 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-09"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-10 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-10"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-11 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-11"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-12 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-12"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-13 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-13"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-14 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-14"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-15 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-15"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-16 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-16"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Do not claim the production has no issues or that every record is consistent.", "id": "memo.forbidden_claims_absent"}], "decision_options": [{"id": "cross-source-reconciliation", "label": "Reconcile controlling and corroborating records", "reason": "The CB-PC-3309 production contains independently maintained records; a defensible answer must preserve each supported conflict and its cure owner.", "selected": true}, {"id": "latest-record-controls", "label": "Treat the latest record as controlling", "reason": "Timestamp recency does not establish legal priority, execution, or approval authority.", "selected": false}, {"id": "primary-records-only", "label": "Report primary records without reconciliation", "reason": "Primary records alone conceal the operational conflicts that create the actionable exceptions.", "selected": false}], "gates": ["all_evidence_read_in_full", "chain_of_custody_metadata_checked", "findings_criteria_complete", "memo_criteria_complete", "deliverables_written_through_mcp"], "metadata_checks": 8, "metric": "weighted_criteria_score", "minimum_tool_calls": 46, "required_deliverables": ["findings.json", "advice.md"], "required_document_reads": 33, "type": "deterministic", "weights": {"findings": 0.55, "memo": 0.2, "procedure": 0.25}}, "task_id": "cb100-099-ironclad-logistics", "task_name": "Ironclad trading-window inquiry", "world_id": "counselbench-filesystem-mcp-v2"}
-{"context_files": ["task_files/cb100-100-juniper-photonics/01_board_committees/001_board_committees_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-100-juniper-photonics/01_board_committees/002_board_committees_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-100-juniper-photonics/01_board_committees/003_board_committees_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-100-juniper-photonics/01_board_committees/004_board_committees_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-100-juniper-photonics/01_board_committees/005_board_committees_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-100-juniper-photonics/01_board_committees/006_board_committees_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-100-juniper-photonics/01_board_committees/007_board_committees_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-100-juniper-photonics/01_board_committees/008_board_committees_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-100-juniper-photonics/02_minutes_materials/009_minutes_materials_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-100-juniper-photonics/02_minutes_materials/010_minutes_materials_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-100-juniper-photonics/02_minutes_materials/011_minutes_materials_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-100-juniper-photonics/02_minutes_materials/012_minutes_materials_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-100-juniper-photonics/02_minutes_materials/013_minutes_materials_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-100-juniper-photonics/02_minutes_materials/014_minutes_materials_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-100-juniper-photonics/02_minutes_materials/015_minutes_materials_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-100-juniper-photonics/02_minutes_materials/016_minutes_materials_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-100-juniper-photonics/03_sec_filings/017_sec_filings_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-100-juniper-photonics/03_sec_filings/018_sec_filings_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-100-juniper-photonics/03_sec_filings/019_sec_filings_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-100-juniper-photonics/03_sec_filings/020_sec_filings_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-100-juniper-photonics/03_sec_filings/021_sec_filings_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-100-juniper-photonics/03_sec_filings/022_sec_filings_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-100-juniper-photonics/03_sec_filings/023_sec_filings_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-100-juniper-photonics/03_sec_filings/024_sec_filings_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-100-juniper-photonics/04_disclosure_controls/025_disclosure_controls_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-100-juniper-photonics/04_disclosure_controls/026_disclosure_controls_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-100-juniper-photonics/04_disclosure_controls/027_disclosure_controls_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-100-juniper-photonics/04_disclosure_controls/028_disclosure_controls_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-100-juniper-photonics/04_disclosure_controls/029_disclosure_controls_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-100-juniper-photonics/04_disclosure_controls/030_disclosure_controls_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-100-juniper-photonics/04_disclosure_controls/031_disclosure_controls_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-100-juniper-photonics/04_disclosure_controls/032_disclosure_controls_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-100-juniper-photonics/05_insider_trading/033_insider_trading_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-100-juniper-photonics/05_insider_trading/034_insider_trading_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-100-juniper-photonics/05_insider_trading/035_insider_trading_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-100-juniper-photonics/05_insider_trading/036_insider_trading_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-100-juniper-photonics/05_insider_trading/037_insider_trading_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-100-juniper-photonics/05_insider_trading/038_insider_trading_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-100-juniper-photonics/05_insider_trading/039_insider_trading_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-100-juniper-photonics/05_insider_trading/040_insider_trading_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-100-juniper-photonics/06_related_parties/041_related_parties_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-100-juniper-photonics/06_related_parties/042_related_parties_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-100-juniper-photonics/06_related_parties/043_related_parties_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-100-juniper-photonics/06_related_parties/044_related_parties_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-100-juniper-photonics/06_related_parties/045_related_parties_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-100-juniper-photonics/06_related_parties/046_related_parties_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-100-juniper-photonics/06_related_parties/047_related_parties_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-100-juniper-photonics/06_related_parties/048_related_parties_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-100-juniper-photonics/07_equity_compensation/049_equity_compensation_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-100-juniper-photonics/07_equity_compensation/050_equity_compensation_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-100-juniper-photonics/07_equity_compensation/051_equity_compensation_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-100-juniper-photonics/07_equity_compensation/052_equity_compensation_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-100-juniper-photonics/07_equity_compensation/053_equity_compensation_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-100-juniper-photonics/07_equity_compensation/054_equity_compensation_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-100-juniper-photonics/07_equity_compensation/055_equity_compensation_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-100-juniper-photonics/07_equity_compensation/056_equity_compensation_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-100-juniper-photonics/08_earnings_guidance/057_earnings_guidance_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-100-juniper-photonics/08_earnings_guidance/058_earnings_guidance_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-100-juniper-photonics/08_earnings_guidance/059_earnings_guidance_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-100-juniper-photonics/08_earnings_guidance/060_earnings_guidance_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-100-juniper-photonics/08_earnings_guidance/061_earnings_guidance_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-100-juniper-photonics/08_earnings_guidance/062_earnings_guidance_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-100-juniper-photonics/08_earnings_guidance/063_earnings_guidance_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-100-juniper-photonics/08_earnings_guidance/064_earnings_guidance_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-100-juniper-photonics/09_whistleblower/065_whistleblower_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-100-juniper-photonics/09_whistleblower/066_whistleblower_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-100-juniper-photonics/09_whistleblower/067_whistleblower_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-100-juniper-photonics/09_whistleblower/068_whistleblower_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-100-juniper-photonics/09_whistleblower/069_whistleblower_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-100-juniper-photonics/09_whistleblower/070_whistleblower_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-100-juniper-photonics/09_whistleblower/071_whistleblower_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-100-juniper-photonics/09_whistleblower/072_whistleblower_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-100-juniper-photonics/10_stock_exchange/073_stock_exchange_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-100-juniper-photonics/10_stock_exchange/074_stock_exchange_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-100-juniper-photonics/10_stock_exchange/075_stock_exchange_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-100-juniper-photonics/10_stock_exchange/076_stock_exchange_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-100-juniper-photonics/10_stock_exchange/077_stock_exchange_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-100-juniper-photonics/10_stock_exchange/078_stock_exchange_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-100-juniper-photonics/10_stock_exchange/079_stock_exchange_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-100-juniper-photonics/10_stock_exchange/080_stock_exchange_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-100-juniper-photonics/11_debt_covenants/081_debt_covenants_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-100-juniper-photonics/11_debt_covenants/082_debt_covenants_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-100-juniper-photonics/11_debt_covenants/083_debt_covenants_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-100-juniper-photonics/11_debt_covenants/084_debt_covenants_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-100-juniper-photonics/11_debt_covenants/085_debt_covenants_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-100-juniper-photonics/11_debt_covenants/086_debt_covenants_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-100-juniper-photonics/11_debt_covenants/087_debt_covenants_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-100-juniper-photonics/11_debt_covenants/088_debt_covenants_status_report.md", "task_files/cb100-100-juniper-photonics/12_certifications/089_certifications_control_register.md", "task_files/cb100-100-juniper-photonics/12_certifications/090_certifications_executed_instrument.txt", "task_files/cb100-100-juniper-photonics/12_certifications/091_certifications_correspondence.eml", "task_files/cb100-100-juniper-photonics/12_certifications/092_certifications_ledger_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-100-juniper-photonics/12_certifications/093_certifications_review_memorandum.json", "task_files/cb100-100-juniper-photonics/12_certifications/094_certifications_formal_notice.xml", "task_files/cb100-100-juniper-photonics/12_certifications/095_certifications_officer_certificate.html", "task_files/cb100-100-juniper-photonics/12_certifications/096_certifications_status_report.md"], "gold_output": {"advice_markdown": "# Counsel advice — Juniper Photonics filing readiness audit\n\n## Executive assessment\n\nFor Juniper Photonics, Inc. matter CB-PC-3310, the review identified 16 source-supported exceptions requiring action before 2026-10-05. The assessment concerns Disclosure Committee and the supplied record for Delaware.\n\n## Method and record coverage\n\nThe review inventoried all 96 production files, read the 33 controlling, corroborating, and control records, searched the email exports, and checked metadata for the designated chain-of-custody sample. Conclusions are limited to the synthetic production supplied for this benchmark matter.\n\n## Findings\n\n### F-01 — committee-independence gap (critical)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for committee-independence gap: one source states the operative date is 2026-02-05 under control reference CB-PC-3310-A738, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2026-03-09 under response reference CB-PC-3310-J841.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/01_board_committees/001_board_committees_control_register.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/07_equity_compensation/049_equity_compensation_control_register.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-10-05, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Willa Novak.\n\n### F-02 — minutes-approval omission (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for minutes-approval omission: one source states the controlling amount is $5,577,960.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $5,622,420.00.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/01_board_committees/004_board_committees_ledger_export.csv`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/07_equity_compensation/052_equity_compensation_ledger_export.csv`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-10-05, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Theo Laurent.\n\n### F-03 — 8-K deadline (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for 8-K deadline: one source states approval is attributed to Caleb Hassan as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Samuel Kim and contains no entry for Caleb Hassan.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/01_board_committees/007_board_committees_officer_certificate.html`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/07_equity_compensation/055_equity_compensation_officer_certificate.html`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-10-05, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Amara Patel.\n\n### F-04 — risk-factor inconsistency (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for risk-factor inconsistency: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-PC-3310-D757, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-PC-3310-M565.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/010_minutes_materials_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/08_earnings_guidance/058_earnings_guidance_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-10-05, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Henry Cho.\n\n### F-05 — disclosure-control exception (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for disclosure-control exception: one source states the applicable location is Nasdaq Stock Market, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to Delaware operations outside Nasdaq Stock Market.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/013_minutes_materials_review_memorandum.json`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/08_earnings_guidance/061_earnings_guidance_review_memorandum.json`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-10-05, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Nadine Flores.\n\n### F-06 — trading-window violation (low)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for trading-window violation: one source states the threshold is 11% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 14% and produced a different exception result.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/016_minutes_materials_status_report.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/08_earnings_guidance/064_earnings_guidance_status_report.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-10-05, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Micah Sullivan.\n\n### F-07 — Section 16 filing delay (critical)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for Section 16 filing delay: one source states formal notice must use notices-juniper_photonics_inc@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-disclosure_committee@example.test.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/019_sec_filings_correspondence.eml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/09_whistleblower/067_whistleblower_correspondence.eml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-10-05, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Farah Ibrahim.\n\n### F-08 — related-party disclosure gap (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for related-party disclosure gap: one source states the governed population contains 67 records through 2025-01-22, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 59 records through 2025-02-22.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/022_sec_filings_formal_notice.xml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/09_whistleblower/070_whistleblower_formal_notice.xml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-10-05, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Owen Delgado.\n\n### F-09 — equity-plan share mismatch (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for equity-plan share mismatch: one source states the operative date is 2025-10-21 under control reference CB-PC-3310-I211, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2025-11-11 under response reference CB-PC-3310-R454.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/025_disclosure_controls_control_register.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/10_stock_exchange/073_stock_exchange_control_register.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-10-05, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Lena Varga.\n\n### F-10 — non-GAAP reconciliation issue (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for non-GAAP reconciliation issue: one source states the controlling amount is $3,222,748.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $3,401,996.00.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/028_disclosure_controls_ledger_export.csv`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/10_stock_exchange/076_stock_exchange_ledger_export.csv`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-10-05, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Samuel Kim.\n\n### F-11 — guidance-control failure (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for guidance-control failure: one source states approval is attributed to Caleb Hassan as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Theo Laurent and contains no entry for Caleb Hassan.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/031_disclosure_controls_officer_certificate.html`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/10_stock_exchange/079_stock_exchange_officer_certificate.html`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-10-05, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Maya Ellison.\n\n### F-12 — whistleblower escalation delay (low)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for whistleblower escalation delay: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-PC-3310-L404, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-PC-3310-U608.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/034_insider_trading_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/11_debt_covenants/082_debt_covenants_executed_instrument.txt`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-10-05, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Rafael Okafor.\n\n### F-13 — listing-standard notice (critical)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for listing-standard notice: one source states the applicable location is Nasdaq Stock Market, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to Delaware operations outside Nasdaq Stock Market.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/037_insider_trading_review_memorandum.json`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/11_debt_covenants/085_debt_covenants_review_memorandum.json`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-10-05, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Nora Chen.\n\n### F-14 — debt-covenant disclosure (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for debt-covenant disclosure: one source states the threshold is 8% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 14% and produced a different exception result.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/040_insider_trading_status_report.md`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/11_debt_covenants/088_debt_covenants_status_report.md`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-10-05, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Dominic Alvarez.\n\n### F-15 — officer certification exception (high)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for officer certification exception: one source states formal notice must use notices-juniper_photonics_inc@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-disclosure_committee@example.test.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/06_related_parties/043_related_parties_correspondence.eml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/12_certifications/091_certifications_correspondence.eml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-10-05, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Priya Raman.\n\n### F-16 — board-matrix inconsistency (medium)\n\nThe records do not reconcile for board-matrix inconsistency: one source states the governed population contains 149 records through 2026-01-19, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 73 records through 2026-03-05.\n\nPrimary source: `/workspace/documents/06_related_parties/046_related_parties_formal_notice.xml`\n\nCorroborating source: `/workspace/documents/12_certifications/094_certifications_formal_notice.xml`\n\nRecommended action: Before 2026-10-05, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Elliot Mercer.\n\n## Recommended next actions\n\nSequence the critical and high findings first, assign the named owners, preserve the cited records, and document any resolution in the controlling matter register before the stated deadline.\n\n## Assumptions and limitations\n\nThis analysis is confined to task cb100-100-juniper-photonics and the supplied synthetic evidence. It does not rely on external facts, does not resolve disputed law, and is not legal advice for a real person or entity.\n", "findings": {"as_of": "2026-10-05", "findings": [{"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/07_equity_compensation/049_equity_compensation_control_register.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for committee-independence gap: one source states the operative date is 2026-02-05 under control reference CB-PC-3310-A738, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2026-03-09 under response reference CB-PC-3310-J841.", "id": "F-01", "issue": "committee-independence gap", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/01_board_committees/001_board_committees_control_register.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-10-05, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Willa Novak.", "severity": "critical"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/07_equity_compensation/052_equity_compensation_ledger_export.csv", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for minutes-approval omission: one source states the controlling amount is $5,577,960.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $5,622,420.00.", "id": "F-02", "issue": "minutes-approval omission", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/01_board_committees/004_board_committees_ledger_export.csv", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-10-05, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Theo Laurent.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/07_equity_compensation/055_equity_compensation_officer_certificate.html", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for 8-K deadline: one source states approval is attributed to Caleb Hassan as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Samuel Kim and contains no entry for Caleb Hassan.", "id": "F-03", "issue": "8-K deadline", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/01_board_committees/007_board_committees_officer_certificate.html", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-10-05, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Amara Patel.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/08_earnings_guidance/058_earnings_guidance_executed_instrument.txt", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for risk-factor inconsistency: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-PC-3310-D757, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-PC-3310-M565.", "id": "F-04", "issue": "risk-factor inconsistency", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/010_minutes_materials_executed_instrument.txt", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-10-05, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Henry Cho.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/08_earnings_guidance/061_earnings_guidance_review_memorandum.json", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for disclosure-control exception: one source states the applicable location is Nasdaq Stock Market, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to Delaware operations outside Nasdaq Stock Market.", "id": "F-05", "issue": "disclosure-control exception", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/013_minutes_materials_review_memorandum.json", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-10-05, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Nadine Flores.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/08_earnings_guidance/064_earnings_guidance_status_report.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for trading-window violation: one source states the threshold is 11% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 14% and produced a different exception result.", "id": "F-06", "issue": "trading-window violation", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/016_minutes_materials_status_report.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-10-05, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Micah Sullivan.", "severity": "low"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/09_whistleblower/067_whistleblower_correspondence.eml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for Section 16 filing delay: one source states formal notice must use notices-juniper_photonics_inc@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-disclosure_committee@example.test.", "id": "F-07", "issue": "Section 16 filing delay", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/019_sec_filings_correspondence.eml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-10-05, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Farah Ibrahim.", "severity": "critical"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/09_whistleblower/070_whistleblower_formal_notice.xml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for related-party disclosure gap: one source states the governed population contains 67 records through 2025-01-22, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 59 records through 2025-02-22.", "id": "F-08", "issue": "related-party disclosure gap", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/022_sec_filings_formal_notice.xml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-10-05, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Owen Delgado.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/10_stock_exchange/073_stock_exchange_control_register.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for equity-plan share mismatch: one source states the operative date is 2025-10-21 under control reference CB-PC-3310-I211, while the corroborating source states the acknowledged date is 2025-11-11 under response reference CB-PC-3310-R454.", "id": "F-09", "issue": "equity-plan share mismatch", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/025_disclosure_controls_control_register.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-10-05, obtain a signed ratification and update the controlling register; owner: Lena Varga.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/10_stock_exchange/076_stock_exchange_ledger_export.csv", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for non-GAAP reconciliation issue: one source states the controlling amount is $3,222,748.00, while the corroborating source states the reconciliation and counterparty record use $3,401,996.00.", "id": "F-10", "issue": "non-GAAP reconciliation issue", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/028_disclosure_controls_ledger_export.csv", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-10-05, recalculate the exposure and preserve the supporting ledger; owner: Samuel Kim.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/10_stock_exchange/079_stock_exchange_officer_certificate.html", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for guidance-control failure: one source states approval is attributed to Caleb Hassan as the sole authorized reviewer, while the corroborating source states the approval log names Theo Laurent and contains no entry for Caleb Hassan.", "id": "F-11", "issue": "guidance-control failure", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/031_disclosure_controls_officer_certificate.html", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-10-05, secure written consent from the authorized decision-maker; owner: Maya Ellison.", "severity": "medium"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/11_debt_covenants/082_debt_covenants_executed_instrument.txt", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for whistleblower escalation delay: one source states the item is recorded as closed without exception in CB-PC-3310-L404, while the corroborating source states the later status register marks it open and escalated in CB-PC-3310-U608.", "id": "F-12", "issue": "whistleblower escalation delay", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/034_insider_trading_executed_instrument.txt", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-10-05, issue a corrective notice using the contractually operative method; owner: Rafael Okafor.", "severity": "low"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/11_debt_covenants/085_debt_covenants_review_memorandum.json", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for listing-standard notice: one source states the applicable location is Nasdaq Stock Market, while the corroborating source states the implementation record assigns the obligation to Delaware operations outside Nasdaq Stock Market.", "id": "F-13", "issue": "listing-standard notice", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/037_insider_trading_review_memorandum.json", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-10-05, escalate the conflict to the responsible legal and business owners; owner: Nora Chen.", "severity": "critical"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/11_debt_covenants/088_debt_covenants_status_report.md", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for debt-covenant disclosure: one source states the threshold is 8% with no stated tolerance, while the corroborating source states the applied threshold is 14% and produced a different exception result.", "id": "F-14", "issue": "debt-covenant disclosure", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/040_insider_trading_status_report.md", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-10-05, document the governing interpretation before the deadline; owner: Dominic Alvarez.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/12_certifications/091_certifications_correspondence.eml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for officer certification exception: one source states formal notice must use notices-juniper_photonics_inc@example.test, while the corroborating source states the only delivery record was sent to archive-disclosure_committee@example.test.", "id": "F-15", "issue": "officer certification exception", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/06_related_parties/043_related_parties_correspondence.eml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-10-05, place the affected population on hold pending reconciliation; owner: Priya Raman.", "severity": "high"}, {"corroborating_source": "/workspace/documents/12_certifications/094_certifications_formal_notice.xml", "determination": "The records do not reconcile for board-matrix inconsistency: one source states the governed population contains 149 records through 2026-01-19, while the corroborating source states the certification covers 73 records through 2026-03-05.", "id": "F-16", "issue": "board-matrix inconsistency", "primary_source": "/workspace/documents/06_related_parties/046_related_parties_formal_notice.xml", "recommended_action": "Before 2026-10-05, amend the closing or response checklist with a dated cure item; owner: Elliot Mercer.", "severity": "medium"}], "matter_number": "CB-PC-3310", "prepared_for": "Juniper Photonics, Inc.", "schema_version": "1.0", "task_id": "cb100-100-juniper-photonics"}}, "metadata": {"benchmark": "CounselBench-100", "code_license": "Apache-2.0", "data_license": "CC-BY-4.0", "deadline": "2026-10-05", "document_count": 96, "jurisdiction": "Delaware", "matter_number": "CB-PC-3310", "mcp_commit": "9a96ea6e5913736f92b88345bf51caeaaa8e719f", "mcp_package": "@modelcontextprotocol/server-filesystem@2026.7.10", "practice_area": "public-company", "reference_tool_calls": 46, "required_evidence_reads": 33, "synthetic": true, "venue": "Nasdaq Stock Market", "version": "2.0.0"}, "prompt": "You are securities and governance counsel for Juniper Photonics, Inc. The record contains amendments, exports, and correspondence from different custodians; reconcile them into an actionable counsel work product. Cybersecurity, customer concentration, equity-plan, committee, and certification records require reconciliation before a periodic report. Decision due 2026-10-05. Delaware law governs; Nasdaq Stock Market is the forum. Write for a supervising lawyer who will spot-check source paths and exact values. Work out the defensible position from the matter production and leave an audit-ready exception tracker and concise advice for the supervising lawyer. Keep confirmed conflicts separate from open questions, cite the records that actually control each conclusion, and do not fill gaps with outside facts.", "rubric": {"criteria": [{"category": "procedure", "description": "Complete at least 46 successful, argument-specific evidence and output calls.", "id": "procedure.minimum_successful_tool_calls"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Find and read the 33 controlling, corroborating, and work-product-control records in full.", "id": "procedure.all_evidence_read_in_full"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Inspect file metadata for the eight designated critical primary records before relying on them.", "id": "procedure.chain_of_custody_metadata_checked"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Confirm the sandbox's allowed document and output roots.", "id": "procedure.allowed_directories_checked"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Inventory all 96 records so the relevant sources are discovered among the context records.", "id": "procedure.recursive_inventory_completed"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Search the production for email evidence that may corroborate or contradict formal records.", "id": "procedure.targeted_search_completed"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Leave only findings.json and advice.md in the output workspace.", "id": "procedure.exact_deliverable_set"}, {"category": "procedure", "description": "Create both final work products through the sandbox MCP surface.", "id": "procedure.deliverables_written_through_mcp"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Produce findings.json as a valid JSON object.", "id": "findings.findings_is_object"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Report exactly 16 confirmed exceptions.", "id": "findings.findings_exact_count"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Use each stable finding ID exactly once.", "id": "findings.finding_ids_unique"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set schema_version to the released matter value '1.0'.", "id": "findings.top_level_schema_version"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set task_id to the released matter value 'cb100-100-juniper-photonics'.", "id": "findings.top_level_task_id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set matter_number to the released matter value 'CB-PC-3310'.", "id": "findings.top_level_matter_number"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set prepared_for to the released matter value 'Juniper Photonics, Inc.'.", "id": "findings.top_level_prepared_for"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Set as_of to the released matter value '2026-10-05'.", "id": "findings.top_level_as_of"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-01 exception for committee-independence gap.", "id": "findings.F-01.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's id from /workspace/documents/01_board_committees/001_board_committees_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_equity_compensation/049_equity_compensation_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's issue from /workspace/documents/01_board_committees/001_board_committees_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_equity_compensation/049_equity_compensation_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's severity from /workspace/documents/01_board_committees/001_board_committees_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_equity_compensation/049_equity_compensation_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's primary_source from /workspace/documents/01_board_committees/001_board_committees_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_equity_compensation/049_equity_compensation_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-01's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/01_board_committees/001_board_committees_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/07_equity_compensation/049_equity_compensation_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-01.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-01 using the exact controlled facts ['2026-02-05', 'CB-PC-3310-A738', '2026-03-09', 'CB-PC-3310-J841'].", "id": "findings.F-01.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-01's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-01.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-10-05', 'Willa Novak'] for F-01.", "id": "findings.F-01.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-02 exception for minutes-approval omission.", "id": "findings.F-02.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's id from /workspace/documents/01_board_committees/004_board_committees_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_equity_compensation/052_equity_compensation_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's issue from /workspace/documents/01_board_committees/004_board_committees_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_equity_compensation/052_equity_compensation_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's severity from /workspace/documents/01_board_committees/004_board_committees_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_equity_compensation/052_equity_compensation_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's primary_source from /workspace/documents/01_board_committees/004_board_committees_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_equity_compensation/052_equity_compensation_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-02's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/01_board_committees/004_board_committees_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/07_equity_compensation/052_equity_compensation_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-02.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-02 using the exact controlled facts ['$5,577,960.00', '$5,622,420.00'].", "id": "findings.F-02.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-02's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-02.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-10-05', 'Theo Laurent'] for F-02.", "id": "findings.F-02.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-03 exception for 8-K deadline.", "id": "findings.F-03.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's id from /workspace/documents/01_board_committees/007_board_committees_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_equity_compensation/055_equity_compensation_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's issue from /workspace/documents/01_board_committees/007_board_committees_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_equity_compensation/055_equity_compensation_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's severity from /workspace/documents/01_board_committees/007_board_committees_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_equity_compensation/055_equity_compensation_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's primary_source from /workspace/documents/01_board_committees/007_board_committees_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_equity_compensation/055_equity_compensation_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-03's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/01_board_committees/007_board_committees_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/07_equity_compensation/055_equity_compensation_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-03.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-03 using the exact controlled facts ['Caleb Hassan', 'Samuel Kim'].", "id": "findings.F-03.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-03's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-03.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-10-05', 'Amara Patel'] for F-03.", "id": "findings.F-03.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-04 exception for risk-factor inconsistency.", "id": "findings.F-04.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's id from /workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/010_minutes_materials_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_earnings_guidance/058_earnings_guidance_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's issue from /workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/010_minutes_materials_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_earnings_guidance/058_earnings_guidance_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's severity from /workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/010_minutes_materials_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_earnings_guidance/058_earnings_guidance_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's primary_source from /workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/010_minutes_materials_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_earnings_guidance/058_earnings_guidance_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-04's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/010_minutes_materials_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/08_earnings_guidance/058_earnings_guidance_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-04.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-04 using the exact controlled facts ['closed without exception', 'CB-PC-3310-D757', 'open and escalated', 'CB-PC-3310-M565'].", "id": "findings.F-04.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-04's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-04.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-10-05', 'Henry Cho'] for F-04.", "id": "findings.F-04.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-05 exception for disclosure-control exception.", "id": "findings.F-05.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's id from /workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/013_minutes_materials_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_earnings_guidance/061_earnings_guidance_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's issue from /workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/013_minutes_materials_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_earnings_guidance/061_earnings_guidance_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's severity from /workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/013_minutes_materials_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_earnings_guidance/061_earnings_guidance_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's primary_source from /workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/013_minutes_materials_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_earnings_guidance/061_earnings_guidance_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-05's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/013_minutes_materials_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/08_earnings_guidance/061_earnings_guidance_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-05.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-05 using the exact controlled facts ['Nasdaq Stock Market', 'Delaware'].", "id": "findings.F-05.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-05's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-05.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-10-05', 'Nadine Flores'] for F-05.", "id": "findings.F-05.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-06 exception for trading-window violation.", "id": "findings.F-06.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's id from /workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/016_minutes_materials_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_earnings_guidance/064_earnings_guidance_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's issue from /workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/016_minutes_materials_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_earnings_guidance/064_earnings_guidance_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's severity from /workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/016_minutes_materials_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_earnings_guidance/064_earnings_guidance_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's primary_source from /workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/016_minutes_materials_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_earnings_guidance/064_earnings_guidance_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-06's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/016_minutes_materials_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/08_earnings_guidance/064_earnings_guidance_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-06.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-06 using the exact controlled facts ['11%', '14%'].", "id": "findings.F-06.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-06's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-06.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-10-05', 'Micah Sullivan'] for F-06.", "id": "findings.F-06.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-07 exception for Section 16 filing delay.", "id": "findings.F-07.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's id from /workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/019_sec_filings_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_whistleblower/067_whistleblower_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's issue from /workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/019_sec_filings_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_whistleblower/067_whistleblower_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's severity from /workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/019_sec_filings_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_whistleblower/067_whistleblower_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's primary_source from /workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/019_sec_filings_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_whistleblower/067_whistleblower_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-07's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/019_sec_filings_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/09_whistleblower/067_whistleblower_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-07.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-07 using the exact controlled facts ['notices-juniper_photonics_inc@example.test', 'archive-disclosure_committee@example.test'].", "id": "findings.F-07.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-07's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-07.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-10-05', 'Farah Ibrahim'] for F-07.", "id": "findings.F-07.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-08 exception for related-party disclosure gap.", "id": "findings.F-08.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's id from /workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/022_sec_filings_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_whistleblower/070_whistleblower_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's issue from /workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/022_sec_filings_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_whistleblower/070_whistleblower_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's severity from /workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/022_sec_filings_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_whistleblower/070_whistleblower_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's primary_source from /workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/022_sec_filings_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_whistleblower/070_whistleblower_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-08's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/022_sec_filings_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/09_whistleblower/070_whistleblower_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-08.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-08 using the exact controlled facts ['67 records', '2025-01-22', '59 records', '2025-02-22'].", "id": "findings.F-08.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-08's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-08.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-10-05', 'Owen Delgado'] for F-08.", "id": "findings.F-08.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-09 exception for equity-plan share mismatch.", "id": "findings.F-09.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's id from /workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/025_disclosure_controls_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_stock_exchange/073_stock_exchange_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's issue from /workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/025_disclosure_controls_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_stock_exchange/073_stock_exchange_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's severity from /workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/025_disclosure_controls_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_stock_exchange/073_stock_exchange_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's primary_source from /workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/025_disclosure_controls_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_stock_exchange/073_stock_exchange_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-09's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/025_disclosure_controls_control_register.md and /workspace/documents/10_stock_exchange/073_stock_exchange_control_register.md.", "id": "findings.F-09.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-09 using the exact controlled facts ['2025-10-21', 'CB-PC-3310-I211', '2025-11-11', 'CB-PC-3310-R454'].", "id": "findings.F-09.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-09's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-09.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-10-05', 'Lena Varga'] for F-09.", "id": "findings.F-09.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-10 exception for non-GAAP reconciliation issue.", "id": "findings.F-10.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's id from /workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/028_disclosure_controls_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_stock_exchange/076_stock_exchange_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's issue from /workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/028_disclosure_controls_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_stock_exchange/076_stock_exchange_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's severity from /workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/028_disclosure_controls_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_stock_exchange/076_stock_exchange_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's primary_source from /workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/028_disclosure_controls_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_stock_exchange/076_stock_exchange_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-10's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/028_disclosure_controls_ledger_export.csv and /workspace/documents/10_stock_exchange/076_stock_exchange_ledger_export.csv.", "id": "findings.F-10.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-10 using the exact controlled facts ['$3,222,748.00', '$3,401,996.00'].", "id": "findings.F-10.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-10's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-10.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-10-05', 'Samuel Kim'] for F-10.", "id": "findings.F-10.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-11 exception for guidance-control failure.", "id": "findings.F-11.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's id from /workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/031_disclosure_controls_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_stock_exchange/079_stock_exchange_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's issue from /workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/031_disclosure_controls_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_stock_exchange/079_stock_exchange_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's severity from /workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/031_disclosure_controls_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_stock_exchange/079_stock_exchange_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's primary_source from /workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/031_disclosure_controls_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_stock_exchange/079_stock_exchange_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-11's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/031_disclosure_controls_officer_certificate.html and /workspace/documents/10_stock_exchange/079_stock_exchange_officer_certificate.html.", "id": "findings.F-11.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-11 using the exact controlled facts ['Caleb Hassan', 'Theo Laurent'].", "id": "findings.F-11.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-11's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-11.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-10-05', 'Maya Ellison'] for F-11.", "id": "findings.F-11.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-12 exception for whistleblower escalation delay.", "id": "findings.F-12.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's id from /workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/034_insider_trading_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_debt_covenants/082_debt_covenants_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's issue from /workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/034_insider_trading_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_debt_covenants/082_debt_covenants_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's severity from /workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/034_insider_trading_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_debt_covenants/082_debt_covenants_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's primary_source from /workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/034_insider_trading_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_debt_covenants/082_debt_covenants_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-12's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/034_insider_trading_executed_instrument.txt and /workspace/documents/11_debt_covenants/082_debt_covenants_executed_instrument.txt.", "id": "findings.F-12.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-12 using the exact controlled facts ['closed without exception', 'CB-PC-3310-L404', 'open and escalated', 'CB-PC-3310-U608'].", "id": "findings.F-12.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-12's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-12.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-10-05', 'Rafael Okafor'] for F-12.", "id": "findings.F-12.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-13 exception for listing-standard notice.", "id": "findings.F-13.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's id from /workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/037_insider_trading_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_debt_covenants/085_debt_covenants_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's issue from /workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/037_insider_trading_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_debt_covenants/085_debt_covenants_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's severity from /workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/037_insider_trading_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_debt_covenants/085_debt_covenants_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's primary_source from /workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/037_insider_trading_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_debt_covenants/085_debt_covenants_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-13's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/037_insider_trading_review_memorandum.json and /workspace/documents/11_debt_covenants/085_debt_covenants_review_memorandum.json.", "id": "findings.F-13.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-13 using the exact controlled facts ['Nasdaq Stock Market', 'Delaware'].", "id": "findings.F-13.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-13's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-13.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-10-05', 'Nora Chen'] for F-13.", "id": "findings.F-13.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-14 exception for debt-covenant disclosure.", "id": "findings.F-14.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's id from /workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/040_insider_trading_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_debt_covenants/088_debt_covenants_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's issue from /workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/040_insider_trading_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_debt_covenants/088_debt_covenants_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's severity from /workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/040_insider_trading_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_debt_covenants/088_debt_covenants_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's primary_source from /workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/040_insider_trading_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_debt_covenants/088_debt_covenants_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-14's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/040_insider_trading_status_report.md and /workspace/documents/11_debt_covenants/088_debt_covenants_status_report.md.", "id": "findings.F-14.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-14 using the exact controlled facts ['8%', '14%'].", "id": "findings.F-14.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-14's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-14.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-10-05', 'Dominic Alvarez'] for F-14.", "id": "findings.F-14.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-15 exception for officer certification exception.", "id": "findings.F-15.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's id from /workspace/documents/06_related_parties/043_related_parties_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_certifications/091_certifications_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's issue from /workspace/documents/06_related_parties/043_related_parties_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_certifications/091_certifications_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's severity from /workspace/documents/06_related_parties/043_related_parties_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_certifications/091_certifications_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's primary_source from /workspace/documents/06_related_parties/043_related_parties_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_certifications/091_certifications_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-15's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/06_related_parties/043_related_parties_correspondence.eml and /workspace/documents/12_certifications/091_certifications_correspondence.eml.", "id": "findings.F-15.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-15 using the exact controlled facts ['notices-juniper_photonics_inc@example.test', 'archive-disclosure_committee@example.test'].", "id": "findings.F-15.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-15's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-15.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-10-05', 'Priya Raman'] for F-15.", "id": "findings.F-15.action_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Include the confirmed F-16 exception for board-matrix inconsistency.", "id": "findings.F-16.present"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's id from /workspace/documents/06_related_parties/046_related_parties_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_certifications/094_certifications_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.id"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's issue from /workspace/documents/06_related_parties/046_related_parties_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_certifications/094_certifications_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.issue"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's severity from /workspace/documents/06_related_parties/046_related_parties_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_certifications/094_certifications_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.severity"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's primary_source from /workspace/documents/06_related_parties/046_related_parties_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_certifications/094_certifications_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.primary_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve F-16's corroborating_source from /workspace/documents/06_related_parties/046_related_parties_formal_notice.xml and /workspace/documents/12_certifications/094_certifications_formal_notice.xml.", "id": "findings.F-16.corroborating_source"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Reconcile F-16 using the exact controlled facts ['149 records', '2026-01-19', '73 records', '2026-03-05'].", "id": "findings.F-16.fact_anchors"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Do not introduce a controlled date, amount, percentage, address, or reference absent from F-16's cited source pair.", "id": "findings.F-16.facts_source_bounded"}, {"category": "findings", "description": "Preserve the supported cure owner and deadline anchors ['2026-10-05', 'Elliot Mercer'] for F-16.", "id": "findings.F-16.action_anchors"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Executive assessment' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Executive assessment"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Method and record coverage' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Method and record coverage"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Findings' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Findings"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Recommended next actions' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Recommended next actions"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Include the 'Assumptions and limitations' decision section in advice.md.", "id": "memo.section.Assumptions and limitations"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-01 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-01"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-02 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-02"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-03 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-03"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-04 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-04"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-05 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-05"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-06 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-06"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-07 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-07"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-08 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-08"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-09 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-09"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-10 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-10"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-11 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-11"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-12 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-12"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-13 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-13"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-14 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-14"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-15 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-15"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Explain F-16 with its issue, severity, cited source pair, exact conflicting facts, owner, and deadline.", "id": "memo.finding.F-16"}, {"category": "memo", "description": "Do not claim the production has no issues or that every record is consistent.", "id": "memo.forbidden_claims_absent"}], "decision_options": [{"id": "cross-source-reconciliation", "label": "Reconcile controlling and corroborating records", "reason": "The CB-PC-3310 production contains independently maintained records; a defensible answer must preserve each supported conflict and its cure owner.", "selected": true}, {"id": "latest-record-controls", "label": "Treat the latest record as controlling", "reason": "Timestamp recency does not establish legal priority, execution, or approval authority.", "selected": false}, {"id": "primary-records-only", "label": "Report primary records without reconciliation", "reason": "Primary records alone conceal the operational conflicts that create the actionable exceptions.", "selected": false}], "gates": ["all_evidence_read_in_full", "chain_of_custody_metadata_checked", "findings_criteria_complete", "memo_criteria_complete", "deliverables_written_through_mcp"], "metadata_checks": 8, "metric": "weighted_criteria_score", "minimum_tool_calls": 46, "required_deliverables": ["findings.json", "advice.md"], "required_document_reads": 33, "type": "deterministic", "weights": {"findings": 0.55, "memo": 0.2, "procedure": 0.25}}, "task_id": "cb100-100-juniper-photonics", "task_name": "Juniper Photonics filing readiness audit", "world_id": "counselbench-filesystem-mcp-v2"}
+{"context_files": ["task_files/cb100-001-helios-forge/01_corporate/001_corporate_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-001-helios-forge/01_corporate/002_corporate_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-001-helios-forge/01_corporate/003_corporate_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-001-helios-forge/01_corporate/004_corporate_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-001-helios-forge/01_corporate/005_corporate_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-001-helios-forge/01_corporate/006_corporate_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-001-helios-forge/01_corporate/007_corporate_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-001-helios-forge/01_corporate/008_corporate_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-001-helios-forge/02_capitalization/009_capitalization_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-001-helios-forge/02_capitalization/010_capitalization_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-001-helios-forge/02_capitalization/011_capitalization_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-001-helios-forge/02_capitalization/012_capitalization_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-001-helios-forge/02_capitalization/013_capitalization_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-001-helios-forge/02_capitalization/014_capitalization_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-001-helios-forge/02_capitalization/015_capitalization_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-001-helios-forge/02_capitalization/016_capitalization_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-001-helios-forge/03_material_contracts/017_material_contracts_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-001-helios-forge/03_material_contracts/018_material_contracts_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-001-helios-forge/03_material_contracts/019_material_contracts_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-001-helios-forge/03_material_contracts/020_material_contracts_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-001-helios-forge/03_material_contracts/021_material_contracts_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-001-helios-forge/03_material_contracts/022_material_contracts_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-001-helios-forge/03_material_contracts/023_material_contracts_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-001-helios-forge/03_material_contracts/024_material_contracts_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-001-helios-forge/04_debt_security/025_debt_security_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-001-helios-forge/04_debt_security/026_debt_security_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-001-helios-forge/04_debt_security/027_debt_security_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-001-helios-forge/04_debt_security/028_debt_security_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-001-helios-forge/04_debt_security/029_debt_security_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-001-helios-forge/04_debt_security/030_debt_security_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-001-helios-forge/04_debt_security/031_debt_security_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-001-helios-forge/04_debt_security/032_debt_security_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-001-helios-forge/05_employment/033_employment_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-001-helios-forge/05_employment/034_employment_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-001-helios-forge/05_employment/035_employment_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-001-helios-forge/05_employment/036_employment_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-001-helios-forge/05_employment/037_employment_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-001-helios-forge/05_employment/038_employment_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-001-helios-forge/05_employment/039_employment_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-001-helios-forge/05_employment/040_employment_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-001-helios-forge/06_ip_technology/041_ip_technology_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-001-helios-forge/06_ip_technology/042_ip_technology_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-001-helios-forge/06_ip_technology/043_ip_technology_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-001-helios-forge/06_ip_technology/044_ip_technology_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-001-helios-forge/06_ip_technology/045_ip_technology_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-001-helios-forge/06_ip_technology/046_ip_technology_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-001-helios-forge/06_ip_technology/047_ip_technology_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-001-helios-forge/06_ip_technology/048_ip_technology_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-001-helios-forge/07_privacy_security/049_privacy_security_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-001-helios-forge/07_privacy_security/050_privacy_security_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-001-helios-forge/07_privacy_security/051_privacy_security_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-001-helios-forge/07_privacy_security/052_privacy_security_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-001-helios-forge/07_privacy_security/053_privacy_security_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-001-helios-forge/07_privacy_security/054_privacy_security_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-001-helios-forge/07_privacy_security/055_privacy_security_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-001-helios-forge/07_privacy_security/056_privacy_security_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-001-helios-forge/08_regulatory/057_regulatory_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-001-helios-forge/08_regulatory/058_regulatory_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-001-helios-forge/08_regulatory/059_regulatory_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-001-helios-forge/08_regulatory/060_regulatory_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-001-helios-forge/08_regulatory/061_regulatory_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-001-helios-forge/08_regulatory/062_regulatory_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-001-helios-forge/08_regulatory/063_regulatory_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-001-helios-forge/08_regulatory/064_regulatory_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-001-helios-forge/09_litigation/065_litigation_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-001-helios-forge/09_litigation/066_litigation_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-001-helios-forge/09_litigation/067_litigation_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-001-helios-forge/09_litigation/068_litigation_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-001-helios-forge/09_litigation/069_litigation_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-001-helios-forge/09_litigation/070_litigation_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-001-helios-forge/09_litigation/071_litigation_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-001-helios-forge/09_litigation/072_litigation_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-001-helios-forge/10_real_property/073_real_property_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-001-helios-forge/10_real_property/074_real_property_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-001-helios-forge/10_real_property/075_real_property_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-001-helios-forge/10_real_property/076_real_property_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-001-helios-forge/10_real_property/077_real_property_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-001-helios-forge/10_real_property/078_real_property_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-001-helios-forge/10_real_property/079_real_property_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-001-helios-forge/10_real_property/080_real_property_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-001-helios-forge/11_tax_insurance/081_tax_insurance_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-001-helios-forge/11_tax_insurance/082_tax_insurance_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-001-helios-forge/11_tax_insurance/083_tax_insurance_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-001-helios-forge/11_tax_insurance/084_tax_insurance_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-001-helios-forge/11_tax_insurance/085_tax_insurance_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-001-helios-forge/11_tax_insurance/086_tax_insurance_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-001-helios-forge/11_tax_insurance/087_tax_insurance_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-001-helios-forge/11_tax_insurance/088_tax_insurance_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-001-helios-forge/12_financials/089_financials_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-001-helios-forge/12_financials/090_financials_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-001-helios-forge/12_financials/091_financials_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-001-helios-forge/12_financials/092_financials_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-001-helios-forge/12_financials/093_financials_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-001-helios-forge/12_financials/094_financials_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-001-helios-forge/12_financials/095_financials_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-001-helios-forge/12_financials/096_financials_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-001-helios-forge/12_financials/097_helios_forge_impact_population.xlsx"], "gold_output": {"advice_markdown": "# Decision note — Project Daybreak battery acquisition\n\n## Recommendation\n\nProceed only with supported closing conditions and named cure owners. The reconciled record supports 8 scoped actions and leaves 4 items on evidence hold.\n\nSelected option: `helios-forge:scoped-evidence`.\n\n## Why this is the supported option\n\nMatch the cathode-tooling records and automaker consent history to the exact acquired entity. The executed purchase terms and the latest consent schedule control; seller summaries do not.\n\n## Supported actions\n\n### CBP-001-02 — financial covenant breach (high)\n\nthe controlling threshold is 7% under CB-MA-2401-R158; the independently calculated result is 13% under CB-MA-2401-E738. Identity resolves to ENT-001-1001, revision REV-2025.2 is current, and Sofia Bennett is active with capacity 1.\n\nAction: Create a closing-condition row for each supported blocker and hold ambiguous entity matches. Owner: Sofia Bennett; due 2026-09-02.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_corporate/002_corporate_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/02_capitalization/014_capitalization_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/04_debt_security/026_debt_security_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/05_employment/038_employment_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/12_financials/097_helios_forge_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-001-03 — permit transfer restriction (medium)\n\napproval must come from Talia Brooks under CB-MA-2401-R164; the effective approval record names Henry Cho under CB-MA-2401-E368. Identity resolves to ENT-001-1002, revision REV-2025.3 is current, and Micah Sullivan is active with capacity 3.\n\nAction: Create a closing-condition row for each supported blocker and hold ambiguous entity matches. Owner: Micah Sullivan; due 2026-09-01.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_corporate/003_corporate_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/02_capitalization/015_capitalization_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/04_debt_security/027_debt_security_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/05_employment/039_employment_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/12_financials/097_helios_forge_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-001-04 — revenue recognition exception (critical)\n\nthe controlled population contains 224 records under CB-MA-2401-R532; the certification covers 197 records under CB-MA-2401-E548. Identity resolves to ENT-001-1003, revision REV-2025.4 is current, and Nora Chen is active with capacity 1.\n\nAction: Create a closing-condition row for each supported blocker and hold ambiguous entity matches. Owner: Nora Chen; due 2026-08-31.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_corporate/004_corporate_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/02_capitalization/016_capitalization_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/04_debt_security/028_debt_security_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/05_employment/040_employment_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/11_tax_insurance/088_tax_insurance_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/12_financials/097_helios_forge_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-001-05 — most-favored-customer exposure (high)\n\nthe permission is limited to Washoe County, Nevada under CB-MA-2401-R572; the matched activity occurred in Delaware under CB-MA-2401-E921. Identity resolves to ENT-001-1004, revision REV-2025.5 is current, and Caleb Hassan is active with capacity 4.\n\nAction: Create a closing-condition row for each supported blocker and hold ambiguous entity matches. Owner: Caleb Hassan; due 2026-08-30.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_corporate/005_corporate_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/017_material_contracts_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/04_debt_security/029_debt_security_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/041_ip_technology_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/12_financials/097_helios_forge_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-001-07 — claims-made insurance tail (low)\n\ndelivery must use notices-helios_forge_inc@example.test under CB-MA-2401-R611; the only matched receipt used archive-bluepeak_battery_systems_llc@example.test under CB-MA-2401-E341. Identity resolves to ENT-001-1006, revision REV-2025.7 is current, and Samuel Kim is active with capacity 3.\n\nAction: Create a closing-condition row for each supported blocker and hold ambiguous entity matches. Owner: Samuel Kim; due 2026-08-28.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_corporate/007_corporate_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/019_material_contracts_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/04_debt_security/031_debt_security_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/043_ip_technology_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/10_real_property/079_real_property_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/12_financials/097_helios_forge_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-001-09 — open-source copyleft exposure (critical)\n\ncompletion is required by 2025-06-06 under CB-MA-2401-R971; the current event record shows completion on 2025-06-19 under CB-MA-2401-E945. Identity resolves to ENT-001-1008, revision REV-2025.2 is current, and Adrian Mensah is active with capacity 4.\n\nAction: Create a closing-condition row for each supported blocker and hold ambiguous entity matches. Owner: Adrian Mensah; due 2026-08-26.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/02_capitalization/009_capitalization_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/021_material_contracts_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/05_employment/033_employment_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/045_ip_technology_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/12_financials/093_financials_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/12_financials/097_helios_forge_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-001-10 — sales-tax nexus gap (high)\n\nthe controlling threshold is 5% under CB-MA-2401-R710; the independently calculated result is 9% under CB-MA-2401-E877. Identity resolves to ENT-001-1009, revision REV-2025.3 is current, and Farah Ibrahim is active with capacity 1.\n\nAction: Create a closing-condition row for each supported blocker and hold ambiguous entity matches. Owner: Farah Ibrahim; due 2026-09-03.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/02_capitalization/010_capitalization_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/022_material_contracts_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/05_employment/034_employment_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/046_ip_technology_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/12_financials/097_helios_forge_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-001-12 — invention assignment defect (medium)\n\nthe controlled population contains 215 records under CB-MA-2401-R433; the certification covers 184 records under CB-MA-2401-E278. Identity resolves to ENT-001-1011, revision REV-2025.5 is current, and Leona Park is active with capacity 3.\n\nAction: Create a closing-condition row for each supported blocker and hold ambiguous entity matches. Owner: Leona Park; due 2026-09-01.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/02_capitalization/012_capitalization_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/024_material_contracts_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/05_employment/036_employment_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/048_ip_technology_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/12_financials/096_financials_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/11_tax_insurance/084_tax_insurance_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/12_financials/097_helios_forge_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n## Evidence holds\n\n- **CBP-001-01 — charter authorization mismatch**: two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key. Next evidence: an approved immutable entity crosswalk. Sources: `/workspace/documents/01_corporate/001_corporate_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/02_capitalization/013_capitalization_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/04_debt_security/025_debt_security_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/05_employment/037_employment_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/10_real_property/073_real_property_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/07_privacy_security/049_privacy_security_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/12_financials/097_helios_forge_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-001-06 — unreported security incident**: the current observation does not meet the operative trigger. Next evidence: a current observation that satisfies the operative trigger. Sources: `/workspace/documents/01_corporate/006_corporate_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/018_material_contracts_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/04_debt_security/030_debt_security_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/042_ip_technology_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/10_real_property/078_real_property_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/12_financials/097_helios_forge_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-001-08 — anti-assignment restriction**: the operational record relies on a superseded control revision. Next evidence: an operational record using the current effective revision. Sources: `/workspace/documents/01_corporate/008_corporate_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/020_material_contracts_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/04_debt_security/032_debt_security_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/044_ip_technology_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/09_litigation/068_litigation_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/12_financials/092_financials_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/12_financials/097_helios_forge_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-001-11 — change-of-control consent**: the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective. Next evidence: effective approval and an active owner with remaining capacity. Sources: `/workspace/documents/02_capitalization/011_capitalization_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/023_material_contracts_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/05_employment/035_employment_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/047_ip_technology_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/11_tax_insurance/083_tax_insurance_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/12_financials/097_helios_forge_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n## Alternatives considered\n\n- `helios-forge:shortcut` — Release every signature page because the seller says the issues are immaterial.: Use a plausible summary or one source without completing the controlling joins.\n- `helios-forge:blanket-hold` — Freeze the entire matter population: Treat supported actions and genuinely ambiguous records as if they were equally unresolved.\n\n## Assumptions and limits\n\nThis decision is limited to cb100-001-helios-forge, the supplied synthetic records, and the matter state as of 2026-09-04. Similar names, stale revisions, and pending authority are not treated as proof.\n", "decision": {"actions": [{"determination": "the controlling threshold is 7% under CB-MA-2401-R158; the independently calculated result is 13% under CB-MA-2401-E738. Identity resolves to ENT-001-1001, revision REV-2025.2 is current, and Sofia Bennett is active with capacity 1.", "due_date": "2026-09-02", "id": "ACT-CBP-001-02", "identity_id": "ENT-001-1001", "issue": "financial covenant breach", "owner": "Sofia Bennett", "portfolio_key": "CBP-001-02", "recommended_action": "Create a closing-condition row for each supported blocker and hold ambiguous entity matches. Owner: Sofia Bennett; due 2026-09-02.", "severity": "high", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_corporate/002_corporate_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/02_capitalization/014_capitalization_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/04_debt_security/026_debt_security_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/05_employment/038_employment_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_financials/097_helios_forge_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "approval must come from Talia Brooks under CB-MA-2401-R164; the effective approval record names Henry Cho under CB-MA-2401-E368. Identity resolves to ENT-001-1002, revision REV-2025.3 is current, and Micah Sullivan is active with capacity 3.", "due_date": "2026-09-01", "id": "ACT-CBP-001-03", "identity_id": "ENT-001-1002", "issue": "permit transfer restriction", "owner": "Micah Sullivan", "portfolio_key": "CBP-001-03", "recommended_action": "Create a closing-condition row for each supported blocker and hold ambiguous entity matches. Owner: Micah Sullivan; due 2026-09-01.", "severity": "medium", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_corporate/003_corporate_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/02_capitalization/015_capitalization_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/04_debt_security/027_debt_security_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/05_employment/039_employment_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_financials/097_helios_forge_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "the controlled population contains 224 records under CB-MA-2401-R532; the certification covers 197 records under CB-MA-2401-E548. Identity resolves to ENT-001-1003, revision REV-2025.4 is current, and Nora Chen is active with capacity 1.", "due_date": "2026-08-31", "id": "ACT-CBP-001-04", "identity_id": "ENT-001-1003", "issue": "revenue recognition exception", "owner": "Nora Chen", "portfolio_key": "CBP-001-04", "recommended_action": "Create a closing-condition row for each supported blocker and hold ambiguous entity matches. Owner: Nora Chen; due 2026-08-31.", "severity": "critical", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_corporate/004_corporate_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/02_capitalization/016_capitalization_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/04_debt_security/028_debt_security_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/05_employment/040_employment_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/11_tax_insurance/088_tax_insurance_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_financials/097_helios_forge_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "the permission is limited to Washoe County, Nevada under CB-MA-2401-R572; the matched activity occurred in Delaware under CB-MA-2401-E921. Identity resolves to ENT-001-1004, revision REV-2025.5 is current, and Caleb Hassan is active with capacity 4.", "due_date": "2026-08-30", "id": "ACT-CBP-001-05", "identity_id": "ENT-001-1004", "issue": "most-favored-customer exposure", "owner": "Caleb Hassan", "portfolio_key": "CBP-001-05", "recommended_action": "Create a closing-condition row for each supported blocker and hold ambiguous entity matches. Owner: Caleb Hassan; due 2026-08-30.", "severity": "high", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_corporate/005_corporate_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/017_material_contracts_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/04_debt_security/029_debt_security_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/041_ip_technology_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/12_financials/097_helios_forge_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "delivery must use notices-helios_forge_inc@example.test under CB-MA-2401-R611; the only matched receipt used archive-bluepeak_battery_systems_llc@example.test under CB-MA-2401-E341. Identity resolves to ENT-001-1006, revision REV-2025.7 is current, and Samuel Kim is active with capacity 3.", "due_date": "2026-08-28", "id": "ACT-CBP-001-07", "identity_id": "ENT-001-1006", "issue": "claims-made insurance tail", "owner": "Samuel Kim", "portfolio_key": "CBP-001-07", "recommended_action": "Create a closing-condition row for each supported blocker and hold ambiguous entity matches. Owner: Samuel Kim; due 2026-08-28.", "severity": "low", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_corporate/007_corporate_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/019_material_contracts_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/04_debt_security/031_debt_security_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/043_ip_technology_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/10_real_property/079_real_property_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_financials/097_helios_forge_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "completion is required by 2025-06-06 under CB-MA-2401-R971; the current event record shows completion on 2025-06-19 under CB-MA-2401-E945. Identity resolves to ENT-001-1008, revision REV-2025.2 is current, and Adrian Mensah is active with capacity 4.", "due_date": "2026-08-26", "id": "ACT-CBP-001-09", "identity_id": "ENT-001-1008", "issue": "open-source copyleft exposure", "owner": "Adrian Mensah", "portfolio_key": "CBP-001-09", "recommended_action": "Create a closing-condition row for each supported blocker and hold ambiguous entity matches. Owner: Adrian Mensah; due 2026-08-26.", "severity": "critical", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_capitalization/009_capitalization_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/021_material_contracts_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/05_employment/033_employment_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/045_ip_technology_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_financials/093_financials_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_financials/097_helios_forge_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "the controlling threshold is 5% under CB-MA-2401-R710; the independently calculated result is 9% under CB-MA-2401-E877. Identity resolves to ENT-001-1009, revision REV-2025.3 is current, and Farah Ibrahim is active with capacity 1.", "due_date": "2026-09-03", "id": "ACT-CBP-001-10", "identity_id": "ENT-001-1009", "issue": "sales-tax nexus gap", "owner": "Farah Ibrahim", "portfolio_key": "CBP-001-10", "recommended_action": "Create a closing-condition row for each supported blocker and hold ambiguous entity matches. Owner: Farah Ibrahim; due 2026-09-03.", "severity": "high", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_capitalization/010_capitalization_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/022_material_contracts_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/05_employment/034_employment_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/046_ip_technology_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_financials/097_helios_forge_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "the controlled population contains 215 records under CB-MA-2401-R433; the certification covers 184 records under CB-MA-2401-E278. Identity resolves to ENT-001-1011, revision REV-2025.5 is current, and Leona Park is active with capacity 3.", "due_date": "2026-09-01", "id": "ACT-CBP-001-12", "identity_id": "ENT-001-1011", "issue": "invention assignment defect", "owner": "Leona Park", "portfolio_key": "CBP-001-12", "recommended_action": "Create a closing-condition row for each supported blocker and hold ambiguous entity matches. Owner: Leona Park; due 2026-09-01.", "severity": "medium", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_capitalization/012_capitalization_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/024_material_contracts_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/05_employment/036_employment_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/048_ip_technology_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_financials/096_financials_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/11_tax_insurance/084_tax_insurance_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/12_financials/097_helios_forge_impact_population.xlsx"]}], "as_of": "2026-09-04", "decision": {"alternatives_considered": ["helios-forge:shortcut", "helios-forge:blanket-hold"], "question": "Can the Daybreak signing proceed, and which tooling or customer-consent gaps must become closing conditions?", "rationale": "The four-part causal test supports 8 scoped actions and leaves 4 records on evidence hold. The executed purchase terms and the latest consent schedule control; seller summaries do not.", "recommendation": "Proceed only with supported closing conditions and named cure owners.", "selected_option_id": "helios-forge:scoped-evidence"}, "holds": [{"id": "HOLD-CBP-001-01", "issue": "charter authorization mismatch", "portfolio_key": "CBP-001-01", "reason": "two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key", "required_next_evidence": "an approved immutable entity crosswalk", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_corporate/001_corporate_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/02_capitalization/013_capitalization_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/04_debt_security/025_debt_security_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/05_employment/037_employment_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/10_real_property/073_real_property_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/07_privacy_security/049_privacy_security_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/12_financials/097_helios_forge_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-001-06", "issue": "unreported security incident", "portfolio_key": "CBP-001-06", "reason": "the current observation does not meet the operative trigger", "required_next_evidence": "a current observation that satisfies the operative trigger", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_corporate/006_corporate_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/018_material_contracts_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/04_debt_security/030_debt_security_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/042_ip_technology_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/10_real_property/078_real_property_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_financials/097_helios_forge_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-001-08", "issue": "anti-assignment restriction", "portfolio_key": "CBP-001-08", "reason": "the operational record relies on a superseded control revision", "required_next_evidence": "an operational record using the current effective revision", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_corporate/008_corporate_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/020_material_contracts_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/04_debt_security/032_debt_security_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/044_ip_technology_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/09_litigation/068_litigation_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/12_financials/092_financials_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/12_financials/097_helios_forge_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-001-11", "issue": "change-of-control consent", "portfolio_key": "CBP-001-11", "reason": "the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective", "required_next_evidence": "effective approval and an active owner with remaining capacity", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_capitalization/011_capitalization_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/023_material_contracts_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/05_employment/035_employment_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/047_ip_technology_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/11_tax_insurance/083_tax_insurance_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/12_financials/097_helios_forge_impact_population.xlsx"]}], "matter_number": "CB-MA-2401", "prepared_for": "Helios Forge, Inc.", "schema_version": "counselbench.decision.v3", "task_id": "cb100-001-helios-forge"}, "matter_register": {"matter_number": "CB-MA-2401", "rows": [{"decision_option_id": "helios-forge:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key", "issue": "charter authorization mismatch", "matter_number": "CB-MA-2401", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-001-01", "row_id": "REG-CBP-001-01", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_corporate/001_corporate_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/02_capitalization/013_capitalization_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/04_debt_security/025_debt_security_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/05_employment/037_employment_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/10_real_property/073_real_property_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/07_privacy_security/049_privacy_security_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/12_financials/097_helios_forge_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "helios-forge:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-02", "issue": "financial covenant breach", "matter_number": "CB-MA-2401", "owner": "Sofia Bennett", "portfolio_key": "CBP-001-02", "row_id": "REG-CBP-001-02", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_corporate/002_corporate_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/02_capitalization/014_capitalization_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/04_debt_security/026_debt_security_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/05_employment/038_employment_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_financials/097_helios_forge_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "helios-forge:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-01", "issue": "permit transfer restriction", "matter_number": "CB-MA-2401", "owner": "Micah Sullivan", "portfolio_key": "CBP-001-03", "row_id": "REG-CBP-001-03", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_corporate/003_corporate_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/02_capitalization/015_capitalization_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/04_debt_security/027_debt_security_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/05_employment/039_employment_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_financials/097_helios_forge_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "helios-forge:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-08-31", "issue": "revenue recognition exception", "matter_number": "CB-MA-2401", "owner": "Nora Chen", "portfolio_key": "CBP-001-04", "row_id": "REG-CBP-001-04", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_corporate/004_corporate_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/02_capitalization/016_capitalization_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/04_debt_security/028_debt_security_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/05_employment/040_employment_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/11_tax_insurance/088_tax_insurance_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_financials/097_helios_forge_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "helios-forge:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-08-30", "issue": "most-favored-customer exposure", "matter_number": "CB-MA-2401", "owner": "Caleb Hassan", "portfolio_key": "CBP-001-05", "row_id": "REG-CBP-001-05", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_corporate/005_corporate_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/017_material_contracts_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/04_debt_security/029_debt_security_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/041_ip_technology_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/12_financials/097_helios_forge_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "helios-forge:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "the current observation does not meet the operative trigger", "issue": "unreported security incident", "matter_number": "CB-MA-2401", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-001-06", "row_id": "REG-CBP-001-06", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_corporate/006_corporate_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/018_material_contracts_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/04_debt_security/030_debt_security_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/042_ip_technology_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/10_real_property/078_real_property_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_financials/097_helios_forge_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "helios-forge:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-08-28", "issue": "claims-made insurance tail", "matter_number": "CB-MA-2401", "owner": "Samuel Kim", "portfolio_key": "CBP-001-07", "row_id": "REG-CBP-001-07", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_corporate/007_corporate_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/019_material_contracts_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/04_debt_security/031_debt_security_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/043_ip_technology_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/10_real_property/079_real_property_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_financials/097_helios_forge_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "helios-forge:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "the operational record relies on a superseded control revision", "issue": "anti-assignment restriction", "matter_number": "CB-MA-2401", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-001-08", "row_id": "REG-CBP-001-08", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_corporate/008_corporate_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/020_material_contracts_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/04_debt_security/032_debt_security_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/044_ip_technology_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/09_litigation/068_litigation_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/12_financials/092_financials_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/12_financials/097_helios_forge_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "helios-forge:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-08-26", "issue": "open-source copyleft exposure", "matter_number": "CB-MA-2401", "owner": "Adrian Mensah", "portfolio_key": "CBP-001-09", "row_id": "REG-CBP-001-09", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_capitalization/009_capitalization_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/021_material_contracts_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/05_employment/033_employment_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/045_ip_technology_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_financials/093_financials_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_financials/097_helios_forge_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "helios-forge:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-03", "issue": "sales-tax nexus gap", "matter_number": "CB-MA-2401", "owner": "Farah Ibrahim", "portfolio_key": "CBP-001-10", "row_id": "REG-CBP-001-10", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_capitalization/010_capitalization_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/022_material_contracts_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/05_employment/034_employment_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/046_ip_technology_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_financials/097_helios_forge_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "helios-forge:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective", "issue": "change-of-control consent", "matter_number": "CB-MA-2401", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-001-11", "row_id": "REG-CBP-001-11", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_capitalization/011_capitalization_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/023_material_contracts_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/05_employment/035_employment_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/047_ip_technology_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/11_tax_insurance/083_tax_insurance_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/12_financials/097_helios_forge_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "helios-forge:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-01", "issue": "invention assignment defect", "matter_number": "CB-MA-2401", "owner": "Leona Park", "portfolio_key": "CBP-001-12", "row_id": "REG-CBP-001-12", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_capitalization/012_capitalization_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/024_material_contracts_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/05_employment/036_employment_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/048_ip_technology_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_financials/096_financials_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/11_tax_insurance/084_tax_insurance_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/12_financials/097_helios_forge_impact_population.xlsx"]}], "schema_version": "counselbench.matter-register.v3", "task_id": "cb100-001-helios-forge"}}, "metadata": {"benchmark": "CounselBench-100", "code_license": "Apache-2.0", "data_license": "CC-BY-4.0", "deadline": "2026-09-04", "document_count": 97, "evidence_holds": 4, "jurisdiction": "Delaware", "matter_number": "CB-MA-2401", "mcp_commit": "9a96ea6e5913736f92b88345bf51caeaaa8e719f", "mcp_package": "@modelcontextprotocol/server-filesystem@2026.7.10", "practice_area": "corporate-ma", "reference_tool_calls": 81, "required_evidence_reads": 61, "supported_actions": 8, "synthetic": true, "venue": "Washoe County, Nevada", "version": "3.1.0"}, "prompt": "I need a straight answer before the next partner call. Can the Daybreak signing proceed, and which tooling or customer-consent gaps must become closing conditions? A carve-out manufacturer owns cathode tooling in Nevada while its largest automaker customer can terminate upon an indirect change of control. The team needs the call by 2026-09-04. Update the matter record only where the evidence supports it, and give me the practical options for the client.", "rubric": {"criteria": [{"category": "investigation", "description": "Inventory the production and use targeted searches to locate records across native formats.", "id": "investigation.discover_production"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Complete every task-specific identity, authority, operations, and approval read before the first state transition.", "id": "investigation.read_before_write"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Inspect designated source metadata before relying on those records.", "id": "investigation.custody_before_write"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "Select the supported option 'helios-forge:scoped-evidence' after applying the four-part test.", "id": "decision.selected_option"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "Identify both rejected approaches and explain why a one-source shortcut and a blanket hold are wrong.", "id": "decision.alternatives"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-001-01 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_corporate/001_corporate_source_export.md rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-001-01.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_capitalization/013_capitalization_source_export.json for charter authorization mismatch.", "id": "investigation.CBP-001-01.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_debt_security/025_debt_security_source_export.md to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-001-01.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_employment/037_employment_source_export.json.", "id": "investigation.CBP-001-01.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-001-01 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key.", "id": "decision.CBP-001-01.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-001-01 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-001-01.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-001-02 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_corporate/002_corporate_source_export.txt rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-001-02.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_capitalization/014_capitalization_source_export.xml for financial covenant breach.", "id": "investigation.CBP-001-02.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_debt_security/026_debt_security_source_export.txt to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-001-02.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_employment/038_employment_source_export.xml.", "id": "investigation.CBP-001-02.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-001-02 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-001-02.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-001-02 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-001-02.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-001-03 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_corporate/003_corporate_source_export.eml rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-001-03.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_capitalization/015_capitalization_source_export.html for permit transfer restriction.", "id": "investigation.CBP-001-03.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_debt_security/027_debt_security_source_export.eml to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-001-03.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_employment/039_employment_source_export.html.", "id": "investigation.CBP-001-03.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-001-03 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-001-03.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-001-03 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-001-03.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-001-04 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_corporate/004_corporate_source_export.csv rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-001-04.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_capitalization/016_capitalization_source_export.pdf for revenue recognition exception.", "id": "investigation.CBP-001-04.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_debt_security/028_debt_security_source_export.csv to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-001-04.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_employment/040_employment_source_export.pdf.", "id": "investigation.CBP-001-04.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-001-04 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-001-04.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-001-04 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-001-04.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-001-05 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_corporate/005_corporate_source_export.json rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-001-05.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/017_material_contracts_source_export.md for most-favored-customer exposure.", "id": "investigation.CBP-001-05.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_debt_security/029_debt_security_source_export.json to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-001-05.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/041_ip_technology_source_export.md.", "id": "investigation.CBP-001-05.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-001-05 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-001-05.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-001-05 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-001-05.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-001-06 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_corporate/006_corporate_source_export.xml rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-001-06.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/018_material_contracts_source_export.txt for unreported security incident.", "id": "investigation.CBP-001-06.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_debt_security/030_debt_security_source_export.xml to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-001-06.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/042_ip_technology_source_export.txt.", "id": "investigation.CBP-001-06.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-001-06 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is the current observation does not meet the operative trigger.", "id": "decision.CBP-001-06.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-001-06 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-001-06.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-001-07 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_corporate/007_corporate_source_export.html rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-001-07.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/019_material_contracts_source_export.eml for claims-made insurance tail.", "id": "investigation.CBP-001-07.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_debt_security/031_debt_security_source_export.html to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-001-07.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/043_ip_technology_source_export.eml.", "id": "investigation.CBP-001-07.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-001-07 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-001-07.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-001-07 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-001-07.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-001-08 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_corporate/008_corporate_source_export.pdf rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-001-08.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/020_material_contracts_source_export.csv for anti-assignment restriction.", "id": "investigation.CBP-001-08.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_debt_security/032_debt_security_source_export.pdf to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-001-08.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/044_ip_technology_source_export.csv.", "id": "investigation.CBP-001-08.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-001-08 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is the operational record relies on a superseded control revision.", "id": "decision.CBP-001-08.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-001-08 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-001-08.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-001-09 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_capitalization/009_capitalization_source_export.md rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-001-09.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/021_material_contracts_source_export.json for open-source copyleft exposure.", "id": "investigation.CBP-001-09.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_employment/033_employment_source_export.md to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-001-09.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/045_ip_technology_source_export.json.", "id": "investigation.CBP-001-09.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-001-09 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-001-09.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-001-09 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-001-09.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-001-10 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_capitalization/010_capitalization_source_export.txt rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-001-10.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/022_material_contracts_source_export.xml for sales-tax nexus gap.", "id": "investigation.CBP-001-10.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_employment/034_employment_source_export.txt to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-001-10.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/046_ip_technology_source_export.xml.", "id": "investigation.CBP-001-10.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-001-10 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-001-10.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-001-10 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-001-10.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-001-11 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_capitalization/011_capitalization_source_export.eml rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-001-11.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/023_material_contracts_source_export.html for change-of-control consent.", "id": "investigation.CBP-001-11.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_employment/035_employment_source_export.eml to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-001-11.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/047_ip_technology_source_export.html.", "id": "investigation.CBP-001-11.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-001-11 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective.", "id": "decision.CBP-001-11.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-001-11 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-001-11.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-001-12 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_capitalization/012_capitalization_source_export.csv rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-001-12.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/024_material_contracts_source_export.pdf for invention assignment defect.", "id": "investigation.CBP-001-12.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_employment/036_employment_source_export.csv to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-001-12.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/048_ip_technology_source_export.pdf.", "id": "investigation.CBP-001-12.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-001-12 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-001-12.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-001-12 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-001-12.register"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Write the exact selected option, supported action population, evidence-hold population, facts, owners, deadlines, and citations.", "id": "state.exact_decision"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create one exact register row per portfolio key with no extra, missing, or modified row.", "id": "state.exact_register"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Leave only the three approved deliverables and perform no extra state-changing write.", "id": "state.write_scope_containment"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Read back decision.json, matter-register.json, and advice.md after their final writes.", "id": "state.postwrite_readback"}, {"category": "answer", "description": "Explain the selected recommendation, supported actions, holds, alternatives, and limitations with exact source anchors.", "id": "answer.decision_note"}], "decision_options": [{"approach": "Apply the exact identity, current-state, authority, and revision test. Create a closing-condition row for each supported blocker and hold ambiguous entity matches.", "id": "helios-forge:scoped-evidence", "label": "Proceed only with supported closing conditions and named cure owners."}, {"approach": "Use a plausible summary or one source without completing the controlling joins.", "id": "helios-forge:shortcut", "label": "Release every signature page because the seller says the issues are immaterial."}, {"approach": "Treat supported actions and genuinely ambiguous records as if they were equally unresolved.", "id": "helios-forge:blanket-hold", "label": "Freeze the entire matter population"}], "evaluation_narrative": {"authority": "The executed purchase terms and the latest consent schedule control; seller summaries do not.", "observation": "Match the cathode-tooling records and automaker consent history to the exact acquired entity.", "question": "Can the Daybreak signing proceed, and which tooling or customer-consent gaps must become closing conditions?", "register_action": "Create a closing-condition row for each supported blocker and hold ambiguous entity matches."}, "gates": ["all_required_evidence_precedes_first_write", "decision_criteria_complete", "register_state_exact", "write_scope_contained", "all_outputs_verified_by_readback"], "metadata_checks": 5, "metric": "weighted_criteria_score", "minimum_tool_calls": 81, "required_deliverables": ["decision.json", "matter-register.json", "advice.md"], "required_document_reads": 61, "type": "deterministic", "weights": {"advice": 0.15, "decision": 0.35, "investigation": 0.25, "state": 0.25}}, "task_id": "cb100-001-helios-forge", "task_name": "Project Daybreak battery acquisition", "world_id": "counselbench-filesystem-mcp-v3"}
+{"context_files": ["task_files/cb100-002-northstar-orbit/01_corporate/001_corporate_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-002-northstar-orbit/01_corporate/002_corporate_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-002-northstar-orbit/01_corporate/003_corporate_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-002-northstar-orbit/01_corporate/004_corporate_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-002-northstar-orbit/01_corporate/005_corporate_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-002-northstar-orbit/01_corporate/006_corporate_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-002-northstar-orbit/01_corporate/007_corporate_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-002-northstar-orbit/01_corporate/008_corporate_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-002-northstar-orbit/02_capitalization/009_capitalization_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-002-northstar-orbit/02_capitalization/010_capitalization_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-002-northstar-orbit/02_capitalization/011_capitalization_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-002-northstar-orbit/02_capitalization/012_capitalization_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-002-northstar-orbit/02_capitalization/013_capitalization_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-002-northstar-orbit/02_capitalization/014_capitalization_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-002-northstar-orbit/02_capitalization/015_capitalization_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-002-northstar-orbit/02_capitalization/016_capitalization_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-002-northstar-orbit/03_material_contracts/017_material_contracts_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-002-northstar-orbit/03_material_contracts/018_material_contracts_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-002-northstar-orbit/03_material_contracts/019_material_contracts_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-002-northstar-orbit/03_material_contracts/020_material_contracts_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-002-northstar-orbit/03_material_contracts/021_material_contracts_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-002-northstar-orbit/03_material_contracts/022_material_contracts_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-002-northstar-orbit/03_material_contracts/023_material_contracts_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-002-northstar-orbit/03_material_contracts/024_material_contracts_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-002-northstar-orbit/04_debt_security/025_debt_security_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-002-northstar-orbit/04_debt_security/026_debt_security_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-002-northstar-orbit/04_debt_security/027_debt_security_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-002-northstar-orbit/04_debt_security/028_debt_security_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-002-northstar-orbit/04_debt_security/029_debt_security_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-002-northstar-orbit/04_debt_security/030_debt_security_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-002-northstar-orbit/04_debt_security/031_debt_security_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-002-northstar-orbit/04_debt_security/032_debt_security_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-002-northstar-orbit/05_employment/033_employment_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-002-northstar-orbit/05_employment/034_employment_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-002-northstar-orbit/05_employment/035_employment_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-002-northstar-orbit/05_employment/036_employment_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-002-northstar-orbit/05_employment/037_employment_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-002-northstar-orbit/05_employment/038_employment_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-002-northstar-orbit/05_employment/039_employment_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-002-northstar-orbit/05_employment/040_employment_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-002-northstar-orbit/06_ip_technology/041_ip_technology_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-002-northstar-orbit/06_ip_technology/042_ip_technology_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-002-northstar-orbit/06_ip_technology/043_ip_technology_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-002-northstar-orbit/06_ip_technology/044_ip_technology_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-002-northstar-orbit/06_ip_technology/045_ip_technology_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-002-northstar-orbit/06_ip_technology/046_ip_technology_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-002-northstar-orbit/06_ip_technology/047_ip_technology_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-002-northstar-orbit/06_ip_technology/048_ip_technology_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-002-northstar-orbit/07_privacy_security/049_privacy_security_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-002-northstar-orbit/07_privacy_security/050_privacy_security_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-002-northstar-orbit/07_privacy_security/051_privacy_security_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-002-northstar-orbit/07_privacy_security/052_privacy_security_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-002-northstar-orbit/07_privacy_security/053_privacy_security_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-002-northstar-orbit/07_privacy_security/054_privacy_security_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-002-northstar-orbit/07_privacy_security/055_privacy_security_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-002-northstar-orbit/07_privacy_security/056_privacy_security_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-002-northstar-orbit/08_regulatory/057_regulatory_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-002-northstar-orbit/08_regulatory/058_regulatory_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-002-northstar-orbit/08_regulatory/059_regulatory_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-002-northstar-orbit/08_regulatory/060_regulatory_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-002-northstar-orbit/08_regulatory/061_regulatory_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-002-northstar-orbit/08_regulatory/062_regulatory_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-002-northstar-orbit/08_regulatory/063_regulatory_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-002-northstar-orbit/08_regulatory/064_regulatory_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-002-northstar-orbit/09_litigation/065_litigation_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-002-northstar-orbit/09_litigation/066_litigation_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-002-northstar-orbit/09_litigation/067_litigation_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-002-northstar-orbit/09_litigation/068_litigation_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-002-northstar-orbit/09_litigation/069_litigation_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-002-northstar-orbit/09_litigation/070_litigation_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-002-northstar-orbit/09_litigation/071_litigation_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-002-northstar-orbit/09_litigation/072_litigation_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-002-northstar-orbit/10_real_property/073_real_property_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-002-northstar-orbit/10_real_property/074_real_property_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-002-northstar-orbit/10_real_property/075_real_property_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-002-northstar-orbit/10_real_property/076_real_property_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-002-northstar-orbit/10_real_property/077_real_property_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-002-northstar-orbit/10_real_property/078_real_property_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-002-northstar-orbit/10_real_property/079_real_property_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-002-northstar-orbit/10_real_property/080_real_property_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-002-northstar-orbit/11_tax_insurance/081_tax_insurance_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-002-northstar-orbit/11_tax_insurance/082_tax_insurance_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-002-northstar-orbit/11_tax_insurance/083_tax_insurance_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-002-northstar-orbit/11_tax_insurance/084_tax_insurance_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-002-northstar-orbit/11_tax_insurance/085_tax_insurance_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-002-northstar-orbit/11_tax_insurance/086_tax_insurance_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-002-northstar-orbit/11_tax_insurance/087_tax_insurance_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-002-northstar-orbit/11_tax_insurance/088_tax_insurance_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-002-northstar-orbit/12_financials/089_financials_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-002-northstar-orbit/12_financials/090_financials_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-002-northstar-orbit/12_financials/091_financials_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-002-northstar-orbit/12_financials/092_financials_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-002-northstar-orbit/12_financials/093_financials_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-002-northstar-orbit/12_financials/094_financials_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-002-northstar-orbit/12_financials/095_financials_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-002-northstar-orbit/12_financials/096_financials_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-002-northstar-orbit/12_financials/097_northstar_orbit_impact_population.xlsx"], "gold_output": {"advice_markdown": "# Decision note — Project Sextant satellite software merger\n\n## Recommendation\n\nCondition signing on the specific consent, screening, or release supported by current records. The reconciled record supports 6 scoped actions and leaves 6 items on evidence hold.\n\nSelected option: `northstar-orbit:scoped-evidence`.\n\n## Why this is the supported option\n\nReconcile license scope, export-support activity, and lien collateral against the exact target assets. Executed licenses, screening records, and current lien releases must all support transferability.\n\n## Supported actions\n\n### CBP-002-03 — threatened customer dispute (high)\n\nan open exception blocks completion under CB-MA-2402-R479; the current status is open and unresolved under CB-MA-2402-E916. Identity resolves to ENT-002-1002, revision REV-2026.3 is current, and Lena Varga is active with capacity 5.\n\nAction: Record only the transfer restrictions that survive exact asset and revision matching. Owner: Lena Varga; due 2026-09-05.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_corporate/003_corporate_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/02_capitalization/015_capitalization_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/04_debt_security/027_debt_security_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/05_employment/039_employment_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/10_real_property/075_real_property_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/12_financials/097_northstar_orbit_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-002-04 — charter authorization mismatch (critical)\n\ncompletion is required by 2025-12-01 under CB-MA-2402-R789; the current event record shows completion on 2025-12-20 under CB-MA-2402-E405. Identity resolves to ENT-002-1003, revision REV-2026.4 is current, and Elliot Mercer is active with capacity 5.\n\nAction: Record only the transfer restrictions that survive exact asset and revision matching. Owner: Elliot Mercer; due 2026-09-04.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_corporate/004_corporate_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/02_capitalization/016_capitalization_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/04_debt_security/028_debt_security_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/05_employment/040_employment_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/12_financials/097_northstar_orbit_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-002-06 — permit transfer restriction (low)\n\napproval must come from Amara Patel under CB-MA-2402-R272; the effective approval record names Caleb Hassan under CB-MA-2402-E798. Identity resolves to ENT-002-1005, revision REV-2026.6 is current, and Micah Sullivan is active with capacity 6.\n\nAction: Record only the transfer restrictions that survive exact asset and revision matching. Owner: Micah Sullivan; due 2026-09-02.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_corporate/006_corporate_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/018_material_contracts_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/04_debt_security/030_debt_security_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/042_ip_technology_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/12_financials/097_northstar_orbit_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-002-09 — unreported security incident (critical)\n\nthe operative cap is $3,442,000.00 under CB-MA-2402-R355; the matched ledger population totals $3,681,155.00 under CB-MA-2402-E750. Identity resolves to ENT-002-1008, revision REV-2026.2 is current, and Amara Patel is active with capacity 6.\n\nAction: Record only the transfer restrictions that survive exact asset and revision matching. Owner: Amara Patel; due 2026-08-30.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/02_capitalization/009_capitalization_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/021_material_contracts_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/05_employment/033_employment_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/045_ip_technology_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/09_litigation/069_litigation_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/12_financials/093_financials_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/12_financials/097_northstar_orbit_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-002-10 — claims-made insurance tail (low)\n\ndelivery must use notices-northstar_orbit_plc@example.test under CB-MA-2402-R311; the only matched receipt used archive-aster_vale_navigation_corp@example.test under CB-MA-2402-E377. Identity resolves to ENT-002-1009, revision REV-2026.3 is current, and Samuel Kim is active with capacity 2.\n\nAction: Record only the transfer restrictions that survive exact asset and revision matching. Owner: Samuel Kim; due 2026-09-07.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/02_capitalization/010_capitalization_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/022_material_contracts_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/05_employment/034_employment_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/046_ip_technology_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/12_financials/094_financials_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/12_financials/097_northstar_orbit_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-002-11 — anti-assignment restriction (low)\n\nan open exception blocks completion under CB-MA-2402-R993; the current status is open and unresolved under CB-MA-2402-E629. Identity resolves to ENT-002-1010, revision REV-2026.4 is current, and Talia Brooks is active with capacity 6.\n\nAction: Record only the transfer restrictions that survive exact asset and revision matching. Owner: Talia Brooks; due 2026-09-06.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/02_capitalization/011_capitalization_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/023_material_contracts_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/05_employment/035_employment_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/047_ip_technology_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/12_financials/097_northstar_orbit_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n## Evidence holds\n\n- **CBP-002-01 — unrecorded option grant**: the current observation does not meet the operative trigger. Next evidence: a current observation that satisfies the operative trigger. Sources: `/workspace/documents/01_corporate/001_corporate_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/02_capitalization/013_capitalization_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/04_debt_security/025_debt_security_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/05_employment/037_employment_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/11_tax_insurance/085_tax_insurance_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/12_financials/097_northstar_orbit_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-002-02 — key-person retention gap**: the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective. Next evidence: effective approval and an active owner with remaining capacity. Sources: `/workspace/documents/01_corporate/002_corporate_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/02_capitalization/014_capitalization_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/04_debt_security/026_debt_security_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/05_employment/038_employment_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/12_financials/097_northstar_orbit_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-002-05 — financial covenant breach**: the current observation does not meet the operative trigger. Next evidence: a current observation that satisfies the operative trigger. Sources: `/workspace/documents/01_corporate/005_corporate_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/017_material_contracts_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/04_debt_security/029_debt_security_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/041_ip_technology_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/10_real_property/077_real_property_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/12_financials/089_financials_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/12_financials/097_northstar_orbit_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-002-07 — revenue recognition exception**: the operational record relies on a superseded control revision. Next evidence: an operational record using the current effective revision. Sources: `/workspace/documents/01_corporate/007_corporate_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/019_material_contracts_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/04_debt_security/031_debt_security_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/043_ip_technology_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/12_financials/091_financials_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/07_privacy_security/055_privacy_security_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/12_financials/097_northstar_orbit_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-002-08 — most-favored-customer exposure**: two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key. Next evidence: an approved immutable entity crosswalk. Sources: `/workspace/documents/01_corporate/008_corporate_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/020_material_contracts_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/04_debt_security/032_debt_security_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/044_ip_technology_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/12_financials/092_financials_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/12_financials/097_northstar_orbit_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-002-12 — open-source copyleft exposure**: two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key. Next evidence: an approved immutable entity crosswalk. Sources: `/workspace/documents/02_capitalization/012_capitalization_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/024_material_contracts_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/05_employment/036_employment_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/048_ip_technology_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/11_tax_insurance/084_tax_insurance_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/12_financials/096_financials_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/12_financials/097_northstar_orbit_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n## Alternatives considered\n\n- `northstar-orbit:shortcut` — Assume the merger transfers every license and clears every lien automatically.: Use a plausible summary or one source without completing the controlling joins.\n- `northstar-orbit:blanket-hold` — Freeze the entire matter population: Treat supported actions and genuinely ambiguous records as if they were equally unresolved.\n\n## Assumptions and limits\n\nThis decision is limited to cb100-002-northstar-orbit, the supplied synthetic records, and the matter state as of 2026-09-08. Similar names, stale revisions, and pending authority are not treated as proof.\n", "decision": {"actions": [{"determination": "an open exception blocks completion under CB-MA-2402-R479; the current status is open and unresolved under CB-MA-2402-E916. Identity resolves to ENT-002-1002, revision REV-2026.3 is current, and Lena Varga is active with capacity 5.", "due_date": "2026-09-05", "id": "ACT-CBP-002-03", "identity_id": "ENT-002-1002", "issue": "threatened customer dispute", "owner": "Lena Varga", "portfolio_key": "CBP-002-03", "recommended_action": "Record only the transfer restrictions that survive exact asset and revision matching. Owner: Lena Varga; due 2026-09-05.", "severity": "high", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_corporate/003_corporate_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/02_capitalization/015_capitalization_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/04_debt_security/027_debt_security_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/05_employment/039_employment_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/10_real_property/075_real_property_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/12_financials/097_northstar_orbit_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "completion is required by 2025-12-01 under CB-MA-2402-R789; the current event record shows completion on 2025-12-20 under CB-MA-2402-E405. Identity resolves to ENT-002-1003, revision REV-2026.4 is current, and Elliot Mercer is active with capacity 5.", "due_date": "2026-09-04", "id": "ACT-CBP-002-04", "identity_id": "ENT-002-1003", "issue": "charter authorization mismatch", "owner": "Elliot Mercer", "portfolio_key": "CBP-002-04", "recommended_action": "Record only the transfer restrictions that survive exact asset and revision matching. Owner: Elliot Mercer; due 2026-09-04.", "severity": "critical", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_corporate/004_corporate_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/02_capitalization/016_capitalization_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/04_debt_security/028_debt_security_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/05_employment/040_employment_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_financials/097_northstar_orbit_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "approval must come from Amara Patel under CB-MA-2402-R272; the effective approval record names Caleb Hassan under CB-MA-2402-E798. Identity resolves to ENT-002-1005, revision REV-2026.6 is current, and Micah Sullivan is active with capacity 6.", "due_date": "2026-09-02", "id": "ACT-CBP-002-06", "identity_id": "ENT-002-1005", "issue": "permit transfer restriction", "owner": "Micah Sullivan", "portfolio_key": "CBP-002-06", "recommended_action": "Record only the transfer restrictions that survive exact asset and revision matching. Owner: Micah Sullivan; due 2026-09-02.", "severity": "low", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_corporate/006_corporate_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/018_material_contracts_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/04_debt_security/030_debt_security_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/042_ip_technology_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/12_financials/097_northstar_orbit_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "the operative cap is $3,442,000.00 under CB-MA-2402-R355; the matched ledger population totals $3,681,155.00 under CB-MA-2402-E750. Identity resolves to ENT-002-1008, revision REV-2026.2 is current, and Amara Patel is active with capacity 6.", "due_date": "2026-08-30", "id": "ACT-CBP-002-09", "identity_id": "ENT-002-1008", "issue": "unreported security incident", "owner": "Amara Patel", "portfolio_key": "CBP-002-09", "recommended_action": "Record only the transfer restrictions that survive exact asset and revision matching. Owner: Amara Patel; due 2026-08-30.", "severity": "critical", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_capitalization/009_capitalization_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/021_material_contracts_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/05_employment/033_employment_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/045_ip_technology_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/09_litigation/069_litigation_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_financials/093_financials_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_financials/097_northstar_orbit_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "delivery must use notices-northstar_orbit_plc@example.test under CB-MA-2402-R311; the only matched receipt used archive-aster_vale_navigation_corp@example.test under CB-MA-2402-E377. Identity resolves to ENT-002-1009, revision REV-2026.3 is current, and Samuel Kim is active with capacity 2.", "due_date": "2026-09-07", "id": "ACT-CBP-002-10", "identity_id": "ENT-002-1009", "issue": "claims-made insurance tail", "owner": "Samuel Kim", "portfolio_key": "CBP-002-10", "recommended_action": "Record only the transfer restrictions that survive exact asset and revision matching. Owner: Samuel Kim; due 2026-09-07.", "severity": "low", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_capitalization/010_capitalization_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/022_material_contracts_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/05_employment/034_employment_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/046_ip_technology_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_financials/094_financials_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_financials/097_northstar_orbit_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "an open exception blocks completion under CB-MA-2402-R993; the current status is open and unresolved under CB-MA-2402-E629. Identity resolves to ENT-002-1010, revision REV-2026.4 is current, and Talia Brooks is active with capacity 6.", "due_date": "2026-09-06", "id": "ACT-CBP-002-11", "identity_id": "ENT-002-1010", "issue": "anti-assignment restriction", "owner": "Talia Brooks", "portfolio_key": "CBP-002-11", "recommended_action": "Record only the transfer restrictions that survive exact asset and revision matching. Owner: Talia Brooks; due 2026-09-06.", "severity": "low", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_capitalization/011_capitalization_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/023_material_contracts_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/05_employment/035_employment_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/047_ip_technology_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_financials/097_northstar_orbit_impact_population.xlsx"]}], "as_of": "2026-09-08", "decision": {"alternatives_considered": ["northstar-orbit:shortcut", "northstar-orbit:blanket-hold"], "question": "Is Sextant ready for signing despite the university code, classified support, and blanket-lien questions?", "rationale": "The four-part causal test supports 6 scoped actions and leaves 6 records on evidence hold. Executed licenses, screening records, and current lien releases must all support transferability.", "recommendation": "Condition signing on the specific consent, screening, or release supported by current records.", "selected_option_id": "northstar-orbit:scoped-evidence"}, "holds": [{"id": "HOLD-CBP-002-01", "issue": "unrecorded option grant", "portfolio_key": "CBP-002-01", "reason": "the current observation does not meet the operative trigger", "required_next_evidence": "a current observation that satisfies the operative trigger", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_corporate/001_corporate_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/02_capitalization/013_capitalization_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/04_debt_security/025_debt_security_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/05_employment/037_employment_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/11_tax_insurance/085_tax_insurance_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_financials/097_northstar_orbit_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-002-02", "issue": "key-person retention gap", "portfolio_key": "CBP-002-02", "reason": "the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective", "required_next_evidence": "effective approval and an active owner with remaining capacity", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_corporate/002_corporate_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/02_capitalization/014_capitalization_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/04_debt_security/026_debt_security_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/05_employment/038_employment_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_financials/097_northstar_orbit_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-002-05", "issue": "financial covenant breach", "portfolio_key": "CBP-002-05", "reason": "the current observation does not meet the operative trigger", "required_next_evidence": "a current observation that satisfies the operative trigger", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_corporate/005_corporate_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/017_material_contracts_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/04_debt_security/029_debt_security_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/041_ip_technology_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/10_real_property/077_real_property_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_financials/089_financials_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/12_financials/097_northstar_orbit_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-002-07", "issue": "revenue recognition exception", "portfolio_key": "CBP-002-07", "reason": "the operational record relies on a superseded control revision", "required_next_evidence": "an operational record using the current effective revision", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_corporate/007_corporate_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/019_material_contracts_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/04_debt_security/031_debt_security_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/043_ip_technology_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/12_financials/091_financials_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/07_privacy_security/055_privacy_security_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_financials/097_northstar_orbit_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-002-08", "issue": "most-favored-customer exposure", "portfolio_key": "CBP-002-08", "reason": "two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key", "required_next_evidence": "an approved immutable entity crosswalk", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_corporate/008_corporate_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/020_material_contracts_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/04_debt_security/032_debt_security_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/044_ip_technology_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/12_financials/092_financials_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/12_financials/097_northstar_orbit_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-002-12", "issue": "open-source copyleft exposure", "portfolio_key": "CBP-002-12", "reason": "two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key", "required_next_evidence": "an approved immutable entity crosswalk", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_capitalization/012_capitalization_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/024_material_contracts_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/05_employment/036_employment_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/048_ip_technology_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/11_tax_insurance/084_tax_insurance_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/12_financials/096_financials_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_financials/097_northstar_orbit_impact_population.xlsx"]}], "matter_number": "CB-MA-2402", "prepared_for": "Northstar Orbit plc", "schema_version": "counselbench.decision.v3", "task_id": "cb100-002-northstar-orbit"}, "matter_register": {"matter_number": "CB-MA-2402", "rows": [{"decision_option_id": "northstar-orbit:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "the current observation does not meet the operative trigger", "issue": "unrecorded option grant", "matter_number": "CB-MA-2402", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-002-01", "row_id": "REG-CBP-002-01", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_corporate/001_corporate_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/02_capitalization/013_capitalization_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/04_debt_security/025_debt_security_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/05_employment/037_employment_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/11_tax_insurance/085_tax_insurance_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_financials/097_northstar_orbit_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "northstar-orbit:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective", "issue": "key-person retention gap", "matter_number": "CB-MA-2402", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-002-02", "row_id": "REG-CBP-002-02", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_corporate/002_corporate_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/02_capitalization/014_capitalization_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/04_debt_security/026_debt_security_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/05_employment/038_employment_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_financials/097_northstar_orbit_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "northstar-orbit:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-05", "issue": "threatened customer dispute", "matter_number": "CB-MA-2402", "owner": "Lena Varga", "portfolio_key": "CBP-002-03", "row_id": "REG-CBP-002-03", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_corporate/003_corporate_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/02_capitalization/015_capitalization_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/04_debt_security/027_debt_security_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/05_employment/039_employment_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/10_real_property/075_real_property_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/12_financials/097_northstar_orbit_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "northstar-orbit:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-04", "issue": "charter authorization mismatch", "matter_number": "CB-MA-2402", "owner": "Elliot Mercer", "portfolio_key": "CBP-002-04", "row_id": "REG-CBP-002-04", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_corporate/004_corporate_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/02_capitalization/016_capitalization_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/04_debt_security/028_debt_security_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/05_employment/040_employment_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_financials/097_northstar_orbit_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "northstar-orbit:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "the current observation does not meet the operative trigger", "issue": "financial covenant breach", "matter_number": "CB-MA-2402", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-002-05", "row_id": "REG-CBP-002-05", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_corporate/005_corporate_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/017_material_contracts_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/04_debt_security/029_debt_security_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/041_ip_technology_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/10_real_property/077_real_property_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_financials/089_financials_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/12_financials/097_northstar_orbit_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "northstar-orbit:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-02", "issue": "permit transfer restriction", "matter_number": "CB-MA-2402", "owner": "Micah Sullivan", "portfolio_key": "CBP-002-06", "row_id": "REG-CBP-002-06", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_corporate/006_corporate_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/018_material_contracts_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/04_debt_security/030_debt_security_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/042_ip_technology_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/12_financials/097_northstar_orbit_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "northstar-orbit:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "the operational record relies on a superseded control revision", "issue": "revenue recognition exception", "matter_number": "CB-MA-2402", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-002-07", "row_id": "REG-CBP-002-07", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_corporate/007_corporate_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/019_material_contracts_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/04_debt_security/031_debt_security_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/043_ip_technology_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/12_financials/091_financials_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/07_privacy_security/055_privacy_security_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_financials/097_northstar_orbit_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "northstar-orbit:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key", "issue": "most-favored-customer exposure", "matter_number": "CB-MA-2402", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-002-08", "row_id": "REG-CBP-002-08", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_corporate/008_corporate_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/020_material_contracts_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/04_debt_security/032_debt_security_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/044_ip_technology_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/12_financials/092_financials_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/12_financials/097_northstar_orbit_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "northstar-orbit:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-08-30", "issue": "unreported security incident", "matter_number": "CB-MA-2402", "owner": "Amara Patel", "portfolio_key": "CBP-002-09", "row_id": "REG-CBP-002-09", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_capitalization/009_capitalization_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/021_material_contracts_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/05_employment/033_employment_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/045_ip_technology_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/09_litigation/069_litigation_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_financials/093_financials_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_financials/097_northstar_orbit_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "northstar-orbit:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-07", "issue": "claims-made insurance tail", "matter_number": "CB-MA-2402", "owner": "Samuel Kim", "portfolio_key": "CBP-002-10", "row_id": "REG-CBP-002-10", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_capitalization/010_capitalization_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/022_material_contracts_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/05_employment/034_employment_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/046_ip_technology_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_financials/094_financials_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_financials/097_northstar_orbit_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "northstar-orbit:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-06", "issue": "anti-assignment restriction", "matter_number": "CB-MA-2402", "owner": "Talia Brooks", "portfolio_key": "CBP-002-11", "row_id": "REG-CBP-002-11", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_capitalization/011_capitalization_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/023_material_contracts_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/05_employment/035_employment_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/047_ip_technology_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_financials/097_northstar_orbit_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "northstar-orbit:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key", "issue": "open-source copyleft exposure", "matter_number": "CB-MA-2402", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-002-12", "row_id": "REG-CBP-002-12", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_capitalization/012_capitalization_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/024_material_contracts_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/05_employment/036_employment_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/048_ip_technology_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/11_tax_insurance/084_tax_insurance_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/12_financials/096_financials_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_financials/097_northstar_orbit_impact_population.xlsx"]}], "schema_version": "counselbench.matter-register.v3", "task_id": "cb100-002-northstar-orbit"}}, "metadata": {"benchmark": "CounselBench-100", "code_license": "Apache-2.0", "data_license": "CC-BY-4.0", "deadline": "2026-09-08", "document_count": 97, "evidence_holds": 6, "jurisdiction": "Delaware", "matter_number": "CB-MA-2402", "mcp_commit": "9a96ea6e5913736f92b88345bf51caeaaa8e719f", "mcp_package": "@modelcontextprotocol/server-filesystem@2026.7.10", "practice_area": "corporate-ma", "reference_tool_calls": 87, "required_evidence_reads": 61, "supported_actions": 6, "synthetic": true, "venue": "District of Colorado", "version": "3.1.0"}, "prompt": "The business team is asking whether it can move, and I do not want to answer from the summary deck. Is Sextant ready for signing despite the university code, classified support, and blanket-lien questions? The target licenses university navigation code, operates a classified support unit, and recently refinanced through a lender with blanket liens. The team needs the call by 2026-09-08. Document the scoped result for the team and separate genuine exceptions from unresolved identity or revision questions.", "rubric": {"criteria": [{"category": "investigation", "description": "Inventory the production and use targeted searches to locate records across native formats.", "id": "investigation.discover_production"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Complete every task-specific identity, authority, operations, and approval read before the first state transition.", "id": "investigation.read_before_write"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Inspect designated source metadata before relying on those records.", "id": "investigation.custody_before_write"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "Select the supported option 'northstar-orbit:scoped-evidence' after applying the four-part test.", "id": "decision.selected_option"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "Identify both rejected approaches and explain why a one-source shortcut and a blanket hold are wrong.", "id": "decision.alternatives"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-002-01 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_corporate/001_corporate_source_export.md rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-002-01.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_capitalization/013_capitalization_source_export.json for unrecorded option grant.", "id": "investigation.CBP-002-01.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_debt_security/025_debt_security_source_export.md to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-002-01.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_employment/037_employment_source_export.json.", "id": "investigation.CBP-002-01.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-002-01 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is the current observation does not meet the operative trigger.", "id": "decision.CBP-002-01.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-002-01 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-002-01.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-002-02 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_corporate/002_corporate_source_export.txt rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-002-02.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_capitalization/014_capitalization_source_export.xml for key-person retention gap.", "id": "investigation.CBP-002-02.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_debt_security/026_debt_security_source_export.txt to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-002-02.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_employment/038_employment_source_export.xml.", "id": "investigation.CBP-002-02.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-002-02 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective.", "id": "decision.CBP-002-02.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-002-02 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-002-02.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-002-03 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_corporate/003_corporate_source_export.eml rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-002-03.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_capitalization/015_capitalization_source_export.html for threatened customer dispute.", "id": "investigation.CBP-002-03.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_debt_security/027_debt_security_source_export.eml to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-002-03.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_employment/039_employment_source_export.html.", "id": "investigation.CBP-002-03.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-002-03 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-002-03.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-002-03 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-002-03.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-002-04 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_corporate/004_corporate_source_export.csv rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-002-04.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_capitalization/016_capitalization_source_export.pdf for charter authorization mismatch.", "id": "investigation.CBP-002-04.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_debt_security/028_debt_security_source_export.csv to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-002-04.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_employment/040_employment_source_export.pdf.", "id": "investigation.CBP-002-04.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-002-04 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-002-04.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-002-04 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-002-04.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-002-05 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_corporate/005_corporate_source_export.json rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-002-05.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/017_material_contracts_source_export.md for financial covenant breach.", "id": "investigation.CBP-002-05.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_debt_security/029_debt_security_source_export.json to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-002-05.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/041_ip_technology_source_export.md.", "id": "investigation.CBP-002-05.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-002-05 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is the current observation does not meet the operative trigger.", "id": "decision.CBP-002-05.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-002-05 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-002-05.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-002-06 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_corporate/006_corporate_source_export.xml rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-002-06.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/018_material_contracts_source_export.txt for permit transfer restriction.", "id": "investigation.CBP-002-06.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_debt_security/030_debt_security_source_export.xml to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-002-06.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/042_ip_technology_source_export.txt.", "id": "investigation.CBP-002-06.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-002-06 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-002-06.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-002-06 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-002-06.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-002-07 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_corporate/007_corporate_source_export.html rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-002-07.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/019_material_contracts_source_export.eml for revenue recognition exception.", "id": "investigation.CBP-002-07.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_debt_security/031_debt_security_source_export.html to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-002-07.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/043_ip_technology_source_export.eml.", "id": "investigation.CBP-002-07.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-002-07 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is the operational record relies on a superseded control revision.", "id": "decision.CBP-002-07.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-002-07 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-002-07.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-002-08 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_corporate/008_corporate_source_export.pdf rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-002-08.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/020_material_contracts_source_export.csv for most-favored-customer exposure.", "id": "investigation.CBP-002-08.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_debt_security/032_debt_security_source_export.pdf to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-002-08.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/044_ip_technology_source_export.csv.", "id": "investigation.CBP-002-08.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-002-08 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key.", "id": "decision.CBP-002-08.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-002-08 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-002-08.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-002-09 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_capitalization/009_capitalization_source_export.md rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-002-09.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/021_material_contracts_source_export.json for unreported security incident.", "id": "investigation.CBP-002-09.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_employment/033_employment_source_export.md to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-002-09.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/045_ip_technology_source_export.json.", "id": "investigation.CBP-002-09.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-002-09 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-002-09.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-002-09 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-002-09.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-002-10 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_capitalization/010_capitalization_source_export.txt rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-002-10.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/022_material_contracts_source_export.xml for claims-made insurance tail.", "id": "investigation.CBP-002-10.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_employment/034_employment_source_export.txt to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-002-10.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/046_ip_technology_source_export.xml.", "id": "investigation.CBP-002-10.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-002-10 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-002-10.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-002-10 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-002-10.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-002-11 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_capitalization/011_capitalization_source_export.eml rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-002-11.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/023_material_contracts_source_export.html for anti-assignment restriction.", "id": "investigation.CBP-002-11.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_employment/035_employment_source_export.eml to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-002-11.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/047_ip_technology_source_export.html.", "id": "investigation.CBP-002-11.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-002-11 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-002-11.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-002-11 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-002-11.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-002-12 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_capitalization/012_capitalization_source_export.csv rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-002-12.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/024_material_contracts_source_export.pdf for open-source copyleft exposure.", "id": "investigation.CBP-002-12.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_employment/036_employment_source_export.csv to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-002-12.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/048_ip_technology_source_export.pdf.", "id": "investigation.CBP-002-12.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-002-12 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key.", "id": "decision.CBP-002-12.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-002-12 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-002-12.register"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Write the exact selected option, supported action population, evidence-hold population, facts, owners, deadlines, and citations.", "id": "state.exact_decision"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create one exact register row per portfolio key with no extra, missing, or modified row.", "id": "state.exact_register"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Leave only the three approved deliverables and perform no extra state-changing write.", "id": "state.write_scope_containment"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Read back decision.json, matter-register.json, and advice.md after their final writes.", "id": "state.postwrite_readback"}, {"category": "answer", "description": "Explain the selected recommendation, supported actions, holds, alternatives, and limitations with exact source anchors.", "id": "answer.decision_note"}], "decision_options": [{"approach": "Use a plausible summary or one source without completing the controlling joins.", "id": "northstar-orbit:shortcut", "label": "Assume the merger transfers every license and clears every lien automatically."}, {"approach": "Treat supported actions and genuinely ambiguous records as if they were equally unresolved.", "id": "northstar-orbit:blanket-hold", "label": "Freeze the entire matter population"}, {"approach": "Apply the exact identity, current-state, authority, and revision test. Record only the transfer restrictions that survive exact asset and revision matching.", "id": "northstar-orbit:scoped-evidence", "label": "Condition signing on the specific consent, screening, or release supported by current records."}], "evaluation_narrative": {"authority": "Executed licenses, screening records, and current lien releases must all support transferability.", "observation": "Reconcile license scope, export-support activity, and lien collateral against the exact target assets.", "question": "Is Sextant ready for signing despite the university code, classified support, and blanket-lien questions?", "register_action": "Record only the transfer restrictions that survive exact asset and revision matching."}, "gates": ["all_required_evidence_precedes_first_write", "decision_criteria_complete", "register_state_exact", "write_scope_contained", "all_outputs_verified_by_readback"], "metadata_checks": 9, "metric": "weighted_criteria_score", "minimum_tool_calls": 87, "required_deliverables": ["decision.json", "matter-register.json", "advice.md"], "required_document_reads": 61, "type": "deterministic", "weights": {"advice": 0.15, "decision": 0.35, "investigation": 0.25, "state": 0.25}}, "task_id": "cb100-002-northstar-orbit", "task_name": "Project Sextant satellite software merger", "world_id": "counselbench-filesystem-mcp-v3"}
+{"context_files": ["task_files/cb100-003-lumen-health/01_corporate/001_corporate_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-003-lumen-health/01_corporate/002_corporate_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-003-lumen-health/01_corporate/003_corporate_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-003-lumen-health/01_corporate/004_corporate_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-003-lumen-health/01_corporate/005_corporate_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-003-lumen-health/01_corporate/006_corporate_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-003-lumen-health/01_corporate/007_corporate_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-003-lumen-health/01_corporate/008_corporate_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-003-lumen-health/02_capitalization/009_capitalization_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-003-lumen-health/02_capitalization/010_capitalization_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-003-lumen-health/02_capitalization/011_capitalization_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-003-lumen-health/02_capitalization/012_capitalization_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-003-lumen-health/02_capitalization/013_capitalization_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-003-lumen-health/02_capitalization/014_capitalization_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-003-lumen-health/02_capitalization/015_capitalization_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-003-lumen-health/02_capitalization/016_capitalization_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-003-lumen-health/03_material_contracts/017_material_contracts_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-003-lumen-health/03_material_contracts/018_material_contracts_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-003-lumen-health/03_material_contracts/019_material_contracts_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-003-lumen-health/03_material_contracts/020_material_contracts_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-003-lumen-health/03_material_contracts/021_material_contracts_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-003-lumen-health/03_material_contracts/022_material_contracts_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-003-lumen-health/03_material_contracts/023_material_contracts_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-003-lumen-health/03_material_contracts/024_material_contracts_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-003-lumen-health/04_debt_security/025_debt_security_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-003-lumen-health/04_debt_security/026_debt_security_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-003-lumen-health/04_debt_security/027_debt_security_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-003-lumen-health/04_debt_security/028_debt_security_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-003-lumen-health/04_debt_security/029_debt_security_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-003-lumen-health/04_debt_security/030_debt_security_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-003-lumen-health/04_debt_security/031_debt_security_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-003-lumen-health/04_debt_security/032_debt_security_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-003-lumen-health/05_employment/033_employment_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-003-lumen-health/05_employment/034_employment_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-003-lumen-health/05_employment/035_employment_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-003-lumen-health/05_employment/036_employment_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-003-lumen-health/05_employment/037_employment_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-003-lumen-health/05_employment/038_employment_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-003-lumen-health/05_employment/039_employment_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-003-lumen-health/05_employment/040_employment_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-003-lumen-health/06_ip_technology/041_ip_technology_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-003-lumen-health/06_ip_technology/042_ip_technology_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-003-lumen-health/06_ip_technology/043_ip_technology_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-003-lumen-health/06_ip_technology/044_ip_technology_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-003-lumen-health/06_ip_technology/045_ip_technology_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-003-lumen-health/06_ip_technology/046_ip_technology_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-003-lumen-health/06_ip_technology/047_ip_technology_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-003-lumen-health/06_ip_technology/048_ip_technology_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-003-lumen-health/07_privacy_security/049_privacy_security_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-003-lumen-health/07_privacy_security/050_privacy_security_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-003-lumen-health/07_privacy_security/051_privacy_security_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-003-lumen-health/07_privacy_security/052_privacy_security_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-003-lumen-health/07_privacy_security/053_privacy_security_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-003-lumen-health/07_privacy_security/054_privacy_security_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-003-lumen-health/07_privacy_security/055_privacy_security_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-003-lumen-health/07_privacy_security/056_privacy_security_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-003-lumen-health/08_regulatory/057_regulatory_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-003-lumen-health/08_regulatory/058_regulatory_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-003-lumen-health/08_regulatory/059_regulatory_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-003-lumen-health/08_regulatory/060_regulatory_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-003-lumen-health/08_regulatory/061_regulatory_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-003-lumen-health/08_regulatory/062_regulatory_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-003-lumen-health/08_regulatory/063_regulatory_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-003-lumen-health/08_regulatory/064_regulatory_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-003-lumen-health/09_litigation/065_litigation_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-003-lumen-health/09_litigation/066_litigation_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-003-lumen-health/09_litigation/067_litigation_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-003-lumen-health/09_litigation/068_litigation_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-003-lumen-health/09_litigation/069_litigation_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-003-lumen-health/09_litigation/070_litigation_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-003-lumen-health/09_litigation/071_litigation_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-003-lumen-health/09_litigation/072_litigation_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-003-lumen-health/10_real_property/073_real_property_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-003-lumen-health/10_real_property/074_real_property_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-003-lumen-health/10_real_property/075_real_property_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-003-lumen-health/10_real_property/076_real_property_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-003-lumen-health/10_real_property/077_real_property_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-003-lumen-health/10_real_property/078_real_property_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-003-lumen-health/10_real_property/079_real_property_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-003-lumen-health/10_real_property/080_real_property_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-003-lumen-health/11_tax_insurance/081_tax_insurance_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-003-lumen-health/11_tax_insurance/082_tax_insurance_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-003-lumen-health/11_tax_insurance/083_tax_insurance_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-003-lumen-health/11_tax_insurance/084_tax_insurance_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-003-lumen-health/11_tax_insurance/085_tax_insurance_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-003-lumen-health/11_tax_insurance/086_tax_insurance_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-003-lumen-health/11_tax_insurance/087_tax_insurance_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-003-lumen-health/11_tax_insurance/088_tax_insurance_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-003-lumen-health/12_financials/089_financials_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-003-lumen-health/12_financials/090_financials_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-003-lumen-health/12_financials/091_financials_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-003-lumen-health/12_financials/092_financials_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-003-lumen-health/12_financials/093_financials_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-003-lumen-health/12_financials/094_financials_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-003-lumen-health/12_financials/095_financials_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-003-lumen-health/12_financials/096_financials_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-003-lumen-health/12_financials/097_lumen_health_impact_population.xlsx"], "gold_output": {"advice_markdown": "# Decision note — Project Orchard clinic platform purchase\n\n## Recommendation\n\nProceed with scoped remediation for supported exclusivity, consent, and data-use exceptions. The reconciled record supports 6 scoped actions and leaves 6 items on evidence hold.\n\nSelected option: `lumen-health:scoped-evidence`.\n\n## Why this is the supported option\n\nJoin physician, privacy, and revenue-share records to the same product and contracting entity. Current executed terms and applicable patient-data controls outrank sales characterizations.\n\n## Supported actions\n\n### CBP-003-01 — change-of-control consent (high)\n\napproval must come from Nora Chen under CB-MA-2403-R116; the effective approval record names Caleb Hassan under CB-MA-2403-E948. Identity resolves to ENT-003-1000, revision REV-2025.1 is current, and Isaac Romero is active with capacity 4.\n\nAction: Write owned closing items for proven restrictions and evidence holds for unresolved identities. Owner: Isaac Romero; due 2026-09-10.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_corporate/001_corporate_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/02_capitalization/013_capitalization_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/04_debt_security/025_debt_security_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/05_employment/037_employment_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/11_tax_insurance/085_tax_insurance_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/12_financials/097_lumen_health_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-003-03 — facility title exception (medium)\n\nthe permission is limited to Kings County, New York under CB-MA-2403-R742; the matched activity occurred in New York under CB-MA-2403-E720. Identity resolves to ENT-003-1002, revision REV-2025.3 is current, and Rafael Okafor is active with capacity 3.\n\nAction: Write owned closing items for proven restrictions and evidence holds for unresolved identities. Owner: Rafael Okafor; due 2026-09-08.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_corporate/003_corporate_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/02_capitalization/015_capitalization_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/04_debt_security/027_debt_security_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/05_employment/039_employment_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/11_tax_insurance/087_tax_insurance_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/12_financials/097_lumen_health_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-003-07 — charter authorization mismatch (high)\n\ncompletion is required by 2026-01-12 under CB-MA-2403-R771; the current event record shows completion on 2026-02-17 under CB-MA-2403-E615. Identity resolves to ENT-003-1006, revision REV-2025.7 is current, and Elliot Mercer is active with capacity 6.\n\nAction: Write owned closing items for proven restrictions and evidence holds for unresolved identities. Owner: Elliot Mercer; due 2026-09-04.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_corporate/007_corporate_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/019_material_contracts_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/04_debt_security/031_debt_security_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/043_ip_technology_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/12_financials/097_lumen_health_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-003-09 — permit transfer restriction (low)\n\napproval must come from Nora Chen under CB-MA-2403-R700; the effective approval record names Rafael Okafor under CB-MA-2403-E823. Identity resolves to ENT-003-1008, revision REV-2025.2 is current, and Micah Sullivan is active with capacity 4.\n\nAction: Write owned closing items for proven restrictions and evidence holds for unresolved identities. Owner: Micah Sullivan; due 2026-09-02.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/02_capitalization/009_capitalization_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/021_material_contracts_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/05_employment/033_employment_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/045_ip_technology_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/12_financials/093_financials_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/09_litigation/069_litigation_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/12_financials/097_lumen_health_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-003-10 — revenue recognition exception (low)\n\nthe controlled population contains 190 records under CB-MA-2403-R958; the certification covers 170 records under CB-MA-2403-E626. Identity resolves to ENT-003-1009, revision REV-2025.3 is current, and Nora Chen is active with capacity 3.\n\nAction: Write owned closing items for proven restrictions and evidence holds for unresolved identities. Owner: Nora Chen; due 2026-09-10.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/02_capitalization/010_capitalization_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/022_material_contracts_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/05_employment/034_employment_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/046_ip_technology_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/12_financials/097_lumen_health_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-003-11 — most-favored-customer exposure (critical)\n\nthe permission is limited to Kings County, New York under CB-MA-2403-R472; the matched activity occurred in New York under CB-MA-2403-E651. Identity resolves to ENT-003-1010, revision REV-2025.4 is current, and Caleb Hassan is active with capacity 2.\n\nAction: Write owned closing items for proven restrictions and evidence holds for unresolved identities. Owner: Caleb Hassan; due 2026-09-09.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/02_capitalization/011_capitalization_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/023_material_contracts_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/05_employment/035_employment_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/047_ip_technology_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/12_financials/095_financials_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/12_financials/097_lumen_health_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n## Evidence holds\n\n- **CBP-003-02 — invention assignment defect**: the operational record relies on a superseded control revision. Next evidence: an operational record using the current effective revision. Sources: `/workspace/documents/01_corporate/002_corporate_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/02_capitalization/014_capitalization_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/04_debt_security/026_debt_security_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/05_employment/038_employment_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/08_regulatory/062_regulatory_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/12_financials/097_lumen_health_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-003-04 — unrecorded option grant**: the current observation does not meet the operative trigger. Next evidence: a current observation that satisfies the operative trigger. Sources: `/workspace/documents/01_corporate/004_corporate_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/02_capitalization/016_capitalization_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/04_debt_security/028_debt_security_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/05_employment/040_employment_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/11_tax_insurance/088_tax_insurance_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/10_real_property/076_real_property_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/12_financials/097_lumen_health_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-003-05 — key-person retention gap**: the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective. Next evidence: effective approval and an active owner with remaining capacity. Sources: `/workspace/documents/01_corporate/005_corporate_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/017_material_contracts_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/04_debt_security/029_debt_security_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/041_ip_technology_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/07_privacy_security/053_privacy_security_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/12_financials/097_lumen_health_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-003-06 — threatened customer dispute**: the operational record relies on a superseded control revision. Next evidence: an operational record using the current effective revision. Sources: `/workspace/documents/01_corporate/006_corporate_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/018_material_contracts_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/04_debt_security/030_debt_security_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/042_ip_technology_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/12_financials/097_lumen_health_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-003-08 — financial covenant breach**: the current observation does not meet the operative trigger. Next evidence: a current observation that satisfies the operative trigger. Sources: `/workspace/documents/01_corporate/008_corporate_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/020_material_contracts_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/04_debt_security/032_debt_security_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/044_ip_technology_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/12_financials/097_lumen_health_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-003-12 — unreported security incident**: the current observation does not meet the operative trigger. Next evidence: a current observation that satisfies the operative trigger. Sources: `/workspace/documents/02_capitalization/012_capitalization_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/024_material_contracts_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/05_employment/036_employment_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/048_ip_technology_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/12_financials/097_lumen_health_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n## Alternatives considered\n\n- `lumen-health:blanket-hold` — Freeze the entire matter population: Treat supported actions and genuinely ambiguous records as if they were equally unresolved.\n- `lumen-health:shortcut` — Treat every channel relationship as nonexclusive because the seller uses that label.: Use a plausible summary or one source without completing the controlling joins.\n\n## Assumptions and limits\n\nThis decision is limited to cb100-003-lumen-health, the supplied synthetic records, and the matter state as of 2026-09-11. Similar names, stale revisions, and pending authority are not treated as proof.\n", "decision": {"actions": [{"determination": "approval must come from Nora Chen under CB-MA-2403-R116; the effective approval record names Caleb Hassan under CB-MA-2403-E948. Identity resolves to ENT-003-1000, revision REV-2025.1 is current, and Isaac Romero is active with capacity 4.", "due_date": "2026-09-10", "id": "ACT-CBP-003-01", "identity_id": "ENT-003-1000", "issue": "change-of-control consent", "owner": "Isaac Romero", "portfolio_key": "CBP-003-01", "recommended_action": "Write owned closing items for proven restrictions and evidence holds for unresolved identities. Owner: Isaac Romero; due 2026-09-10.", "severity": "high", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_corporate/001_corporate_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/02_capitalization/013_capitalization_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/04_debt_security/025_debt_security_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/05_employment/037_employment_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/11_tax_insurance/085_tax_insurance_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_financials/097_lumen_health_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "the permission is limited to Kings County, New York under CB-MA-2403-R742; the matched activity occurred in New York under CB-MA-2403-E720. Identity resolves to ENT-003-1002, revision REV-2025.3 is current, and Rafael Okafor is active with capacity 3.", "due_date": "2026-09-08", "id": "ACT-CBP-003-03", "identity_id": "ENT-003-1002", "issue": "facility title exception", "owner": "Rafael Okafor", "portfolio_key": "CBP-003-03", "recommended_action": "Write owned closing items for proven restrictions and evidence holds for unresolved identities. Owner: Rafael Okafor; due 2026-09-08.", "severity": "medium", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_corporate/003_corporate_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/02_capitalization/015_capitalization_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/04_debt_security/027_debt_security_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/05_employment/039_employment_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/11_tax_insurance/087_tax_insurance_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_financials/097_lumen_health_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "completion is required by 2026-01-12 under CB-MA-2403-R771; the current event record shows completion on 2026-02-17 under CB-MA-2403-E615. Identity resolves to ENT-003-1006, revision REV-2025.7 is current, and Elliot Mercer is active with capacity 6.", "due_date": "2026-09-04", "id": "ACT-CBP-003-07", "identity_id": "ENT-003-1006", "issue": "charter authorization mismatch", "owner": "Elliot Mercer", "portfolio_key": "CBP-003-07", "recommended_action": "Write owned closing items for proven restrictions and evidence holds for unresolved identities. Owner: Elliot Mercer; due 2026-09-04.", "severity": "high", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_corporate/007_corporate_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/019_material_contracts_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/04_debt_security/031_debt_security_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/043_ip_technology_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/12_financials/097_lumen_health_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "approval must come from Nora Chen under CB-MA-2403-R700; the effective approval record names Rafael Okafor under CB-MA-2403-E823. Identity resolves to ENT-003-1008, revision REV-2025.2 is current, and Micah Sullivan is active with capacity 4.", "due_date": "2026-09-02", "id": "ACT-CBP-003-09", "identity_id": "ENT-003-1008", "issue": "permit transfer restriction", "owner": "Micah Sullivan", "portfolio_key": "CBP-003-09", "recommended_action": "Write owned closing items for proven restrictions and evidence holds for unresolved identities. Owner: Micah Sullivan; due 2026-09-02.", "severity": "low", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_capitalization/009_capitalization_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/021_material_contracts_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/05_employment/033_employment_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/045_ip_technology_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_financials/093_financials_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/09_litigation/069_litigation_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_financials/097_lumen_health_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "the controlled population contains 190 records under CB-MA-2403-R958; the certification covers 170 records under CB-MA-2403-E626. Identity resolves to ENT-003-1009, revision REV-2025.3 is current, and Nora Chen is active with capacity 3.", "due_date": "2026-09-10", "id": "ACT-CBP-003-10", "identity_id": "ENT-003-1009", "issue": "revenue recognition exception", "owner": "Nora Chen", "portfolio_key": "CBP-003-10", "recommended_action": "Write owned closing items for proven restrictions and evidence holds for unresolved identities. Owner: Nora Chen; due 2026-09-10.", "severity": "low", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_capitalization/010_capitalization_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/022_material_contracts_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/05_employment/034_employment_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/046_ip_technology_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_financials/097_lumen_health_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "the permission is limited to Kings County, New York under CB-MA-2403-R472; the matched activity occurred in New York under CB-MA-2403-E651. Identity resolves to ENT-003-1010, revision REV-2025.4 is current, and Caleb Hassan is active with capacity 2.", "due_date": "2026-09-09", "id": "ACT-CBP-003-11", "identity_id": "ENT-003-1010", "issue": "most-favored-customer exposure", "owner": "Caleb Hassan", "portfolio_key": "CBP-003-11", "recommended_action": "Write owned closing items for proven restrictions and evidence holds for unresolved identities. Owner: Caleb Hassan; due 2026-09-09.", "severity": "critical", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_capitalization/011_capitalization_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/023_material_contracts_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/05_employment/035_employment_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/047_ip_technology_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_financials/095_financials_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_financials/097_lumen_health_impact_population.xlsx"]}], "as_of": "2026-09-11", "decision": {"alternatives_considered": ["lumen-health:blanket-hold", "lumen-health:shortcut"], "question": "What must be fixed before Orchard can close without inheriting an undisclosed channel or patient-data restriction?", "rationale": "The four-part causal test supports 6 scoped actions and leaves 6 records on evidence hold. Current executed terms and applicable patient-data controls outrank sales characterizations.", "recommendation": "Proceed with scoped remediation for supported exclusivity, consent, and data-use exceptions.", "selected_option_id": "lumen-health:scoped-evidence"}, "holds": [{"id": "HOLD-CBP-003-02", "issue": "invention assignment defect", "portfolio_key": "CBP-003-02", "reason": "the operational record relies on a superseded control revision", "required_next_evidence": "an operational record using the current effective revision", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_corporate/002_corporate_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/02_capitalization/014_capitalization_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/04_debt_security/026_debt_security_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/05_employment/038_employment_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/08_regulatory/062_regulatory_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_financials/097_lumen_health_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-003-04", "issue": "unrecorded option grant", "portfolio_key": "CBP-003-04", "reason": "the current observation does not meet the operative trigger", "required_next_evidence": "a current observation that satisfies the operative trigger", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_corporate/004_corporate_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/02_capitalization/016_capitalization_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/04_debt_security/028_debt_security_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/05_employment/040_employment_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/11_tax_insurance/088_tax_insurance_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/10_real_property/076_real_property_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/12_financials/097_lumen_health_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-003-05", "issue": "key-person retention gap", "portfolio_key": "CBP-003-05", "reason": "the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective", "required_next_evidence": "effective approval and an active owner with remaining capacity", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_corporate/005_corporate_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/017_material_contracts_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/04_debt_security/029_debt_security_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/041_ip_technology_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/07_privacy_security/053_privacy_security_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_financials/097_lumen_health_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-003-06", "issue": "threatened customer dispute", "portfolio_key": "CBP-003-06", "reason": "the operational record relies on a superseded control revision", "required_next_evidence": "an operational record using the current effective revision", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_corporate/006_corporate_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/018_material_contracts_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/04_debt_security/030_debt_security_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/042_ip_technology_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/12_financials/097_lumen_health_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-003-08", "issue": "financial covenant breach", "portfolio_key": "CBP-003-08", "reason": "the current observation does not meet the operative trigger", "required_next_evidence": "a current observation that satisfies the operative trigger", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_corporate/008_corporate_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/020_material_contracts_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/04_debt_security/032_debt_security_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/044_ip_technology_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/12_financials/097_lumen_health_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-003-12", "issue": "unreported security incident", "portfolio_key": "CBP-003-12", "reason": "the current observation does not meet the operative trigger", "required_next_evidence": "a current observation that satisfies the operative trigger", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_capitalization/012_capitalization_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/024_material_contracts_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/05_employment/036_employment_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/048_ip_technology_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_financials/097_lumen_health_impact_population.xlsx"]}], "matter_number": "CB-MA-2403", "prepared_for": "Lumen Health Partners", "schema_version": "counselbench.decision.v3", "task_id": "cb100-003-lumen-health"}, "matter_register": {"matter_number": "CB-MA-2403", "rows": [{"decision_option_id": "lumen-health:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-10", "issue": "change-of-control consent", "matter_number": "CB-MA-2403", "owner": "Isaac Romero", "portfolio_key": "CBP-003-01", "row_id": "REG-CBP-003-01", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_corporate/001_corporate_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/02_capitalization/013_capitalization_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/04_debt_security/025_debt_security_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/05_employment/037_employment_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/11_tax_insurance/085_tax_insurance_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_financials/097_lumen_health_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "lumen-health:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "the operational record relies on a superseded control revision", "issue": "invention assignment defect", "matter_number": "CB-MA-2403", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-003-02", "row_id": "REG-CBP-003-02", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_corporate/002_corporate_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/02_capitalization/014_capitalization_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/04_debt_security/026_debt_security_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/05_employment/038_employment_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/08_regulatory/062_regulatory_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_financials/097_lumen_health_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "lumen-health:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-08", "issue": "facility title exception", "matter_number": "CB-MA-2403", "owner": "Rafael Okafor", "portfolio_key": "CBP-003-03", "row_id": "REG-CBP-003-03", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_corporate/003_corporate_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/02_capitalization/015_capitalization_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/04_debt_security/027_debt_security_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/05_employment/039_employment_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/11_tax_insurance/087_tax_insurance_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_financials/097_lumen_health_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "lumen-health:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "the current observation does not meet the operative trigger", "issue": "unrecorded option grant", "matter_number": "CB-MA-2403", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-003-04", "row_id": "REG-CBP-003-04", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_corporate/004_corporate_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/02_capitalization/016_capitalization_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/04_debt_security/028_debt_security_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/05_employment/040_employment_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/11_tax_insurance/088_tax_insurance_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/10_real_property/076_real_property_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/12_financials/097_lumen_health_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "lumen-health:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective", "issue": "key-person retention gap", "matter_number": "CB-MA-2403", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-003-05", "row_id": "REG-CBP-003-05", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_corporate/005_corporate_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/017_material_contracts_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/04_debt_security/029_debt_security_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/041_ip_technology_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/07_privacy_security/053_privacy_security_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_financials/097_lumen_health_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "lumen-health:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "the operational record relies on a superseded control revision", "issue": "threatened customer dispute", "matter_number": "CB-MA-2403", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-003-06", "row_id": "REG-CBP-003-06", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_corporate/006_corporate_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/018_material_contracts_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/04_debt_security/030_debt_security_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/042_ip_technology_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/12_financials/097_lumen_health_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "lumen-health:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-04", "issue": "charter authorization mismatch", "matter_number": "CB-MA-2403", "owner": "Elliot Mercer", "portfolio_key": "CBP-003-07", "row_id": "REG-CBP-003-07", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_corporate/007_corporate_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/019_material_contracts_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/04_debt_security/031_debt_security_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/043_ip_technology_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/12_financials/097_lumen_health_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "lumen-health:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "the current observation does not meet the operative trigger", "issue": "financial covenant breach", "matter_number": "CB-MA-2403", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-003-08", "row_id": "REG-CBP-003-08", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_corporate/008_corporate_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/020_material_contracts_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/04_debt_security/032_debt_security_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/044_ip_technology_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/12_financials/097_lumen_health_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "lumen-health:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-02", "issue": "permit transfer restriction", "matter_number": "CB-MA-2403", "owner": "Micah Sullivan", "portfolio_key": "CBP-003-09", "row_id": "REG-CBP-003-09", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_capitalization/009_capitalization_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/021_material_contracts_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/05_employment/033_employment_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/045_ip_technology_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_financials/093_financials_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/09_litigation/069_litigation_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_financials/097_lumen_health_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "lumen-health:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-10", "issue": "revenue recognition exception", "matter_number": "CB-MA-2403", "owner": "Nora Chen", "portfolio_key": "CBP-003-10", "row_id": "REG-CBP-003-10", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_capitalization/010_capitalization_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/022_material_contracts_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/05_employment/034_employment_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/046_ip_technology_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_financials/097_lumen_health_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "lumen-health:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-09", "issue": "most-favored-customer exposure", "matter_number": "CB-MA-2403", "owner": "Caleb Hassan", "portfolio_key": "CBP-003-11", "row_id": "REG-CBP-003-11", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_capitalization/011_capitalization_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/023_material_contracts_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/05_employment/035_employment_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/047_ip_technology_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_financials/095_financials_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_financials/097_lumen_health_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "lumen-health:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "the current observation does not meet the operative trigger", "issue": "unreported security incident", "matter_number": "CB-MA-2403", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-003-12", "row_id": "REG-CBP-003-12", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_capitalization/012_capitalization_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/024_material_contracts_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/05_employment/036_employment_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/048_ip_technology_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_financials/097_lumen_health_impact_population.xlsx"]}], "schema_version": "counselbench.matter-register.v3", "task_id": "cb100-003-lumen-health"}}, "metadata": {"benchmark": "CounselBench-100", "code_license": "Apache-2.0", "data_license": "CC-BY-4.0", "deadline": "2026-09-11", "document_count": 97, "evidence_holds": 6, "jurisdiction": "New York", "matter_number": "CB-MA-2403", "mcp_commit": "9a96ea6e5913736f92b88345bf51caeaaa8e719f", "mcp_package": "@modelcontextprotocol/server-filesystem@2026.7.10", "practice_area": "corporate-ma", "reference_tool_calls": 78, "required_evidence_reads": 59, "supported_actions": 6, "synthetic": true, "venue": "Kings County, New York", "version": "3.1.0"}, "prompt": "A late record changed the picture this morning. What must be fixed before Orchard can close without inheriting an undisclosed channel or patient-data restriction? A healthcare scheduling platform combines physician contracts, patient data, and a revenue-share channel relationship that the seller treats as nonexclusive. The team needs the call by 2026-09-11. Make the matter record usable by operations after your review, but do not turn ambiguity into an accusation or obligation.", "rubric": {"criteria": [{"category": "investigation", "description": "Inventory the production and use targeted searches to locate records across native formats.", "id": "investigation.discover_production"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Complete every task-specific identity, authority, operations, and approval read before the first state transition.", "id": "investigation.read_before_write"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Inspect designated source metadata before relying on those records.", "id": "investigation.custody_before_write"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "Select the supported option 'lumen-health:scoped-evidence' after applying the four-part test.", "id": "decision.selected_option"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "Identify both rejected approaches and explain why a one-source shortcut and a blanket hold are wrong.", "id": "decision.alternatives"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-003-01 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_corporate/001_corporate_source_export.md rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-003-01.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_capitalization/013_capitalization_source_export.json for change-of-control consent.", "id": "investigation.CBP-003-01.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_debt_security/025_debt_security_source_export.md to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-003-01.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_employment/037_employment_source_export.json.", "id": "investigation.CBP-003-01.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-003-01 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-003-01.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-003-01 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-003-01.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-003-02 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_corporate/002_corporate_source_export.txt rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-003-02.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_capitalization/014_capitalization_source_export.xml for invention assignment defect.", "id": "investigation.CBP-003-02.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_debt_security/026_debt_security_source_export.txt to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-003-02.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_employment/038_employment_source_export.xml.", "id": "investigation.CBP-003-02.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-003-02 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is the operational record relies on a superseded control revision.", "id": "decision.CBP-003-02.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-003-02 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-003-02.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-003-03 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_corporate/003_corporate_source_export.eml rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-003-03.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_capitalization/015_capitalization_source_export.html for facility title exception.", "id": "investigation.CBP-003-03.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_debt_security/027_debt_security_source_export.eml to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-003-03.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_employment/039_employment_source_export.html.", "id": "investigation.CBP-003-03.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-003-03 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-003-03.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-003-03 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-003-03.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-003-04 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_corporate/004_corporate_source_export.csv rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-003-04.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_capitalization/016_capitalization_source_export.pdf for unrecorded option grant.", "id": "investigation.CBP-003-04.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_debt_security/028_debt_security_source_export.csv to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-003-04.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_employment/040_employment_source_export.pdf.", "id": "investigation.CBP-003-04.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-003-04 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is the current observation does not meet the operative trigger.", "id": "decision.CBP-003-04.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-003-04 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-003-04.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-003-05 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_corporate/005_corporate_source_export.json rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-003-05.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/017_material_contracts_source_export.md for key-person retention gap.", "id": "investigation.CBP-003-05.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_debt_security/029_debt_security_source_export.json to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-003-05.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/041_ip_technology_source_export.md.", "id": "investigation.CBP-003-05.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-003-05 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective.", "id": "decision.CBP-003-05.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-003-05 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-003-05.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-003-06 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_corporate/006_corporate_source_export.xml rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-003-06.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/018_material_contracts_source_export.txt for threatened customer dispute.", "id": "investigation.CBP-003-06.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_debt_security/030_debt_security_source_export.xml to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-003-06.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/042_ip_technology_source_export.txt.", "id": "investigation.CBP-003-06.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-003-06 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is the operational record relies on a superseded control revision.", "id": "decision.CBP-003-06.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-003-06 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-003-06.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-003-07 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_corporate/007_corporate_source_export.html rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-003-07.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/019_material_contracts_source_export.eml for charter authorization mismatch.", "id": "investigation.CBP-003-07.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_debt_security/031_debt_security_source_export.html to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-003-07.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/043_ip_technology_source_export.eml.", "id": "investigation.CBP-003-07.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-003-07 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-003-07.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-003-07 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-003-07.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-003-08 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_corporate/008_corporate_source_export.pdf rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-003-08.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/020_material_contracts_source_export.csv for financial covenant breach.", "id": "investigation.CBP-003-08.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_debt_security/032_debt_security_source_export.pdf to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-003-08.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/044_ip_technology_source_export.csv.", "id": "investigation.CBP-003-08.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-003-08 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is the current observation does not meet the operative trigger.", "id": "decision.CBP-003-08.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-003-08 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-003-08.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-003-09 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_capitalization/009_capitalization_source_export.md rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-003-09.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/021_material_contracts_source_export.json for permit transfer restriction.", "id": "investigation.CBP-003-09.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_employment/033_employment_source_export.md to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-003-09.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/045_ip_technology_source_export.json.", "id": "investigation.CBP-003-09.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-003-09 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-003-09.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-003-09 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-003-09.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-003-10 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_capitalization/010_capitalization_source_export.txt rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-003-10.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/022_material_contracts_source_export.xml for revenue recognition exception.", "id": "investigation.CBP-003-10.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_employment/034_employment_source_export.txt to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-003-10.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/046_ip_technology_source_export.xml.", "id": "investigation.CBP-003-10.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-003-10 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-003-10.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-003-10 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-003-10.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-003-11 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_capitalization/011_capitalization_source_export.eml rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-003-11.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/023_material_contracts_source_export.html for most-favored-customer exposure.", "id": "investigation.CBP-003-11.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_employment/035_employment_source_export.eml to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-003-11.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/047_ip_technology_source_export.html.", "id": "investigation.CBP-003-11.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-003-11 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-003-11.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-003-11 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-003-11.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-003-12 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_capitalization/012_capitalization_source_export.csv rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-003-12.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/024_material_contracts_source_export.pdf for unreported security incident.", "id": "investigation.CBP-003-12.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_employment/036_employment_source_export.csv to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-003-12.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/048_ip_technology_source_export.pdf.", "id": "investigation.CBP-003-12.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-003-12 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is the current observation does not meet the operative trigger.", "id": "decision.CBP-003-12.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-003-12 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-003-12.register"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Write the exact selected option, supported action population, evidence-hold population, facts, owners, deadlines, and citations.", "id": "state.exact_decision"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create one exact register row per portfolio key with no extra, missing, or modified row.", "id": "state.exact_register"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Leave only the three approved deliverables and perform no extra state-changing write.", "id": "state.write_scope_containment"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Read back decision.json, matter-register.json, and advice.md after their final writes.", "id": "state.postwrite_readback"}, {"category": "answer", "description": "Explain the selected recommendation, supported actions, holds, alternatives, and limitations with exact source anchors.", "id": "answer.decision_note"}], "decision_options": [{"approach": "Treat supported actions and genuinely ambiguous records as if they were equally unresolved.", "id": "lumen-health:blanket-hold", "label": "Freeze the entire matter population"}, {"approach": "Apply the exact identity, current-state, authority, and revision test. Write owned closing items for proven restrictions and evidence holds for unresolved identities.", "id": "lumen-health:scoped-evidence", "label": "Proceed with scoped remediation for supported exclusivity, consent, and data-use exceptions."}, {"approach": "Use a plausible summary or one source without completing the controlling joins.", "id": "lumen-health:shortcut", "label": "Treat every channel relationship as nonexclusive because the seller uses that label."}], "evaluation_narrative": {"authority": "Current executed terms and applicable patient-data controls outrank sales characterizations.", "observation": "Join physician, privacy, and revenue-share records to the same product and contracting entity.", "question": "What must be fixed before Orchard can close without inheriting an undisclosed channel or patient-data restriction?", "register_action": "Write owned closing items for proven restrictions and evidence holds for unresolved identities."}, "gates": ["all_required_evidence_precedes_first_write", "decision_criteria_complete", "register_state_exact", "write_scope_contained", "all_outputs_verified_by_readback"], "metadata_checks": 5, "metric": "weighted_criteria_score", "minimum_tool_calls": 78, "required_deliverables": ["decision.json", "matter-register.json", "advice.md"], "required_document_reads": 59, "type": "deterministic", "weights": {"advice": 0.15, "decision": 0.35, "investigation": 0.25, "state": 0.25}}, "task_id": "cb100-003-lumen-health", "task_name": "Project Orchard clinic platform purchase", "world_id": "counselbench-filesystem-mcp-v3"}
+{"context_files": ["task_files/cb100-004-tamarack-foods/01_corporate/001_corporate_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-004-tamarack-foods/01_corporate/002_corporate_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-004-tamarack-foods/01_corporate/003_corporate_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-004-tamarack-foods/01_corporate/004_corporate_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-004-tamarack-foods/01_corporate/005_corporate_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-004-tamarack-foods/01_corporate/006_corporate_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-004-tamarack-foods/01_corporate/007_corporate_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-004-tamarack-foods/01_corporate/008_corporate_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-004-tamarack-foods/02_capitalization/009_capitalization_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-004-tamarack-foods/02_capitalization/010_capitalization_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-004-tamarack-foods/02_capitalization/011_capitalization_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-004-tamarack-foods/02_capitalization/012_capitalization_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-004-tamarack-foods/02_capitalization/013_capitalization_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-004-tamarack-foods/02_capitalization/014_capitalization_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-004-tamarack-foods/02_capitalization/015_capitalization_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-004-tamarack-foods/02_capitalization/016_capitalization_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-004-tamarack-foods/03_material_contracts/017_material_contracts_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-004-tamarack-foods/03_material_contracts/018_material_contracts_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-004-tamarack-foods/03_material_contracts/019_material_contracts_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-004-tamarack-foods/03_material_contracts/020_material_contracts_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-004-tamarack-foods/03_material_contracts/021_material_contracts_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-004-tamarack-foods/03_material_contracts/022_material_contracts_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-004-tamarack-foods/03_material_contracts/023_material_contracts_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-004-tamarack-foods/03_material_contracts/024_material_contracts_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-004-tamarack-foods/04_debt_security/025_debt_security_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-004-tamarack-foods/04_debt_security/026_debt_security_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-004-tamarack-foods/04_debt_security/027_debt_security_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-004-tamarack-foods/04_debt_security/028_debt_security_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-004-tamarack-foods/04_debt_security/029_debt_security_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-004-tamarack-foods/04_debt_security/030_debt_security_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-004-tamarack-foods/04_debt_security/031_debt_security_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-004-tamarack-foods/04_debt_security/032_debt_security_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-004-tamarack-foods/05_employment/033_employment_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-004-tamarack-foods/05_employment/034_employment_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-004-tamarack-foods/05_employment/035_employment_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-004-tamarack-foods/05_employment/036_employment_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-004-tamarack-foods/05_employment/037_employment_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-004-tamarack-foods/05_employment/038_employment_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-004-tamarack-foods/05_employment/039_employment_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-004-tamarack-foods/05_employment/040_employment_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-004-tamarack-foods/06_ip_technology/041_ip_technology_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-004-tamarack-foods/06_ip_technology/042_ip_technology_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-004-tamarack-foods/06_ip_technology/043_ip_technology_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-004-tamarack-foods/06_ip_technology/044_ip_technology_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-004-tamarack-foods/06_ip_technology/045_ip_technology_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-004-tamarack-foods/06_ip_technology/046_ip_technology_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-004-tamarack-foods/06_ip_technology/047_ip_technology_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-004-tamarack-foods/06_ip_technology/048_ip_technology_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-004-tamarack-foods/07_privacy_security/049_privacy_security_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-004-tamarack-foods/07_privacy_security/050_privacy_security_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-004-tamarack-foods/07_privacy_security/051_privacy_security_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-004-tamarack-foods/07_privacy_security/052_privacy_security_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-004-tamarack-foods/07_privacy_security/053_privacy_security_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-004-tamarack-foods/07_privacy_security/054_privacy_security_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-004-tamarack-foods/07_privacy_security/055_privacy_security_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-004-tamarack-foods/07_privacy_security/056_privacy_security_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-004-tamarack-foods/08_regulatory/057_regulatory_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-004-tamarack-foods/08_regulatory/058_regulatory_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-004-tamarack-foods/08_regulatory/059_regulatory_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-004-tamarack-foods/08_regulatory/060_regulatory_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-004-tamarack-foods/08_regulatory/061_regulatory_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-004-tamarack-foods/08_regulatory/062_regulatory_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-004-tamarack-foods/08_regulatory/063_regulatory_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-004-tamarack-foods/08_regulatory/064_regulatory_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-004-tamarack-foods/09_litigation/065_litigation_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-004-tamarack-foods/09_litigation/066_litigation_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-004-tamarack-foods/09_litigation/067_litigation_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-004-tamarack-foods/09_litigation/068_litigation_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-004-tamarack-foods/09_litigation/069_litigation_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-004-tamarack-foods/09_litigation/070_litigation_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-004-tamarack-foods/09_litigation/071_litigation_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-004-tamarack-foods/09_litigation/072_litigation_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-004-tamarack-foods/10_real_property/073_real_property_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-004-tamarack-foods/10_real_property/074_real_property_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-004-tamarack-foods/10_real_property/075_real_property_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-004-tamarack-foods/10_real_property/076_real_property_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-004-tamarack-foods/10_real_property/077_real_property_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-004-tamarack-foods/10_real_property/078_real_property_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-004-tamarack-foods/10_real_property/079_real_property_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-004-tamarack-foods/10_real_property/080_real_property_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-004-tamarack-foods/11_tax_insurance/081_tax_insurance_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-004-tamarack-foods/11_tax_insurance/082_tax_insurance_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-004-tamarack-foods/11_tax_insurance/083_tax_insurance_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-004-tamarack-foods/11_tax_insurance/084_tax_insurance_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-004-tamarack-foods/11_tax_insurance/085_tax_insurance_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-004-tamarack-foods/11_tax_insurance/086_tax_insurance_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-004-tamarack-foods/11_tax_insurance/087_tax_insurance_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-004-tamarack-foods/11_tax_insurance/088_tax_insurance_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-004-tamarack-foods/12_financials/089_financials_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-004-tamarack-foods/12_financials/090_financials_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-004-tamarack-foods/12_financials/091_financials_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-004-tamarack-foods/12_financials/092_financials_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-004-tamarack-foods/12_financials/093_financials_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-004-tamarack-foods/12_financials/094_financials_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-004-tamarack-foods/12_financials/095_financials_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-004-tamarack-foods/12_financials/096_financials_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-004-tamarack-foods/12_financials/097_tamarack_foods_impact_population.xlsx"], "gold_output": {"advice_markdown": "# Decision note — Project Copper Kettle food plant divestiture\n\n## Recommendation\n\nSeparate on schedule only where consents, liabilities, and transition ownership are documented. The reconciled record supports 9 scoped actions and leaves 3 items on evidence hold.\n\nSelected option: `tamarack-foods:scoped-evidence`.\n\n## Why this is the supported option\n\nCompare permit, union, customer, and accrual records for the divested facility and effective period. Transfer terms, permit conditions, and the operative labor agreement determine required treatment.\n\n## Supported actions\n\n### CBP-004-01 — anti-assignment restriction (high)\n\nan open exception blocks completion under CB-MA-2404-R605; the current status is open and unresolved under CB-MA-2404-E606. Identity resolves to ENT-004-1000, revision REV-2026.1 is current, and Willa Novak is active with capacity 6.\n\nAction: Create separation-register rows for supported consents, assumed liabilities, and retained holds. Owner: Willa Novak; due 2026-09-14.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_corporate/001_corporate_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/02_capitalization/013_capitalization_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/04_debt_security/025_debt_security_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/05_employment/037_employment_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/11_tax_insurance/085_tax_insurance_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/10_real_property/073_real_property_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/12_financials/097_tamarack_foods_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-004-02 — open-source copyleft exposure (critical)\n\ncompletion is required by 2025-05-05 under CB-MA-2404-R279; the current event record shows completion on 2025-05-25 under CB-MA-2404-E798. Identity resolves to ENT-004-1001, revision REV-2026.2 is current, and Owen Delgado is active with capacity 3.\n\nAction: Create separation-register rows for supported consents, assumed liabilities, and retained holds. Owner: Owen Delgado; due 2026-09-13.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_corporate/002_corporate_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/02_capitalization/014_capitalization_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/04_debt_security/026_debt_security_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/05_employment/038_employment_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/07_privacy_security/050_privacy_security_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/08_regulatory/062_regulatory_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/12_financials/097_tamarack_foods_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-004-03 — sales-tax nexus gap (high)\n\nthe controlling threshold is 3% under CB-MA-2404-R406; the independently calculated result is 5% under CB-MA-2404-E647. Identity resolves to ENT-004-1002, revision REV-2026.3 is current, and Priya Raman is active with capacity 5.\n\nAction: Create separation-register rows for supported consents, assumed liabilities, and retained holds. Owner: Priya Raman; due 2026-09-12.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_corporate/003_corporate_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/02_capitalization/015_capitalization_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/04_debt_security/027_debt_security_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/05_employment/039_employment_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/08_regulatory/063_regulatory_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/10_real_property/075_real_property_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/12_financials/097_tamarack_foods_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-004-05 — invention assignment defect (medium)\n\nthe controlled population contains 171 records under CB-MA-2404-R459; the certification covers 157 records under CB-MA-2404-E385. Identity resolves to ENT-004-1004, revision REV-2026.5 is current, and Nadine Flores is active with capacity 2.\n\nAction: Create separation-register rows for supported consents, assumed liabilities, and retained holds. Owner: Nadine Flores; due 2026-09-10.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_corporate/005_corporate_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/017_material_contracts_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/04_debt_security/029_debt_security_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/041_ip_technology_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/09_litigation/065_litigation_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/12_financials/089_financials_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/12_financials/097_tamarack_foods_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-004-06 — facility title exception (critical)\n\nthe permission is limited to Cook County, Illinois under CB-MA-2404-R355; the matched activity occurred in Illinois under CB-MA-2404-E220. Identity resolves to ENT-004-1005, revision REV-2026.6 is current, and Rafael Okafor is active with capacity 5.\n\nAction: Create separation-register rows for supported consents, assumed liabilities, and retained holds. Owner: Rafael Okafor; due 2026-09-09.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_corporate/006_corporate_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/018_material_contracts_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/04_debt_security/030_debt_security_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/042_ip_technology_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/10_real_property/078_real_property_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/12_financials/097_tamarack_foods_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-004-08 — key-person retention gap (low)\n\ndelivery must use notices-tamarack_foods_group@example.test under CB-MA-2404-R856; the only matched receipt used archive-copper_kettle_nutrition_co@example.test under CB-MA-2404-E144. Identity resolves to ENT-004-1007, revision REV-2026.1 is current, and Theo Laurent is active with capacity 3.\n\nAction: Create separation-register rows for supported consents, assumed liabilities, and retained holds. Owner: Theo Laurent; due 2026-09-07.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_corporate/008_corporate_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/020_material_contracts_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/04_debt_security/032_debt_security_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/044_ip_technology_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/12_financials/097_tamarack_foods_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-004-09 — threatened customer dispute (critical)\n\nan open exception blocks completion under CB-MA-2404-R342; the current status is open and unresolved under CB-MA-2404-E220. Identity resolves to ENT-004-1008, revision REV-2026.2 is current, and Lena Varga is active with capacity 3.\n\nAction: Create separation-register rows for supported consents, assumed liabilities, and retained holds. Owner: Lena Varga; due 2026-09-06.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/02_capitalization/009_capitalization_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/021_material_contracts_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/05_employment/033_employment_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/045_ip_technology_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/12_financials/093_financials_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/12_financials/097_tamarack_foods_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-004-10 — charter authorization mismatch (critical)\n\ncompletion is required by 2026-02-13 under CB-MA-2404-R983; the current event record shows completion on 2026-03-16 under CB-MA-2404-E734. Identity resolves to ENT-004-1009, revision REV-2026.3 is current, and Elliot Mercer is active with capacity 4.\n\nAction: Create separation-register rows for supported consents, assumed liabilities, and retained holds. Owner: Elliot Mercer; due 2026-09-14.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/02_capitalization/010_capitalization_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/022_material_contracts_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/05_employment/034_employment_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/046_ip_technology_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/12_financials/097_tamarack_foods_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-004-11 — financial covenant breach (low)\n\nthe controlling threshold is 11% under CB-MA-2404-R988; the independently calculated result is 14% under CB-MA-2404-E152. Identity resolves to ENT-004-1010, revision REV-2026.4 is current, and Sofia Bennett is active with capacity 6.\n\nAction: Create separation-register rows for supported consents, assumed liabilities, and retained holds. Owner: Sofia Bennett; due 2026-09-13.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/02_capitalization/011_capitalization_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/023_material_contracts_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/05_employment/035_employment_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/047_ip_technology_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/11_tax_insurance/083_tax_insurance_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/12_financials/097_tamarack_foods_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n## Evidence holds\n\n- **CBP-004-04 — change-of-control consent**: the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective. Next evidence: effective approval and an active owner with remaining capacity. Sources: `/workspace/documents/01_corporate/004_corporate_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/02_capitalization/016_capitalization_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/04_debt_security/028_debt_security_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/05_employment/040_employment_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/12_financials/097_tamarack_foods_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-004-07 — unrecorded option grant**: the current observation does not meet the operative trigger. Next evidence: a current observation that satisfies the operative trigger. Sources: `/workspace/documents/01_corporate/007_corporate_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/019_material_contracts_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/04_debt_security/031_debt_security_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/043_ip_technology_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/12_financials/097_tamarack_foods_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-004-12 — permit transfer restriction**: the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective. Next evidence: effective approval and an active owner with remaining capacity. Sources: `/workspace/documents/02_capitalization/012_capitalization_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/024_material_contracts_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/05_employment/036_employment_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/048_ip_technology_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/12_financials/097_tamarack_foods_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n## Alternatives considered\n\n- `tamarack-foods:shortcut` — Move every shared obligation to the buyer based on the carve-out plan alone.: Use a plausible summary or one source without completing the controlling joins.\n- `tamarack-foods:blanket-hold` — Freeze the entire matter population: Treat supported actions and genuinely ambiguous records as if they were equally unresolved.\n\n## Assumptions and limits\n\nThis decision is limited to cb100-004-tamarack-foods, the supplied synthetic records, and the matter state as of 2026-09-15. Similar names, stale revisions, and pending authority are not treated as proof.\n", "decision": {"actions": [{"determination": "an open exception blocks completion under CB-MA-2404-R605; the current status is open and unresolved under CB-MA-2404-E606. Identity resolves to ENT-004-1000, revision REV-2026.1 is current, and Willa Novak is active with capacity 6.", "due_date": "2026-09-14", "id": "ACT-CBP-004-01", "identity_id": "ENT-004-1000", "issue": "anti-assignment restriction", "owner": "Willa Novak", "portfolio_key": "CBP-004-01", "recommended_action": "Create separation-register rows for supported consents, assumed liabilities, and retained holds. Owner: Willa Novak; due 2026-09-14.", "severity": "high", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_corporate/001_corporate_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/02_capitalization/013_capitalization_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/04_debt_security/025_debt_security_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/05_employment/037_employment_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/11_tax_insurance/085_tax_insurance_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/10_real_property/073_real_property_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/12_financials/097_tamarack_foods_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "completion is required by 2025-05-05 under CB-MA-2404-R279; the current event record shows completion on 2025-05-25 under CB-MA-2404-E798. Identity resolves to ENT-004-1001, revision REV-2026.2 is current, and Owen Delgado is active with capacity 3.", "due_date": "2026-09-13", "id": "ACT-CBP-004-02", "identity_id": "ENT-004-1001", "issue": "open-source copyleft exposure", "owner": "Owen Delgado", "portfolio_key": "CBP-004-02", "recommended_action": "Create separation-register rows for supported consents, assumed liabilities, and retained holds. Owner: Owen Delgado; due 2026-09-13.", "severity": "critical", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_corporate/002_corporate_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/02_capitalization/014_capitalization_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/04_debt_security/026_debt_security_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/05_employment/038_employment_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/07_privacy_security/050_privacy_security_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/08_regulatory/062_regulatory_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_financials/097_tamarack_foods_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "the controlling threshold is 3% under CB-MA-2404-R406; the independently calculated result is 5% under CB-MA-2404-E647. Identity resolves to ENT-004-1002, revision REV-2026.3 is current, and Priya Raman is active with capacity 5.", "due_date": "2026-09-12", "id": "ACT-CBP-004-03", "identity_id": "ENT-004-1002", "issue": "sales-tax nexus gap", "owner": "Priya Raman", "portfolio_key": "CBP-004-03", "recommended_action": "Create separation-register rows for supported consents, assumed liabilities, and retained holds. Owner: Priya Raman; due 2026-09-12.", "severity": "high", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_corporate/003_corporate_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/02_capitalization/015_capitalization_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/04_debt_security/027_debt_security_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/05_employment/039_employment_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/08_regulatory/063_regulatory_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/10_real_property/075_real_property_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/12_financials/097_tamarack_foods_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "the controlled population contains 171 records under CB-MA-2404-R459; the certification covers 157 records under CB-MA-2404-E385. Identity resolves to ENT-004-1004, revision REV-2026.5 is current, and Nadine Flores is active with capacity 2.", "due_date": "2026-09-10", "id": "ACT-CBP-004-05", "identity_id": "ENT-004-1004", "issue": "invention assignment defect", "owner": "Nadine Flores", "portfolio_key": "CBP-004-05", "recommended_action": "Create separation-register rows for supported consents, assumed liabilities, and retained holds. Owner: Nadine Flores; due 2026-09-10.", "severity": "medium", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_corporate/005_corporate_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/017_material_contracts_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/04_debt_security/029_debt_security_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/041_ip_technology_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/09_litigation/065_litigation_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/12_financials/089_financials_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/12_financials/097_tamarack_foods_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "the permission is limited to Cook County, Illinois under CB-MA-2404-R355; the matched activity occurred in Illinois under CB-MA-2404-E220. Identity resolves to ENT-004-1005, revision REV-2026.6 is current, and Rafael Okafor is active with capacity 5.", "due_date": "2026-09-09", "id": "ACT-CBP-004-06", "identity_id": "ENT-004-1005", "issue": "facility title exception", "owner": "Rafael Okafor", "portfolio_key": "CBP-004-06", "recommended_action": "Create separation-register rows for supported consents, assumed liabilities, and retained holds. Owner: Rafael Okafor; due 2026-09-09.", "severity": "critical", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_corporate/006_corporate_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/018_material_contracts_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/04_debt_security/030_debt_security_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/042_ip_technology_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/10_real_property/078_real_property_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_financials/097_tamarack_foods_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "delivery must use notices-tamarack_foods_group@example.test under CB-MA-2404-R856; the only matched receipt used archive-copper_kettle_nutrition_co@example.test under CB-MA-2404-E144. Identity resolves to ENT-004-1007, revision REV-2026.1 is current, and Theo Laurent is active with capacity 3.", "due_date": "2026-09-07", "id": "ACT-CBP-004-08", "identity_id": "ENT-004-1007", "issue": "key-person retention gap", "owner": "Theo Laurent", "portfolio_key": "CBP-004-08", "recommended_action": "Create separation-register rows for supported consents, assumed liabilities, and retained holds. Owner: Theo Laurent; due 2026-09-07.", "severity": "low", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_corporate/008_corporate_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/020_material_contracts_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/04_debt_security/032_debt_security_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/044_ip_technology_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/12_financials/097_tamarack_foods_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "an open exception blocks completion under CB-MA-2404-R342; the current status is open and unresolved under CB-MA-2404-E220. Identity resolves to ENT-004-1008, revision REV-2026.2 is current, and Lena Varga is active with capacity 3.", "due_date": "2026-09-06", "id": "ACT-CBP-004-09", "identity_id": "ENT-004-1008", "issue": "threatened customer dispute", "owner": "Lena Varga", "portfolio_key": "CBP-004-09", "recommended_action": "Create separation-register rows for supported consents, assumed liabilities, and retained holds. Owner: Lena Varga; due 2026-09-06.", "severity": "critical", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_capitalization/009_capitalization_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/021_material_contracts_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/05_employment/033_employment_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/045_ip_technology_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_financials/093_financials_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_financials/097_tamarack_foods_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "completion is required by 2026-02-13 under CB-MA-2404-R983; the current event record shows completion on 2026-03-16 under CB-MA-2404-E734. Identity resolves to ENT-004-1009, revision REV-2026.3 is current, and Elliot Mercer is active with capacity 4.", "due_date": "2026-09-14", "id": "ACT-CBP-004-10", "identity_id": "ENT-004-1009", "issue": "charter authorization mismatch", "owner": "Elliot Mercer", "portfolio_key": "CBP-004-10", "recommended_action": "Create separation-register rows for supported consents, assumed liabilities, and retained holds. Owner: Elliot Mercer; due 2026-09-14.", "severity": "critical", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_capitalization/010_capitalization_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/022_material_contracts_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/05_employment/034_employment_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/046_ip_technology_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_financials/097_tamarack_foods_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "the controlling threshold is 11% under CB-MA-2404-R988; the independently calculated result is 14% under CB-MA-2404-E152. Identity resolves to ENT-004-1010, revision REV-2026.4 is current, and Sofia Bennett is active with capacity 6.", "due_date": "2026-09-13", "id": "ACT-CBP-004-11", "identity_id": "ENT-004-1010", "issue": "financial covenant breach", "owner": "Sofia Bennett", "portfolio_key": "CBP-004-11", "recommended_action": "Create separation-register rows for supported consents, assumed liabilities, and retained holds. Owner: Sofia Bennett; due 2026-09-13.", "severity": "low", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_capitalization/011_capitalization_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/023_material_contracts_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/05_employment/035_employment_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/047_ip_technology_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/11_tax_insurance/083_tax_insurance_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/12_financials/097_tamarack_foods_impact_population.xlsx"]}], "as_of": "2026-09-15", "decision": {"alternatives_considered": ["tamarack-foods:shortcut", "tamarack-foods:blanket-hold"], "question": "Can Copper Kettle be separated on schedule, and which plant obligations have to travel with the business?", "rationale": "The four-part causal test supports 9 scoped actions and leaves 3 records on evidence hold. Transfer terms, permit conditions, and the operative labor agreement determine required treatment.", "recommendation": "Separate on schedule only where consents, liabilities, and transition ownership are documented.", "selected_option_id": "tamarack-foods:scoped-evidence"}, "holds": [{"id": "HOLD-CBP-004-04", "issue": "change-of-control consent", "portfolio_key": "CBP-004-04", "reason": "the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective", "required_next_evidence": "effective approval and an active owner with remaining capacity", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_corporate/004_corporate_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/02_capitalization/016_capitalization_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/04_debt_security/028_debt_security_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/05_employment/040_employment_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_financials/097_tamarack_foods_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-004-07", "issue": "unrecorded option grant", "portfolio_key": "CBP-004-07", "reason": "the current observation does not meet the operative trigger", "required_next_evidence": "a current observation that satisfies the operative trigger", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_corporate/007_corporate_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/019_material_contracts_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/04_debt_security/031_debt_security_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/043_ip_technology_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/12_financials/097_tamarack_foods_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-004-12", "issue": "permit transfer restriction", "portfolio_key": "CBP-004-12", "reason": "the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective", "required_next_evidence": "effective approval and an active owner with remaining capacity", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_capitalization/012_capitalization_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/024_material_contracts_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/05_employment/036_employment_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/048_ip_technology_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_financials/097_tamarack_foods_impact_population.xlsx"]}], "matter_number": "CB-MA-2404", "prepared_for": "Tamarack Foods Group", "schema_version": "counselbench.decision.v3", "task_id": "cb100-004-tamarack-foods"}, "matter_register": {"matter_number": "CB-MA-2404", "rows": [{"decision_option_id": "tamarack-foods:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-14", "issue": "anti-assignment restriction", "matter_number": "CB-MA-2404", "owner": "Willa Novak", "portfolio_key": "CBP-004-01", "row_id": "REG-CBP-004-01", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_corporate/001_corporate_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/02_capitalization/013_capitalization_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/04_debt_security/025_debt_security_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/05_employment/037_employment_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/11_tax_insurance/085_tax_insurance_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/10_real_property/073_real_property_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/12_financials/097_tamarack_foods_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "tamarack-foods:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-13", "issue": "open-source copyleft exposure", "matter_number": "CB-MA-2404", "owner": "Owen Delgado", "portfolio_key": "CBP-004-02", "row_id": "REG-CBP-004-02", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_corporate/002_corporate_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/02_capitalization/014_capitalization_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/04_debt_security/026_debt_security_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/05_employment/038_employment_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/07_privacy_security/050_privacy_security_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/08_regulatory/062_regulatory_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_financials/097_tamarack_foods_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "tamarack-foods:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-12", "issue": "sales-tax nexus gap", "matter_number": "CB-MA-2404", "owner": "Priya Raman", "portfolio_key": "CBP-004-03", "row_id": "REG-CBP-004-03", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_corporate/003_corporate_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/02_capitalization/015_capitalization_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/04_debt_security/027_debt_security_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/05_employment/039_employment_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/08_regulatory/063_regulatory_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/10_real_property/075_real_property_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/12_financials/097_tamarack_foods_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "tamarack-foods:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective", "issue": "change-of-control consent", "matter_number": "CB-MA-2404", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-004-04", "row_id": "REG-CBP-004-04", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_corporate/004_corporate_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/02_capitalization/016_capitalization_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/04_debt_security/028_debt_security_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/05_employment/040_employment_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_financials/097_tamarack_foods_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "tamarack-foods:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-10", "issue": "invention assignment defect", "matter_number": "CB-MA-2404", "owner": "Nadine Flores", "portfolio_key": "CBP-004-05", "row_id": "REG-CBP-004-05", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_corporate/005_corporate_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/017_material_contracts_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/04_debt_security/029_debt_security_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/041_ip_technology_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/09_litigation/065_litigation_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/12_financials/089_financials_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/12_financials/097_tamarack_foods_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "tamarack-foods:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-09", "issue": "facility title exception", "matter_number": "CB-MA-2404", "owner": "Rafael Okafor", "portfolio_key": "CBP-004-06", "row_id": "REG-CBP-004-06", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_corporate/006_corporate_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/018_material_contracts_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/04_debt_security/030_debt_security_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/042_ip_technology_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/10_real_property/078_real_property_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_financials/097_tamarack_foods_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "tamarack-foods:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "the current observation does not meet the operative trigger", "issue": "unrecorded option grant", "matter_number": "CB-MA-2404", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-004-07", "row_id": "REG-CBP-004-07", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_corporate/007_corporate_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/019_material_contracts_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/04_debt_security/031_debt_security_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/043_ip_technology_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/12_financials/097_tamarack_foods_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "tamarack-foods:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-07", "issue": "key-person retention gap", "matter_number": "CB-MA-2404", "owner": "Theo Laurent", "portfolio_key": "CBP-004-08", "row_id": "REG-CBP-004-08", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_corporate/008_corporate_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/020_material_contracts_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/04_debt_security/032_debt_security_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/044_ip_technology_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/12_financials/097_tamarack_foods_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "tamarack-foods:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-06", "issue": "threatened customer dispute", "matter_number": "CB-MA-2404", "owner": "Lena Varga", "portfolio_key": "CBP-004-09", "row_id": "REG-CBP-004-09", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_capitalization/009_capitalization_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/021_material_contracts_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/05_employment/033_employment_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/045_ip_technology_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_financials/093_financials_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_financials/097_tamarack_foods_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "tamarack-foods:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-14", "issue": "charter authorization mismatch", "matter_number": "CB-MA-2404", "owner": "Elliot Mercer", "portfolio_key": "CBP-004-10", "row_id": "REG-CBP-004-10", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_capitalization/010_capitalization_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/022_material_contracts_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/05_employment/034_employment_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/046_ip_technology_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_financials/097_tamarack_foods_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "tamarack-foods:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-13", "issue": "financial covenant breach", "matter_number": "CB-MA-2404", "owner": "Sofia Bennett", "portfolio_key": "CBP-004-11", "row_id": "REG-CBP-004-11", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_capitalization/011_capitalization_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/023_material_contracts_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/05_employment/035_employment_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/047_ip_technology_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/11_tax_insurance/083_tax_insurance_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/12_financials/097_tamarack_foods_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "tamarack-foods:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective", "issue": "permit transfer restriction", "matter_number": "CB-MA-2404", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-004-12", "row_id": "REG-CBP-004-12", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_capitalization/012_capitalization_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/024_material_contracts_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/05_employment/036_employment_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/048_ip_technology_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_financials/097_tamarack_foods_impact_population.xlsx"]}], "schema_version": "counselbench.matter-register.v3", "task_id": "cb100-004-tamarack-foods"}}, "metadata": {"benchmark": "CounselBench-100", "code_license": "Apache-2.0", "data_license": "CC-BY-4.0", "deadline": "2026-09-15", "document_count": 97, "evidence_holds": 3, "jurisdiction": "Illinois", "matter_number": "CB-MA-2404", "mcp_commit": "9a96ea6e5913736f92b88345bf51caeaaa8e719f", "mcp_package": "@modelcontextprotocol/server-filesystem@2026.7.10", "practice_area": "corporate-ma", "reference_tool_calls": 86, "required_evidence_reads": 60, "supported_actions": 9, "synthetic": true, "venue": "Cook County, Illinois", "version": "3.1.0"}, "prompt": "The client wants a decision, not another document inventory. Can Copper Kettle be separated on schedule, and which plant obligations have to travel with the business? The divested nutrition plant has private-label commitments, shared wastewater permits, a union successorship clause, and disputed promotional accruals. The team needs the call by 2026-09-15. Put the supported calls into the matter register and leave me a short note I can use with the partner.", "rubric": {"criteria": [{"category": "investigation", "description": "Inventory the production and use targeted searches to locate records across native formats.", "id": "investigation.discover_production"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Complete every task-specific identity, authority, operations, and approval read before the first state transition.", "id": "investigation.read_before_write"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Inspect designated source metadata before relying on those records.", "id": "investigation.custody_before_write"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "Select the supported option 'tamarack-foods:scoped-evidence' after applying the four-part test.", "id": "decision.selected_option"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "Identify both rejected approaches and explain why a one-source shortcut and a blanket hold are wrong.", "id": "decision.alternatives"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-004-01 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_corporate/001_corporate_source_export.md rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-004-01.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_capitalization/013_capitalization_source_export.json for anti-assignment restriction.", "id": "investigation.CBP-004-01.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_debt_security/025_debt_security_source_export.md to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-004-01.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_employment/037_employment_source_export.json.", "id": "investigation.CBP-004-01.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-004-01 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-004-01.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-004-01 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-004-01.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-004-02 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_corporate/002_corporate_source_export.txt rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-004-02.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_capitalization/014_capitalization_source_export.xml for open-source copyleft exposure.", "id": "investigation.CBP-004-02.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_debt_security/026_debt_security_source_export.txt to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-004-02.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_employment/038_employment_source_export.xml.", "id": "investigation.CBP-004-02.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-004-02 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-004-02.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-004-02 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-004-02.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-004-03 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_corporate/003_corporate_source_export.eml rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-004-03.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_capitalization/015_capitalization_source_export.html for sales-tax nexus gap.", "id": "investigation.CBP-004-03.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_debt_security/027_debt_security_source_export.eml to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-004-03.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_employment/039_employment_source_export.html.", "id": "investigation.CBP-004-03.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-004-03 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-004-03.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-004-03 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-004-03.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-004-04 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_corporate/004_corporate_source_export.csv rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-004-04.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_capitalization/016_capitalization_source_export.pdf for change-of-control consent.", "id": "investigation.CBP-004-04.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_debt_security/028_debt_security_source_export.csv to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-004-04.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_employment/040_employment_source_export.pdf.", "id": "investigation.CBP-004-04.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-004-04 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective.", "id": "decision.CBP-004-04.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-004-04 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-004-04.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-004-05 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_corporate/005_corporate_source_export.json rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-004-05.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/017_material_contracts_source_export.md for invention assignment defect.", "id": "investigation.CBP-004-05.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_debt_security/029_debt_security_source_export.json to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-004-05.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/041_ip_technology_source_export.md.", "id": "investigation.CBP-004-05.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-004-05 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-004-05.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-004-05 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-004-05.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-004-06 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_corporate/006_corporate_source_export.xml rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-004-06.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/018_material_contracts_source_export.txt for facility title exception.", "id": "investigation.CBP-004-06.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_debt_security/030_debt_security_source_export.xml to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-004-06.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/042_ip_technology_source_export.txt.", "id": "investigation.CBP-004-06.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-004-06 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-004-06.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-004-06 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-004-06.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-004-07 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_corporate/007_corporate_source_export.html rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-004-07.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/019_material_contracts_source_export.eml for unrecorded option grant.", "id": "investigation.CBP-004-07.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_debt_security/031_debt_security_source_export.html to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-004-07.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/043_ip_technology_source_export.eml.", "id": "investigation.CBP-004-07.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-004-07 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is the current observation does not meet the operative trigger.", "id": "decision.CBP-004-07.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-004-07 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-004-07.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-004-08 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_corporate/008_corporate_source_export.pdf rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-004-08.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/020_material_contracts_source_export.csv for key-person retention gap.", "id": "investigation.CBP-004-08.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_debt_security/032_debt_security_source_export.pdf to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-004-08.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/044_ip_technology_source_export.csv.", "id": "investigation.CBP-004-08.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-004-08 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-004-08.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-004-08 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-004-08.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-004-09 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_capitalization/009_capitalization_source_export.md rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-004-09.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/021_material_contracts_source_export.json for threatened customer dispute.", "id": "investigation.CBP-004-09.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_employment/033_employment_source_export.md to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-004-09.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/045_ip_technology_source_export.json.", "id": "investigation.CBP-004-09.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-004-09 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-004-09.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-004-09 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-004-09.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-004-10 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_capitalization/010_capitalization_source_export.txt rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-004-10.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/022_material_contracts_source_export.xml for charter authorization mismatch.", "id": "investigation.CBP-004-10.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_employment/034_employment_source_export.txt to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-004-10.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/046_ip_technology_source_export.xml.", "id": "investigation.CBP-004-10.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-004-10 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-004-10.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-004-10 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-004-10.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-004-11 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_capitalization/011_capitalization_source_export.eml rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-004-11.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/023_material_contracts_source_export.html for financial covenant breach.", "id": "investigation.CBP-004-11.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_employment/035_employment_source_export.eml to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-004-11.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/047_ip_technology_source_export.html.", "id": "investigation.CBP-004-11.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-004-11 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-004-11.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-004-11 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-004-11.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-004-12 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_capitalization/012_capitalization_source_export.csv rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-004-12.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/024_material_contracts_source_export.pdf for permit transfer restriction.", "id": "investigation.CBP-004-12.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_employment/036_employment_source_export.csv to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-004-12.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/048_ip_technology_source_export.pdf.", "id": "investigation.CBP-004-12.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-004-12 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective.", "id": "decision.CBP-004-12.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-004-12 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-004-12.register"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Write the exact selected option, supported action population, evidence-hold population, facts, owners, deadlines, and citations.", "id": "state.exact_decision"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create one exact register row per portfolio key with no extra, missing, or modified row.", "id": "state.exact_register"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Leave only the three approved deliverables and perform no extra state-changing write.", "id": "state.write_scope_containment"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Read back decision.json, matter-register.json, and advice.md after their final writes.", "id": "state.postwrite_readback"}, {"category": "answer", "description": "Explain the selected recommendation, supported actions, holds, alternatives, and limitations with exact source anchors.", "id": "answer.decision_note"}], "decision_options": [{"approach": "Apply the exact identity, current-state, authority, and revision test. Create separation-register rows for supported consents, assumed liabilities, and retained holds.", "id": "tamarack-foods:scoped-evidence", "label": "Separate on schedule only where consents, liabilities, and transition ownership are documented."}, {"approach": "Use a plausible summary or one source without completing the controlling joins.", "id": "tamarack-foods:shortcut", "label": "Move every shared obligation to the buyer based on the carve-out plan alone."}, {"approach": "Treat supported actions and genuinely ambiguous records as if they were equally unresolved.", "id": "tamarack-foods:blanket-hold", "label": "Freeze the entire matter population"}], "evaluation_narrative": {"authority": "Transfer terms, permit conditions, and the operative labor agreement determine required treatment.", "observation": "Compare permit, union, customer, and accrual records for the divested facility and effective period.", "question": "Can Copper Kettle be separated on schedule, and which plant obligations have to travel with the business?", "register_action": "Create separation-register rows for supported consents, assumed liabilities, and retained holds."}, "gates": ["all_required_evidence_precedes_first_write", "decision_criteria_complete", "register_state_exact", "write_scope_contained", "all_outputs_verified_by_readback"], "metadata_checks": 9, "metric": "weighted_criteria_score", "minimum_tool_calls": 86, "required_deliverables": ["decision.json", "matter-register.json", "advice.md"], "required_document_reads": 60, "type": "deterministic", "weights": {"advice": 0.15, "decision": 0.35, "investigation": 0.25, "state": 0.25}}, "task_id": "cb100-004-tamarack-foods", "task_name": "Project Copper Kettle food plant divestiture", "world_id": "counselbench-filesystem-mcp-v3"}
+{"context_files": ["task_files/cb100-005-solace-mobility/01_corporate/001_corporate_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-005-solace-mobility/01_corporate/002_corporate_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-005-solace-mobility/01_corporate/003_corporate_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-005-solace-mobility/01_corporate/004_corporate_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-005-solace-mobility/01_corporate/005_corporate_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-005-solace-mobility/01_corporate/006_corporate_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-005-solace-mobility/01_corporate/007_corporate_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-005-solace-mobility/01_corporate/008_corporate_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-005-solace-mobility/02_capitalization/009_capitalization_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-005-solace-mobility/02_capitalization/010_capitalization_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-005-solace-mobility/02_capitalization/011_capitalization_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-005-solace-mobility/02_capitalization/012_capitalization_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-005-solace-mobility/02_capitalization/013_capitalization_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-005-solace-mobility/02_capitalization/014_capitalization_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-005-solace-mobility/02_capitalization/015_capitalization_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-005-solace-mobility/02_capitalization/016_capitalization_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-005-solace-mobility/03_material_contracts/017_material_contracts_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-005-solace-mobility/03_material_contracts/018_material_contracts_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-005-solace-mobility/03_material_contracts/019_material_contracts_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-005-solace-mobility/03_material_contracts/020_material_contracts_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-005-solace-mobility/03_material_contracts/021_material_contracts_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-005-solace-mobility/03_material_contracts/022_material_contracts_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-005-solace-mobility/03_material_contracts/023_material_contracts_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-005-solace-mobility/03_material_contracts/024_material_contracts_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-005-solace-mobility/04_debt_security/025_debt_security_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-005-solace-mobility/04_debt_security/026_debt_security_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-005-solace-mobility/04_debt_security/027_debt_security_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-005-solace-mobility/04_debt_security/028_debt_security_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-005-solace-mobility/04_debt_security/029_debt_security_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-005-solace-mobility/04_debt_security/030_debt_security_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-005-solace-mobility/04_debt_security/031_debt_security_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-005-solace-mobility/04_debt_security/032_debt_security_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-005-solace-mobility/05_employment/033_employment_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-005-solace-mobility/05_employment/034_employment_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-005-solace-mobility/05_employment/035_employment_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-005-solace-mobility/05_employment/036_employment_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-005-solace-mobility/05_employment/037_employment_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-005-solace-mobility/05_employment/038_employment_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-005-solace-mobility/05_employment/039_employment_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-005-solace-mobility/05_employment/040_employment_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-005-solace-mobility/06_ip_technology/041_ip_technology_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-005-solace-mobility/06_ip_technology/042_ip_technology_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-005-solace-mobility/06_ip_technology/043_ip_technology_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-005-solace-mobility/06_ip_technology/044_ip_technology_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-005-solace-mobility/06_ip_technology/045_ip_technology_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-005-solace-mobility/06_ip_technology/046_ip_technology_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-005-solace-mobility/06_ip_technology/047_ip_technology_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-005-solace-mobility/06_ip_technology/048_ip_technology_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-005-solace-mobility/07_privacy_security/049_privacy_security_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-005-solace-mobility/07_privacy_security/050_privacy_security_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-005-solace-mobility/07_privacy_security/051_privacy_security_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-005-solace-mobility/07_privacy_security/052_privacy_security_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-005-solace-mobility/07_privacy_security/053_privacy_security_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-005-solace-mobility/07_privacy_security/054_privacy_security_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-005-solace-mobility/07_privacy_security/055_privacy_security_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-005-solace-mobility/07_privacy_security/056_privacy_security_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-005-solace-mobility/08_regulatory/057_regulatory_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-005-solace-mobility/08_regulatory/058_regulatory_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-005-solace-mobility/08_regulatory/059_regulatory_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-005-solace-mobility/08_regulatory/060_regulatory_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-005-solace-mobility/08_regulatory/061_regulatory_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-005-solace-mobility/08_regulatory/062_regulatory_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-005-solace-mobility/08_regulatory/063_regulatory_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-005-solace-mobility/08_regulatory/064_regulatory_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-005-solace-mobility/09_litigation/065_litigation_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-005-solace-mobility/09_litigation/066_litigation_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-005-solace-mobility/09_litigation/067_litigation_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-005-solace-mobility/09_litigation/068_litigation_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-005-solace-mobility/09_litigation/069_litigation_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-005-solace-mobility/09_litigation/070_litigation_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-005-solace-mobility/09_litigation/071_litigation_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-005-solace-mobility/09_litigation/072_litigation_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-005-solace-mobility/10_real_property/073_real_property_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-005-solace-mobility/10_real_property/074_real_property_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-005-solace-mobility/10_real_property/075_real_property_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-005-solace-mobility/10_real_property/076_real_property_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-005-solace-mobility/10_real_property/077_real_property_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-005-solace-mobility/10_real_property/078_real_property_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-005-solace-mobility/10_real_property/079_real_property_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-005-solace-mobility/10_real_property/080_real_property_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-005-solace-mobility/11_tax_insurance/081_tax_insurance_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-005-solace-mobility/11_tax_insurance/082_tax_insurance_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-005-solace-mobility/11_tax_insurance/083_tax_insurance_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-005-solace-mobility/11_tax_insurance/084_tax_insurance_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-005-solace-mobility/11_tax_insurance/085_tax_insurance_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-005-solace-mobility/11_tax_insurance/086_tax_insurance_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-005-solace-mobility/11_tax_insurance/087_tax_insurance_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-005-solace-mobility/11_tax_insurance/088_tax_insurance_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-005-solace-mobility/12_financials/089_financials_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-005-solace-mobility/12_financials/090_financials_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-005-solace-mobility/12_financials/091_financials_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-005-solace-mobility/12_financials/092_financials_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-005-solace-mobility/12_financials/093_financials_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-005-solace-mobility/12_financials/094_financials_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-005-solace-mobility/12_financials/095_financials_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-005-solace-mobility/12_financials/096_financials_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-005-solace-mobility/12_financials/097_solace_mobility_impact_population.xlsx"], "gold_output": {"advice_markdown": "# Decision note — Project Lantern fleet technology acquisition\n\n## Recommendation\n\nUse targeted assignment or economic protections where the evidence shows a closing exposure. The reconciled record supports 8 scoped actions and leaves 4 items on evidence hold.\n\nSelected option: `solace-mobility:scoped-evidence`.\n\n## Why this is the supported option\n\nTie model contributions, municipal data rights, and the pricing letter to exact repositories and accounts. Signed assignments, data-use grants, and the effective customer amendment govern value transfer.\n\n## Supported actions\n\n### CBP-005-02 — unreported security incident (medium)\n\nthe operative cap is $82,000.00 under CB-MA-2405-R715; the matched ledger population totals $304,715.00 under CB-MA-2405-E877. Identity resolves to ENT-005-1001, revision REV-2025.2 is current, and Maya Ellison is active with capacity 3.\n\nAction: Register each supported title or pricing protection without changing clean portfolio items. Owner: Maya Ellison; due 2026-09-16.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_corporate/002_corporate_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/02_capitalization/014_capitalization_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/04_debt_security/026_debt_security_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/05_employment/038_employment_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/12_financials/097_solace_mobility_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-005-03 — claims-made insurance tail (critical)\n\ndelivery must use notices-solace_mobility_holdings@example.test under CB-MA-2405-R931; the only matched receipt used archive-lantern_route_analytics_inc@example.test under CB-MA-2405-E413. Identity resolves to ENT-005-1002, revision REV-2025.3 is current, and Jonas Feld is active with capacity 6.\n\nAction: Register each supported title or pricing protection without changing clean portfolio items. Owner: Jonas Feld; due 2026-09-15.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_corporate/003_corporate_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/02_capitalization/015_capitalization_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/04_debt_security/027_debt_security_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/05_employment/039_employment_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/11_tax_insurance/087_tax_insurance_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/12_financials/097_solace_mobility_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-005-04 — anti-assignment restriction (high)\n\nan open exception blocks completion under CB-MA-2405-R735; the current status is open and unresolved under CB-MA-2405-E296. Identity resolves to ENT-005-1003, revision REV-2025.4 is current, and Willa Novak is active with capacity 6.\n\nAction: Register each supported title or pricing protection without changing clean portfolio items. Owner: Willa Novak; due 2026-09-14.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_corporate/004_corporate_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/02_capitalization/016_capitalization_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/04_debt_security/028_debt_security_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/05_employment/040_employment_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/07_privacy_security/052_privacy_security_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/08_regulatory/064_regulatory_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/12_financials/097_solace_mobility_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-005-05 — open-source copyleft exposure (high)\n\ncompletion is required by 2025-08-29 under CB-MA-2405-R335; the current event record shows completion on 2025-10-07 under CB-MA-2405-E113. Identity resolves to ENT-005-1004, revision REV-2025.5 is current, and Owen Delgado is active with capacity 2.\n\nAction: Register each supported title or pricing protection without changing clean portfolio items. Owner: Owen Delgado; due 2026-09-13.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_corporate/005_corporate_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/017_material_contracts_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/04_debt_security/029_debt_security_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/041_ip_technology_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/09_litigation/065_litigation_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/12_financials/089_financials_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/12_financials/097_solace_mobility_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-005-06 — sales-tax nexus gap (low)\n\nthe controlling threshold is 3% under CB-MA-2405-R882; the independently calculated result is 5% under CB-MA-2405-E410. Identity resolves to ENT-005-1005, revision REV-2025.6 is current, and Priya Raman is active with capacity 4.\n\nAction: Register each supported title or pricing protection without changing clean portfolio items. Owner: Priya Raman; due 2026-09-12.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_corporate/006_corporate_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/018_material_contracts_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/04_debt_security/030_debt_security_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/042_ip_technology_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/12_financials/097_solace_mobility_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-005-09 — facility title exception (high)\n\nthe permission is limited to Santa Clara County, California under CB-MA-2405-R627; the matched activity occurred in California under CB-MA-2405-E448. Identity resolves to ENT-005-1008, revision REV-2025.2 is current, and Rafael Okafor is active with capacity 5.\n\nAction: Register each supported title or pricing protection without changing clean portfolio items. Owner: Rafael Okafor; due 2026-09-09.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/02_capitalization/009_capitalization_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/021_material_contracts_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/05_employment/033_employment_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/045_ip_technology_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/08_regulatory/057_regulatory_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/12_financials/097_solace_mobility_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-005-11 — key-person retention gap (high)\n\ndelivery must use notices-solace_mobility_holdings@example.test under CB-MA-2405-R714; the only matched receipt used archive-lantern_route_analytics_inc@example.test under CB-MA-2405-E453. Identity resolves to ENT-005-1010, revision REV-2025.4 is current, and Theo Laurent is active with capacity 2.\n\nAction: Register each supported title or pricing protection without changing clean portfolio items. Owner: Theo Laurent; due 2026-09-16.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/02_capitalization/011_capitalization_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/023_material_contracts_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/05_employment/035_employment_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/047_ip_technology_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/12_financials/097_solace_mobility_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-005-12 — threatened customer dispute (critical)\n\nan open exception blocks completion under CB-MA-2405-R744; the current status is open and unresolved under CB-MA-2405-E879. Identity resolves to ENT-005-1011, revision REV-2025.5 is current, and Lena Varga is active with capacity 2.\n\nAction: Register each supported title or pricing protection without changing clean portfolio items. Owner: Lena Varga; due 2026-09-15.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/02_capitalization/012_capitalization_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/024_material_contracts_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/05_employment/036_employment_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/048_ip_technology_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/09_litigation/072_litigation_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/08_regulatory/060_regulatory_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/12_financials/097_solace_mobility_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n## Evidence holds\n\n- **CBP-005-01 — most-favored-customer exposure**: two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key. Next evidence: an approved immutable entity crosswalk. Sources: `/workspace/documents/01_corporate/001_corporate_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/02_capitalization/013_capitalization_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/04_debt_security/025_debt_security_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/05_employment/037_employment_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/08_regulatory/061_regulatory_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/07_privacy_security/049_privacy_security_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/12_financials/097_solace_mobility_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-005-07 — change-of-control consent**: the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective. Next evidence: effective approval and an active owner with remaining capacity. Sources: `/workspace/documents/01_corporate/007_corporate_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/019_material_contracts_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/04_debt_security/031_debt_security_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/043_ip_technology_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/12_financials/091_financials_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/10_real_property/079_real_property_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/12_financials/097_solace_mobility_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-005-08 — invention assignment defect**: the operational record relies on a superseded control revision. Next evidence: an operational record using the current effective revision. Sources: `/workspace/documents/01_corporate/008_corporate_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/020_material_contracts_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/04_debt_security/032_debt_security_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/044_ip_technology_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/09_litigation/068_litigation_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/12_financials/097_solace_mobility_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-005-10 — unrecorded option grant**: the current observation does not meet the operative trigger. Next evidence: a current observation that satisfies the operative trigger. Sources: `/workspace/documents/02_capitalization/010_capitalization_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/022_material_contracts_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/05_employment/034_employment_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/046_ip_technology_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/08_regulatory/058_regulatory_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/12_financials/097_solace_mobility_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n## Alternatives considered\n\n- `solace-mobility:shortcut` — Rely on repository access and current invoices as proof of ownership and pricing rights.: Use a plausible summary or one source without completing the controlling joins.\n- `solace-mobility:blanket-hold` — Freeze the entire matter population: Treat supported actions and genuinely ambiguous records as if they were equally unresolved.\n\n## Assumptions and limits\n\nThis decision is limited to cb100-005-solace-mobility, the supplied synthetic records, and the matter state as of 2026-09-18. Similar names, stale revisions, and pending authority are not treated as proof.\n", "decision": {"actions": [{"determination": "the operative cap is $82,000.00 under CB-MA-2405-R715; the matched ledger population totals $304,715.00 under CB-MA-2405-E877. Identity resolves to ENT-005-1001, revision REV-2025.2 is current, and Maya Ellison is active with capacity 3.", "due_date": "2026-09-16", "id": "ACT-CBP-005-02", "identity_id": "ENT-005-1001", "issue": "unreported security incident", "owner": "Maya Ellison", "portfolio_key": "CBP-005-02", "recommended_action": "Register each supported title or pricing protection without changing clean portfolio items. Owner: Maya Ellison; due 2026-09-16.", "severity": "medium", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_corporate/002_corporate_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/02_capitalization/014_capitalization_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/04_debt_security/026_debt_security_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/05_employment/038_employment_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_financials/097_solace_mobility_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "delivery must use notices-solace_mobility_holdings@example.test under CB-MA-2405-R931; the only matched receipt used archive-lantern_route_analytics_inc@example.test under CB-MA-2405-E413. Identity resolves to ENT-005-1002, revision REV-2025.3 is current, and Jonas Feld is active with capacity 6.", "due_date": "2026-09-15", "id": "ACT-CBP-005-03", "identity_id": "ENT-005-1002", "issue": "claims-made insurance tail", "owner": "Jonas Feld", "portfolio_key": "CBP-005-03", "recommended_action": "Register each supported title or pricing protection without changing clean portfolio items. Owner: Jonas Feld; due 2026-09-15.", "severity": "critical", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_corporate/003_corporate_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/02_capitalization/015_capitalization_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/04_debt_security/027_debt_security_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/05_employment/039_employment_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/11_tax_insurance/087_tax_insurance_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_financials/097_solace_mobility_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "an open exception blocks completion under CB-MA-2405-R735; the current status is open and unresolved under CB-MA-2405-E296. Identity resolves to ENT-005-1003, revision REV-2025.4 is current, and Willa Novak is active with capacity 6.", "due_date": "2026-09-14", "id": "ACT-CBP-005-04", "identity_id": "ENT-005-1003", "issue": "anti-assignment restriction", "owner": "Willa Novak", "portfolio_key": "CBP-005-04", "recommended_action": "Register each supported title or pricing protection without changing clean portfolio items. Owner: Willa Novak; due 2026-09-14.", "severity": "high", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_corporate/004_corporate_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/02_capitalization/016_capitalization_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/04_debt_security/028_debt_security_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/05_employment/040_employment_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/07_privacy_security/052_privacy_security_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/08_regulatory/064_regulatory_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_financials/097_solace_mobility_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "completion is required by 2025-08-29 under CB-MA-2405-R335; the current event record shows completion on 2025-10-07 under CB-MA-2405-E113. Identity resolves to ENT-005-1004, revision REV-2025.5 is current, and Owen Delgado is active with capacity 2.", "due_date": "2026-09-13", "id": "ACT-CBP-005-05", "identity_id": "ENT-005-1004", "issue": "open-source copyleft exposure", "owner": "Owen Delgado", "portfolio_key": "CBP-005-05", "recommended_action": "Register each supported title or pricing protection without changing clean portfolio items. Owner: Owen Delgado; due 2026-09-13.", "severity": "high", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_corporate/005_corporate_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/017_material_contracts_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/04_debt_security/029_debt_security_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/041_ip_technology_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/09_litigation/065_litigation_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/12_financials/089_financials_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/12_financials/097_solace_mobility_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "the controlling threshold is 3% under CB-MA-2405-R882; the independently calculated result is 5% under CB-MA-2405-E410. Identity resolves to ENT-005-1005, revision REV-2025.6 is current, and Priya Raman is active with capacity 4.", "due_date": "2026-09-12", "id": "ACT-CBP-005-06", "identity_id": "ENT-005-1005", "issue": "sales-tax nexus gap", "owner": "Priya Raman", "portfolio_key": "CBP-005-06", "recommended_action": "Register each supported title or pricing protection without changing clean portfolio items. Owner: Priya Raman; due 2026-09-12.", "severity": "low", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_corporate/006_corporate_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/018_material_contracts_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/04_debt_security/030_debt_security_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/042_ip_technology_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/12_financials/097_solace_mobility_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "the permission is limited to Santa Clara County, California under CB-MA-2405-R627; the matched activity occurred in California under CB-MA-2405-E448. Identity resolves to ENT-005-1008, revision REV-2025.2 is current, and Rafael Okafor is active with capacity 5.", "due_date": "2026-09-09", "id": "ACT-CBP-005-09", "identity_id": "ENT-005-1008", "issue": "facility title exception", "owner": "Rafael Okafor", "portfolio_key": "CBP-005-09", "recommended_action": "Register each supported title or pricing protection without changing clean portfolio items. Owner: Rafael Okafor; due 2026-09-09.", "severity": "high", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_capitalization/009_capitalization_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/021_material_contracts_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/05_employment/033_employment_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/045_ip_technology_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/08_regulatory/057_regulatory_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/12_financials/097_solace_mobility_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "delivery must use notices-solace_mobility_holdings@example.test under CB-MA-2405-R714; the only matched receipt used archive-lantern_route_analytics_inc@example.test under CB-MA-2405-E453. Identity resolves to ENT-005-1010, revision REV-2025.4 is current, and Theo Laurent is active with capacity 2.", "due_date": "2026-09-16", "id": "ACT-CBP-005-11", "identity_id": "ENT-005-1010", "issue": "key-person retention gap", "owner": "Theo Laurent", "portfolio_key": "CBP-005-11", "recommended_action": "Register each supported title or pricing protection without changing clean portfolio items. Owner: Theo Laurent; due 2026-09-16.", "severity": "high", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_capitalization/011_capitalization_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/023_material_contracts_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/05_employment/035_employment_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/047_ip_technology_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_financials/097_solace_mobility_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "an open exception blocks completion under CB-MA-2405-R744; the current status is open and unresolved under CB-MA-2405-E879. Identity resolves to ENT-005-1011, revision REV-2025.5 is current, and Lena Varga is active with capacity 2.", "due_date": "2026-09-15", "id": "ACT-CBP-005-12", "identity_id": "ENT-005-1011", "issue": "threatened customer dispute", "owner": "Lena Varga", "portfolio_key": "CBP-005-12", "recommended_action": "Register each supported title or pricing protection without changing clean portfolio items. Owner: Lena Varga; due 2026-09-15.", "severity": "critical", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_capitalization/012_capitalization_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/024_material_contracts_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/05_employment/036_employment_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/048_ip_technology_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/09_litigation/072_litigation_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/08_regulatory/060_regulatory_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/12_financials/097_solace_mobility_impact_population.xlsx"]}], "as_of": "2026-09-18", "decision": {"alternatives_considered": ["solace-mobility:shortcut", "solace-mobility:blanket-hold"], "question": "Does Lantern own and price what we think it does at closing, or do the contractor and customer records require a holdback?", "rationale": "The four-part causal test supports 8 scoped actions and leaves 4 records on evidence hold. Signed assignments, data-use grants, and the effective customer amendment govern value transfer.", "recommendation": "Use targeted assignment or economic protections where the evidence shows a closing exposure.", "selected_option_id": "solace-mobility:scoped-evidence"}, "holds": [{"id": "HOLD-CBP-005-01", "issue": "most-favored-customer exposure", "portfolio_key": "CBP-005-01", "reason": "two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key", "required_next_evidence": "an approved immutable entity crosswalk", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_corporate/001_corporate_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/02_capitalization/013_capitalization_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/04_debt_security/025_debt_security_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/05_employment/037_employment_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/08_regulatory/061_regulatory_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/07_privacy_security/049_privacy_security_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/12_financials/097_solace_mobility_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-005-07", "issue": "change-of-control consent", "portfolio_key": "CBP-005-07", "reason": "the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective", "required_next_evidence": "effective approval and an active owner with remaining capacity", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_corporate/007_corporate_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/019_material_contracts_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/04_debt_security/031_debt_security_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/043_ip_technology_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/12_financials/091_financials_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/10_real_property/079_real_property_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_financials/097_solace_mobility_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-005-08", "issue": "invention assignment defect", "portfolio_key": "CBP-005-08", "reason": "the operational record relies on a superseded control revision", "required_next_evidence": "an operational record using the current effective revision", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_corporate/008_corporate_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/020_material_contracts_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/04_debt_security/032_debt_security_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/044_ip_technology_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/09_litigation/068_litigation_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/12_financials/097_solace_mobility_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-005-10", "issue": "unrecorded option grant", "portfolio_key": "CBP-005-10", "reason": "the current observation does not meet the operative trigger", "required_next_evidence": "a current observation that satisfies the operative trigger", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_capitalization/010_capitalization_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/022_material_contracts_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/05_employment/034_employment_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/046_ip_technology_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/08_regulatory/058_regulatory_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/12_financials/097_solace_mobility_impact_population.xlsx"]}], "matter_number": "CB-MA-2405", "prepared_for": "Solace Mobility Holdings", "schema_version": "counselbench.decision.v3", "task_id": "cb100-005-solace-mobility"}, "matter_register": {"matter_number": "CB-MA-2405", "rows": [{"decision_option_id": "solace-mobility:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key", "issue": "most-favored-customer exposure", "matter_number": "CB-MA-2405", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-005-01", "row_id": "REG-CBP-005-01", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_corporate/001_corporate_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/02_capitalization/013_capitalization_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/04_debt_security/025_debt_security_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/05_employment/037_employment_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/08_regulatory/061_regulatory_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/07_privacy_security/049_privacy_security_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/12_financials/097_solace_mobility_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "solace-mobility:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-16", "issue": "unreported security incident", "matter_number": "CB-MA-2405", "owner": "Maya Ellison", "portfolio_key": "CBP-005-02", "row_id": "REG-CBP-005-02", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_corporate/002_corporate_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/02_capitalization/014_capitalization_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/04_debt_security/026_debt_security_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/05_employment/038_employment_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_financials/097_solace_mobility_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "solace-mobility:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-15", "issue": "claims-made insurance tail", "matter_number": "CB-MA-2405", "owner": "Jonas Feld", "portfolio_key": "CBP-005-03", "row_id": "REG-CBP-005-03", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_corporate/003_corporate_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/02_capitalization/015_capitalization_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/04_debt_security/027_debt_security_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/05_employment/039_employment_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/11_tax_insurance/087_tax_insurance_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_financials/097_solace_mobility_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "solace-mobility:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-14", "issue": "anti-assignment restriction", "matter_number": "CB-MA-2405", "owner": "Willa Novak", "portfolio_key": "CBP-005-04", "row_id": "REG-CBP-005-04", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_corporate/004_corporate_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/02_capitalization/016_capitalization_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/04_debt_security/028_debt_security_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/05_employment/040_employment_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/07_privacy_security/052_privacy_security_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/08_regulatory/064_regulatory_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_financials/097_solace_mobility_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "solace-mobility:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-13", "issue": "open-source copyleft exposure", "matter_number": "CB-MA-2405", "owner": "Owen Delgado", "portfolio_key": "CBP-005-05", "row_id": "REG-CBP-005-05", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_corporate/005_corporate_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/017_material_contracts_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/04_debt_security/029_debt_security_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/041_ip_technology_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/09_litigation/065_litigation_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/12_financials/089_financials_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/12_financials/097_solace_mobility_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "solace-mobility:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-12", "issue": "sales-tax nexus gap", "matter_number": "CB-MA-2405", "owner": "Priya Raman", "portfolio_key": "CBP-005-06", "row_id": "REG-CBP-005-06", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_corporate/006_corporate_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/018_material_contracts_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/04_debt_security/030_debt_security_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/042_ip_technology_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/12_financials/097_solace_mobility_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "solace-mobility:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective", "issue": "change-of-control consent", "matter_number": "CB-MA-2405", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-005-07", "row_id": "REG-CBP-005-07", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_corporate/007_corporate_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/019_material_contracts_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/04_debt_security/031_debt_security_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/043_ip_technology_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/12_financials/091_financials_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/10_real_property/079_real_property_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_financials/097_solace_mobility_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "solace-mobility:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "the operational record relies on a superseded control revision", "issue": "invention assignment defect", "matter_number": "CB-MA-2405", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-005-08", "row_id": "REG-CBP-005-08", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_corporate/008_corporate_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/020_material_contracts_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/04_debt_security/032_debt_security_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/044_ip_technology_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/09_litigation/068_litigation_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/12_financials/097_solace_mobility_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "solace-mobility:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-09", "issue": "facility title exception", "matter_number": "CB-MA-2405", "owner": "Rafael Okafor", "portfolio_key": "CBP-005-09", "row_id": "REG-CBP-005-09", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_capitalization/009_capitalization_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/021_material_contracts_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/05_employment/033_employment_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/045_ip_technology_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/08_regulatory/057_regulatory_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/12_financials/097_solace_mobility_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "solace-mobility:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "the current observation does not meet the operative trigger", "issue": "unrecorded option grant", "matter_number": "CB-MA-2405", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-005-10", "row_id": "REG-CBP-005-10", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_capitalization/010_capitalization_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/022_material_contracts_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/05_employment/034_employment_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/046_ip_technology_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/08_regulatory/058_regulatory_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/12_financials/097_solace_mobility_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "solace-mobility:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-16", "issue": "key-person retention gap", "matter_number": "CB-MA-2405", "owner": "Theo Laurent", "portfolio_key": "CBP-005-11", "row_id": "REG-CBP-005-11", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_capitalization/011_capitalization_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/023_material_contracts_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/05_employment/035_employment_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/047_ip_technology_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_financials/097_solace_mobility_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "solace-mobility:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-15", "issue": "threatened customer dispute", "matter_number": "CB-MA-2405", "owner": "Lena Varga", "portfolio_key": "CBP-005-12", "row_id": "REG-CBP-005-12", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_capitalization/012_capitalization_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/024_material_contracts_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/05_employment/036_employment_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/048_ip_technology_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/09_litigation/072_litigation_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/08_regulatory/060_regulatory_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/12_financials/097_solace_mobility_impact_population.xlsx"]}], "schema_version": "counselbench.matter-register.v3", "task_id": "cb100-005-solace-mobility"}}, "metadata": {"benchmark": "CounselBench-100", "code_license": "Apache-2.0", "data_license": "CC-BY-4.0", "deadline": "2026-09-18", "document_count": 97, "evidence_holds": 4, "jurisdiction": "California", "matter_number": "CB-MA-2405", "mcp_commit": "9a96ea6e5913736f92b88345bf51caeaaa8e719f", "mcp_package": "@modelcontextprotocol/server-filesystem@2026.7.10", "practice_area": "corporate-ma", "reference_tool_calls": 83, "required_evidence_reads": 63, "supported_actions": 8, "synthetic": true, "venue": "Santa Clara County, California", "version": "3.1.0"}, "prompt": "We inherited inconsistent versions of this matter and need to settle the operating position. Does Lantern own and price what we think it does at closing, or do the contractor and customer records require a holdback? The route-optimization target relies on contractor-created models, municipal fleet data, and a customer letter that changes the pricing floor after closing. The team needs the call by 2026-09-18. I need the recommendation and the real blockers recorded before the team acts.", "rubric": {"criteria": [{"category": "investigation", "description": "Inventory the production and use targeted searches to locate records across native formats.", "id": "investigation.discover_production"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Complete every task-specific identity, authority, operations, and approval read before the first state transition.", "id": "investigation.read_before_write"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Inspect designated source metadata before relying on those records.", "id": "investigation.custody_before_write"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "Select the supported option 'solace-mobility:scoped-evidence' after applying the four-part test.", "id": "decision.selected_option"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "Identify both rejected approaches and explain why a one-source shortcut and a blanket hold are wrong.", "id": "decision.alternatives"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-005-01 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_corporate/001_corporate_source_export.md rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-005-01.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_capitalization/013_capitalization_source_export.json for most-favored-customer exposure.", "id": "investigation.CBP-005-01.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_debt_security/025_debt_security_source_export.md to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-005-01.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_employment/037_employment_source_export.json.", "id": "investigation.CBP-005-01.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-005-01 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key.", "id": "decision.CBP-005-01.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-005-01 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-005-01.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-005-02 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_corporate/002_corporate_source_export.txt rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-005-02.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_capitalization/014_capitalization_source_export.xml for unreported security incident.", "id": "investigation.CBP-005-02.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_debt_security/026_debt_security_source_export.txt to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-005-02.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_employment/038_employment_source_export.xml.", "id": "investigation.CBP-005-02.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-005-02 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-005-02.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-005-02 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-005-02.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-005-03 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_corporate/003_corporate_source_export.eml rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-005-03.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_capitalization/015_capitalization_source_export.html for claims-made insurance tail.", "id": "investigation.CBP-005-03.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_debt_security/027_debt_security_source_export.eml to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-005-03.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_employment/039_employment_source_export.html.", "id": "investigation.CBP-005-03.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-005-03 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-005-03.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-005-03 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-005-03.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-005-04 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_corporate/004_corporate_source_export.csv rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-005-04.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_capitalization/016_capitalization_source_export.pdf for anti-assignment restriction.", "id": "investigation.CBP-005-04.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_debt_security/028_debt_security_source_export.csv to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-005-04.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_employment/040_employment_source_export.pdf.", "id": "investigation.CBP-005-04.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-005-04 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-005-04.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-005-04 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-005-04.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-005-05 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_corporate/005_corporate_source_export.json rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-005-05.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/017_material_contracts_source_export.md for open-source copyleft exposure.", "id": "investigation.CBP-005-05.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_debt_security/029_debt_security_source_export.json to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-005-05.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/041_ip_technology_source_export.md.", "id": "investigation.CBP-005-05.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-005-05 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-005-05.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-005-05 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-005-05.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-005-06 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_corporate/006_corporate_source_export.xml rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-005-06.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/018_material_contracts_source_export.txt for sales-tax nexus gap.", "id": "investigation.CBP-005-06.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_debt_security/030_debt_security_source_export.xml to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-005-06.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/042_ip_technology_source_export.txt.", "id": "investigation.CBP-005-06.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-005-06 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-005-06.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-005-06 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-005-06.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-005-07 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_corporate/007_corporate_source_export.html rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-005-07.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/019_material_contracts_source_export.eml for change-of-control consent.", "id": "investigation.CBP-005-07.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_debt_security/031_debt_security_source_export.html to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-005-07.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/043_ip_technology_source_export.eml.", "id": "investigation.CBP-005-07.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-005-07 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective.", "id": "decision.CBP-005-07.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-005-07 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-005-07.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-005-08 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_corporate/008_corporate_source_export.pdf rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-005-08.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/020_material_contracts_source_export.csv for invention assignment defect.", "id": "investigation.CBP-005-08.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_debt_security/032_debt_security_source_export.pdf to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-005-08.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/044_ip_technology_source_export.csv.", "id": "investigation.CBP-005-08.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-005-08 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is the operational record relies on a superseded control revision.", "id": "decision.CBP-005-08.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-005-08 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-005-08.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-005-09 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_capitalization/009_capitalization_source_export.md rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-005-09.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/021_material_contracts_source_export.json for facility title exception.", "id": "investigation.CBP-005-09.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_employment/033_employment_source_export.md to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-005-09.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/045_ip_technology_source_export.json.", "id": "investigation.CBP-005-09.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-005-09 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-005-09.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-005-09 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-005-09.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-005-10 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_capitalization/010_capitalization_source_export.txt rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-005-10.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/022_material_contracts_source_export.xml for unrecorded option grant.", "id": "investigation.CBP-005-10.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_employment/034_employment_source_export.txt to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-005-10.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/046_ip_technology_source_export.xml.", "id": "investigation.CBP-005-10.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-005-10 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is the current observation does not meet the operative trigger.", "id": "decision.CBP-005-10.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-005-10 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-005-10.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-005-11 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_capitalization/011_capitalization_source_export.eml rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-005-11.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/023_material_contracts_source_export.html for key-person retention gap.", "id": "investigation.CBP-005-11.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_employment/035_employment_source_export.eml to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-005-11.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/047_ip_technology_source_export.html.", "id": "investigation.CBP-005-11.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-005-11 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-005-11.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-005-11 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-005-11.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-005-12 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_capitalization/012_capitalization_source_export.csv rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-005-12.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/024_material_contracts_source_export.pdf for threatened customer dispute.", "id": "investigation.CBP-005-12.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_employment/036_employment_source_export.csv to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-005-12.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/048_ip_technology_source_export.pdf.", "id": "investigation.CBP-005-12.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-005-12 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-005-12.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-005-12 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-005-12.register"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Write the exact selected option, supported action population, evidence-hold population, facts, owners, deadlines, and citations.", "id": "state.exact_decision"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create one exact register row per portfolio key with no extra, missing, or modified row.", "id": "state.exact_register"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Leave only the three approved deliverables and perform no extra state-changing write.", "id": "state.write_scope_containment"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Read back decision.json, matter-register.json, and advice.md after their final writes.", "id": "state.postwrite_readback"}, {"category": "answer", "description": "Explain the selected recommendation, supported actions, holds, alternatives, and limitations with exact source anchors.", "id": "answer.decision_note"}], "decision_options": [{"approach": "Use a plausible summary or one source without completing the controlling joins.", "id": "solace-mobility:shortcut", "label": "Rely on repository access and current invoices as proof of ownership and pricing rights."}, {"approach": "Treat supported actions and genuinely ambiguous records as if they were equally unresolved.", "id": "solace-mobility:blanket-hold", "label": "Freeze the entire matter population"}, {"approach": "Apply the exact identity, current-state, authority, and revision test. Register each supported title or pricing protection without changing clean portfolio items.", "id": "solace-mobility:scoped-evidence", "label": "Use targeted assignment or economic protections where the evidence shows a closing exposure."}], "evaluation_narrative": {"authority": "Signed assignments, data-use grants, and the effective customer amendment govern value transfer.", "observation": "Tie model contributions, municipal data rights, and the pricing letter to exact repositories and accounts.", "question": "Does Lantern own and price what we think it does at closing, or do the contractor and customer records require a holdback?", "register_action": "Register each supported title or pricing protection without changing clean portfolio items."}, "gates": ["all_required_evidence_precedes_first_write", "decision_criteria_complete", "register_state_exact", "write_scope_contained", "all_outputs_verified_by_readback"], "metadata_checks": 4, "metric": "weighted_criteria_score", "minimum_tool_calls": 83, "required_deliverables": ["decision.json", "matter-register.json", "advice.md"], "required_document_reads": 63, "type": "deterministic", "weights": {"advice": 0.15, "decision": 0.35, "investigation": 0.25, "state": 0.25}}, "task_id": "cb100-005-solace-mobility", "task_name": "Project Lantern fleet technology acquisition", "world_id": "counselbench-filesystem-mcp-v3"}
+{"context_files": ["task_files/cb100-006-meridian-water/01_corporate/001_corporate_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-006-meridian-water/01_corporate/002_corporate_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-006-meridian-water/01_corporate/003_corporate_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-006-meridian-water/01_corporate/004_corporate_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-006-meridian-water/01_corporate/005_corporate_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-006-meridian-water/01_corporate/006_corporate_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-006-meridian-water/01_corporate/007_corporate_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-006-meridian-water/01_corporate/008_corporate_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-006-meridian-water/02_capitalization/009_capitalization_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-006-meridian-water/02_capitalization/010_capitalization_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-006-meridian-water/02_capitalization/011_capitalization_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-006-meridian-water/02_capitalization/012_capitalization_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-006-meridian-water/02_capitalization/013_capitalization_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-006-meridian-water/02_capitalization/014_capitalization_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-006-meridian-water/02_capitalization/015_capitalization_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-006-meridian-water/02_capitalization/016_capitalization_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-006-meridian-water/03_material_contracts/017_material_contracts_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-006-meridian-water/03_material_contracts/018_material_contracts_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-006-meridian-water/03_material_contracts/019_material_contracts_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-006-meridian-water/03_material_contracts/020_material_contracts_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-006-meridian-water/03_material_contracts/021_material_contracts_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-006-meridian-water/03_material_contracts/022_material_contracts_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-006-meridian-water/03_material_contracts/023_material_contracts_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-006-meridian-water/03_material_contracts/024_material_contracts_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-006-meridian-water/04_debt_security/025_debt_security_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-006-meridian-water/04_debt_security/026_debt_security_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-006-meridian-water/04_debt_security/027_debt_security_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-006-meridian-water/04_debt_security/028_debt_security_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-006-meridian-water/04_debt_security/029_debt_security_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-006-meridian-water/04_debt_security/030_debt_security_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-006-meridian-water/04_debt_security/031_debt_security_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-006-meridian-water/04_debt_security/032_debt_security_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-006-meridian-water/05_employment/033_employment_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-006-meridian-water/05_employment/034_employment_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-006-meridian-water/05_employment/035_employment_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-006-meridian-water/05_employment/036_employment_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-006-meridian-water/05_employment/037_employment_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-006-meridian-water/05_employment/038_employment_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-006-meridian-water/05_employment/039_employment_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-006-meridian-water/05_employment/040_employment_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-006-meridian-water/06_ip_technology/041_ip_technology_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-006-meridian-water/06_ip_technology/042_ip_technology_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-006-meridian-water/06_ip_technology/043_ip_technology_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-006-meridian-water/06_ip_technology/044_ip_technology_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-006-meridian-water/06_ip_technology/045_ip_technology_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-006-meridian-water/06_ip_technology/046_ip_technology_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-006-meridian-water/06_ip_technology/047_ip_technology_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-006-meridian-water/06_ip_technology/048_ip_technology_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-006-meridian-water/07_privacy_security/049_privacy_security_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-006-meridian-water/07_privacy_security/050_privacy_security_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-006-meridian-water/07_privacy_security/051_privacy_security_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-006-meridian-water/07_privacy_security/052_privacy_security_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-006-meridian-water/07_privacy_security/053_privacy_security_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-006-meridian-water/07_privacy_security/054_privacy_security_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-006-meridian-water/07_privacy_security/055_privacy_security_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-006-meridian-water/07_privacy_security/056_privacy_security_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-006-meridian-water/08_regulatory/057_regulatory_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-006-meridian-water/08_regulatory/058_regulatory_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-006-meridian-water/08_regulatory/059_regulatory_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-006-meridian-water/08_regulatory/060_regulatory_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-006-meridian-water/08_regulatory/061_regulatory_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-006-meridian-water/08_regulatory/062_regulatory_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-006-meridian-water/08_regulatory/063_regulatory_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-006-meridian-water/08_regulatory/064_regulatory_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-006-meridian-water/09_litigation/065_litigation_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-006-meridian-water/09_litigation/066_litigation_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-006-meridian-water/09_litigation/067_litigation_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-006-meridian-water/09_litigation/068_litigation_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-006-meridian-water/09_litigation/069_litigation_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-006-meridian-water/09_litigation/070_litigation_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-006-meridian-water/09_litigation/071_litigation_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-006-meridian-water/09_litigation/072_litigation_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-006-meridian-water/10_real_property/073_real_property_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-006-meridian-water/10_real_property/074_real_property_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-006-meridian-water/10_real_property/075_real_property_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-006-meridian-water/10_real_property/076_real_property_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-006-meridian-water/10_real_property/077_real_property_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-006-meridian-water/10_real_property/078_real_property_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-006-meridian-water/10_real_property/079_real_property_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-006-meridian-water/10_real_property/080_real_property_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-006-meridian-water/11_tax_insurance/081_tax_insurance_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-006-meridian-water/11_tax_insurance/082_tax_insurance_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-006-meridian-water/11_tax_insurance/083_tax_insurance_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-006-meridian-water/11_tax_insurance/084_tax_insurance_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-006-meridian-water/11_tax_insurance/085_tax_insurance_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-006-meridian-water/11_tax_insurance/086_tax_insurance_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-006-meridian-water/11_tax_insurance/087_tax_insurance_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-006-meridian-water/11_tax_insurance/088_tax_insurance_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-006-meridian-water/12_financials/089_financials_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-006-meridian-water/12_financials/090_financials_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-006-meridian-water/12_financials/091_financials_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-006-meridian-water/12_financials/092_financials_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-006-meridian-water/12_financials/093_financials_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-006-meridian-water/12_financials/094_financials_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-006-meridian-water/12_financials/095_financials_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-006-meridian-water/12_financials/096_financials_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-006-meridian-water/12_financials/097_meridian_water_impact_population.xlsx"], "gold_output": {"advice_markdown": "# Decision note — Project Spillway treatment business acquisition\n\n## Recommendation\n\nChoose a scoped consent, escrow, or covenant response for each proven exposure. The reconciled record supports 5 scoped actions and leaves 7 items on evidence hold.\n\nSelected option: `meridian-water:scoped-evidence`.\n\n## Why this is the supported option\n\nCorrelate municipal contracts, escrow duties, and the explosion claim to the acquired entity and policy period. Consent clauses, current escrow terms, and applicable insurance exclusions control the allocation.\n\n## Supported actions\n\n### CBP-006-01 — financial covenant breach (low)\n\nthe controlling threshold is 9% under CB-MA-2406-R304; the independently calculated result is 17% under CB-MA-2406-E747. Identity resolves to ENT-006-1000, revision REV-2026.1 is current, and Farah Ibrahim is active with capacity 1.\n\nAction: Record supported allocation items and quarantine records outside the covered entity or period. Owner: Farah Ibrahim; due 2026-09-21.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_corporate/001_corporate_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/02_capitalization/013_capitalization_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/04_debt_security/025_debt_security_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/05_employment/037_employment_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/07_privacy_security/049_privacy_security_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/12_financials/097_meridian_water_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-006-04 — most-favored-customer exposure (medium)\n\nthe permission is limited to Harris County, Texas under CB-MA-2406-R988; the matched activity occurred in Texas under CB-MA-2406-E734. Identity resolves to ENT-006-1003, revision REV-2026.4 is current, and Henry Cho is active with capacity 1.\n\nAction: Record supported allocation items and quarantine records outside the covered entity or period. Owner: Henry Cho; due 2026-09-18.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_corporate/004_corporate_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/02_capitalization/016_capitalization_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/04_debt_security/028_debt_security_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/05_employment/040_employment_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/08_regulatory/064_regulatory_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/11_tax_insurance/088_tax_insurance_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/12_financials/097_meridian_water_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-006-07 — anti-assignment restriction (high)\n\nan open exception blocks completion under CB-MA-2406-R192; the current status is open and unresolved under CB-MA-2406-E105. Identity resolves to ENT-006-1006, revision REV-2026.7 is current, and Willa Novak is active with capacity 4.\n\nAction: Record supported allocation items and quarantine records outside the covered entity or period. Owner: Willa Novak; due 2026-09-15.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_corporate/007_corporate_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/019_material_contracts_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/04_debt_security/031_debt_security_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/043_ip_technology_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/12_financials/097_meridian_water_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-006-10 — change-of-control consent (low)\n\napproval must come from Mei Whitaker under CB-MA-2406-R994; the effective approval record names Caleb Hassan under CB-MA-2406-E946. Identity resolves to ENT-006-1009, revision REV-2026.3 is current, and Isaac Romero is active with capacity 3.\n\nAction: Record supported allocation items and quarantine records outside the covered entity or period. Owner: Isaac Romero; due 2026-09-21.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/02_capitalization/010_capitalization_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/022_material_contracts_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/05_employment/034_employment_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/046_ip_technology_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/09_litigation/070_litigation_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/12_financials/097_meridian_water_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-006-11 — invention assignment defect (medium)\n\nthe controlled population contains 161 records under CB-MA-2406-R719; the certification covers 126 records under CB-MA-2406-E295. Identity resolves to ENT-006-1010, revision REV-2026.4 is current, and Nadine Flores is active with capacity 3.\n\nAction: Record supported allocation items and quarantine records outside the covered entity or period. Owner: Nadine Flores; due 2026-09-20.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/02_capitalization/011_capitalization_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/023_material_contracts_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/05_employment/035_employment_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/047_ip_technology_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/12_financials/097_meridian_water_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n## Evidence holds\n\n- **CBP-006-02 — permit transfer restriction**: the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective. Next evidence: effective approval and an active owner with remaining capacity. Sources: `/workspace/documents/01_corporate/002_corporate_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/02_capitalization/014_capitalization_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/04_debt_security/026_debt_security_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/05_employment/038_employment_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/10_real_property/074_real_property_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/08_regulatory/062_regulatory_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/12_financials/097_meridian_water_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-006-03 — revenue recognition exception**: the operational record relies on a superseded control revision. Next evidence: an operational record using the current effective revision. Sources: `/workspace/documents/01_corporate/003_corporate_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/02_capitalization/015_capitalization_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/04_debt_security/027_debt_security_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/05_employment/039_employment_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/07_privacy_security/051_privacy_security_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/12_financials/097_meridian_water_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-006-05 — unreported security incident**: the current observation does not meet the operative trigger. Next evidence: a current observation that satisfies the operative trigger. Sources: `/workspace/documents/01_corporate/005_corporate_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/017_material_contracts_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/04_debt_security/029_debt_security_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/041_ip_technology_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/09_litigation/065_litigation_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/12_financials/089_financials_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/12_financials/097_meridian_water_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-006-06 — claims-made insurance tail**: the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective. Next evidence: effective approval and an active owner with remaining capacity. Sources: `/workspace/documents/01_corporate/006_corporate_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/018_material_contracts_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/04_debt_security/030_debt_security_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/042_ip_technology_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/12_financials/090_financials_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/12_financials/097_meridian_water_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-006-08 — open-source copyleft exposure**: two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key. Next evidence: an approved immutable entity crosswalk. Sources: `/workspace/documents/01_corporate/008_corporate_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/020_material_contracts_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/04_debt_security/032_debt_security_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/044_ip_technology_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/07_privacy_security/056_privacy_security_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/12_financials/097_meridian_water_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-006-09 — sales-tax nexus gap**: the current observation does not meet the operative trigger. Next evidence: a current observation that satisfies the operative trigger. Sources: `/workspace/documents/02_capitalization/009_capitalization_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/021_material_contracts_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/05_employment/033_employment_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/045_ip_technology_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/11_tax_insurance/081_tax_insurance_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/12_financials/093_financials_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/12_financials/097_meridian_water_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-006-12 — facility title exception**: two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key. Next evidence: an approved immutable entity crosswalk. Sources: `/workspace/documents/02_capitalization/012_capitalization_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/024_material_contracts_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/05_employment/036_employment_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/048_ip_technology_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/09_litigation/072_litigation_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/12_financials/096_financials_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/12_financials/097_meridian_water_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n## Alternatives considered\n\n- `meridian-water:blanket-hold` — Freeze the entire matter population: Treat supported actions and genuinely ambiguous records as if they were equally unresolved.\n- `meridian-water:shortcut` — Assume ordinary-course renewals and current insurance eliminate every legacy issue.: Use a plausible summary or one source without completing the controlling joins.\n\n## Assumptions and limits\n\nThis decision is limited to cb100-006-meridian-water, the supplied synthetic records, and the matter state as of 2026-09-22. Similar names, stale revisions, and pending authority are not treated as proof.\n", "decision": {"actions": [{"determination": "the controlling threshold is 9% under CB-MA-2406-R304; the independently calculated result is 17% under CB-MA-2406-E747. Identity resolves to ENT-006-1000, revision REV-2026.1 is current, and Farah Ibrahim is active with capacity 1.", "due_date": "2026-09-21", "id": "ACT-CBP-006-01", "identity_id": "ENT-006-1000", "issue": "financial covenant breach", "owner": "Farah Ibrahim", "portfolio_key": "CBP-006-01", "recommended_action": "Record supported allocation items and quarantine records outside the covered entity or period. Owner: Farah Ibrahim; due 2026-09-21.", "severity": "low", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_corporate/001_corporate_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/02_capitalization/013_capitalization_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/04_debt_security/025_debt_security_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/05_employment/037_employment_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/07_privacy_security/049_privacy_security_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/12_financials/097_meridian_water_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "the permission is limited to Harris County, Texas under CB-MA-2406-R988; the matched activity occurred in Texas under CB-MA-2406-E734. Identity resolves to ENT-006-1003, revision REV-2026.4 is current, and Henry Cho is active with capacity 1.", "due_date": "2026-09-18", "id": "ACT-CBP-006-04", "identity_id": "ENT-006-1003", "issue": "most-favored-customer exposure", "owner": "Henry Cho", "portfolio_key": "CBP-006-04", "recommended_action": "Record supported allocation items and quarantine records outside the covered entity or period. Owner: Henry Cho; due 2026-09-18.", "severity": "medium", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_corporate/004_corporate_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/02_capitalization/016_capitalization_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/04_debt_security/028_debt_security_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/05_employment/040_employment_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/08_regulatory/064_regulatory_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/11_tax_insurance/088_tax_insurance_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_financials/097_meridian_water_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "an open exception blocks completion under CB-MA-2406-R192; the current status is open and unresolved under CB-MA-2406-E105. Identity resolves to ENT-006-1006, revision REV-2026.7 is current, and Willa Novak is active with capacity 4.", "due_date": "2026-09-15", "id": "ACT-CBP-006-07", "identity_id": "ENT-006-1006", "issue": "anti-assignment restriction", "owner": "Willa Novak", "portfolio_key": "CBP-006-07", "recommended_action": "Record supported allocation items and quarantine records outside the covered entity or period. Owner: Willa Novak; due 2026-09-15.", "severity": "high", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_corporate/007_corporate_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/019_material_contracts_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/04_debt_security/031_debt_security_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/043_ip_technology_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/12_financials/097_meridian_water_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "approval must come from Mei Whitaker under CB-MA-2406-R994; the effective approval record names Caleb Hassan under CB-MA-2406-E946. Identity resolves to ENT-006-1009, revision REV-2026.3 is current, and Isaac Romero is active with capacity 3.", "due_date": "2026-09-21", "id": "ACT-CBP-006-10", "identity_id": "ENT-006-1009", "issue": "change-of-control consent", "owner": "Isaac Romero", "portfolio_key": "CBP-006-10", "recommended_action": "Record supported allocation items and quarantine records outside the covered entity or period. Owner: Isaac Romero; due 2026-09-21.", "severity": "low", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_capitalization/010_capitalization_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/022_material_contracts_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/05_employment/034_employment_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/046_ip_technology_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/09_litigation/070_litigation_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_financials/097_meridian_water_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "the controlled population contains 161 records under CB-MA-2406-R719; the certification covers 126 records under CB-MA-2406-E295. Identity resolves to ENT-006-1010, revision REV-2026.4 is current, and Nadine Flores is active with capacity 3.", "due_date": "2026-09-20", "id": "ACT-CBP-006-11", "identity_id": "ENT-006-1010", "issue": "invention assignment defect", "owner": "Nadine Flores", "portfolio_key": "CBP-006-11", "recommended_action": "Record supported allocation items and quarantine records outside the covered entity or period. Owner: Nadine Flores; due 2026-09-20.", "severity": "medium", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_capitalization/011_capitalization_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/023_material_contracts_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/05_employment/035_employment_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/047_ip_technology_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_financials/097_meridian_water_impact_population.xlsx"]}], "as_of": "2026-09-22", "decision": {"alternatives_considered": ["meridian-water:blanket-hold", "meridian-water:shortcut"], "question": "Which Spillway risks actually prevent a clean close, and which can be handled through escrow or post-close covenants?", "rationale": "The four-part causal test supports 5 scoped actions and leaves 7 records on evidence hold. Consent clauses, current escrow terms, and applicable insurance exclusions control the allocation.", "recommendation": "Choose a scoped consent, escrow, or covenant response for each proven exposure.", "selected_option_id": "meridian-water:scoped-evidence"}, "holds": [{"id": "HOLD-CBP-006-02", "issue": "permit transfer restriction", "portfolio_key": "CBP-006-02", "reason": "the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective", "required_next_evidence": "effective approval and an active owner with remaining capacity", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_corporate/002_corporate_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/02_capitalization/014_capitalization_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/04_debt_security/026_debt_security_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/05_employment/038_employment_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/10_real_property/074_real_property_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/08_regulatory/062_regulatory_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_financials/097_meridian_water_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-006-03", "issue": "revenue recognition exception", "portfolio_key": "CBP-006-03", "reason": "the operational record relies on a superseded control revision", "required_next_evidence": "an operational record using the current effective revision", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_corporate/003_corporate_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/02_capitalization/015_capitalization_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/04_debt_security/027_debt_security_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/05_employment/039_employment_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/07_privacy_security/051_privacy_security_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/12_financials/097_meridian_water_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-006-05", "issue": "unreported security incident", "portfolio_key": "CBP-006-05", "reason": "the current observation does not meet the operative trigger", "required_next_evidence": "a current observation that satisfies the operative trigger", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_corporate/005_corporate_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/017_material_contracts_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/04_debt_security/029_debt_security_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/041_ip_technology_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/09_litigation/065_litigation_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/12_financials/089_financials_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/12_financials/097_meridian_water_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-006-06", "issue": "claims-made insurance tail", "portfolio_key": "CBP-006-06", "reason": "the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective", "required_next_evidence": "effective approval and an active owner with remaining capacity", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_corporate/006_corporate_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/018_material_contracts_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/04_debt_security/030_debt_security_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/042_ip_technology_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/12_financials/090_financials_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/12_financials/097_meridian_water_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-006-08", "issue": "open-source copyleft exposure", "portfolio_key": "CBP-006-08", "reason": "two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key", "required_next_evidence": "an approved immutable entity crosswalk", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_corporate/008_corporate_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/020_material_contracts_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/04_debt_security/032_debt_security_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/044_ip_technology_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/07_privacy_security/056_privacy_security_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_financials/097_meridian_water_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-006-09", "issue": "sales-tax nexus gap", "portfolio_key": "CBP-006-09", "reason": "the current observation does not meet the operative trigger", "required_next_evidence": "a current observation that satisfies the operative trigger", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_capitalization/009_capitalization_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/021_material_contracts_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/05_employment/033_employment_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/045_ip_technology_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/11_tax_insurance/081_tax_insurance_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/12_financials/093_financials_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_financials/097_meridian_water_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-006-12", "issue": "facility title exception", "portfolio_key": "CBP-006-12", "reason": "two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key", "required_next_evidence": "an approved immutable entity crosswalk", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_capitalization/012_capitalization_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/024_material_contracts_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/05_employment/036_employment_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/048_ip_technology_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/09_litigation/072_litigation_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_financials/096_financials_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_financials/097_meridian_water_impact_population.xlsx"]}], "matter_number": "CB-MA-2406", "prepared_for": "Meridian Water Infrastructure", "schema_version": "counselbench.decision.v3", "task_id": "cb100-006-meridian-water"}, "matter_register": {"matter_number": "CB-MA-2406", "rows": [{"decision_option_id": "meridian-water:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-21", "issue": "financial covenant breach", "matter_number": "CB-MA-2406", "owner": "Farah Ibrahim", "portfolio_key": "CBP-006-01", "row_id": "REG-CBP-006-01", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_corporate/001_corporate_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/02_capitalization/013_capitalization_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/04_debt_security/025_debt_security_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/05_employment/037_employment_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/07_privacy_security/049_privacy_security_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/12_financials/097_meridian_water_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "meridian-water:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective", "issue": "permit transfer restriction", "matter_number": "CB-MA-2406", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-006-02", "row_id": "REG-CBP-006-02", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_corporate/002_corporate_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/02_capitalization/014_capitalization_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/04_debt_security/026_debt_security_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/05_employment/038_employment_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/10_real_property/074_real_property_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/08_regulatory/062_regulatory_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_financials/097_meridian_water_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "meridian-water:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "the operational record relies on a superseded control revision", "issue": "revenue recognition exception", "matter_number": "CB-MA-2406", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-006-03", "row_id": "REG-CBP-006-03", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_corporate/003_corporate_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/02_capitalization/015_capitalization_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/04_debt_security/027_debt_security_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/05_employment/039_employment_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/07_privacy_security/051_privacy_security_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/12_financials/097_meridian_water_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "meridian-water:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-18", "issue": "most-favored-customer exposure", "matter_number": "CB-MA-2406", "owner": "Henry Cho", "portfolio_key": "CBP-006-04", "row_id": "REG-CBP-006-04", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_corporate/004_corporate_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/02_capitalization/016_capitalization_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/04_debt_security/028_debt_security_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/05_employment/040_employment_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/08_regulatory/064_regulatory_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/11_tax_insurance/088_tax_insurance_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_financials/097_meridian_water_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "meridian-water:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "the current observation does not meet the operative trigger", "issue": "unreported security incident", "matter_number": "CB-MA-2406", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-006-05", "row_id": "REG-CBP-006-05", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_corporate/005_corporate_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/017_material_contracts_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/04_debt_security/029_debt_security_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/041_ip_technology_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/09_litigation/065_litigation_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/12_financials/089_financials_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/12_financials/097_meridian_water_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "meridian-water:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective", "issue": "claims-made insurance tail", "matter_number": "CB-MA-2406", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-006-06", "row_id": "REG-CBP-006-06", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_corporate/006_corporate_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/018_material_contracts_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/04_debt_security/030_debt_security_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/042_ip_technology_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/12_financials/090_financials_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/12_financials/097_meridian_water_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "meridian-water:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-15", "issue": "anti-assignment restriction", "matter_number": "CB-MA-2406", "owner": "Willa Novak", "portfolio_key": "CBP-006-07", "row_id": "REG-CBP-006-07", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_corporate/007_corporate_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/019_material_contracts_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/04_debt_security/031_debt_security_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/043_ip_technology_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/12_financials/097_meridian_water_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "meridian-water:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key", "issue": "open-source copyleft exposure", "matter_number": "CB-MA-2406", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-006-08", "row_id": "REG-CBP-006-08", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_corporate/008_corporate_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/020_material_contracts_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/04_debt_security/032_debt_security_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/044_ip_technology_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/07_privacy_security/056_privacy_security_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_financials/097_meridian_water_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "meridian-water:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "the current observation does not meet the operative trigger", "issue": "sales-tax nexus gap", "matter_number": "CB-MA-2406", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-006-09", "row_id": "REG-CBP-006-09", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_capitalization/009_capitalization_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/021_material_contracts_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/05_employment/033_employment_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/045_ip_technology_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/11_tax_insurance/081_tax_insurance_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/12_financials/093_financials_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_financials/097_meridian_water_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "meridian-water:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-21", "issue": "change-of-control consent", "matter_number": "CB-MA-2406", "owner": "Isaac Romero", "portfolio_key": "CBP-006-10", "row_id": "REG-CBP-006-10", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_capitalization/010_capitalization_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/022_material_contracts_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/05_employment/034_employment_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/046_ip_technology_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/09_litigation/070_litigation_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_financials/097_meridian_water_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "meridian-water:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-20", "issue": "invention assignment defect", "matter_number": "CB-MA-2406", "owner": "Nadine Flores", "portfolio_key": "CBP-006-11", "row_id": "REG-CBP-006-11", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_capitalization/011_capitalization_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/023_material_contracts_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/05_employment/035_employment_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/047_ip_technology_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_financials/097_meridian_water_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "meridian-water:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key", "issue": "facility title exception", "matter_number": "CB-MA-2406", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-006-12", "row_id": "REG-CBP-006-12", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_capitalization/012_capitalization_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/024_material_contracts_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/05_employment/036_employment_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/048_ip_technology_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/09_litigation/072_litigation_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_financials/096_financials_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_financials/097_meridian_water_impact_population.xlsx"]}], "schema_version": "counselbench.matter-register.v3", "task_id": "cb100-006-meridian-water"}}, "metadata": {"benchmark": "CounselBench-100", "code_license": "Apache-2.0", "data_license": "CC-BY-4.0", "deadline": "2026-09-22", "document_count": 97, "evidence_holds": 7, "jurisdiction": "Texas", "matter_number": "CB-MA-2406", "mcp_commit": "9a96ea6e5913736f92b88345bf51caeaaa8e719f", "mcp_package": "@modelcontextprotocol/server-filesystem@2026.7.10", "practice_area": "corporate-ma", "reference_tool_calls": 91, "required_evidence_reads": 64, "supported_actions": 5, "synthetic": true, "venue": "Harris County, Texas", "version": "3.1.0"}, "prompt": "I am about to brief the decision makers and need the source record reconciled first. Which Spillway risks actually prevent a clean close, and which can be handled through escrow or post-close covenants? A process-controls business has municipal framework contracts, source-code escrow obligations, and a legacy explosion claim excluded from current insurance. The team needs the call by 2026-09-22. Record the outcome the source hierarchy supports and explain the alternatives we should not take.", "rubric": {"criteria": [{"category": "investigation", "description": "Inventory the production and use targeted searches to locate records across native formats.", "id": "investigation.discover_production"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Complete every task-specific identity, authority, operations, and approval read before the first state transition.", "id": "investigation.read_before_write"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Inspect designated source metadata before relying on those records.", "id": "investigation.custody_before_write"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "Select the supported option 'meridian-water:scoped-evidence' after applying the four-part test.", "id": "decision.selected_option"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "Identify both rejected approaches and explain why a one-source shortcut and a blanket hold are wrong.", "id": "decision.alternatives"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-006-01 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_corporate/001_corporate_source_export.md rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-006-01.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_capitalization/013_capitalization_source_export.json for financial covenant breach.", "id": "investigation.CBP-006-01.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_debt_security/025_debt_security_source_export.md to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-006-01.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_employment/037_employment_source_export.json.", "id": "investigation.CBP-006-01.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-006-01 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-006-01.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-006-01 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-006-01.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-006-02 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_corporate/002_corporate_source_export.txt rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-006-02.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_capitalization/014_capitalization_source_export.xml for permit transfer restriction.", "id": "investigation.CBP-006-02.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_debt_security/026_debt_security_source_export.txt to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-006-02.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_employment/038_employment_source_export.xml.", "id": "investigation.CBP-006-02.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-006-02 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective.", "id": "decision.CBP-006-02.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-006-02 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-006-02.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-006-03 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_corporate/003_corporate_source_export.eml rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-006-03.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_capitalization/015_capitalization_source_export.html for revenue recognition exception.", "id": "investigation.CBP-006-03.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_debt_security/027_debt_security_source_export.eml to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-006-03.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_employment/039_employment_source_export.html.", "id": "investigation.CBP-006-03.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-006-03 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is the operational record relies on a superseded control revision.", "id": "decision.CBP-006-03.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-006-03 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-006-03.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-006-04 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_corporate/004_corporate_source_export.csv rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-006-04.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_capitalization/016_capitalization_source_export.pdf for most-favored-customer exposure.", "id": "investigation.CBP-006-04.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_debt_security/028_debt_security_source_export.csv to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-006-04.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_employment/040_employment_source_export.pdf.", "id": "investigation.CBP-006-04.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-006-04 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-006-04.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-006-04 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-006-04.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-006-05 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_corporate/005_corporate_source_export.json rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-006-05.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/017_material_contracts_source_export.md for unreported security incident.", "id": "investigation.CBP-006-05.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_debt_security/029_debt_security_source_export.json to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-006-05.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/041_ip_technology_source_export.md.", "id": "investigation.CBP-006-05.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-006-05 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is the current observation does not meet the operative trigger.", "id": "decision.CBP-006-05.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-006-05 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-006-05.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-006-06 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_corporate/006_corporate_source_export.xml rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-006-06.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/018_material_contracts_source_export.txt for claims-made insurance tail.", "id": "investigation.CBP-006-06.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_debt_security/030_debt_security_source_export.xml to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-006-06.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/042_ip_technology_source_export.txt.", "id": "investigation.CBP-006-06.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-006-06 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective.", "id": "decision.CBP-006-06.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-006-06 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-006-06.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-006-07 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_corporate/007_corporate_source_export.html rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-006-07.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/019_material_contracts_source_export.eml for anti-assignment restriction.", "id": "investigation.CBP-006-07.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_debt_security/031_debt_security_source_export.html to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-006-07.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/043_ip_technology_source_export.eml.", "id": "investigation.CBP-006-07.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-006-07 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-006-07.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-006-07 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-006-07.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-006-08 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_corporate/008_corporate_source_export.pdf rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-006-08.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/020_material_contracts_source_export.csv for open-source copyleft exposure.", "id": "investigation.CBP-006-08.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_debt_security/032_debt_security_source_export.pdf to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-006-08.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/044_ip_technology_source_export.csv.", "id": "investigation.CBP-006-08.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-006-08 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key.", "id": "decision.CBP-006-08.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-006-08 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-006-08.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-006-09 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_capitalization/009_capitalization_source_export.md rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-006-09.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/021_material_contracts_source_export.json for sales-tax nexus gap.", "id": "investigation.CBP-006-09.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_employment/033_employment_source_export.md to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-006-09.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/045_ip_technology_source_export.json.", "id": "investigation.CBP-006-09.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-006-09 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is the current observation does not meet the operative trigger.", "id": "decision.CBP-006-09.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-006-09 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-006-09.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-006-10 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_capitalization/010_capitalization_source_export.txt rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-006-10.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/022_material_contracts_source_export.xml for change-of-control consent.", "id": "investigation.CBP-006-10.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_employment/034_employment_source_export.txt to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-006-10.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/046_ip_technology_source_export.xml.", "id": "investigation.CBP-006-10.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-006-10 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-006-10.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-006-10 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-006-10.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-006-11 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_capitalization/011_capitalization_source_export.eml rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-006-11.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/023_material_contracts_source_export.html for invention assignment defect.", "id": "investigation.CBP-006-11.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_employment/035_employment_source_export.eml to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-006-11.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/047_ip_technology_source_export.html.", "id": "investigation.CBP-006-11.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-006-11 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-006-11.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-006-11 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-006-11.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-006-12 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_capitalization/012_capitalization_source_export.csv rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-006-12.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/024_material_contracts_source_export.pdf for facility title exception.", "id": "investigation.CBP-006-12.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_employment/036_employment_source_export.csv to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-006-12.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/048_ip_technology_source_export.pdf.", "id": "investigation.CBP-006-12.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-006-12 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key.", "id": "decision.CBP-006-12.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-006-12 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-006-12.register"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Write the exact selected option, supported action population, evidence-hold population, facts, owners, deadlines, and citations.", "id": "state.exact_decision"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create one exact register row per portfolio key with no extra, missing, or modified row.", "id": "state.exact_register"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Leave only the three approved deliverables and perform no extra state-changing write.", "id": "state.write_scope_containment"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Read back decision.json, matter-register.json, and advice.md after their final writes.", "id": "state.postwrite_readback"}, {"category": "answer", "description": "Explain the selected recommendation, supported actions, holds, alternatives, and limitations with exact source anchors.", "id": "answer.decision_note"}], "decision_options": [{"approach": "Treat supported actions and genuinely ambiguous records as if they were equally unresolved.", "id": "meridian-water:blanket-hold", "label": "Freeze the entire matter population"}, {"approach": "Apply the exact identity, current-state, authority, and revision test. Record supported allocation items and quarantine records outside the covered entity or period.", "id": "meridian-water:scoped-evidence", "label": "Choose a scoped consent, escrow, or covenant response for each proven exposure."}, {"approach": "Use a plausible summary or one source without completing the controlling joins.", "id": "meridian-water:shortcut", "label": "Assume ordinary-course renewals and current insurance eliminate every legacy issue."}], "evaluation_narrative": {"authority": "Consent clauses, current escrow terms, and applicable insurance exclusions control the allocation.", "observation": "Correlate municipal contracts, escrow duties, and the explosion claim to the acquired entity and policy period.", "question": "Which Spillway risks actually prevent a clean close, and which can be handled through escrow or post-close covenants?", "register_action": "Record supported allocation items and quarantine records outside the covered entity or period."}, "gates": ["all_required_evidence_precedes_first_write", "decision_criteria_complete", "register_state_exact", "write_scope_contained", "all_outputs_verified_by_readback"], "metadata_checks": 12, "metric": "weighted_criteria_score", "minimum_tool_calls": 91, "required_deliverables": ["decision.json", "matter-register.json", "advice.md"], "required_document_reads": 64, "type": "deterministic", "weights": {"advice": 0.15, "decision": 0.35, "investigation": 0.25, "state": 0.25}}, "task_id": "cb100-006-meridian-water", "task_name": "Project Spillway treatment business acquisition", "world_id": "counselbench-filesystem-mcp-v3"}
+{"context_files": ["task_files/cb100-007-bracken-home/01_corporate/001_corporate_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-007-bracken-home/01_corporate/002_corporate_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-007-bracken-home/01_corporate/003_corporate_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-007-bracken-home/01_corporate/004_corporate_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-007-bracken-home/01_corporate/005_corporate_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-007-bracken-home/01_corporate/006_corporate_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-007-bracken-home/01_corporate/007_corporate_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-007-bracken-home/01_corporate/008_corporate_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-007-bracken-home/02_capitalization/009_capitalization_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-007-bracken-home/02_capitalization/010_capitalization_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-007-bracken-home/02_capitalization/011_capitalization_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-007-bracken-home/02_capitalization/012_capitalization_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-007-bracken-home/02_capitalization/013_capitalization_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-007-bracken-home/02_capitalization/014_capitalization_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-007-bracken-home/02_capitalization/015_capitalization_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-007-bracken-home/02_capitalization/016_capitalization_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-007-bracken-home/03_material_contracts/017_material_contracts_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-007-bracken-home/03_material_contracts/018_material_contracts_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-007-bracken-home/03_material_contracts/019_material_contracts_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-007-bracken-home/03_material_contracts/020_material_contracts_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-007-bracken-home/03_material_contracts/021_material_contracts_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-007-bracken-home/03_material_contracts/022_material_contracts_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-007-bracken-home/03_material_contracts/023_material_contracts_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-007-bracken-home/03_material_contracts/024_material_contracts_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-007-bracken-home/04_debt_security/025_debt_security_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-007-bracken-home/04_debt_security/026_debt_security_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-007-bracken-home/04_debt_security/027_debt_security_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-007-bracken-home/04_debt_security/028_debt_security_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-007-bracken-home/04_debt_security/029_debt_security_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-007-bracken-home/04_debt_security/030_debt_security_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-007-bracken-home/04_debt_security/031_debt_security_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-007-bracken-home/04_debt_security/032_debt_security_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-007-bracken-home/05_employment/033_employment_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-007-bracken-home/05_employment/034_employment_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-007-bracken-home/05_employment/035_employment_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-007-bracken-home/05_employment/036_employment_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-007-bracken-home/05_employment/037_employment_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-007-bracken-home/05_employment/038_employment_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-007-bracken-home/05_employment/039_employment_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-007-bracken-home/05_employment/040_employment_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-007-bracken-home/06_ip_technology/041_ip_technology_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-007-bracken-home/06_ip_technology/042_ip_technology_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-007-bracken-home/06_ip_technology/043_ip_technology_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-007-bracken-home/06_ip_technology/044_ip_technology_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-007-bracken-home/06_ip_technology/045_ip_technology_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-007-bracken-home/06_ip_technology/046_ip_technology_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-007-bracken-home/06_ip_technology/047_ip_technology_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-007-bracken-home/06_ip_technology/048_ip_technology_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-007-bracken-home/07_privacy_security/049_privacy_security_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-007-bracken-home/07_privacy_security/050_privacy_security_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-007-bracken-home/07_privacy_security/051_privacy_security_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-007-bracken-home/07_privacy_security/052_privacy_security_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-007-bracken-home/07_privacy_security/053_privacy_security_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-007-bracken-home/07_privacy_security/054_privacy_security_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-007-bracken-home/07_privacy_security/055_privacy_security_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-007-bracken-home/07_privacy_security/056_privacy_security_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-007-bracken-home/08_regulatory/057_regulatory_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-007-bracken-home/08_regulatory/058_regulatory_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-007-bracken-home/08_regulatory/059_regulatory_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-007-bracken-home/08_regulatory/060_regulatory_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-007-bracken-home/08_regulatory/061_regulatory_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-007-bracken-home/08_regulatory/062_regulatory_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-007-bracken-home/08_regulatory/063_regulatory_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-007-bracken-home/08_regulatory/064_regulatory_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-007-bracken-home/09_litigation/065_litigation_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-007-bracken-home/09_litigation/066_litigation_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-007-bracken-home/09_litigation/067_litigation_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-007-bracken-home/09_litigation/068_litigation_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-007-bracken-home/09_litigation/069_litigation_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-007-bracken-home/09_litigation/070_litigation_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-007-bracken-home/09_litigation/071_litigation_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-007-bracken-home/09_litigation/072_litigation_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-007-bracken-home/10_real_property/073_real_property_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-007-bracken-home/10_real_property/074_real_property_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-007-bracken-home/10_real_property/075_real_property_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-007-bracken-home/10_real_property/076_real_property_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-007-bracken-home/10_real_property/077_real_property_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-007-bracken-home/10_real_property/078_real_property_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-007-bracken-home/10_real_property/079_real_property_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-007-bracken-home/10_real_property/080_real_property_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-007-bracken-home/11_tax_insurance/081_tax_insurance_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-007-bracken-home/11_tax_insurance/082_tax_insurance_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-007-bracken-home/11_tax_insurance/083_tax_insurance_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-007-bracken-home/11_tax_insurance/084_tax_insurance_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-007-bracken-home/11_tax_insurance/085_tax_insurance_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-007-bracken-home/11_tax_insurance/086_tax_insurance_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-007-bracken-home/11_tax_insurance/087_tax_insurance_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-007-bracken-home/11_tax_insurance/088_tax_insurance_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-007-bracken-home/12_financials/089_financials_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-007-bracken-home/12_financials/090_financials_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-007-bracken-home/12_financials/091_financials_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-007-bracken-home/12_financials/092_financials_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-007-bracken-home/12_financials/093_financials_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-007-bracken-home/12_financials/094_financials_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-007-bracken-home/12_financials/095_financials_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-007-bracken-home/12_financials/096_financials_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-007-bracken-home/12_financials/097_bracken_home_impact_population.xlsx"], "gold_output": {"advice_markdown": "# Decision note — Project Hearth consumer products merger\n\n## Recommendation\n\nProceed with item-specific release, reserve, or pricing protection where all evidence joins. The reconciled record supports 9 scoped actions and leaves 3 items on evidence hold.\n\nSelected option: `bracken-home:scoped-evidence`.\n\n## Why this is the supported option\n\nReconcile recalled components, pledged inventory, and parity commitments by SKU, lender, and customer ID. Current recall scope, perfected collateral records, and executed pricing terms govern.\n\n## Supported actions\n\n### CBP-007-01 — key-person retention gap (high)\n\ndelivery must use notices-bracken_home_brands@example.test under CB-MA-2407-R431; the only matched receipt used archive-hearth_reed_appliances_corp@example.test under CB-MA-2407-E913. Identity resolves to ENT-007-1000, revision REV-2025.1 is current, and Samuel Kim is active with capacity 5.\n\nAction: Create exact closing-protection rows while preserving unaffected SKUs and customers. Owner: Samuel Kim; due 2026-09-24.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_corporate/001_corporate_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/02_capitalization/013_capitalization_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/04_debt_security/025_debt_security_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/05_employment/037_employment_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/10_real_property/073_real_property_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/12_financials/097_bracken_home_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-007-02 — threatened customer dispute (critical)\n\nan open exception blocks completion under CB-MA-2407-R760; the current status is open and unresolved under CB-MA-2407-E244. Identity resolves to ENT-007-1001, revision REV-2025.2 is current, and Talia Brooks is active with capacity 5.\n\nAction: Create exact closing-protection rows while preserving unaffected SKUs and customers. Owner: Talia Brooks; due 2026-09-23.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_corporate/002_corporate_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/02_capitalization/014_capitalization_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/04_debt_security/026_debt_security_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/05_employment/038_employment_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/12_financials/097_bracken_home_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-007-04 — financial covenant breach (critical)\n\nthe controlling threshold is 7% under CB-MA-2407-R658; the independently calculated result is 13% under CB-MA-2407-E556. Identity resolves to ENT-007-1003, revision REV-2025.4 is current, and Farah Ibrahim is active with capacity 5.\n\nAction: Create exact closing-protection rows while preserving unaffected SKUs and customers. Owner: Farah Ibrahim; due 2026-09-21.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_corporate/004_corporate_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/02_capitalization/016_capitalization_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/04_debt_security/028_debt_security_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/05_employment/040_employment_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/12_financials/097_bracken_home_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-007-05 — permit transfer restriction (medium)\n\napproval must come from Nadine Flores under CB-MA-2407-R756; the effective approval record names Caleb Hassan under CB-MA-2407-E297. Identity resolves to ENT-007-1004, revision REV-2025.5 is current, and Dominic Alvarez is active with capacity 5.\n\nAction: Create exact closing-protection rows while preserving unaffected SKUs and customers. Owner: Dominic Alvarez; due 2026-09-20.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_corporate/005_corporate_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/017_material_contracts_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/04_debt_security/029_debt_security_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/041_ip_technology_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/07_privacy_security/053_privacy_security_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/12_financials/097_bracken_home_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-007-06 — revenue recognition exception (medium)\n\nthe controlled population contains 137 records under CB-MA-2407-R745; the certification covers 128 records under CB-MA-2407-E243. Identity resolves to ENT-007-1005, revision REV-2025.6 is current, and Leona Park is active with capacity 1.\n\nAction: Create exact closing-protection rows while preserving unaffected SKUs and customers. Owner: Leona Park; due 2026-09-19.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_corporate/006_corporate_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/018_material_contracts_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/04_debt_security/030_debt_security_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/042_ip_technology_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/12_financials/097_bracken_home_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-007-07 — most-favored-customer exposure (critical)\n\nthe permission is limited to Franklin County, Ohio under CB-MA-2407-R475; the matched activity occurred in Ohio under CB-MA-2407-E227. Identity resolves to ENT-007-1006, revision REV-2025.7 is current, and Henry Cho is active with capacity 1.\n\nAction: Create exact closing-protection rows while preserving unaffected SKUs and customers. Owner: Henry Cho; due 2026-09-18.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_corporate/007_corporate_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/019_material_contracts_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/04_debt_security/031_debt_security_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/043_ip_technology_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/10_real_property/079_real_property_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/09_litigation/067_litigation_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/12_financials/097_bracken_home_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-007-08 — unreported security incident (high)\n\nthe operative cap is $3,682,000.00 under CB-MA-2407-R946; the matched ledger population totals $3,705,146.00 under CB-MA-2407-E996. Identity resolves to ENT-007-1007, revision REV-2025.1 is current, and Maya Ellison is active with capacity 3.\n\nAction: Create exact closing-protection rows while preserving unaffected SKUs and customers. Owner: Maya Ellison; due 2026-09-17.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_corporate/008_corporate_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/020_material_contracts_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/04_debt_security/032_debt_security_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/044_ip_technology_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/12_financials/097_bracken_home_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-007-11 — open-source copyleft exposure (medium)\n\ncompletion is required by 2026-01-31 under CB-MA-2407-R190; the current event record shows completion on 2026-03-13 under CB-MA-2407-E370. Identity resolves to ENT-007-1010, revision REV-2025.4 is current, and Owen Delgado is active with capacity 5.\n\nAction: Create exact closing-protection rows while preserving unaffected SKUs and customers. Owner: Owen Delgado; due 2026-09-23.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/02_capitalization/011_capitalization_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/023_material_contracts_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/05_employment/035_employment_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/047_ip_technology_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/11_tax_insurance/083_tax_insurance_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/12_financials/097_bracken_home_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-007-12 — sales-tax nexus gap (critical)\n\nthe controlling threshold is 5% under CB-MA-2407-R718; the independently calculated result is 9% under CB-MA-2407-E718. Identity resolves to ENT-007-1011, revision REV-2025.5 is current, and Priya Raman is active with capacity 2.\n\nAction: Create exact closing-protection rows while preserving unaffected SKUs and customers. Owner: Priya Raman; due 2026-09-22.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/02_capitalization/012_capitalization_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/024_material_contracts_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/05_employment/036_employment_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/048_ip_technology_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/08_regulatory/060_regulatory_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/12_financials/097_bracken_home_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n## Evidence holds\n\n- **CBP-007-03 — charter authorization mismatch**: two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key. Next evidence: an approved immutable entity crosswalk. Sources: `/workspace/documents/01_corporate/003_corporate_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/02_capitalization/015_capitalization_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/04_debt_security/027_debt_security_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/05_employment/039_employment_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/12_financials/097_bracken_home_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-007-09 — claims-made insurance tail**: the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective. Next evidence: effective approval and an active owner with remaining capacity. Sources: `/workspace/documents/02_capitalization/009_capitalization_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/021_material_contracts_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/05_employment/033_employment_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/045_ip_technology_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/12_financials/097_bracken_home_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-007-10 — anti-assignment restriction**: the operational record relies on a superseded control revision. Next evidence: an operational record using the current effective revision. Sources: `/workspace/documents/02_capitalization/010_capitalization_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/022_material_contracts_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/05_employment/034_employment_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/046_ip_technology_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/11_tax_insurance/082_tax_insurance_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/12_financials/097_bracken_home_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n## Alternatives considered\n\n- `bracken-home:shortcut` — Treat the new supplier and clean sales trend as curing the historical obligations.: Use a plausible summary or one source without completing the controlling joins.\n- `bracken-home:blanket-hold` — Freeze the entire matter population: Treat supported actions and genuinely ambiguous records as if they were equally unresolved.\n\n## Assumptions and limits\n\nThis decision is limited to cb100-007-bracken-home, the supplied synthetic records, and the matter state as of 2026-09-25. Similar names, stale revisions, and pending authority are not treated as proof.\n", "decision": {"actions": [{"determination": "delivery must use notices-bracken_home_brands@example.test under CB-MA-2407-R431; the only matched receipt used archive-hearth_reed_appliances_corp@example.test under CB-MA-2407-E913. Identity resolves to ENT-007-1000, revision REV-2025.1 is current, and Samuel Kim is active with capacity 5.", "due_date": "2026-09-24", "id": "ACT-CBP-007-01", "identity_id": "ENT-007-1000", "issue": "key-person retention gap", "owner": "Samuel Kim", "portfolio_key": "CBP-007-01", "recommended_action": "Create exact closing-protection rows while preserving unaffected SKUs and customers. Owner: Samuel Kim; due 2026-09-24.", "severity": "high", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_corporate/001_corporate_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/02_capitalization/013_capitalization_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/04_debt_security/025_debt_security_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/05_employment/037_employment_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/10_real_property/073_real_property_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/12_financials/097_bracken_home_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "an open exception blocks completion under CB-MA-2407-R760; the current status is open and unresolved under CB-MA-2407-E244. Identity resolves to ENT-007-1001, revision REV-2025.2 is current, and Talia Brooks is active with capacity 5.", "due_date": "2026-09-23", "id": "ACT-CBP-007-02", "identity_id": "ENT-007-1001", "issue": "threatened customer dispute", "owner": "Talia Brooks", "portfolio_key": "CBP-007-02", "recommended_action": "Create exact closing-protection rows while preserving unaffected SKUs and customers. Owner: Talia Brooks; due 2026-09-23.", "severity": "critical", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_corporate/002_corporate_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/02_capitalization/014_capitalization_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/04_debt_security/026_debt_security_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/05_employment/038_employment_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_financials/097_bracken_home_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "the controlling threshold is 7% under CB-MA-2407-R658; the independently calculated result is 13% under CB-MA-2407-E556. Identity resolves to ENT-007-1003, revision REV-2025.4 is current, and Farah Ibrahim is active with capacity 5.", "due_date": "2026-09-21", "id": "ACT-CBP-007-04", "identity_id": "ENT-007-1003", "issue": "financial covenant breach", "owner": "Farah Ibrahim", "portfolio_key": "CBP-007-04", "recommended_action": "Create exact closing-protection rows while preserving unaffected SKUs and customers. Owner: Farah Ibrahim; due 2026-09-21.", "severity": "critical", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_corporate/004_corporate_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/02_capitalization/016_capitalization_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/04_debt_security/028_debt_security_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/05_employment/040_employment_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_financials/097_bracken_home_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "approval must come from Nadine Flores under CB-MA-2407-R756; the effective approval record names Caleb Hassan under CB-MA-2407-E297. Identity resolves to ENT-007-1004, revision REV-2025.5 is current, and Dominic Alvarez is active with capacity 5.", "due_date": "2026-09-20", "id": "ACT-CBP-007-05", "identity_id": "ENT-007-1004", "issue": "permit transfer restriction", "owner": "Dominic Alvarez", "portfolio_key": "CBP-007-05", "recommended_action": "Create exact closing-protection rows while preserving unaffected SKUs and customers. Owner: Dominic Alvarez; due 2026-09-20.", "severity": "medium", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_corporate/005_corporate_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/017_material_contracts_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/04_debt_security/029_debt_security_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/041_ip_technology_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/07_privacy_security/053_privacy_security_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_financials/097_bracken_home_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "the controlled population contains 137 records under CB-MA-2407-R745; the certification covers 128 records under CB-MA-2407-E243. Identity resolves to ENT-007-1005, revision REV-2025.6 is current, and Leona Park is active with capacity 1.", "due_date": "2026-09-19", "id": "ACT-CBP-007-06", "identity_id": "ENT-007-1005", "issue": "revenue recognition exception", "owner": "Leona Park", "portfolio_key": "CBP-007-06", "recommended_action": "Create exact closing-protection rows while preserving unaffected SKUs and customers. Owner: Leona Park; due 2026-09-19.", "severity": "medium", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_corporate/006_corporate_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/018_material_contracts_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/04_debt_security/030_debt_security_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/042_ip_technology_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/12_financials/097_bracken_home_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "the permission is limited to Franklin County, Ohio under CB-MA-2407-R475; the matched activity occurred in Ohio under CB-MA-2407-E227. Identity resolves to ENT-007-1006, revision REV-2025.7 is current, and Henry Cho is active with capacity 1.", "due_date": "2026-09-18", "id": "ACT-CBP-007-07", "identity_id": "ENT-007-1006", "issue": "most-favored-customer exposure", "owner": "Henry Cho", "portfolio_key": "CBP-007-07", "recommended_action": "Create exact closing-protection rows while preserving unaffected SKUs and customers. Owner: Henry Cho; due 2026-09-18.", "severity": "critical", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_corporate/007_corporate_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/019_material_contracts_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/04_debt_security/031_debt_security_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/043_ip_technology_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/10_real_property/079_real_property_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/09_litigation/067_litigation_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/12_financials/097_bracken_home_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "the operative cap is $3,682,000.00 under CB-MA-2407-R946; the matched ledger population totals $3,705,146.00 under CB-MA-2407-E996. Identity resolves to ENT-007-1007, revision REV-2025.1 is current, and Maya Ellison is active with capacity 3.", "due_date": "2026-09-17", "id": "ACT-CBP-007-08", "identity_id": "ENT-007-1007", "issue": "unreported security incident", "owner": "Maya Ellison", "portfolio_key": "CBP-007-08", "recommended_action": "Create exact closing-protection rows while preserving unaffected SKUs and customers. Owner: Maya Ellison; due 2026-09-17.", "severity": "high", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_corporate/008_corporate_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/020_material_contracts_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/04_debt_security/032_debt_security_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/044_ip_technology_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/12_financials/097_bracken_home_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "completion is required by 2026-01-31 under CB-MA-2407-R190; the current event record shows completion on 2026-03-13 under CB-MA-2407-E370. Identity resolves to ENT-007-1010, revision REV-2025.4 is current, and Owen Delgado is active with capacity 5.", "due_date": "2026-09-23", "id": "ACT-CBP-007-11", "identity_id": "ENT-007-1010", "issue": "open-source copyleft exposure", "owner": "Owen Delgado", "portfolio_key": "CBP-007-11", "recommended_action": "Create exact closing-protection rows while preserving unaffected SKUs and customers. Owner: Owen Delgado; due 2026-09-23.", "severity": "medium", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_capitalization/011_capitalization_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/023_material_contracts_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/05_employment/035_employment_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/047_ip_technology_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/11_tax_insurance/083_tax_insurance_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/12_financials/097_bracken_home_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "the controlling threshold is 5% under CB-MA-2407-R718; the independently calculated result is 9% under CB-MA-2407-E718. Identity resolves to ENT-007-1011, revision REV-2025.5 is current, and Priya Raman is active with capacity 2.", "due_date": "2026-09-22", "id": "ACT-CBP-007-12", "identity_id": "ENT-007-1011", "issue": "sales-tax nexus gap", "owner": "Priya Raman", "portfolio_key": "CBP-007-12", "recommended_action": "Create exact closing-protection rows while preserving unaffected SKUs and customers. Owner: Priya Raman; due 2026-09-22.", "severity": "critical", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_capitalization/012_capitalization_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/024_material_contracts_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/05_employment/036_employment_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/048_ip_technology_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/08_regulatory/060_regulatory_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/12_financials/097_bracken_home_impact_population.xlsx"]}], "as_of": "2026-09-25", "decision": {"alternatives_considered": ["bracken-home:shortcut", "bracken-home:blanket-hold"], "question": "Can Hearth close with the supplier change and recall history, and what protection is needed for inventory and retailer parity?", "rationale": "The four-part causal test supports 9 scoped actions and leaves 3 records on evidence hold. Current recall scope, perfected collateral records, and executed pricing terms govern.", "recommendation": "Proceed with item-specific release, reserve, or pricing protection where all evidence joins.", "selected_option_id": "bracken-home:scoped-evidence"}, "holds": [{"id": "HOLD-CBP-007-03", "issue": "charter authorization mismatch", "portfolio_key": "CBP-007-03", "reason": "two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key", "required_next_evidence": "an approved immutable entity crosswalk", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_corporate/003_corporate_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/02_capitalization/015_capitalization_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/04_debt_security/027_debt_security_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/05_employment/039_employment_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_financials/097_bracken_home_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-007-09", "issue": "claims-made insurance tail", "portfolio_key": "CBP-007-09", "reason": "the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective", "required_next_evidence": "effective approval and an active owner with remaining capacity", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_capitalization/009_capitalization_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/021_material_contracts_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/05_employment/033_employment_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/045_ip_technology_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_financials/097_bracken_home_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-007-10", "issue": "anti-assignment restriction", "portfolio_key": "CBP-007-10", "reason": "the operational record relies on a superseded control revision", "required_next_evidence": "an operational record using the current effective revision", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_capitalization/010_capitalization_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/022_material_contracts_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/05_employment/034_employment_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/046_ip_technology_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/11_tax_insurance/082_tax_insurance_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/12_financials/097_bracken_home_impact_population.xlsx"]}], "matter_number": "CB-MA-2407", "prepared_for": "Bracken Home Brands", "schema_version": "counselbench.decision.v3", "task_id": "cb100-007-bracken-home"}, "matter_register": {"matter_number": "CB-MA-2407", "rows": [{"decision_option_id": "bracken-home:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-24", "issue": "key-person retention gap", "matter_number": "CB-MA-2407", "owner": "Samuel Kim", "portfolio_key": "CBP-007-01", "row_id": "REG-CBP-007-01", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_corporate/001_corporate_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/02_capitalization/013_capitalization_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/04_debt_security/025_debt_security_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/05_employment/037_employment_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/10_real_property/073_real_property_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/12_financials/097_bracken_home_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "bracken-home:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-23", "issue": "threatened customer dispute", "matter_number": "CB-MA-2407", "owner": "Talia Brooks", "portfolio_key": "CBP-007-02", "row_id": "REG-CBP-007-02", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_corporate/002_corporate_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/02_capitalization/014_capitalization_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/04_debt_security/026_debt_security_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/05_employment/038_employment_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_financials/097_bracken_home_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "bracken-home:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key", "issue": "charter authorization mismatch", "matter_number": "CB-MA-2407", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-007-03", "row_id": "REG-CBP-007-03", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_corporate/003_corporate_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/02_capitalization/015_capitalization_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/04_debt_security/027_debt_security_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/05_employment/039_employment_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_financials/097_bracken_home_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "bracken-home:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-21", "issue": "financial covenant breach", "matter_number": "CB-MA-2407", "owner": "Farah Ibrahim", "portfolio_key": "CBP-007-04", "row_id": "REG-CBP-007-04", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_corporate/004_corporate_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/02_capitalization/016_capitalization_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/04_debt_security/028_debt_security_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/05_employment/040_employment_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_financials/097_bracken_home_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "bracken-home:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-20", "issue": "permit transfer restriction", "matter_number": "CB-MA-2407", "owner": "Dominic Alvarez", "portfolio_key": "CBP-007-05", "row_id": "REG-CBP-007-05", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_corporate/005_corporate_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/017_material_contracts_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/04_debt_security/029_debt_security_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/041_ip_technology_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/07_privacy_security/053_privacy_security_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_financials/097_bracken_home_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "bracken-home:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-19", "issue": "revenue recognition exception", "matter_number": "CB-MA-2407", "owner": "Leona Park", "portfolio_key": "CBP-007-06", "row_id": "REG-CBP-007-06", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_corporate/006_corporate_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/018_material_contracts_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/04_debt_security/030_debt_security_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/042_ip_technology_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/12_financials/097_bracken_home_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "bracken-home:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-18", "issue": "most-favored-customer exposure", "matter_number": "CB-MA-2407", "owner": "Henry Cho", "portfolio_key": "CBP-007-07", "row_id": "REG-CBP-007-07", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_corporate/007_corporate_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/019_material_contracts_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/04_debt_security/031_debt_security_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/043_ip_technology_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/10_real_property/079_real_property_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/09_litigation/067_litigation_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/12_financials/097_bracken_home_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "bracken-home:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-17", "issue": "unreported security incident", "matter_number": "CB-MA-2407", "owner": "Maya Ellison", "portfolio_key": "CBP-007-08", "row_id": "REG-CBP-007-08", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_corporate/008_corporate_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/020_material_contracts_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/04_debt_security/032_debt_security_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/044_ip_technology_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/12_financials/097_bracken_home_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "bracken-home:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective", "issue": "claims-made insurance tail", "matter_number": "CB-MA-2407", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-007-09", "row_id": "REG-CBP-007-09", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_capitalization/009_capitalization_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/021_material_contracts_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/05_employment/033_employment_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/045_ip_technology_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_financials/097_bracken_home_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "bracken-home:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "the operational record relies on a superseded control revision", "issue": "anti-assignment restriction", "matter_number": "CB-MA-2407", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-007-10", "row_id": "REG-CBP-007-10", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_capitalization/010_capitalization_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/022_material_contracts_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/05_employment/034_employment_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/046_ip_technology_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/11_tax_insurance/082_tax_insurance_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/12_financials/097_bracken_home_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "bracken-home:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-23", "issue": "open-source copyleft exposure", "matter_number": "CB-MA-2407", "owner": "Owen Delgado", "portfolio_key": "CBP-007-11", "row_id": "REG-CBP-007-11", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_capitalization/011_capitalization_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/023_material_contracts_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/05_employment/035_employment_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/047_ip_technology_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/11_tax_insurance/083_tax_insurance_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/12_financials/097_bracken_home_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "bracken-home:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-22", "issue": "sales-tax nexus gap", "matter_number": "CB-MA-2407", "owner": "Priya Raman", "portfolio_key": "CBP-007-12", "row_id": "REG-CBP-007-12", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_capitalization/012_capitalization_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/024_material_contracts_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/05_employment/036_employment_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/048_ip_technology_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/08_regulatory/060_regulatory_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/12_financials/097_bracken_home_impact_population.xlsx"]}], "schema_version": "counselbench.matter-register.v3", "task_id": "cb100-007-bracken-home"}}, "metadata": {"benchmark": "CounselBench-100", "code_license": "Apache-2.0", "data_license": "CC-BY-4.0", "deadline": "2026-09-25", "document_count": 97, "evidence_holds": 3, "jurisdiction": "Ohio", "matter_number": "CB-MA-2407", "mcp_commit": "9a96ea6e5913736f92b88345bf51caeaaa8e719f", "mcp_package": "@modelcontextprotocol/server-filesystem@2026.7.10", "practice_area": "corporate-ma", "reference_tool_calls": 77, "required_evidence_reads": 57, "supported_actions": 9, "synthetic": true, "venue": "Franklin County, Ohio", "version": "3.1.0"}, "prompt": "The other side has challenged our internal account of the facts. Can Hearth close with the supplier change and recall history, and what protection is needed for inventory and retailer parity? A connected-appliance company changed component suppliers after a recall, pledged inventory under a revolver, and promised one retailer price parity. The team needs the call by 2026-09-25. Leave a concise decision record with exact source references and an owner for each supported next step.", "rubric": {"criteria": [{"category": "investigation", "description": "Inventory the production and use targeted searches to locate records across native formats.", "id": "investigation.discover_production"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Complete every task-specific identity, authority, operations, and approval read before the first state transition.", "id": "investigation.read_before_write"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Inspect designated source metadata before relying on those records.", "id": "investigation.custody_before_write"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "Select the supported option 'bracken-home:scoped-evidence' after applying the four-part test.", "id": "decision.selected_option"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "Identify both rejected approaches and explain why a one-source shortcut and a blanket hold are wrong.", "id": "decision.alternatives"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-007-01 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_corporate/001_corporate_source_export.md rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-007-01.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_capitalization/013_capitalization_source_export.json for key-person retention gap.", "id": "investigation.CBP-007-01.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_debt_security/025_debt_security_source_export.md to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-007-01.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_employment/037_employment_source_export.json.", "id": "investigation.CBP-007-01.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-007-01 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-007-01.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-007-01 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-007-01.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-007-02 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_corporate/002_corporate_source_export.txt rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-007-02.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_capitalization/014_capitalization_source_export.xml for threatened customer dispute.", "id": "investigation.CBP-007-02.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_debt_security/026_debt_security_source_export.txt to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-007-02.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_employment/038_employment_source_export.xml.", "id": "investigation.CBP-007-02.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-007-02 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-007-02.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-007-02 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-007-02.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-007-03 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_corporate/003_corporate_source_export.eml rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-007-03.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_capitalization/015_capitalization_source_export.html for charter authorization mismatch.", "id": "investigation.CBP-007-03.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_debt_security/027_debt_security_source_export.eml to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-007-03.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_employment/039_employment_source_export.html.", "id": "investigation.CBP-007-03.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-007-03 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key.", "id": "decision.CBP-007-03.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-007-03 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-007-03.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-007-04 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_corporate/004_corporate_source_export.csv rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-007-04.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_capitalization/016_capitalization_source_export.pdf for financial covenant breach.", "id": "investigation.CBP-007-04.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_debt_security/028_debt_security_source_export.csv to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-007-04.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_employment/040_employment_source_export.pdf.", "id": "investigation.CBP-007-04.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-007-04 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-007-04.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-007-04 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-007-04.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-007-05 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_corporate/005_corporate_source_export.json rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-007-05.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/017_material_contracts_source_export.md for permit transfer restriction.", "id": "investigation.CBP-007-05.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_debt_security/029_debt_security_source_export.json to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-007-05.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/041_ip_technology_source_export.md.", "id": "investigation.CBP-007-05.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-007-05 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-007-05.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-007-05 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-007-05.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-007-06 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_corporate/006_corporate_source_export.xml rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-007-06.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/018_material_contracts_source_export.txt for revenue recognition exception.", "id": "investigation.CBP-007-06.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_debt_security/030_debt_security_source_export.xml to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-007-06.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/042_ip_technology_source_export.txt.", "id": "investigation.CBP-007-06.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-007-06 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-007-06.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-007-06 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-007-06.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-007-07 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_corporate/007_corporate_source_export.html rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-007-07.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/019_material_contracts_source_export.eml for most-favored-customer exposure.", "id": "investigation.CBP-007-07.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_debt_security/031_debt_security_source_export.html to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-007-07.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/043_ip_technology_source_export.eml.", "id": "investigation.CBP-007-07.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-007-07 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-007-07.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-007-07 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-007-07.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-007-08 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_corporate/008_corporate_source_export.pdf rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-007-08.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/020_material_contracts_source_export.csv for unreported security incident.", "id": "investigation.CBP-007-08.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_debt_security/032_debt_security_source_export.pdf to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-007-08.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/044_ip_technology_source_export.csv.", "id": "investigation.CBP-007-08.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-007-08 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-007-08.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-007-08 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-007-08.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-007-09 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_capitalization/009_capitalization_source_export.md rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-007-09.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/021_material_contracts_source_export.json for claims-made insurance tail.", "id": "investigation.CBP-007-09.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_employment/033_employment_source_export.md to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-007-09.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/045_ip_technology_source_export.json.", "id": "investigation.CBP-007-09.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-007-09 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective.", "id": "decision.CBP-007-09.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-007-09 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-007-09.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-007-10 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_capitalization/010_capitalization_source_export.txt rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-007-10.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/022_material_contracts_source_export.xml for anti-assignment restriction.", "id": "investigation.CBP-007-10.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_employment/034_employment_source_export.txt to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-007-10.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/046_ip_technology_source_export.xml.", "id": "investigation.CBP-007-10.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-007-10 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is the operational record relies on a superseded control revision.", "id": "decision.CBP-007-10.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-007-10 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-007-10.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-007-11 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_capitalization/011_capitalization_source_export.eml rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-007-11.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/023_material_contracts_source_export.html for open-source copyleft exposure.", "id": "investigation.CBP-007-11.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_employment/035_employment_source_export.eml to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-007-11.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/047_ip_technology_source_export.html.", "id": "investigation.CBP-007-11.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-007-11 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-007-11.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-007-11 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-007-11.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-007-12 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_capitalization/012_capitalization_source_export.csv rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-007-12.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/024_material_contracts_source_export.pdf for sales-tax nexus gap.", "id": "investigation.CBP-007-12.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_employment/036_employment_source_export.csv to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-007-12.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/048_ip_technology_source_export.pdf.", "id": "investigation.CBP-007-12.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-007-12 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-007-12.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-007-12 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-007-12.register"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Write the exact selected option, supported action population, evidence-hold population, facts, owners, deadlines, and citations.", "id": "state.exact_decision"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create one exact register row per portfolio key with no extra, missing, or modified row.", "id": "state.exact_register"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Leave only the three approved deliverables and perform no extra state-changing write.", "id": "state.write_scope_containment"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Read back decision.json, matter-register.json, and advice.md after their final writes.", "id": "state.postwrite_readback"}, {"category": "answer", "description": "Explain the selected recommendation, supported actions, holds, alternatives, and limitations with exact source anchors.", "id": "answer.decision_note"}], "decision_options": [{"approach": "Apply the exact identity, current-state, authority, and revision test. Create exact closing-protection rows while preserving unaffected SKUs and customers.", "id": "bracken-home:scoped-evidence", "label": "Proceed with item-specific release, reserve, or pricing protection where all evidence joins."}, {"approach": "Use a plausible summary or one source without completing the controlling joins.", "id": "bracken-home:shortcut", "label": "Treat the new supplier and clean sales trend as curing the historical obligations."}, {"approach": "Treat supported actions and genuinely ambiguous records as if they were equally unresolved.", "id": "bracken-home:blanket-hold", "label": "Freeze the entire matter population"}], "evaluation_narrative": {"authority": "Current recall scope, perfected collateral records, and executed pricing terms govern.", "observation": "Reconcile recalled components, pledged inventory, and parity commitments by SKU, lender, and customer ID.", "question": "Can Hearth close with the supplier change and recall history, and what protection is needed for inventory and retailer parity?", "register_action": "Create exact closing-protection rows while preserving unaffected SKUs and customers."}, "gates": ["all_required_evidence_precedes_first_write", "decision_criteria_complete", "register_state_exact", "write_scope_contained", "all_outputs_verified_by_readback"], "metadata_checks": 4, "metric": "weighted_criteria_score", "minimum_tool_calls": 77, "required_deliverables": ["decision.json", "matter-register.json", "advice.md"], "required_document_reads": 57, "type": "deterministic", "weights": {"advice": 0.15, "decision": 0.35, "investigation": 0.25, "state": 0.25}}, "task_id": "cb100-007-bracken-home", "task_name": "Project Hearth consumer products merger", "world_id": "counselbench-filesystem-mcp-v3"}
+{"context_files": ["task_files/cb100-008-cobalt-learning/01_corporate/001_corporate_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-008-cobalt-learning/01_corporate/002_corporate_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-008-cobalt-learning/01_corporate/003_corporate_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-008-cobalt-learning/01_corporate/004_corporate_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-008-cobalt-learning/01_corporate/005_corporate_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-008-cobalt-learning/01_corporate/006_corporate_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-008-cobalt-learning/01_corporate/007_corporate_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-008-cobalt-learning/01_corporate/008_corporate_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-008-cobalt-learning/02_capitalization/009_capitalization_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-008-cobalt-learning/02_capitalization/010_capitalization_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-008-cobalt-learning/02_capitalization/011_capitalization_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-008-cobalt-learning/02_capitalization/012_capitalization_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-008-cobalt-learning/02_capitalization/013_capitalization_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-008-cobalt-learning/02_capitalization/014_capitalization_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-008-cobalt-learning/02_capitalization/015_capitalization_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-008-cobalt-learning/02_capitalization/016_capitalization_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-008-cobalt-learning/03_material_contracts/017_material_contracts_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-008-cobalt-learning/03_material_contracts/018_material_contracts_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-008-cobalt-learning/03_material_contracts/019_material_contracts_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-008-cobalt-learning/03_material_contracts/020_material_contracts_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-008-cobalt-learning/03_material_contracts/021_material_contracts_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-008-cobalt-learning/03_material_contracts/022_material_contracts_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-008-cobalt-learning/03_material_contracts/023_material_contracts_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-008-cobalt-learning/03_material_contracts/024_material_contracts_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-008-cobalt-learning/04_debt_security/025_debt_security_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-008-cobalt-learning/04_debt_security/026_debt_security_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-008-cobalt-learning/04_debt_security/027_debt_security_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-008-cobalt-learning/04_debt_security/028_debt_security_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-008-cobalt-learning/04_debt_security/029_debt_security_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-008-cobalt-learning/04_debt_security/030_debt_security_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-008-cobalt-learning/04_debt_security/031_debt_security_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-008-cobalt-learning/04_debt_security/032_debt_security_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-008-cobalt-learning/05_employment/033_employment_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-008-cobalt-learning/05_employment/034_employment_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-008-cobalt-learning/05_employment/035_employment_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-008-cobalt-learning/05_employment/036_employment_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-008-cobalt-learning/05_employment/037_employment_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-008-cobalt-learning/05_employment/038_employment_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-008-cobalt-learning/05_employment/039_employment_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-008-cobalt-learning/05_employment/040_employment_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-008-cobalt-learning/06_ip_technology/041_ip_technology_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-008-cobalt-learning/06_ip_technology/042_ip_technology_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-008-cobalt-learning/06_ip_technology/043_ip_technology_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-008-cobalt-learning/06_ip_technology/044_ip_technology_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-008-cobalt-learning/06_ip_technology/045_ip_technology_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-008-cobalt-learning/06_ip_technology/046_ip_technology_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-008-cobalt-learning/06_ip_technology/047_ip_technology_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-008-cobalt-learning/06_ip_technology/048_ip_technology_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-008-cobalt-learning/07_privacy_security/049_privacy_security_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-008-cobalt-learning/07_privacy_security/050_privacy_security_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-008-cobalt-learning/07_privacy_security/051_privacy_security_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-008-cobalt-learning/07_privacy_security/052_privacy_security_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-008-cobalt-learning/07_privacy_security/053_privacy_security_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-008-cobalt-learning/07_privacy_security/054_privacy_security_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-008-cobalt-learning/07_privacy_security/055_privacy_security_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-008-cobalt-learning/07_privacy_security/056_privacy_security_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-008-cobalt-learning/08_regulatory/057_regulatory_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-008-cobalt-learning/08_regulatory/058_regulatory_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-008-cobalt-learning/08_regulatory/059_regulatory_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-008-cobalt-learning/08_regulatory/060_regulatory_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-008-cobalt-learning/08_regulatory/061_regulatory_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-008-cobalt-learning/08_regulatory/062_regulatory_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-008-cobalt-learning/08_regulatory/063_regulatory_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-008-cobalt-learning/08_regulatory/064_regulatory_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-008-cobalt-learning/09_litigation/065_litigation_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-008-cobalt-learning/09_litigation/066_litigation_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-008-cobalt-learning/09_litigation/067_litigation_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-008-cobalt-learning/09_litigation/068_litigation_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-008-cobalt-learning/09_litigation/069_litigation_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-008-cobalt-learning/09_litigation/070_litigation_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-008-cobalt-learning/09_litigation/071_litigation_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-008-cobalt-learning/09_litigation/072_litigation_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-008-cobalt-learning/10_real_property/073_real_property_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-008-cobalt-learning/10_real_property/074_real_property_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-008-cobalt-learning/10_real_property/075_real_property_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-008-cobalt-learning/10_real_property/076_real_property_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-008-cobalt-learning/10_real_property/077_real_property_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-008-cobalt-learning/10_real_property/078_real_property_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-008-cobalt-learning/10_real_property/079_real_property_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-008-cobalt-learning/10_real_property/080_real_property_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-008-cobalt-learning/11_tax_insurance/081_tax_insurance_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-008-cobalt-learning/11_tax_insurance/082_tax_insurance_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-008-cobalt-learning/11_tax_insurance/083_tax_insurance_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-008-cobalt-learning/11_tax_insurance/084_tax_insurance_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-008-cobalt-learning/11_tax_insurance/085_tax_insurance_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-008-cobalt-learning/11_tax_insurance/086_tax_insurance_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-008-cobalt-learning/11_tax_insurance/087_tax_insurance_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-008-cobalt-learning/11_tax_insurance/088_tax_insurance_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-008-cobalt-learning/12_financials/089_financials_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-008-cobalt-learning/12_financials/090_financials_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-008-cobalt-learning/12_financials/091_financials_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-008-cobalt-learning/12_financials/092_financials_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-008-cobalt-learning/12_financials/093_financials_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-008-cobalt-learning/12_financials/094_financials_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-008-cobalt-learning/12_financials/095_financials_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-008-cobalt-learning/12_financials/096_financials_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-008-cobalt-learning/12_financials/097_cobalt_learning_impact_population.xlsx"], "gold_output": {"advice_markdown": "# Decision note — Project Chalkboard education platform purchase\n\n## Recommendation\n\nRequire the supported consent, capitalization correction, or data-use restriction before close. The reconciled record supports 7 scoped actions and leaves 5 items on evidence hold.\n\nSelected option: `cobalt-learning:scoped-evidence`.\n\n## Why this is the supported option\n\nMatch data flows, licensed content, and warrant grants to immutable product, school, and holder records. Student-data commitments, sublicense limits, and valid grant approvals determine the cap table and transfer scope.\n\n## Supported actions\n\n### CBP-008-01 — invention assignment defect (high)\n\nthe controlled population contains 92 records under CB-MA-2408-R270; the certification covers 57 records under CB-MA-2408-E851. Identity resolves to ENT-008-1000, revision REV-2026.1 is current, and Nora Chen is active with capacity 1.\n\nAction: Write only evidence-backed cap-table and rights exceptions with explicit unresolved holds. Owner: Nora Chen; due 2026-09-28.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_corporate/001_corporate_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/02_capitalization/013_capitalization_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/04_debt_security/025_debt_security_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/05_employment/037_employment_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/12_financials/097_cobalt_learning_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-008-02 — facility title exception (medium)\n\nthe permission is limited to Suffolk County, Massachusetts under CB-MA-2408-R345; the matched activity occurred in Massachusetts under CB-MA-2408-E855. Identity resolves to ENT-008-1001, revision REV-2026.2 is current, and Caleb Hassan is active with capacity 4.\n\nAction: Write only evidence-backed cap-table and rights exceptions with explicit unresolved holds. Owner: Caleb Hassan; due 2026-09-27.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_corporate/002_corporate_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/02_capitalization/014_capitalization_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/04_debt_security/026_debt_security_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/05_employment/038_employment_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/12_financials/097_cobalt_learning_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-008-03 — unrecorded option grant (high)\n\nthe operative cap is $1,402,000.00 under CB-MA-2408-R288; the matched ledger population totals $1,470,688.00 under CB-MA-2408-E905. Identity resolves to ENT-008-1002, revision REV-2026.3 is current, and Amara Patel is active with capacity 3.\n\nAction: Write only evidence-backed cap-table and rights exceptions with explicit unresolved holds. Owner: Amara Patel; due 2026-09-26.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_corporate/003_corporate_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/02_capitalization/015_capitalization_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/04_debt_security/027_debt_security_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/05_employment/039_employment_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/10_real_property/075_real_property_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/12_financials/097_cobalt_learning_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-008-04 — key-person retention gap (high)\n\ndelivery must use notices-cobalt_learning_cooperative@example.test under CB-MA-2408-R880; the only matched receipt used archive-chalkboard_metrics_pbc@example.test under CB-MA-2408-E675. Identity resolves to ENT-008-1003, revision REV-2026.4 is current, and Samuel Kim is active with capacity 6.\n\nAction: Write only evidence-backed cap-table and rights exceptions with explicit unresolved holds. Owner: Samuel Kim; due 2026-09-25.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_corporate/004_corporate_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/02_capitalization/016_capitalization_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/04_debt_security/028_debt_security_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/05_employment/040_employment_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/08_regulatory/064_regulatory_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/12_financials/097_cobalt_learning_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-008-09 — revenue recognition exception (medium)\n\nthe controlled population contains 133 records under CB-MA-2408-R431; the certification covers 124 records under CB-MA-2408-E913. Identity resolves to ENT-008-1008, revision REV-2026.2 is current, and Leona Park is active with capacity 6.\n\nAction: Write only evidence-backed cap-table and rights exceptions with explicit unresolved holds. Owner: Leona Park; due 2026-09-20.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/02_capitalization/009_capitalization_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/021_material_contracts_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/05_employment/033_employment_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/045_ip_technology_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/12_financials/097_cobalt_learning_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-008-10 — most-favored-customer exposure (medium)\n\nthe permission is limited to Suffolk County, Massachusetts under CB-MA-2408-R819; the matched activity occurred in Massachusetts under CB-MA-2408-E407. Identity resolves to ENT-008-1009, revision REV-2026.3 is current, and Henry Cho is active with capacity 3.\n\nAction: Write only evidence-backed cap-table and rights exceptions with explicit unresolved holds. Owner: Henry Cho; due 2026-09-28.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/02_capitalization/010_capitalization_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/022_material_contracts_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/05_employment/034_employment_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/046_ip_technology_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/12_financials/097_cobalt_learning_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-008-12 — claims-made insurance tail (high)\n\ndelivery must use notices-cobalt_learning_cooperative@example.test under CB-MA-2408-R460; the only matched receipt used archive-chalkboard_metrics_pbc@example.test under CB-MA-2408-E915. Identity resolves to ENT-008-1011, revision REV-2026.5 is current, and Jonas Feld is active with capacity 4.\n\nAction: Write only evidence-backed cap-table and rights exceptions with explicit unresolved holds. Owner: Jonas Feld; due 2026-09-26.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/02_capitalization/012_capitalization_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/024_material_contracts_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/05_employment/036_employment_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/048_ip_technology_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/08_regulatory/060_regulatory_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/09_litigation/072_litigation_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/12_financials/097_cobalt_learning_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n## Evidence holds\n\n- **CBP-008-05 — threatened customer dispute**: the operational record relies on a superseded control revision. Next evidence: an operational record using the current effective revision. Sources: `/workspace/documents/01_corporate/005_corporate_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/017_material_contracts_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/04_debt_security/029_debt_security_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/041_ip_technology_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/09_litigation/065_litigation_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/12_financials/097_cobalt_learning_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-008-06 — charter authorization mismatch**: two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key. Next evidence: an approved immutable entity crosswalk. Sources: `/workspace/documents/01_corporate/006_corporate_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/018_material_contracts_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/04_debt_security/030_debt_security_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/042_ip_technology_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/12_financials/097_cobalt_learning_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-008-07 — financial covenant breach**: the current observation does not meet the operative trigger. Next evidence: a current observation that satisfies the operative trigger. Sources: `/workspace/documents/01_corporate/007_corporate_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/019_material_contracts_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/04_debt_security/031_debt_security_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/043_ip_technology_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/12_financials/097_cobalt_learning_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-008-08 — permit transfer restriction**: the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective. Next evidence: effective approval and an active owner with remaining capacity. Sources: `/workspace/documents/01_corporate/008_corporate_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/020_material_contracts_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/04_debt_security/032_debt_security_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/044_ip_technology_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/09_litigation/068_litigation_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/12_financials/097_cobalt_learning_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-008-11 — unreported security incident**: the current observation does not meet the operative trigger. Next evidence: a current observation that satisfies the operative trigger. Sources: `/workspace/documents/02_capitalization/011_capitalization_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/023_material_contracts_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/05_employment/035_employment_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/047_ip_technology_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/08_regulatory/059_regulatory_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/12_financials/097_cobalt_learning_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n## Alternatives considered\n\n- `cobalt-learning:shortcut` — Use the formal cap table and product catalog without checking side records.: Use a plausible summary or one source without completing the controlling joins.\n- `cobalt-learning:blanket-hold` — Freeze the entire matter population: Treat supported actions and genuinely ambiguous records as if they were equally unresolved.\n\n## Assumptions and limits\n\nThis decision is limited to cb100-008-cobalt-learning, the supplied synthetic records, and the matter state as of 2026-09-29. Similar names, stale revisions, and pending authority are not treated as proof.\n", "decision": {"actions": [{"determination": "the controlled population contains 92 records under CB-MA-2408-R270; the certification covers 57 records under CB-MA-2408-E851. Identity resolves to ENT-008-1000, revision REV-2026.1 is current, and Nora Chen is active with capacity 1.", "due_date": "2026-09-28", "id": "ACT-CBP-008-01", "identity_id": "ENT-008-1000", "issue": "invention assignment defect", "owner": "Nora Chen", "portfolio_key": "CBP-008-01", "recommended_action": "Write only evidence-backed cap-table and rights exceptions with explicit unresolved holds. Owner: Nora Chen; due 2026-09-28.", "severity": "high", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_corporate/001_corporate_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/02_capitalization/013_capitalization_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/04_debt_security/025_debt_security_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/05_employment/037_employment_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_financials/097_cobalt_learning_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "the permission is limited to Suffolk County, Massachusetts under CB-MA-2408-R345; the matched activity occurred in Massachusetts under CB-MA-2408-E855. Identity resolves to ENT-008-1001, revision REV-2026.2 is current, and Caleb Hassan is active with capacity 4.", "due_date": "2026-09-27", "id": "ACT-CBP-008-02", "identity_id": "ENT-008-1001", "issue": "facility title exception", "owner": "Caleb Hassan", "portfolio_key": "CBP-008-02", "recommended_action": "Write only evidence-backed cap-table and rights exceptions with explicit unresolved holds. Owner: Caleb Hassan; due 2026-09-27.", "severity": "medium", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_corporate/002_corporate_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/02_capitalization/014_capitalization_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/04_debt_security/026_debt_security_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/05_employment/038_employment_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_financials/097_cobalt_learning_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "the operative cap is $1,402,000.00 under CB-MA-2408-R288; the matched ledger population totals $1,470,688.00 under CB-MA-2408-E905. Identity resolves to ENT-008-1002, revision REV-2026.3 is current, and Amara Patel is active with capacity 3.", "due_date": "2026-09-26", "id": "ACT-CBP-008-03", "identity_id": "ENT-008-1002", "issue": "unrecorded option grant", "owner": "Amara Patel", "portfolio_key": "CBP-008-03", "recommended_action": "Write only evidence-backed cap-table and rights exceptions with explicit unresolved holds. Owner: Amara Patel; due 2026-09-26.", "severity": "high", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_corporate/003_corporate_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/02_capitalization/015_capitalization_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/04_debt_security/027_debt_security_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/05_employment/039_employment_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/10_real_property/075_real_property_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/12_financials/097_cobalt_learning_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "delivery must use notices-cobalt_learning_cooperative@example.test under CB-MA-2408-R880; the only matched receipt used archive-chalkboard_metrics_pbc@example.test under CB-MA-2408-E675. Identity resolves to ENT-008-1003, revision REV-2026.4 is current, and Samuel Kim is active with capacity 6.", "due_date": "2026-09-25", "id": "ACT-CBP-008-04", "identity_id": "ENT-008-1003", "issue": "key-person retention gap", "owner": "Samuel Kim", "portfolio_key": "CBP-008-04", "recommended_action": "Write only evidence-backed cap-table and rights exceptions with explicit unresolved holds. Owner: Samuel Kim; due 2026-09-25.", "severity": "high", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_corporate/004_corporate_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/02_capitalization/016_capitalization_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/04_debt_security/028_debt_security_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/05_employment/040_employment_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/08_regulatory/064_regulatory_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_financials/097_cobalt_learning_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "the controlled population contains 133 records under CB-MA-2408-R431; the certification covers 124 records under CB-MA-2408-E913. Identity resolves to ENT-008-1008, revision REV-2026.2 is current, and Leona Park is active with capacity 6.", "due_date": "2026-09-20", "id": "ACT-CBP-008-09", "identity_id": "ENT-008-1008", "issue": "revenue recognition exception", "owner": "Leona Park", "portfolio_key": "CBP-008-09", "recommended_action": "Write only evidence-backed cap-table and rights exceptions with explicit unresolved holds. Owner: Leona Park; due 2026-09-20.", "severity": "medium", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_capitalization/009_capitalization_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/021_material_contracts_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/05_employment/033_employment_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/045_ip_technology_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_financials/097_cobalt_learning_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "the permission is limited to Suffolk County, Massachusetts under CB-MA-2408-R819; the matched activity occurred in Massachusetts under CB-MA-2408-E407. Identity resolves to ENT-008-1009, revision REV-2026.3 is current, and Henry Cho is active with capacity 3.", "due_date": "2026-09-28", "id": "ACT-CBP-008-10", "identity_id": "ENT-008-1009", "issue": "most-favored-customer exposure", "owner": "Henry Cho", "portfolio_key": "CBP-008-10", "recommended_action": "Write only evidence-backed cap-table and rights exceptions with explicit unresolved holds. Owner: Henry Cho; due 2026-09-28.", "severity": "medium", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_capitalization/010_capitalization_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/022_material_contracts_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/05_employment/034_employment_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/046_ip_technology_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_financials/097_cobalt_learning_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "delivery must use notices-cobalt_learning_cooperative@example.test under CB-MA-2408-R460; the only matched receipt used archive-chalkboard_metrics_pbc@example.test under CB-MA-2408-E915. Identity resolves to ENT-008-1011, revision REV-2026.5 is current, and Jonas Feld is active with capacity 4.", "due_date": "2026-09-26", "id": "ACT-CBP-008-12", "identity_id": "ENT-008-1011", "issue": "claims-made insurance tail", "owner": "Jonas Feld", "portfolio_key": "CBP-008-12", "recommended_action": "Write only evidence-backed cap-table and rights exceptions with explicit unresolved holds. Owner: Jonas Feld; due 2026-09-26.", "severity": "high", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_capitalization/012_capitalization_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/024_material_contracts_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/05_employment/036_employment_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/048_ip_technology_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/08_regulatory/060_regulatory_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/09_litigation/072_litigation_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_financials/097_cobalt_learning_impact_population.xlsx"]}], "as_of": "2026-09-29", "decision": {"alternatives_considered": ["cobalt-learning:shortcut", "cobalt-learning:blanket-hold"], "question": "What is the real closing exposure from school data, content sublicensing, and the missing advisor warrants?", "rationale": "The four-part causal test supports 7 scoped actions and leaves 5 records on evidence hold. Student-data commitments, sublicense limits, and valid grant approvals determine the cap table and transfer scope.", "recommendation": "Require the supported consent, capitalization correction, or data-use restriction before close.", "selected_option_id": "cobalt-learning:scoped-evidence"}, "holds": [{"id": "HOLD-CBP-008-05", "issue": "threatened customer dispute", "portfolio_key": "CBP-008-05", "reason": "the operational record relies on a superseded control revision", "required_next_evidence": "an operational record using the current effective revision", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_corporate/005_corporate_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/017_material_contracts_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/04_debt_security/029_debt_security_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/041_ip_technology_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/09_litigation/065_litigation_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/12_financials/097_cobalt_learning_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-008-06", "issue": "charter authorization mismatch", "portfolio_key": "CBP-008-06", "reason": "two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key", "required_next_evidence": "an approved immutable entity crosswalk", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_corporate/006_corporate_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/018_material_contracts_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/04_debt_security/030_debt_security_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/042_ip_technology_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/12_financials/097_cobalt_learning_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-008-07", "issue": "financial covenant breach", "portfolio_key": "CBP-008-07", "reason": "the current observation does not meet the operative trigger", "required_next_evidence": "a current observation that satisfies the operative trigger", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_corporate/007_corporate_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/019_material_contracts_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/04_debt_security/031_debt_security_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/043_ip_technology_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/12_financials/097_cobalt_learning_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-008-08", "issue": "permit transfer restriction", "portfolio_key": "CBP-008-08", "reason": "the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective", "required_next_evidence": "effective approval and an active owner with remaining capacity", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_corporate/008_corporate_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/020_material_contracts_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/04_debt_security/032_debt_security_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/044_ip_technology_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/09_litigation/068_litigation_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/12_financials/097_cobalt_learning_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-008-11", "issue": "unreported security incident", "portfolio_key": "CBP-008-11", "reason": "the current observation does not meet the operative trigger", "required_next_evidence": "a current observation that satisfies the operative trigger", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_capitalization/011_capitalization_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/023_material_contracts_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/05_employment/035_employment_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/047_ip_technology_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/08_regulatory/059_regulatory_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/12_financials/097_cobalt_learning_impact_population.xlsx"]}], "matter_number": "CB-MA-2408", "prepared_for": "Cobalt Learning Cooperative", "schema_version": "counselbench.decision.v3", "task_id": "cb100-008-cobalt-learning"}, "matter_register": {"matter_number": "CB-MA-2408", "rows": [{"decision_option_id": "cobalt-learning:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-28", "issue": "invention assignment defect", "matter_number": "CB-MA-2408", "owner": "Nora Chen", "portfolio_key": "CBP-008-01", "row_id": "REG-CBP-008-01", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_corporate/001_corporate_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/02_capitalization/013_capitalization_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/04_debt_security/025_debt_security_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/05_employment/037_employment_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_financials/097_cobalt_learning_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "cobalt-learning:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-27", "issue": "facility title exception", "matter_number": "CB-MA-2408", "owner": "Caleb Hassan", "portfolio_key": "CBP-008-02", "row_id": "REG-CBP-008-02", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_corporate/002_corporate_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/02_capitalization/014_capitalization_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/04_debt_security/026_debt_security_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/05_employment/038_employment_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_financials/097_cobalt_learning_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "cobalt-learning:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-26", "issue": "unrecorded option grant", "matter_number": "CB-MA-2408", "owner": "Amara Patel", "portfolio_key": "CBP-008-03", "row_id": "REG-CBP-008-03", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_corporate/003_corporate_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/02_capitalization/015_capitalization_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/04_debt_security/027_debt_security_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/05_employment/039_employment_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/10_real_property/075_real_property_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/12_financials/097_cobalt_learning_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "cobalt-learning:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-25", "issue": "key-person retention gap", "matter_number": "CB-MA-2408", "owner": "Samuel Kim", "portfolio_key": "CBP-008-04", "row_id": "REG-CBP-008-04", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_corporate/004_corporate_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/02_capitalization/016_capitalization_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/04_debt_security/028_debt_security_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/05_employment/040_employment_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/08_regulatory/064_regulatory_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_financials/097_cobalt_learning_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "cobalt-learning:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "the operational record relies on a superseded control revision", "issue": "threatened customer dispute", "matter_number": "CB-MA-2408", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-008-05", "row_id": "REG-CBP-008-05", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_corporate/005_corporate_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/017_material_contracts_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/04_debt_security/029_debt_security_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/041_ip_technology_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/09_litigation/065_litigation_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/12_financials/097_cobalt_learning_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "cobalt-learning:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key", "issue": "charter authorization mismatch", "matter_number": "CB-MA-2408", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-008-06", "row_id": "REG-CBP-008-06", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_corporate/006_corporate_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/018_material_contracts_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/04_debt_security/030_debt_security_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/042_ip_technology_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/12_financials/097_cobalt_learning_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "cobalt-learning:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "the current observation does not meet the operative trigger", "issue": "financial covenant breach", "matter_number": "CB-MA-2408", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-008-07", "row_id": "REG-CBP-008-07", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_corporate/007_corporate_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/019_material_contracts_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/04_debt_security/031_debt_security_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/043_ip_technology_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/12_financials/097_cobalt_learning_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "cobalt-learning:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective", "issue": "permit transfer restriction", "matter_number": "CB-MA-2408", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-008-08", "row_id": "REG-CBP-008-08", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_corporate/008_corporate_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/020_material_contracts_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/04_debt_security/032_debt_security_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/044_ip_technology_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/09_litigation/068_litigation_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/12_financials/097_cobalt_learning_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "cobalt-learning:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-20", "issue": "revenue recognition exception", "matter_number": "CB-MA-2408", "owner": "Leona Park", "portfolio_key": "CBP-008-09", "row_id": "REG-CBP-008-09", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_capitalization/009_capitalization_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/021_material_contracts_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/05_employment/033_employment_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/045_ip_technology_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_financials/097_cobalt_learning_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "cobalt-learning:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-28", "issue": "most-favored-customer exposure", "matter_number": "CB-MA-2408", "owner": "Henry Cho", "portfolio_key": "CBP-008-10", "row_id": "REG-CBP-008-10", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_capitalization/010_capitalization_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/022_material_contracts_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/05_employment/034_employment_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/046_ip_technology_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_financials/097_cobalt_learning_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "cobalt-learning:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "the current observation does not meet the operative trigger", "issue": "unreported security incident", "matter_number": "CB-MA-2408", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-008-11", "row_id": "REG-CBP-008-11", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_capitalization/011_capitalization_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/023_material_contracts_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/05_employment/035_employment_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/047_ip_technology_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/08_regulatory/059_regulatory_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/12_financials/097_cobalt_learning_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "cobalt-learning:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-26", "issue": "claims-made insurance tail", "matter_number": "CB-MA-2408", "owner": "Jonas Feld", "portfolio_key": "CBP-008-12", "row_id": "REG-CBP-008-12", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_capitalization/012_capitalization_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/024_material_contracts_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/05_employment/036_employment_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/048_ip_technology_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/08_regulatory/060_regulatory_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/09_litigation/072_litigation_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_financials/097_cobalt_learning_impact_population.xlsx"]}], "schema_version": "counselbench.matter-register.v3", "task_id": "cb100-008-cobalt-learning"}}, "metadata": {"benchmark": "CounselBench-100", "code_license": "Apache-2.0", "data_license": "CC-BY-4.0", "deadline": "2026-09-29", "document_count": 97, "evidence_holds": 5, "jurisdiction": "Massachusetts", "matter_number": "CB-MA-2408", "mcp_commit": "9a96ea6e5913736f92b88345bf51caeaaa8e719f", "mcp_package": "@modelcontextprotocol/server-filesystem@2026.7.10", "practice_area": "corporate-ma", "reference_tool_calls": 81, "required_evidence_reads": 57, "supported_actions": 7, "synthetic": true, "venue": "Suffolk County, Massachusetts", "version": "3.1.0"}, "prompt": "There is enough noise in this file that a name match or newest-document shortcut will be dangerous. What is the real closing exposure from school data, content sublicensing, and the missing advisor warrants? The target processes school records, sublicenses assessment content, and issued advisor warrants that never reached the formal capitalization schedule. The team needs the call by 2026-09-29. Leave the defensible result in the matter workspace, including any item that must stay on hold for better evidence.", "rubric": {"criteria": [{"category": "investigation", "description": "Inventory the production and use targeted searches to locate records across native formats.", "id": "investigation.discover_production"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Complete every task-specific identity, authority, operations, and approval read before the first state transition.", "id": "investigation.read_before_write"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Inspect designated source metadata before relying on those records.", "id": "investigation.custody_before_write"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "Select the supported option 'cobalt-learning:scoped-evidence' after applying the four-part test.", "id": "decision.selected_option"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "Identify both rejected approaches and explain why a one-source shortcut and a blanket hold are wrong.", "id": "decision.alternatives"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-008-01 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_corporate/001_corporate_source_export.md rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-008-01.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_capitalization/013_capitalization_source_export.json for invention assignment defect.", "id": "investigation.CBP-008-01.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_debt_security/025_debt_security_source_export.md to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-008-01.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_employment/037_employment_source_export.json.", "id": "investigation.CBP-008-01.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-008-01 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-008-01.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-008-01 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-008-01.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-008-02 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_corporate/002_corporate_source_export.txt rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-008-02.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_capitalization/014_capitalization_source_export.xml for facility title exception.", "id": "investigation.CBP-008-02.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_debt_security/026_debt_security_source_export.txt to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-008-02.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_employment/038_employment_source_export.xml.", "id": "investigation.CBP-008-02.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-008-02 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-008-02.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-008-02 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-008-02.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-008-03 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_corporate/003_corporate_source_export.eml rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-008-03.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_capitalization/015_capitalization_source_export.html for unrecorded option grant.", "id": "investigation.CBP-008-03.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_debt_security/027_debt_security_source_export.eml to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-008-03.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_employment/039_employment_source_export.html.", "id": "investigation.CBP-008-03.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-008-03 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-008-03.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-008-03 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-008-03.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-008-04 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_corporate/004_corporate_source_export.csv rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-008-04.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_capitalization/016_capitalization_source_export.pdf for key-person retention gap.", "id": "investigation.CBP-008-04.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_debt_security/028_debt_security_source_export.csv to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-008-04.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_employment/040_employment_source_export.pdf.", "id": "investigation.CBP-008-04.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-008-04 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-008-04.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-008-04 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-008-04.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-008-05 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_corporate/005_corporate_source_export.json rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-008-05.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/017_material_contracts_source_export.md for threatened customer dispute.", "id": "investigation.CBP-008-05.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_debt_security/029_debt_security_source_export.json to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-008-05.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/041_ip_technology_source_export.md.", "id": "investigation.CBP-008-05.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-008-05 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is the operational record relies on a superseded control revision.", "id": "decision.CBP-008-05.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-008-05 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-008-05.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-008-06 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_corporate/006_corporate_source_export.xml rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-008-06.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/018_material_contracts_source_export.txt for charter authorization mismatch.", "id": "investigation.CBP-008-06.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_debt_security/030_debt_security_source_export.xml to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-008-06.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/042_ip_technology_source_export.txt.", "id": "investigation.CBP-008-06.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-008-06 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key.", "id": "decision.CBP-008-06.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-008-06 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-008-06.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-008-07 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_corporate/007_corporate_source_export.html rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-008-07.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/019_material_contracts_source_export.eml for financial covenant breach.", "id": "investigation.CBP-008-07.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_debt_security/031_debt_security_source_export.html to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-008-07.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/043_ip_technology_source_export.eml.", "id": "investigation.CBP-008-07.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-008-07 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is the current observation does not meet the operative trigger.", "id": "decision.CBP-008-07.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-008-07 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-008-07.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-008-08 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_corporate/008_corporate_source_export.pdf rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-008-08.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/020_material_contracts_source_export.csv for permit transfer restriction.", "id": "investigation.CBP-008-08.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_debt_security/032_debt_security_source_export.pdf to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-008-08.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/044_ip_technology_source_export.csv.", "id": "investigation.CBP-008-08.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-008-08 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective.", "id": "decision.CBP-008-08.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-008-08 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-008-08.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-008-09 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_capitalization/009_capitalization_source_export.md rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-008-09.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/021_material_contracts_source_export.json for revenue recognition exception.", "id": "investigation.CBP-008-09.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_employment/033_employment_source_export.md to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-008-09.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/045_ip_technology_source_export.json.", "id": "investigation.CBP-008-09.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-008-09 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-008-09.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-008-09 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-008-09.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-008-10 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_capitalization/010_capitalization_source_export.txt rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-008-10.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/022_material_contracts_source_export.xml for most-favored-customer exposure.", "id": "investigation.CBP-008-10.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_employment/034_employment_source_export.txt to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-008-10.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/046_ip_technology_source_export.xml.", "id": "investigation.CBP-008-10.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-008-10 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-008-10.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-008-10 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-008-10.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-008-11 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_capitalization/011_capitalization_source_export.eml rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-008-11.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/023_material_contracts_source_export.html for unreported security incident.", "id": "investigation.CBP-008-11.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_employment/035_employment_source_export.eml to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-008-11.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/047_ip_technology_source_export.html.", "id": "investigation.CBP-008-11.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-008-11 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is the current observation does not meet the operative trigger.", "id": "decision.CBP-008-11.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-008-11 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-008-11.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-008-12 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_capitalization/012_capitalization_source_export.csv rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-008-12.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/024_material_contracts_source_export.pdf for claims-made insurance tail.", "id": "investigation.CBP-008-12.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_employment/036_employment_source_export.csv to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-008-12.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/048_ip_technology_source_export.pdf.", "id": "investigation.CBP-008-12.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-008-12 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-008-12.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-008-12 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-008-12.register"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Write the exact selected option, supported action population, evidence-hold population, facts, owners, deadlines, and citations.", "id": "state.exact_decision"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create one exact register row per portfolio key with no extra, missing, or modified row.", "id": "state.exact_register"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Leave only the three approved deliverables and perform no extra state-changing write.", "id": "state.write_scope_containment"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Read back decision.json, matter-register.json, and advice.md after their final writes.", "id": "state.postwrite_readback"}, {"category": "answer", "description": "Explain the selected recommendation, supported actions, holds, alternatives, and limitations with exact source anchors.", "id": "answer.decision_note"}], "decision_options": [{"approach": "Use a plausible summary or one source without completing the controlling joins.", "id": "cobalt-learning:shortcut", "label": "Use the formal cap table and product catalog without checking side records."}, {"approach": "Treat supported actions and genuinely ambiguous records as if they were equally unresolved.", "id": "cobalt-learning:blanket-hold", "label": "Freeze the entire matter population"}, {"approach": "Apply the exact identity, current-state, authority, and revision test. Write only evidence-backed cap-table and rights exceptions with explicit unresolved holds.", "id": "cobalt-learning:scoped-evidence", "label": "Require the supported consent, capitalization correction, or data-use restriction before close."}], "evaluation_narrative": {"authority": "Student-data commitments, sublicense limits, and valid grant approvals determine the cap table and transfer scope.", "observation": "Match data flows, licensed content, and warrant grants to immutable product, school, and holder records.", "question": "What is the real closing exposure from school data, content sublicensing, and the missing advisor warrants?", "register_action": "Write only evidence-backed cap-table and rights exceptions with explicit unresolved holds."}, "gates": ["all_required_evidence_precedes_first_write", "decision_criteria_complete", "register_state_exact", "write_scope_contained", "all_outputs_verified_by_readback"], "metadata_checks": 9, "metric": "weighted_criteria_score", "minimum_tool_calls": 81, "required_deliverables": ["decision.json", "matter-register.json", "advice.md"], "required_document_reads": 57, "type": "deterministic", "weights": {"advice": 0.15, "decision": 0.35, "investigation": 0.25, "state": 0.25}}, "task_id": "cb100-008-cobalt-learning", "task_name": "Project Chalkboard education platform purchase", "world_id": "counselbench-filesystem-mcp-v3"}
+{"context_files": ["task_files/cb100-009-silverline-logistics/01_corporate/001_corporate_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-009-silverline-logistics/01_corporate/002_corporate_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-009-silverline-logistics/01_corporate/003_corporate_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-009-silverline-logistics/01_corporate/004_corporate_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-009-silverline-logistics/01_corporate/005_corporate_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-009-silverline-logistics/01_corporate/006_corporate_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-009-silverline-logistics/01_corporate/007_corporate_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-009-silverline-logistics/01_corporate/008_corporate_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-009-silverline-logistics/02_capitalization/009_capitalization_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-009-silverline-logistics/02_capitalization/010_capitalization_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-009-silverline-logistics/02_capitalization/011_capitalization_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-009-silverline-logistics/02_capitalization/012_capitalization_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-009-silverline-logistics/02_capitalization/013_capitalization_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-009-silverline-logistics/02_capitalization/014_capitalization_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-009-silverline-logistics/02_capitalization/015_capitalization_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-009-silverline-logistics/02_capitalization/016_capitalization_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-009-silverline-logistics/03_material_contracts/017_material_contracts_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-009-silverline-logistics/03_material_contracts/018_material_contracts_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-009-silverline-logistics/03_material_contracts/019_material_contracts_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-009-silverline-logistics/03_material_contracts/020_material_contracts_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-009-silverline-logistics/03_material_contracts/021_material_contracts_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-009-silverline-logistics/03_material_contracts/022_material_contracts_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-009-silverline-logistics/03_material_contracts/023_material_contracts_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-009-silverline-logistics/03_material_contracts/024_material_contracts_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-009-silverline-logistics/04_debt_security/025_debt_security_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-009-silverline-logistics/04_debt_security/026_debt_security_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-009-silverline-logistics/04_debt_security/027_debt_security_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-009-silverline-logistics/04_debt_security/028_debt_security_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-009-silverline-logistics/04_debt_security/029_debt_security_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-009-silverline-logistics/04_debt_security/030_debt_security_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-009-silverline-logistics/04_debt_security/031_debt_security_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-009-silverline-logistics/04_debt_security/032_debt_security_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-009-silverline-logistics/05_employment/033_employment_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-009-silverline-logistics/05_employment/034_employment_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-009-silverline-logistics/05_employment/035_employment_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-009-silverline-logistics/05_employment/036_employment_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-009-silverline-logistics/05_employment/037_employment_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-009-silverline-logistics/05_employment/038_employment_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-009-silverline-logistics/05_employment/039_employment_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-009-silverline-logistics/05_employment/040_employment_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-009-silverline-logistics/06_ip_technology/041_ip_technology_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-009-silverline-logistics/06_ip_technology/042_ip_technology_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-009-silverline-logistics/06_ip_technology/043_ip_technology_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-009-silverline-logistics/06_ip_technology/044_ip_technology_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-009-silverline-logistics/06_ip_technology/045_ip_technology_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-009-silverline-logistics/06_ip_technology/046_ip_technology_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-009-silverline-logistics/06_ip_technology/047_ip_technology_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-009-silverline-logistics/06_ip_technology/048_ip_technology_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-009-silverline-logistics/07_privacy_security/049_privacy_security_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-009-silverline-logistics/07_privacy_security/050_privacy_security_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-009-silverline-logistics/07_privacy_security/051_privacy_security_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-009-silverline-logistics/07_privacy_security/052_privacy_security_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-009-silverline-logistics/07_privacy_security/053_privacy_security_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-009-silverline-logistics/07_privacy_security/054_privacy_security_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-009-silverline-logistics/07_privacy_security/055_privacy_security_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-009-silverline-logistics/07_privacy_security/056_privacy_security_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-009-silverline-logistics/08_regulatory/057_regulatory_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-009-silverline-logistics/08_regulatory/058_regulatory_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-009-silverline-logistics/08_regulatory/059_regulatory_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-009-silverline-logistics/08_regulatory/060_regulatory_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-009-silverline-logistics/08_regulatory/061_regulatory_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-009-silverline-logistics/08_regulatory/062_regulatory_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-009-silverline-logistics/08_regulatory/063_regulatory_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-009-silverline-logistics/08_regulatory/064_regulatory_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-009-silverline-logistics/09_litigation/065_litigation_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-009-silverline-logistics/09_litigation/066_litigation_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-009-silverline-logistics/09_litigation/067_litigation_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-009-silverline-logistics/09_litigation/068_litigation_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-009-silverline-logistics/09_litigation/069_litigation_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-009-silverline-logistics/09_litigation/070_litigation_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-009-silverline-logistics/09_litigation/071_litigation_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-009-silverline-logistics/09_litigation/072_litigation_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-009-silverline-logistics/10_real_property/073_real_property_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-009-silverline-logistics/10_real_property/074_real_property_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-009-silverline-logistics/10_real_property/075_real_property_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-009-silverline-logistics/10_real_property/076_real_property_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-009-silverline-logistics/10_real_property/077_real_property_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-009-silverline-logistics/10_real_property/078_real_property_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-009-silverline-logistics/10_real_property/079_real_property_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-009-silverline-logistics/10_real_property/080_real_property_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-009-silverline-logistics/11_tax_insurance/081_tax_insurance_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-009-silverline-logistics/11_tax_insurance/082_tax_insurance_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-009-silverline-logistics/11_tax_insurance/083_tax_insurance_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-009-silverline-logistics/11_tax_insurance/084_tax_insurance_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-009-silverline-logistics/11_tax_insurance/085_tax_insurance_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-009-silverline-logistics/11_tax_insurance/086_tax_insurance_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-009-silverline-logistics/11_tax_insurance/087_tax_insurance_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-009-silverline-logistics/11_tax_insurance/088_tax_insurance_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-009-silverline-logistics/12_financials/089_financials_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-009-silverline-logistics/12_financials/090_financials_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-009-silverline-logistics/12_financials/091_financials_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-009-silverline-logistics/12_financials/092_financials_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-009-silverline-logistics/12_financials/093_financials_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-009-silverline-logistics/12_financials/094_financials_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-009-silverline-logistics/12_financials/095_financials_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-009-silverline-logistics/12_financials/096_financials_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-009-silverline-logistics/12_financials/097_silverline_logistics_impact_population.xlsx"], "gold_output": {"advice_markdown": "# Decision note — Project Switchyard logistics roll-up\n\n## Recommendation\n\nApply a targeted price, consent, or title condition for each proven exception. The reconciled record supports 9 scoped actions and leaves 3 items on evidence hold.\n\nSelected option: `silverline-logistics:scoped-evidence`.\n\n## Why this is the supported option\n\nJoin carrier permissions, title records, and invoice offsets to the exact asset and customer account. Operative data licenses, current title exceptions, and executed setoff rights control.\n\n## Supported actions\n\n### CBP-009-01 — open-source copyleft exposure (medium)\n\ncompletion is required by 2025-12-29 under CB-MA-2409-R697; the current event record shows completion on 2026-01-28 under CB-MA-2409-E505. Identity resolves to ENT-009-1000, revision REV-2025.1 is current, and Elliot Mercer is active with capacity 3.\n\nAction: Create scoped purchase-price and closing-condition rows tied to exact source identifiers. Owner: Elliot Mercer; due 2026-10-01.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_corporate/001_corporate_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/02_capitalization/013_capitalization_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/04_debt_security/025_debt_security_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/05_employment/037_employment_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/11_tax_insurance/085_tax_insurance_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/08_regulatory/061_regulatory_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/12_financials/097_silverline_logistics_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-009-02 — sales-tax nexus gap (high)\n\nthe controlling threshold is 7% under CB-MA-2409-R338; the independently calculated result is 13% under CB-MA-2409-E537. Identity resolves to ENT-009-1001, revision REV-2025.2 is current, and Sofia Bennett is active with capacity 1.\n\nAction: Create scoped purchase-price and closing-condition rows tied to exact source identifiers. Owner: Sofia Bennett; due 2026-09-30.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_corporate/002_corporate_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/02_capitalization/014_capitalization_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/04_debt_security/026_debt_security_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/05_employment/038_employment_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/11_tax_insurance/086_tax_insurance_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/12_financials/097_silverline_logistics_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-009-03 — change-of-control consent (high)\n\napproval must come from Willa Novak under CB-MA-2409-R716; the effective approval record names Rafael Okafor under CB-MA-2409-E824. Identity resolves to ENT-009-1002, revision REV-2025.3 is current, and Micah Sullivan is active with capacity 4.\n\nAction: Create scoped purchase-price and closing-condition rows tied to exact source identifiers. Owner: Micah Sullivan; due 2026-09-29.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_corporate/003_corporate_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/02_capitalization/015_capitalization_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/04_debt_security/027_debt_security_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/05_employment/039_employment_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/12_financials/097_silverline_logistics_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-009-04 — invention assignment defect (medium)\n\nthe controlled population contains 153 records under CB-MA-2409-R711; the certification covers 133 records under CB-MA-2409-E294. Identity resolves to ENT-009-1003, revision REV-2025.4 is current, and Nora Chen is active with capacity 2.\n\nAction: Create scoped purchase-price and closing-condition rows tied to exact source identifiers. Owner: Nora Chen; due 2026-09-28.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_corporate/004_corporate_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/02_capitalization/016_capitalization_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/04_debt_security/028_debt_security_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/05_employment/040_employment_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/12_financials/097_silverline_logistics_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-009-05 — facility title exception (medium)\n\nthe permission is limited to Fulton County, Georgia under CB-MA-2409-R972; the matched activity occurred in Georgia under CB-MA-2409-E680. Identity resolves to ENT-009-1004, revision REV-2025.5 is current, and Caleb Hassan is active with capacity 1.\n\nAction: Create scoped purchase-price and closing-condition rows tied to exact source identifiers. Owner: Caleb Hassan; due 2026-09-27.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_corporate/005_corporate_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/017_material_contracts_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/04_debt_security/029_debt_security_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/041_ip_technology_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/12_financials/097_silverline_logistics_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-009-07 — key-person retention gap (high)\n\ndelivery must use notices-silverline_logistics_lp@example.test under CB-MA-2409-R214; the only matched receipt used archive-switchyard_freight_intelligence_llc@example.test under CB-MA-2409-E371. Identity resolves to ENT-009-1006, revision REV-2025.7 is current, and Samuel Kim is active with capacity 3.\n\nAction: Create scoped purchase-price and closing-condition rows tied to exact source identifiers. Owner: Samuel Kim; due 2026-09-25.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_corporate/007_corporate_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/019_material_contracts_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/04_debt_security/031_debt_security_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/043_ip_technology_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/12_financials/091_financials_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/12_financials/097_silverline_logistics_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-009-08 — threatened customer dispute (medium)\n\nan open exception blocks completion under CB-MA-2409-R623; the current status is open and unresolved under CB-MA-2409-E819. Identity resolves to ENT-009-1007, revision REV-2025.1 is current, and Talia Brooks is active with capacity 5.\n\nAction: Create scoped purchase-price and closing-condition rows tied to exact source identifiers. Owner: Talia Brooks; due 2026-09-24.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_corporate/008_corporate_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/020_material_contracts_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/04_debt_security/032_debt_security_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/044_ip_technology_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/12_financials/097_silverline_logistics_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-009-09 — charter authorization mismatch (medium)\n\ncompletion is required by 2026-03-11 under CB-MA-2409-R229; the current event record shows completion on 2026-04-12 under CB-MA-2409-E795. Identity resolves to ENT-009-1008, revision REV-2025.2 is current, and Adrian Mensah is active with capacity 6.\n\nAction: Create scoped purchase-price and closing-condition rows tied to exact source identifiers. Owner: Adrian Mensah; due 2026-09-23.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/02_capitalization/009_capitalization_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/021_material_contracts_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/05_employment/033_employment_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/045_ip_technology_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/12_financials/093_financials_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/09_litigation/069_litigation_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/12_financials/097_silverline_logistics_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-009-12 — revenue recognition exception (high)\n\nthe controlled population contains 130 records under CB-MA-2409-R188; the certification covers 94 records under CB-MA-2409-E793. Identity resolves to ENT-009-1011, revision REV-2025.5 is current, and Leona Park is active with capacity 6.\n\nAction: Create scoped purchase-price and closing-condition rows tied to exact source identifiers. Owner: Leona Park; due 2026-09-29.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/02_capitalization/012_capitalization_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/024_material_contracts_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/05_employment/036_employment_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/048_ip_technology_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/12_financials/097_silverline_logistics_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n## Evidence holds\n\n- **CBP-009-06 — unrecorded option grant**: the current observation does not meet the operative trigger. Next evidence: a current observation that satisfies the operative trigger. Sources: `/workspace/documents/01_corporate/006_corporate_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/018_material_contracts_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/04_debt_security/030_debt_security_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/042_ip_technology_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/09_litigation/066_litigation_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/12_financials/097_silverline_logistics_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-009-10 — financial covenant breach**: the current observation does not meet the operative trigger. Next evidence: a current observation that satisfies the operative trigger. Sources: `/workspace/documents/02_capitalization/010_capitalization_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/022_material_contracts_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/05_employment/034_employment_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/046_ip_technology_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/09_litigation/070_litigation_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/12_financials/094_financials_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/12_financials/097_silverline_logistics_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-009-11 — permit transfer restriction**: the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective. Next evidence: effective approval and an active owner with remaining capacity. Sources: `/workspace/documents/02_capitalization/011_capitalization_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/023_material_contracts_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/05_employment/035_employment_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/047_ip_technology_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/08_regulatory/059_regulatory_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/09_litigation/071_litigation_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/12_financials/097_silverline_logistics_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n## Alternatives considered\n\n- `silverline-logistics:blanket-hold` — Freeze the entire matter population: Treat supported actions and genuinely ambiguous records as if they were equally unresolved.\n- `silverline-logistics:shortcut` — Net every customer dispute against price and assume facility access transfers.: Use a plausible summary or one source without completing the controlling joins.\n\n## Assumptions and limits\n\nThis decision is limited to cb100-009-silverline-logistics, the supplied synthetic records, and the matter state as of 2026-10-02. Similar names, stale revisions, and pending authority are not treated as proof.\n", "decision": {"actions": [{"determination": "completion is required by 2025-12-29 under CB-MA-2409-R697; the current event record shows completion on 2026-01-28 under CB-MA-2409-E505. Identity resolves to ENT-009-1000, revision REV-2025.1 is current, and Elliot Mercer is active with capacity 3.", "due_date": "2026-10-01", "id": "ACT-CBP-009-01", "identity_id": "ENT-009-1000", "issue": "open-source copyleft exposure", "owner": "Elliot Mercer", "portfolio_key": "CBP-009-01", "recommended_action": "Create scoped purchase-price and closing-condition rows tied to exact source identifiers. Owner: Elliot Mercer; due 2026-10-01.", "severity": "medium", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_corporate/001_corporate_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/02_capitalization/013_capitalization_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/04_debt_security/025_debt_security_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/05_employment/037_employment_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/11_tax_insurance/085_tax_insurance_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/08_regulatory/061_regulatory_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_financials/097_silverline_logistics_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "the controlling threshold is 7% under CB-MA-2409-R338; the independently calculated result is 13% under CB-MA-2409-E537. Identity resolves to ENT-009-1001, revision REV-2025.2 is current, and Sofia Bennett is active with capacity 1.", "due_date": "2026-09-30", "id": "ACT-CBP-009-02", "identity_id": "ENT-009-1001", "issue": "sales-tax nexus gap", "owner": "Sofia Bennett", "portfolio_key": "CBP-009-02", "recommended_action": "Create scoped purchase-price and closing-condition rows tied to exact source identifiers. Owner: Sofia Bennett; due 2026-09-30.", "severity": "high", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_corporate/002_corporate_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/02_capitalization/014_capitalization_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/04_debt_security/026_debt_security_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/05_employment/038_employment_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/11_tax_insurance/086_tax_insurance_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_financials/097_silverline_logistics_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "approval must come from Willa Novak under CB-MA-2409-R716; the effective approval record names Rafael Okafor under CB-MA-2409-E824. Identity resolves to ENT-009-1002, revision REV-2025.3 is current, and Micah Sullivan is active with capacity 4.", "due_date": "2026-09-29", "id": "ACT-CBP-009-03", "identity_id": "ENT-009-1002", "issue": "change-of-control consent", "owner": "Micah Sullivan", "portfolio_key": "CBP-009-03", "recommended_action": "Create scoped purchase-price and closing-condition rows tied to exact source identifiers. Owner: Micah Sullivan; due 2026-09-29.", "severity": "high", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_corporate/003_corporate_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/02_capitalization/015_capitalization_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/04_debt_security/027_debt_security_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/05_employment/039_employment_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_financials/097_silverline_logistics_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "the controlled population contains 153 records under CB-MA-2409-R711; the certification covers 133 records under CB-MA-2409-E294. Identity resolves to ENT-009-1003, revision REV-2025.4 is current, and Nora Chen is active with capacity 2.", "due_date": "2026-09-28", "id": "ACT-CBP-009-04", "identity_id": "ENT-009-1003", "issue": "invention assignment defect", "owner": "Nora Chen", "portfolio_key": "CBP-009-04", "recommended_action": "Create scoped purchase-price and closing-condition rows tied to exact source identifiers. Owner: Nora Chen; due 2026-09-28.", "severity": "medium", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_corporate/004_corporate_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/02_capitalization/016_capitalization_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/04_debt_security/028_debt_security_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/05_employment/040_employment_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_financials/097_silverline_logistics_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "the permission is limited to Fulton County, Georgia under CB-MA-2409-R972; the matched activity occurred in Georgia under CB-MA-2409-E680. Identity resolves to ENT-009-1004, revision REV-2025.5 is current, and Caleb Hassan is active with capacity 1.", "due_date": "2026-09-27", "id": "ACT-CBP-009-05", "identity_id": "ENT-009-1004", "issue": "facility title exception", "owner": "Caleb Hassan", "portfolio_key": "CBP-009-05", "recommended_action": "Create scoped purchase-price and closing-condition rows tied to exact source identifiers. Owner: Caleb Hassan; due 2026-09-27.", "severity": "medium", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_corporate/005_corporate_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/017_material_contracts_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/04_debt_security/029_debt_security_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/041_ip_technology_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/12_financials/097_silverline_logistics_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "delivery must use notices-silverline_logistics_lp@example.test under CB-MA-2409-R214; the only matched receipt used archive-switchyard_freight_intelligence_llc@example.test under CB-MA-2409-E371. Identity resolves to ENT-009-1006, revision REV-2025.7 is current, and Samuel Kim is active with capacity 3.", "due_date": "2026-09-25", "id": "ACT-CBP-009-07", "identity_id": "ENT-009-1006", "issue": "key-person retention gap", "owner": "Samuel Kim", "portfolio_key": "CBP-009-07", "recommended_action": "Create scoped purchase-price and closing-condition rows tied to exact source identifiers. Owner: Samuel Kim; due 2026-09-25.", "severity": "high", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_corporate/007_corporate_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/019_material_contracts_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/04_debt_security/031_debt_security_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/043_ip_technology_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/12_financials/091_financials_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/12_financials/097_silverline_logistics_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "an open exception blocks completion under CB-MA-2409-R623; the current status is open and unresolved under CB-MA-2409-E819. Identity resolves to ENT-009-1007, revision REV-2025.1 is current, and Talia Brooks is active with capacity 5.", "due_date": "2026-09-24", "id": "ACT-CBP-009-08", "identity_id": "ENT-009-1007", "issue": "threatened customer dispute", "owner": "Talia Brooks", "portfolio_key": "CBP-009-08", "recommended_action": "Create scoped purchase-price and closing-condition rows tied to exact source identifiers. Owner: Talia Brooks; due 2026-09-24.", "severity": "medium", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_corporate/008_corporate_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/020_material_contracts_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/04_debt_security/032_debt_security_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/044_ip_technology_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/12_financials/097_silverline_logistics_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "completion is required by 2026-03-11 under CB-MA-2409-R229; the current event record shows completion on 2026-04-12 under CB-MA-2409-E795. Identity resolves to ENT-009-1008, revision REV-2025.2 is current, and Adrian Mensah is active with capacity 6.", "due_date": "2026-09-23", "id": "ACT-CBP-009-09", "identity_id": "ENT-009-1008", "issue": "charter authorization mismatch", "owner": "Adrian Mensah", "portfolio_key": "CBP-009-09", "recommended_action": "Create scoped purchase-price and closing-condition rows tied to exact source identifiers. Owner: Adrian Mensah; due 2026-09-23.", "severity": "medium", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_capitalization/009_capitalization_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/021_material_contracts_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/05_employment/033_employment_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/045_ip_technology_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_financials/093_financials_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/09_litigation/069_litigation_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_financials/097_silverline_logistics_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "the controlled population contains 130 records under CB-MA-2409-R188; the certification covers 94 records under CB-MA-2409-E793. Identity resolves to ENT-009-1011, revision REV-2025.5 is current, and Leona Park is active with capacity 6.", "due_date": "2026-09-29", "id": "ACT-CBP-009-12", "identity_id": "ENT-009-1011", "issue": "revenue recognition exception", "owner": "Leona Park", "portfolio_key": "CBP-009-12", "recommended_action": "Create scoped purchase-price and closing-condition rows tied to exact source identifiers. Owner: Leona Park; due 2026-09-29.", "severity": "high", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_capitalization/012_capitalization_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/024_material_contracts_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/05_employment/036_employment_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/048_ip_technology_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_financials/097_silverline_logistics_impact_population.xlsx"]}], "as_of": "2026-10-02", "decision": {"alternatives_considered": ["silverline-logistics:blanket-hold", "silverline-logistics:shortcut"], "question": "Which Switchyard issues change price or closing certainty after we reconcile carrier data, the facility, and the customer offset?", "rationale": "The four-part causal test supports 9 scoped actions and leaves 3 records on evidence hold. Operative data licenses, current title exceptions, and executed setoff rights control.", "recommendation": "Apply a targeted price, consent, or title condition for each proven exception.", "selected_option_id": "silverline-logistics:scoped-evidence"}, "holds": [{"id": "HOLD-CBP-009-06", "issue": "unrecorded option grant", "portfolio_key": "CBP-009-06", "reason": "the current observation does not meet the operative trigger", "required_next_evidence": "a current observation that satisfies the operative trigger", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_corporate/006_corporate_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/018_material_contracts_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/04_debt_security/030_debt_security_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/042_ip_technology_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/09_litigation/066_litigation_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/12_financials/097_silverline_logistics_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-009-10", "issue": "financial covenant breach", "portfolio_key": "CBP-009-10", "reason": "the current observation does not meet the operative trigger", "required_next_evidence": "a current observation that satisfies the operative trigger", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_capitalization/010_capitalization_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/022_material_contracts_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/05_employment/034_employment_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/046_ip_technology_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/09_litigation/070_litigation_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_financials/094_financials_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_financials/097_silverline_logistics_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-009-11", "issue": "permit transfer restriction", "portfolio_key": "CBP-009-11", "reason": "the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective", "required_next_evidence": "effective approval and an active owner with remaining capacity", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_capitalization/011_capitalization_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/023_material_contracts_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/05_employment/035_employment_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/047_ip_technology_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/08_regulatory/059_regulatory_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/09_litigation/071_litigation_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_financials/097_silverline_logistics_impact_population.xlsx"]}], "matter_number": "CB-MA-2409", "prepared_for": "Silverline Logistics LP", "schema_version": "counselbench.decision.v3", "task_id": "cb100-009-silverline-logistics"}, "matter_register": {"matter_number": "CB-MA-2409", "rows": [{"decision_option_id": "silverline-logistics:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-10-01", "issue": "open-source copyleft exposure", "matter_number": "CB-MA-2409", "owner": "Elliot Mercer", "portfolio_key": "CBP-009-01", "row_id": "REG-CBP-009-01", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_corporate/001_corporate_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/02_capitalization/013_capitalization_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/04_debt_security/025_debt_security_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/05_employment/037_employment_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/11_tax_insurance/085_tax_insurance_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/08_regulatory/061_regulatory_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_financials/097_silverline_logistics_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "silverline-logistics:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-30", "issue": "sales-tax nexus gap", "matter_number": "CB-MA-2409", "owner": "Sofia Bennett", "portfolio_key": "CBP-009-02", "row_id": "REG-CBP-009-02", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_corporate/002_corporate_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/02_capitalization/014_capitalization_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/04_debt_security/026_debt_security_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/05_employment/038_employment_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/11_tax_insurance/086_tax_insurance_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_financials/097_silverline_logistics_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "silverline-logistics:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-29", "issue": "change-of-control consent", "matter_number": "CB-MA-2409", "owner": "Micah Sullivan", "portfolio_key": "CBP-009-03", "row_id": "REG-CBP-009-03", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_corporate/003_corporate_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/02_capitalization/015_capitalization_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/04_debt_security/027_debt_security_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/05_employment/039_employment_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_financials/097_silverline_logistics_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "silverline-logistics:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-28", "issue": "invention assignment defect", "matter_number": "CB-MA-2409", "owner": "Nora Chen", "portfolio_key": "CBP-009-04", "row_id": "REG-CBP-009-04", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_corporate/004_corporate_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/02_capitalization/016_capitalization_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/04_debt_security/028_debt_security_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/05_employment/040_employment_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_financials/097_silverline_logistics_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "silverline-logistics:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-27", "issue": "facility title exception", "matter_number": "CB-MA-2409", "owner": "Caleb Hassan", "portfolio_key": "CBP-009-05", "row_id": "REG-CBP-009-05", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_corporate/005_corporate_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/017_material_contracts_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/04_debt_security/029_debt_security_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/041_ip_technology_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/12_financials/097_silverline_logistics_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "silverline-logistics:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "the current observation does not meet the operative trigger", "issue": "unrecorded option grant", "matter_number": "CB-MA-2409", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-009-06", "row_id": "REG-CBP-009-06", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_corporate/006_corporate_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/018_material_contracts_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/04_debt_security/030_debt_security_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/042_ip_technology_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/09_litigation/066_litigation_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/12_financials/097_silverline_logistics_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "silverline-logistics:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-25", "issue": "key-person retention gap", "matter_number": "CB-MA-2409", "owner": "Samuel Kim", "portfolio_key": "CBP-009-07", "row_id": "REG-CBP-009-07", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_corporate/007_corporate_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/019_material_contracts_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/04_debt_security/031_debt_security_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/043_ip_technology_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/12_financials/091_financials_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/12_financials/097_silverline_logistics_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "silverline-logistics:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-24", "issue": "threatened customer dispute", "matter_number": "CB-MA-2409", "owner": "Talia Brooks", "portfolio_key": "CBP-009-08", "row_id": "REG-CBP-009-08", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_corporate/008_corporate_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/020_material_contracts_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/04_debt_security/032_debt_security_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/044_ip_technology_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/12_financials/097_silverline_logistics_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "silverline-logistics:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-23", "issue": "charter authorization mismatch", "matter_number": "CB-MA-2409", "owner": "Adrian Mensah", "portfolio_key": "CBP-009-09", "row_id": "REG-CBP-009-09", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_capitalization/009_capitalization_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/021_material_contracts_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/05_employment/033_employment_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/045_ip_technology_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_financials/093_financials_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/09_litigation/069_litigation_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_financials/097_silverline_logistics_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "silverline-logistics:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "the current observation does not meet the operative trigger", "issue": "financial covenant breach", "matter_number": "CB-MA-2409", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-009-10", "row_id": "REG-CBP-009-10", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_capitalization/010_capitalization_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/022_material_contracts_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/05_employment/034_employment_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/046_ip_technology_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/09_litigation/070_litigation_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_financials/094_financials_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_financials/097_silverline_logistics_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "silverline-logistics:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective", "issue": "permit transfer restriction", "matter_number": "CB-MA-2409", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-009-11", "row_id": "REG-CBP-009-11", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_capitalization/011_capitalization_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/023_material_contracts_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/05_employment/035_employment_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/047_ip_technology_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/08_regulatory/059_regulatory_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/09_litigation/071_litigation_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_financials/097_silverline_logistics_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "silverline-logistics:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-29", "issue": "revenue recognition exception", "matter_number": "CB-MA-2409", "owner": "Leona Park", "portfolio_key": "CBP-009-12", "row_id": "REG-CBP-009-12", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_capitalization/012_capitalization_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/024_material_contracts_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/05_employment/036_employment_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/048_ip_technology_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_financials/097_silverline_logistics_impact_population.xlsx"]}], "schema_version": "counselbench.matter-register.v3", "task_id": "cb100-009-silverline-logistics"}}, "metadata": {"benchmark": "CounselBench-100", "code_license": "Apache-2.0", "data_license": "CC-BY-4.0", "deadline": "2026-10-02", "document_count": 97, "evidence_holds": 3, "jurisdiction": "Georgia", "matter_number": "CB-MA-2409", "mcp_commit": "9a96ea6e5913736f92b88345bf51caeaaa8e719f", "mcp_package": "@modelcontextprotocol/server-filesystem@2026.7.10", "practice_area": "corporate-ma", "reference_tool_calls": 85, "required_evidence_reads": 61, "supported_actions": 9, "synthetic": true, "venue": "Fulton County, Georgia", "version": "3.1.0"}, "prompt": "Please take ownership of the open question before the deadline. Which Switchyard issues change price or closing certainty after we reconcile carrier data, the facility, and the customer offset? A freight analytics add-on uses carrier fuel data, occupies a rail-adjacent facility, and disputes a customer offset against implementation invoices. The team needs the call by 2026-10-02. Give me a decision-ready note and make the corresponding matter-register entries, without guessing through missing records.", "rubric": {"criteria": [{"category": "investigation", "description": "Inventory the production and use targeted searches to locate records across native formats.", "id": "investigation.discover_production"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Complete every task-specific identity, authority, operations, and approval read before the first state transition.", "id": "investigation.read_before_write"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Inspect designated source metadata before relying on those records.", "id": "investigation.custody_before_write"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "Select the supported option 'silverline-logistics:scoped-evidence' after applying the four-part test.", "id": "decision.selected_option"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "Identify both rejected approaches and explain why a one-source shortcut and a blanket hold are wrong.", "id": "decision.alternatives"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-009-01 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_corporate/001_corporate_source_export.md rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-009-01.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_capitalization/013_capitalization_source_export.json for open-source copyleft exposure.", "id": "investigation.CBP-009-01.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_debt_security/025_debt_security_source_export.md to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-009-01.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_employment/037_employment_source_export.json.", "id": "investigation.CBP-009-01.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-009-01 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-009-01.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-009-01 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-009-01.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-009-02 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_corporate/002_corporate_source_export.txt rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-009-02.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_capitalization/014_capitalization_source_export.xml for sales-tax nexus gap.", "id": "investigation.CBP-009-02.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_debt_security/026_debt_security_source_export.txt to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-009-02.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_employment/038_employment_source_export.xml.", "id": "investigation.CBP-009-02.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-009-02 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-009-02.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-009-02 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-009-02.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-009-03 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_corporate/003_corporate_source_export.eml rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-009-03.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_capitalization/015_capitalization_source_export.html for change-of-control consent.", "id": "investigation.CBP-009-03.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_debt_security/027_debt_security_source_export.eml to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-009-03.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_employment/039_employment_source_export.html.", "id": "investigation.CBP-009-03.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-009-03 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-009-03.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-009-03 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-009-03.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-009-04 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_corporate/004_corporate_source_export.csv rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-009-04.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_capitalization/016_capitalization_source_export.pdf for invention assignment defect.", "id": "investigation.CBP-009-04.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_debt_security/028_debt_security_source_export.csv to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-009-04.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_employment/040_employment_source_export.pdf.", "id": "investigation.CBP-009-04.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-009-04 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-009-04.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-009-04 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-009-04.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-009-05 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_corporate/005_corporate_source_export.json rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-009-05.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/017_material_contracts_source_export.md for facility title exception.", "id": "investigation.CBP-009-05.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_debt_security/029_debt_security_source_export.json to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-009-05.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/041_ip_technology_source_export.md.", "id": "investigation.CBP-009-05.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-009-05 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-009-05.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-009-05 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-009-05.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-009-06 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_corporate/006_corporate_source_export.xml rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-009-06.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/018_material_contracts_source_export.txt for unrecorded option grant.", "id": "investigation.CBP-009-06.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_debt_security/030_debt_security_source_export.xml to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-009-06.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/042_ip_technology_source_export.txt.", "id": "investigation.CBP-009-06.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-009-06 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is the current observation does not meet the operative trigger.", "id": "decision.CBP-009-06.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-009-06 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-009-06.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-009-07 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_corporate/007_corporate_source_export.html rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-009-07.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/019_material_contracts_source_export.eml for key-person retention gap.", "id": "investigation.CBP-009-07.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_debt_security/031_debt_security_source_export.html to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-009-07.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/043_ip_technology_source_export.eml.", "id": "investigation.CBP-009-07.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-009-07 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-009-07.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-009-07 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-009-07.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-009-08 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_corporate/008_corporate_source_export.pdf rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-009-08.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/020_material_contracts_source_export.csv for threatened customer dispute.", "id": "investigation.CBP-009-08.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_debt_security/032_debt_security_source_export.pdf to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-009-08.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/044_ip_technology_source_export.csv.", "id": "investigation.CBP-009-08.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-009-08 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-009-08.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-009-08 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-009-08.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-009-09 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_capitalization/009_capitalization_source_export.md rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-009-09.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/021_material_contracts_source_export.json for charter authorization mismatch.", "id": "investigation.CBP-009-09.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_employment/033_employment_source_export.md to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-009-09.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/045_ip_technology_source_export.json.", "id": "investigation.CBP-009-09.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-009-09 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-009-09.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-009-09 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-009-09.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-009-10 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_capitalization/010_capitalization_source_export.txt rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-009-10.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/022_material_contracts_source_export.xml for financial covenant breach.", "id": "investigation.CBP-009-10.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_employment/034_employment_source_export.txt to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-009-10.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/046_ip_technology_source_export.xml.", "id": "investigation.CBP-009-10.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-009-10 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is the current observation does not meet the operative trigger.", "id": "decision.CBP-009-10.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-009-10 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-009-10.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-009-11 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_capitalization/011_capitalization_source_export.eml rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-009-11.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/023_material_contracts_source_export.html for permit transfer restriction.", "id": "investigation.CBP-009-11.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_employment/035_employment_source_export.eml to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-009-11.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/047_ip_technology_source_export.html.", "id": "investigation.CBP-009-11.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-009-11 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective.", "id": "decision.CBP-009-11.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-009-11 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-009-11.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-009-12 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_capitalization/012_capitalization_source_export.csv rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-009-12.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/024_material_contracts_source_export.pdf for revenue recognition exception.", "id": "investigation.CBP-009-12.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_employment/036_employment_source_export.csv to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-009-12.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/048_ip_technology_source_export.pdf.", "id": "investigation.CBP-009-12.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-009-12 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-009-12.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-009-12 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-009-12.register"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Write the exact selected option, supported action population, evidence-hold population, facts, owners, deadlines, and citations.", "id": "state.exact_decision"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create one exact register row per portfolio key with no extra, missing, or modified row.", "id": "state.exact_register"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Leave only the three approved deliverables and perform no extra state-changing write.", "id": "state.write_scope_containment"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Read back decision.json, matter-register.json, and advice.md after their final writes.", "id": "state.postwrite_readback"}, {"category": "answer", "description": "Explain the selected recommendation, supported actions, holds, alternatives, and limitations with exact source anchors.", "id": "answer.decision_note"}], "decision_options": [{"approach": "Treat supported actions and genuinely ambiguous records as if they were equally unresolved.", "id": "silverline-logistics:blanket-hold", "label": "Freeze the entire matter population"}, {"approach": "Apply the exact identity, current-state, authority, and revision test. Create scoped purchase-price and closing-condition rows tied to exact source identifiers.", "id": "silverline-logistics:scoped-evidence", "label": "Apply a targeted price, consent, or title condition for each proven exception."}, {"approach": "Use a plausible summary or one source without completing the controlling joins.", "id": "silverline-logistics:shortcut", "label": "Net every customer dispute against price and assume facility access transfers."}], "evaluation_narrative": {"authority": "Operative data licenses, current title exceptions, and executed setoff rights control.", "observation": "Join carrier permissions, title records, and invoice offsets to the exact asset and customer account.", "question": "Which Switchyard issues change price or closing certainty after we reconcile carrier data, the facility, and the customer offset?", "register_action": "Create scoped purchase-price and closing-condition rows tied to exact source identifiers."}, "gates": ["all_required_evidence_precedes_first_write", "decision_criteria_complete", "register_state_exact", "write_scope_contained", "all_outputs_verified_by_readback"], "metadata_checks": 10, "metric": "weighted_criteria_score", "minimum_tool_calls": 85, "required_deliverables": ["decision.json", "matter-register.json", "advice.md"], "required_document_reads": 61, "type": "deterministic", "weights": {"advice": 0.15, "decision": 0.35, "investigation": 0.25, "state": 0.25}}, "task_id": "cb100-009-silverline-logistics", "task_name": "Project Switchyard logistics roll-up", "world_id": "counselbench-filesystem-mcp-v3"}
+{"context_files": ["task_files/cb100-010-verdant-grid/01_corporate/001_corporate_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-010-verdant-grid/01_corporate/002_corporate_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-010-verdant-grid/01_corporate/003_corporate_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-010-verdant-grid/01_corporate/004_corporate_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-010-verdant-grid/01_corporate/005_corporate_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-010-verdant-grid/01_corporate/006_corporate_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-010-verdant-grid/01_corporate/007_corporate_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-010-verdant-grid/01_corporate/008_corporate_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-010-verdant-grid/02_capitalization/009_capitalization_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-010-verdant-grid/02_capitalization/010_capitalization_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-010-verdant-grid/02_capitalization/011_capitalization_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-010-verdant-grid/02_capitalization/012_capitalization_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-010-verdant-grid/02_capitalization/013_capitalization_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-010-verdant-grid/02_capitalization/014_capitalization_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-010-verdant-grid/02_capitalization/015_capitalization_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-010-verdant-grid/02_capitalization/016_capitalization_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-010-verdant-grid/03_material_contracts/017_material_contracts_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-010-verdant-grid/03_material_contracts/018_material_contracts_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-010-verdant-grid/03_material_contracts/019_material_contracts_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-010-verdant-grid/03_material_contracts/020_material_contracts_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-010-verdant-grid/03_material_contracts/021_material_contracts_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-010-verdant-grid/03_material_contracts/022_material_contracts_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-010-verdant-grid/03_material_contracts/023_material_contracts_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-010-verdant-grid/03_material_contracts/024_material_contracts_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-010-verdant-grid/04_debt_security/025_debt_security_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-010-verdant-grid/04_debt_security/026_debt_security_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-010-verdant-grid/04_debt_security/027_debt_security_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-010-verdant-grid/04_debt_security/028_debt_security_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-010-verdant-grid/04_debt_security/029_debt_security_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-010-verdant-grid/04_debt_security/030_debt_security_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-010-verdant-grid/04_debt_security/031_debt_security_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-010-verdant-grid/04_debt_security/032_debt_security_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-010-verdant-grid/05_employment/033_employment_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-010-verdant-grid/05_employment/034_employment_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-010-verdant-grid/05_employment/035_employment_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-010-verdant-grid/05_employment/036_employment_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-010-verdant-grid/05_employment/037_employment_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-010-verdant-grid/05_employment/038_employment_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-010-verdant-grid/05_employment/039_employment_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-010-verdant-grid/05_employment/040_employment_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-010-verdant-grid/06_ip_technology/041_ip_technology_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-010-verdant-grid/06_ip_technology/042_ip_technology_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-010-verdant-grid/06_ip_technology/043_ip_technology_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-010-verdant-grid/06_ip_technology/044_ip_technology_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-010-verdant-grid/06_ip_technology/045_ip_technology_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-010-verdant-grid/06_ip_technology/046_ip_technology_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-010-verdant-grid/06_ip_technology/047_ip_technology_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-010-verdant-grid/06_ip_technology/048_ip_technology_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-010-verdant-grid/07_privacy_security/049_privacy_security_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-010-verdant-grid/07_privacy_security/050_privacy_security_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-010-verdant-grid/07_privacy_security/051_privacy_security_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-010-verdant-grid/07_privacy_security/052_privacy_security_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-010-verdant-grid/07_privacy_security/053_privacy_security_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-010-verdant-grid/07_privacy_security/054_privacy_security_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-010-verdant-grid/07_privacy_security/055_privacy_security_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-010-verdant-grid/07_privacy_security/056_privacy_security_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-010-verdant-grid/08_regulatory/057_regulatory_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-010-verdant-grid/08_regulatory/058_regulatory_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-010-verdant-grid/08_regulatory/059_regulatory_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-010-verdant-grid/08_regulatory/060_regulatory_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-010-verdant-grid/08_regulatory/061_regulatory_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-010-verdant-grid/08_regulatory/062_regulatory_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-010-verdant-grid/08_regulatory/063_regulatory_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-010-verdant-grid/08_regulatory/064_regulatory_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-010-verdant-grid/09_litigation/065_litigation_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-010-verdant-grid/09_litigation/066_litigation_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-010-verdant-grid/09_litigation/067_litigation_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-010-verdant-grid/09_litigation/068_litigation_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-010-verdant-grid/09_litigation/069_litigation_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-010-verdant-grid/09_litigation/070_litigation_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-010-verdant-grid/09_litigation/071_litigation_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-010-verdant-grid/09_litigation/072_litigation_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-010-verdant-grid/10_real_property/073_real_property_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-010-verdant-grid/10_real_property/074_real_property_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-010-verdant-grid/10_real_property/075_real_property_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-010-verdant-grid/10_real_property/076_real_property_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-010-verdant-grid/10_real_property/077_real_property_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-010-verdant-grid/10_real_property/078_real_property_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-010-verdant-grid/10_real_property/079_real_property_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-010-verdant-grid/10_real_property/080_real_property_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-010-verdant-grid/11_tax_insurance/081_tax_insurance_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-010-verdant-grid/11_tax_insurance/082_tax_insurance_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-010-verdant-grid/11_tax_insurance/083_tax_insurance_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-010-verdant-grid/11_tax_insurance/084_tax_insurance_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-010-verdant-grid/11_tax_insurance/085_tax_insurance_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-010-verdant-grid/11_tax_insurance/086_tax_insurance_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-010-verdant-grid/11_tax_insurance/087_tax_insurance_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-010-verdant-grid/11_tax_insurance/088_tax_insurance_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-010-verdant-grid/12_financials/089_financials_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-010-verdant-grid/12_financials/090_financials_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-010-verdant-grid/12_financials/091_financials_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-010-verdant-grid/12_financials/092_financials_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-010-verdant-grid/12_financials/093_financials_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-010-verdant-grid/12_financials/094_financials_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-010-verdant-grid/12_financials/095_financials_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-010-verdant-grid/12_financials/096_financials_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-010-verdant-grid/12_financials/097_verdant_grid_impact_population.xlsx"], "gold_output": {"advice_markdown": "# Decision note — Project Canopy microgrid acquisition\n\n## Recommendation\n\nProceed only with the supported eligibility cure, site condition, or valuation adjustment. The reconciled record supports 5 scoped actions and leaves 7 items on evidence hold.\n\nSelected option: `verdant-grid:scoped-evidence`.\n\n## Why this is the supported option\n\nReconcile incentive eligibility, test-site rights, and milestone acceptance to the same project and period. Program rules, executed leases, and customer acceptance evidence govern transfer and revenue treatment.\n\n## Supported actions\n\n### CBP-010-01 — unreported security incident (high)\n\nthe operative cap is $3,802,000.00 under CB-MA-2410-R626; the matched ledger population totals $4,053,726.00 under CB-MA-2410-E978. Identity resolves to ENT-010-1000, revision REV-2026.1 is current, and Mei Whitaker is active with capacity 4.\n\nAction: Register supported valuation and closing adjustments and hold stale project revisions. Owner: Mei Whitaker; due 2026-10-05.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_corporate/001_corporate_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/02_capitalization/013_capitalization_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/04_debt_security/025_debt_security_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/05_employment/037_employment_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/12_financials/097_verdant_grid_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-010-02 — claims-made insurance tail (high)\n\ndelivery must use notices-verdant_grid_holdings@example.test under CB-MA-2410-R700; the only matched receipt used archive-canopy_storage_works_inc@example.test under CB-MA-2410-E717. Identity resolves to ENT-010-1001, revision REV-2026.2 is current, and Theo Laurent is active with capacity 4.\n\nAction: Register supported valuation and closing adjustments and hold stale project revisions. Owner: Theo Laurent; due 2026-10-04.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_corporate/002_corporate_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/02_capitalization/014_capitalization_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/04_debt_security/026_debt_security_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/05_employment/038_employment_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/07_privacy_security/050_privacy_security_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/08_regulatory/062_regulatory_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/12_financials/097_verdant_grid_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-010-06 — change-of-control consent (high)\n\napproval must come from Maya Ellison under CB-MA-2410-R855; the effective approval record names Henry Cho under CB-MA-2410-E462. Identity resolves to ENT-010-1005, revision REV-2026.6 is current, and Micah Sullivan is active with capacity 4.\n\nAction: Register supported valuation and closing adjustments and hold stale project revisions. Owner: Micah Sullivan; due 2026-09-30.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_corporate/006_corporate_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/018_material_contracts_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/04_debt_security/030_debt_security_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/042_ip_technology_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/12_financials/097_verdant_grid_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-010-11 — threatened customer dispute (critical)\n\nan open exception blocks completion under CB-MA-2410-R844; the current status is open and unresolved under CB-MA-2410-E673. Identity resolves to ENT-010-1010, revision REV-2026.4 is current, and Talia Brooks is active with capacity 1.\n\nAction: Register supported valuation and closing adjustments and hold stale project revisions. Owner: Talia Brooks; due 2026-10-04.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/02_capitalization/011_capitalization_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/023_material_contracts_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/05_employment/035_employment_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/047_ip_technology_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/08_regulatory/059_regulatory_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/11_tax_insurance/083_tax_insurance_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/12_financials/097_verdant_grid_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-010-12 — charter authorization mismatch (high)\n\ncompletion is required by 2025-08-04 under CB-MA-2410-R670; the current event record shows completion on 2025-08-24 under CB-MA-2410-E610. Identity resolves to ENT-010-1011, revision REV-2026.5 is current, and Adrian Mensah is active with capacity 2.\n\nAction: Register supported valuation and closing adjustments and hold stale project revisions. Owner: Adrian Mensah; due 2026-10-03.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/02_capitalization/012_capitalization_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/024_material_contracts_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/05_employment/036_employment_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/048_ip_technology_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/12_financials/097_verdant_grid_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n## Evidence holds\n\n- **CBP-010-03 — anti-assignment restriction**: the operational record relies on a superseded control revision. Next evidence: an operational record using the current effective revision. Sources: `/workspace/documents/01_corporate/003_corporate_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/02_capitalization/015_capitalization_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/04_debt_security/027_debt_security_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/05_employment/039_employment_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/07_privacy_security/051_privacy_security_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/11_tax_insurance/087_tax_insurance_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/12_financials/097_verdant_grid_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-010-04 — open-source copyleft exposure**: two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key. Next evidence: an approved immutable entity crosswalk. Sources: `/workspace/documents/01_corporate/004_corporate_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/02_capitalization/016_capitalization_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/04_debt_security/028_debt_security_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/05_employment/040_employment_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/07_privacy_security/052_privacy_security_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/12_financials/097_verdant_grid_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-010-05 — sales-tax nexus gap**: the current observation does not meet the operative trigger. Next evidence: a current observation that satisfies the operative trigger. Sources: `/workspace/documents/01_corporate/005_corporate_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/017_material_contracts_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/04_debt_security/029_debt_security_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/041_ip_technology_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/09_litigation/065_litigation_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/10_real_property/077_real_property_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/12_financials/097_verdant_grid_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-010-07 — invention assignment defect**: the operational record relies on a superseded control revision. Next evidence: an operational record using the current effective revision. Sources: `/workspace/documents/01_corporate/007_corporate_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/019_material_contracts_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/04_debt_security/031_debt_security_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/043_ip_technology_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/07_privacy_security/055_privacy_security_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/12_financials/097_verdant_grid_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-010-08 — facility title exception**: two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key. Next evidence: an approved immutable entity crosswalk. Sources: `/workspace/documents/01_corporate/008_corporate_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/020_material_contracts_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/04_debt_security/032_debt_security_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/044_ip_technology_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/09_litigation/068_litigation_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/12_financials/097_verdant_grid_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-010-09 — unrecorded option grant**: the current observation does not meet the operative trigger. Next evidence: a current observation that satisfies the operative trigger. Sources: `/workspace/documents/02_capitalization/009_capitalization_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/021_material_contracts_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/05_employment/033_employment_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/045_ip_technology_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/09_litigation/069_litigation_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/12_financials/097_verdant_grid_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-010-10 — key-person retention gap**: the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective. Next evidence: effective approval and an active owner with remaining capacity. Sources: `/workspace/documents/02_capitalization/010_capitalization_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/022_material_contracts_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/05_employment/034_employment_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/046_ip_technology_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/09_litigation/070_litigation_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/11_tax_insurance/082_tax_insurance_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/12_financials/097_verdant_grid_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n## Alternatives considered\n\n- `verdant-grid:shortcut` — Treat booked revenue and active production as proof that every condition was satisfied.: Use a plausible summary or one source without completing the controlling joins.\n- `verdant-grid:blanket-hold` — Freeze the entire matter population: Treat supported actions and genuinely ambiguous records as if they were equally unresolved.\n\n## Assumptions and limits\n\nThis decision is limited to cb100-010-verdant-grid, the supplied synthetic records, and the matter state as of 2026-10-06. Similar names, stale revisions, and pending authority are not treated as proof.\n", "decision": {"actions": [{"determination": "the operative cap is $3,802,000.00 under CB-MA-2410-R626; the matched ledger population totals $4,053,726.00 under CB-MA-2410-E978. Identity resolves to ENT-010-1000, revision REV-2026.1 is current, and Mei Whitaker is active with capacity 4.", "due_date": "2026-10-05", "id": "ACT-CBP-010-01", "identity_id": "ENT-010-1000", "issue": "unreported security incident", "owner": "Mei Whitaker", "portfolio_key": "CBP-010-01", "recommended_action": "Register supported valuation and closing adjustments and hold stale project revisions. Owner: Mei Whitaker; due 2026-10-05.", "severity": "high", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_corporate/001_corporate_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/02_capitalization/013_capitalization_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/04_debt_security/025_debt_security_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/05_employment/037_employment_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_financials/097_verdant_grid_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "delivery must use notices-verdant_grid_holdings@example.test under CB-MA-2410-R700; the only matched receipt used archive-canopy_storage_works_inc@example.test under CB-MA-2410-E717. Identity resolves to ENT-010-1001, revision REV-2026.2 is current, and Theo Laurent is active with capacity 4.", "due_date": "2026-10-04", "id": "ACT-CBP-010-02", "identity_id": "ENT-010-1001", "issue": "claims-made insurance tail", "owner": "Theo Laurent", "portfolio_key": "CBP-010-02", "recommended_action": "Register supported valuation and closing adjustments and hold stale project revisions. Owner: Theo Laurent; due 2026-10-04.", "severity": "high", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_corporate/002_corporate_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/02_capitalization/014_capitalization_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/04_debt_security/026_debt_security_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/05_employment/038_employment_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/07_privacy_security/050_privacy_security_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/08_regulatory/062_regulatory_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_financials/097_verdant_grid_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "approval must come from Maya Ellison under CB-MA-2410-R855; the effective approval record names Henry Cho under CB-MA-2410-E462. Identity resolves to ENT-010-1005, revision REV-2026.6 is current, and Micah Sullivan is active with capacity 4.", "due_date": "2026-09-30", "id": "ACT-CBP-010-06", "identity_id": "ENT-010-1005", "issue": "change-of-control consent", "owner": "Micah Sullivan", "portfolio_key": "CBP-010-06", "recommended_action": "Register supported valuation and closing adjustments and hold stale project revisions. Owner: Micah Sullivan; due 2026-09-30.", "severity": "high", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_corporate/006_corporate_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/018_material_contracts_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/04_debt_security/030_debt_security_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/042_ip_technology_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/12_financials/097_verdant_grid_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "an open exception blocks completion under CB-MA-2410-R844; the current status is open and unresolved under CB-MA-2410-E673. Identity resolves to ENT-010-1010, revision REV-2026.4 is current, and Talia Brooks is active with capacity 1.", "due_date": "2026-10-04", "id": "ACT-CBP-010-11", "identity_id": "ENT-010-1010", "issue": "threatened customer dispute", "owner": "Talia Brooks", "portfolio_key": "CBP-010-11", "recommended_action": "Register supported valuation and closing adjustments and hold stale project revisions. Owner: Talia Brooks; due 2026-10-04.", "severity": "critical", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_capitalization/011_capitalization_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/023_material_contracts_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/05_employment/035_employment_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/047_ip_technology_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/08_regulatory/059_regulatory_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/11_tax_insurance/083_tax_insurance_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/12_financials/097_verdant_grid_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "completion is required by 2025-08-04 under CB-MA-2410-R670; the current event record shows completion on 2025-08-24 under CB-MA-2410-E610. Identity resolves to ENT-010-1011, revision REV-2026.5 is current, and Adrian Mensah is active with capacity 2.", "due_date": "2026-10-03", "id": "ACT-CBP-010-12", "identity_id": "ENT-010-1011", "issue": "charter authorization mismatch", "owner": "Adrian Mensah", "portfolio_key": "CBP-010-12", "recommended_action": "Register supported valuation and closing adjustments and hold stale project revisions. Owner: Adrian Mensah; due 2026-10-03.", "severity": "high", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_capitalization/012_capitalization_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/024_material_contracts_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/05_employment/036_employment_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/048_ip_technology_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_financials/097_verdant_grid_impact_population.xlsx"]}], "as_of": "2026-10-06", "decision": {"alternatives_considered": ["verdant-grid:shortcut", "verdant-grid:blanket-hold"], "question": "Can Canopy close on the current valuation, or do incentive, land, and acceptance records require a different posture?", "rationale": "The four-part causal test supports 5 scoped actions and leaves 7 records on evidence hold. Program rules, executed leases, and customer acceptance evidence govern transfer and revenue treatment.", "recommendation": "Proceed only with the supported eligibility cure, site condition, or valuation adjustment.", "selected_option_id": "verdant-grid:scoped-evidence"}, "holds": [{"id": "HOLD-CBP-010-03", "issue": "anti-assignment restriction", "portfolio_key": "CBP-010-03", "reason": "the operational record relies on a superseded control revision", "required_next_evidence": "an operational record using the current effective revision", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_corporate/003_corporate_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/02_capitalization/015_capitalization_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/04_debt_security/027_debt_security_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/05_employment/039_employment_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/07_privacy_security/051_privacy_security_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/11_tax_insurance/087_tax_insurance_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_financials/097_verdant_grid_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-010-04", "issue": "open-source copyleft exposure", "portfolio_key": "CBP-010-04", "reason": "two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key", "required_next_evidence": "an approved immutable entity crosswalk", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_corporate/004_corporate_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/02_capitalization/016_capitalization_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/04_debt_security/028_debt_security_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/05_employment/040_employment_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/07_privacy_security/052_privacy_security_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/12_financials/097_verdant_grid_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-010-05", "issue": "sales-tax nexus gap", "portfolio_key": "CBP-010-05", "reason": "the current observation does not meet the operative trigger", "required_next_evidence": "a current observation that satisfies the operative trigger", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_corporate/005_corporate_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/017_material_contracts_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/04_debt_security/029_debt_security_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/041_ip_technology_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/09_litigation/065_litigation_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/10_real_property/077_real_property_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_financials/097_verdant_grid_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-010-07", "issue": "invention assignment defect", "portfolio_key": "CBP-010-07", "reason": "the operational record relies on a superseded control revision", "required_next_evidence": "an operational record using the current effective revision", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_corporate/007_corporate_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/019_material_contracts_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/04_debt_security/031_debt_security_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/043_ip_technology_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/07_privacy_security/055_privacy_security_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_financials/097_verdant_grid_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-010-08", "issue": "facility title exception", "portfolio_key": "CBP-010-08", "reason": "two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key", "required_next_evidence": "an approved immutable entity crosswalk", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_corporate/008_corporate_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/020_material_contracts_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/04_debt_security/032_debt_security_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/044_ip_technology_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/09_litigation/068_litigation_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/12_financials/097_verdant_grid_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-010-09", "issue": "unrecorded option grant", "portfolio_key": "CBP-010-09", "reason": "the current observation does not meet the operative trigger", "required_next_evidence": "a current observation that satisfies the operative trigger", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_capitalization/009_capitalization_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/021_material_contracts_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/05_employment/033_employment_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/045_ip_technology_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/09_litigation/069_litigation_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_financials/097_verdant_grid_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-010-10", "issue": "key-person retention gap", "portfolio_key": "CBP-010-10", "reason": "the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective", "required_next_evidence": "effective approval and an active owner with remaining capacity", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_capitalization/010_capitalization_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/022_material_contracts_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/05_employment/034_employment_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/046_ip_technology_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/09_litigation/070_litigation_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/11_tax_insurance/082_tax_insurance_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/12_financials/097_verdant_grid_impact_population.xlsx"]}], "matter_number": "CB-MA-2410", "prepared_for": "Verdant Grid Holdings", "schema_version": "counselbench.decision.v3", "task_id": "cb100-010-verdant-grid"}, "matter_register": {"matter_number": "CB-MA-2410", "rows": [{"decision_option_id": "verdant-grid:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-10-05", "issue": "unreported security incident", "matter_number": "CB-MA-2410", "owner": "Mei Whitaker", "portfolio_key": "CBP-010-01", "row_id": "REG-CBP-010-01", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_corporate/001_corporate_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/02_capitalization/013_capitalization_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/04_debt_security/025_debt_security_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/05_employment/037_employment_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_financials/097_verdant_grid_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "verdant-grid:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-10-04", "issue": "claims-made insurance tail", "matter_number": "CB-MA-2410", "owner": "Theo Laurent", "portfolio_key": "CBP-010-02", "row_id": "REG-CBP-010-02", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_corporate/002_corporate_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/02_capitalization/014_capitalization_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/04_debt_security/026_debt_security_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/05_employment/038_employment_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/07_privacy_security/050_privacy_security_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/08_regulatory/062_regulatory_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_financials/097_verdant_grid_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "verdant-grid:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "the operational record relies on a superseded control revision", "issue": "anti-assignment restriction", "matter_number": "CB-MA-2410", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-010-03", "row_id": "REG-CBP-010-03", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_corporate/003_corporate_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/02_capitalization/015_capitalization_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/04_debt_security/027_debt_security_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/05_employment/039_employment_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/07_privacy_security/051_privacy_security_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/11_tax_insurance/087_tax_insurance_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_financials/097_verdant_grid_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "verdant-grid:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key", "issue": "open-source copyleft exposure", "matter_number": "CB-MA-2410", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-010-04", "row_id": "REG-CBP-010-04", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_corporate/004_corporate_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/02_capitalization/016_capitalization_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/04_debt_security/028_debt_security_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/05_employment/040_employment_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/07_privacy_security/052_privacy_security_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/12_financials/097_verdant_grid_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "verdant-grid:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "the current observation does not meet the operative trigger", "issue": "sales-tax nexus gap", "matter_number": "CB-MA-2410", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-010-05", "row_id": "REG-CBP-010-05", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_corporate/005_corporate_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/017_material_contracts_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/04_debt_security/029_debt_security_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/041_ip_technology_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/09_litigation/065_litigation_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/10_real_property/077_real_property_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_financials/097_verdant_grid_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "verdant-grid:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-30", "issue": "change-of-control consent", "matter_number": "CB-MA-2410", "owner": "Micah Sullivan", "portfolio_key": "CBP-010-06", "row_id": "REG-CBP-010-06", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_corporate/006_corporate_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/018_material_contracts_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/04_debt_security/030_debt_security_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/042_ip_technology_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/12_financials/097_verdant_grid_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "verdant-grid:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "the operational record relies on a superseded control revision", "issue": "invention assignment defect", "matter_number": "CB-MA-2410", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-010-07", "row_id": "REG-CBP-010-07", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_corporate/007_corporate_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/019_material_contracts_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/04_debt_security/031_debt_security_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/043_ip_technology_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/07_privacy_security/055_privacy_security_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_financials/097_verdant_grid_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "verdant-grid:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key", "issue": "facility title exception", "matter_number": "CB-MA-2410", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-010-08", "row_id": "REG-CBP-010-08", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_corporate/008_corporate_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/020_material_contracts_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/04_debt_security/032_debt_security_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/044_ip_technology_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/09_litigation/068_litigation_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/12_financials/097_verdant_grid_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "verdant-grid:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "the current observation does not meet the operative trigger", "issue": "unrecorded option grant", "matter_number": "CB-MA-2410", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-010-09", "row_id": "REG-CBP-010-09", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_capitalization/009_capitalization_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/021_material_contracts_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/05_employment/033_employment_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/045_ip_technology_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/09_litigation/069_litigation_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_financials/097_verdant_grid_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "verdant-grid:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective", "issue": "key-person retention gap", "matter_number": "CB-MA-2410", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-010-10", "row_id": "REG-CBP-010-10", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_capitalization/010_capitalization_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/022_material_contracts_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/05_employment/034_employment_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/046_ip_technology_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/09_litigation/070_litigation_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/11_tax_insurance/082_tax_insurance_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/12_financials/097_verdant_grid_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "verdant-grid:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-10-04", "issue": "threatened customer dispute", "matter_number": "CB-MA-2410", "owner": "Talia Brooks", "portfolio_key": "CBP-010-11", "row_id": "REG-CBP-010-11", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_capitalization/011_capitalization_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/023_material_contracts_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/05_employment/035_employment_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/047_ip_technology_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/08_regulatory/059_regulatory_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/11_tax_insurance/083_tax_insurance_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/12_financials/097_verdant_grid_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "verdant-grid:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-10-03", "issue": "charter authorization mismatch", "matter_number": "CB-MA-2410", "owner": "Adrian Mensah", "portfolio_key": "CBP-010-12", "row_id": "REG-CBP-010-12", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_capitalization/012_capitalization_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/024_material_contracts_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/05_employment/036_employment_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/048_ip_technology_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_financials/097_verdant_grid_impact_population.xlsx"]}], "schema_version": "counselbench.matter-register.v3", "task_id": "cb100-010-verdant-grid"}}, "metadata": {"benchmark": "CounselBench-100", "code_license": "Apache-2.0", "data_license": "CC-BY-4.0", "deadline": "2026-10-06", "document_count": 97, "evidence_holds": 7, "jurisdiction": "Delaware", "matter_number": "CB-MA-2410", "mcp_commit": "9a96ea6e5913736f92b88345bf51caeaaa8e719f", "mcp_package": "@modelcontextprotocol/server-filesystem@2026.7.10", "practice_area": "corporate-ma", "reference_tool_calls": 87, "required_evidence_reads": 64, "supported_actions": 5, "synthetic": true, "venue": "Maricopa County, Arizona", "version": "3.1.0"}, "prompt": "I need to know what is proven, what we can do about it, and what is still only an evidence gap. Can Canopy close on the current valuation, or do incentive, land, and acceptance records require a different posture? The target assembles storage systems under state incentives, leases desert test acreage, and may have recognized milestone revenue before customer acceptance. The team needs the call by 2026-10-06. Capture the supported action and the remaining holds so the next reviewer can reproduce the call.", "rubric": {"criteria": [{"category": "investigation", "description": "Inventory the production and use targeted searches to locate records across native formats.", "id": "investigation.discover_production"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Complete every task-specific identity, authority, operations, and approval read before the first state transition.", "id": "investigation.read_before_write"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Inspect designated source metadata before relying on those records.", "id": "investigation.custody_before_write"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "Select the supported option 'verdant-grid:scoped-evidence' after applying the four-part test.", "id": "decision.selected_option"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "Identify both rejected approaches and explain why a one-source shortcut and a blanket hold are wrong.", "id": "decision.alternatives"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-010-01 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_corporate/001_corporate_source_export.md rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-010-01.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_capitalization/013_capitalization_source_export.json for unreported security incident.", "id": "investigation.CBP-010-01.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_debt_security/025_debt_security_source_export.md to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-010-01.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_employment/037_employment_source_export.json.", "id": "investigation.CBP-010-01.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-010-01 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-010-01.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-010-01 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-010-01.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-010-02 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_corporate/002_corporate_source_export.txt rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-010-02.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_capitalization/014_capitalization_source_export.xml for claims-made insurance tail.", "id": "investigation.CBP-010-02.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_debt_security/026_debt_security_source_export.txt to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-010-02.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_employment/038_employment_source_export.xml.", "id": "investigation.CBP-010-02.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-010-02 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-010-02.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-010-02 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-010-02.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-010-03 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_corporate/003_corporate_source_export.eml rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-010-03.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_capitalization/015_capitalization_source_export.html for anti-assignment restriction.", "id": "investigation.CBP-010-03.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_debt_security/027_debt_security_source_export.eml to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-010-03.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_employment/039_employment_source_export.html.", "id": "investigation.CBP-010-03.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-010-03 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is the operational record relies on a superseded control revision.", "id": "decision.CBP-010-03.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-010-03 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-010-03.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-010-04 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_corporate/004_corporate_source_export.csv rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-010-04.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_capitalization/016_capitalization_source_export.pdf for open-source copyleft exposure.", "id": "investigation.CBP-010-04.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_debt_security/028_debt_security_source_export.csv to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-010-04.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_employment/040_employment_source_export.pdf.", "id": "investigation.CBP-010-04.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-010-04 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key.", "id": "decision.CBP-010-04.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-010-04 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-010-04.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-010-05 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_corporate/005_corporate_source_export.json rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-010-05.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/017_material_contracts_source_export.md for sales-tax nexus gap.", "id": "investigation.CBP-010-05.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_debt_security/029_debt_security_source_export.json to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-010-05.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/041_ip_technology_source_export.md.", "id": "investigation.CBP-010-05.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-010-05 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is the current observation does not meet the operative trigger.", "id": "decision.CBP-010-05.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-010-05 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-010-05.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-010-06 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_corporate/006_corporate_source_export.xml rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-010-06.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/018_material_contracts_source_export.txt for change-of-control consent.", "id": "investigation.CBP-010-06.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_debt_security/030_debt_security_source_export.xml to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-010-06.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/042_ip_technology_source_export.txt.", "id": "investigation.CBP-010-06.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-010-06 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-010-06.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-010-06 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-010-06.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-010-07 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_corporate/007_corporate_source_export.html rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-010-07.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/019_material_contracts_source_export.eml for invention assignment defect.", "id": "investigation.CBP-010-07.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_debt_security/031_debt_security_source_export.html to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-010-07.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/043_ip_technology_source_export.eml.", "id": "investigation.CBP-010-07.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-010-07 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is the operational record relies on a superseded control revision.", "id": "decision.CBP-010-07.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-010-07 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-010-07.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-010-08 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_corporate/008_corporate_source_export.pdf rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-010-08.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/020_material_contracts_source_export.csv for facility title exception.", "id": "investigation.CBP-010-08.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_debt_security/032_debt_security_source_export.pdf to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-010-08.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/044_ip_technology_source_export.csv.", "id": "investigation.CBP-010-08.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-010-08 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key.", "id": "decision.CBP-010-08.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-010-08 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-010-08.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-010-09 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_capitalization/009_capitalization_source_export.md rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-010-09.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/021_material_contracts_source_export.json for unrecorded option grant.", "id": "investigation.CBP-010-09.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_employment/033_employment_source_export.md to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-010-09.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/045_ip_technology_source_export.json.", "id": "investigation.CBP-010-09.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-010-09 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is the current observation does not meet the operative trigger.", "id": "decision.CBP-010-09.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-010-09 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-010-09.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-010-10 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_capitalization/010_capitalization_source_export.txt rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-010-10.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/022_material_contracts_source_export.xml for key-person retention gap.", "id": "investigation.CBP-010-10.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_employment/034_employment_source_export.txt to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-010-10.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/046_ip_technology_source_export.xml.", "id": "investigation.CBP-010-10.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-010-10 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective.", "id": "decision.CBP-010-10.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-010-10 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-010-10.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-010-11 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_capitalization/011_capitalization_source_export.eml rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-010-11.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/023_material_contracts_source_export.html for threatened customer dispute.", "id": "investigation.CBP-010-11.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_employment/035_employment_source_export.eml to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-010-11.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/047_ip_technology_source_export.html.", "id": "investigation.CBP-010-11.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-010-11 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-010-11.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-010-11 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-010-11.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-010-12 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_capitalization/012_capitalization_source_export.csv rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-010-12.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_material_contracts/024_material_contracts_source_export.pdf for charter authorization mismatch.", "id": "investigation.CBP-010-12.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_employment/036_employment_source_export.csv to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-010-12.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_ip_technology/048_ip_technology_source_export.pdf.", "id": "investigation.CBP-010-12.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-010-12 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-010-12.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-010-12 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-010-12.register"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Write the exact selected option, supported action population, evidence-hold population, facts, owners, deadlines, and citations.", "id": "state.exact_decision"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create one exact register row per portfolio key with no extra, missing, or modified row.", "id": "state.exact_register"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Leave only the three approved deliverables and perform no extra state-changing write.", "id": "state.write_scope_containment"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Read back decision.json, matter-register.json, and advice.md after their final writes.", "id": "state.postwrite_readback"}, {"category": "answer", "description": "Explain the selected recommendation, supported actions, holds, alternatives, and limitations with exact source anchors.", "id": "answer.decision_note"}], "decision_options": [{"approach": "Apply the exact identity, current-state, authority, and revision test. Register supported valuation and closing adjustments and hold stale project revisions.", "id": "verdant-grid:scoped-evidence", "label": "Proceed only with the supported eligibility cure, site condition, or valuation adjustment."}, {"approach": "Use a plausible summary or one source without completing the controlling joins.", "id": "verdant-grid:shortcut", "label": "Treat booked revenue and active production as proof that every condition was satisfied."}, {"approach": "Treat supported actions and genuinely ambiguous records as if they were equally unresolved.", "id": "verdant-grid:blanket-hold", "label": "Freeze the entire matter population"}], "evaluation_narrative": {"authority": "Program rules, executed leases, and customer acceptance evidence govern transfer and revenue treatment.", "observation": "Reconcile incentive eligibility, test-site rights, and milestone acceptance to the same project and period.", "question": "Can Canopy close on the current valuation, or do incentive, land, and acceptance records require a different posture?", "register_action": "Register supported valuation and closing adjustments and hold stale project revisions."}, "gates": ["all_required_evidence_precedes_first_write", "decision_criteria_complete", "register_state_exact", "write_scope_contained", "all_outputs_verified_by_readback"], "metadata_checks": 9, "metric": "weighted_criteria_score", "minimum_tool_calls": 87, "required_deliverables": ["decision.json", "matter-register.json", "advice.md"], "required_document_reads": 64, "type": "deterministic", "weights": {"advice": 0.15, "decision": 0.35, "investigation": 0.25, "state": 0.25}}, "task_id": "cb100-010-verdant-grid", "task_name": "Project Canopy microgrid acquisition", "world_id": "counselbench-filesystem-mcp-v3"}
+{"context_files": ["task_files/cb100-011-atlas-fiber/01_master_agreements/001_master_agreements_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-011-atlas-fiber/01_master_agreements/002_master_agreements_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-011-atlas-fiber/01_master_agreements/003_master_agreements_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-011-atlas-fiber/01_master_agreements/004_master_agreements_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-011-atlas-fiber/01_master_agreements/005_master_agreements_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-011-atlas-fiber/01_master_agreements/006_master_agreements_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-011-atlas-fiber/01_master_agreements/007_master_agreements_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-011-atlas-fiber/01_master_agreements/008_master_agreements_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-011-atlas-fiber/02_order_forms/009_order_forms_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-011-atlas-fiber/02_order_forms/010_order_forms_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-011-atlas-fiber/02_order_forms/011_order_forms_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-011-atlas-fiber/02_order_forms/012_order_forms_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-011-atlas-fiber/02_order_forms/013_order_forms_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-011-atlas-fiber/02_order_forms/014_order_forms_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-011-atlas-fiber/02_order_forms/015_order_forms_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-011-atlas-fiber/02_order_forms/016_order_forms_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-011-atlas-fiber/03_amendments/017_amendments_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-011-atlas-fiber/03_amendments/018_amendments_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-011-atlas-fiber/03_amendments/019_amendments_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-011-atlas-fiber/03_amendments/020_amendments_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-011-atlas-fiber/03_amendments/021_amendments_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-011-atlas-fiber/03_amendments/022_amendments_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-011-atlas-fiber/03_amendments/023_amendments_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-011-atlas-fiber/03_amendments/024_amendments_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-011-atlas-fiber/04_statements_of_work/025_statements_of_work_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-011-atlas-fiber/04_statements_of_work/026_statements_of_work_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-011-atlas-fiber/04_statements_of_work/027_statements_of_work_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-011-atlas-fiber/04_statements_of_work/028_statements_of_work_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-011-atlas-fiber/04_statements_of_work/029_statements_of_work_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-011-atlas-fiber/04_statements_of_work/030_statements_of_work_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-011-atlas-fiber/04_statements_of_work/031_statements_of_work_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-011-atlas-fiber/04_statements_of_work/032_statements_of_work_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-011-atlas-fiber/05_pricing/033_pricing_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-011-atlas-fiber/05_pricing/034_pricing_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-011-atlas-fiber/05_pricing/035_pricing_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-011-atlas-fiber/05_pricing/036_pricing_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-011-atlas-fiber/05_pricing/037_pricing_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-011-atlas-fiber/05_pricing/038_pricing_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-011-atlas-fiber/05_pricing/039_pricing_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-011-atlas-fiber/05_pricing/040_pricing_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-011-atlas-fiber/06_service_levels/041_service_levels_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-011-atlas-fiber/06_service_levels/042_service_levels_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-011-atlas-fiber/06_service_levels/043_service_levels_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-011-atlas-fiber/06_service_levels/044_service_levels_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-011-atlas-fiber/06_service_levels/045_service_levels_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-011-atlas-fiber/06_service_levels/046_service_levels_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-011-atlas-fiber/06_service_levels/047_service_levels_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-011-atlas-fiber/06_service_levels/048_service_levels_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-011-atlas-fiber/07_security_privacy/049_security_privacy_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-011-atlas-fiber/07_security_privacy/050_security_privacy_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-011-atlas-fiber/07_security_privacy/051_security_privacy_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-011-atlas-fiber/07_security_privacy/052_security_privacy_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-011-atlas-fiber/07_security_privacy/053_security_privacy_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-011-atlas-fiber/07_security_privacy/054_security_privacy_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-011-atlas-fiber/07_security_privacy/055_security_privacy_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-011-atlas-fiber/07_security_privacy/056_security_privacy_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-011-atlas-fiber/08_notices/057_notices_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-011-atlas-fiber/08_notices/058_notices_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-011-atlas-fiber/08_notices/059_notices_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-011-atlas-fiber/08_notices/060_notices_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-011-atlas-fiber/08_notices/061_notices_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-011-atlas-fiber/08_notices/062_notices_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-011-atlas-fiber/08_notices/063_notices_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-011-atlas-fiber/08_notices/064_notices_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-011-atlas-fiber/09_invoices/065_invoices_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-011-atlas-fiber/09_invoices/066_invoices_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-011-atlas-fiber/09_invoices/067_invoices_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-011-atlas-fiber/09_invoices/068_invoices_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-011-atlas-fiber/09_invoices/069_invoices_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-011-atlas-fiber/09_invoices/070_invoices_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-011-atlas-fiber/09_invoices/071_invoices_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-011-atlas-fiber/09_invoices/072_invoices_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-011-atlas-fiber/10_correspondence/073_correspondence_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-011-atlas-fiber/10_correspondence/074_correspondence_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-011-atlas-fiber/10_correspondence/075_correspondence_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-011-atlas-fiber/10_correspondence/076_correspondence_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-011-atlas-fiber/10_correspondence/077_correspondence_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-011-atlas-fiber/10_correspondence/078_correspondence_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-011-atlas-fiber/10_correspondence/079_correspondence_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-011-atlas-fiber/10_correspondence/080_correspondence_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-011-atlas-fiber/11_policies/081_policies_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-011-atlas-fiber/11_policies/082_policies_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-011-atlas-fiber/11_policies/083_policies_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-011-atlas-fiber/11_policies/084_policies_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-011-atlas-fiber/11_policies/085_policies_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-011-atlas-fiber/11_policies/086_policies_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-011-atlas-fiber/11_policies/087_policies_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-011-atlas-fiber/11_policies/088_policies_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-011-atlas-fiber/12_renewal_records/089_renewal_records_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-011-atlas-fiber/12_renewal_records/090_renewal_records_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-011-atlas-fiber/12_renewal_records/091_renewal_records_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-011-atlas-fiber/12_renewal_records/092_renewal_records_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-011-atlas-fiber/12_renewal_records/093_renewal_records_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-011-atlas-fiber/12_renewal_records/094_renewal_records_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-011-atlas-fiber/12_renewal_records/095_renewal_records_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-011-atlas-fiber/12_renewal_records/096_renewal_records_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-011-atlas-fiber/12_renewal_records/097_atlas_fiber_impact_population.xlsx"], "gold_output": {"advice_markdown": "# Decision note — Atlas Fiber enterprise customer reset\n\n## Recommendation\n\nUse the reconciled renewal and credit treatment for each exact service instance. The reconciled record supports 9 scoped actions and leaves 3 items on evidence hold.\n\nSelected option: `atlas-fiber:scoped-evidence`.\n\n## Why this is the supported option\n\nMatch each order form and outage record to the migration amendment and customer service instance. The effective amendment hierarchy and measured SLA terms govern renewal and credits.\n\n## Supported actions\n\n### CBP-011-01 — exclusivity carveout breach (high)\n\napproval must come from Leona Park under CB-CC-2501-R175; the effective approval record names Henry Cho under CB-CC-2501-E686. Identity resolves to ENT-011-1000, revision REV-2025.1 is current, and Isaac Romero is active with capacity 5.\n\nAction: Update the contract register only for instances with matched amendments and telemetry. Owner: Isaac Romero; due 2026-09-02.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/001_master_agreements_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/02_order_forms/013_order_forms_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/025_statements_of_work_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/05_pricing/037_pricing_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/07_security_privacy/049_security_privacy_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/097_atlas_fiber_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-011-02 — survival-clause ambiguity (high)\n\nthe controlled population contains 240 records under CB-CC-2501-R438; the certification covers 229 records under CB-CC-2501-E119. Identity resolves to ENT-011-1001, revision REV-2025.2 is current, and Nadine Flores is active with capacity 2.\n\nAction: Update the contract register only for instances with matched amendments and telemetry. Owner: Nadine Flores; due 2026-09-01.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/002_master_agreements_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/02_order_forms/014_order_forms_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/026_statements_of_work_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/05_pricing/038_pricing_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/11_policies/086_policies_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/08_notices/062_notices_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/097_atlas_fiber_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-011-05 — order-form precedence conflict (high)\n\ndelivery must use notices-atlas_fiber_networks@example.test under CB-CC-2501-R257; the only matched receipt used archive-juniper_peak_retail_group@example.test under CB-CC-2501-E268. Identity resolves to ENT-011-1004, revision REV-2025.5 is current, and Theo Laurent is active with capacity 4.\n\nAction: Update the contract register only for instances with matched amendments and telemetry. Owner: Theo Laurent; due 2026-08-29.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/005_master_agreements_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/03_amendments/017_amendments_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/029_statements_of_work_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/06_service_levels/041_service_levels_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/07_security_privacy/053_security_privacy_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/097_atlas_fiber_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-011-06 — service-credit underpayment (high)\n\nan open exception blocks completion under CB-CC-2501-R481; the current status is open and unresolved under CB-CC-2501-E387. Identity resolves to ENT-011-1005, revision REV-2025.6 is current, and Lena Varga is active with capacity 6.\n\nAction: Update the contract register only for instances with matched amendments and telemetry. Owner: Lena Varga; due 2026-08-28.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/006_master_agreements_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/03_amendments/018_amendments_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/030_statements_of_work_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/06_service_levels/042_service_levels_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/090_renewal_records_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/097_atlas_fiber_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-011-07 — insurance-limit deficiency (medium)\n\ncompletion is required by 2026-03-30 under CB-CC-2501-R428; the current event record shows completion on 2026-04-19 under CB-CC-2501-E754. Identity resolves to ENT-011-1006, revision REV-2025.7 is current, and Elliot Mercer is active with capacity 4.\n\nAction: Update the contract register only for instances with matched amendments and telemetry. Owner: Elliot Mercer; due 2026-08-27.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/007_master_agreements_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/03_amendments/019_amendments_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/031_statements_of_work_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/06_service_levels/043_service_levels_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/091_renewal_records_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/07_security_privacy/055_security_privacy_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/097_atlas_fiber_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-011-08 — usage-report inconsistency (critical)\n\nthe controlling threshold is 12% under CB-CC-2501-R755; the independently calculated result is 16% under CB-CC-2501-E350. Identity resolves to ENT-011-1007, revision REV-2025.1 is current, and Sofia Bennett is active with capacity 1.\n\nAction: Update the contract register only for instances with matched amendments and telemetry. Owner: Sofia Bennett; due 2026-08-26.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/008_master_agreements_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/03_amendments/020_amendments_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/032_statements_of_work_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/06_service_levels/044_service_levels_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/097_atlas_fiber_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-011-10 — subprocessor notice lapse (medium)\n\nthe controlled population contains 230 records under CB-CC-2501-R538; the certification covers 220 records under CB-CC-2501-E549. Identity resolves to ENT-011-1009, revision REV-2025.3 is current, and Nora Chen is active with capacity 2.\n\nAction: Update the contract register only for instances with matched amendments and telemetry. Owner: Nora Chen; due 2026-09-02.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/02_order_forms/010_order_forms_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/03_amendments/022_amendments_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/05_pricing/034_pricing_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/06_service_levels/046_service_levels_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/094_renewal_records_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/09_invoices/070_invoices_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/097_atlas_fiber_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-011-11 — invoice currency discrepancy (high)\n\nthe permission is limited to Denver, Colorado under CB-CC-2501-R811; the matched activity occurred in Colorado under CB-CC-2501-E300. Identity resolves to ENT-011-1010, revision REV-2025.4 is current, and Caleb Hassan is active with capacity 5.\n\nAction: Update the contract register only for instances with matched amendments and telemetry. Owner: Caleb Hassan; due 2026-09-01.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/02_order_forms/011_order_forms_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/03_amendments/023_amendments_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/05_pricing/035_pricing_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/06_service_levels/047_service_levels_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/095_renewal_records_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/097_atlas_fiber_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-011-12 — pricing-escalator mismatch (medium)\n\nthe operative cap is $922,000.00 under CB-CC-2501-R915; the matched ledger population totals $978,715.00 under CB-CC-2501-E995. Identity resolves to ENT-011-1011, revision REV-2025.5 is current, and Amara Patel is active with capacity 5.\n\nAction: Update the contract register only for instances with matched amendments and telemetry. Owner: Amara Patel; due 2026-08-31.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/02_order_forms/012_order_forms_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/03_amendments/024_amendments_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/05_pricing/036_pricing_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/06_service_levels/048_service_levels_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/097_atlas_fiber_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n## Evidence holds\n\n- **CBP-011-03 — termination notice defect**: two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key. Next evidence: an approved immutable entity crosswalk. Sources: `/workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/003_master_agreements_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/02_order_forms/015_order_forms_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/027_statements_of_work_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/05_pricing/039_pricing_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/07_security_privacy/051_security_privacy_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/11_policies/087_policies_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/097_atlas_fiber_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-011-04 — audit-right deadline**: the current observation does not meet the operative trigger. Next evidence: a current observation that satisfies the operative trigger. Sources: `/workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/004_master_agreements_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/02_order_forms/016_order_forms_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/028_statements_of_work_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/05_pricing/040_pricing_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/097_atlas_fiber_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-011-09 — minimum-commit shortfall**: the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective. Next evidence: effective approval and an active owner with remaining capacity. Sources: `/workspace/documents/02_order_forms/009_order_forms_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/03_amendments/021_amendments_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/05_pricing/033_pricing_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/06_service_levels/045_service_levels_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/09_invoices/069_invoices_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/11_policies/081_policies_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/097_atlas_fiber_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n## Alternatives considered\n\n- `atlas-fiber:shortcut` — Pick the newest date and largest credit without applying document precedence.: Use a plausible summary or one source without completing the controlling joins.\n- `atlas-fiber:blanket-hold` — Freeze the entire matter population: Treat supported actions and genuinely ambiguous records as if they were equally unresolved.\n\n## Assumptions and limits\n\nThis decision is limited to cb100-011-atlas-fiber, the supplied synthetic records, and the matter state as of 2026-09-03. Similar names, stale revisions, and pending authority are not treated as proof.\n", "decision": {"actions": [{"determination": "approval must come from Leona Park under CB-CC-2501-R175; the effective approval record names Henry Cho under CB-CC-2501-E686. Identity resolves to ENT-011-1000, revision REV-2025.1 is current, and Isaac Romero is active with capacity 5.", "due_date": "2026-09-02", "id": "ACT-CBP-011-01", "identity_id": "ENT-011-1000", "issue": "exclusivity carveout breach", "owner": "Isaac Romero", "portfolio_key": "CBP-011-01", "recommended_action": "Update the contract register only for instances with matched amendments and telemetry. Owner: Isaac Romero; due 2026-09-02.", "severity": "high", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/001_master_agreements_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/02_order_forms/013_order_forms_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/025_statements_of_work_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/05_pricing/037_pricing_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/07_security_privacy/049_security_privacy_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/097_atlas_fiber_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "the controlled population contains 240 records under CB-CC-2501-R438; the certification covers 229 records under CB-CC-2501-E119. Identity resolves to ENT-011-1001, revision REV-2025.2 is current, and Nadine Flores is active with capacity 2.", "due_date": "2026-09-01", "id": "ACT-CBP-011-02", "identity_id": "ENT-011-1001", "issue": "survival-clause ambiguity", "owner": "Nadine Flores", "portfolio_key": "CBP-011-02", "recommended_action": "Update the contract register only for instances with matched amendments and telemetry. Owner: Nadine Flores; due 2026-09-01.", "severity": "high", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/002_master_agreements_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/02_order_forms/014_order_forms_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/026_statements_of_work_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/05_pricing/038_pricing_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/11_policies/086_policies_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/08_notices/062_notices_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/097_atlas_fiber_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "delivery must use notices-atlas_fiber_networks@example.test under CB-CC-2501-R257; the only matched receipt used archive-juniper_peak_retail_group@example.test under CB-CC-2501-E268. Identity resolves to ENT-011-1004, revision REV-2025.5 is current, and Theo Laurent is active with capacity 4.", "due_date": "2026-08-29", "id": "ACT-CBP-011-05", "identity_id": "ENT-011-1004", "issue": "order-form precedence conflict", "owner": "Theo Laurent", "portfolio_key": "CBP-011-05", "recommended_action": "Update the contract register only for instances with matched amendments and telemetry. Owner: Theo Laurent; due 2026-08-29.", "severity": "high", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/005_master_agreements_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/03_amendments/017_amendments_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/029_statements_of_work_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/06_service_levels/041_service_levels_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/07_security_privacy/053_security_privacy_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/097_atlas_fiber_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "an open exception blocks completion under CB-CC-2501-R481; the current status is open and unresolved under CB-CC-2501-E387. Identity resolves to ENT-011-1005, revision REV-2025.6 is current, and Lena Varga is active with capacity 6.", "due_date": "2026-08-28", "id": "ACT-CBP-011-06", "identity_id": "ENT-011-1005", "issue": "service-credit underpayment", "owner": "Lena Varga", "portfolio_key": "CBP-011-06", "recommended_action": "Update the contract register only for instances with matched amendments and telemetry. Owner: Lena Varga; due 2026-08-28.", "severity": "high", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/006_master_agreements_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/03_amendments/018_amendments_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/030_statements_of_work_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/06_service_levels/042_service_levels_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/090_renewal_records_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/097_atlas_fiber_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "completion is required by 2026-03-30 under CB-CC-2501-R428; the current event record shows completion on 2026-04-19 under CB-CC-2501-E754. Identity resolves to ENT-011-1006, revision REV-2025.7 is current, and Elliot Mercer is active with capacity 4.", "due_date": "2026-08-27", "id": "ACT-CBP-011-07", "identity_id": "ENT-011-1006", "issue": "insurance-limit deficiency", "owner": "Elliot Mercer", "portfolio_key": "CBP-011-07", "recommended_action": "Update the contract register only for instances with matched amendments and telemetry. Owner: Elliot Mercer; due 2026-08-27.", "severity": "medium", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/007_master_agreements_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/03_amendments/019_amendments_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/031_statements_of_work_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/06_service_levels/043_service_levels_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/091_renewal_records_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/07_security_privacy/055_security_privacy_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/097_atlas_fiber_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "the controlling threshold is 12% under CB-CC-2501-R755; the independently calculated result is 16% under CB-CC-2501-E350. Identity resolves to ENT-011-1007, revision REV-2025.1 is current, and Sofia Bennett is active with capacity 1.", "due_date": "2026-08-26", "id": "ACT-CBP-011-08", "identity_id": "ENT-011-1007", "issue": "usage-report inconsistency", "owner": "Sofia Bennett", "portfolio_key": "CBP-011-08", "recommended_action": "Update the contract register only for instances with matched amendments and telemetry. Owner: Sofia Bennett; due 2026-08-26.", "severity": "critical", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/008_master_agreements_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/03_amendments/020_amendments_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/032_statements_of_work_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/06_service_levels/044_service_levels_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/097_atlas_fiber_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "the controlled population contains 230 records under CB-CC-2501-R538; the certification covers 220 records under CB-CC-2501-E549. Identity resolves to ENT-011-1009, revision REV-2025.3 is current, and Nora Chen is active with capacity 2.", "due_date": "2026-09-02", "id": "ACT-CBP-011-10", "identity_id": "ENT-011-1009", "issue": "subprocessor notice lapse", "owner": "Nora Chen", "portfolio_key": "CBP-011-10", "recommended_action": "Update the contract register only for instances with matched amendments and telemetry. Owner: Nora Chen; due 2026-09-02.", "severity": "medium", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_order_forms/010_order_forms_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/03_amendments/022_amendments_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/05_pricing/034_pricing_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/06_service_levels/046_service_levels_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/094_renewal_records_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/09_invoices/070_invoices_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/097_atlas_fiber_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "the permission is limited to Denver, Colorado under CB-CC-2501-R811; the matched activity occurred in Colorado under CB-CC-2501-E300. Identity resolves to ENT-011-1010, revision REV-2025.4 is current, and Caleb Hassan is active with capacity 5.", "due_date": "2026-09-01", "id": "ACT-CBP-011-11", "identity_id": "ENT-011-1010", "issue": "invoice currency discrepancy", "owner": "Caleb Hassan", "portfolio_key": "CBP-011-11", "recommended_action": "Update the contract register only for instances with matched amendments and telemetry. Owner: Caleb Hassan; due 2026-09-01.", "severity": "high", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_order_forms/011_order_forms_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/03_amendments/023_amendments_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/05_pricing/035_pricing_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/06_service_levels/047_service_levels_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/095_renewal_records_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/097_atlas_fiber_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "the operative cap is $922,000.00 under CB-CC-2501-R915; the matched ledger population totals $978,715.00 under CB-CC-2501-E995. Identity resolves to ENT-011-1011, revision REV-2025.5 is current, and Amara Patel is active with capacity 5.", "due_date": "2026-08-31", "id": "ACT-CBP-011-12", "identity_id": "ENT-011-1011", "issue": "pricing-escalator mismatch", "owner": "Amara Patel", "portfolio_key": "CBP-011-12", "recommended_action": "Update the contract register only for instances with matched amendments and telemetry. Owner: Amara Patel; due 2026-08-31.", "severity": "medium", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_order_forms/012_order_forms_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/03_amendments/024_amendments_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/05_pricing/036_pricing_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/06_service_levels/048_service_levels_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/097_atlas_fiber_impact_population.xlsx"]}], "as_of": "2026-09-03", "decision": {"alternatives_considered": ["atlas-fiber:shortcut", "atlas-fiber:blanket-hold"], "question": "When can we reset Atlas Fiber, and which renewal date and service-credit position should operations use?", "rationale": "The four-part causal test supports 9 scoped actions and leaves 3 records on evidence hold. The effective amendment hierarchy and measured SLA terms govern renewal and credits.", "recommendation": "Use the reconciled renewal and credit treatment for each exact service instance.", "selected_option_id": "atlas-fiber:scoped-evidence"}, "holds": [{"id": "HOLD-CBP-011-03", "issue": "termination notice defect", "portfolio_key": "CBP-011-03", "reason": "two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key", "required_next_evidence": "an approved immutable entity crosswalk", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/003_master_agreements_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/02_order_forms/015_order_forms_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/027_statements_of_work_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/05_pricing/039_pricing_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/07_security_privacy/051_security_privacy_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/11_policies/087_policies_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/097_atlas_fiber_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-011-04", "issue": "audit-right deadline", "portfolio_key": "CBP-011-04", "reason": "the current observation does not meet the operative trigger", "required_next_evidence": "a current observation that satisfies the operative trigger", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/004_master_agreements_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/02_order_forms/016_order_forms_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/028_statements_of_work_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/05_pricing/040_pricing_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/097_atlas_fiber_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-011-09", "issue": "minimum-commit shortfall", "portfolio_key": "CBP-011-09", "reason": "the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective", "required_next_evidence": "effective approval and an active owner with remaining capacity", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_order_forms/009_order_forms_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/03_amendments/021_amendments_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/05_pricing/033_pricing_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/06_service_levels/045_service_levels_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/09_invoices/069_invoices_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/11_policies/081_policies_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/097_atlas_fiber_impact_population.xlsx"]}], "matter_number": "CB-CC-2501", "prepared_for": "Atlas Fiber Networks", "schema_version": "counselbench.decision.v3", "task_id": "cb100-011-atlas-fiber"}, "matter_register": {"matter_number": "CB-CC-2501", "rows": [{"decision_option_id": "atlas-fiber:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-02", "issue": "exclusivity carveout breach", "matter_number": "CB-CC-2501", "owner": "Isaac Romero", "portfolio_key": "CBP-011-01", "row_id": "REG-CBP-011-01", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/001_master_agreements_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/02_order_forms/013_order_forms_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/025_statements_of_work_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/05_pricing/037_pricing_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/07_security_privacy/049_security_privacy_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/097_atlas_fiber_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "atlas-fiber:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-01", "issue": "survival-clause ambiguity", "matter_number": "CB-CC-2501", "owner": "Nadine Flores", "portfolio_key": "CBP-011-02", "row_id": "REG-CBP-011-02", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/002_master_agreements_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/02_order_forms/014_order_forms_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/026_statements_of_work_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/05_pricing/038_pricing_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/11_policies/086_policies_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/08_notices/062_notices_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/097_atlas_fiber_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "atlas-fiber:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key", "issue": "termination notice defect", "matter_number": "CB-CC-2501", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-011-03", "row_id": "REG-CBP-011-03", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/003_master_agreements_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/02_order_forms/015_order_forms_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/027_statements_of_work_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/05_pricing/039_pricing_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/07_security_privacy/051_security_privacy_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/11_policies/087_policies_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/097_atlas_fiber_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "atlas-fiber:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "the current observation does not meet the operative trigger", "issue": "audit-right deadline", "matter_number": "CB-CC-2501", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-011-04", "row_id": "REG-CBP-011-04", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/004_master_agreements_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/02_order_forms/016_order_forms_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/028_statements_of_work_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/05_pricing/040_pricing_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/097_atlas_fiber_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "atlas-fiber:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-08-29", "issue": "order-form precedence conflict", "matter_number": "CB-CC-2501", "owner": "Theo Laurent", "portfolio_key": "CBP-011-05", "row_id": "REG-CBP-011-05", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/005_master_agreements_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/03_amendments/017_amendments_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/029_statements_of_work_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/06_service_levels/041_service_levels_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/07_security_privacy/053_security_privacy_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/097_atlas_fiber_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "atlas-fiber:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-08-28", "issue": "service-credit underpayment", "matter_number": "CB-CC-2501", "owner": "Lena Varga", "portfolio_key": "CBP-011-06", "row_id": "REG-CBP-011-06", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/006_master_agreements_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/03_amendments/018_amendments_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/030_statements_of_work_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/06_service_levels/042_service_levels_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/090_renewal_records_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/097_atlas_fiber_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "atlas-fiber:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-08-27", "issue": "insurance-limit deficiency", "matter_number": "CB-CC-2501", "owner": "Elliot Mercer", "portfolio_key": "CBP-011-07", "row_id": "REG-CBP-011-07", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/007_master_agreements_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/03_amendments/019_amendments_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/031_statements_of_work_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/06_service_levels/043_service_levels_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/091_renewal_records_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/07_security_privacy/055_security_privacy_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/097_atlas_fiber_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "atlas-fiber:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-08-26", "issue": "usage-report inconsistency", "matter_number": "CB-CC-2501", "owner": "Sofia Bennett", "portfolio_key": "CBP-011-08", "row_id": "REG-CBP-011-08", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/008_master_agreements_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/03_amendments/020_amendments_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/032_statements_of_work_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/06_service_levels/044_service_levels_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/097_atlas_fiber_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "atlas-fiber:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective", "issue": "minimum-commit shortfall", "matter_number": "CB-CC-2501", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-011-09", "row_id": "REG-CBP-011-09", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_order_forms/009_order_forms_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/03_amendments/021_amendments_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/05_pricing/033_pricing_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/06_service_levels/045_service_levels_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/09_invoices/069_invoices_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/11_policies/081_policies_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/097_atlas_fiber_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "atlas-fiber:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-02", "issue": "subprocessor notice lapse", "matter_number": "CB-CC-2501", "owner": "Nora Chen", "portfolio_key": "CBP-011-10", "row_id": "REG-CBP-011-10", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_order_forms/010_order_forms_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/03_amendments/022_amendments_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/05_pricing/034_pricing_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/06_service_levels/046_service_levels_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/094_renewal_records_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/09_invoices/070_invoices_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/097_atlas_fiber_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "atlas-fiber:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-01", "issue": "invoice currency discrepancy", "matter_number": "CB-CC-2501", "owner": "Caleb Hassan", "portfolio_key": "CBP-011-11", "row_id": "REG-CBP-011-11", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_order_forms/011_order_forms_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/03_amendments/023_amendments_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/05_pricing/035_pricing_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/06_service_levels/047_service_levels_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/095_renewal_records_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/097_atlas_fiber_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "atlas-fiber:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-08-31", "issue": "pricing-escalator mismatch", "matter_number": "CB-CC-2501", "owner": "Amara Patel", "portfolio_key": "CBP-011-12", "row_id": "REG-CBP-011-12", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_order_forms/012_order_forms_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/03_amendments/024_amendments_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/05_pricing/036_pricing_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/06_service_levels/048_service_levels_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/097_atlas_fiber_impact_population.xlsx"]}], "schema_version": "counselbench.matter-register.v3", "task_id": "cb100-011-atlas-fiber"}}, "metadata": {"benchmark": "CounselBench-100", "code_license": "Apache-2.0", "data_license": "CC-BY-4.0", "deadline": "2026-09-03", "document_count": 97, "evidence_holds": 3, "jurisdiction": "Colorado", "matter_number": "CB-CC-2501", "mcp_commit": "9a96ea6e5913736f92b88345bf51caeaaa8e719f", "mcp_package": "@modelcontextprotocol/server-filesystem@2026.7.10", "practice_area": "commercial-contracts", "reference_tool_calls": 93, "required_evidence_reads": 64, "supported_actions": 9, "synthetic": true, "venue": "Denver, Colorado", "version": "3.1.0"}, "prompt": "I need a straight answer before the next partner call. When can we reset Atlas Fiber, and which renewal date and service-credit position should operations use? A five-year network agreement has three order forms, disputed uptime credits, and competing renewal dates created by a migration amendment. The team needs the call by 2026-09-03. Update the matter record only where the evidence supports it, and give me the practical options for the client.", "rubric": {"criteria": [{"category": "investigation", "description": "Inventory the production and use targeted searches to locate records across native formats.", "id": "investigation.discover_production"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Complete every task-specific identity, authority, operations, and approval read before the first state transition.", "id": "investigation.read_before_write"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Inspect designated source metadata before relying on those records.", "id": "investigation.custody_before_write"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "Select the supported option 'atlas-fiber:scoped-evidence' after applying the four-part test.", "id": "decision.selected_option"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "Identify both rejected approaches and explain why a one-source shortcut and a blanket hold are wrong.", "id": "decision.alternatives"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-011-01 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/001_master_agreements_source_export.md rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-011-01.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_order_forms/013_order_forms_source_export.json for exclusivity carveout breach.", "id": "investigation.CBP-011-01.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/025_statements_of_work_source_export.md to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-011-01.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_pricing/037_pricing_source_export.json.", "id": "investigation.CBP-011-01.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-011-01 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-011-01.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-011-01 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-011-01.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-011-02 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/002_master_agreements_source_export.txt rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-011-02.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_order_forms/014_order_forms_source_export.xml for survival-clause ambiguity.", "id": "investigation.CBP-011-02.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/026_statements_of_work_source_export.txt to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-011-02.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_pricing/038_pricing_source_export.xml.", "id": "investigation.CBP-011-02.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-011-02 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-011-02.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-011-02 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-011-02.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-011-03 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/003_master_agreements_source_export.eml rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-011-03.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_order_forms/015_order_forms_source_export.html for termination notice defect.", "id": "investigation.CBP-011-03.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/027_statements_of_work_source_export.eml to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-011-03.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_pricing/039_pricing_source_export.html.", "id": "investigation.CBP-011-03.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-011-03 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key.", "id": "decision.CBP-011-03.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-011-03 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-011-03.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-011-04 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/004_master_agreements_source_export.csv rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-011-04.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_order_forms/016_order_forms_source_export.pdf for audit-right deadline.", "id": "investigation.CBP-011-04.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/028_statements_of_work_source_export.csv to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-011-04.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_pricing/040_pricing_source_export.pdf.", "id": "investigation.CBP-011-04.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-011-04 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is the current observation does not meet the operative trigger.", "id": "decision.CBP-011-04.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-011-04 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-011-04.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-011-05 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/005_master_agreements_source_export.json rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-011-05.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_amendments/017_amendments_source_export.md for order-form precedence conflict.", "id": "investigation.CBP-011-05.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/029_statements_of_work_source_export.json to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-011-05.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_service_levels/041_service_levels_source_export.md.", "id": "investigation.CBP-011-05.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-011-05 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-011-05.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-011-05 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-011-05.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-011-06 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/006_master_agreements_source_export.xml rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-011-06.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_amendments/018_amendments_source_export.txt for service-credit underpayment.", "id": "investigation.CBP-011-06.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/030_statements_of_work_source_export.xml to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-011-06.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_service_levels/042_service_levels_source_export.txt.", "id": "investigation.CBP-011-06.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-011-06 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-011-06.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-011-06 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-011-06.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-011-07 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/007_master_agreements_source_export.html rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-011-07.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_amendments/019_amendments_source_export.eml for insurance-limit deficiency.", "id": "investigation.CBP-011-07.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/031_statements_of_work_source_export.html to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-011-07.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_service_levels/043_service_levels_source_export.eml.", "id": "investigation.CBP-011-07.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-011-07 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-011-07.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-011-07 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-011-07.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-011-08 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/008_master_agreements_source_export.pdf rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-011-08.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_amendments/020_amendments_source_export.csv for usage-report inconsistency.", "id": "investigation.CBP-011-08.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/032_statements_of_work_source_export.pdf to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-011-08.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_service_levels/044_service_levels_source_export.csv.", "id": "investigation.CBP-011-08.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-011-08 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-011-08.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-011-08 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-011-08.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-011-09 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_order_forms/009_order_forms_source_export.md rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-011-09.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_amendments/021_amendments_source_export.json for minimum-commit shortfall.", "id": "investigation.CBP-011-09.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_pricing/033_pricing_source_export.md to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-011-09.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_service_levels/045_service_levels_source_export.json.", "id": "investigation.CBP-011-09.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-011-09 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective.", "id": "decision.CBP-011-09.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-011-09 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-011-09.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-011-10 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_order_forms/010_order_forms_source_export.txt rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-011-10.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_amendments/022_amendments_source_export.xml for subprocessor notice lapse.", "id": "investigation.CBP-011-10.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_pricing/034_pricing_source_export.txt to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-011-10.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_service_levels/046_service_levels_source_export.xml.", "id": "investigation.CBP-011-10.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-011-10 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-011-10.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-011-10 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-011-10.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-011-11 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_order_forms/011_order_forms_source_export.eml rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-011-11.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_amendments/023_amendments_source_export.html for invoice currency discrepancy.", "id": "investigation.CBP-011-11.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_pricing/035_pricing_source_export.eml to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-011-11.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_service_levels/047_service_levels_source_export.html.", "id": "investigation.CBP-011-11.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-011-11 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-011-11.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-011-11 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-011-11.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-011-12 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_order_forms/012_order_forms_source_export.csv rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-011-12.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_amendments/024_amendments_source_export.pdf for pricing-escalator mismatch.", "id": "investigation.CBP-011-12.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_pricing/036_pricing_source_export.csv to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-011-12.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_service_levels/048_service_levels_source_export.pdf.", "id": "investigation.CBP-011-12.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-011-12 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-011-12.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-011-12 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-011-12.register"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Write the exact selected option, supported action population, evidence-hold population, facts, owners, deadlines, and citations.", "id": "state.exact_decision"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create one exact register row per portfolio key with no extra, missing, or modified row.", "id": "state.exact_register"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Leave only the three approved deliverables and perform no extra state-changing write.", "id": "state.write_scope_containment"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Read back decision.json, matter-register.json, and advice.md after their final writes.", "id": "state.postwrite_readback"}, {"category": "answer", "description": "Explain the selected recommendation, supported actions, holds, alternatives, and limitations with exact source anchors.", "id": "answer.decision_note"}], "decision_options": [{"approach": "Use a plausible summary or one source without completing the controlling joins.", "id": "atlas-fiber:shortcut", "label": "Pick the newest date and largest credit without applying document precedence."}, {"approach": "Treat supported actions and genuinely ambiguous records as if they were equally unresolved.", "id": "atlas-fiber:blanket-hold", "label": "Freeze the entire matter population"}, {"approach": "Apply the exact identity, current-state, authority, and revision test. Update the contract register only for instances with matched amendments and telemetry.", "id": "atlas-fiber:scoped-evidence", "label": "Use the reconciled renewal and credit treatment for each exact service instance."}], "evaluation_narrative": {"authority": "The effective amendment hierarchy and measured SLA terms govern renewal and credits.", "observation": "Match each order form and outage record to the migration amendment and customer service instance.", "question": "When can we reset Atlas Fiber, and which renewal date and service-credit position should operations use?", "register_action": "Update the contract register only for instances with matched amendments and telemetry."}, "gates": ["all_required_evidence_precedes_first_write", "decision_criteria_complete", "register_state_exact", "write_scope_contained", "all_outputs_verified_by_readback"], "metadata_checks": 12, "metric": "weighted_criteria_score", "minimum_tool_calls": 93, "required_deliverables": ["decision.json", "matter-register.json", "advice.md"], "required_document_reads": 64, "type": "deterministic", "weights": {"advice": 0.15, "decision": 0.35, "investigation": 0.25, "state": 0.25}}, "task_id": "cb100-011-atlas-fiber", "task_name": "Atlas Fiber enterprise customer reset", "world_id": "counselbench-filesystem-mcp-v3"}
+{"context_files": ["task_files/cb100-012-banyan-payments/01_master_agreements/001_master_agreements_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-012-banyan-payments/01_master_agreements/002_master_agreements_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-012-banyan-payments/01_master_agreements/003_master_agreements_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-012-banyan-payments/01_master_agreements/004_master_agreements_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-012-banyan-payments/01_master_agreements/005_master_agreements_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-012-banyan-payments/01_master_agreements/006_master_agreements_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-012-banyan-payments/01_master_agreements/007_master_agreements_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-012-banyan-payments/01_master_agreements/008_master_agreements_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-012-banyan-payments/02_order_forms/009_order_forms_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-012-banyan-payments/02_order_forms/010_order_forms_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-012-banyan-payments/02_order_forms/011_order_forms_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-012-banyan-payments/02_order_forms/012_order_forms_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-012-banyan-payments/02_order_forms/013_order_forms_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-012-banyan-payments/02_order_forms/014_order_forms_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-012-banyan-payments/02_order_forms/015_order_forms_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-012-banyan-payments/02_order_forms/016_order_forms_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-012-banyan-payments/03_amendments/017_amendments_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-012-banyan-payments/03_amendments/018_amendments_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-012-banyan-payments/03_amendments/019_amendments_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-012-banyan-payments/03_amendments/020_amendments_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-012-banyan-payments/03_amendments/021_amendments_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-012-banyan-payments/03_amendments/022_amendments_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-012-banyan-payments/03_amendments/023_amendments_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-012-banyan-payments/03_amendments/024_amendments_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-012-banyan-payments/04_statements_of_work/025_statements_of_work_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-012-banyan-payments/04_statements_of_work/026_statements_of_work_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-012-banyan-payments/04_statements_of_work/027_statements_of_work_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-012-banyan-payments/04_statements_of_work/028_statements_of_work_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-012-banyan-payments/04_statements_of_work/029_statements_of_work_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-012-banyan-payments/04_statements_of_work/030_statements_of_work_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-012-banyan-payments/04_statements_of_work/031_statements_of_work_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-012-banyan-payments/04_statements_of_work/032_statements_of_work_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-012-banyan-payments/05_pricing/033_pricing_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-012-banyan-payments/05_pricing/034_pricing_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-012-banyan-payments/05_pricing/035_pricing_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-012-banyan-payments/05_pricing/036_pricing_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-012-banyan-payments/05_pricing/037_pricing_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-012-banyan-payments/05_pricing/038_pricing_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-012-banyan-payments/05_pricing/039_pricing_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-012-banyan-payments/05_pricing/040_pricing_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-012-banyan-payments/06_service_levels/041_service_levels_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-012-banyan-payments/06_service_levels/042_service_levels_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-012-banyan-payments/06_service_levels/043_service_levels_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-012-banyan-payments/06_service_levels/044_service_levels_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-012-banyan-payments/06_service_levels/045_service_levels_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-012-banyan-payments/06_service_levels/046_service_levels_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-012-banyan-payments/06_service_levels/047_service_levels_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-012-banyan-payments/06_service_levels/048_service_levels_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-012-banyan-payments/07_security_privacy/049_security_privacy_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-012-banyan-payments/07_security_privacy/050_security_privacy_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-012-banyan-payments/07_security_privacy/051_security_privacy_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-012-banyan-payments/07_security_privacy/052_security_privacy_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-012-banyan-payments/07_security_privacy/053_security_privacy_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-012-banyan-payments/07_security_privacy/054_security_privacy_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-012-banyan-payments/07_security_privacy/055_security_privacy_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-012-banyan-payments/07_security_privacy/056_security_privacy_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-012-banyan-payments/08_notices/057_notices_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-012-banyan-payments/08_notices/058_notices_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-012-banyan-payments/08_notices/059_notices_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-012-banyan-payments/08_notices/060_notices_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-012-banyan-payments/08_notices/061_notices_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-012-banyan-payments/08_notices/062_notices_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-012-banyan-payments/08_notices/063_notices_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-012-banyan-payments/08_notices/064_notices_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-012-banyan-payments/09_invoices/065_invoices_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-012-banyan-payments/09_invoices/066_invoices_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-012-banyan-payments/09_invoices/067_invoices_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-012-banyan-payments/09_invoices/068_invoices_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-012-banyan-payments/09_invoices/069_invoices_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-012-banyan-payments/09_invoices/070_invoices_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-012-banyan-payments/09_invoices/071_invoices_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-012-banyan-payments/09_invoices/072_invoices_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-012-banyan-payments/10_correspondence/073_correspondence_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-012-banyan-payments/10_correspondence/074_correspondence_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-012-banyan-payments/10_correspondence/075_correspondence_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-012-banyan-payments/10_correspondence/076_correspondence_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-012-banyan-payments/10_correspondence/077_correspondence_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-012-banyan-payments/10_correspondence/078_correspondence_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-012-banyan-payments/10_correspondence/079_correspondence_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-012-banyan-payments/10_correspondence/080_correspondence_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-012-banyan-payments/11_policies/081_policies_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-012-banyan-payments/11_policies/082_policies_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-012-banyan-payments/11_policies/083_policies_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-012-banyan-payments/11_policies/084_policies_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-012-banyan-payments/11_policies/085_policies_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-012-banyan-payments/11_policies/086_policies_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-012-banyan-payments/11_policies/087_policies_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-012-banyan-payments/11_policies/088_policies_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-012-banyan-payments/12_renewal_records/089_renewal_records_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-012-banyan-payments/12_renewal_records/090_renewal_records_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-012-banyan-payments/12_renewal_records/091_renewal_records_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-012-banyan-payments/12_renewal_records/092_renewal_records_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-012-banyan-payments/12_renewal_records/093_renewal_records_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-012-banyan-payments/12_renewal_records/094_renewal_records_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-012-banyan-payments/12_renewal_records/095_renewal_records_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-012-banyan-payments/12_renewal_records/096_renewal_records_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-012-banyan-payments/12_renewal_records/097_banyan_payments_impact_population.xlsx"], "gold_output": {"advice_markdown": "# Decision note — Banyan acquiring-bank portfolio review\n\n## Recommendation\n\nApply the supported repricing or cure path only where every condition is met. The reconciled record supports 6 scoped actions and leaves 6 items on evidence hold.\n\nSelected option: `banyan-payments:scoped-evidence`.\n\n## Why this is the supported option\n\nReconcile processed volume, security status, and pricing consequences for the same merchant portfolio and year. The executed floor, effective security addendum, and consequence schedule must be read together.\n\n## Supported actions\n\n### CBP-012-03 — assignment consent requirement (medium)\n\nthe controlling threshold is 12% under CB-CC-2502-R197; the independently calculated result is 16% under CB-CC-2502-E635. Identity resolves to ENT-012-1002, revision REV-2026.3 is current, and Priya Raman is active with capacity 4.\n\nAction: Create portfolio-level remedy rows and hold records with mismatched period or security scope. Owner: Priya Raman; due 2026-09-04.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/003_master_agreements_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/02_order_forms/015_order_forms_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/027_statements_of_work_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/05_pricing/039_pricing_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/11_policies/087_policies_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/10_correspondence/075_correspondence_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/097_banyan_payments_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-012-04 — exclusivity carveout breach (critical)\n\napproval must come from Farah Ibrahim under CB-CC-2502-R790; the effective approval record names Caleb Hassan under CB-CC-2502-E193. Identity resolves to ENT-012-1003, revision REV-2026.4 is current, and Isaac Romero is active with capacity 6.\n\nAction: Create portfolio-level remedy rows and hold records with mismatched period or security scope. Owner: Isaac Romero; due 2026-09-03.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/004_master_agreements_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/02_order_forms/016_order_forms_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/028_statements_of_work_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/05_pricing/040_pricing_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/097_banyan_payments_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-012-06 — termination notice defect (high)\n\nthe permission is limited to New York County, New York under CB-CC-2502-R137; the matched activity occurred in New York under CB-CC-2502-E366. Identity resolves to ENT-012-1005, revision REV-2026.6 is current, and Rafael Okafor is active with capacity 4.\n\nAction: Create portfolio-level remedy rows and hold records with mismatched period or security scope. Owner: Rafael Okafor; due 2026-09-01.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/006_master_agreements_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/03_amendments/018_amendments_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/030_statements_of_work_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/06_service_levels/042_service_levels_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/097_banyan_payments_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-012-09 — service-credit underpayment (high)\n\nan open exception blocks completion under CB-CC-2502-R947; the current status is open and unresolved under CB-CC-2502-E149. Identity resolves to ENT-012-1008, revision REV-2026.2 is current, and Lena Varga is active with capacity 3.\n\nAction: Create portfolio-level remedy rows and hold records with mismatched period or security scope. Owner: Lena Varga; due 2026-08-29.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/02_order_forms/009_order_forms_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/03_amendments/021_amendments_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/05_pricing/033_pricing_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/06_service_levels/045_service_levels_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/093_renewal_records_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/097_banyan_payments_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-012-10 — insurance-limit deficiency (medium)\n\ncompletion is required by 2025-09-14 under CB-CC-2502-R831; the current event record shows completion on 2025-10-06 under CB-CC-2502-E725. Identity resolves to ENT-012-1009, revision REV-2026.3 is current, and Elliot Mercer is active with capacity 5.\n\nAction: Create portfolio-level remedy rows and hold records with mismatched period or security scope. Owner: Elliot Mercer; due 2026-09-06.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/02_order_forms/010_order_forms_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/03_amendments/022_amendments_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/05_pricing/034_pricing_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/06_service_levels/046_service_levels_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/097_banyan_payments_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-012-12 — minimum-commit shortfall (medium)\n\napproval must come from Farah Ibrahim under CB-CC-2502-R805; the effective approval record names Rafael Okafor under CB-CC-2502-E617. Identity resolves to ENT-012-1011, revision REV-2026.5 is current, and Micah Sullivan is active with capacity 2.\n\nAction: Create portfolio-level remedy rows and hold records with mismatched period or security scope. Owner: Micah Sullivan; due 2026-09-04.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/02_order_forms/012_order_forms_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/03_amendments/024_amendments_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/05_pricing/036_pricing_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/06_service_levels/048_service_levels_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/096_renewal_records_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/097_banyan_payments_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n## Evidence holds\n\n- **CBP-012-01 — benchmarking right omission**: the operational record relies on a superseded control revision. Next evidence: an operational record using the current effective revision. Sources: `/workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/001_master_agreements_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/02_order_forms/013_order_forms_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/025_statements_of_work_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/05_pricing/037_pricing_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/097_banyan_payments_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-012-02 — renewal date conflict**: two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key. Next evidence: an approved immutable entity crosswalk. Sources: `/workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/002_master_agreements_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/02_order_forms/014_order_forms_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/026_statements_of_work_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/05_pricing/038_pricing_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/097_banyan_payments_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-012-05 — survival-clause ambiguity**: the operational record relies on a superseded control revision. Next evidence: an operational record using the current effective revision. Sources: `/workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/005_master_agreements_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/03_amendments/017_amendments_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/029_statements_of_work_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/06_service_levels/041_service_levels_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/07_security_privacy/053_security_privacy_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/097_banyan_payments_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-012-07 — audit-right deadline**: the current observation does not meet the operative trigger. Next evidence: a current observation that satisfies the operative trigger. Sources: `/workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/007_master_agreements_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/03_amendments/019_amendments_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/031_statements_of_work_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/06_service_levels/043_service_levels_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/097_banyan_payments_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-012-08 — order-form precedence conflict**: the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective. Next evidence: effective approval and an active owner with remaining capacity. Sources: `/workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/008_master_agreements_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/03_amendments/020_amendments_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/032_statements_of_work_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/06_service_levels/044_service_levels_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/092_renewal_records_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/097_banyan_payments_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-012-11 — usage-report inconsistency**: the current observation does not meet the operative trigger. Next evidence: a current observation that satisfies the operative trigger. Sources: `/workspace/documents/02_order_forms/011_order_forms_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/03_amendments/023_amendments_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/05_pricing/035_pricing_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/06_service_levels/047_service_levels_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/11_policies/083_policies_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/095_renewal_records_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/097_banyan_payments_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n## Alternatives considered\n\n- `banyan-payments:blanket-hold` — Freeze the entire matter population: Treat supported actions and genuinely ambiguous records as if they were equally unresolved.\n- `banyan-payments:shortcut` — Apply the harshest consequence to the entire portfolio based on aggregate volume.: Use a plausible summary or one source without completing the controlling joins.\n\n## Assumptions and limits\n\nThis decision is limited to cb100-012-banyan-payments, the supplied synthetic records, and the matter state as of 2026-09-07. Similar names, stale revisions, and pending authority are not treated as proof.\n", "decision": {"actions": [{"determination": "the controlling threshold is 12% under CB-CC-2502-R197; the independently calculated result is 16% under CB-CC-2502-E635. Identity resolves to ENT-012-1002, revision REV-2026.3 is current, and Priya Raman is active with capacity 4.", "due_date": "2026-09-04", "id": "ACT-CBP-012-03", "identity_id": "ENT-012-1002", "issue": "assignment consent requirement", "owner": "Priya Raman", "portfolio_key": "CBP-012-03", "recommended_action": "Create portfolio-level remedy rows and hold records with mismatched period or security scope. Owner: Priya Raman; due 2026-09-04.", "severity": "medium", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/003_master_agreements_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/02_order_forms/015_order_forms_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/027_statements_of_work_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/05_pricing/039_pricing_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/11_policies/087_policies_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/10_correspondence/075_correspondence_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/097_banyan_payments_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "approval must come from Farah Ibrahim under CB-CC-2502-R790; the effective approval record names Caleb Hassan under CB-CC-2502-E193. Identity resolves to ENT-012-1003, revision REV-2026.4 is current, and Isaac Romero is active with capacity 6.", "due_date": "2026-09-03", "id": "ACT-CBP-012-04", "identity_id": "ENT-012-1003", "issue": "exclusivity carveout breach", "owner": "Isaac Romero", "portfolio_key": "CBP-012-04", "recommended_action": "Create portfolio-level remedy rows and hold records with mismatched period or security scope. Owner: Isaac Romero; due 2026-09-03.", "severity": "critical", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/004_master_agreements_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/02_order_forms/016_order_forms_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/028_statements_of_work_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/05_pricing/040_pricing_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/097_banyan_payments_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "the permission is limited to New York County, New York under CB-CC-2502-R137; the matched activity occurred in New York under CB-CC-2502-E366. Identity resolves to ENT-012-1005, revision REV-2026.6 is current, and Rafael Okafor is active with capacity 4.", "due_date": "2026-09-01", "id": "ACT-CBP-012-06", "identity_id": "ENT-012-1005", "issue": "termination notice defect", "owner": "Rafael Okafor", "portfolio_key": "CBP-012-06", "recommended_action": "Create portfolio-level remedy rows and hold records with mismatched period or security scope. Owner: Rafael Okafor; due 2026-09-01.", "severity": "high", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/006_master_agreements_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/03_amendments/018_amendments_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/030_statements_of_work_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/06_service_levels/042_service_levels_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/097_banyan_payments_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "an open exception blocks completion under CB-CC-2502-R947; the current status is open and unresolved under CB-CC-2502-E149. Identity resolves to ENT-012-1008, revision REV-2026.2 is current, and Lena Varga is active with capacity 3.", "due_date": "2026-08-29", "id": "ACT-CBP-012-09", "identity_id": "ENT-012-1008", "issue": "service-credit underpayment", "owner": "Lena Varga", "portfolio_key": "CBP-012-09", "recommended_action": "Create portfolio-level remedy rows and hold records with mismatched period or security scope. Owner: Lena Varga; due 2026-08-29.", "severity": "high", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_order_forms/009_order_forms_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/03_amendments/021_amendments_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/05_pricing/033_pricing_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/06_service_levels/045_service_levels_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/093_renewal_records_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/097_banyan_payments_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "completion is required by 2025-09-14 under CB-CC-2502-R831; the current event record shows completion on 2025-10-06 under CB-CC-2502-E725. Identity resolves to ENT-012-1009, revision REV-2026.3 is current, and Elliot Mercer is active with capacity 5.", "due_date": "2026-09-06", "id": "ACT-CBP-012-10", "identity_id": "ENT-012-1009", "issue": "insurance-limit deficiency", "owner": "Elliot Mercer", "portfolio_key": "CBP-012-10", "recommended_action": "Create portfolio-level remedy rows and hold records with mismatched period or security scope. Owner: Elliot Mercer; due 2026-09-06.", "severity": "medium", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_order_forms/010_order_forms_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/03_amendments/022_amendments_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/05_pricing/034_pricing_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/06_service_levels/046_service_levels_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/097_banyan_payments_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "approval must come from Farah Ibrahim under CB-CC-2502-R805; the effective approval record names Rafael Okafor under CB-CC-2502-E617. Identity resolves to ENT-012-1011, revision REV-2026.5 is current, and Micah Sullivan is active with capacity 2.", "due_date": "2026-09-04", "id": "ACT-CBP-012-12", "identity_id": "ENT-012-1011", "issue": "minimum-commit shortfall", "owner": "Micah Sullivan", "portfolio_key": "CBP-012-12", "recommended_action": "Create portfolio-level remedy rows and hold records with mismatched period or security scope. Owner: Micah Sullivan; due 2026-09-04.", "severity": "medium", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_order_forms/012_order_forms_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/03_amendments/024_amendments_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/05_pricing/036_pricing_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/06_service_levels/048_service_levels_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/096_renewal_records_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/097_banyan_payments_impact_population.xlsx"]}], "as_of": "2026-09-07", "decision": {"alternatives_considered": ["banyan-payments:blanket-hold", "banyan-payments:shortcut"], "question": "What is Banyan actually entitled to do after the volume shortfall?", "rationale": "The four-part causal test supports 6 scoped actions and leaves 6 records on evidence hold. The executed floor, effective security addendum, and consequence schedule must be read together.", "recommendation": "Apply the supported repricing or cure path only where every condition is met.", "selected_option_id": "banyan-payments:scoped-evidence"}, "holds": [{"id": "HOLD-CBP-012-01", "issue": "benchmarking right omission", "portfolio_key": "CBP-012-01", "reason": "the operational record relies on a superseded control revision", "required_next_evidence": "an operational record using the current effective revision", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/001_master_agreements_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/02_order_forms/013_order_forms_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/025_statements_of_work_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/05_pricing/037_pricing_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/097_banyan_payments_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-012-02", "issue": "renewal date conflict", "portfolio_key": "CBP-012-02", "reason": "two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key", "required_next_evidence": "an approved immutable entity crosswalk", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/002_master_agreements_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/02_order_forms/014_order_forms_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/026_statements_of_work_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/05_pricing/038_pricing_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/097_banyan_payments_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-012-05", "issue": "survival-clause ambiguity", "portfolio_key": "CBP-012-05", "reason": "the operational record relies on a superseded control revision", "required_next_evidence": "an operational record using the current effective revision", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/005_master_agreements_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/03_amendments/017_amendments_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/029_statements_of_work_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/06_service_levels/041_service_levels_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/07_security_privacy/053_security_privacy_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/097_banyan_payments_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-012-07", "issue": "audit-right deadline", "portfolio_key": "CBP-012-07", "reason": "the current observation does not meet the operative trigger", "required_next_evidence": "a current observation that satisfies the operative trigger", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/007_master_agreements_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/03_amendments/019_amendments_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/031_statements_of_work_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/06_service_levels/043_service_levels_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/097_banyan_payments_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-012-08", "issue": "order-form precedence conflict", "portfolio_key": "CBP-012-08", "reason": "the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective", "required_next_evidence": "effective approval and an active owner with remaining capacity", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/008_master_agreements_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/03_amendments/020_amendments_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/032_statements_of_work_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/06_service_levels/044_service_levels_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/092_renewal_records_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/097_banyan_payments_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-012-11", "issue": "usage-report inconsistency", "portfolio_key": "CBP-012-11", "reason": "the current observation does not meet the operative trigger", "required_next_evidence": "a current observation that satisfies the operative trigger", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_order_forms/011_order_forms_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/03_amendments/023_amendments_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/05_pricing/035_pricing_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/06_service_levels/047_service_levels_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/11_policies/083_policies_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/095_renewal_records_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/097_banyan_payments_impact_population.xlsx"]}], "matter_number": "CB-CC-2502", "prepared_for": "Banyan Payments, Inc.", "schema_version": "counselbench.decision.v3", "task_id": "cb100-012-banyan-payments"}, "matter_register": {"matter_number": "CB-CC-2502", "rows": [{"decision_option_id": "banyan-payments:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "the operational record relies on a superseded control revision", "issue": "benchmarking right omission", "matter_number": "CB-CC-2502", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-012-01", "row_id": "REG-CBP-012-01", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/001_master_agreements_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/02_order_forms/013_order_forms_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/025_statements_of_work_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/05_pricing/037_pricing_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/097_banyan_payments_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "banyan-payments:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key", "issue": "renewal date conflict", "matter_number": "CB-CC-2502", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-012-02", "row_id": "REG-CBP-012-02", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/002_master_agreements_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/02_order_forms/014_order_forms_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/026_statements_of_work_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/05_pricing/038_pricing_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/097_banyan_payments_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "banyan-payments:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-04", "issue": "assignment consent requirement", "matter_number": "CB-CC-2502", "owner": "Priya Raman", "portfolio_key": "CBP-012-03", "row_id": "REG-CBP-012-03", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/003_master_agreements_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/02_order_forms/015_order_forms_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/027_statements_of_work_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/05_pricing/039_pricing_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/11_policies/087_policies_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/10_correspondence/075_correspondence_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/097_banyan_payments_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "banyan-payments:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-03", "issue": "exclusivity carveout breach", "matter_number": "CB-CC-2502", "owner": "Isaac Romero", "portfolio_key": "CBP-012-04", "row_id": "REG-CBP-012-04", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/004_master_agreements_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/02_order_forms/016_order_forms_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/028_statements_of_work_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/05_pricing/040_pricing_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/097_banyan_payments_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "banyan-payments:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "the operational record relies on a superseded control revision", "issue": "survival-clause ambiguity", "matter_number": "CB-CC-2502", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-012-05", "row_id": "REG-CBP-012-05", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/005_master_agreements_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/03_amendments/017_amendments_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/029_statements_of_work_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/06_service_levels/041_service_levels_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/07_security_privacy/053_security_privacy_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/097_banyan_payments_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "banyan-payments:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-01", "issue": "termination notice defect", "matter_number": "CB-CC-2502", "owner": "Rafael Okafor", "portfolio_key": "CBP-012-06", "row_id": "REG-CBP-012-06", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/006_master_agreements_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/03_amendments/018_amendments_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/030_statements_of_work_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/06_service_levels/042_service_levels_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/097_banyan_payments_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "banyan-payments:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "the current observation does not meet the operative trigger", "issue": "audit-right deadline", "matter_number": "CB-CC-2502", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-012-07", "row_id": "REG-CBP-012-07", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/007_master_agreements_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/03_amendments/019_amendments_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/031_statements_of_work_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/06_service_levels/043_service_levels_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/097_banyan_payments_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "banyan-payments:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective", "issue": "order-form precedence conflict", "matter_number": "CB-CC-2502", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-012-08", "row_id": "REG-CBP-012-08", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/008_master_agreements_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/03_amendments/020_amendments_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/032_statements_of_work_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/06_service_levels/044_service_levels_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/092_renewal_records_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/097_banyan_payments_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "banyan-payments:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-08-29", "issue": "service-credit underpayment", "matter_number": "CB-CC-2502", "owner": "Lena Varga", "portfolio_key": "CBP-012-09", "row_id": "REG-CBP-012-09", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_order_forms/009_order_forms_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/03_amendments/021_amendments_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/05_pricing/033_pricing_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/06_service_levels/045_service_levels_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/093_renewal_records_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/097_banyan_payments_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "banyan-payments:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-06", "issue": "insurance-limit deficiency", "matter_number": "CB-CC-2502", "owner": "Elliot Mercer", "portfolio_key": "CBP-012-10", "row_id": "REG-CBP-012-10", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_order_forms/010_order_forms_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/03_amendments/022_amendments_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/05_pricing/034_pricing_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/06_service_levels/046_service_levels_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/097_banyan_payments_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "banyan-payments:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "the current observation does not meet the operative trigger", "issue": "usage-report inconsistency", "matter_number": "CB-CC-2502", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-012-11", "row_id": "REG-CBP-012-11", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_order_forms/011_order_forms_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/03_amendments/023_amendments_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/05_pricing/035_pricing_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/06_service_levels/047_service_levels_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/11_policies/083_policies_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/095_renewal_records_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/097_banyan_payments_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "banyan-payments:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-04", "issue": "minimum-commit shortfall", "matter_number": "CB-CC-2502", "owner": "Micah Sullivan", "portfolio_key": "CBP-012-12", "row_id": "REG-CBP-012-12", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_order_forms/012_order_forms_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/03_amendments/024_amendments_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/05_pricing/036_pricing_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/06_service_levels/048_service_levels_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/096_renewal_records_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/097_banyan_payments_impact_population.xlsx"]}], "schema_version": "counselbench.matter-register.v3", "task_id": "cb100-012-banyan-payments"}}, "metadata": {"benchmark": "CounselBench-100", "code_license": "Apache-2.0", "data_license": "CC-BY-4.0", "deadline": "2026-09-07", "document_count": 97, "evidence_holds": 6, "jurisdiction": "New York", "matter_number": "CB-CC-2502", "mcp_commit": "9a96ea6e5913736f92b88345bf51caeaaa8e719f", "mcp_package": "@modelcontextprotocol/server-filesystem@2026.7.10", "practice_area": "commercial-contracts", "reference_tool_calls": 81, "required_evidence_reads": 58, "supported_actions": 6, "synthetic": true, "venue": "New York County, New York", "version": "3.1.0"}, "prompt": "The business team is asking whether it can move, and I do not want to answer from the summary deck. What is Banyan actually entitled to do after the volume shortfall? Processing volume dropped below an annual floor while a security addendum and pricing schedule assign different consequences to the same shortfall. The team needs the call by 2026-09-07. Document the scoped result for the team and separate genuine exceptions from unresolved identity or revision questions.", "rubric": {"criteria": [{"category": "investigation", "description": "Inventory the production and use targeted searches to locate records across native formats.", "id": "investigation.discover_production"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Complete every task-specific identity, authority, operations, and approval read before the first state transition.", "id": "investigation.read_before_write"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Inspect designated source metadata before relying on those records.", "id": "investigation.custody_before_write"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "Select the supported option 'banyan-payments:scoped-evidence' after applying the four-part test.", "id": "decision.selected_option"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "Identify both rejected approaches and explain why a one-source shortcut and a blanket hold are wrong.", "id": "decision.alternatives"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-012-01 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/001_master_agreements_source_export.md rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-012-01.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_order_forms/013_order_forms_source_export.json for benchmarking right omission.", "id": "investigation.CBP-012-01.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/025_statements_of_work_source_export.md to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-012-01.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_pricing/037_pricing_source_export.json.", "id": "investigation.CBP-012-01.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-012-01 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is the operational record relies on a superseded control revision.", "id": "decision.CBP-012-01.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-012-01 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-012-01.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-012-02 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/002_master_agreements_source_export.txt rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-012-02.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_order_forms/014_order_forms_source_export.xml for renewal date conflict.", "id": "investigation.CBP-012-02.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/026_statements_of_work_source_export.txt to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-012-02.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_pricing/038_pricing_source_export.xml.", "id": "investigation.CBP-012-02.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-012-02 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key.", "id": "decision.CBP-012-02.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-012-02 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-012-02.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-012-03 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/003_master_agreements_source_export.eml rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-012-03.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_order_forms/015_order_forms_source_export.html for assignment consent requirement.", "id": "investigation.CBP-012-03.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/027_statements_of_work_source_export.eml to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-012-03.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_pricing/039_pricing_source_export.html.", "id": "investigation.CBP-012-03.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-012-03 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-012-03.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-012-03 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-012-03.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-012-04 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/004_master_agreements_source_export.csv rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-012-04.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_order_forms/016_order_forms_source_export.pdf for exclusivity carveout breach.", "id": "investigation.CBP-012-04.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/028_statements_of_work_source_export.csv to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-012-04.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_pricing/040_pricing_source_export.pdf.", "id": "investigation.CBP-012-04.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-012-04 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-012-04.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-012-04 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-012-04.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-012-05 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/005_master_agreements_source_export.json rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-012-05.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_amendments/017_amendments_source_export.md for survival-clause ambiguity.", "id": "investigation.CBP-012-05.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/029_statements_of_work_source_export.json to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-012-05.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_service_levels/041_service_levels_source_export.md.", "id": "investigation.CBP-012-05.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-012-05 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is the operational record relies on a superseded control revision.", "id": "decision.CBP-012-05.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-012-05 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-012-05.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-012-06 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/006_master_agreements_source_export.xml rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-012-06.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_amendments/018_amendments_source_export.txt for termination notice defect.", "id": "investigation.CBP-012-06.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/030_statements_of_work_source_export.xml to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-012-06.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_service_levels/042_service_levels_source_export.txt.", "id": "investigation.CBP-012-06.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-012-06 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-012-06.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-012-06 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-012-06.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-012-07 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/007_master_agreements_source_export.html rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-012-07.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_amendments/019_amendments_source_export.eml for audit-right deadline.", "id": "investigation.CBP-012-07.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/031_statements_of_work_source_export.html to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-012-07.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_service_levels/043_service_levels_source_export.eml.", "id": "investigation.CBP-012-07.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-012-07 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is the current observation does not meet the operative trigger.", "id": "decision.CBP-012-07.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-012-07 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-012-07.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-012-08 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/008_master_agreements_source_export.pdf rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-012-08.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_amendments/020_amendments_source_export.csv for order-form precedence conflict.", "id": "investigation.CBP-012-08.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/032_statements_of_work_source_export.pdf to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-012-08.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_service_levels/044_service_levels_source_export.csv.", "id": "investigation.CBP-012-08.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-012-08 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective.", "id": "decision.CBP-012-08.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-012-08 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-012-08.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-012-09 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_order_forms/009_order_forms_source_export.md rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-012-09.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_amendments/021_amendments_source_export.json for service-credit underpayment.", "id": "investigation.CBP-012-09.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_pricing/033_pricing_source_export.md to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-012-09.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_service_levels/045_service_levels_source_export.json.", "id": "investigation.CBP-012-09.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-012-09 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-012-09.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-012-09 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-012-09.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-012-10 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_order_forms/010_order_forms_source_export.txt rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-012-10.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_amendments/022_amendments_source_export.xml for insurance-limit deficiency.", "id": "investigation.CBP-012-10.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_pricing/034_pricing_source_export.txt to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-012-10.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_service_levels/046_service_levels_source_export.xml.", "id": "investigation.CBP-012-10.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-012-10 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-012-10.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-012-10 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-012-10.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-012-11 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_order_forms/011_order_forms_source_export.eml rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-012-11.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_amendments/023_amendments_source_export.html for usage-report inconsistency.", "id": "investigation.CBP-012-11.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_pricing/035_pricing_source_export.eml to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-012-11.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_service_levels/047_service_levels_source_export.html.", "id": "investigation.CBP-012-11.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-012-11 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is the current observation does not meet the operative trigger.", "id": "decision.CBP-012-11.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-012-11 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-012-11.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-012-12 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_order_forms/012_order_forms_source_export.csv rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-012-12.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_amendments/024_amendments_source_export.pdf for minimum-commit shortfall.", "id": "investigation.CBP-012-12.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_pricing/036_pricing_source_export.csv to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-012-12.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_service_levels/048_service_levels_source_export.pdf.", "id": "investigation.CBP-012-12.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-012-12 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-012-12.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-012-12 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-012-12.register"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Write the exact selected option, supported action population, evidence-hold population, facts, owners, deadlines, and citations.", "id": "state.exact_decision"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create one exact register row per portfolio key with no extra, missing, or modified row.", "id": "state.exact_register"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Leave only the three approved deliverables and perform no extra state-changing write.", "id": "state.write_scope_containment"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Read back decision.json, matter-register.json, and advice.md after their final writes.", "id": "state.postwrite_readback"}, {"category": "answer", "description": "Explain the selected recommendation, supported actions, holds, alternatives, and limitations with exact source anchors.", "id": "answer.decision_note"}], "decision_options": [{"approach": "Treat supported actions and genuinely ambiguous records as if they were equally unresolved.", "id": "banyan-payments:blanket-hold", "label": "Freeze the entire matter population"}, {"approach": "Apply the exact identity, current-state, authority, and revision test. Create portfolio-level remedy rows and hold records with mismatched period or security scope.", "id": "banyan-payments:scoped-evidence", "label": "Apply the supported repricing or cure path only where every condition is met."}, {"approach": "Use a plausible summary or one source without completing the controlling joins.", "id": "banyan-payments:shortcut", "label": "Apply the harshest consequence to the entire portfolio based on aggregate volume."}], "evaluation_narrative": {"authority": "The executed floor, effective security addendum, and consequence schedule must be read together.", "observation": "Reconcile processed volume, security status, and pricing consequences for the same merchant portfolio and year.", "question": "What is Banyan actually entitled to do after the volume shortfall?", "register_action": "Create portfolio-level remedy rows and hold records with mismatched period or security scope."}, "gates": ["all_required_evidence_precedes_first_write", "decision_criteria_complete", "register_state_exact", "write_scope_contained", "all_outputs_verified_by_readback"], "metadata_checks": 7, "metric": "weighted_criteria_score", "minimum_tool_calls": 81, "required_deliverables": ["decision.json", "matter-register.json", "advice.md"], "required_document_reads": 58, "type": "deterministic", "weights": {"advice": 0.15, "decision": 0.35, "investigation": 0.25, "state": 0.25}}, "task_id": "cb100-012-banyan-payments", "task_name": "Banyan acquiring-bank portfolio review", "world_id": "counselbench-filesystem-mcp-v3"}
+{"context_files": ["task_files/cb100-013-cirrus-labs/01_master_agreements/001_master_agreements_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-013-cirrus-labs/01_master_agreements/002_master_agreements_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-013-cirrus-labs/01_master_agreements/003_master_agreements_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-013-cirrus-labs/01_master_agreements/004_master_agreements_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-013-cirrus-labs/01_master_agreements/005_master_agreements_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-013-cirrus-labs/01_master_agreements/006_master_agreements_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-013-cirrus-labs/01_master_agreements/007_master_agreements_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-013-cirrus-labs/01_master_agreements/008_master_agreements_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-013-cirrus-labs/02_order_forms/009_order_forms_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-013-cirrus-labs/02_order_forms/010_order_forms_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-013-cirrus-labs/02_order_forms/011_order_forms_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-013-cirrus-labs/02_order_forms/012_order_forms_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-013-cirrus-labs/02_order_forms/013_order_forms_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-013-cirrus-labs/02_order_forms/014_order_forms_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-013-cirrus-labs/02_order_forms/015_order_forms_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-013-cirrus-labs/02_order_forms/016_order_forms_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-013-cirrus-labs/03_amendments/017_amendments_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-013-cirrus-labs/03_amendments/018_amendments_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-013-cirrus-labs/03_amendments/019_amendments_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-013-cirrus-labs/03_amendments/020_amendments_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-013-cirrus-labs/03_amendments/021_amendments_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-013-cirrus-labs/03_amendments/022_amendments_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-013-cirrus-labs/03_amendments/023_amendments_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-013-cirrus-labs/03_amendments/024_amendments_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-013-cirrus-labs/04_statements_of_work/025_statements_of_work_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-013-cirrus-labs/04_statements_of_work/026_statements_of_work_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-013-cirrus-labs/04_statements_of_work/027_statements_of_work_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-013-cirrus-labs/04_statements_of_work/028_statements_of_work_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-013-cirrus-labs/04_statements_of_work/029_statements_of_work_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-013-cirrus-labs/04_statements_of_work/030_statements_of_work_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-013-cirrus-labs/04_statements_of_work/031_statements_of_work_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-013-cirrus-labs/04_statements_of_work/032_statements_of_work_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-013-cirrus-labs/05_pricing/033_pricing_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-013-cirrus-labs/05_pricing/034_pricing_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-013-cirrus-labs/05_pricing/035_pricing_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-013-cirrus-labs/05_pricing/036_pricing_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-013-cirrus-labs/05_pricing/037_pricing_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-013-cirrus-labs/05_pricing/038_pricing_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-013-cirrus-labs/05_pricing/039_pricing_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-013-cirrus-labs/05_pricing/040_pricing_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-013-cirrus-labs/06_service_levels/041_service_levels_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-013-cirrus-labs/06_service_levels/042_service_levels_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-013-cirrus-labs/06_service_levels/043_service_levels_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-013-cirrus-labs/06_service_levels/044_service_levels_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-013-cirrus-labs/06_service_levels/045_service_levels_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-013-cirrus-labs/06_service_levels/046_service_levels_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-013-cirrus-labs/06_service_levels/047_service_levels_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-013-cirrus-labs/06_service_levels/048_service_levels_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-013-cirrus-labs/07_security_privacy/049_security_privacy_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-013-cirrus-labs/07_security_privacy/050_security_privacy_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-013-cirrus-labs/07_security_privacy/051_security_privacy_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-013-cirrus-labs/07_security_privacy/052_security_privacy_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-013-cirrus-labs/07_security_privacy/053_security_privacy_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-013-cirrus-labs/07_security_privacy/054_security_privacy_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-013-cirrus-labs/07_security_privacy/055_security_privacy_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-013-cirrus-labs/07_security_privacy/056_security_privacy_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-013-cirrus-labs/08_notices/057_notices_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-013-cirrus-labs/08_notices/058_notices_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-013-cirrus-labs/08_notices/059_notices_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-013-cirrus-labs/08_notices/060_notices_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-013-cirrus-labs/08_notices/061_notices_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-013-cirrus-labs/08_notices/062_notices_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-013-cirrus-labs/08_notices/063_notices_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-013-cirrus-labs/08_notices/064_notices_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-013-cirrus-labs/09_invoices/065_invoices_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-013-cirrus-labs/09_invoices/066_invoices_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-013-cirrus-labs/09_invoices/067_invoices_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-013-cirrus-labs/09_invoices/068_invoices_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-013-cirrus-labs/09_invoices/069_invoices_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-013-cirrus-labs/09_invoices/070_invoices_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-013-cirrus-labs/09_invoices/071_invoices_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-013-cirrus-labs/09_invoices/072_invoices_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-013-cirrus-labs/10_correspondence/073_correspondence_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-013-cirrus-labs/10_correspondence/074_correspondence_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-013-cirrus-labs/10_correspondence/075_correspondence_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-013-cirrus-labs/10_correspondence/076_correspondence_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-013-cirrus-labs/10_correspondence/077_correspondence_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-013-cirrus-labs/10_correspondence/078_correspondence_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-013-cirrus-labs/10_correspondence/079_correspondence_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-013-cirrus-labs/10_correspondence/080_correspondence_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-013-cirrus-labs/11_policies/081_policies_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-013-cirrus-labs/11_policies/082_policies_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-013-cirrus-labs/11_policies/083_policies_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-013-cirrus-labs/11_policies/084_policies_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-013-cirrus-labs/11_policies/085_policies_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-013-cirrus-labs/11_policies/086_policies_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-013-cirrus-labs/11_policies/087_policies_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-013-cirrus-labs/11_policies/088_policies_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-013-cirrus-labs/12_renewal_records/089_renewal_records_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-013-cirrus-labs/12_renewal_records/090_renewal_records_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-013-cirrus-labs/12_renewal_records/091_renewal_records_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-013-cirrus-labs/12_renewal_records/092_renewal_records_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-013-cirrus-labs/12_renewal_records/093_renewal_records_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-013-cirrus-labs/12_renewal_records/094_renewal_records_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-013-cirrus-labs/12_renewal_records/095_renewal_records_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-013-cirrus-labs/12_renewal_records/096_renewal_records_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-013-cirrus-labs/12_renewal_records/097_cirrus_labs_impact_population.xlsx"], "gold_output": {"advice_markdown": "# Decision note — Cirrus cloud-reseller reconciliation\n\n## Recommendation\n\nApply the supported exclusivity and reporting treatment by exact account scope. The reconciled record supports 5 scoped actions and leaves 7 items on evidence hold.\n\nSelected option: `cirrus-labs:scoped-evidence`.\n\n## Why this is the supported option\n\nMatch the signed agreement, public-sector accounts, and order-form execution evidence. Executed precedence and modification requirements control; an unsigned form cannot silently amend them.\n\n## Supported actions\n\n### CBP-013-04 — benchmarking right omission (low)\n\nan open exception blocks completion under CB-CC-2503-R418; the current status is open and unresolved under CB-CC-2503-E701. Identity resolves to ENT-013-1003, revision REV-2025.4 is current, and Willa Novak is active with capacity 1.\n\nAction: Record enforceable account restrictions and separate unresolved modification evidence. Owner: Willa Novak; due 2026-09-06.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/004_master_agreements_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/02_order_forms/016_order_forms_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/028_statements_of_work_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/05_pricing/040_pricing_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/07_security_privacy/052_security_privacy_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/097_cirrus_labs_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-013-05 — renewal date conflict (critical)\n\ncompletion is required by 2026-04-26 under CB-CC-2503-R815; the current event record shows completion on 2026-05-25 under CB-CC-2503-E247. Identity resolves to ENT-013-1004, revision REV-2025.5 is current, and Owen Delgado is active with capacity 2.\n\nAction: Record enforceable account restrictions and separate unresolved modification evidence. Owner: Owen Delgado; due 2026-09-05.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/005_master_agreements_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/03_amendments/017_amendments_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/029_statements_of_work_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/06_service_levels/041_service_levels_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/097_cirrus_labs_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-013-06 — assignment consent requirement (critical)\n\nthe controlling threshold is 13% under CB-CC-2503-R222; the independently calculated result is 18% under CB-CC-2503-E160. Identity resolves to ENT-013-1005, revision REV-2025.6 is current, and Priya Raman is active with capacity 6.\n\nAction: Record enforceable account restrictions and separate unresolved modification evidence. Owner: Priya Raman; due 2026-09-04.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/006_master_agreements_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/03_amendments/018_amendments_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/030_statements_of_work_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/06_service_levels/042_service_levels_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/097_cirrus_labs_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-013-10 — audit-right deadline (high)\n\nthe operative cap is $3,682,000.00 under CB-CC-2503-R220; the matched ledger population totals $3,823,820.00 under CB-CC-2503-E265. Identity resolves to ENT-013-1009, revision REV-2025.3 is current, and Mei Whitaker is active with capacity 1.\n\nAction: Record enforceable account restrictions and separate unresolved modification evidence. Owner: Mei Whitaker; due 2026-09-09.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/02_order_forms/010_order_forms_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/03_amendments/022_amendments_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/05_pricing/034_pricing_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/06_service_levels/046_service_levels_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/11_policies/082_policies_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/09_invoices/070_invoices_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/097_cirrus_labs_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-013-11 — order-form precedence conflict (medium)\n\ndelivery must use notices-cirrus_laboratory_cloud_llc@example.test under CB-CC-2503-R137; the only matched receipt used archive-quartzline_resellers_ltd@example.test under CB-CC-2503-E525. Identity resolves to ENT-013-1010, revision REV-2025.4 is current, and Theo Laurent is active with capacity 1.\n\nAction: Record enforceable account restrictions and separate unresolved modification evidence. Owner: Theo Laurent; due 2026-09-08.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/02_order_forms/011_order_forms_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/03_amendments/023_amendments_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/05_pricing/035_pricing_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/06_service_levels/047_service_levels_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/11_policies/083_policies_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/097_cirrus_labs_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n## Evidence holds\n\n- **CBP-013-01 — invoice currency discrepancy**: two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key. Next evidence: an approved immutable entity crosswalk. Sources: `/workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/001_master_agreements_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/02_order_forms/013_order_forms_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/025_statements_of_work_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/05_pricing/037_pricing_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/08_notices/061_notices_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/097_cirrus_labs_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-013-02 — pricing-escalator mismatch**: the current observation does not meet the operative trigger. Next evidence: a current observation that satisfies the operative trigger. Sources: `/workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/002_master_agreements_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/02_order_forms/014_order_forms_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/026_statements_of_work_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/05_pricing/038_pricing_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/07_security_privacy/050_security_privacy_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/097_cirrus_labs_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-013-03 — data-localization conflict**: the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective. Next evidence: effective approval and an active owner with remaining capacity. Sources: `/workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/003_master_agreements_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/02_order_forms/015_order_forms_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/027_statements_of_work_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/05_pricing/039_pricing_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/08_notices/063_notices_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/07_security_privacy/051_security_privacy_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/097_cirrus_labs_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-013-07 — exclusivity carveout breach**: the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective. Next evidence: effective approval and an active owner with remaining capacity. Sources: `/workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/007_master_agreements_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/03_amendments/019_amendments_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/031_statements_of_work_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/06_service_levels/043_service_levels_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/09_invoices/067_invoices_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/10_correspondence/079_correspondence_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/097_cirrus_labs_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-013-08 — survival-clause ambiguity**: the operational record relies on a superseded control revision. Next evidence: an operational record using the current effective revision. Sources: `/workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/008_master_agreements_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/03_amendments/020_amendments_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/032_statements_of_work_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/06_service_levels/044_service_levels_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/097_cirrus_labs_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-013-09 — termination notice defect**: two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key. Next evidence: an approved immutable entity crosswalk. Sources: `/workspace/documents/02_order_forms/009_order_forms_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/03_amendments/021_amendments_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/05_pricing/033_pricing_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/06_service_levels/045_service_levels_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/093_renewal_records_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/11_policies/081_policies_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/097_cirrus_labs_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-013-12 — service-credit underpayment**: the operational record relies on a superseded control revision. Next evidence: an operational record using the current effective revision. Sources: `/workspace/documents/02_order_forms/012_order_forms_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/03_amendments/024_amendments_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/05_pricing/036_pricing_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/06_service_levels/048_service_levels_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/11_policies/084_policies_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/08_notices/060_notices_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/097_cirrus_labs_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n## Alternatives considered\n\n- `cirrus-labs:shortcut` — Treat the reseller's copy of the order form as effective because operations used it.: Use a plausible summary or one source without completing the controlling joins.\n- `cirrus-labs:blanket-hold` — Freeze the entire matter population: Treat supported actions and genuinely ambiguous records as if they were equally unresolved.\n\n## Assumptions and limits\n\nThis decision is limited to cb100-013-cirrus-labs, the supplied synthetic records, and the matter state as of 2026-09-10. Similar names, stale revisions, and pending authority are not treated as proof.\n", "decision": {"actions": [{"determination": "an open exception blocks completion under CB-CC-2503-R418; the current status is open and unresolved under CB-CC-2503-E701. Identity resolves to ENT-013-1003, revision REV-2025.4 is current, and Willa Novak is active with capacity 1.", "due_date": "2026-09-06", "id": "ACT-CBP-013-04", "identity_id": "ENT-013-1003", "issue": "benchmarking right omission", "owner": "Willa Novak", "portfolio_key": "CBP-013-04", "recommended_action": "Record enforceable account restrictions and separate unresolved modification evidence. Owner: Willa Novak; due 2026-09-06.", "severity": "low", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/004_master_agreements_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/02_order_forms/016_order_forms_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/028_statements_of_work_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/05_pricing/040_pricing_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/07_security_privacy/052_security_privacy_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/097_cirrus_labs_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "completion is required by 2026-04-26 under CB-CC-2503-R815; the current event record shows completion on 2026-05-25 under CB-CC-2503-E247. Identity resolves to ENT-013-1004, revision REV-2025.5 is current, and Owen Delgado is active with capacity 2.", "due_date": "2026-09-05", "id": "ACT-CBP-013-05", "identity_id": "ENT-013-1004", "issue": "renewal date conflict", "owner": "Owen Delgado", "portfolio_key": "CBP-013-05", "recommended_action": "Record enforceable account restrictions and separate unresolved modification evidence. Owner: Owen Delgado; due 2026-09-05.", "severity": "critical", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/005_master_agreements_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/03_amendments/017_amendments_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/029_statements_of_work_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/06_service_levels/041_service_levels_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/097_cirrus_labs_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "the controlling threshold is 13% under CB-CC-2503-R222; the independently calculated result is 18% under CB-CC-2503-E160. Identity resolves to ENT-013-1005, revision REV-2025.6 is current, and Priya Raman is active with capacity 6.", "due_date": "2026-09-04", "id": "ACT-CBP-013-06", "identity_id": "ENT-013-1005", "issue": "assignment consent requirement", "owner": "Priya Raman", "portfolio_key": "CBP-013-06", "recommended_action": "Record enforceable account restrictions and separate unresolved modification evidence. Owner: Priya Raman; due 2026-09-04.", "severity": "critical", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/006_master_agreements_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/03_amendments/018_amendments_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/030_statements_of_work_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/06_service_levels/042_service_levels_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/097_cirrus_labs_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "the operative cap is $3,682,000.00 under CB-CC-2503-R220; the matched ledger population totals $3,823,820.00 under CB-CC-2503-E265. Identity resolves to ENT-013-1009, revision REV-2025.3 is current, and Mei Whitaker is active with capacity 1.", "due_date": "2026-09-09", "id": "ACT-CBP-013-10", "identity_id": "ENT-013-1009", "issue": "audit-right deadline", "owner": "Mei Whitaker", "portfolio_key": "CBP-013-10", "recommended_action": "Record enforceable account restrictions and separate unresolved modification evidence. Owner: Mei Whitaker; due 2026-09-09.", "severity": "high", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_order_forms/010_order_forms_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/03_amendments/022_amendments_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/05_pricing/034_pricing_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/06_service_levels/046_service_levels_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/11_policies/082_policies_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/09_invoices/070_invoices_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/097_cirrus_labs_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "delivery must use notices-cirrus_laboratory_cloud_llc@example.test under CB-CC-2503-R137; the only matched receipt used archive-quartzline_resellers_ltd@example.test under CB-CC-2503-E525. Identity resolves to ENT-013-1010, revision REV-2025.4 is current, and Theo Laurent is active with capacity 1.", "due_date": "2026-09-08", "id": "ACT-CBP-013-11", "identity_id": "ENT-013-1010", "issue": "order-form precedence conflict", "owner": "Theo Laurent", "portfolio_key": "CBP-013-11", "recommended_action": "Record enforceable account restrictions and separate unresolved modification evidence. Owner: Theo Laurent; due 2026-09-08.", "severity": "medium", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_order_forms/011_order_forms_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/03_amendments/023_amendments_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/05_pricing/035_pricing_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/06_service_levels/047_service_levels_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/11_policies/083_policies_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/097_cirrus_labs_impact_population.xlsx"]}], "as_of": "2026-09-10", "decision": {"alternatives_considered": ["cirrus-labs:shortcut", "cirrus-labs:blanket-hold"], "question": "Does Cirrus owe the reseller exclusivity, and can the disputed order form change reporting or audit rights?", "rationale": "The four-part causal test supports 5 scoped actions and leaves 7 records on evidence hold. Executed precedence and modification requirements control; an unsigned form cannot silently amend them.", "recommendation": "Apply the supported exclusivity and reporting treatment by exact account scope.", "selected_option_id": "cirrus-labs:scoped-evidence"}, "holds": [{"id": "HOLD-CBP-013-01", "issue": "invoice currency discrepancy", "portfolio_key": "CBP-013-01", "reason": "two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key", "required_next_evidence": "an approved immutable entity crosswalk", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/001_master_agreements_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/02_order_forms/013_order_forms_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/025_statements_of_work_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/05_pricing/037_pricing_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/08_notices/061_notices_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/097_cirrus_labs_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-013-02", "issue": "pricing-escalator mismatch", "portfolio_key": "CBP-013-02", "reason": "the current observation does not meet the operative trigger", "required_next_evidence": "a current observation that satisfies the operative trigger", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/002_master_agreements_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/02_order_forms/014_order_forms_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/026_statements_of_work_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/05_pricing/038_pricing_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/07_security_privacy/050_security_privacy_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/097_cirrus_labs_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-013-03", "issue": "data-localization conflict", "portfolio_key": "CBP-013-03", "reason": "the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective", "required_next_evidence": "effective approval and an active owner with remaining capacity", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/003_master_agreements_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/02_order_forms/015_order_forms_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/027_statements_of_work_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/05_pricing/039_pricing_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/08_notices/063_notices_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/07_security_privacy/051_security_privacy_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/097_cirrus_labs_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-013-07", "issue": "exclusivity carveout breach", "portfolio_key": "CBP-013-07", "reason": "the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective", "required_next_evidence": "effective approval and an active owner with remaining capacity", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/007_master_agreements_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/03_amendments/019_amendments_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/031_statements_of_work_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/06_service_levels/043_service_levels_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/09_invoices/067_invoices_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/10_correspondence/079_correspondence_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/097_cirrus_labs_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-013-08", "issue": "survival-clause ambiguity", "portfolio_key": "CBP-013-08", "reason": "the operational record relies on a superseded control revision", "required_next_evidence": "an operational record using the current effective revision", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/008_master_agreements_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/03_amendments/020_amendments_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/032_statements_of_work_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/06_service_levels/044_service_levels_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/097_cirrus_labs_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-013-09", "issue": "termination notice defect", "portfolio_key": "CBP-013-09", "reason": "two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key", "required_next_evidence": "an approved immutable entity crosswalk", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_order_forms/009_order_forms_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/03_amendments/021_amendments_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/05_pricing/033_pricing_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/06_service_levels/045_service_levels_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/093_renewal_records_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/11_policies/081_policies_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/097_cirrus_labs_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-013-12", "issue": "service-credit underpayment", "portfolio_key": "CBP-013-12", "reason": "the operational record relies on a superseded control revision", "required_next_evidence": "an operational record using the current effective revision", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_order_forms/012_order_forms_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/03_amendments/024_amendments_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/05_pricing/036_pricing_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/06_service_levels/048_service_levels_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/11_policies/084_policies_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/08_notices/060_notices_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/097_cirrus_labs_impact_population.xlsx"]}], "matter_number": "CB-CC-2503", "prepared_for": "Cirrus Laboratory Cloud LLC", "schema_version": "counselbench.decision.v3", "task_id": "cb100-013-cirrus-labs"}, "matter_register": {"matter_number": "CB-CC-2503", "rows": [{"decision_option_id": "cirrus-labs:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key", "issue": "invoice currency discrepancy", "matter_number": "CB-CC-2503", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-013-01", "row_id": "REG-CBP-013-01", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/001_master_agreements_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/02_order_forms/013_order_forms_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/025_statements_of_work_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/05_pricing/037_pricing_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/08_notices/061_notices_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/097_cirrus_labs_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "cirrus-labs:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "the current observation does not meet the operative trigger", "issue": "pricing-escalator mismatch", "matter_number": "CB-CC-2503", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-013-02", "row_id": "REG-CBP-013-02", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/002_master_agreements_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/02_order_forms/014_order_forms_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/026_statements_of_work_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/05_pricing/038_pricing_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/07_security_privacy/050_security_privacy_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/097_cirrus_labs_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "cirrus-labs:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective", "issue": "data-localization conflict", "matter_number": "CB-CC-2503", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-013-03", "row_id": "REG-CBP-013-03", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/003_master_agreements_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/02_order_forms/015_order_forms_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/027_statements_of_work_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/05_pricing/039_pricing_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/08_notices/063_notices_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/07_security_privacy/051_security_privacy_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/097_cirrus_labs_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "cirrus-labs:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-06", "issue": "benchmarking right omission", "matter_number": "CB-CC-2503", "owner": "Willa Novak", "portfolio_key": "CBP-013-04", "row_id": "REG-CBP-013-04", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/004_master_agreements_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/02_order_forms/016_order_forms_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/028_statements_of_work_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/05_pricing/040_pricing_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/07_security_privacy/052_security_privacy_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/097_cirrus_labs_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "cirrus-labs:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-05", "issue": "renewal date conflict", "matter_number": "CB-CC-2503", "owner": "Owen Delgado", "portfolio_key": "CBP-013-05", "row_id": "REG-CBP-013-05", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/005_master_agreements_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/03_amendments/017_amendments_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/029_statements_of_work_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/06_service_levels/041_service_levels_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/097_cirrus_labs_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "cirrus-labs:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-04", "issue": "assignment consent requirement", "matter_number": "CB-CC-2503", "owner": "Priya Raman", "portfolio_key": "CBP-013-06", "row_id": "REG-CBP-013-06", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/006_master_agreements_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/03_amendments/018_amendments_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/030_statements_of_work_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/06_service_levels/042_service_levels_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/097_cirrus_labs_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "cirrus-labs:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective", "issue": "exclusivity carveout breach", "matter_number": "CB-CC-2503", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-013-07", "row_id": "REG-CBP-013-07", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/007_master_agreements_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/03_amendments/019_amendments_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/031_statements_of_work_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/06_service_levels/043_service_levels_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/09_invoices/067_invoices_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/10_correspondence/079_correspondence_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/097_cirrus_labs_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "cirrus-labs:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "the operational record relies on a superseded control revision", "issue": "survival-clause ambiguity", "matter_number": "CB-CC-2503", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-013-08", "row_id": "REG-CBP-013-08", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/008_master_agreements_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/03_amendments/020_amendments_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/032_statements_of_work_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/06_service_levels/044_service_levels_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/097_cirrus_labs_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "cirrus-labs:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key", "issue": "termination notice defect", "matter_number": "CB-CC-2503", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-013-09", "row_id": "REG-CBP-013-09", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_order_forms/009_order_forms_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/03_amendments/021_amendments_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/05_pricing/033_pricing_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/06_service_levels/045_service_levels_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/093_renewal_records_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/11_policies/081_policies_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/097_cirrus_labs_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "cirrus-labs:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-09", "issue": "audit-right deadline", "matter_number": "CB-CC-2503", "owner": "Mei Whitaker", "portfolio_key": "CBP-013-10", "row_id": "REG-CBP-013-10", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_order_forms/010_order_forms_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/03_amendments/022_amendments_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/05_pricing/034_pricing_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/06_service_levels/046_service_levels_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/11_policies/082_policies_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/09_invoices/070_invoices_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/097_cirrus_labs_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "cirrus-labs:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-08", "issue": "order-form precedence conflict", "matter_number": "CB-CC-2503", "owner": "Theo Laurent", "portfolio_key": "CBP-013-11", "row_id": "REG-CBP-013-11", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_order_forms/011_order_forms_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/03_amendments/023_amendments_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/05_pricing/035_pricing_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/06_service_levels/047_service_levels_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/11_policies/083_policies_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/097_cirrus_labs_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "cirrus-labs:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "the operational record relies on a superseded control revision", "issue": "service-credit underpayment", "matter_number": "CB-CC-2503", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-013-12", "row_id": "REG-CBP-013-12", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_order_forms/012_order_forms_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/03_amendments/024_amendments_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/05_pricing/036_pricing_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/06_service_levels/048_service_levels_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/11_policies/084_policies_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/08_notices/060_notices_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/097_cirrus_labs_impact_population.xlsx"]}], "schema_version": "counselbench.matter-register.v3", "task_id": "cb100-013-cirrus-labs"}}, "metadata": {"benchmark": "CounselBench-100", "code_license": "Apache-2.0", "data_license": "CC-BY-4.0", "deadline": "2026-09-10", "document_count": 97, "evidence_holds": 7, "jurisdiction": "Washington", "matter_number": "CB-CC-2503", "mcp_commit": "9a96ea6e5913736f92b88345bf51caeaaa8e719f", "mcp_package": "@modelcontextprotocol/server-filesystem@2026.7.10", "practice_area": "commercial-contracts", "reference_tool_calls": 84, "required_evidence_reads": 64, "supported_actions": 5, "synthetic": true, "venue": "King County, Washington", "version": "3.1.0"}, "prompt": "A late record changed the picture this morning. Does Cirrus owe the reseller exclusivity, and can the disputed order form change reporting or audit rights? A reseller claims exclusivity in public-sector accounts and relies on an unsigned order form that changed usage reporting and audit mechanics. The team needs the call by 2026-09-10. Make the matter record usable by operations after your review, but do not turn ambiguity into an accusation or obligation.", "rubric": {"criteria": [{"category": "investigation", "description": "Inventory the production and use targeted searches to locate records across native formats.", "id": "investigation.discover_production"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Complete every task-specific identity, authority, operations, and approval read before the first state transition.", "id": "investigation.read_before_write"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Inspect designated source metadata before relying on those records.", "id": "investigation.custody_before_write"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "Select the supported option 'cirrus-labs:scoped-evidence' after applying the four-part test.", "id": "decision.selected_option"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "Identify both rejected approaches and explain why a one-source shortcut and a blanket hold are wrong.", "id": "decision.alternatives"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-013-01 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/001_master_agreements_source_export.md rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-013-01.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_order_forms/013_order_forms_source_export.json for invoice currency discrepancy.", "id": "investigation.CBP-013-01.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/025_statements_of_work_source_export.md to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-013-01.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_pricing/037_pricing_source_export.json.", "id": "investigation.CBP-013-01.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-013-01 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key.", "id": "decision.CBP-013-01.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-013-01 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-013-01.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-013-02 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/002_master_agreements_source_export.txt rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-013-02.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_order_forms/014_order_forms_source_export.xml for pricing-escalator mismatch.", "id": "investigation.CBP-013-02.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/026_statements_of_work_source_export.txt to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-013-02.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_pricing/038_pricing_source_export.xml.", "id": "investigation.CBP-013-02.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-013-02 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is the current observation does not meet the operative trigger.", "id": "decision.CBP-013-02.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-013-02 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-013-02.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-013-03 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/003_master_agreements_source_export.eml rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-013-03.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_order_forms/015_order_forms_source_export.html for data-localization conflict.", "id": "investigation.CBP-013-03.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/027_statements_of_work_source_export.eml to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-013-03.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_pricing/039_pricing_source_export.html.", "id": "investigation.CBP-013-03.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-013-03 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective.", "id": "decision.CBP-013-03.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-013-03 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-013-03.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-013-04 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/004_master_agreements_source_export.csv rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-013-04.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_order_forms/016_order_forms_source_export.pdf for benchmarking right omission.", "id": "investigation.CBP-013-04.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/028_statements_of_work_source_export.csv to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-013-04.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_pricing/040_pricing_source_export.pdf.", "id": "investigation.CBP-013-04.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-013-04 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-013-04.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-013-04 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-013-04.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-013-05 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/005_master_agreements_source_export.json rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-013-05.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_amendments/017_amendments_source_export.md for renewal date conflict.", "id": "investigation.CBP-013-05.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/029_statements_of_work_source_export.json to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-013-05.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_service_levels/041_service_levels_source_export.md.", "id": "investigation.CBP-013-05.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-013-05 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-013-05.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-013-05 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-013-05.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-013-06 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/006_master_agreements_source_export.xml rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-013-06.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_amendments/018_amendments_source_export.txt for assignment consent requirement.", "id": "investigation.CBP-013-06.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/030_statements_of_work_source_export.xml to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-013-06.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_service_levels/042_service_levels_source_export.txt.", "id": "investigation.CBP-013-06.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-013-06 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-013-06.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-013-06 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-013-06.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-013-07 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/007_master_agreements_source_export.html rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-013-07.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_amendments/019_amendments_source_export.eml for exclusivity carveout breach.", "id": "investigation.CBP-013-07.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/031_statements_of_work_source_export.html to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-013-07.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_service_levels/043_service_levels_source_export.eml.", "id": "investigation.CBP-013-07.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-013-07 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective.", "id": "decision.CBP-013-07.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-013-07 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-013-07.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-013-08 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/008_master_agreements_source_export.pdf rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-013-08.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_amendments/020_amendments_source_export.csv for survival-clause ambiguity.", "id": "investigation.CBP-013-08.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/032_statements_of_work_source_export.pdf to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-013-08.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_service_levels/044_service_levels_source_export.csv.", "id": "investigation.CBP-013-08.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-013-08 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is the operational record relies on a superseded control revision.", "id": "decision.CBP-013-08.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-013-08 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-013-08.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-013-09 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_order_forms/009_order_forms_source_export.md rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-013-09.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_amendments/021_amendments_source_export.json for termination notice defect.", "id": "investigation.CBP-013-09.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_pricing/033_pricing_source_export.md to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-013-09.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_service_levels/045_service_levels_source_export.json.", "id": "investigation.CBP-013-09.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-013-09 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key.", "id": "decision.CBP-013-09.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-013-09 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-013-09.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-013-10 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_order_forms/010_order_forms_source_export.txt rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-013-10.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_amendments/022_amendments_source_export.xml for audit-right deadline.", "id": "investigation.CBP-013-10.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_pricing/034_pricing_source_export.txt to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-013-10.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_service_levels/046_service_levels_source_export.xml.", "id": "investigation.CBP-013-10.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-013-10 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-013-10.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-013-10 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-013-10.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-013-11 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_order_forms/011_order_forms_source_export.eml rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-013-11.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_amendments/023_amendments_source_export.html for order-form precedence conflict.", "id": "investigation.CBP-013-11.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_pricing/035_pricing_source_export.eml to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-013-11.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_service_levels/047_service_levels_source_export.html.", "id": "investigation.CBP-013-11.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-013-11 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-013-11.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-013-11 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-013-11.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-013-12 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_order_forms/012_order_forms_source_export.csv rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-013-12.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_amendments/024_amendments_source_export.pdf for service-credit underpayment.", "id": "investigation.CBP-013-12.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_pricing/036_pricing_source_export.csv to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-013-12.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_service_levels/048_service_levels_source_export.pdf.", "id": "investigation.CBP-013-12.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-013-12 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is the operational record relies on a superseded control revision.", "id": "decision.CBP-013-12.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-013-12 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-013-12.register"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Write the exact selected option, supported action population, evidence-hold population, facts, owners, deadlines, and citations.", "id": "state.exact_decision"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create one exact register row per portfolio key with no extra, missing, or modified row.", "id": "state.exact_register"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Leave only the three approved deliverables and perform no extra state-changing write.", "id": "state.write_scope_containment"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Read back decision.json, matter-register.json, and advice.md after their final writes.", "id": "state.postwrite_readback"}, {"category": "answer", "description": "Explain the selected recommendation, supported actions, holds, alternatives, and limitations with exact source anchors.", "id": "answer.decision_note"}], "decision_options": [{"approach": "Apply the exact identity, current-state, authority, and revision test. Record enforceable account restrictions and separate unresolved modification evidence.", "id": "cirrus-labs:scoped-evidence", "label": "Apply the supported exclusivity and reporting treatment by exact account scope."}, {"approach": "Use a plausible summary or one source without completing the controlling joins.", "id": "cirrus-labs:shortcut", "label": "Treat the reseller's copy of the order form as effective because operations used it."}, {"approach": "Treat supported actions and genuinely ambiguous records as if they were equally unresolved.", "id": "cirrus-labs:blanket-hold", "label": "Freeze the entire matter population"}], "evaluation_narrative": {"authority": "Executed precedence and modification requirements control; an unsigned form cannot silently amend them.", "observation": "Match the signed agreement, public-sector accounts, and order-form execution evidence.", "question": "Does Cirrus owe the reseller exclusivity, and can the disputed order form change reporting or audit rights?", "register_action": "Record enforceable account restrictions and separate unresolved modification evidence."}, "gates": ["all_required_evidence_precedes_first_write", "decision_criteria_complete", "register_state_exact", "write_scope_contained", "all_outputs_verified_by_readback"], "metadata_checks": 8, "metric": "weighted_criteria_score", "minimum_tool_calls": 84, "required_deliverables": ["decision.json", "matter-register.json", "advice.md"], "required_document_reads": 64, "type": "deterministic", "weights": {"advice": 0.15, "decision": 0.35, "investigation": 0.25, "state": 0.25}}, "task_id": "cb100-013-cirrus-labs", "task_name": "Cirrus cloud-reseller reconciliation", "world_id": "counselbench-filesystem-mcp-v3"}
+{"context_files": ["task_files/cb100-014-driftwood-media/01_master_agreements/001_master_agreements_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-014-driftwood-media/01_master_agreements/002_master_agreements_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-014-driftwood-media/01_master_agreements/003_master_agreements_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-014-driftwood-media/01_master_agreements/004_master_agreements_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-014-driftwood-media/01_master_agreements/005_master_agreements_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-014-driftwood-media/01_master_agreements/006_master_agreements_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-014-driftwood-media/01_master_agreements/007_master_agreements_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-014-driftwood-media/01_master_agreements/008_master_agreements_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-014-driftwood-media/02_order_forms/009_order_forms_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-014-driftwood-media/02_order_forms/010_order_forms_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-014-driftwood-media/02_order_forms/011_order_forms_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-014-driftwood-media/02_order_forms/012_order_forms_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-014-driftwood-media/02_order_forms/013_order_forms_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-014-driftwood-media/02_order_forms/014_order_forms_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-014-driftwood-media/02_order_forms/015_order_forms_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-014-driftwood-media/02_order_forms/016_order_forms_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-014-driftwood-media/03_amendments/017_amendments_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-014-driftwood-media/03_amendments/018_amendments_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-014-driftwood-media/03_amendments/019_amendments_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-014-driftwood-media/03_amendments/020_amendments_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-014-driftwood-media/03_amendments/021_amendments_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-014-driftwood-media/03_amendments/022_amendments_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-014-driftwood-media/03_amendments/023_amendments_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-014-driftwood-media/03_amendments/024_amendments_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-014-driftwood-media/04_statements_of_work/025_statements_of_work_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-014-driftwood-media/04_statements_of_work/026_statements_of_work_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-014-driftwood-media/04_statements_of_work/027_statements_of_work_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-014-driftwood-media/04_statements_of_work/028_statements_of_work_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-014-driftwood-media/04_statements_of_work/029_statements_of_work_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-014-driftwood-media/04_statements_of_work/030_statements_of_work_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-014-driftwood-media/04_statements_of_work/031_statements_of_work_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-014-driftwood-media/04_statements_of_work/032_statements_of_work_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-014-driftwood-media/05_pricing/033_pricing_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-014-driftwood-media/05_pricing/034_pricing_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-014-driftwood-media/05_pricing/035_pricing_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-014-driftwood-media/05_pricing/036_pricing_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-014-driftwood-media/05_pricing/037_pricing_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-014-driftwood-media/05_pricing/038_pricing_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-014-driftwood-media/05_pricing/039_pricing_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-014-driftwood-media/05_pricing/040_pricing_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-014-driftwood-media/06_service_levels/041_service_levels_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-014-driftwood-media/06_service_levels/042_service_levels_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-014-driftwood-media/06_service_levels/043_service_levels_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-014-driftwood-media/06_service_levels/044_service_levels_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-014-driftwood-media/06_service_levels/045_service_levels_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-014-driftwood-media/06_service_levels/046_service_levels_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-014-driftwood-media/06_service_levels/047_service_levels_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-014-driftwood-media/06_service_levels/048_service_levels_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-014-driftwood-media/07_security_privacy/049_security_privacy_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-014-driftwood-media/07_security_privacy/050_security_privacy_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-014-driftwood-media/07_security_privacy/051_security_privacy_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-014-driftwood-media/07_security_privacy/052_security_privacy_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-014-driftwood-media/07_security_privacy/053_security_privacy_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-014-driftwood-media/07_security_privacy/054_security_privacy_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-014-driftwood-media/07_security_privacy/055_security_privacy_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-014-driftwood-media/07_security_privacy/056_security_privacy_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-014-driftwood-media/08_notices/057_notices_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-014-driftwood-media/08_notices/058_notices_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-014-driftwood-media/08_notices/059_notices_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-014-driftwood-media/08_notices/060_notices_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-014-driftwood-media/08_notices/061_notices_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-014-driftwood-media/08_notices/062_notices_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-014-driftwood-media/08_notices/063_notices_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-014-driftwood-media/08_notices/064_notices_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-014-driftwood-media/09_invoices/065_invoices_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-014-driftwood-media/09_invoices/066_invoices_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-014-driftwood-media/09_invoices/067_invoices_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-014-driftwood-media/09_invoices/068_invoices_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-014-driftwood-media/09_invoices/069_invoices_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-014-driftwood-media/09_invoices/070_invoices_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-014-driftwood-media/09_invoices/071_invoices_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-014-driftwood-media/09_invoices/072_invoices_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-014-driftwood-media/10_correspondence/073_correspondence_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-014-driftwood-media/10_correspondence/074_correspondence_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-014-driftwood-media/10_correspondence/075_correspondence_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-014-driftwood-media/10_correspondence/076_correspondence_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-014-driftwood-media/10_correspondence/077_correspondence_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-014-driftwood-media/10_correspondence/078_correspondence_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-014-driftwood-media/10_correspondence/079_correspondence_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-014-driftwood-media/10_correspondence/080_correspondence_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-014-driftwood-media/11_policies/081_policies_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-014-driftwood-media/11_policies/082_policies_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-014-driftwood-media/11_policies/083_policies_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-014-driftwood-media/11_policies/084_policies_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-014-driftwood-media/11_policies/085_policies_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-014-driftwood-media/11_policies/086_policies_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-014-driftwood-media/11_policies/087_policies_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-014-driftwood-media/11_policies/088_policies_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-014-driftwood-media/12_renewal_records/089_renewal_records_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-014-driftwood-media/12_renewal_records/090_renewal_records_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-014-driftwood-media/12_renewal_records/091_renewal_records_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-014-driftwood-media/12_renewal_records/092_renewal_records_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-014-driftwood-media/12_renewal_records/093_renewal_records_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-014-driftwood-media/12_renewal_records/094_renewal_records_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-014-driftwood-media/12_renewal_records/095_renewal_records_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-014-driftwood-media/12_renewal_records/096_renewal_records_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-014-driftwood-media/12_renewal_records/097_driftwood_media_impact_population.xlsx"], "gold_output": {"advice_markdown": "# Decision note — Driftwood content-delivery renewal audit\n\n## Recommendation\n\nUse the exact period-by-period reconciliation and surface only supported renewal blockers. The reconciled record supports 5 scoped actions and leaves 7 items on evidence hold.\n\nSelected option: `driftwood-media:scoped-evidence`.\n\n## Why this is the supported option\n\nRecalculate delivery charges and credits against the effective agreement chain and measured service periods. Signed amendments and their precedence clauses govern rates, localization, and credits.\n\n## Supported actions\n\n### CBP-014-04 — invoice currency discrepancy (medium)\n\nthe permission is limited to Los Angeles County, California under CB-CC-2504-R865; the matched activity occurred in California under CB-CC-2504-E145. Identity resolves to ENT-014-1003, revision REV-2026.4 is current, and Henry Cho is active with capacity 3.\n\nAction: Write adjustment and renewal rows for matched service periods; hold unmatched billing populations. Owner: Henry Cho; due 2026-09-10.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/004_master_agreements_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/02_order_forms/016_order_forms_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/028_statements_of_work_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/05_pricing/040_pricing_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/097_driftwood_media_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-014-05 — pricing-escalator mismatch (medium)\n\nthe operative cap is $4,522,000.00 under CB-CC-2504-R421; the matched ledger population totals $4,550,621.00 under CB-CC-2504-E224. Identity resolves to ENT-014-1004, revision REV-2026.5 is current, and Maya Ellison is active with capacity 1.\n\nAction: Write adjustment and renewal rows for matched service periods; hold unmatched billing populations. Owner: Maya Ellison; due 2026-09-09.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/005_master_agreements_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/03_amendments/017_amendments_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/029_statements_of_work_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/06_service_levels/041_service_levels_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/097_driftwood_media_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-014-06 — data-localization conflict (medium)\n\ndelivery must use notices-driftwood_media_studios@example.test under CB-CC-2504-R283; the only matched receipt used archive-palisade_stream_services_inc@example.test under CB-CC-2504-E534. Identity resolves to ENT-014-1005, revision REV-2026.6 is current, and Jonas Feld is active with capacity 1.\n\nAction: Write adjustment and renewal rows for matched service periods; hold unmatched billing populations. Owner: Jonas Feld; due 2026-09-08.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/006_master_agreements_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/03_amendments/018_amendments_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/030_statements_of_work_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/06_service_levels/042_service_levels_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/07_security_privacy/054_security_privacy_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/097_driftwood_media_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-014-11 — survival-clause ambiguity (critical)\n\nthe controlled population contains 186 records under CB-CC-2504-R834; the certification covers 150 records under CB-CC-2504-E566. Identity resolves to ENT-014-1010, revision REV-2026.4 is current, and Nadine Flores is active with capacity 2.\n\nAction: Write adjustment and renewal rows for matched service periods; hold unmatched billing populations. Owner: Nadine Flores; due 2026-09-12.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/02_order_forms/011_order_forms_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/03_amendments/023_amendments_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/05_pricing/035_pricing_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/06_service_levels/047_service_levels_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/095_renewal_records_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/09_invoices/071_invoices_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/097_driftwood_media_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-014-12 — termination notice defect (critical)\n\nthe permission is limited to Los Angeles County, California under CB-CC-2504-R721; the matched activity occurred in California under CB-CC-2504-E295. Identity resolves to ENT-014-1011, revision REV-2026.5 is current, and Rafael Okafor is active with capacity 3.\n\nAction: Write adjustment and renewal rows for matched service periods; hold unmatched billing populations. Owner: Rafael Okafor; due 2026-09-11.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/02_order_forms/012_order_forms_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/03_amendments/024_amendments_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/05_pricing/036_pricing_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/06_service_levels/048_service_levels_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/096_renewal_records_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/097_driftwood_media_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n## Evidence holds\n\n- **CBP-014-01 — usage-report inconsistency**: the current observation does not meet the operative trigger. Next evidence: a current observation that satisfies the operative trigger. Sources: `/workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/001_master_agreements_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/02_order_forms/013_order_forms_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/025_statements_of_work_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/05_pricing/037_pricing_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/08_notices/061_notices_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/097_driftwood_media_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-014-02 — minimum-commit shortfall**: the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective. Next evidence: effective approval and an active owner with remaining capacity. Sources: `/workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/002_master_agreements_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/02_order_forms/014_order_forms_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/026_statements_of_work_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/05_pricing/038_pricing_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/11_policies/086_policies_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/097_driftwood_media_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-014-03 — subprocessor notice lapse**: the operational record relies on a superseded control revision. Next evidence: an operational record using the current effective revision. Sources: `/workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/003_master_agreements_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/02_order_forms/015_order_forms_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/027_statements_of_work_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/05_pricing/039_pricing_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/11_policies/087_policies_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/10_correspondence/075_correspondence_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/097_driftwood_media_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-014-07 — benchmarking right omission**: the operational record relies on a superseded control revision. Next evidence: an operational record using the current effective revision. Sources: `/workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/007_master_agreements_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/03_amendments/019_amendments_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/031_statements_of_work_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/06_service_levels/043_service_levels_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/097_driftwood_media_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-014-08 — renewal date conflict**: two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key. Next evidence: an approved immutable entity crosswalk. Sources: `/workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/008_master_agreements_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/03_amendments/020_amendments_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/032_statements_of_work_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/06_service_levels/044_service_levels_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/09_invoices/068_invoices_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/097_driftwood_media_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-014-09 — assignment consent requirement**: the current observation does not meet the operative trigger. Next evidence: a current observation that satisfies the operative trigger. Sources: `/workspace/documents/02_order_forms/009_order_forms_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/03_amendments/021_amendments_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/05_pricing/033_pricing_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/06_service_levels/045_service_levels_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/097_driftwood_media_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-014-10 — exclusivity carveout breach**: the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective. Next evidence: effective approval and an active owner with remaining capacity. Sources: `/workspace/documents/02_order_forms/010_order_forms_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/03_amendments/022_amendments_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/05_pricing/034_pricing_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/06_service_levels/046_service_levels_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/11_policies/082_policies_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/097_driftwood_media_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n## Alternatives considered\n\n- `driftwood-media:shortcut` — Average the invoices and use the most recent amendment for every period.: Use a plausible summary or one source without completing the controlling joins.\n- `driftwood-media:blanket-hold` — Freeze the entire matter population: Treat supported actions and genuinely ambiguous records as if they were equally unresolved.\n\n## Assumptions and limits\n\nThis decision is limited to cb100-014-driftwood-media, the supplied synthetic records, and the matter state as of 2026-09-14. Similar names, stale revisions, and pending authority are not treated as proof.\n", "decision": {"actions": [{"determination": "the permission is limited to Los Angeles County, California under CB-CC-2504-R865; the matched activity occurred in California under CB-CC-2504-E145. Identity resolves to ENT-014-1003, revision REV-2026.4 is current, and Henry Cho is active with capacity 3.", "due_date": "2026-09-10", "id": "ACT-CBP-014-04", "identity_id": "ENT-014-1003", "issue": "invoice currency discrepancy", "owner": "Henry Cho", "portfolio_key": "CBP-014-04", "recommended_action": "Write adjustment and renewal rows for matched service periods; hold unmatched billing populations. Owner: Henry Cho; due 2026-09-10.", "severity": "medium", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/004_master_agreements_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/02_order_forms/016_order_forms_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/028_statements_of_work_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/05_pricing/040_pricing_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/097_driftwood_media_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "the operative cap is $4,522,000.00 under CB-CC-2504-R421; the matched ledger population totals $4,550,621.00 under CB-CC-2504-E224. Identity resolves to ENT-014-1004, revision REV-2026.5 is current, and Maya Ellison is active with capacity 1.", "due_date": "2026-09-09", "id": "ACT-CBP-014-05", "identity_id": "ENT-014-1004", "issue": "pricing-escalator mismatch", "owner": "Maya Ellison", "portfolio_key": "CBP-014-05", "recommended_action": "Write adjustment and renewal rows for matched service periods; hold unmatched billing populations. Owner: Maya Ellison; due 2026-09-09.", "severity": "medium", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/005_master_agreements_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/03_amendments/017_amendments_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/029_statements_of_work_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/06_service_levels/041_service_levels_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/097_driftwood_media_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "delivery must use notices-driftwood_media_studios@example.test under CB-CC-2504-R283; the only matched receipt used archive-palisade_stream_services_inc@example.test under CB-CC-2504-E534. Identity resolves to ENT-014-1005, revision REV-2026.6 is current, and Jonas Feld is active with capacity 1.", "due_date": "2026-09-08", "id": "ACT-CBP-014-06", "identity_id": "ENT-014-1005", "issue": "data-localization conflict", "owner": "Jonas Feld", "portfolio_key": "CBP-014-06", "recommended_action": "Write adjustment and renewal rows for matched service periods; hold unmatched billing populations. Owner: Jonas Feld; due 2026-09-08.", "severity": "medium", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/006_master_agreements_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/03_amendments/018_amendments_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/030_statements_of_work_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/06_service_levels/042_service_levels_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/07_security_privacy/054_security_privacy_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/097_driftwood_media_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "the controlled population contains 186 records under CB-CC-2504-R834; the certification covers 150 records under CB-CC-2504-E566. Identity resolves to ENT-014-1010, revision REV-2026.4 is current, and Nadine Flores is active with capacity 2.", "due_date": "2026-09-12", "id": "ACT-CBP-014-11", "identity_id": "ENT-014-1010", "issue": "survival-clause ambiguity", "owner": "Nadine Flores", "portfolio_key": "CBP-014-11", "recommended_action": "Write adjustment and renewal rows for matched service periods; hold unmatched billing populations. Owner: Nadine Flores; due 2026-09-12.", "severity": "critical", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_order_forms/011_order_forms_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/03_amendments/023_amendments_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/05_pricing/035_pricing_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/06_service_levels/047_service_levels_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/095_renewal_records_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/09_invoices/071_invoices_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/097_driftwood_media_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "the permission is limited to Los Angeles County, California under CB-CC-2504-R721; the matched activity occurred in California under CB-CC-2504-E295. Identity resolves to ENT-014-1011, revision REV-2026.5 is current, and Rafael Okafor is active with capacity 3.", "due_date": "2026-09-11", "id": "ACT-CBP-014-12", "identity_id": "ENT-014-1011", "issue": "termination notice defect", "owner": "Rafael Okafor", "portfolio_key": "CBP-014-12", "recommended_action": "Write adjustment and renewal rows for matched service periods; hold unmatched billing populations. Owner: Rafael Okafor; due 2026-09-11.", "severity": "critical", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_order_forms/012_order_forms_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/03_amendments/024_amendments_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/05_pricing/036_pricing_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/06_service_levels/048_service_levels_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/096_renewal_records_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/097_driftwood_media_impact_population.xlsx"]}], "as_of": "2026-09-14", "decision": {"alternatives_considered": ["driftwood-media:shortcut", "driftwood-media:blanket-hold"], "question": "What renewal and credit position can Driftwood defend across the content-delivery portfolio?", "rationale": "The four-part causal test supports 5 scoped actions and leaves 7 records on evidence hold. Signed amendments and their precedence clauses govern rates, localization, and credits.", "recommendation": "Use the exact period-by-period reconciliation and surface only supported renewal blockers.", "selected_option_id": "driftwood-media:scoped-evidence"}, "holds": [{"id": "HOLD-CBP-014-01", "issue": "usage-report inconsistency", "portfolio_key": "CBP-014-01", "reason": "the current observation does not meet the operative trigger", "required_next_evidence": "a current observation that satisfies the operative trigger", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/001_master_agreements_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/02_order_forms/013_order_forms_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/025_statements_of_work_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/05_pricing/037_pricing_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/08_notices/061_notices_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/097_driftwood_media_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-014-02", "issue": "minimum-commit shortfall", "portfolio_key": "CBP-014-02", "reason": "the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective", "required_next_evidence": "effective approval and an active owner with remaining capacity", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/002_master_agreements_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/02_order_forms/014_order_forms_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/026_statements_of_work_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/05_pricing/038_pricing_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/11_policies/086_policies_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/097_driftwood_media_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-014-03", "issue": "subprocessor notice lapse", "portfolio_key": "CBP-014-03", "reason": "the operational record relies on a superseded control revision", "required_next_evidence": "an operational record using the current effective revision", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/003_master_agreements_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/02_order_forms/015_order_forms_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/027_statements_of_work_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/05_pricing/039_pricing_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/11_policies/087_policies_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/10_correspondence/075_correspondence_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/097_driftwood_media_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-014-07", "issue": "benchmarking right omission", "portfolio_key": "CBP-014-07", "reason": "the operational record relies on a superseded control revision", "required_next_evidence": "an operational record using the current effective revision", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/007_master_agreements_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/03_amendments/019_amendments_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/031_statements_of_work_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/06_service_levels/043_service_levels_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/097_driftwood_media_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-014-08", "issue": "renewal date conflict", "portfolio_key": "CBP-014-08", "reason": "two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key", "required_next_evidence": "an approved immutable entity crosswalk", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/008_master_agreements_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/03_amendments/020_amendments_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/032_statements_of_work_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/06_service_levels/044_service_levels_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/09_invoices/068_invoices_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/097_driftwood_media_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-014-09", "issue": "assignment consent requirement", "portfolio_key": "CBP-014-09", "reason": "the current observation does not meet the operative trigger", "required_next_evidence": "a current observation that satisfies the operative trigger", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_order_forms/009_order_forms_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/03_amendments/021_amendments_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/05_pricing/033_pricing_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/06_service_levels/045_service_levels_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/097_driftwood_media_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-014-10", "issue": "exclusivity carveout breach", "portfolio_key": "CBP-014-10", "reason": "the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective", "required_next_evidence": "effective approval and an active owner with remaining capacity", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_order_forms/010_order_forms_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/03_amendments/022_amendments_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/05_pricing/034_pricing_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/06_service_levels/046_service_levels_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/11_policies/082_policies_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/097_driftwood_media_impact_population.xlsx"]}], "matter_number": "CB-CC-2504", "prepared_for": "Driftwood Media Studios", "schema_version": "counselbench.decision.v3", "task_id": "cb100-014-driftwood-media"}, "matter_register": {"matter_number": "CB-CC-2504", "rows": [{"decision_option_id": "driftwood-media:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "the current observation does not meet the operative trigger", "issue": "usage-report inconsistency", "matter_number": "CB-CC-2504", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-014-01", "row_id": "REG-CBP-014-01", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/001_master_agreements_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/02_order_forms/013_order_forms_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/025_statements_of_work_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/05_pricing/037_pricing_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/08_notices/061_notices_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/097_driftwood_media_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "driftwood-media:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective", "issue": "minimum-commit shortfall", "matter_number": "CB-CC-2504", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-014-02", "row_id": "REG-CBP-014-02", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/002_master_agreements_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/02_order_forms/014_order_forms_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/026_statements_of_work_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/05_pricing/038_pricing_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/11_policies/086_policies_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/097_driftwood_media_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "driftwood-media:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "the operational record relies on a superseded control revision", "issue": "subprocessor notice lapse", "matter_number": "CB-CC-2504", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-014-03", "row_id": "REG-CBP-014-03", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/003_master_agreements_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/02_order_forms/015_order_forms_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/027_statements_of_work_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/05_pricing/039_pricing_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/11_policies/087_policies_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/10_correspondence/075_correspondence_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/097_driftwood_media_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "driftwood-media:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-10", "issue": "invoice currency discrepancy", "matter_number": "CB-CC-2504", "owner": "Henry Cho", "portfolio_key": "CBP-014-04", "row_id": "REG-CBP-014-04", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/004_master_agreements_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/02_order_forms/016_order_forms_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/028_statements_of_work_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/05_pricing/040_pricing_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/097_driftwood_media_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "driftwood-media:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-09", "issue": "pricing-escalator mismatch", "matter_number": "CB-CC-2504", "owner": "Maya Ellison", "portfolio_key": "CBP-014-05", "row_id": "REG-CBP-014-05", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/005_master_agreements_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/03_amendments/017_amendments_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/029_statements_of_work_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/06_service_levels/041_service_levels_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/097_driftwood_media_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "driftwood-media:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-08", "issue": "data-localization conflict", "matter_number": "CB-CC-2504", "owner": "Jonas Feld", "portfolio_key": "CBP-014-06", "row_id": "REG-CBP-014-06", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/006_master_agreements_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/03_amendments/018_amendments_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/030_statements_of_work_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/06_service_levels/042_service_levels_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/07_security_privacy/054_security_privacy_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/097_driftwood_media_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "driftwood-media:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "the operational record relies on a superseded control revision", "issue": "benchmarking right omission", "matter_number": "CB-CC-2504", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-014-07", "row_id": "REG-CBP-014-07", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/007_master_agreements_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/03_amendments/019_amendments_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/031_statements_of_work_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/06_service_levels/043_service_levels_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/097_driftwood_media_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "driftwood-media:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key", "issue": "renewal date conflict", "matter_number": "CB-CC-2504", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-014-08", "row_id": "REG-CBP-014-08", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/008_master_agreements_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/03_amendments/020_amendments_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/032_statements_of_work_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/06_service_levels/044_service_levels_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/09_invoices/068_invoices_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/097_driftwood_media_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "driftwood-media:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "the current observation does not meet the operative trigger", "issue": "assignment consent requirement", "matter_number": "CB-CC-2504", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-014-09", "row_id": "REG-CBP-014-09", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_order_forms/009_order_forms_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/03_amendments/021_amendments_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/05_pricing/033_pricing_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/06_service_levels/045_service_levels_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/097_driftwood_media_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "driftwood-media:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective", "issue": "exclusivity carveout breach", "matter_number": "CB-CC-2504", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-014-10", "row_id": "REG-CBP-014-10", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_order_forms/010_order_forms_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/03_amendments/022_amendments_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/05_pricing/034_pricing_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/06_service_levels/046_service_levels_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/11_policies/082_policies_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/097_driftwood_media_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "driftwood-media:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-12", "issue": "survival-clause ambiguity", "matter_number": "CB-CC-2504", "owner": "Nadine Flores", "portfolio_key": "CBP-014-11", "row_id": "REG-CBP-014-11", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_order_forms/011_order_forms_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/03_amendments/023_amendments_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/05_pricing/035_pricing_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/06_service_levels/047_service_levels_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/095_renewal_records_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/09_invoices/071_invoices_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/097_driftwood_media_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "driftwood-media:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-11", "issue": "termination notice defect", "matter_number": "CB-CC-2504", "owner": "Rafael Okafor", "portfolio_key": "CBP-014-12", "row_id": "REG-CBP-014-12", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_order_forms/012_order_forms_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/03_amendments/024_amendments_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/05_pricing/036_pricing_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/06_service_levels/048_service_levels_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/096_renewal_records_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/097_driftwood_media_impact_population.xlsx"]}], "schema_version": "counselbench.matter-register.v3", "task_id": "cb100-014-driftwood-media"}}, "metadata": {"benchmark": "CounselBench-100", "code_license": "Apache-2.0", "data_license": "CC-BY-4.0", "deadline": "2026-09-14", "document_count": 97, "evidence_holds": 7, "jurisdiction": "California", "matter_number": "CB-CC-2504", "mcp_commit": "9a96ea6e5913736f92b88345bf51caeaaa8e719f", "mcp_package": "@modelcontextprotocol/server-filesystem@2026.7.10", "practice_area": "commercial-contracts", "reference_tool_calls": 77, "required_evidence_reads": 60, "supported_actions": 5, "synthetic": true, "venue": "Los Angeles County, California", "version": "3.1.0"}, "prompt": "The client wants a decision, not another document inventory. What renewal and credit position can Driftwood defend across the content-delivery portfolio? Delivery charges, localization commitments, and service credits diverge across a master agreement, two amendments, and eighteen months of invoices. The team needs the call by 2026-09-14. Put the supported calls into the matter register and leave me a short note I can use with the partner.", "rubric": {"criteria": [{"category": "investigation", "description": "Inventory the production and use targeted searches to locate records across native formats.", "id": "investigation.discover_production"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Complete every task-specific identity, authority, operations, and approval read before the first state transition.", "id": "investigation.read_before_write"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Inspect designated source metadata before relying on those records.", "id": "investigation.custody_before_write"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "Select the supported option 'driftwood-media:scoped-evidence' after applying the four-part test.", "id": "decision.selected_option"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "Identify both rejected approaches and explain why a one-source shortcut and a blanket hold are wrong.", "id": "decision.alternatives"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-014-01 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/001_master_agreements_source_export.md rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-014-01.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_order_forms/013_order_forms_source_export.json for usage-report inconsistency.", "id": "investigation.CBP-014-01.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/025_statements_of_work_source_export.md to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-014-01.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_pricing/037_pricing_source_export.json.", "id": "investigation.CBP-014-01.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-014-01 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is the current observation does not meet the operative trigger.", "id": "decision.CBP-014-01.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-014-01 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-014-01.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-014-02 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/002_master_agreements_source_export.txt rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-014-02.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_order_forms/014_order_forms_source_export.xml for minimum-commit shortfall.", "id": "investigation.CBP-014-02.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/026_statements_of_work_source_export.txt to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-014-02.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_pricing/038_pricing_source_export.xml.", "id": "investigation.CBP-014-02.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-014-02 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective.", "id": "decision.CBP-014-02.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-014-02 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-014-02.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-014-03 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/003_master_agreements_source_export.eml rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-014-03.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_order_forms/015_order_forms_source_export.html for subprocessor notice lapse.", "id": "investigation.CBP-014-03.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/027_statements_of_work_source_export.eml to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-014-03.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_pricing/039_pricing_source_export.html.", "id": "investigation.CBP-014-03.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-014-03 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is the operational record relies on a superseded control revision.", "id": "decision.CBP-014-03.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-014-03 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-014-03.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-014-04 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/004_master_agreements_source_export.csv rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-014-04.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_order_forms/016_order_forms_source_export.pdf for invoice currency discrepancy.", "id": "investigation.CBP-014-04.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/028_statements_of_work_source_export.csv to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-014-04.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_pricing/040_pricing_source_export.pdf.", "id": "investigation.CBP-014-04.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-014-04 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-014-04.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-014-04 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-014-04.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-014-05 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/005_master_agreements_source_export.json rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-014-05.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_amendments/017_amendments_source_export.md for pricing-escalator mismatch.", "id": "investigation.CBP-014-05.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/029_statements_of_work_source_export.json to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-014-05.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_service_levels/041_service_levels_source_export.md.", "id": "investigation.CBP-014-05.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-014-05 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-014-05.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-014-05 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-014-05.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-014-06 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/006_master_agreements_source_export.xml rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-014-06.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_amendments/018_amendments_source_export.txt for data-localization conflict.", "id": "investigation.CBP-014-06.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/030_statements_of_work_source_export.xml to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-014-06.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_service_levels/042_service_levels_source_export.txt.", "id": "investigation.CBP-014-06.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-014-06 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-014-06.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-014-06 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-014-06.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-014-07 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/007_master_agreements_source_export.html rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-014-07.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_amendments/019_amendments_source_export.eml for benchmarking right omission.", "id": "investigation.CBP-014-07.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/031_statements_of_work_source_export.html to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-014-07.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_service_levels/043_service_levels_source_export.eml.", "id": "investigation.CBP-014-07.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-014-07 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is the operational record relies on a superseded control revision.", "id": "decision.CBP-014-07.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-014-07 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-014-07.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-014-08 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/008_master_agreements_source_export.pdf rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-014-08.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_amendments/020_amendments_source_export.csv for renewal date conflict.", "id": "investigation.CBP-014-08.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/032_statements_of_work_source_export.pdf to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-014-08.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_service_levels/044_service_levels_source_export.csv.", "id": "investigation.CBP-014-08.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-014-08 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key.", "id": "decision.CBP-014-08.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-014-08 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-014-08.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-014-09 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_order_forms/009_order_forms_source_export.md rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-014-09.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_amendments/021_amendments_source_export.json for assignment consent requirement.", "id": "investigation.CBP-014-09.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_pricing/033_pricing_source_export.md to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-014-09.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_service_levels/045_service_levels_source_export.json.", "id": "investigation.CBP-014-09.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-014-09 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is the current observation does not meet the operative trigger.", "id": "decision.CBP-014-09.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-014-09 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-014-09.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-014-10 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_order_forms/010_order_forms_source_export.txt rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-014-10.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_amendments/022_amendments_source_export.xml for exclusivity carveout breach.", "id": "investigation.CBP-014-10.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_pricing/034_pricing_source_export.txt to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-014-10.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_service_levels/046_service_levels_source_export.xml.", "id": "investigation.CBP-014-10.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-014-10 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective.", "id": "decision.CBP-014-10.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-014-10 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-014-10.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-014-11 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_order_forms/011_order_forms_source_export.eml rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-014-11.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_amendments/023_amendments_source_export.html for survival-clause ambiguity.", "id": "investigation.CBP-014-11.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_pricing/035_pricing_source_export.eml to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-014-11.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_service_levels/047_service_levels_source_export.html.", "id": "investigation.CBP-014-11.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-014-11 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-014-11.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-014-11 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-014-11.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-014-12 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_order_forms/012_order_forms_source_export.csv rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-014-12.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_amendments/024_amendments_source_export.pdf for termination notice defect.", "id": "investigation.CBP-014-12.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_pricing/036_pricing_source_export.csv to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-014-12.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_service_levels/048_service_levels_source_export.pdf.", "id": "investigation.CBP-014-12.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-014-12 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-014-12.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-014-12 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-014-12.register"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Write the exact selected option, supported action population, evidence-hold population, facts, owners, deadlines, and citations.", "id": "state.exact_decision"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create one exact register row per portfolio key with no extra, missing, or modified row.", "id": "state.exact_register"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Leave only the three approved deliverables and perform no extra state-changing write.", "id": "state.write_scope_containment"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Read back decision.json, matter-register.json, and advice.md after their final writes.", "id": "state.postwrite_readback"}, {"category": "answer", "description": "Explain the selected recommendation, supported actions, holds, alternatives, and limitations with exact source anchors.", "id": "answer.decision_note"}], "decision_options": [{"approach": "Use a plausible summary or one source without completing the controlling joins.", "id": "driftwood-media:shortcut", "label": "Average the invoices and use the most recent amendment for every period."}, {"approach": "Treat supported actions and genuinely ambiguous records as if they were equally unresolved.", "id": "driftwood-media:blanket-hold", "label": "Freeze the entire matter population"}, {"approach": "Apply the exact identity, current-state, authority, and revision test. Write adjustment and renewal rows for matched service periods; hold unmatched billing populations.", "id": "driftwood-media:scoped-evidence", "label": "Use the exact period-by-period reconciliation and surface only supported renewal blockers."}], "evaluation_narrative": {"authority": "Signed amendments and their precedence clauses govern rates, localization, and credits.", "observation": "Recalculate delivery charges and credits against the effective agreement chain and measured service periods.", "question": "What renewal and credit position can Driftwood defend across the content-delivery portfolio?", "register_action": "Write adjustment and renewal rows for matched service periods; hold unmatched billing populations."}, "gates": ["all_required_evidence_precedes_first_write", "decision_criteria_complete", "register_state_exact", "write_scope_contained", "all_outputs_verified_by_readback"], "metadata_checks": 4, "metric": "weighted_criteria_score", "minimum_tool_calls": 77, "required_deliverables": ["decision.json", "matter-register.json", "advice.md"], "required_document_reads": 60, "type": "deterministic", "weights": {"advice": 0.15, "decision": 0.35, "investigation": 0.25, "state": 0.25}}, "task_id": "cb100-014-driftwood-media", "task_name": "Driftwood content-delivery renewal audit", "world_id": "counselbench-filesystem-mcp-v3"}
+{"context_files": ["task_files/cb100-015-ember-medical/01_master_agreements/001_master_agreements_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-015-ember-medical/01_master_agreements/002_master_agreements_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-015-ember-medical/01_master_agreements/003_master_agreements_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-015-ember-medical/01_master_agreements/004_master_agreements_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-015-ember-medical/01_master_agreements/005_master_agreements_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-015-ember-medical/01_master_agreements/006_master_agreements_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-015-ember-medical/01_master_agreements/007_master_agreements_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-015-ember-medical/01_master_agreements/008_master_agreements_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-015-ember-medical/02_order_forms/009_order_forms_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-015-ember-medical/02_order_forms/010_order_forms_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-015-ember-medical/02_order_forms/011_order_forms_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-015-ember-medical/02_order_forms/012_order_forms_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-015-ember-medical/02_order_forms/013_order_forms_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-015-ember-medical/02_order_forms/014_order_forms_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-015-ember-medical/02_order_forms/015_order_forms_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-015-ember-medical/02_order_forms/016_order_forms_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-015-ember-medical/03_amendments/017_amendments_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-015-ember-medical/03_amendments/018_amendments_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-015-ember-medical/03_amendments/019_amendments_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-015-ember-medical/03_amendments/020_amendments_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-015-ember-medical/03_amendments/021_amendments_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-015-ember-medical/03_amendments/022_amendments_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-015-ember-medical/03_amendments/023_amendments_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-015-ember-medical/03_amendments/024_amendments_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-015-ember-medical/04_statements_of_work/025_statements_of_work_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-015-ember-medical/04_statements_of_work/026_statements_of_work_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-015-ember-medical/04_statements_of_work/027_statements_of_work_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-015-ember-medical/04_statements_of_work/028_statements_of_work_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-015-ember-medical/04_statements_of_work/029_statements_of_work_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-015-ember-medical/04_statements_of_work/030_statements_of_work_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-015-ember-medical/04_statements_of_work/031_statements_of_work_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-015-ember-medical/04_statements_of_work/032_statements_of_work_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-015-ember-medical/05_pricing/033_pricing_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-015-ember-medical/05_pricing/034_pricing_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-015-ember-medical/05_pricing/035_pricing_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-015-ember-medical/05_pricing/036_pricing_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-015-ember-medical/05_pricing/037_pricing_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-015-ember-medical/05_pricing/038_pricing_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-015-ember-medical/05_pricing/039_pricing_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-015-ember-medical/05_pricing/040_pricing_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-015-ember-medical/06_service_levels/041_service_levels_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-015-ember-medical/06_service_levels/042_service_levels_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-015-ember-medical/06_service_levels/043_service_levels_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-015-ember-medical/06_service_levels/044_service_levels_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-015-ember-medical/06_service_levels/045_service_levels_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-015-ember-medical/06_service_levels/046_service_levels_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-015-ember-medical/06_service_levels/047_service_levels_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-015-ember-medical/06_service_levels/048_service_levels_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-015-ember-medical/07_security_privacy/049_security_privacy_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-015-ember-medical/07_security_privacy/050_security_privacy_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-015-ember-medical/07_security_privacy/051_security_privacy_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-015-ember-medical/07_security_privacy/052_security_privacy_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-015-ember-medical/07_security_privacy/053_security_privacy_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-015-ember-medical/07_security_privacy/054_security_privacy_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-015-ember-medical/07_security_privacy/055_security_privacy_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-015-ember-medical/07_security_privacy/056_security_privacy_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-015-ember-medical/08_notices/057_notices_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-015-ember-medical/08_notices/058_notices_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-015-ember-medical/08_notices/059_notices_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-015-ember-medical/08_notices/060_notices_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-015-ember-medical/08_notices/061_notices_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-015-ember-medical/08_notices/062_notices_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-015-ember-medical/08_notices/063_notices_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-015-ember-medical/08_notices/064_notices_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-015-ember-medical/09_invoices/065_invoices_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-015-ember-medical/09_invoices/066_invoices_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-015-ember-medical/09_invoices/067_invoices_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-015-ember-medical/09_invoices/068_invoices_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-015-ember-medical/09_invoices/069_invoices_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-015-ember-medical/09_invoices/070_invoices_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-015-ember-medical/09_invoices/071_invoices_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-015-ember-medical/09_invoices/072_invoices_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-015-ember-medical/10_correspondence/073_correspondence_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-015-ember-medical/10_correspondence/074_correspondence_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-015-ember-medical/10_correspondence/075_correspondence_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-015-ember-medical/10_correspondence/076_correspondence_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-015-ember-medical/10_correspondence/077_correspondence_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-015-ember-medical/10_correspondence/078_correspondence_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-015-ember-medical/10_correspondence/079_correspondence_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-015-ember-medical/10_correspondence/080_correspondence_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-015-ember-medical/11_policies/081_policies_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-015-ember-medical/11_policies/082_policies_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-015-ember-medical/11_policies/083_policies_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-015-ember-medical/11_policies/084_policies_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-015-ember-medical/11_policies/085_policies_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-015-ember-medical/11_policies/086_policies_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-015-ember-medical/11_policies/087_policies_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-015-ember-medical/11_policies/088_policies_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-015-ember-medical/12_renewal_records/089_renewal_records_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-015-ember-medical/12_renewal_records/090_renewal_records_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-015-ember-medical/12_renewal_records/091_renewal_records_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-015-ember-medical/12_renewal_records/092_renewal_records_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-015-ember-medical/12_renewal_records/093_renewal_records_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-015-ember-medical/12_renewal_records/094_renewal_records_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-015-ember-medical/12_renewal_records/095_renewal_records_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-015-ember-medical/12_renewal_records/096_renewal_records_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-015-ember-medical/12_renewal_records/097_ember_medical_impact_population.xlsx"], "gold_output": {"advice_markdown": "# Decision note — Ember device-support contract triage\n\n## Recommendation\n\nUse the documented cure, suspension, or termination path for each supported breach. The reconciled record supports 5 scoped actions and leaves 7 items on evidence hold.\n\nSelected option: `ember-medical:scoped-evidence`.\n\n## Why this is the supported option\n\nJoin incident response records, subcontractor identities, background checks, and insurance periods. Cure and termination rights depend on measured SLA breaches and current compliance prerequisites.\n\n## Supported actions\n\n### CBP-015-05 — minimum-commit shortfall (medium)\n\napproval must come from Nora Chen under CB-CC-2505-R351; the effective approval record names Henry Cho under CB-CC-2505-E855. Identity resolves to ENT-015-1004, revision REV-2025.5 is current, and Dominic Alvarez is active with capacity 4.\n\nAction: Register supported breaches with cure deadlines and hold unverified subcontractor aliases. Owner: Dominic Alvarez; due 2026-09-12.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/005_master_agreements_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/03_amendments/017_amendments_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/029_statements_of_work_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/06_service_levels/041_service_levels_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/097_ember_medical_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-015-06 — subprocessor notice lapse (high)\n\nthe controlled population contains 131 records under CB-CC-2505-R849; the certification covers 120 records under CB-CC-2505-E673. Identity resolves to ENT-015-1005, revision REV-2025.6 is current, and Leona Park is active with capacity 2.\n\nAction: Register supported breaches with cure deadlines and hold unverified subcontractor aliases. Owner: Leona Park; due 2026-09-11.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/006_master_agreements_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/03_amendments/018_amendments_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/030_statements_of_work_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/06_service_levels/042_service_levels_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/097_ember_medical_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-015-10 — benchmarking right omission (medium)\n\nan open exception blocks completion under CB-CC-2505-R808; the current status is open and unresolved under CB-CC-2505-E406. Identity resolves to ENT-015-1009, revision REV-2025.3 is current, and Willa Novak is active with capacity 1.\n\nAction: Register supported breaches with cure deadlines and hold unverified subcontractor aliases. Owner: Willa Novak; due 2026-09-16.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/02_order_forms/010_order_forms_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/03_amendments/022_amendments_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/05_pricing/034_pricing_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/06_service_levels/046_service_levels_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/097_ember_medical_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-015-11 — renewal date conflict (medium)\n\ncompletion is required by 2025-07-02 under CB-CC-2505-R997; the current event record shows completion on 2025-08-06 under CB-CC-2505-E205. Identity resolves to ENT-015-1010, revision REV-2025.4 is current, and Owen Delgado is active with capacity 3.\n\nAction: Register supported breaches with cure deadlines and hold unverified subcontractor aliases. Owner: Owen Delgado; due 2026-09-15.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/02_order_forms/011_order_forms_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/03_amendments/023_amendments_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/05_pricing/035_pricing_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/06_service_levels/047_service_levels_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/095_renewal_records_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/09_invoices/071_invoices_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/097_ember_medical_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-015-12 — assignment consent requirement (medium)\n\nthe controlling threshold is 9% under CB-CC-2505-R810; the independently calculated result is 17% under CB-CC-2505-E247. Identity resolves to ENT-015-1011, revision REV-2025.5 is current, and Priya Raman is active with capacity 4.\n\nAction: Register supported breaches with cure deadlines and hold unverified subcontractor aliases. Owner: Priya Raman; due 2026-09-14.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/02_order_forms/012_order_forms_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/03_amendments/024_amendments_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/05_pricing/036_pricing_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/06_service_levels/048_service_levels_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/096_renewal_records_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/097_ember_medical_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n## Evidence holds\n\n- **CBP-015-01 — order-form precedence conflict**: the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective. Next evidence: effective approval and an active owner with remaining capacity. Sources: `/workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/001_master_agreements_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/02_order_forms/013_order_forms_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/025_statements_of_work_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/05_pricing/037_pricing_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/097_ember_medical_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-015-02 — service-credit underpayment**: the operational record relies on a superseded control revision. Next evidence: an operational record using the current effective revision. Sources: `/workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/002_master_agreements_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/02_order_forms/014_order_forms_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/026_statements_of_work_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/05_pricing/038_pricing_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/10_correspondence/074_correspondence_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/097_ember_medical_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-015-03 — insurance-limit deficiency**: two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key. Next evidence: an approved immutable entity crosswalk. Sources: `/workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/003_master_agreements_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/02_order_forms/015_order_forms_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/027_statements_of_work_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/05_pricing/039_pricing_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/07_security_privacy/051_security_privacy_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/11_policies/087_policies_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/097_ember_medical_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-015-04 — usage-report inconsistency**: the current observation does not meet the operative trigger. Next evidence: a current observation that satisfies the operative trigger. Sources: `/workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/004_master_agreements_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/02_order_forms/016_order_forms_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/028_statements_of_work_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/05_pricing/040_pricing_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/097_ember_medical_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-015-07 — invoice currency discrepancy**: two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key. Next evidence: an approved immutable entity crosswalk. Sources: `/workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/007_master_agreements_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/03_amendments/019_amendments_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/031_statements_of_work_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/06_service_levels/043_service_levels_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/10_correspondence/079_correspondence_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/07_security_privacy/055_security_privacy_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/097_ember_medical_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-015-08 — pricing-escalator mismatch**: the current observation does not meet the operative trigger. Next evidence: a current observation that satisfies the operative trigger. Sources: `/workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/008_master_agreements_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/03_amendments/020_amendments_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/032_statements_of_work_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/06_service_levels/044_service_levels_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/092_renewal_records_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/09_invoices/068_invoices_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/097_ember_medical_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-015-09 — data-localization conflict**: the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective. Next evidence: effective approval and an active owner with remaining capacity. Sources: `/workspace/documents/02_order_forms/009_order_forms_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/03_amendments/021_amendments_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/05_pricing/033_pricing_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/06_service_levels/045_service_levels_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/08_notices/057_notices_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/097_ember_medical_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n## Alternatives considered\n\n- `ember-medical:blanket-hold` — Freeze the entire matter population: Treat supported actions and genuinely ambiguous records as if they were equally unresolved.\n- `ember-medical:shortcut` — Terminate immediately based on complaint volume without applying cure mechanics.: Use a plausible summary or one source without completing the controlling joins.\n\n## Assumptions and limits\n\nThis decision is limited to cb100-015-ember-medical, the supplied synthetic records, and the matter state as of 2026-09-17. Similar names, stale revisions, and pending authority are not treated as proof.\n", "decision": {"actions": [{"determination": "approval must come from Nora Chen under CB-CC-2505-R351; the effective approval record names Henry Cho under CB-CC-2505-E855. Identity resolves to ENT-015-1004, revision REV-2025.5 is current, and Dominic Alvarez is active with capacity 4.", "due_date": "2026-09-12", "id": "ACT-CBP-015-05", "identity_id": "ENT-015-1004", "issue": "minimum-commit shortfall", "owner": "Dominic Alvarez", "portfolio_key": "CBP-015-05", "recommended_action": "Register supported breaches with cure deadlines and hold unverified subcontractor aliases. Owner: Dominic Alvarez; due 2026-09-12.", "severity": "medium", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/005_master_agreements_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/03_amendments/017_amendments_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/029_statements_of_work_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/06_service_levels/041_service_levels_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/097_ember_medical_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "the controlled population contains 131 records under CB-CC-2505-R849; the certification covers 120 records under CB-CC-2505-E673. Identity resolves to ENT-015-1005, revision REV-2025.6 is current, and Leona Park is active with capacity 2.", "due_date": "2026-09-11", "id": "ACT-CBP-015-06", "identity_id": "ENT-015-1005", "issue": "subprocessor notice lapse", "owner": "Leona Park", "portfolio_key": "CBP-015-06", "recommended_action": "Register supported breaches with cure deadlines and hold unverified subcontractor aliases. Owner: Leona Park; due 2026-09-11.", "severity": "high", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/006_master_agreements_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/03_amendments/018_amendments_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/030_statements_of_work_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/06_service_levels/042_service_levels_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/097_ember_medical_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "an open exception blocks completion under CB-CC-2505-R808; the current status is open and unresolved under CB-CC-2505-E406. Identity resolves to ENT-015-1009, revision REV-2025.3 is current, and Willa Novak is active with capacity 1.", "due_date": "2026-09-16", "id": "ACT-CBP-015-10", "identity_id": "ENT-015-1009", "issue": "benchmarking right omission", "owner": "Willa Novak", "portfolio_key": "CBP-015-10", "recommended_action": "Register supported breaches with cure deadlines and hold unverified subcontractor aliases. Owner: Willa Novak; due 2026-09-16.", "severity": "medium", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_order_forms/010_order_forms_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/03_amendments/022_amendments_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/05_pricing/034_pricing_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/06_service_levels/046_service_levels_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/097_ember_medical_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "completion is required by 2025-07-02 under CB-CC-2505-R997; the current event record shows completion on 2025-08-06 under CB-CC-2505-E205. Identity resolves to ENT-015-1010, revision REV-2025.4 is current, and Owen Delgado is active with capacity 3.", "due_date": "2026-09-15", "id": "ACT-CBP-015-11", "identity_id": "ENT-015-1010", "issue": "renewal date conflict", "owner": "Owen Delgado", "portfolio_key": "CBP-015-11", "recommended_action": "Register supported breaches with cure deadlines and hold unverified subcontractor aliases. Owner: Owen Delgado; due 2026-09-15.", "severity": "medium", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_order_forms/011_order_forms_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/03_amendments/023_amendments_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/05_pricing/035_pricing_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/06_service_levels/047_service_levels_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/095_renewal_records_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/09_invoices/071_invoices_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/097_ember_medical_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "the controlling threshold is 9% under CB-CC-2505-R810; the independently calculated result is 17% under CB-CC-2505-E247. Identity resolves to ENT-015-1011, revision REV-2025.5 is current, and Priya Raman is active with capacity 4.", "due_date": "2026-09-14", "id": "ACT-CBP-015-12", "identity_id": "ENT-015-1011", "issue": "assignment consent requirement", "owner": "Priya Raman", "portfolio_key": "CBP-015-12", "recommended_action": "Register supported breaches with cure deadlines and hold unverified subcontractor aliases. Owner: Priya Raman; due 2026-09-14.", "severity": "medium", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_order_forms/012_order_forms_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/03_amendments/024_amendments_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/05_pricing/036_pricing_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/06_service_levels/048_service_levels_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/096_renewal_records_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/097_ember_medical_impact_population.xlsx"]}], "as_of": "2026-09-17", "decision": {"alternatives_considered": ["ember-medical:blanket-hold", "ember-medical:shortcut"], "question": "Can Ember continue or terminate the support arrangement after the missed responses and subcontractor additions?", "rationale": "The four-part causal test supports 5 scoped actions and leaves 7 records on evidence hold. Cure and termination rights depend on measured SLA breaches and current compliance prerequisites.", "recommendation": "Use the documented cure, suspension, or termination path for each supported breach.", "selected_option_id": "ember-medical:scoped-evidence"}, "holds": [{"id": "HOLD-CBP-015-01", "issue": "order-form precedence conflict", "portfolio_key": "CBP-015-01", "reason": "the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective", "required_next_evidence": "effective approval and an active owner with remaining capacity", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/001_master_agreements_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/02_order_forms/013_order_forms_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/025_statements_of_work_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/05_pricing/037_pricing_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/097_ember_medical_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-015-02", "issue": "service-credit underpayment", "portfolio_key": "CBP-015-02", "reason": "the operational record relies on a superseded control revision", "required_next_evidence": "an operational record using the current effective revision", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/002_master_agreements_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/02_order_forms/014_order_forms_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/026_statements_of_work_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/05_pricing/038_pricing_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/10_correspondence/074_correspondence_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/097_ember_medical_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-015-03", "issue": "insurance-limit deficiency", "portfolio_key": "CBP-015-03", "reason": "two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key", "required_next_evidence": "an approved immutable entity crosswalk", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/003_master_agreements_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/02_order_forms/015_order_forms_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/027_statements_of_work_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/05_pricing/039_pricing_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/07_security_privacy/051_security_privacy_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/11_policies/087_policies_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/097_ember_medical_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-015-04", "issue": "usage-report inconsistency", "portfolio_key": "CBP-015-04", "reason": "the current observation does not meet the operative trigger", "required_next_evidence": "a current observation that satisfies the operative trigger", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/004_master_agreements_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/02_order_forms/016_order_forms_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/028_statements_of_work_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/05_pricing/040_pricing_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/097_ember_medical_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-015-07", "issue": "invoice currency discrepancy", "portfolio_key": "CBP-015-07", "reason": "two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key", "required_next_evidence": "an approved immutable entity crosswalk", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/007_master_agreements_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/03_amendments/019_amendments_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/031_statements_of_work_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/06_service_levels/043_service_levels_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/10_correspondence/079_correspondence_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/07_security_privacy/055_security_privacy_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/097_ember_medical_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-015-08", "issue": "pricing-escalator mismatch", "portfolio_key": "CBP-015-08", "reason": "the current observation does not meet the operative trigger", "required_next_evidence": "a current observation that satisfies the operative trigger", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/008_master_agreements_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/03_amendments/020_amendments_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/032_statements_of_work_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/06_service_levels/044_service_levels_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/092_renewal_records_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/09_invoices/068_invoices_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/097_ember_medical_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-015-09", "issue": "data-localization conflict", "portfolio_key": "CBP-015-09", "reason": "the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective", "required_next_evidence": "effective approval and an active owner with remaining capacity", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_order_forms/009_order_forms_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/03_amendments/021_amendments_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/05_pricing/033_pricing_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/06_service_levels/045_service_levels_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/08_notices/057_notices_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/097_ember_medical_impact_population.xlsx"]}], "matter_number": "CB-CC-2505", "prepared_for": "Ember Medical Devices", "schema_version": "counselbench.decision.v3", "task_id": "cb100-015-ember-medical"}, "matter_register": {"matter_number": "CB-CC-2505", "rows": [{"decision_option_id": "ember-medical:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective", "issue": "order-form precedence conflict", "matter_number": "CB-CC-2505", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-015-01", "row_id": "REG-CBP-015-01", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/001_master_agreements_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/02_order_forms/013_order_forms_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/025_statements_of_work_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/05_pricing/037_pricing_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/097_ember_medical_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "ember-medical:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "the operational record relies on a superseded control revision", "issue": "service-credit underpayment", "matter_number": "CB-CC-2505", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-015-02", "row_id": "REG-CBP-015-02", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/002_master_agreements_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/02_order_forms/014_order_forms_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/026_statements_of_work_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/05_pricing/038_pricing_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/10_correspondence/074_correspondence_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/097_ember_medical_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "ember-medical:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key", "issue": "insurance-limit deficiency", "matter_number": "CB-CC-2505", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-015-03", "row_id": "REG-CBP-015-03", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/003_master_agreements_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/02_order_forms/015_order_forms_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/027_statements_of_work_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/05_pricing/039_pricing_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/07_security_privacy/051_security_privacy_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/11_policies/087_policies_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/097_ember_medical_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "ember-medical:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "the current observation does not meet the operative trigger", "issue": "usage-report inconsistency", "matter_number": "CB-CC-2505", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-015-04", "row_id": "REG-CBP-015-04", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/004_master_agreements_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/02_order_forms/016_order_forms_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/028_statements_of_work_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/05_pricing/040_pricing_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/097_ember_medical_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "ember-medical:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-12", "issue": "minimum-commit shortfall", "matter_number": "CB-CC-2505", "owner": "Dominic Alvarez", "portfolio_key": "CBP-015-05", "row_id": "REG-CBP-015-05", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/005_master_agreements_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/03_amendments/017_amendments_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/029_statements_of_work_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/06_service_levels/041_service_levels_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/097_ember_medical_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "ember-medical:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-11", "issue": "subprocessor notice lapse", "matter_number": "CB-CC-2505", "owner": "Leona Park", "portfolio_key": "CBP-015-06", "row_id": "REG-CBP-015-06", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/006_master_agreements_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/03_amendments/018_amendments_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/030_statements_of_work_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/06_service_levels/042_service_levels_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/097_ember_medical_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "ember-medical:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key", "issue": "invoice currency discrepancy", "matter_number": "CB-CC-2505", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-015-07", "row_id": "REG-CBP-015-07", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/007_master_agreements_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/03_amendments/019_amendments_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/031_statements_of_work_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/06_service_levels/043_service_levels_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/10_correspondence/079_correspondence_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/07_security_privacy/055_security_privacy_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/097_ember_medical_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "ember-medical:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "the current observation does not meet the operative trigger", "issue": "pricing-escalator mismatch", "matter_number": "CB-CC-2505", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-015-08", "row_id": "REG-CBP-015-08", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/008_master_agreements_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/03_amendments/020_amendments_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/032_statements_of_work_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/06_service_levels/044_service_levels_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/092_renewal_records_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/09_invoices/068_invoices_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/097_ember_medical_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "ember-medical:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective", "issue": "data-localization conflict", "matter_number": "CB-CC-2505", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-015-09", "row_id": "REG-CBP-015-09", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_order_forms/009_order_forms_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/03_amendments/021_amendments_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/05_pricing/033_pricing_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/06_service_levels/045_service_levels_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/08_notices/057_notices_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/097_ember_medical_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "ember-medical:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-16", "issue": "benchmarking right omission", "matter_number": "CB-CC-2505", "owner": "Willa Novak", "portfolio_key": "CBP-015-10", "row_id": "REG-CBP-015-10", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_order_forms/010_order_forms_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/03_amendments/022_amendments_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/05_pricing/034_pricing_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/06_service_levels/046_service_levels_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/097_ember_medical_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "ember-medical:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-15", "issue": "renewal date conflict", "matter_number": "CB-CC-2505", "owner": "Owen Delgado", "portfolio_key": "CBP-015-11", "row_id": "REG-CBP-015-11", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_order_forms/011_order_forms_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/03_amendments/023_amendments_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/05_pricing/035_pricing_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/06_service_levels/047_service_levels_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/095_renewal_records_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/09_invoices/071_invoices_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/097_ember_medical_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "ember-medical:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-14", "issue": "assignment consent requirement", "matter_number": "CB-CC-2505", "owner": "Priya Raman", "portfolio_key": "CBP-015-12", "row_id": "REG-CBP-015-12", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_order_forms/012_order_forms_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/03_amendments/024_amendments_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/05_pricing/036_pricing_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/06_service_levels/048_service_levels_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/096_renewal_records_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/097_ember_medical_impact_population.xlsx"]}], "schema_version": "counselbench.matter-register.v3", "task_id": "cb100-015-ember-medical"}}, "metadata": {"benchmark": "CounselBench-100", "code_license": "Apache-2.0", "data_license": "CC-BY-4.0", "deadline": "2026-09-17", "document_count": 97, "evidence_holds": 7, "jurisdiction": "Minnesota", "matter_number": "CB-CC-2505", "mcp_commit": "9a96ea6e5913736f92b88345bf51caeaaa8e719f", "mcp_package": "@modelcontextprotocol/server-filesystem@2026.7.10", "practice_area": "commercial-contracts", "reference_tool_calls": 89, "required_evidence_reads": 61, "supported_actions": 5, "synthetic": true, "venue": "Hennepin County, Minnesota", "version": "3.1.0"}, "prompt": "We inherited inconsistent versions of this matter and need to settle the operating position. Can Ember continue or terminate the support arrangement after the missed responses and subcontractor additions? A national maintenance vendor missed response targets and added subcontractors without completing required background or insurance documentation. The team needs the call by 2026-09-17. I need the recommendation and the real blockers recorded before the team acts.", "rubric": {"criteria": [{"category": "investigation", "description": "Inventory the production and use targeted searches to locate records across native formats.", "id": "investigation.discover_production"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Complete every task-specific identity, authority, operations, and approval read before the first state transition.", "id": "investigation.read_before_write"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Inspect designated source metadata before relying on those records.", "id": "investigation.custody_before_write"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "Select the supported option 'ember-medical:scoped-evidence' after applying the four-part test.", "id": "decision.selected_option"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "Identify both rejected approaches and explain why a one-source shortcut and a blanket hold are wrong.", "id": "decision.alternatives"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-015-01 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/001_master_agreements_source_export.md rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-015-01.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_order_forms/013_order_forms_source_export.json for order-form precedence conflict.", "id": "investigation.CBP-015-01.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/025_statements_of_work_source_export.md to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-015-01.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_pricing/037_pricing_source_export.json.", "id": "investigation.CBP-015-01.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-015-01 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective.", "id": "decision.CBP-015-01.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-015-01 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-015-01.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-015-02 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/002_master_agreements_source_export.txt rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-015-02.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_order_forms/014_order_forms_source_export.xml for service-credit underpayment.", "id": "investigation.CBP-015-02.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/026_statements_of_work_source_export.txt to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-015-02.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_pricing/038_pricing_source_export.xml.", "id": "investigation.CBP-015-02.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-015-02 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is the operational record relies on a superseded control revision.", "id": "decision.CBP-015-02.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-015-02 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-015-02.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-015-03 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/003_master_agreements_source_export.eml rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-015-03.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_order_forms/015_order_forms_source_export.html for insurance-limit deficiency.", "id": "investigation.CBP-015-03.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/027_statements_of_work_source_export.eml to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-015-03.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_pricing/039_pricing_source_export.html.", "id": "investigation.CBP-015-03.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-015-03 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key.", "id": "decision.CBP-015-03.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-015-03 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-015-03.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-015-04 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/004_master_agreements_source_export.csv rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-015-04.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_order_forms/016_order_forms_source_export.pdf for usage-report inconsistency.", "id": "investigation.CBP-015-04.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/028_statements_of_work_source_export.csv to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-015-04.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_pricing/040_pricing_source_export.pdf.", "id": "investigation.CBP-015-04.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-015-04 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is the current observation does not meet the operative trigger.", "id": "decision.CBP-015-04.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-015-04 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-015-04.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-015-05 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/005_master_agreements_source_export.json rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-015-05.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_amendments/017_amendments_source_export.md for minimum-commit shortfall.", "id": "investigation.CBP-015-05.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/029_statements_of_work_source_export.json to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-015-05.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_service_levels/041_service_levels_source_export.md.", "id": "investigation.CBP-015-05.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-015-05 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-015-05.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-015-05 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-015-05.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-015-06 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/006_master_agreements_source_export.xml rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-015-06.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_amendments/018_amendments_source_export.txt for subprocessor notice lapse.", "id": "investigation.CBP-015-06.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/030_statements_of_work_source_export.xml to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-015-06.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_service_levels/042_service_levels_source_export.txt.", "id": "investigation.CBP-015-06.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-015-06 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-015-06.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-015-06 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-015-06.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-015-07 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/007_master_agreements_source_export.html rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-015-07.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_amendments/019_amendments_source_export.eml for invoice currency discrepancy.", "id": "investigation.CBP-015-07.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/031_statements_of_work_source_export.html to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-015-07.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_service_levels/043_service_levels_source_export.eml.", "id": "investigation.CBP-015-07.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-015-07 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key.", "id": "decision.CBP-015-07.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-015-07 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-015-07.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-015-08 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/008_master_agreements_source_export.pdf rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-015-08.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_amendments/020_amendments_source_export.csv for pricing-escalator mismatch.", "id": "investigation.CBP-015-08.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/032_statements_of_work_source_export.pdf to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-015-08.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_service_levels/044_service_levels_source_export.csv.", "id": "investigation.CBP-015-08.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-015-08 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is the current observation does not meet the operative trigger.", "id": "decision.CBP-015-08.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-015-08 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-015-08.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-015-09 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_order_forms/009_order_forms_source_export.md rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-015-09.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_amendments/021_amendments_source_export.json for data-localization conflict.", "id": "investigation.CBP-015-09.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_pricing/033_pricing_source_export.md to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-015-09.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_service_levels/045_service_levels_source_export.json.", "id": "investigation.CBP-015-09.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-015-09 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective.", "id": "decision.CBP-015-09.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-015-09 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-015-09.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-015-10 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_order_forms/010_order_forms_source_export.txt rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-015-10.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_amendments/022_amendments_source_export.xml for benchmarking right omission.", "id": "investigation.CBP-015-10.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_pricing/034_pricing_source_export.txt to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-015-10.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_service_levels/046_service_levels_source_export.xml.", "id": "investigation.CBP-015-10.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-015-10 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-015-10.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-015-10 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-015-10.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-015-11 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_order_forms/011_order_forms_source_export.eml rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-015-11.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_amendments/023_amendments_source_export.html for renewal date conflict.", "id": "investigation.CBP-015-11.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_pricing/035_pricing_source_export.eml to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-015-11.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_service_levels/047_service_levels_source_export.html.", "id": "investigation.CBP-015-11.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-015-11 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-015-11.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-015-11 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-015-11.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-015-12 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_order_forms/012_order_forms_source_export.csv rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-015-12.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_amendments/024_amendments_source_export.pdf for assignment consent requirement.", "id": "investigation.CBP-015-12.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_pricing/036_pricing_source_export.csv to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-015-12.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_service_levels/048_service_levels_source_export.pdf.", "id": "investigation.CBP-015-12.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-015-12 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-015-12.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-015-12 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-015-12.register"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Write the exact selected option, supported action population, evidence-hold population, facts, owners, deadlines, and citations.", "id": "state.exact_decision"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create one exact register row per portfolio key with no extra, missing, or modified row.", "id": "state.exact_register"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Leave only the three approved deliverables and perform no extra state-changing write.", "id": "state.write_scope_containment"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Read back decision.json, matter-register.json, and advice.md after their final writes.", "id": "state.postwrite_readback"}, {"category": "answer", "description": "Explain the selected recommendation, supported actions, holds, alternatives, and limitations with exact source anchors.", "id": "answer.decision_note"}], "decision_options": [{"approach": "Treat supported actions and genuinely ambiguous records as if they were equally unresolved.", "id": "ember-medical:blanket-hold", "label": "Freeze the entire matter population"}, {"approach": "Apply the exact identity, current-state, authority, and revision test. Register supported breaches with cure deadlines and hold unverified subcontractor aliases.", "id": "ember-medical:scoped-evidence", "label": "Use the documented cure, suspension, or termination path for each supported breach."}, {"approach": "Use a plausible summary or one source without completing the controlling joins.", "id": "ember-medical:shortcut", "label": "Terminate immediately based on complaint volume without applying cure mechanics."}], "evaluation_narrative": {"authority": "Cure and termination rights depend on measured SLA breaches and current compliance prerequisites.", "observation": "Join incident response records, subcontractor identities, background checks, and insurance periods.", "question": "Can Ember continue or terminate the support arrangement after the missed responses and subcontractor additions?", "register_action": "Register supported breaches with cure deadlines and hold unverified subcontractor aliases."}, "gates": ["all_required_evidence_precedes_first_write", "decision_criteria_complete", "register_state_exact", "write_scope_contained", "all_outputs_verified_by_readback"], "metadata_checks": 12, "metric": "weighted_criteria_score", "minimum_tool_calls": 89, "required_deliverables": ["decision.json", "matter-register.json", "advice.md"], "required_document_reads": 61, "type": "deterministic", "weights": {"advice": 0.15, "decision": 0.35, "investigation": 0.25, "state": 0.25}}, "task_id": "cb100-015-ember-medical", "task_name": "Ember device-support contract triage", "world_id": "counselbench-filesystem-mcp-v3"}
+{"context_files": ["task_files/cb100-016-fathom-retail/01_master_agreements/001_master_agreements_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-016-fathom-retail/01_master_agreements/002_master_agreements_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-016-fathom-retail/01_master_agreements/003_master_agreements_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-016-fathom-retail/01_master_agreements/004_master_agreements_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-016-fathom-retail/01_master_agreements/005_master_agreements_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-016-fathom-retail/01_master_agreements/006_master_agreements_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-016-fathom-retail/01_master_agreements/007_master_agreements_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-016-fathom-retail/01_master_agreements/008_master_agreements_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-016-fathom-retail/02_order_forms/009_order_forms_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-016-fathom-retail/02_order_forms/010_order_forms_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-016-fathom-retail/02_order_forms/011_order_forms_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-016-fathom-retail/02_order_forms/012_order_forms_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-016-fathom-retail/02_order_forms/013_order_forms_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-016-fathom-retail/02_order_forms/014_order_forms_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-016-fathom-retail/02_order_forms/015_order_forms_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-016-fathom-retail/02_order_forms/016_order_forms_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-016-fathom-retail/03_amendments/017_amendments_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-016-fathom-retail/03_amendments/018_amendments_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-016-fathom-retail/03_amendments/019_amendments_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-016-fathom-retail/03_amendments/020_amendments_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-016-fathom-retail/03_amendments/021_amendments_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-016-fathom-retail/03_amendments/022_amendments_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-016-fathom-retail/03_amendments/023_amendments_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-016-fathom-retail/03_amendments/024_amendments_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-016-fathom-retail/04_statements_of_work/025_statements_of_work_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-016-fathom-retail/04_statements_of_work/026_statements_of_work_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-016-fathom-retail/04_statements_of_work/027_statements_of_work_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-016-fathom-retail/04_statements_of_work/028_statements_of_work_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-016-fathom-retail/04_statements_of_work/029_statements_of_work_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-016-fathom-retail/04_statements_of_work/030_statements_of_work_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-016-fathom-retail/04_statements_of_work/031_statements_of_work_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-016-fathom-retail/04_statements_of_work/032_statements_of_work_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-016-fathom-retail/05_pricing/033_pricing_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-016-fathom-retail/05_pricing/034_pricing_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-016-fathom-retail/05_pricing/035_pricing_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-016-fathom-retail/05_pricing/036_pricing_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-016-fathom-retail/05_pricing/037_pricing_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-016-fathom-retail/05_pricing/038_pricing_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-016-fathom-retail/05_pricing/039_pricing_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-016-fathom-retail/05_pricing/040_pricing_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-016-fathom-retail/06_service_levels/041_service_levels_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-016-fathom-retail/06_service_levels/042_service_levels_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-016-fathom-retail/06_service_levels/043_service_levels_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-016-fathom-retail/06_service_levels/044_service_levels_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-016-fathom-retail/06_service_levels/045_service_levels_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-016-fathom-retail/06_service_levels/046_service_levels_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-016-fathom-retail/06_service_levels/047_service_levels_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-016-fathom-retail/06_service_levels/048_service_levels_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-016-fathom-retail/07_security_privacy/049_security_privacy_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-016-fathom-retail/07_security_privacy/050_security_privacy_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-016-fathom-retail/07_security_privacy/051_security_privacy_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-016-fathom-retail/07_security_privacy/052_security_privacy_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-016-fathom-retail/07_security_privacy/053_security_privacy_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-016-fathom-retail/07_security_privacy/054_security_privacy_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-016-fathom-retail/07_security_privacy/055_security_privacy_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-016-fathom-retail/07_security_privacy/056_security_privacy_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-016-fathom-retail/08_notices/057_notices_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-016-fathom-retail/08_notices/058_notices_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-016-fathom-retail/08_notices/059_notices_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-016-fathom-retail/08_notices/060_notices_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-016-fathom-retail/08_notices/061_notices_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-016-fathom-retail/08_notices/062_notices_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-016-fathom-retail/08_notices/063_notices_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-016-fathom-retail/08_notices/064_notices_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-016-fathom-retail/09_invoices/065_invoices_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-016-fathom-retail/09_invoices/066_invoices_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-016-fathom-retail/09_invoices/067_invoices_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-016-fathom-retail/09_invoices/068_invoices_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-016-fathom-retail/09_invoices/069_invoices_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-016-fathom-retail/09_invoices/070_invoices_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-016-fathom-retail/09_invoices/071_invoices_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-016-fathom-retail/09_invoices/072_invoices_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-016-fathom-retail/10_correspondence/073_correspondence_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-016-fathom-retail/10_correspondence/074_correspondence_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-016-fathom-retail/10_correspondence/075_correspondence_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-016-fathom-retail/10_correspondence/076_correspondence_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-016-fathom-retail/10_correspondence/077_correspondence_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-016-fathom-retail/10_correspondence/078_correspondence_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-016-fathom-retail/10_correspondence/079_correspondence_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-016-fathom-retail/10_correspondence/080_correspondence_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-016-fathom-retail/11_policies/081_policies_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-016-fathom-retail/11_policies/082_policies_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-016-fathom-retail/11_policies/083_policies_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-016-fathom-retail/11_policies/084_policies_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-016-fathom-retail/11_policies/085_policies_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-016-fathom-retail/11_policies/086_policies_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-016-fathom-retail/11_policies/087_policies_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-016-fathom-retail/11_policies/088_policies_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-016-fathom-retail/12_renewal_records/089_renewal_records_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-016-fathom-retail/12_renewal_records/090_renewal_records_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-016-fathom-retail/12_renewal_records/091_renewal_records_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-016-fathom-retail/12_renewal_records/092_renewal_records_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-016-fathom-retail/12_renewal_records/093_renewal_records_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-016-fathom-retail/12_renewal_records/094_renewal_records_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-016-fathom-retail/12_renewal_records/095_renewal_records_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-016-fathom-retail/12_renewal_records/096_renewal_records_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-016-fathom-retail/12_renewal_records/097_fathom_retail_impact_population.xlsx"], "gold_output": {"advice_markdown": "# Decision note — Fathom marketplace vendor audit\n\n## Recommendation\n\nApply the supported fee correction, territorial response, or transfer restriction. The reconciled record supports 7 scoped actions and leaves 5 items on evidence hold.\n\nSelected option: `fathom-retail:scoped-evidence`.\n\n## Why this is the supported option\n\nReconcile fee changes, seller geography, data routes, and the alleged email modification. Executed modification rules and current privacy schedules control over informal business understanding.\n\n## Supported actions\n\n### CBP-016-01 — survival-clause ambiguity (low)\n\nthe controlled population contains 121 records under CB-CC-2506-R779; the certification covers 111 records under CB-CC-2506-E192. Identity resolves to ENT-016-1000, revision REV-2026.1 is current, and Nora Chen is active with capacity 1.\n\nAction: Create scoped contract rows by category and period while holding ambiguous modifications. Owner: Nora Chen; due 2026-09-20.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/001_master_agreements_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/02_order_forms/013_order_forms_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/025_statements_of_work_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/05_pricing/037_pricing_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/08_notices/061_notices_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/097_fathom_retail_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-016-05 — service-credit underpayment (medium)\n\nan open exception blocks completion under CB-CC-2506-R787; the current status is open and unresolved under CB-CC-2506-E511. Identity resolves to ENT-016-1004, revision REV-2026.5 is current, and Talia Brooks is active with capacity 1.\n\nAction: Create scoped contract rows by category and period while holding ambiguous modifications. Owner: Talia Brooks; due 2026-09-16.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/005_master_agreements_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/03_amendments/017_amendments_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/029_statements_of_work_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/06_service_levels/041_service_levels_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/089_renewal_records_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/10_correspondence/077_correspondence_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/097_fathom_retail_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-016-06 — insurance-limit deficiency (critical)\n\ncompletion is required by 2026-01-18 under CB-CC-2506-R537; the current event record shows completion on 2026-01-30 under CB-CC-2506-E761. Identity resolves to ENT-016-1005, revision REV-2026.6 is current, and Adrian Mensah is active with capacity 5.\n\nAction: Create scoped contract rows by category and period while holding ambiguous modifications. Owner: Adrian Mensah; due 2026-09-15.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/006_master_agreements_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/03_amendments/018_amendments_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/030_statements_of_work_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/06_service_levels/042_service_levels_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/09_invoices/066_invoices_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/097_fathom_retail_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-016-07 — usage-report inconsistency (medium)\n\nthe controlling threshold is 5% under CB-CC-2506-R448; the independently calculated result is 9% under CB-CC-2506-E914. Identity resolves to ENT-016-1006, revision REV-2026.7 is current, and Farah Ibrahim is active with capacity 5.\n\nAction: Create scoped contract rows by category and period while holding ambiguous modifications. Owner: Farah Ibrahim; due 2026-09-14.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/007_master_agreements_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/03_amendments/019_amendments_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/031_statements_of_work_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/06_service_levels/043_service_levels_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/091_renewal_records_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/07_security_privacy/055_security_privacy_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/097_fathom_retail_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-016-08 — minimum-commit shortfall (critical)\n\napproval must come from Sofia Bennett under CB-CC-2506-R711; the effective approval record names Caleb Hassan under CB-CC-2506-E453. Identity resolves to ENT-016-1007, revision REV-2026.1 is current, and Dominic Alvarez is active with capacity 2.\n\nAction: Create scoped contract rows by category and period while holding ambiguous modifications. Owner: Dominic Alvarez; due 2026-09-13.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/008_master_agreements_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/03_amendments/020_amendments_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/032_statements_of_work_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/06_service_levels/044_service_levels_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/097_fathom_retail_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-016-11 — pricing-escalator mismatch (low)\n\nthe operative cap is $7,522,000.00 under CB-CC-2506-R330; the matched ledger population totals $7,646,230.00 under CB-CC-2506-E907. Identity resolves to ENT-016-1010, revision REV-2026.4 is current, and Maya Ellison is active with capacity 5.\n\nAction: Create scoped contract rows by category and period while holding ambiguous modifications. Owner: Maya Ellison; due 2026-09-19.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/02_order_forms/011_order_forms_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/03_amendments/023_amendments_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/05_pricing/035_pricing_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/06_service_levels/047_service_levels_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/09_invoices/071_invoices_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/097_fathom_retail_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-016-12 — data-localization conflict (high)\n\ndelivery must use notices-fathom_retail_markets@example.test under CB-CC-2506-R534; the only matched receipt used archive-north_cove_merchandising_corp@example.test under CB-CC-2506-E337. Identity resolves to ENT-016-1011, revision REV-2026.5 is current, and Jonas Feld is active with capacity 6.\n\nAction: Create scoped contract rows by category and period while holding ambiguous modifications. Owner: Jonas Feld; due 2026-09-18.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/02_order_forms/012_order_forms_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/03_amendments/024_amendments_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/05_pricing/036_pricing_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/06_service_levels/048_service_levels_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/11_policies/084_policies_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/097_fathom_retail_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n## Evidence holds\n\n- **CBP-016-02 — termination notice defect**: two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key. Next evidence: an approved immutable entity crosswalk. Sources: `/workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/002_master_agreements_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/02_order_forms/014_order_forms_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/026_statements_of_work_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/05_pricing/038_pricing_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/10_correspondence/074_correspondence_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/097_fathom_retail_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-016-03 — audit-right deadline**: the current observation does not meet the operative trigger. Next evidence: a current observation that satisfies the operative trigger. Sources: `/workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/003_master_agreements_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/02_order_forms/015_order_forms_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/027_statements_of_work_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/05_pricing/039_pricing_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/08_notices/063_notices_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/10_correspondence/075_correspondence_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/097_fathom_retail_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-016-04 — order-form precedence conflict**: the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective. Next evidence: effective approval and an active owner with remaining capacity. Sources: `/workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/004_master_agreements_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/02_order_forms/016_order_forms_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/028_statements_of_work_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/05_pricing/040_pricing_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/097_fathom_retail_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-016-09 — subprocessor notice lapse**: the operational record relies on a superseded control revision. Next evidence: an operational record using the current effective revision. Sources: `/workspace/documents/02_order_forms/009_order_forms_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/03_amendments/021_amendments_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/05_pricing/033_pricing_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/06_service_levels/045_service_levels_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/093_renewal_records_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/097_fathom_retail_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-016-10 — invoice currency discrepancy**: two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key. Next evidence: an approved immutable entity crosswalk. Sources: `/workspace/documents/02_order_forms/010_order_forms_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/03_amendments/022_amendments_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/05_pricing/034_pricing_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/06_service_levels/046_service_levels_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/097_fathom_retail_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n## Alternatives considered\n\n- `fathom-retail:shortcut` — Treat the email as a complete amendment and apply it to every category.: Use a plausible summary or one source without completing the controlling joins.\n- `fathom-retail:blanket-hold` — Freeze the entire matter population: Treat supported actions and genuinely ambiguous records as if they were equally unresolved.\n\n## Assumptions and limits\n\nThis decision is limited to cb100-016-fathom-retail, the supplied synthetic records, and the matter state as of 2026-09-21. Similar names, stale revisions, and pending authority are not treated as proof.\n", "decision": {"actions": [{"determination": "the controlled population contains 121 records under CB-CC-2506-R779; the certification covers 111 records under CB-CC-2506-E192. Identity resolves to ENT-016-1000, revision REV-2026.1 is current, and Nora Chen is active with capacity 1.", "due_date": "2026-09-20", "id": "ACT-CBP-016-01", "identity_id": "ENT-016-1000", "issue": "survival-clause ambiguity", "owner": "Nora Chen", "portfolio_key": "CBP-016-01", "recommended_action": "Create scoped contract rows by category and period while holding ambiguous modifications. Owner: Nora Chen; due 2026-09-20.", "severity": "low", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/001_master_agreements_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/02_order_forms/013_order_forms_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/025_statements_of_work_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/05_pricing/037_pricing_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/08_notices/061_notices_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/097_fathom_retail_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "an open exception blocks completion under CB-CC-2506-R787; the current status is open and unresolved under CB-CC-2506-E511. Identity resolves to ENT-016-1004, revision REV-2026.5 is current, and Talia Brooks is active with capacity 1.", "due_date": "2026-09-16", "id": "ACT-CBP-016-05", "identity_id": "ENT-016-1004", "issue": "service-credit underpayment", "owner": "Talia Brooks", "portfolio_key": "CBP-016-05", "recommended_action": "Create scoped contract rows by category and period while holding ambiguous modifications. Owner: Talia Brooks; due 2026-09-16.", "severity": "medium", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/005_master_agreements_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/03_amendments/017_amendments_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/029_statements_of_work_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/06_service_levels/041_service_levels_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/089_renewal_records_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/10_correspondence/077_correspondence_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/097_fathom_retail_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "completion is required by 2026-01-18 under CB-CC-2506-R537; the current event record shows completion on 2026-01-30 under CB-CC-2506-E761. Identity resolves to ENT-016-1005, revision REV-2026.6 is current, and Adrian Mensah is active with capacity 5.", "due_date": "2026-09-15", "id": "ACT-CBP-016-06", "identity_id": "ENT-016-1005", "issue": "insurance-limit deficiency", "owner": "Adrian Mensah", "portfolio_key": "CBP-016-06", "recommended_action": "Create scoped contract rows by category and period while holding ambiguous modifications. Owner: Adrian Mensah; due 2026-09-15.", "severity": "critical", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/006_master_agreements_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/03_amendments/018_amendments_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/030_statements_of_work_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/06_service_levels/042_service_levels_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/09_invoices/066_invoices_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/097_fathom_retail_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "the controlling threshold is 5% under CB-CC-2506-R448; the independently calculated result is 9% under CB-CC-2506-E914. Identity resolves to ENT-016-1006, revision REV-2026.7 is current, and Farah Ibrahim is active with capacity 5.", "due_date": "2026-09-14", "id": "ACT-CBP-016-07", "identity_id": "ENT-016-1006", "issue": "usage-report inconsistency", "owner": "Farah Ibrahim", "portfolio_key": "CBP-016-07", "recommended_action": "Create scoped contract rows by category and period while holding ambiguous modifications. Owner: Farah Ibrahim; due 2026-09-14.", "severity": "medium", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/007_master_agreements_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/03_amendments/019_amendments_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/031_statements_of_work_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/06_service_levels/043_service_levels_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/091_renewal_records_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/07_security_privacy/055_security_privacy_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/097_fathom_retail_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "approval must come from Sofia Bennett under CB-CC-2506-R711; the effective approval record names Caleb Hassan under CB-CC-2506-E453. Identity resolves to ENT-016-1007, revision REV-2026.1 is current, and Dominic Alvarez is active with capacity 2.", "due_date": "2026-09-13", "id": "ACT-CBP-016-08", "identity_id": "ENT-016-1007", "issue": "minimum-commit shortfall", "owner": "Dominic Alvarez", "portfolio_key": "CBP-016-08", "recommended_action": "Create scoped contract rows by category and period while holding ambiguous modifications. Owner: Dominic Alvarez; due 2026-09-13.", "severity": "critical", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/008_master_agreements_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/03_amendments/020_amendments_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/032_statements_of_work_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/06_service_levels/044_service_levels_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/097_fathom_retail_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "the operative cap is $7,522,000.00 under CB-CC-2506-R330; the matched ledger population totals $7,646,230.00 under CB-CC-2506-E907. Identity resolves to ENT-016-1010, revision REV-2026.4 is current, and Maya Ellison is active with capacity 5.", "due_date": "2026-09-19", "id": "ACT-CBP-016-11", "identity_id": "ENT-016-1010", "issue": "pricing-escalator mismatch", "owner": "Maya Ellison", "portfolio_key": "CBP-016-11", "recommended_action": "Create scoped contract rows by category and period while holding ambiguous modifications. Owner: Maya Ellison; due 2026-09-19.", "severity": "low", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_order_forms/011_order_forms_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/03_amendments/023_amendments_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/05_pricing/035_pricing_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/06_service_levels/047_service_levels_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/09_invoices/071_invoices_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/097_fathom_retail_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "delivery must use notices-fathom_retail_markets@example.test under CB-CC-2506-R534; the only matched receipt used archive-north_cove_merchandising_corp@example.test under CB-CC-2506-E337. Identity resolves to ENT-016-1011, revision REV-2026.5 is current, and Jonas Feld is active with capacity 6.", "due_date": "2026-09-18", "id": "ACT-CBP-016-12", "identity_id": "ENT-016-1011", "issue": "data-localization conflict", "owner": "Jonas Feld", "portfolio_key": "CBP-016-12", "recommended_action": "Create scoped contract rows by category and period while holding ambiguous modifications. Owner: Jonas Feld; due 2026-09-18.", "severity": "high", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_order_forms/012_order_forms_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/03_amendments/024_amendments_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/05_pricing/036_pricing_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/06_service_levels/048_service_levels_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/11_policies/084_policies_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/097_fathom_retail_impact_population.xlsx"]}], "as_of": "2026-09-21", "decision": {"alternatives_considered": ["fathom-retail:shortcut", "fathom-retail:blanket-hold"], "question": "Which marketplace fee, exclusivity, and data-location terms govern Fathom now?", "rationale": "The four-part causal test supports 7 scoped actions and leaves 5 records on evidence hold. Executed modification rules and current privacy schedules control over informal business understanding.", "recommendation": "Apply the supported fee correction, territorial response, or transfer restriction.", "selected_option_id": "fathom-retail:scoped-evidence"}, "holds": [{"id": "HOLD-CBP-016-02", "issue": "termination notice defect", "portfolio_key": "CBP-016-02", "reason": "two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key", "required_next_evidence": "an approved immutable entity crosswalk", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/002_master_agreements_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/02_order_forms/014_order_forms_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/026_statements_of_work_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/05_pricing/038_pricing_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/10_correspondence/074_correspondence_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/097_fathom_retail_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-016-03", "issue": "audit-right deadline", "portfolio_key": "CBP-016-03", "reason": "the current observation does not meet the operative trigger", "required_next_evidence": "a current observation that satisfies the operative trigger", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/003_master_agreements_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/02_order_forms/015_order_forms_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/027_statements_of_work_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/05_pricing/039_pricing_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/08_notices/063_notices_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/10_correspondence/075_correspondence_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/097_fathom_retail_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-016-04", "issue": "order-form precedence conflict", "portfolio_key": "CBP-016-04", "reason": "the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective", "required_next_evidence": "effective approval and an active owner with remaining capacity", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/004_master_agreements_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/02_order_forms/016_order_forms_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/028_statements_of_work_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/05_pricing/040_pricing_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/097_fathom_retail_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-016-09", "issue": "subprocessor notice lapse", "portfolio_key": "CBP-016-09", "reason": "the operational record relies on a superseded control revision", "required_next_evidence": "an operational record using the current effective revision", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_order_forms/009_order_forms_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/03_amendments/021_amendments_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/05_pricing/033_pricing_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/06_service_levels/045_service_levels_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/093_renewal_records_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/097_fathom_retail_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-016-10", "issue": "invoice currency discrepancy", "portfolio_key": "CBP-016-10", "reason": "two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key", "required_next_evidence": "an approved immutable entity crosswalk", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_order_forms/010_order_forms_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/03_amendments/022_amendments_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/05_pricing/034_pricing_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/06_service_levels/046_service_levels_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/097_fathom_retail_impact_population.xlsx"]}], "matter_number": "CB-CC-2506", "prepared_for": "Fathom Retail Markets", "schema_version": "counselbench.decision.v3", "task_id": "cb100-016-fathom-retail"}, "matter_register": {"matter_number": "CB-CC-2506", "rows": [{"decision_option_id": "fathom-retail:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-20", "issue": "survival-clause ambiguity", "matter_number": "CB-CC-2506", "owner": "Nora Chen", "portfolio_key": "CBP-016-01", "row_id": "REG-CBP-016-01", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/001_master_agreements_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/02_order_forms/013_order_forms_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/025_statements_of_work_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/05_pricing/037_pricing_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/08_notices/061_notices_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/097_fathom_retail_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "fathom-retail:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key", "issue": "termination notice defect", "matter_number": "CB-CC-2506", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-016-02", "row_id": "REG-CBP-016-02", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/002_master_agreements_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/02_order_forms/014_order_forms_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/026_statements_of_work_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/05_pricing/038_pricing_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/10_correspondence/074_correspondence_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/097_fathom_retail_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "fathom-retail:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "the current observation does not meet the operative trigger", "issue": "audit-right deadline", "matter_number": "CB-CC-2506", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-016-03", "row_id": "REG-CBP-016-03", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/003_master_agreements_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/02_order_forms/015_order_forms_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/027_statements_of_work_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/05_pricing/039_pricing_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/08_notices/063_notices_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/10_correspondence/075_correspondence_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/097_fathom_retail_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "fathom-retail:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective", "issue": "order-form precedence conflict", "matter_number": "CB-CC-2506", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-016-04", "row_id": "REG-CBP-016-04", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/004_master_agreements_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/02_order_forms/016_order_forms_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/028_statements_of_work_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/05_pricing/040_pricing_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/097_fathom_retail_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "fathom-retail:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-16", "issue": "service-credit underpayment", "matter_number": "CB-CC-2506", "owner": "Talia Brooks", "portfolio_key": "CBP-016-05", "row_id": "REG-CBP-016-05", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/005_master_agreements_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/03_amendments/017_amendments_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/029_statements_of_work_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/06_service_levels/041_service_levels_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/089_renewal_records_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/10_correspondence/077_correspondence_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/097_fathom_retail_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "fathom-retail:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-15", "issue": "insurance-limit deficiency", "matter_number": "CB-CC-2506", "owner": "Adrian Mensah", "portfolio_key": "CBP-016-06", "row_id": "REG-CBP-016-06", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/006_master_agreements_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/03_amendments/018_amendments_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/030_statements_of_work_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/06_service_levels/042_service_levels_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/09_invoices/066_invoices_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/097_fathom_retail_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "fathom-retail:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-14", "issue": "usage-report inconsistency", "matter_number": "CB-CC-2506", "owner": "Farah Ibrahim", "portfolio_key": "CBP-016-07", "row_id": "REG-CBP-016-07", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/007_master_agreements_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/03_amendments/019_amendments_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/031_statements_of_work_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/06_service_levels/043_service_levels_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/091_renewal_records_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/07_security_privacy/055_security_privacy_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/097_fathom_retail_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "fathom-retail:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-13", "issue": "minimum-commit shortfall", "matter_number": "CB-CC-2506", "owner": "Dominic Alvarez", "portfolio_key": "CBP-016-08", "row_id": "REG-CBP-016-08", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/008_master_agreements_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/03_amendments/020_amendments_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/032_statements_of_work_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/06_service_levels/044_service_levels_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/097_fathom_retail_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "fathom-retail:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "the operational record relies on a superseded control revision", "issue": "subprocessor notice lapse", "matter_number": "CB-CC-2506", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-016-09", "row_id": "REG-CBP-016-09", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_order_forms/009_order_forms_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/03_amendments/021_amendments_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/05_pricing/033_pricing_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/06_service_levels/045_service_levels_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/093_renewal_records_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/097_fathom_retail_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "fathom-retail:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key", "issue": "invoice currency discrepancy", "matter_number": "CB-CC-2506", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-016-10", "row_id": "REG-CBP-016-10", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_order_forms/010_order_forms_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/03_amendments/022_amendments_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/05_pricing/034_pricing_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/06_service_levels/046_service_levels_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/097_fathom_retail_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "fathom-retail:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-19", "issue": "pricing-escalator mismatch", "matter_number": "CB-CC-2506", "owner": "Maya Ellison", "portfolio_key": "CBP-016-11", "row_id": "REG-CBP-016-11", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_order_forms/011_order_forms_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/03_amendments/023_amendments_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/05_pricing/035_pricing_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/06_service_levels/047_service_levels_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/09_invoices/071_invoices_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/097_fathom_retail_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "fathom-retail:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-18", "issue": "data-localization conflict", "matter_number": "CB-CC-2506", "owner": "Jonas Feld", "portfolio_key": "CBP-016-12", "row_id": "REG-CBP-016-12", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_order_forms/012_order_forms_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/03_amendments/024_amendments_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/05_pricing/036_pricing_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/06_service_levels/048_service_levels_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/11_policies/084_policies_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/097_fathom_retail_impact_population.xlsx"]}], "schema_version": "counselbench.matter-register.v3", "task_id": "cb100-016-fathom-retail"}}, "metadata": {"benchmark": "CounselBench-100", "code_license": "Apache-2.0", "data_license": "CC-BY-4.0", "deadline": "2026-09-21", "document_count": 97, "evidence_holds": 5, "jurisdiction": "Illinois", "matter_number": "CB-CC-2506", "mcp_commit": "9a96ea6e5913736f92b88345bf51caeaaa8e719f", "mcp_package": "@modelcontextprotocol/server-filesystem@2026.7.10", "practice_area": "commercial-contracts", "reference_tool_calls": 82, "required_evidence_reads": 61, "supported_actions": 7, "synthetic": true, "venue": "Cook County, Illinois", "version": "3.1.0"}, "prompt": "I am about to brief the decision makers and need the source record reconciled first. Which marketplace fee, exclusivity, and data-location terms govern Fathom now? Marketplace fees changed mid-quarter, returns data moved offshore, and the parties disagree whether an email modified the category exclusivity provision. The team needs the call by 2026-09-21. Record the outcome the source hierarchy supports and explain the alternatives we should not take.", "rubric": {"criteria": [{"category": "investigation", "description": "Inventory the production and use targeted searches to locate records across native formats.", "id": "investigation.discover_production"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Complete every task-specific identity, authority, operations, and approval read before the first state transition.", "id": "investigation.read_before_write"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Inspect designated source metadata before relying on those records.", "id": "investigation.custody_before_write"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "Select the supported option 'fathom-retail:scoped-evidence' after applying the four-part test.", "id": "decision.selected_option"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "Identify both rejected approaches and explain why a one-source shortcut and a blanket hold are wrong.", "id": "decision.alternatives"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-016-01 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/001_master_agreements_source_export.md rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-016-01.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_order_forms/013_order_forms_source_export.json for survival-clause ambiguity.", "id": "investigation.CBP-016-01.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/025_statements_of_work_source_export.md to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-016-01.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_pricing/037_pricing_source_export.json.", "id": "investigation.CBP-016-01.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-016-01 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-016-01.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-016-01 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-016-01.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-016-02 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/002_master_agreements_source_export.txt rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-016-02.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_order_forms/014_order_forms_source_export.xml for termination notice defect.", "id": "investigation.CBP-016-02.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/026_statements_of_work_source_export.txt to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-016-02.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_pricing/038_pricing_source_export.xml.", "id": "investigation.CBP-016-02.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-016-02 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key.", "id": "decision.CBP-016-02.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-016-02 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-016-02.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-016-03 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/003_master_agreements_source_export.eml rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-016-03.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_order_forms/015_order_forms_source_export.html for audit-right deadline.", "id": "investigation.CBP-016-03.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/027_statements_of_work_source_export.eml to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-016-03.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_pricing/039_pricing_source_export.html.", "id": "investigation.CBP-016-03.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-016-03 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is the current observation does not meet the operative trigger.", "id": "decision.CBP-016-03.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-016-03 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-016-03.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-016-04 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/004_master_agreements_source_export.csv rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-016-04.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_order_forms/016_order_forms_source_export.pdf for order-form precedence conflict.", "id": "investigation.CBP-016-04.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/028_statements_of_work_source_export.csv to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-016-04.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_pricing/040_pricing_source_export.pdf.", "id": "investigation.CBP-016-04.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-016-04 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective.", "id": "decision.CBP-016-04.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-016-04 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-016-04.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-016-05 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/005_master_agreements_source_export.json rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-016-05.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_amendments/017_amendments_source_export.md for service-credit underpayment.", "id": "investigation.CBP-016-05.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/029_statements_of_work_source_export.json to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-016-05.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_service_levels/041_service_levels_source_export.md.", "id": "investigation.CBP-016-05.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-016-05 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-016-05.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-016-05 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-016-05.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-016-06 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/006_master_agreements_source_export.xml rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-016-06.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_amendments/018_amendments_source_export.txt for insurance-limit deficiency.", "id": "investigation.CBP-016-06.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/030_statements_of_work_source_export.xml to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-016-06.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_service_levels/042_service_levels_source_export.txt.", "id": "investigation.CBP-016-06.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-016-06 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-016-06.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-016-06 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-016-06.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-016-07 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/007_master_agreements_source_export.html rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-016-07.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_amendments/019_amendments_source_export.eml for usage-report inconsistency.", "id": "investigation.CBP-016-07.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/031_statements_of_work_source_export.html to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-016-07.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_service_levels/043_service_levels_source_export.eml.", "id": "investigation.CBP-016-07.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-016-07 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-016-07.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-016-07 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-016-07.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-016-08 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/008_master_agreements_source_export.pdf rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-016-08.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_amendments/020_amendments_source_export.csv for minimum-commit shortfall.", "id": "investigation.CBP-016-08.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/032_statements_of_work_source_export.pdf to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-016-08.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_service_levels/044_service_levels_source_export.csv.", "id": "investigation.CBP-016-08.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-016-08 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-016-08.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-016-08 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-016-08.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-016-09 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_order_forms/009_order_forms_source_export.md rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-016-09.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_amendments/021_amendments_source_export.json for subprocessor notice lapse.", "id": "investigation.CBP-016-09.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_pricing/033_pricing_source_export.md to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-016-09.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_service_levels/045_service_levels_source_export.json.", "id": "investigation.CBP-016-09.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-016-09 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is the operational record relies on a superseded control revision.", "id": "decision.CBP-016-09.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-016-09 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-016-09.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-016-10 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_order_forms/010_order_forms_source_export.txt rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-016-10.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_amendments/022_amendments_source_export.xml for invoice currency discrepancy.", "id": "investigation.CBP-016-10.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_pricing/034_pricing_source_export.txt to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-016-10.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_service_levels/046_service_levels_source_export.xml.", "id": "investigation.CBP-016-10.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-016-10 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key.", "id": "decision.CBP-016-10.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-016-10 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-016-10.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-016-11 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_order_forms/011_order_forms_source_export.eml rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-016-11.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_amendments/023_amendments_source_export.html for pricing-escalator mismatch.", "id": "investigation.CBP-016-11.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_pricing/035_pricing_source_export.eml to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-016-11.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_service_levels/047_service_levels_source_export.html.", "id": "investigation.CBP-016-11.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-016-11 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-016-11.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-016-11 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-016-11.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-016-12 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_order_forms/012_order_forms_source_export.csv rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-016-12.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_amendments/024_amendments_source_export.pdf for data-localization conflict.", "id": "investigation.CBP-016-12.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_pricing/036_pricing_source_export.csv to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-016-12.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_service_levels/048_service_levels_source_export.pdf.", "id": "investigation.CBP-016-12.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-016-12 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-016-12.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-016-12 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-016-12.register"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Write the exact selected option, supported action population, evidence-hold population, facts, owners, deadlines, and citations.", "id": "state.exact_decision"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create one exact register row per portfolio key with no extra, missing, or modified row.", "id": "state.exact_register"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Leave only the three approved deliverables and perform no extra state-changing write.", "id": "state.write_scope_containment"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Read back decision.json, matter-register.json, and advice.md after their final writes.", "id": "state.postwrite_readback"}, {"category": "answer", "description": "Explain the selected recommendation, supported actions, holds, alternatives, and limitations with exact source anchors.", "id": "answer.decision_note"}], "decision_options": [{"approach": "Apply the exact identity, current-state, authority, and revision test. Create scoped contract rows by category and period while holding ambiguous modifications.", "id": "fathom-retail:scoped-evidence", "label": "Apply the supported fee correction, territorial response, or transfer restriction."}, {"approach": "Use a plausible summary or one source without completing the controlling joins.", "id": "fathom-retail:shortcut", "label": "Treat the email as a complete amendment and apply it to every category."}, {"approach": "Treat supported actions and genuinely ambiguous records as if they were equally unresolved.", "id": "fathom-retail:blanket-hold", "label": "Freeze the entire matter population"}], "evaluation_narrative": {"authority": "Executed modification rules and current privacy schedules control over informal business understanding.", "observation": "Reconcile fee changes, seller geography, data routes, and the alleged email modification.", "question": "Which marketplace fee, exclusivity, and data-location terms govern Fathom now?", "register_action": "Create scoped contract rows by category and period while holding ambiguous modifications."}, "gates": ["all_required_evidence_precedes_first_write", "decision_criteria_complete", "register_state_exact", "write_scope_contained", "all_outputs_verified_by_readback"], "metadata_checks": 8, "metric": "weighted_criteria_score", "minimum_tool_calls": 82, "required_deliverables": ["decision.json", "matter-register.json", "advice.md"], "required_document_reads": 61, "type": "deterministic", "weights": {"advice": 0.15, "decision": 0.35, "investigation": 0.25, "state": 0.25}}, "task_id": "cb100-016-fathom-retail", "task_name": "Fathom marketplace vendor audit", "world_id": "counselbench-filesystem-mcp-v3"}
+{"context_files": ["task_files/cb100-017-garnet-energy/01_master_agreements/001_master_agreements_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-017-garnet-energy/01_master_agreements/002_master_agreements_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-017-garnet-energy/01_master_agreements/003_master_agreements_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-017-garnet-energy/01_master_agreements/004_master_agreements_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-017-garnet-energy/01_master_agreements/005_master_agreements_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-017-garnet-energy/01_master_agreements/006_master_agreements_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-017-garnet-energy/01_master_agreements/007_master_agreements_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-017-garnet-energy/01_master_agreements/008_master_agreements_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-017-garnet-energy/02_order_forms/009_order_forms_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-017-garnet-energy/02_order_forms/010_order_forms_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-017-garnet-energy/02_order_forms/011_order_forms_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-017-garnet-energy/02_order_forms/012_order_forms_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-017-garnet-energy/02_order_forms/013_order_forms_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-017-garnet-energy/02_order_forms/014_order_forms_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-017-garnet-energy/02_order_forms/015_order_forms_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-017-garnet-energy/02_order_forms/016_order_forms_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-017-garnet-energy/03_amendments/017_amendments_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-017-garnet-energy/03_amendments/018_amendments_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-017-garnet-energy/03_amendments/019_amendments_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-017-garnet-energy/03_amendments/020_amendments_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-017-garnet-energy/03_amendments/021_amendments_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-017-garnet-energy/03_amendments/022_amendments_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-017-garnet-energy/03_amendments/023_amendments_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-017-garnet-energy/03_amendments/024_amendments_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-017-garnet-energy/04_statements_of_work/025_statements_of_work_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-017-garnet-energy/04_statements_of_work/026_statements_of_work_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-017-garnet-energy/04_statements_of_work/027_statements_of_work_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-017-garnet-energy/04_statements_of_work/028_statements_of_work_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-017-garnet-energy/04_statements_of_work/029_statements_of_work_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-017-garnet-energy/04_statements_of_work/030_statements_of_work_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-017-garnet-energy/04_statements_of_work/031_statements_of_work_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-017-garnet-energy/04_statements_of_work/032_statements_of_work_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-017-garnet-energy/05_pricing/033_pricing_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-017-garnet-energy/05_pricing/034_pricing_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-017-garnet-energy/05_pricing/035_pricing_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-017-garnet-energy/05_pricing/036_pricing_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-017-garnet-energy/05_pricing/037_pricing_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-017-garnet-energy/05_pricing/038_pricing_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-017-garnet-energy/05_pricing/039_pricing_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-017-garnet-energy/05_pricing/040_pricing_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-017-garnet-energy/06_service_levels/041_service_levels_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-017-garnet-energy/06_service_levels/042_service_levels_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-017-garnet-energy/06_service_levels/043_service_levels_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-017-garnet-energy/06_service_levels/044_service_levels_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-017-garnet-energy/06_service_levels/045_service_levels_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-017-garnet-energy/06_service_levels/046_service_levels_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-017-garnet-energy/06_service_levels/047_service_levels_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-017-garnet-energy/06_service_levels/048_service_levels_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-017-garnet-energy/07_security_privacy/049_security_privacy_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-017-garnet-energy/07_security_privacy/050_security_privacy_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-017-garnet-energy/07_security_privacy/051_security_privacy_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-017-garnet-energy/07_security_privacy/052_security_privacy_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-017-garnet-energy/07_security_privacy/053_security_privacy_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-017-garnet-energy/07_security_privacy/054_security_privacy_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-017-garnet-energy/07_security_privacy/055_security_privacy_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-017-garnet-energy/07_security_privacy/056_security_privacy_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-017-garnet-energy/08_notices/057_notices_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-017-garnet-energy/08_notices/058_notices_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-017-garnet-energy/08_notices/059_notices_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-017-garnet-energy/08_notices/060_notices_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-017-garnet-energy/08_notices/061_notices_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-017-garnet-energy/08_notices/062_notices_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-017-garnet-energy/08_notices/063_notices_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-017-garnet-energy/08_notices/064_notices_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-017-garnet-energy/09_invoices/065_invoices_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-017-garnet-energy/09_invoices/066_invoices_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-017-garnet-energy/09_invoices/067_invoices_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-017-garnet-energy/09_invoices/068_invoices_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-017-garnet-energy/09_invoices/069_invoices_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-017-garnet-energy/09_invoices/070_invoices_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-017-garnet-energy/09_invoices/071_invoices_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-017-garnet-energy/09_invoices/072_invoices_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-017-garnet-energy/10_correspondence/073_correspondence_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-017-garnet-energy/10_correspondence/074_correspondence_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-017-garnet-energy/10_correspondence/075_correspondence_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-017-garnet-energy/10_correspondence/076_correspondence_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-017-garnet-energy/10_correspondence/077_correspondence_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-017-garnet-energy/10_correspondence/078_correspondence_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-017-garnet-energy/10_correspondence/079_correspondence_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-017-garnet-energy/10_correspondence/080_correspondence_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-017-garnet-energy/11_policies/081_policies_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-017-garnet-energy/11_policies/082_policies_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-017-garnet-energy/11_policies/083_policies_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-017-garnet-energy/11_policies/084_policies_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-017-garnet-energy/11_policies/085_policies_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-017-garnet-energy/11_policies/086_policies_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-017-garnet-energy/11_policies/087_policies_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-017-garnet-energy/11_policies/088_policies_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-017-garnet-energy/12_renewal_records/089_renewal_records_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-017-garnet-energy/12_renewal_records/090_renewal_records_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-017-garnet-energy/12_renewal_records/091_renewal_records_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-017-garnet-energy/12_renewal_records/092_renewal_records_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-017-garnet-energy/12_renewal_records/093_renewal_records_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-017-garnet-energy/12_renewal_records/094_renewal_records_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-017-garnet-energy/12_renewal_records/095_renewal_records_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-017-garnet-energy/12_renewal_records/096_renewal_records_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-017-garnet-energy/12_renewal_records/097_garnet_energy_impact_population.xlsx"], "gold_output": {"advice_markdown": "# Decision note — Garnet offtake agreement review\n\n## Recommendation\n\nCalculate the supported adjustment and preserve any notice defect that changes enforceability. The reconciled record supports 5 scoped actions and leaves 7 items on evidence hold.\n\nSelected option: `garnet-energy:scoped-evidence`.\n\n## Why this is the supported option\n\nMatch meter intervals, tariff events, and delivery receipts to the operative notice clause and facility. The effective pricing formula and amended notice instructions determine relief.\n\n## Supported actions\n\n### CBP-017-02 — assignment consent requirement (low)\n\nthe controlling threshold is 9% under CB-CC-2507-R754; the independently calculated result is 17% under CB-CC-2507-E138. Identity resolves to ENT-017-1001, revision REV-2025.2 is current, and Sofia Bennett is active with capacity 4.\n\nAction: Register exact facility-period adjustments and separately flag defective notice service. Owner: Sofia Bennett; due 2026-09-22.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/002_master_agreements_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/02_order_forms/014_order_forms_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/026_statements_of_work_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/05_pricing/038_pricing_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/10_correspondence/074_correspondence_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/07_security_privacy/050_security_privacy_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/097_garnet_energy_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-017-03 — exclusivity carveout breach (low)\n\napproval must come from Lena Varga under CB-CC-2507-R160; the effective approval record names Caleb Hassan under CB-CC-2507-E527. Identity resolves to ENT-017-1002, revision REV-2025.3 is current, and Micah Sullivan is active with capacity 2.\n\nAction: Register exact facility-period adjustments and separately flag defective notice service. Owner: Micah Sullivan; due 2026-09-21.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/003_master_agreements_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/02_order_forms/015_order_forms_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/027_statements_of_work_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/05_pricing/039_pricing_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/07_security_privacy/051_security_privacy_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/08_notices/063_notices_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/097_garnet_energy_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-017-07 — order-form precedence conflict (high)\n\ndelivery must use notices-garnet_renewable_energy@example.test under CB-CC-2507-R820; the only matched receipt used archive-mesa_crown_utilities@example.test under CB-CC-2507-E195. Identity resolves to ENT-017-1006, revision REV-2025.7 is current, and Samuel Kim is active with capacity 5.\n\nAction: Register exact facility-period adjustments and separately flag defective notice service. Owner: Samuel Kim; due 2026-09-17.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/007_master_agreements_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/03_amendments/019_amendments_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/031_statements_of_work_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/06_service_levels/043_service_levels_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/091_renewal_records_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/097_garnet_energy_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-017-09 — insurance-limit deficiency (critical)\n\ncompletion is required by 2025-06-15 under CB-CC-2507-R500; the current event record shows completion on 2025-07-27 under CB-CC-2507-E441. Identity resolves to ENT-017-1008, revision REV-2025.2 is current, and Adrian Mensah is active with capacity 5.\n\nAction: Register exact facility-period adjustments and separately flag defective notice service. Owner: Adrian Mensah; due 2026-09-15.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/02_order_forms/009_order_forms_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/03_amendments/021_amendments_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/05_pricing/033_pricing_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/06_service_levels/045_service_levels_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/093_renewal_records_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/097_garnet_energy_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-017-11 — minimum-commit shortfall (medium)\n\napproval must come from Lena Varga under CB-CC-2507-R754; the effective approval record names Rafael Okafor under CB-CC-2507-E614. Identity resolves to ENT-017-1010, revision REV-2025.4 is current, and Dominic Alvarez is active with capacity 1.\n\nAction: Register exact facility-period adjustments and separately flag defective notice service. Owner: Dominic Alvarez; due 2026-09-22.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/02_order_forms/011_order_forms_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/03_amendments/023_amendments_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/05_pricing/035_pricing_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/06_service_levels/047_service_levels_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/09_invoices/071_invoices_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/097_garnet_energy_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n## Evidence holds\n\n- **CBP-017-01 — renewal date conflict**: two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key. Next evidence: an approved immutable entity crosswalk. Sources: `/workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/001_master_agreements_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/02_order_forms/013_order_forms_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/025_statements_of_work_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/05_pricing/037_pricing_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/11_policies/085_policies_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/07_security_privacy/049_security_privacy_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/097_garnet_energy_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-017-04 — survival-clause ambiguity**: the operational record relies on a superseded control revision. Next evidence: an operational record using the current effective revision. Sources: `/workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/004_master_agreements_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/02_order_forms/016_order_forms_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/028_statements_of_work_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/05_pricing/040_pricing_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/097_garnet_energy_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-017-05 — termination notice defect**: two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key. Next evidence: an approved immutable entity crosswalk. Sources: `/workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/005_master_agreements_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/03_amendments/017_amendments_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/029_statements_of_work_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/06_service_levels/041_service_levels_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/097_garnet_energy_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-017-06 — audit-right deadline**: the current observation does not meet the operative trigger. Next evidence: a current observation that satisfies the operative trigger. Sources: `/workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/006_master_agreements_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/03_amendments/018_amendments_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/030_statements_of_work_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/06_service_levels/042_service_levels_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/09_invoices/066_invoices_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/097_garnet_energy_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-017-08 — service-credit underpayment**: the operational record relies on a superseded control revision. Next evidence: an operational record using the current effective revision. Sources: `/workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/008_master_agreements_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/03_amendments/020_amendments_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/032_statements_of_work_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/06_service_levels/044_service_levels_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/097_garnet_energy_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-017-10 — usage-report inconsistency**: the current observation does not meet the operative trigger. Next evidence: a current observation that satisfies the operative trigger. Sources: `/workspace/documents/02_order_forms/010_order_forms_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/03_amendments/022_amendments_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/05_pricing/034_pricing_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/06_service_levels/046_service_levels_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/08_notices/058_notices_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/097_garnet_energy_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-017-12 — subprocessor notice lapse**: the operational record relies on a superseded control revision. Next evidence: an operational record using the current effective revision. Sources: `/workspace/documents/02_order_forms/012_order_forms_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/03_amendments/024_amendments_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/05_pricing/036_pricing_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/06_service_levels/048_service_levels_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/097_garnet_energy_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n## Alternatives considered\n\n- `garnet-energy:shortcut` — Use the claimant's aggregate spreadsheet and the superseded notice address.: Use a plausible summary or one source without completing the controlling joins.\n- `garnet-energy:blanket-hold` — Freeze the entire matter population: Treat supported actions and genuinely ambiguous records as if they were equally unresolved.\n\n## Assumptions and limits\n\nThis decision is limited to cb100-017-garnet-energy, the supplied synthetic records, and the matter state as of 2026-09-24. Similar names, stale revisions, and pending authority are not treated as proof.\n", "decision": {"actions": [{"determination": "the controlling threshold is 9% under CB-CC-2507-R754; the independently calculated result is 17% under CB-CC-2507-E138. Identity resolves to ENT-017-1001, revision REV-2025.2 is current, and Sofia Bennett is active with capacity 4.", "due_date": "2026-09-22", "id": "ACT-CBP-017-02", "identity_id": "ENT-017-1001", "issue": "assignment consent requirement", "owner": "Sofia Bennett", "portfolio_key": "CBP-017-02", "recommended_action": "Register exact facility-period adjustments and separately flag defective notice service. Owner: Sofia Bennett; due 2026-09-22.", "severity": "low", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/002_master_agreements_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/02_order_forms/014_order_forms_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/026_statements_of_work_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/05_pricing/038_pricing_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/10_correspondence/074_correspondence_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/07_security_privacy/050_security_privacy_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/097_garnet_energy_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "approval must come from Lena Varga under CB-CC-2507-R160; the effective approval record names Caleb Hassan under CB-CC-2507-E527. Identity resolves to ENT-017-1002, revision REV-2025.3 is current, and Micah Sullivan is active with capacity 2.", "due_date": "2026-09-21", "id": "ACT-CBP-017-03", "identity_id": "ENT-017-1002", "issue": "exclusivity carveout breach", "owner": "Micah Sullivan", "portfolio_key": "CBP-017-03", "recommended_action": "Register exact facility-period adjustments and separately flag defective notice service. Owner: Micah Sullivan; due 2026-09-21.", "severity": "low", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/003_master_agreements_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/02_order_forms/015_order_forms_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/027_statements_of_work_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/05_pricing/039_pricing_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/07_security_privacy/051_security_privacy_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/08_notices/063_notices_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/097_garnet_energy_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "delivery must use notices-garnet_renewable_energy@example.test under CB-CC-2507-R820; the only matched receipt used archive-mesa_crown_utilities@example.test under CB-CC-2507-E195. Identity resolves to ENT-017-1006, revision REV-2025.7 is current, and Samuel Kim is active with capacity 5.", "due_date": "2026-09-17", "id": "ACT-CBP-017-07", "identity_id": "ENT-017-1006", "issue": "order-form precedence conflict", "owner": "Samuel Kim", "portfolio_key": "CBP-017-07", "recommended_action": "Register exact facility-period adjustments and separately flag defective notice service. Owner: Samuel Kim; due 2026-09-17.", "severity": "high", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/007_master_agreements_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/03_amendments/019_amendments_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/031_statements_of_work_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/06_service_levels/043_service_levels_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/091_renewal_records_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/097_garnet_energy_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "completion is required by 2025-06-15 under CB-CC-2507-R500; the current event record shows completion on 2025-07-27 under CB-CC-2507-E441. Identity resolves to ENT-017-1008, revision REV-2025.2 is current, and Adrian Mensah is active with capacity 5.", "due_date": "2026-09-15", "id": "ACT-CBP-017-09", "identity_id": "ENT-017-1008", "issue": "insurance-limit deficiency", "owner": "Adrian Mensah", "portfolio_key": "CBP-017-09", "recommended_action": "Register exact facility-period adjustments and separately flag defective notice service. Owner: Adrian Mensah; due 2026-09-15.", "severity": "critical", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_order_forms/009_order_forms_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/03_amendments/021_amendments_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/05_pricing/033_pricing_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/06_service_levels/045_service_levels_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/093_renewal_records_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/097_garnet_energy_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "approval must come from Lena Varga under CB-CC-2507-R754; the effective approval record names Rafael Okafor under CB-CC-2507-E614. Identity resolves to ENT-017-1010, revision REV-2025.4 is current, and Dominic Alvarez is active with capacity 1.", "due_date": "2026-09-22", "id": "ACT-CBP-017-11", "identity_id": "ENT-017-1010", "issue": "minimum-commit shortfall", "owner": "Dominic Alvarez", "portfolio_key": "CBP-017-11", "recommended_action": "Register exact facility-period adjustments and separately flag defective notice service. Owner: Dominic Alvarez; due 2026-09-22.", "severity": "medium", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_order_forms/011_order_forms_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/03_amendments/023_amendments_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/05_pricing/035_pricing_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/06_service_levels/047_service_levels_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/09_invoices/071_invoices_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/097_garnet_energy_impact_population.xlsx"]}], "as_of": "2026-09-24", "decision": {"alternatives_considered": ["garnet-energy:shortcut", "garnet-energy:blanket-hold"], "question": "What amount and notice position should Garnet use for the metering and change-in-law dispute?", "rationale": "The four-part causal test supports 5 scoped actions and leaves 7 records on evidence hold. The effective pricing formula and amended notice instructions determine relief.", "recommendation": "Calculate the supported adjustment and preserve any notice defect that changes enforceability.", "selected_option_id": "garnet-energy:scoped-evidence"}, "holds": [{"id": "HOLD-CBP-017-01", "issue": "renewal date conflict", "portfolio_key": "CBP-017-01", "reason": "two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key", "required_next_evidence": "an approved immutable entity crosswalk", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/001_master_agreements_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/02_order_forms/013_order_forms_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/025_statements_of_work_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/05_pricing/037_pricing_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/11_policies/085_policies_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/07_security_privacy/049_security_privacy_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/097_garnet_energy_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-017-04", "issue": "survival-clause ambiguity", "portfolio_key": "CBP-017-04", "reason": "the operational record relies on a superseded control revision", "required_next_evidence": "an operational record using the current effective revision", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/004_master_agreements_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/02_order_forms/016_order_forms_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/028_statements_of_work_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/05_pricing/040_pricing_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/097_garnet_energy_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-017-05", "issue": "termination notice defect", "portfolio_key": "CBP-017-05", "reason": "two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key", "required_next_evidence": "an approved immutable entity crosswalk", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/005_master_agreements_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/03_amendments/017_amendments_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/029_statements_of_work_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/06_service_levels/041_service_levels_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/097_garnet_energy_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-017-06", "issue": "audit-right deadline", "portfolio_key": "CBP-017-06", "reason": "the current observation does not meet the operative trigger", "required_next_evidence": "a current observation that satisfies the operative trigger", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/006_master_agreements_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/03_amendments/018_amendments_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/030_statements_of_work_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/06_service_levels/042_service_levels_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/09_invoices/066_invoices_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/097_garnet_energy_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-017-08", "issue": "service-credit underpayment", "portfolio_key": "CBP-017-08", "reason": "the operational record relies on a superseded control revision", "required_next_evidence": "an operational record using the current effective revision", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/008_master_agreements_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/03_amendments/020_amendments_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/032_statements_of_work_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/06_service_levels/044_service_levels_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/097_garnet_energy_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-017-10", "issue": "usage-report inconsistency", "portfolio_key": "CBP-017-10", "reason": "the current observation does not meet the operative trigger", "required_next_evidence": "a current observation that satisfies the operative trigger", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_order_forms/010_order_forms_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/03_amendments/022_amendments_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/05_pricing/034_pricing_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/06_service_levels/046_service_levels_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/08_notices/058_notices_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/097_garnet_energy_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-017-12", "issue": "subprocessor notice lapse", "portfolio_key": "CBP-017-12", "reason": "the operational record relies on a superseded control revision", "required_next_evidence": "an operational record using the current effective revision", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_order_forms/012_order_forms_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/03_amendments/024_amendments_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/05_pricing/036_pricing_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/06_service_levels/048_service_levels_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/097_garnet_energy_impact_population.xlsx"]}], "matter_number": "CB-CC-2507", "prepared_for": "Garnet Renewable Energy", "schema_version": "counselbench.decision.v3", "task_id": "cb100-017-garnet-energy"}, "matter_register": {"matter_number": "CB-CC-2507", "rows": [{"decision_option_id": "garnet-energy:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key", "issue": "renewal date conflict", "matter_number": "CB-CC-2507", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-017-01", "row_id": "REG-CBP-017-01", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/001_master_agreements_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/02_order_forms/013_order_forms_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/025_statements_of_work_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/05_pricing/037_pricing_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/11_policies/085_policies_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/07_security_privacy/049_security_privacy_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/097_garnet_energy_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "garnet-energy:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-22", "issue": "assignment consent requirement", "matter_number": "CB-CC-2507", "owner": "Sofia Bennett", "portfolio_key": "CBP-017-02", "row_id": "REG-CBP-017-02", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/002_master_agreements_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/02_order_forms/014_order_forms_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/026_statements_of_work_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/05_pricing/038_pricing_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/10_correspondence/074_correspondence_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/07_security_privacy/050_security_privacy_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/097_garnet_energy_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "garnet-energy:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-21", "issue": "exclusivity carveout breach", "matter_number": "CB-CC-2507", "owner": "Micah Sullivan", "portfolio_key": "CBP-017-03", "row_id": "REG-CBP-017-03", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/003_master_agreements_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/02_order_forms/015_order_forms_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/027_statements_of_work_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/05_pricing/039_pricing_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/07_security_privacy/051_security_privacy_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/08_notices/063_notices_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/097_garnet_energy_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "garnet-energy:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "the operational record relies on a superseded control revision", "issue": "survival-clause ambiguity", "matter_number": "CB-CC-2507", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-017-04", "row_id": "REG-CBP-017-04", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/004_master_agreements_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/02_order_forms/016_order_forms_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/028_statements_of_work_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/05_pricing/040_pricing_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/097_garnet_energy_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "garnet-energy:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key", "issue": "termination notice defect", "matter_number": "CB-CC-2507", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-017-05", "row_id": "REG-CBP-017-05", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/005_master_agreements_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/03_amendments/017_amendments_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/029_statements_of_work_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/06_service_levels/041_service_levels_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/097_garnet_energy_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "garnet-energy:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "the current observation does not meet the operative trigger", "issue": "audit-right deadline", "matter_number": "CB-CC-2507", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-017-06", "row_id": "REG-CBP-017-06", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/006_master_agreements_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/03_amendments/018_amendments_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/030_statements_of_work_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/06_service_levels/042_service_levels_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/09_invoices/066_invoices_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/097_garnet_energy_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "garnet-energy:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-17", "issue": "order-form precedence conflict", "matter_number": "CB-CC-2507", "owner": "Samuel Kim", "portfolio_key": "CBP-017-07", "row_id": "REG-CBP-017-07", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/007_master_agreements_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/03_amendments/019_amendments_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/031_statements_of_work_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/06_service_levels/043_service_levels_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/091_renewal_records_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/097_garnet_energy_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "garnet-energy:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "the operational record relies on a superseded control revision", "issue": "service-credit underpayment", "matter_number": "CB-CC-2507", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-017-08", "row_id": "REG-CBP-017-08", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/008_master_agreements_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/03_amendments/020_amendments_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/032_statements_of_work_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/06_service_levels/044_service_levels_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/097_garnet_energy_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "garnet-energy:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-15", "issue": "insurance-limit deficiency", "matter_number": "CB-CC-2507", "owner": "Adrian Mensah", "portfolio_key": "CBP-017-09", "row_id": "REG-CBP-017-09", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_order_forms/009_order_forms_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/03_amendments/021_amendments_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/05_pricing/033_pricing_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/06_service_levels/045_service_levels_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/093_renewal_records_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/097_garnet_energy_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "garnet-energy:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "the current observation does not meet the operative trigger", "issue": "usage-report inconsistency", "matter_number": "CB-CC-2507", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-017-10", "row_id": "REG-CBP-017-10", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_order_forms/010_order_forms_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/03_amendments/022_amendments_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/05_pricing/034_pricing_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/06_service_levels/046_service_levels_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/08_notices/058_notices_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/097_garnet_energy_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "garnet-energy:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-22", "issue": "minimum-commit shortfall", "matter_number": "CB-CC-2507", "owner": "Dominic Alvarez", "portfolio_key": "CBP-017-11", "row_id": "REG-CBP-017-11", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_order_forms/011_order_forms_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/03_amendments/023_amendments_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/05_pricing/035_pricing_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/06_service_levels/047_service_levels_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/09_invoices/071_invoices_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/097_garnet_energy_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "garnet-energy:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "the operational record relies on a superseded control revision", "issue": "subprocessor notice lapse", "matter_number": "CB-CC-2507", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-017-12", "row_id": "REG-CBP-017-12", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_order_forms/012_order_forms_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/03_amendments/024_amendments_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/05_pricing/036_pricing_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/06_service_levels/048_service_levels_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/097_garnet_energy_impact_population.xlsx"]}], "schema_version": "counselbench.matter-register.v3", "task_id": "cb100-017-garnet-energy"}}, "metadata": {"benchmark": "CounselBench-100", "code_license": "Apache-2.0", "data_license": "CC-BY-4.0", "deadline": "2026-09-24", "document_count": 97, "evidence_holds": 7, "jurisdiction": "Texas", "matter_number": "CB-CC-2507", "mcp_commit": "9a96ea6e5913736f92b88345bf51caeaaa8e719f", "mcp_package": "@modelcontextprotocol/server-filesystem@2026.7.10", "practice_area": "commercial-contracts", "reference_tool_calls": 87, "required_evidence_reads": 61, "supported_actions": 5, "synthetic": true, "venue": "Travis County, Texas", "version": "3.1.0"}, "prompt": "The other side has challenged our internal account of the facts. What amount and notice position should Garnet use for the metering and change-in-law dispute? An energy offtake portfolio contains metering disputes, a change-in-law pass-through, and notice records sent to an address deleted by amendment. The team needs the call by 2026-09-24. Leave a concise decision record with exact source references and an owner for each supported next step.", "rubric": {"criteria": [{"category": "investigation", "description": "Inventory the production and use targeted searches to locate records across native formats.", "id": "investigation.discover_production"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Complete every task-specific identity, authority, operations, and approval read before the first state transition.", "id": "investigation.read_before_write"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Inspect designated source metadata before relying on those records.", "id": "investigation.custody_before_write"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "Select the supported option 'garnet-energy:scoped-evidence' after applying the four-part test.", "id": "decision.selected_option"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "Identify both rejected approaches and explain why a one-source shortcut and a blanket hold are wrong.", "id": "decision.alternatives"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-017-01 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/001_master_agreements_source_export.md rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-017-01.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_order_forms/013_order_forms_source_export.json for renewal date conflict.", "id": "investigation.CBP-017-01.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/025_statements_of_work_source_export.md to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-017-01.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_pricing/037_pricing_source_export.json.", "id": "investigation.CBP-017-01.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-017-01 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key.", "id": "decision.CBP-017-01.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-017-01 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-017-01.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-017-02 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/002_master_agreements_source_export.txt rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-017-02.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_order_forms/014_order_forms_source_export.xml for assignment consent requirement.", "id": "investigation.CBP-017-02.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/026_statements_of_work_source_export.txt to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-017-02.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_pricing/038_pricing_source_export.xml.", "id": "investigation.CBP-017-02.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-017-02 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-017-02.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-017-02 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-017-02.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-017-03 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/003_master_agreements_source_export.eml rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-017-03.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_order_forms/015_order_forms_source_export.html for exclusivity carveout breach.", "id": "investigation.CBP-017-03.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/027_statements_of_work_source_export.eml to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-017-03.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_pricing/039_pricing_source_export.html.", "id": "investigation.CBP-017-03.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-017-03 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-017-03.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-017-03 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-017-03.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-017-04 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/004_master_agreements_source_export.csv rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-017-04.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_order_forms/016_order_forms_source_export.pdf for survival-clause ambiguity.", "id": "investigation.CBP-017-04.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/028_statements_of_work_source_export.csv to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-017-04.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_pricing/040_pricing_source_export.pdf.", "id": "investigation.CBP-017-04.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-017-04 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is the operational record relies on a superseded control revision.", "id": "decision.CBP-017-04.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-017-04 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-017-04.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-017-05 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/005_master_agreements_source_export.json rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-017-05.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_amendments/017_amendments_source_export.md for termination notice defect.", "id": "investigation.CBP-017-05.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/029_statements_of_work_source_export.json to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-017-05.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_service_levels/041_service_levels_source_export.md.", "id": "investigation.CBP-017-05.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-017-05 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key.", "id": "decision.CBP-017-05.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-017-05 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-017-05.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-017-06 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/006_master_agreements_source_export.xml rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-017-06.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_amendments/018_amendments_source_export.txt for audit-right deadline.", "id": "investigation.CBP-017-06.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/030_statements_of_work_source_export.xml to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-017-06.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_service_levels/042_service_levels_source_export.txt.", "id": "investigation.CBP-017-06.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-017-06 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is the current observation does not meet the operative trigger.", "id": "decision.CBP-017-06.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-017-06 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-017-06.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-017-07 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/007_master_agreements_source_export.html rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-017-07.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_amendments/019_amendments_source_export.eml for order-form precedence conflict.", "id": "investigation.CBP-017-07.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/031_statements_of_work_source_export.html to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-017-07.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_service_levels/043_service_levels_source_export.eml.", "id": "investigation.CBP-017-07.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-017-07 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-017-07.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-017-07 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-017-07.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-017-08 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/008_master_agreements_source_export.pdf rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-017-08.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_amendments/020_amendments_source_export.csv for service-credit underpayment.", "id": "investigation.CBP-017-08.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/032_statements_of_work_source_export.pdf to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-017-08.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_service_levels/044_service_levels_source_export.csv.", "id": "investigation.CBP-017-08.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-017-08 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is the operational record relies on a superseded control revision.", "id": "decision.CBP-017-08.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-017-08 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-017-08.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-017-09 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_order_forms/009_order_forms_source_export.md rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-017-09.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_amendments/021_amendments_source_export.json for insurance-limit deficiency.", "id": "investigation.CBP-017-09.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_pricing/033_pricing_source_export.md to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-017-09.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_service_levels/045_service_levels_source_export.json.", "id": "investigation.CBP-017-09.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-017-09 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-017-09.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-017-09 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-017-09.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-017-10 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_order_forms/010_order_forms_source_export.txt rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-017-10.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_amendments/022_amendments_source_export.xml for usage-report inconsistency.", "id": "investigation.CBP-017-10.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_pricing/034_pricing_source_export.txt to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-017-10.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_service_levels/046_service_levels_source_export.xml.", "id": "investigation.CBP-017-10.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-017-10 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is the current observation does not meet the operative trigger.", "id": "decision.CBP-017-10.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-017-10 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-017-10.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-017-11 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_order_forms/011_order_forms_source_export.eml rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-017-11.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_amendments/023_amendments_source_export.html for minimum-commit shortfall.", "id": "investigation.CBP-017-11.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_pricing/035_pricing_source_export.eml to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-017-11.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_service_levels/047_service_levels_source_export.html.", "id": "investigation.CBP-017-11.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-017-11 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-017-11.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-017-11 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-017-11.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-017-12 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_order_forms/012_order_forms_source_export.csv rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-017-12.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_amendments/024_amendments_source_export.pdf for subprocessor notice lapse.", "id": "investigation.CBP-017-12.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_pricing/036_pricing_source_export.csv to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-017-12.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_service_levels/048_service_levels_source_export.pdf.", "id": "investigation.CBP-017-12.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-017-12 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is the operational record relies on a superseded control revision.", "id": "decision.CBP-017-12.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-017-12 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-017-12.register"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Write the exact selected option, supported action population, evidence-hold population, facts, owners, deadlines, and citations.", "id": "state.exact_decision"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create one exact register row per portfolio key with no extra, missing, or modified row.", "id": "state.exact_register"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Leave only the three approved deliverables and perform no extra state-changing write.", "id": "state.write_scope_containment"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Read back decision.json, matter-register.json, and advice.md after their final writes.", "id": "state.postwrite_readback"}, {"category": "answer", "description": "Explain the selected recommendation, supported actions, holds, alternatives, and limitations with exact source anchors.", "id": "answer.decision_note"}], "decision_options": [{"approach": "Use a plausible summary or one source without completing the controlling joins.", "id": "garnet-energy:shortcut", "label": "Use the claimant's aggregate spreadsheet and the superseded notice address."}, {"approach": "Treat supported actions and genuinely ambiguous records as if they were equally unresolved.", "id": "garnet-energy:blanket-hold", "label": "Freeze the entire matter population"}, {"approach": "Apply the exact identity, current-state, authority, and revision test. Register exact facility-period adjustments and separately flag defective notice service.", "id": "garnet-energy:scoped-evidence", "label": "Calculate the supported adjustment and preserve any notice defect that changes enforceability."}], "evaluation_narrative": {"authority": "The effective pricing formula and amended notice instructions determine relief.", "observation": "Match meter intervals, tariff events, and delivery receipts to the operative notice clause and facility.", "question": "What amount and notice position should Garnet use for the metering and change-in-law dispute?", "register_action": "Register exact facility-period adjustments and separately flag defective notice service."}, "gates": ["all_required_evidence_precedes_first_write", "decision_criteria_complete", "register_state_exact", "write_scope_contained", "all_outputs_verified_by_readback"], "metadata_checks": 12, "metric": "weighted_criteria_score", "minimum_tool_calls": 87, "required_deliverables": ["decision.json", "matter-register.json", "advice.md"], "required_document_reads": 61, "type": "deterministic", "weights": {"advice": 0.15, "decision": 0.35, "investigation": 0.25, "state": 0.25}}, "task_id": "cb100-017-garnet-energy", "task_name": "Garnet offtake agreement review", "world_id": "counselbench-filesystem-mcp-v3"}
+{"context_files": ["task_files/cb100-018-harborlight-ai/01_master_agreements/001_master_agreements_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-018-harborlight-ai/01_master_agreements/002_master_agreements_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-018-harborlight-ai/01_master_agreements/003_master_agreements_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-018-harborlight-ai/01_master_agreements/004_master_agreements_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-018-harborlight-ai/01_master_agreements/005_master_agreements_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-018-harborlight-ai/01_master_agreements/006_master_agreements_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-018-harborlight-ai/01_master_agreements/007_master_agreements_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-018-harborlight-ai/01_master_agreements/008_master_agreements_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-018-harborlight-ai/02_order_forms/009_order_forms_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-018-harborlight-ai/02_order_forms/010_order_forms_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-018-harborlight-ai/02_order_forms/011_order_forms_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-018-harborlight-ai/02_order_forms/012_order_forms_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-018-harborlight-ai/02_order_forms/013_order_forms_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-018-harborlight-ai/02_order_forms/014_order_forms_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-018-harborlight-ai/02_order_forms/015_order_forms_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-018-harborlight-ai/02_order_forms/016_order_forms_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-018-harborlight-ai/03_amendments/017_amendments_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-018-harborlight-ai/03_amendments/018_amendments_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-018-harborlight-ai/03_amendments/019_amendments_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-018-harborlight-ai/03_amendments/020_amendments_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-018-harborlight-ai/03_amendments/021_amendments_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-018-harborlight-ai/03_amendments/022_amendments_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-018-harborlight-ai/03_amendments/023_amendments_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-018-harborlight-ai/03_amendments/024_amendments_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-018-harborlight-ai/04_statements_of_work/025_statements_of_work_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-018-harborlight-ai/04_statements_of_work/026_statements_of_work_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-018-harborlight-ai/04_statements_of_work/027_statements_of_work_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-018-harborlight-ai/04_statements_of_work/028_statements_of_work_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-018-harborlight-ai/04_statements_of_work/029_statements_of_work_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-018-harborlight-ai/04_statements_of_work/030_statements_of_work_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-018-harborlight-ai/04_statements_of_work/031_statements_of_work_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-018-harborlight-ai/04_statements_of_work/032_statements_of_work_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-018-harborlight-ai/05_pricing/033_pricing_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-018-harborlight-ai/05_pricing/034_pricing_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-018-harborlight-ai/05_pricing/035_pricing_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-018-harborlight-ai/05_pricing/036_pricing_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-018-harborlight-ai/05_pricing/037_pricing_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-018-harborlight-ai/05_pricing/038_pricing_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-018-harborlight-ai/05_pricing/039_pricing_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-018-harborlight-ai/05_pricing/040_pricing_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-018-harborlight-ai/06_service_levels/041_service_levels_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-018-harborlight-ai/06_service_levels/042_service_levels_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-018-harborlight-ai/06_service_levels/043_service_levels_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-018-harborlight-ai/06_service_levels/044_service_levels_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-018-harborlight-ai/06_service_levels/045_service_levels_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-018-harborlight-ai/06_service_levels/046_service_levels_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-018-harborlight-ai/06_service_levels/047_service_levels_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-018-harborlight-ai/06_service_levels/048_service_levels_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-018-harborlight-ai/07_security_privacy/049_security_privacy_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-018-harborlight-ai/07_security_privacy/050_security_privacy_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-018-harborlight-ai/07_security_privacy/051_security_privacy_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-018-harborlight-ai/07_security_privacy/052_security_privacy_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-018-harborlight-ai/07_security_privacy/053_security_privacy_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-018-harborlight-ai/07_security_privacy/054_security_privacy_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-018-harborlight-ai/07_security_privacy/055_security_privacy_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-018-harborlight-ai/07_security_privacy/056_security_privacy_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-018-harborlight-ai/08_notices/057_notices_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-018-harborlight-ai/08_notices/058_notices_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-018-harborlight-ai/08_notices/059_notices_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-018-harborlight-ai/08_notices/060_notices_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-018-harborlight-ai/08_notices/061_notices_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-018-harborlight-ai/08_notices/062_notices_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-018-harborlight-ai/08_notices/063_notices_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-018-harborlight-ai/08_notices/064_notices_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-018-harborlight-ai/09_invoices/065_invoices_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-018-harborlight-ai/09_invoices/066_invoices_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-018-harborlight-ai/09_invoices/067_invoices_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-018-harborlight-ai/09_invoices/068_invoices_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-018-harborlight-ai/09_invoices/069_invoices_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-018-harborlight-ai/09_invoices/070_invoices_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-018-harborlight-ai/09_invoices/071_invoices_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-018-harborlight-ai/09_invoices/072_invoices_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-018-harborlight-ai/10_correspondence/073_correspondence_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-018-harborlight-ai/10_correspondence/074_correspondence_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-018-harborlight-ai/10_correspondence/075_correspondence_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-018-harborlight-ai/10_correspondence/076_correspondence_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-018-harborlight-ai/10_correspondence/077_correspondence_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-018-harborlight-ai/10_correspondence/078_correspondence_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-018-harborlight-ai/10_correspondence/079_correspondence_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-018-harborlight-ai/10_correspondence/080_correspondence_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-018-harborlight-ai/11_policies/081_policies_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-018-harborlight-ai/11_policies/082_policies_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-018-harborlight-ai/11_policies/083_policies_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-018-harborlight-ai/11_policies/084_policies_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-018-harborlight-ai/11_policies/085_policies_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-018-harborlight-ai/11_policies/086_policies_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-018-harborlight-ai/11_policies/087_policies_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-018-harborlight-ai/11_policies/088_policies_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-018-harborlight-ai/12_renewal_records/089_renewal_records_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-018-harborlight-ai/12_renewal_records/090_renewal_records_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-018-harborlight-ai/12_renewal_records/091_renewal_records_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-018-harborlight-ai/12_renewal_records/092_renewal_records_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-018-harborlight-ai/12_renewal_records/093_renewal_records_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-018-harborlight-ai/12_renewal_records/094_renewal_records_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-018-harborlight-ai/12_renewal_records/095_renewal_records_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-018-harborlight-ai/12_renewal_records/096_renewal_records_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-018-harborlight-ai/12_renewal_records/097_harborlight_ai_impact_population.xlsx"], "gold_output": {"advice_markdown": "# Decision note — Harborlight AI procurement reconciliation\n\n## Recommendation\n\nRenew only with the supported data-use, deletion, and notification corrections. The reconciled record supports 6 scoped actions and leaves 6 items on evidence hold.\n\nSelected option: `harborlight-ai:scoped-evidence`.\n\n## Why this is the supported option\n\nJoin benchmark results, model-use records, deletion schedules, and incident chronology by product instance. Executed data restrictions and the stricter effective deletion and notice obligations control.\n\n## Supported actions\n\n### CBP-018-01 — pricing-escalator mismatch (high)\n\nthe operative cap is $3,322,000.00 under CB-CC-2508-R878; the matched ledger population totals $3,409,878.00 under CB-CC-2508-E781. Identity resolves to ENT-018-1000, revision REV-2026.1 is current, and Mei Whitaker is active with capacity 4.\n\nAction: Create product-specific remediation rows and hold records lacking an exact instance match. Owner: Mei Whitaker; due 2026-09-27.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/001_master_agreements_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/02_order_forms/013_order_forms_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/025_statements_of_work_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/05_pricing/037_pricing_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/097_harborlight_ai_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-018-02 — data-localization conflict (high)\n\ndelivery must use notices-harborlight_ai_systems@example.test under CB-CC-2508-R946; the only matched receipt used archive-westmere_insurance_cooperative@example.test under CB-CC-2508-E255. Identity resolves to ENT-018-1001, revision REV-2026.2 is current, and Theo Laurent is active with capacity 4.\n\nAction: Create product-specific remediation rows and hold records lacking an exact instance match. Owner: Theo Laurent; due 2026-09-26.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/002_master_agreements_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/02_order_forms/014_order_forms_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/026_statements_of_work_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/05_pricing/038_pricing_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/097_harborlight_ai_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-018-03 — benchmarking right omission (medium)\n\nan open exception blocks completion under CB-CC-2508-R784; the current status is open and unresolved under CB-CC-2508-E828. Identity resolves to ENT-018-1002, revision REV-2026.3 is current, and Lena Varga is active with capacity 2.\n\nAction: Create product-specific remediation rows and hold records lacking an exact instance match. Owner: Lena Varga; due 2026-09-25.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/003_master_agreements_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/02_order_forms/015_order_forms_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/027_statements_of_work_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/05_pricing/039_pricing_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/08_notices/063_notices_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/097_harborlight_ai_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-018-04 — renewal date conflict (high)\n\ncompletion is required by 2025-02-15 under CB-CC-2508-R440; the current event record shows completion on 2025-02-26 under CB-CC-2508-E331. Identity resolves to ENT-018-1003, revision REV-2026.4 is current, and Elliot Mercer is active with capacity 3.\n\nAction: Create product-specific remediation rows and hold records lacking an exact instance match. Owner: Elliot Mercer; due 2026-09-24.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/004_master_agreements_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/02_order_forms/016_order_forms_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/028_statements_of_work_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/05_pricing/040_pricing_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/08_notices/064_notices_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/097_harborlight_ai_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-018-10 — order-form precedence conflict (critical)\n\ndelivery must use notices-harborlight_ai_systems@example.test under CB-CC-2508-R169; the only matched receipt used archive-westmere_insurance_cooperative@example.test under CB-CC-2508-E104. Identity resolves to ENT-018-1009, revision REV-2026.3 is current, and Samuel Kim is active with capacity 6.\n\nAction: Create product-specific remediation rows and hold records lacking an exact instance match. Owner: Samuel Kim; due 2026-09-27.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/02_order_forms/010_order_forms_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/03_amendments/022_amendments_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/05_pricing/034_pricing_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/06_service_levels/046_service_levels_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/094_renewal_records_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/09_invoices/070_invoices_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/097_harborlight_ai_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-018-11 — service-credit underpayment (medium)\n\nan open exception blocks completion under CB-CC-2508-R108; the current status is open and unresolved under CB-CC-2508-E365. Identity resolves to ENT-018-1010, revision REV-2026.4 is current, and Talia Brooks is active with capacity 2.\n\nAction: Create product-specific remediation rows and hold records lacking an exact instance match. Owner: Talia Brooks; due 2026-09-26.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/02_order_forms/011_order_forms_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/03_amendments/023_amendments_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/05_pricing/035_pricing_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/06_service_levels/047_service_levels_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/11_policies/083_policies_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/097_harborlight_ai_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n## Evidence holds\n\n- **CBP-018-05 — assignment consent requirement**: the current observation does not meet the operative trigger. Next evidence: a current observation that satisfies the operative trigger. Sources: `/workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/005_master_agreements_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/03_amendments/017_amendments_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/029_statements_of_work_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/06_service_levels/041_service_levels_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/10_correspondence/077_correspondence_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/097_harborlight_ai_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-018-06 — exclusivity carveout breach**: the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective. Next evidence: effective approval and an active owner with remaining capacity. Sources: `/workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/006_master_agreements_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/03_amendments/018_amendments_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/030_statements_of_work_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/06_service_levels/042_service_levels_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/10_correspondence/078_correspondence_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/097_harborlight_ai_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-018-07 — survival-clause ambiguity**: the operational record relies on a superseded control revision. Next evidence: an operational record using the current effective revision. Sources: `/workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/007_master_agreements_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/03_amendments/019_amendments_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/031_statements_of_work_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/06_service_levels/043_service_levels_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/10_correspondence/079_correspondence_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/091_renewal_records_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/097_harborlight_ai_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-018-08 — termination notice defect**: two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key. Next evidence: an approved immutable entity crosswalk. Sources: `/workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/008_master_agreements_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/03_amendments/020_amendments_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/032_statements_of_work_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/06_service_levels/044_service_levels_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/09_invoices/068_invoices_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/092_renewal_records_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/097_harborlight_ai_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-018-09 — audit-right deadline**: the current observation does not meet the operative trigger. Next evidence: a current observation that satisfies the operative trigger. Sources: `/workspace/documents/02_order_forms/009_order_forms_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/03_amendments/021_amendments_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/05_pricing/033_pricing_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/06_service_levels/045_service_levels_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/09_invoices/069_invoices_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/08_notices/057_notices_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/097_harborlight_ai_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-018-12 — insurance-limit deficiency**: two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key. Next evidence: an approved immutable entity crosswalk. Sources: `/workspace/documents/02_order_forms/012_order_forms_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/03_amendments/024_amendments_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/05_pricing/036_pricing_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/06_service_levels/048_service_levels_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/09_invoices/072_invoices_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/097_harborlight_ai_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n## Alternatives considered\n\n- `harborlight-ai:blanket-hold` — Freeze the entire matter population: Treat supported actions and genuinely ambiguous records as if they were equally unresolved.\n- `harborlight-ai:shortcut` — Treat benchmark performance as waiving conflicting data obligations.: Use a plausible summary or one source without completing the controlling joins.\n\n## Assumptions and limits\n\nThis decision is limited to cb100-018-harborlight-ai, the supplied synthetic records, and the matter state as of 2026-09-28. Similar names, stale revisions, and pending authority are not treated as proof.\n", "decision": {"actions": [{"determination": "the operative cap is $3,322,000.00 under CB-CC-2508-R878; the matched ledger population totals $3,409,878.00 under CB-CC-2508-E781. Identity resolves to ENT-018-1000, revision REV-2026.1 is current, and Mei Whitaker is active with capacity 4.", "due_date": "2026-09-27", "id": "ACT-CBP-018-01", "identity_id": "ENT-018-1000", "issue": "pricing-escalator mismatch", "owner": "Mei Whitaker", "portfolio_key": "CBP-018-01", "recommended_action": "Create product-specific remediation rows and hold records lacking an exact instance match. Owner: Mei Whitaker; due 2026-09-27.", "severity": "high", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/001_master_agreements_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/02_order_forms/013_order_forms_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/025_statements_of_work_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/05_pricing/037_pricing_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/097_harborlight_ai_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "delivery must use notices-harborlight_ai_systems@example.test under CB-CC-2508-R946; the only matched receipt used archive-westmere_insurance_cooperative@example.test under CB-CC-2508-E255. Identity resolves to ENT-018-1001, revision REV-2026.2 is current, and Theo Laurent is active with capacity 4.", "due_date": "2026-09-26", "id": "ACT-CBP-018-02", "identity_id": "ENT-018-1001", "issue": "data-localization conflict", "owner": "Theo Laurent", "portfolio_key": "CBP-018-02", "recommended_action": "Create product-specific remediation rows and hold records lacking an exact instance match. Owner: Theo Laurent; due 2026-09-26.", "severity": "high", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/002_master_agreements_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/02_order_forms/014_order_forms_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/026_statements_of_work_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/05_pricing/038_pricing_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/097_harborlight_ai_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "an open exception blocks completion under CB-CC-2508-R784; the current status is open and unresolved under CB-CC-2508-E828. Identity resolves to ENT-018-1002, revision REV-2026.3 is current, and Lena Varga is active with capacity 2.", "due_date": "2026-09-25", "id": "ACT-CBP-018-03", "identity_id": "ENT-018-1002", "issue": "benchmarking right omission", "owner": "Lena Varga", "portfolio_key": "CBP-018-03", "recommended_action": "Create product-specific remediation rows and hold records lacking an exact instance match. Owner: Lena Varga; due 2026-09-25.", "severity": "medium", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/003_master_agreements_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/02_order_forms/015_order_forms_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/027_statements_of_work_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/05_pricing/039_pricing_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/08_notices/063_notices_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/097_harborlight_ai_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "completion is required by 2025-02-15 under CB-CC-2508-R440; the current event record shows completion on 2025-02-26 under CB-CC-2508-E331. Identity resolves to ENT-018-1003, revision REV-2026.4 is current, and Elliot Mercer is active with capacity 3.", "due_date": "2026-09-24", "id": "ACT-CBP-018-04", "identity_id": "ENT-018-1003", "issue": "renewal date conflict", "owner": "Elliot Mercer", "portfolio_key": "CBP-018-04", "recommended_action": "Create product-specific remediation rows and hold records lacking an exact instance match. Owner: Elliot Mercer; due 2026-09-24.", "severity": "high", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/004_master_agreements_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/02_order_forms/016_order_forms_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/028_statements_of_work_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/05_pricing/040_pricing_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/08_notices/064_notices_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/097_harborlight_ai_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "delivery must use notices-harborlight_ai_systems@example.test under CB-CC-2508-R169; the only matched receipt used archive-westmere_insurance_cooperative@example.test under CB-CC-2508-E104. Identity resolves to ENT-018-1009, revision REV-2026.3 is current, and Samuel Kim is active with capacity 6.", "due_date": "2026-09-27", "id": "ACT-CBP-018-10", "identity_id": "ENT-018-1009", "issue": "order-form precedence conflict", "owner": "Samuel Kim", "portfolio_key": "CBP-018-10", "recommended_action": "Create product-specific remediation rows and hold records lacking an exact instance match. Owner: Samuel Kim; due 2026-09-27.", "severity": "critical", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_order_forms/010_order_forms_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/03_amendments/022_amendments_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/05_pricing/034_pricing_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/06_service_levels/046_service_levels_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/094_renewal_records_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/09_invoices/070_invoices_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/097_harborlight_ai_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "an open exception blocks completion under CB-CC-2508-R108; the current status is open and unresolved under CB-CC-2508-E365. Identity resolves to ENT-018-1010, revision REV-2026.4 is current, and Talia Brooks is active with capacity 2.", "due_date": "2026-09-26", "id": "ACT-CBP-018-11", "identity_id": "ENT-018-1010", "issue": "service-credit underpayment", "owner": "Talia Brooks", "portfolio_key": "CBP-018-11", "recommended_action": "Create product-specific remediation rows and hold records lacking an exact instance match. Owner: Talia Brooks; due 2026-09-26.", "severity": "medium", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_order_forms/011_order_forms_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/03_amendments/023_amendments_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/05_pricing/035_pricing_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/06_service_levels/047_service_levels_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/11_policies/083_policies_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/097_harborlight_ai_impact_population.xlsx"]}], "as_of": "2026-09-28", "decision": {"alternatives_considered": ["harborlight-ai:blanket-hold", "harborlight-ai:shortcut"], "question": "Can Harborlight accept the AI services renewal, and what data and incident terms must be corrected first?", "rationale": "The four-part causal test supports 6 scoped actions and leaves 6 records on evidence hold. Executed data restrictions and the stricter effective deletion and notice obligations control.", "recommendation": "Renew only with the supported data-use, deletion, and notification corrections.", "selected_option_id": "harborlight-ai:scoped-evidence"}, "holds": [{"id": "HOLD-CBP-018-05", "issue": "assignment consent requirement", "portfolio_key": "CBP-018-05", "reason": "the current observation does not meet the operative trigger", "required_next_evidence": "a current observation that satisfies the operative trigger", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/005_master_agreements_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/03_amendments/017_amendments_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/029_statements_of_work_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/06_service_levels/041_service_levels_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/10_correspondence/077_correspondence_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/097_harborlight_ai_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-018-06", "issue": "exclusivity carveout breach", "portfolio_key": "CBP-018-06", "reason": "the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective", "required_next_evidence": "effective approval and an active owner with remaining capacity", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/006_master_agreements_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/03_amendments/018_amendments_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/030_statements_of_work_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/06_service_levels/042_service_levels_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/10_correspondence/078_correspondence_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/097_harborlight_ai_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-018-07", "issue": "survival-clause ambiguity", "portfolio_key": "CBP-018-07", "reason": "the operational record relies on a superseded control revision", "required_next_evidence": "an operational record using the current effective revision", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/007_master_agreements_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/03_amendments/019_amendments_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/031_statements_of_work_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/06_service_levels/043_service_levels_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/10_correspondence/079_correspondence_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/091_renewal_records_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/097_harborlight_ai_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-018-08", "issue": "termination notice defect", "portfolio_key": "CBP-018-08", "reason": "two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key", "required_next_evidence": "an approved immutable entity crosswalk", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/008_master_agreements_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/03_amendments/020_amendments_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/032_statements_of_work_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/06_service_levels/044_service_levels_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/09_invoices/068_invoices_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/092_renewal_records_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/097_harborlight_ai_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-018-09", "issue": "audit-right deadline", "portfolio_key": "CBP-018-09", "reason": "the current observation does not meet the operative trigger", "required_next_evidence": "a current observation that satisfies the operative trigger", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_order_forms/009_order_forms_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/03_amendments/021_amendments_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/05_pricing/033_pricing_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/06_service_levels/045_service_levels_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/09_invoices/069_invoices_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/08_notices/057_notices_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/097_harborlight_ai_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-018-12", "issue": "insurance-limit deficiency", "portfolio_key": "CBP-018-12", "reason": "two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key", "required_next_evidence": "an approved immutable entity crosswalk", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_order_forms/012_order_forms_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/03_amendments/024_amendments_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/05_pricing/036_pricing_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/06_service_levels/048_service_levels_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/09_invoices/072_invoices_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/097_harborlight_ai_impact_population.xlsx"]}], "matter_number": "CB-CC-2508", "prepared_for": "Harborlight AI Systems", "schema_version": "counselbench.decision.v3", "task_id": "cb100-018-harborlight-ai"}, "matter_register": {"matter_number": "CB-CC-2508", "rows": [{"decision_option_id": "harborlight-ai:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-27", "issue": "pricing-escalator mismatch", "matter_number": "CB-CC-2508", "owner": "Mei Whitaker", "portfolio_key": "CBP-018-01", "row_id": "REG-CBP-018-01", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/001_master_agreements_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/02_order_forms/013_order_forms_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/025_statements_of_work_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/05_pricing/037_pricing_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/097_harborlight_ai_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "harborlight-ai:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-26", "issue": "data-localization conflict", "matter_number": "CB-CC-2508", "owner": "Theo Laurent", "portfolio_key": "CBP-018-02", "row_id": "REG-CBP-018-02", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/002_master_agreements_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/02_order_forms/014_order_forms_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/026_statements_of_work_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/05_pricing/038_pricing_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/097_harborlight_ai_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "harborlight-ai:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-25", "issue": "benchmarking right omission", "matter_number": "CB-CC-2508", "owner": "Lena Varga", "portfolio_key": "CBP-018-03", "row_id": "REG-CBP-018-03", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/003_master_agreements_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/02_order_forms/015_order_forms_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/027_statements_of_work_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/05_pricing/039_pricing_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/08_notices/063_notices_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/097_harborlight_ai_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "harborlight-ai:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-24", "issue": "renewal date conflict", "matter_number": "CB-CC-2508", "owner": "Elliot Mercer", "portfolio_key": "CBP-018-04", "row_id": "REG-CBP-018-04", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/004_master_agreements_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/02_order_forms/016_order_forms_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/028_statements_of_work_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/05_pricing/040_pricing_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/08_notices/064_notices_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/097_harborlight_ai_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "harborlight-ai:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "the current observation does not meet the operative trigger", "issue": "assignment consent requirement", "matter_number": "CB-CC-2508", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-018-05", "row_id": "REG-CBP-018-05", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/005_master_agreements_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/03_amendments/017_amendments_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/029_statements_of_work_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/06_service_levels/041_service_levels_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/10_correspondence/077_correspondence_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/097_harborlight_ai_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "harborlight-ai:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective", "issue": "exclusivity carveout breach", "matter_number": "CB-CC-2508", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-018-06", "row_id": "REG-CBP-018-06", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/006_master_agreements_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/03_amendments/018_amendments_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/030_statements_of_work_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/06_service_levels/042_service_levels_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/10_correspondence/078_correspondence_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/097_harborlight_ai_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "harborlight-ai:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "the operational record relies on a superseded control revision", "issue": "survival-clause ambiguity", "matter_number": "CB-CC-2508", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-018-07", "row_id": "REG-CBP-018-07", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/007_master_agreements_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/03_amendments/019_amendments_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/031_statements_of_work_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/06_service_levels/043_service_levels_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/10_correspondence/079_correspondence_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/091_renewal_records_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/097_harborlight_ai_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "harborlight-ai:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key", "issue": "termination notice defect", "matter_number": "CB-CC-2508", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-018-08", "row_id": "REG-CBP-018-08", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/008_master_agreements_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/03_amendments/020_amendments_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/032_statements_of_work_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/06_service_levels/044_service_levels_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/09_invoices/068_invoices_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/092_renewal_records_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/097_harborlight_ai_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "harborlight-ai:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "the current observation does not meet the operative trigger", "issue": "audit-right deadline", "matter_number": "CB-CC-2508", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-018-09", "row_id": "REG-CBP-018-09", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_order_forms/009_order_forms_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/03_amendments/021_amendments_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/05_pricing/033_pricing_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/06_service_levels/045_service_levels_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/09_invoices/069_invoices_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/08_notices/057_notices_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/097_harborlight_ai_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "harborlight-ai:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-27", "issue": "order-form precedence conflict", "matter_number": "CB-CC-2508", "owner": "Samuel Kim", "portfolio_key": "CBP-018-10", "row_id": "REG-CBP-018-10", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_order_forms/010_order_forms_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/03_amendments/022_amendments_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/05_pricing/034_pricing_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/06_service_levels/046_service_levels_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/094_renewal_records_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/09_invoices/070_invoices_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/097_harborlight_ai_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "harborlight-ai:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-26", "issue": "service-credit underpayment", "matter_number": "CB-CC-2508", "owner": "Talia Brooks", "portfolio_key": "CBP-018-11", "row_id": "REG-CBP-018-11", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_order_forms/011_order_forms_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/03_amendments/023_amendments_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/05_pricing/035_pricing_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/06_service_levels/047_service_levels_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/11_policies/083_policies_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/097_harborlight_ai_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "harborlight-ai:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key", "issue": "insurance-limit deficiency", "matter_number": "CB-CC-2508", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-018-12", "row_id": "REG-CBP-018-12", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_order_forms/012_order_forms_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/03_amendments/024_amendments_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/05_pricing/036_pricing_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/06_service_levels/048_service_levels_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/09_invoices/072_invoices_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/097_harborlight_ai_impact_population.xlsx"]}], "schema_version": "counselbench.matter-register.v3", "task_id": "cb100-018-harborlight-ai"}}, "metadata": {"benchmark": "CounselBench-100", "code_license": "Apache-2.0", "data_license": "CC-BY-4.0", "deadline": "2026-09-28", "document_count": 97, "evidence_holds": 6, "jurisdiction": "Connecticut", "matter_number": "CB-CC-2508", "mcp_commit": "9a96ea6e5913736f92b88345bf51caeaaa8e719f", "mcp_package": "@modelcontextprotocol/server-filesystem@2026.7.10", "practice_area": "commercial-contracts", "reference_tool_calls": 89, "required_evidence_reads": 64, "supported_actions": 6, "synthetic": true, "venue": "Hartford County, Connecticut", "version": "3.1.0"}, "prompt": "There is enough noise in this file that a name match or newest-document shortcut will be dangerous. Can Harborlight accept the AI services renewal, and what data and incident terms must be corrected first? An AI services deal combines outcome benchmarks, model-training restrictions, and contradictory schedules for data deletion and incident notice. The team needs the call by 2026-09-28. Leave the defensible result in the matter workspace, including any item that must stay on hold for better evidence.", "rubric": {"criteria": [{"category": "investigation", "description": "Inventory the production and use targeted searches to locate records across native formats.", "id": "investigation.discover_production"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Complete every task-specific identity, authority, operations, and approval read before the first state transition.", "id": "investigation.read_before_write"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Inspect designated source metadata before relying on those records.", "id": "investigation.custody_before_write"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "Select the supported option 'harborlight-ai:scoped-evidence' after applying the four-part test.", "id": "decision.selected_option"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "Identify both rejected approaches and explain why a one-source shortcut and a blanket hold are wrong.", "id": "decision.alternatives"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-018-01 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/001_master_agreements_source_export.md rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-018-01.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_order_forms/013_order_forms_source_export.json for pricing-escalator mismatch.", "id": "investigation.CBP-018-01.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/025_statements_of_work_source_export.md to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-018-01.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_pricing/037_pricing_source_export.json.", "id": "investigation.CBP-018-01.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-018-01 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-018-01.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-018-01 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-018-01.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-018-02 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/002_master_agreements_source_export.txt rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-018-02.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_order_forms/014_order_forms_source_export.xml for data-localization conflict.", "id": "investigation.CBP-018-02.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/026_statements_of_work_source_export.txt to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-018-02.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_pricing/038_pricing_source_export.xml.", "id": "investigation.CBP-018-02.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-018-02 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-018-02.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-018-02 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-018-02.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-018-03 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/003_master_agreements_source_export.eml rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-018-03.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_order_forms/015_order_forms_source_export.html for benchmarking right omission.", "id": "investigation.CBP-018-03.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/027_statements_of_work_source_export.eml to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-018-03.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_pricing/039_pricing_source_export.html.", "id": "investigation.CBP-018-03.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-018-03 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-018-03.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-018-03 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-018-03.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-018-04 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/004_master_agreements_source_export.csv rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-018-04.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_order_forms/016_order_forms_source_export.pdf for renewal date conflict.", "id": "investigation.CBP-018-04.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/028_statements_of_work_source_export.csv to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-018-04.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_pricing/040_pricing_source_export.pdf.", "id": "investigation.CBP-018-04.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-018-04 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-018-04.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-018-04 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-018-04.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-018-05 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/005_master_agreements_source_export.json rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-018-05.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_amendments/017_amendments_source_export.md for assignment consent requirement.", "id": "investigation.CBP-018-05.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/029_statements_of_work_source_export.json to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-018-05.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_service_levels/041_service_levels_source_export.md.", "id": "investigation.CBP-018-05.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-018-05 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is the current observation does not meet the operative trigger.", "id": "decision.CBP-018-05.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-018-05 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-018-05.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-018-06 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/006_master_agreements_source_export.xml rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-018-06.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_amendments/018_amendments_source_export.txt for exclusivity carveout breach.", "id": "investigation.CBP-018-06.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/030_statements_of_work_source_export.xml to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-018-06.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_service_levels/042_service_levels_source_export.txt.", "id": "investigation.CBP-018-06.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-018-06 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective.", "id": "decision.CBP-018-06.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-018-06 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-018-06.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-018-07 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/007_master_agreements_source_export.html rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-018-07.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_amendments/019_amendments_source_export.eml for survival-clause ambiguity.", "id": "investigation.CBP-018-07.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/031_statements_of_work_source_export.html to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-018-07.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_service_levels/043_service_levels_source_export.eml.", "id": "investigation.CBP-018-07.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-018-07 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is the operational record relies on a superseded control revision.", "id": "decision.CBP-018-07.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-018-07 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-018-07.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-018-08 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/008_master_agreements_source_export.pdf rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-018-08.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_amendments/020_amendments_source_export.csv for termination notice defect.", "id": "investigation.CBP-018-08.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/032_statements_of_work_source_export.pdf to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-018-08.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_service_levels/044_service_levels_source_export.csv.", "id": "investigation.CBP-018-08.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-018-08 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key.", "id": "decision.CBP-018-08.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-018-08 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-018-08.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-018-09 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_order_forms/009_order_forms_source_export.md rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-018-09.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_amendments/021_amendments_source_export.json for audit-right deadline.", "id": "investigation.CBP-018-09.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_pricing/033_pricing_source_export.md to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-018-09.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_service_levels/045_service_levels_source_export.json.", "id": "investigation.CBP-018-09.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-018-09 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is the current observation does not meet the operative trigger.", "id": "decision.CBP-018-09.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-018-09 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-018-09.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-018-10 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_order_forms/010_order_forms_source_export.txt rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-018-10.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_amendments/022_amendments_source_export.xml for order-form precedence conflict.", "id": "investigation.CBP-018-10.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_pricing/034_pricing_source_export.txt to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-018-10.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_service_levels/046_service_levels_source_export.xml.", "id": "investigation.CBP-018-10.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-018-10 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-018-10.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-018-10 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-018-10.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-018-11 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_order_forms/011_order_forms_source_export.eml rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-018-11.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_amendments/023_amendments_source_export.html for service-credit underpayment.", "id": "investigation.CBP-018-11.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_pricing/035_pricing_source_export.eml to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-018-11.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_service_levels/047_service_levels_source_export.html.", "id": "investigation.CBP-018-11.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-018-11 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-018-11.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-018-11 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-018-11.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-018-12 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_order_forms/012_order_forms_source_export.csv rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-018-12.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_amendments/024_amendments_source_export.pdf for insurance-limit deficiency.", "id": "investigation.CBP-018-12.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_pricing/036_pricing_source_export.csv to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-018-12.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_service_levels/048_service_levels_source_export.pdf.", "id": "investigation.CBP-018-12.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-018-12 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key.", "id": "decision.CBP-018-12.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-018-12 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-018-12.register"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Write the exact selected option, supported action population, evidence-hold population, facts, owners, deadlines, and citations.", "id": "state.exact_decision"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create one exact register row per portfolio key with no extra, missing, or modified row.", "id": "state.exact_register"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Leave only the three approved deliverables and perform no extra state-changing write.", "id": "state.write_scope_containment"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Read back decision.json, matter-register.json, and advice.md after their final writes.", "id": "state.postwrite_readback"}, {"category": "answer", "description": "Explain the selected recommendation, supported actions, holds, alternatives, and limitations with exact source anchors.", "id": "answer.decision_note"}], "decision_options": [{"approach": "Treat supported actions and genuinely ambiguous records as if they were equally unresolved.", "id": "harborlight-ai:blanket-hold", "label": "Freeze the entire matter population"}, {"approach": "Apply the exact identity, current-state, authority, and revision test. Create product-specific remediation rows and hold records lacking an exact instance match.", "id": "harborlight-ai:scoped-evidence", "label": "Renew only with the supported data-use, deletion, and notification corrections."}, {"approach": "Use a plausible summary or one source without completing the controlling joins.", "id": "harborlight-ai:shortcut", "label": "Treat benchmark performance as waiving conflicting data obligations."}], "evaluation_narrative": {"authority": "Executed data restrictions and the stricter effective deletion and notice obligations control.", "observation": "Join benchmark results, model-use records, deletion schedules, and incident chronology by product instance.", "question": "Can Harborlight accept the AI services renewal, and what data and incident terms must be corrected first?", "register_action": "Create product-specific remediation rows and hold records lacking an exact instance match."}, "gates": ["all_required_evidence_precedes_first_write", "decision_criteria_complete", "register_state_exact", "write_scope_contained", "all_outputs_verified_by_readback"], "metadata_checks": 10, "metric": "weighted_criteria_score", "minimum_tool_calls": 89, "required_deliverables": ["decision.json", "matter-register.json", "advice.md"], "required_document_reads": 64, "type": "deterministic", "weights": {"advice": 0.15, "decision": 0.35, "investigation": 0.25, "state": 0.25}}, "task_id": "cb100-018-harborlight-ai", "task_name": "Harborlight AI procurement reconciliation", "world_id": "counselbench-filesystem-mcp-v3"}
+{"context_files": ["task_files/cb100-019-ironwood-agri/01_master_agreements/001_master_agreements_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-019-ironwood-agri/01_master_agreements/002_master_agreements_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-019-ironwood-agri/01_master_agreements/003_master_agreements_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-019-ironwood-agri/01_master_agreements/004_master_agreements_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-019-ironwood-agri/01_master_agreements/005_master_agreements_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-019-ironwood-agri/01_master_agreements/006_master_agreements_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-019-ironwood-agri/01_master_agreements/007_master_agreements_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-019-ironwood-agri/01_master_agreements/008_master_agreements_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-019-ironwood-agri/02_order_forms/009_order_forms_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-019-ironwood-agri/02_order_forms/010_order_forms_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-019-ironwood-agri/02_order_forms/011_order_forms_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-019-ironwood-agri/02_order_forms/012_order_forms_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-019-ironwood-agri/02_order_forms/013_order_forms_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-019-ironwood-agri/02_order_forms/014_order_forms_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-019-ironwood-agri/02_order_forms/015_order_forms_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-019-ironwood-agri/02_order_forms/016_order_forms_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-019-ironwood-agri/03_amendments/017_amendments_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-019-ironwood-agri/03_amendments/018_amendments_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-019-ironwood-agri/03_amendments/019_amendments_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-019-ironwood-agri/03_amendments/020_amendments_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-019-ironwood-agri/03_amendments/021_amendments_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-019-ironwood-agri/03_amendments/022_amendments_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-019-ironwood-agri/03_amendments/023_amendments_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-019-ironwood-agri/03_amendments/024_amendments_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-019-ironwood-agri/04_statements_of_work/025_statements_of_work_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-019-ironwood-agri/04_statements_of_work/026_statements_of_work_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-019-ironwood-agri/04_statements_of_work/027_statements_of_work_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-019-ironwood-agri/04_statements_of_work/028_statements_of_work_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-019-ironwood-agri/04_statements_of_work/029_statements_of_work_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-019-ironwood-agri/04_statements_of_work/030_statements_of_work_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-019-ironwood-agri/04_statements_of_work/031_statements_of_work_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-019-ironwood-agri/04_statements_of_work/032_statements_of_work_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-019-ironwood-agri/05_pricing/033_pricing_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-019-ironwood-agri/05_pricing/034_pricing_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-019-ironwood-agri/05_pricing/035_pricing_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-019-ironwood-agri/05_pricing/036_pricing_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-019-ironwood-agri/05_pricing/037_pricing_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-019-ironwood-agri/05_pricing/038_pricing_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-019-ironwood-agri/05_pricing/039_pricing_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-019-ironwood-agri/05_pricing/040_pricing_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-019-ironwood-agri/06_service_levels/041_service_levels_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-019-ironwood-agri/06_service_levels/042_service_levels_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-019-ironwood-agri/06_service_levels/043_service_levels_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-019-ironwood-agri/06_service_levels/044_service_levels_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-019-ironwood-agri/06_service_levels/045_service_levels_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-019-ironwood-agri/06_service_levels/046_service_levels_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-019-ironwood-agri/06_service_levels/047_service_levels_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-019-ironwood-agri/06_service_levels/048_service_levels_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-019-ironwood-agri/07_security_privacy/049_security_privacy_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-019-ironwood-agri/07_security_privacy/050_security_privacy_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-019-ironwood-agri/07_security_privacy/051_security_privacy_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-019-ironwood-agri/07_security_privacy/052_security_privacy_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-019-ironwood-agri/07_security_privacy/053_security_privacy_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-019-ironwood-agri/07_security_privacy/054_security_privacy_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-019-ironwood-agri/07_security_privacy/055_security_privacy_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-019-ironwood-agri/07_security_privacy/056_security_privacy_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-019-ironwood-agri/08_notices/057_notices_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-019-ironwood-agri/08_notices/058_notices_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-019-ironwood-agri/08_notices/059_notices_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-019-ironwood-agri/08_notices/060_notices_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-019-ironwood-agri/08_notices/061_notices_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-019-ironwood-agri/08_notices/062_notices_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-019-ironwood-agri/08_notices/063_notices_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-019-ironwood-agri/08_notices/064_notices_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-019-ironwood-agri/09_invoices/065_invoices_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-019-ironwood-agri/09_invoices/066_invoices_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-019-ironwood-agri/09_invoices/067_invoices_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-019-ironwood-agri/09_invoices/068_invoices_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-019-ironwood-agri/09_invoices/069_invoices_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-019-ironwood-agri/09_invoices/070_invoices_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-019-ironwood-agri/09_invoices/071_invoices_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-019-ironwood-agri/09_invoices/072_invoices_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-019-ironwood-agri/10_correspondence/073_correspondence_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-019-ironwood-agri/10_correspondence/074_correspondence_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-019-ironwood-agri/10_correspondence/075_correspondence_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-019-ironwood-agri/10_correspondence/076_correspondence_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-019-ironwood-agri/10_correspondence/077_correspondence_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-019-ironwood-agri/10_correspondence/078_correspondence_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-019-ironwood-agri/10_correspondence/079_correspondence_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-019-ironwood-agri/10_correspondence/080_correspondence_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-019-ironwood-agri/11_policies/081_policies_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-019-ironwood-agri/11_policies/082_policies_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-019-ironwood-agri/11_policies/083_policies_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-019-ironwood-agri/11_policies/084_policies_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-019-ironwood-agri/11_policies/085_policies_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-019-ironwood-agri/11_policies/086_policies_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-019-ironwood-agri/11_policies/087_policies_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-019-ironwood-agri/11_policies/088_policies_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-019-ironwood-agri/12_renewal_records/089_renewal_records_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-019-ironwood-agri/12_renewal_records/090_renewal_records_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-019-ironwood-agri/12_renewal_records/091_renewal_records_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-019-ironwood-agri/12_renewal_records/092_renewal_records_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-019-ironwood-agri/12_renewal_records/093_renewal_records_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-019-ironwood-agri/12_renewal_records/094_renewal_records_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-019-ironwood-agri/12_renewal_records/095_renewal_records_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-019-ironwood-agri/12_renewal_records/096_renewal_records_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-019-ironwood-agri/12_renewal_records/097_ironwood_agri_impact_population.xlsx"], "gold_output": {"advice_markdown": "# Decision note — Ironwood distribution portfolio review\n\n## Recommendation\n\nHonor only claims proven at product, dealer, state, and period level. The reconciled record supports 8 scoped actions and leaves 4 items on evidence hold.\n\nSelected option: `ironwood-agri:scoped-evidence`.\n\n## Why this is the supported option\n\nCorrelate dealer sales, protected prices, and assigned states to the same products and effective dates. Executed territory and price-protection schedules govern, subject to documented carveouts.\n\n## Supported actions\n\n### CBP-019-03 — invoice currency discrepancy (high)\n\nthe permission is limited to Polk County, Iowa under CB-CC-2509-R672; the matched activity occurred in Iowa under CB-CC-2509-E557. Identity resolves to ENT-019-1002, revision REV-2025.3 is current, and Rafael Okafor is active with capacity 6.\n\nAction: Register supported credits and territory exceptions; hold unmatched dealer reports. Owner: Rafael Okafor; due 2026-09-28.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/003_master_agreements_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/02_order_forms/015_order_forms_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/027_statements_of_work_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/05_pricing/039_pricing_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/08_notices/063_notices_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/097_ironwood_agri_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-019-04 — pricing-escalator mismatch (medium)\n\nthe operative cap is $3,922,000.00 under CB-CC-2509-R310; the matched ledger population totals $4,020,710.00 under CB-CC-2509-E324. Identity resolves to ENT-019-1003, revision REV-2025.4 is current, and Mei Whitaker is active with capacity 3.\n\nAction: Register supported credits and territory exceptions; hold unmatched dealer reports. Owner: Mei Whitaker; due 2026-09-27.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/004_master_agreements_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/02_order_forms/016_order_forms_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/028_statements_of_work_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/05_pricing/040_pricing_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/07_security_privacy/052_security_privacy_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/097_ironwood_agri_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-019-05 — data-localization conflict (medium)\n\ndelivery must use notices-ironwood_agricultural_supply@example.test under CB-CC-2509-R873; the only matched receipt used archive-blue_fen_distribution_inc@example.test under CB-CC-2509-E304. Identity resolves to ENT-019-1004, revision REV-2025.5 is current, and Theo Laurent is active with capacity 4.\n\nAction: Register supported credits and territory exceptions; hold unmatched dealer reports. Owner: Theo Laurent; due 2026-09-26.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/005_master_agreements_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/03_amendments/017_amendments_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/029_statements_of_work_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/06_service_levels/041_service_levels_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/07_security_privacy/053_security_privacy_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/089_renewal_records_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/097_ironwood_agri_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-019-06 — benchmarking right omission (medium)\n\nan open exception blocks completion under CB-CC-2509-R684; the current status is open and unresolved under CB-CC-2509-E240. Identity resolves to ENT-019-1005, revision REV-2025.6 is current, and Lena Varga is active with capacity 4.\n\nAction: Register supported credits and territory exceptions; hold unmatched dealer reports. Owner: Lena Varga; due 2026-09-25.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/006_master_agreements_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/03_amendments/018_amendments_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/030_statements_of_work_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/06_service_levels/042_service_levels_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/10_correspondence/078_correspondence_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/097_ironwood_agri_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-019-08 — assignment consent requirement (medium)\n\nthe controlling threshold is 15% under CB-CC-2509-R844; the independently calculated result is 22% under CB-CC-2509-E567. Identity resolves to ENT-019-1007, revision REV-2025.1 is current, and Sofia Bennett is active with capacity 6.\n\nAction: Register supported credits and territory exceptions; hold unmatched dealer reports. Owner: Sofia Bennett; due 2026-09-23.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/008_master_agreements_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/03_amendments/020_amendments_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/032_statements_of_work_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/06_service_levels/044_service_levels_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/09_invoices/068_invoices_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/097_ironwood_agri_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-019-09 — exclusivity carveout breach (high)\n\napproval must come from Nadine Flores under CB-CC-2509-R210; the effective approval record names Henry Cho under CB-CC-2509-E900. Identity resolves to ENT-019-1008, revision REV-2025.2 is current, and Micah Sullivan is active with capacity 1.\n\nAction: Register supported credits and territory exceptions; hold unmatched dealer reports. Owner: Micah Sullivan; due 2026-09-22.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/02_order_forms/009_order_forms_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/03_amendments/021_amendments_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/05_pricing/033_pricing_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/06_service_levels/045_service_levels_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/097_ironwood_agri_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-019-11 — termination notice defect (high)\n\nthe permission is limited to Polk County, Iowa under CB-CC-2509-R443; the matched activity occurred in Iowa under CB-CC-2509-E384. Identity resolves to ENT-019-1010, revision REV-2025.4 is current, and Caleb Hassan is active with capacity 2.\n\nAction: Register supported credits and territory exceptions; hold unmatched dealer reports. Owner: Caleb Hassan; due 2026-09-29.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/02_order_forms/011_order_forms_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/03_amendments/023_amendments_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/05_pricing/035_pricing_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/06_service_levels/047_service_levels_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/097_ironwood_agri_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-019-12 — audit-right deadline (medium)\n\nthe operative cap is $6,082,000.00 under CB-CC-2509-R878; the matched ledger population totals $6,168,978.00 under CB-CC-2509-E992. Identity resolves to ENT-019-1011, revision REV-2025.5 is current, and Amara Patel is active with capacity 6.\n\nAction: Register supported credits and territory exceptions; hold unmatched dealer reports. Owner: Amara Patel; due 2026-09-28.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/02_order_forms/012_order_forms_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/03_amendments/024_amendments_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/05_pricing/036_pricing_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/06_service_levels/048_service_levels_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/097_ironwood_agri_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n## Evidence holds\n\n- **CBP-019-01 — minimum-commit shortfall**: the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective. Next evidence: effective approval and an active owner with remaining capacity. Sources: `/workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/001_master_agreements_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/02_order_forms/013_order_forms_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/025_statements_of_work_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/05_pricing/037_pricing_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/08_notices/061_notices_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/10_correspondence/073_correspondence_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/097_ironwood_agri_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-019-02 — subprocessor notice lapse**: the operational record relies on a superseded control revision. Next evidence: an operational record using the current effective revision. Sources: `/workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/002_master_agreements_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/02_order_forms/014_order_forms_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/026_statements_of_work_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/05_pricing/038_pricing_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/08_notices/062_notices_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/11_policies/086_policies_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/097_ironwood_agri_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-019-07 — renewal date conflict**: two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key. Next evidence: an approved immutable entity crosswalk. Sources: `/workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/007_master_agreements_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/03_amendments/019_amendments_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/031_statements_of_work_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/06_service_levels/043_service_levels_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/097_ironwood_agri_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-019-10 — survival-clause ambiguity**: the operational record relies on a superseded control revision. Next evidence: an operational record using the current effective revision. Sources: `/workspace/documents/02_order_forms/010_order_forms_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/03_amendments/022_amendments_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/05_pricing/034_pricing_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/06_service_levels/046_service_levels_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/097_ironwood_agri_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n## Alternatives considered\n\n- `ironwood-agri:shortcut` — Accept the distributor's aggregate claim and assume every out-of-state sale breaches exclusivity.: Use a plausible summary or one source without completing the controlling joins.\n- `ironwood-agri:blanket-hold` — Freeze the entire matter population: Treat supported actions and genuinely ambiguous records as if they were equally unresolved.\n\n## Assumptions and limits\n\nThis decision is limited to cb100-019-ironwood-agri, the supplied synthetic records, and the matter state as of 2026-10-01. Similar names, stale revisions, and pending authority are not treated as proof.\n", "decision": {"actions": [{"determination": "the permission is limited to Polk County, Iowa under CB-CC-2509-R672; the matched activity occurred in Iowa under CB-CC-2509-E557. Identity resolves to ENT-019-1002, revision REV-2025.3 is current, and Rafael Okafor is active with capacity 6.", "due_date": "2026-09-28", "id": "ACT-CBP-019-03", "identity_id": "ENT-019-1002", "issue": "invoice currency discrepancy", "owner": "Rafael Okafor", "portfolio_key": "CBP-019-03", "recommended_action": "Register supported credits and territory exceptions; hold unmatched dealer reports. Owner: Rafael Okafor; due 2026-09-28.", "severity": "high", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/003_master_agreements_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/02_order_forms/015_order_forms_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/027_statements_of_work_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/05_pricing/039_pricing_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/08_notices/063_notices_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/097_ironwood_agri_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "the operative cap is $3,922,000.00 under CB-CC-2509-R310; the matched ledger population totals $4,020,710.00 under CB-CC-2509-E324. Identity resolves to ENT-019-1003, revision REV-2025.4 is current, and Mei Whitaker is active with capacity 3.", "due_date": "2026-09-27", "id": "ACT-CBP-019-04", "identity_id": "ENT-019-1003", "issue": "pricing-escalator mismatch", "owner": "Mei Whitaker", "portfolio_key": "CBP-019-04", "recommended_action": "Register supported credits and territory exceptions; hold unmatched dealer reports. Owner: Mei Whitaker; due 2026-09-27.", "severity": "medium", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/004_master_agreements_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/02_order_forms/016_order_forms_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/028_statements_of_work_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/05_pricing/040_pricing_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/07_security_privacy/052_security_privacy_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/097_ironwood_agri_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "delivery must use notices-ironwood_agricultural_supply@example.test under CB-CC-2509-R873; the only matched receipt used archive-blue_fen_distribution_inc@example.test under CB-CC-2509-E304. Identity resolves to ENT-019-1004, revision REV-2025.5 is current, and Theo Laurent is active with capacity 4.", "due_date": "2026-09-26", "id": "ACT-CBP-019-05", "identity_id": "ENT-019-1004", "issue": "data-localization conflict", "owner": "Theo Laurent", "portfolio_key": "CBP-019-05", "recommended_action": "Register supported credits and territory exceptions; hold unmatched dealer reports. Owner: Theo Laurent; due 2026-09-26.", "severity": "medium", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/005_master_agreements_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/03_amendments/017_amendments_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/029_statements_of_work_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/06_service_levels/041_service_levels_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/07_security_privacy/053_security_privacy_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/089_renewal_records_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/097_ironwood_agri_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "an open exception blocks completion under CB-CC-2509-R684; the current status is open and unresolved under CB-CC-2509-E240. Identity resolves to ENT-019-1005, revision REV-2025.6 is current, and Lena Varga is active with capacity 4.", "due_date": "2026-09-25", "id": "ACT-CBP-019-06", "identity_id": "ENT-019-1005", "issue": "benchmarking right omission", "owner": "Lena Varga", "portfolio_key": "CBP-019-06", "recommended_action": "Register supported credits and territory exceptions; hold unmatched dealer reports. Owner: Lena Varga; due 2026-09-25.", "severity": "medium", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/006_master_agreements_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/03_amendments/018_amendments_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/030_statements_of_work_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/06_service_levels/042_service_levels_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/10_correspondence/078_correspondence_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/097_ironwood_agri_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "the controlling threshold is 15% under CB-CC-2509-R844; the independently calculated result is 22% under CB-CC-2509-E567. Identity resolves to ENT-019-1007, revision REV-2025.1 is current, and Sofia Bennett is active with capacity 6.", "due_date": "2026-09-23", "id": "ACT-CBP-019-08", "identity_id": "ENT-019-1007", "issue": "assignment consent requirement", "owner": "Sofia Bennett", "portfolio_key": "CBP-019-08", "recommended_action": "Register supported credits and territory exceptions; hold unmatched dealer reports. Owner: Sofia Bennett; due 2026-09-23.", "severity": "medium", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/008_master_agreements_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/03_amendments/020_amendments_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/032_statements_of_work_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/06_service_levels/044_service_levels_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/09_invoices/068_invoices_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/097_ironwood_agri_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "approval must come from Nadine Flores under CB-CC-2509-R210; the effective approval record names Henry Cho under CB-CC-2509-E900. Identity resolves to ENT-019-1008, revision REV-2025.2 is current, and Micah Sullivan is active with capacity 1.", "due_date": "2026-09-22", "id": "ACT-CBP-019-09", "identity_id": "ENT-019-1008", "issue": "exclusivity carveout breach", "owner": "Micah Sullivan", "portfolio_key": "CBP-019-09", "recommended_action": "Register supported credits and territory exceptions; hold unmatched dealer reports. Owner: Micah Sullivan; due 2026-09-22.", "severity": "high", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_order_forms/009_order_forms_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/03_amendments/021_amendments_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/05_pricing/033_pricing_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/06_service_levels/045_service_levels_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/097_ironwood_agri_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "the permission is limited to Polk County, Iowa under CB-CC-2509-R443; the matched activity occurred in Iowa under CB-CC-2509-E384. Identity resolves to ENT-019-1010, revision REV-2025.4 is current, and Caleb Hassan is active with capacity 2.", "due_date": "2026-09-29", "id": "ACT-CBP-019-11", "identity_id": "ENT-019-1010", "issue": "termination notice defect", "owner": "Caleb Hassan", "portfolio_key": "CBP-019-11", "recommended_action": "Register supported credits and territory exceptions; hold unmatched dealer reports. Owner: Caleb Hassan; due 2026-09-29.", "severity": "high", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_order_forms/011_order_forms_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/03_amendments/023_amendments_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/05_pricing/035_pricing_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/06_service_levels/047_service_levels_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/097_ironwood_agri_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "the operative cap is $6,082,000.00 under CB-CC-2509-R878; the matched ledger population totals $6,168,978.00 under CB-CC-2509-E992. Identity resolves to ENT-019-1011, revision REV-2025.5 is current, and Amara Patel is active with capacity 6.", "due_date": "2026-09-28", "id": "ACT-CBP-019-12", "identity_id": "ENT-019-1011", "issue": "audit-right deadline", "owner": "Amara Patel", "portfolio_key": "CBP-019-12", "recommended_action": "Register supported credits and territory exceptions; hold unmatched dealer reports. Owner: Amara Patel; due 2026-09-28.", "severity": "medium", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_order_forms/012_order_forms_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/03_amendments/024_amendments_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/05_pricing/036_pricing_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/06_service_levels/048_service_levels_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/097_ironwood_agri_impact_population.xlsx"]}], "as_of": "2026-10-01", "decision": {"alternatives_considered": ["ironwood-agri:shortcut", "ironwood-agri:blanket-hold"], "question": "Which price-protection and territory claims are valid in Ironwood's distributor portfolio?", "rationale": "The four-part causal test supports 8 scoped actions and leaves 4 records on evidence hold. Executed territory and price-protection schedules govern, subject to documented carveouts.", "recommendation": "Honor only claims proven at product, dealer, state, and period level.", "selected_option_id": "ironwood-agri:scoped-evidence"}, "holds": [{"id": "HOLD-CBP-019-01", "issue": "minimum-commit shortfall", "portfolio_key": "CBP-019-01", "reason": "the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective", "required_next_evidence": "effective approval and an active owner with remaining capacity", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/001_master_agreements_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/02_order_forms/013_order_forms_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/025_statements_of_work_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/05_pricing/037_pricing_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/08_notices/061_notices_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/10_correspondence/073_correspondence_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/097_ironwood_agri_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-019-02", "issue": "subprocessor notice lapse", "portfolio_key": "CBP-019-02", "reason": "the operational record relies on a superseded control revision", "required_next_evidence": "an operational record using the current effective revision", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/002_master_agreements_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/02_order_forms/014_order_forms_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/026_statements_of_work_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/05_pricing/038_pricing_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/08_notices/062_notices_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/11_policies/086_policies_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/097_ironwood_agri_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-019-07", "issue": "renewal date conflict", "portfolio_key": "CBP-019-07", "reason": "two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key", "required_next_evidence": "an approved immutable entity crosswalk", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/007_master_agreements_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/03_amendments/019_amendments_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/031_statements_of_work_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/06_service_levels/043_service_levels_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/097_ironwood_agri_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-019-10", "issue": "survival-clause ambiguity", "portfolio_key": "CBP-019-10", "reason": "the operational record relies on a superseded control revision", "required_next_evidence": "an operational record using the current effective revision", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_order_forms/010_order_forms_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/03_amendments/022_amendments_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/05_pricing/034_pricing_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/06_service_levels/046_service_levels_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/097_ironwood_agri_impact_population.xlsx"]}], "matter_number": "CB-CC-2509", "prepared_for": "Ironwood Agricultural Supply", "schema_version": "counselbench.decision.v3", "task_id": "cb100-019-ironwood-agri"}, "matter_register": {"matter_number": "CB-CC-2509", "rows": [{"decision_option_id": "ironwood-agri:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective", "issue": "minimum-commit shortfall", "matter_number": "CB-CC-2509", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-019-01", "row_id": "REG-CBP-019-01", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/001_master_agreements_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/02_order_forms/013_order_forms_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/025_statements_of_work_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/05_pricing/037_pricing_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/08_notices/061_notices_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/10_correspondence/073_correspondence_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/097_ironwood_agri_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "ironwood-agri:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "the operational record relies on a superseded control revision", "issue": "subprocessor notice lapse", "matter_number": "CB-CC-2509", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-019-02", "row_id": "REG-CBP-019-02", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/002_master_agreements_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/02_order_forms/014_order_forms_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/026_statements_of_work_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/05_pricing/038_pricing_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/08_notices/062_notices_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/11_policies/086_policies_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/097_ironwood_agri_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "ironwood-agri:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-28", "issue": "invoice currency discrepancy", "matter_number": "CB-CC-2509", "owner": "Rafael Okafor", "portfolio_key": "CBP-019-03", "row_id": "REG-CBP-019-03", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/003_master_agreements_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/02_order_forms/015_order_forms_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/027_statements_of_work_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/05_pricing/039_pricing_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/08_notices/063_notices_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/097_ironwood_agri_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "ironwood-agri:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-27", "issue": "pricing-escalator mismatch", "matter_number": "CB-CC-2509", "owner": "Mei Whitaker", "portfolio_key": "CBP-019-04", "row_id": "REG-CBP-019-04", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/004_master_agreements_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/02_order_forms/016_order_forms_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/028_statements_of_work_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/05_pricing/040_pricing_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/07_security_privacy/052_security_privacy_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/097_ironwood_agri_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "ironwood-agri:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-26", "issue": "data-localization conflict", "matter_number": "CB-CC-2509", "owner": "Theo Laurent", "portfolio_key": "CBP-019-05", "row_id": "REG-CBP-019-05", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/005_master_agreements_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/03_amendments/017_amendments_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/029_statements_of_work_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/06_service_levels/041_service_levels_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/07_security_privacy/053_security_privacy_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/089_renewal_records_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/097_ironwood_agri_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "ironwood-agri:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-25", "issue": "benchmarking right omission", "matter_number": "CB-CC-2509", "owner": "Lena Varga", "portfolio_key": "CBP-019-06", "row_id": "REG-CBP-019-06", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/006_master_agreements_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/03_amendments/018_amendments_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/030_statements_of_work_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/06_service_levels/042_service_levels_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/10_correspondence/078_correspondence_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/097_ironwood_agri_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "ironwood-agri:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key", "issue": "renewal date conflict", "matter_number": "CB-CC-2509", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-019-07", "row_id": "REG-CBP-019-07", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/007_master_agreements_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/03_amendments/019_amendments_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/031_statements_of_work_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/06_service_levels/043_service_levels_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/097_ironwood_agri_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "ironwood-agri:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-23", "issue": "assignment consent requirement", "matter_number": "CB-CC-2509", "owner": "Sofia Bennett", "portfolio_key": "CBP-019-08", "row_id": "REG-CBP-019-08", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/008_master_agreements_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/03_amendments/020_amendments_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/032_statements_of_work_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/06_service_levels/044_service_levels_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/09_invoices/068_invoices_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/097_ironwood_agri_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "ironwood-agri:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-22", "issue": "exclusivity carveout breach", "matter_number": "CB-CC-2509", "owner": "Micah Sullivan", "portfolio_key": "CBP-019-09", "row_id": "REG-CBP-019-09", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_order_forms/009_order_forms_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/03_amendments/021_amendments_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/05_pricing/033_pricing_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/06_service_levels/045_service_levels_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/097_ironwood_agri_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "ironwood-agri:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "the operational record relies on a superseded control revision", "issue": "survival-clause ambiguity", "matter_number": "CB-CC-2509", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-019-10", "row_id": "REG-CBP-019-10", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_order_forms/010_order_forms_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/03_amendments/022_amendments_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/05_pricing/034_pricing_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/06_service_levels/046_service_levels_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/097_ironwood_agri_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "ironwood-agri:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-29", "issue": "termination notice defect", "matter_number": "CB-CC-2509", "owner": "Caleb Hassan", "portfolio_key": "CBP-019-11", "row_id": "REG-CBP-019-11", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_order_forms/011_order_forms_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/03_amendments/023_amendments_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/05_pricing/035_pricing_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/06_service_levels/047_service_levels_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/097_ironwood_agri_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "ironwood-agri:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-28", "issue": "audit-right deadline", "matter_number": "CB-CC-2509", "owner": "Amara Patel", "portfolio_key": "CBP-019-12", "row_id": "REG-CBP-019-12", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_order_forms/012_order_forms_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/03_amendments/024_amendments_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/05_pricing/036_pricing_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/06_service_levels/048_service_levels_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/097_ironwood_agri_impact_population.xlsx"]}], "schema_version": "counselbench.matter-register.v3", "task_id": "cb100-019-ironwood-agri"}}, "metadata": {"benchmark": "CounselBench-100", "code_license": "Apache-2.0", "data_license": "CC-BY-4.0", "deadline": "2026-10-01", "document_count": 97, "evidence_holds": 4, "jurisdiction": "Iowa", "matter_number": "CB-CC-2509", "mcp_commit": "9a96ea6e5913736f92b88345bf51caeaaa8e719f", "mcp_package": "@modelcontextprotocol/server-filesystem@2026.7.10", "practice_area": "commercial-contracts", "reference_tool_calls": 83, "required_evidence_reads": 59, "supported_actions": 8, "synthetic": true, "venue": "Polk County, Iowa", "version": "3.1.0"}, "prompt": "Please take ownership of the open question before the deadline. Which price-protection and territory claims are valid in Ironwood's distributor portfolio? A regional distributor invokes price protection and territorial exclusivity despite dealer reports showing sales outside the assigned states. The team needs the call by 2026-10-01. Give me a decision-ready note and make the corresponding matter-register entries, without guessing through missing records.", "rubric": {"criteria": [{"category": "investigation", "description": "Inventory the production and use targeted searches to locate records across native formats.", "id": "investigation.discover_production"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Complete every task-specific identity, authority, operations, and approval read before the first state transition.", "id": "investigation.read_before_write"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Inspect designated source metadata before relying on those records.", "id": "investigation.custody_before_write"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "Select the supported option 'ironwood-agri:scoped-evidence' after applying the four-part test.", "id": "decision.selected_option"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "Identify both rejected approaches and explain why a one-source shortcut and a blanket hold are wrong.", "id": "decision.alternatives"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-019-01 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/001_master_agreements_source_export.md rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-019-01.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_order_forms/013_order_forms_source_export.json for minimum-commit shortfall.", "id": "investigation.CBP-019-01.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/025_statements_of_work_source_export.md to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-019-01.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_pricing/037_pricing_source_export.json.", "id": "investigation.CBP-019-01.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-019-01 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective.", "id": "decision.CBP-019-01.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-019-01 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-019-01.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-019-02 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/002_master_agreements_source_export.txt rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-019-02.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_order_forms/014_order_forms_source_export.xml for subprocessor notice lapse.", "id": "investigation.CBP-019-02.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/026_statements_of_work_source_export.txt to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-019-02.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_pricing/038_pricing_source_export.xml.", "id": "investigation.CBP-019-02.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-019-02 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is the operational record relies on a superseded control revision.", "id": "decision.CBP-019-02.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-019-02 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-019-02.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-019-03 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/003_master_agreements_source_export.eml rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-019-03.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_order_forms/015_order_forms_source_export.html for invoice currency discrepancy.", "id": "investigation.CBP-019-03.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/027_statements_of_work_source_export.eml to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-019-03.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_pricing/039_pricing_source_export.html.", "id": "investigation.CBP-019-03.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-019-03 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-019-03.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-019-03 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-019-03.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-019-04 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/004_master_agreements_source_export.csv rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-019-04.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_order_forms/016_order_forms_source_export.pdf for pricing-escalator mismatch.", "id": "investigation.CBP-019-04.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/028_statements_of_work_source_export.csv to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-019-04.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_pricing/040_pricing_source_export.pdf.", "id": "investigation.CBP-019-04.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-019-04 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-019-04.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-019-04 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-019-04.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-019-05 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/005_master_agreements_source_export.json rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-019-05.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_amendments/017_amendments_source_export.md for data-localization conflict.", "id": "investigation.CBP-019-05.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/029_statements_of_work_source_export.json to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-019-05.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_service_levels/041_service_levels_source_export.md.", "id": "investigation.CBP-019-05.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-019-05 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-019-05.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-019-05 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-019-05.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-019-06 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/006_master_agreements_source_export.xml rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-019-06.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_amendments/018_amendments_source_export.txt for benchmarking right omission.", "id": "investigation.CBP-019-06.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/030_statements_of_work_source_export.xml to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-019-06.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_service_levels/042_service_levels_source_export.txt.", "id": "investigation.CBP-019-06.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-019-06 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-019-06.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-019-06 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-019-06.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-019-07 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/007_master_agreements_source_export.html rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-019-07.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_amendments/019_amendments_source_export.eml for renewal date conflict.", "id": "investigation.CBP-019-07.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/031_statements_of_work_source_export.html to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-019-07.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_service_levels/043_service_levels_source_export.eml.", "id": "investigation.CBP-019-07.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-019-07 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key.", "id": "decision.CBP-019-07.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-019-07 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-019-07.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-019-08 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/008_master_agreements_source_export.pdf rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-019-08.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_amendments/020_amendments_source_export.csv for assignment consent requirement.", "id": "investigation.CBP-019-08.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/032_statements_of_work_source_export.pdf to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-019-08.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_service_levels/044_service_levels_source_export.csv.", "id": "investigation.CBP-019-08.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-019-08 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-019-08.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-019-08 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-019-08.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-019-09 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_order_forms/009_order_forms_source_export.md rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-019-09.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_amendments/021_amendments_source_export.json for exclusivity carveout breach.", "id": "investigation.CBP-019-09.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_pricing/033_pricing_source_export.md to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-019-09.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_service_levels/045_service_levels_source_export.json.", "id": "investigation.CBP-019-09.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-019-09 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-019-09.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-019-09 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-019-09.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-019-10 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_order_forms/010_order_forms_source_export.txt rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-019-10.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_amendments/022_amendments_source_export.xml for survival-clause ambiguity.", "id": "investigation.CBP-019-10.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_pricing/034_pricing_source_export.txt to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-019-10.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_service_levels/046_service_levels_source_export.xml.", "id": "investigation.CBP-019-10.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-019-10 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is the operational record relies on a superseded control revision.", "id": "decision.CBP-019-10.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-019-10 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-019-10.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-019-11 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_order_forms/011_order_forms_source_export.eml rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-019-11.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_amendments/023_amendments_source_export.html for termination notice defect.", "id": "investigation.CBP-019-11.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_pricing/035_pricing_source_export.eml to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-019-11.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_service_levels/047_service_levels_source_export.html.", "id": "investigation.CBP-019-11.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-019-11 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-019-11.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-019-11 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-019-11.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-019-12 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_order_forms/012_order_forms_source_export.csv rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-019-12.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_amendments/024_amendments_source_export.pdf for audit-right deadline.", "id": "investigation.CBP-019-12.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_pricing/036_pricing_source_export.csv to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-019-12.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_service_levels/048_service_levels_source_export.pdf.", "id": "investigation.CBP-019-12.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-019-12 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-019-12.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-019-12 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-019-12.register"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Write the exact selected option, supported action population, evidence-hold population, facts, owners, deadlines, and citations.", "id": "state.exact_decision"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create one exact register row per portfolio key with no extra, missing, or modified row.", "id": "state.exact_register"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Leave only the three approved deliverables and perform no extra state-changing write.", "id": "state.write_scope_containment"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Read back decision.json, matter-register.json, and advice.md after their final writes.", "id": "state.postwrite_readback"}, {"category": "answer", "description": "Explain the selected recommendation, supported actions, holds, alternatives, and limitations with exact source anchors.", "id": "answer.decision_note"}], "decision_options": [{"approach": "Apply the exact identity, current-state, authority, and revision test. Register supported credits and territory exceptions; hold unmatched dealer reports.", "id": "ironwood-agri:scoped-evidence", "label": "Honor only claims proven at product, dealer, state, and period level."}, {"approach": "Use a plausible summary or one source without completing the controlling joins.", "id": "ironwood-agri:shortcut", "label": "Accept the distributor's aggregate claim and assume every out-of-state sale breaches exclusivity."}, {"approach": "Treat supported actions and genuinely ambiguous records as if they were equally unresolved.", "id": "ironwood-agri:blanket-hold", "label": "Freeze the entire matter population"}], "evaluation_narrative": {"authority": "Executed territory and price-protection schedules govern, subject to documented carveouts.", "observation": "Correlate dealer sales, protected prices, and assigned states to the same products and effective dates.", "question": "Which price-protection and territory claims are valid in Ironwood's distributor portfolio?", "register_action": "Register supported credits and territory exceptions; hold unmatched dealer reports."}, "gates": ["all_required_evidence_precedes_first_write", "decision_criteria_complete", "register_state_exact", "write_scope_contained", "all_outputs_verified_by_readback"], "metadata_checks": 10, "metric": "weighted_criteria_score", "minimum_tool_calls": 83, "required_deliverables": ["decision.json", "matter-register.json", "advice.md"], "required_document_reads": 59, "type": "deterministic", "weights": {"advice": 0.15, "decision": 0.35, "investigation": 0.25, "state": 0.25}}, "task_id": "cb100-019-ironwood-agri", "task_name": "Ironwood distribution portfolio review", "world_id": "counselbench-filesystem-mcp-v3"}
+{"context_files": ["task_files/cb100-020-juno-travel/01_master_agreements/001_master_agreements_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-020-juno-travel/01_master_agreements/002_master_agreements_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-020-juno-travel/01_master_agreements/003_master_agreements_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-020-juno-travel/01_master_agreements/004_master_agreements_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-020-juno-travel/01_master_agreements/005_master_agreements_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-020-juno-travel/01_master_agreements/006_master_agreements_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-020-juno-travel/01_master_agreements/007_master_agreements_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-020-juno-travel/01_master_agreements/008_master_agreements_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-020-juno-travel/02_order_forms/009_order_forms_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-020-juno-travel/02_order_forms/010_order_forms_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-020-juno-travel/02_order_forms/011_order_forms_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-020-juno-travel/02_order_forms/012_order_forms_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-020-juno-travel/02_order_forms/013_order_forms_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-020-juno-travel/02_order_forms/014_order_forms_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-020-juno-travel/02_order_forms/015_order_forms_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-020-juno-travel/02_order_forms/016_order_forms_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-020-juno-travel/03_amendments/017_amendments_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-020-juno-travel/03_amendments/018_amendments_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-020-juno-travel/03_amendments/019_amendments_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-020-juno-travel/03_amendments/020_amendments_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-020-juno-travel/03_amendments/021_amendments_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-020-juno-travel/03_amendments/022_amendments_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-020-juno-travel/03_amendments/023_amendments_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-020-juno-travel/03_amendments/024_amendments_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-020-juno-travel/04_statements_of_work/025_statements_of_work_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-020-juno-travel/04_statements_of_work/026_statements_of_work_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-020-juno-travel/04_statements_of_work/027_statements_of_work_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-020-juno-travel/04_statements_of_work/028_statements_of_work_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-020-juno-travel/04_statements_of_work/029_statements_of_work_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-020-juno-travel/04_statements_of_work/030_statements_of_work_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-020-juno-travel/04_statements_of_work/031_statements_of_work_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-020-juno-travel/04_statements_of_work/032_statements_of_work_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-020-juno-travel/05_pricing/033_pricing_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-020-juno-travel/05_pricing/034_pricing_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-020-juno-travel/05_pricing/035_pricing_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-020-juno-travel/05_pricing/036_pricing_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-020-juno-travel/05_pricing/037_pricing_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-020-juno-travel/05_pricing/038_pricing_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-020-juno-travel/05_pricing/039_pricing_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-020-juno-travel/05_pricing/040_pricing_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-020-juno-travel/06_service_levels/041_service_levels_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-020-juno-travel/06_service_levels/042_service_levels_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-020-juno-travel/06_service_levels/043_service_levels_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-020-juno-travel/06_service_levels/044_service_levels_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-020-juno-travel/06_service_levels/045_service_levels_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-020-juno-travel/06_service_levels/046_service_levels_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-020-juno-travel/06_service_levels/047_service_levels_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-020-juno-travel/06_service_levels/048_service_levels_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-020-juno-travel/07_security_privacy/049_security_privacy_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-020-juno-travel/07_security_privacy/050_security_privacy_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-020-juno-travel/07_security_privacy/051_security_privacy_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-020-juno-travel/07_security_privacy/052_security_privacy_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-020-juno-travel/07_security_privacy/053_security_privacy_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-020-juno-travel/07_security_privacy/054_security_privacy_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-020-juno-travel/07_security_privacy/055_security_privacy_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-020-juno-travel/07_security_privacy/056_security_privacy_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-020-juno-travel/08_notices/057_notices_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-020-juno-travel/08_notices/058_notices_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-020-juno-travel/08_notices/059_notices_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-020-juno-travel/08_notices/060_notices_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-020-juno-travel/08_notices/061_notices_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-020-juno-travel/08_notices/062_notices_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-020-juno-travel/08_notices/063_notices_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-020-juno-travel/08_notices/064_notices_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-020-juno-travel/09_invoices/065_invoices_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-020-juno-travel/09_invoices/066_invoices_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-020-juno-travel/09_invoices/067_invoices_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-020-juno-travel/09_invoices/068_invoices_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-020-juno-travel/09_invoices/069_invoices_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-020-juno-travel/09_invoices/070_invoices_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-020-juno-travel/09_invoices/071_invoices_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-020-juno-travel/09_invoices/072_invoices_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-020-juno-travel/10_correspondence/073_correspondence_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-020-juno-travel/10_correspondence/074_correspondence_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-020-juno-travel/10_correspondence/075_correspondence_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-020-juno-travel/10_correspondence/076_correspondence_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-020-juno-travel/10_correspondence/077_correspondence_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-020-juno-travel/10_correspondence/078_correspondence_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-020-juno-travel/10_correspondence/079_correspondence_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-020-juno-travel/10_correspondence/080_correspondence_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-020-juno-travel/11_policies/081_policies_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-020-juno-travel/11_policies/082_policies_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-020-juno-travel/11_policies/083_policies_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-020-juno-travel/11_policies/084_policies_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-020-juno-travel/11_policies/085_policies_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-020-juno-travel/11_policies/086_policies_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-020-juno-travel/11_policies/087_policies_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-020-juno-travel/11_policies/088_policies_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-020-juno-travel/12_renewal_records/089_renewal_records_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-020-juno-travel/12_renewal_records/090_renewal_records_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-020-juno-travel/12_renewal_records/091_renewal_records_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-020-juno-travel/12_renewal_records/092_renewal_records_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-020-juno-travel/12_renewal_records/093_renewal_records_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-020-juno-travel/12_renewal_records/094_renewal_records_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-020-juno-travel/12_renewal_records/095_renewal_records_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-020-juno-travel/12_renewal_records/096_renewal_records_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-020-juno-travel/12_renewal_records/097_juno_travel_impact_population.xlsx"], "gold_output": {"advice_markdown": "# Decision note — Juno reservation platform exit analysis\n\n## Recommendation\n\nUse the supported termination date and preserve surviving transition and credit duties. The reconciled record supports 7 scoped actions and leaves 5 items on evidence hold.\n\nSelected option: `juno-travel:scoped-evidence`.\n\n## Why this is the supported option\n\nReconcile outage measurements, cure notices, prepaid balances, and transition milestones. Termination rights require the applicable cure sequence; survival and credit terms remain independently effective.\n\n## Supported actions\n\n### CBP-020-01 — service-credit underpayment (high)\n\nan open exception blocks completion under CB-CC-2510-R117; the current status is open and unresolved under CB-CC-2510-E206. Identity resolves to ENT-020-1000, revision REV-2026.1 is current, and Willa Novak is active with capacity 6.\n\nAction: Create an exit-plan row for each supported right or surviving obligation. Owner: Willa Novak; due 2026-10-04.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/001_master_agreements_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/02_order_forms/013_order_forms_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/025_statements_of_work_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/05_pricing/037_pricing_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/10_correspondence/073_correspondence_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/08_notices/061_notices_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/097_juno_travel_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-020-02 — insurance-limit deficiency (medium)\n\ncompletion is required by 2025-09-08 under CB-CC-2510-R405; the current event record shows completion on 2025-09-21 under CB-CC-2510-E647. Identity resolves to ENT-020-1001, revision REV-2026.2 is current, and Owen Delgado is active with capacity 4.\n\nAction: Create an exit-plan row for each supported right or surviving obligation. Owner: Owen Delgado; due 2026-10-03.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/002_master_agreements_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/02_order_forms/014_order_forms_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/026_statements_of_work_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/05_pricing/038_pricing_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/11_policies/086_policies_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/097_juno_travel_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-020-03 — usage-report inconsistency (critical)\n\nthe controlling threshold is 15% under CB-CC-2510-R960; the independently calculated result is 22% under CB-CC-2510-E521. Identity resolves to ENT-020-1002, revision REV-2026.3 is current, and Priya Raman is active with capacity 2.\n\nAction: Create an exit-plan row for each supported right or surviving obligation. Owner: Priya Raman; due 2026-10-02.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/003_master_agreements_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/02_order_forms/015_order_forms_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/027_statements_of_work_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/05_pricing/039_pricing_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/097_juno_travel_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-020-04 — minimum-commit shortfall (high)\n\napproval must come from Priya Raman under CB-CC-2510-R537; the effective approval record names Henry Cho under CB-CC-2510-E178. Identity resolves to ENT-020-1003, revision REV-2026.4 is current, and Isaac Romero is active with capacity 5.\n\nAction: Create an exit-plan row for each supported right or surviving obligation. Owner: Isaac Romero; due 2026-10-01.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/004_master_agreements_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/02_order_forms/016_order_forms_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/028_statements_of_work_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/05_pricing/040_pricing_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/097_juno_travel_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-020-08 — data-localization conflict (medium)\n\ndelivery must use notices-juno_travel_technologies@example.test under CB-CC-2510-R743; the only matched receipt used archive-crescent_hotel_consortium@example.test under CB-CC-2510-E296. Identity resolves to ENT-020-1007, revision REV-2026.1 is current, and Theo Laurent is active with capacity 2.\n\nAction: Create an exit-plan row for each supported right or surviving obligation. Owner: Theo Laurent; due 2026-09-27.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/008_master_agreements_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/03_amendments/020_amendments_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/032_statements_of_work_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/06_service_levels/044_service_levels_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/097_juno_travel_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-020-09 — benchmarking right omission (critical)\n\nan open exception blocks completion under CB-CC-2510-R480; the current status is open and unresolved under CB-CC-2510-E598. Identity resolves to ENT-020-1008, revision REV-2026.2 is current, and Lena Varga is active with capacity 4.\n\nAction: Create an exit-plan row for each supported right or surviving obligation. Owner: Lena Varga; due 2026-09-26.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/02_order_forms/009_order_forms_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/03_amendments/021_amendments_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/05_pricing/033_pricing_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/06_service_levels/045_service_levels_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/097_juno_travel_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-020-12 — exclusivity carveout breach (critical)\n\napproval must come from Priya Raman under CB-CC-2510-R286; the effective approval record names Caleb Hassan under CB-CC-2510-E375. Identity resolves to ENT-020-1011, revision REV-2026.5 is current, and Micah Sullivan is active with capacity 2.\n\nAction: Create an exit-plan row for each supported right or surviving obligation. Owner: Micah Sullivan; due 2026-10-02.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/02_order_forms/012_order_forms_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/03_amendments/024_amendments_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/05_pricing/036_pricing_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/06_service_levels/048_service_levels_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/08_notices/060_notices_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/097_juno_travel_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n## Evidence holds\n\n- **CBP-020-05 — subprocessor notice lapse**: the operational record relies on a superseded control revision. Next evidence: an operational record using the current effective revision. Sources: `/workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/005_master_agreements_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/03_amendments/017_amendments_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/029_statements_of_work_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/06_service_levels/041_service_levels_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/07_security_privacy/053_security_privacy_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/097_juno_travel_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-020-06 — invoice currency discrepancy**: two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key. Next evidence: an approved immutable entity crosswalk. Sources: `/workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/006_master_agreements_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/03_amendments/018_amendments_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/030_statements_of_work_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/06_service_levels/042_service_levels_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/09_invoices/066_invoices_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/097_juno_travel_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-020-07 — pricing-escalator mismatch**: the current observation does not meet the operative trigger. Next evidence: a current observation that satisfies the operative trigger. Sources: `/workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/007_master_agreements_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/03_amendments/019_amendments_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/031_statements_of_work_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/06_service_levels/043_service_levels_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/091_renewal_records_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/097_juno_travel_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-020-10 — renewal date conflict**: two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key. Next evidence: an approved immutable entity crosswalk. Sources: `/workspace/documents/02_order_forms/010_order_forms_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/03_amendments/022_amendments_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/05_pricing/034_pricing_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/06_service_levels/046_service_levels_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/08_notices/058_notices_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/097_juno_travel_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-020-11 — assignment consent requirement**: the current observation does not meet the operative trigger. Next evidence: a current observation that satisfies the operative trigger. Sources: `/workspace/documents/02_order_forms/011_order_forms_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/03_amendments/023_amendments_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/05_pricing/035_pricing_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/06_service_levels/047_service_levels_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/095_renewal_records_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/097_juno_travel_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n## Alternatives considered\n\n- `juno-travel:shortcut` — Exit immediately on the first outage and stop all surviving performance.: Use a plausible summary or one source without completing the controlling joins.\n- `juno-travel:blanket-hold` — Freeze the entire matter population: Treat supported actions and genuinely ambiguous records as if they were equally unresolved.\n\n## Assumptions and limits\n\nThis decision is limited to cb100-020-juno-travel, the supplied synthetic records, and the matter state as of 2026-10-05. Similar names, stale revisions, and pending authority are not treated as proof.\n", "decision": {"actions": [{"determination": "an open exception blocks completion under CB-CC-2510-R117; the current status is open and unresolved under CB-CC-2510-E206. Identity resolves to ENT-020-1000, revision REV-2026.1 is current, and Willa Novak is active with capacity 6.", "due_date": "2026-10-04", "id": "ACT-CBP-020-01", "identity_id": "ENT-020-1000", "issue": "service-credit underpayment", "owner": "Willa Novak", "portfolio_key": "CBP-020-01", "recommended_action": "Create an exit-plan row for each supported right or surviving obligation. Owner: Willa Novak; due 2026-10-04.", "severity": "high", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/001_master_agreements_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/02_order_forms/013_order_forms_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/025_statements_of_work_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/05_pricing/037_pricing_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/10_correspondence/073_correspondence_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/08_notices/061_notices_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/097_juno_travel_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "completion is required by 2025-09-08 under CB-CC-2510-R405; the current event record shows completion on 2025-09-21 under CB-CC-2510-E647. Identity resolves to ENT-020-1001, revision REV-2026.2 is current, and Owen Delgado is active with capacity 4.", "due_date": "2026-10-03", "id": "ACT-CBP-020-02", "identity_id": "ENT-020-1001", "issue": "insurance-limit deficiency", "owner": "Owen Delgado", "portfolio_key": "CBP-020-02", "recommended_action": "Create an exit-plan row for each supported right or surviving obligation. Owner: Owen Delgado; due 2026-10-03.", "severity": "medium", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/002_master_agreements_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/02_order_forms/014_order_forms_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/026_statements_of_work_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/05_pricing/038_pricing_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/11_policies/086_policies_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/097_juno_travel_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "the controlling threshold is 15% under CB-CC-2510-R960; the independently calculated result is 22% under CB-CC-2510-E521. Identity resolves to ENT-020-1002, revision REV-2026.3 is current, and Priya Raman is active with capacity 2.", "due_date": "2026-10-02", "id": "ACT-CBP-020-03", "identity_id": "ENT-020-1002", "issue": "usage-report inconsistency", "owner": "Priya Raman", "portfolio_key": "CBP-020-03", "recommended_action": "Create an exit-plan row for each supported right or surviving obligation. Owner: Priya Raman; due 2026-10-02.", "severity": "critical", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/003_master_agreements_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/02_order_forms/015_order_forms_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/027_statements_of_work_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/05_pricing/039_pricing_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/097_juno_travel_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "approval must come from Priya Raman under CB-CC-2510-R537; the effective approval record names Henry Cho under CB-CC-2510-E178. Identity resolves to ENT-020-1003, revision REV-2026.4 is current, and Isaac Romero is active with capacity 5.", "due_date": "2026-10-01", "id": "ACT-CBP-020-04", "identity_id": "ENT-020-1003", "issue": "minimum-commit shortfall", "owner": "Isaac Romero", "portfolio_key": "CBP-020-04", "recommended_action": "Create an exit-plan row for each supported right or surviving obligation. Owner: Isaac Romero; due 2026-10-01.", "severity": "high", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/004_master_agreements_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/02_order_forms/016_order_forms_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/028_statements_of_work_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/05_pricing/040_pricing_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/097_juno_travel_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "delivery must use notices-juno_travel_technologies@example.test under CB-CC-2510-R743; the only matched receipt used archive-crescent_hotel_consortium@example.test under CB-CC-2510-E296. Identity resolves to ENT-020-1007, revision REV-2026.1 is current, and Theo Laurent is active with capacity 2.", "due_date": "2026-09-27", "id": "ACT-CBP-020-08", "identity_id": "ENT-020-1007", "issue": "data-localization conflict", "owner": "Theo Laurent", "portfolio_key": "CBP-020-08", "recommended_action": "Create an exit-plan row for each supported right or surviving obligation. Owner: Theo Laurent; due 2026-09-27.", "severity": "medium", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/008_master_agreements_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/03_amendments/020_amendments_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/032_statements_of_work_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/06_service_levels/044_service_levels_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/097_juno_travel_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "an open exception blocks completion under CB-CC-2510-R480; the current status is open and unresolved under CB-CC-2510-E598. Identity resolves to ENT-020-1008, revision REV-2026.2 is current, and Lena Varga is active with capacity 4.", "due_date": "2026-09-26", "id": "ACT-CBP-020-09", "identity_id": "ENT-020-1008", "issue": "benchmarking right omission", "owner": "Lena Varga", "portfolio_key": "CBP-020-09", "recommended_action": "Create an exit-plan row for each supported right or surviving obligation. Owner: Lena Varga; due 2026-09-26.", "severity": "critical", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_order_forms/009_order_forms_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/03_amendments/021_amendments_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/05_pricing/033_pricing_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/06_service_levels/045_service_levels_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/097_juno_travel_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "approval must come from Priya Raman under CB-CC-2510-R286; the effective approval record names Caleb Hassan under CB-CC-2510-E375. Identity resolves to ENT-020-1011, revision REV-2026.5 is current, and Micah Sullivan is active with capacity 2.", "due_date": "2026-10-02", "id": "ACT-CBP-020-12", "identity_id": "ENT-020-1011", "issue": "exclusivity carveout breach", "owner": "Micah Sullivan", "portfolio_key": "CBP-020-12", "recommended_action": "Create an exit-plan row for each supported right or surviving obligation. Owner: Micah Sullivan; due 2026-10-02.", "severity": "critical", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_order_forms/012_order_forms_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/03_amendments/024_amendments_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/05_pricing/036_pricing_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/06_service_levels/048_service_levels_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/08_notices/060_notices_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/097_juno_travel_impact_population.xlsx"]}], "as_of": "2026-10-05", "decision": {"alternatives_considered": ["juno-travel:shortcut", "juno-travel:blanket-hold"], "question": "What exit path can Juno use after the outages, and what transition or prepaid-credit obligations survive?", "rationale": "The four-part causal test supports 7 scoped actions and leaves 5 records on evidence hold. Termination rights require the applicable cure sequence; survival and credit terms remain independently effective.", "recommendation": "Use the supported termination date and preserve surviving transition and credit duties.", "selected_option_id": "juno-travel:scoped-evidence"}, "holds": [{"id": "HOLD-CBP-020-05", "issue": "subprocessor notice lapse", "portfolio_key": "CBP-020-05", "reason": "the operational record relies on a superseded control revision", "required_next_evidence": "an operational record using the current effective revision", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/005_master_agreements_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/03_amendments/017_amendments_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/029_statements_of_work_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/06_service_levels/041_service_levels_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/07_security_privacy/053_security_privacy_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/097_juno_travel_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-020-06", "issue": "invoice currency discrepancy", "portfolio_key": "CBP-020-06", "reason": "two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key", "required_next_evidence": "an approved immutable entity crosswalk", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/006_master_agreements_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/03_amendments/018_amendments_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/030_statements_of_work_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/06_service_levels/042_service_levels_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/09_invoices/066_invoices_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/097_juno_travel_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-020-07", "issue": "pricing-escalator mismatch", "portfolio_key": "CBP-020-07", "reason": "the current observation does not meet the operative trigger", "required_next_evidence": "a current observation that satisfies the operative trigger", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/007_master_agreements_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/03_amendments/019_amendments_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/031_statements_of_work_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/06_service_levels/043_service_levels_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/091_renewal_records_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/097_juno_travel_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-020-10", "issue": "renewal date conflict", "portfolio_key": "CBP-020-10", "reason": "two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key", "required_next_evidence": "an approved immutable entity crosswalk", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_order_forms/010_order_forms_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/03_amendments/022_amendments_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/05_pricing/034_pricing_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/06_service_levels/046_service_levels_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/08_notices/058_notices_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/097_juno_travel_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-020-11", "issue": "assignment consent requirement", "portfolio_key": "CBP-020-11", "reason": "the current observation does not meet the operative trigger", "required_next_evidence": "a current observation that satisfies the operative trigger", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_order_forms/011_order_forms_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/03_amendments/023_amendments_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/05_pricing/035_pricing_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/06_service_levels/047_service_levels_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/095_renewal_records_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/097_juno_travel_impact_population.xlsx"]}], "matter_number": "CB-CC-2510", "prepared_for": "Juno Travel Technologies", "schema_version": "counselbench.decision.v3", "task_id": "cb100-020-juno-travel"}, "matter_register": {"matter_number": "CB-CC-2510", "rows": [{"decision_option_id": "juno-travel:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-10-04", "issue": "service-credit underpayment", "matter_number": "CB-CC-2510", "owner": "Willa Novak", "portfolio_key": "CBP-020-01", "row_id": "REG-CBP-020-01", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/001_master_agreements_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/02_order_forms/013_order_forms_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/025_statements_of_work_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/05_pricing/037_pricing_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/10_correspondence/073_correspondence_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/08_notices/061_notices_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/097_juno_travel_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "juno-travel:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-10-03", "issue": "insurance-limit deficiency", "matter_number": "CB-CC-2510", "owner": "Owen Delgado", "portfolio_key": "CBP-020-02", "row_id": "REG-CBP-020-02", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/002_master_agreements_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/02_order_forms/014_order_forms_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/026_statements_of_work_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/05_pricing/038_pricing_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/11_policies/086_policies_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/097_juno_travel_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "juno-travel:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-10-02", "issue": "usage-report inconsistency", "matter_number": "CB-CC-2510", "owner": "Priya Raman", "portfolio_key": "CBP-020-03", "row_id": "REG-CBP-020-03", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/003_master_agreements_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/02_order_forms/015_order_forms_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/027_statements_of_work_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/05_pricing/039_pricing_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/097_juno_travel_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "juno-travel:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-10-01", "issue": "minimum-commit shortfall", "matter_number": "CB-CC-2510", "owner": "Isaac Romero", "portfolio_key": "CBP-020-04", "row_id": "REG-CBP-020-04", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/004_master_agreements_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/02_order_forms/016_order_forms_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/028_statements_of_work_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/05_pricing/040_pricing_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/097_juno_travel_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "juno-travel:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "the operational record relies on a superseded control revision", "issue": "subprocessor notice lapse", "matter_number": "CB-CC-2510", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-020-05", "row_id": "REG-CBP-020-05", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/005_master_agreements_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/03_amendments/017_amendments_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/029_statements_of_work_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/06_service_levels/041_service_levels_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/07_security_privacy/053_security_privacy_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/097_juno_travel_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "juno-travel:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key", "issue": "invoice currency discrepancy", "matter_number": "CB-CC-2510", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-020-06", "row_id": "REG-CBP-020-06", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/006_master_agreements_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/03_amendments/018_amendments_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/030_statements_of_work_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/06_service_levels/042_service_levels_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/09_invoices/066_invoices_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/097_juno_travel_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "juno-travel:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "the current observation does not meet the operative trigger", "issue": "pricing-escalator mismatch", "matter_number": "CB-CC-2510", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-020-07", "row_id": "REG-CBP-020-07", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/007_master_agreements_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/03_amendments/019_amendments_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/031_statements_of_work_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/06_service_levels/043_service_levels_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/091_renewal_records_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/097_juno_travel_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "juno-travel:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-27", "issue": "data-localization conflict", "matter_number": "CB-CC-2510", "owner": "Theo Laurent", "portfolio_key": "CBP-020-08", "row_id": "REG-CBP-020-08", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/008_master_agreements_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/03_amendments/020_amendments_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/032_statements_of_work_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/06_service_levels/044_service_levels_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/097_juno_travel_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "juno-travel:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-26", "issue": "benchmarking right omission", "matter_number": "CB-CC-2510", "owner": "Lena Varga", "portfolio_key": "CBP-020-09", "row_id": "REG-CBP-020-09", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_order_forms/009_order_forms_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/03_amendments/021_amendments_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/05_pricing/033_pricing_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/06_service_levels/045_service_levels_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/097_juno_travel_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "juno-travel:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key", "issue": "renewal date conflict", "matter_number": "CB-CC-2510", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-020-10", "row_id": "REG-CBP-020-10", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_order_forms/010_order_forms_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/03_amendments/022_amendments_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/05_pricing/034_pricing_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/06_service_levels/046_service_levels_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/08_notices/058_notices_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/097_juno_travel_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "juno-travel:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "the current observation does not meet the operative trigger", "issue": "assignment consent requirement", "matter_number": "CB-CC-2510", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-020-11", "row_id": "REG-CBP-020-11", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_order_forms/011_order_forms_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/03_amendments/023_amendments_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/05_pricing/035_pricing_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/06_service_levels/047_service_levels_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/095_renewal_records_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/097_juno_travel_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "juno-travel:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-10-02", "issue": "exclusivity carveout breach", "matter_number": "CB-CC-2510", "owner": "Micah Sullivan", "portfolio_key": "CBP-020-12", "row_id": "REG-CBP-020-12", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_order_forms/012_order_forms_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/03_amendments/024_amendments_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/05_pricing/036_pricing_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/06_service_levels/048_service_levels_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/08_notices/060_notices_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/12_renewal_records/097_juno_travel_impact_population.xlsx"]}], "schema_version": "counselbench.matter-register.v3", "task_id": "cb100-020-juno-travel"}}, "metadata": {"benchmark": "CounselBench-100", "code_license": "Apache-2.0", "data_license": "CC-BY-4.0", "deadline": "2026-10-05", "document_count": 97, "evidence_holds": 5, "jurisdiction": "Florida", "matter_number": "CB-CC-2510", "mcp_commit": "9a96ea6e5913736f92b88345bf51caeaaa8e719f", "mcp_package": "@modelcontextprotocol/server-filesystem@2026.7.10", "practice_area": "commercial-contracts", "reference_tool_calls": 83, "required_evidence_reads": 59, "supported_actions": 7, "synthetic": true, "venue": "Miami-Dade County, Florida", "version": "3.1.0"}, "prompt": "I need to know what is proven, what we can do about it, and what is still only an evidence gap. What exit path can Juno use after the outages, and what transition or prepaid-credit obligations survive? The customer seeks an early exit after repeated outages, but separate documents disagree about cure periods, transition services, and prepaid credits. The team needs the call by 2026-10-05. Capture the supported action and the remaining holds so the next reviewer can reproduce the call.", "rubric": {"criteria": [{"category": "investigation", "description": "Inventory the production and use targeted searches to locate records across native formats.", "id": "investigation.discover_production"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Complete every task-specific identity, authority, operations, and approval read before the first state transition.", "id": "investigation.read_before_write"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Inspect designated source metadata before relying on those records.", "id": "investigation.custody_before_write"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "Select the supported option 'juno-travel:scoped-evidence' after applying the four-part test.", "id": "decision.selected_option"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "Identify both rejected approaches and explain why a one-source shortcut and a blanket hold are wrong.", "id": "decision.alternatives"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-020-01 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/001_master_agreements_source_export.md rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-020-01.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_order_forms/013_order_forms_source_export.json for service-credit underpayment.", "id": "investigation.CBP-020-01.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/025_statements_of_work_source_export.md to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-020-01.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_pricing/037_pricing_source_export.json.", "id": "investigation.CBP-020-01.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-020-01 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-020-01.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-020-01 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-020-01.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-020-02 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/002_master_agreements_source_export.txt rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-020-02.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_order_forms/014_order_forms_source_export.xml for insurance-limit deficiency.", "id": "investigation.CBP-020-02.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/026_statements_of_work_source_export.txt to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-020-02.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_pricing/038_pricing_source_export.xml.", "id": "investigation.CBP-020-02.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-020-02 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-020-02.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-020-02 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-020-02.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-020-03 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/003_master_agreements_source_export.eml rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-020-03.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_order_forms/015_order_forms_source_export.html for usage-report inconsistency.", "id": "investigation.CBP-020-03.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/027_statements_of_work_source_export.eml to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-020-03.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_pricing/039_pricing_source_export.html.", "id": "investigation.CBP-020-03.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-020-03 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-020-03.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-020-03 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-020-03.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-020-04 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/004_master_agreements_source_export.csv rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-020-04.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_order_forms/016_order_forms_source_export.pdf for minimum-commit shortfall.", "id": "investigation.CBP-020-04.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/028_statements_of_work_source_export.csv to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-020-04.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_pricing/040_pricing_source_export.pdf.", "id": "investigation.CBP-020-04.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-020-04 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-020-04.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-020-04 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-020-04.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-020-05 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/005_master_agreements_source_export.json rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-020-05.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_amendments/017_amendments_source_export.md for subprocessor notice lapse.", "id": "investigation.CBP-020-05.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/029_statements_of_work_source_export.json to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-020-05.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_service_levels/041_service_levels_source_export.md.", "id": "investigation.CBP-020-05.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-020-05 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is the operational record relies on a superseded control revision.", "id": "decision.CBP-020-05.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-020-05 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-020-05.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-020-06 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/006_master_agreements_source_export.xml rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-020-06.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_amendments/018_amendments_source_export.txt for invoice currency discrepancy.", "id": "investigation.CBP-020-06.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/030_statements_of_work_source_export.xml to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-020-06.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_service_levels/042_service_levels_source_export.txt.", "id": "investigation.CBP-020-06.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-020-06 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key.", "id": "decision.CBP-020-06.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-020-06 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-020-06.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-020-07 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/007_master_agreements_source_export.html rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-020-07.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_amendments/019_amendments_source_export.eml for pricing-escalator mismatch.", "id": "investigation.CBP-020-07.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/031_statements_of_work_source_export.html to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-020-07.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_service_levels/043_service_levels_source_export.eml.", "id": "investigation.CBP-020-07.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-020-07 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is the current observation does not meet the operative trigger.", "id": "decision.CBP-020-07.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-020-07 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-020-07.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-020-08 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_master_agreements/008_master_agreements_source_export.pdf rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-020-08.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_amendments/020_amendments_source_export.csv for data-localization conflict.", "id": "investigation.CBP-020-08.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_statements_of_work/032_statements_of_work_source_export.pdf to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-020-08.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_service_levels/044_service_levels_source_export.csv.", "id": "investigation.CBP-020-08.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-020-08 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-020-08.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-020-08 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-020-08.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-020-09 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_order_forms/009_order_forms_source_export.md rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-020-09.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_amendments/021_amendments_source_export.json for benchmarking right omission.", "id": "investigation.CBP-020-09.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_pricing/033_pricing_source_export.md to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-020-09.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_service_levels/045_service_levels_source_export.json.", "id": "investigation.CBP-020-09.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-020-09 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-020-09.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-020-09 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-020-09.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-020-10 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_order_forms/010_order_forms_source_export.txt rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-020-10.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_amendments/022_amendments_source_export.xml for renewal date conflict.", "id": "investigation.CBP-020-10.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_pricing/034_pricing_source_export.txt to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-020-10.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_service_levels/046_service_levels_source_export.xml.", "id": "investigation.CBP-020-10.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-020-10 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key.", "id": "decision.CBP-020-10.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-020-10 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-020-10.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-020-11 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_order_forms/011_order_forms_source_export.eml rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-020-11.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_amendments/023_amendments_source_export.html for assignment consent requirement.", "id": "investigation.CBP-020-11.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_pricing/035_pricing_source_export.eml to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-020-11.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_service_levels/047_service_levels_source_export.html.", "id": "investigation.CBP-020-11.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-020-11 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is the current observation does not meet the operative trigger.", "id": "decision.CBP-020-11.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-020-11 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-020-11.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-020-12 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_order_forms/012_order_forms_source_export.csv rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-020-12.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_amendments/024_amendments_source_export.pdf for exclusivity carveout breach.", "id": "investigation.CBP-020-12.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_pricing/036_pricing_source_export.csv to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-020-12.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_service_levels/048_service_levels_source_export.pdf.", "id": "investigation.CBP-020-12.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-020-12 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-020-12.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-020-12 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-020-12.register"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Write the exact selected option, supported action population, evidence-hold population, facts, owners, deadlines, and citations.", "id": "state.exact_decision"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create one exact register row per portfolio key with no extra, missing, or modified row.", "id": "state.exact_register"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Leave only the three approved deliverables and perform no extra state-changing write.", "id": "state.write_scope_containment"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Read back decision.json, matter-register.json, and advice.md after their final writes.", "id": "state.postwrite_readback"}, {"category": "answer", "description": "Explain the selected recommendation, supported actions, holds, alternatives, and limitations with exact source anchors.", "id": "answer.decision_note"}], "decision_options": [{"approach": "Use a plausible summary or one source without completing the controlling joins.", "id": "juno-travel:shortcut", "label": "Exit immediately on the first outage and stop all surviving performance."}, {"approach": "Treat supported actions and genuinely ambiguous records as if they were equally unresolved.", "id": "juno-travel:blanket-hold", "label": "Freeze the entire matter population"}, {"approach": "Apply the exact identity, current-state, authority, and revision test. Create an exit-plan row for each supported right or surviving obligation.", "id": "juno-travel:scoped-evidence", "label": "Use the supported termination date and preserve surviving transition and credit duties."}], "evaluation_narrative": {"authority": "Termination rights require the applicable cure sequence; survival and credit terms remain independently effective.", "observation": "Reconcile outage measurements, cure notices, prepaid balances, and transition milestones.", "question": "What exit path can Juno use after the outages, and what transition or prepaid-credit obligations survive?", "register_action": "Create an exit-plan row for each supported right or surviving obligation."}, "gates": ["all_required_evidence_precedes_first_write", "decision_criteria_complete", "register_state_exact", "write_scope_contained", "all_outputs_verified_by_readback"], "metadata_checks": 9, "metric": "weighted_criteria_score", "minimum_tool_calls": 83, "required_deliverables": ["decision.json", "matter-register.json", "advice.md"], "required_document_reads": 59, "type": "deterministic", "weights": {"advice": 0.15, "decision": 0.35, "investigation": 0.25, "state": 0.25}}, "task_id": "cb100-020-juno-travel", "task_name": "Juno reservation platform exit analysis", "world_id": "counselbench-filesystem-mcp-v3"}
+{"context_files": ["task_files/cb100-021-alder-biotech/01_intake/001_intake_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-021-alder-biotech/01_intake/002_intake_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-021-alder-biotech/01_intake/003_intake_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-021-alder-biotech/01_intake/004_intake_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-021-alder-biotech/01_intake/005_intake_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-021-alder-biotech/01_intake/006_intake_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-021-alder-biotech/01_intake/007_intake_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-021-alder-biotech/01_intake/008_intake_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-021-alder-biotech/02_preservation/009_preservation_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-021-alder-biotech/02_preservation/010_preservation_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-021-alder-biotech/02_preservation/011_preservation_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-021-alder-biotech/02_preservation/012_preservation_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-021-alder-biotech/02_preservation/013_preservation_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-021-alder-biotech/02_preservation/014_preservation_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-021-alder-biotech/02_preservation/015_preservation_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-021-alder-biotech/02_preservation/016_preservation_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-021-alder-biotech/03_interviews/017_interviews_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-021-alder-biotech/03_interviews/018_interviews_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-021-alder-biotech/03_interviews/019_interviews_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-021-alder-biotech/03_interviews/020_interviews_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-021-alder-biotech/03_interviews/021_interviews_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-021-alder-biotech/03_interviews/022_interviews_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-021-alder-biotech/03_interviews/023_interviews_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-021-alder-biotech/03_interviews/024_interviews_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-021-alder-biotech/04_email_exports/025_email_exports_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-021-alder-biotech/04_email_exports/026_email_exports_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-021-alder-biotech/04_email_exports/027_email_exports_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-021-alder-biotech/04_email_exports/028_email_exports_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-021-alder-biotech/04_email_exports/029_email_exports_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-021-alder-biotech/04_email_exports/030_email_exports_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-021-alder-biotech/04_email_exports/031_email_exports_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-021-alder-biotech/04_email_exports/032_email_exports_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-021-alder-biotech/05_chat_exports/033_chat_exports_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-021-alder-biotech/05_chat_exports/034_chat_exports_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-021-alder-biotech/05_chat_exports/035_chat_exports_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-021-alder-biotech/05_chat_exports/036_chat_exports_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-021-alder-biotech/05_chat_exports/037_chat_exports_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-021-alder-biotech/05_chat_exports/038_chat_exports_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-021-alder-biotech/05_chat_exports/039_chat_exports_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-021-alder-biotech/05_chat_exports/040_chat_exports_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-021-alder-biotech/06_expenses/041_expenses_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-021-alder-biotech/06_expenses/042_expenses_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-021-alder-biotech/06_expenses/043_expenses_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-021-alder-biotech/06_expenses/044_expenses_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-021-alder-biotech/06_expenses/045_expenses_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-021-alder-biotech/06_expenses/046_expenses_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-021-alder-biotech/06_expenses/047_expenses_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-021-alder-biotech/06_expenses/048_expenses_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-021-alder-biotech/07_access_logs/049_access_logs_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-021-alder-biotech/07_access_logs/050_access_logs_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-021-alder-biotech/07_access_logs/051_access_logs_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-021-alder-biotech/07_access_logs/052_access_logs_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-021-alder-biotech/07_access_logs/053_access_logs_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-021-alder-biotech/07_access_logs/054_access_logs_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-021-alder-biotech/07_access_logs/055_access_logs_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-021-alder-biotech/07_access_logs/056_access_logs_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-021-alder-biotech/08_vendor_files/057_vendor_files_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-021-alder-biotech/08_vendor_files/058_vendor_files_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-021-alder-biotech/08_vendor_files/059_vendor_files_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-021-alder-biotech/08_vendor_files/060_vendor_files_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-021-alder-biotech/08_vendor_files/061_vendor_files_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-021-alder-biotech/08_vendor_files/062_vendor_files_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-021-alder-biotech/08_vendor_files/063_vendor_files_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-021-alder-biotech/08_vendor_files/064_vendor_files_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-021-alder-biotech/09_policies/065_policies_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-021-alder-biotech/09_policies/066_policies_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-021-alder-biotech/09_policies/067_policies_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-021-alder-biotech/09_policies/068_policies_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-021-alder-biotech/09_policies/069_policies_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-021-alder-biotech/09_policies/070_policies_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-021-alder-biotech/09_policies/071_policies_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-021-alder-biotech/09_policies/072_policies_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-021-alder-biotech/10_hr_records/073_hr_records_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-021-alder-biotech/10_hr_records/074_hr_records_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-021-alder-biotech/10_hr_records/075_hr_records_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-021-alder-biotech/10_hr_records/076_hr_records_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-021-alder-biotech/10_hr_records/077_hr_records_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-021-alder-biotech/10_hr_records/078_hr_records_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-021-alder-biotech/10_hr_records/079_hr_records_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-021-alder-biotech/10_hr_records/080_hr_records_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-021-alder-biotech/11_board_reporting/081_board_reporting_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-021-alder-biotech/11_board_reporting/082_board_reporting_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-021-alder-biotech/11_board_reporting/083_board_reporting_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-021-alder-biotech/11_board_reporting/084_board_reporting_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-021-alder-biotech/11_board_reporting/085_board_reporting_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-021-alder-biotech/11_board_reporting/086_board_reporting_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-021-alder-biotech/11_board_reporting/087_board_reporting_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-021-alder-biotech/11_board_reporting/088_board_reporting_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-021-alder-biotech/12_remediation/089_remediation_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-021-alder-biotech/12_remediation/090_remediation_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-021-alder-biotech/12_remediation/091_remediation_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-021-alder-biotech/12_remediation/092_remediation_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-021-alder-biotech/12_remediation/093_remediation_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-021-alder-biotech/12_remediation/094_remediation_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-021-alder-biotech/12_remediation/095_remediation_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-021-alder-biotech/12_remediation/096_remediation_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-021-alder-biotech/12_remediation/097_alder_biotech_impact_population.xlsx"], "gold_output": {"advice_markdown": "# Decision note — Alder clinical-vendor payment inquiry\n\n## Recommendation\n\nSubstantiate and escalate only the supported conduct, with scoped preservation and remediation. The reconciled record supports 9 scoped actions and leaves 3 items on evidence hold.\n\nSelected option: `alder-biotech:scoped-evidence`.\n\n## Why this is the supported option\n\nJoin invoice sequences, travel records, relationship disclosures, and approver identity for the same vendor and study. Policy thresholds, conflict disclosure rules, and corroborated intent evidence determine disposition.\n\n## Supported actions\n\n### CBP-021-01 — approval override (critical)\n\nthe permission is limited to Cambridge, Massachusetts under CB-IV-2601-R903; the matched activity occurred in Massachusetts under CB-IV-2601-E676. Identity resolves to ENT-021-1000, revision REV-2025.1 is current, and Henry Cho is active with capacity 5.\n\nAction: Create investigation findings for proven conduct and evidence holds for unresolved intent. Owner: Henry Cho; due 2026-09-01.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_intake/001_intake_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/02_preservation/013_preservation_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/04_email_exports/025_email_exports_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/037_chat_exports_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/07_access_logs/049_access_logs_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/08_vendor_files/061_vendor_files_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_alder_biotech_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-021-02 — vendor due-diligence gap (critical)\n\nthe operative cap is $6,682,000.00 under CB-IV-2601-R954; the matched ledger population totals $6,905,254.00 under CB-IV-2601-E203. Identity resolves to ENT-021-1001, revision REV-2025.2 is current, and Maya Ellison is active with capacity 3.\n\nAction: Create investigation findings for proven conduct and evidence holds for unresolved intent. Owner: Maya Ellison; due 2026-08-31.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_intake/002_intake_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/02_preservation/014_preservation_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/04_email_exports/026_email_exports_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/038_chat_exports_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/07_access_logs/050_access_logs_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/11_board_reporting/086_board_reporting_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_alder_biotech_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-021-04 — split-purchase pattern (critical)\n\nan open exception blocks completion under CB-IV-2601-R261; the current status is open and unresolved under CB-IV-2601-E321. Identity resolves to ENT-021-1003, revision REV-2025.4 is current, and Willa Novak is active with capacity 6.\n\nAction: Create investigation findings for proven conduct and evidence holds for unresolved intent. Owner: Willa Novak; due 2026-08-29.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_intake/004_intake_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/02_preservation/016_preservation_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/04_email_exports/028_email_exports_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/040_chat_exports_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/10_hr_records/076_hr_records_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/11_board_reporting/088_board_reporting_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_alder_biotech_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-021-05 — badge-log inconsistency (high)\n\ncompletion is required by 2025-03-07 under CB-IV-2601-R580; the current event record shows completion on 2025-04-09 under CB-IV-2601-E922. Identity resolves to ENT-021-1004, revision REV-2025.5 is current, and Owen Delgado is active with capacity 1.\n\nAction: Create investigation findings for proven conduct and evidence holds for unresolved intent. Owner: Owen Delgado; due 2026-08-28.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_intake/005_intake_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/03_interviews/017_interviews_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/04_email_exports/029_email_exports_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/06_expenses/041_expenses_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/10_hr_records/077_hr_records_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/07_access_logs/053_access_logs_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_alder_biotech_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-021-06 — hotline classification error (high)\n\nthe controlling threshold is 11% under CB-IV-2601-R956; the independently calculated result is 14% under CB-IV-2601-E203. Identity resolves to ENT-021-1005, revision REV-2025.6 is current, and Priya Raman is active with capacity 2.\n\nAction: Create investigation findings for proven conduct and evidence holds for unresolved intent. Owner: Priya Raman; due 2026-08-27.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_intake/006_intake_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/03_interviews/018_interviews_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/04_email_exports/030_email_exports_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/06_expenses/042_expenses_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_alder_biotech_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-021-07 — undisclosed related party (high)\n\napproval must come from Willa Novak under CB-IV-2601-R956; the effective approval record names Caleb Hassan under CB-IV-2601-E626. Identity resolves to ENT-021-1006, revision REV-2025.7 is current, and Isaac Romero is active with capacity 2.\n\nAction: Create investigation findings for proven conduct and evidence holds for unresolved intent. Owner: Isaac Romero; due 2026-08-26.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_intake/007_intake_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/03_interviews/019_interviews_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/04_email_exports/031_email_exports_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/06_expenses/043_expenses_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/09_policies/067_policies_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/07_access_logs/055_access_logs_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_alder_biotech_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-021-08 — deleted-message anomaly (high)\n\nthe controlled population contains 98 records under CB-IV-2601-R836; the certification covers 89 records under CB-IV-2601-E831. Identity resolves to ENT-021-1007, revision REV-2025.1 is current, and Nadine Flores is active with capacity 1.\n\nAction: Create investigation findings for proven conduct and evidence holds for unresolved intent. Owner: Nadine Flores; due 2026-08-25.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_intake/008_intake_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/03_interviews/020_interviews_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/04_email_exports/032_email_exports_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/06_expenses/044_expenses_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_alder_biotech_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-021-09 — board-reporting omission (high)\n\nthe permission is limited to Cambridge, Massachusetts under CB-IV-2601-R302; the matched activity occurred in Massachusetts under CB-IV-2601-E270. Identity resolves to ENT-021-1008, revision REV-2025.2 is current, and Rafael Okafor is active with capacity 6.\n\nAction: Create investigation findings for proven conduct and evidence holds for unresolved intent. Owner: Rafael Okafor; due 2026-08-24.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/02_preservation/009_preservation_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/03_interviews/021_interviews_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/033_chat_exports_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/06_expenses/045_expenses_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_alder_biotech_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-021-11 — off-channel communication (high)\n\ndelivery must use notices-alder_biotherapeutics@example.test under CB-IV-2601-R641; the only matched receipt used archive-morrow_trial_services_llc@example.test under CB-IV-2601-E343. Identity resolves to ENT-021-1010, revision REV-2025.4 is current, and Theo Laurent is active with capacity 2.\n\nAction: Create investigation findings for proven conduct and evidence holds for unresolved intent. Owner: Theo Laurent; due 2026-08-31.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/02_preservation/011_preservation_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/03_interviews/023_interviews_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/035_chat_exports_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/06_expenses/047_expenses_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/09_policies/071_policies_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/08_vendor_files/059_vendor_files_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_alder_biotech_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n## Evidence holds\n\n- **CBP-021-03 — expense support deficiency**: the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective. Next evidence: effective approval and an active owner with remaining capacity. Sources: `/workspace/documents/01_intake/003_intake_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/02_preservation/015_preservation_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/04_email_exports/027_email_exports_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/039_chat_exports_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_alder_biotech_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-021-10 — interview timeline conflict**: the current observation does not meet the operative trigger. Next evidence: a current observation that satisfies the operative trigger. Sources: `/workspace/documents/02_preservation/010_preservation_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/03_interviews/022_interviews_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/034_chat_exports_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/06_expenses/046_expenses_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/11_board_reporting/082_board_reporting_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/09_policies/070_policies_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_alder_biotech_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-021-12 — policy training lapse**: the operational record relies on a superseded control revision. Next evidence: an operational record using the current effective revision. Sources: `/workspace/documents/02_preservation/012_preservation_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/03_interviews/024_interviews_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/036_chat_exports_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/06_expenses/048_expenses_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/09_policies/072_policies_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_alder_biotech_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n## Alternatives considered\n\n- `alder-biotech:blanket-hold` — Freeze the entire matter population: Treat supported actions and genuinely ambiguous records as if they were equally unresolved.\n- `alder-biotech:shortcut` — Treat every split invoice as intentional misconduct without checking approvals or relationships.: Use a plausible summary or one source without completing the controlling joins.\n\n## Assumptions and limits\n\nThis decision is limited to cb100-021-alder-biotech, the supplied synthetic records, and the matter state as of 2026-09-02. Similar names, stale revisions, and pending authority are not treated as proof.\n", "decision": {"actions": [{"determination": "the permission is limited to Cambridge, Massachusetts under CB-IV-2601-R903; the matched activity occurred in Massachusetts under CB-IV-2601-E676. Identity resolves to ENT-021-1000, revision REV-2025.1 is current, and Henry Cho is active with capacity 5.", "due_date": "2026-09-01", "id": "ACT-CBP-021-01", "identity_id": "ENT-021-1000", "issue": "approval override", "owner": "Henry Cho", "portfolio_key": "CBP-021-01", "recommended_action": "Create investigation findings for proven conduct and evidence holds for unresolved intent. Owner: Henry Cho; due 2026-09-01.", "severity": "critical", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_intake/001_intake_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/02_preservation/013_preservation_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/04_email_exports/025_email_exports_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/037_chat_exports_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/07_access_logs/049_access_logs_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/08_vendor_files/061_vendor_files_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_alder_biotech_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "the operative cap is $6,682,000.00 under CB-IV-2601-R954; the matched ledger population totals $6,905,254.00 under CB-IV-2601-E203. Identity resolves to ENT-021-1001, revision REV-2025.2 is current, and Maya Ellison is active with capacity 3.", "due_date": "2026-08-31", "id": "ACT-CBP-021-02", "identity_id": "ENT-021-1001", "issue": "vendor due-diligence gap", "owner": "Maya Ellison", "portfolio_key": "CBP-021-02", "recommended_action": "Create investigation findings for proven conduct and evidence holds for unresolved intent. Owner: Maya Ellison; due 2026-08-31.", "severity": "critical", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_intake/002_intake_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/02_preservation/014_preservation_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/04_email_exports/026_email_exports_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/038_chat_exports_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/07_access_logs/050_access_logs_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/11_board_reporting/086_board_reporting_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_alder_biotech_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "an open exception blocks completion under CB-IV-2601-R261; the current status is open and unresolved under CB-IV-2601-E321. Identity resolves to ENT-021-1003, revision REV-2025.4 is current, and Willa Novak is active with capacity 6.", "due_date": "2026-08-29", "id": "ACT-CBP-021-04", "identity_id": "ENT-021-1003", "issue": "split-purchase pattern", "owner": "Willa Novak", "portfolio_key": "CBP-021-04", "recommended_action": "Create investigation findings for proven conduct and evidence holds for unresolved intent. Owner: Willa Novak; due 2026-08-29.", "severity": "critical", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_intake/004_intake_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/02_preservation/016_preservation_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/04_email_exports/028_email_exports_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/040_chat_exports_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/10_hr_records/076_hr_records_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/11_board_reporting/088_board_reporting_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_alder_biotech_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "completion is required by 2025-03-07 under CB-IV-2601-R580; the current event record shows completion on 2025-04-09 under CB-IV-2601-E922. Identity resolves to ENT-021-1004, revision REV-2025.5 is current, and Owen Delgado is active with capacity 1.", "due_date": "2026-08-28", "id": "ACT-CBP-021-05", "identity_id": "ENT-021-1004", "issue": "badge-log inconsistency", "owner": "Owen Delgado", "portfolio_key": "CBP-021-05", "recommended_action": "Create investigation findings for proven conduct and evidence holds for unresolved intent. Owner: Owen Delgado; due 2026-08-28.", "severity": "high", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_intake/005_intake_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/03_interviews/017_interviews_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/04_email_exports/029_email_exports_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/06_expenses/041_expenses_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/10_hr_records/077_hr_records_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/07_access_logs/053_access_logs_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_alder_biotech_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "the controlling threshold is 11% under CB-IV-2601-R956; the independently calculated result is 14% under CB-IV-2601-E203. Identity resolves to ENT-021-1005, revision REV-2025.6 is current, and Priya Raman is active with capacity 2.", "due_date": "2026-08-27", "id": "ACT-CBP-021-06", "identity_id": "ENT-021-1005", "issue": "hotline classification error", "owner": "Priya Raman", "portfolio_key": "CBP-021-06", "recommended_action": "Create investigation findings for proven conduct and evidence holds for unresolved intent. Owner: Priya Raman; due 2026-08-27.", "severity": "high", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_intake/006_intake_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/03_interviews/018_interviews_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/04_email_exports/030_email_exports_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/06_expenses/042_expenses_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_alder_biotech_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "approval must come from Willa Novak under CB-IV-2601-R956; the effective approval record names Caleb Hassan under CB-IV-2601-E626. Identity resolves to ENT-021-1006, revision REV-2025.7 is current, and Isaac Romero is active with capacity 2.", "due_date": "2026-08-26", "id": "ACT-CBP-021-07", "identity_id": "ENT-021-1006", "issue": "undisclosed related party", "owner": "Isaac Romero", "portfolio_key": "CBP-021-07", "recommended_action": "Create investigation findings for proven conduct and evidence holds for unresolved intent. Owner: Isaac Romero; due 2026-08-26.", "severity": "high", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_intake/007_intake_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/03_interviews/019_interviews_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/04_email_exports/031_email_exports_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/06_expenses/043_expenses_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/09_policies/067_policies_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/07_access_logs/055_access_logs_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_alder_biotech_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "the controlled population contains 98 records under CB-IV-2601-R836; the certification covers 89 records under CB-IV-2601-E831. Identity resolves to ENT-021-1007, revision REV-2025.1 is current, and Nadine Flores is active with capacity 1.", "due_date": "2026-08-25", "id": "ACT-CBP-021-08", "identity_id": "ENT-021-1007", "issue": "deleted-message anomaly", "owner": "Nadine Flores", "portfolio_key": "CBP-021-08", "recommended_action": "Create investigation findings for proven conduct and evidence holds for unresolved intent. Owner: Nadine Flores; due 2026-08-25.", "severity": "high", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_intake/008_intake_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/03_interviews/020_interviews_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/04_email_exports/032_email_exports_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/06_expenses/044_expenses_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_alder_biotech_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "the permission is limited to Cambridge, Massachusetts under CB-IV-2601-R302; the matched activity occurred in Massachusetts under CB-IV-2601-E270. Identity resolves to ENT-021-1008, revision REV-2025.2 is current, and Rafael Okafor is active with capacity 6.", "due_date": "2026-08-24", "id": "ACT-CBP-021-09", "identity_id": "ENT-021-1008", "issue": "board-reporting omission", "owner": "Rafael Okafor", "portfolio_key": "CBP-021-09", "recommended_action": "Create investigation findings for proven conduct and evidence holds for unresolved intent. Owner: Rafael Okafor; due 2026-08-24.", "severity": "high", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_preservation/009_preservation_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/03_interviews/021_interviews_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/033_chat_exports_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/06_expenses/045_expenses_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_alder_biotech_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "delivery must use notices-alder_biotherapeutics@example.test under CB-IV-2601-R641; the only matched receipt used archive-morrow_trial_services_llc@example.test under CB-IV-2601-E343. Identity resolves to ENT-021-1010, revision REV-2025.4 is current, and Theo Laurent is active with capacity 2.", "due_date": "2026-08-31", "id": "ACT-CBP-021-11", "identity_id": "ENT-021-1010", "issue": "off-channel communication", "owner": "Theo Laurent", "portfolio_key": "CBP-021-11", "recommended_action": "Create investigation findings for proven conduct and evidence holds for unresolved intent. Owner: Theo Laurent; due 2026-08-31.", "severity": "high", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_preservation/011_preservation_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/03_interviews/023_interviews_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/035_chat_exports_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/06_expenses/047_expenses_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/09_policies/071_policies_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/08_vendor_files/059_vendor_files_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_alder_biotech_impact_population.xlsx"]}], "as_of": "2026-09-02", "decision": {"alternatives_considered": ["alder-biotech:blanket-hold", "alder-biotech:shortcut"], "question": "Is the Alder allegation substantiated enough for corrective action, and what must be preserved or escalated?", "rationale": "The four-part causal test supports 9 scoped actions and leaves 3 records on evidence hold. Policy thresholds, conflict disclosure rules, and corroborated intent evidence determine disposition.", "recommendation": "Substantiate and escalate only the supported conduct, with scoped preservation and remediation.", "selected_option_id": "alder-biotech:scoped-evidence"}, "holds": [{"id": "HOLD-CBP-021-03", "issue": "expense support deficiency", "portfolio_key": "CBP-021-03", "reason": "the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective", "required_next_evidence": "effective approval and an active owner with remaining capacity", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_intake/003_intake_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/02_preservation/015_preservation_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/04_email_exports/027_email_exports_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/039_chat_exports_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_alder_biotech_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-021-10", "issue": "interview timeline conflict", "portfolio_key": "CBP-021-10", "reason": "the current observation does not meet the operative trigger", "required_next_evidence": "a current observation that satisfies the operative trigger", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_preservation/010_preservation_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/03_interviews/022_interviews_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/034_chat_exports_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/06_expenses/046_expenses_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/11_board_reporting/082_board_reporting_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/09_policies/070_policies_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_alder_biotech_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-021-12", "issue": "policy training lapse", "portfolio_key": "CBP-021-12", "reason": "the operational record relies on a superseded control revision", "required_next_evidence": "an operational record using the current effective revision", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_preservation/012_preservation_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/03_interviews/024_interviews_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/036_chat_exports_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/06_expenses/048_expenses_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/09_policies/072_policies_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_alder_biotech_impact_population.xlsx"]}], "matter_number": "CB-IV-2601", "prepared_for": "Alder Biotherapeutics", "schema_version": "counselbench.decision.v3", "task_id": "cb100-021-alder-biotech"}, "matter_register": {"matter_number": "CB-IV-2601", "rows": [{"decision_option_id": "alder-biotech:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-01", "issue": "approval override", "matter_number": "CB-IV-2601", "owner": "Henry Cho", "portfolio_key": "CBP-021-01", "row_id": "REG-CBP-021-01", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_intake/001_intake_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/02_preservation/013_preservation_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/04_email_exports/025_email_exports_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/037_chat_exports_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/07_access_logs/049_access_logs_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/08_vendor_files/061_vendor_files_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_alder_biotech_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "alder-biotech:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-08-31", "issue": "vendor due-diligence gap", "matter_number": "CB-IV-2601", "owner": "Maya Ellison", "portfolio_key": "CBP-021-02", "row_id": "REG-CBP-021-02", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_intake/002_intake_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/02_preservation/014_preservation_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/04_email_exports/026_email_exports_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/038_chat_exports_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/07_access_logs/050_access_logs_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/11_board_reporting/086_board_reporting_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_alder_biotech_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "alder-biotech:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective", "issue": "expense support deficiency", "matter_number": "CB-IV-2601", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-021-03", "row_id": "REG-CBP-021-03", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_intake/003_intake_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/02_preservation/015_preservation_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/04_email_exports/027_email_exports_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/039_chat_exports_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_alder_biotech_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "alder-biotech:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-08-29", "issue": "split-purchase pattern", "matter_number": "CB-IV-2601", "owner": "Willa Novak", "portfolio_key": "CBP-021-04", "row_id": "REG-CBP-021-04", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_intake/004_intake_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/02_preservation/016_preservation_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/04_email_exports/028_email_exports_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/040_chat_exports_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/10_hr_records/076_hr_records_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/11_board_reporting/088_board_reporting_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_alder_biotech_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "alder-biotech:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-08-28", "issue": "badge-log inconsistency", "matter_number": "CB-IV-2601", "owner": "Owen Delgado", "portfolio_key": "CBP-021-05", "row_id": "REG-CBP-021-05", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_intake/005_intake_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/03_interviews/017_interviews_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/04_email_exports/029_email_exports_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/06_expenses/041_expenses_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/10_hr_records/077_hr_records_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/07_access_logs/053_access_logs_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_alder_biotech_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "alder-biotech:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-08-27", "issue": "hotline classification error", "matter_number": "CB-IV-2601", "owner": "Priya Raman", "portfolio_key": "CBP-021-06", "row_id": "REG-CBP-021-06", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_intake/006_intake_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/03_interviews/018_interviews_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/04_email_exports/030_email_exports_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/06_expenses/042_expenses_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_alder_biotech_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "alder-biotech:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-08-26", "issue": "undisclosed related party", "matter_number": "CB-IV-2601", "owner": "Isaac Romero", "portfolio_key": "CBP-021-07", "row_id": "REG-CBP-021-07", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_intake/007_intake_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/03_interviews/019_interviews_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/04_email_exports/031_email_exports_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/06_expenses/043_expenses_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/09_policies/067_policies_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/07_access_logs/055_access_logs_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_alder_biotech_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "alder-biotech:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-08-25", "issue": "deleted-message anomaly", "matter_number": "CB-IV-2601", "owner": "Nadine Flores", "portfolio_key": "CBP-021-08", "row_id": "REG-CBP-021-08", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_intake/008_intake_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/03_interviews/020_interviews_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/04_email_exports/032_email_exports_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/06_expenses/044_expenses_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_alder_biotech_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "alder-biotech:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-08-24", "issue": "board-reporting omission", "matter_number": "CB-IV-2601", "owner": "Rafael Okafor", "portfolio_key": "CBP-021-09", "row_id": "REG-CBP-021-09", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_preservation/009_preservation_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/03_interviews/021_interviews_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/033_chat_exports_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/06_expenses/045_expenses_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_alder_biotech_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "alder-biotech:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "the current observation does not meet the operative trigger", "issue": "interview timeline conflict", "matter_number": "CB-IV-2601", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-021-10", "row_id": "REG-CBP-021-10", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_preservation/010_preservation_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/03_interviews/022_interviews_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/034_chat_exports_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/06_expenses/046_expenses_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/11_board_reporting/082_board_reporting_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/09_policies/070_policies_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_alder_biotech_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "alder-biotech:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-08-31", "issue": "off-channel communication", "matter_number": "CB-IV-2601", "owner": "Theo Laurent", "portfolio_key": "CBP-021-11", "row_id": "REG-CBP-021-11", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_preservation/011_preservation_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/03_interviews/023_interviews_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/035_chat_exports_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/06_expenses/047_expenses_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/09_policies/071_policies_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/08_vendor_files/059_vendor_files_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_alder_biotech_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "alder-biotech:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "the operational record relies on a superseded control revision", "issue": "policy training lapse", "matter_number": "CB-IV-2601", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-021-12", "row_id": "REG-CBP-021-12", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_preservation/012_preservation_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/03_interviews/024_interviews_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/036_chat_exports_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/06_expenses/048_expenses_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/09_policies/072_policies_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_alder_biotech_impact_population.xlsx"]}], "schema_version": "counselbench.matter-register.v3", "task_id": "cb100-021-alder-biotech"}}, "metadata": {"benchmark": "CounselBench-100", "code_license": "Apache-2.0", "data_license": "CC-BY-4.0", "deadline": "2026-09-02", "document_count": 97, "evidence_holds": 3, "jurisdiction": "Massachusetts", "matter_number": "CB-IV-2601", "mcp_commit": "9a96ea6e5913736f92b88345bf51caeaaa8e719f", "mcp_package": "@modelcontextprotocol/server-filesystem@2026.7.10", "practice_area": "internal-investigations", "reference_tool_calls": 83, "required_evidence_reads": 65, "supported_actions": 9, "synthetic": true, "venue": "Cambridge, Massachusetts", "version": "3.1.0"}, "prompt": "I need a straight answer before the next partner call. Is the Alder allegation substantiated enough for corrective action, and what must be preserved or escalated? A hotline report alleges that a study manager split vendor invoices after accepting travel from a firm owned by a former colleague. The team needs the call by 2026-09-02. Update the matter record only where the evidence supports it, and give me the practical options for the client.", "rubric": {"criteria": [{"category": "investigation", "description": "Inventory the production and use targeted searches to locate records across native formats.", "id": "investigation.discover_production"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Complete every task-specific identity, authority, operations, and approval read before the first state transition.", "id": "investigation.read_before_write"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Inspect designated source metadata before relying on those records.", "id": "investigation.custody_before_write"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "Select the supported option 'alder-biotech:scoped-evidence' after applying the four-part test.", "id": "decision.selected_option"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "Identify both rejected approaches and explain why a one-source shortcut and a blanket hold are wrong.", "id": "decision.alternatives"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-021-01 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_intake/001_intake_source_export.md rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-021-01.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_preservation/013_preservation_source_export.json for approval override.", "id": "investigation.CBP-021-01.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_email_exports/025_email_exports_source_export.md to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-021-01.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/037_chat_exports_source_export.json.", "id": "investigation.CBP-021-01.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-021-01 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-021-01.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-021-01 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-021-01.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-021-02 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_intake/002_intake_source_export.txt rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-021-02.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_preservation/014_preservation_source_export.xml for vendor due-diligence gap.", "id": "investigation.CBP-021-02.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_email_exports/026_email_exports_source_export.txt to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-021-02.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/038_chat_exports_source_export.xml.", "id": "investigation.CBP-021-02.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-021-02 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-021-02.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-021-02 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-021-02.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-021-03 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_intake/003_intake_source_export.eml rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-021-03.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_preservation/015_preservation_source_export.html for expense support deficiency.", "id": "investigation.CBP-021-03.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_email_exports/027_email_exports_source_export.eml to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-021-03.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/039_chat_exports_source_export.html.", "id": "investigation.CBP-021-03.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-021-03 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective.", "id": "decision.CBP-021-03.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-021-03 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-021-03.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-021-04 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_intake/004_intake_source_export.csv rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-021-04.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_preservation/016_preservation_source_export.pdf for split-purchase pattern.", "id": "investigation.CBP-021-04.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_email_exports/028_email_exports_source_export.csv to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-021-04.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/040_chat_exports_source_export.pdf.", "id": "investigation.CBP-021-04.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-021-04 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-021-04.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-021-04 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-021-04.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-021-05 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_intake/005_intake_source_export.json rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-021-05.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_interviews/017_interviews_source_export.md for badge-log inconsistency.", "id": "investigation.CBP-021-05.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_email_exports/029_email_exports_source_export.json to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-021-05.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_expenses/041_expenses_source_export.md.", "id": "investigation.CBP-021-05.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-021-05 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-021-05.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-021-05 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-021-05.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-021-06 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_intake/006_intake_source_export.xml rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-021-06.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_interviews/018_interviews_source_export.txt for hotline classification error.", "id": "investigation.CBP-021-06.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_email_exports/030_email_exports_source_export.xml to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-021-06.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_expenses/042_expenses_source_export.txt.", "id": "investigation.CBP-021-06.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-021-06 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-021-06.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-021-06 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-021-06.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-021-07 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_intake/007_intake_source_export.html rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-021-07.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_interviews/019_interviews_source_export.eml for undisclosed related party.", "id": "investigation.CBP-021-07.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_email_exports/031_email_exports_source_export.html to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-021-07.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_expenses/043_expenses_source_export.eml.", "id": "investigation.CBP-021-07.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-021-07 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-021-07.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-021-07 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-021-07.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-021-08 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_intake/008_intake_source_export.pdf rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-021-08.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_interviews/020_interviews_source_export.csv for deleted-message anomaly.", "id": "investigation.CBP-021-08.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_email_exports/032_email_exports_source_export.pdf to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-021-08.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_expenses/044_expenses_source_export.csv.", "id": "investigation.CBP-021-08.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-021-08 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-021-08.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-021-08 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-021-08.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-021-09 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_preservation/009_preservation_source_export.md rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-021-09.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_interviews/021_interviews_source_export.json for board-reporting omission.", "id": "investigation.CBP-021-09.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/033_chat_exports_source_export.md to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-021-09.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_expenses/045_expenses_source_export.json.", "id": "investigation.CBP-021-09.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-021-09 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-021-09.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-021-09 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-021-09.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-021-10 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_preservation/010_preservation_source_export.txt rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-021-10.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_interviews/022_interviews_source_export.xml for interview timeline conflict.", "id": "investigation.CBP-021-10.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/034_chat_exports_source_export.txt to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-021-10.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_expenses/046_expenses_source_export.xml.", "id": "investigation.CBP-021-10.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-021-10 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is the current observation does not meet the operative trigger.", "id": "decision.CBP-021-10.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-021-10 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-021-10.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-021-11 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_preservation/011_preservation_source_export.eml rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-021-11.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_interviews/023_interviews_source_export.html for off-channel communication.", "id": "investigation.CBP-021-11.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/035_chat_exports_source_export.eml to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-021-11.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_expenses/047_expenses_source_export.html.", "id": "investigation.CBP-021-11.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-021-11 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-021-11.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-021-11 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-021-11.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-021-12 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_preservation/012_preservation_source_export.csv rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-021-12.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_interviews/024_interviews_source_export.pdf for policy training lapse.", "id": "investigation.CBP-021-12.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/036_chat_exports_source_export.csv to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-021-12.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_expenses/048_expenses_source_export.pdf.", "id": "investigation.CBP-021-12.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-021-12 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is the operational record relies on a superseded control revision.", "id": "decision.CBP-021-12.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-021-12 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-021-12.register"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Write the exact selected option, supported action population, evidence-hold population, facts, owners, deadlines, and citations.", "id": "state.exact_decision"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create one exact register row per portfolio key with no extra, missing, or modified row.", "id": "state.exact_register"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Leave only the three approved deliverables and perform no extra state-changing write.", "id": "state.write_scope_containment"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Read back decision.json, matter-register.json, and advice.md after their final writes.", "id": "state.postwrite_readback"}, {"category": "answer", "description": "Explain the selected recommendation, supported actions, holds, alternatives, and limitations with exact source anchors.", "id": "answer.decision_note"}], "decision_options": [{"approach": "Treat supported actions and genuinely ambiguous records as if they were equally unresolved.", "id": "alder-biotech:blanket-hold", "label": "Freeze the entire matter population"}, {"approach": "Apply the exact identity, current-state, authority, and revision test. Create investigation findings for proven conduct and evidence holds for unresolved intent.", "id": "alder-biotech:scoped-evidence", "label": "Substantiate and escalate only the supported conduct, with scoped preservation and remediation."}, {"approach": "Use a plausible summary or one source without completing the controlling joins.", "id": "alder-biotech:shortcut", "label": "Treat every split invoice as intentional misconduct without checking approvals or relationships."}], "evaluation_narrative": {"authority": "Policy thresholds, conflict disclosure rules, and corroborated intent evidence determine disposition.", "observation": "Join invoice sequences, travel records, relationship disclosures, and approver identity for the same vendor and study.", "question": "Is the Alder allegation substantiated enough for corrective action, and what must be preserved or escalated?", "register_action": "Create investigation findings for proven conduct and evidence holds for unresolved intent."}, "gates": ["all_required_evidence_precedes_first_write", "decision_criteria_complete", "register_state_exact", "write_scope_contained", "all_outputs_verified_by_readback"], "metadata_checks": 5, "metric": "weighted_criteria_score", "minimum_tool_calls": 83, "required_deliverables": ["decision.json", "matter-register.json", "advice.md"], "required_document_reads": 65, "type": "deterministic", "weights": {"advice": 0.15, "decision": 0.35, "investigation": 0.25, "state": 0.25}}, "task_id": "cb100-021-alder-biotech", "task_name": "Alder clinical-vendor payment inquiry", "world_id": "counselbench-filesystem-mcp-v3"}
+{"context_files": ["task_files/cb100-022-beacon-mining/01_intake/001_intake_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-022-beacon-mining/01_intake/002_intake_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-022-beacon-mining/01_intake/003_intake_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-022-beacon-mining/01_intake/004_intake_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-022-beacon-mining/01_intake/005_intake_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-022-beacon-mining/01_intake/006_intake_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-022-beacon-mining/01_intake/007_intake_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-022-beacon-mining/01_intake/008_intake_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-022-beacon-mining/02_preservation/009_preservation_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-022-beacon-mining/02_preservation/010_preservation_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-022-beacon-mining/02_preservation/011_preservation_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-022-beacon-mining/02_preservation/012_preservation_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-022-beacon-mining/02_preservation/013_preservation_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-022-beacon-mining/02_preservation/014_preservation_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-022-beacon-mining/02_preservation/015_preservation_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-022-beacon-mining/02_preservation/016_preservation_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-022-beacon-mining/03_interviews/017_interviews_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-022-beacon-mining/03_interviews/018_interviews_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-022-beacon-mining/03_interviews/019_interviews_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-022-beacon-mining/03_interviews/020_interviews_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-022-beacon-mining/03_interviews/021_interviews_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-022-beacon-mining/03_interviews/022_interviews_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-022-beacon-mining/03_interviews/023_interviews_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-022-beacon-mining/03_interviews/024_interviews_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-022-beacon-mining/04_email_exports/025_email_exports_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-022-beacon-mining/04_email_exports/026_email_exports_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-022-beacon-mining/04_email_exports/027_email_exports_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-022-beacon-mining/04_email_exports/028_email_exports_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-022-beacon-mining/04_email_exports/029_email_exports_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-022-beacon-mining/04_email_exports/030_email_exports_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-022-beacon-mining/04_email_exports/031_email_exports_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-022-beacon-mining/04_email_exports/032_email_exports_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-022-beacon-mining/05_chat_exports/033_chat_exports_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-022-beacon-mining/05_chat_exports/034_chat_exports_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-022-beacon-mining/05_chat_exports/035_chat_exports_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-022-beacon-mining/05_chat_exports/036_chat_exports_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-022-beacon-mining/05_chat_exports/037_chat_exports_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-022-beacon-mining/05_chat_exports/038_chat_exports_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-022-beacon-mining/05_chat_exports/039_chat_exports_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-022-beacon-mining/05_chat_exports/040_chat_exports_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-022-beacon-mining/06_expenses/041_expenses_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-022-beacon-mining/06_expenses/042_expenses_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-022-beacon-mining/06_expenses/043_expenses_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-022-beacon-mining/06_expenses/044_expenses_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-022-beacon-mining/06_expenses/045_expenses_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-022-beacon-mining/06_expenses/046_expenses_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-022-beacon-mining/06_expenses/047_expenses_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-022-beacon-mining/06_expenses/048_expenses_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-022-beacon-mining/07_access_logs/049_access_logs_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-022-beacon-mining/07_access_logs/050_access_logs_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-022-beacon-mining/07_access_logs/051_access_logs_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-022-beacon-mining/07_access_logs/052_access_logs_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-022-beacon-mining/07_access_logs/053_access_logs_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-022-beacon-mining/07_access_logs/054_access_logs_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-022-beacon-mining/07_access_logs/055_access_logs_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-022-beacon-mining/07_access_logs/056_access_logs_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-022-beacon-mining/08_vendor_files/057_vendor_files_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-022-beacon-mining/08_vendor_files/058_vendor_files_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-022-beacon-mining/08_vendor_files/059_vendor_files_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-022-beacon-mining/08_vendor_files/060_vendor_files_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-022-beacon-mining/08_vendor_files/061_vendor_files_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-022-beacon-mining/08_vendor_files/062_vendor_files_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-022-beacon-mining/08_vendor_files/063_vendor_files_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-022-beacon-mining/08_vendor_files/064_vendor_files_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-022-beacon-mining/09_policies/065_policies_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-022-beacon-mining/09_policies/066_policies_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-022-beacon-mining/09_policies/067_policies_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-022-beacon-mining/09_policies/068_policies_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-022-beacon-mining/09_policies/069_policies_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-022-beacon-mining/09_policies/070_policies_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-022-beacon-mining/09_policies/071_policies_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-022-beacon-mining/09_policies/072_policies_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-022-beacon-mining/10_hr_records/073_hr_records_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-022-beacon-mining/10_hr_records/074_hr_records_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-022-beacon-mining/10_hr_records/075_hr_records_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-022-beacon-mining/10_hr_records/076_hr_records_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-022-beacon-mining/10_hr_records/077_hr_records_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-022-beacon-mining/10_hr_records/078_hr_records_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-022-beacon-mining/10_hr_records/079_hr_records_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-022-beacon-mining/10_hr_records/080_hr_records_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-022-beacon-mining/11_board_reporting/081_board_reporting_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-022-beacon-mining/11_board_reporting/082_board_reporting_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-022-beacon-mining/11_board_reporting/083_board_reporting_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-022-beacon-mining/11_board_reporting/084_board_reporting_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-022-beacon-mining/11_board_reporting/085_board_reporting_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-022-beacon-mining/11_board_reporting/086_board_reporting_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-022-beacon-mining/11_board_reporting/087_board_reporting_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-022-beacon-mining/11_board_reporting/088_board_reporting_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-022-beacon-mining/12_remediation/089_remediation_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-022-beacon-mining/12_remediation/090_remediation_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-022-beacon-mining/12_remediation/091_remediation_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-022-beacon-mining/12_remediation/092_remediation_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-022-beacon-mining/12_remediation/093_remediation_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-022-beacon-mining/12_remediation/094_remediation_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-022-beacon-mining/12_remediation/095_remediation_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-022-beacon-mining/12_remediation/096_remediation_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-022-beacon-mining/12_remediation/097_beacon_mining_impact_population.xlsx"], "gold_output": {"advice_markdown": "# Decision note — Beacon procurement integrity review\n\n## Recommendation\n\nTake targeted recusal and control action where identity and involvement are proven. The reconciled record supports 9 scoped actions and leaves 3 items on evidence hold.\n\nSelected option: `beacon-mining:scoped-evidence`.\n\n## Why this is the supported option\n\nCorrelate award timing, chats, badge activity, and beneficial ownership by person and vendor ID. Conflict rules and procurement authority require independently corroborated relationship and intervention evidence.\n\n## Supported actions\n\n### CBP-022-01 — gift-policy threshold breach (low)\n\nthe controlling threshold is 12% under CB-IV-2602-R143; the independently calculated result is 16% under CB-IV-2602-E896. Identity resolves to ENT-022-1000, revision REV-2026.1 is current, and Farah Ibrahim is active with capacity 6.\n\nAction: Register substantiated relationships and preserve ambiguous messages without accusation. Owner: Farah Ibrahim; due 2026-09-05.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_intake/001_intake_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/02_preservation/013_preservation_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/04_email_exports/025_email_exports_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/037_chat_exports_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/11_board_reporting/085_board_reporting_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/10_hr_records/073_hr_records_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_beacon_mining_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-022-02 — retaliation concern (high)\n\napproval must come from Maya Ellison under CB-IV-2602-R224; the effective approval record names Caleb Hassan under CB-IV-2602-E424. Identity resolves to ENT-022-1001, revision REV-2026.2 is current, and Dominic Alvarez is active with capacity 5.\n\nAction: Register substantiated relationships and preserve ambiguous messages without accusation. Owner: Dominic Alvarez; due 2026-09-04.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_intake/002_intake_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/02_preservation/014_preservation_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/04_email_exports/026_email_exports_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/038_chat_exports_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/11_board_reporting/086_board_reporting_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_beacon_mining_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-022-03 — remediation ownership gap (high)\n\nthe controlled population contains 239 records under CB-IV-2602-R487; the certification covers 209 records under CB-IV-2602-E969. Identity resolves to ENT-022-1002, revision REV-2026.3 is current, and Leona Park is active with capacity 5.\n\nAction: Register substantiated relationships and preserve ambiguous messages without accusation. Owner: Leona Park; due 2026-09-03.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_intake/003_intake_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/02_preservation/015_preservation_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/04_email_exports/027_email_exports_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/039_chat_exports_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_beacon_mining_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-022-05 — vendor due-diligence gap (low)\n\nthe operative cap is $202,000.00 under CB-IV-2602-R465; the matched ledger population totals $422,065.00 under CB-IV-2602-E174. Identity resolves to ENT-022-1004, revision REV-2026.5 is current, and Maya Ellison is active with capacity 2.\n\nAction: Register substantiated relationships and preserve ambiguous messages without accusation. Owner: Maya Ellison; due 2026-09-01.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_intake/005_intake_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/03_interviews/017_interviews_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/04_email_exports/029_email_exports_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/06_expenses/041_expenses_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_beacon_mining_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-022-06 — expense support deficiency (high)\n\ndelivery must use notices-beacon_mineral_resources@example.test under CB-IV-2602-R874; the only matched receipt used archive-red_mesa_hauling_co@example.test under CB-IV-2602-E833. Identity resolves to ENT-022-1005, revision REV-2026.6 is current, and Jonas Feld is active with capacity 3.\n\nAction: Register substantiated relationships and preserve ambiguous messages without accusation. Owner: Jonas Feld; due 2026-08-31.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_intake/006_intake_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/03_interviews/018_interviews_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/04_email_exports/030_email_exports_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/06_expenses/042_expenses_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_beacon_mining_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-022-07 — split-purchase pattern (medium)\n\nan open exception blocks completion under CB-IV-2602-R750; the current status is open and unresolved under CB-IV-2602-E244. Identity resolves to ENT-022-1006, revision REV-2026.7 is current, and Willa Novak is active with capacity 6.\n\nAction: Register substantiated relationships and preserve ambiguous messages without accusation. Owner: Willa Novak; due 2026-08-30.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_intake/007_intake_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/03_interviews/019_interviews_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/04_email_exports/031_email_exports_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/06_expenses/043_expenses_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_beacon_mining_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-022-09 — hotline classification error (medium)\n\nthe controlling threshold is 7% under CB-IV-2602-R268; the independently calculated result is 13% under CB-IV-2602-E162. Identity resolves to ENT-022-1008, revision REV-2026.2 is current, and Priya Raman is active with capacity 4.\n\nAction: Register substantiated relationships and preserve ambiguous messages without accusation. Owner: Priya Raman; due 2026-08-28.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/02_preservation/009_preservation_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/03_interviews/021_interviews_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/033_chat_exports_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/06_expenses/045_expenses_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/12_remediation/093_remediation_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/11_board_reporting/081_board_reporting_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_beacon_mining_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-022-10 — undisclosed related party (critical)\n\napproval must come from Maya Ellison under CB-IV-2602-R460; the effective approval record names Rafael Okafor under CB-IV-2602-E862. Identity resolves to ENT-022-1009, revision REV-2026.3 is current, and Isaac Romero is active with capacity 4.\n\nAction: Register substantiated relationships and preserve ambiguous messages without accusation. Owner: Isaac Romero; due 2026-09-05.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/02_preservation/010_preservation_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/03_interviews/022_interviews_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/034_chat_exports_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/06_expenses/046_expenses_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/11_board_reporting/082_board_reporting_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_beacon_mining_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-022-12 — board-reporting omission (critical)\n\nthe permission is limited to Pima County, Arizona under CB-IV-2602-R881; the matched activity occurred in Arizona under CB-IV-2602-E251. Identity resolves to ENT-022-1011, revision REV-2026.5 is current, and Rafael Okafor is active with capacity 4.\n\nAction: Register substantiated relationships and preserve ambiguous messages without accusation. Owner: Rafael Okafor; due 2026-09-03.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/02_preservation/012_preservation_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/03_interviews/024_interviews_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/036_chat_exports_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/06_expenses/048_expenses_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/09_policies/072_policies_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/12_remediation/096_remediation_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_beacon_mining_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n## Evidence holds\n\n- **CBP-022-04 — approval override**: two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key. Next evidence: an approved immutable entity crosswalk. Sources: `/workspace/documents/01_intake/004_intake_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/02_preservation/016_preservation_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/04_email_exports/028_email_exports_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/040_chat_exports_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_beacon_mining_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-022-08 — badge-log inconsistency**: two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key. Next evidence: an approved immutable entity crosswalk. Sources: `/workspace/documents/01_intake/008_intake_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/03_interviews/020_interviews_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/04_email_exports/032_email_exports_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/06_expenses/044_expenses_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/09_policies/068_policies_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/10_hr_records/080_hr_records_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_beacon_mining_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-022-11 — deleted-message anomaly**: the operational record relies on a superseded control revision. Next evidence: an operational record using the current effective revision. Sources: `/workspace/documents/02_preservation/011_preservation_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/03_interviews/023_interviews_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/035_chat_exports_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/06_expenses/047_expenses_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/09_policies/071_policies_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_beacon_mining_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n## Alternatives considered\n\n- `beacon-mining:shortcut` — Assume every emergency award is corrupt because prices increased.: Use a plausible summary or one source without completing the controlling joins.\n- `beacon-mining:blanket-hold` — Freeze the entire matter population: Treat supported actions and genuinely ambiguous records as if they were equally unresolved.\n\n## Assumptions and limits\n\nThis decision is limited to cb100-022-beacon-mining, the supplied synthetic records, and the matter state as of 2026-09-06. Similar names, stale revisions, and pending authority are not treated as proof.\n", "decision": {"actions": [{"determination": "the controlling threshold is 12% under CB-IV-2602-R143; the independently calculated result is 16% under CB-IV-2602-E896. Identity resolves to ENT-022-1000, revision REV-2026.1 is current, and Farah Ibrahim is active with capacity 6.", "due_date": "2026-09-05", "id": "ACT-CBP-022-01", "identity_id": "ENT-022-1000", "issue": "gift-policy threshold breach", "owner": "Farah Ibrahim", "portfolio_key": "CBP-022-01", "recommended_action": "Register substantiated relationships and preserve ambiguous messages without accusation. Owner: Farah Ibrahim; due 2026-09-05.", "severity": "low", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_intake/001_intake_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/02_preservation/013_preservation_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/04_email_exports/025_email_exports_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/037_chat_exports_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/11_board_reporting/085_board_reporting_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/10_hr_records/073_hr_records_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_beacon_mining_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "approval must come from Maya Ellison under CB-IV-2602-R224; the effective approval record names Caleb Hassan under CB-IV-2602-E424. Identity resolves to ENT-022-1001, revision REV-2026.2 is current, and Dominic Alvarez is active with capacity 5.", "due_date": "2026-09-04", "id": "ACT-CBP-022-02", "identity_id": "ENT-022-1001", "issue": "retaliation concern", "owner": "Dominic Alvarez", "portfolio_key": "CBP-022-02", "recommended_action": "Register substantiated relationships and preserve ambiguous messages without accusation. Owner: Dominic Alvarez; due 2026-09-04.", "severity": "high", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_intake/002_intake_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/02_preservation/014_preservation_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/04_email_exports/026_email_exports_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/038_chat_exports_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/11_board_reporting/086_board_reporting_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_beacon_mining_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "the controlled population contains 239 records under CB-IV-2602-R487; the certification covers 209 records under CB-IV-2602-E969. Identity resolves to ENT-022-1002, revision REV-2026.3 is current, and Leona Park is active with capacity 5.", "due_date": "2026-09-03", "id": "ACT-CBP-022-03", "identity_id": "ENT-022-1002", "issue": "remediation ownership gap", "owner": "Leona Park", "portfolio_key": "CBP-022-03", "recommended_action": "Register substantiated relationships and preserve ambiguous messages without accusation. Owner: Leona Park; due 2026-09-03.", "severity": "high", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_intake/003_intake_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/02_preservation/015_preservation_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/04_email_exports/027_email_exports_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/039_chat_exports_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_beacon_mining_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "the operative cap is $202,000.00 under CB-IV-2602-R465; the matched ledger population totals $422,065.00 under CB-IV-2602-E174. Identity resolves to ENT-022-1004, revision REV-2026.5 is current, and Maya Ellison is active with capacity 2.", "due_date": "2026-09-01", "id": "ACT-CBP-022-05", "identity_id": "ENT-022-1004", "issue": "vendor due-diligence gap", "owner": "Maya Ellison", "portfolio_key": "CBP-022-05", "recommended_action": "Register substantiated relationships and preserve ambiguous messages without accusation. Owner: Maya Ellison; due 2026-09-01.", "severity": "low", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_intake/005_intake_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/03_interviews/017_interviews_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/04_email_exports/029_email_exports_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/06_expenses/041_expenses_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_beacon_mining_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "delivery must use notices-beacon_mineral_resources@example.test under CB-IV-2602-R874; the only matched receipt used archive-red_mesa_hauling_co@example.test under CB-IV-2602-E833. Identity resolves to ENT-022-1005, revision REV-2026.6 is current, and Jonas Feld is active with capacity 3.", "due_date": "2026-08-31", "id": "ACT-CBP-022-06", "identity_id": "ENT-022-1005", "issue": "expense support deficiency", "owner": "Jonas Feld", "portfolio_key": "CBP-022-06", "recommended_action": "Register substantiated relationships and preserve ambiguous messages without accusation. Owner: Jonas Feld; due 2026-08-31.", "severity": "high", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_intake/006_intake_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/03_interviews/018_interviews_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/04_email_exports/030_email_exports_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/06_expenses/042_expenses_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_beacon_mining_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "an open exception blocks completion under CB-IV-2602-R750; the current status is open and unresolved under CB-IV-2602-E244. Identity resolves to ENT-022-1006, revision REV-2026.7 is current, and Willa Novak is active with capacity 6.", "due_date": "2026-08-30", "id": "ACT-CBP-022-07", "identity_id": "ENT-022-1006", "issue": "split-purchase pattern", "owner": "Willa Novak", "portfolio_key": "CBP-022-07", "recommended_action": "Register substantiated relationships and preserve ambiguous messages without accusation. Owner: Willa Novak; due 2026-08-30.", "severity": "medium", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_intake/007_intake_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/03_interviews/019_interviews_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/04_email_exports/031_email_exports_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/06_expenses/043_expenses_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_beacon_mining_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "the controlling threshold is 7% under CB-IV-2602-R268; the independently calculated result is 13% under CB-IV-2602-E162. Identity resolves to ENT-022-1008, revision REV-2026.2 is current, and Priya Raman is active with capacity 4.", "due_date": "2026-08-28", "id": "ACT-CBP-022-09", "identity_id": "ENT-022-1008", "issue": "hotline classification error", "owner": "Priya Raman", "portfolio_key": "CBP-022-09", "recommended_action": "Register substantiated relationships and preserve ambiguous messages without accusation. Owner: Priya Raman; due 2026-08-28.", "severity": "medium", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_preservation/009_preservation_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/03_interviews/021_interviews_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/033_chat_exports_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/06_expenses/045_expenses_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/093_remediation_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/11_board_reporting/081_board_reporting_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_beacon_mining_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "approval must come from Maya Ellison under CB-IV-2602-R460; the effective approval record names Rafael Okafor under CB-IV-2602-E862. Identity resolves to ENT-022-1009, revision REV-2026.3 is current, and Isaac Romero is active with capacity 4.", "due_date": "2026-09-05", "id": "ACT-CBP-022-10", "identity_id": "ENT-022-1009", "issue": "undisclosed related party", "owner": "Isaac Romero", "portfolio_key": "CBP-022-10", "recommended_action": "Register substantiated relationships and preserve ambiguous messages without accusation. Owner: Isaac Romero; due 2026-09-05.", "severity": "critical", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_preservation/010_preservation_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/03_interviews/022_interviews_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/034_chat_exports_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/06_expenses/046_expenses_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/11_board_reporting/082_board_reporting_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_beacon_mining_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "the permission is limited to Pima County, Arizona under CB-IV-2602-R881; the matched activity occurred in Arizona under CB-IV-2602-E251. Identity resolves to ENT-022-1011, revision REV-2026.5 is current, and Rafael Okafor is active with capacity 4.", "due_date": "2026-09-03", "id": "ACT-CBP-022-12", "identity_id": "ENT-022-1011", "issue": "board-reporting omission", "owner": "Rafael Okafor", "portfolio_key": "CBP-022-12", "recommended_action": "Register substantiated relationships and preserve ambiguous messages without accusation. Owner: Rafael Okafor; due 2026-09-03.", "severity": "critical", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_preservation/012_preservation_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/03_interviews/024_interviews_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/036_chat_exports_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/06_expenses/048_expenses_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/09_policies/072_policies_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/096_remediation_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_beacon_mining_impact_population.xlsx"]}], "as_of": "2026-09-06", "decision": {"alternatives_considered": ["beacon-mining:shortcut", "beacon-mining:blanket-hold"], "question": "What can we conclude about the Beacon hauling awards, and who should be removed from the decision chain?", "rationale": "The four-part causal test supports 9 scoped actions and leaves 3 records on evidence hold. Conflict rules and procurement authority require independently corroborated relationship and intervention evidence.", "recommendation": "Take targeted recusal and control action where identity and involvement are proven.", "selected_option_id": "beacon-mining:scoped-evidence"}, "holds": [{"id": "HOLD-CBP-022-04", "issue": "approval override", "portfolio_key": "CBP-022-04", "reason": "two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key", "required_next_evidence": "an approved immutable entity crosswalk", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_intake/004_intake_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/02_preservation/016_preservation_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/04_email_exports/028_email_exports_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/040_chat_exports_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_beacon_mining_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-022-08", "issue": "badge-log inconsistency", "portfolio_key": "CBP-022-08", "reason": "two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key", "required_next_evidence": "an approved immutable entity crosswalk", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_intake/008_intake_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/03_interviews/020_interviews_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/04_email_exports/032_email_exports_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/06_expenses/044_expenses_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/09_policies/068_policies_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/10_hr_records/080_hr_records_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_beacon_mining_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-022-11", "issue": "deleted-message anomaly", "portfolio_key": "CBP-022-11", "reason": "the operational record relies on a superseded control revision", "required_next_evidence": "an operational record using the current effective revision", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_preservation/011_preservation_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/03_interviews/023_interviews_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/035_chat_exports_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/06_expenses/047_expenses_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/09_policies/071_policies_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_beacon_mining_impact_population.xlsx"]}], "matter_number": "CB-IV-2602", "prepared_for": "Beacon Mineral Resources", "schema_version": "counselbench.decision.v3", "task_id": "cb100-022-beacon-mining"}, "matter_register": {"matter_number": "CB-IV-2602", "rows": [{"decision_option_id": "beacon-mining:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-05", "issue": "gift-policy threshold breach", "matter_number": "CB-IV-2602", "owner": "Farah Ibrahim", "portfolio_key": "CBP-022-01", "row_id": "REG-CBP-022-01", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_intake/001_intake_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/02_preservation/013_preservation_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/04_email_exports/025_email_exports_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/037_chat_exports_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/11_board_reporting/085_board_reporting_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/10_hr_records/073_hr_records_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_beacon_mining_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "beacon-mining:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-04", "issue": "retaliation concern", "matter_number": "CB-IV-2602", "owner": "Dominic Alvarez", "portfolio_key": "CBP-022-02", "row_id": "REG-CBP-022-02", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_intake/002_intake_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/02_preservation/014_preservation_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/04_email_exports/026_email_exports_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/038_chat_exports_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/11_board_reporting/086_board_reporting_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_beacon_mining_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "beacon-mining:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-03", "issue": "remediation ownership gap", "matter_number": "CB-IV-2602", "owner": "Leona Park", "portfolio_key": "CBP-022-03", "row_id": "REG-CBP-022-03", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_intake/003_intake_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/02_preservation/015_preservation_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/04_email_exports/027_email_exports_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/039_chat_exports_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_beacon_mining_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "beacon-mining:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key", "issue": "approval override", "matter_number": "CB-IV-2602", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-022-04", "row_id": "REG-CBP-022-04", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_intake/004_intake_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/02_preservation/016_preservation_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/04_email_exports/028_email_exports_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/040_chat_exports_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_beacon_mining_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "beacon-mining:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-01", "issue": "vendor due-diligence gap", "matter_number": "CB-IV-2602", "owner": "Maya Ellison", "portfolio_key": "CBP-022-05", "row_id": "REG-CBP-022-05", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_intake/005_intake_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/03_interviews/017_interviews_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/04_email_exports/029_email_exports_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/06_expenses/041_expenses_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_beacon_mining_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "beacon-mining:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-08-31", "issue": "expense support deficiency", "matter_number": "CB-IV-2602", "owner": "Jonas Feld", "portfolio_key": "CBP-022-06", "row_id": "REG-CBP-022-06", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_intake/006_intake_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/03_interviews/018_interviews_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/04_email_exports/030_email_exports_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/06_expenses/042_expenses_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_beacon_mining_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "beacon-mining:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-08-30", "issue": "split-purchase pattern", "matter_number": "CB-IV-2602", "owner": "Willa Novak", "portfolio_key": "CBP-022-07", "row_id": "REG-CBP-022-07", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_intake/007_intake_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/03_interviews/019_interviews_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/04_email_exports/031_email_exports_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/06_expenses/043_expenses_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_beacon_mining_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "beacon-mining:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key", "issue": "badge-log inconsistency", "matter_number": "CB-IV-2602", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-022-08", "row_id": "REG-CBP-022-08", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_intake/008_intake_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/03_interviews/020_interviews_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/04_email_exports/032_email_exports_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/06_expenses/044_expenses_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/09_policies/068_policies_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/10_hr_records/080_hr_records_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_beacon_mining_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "beacon-mining:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-08-28", "issue": "hotline classification error", "matter_number": "CB-IV-2602", "owner": "Priya Raman", "portfolio_key": "CBP-022-09", "row_id": "REG-CBP-022-09", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_preservation/009_preservation_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/03_interviews/021_interviews_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/033_chat_exports_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/06_expenses/045_expenses_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/093_remediation_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/11_board_reporting/081_board_reporting_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_beacon_mining_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "beacon-mining:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-05", "issue": "undisclosed related party", "matter_number": "CB-IV-2602", "owner": "Isaac Romero", "portfolio_key": "CBP-022-10", "row_id": "REG-CBP-022-10", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_preservation/010_preservation_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/03_interviews/022_interviews_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/034_chat_exports_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/06_expenses/046_expenses_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/11_board_reporting/082_board_reporting_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_beacon_mining_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "beacon-mining:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "the operational record relies on a superseded control revision", "issue": "deleted-message anomaly", "matter_number": "CB-IV-2602", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-022-11", "row_id": "REG-CBP-022-11", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_preservation/011_preservation_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/03_interviews/023_interviews_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/035_chat_exports_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/06_expenses/047_expenses_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/09_policies/071_policies_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_beacon_mining_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "beacon-mining:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-03", "issue": "board-reporting omission", "matter_number": "CB-IV-2602", "owner": "Rafael Okafor", "portfolio_key": "CBP-022-12", "row_id": "REG-CBP-022-12", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_preservation/012_preservation_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/03_interviews/024_interviews_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/036_chat_exports_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/06_expenses/048_expenses_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/09_policies/072_policies_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/096_remediation_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_beacon_mining_impact_population.xlsx"]}], "schema_version": "counselbench.matter-register.v3", "task_id": "cb100-022-beacon-mining"}}, "metadata": {"benchmark": "CounselBench-100", "code_license": "Apache-2.0", "data_license": "CC-BY-4.0", "deadline": "2026-09-06", "document_count": 97, "evidence_holds": 3, "jurisdiction": "Arizona", "matter_number": "CB-IV-2602", "mcp_commit": "9a96ea6e5913736f92b88345bf51caeaaa8e719f", "mcp_package": "@modelcontextprotocol/server-filesystem@2026.7.10", "practice_area": "internal-investigations", "reference_tool_calls": 88, "required_evidence_reads": 61, "supported_actions": 9, "synthetic": true, "venue": "Pima County, Arizona", "version": "3.1.0"}, "prompt": "The business team is asking whether it can move, and I do not want to answer from the summary deck. What can we conclude about the Beacon hauling awards, and who should be removed from the decision chain? Anonymous allegations connect emergency hauling awards to off-channel messages, badge visits, and an undeclared family relationship. The team needs the call by 2026-09-06. Document the scoped result for the team and separate genuine exceptions from unresolved identity or revision questions.", "rubric": {"criteria": [{"category": "investigation", "description": "Inventory the production and use targeted searches to locate records across native formats.", "id": "investigation.discover_production"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Complete every task-specific identity, authority, operations, and approval read before the first state transition.", "id": "investigation.read_before_write"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Inspect designated source metadata before relying on those records.", "id": "investigation.custody_before_write"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "Select the supported option 'beacon-mining:scoped-evidence' after applying the four-part test.", "id": "decision.selected_option"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "Identify both rejected approaches and explain why a one-source shortcut and a blanket hold are wrong.", "id": "decision.alternatives"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-022-01 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_intake/001_intake_source_export.md rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-022-01.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_preservation/013_preservation_source_export.json for gift-policy threshold breach.", "id": "investigation.CBP-022-01.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_email_exports/025_email_exports_source_export.md to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-022-01.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/037_chat_exports_source_export.json.", "id": "investigation.CBP-022-01.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-022-01 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-022-01.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-022-01 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-022-01.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-022-02 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_intake/002_intake_source_export.txt rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-022-02.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_preservation/014_preservation_source_export.xml for retaliation concern.", "id": "investigation.CBP-022-02.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_email_exports/026_email_exports_source_export.txt to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-022-02.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/038_chat_exports_source_export.xml.", "id": "investigation.CBP-022-02.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-022-02 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-022-02.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-022-02 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-022-02.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-022-03 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_intake/003_intake_source_export.eml rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-022-03.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_preservation/015_preservation_source_export.html for remediation ownership gap.", "id": "investigation.CBP-022-03.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_email_exports/027_email_exports_source_export.eml to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-022-03.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/039_chat_exports_source_export.html.", "id": "investigation.CBP-022-03.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-022-03 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-022-03.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-022-03 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-022-03.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-022-04 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_intake/004_intake_source_export.csv rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-022-04.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_preservation/016_preservation_source_export.pdf for approval override.", "id": "investigation.CBP-022-04.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_email_exports/028_email_exports_source_export.csv to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-022-04.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/040_chat_exports_source_export.pdf.", "id": "investigation.CBP-022-04.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-022-04 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key.", "id": "decision.CBP-022-04.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-022-04 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-022-04.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-022-05 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_intake/005_intake_source_export.json rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-022-05.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_interviews/017_interviews_source_export.md for vendor due-diligence gap.", "id": "investigation.CBP-022-05.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_email_exports/029_email_exports_source_export.json to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-022-05.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_expenses/041_expenses_source_export.md.", "id": "investigation.CBP-022-05.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-022-05 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-022-05.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-022-05 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-022-05.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-022-06 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_intake/006_intake_source_export.xml rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-022-06.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_interviews/018_interviews_source_export.txt for expense support deficiency.", "id": "investigation.CBP-022-06.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_email_exports/030_email_exports_source_export.xml to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-022-06.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_expenses/042_expenses_source_export.txt.", "id": "investigation.CBP-022-06.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-022-06 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-022-06.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-022-06 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-022-06.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-022-07 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_intake/007_intake_source_export.html rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-022-07.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_interviews/019_interviews_source_export.eml for split-purchase pattern.", "id": "investigation.CBP-022-07.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_email_exports/031_email_exports_source_export.html to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-022-07.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_expenses/043_expenses_source_export.eml.", "id": "investigation.CBP-022-07.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-022-07 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-022-07.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-022-07 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-022-07.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-022-08 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_intake/008_intake_source_export.pdf rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-022-08.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_interviews/020_interviews_source_export.csv for badge-log inconsistency.", "id": "investigation.CBP-022-08.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_email_exports/032_email_exports_source_export.pdf to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-022-08.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_expenses/044_expenses_source_export.csv.", "id": "investigation.CBP-022-08.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-022-08 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key.", "id": "decision.CBP-022-08.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-022-08 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-022-08.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-022-09 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_preservation/009_preservation_source_export.md rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-022-09.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_interviews/021_interviews_source_export.json for hotline classification error.", "id": "investigation.CBP-022-09.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/033_chat_exports_source_export.md to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-022-09.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_expenses/045_expenses_source_export.json.", "id": "investigation.CBP-022-09.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-022-09 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-022-09.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-022-09 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-022-09.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-022-10 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_preservation/010_preservation_source_export.txt rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-022-10.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_interviews/022_interviews_source_export.xml for undisclosed related party.", "id": "investigation.CBP-022-10.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/034_chat_exports_source_export.txt to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-022-10.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_expenses/046_expenses_source_export.xml.", "id": "investigation.CBP-022-10.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-022-10 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-022-10.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-022-10 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-022-10.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-022-11 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_preservation/011_preservation_source_export.eml rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-022-11.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_interviews/023_interviews_source_export.html for deleted-message anomaly.", "id": "investigation.CBP-022-11.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/035_chat_exports_source_export.eml to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-022-11.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_expenses/047_expenses_source_export.html.", "id": "investigation.CBP-022-11.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-022-11 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is the operational record relies on a superseded control revision.", "id": "decision.CBP-022-11.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-022-11 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-022-11.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-022-12 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_preservation/012_preservation_source_export.csv rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-022-12.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_interviews/024_interviews_source_export.pdf for board-reporting omission.", "id": "investigation.CBP-022-12.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/036_chat_exports_source_export.csv to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-022-12.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_expenses/048_expenses_source_export.pdf.", "id": "investigation.CBP-022-12.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-022-12 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-022-12.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-022-12 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-022-12.register"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Write the exact selected option, supported action population, evidence-hold population, facts, owners, deadlines, and citations.", "id": "state.exact_decision"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create one exact register row per portfolio key with no extra, missing, or modified row.", "id": "state.exact_register"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Leave only the three approved deliverables and perform no extra state-changing write.", "id": "state.write_scope_containment"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Read back decision.json, matter-register.json, and advice.md after their final writes.", "id": "state.postwrite_readback"}, {"category": "answer", "description": "Explain the selected recommendation, supported actions, holds, alternatives, and limitations with exact source anchors.", "id": "answer.decision_note"}], "decision_options": [{"approach": "Apply the exact identity, current-state, authority, and revision test. Register substantiated relationships and preserve ambiguous messages without accusation.", "id": "beacon-mining:scoped-evidence", "label": "Take targeted recusal and control action where identity and involvement are proven."}, {"approach": "Use a plausible summary or one source without completing the controlling joins.", "id": "beacon-mining:shortcut", "label": "Assume every emergency award is corrupt because prices increased."}, {"approach": "Treat supported actions and genuinely ambiguous records as if they were equally unresolved.", "id": "beacon-mining:blanket-hold", "label": "Freeze the entire matter population"}], "evaluation_narrative": {"authority": "Conflict rules and procurement authority require independently corroborated relationship and intervention evidence.", "observation": "Correlate award timing, chats, badge activity, and beneficial ownership by person and vendor ID.", "question": "What can we conclude about the Beacon hauling awards, and who should be removed from the decision chain?", "register_action": "Register substantiated relationships and preserve ambiguous messages without accusation."}, "gates": ["all_required_evidence_precedes_first_write", "decision_criteria_complete", "register_state_exact", "write_scope_contained", "all_outputs_verified_by_readback"], "metadata_checks": 10, "metric": "weighted_criteria_score", "minimum_tool_calls": 88, "required_deliverables": ["decision.json", "matter-register.json", "advice.md"], "required_document_reads": 61, "type": "deterministic", "weights": {"advice": 0.15, "decision": 0.35, "investigation": 0.25, "state": 0.25}}, "task_id": "cb100-022-beacon-mining", "task_name": "Beacon procurement integrity review", "world_id": "counselbench-filesystem-mcp-v3"}
+{"context_files": ["task_files/cb100-023-cedar-finance/01_intake/001_intake_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-023-cedar-finance/01_intake/002_intake_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-023-cedar-finance/01_intake/003_intake_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-023-cedar-finance/01_intake/004_intake_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-023-cedar-finance/01_intake/005_intake_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-023-cedar-finance/01_intake/006_intake_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-023-cedar-finance/01_intake/007_intake_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-023-cedar-finance/01_intake/008_intake_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-023-cedar-finance/02_preservation/009_preservation_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-023-cedar-finance/02_preservation/010_preservation_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-023-cedar-finance/02_preservation/011_preservation_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-023-cedar-finance/02_preservation/012_preservation_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-023-cedar-finance/02_preservation/013_preservation_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-023-cedar-finance/02_preservation/014_preservation_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-023-cedar-finance/02_preservation/015_preservation_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-023-cedar-finance/02_preservation/016_preservation_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-023-cedar-finance/03_interviews/017_interviews_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-023-cedar-finance/03_interviews/018_interviews_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-023-cedar-finance/03_interviews/019_interviews_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-023-cedar-finance/03_interviews/020_interviews_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-023-cedar-finance/03_interviews/021_interviews_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-023-cedar-finance/03_interviews/022_interviews_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-023-cedar-finance/03_interviews/023_interviews_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-023-cedar-finance/03_interviews/024_interviews_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-023-cedar-finance/04_email_exports/025_email_exports_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-023-cedar-finance/04_email_exports/026_email_exports_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-023-cedar-finance/04_email_exports/027_email_exports_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-023-cedar-finance/04_email_exports/028_email_exports_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-023-cedar-finance/04_email_exports/029_email_exports_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-023-cedar-finance/04_email_exports/030_email_exports_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-023-cedar-finance/04_email_exports/031_email_exports_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-023-cedar-finance/04_email_exports/032_email_exports_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-023-cedar-finance/05_chat_exports/033_chat_exports_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-023-cedar-finance/05_chat_exports/034_chat_exports_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-023-cedar-finance/05_chat_exports/035_chat_exports_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-023-cedar-finance/05_chat_exports/036_chat_exports_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-023-cedar-finance/05_chat_exports/037_chat_exports_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-023-cedar-finance/05_chat_exports/038_chat_exports_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-023-cedar-finance/05_chat_exports/039_chat_exports_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-023-cedar-finance/05_chat_exports/040_chat_exports_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-023-cedar-finance/06_expenses/041_expenses_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-023-cedar-finance/06_expenses/042_expenses_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-023-cedar-finance/06_expenses/043_expenses_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-023-cedar-finance/06_expenses/044_expenses_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-023-cedar-finance/06_expenses/045_expenses_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-023-cedar-finance/06_expenses/046_expenses_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-023-cedar-finance/06_expenses/047_expenses_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-023-cedar-finance/06_expenses/048_expenses_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-023-cedar-finance/07_access_logs/049_access_logs_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-023-cedar-finance/07_access_logs/050_access_logs_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-023-cedar-finance/07_access_logs/051_access_logs_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-023-cedar-finance/07_access_logs/052_access_logs_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-023-cedar-finance/07_access_logs/053_access_logs_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-023-cedar-finance/07_access_logs/054_access_logs_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-023-cedar-finance/07_access_logs/055_access_logs_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-023-cedar-finance/07_access_logs/056_access_logs_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-023-cedar-finance/08_vendor_files/057_vendor_files_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-023-cedar-finance/08_vendor_files/058_vendor_files_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-023-cedar-finance/08_vendor_files/059_vendor_files_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-023-cedar-finance/08_vendor_files/060_vendor_files_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-023-cedar-finance/08_vendor_files/061_vendor_files_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-023-cedar-finance/08_vendor_files/062_vendor_files_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-023-cedar-finance/08_vendor_files/063_vendor_files_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-023-cedar-finance/08_vendor_files/064_vendor_files_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-023-cedar-finance/09_policies/065_policies_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-023-cedar-finance/09_policies/066_policies_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-023-cedar-finance/09_policies/067_policies_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-023-cedar-finance/09_policies/068_policies_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-023-cedar-finance/09_policies/069_policies_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-023-cedar-finance/09_policies/070_policies_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-023-cedar-finance/09_policies/071_policies_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-023-cedar-finance/09_policies/072_policies_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-023-cedar-finance/10_hr_records/073_hr_records_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-023-cedar-finance/10_hr_records/074_hr_records_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-023-cedar-finance/10_hr_records/075_hr_records_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-023-cedar-finance/10_hr_records/076_hr_records_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-023-cedar-finance/10_hr_records/077_hr_records_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-023-cedar-finance/10_hr_records/078_hr_records_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-023-cedar-finance/10_hr_records/079_hr_records_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-023-cedar-finance/10_hr_records/080_hr_records_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-023-cedar-finance/11_board_reporting/081_board_reporting_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-023-cedar-finance/11_board_reporting/082_board_reporting_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-023-cedar-finance/11_board_reporting/083_board_reporting_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-023-cedar-finance/11_board_reporting/084_board_reporting_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-023-cedar-finance/11_board_reporting/085_board_reporting_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-023-cedar-finance/11_board_reporting/086_board_reporting_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-023-cedar-finance/11_board_reporting/087_board_reporting_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-023-cedar-finance/11_board_reporting/088_board_reporting_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-023-cedar-finance/12_remediation/089_remediation_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-023-cedar-finance/12_remediation/090_remediation_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-023-cedar-finance/12_remediation/091_remediation_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-023-cedar-finance/12_remediation/092_remediation_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-023-cedar-finance/12_remediation/093_remediation_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-023-cedar-finance/12_remediation/094_remediation_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-023-cedar-finance/12_remediation/095_remediation_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-023-cedar-finance/12_remediation/096_remediation_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-023-cedar-finance/12_remediation/097_cedar_finance_impact_population.xlsx"], "gold_output": {"advice_markdown": "# Decision note — Cedar branch incentive investigation\n\n## Recommendation\n\nEscalate supported override patterns and repair the affected control population. The reconciled record supports 5 scoped actions and leaves 7 items on evidence hold.\n\nSelected option: `cedar-finance:scoped-evidence`.\n\n## Why this is the supported option\n\nCompare bonus batches, thresholds, access events, interviews, and expense support by employee and date. The effective approval matrix and corroborated override evidence govern a misconduct finding.\n\n## Supported actions\n\n### CBP-023-01 — off-channel communication (high)\n\ndelivery must use notices-cedar_community_finance@example.test under CB-IV-2603-R237; the only matched receipt used archive-lakefront_referral_partners@example.test under CB-IV-2603-E108. Identity resolves to ENT-023-1000, revision REV-2025.1 is current, and Samuel Kim is active with capacity 5.\n\nAction: Create exact case rows for proven overrides and hold interview-only allegations. Owner: Samuel Kim; due 2026-09-08.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_intake/001_intake_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/02_preservation/013_preservation_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/04_email_exports/025_email_exports_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/037_chat_exports_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/10_hr_records/073_hr_records_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/08_vendor_files/061_vendor_files_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_cedar_finance_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-023-05 — retaliation concern (high)\n\napproval must come from Leona Park under CB-IV-2603-R784; the effective approval record names Rafael Okafor under CB-IV-2603-E352. Identity resolves to ENT-023-1004, revision REV-2025.5 is current, and Dominic Alvarez is active with capacity 4.\n\nAction: Create exact case rows for proven overrides and hold interview-only allegations. Owner: Dominic Alvarez; due 2026-09-04.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_intake/005_intake_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/03_interviews/017_interviews_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/04_email_exports/029_email_exports_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/06_expenses/041_expenses_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_cedar_finance_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-023-06 — remediation ownership gap (critical)\n\nthe controlled population contains 172 records under CB-IV-2603-R610; the certification covers 141 records under CB-IV-2603-E235. Identity resolves to ENT-023-1005, revision REV-2025.6 is current, and Leona Park is active with capacity 2.\n\nAction: Create exact case rows for proven overrides and hold interview-only allegations. Owner: Leona Park; due 2026-09-03.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_intake/006_intake_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/03_interviews/018_interviews_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/04_email_exports/030_email_exports_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/06_expenses/042_expenses_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_cedar_finance_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-023-11 — badge-log inconsistency (high)\n\ncompletion is required by 2025-08-23 under CB-IV-2603-R749; the current event record shows completion on 2025-09-28 under CB-IV-2603-E402. Identity resolves to ENT-023-1010, revision REV-2025.4 is current, and Owen Delgado is active with capacity 5.\n\nAction: Create exact case rows for proven overrides and hold interview-only allegations. Owner: Owen Delgado; due 2026-09-07.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/02_preservation/011_preservation_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/03_interviews/023_interviews_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/035_chat_exports_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/06_expenses/047_expenses_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/08_vendor_files/059_vendor_files_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_cedar_finance_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-023-12 — hotline classification error (high)\n\nthe controlling threshold is 16% under CB-IV-2603-R961; the independently calculated result is 24% under CB-IV-2603-E256. Identity resolves to ENT-023-1011, revision REV-2025.5 is current, and Priya Raman is active with capacity 2.\n\nAction: Create exact case rows for proven overrides and hold interview-only allegations. Owner: Priya Raman; due 2026-09-06.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/02_preservation/012_preservation_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/03_interviews/024_interviews_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/036_chat_exports_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/06_expenses/048_expenses_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/08_vendor_files/060_vendor_files_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_cedar_finance_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n## Evidence holds\n\n- **CBP-023-02 — policy training lapse**: the operational record relies on a superseded control revision. Next evidence: an operational record using the current effective revision. Sources: `/workspace/documents/01_intake/002_intake_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/02_preservation/014_preservation_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/04_email_exports/026_email_exports_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/038_chat_exports_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_cedar_finance_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-023-03 — preservation delay**: two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key. Next evidence: an approved immutable entity crosswalk. Sources: `/workspace/documents/01_intake/003_intake_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/02_preservation/015_preservation_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/04_email_exports/027_email_exports_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/039_chat_exports_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_cedar_finance_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-023-04 — gift-policy threshold breach**: the current observation does not meet the operative trigger. Next evidence: a current observation that satisfies the operative trigger. Sources: `/workspace/documents/01_intake/004_intake_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/02_preservation/016_preservation_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/04_email_exports/028_email_exports_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/040_chat_exports_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/10_hr_records/076_hr_records_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/07_access_logs/052_access_logs_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_cedar_finance_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-023-07 — approval override**: two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key. Next evidence: an approved immutable entity crosswalk. Sources: `/workspace/documents/01_intake/007_intake_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/03_interviews/019_interviews_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/04_email_exports/031_email_exports_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/06_expenses/043_expenses_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_cedar_finance_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-023-08 — vendor due-diligence gap**: the current observation does not meet the operative trigger. Next evidence: a current observation that satisfies the operative trigger. Sources: `/workspace/documents/01_intake/008_intake_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/03_interviews/020_interviews_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/04_email_exports/032_email_exports_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/06_expenses/044_expenses_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_cedar_finance_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-023-09 — expense support deficiency**: the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective. Next evidence: effective approval and an active owner with remaining capacity. Sources: `/workspace/documents/02_preservation/009_preservation_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/03_interviews/021_interviews_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/033_chat_exports_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/06_expenses/045_expenses_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_cedar_finance_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-023-10 — split-purchase pattern**: the operational record relies on a superseded control revision. Next evidence: an operational record using the current effective revision. Sources: `/workspace/documents/02_preservation/010_preservation_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/03_interviews/022_interviews_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/034_chat_exports_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/06_expenses/046_expenses_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/11_board_reporting/082_board_reporting_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_cedar_finance_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n## Alternatives considered\n\n- `cedar-finance:shortcut` — Infer intent from amounts just below threshold without checking access or approval history.: Use a plausible summary or one source without completing the controlling joins.\n- `cedar-finance:blanket-hold` — Freeze the entire matter population: Treat supported actions and genuinely ambiguous records as if they were equally unresolved.\n\n## Assumptions and limits\n\nThis decision is limited to cb100-023-cedar-finance, the supplied synthetic records, and the matter state as of 2026-09-09. Similar names, stale revisions, and pending authority are not treated as proof.\n", "decision": {"actions": [{"determination": "delivery must use notices-cedar_community_finance@example.test under CB-IV-2603-R237; the only matched receipt used archive-lakefront_referral_partners@example.test under CB-IV-2603-E108. Identity resolves to ENT-023-1000, revision REV-2025.1 is current, and Samuel Kim is active with capacity 5.", "due_date": "2026-09-08", "id": "ACT-CBP-023-01", "identity_id": "ENT-023-1000", "issue": "off-channel communication", "owner": "Samuel Kim", "portfolio_key": "CBP-023-01", "recommended_action": "Create exact case rows for proven overrides and hold interview-only allegations. Owner: Samuel Kim; due 2026-09-08.", "severity": "high", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_intake/001_intake_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/02_preservation/013_preservation_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/04_email_exports/025_email_exports_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/037_chat_exports_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/10_hr_records/073_hr_records_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/08_vendor_files/061_vendor_files_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_cedar_finance_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "approval must come from Leona Park under CB-IV-2603-R784; the effective approval record names Rafael Okafor under CB-IV-2603-E352. Identity resolves to ENT-023-1004, revision REV-2025.5 is current, and Dominic Alvarez is active with capacity 4.", "due_date": "2026-09-04", "id": "ACT-CBP-023-05", "identity_id": "ENT-023-1004", "issue": "retaliation concern", "owner": "Dominic Alvarez", "portfolio_key": "CBP-023-05", "recommended_action": "Create exact case rows for proven overrides and hold interview-only allegations. Owner: Dominic Alvarez; due 2026-09-04.", "severity": "high", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_intake/005_intake_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/03_interviews/017_interviews_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/04_email_exports/029_email_exports_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/06_expenses/041_expenses_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_cedar_finance_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "the controlled population contains 172 records under CB-IV-2603-R610; the certification covers 141 records under CB-IV-2603-E235. Identity resolves to ENT-023-1005, revision REV-2025.6 is current, and Leona Park is active with capacity 2.", "due_date": "2026-09-03", "id": "ACT-CBP-023-06", "identity_id": "ENT-023-1005", "issue": "remediation ownership gap", "owner": "Leona Park", "portfolio_key": "CBP-023-06", "recommended_action": "Create exact case rows for proven overrides and hold interview-only allegations. Owner: Leona Park; due 2026-09-03.", "severity": "critical", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_intake/006_intake_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/03_interviews/018_interviews_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/04_email_exports/030_email_exports_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/06_expenses/042_expenses_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_cedar_finance_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "completion is required by 2025-08-23 under CB-IV-2603-R749; the current event record shows completion on 2025-09-28 under CB-IV-2603-E402. Identity resolves to ENT-023-1010, revision REV-2025.4 is current, and Owen Delgado is active with capacity 5.", "due_date": "2026-09-07", "id": "ACT-CBP-023-11", "identity_id": "ENT-023-1010", "issue": "badge-log inconsistency", "owner": "Owen Delgado", "portfolio_key": "CBP-023-11", "recommended_action": "Create exact case rows for proven overrides and hold interview-only allegations. Owner: Owen Delgado; due 2026-09-07.", "severity": "high", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_preservation/011_preservation_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/03_interviews/023_interviews_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/035_chat_exports_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/06_expenses/047_expenses_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/08_vendor_files/059_vendor_files_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_cedar_finance_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "the controlling threshold is 16% under CB-IV-2603-R961; the independently calculated result is 24% under CB-IV-2603-E256. Identity resolves to ENT-023-1011, revision REV-2025.5 is current, and Priya Raman is active with capacity 2.", "due_date": "2026-09-06", "id": "ACT-CBP-023-12", "identity_id": "ENT-023-1011", "issue": "hotline classification error", "owner": "Priya Raman", "portfolio_key": "CBP-023-12", "recommended_action": "Create exact case rows for proven overrides and hold interview-only allegations. Owner: Priya Raman; due 2026-09-06.", "severity": "high", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_preservation/012_preservation_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/03_interviews/024_interviews_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/036_chat_exports_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/06_expenses/048_expenses_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/08_vendor_files/060_vendor_files_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_cedar_finance_impact_population.xlsx"]}], "as_of": "2026-09-09", "decision": {"alternatives_considered": ["cedar-finance:shortcut", "cedar-finance:blanket-hold"], "question": "Were Cedar's referral bonuses deliberately structured around approval controls, and what remediation is warranted?", "rationale": "The four-part causal test supports 5 scoped actions and leaves 7 records on evidence hold. The effective approval matrix and corroborated override evidence govern a misconduct finding.", "recommendation": "Escalate supported override patterns and repair the affected control population.", "selected_option_id": "cedar-finance:scoped-evidence"}, "holds": [{"id": "HOLD-CBP-023-02", "issue": "policy training lapse", "portfolio_key": "CBP-023-02", "reason": "the operational record relies on a superseded control revision", "required_next_evidence": "an operational record using the current effective revision", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_intake/002_intake_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/02_preservation/014_preservation_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/04_email_exports/026_email_exports_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/038_chat_exports_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_cedar_finance_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-023-03", "issue": "preservation delay", "portfolio_key": "CBP-023-03", "reason": "two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key", "required_next_evidence": "an approved immutable entity crosswalk", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_intake/003_intake_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/02_preservation/015_preservation_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/04_email_exports/027_email_exports_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/039_chat_exports_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_cedar_finance_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-023-04", "issue": "gift-policy threshold breach", "portfolio_key": "CBP-023-04", "reason": "the current observation does not meet the operative trigger", "required_next_evidence": "a current observation that satisfies the operative trigger", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_intake/004_intake_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/02_preservation/016_preservation_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/04_email_exports/028_email_exports_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/040_chat_exports_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/10_hr_records/076_hr_records_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/07_access_logs/052_access_logs_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_cedar_finance_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-023-07", "issue": "approval override", "portfolio_key": "CBP-023-07", "reason": "two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key", "required_next_evidence": "an approved immutable entity crosswalk", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_intake/007_intake_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/03_interviews/019_interviews_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/04_email_exports/031_email_exports_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/06_expenses/043_expenses_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_cedar_finance_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-023-08", "issue": "vendor due-diligence gap", "portfolio_key": "CBP-023-08", "reason": "the current observation does not meet the operative trigger", "required_next_evidence": "a current observation that satisfies the operative trigger", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_intake/008_intake_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/03_interviews/020_interviews_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/04_email_exports/032_email_exports_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/06_expenses/044_expenses_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_cedar_finance_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-023-09", "issue": "expense support deficiency", "portfolio_key": "CBP-023-09", "reason": "the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective", "required_next_evidence": "effective approval and an active owner with remaining capacity", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_preservation/009_preservation_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/03_interviews/021_interviews_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/033_chat_exports_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/06_expenses/045_expenses_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_cedar_finance_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-023-10", "issue": "split-purchase pattern", "portfolio_key": "CBP-023-10", "reason": "the operational record relies on a superseded control revision", "required_next_evidence": "an operational record using the current effective revision", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_preservation/010_preservation_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/03_interviews/022_interviews_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/034_chat_exports_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/06_expenses/046_expenses_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/11_board_reporting/082_board_reporting_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_cedar_finance_impact_population.xlsx"]}], "matter_number": "CB-IV-2603", "prepared_for": "Cedar Community Finance", "schema_version": "counselbench.decision.v3", "task_id": "cb100-023-cedar-finance"}, "matter_register": {"matter_number": "CB-IV-2603", "rows": [{"decision_option_id": "cedar-finance:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-08", "issue": "off-channel communication", "matter_number": "CB-IV-2603", "owner": "Samuel Kim", "portfolio_key": "CBP-023-01", "row_id": "REG-CBP-023-01", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_intake/001_intake_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/02_preservation/013_preservation_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/04_email_exports/025_email_exports_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/037_chat_exports_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/10_hr_records/073_hr_records_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/08_vendor_files/061_vendor_files_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_cedar_finance_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "cedar-finance:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "the operational record relies on a superseded control revision", "issue": "policy training lapse", "matter_number": "CB-IV-2603", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-023-02", "row_id": "REG-CBP-023-02", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_intake/002_intake_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/02_preservation/014_preservation_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/04_email_exports/026_email_exports_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/038_chat_exports_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_cedar_finance_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "cedar-finance:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key", "issue": "preservation delay", "matter_number": "CB-IV-2603", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-023-03", "row_id": "REG-CBP-023-03", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_intake/003_intake_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/02_preservation/015_preservation_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/04_email_exports/027_email_exports_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/039_chat_exports_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_cedar_finance_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "cedar-finance:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "the current observation does not meet the operative trigger", "issue": "gift-policy threshold breach", "matter_number": "CB-IV-2603", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-023-04", "row_id": "REG-CBP-023-04", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_intake/004_intake_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/02_preservation/016_preservation_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/04_email_exports/028_email_exports_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/040_chat_exports_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/10_hr_records/076_hr_records_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/07_access_logs/052_access_logs_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_cedar_finance_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "cedar-finance:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-04", "issue": "retaliation concern", "matter_number": "CB-IV-2603", "owner": "Dominic Alvarez", "portfolio_key": "CBP-023-05", "row_id": "REG-CBP-023-05", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_intake/005_intake_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/03_interviews/017_interviews_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/04_email_exports/029_email_exports_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/06_expenses/041_expenses_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_cedar_finance_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "cedar-finance:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-03", "issue": "remediation ownership gap", "matter_number": "CB-IV-2603", "owner": "Leona Park", "portfolio_key": "CBP-023-06", "row_id": "REG-CBP-023-06", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_intake/006_intake_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/03_interviews/018_interviews_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/04_email_exports/030_email_exports_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/06_expenses/042_expenses_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_cedar_finance_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "cedar-finance:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key", "issue": "approval override", "matter_number": "CB-IV-2603", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-023-07", "row_id": "REG-CBP-023-07", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_intake/007_intake_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/03_interviews/019_interviews_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/04_email_exports/031_email_exports_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/06_expenses/043_expenses_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_cedar_finance_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "cedar-finance:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "the current observation does not meet the operative trigger", "issue": "vendor due-diligence gap", "matter_number": "CB-IV-2603", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-023-08", "row_id": "REG-CBP-023-08", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_intake/008_intake_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/03_interviews/020_interviews_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/04_email_exports/032_email_exports_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/06_expenses/044_expenses_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_cedar_finance_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "cedar-finance:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective", "issue": "expense support deficiency", "matter_number": "CB-IV-2603", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-023-09", "row_id": "REG-CBP-023-09", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_preservation/009_preservation_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/03_interviews/021_interviews_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/033_chat_exports_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/06_expenses/045_expenses_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_cedar_finance_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "cedar-finance:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "the operational record relies on a superseded control revision", "issue": "split-purchase pattern", "matter_number": "CB-IV-2603", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-023-10", "row_id": "REG-CBP-023-10", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_preservation/010_preservation_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/03_interviews/022_interviews_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/034_chat_exports_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/06_expenses/046_expenses_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/11_board_reporting/082_board_reporting_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_cedar_finance_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "cedar-finance:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-07", "issue": "badge-log inconsistency", "matter_number": "CB-IV-2603", "owner": "Owen Delgado", "portfolio_key": "CBP-023-11", "row_id": "REG-CBP-023-11", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_preservation/011_preservation_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/03_interviews/023_interviews_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/035_chat_exports_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/06_expenses/047_expenses_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/08_vendor_files/059_vendor_files_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_cedar_finance_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "cedar-finance:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-06", "issue": "hotline classification error", "matter_number": "CB-IV-2603", "owner": "Priya Raman", "portfolio_key": "CBP-023-12", "row_id": "REG-CBP-023-12", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_preservation/012_preservation_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/03_interviews/024_interviews_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/036_chat_exports_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/06_expenses/048_expenses_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/08_vendor_files/060_vendor_files_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_cedar_finance_impact_population.xlsx"]}], "schema_version": "counselbench.matter-register.v3", "task_id": "cb100-023-cedar-finance"}}, "metadata": {"benchmark": "CounselBench-100", "code_license": "Apache-2.0", "data_license": "CC-BY-4.0", "deadline": "2026-09-09", "document_count": 97, "evidence_holds": 7, "jurisdiction": "Wisconsin", "matter_number": "CB-IV-2603", "mcp_commit": "9a96ea6e5913736f92b88345bf51caeaaa8e719f", "mcp_package": "@modelcontextprotocol/server-filesystem@2026.7.10", "practice_area": "internal-investigations", "reference_tool_calls": 79, "required_evidence_reads": 57, "supported_actions": 5, "synthetic": true, "venue": "Milwaukee County, Wisconsin", "version": "3.1.0"}, "prompt": "A late record changed the picture this morning. Were Cedar's referral bonuses deliberately structured around approval controls, and what remediation is warranted? A branch posted referral bonuses just below secondary-approval thresholds while employee interviews conflict with access and expense records. The team needs the call by 2026-09-09. Make the matter record usable by operations after your review, but do not turn ambiguity into an accusation or obligation.", "rubric": {"criteria": [{"category": "investigation", "description": "Inventory the production and use targeted searches to locate records across native formats.", "id": "investigation.discover_production"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Complete every task-specific identity, authority, operations, and approval read before the first state transition.", "id": "investigation.read_before_write"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Inspect designated source metadata before relying on those records.", "id": "investigation.custody_before_write"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "Select the supported option 'cedar-finance:scoped-evidence' after applying the four-part test.", "id": "decision.selected_option"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "Identify both rejected approaches and explain why a one-source shortcut and a blanket hold are wrong.", "id": "decision.alternatives"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-023-01 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_intake/001_intake_source_export.md rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-023-01.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_preservation/013_preservation_source_export.json for off-channel communication.", "id": "investigation.CBP-023-01.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_email_exports/025_email_exports_source_export.md to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-023-01.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/037_chat_exports_source_export.json.", "id": "investigation.CBP-023-01.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-023-01 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-023-01.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-023-01 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-023-01.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-023-02 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_intake/002_intake_source_export.txt rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-023-02.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_preservation/014_preservation_source_export.xml for policy training lapse.", "id": "investigation.CBP-023-02.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_email_exports/026_email_exports_source_export.txt to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-023-02.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/038_chat_exports_source_export.xml.", "id": "investigation.CBP-023-02.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-023-02 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is the operational record relies on a superseded control revision.", "id": "decision.CBP-023-02.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-023-02 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-023-02.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-023-03 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_intake/003_intake_source_export.eml rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-023-03.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_preservation/015_preservation_source_export.html for preservation delay.", "id": "investigation.CBP-023-03.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_email_exports/027_email_exports_source_export.eml to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-023-03.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/039_chat_exports_source_export.html.", "id": "investigation.CBP-023-03.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-023-03 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key.", "id": "decision.CBP-023-03.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-023-03 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-023-03.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-023-04 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_intake/004_intake_source_export.csv rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-023-04.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_preservation/016_preservation_source_export.pdf for gift-policy threshold breach.", "id": "investigation.CBP-023-04.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_email_exports/028_email_exports_source_export.csv to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-023-04.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/040_chat_exports_source_export.pdf.", "id": "investigation.CBP-023-04.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-023-04 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is the current observation does not meet the operative trigger.", "id": "decision.CBP-023-04.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-023-04 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-023-04.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-023-05 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_intake/005_intake_source_export.json rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-023-05.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_interviews/017_interviews_source_export.md for retaliation concern.", "id": "investigation.CBP-023-05.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_email_exports/029_email_exports_source_export.json to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-023-05.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_expenses/041_expenses_source_export.md.", "id": "investigation.CBP-023-05.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-023-05 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-023-05.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-023-05 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-023-05.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-023-06 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_intake/006_intake_source_export.xml rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-023-06.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_interviews/018_interviews_source_export.txt for remediation ownership gap.", "id": "investigation.CBP-023-06.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_email_exports/030_email_exports_source_export.xml to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-023-06.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_expenses/042_expenses_source_export.txt.", "id": "investigation.CBP-023-06.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-023-06 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-023-06.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-023-06 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-023-06.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-023-07 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_intake/007_intake_source_export.html rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-023-07.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_interviews/019_interviews_source_export.eml for approval override.", "id": "investigation.CBP-023-07.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_email_exports/031_email_exports_source_export.html to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-023-07.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_expenses/043_expenses_source_export.eml.", "id": "investigation.CBP-023-07.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-023-07 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key.", "id": "decision.CBP-023-07.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-023-07 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-023-07.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-023-08 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_intake/008_intake_source_export.pdf rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-023-08.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_interviews/020_interviews_source_export.csv for vendor due-diligence gap.", "id": "investigation.CBP-023-08.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_email_exports/032_email_exports_source_export.pdf to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-023-08.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_expenses/044_expenses_source_export.csv.", "id": "investigation.CBP-023-08.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-023-08 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is the current observation does not meet the operative trigger.", "id": "decision.CBP-023-08.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-023-08 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-023-08.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-023-09 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_preservation/009_preservation_source_export.md rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-023-09.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_interviews/021_interviews_source_export.json for expense support deficiency.", "id": "investigation.CBP-023-09.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/033_chat_exports_source_export.md to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-023-09.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_expenses/045_expenses_source_export.json.", "id": "investigation.CBP-023-09.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-023-09 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective.", "id": "decision.CBP-023-09.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-023-09 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-023-09.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-023-10 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_preservation/010_preservation_source_export.txt rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-023-10.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_interviews/022_interviews_source_export.xml for split-purchase pattern.", "id": "investigation.CBP-023-10.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/034_chat_exports_source_export.txt to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-023-10.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_expenses/046_expenses_source_export.xml.", "id": "investigation.CBP-023-10.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-023-10 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is the operational record relies on a superseded control revision.", "id": "decision.CBP-023-10.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-023-10 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-023-10.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-023-11 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_preservation/011_preservation_source_export.eml rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-023-11.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_interviews/023_interviews_source_export.html for badge-log inconsistency.", "id": "investigation.CBP-023-11.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/035_chat_exports_source_export.eml to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-023-11.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_expenses/047_expenses_source_export.html.", "id": "investigation.CBP-023-11.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-023-11 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-023-11.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-023-11 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-023-11.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-023-12 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_preservation/012_preservation_source_export.csv rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-023-12.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_interviews/024_interviews_source_export.pdf for hotline classification error.", "id": "investigation.CBP-023-12.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/036_chat_exports_source_export.csv to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-023-12.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_expenses/048_expenses_source_export.pdf.", "id": "investigation.CBP-023-12.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-023-12 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-023-12.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-023-12 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-023-12.register"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Write the exact selected option, supported action population, evidence-hold population, facts, owners, deadlines, and citations.", "id": "state.exact_decision"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create one exact register row per portfolio key with no extra, missing, or modified row.", "id": "state.exact_register"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Leave only the three approved deliverables and perform no extra state-changing write.", "id": "state.write_scope_containment"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Read back decision.json, matter-register.json, and advice.md after their final writes.", "id": "state.postwrite_readback"}, {"category": "answer", "description": "Explain the selected recommendation, supported actions, holds, alternatives, and limitations with exact source anchors.", "id": "answer.decision_note"}], "decision_options": [{"approach": "Use a plausible summary or one source without completing the controlling joins.", "id": "cedar-finance:shortcut", "label": "Infer intent from amounts just below threshold without checking access or approval history."}, {"approach": "Treat supported actions and genuinely ambiguous records as if they were equally unresolved.", "id": "cedar-finance:blanket-hold", "label": "Freeze the entire matter population"}, {"approach": "Apply the exact identity, current-state, authority, and revision test. Create exact case rows for proven overrides and hold interview-only allegations.", "id": "cedar-finance:scoped-evidence", "label": "Escalate supported override patterns and repair the affected control population."}], "evaluation_narrative": {"authority": "The effective approval matrix and corroborated override evidence govern a misconduct finding.", "observation": "Compare bonus batches, thresholds, access events, interviews, and expense support by employee and date.", "question": "Were Cedar's referral bonuses deliberately structured around approval controls, and what remediation is warranted?", "register_action": "Create exact case rows for proven overrides and hold interview-only allegations."}, "gates": ["all_required_evidence_precedes_first_write", "decision_criteria_complete", "register_state_exact", "write_scope_contained", "all_outputs_verified_by_readback"], "metadata_checks": 9, "metric": "weighted_criteria_score", "minimum_tool_calls": 79, "required_deliverables": ["decision.json", "matter-register.json", "advice.md"], "required_document_reads": 57, "type": "deterministic", "weights": {"advice": 0.15, "decision": 0.35, "investigation": 0.25, "state": 0.25}}, "task_id": "cb100-023-cedar-finance", "task_name": "Cedar branch incentive investigation", "world_id": "counselbench-filesystem-mcp-v3"}
+{"context_files": ["task_files/cb100-024-dovetail-aerospace/01_intake/001_intake_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-024-dovetail-aerospace/01_intake/002_intake_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-024-dovetail-aerospace/01_intake/003_intake_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-024-dovetail-aerospace/01_intake/004_intake_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-024-dovetail-aerospace/01_intake/005_intake_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-024-dovetail-aerospace/01_intake/006_intake_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-024-dovetail-aerospace/01_intake/007_intake_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-024-dovetail-aerospace/01_intake/008_intake_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-024-dovetail-aerospace/02_preservation/009_preservation_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-024-dovetail-aerospace/02_preservation/010_preservation_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-024-dovetail-aerospace/02_preservation/011_preservation_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-024-dovetail-aerospace/02_preservation/012_preservation_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-024-dovetail-aerospace/02_preservation/013_preservation_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-024-dovetail-aerospace/02_preservation/014_preservation_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-024-dovetail-aerospace/02_preservation/015_preservation_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-024-dovetail-aerospace/02_preservation/016_preservation_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-024-dovetail-aerospace/03_interviews/017_interviews_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-024-dovetail-aerospace/03_interviews/018_interviews_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-024-dovetail-aerospace/03_interviews/019_interviews_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-024-dovetail-aerospace/03_interviews/020_interviews_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-024-dovetail-aerospace/03_interviews/021_interviews_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-024-dovetail-aerospace/03_interviews/022_interviews_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-024-dovetail-aerospace/03_interviews/023_interviews_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-024-dovetail-aerospace/03_interviews/024_interviews_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-024-dovetail-aerospace/04_email_exports/025_email_exports_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-024-dovetail-aerospace/04_email_exports/026_email_exports_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-024-dovetail-aerospace/04_email_exports/027_email_exports_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-024-dovetail-aerospace/04_email_exports/028_email_exports_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-024-dovetail-aerospace/04_email_exports/029_email_exports_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-024-dovetail-aerospace/04_email_exports/030_email_exports_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-024-dovetail-aerospace/04_email_exports/031_email_exports_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-024-dovetail-aerospace/04_email_exports/032_email_exports_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-024-dovetail-aerospace/05_chat_exports/033_chat_exports_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-024-dovetail-aerospace/05_chat_exports/034_chat_exports_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-024-dovetail-aerospace/05_chat_exports/035_chat_exports_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-024-dovetail-aerospace/05_chat_exports/036_chat_exports_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-024-dovetail-aerospace/05_chat_exports/037_chat_exports_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-024-dovetail-aerospace/05_chat_exports/038_chat_exports_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-024-dovetail-aerospace/05_chat_exports/039_chat_exports_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-024-dovetail-aerospace/05_chat_exports/040_chat_exports_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-024-dovetail-aerospace/06_expenses/041_expenses_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-024-dovetail-aerospace/06_expenses/042_expenses_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-024-dovetail-aerospace/06_expenses/043_expenses_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-024-dovetail-aerospace/06_expenses/044_expenses_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-024-dovetail-aerospace/06_expenses/045_expenses_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-024-dovetail-aerospace/06_expenses/046_expenses_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-024-dovetail-aerospace/06_expenses/047_expenses_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-024-dovetail-aerospace/06_expenses/048_expenses_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-024-dovetail-aerospace/07_access_logs/049_access_logs_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-024-dovetail-aerospace/07_access_logs/050_access_logs_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-024-dovetail-aerospace/07_access_logs/051_access_logs_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-024-dovetail-aerospace/07_access_logs/052_access_logs_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-024-dovetail-aerospace/07_access_logs/053_access_logs_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-024-dovetail-aerospace/07_access_logs/054_access_logs_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-024-dovetail-aerospace/07_access_logs/055_access_logs_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-024-dovetail-aerospace/07_access_logs/056_access_logs_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-024-dovetail-aerospace/08_vendor_files/057_vendor_files_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-024-dovetail-aerospace/08_vendor_files/058_vendor_files_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-024-dovetail-aerospace/08_vendor_files/059_vendor_files_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-024-dovetail-aerospace/08_vendor_files/060_vendor_files_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-024-dovetail-aerospace/08_vendor_files/061_vendor_files_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-024-dovetail-aerospace/08_vendor_files/062_vendor_files_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-024-dovetail-aerospace/08_vendor_files/063_vendor_files_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-024-dovetail-aerospace/08_vendor_files/064_vendor_files_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-024-dovetail-aerospace/09_policies/065_policies_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-024-dovetail-aerospace/09_policies/066_policies_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-024-dovetail-aerospace/09_policies/067_policies_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-024-dovetail-aerospace/09_policies/068_policies_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-024-dovetail-aerospace/09_policies/069_policies_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-024-dovetail-aerospace/09_policies/070_policies_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-024-dovetail-aerospace/09_policies/071_policies_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-024-dovetail-aerospace/09_policies/072_policies_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-024-dovetail-aerospace/10_hr_records/073_hr_records_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-024-dovetail-aerospace/10_hr_records/074_hr_records_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-024-dovetail-aerospace/10_hr_records/075_hr_records_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-024-dovetail-aerospace/10_hr_records/076_hr_records_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-024-dovetail-aerospace/10_hr_records/077_hr_records_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-024-dovetail-aerospace/10_hr_records/078_hr_records_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-024-dovetail-aerospace/10_hr_records/079_hr_records_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-024-dovetail-aerospace/10_hr_records/080_hr_records_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-024-dovetail-aerospace/11_board_reporting/081_board_reporting_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-024-dovetail-aerospace/11_board_reporting/082_board_reporting_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-024-dovetail-aerospace/11_board_reporting/083_board_reporting_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-024-dovetail-aerospace/11_board_reporting/084_board_reporting_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-024-dovetail-aerospace/11_board_reporting/085_board_reporting_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-024-dovetail-aerospace/11_board_reporting/086_board_reporting_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-024-dovetail-aerospace/11_board_reporting/087_board_reporting_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-024-dovetail-aerospace/11_board_reporting/088_board_reporting_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-024-dovetail-aerospace/12_remediation/089_remediation_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-024-dovetail-aerospace/12_remediation/090_remediation_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-024-dovetail-aerospace/12_remediation/091_remediation_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-024-dovetail-aerospace/12_remediation/092_remediation_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-024-dovetail-aerospace/12_remediation/093_remediation_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-024-dovetail-aerospace/12_remediation/094_remediation_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-024-dovetail-aerospace/12_remediation/095_remediation_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-024-dovetail-aerospace/12_remediation/096_remediation_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-024-dovetail-aerospace/12_remediation/097_dovetail_aerospace_impact_population.xlsx"], "gold_output": {"advice_markdown": "# Decision note — Dovetail export-controls inquiry\n\n## Recommendation\n\nEscalate supported transfers and remediate preservation gaps without overstating unverified access. The reconciled record supports 7 scoped actions and leaves 5 items on evidence hold.\n\nSelected option: `dovetail-aerospace:scoped-evidence`.\n\n## Why this is the supported option\n\nJoin file-access logs, consultant identity, jurisdiction, screening results, and account-deactivation timing. Export scope, screening requirements, and legal-hold timing must all apply to the same data and person.\n\n## Supported actions\n\n### CBP-024-01 — deleted-message anomaly (low)\n\nthe controlled population contains 131 records under CB-IV-2604-R619; the certification covers 122 records under CB-IV-2604-E183. Identity resolves to ENT-024-1000, revision REV-2026.1 is current, and Nora Chen is active with capacity 2.\n\nAction: Register proven transfer and hold failures; quarantine device or identity mismatches. Owner: Nora Chen; due 2026-09-12.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_intake/001_intake_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/02_preservation/013_preservation_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/04_email_exports/025_email_exports_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/037_chat_exports_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_dovetail_aerospace_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-024-04 — off-channel communication (medium)\n\ndelivery must use notices-dovetail_aerospace_components@example.test under CB-IV-2604-R335; the only matched receipt used archive-orion_bridge_consulting@example.test under CB-IV-2604-E802. Identity resolves to ENT-024-1003, revision REV-2026.4 is current, and Samuel Kim is active with capacity 2.\n\nAction: Register proven transfer and hold failures; quarantine device or identity mismatches. Owner: Samuel Kim; due 2026-09-09.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_intake/004_intake_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/02_preservation/016_preservation_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/04_email_exports/028_email_exports_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/040_chat_exports_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/08_vendor_files/064_vendor_files_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/11_board_reporting/088_board_reporting_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_dovetail_aerospace_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-024-06 — preservation delay (medium)\n\ncompletion is required by 2025-05-01 under CB-IV-2604-R155; the current event record shows completion on 2025-05-11 under CB-IV-2604-E526. Identity resolves to ENT-024-1005, revision REV-2026.6 is current, and Adrian Mensah is active with capacity 5.\n\nAction: Register proven transfer and hold failures; quarantine device or identity mismatches. Owner: Adrian Mensah; due 2026-09-07.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_intake/006_intake_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/03_interviews/018_interviews_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/04_email_exports/030_email_exports_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/06_expenses/042_expenses_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_dovetail_aerospace_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-024-08 — retaliation concern (low)\n\napproval must come from Farah Ibrahim under CB-IV-2604-R745; the effective approval record names Henry Cho under CB-IV-2604-E720. Identity resolves to ENT-024-1007, revision REV-2026.1 is current, and Dominic Alvarez is active with capacity 4.\n\nAction: Register proven transfer and hold failures; quarantine device or identity mismatches. Owner: Dominic Alvarez; due 2026-09-05.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_intake/008_intake_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/03_interviews/020_interviews_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/04_email_exports/032_email_exports_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/06_expenses/044_expenses_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/09_policies/068_policies_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/10_hr_records/080_hr_records_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_dovetail_aerospace_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-024-09 — remediation ownership gap (medium)\n\nthe controlled population contains 189 records under CB-IV-2604-R357; the certification covers 173 records under CB-IV-2604-E326. Identity resolves to ENT-024-1008, revision REV-2026.2 is current, and Leona Park is active with capacity 4.\n\nAction: Register proven transfer and hold failures; quarantine device or identity mismatches. Owner: Leona Park; due 2026-09-04.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/02_preservation/009_preservation_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/03_interviews/021_interviews_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/033_chat_exports_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/06_expenses/045_expenses_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/12_remediation/093_remediation_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/11_board_reporting/081_board_reporting_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_dovetail_aerospace_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-024-10 — approval override (critical)\n\nthe permission is limited to Fairfax County, Virginia under CB-IV-2604-R697; the matched activity occurred in Virginia under CB-IV-2604-E611. Identity resolves to ENT-024-1009, revision REV-2026.3 is current, and Henry Cho is active with capacity 5.\n\nAction: Register proven transfer and hold failures; quarantine device or identity mismatches. Owner: Henry Cho; due 2026-09-12.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/02_preservation/010_preservation_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/03_interviews/022_interviews_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/034_chat_exports_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/06_expenses/046_expenses_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/09_policies/070_policies_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/08_vendor_files/058_vendor_files_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_dovetail_aerospace_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-024-11 — vendor due-diligence gap (high)\n\nthe operative cap is $5,722,000.00 under CB-IV-2604-R719; the matched ledger population totals $5,815,119.00 under CB-IV-2604-E612. Identity resolves to ENT-024-1010, revision REV-2026.4 is current, and Maya Ellison is active with capacity 3.\n\nAction: Register proven transfer and hold failures; quarantine device or identity mismatches. Owner: Maya Ellison; due 2026-09-11.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/02_preservation/011_preservation_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/03_interviews/023_interviews_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/035_chat_exports_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/06_expenses/047_expenses_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_dovetail_aerospace_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n## Evidence holds\n\n- **CBP-024-02 — board-reporting omission**: two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key. Next evidence: an approved immutable entity crosswalk. Sources: `/workspace/documents/01_intake/002_intake_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/02_preservation/014_preservation_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/04_email_exports/026_email_exports_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/038_chat_exports_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/08_vendor_files/062_vendor_files_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/11_board_reporting/086_board_reporting_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_dovetail_aerospace_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-024-03 — interview timeline conflict**: the current observation does not meet the operative trigger. Next evidence: a current observation that satisfies the operative trigger. Sources: `/workspace/documents/01_intake/003_intake_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/02_preservation/015_preservation_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/04_email_exports/027_email_exports_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/039_chat_exports_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/08_vendor_files/063_vendor_files_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_dovetail_aerospace_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-024-05 — policy training lapse**: the operational record relies on a superseded control revision. Next evidence: an operational record using the current effective revision. Sources: `/workspace/documents/01_intake/005_intake_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/03_interviews/017_interviews_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/04_email_exports/029_email_exports_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/06_expenses/041_expenses_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/07_access_logs/053_access_logs_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_dovetail_aerospace_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-024-07 — gift-policy threshold breach**: the current observation does not meet the operative trigger. Next evidence: a current observation that satisfies the operative trigger. Sources: `/workspace/documents/01_intake/007_intake_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/03_interviews/019_interviews_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/04_email_exports/031_email_exports_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/06_expenses/043_expenses_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_dovetail_aerospace_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-024-12 — expense support deficiency**: the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective. Next evidence: effective approval and an active owner with remaining capacity. Sources: `/workspace/documents/02_preservation/012_preservation_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/03_interviews/024_interviews_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/036_chat_exports_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/06_expenses/048_expenses_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/12_remediation/096_remediation_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_dovetail_aerospace_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n## Alternatives considered\n\n- `dovetail-aerospace:blanket-hold` — Freeze the entire matter population: Treat supported actions and genuinely ambiguous records as if they were equally unresolved.\n- `dovetail-aerospace:shortcut` — Treat every overseas login as an export violation.: Use a plausible summary or one source without completing the controlling joins.\n\n## Assumptions and limits\n\nThis decision is limited to cb100-024-dovetail-aerospace, the supplied synthetic records, and the matter state as of 2026-09-13. Similar names, stale revisions, and pending authority are not treated as proof.\n", "decision": {"actions": [{"determination": "the controlled population contains 131 records under CB-IV-2604-R619; the certification covers 122 records under CB-IV-2604-E183. Identity resolves to ENT-024-1000, revision REV-2026.1 is current, and Nora Chen is active with capacity 2.", "due_date": "2026-09-12", "id": "ACT-CBP-024-01", "identity_id": "ENT-024-1000", "issue": "deleted-message anomaly", "owner": "Nora Chen", "portfolio_key": "CBP-024-01", "recommended_action": "Register proven transfer and hold failures; quarantine device or identity mismatches. Owner: Nora Chen; due 2026-09-12.", "severity": "low", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_intake/001_intake_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/02_preservation/013_preservation_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/04_email_exports/025_email_exports_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/037_chat_exports_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_dovetail_aerospace_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "delivery must use notices-dovetail_aerospace_components@example.test under CB-IV-2604-R335; the only matched receipt used archive-orion_bridge_consulting@example.test under CB-IV-2604-E802. Identity resolves to ENT-024-1003, revision REV-2026.4 is current, and Samuel Kim is active with capacity 2.", "due_date": "2026-09-09", "id": "ACT-CBP-024-04", "identity_id": "ENT-024-1003", "issue": "off-channel communication", "owner": "Samuel Kim", "portfolio_key": "CBP-024-04", "recommended_action": "Register proven transfer and hold failures; quarantine device or identity mismatches. Owner: Samuel Kim; due 2026-09-09.", "severity": "medium", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_intake/004_intake_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/02_preservation/016_preservation_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/04_email_exports/028_email_exports_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/040_chat_exports_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/08_vendor_files/064_vendor_files_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/11_board_reporting/088_board_reporting_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_dovetail_aerospace_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "completion is required by 2025-05-01 under CB-IV-2604-R155; the current event record shows completion on 2025-05-11 under CB-IV-2604-E526. Identity resolves to ENT-024-1005, revision REV-2026.6 is current, and Adrian Mensah is active with capacity 5.", "due_date": "2026-09-07", "id": "ACT-CBP-024-06", "identity_id": "ENT-024-1005", "issue": "preservation delay", "owner": "Adrian Mensah", "portfolio_key": "CBP-024-06", "recommended_action": "Register proven transfer and hold failures; quarantine device or identity mismatches. Owner: Adrian Mensah; due 2026-09-07.", "severity": "medium", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_intake/006_intake_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/03_interviews/018_interviews_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/04_email_exports/030_email_exports_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/06_expenses/042_expenses_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_dovetail_aerospace_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "approval must come from Farah Ibrahim under CB-IV-2604-R745; the effective approval record names Henry Cho under CB-IV-2604-E720. Identity resolves to ENT-024-1007, revision REV-2026.1 is current, and Dominic Alvarez is active with capacity 4.", "due_date": "2026-09-05", "id": "ACT-CBP-024-08", "identity_id": "ENT-024-1007", "issue": "retaliation concern", "owner": "Dominic Alvarez", "portfolio_key": "CBP-024-08", "recommended_action": "Register proven transfer and hold failures; quarantine device or identity mismatches. Owner: Dominic Alvarez; due 2026-09-05.", "severity": "low", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_intake/008_intake_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/03_interviews/020_interviews_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/04_email_exports/032_email_exports_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/06_expenses/044_expenses_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/09_policies/068_policies_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/10_hr_records/080_hr_records_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_dovetail_aerospace_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "the controlled population contains 189 records under CB-IV-2604-R357; the certification covers 173 records under CB-IV-2604-E326. Identity resolves to ENT-024-1008, revision REV-2026.2 is current, and Leona Park is active with capacity 4.", "due_date": "2026-09-04", "id": "ACT-CBP-024-09", "identity_id": "ENT-024-1008", "issue": "remediation ownership gap", "owner": "Leona Park", "portfolio_key": "CBP-024-09", "recommended_action": "Register proven transfer and hold failures; quarantine device or identity mismatches. Owner: Leona Park; due 2026-09-04.", "severity": "medium", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_preservation/009_preservation_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/03_interviews/021_interviews_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/033_chat_exports_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/06_expenses/045_expenses_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/093_remediation_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/11_board_reporting/081_board_reporting_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_dovetail_aerospace_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "the permission is limited to Fairfax County, Virginia under CB-IV-2604-R697; the matched activity occurred in Virginia under CB-IV-2604-E611. Identity resolves to ENT-024-1009, revision REV-2026.3 is current, and Henry Cho is active with capacity 5.", "due_date": "2026-09-12", "id": "ACT-CBP-024-10", "identity_id": "ENT-024-1009", "issue": "approval override", "owner": "Henry Cho", "portfolio_key": "CBP-024-10", "recommended_action": "Register proven transfer and hold failures; quarantine device or identity mismatches. Owner: Henry Cho; due 2026-09-12.", "severity": "critical", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_preservation/010_preservation_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/03_interviews/022_interviews_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/034_chat_exports_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/06_expenses/046_expenses_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/09_policies/070_policies_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/08_vendor_files/058_vendor_files_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_dovetail_aerospace_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "the operative cap is $5,722,000.00 under CB-IV-2604-R719; the matched ledger population totals $5,815,119.00 under CB-IV-2604-E612. Identity resolves to ENT-024-1010, revision REV-2026.4 is current, and Maya Ellison is active with capacity 3.", "due_date": "2026-09-11", "id": "ACT-CBP-024-11", "identity_id": "ENT-024-1010", "issue": "vendor due-diligence gap", "owner": "Maya Ellison", "portfolio_key": "CBP-024-11", "recommended_action": "Register proven transfer and hold failures; quarantine device or identity mismatches. Owner: Maya Ellison; due 2026-09-11.", "severity": "high", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_preservation/011_preservation_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/03_interviews/023_interviews_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/035_chat_exports_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/06_expenses/047_expenses_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_dovetail_aerospace_impact_population.xlsx"]}], "as_of": "2026-09-13", "decision": {"alternatives_considered": ["dovetail-aerospace:blanket-hold", "dovetail-aerospace:shortcut"], "question": "Did Dovetail make an unauthorized export, and what preservation or screening response is required now?", "rationale": "The four-part causal test supports 7 scoped actions and leaves 5 records on evidence hold. Export scope, screening requirements, and legal-hold timing must all apply to the same data and person.", "recommendation": "Escalate supported transfers and remediate preservation gaps without overstating unverified access.", "selected_option_id": "dovetail-aerospace:scoped-evidence"}, "holds": [{"id": "HOLD-CBP-024-02", "issue": "board-reporting omission", "portfolio_key": "CBP-024-02", "reason": "two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key", "required_next_evidence": "an approved immutable entity crosswalk", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_intake/002_intake_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/02_preservation/014_preservation_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/04_email_exports/026_email_exports_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/038_chat_exports_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/08_vendor_files/062_vendor_files_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/11_board_reporting/086_board_reporting_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_dovetail_aerospace_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-024-03", "issue": "interview timeline conflict", "portfolio_key": "CBP-024-03", "reason": "the current observation does not meet the operative trigger", "required_next_evidence": "a current observation that satisfies the operative trigger", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_intake/003_intake_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/02_preservation/015_preservation_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/04_email_exports/027_email_exports_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/039_chat_exports_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/08_vendor_files/063_vendor_files_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_dovetail_aerospace_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-024-05", "issue": "policy training lapse", "portfolio_key": "CBP-024-05", "reason": "the operational record relies on a superseded control revision", "required_next_evidence": "an operational record using the current effective revision", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_intake/005_intake_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/03_interviews/017_interviews_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/04_email_exports/029_email_exports_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/06_expenses/041_expenses_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/07_access_logs/053_access_logs_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_dovetail_aerospace_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-024-07", "issue": "gift-policy threshold breach", "portfolio_key": "CBP-024-07", "reason": "the current observation does not meet the operative trigger", "required_next_evidence": "a current observation that satisfies the operative trigger", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_intake/007_intake_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/03_interviews/019_interviews_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/04_email_exports/031_email_exports_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/06_expenses/043_expenses_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_dovetail_aerospace_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-024-12", "issue": "expense support deficiency", "portfolio_key": "CBP-024-12", "reason": "the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective", "required_next_evidence": "effective approval and an active owner with remaining capacity", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_preservation/012_preservation_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/03_interviews/024_interviews_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/036_chat_exports_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/06_expenses/048_expenses_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/096_remediation_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_dovetail_aerospace_impact_population.xlsx"]}], "matter_number": "CB-IV-2604", "prepared_for": "Dovetail Aerospace Components", "schema_version": "counselbench.decision.v3", "task_id": "cb100-024-dovetail-aerospace"}, "matter_register": {"matter_number": "CB-IV-2604", "rows": [{"decision_option_id": "dovetail-aerospace:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-12", "issue": "deleted-message anomaly", "matter_number": "CB-IV-2604", "owner": "Nora Chen", "portfolio_key": "CBP-024-01", "row_id": "REG-CBP-024-01", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_intake/001_intake_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/02_preservation/013_preservation_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/04_email_exports/025_email_exports_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/037_chat_exports_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_dovetail_aerospace_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "dovetail-aerospace:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key", "issue": "board-reporting omission", "matter_number": "CB-IV-2604", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-024-02", "row_id": "REG-CBP-024-02", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_intake/002_intake_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/02_preservation/014_preservation_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/04_email_exports/026_email_exports_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/038_chat_exports_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/08_vendor_files/062_vendor_files_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/11_board_reporting/086_board_reporting_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_dovetail_aerospace_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "dovetail-aerospace:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "the current observation does not meet the operative trigger", "issue": "interview timeline conflict", "matter_number": "CB-IV-2604", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-024-03", "row_id": "REG-CBP-024-03", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_intake/003_intake_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/02_preservation/015_preservation_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/04_email_exports/027_email_exports_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/039_chat_exports_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/08_vendor_files/063_vendor_files_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_dovetail_aerospace_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "dovetail-aerospace:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-09", "issue": "off-channel communication", "matter_number": "CB-IV-2604", "owner": "Samuel Kim", "portfolio_key": "CBP-024-04", "row_id": "REG-CBP-024-04", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_intake/004_intake_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/02_preservation/016_preservation_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/04_email_exports/028_email_exports_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/040_chat_exports_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/08_vendor_files/064_vendor_files_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/11_board_reporting/088_board_reporting_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_dovetail_aerospace_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "dovetail-aerospace:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "the operational record relies on a superseded control revision", "issue": "policy training lapse", "matter_number": "CB-IV-2604", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-024-05", "row_id": "REG-CBP-024-05", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_intake/005_intake_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/03_interviews/017_interviews_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/04_email_exports/029_email_exports_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/06_expenses/041_expenses_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/07_access_logs/053_access_logs_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_dovetail_aerospace_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "dovetail-aerospace:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-07", "issue": "preservation delay", "matter_number": "CB-IV-2604", "owner": "Adrian Mensah", "portfolio_key": "CBP-024-06", "row_id": "REG-CBP-024-06", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_intake/006_intake_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/03_interviews/018_interviews_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/04_email_exports/030_email_exports_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/06_expenses/042_expenses_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_dovetail_aerospace_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "dovetail-aerospace:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "the current observation does not meet the operative trigger", "issue": "gift-policy threshold breach", "matter_number": "CB-IV-2604", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-024-07", "row_id": "REG-CBP-024-07", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_intake/007_intake_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/03_interviews/019_interviews_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/04_email_exports/031_email_exports_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/06_expenses/043_expenses_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_dovetail_aerospace_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "dovetail-aerospace:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-05", "issue": "retaliation concern", "matter_number": "CB-IV-2604", "owner": "Dominic Alvarez", "portfolio_key": "CBP-024-08", "row_id": "REG-CBP-024-08", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_intake/008_intake_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/03_interviews/020_interviews_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/04_email_exports/032_email_exports_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/06_expenses/044_expenses_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/09_policies/068_policies_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/10_hr_records/080_hr_records_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_dovetail_aerospace_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "dovetail-aerospace:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-04", "issue": "remediation ownership gap", "matter_number": "CB-IV-2604", "owner": "Leona Park", "portfolio_key": "CBP-024-09", "row_id": "REG-CBP-024-09", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_preservation/009_preservation_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/03_interviews/021_interviews_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/033_chat_exports_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/06_expenses/045_expenses_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/093_remediation_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/11_board_reporting/081_board_reporting_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_dovetail_aerospace_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "dovetail-aerospace:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-12", "issue": "approval override", "matter_number": "CB-IV-2604", "owner": "Henry Cho", "portfolio_key": "CBP-024-10", "row_id": "REG-CBP-024-10", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_preservation/010_preservation_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/03_interviews/022_interviews_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/034_chat_exports_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/06_expenses/046_expenses_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/09_policies/070_policies_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/08_vendor_files/058_vendor_files_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_dovetail_aerospace_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "dovetail-aerospace:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-11", "issue": "vendor due-diligence gap", "matter_number": "CB-IV-2604", "owner": "Maya Ellison", "portfolio_key": "CBP-024-11", "row_id": "REG-CBP-024-11", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_preservation/011_preservation_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/03_interviews/023_interviews_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/035_chat_exports_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/06_expenses/047_expenses_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_dovetail_aerospace_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "dovetail-aerospace:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective", "issue": "expense support deficiency", "matter_number": "CB-IV-2604", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-024-12", "row_id": "REG-CBP-024-12", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_preservation/012_preservation_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/03_interviews/024_interviews_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/036_chat_exports_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/06_expenses/048_expenses_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/096_remediation_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_dovetail_aerospace_impact_population.xlsx"]}], "schema_version": "counselbench.matter-register.v3", "task_id": "cb100-024-dovetail-aerospace"}}, "metadata": {"benchmark": "CounselBench-100", "code_license": "Apache-2.0", "data_license": "CC-BY-4.0", "deadline": "2026-09-13", "document_count": 97, "evidence_holds": 5, "jurisdiction": "Virginia", "matter_number": "CB-IV-2604", "mcp_commit": "9a96ea6e5913736f92b88345bf51caeaaa8e719f", "mcp_package": "@modelcontextprotocol/server-filesystem@2026.7.10", "practice_area": "internal-investigations", "reference_tool_calls": 86, "required_evidence_reads": 63, "supported_actions": 7, "synthetic": true, "venue": "Fairfax County, Virginia", "version": "3.1.0"}, "prompt": "The client wants a decision, not another document inventory. Did Dovetail make an unauthorized export, and what preservation or screening response is required now? Engineering files may have been shared with an overseas consultant before screening, and preservation began after an account was deactivated. The team needs the call by 2026-09-13. Put the supported calls into the matter register and leave me a short note I can use with the partner.", "rubric": {"criteria": [{"category": "investigation", "description": "Inventory the production and use targeted searches to locate records across native formats.", "id": "investigation.discover_production"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Complete every task-specific identity, authority, operations, and approval read before the first state transition.", "id": "investigation.read_before_write"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Inspect designated source metadata before relying on those records.", "id": "investigation.custody_before_write"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "Select the supported option 'dovetail-aerospace:scoped-evidence' after applying the four-part test.", "id": "decision.selected_option"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "Identify both rejected approaches and explain why a one-source shortcut and a blanket hold are wrong.", "id": "decision.alternatives"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-024-01 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_intake/001_intake_source_export.md rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-024-01.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_preservation/013_preservation_source_export.json for deleted-message anomaly.", "id": "investigation.CBP-024-01.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_email_exports/025_email_exports_source_export.md to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-024-01.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/037_chat_exports_source_export.json.", "id": "investigation.CBP-024-01.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-024-01 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-024-01.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-024-01 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-024-01.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-024-02 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_intake/002_intake_source_export.txt rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-024-02.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_preservation/014_preservation_source_export.xml for board-reporting omission.", "id": "investigation.CBP-024-02.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_email_exports/026_email_exports_source_export.txt to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-024-02.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/038_chat_exports_source_export.xml.", "id": "investigation.CBP-024-02.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-024-02 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key.", "id": "decision.CBP-024-02.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-024-02 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-024-02.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-024-03 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_intake/003_intake_source_export.eml rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-024-03.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_preservation/015_preservation_source_export.html for interview timeline conflict.", "id": "investigation.CBP-024-03.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_email_exports/027_email_exports_source_export.eml to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-024-03.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/039_chat_exports_source_export.html.", "id": "investigation.CBP-024-03.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-024-03 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is the current observation does not meet the operative trigger.", "id": "decision.CBP-024-03.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-024-03 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-024-03.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-024-04 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_intake/004_intake_source_export.csv rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-024-04.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_preservation/016_preservation_source_export.pdf for off-channel communication.", "id": "investigation.CBP-024-04.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_email_exports/028_email_exports_source_export.csv to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-024-04.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/040_chat_exports_source_export.pdf.", "id": "investigation.CBP-024-04.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-024-04 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-024-04.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-024-04 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-024-04.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-024-05 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_intake/005_intake_source_export.json rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-024-05.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_interviews/017_interviews_source_export.md for policy training lapse.", "id": "investigation.CBP-024-05.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_email_exports/029_email_exports_source_export.json to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-024-05.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_expenses/041_expenses_source_export.md.", "id": "investigation.CBP-024-05.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-024-05 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is the operational record relies on a superseded control revision.", "id": "decision.CBP-024-05.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-024-05 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-024-05.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-024-06 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_intake/006_intake_source_export.xml rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-024-06.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_interviews/018_interviews_source_export.txt for preservation delay.", "id": "investigation.CBP-024-06.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_email_exports/030_email_exports_source_export.xml to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-024-06.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_expenses/042_expenses_source_export.txt.", "id": "investigation.CBP-024-06.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-024-06 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-024-06.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-024-06 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-024-06.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-024-07 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_intake/007_intake_source_export.html rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-024-07.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_interviews/019_interviews_source_export.eml for gift-policy threshold breach.", "id": "investigation.CBP-024-07.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_email_exports/031_email_exports_source_export.html to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-024-07.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_expenses/043_expenses_source_export.eml.", "id": "investigation.CBP-024-07.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-024-07 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is the current observation does not meet the operative trigger.", "id": "decision.CBP-024-07.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-024-07 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-024-07.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-024-08 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_intake/008_intake_source_export.pdf rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-024-08.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_interviews/020_interviews_source_export.csv for retaliation concern.", "id": "investigation.CBP-024-08.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_email_exports/032_email_exports_source_export.pdf to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-024-08.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_expenses/044_expenses_source_export.csv.", "id": "investigation.CBP-024-08.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-024-08 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-024-08.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-024-08 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-024-08.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-024-09 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_preservation/009_preservation_source_export.md rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-024-09.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_interviews/021_interviews_source_export.json for remediation ownership gap.", "id": "investigation.CBP-024-09.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/033_chat_exports_source_export.md to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-024-09.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_expenses/045_expenses_source_export.json.", "id": "investigation.CBP-024-09.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-024-09 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-024-09.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-024-09 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-024-09.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-024-10 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_preservation/010_preservation_source_export.txt rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-024-10.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_interviews/022_interviews_source_export.xml for approval override.", "id": "investigation.CBP-024-10.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/034_chat_exports_source_export.txt to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-024-10.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_expenses/046_expenses_source_export.xml.", "id": "investigation.CBP-024-10.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-024-10 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-024-10.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-024-10 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-024-10.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-024-11 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_preservation/011_preservation_source_export.eml rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-024-11.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_interviews/023_interviews_source_export.html for vendor due-diligence gap.", "id": "investigation.CBP-024-11.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/035_chat_exports_source_export.eml to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-024-11.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_expenses/047_expenses_source_export.html.", "id": "investigation.CBP-024-11.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-024-11 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-024-11.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-024-11 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-024-11.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-024-12 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_preservation/012_preservation_source_export.csv rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-024-12.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_interviews/024_interviews_source_export.pdf for expense support deficiency.", "id": "investigation.CBP-024-12.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/036_chat_exports_source_export.csv to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-024-12.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_expenses/048_expenses_source_export.pdf.", "id": "investigation.CBP-024-12.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-024-12 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective.", "id": "decision.CBP-024-12.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-024-12 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-024-12.register"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Write the exact selected option, supported action population, evidence-hold population, facts, owners, deadlines, and citations.", "id": "state.exact_decision"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create one exact register row per portfolio key with no extra, missing, or modified row.", "id": "state.exact_register"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Leave only the three approved deliverables and perform no extra state-changing write.", "id": "state.write_scope_containment"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Read back decision.json, matter-register.json, and advice.md after their final writes.", "id": "state.postwrite_readback"}, {"category": "answer", "description": "Explain the selected recommendation, supported actions, holds, alternatives, and limitations with exact source anchors.", "id": "answer.decision_note"}], "decision_options": [{"approach": "Treat supported actions and genuinely ambiguous records as if they were equally unresolved.", "id": "dovetail-aerospace:blanket-hold", "label": "Freeze the entire matter population"}, {"approach": "Apply the exact identity, current-state, authority, and revision test. Register proven transfer and hold failures; quarantine device or identity mismatches.", "id": "dovetail-aerospace:scoped-evidence", "label": "Escalate supported transfers and remediate preservation gaps without overstating unverified access."}, {"approach": "Use a plausible summary or one source without completing the controlling joins.", "id": "dovetail-aerospace:shortcut", "label": "Treat every overseas login as an export violation."}], "evaluation_narrative": {"authority": "Export scope, screening requirements, and legal-hold timing must all apply to the same data and person.", "observation": "Join file-access logs, consultant identity, jurisdiction, screening results, and account-deactivation timing.", "question": "Did Dovetail make an unauthorized export, and what preservation or screening response is required now?", "register_action": "Register proven transfer and hold failures; quarantine device or identity mismatches."}, "gates": ["all_required_evidence_precedes_first_write", "decision_criteria_complete", "register_state_exact", "write_scope_contained", "all_outputs_verified_by_readback"], "metadata_checks": 10, "metric": "weighted_criteria_score", "minimum_tool_calls": 86, "required_deliverables": ["decision.json", "matter-register.json", "advice.md"], "required_document_reads": 63, "type": "deterministic", "weights": {"advice": 0.15, "decision": 0.35, "investigation": 0.25, "state": 0.25}}, "task_id": "cb100-024-dovetail-aerospace", "task_name": "Dovetail export-controls inquiry", "world_id": "counselbench-filesystem-mcp-v3"}
+{"context_files": ["task_files/cb100-025-evergreen-charter/01_intake/001_intake_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-025-evergreen-charter/01_intake/002_intake_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-025-evergreen-charter/01_intake/003_intake_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-025-evergreen-charter/01_intake/004_intake_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-025-evergreen-charter/01_intake/005_intake_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-025-evergreen-charter/01_intake/006_intake_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-025-evergreen-charter/01_intake/007_intake_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-025-evergreen-charter/01_intake/008_intake_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-025-evergreen-charter/02_preservation/009_preservation_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-025-evergreen-charter/02_preservation/010_preservation_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-025-evergreen-charter/02_preservation/011_preservation_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-025-evergreen-charter/02_preservation/012_preservation_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-025-evergreen-charter/02_preservation/013_preservation_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-025-evergreen-charter/02_preservation/014_preservation_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-025-evergreen-charter/02_preservation/015_preservation_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-025-evergreen-charter/02_preservation/016_preservation_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-025-evergreen-charter/03_interviews/017_interviews_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-025-evergreen-charter/03_interviews/018_interviews_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-025-evergreen-charter/03_interviews/019_interviews_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-025-evergreen-charter/03_interviews/020_interviews_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-025-evergreen-charter/03_interviews/021_interviews_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-025-evergreen-charter/03_interviews/022_interviews_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-025-evergreen-charter/03_interviews/023_interviews_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-025-evergreen-charter/03_interviews/024_interviews_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-025-evergreen-charter/04_email_exports/025_email_exports_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-025-evergreen-charter/04_email_exports/026_email_exports_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-025-evergreen-charter/04_email_exports/027_email_exports_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-025-evergreen-charter/04_email_exports/028_email_exports_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-025-evergreen-charter/04_email_exports/029_email_exports_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-025-evergreen-charter/04_email_exports/030_email_exports_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-025-evergreen-charter/04_email_exports/031_email_exports_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-025-evergreen-charter/04_email_exports/032_email_exports_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-025-evergreen-charter/05_chat_exports/033_chat_exports_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-025-evergreen-charter/05_chat_exports/034_chat_exports_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-025-evergreen-charter/05_chat_exports/035_chat_exports_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-025-evergreen-charter/05_chat_exports/036_chat_exports_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-025-evergreen-charter/05_chat_exports/037_chat_exports_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-025-evergreen-charter/05_chat_exports/038_chat_exports_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-025-evergreen-charter/05_chat_exports/039_chat_exports_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-025-evergreen-charter/05_chat_exports/040_chat_exports_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-025-evergreen-charter/06_expenses/041_expenses_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-025-evergreen-charter/06_expenses/042_expenses_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-025-evergreen-charter/06_expenses/043_expenses_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-025-evergreen-charter/06_expenses/044_expenses_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-025-evergreen-charter/06_expenses/045_expenses_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-025-evergreen-charter/06_expenses/046_expenses_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-025-evergreen-charter/06_expenses/047_expenses_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-025-evergreen-charter/06_expenses/048_expenses_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-025-evergreen-charter/07_access_logs/049_access_logs_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-025-evergreen-charter/07_access_logs/050_access_logs_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-025-evergreen-charter/07_access_logs/051_access_logs_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-025-evergreen-charter/07_access_logs/052_access_logs_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-025-evergreen-charter/07_access_logs/053_access_logs_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-025-evergreen-charter/07_access_logs/054_access_logs_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-025-evergreen-charter/07_access_logs/055_access_logs_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-025-evergreen-charter/07_access_logs/056_access_logs_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-025-evergreen-charter/08_vendor_files/057_vendor_files_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-025-evergreen-charter/08_vendor_files/058_vendor_files_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-025-evergreen-charter/08_vendor_files/059_vendor_files_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-025-evergreen-charter/08_vendor_files/060_vendor_files_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-025-evergreen-charter/08_vendor_files/061_vendor_files_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-025-evergreen-charter/08_vendor_files/062_vendor_files_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-025-evergreen-charter/08_vendor_files/063_vendor_files_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-025-evergreen-charter/08_vendor_files/064_vendor_files_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-025-evergreen-charter/09_policies/065_policies_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-025-evergreen-charter/09_policies/066_policies_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-025-evergreen-charter/09_policies/067_policies_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-025-evergreen-charter/09_policies/068_policies_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-025-evergreen-charter/09_policies/069_policies_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-025-evergreen-charter/09_policies/070_policies_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-025-evergreen-charter/09_policies/071_policies_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-025-evergreen-charter/09_policies/072_policies_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-025-evergreen-charter/10_hr_records/073_hr_records_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-025-evergreen-charter/10_hr_records/074_hr_records_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-025-evergreen-charter/10_hr_records/075_hr_records_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-025-evergreen-charter/10_hr_records/076_hr_records_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-025-evergreen-charter/10_hr_records/077_hr_records_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-025-evergreen-charter/10_hr_records/078_hr_records_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-025-evergreen-charter/10_hr_records/079_hr_records_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-025-evergreen-charter/10_hr_records/080_hr_records_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-025-evergreen-charter/11_board_reporting/081_board_reporting_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-025-evergreen-charter/11_board_reporting/082_board_reporting_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-025-evergreen-charter/11_board_reporting/083_board_reporting_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-025-evergreen-charter/11_board_reporting/084_board_reporting_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-025-evergreen-charter/11_board_reporting/085_board_reporting_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-025-evergreen-charter/11_board_reporting/086_board_reporting_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-025-evergreen-charter/11_board_reporting/087_board_reporting_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-025-evergreen-charter/11_board_reporting/088_board_reporting_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-025-evergreen-charter/12_remediation/089_remediation_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-025-evergreen-charter/12_remediation/090_remediation_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-025-evergreen-charter/12_remediation/091_remediation_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-025-evergreen-charter/12_remediation/092_remediation_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-025-evergreen-charter/12_remediation/093_remediation_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-025-evergreen-charter/12_remediation/094_remediation_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-025-evergreen-charter/12_remediation/095_remediation_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-025-evergreen-charter/12_remediation/096_remediation_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-025-evergreen-charter/12_remediation/097_evergreen_charter_impact_population.xlsx"], "gold_output": {"advice_markdown": "# Decision note — Evergreen enrollment complaint review\n\n## Recommendation\n\nCorrect supported enrollment changes and escalate only corroborated retaliation indicators. The reconciled record supports 5 scoped actions and leaves 7 items on evidence hold.\n\nSelected option: `evergreen-charter:scoped-evidence`.\n\n## Why this is the supported option\n\nReconcile wait-list edits, override authority, gifts, complaints, and subsequent personnel events by actor and student record. Enrollment policy and anti-retaliation analysis require valid comparators, protected activity, and timing evidence.\n\n## Supported actions\n\n### CBP-025-02 — hotline classification error (low)\n\nthe controlling threshold is 5% under CB-IV-2605-R392; the independently calculated result is 9% under CB-IV-2605-E699. Identity resolves to ENT-025-1001, revision REV-2025.2 is current, and Sofia Bennett is active with capacity 1.\n\nAction: Create separate enrollment and retaliation rows with evidence-specific dispositions. Owner: Sofia Bennett; due 2026-09-14.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_intake/002_intake_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/02_preservation/014_preservation_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/04_email_exports/026_email_exports_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/038_chat_exports_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_evergreen_charter_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-025-03 — undisclosed related party (high)\n\napproval must come from Talia Brooks under CB-IV-2605-R884; the effective approval record names Henry Cho under CB-IV-2605-E304. Identity resolves to ENT-025-1002, revision REV-2025.3 is current, and Micah Sullivan is active with capacity 4.\n\nAction: Create separate enrollment and retaliation rows with evidence-specific dispositions. Owner: Micah Sullivan; due 2026-09-13.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_intake/003_intake_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/02_preservation/015_preservation_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/04_email_exports/027_email_exports_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/039_chat_exports_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/07_access_logs/051_access_logs_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/08_vendor_files/063_vendor_files_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_evergreen_charter_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-025-04 — deleted-message anomaly (medium)\n\nthe controlled population contains 98 records under CB-IV-2605-R146; the certification covers 86 records under CB-IV-2605-E261. Identity resolves to ENT-025-1003, revision REV-2025.4 is current, and Nora Chen is active with capacity 1.\n\nAction: Create separate enrollment and retaliation rows with evidence-specific dispositions. Owner: Nora Chen; due 2026-09-12.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_intake/004_intake_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/02_preservation/016_preservation_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/04_email_exports/028_email_exports_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/040_chat_exports_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_evergreen_charter_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-025-05 — board-reporting omission (medium)\n\nthe permission is limited to Multnomah County, Oregon under CB-IV-2605-R202; the matched activity occurred in Oregon under CB-IV-2605-E688. Identity resolves to ENT-025-1004, revision REV-2025.5 is current, and Caleb Hassan is active with capacity 4.\n\nAction: Create separate enrollment and retaliation rows with evidence-specific dispositions. Owner: Caleb Hassan; due 2026-09-11.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_intake/005_intake_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/03_interviews/017_interviews_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/04_email_exports/029_email_exports_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/06_expenses/041_expenses_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_evergreen_charter_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-025-11 — retaliation concern (high)\n\napproval must come from Talia Brooks under CB-IV-2605-R461; the effective approval record names Caleb Hassan under CB-IV-2605-E862. Identity resolves to ENT-025-1010, revision REV-2025.4 is current, and Dominic Alvarez is active with capacity 3.\n\nAction: Create separate enrollment and retaliation rows with evidence-specific dispositions. Owner: Dominic Alvarez; due 2026-09-14.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/02_preservation/011_preservation_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/03_interviews/023_interviews_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/035_chat_exports_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/06_expenses/047_expenses_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_evergreen_charter_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n## Evidence holds\n\n- **CBP-025-01 — badge-log inconsistency**: two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key. Next evidence: an approved immutable entity crosswalk. Sources: `/workspace/documents/01_intake/001_intake_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/02_preservation/013_preservation_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/04_email_exports/025_email_exports_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/037_chat_exports_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/11_board_reporting/085_board_reporting_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_evergreen_charter_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-025-06 — interview timeline conflict**: the current observation does not meet the operative trigger. Next evidence: a current observation that satisfies the operative trigger. Sources: `/workspace/documents/01_intake/006_intake_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/03_interviews/018_interviews_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/04_email_exports/030_email_exports_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/06_expenses/042_expenses_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_evergreen_charter_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-025-07 — off-channel communication**: the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective. Next evidence: effective approval and an active owner with remaining capacity. Sources: `/workspace/documents/01_intake/007_intake_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/03_interviews/019_interviews_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/04_email_exports/031_email_exports_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/06_expenses/043_expenses_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/12_remediation/091_remediation_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_evergreen_charter_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-025-08 — policy training lapse**: the operational record relies on a superseded control revision. Next evidence: an operational record using the current effective revision. Sources: `/workspace/documents/01_intake/008_intake_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/03_interviews/020_interviews_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/04_email_exports/032_email_exports_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/06_expenses/044_expenses_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/07_access_logs/056_access_logs_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_evergreen_charter_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-025-09 — preservation delay**: two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key. Next evidence: an approved immutable entity crosswalk. Sources: `/workspace/documents/02_preservation/009_preservation_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/03_interviews/021_interviews_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/033_chat_exports_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/06_expenses/045_expenses_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_evergreen_charter_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-025-10 — gift-policy threshold breach**: the current observation does not meet the operative trigger. Next evidence: a current observation that satisfies the operative trigger. Sources: `/workspace/documents/02_preservation/010_preservation_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/03_interviews/022_interviews_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/034_chat_exports_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/06_expenses/046_expenses_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_evergreen_charter_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-025-12 — remediation ownership gap**: the operational record relies on a superseded control revision. Next evidence: an operational record using the current effective revision. Sources: `/workspace/documents/02_preservation/012_preservation_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/03_interviews/024_interviews_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/036_chat_exports_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/06_expenses/048_expenses_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/08_vendor_files/060_vendor_files_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/09_policies/072_policies_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_evergreen_charter_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n## Alternatives considered\n\n- `evergreen-charter:shortcut` — Assume every manual override and later schedule change proves retaliation.: Use a plausible summary or one source without completing the controlling joins.\n- `evergreen-charter:blanket-hold` — Freeze the entire matter population: Treat supported actions and genuinely ambiguous records as if they were equally unresolved.\n\n## Assumptions and limits\n\nThis decision is limited to cb100-025-evergreen-charter, the supplied synthetic records, and the matter state as of 2026-09-16. Similar names, stale revisions, and pending authority are not treated as proof.\n", "decision": {"actions": [{"determination": "the controlling threshold is 5% under CB-IV-2605-R392; the independently calculated result is 9% under CB-IV-2605-E699. Identity resolves to ENT-025-1001, revision REV-2025.2 is current, and Sofia Bennett is active with capacity 1.", "due_date": "2026-09-14", "id": "ACT-CBP-025-02", "identity_id": "ENT-025-1001", "issue": "hotline classification error", "owner": "Sofia Bennett", "portfolio_key": "CBP-025-02", "recommended_action": "Create separate enrollment and retaliation rows with evidence-specific dispositions. Owner: Sofia Bennett; due 2026-09-14.", "severity": "low", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_intake/002_intake_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/02_preservation/014_preservation_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/04_email_exports/026_email_exports_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/038_chat_exports_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_evergreen_charter_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "approval must come from Talia Brooks under CB-IV-2605-R884; the effective approval record names Henry Cho under CB-IV-2605-E304. Identity resolves to ENT-025-1002, revision REV-2025.3 is current, and Micah Sullivan is active with capacity 4.", "due_date": "2026-09-13", "id": "ACT-CBP-025-03", "identity_id": "ENT-025-1002", "issue": "undisclosed related party", "owner": "Micah Sullivan", "portfolio_key": "CBP-025-03", "recommended_action": "Create separate enrollment and retaliation rows with evidence-specific dispositions. Owner: Micah Sullivan; due 2026-09-13.", "severity": "high", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_intake/003_intake_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/02_preservation/015_preservation_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/04_email_exports/027_email_exports_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/039_chat_exports_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/07_access_logs/051_access_logs_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/08_vendor_files/063_vendor_files_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_evergreen_charter_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "the controlled population contains 98 records under CB-IV-2605-R146; the certification covers 86 records under CB-IV-2605-E261. Identity resolves to ENT-025-1003, revision REV-2025.4 is current, and Nora Chen is active with capacity 1.", "due_date": "2026-09-12", "id": "ACT-CBP-025-04", "identity_id": "ENT-025-1003", "issue": "deleted-message anomaly", "owner": "Nora Chen", "portfolio_key": "CBP-025-04", "recommended_action": "Create separate enrollment and retaliation rows with evidence-specific dispositions. Owner: Nora Chen; due 2026-09-12.", "severity": "medium", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_intake/004_intake_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/02_preservation/016_preservation_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/04_email_exports/028_email_exports_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/040_chat_exports_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_evergreen_charter_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "the permission is limited to Multnomah County, Oregon under CB-IV-2605-R202; the matched activity occurred in Oregon under CB-IV-2605-E688. Identity resolves to ENT-025-1004, revision REV-2025.5 is current, and Caleb Hassan is active with capacity 4.", "due_date": "2026-09-11", "id": "ACT-CBP-025-05", "identity_id": "ENT-025-1004", "issue": "board-reporting omission", "owner": "Caleb Hassan", "portfolio_key": "CBP-025-05", "recommended_action": "Create separate enrollment and retaliation rows with evidence-specific dispositions. Owner: Caleb Hassan; due 2026-09-11.", "severity": "medium", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_intake/005_intake_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/03_interviews/017_interviews_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/04_email_exports/029_email_exports_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/06_expenses/041_expenses_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_evergreen_charter_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "approval must come from Talia Brooks under CB-IV-2605-R461; the effective approval record names Caleb Hassan under CB-IV-2605-E862. Identity resolves to ENT-025-1010, revision REV-2025.4 is current, and Dominic Alvarez is active with capacity 3.", "due_date": "2026-09-14", "id": "ACT-CBP-025-11", "identity_id": "ENT-025-1010", "issue": "retaliation concern", "owner": "Dominic Alvarez", "portfolio_key": "CBP-025-11", "recommended_action": "Create separate enrollment and retaliation rows with evidence-specific dispositions. Owner: Dominic Alvarez; due 2026-09-14.", "severity": "high", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_preservation/011_preservation_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/03_interviews/023_interviews_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/035_chat_exports_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/06_expenses/047_expenses_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_evergreen_charter_impact_population.xlsx"]}], "as_of": "2026-09-16", "decision": {"alternatives_considered": ["evergreen-charter:shortcut", "evergreen-charter:blanket-hold"], "question": "Which Evergreen enrollment actions were improper, and is the retaliation concern supported?", "rationale": "The four-part causal test supports 5 scoped actions and leaves 7 records on evidence hold. Enrollment policy and anti-retaliation analysis require valid comparators, protected activity, and timing evidence.", "recommendation": "Correct supported enrollment changes and escalate only corroborated retaliation indicators.", "selected_option_id": "evergreen-charter:scoped-evidence"}, "holds": [{"id": "HOLD-CBP-025-01", "issue": "badge-log inconsistency", "portfolio_key": "CBP-025-01", "reason": "two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key", "required_next_evidence": "an approved immutable entity crosswalk", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_intake/001_intake_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/02_preservation/013_preservation_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/04_email_exports/025_email_exports_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/037_chat_exports_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/11_board_reporting/085_board_reporting_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_evergreen_charter_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-025-06", "issue": "interview timeline conflict", "portfolio_key": "CBP-025-06", "reason": "the current observation does not meet the operative trigger", "required_next_evidence": "a current observation that satisfies the operative trigger", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_intake/006_intake_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/03_interviews/018_interviews_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/04_email_exports/030_email_exports_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/06_expenses/042_expenses_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_evergreen_charter_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-025-07", "issue": "off-channel communication", "portfolio_key": "CBP-025-07", "reason": "the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective", "required_next_evidence": "effective approval and an active owner with remaining capacity", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_intake/007_intake_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/03_interviews/019_interviews_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/04_email_exports/031_email_exports_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/06_expenses/043_expenses_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/091_remediation_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_evergreen_charter_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-025-08", "issue": "policy training lapse", "portfolio_key": "CBP-025-08", "reason": "the operational record relies on a superseded control revision", "required_next_evidence": "an operational record using the current effective revision", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_intake/008_intake_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/03_interviews/020_interviews_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/04_email_exports/032_email_exports_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/06_expenses/044_expenses_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/07_access_logs/056_access_logs_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_evergreen_charter_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-025-09", "issue": "preservation delay", "portfolio_key": "CBP-025-09", "reason": "two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key", "required_next_evidence": "an approved immutable entity crosswalk", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_preservation/009_preservation_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/03_interviews/021_interviews_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/033_chat_exports_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/06_expenses/045_expenses_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_evergreen_charter_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-025-10", "issue": "gift-policy threshold breach", "portfolio_key": "CBP-025-10", "reason": "the current observation does not meet the operative trigger", "required_next_evidence": "a current observation that satisfies the operative trigger", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_preservation/010_preservation_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/03_interviews/022_interviews_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/034_chat_exports_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/06_expenses/046_expenses_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_evergreen_charter_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-025-12", "issue": "remediation ownership gap", "portfolio_key": "CBP-025-12", "reason": "the operational record relies on a superseded control revision", "required_next_evidence": "an operational record using the current effective revision", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_preservation/012_preservation_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/03_interviews/024_interviews_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/036_chat_exports_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/06_expenses/048_expenses_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/08_vendor_files/060_vendor_files_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/09_policies/072_policies_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_evergreen_charter_impact_population.xlsx"]}], "matter_number": "CB-IV-2605", "prepared_for": "Evergreen Charter Network", "schema_version": "counselbench.decision.v3", "task_id": "cb100-025-evergreen-charter"}, "matter_register": {"matter_number": "CB-IV-2605", "rows": [{"decision_option_id": "evergreen-charter:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key", "issue": "badge-log inconsistency", "matter_number": "CB-IV-2605", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-025-01", "row_id": "REG-CBP-025-01", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_intake/001_intake_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/02_preservation/013_preservation_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/04_email_exports/025_email_exports_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/037_chat_exports_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/11_board_reporting/085_board_reporting_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_evergreen_charter_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "evergreen-charter:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-14", "issue": "hotline classification error", "matter_number": "CB-IV-2605", "owner": "Sofia Bennett", "portfolio_key": "CBP-025-02", "row_id": "REG-CBP-025-02", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_intake/002_intake_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/02_preservation/014_preservation_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/04_email_exports/026_email_exports_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/038_chat_exports_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_evergreen_charter_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "evergreen-charter:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-13", "issue": "undisclosed related party", "matter_number": "CB-IV-2605", "owner": "Micah Sullivan", "portfolio_key": "CBP-025-03", "row_id": "REG-CBP-025-03", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_intake/003_intake_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/02_preservation/015_preservation_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/04_email_exports/027_email_exports_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/039_chat_exports_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/07_access_logs/051_access_logs_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/08_vendor_files/063_vendor_files_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_evergreen_charter_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "evergreen-charter:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-12", "issue": "deleted-message anomaly", "matter_number": "CB-IV-2605", "owner": "Nora Chen", "portfolio_key": "CBP-025-04", "row_id": "REG-CBP-025-04", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_intake/004_intake_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/02_preservation/016_preservation_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/04_email_exports/028_email_exports_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/040_chat_exports_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_evergreen_charter_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "evergreen-charter:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-11", "issue": "board-reporting omission", "matter_number": "CB-IV-2605", "owner": "Caleb Hassan", "portfolio_key": "CBP-025-05", "row_id": "REG-CBP-025-05", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_intake/005_intake_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/03_interviews/017_interviews_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/04_email_exports/029_email_exports_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/06_expenses/041_expenses_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_evergreen_charter_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "evergreen-charter:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "the current observation does not meet the operative trigger", "issue": "interview timeline conflict", "matter_number": "CB-IV-2605", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-025-06", "row_id": "REG-CBP-025-06", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_intake/006_intake_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/03_interviews/018_interviews_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/04_email_exports/030_email_exports_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/06_expenses/042_expenses_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_evergreen_charter_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "evergreen-charter:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective", "issue": "off-channel communication", "matter_number": "CB-IV-2605", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-025-07", "row_id": "REG-CBP-025-07", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_intake/007_intake_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/03_interviews/019_interviews_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/04_email_exports/031_email_exports_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/06_expenses/043_expenses_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/091_remediation_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_evergreen_charter_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "evergreen-charter:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "the operational record relies on a superseded control revision", "issue": "policy training lapse", "matter_number": "CB-IV-2605", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-025-08", "row_id": "REG-CBP-025-08", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_intake/008_intake_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/03_interviews/020_interviews_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/04_email_exports/032_email_exports_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/06_expenses/044_expenses_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/07_access_logs/056_access_logs_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_evergreen_charter_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "evergreen-charter:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key", "issue": "preservation delay", "matter_number": "CB-IV-2605", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-025-09", "row_id": "REG-CBP-025-09", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_preservation/009_preservation_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/03_interviews/021_interviews_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/033_chat_exports_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/06_expenses/045_expenses_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_evergreen_charter_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "evergreen-charter:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "the current observation does not meet the operative trigger", "issue": "gift-policy threshold breach", "matter_number": "CB-IV-2605", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-025-10", "row_id": "REG-CBP-025-10", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_preservation/010_preservation_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/03_interviews/022_interviews_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/034_chat_exports_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/06_expenses/046_expenses_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_evergreen_charter_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "evergreen-charter:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-14", "issue": "retaliation concern", "matter_number": "CB-IV-2605", "owner": "Dominic Alvarez", "portfolio_key": "CBP-025-11", "row_id": "REG-CBP-025-11", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_preservation/011_preservation_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/03_interviews/023_interviews_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/035_chat_exports_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/06_expenses/047_expenses_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_evergreen_charter_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "evergreen-charter:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "the operational record relies on a superseded control revision", "issue": "remediation ownership gap", "matter_number": "CB-IV-2605", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-025-12", "row_id": "REG-CBP-025-12", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_preservation/012_preservation_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/03_interviews/024_interviews_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/036_chat_exports_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/06_expenses/048_expenses_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/08_vendor_files/060_vendor_files_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/09_policies/072_policies_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_evergreen_charter_impact_population.xlsx"]}], "schema_version": "counselbench.matter-register.v3", "task_id": "cb100-025-evergreen-charter"}}, "metadata": {"benchmark": "CounselBench-100", "code_license": "Apache-2.0", "data_license": "CC-BY-4.0", "deadline": "2026-09-16", "document_count": 97, "evidence_holds": 7, "jurisdiction": "Oregon", "matter_number": "CB-IV-2605", "mcp_commit": "9a96ea6e5913736f92b88345bf51caeaaa8e719f", "mcp_package": "@modelcontextprotocol/server-filesystem@2026.7.10", "practice_area": "internal-investigations", "reference_tool_calls": 76, "required_evidence_reads": 57, "supported_actions": 5, "synthetic": true, "venue": "Multnomah County, Oregon", "version": "3.1.0"}, "prompt": "We inherited inconsistent versions of this matter and need to settle the operating position. Which Evergreen enrollment actions were improper, and is the retaliation concern supported? A complaint alleges manipulated wait-list entries, consultant gifts, and retaliation against the registrar who questioned manual overrides. The team needs the call by 2026-09-16. I need the recommendation and the real blockers recorded before the team acts.", "rubric": {"criteria": [{"category": "investigation", "description": "Inventory the production and use targeted searches to locate records across native formats.", "id": "investigation.discover_production"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Complete every task-specific identity, authority, operations, and approval read before the first state transition.", "id": "investigation.read_before_write"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Inspect designated source metadata before relying on those records.", "id": "investigation.custody_before_write"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "Select the supported option 'evergreen-charter:scoped-evidence' after applying the four-part test.", "id": "decision.selected_option"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "Identify both rejected approaches and explain why a one-source shortcut and a blanket hold are wrong.", "id": "decision.alternatives"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-025-01 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_intake/001_intake_source_export.md rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-025-01.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_preservation/013_preservation_source_export.json for badge-log inconsistency.", "id": "investigation.CBP-025-01.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_email_exports/025_email_exports_source_export.md to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-025-01.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/037_chat_exports_source_export.json.", "id": "investigation.CBP-025-01.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-025-01 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key.", "id": "decision.CBP-025-01.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-025-01 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-025-01.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-025-02 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_intake/002_intake_source_export.txt rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-025-02.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_preservation/014_preservation_source_export.xml for hotline classification error.", "id": "investigation.CBP-025-02.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_email_exports/026_email_exports_source_export.txt to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-025-02.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/038_chat_exports_source_export.xml.", "id": "investigation.CBP-025-02.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-025-02 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-025-02.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-025-02 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-025-02.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-025-03 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_intake/003_intake_source_export.eml rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-025-03.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_preservation/015_preservation_source_export.html for undisclosed related party.", "id": "investigation.CBP-025-03.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_email_exports/027_email_exports_source_export.eml to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-025-03.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/039_chat_exports_source_export.html.", "id": "investigation.CBP-025-03.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-025-03 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-025-03.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-025-03 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-025-03.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-025-04 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_intake/004_intake_source_export.csv rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-025-04.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_preservation/016_preservation_source_export.pdf for deleted-message anomaly.", "id": "investigation.CBP-025-04.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_email_exports/028_email_exports_source_export.csv to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-025-04.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/040_chat_exports_source_export.pdf.", "id": "investigation.CBP-025-04.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-025-04 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-025-04.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-025-04 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-025-04.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-025-05 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_intake/005_intake_source_export.json rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-025-05.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_interviews/017_interviews_source_export.md for board-reporting omission.", "id": "investigation.CBP-025-05.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_email_exports/029_email_exports_source_export.json to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-025-05.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_expenses/041_expenses_source_export.md.", "id": "investigation.CBP-025-05.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-025-05 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-025-05.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-025-05 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-025-05.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-025-06 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_intake/006_intake_source_export.xml rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-025-06.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_interviews/018_interviews_source_export.txt for interview timeline conflict.", "id": "investigation.CBP-025-06.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_email_exports/030_email_exports_source_export.xml to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-025-06.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_expenses/042_expenses_source_export.txt.", "id": "investigation.CBP-025-06.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-025-06 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is the current observation does not meet the operative trigger.", "id": "decision.CBP-025-06.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-025-06 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-025-06.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-025-07 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_intake/007_intake_source_export.html rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-025-07.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_interviews/019_interviews_source_export.eml for off-channel communication.", "id": "investigation.CBP-025-07.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_email_exports/031_email_exports_source_export.html to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-025-07.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_expenses/043_expenses_source_export.eml.", "id": "investigation.CBP-025-07.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-025-07 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective.", "id": "decision.CBP-025-07.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-025-07 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-025-07.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-025-08 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_intake/008_intake_source_export.pdf rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-025-08.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_interviews/020_interviews_source_export.csv for policy training lapse.", "id": "investigation.CBP-025-08.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_email_exports/032_email_exports_source_export.pdf to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-025-08.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_expenses/044_expenses_source_export.csv.", "id": "investigation.CBP-025-08.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-025-08 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is the operational record relies on a superseded control revision.", "id": "decision.CBP-025-08.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-025-08 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-025-08.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-025-09 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_preservation/009_preservation_source_export.md rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-025-09.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_interviews/021_interviews_source_export.json for preservation delay.", "id": "investigation.CBP-025-09.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/033_chat_exports_source_export.md to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-025-09.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_expenses/045_expenses_source_export.json.", "id": "investigation.CBP-025-09.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-025-09 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key.", "id": "decision.CBP-025-09.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-025-09 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-025-09.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-025-10 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_preservation/010_preservation_source_export.txt rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-025-10.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_interviews/022_interviews_source_export.xml for gift-policy threshold breach.", "id": "investigation.CBP-025-10.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/034_chat_exports_source_export.txt to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-025-10.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_expenses/046_expenses_source_export.xml.", "id": "investigation.CBP-025-10.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-025-10 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is the current observation does not meet the operative trigger.", "id": "decision.CBP-025-10.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-025-10 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-025-10.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-025-11 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_preservation/011_preservation_source_export.eml rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-025-11.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_interviews/023_interviews_source_export.html for retaliation concern.", "id": "investigation.CBP-025-11.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/035_chat_exports_source_export.eml to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-025-11.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_expenses/047_expenses_source_export.html.", "id": "investigation.CBP-025-11.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-025-11 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-025-11.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-025-11 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-025-11.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-025-12 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_preservation/012_preservation_source_export.csv rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-025-12.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_interviews/024_interviews_source_export.pdf for remediation ownership gap.", "id": "investigation.CBP-025-12.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/036_chat_exports_source_export.csv to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-025-12.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_expenses/048_expenses_source_export.pdf.", "id": "investigation.CBP-025-12.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-025-12 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is the operational record relies on a superseded control revision.", "id": "decision.CBP-025-12.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-025-12 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-025-12.register"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Write the exact selected option, supported action population, evidence-hold population, facts, owners, deadlines, and citations.", "id": "state.exact_decision"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create one exact register row per portfolio key with no extra, missing, or modified row.", "id": "state.exact_register"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Leave only the three approved deliverables and perform no extra state-changing write.", "id": "state.write_scope_containment"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Read back decision.json, matter-register.json, and advice.md after their final writes.", "id": "state.postwrite_readback"}, {"category": "answer", "description": "Explain the selected recommendation, supported actions, holds, alternatives, and limitations with exact source anchors.", "id": "answer.decision_note"}], "decision_options": [{"approach": "Apply the exact identity, current-state, authority, and revision test. Create separate enrollment and retaliation rows with evidence-specific dispositions.", "id": "evergreen-charter:scoped-evidence", "label": "Correct supported enrollment changes and escalate only corroborated retaliation indicators."}, {"approach": "Use a plausible summary or one source without completing the controlling joins.", "id": "evergreen-charter:shortcut", "label": "Assume every manual override and later schedule change proves retaliation."}, {"approach": "Treat supported actions and genuinely ambiguous records as if they were equally unresolved.", "id": "evergreen-charter:blanket-hold", "label": "Freeze the entire matter population"}], "evaluation_narrative": {"authority": "Enrollment policy and anti-retaliation analysis require valid comparators, protected activity, and timing evidence.", "observation": "Reconcile wait-list edits, override authority, gifts, complaints, and subsequent personnel events by actor and student record.", "question": "Which Evergreen enrollment actions were improper, and is the retaliation concern supported?", "register_action": "Create separate enrollment and retaliation rows with evidence-specific dispositions."}, "gates": ["all_required_evidence_precedes_first_write", "decision_criteria_complete", "register_state_exact", "write_scope_contained", "all_outputs_verified_by_readback"], "metadata_checks": 5, "metric": "weighted_criteria_score", "minimum_tool_calls": 76, "required_deliverables": ["decision.json", "matter-register.json", "advice.md"], "required_document_reads": 57, "type": "deterministic", "weights": {"advice": 0.15, "decision": 0.35, "investigation": 0.25, "state": 0.25}}, "task_id": "cb100-025-evergreen-charter", "task_name": "Evergreen enrollment complaint review", "world_id": "counselbench-filesystem-mcp-v3"}
+{"context_files": ["task_files/cb100-026-foxglove-pharma/01_intake/001_intake_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-026-foxglove-pharma/01_intake/002_intake_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-026-foxglove-pharma/01_intake/003_intake_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-026-foxglove-pharma/01_intake/004_intake_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-026-foxglove-pharma/01_intake/005_intake_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-026-foxglove-pharma/01_intake/006_intake_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-026-foxglove-pharma/01_intake/007_intake_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-026-foxglove-pharma/01_intake/008_intake_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-026-foxglove-pharma/02_preservation/009_preservation_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-026-foxglove-pharma/02_preservation/010_preservation_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-026-foxglove-pharma/02_preservation/011_preservation_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-026-foxglove-pharma/02_preservation/012_preservation_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-026-foxglove-pharma/02_preservation/013_preservation_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-026-foxglove-pharma/02_preservation/014_preservation_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-026-foxglove-pharma/02_preservation/015_preservation_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-026-foxglove-pharma/02_preservation/016_preservation_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-026-foxglove-pharma/03_interviews/017_interviews_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-026-foxglove-pharma/03_interviews/018_interviews_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-026-foxglove-pharma/03_interviews/019_interviews_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-026-foxglove-pharma/03_interviews/020_interviews_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-026-foxglove-pharma/03_interviews/021_interviews_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-026-foxglove-pharma/03_interviews/022_interviews_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-026-foxglove-pharma/03_interviews/023_interviews_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-026-foxglove-pharma/03_interviews/024_interviews_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-026-foxglove-pharma/04_email_exports/025_email_exports_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-026-foxglove-pharma/04_email_exports/026_email_exports_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-026-foxglove-pharma/04_email_exports/027_email_exports_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-026-foxglove-pharma/04_email_exports/028_email_exports_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-026-foxglove-pharma/04_email_exports/029_email_exports_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-026-foxglove-pharma/04_email_exports/030_email_exports_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-026-foxglove-pharma/04_email_exports/031_email_exports_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-026-foxglove-pharma/04_email_exports/032_email_exports_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-026-foxglove-pharma/05_chat_exports/033_chat_exports_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-026-foxglove-pharma/05_chat_exports/034_chat_exports_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-026-foxglove-pharma/05_chat_exports/035_chat_exports_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-026-foxglove-pharma/05_chat_exports/036_chat_exports_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-026-foxglove-pharma/05_chat_exports/037_chat_exports_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-026-foxglove-pharma/05_chat_exports/038_chat_exports_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-026-foxglove-pharma/05_chat_exports/039_chat_exports_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-026-foxglove-pharma/05_chat_exports/040_chat_exports_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-026-foxglove-pharma/06_expenses/041_expenses_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-026-foxglove-pharma/06_expenses/042_expenses_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-026-foxglove-pharma/06_expenses/043_expenses_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-026-foxglove-pharma/06_expenses/044_expenses_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-026-foxglove-pharma/06_expenses/045_expenses_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-026-foxglove-pharma/06_expenses/046_expenses_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-026-foxglove-pharma/06_expenses/047_expenses_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-026-foxglove-pharma/06_expenses/048_expenses_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-026-foxglove-pharma/07_access_logs/049_access_logs_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-026-foxglove-pharma/07_access_logs/050_access_logs_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-026-foxglove-pharma/07_access_logs/051_access_logs_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-026-foxglove-pharma/07_access_logs/052_access_logs_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-026-foxglove-pharma/07_access_logs/053_access_logs_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-026-foxglove-pharma/07_access_logs/054_access_logs_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-026-foxglove-pharma/07_access_logs/055_access_logs_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-026-foxglove-pharma/07_access_logs/056_access_logs_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-026-foxglove-pharma/08_vendor_files/057_vendor_files_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-026-foxglove-pharma/08_vendor_files/058_vendor_files_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-026-foxglove-pharma/08_vendor_files/059_vendor_files_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-026-foxglove-pharma/08_vendor_files/060_vendor_files_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-026-foxglove-pharma/08_vendor_files/061_vendor_files_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-026-foxglove-pharma/08_vendor_files/062_vendor_files_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-026-foxglove-pharma/08_vendor_files/063_vendor_files_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-026-foxglove-pharma/08_vendor_files/064_vendor_files_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-026-foxglove-pharma/09_policies/065_policies_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-026-foxglove-pharma/09_policies/066_policies_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-026-foxglove-pharma/09_policies/067_policies_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-026-foxglove-pharma/09_policies/068_policies_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-026-foxglove-pharma/09_policies/069_policies_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-026-foxglove-pharma/09_policies/070_policies_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-026-foxglove-pharma/09_policies/071_policies_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-026-foxglove-pharma/09_policies/072_policies_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-026-foxglove-pharma/10_hr_records/073_hr_records_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-026-foxglove-pharma/10_hr_records/074_hr_records_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-026-foxglove-pharma/10_hr_records/075_hr_records_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-026-foxglove-pharma/10_hr_records/076_hr_records_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-026-foxglove-pharma/10_hr_records/077_hr_records_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-026-foxglove-pharma/10_hr_records/078_hr_records_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-026-foxglove-pharma/10_hr_records/079_hr_records_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-026-foxglove-pharma/10_hr_records/080_hr_records_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-026-foxglove-pharma/11_board_reporting/081_board_reporting_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-026-foxglove-pharma/11_board_reporting/082_board_reporting_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-026-foxglove-pharma/11_board_reporting/083_board_reporting_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-026-foxglove-pharma/11_board_reporting/084_board_reporting_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-026-foxglove-pharma/11_board_reporting/085_board_reporting_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-026-foxglove-pharma/11_board_reporting/086_board_reporting_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-026-foxglove-pharma/11_board_reporting/087_board_reporting_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-026-foxglove-pharma/11_board_reporting/088_board_reporting_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-026-foxglove-pharma/12_remediation/089_remediation_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-026-foxglove-pharma/12_remediation/090_remediation_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-026-foxglove-pharma/12_remediation/091_remediation_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-026-foxglove-pharma/12_remediation/092_remediation_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-026-foxglove-pharma/12_remediation/093_remediation_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-026-foxglove-pharma/12_remediation/094_remediation_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-026-foxglove-pharma/12_remediation/095_remediation_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-026-foxglove-pharma/12_remediation/096_remediation_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-026-foxglove-pharma/12_remediation/097_foxglove_pharma_impact_population.xlsx"], "gold_output": {"advice_markdown": "# Decision note — Foxglove speaker-program investigation\n\n## Recommendation\n\nTake scoped repayment and control action for events meeting the complete failure test. The reconciled record supports 8 scoped actions and leaves 4 items on evidence hold.\n\nSelected option: `foxglove-pharma:scoped-evidence`.\n\n## Why this is the supported option\n\nJoin attendance, meal, speaker, content, and escalation records for each program event. Program policy thresholds and required educational purpose apply event by event.\n\n## Supported actions\n\n### CBP-026-01 — vendor due-diligence gap (high)\n\nthe operative cap is $2,722,000.00 under CB-IV-2606-R560; the matched ledger population totals $2,895,660.00 under CB-IV-2606-E974. Identity resolves to ENT-026-1000, revision REV-2026.1 is current, and Mei Whitaker is active with capacity 6.\n\nAction: Register event-specific outcomes and hold programs with missing but nonadverse evidence. Owner: Mei Whitaker; due 2026-09-19.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_intake/001_intake_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/02_preservation/013_preservation_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/04_email_exports/025_email_exports_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/037_chat_exports_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_foxglove_pharma_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-026-02 — expense support deficiency (medium)\n\ndelivery must use notices-foxglove_pharmaceuticals@example.test under CB-IV-2606-R205; the only matched receipt used archive-clearwater_medical_events@example.test under CB-IV-2606-E423. Identity resolves to ENT-026-1001, revision REV-2026.2 is current, and Theo Laurent is active with capacity 6.\n\nAction: Register event-specific outcomes and hold programs with missing but nonadverse evidence. Owner: Theo Laurent; due 2026-09-18.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_intake/002_intake_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/02_preservation/014_preservation_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/04_email_exports/026_email_exports_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/038_chat_exports_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/11_board_reporting/086_board_reporting_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_foxglove_pharma_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-026-03 — split-purchase pattern (medium)\n\nan open exception blocks completion under CB-IV-2606-R476; the current status is open and unresolved under CB-IV-2606-E333. Identity resolves to ENT-026-1002, revision REV-2026.3 is current, and Lena Varga is active with capacity 1.\n\nAction: Register event-specific outcomes and hold programs with missing but nonadverse evidence. Owner: Lena Varga; due 2026-09-17.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_intake/003_intake_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/02_preservation/015_preservation_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/04_email_exports/027_email_exports_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/039_chat_exports_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/08_vendor_files/063_vendor_files_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/10_hr_records/075_hr_records_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_foxglove_pharma_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-026-05 — hotline classification error (high)\n\nthe controlling threshold is 16% under CB-IV-2606-R611; the independently calculated result is 24% under CB-IV-2606-E553. Identity resolves to ENT-026-1004, revision REV-2026.5 is current, and Sofia Bennett is active with capacity 4.\n\nAction: Register event-specific outcomes and hold programs with missing but nonadverse evidence. Owner: Sofia Bennett; due 2026-09-15.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_intake/005_intake_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/03_interviews/017_interviews_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/04_email_exports/029_email_exports_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/06_expenses/041_expenses_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_foxglove_pharma_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-026-07 — deleted-message anomaly (medium)\n\nthe controlled population contains 226 records under CB-IV-2606-R484; the certification covers 207 records under CB-IV-2606-E599. Identity resolves to ENT-026-1006, revision REV-2026.7 is current, and Nora Chen is active with capacity 5.\n\nAction: Register event-specific outcomes and hold programs with missing but nonadverse evidence. Owner: Nora Chen; due 2026-09-13.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_intake/007_intake_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/03_interviews/019_interviews_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/04_email_exports/031_email_exports_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/06_expenses/043_expenses_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/09_policies/067_policies_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_foxglove_pharma_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-026-08 — board-reporting omission (high)\n\nthe permission is limited to Middlesex County, New Jersey under CB-IV-2606-R917; the matched activity occurred in New Jersey under CB-IV-2606-E359. Identity resolves to ENT-026-1007, revision REV-2026.1 is current, and Caleb Hassan is active with capacity 3.\n\nAction: Register event-specific outcomes and hold programs with missing but nonadverse evidence. Owner: Caleb Hassan; due 2026-09-12.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_intake/008_intake_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/03_interviews/020_interviews_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/04_email_exports/032_email_exports_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/06_expenses/044_expenses_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_foxglove_pharma_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-026-10 — off-channel communication (low)\n\ndelivery must use notices-foxglove_pharmaceuticals@example.test under CB-IV-2606-R133; the only matched receipt used archive-clearwater_medical_events@example.test under CB-IV-2606-E472. Identity resolves to ENT-026-1009, revision REV-2026.3 is current, and Samuel Kim is active with capacity 3.\n\nAction: Register event-specific outcomes and hold programs with missing but nonadverse evidence. Owner: Samuel Kim; due 2026-09-19.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/02_preservation/010_preservation_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/03_interviews/022_interviews_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/034_chat_exports_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/06_expenses/046_expenses_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/09_policies/070_policies_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/12_remediation/094_remediation_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_foxglove_pharma_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-026-11 — policy training lapse (medium)\n\nan open exception blocks completion under CB-IV-2606-R786; the current status is open and unresolved under CB-IV-2606-E563. Identity resolves to ENT-026-1010, revision REV-2026.4 is current, and Talia Brooks is active with capacity 6.\n\nAction: Register event-specific outcomes and hold programs with missing but nonadverse evidence. Owner: Talia Brooks; due 2026-09-18.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/02_preservation/011_preservation_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/03_interviews/023_interviews_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/035_chat_exports_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/06_expenses/047_expenses_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/12_remediation/095_remediation_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_foxglove_pharma_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n## Evidence holds\n\n- **CBP-026-04 — badge-log inconsistency**: two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key. Next evidence: an approved immutable entity crosswalk. Sources: `/workspace/documents/01_intake/004_intake_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/02_preservation/016_preservation_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/04_email_exports/028_email_exports_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/040_chat_exports_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/07_access_logs/052_access_logs_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_foxglove_pharma_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-026-06 — undisclosed related party**: the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective. Next evidence: effective approval and an active owner with remaining capacity. Sources: `/workspace/documents/01_intake/006_intake_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/03_interviews/018_interviews_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/04_email_exports/030_email_exports_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/06_expenses/042_expenses_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_foxglove_pharma_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-026-09 — interview timeline conflict**: the current observation does not meet the operative trigger. Next evidence: a current observation that satisfies the operative trigger. Sources: `/workspace/documents/02_preservation/009_preservation_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/03_interviews/021_interviews_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/033_chat_exports_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/06_expenses/045_expenses_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/12_remediation/093_remediation_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_foxglove_pharma_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-026-12 — preservation delay**: two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key. Next evidence: an approved immutable entity crosswalk. Sources: `/workspace/documents/02_preservation/012_preservation_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/03_interviews/024_interviews_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/036_chat_exports_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/06_expenses/048_expenses_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_foxglove_pharma_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n## Alternatives considered\n\n- `foxglove-pharma:shortcut` — Aggregate all repeat speakers and label every event noncompliant.: Use a plausible summary or one source without completing the controlling joins.\n- `foxglove-pharma:blanket-hold` — Freeze the entire matter population: Treat supported actions and genuinely ambiguous records as if they were equally unresolved.\n\n## Assumptions and limits\n\nThis decision is limited to cb100-026-foxglove-pharma, the supplied synthetic records, and the matter state as of 2026-09-20. Similar names, stale revisions, and pending authority are not treated as proof.\n", "decision": {"actions": [{"determination": "the operative cap is $2,722,000.00 under CB-IV-2606-R560; the matched ledger population totals $2,895,660.00 under CB-IV-2606-E974. Identity resolves to ENT-026-1000, revision REV-2026.1 is current, and Mei Whitaker is active with capacity 6.", "due_date": "2026-09-19", "id": "ACT-CBP-026-01", "identity_id": "ENT-026-1000", "issue": "vendor due-diligence gap", "owner": "Mei Whitaker", "portfolio_key": "CBP-026-01", "recommended_action": "Register event-specific outcomes and hold programs with missing but nonadverse evidence. Owner: Mei Whitaker; due 2026-09-19.", "severity": "high", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_intake/001_intake_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/02_preservation/013_preservation_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/04_email_exports/025_email_exports_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/037_chat_exports_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_foxglove_pharma_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "delivery must use notices-foxglove_pharmaceuticals@example.test under CB-IV-2606-R205; the only matched receipt used archive-clearwater_medical_events@example.test under CB-IV-2606-E423. Identity resolves to ENT-026-1001, revision REV-2026.2 is current, and Theo Laurent is active with capacity 6.", "due_date": "2026-09-18", "id": "ACT-CBP-026-02", "identity_id": "ENT-026-1001", "issue": "expense support deficiency", "owner": "Theo Laurent", "portfolio_key": "CBP-026-02", "recommended_action": "Register event-specific outcomes and hold programs with missing but nonadverse evidence. Owner: Theo Laurent; due 2026-09-18.", "severity": "medium", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_intake/002_intake_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/02_preservation/014_preservation_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/04_email_exports/026_email_exports_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/038_chat_exports_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/11_board_reporting/086_board_reporting_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_foxglove_pharma_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "an open exception blocks completion under CB-IV-2606-R476; the current status is open and unresolved under CB-IV-2606-E333. Identity resolves to ENT-026-1002, revision REV-2026.3 is current, and Lena Varga is active with capacity 1.", "due_date": "2026-09-17", "id": "ACT-CBP-026-03", "identity_id": "ENT-026-1002", "issue": "split-purchase pattern", "owner": "Lena Varga", "portfolio_key": "CBP-026-03", "recommended_action": "Register event-specific outcomes and hold programs with missing but nonadverse evidence. Owner: Lena Varga; due 2026-09-17.", "severity": "medium", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_intake/003_intake_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/02_preservation/015_preservation_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/04_email_exports/027_email_exports_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/039_chat_exports_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/08_vendor_files/063_vendor_files_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/10_hr_records/075_hr_records_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_foxglove_pharma_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "the controlling threshold is 16% under CB-IV-2606-R611; the independently calculated result is 24% under CB-IV-2606-E553. Identity resolves to ENT-026-1004, revision REV-2026.5 is current, and Sofia Bennett is active with capacity 4.", "due_date": "2026-09-15", "id": "ACT-CBP-026-05", "identity_id": "ENT-026-1004", "issue": "hotline classification error", "owner": "Sofia Bennett", "portfolio_key": "CBP-026-05", "recommended_action": "Register event-specific outcomes and hold programs with missing but nonadverse evidence. Owner: Sofia Bennett; due 2026-09-15.", "severity": "high", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_intake/005_intake_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/03_interviews/017_interviews_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/04_email_exports/029_email_exports_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/06_expenses/041_expenses_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_foxglove_pharma_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "the controlled population contains 226 records under CB-IV-2606-R484; the certification covers 207 records under CB-IV-2606-E599. Identity resolves to ENT-026-1006, revision REV-2026.7 is current, and Nora Chen is active with capacity 5.", "due_date": "2026-09-13", "id": "ACT-CBP-026-07", "identity_id": "ENT-026-1006", "issue": "deleted-message anomaly", "owner": "Nora Chen", "portfolio_key": "CBP-026-07", "recommended_action": "Register event-specific outcomes and hold programs with missing but nonadverse evidence. Owner: Nora Chen; due 2026-09-13.", "severity": "medium", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_intake/007_intake_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/03_interviews/019_interviews_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/04_email_exports/031_email_exports_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/06_expenses/043_expenses_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/09_policies/067_policies_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_foxglove_pharma_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "the permission is limited to Middlesex County, New Jersey under CB-IV-2606-R917; the matched activity occurred in New Jersey under CB-IV-2606-E359. Identity resolves to ENT-026-1007, revision REV-2026.1 is current, and Caleb Hassan is active with capacity 3.", "due_date": "2026-09-12", "id": "ACT-CBP-026-08", "identity_id": "ENT-026-1007", "issue": "board-reporting omission", "owner": "Caleb Hassan", "portfolio_key": "CBP-026-08", "recommended_action": "Register event-specific outcomes and hold programs with missing but nonadverse evidence. Owner: Caleb Hassan; due 2026-09-12.", "severity": "high", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_intake/008_intake_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/03_interviews/020_interviews_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/04_email_exports/032_email_exports_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/06_expenses/044_expenses_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_foxglove_pharma_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "delivery must use notices-foxglove_pharmaceuticals@example.test under CB-IV-2606-R133; the only matched receipt used archive-clearwater_medical_events@example.test under CB-IV-2606-E472. Identity resolves to ENT-026-1009, revision REV-2026.3 is current, and Samuel Kim is active with capacity 3.", "due_date": "2026-09-19", "id": "ACT-CBP-026-10", "identity_id": "ENT-026-1009", "issue": "off-channel communication", "owner": "Samuel Kim", "portfolio_key": "CBP-026-10", "recommended_action": "Register event-specific outcomes and hold programs with missing but nonadverse evidence. Owner: Samuel Kim; due 2026-09-19.", "severity": "low", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_preservation/010_preservation_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/03_interviews/022_interviews_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/034_chat_exports_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/06_expenses/046_expenses_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/09_policies/070_policies_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/094_remediation_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_foxglove_pharma_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "an open exception blocks completion under CB-IV-2606-R786; the current status is open and unresolved under CB-IV-2606-E563. Identity resolves to ENT-026-1010, revision REV-2026.4 is current, and Talia Brooks is active with capacity 6.", "due_date": "2026-09-18", "id": "ACT-CBP-026-11", "identity_id": "ENT-026-1010", "issue": "policy training lapse", "owner": "Talia Brooks", "portfolio_key": "CBP-026-11", "recommended_action": "Register event-specific outcomes and hold programs with missing but nonadverse evidence. Owner: Talia Brooks; due 2026-09-18.", "severity": "medium", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_preservation/011_preservation_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/03_interviews/023_interviews_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/035_chat_exports_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/06_expenses/047_expenses_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/095_remediation_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_foxglove_pharma_impact_population.xlsx"]}], "as_of": "2026-09-20", "decision": {"alternatives_considered": ["foxglove-pharma:shortcut", "foxglove-pharma:blanket-hold"], "question": "Which Foxglove programs require repayment, discipline, or further review?", "rationale": "The four-part causal test supports 8 scoped actions and leaves 4 records on evidence hold. Program policy thresholds and required educational purpose apply event by event.", "recommendation": "Take scoped repayment and control action for events meeting the complete failure test.", "selected_option_id": "foxglove-pharma:scoped-evidence"}, "holds": [{"id": "HOLD-CBP-026-04", "issue": "badge-log inconsistency", "portfolio_key": "CBP-026-04", "reason": "two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key", "required_next_evidence": "an approved immutable entity crosswalk", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_intake/004_intake_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/02_preservation/016_preservation_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/04_email_exports/028_email_exports_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/040_chat_exports_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/07_access_logs/052_access_logs_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_foxglove_pharma_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-026-06", "issue": "undisclosed related party", "portfolio_key": "CBP-026-06", "reason": "the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective", "required_next_evidence": "effective approval and an active owner with remaining capacity", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_intake/006_intake_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/03_interviews/018_interviews_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/04_email_exports/030_email_exports_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/06_expenses/042_expenses_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_foxglove_pharma_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-026-09", "issue": "interview timeline conflict", "portfolio_key": "CBP-026-09", "reason": "the current observation does not meet the operative trigger", "required_next_evidence": "a current observation that satisfies the operative trigger", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_preservation/009_preservation_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/03_interviews/021_interviews_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/033_chat_exports_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/06_expenses/045_expenses_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/093_remediation_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_foxglove_pharma_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-026-12", "issue": "preservation delay", "portfolio_key": "CBP-026-12", "reason": "two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key", "required_next_evidence": "an approved immutable entity crosswalk", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_preservation/012_preservation_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/03_interviews/024_interviews_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/036_chat_exports_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/06_expenses/048_expenses_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_foxglove_pharma_impact_population.xlsx"]}], "matter_number": "CB-IV-2606", "prepared_for": "Foxglove Pharmaceuticals", "schema_version": "counselbench.decision.v3", "task_id": "cb100-026-foxglove-pharma"}, "matter_register": {"matter_number": "CB-IV-2606", "rows": [{"decision_option_id": "foxglove-pharma:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-19", "issue": "vendor due-diligence gap", "matter_number": "CB-IV-2606", "owner": "Mei Whitaker", "portfolio_key": "CBP-026-01", "row_id": "REG-CBP-026-01", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_intake/001_intake_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/02_preservation/013_preservation_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/04_email_exports/025_email_exports_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/037_chat_exports_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_foxglove_pharma_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "foxglove-pharma:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-18", "issue": "expense support deficiency", "matter_number": "CB-IV-2606", "owner": "Theo Laurent", "portfolio_key": "CBP-026-02", "row_id": "REG-CBP-026-02", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_intake/002_intake_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/02_preservation/014_preservation_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/04_email_exports/026_email_exports_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/038_chat_exports_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/11_board_reporting/086_board_reporting_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_foxglove_pharma_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "foxglove-pharma:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-17", "issue": "split-purchase pattern", "matter_number": "CB-IV-2606", "owner": "Lena Varga", "portfolio_key": "CBP-026-03", "row_id": "REG-CBP-026-03", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_intake/003_intake_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/02_preservation/015_preservation_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/04_email_exports/027_email_exports_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/039_chat_exports_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/08_vendor_files/063_vendor_files_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/10_hr_records/075_hr_records_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_foxglove_pharma_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "foxglove-pharma:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key", "issue": "badge-log inconsistency", "matter_number": "CB-IV-2606", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-026-04", "row_id": "REG-CBP-026-04", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_intake/004_intake_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/02_preservation/016_preservation_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/04_email_exports/028_email_exports_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/040_chat_exports_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/07_access_logs/052_access_logs_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_foxglove_pharma_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "foxglove-pharma:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-15", "issue": "hotline classification error", "matter_number": "CB-IV-2606", "owner": "Sofia Bennett", "portfolio_key": "CBP-026-05", "row_id": "REG-CBP-026-05", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_intake/005_intake_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/03_interviews/017_interviews_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/04_email_exports/029_email_exports_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/06_expenses/041_expenses_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_foxglove_pharma_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "foxglove-pharma:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective", "issue": "undisclosed related party", "matter_number": "CB-IV-2606", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-026-06", "row_id": "REG-CBP-026-06", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_intake/006_intake_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/03_interviews/018_interviews_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/04_email_exports/030_email_exports_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/06_expenses/042_expenses_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_foxglove_pharma_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "foxglove-pharma:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-13", "issue": "deleted-message anomaly", "matter_number": "CB-IV-2606", "owner": "Nora Chen", "portfolio_key": "CBP-026-07", "row_id": "REG-CBP-026-07", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_intake/007_intake_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/03_interviews/019_interviews_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/04_email_exports/031_email_exports_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/06_expenses/043_expenses_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/09_policies/067_policies_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_foxglove_pharma_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "foxglove-pharma:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-12", "issue": "board-reporting omission", "matter_number": "CB-IV-2606", "owner": "Caleb Hassan", "portfolio_key": "CBP-026-08", "row_id": "REG-CBP-026-08", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_intake/008_intake_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/03_interviews/020_interviews_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/04_email_exports/032_email_exports_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/06_expenses/044_expenses_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_foxglove_pharma_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "foxglove-pharma:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "the current observation does not meet the operative trigger", "issue": "interview timeline conflict", "matter_number": "CB-IV-2606", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-026-09", "row_id": "REG-CBP-026-09", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_preservation/009_preservation_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/03_interviews/021_interviews_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/033_chat_exports_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/06_expenses/045_expenses_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/093_remediation_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_foxglove_pharma_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "foxglove-pharma:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-19", "issue": "off-channel communication", "matter_number": "CB-IV-2606", "owner": "Samuel Kim", "portfolio_key": "CBP-026-10", "row_id": "REG-CBP-026-10", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_preservation/010_preservation_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/03_interviews/022_interviews_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/034_chat_exports_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/06_expenses/046_expenses_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/09_policies/070_policies_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/094_remediation_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_foxglove_pharma_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "foxglove-pharma:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-18", "issue": "policy training lapse", "matter_number": "CB-IV-2606", "owner": "Talia Brooks", "portfolio_key": "CBP-026-11", "row_id": "REG-CBP-026-11", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_preservation/011_preservation_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/03_interviews/023_interviews_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/035_chat_exports_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/06_expenses/047_expenses_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/095_remediation_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_foxglove_pharma_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "foxglove-pharma:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key", "issue": "preservation delay", "matter_number": "CB-IV-2606", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-026-12", "row_id": "REG-CBP-026-12", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_preservation/012_preservation_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/03_interviews/024_interviews_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/036_chat_exports_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/06_expenses/048_expenses_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_foxglove_pharma_impact_population.xlsx"]}], "schema_version": "counselbench.matter-register.v3", "task_id": "cb100-026-foxglove-pharma"}}, "metadata": {"benchmark": "CounselBench-100", "code_license": "Apache-2.0", "data_license": "CC-BY-4.0", "deadline": "2026-09-20", "document_count": 97, "evidence_holds": 4, "jurisdiction": "New Jersey", "matter_number": "CB-IV-2606", "mcp_commit": "9a96ea6e5913736f92b88345bf51caeaaa8e719f", "mcp_package": "@modelcontextprotocol/server-filesystem@2026.7.10", "practice_area": "internal-investigations", "reference_tool_calls": 79, "required_evidence_reads": 59, "supported_actions": 8, "synthetic": true, "venue": "Middlesex County, New Jersey", "version": "3.1.0"}, "prompt": "I am about to brief the decision makers and need the source record reconciled first. Which Foxglove programs require repayment, discipline, or further review? Attendance logs, meal receipts, and speaker agreements suggest repeat programs with missing educational content and incomplete escalation. The team needs the call by 2026-09-20. Record the outcome the source hierarchy supports and explain the alternatives we should not take.", "rubric": {"criteria": [{"category": "investigation", "description": "Inventory the production and use targeted searches to locate records across native formats.", "id": "investigation.discover_production"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Complete every task-specific identity, authority, operations, and approval read before the first state transition.", "id": "investigation.read_before_write"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Inspect designated source metadata before relying on those records.", "id": "investigation.custody_before_write"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "Select the supported option 'foxglove-pharma:scoped-evidence' after applying the four-part test.", "id": "decision.selected_option"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "Identify both rejected approaches and explain why a one-source shortcut and a blanket hold are wrong.", "id": "decision.alternatives"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-026-01 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_intake/001_intake_source_export.md rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-026-01.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_preservation/013_preservation_source_export.json for vendor due-diligence gap.", "id": "investigation.CBP-026-01.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_email_exports/025_email_exports_source_export.md to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-026-01.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/037_chat_exports_source_export.json.", "id": "investigation.CBP-026-01.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-026-01 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-026-01.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-026-01 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-026-01.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-026-02 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_intake/002_intake_source_export.txt rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-026-02.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_preservation/014_preservation_source_export.xml for expense support deficiency.", "id": "investigation.CBP-026-02.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_email_exports/026_email_exports_source_export.txt to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-026-02.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/038_chat_exports_source_export.xml.", "id": "investigation.CBP-026-02.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-026-02 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-026-02.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-026-02 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-026-02.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-026-03 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_intake/003_intake_source_export.eml rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-026-03.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_preservation/015_preservation_source_export.html for split-purchase pattern.", "id": "investigation.CBP-026-03.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_email_exports/027_email_exports_source_export.eml to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-026-03.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/039_chat_exports_source_export.html.", "id": "investigation.CBP-026-03.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-026-03 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-026-03.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-026-03 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-026-03.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-026-04 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_intake/004_intake_source_export.csv rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-026-04.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_preservation/016_preservation_source_export.pdf for badge-log inconsistency.", "id": "investigation.CBP-026-04.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_email_exports/028_email_exports_source_export.csv to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-026-04.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/040_chat_exports_source_export.pdf.", "id": "investigation.CBP-026-04.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-026-04 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key.", "id": "decision.CBP-026-04.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-026-04 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-026-04.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-026-05 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_intake/005_intake_source_export.json rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-026-05.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_interviews/017_interviews_source_export.md for hotline classification error.", "id": "investigation.CBP-026-05.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_email_exports/029_email_exports_source_export.json to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-026-05.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_expenses/041_expenses_source_export.md.", "id": "investigation.CBP-026-05.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-026-05 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-026-05.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-026-05 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-026-05.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-026-06 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_intake/006_intake_source_export.xml rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-026-06.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_interviews/018_interviews_source_export.txt for undisclosed related party.", "id": "investigation.CBP-026-06.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_email_exports/030_email_exports_source_export.xml to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-026-06.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_expenses/042_expenses_source_export.txt.", "id": "investigation.CBP-026-06.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-026-06 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective.", "id": "decision.CBP-026-06.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-026-06 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-026-06.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-026-07 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_intake/007_intake_source_export.html rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-026-07.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_interviews/019_interviews_source_export.eml for deleted-message anomaly.", "id": "investigation.CBP-026-07.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_email_exports/031_email_exports_source_export.html to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-026-07.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_expenses/043_expenses_source_export.eml.", "id": "investigation.CBP-026-07.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-026-07 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-026-07.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-026-07 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-026-07.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-026-08 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_intake/008_intake_source_export.pdf rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-026-08.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_interviews/020_interviews_source_export.csv for board-reporting omission.", "id": "investigation.CBP-026-08.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_email_exports/032_email_exports_source_export.pdf to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-026-08.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_expenses/044_expenses_source_export.csv.", "id": "investigation.CBP-026-08.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-026-08 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-026-08.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-026-08 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-026-08.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-026-09 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_preservation/009_preservation_source_export.md rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-026-09.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_interviews/021_interviews_source_export.json for interview timeline conflict.", "id": "investigation.CBP-026-09.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/033_chat_exports_source_export.md to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-026-09.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_expenses/045_expenses_source_export.json.", "id": "investigation.CBP-026-09.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-026-09 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is the current observation does not meet the operative trigger.", "id": "decision.CBP-026-09.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-026-09 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-026-09.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-026-10 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_preservation/010_preservation_source_export.txt rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-026-10.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_interviews/022_interviews_source_export.xml for off-channel communication.", "id": "investigation.CBP-026-10.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/034_chat_exports_source_export.txt to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-026-10.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_expenses/046_expenses_source_export.xml.", "id": "investigation.CBP-026-10.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-026-10 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-026-10.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-026-10 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-026-10.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-026-11 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_preservation/011_preservation_source_export.eml rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-026-11.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_interviews/023_interviews_source_export.html for policy training lapse.", "id": "investigation.CBP-026-11.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/035_chat_exports_source_export.eml to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-026-11.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_expenses/047_expenses_source_export.html.", "id": "investigation.CBP-026-11.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-026-11 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-026-11.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-026-11 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-026-11.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-026-12 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_preservation/012_preservation_source_export.csv rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-026-12.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_interviews/024_interviews_source_export.pdf for preservation delay.", "id": "investigation.CBP-026-12.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/036_chat_exports_source_export.csv to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-026-12.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_expenses/048_expenses_source_export.pdf.", "id": "investigation.CBP-026-12.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-026-12 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key.", "id": "decision.CBP-026-12.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-026-12 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-026-12.register"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Write the exact selected option, supported action population, evidence-hold population, facts, owners, deadlines, and citations.", "id": "state.exact_decision"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create one exact register row per portfolio key with no extra, missing, or modified row.", "id": "state.exact_register"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Leave only the three approved deliverables and perform no extra state-changing write.", "id": "state.write_scope_containment"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Read back decision.json, matter-register.json, and advice.md after their final writes.", "id": "state.postwrite_readback"}, {"category": "answer", "description": "Explain the selected recommendation, supported actions, holds, alternatives, and limitations with exact source anchors.", "id": "answer.decision_note"}], "decision_options": [{"approach": "Use a plausible summary or one source without completing the controlling joins.", "id": "foxglove-pharma:shortcut", "label": "Aggregate all repeat speakers and label every event noncompliant."}, {"approach": "Treat supported actions and genuinely ambiguous records as if they were equally unresolved.", "id": "foxglove-pharma:blanket-hold", "label": "Freeze the entire matter population"}, {"approach": "Apply the exact identity, current-state, authority, and revision test. Register event-specific outcomes and hold programs with missing but nonadverse evidence.", "id": "foxglove-pharma:scoped-evidence", "label": "Take scoped repayment and control action for events meeting the complete failure test."}], "evaluation_narrative": {"authority": "Program policy thresholds and required educational purpose apply event by event.", "observation": "Join attendance, meal, speaker, content, and escalation records for each program event.", "question": "Which Foxglove programs require repayment, discipline, or further review?", "register_action": "Register event-specific outcomes and hold programs with missing but nonadverse evidence."}, "gates": ["all_required_evidence_precedes_first_write", "decision_criteria_complete", "register_state_exact", "write_scope_contained", "all_outputs_verified_by_readback"], "metadata_checks": 6, "metric": "weighted_criteria_score", "minimum_tool_calls": 79, "required_deliverables": ["decision.json", "matter-register.json", "advice.md"], "required_document_reads": 59, "type": "deterministic", "weights": {"advice": 0.15, "decision": 0.35, "investigation": 0.25, "state": 0.25}}, "task_id": "cb100-026-foxglove-pharma", "task_name": "Foxglove speaker-program investigation", "world_id": "counselbench-filesystem-mcp-v3"}
+{"context_files": ["task_files/cb100-027-granite-hospitality/01_intake/001_intake_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-027-granite-hospitality/01_intake/002_intake_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-027-granite-hospitality/01_intake/003_intake_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-027-granite-hospitality/01_intake/004_intake_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-027-granite-hospitality/01_intake/005_intake_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-027-granite-hospitality/01_intake/006_intake_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-027-granite-hospitality/01_intake/007_intake_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-027-granite-hospitality/01_intake/008_intake_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-027-granite-hospitality/02_preservation/009_preservation_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-027-granite-hospitality/02_preservation/010_preservation_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-027-granite-hospitality/02_preservation/011_preservation_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-027-granite-hospitality/02_preservation/012_preservation_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-027-granite-hospitality/02_preservation/013_preservation_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-027-granite-hospitality/02_preservation/014_preservation_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-027-granite-hospitality/02_preservation/015_preservation_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-027-granite-hospitality/02_preservation/016_preservation_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-027-granite-hospitality/03_interviews/017_interviews_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-027-granite-hospitality/03_interviews/018_interviews_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-027-granite-hospitality/03_interviews/019_interviews_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-027-granite-hospitality/03_interviews/020_interviews_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-027-granite-hospitality/03_interviews/021_interviews_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-027-granite-hospitality/03_interviews/022_interviews_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-027-granite-hospitality/03_interviews/023_interviews_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-027-granite-hospitality/03_interviews/024_interviews_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-027-granite-hospitality/04_email_exports/025_email_exports_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-027-granite-hospitality/04_email_exports/026_email_exports_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-027-granite-hospitality/04_email_exports/027_email_exports_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-027-granite-hospitality/04_email_exports/028_email_exports_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-027-granite-hospitality/04_email_exports/029_email_exports_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-027-granite-hospitality/04_email_exports/030_email_exports_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-027-granite-hospitality/04_email_exports/031_email_exports_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-027-granite-hospitality/04_email_exports/032_email_exports_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-027-granite-hospitality/05_chat_exports/033_chat_exports_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-027-granite-hospitality/05_chat_exports/034_chat_exports_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-027-granite-hospitality/05_chat_exports/035_chat_exports_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-027-granite-hospitality/05_chat_exports/036_chat_exports_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-027-granite-hospitality/05_chat_exports/037_chat_exports_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-027-granite-hospitality/05_chat_exports/038_chat_exports_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-027-granite-hospitality/05_chat_exports/039_chat_exports_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-027-granite-hospitality/05_chat_exports/040_chat_exports_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-027-granite-hospitality/06_expenses/041_expenses_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-027-granite-hospitality/06_expenses/042_expenses_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-027-granite-hospitality/06_expenses/043_expenses_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-027-granite-hospitality/06_expenses/044_expenses_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-027-granite-hospitality/06_expenses/045_expenses_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-027-granite-hospitality/06_expenses/046_expenses_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-027-granite-hospitality/06_expenses/047_expenses_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-027-granite-hospitality/06_expenses/048_expenses_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-027-granite-hospitality/07_access_logs/049_access_logs_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-027-granite-hospitality/07_access_logs/050_access_logs_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-027-granite-hospitality/07_access_logs/051_access_logs_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-027-granite-hospitality/07_access_logs/052_access_logs_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-027-granite-hospitality/07_access_logs/053_access_logs_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-027-granite-hospitality/07_access_logs/054_access_logs_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-027-granite-hospitality/07_access_logs/055_access_logs_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-027-granite-hospitality/07_access_logs/056_access_logs_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-027-granite-hospitality/08_vendor_files/057_vendor_files_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-027-granite-hospitality/08_vendor_files/058_vendor_files_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-027-granite-hospitality/08_vendor_files/059_vendor_files_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-027-granite-hospitality/08_vendor_files/060_vendor_files_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-027-granite-hospitality/08_vendor_files/061_vendor_files_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-027-granite-hospitality/08_vendor_files/062_vendor_files_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-027-granite-hospitality/08_vendor_files/063_vendor_files_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-027-granite-hospitality/08_vendor_files/064_vendor_files_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-027-granite-hospitality/09_policies/065_policies_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-027-granite-hospitality/09_policies/066_policies_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-027-granite-hospitality/09_policies/067_policies_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-027-granite-hospitality/09_policies/068_policies_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-027-granite-hospitality/09_policies/069_policies_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-027-granite-hospitality/09_policies/070_policies_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-027-granite-hospitality/09_policies/071_policies_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-027-granite-hospitality/09_policies/072_policies_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-027-granite-hospitality/10_hr_records/073_hr_records_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-027-granite-hospitality/10_hr_records/074_hr_records_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-027-granite-hospitality/10_hr_records/075_hr_records_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-027-granite-hospitality/10_hr_records/076_hr_records_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-027-granite-hospitality/10_hr_records/077_hr_records_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-027-granite-hospitality/10_hr_records/078_hr_records_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-027-granite-hospitality/10_hr_records/079_hr_records_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-027-granite-hospitality/10_hr_records/080_hr_records_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-027-granite-hospitality/11_board_reporting/081_board_reporting_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-027-granite-hospitality/11_board_reporting/082_board_reporting_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-027-granite-hospitality/11_board_reporting/083_board_reporting_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-027-granite-hospitality/11_board_reporting/084_board_reporting_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-027-granite-hospitality/11_board_reporting/085_board_reporting_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-027-granite-hospitality/11_board_reporting/086_board_reporting_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-027-granite-hospitality/11_board_reporting/087_board_reporting_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-027-granite-hospitality/11_board_reporting/088_board_reporting_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-027-granite-hospitality/12_remediation/089_remediation_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-027-granite-hospitality/12_remediation/090_remediation_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-027-granite-hospitality/12_remediation/091_remediation_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-027-granite-hospitality/12_remediation/092_remediation_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-027-granite-hospitality/12_remediation/093_remediation_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-027-granite-hospitality/12_remediation/094_remediation_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-027-granite-hospitality/12_remediation/095_remediation_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-027-granite-hospitality/12_remediation/096_remediation_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-027-granite-hospitality/12_remediation/097_granite_hospitality_impact_population.xlsx"], "gold_output": {"advice_markdown": "# Decision note — Granite hotel renovation inquiry\n\n## Recommendation\n\nEscalate supported conflicts, revalidate affected awards, and correct board reporting. The reconciled record supports 9 scoped actions and leaves 3 items on evidence hold.\n\nSelected option: `granite-hospitality:scoped-evidence`.\n\n## Why this is the supported option\n\nMatch vendor ownership, approvals, project chats, pricing, and board disclosures to each change order. Related-party and approval rules require exact ownership and decision participation evidence.\n\n## Supported actions\n\n### CBP-027-02 — remediation ownership gap (low)\n\nthe controlled population contains 92 records under CB-IV-2607-R840; the certification covers 75 records under CB-IV-2607-E461. Identity resolves to ENT-027-1001, revision REV-2025.2 is current, and Nadine Flores is active with capacity 6.\n\nAction: Create change-order findings only where ownership and participation both join. Owner: Nadine Flores; due 2026-09-21.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_intake/002_intake_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/02_preservation/014_preservation_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/04_email_exports/026_email_exports_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/038_chat_exports_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/11_board_reporting/086_board_reporting_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_granite_hospitality_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-027-03 — approval override (high)\n\nthe permission is limited to Clark County, Nevada under CB-IV-2607-R572; the matched activity occurred in Nevada under CB-IV-2607-E392. Identity resolves to ENT-027-1002, revision REV-2025.3 is current, and Rafael Okafor is active with capacity 4.\n\nAction: Create change-order findings only where ownership and participation both join. Owner: Rafael Okafor; due 2026-09-20.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_intake/003_intake_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/02_preservation/015_preservation_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/04_email_exports/027_email_exports_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/039_chat_exports_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/11_board_reporting/087_board_reporting_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_granite_hospitality_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-027-05 — expense support deficiency (high)\n\ndelivery must use notices-granite_hospitality_trust@example.test under CB-IV-2607-R953; the only matched receipt used archive-sable_ridge_interiors@example.test under CB-IV-2607-E309. Identity resolves to ENT-027-1004, revision REV-2025.5 is current, and Theo Laurent is active with capacity 2.\n\nAction: Create change-order findings only where ownership and participation both join. Owner: Theo Laurent; due 2026-09-18.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_intake/005_intake_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/03_interviews/017_interviews_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/04_email_exports/029_email_exports_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/06_expenses/041_expenses_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_granite_hospitality_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-027-06 — split-purchase pattern (critical)\n\nan open exception blocks completion under CB-IV-2607-R886; the current status is open and unresolved under CB-IV-2607-E199. Identity resolves to ENT-027-1005, revision REV-2025.6 is current, and Lena Varga is active with capacity 5.\n\nAction: Create change-order findings only where ownership and participation both join. Owner: Lena Varga; due 2026-09-17.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_intake/006_intake_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/03_interviews/018_interviews_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/04_email_exports/030_email_exports_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/06_expenses/042_expenses_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_granite_hospitality_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-027-07 — badge-log inconsistency (medium)\n\ncompletion is required by 2025-03-03 under CB-IV-2607-R576; the current event record shows completion on 2025-03-23 under CB-IV-2607-E498. Identity resolves to ENT-027-1006, revision REV-2025.7 is current, and Elliot Mercer is active with capacity 6.\n\nAction: Create change-order findings only where ownership and participation both join. Owner: Elliot Mercer; due 2026-09-16.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_intake/007_intake_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/03_interviews/019_interviews_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/04_email_exports/031_email_exports_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/06_expenses/043_expenses_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_granite_hospitality_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-027-08 — hotline classification error (high)\n\nthe controlling threshold is 3% under CB-IV-2607-R742; the independently calculated result is 5% under CB-IV-2607-E455. Identity resolves to ENT-027-1007, revision REV-2025.1 is current, and Sofia Bennett is active with capacity 5.\n\nAction: Create change-order findings only where ownership and participation both join. Owner: Sofia Bennett; due 2026-09-15.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_intake/008_intake_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/03_interviews/020_interviews_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/04_email_exports/032_email_exports_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/06_expenses/044_expenses_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/10_hr_records/080_hr_records_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_granite_hospitality_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-027-09 — undisclosed related party (medium)\n\napproval must come from Nora Chen under CB-IV-2607-R587; the effective approval record names Rafael Okafor under CB-IV-2607-E975. Identity resolves to ENT-027-1008, revision REV-2025.2 is current, and Micah Sullivan is active with capacity 3.\n\nAction: Create change-order findings only where ownership and participation both join. Owner: Micah Sullivan; due 2026-09-14.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/02_preservation/009_preservation_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/03_interviews/021_interviews_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/033_chat_exports_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/06_expenses/045_expenses_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/11_board_reporting/081_board_reporting_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/12_remediation/093_remediation_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_granite_hospitality_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-027-10 — deleted-message anomaly (medium)\n\nthe controlled population contains 188 records under CB-IV-2607-R706; the certification covers 149 records under CB-IV-2607-E876. Identity resolves to ENT-027-1009, revision REV-2025.3 is current, and Nora Chen is active with capacity 1.\n\nAction: Create change-order findings only where ownership and participation both join. Owner: Nora Chen; due 2026-09-22.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/02_preservation/010_preservation_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/03_interviews/022_interviews_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/034_chat_exports_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/06_expenses/046_expenses_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_granite_hospitality_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-027-12 — interview timeline conflict (high)\n\nthe operative cap is $3,082,000.00 under CB-IV-2607-R725; the matched ledger population totals $3,241,725.00 under CB-IV-2607-E295. Identity resolves to ENT-027-1011, revision REV-2025.5 is current, and Amara Patel is active with capacity 1.\n\nAction: Create change-order findings only where ownership and participation both join. Owner: Amara Patel; due 2026-09-20.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/02_preservation/012_preservation_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/03_interviews/024_interviews_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/036_chat_exports_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/06_expenses/048_expenses_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/09_policies/072_policies_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/12_remediation/096_remediation_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_granite_hospitality_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n## Evidence holds\n\n- **CBP-027-01 — retaliation concern**: the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective. Next evidence: effective approval and an active owner with remaining capacity. Sources: `/workspace/documents/01_intake/001_intake_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/02_preservation/013_preservation_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/04_email_exports/025_email_exports_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/037_chat_exports_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_granite_hospitality_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-027-04 — vendor due-diligence gap**: the current observation does not meet the operative trigger. Next evidence: a current observation that satisfies the operative trigger. Sources: `/workspace/documents/01_intake/004_intake_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/02_preservation/016_preservation_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/04_email_exports/028_email_exports_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/040_chat_exports_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_granite_hospitality_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-027-11 — board-reporting omission**: two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key. Next evidence: an approved immutable entity crosswalk. Sources: `/workspace/documents/02_preservation/011_preservation_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/03_interviews/023_interviews_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/035_chat_exports_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/06_expenses/047_expenses_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_granite_hospitality_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n## Alternatives considered\n\n- `granite-hospitality:blanket-hold` — Freeze the entire matter population: Treat supported actions and genuinely ambiguous records as if they were equally unresolved.\n- `granite-hospitality:shortcut` — Treat any personal acquaintance as a disqualifying related party.: Use a plausible summary or one source without completing the controlling joins.\n\n## Assumptions and limits\n\nThis decision is limited to cb100-027-granite-hospitality, the supplied synthetic records, and the matter state as of 2026-09-23. Similar names, stale revisions, and pending authority are not treated as proof.\n", "decision": {"actions": [{"determination": "the controlled population contains 92 records under CB-IV-2607-R840; the certification covers 75 records under CB-IV-2607-E461. Identity resolves to ENT-027-1001, revision REV-2025.2 is current, and Nadine Flores is active with capacity 6.", "due_date": "2026-09-21", "id": "ACT-CBP-027-02", "identity_id": "ENT-027-1001", "issue": "remediation ownership gap", "owner": "Nadine Flores", "portfolio_key": "CBP-027-02", "recommended_action": "Create change-order findings only where ownership and participation both join. Owner: Nadine Flores; due 2026-09-21.", "severity": "low", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_intake/002_intake_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/02_preservation/014_preservation_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/04_email_exports/026_email_exports_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/038_chat_exports_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/11_board_reporting/086_board_reporting_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_granite_hospitality_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "the permission is limited to Clark County, Nevada under CB-IV-2607-R572; the matched activity occurred in Nevada under CB-IV-2607-E392. Identity resolves to ENT-027-1002, revision REV-2025.3 is current, and Rafael Okafor is active with capacity 4.", "due_date": "2026-09-20", "id": "ACT-CBP-027-03", "identity_id": "ENT-027-1002", "issue": "approval override", "owner": "Rafael Okafor", "portfolio_key": "CBP-027-03", "recommended_action": "Create change-order findings only where ownership and participation both join. Owner: Rafael Okafor; due 2026-09-20.", "severity": "high", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_intake/003_intake_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/02_preservation/015_preservation_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/04_email_exports/027_email_exports_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/039_chat_exports_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/11_board_reporting/087_board_reporting_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_granite_hospitality_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "delivery must use notices-granite_hospitality_trust@example.test under CB-IV-2607-R953; the only matched receipt used archive-sable_ridge_interiors@example.test under CB-IV-2607-E309. Identity resolves to ENT-027-1004, revision REV-2025.5 is current, and Theo Laurent is active with capacity 2.", "due_date": "2026-09-18", "id": "ACT-CBP-027-05", "identity_id": "ENT-027-1004", "issue": "expense support deficiency", "owner": "Theo Laurent", "portfolio_key": "CBP-027-05", "recommended_action": "Create change-order findings only where ownership and participation both join. Owner: Theo Laurent; due 2026-09-18.", "severity": "high", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_intake/005_intake_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/03_interviews/017_interviews_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/04_email_exports/029_email_exports_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/06_expenses/041_expenses_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_granite_hospitality_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "an open exception blocks completion under CB-IV-2607-R886; the current status is open and unresolved under CB-IV-2607-E199. Identity resolves to ENT-027-1005, revision REV-2025.6 is current, and Lena Varga is active with capacity 5.", "due_date": "2026-09-17", "id": "ACT-CBP-027-06", "identity_id": "ENT-027-1005", "issue": "split-purchase pattern", "owner": "Lena Varga", "portfolio_key": "CBP-027-06", "recommended_action": "Create change-order findings only where ownership and participation both join. Owner: Lena Varga; due 2026-09-17.", "severity": "critical", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_intake/006_intake_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/03_interviews/018_interviews_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/04_email_exports/030_email_exports_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/06_expenses/042_expenses_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_granite_hospitality_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "completion is required by 2025-03-03 under CB-IV-2607-R576; the current event record shows completion on 2025-03-23 under CB-IV-2607-E498. Identity resolves to ENT-027-1006, revision REV-2025.7 is current, and Elliot Mercer is active with capacity 6.", "due_date": "2026-09-16", "id": "ACT-CBP-027-07", "identity_id": "ENT-027-1006", "issue": "badge-log inconsistency", "owner": "Elliot Mercer", "portfolio_key": "CBP-027-07", "recommended_action": "Create change-order findings only where ownership and participation both join. Owner: Elliot Mercer; due 2026-09-16.", "severity": "medium", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_intake/007_intake_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/03_interviews/019_interviews_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/04_email_exports/031_email_exports_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/06_expenses/043_expenses_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_granite_hospitality_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "the controlling threshold is 3% under CB-IV-2607-R742; the independently calculated result is 5% under CB-IV-2607-E455. Identity resolves to ENT-027-1007, revision REV-2025.1 is current, and Sofia Bennett is active with capacity 5.", "due_date": "2026-09-15", "id": "ACT-CBP-027-08", "identity_id": "ENT-027-1007", "issue": "hotline classification error", "owner": "Sofia Bennett", "portfolio_key": "CBP-027-08", "recommended_action": "Create change-order findings only where ownership and participation both join. Owner: Sofia Bennett; due 2026-09-15.", "severity": "high", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_intake/008_intake_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/03_interviews/020_interviews_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/04_email_exports/032_email_exports_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/06_expenses/044_expenses_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/10_hr_records/080_hr_records_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_granite_hospitality_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "approval must come from Nora Chen under CB-IV-2607-R587; the effective approval record names Rafael Okafor under CB-IV-2607-E975. Identity resolves to ENT-027-1008, revision REV-2025.2 is current, and Micah Sullivan is active with capacity 3.", "due_date": "2026-09-14", "id": "ACT-CBP-027-09", "identity_id": "ENT-027-1008", "issue": "undisclosed related party", "owner": "Micah Sullivan", "portfolio_key": "CBP-027-09", "recommended_action": "Create change-order findings only where ownership and participation both join. Owner: Micah Sullivan; due 2026-09-14.", "severity": "medium", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_preservation/009_preservation_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/03_interviews/021_interviews_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/033_chat_exports_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/06_expenses/045_expenses_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/11_board_reporting/081_board_reporting_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/093_remediation_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_granite_hospitality_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "the controlled population contains 188 records under CB-IV-2607-R706; the certification covers 149 records under CB-IV-2607-E876. Identity resolves to ENT-027-1009, revision REV-2025.3 is current, and Nora Chen is active with capacity 1.", "due_date": "2026-09-22", "id": "ACT-CBP-027-10", "identity_id": "ENT-027-1009", "issue": "deleted-message anomaly", "owner": "Nora Chen", "portfolio_key": "CBP-027-10", "recommended_action": "Create change-order findings only where ownership and participation both join. Owner: Nora Chen; due 2026-09-22.", "severity": "medium", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_preservation/010_preservation_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/03_interviews/022_interviews_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/034_chat_exports_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/06_expenses/046_expenses_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_granite_hospitality_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "the operative cap is $3,082,000.00 under CB-IV-2607-R725; the matched ledger population totals $3,241,725.00 under CB-IV-2607-E295. Identity resolves to ENT-027-1011, revision REV-2025.5 is current, and Amara Patel is active with capacity 1.", "due_date": "2026-09-20", "id": "ACT-CBP-027-12", "identity_id": "ENT-027-1011", "issue": "interview timeline conflict", "owner": "Amara Patel", "portfolio_key": "CBP-027-12", "recommended_action": "Create change-order findings only where ownership and participation both join. Owner: Amara Patel; due 2026-09-20.", "severity": "high", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_preservation/012_preservation_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/03_interviews/024_interviews_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/036_chat_exports_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/06_expenses/048_expenses_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/09_policies/072_policies_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/096_remediation_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_granite_hospitality_impact_population.xlsx"]}], "as_of": "2026-09-23", "decision": {"alternatives_considered": ["granite-hospitality:blanket-hold", "granite-hospitality:shortcut"], "question": "Is the Granite change-order conflict substantiated, and what governance response should follow?", "rationale": "The four-part causal test supports 9 scoped actions and leaves 3 records on evidence hold. Related-party and approval rules require exact ownership and decision participation evidence.", "recommendation": "Escalate supported conflicts, revalidate affected awards, and correct board reporting.", "selected_option_id": "granite-hospitality:scoped-evidence"}, "holds": [{"id": "HOLD-CBP-027-01", "issue": "retaliation concern", "portfolio_key": "CBP-027-01", "reason": "the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective", "required_next_evidence": "effective approval and an active owner with remaining capacity", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_intake/001_intake_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/02_preservation/013_preservation_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/04_email_exports/025_email_exports_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/037_chat_exports_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_granite_hospitality_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-027-04", "issue": "vendor due-diligence gap", "portfolio_key": "CBP-027-04", "reason": "the current observation does not meet the operative trigger", "required_next_evidence": "a current observation that satisfies the operative trigger", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_intake/004_intake_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/02_preservation/016_preservation_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/04_email_exports/028_email_exports_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/040_chat_exports_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_granite_hospitality_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-027-11", "issue": "board-reporting omission", "portfolio_key": "CBP-027-11", "reason": "two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key", "required_next_evidence": "an approved immutable entity crosswalk", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_preservation/011_preservation_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/03_interviews/023_interviews_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/035_chat_exports_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/06_expenses/047_expenses_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_granite_hospitality_impact_population.xlsx"]}], "matter_number": "CB-IV-2607", "prepared_for": "Granite Hospitality Trust", "schema_version": "counselbench.decision.v3", "task_id": "cb100-027-granite-hospitality"}, "matter_register": {"matter_number": "CB-IV-2607", "rows": [{"decision_option_id": "granite-hospitality:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective", "issue": "retaliation concern", "matter_number": "CB-IV-2607", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-027-01", "row_id": "REG-CBP-027-01", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_intake/001_intake_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/02_preservation/013_preservation_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/04_email_exports/025_email_exports_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/037_chat_exports_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_granite_hospitality_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "granite-hospitality:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-21", "issue": "remediation ownership gap", "matter_number": "CB-IV-2607", "owner": "Nadine Flores", "portfolio_key": "CBP-027-02", "row_id": "REG-CBP-027-02", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_intake/002_intake_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/02_preservation/014_preservation_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/04_email_exports/026_email_exports_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/038_chat_exports_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/11_board_reporting/086_board_reporting_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_granite_hospitality_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "granite-hospitality:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-20", "issue": "approval override", "matter_number": "CB-IV-2607", "owner": "Rafael Okafor", "portfolio_key": "CBP-027-03", "row_id": "REG-CBP-027-03", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_intake/003_intake_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/02_preservation/015_preservation_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/04_email_exports/027_email_exports_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/039_chat_exports_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/11_board_reporting/087_board_reporting_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_granite_hospitality_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "granite-hospitality:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "the current observation does not meet the operative trigger", "issue": "vendor due-diligence gap", "matter_number": "CB-IV-2607", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-027-04", "row_id": "REG-CBP-027-04", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_intake/004_intake_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/02_preservation/016_preservation_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/04_email_exports/028_email_exports_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/040_chat_exports_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_granite_hospitality_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "granite-hospitality:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-18", "issue": "expense support deficiency", "matter_number": "CB-IV-2607", "owner": "Theo Laurent", "portfolio_key": "CBP-027-05", "row_id": "REG-CBP-027-05", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_intake/005_intake_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/03_interviews/017_interviews_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/04_email_exports/029_email_exports_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/06_expenses/041_expenses_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_granite_hospitality_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "granite-hospitality:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-17", "issue": "split-purchase pattern", "matter_number": "CB-IV-2607", "owner": "Lena Varga", "portfolio_key": "CBP-027-06", "row_id": "REG-CBP-027-06", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_intake/006_intake_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/03_interviews/018_interviews_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/04_email_exports/030_email_exports_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/06_expenses/042_expenses_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_granite_hospitality_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "granite-hospitality:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-16", "issue": "badge-log inconsistency", "matter_number": "CB-IV-2607", "owner": "Elliot Mercer", "portfolio_key": "CBP-027-07", "row_id": "REG-CBP-027-07", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_intake/007_intake_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/03_interviews/019_interviews_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/04_email_exports/031_email_exports_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/06_expenses/043_expenses_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_granite_hospitality_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "granite-hospitality:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-15", "issue": "hotline classification error", "matter_number": "CB-IV-2607", "owner": "Sofia Bennett", "portfolio_key": "CBP-027-08", "row_id": "REG-CBP-027-08", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_intake/008_intake_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/03_interviews/020_interviews_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/04_email_exports/032_email_exports_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/06_expenses/044_expenses_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/10_hr_records/080_hr_records_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_granite_hospitality_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "granite-hospitality:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-14", "issue": "undisclosed related party", "matter_number": "CB-IV-2607", "owner": "Micah Sullivan", "portfolio_key": "CBP-027-09", "row_id": "REG-CBP-027-09", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_preservation/009_preservation_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/03_interviews/021_interviews_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/033_chat_exports_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/06_expenses/045_expenses_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/11_board_reporting/081_board_reporting_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/093_remediation_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_granite_hospitality_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "granite-hospitality:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-22", "issue": "deleted-message anomaly", "matter_number": "CB-IV-2607", "owner": "Nora Chen", "portfolio_key": "CBP-027-10", "row_id": "REG-CBP-027-10", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_preservation/010_preservation_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/03_interviews/022_interviews_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/034_chat_exports_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/06_expenses/046_expenses_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_granite_hospitality_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "granite-hospitality:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key", "issue": "board-reporting omission", "matter_number": "CB-IV-2607", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-027-11", "row_id": "REG-CBP-027-11", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_preservation/011_preservation_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/03_interviews/023_interviews_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/035_chat_exports_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/06_expenses/047_expenses_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_granite_hospitality_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "granite-hospitality:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-20", "issue": "interview timeline conflict", "matter_number": "CB-IV-2607", "owner": "Amara Patel", "portfolio_key": "CBP-027-12", "row_id": "REG-CBP-027-12", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_preservation/012_preservation_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/03_interviews/024_interviews_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/036_chat_exports_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/06_expenses/048_expenses_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/09_policies/072_policies_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/096_remediation_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_granite_hospitality_impact_population.xlsx"]}], "schema_version": "counselbench.matter-register.v3", "task_id": "cb100-027-granite-hospitality"}}, "metadata": {"benchmark": "CounselBench-100", "code_license": "Apache-2.0", "data_license": "CC-BY-4.0", "deadline": "2026-09-23", "document_count": 97, "evidence_holds": 3, "jurisdiction": "Nevada", "matter_number": "CB-IV-2607", "mcp_commit": "9a96ea6e5913736f92b88345bf51caeaaa8e719f", "mcp_package": "@modelcontextprotocol/server-filesystem@2026.7.10", "practice_area": "internal-investigations", "reference_tool_calls": 83, "required_evidence_reads": 57, "supported_actions": 9, "synthetic": true, "venue": "Clark County, Nevada", "version": "3.1.0"}, "prompt": "The other side has challenged our internal account of the facts. Is the Granite change-order conflict substantiated, and what governance response should follow? A renovation executive approved change orders for a related vendor while project chats and board reporting omit key ownership information. The team needs the call by 2026-09-23. Leave a concise decision record with exact source references and an owner for each supported next step.", "rubric": {"criteria": [{"category": "investigation", "description": "Inventory the production and use targeted searches to locate records across native formats.", "id": "investigation.discover_production"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Complete every task-specific identity, authority, operations, and approval read before the first state transition.", "id": "investigation.read_before_write"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Inspect designated source metadata before relying on those records.", "id": "investigation.custody_before_write"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "Select the supported option 'granite-hospitality:scoped-evidence' after applying the four-part test.", "id": "decision.selected_option"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "Identify both rejected approaches and explain why a one-source shortcut and a blanket hold are wrong.", "id": "decision.alternatives"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-027-01 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_intake/001_intake_source_export.md rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-027-01.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_preservation/013_preservation_source_export.json for retaliation concern.", "id": "investigation.CBP-027-01.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_email_exports/025_email_exports_source_export.md to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-027-01.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/037_chat_exports_source_export.json.", "id": "investigation.CBP-027-01.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-027-01 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective.", "id": "decision.CBP-027-01.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-027-01 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-027-01.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-027-02 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_intake/002_intake_source_export.txt rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-027-02.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_preservation/014_preservation_source_export.xml for remediation ownership gap.", "id": "investigation.CBP-027-02.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_email_exports/026_email_exports_source_export.txt to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-027-02.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/038_chat_exports_source_export.xml.", "id": "investigation.CBP-027-02.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-027-02 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-027-02.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-027-02 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-027-02.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-027-03 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_intake/003_intake_source_export.eml rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-027-03.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_preservation/015_preservation_source_export.html for approval override.", "id": "investigation.CBP-027-03.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_email_exports/027_email_exports_source_export.eml to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-027-03.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/039_chat_exports_source_export.html.", "id": "investigation.CBP-027-03.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-027-03 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-027-03.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-027-03 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-027-03.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-027-04 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_intake/004_intake_source_export.csv rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-027-04.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_preservation/016_preservation_source_export.pdf for vendor due-diligence gap.", "id": "investigation.CBP-027-04.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_email_exports/028_email_exports_source_export.csv to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-027-04.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/040_chat_exports_source_export.pdf.", "id": "investigation.CBP-027-04.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-027-04 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is the current observation does not meet the operative trigger.", "id": "decision.CBP-027-04.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-027-04 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-027-04.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-027-05 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_intake/005_intake_source_export.json rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-027-05.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_interviews/017_interviews_source_export.md for expense support deficiency.", "id": "investigation.CBP-027-05.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_email_exports/029_email_exports_source_export.json to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-027-05.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_expenses/041_expenses_source_export.md.", "id": "investigation.CBP-027-05.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-027-05 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-027-05.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-027-05 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-027-05.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-027-06 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_intake/006_intake_source_export.xml rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-027-06.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_interviews/018_interviews_source_export.txt for split-purchase pattern.", "id": "investigation.CBP-027-06.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_email_exports/030_email_exports_source_export.xml to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-027-06.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_expenses/042_expenses_source_export.txt.", "id": "investigation.CBP-027-06.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-027-06 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-027-06.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-027-06 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-027-06.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-027-07 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_intake/007_intake_source_export.html rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-027-07.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_interviews/019_interviews_source_export.eml for badge-log inconsistency.", "id": "investigation.CBP-027-07.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_email_exports/031_email_exports_source_export.html to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-027-07.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_expenses/043_expenses_source_export.eml.", "id": "investigation.CBP-027-07.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-027-07 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-027-07.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-027-07 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-027-07.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-027-08 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_intake/008_intake_source_export.pdf rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-027-08.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_interviews/020_interviews_source_export.csv for hotline classification error.", "id": "investigation.CBP-027-08.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_email_exports/032_email_exports_source_export.pdf to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-027-08.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_expenses/044_expenses_source_export.csv.", "id": "investigation.CBP-027-08.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-027-08 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-027-08.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-027-08 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-027-08.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-027-09 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_preservation/009_preservation_source_export.md rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-027-09.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_interviews/021_interviews_source_export.json for undisclosed related party.", "id": "investigation.CBP-027-09.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/033_chat_exports_source_export.md to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-027-09.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_expenses/045_expenses_source_export.json.", "id": "investigation.CBP-027-09.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-027-09 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-027-09.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-027-09 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-027-09.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-027-10 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_preservation/010_preservation_source_export.txt rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-027-10.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_interviews/022_interviews_source_export.xml for deleted-message anomaly.", "id": "investigation.CBP-027-10.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/034_chat_exports_source_export.txt to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-027-10.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_expenses/046_expenses_source_export.xml.", "id": "investigation.CBP-027-10.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-027-10 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-027-10.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-027-10 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-027-10.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-027-11 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_preservation/011_preservation_source_export.eml rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-027-11.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_interviews/023_interviews_source_export.html for board-reporting omission.", "id": "investigation.CBP-027-11.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/035_chat_exports_source_export.eml to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-027-11.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_expenses/047_expenses_source_export.html.", "id": "investigation.CBP-027-11.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-027-11 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key.", "id": "decision.CBP-027-11.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-027-11 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-027-11.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-027-12 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_preservation/012_preservation_source_export.csv rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-027-12.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_interviews/024_interviews_source_export.pdf for interview timeline conflict.", "id": "investigation.CBP-027-12.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/036_chat_exports_source_export.csv to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-027-12.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_expenses/048_expenses_source_export.pdf.", "id": "investigation.CBP-027-12.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-027-12 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-027-12.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-027-12 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-027-12.register"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Write the exact selected option, supported action population, evidence-hold population, facts, owners, deadlines, and citations.", "id": "state.exact_decision"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create one exact register row per portfolio key with no extra, missing, or modified row.", "id": "state.exact_register"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Leave only the three approved deliverables and perform no extra state-changing write.", "id": "state.write_scope_containment"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Read back decision.json, matter-register.json, and advice.md after their final writes.", "id": "state.postwrite_readback"}, {"category": "answer", "description": "Explain the selected recommendation, supported actions, holds, alternatives, and limitations with exact source anchors.", "id": "answer.decision_note"}], "decision_options": [{"approach": "Treat supported actions and genuinely ambiguous records as if they were equally unresolved.", "id": "granite-hospitality:blanket-hold", "label": "Freeze the entire matter population"}, {"approach": "Apply the exact identity, current-state, authority, and revision test. Create change-order findings only where ownership and participation both join.", "id": "granite-hospitality:scoped-evidence", "label": "Escalate supported conflicts, revalidate affected awards, and correct board reporting."}, {"approach": "Use a plausible summary or one source without completing the controlling joins.", "id": "granite-hospitality:shortcut", "label": "Treat any personal acquaintance as a disqualifying related party."}], "evaluation_narrative": {"authority": "Related-party and approval rules require exact ownership and decision participation evidence.", "observation": "Match vendor ownership, approvals, project chats, pricing, and board disclosures to each change order.", "question": "Is the Granite change-order conflict substantiated, and what governance response should follow?", "register_action": "Create change-order findings only where ownership and participation both join."}, "gates": ["all_required_evidence_precedes_first_write", "decision_criteria_complete", "register_state_exact", "write_scope_contained", "all_outputs_verified_by_readback"], "metadata_checks": 10, "metric": "weighted_criteria_score", "minimum_tool_calls": 83, "required_deliverables": ["decision.json", "matter-register.json", "advice.md"], "required_document_reads": 57, "type": "deterministic", "weights": {"advice": 0.15, "decision": 0.35, "investigation": 0.25, "state": 0.25}}, "task_id": "cb100-027-granite-hospitality", "task_name": "Granite hotel renovation inquiry", "world_id": "counselbench-filesystem-mcp-v3"}
+{"context_files": ["task_files/cb100-028-horizon-relief/01_intake/001_intake_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-028-horizon-relief/01_intake/002_intake_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-028-horizon-relief/01_intake/003_intake_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-028-horizon-relief/01_intake/004_intake_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-028-horizon-relief/01_intake/005_intake_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-028-horizon-relief/01_intake/006_intake_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-028-horizon-relief/01_intake/007_intake_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-028-horizon-relief/01_intake/008_intake_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-028-horizon-relief/02_preservation/009_preservation_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-028-horizon-relief/02_preservation/010_preservation_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-028-horizon-relief/02_preservation/011_preservation_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-028-horizon-relief/02_preservation/012_preservation_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-028-horizon-relief/02_preservation/013_preservation_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-028-horizon-relief/02_preservation/014_preservation_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-028-horizon-relief/02_preservation/015_preservation_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-028-horizon-relief/02_preservation/016_preservation_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-028-horizon-relief/03_interviews/017_interviews_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-028-horizon-relief/03_interviews/018_interviews_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-028-horizon-relief/03_interviews/019_interviews_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-028-horizon-relief/03_interviews/020_interviews_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-028-horizon-relief/03_interviews/021_interviews_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-028-horizon-relief/03_interviews/022_interviews_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-028-horizon-relief/03_interviews/023_interviews_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-028-horizon-relief/03_interviews/024_interviews_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-028-horizon-relief/04_email_exports/025_email_exports_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-028-horizon-relief/04_email_exports/026_email_exports_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-028-horizon-relief/04_email_exports/027_email_exports_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-028-horizon-relief/04_email_exports/028_email_exports_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-028-horizon-relief/04_email_exports/029_email_exports_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-028-horizon-relief/04_email_exports/030_email_exports_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-028-horizon-relief/04_email_exports/031_email_exports_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-028-horizon-relief/04_email_exports/032_email_exports_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-028-horizon-relief/05_chat_exports/033_chat_exports_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-028-horizon-relief/05_chat_exports/034_chat_exports_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-028-horizon-relief/05_chat_exports/035_chat_exports_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-028-horizon-relief/05_chat_exports/036_chat_exports_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-028-horizon-relief/05_chat_exports/037_chat_exports_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-028-horizon-relief/05_chat_exports/038_chat_exports_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-028-horizon-relief/05_chat_exports/039_chat_exports_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-028-horizon-relief/05_chat_exports/040_chat_exports_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-028-horizon-relief/06_expenses/041_expenses_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-028-horizon-relief/06_expenses/042_expenses_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-028-horizon-relief/06_expenses/043_expenses_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-028-horizon-relief/06_expenses/044_expenses_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-028-horizon-relief/06_expenses/045_expenses_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-028-horizon-relief/06_expenses/046_expenses_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-028-horizon-relief/06_expenses/047_expenses_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-028-horizon-relief/06_expenses/048_expenses_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-028-horizon-relief/07_access_logs/049_access_logs_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-028-horizon-relief/07_access_logs/050_access_logs_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-028-horizon-relief/07_access_logs/051_access_logs_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-028-horizon-relief/07_access_logs/052_access_logs_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-028-horizon-relief/07_access_logs/053_access_logs_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-028-horizon-relief/07_access_logs/054_access_logs_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-028-horizon-relief/07_access_logs/055_access_logs_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-028-horizon-relief/07_access_logs/056_access_logs_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-028-horizon-relief/08_vendor_files/057_vendor_files_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-028-horizon-relief/08_vendor_files/058_vendor_files_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-028-horizon-relief/08_vendor_files/059_vendor_files_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-028-horizon-relief/08_vendor_files/060_vendor_files_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-028-horizon-relief/08_vendor_files/061_vendor_files_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-028-horizon-relief/08_vendor_files/062_vendor_files_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-028-horizon-relief/08_vendor_files/063_vendor_files_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-028-horizon-relief/08_vendor_files/064_vendor_files_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-028-horizon-relief/09_policies/065_policies_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-028-horizon-relief/09_policies/066_policies_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-028-horizon-relief/09_policies/067_policies_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-028-horizon-relief/09_policies/068_policies_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-028-horizon-relief/09_policies/069_policies_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-028-horizon-relief/09_policies/070_policies_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-028-horizon-relief/09_policies/071_policies_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-028-horizon-relief/09_policies/072_policies_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-028-horizon-relief/10_hr_records/073_hr_records_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-028-horizon-relief/10_hr_records/074_hr_records_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-028-horizon-relief/10_hr_records/075_hr_records_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-028-horizon-relief/10_hr_records/076_hr_records_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-028-horizon-relief/10_hr_records/077_hr_records_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-028-horizon-relief/10_hr_records/078_hr_records_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-028-horizon-relief/10_hr_records/079_hr_records_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-028-horizon-relief/10_hr_records/080_hr_records_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-028-horizon-relief/11_board_reporting/081_board_reporting_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-028-horizon-relief/11_board_reporting/082_board_reporting_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-028-horizon-relief/11_board_reporting/083_board_reporting_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-028-horizon-relief/11_board_reporting/084_board_reporting_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-028-horizon-relief/11_board_reporting/085_board_reporting_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-028-horizon-relief/11_board_reporting/086_board_reporting_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-028-horizon-relief/11_board_reporting/087_board_reporting_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-028-horizon-relief/11_board_reporting/088_board_reporting_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-028-horizon-relief/12_remediation/089_remediation_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-028-horizon-relief/12_remediation/090_remediation_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-028-horizon-relief/12_remediation/091_remediation_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-028-horizon-relief/12_remediation/092_remediation_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-028-horizon-relief/12_remediation/093_remediation_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-028-horizon-relief/12_remediation/094_remediation_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-028-horizon-relief/12_remediation/095_remediation_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-028-horizon-relief/12_remediation/096_remediation_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-028-horizon-relief/12_remediation/097_horizon_relief_impact_population.xlsx"], "gold_output": {"advice_markdown": "# Decision note — Horizon grant-use investigation\n\n## Recommendation\n\nRecover or escalate supported diversions and repair delayed oversight reporting. The reconciled record supports 6 scoped actions and leaves 6 items on evidence hold.\n\nSelected option: `horizon-relief:scoped-evidence`.\n\n## Why this is the supported option\n\nReconcile grant restrictions, purchase flows, delivery proof, emergency approvals, and committee reporting. Grant purpose, emergency authority, and reporting commitments apply to exact disbursements.\n\n## Supported actions\n\n### CBP-028-04 — retaliation concern (low)\n\napproval must come from Sofia Bennett under CB-IV-2608-R932; the effective approval record names Rafael Okafor under CB-IV-2608-E360. Identity resolves to ENT-028-1003, revision REV-2026.4 is current, and Isaac Romero is active with capacity 6.\n\nAction: Register disbursement-specific outcomes and hold deliveries lacking reliable identity evidence. Owner: Isaac Romero; due 2026-09-23.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_intake/004_intake_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/02_preservation/016_preservation_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/04_email_exports/028_email_exports_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/040_chat_exports_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_horizon_relief_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-028-05 — remediation ownership gap (high)\n\nthe controlled population contains 176 records under CB-IV-2608-R184; the certification covers 167 records under CB-IV-2608-E846. Identity resolves to ENT-028-1004, revision REV-2026.5 is current, and Nadine Flores is active with capacity 5.\n\nAction: Register disbursement-specific outcomes and hold deliveries lacking reliable identity evidence. Owner: Nadine Flores; due 2026-09-22.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_intake/005_intake_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/03_interviews/017_interviews_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/04_email_exports/029_email_exports_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/06_expenses/041_expenses_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/07_access_logs/053_access_logs_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/10_hr_records/077_hr_records_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_horizon_relief_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-028-07 — vendor due-diligence gap (medium)\n\nthe operative cap is $2,122,000.00 under CB-IV-2608-R716; the matched ledger population totals $2,237,316.00 under CB-IV-2608-E242. Identity resolves to ENT-028-1006, revision REV-2026.7 is current, and Mei Whitaker is active with capacity 1.\n\nAction: Register disbursement-specific outcomes and hold deliveries lacking reliable identity evidence. Owner: Mei Whitaker; due 2026-09-20.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_intake/007_intake_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/03_interviews/019_interviews_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/04_email_exports/031_email_exports_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/06_expenses/043_expenses_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/10_hr_records/079_hr_records_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/09_policies/067_policies_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_horizon_relief_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-028-08 — expense support deficiency (high)\n\ndelivery must use notices-horizon_relief_foundation@example.test under CB-IV-2608-R513; the only matched receipt used archive-fieldstone_logistics_ngo@example.test under CB-IV-2608-E177. Identity resolves to ENT-028-1007, revision REV-2026.1 is current, and Theo Laurent is active with capacity 1.\n\nAction: Register disbursement-specific outcomes and hold deliveries lacking reliable identity evidence. Owner: Theo Laurent; due 2026-09-19.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_intake/008_intake_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/03_interviews/020_interviews_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/04_email_exports/032_email_exports_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/06_expenses/044_expenses_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/09_policies/068_policies_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_horizon_relief_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-028-09 — split-purchase pattern (medium)\n\nan open exception blocks completion under CB-IV-2608-R513; the current status is open and unresolved under CB-IV-2608-E389. Identity resolves to ENT-028-1008, revision REV-2026.2 is current, and Lena Varga is active with capacity 2.\n\nAction: Register disbursement-specific outcomes and hold deliveries lacking reliable identity evidence. Owner: Lena Varga; due 2026-09-18.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/02_preservation/009_preservation_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/03_interviews/021_interviews_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/033_chat_exports_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/06_expenses/045_expenses_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/11_board_reporting/081_board_reporting_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/08_vendor_files/057_vendor_files_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_horizon_relief_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-028-11 — hotline classification error (low)\n\nthe controlling threshold is 8% under CB-IV-2608-R665; the independently calculated result is 15% under CB-IV-2608-E662. Identity resolves to ENT-028-1010, revision REV-2026.4 is current, and Sofia Bennett is active with capacity 1.\n\nAction: Register disbursement-specific outcomes and hold deliveries lacking reliable identity evidence. Owner: Sofia Bennett; due 2026-09-25.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/02_preservation/011_preservation_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/03_interviews/023_interviews_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/035_chat_exports_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/06_expenses/047_expenses_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/09_policies/071_policies_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_horizon_relief_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n## Evidence holds\n\n- **CBP-028-01 — policy training lapse**: the operational record relies on a superseded control revision. Next evidence: an operational record using the current effective revision. Sources: `/workspace/documents/01_intake/001_intake_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/02_preservation/013_preservation_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/04_email_exports/025_email_exports_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/037_chat_exports_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_horizon_relief_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-028-02 — preservation delay**: two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key. Next evidence: an approved immutable entity crosswalk. Sources: `/workspace/documents/01_intake/002_intake_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/02_preservation/014_preservation_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/04_email_exports/026_email_exports_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/038_chat_exports_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/10_hr_records/074_hr_records_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/11_board_reporting/086_board_reporting_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_horizon_relief_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-028-03 — gift-policy threshold breach**: the current observation does not meet the operative trigger. Next evidence: a current observation that satisfies the operative trigger. Sources: `/workspace/documents/01_intake/003_intake_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/02_preservation/015_preservation_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/04_email_exports/027_email_exports_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/039_chat_exports_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/10_hr_records/075_hr_records_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/07_access_logs/051_access_logs_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_horizon_relief_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-028-06 — approval override**: two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key. Next evidence: an approved immutable entity crosswalk. Sources: `/workspace/documents/01_intake/006_intake_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/03_interviews/018_interviews_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/04_email_exports/030_email_exports_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/06_expenses/042_expenses_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_horizon_relief_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-028-10 — badge-log inconsistency**: two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key. Next evidence: an approved immutable entity crosswalk. Sources: `/workspace/documents/02_preservation/010_preservation_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/03_interviews/022_interviews_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/034_chat_exports_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/06_expenses/046_expenses_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_horizon_relief_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-028-12 — undisclosed related party**: the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective. Next evidence: effective approval and an active owner with remaining capacity. Sources: `/workspace/documents/02_preservation/012_preservation_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/03_interviews/024_interviews_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/036_chat_exports_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/06_expenses/048_expenses_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_horizon_relief_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n## Alternatives considered\n\n- `horizon-relief:shortcut` — Treat every emergency vendor as an impermissible use of grant funds.: Use a plausible summary or one source without completing the controlling joins.\n- `horizon-relief:blanket-hold` — Freeze the entire matter population: Treat supported actions and genuinely ambiguous records as if they were equally unresolved.\n\n## Assumptions and limits\n\nThis decision is limited to cb100-028-horizon-relief, the supplied synthetic records, and the matter state as of 2026-09-27. Similar names, stale revisions, and pending authority are not treated as proof.\n", "decision": {"actions": [{"determination": "approval must come from Sofia Bennett under CB-IV-2608-R932; the effective approval record names Rafael Okafor under CB-IV-2608-E360. Identity resolves to ENT-028-1003, revision REV-2026.4 is current, and Isaac Romero is active with capacity 6.", "due_date": "2026-09-23", "id": "ACT-CBP-028-04", "identity_id": "ENT-028-1003", "issue": "retaliation concern", "owner": "Isaac Romero", "portfolio_key": "CBP-028-04", "recommended_action": "Register disbursement-specific outcomes and hold deliveries lacking reliable identity evidence. Owner: Isaac Romero; due 2026-09-23.", "severity": "low", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_intake/004_intake_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/02_preservation/016_preservation_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/04_email_exports/028_email_exports_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/040_chat_exports_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_horizon_relief_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "the controlled population contains 176 records under CB-IV-2608-R184; the certification covers 167 records under CB-IV-2608-E846. Identity resolves to ENT-028-1004, revision REV-2026.5 is current, and Nadine Flores is active with capacity 5.", "due_date": "2026-09-22", "id": "ACT-CBP-028-05", "identity_id": "ENT-028-1004", "issue": "remediation ownership gap", "owner": "Nadine Flores", "portfolio_key": "CBP-028-05", "recommended_action": "Register disbursement-specific outcomes and hold deliveries lacking reliable identity evidence. Owner: Nadine Flores; due 2026-09-22.", "severity": "high", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_intake/005_intake_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/03_interviews/017_interviews_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/04_email_exports/029_email_exports_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/06_expenses/041_expenses_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/07_access_logs/053_access_logs_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/10_hr_records/077_hr_records_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_horizon_relief_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "the operative cap is $2,122,000.00 under CB-IV-2608-R716; the matched ledger population totals $2,237,316.00 under CB-IV-2608-E242. Identity resolves to ENT-028-1006, revision REV-2026.7 is current, and Mei Whitaker is active with capacity 1.", "due_date": "2026-09-20", "id": "ACT-CBP-028-07", "identity_id": "ENT-028-1006", "issue": "vendor due-diligence gap", "owner": "Mei Whitaker", "portfolio_key": "CBP-028-07", "recommended_action": "Register disbursement-specific outcomes and hold deliveries lacking reliable identity evidence. Owner: Mei Whitaker; due 2026-09-20.", "severity": "medium", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_intake/007_intake_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/03_interviews/019_interviews_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/04_email_exports/031_email_exports_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/06_expenses/043_expenses_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/10_hr_records/079_hr_records_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/09_policies/067_policies_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_horizon_relief_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "delivery must use notices-horizon_relief_foundation@example.test under CB-IV-2608-R513; the only matched receipt used archive-fieldstone_logistics_ngo@example.test under CB-IV-2608-E177. Identity resolves to ENT-028-1007, revision REV-2026.1 is current, and Theo Laurent is active with capacity 1.", "due_date": "2026-09-19", "id": "ACT-CBP-028-08", "identity_id": "ENT-028-1007", "issue": "expense support deficiency", "owner": "Theo Laurent", "portfolio_key": "CBP-028-08", "recommended_action": "Register disbursement-specific outcomes and hold deliveries lacking reliable identity evidence. Owner: Theo Laurent; due 2026-09-19.", "severity": "high", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_intake/008_intake_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/03_interviews/020_interviews_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/04_email_exports/032_email_exports_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/06_expenses/044_expenses_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/09_policies/068_policies_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_horizon_relief_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "an open exception blocks completion under CB-IV-2608-R513; the current status is open and unresolved under CB-IV-2608-E389. Identity resolves to ENT-028-1008, revision REV-2026.2 is current, and Lena Varga is active with capacity 2.", "due_date": "2026-09-18", "id": "ACT-CBP-028-09", "identity_id": "ENT-028-1008", "issue": "split-purchase pattern", "owner": "Lena Varga", "portfolio_key": "CBP-028-09", "recommended_action": "Register disbursement-specific outcomes and hold deliveries lacking reliable identity evidence. Owner: Lena Varga; due 2026-09-18.", "severity": "medium", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_preservation/009_preservation_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/03_interviews/021_interviews_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/033_chat_exports_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/06_expenses/045_expenses_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/11_board_reporting/081_board_reporting_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/08_vendor_files/057_vendor_files_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_horizon_relief_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "the controlling threshold is 8% under CB-IV-2608-R665; the independently calculated result is 15% under CB-IV-2608-E662. Identity resolves to ENT-028-1010, revision REV-2026.4 is current, and Sofia Bennett is active with capacity 1.", "due_date": "2026-09-25", "id": "ACT-CBP-028-11", "identity_id": "ENT-028-1010", "issue": "hotline classification error", "owner": "Sofia Bennett", "portfolio_key": "CBP-028-11", "recommended_action": "Register disbursement-specific outcomes and hold deliveries lacking reliable identity evidence. Owner: Sofia Bennett; due 2026-09-25.", "severity": "low", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_preservation/011_preservation_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/03_interviews/023_interviews_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/035_chat_exports_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/06_expenses/047_expenses_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/09_policies/071_policies_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_horizon_relief_impact_population.xlsx"]}], "as_of": "2026-09-27", "decision": {"alternatives_considered": ["horizon-relief:shortcut", "horizon-relief:blanket-hold"], "question": "Were Horizon grant funds misused, and which vendor or committee actions are required?", "rationale": "The four-part causal test supports 6 scoped actions and leaves 6 records on evidence hold. Grant purpose, emergency authority, and reporting commitments apply to exact disbursements.", "recommendation": "Recover or escalate supported diversions and repair delayed oversight reporting.", "selected_option_id": "horizon-relief:scoped-evidence"}, "holds": [{"id": "HOLD-CBP-028-01", "issue": "policy training lapse", "portfolio_key": "CBP-028-01", "reason": "the operational record relies on a superseded control revision", "required_next_evidence": "an operational record using the current effective revision", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_intake/001_intake_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/02_preservation/013_preservation_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/04_email_exports/025_email_exports_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/037_chat_exports_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_horizon_relief_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-028-02", "issue": "preservation delay", "portfolio_key": "CBP-028-02", "reason": "two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key", "required_next_evidence": "an approved immutable entity crosswalk", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_intake/002_intake_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/02_preservation/014_preservation_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/04_email_exports/026_email_exports_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/038_chat_exports_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/10_hr_records/074_hr_records_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/11_board_reporting/086_board_reporting_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_horizon_relief_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-028-03", "issue": "gift-policy threshold breach", "portfolio_key": "CBP-028-03", "reason": "the current observation does not meet the operative trigger", "required_next_evidence": "a current observation that satisfies the operative trigger", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_intake/003_intake_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/02_preservation/015_preservation_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/04_email_exports/027_email_exports_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/039_chat_exports_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/10_hr_records/075_hr_records_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/07_access_logs/051_access_logs_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_horizon_relief_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-028-06", "issue": "approval override", "portfolio_key": "CBP-028-06", "reason": "two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key", "required_next_evidence": "an approved immutable entity crosswalk", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_intake/006_intake_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/03_interviews/018_interviews_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/04_email_exports/030_email_exports_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/06_expenses/042_expenses_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_horizon_relief_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-028-10", "issue": "badge-log inconsistency", "portfolio_key": "CBP-028-10", "reason": "two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key", "required_next_evidence": "an approved immutable entity crosswalk", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_preservation/010_preservation_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/03_interviews/022_interviews_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/034_chat_exports_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/06_expenses/046_expenses_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_horizon_relief_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-028-12", "issue": "undisclosed related party", "portfolio_key": "CBP-028-12", "reason": "the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective", "required_next_evidence": "effective approval and an active owner with remaining capacity", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_preservation/012_preservation_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/03_interviews/024_interviews_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/036_chat_exports_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/06_expenses/048_expenses_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_horizon_relief_impact_population.xlsx"]}], "matter_number": "CB-IV-2608", "prepared_for": "Horizon Relief Foundation", "schema_version": "counselbench.decision.v3", "task_id": "cb100-028-horizon-relief"}, "matter_register": {"matter_number": "CB-IV-2608", "rows": [{"decision_option_id": "horizon-relief:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "the operational record relies on a superseded control revision", "issue": "policy training lapse", "matter_number": "CB-IV-2608", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-028-01", "row_id": "REG-CBP-028-01", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_intake/001_intake_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/02_preservation/013_preservation_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/04_email_exports/025_email_exports_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/037_chat_exports_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_horizon_relief_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "horizon-relief:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key", "issue": "preservation delay", "matter_number": "CB-IV-2608", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-028-02", "row_id": "REG-CBP-028-02", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_intake/002_intake_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/02_preservation/014_preservation_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/04_email_exports/026_email_exports_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/038_chat_exports_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/10_hr_records/074_hr_records_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/11_board_reporting/086_board_reporting_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_horizon_relief_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "horizon-relief:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "the current observation does not meet the operative trigger", "issue": "gift-policy threshold breach", "matter_number": "CB-IV-2608", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-028-03", "row_id": "REG-CBP-028-03", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_intake/003_intake_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/02_preservation/015_preservation_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/04_email_exports/027_email_exports_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/039_chat_exports_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/10_hr_records/075_hr_records_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/07_access_logs/051_access_logs_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_horizon_relief_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "horizon-relief:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-23", "issue": "retaliation concern", "matter_number": "CB-IV-2608", "owner": "Isaac Romero", "portfolio_key": "CBP-028-04", "row_id": "REG-CBP-028-04", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_intake/004_intake_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/02_preservation/016_preservation_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/04_email_exports/028_email_exports_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/040_chat_exports_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_horizon_relief_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "horizon-relief:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-22", "issue": "remediation ownership gap", "matter_number": "CB-IV-2608", "owner": "Nadine Flores", "portfolio_key": "CBP-028-05", "row_id": "REG-CBP-028-05", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_intake/005_intake_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/03_interviews/017_interviews_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/04_email_exports/029_email_exports_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/06_expenses/041_expenses_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/07_access_logs/053_access_logs_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/10_hr_records/077_hr_records_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_horizon_relief_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "horizon-relief:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key", "issue": "approval override", "matter_number": "CB-IV-2608", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-028-06", "row_id": "REG-CBP-028-06", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_intake/006_intake_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/03_interviews/018_interviews_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/04_email_exports/030_email_exports_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/06_expenses/042_expenses_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_horizon_relief_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "horizon-relief:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-20", "issue": "vendor due-diligence gap", "matter_number": "CB-IV-2608", "owner": "Mei Whitaker", "portfolio_key": "CBP-028-07", "row_id": "REG-CBP-028-07", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_intake/007_intake_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/03_interviews/019_interviews_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/04_email_exports/031_email_exports_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/06_expenses/043_expenses_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/10_hr_records/079_hr_records_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/09_policies/067_policies_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_horizon_relief_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "horizon-relief:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-19", "issue": "expense support deficiency", "matter_number": "CB-IV-2608", "owner": "Theo Laurent", "portfolio_key": "CBP-028-08", "row_id": "REG-CBP-028-08", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_intake/008_intake_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/03_interviews/020_interviews_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/04_email_exports/032_email_exports_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/06_expenses/044_expenses_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/09_policies/068_policies_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_horizon_relief_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "horizon-relief:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-18", "issue": "split-purchase pattern", "matter_number": "CB-IV-2608", "owner": "Lena Varga", "portfolio_key": "CBP-028-09", "row_id": "REG-CBP-028-09", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_preservation/009_preservation_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/03_interviews/021_interviews_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/033_chat_exports_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/06_expenses/045_expenses_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/11_board_reporting/081_board_reporting_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/08_vendor_files/057_vendor_files_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_horizon_relief_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "horizon-relief:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key", "issue": "badge-log inconsistency", "matter_number": "CB-IV-2608", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-028-10", "row_id": "REG-CBP-028-10", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_preservation/010_preservation_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/03_interviews/022_interviews_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/034_chat_exports_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/06_expenses/046_expenses_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_horizon_relief_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "horizon-relief:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-25", "issue": "hotline classification error", "matter_number": "CB-IV-2608", "owner": "Sofia Bennett", "portfolio_key": "CBP-028-11", "row_id": "REG-CBP-028-11", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_preservation/011_preservation_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/03_interviews/023_interviews_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/035_chat_exports_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/06_expenses/047_expenses_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/09_policies/071_policies_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_horizon_relief_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "horizon-relief:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective", "issue": "undisclosed related party", "matter_number": "CB-IV-2608", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-028-12", "row_id": "REG-CBP-028-12", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_preservation/012_preservation_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/03_interviews/024_interviews_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/036_chat_exports_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/06_expenses/048_expenses_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_horizon_relief_impact_population.xlsx"]}], "schema_version": "counselbench.matter-register.v3", "task_id": "cb100-028-horizon-relief"}}, "metadata": {"benchmark": "CounselBench-100", "code_license": "Apache-2.0", "data_license": "CC-BY-4.0", "deadline": "2026-09-27", "document_count": 97, "evidence_holds": 6, "jurisdiction": "District of Columbia", "matter_number": "CB-IV-2608", "mcp_commit": "9a96ea6e5913736f92b88345bf51caeaaa8e719f", "mcp_package": "@modelcontextprotocol/server-filesystem@2026.7.10", "practice_area": "internal-investigations", "reference_tool_calls": 84, "required_evidence_reads": 62, "supported_actions": 6, "synthetic": true, "venue": "Washington, District of Columbia", "version": "3.1.0"}, "prompt": "There is enough noise in this file that a name match or newest-document shortcut will be dangerous. Were Horizon grant funds misused, and which vendor or committee actions are required? Grant funds were rerouted through emergency vendors, with inconsistent delivery evidence and delayed reports to the audit committee. The team needs the call by 2026-09-27. Leave the defensible result in the matter workspace, including any item that must stay on hold for better evidence.", "rubric": {"criteria": [{"category": "investigation", "description": "Inventory the production and use targeted searches to locate records across native formats.", "id": "investigation.discover_production"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Complete every task-specific identity, authority, operations, and approval read before the first state transition.", "id": "investigation.read_before_write"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Inspect designated source metadata before relying on those records.", "id": "investigation.custody_before_write"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "Select the supported option 'horizon-relief:scoped-evidence' after applying the four-part test.", "id": "decision.selected_option"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "Identify both rejected approaches and explain why a one-source shortcut and a blanket hold are wrong.", "id": "decision.alternatives"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-028-01 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_intake/001_intake_source_export.md rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-028-01.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_preservation/013_preservation_source_export.json for policy training lapse.", "id": "investigation.CBP-028-01.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_email_exports/025_email_exports_source_export.md to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-028-01.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/037_chat_exports_source_export.json.", "id": "investigation.CBP-028-01.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-028-01 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is the operational record relies on a superseded control revision.", "id": "decision.CBP-028-01.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-028-01 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-028-01.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-028-02 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_intake/002_intake_source_export.txt rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-028-02.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_preservation/014_preservation_source_export.xml for preservation delay.", "id": "investigation.CBP-028-02.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_email_exports/026_email_exports_source_export.txt to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-028-02.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/038_chat_exports_source_export.xml.", "id": "investigation.CBP-028-02.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-028-02 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key.", "id": "decision.CBP-028-02.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-028-02 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-028-02.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-028-03 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_intake/003_intake_source_export.eml rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-028-03.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_preservation/015_preservation_source_export.html for gift-policy threshold breach.", "id": "investigation.CBP-028-03.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_email_exports/027_email_exports_source_export.eml to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-028-03.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/039_chat_exports_source_export.html.", "id": "investigation.CBP-028-03.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-028-03 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is the current observation does not meet the operative trigger.", "id": "decision.CBP-028-03.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-028-03 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-028-03.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-028-04 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_intake/004_intake_source_export.csv rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-028-04.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_preservation/016_preservation_source_export.pdf for retaliation concern.", "id": "investigation.CBP-028-04.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_email_exports/028_email_exports_source_export.csv to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-028-04.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/040_chat_exports_source_export.pdf.", "id": "investigation.CBP-028-04.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-028-04 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-028-04.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-028-04 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-028-04.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-028-05 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_intake/005_intake_source_export.json rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-028-05.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_interviews/017_interviews_source_export.md for remediation ownership gap.", "id": "investigation.CBP-028-05.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_email_exports/029_email_exports_source_export.json to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-028-05.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_expenses/041_expenses_source_export.md.", "id": "investigation.CBP-028-05.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-028-05 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-028-05.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-028-05 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-028-05.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-028-06 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_intake/006_intake_source_export.xml rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-028-06.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_interviews/018_interviews_source_export.txt for approval override.", "id": "investigation.CBP-028-06.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_email_exports/030_email_exports_source_export.xml to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-028-06.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_expenses/042_expenses_source_export.txt.", "id": "investigation.CBP-028-06.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-028-06 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key.", "id": "decision.CBP-028-06.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-028-06 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-028-06.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-028-07 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_intake/007_intake_source_export.html rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-028-07.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_interviews/019_interviews_source_export.eml for vendor due-diligence gap.", "id": "investigation.CBP-028-07.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_email_exports/031_email_exports_source_export.html to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-028-07.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_expenses/043_expenses_source_export.eml.", "id": "investigation.CBP-028-07.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-028-07 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-028-07.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-028-07 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-028-07.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-028-08 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_intake/008_intake_source_export.pdf rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-028-08.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_interviews/020_interviews_source_export.csv for expense support deficiency.", "id": "investigation.CBP-028-08.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_email_exports/032_email_exports_source_export.pdf to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-028-08.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_expenses/044_expenses_source_export.csv.", "id": "investigation.CBP-028-08.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-028-08 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-028-08.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-028-08 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-028-08.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-028-09 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_preservation/009_preservation_source_export.md rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-028-09.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_interviews/021_interviews_source_export.json for split-purchase pattern.", "id": "investigation.CBP-028-09.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/033_chat_exports_source_export.md to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-028-09.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_expenses/045_expenses_source_export.json.", "id": "investigation.CBP-028-09.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-028-09 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-028-09.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-028-09 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-028-09.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-028-10 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_preservation/010_preservation_source_export.txt rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-028-10.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_interviews/022_interviews_source_export.xml for badge-log inconsistency.", "id": "investigation.CBP-028-10.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/034_chat_exports_source_export.txt to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-028-10.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_expenses/046_expenses_source_export.xml.", "id": "investigation.CBP-028-10.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-028-10 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key.", "id": "decision.CBP-028-10.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-028-10 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-028-10.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-028-11 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_preservation/011_preservation_source_export.eml rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-028-11.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_interviews/023_interviews_source_export.html for hotline classification error.", "id": "investigation.CBP-028-11.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/035_chat_exports_source_export.eml to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-028-11.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_expenses/047_expenses_source_export.html.", "id": "investigation.CBP-028-11.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-028-11 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-028-11.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-028-11 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-028-11.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-028-12 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_preservation/012_preservation_source_export.csv rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-028-12.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_interviews/024_interviews_source_export.pdf for undisclosed related party.", "id": "investigation.CBP-028-12.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/036_chat_exports_source_export.csv to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-028-12.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_expenses/048_expenses_source_export.pdf.", "id": "investigation.CBP-028-12.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-028-12 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective.", "id": "decision.CBP-028-12.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-028-12 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-028-12.register"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Write the exact selected option, supported action population, evidence-hold population, facts, owners, deadlines, and citations.", "id": "state.exact_decision"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create one exact register row per portfolio key with no extra, missing, or modified row.", "id": "state.exact_register"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Leave only the three approved deliverables and perform no extra state-changing write.", "id": "state.write_scope_containment"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Read back decision.json, matter-register.json, and advice.md after their final writes.", "id": "state.postwrite_readback"}, {"category": "answer", "description": "Explain the selected recommendation, supported actions, holds, alternatives, and limitations with exact source anchors.", "id": "answer.decision_note"}], "decision_options": [{"approach": "Apply the exact identity, current-state, authority, and revision test. Register disbursement-specific outcomes and hold deliveries lacking reliable identity evidence.", "id": "horizon-relief:scoped-evidence", "label": "Recover or escalate supported diversions and repair delayed oversight reporting."}, {"approach": "Use a plausible summary or one source without completing the controlling joins.", "id": "horizon-relief:shortcut", "label": "Treat every emergency vendor as an impermissible use of grant funds."}, {"approach": "Treat supported actions and genuinely ambiguous records as if they were equally unresolved.", "id": "horizon-relief:blanket-hold", "label": "Freeze the entire matter population"}], "evaluation_narrative": {"authority": "Grant purpose, emergency authority, and reporting commitments apply to exact disbursements.", "observation": "Reconcile grant restrictions, purchase flows, delivery proof, emergency approvals, and committee reporting.", "question": "Were Horizon grant funds misused, and which vendor or committee actions are required?", "register_action": "Register disbursement-specific outcomes and hold deliveries lacking reliable identity evidence."}, "gates": ["all_required_evidence_precedes_first_write", "decision_criteria_complete", "register_state_exact", "write_scope_contained", "all_outputs_verified_by_readback"], "metadata_checks": 5, "metric": "weighted_criteria_score", "minimum_tool_calls": 84, "required_deliverables": ["decision.json", "matter-register.json", "advice.md"], "required_document_reads": 62, "type": "deterministic", "weights": {"advice": 0.15, "decision": 0.35, "investigation": 0.25, "state": 0.25}}, "task_id": "cb100-028-horizon-relief", "task_name": "Horizon grant-use investigation", "world_id": "counselbench-filesystem-mcp-v3"}
+{"context_files": ["task_files/cb100-029-indigo-telecom/01_intake/001_intake_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-029-indigo-telecom/01_intake/002_intake_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-029-indigo-telecom/01_intake/003_intake_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-029-indigo-telecom/01_intake/004_intake_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-029-indigo-telecom/01_intake/005_intake_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-029-indigo-telecom/01_intake/006_intake_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-029-indigo-telecom/01_intake/007_intake_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-029-indigo-telecom/01_intake/008_intake_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-029-indigo-telecom/02_preservation/009_preservation_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-029-indigo-telecom/02_preservation/010_preservation_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-029-indigo-telecom/02_preservation/011_preservation_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-029-indigo-telecom/02_preservation/012_preservation_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-029-indigo-telecom/02_preservation/013_preservation_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-029-indigo-telecom/02_preservation/014_preservation_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-029-indigo-telecom/02_preservation/015_preservation_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-029-indigo-telecom/02_preservation/016_preservation_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-029-indigo-telecom/03_interviews/017_interviews_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-029-indigo-telecom/03_interviews/018_interviews_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-029-indigo-telecom/03_interviews/019_interviews_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-029-indigo-telecom/03_interviews/020_interviews_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-029-indigo-telecom/03_interviews/021_interviews_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-029-indigo-telecom/03_interviews/022_interviews_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-029-indigo-telecom/03_interviews/023_interviews_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-029-indigo-telecom/03_interviews/024_interviews_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-029-indigo-telecom/04_email_exports/025_email_exports_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-029-indigo-telecom/04_email_exports/026_email_exports_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-029-indigo-telecom/04_email_exports/027_email_exports_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-029-indigo-telecom/04_email_exports/028_email_exports_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-029-indigo-telecom/04_email_exports/029_email_exports_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-029-indigo-telecom/04_email_exports/030_email_exports_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-029-indigo-telecom/04_email_exports/031_email_exports_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-029-indigo-telecom/04_email_exports/032_email_exports_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-029-indigo-telecom/05_chat_exports/033_chat_exports_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-029-indigo-telecom/05_chat_exports/034_chat_exports_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-029-indigo-telecom/05_chat_exports/035_chat_exports_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-029-indigo-telecom/05_chat_exports/036_chat_exports_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-029-indigo-telecom/05_chat_exports/037_chat_exports_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-029-indigo-telecom/05_chat_exports/038_chat_exports_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-029-indigo-telecom/05_chat_exports/039_chat_exports_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-029-indigo-telecom/05_chat_exports/040_chat_exports_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-029-indigo-telecom/06_expenses/041_expenses_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-029-indigo-telecom/06_expenses/042_expenses_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-029-indigo-telecom/06_expenses/043_expenses_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-029-indigo-telecom/06_expenses/044_expenses_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-029-indigo-telecom/06_expenses/045_expenses_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-029-indigo-telecom/06_expenses/046_expenses_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-029-indigo-telecom/06_expenses/047_expenses_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-029-indigo-telecom/06_expenses/048_expenses_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-029-indigo-telecom/07_access_logs/049_access_logs_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-029-indigo-telecom/07_access_logs/050_access_logs_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-029-indigo-telecom/07_access_logs/051_access_logs_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-029-indigo-telecom/07_access_logs/052_access_logs_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-029-indigo-telecom/07_access_logs/053_access_logs_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-029-indigo-telecom/07_access_logs/054_access_logs_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-029-indigo-telecom/07_access_logs/055_access_logs_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-029-indigo-telecom/07_access_logs/056_access_logs_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-029-indigo-telecom/08_vendor_files/057_vendor_files_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-029-indigo-telecom/08_vendor_files/058_vendor_files_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-029-indigo-telecom/08_vendor_files/059_vendor_files_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-029-indigo-telecom/08_vendor_files/060_vendor_files_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-029-indigo-telecom/08_vendor_files/061_vendor_files_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-029-indigo-telecom/08_vendor_files/062_vendor_files_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-029-indigo-telecom/08_vendor_files/063_vendor_files_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-029-indigo-telecom/08_vendor_files/064_vendor_files_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-029-indigo-telecom/09_policies/065_policies_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-029-indigo-telecom/09_policies/066_policies_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-029-indigo-telecom/09_policies/067_policies_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-029-indigo-telecom/09_policies/068_policies_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-029-indigo-telecom/09_policies/069_policies_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-029-indigo-telecom/09_policies/070_policies_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-029-indigo-telecom/09_policies/071_policies_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-029-indigo-telecom/09_policies/072_policies_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-029-indigo-telecom/10_hr_records/073_hr_records_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-029-indigo-telecom/10_hr_records/074_hr_records_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-029-indigo-telecom/10_hr_records/075_hr_records_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-029-indigo-telecom/10_hr_records/076_hr_records_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-029-indigo-telecom/10_hr_records/077_hr_records_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-029-indigo-telecom/10_hr_records/078_hr_records_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-029-indigo-telecom/10_hr_records/079_hr_records_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-029-indigo-telecom/10_hr_records/080_hr_records_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-029-indigo-telecom/11_board_reporting/081_board_reporting_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-029-indigo-telecom/11_board_reporting/082_board_reporting_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-029-indigo-telecom/11_board_reporting/083_board_reporting_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-029-indigo-telecom/11_board_reporting/084_board_reporting_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-029-indigo-telecom/11_board_reporting/085_board_reporting_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-029-indigo-telecom/11_board_reporting/086_board_reporting_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-029-indigo-telecom/11_board_reporting/087_board_reporting_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-029-indigo-telecom/11_board_reporting/088_board_reporting_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-029-indigo-telecom/12_remediation/089_remediation_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-029-indigo-telecom/12_remediation/090_remediation_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-029-indigo-telecom/12_remediation/091_remediation_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-029-indigo-telecom/12_remediation/092_remediation_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-029-indigo-telecom/12_remediation/093_remediation_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-029-indigo-telecom/12_remediation/094_remediation_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-029-indigo-telecom/12_remediation/095_remediation_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-029-indigo-telecom/12_remediation/096_remediation_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-029-indigo-telecom/12_remediation/097_indigo_telecom_impact_population.xlsx"], "gold_output": {"advice_markdown": "# Decision note — Indigo channel-rebate inquiry\n\n## Recommendation\n\nReverse and escalate only transactions that meet the combined control test. The reconciled record supports 5 scoped actions and leaves 7 items on evidence hold.\n\nSelected option: `indigo-telecom:scoped-evidence`.\n\n## Why this is the supported option\n\nJoin rebate support, duplicate claims, chats, approval history, and beneficial ownership by transaction. Rebate policy and conflict controls require both an invalid override and reliable counterparty identity.\n\n## Supported actions\n\n### CBP-029-02 — interview timeline conflict (high)\n\nthe operative cap is $1,522,000.00 under CB-IV-2609-R847; the matched ledger population totals $1,545,347.00 under CB-IV-2609-E938. Identity resolves to ENT-029-1001, revision REV-2025.2 is current, and Maya Ellison is active with capacity 2.\n\nAction: Create transaction rows for proven defects and separate ownership-evidence holds. Owner: Maya Ellison; due 2026-09-28.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_intake/002_intake_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/02_preservation/014_preservation_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/04_email_exports/026_email_exports_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/038_chat_exports_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_indigo_telecom_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-029-05 — preservation delay (critical)\n\ncompletion is required by 2026-01-15 under CB-IV-2609-R294; the current event record shows completion on 2026-02-18 under CB-IV-2609-E746. Identity resolves to ENT-029-1004, revision REV-2025.5 is current, and Owen Delgado is active with capacity 3.\n\nAction: Create transaction rows for proven defects and separate ownership-evidence holds. Owner: Owen Delgado; due 2026-09-25.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_intake/005_intake_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/03_interviews/017_interviews_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/04_email_exports/029_email_exports_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/06_expenses/041_expenses_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_indigo_telecom_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-029-06 — gift-policy threshold breach (medium)\n\nthe controlling threshold is 4% under CB-IV-2609-R527; the independently calculated result is 7% under CB-IV-2609-E125. Identity resolves to ENT-029-1005, revision REV-2025.6 is current, and Priya Raman is active with capacity 2.\n\nAction: Create transaction rows for proven defects and separate ownership-evidence holds. Owner: Priya Raman; due 2026-09-24.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_intake/006_intake_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/03_interviews/018_interviews_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/04_email_exports/030_email_exports_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/06_expenses/042_expenses_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_indigo_telecom_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-029-07 — retaliation concern (high)\n\napproval must come from Lena Varga under CB-IV-2609-R646; the effective approval record names Henry Cho under CB-IV-2609-E820. Identity resolves to ENT-029-1006, revision REV-2025.7 is current, and Isaac Romero is active with capacity 6.\n\nAction: Create transaction rows for proven defects and separate ownership-evidence holds. Owner: Isaac Romero; due 2026-09-23.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_intake/007_intake_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/03_interviews/019_interviews_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/04_email_exports/031_email_exports_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/06_expenses/043_expenses_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_indigo_telecom_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-029-08 — remediation ownership gap (high)\n\nthe controlled population contains 223 records under CB-IV-2609-R571; the certification covers 206 records under CB-IV-2609-E868. Identity resolves to ENT-029-1007, revision REV-2025.1 is current, and Nadine Flores is active with capacity 1.\n\nAction: Create transaction rows for proven defects and separate ownership-evidence holds. Owner: Nadine Flores; due 2026-09-22.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_intake/008_intake_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/03_interviews/020_interviews_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/04_email_exports/032_email_exports_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/06_expenses/044_expenses_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/09_policies/068_policies_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/10_hr_records/080_hr_records_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_indigo_telecom_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n## Evidence holds\n\n- **CBP-029-01 — board-reporting omission**: two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key. Next evidence: an approved immutable entity crosswalk. Sources: `/workspace/documents/01_intake/001_intake_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/02_preservation/013_preservation_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/04_email_exports/025_email_exports_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/037_chat_exports_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/11_board_reporting/085_board_reporting_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_indigo_telecom_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-029-03 — off-channel communication**: the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective. Next evidence: effective approval and an active owner with remaining capacity. Sources: `/workspace/documents/01_intake/003_intake_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/02_preservation/015_preservation_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/04_email_exports/027_email_exports_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/039_chat_exports_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_indigo_telecom_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-029-04 — policy training lapse**: the operational record relies on a superseded control revision. Next evidence: an operational record using the current effective revision. Sources: `/workspace/documents/01_intake/004_intake_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/02_preservation/016_preservation_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/04_email_exports/028_email_exports_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/040_chat_exports_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_indigo_telecom_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-029-09 — approval override**: two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key. Next evidence: an approved immutable entity crosswalk. Sources: `/workspace/documents/02_preservation/009_preservation_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/03_interviews/021_interviews_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/033_chat_exports_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/06_expenses/045_expenses_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/11_board_reporting/081_board_reporting_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_indigo_telecom_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-029-10 — vendor due-diligence gap**: the current observation does not meet the operative trigger. Next evidence: a current observation that satisfies the operative trigger. Sources: `/workspace/documents/02_preservation/010_preservation_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/03_interviews/022_interviews_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/034_chat_exports_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/06_expenses/046_expenses_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/08_vendor_files/058_vendor_files_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/09_policies/070_policies_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_indigo_telecom_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-029-11 — expense support deficiency**: the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective. Next evidence: effective approval and an active owner with remaining capacity. Sources: `/workspace/documents/02_preservation/011_preservation_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/03_interviews/023_interviews_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/035_chat_exports_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/06_expenses/047_expenses_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_indigo_telecom_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-029-12 — split-purchase pattern**: the operational record relies on a superseded control revision. Next evidence: an operational record using the current effective revision. Sources: `/workspace/documents/02_preservation/012_preservation_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/03_interviews/024_interviews_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/036_chat_exports_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/06_expenses/048_expenses_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/09_policies/072_policies_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/08_vendor_files/060_vendor_files_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_indigo_telecom_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n## Alternatives considered\n\n- `indigo-telecom:shortcut` — Reverse all quarter-end rebates because the timing looks suspicious.: Use a plausible summary or one source without completing the controlling joins.\n- `indigo-telecom:blanket-hold` — Freeze the entire matter population: Treat supported actions and genuinely ambiguous records as if they were equally unresolved.\n\n## Assumptions and limits\n\nThis decision is limited to cb100-029-indigo-telecom, the supplied synthetic records, and the matter state as of 2026-09-30. Similar names, stale revisions, and pending authority are not treated as proof.\n", "decision": {"actions": [{"determination": "the operative cap is $1,522,000.00 under CB-IV-2609-R847; the matched ledger population totals $1,545,347.00 under CB-IV-2609-E938. Identity resolves to ENT-029-1001, revision REV-2025.2 is current, and Maya Ellison is active with capacity 2.", "due_date": "2026-09-28", "id": "ACT-CBP-029-02", "identity_id": "ENT-029-1001", "issue": "interview timeline conflict", "owner": "Maya Ellison", "portfolio_key": "CBP-029-02", "recommended_action": "Create transaction rows for proven defects and separate ownership-evidence holds. Owner: Maya Ellison; due 2026-09-28.", "severity": "high", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_intake/002_intake_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/02_preservation/014_preservation_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/04_email_exports/026_email_exports_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/038_chat_exports_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_indigo_telecom_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "completion is required by 2026-01-15 under CB-IV-2609-R294; the current event record shows completion on 2026-02-18 under CB-IV-2609-E746. Identity resolves to ENT-029-1004, revision REV-2025.5 is current, and Owen Delgado is active with capacity 3.", "due_date": "2026-09-25", "id": "ACT-CBP-029-05", "identity_id": "ENT-029-1004", "issue": "preservation delay", "owner": "Owen Delgado", "portfolio_key": "CBP-029-05", "recommended_action": "Create transaction rows for proven defects and separate ownership-evidence holds. Owner: Owen Delgado; due 2026-09-25.", "severity": "critical", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_intake/005_intake_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/03_interviews/017_interviews_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/04_email_exports/029_email_exports_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/06_expenses/041_expenses_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_indigo_telecom_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "the controlling threshold is 4% under CB-IV-2609-R527; the independently calculated result is 7% under CB-IV-2609-E125. Identity resolves to ENT-029-1005, revision REV-2025.6 is current, and Priya Raman is active with capacity 2.", "due_date": "2026-09-24", "id": "ACT-CBP-029-06", "identity_id": "ENT-029-1005", "issue": "gift-policy threshold breach", "owner": "Priya Raman", "portfolio_key": "CBP-029-06", "recommended_action": "Create transaction rows for proven defects and separate ownership-evidence holds. Owner: Priya Raman; due 2026-09-24.", "severity": "medium", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_intake/006_intake_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/03_interviews/018_interviews_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/04_email_exports/030_email_exports_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/06_expenses/042_expenses_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_indigo_telecom_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "approval must come from Lena Varga under CB-IV-2609-R646; the effective approval record names Henry Cho under CB-IV-2609-E820. Identity resolves to ENT-029-1006, revision REV-2025.7 is current, and Isaac Romero is active with capacity 6.", "due_date": "2026-09-23", "id": "ACT-CBP-029-07", "identity_id": "ENT-029-1006", "issue": "retaliation concern", "owner": "Isaac Romero", "portfolio_key": "CBP-029-07", "recommended_action": "Create transaction rows for proven defects and separate ownership-evidence holds. Owner: Isaac Romero; due 2026-09-23.", "severity": "high", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_intake/007_intake_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/03_interviews/019_interviews_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/04_email_exports/031_email_exports_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/06_expenses/043_expenses_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_indigo_telecom_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "the controlled population contains 223 records under CB-IV-2609-R571; the certification covers 206 records under CB-IV-2609-E868. Identity resolves to ENT-029-1007, revision REV-2025.1 is current, and Nadine Flores is active with capacity 1.", "due_date": "2026-09-22", "id": "ACT-CBP-029-08", "identity_id": "ENT-029-1007", "issue": "remediation ownership gap", "owner": "Nadine Flores", "portfolio_key": "CBP-029-08", "recommended_action": "Create transaction rows for proven defects and separate ownership-evidence holds. Owner: Nadine Flores; due 2026-09-22.", "severity": "high", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_intake/008_intake_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/03_interviews/020_interviews_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/04_email_exports/032_email_exports_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/06_expenses/044_expenses_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/09_policies/068_policies_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/10_hr_records/080_hr_records_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_indigo_telecom_impact_population.xlsx"]}], "as_of": "2026-09-30", "decision": {"alternatives_considered": ["indigo-telecom:shortcut", "indigo-telecom:blanket-hold"], "question": "Which Indigo rebates reflect an improper override or undisclosed vendor relationship?", "rationale": "The four-part causal test supports 5 scoped actions and leaves 7 records on evidence hold. Rebate policy and conflict controls require both an invalid override and reliable counterparty identity.", "recommendation": "Reverse and escalate only transactions that meet the combined control test.", "selected_option_id": "indigo-telecom:scoped-evidence"}, "holds": [{"id": "HOLD-CBP-029-01", "issue": "board-reporting omission", "portfolio_key": "CBP-029-01", "reason": "two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key", "required_next_evidence": "an approved immutable entity crosswalk", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_intake/001_intake_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/02_preservation/013_preservation_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/04_email_exports/025_email_exports_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/037_chat_exports_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/11_board_reporting/085_board_reporting_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_indigo_telecom_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-029-03", "issue": "off-channel communication", "portfolio_key": "CBP-029-03", "reason": "the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective", "required_next_evidence": "effective approval and an active owner with remaining capacity", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_intake/003_intake_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/02_preservation/015_preservation_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/04_email_exports/027_email_exports_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/039_chat_exports_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_indigo_telecom_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-029-04", "issue": "policy training lapse", "portfolio_key": "CBP-029-04", "reason": "the operational record relies on a superseded control revision", "required_next_evidence": "an operational record using the current effective revision", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_intake/004_intake_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/02_preservation/016_preservation_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/04_email_exports/028_email_exports_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/040_chat_exports_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_indigo_telecom_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-029-09", "issue": "approval override", "portfolio_key": "CBP-029-09", "reason": "two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key", "required_next_evidence": "an approved immutable entity crosswalk", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_preservation/009_preservation_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/03_interviews/021_interviews_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/033_chat_exports_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/06_expenses/045_expenses_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/11_board_reporting/081_board_reporting_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_indigo_telecom_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-029-10", "issue": "vendor due-diligence gap", "portfolio_key": "CBP-029-10", "reason": "the current observation does not meet the operative trigger", "required_next_evidence": "a current observation that satisfies the operative trigger", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_preservation/010_preservation_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/03_interviews/022_interviews_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/034_chat_exports_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/06_expenses/046_expenses_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/08_vendor_files/058_vendor_files_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/09_policies/070_policies_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_indigo_telecom_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-029-11", "issue": "expense support deficiency", "portfolio_key": "CBP-029-11", "reason": "the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective", "required_next_evidence": "effective approval and an active owner with remaining capacity", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_preservation/011_preservation_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/03_interviews/023_interviews_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/035_chat_exports_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/06_expenses/047_expenses_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_indigo_telecom_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-029-12", "issue": "split-purchase pattern", "portfolio_key": "CBP-029-12", "reason": "the operational record relies on a superseded control revision", "required_next_evidence": "an operational record using the current effective revision", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_preservation/012_preservation_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/03_interviews/024_interviews_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/036_chat_exports_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/06_expenses/048_expenses_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/09_policies/072_policies_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/08_vendor_files/060_vendor_files_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_indigo_telecom_impact_population.xlsx"]}], "matter_number": "CB-IV-2609", "prepared_for": "Indigo Telecom Americas", "schema_version": "counselbench.decision.v3", "task_id": "cb100-029-indigo-telecom"}, "matter_register": {"matter_number": "CB-IV-2609", "rows": [{"decision_option_id": "indigo-telecom:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key", "issue": "board-reporting omission", "matter_number": "CB-IV-2609", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-029-01", "row_id": "REG-CBP-029-01", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_intake/001_intake_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/02_preservation/013_preservation_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/04_email_exports/025_email_exports_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/037_chat_exports_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/11_board_reporting/085_board_reporting_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_indigo_telecom_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "indigo-telecom:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-28", "issue": "interview timeline conflict", "matter_number": "CB-IV-2609", "owner": "Maya Ellison", "portfolio_key": "CBP-029-02", "row_id": "REG-CBP-029-02", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_intake/002_intake_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/02_preservation/014_preservation_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/04_email_exports/026_email_exports_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/038_chat_exports_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_indigo_telecom_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "indigo-telecom:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective", "issue": "off-channel communication", "matter_number": "CB-IV-2609", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-029-03", "row_id": "REG-CBP-029-03", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_intake/003_intake_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/02_preservation/015_preservation_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/04_email_exports/027_email_exports_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/039_chat_exports_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_indigo_telecom_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "indigo-telecom:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "the operational record relies on a superseded control revision", "issue": "policy training lapse", "matter_number": "CB-IV-2609", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-029-04", "row_id": "REG-CBP-029-04", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_intake/004_intake_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/02_preservation/016_preservation_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/04_email_exports/028_email_exports_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/040_chat_exports_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_indigo_telecom_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "indigo-telecom:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-25", "issue": "preservation delay", "matter_number": "CB-IV-2609", "owner": "Owen Delgado", "portfolio_key": "CBP-029-05", "row_id": "REG-CBP-029-05", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_intake/005_intake_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/03_interviews/017_interviews_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/04_email_exports/029_email_exports_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/06_expenses/041_expenses_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_indigo_telecom_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "indigo-telecom:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-24", "issue": "gift-policy threshold breach", "matter_number": "CB-IV-2609", "owner": "Priya Raman", "portfolio_key": "CBP-029-06", "row_id": "REG-CBP-029-06", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_intake/006_intake_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/03_interviews/018_interviews_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/04_email_exports/030_email_exports_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/06_expenses/042_expenses_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_indigo_telecom_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "indigo-telecom:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-23", "issue": "retaliation concern", "matter_number": "CB-IV-2609", "owner": "Isaac Romero", "portfolio_key": "CBP-029-07", "row_id": "REG-CBP-029-07", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_intake/007_intake_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/03_interviews/019_interviews_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/04_email_exports/031_email_exports_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/06_expenses/043_expenses_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_indigo_telecom_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "indigo-telecom:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-22", "issue": "remediation ownership gap", "matter_number": "CB-IV-2609", "owner": "Nadine Flores", "portfolio_key": "CBP-029-08", "row_id": "REG-CBP-029-08", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_intake/008_intake_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/03_interviews/020_interviews_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/04_email_exports/032_email_exports_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/06_expenses/044_expenses_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/09_policies/068_policies_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/10_hr_records/080_hr_records_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_indigo_telecom_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "indigo-telecom:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key", "issue": "approval override", "matter_number": "CB-IV-2609", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-029-09", "row_id": "REG-CBP-029-09", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_preservation/009_preservation_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/03_interviews/021_interviews_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/033_chat_exports_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/06_expenses/045_expenses_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/11_board_reporting/081_board_reporting_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_indigo_telecom_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "indigo-telecom:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "the current observation does not meet the operative trigger", "issue": "vendor due-diligence gap", "matter_number": "CB-IV-2609", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-029-10", "row_id": "REG-CBP-029-10", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_preservation/010_preservation_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/03_interviews/022_interviews_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/034_chat_exports_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/06_expenses/046_expenses_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/08_vendor_files/058_vendor_files_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/09_policies/070_policies_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_indigo_telecom_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "indigo-telecom:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective", "issue": "expense support deficiency", "matter_number": "CB-IV-2609", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-029-11", "row_id": "REG-CBP-029-11", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_preservation/011_preservation_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/03_interviews/023_interviews_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/035_chat_exports_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/06_expenses/047_expenses_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_indigo_telecom_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "indigo-telecom:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "the operational record relies on a superseded control revision", "issue": "split-purchase pattern", "matter_number": "CB-IV-2609", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-029-12", "row_id": "REG-CBP-029-12", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_preservation/012_preservation_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/03_interviews/024_interviews_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/036_chat_exports_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/06_expenses/048_expenses_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/09_policies/072_policies_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/08_vendor_files/060_vendor_files_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_indigo_telecom_impact_population.xlsx"]}], "schema_version": "counselbench.matter-register.v3", "task_id": "cb100-029-indigo-telecom"}}, "metadata": {"benchmark": "CounselBench-100", "code_license": "Apache-2.0", "data_license": "CC-BY-4.0", "deadline": "2026-09-30", "document_count": 97, "evidence_holds": 7, "jurisdiction": "Texas", "matter_number": "CB-IV-2609", "mcp_commit": "9a96ea6e5913736f92b88345bf51caeaaa8e719f", "mcp_package": "@modelcontextprotocol/server-filesystem@2026.7.10", "practice_area": "internal-investigations", "reference_tool_calls": 80, "required_evidence_reads": 58, "supported_actions": 5, "synthetic": true, "venue": "Dallas County, Texas", "version": "3.1.0"}, "prompt": "Please take ownership of the open question before the deadline. Which Indigo rebates reflect an improper override or undisclosed vendor relationship? Quarter-end rebates were approved through overrides after unusual chats, duplicate support, and a vendor diligence file that omits beneficial ownership. The team needs the call by 2026-09-30. Give me a decision-ready note and make the corresponding matter-register entries, without guessing through missing records.", "rubric": {"criteria": [{"category": "investigation", "description": "Inventory the production and use targeted searches to locate records across native formats.", "id": "investigation.discover_production"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Complete every task-specific identity, authority, operations, and approval read before the first state transition.", "id": "investigation.read_before_write"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Inspect designated source metadata before relying on those records.", "id": "investigation.custody_before_write"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "Select the supported option 'indigo-telecom:scoped-evidence' after applying the four-part test.", "id": "decision.selected_option"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "Identify both rejected approaches and explain why a one-source shortcut and a blanket hold are wrong.", "id": "decision.alternatives"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-029-01 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_intake/001_intake_source_export.md rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-029-01.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_preservation/013_preservation_source_export.json for board-reporting omission.", "id": "investigation.CBP-029-01.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_email_exports/025_email_exports_source_export.md to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-029-01.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/037_chat_exports_source_export.json.", "id": "investigation.CBP-029-01.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-029-01 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key.", "id": "decision.CBP-029-01.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-029-01 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-029-01.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-029-02 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_intake/002_intake_source_export.txt rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-029-02.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_preservation/014_preservation_source_export.xml for interview timeline conflict.", "id": "investigation.CBP-029-02.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_email_exports/026_email_exports_source_export.txt to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-029-02.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/038_chat_exports_source_export.xml.", "id": "investigation.CBP-029-02.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-029-02 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-029-02.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-029-02 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-029-02.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-029-03 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_intake/003_intake_source_export.eml rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-029-03.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_preservation/015_preservation_source_export.html for off-channel communication.", "id": "investigation.CBP-029-03.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_email_exports/027_email_exports_source_export.eml to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-029-03.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/039_chat_exports_source_export.html.", "id": "investigation.CBP-029-03.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-029-03 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective.", "id": "decision.CBP-029-03.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-029-03 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-029-03.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-029-04 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_intake/004_intake_source_export.csv rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-029-04.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_preservation/016_preservation_source_export.pdf for policy training lapse.", "id": "investigation.CBP-029-04.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_email_exports/028_email_exports_source_export.csv to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-029-04.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/040_chat_exports_source_export.pdf.", "id": "investigation.CBP-029-04.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-029-04 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is the operational record relies on a superseded control revision.", "id": "decision.CBP-029-04.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-029-04 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-029-04.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-029-05 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_intake/005_intake_source_export.json rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-029-05.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_interviews/017_interviews_source_export.md for preservation delay.", "id": "investigation.CBP-029-05.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_email_exports/029_email_exports_source_export.json to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-029-05.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_expenses/041_expenses_source_export.md.", "id": "investigation.CBP-029-05.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-029-05 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-029-05.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-029-05 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-029-05.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-029-06 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_intake/006_intake_source_export.xml rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-029-06.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_interviews/018_interviews_source_export.txt for gift-policy threshold breach.", "id": "investigation.CBP-029-06.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_email_exports/030_email_exports_source_export.xml to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-029-06.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_expenses/042_expenses_source_export.txt.", "id": "investigation.CBP-029-06.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-029-06 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-029-06.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-029-06 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-029-06.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-029-07 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_intake/007_intake_source_export.html rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-029-07.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_interviews/019_interviews_source_export.eml for retaliation concern.", "id": "investigation.CBP-029-07.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_email_exports/031_email_exports_source_export.html to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-029-07.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_expenses/043_expenses_source_export.eml.", "id": "investigation.CBP-029-07.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-029-07 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-029-07.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-029-07 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-029-07.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-029-08 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_intake/008_intake_source_export.pdf rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-029-08.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_interviews/020_interviews_source_export.csv for remediation ownership gap.", "id": "investigation.CBP-029-08.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_email_exports/032_email_exports_source_export.pdf to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-029-08.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_expenses/044_expenses_source_export.csv.", "id": "investigation.CBP-029-08.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-029-08 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-029-08.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-029-08 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-029-08.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-029-09 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_preservation/009_preservation_source_export.md rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-029-09.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_interviews/021_interviews_source_export.json for approval override.", "id": "investigation.CBP-029-09.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/033_chat_exports_source_export.md to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-029-09.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_expenses/045_expenses_source_export.json.", "id": "investigation.CBP-029-09.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-029-09 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key.", "id": "decision.CBP-029-09.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-029-09 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-029-09.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-029-10 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_preservation/010_preservation_source_export.txt rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-029-10.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_interviews/022_interviews_source_export.xml for vendor due-diligence gap.", "id": "investigation.CBP-029-10.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/034_chat_exports_source_export.txt to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-029-10.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_expenses/046_expenses_source_export.xml.", "id": "investigation.CBP-029-10.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-029-10 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is the current observation does not meet the operative trigger.", "id": "decision.CBP-029-10.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-029-10 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-029-10.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-029-11 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_preservation/011_preservation_source_export.eml rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-029-11.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_interviews/023_interviews_source_export.html for expense support deficiency.", "id": "investigation.CBP-029-11.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/035_chat_exports_source_export.eml to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-029-11.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_expenses/047_expenses_source_export.html.", "id": "investigation.CBP-029-11.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-029-11 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective.", "id": "decision.CBP-029-11.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-029-11 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-029-11.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-029-12 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_preservation/012_preservation_source_export.csv rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-029-12.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_interviews/024_interviews_source_export.pdf for split-purchase pattern.", "id": "investigation.CBP-029-12.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/036_chat_exports_source_export.csv to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-029-12.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_expenses/048_expenses_source_export.pdf.", "id": "investigation.CBP-029-12.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-029-12 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is the operational record relies on a superseded control revision.", "id": "decision.CBP-029-12.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-029-12 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-029-12.register"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Write the exact selected option, supported action population, evidence-hold population, facts, owners, deadlines, and citations.", "id": "state.exact_decision"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create one exact register row per portfolio key with no extra, missing, or modified row.", "id": "state.exact_register"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Leave only the three approved deliverables and perform no extra state-changing write.", "id": "state.write_scope_containment"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Read back decision.json, matter-register.json, and advice.md after their final writes.", "id": "state.postwrite_readback"}, {"category": "answer", "description": "Explain the selected recommendation, supported actions, holds, alternatives, and limitations with exact source anchors.", "id": "answer.decision_note"}], "decision_options": [{"approach": "Use a plausible summary or one source without completing the controlling joins.", "id": "indigo-telecom:shortcut", "label": "Reverse all quarter-end rebates because the timing looks suspicious."}, {"approach": "Treat supported actions and genuinely ambiguous records as if they were equally unresolved.", "id": "indigo-telecom:blanket-hold", "label": "Freeze the entire matter population"}, {"approach": "Apply the exact identity, current-state, authority, and revision test. Create transaction rows for proven defects and separate ownership-evidence holds.", "id": "indigo-telecom:scoped-evidence", "label": "Reverse and escalate only transactions that meet the combined control test."}], "evaluation_narrative": {"authority": "Rebate policy and conflict controls require both an invalid override and reliable counterparty identity.", "observation": "Join rebate support, duplicate claims, chats, approval history, and beneficial ownership by transaction.", "question": "Which Indigo rebates reflect an improper override or undisclosed vendor relationship?", "register_action": "Create transaction rows for proven defects and separate ownership-evidence holds."}, "gates": ["all_required_evidence_precedes_first_write", "decision_criteria_complete", "register_state_exact", "write_scope_contained", "all_outputs_verified_by_readback"], "metadata_checks": 10, "metric": "weighted_criteria_score", "minimum_tool_calls": 80, "required_deliverables": ["decision.json", "matter-register.json", "advice.md"], "required_document_reads": 58, "type": "deterministic", "weights": {"advice": 0.15, "decision": 0.35, "investigation": 0.25, "state": 0.25}}, "task_id": "cb100-029-indigo-telecom", "task_name": "Indigo channel-rebate inquiry", "world_id": "counselbench-filesystem-mcp-v3"}
+{"context_files": ["task_files/cb100-030-jasper-university/01_intake/001_intake_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-030-jasper-university/01_intake/002_intake_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-030-jasper-university/01_intake/003_intake_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-030-jasper-university/01_intake/004_intake_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-030-jasper-university/01_intake/005_intake_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-030-jasper-university/01_intake/006_intake_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-030-jasper-university/01_intake/007_intake_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-030-jasper-university/01_intake/008_intake_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-030-jasper-university/02_preservation/009_preservation_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-030-jasper-university/02_preservation/010_preservation_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-030-jasper-university/02_preservation/011_preservation_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-030-jasper-university/02_preservation/012_preservation_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-030-jasper-university/02_preservation/013_preservation_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-030-jasper-university/02_preservation/014_preservation_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-030-jasper-university/02_preservation/015_preservation_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-030-jasper-university/02_preservation/016_preservation_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-030-jasper-university/03_interviews/017_interviews_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-030-jasper-university/03_interviews/018_interviews_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-030-jasper-university/03_interviews/019_interviews_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-030-jasper-university/03_interviews/020_interviews_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-030-jasper-university/03_interviews/021_interviews_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-030-jasper-university/03_interviews/022_interviews_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-030-jasper-university/03_interviews/023_interviews_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-030-jasper-university/03_interviews/024_interviews_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-030-jasper-university/04_email_exports/025_email_exports_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-030-jasper-university/04_email_exports/026_email_exports_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-030-jasper-university/04_email_exports/027_email_exports_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-030-jasper-university/04_email_exports/028_email_exports_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-030-jasper-university/04_email_exports/029_email_exports_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-030-jasper-university/04_email_exports/030_email_exports_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-030-jasper-university/04_email_exports/031_email_exports_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-030-jasper-university/04_email_exports/032_email_exports_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-030-jasper-university/05_chat_exports/033_chat_exports_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-030-jasper-university/05_chat_exports/034_chat_exports_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-030-jasper-university/05_chat_exports/035_chat_exports_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-030-jasper-university/05_chat_exports/036_chat_exports_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-030-jasper-university/05_chat_exports/037_chat_exports_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-030-jasper-university/05_chat_exports/038_chat_exports_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-030-jasper-university/05_chat_exports/039_chat_exports_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-030-jasper-university/05_chat_exports/040_chat_exports_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-030-jasper-university/06_expenses/041_expenses_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-030-jasper-university/06_expenses/042_expenses_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-030-jasper-university/06_expenses/043_expenses_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-030-jasper-university/06_expenses/044_expenses_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-030-jasper-university/06_expenses/045_expenses_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-030-jasper-university/06_expenses/046_expenses_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-030-jasper-university/06_expenses/047_expenses_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-030-jasper-university/06_expenses/048_expenses_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-030-jasper-university/07_access_logs/049_access_logs_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-030-jasper-university/07_access_logs/050_access_logs_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-030-jasper-university/07_access_logs/051_access_logs_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-030-jasper-university/07_access_logs/052_access_logs_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-030-jasper-university/07_access_logs/053_access_logs_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-030-jasper-university/07_access_logs/054_access_logs_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-030-jasper-university/07_access_logs/055_access_logs_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-030-jasper-university/07_access_logs/056_access_logs_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-030-jasper-university/08_vendor_files/057_vendor_files_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-030-jasper-university/08_vendor_files/058_vendor_files_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-030-jasper-university/08_vendor_files/059_vendor_files_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-030-jasper-university/08_vendor_files/060_vendor_files_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-030-jasper-university/08_vendor_files/061_vendor_files_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-030-jasper-university/08_vendor_files/062_vendor_files_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-030-jasper-university/08_vendor_files/063_vendor_files_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-030-jasper-university/08_vendor_files/064_vendor_files_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-030-jasper-university/09_policies/065_policies_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-030-jasper-university/09_policies/066_policies_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-030-jasper-university/09_policies/067_policies_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-030-jasper-university/09_policies/068_policies_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-030-jasper-university/09_policies/069_policies_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-030-jasper-university/09_policies/070_policies_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-030-jasper-university/09_policies/071_policies_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-030-jasper-university/09_policies/072_policies_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-030-jasper-university/10_hr_records/073_hr_records_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-030-jasper-university/10_hr_records/074_hr_records_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-030-jasper-university/10_hr_records/075_hr_records_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-030-jasper-university/10_hr_records/076_hr_records_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-030-jasper-university/10_hr_records/077_hr_records_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-030-jasper-university/10_hr_records/078_hr_records_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-030-jasper-university/10_hr_records/079_hr_records_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-030-jasper-university/10_hr_records/080_hr_records_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-030-jasper-university/11_board_reporting/081_board_reporting_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-030-jasper-university/11_board_reporting/082_board_reporting_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-030-jasper-university/11_board_reporting/083_board_reporting_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-030-jasper-university/11_board_reporting/084_board_reporting_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-030-jasper-university/11_board_reporting/085_board_reporting_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-030-jasper-university/11_board_reporting/086_board_reporting_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-030-jasper-university/11_board_reporting/087_board_reporting_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-030-jasper-university/11_board_reporting/088_board_reporting_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-030-jasper-university/12_remediation/089_remediation_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-030-jasper-university/12_remediation/090_remediation_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-030-jasper-university/12_remediation/091_remediation_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-030-jasper-university/12_remediation/092_remediation_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-030-jasper-university/12_remediation/093_remediation_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-030-jasper-university/12_remediation/094_remediation_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-030-jasper-university/12_remediation/095_remediation_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-030-jasper-university/12_remediation/096_remediation_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-030-jasper-university/12_remediation/097_jasper_university_impact_population.xlsx"], "gold_output": {"advice_markdown": "# Decision note — Jasper research-fund inquiry\n\n## Recommendation\n\nEscalate supported conflicts and repair disclosure or training controls at the correct scope. The reconciled record supports 9 scoped actions and leaves 3 items on evidence hold.\n\nSelected option: `jasper-university:scoped-evidence`.\n\n## Why this is the supported option\n\nCorrelate vendor ownership, purchase decisions, disclosure forms, training status, and expense purpose. Conflict policy and grant rules require exact relationship, participation, and funding-source evidence.\n\n## Supported actions\n\n### CBP-030-01 — hotline classification error (critical)\n\nthe controlling threshold is 3% under CB-IV-2610-R550; the independently calculated result is 5% under CB-IV-2610-E761. Identity resolves to ENT-030-1000, revision REV-2026.1 is current, and Farah Ibrahim is active with capacity 3.\n\nAction: Register supported purchase findings and preserve unsupported motive questions. Owner: Farah Ibrahim; due 2026-10-03.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_intake/001_intake_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/02_preservation/013_preservation_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/04_email_exports/025_email_exports_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/037_chat_exports_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/07_access_logs/049_access_logs_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/11_board_reporting/085_board_reporting_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_jasper_university_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-030-02 — undisclosed related party (critical)\n\napproval must come from Mei Whitaker under CB-IV-2610-R598; the effective approval record names Henry Cho under CB-IV-2610-E605. Identity resolves to ENT-030-1001, revision REV-2026.2 is current, and Dominic Alvarez is active with capacity 5.\n\nAction: Register supported purchase findings and preserve unsupported motive questions. Owner: Dominic Alvarez; due 2026-10-02.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_intake/002_intake_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/02_preservation/014_preservation_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/04_email_exports/026_email_exports_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/038_chat_exports_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/10_hr_records/074_hr_records_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_jasper_university_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-030-03 — deleted-message anomaly (medium)\n\nthe controlled population contains 93 records under CB-IV-2610-R301; the certification covers 54 records under CB-IV-2610-E641. Identity resolves to ENT-030-1002, revision REV-2026.3 is current, and Leona Park is active with capacity 2.\n\nAction: Register supported purchase findings and preserve unsupported motive questions. Owner: Leona Park; due 2026-10-01.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_intake/003_intake_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/02_preservation/015_preservation_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/04_email_exports/027_email_exports_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/039_chat_exports_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/07_access_logs/051_access_logs_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_jasper_university_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-030-04 — board-reporting omission (critical)\n\nthe permission is limited to Allegheny County, Pennsylvania under CB-IV-2610-R355; the matched activity occurred in Pennsylvania under CB-IV-2610-E962. Identity resolves to ENT-030-1003, revision REV-2026.4 is current, and Henry Cho is active with capacity 6.\n\nAction: Register supported purchase findings and preserve unsupported motive questions. Owner: Henry Cho; due 2026-09-30.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_intake/004_intake_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/02_preservation/016_preservation_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/04_email_exports/028_email_exports_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/040_chat_exports_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_jasper_university_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-030-06 — off-channel communication (low)\n\ndelivery must use notices-jasper_university_research_institute@example.test under CB-IV-2610-R671; the only matched receipt used archive-nova_bench_analytics@example.test under CB-IV-2610-E398. Identity resolves to ENT-030-1005, revision REV-2026.6 is current, and Jonas Feld is active with capacity 6.\n\nAction: Register supported purchase findings and preserve unsupported motive questions. Owner: Jonas Feld; due 2026-09-28.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_intake/006_intake_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/03_interviews/018_interviews_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/04_email_exports/030_email_exports_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/06_expenses/042_expenses_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_jasper_university_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-030-07 — policy training lapse (medium)\n\nan open exception blocks completion under CB-IV-2610-R728; the current status is open and unresolved under CB-IV-2610-E666. Identity resolves to ENT-030-1006, revision REV-2026.7 is current, and Willa Novak is active with capacity 2.\n\nAction: Register supported purchase findings and preserve unsupported motive questions. Owner: Willa Novak; due 2026-09-27.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_intake/007_intake_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/03_interviews/019_interviews_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/04_email_exports/031_email_exports_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/06_expenses/043_expenses_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/10_hr_records/079_hr_records_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/09_policies/067_policies_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_jasper_university_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-030-08 — preservation delay (medium)\n\ncompletion is required by 2026-03-11 under CB-IV-2610-R949; the current event record shows completion on 2026-03-30 under CB-IV-2610-E255. Identity resolves to ENT-030-1007, revision REV-2026.1 is current, and Owen Delgado is active with capacity 3.\n\nAction: Register supported purchase findings and preserve unsupported motive questions. Owner: Owen Delgado; due 2026-09-26.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_intake/008_intake_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/03_interviews/020_interviews_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/04_email_exports/032_email_exports_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/06_expenses/044_expenses_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/12_remediation/092_remediation_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_jasper_university_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-030-09 — gift-policy threshold breach (high)\n\nthe controlling threshold is 8% under CB-IV-2610-R601; the independently calculated result is 15% under CB-IV-2610-E129. Identity resolves to ENT-030-1008, revision REV-2026.2 is current, and Priya Raman is active with capacity 2.\n\nAction: Register supported purchase findings and preserve unsupported motive questions. Owner: Priya Raman; due 2026-09-25.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/02_preservation/009_preservation_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/03_interviews/021_interviews_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/033_chat_exports_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/06_expenses/045_expenses_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/08_vendor_files/057_vendor_files_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/11_board_reporting/081_board_reporting_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_jasper_university_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-030-11 — remediation ownership gap (high)\n\nthe controlled population contains 207 records under CB-IV-2610-R725; the certification covers 189 records under CB-IV-2610-E877. Identity resolves to ENT-030-1010, revision REV-2026.4 is current, and Nadine Flores is active with capacity 2.\n\nAction: Register supported purchase findings and preserve unsupported motive questions. Owner: Nadine Flores; due 2026-10-02.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/02_preservation/011_preservation_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/03_interviews/023_interviews_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/035_chat_exports_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/06_expenses/047_expenses_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/08_vendor_files/059_vendor_files_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_jasper_university_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n## Evidence holds\n\n- **CBP-030-05 — interview timeline conflict**: the current observation does not meet the operative trigger. Next evidence: a current observation that satisfies the operative trigger. Sources: `/workspace/documents/01_intake/005_intake_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/03_interviews/017_interviews_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/04_email_exports/029_email_exports_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/06_expenses/041_expenses_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/09_policies/065_policies_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_jasper_university_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-030-10 — retaliation concern**: the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective. Next evidence: effective approval and an active owner with remaining capacity. Sources: `/workspace/documents/02_preservation/010_preservation_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/03_interviews/022_interviews_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/034_chat_exports_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/06_expenses/046_expenses_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/08_vendor_files/058_vendor_files_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_jasper_university_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-030-12 — approval override**: two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key. Next evidence: an approved immutable entity crosswalk. Sources: `/workspace/documents/02_preservation/012_preservation_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/03_interviews/024_interviews_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/036_chat_exports_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/06_expenses/048_expenses_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/11_board_reporting/084_board_reporting_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/09_policies/072_policies_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_jasper_university_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n## Alternatives considered\n\n- `jasper-university:blanket-hold` — Freeze the entire matter population: Treat supported actions and genuinely ambiguous records as if they were equally unresolved.\n- `jasper-university:shortcut` — Treat the former-student relationship alone as prohibited self-dealing.: Use a plausible summary or one source without completing the controlling joins.\n\n## Assumptions and limits\n\nThis decision is limited to cb100-030-jasper-university, the supplied synthetic records, and the matter state as of 2026-10-04. Similar names, stale revisions, and pending authority are not treated as proof.\n", "decision": {"actions": [{"determination": "the controlling threshold is 3% under CB-IV-2610-R550; the independently calculated result is 5% under CB-IV-2610-E761. Identity resolves to ENT-030-1000, revision REV-2026.1 is current, and Farah Ibrahim is active with capacity 3.", "due_date": "2026-10-03", "id": "ACT-CBP-030-01", "identity_id": "ENT-030-1000", "issue": "hotline classification error", "owner": "Farah Ibrahim", "portfolio_key": "CBP-030-01", "recommended_action": "Register supported purchase findings and preserve unsupported motive questions. Owner: Farah Ibrahim; due 2026-10-03.", "severity": "critical", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_intake/001_intake_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/02_preservation/013_preservation_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/04_email_exports/025_email_exports_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/037_chat_exports_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/07_access_logs/049_access_logs_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/11_board_reporting/085_board_reporting_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_jasper_university_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "approval must come from Mei Whitaker under CB-IV-2610-R598; the effective approval record names Henry Cho under CB-IV-2610-E605. Identity resolves to ENT-030-1001, revision REV-2026.2 is current, and Dominic Alvarez is active with capacity 5.", "due_date": "2026-10-02", "id": "ACT-CBP-030-02", "identity_id": "ENT-030-1001", "issue": "undisclosed related party", "owner": "Dominic Alvarez", "portfolio_key": "CBP-030-02", "recommended_action": "Register supported purchase findings and preserve unsupported motive questions. Owner: Dominic Alvarez; due 2026-10-02.", "severity": "critical", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_intake/002_intake_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/02_preservation/014_preservation_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/04_email_exports/026_email_exports_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/038_chat_exports_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/10_hr_records/074_hr_records_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_jasper_university_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "the controlled population contains 93 records under CB-IV-2610-R301; the certification covers 54 records under CB-IV-2610-E641. Identity resolves to ENT-030-1002, revision REV-2026.3 is current, and Leona Park is active with capacity 2.", "due_date": "2026-10-01", "id": "ACT-CBP-030-03", "identity_id": "ENT-030-1002", "issue": "deleted-message anomaly", "owner": "Leona Park", "portfolio_key": "CBP-030-03", "recommended_action": "Register supported purchase findings and preserve unsupported motive questions. Owner: Leona Park; due 2026-10-01.", "severity": "medium", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_intake/003_intake_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/02_preservation/015_preservation_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/04_email_exports/027_email_exports_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/039_chat_exports_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/07_access_logs/051_access_logs_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_jasper_university_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "the permission is limited to Allegheny County, Pennsylvania under CB-IV-2610-R355; the matched activity occurred in Pennsylvania under CB-IV-2610-E962. Identity resolves to ENT-030-1003, revision REV-2026.4 is current, and Henry Cho is active with capacity 6.", "due_date": "2026-09-30", "id": "ACT-CBP-030-04", "identity_id": "ENT-030-1003", "issue": "board-reporting omission", "owner": "Henry Cho", "portfolio_key": "CBP-030-04", "recommended_action": "Register supported purchase findings and preserve unsupported motive questions. Owner: Henry Cho; due 2026-09-30.", "severity": "critical", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_intake/004_intake_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/02_preservation/016_preservation_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/04_email_exports/028_email_exports_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/040_chat_exports_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_jasper_university_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "delivery must use notices-jasper_university_research_institute@example.test under CB-IV-2610-R671; the only matched receipt used archive-nova_bench_analytics@example.test under CB-IV-2610-E398. Identity resolves to ENT-030-1005, revision REV-2026.6 is current, and Jonas Feld is active with capacity 6.", "due_date": "2026-09-28", "id": "ACT-CBP-030-06", "identity_id": "ENT-030-1005", "issue": "off-channel communication", "owner": "Jonas Feld", "portfolio_key": "CBP-030-06", "recommended_action": "Register supported purchase findings and preserve unsupported motive questions. Owner: Jonas Feld; due 2026-09-28.", "severity": "low", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_intake/006_intake_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/03_interviews/018_interviews_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/04_email_exports/030_email_exports_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/06_expenses/042_expenses_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_jasper_university_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "an open exception blocks completion under CB-IV-2610-R728; the current status is open and unresolved under CB-IV-2610-E666. Identity resolves to ENT-030-1006, revision REV-2026.7 is current, and Willa Novak is active with capacity 2.", "due_date": "2026-09-27", "id": "ACT-CBP-030-07", "identity_id": "ENT-030-1006", "issue": "policy training lapse", "owner": "Willa Novak", "portfolio_key": "CBP-030-07", "recommended_action": "Register supported purchase findings and preserve unsupported motive questions. Owner: Willa Novak; due 2026-09-27.", "severity": "medium", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_intake/007_intake_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/03_interviews/019_interviews_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/04_email_exports/031_email_exports_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/06_expenses/043_expenses_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/10_hr_records/079_hr_records_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/09_policies/067_policies_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_jasper_university_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "completion is required by 2026-03-11 under CB-IV-2610-R949; the current event record shows completion on 2026-03-30 under CB-IV-2610-E255. Identity resolves to ENT-030-1007, revision REV-2026.1 is current, and Owen Delgado is active with capacity 3.", "due_date": "2026-09-26", "id": "ACT-CBP-030-08", "identity_id": "ENT-030-1007", "issue": "preservation delay", "owner": "Owen Delgado", "portfolio_key": "CBP-030-08", "recommended_action": "Register supported purchase findings and preserve unsupported motive questions. Owner: Owen Delgado; due 2026-09-26.", "severity": "medium", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_intake/008_intake_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/03_interviews/020_interviews_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/04_email_exports/032_email_exports_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/06_expenses/044_expenses_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/092_remediation_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_jasper_university_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "the controlling threshold is 8% under CB-IV-2610-R601; the independently calculated result is 15% under CB-IV-2610-E129. Identity resolves to ENT-030-1008, revision REV-2026.2 is current, and Priya Raman is active with capacity 2.", "due_date": "2026-09-25", "id": "ACT-CBP-030-09", "identity_id": "ENT-030-1008", "issue": "gift-policy threshold breach", "owner": "Priya Raman", "portfolio_key": "CBP-030-09", "recommended_action": "Register supported purchase findings and preserve unsupported motive questions. Owner: Priya Raman; due 2026-09-25.", "severity": "high", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_preservation/009_preservation_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/03_interviews/021_interviews_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/033_chat_exports_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/06_expenses/045_expenses_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/08_vendor_files/057_vendor_files_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/11_board_reporting/081_board_reporting_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_jasper_university_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "the controlled population contains 207 records under CB-IV-2610-R725; the certification covers 189 records under CB-IV-2610-E877. Identity resolves to ENT-030-1010, revision REV-2026.4 is current, and Nadine Flores is active with capacity 2.", "due_date": "2026-10-02", "id": "ACT-CBP-030-11", "identity_id": "ENT-030-1010", "issue": "remediation ownership gap", "owner": "Nadine Flores", "portfolio_key": "CBP-030-11", "recommended_action": "Register supported purchase findings and preserve unsupported motive questions. Owner: Nadine Flores; due 2026-10-02.", "severity": "high", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_preservation/011_preservation_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/03_interviews/023_interviews_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/035_chat_exports_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/06_expenses/047_expenses_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/08_vendor_files/059_vendor_files_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_jasper_university_impact_population.xlsx"]}], "as_of": "2026-10-04", "decision": {"alternatives_considered": ["jasper-university:blanket-hold", "jasper-university:shortcut"], "question": "Did the Jasper purchases violate conflict or training requirements, and what should be reported?", "rationale": "The four-part causal test supports 9 scoped actions and leaves 3 records on evidence hold. Conflict policy and grant rules require exact relationship, participation, and funding-source evidence.", "recommendation": "Escalate supported conflicts and repair disclosure or training controls at the correct scope.", "selected_option_id": "jasper-university:scoped-evidence"}, "holds": [{"id": "HOLD-CBP-030-05", "issue": "interview timeline conflict", "portfolio_key": "CBP-030-05", "reason": "the current observation does not meet the operative trigger", "required_next_evidence": "a current observation that satisfies the operative trigger", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_intake/005_intake_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/03_interviews/017_interviews_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/04_email_exports/029_email_exports_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/06_expenses/041_expenses_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/09_policies/065_policies_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_jasper_university_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-030-10", "issue": "retaliation concern", "portfolio_key": "CBP-030-10", "reason": "the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective", "required_next_evidence": "effective approval and an active owner with remaining capacity", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_preservation/010_preservation_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/03_interviews/022_interviews_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/034_chat_exports_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/06_expenses/046_expenses_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/08_vendor_files/058_vendor_files_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_jasper_university_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-030-12", "issue": "approval override", "portfolio_key": "CBP-030-12", "reason": "two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key", "required_next_evidence": "an approved immutable entity crosswalk", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_preservation/012_preservation_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/03_interviews/024_interviews_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/036_chat_exports_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/06_expenses/048_expenses_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/11_board_reporting/084_board_reporting_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/09_policies/072_policies_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_jasper_university_impact_population.xlsx"]}], "matter_number": "CB-IV-2610", "prepared_for": "Jasper University Research Institute", "schema_version": "counselbench.decision.v3", "task_id": "cb100-030-jasper-university"}, "matter_register": {"matter_number": "CB-IV-2610", "rows": [{"decision_option_id": "jasper-university:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-10-03", "issue": "hotline classification error", "matter_number": "CB-IV-2610", "owner": "Farah Ibrahim", "portfolio_key": "CBP-030-01", "row_id": "REG-CBP-030-01", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_intake/001_intake_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/02_preservation/013_preservation_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/04_email_exports/025_email_exports_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/037_chat_exports_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/07_access_logs/049_access_logs_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/11_board_reporting/085_board_reporting_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_jasper_university_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "jasper-university:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-10-02", "issue": "undisclosed related party", "matter_number": "CB-IV-2610", "owner": "Dominic Alvarez", "portfolio_key": "CBP-030-02", "row_id": "REG-CBP-030-02", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_intake/002_intake_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/02_preservation/014_preservation_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/04_email_exports/026_email_exports_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/038_chat_exports_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/10_hr_records/074_hr_records_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_jasper_university_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "jasper-university:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-10-01", "issue": "deleted-message anomaly", "matter_number": "CB-IV-2610", "owner": "Leona Park", "portfolio_key": "CBP-030-03", "row_id": "REG-CBP-030-03", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_intake/003_intake_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/02_preservation/015_preservation_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/04_email_exports/027_email_exports_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/039_chat_exports_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/07_access_logs/051_access_logs_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_jasper_university_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "jasper-university:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-30", "issue": "board-reporting omission", "matter_number": "CB-IV-2610", "owner": "Henry Cho", "portfolio_key": "CBP-030-04", "row_id": "REG-CBP-030-04", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_intake/004_intake_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/02_preservation/016_preservation_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/04_email_exports/028_email_exports_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/040_chat_exports_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_jasper_university_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "jasper-university:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "the current observation does not meet the operative trigger", "issue": "interview timeline conflict", "matter_number": "CB-IV-2610", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-030-05", "row_id": "REG-CBP-030-05", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_intake/005_intake_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/03_interviews/017_interviews_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/04_email_exports/029_email_exports_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/06_expenses/041_expenses_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/09_policies/065_policies_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_jasper_university_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "jasper-university:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-28", "issue": "off-channel communication", "matter_number": "CB-IV-2610", "owner": "Jonas Feld", "portfolio_key": "CBP-030-06", "row_id": "REG-CBP-030-06", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_intake/006_intake_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/03_interviews/018_interviews_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/04_email_exports/030_email_exports_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/06_expenses/042_expenses_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_jasper_university_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "jasper-university:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-27", "issue": "policy training lapse", "matter_number": "CB-IV-2610", "owner": "Willa Novak", "portfolio_key": "CBP-030-07", "row_id": "REG-CBP-030-07", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_intake/007_intake_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/03_interviews/019_interviews_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/04_email_exports/031_email_exports_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/06_expenses/043_expenses_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/10_hr_records/079_hr_records_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/09_policies/067_policies_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_jasper_university_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "jasper-university:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-26", "issue": "preservation delay", "matter_number": "CB-IV-2610", "owner": "Owen Delgado", "portfolio_key": "CBP-030-08", "row_id": "REG-CBP-030-08", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_intake/008_intake_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/03_interviews/020_interviews_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/04_email_exports/032_email_exports_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/06_expenses/044_expenses_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/092_remediation_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_jasper_university_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "jasper-university:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-25", "issue": "gift-policy threshold breach", "matter_number": "CB-IV-2610", "owner": "Priya Raman", "portfolio_key": "CBP-030-09", "row_id": "REG-CBP-030-09", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_preservation/009_preservation_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/03_interviews/021_interviews_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/033_chat_exports_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/06_expenses/045_expenses_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/08_vendor_files/057_vendor_files_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/11_board_reporting/081_board_reporting_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_jasper_university_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "jasper-university:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective", "issue": "retaliation concern", "matter_number": "CB-IV-2610", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-030-10", "row_id": "REG-CBP-030-10", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_preservation/010_preservation_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/03_interviews/022_interviews_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/034_chat_exports_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/06_expenses/046_expenses_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/08_vendor_files/058_vendor_files_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_jasper_university_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "jasper-university:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-10-02", "issue": "remediation ownership gap", "matter_number": "CB-IV-2610", "owner": "Nadine Flores", "portfolio_key": "CBP-030-11", "row_id": "REG-CBP-030-11", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_preservation/011_preservation_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/03_interviews/023_interviews_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/035_chat_exports_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/06_expenses/047_expenses_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/08_vendor_files/059_vendor_files_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_jasper_university_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "jasper-university:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key", "issue": "approval override", "matter_number": "CB-IV-2610", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-030-12", "row_id": "REG-CBP-030-12", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_preservation/012_preservation_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/03_interviews/024_interviews_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/036_chat_exports_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/06_expenses/048_expenses_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/11_board_reporting/084_board_reporting_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/09_policies/072_policies_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_jasper_university_impact_population.xlsx"]}], "schema_version": "counselbench.matter-register.v3", "task_id": "cb100-030-jasper-university"}}, "metadata": {"benchmark": "CounselBench-100", "code_license": "Apache-2.0", "data_license": "CC-BY-4.0", "deadline": "2026-10-04", "document_count": 97, "evidence_holds": 3, "jurisdiction": "Pennsylvania", "matter_number": "CB-IV-2610", "mcp_commit": "9a96ea6e5913736f92b88345bf51caeaaa8e719f", "mcp_package": "@modelcontextprotocol/server-filesystem@2026.7.10", "practice_area": "internal-investigations", "reference_tool_calls": 92, "required_evidence_reads": 64, "supported_actions": 9, "synthetic": true, "venue": "Allegheny County, Pennsylvania", "version": "3.1.0"}, "prompt": "I need to know what is proven, what we can do about it, and what is still only an evidence gap. Did the Jasper purchases violate conflict or training requirements, and what should be reported? A principal investigator directed purchases to a startup owned by a former student while training, disclosure, and expense records diverge. The team needs the call by 2026-10-04. Capture the supported action and the remaining holds so the next reviewer can reproduce the call.", "rubric": {"criteria": [{"category": "investigation", "description": "Inventory the production and use targeted searches to locate records across native formats.", "id": "investigation.discover_production"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Complete every task-specific identity, authority, operations, and approval read before the first state transition.", "id": "investigation.read_before_write"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Inspect designated source metadata before relying on those records.", "id": "investigation.custody_before_write"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "Select the supported option 'jasper-university:scoped-evidence' after applying the four-part test.", "id": "decision.selected_option"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "Identify both rejected approaches and explain why a one-source shortcut and a blanket hold are wrong.", "id": "decision.alternatives"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-030-01 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_intake/001_intake_source_export.md rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-030-01.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_preservation/013_preservation_source_export.json for hotline classification error.", "id": "investigation.CBP-030-01.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_email_exports/025_email_exports_source_export.md to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-030-01.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/037_chat_exports_source_export.json.", "id": "investigation.CBP-030-01.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-030-01 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-030-01.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-030-01 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-030-01.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-030-02 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_intake/002_intake_source_export.txt rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-030-02.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_preservation/014_preservation_source_export.xml for undisclosed related party.", "id": "investigation.CBP-030-02.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_email_exports/026_email_exports_source_export.txt to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-030-02.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/038_chat_exports_source_export.xml.", "id": "investigation.CBP-030-02.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-030-02 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-030-02.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-030-02 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-030-02.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-030-03 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_intake/003_intake_source_export.eml rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-030-03.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_preservation/015_preservation_source_export.html for deleted-message anomaly.", "id": "investigation.CBP-030-03.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_email_exports/027_email_exports_source_export.eml to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-030-03.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/039_chat_exports_source_export.html.", "id": "investigation.CBP-030-03.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-030-03 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-030-03.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-030-03 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-030-03.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-030-04 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_intake/004_intake_source_export.csv rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-030-04.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_preservation/016_preservation_source_export.pdf for board-reporting omission.", "id": "investigation.CBP-030-04.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_email_exports/028_email_exports_source_export.csv to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-030-04.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/040_chat_exports_source_export.pdf.", "id": "investigation.CBP-030-04.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-030-04 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-030-04.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-030-04 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-030-04.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-030-05 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_intake/005_intake_source_export.json rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-030-05.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_interviews/017_interviews_source_export.md for interview timeline conflict.", "id": "investigation.CBP-030-05.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_email_exports/029_email_exports_source_export.json to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-030-05.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_expenses/041_expenses_source_export.md.", "id": "investigation.CBP-030-05.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-030-05 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is the current observation does not meet the operative trigger.", "id": "decision.CBP-030-05.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-030-05 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-030-05.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-030-06 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_intake/006_intake_source_export.xml rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-030-06.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_interviews/018_interviews_source_export.txt for off-channel communication.", "id": "investigation.CBP-030-06.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_email_exports/030_email_exports_source_export.xml to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-030-06.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_expenses/042_expenses_source_export.txt.", "id": "investigation.CBP-030-06.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-030-06 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-030-06.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-030-06 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-030-06.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-030-07 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_intake/007_intake_source_export.html rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-030-07.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_interviews/019_interviews_source_export.eml for policy training lapse.", "id": "investigation.CBP-030-07.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_email_exports/031_email_exports_source_export.html to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-030-07.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_expenses/043_expenses_source_export.eml.", "id": "investigation.CBP-030-07.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-030-07 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-030-07.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-030-07 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-030-07.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-030-08 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_intake/008_intake_source_export.pdf rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-030-08.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_interviews/020_interviews_source_export.csv for preservation delay.", "id": "investigation.CBP-030-08.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_email_exports/032_email_exports_source_export.pdf to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-030-08.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_expenses/044_expenses_source_export.csv.", "id": "investigation.CBP-030-08.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-030-08 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-030-08.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-030-08 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-030-08.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-030-09 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_preservation/009_preservation_source_export.md rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-030-09.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_interviews/021_interviews_source_export.json for gift-policy threshold breach.", "id": "investigation.CBP-030-09.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/033_chat_exports_source_export.md to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-030-09.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_expenses/045_expenses_source_export.json.", "id": "investigation.CBP-030-09.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-030-09 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-030-09.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-030-09 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-030-09.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-030-10 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_preservation/010_preservation_source_export.txt rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-030-10.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_interviews/022_interviews_source_export.xml for retaliation concern.", "id": "investigation.CBP-030-10.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/034_chat_exports_source_export.txt to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-030-10.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_expenses/046_expenses_source_export.xml.", "id": "investigation.CBP-030-10.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-030-10 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective.", "id": "decision.CBP-030-10.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-030-10 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-030-10.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-030-11 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_preservation/011_preservation_source_export.eml rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-030-11.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_interviews/023_interviews_source_export.html for remediation ownership gap.", "id": "investigation.CBP-030-11.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/035_chat_exports_source_export.eml to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-030-11.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_expenses/047_expenses_source_export.html.", "id": "investigation.CBP-030-11.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-030-11 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-030-11.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-030-11 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-030-11.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-030-12 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_preservation/012_preservation_source_export.csv rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-030-12.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_interviews/024_interviews_source_export.pdf for approval override.", "id": "investigation.CBP-030-12.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_chat_exports/036_chat_exports_source_export.csv to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-030-12.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_expenses/048_expenses_source_export.pdf.", "id": "investigation.CBP-030-12.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-030-12 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key.", "id": "decision.CBP-030-12.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-030-12 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-030-12.register"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Write the exact selected option, supported action population, evidence-hold population, facts, owners, deadlines, and citations.", "id": "state.exact_decision"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create one exact register row per portfolio key with no extra, missing, or modified row.", "id": "state.exact_register"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Leave only the three approved deliverables and perform no extra state-changing write.", "id": "state.write_scope_containment"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Read back decision.json, matter-register.json, and advice.md after their final writes.", "id": "state.postwrite_readback"}, {"category": "answer", "description": "Explain the selected recommendation, supported actions, holds, alternatives, and limitations with exact source anchors.", "id": "answer.decision_note"}], "decision_options": [{"approach": "Treat supported actions and genuinely ambiguous records as if they were equally unresolved.", "id": "jasper-university:blanket-hold", "label": "Freeze the entire matter population"}, {"approach": "Apply the exact identity, current-state, authority, and revision test. Register supported purchase findings and preserve unsupported motive questions.", "id": "jasper-university:scoped-evidence", "label": "Escalate supported conflicts and repair disclosure or training controls at the correct scope."}, {"approach": "Use a plausible summary or one source without completing the controlling joins.", "id": "jasper-university:shortcut", "label": "Treat the former-student relationship alone as prohibited self-dealing."}], "evaluation_narrative": {"authority": "Conflict policy and grant rules require exact relationship, participation, and funding-source evidence.", "observation": "Correlate vendor ownership, purchase decisions, disclosure forms, training status, and expense purpose.", "question": "Did the Jasper purchases violate conflict or training requirements, and what should be reported?", "register_action": "Register supported purchase findings and preserve unsupported motive questions."}, "gates": ["all_required_evidence_precedes_first_write", "decision_criteria_complete", "register_state_exact", "write_scope_contained", "all_outputs_verified_by_readback"], "metadata_checks": 12, "metric": "weighted_criteria_score", "minimum_tool_calls": 92, "required_deliverables": ["decision.json", "matter-register.json", "advice.md"], "required_document_reads": 64, "type": "deterministic", "weights": {"advice": 0.15, "decision": 0.35, "investigation": 0.25, "state": 0.25}}, "task_id": "cb100-030-jasper-university", "task_name": "Jasper research-fund inquiry", "world_id": "counselbench-filesystem-mcp-v3"}
+{"context_files": ["task_files/cb100-031-aurora-antitrust/01_pleadings/001_pleadings_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-031-aurora-antitrust/01_pleadings/002_pleadings_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-031-aurora-antitrust/01_pleadings/003_pleadings_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-031-aurora-antitrust/01_pleadings/004_pleadings_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-031-aurora-antitrust/01_pleadings/005_pleadings_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-031-aurora-antitrust/01_pleadings/006_pleadings_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-031-aurora-antitrust/01_pleadings/007_pleadings_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-031-aurora-antitrust/01_pleadings/008_pleadings_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-031-aurora-antitrust/02_orders/009_orders_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-031-aurora-antitrust/02_orders/010_orders_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-031-aurora-antitrust/02_orders/011_orders_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-031-aurora-antitrust/02_orders/012_orders_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-031-aurora-antitrust/02_orders/013_orders_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-031-aurora-antitrust/02_orders/014_orders_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-031-aurora-antitrust/02_orders/015_orders_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-031-aurora-antitrust/02_orders/016_orders_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-031-aurora-antitrust/03_requests_responses/017_requests_responses_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-031-aurora-antitrust/03_requests_responses/018_requests_responses_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-031-aurora-antitrust/03_requests_responses/019_requests_responses_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-031-aurora-antitrust/03_requests_responses/020_requests_responses_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-031-aurora-antitrust/03_requests_responses/021_requests_responses_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-031-aurora-antitrust/03_requests_responses/022_requests_responses_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-031-aurora-antitrust/03_requests_responses/023_requests_responses_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-031-aurora-antitrust/03_requests_responses/024_requests_responses_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-031-aurora-antitrust/04_custodian_files/025_custodian_files_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-031-aurora-antitrust/04_custodian_files/026_custodian_files_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-031-aurora-antitrust/04_custodian_files/027_custodian_files_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-031-aurora-antitrust/04_custodian_files/028_custodian_files_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-031-aurora-antitrust/04_custodian_files/029_custodian_files_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-031-aurora-antitrust/04_custodian_files/030_custodian_files_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-031-aurora-antitrust/04_custodian_files/031_custodian_files_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-031-aurora-antitrust/04_custodian_files/032_custodian_files_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-031-aurora-antitrust/05_email_families/033_email_families_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-031-aurora-antitrust/05_email_families/034_email_families_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-031-aurora-antitrust/05_email_families/035_email_families_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-031-aurora-antitrust/05_email_families/036_email_families_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-031-aurora-antitrust/05_email_families/037_email_families_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-031-aurora-antitrust/05_email_families/038_email_families_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-031-aurora-antitrust/05_email_families/039_email_families_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-031-aurora-antitrust/05_email_families/040_email_families_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-031-aurora-antitrust/06_chat_exports/041_chat_exports_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-031-aurora-antitrust/06_chat_exports/042_chat_exports_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-031-aurora-antitrust/06_chat_exports/043_chat_exports_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-031-aurora-antitrust/06_chat_exports/044_chat_exports_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-031-aurora-antitrust/06_chat_exports/045_chat_exports_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-031-aurora-antitrust/06_chat_exports/046_chat_exports_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-031-aurora-antitrust/06_chat_exports/047_chat_exports_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-031-aurora-antitrust/06_chat_exports/048_chat_exports_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-031-aurora-antitrust/07_privilege_material/049_privilege_material_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-031-aurora-antitrust/07_privilege_material/050_privilege_material_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-031-aurora-antitrust/07_privilege_material/051_privilege_material_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-031-aurora-antitrust/07_privilege_material/052_privilege_material_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-031-aurora-antitrust/07_privilege_material/053_privilege_material_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-031-aurora-antitrust/07_privilege_material/054_privilege_material_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-031-aurora-antitrust/07_privilege_material/055_privilege_material_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-031-aurora-antitrust/07_privilege_material/056_privilege_material_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-031-aurora-antitrust/08_production_logs/057_production_logs_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-031-aurora-antitrust/08_production_logs/058_production_logs_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-031-aurora-antitrust/08_production_logs/059_production_logs_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-031-aurora-antitrust/08_production_logs/060_production_logs_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-031-aurora-antitrust/08_production_logs/061_production_logs_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-031-aurora-antitrust/08_production_logs/062_production_logs_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-031-aurora-antitrust/08_production_logs/063_production_logs_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-031-aurora-antitrust/08_production_logs/064_production_logs_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-031-aurora-antitrust/09_depositions/065_depositions_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-031-aurora-antitrust/09_depositions/066_depositions_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-031-aurora-antitrust/09_depositions/067_depositions_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-031-aurora-antitrust/09_depositions/068_depositions_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-031-aurora-antitrust/09_depositions/069_depositions_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-031-aurora-antitrust/09_depositions/070_depositions_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-031-aurora-antitrust/09_depositions/071_depositions_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-031-aurora-antitrust/09_depositions/072_depositions_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-031-aurora-antitrust/10_expert_material/073_expert_material_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-031-aurora-antitrust/10_expert_material/074_expert_material_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-031-aurora-antitrust/10_expert_material/075_expert_material_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-031-aurora-antitrust/10_expert_material/076_expert_material_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-031-aurora-antitrust/10_expert_material/077_expert_material_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-031-aurora-antitrust/10_expert_material/078_expert_material_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-031-aurora-antitrust/10_expert_material/079_expert_material_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-031-aurora-antitrust/10_expert_material/080_expert_material_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-031-aurora-antitrust/11_third_party/081_third_party_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-031-aurora-antitrust/11_third_party/082_third_party_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-031-aurora-antitrust/11_third_party/083_third_party_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-031-aurora-antitrust/11_third_party/084_third_party_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-031-aurora-antitrust/11_third_party/085_third_party_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-031-aurora-antitrust/11_third_party/086_third_party_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-031-aurora-antitrust/11_third_party/087_third_party_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-031-aurora-antitrust/11_third_party/088_third_party_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-031-aurora-antitrust/12_case_management/089_case_management_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-031-aurora-antitrust/12_case_management/090_case_management_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-031-aurora-antitrust/12_case_management/091_case_management_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-031-aurora-antitrust/12_case_management/092_case_management_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-031-aurora-antitrust/12_case_management/093_case_management_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-031-aurora-antitrust/12_case_management/094_case_management_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-031-aurora-antitrust/12_case_management/095_case_management_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-031-aurora-antitrust/12_case_management/096_case_management_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-031-aurora-antitrust/12_case_management/097_aurora_antitrust_impact_population.xlsx"], "gold_output": {"advice_markdown": "# Decision note — Aurora pricing MDL discovery audit\n\n## Recommendation\n\nCertify only after supported collection, family, and privilege gaps are cured or disclosed. The reconciled record supports 6 scoped actions and leaves 6 items on evidence hold.\n\nSelected option: `aurora-antitrust:scoped-evidence`.\n\n## Why this is the supported option\n\nReconcile custodian scope, mobile collections, Bates families, and privilege challenges against court requirements. The operative discovery order and certification population govern completeness and privilege treatment.\n\n## Supported actions\n\n### CBP-031-02 — email-family separation (critical)\n\nan open exception blocks completion under CB-LD-2701-R682; the current status is open and unresolved under CB-LD-2701-E716. Identity resolves to ENT-031-1001, revision REV-2025.2 is current, and Talia Brooks is active with capacity 1.\n\nAction: Create production-control rows for exact gaps and hold nonresponsive anomalies. Owner: Talia Brooks; due 2026-09-03.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_pleadings/002_pleadings_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/02_orders/014_orders_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/026_custodian_files_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/05_email_families/038_email_families_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/12_case_management/097_aurora_antitrust_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-031-06 — protective-order designation error (high)\n\nthe controlled population contains 148 records under CB-LD-2701-R246; the certification covers 125 records under CB-LD-2701-E214. Identity resolves to ENT-031-1005, revision REV-2025.6 is current, and Leona Park is active with capacity 6.\n\nAction: Create production-control rows for exact gaps and hold nonresponsive anomalies. Owner: Leona Park; due 2026-08-30.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_pleadings/006_pleadings_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/018_requests_responses_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/030_custodian_files_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/042_chat_exports_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/09_depositions/066_depositions_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/10_expert_material/078_expert_material_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/12_case_management/097_aurora_antitrust_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-031-07 — production gap (medium)\n\nthe permission is limited to Northern District of Illinois under CB-LD-2701-R626; the matched activity occurred in Illinois under CB-LD-2701-E660. Identity resolves to ENT-031-1006, revision REV-2025.7 is current, and Henry Cho is active with capacity 6.\n\nAction: Create production-control rows for exact gaps and hold nonresponsive anomalies. Owner: Henry Cho; due 2026-08-29.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_pleadings/007_pleadings_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/019_requests_responses_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/031_custodian_files_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/043_chat_exports_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/12_case_management/097_aurora_antitrust_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-031-08 — legal-hold delivery gap (medium)\n\nthe operative cap is $6,202,000.00 under CB-LD-2701-R397; the matched ledger population totals $6,445,997.00 under CB-LD-2701-E382. Identity resolves to ENT-031-1007, revision REV-2025.1 is current, and Maya Ellison is active with capacity 1.\n\nAction: Create production-control rows for exact gaps and hold nonresponsive anomalies. Owner: Maya Ellison; due 2026-08-28.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_pleadings/008_pleadings_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/020_requests_responses_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/032_custodian_files_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/044_chat_exports_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/12_case_management/097_aurora_antitrust_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-031-09 — clawback deadline (medium)\n\ndelivery must use notices-aurora_home_supply_co@example.test under CB-LD-2701-R664; the only matched receipt used archive-in_re_residential_fixture_pricing@example.test under CB-LD-2701-E503. Identity resolves to ENT-031-1008, revision REV-2025.2 is current, and Jonas Feld is active with capacity 1.\n\nAction: Create production-control rows for exact gaps and hold nonresponsive anomalies. Owner: Jonas Feld; due 2026-08-27.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/02_orders/009_orders_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/021_requests_responses_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/05_email_families/033_email_families_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/045_chat_exports_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/09_depositions/069_depositions_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/08_production_logs/057_production_logs_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/12_case_management/097_aurora_antitrust_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-031-12 — common-interest support gap (critical)\n\nthe controlling threshold is 5% under CB-LD-2701-R908; the independently calculated result is 9% under CB-LD-2701-E253. Identity resolves to ENT-031-1011, revision REV-2025.5 is current, and Priya Raman is active with capacity 1.\n\nAction: Create production-control rows for exact gaps and hold nonresponsive anomalies. Owner: Priya Raman; due 2026-09-02.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/02_orders/012_orders_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/024_requests_responses_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/05_email_families/036_email_families_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/048_chat_exports_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/12_case_management/097_aurora_antitrust_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n## Evidence holds\n\n- **CBP-031-01 — Bates-range overlap**: the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective. Next evidence: effective approval and an active owner with remaining capacity. Sources: `/workspace/documents/01_pleadings/001_pleadings_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/02_orders/013_orders_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/025_custodian_files_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/05_email_families/037_email_families_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/11_third_party/085_third_party_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/08_production_logs/061_production_logs_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/12_case_management/097_aurora_antitrust_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-031-03 — request-response mismatch**: two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key. Next evidence: an approved immutable entity crosswalk. Sources: `/workspace/documents/01_pleadings/003_pleadings_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/02_orders/015_orders_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/027_custodian_files_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/05_email_families/039_email_families_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/12_case_management/097_aurora_antitrust_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-031-04 — metadata field loss**: the current observation does not meet the operative trigger. Next evidence: a current observation that satisfies the operative trigger. Sources: `/workspace/documents/01_pleadings/004_pleadings_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/02_orders/016_orders_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/028_custodian_files_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/05_email_families/040_email_families_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/12_case_management/097_aurora_antitrust_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-031-05 — collection-date inconsistency**: the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective. Next evidence: effective approval and an active owner with remaining capacity. Sources: `/workspace/documents/01_pleadings/005_pleadings_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/017_requests_responses_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/029_custodian_files_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/041_chat_exports_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/12_case_management/089_case_management_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/12_case_management/097_aurora_antitrust_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-031-10 — third-party subpoena deadline**: the operational record relies on a superseded control revision. Next evidence: an operational record using the current effective revision. Sources: `/workspace/documents/02_orders/010_orders_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/022_requests_responses_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/05_email_families/034_email_families_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/046_chat_exports_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/09_depositions/070_depositions_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/12_case_management/097_aurora_antitrust_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-031-11 — custodian omission**: two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key. Next evidence: an approved immutable entity crosswalk. Sources: `/workspace/documents/02_orders/011_orders_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/023_requests_responses_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/05_email_families/035_email_families_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/047_chat_exports_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/12_case_management/097_aurora_antitrust_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n## Alternatives considered\n\n- `aurora-antitrust:shortcut` — Certify from the production log totals without checking custodians or overlaps.: Use a plausible summary or one source without completing the controlling joins.\n- `aurora-antitrust:blanket-hold` — Freeze the entire matter population: Treat supported actions and genuinely ambiguous records as if they were equally unresolved.\n\n## Assumptions and limits\n\nThis decision is limited to cb100-031-aurora-antitrust, the supplied synthetic records, and the matter state as of 2026-09-05. Similar names, stale revisions, and pending authority are not treated as proof.\n", "decision": {"actions": [{"determination": "an open exception blocks completion under CB-LD-2701-R682; the current status is open and unresolved under CB-LD-2701-E716. Identity resolves to ENT-031-1001, revision REV-2025.2 is current, and Talia Brooks is active with capacity 1.", "due_date": "2026-09-03", "id": "ACT-CBP-031-02", "identity_id": "ENT-031-1001", "issue": "email-family separation", "owner": "Talia Brooks", "portfolio_key": "CBP-031-02", "recommended_action": "Create production-control rows for exact gaps and hold nonresponsive anomalies. Owner: Talia Brooks; due 2026-09-03.", "severity": "critical", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_pleadings/002_pleadings_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/02_orders/014_orders_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/026_custodian_files_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/05_email_families/038_email_families_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_case_management/097_aurora_antitrust_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "the controlled population contains 148 records under CB-LD-2701-R246; the certification covers 125 records under CB-LD-2701-E214. Identity resolves to ENT-031-1005, revision REV-2025.6 is current, and Leona Park is active with capacity 6.", "due_date": "2026-08-30", "id": "ACT-CBP-031-06", "identity_id": "ENT-031-1005", "issue": "protective-order designation error", "owner": "Leona Park", "portfolio_key": "CBP-031-06", "recommended_action": "Create production-control rows for exact gaps and hold nonresponsive anomalies. Owner: Leona Park; due 2026-08-30.", "severity": "high", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_pleadings/006_pleadings_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/018_requests_responses_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/030_custodian_files_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/042_chat_exports_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/09_depositions/066_depositions_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/10_expert_material/078_expert_material_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_case_management/097_aurora_antitrust_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "the permission is limited to Northern District of Illinois under CB-LD-2701-R626; the matched activity occurred in Illinois under CB-LD-2701-E660. Identity resolves to ENT-031-1006, revision REV-2025.7 is current, and Henry Cho is active with capacity 6.", "due_date": "2026-08-29", "id": "ACT-CBP-031-07", "identity_id": "ENT-031-1006", "issue": "production gap", "owner": "Henry Cho", "portfolio_key": "CBP-031-07", "recommended_action": "Create production-control rows for exact gaps and hold nonresponsive anomalies. Owner: Henry Cho; due 2026-08-29.", "severity": "medium", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_pleadings/007_pleadings_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/019_requests_responses_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/031_custodian_files_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/043_chat_exports_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/12_case_management/097_aurora_antitrust_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "the operative cap is $6,202,000.00 under CB-LD-2701-R397; the matched ledger population totals $6,445,997.00 under CB-LD-2701-E382. Identity resolves to ENT-031-1007, revision REV-2025.1 is current, and Maya Ellison is active with capacity 1.", "due_date": "2026-08-28", "id": "ACT-CBP-031-08", "identity_id": "ENT-031-1007", "issue": "legal-hold delivery gap", "owner": "Maya Ellison", "portfolio_key": "CBP-031-08", "recommended_action": "Create production-control rows for exact gaps and hold nonresponsive anomalies. Owner: Maya Ellison; due 2026-08-28.", "severity": "medium", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_pleadings/008_pleadings_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/020_requests_responses_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/032_custodian_files_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/044_chat_exports_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/12_case_management/097_aurora_antitrust_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "delivery must use notices-aurora_home_supply_co@example.test under CB-LD-2701-R664; the only matched receipt used archive-in_re_residential_fixture_pricing@example.test under CB-LD-2701-E503. Identity resolves to ENT-031-1008, revision REV-2025.2 is current, and Jonas Feld is active with capacity 1.", "due_date": "2026-08-27", "id": "ACT-CBP-031-09", "identity_id": "ENT-031-1008", "issue": "clawback deadline", "owner": "Jonas Feld", "portfolio_key": "CBP-031-09", "recommended_action": "Create production-control rows for exact gaps and hold nonresponsive anomalies. Owner: Jonas Feld; due 2026-08-27.", "severity": "medium", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_orders/009_orders_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/021_requests_responses_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/05_email_families/033_email_families_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/045_chat_exports_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/09_depositions/069_depositions_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/08_production_logs/057_production_logs_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/12_case_management/097_aurora_antitrust_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "the controlling threshold is 5% under CB-LD-2701-R908; the independently calculated result is 9% under CB-LD-2701-E253. Identity resolves to ENT-031-1011, revision REV-2025.5 is current, and Priya Raman is active with capacity 1.", "due_date": "2026-09-02", "id": "ACT-CBP-031-12", "identity_id": "ENT-031-1011", "issue": "common-interest support gap", "owner": "Priya Raman", "portfolio_key": "CBP-031-12", "recommended_action": "Create production-control rows for exact gaps and hold nonresponsive anomalies. Owner: Priya Raman; due 2026-09-02.", "severity": "critical", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_orders/012_orders_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/024_requests_responses_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/05_email_families/036_email_families_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/048_chat_exports_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_case_management/097_aurora_antitrust_impact_population.xlsx"]}], "as_of": "2026-09-05", "decision": {"alternatives_considered": ["aurora-antitrust:shortcut", "aurora-antitrust:blanket-hold"], "question": "Can Aurora certify the MDL production, and which gaps must be cured before certification?", "rationale": "The four-part causal test supports 6 scoped actions and leaves 6 records on evidence hold. The operative discovery order and certification population govern completeness and privilege treatment.", "recommendation": "Certify only after supported collection, family, and privilege gaps are cured or disclosed.", "selected_option_id": "aurora-antitrust:scoped-evidence"}, "holds": [{"id": "HOLD-CBP-031-01", "issue": "Bates-range overlap", "portfolio_key": "CBP-031-01", "reason": "the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective", "required_next_evidence": "effective approval and an active owner with remaining capacity", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_pleadings/001_pleadings_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/02_orders/013_orders_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/025_custodian_files_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/05_email_families/037_email_families_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/11_third_party/085_third_party_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/08_production_logs/061_production_logs_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_case_management/097_aurora_antitrust_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-031-03", "issue": "request-response mismatch", "portfolio_key": "CBP-031-03", "reason": "two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key", "required_next_evidence": "an approved immutable entity crosswalk", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_pleadings/003_pleadings_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/02_orders/015_orders_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/027_custodian_files_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/05_email_families/039_email_families_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_case_management/097_aurora_antitrust_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-031-04", "issue": "metadata field loss", "portfolio_key": "CBP-031-04", "reason": "the current observation does not meet the operative trigger", "required_next_evidence": "a current observation that satisfies the operative trigger", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_pleadings/004_pleadings_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/02_orders/016_orders_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/028_custodian_files_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/05_email_families/040_email_families_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_case_management/097_aurora_antitrust_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-031-05", "issue": "collection-date inconsistency", "portfolio_key": "CBP-031-05", "reason": "the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective", "required_next_evidence": "effective approval and an active owner with remaining capacity", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_pleadings/005_pleadings_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/017_requests_responses_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/029_custodian_files_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/041_chat_exports_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/12_case_management/089_case_management_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/12_case_management/097_aurora_antitrust_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-031-10", "issue": "third-party subpoena deadline", "portfolio_key": "CBP-031-10", "reason": "the operational record relies on a superseded control revision", "required_next_evidence": "an operational record using the current effective revision", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_orders/010_orders_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/022_requests_responses_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/05_email_families/034_email_families_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/046_chat_exports_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/09_depositions/070_depositions_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_case_management/097_aurora_antitrust_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-031-11", "issue": "custodian omission", "portfolio_key": "CBP-031-11", "reason": "two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key", "required_next_evidence": "an approved immutable entity crosswalk", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_orders/011_orders_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/023_requests_responses_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/05_email_families/035_email_families_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/047_chat_exports_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_case_management/097_aurora_antitrust_impact_population.xlsx"]}], "matter_number": "CB-LD-2701", "prepared_for": "Aurora Home Supply Co.", "schema_version": "counselbench.decision.v3", "task_id": "cb100-031-aurora-antitrust"}, "matter_register": {"matter_number": "CB-LD-2701", "rows": [{"decision_option_id": "aurora-antitrust:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective", "issue": "Bates-range overlap", "matter_number": "CB-LD-2701", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-031-01", "row_id": "REG-CBP-031-01", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_pleadings/001_pleadings_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/02_orders/013_orders_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/025_custodian_files_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/05_email_families/037_email_families_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/11_third_party/085_third_party_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/08_production_logs/061_production_logs_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_case_management/097_aurora_antitrust_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "aurora-antitrust:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-03", "issue": "email-family separation", "matter_number": "CB-LD-2701", "owner": "Talia Brooks", "portfolio_key": "CBP-031-02", "row_id": "REG-CBP-031-02", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_pleadings/002_pleadings_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/02_orders/014_orders_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/026_custodian_files_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/05_email_families/038_email_families_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_case_management/097_aurora_antitrust_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "aurora-antitrust:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key", "issue": "request-response mismatch", "matter_number": "CB-LD-2701", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-031-03", "row_id": "REG-CBP-031-03", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_pleadings/003_pleadings_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/02_orders/015_orders_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/027_custodian_files_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/05_email_families/039_email_families_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_case_management/097_aurora_antitrust_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "aurora-antitrust:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "the current observation does not meet the operative trigger", "issue": "metadata field loss", "matter_number": "CB-LD-2701", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-031-04", "row_id": "REG-CBP-031-04", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_pleadings/004_pleadings_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/02_orders/016_orders_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/028_custodian_files_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/05_email_families/040_email_families_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_case_management/097_aurora_antitrust_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "aurora-antitrust:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective", "issue": "collection-date inconsistency", "matter_number": "CB-LD-2701", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-031-05", "row_id": "REG-CBP-031-05", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_pleadings/005_pleadings_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/017_requests_responses_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/029_custodian_files_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/041_chat_exports_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/12_case_management/089_case_management_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/12_case_management/097_aurora_antitrust_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "aurora-antitrust:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-08-30", "issue": "protective-order designation error", "matter_number": "CB-LD-2701", "owner": "Leona Park", "portfolio_key": "CBP-031-06", "row_id": "REG-CBP-031-06", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_pleadings/006_pleadings_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/018_requests_responses_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/030_custodian_files_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/042_chat_exports_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/09_depositions/066_depositions_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/10_expert_material/078_expert_material_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_case_management/097_aurora_antitrust_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "aurora-antitrust:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-08-29", "issue": "production gap", "matter_number": "CB-LD-2701", "owner": "Henry Cho", "portfolio_key": "CBP-031-07", "row_id": "REG-CBP-031-07", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_pleadings/007_pleadings_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/019_requests_responses_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/031_custodian_files_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/043_chat_exports_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/12_case_management/097_aurora_antitrust_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "aurora-antitrust:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-08-28", "issue": "legal-hold delivery gap", "matter_number": "CB-LD-2701", "owner": "Maya Ellison", "portfolio_key": "CBP-031-08", "row_id": "REG-CBP-031-08", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_pleadings/008_pleadings_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/020_requests_responses_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/032_custodian_files_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/044_chat_exports_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/12_case_management/097_aurora_antitrust_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "aurora-antitrust:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-08-27", "issue": "clawback deadline", "matter_number": "CB-LD-2701", "owner": "Jonas Feld", "portfolio_key": "CBP-031-09", "row_id": "REG-CBP-031-09", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_orders/009_orders_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/021_requests_responses_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/05_email_families/033_email_families_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/045_chat_exports_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/09_depositions/069_depositions_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/08_production_logs/057_production_logs_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/12_case_management/097_aurora_antitrust_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "aurora-antitrust:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "the operational record relies on a superseded control revision", "issue": "third-party subpoena deadline", "matter_number": "CB-LD-2701", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-031-10", "row_id": "REG-CBP-031-10", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_orders/010_orders_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/022_requests_responses_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/05_email_families/034_email_families_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/046_chat_exports_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/09_depositions/070_depositions_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_case_management/097_aurora_antitrust_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "aurora-antitrust:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key", "issue": "custodian omission", "matter_number": "CB-LD-2701", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-031-11", "row_id": "REG-CBP-031-11", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_orders/011_orders_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/023_requests_responses_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/05_email_families/035_email_families_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/047_chat_exports_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_case_management/097_aurora_antitrust_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "aurora-antitrust:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-02", "issue": "common-interest support gap", "matter_number": "CB-LD-2701", "owner": "Priya Raman", "portfolio_key": "CBP-031-12", "row_id": "REG-CBP-031-12", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_orders/012_orders_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/024_requests_responses_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/05_email_families/036_email_families_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/048_chat_exports_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_case_management/097_aurora_antitrust_impact_population.xlsx"]}], "schema_version": "counselbench.matter-register.v3", "task_id": "cb100-031-aurora-antitrust"}}, "metadata": {"benchmark": "CounselBench-100", "code_license": "Apache-2.0", "data_license": "CC-BY-4.0", "deadline": "2026-09-05", "document_count": 97, "evidence_holds": 6, "jurisdiction": "Illinois", "matter_number": "CB-LD-2701", "mcp_commit": "9a96ea6e5913736f92b88345bf51caeaaa8e719f", "mcp_package": "@modelcontextprotocol/server-filesystem@2026.7.10", "practice_area": "litigation-discovery", "reference_tool_calls": 76, "required_evidence_reads": 57, "supported_actions": 6, "synthetic": true, "venue": "Northern District of Illinois", "version": "3.1.0"}, "prompt": "I need a straight answer before the next partner call. Can Aurora certify the MDL production, and which gaps must be cured before certification? A multidistrict antitrust production must reconcile mobile chats, departed custodians, overlapping Bates ranges, and a pending privilege challenge. The team needs the call by 2026-09-05. Update the matter record only where the evidence supports it, and give me the practical options for the client.", "rubric": {"criteria": [{"category": "investigation", "description": "Inventory the production and use targeted searches to locate records across native formats.", "id": "investigation.discover_production"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Complete every task-specific identity, authority, operations, and approval read before the first state transition.", "id": "investigation.read_before_write"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Inspect designated source metadata before relying on those records.", "id": "investigation.custody_before_write"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "Select the supported option 'aurora-antitrust:scoped-evidence' after applying the four-part test.", "id": "decision.selected_option"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "Identify both rejected approaches and explain why a one-source shortcut and a blanket hold are wrong.", "id": "decision.alternatives"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-031-01 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_pleadings/001_pleadings_source_export.md rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-031-01.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_orders/013_orders_source_export.json for Bates-range overlap.", "id": "investigation.CBP-031-01.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/025_custodian_files_source_export.md to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-031-01.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_email_families/037_email_families_source_export.json.", "id": "investigation.CBP-031-01.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-031-01 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective.", "id": "decision.CBP-031-01.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-031-01 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-031-01.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-031-02 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_pleadings/002_pleadings_source_export.txt rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-031-02.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_orders/014_orders_source_export.xml for email-family separation.", "id": "investigation.CBP-031-02.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/026_custodian_files_source_export.txt to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-031-02.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_email_families/038_email_families_source_export.xml.", "id": "investigation.CBP-031-02.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-031-02 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-031-02.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-031-02 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-031-02.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-031-03 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_pleadings/003_pleadings_source_export.eml rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-031-03.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_orders/015_orders_source_export.html for request-response mismatch.", "id": "investigation.CBP-031-03.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/027_custodian_files_source_export.eml to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-031-03.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_email_families/039_email_families_source_export.html.", "id": "investigation.CBP-031-03.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-031-03 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key.", "id": "decision.CBP-031-03.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-031-03 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-031-03.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-031-04 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_pleadings/004_pleadings_source_export.csv rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-031-04.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_orders/016_orders_source_export.pdf for metadata field loss.", "id": "investigation.CBP-031-04.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/028_custodian_files_source_export.csv to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-031-04.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_email_families/040_email_families_source_export.pdf.", "id": "investigation.CBP-031-04.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-031-04 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is the current observation does not meet the operative trigger.", "id": "decision.CBP-031-04.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-031-04 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-031-04.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-031-05 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_pleadings/005_pleadings_source_export.json rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-031-05.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/017_requests_responses_source_export.md for collection-date inconsistency.", "id": "investigation.CBP-031-05.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/029_custodian_files_source_export.json to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-031-05.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/041_chat_exports_source_export.md.", "id": "investigation.CBP-031-05.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-031-05 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective.", "id": "decision.CBP-031-05.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-031-05 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-031-05.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-031-06 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_pleadings/006_pleadings_source_export.xml rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-031-06.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/018_requests_responses_source_export.txt for protective-order designation error.", "id": "investigation.CBP-031-06.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/030_custodian_files_source_export.xml to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-031-06.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/042_chat_exports_source_export.txt.", "id": "investigation.CBP-031-06.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-031-06 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-031-06.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-031-06 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-031-06.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-031-07 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_pleadings/007_pleadings_source_export.html rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-031-07.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/019_requests_responses_source_export.eml for production gap.", "id": "investigation.CBP-031-07.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/031_custodian_files_source_export.html to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-031-07.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/043_chat_exports_source_export.eml.", "id": "investigation.CBP-031-07.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-031-07 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-031-07.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-031-07 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-031-07.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-031-08 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_pleadings/008_pleadings_source_export.pdf rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-031-08.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/020_requests_responses_source_export.csv for legal-hold delivery gap.", "id": "investigation.CBP-031-08.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/032_custodian_files_source_export.pdf to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-031-08.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/044_chat_exports_source_export.csv.", "id": "investigation.CBP-031-08.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-031-08 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-031-08.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-031-08 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-031-08.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-031-09 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_orders/009_orders_source_export.md rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-031-09.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/021_requests_responses_source_export.json for clawback deadline.", "id": "investigation.CBP-031-09.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_email_families/033_email_families_source_export.md to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-031-09.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/045_chat_exports_source_export.json.", "id": "investigation.CBP-031-09.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-031-09 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-031-09.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-031-09 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-031-09.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-031-10 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_orders/010_orders_source_export.txt rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-031-10.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/022_requests_responses_source_export.xml for third-party subpoena deadline.", "id": "investigation.CBP-031-10.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_email_families/034_email_families_source_export.txt to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-031-10.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/046_chat_exports_source_export.xml.", "id": "investigation.CBP-031-10.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-031-10 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is the operational record relies on a superseded control revision.", "id": "decision.CBP-031-10.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-031-10 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-031-10.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-031-11 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_orders/011_orders_source_export.eml rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-031-11.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/023_requests_responses_source_export.html for custodian omission.", "id": "investigation.CBP-031-11.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_email_families/035_email_families_source_export.eml to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-031-11.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/047_chat_exports_source_export.html.", "id": "investigation.CBP-031-11.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-031-11 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key.", "id": "decision.CBP-031-11.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-031-11 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-031-11.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-031-12 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_orders/012_orders_source_export.csv rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-031-12.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/024_requests_responses_source_export.pdf for common-interest support gap.", "id": "investigation.CBP-031-12.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_email_families/036_email_families_source_export.csv to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-031-12.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/048_chat_exports_source_export.pdf.", "id": "investigation.CBP-031-12.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-031-12 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-031-12.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-031-12 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-031-12.register"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Write the exact selected option, supported action population, evidence-hold population, facts, owners, deadlines, and citations.", "id": "state.exact_decision"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create one exact register row per portfolio key with no extra, missing, or modified row.", "id": "state.exact_register"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Leave only the three approved deliverables and perform no extra state-changing write.", "id": "state.write_scope_containment"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Read back decision.json, matter-register.json, and advice.md after their final writes.", "id": "state.postwrite_readback"}, {"category": "answer", "description": "Explain the selected recommendation, supported actions, holds, alternatives, and limitations with exact source anchors.", "id": "answer.decision_note"}], "decision_options": [{"approach": "Apply the exact identity, current-state, authority, and revision test. Create production-control rows for exact gaps and hold nonresponsive anomalies.", "id": "aurora-antitrust:scoped-evidence", "label": "Certify only after supported collection, family, and privilege gaps are cured or disclosed."}, {"approach": "Use a plausible summary or one source without completing the controlling joins.", "id": "aurora-antitrust:shortcut", "label": "Certify from the production log totals without checking custodians or overlaps."}, {"approach": "Treat supported actions and genuinely ambiguous records as if they were equally unresolved.", "id": "aurora-antitrust:blanket-hold", "label": "Freeze the entire matter population"}], "evaluation_narrative": {"authority": "The operative discovery order and certification population govern completeness and privilege treatment.", "observation": "Reconcile custodian scope, mobile collections, Bates families, and privilege challenges against court requirements.", "question": "Can Aurora certify the MDL production, and which gaps must be cured before certification?", "register_action": "Create production-control rows for exact gaps and hold nonresponsive anomalies."}, "gates": ["all_required_evidence_precedes_first_write", "decision_criteria_complete", "register_state_exact", "write_scope_contained", "all_outputs_verified_by_readback"], "metadata_checks": 4, "metric": "weighted_criteria_score", "minimum_tool_calls": 76, "required_deliverables": ["decision.json", "matter-register.json", "advice.md"], "required_document_reads": 57, "type": "deterministic", "weights": {"advice": 0.15, "decision": 0.35, "investigation": 0.25, "state": 0.25}}, "task_id": "cb100-031-aurora-antitrust", "task_name": "Aurora pricing MDL discovery audit", "world_id": "counselbench-filesystem-mcp-v3"}
+{"context_files": ["task_files/cb100-032-bayfield-patent/01_pleadings/001_pleadings_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-032-bayfield-patent/01_pleadings/002_pleadings_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-032-bayfield-patent/01_pleadings/003_pleadings_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-032-bayfield-patent/01_pleadings/004_pleadings_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-032-bayfield-patent/01_pleadings/005_pleadings_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-032-bayfield-patent/01_pleadings/006_pleadings_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-032-bayfield-patent/01_pleadings/007_pleadings_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-032-bayfield-patent/01_pleadings/008_pleadings_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-032-bayfield-patent/02_orders/009_orders_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-032-bayfield-patent/02_orders/010_orders_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-032-bayfield-patent/02_orders/011_orders_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-032-bayfield-patent/02_orders/012_orders_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-032-bayfield-patent/02_orders/013_orders_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-032-bayfield-patent/02_orders/014_orders_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-032-bayfield-patent/02_orders/015_orders_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-032-bayfield-patent/02_orders/016_orders_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-032-bayfield-patent/03_requests_responses/017_requests_responses_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-032-bayfield-patent/03_requests_responses/018_requests_responses_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-032-bayfield-patent/03_requests_responses/019_requests_responses_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-032-bayfield-patent/03_requests_responses/020_requests_responses_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-032-bayfield-patent/03_requests_responses/021_requests_responses_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-032-bayfield-patent/03_requests_responses/022_requests_responses_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-032-bayfield-patent/03_requests_responses/023_requests_responses_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-032-bayfield-patent/03_requests_responses/024_requests_responses_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-032-bayfield-patent/04_custodian_files/025_custodian_files_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-032-bayfield-patent/04_custodian_files/026_custodian_files_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-032-bayfield-patent/04_custodian_files/027_custodian_files_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-032-bayfield-patent/04_custodian_files/028_custodian_files_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-032-bayfield-patent/04_custodian_files/029_custodian_files_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-032-bayfield-patent/04_custodian_files/030_custodian_files_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-032-bayfield-patent/04_custodian_files/031_custodian_files_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-032-bayfield-patent/04_custodian_files/032_custodian_files_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-032-bayfield-patent/05_email_families/033_email_families_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-032-bayfield-patent/05_email_families/034_email_families_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-032-bayfield-patent/05_email_families/035_email_families_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-032-bayfield-patent/05_email_families/036_email_families_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-032-bayfield-patent/05_email_families/037_email_families_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-032-bayfield-patent/05_email_families/038_email_families_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-032-bayfield-patent/05_email_families/039_email_families_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-032-bayfield-patent/05_email_families/040_email_families_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-032-bayfield-patent/06_chat_exports/041_chat_exports_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-032-bayfield-patent/06_chat_exports/042_chat_exports_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-032-bayfield-patent/06_chat_exports/043_chat_exports_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-032-bayfield-patent/06_chat_exports/044_chat_exports_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-032-bayfield-patent/06_chat_exports/045_chat_exports_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-032-bayfield-patent/06_chat_exports/046_chat_exports_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-032-bayfield-patent/06_chat_exports/047_chat_exports_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-032-bayfield-patent/06_chat_exports/048_chat_exports_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-032-bayfield-patent/07_privilege_material/049_privilege_material_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-032-bayfield-patent/07_privilege_material/050_privilege_material_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-032-bayfield-patent/07_privilege_material/051_privilege_material_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-032-bayfield-patent/07_privilege_material/052_privilege_material_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-032-bayfield-patent/07_privilege_material/053_privilege_material_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-032-bayfield-patent/07_privilege_material/054_privilege_material_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-032-bayfield-patent/07_privilege_material/055_privilege_material_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-032-bayfield-patent/07_privilege_material/056_privilege_material_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-032-bayfield-patent/08_production_logs/057_production_logs_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-032-bayfield-patent/08_production_logs/058_production_logs_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-032-bayfield-patent/08_production_logs/059_production_logs_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-032-bayfield-patent/08_production_logs/060_production_logs_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-032-bayfield-patent/08_production_logs/061_production_logs_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-032-bayfield-patent/08_production_logs/062_production_logs_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-032-bayfield-patent/08_production_logs/063_production_logs_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-032-bayfield-patent/08_production_logs/064_production_logs_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-032-bayfield-patent/09_depositions/065_depositions_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-032-bayfield-patent/09_depositions/066_depositions_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-032-bayfield-patent/09_depositions/067_depositions_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-032-bayfield-patent/09_depositions/068_depositions_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-032-bayfield-patent/09_depositions/069_depositions_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-032-bayfield-patent/09_depositions/070_depositions_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-032-bayfield-patent/09_depositions/071_depositions_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-032-bayfield-patent/09_depositions/072_depositions_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-032-bayfield-patent/10_expert_material/073_expert_material_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-032-bayfield-patent/10_expert_material/074_expert_material_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-032-bayfield-patent/10_expert_material/075_expert_material_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-032-bayfield-patent/10_expert_material/076_expert_material_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-032-bayfield-patent/10_expert_material/077_expert_material_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-032-bayfield-patent/10_expert_material/078_expert_material_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-032-bayfield-patent/10_expert_material/079_expert_material_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-032-bayfield-patent/10_expert_material/080_expert_material_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-032-bayfield-patent/11_third_party/081_third_party_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-032-bayfield-patent/11_third_party/082_third_party_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-032-bayfield-patent/11_third_party/083_third_party_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-032-bayfield-patent/11_third_party/084_third_party_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-032-bayfield-patent/11_third_party/085_third_party_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-032-bayfield-patent/11_third_party/086_third_party_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-032-bayfield-patent/11_third_party/087_third_party_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-032-bayfield-patent/11_third_party/088_third_party_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-032-bayfield-patent/12_case_management/089_case_management_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-032-bayfield-patent/12_case_management/090_case_management_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-032-bayfield-patent/12_case_management/091_case_management_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-032-bayfield-patent/12_case_management/092_case_management_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-032-bayfield-patent/12_case_management/093_case_management_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-032-bayfield-patent/12_case_management/094_case_management_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-032-bayfield-patent/12_case_management/095_case_management_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-032-bayfield-patent/12_case_management/096_case_management_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-032-bayfield-patent/12_case_management/097_bayfield_patent_impact_population.xlsx"], "gold_output": {"advice_markdown": "# Decision note — Bayfield patent case production review\n\n## Recommendation\n\nApply scoped supplementation or redesignation only to records meeting the exact rule. The reconciled record supports 7 scoped actions and leaves 5 items on evidence hold.\n\nSelected option: `bayfield-patent:scoped-evidence`.\n\n## Why this is the supported option\n\nJoin source-code collections, email families, designation metadata, and protective-order categories by document ID. The protective order, production protocol, and privilege rules determine treatment at file level.\n\n## Supported actions\n\n### CBP-032-02 — privilege-log description defect (high)\n\nthe permission is limited to District of Delaware under CB-LD-2702-R272; the matched activity occurred in Delaware under CB-LD-2702-E163. Identity resolves to ENT-032-1001, revision REV-2026.2 is current, and Caleb Hassan is active with capacity 3.\n\nAction: Register document-specific corrections and hold records with incomplete lineage. Owner: Caleb Hassan; due 2026-09-07.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_pleadings/002_pleadings_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/02_orders/014_orders_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/026_custodian_files_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/05_email_families/038_email_families_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/12_case_management/097_bayfield_patent_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-032-04 — Bates-range overlap (critical)\n\ndelivery must use notices-bayfield_sensorics_inc@example.test under CB-LD-2702-R142; the only matched receipt used archive-kestrel_vision_systems_llc@example.test under CB-LD-2702-E578. Identity resolves to ENT-032-1003, revision REV-2026.4 is current, and Samuel Kim is active with capacity 5.\n\nAction: Register document-specific corrections and hold records with incomplete lineage. Owner: Samuel Kim; due 2026-09-05.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_pleadings/004_pleadings_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/02_orders/016_orders_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/028_custodian_files_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/05_email_families/040_email_families_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/08_production_logs/064_production_logs_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/11_third_party/088_third_party_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/12_case_management/097_bayfield_patent_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-032-05 — email-family separation (high)\n\nan open exception blocks completion under CB-LD-2702-R631; the current status is open and unresolved under CB-LD-2702-E290. Identity resolves to ENT-032-1004, revision REV-2026.5 is current, and Talia Brooks is active with capacity 5.\n\nAction: Register document-specific corrections and hold records with incomplete lineage. Owner: Talia Brooks; due 2026-09-04.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_pleadings/005_pleadings_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/017_requests_responses_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/029_custodian_files_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/041_chat_exports_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/09_depositions/065_depositions_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/10_expert_material/077_expert_material_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/12_case_management/097_bayfield_patent_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-032-07 — metadata field loss (low)\n\nthe controlling threshold is 7% under CB-LD-2702-R112; the independently calculated result is 13% under CB-LD-2702-E418. Identity resolves to ENT-032-1006, revision REV-2026.7 is current, and Farah Ibrahim is active with capacity 3.\n\nAction: Register document-specific corrections and hold records with incomplete lineage. Owner: Farah Ibrahim; due 2026-09-02.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_pleadings/007_pleadings_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/019_requests_responses_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/031_custodian_files_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/043_chat_exports_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/07_privilege_material/055_privilege_material_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/09_depositions/067_depositions_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/12_case_management/097_bayfield_patent_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-032-08 — collection-date inconsistency (critical)\n\napproval must come from Priya Raman under CB-LD-2702-R923; the effective approval record names Rafael Okafor under CB-LD-2702-E942. Identity resolves to ENT-032-1007, revision REV-2026.1 is current, and Dominic Alvarez is active with capacity 3.\n\nAction: Register document-specific corrections and hold records with incomplete lineage. Owner: Dominic Alvarez; due 2026-09-01.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_pleadings/008_pleadings_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/020_requests_responses_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/032_custodian_files_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/044_chat_exports_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/12_case_management/097_bayfield_patent_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-032-10 — production gap (medium)\n\nthe permission is limited to District of Delaware under CB-LD-2702-R912; the matched activity occurred in Delaware under CB-LD-2702-E359. Identity resolves to ENT-032-1009, revision REV-2026.3 is current, and Henry Cho is active with capacity 6.\n\nAction: Register document-specific corrections and hold records with incomplete lineage. Owner: Henry Cho; due 2026-09-08.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/02_orders/010_orders_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/022_requests_responses_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/05_email_families/034_email_families_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/046_chat_exports_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/12_case_management/097_bayfield_patent_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-032-12 — clawback deadline (critical)\n\ndelivery must use notices-bayfield_sensorics_inc@example.test under CB-LD-2702-R932; the only matched receipt used archive-kestrel_vision_systems_llc@example.test under CB-LD-2702-E837. Identity resolves to ENT-032-1011, revision REV-2026.5 is current, and Jonas Feld is active with capacity 1.\n\nAction: Register document-specific corrections and hold records with incomplete lineage. Owner: Jonas Feld; due 2026-09-06.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/02_orders/012_orders_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/024_requests_responses_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/05_email_families/036_email_families_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/048_chat_exports_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/12_case_management/097_bayfield_patent_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n## Evidence holds\n\n- **CBP-032-01 — meet-and-confer commitment**: the operational record relies on a superseded control revision. Next evidence: an operational record using the current effective revision. Sources: `/workspace/documents/01_pleadings/001_pleadings_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/02_orders/013_orders_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/025_custodian_files_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/05_email_families/037_email_families_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/12_case_management/097_bayfield_patent_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-032-03 — deposition exhibit omission**: the current observation does not meet the operative trigger. Next evidence: a current observation that satisfies the operative trigger. Sources: `/workspace/documents/01_pleadings/003_pleadings_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/02_orders/015_orders_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/027_custodian_files_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/05_email_families/039_email_families_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/11_third_party/087_third_party_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/12_case_management/097_bayfield_patent_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-032-06 — request-response mismatch**: two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key. Next evidence: an approved immutable entity crosswalk. Sources: `/workspace/documents/01_pleadings/006_pleadings_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/018_requests_responses_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/030_custodian_files_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/042_chat_exports_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/10_expert_material/078_expert_material_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/12_case_management/097_bayfield_patent_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-032-09 — protective-order designation error**: the operational record relies on a superseded control revision. Next evidence: an operational record using the current effective revision. Sources: `/workspace/documents/02_orders/009_orders_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/021_requests_responses_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/05_email_families/033_email_families_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/045_chat_exports_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/12_case_management/097_bayfield_patent_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-032-11 — legal-hold delivery gap**: the current observation does not meet the operative trigger. Next evidence: a current observation that satisfies the operative trigger. Sources: `/workspace/documents/02_orders/011_orders_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/023_requests_responses_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/05_email_families/035_email_families_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/047_chat_exports_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/12_case_management/095_case_management_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/12_case_management/097_bayfield_patent_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n## Alternatives considered\n\n- `bayfield-patent:shortcut` — Mark all source code confidential and ignore family-link defects.: Use a plausible summary or one source without completing the controlling joins.\n- `bayfield-patent:blanket-hold` — Freeze the entire matter population: Treat supported actions and genuinely ambiguous records as if they were equally unresolved.\n\n## Assumptions and limits\n\nThis decision is limited to cb100-032-bayfield-patent, the supplied synthetic records, and the matter state as of 2026-09-09. Similar names, stale revisions, and pending authority are not treated as proof.\n", "decision": {"actions": [{"determination": "the permission is limited to District of Delaware under CB-LD-2702-R272; the matched activity occurred in Delaware under CB-LD-2702-E163. Identity resolves to ENT-032-1001, revision REV-2026.2 is current, and Caleb Hassan is active with capacity 3.", "due_date": "2026-09-07", "id": "ACT-CBP-032-02", "identity_id": "ENT-032-1001", "issue": "privilege-log description defect", "owner": "Caleb Hassan", "portfolio_key": "CBP-032-02", "recommended_action": "Register document-specific corrections and hold records with incomplete lineage. Owner: Caleb Hassan; due 2026-09-07.", "severity": "high", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_pleadings/002_pleadings_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/02_orders/014_orders_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/026_custodian_files_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/05_email_families/038_email_families_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_case_management/097_bayfield_patent_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "delivery must use notices-bayfield_sensorics_inc@example.test under CB-LD-2702-R142; the only matched receipt used archive-kestrel_vision_systems_llc@example.test under CB-LD-2702-E578. Identity resolves to ENT-032-1003, revision REV-2026.4 is current, and Samuel Kim is active with capacity 5.", "due_date": "2026-09-05", "id": "ACT-CBP-032-04", "identity_id": "ENT-032-1003", "issue": "Bates-range overlap", "owner": "Samuel Kim", "portfolio_key": "CBP-032-04", "recommended_action": "Register document-specific corrections and hold records with incomplete lineage. Owner: Samuel Kim; due 2026-09-05.", "severity": "critical", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_pleadings/004_pleadings_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/02_orders/016_orders_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/028_custodian_files_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/05_email_families/040_email_families_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/08_production_logs/064_production_logs_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/11_third_party/088_third_party_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_case_management/097_bayfield_patent_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "an open exception blocks completion under CB-LD-2702-R631; the current status is open and unresolved under CB-LD-2702-E290. Identity resolves to ENT-032-1004, revision REV-2026.5 is current, and Talia Brooks is active with capacity 5.", "due_date": "2026-09-04", "id": "ACT-CBP-032-05", "identity_id": "ENT-032-1004", "issue": "email-family separation", "owner": "Talia Brooks", "portfolio_key": "CBP-032-05", "recommended_action": "Register document-specific corrections and hold records with incomplete lineage. Owner: Talia Brooks; due 2026-09-04.", "severity": "high", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_pleadings/005_pleadings_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/017_requests_responses_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/029_custodian_files_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/041_chat_exports_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/09_depositions/065_depositions_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/10_expert_material/077_expert_material_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_case_management/097_bayfield_patent_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "the controlling threshold is 7% under CB-LD-2702-R112; the independently calculated result is 13% under CB-LD-2702-E418. Identity resolves to ENT-032-1006, revision REV-2026.7 is current, and Farah Ibrahim is active with capacity 3.", "due_date": "2026-09-02", "id": "ACT-CBP-032-07", "identity_id": "ENT-032-1006", "issue": "metadata field loss", "owner": "Farah Ibrahim", "portfolio_key": "CBP-032-07", "recommended_action": "Register document-specific corrections and hold records with incomplete lineage. Owner: Farah Ibrahim; due 2026-09-02.", "severity": "low", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_pleadings/007_pleadings_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/019_requests_responses_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/031_custodian_files_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/043_chat_exports_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/07_privilege_material/055_privilege_material_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/09_depositions/067_depositions_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/12_case_management/097_bayfield_patent_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "approval must come from Priya Raman under CB-LD-2702-R923; the effective approval record names Rafael Okafor under CB-LD-2702-E942. Identity resolves to ENT-032-1007, revision REV-2026.1 is current, and Dominic Alvarez is active with capacity 3.", "due_date": "2026-09-01", "id": "ACT-CBP-032-08", "identity_id": "ENT-032-1007", "issue": "collection-date inconsistency", "owner": "Dominic Alvarez", "portfolio_key": "CBP-032-08", "recommended_action": "Register document-specific corrections and hold records with incomplete lineage. Owner: Dominic Alvarez; due 2026-09-01.", "severity": "critical", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_pleadings/008_pleadings_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/020_requests_responses_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/032_custodian_files_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/044_chat_exports_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/12_case_management/097_bayfield_patent_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "the permission is limited to District of Delaware under CB-LD-2702-R912; the matched activity occurred in Delaware under CB-LD-2702-E359. Identity resolves to ENT-032-1009, revision REV-2026.3 is current, and Henry Cho is active with capacity 6.", "due_date": "2026-09-08", "id": "ACT-CBP-032-10", "identity_id": "ENT-032-1009", "issue": "production gap", "owner": "Henry Cho", "portfolio_key": "CBP-032-10", "recommended_action": "Register document-specific corrections and hold records with incomplete lineage. Owner: Henry Cho; due 2026-09-08.", "severity": "medium", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_orders/010_orders_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/022_requests_responses_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/05_email_families/034_email_families_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/046_chat_exports_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_case_management/097_bayfield_patent_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "delivery must use notices-bayfield_sensorics_inc@example.test under CB-LD-2702-R932; the only matched receipt used archive-kestrel_vision_systems_llc@example.test under CB-LD-2702-E837. Identity resolves to ENT-032-1011, revision REV-2026.5 is current, and Jonas Feld is active with capacity 1.", "due_date": "2026-09-06", "id": "ACT-CBP-032-12", "identity_id": "ENT-032-1011", "issue": "clawback deadline", "owner": "Jonas Feld", "portfolio_key": "CBP-032-12", "recommended_action": "Register document-specific corrections and hold records with incomplete lineage. Owner: Jonas Feld; due 2026-09-06.", "severity": "critical", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_orders/012_orders_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/024_requests_responses_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/05_email_families/036_email_families_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/048_chat_exports_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_case_management/097_bayfield_patent_impact_population.xlsx"]}], "as_of": "2026-09-09", "decision": {"alternatives_considered": ["bayfield-patent:shortcut", "bayfield-patent:blanket-hold"], "question": "Which Bayfield files need supplementation, redesignation, or privilege correction?", "rationale": "The four-part causal test supports 7 scoped actions and leaves 5 records on evidence hold. The protective order, production protocol, and privilege rules determine treatment at file level.", "recommendation": "Apply scoped supplementation or redesignation only to records meeting the exact rule.", "selected_option_id": "bayfield-patent:scoped-evidence"}, "holds": [{"id": "HOLD-CBP-032-01", "issue": "meet-and-confer commitment", "portfolio_key": "CBP-032-01", "reason": "the operational record relies on a superseded control revision", "required_next_evidence": "an operational record using the current effective revision", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_pleadings/001_pleadings_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/02_orders/013_orders_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/025_custodian_files_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/05_email_families/037_email_families_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_case_management/097_bayfield_patent_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-032-03", "issue": "deposition exhibit omission", "portfolio_key": "CBP-032-03", "reason": "the current observation does not meet the operative trigger", "required_next_evidence": "a current observation that satisfies the operative trigger", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_pleadings/003_pleadings_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/02_orders/015_orders_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/027_custodian_files_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/05_email_families/039_email_families_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/11_third_party/087_third_party_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_case_management/097_bayfield_patent_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-032-06", "issue": "request-response mismatch", "portfolio_key": "CBP-032-06", "reason": "two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key", "required_next_evidence": "an approved immutable entity crosswalk", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_pleadings/006_pleadings_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/018_requests_responses_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/030_custodian_files_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/042_chat_exports_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/10_expert_material/078_expert_material_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_case_management/097_bayfield_patent_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-032-09", "issue": "protective-order designation error", "portfolio_key": "CBP-032-09", "reason": "the operational record relies on a superseded control revision", "required_next_evidence": "an operational record using the current effective revision", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_orders/009_orders_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/021_requests_responses_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/05_email_families/033_email_families_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/045_chat_exports_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_case_management/097_bayfield_patent_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-032-11", "issue": "legal-hold delivery gap", "portfolio_key": "CBP-032-11", "reason": "the current observation does not meet the operative trigger", "required_next_evidence": "a current observation that satisfies the operative trigger", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_orders/011_orders_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/023_requests_responses_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/05_email_families/035_email_families_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/047_chat_exports_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_case_management/095_case_management_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_case_management/097_bayfield_patent_impact_population.xlsx"]}], "matter_number": "CB-LD-2702", "prepared_for": "Bayfield Sensorics, Inc.", "schema_version": "counselbench.decision.v3", "task_id": "cb100-032-bayfield-patent"}, "matter_register": {"matter_number": "CB-LD-2702", "rows": [{"decision_option_id": "bayfield-patent:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "the operational record relies on a superseded control revision", "issue": "meet-and-confer commitment", "matter_number": "CB-LD-2702", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-032-01", "row_id": "REG-CBP-032-01", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_pleadings/001_pleadings_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/02_orders/013_orders_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/025_custodian_files_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/05_email_families/037_email_families_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_case_management/097_bayfield_patent_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "bayfield-patent:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-07", "issue": "privilege-log description defect", "matter_number": "CB-LD-2702", "owner": "Caleb Hassan", "portfolio_key": "CBP-032-02", "row_id": "REG-CBP-032-02", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_pleadings/002_pleadings_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/02_orders/014_orders_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/026_custodian_files_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/05_email_families/038_email_families_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_case_management/097_bayfield_patent_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "bayfield-patent:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "the current observation does not meet the operative trigger", "issue": "deposition exhibit omission", "matter_number": "CB-LD-2702", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-032-03", "row_id": "REG-CBP-032-03", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_pleadings/003_pleadings_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/02_orders/015_orders_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/027_custodian_files_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/05_email_families/039_email_families_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/11_third_party/087_third_party_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_case_management/097_bayfield_patent_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "bayfield-patent:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-05", "issue": "Bates-range overlap", "matter_number": "CB-LD-2702", "owner": "Samuel Kim", "portfolio_key": "CBP-032-04", "row_id": "REG-CBP-032-04", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_pleadings/004_pleadings_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/02_orders/016_orders_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/028_custodian_files_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/05_email_families/040_email_families_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/08_production_logs/064_production_logs_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/11_third_party/088_third_party_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_case_management/097_bayfield_patent_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "bayfield-patent:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-04", "issue": "email-family separation", "matter_number": "CB-LD-2702", "owner": "Talia Brooks", "portfolio_key": "CBP-032-05", "row_id": "REG-CBP-032-05", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_pleadings/005_pleadings_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/017_requests_responses_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/029_custodian_files_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/041_chat_exports_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/09_depositions/065_depositions_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/10_expert_material/077_expert_material_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_case_management/097_bayfield_patent_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "bayfield-patent:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key", "issue": "request-response mismatch", "matter_number": "CB-LD-2702", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-032-06", "row_id": "REG-CBP-032-06", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_pleadings/006_pleadings_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/018_requests_responses_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/030_custodian_files_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/042_chat_exports_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/10_expert_material/078_expert_material_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_case_management/097_bayfield_patent_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "bayfield-patent:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-02", "issue": "metadata field loss", "matter_number": "CB-LD-2702", "owner": "Farah Ibrahim", "portfolio_key": "CBP-032-07", "row_id": "REG-CBP-032-07", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_pleadings/007_pleadings_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/019_requests_responses_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/031_custodian_files_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/043_chat_exports_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/07_privilege_material/055_privilege_material_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/09_depositions/067_depositions_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/12_case_management/097_bayfield_patent_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "bayfield-patent:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-01", "issue": "collection-date inconsistency", "matter_number": "CB-LD-2702", "owner": "Dominic Alvarez", "portfolio_key": "CBP-032-08", "row_id": "REG-CBP-032-08", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_pleadings/008_pleadings_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/020_requests_responses_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/032_custodian_files_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/044_chat_exports_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/12_case_management/097_bayfield_patent_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "bayfield-patent:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "the operational record relies on a superseded control revision", "issue": "protective-order designation error", "matter_number": "CB-LD-2702", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-032-09", "row_id": "REG-CBP-032-09", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_orders/009_orders_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/021_requests_responses_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/05_email_families/033_email_families_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/045_chat_exports_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_case_management/097_bayfield_patent_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "bayfield-patent:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-08", "issue": "production gap", "matter_number": "CB-LD-2702", "owner": "Henry Cho", "portfolio_key": "CBP-032-10", "row_id": "REG-CBP-032-10", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_orders/010_orders_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/022_requests_responses_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/05_email_families/034_email_families_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/046_chat_exports_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_case_management/097_bayfield_patent_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "bayfield-patent:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "the current observation does not meet the operative trigger", "issue": "legal-hold delivery gap", "matter_number": "CB-LD-2702", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-032-11", "row_id": "REG-CBP-032-11", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_orders/011_orders_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/023_requests_responses_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/05_email_families/035_email_families_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/047_chat_exports_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_case_management/095_case_management_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_case_management/097_bayfield_patent_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "bayfield-patent:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-06", "issue": "clawback deadline", "matter_number": "CB-LD-2702", "owner": "Jonas Feld", "portfolio_key": "CBP-032-12", "row_id": "REG-CBP-032-12", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_orders/012_orders_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/024_requests_responses_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/05_email_families/036_email_families_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/048_chat_exports_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_case_management/097_bayfield_patent_impact_population.xlsx"]}], "schema_version": "counselbench.matter-register.v3", "task_id": "cb100-032-bayfield-patent"}}, "metadata": {"benchmark": "CounselBench-100", "code_license": "Apache-2.0", "data_license": "CC-BY-4.0", "deadline": "2026-09-09", "document_count": 97, "evidence_holds": 5, "jurisdiction": "Delaware", "matter_number": "CB-LD-2702", "mcp_commit": "9a96ea6e5913736f92b88345bf51caeaaa8e719f", "mcp_package": "@modelcontextprotocol/server-filesystem@2026.7.10", "practice_area": "litigation-discovery", "reference_tool_calls": 81, "required_evidence_reads": 59, "supported_actions": 7, "synthetic": true, "venue": "District of Delaware", "version": "3.1.0"}, "prompt": "The business team is asking whether it can move, and I do not want to answer from the summary deck. Which Bayfield files need supplementation, redesignation, or privilege correction? Source-code collections and inventor communications were produced under a protective order, but family links and designation fields are inconsistent. The team needs the call by 2026-09-09. Document the scoped result for the team and separate genuine exceptions from unresolved identity or revision questions.", "rubric": {"criteria": [{"category": "investigation", "description": "Inventory the production and use targeted searches to locate records across native formats.", "id": "investigation.discover_production"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Complete every task-specific identity, authority, operations, and approval read before the first state transition.", "id": "investigation.read_before_write"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Inspect designated source metadata before relying on those records.", "id": "investigation.custody_before_write"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "Select the supported option 'bayfield-patent:scoped-evidence' after applying the four-part test.", "id": "decision.selected_option"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "Identify both rejected approaches and explain why a one-source shortcut and a blanket hold are wrong.", "id": "decision.alternatives"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-032-01 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_pleadings/001_pleadings_source_export.md rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-032-01.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_orders/013_orders_source_export.json for meet-and-confer commitment.", "id": "investigation.CBP-032-01.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/025_custodian_files_source_export.md to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-032-01.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_email_families/037_email_families_source_export.json.", "id": "investigation.CBP-032-01.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-032-01 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is the operational record relies on a superseded control revision.", "id": "decision.CBP-032-01.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-032-01 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-032-01.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-032-02 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_pleadings/002_pleadings_source_export.txt rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-032-02.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_orders/014_orders_source_export.xml for privilege-log description defect.", "id": "investigation.CBP-032-02.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/026_custodian_files_source_export.txt to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-032-02.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_email_families/038_email_families_source_export.xml.", "id": "investigation.CBP-032-02.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-032-02 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-032-02.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-032-02 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-032-02.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-032-03 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_pleadings/003_pleadings_source_export.eml rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-032-03.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_orders/015_orders_source_export.html for deposition exhibit omission.", "id": "investigation.CBP-032-03.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/027_custodian_files_source_export.eml to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-032-03.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_email_families/039_email_families_source_export.html.", "id": "investigation.CBP-032-03.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-032-03 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is the current observation does not meet the operative trigger.", "id": "decision.CBP-032-03.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-032-03 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-032-03.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-032-04 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_pleadings/004_pleadings_source_export.csv rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-032-04.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_orders/016_orders_source_export.pdf for Bates-range overlap.", "id": "investigation.CBP-032-04.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/028_custodian_files_source_export.csv to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-032-04.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_email_families/040_email_families_source_export.pdf.", "id": "investigation.CBP-032-04.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-032-04 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-032-04.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-032-04 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-032-04.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-032-05 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_pleadings/005_pleadings_source_export.json rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-032-05.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/017_requests_responses_source_export.md for email-family separation.", "id": "investigation.CBP-032-05.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/029_custodian_files_source_export.json to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-032-05.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/041_chat_exports_source_export.md.", "id": "investigation.CBP-032-05.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-032-05 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-032-05.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-032-05 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-032-05.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-032-06 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_pleadings/006_pleadings_source_export.xml rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-032-06.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/018_requests_responses_source_export.txt for request-response mismatch.", "id": "investigation.CBP-032-06.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/030_custodian_files_source_export.xml to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-032-06.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/042_chat_exports_source_export.txt.", "id": "investigation.CBP-032-06.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-032-06 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key.", "id": "decision.CBP-032-06.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-032-06 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-032-06.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-032-07 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_pleadings/007_pleadings_source_export.html rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-032-07.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/019_requests_responses_source_export.eml for metadata field loss.", "id": "investigation.CBP-032-07.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/031_custodian_files_source_export.html to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-032-07.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/043_chat_exports_source_export.eml.", "id": "investigation.CBP-032-07.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-032-07 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-032-07.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-032-07 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-032-07.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-032-08 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_pleadings/008_pleadings_source_export.pdf rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-032-08.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/020_requests_responses_source_export.csv for collection-date inconsistency.", "id": "investigation.CBP-032-08.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/032_custodian_files_source_export.pdf to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-032-08.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/044_chat_exports_source_export.csv.", "id": "investigation.CBP-032-08.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-032-08 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-032-08.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-032-08 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-032-08.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-032-09 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_orders/009_orders_source_export.md rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-032-09.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/021_requests_responses_source_export.json for protective-order designation error.", "id": "investigation.CBP-032-09.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_email_families/033_email_families_source_export.md to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-032-09.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/045_chat_exports_source_export.json.", "id": "investigation.CBP-032-09.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-032-09 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is the operational record relies on a superseded control revision.", "id": "decision.CBP-032-09.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-032-09 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-032-09.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-032-10 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_orders/010_orders_source_export.txt rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-032-10.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/022_requests_responses_source_export.xml for production gap.", "id": "investigation.CBP-032-10.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_email_families/034_email_families_source_export.txt to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-032-10.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/046_chat_exports_source_export.xml.", "id": "investigation.CBP-032-10.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-032-10 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-032-10.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-032-10 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-032-10.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-032-11 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_orders/011_orders_source_export.eml rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-032-11.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/023_requests_responses_source_export.html for legal-hold delivery gap.", "id": "investigation.CBP-032-11.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_email_families/035_email_families_source_export.eml to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-032-11.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/047_chat_exports_source_export.html.", "id": "investigation.CBP-032-11.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-032-11 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is the current observation does not meet the operative trigger.", "id": "decision.CBP-032-11.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-032-11 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-032-11.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-032-12 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_orders/012_orders_source_export.csv rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-032-12.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/024_requests_responses_source_export.pdf for clawback deadline.", "id": "investigation.CBP-032-12.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_email_families/036_email_families_source_export.csv to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-032-12.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/048_chat_exports_source_export.pdf.", "id": "investigation.CBP-032-12.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-032-12 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-032-12.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-032-12 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-032-12.register"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Write the exact selected option, supported action population, evidence-hold population, facts, owners, deadlines, and citations.", "id": "state.exact_decision"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create one exact register row per portfolio key with no extra, missing, or modified row.", "id": "state.exact_register"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Leave only the three approved deliverables and perform no extra state-changing write.", "id": "state.write_scope_containment"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Read back decision.json, matter-register.json, and advice.md after their final writes.", "id": "state.postwrite_readback"}, {"category": "answer", "description": "Explain the selected recommendation, supported actions, holds, alternatives, and limitations with exact source anchors.", "id": "answer.decision_note"}], "decision_options": [{"approach": "Use a plausible summary or one source without completing the controlling joins.", "id": "bayfield-patent:shortcut", "label": "Mark all source code confidential and ignore family-link defects."}, {"approach": "Treat supported actions and genuinely ambiguous records as if they were equally unresolved.", "id": "bayfield-patent:blanket-hold", "label": "Freeze the entire matter population"}, {"approach": "Apply the exact identity, current-state, authority, and revision test. Register document-specific corrections and hold records with incomplete lineage.", "id": "bayfield-patent:scoped-evidence", "label": "Apply scoped supplementation or redesignation only to records meeting the exact rule."}], "evaluation_narrative": {"authority": "The protective order, production protocol, and privilege rules determine treatment at file level.", "observation": "Join source-code collections, email families, designation metadata, and protective-order categories by document ID.", "question": "Which Bayfield files need supplementation, redesignation, or privilege correction?", "register_action": "Register document-specific corrections and hold records with incomplete lineage."}, "gates": ["all_required_evidence_precedes_first_write", "decision_criteria_complete", "register_state_exact", "write_scope_contained", "all_outputs_verified_by_readback"], "metadata_checks": 7, "metric": "weighted_criteria_score", "minimum_tool_calls": 81, "required_deliverables": ["decision.json", "matter-register.json", "advice.md"], "required_document_reads": 59, "type": "deterministic", "weights": {"advice": 0.15, "decision": 0.35, "investigation": 0.25, "state": 0.25}}, "task_id": "cb100-032-bayfield-patent", "task_name": "Bayfield patent case production review", "world_id": "counselbench-filesystem-mcp-v3"}
+{"context_files": ["task_files/cb100-033-crown-employment/01_pleadings/001_pleadings_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-033-crown-employment/01_pleadings/002_pleadings_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-033-crown-employment/01_pleadings/003_pleadings_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-033-crown-employment/01_pleadings/004_pleadings_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-033-crown-employment/01_pleadings/005_pleadings_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-033-crown-employment/01_pleadings/006_pleadings_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-033-crown-employment/01_pleadings/007_pleadings_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-033-crown-employment/01_pleadings/008_pleadings_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-033-crown-employment/02_orders/009_orders_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-033-crown-employment/02_orders/010_orders_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-033-crown-employment/02_orders/011_orders_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-033-crown-employment/02_orders/012_orders_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-033-crown-employment/02_orders/013_orders_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-033-crown-employment/02_orders/014_orders_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-033-crown-employment/02_orders/015_orders_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-033-crown-employment/02_orders/016_orders_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-033-crown-employment/03_requests_responses/017_requests_responses_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-033-crown-employment/03_requests_responses/018_requests_responses_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-033-crown-employment/03_requests_responses/019_requests_responses_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-033-crown-employment/03_requests_responses/020_requests_responses_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-033-crown-employment/03_requests_responses/021_requests_responses_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-033-crown-employment/03_requests_responses/022_requests_responses_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-033-crown-employment/03_requests_responses/023_requests_responses_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-033-crown-employment/03_requests_responses/024_requests_responses_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-033-crown-employment/04_custodian_files/025_custodian_files_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-033-crown-employment/04_custodian_files/026_custodian_files_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-033-crown-employment/04_custodian_files/027_custodian_files_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-033-crown-employment/04_custodian_files/028_custodian_files_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-033-crown-employment/04_custodian_files/029_custodian_files_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-033-crown-employment/04_custodian_files/030_custodian_files_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-033-crown-employment/04_custodian_files/031_custodian_files_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-033-crown-employment/04_custodian_files/032_custodian_files_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-033-crown-employment/05_email_families/033_email_families_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-033-crown-employment/05_email_families/034_email_families_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-033-crown-employment/05_email_families/035_email_families_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-033-crown-employment/05_email_families/036_email_families_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-033-crown-employment/05_email_families/037_email_families_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-033-crown-employment/05_email_families/038_email_families_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-033-crown-employment/05_email_families/039_email_families_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-033-crown-employment/05_email_families/040_email_families_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-033-crown-employment/06_chat_exports/041_chat_exports_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-033-crown-employment/06_chat_exports/042_chat_exports_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-033-crown-employment/06_chat_exports/043_chat_exports_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-033-crown-employment/06_chat_exports/044_chat_exports_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-033-crown-employment/06_chat_exports/045_chat_exports_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-033-crown-employment/06_chat_exports/046_chat_exports_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-033-crown-employment/06_chat_exports/047_chat_exports_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-033-crown-employment/06_chat_exports/048_chat_exports_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-033-crown-employment/07_privilege_material/049_privilege_material_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-033-crown-employment/07_privilege_material/050_privilege_material_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-033-crown-employment/07_privilege_material/051_privilege_material_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-033-crown-employment/07_privilege_material/052_privilege_material_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-033-crown-employment/07_privilege_material/053_privilege_material_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-033-crown-employment/07_privilege_material/054_privilege_material_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-033-crown-employment/07_privilege_material/055_privilege_material_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-033-crown-employment/07_privilege_material/056_privilege_material_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-033-crown-employment/08_production_logs/057_production_logs_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-033-crown-employment/08_production_logs/058_production_logs_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-033-crown-employment/08_production_logs/059_production_logs_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-033-crown-employment/08_production_logs/060_production_logs_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-033-crown-employment/08_production_logs/061_production_logs_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-033-crown-employment/08_production_logs/062_production_logs_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-033-crown-employment/08_production_logs/063_production_logs_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-033-crown-employment/08_production_logs/064_production_logs_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-033-crown-employment/09_depositions/065_depositions_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-033-crown-employment/09_depositions/066_depositions_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-033-crown-employment/09_depositions/067_depositions_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-033-crown-employment/09_depositions/068_depositions_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-033-crown-employment/09_depositions/069_depositions_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-033-crown-employment/09_depositions/070_depositions_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-033-crown-employment/09_depositions/071_depositions_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-033-crown-employment/09_depositions/072_depositions_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-033-crown-employment/10_expert_material/073_expert_material_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-033-crown-employment/10_expert_material/074_expert_material_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-033-crown-employment/10_expert_material/075_expert_material_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-033-crown-employment/10_expert_material/076_expert_material_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-033-crown-employment/10_expert_material/077_expert_material_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-033-crown-employment/10_expert_material/078_expert_material_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-033-crown-employment/10_expert_material/079_expert_material_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-033-crown-employment/10_expert_material/080_expert_material_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-033-crown-employment/11_third_party/081_third_party_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-033-crown-employment/11_third_party/082_third_party_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-033-crown-employment/11_third_party/083_third_party_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-033-crown-employment/11_third_party/084_third_party_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-033-crown-employment/11_third_party/085_third_party_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-033-crown-employment/11_third_party/086_third_party_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-033-crown-employment/11_third_party/087_third_party_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-033-crown-employment/11_third_party/088_third_party_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-033-crown-employment/12_case_management/089_case_management_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-033-crown-employment/12_case_management/090_case_management_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-033-crown-employment/12_case_management/091_case_management_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-033-crown-employment/12_case_management/092_case_management_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-033-crown-employment/12_case_management/093_case_management_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-033-crown-employment/12_case_management/094_case_management_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-033-crown-employment/12_case_management/095_case_management_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-033-crown-employment/12_case_management/096_case_management_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-033-crown-employment/12_case_management/097_crown_employment_impact_population.xlsx"], "gold_output": {"advice_markdown": "# Decision note — Crown wage action discovery check\n\n## Recommendation\n\nCure supported hold and production gaps before giving a bounded certification. The reconciled record supports 8 scoped actions and leaves 4 items on evidence hold.\n\nSelected option: `crown-employment:scoped-evidence`.\n\n## Why this is the supported option\n\nMatch custodians, texts, schedule exports, hold delivery, and promised supplements to request populations. Court orders and recorded meet-and-confer commitments define the certification scope.\n\n## Supported actions\n\n### CBP-033-02 — common-interest support gap (low)\n\nthe controlling threshold is 13% under CB-LD-2703-R766; the independently calculated result is 18% under CB-LD-2703-E245. Identity resolves to ENT-033-1001, revision REV-2025.2 is current, and Sofia Bennett is active with capacity 6.\n\nAction: Create custodian and request-level cure rows with explicit certification holds. Owner: Sofia Bennett; due 2026-09-10.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_pleadings/002_pleadings_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/02_orders/014_orders_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/026_custodian_files_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/05_email_families/038_email_families_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/08_production_logs/062_production_logs_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/12_case_management/097_crown_employment_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-033-03 — expert draft segregation (medium)\n\napproval must come from Willa Novak under CB-LD-2703-R997; the effective approval record names Rafael Okafor under CB-LD-2703-E258. Identity resolves to ENT-033-1002, revision REV-2025.3 is current, and Micah Sullivan is active with capacity 4.\n\nAction: Create custodian and request-level cure rows with explicit certification holds. Owner: Micah Sullivan; due 2026-09-09.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_pleadings/003_pleadings_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/02_orders/015_orders_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/027_custodian_files_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/05_email_families/039_email_families_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/12_case_management/097_crown_employment_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-033-04 — meet-and-confer commitment (high)\n\nthe controlled population contains 180 records under CB-LD-2703-R808; the certification covers 143 records under CB-LD-2703-E406. Identity resolves to ENT-033-1003, revision REV-2025.4 is current, and Nora Chen is active with capacity 5.\n\nAction: Create custodian and request-level cure rows with explicit certification holds. Owner: Nora Chen; due 2026-09-08.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_pleadings/004_pleadings_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/02_orders/016_orders_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/028_custodian_files_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/05_email_families/040_email_families_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/10_expert_material/076_expert_material_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/08_production_logs/064_production_logs_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/12_case_management/097_crown_employment_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-033-05 — privilege-log description defect (medium)\n\nthe permission is limited to Central District of California under CB-LD-2703-R604; the matched activity occurred in California under CB-LD-2703-E394. Identity resolves to ENT-033-1004, revision REV-2025.5 is current, and Caleb Hassan is active with capacity 5.\n\nAction: Create custodian and request-level cure rows with explicit certification holds. Owner: Caleb Hassan; due 2026-09-07.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_pleadings/005_pleadings_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/017_requests_responses_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/029_custodian_files_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/041_chat_exports_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/07_privilege_material/053_privilege_material_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/12_case_management/097_crown_employment_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-033-07 — Bates-range overlap (critical)\n\ndelivery must use notices-crown_kitchen_group@example.test under CB-LD-2703-R218; the only matched receipt used archive-martinez_et_al@example.test under CB-LD-2703-E318. Identity resolves to ENT-033-1006, revision REV-2025.7 is current, and Samuel Kim is active with capacity 2.\n\nAction: Create custodian and request-level cure rows with explicit certification holds. Owner: Samuel Kim; due 2026-09-05.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_pleadings/007_pleadings_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/019_requests_responses_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/031_custodian_files_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/043_chat_exports_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/07_privilege_material/055_privilege_material_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/10_expert_material/079_expert_material_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/12_case_management/097_crown_employment_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-033-09 — request-response mismatch (critical)\n\ncompletion is required by 2025-04-24 under CB-LD-2703-R448; the current event record shows completion on 2025-06-07 under CB-LD-2703-E808. Identity resolves to ENT-033-1008, revision REV-2025.2 is current, and Adrian Mensah is active with capacity 4.\n\nAction: Create custodian and request-level cure rows with explicit certification holds. Owner: Adrian Mensah; due 2026-09-03.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/02_orders/009_orders_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/021_requests_responses_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/05_email_families/033_email_families_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/045_chat_exports_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/11_third_party/081_third_party_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/12_case_management/093_case_management_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/12_case_management/097_crown_employment_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-033-10 — metadata field loss (medium)\n\nthe controlling threshold is 3% under CB-LD-2703-R506; the independently calculated result is 5% under CB-LD-2703-E918. Identity resolves to ENT-033-1009, revision REV-2025.3 is current, and Farah Ibrahim is active with capacity 5.\n\nAction: Create custodian and request-level cure rows with explicit certification holds. Owner: Farah Ibrahim; due 2026-09-11.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/02_orders/010_orders_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/022_requests_responses_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/05_email_families/034_email_families_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/046_chat_exports_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/12_case_management/094_case_management_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/12_case_management/097_crown_employment_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-033-12 — protective-order designation error (medium)\n\nthe controlled population contains 134 records under CB-LD-2703-R902; the certification covers 117 records under CB-LD-2703-E623. Identity resolves to ENT-033-1011, revision REV-2025.5 is current, and Leona Park is active with capacity 5.\n\nAction: Create custodian and request-level cure rows with explicit certification holds. Owner: Leona Park; due 2026-09-09.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/02_orders/012_orders_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/024_requests_responses_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/05_email_families/036_email_families_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/048_chat_exports_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/09_depositions/072_depositions_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/08_production_logs/060_production_logs_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/12_case_management/097_crown_employment_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n## Evidence holds\n\n- **CBP-033-01 — custodian omission**: two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key. Next evidence: an approved immutable entity crosswalk. Sources: `/workspace/documents/01_pleadings/001_pleadings_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/02_orders/013_orders_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/025_custodian_files_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/05_email_families/037_email_families_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/12_case_management/097_crown_employment_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-033-06 — deposition exhibit omission**: the current observation does not meet the operative trigger. Next evidence: a current observation that satisfies the operative trigger. Sources: `/workspace/documents/01_pleadings/006_pleadings_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/018_requests_responses_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/030_custodian_files_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/042_chat_exports_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/12_case_management/097_crown_employment_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-033-08 — email-family separation**: the operational record relies on a superseded control revision. Next evidence: an operational record using the current effective revision. Sources: `/workspace/documents/01_pleadings/008_pleadings_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/020_requests_responses_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/032_custodian_files_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/044_chat_exports_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/10_expert_material/080_expert_material_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/07_privilege_material/056_privilege_material_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/12_case_management/097_crown_employment_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-033-11 — collection-date inconsistency**: the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective. Next evidence: effective approval and an active owner with remaining capacity. Sources: `/workspace/documents/02_orders/011_orders_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/023_requests_responses_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/05_email_families/035_email_families_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/047_chat_exports_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/12_case_management/097_crown_employment_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n## Alternatives considered\n\n- `crown-employment:blanket-hold` — Freeze the entire matter population: Treat supported actions and genuinely ambiguous records as if they were equally unresolved.\n- `crown-employment:shortcut` — Certify because all currently collected files were produced.: Use a plausible summary or one source without completing the controlling joins.\n\n## Assumptions and limits\n\nThis decision is limited to cb100-033-crown-employment, the supplied synthetic records, and the matter state as of 2026-09-12. Similar names, stale revisions, and pending authority are not treated as proof.\n", "decision": {"actions": [{"determination": "the controlling threshold is 13% under CB-LD-2703-R766; the independently calculated result is 18% under CB-LD-2703-E245. Identity resolves to ENT-033-1001, revision REV-2025.2 is current, and Sofia Bennett is active with capacity 6.", "due_date": "2026-09-10", "id": "ACT-CBP-033-02", "identity_id": "ENT-033-1001", "issue": "common-interest support gap", "owner": "Sofia Bennett", "portfolio_key": "CBP-033-02", "recommended_action": "Create custodian and request-level cure rows with explicit certification holds. Owner: Sofia Bennett; due 2026-09-10.", "severity": "low", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_pleadings/002_pleadings_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/02_orders/014_orders_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/026_custodian_files_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/05_email_families/038_email_families_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/08_production_logs/062_production_logs_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_case_management/097_crown_employment_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "approval must come from Willa Novak under CB-LD-2703-R997; the effective approval record names Rafael Okafor under CB-LD-2703-E258. Identity resolves to ENT-033-1002, revision REV-2025.3 is current, and Micah Sullivan is active with capacity 4.", "due_date": "2026-09-09", "id": "ACT-CBP-033-03", "identity_id": "ENT-033-1002", "issue": "expert draft segregation", "owner": "Micah Sullivan", "portfolio_key": "CBP-033-03", "recommended_action": "Create custodian and request-level cure rows with explicit certification holds. Owner: Micah Sullivan; due 2026-09-09.", "severity": "medium", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_pleadings/003_pleadings_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/02_orders/015_orders_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/027_custodian_files_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/05_email_families/039_email_families_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_case_management/097_crown_employment_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "the controlled population contains 180 records under CB-LD-2703-R808; the certification covers 143 records under CB-LD-2703-E406. Identity resolves to ENT-033-1003, revision REV-2025.4 is current, and Nora Chen is active with capacity 5.", "due_date": "2026-09-08", "id": "ACT-CBP-033-04", "identity_id": "ENT-033-1003", "issue": "meet-and-confer commitment", "owner": "Nora Chen", "portfolio_key": "CBP-033-04", "recommended_action": "Create custodian and request-level cure rows with explicit certification holds. Owner: Nora Chen; due 2026-09-08.", "severity": "high", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_pleadings/004_pleadings_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/02_orders/016_orders_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/028_custodian_files_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/05_email_families/040_email_families_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/10_expert_material/076_expert_material_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/08_production_logs/064_production_logs_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_case_management/097_crown_employment_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "the permission is limited to Central District of California under CB-LD-2703-R604; the matched activity occurred in California under CB-LD-2703-E394. Identity resolves to ENT-033-1004, revision REV-2025.5 is current, and Caleb Hassan is active with capacity 5.", "due_date": "2026-09-07", "id": "ACT-CBP-033-05", "identity_id": "ENT-033-1004", "issue": "privilege-log description defect", "owner": "Caleb Hassan", "portfolio_key": "CBP-033-05", "recommended_action": "Create custodian and request-level cure rows with explicit certification holds. Owner: Caleb Hassan; due 2026-09-07.", "severity": "medium", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_pleadings/005_pleadings_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/017_requests_responses_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/029_custodian_files_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/041_chat_exports_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/07_privilege_material/053_privilege_material_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_case_management/097_crown_employment_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "delivery must use notices-crown_kitchen_group@example.test under CB-LD-2703-R218; the only matched receipt used archive-martinez_et_al@example.test under CB-LD-2703-E318. Identity resolves to ENT-033-1006, revision REV-2025.7 is current, and Samuel Kim is active with capacity 2.", "due_date": "2026-09-05", "id": "ACT-CBP-033-07", "identity_id": "ENT-033-1006", "issue": "Bates-range overlap", "owner": "Samuel Kim", "portfolio_key": "CBP-033-07", "recommended_action": "Create custodian and request-level cure rows with explicit certification holds. Owner: Samuel Kim; due 2026-09-05.", "severity": "critical", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_pleadings/007_pleadings_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/019_requests_responses_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/031_custodian_files_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/043_chat_exports_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/07_privilege_material/055_privilege_material_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/10_expert_material/079_expert_material_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_case_management/097_crown_employment_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "completion is required by 2025-04-24 under CB-LD-2703-R448; the current event record shows completion on 2025-06-07 under CB-LD-2703-E808. Identity resolves to ENT-033-1008, revision REV-2025.2 is current, and Adrian Mensah is active with capacity 4.", "due_date": "2026-09-03", "id": "ACT-CBP-033-09", "identity_id": "ENT-033-1008", "issue": "request-response mismatch", "owner": "Adrian Mensah", "portfolio_key": "CBP-033-09", "recommended_action": "Create custodian and request-level cure rows with explicit certification holds. Owner: Adrian Mensah; due 2026-09-03.", "severity": "critical", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_orders/009_orders_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/021_requests_responses_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/05_email_families/033_email_families_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/045_chat_exports_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/11_third_party/081_third_party_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/12_case_management/093_case_management_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_case_management/097_crown_employment_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "the controlling threshold is 3% under CB-LD-2703-R506; the independently calculated result is 5% under CB-LD-2703-E918. Identity resolves to ENT-033-1009, revision REV-2025.3 is current, and Farah Ibrahim is active with capacity 5.", "due_date": "2026-09-11", "id": "ACT-CBP-033-10", "identity_id": "ENT-033-1009", "issue": "metadata field loss", "owner": "Farah Ibrahim", "portfolio_key": "CBP-033-10", "recommended_action": "Create custodian and request-level cure rows with explicit certification holds. Owner: Farah Ibrahim; due 2026-09-11.", "severity": "medium", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_orders/010_orders_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/022_requests_responses_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/05_email_families/034_email_families_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/046_chat_exports_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_case_management/094_case_management_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_case_management/097_crown_employment_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "the controlled population contains 134 records under CB-LD-2703-R902; the certification covers 117 records under CB-LD-2703-E623. Identity resolves to ENT-033-1011, revision REV-2025.5 is current, and Leona Park is active with capacity 5.", "due_date": "2026-09-09", "id": "ACT-CBP-033-12", "identity_id": "ENT-033-1011", "issue": "protective-order designation error", "owner": "Leona Park", "portfolio_key": "CBP-033-12", "recommended_action": "Create custodian and request-level cure rows with explicit certification holds. Owner: Leona Park; due 2026-09-09.", "severity": "medium", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_orders/012_orders_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/024_requests_responses_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/05_email_families/036_email_families_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/048_chat_exports_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/09_depositions/072_depositions_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/08_production_logs/060_production_logs_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/12_case_management/097_crown_employment_impact_population.xlsx"]}], "as_of": "2026-09-12", "decision": {"alternatives_considered": ["crown-employment:blanket-hold", "crown-employment:shortcut"], "question": "Is Crown ready to certify its wage-case production after the late holds and meet-and-confer promises?", "rationale": "The four-part causal test supports 8 scoped actions and leaves 4 records on evidence hold. Court orders and recorded meet-and-confer commitments define the certification scope.", "recommendation": "Cure supported hold and production gaps before giving a bounded certification.", "selected_option_id": "crown-employment:scoped-evidence"}, "holds": [{"id": "HOLD-CBP-033-01", "issue": "custodian omission", "portfolio_key": "CBP-033-01", "reason": "two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key", "required_next_evidence": "an approved immutable entity crosswalk", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_pleadings/001_pleadings_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/02_orders/013_orders_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/025_custodian_files_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/05_email_families/037_email_families_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_case_management/097_crown_employment_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-033-06", "issue": "deposition exhibit omission", "portfolio_key": "CBP-033-06", "reason": "the current observation does not meet the operative trigger", "required_next_evidence": "a current observation that satisfies the operative trigger", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_pleadings/006_pleadings_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/018_requests_responses_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/030_custodian_files_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/042_chat_exports_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/12_case_management/097_crown_employment_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-033-08", "issue": "email-family separation", "portfolio_key": "CBP-033-08", "reason": "the operational record relies on a superseded control revision", "required_next_evidence": "an operational record using the current effective revision", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_pleadings/008_pleadings_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/020_requests_responses_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/032_custodian_files_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/044_chat_exports_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/10_expert_material/080_expert_material_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/07_privilege_material/056_privilege_material_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_case_management/097_crown_employment_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-033-11", "issue": "collection-date inconsistency", "portfolio_key": "CBP-033-11", "reason": "the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective", "required_next_evidence": "effective approval and an active owner with remaining capacity", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_orders/011_orders_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/023_requests_responses_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/05_email_families/035_email_families_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/047_chat_exports_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_case_management/097_crown_employment_impact_population.xlsx"]}], "matter_number": "CB-LD-2703", "prepared_for": "Crown Kitchen Group", "schema_version": "counselbench.decision.v3", "task_id": "cb100-033-crown-employment"}, "matter_register": {"matter_number": "CB-LD-2703", "rows": [{"decision_option_id": "crown-employment:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key", "issue": "custodian omission", "matter_number": "CB-LD-2703", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-033-01", "row_id": "REG-CBP-033-01", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_pleadings/001_pleadings_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/02_orders/013_orders_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/025_custodian_files_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/05_email_families/037_email_families_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_case_management/097_crown_employment_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "crown-employment:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-10", "issue": "common-interest support gap", "matter_number": "CB-LD-2703", "owner": "Sofia Bennett", "portfolio_key": "CBP-033-02", "row_id": "REG-CBP-033-02", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_pleadings/002_pleadings_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/02_orders/014_orders_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/026_custodian_files_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/05_email_families/038_email_families_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/08_production_logs/062_production_logs_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_case_management/097_crown_employment_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "crown-employment:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-09", "issue": "expert draft segregation", "matter_number": "CB-LD-2703", "owner": "Micah Sullivan", "portfolio_key": "CBP-033-03", "row_id": "REG-CBP-033-03", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_pleadings/003_pleadings_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/02_orders/015_orders_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/027_custodian_files_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/05_email_families/039_email_families_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_case_management/097_crown_employment_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "crown-employment:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-08", "issue": "meet-and-confer commitment", "matter_number": "CB-LD-2703", "owner": "Nora Chen", "portfolio_key": "CBP-033-04", "row_id": "REG-CBP-033-04", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_pleadings/004_pleadings_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/02_orders/016_orders_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/028_custodian_files_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/05_email_families/040_email_families_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/10_expert_material/076_expert_material_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/08_production_logs/064_production_logs_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_case_management/097_crown_employment_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "crown-employment:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-07", "issue": "privilege-log description defect", "matter_number": "CB-LD-2703", "owner": "Caleb Hassan", "portfolio_key": "CBP-033-05", "row_id": "REG-CBP-033-05", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_pleadings/005_pleadings_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/017_requests_responses_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/029_custodian_files_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/041_chat_exports_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/07_privilege_material/053_privilege_material_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_case_management/097_crown_employment_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "crown-employment:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "the current observation does not meet the operative trigger", "issue": "deposition exhibit omission", "matter_number": "CB-LD-2703", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-033-06", "row_id": "REG-CBP-033-06", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_pleadings/006_pleadings_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/018_requests_responses_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/030_custodian_files_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/042_chat_exports_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/12_case_management/097_crown_employment_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "crown-employment:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-05", "issue": "Bates-range overlap", "matter_number": "CB-LD-2703", "owner": "Samuel Kim", "portfolio_key": "CBP-033-07", "row_id": "REG-CBP-033-07", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_pleadings/007_pleadings_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/019_requests_responses_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/031_custodian_files_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/043_chat_exports_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/07_privilege_material/055_privilege_material_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/10_expert_material/079_expert_material_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_case_management/097_crown_employment_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "crown-employment:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "the operational record relies on a superseded control revision", "issue": "email-family separation", "matter_number": "CB-LD-2703", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-033-08", "row_id": "REG-CBP-033-08", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_pleadings/008_pleadings_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/020_requests_responses_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/032_custodian_files_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/044_chat_exports_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/10_expert_material/080_expert_material_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/07_privilege_material/056_privilege_material_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_case_management/097_crown_employment_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "crown-employment:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-03", "issue": "request-response mismatch", "matter_number": "CB-LD-2703", "owner": "Adrian Mensah", "portfolio_key": "CBP-033-09", "row_id": "REG-CBP-033-09", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_orders/009_orders_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/021_requests_responses_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/05_email_families/033_email_families_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/045_chat_exports_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/11_third_party/081_third_party_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/12_case_management/093_case_management_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_case_management/097_crown_employment_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "crown-employment:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-11", "issue": "metadata field loss", "matter_number": "CB-LD-2703", "owner": "Farah Ibrahim", "portfolio_key": "CBP-033-10", "row_id": "REG-CBP-033-10", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_orders/010_orders_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/022_requests_responses_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/05_email_families/034_email_families_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/046_chat_exports_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_case_management/094_case_management_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_case_management/097_crown_employment_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "crown-employment:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective", "issue": "collection-date inconsistency", "matter_number": "CB-LD-2703", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-033-11", "row_id": "REG-CBP-033-11", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_orders/011_orders_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/023_requests_responses_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/05_email_families/035_email_families_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/047_chat_exports_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_case_management/097_crown_employment_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "crown-employment:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-09", "issue": "protective-order designation error", "matter_number": "CB-LD-2703", "owner": "Leona Park", "portfolio_key": "CBP-033-12", "row_id": "REG-CBP-033-12", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_orders/012_orders_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/024_requests_responses_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/05_email_families/036_email_families_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/048_chat_exports_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/09_depositions/072_depositions_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/08_production_logs/060_production_logs_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/12_case_management/097_crown_employment_impact_population.xlsx"]}], "schema_version": "counselbench.matter-register.v3", "task_id": "cb100-033-crown-employment"}}, "metadata": {"benchmark": "CounselBench-100", "code_license": "Apache-2.0", "data_license": "CC-BY-4.0", "deadline": "2026-09-12", "document_count": 97, "evidence_holds": 4, "jurisdiction": "California", "matter_number": "CB-LD-2703", "mcp_commit": "9a96ea6e5913736f92b88345bf51caeaaa8e719f", "mcp_package": "@modelcontextprotocol/server-filesystem@2026.7.10", "practice_area": "litigation-discovery", "reference_tool_calls": 83, "required_evidence_reads": 63, "supported_actions": 8, "synthetic": true, "venue": "Central District of California", "version": "3.1.0"}, "prompt": "A late record changed the picture this morning. Is Crown ready to certify its wage-case production after the late holds and meet-and-confer promises? A wage class action involves manager texts, scheduling exports, late legal holds, and commitments made during two meet-and-confer sessions. The team needs the call by 2026-09-12. Make the matter record usable by operations after your review, but do not turn ambiguity into an accusation or obligation.", "rubric": {"criteria": [{"category": "investigation", "description": "Inventory the production and use targeted searches to locate records across native formats.", "id": "investigation.discover_production"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Complete every task-specific identity, authority, operations, and approval read before the first state transition.", "id": "investigation.read_before_write"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Inspect designated source metadata before relying on those records.", "id": "investigation.custody_before_write"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "Select the supported option 'crown-employment:scoped-evidence' after applying the four-part test.", "id": "decision.selected_option"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "Identify both rejected approaches and explain why a one-source shortcut and a blanket hold are wrong.", "id": "decision.alternatives"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-033-01 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_pleadings/001_pleadings_source_export.md rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-033-01.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_orders/013_orders_source_export.json for custodian omission.", "id": "investigation.CBP-033-01.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/025_custodian_files_source_export.md to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-033-01.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_email_families/037_email_families_source_export.json.", "id": "investigation.CBP-033-01.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-033-01 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key.", "id": "decision.CBP-033-01.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-033-01 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-033-01.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-033-02 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_pleadings/002_pleadings_source_export.txt rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-033-02.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_orders/014_orders_source_export.xml for common-interest support gap.", "id": "investigation.CBP-033-02.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/026_custodian_files_source_export.txt to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-033-02.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_email_families/038_email_families_source_export.xml.", "id": "investigation.CBP-033-02.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-033-02 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-033-02.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-033-02 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-033-02.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-033-03 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_pleadings/003_pleadings_source_export.eml rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-033-03.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_orders/015_orders_source_export.html for expert draft segregation.", "id": "investigation.CBP-033-03.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/027_custodian_files_source_export.eml to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-033-03.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_email_families/039_email_families_source_export.html.", "id": "investigation.CBP-033-03.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-033-03 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-033-03.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-033-03 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-033-03.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-033-04 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_pleadings/004_pleadings_source_export.csv rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-033-04.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_orders/016_orders_source_export.pdf for meet-and-confer commitment.", "id": "investigation.CBP-033-04.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/028_custodian_files_source_export.csv to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-033-04.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_email_families/040_email_families_source_export.pdf.", "id": "investigation.CBP-033-04.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-033-04 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-033-04.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-033-04 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-033-04.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-033-05 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_pleadings/005_pleadings_source_export.json rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-033-05.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/017_requests_responses_source_export.md for privilege-log description defect.", "id": "investigation.CBP-033-05.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/029_custodian_files_source_export.json to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-033-05.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/041_chat_exports_source_export.md.", "id": "investigation.CBP-033-05.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-033-05 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-033-05.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-033-05 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-033-05.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-033-06 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_pleadings/006_pleadings_source_export.xml rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-033-06.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/018_requests_responses_source_export.txt for deposition exhibit omission.", "id": "investigation.CBP-033-06.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/030_custodian_files_source_export.xml to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-033-06.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/042_chat_exports_source_export.txt.", "id": "investigation.CBP-033-06.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-033-06 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is the current observation does not meet the operative trigger.", "id": "decision.CBP-033-06.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-033-06 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-033-06.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-033-07 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_pleadings/007_pleadings_source_export.html rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-033-07.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/019_requests_responses_source_export.eml for Bates-range overlap.", "id": "investigation.CBP-033-07.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/031_custodian_files_source_export.html to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-033-07.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/043_chat_exports_source_export.eml.", "id": "investigation.CBP-033-07.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-033-07 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-033-07.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-033-07 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-033-07.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-033-08 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_pleadings/008_pleadings_source_export.pdf rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-033-08.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/020_requests_responses_source_export.csv for email-family separation.", "id": "investigation.CBP-033-08.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/032_custodian_files_source_export.pdf to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-033-08.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/044_chat_exports_source_export.csv.", "id": "investigation.CBP-033-08.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-033-08 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is the operational record relies on a superseded control revision.", "id": "decision.CBP-033-08.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-033-08 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-033-08.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-033-09 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_orders/009_orders_source_export.md rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-033-09.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/021_requests_responses_source_export.json for request-response mismatch.", "id": "investigation.CBP-033-09.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_email_families/033_email_families_source_export.md to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-033-09.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/045_chat_exports_source_export.json.", "id": "investigation.CBP-033-09.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-033-09 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-033-09.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-033-09 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-033-09.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-033-10 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_orders/010_orders_source_export.txt rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-033-10.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/022_requests_responses_source_export.xml for metadata field loss.", "id": "investigation.CBP-033-10.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_email_families/034_email_families_source_export.txt to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-033-10.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/046_chat_exports_source_export.xml.", "id": "investigation.CBP-033-10.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-033-10 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-033-10.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-033-10 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-033-10.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-033-11 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_orders/011_orders_source_export.eml rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-033-11.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/023_requests_responses_source_export.html for collection-date inconsistency.", "id": "investigation.CBP-033-11.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_email_families/035_email_families_source_export.eml to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-033-11.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/047_chat_exports_source_export.html.", "id": "investigation.CBP-033-11.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-033-11 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective.", "id": "decision.CBP-033-11.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-033-11 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-033-11.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-033-12 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_orders/012_orders_source_export.csv rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-033-12.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/024_requests_responses_source_export.pdf for protective-order designation error.", "id": "investigation.CBP-033-12.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_email_families/036_email_families_source_export.csv to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-033-12.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/048_chat_exports_source_export.pdf.", "id": "investigation.CBP-033-12.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-033-12 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-033-12.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-033-12 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-033-12.register"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Write the exact selected option, supported action population, evidence-hold population, facts, owners, deadlines, and citations.", "id": "state.exact_decision"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create one exact register row per portfolio key with no extra, missing, or modified row.", "id": "state.exact_register"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Leave only the three approved deliverables and perform no extra state-changing write.", "id": "state.write_scope_containment"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Read back decision.json, matter-register.json, and advice.md after their final writes.", "id": "state.postwrite_readback"}, {"category": "answer", "description": "Explain the selected recommendation, supported actions, holds, alternatives, and limitations with exact source anchors.", "id": "answer.decision_note"}], "decision_options": [{"approach": "Treat supported actions and genuinely ambiguous records as if they were equally unresolved.", "id": "crown-employment:blanket-hold", "label": "Freeze the entire matter population"}, {"approach": "Apply the exact identity, current-state, authority, and revision test. Create custodian and request-level cure rows with explicit certification holds.", "id": "crown-employment:scoped-evidence", "label": "Cure supported hold and production gaps before giving a bounded certification."}, {"approach": "Use a plausible summary or one source without completing the controlling joins.", "id": "crown-employment:shortcut", "label": "Certify because all currently collected files were produced."}], "evaluation_narrative": {"authority": "Court orders and recorded meet-and-confer commitments define the certification scope.", "observation": "Match custodians, texts, schedule exports, hold delivery, and promised supplements to request populations.", "question": "Is Crown ready to certify its wage-case production after the late holds and meet-and-confer promises?", "register_action": "Create custodian and request-level cure rows with explicit certification holds."}, "gates": ["all_required_evidence_precedes_first_write", "decision_criteria_complete", "register_state_exact", "write_scope_contained", "all_outputs_verified_by_readback"], "metadata_checks": 7, "metric": "weighted_criteria_score", "minimum_tool_calls": 83, "required_deliverables": ["decision.json", "matter-register.json", "advice.md"], "required_document_reads": 63, "type": "deterministic", "weights": {"advice": 0.15, "decision": 0.35, "investigation": 0.25, "state": 0.25}}, "task_id": "cb100-033-crown-employment", "task_name": "Crown wage action discovery check", "world_id": "counselbench-filesystem-mcp-v3"}
+{"context_files": ["task_files/cb100-034-delta-products/01_pleadings/001_pleadings_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-034-delta-products/01_pleadings/002_pleadings_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-034-delta-products/01_pleadings/003_pleadings_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-034-delta-products/01_pleadings/004_pleadings_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-034-delta-products/01_pleadings/005_pleadings_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-034-delta-products/01_pleadings/006_pleadings_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-034-delta-products/01_pleadings/007_pleadings_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-034-delta-products/01_pleadings/008_pleadings_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-034-delta-products/02_orders/009_orders_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-034-delta-products/02_orders/010_orders_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-034-delta-products/02_orders/011_orders_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-034-delta-products/02_orders/012_orders_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-034-delta-products/02_orders/013_orders_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-034-delta-products/02_orders/014_orders_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-034-delta-products/02_orders/015_orders_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-034-delta-products/02_orders/016_orders_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-034-delta-products/03_requests_responses/017_requests_responses_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-034-delta-products/03_requests_responses/018_requests_responses_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-034-delta-products/03_requests_responses/019_requests_responses_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-034-delta-products/03_requests_responses/020_requests_responses_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-034-delta-products/03_requests_responses/021_requests_responses_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-034-delta-products/03_requests_responses/022_requests_responses_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-034-delta-products/03_requests_responses/023_requests_responses_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-034-delta-products/03_requests_responses/024_requests_responses_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-034-delta-products/04_custodian_files/025_custodian_files_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-034-delta-products/04_custodian_files/026_custodian_files_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-034-delta-products/04_custodian_files/027_custodian_files_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-034-delta-products/04_custodian_files/028_custodian_files_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-034-delta-products/04_custodian_files/029_custodian_files_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-034-delta-products/04_custodian_files/030_custodian_files_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-034-delta-products/04_custodian_files/031_custodian_files_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-034-delta-products/04_custodian_files/032_custodian_files_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-034-delta-products/05_email_families/033_email_families_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-034-delta-products/05_email_families/034_email_families_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-034-delta-products/05_email_families/035_email_families_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-034-delta-products/05_email_families/036_email_families_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-034-delta-products/05_email_families/037_email_families_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-034-delta-products/05_email_families/038_email_families_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-034-delta-products/05_email_families/039_email_families_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-034-delta-products/05_email_families/040_email_families_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-034-delta-products/06_chat_exports/041_chat_exports_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-034-delta-products/06_chat_exports/042_chat_exports_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-034-delta-products/06_chat_exports/043_chat_exports_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-034-delta-products/06_chat_exports/044_chat_exports_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-034-delta-products/06_chat_exports/045_chat_exports_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-034-delta-products/06_chat_exports/046_chat_exports_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-034-delta-products/06_chat_exports/047_chat_exports_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-034-delta-products/06_chat_exports/048_chat_exports_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-034-delta-products/07_privilege_material/049_privilege_material_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-034-delta-products/07_privilege_material/050_privilege_material_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-034-delta-products/07_privilege_material/051_privilege_material_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-034-delta-products/07_privilege_material/052_privilege_material_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-034-delta-products/07_privilege_material/053_privilege_material_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-034-delta-products/07_privilege_material/054_privilege_material_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-034-delta-products/07_privilege_material/055_privilege_material_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-034-delta-products/07_privilege_material/056_privilege_material_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-034-delta-products/08_production_logs/057_production_logs_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-034-delta-products/08_production_logs/058_production_logs_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-034-delta-products/08_production_logs/059_production_logs_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-034-delta-products/08_production_logs/060_production_logs_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-034-delta-products/08_production_logs/061_production_logs_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-034-delta-products/08_production_logs/062_production_logs_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-034-delta-products/08_production_logs/063_production_logs_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-034-delta-products/08_production_logs/064_production_logs_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-034-delta-products/09_depositions/065_depositions_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-034-delta-products/09_depositions/066_depositions_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-034-delta-products/09_depositions/067_depositions_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-034-delta-products/09_depositions/068_depositions_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-034-delta-products/09_depositions/069_depositions_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-034-delta-products/09_depositions/070_depositions_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-034-delta-products/09_depositions/071_depositions_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-034-delta-products/09_depositions/072_depositions_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-034-delta-products/10_expert_material/073_expert_material_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-034-delta-products/10_expert_material/074_expert_material_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-034-delta-products/10_expert_material/075_expert_material_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-034-delta-products/10_expert_material/076_expert_material_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-034-delta-products/10_expert_material/077_expert_material_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-034-delta-products/10_expert_material/078_expert_material_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-034-delta-products/10_expert_material/079_expert_material_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-034-delta-products/10_expert_material/080_expert_material_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-034-delta-products/11_third_party/081_third_party_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-034-delta-products/11_third_party/082_third_party_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-034-delta-products/11_third_party/083_third_party_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-034-delta-products/11_third_party/084_third_party_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-034-delta-products/11_third_party/085_third_party_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-034-delta-products/11_third_party/086_third_party_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-034-delta-products/11_third_party/087_third_party_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-034-delta-products/11_third_party/088_third_party_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-034-delta-products/12_case_management/089_case_management_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-034-delta-products/12_case_management/090_case_management_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-034-delta-products/12_case_management/091_case_management_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-034-delta-products/12_case_management/092_case_management_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-034-delta-products/12_case_management/093_case_management_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-034-delta-products/12_case_management/094_case_management_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-034-delta-products/12_case_management/095_case_management_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-034-delta-products/12_case_management/096_case_management_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-034-delta-products/12_case_management/097_delta_products_impact_population.xlsx"], "gold_output": {"advice_markdown": "# Decision note — Delta product-liability collection audit\n\n## Recommendation\n\nCollect or segregate the supported gaps and escalate overdue third-party evidence. The reconciled record supports 7 scoped actions and leaves 5 items on evidence hold.\n\nSelected option: `delta-products:scoped-evidence`.\n\n## Why this is the supported option\n\nReconcile design-history versions, supplier custodians, collection dates, expert status, and subpoena returns. Requests, expert-discovery rules, and subpoena deadlines apply to exact files and custodians.\n\n## Supported actions\n\n### CBP-034-02 — clawback deadline (low)\n\ndelivery must use notices-delta_infant_products@example.test under CB-LD-2704-R628; the only matched receipt used archive-reed_v_delta_infant_products@example.test under CB-LD-2704-E289. Identity resolves to ENT-034-1001, revision REV-2026.2 is current, and Theo Laurent is active with capacity 5.\n\nAction: Register exact collection and expert-treatment decisions without bulk assumptions. Owner: Theo Laurent; due 2026-09-14.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_pleadings/002_pleadings_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/02_orders/014_orders_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/026_custodian_files_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/05_email_families/038_email_families_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/12_case_management/097_delta_products_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-034-05 — common-interest support gap (low)\n\nthe controlling threshold is 10% under CB-LD-2704-R293; the independently calculated result is 12% under CB-LD-2704-E217. Identity resolves to ENT-034-1004, revision REV-2026.5 is current, and Sofia Bennett is active with capacity 6.\n\nAction: Register exact collection and expert-treatment decisions without bulk assumptions. Owner: Sofia Bennett; due 2026-09-11.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_pleadings/005_pleadings_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/017_requests_responses_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/029_custodian_files_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/041_chat_exports_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/12_case_management/089_case_management_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/12_case_management/097_delta_products_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-034-06 — expert draft segregation (medium)\n\napproval must come from Maya Ellison under CB-LD-2704-R469; the effective approval record names Henry Cho under CB-LD-2704-E333. Identity resolves to ENT-034-1005, revision REV-2026.6 is current, and Micah Sullivan is active with capacity 6.\n\nAction: Register exact collection and expert-treatment decisions without bulk assumptions. Owner: Micah Sullivan; due 2026-09-10.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_pleadings/006_pleadings_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/018_requests_responses_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/030_custodian_files_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/042_chat_exports_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/12_case_management/090_case_management_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/12_case_management/097_delta_products_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-034-07 — meet-and-confer commitment (low)\n\nthe controlled population contains 202 records under CB-LD-2704-R540; the certification covers 189 records under CB-LD-2704-E337. Identity resolves to ENT-034-1006, revision REV-2026.7 is current, and Nora Chen is active with capacity 1.\n\nAction: Register exact collection and expert-treatment decisions without bulk assumptions. Owner: Nora Chen; due 2026-09-09.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_pleadings/007_pleadings_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/019_requests_responses_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/031_custodian_files_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/043_chat_exports_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/07_privilege_material/055_privilege_material_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/12_case_management/097_delta_products_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-034-08 — privilege-log description defect (medium)\n\nthe permission is limited to Northern District of Georgia under CB-LD-2704-R318; the matched activity occurred in Georgia under CB-LD-2704-E906. Identity resolves to ENT-034-1007, revision REV-2026.1 is current, and Caleb Hassan is active with capacity 3.\n\nAction: Register exact collection and expert-treatment decisions without bulk assumptions. Owner: Caleb Hassan; due 2026-09-08.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_pleadings/008_pleadings_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/020_requests_responses_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/032_custodian_files_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/044_chat_exports_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/12_case_management/097_delta_products_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-034-09 — deposition exhibit omission (critical)\n\nthe operative cap is $3,922,000.00 under CB-LD-2704-R852; the matched ledger population totals $4,017,652.00 under CB-LD-2704-E408. Identity resolves to ENT-034-1008, revision REV-2026.2 is current, and Amara Patel is active with capacity 1.\n\nAction: Register exact collection and expert-treatment decisions without bulk assumptions. Owner: Amara Patel; due 2026-09-07.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/02_orders/009_orders_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/021_requests_responses_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/05_email_families/033_email_families_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/045_chat_exports_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/12_case_management/097_delta_products_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-034-10 — Bates-range overlap (medium)\n\ndelivery must use notices-delta_infant_products@example.test under CB-LD-2704-R140; the only matched receipt used archive-reed_v_delta_infant_products@example.test under CB-LD-2704-E843. Identity resolves to ENT-034-1009, revision REV-2026.3 is current, and Samuel Kim is active with capacity 5.\n\nAction: Register exact collection and expert-treatment decisions without bulk assumptions. Owner: Samuel Kim; due 2026-09-15.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/02_orders/010_orders_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/022_requests_responses_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/05_email_families/034_email_families_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/046_chat_exports_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/08_production_logs/058_production_logs_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/12_case_management/094_case_management_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/12_case_management/097_delta_products_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n## Evidence holds\n\n- **CBP-034-01 — legal-hold delivery gap**: the current observation does not meet the operative trigger. Next evidence: a current observation that satisfies the operative trigger. Sources: `/workspace/documents/01_pleadings/001_pleadings_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/02_orders/013_orders_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/025_custodian_files_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/05_email_families/037_email_families_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/07_privilege_material/049_privilege_material_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/12_case_management/097_delta_products_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-034-03 — third-party subpoena deadline**: the operational record relies on a superseded control revision. Next evidence: an operational record using the current effective revision. Sources: `/workspace/documents/01_pleadings/003_pleadings_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/02_orders/015_orders_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/027_custodian_files_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/05_email_families/039_email_families_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/12_case_management/097_delta_products_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-034-04 — custodian omission**: two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key. Next evidence: an approved immutable entity crosswalk. Sources: `/workspace/documents/01_pleadings/004_pleadings_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/02_orders/016_orders_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/028_custodian_files_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/05_email_families/040_email_families_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/10_expert_material/076_expert_material_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/12_case_management/097_delta_products_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-034-11 — email-family separation**: the operational record relies on a superseded control revision. Next evidence: an operational record using the current effective revision. Sources: `/workspace/documents/02_orders/011_orders_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/023_requests_responses_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/05_email_families/035_email_families_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/047_chat_exports_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/12_case_management/095_case_management_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/09_depositions/071_depositions_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/12_case_management/097_delta_products_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-034-12 — request-response mismatch**: two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key. Next evidence: an approved immutable entity crosswalk. Sources: `/workspace/documents/02_orders/012_orders_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/024_requests_responses_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/05_email_families/036_email_families_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/048_chat_exports_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/11_third_party/084_third_party_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/12_case_management/097_delta_products_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n## Alternatives considered\n\n- `delta-products:shortcut` — Treat every late-created file as missing discovery and every expert file as protected.: Use a plausible summary or one source without completing the controlling joins.\n- `delta-products:blanket-hold` — Freeze the entire matter population: Treat supported actions and genuinely ambiguous records as if they were equally unresolved.\n\n## Assumptions and limits\n\nThis decision is limited to cb100-034-delta-products, the supplied synthetic records, and the matter state as of 2026-09-16. Similar names, stale revisions, and pending authority are not treated as proof.\n", "decision": {"actions": [{"determination": "delivery must use notices-delta_infant_products@example.test under CB-LD-2704-R628; the only matched receipt used archive-reed_v_delta_infant_products@example.test under CB-LD-2704-E289. Identity resolves to ENT-034-1001, revision REV-2026.2 is current, and Theo Laurent is active with capacity 5.", "due_date": "2026-09-14", "id": "ACT-CBP-034-02", "identity_id": "ENT-034-1001", "issue": "clawback deadline", "owner": "Theo Laurent", "portfolio_key": "CBP-034-02", "recommended_action": "Register exact collection and expert-treatment decisions without bulk assumptions. Owner: Theo Laurent; due 2026-09-14.", "severity": "low", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_pleadings/002_pleadings_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/02_orders/014_orders_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/026_custodian_files_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/05_email_families/038_email_families_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_case_management/097_delta_products_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "the controlling threshold is 10% under CB-LD-2704-R293; the independently calculated result is 12% under CB-LD-2704-E217. Identity resolves to ENT-034-1004, revision REV-2026.5 is current, and Sofia Bennett is active with capacity 6.", "due_date": "2026-09-11", "id": "ACT-CBP-034-05", "identity_id": "ENT-034-1004", "issue": "common-interest support gap", "owner": "Sofia Bennett", "portfolio_key": "CBP-034-05", "recommended_action": "Register exact collection and expert-treatment decisions without bulk assumptions. Owner: Sofia Bennett; due 2026-09-11.", "severity": "low", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_pleadings/005_pleadings_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/017_requests_responses_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/029_custodian_files_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/041_chat_exports_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/12_case_management/089_case_management_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/12_case_management/097_delta_products_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "approval must come from Maya Ellison under CB-LD-2704-R469; the effective approval record names Henry Cho under CB-LD-2704-E333. Identity resolves to ENT-034-1005, revision REV-2026.6 is current, and Micah Sullivan is active with capacity 6.", "due_date": "2026-09-10", "id": "ACT-CBP-034-06", "identity_id": "ENT-034-1005", "issue": "expert draft segregation", "owner": "Micah Sullivan", "portfolio_key": "CBP-034-06", "recommended_action": "Register exact collection and expert-treatment decisions without bulk assumptions. Owner: Micah Sullivan; due 2026-09-10.", "severity": "medium", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_pleadings/006_pleadings_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/018_requests_responses_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/030_custodian_files_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/042_chat_exports_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/12_case_management/090_case_management_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/12_case_management/097_delta_products_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "the controlled population contains 202 records under CB-LD-2704-R540; the certification covers 189 records under CB-LD-2704-E337. Identity resolves to ENT-034-1006, revision REV-2026.7 is current, and Nora Chen is active with capacity 1.", "due_date": "2026-09-09", "id": "ACT-CBP-034-07", "identity_id": "ENT-034-1006", "issue": "meet-and-confer commitment", "owner": "Nora Chen", "portfolio_key": "CBP-034-07", "recommended_action": "Register exact collection and expert-treatment decisions without bulk assumptions. Owner: Nora Chen; due 2026-09-09.", "severity": "low", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_pleadings/007_pleadings_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/019_requests_responses_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/031_custodian_files_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/043_chat_exports_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/07_privilege_material/055_privilege_material_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_case_management/097_delta_products_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "the permission is limited to Northern District of Georgia under CB-LD-2704-R318; the matched activity occurred in Georgia under CB-LD-2704-E906. Identity resolves to ENT-034-1007, revision REV-2026.1 is current, and Caleb Hassan is active with capacity 3.", "due_date": "2026-09-08", "id": "ACT-CBP-034-08", "identity_id": "ENT-034-1007", "issue": "privilege-log description defect", "owner": "Caleb Hassan", "portfolio_key": "CBP-034-08", "recommended_action": "Register exact collection and expert-treatment decisions without bulk assumptions. Owner: Caleb Hassan; due 2026-09-08.", "severity": "medium", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_pleadings/008_pleadings_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/020_requests_responses_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/032_custodian_files_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/044_chat_exports_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/12_case_management/097_delta_products_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "the operative cap is $3,922,000.00 under CB-LD-2704-R852; the matched ledger population totals $4,017,652.00 under CB-LD-2704-E408. Identity resolves to ENT-034-1008, revision REV-2026.2 is current, and Amara Patel is active with capacity 1.", "due_date": "2026-09-07", "id": "ACT-CBP-034-09", "identity_id": "ENT-034-1008", "issue": "deposition exhibit omission", "owner": "Amara Patel", "portfolio_key": "CBP-034-09", "recommended_action": "Register exact collection and expert-treatment decisions without bulk assumptions. Owner: Amara Patel; due 2026-09-07.", "severity": "critical", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_orders/009_orders_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/021_requests_responses_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/05_email_families/033_email_families_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/045_chat_exports_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_case_management/097_delta_products_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "delivery must use notices-delta_infant_products@example.test under CB-LD-2704-R140; the only matched receipt used archive-reed_v_delta_infant_products@example.test under CB-LD-2704-E843. Identity resolves to ENT-034-1009, revision REV-2026.3 is current, and Samuel Kim is active with capacity 5.", "due_date": "2026-09-15", "id": "ACT-CBP-034-10", "identity_id": "ENT-034-1009", "issue": "Bates-range overlap", "owner": "Samuel Kim", "portfolio_key": "CBP-034-10", "recommended_action": "Register exact collection and expert-treatment decisions without bulk assumptions. Owner: Samuel Kim; due 2026-09-15.", "severity": "medium", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_orders/010_orders_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/022_requests_responses_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/05_email_families/034_email_families_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/046_chat_exports_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/08_production_logs/058_production_logs_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/12_case_management/094_case_management_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_case_management/097_delta_products_impact_population.xlsx"]}], "as_of": "2026-09-16", "decision": {"alternatives_considered": ["delta-products:shortcut", "delta-products:blanket-hold"], "question": "What must Delta collect or segregate before the product-liability production is complete?", "rationale": "The four-part causal test supports 7 scoped actions and leaves 5 records on evidence hold. Requests, expert-discovery rules, and subpoena deadlines apply to exact files and custodians.", "recommendation": "Collect or segregate the supported gaps and escalate overdue third-party evidence.", "selected_option_id": "delta-products:scoped-evidence"}, "holds": [{"id": "HOLD-CBP-034-01", "issue": "legal-hold delivery gap", "portfolio_key": "CBP-034-01", "reason": "the current observation does not meet the operative trigger", "required_next_evidence": "a current observation that satisfies the operative trigger", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_pleadings/001_pleadings_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/02_orders/013_orders_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/025_custodian_files_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/05_email_families/037_email_families_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/07_privilege_material/049_privilege_material_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/12_case_management/097_delta_products_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-034-03", "issue": "third-party subpoena deadline", "portfolio_key": "CBP-034-03", "reason": "the operational record relies on a superseded control revision", "required_next_evidence": "an operational record using the current effective revision", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_pleadings/003_pleadings_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/02_orders/015_orders_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/027_custodian_files_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/05_email_families/039_email_families_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_case_management/097_delta_products_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-034-04", "issue": "custodian omission", "portfolio_key": "CBP-034-04", "reason": "two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key", "required_next_evidence": "an approved immutable entity crosswalk", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_pleadings/004_pleadings_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/02_orders/016_orders_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/028_custodian_files_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/05_email_families/040_email_families_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/10_expert_material/076_expert_material_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/12_case_management/097_delta_products_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-034-11", "issue": "email-family separation", "portfolio_key": "CBP-034-11", "reason": "the operational record relies on a superseded control revision", "required_next_evidence": "an operational record using the current effective revision", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_orders/011_orders_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/023_requests_responses_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/05_email_families/035_email_families_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/047_chat_exports_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_case_management/095_case_management_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/09_depositions/071_depositions_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_case_management/097_delta_products_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-034-12", "issue": "request-response mismatch", "portfolio_key": "CBP-034-12", "reason": "two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key", "required_next_evidence": "an approved immutable entity crosswalk", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_orders/012_orders_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/024_requests_responses_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/05_email_families/036_email_families_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/048_chat_exports_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/11_third_party/084_third_party_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/12_case_management/097_delta_products_impact_population.xlsx"]}], "matter_number": "CB-LD-2704", "prepared_for": "Delta Infant Products", "schema_version": "counselbench.decision.v3", "task_id": "cb100-034-delta-products"}, "matter_register": {"matter_number": "CB-LD-2704", "rows": [{"decision_option_id": "delta-products:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "the current observation does not meet the operative trigger", "issue": "legal-hold delivery gap", "matter_number": "CB-LD-2704", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-034-01", "row_id": "REG-CBP-034-01", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_pleadings/001_pleadings_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/02_orders/013_orders_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/025_custodian_files_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/05_email_families/037_email_families_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/07_privilege_material/049_privilege_material_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/12_case_management/097_delta_products_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "delta-products:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-14", "issue": "clawback deadline", "matter_number": "CB-LD-2704", "owner": "Theo Laurent", "portfolio_key": "CBP-034-02", "row_id": "REG-CBP-034-02", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_pleadings/002_pleadings_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/02_orders/014_orders_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/026_custodian_files_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/05_email_families/038_email_families_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_case_management/097_delta_products_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "delta-products:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "the operational record relies on a superseded control revision", "issue": "third-party subpoena deadline", "matter_number": "CB-LD-2704", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-034-03", "row_id": "REG-CBP-034-03", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_pleadings/003_pleadings_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/02_orders/015_orders_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/027_custodian_files_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/05_email_families/039_email_families_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_case_management/097_delta_products_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "delta-products:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key", "issue": "custodian omission", "matter_number": "CB-LD-2704", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-034-04", "row_id": "REG-CBP-034-04", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_pleadings/004_pleadings_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/02_orders/016_orders_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/028_custodian_files_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/05_email_families/040_email_families_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/10_expert_material/076_expert_material_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/12_case_management/097_delta_products_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "delta-products:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-11", "issue": "common-interest support gap", "matter_number": "CB-LD-2704", "owner": "Sofia Bennett", "portfolio_key": "CBP-034-05", "row_id": "REG-CBP-034-05", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_pleadings/005_pleadings_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/017_requests_responses_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/029_custodian_files_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/041_chat_exports_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/12_case_management/089_case_management_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/12_case_management/097_delta_products_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "delta-products:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-10", "issue": "expert draft segregation", "matter_number": "CB-LD-2704", "owner": "Micah Sullivan", "portfolio_key": "CBP-034-06", "row_id": "REG-CBP-034-06", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_pleadings/006_pleadings_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/018_requests_responses_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/030_custodian_files_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/042_chat_exports_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/12_case_management/090_case_management_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/12_case_management/097_delta_products_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "delta-products:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-09", "issue": "meet-and-confer commitment", "matter_number": "CB-LD-2704", "owner": "Nora Chen", "portfolio_key": "CBP-034-07", "row_id": "REG-CBP-034-07", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_pleadings/007_pleadings_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/019_requests_responses_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/031_custodian_files_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/043_chat_exports_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/07_privilege_material/055_privilege_material_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_case_management/097_delta_products_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "delta-products:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-08", "issue": "privilege-log description defect", "matter_number": "CB-LD-2704", "owner": "Caleb Hassan", "portfolio_key": "CBP-034-08", "row_id": "REG-CBP-034-08", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_pleadings/008_pleadings_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/020_requests_responses_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/032_custodian_files_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/044_chat_exports_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/12_case_management/097_delta_products_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "delta-products:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-07", "issue": "deposition exhibit omission", "matter_number": "CB-LD-2704", "owner": "Amara Patel", "portfolio_key": "CBP-034-09", "row_id": "REG-CBP-034-09", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_orders/009_orders_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/021_requests_responses_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/05_email_families/033_email_families_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/045_chat_exports_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_case_management/097_delta_products_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "delta-products:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-15", "issue": "Bates-range overlap", "matter_number": "CB-LD-2704", "owner": "Samuel Kim", "portfolio_key": "CBP-034-10", "row_id": "REG-CBP-034-10", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_orders/010_orders_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/022_requests_responses_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/05_email_families/034_email_families_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/046_chat_exports_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/08_production_logs/058_production_logs_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/12_case_management/094_case_management_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_case_management/097_delta_products_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "delta-products:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "the operational record relies on a superseded control revision", "issue": "email-family separation", "matter_number": "CB-LD-2704", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-034-11", "row_id": "REG-CBP-034-11", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_orders/011_orders_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/023_requests_responses_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/05_email_families/035_email_families_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/047_chat_exports_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_case_management/095_case_management_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/09_depositions/071_depositions_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_case_management/097_delta_products_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "delta-products:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key", "issue": "request-response mismatch", "matter_number": "CB-LD-2704", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-034-12", "row_id": "REG-CBP-034-12", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_orders/012_orders_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/024_requests_responses_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/05_email_families/036_email_families_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/048_chat_exports_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/11_third_party/084_third_party_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/12_case_management/097_delta_products_impact_population.xlsx"]}], "schema_version": "counselbench.matter-register.v3", "task_id": "cb100-034-delta-products"}}, "metadata": {"benchmark": "CounselBench-100", "code_license": "Apache-2.0", "data_license": "CC-BY-4.0", "deadline": "2026-09-16", "document_count": 97, "evidence_holds": 5, "jurisdiction": "Georgia", "matter_number": "CB-LD-2704", "mcp_commit": "9a96ea6e5913736f92b88345bf51caeaaa8e719f", "mcp_package": "@modelcontextprotocol/server-filesystem@2026.7.10", "practice_area": "litigation-discovery", "reference_tool_calls": 82, "required_evidence_reads": 59, "supported_actions": 7, "synthetic": true, "venue": "Northern District of Georgia", "version": "3.1.0"}, "prompt": "The client wants a decision, not another document inventory. What must Delta collect or segregate before the product-liability production is complete? Design-history files, overseas supplier emails, and expert materials have inconsistent collection dates and an unresolved third-party subpoena. The team needs the call by 2026-09-16. Put the supported calls into the matter register and leave me a short note I can use with the partner.", "rubric": {"criteria": [{"category": "investigation", "description": "Inventory the production and use targeted searches to locate records across native formats.", "id": "investigation.discover_production"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Complete every task-specific identity, authority, operations, and approval read before the first state transition.", "id": "investigation.read_before_write"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Inspect designated source metadata before relying on those records.", "id": "investigation.custody_before_write"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "Select the supported option 'delta-products:scoped-evidence' after applying the four-part test.", "id": "decision.selected_option"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "Identify both rejected approaches and explain why a one-source shortcut and a blanket hold are wrong.", "id": "decision.alternatives"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-034-01 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_pleadings/001_pleadings_source_export.md rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-034-01.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_orders/013_orders_source_export.json for legal-hold delivery gap.", "id": "investigation.CBP-034-01.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/025_custodian_files_source_export.md to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-034-01.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_email_families/037_email_families_source_export.json.", "id": "investigation.CBP-034-01.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-034-01 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is the current observation does not meet the operative trigger.", "id": "decision.CBP-034-01.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-034-01 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-034-01.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-034-02 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_pleadings/002_pleadings_source_export.txt rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-034-02.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_orders/014_orders_source_export.xml for clawback deadline.", "id": "investigation.CBP-034-02.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/026_custodian_files_source_export.txt to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-034-02.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_email_families/038_email_families_source_export.xml.", "id": "investigation.CBP-034-02.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-034-02 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-034-02.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-034-02 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-034-02.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-034-03 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_pleadings/003_pleadings_source_export.eml rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-034-03.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_orders/015_orders_source_export.html for third-party subpoena deadline.", "id": "investigation.CBP-034-03.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/027_custodian_files_source_export.eml to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-034-03.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_email_families/039_email_families_source_export.html.", "id": "investigation.CBP-034-03.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-034-03 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is the operational record relies on a superseded control revision.", "id": "decision.CBP-034-03.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-034-03 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-034-03.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-034-04 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_pleadings/004_pleadings_source_export.csv rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-034-04.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_orders/016_orders_source_export.pdf for custodian omission.", "id": "investigation.CBP-034-04.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/028_custodian_files_source_export.csv to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-034-04.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_email_families/040_email_families_source_export.pdf.", "id": "investigation.CBP-034-04.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-034-04 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key.", "id": "decision.CBP-034-04.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-034-04 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-034-04.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-034-05 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_pleadings/005_pleadings_source_export.json rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-034-05.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/017_requests_responses_source_export.md for common-interest support gap.", "id": "investigation.CBP-034-05.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/029_custodian_files_source_export.json to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-034-05.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/041_chat_exports_source_export.md.", "id": "investigation.CBP-034-05.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-034-05 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-034-05.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-034-05 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-034-05.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-034-06 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_pleadings/006_pleadings_source_export.xml rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-034-06.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/018_requests_responses_source_export.txt for expert draft segregation.", "id": "investigation.CBP-034-06.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/030_custodian_files_source_export.xml to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-034-06.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/042_chat_exports_source_export.txt.", "id": "investigation.CBP-034-06.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-034-06 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-034-06.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-034-06 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-034-06.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-034-07 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_pleadings/007_pleadings_source_export.html rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-034-07.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/019_requests_responses_source_export.eml for meet-and-confer commitment.", "id": "investigation.CBP-034-07.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/031_custodian_files_source_export.html to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-034-07.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/043_chat_exports_source_export.eml.", "id": "investigation.CBP-034-07.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-034-07 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-034-07.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-034-07 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-034-07.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-034-08 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_pleadings/008_pleadings_source_export.pdf rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-034-08.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/020_requests_responses_source_export.csv for privilege-log description defect.", "id": "investigation.CBP-034-08.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/032_custodian_files_source_export.pdf to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-034-08.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/044_chat_exports_source_export.csv.", "id": "investigation.CBP-034-08.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-034-08 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-034-08.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-034-08 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-034-08.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-034-09 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_orders/009_orders_source_export.md rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-034-09.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/021_requests_responses_source_export.json for deposition exhibit omission.", "id": "investigation.CBP-034-09.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_email_families/033_email_families_source_export.md to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-034-09.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/045_chat_exports_source_export.json.", "id": "investigation.CBP-034-09.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-034-09 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-034-09.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-034-09 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-034-09.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-034-10 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_orders/010_orders_source_export.txt rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-034-10.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/022_requests_responses_source_export.xml for Bates-range overlap.", "id": "investigation.CBP-034-10.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_email_families/034_email_families_source_export.txt to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-034-10.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/046_chat_exports_source_export.xml.", "id": "investigation.CBP-034-10.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-034-10 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-034-10.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-034-10 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-034-10.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-034-11 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_orders/011_orders_source_export.eml rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-034-11.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/023_requests_responses_source_export.html for email-family separation.", "id": "investigation.CBP-034-11.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_email_families/035_email_families_source_export.eml to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-034-11.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/047_chat_exports_source_export.html.", "id": "investigation.CBP-034-11.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-034-11 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is the operational record relies on a superseded control revision.", "id": "decision.CBP-034-11.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-034-11 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-034-11.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-034-12 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_orders/012_orders_source_export.csv rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-034-12.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/024_requests_responses_source_export.pdf for request-response mismatch.", "id": "investigation.CBP-034-12.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_email_families/036_email_families_source_export.csv to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-034-12.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/048_chat_exports_source_export.pdf.", "id": "investigation.CBP-034-12.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-034-12 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key.", "id": "decision.CBP-034-12.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-034-12 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-034-12.register"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Write the exact selected option, supported action population, evidence-hold population, facts, owners, deadlines, and citations.", "id": "state.exact_decision"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create one exact register row per portfolio key with no extra, missing, or modified row.", "id": "state.exact_register"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Leave only the three approved deliverables and perform no extra state-changing write.", "id": "state.write_scope_containment"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Read back decision.json, matter-register.json, and advice.md after their final writes.", "id": "state.postwrite_readback"}, {"category": "answer", "description": "Explain the selected recommendation, supported actions, holds, alternatives, and limitations with exact source anchors.", "id": "answer.decision_note"}], "decision_options": [{"approach": "Apply the exact identity, current-state, authority, and revision test. Register exact collection and expert-treatment decisions without bulk assumptions.", "id": "delta-products:scoped-evidence", "label": "Collect or segregate the supported gaps and escalate overdue third-party evidence."}, {"approach": "Use a plausible summary or one source without completing the controlling joins.", "id": "delta-products:shortcut", "label": "Treat every late-created file as missing discovery and every expert file as protected."}, {"approach": "Treat supported actions and genuinely ambiguous records as if they were equally unresolved.", "id": "delta-products:blanket-hold", "label": "Freeze the entire matter population"}], "evaluation_narrative": {"authority": "Requests, expert-discovery rules, and subpoena deadlines apply to exact files and custodians.", "observation": "Reconcile design-history versions, supplier custodians, collection dates, expert status, and subpoena returns.", "question": "What must Delta collect or segregate before the product-liability production is complete?", "register_action": "Register exact collection and expert-treatment decisions without bulk assumptions."}, "gates": ["all_required_evidence_precedes_first_write", "decision_criteria_complete", "register_state_exact", "write_scope_contained", "all_outputs_verified_by_readback"], "metadata_checks": 7, "metric": "weighted_criteria_score", "minimum_tool_calls": 82, "required_deliverables": ["decision.json", "matter-register.json", "advice.md"], "required_document_reads": 59, "type": "deterministic", "weights": {"advice": 0.15, "decision": 0.35, "investigation": 0.25, "state": 0.25}}, "task_id": "cb100-034-delta-products", "task_name": "Delta product-liability collection audit", "world_id": "counselbench-filesystem-mcp-v3"}
+{"context_files": ["task_files/cb100-035-elm-river/01_pleadings/001_pleadings_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-035-elm-river/01_pleadings/002_pleadings_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-035-elm-river/01_pleadings/003_pleadings_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-035-elm-river/01_pleadings/004_pleadings_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-035-elm-river/01_pleadings/005_pleadings_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-035-elm-river/01_pleadings/006_pleadings_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-035-elm-river/01_pleadings/007_pleadings_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-035-elm-river/01_pleadings/008_pleadings_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-035-elm-river/02_orders/009_orders_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-035-elm-river/02_orders/010_orders_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-035-elm-river/02_orders/011_orders_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-035-elm-river/02_orders/012_orders_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-035-elm-river/02_orders/013_orders_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-035-elm-river/02_orders/014_orders_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-035-elm-river/02_orders/015_orders_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-035-elm-river/02_orders/016_orders_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-035-elm-river/03_requests_responses/017_requests_responses_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-035-elm-river/03_requests_responses/018_requests_responses_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-035-elm-river/03_requests_responses/019_requests_responses_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-035-elm-river/03_requests_responses/020_requests_responses_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-035-elm-river/03_requests_responses/021_requests_responses_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-035-elm-river/03_requests_responses/022_requests_responses_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-035-elm-river/03_requests_responses/023_requests_responses_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-035-elm-river/03_requests_responses/024_requests_responses_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-035-elm-river/04_custodian_files/025_custodian_files_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-035-elm-river/04_custodian_files/026_custodian_files_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-035-elm-river/04_custodian_files/027_custodian_files_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-035-elm-river/04_custodian_files/028_custodian_files_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-035-elm-river/04_custodian_files/029_custodian_files_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-035-elm-river/04_custodian_files/030_custodian_files_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-035-elm-river/04_custodian_files/031_custodian_files_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-035-elm-river/04_custodian_files/032_custodian_files_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-035-elm-river/05_email_families/033_email_families_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-035-elm-river/05_email_families/034_email_families_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-035-elm-river/05_email_families/035_email_families_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-035-elm-river/05_email_families/036_email_families_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-035-elm-river/05_email_families/037_email_families_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-035-elm-river/05_email_families/038_email_families_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-035-elm-river/05_email_families/039_email_families_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-035-elm-river/05_email_families/040_email_families_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-035-elm-river/06_chat_exports/041_chat_exports_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-035-elm-river/06_chat_exports/042_chat_exports_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-035-elm-river/06_chat_exports/043_chat_exports_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-035-elm-river/06_chat_exports/044_chat_exports_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-035-elm-river/06_chat_exports/045_chat_exports_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-035-elm-river/06_chat_exports/046_chat_exports_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-035-elm-river/06_chat_exports/047_chat_exports_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-035-elm-river/06_chat_exports/048_chat_exports_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-035-elm-river/07_privilege_material/049_privilege_material_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-035-elm-river/07_privilege_material/050_privilege_material_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-035-elm-river/07_privilege_material/051_privilege_material_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-035-elm-river/07_privilege_material/052_privilege_material_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-035-elm-river/07_privilege_material/053_privilege_material_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-035-elm-river/07_privilege_material/054_privilege_material_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-035-elm-river/07_privilege_material/055_privilege_material_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-035-elm-river/07_privilege_material/056_privilege_material_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-035-elm-river/08_production_logs/057_production_logs_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-035-elm-river/08_production_logs/058_production_logs_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-035-elm-river/08_production_logs/059_production_logs_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-035-elm-river/08_production_logs/060_production_logs_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-035-elm-river/08_production_logs/061_production_logs_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-035-elm-river/08_production_logs/062_production_logs_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-035-elm-river/08_production_logs/063_production_logs_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-035-elm-river/08_production_logs/064_production_logs_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-035-elm-river/09_depositions/065_depositions_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-035-elm-river/09_depositions/066_depositions_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-035-elm-river/09_depositions/067_depositions_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-035-elm-river/09_depositions/068_depositions_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-035-elm-river/09_depositions/069_depositions_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-035-elm-river/09_depositions/070_depositions_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-035-elm-river/09_depositions/071_depositions_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-035-elm-river/09_depositions/072_depositions_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-035-elm-river/10_expert_material/073_expert_material_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-035-elm-river/10_expert_material/074_expert_material_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-035-elm-river/10_expert_material/075_expert_material_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-035-elm-river/10_expert_material/076_expert_material_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-035-elm-river/10_expert_material/077_expert_material_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-035-elm-river/10_expert_material/078_expert_material_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-035-elm-river/10_expert_material/079_expert_material_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-035-elm-river/10_expert_material/080_expert_material_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-035-elm-river/11_third_party/081_third_party_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-035-elm-river/11_third_party/082_third_party_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-035-elm-river/11_third_party/083_third_party_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-035-elm-river/11_third_party/084_third_party_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-035-elm-river/11_third_party/085_third_party_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-035-elm-river/11_third_party/086_third_party_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-035-elm-river/11_third_party/087_third_party_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-035-elm-river/11_third_party/088_third_party_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-035-elm-river/12_case_management/089_case_management_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-035-elm-river/12_case_management/090_case_management_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-035-elm-river/12_case_management/091_case_management_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-035-elm-river/12_case_management/092_case_management_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-035-elm-river/12_case_management/093_case_management_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-035-elm-river/12_case_management/094_case_management_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-035-elm-river/12_case_management/095_case_management_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-035-elm-river/12_case_management/096_case_management_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-035-elm-river/12_case_management/097_elm_river_impact_population.xlsx"], "gold_output": {"advice_markdown": "# Decision note — Elm River trade-secret privilege audit\n\n## Recommendation\n\nWithhold or produce at document level and supplement incomplete families. The reconciled record supports 9 scoped actions and leaves 3 items on evidence hold.\n\nSelected option: `elm-river:scoped-evidence`.\n\n## Why this is the supported option\n\nJoin commissioning purpose, recipients, legal direction, attachment families, and privilege-log descriptions. Privilege depends on purpose and confidentiality; family completeness is a separate production control.\n\n## Supported actions\n\n### CBP-035-01 — collection-date inconsistency (low)\n\napproval must come from Leona Park under CB-LD-2705-R775; the effective approval record names Henry Cho under CB-LD-2705-E616. Identity resolves to ENT-035-1000, revision REV-2025.1 is current, and Isaac Romero is active with capacity 5.\n\nAction: Create privilege and family-cure rows with independent rationales. Owner: Isaac Romero; due 2026-09-18.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_pleadings/001_pleadings_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/02_orders/013_orders_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/025_custodian_files_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/05_email_families/037_email_families_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/12_case_management/097_elm_river_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-035-02 — protective-order designation error (medium)\n\nthe controlled population contains 156 records under CB-LD-2705-R874; the certification covers 127 records under CB-LD-2705-E674. Identity resolves to ENT-035-1001, revision REV-2025.2 is current, and Nadine Flores is active with capacity 3.\n\nAction: Create privilege and family-cure rows with independent rationales. Owner: Nadine Flores; due 2026-09-17.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_pleadings/002_pleadings_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/02_orders/014_orders_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/026_custodian_files_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/05_email_families/038_email_families_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/11_third_party/086_third_party_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/10_expert_material/074_expert_material_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/12_case_management/097_elm_river_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-035-03 — production gap (critical)\n\nthe permission is limited to District of Massachusetts under CB-LD-2705-R631; the matched activity occurred in Massachusetts under CB-LD-2705-E872. Identity resolves to ENT-035-1002, revision REV-2025.3 is current, and Rafael Okafor is active with capacity 4.\n\nAction: Create privilege and family-cure rows with independent rationales. Owner: Rafael Okafor; due 2026-09-16.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_pleadings/003_pleadings_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/02_orders/015_orders_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/027_custodian_files_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/05_email_families/039_email_families_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/08_production_logs/063_production_logs_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/10_expert_material/075_expert_material_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/12_case_management/097_elm_river_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-035-05 — clawback deadline (medium)\n\ndelivery must use notices-elm_river_robotics@example.test under CB-LD-2705-R636; the only matched receipt used archive-former_engineers_and_nacre_automation@example.test under CB-LD-2705-E131. Identity resolves to ENT-035-1004, revision REV-2025.5 is current, and Theo Laurent is active with capacity 1.\n\nAction: Create privilege and family-cure rows with independent rationales. Owner: Theo Laurent; due 2026-09-14.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_pleadings/005_pleadings_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/017_requests_responses_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/029_custodian_files_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/041_chat_exports_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/12_case_management/097_elm_river_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-035-06 — third-party subpoena deadline (medium)\n\nan open exception blocks completion under CB-LD-2705-R688; the current status is open and unresolved under CB-LD-2705-E346. Identity resolves to ENT-035-1005, revision REV-2025.6 is current, and Lena Varga is active with capacity 5.\n\nAction: Create privilege and family-cure rows with independent rationales. Owner: Lena Varga; due 2026-09-13.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_pleadings/006_pleadings_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/018_requests_responses_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/030_custodian_files_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/042_chat_exports_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/12_case_management/097_elm_river_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-035-08 — common-interest support gap (critical)\n\nthe controlling threshold is 12% under CB-LD-2705-R463; the independently calculated result is 16% under CB-LD-2705-E491. Identity resolves to ENT-035-1007, revision REV-2025.1 is current, and Sofia Bennett is active with capacity 1.\n\nAction: Create privilege and family-cure rows with independent rationales. Owner: Sofia Bennett; due 2026-09-11.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_pleadings/008_pleadings_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/020_requests_responses_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/032_custodian_files_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/044_chat_exports_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/12_case_management/097_elm_river_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-035-09 — expert draft segregation (critical)\n\napproval must come from Leona Park under CB-LD-2705-R362; the effective approval record names Caleb Hassan under CB-LD-2705-E274. Identity resolves to ENT-035-1008, revision REV-2025.2 is current, and Micah Sullivan is active with capacity 2.\n\nAction: Create privilege and family-cure rows with independent rationales. Owner: Micah Sullivan; due 2026-09-10.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/02_orders/009_orders_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/021_requests_responses_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/05_email_families/033_email_families_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/045_chat_exports_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/11_third_party/081_third_party_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/12_case_management/097_elm_river_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-035-11 — privilege-log description defect (high)\n\nthe permission is limited to District of Massachusetts under CB-LD-2705-R130; the matched activity occurred in Massachusetts under CB-LD-2705-E895. Identity resolves to ENT-035-1010, revision REV-2025.4 is current, and Caleb Hassan is active with capacity 1.\n\nAction: Create privilege and family-cure rows with independent rationales. Owner: Caleb Hassan; due 2026-09-17.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/02_orders/011_orders_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/023_requests_responses_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/05_email_families/035_email_families_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/047_chat_exports_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/08_production_logs/059_production_logs_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/12_case_management/095_case_management_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/12_case_management/097_elm_river_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-035-12 — deposition exhibit omission (high)\n\nthe operative cap is $7,042,000.00 under CB-LD-2705-R127; the matched ledger population totals $7,206,527.00 under CB-LD-2705-E948. Identity resolves to ENT-035-1011, revision REV-2025.5 is current, and Amara Patel is active with capacity 4.\n\nAction: Create privilege and family-cure rows with independent rationales. Owner: Amara Patel; due 2026-09-16.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/02_orders/012_orders_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/024_requests_responses_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/05_email_families/036_email_families_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/048_chat_exports_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/11_third_party/084_third_party_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/12_case_management/096_case_management_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/12_case_management/097_elm_river_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n## Evidence holds\n\n- **CBP-035-04 — legal-hold delivery gap**: the current observation does not meet the operative trigger. Next evidence: a current observation that satisfies the operative trigger. Sources: `/workspace/documents/01_pleadings/004_pleadings_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/02_orders/016_orders_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/028_custodian_files_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/05_email_families/040_email_families_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/11_third_party/088_third_party_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/12_case_management/097_elm_river_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-035-07 — custodian omission**: two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key. Next evidence: an approved immutable entity crosswalk. Sources: `/workspace/documents/01_pleadings/007_pleadings_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/019_requests_responses_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/031_custodian_files_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/043_chat_exports_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/12_case_management/097_elm_river_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-035-10 — meet-and-confer commitment**: the operational record relies on a superseded control revision. Next evidence: an operational record using the current effective revision. Sources: `/workspace/documents/02_orders/010_orders_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/022_requests_responses_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/05_email_families/034_email_families_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/046_chat_exports_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/12_case_management/097_elm_river_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n## Alternatives considered\n\n- `elm-river:shortcut` — Withhold every forensic report because counsel received a copy.: Use a plausible summary or one source without completing the controlling joins.\n- `elm-river:blanket-hold` — Freeze the entire matter population: Treat supported actions and genuinely ambiguous records as if they were equally unresolved.\n\n## Assumptions and limits\n\nThis decision is limited to cb100-035-elm-river, the supplied synthetic records, and the matter state as of 2026-09-19. Similar names, stale revisions, and pending authority are not treated as proof.\n", "decision": {"actions": [{"determination": "approval must come from Leona Park under CB-LD-2705-R775; the effective approval record names Henry Cho under CB-LD-2705-E616. Identity resolves to ENT-035-1000, revision REV-2025.1 is current, and Isaac Romero is active with capacity 5.", "due_date": "2026-09-18", "id": "ACT-CBP-035-01", "identity_id": "ENT-035-1000", "issue": "collection-date inconsistency", "owner": "Isaac Romero", "portfolio_key": "CBP-035-01", "recommended_action": "Create privilege and family-cure rows with independent rationales. Owner: Isaac Romero; due 2026-09-18.", "severity": "low", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_pleadings/001_pleadings_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/02_orders/013_orders_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/025_custodian_files_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/05_email_families/037_email_families_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_case_management/097_elm_river_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "the controlled population contains 156 records under CB-LD-2705-R874; the certification covers 127 records under CB-LD-2705-E674. Identity resolves to ENT-035-1001, revision REV-2025.2 is current, and Nadine Flores is active with capacity 3.", "due_date": "2026-09-17", "id": "ACT-CBP-035-02", "identity_id": "ENT-035-1001", "issue": "protective-order designation error", "owner": "Nadine Flores", "portfolio_key": "CBP-035-02", "recommended_action": "Create privilege and family-cure rows with independent rationales. Owner: Nadine Flores; due 2026-09-17.", "severity": "medium", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_pleadings/002_pleadings_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/02_orders/014_orders_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/026_custodian_files_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/05_email_families/038_email_families_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/11_third_party/086_third_party_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/10_expert_material/074_expert_material_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/12_case_management/097_elm_river_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "the permission is limited to District of Massachusetts under CB-LD-2705-R631; the matched activity occurred in Massachusetts under CB-LD-2705-E872. Identity resolves to ENT-035-1002, revision REV-2025.3 is current, and Rafael Okafor is active with capacity 4.", "due_date": "2026-09-16", "id": "ACT-CBP-035-03", "identity_id": "ENT-035-1002", "issue": "production gap", "owner": "Rafael Okafor", "portfolio_key": "CBP-035-03", "recommended_action": "Create privilege and family-cure rows with independent rationales. Owner: Rafael Okafor; due 2026-09-16.", "severity": "critical", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_pleadings/003_pleadings_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/02_orders/015_orders_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/027_custodian_files_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/05_email_families/039_email_families_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/08_production_logs/063_production_logs_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/10_expert_material/075_expert_material_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/12_case_management/097_elm_river_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "delivery must use notices-elm_river_robotics@example.test under CB-LD-2705-R636; the only matched receipt used archive-former_engineers_and_nacre_automation@example.test under CB-LD-2705-E131. Identity resolves to ENT-035-1004, revision REV-2025.5 is current, and Theo Laurent is active with capacity 1.", "due_date": "2026-09-14", "id": "ACT-CBP-035-05", "identity_id": "ENT-035-1004", "issue": "clawback deadline", "owner": "Theo Laurent", "portfolio_key": "CBP-035-05", "recommended_action": "Create privilege and family-cure rows with independent rationales. Owner: Theo Laurent; due 2026-09-14.", "severity": "medium", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_pleadings/005_pleadings_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/017_requests_responses_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/029_custodian_files_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/041_chat_exports_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/12_case_management/097_elm_river_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "an open exception blocks completion under CB-LD-2705-R688; the current status is open and unresolved under CB-LD-2705-E346. Identity resolves to ENT-035-1005, revision REV-2025.6 is current, and Lena Varga is active with capacity 5.", "due_date": "2026-09-13", "id": "ACT-CBP-035-06", "identity_id": "ENT-035-1005", "issue": "third-party subpoena deadline", "owner": "Lena Varga", "portfolio_key": "CBP-035-06", "recommended_action": "Create privilege and family-cure rows with independent rationales. Owner: Lena Varga; due 2026-09-13.", "severity": "medium", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_pleadings/006_pleadings_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/018_requests_responses_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/030_custodian_files_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/042_chat_exports_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/12_case_management/097_elm_river_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "the controlling threshold is 12% under CB-LD-2705-R463; the independently calculated result is 16% under CB-LD-2705-E491. Identity resolves to ENT-035-1007, revision REV-2025.1 is current, and Sofia Bennett is active with capacity 1.", "due_date": "2026-09-11", "id": "ACT-CBP-035-08", "identity_id": "ENT-035-1007", "issue": "common-interest support gap", "owner": "Sofia Bennett", "portfolio_key": "CBP-035-08", "recommended_action": "Create privilege and family-cure rows with independent rationales. Owner: Sofia Bennett; due 2026-09-11.", "severity": "critical", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_pleadings/008_pleadings_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/020_requests_responses_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/032_custodian_files_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/044_chat_exports_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/12_case_management/097_elm_river_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "approval must come from Leona Park under CB-LD-2705-R362; the effective approval record names Caleb Hassan under CB-LD-2705-E274. Identity resolves to ENT-035-1008, revision REV-2025.2 is current, and Micah Sullivan is active with capacity 2.", "due_date": "2026-09-10", "id": "ACT-CBP-035-09", "identity_id": "ENT-035-1008", "issue": "expert draft segregation", "owner": "Micah Sullivan", "portfolio_key": "CBP-035-09", "recommended_action": "Create privilege and family-cure rows with independent rationales. Owner: Micah Sullivan; due 2026-09-10.", "severity": "critical", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_orders/009_orders_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/021_requests_responses_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/05_email_families/033_email_families_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/045_chat_exports_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/11_third_party/081_third_party_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/12_case_management/097_elm_river_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "the permission is limited to District of Massachusetts under CB-LD-2705-R130; the matched activity occurred in Massachusetts under CB-LD-2705-E895. Identity resolves to ENT-035-1010, revision REV-2025.4 is current, and Caleb Hassan is active with capacity 1.", "due_date": "2026-09-17", "id": "ACT-CBP-035-11", "identity_id": "ENT-035-1010", "issue": "privilege-log description defect", "owner": "Caleb Hassan", "portfolio_key": "CBP-035-11", "recommended_action": "Create privilege and family-cure rows with independent rationales. Owner: Caleb Hassan; due 2026-09-17.", "severity": "high", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_orders/011_orders_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/023_requests_responses_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/05_email_families/035_email_families_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/047_chat_exports_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/08_production_logs/059_production_logs_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/12_case_management/095_case_management_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_case_management/097_elm_river_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "the operative cap is $7,042,000.00 under CB-LD-2705-R127; the matched ledger population totals $7,206,527.00 under CB-LD-2705-E948. Identity resolves to ENT-035-1011, revision REV-2025.5 is current, and Amara Patel is active with capacity 4.", "due_date": "2026-09-16", "id": "ACT-CBP-035-12", "identity_id": "ENT-035-1011", "issue": "deposition exhibit omission", "owner": "Amara Patel", "portfolio_key": "CBP-035-12", "recommended_action": "Create privilege and family-cure rows with independent rationales. Owner: Amara Patel; due 2026-09-16.", "severity": "high", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_orders/012_orders_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/024_requests_responses_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/05_email_families/036_email_families_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/048_chat_exports_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/11_third_party/084_third_party_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/12_case_management/096_case_management_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_case_management/097_elm_river_impact_population.xlsx"]}], "as_of": "2026-09-19", "decision": {"alternatives_considered": ["elm-river:shortcut", "elm-river:blanket-hold"], "question": "Which Elm River reports are privileged, which are ordinary-course, and what family gaps require cure?", "rationale": "The four-part causal test supports 9 scoped actions and leaves 3 records on evidence hold. Privilege depends on purpose and confidentiality; family completeness is a separate production control.", "recommendation": "Withhold or produce at document level and supplement incomplete families.", "selected_option_id": "elm-river:scoped-evidence"}, "holds": [{"id": "HOLD-CBP-035-04", "issue": "legal-hold delivery gap", "portfolio_key": "CBP-035-04", "reason": "the current observation does not meet the operative trigger", "required_next_evidence": "a current observation that satisfies the operative trigger", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_pleadings/004_pleadings_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/02_orders/016_orders_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/028_custodian_files_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/05_email_families/040_email_families_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/11_third_party/088_third_party_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_case_management/097_elm_river_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-035-07", "issue": "custodian omission", "portfolio_key": "CBP-035-07", "reason": "two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key", "required_next_evidence": "an approved immutable entity crosswalk", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_pleadings/007_pleadings_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/019_requests_responses_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/031_custodian_files_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/043_chat_exports_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/12_case_management/097_elm_river_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-035-10", "issue": "meet-and-confer commitment", "portfolio_key": "CBP-035-10", "reason": "the operational record relies on a superseded control revision", "required_next_evidence": "an operational record using the current effective revision", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_orders/010_orders_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/022_requests_responses_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/05_email_families/034_email_families_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/046_chat_exports_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_case_management/097_elm_river_impact_population.xlsx"]}], "matter_number": "CB-LD-2705", "prepared_for": "Elm River Robotics", "schema_version": "counselbench.decision.v3", "task_id": "cb100-035-elm-river"}, "matter_register": {"matter_number": "CB-LD-2705", "rows": [{"decision_option_id": "elm-river:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-18", "issue": "collection-date inconsistency", "matter_number": "CB-LD-2705", "owner": "Isaac Romero", "portfolio_key": "CBP-035-01", "row_id": "REG-CBP-035-01", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_pleadings/001_pleadings_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/02_orders/013_orders_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/025_custodian_files_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/05_email_families/037_email_families_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_case_management/097_elm_river_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "elm-river:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-17", "issue": "protective-order designation error", "matter_number": "CB-LD-2705", "owner": "Nadine Flores", "portfolio_key": "CBP-035-02", "row_id": "REG-CBP-035-02", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_pleadings/002_pleadings_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/02_orders/014_orders_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/026_custodian_files_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/05_email_families/038_email_families_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/11_third_party/086_third_party_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/10_expert_material/074_expert_material_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/12_case_management/097_elm_river_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "elm-river:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-16", "issue": "production gap", "matter_number": "CB-LD-2705", "owner": "Rafael Okafor", "portfolio_key": "CBP-035-03", "row_id": "REG-CBP-035-03", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_pleadings/003_pleadings_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/02_orders/015_orders_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/027_custodian_files_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/05_email_families/039_email_families_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/08_production_logs/063_production_logs_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/10_expert_material/075_expert_material_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/12_case_management/097_elm_river_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "elm-river:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "the current observation does not meet the operative trigger", "issue": "legal-hold delivery gap", "matter_number": "CB-LD-2705", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-035-04", "row_id": "REG-CBP-035-04", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_pleadings/004_pleadings_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/02_orders/016_orders_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/028_custodian_files_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/05_email_families/040_email_families_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/11_third_party/088_third_party_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_case_management/097_elm_river_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "elm-river:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-14", "issue": "clawback deadline", "matter_number": "CB-LD-2705", "owner": "Theo Laurent", "portfolio_key": "CBP-035-05", "row_id": "REG-CBP-035-05", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_pleadings/005_pleadings_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/017_requests_responses_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/029_custodian_files_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/041_chat_exports_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/12_case_management/097_elm_river_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "elm-river:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-13", "issue": "third-party subpoena deadline", "matter_number": "CB-LD-2705", "owner": "Lena Varga", "portfolio_key": "CBP-035-06", "row_id": "REG-CBP-035-06", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_pleadings/006_pleadings_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/018_requests_responses_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/030_custodian_files_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/042_chat_exports_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/12_case_management/097_elm_river_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "elm-river:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key", "issue": "custodian omission", "matter_number": "CB-LD-2705", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-035-07", "row_id": "REG-CBP-035-07", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_pleadings/007_pleadings_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/019_requests_responses_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/031_custodian_files_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/043_chat_exports_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/12_case_management/097_elm_river_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "elm-river:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-11", "issue": "common-interest support gap", "matter_number": "CB-LD-2705", "owner": "Sofia Bennett", "portfolio_key": "CBP-035-08", "row_id": "REG-CBP-035-08", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_pleadings/008_pleadings_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/020_requests_responses_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/032_custodian_files_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/044_chat_exports_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/12_case_management/097_elm_river_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "elm-river:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-10", "issue": "expert draft segregation", "matter_number": "CB-LD-2705", "owner": "Micah Sullivan", "portfolio_key": "CBP-035-09", "row_id": "REG-CBP-035-09", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_orders/009_orders_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/021_requests_responses_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/05_email_families/033_email_families_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/045_chat_exports_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/11_third_party/081_third_party_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/12_case_management/097_elm_river_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "elm-river:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "the operational record relies on a superseded control revision", "issue": "meet-and-confer commitment", "matter_number": "CB-LD-2705", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-035-10", "row_id": "REG-CBP-035-10", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_orders/010_orders_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/022_requests_responses_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/05_email_families/034_email_families_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/046_chat_exports_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_case_management/097_elm_river_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "elm-river:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-17", "issue": "privilege-log description defect", "matter_number": "CB-LD-2705", "owner": "Caleb Hassan", "portfolio_key": "CBP-035-11", "row_id": "REG-CBP-035-11", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_orders/011_orders_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/023_requests_responses_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/05_email_families/035_email_families_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/047_chat_exports_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/08_production_logs/059_production_logs_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/12_case_management/095_case_management_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_case_management/097_elm_river_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "elm-river:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-16", "issue": "deposition exhibit omission", "matter_number": "CB-LD-2705", "owner": "Amara Patel", "portfolio_key": "CBP-035-12", "row_id": "REG-CBP-035-12", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_orders/012_orders_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/024_requests_responses_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/05_email_families/036_email_families_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/048_chat_exports_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/11_third_party/084_third_party_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/12_case_management/096_case_management_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_case_management/097_elm_river_impact_population.xlsx"]}], "schema_version": "counselbench.matter-register.v3", "task_id": "cb100-035-elm-river"}}, "metadata": {"benchmark": "CounselBench-100", "code_license": "Apache-2.0", "data_license": "CC-BY-4.0", "deadline": "2026-09-19", "document_count": 97, "evidence_holds": 3, "jurisdiction": "Massachusetts", "matter_number": "CB-LD-2705", "mcp_commit": "9a96ea6e5913736f92b88345bf51caeaaa8e719f", "mcp_package": "@modelcontextprotocol/server-filesystem@2026.7.10", "practice_area": "litigation-discovery", "reference_tool_calls": 79, "required_evidence_reads": 60, "supported_actions": 9, "synthetic": true, "venue": "District of Massachusetts", "version": "3.1.0"}, "prompt": "We inherited inconsistent versions of this matter and need to settle the operating position. Which Elm River reports are privileged, which are ordinary-course, and what family gaps require cure? The production mixes counsel-directed forensic reports with ordinary-course analyses and omits attachments from several high-value email families. The team needs the call by 2026-09-19. I need the recommendation and the real blockers recorded before the team acts.", "rubric": {"criteria": [{"category": "investigation", "description": "Inventory the production and use targeted searches to locate records across native formats.", "id": "investigation.discover_production"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Complete every task-specific identity, authority, operations, and approval read before the first state transition.", "id": "investigation.read_before_write"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Inspect designated source metadata before relying on those records.", "id": "investigation.custody_before_write"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "Select the supported option 'elm-river:scoped-evidence' after applying the four-part test.", "id": "decision.selected_option"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "Identify both rejected approaches and explain why a one-source shortcut and a blanket hold are wrong.", "id": "decision.alternatives"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-035-01 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_pleadings/001_pleadings_source_export.md rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-035-01.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_orders/013_orders_source_export.json for collection-date inconsistency.", "id": "investigation.CBP-035-01.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/025_custodian_files_source_export.md to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-035-01.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_email_families/037_email_families_source_export.json.", "id": "investigation.CBP-035-01.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-035-01 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-035-01.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-035-01 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-035-01.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-035-02 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_pleadings/002_pleadings_source_export.txt rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-035-02.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_orders/014_orders_source_export.xml for protective-order designation error.", "id": "investigation.CBP-035-02.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/026_custodian_files_source_export.txt to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-035-02.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_email_families/038_email_families_source_export.xml.", "id": "investigation.CBP-035-02.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-035-02 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-035-02.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-035-02 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-035-02.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-035-03 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_pleadings/003_pleadings_source_export.eml rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-035-03.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_orders/015_orders_source_export.html for production gap.", "id": "investigation.CBP-035-03.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/027_custodian_files_source_export.eml to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-035-03.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_email_families/039_email_families_source_export.html.", "id": "investigation.CBP-035-03.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-035-03 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-035-03.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-035-03 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-035-03.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-035-04 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_pleadings/004_pleadings_source_export.csv rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-035-04.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_orders/016_orders_source_export.pdf for legal-hold delivery gap.", "id": "investigation.CBP-035-04.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/028_custodian_files_source_export.csv to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-035-04.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_email_families/040_email_families_source_export.pdf.", "id": "investigation.CBP-035-04.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-035-04 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is the current observation does not meet the operative trigger.", "id": "decision.CBP-035-04.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-035-04 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-035-04.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-035-05 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_pleadings/005_pleadings_source_export.json rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-035-05.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/017_requests_responses_source_export.md for clawback deadline.", "id": "investigation.CBP-035-05.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/029_custodian_files_source_export.json to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-035-05.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/041_chat_exports_source_export.md.", "id": "investigation.CBP-035-05.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-035-05 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-035-05.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-035-05 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-035-05.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-035-06 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_pleadings/006_pleadings_source_export.xml rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-035-06.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/018_requests_responses_source_export.txt for third-party subpoena deadline.", "id": "investigation.CBP-035-06.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/030_custodian_files_source_export.xml to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-035-06.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/042_chat_exports_source_export.txt.", "id": "investigation.CBP-035-06.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-035-06 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-035-06.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-035-06 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-035-06.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-035-07 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_pleadings/007_pleadings_source_export.html rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-035-07.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/019_requests_responses_source_export.eml for custodian omission.", "id": "investigation.CBP-035-07.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/031_custodian_files_source_export.html to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-035-07.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/043_chat_exports_source_export.eml.", "id": "investigation.CBP-035-07.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-035-07 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key.", "id": "decision.CBP-035-07.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-035-07 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-035-07.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-035-08 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_pleadings/008_pleadings_source_export.pdf rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-035-08.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/020_requests_responses_source_export.csv for common-interest support gap.", "id": "investigation.CBP-035-08.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/032_custodian_files_source_export.pdf to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-035-08.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/044_chat_exports_source_export.csv.", "id": "investigation.CBP-035-08.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-035-08 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-035-08.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-035-08 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-035-08.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-035-09 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_orders/009_orders_source_export.md rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-035-09.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/021_requests_responses_source_export.json for expert draft segregation.", "id": "investigation.CBP-035-09.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_email_families/033_email_families_source_export.md to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-035-09.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/045_chat_exports_source_export.json.", "id": "investigation.CBP-035-09.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-035-09 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-035-09.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-035-09 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-035-09.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-035-10 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_orders/010_orders_source_export.txt rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-035-10.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/022_requests_responses_source_export.xml for meet-and-confer commitment.", "id": "investigation.CBP-035-10.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_email_families/034_email_families_source_export.txt to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-035-10.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/046_chat_exports_source_export.xml.", "id": "investigation.CBP-035-10.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-035-10 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is the operational record relies on a superseded control revision.", "id": "decision.CBP-035-10.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-035-10 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-035-10.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-035-11 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_orders/011_orders_source_export.eml rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-035-11.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/023_requests_responses_source_export.html for privilege-log description defect.", "id": "investigation.CBP-035-11.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_email_families/035_email_families_source_export.eml to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-035-11.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/047_chat_exports_source_export.html.", "id": "investigation.CBP-035-11.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-035-11 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-035-11.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-035-11 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-035-11.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-035-12 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_orders/012_orders_source_export.csv rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-035-12.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/024_requests_responses_source_export.pdf for deposition exhibit omission.", "id": "investigation.CBP-035-12.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_email_families/036_email_families_source_export.csv to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-035-12.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/048_chat_exports_source_export.pdf.", "id": "investigation.CBP-035-12.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-035-12 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-035-12.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-035-12 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-035-12.register"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Write the exact selected option, supported action population, evidence-hold population, facts, owners, deadlines, and citations.", "id": "state.exact_decision"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create one exact register row per portfolio key with no extra, missing, or modified row.", "id": "state.exact_register"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Leave only the three approved deliverables and perform no extra state-changing write.", "id": "state.write_scope_containment"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Read back decision.json, matter-register.json, and advice.md after their final writes.", "id": "state.postwrite_readback"}, {"category": "answer", "description": "Explain the selected recommendation, supported actions, holds, alternatives, and limitations with exact source anchors.", "id": "answer.decision_note"}], "decision_options": [{"approach": "Use a plausible summary or one source without completing the controlling joins.", "id": "elm-river:shortcut", "label": "Withhold every forensic report because counsel received a copy."}, {"approach": "Treat supported actions and genuinely ambiguous records as if they were equally unresolved.", "id": "elm-river:blanket-hold", "label": "Freeze the entire matter population"}, {"approach": "Apply the exact identity, current-state, authority, and revision test. Create privilege and family-cure rows with independent rationales.", "id": "elm-river:scoped-evidence", "label": "Withhold or produce at document level and supplement incomplete families."}], "evaluation_narrative": {"authority": "Privilege depends on purpose and confidentiality; family completeness is a separate production control.", "observation": "Join commissioning purpose, recipients, legal direction, attachment families, and privilege-log descriptions.", "question": "Which Elm River reports are privileged, which are ordinary-course, and what family gaps require cure?", "register_action": "Create privilege and family-cure rows with independent rationales."}, "gates": ["all_required_evidence_precedes_first_write", "decision_criteria_complete", "register_state_exact", "write_scope_contained", "all_outputs_verified_by_readback"], "metadata_checks": 7, "metric": "weighted_criteria_score", "minimum_tool_calls": 79, "required_deliverables": ["decision.json", "matter-register.json", "advice.md"], "required_document_reads": 60, "type": "deterministic", "weights": {"advice": 0.15, "decision": 0.35, "investigation": 0.25, "state": 0.25}}, "task_id": "cb100-035-elm-river", "task_name": "Elm River trade-secret privilege audit", "world_id": "counselbench-filesystem-mcp-v3"}
+{"context_files": ["task_files/cb100-036-federal-basin/01_pleadings/001_pleadings_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-036-federal-basin/01_pleadings/002_pleadings_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-036-federal-basin/01_pleadings/003_pleadings_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-036-federal-basin/01_pleadings/004_pleadings_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-036-federal-basin/01_pleadings/005_pleadings_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-036-federal-basin/01_pleadings/006_pleadings_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-036-federal-basin/01_pleadings/007_pleadings_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-036-federal-basin/01_pleadings/008_pleadings_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-036-federal-basin/02_orders/009_orders_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-036-federal-basin/02_orders/010_orders_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-036-federal-basin/02_orders/011_orders_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-036-federal-basin/02_orders/012_orders_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-036-federal-basin/02_orders/013_orders_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-036-federal-basin/02_orders/014_orders_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-036-federal-basin/02_orders/015_orders_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-036-federal-basin/02_orders/016_orders_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-036-federal-basin/03_requests_responses/017_requests_responses_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-036-federal-basin/03_requests_responses/018_requests_responses_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-036-federal-basin/03_requests_responses/019_requests_responses_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-036-federal-basin/03_requests_responses/020_requests_responses_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-036-federal-basin/03_requests_responses/021_requests_responses_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-036-federal-basin/03_requests_responses/022_requests_responses_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-036-federal-basin/03_requests_responses/023_requests_responses_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-036-federal-basin/03_requests_responses/024_requests_responses_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-036-federal-basin/04_custodian_files/025_custodian_files_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-036-federal-basin/04_custodian_files/026_custodian_files_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-036-federal-basin/04_custodian_files/027_custodian_files_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-036-federal-basin/04_custodian_files/028_custodian_files_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-036-federal-basin/04_custodian_files/029_custodian_files_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-036-federal-basin/04_custodian_files/030_custodian_files_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-036-federal-basin/04_custodian_files/031_custodian_files_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-036-federal-basin/04_custodian_files/032_custodian_files_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-036-federal-basin/05_email_families/033_email_families_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-036-federal-basin/05_email_families/034_email_families_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-036-federal-basin/05_email_families/035_email_families_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-036-federal-basin/05_email_families/036_email_families_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-036-federal-basin/05_email_families/037_email_families_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-036-federal-basin/05_email_families/038_email_families_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-036-federal-basin/05_email_families/039_email_families_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-036-federal-basin/05_email_families/040_email_families_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-036-federal-basin/06_chat_exports/041_chat_exports_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-036-federal-basin/06_chat_exports/042_chat_exports_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-036-federal-basin/06_chat_exports/043_chat_exports_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-036-federal-basin/06_chat_exports/044_chat_exports_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-036-federal-basin/06_chat_exports/045_chat_exports_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-036-federal-basin/06_chat_exports/046_chat_exports_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-036-federal-basin/06_chat_exports/047_chat_exports_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-036-federal-basin/06_chat_exports/048_chat_exports_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-036-federal-basin/07_privilege_material/049_privilege_material_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-036-federal-basin/07_privilege_material/050_privilege_material_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-036-federal-basin/07_privilege_material/051_privilege_material_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-036-federal-basin/07_privilege_material/052_privilege_material_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-036-federal-basin/07_privilege_material/053_privilege_material_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-036-federal-basin/07_privilege_material/054_privilege_material_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-036-federal-basin/07_privilege_material/055_privilege_material_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-036-federal-basin/07_privilege_material/056_privilege_material_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-036-federal-basin/08_production_logs/057_production_logs_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-036-federal-basin/08_production_logs/058_production_logs_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-036-federal-basin/08_production_logs/059_production_logs_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-036-federal-basin/08_production_logs/060_production_logs_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-036-federal-basin/08_production_logs/061_production_logs_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-036-federal-basin/08_production_logs/062_production_logs_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-036-federal-basin/08_production_logs/063_production_logs_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-036-federal-basin/08_production_logs/064_production_logs_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-036-federal-basin/09_depositions/065_depositions_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-036-federal-basin/09_depositions/066_depositions_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-036-federal-basin/09_depositions/067_depositions_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-036-federal-basin/09_depositions/068_depositions_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-036-federal-basin/09_depositions/069_depositions_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-036-federal-basin/09_depositions/070_depositions_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-036-federal-basin/09_depositions/071_depositions_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-036-federal-basin/09_depositions/072_depositions_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-036-federal-basin/10_expert_material/073_expert_material_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-036-federal-basin/10_expert_material/074_expert_material_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-036-federal-basin/10_expert_material/075_expert_material_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-036-federal-basin/10_expert_material/076_expert_material_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-036-federal-basin/10_expert_material/077_expert_material_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-036-federal-basin/10_expert_material/078_expert_material_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-036-federal-basin/10_expert_material/079_expert_material_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-036-federal-basin/10_expert_material/080_expert_material_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-036-federal-basin/11_third_party/081_third_party_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-036-federal-basin/11_third_party/082_third_party_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-036-federal-basin/11_third_party/083_third_party_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-036-federal-basin/11_third_party/084_third_party_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-036-federal-basin/11_third_party/085_third_party_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-036-federal-basin/11_third_party/086_third_party_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-036-federal-basin/11_third_party/087_third_party_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-036-federal-basin/11_third_party/088_third_party_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-036-federal-basin/12_case_management/089_case_management_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-036-federal-basin/12_case_management/090_case_management_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-036-federal-basin/12_case_management/091_case_management_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-036-federal-basin/12_case_management/092_case_management_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-036-federal-basin/12_case_management/093_case_management_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-036-federal-basin/12_case_management/094_case_management_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-036-federal-basin/12_case_management/095_case_management_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-036-federal-basin/12_case_management/096_case_management_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-036-federal-basin/12_case_management/097_federal_basin_impact_population.xlsx"], "gold_output": {"advice_markdown": "# Decision note — Federal Basin royalty dispute production\n\n## Recommendation\n\nSupplement mapped gaps and certify only the bounded, reconciled population. The reconciled record supports 6 scoped actions and leaves 6 items on evidence hold.\n\nSelected option: `federal-basin:scoped-evidence`.\n\n## Why this is the supported option\n\nMap accounting entries, title opinions, and executive messages to exact requests and date ranges. The request definitions and court-ordered certification language govern the population.\n\n## Supported actions\n\n### CBP-036-01 — email-family separation (high)\n\nan open exception blocks completion under CB-LD-2706-R485; the current status is open and unresolved under CB-LD-2706-E599. Identity resolves to ENT-036-1000, revision REV-2026.1 is current, and Willa Novak is active with capacity 1.\n\nAction: Create request-level exception rows and preserve disputed privilege items separately. Owner: Willa Novak; due 2026-09-22.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_pleadings/001_pleadings_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/02_orders/013_orders_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/025_custodian_files_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/05_email_families/037_email_families_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/11_third_party/085_third_party_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/08_production_logs/061_production_logs_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/12_case_management/097_federal_basin_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-036-02 — request-response mismatch (medium)\n\ncompletion is required by 2025-05-12 under CB-LD-2706-R586; the current event record shows completion on 2025-06-13 under CB-LD-2706-E234. Identity resolves to ENT-036-1001, revision REV-2026.2 is current, and Owen Delgado is active with capacity 1.\n\nAction: Create request-level exception rows and preserve disputed privilege items separately. Owner: Owen Delgado; due 2026-09-21.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_pleadings/002_pleadings_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/02_orders/014_orders_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/026_custodian_files_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/05_email_families/038_email_families_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/08_production_logs/062_production_logs_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/12_case_management/097_federal_basin_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-036-03 — metadata field loss (critical)\n\nthe controlling threshold is 12% under CB-LD-2706-R419; the independently calculated result is 16% under CB-LD-2706-E118. Identity resolves to ENT-036-1002, revision REV-2026.3 is current, and Priya Raman is active with capacity 1.\n\nAction: Create request-level exception rows and preserve disputed privilege items separately. Owner: Priya Raman; due 2026-09-20.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_pleadings/003_pleadings_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/02_orders/015_orders_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/027_custodian_files_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/05_email_families/039_email_families_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/11_third_party/087_third_party_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/08_production_logs/063_production_logs_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/12_case_management/097_federal_basin_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-036-04 — collection-date inconsistency (medium)\n\napproval must come from Farah Ibrahim under CB-LD-2706-R109; the effective approval record names Caleb Hassan under CB-LD-2706-E365. Identity resolves to ENT-036-1003, revision REV-2026.4 is current, and Isaac Romero is active with capacity 2.\n\nAction: Create request-level exception rows and preserve disputed privilege items separately. Owner: Isaac Romero; due 2026-09-19.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_pleadings/004_pleadings_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/02_orders/016_orders_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/028_custodian_files_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/05_email_families/040_email_families_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/12_case_management/097_federal_basin_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-036-06 — production gap (medium)\n\nthe permission is limited to Western District of Oklahoma under CB-LD-2706-R575; the matched activity occurred in Oklahoma under CB-LD-2706-E763. Identity resolves to ENT-036-1005, revision REV-2026.6 is current, and Rafael Okafor is active with capacity 3.\n\nAction: Create request-level exception rows and preserve disputed privilege items separately. Owner: Rafael Okafor; due 2026-09-17.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_pleadings/006_pleadings_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/018_requests_responses_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/030_custodian_files_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/042_chat_exports_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/12_case_management/090_case_management_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/07_privilege_material/054_privilege_material_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/12_case_management/097_federal_basin_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-036-11 — common-interest support gap (medium)\n\nthe controlling threshold is 3% under CB-LD-2706-R328; the independently calculated result is 5% under CB-LD-2706-E484. Identity resolves to ENT-036-1010, revision REV-2026.4 is current, and Sofia Bennett is active with capacity 1.\n\nAction: Create request-level exception rows and preserve disputed privilege items separately. Owner: Sofia Bennett; due 2026-09-21.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/02_orders/011_orders_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/023_requests_responses_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/05_email_families/035_email_families_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/047_chat_exports_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/12_case_management/097_federal_basin_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n## Evidence holds\n\n- **CBP-036-05 — protective-order designation error**: the operational record relies on a superseded control revision. Next evidence: an operational record using the current effective revision. Sources: `/workspace/documents/01_pleadings/005_pleadings_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/017_requests_responses_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/029_custodian_files_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/041_chat_exports_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/10_expert_material/077_expert_material_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/07_privilege_material/053_privilege_material_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/12_case_management/097_federal_basin_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-036-07 — legal-hold delivery gap**: the current observation does not meet the operative trigger. Next evidence: a current observation that satisfies the operative trigger. Sources: `/workspace/documents/01_pleadings/007_pleadings_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/019_requests_responses_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/031_custodian_files_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/043_chat_exports_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/12_case_management/097_federal_basin_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-036-08 — clawback deadline**: the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective. Next evidence: effective approval and an active owner with remaining capacity. Sources: `/workspace/documents/01_pleadings/008_pleadings_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/020_requests_responses_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/032_custodian_files_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/044_chat_exports_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/10_expert_material/080_expert_material_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/07_privilege_material/056_privilege_material_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/12_case_management/097_federal_basin_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-036-09 — third-party subpoena deadline**: the operational record relies on a superseded control revision. Next evidence: an operational record using the current effective revision. Sources: `/workspace/documents/02_orders/009_orders_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/021_requests_responses_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/05_email_families/033_email_families_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/045_chat_exports_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/12_case_management/097_federal_basin_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-036-10 — custodian omission**: two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key. Next evidence: an approved immutable entity crosswalk. Sources: `/workspace/documents/02_orders/010_orders_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/022_requests_responses_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/05_email_families/034_email_families_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/046_chat_exports_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/12_case_management/097_federal_basin_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-036-12 — expert draft segregation**: the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective. Next evidence: effective approval and an active owner with remaining capacity. Sources: `/workspace/documents/02_orders/012_orders_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/024_requests_responses_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/05_email_families/036_email_families_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/048_chat_exports_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/08_production_logs/060_production_logs_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/12_case_management/096_case_management_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/12_case_management/097_federal_basin_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n## Alternatives considered\n\n- `federal-basin:blanket-hold` — Freeze the entire matter population: Treat supported actions and genuinely ambiguous records as if they were equally unresolved.\n- `federal-basin:shortcut` — Use the accounting export count as the entire responsive population.: Use a plausible summary or one source without completing the controlling joins.\n\n## Assumptions and limits\n\nThis decision is limited to cb100-036-federal-basin, the supplied synthetic records, and the matter state as of 2026-09-23. Similar names, stale revisions, and pending authority are not treated as proof.\n", "decision": {"actions": [{"determination": "an open exception blocks completion under CB-LD-2706-R485; the current status is open and unresolved under CB-LD-2706-E599. Identity resolves to ENT-036-1000, revision REV-2026.1 is current, and Willa Novak is active with capacity 1.", "due_date": "2026-09-22", "id": "ACT-CBP-036-01", "identity_id": "ENT-036-1000", "issue": "email-family separation", "owner": "Willa Novak", "portfolio_key": "CBP-036-01", "recommended_action": "Create request-level exception rows and preserve disputed privilege items separately. Owner: Willa Novak; due 2026-09-22.", "severity": "high", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_pleadings/001_pleadings_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/02_orders/013_orders_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/025_custodian_files_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/05_email_families/037_email_families_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/11_third_party/085_third_party_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/08_production_logs/061_production_logs_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_case_management/097_federal_basin_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "completion is required by 2025-05-12 under CB-LD-2706-R586; the current event record shows completion on 2025-06-13 under CB-LD-2706-E234. Identity resolves to ENT-036-1001, revision REV-2026.2 is current, and Owen Delgado is active with capacity 1.", "due_date": "2026-09-21", "id": "ACT-CBP-036-02", "identity_id": "ENT-036-1001", "issue": "request-response mismatch", "owner": "Owen Delgado", "portfolio_key": "CBP-036-02", "recommended_action": "Create request-level exception rows and preserve disputed privilege items separately. Owner: Owen Delgado; due 2026-09-21.", "severity": "medium", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_pleadings/002_pleadings_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/02_orders/014_orders_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/026_custodian_files_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/05_email_families/038_email_families_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/08_production_logs/062_production_logs_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_case_management/097_federal_basin_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "the controlling threshold is 12% under CB-LD-2706-R419; the independently calculated result is 16% under CB-LD-2706-E118. Identity resolves to ENT-036-1002, revision REV-2026.3 is current, and Priya Raman is active with capacity 1.", "due_date": "2026-09-20", "id": "ACT-CBP-036-03", "identity_id": "ENT-036-1002", "issue": "metadata field loss", "owner": "Priya Raman", "portfolio_key": "CBP-036-03", "recommended_action": "Create request-level exception rows and preserve disputed privilege items separately. Owner: Priya Raman; due 2026-09-20.", "severity": "critical", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_pleadings/003_pleadings_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/02_orders/015_orders_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/027_custodian_files_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/05_email_families/039_email_families_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/11_third_party/087_third_party_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/08_production_logs/063_production_logs_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_case_management/097_federal_basin_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "approval must come from Farah Ibrahim under CB-LD-2706-R109; the effective approval record names Caleb Hassan under CB-LD-2706-E365. Identity resolves to ENT-036-1003, revision REV-2026.4 is current, and Isaac Romero is active with capacity 2.", "due_date": "2026-09-19", "id": "ACT-CBP-036-04", "identity_id": "ENT-036-1003", "issue": "collection-date inconsistency", "owner": "Isaac Romero", "portfolio_key": "CBP-036-04", "recommended_action": "Create request-level exception rows and preserve disputed privilege items separately. Owner: Isaac Romero; due 2026-09-19.", "severity": "medium", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_pleadings/004_pleadings_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/02_orders/016_orders_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/028_custodian_files_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/05_email_families/040_email_families_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_case_management/097_federal_basin_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "the permission is limited to Western District of Oklahoma under CB-LD-2706-R575; the matched activity occurred in Oklahoma under CB-LD-2706-E763. Identity resolves to ENT-036-1005, revision REV-2026.6 is current, and Rafael Okafor is active with capacity 3.", "due_date": "2026-09-17", "id": "ACT-CBP-036-06", "identity_id": "ENT-036-1005", "issue": "production gap", "owner": "Rafael Okafor", "portfolio_key": "CBP-036-06", "recommended_action": "Create request-level exception rows and preserve disputed privilege items separately. Owner: Rafael Okafor; due 2026-09-17.", "severity": "medium", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_pleadings/006_pleadings_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/018_requests_responses_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/030_custodian_files_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/042_chat_exports_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/12_case_management/090_case_management_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/07_privilege_material/054_privilege_material_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_case_management/097_federal_basin_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "the controlling threshold is 3% under CB-LD-2706-R328; the independently calculated result is 5% under CB-LD-2706-E484. Identity resolves to ENT-036-1010, revision REV-2026.4 is current, and Sofia Bennett is active with capacity 1.", "due_date": "2026-09-21", "id": "ACT-CBP-036-11", "identity_id": "ENT-036-1010", "issue": "common-interest support gap", "owner": "Sofia Bennett", "portfolio_key": "CBP-036-11", "recommended_action": "Create request-level exception rows and preserve disputed privilege items separately. Owner: Sofia Bennett; due 2026-09-21.", "severity": "medium", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_orders/011_orders_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/023_requests_responses_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/05_email_families/035_email_families_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/047_chat_exports_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_case_management/097_federal_basin_impact_population.xlsx"]}], "as_of": "2026-09-23", "decision": {"alternatives_considered": ["federal-basin:blanket-hold", "federal-basin:shortcut"], "question": "Can Federal Basin certify its royalty production against the document requests?", "rationale": "The four-part causal test supports 6 scoped actions and leaves 6 records on evidence hold. The request definitions and court-ordered certification language govern the population.", "recommendation": "Supplement mapped gaps and certify only the bounded, reconciled population.", "selected_option_id": "federal-basin:scoped-evidence"}, "holds": [{"id": "HOLD-CBP-036-05", "issue": "protective-order designation error", "portfolio_key": "CBP-036-05", "reason": "the operational record relies on a superseded control revision", "required_next_evidence": "an operational record using the current effective revision", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_pleadings/005_pleadings_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/017_requests_responses_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/029_custodian_files_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/041_chat_exports_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/10_expert_material/077_expert_material_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/07_privilege_material/053_privilege_material_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_case_management/097_federal_basin_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-036-07", "issue": "legal-hold delivery gap", "portfolio_key": "CBP-036-07", "reason": "the current observation does not meet the operative trigger", "required_next_evidence": "a current observation that satisfies the operative trigger", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_pleadings/007_pleadings_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/019_requests_responses_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/031_custodian_files_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/043_chat_exports_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/12_case_management/097_federal_basin_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-036-08", "issue": "clawback deadline", "portfolio_key": "CBP-036-08", "reason": "the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective", "required_next_evidence": "effective approval and an active owner with remaining capacity", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_pleadings/008_pleadings_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/020_requests_responses_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/032_custodian_files_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/044_chat_exports_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/10_expert_material/080_expert_material_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/07_privilege_material/056_privilege_material_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_case_management/097_federal_basin_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-036-09", "issue": "third-party subpoena deadline", "portfolio_key": "CBP-036-09", "reason": "the operational record relies on a superseded control revision", "required_next_evidence": "an operational record using the current effective revision", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_orders/009_orders_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/021_requests_responses_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/05_email_families/033_email_families_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/045_chat_exports_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_case_management/097_federal_basin_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-036-10", "issue": "custodian omission", "portfolio_key": "CBP-036-10", "reason": "two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key", "required_next_evidence": "an approved immutable entity crosswalk", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_orders/010_orders_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/022_requests_responses_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/05_email_families/034_email_families_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/046_chat_exports_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_case_management/097_federal_basin_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-036-12", "issue": "expert draft segregation", "portfolio_key": "CBP-036-12", "reason": "the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective", "required_next_evidence": "effective approval and an active owner with remaining capacity", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_orders/012_orders_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/024_requests_responses_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/05_email_families/036_email_families_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/048_chat_exports_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/08_production_logs/060_production_logs_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/12_case_management/096_case_management_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_case_management/097_federal_basin_impact_population.xlsx"]}], "matter_number": "CB-LD-2706", "prepared_for": "Federal Basin Resources", "schema_version": "counselbench.decision.v3", "task_id": "cb100-036-federal-basin"}, "matter_register": {"matter_number": "CB-LD-2706", "rows": [{"decision_option_id": "federal-basin:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-22", "issue": "email-family separation", "matter_number": "CB-LD-2706", "owner": "Willa Novak", "portfolio_key": "CBP-036-01", "row_id": "REG-CBP-036-01", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_pleadings/001_pleadings_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/02_orders/013_orders_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/025_custodian_files_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/05_email_families/037_email_families_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/11_third_party/085_third_party_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/08_production_logs/061_production_logs_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_case_management/097_federal_basin_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "federal-basin:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-21", "issue": "request-response mismatch", "matter_number": "CB-LD-2706", "owner": "Owen Delgado", "portfolio_key": "CBP-036-02", "row_id": "REG-CBP-036-02", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_pleadings/002_pleadings_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/02_orders/014_orders_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/026_custodian_files_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/05_email_families/038_email_families_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/08_production_logs/062_production_logs_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_case_management/097_federal_basin_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "federal-basin:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-20", "issue": "metadata field loss", "matter_number": "CB-LD-2706", "owner": "Priya Raman", "portfolio_key": "CBP-036-03", "row_id": "REG-CBP-036-03", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_pleadings/003_pleadings_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/02_orders/015_orders_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/027_custodian_files_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/05_email_families/039_email_families_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/11_third_party/087_third_party_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/08_production_logs/063_production_logs_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_case_management/097_federal_basin_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "federal-basin:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-19", "issue": "collection-date inconsistency", "matter_number": "CB-LD-2706", "owner": "Isaac Romero", "portfolio_key": "CBP-036-04", "row_id": "REG-CBP-036-04", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_pleadings/004_pleadings_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/02_orders/016_orders_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/028_custodian_files_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/05_email_families/040_email_families_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_case_management/097_federal_basin_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "federal-basin:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "the operational record relies on a superseded control revision", "issue": "protective-order designation error", "matter_number": "CB-LD-2706", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-036-05", "row_id": "REG-CBP-036-05", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_pleadings/005_pleadings_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/017_requests_responses_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/029_custodian_files_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/041_chat_exports_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/10_expert_material/077_expert_material_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/07_privilege_material/053_privilege_material_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_case_management/097_federal_basin_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "federal-basin:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-17", "issue": "production gap", "matter_number": "CB-LD-2706", "owner": "Rafael Okafor", "portfolio_key": "CBP-036-06", "row_id": "REG-CBP-036-06", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_pleadings/006_pleadings_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/018_requests_responses_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/030_custodian_files_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/042_chat_exports_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/12_case_management/090_case_management_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/07_privilege_material/054_privilege_material_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_case_management/097_federal_basin_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "federal-basin:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "the current observation does not meet the operative trigger", "issue": "legal-hold delivery gap", "matter_number": "CB-LD-2706", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-036-07", "row_id": "REG-CBP-036-07", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_pleadings/007_pleadings_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/019_requests_responses_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/031_custodian_files_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/043_chat_exports_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/12_case_management/097_federal_basin_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "federal-basin:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective", "issue": "clawback deadline", "matter_number": "CB-LD-2706", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-036-08", "row_id": "REG-CBP-036-08", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_pleadings/008_pleadings_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/020_requests_responses_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/032_custodian_files_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/044_chat_exports_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/10_expert_material/080_expert_material_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/07_privilege_material/056_privilege_material_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_case_management/097_federal_basin_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "federal-basin:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "the operational record relies on a superseded control revision", "issue": "third-party subpoena deadline", "matter_number": "CB-LD-2706", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-036-09", "row_id": "REG-CBP-036-09", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_orders/009_orders_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/021_requests_responses_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/05_email_families/033_email_families_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/045_chat_exports_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_case_management/097_federal_basin_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "federal-basin:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key", "issue": "custodian omission", "matter_number": "CB-LD-2706", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-036-10", "row_id": "REG-CBP-036-10", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_orders/010_orders_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/022_requests_responses_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/05_email_families/034_email_families_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/046_chat_exports_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_case_management/097_federal_basin_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "federal-basin:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-21", "issue": "common-interest support gap", "matter_number": "CB-LD-2706", "owner": "Sofia Bennett", "portfolio_key": "CBP-036-11", "row_id": "REG-CBP-036-11", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_orders/011_orders_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/023_requests_responses_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/05_email_families/035_email_families_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/047_chat_exports_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_case_management/097_federal_basin_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "federal-basin:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective", "issue": "expert draft segregation", "matter_number": "CB-LD-2706", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-036-12", "row_id": "REG-CBP-036-12", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_orders/012_orders_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/024_requests_responses_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/05_email_families/036_email_families_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/048_chat_exports_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/08_production_logs/060_production_logs_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/12_case_management/096_case_management_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_case_management/097_federal_basin_impact_population.xlsx"]}], "schema_version": "counselbench.matter-register.v3", "task_id": "cb100-036-federal-basin"}}, "metadata": {"benchmark": "CounselBench-100", "code_license": "Apache-2.0", "data_license": "CC-BY-4.0", "deadline": "2026-09-23", "document_count": 97, "evidence_holds": 6, "jurisdiction": "Oklahoma", "matter_number": "CB-LD-2706", "mcp_commit": "9a96ea6e5913736f92b88345bf51caeaaa8e719f", "mcp_package": "@modelcontextprotocol/server-filesystem@2026.7.10", "practice_area": "litigation-discovery", "reference_tool_calls": 87, "required_evidence_reads": 63, "supported_actions": 6, "synthetic": true, "venue": "Western District of Oklahoma", "version": "3.1.0"}, "prompt": "I am about to brief the decision makers and need the source record reconciled first. Can Federal Basin certify its royalty production against the document requests? Lease-accounting exports, title opinions, and executive messages must be mapped to document requests before a court-ordered certification. The team needs the call by 2026-09-23. Record the outcome the source hierarchy supports and explain the alternatives we should not take.", "rubric": {"criteria": [{"category": "investigation", "description": "Inventory the production and use targeted searches to locate records across native formats.", "id": "investigation.discover_production"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Complete every task-specific identity, authority, operations, and approval read before the first state transition.", "id": "investigation.read_before_write"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Inspect designated source metadata before relying on those records.", "id": "investigation.custody_before_write"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "Select the supported option 'federal-basin:scoped-evidence' after applying the four-part test.", "id": "decision.selected_option"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "Identify both rejected approaches and explain why a one-source shortcut and a blanket hold are wrong.", "id": "decision.alternatives"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-036-01 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_pleadings/001_pleadings_source_export.md rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-036-01.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_orders/013_orders_source_export.json for email-family separation.", "id": "investigation.CBP-036-01.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/025_custodian_files_source_export.md to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-036-01.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_email_families/037_email_families_source_export.json.", "id": "investigation.CBP-036-01.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-036-01 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-036-01.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-036-01 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-036-01.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-036-02 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_pleadings/002_pleadings_source_export.txt rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-036-02.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_orders/014_orders_source_export.xml for request-response mismatch.", "id": "investigation.CBP-036-02.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/026_custodian_files_source_export.txt to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-036-02.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_email_families/038_email_families_source_export.xml.", "id": "investigation.CBP-036-02.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-036-02 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-036-02.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-036-02 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-036-02.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-036-03 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_pleadings/003_pleadings_source_export.eml rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-036-03.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_orders/015_orders_source_export.html for metadata field loss.", "id": "investigation.CBP-036-03.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/027_custodian_files_source_export.eml to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-036-03.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_email_families/039_email_families_source_export.html.", "id": "investigation.CBP-036-03.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-036-03 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-036-03.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-036-03 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-036-03.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-036-04 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_pleadings/004_pleadings_source_export.csv rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-036-04.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_orders/016_orders_source_export.pdf for collection-date inconsistency.", "id": "investigation.CBP-036-04.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/028_custodian_files_source_export.csv to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-036-04.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_email_families/040_email_families_source_export.pdf.", "id": "investigation.CBP-036-04.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-036-04 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-036-04.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-036-04 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-036-04.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-036-05 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_pleadings/005_pleadings_source_export.json rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-036-05.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/017_requests_responses_source_export.md for protective-order designation error.", "id": "investigation.CBP-036-05.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/029_custodian_files_source_export.json to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-036-05.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/041_chat_exports_source_export.md.", "id": "investigation.CBP-036-05.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-036-05 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is the operational record relies on a superseded control revision.", "id": "decision.CBP-036-05.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-036-05 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-036-05.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-036-06 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_pleadings/006_pleadings_source_export.xml rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-036-06.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/018_requests_responses_source_export.txt for production gap.", "id": "investigation.CBP-036-06.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/030_custodian_files_source_export.xml to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-036-06.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/042_chat_exports_source_export.txt.", "id": "investigation.CBP-036-06.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-036-06 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-036-06.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-036-06 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-036-06.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-036-07 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_pleadings/007_pleadings_source_export.html rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-036-07.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/019_requests_responses_source_export.eml for legal-hold delivery gap.", "id": "investigation.CBP-036-07.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/031_custodian_files_source_export.html to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-036-07.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/043_chat_exports_source_export.eml.", "id": "investigation.CBP-036-07.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-036-07 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is the current observation does not meet the operative trigger.", "id": "decision.CBP-036-07.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-036-07 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-036-07.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-036-08 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_pleadings/008_pleadings_source_export.pdf rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-036-08.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/020_requests_responses_source_export.csv for clawback deadline.", "id": "investigation.CBP-036-08.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/032_custodian_files_source_export.pdf to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-036-08.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/044_chat_exports_source_export.csv.", "id": "investigation.CBP-036-08.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-036-08 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective.", "id": "decision.CBP-036-08.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-036-08 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-036-08.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-036-09 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_orders/009_orders_source_export.md rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-036-09.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/021_requests_responses_source_export.json for third-party subpoena deadline.", "id": "investigation.CBP-036-09.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_email_families/033_email_families_source_export.md to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-036-09.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/045_chat_exports_source_export.json.", "id": "investigation.CBP-036-09.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-036-09 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is the operational record relies on a superseded control revision.", "id": "decision.CBP-036-09.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-036-09 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-036-09.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-036-10 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_orders/010_orders_source_export.txt rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-036-10.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/022_requests_responses_source_export.xml for custodian omission.", "id": "investigation.CBP-036-10.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_email_families/034_email_families_source_export.txt to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-036-10.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/046_chat_exports_source_export.xml.", "id": "investigation.CBP-036-10.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-036-10 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key.", "id": "decision.CBP-036-10.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-036-10 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-036-10.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-036-11 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_orders/011_orders_source_export.eml rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-036-11.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/023_requests_responses_source_export.html for common-interest support gap.", "id": "investigation.CBP-036-11.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_email_families/035_email_families_source_export.eml to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-036-11.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/047_chat_exports_source_export.html.", "id": "investigation.CBP-036-11.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-036-11 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-036-11.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-036-11 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-036-11.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-036-12 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_orders/012_orders_source_export.csv rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-036-12.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/024_requests_responses_source_export.pdf for expert draft segregation.", "id": "investigation.CBP-036-12.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_email_families/036_email_families_source_export.csv to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-036-12.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/048_chat_exports_source_export.pdf.", "id": "investigation.CBP-036-12.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-036-12 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective.", "id": "decision.CBP-036-12.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-036-12 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-036-12.register"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Write the exact selected option, supported action population, evidence-hold population, facts, owners, deadlines, and citations.", "id": "state.exact_decision"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create one exact register row per portfolio key with no extra, missing, or modified row.", "id": "state.exact_register"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Leave only the three approved deliverables and perform no extra state-changing write.", "id": "state.write_scope_containment"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Read back decision.json, matter-register.json, and advice.md after their final writes.", "id": "state.postwrite_readback"}, {"category": "answer", "description": "Explain the selected recommendation, supported actions, holds, alternatives, and limitations with exact source anchors.", "id": "answer.decision_note"}], "decision_options": [{"approach": "Treat supported actions and genuinely ambiguous records as if they were equally unresolved.", "id": "federal-basin:blanket-hold", "label": "Freeze the entire matter population"}, {"approach": "Apply the exact identity, current-state, authority, and revision test. Create request-level exception rows and preserve disputed privilege items separately.", "id": "federal-basin:scoped-evidence", "label": "Supplement mapped gaps and certify only the bounded, reconciled population."}, {"approach": "Use a plausible summary or one source without completing the controlling joins.", "id": "federal-basin:shortcut", "label": "Use the accounting export count as the entire responsive population."}], "evaluation_narrative": {"authority": "The request definitions and court-ordered certification language govern the population.", "observation": "Map accounting entries, title opinions, and executive messages to exact requests and date ranges.", "question": "Can Federal Basin certify its royalty production against the document requests?", "register_action": "Create request-level exception rows and preserve disputed privilege items separately."}, "gates": ["all_required_evidence_precedes_first_write", "decision_criteria_complete", "register_state_exact", "write_scope_contained", "all_outputs_verified_by_readback"], "metadata_checks": 11, "metric": "weighted_criteria_score", "minimum_tool_calls": 87, "required_deliverables": ["decision.json", "matter-register.json", "advice.md"], "required_document_reads": 63, "type": "deterministic", "weights": {"advice": 0.15, "decision": 0.35, "investigation": 0.25, "state": 0.25}}, "task_id": "cb100-036-federal-basin", "task_name": "Federal Basin royalty dispute production", "world_id": "counselbench-filesystem-mcp-v3"}
+{"context_files": ["task_files/cb100-037-glacier-insurance/01_pleadings/001_pleadings_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-037-glacier-insurance/01_pleadings/002_pleadings_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-037-glacier-insurance/01_pleadings/003_pleadings_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-037-glacier-insurance/01_pleadings/004_pleadings_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-037-glacier-insurance/01_pleadings/005_pleadings_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-037-glacier-insurance/01_pleadings/006_pleadings_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-037-glacier-insurance/01_pleadings/007_pleadings_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-037-glacier-insurance/01_pleadings/008_pleadings_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-037-glacier-insurance/02_orders/009_orders_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-037-glacier-insurance/02_orders/010_orders_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-037-glacier-insurance/02_orders/011_orders_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-037-glacier-insurance/02_orders/012_orders_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-037-glacier-insurance/02_orders/013_orders_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-037-glacier-insurance/02_orders/014_orders_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-037-glacier-insurance/02_orders/015_orders_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-037-glacier-insurance/02_orders/016_orders_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-037-glacier-insurance/03_requests_responses/017_requests_responses_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-037-glacier-insurance/03_requests_responses/018_requests_responses_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-037-glacier-insurance/03_requests_responses/019_requests_responses_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-037-glacier-insurance/03_requests_responses/020_requests_responses_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-037-glacier-insurance/03_requests_responses/021_requests_responses_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-037-glacier-insurance/03_requests_responses/022_requests_responses_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-037-glacier-insurance/03_requests_responses/023_requests_responses_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-037-glacier-insurance/03_requests_responses/024_requests_responses_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-037-glacier-insurance/04_custodian_files/025_custodian_files_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-037-glacier-insurance/04_custodian_files/026_custodian_files_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-037-glacier-insurance/04_custodian_files/027_custodian_files_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-037-glacier-insurance/04_custodian_files/028_custodian_files_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-037-glacier-insurance/04_custodian_files/029_custodian_files_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-037-glacier-insurance/04_custodian_files/030_custodian_files_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-037-glacier-insurance/04_custodian_files/031_custodian_files_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-037-glacier-insurance/04_custodian_files/032_custodian_files_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-037-glacier-insurance/05_email_families/033_email_families_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-037-glacier-insurance/05_email_families/034_email_families_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-037-glacier-insurance/05_email_families/035_email_families_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-037-glacier-insurance/05_email_families/036_email_families_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-037-glacier-insurance/05_email_families/037_email_families_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-037-glacier-insurance/05_email_families/038_email_families_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-037-glacier-insurance/05_email_families/039_email_families_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-037-glacier-insurance/05_email_families/040_email_families_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-037-glacier-insurance/06_chat_exports/041_chat_exports_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-037-glacier-insurance/06_chat_exports/042_chat_exports_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-037-glacier-insurance/06_chat_exports/043_chat_exports_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-037-glacier-insurance/06_chat_exports/044_chat_exports_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-037-glacier-insurance/06_chat_exports/045_chat_exports_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-037-glacier-insurance/06_chat_exports/046_chat_exports_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-037-glacier-insurance/06_chat_exports/047_chat_exports_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-037-glacier-insurance/06_chat_exports/048_chat_exports_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-037-glacier-insurance/07_privilege_material/049_privilege_material_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-037-glacier-insurance/07_privilege_material/050_privilege_material_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-037-glacier-insurance/07_privilege_material/051_privilege_material_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-037-glacier-insurance/07_privilege_material/052_privilege_material_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-037-glacier-insurance/07_privilege_material/053_privilege_material_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-037-glacier-insurance/07_privilege_material/054_privilege_material_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-037-glacier-insurance/07_privilege_material/055_privilege_material_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-037-glacier-insurance/07_privilege_material/056_privilege_material_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-037-glacier-insurance/08_production_logs/057_production_logs_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-037-glacier-insurance/08_production_logs/058_production_logs_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-037-glacier-insurance/08_production_logs/059_production_logs_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-037-glacier-insurance/08_production_logs/060_production_logs_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-037-glacier-insurance/08_production_logs/061_production_logs_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-037-glacier-insurance/08_production_logs/062_production_logs_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-037-glacier-insurance/08_production_logs/063_production_logs_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-037-glacier-insurance/08_production_logs/064_production_logs_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-037-glacier-insurance/09_depositions/065_depositions_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-037-glacier-insurance/09_depositions/066_depositions_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-037-glacier-insurance/09_depositions/067_depositions_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-037-glacier-insurance/09_depositions/068_depositions_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-037-glacier-insurance/09_depositions/069_depositions_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-037-glacier-insurance/09_depositions/070_depositions_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-037-glacier-insurance/09_depositions/071_depositions_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-037-glacier-insurance/09_depositions/072_depositions_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-037-glacier-insurance/10_expert_material/073_expert_material_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-037-glacier-insurance/10_expert_material/074_expert_material_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-037-glacier-insurance/10_expert_material/075_expert_material_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-037-glacier-insurance/10_expert_material/076_expert_material_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-037-glacier-insurance/10_expert_material/077_expert_material_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-037-glacier-insurance/10_expert_material/078_expert_material_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-037-glacier-insurance/10_expert_material/079_expert_material_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-037-glacier-insurance/10_expert_material/080_expert_material_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-037-glacier-insurance/11_third_party/081_third_party_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-037-glacier-insurance/11_third_party/082_third_party_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-037-glacier-insurance/11_third_party/083_third_party_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-037-glacier-insurance/11_third_party/084_third_party_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-037-glacier-insurance/11_third_party/085_third_party_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-037-glacier-insurance/11_third_party/086_third_party_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-037-glacier-insurance/11_third_party/087_third_party_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-037-glacier-insurance/11_third_party/088_third_party_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-037-glacier-insurance/12_case_management/089_case_management_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-037-glacier-insurance/12_case_management/090_case_management_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-037-glacier-insurance/12_case_management/091_case_management_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-037-glacier-insurance/12_case_management/092_case_management_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-037-glacier-insurance/12_case_management/093_case_management_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-037-glacier-insurance/12_case_management/094_case_management_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-037-glacier-insurance/12_case_management/095_case_management_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-037-glacier-insurance/12_case_management/096_case_management_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-037-glacier-insurance/12_case_management/097_glacier_insurance_impact_population.xlsx"], "gold_output": {"advice_markdown": "# Decision note — Glacier coverage action discovery review\n\n## Recommendation\n\nTake document-specific clawback or production action supported by content and timing. The reconciled record supports 7 scoped actions and leaves 5 items on evidence hold.\n\nSelected option: `glacier-insurance:scoped-evidence`.\n\n## Why this is the supported option\n\nReconcile communication purpose, participants, redactions, production time, and clawback service. Privilege law and the operative clawback order require exact document and notice chronology.\n\n## Supported actions\n\n### CBP-037-01 — privilege-log description defect (high)\n\nthe permission is limited to Southern District of New York under CB-LD-2707-R812; the matched activity occurred in New York under CB-LD-2707-E300. Identity resolves to ENT-037-1000, revision REV-2025.1 is current, and Henry Cho is active with capacity 5.\n\nAction: Register exact document dispositions and isolate notice-date uncertainty. Owner: Henry Cho; due 2026-09-25.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_pleadings/001_pleadings_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/02_orders/013_orders_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/025_custodian_files_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/05_email_families/037_email_families_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/12_case_management/097_glacier_insurance_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-037-05 — request-response mismatch (medium)\n\ncompletion is required by 2025-03-13 under CB-LD-2707-R526; the current event record shows completion on 2025-03-23 under CB-LD-2707-E601. Identity resolves to ENT-037-1004, revision REV-2025.5 is current, and Owen Delgado is active with capacity 5.\n\nAction: Register exact document dispositions and isolate notice-date uncertainty. Owner: Owen Delgado; due 2026-09-21.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_pleadings/005_pleadings_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/017_requests_responses_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/029_custodian_files_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/041_chat_exports_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/09_depositions/065_depositions_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/07_privilege_material/053_privilege_material_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/12_case_management/097_glacier_insurance_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-037-06 — metadata field loss (high)\n\nthe controlling threshold is 5% under CB-LD-2707-R228; the independently calculated result is 9% under CB-LD-2707-E266. Identity resolves to ENT-037-1005, revision REV-2025.6 is current, and Priya Raman is active with capacity 1.\n\nAction: Register exact document dispositions and isolate notice-date uncertainty. Owner: Priya Raman; due 2026-09-20.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_pleadings/006_pleadings_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/018_requests_responses_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/030_custodian_files_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/042_chat_exports_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/12_case_management/090_case_management_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/12_case_management/097_glacier_insurance_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-037-07 — collection-date inconsistency (critical)\n\napproval must come from Talia Brooks under CB-LD-2707-R715; the effective approval record names Rafael Okafor under CB-LD-2707-E506. Identity resolves to ENT-037-1006, revision REV-2025.7 is current, and Isaac Romero is active with capacity 6.\n\nAction: Register exact document dispositions and isolate notice-date uncertainty. Owner: Isaac Romero; due 2026-09-19.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_pleadings/007_pleadings_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/019_requests_responses_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/031_custodian_files_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/043_chat_exports_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/07_privilege_material/055_privilege_material_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/10_expert_material/079_expert_material_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/12_case_management/097_glacier_insurance_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-037-08 — protective-order designation error (critical)\n\nthe controlled population contains 168 records under CB-LD-2707-R556; the certification covers 142 records under CB-LD-2707-E285. Identity resolves to ENT-037-1007, revision REV-2025.1 is current, and Nadine Flores is active with capacity 4.\n\nAction: Register exact document dispositions and isolate notice-date uncertainty. Owner: Nadine Flores; due 2026-09-18.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_pleadings/008_pleadings_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/020_requests_responses_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/032_custodian_files_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/044_chat_exports_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/12_case_management/097_glacier_insurance_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-037-11 — clawback deadline (critical)\n\ndelivery must use notices-glacier_mutual_insurance@example.test under CB-LD-2707-R428; the only matched receipt used archive-moraine_data_centers_inc@example.test under CB-LD-2707-E807. Identity resolves to ENT-037-1010, revision REV-2025.4 is current, and Theo Laurent is active with capacity 6.\n\nAction: Register exact document dispositions and isolate notice-date uncertainty. Owner: Theo Laurent; due 2026-09-24.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/02_orders/011_orders_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/023_requests_responses_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/05_email_families/035_email_families_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/047_chat_exports_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/12_case_management/095_case_management_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/12_case_management/097_glacier_insurance_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-037-12 — third-party subpoena deadline (medium)\n\nan open exception blocks completion under CB-LD-2707-R621; the current status is open and unresolved under CB-LD-2707-E236. Identity resolves to ENT-037-1011, revision REV-2025.5 is current, and Lena Varga is active with capacity 6.\n\nAction: Register exact document dispositions and isolate notice-date uncertainty. Owner: Lena Varga; due 2026-09-23.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/02_orders/012_orders_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/024_requests_responses_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/05_email_families/036_email_families_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/048_chat_exports_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/09_depositions/072_depositions_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/12_case_management/097_glacier_insurance_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n## Evidence holds\n\n- **CBP-037-02 — deposition exhibit omission**: the current observation does not meet the operative trigger. Next evidence: a current observation that satisfies the operative trigger. Sources: `/workspace/documents/01_pleadings/002_pleadings_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/02_orders/014_orders_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/026_custodian_files_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/05_email_families/038_email_families_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/11_third_party/086_third_party_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/12_case_management/097_glacier_insurance_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-037-03 — Bates-range overlap**: the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective. Next evidence: effective approval and an active owner with remaining capacity. Sources: `/workspace/documents/01_pleadings/003_pleadings_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/02_orders/015_orders_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/027_custodian_files_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/05_email_families/039_email_families_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/12_case_management/097_glacier_insurance_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-037-04 — email-family separation**: the operational record relies on a superseded control revision. Next evidence: an operational record using the current effective revision. Sources: `/workspace/documents/01_pleadings/004_pleadings_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/02_orders/016_orders_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/028_custodian_files_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/05_email_families/040_email_families_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/10_expert_material/076_expert_material_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/12_case_management/097_glacier_insurance_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-037-09 — production gap**: two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key. Next evidence: an approved immutable entity crosswalk. Sources: `/workspace/documents/02_orders/009_orders_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/021_requests_responses_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/05_email_families/033_email_families_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/045_chat_exports_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/08_production_logs/057_production_logs_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/11_third_party/081_third_party_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/12_case_management/097_glacier_insurance_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-037-10 — legal-hold delivery gap**: the current observation does not meet the operative trigger. Next evidence: a current observation that satisfies the operative trigger. Sources: `/workspace/documents/02_orders/010_orders_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/022_requests_responses_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/05_email_families/034_email_families_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/046_chat_exports_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/11_third_party/082_third_party_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/12_case_management/097_glacier_insurance_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n## Alternatives considered\n\n- `glacier-insurance:shortcut` — Claw back every communication involving a lawyer.: Use a plausible summary or one source without completing the controlling joins.\n- `glacier-insurance:blanket-hold` — Freeze the entire matter population: Treat supported actions and genuinely ambiguous records as if they were equally unresolved.\n\n## Assumptions and limits\n\nThis decision is limited to cb100-037-glacier-insurance, the supplied synthetic records, and the matter state as of 2026-09-26. Similar names, stale revisions, and pending authority are not treated as proof.\n", "decision": {"actions": [{"determination": "the permission is limited to Southern District of New York under CB-LD-2707-R812; the matched activity occurred in New York under CB-LD-2707-E300. Identity resolves to ENT-037-1000, revision REV-2025.1 is current, and Henry Cho is active with capacity 5.", "due_date": "2026-09-25", "id": "ACT-CBP-037-01", "identity_id": "ENT-037-1000", "issue": "privilege-log description defect", "owner": "Henry Cho", "portfolio_key": "CBP-037-01", "recommended_action": "Register exact document dispositions and isolate notice-date uncertainty. Owner: Henry Cho; due 2026-09-25.", "severity": "high", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_pleadings/001_pleadings_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/02_orders/013_orders_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/025_custodian_files_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/05_email_families/037_email_families_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_case_management/097_glacier_insurance_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "completion is required by 2025-03-13 under CB-LD-2707-R526; the current event record shows completion on 2025-03-23 under CB-LD-2707-E601. Identity resolves to ENT-037-1004, revision REV-2025.5 is current, and Owen Delgado is active with capacity 5.", "due_date": "2026-09-21", "id": "ACT-CBP-037-05", "identity_id": "ENT-037-1004", "issue": "request-response mismatch", "owner": "Owen Delgado", "portfolio_key": "CBP-037-05", "recommended_action": "Register exact document dispositions and isolate notice-date uncertainty. Owner: Owen Delgado; due 2026-09-21.", "severity": "medium", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_pleadings/005_pleadings_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/017_requests_responses_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/029_custodian_files_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/041_chat_exports_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/09_depositions/065_depositions_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/07_privilege_material/053_privilege_material_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_case_management/097_glacier_insurance_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "the controlling threshold is 5% under CB-LD-2707-R228; the independently calculated result is 9% under CB-LD-2707-E266. Identity resolves to ENT-037-1005, revision REV-2025.6 is current, and Priya Raman is active with capacity 1.", "due_date": "2026-09-20", "id": "ACT-CBP-037-06", "identity_id": "ENT-037-1005", "issue": "metadata field loss", "owner": "Priya Raman", "portfolio_key": "CBP-037-06", "recommended_action": "Register exact document dispositions and isolate notice-date uncertainty. Owner: Priya Raman; due 2026-09-20.", "severity": "high", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_pleadings/006_pleadings_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/018_requests_responses_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/030_custodian_files_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/042_chat_exports_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/12_case_management/090_case_management_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/12_case_management/097_glacier_insurance_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "approval must come from Talia Brooks under CB-LD-2707-R715; the effective approval record names Rafael Okafor under CB-LD-2707-E506. Identity resolves to ENT-037-1006, revision REV-2025.7 is current, and Isaac Romero is active with capacity 6.", "due_date": "2026-09-19", "id": "ACT-CBP-037-07", "identity_id": "ENT-037-1006", "issue": "collection-date inconsistency", "owner": "Isaac Romero", "portfolio_key": "CBP-037-07", "recommended_action": "Register exact document dispositions and isolate notice-date uncertainty. Owner: Isaac Romero; due 2026-09-19.", "severity": "critical", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_pleadings/007_pleadings_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/019_requests_responses_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/031_custodian_files_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/043_chat_exports_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/07_privilege_material/055_privilege_material_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/10_expert_material/079_expert_material_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_case_management/097_glacier_insurance_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "the controlled population contains 168 records under CB-LD-2707-R556; the certification covers 142 records under CB-LD-2707-E285. Identity resolves to ENT-037-1007, revision REV-2025.1 is current, and Nadine Flores is active with capacity 4.", "due_date": "2026-09-18", "id": "ACT-CBP-037-08", "identity_id": "ENT-037-1007", "issue": "protective-order designation error", "owner": "Nadine Flores", "portfolio_key": "CBP-037-08", "recommended_action": "Register exact document dispositions and isolate notice-date uncertainty. Owner: Nadine Flores; due 2026-09-18.", "severity": "critical", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_pleadings/008_pleadings_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/020_requests_responses_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/032_custodian_files_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/044_chat_exports_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/12_case_management/097_glacier_insurance_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "delivery must use notices-glacier_mutual_insurance@example.test under CB-LD-2707-R428; the only matched receipt used archive-moraine_data_centers_inc@example.test under CB-LD-2707-E807. Identity resolves to ENT-037-1010, revision REV-2025.4 is current, and Theo Laurent is active with capacity 6.", "due_date": "2026-09-24", "id": "ACT-CBP-037-11", "identity_id": "ENT-037-1010", "issue": "clawback deadline", "owner": "Theo Laurent", "portfolio_key": "CBP-037-11", "recommended_action": "Register exact document dispositions and isolate notice-date uncertainty. Owner: Theo Laurent; due 2026-09-24.", "severity": "critical", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_orders/011_orders_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/023_requests_responses_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/05_email_families/035_email_families_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/047_chat_exports_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_case_management/095_case_management_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_case_management/097_glacier_insurance_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "an open exception blocks completion under CB-LD-2707-R621; the current status is open and unresolved under CB-LD-2707-E236. Identity resolves to ENT-037-1011, revision REV-2025.5 is current, and Lena Varga is active with capacity 6.", "due_date": "2026-09-23", "id": "ACT-CBP-037-12", "identity_id": "ENT-037-1011", "issue": "third-party subpoena deadline", "owner": "Lena Varga", "portfolio_key": "CBP-037-12", "recommended_action": "Register exact document dispositions and isolate notice-date uncertainty. Owner: Lena Varga; due 2026-09-23.", "severity": "medium", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_orders/012_orders_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/024_requests_responses_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/05_email_families/036_email_families_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/048_chat_exports_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/09_depositions/072_depositions_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_case_management/097_glacier_insurance_impact_population.xlsx"]}], "as_of": "2026-09-26", "decision": {"alternatives_considered": ["glacier-insurance:shortcut", "glacier-insurance:blanket-hold"], "question": "What should Glacier claw back, relog, or produce from the mixed claims files?", "rationale": "The four-part causal test supports 7 scoped actions and leaves 5 records on evidence hold. Privilege law and the operative clawback order require exact document and notice chronology.", "recommendation": "Take document-specific clawback or production action supported by content and timing.", "selected_option_id": "glacier-insurance:scoped-evidence"}, "holds": [{"id": "HOLD-CBP-037-02", "issue": "deposition exhibit omission", "portfolio_key": "CBP-037-02", "reason": "the current observation does not meet the operative trigger", "required_next_evidence": "a current observation that satisfies the operative trigger", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_pleadings/002_pleadings_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/02_orders/014_orders_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/026_custodian_files_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/05_email_families/038_email_families_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/11_third_party/086_third_party_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_case_management/097_glacier_insurance_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-037-03", "issue": "Bates-range overlap", "portfolio_key": "CBP-037-03", "reason": "the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective", "required_next_evidence": "effective approval and an active owner with remaining capacity", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_pleadings/003_pleadings_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/02_orders/015_orders_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/027_custodian_files_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/05_email_families/039_email_families_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_case_management/097_glacier_insurance_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-037-04", "issue": "email-family separation", "portfolio_key": "CBP-037-04", "reason": "the operational record relies on a superseded control revision", "required_next_evidence": "an operational record using the current effective revision", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_pleadings/004_pleadings_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/02_orders/016_orders_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/028_custodian_files_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/05_email_families/040_email_families_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/10_expert_material/076_expert_material_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/12_case_management/097_glacier_insurance_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-037-09", "issue": "production gap", "portfolio_key": "CBP-037-09", "reason": "two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key", "required_next_evidence": "an approved immutable entity crosswalk", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_orders/009_orders_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/021_requests_responses_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/05_email_families/033_email_families_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/045_chat_exports_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/08_production_logs/057_production_logs_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/11_third_party/081_third_party_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/12_case_management/097_glacier_insurance_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-037-10", "issue": "legal-hold delivery gap", "portfolio_key": "CBP-037-10", "reason": "the current observation does not meet the operative trigger", "required_next_evidence": "a current observation that satisfies the operative trigger", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_orders/010_orders_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/022_requests_responses_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/05_email_families/034_email_families_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/046_chat_exports_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/11_third_party/082_third_party_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/12_case_management/097_glacier_insurance_impact_population.xlsx"]}], "matter_number": "CB-LD-2707", "prepared_for": "Glacier Mutual Insurance", "schema_version": "counselbench.decision.v3", "task_id": "cb100-037-glacier-insurance"}, "matter_register": {"matter_number": "CB-LD-2707", "rows": [{"decision_option_id": "glacier-insurance:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-25", "issue": "privilege-log description defect", "matter_number": "CB-LD-2707", "owner": "Henry Cho", "portfolio_key": "CBP-037-01", "row_id": "REG-CBP-037-01", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_pleadings/001_pleadings_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/02_orders/013_orders_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/025_custodian_files_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/05_email_families/037_email_families_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_case_management/097_glacier_insurance_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "glacier-insurance:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "the current observation does not meet the operative trigger", "issue": "deposition exhibit omission", "matter_number": "CB-LD-2707", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-037-02", "row_id": "REG-CBP-037-02", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_pleadings/002_pleadings_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/02_orders/014_orders_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/026_custodian_files_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/05_email_families/038_email_families_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/11_third_party/086_third_party_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_case_management/097_glacier_insurance_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "glacier-insurance:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective", "issue": "Bates-range overlap", "matter_number": "CB-LD-2707", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-037-03", "row_id": "REG-CBP-037-03", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_pleadings/003_pleadings_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/02_orders/015_orders_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/027_custodian_files_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/05_email_families/039_email_families_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_case_management/097_glacier_insurance_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "glacier-insurance:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "the operational record relies on a superseded control revision", "issue": "email-family separation", "matter_number": "CB-LD-2707", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-037-04", "row_id": "REG-CBP-037-04", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_pleadings/004_pleadings_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/02_orders/016_orders_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/028_custodian_files_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/05_email_families/040_email_families_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/10_expert_material/076_expert_material_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/12_case_management/097_glacier_insurance_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "glacier-insurance:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-21", "issue": "request-response mismatch", "matter_number": "CB-LD-2707", "owner": "Owen Delgado", "portfolio_key": "CBP-037-05", "row_id": "REG-CBP-037-05", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_pleadings/005_pleadings_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/017_requests_responses_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/029_custodian_files_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/041_chat_exports_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/09_depositions/065_depositions_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/07_privilege_material/053_privilege_material_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_case_management/097_glacier_insurance_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "glacier-insurance:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-20", "issue": "metadata field loss", "matter_number": "CB-LD-2707", "owner": "Priya Raman", "portfolio_key": "CBP-037-06", "row_id": "REG-CBP-037-06", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_pleadings/006_pleadings_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/018_requests_responses_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/030_custodian_files_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/042_chat_exports_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/12_case_management/090_case_management_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/12_case_management/097_glacier_insurance_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "glacier-insurance:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-19", "issue": "collection-date inconsistency", "matter_number": "CB-LD-2707", "owner": "Isaac Romero", "portfolio_key": "CBP-037-07", "row_id": "REG-CBP-037-07", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_pleadings/007_pleadings_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/019_requests_responses_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/031_custodian_files_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/043_chat_exports_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/07_privilege_material/055_privilege_material_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/10_expert_material/079_expert_material_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_case_management/097_glacier_insurance_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "glacier-insurance:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-18", "issue": "protective-order designation error", "matter_number": "CB-LD-2707", "owner": "Nadine Flores", "portfolio_key": "CBP-037-08", "row_id": "REG-CBP-037-08", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_pleadings/008_pleadings_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/020_requests_responses_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/032_custodian_files_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/044_chat_exports_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/12_case_management/097_glacier_insurance_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "glacier-insurance:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key", "issue": "production gap", "matter_number": "CB-LD-2707", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-037-09", "row_id": "REG-CBP-037-09", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_orders/009_orders_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/021_requests_responses_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/05_email_families/033_email_families_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/045_chat_exports_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/08_production_logs/057_production_logs_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/11_third_party/081_third_party_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/12_case_management/097_glacier_insurance_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "glacier-insurance:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "the current observation does not meet the operative trigger", "issue": "legal-hold delivery gap", "matter_number": "CB-LD-2707", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-037-10", "row_id": "REG-CBP-037-10", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_orders/010_orders_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/022_requests_responses_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/05_email_families/034_email_families_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/046_chat_exports_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/11_third_party/082_third_party_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/12_case_management/097_glacier_insurance_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "glacier-insurance:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-24", "issue": "clawback deadline", "matter_number": "CB-LD-2707", "owner": "Theo Laurent", "portfolio_key": "CBP-037-11", "row_id": "REG-CBP-037-11", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_orders/011_orders_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/023_requests_responses_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/05_email_families/035_email_families_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/047_chat_exports_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_case_management/095_case_management_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_case_management/097_glacier_insurance_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "glacier-insurance:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-23", "issue": "third-party subpoena deadline", "matter_number": "CB-LD-2707", "owner": "Lena Varga", "portfolio_key": "CBP-037-12", "row_id": "REG-CBP-037-12", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_orders/012_orders_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/024_requests_responses_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/05_email_families/036_email_families_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/048_chat_exports_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/09_depositions/072_depositions_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_case_management/097_glacier_insurance_impact_population.xlsx"]}], "schema_version": "counselbench.matter-register.v3", "task_id": "cb100-037-glacier-insurance"}}, "metadata": {"benchmark": "CounselBench-100", "code_license": "Apache-2.0", "data_license": "CC-BY-4.0", "deadline": "2026-09-26", "document_count": 97, "evidence_holds": 5, "jurisdiction": "New York", "matter_number": "CB-LD-2707", "mcp_commit": "9a96ea6e5913736f92b88345bf51caeaaa8e719f", "mcp_package": "@modelcontextprotocol/server-filesystem@2026.7.10", "practice_area": "litigation-discovery", "reference_tool_calls": 86, "required_evidence_reads": 62, "supported_actions": 7, "synthetic": true, "venue": "Southern District of New York", "version": "3.1.0"}, "prompt": "The other side has challenged our internal account of the facts. What should Glacier claw back, relog, or produce from the mixed claims files? Claims files contain mixed business and legal communications, redaction inconsistencies, and a disputed clawback notice date. The team needs the call by 2026-09-26. Leave a concise decision record with exact source references and an owner for each supported next step.", "rubric": {"criteria": [{"category": "investigation", "description": "Inventory the production and use targeted searches to locate records across native formats.", "id": "investigation.discover_production"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Complete every task-specific identity, authority, operations, and approval read before the first state transition.", "id": "investigation.read_before_write"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Inspect designated source metadata before relying on those records.", "id": "investigation.custody_before_write"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "Select the supported option 'glacier-insurance:scoped-evidence' after applying the four-part test.", "id": "decision.selected_option"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "Identify both rejected approaches and explain why a one-source shortcut and a blanket hold are wrong.", "id": "decision.alternatives"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-037-01 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_pleadings/001_pleadings_source_export.md rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-037-01.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_orders/013_orders_source_export.json for privilege-log description defect.", "id": "investigation.CBP-037-01.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/025_custodian_files_source_export.md to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-037-01.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_email_families/037_email_families_source_export.json.", "id": "investigation.CBP-037-01.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-037-01 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-037-01.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-037-01 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-037-01.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-037-02 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_pleadings/002_pleadings_source_export.txt rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-037-02.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_orders/014_orders_source_export.xml for deposition exhibit omission.", "id": "investigation.CBP-037-02.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/026_custodian_files_source_export.txt to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-037-02.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_email_families/038_email_families_source_export.xml.", "id": "investigation.CBP-037-02.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-037-02 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is the current observation does not meet the operative trigger.", "id": "decision.CBP-037-02.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-037-02 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-037-02.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-037-03 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_pleadings/003_pleadings_source_export.eml rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-037-03.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_orders/015_orders_source_export.html for Bates-range overlap.", "id": "investigation.CBP-037-03.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/027_custodian_files_source_export.eml to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-037-03.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_email_families/039_email_families_source_export.html.", "id": "investigation.CBP-037-03.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-037-03 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective.", "id": "decision.CBP-037-03.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-037-03 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-037-03.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-037-04 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_pleadings/004_pleadings_source_export.csv rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-037-04.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_orders/016_orders_source_export.pdf for email-family separation.", "id": "investigation.CBP-037-04.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/028_custodian_files_source_export.csv to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-037-04.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_email_families/040_email_families_source_export.pdf.", "id": "investigation.CBP-037-04.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-037-04 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is the operational record relies on a superseded control revision.", "id": "decision.CBP-037-04.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-037-04 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-037-04.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-037-05 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_pleadings/005_pleadings_source_export.json rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-037-05.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/017_requests_responses_source_export.md for request-response mismatch.", "id": "investigation.CBP-037-05.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/029_custodian_files_source_export.json to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-037-05.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/041_chat_exports_source_export.md.", "id": "investigation.CBP-037-05.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-037-05 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-037-05.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-037-05 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-037-05.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-037-06 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_pleadings/006_pleadings_source_export.xml rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-037-06.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/018_requests_responses_source_export.txt for metadata field loss.", "id": "investigation.CBP-037-06.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/030_custodian_files_source_export.xml to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-037-06.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/042_chat_exports_source_export.txt.", "id": "investigation.CBP-037-06.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-037-06 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-037-06.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-037-06 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-037-06.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-037-07 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_pleadings/007_pleadings_source_export.html rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-037-07.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/019_requests_responses_source_export.eml for collection-date inconsistency.", "id": "investigation.CBP-037-07.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/031_custodian_files_source_export.html to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-037-07.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/043_chat_exports_source_export.eml.", "id": "investigation.CBP-037-07.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-037-07 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-037-07.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-037-07 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-037-07.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-037-08 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_pleadings/008_pleadings_source_export.pdf rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-037-08.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/020_requests_responses_source_export.csv for protective-order designation error.", "id": "investigation.CBP-037-08.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/032_custodian_files_source_export.pdf to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-037-08.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/044_chat_exports_source_export.csv.", "id": "investigation.CBP-037-08.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-037-08 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-037-08.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-037-08 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-037-08.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-037-09 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_orders/009_orders_source_export.md rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-037-09.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/021_requests_responses_source_export.json for production gap.", "id": "investigation.CBP-037-09.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_email_families/033_email_families_source_export.md to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-037-09.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/045_chat_exports_source_export.json.", "id": "investigation.CBP-037-09.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-037-09 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key.", "id": "decision.CBP-037-09.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-037-09 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-037-09.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-037-10 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_orders/010_orders_source_export.txt rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-037-10.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/022_requests_responses_source_export.xml for legal-hold delivery gap.", "id": "investigation.CBP-037-10.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_email_families/034_email_families_source_export.txt to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-037-10.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/046_chat_exports_source_export.xml.", "id": "investigation.CBP-037-10.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-037-10 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is the current observation does not meet the operative trigger.", "id": "decision.CBP-037-10.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-037-10 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-037-10.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-037-11 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_orders/011_orders_source_export.eml rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-037-11.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/023_requests_responses_source_export.html for clawback deadline.", "id": "investigation.CBP-037-11.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_email_families/035_email_families_source_export.eml to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-037-11.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/047_chat_exports_source_export.html.", "id": "investigation.CBP-037-11.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-037-11 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-037-11.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-037-11 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-037-11.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-037-12 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_orders/012_orders_source_export.csv rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-037-12.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/024_requests_responses_source_export.pdf for third-party subpoena deadline.", "id": "investigation.CBP-037-12.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_email_families/036_email_families_source_export.csv to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-037-12.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/048_chat_exports_source_export.pdf.", "id": "investigation.CBP-037-12.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-037-12 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-037-12.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-037-12 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-037-12.register"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Write the exact selected option, supported action population, evidence-hold population, facts, owners, deadlines, and citations.", "id": "state.exact_decision"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create one exact register row per portfolio key with no extra, missing, or modified row.", "id": "state.exact_register"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Leave only the three approved deliverables and perform no extra state-changing write.", "id": "state.write_scope_containment"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Read back decision.json, matter-register.json, and advice.md after their final writes.", "id": "state.postwrite_readback"}, {"category": "answer", "description": "Explain the selected recommendation, supported actions, holds, alternatives, and limitations with exact source anchors.", "id": "answer.decision_note"}], "decision_options": [{"approach": "Apply the exact identity, current-state, authority, and revision test. Register exact document dispositions and isolate notice-date uncertainty.", "id": "glacier-insurance:scoped-evidence", "label": "Take document-specific clawback or production action supported by content and timing."}, {"approach": "Use a plausible summary or one source without completing the controlling joins.", "id": "glacier-insurance:shortcut", "label": "Claw back every communication involving a lawyer."}, {"approach": "Treat supported actions and genuinely ambiguous records as if they were equally unresolved.", "id": "glacier-insurance:blanket-hold", "label": "Freeze the entire matter population"}], "evaluation_narrative": {"authority": "Privilege law and the operative clawback order require exact document and notice chronology.", "observation": "Reconcile communication purpose, participants, redactions, production time, and clawback service.", "question": "What should Glacier claw back, relog, or produce from the mixed claims files?", "register_action": "Register exact document dispositions and isolate notice-date uncertainty."}, "gates": ["all_required_evidence_precedes_first_write", "decision_criteria_complete", "register_state_exact", "write_scope_contained", "all_outputs_verified_by_readback"], "metadata_checks": 10, "metric": "weighted_criteria_score", "minimum_tool_calls": 86, "required_deliverables": ["decision.json", "matter-register.json", "advice.md"], "required_document_reads": 62, "type": "deterministic", "weights": {"advice": 0.15, "decision": 0.35, "investigation": 0.25, "state": 0.25}}, "task_id": "cb100-037-glacier-insurance", "task_name": "Glacier coverage action discovery review", "world_id": "counselbench-filesystem-mcp-v3"}
+{"context_files": ["task_files/cb100-038-highland-securities/01_pleadings/001_pleadings_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-038-highland-securities/01_pleadings/002_pleadings_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-038-highland-securities/01_pleadings/003_pleadings_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-038-highland-securities/01_pleadings/004_pleadings_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-038-highland-securities/01_pleadings/005_pleadings_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-038-highland-securities/01_pleadings/006_pleadings_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-038-highland-securities/01_pleadings/007_pleadings_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-038-highland-securities/01_pleadings/008_pleadings_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-038-highland-securities/02_orders/009_orders_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-038-highland-securities/02_orders/010_orders_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-038-highland-securities/02_orders/011_orders_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-038-highland-securities/02_orders/012_orders_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-038-highland-securities/02_orders/013_orders_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-038-highland-securities/02_orders/014_orders_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-038-highland-securities/02_orders/015_orders_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-038-highland-securities/02_orders/016_orders_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-038-highland-securities/03_requests_responses/017_requests_responses_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-038-highland-securities/03_requests_responses/018_requests_responses_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-038-highland-securities/03_requests_responses/019_requests_responses_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-038-highland-securities/03_requests_responses/020_requests_responses_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-038-highland-securities/03_requests_responses/021_requests_responses_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-038-highland-securities/03_requests_responses/022_requests_responses_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-038-highland-securities/03_requests_responses/023_requests_responses_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-038-highland-securities/03_requests_responses/024_requests_responses_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-038-highland-securities/04_custodian_files/025_custodian_files_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-038-highland-securities/04_custodian_files/026_custodian_files_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-038-highland-securities/04_custodian_files/027_custodian_files_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-038-highland-securities/04_custodian_files/028_custodian_files_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-038-highland-securities/04_custodian_files/029_custodian_files_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-038-highland-securities/04_custodian_files/030_custodian_files_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-038-highland-securities/04_custodian_files/031_custodian_files_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-038-highland-securities/04_custodian_files/032_custodian_files_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-038-highland-securities/05_email_families/033_email_families_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-038-highland-securities/05_email_families/034_email_families_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-038-highland-securities/05_email_families/035_email_families_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-038-highland-securities/05_email_families/036_email_families_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-038-highland-securities/05_email_families/037_email_families_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-038-highland-securities/05_email_families/038_email_families_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-038-highland-securities/05_email_families/039_email_families_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-038-highland-securities/05_email_families/040_email_families_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-038-highland-securities/06_chat_exports/041_chat_exports_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-038-highland-securities/06_chat_exports/042_chat_exports_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-038-highland-securities/06_chat_exports/043_chat_exports_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-038-highland-securities/06_chat_exports/044_chat_exports_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-038-highland-securities/06_chat_exports/045_chat_exports_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-038-highland-securities/06_chat_exports/046_chat_exports_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-038-highland-securities/06_chat_exports/047_chat_exports_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-038-highland-securities/06_chat_exports/048_chat_exports_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-038-highland-securities/07_privilege_material/049_privilege_material_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-038-highland-securities/07_privilege_material/050_privilege_material_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-038-highland-securities/07_privilege_material/051_privilege_material_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-038-highland-securities/07_privilege_material/052_privilege_material_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-038-highland-securities/07_privilege_material/053_privilege_material_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-038-highland-securities/07_privilege_material/054_privilege_material_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-038-highland-securities/07_privilege_material/055_privilege_material_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-038-highland-securities/07_privilege_material/056_privilege_material_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-038-highland-securities/08_production_logs/057_production_logs_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-038-highland-securities/08_production_logs/058_production_logs_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-038-highland-securities/08_production_logs/059_production_logs_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-038-highland-securities/08_production_logs/060_production_logs_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-038-highland-securities/08_production_logs/061_production_logs_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-038-highland-securities/08_production_logs/062_production_logs_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-038-highland-securities/08_production_logs/063_production_logs_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-038-highland-securities/08_production_logs/064_production_logs_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-038-highland-securities/09_depositions/065_depositions_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-038-highland-securities/09_depositions/066_depositions_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-038-highland-securities/09_depositions/067_depositions_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-038-highland-securities/09_depositions/068_depositions_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-038-highland-securities/09_depositions/069_depositions_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-038-highland-securities/09_depositions/070_depositions_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-038-highland-securities/09_depositions/071_depositions_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-038-highland-securities/09_depositions/072_depositions_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-038-highland-securities/10_expert_material/073_expert_material_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-038-highland-securities/10_expert_material/074_expert_material_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-038-highland-securities/10_expert_material/075_expert_material_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-038-highland-securities/10_expert_material/076_expert_material_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-038-highland-securities/10_expert_material/077_expert_material_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-038-highland-securities/10_expert_material/078_expert_material_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-038-highland-securities/10_expert_material/079_expert_material_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-038-highland-securities/10_expert_material/080_expert_material_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-038-highland-securities/11_third_party/081_third_party_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-038-highland-securities/11_third_party/082_third_party_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-038-highland-securities/11_third_party/083_third_party_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-038-highland-securities/11_third_party/084_third_party_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-038-highland-securities/11_third_party/085_third_party_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-038-highland-securities/11_third_party/086_third_party_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-038-highland-securities/11_third_party/087_third_party_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-038-highland-securities/11_third_party/088_third_party_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-038-highland-securities/12_case_management/089_case_management_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-038-highland-securities/12_case_management/090_case_management_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-038-highland-securities/12_case_management/091_case_management_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-038-highland-securities/12_case_management/092_case_management_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-038-highland-securities/12_case_management/093_case_management_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-038-highland-securities/12_case_management/094_case_management_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-038-highland-securities/12_case_management/095_case_management_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-038-highland-securities/12_case_management/096_case_management_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-038-highland-securities/12_case_management/097_highland_securities_impact_population.xlsx"], "gold_output": {"advice_markdown": "# Decision note — Highland securities case hold audit\n\n## Recommendation\n\nAdd and collect supported custodians while documenting unreachable or duplicate accounts. The reconciled record supports 8 scoped actions and leaves 4 items on evidence hold.\n\nSelected option: `highland-securities:scoped-evidence`.\n\n## Why this is the supported option\n\nJoin executive roles before and after the acquisition, account ownership, hold receipts, and platform exports. The operative hold population and account-transition mapping define required collection.\n\n## Supported actions\n\n### CBP-038-01 — common-interest support gap (high)\n\nthe controlling threshold is 9% under CB-LD-2708-R114; the independently calculated result is 17% under CB-LD-2708-E894. Identity resolves to ENT-038-1000, revision REV-2026.1 is current, and Farah Ibrahim is active with capacity 2.\n\nAction: Create custodian-platform rows based on exact identity and effective ownership. Owner: Farah Ibrahim; due 2026-09-29.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_pleadings/001_pleadings_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/02_orders/013_orders_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/025_custodian_files_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/05_email_families/037_email_families_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/10_expert_material/073_expert_material_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/07_privilege_material/049_privilege_material_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/12_case_management/097_highland_securities_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-038-04 — privilege-log description defect (medium)\n\nthe permission is limited to Middle District of Tennessee under CB-LD-2708-R496; the matched activity occurred in Tennessee under CB-LD-2708-E970. Identity resolves to ENT-038-1003, revision REV-2026.4 is current, and Henry Cho is active with capacity 4.\n\nAction: Create custodian-platform rows based on exact identity and effective ownership. Owner: Henry Cho; due 2026-09-26.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_pleadings/004_pleadings_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/02_orders/016_orders_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/028_custodian_files_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/05_email_families/040_email_families_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/07_privilege_material/052_privilege_material_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/12_case_management/097_highland_securities_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-038-05 — deposition exhibit omission (medium)\n\nthe operative cap is $5,482,000.00 under CB-LD-2708-R136; the matched ledger population totals $5,529,236.00 under CB-LD-2708-E208. Identity resolves to ENT-038-1004, revision REV-2026.5 is current, and Maya Ellison is active with capacity 1.\n\nAction: Create custodian-platform rows based on exact identity and effective ownership. Owner: Maya Ellison; due 2026-09-25.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_pleadings/005_pleadings_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/017_requests_responses_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/029_custodian_files_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/041_chat_exports_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/09_depositions/065_depositions_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/12_case_management/097_highland_securities_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-038-06 — Bates-range overlap (medium)\n\ndelivery must use notices-highland_medical_analytics@example.test under CB-LD-2708-R933; the only matched receipt used archive-patel_securities_action@example.test under CB-LD-2708-E360. Identity resolves to ENT-038-1005, revision REV-2026.6 is current, and Jonas Feld is active with capacity 5.\n\nAction: Create custodian-platform rows based on exact identity and effective ownership. Owner: Jonas Feld; due 2026-09-24.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_pleadings/006_pleadings_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/018_requests_responses_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/030_custodian_files_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/042_chat_exports_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/12_case_management/090_case_management_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/10_expert_material/078_expert_material_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/12_case_management/097_highland_securities_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-038-07 — email-family separation (critical)\n\nan open exception blocks completion under CB-LD-2708-R229; the current status is open and unresolved under CB-LD-2708-E901. Identity resolves to ENT-038-1006, revision REV-2026.7 is current, and Willa Novak is active with capacity 5.\n\nAction: Create custodian-platform rows based on exact identity and effective ownership. Owner: Willa Novak; due 2026-09-23.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_pleadings/007_pleadings_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/019_requests_responses_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/031_custodian_files_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/043_chat_exports_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/12_case_management/097_highland_securities_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-038-08 — request-response mismatch (medium)\n\ncompletion is required by 2025-05-08 under CB-LD-2708-R942; the current event record shows completion on 2025-05-28 under CB-LD-2708-E678. Identity resolves to ENT-038-1007, revision REV-2026.1 is current, and Owen Delgado is active with capacity 2.\n\nAction: Create custodian-platform rows based on exact identity and effective ownership. Owner: Owen Delgado; due 2026-09-22.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_pleadings/008_pleadings_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/020_requests_responses_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/032_custodian_files_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/044_chat_exports_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/12_case_management/097_highland_securities_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-038-10 — collection-date inconsistency (high)\n\napproval must come from Amara Patel under CB-LD-2708-R321; the effective approval record names Henry Cho under CB-LD-2708-E271. Identity resolves to ENT-038-1009, revision REV-2026.3 is current, and Isaac Romero is active with capacity 2.\n\nAction: Create custodian-platform rows based on exact identity and effective ownership. Owner: Isaac Romero; due 2026-09-29.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/02_orders/010_orders_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/022_requests_responses_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/05_email_families/034_email_families_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/046_chat_exports_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/12_case_management/097_highland_securities_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-038-12 — production gap (critical)\n\nthe permission is limited to Middle District of Tennessee under CB-LD-2708-R993; the matched activity occurred in Tennessee under CB-LD-2708-E311. Identity resolves to ENT-038-1011, revision REV-2026.5 is current, and Rafael Okafor is active with capacity 6.\n\nAction: Create custodian-platform rows based on exact identity and effective ownership. Owner: Rafael Okafor; due 2026-09-27.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/02_orders/012_orders_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/024_requests_responses_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/05_email_families/036_email_families_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/048_chat_exports_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/12_case_management/097_highland_securities_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n## Evidence holds\n\n- **CBP-038-02 — expert draft segregation**: the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective. Next evidence: effective approval and an active owner with remaining capacity. Sources: `/workspace/documents/01_pleadings/002_pleadings_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/02_orders/014_orders_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/026_custodian_files_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/05_email_families/038_email_families_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/12_case_management/097_highland_securities_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-038-03 — meet-and-confer commitment**: the operational record relies on a superseded control revision. Next evidence: an operational record using the current effective revision. Sources: `/workspace/documents/01_pleadings/003_pleadings_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/02_orders/015_orders_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/027_custodian_files_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/05_email_families/039_email_families_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/10_expert_material/075_expert_material_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/08_production_logs/063_production_logs_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/12_case_management/097_highland_securities_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-038-09 — metadata field loss**: the current observation does not meet the operative trigger. Next evidence: a current observation that satisfies the operative trigger. Sources: `/workspace/documents/02_orders/009_orders_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/021_requests_responses_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/05_email_families/033_email_families_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/045_chat_exports_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/09_depositions/069_depositions_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/12_case_management/097_highland_securities_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-038-11 — protective-order designation error**: the operational record relies on a superseded control revision. Next evidence: an operational record using the current effective revision. Sources: `/workspace/documents/02_orders/011_orders_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/023_requests_responses_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/05_email_families/035_email_families_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/047_chat_exports_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/12_case_management/097_highland_securities_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n## Alternatives considered\n\n- `highland-securities:shortcut` — Collect every account ever associated with an executive name.: Use a plausible summary or one source without completing the controlling joins.\n- `highland-securities:blanket-hold` — Freeze the entire matter population: Treat supported actions and genuinely ambiguous records as if they were equally unresolved.\n\n## Assumptions and limits\n\nThis decision is limited to cb100-038-highland-securities, the supplied synthetic records, and the matter state as of 2026-09-30. Similar names, stale revisions, and pending authority are not treated as proof.\n", "decision": {"actions": [{"determination": "the controlling threshold is 9% under CB-LD-2708-R114; the independently calculated result is 17% under CB-LD-2708-E894. Identity resolves to ENT-038-1000, revision REV-2026.1 is current, and Farah Ibrahim is active with capacity 2.", "due_date": "2026-09-29", "id": "ACT-CBP-038-01", "identity_id": "ENT-038-1000", "issue": "common-interest support gap", "owner": "Farah Ibrahim", "portfolio_key": "CBP-038-01", "recommended_action": "Create custodian-platform rows based on exact identity and effective ownership. Owner: Farah Ibrahim; due 2026-09-29.", "severity": "high", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_pleadings/001_pleadings_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/02_orders/013_orders_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/025_custodian_files_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/05_email_families/037_email_families_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/10_expert_material/073_expert_material_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/07_privilege_material/049_privilege_material_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/12_case_management/097_highland_securities_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "the permission is limited to Middle District of Tennessee under CB-LD-2708-R496; the matched activity occurred in Tennessee under CB-LD-2708-E970. Identity resolves to ENT-038-1003, revision REV-2026.4 is current, and Henry Cho is active with capacity 4.", "due_date": "2026-09-26", "id": "ACT-CBP-038-04", "identity_id": "ENT-038-1003", "issue": "privilege-log description defect", "owner": "Henry Cho", "portfolio_key": "CBP-038-04", "recommended_action": "Create custodian-platform rows based on exact identity and effective ownership. Owner: Henry Cho; due 2026-09-26.", "severity": "medium", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_pleadings/004_pleadings_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/02_orders/016_orders_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/028_custodian_files_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/05_email_families/040_email_families_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/07_privilege_material/052_privilege_material_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/12_case_management/097_highland_securities_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "the operative cap is $5,482,000.00 under CB-LD-2708-R136; the matched ledger population totals $5,529,236.00 under CB-LD-2708-E208. Identity resolves to ENT-038-1004, revision REV-2026.5 is current, and Maya Ellison is active with capacity 1.", "due_date": "2026-09-25", "id": "ACT-CBP-038-05", "identity_id": "ENT-038-1004", "issue": "deposition exhibit omission", "owner": "Maya Ellison", "portfolio_key": "CBP-038-05", "recommended_action": "Create custodian-platform rows based on exact identity and effective ownership. Owner: Maya Ellison; due 2026-09-25.", "severity": "medium", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_pleadings/005_pleadings_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/017_requests_responses_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/029_custodian_files_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/041_chat_exports_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/09_depositions/065_depositions_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/12_case_management/097_highland_securities_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "delivery must use notices-highland_medical_analytics@example.test under CB-LD-2708-R933; the only matched receipt used archive-patel_securities_action@example.test under CB-LD-2708-E360. Identity resolves to ENT-038-1005, revision REV-2026.6 is current, and Jonas Feld is active with capacity 5.", "due_date": "2026-09-24", "id": "ACT-CBP-038-06", "identity_id": "ENT-038-1005", "issue": "Bates-range overlap", "owner": "Jonas Feld", "portfolio_key": "CBP-038-06", "recommended_action": "Create custodian-platform rows based on exact identity and effective ownership. Owner: Jonas Feld; due 2026-09-24.", "severity": "medium", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_pleadings/006_pleadings_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/018_requests_responses_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/030_custodian_files_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/042_chat_exports_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/12_case_management/090_case_management_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/10_expert_material/078_expert_material_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_case_management/097_highland_securities_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "an open exception blocks completion under CB-LD-2708-R229; the current status is open and unresolved under CB-LD-2708-E901. Identity resolves to ENT-038-1006, revision REV-2026.7 is current, and Willa Novak is active with capacity 5.", "due_date": "2026-09-23", "id": "ACT-CBP-038-07", "identity_id": "ENT-038-1006", "issue": "email-family separation", "owner": "Willa Novak", "portfolio_key": "CBP-038-07", "recommended_action": "Create custodian-platform rows based on exact identity and effective ownership. Owner: Willa Novak; due 2026-09-23.", "severity": "critical", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_pleadings/007_pleadings_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/019_requests_responses_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/031_custodian_files_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/043_chat_exports_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/12_case_management/097_highland_securities_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "completion is required by 2025-05-08 under CB-LD-2708-R942; the current event record shows completion on 2025-05-28 under CB-LD-2708-E678. Identity resolves to ENT-038-1007, revision REV-2026.1 is current, and Owen Delgado is active with capacity 2.", "due_date": "2026-09-22", "id": "ACT-CBP-038-08", "identity_id": "ENT-038-1007", "issue": "request-response mismatch", "owner": "Owen Delgado", "portfolio_key": "CBP-038-08", "recommended_action": "Create custodian-platform rows based on exact identity and effective ownership. Owner: Owen Delgado; due 2026-09-22.", "severity": "medium", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_pleadings/008_pleadings_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/020_requests_responses_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/032_custodian_files_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/044_chat_exports_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/12_case_management/097_highland_securities_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "approval must come from Amara Patel under CB-LD-2708-R321; the effective approval record names Henry Cho under CB-LD-2708-E271. Identity resolves to ENT-038-1009, revision REV-2026.3 is current, and Isaac Romero is active with capacity 2.", "due_date": "2026-09-29", "id": "ACT-CBP-038-10", "identity_id": "ENT-038-1009", "issue": "collection-date inconsistency", "owner": "Isaac Romero", "portfolio_key": "CBP-038-10", "recommended_action": "Create custodian-platform rows based on exact identity and effective ownership. Owner: Isaac Romero; due 2026-09-29.", "severity": "high", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_orders/010_orders_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/022_requests_responses_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/05_email_families/034_email_families_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/046_chat_exports_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_case_management/097_highland_securities_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "the permission is limited to Middle District of Tennessee under CB-LD-2708-R993; the matched activity occurred in Tennessee under CB-LD-2708-E311. Identity resolves to ENT-038-1011, revision REV-2026.5 is current, and Rafael Okafor is active with capacity 6.", "due_date": "2026-09-27", "id": "ACT-CBP-038-12", "identity_id": "ENT-038-1011", "issue": "production gap", "owner": "Rafael Okafor", "portfolio_key": "CBP-038-12", "recommended_action": "Create custodian-platform rows based on exact identity and effective ownership. Owner: Rafael Okafor; due 2026-09-27.", "severity": "critical", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_orders/012_orders_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/024_requests_responses_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/05_email_families/036_email_families_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/048_chat_exports_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_case_management/097_highland_securities_impact_population.xlsx"]}], "as_of": "2026-09-30", "decision": {"alternatives_considered": ["highland-securities:shortcut", "highland-securities:blanket-hold"], "question": "Which Highland custodians or platforms remain outside the hold and collection scope?", "rationale": "The four-part causal test supports 8 scoped actions and leaves 4 records on evidence hold. The operative hold population and account-transition mapping define required collection.", "recommendation": "Add and collect supported custodians while documenting unreachable or duplicate accounts.", "selected_option_id": "highland-securities:scoped-evidence"}, "holds": [{"id": "HOLD-CBP-038-02", "issue": "expert draft segregation", "portfolio_key": "CBP-038-02", "reason": "the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective", "required_next_evidence": "effective approval and an active owner with remaining capacity", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_pleadings/002_pleadings_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/02_orders/014_orders_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/026_custodian_files_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/05_email_families/038_email_families_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_case_management/097_highland_securities_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-038-03", "issue": "meet-and-confer commitment", "portfolio_key": "CBP-038-03", "reason": "the operational record relies on a superseded control revision", "required_next_evidence": "an operational record using the current effective revision", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_pleadings/003_pleadings_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/02_orders/015_orders_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/027_custodian_files_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/05_email_families/039_email_families_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/10_expert_material/075_expert_material_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/08_production_logs/063_production_logs_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_case_management/097_highland_securities_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-038-09", "issue": "metadata field loss", "portfolio_key": "CBP-038-09", "reason": "the current observation does not meet the operative trigger", "required_next_evidence": "a current observation that satisfies the operative trigger", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_orders/009_orders_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/021_requests_responses_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/05_email_families/033_email_families_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/045_chat_exports_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/09_depositions/069_depositions_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_case_management/097_highland_securities_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-038-11", "issue": "protective-order designation error", "portfolio_key": "CBP-038-11", "reason": "the operational record relies on a superseded control revision", "required_next_evidence": "an operational record using the current effective revision", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_orders/011_orders_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/023_requests_responses_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/05_email_families/035_email_families_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/047_chat_exports_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_case_management/097_highland_securities_impact_population.xlsx"]}], "matter_number": "CB-LD-2708", "prepared_for": "Highland Medical Analytics", "schema_version": "counselbench.decision.v3", "task_id": "cb100-038-highland-securities"}, "matter_register": {"matter_number": "CB-LD-2708", "rows": [{"decision_option_id": "highland-securities:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-29", "issue": "common-interest support gap", "matter_number": "CB-LD-2708", "owner": "Farah Ibrahim", "portfolio_key": "CBP-038-01", "row_id": "REG-CBP-038-01", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_pleadings/001_pleadings_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/02_orders/013_orders_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/025_custodian_files_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/05_email_families/037_email_families_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/10_expert_material/073_expert_material_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/07_privilege_material/049_privilege_material_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/12_case_management/097_highland_securities_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "highland-securities:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective", "issue": "expert draft segregation", "matter_number": "CB-LD-2708", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-038-02", "row_id": "REG-CBP-038-02", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_pleadings/002_pleadings_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/02_orders/014_orders_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/026_custodian_files_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/05_email_families/038_email_families_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_case_management/097_highland_securities_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "highland-securities:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "the operational record relies on a superseded control revision", "issue": "meet-and-confer commitment", "matter_number": "CB-LD-2708", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-038-03", "row_id": "REG-CBP-038-03", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_pleadings/003_pleadings_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/02_orders/015_orders_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/027_custodian_files_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/05_email_families/039_email_families_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/10_expert_material/075_expert_material_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/08_production_logs/063_production_logs_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_case_management/097_highland_securities_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "highland-securities:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-26", "issue": "privilege-log description defect", "matter_number": "CB-LD-2708", "owner": "Henry Cho", "portfolio_key": "CBP-038-04", "row_id": "REG-CBP-038-04", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_pleadings/004_pleadings_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/02_orders/016_orders_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/028_custodian_files_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/05_email_families/040_email_families_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/07_privilege_material/052_privilege_material_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/12_case_management/097_highland_securities_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "highland-securities:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-25", "issue": "deposition exhibit omission", "matter_number": "CB-LD-2708", "owner": "Maya Ellison", "portfolio_key": "CBP-038-05", "row_id": "REG-CBP-038-05", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_pleadings/005_pleadings_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/017_requests_responses_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/029_custodian_files_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/041_chat_exports_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/09_depositions/065_depositions_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/12_case_management/097_highland_securities_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "highland-securities:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-24", "issue": "Bates-range overlap", "matter_number": "CB-LD-2708", "owner": "Jonas Feld", "portfolio_key": "CBP-038-06", "row_id": "REG-CBP-038-06", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_pleadings/006_pleadings_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/018_requests_responses_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/030_custodian_files_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/042_chat_exports_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/12_case_management/090_case_management_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/10_expert_material/078_expert_material_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_case_management/097_highland_securities_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "highland-securities:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-23", "issue": "email-family separation", "matter_number": "CB-LD-2708", "owner": "Willa Novak", "portfolio_key": "CBP-038-07", "row_id": "REG-CBP-038-07", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_pleadings/007_pleadings_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/019_requests_responses_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/031_custodian_files_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/043_chat_exports_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/12_case_management/097_highland_securities_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "highland-securities:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-22", "issue": "request-response mismatch", "matter_number": "CB-LD-2708", "owner": "Owen Delgado", "portfolio_key": "CBP-038-08", "row_id": "REG-CBP-038-08", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_pleadings/008_pleadings_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/020_requests_responses_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/032_custodian_files_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/044_chat_exports_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/12_case_management/097_highland_securities_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "highland-securities:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "the current observation does not meet the operative trigger", "issue": "metadata field loss", "matter_number": "CB-LD-2708", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-038-09", "row_id": "REG-CBP-038-09", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_orders/009_orders_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/021_requests_responses_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/05_email_families/033_email_families_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/045_chat_exports_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/09_depositions/069_depositions_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_case_management/097_highland_securities_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "highland-securities:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-29", "issue": "collection-date inconsistency", "matter_number": "CB-LD-2708", "owner": "Isaac Romero", "portfolio_key": "CBP-038-10", "row_id": "REG-CBP-038-10", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_orders/010_orders_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/022_requests_responses_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/05_email_families/034_email_families_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/046_chat_exports_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_case_management/097_highland_securities_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "highland-securities:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "the operational record relies on a superseded control revision", "issue": "protective-order designation error", "matter_number": "CB-LD-2708", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-038-11", "row_id": "REG-CBP-038-11", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_orders/011_orders_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/023_requests_responses_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/05_email_families/035_email_families_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/047_chat_exports_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_case_management/097_highland_securities_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "highland-securities:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-27", "issue": "production gap", "matter_number": "CB-LD-2708", "owner": "Rafael Okafor", "portfolio_key": "CBP-038-12", "row_id": "REG-CBP-038-12", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_orders/012_orders_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/024_requests_responses_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/05_email_families/036_email_families_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/048_chat_exports_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_case_management/097_highland_securities_impact_population.xlsx"]}], "schema_version": "counselbench.matter-register.v3", "task_id": "cb100-038-highland-securities"}}, "metadata": {"benchmark": "CounselBench-100", "code_license": "Apache-2.0", "data_license": "CC-BY-4.0", "deadline": "2026-09-30", "document_count": 97, "evidence_holds": 4, "jurisdiction": "Tennessee", "matter_number": "CB-LD-2708", "mcp_commit": "9a96ea6e5913736f92b88345bf51caeaaa8e719f", "mcp_package": "@modelcontextprotocol/server-filesystem@2026.7.10", "practice_area": "litigation-discovery", "reference_tool_calls": 82, "required_evidence_reads": 59, "supported_actions": 8, "synthetic": true, "venue": "Middle District of Tennessee", "version": "3.1.0"}, "prompt": "There is enough noise in this file that a name match or newest-document shortcut will be dangerous. Which Highland custodians or platforms remain outside the hold and collection scope? A securities action requires collection from executives, messaging platforms, and board portals after an acquisition changed account ownership. The team needs the call by 2026-09-30. Leave the defensible result in the matter workspace, including any item that must stay on hold for better evidence.", "rubric": {"criteria": [{"category": "investigation", "description": "Inventory the production and use targeted searches to locate records across native formats.", "id": "investigation.discover_production"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Complete every task-specific identity, authority, operations, and approval read before the first state transition.", "id": "investigation.read_before_write"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Inspect designated source metadata before relying on those records.", "id": "investigation.custody_before_write"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "Select the supported option 'highland-securities:scoped-evidence' after applying the four-part test.", "id": "decision.selected_option"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "Identify both rejected approaches and explain why a one-source shortcut and a blanket hold are wrong.", "id": "decision.alternatives"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-038-01 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_pleadings/001_pleadings_source_export.md rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-038-01.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_orders/013_orders_source_export.json for common-interest support gap.", "id": "investigation.CBP-038-01.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/025_custodian_files_source_export.md to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-038-01.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_email_families/037_email_families_source_export.json.", "id": "investigation.CBP-038-01.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-038-01 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-038-01.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-038-01 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-038-01.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-038-02 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_pleadings/002_pleadings_source_export.txt rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-038-02.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_orders/014_orders_source_export.xml for expert draft segregation.", "id": "investigation.CBP-038-02.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/026_custodian_files_source_export.txt to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-038-02.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_email_families/038_email_families_source_export.xml.", "id": "investigation.CBP-038-02.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-038-02 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective.", "id": "decision.CBP-038-02.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-038-02 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-038-02.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-038-03 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_pleadings/003_pleadings_source_export.eml rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-038-03.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_orders/015_orders_source_export.html for meet-and-confer commitment.", "id": "investigation.CBP-038-03.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/027_custodian_files_source_export.eml to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-038-03.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_email_families/039_email_families_source_export.html.", "id": "investigation.CBP-038-03.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-038-03 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is the operational record relies on a superseded control revision.", "id": "decision.CBP-038-03.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-038-03 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-038-03.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-038-04 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_pleadings/004_pleadings_source_export.csv rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-038-04.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_orders/016_orders_source_export.pdf for privilege-log description defect.", "id": "investigation.CBP-038-04.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/028_custodian_files_source_export.csv to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-038-04.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_email_families/040_email_families_source_export.pdf.", "id": "investigation.CBP-038-04.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-038-04 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-038-04.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-038-04 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-038-04.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-038-05 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_pleadings/005_pleadings_source_export.json rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-038-05.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/017_requests_responses_source_export.md for deposition exhibit omission.", "id": "investigation.CBP-038-05.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/029_custodian_files_source_export.json to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-038-05.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/041_chat_exports_source_export.md.", "id": "investigation.CBP-038-05.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-038-05 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-038-05.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-038-05 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-038-05.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-038-06 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_pleadings/006_pleadings_source_export.xml rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-038-06.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/018_requests_responses_source_export.txt for Bates-range overlap.", "id": "investigation.CBP-038-06.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/030_custodian_files_source_export.xml to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-038-06.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/042_chat_exports_source_export.txt.", "id": "investigation.CBP-038-06.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-038-06 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-038-06.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-038-06 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-038-06.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-038-07 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_pleadings/007_pleadings_source_export.html rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-038-07.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/019_requests_responses_source_export.eml for email-family separation.", "id": "investigation.CBP-038-07.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/031_custodian_files_source_export.html to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-038-07.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/043_chat_exports_source_export.eml.", "id": "investigation.CBP-038-07.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-038-07 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-038-07.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-038-07 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-038-07.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-038-08 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_pleadings/008_pleadings_source_export.pdf rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-038-08.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/020_requests_responses_source_export.csv for request-response mismatch.", "id": "investigation.CBP-038-08.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/032_custodian_files_source_export.pdf to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-038-08.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/044_chat_exports_source_export.csv.", "id": "investigation.CBP-038-08.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-038-08 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-038-08.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-038-08 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-038-08.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-038-09 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_orders/009_orders_source_export.md rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-038-09.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/021_requests_responses_source_export.json for metadata field loss.", "id": "investigation.CBP-038-09.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_email_families/033_email_families_source_export.md to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-038-09.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/045_chat_exports_source_export.json.", "id": "investigation.CBP-038-09.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-038-09 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is the current observation does not meet the operative trigger.", "id": "decision.CBP-038-09.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-038-09 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-038-09.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-038-10 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_orders/010_orders_source_export.txt rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-038-10.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/022_requests_responses_source_export.xml for collection-date inconsistency.", "id": "investigation.CBP-038-10.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_email_families/034_email_families_source_export.txt to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-038-10.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/046_chat_exports_source_export.xml.", "id": "investigation.CBP-038-10.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-038-10 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-038-10.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-038-10 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-038-10.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-038-11 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_orders/011_orders_source_export.eml rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-038-11.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/023_requests_responses_source_export.html for protective-order designation error.", "id": "investigation.CBP-038-11.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_email_families/035_email_families_source_export.eml to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-038-11.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/047_chat_exports_source_export.html.", "id": "investigation.CBP-038-11.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-038-11 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is the operational record relies on a superseded control revision.", "id": "decision.CBP-038-11.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-038-11 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-038-11.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-038-12 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_orders/012_orders_source_export.csv rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-038-12.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/024_requests_responses_source_export.pdf for production gap.", "id": "investigation.CBP-038-12.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_email_families/036_email_families_source_export.csv to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-038-12.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/048_chat_exports_source_export.pdf.", "id": "investigation.CBP-038-12.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-038-12 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-038-12.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-038-12 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-038-12.register"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Write the exact selected option, supported action population, evidence-hold population, facts, owners, deadlines, and citations.", "id": "state.exact_decision"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create one exact register row per portfolio key with no extra, missing, or modified row.", "id": "state.exact_register"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Leave only the three approved deliverables and perform no extra state-changing write.", "id": "state.write_scope_containment"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Read back decision.json, matter-register.json, and advice.md after their final writes.", "id": "state.postwrite_readback"}, {"category": "answer", "description": "Explain the selected recommendation, supported actions, holds, alternatives, and limitations with exact source anchors.", "id": "answer.decision_note"}], "decision_options": [{"approach": "Use a plausible summary or one source without completing the controlling joins.", "id": "highland-securities:shortcut", "label": "Collect every account ever associated with an executive name."}, {"approach": "Treat supported actions and genuinely ambiguous records as if they were equally unresolved.", "id": "highland-securities:blanket-hold", "label": "Freeze the entire matter population"}, {"approach": "Apply the exact identity, current-state, authority, and revision test. Create custodian-platform rows based on exact identity and effective ownership.", "id": "highland-securities:scoped-evidence", "label": "Add and collect supported custodians while documenting unreachable or duplicate accounts."}], "evaluation_narrative": {"authority": "The operative hold population and account-transition mapping define required collection.", "observation": "Join executive roles before and after the acquisition, account ownership, hold receipts, and platform exports.", "question": "Which Highland custodians or platforms remain outside the hold and collection scope?", "register_action": "Create custodian-platform rows based on exact identity and effective ownership."}, "gates": ["all_required_evidence_precedes_first_write", "decision_criteria_complete", "register_state_exact", "write_scope_contained", "all_outputs_verified_by_readback"], "metadata_checks": 11, "metric": "weighted_criteria_score", "minimum_tool_calls": 82, "required_deliverables": ["decision.json", "matter-register.json", "advice.md"], "required_document_reads": 59, "type": "deterministic", "weights": {"advice": 0.15, "decision": 0.35, "investigation": 0.25, "state": 0.25}}, "task_id": "cb100-038-highland-securities", "task_name": "Highland securities case hold audit", "world_id": "counselbench-filesystem-mcp-v3"}
+{"context_files": ["task_files/cb100-039-isotope-environmental/01_pleadings/001_pleadings_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-039-isotope-environmental/01_pleadings/002_pleadings_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-039-isotope-environmental/01_pleadings/003_pleadings_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-039-isotope-environmental/01_pleadings/004_pleadings_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-039-isotope-environmental/01_pleadings/005_pleadings_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-039-isotope-environmental/01_pleadings/006_pleadings_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-039-isotope-environmental/01_pleadings/007_pleadings_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-039-isotope-environmental/01_pleadings/008_pleadings_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-039-isotope-environmental/02_orders/009_orders_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-039-isotope-environmental/02_orders/010_orders_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-039-isotope-environmental/02_orders/011_orders_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-039-isotope-environmental/02_orders/012_orders_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-039-isotope-environmental/02_orders/013_orders_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-039-isotope-environmental/02_orders/014_orders_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-039-isotope-environmental/02_orders/015_orders_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-039-isotope-environmental/02_orders/016_orders_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-039-isotope-environmental/03_requests_responses/017_requests_responses_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-039-isotope-environmental/03_requests_responses/018_requests_responses_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-039-isotope-environmental/03_requests_responses/019_requests_responses_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-039-isotope-environmental/03_requests_responses/020_requests_responses_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-039-isotope-environmental/03_requests_responses/021_requests_responses_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-039-isotope-environmental/03_requests_responses/022_requests_responses_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-039-isotope-environmental/03_requests_responses/023_requests_responses_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-039-isotope-environmental/03_requests_responses/024_requests_responses_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-039-isotope-environmental/04_custodian_files/025_custodian_files_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-039-isotope-environmental/04_custodian_files/026_custodian_files_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-039-isotope-environmental/04_custodian_files/027_custodian_files_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-039-isotope-environmental/04_custodian_files/028_custodian_files_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-039-isotope-environmental/04_custodian_files/029_custodian_files_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-039-isotope-environmental/04_custodian_files/030_custodian_files_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-039-isotope-environmental/04_custodian_files/031_custodian_files_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-039-isotope-environmental/04_custodian_files/032_custodian_files_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-039-isotope-environmental/05_email_families/033_email_families_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-039-isotope-environmental/05_email_families/034_email_families_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-039-isotope-environmental/05_email_families/035_email_families_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-039-isotope-environmental/05_email_families/036_email_families_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-039-isotope-environmental/05_email_families/037_email_families_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-039-isotope-environmental/05_email_families/038_email_families_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-039-isotope-environmental/05_email_families/039_email_families_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-039-isotope-environmental/05_email_families/040_email_families_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-039-isotope-environmental/06_chat_exports/041_chat_exports_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-039-isotope-environmental/06_chat_exports/042_chat_exports_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-039-isotope-environmental/06_chat_exports/043_chat_exports_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-039-isotope-environmental/06_chat_exports/044_chat_exports_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-039-isotope-environmental/06_chat_exports/045_chat_exports_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-039-isotope-environmental/06_chat_exports/046_chat_exports_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-039-isotope-environmental/06_chat_exports/047_chat_exports_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-039-isotope-environmental/06_chat_exports/048_chat_exports_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-039-isotope-environmental/07_privilege_material/049_privilege_material_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-039-isotope-environmental/07_privilege_material/050_privilege_material_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-039-isotope-environmental/07_privilege_material/051_privilege_material_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-039-isotope-environmental/07_privilege_material/052_privilege_material_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-039-isotope-environmental/07_privilege_material/053_privilege_material_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-039-isotope-environmental/07_privilege_material/054_privilege_material_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-039-isotope-environmental/07_privilege_material/055_privilege_material_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-039-isotope-environmental/07_privilege_material/056_privilege_material_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-039-isotope-environmental/08_production_logs/057_production_logs_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-039-isotope-environmental/08_production_logs/058_production_logs_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-039-isotope-environmental/08_production_logs/059_production_logs_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-039-isotope-environmental/08_production_logs/060_production_logs_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-039-isotope-environmental/08_production_logs/061_production_logs_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-039-isotope-environmental/08_production_logs/062_production_logs_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-039-isotope-environmental/08_production_logs/063_production_logs_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-039-isotope-environmental/08_production_logs/064_production_logs_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-039-isotope-environmental/09_depositions/065_depositions_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-039-isotope-environmental/09_depositions/066_depositions_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-039-isotope-environmental/09_depositions/067_depositions_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-039-isotope-environmental/09_depositions/068_depositions_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-039-isotope-environmental/09_depositions/069_depositions_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-039-isotope-environmental/09_depositions/070_depositions_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-039-isotope-environmental/09_depositions/071_depositions_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-039-isotope-environmental/09_depositions/072_depositions_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-039-isotope-environmental/10_expert_material/073_expert_material_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-039-isotope-environmental/10_expert_material/074_expert_material_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-039-isotope-environmental/10_expert_material/075_expert_material_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-039-isotope-environmental/10_expert_material/076_expert_material_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-039-isotope-environmental/10_expert_material/077_expert_material_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-039-isotope-environmental/10_expert_material/078_expert_material_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-039-isotope-environmental/10_expert_material/079_expert_material_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-039-isotope-environmental/10_expert_material/080_expert_material_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-039-isotope-environmental/11_third_party/081_third_party_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-039-isotope-environmental/11_third_party/082_third_party_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-039-isotope-environmental/11_third_party/083_third_party_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-039-isotope-environmental/11_third_party/084_third_party_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-039-isotope-environmental/11_third_party/085_third_party_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-039-isotope-environmental/11_third_party/086_third_party_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-039-isotope-environmental/11_third_party/087_third_party_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-039-isotope-environmental/11_third_party/088_third_party_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-039-isotope-environmental/12_case_management/089_case_management_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-039-isotope-environmental/12_case_management/090_case_management_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-039-isotope-environmental/12_case_management/091_case_management_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-039-isotope-environmental/12_case_management/092_case_management_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-039-isotope-environmental/12_case_management/093_case_management_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-039-isotope-environmental/12_case_management/094_case_management_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-039-isotope-environmental/12_case_management/095_case_management_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-039-isotope-environmental/12_case_management/096_case_management_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-039-isotope-environmental/12_case_management/097_isotope_environmental_impact_population.xlsx"], "gold_output": {"advice_markdown": "# Decision note — Isotope contamination case production check\n\n## Recommendation\n\nRedesignate, supplement, or segregate only the supported files. The reconciled record supports 7 scoped actions and leaves 5 items on evidence hold.\n\nSelected option: `isotope-environmental:scoped-evidence`.\n\n## Why this is the supported option\n\nMatch drafts, recipients, expert designation dates, metadata, and confidentiality labels by file lineage. Discovery rules and the protective order apply according to purpose, timing, and exact document family.\n\n## Supported actions\n\n### CBP-039-04 — common-interest support gap (medium)\n\nthe controlling threshold is 8% under CB-LD-2709-R189; the independently calculated result is 15% under CB-LD-2709-E846. Identity resolves to ENT-039-1003, revision REV-2025.4 is current, and Farah Ibrahim is active with capacity 5.\n\nAction: Register file-level decisions and hold records with broken lineage. Owner: Farah Ibrahim; due 2026-09-29.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_pleadings/004_pleadings_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/02_orders/016_orders_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/028_custodian_files_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/05_email_families/040_email_families_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/12_case_management/097_isotope_environmental_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-039-05 — expert draft segregation (medium)\n\napproval must come from Nora Chen under CB-LD-2709-R356; the effective approval record names Henry Cho under CB-LD-2709-E962. Identity resolves to ENT-039-1004, revision REV-2025.5 is current, and Dominic Alvarez is active with capacity 4.\n\nAction: Register file-level decisions and hold records with broken lineage. Owner: Dominic Alvarez; due 2026-09-28.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_pleadings/005_pleadings_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/017_requests_responses_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/029_custodian_files_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/041_chat_exports_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/07_privilege_material/053_privilege_material_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/12_case_management/097_isotope_environmental_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-039-06 — meet-and-confer commitment (high)\n\nthe controlled population contains 138 records under CB-LD-2709-R816; the certification covers 99 records under CB-LD-2709-E353. Identity resolves to ENT-039-1005, revision REV-2025.6 is current, and Leona Park is active with capacity 1.\n\nAction: Register file-level decisions and hold records with broken lineage. Owner: Leona Park; due 2026-09-27.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_pleadings/006_pleadings_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/018_requests_responses_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/030_custodian_files_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/042_chat_exports_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/10_expert_material/078_expert_material_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/09_depositions/066_depositions_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/12_case_management/097_isotope_environmental_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-039-07 — privilege-log description defect (critical)\n\nthe permission is limited to Eastern District of Louisiana under CB-LD-2709-R276; the matched activity occurred in Louisiana under CB-LD-2709-E322. Identity resolves to ENT-039-1006, revision REV-2025.7 is current, and Henry Cho is active with capacity 5.\n\nAction: Register file-level decisions and hold records with broken lineage. Owner: Henry Cho; due 2026-09-26.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_pleadings/007_pleadings_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/019_requests_responses_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/031_custodian_files_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/043_chat_exports_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/12_case_management/097_isotope_environmental_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-039-08 — deposition exhibit omission (medium)\n\nthe operative cap is $1,762,000.00 under CB-LD-2709-R556; the matched ledger population totals $1,948,556.00 under CB-LD-2709-E497. Identity resolves to ENT-039-1007, revision REV-2025.1 is current, and Maya Ellison is active with capacity 4.\n\nAction: Register file-level decisions and hold records with broken lineage. Owner: Maya Ellison; due 2026-09-25.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_pleadings/008_pleadings_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/020_requests_responses_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/032_custodian_files_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/044_chat_exports_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/09_depositions/068_depositions_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/12_case_management/097_isotope_environmental_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-039-09 — Bates-range overlap (high)\n\ndelivery must use notices-isotope_specialty_chemicals@example.test under CB-LD-2709-R860; the only matched receipt used archive-county_of_briar_v_isotope@example.test under CB-LD-2709-E991. Identity resolves to ENT-039-1008, revision REV-2025.2 is current, and Jonas Feld is active with capacity 3.\n\nAction: Register file-level decisions and hold records with broken lineage. Owner: Jonas Feld; due 2026-09-24.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/02_orders/009_orders_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/021_requests_responses_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/05_email_families/033_email_families_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/045_chat_exports_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/12_case_management/097_isotope_environmental_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-039-11 — request-response mismatch (high)\n\ncompletion is required by 2025-10-04 under CB-LD-2709-R971; the current event record shows completion on 2025-10-21 under CB-LD-2709-E945. Identity resolves to ENT-039-1010, revision REV-2025.4 is current, and Owen Delgado is active with capacity 3.\n\nAction: Register file-level decisions and hold records with broken lineage. Owner: Owen Delgado; due 2026-10-01.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/02_orders/011_orders_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/023_requests_responses_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/05_email_families/035_email_families_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/047_chat_exports_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/08_production_logs/059_production_logs_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/11_third_party/083_third_party_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/12_case_management/097_isotope_environmental_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n## Evidence holds\n\n- **CBP-039-01 — clawback deadline**: the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective. Next evidence: effective approval and an active owner with remaining capacity. Sources: `/workspace/documents/01_pleadings/001_pleadings_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/02_orders/013_orders_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/025_custodian_files_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/05_email_families/037_email_families_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/07_privilege_material/049_privilege_material_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/12_case_management/097_isotope_environmental_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-039-02 — third-party subpoena deadline**: the operational record relies on a superseded control revision. Next evidence: an operational record using the current effective revision. Sources: `/workspace/documents/01_pleadings/002_pleadings_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/02_orders/014_orders_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/026_custodian_files_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/05_email_families/038_email_families_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/07_privilege_material/050_privilege_material_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/10_expert_material/074_expert_material_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/12_case_management/097_isotope_environmental_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-039-03 — custodian omission**: two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key. Next evidence: an approved immutable entity crosswalk. Sources: `/workspace/documents/01_pleadings/003_pleadings_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/02_orders/015_orders_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/027_custodian_files_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/05_email_families/039_email_families_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/07_privilege_material/051_privilege_material_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/12_case_management/097_isotope_environmental_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-039-10 — email-family separation**: the operational record relies on a superseded control revision. Next evidence: an operational record using the current effective revision. Sources: `/workspace/documents/02_orders/010_orders_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/022_requests_responses_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/05_email_families/034_email_families_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/046_chat_exports_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/12_case_management/094_case_management_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/08_production_logs/058_production_logs_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/12_case_management/097_isotope_environmental_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-039-12 — metadata field loss**: the current observation does not meet the operative trigger. Next evidence: a current observation that satisfies the operative trigger. Sources: `/workspace/documents/02_orders/012_orders_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/024_requests_responses_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/05_email_families/036_email_families_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/048_chat_exports_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/11_third_party/084_third_party_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/12_case_management/097_isotope_environmental_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n## Alternatives considered\n\n- `isotope-environmental:blanket-hold` — Freeze the entire matter population: Treat supported actions and genuinely ambiguous records as if they were equally unresolved.\n- `isotope-environmental:shortcut` — Treat all consultant drafts as protected expert material.: Use a plausible summary or one source without completing the controlling joins.\n\n## Assumptions and limits\n\nThis decision is limited to cb100-039-isotope-environmental, the supplied synthetic records, and the matter state as of 2026-10-03. Similar names, stale revisions, and pending authority are not treated as proof.\n", "decision": {"actions": [{"determination": "the controlling threshold is 8% under CB-LD-2709-R189; the independently calculated result is 15% under CB-LD-2709-E846. Identity resolves to ENT-039-1003, revision REV-2025.4 is current, and Farah Ibrahim is active with capacity 5.", "due_date": "2026-09-29", "id": "ACT-CBP-039-04", "identity_id": "ENT-039-1003", "issue": "common-interest support gap", "owner": "Farah Ibrahim", "portfolio_key": "CBP-039-04", "recommended_action": "Register file-level decisions and hold records with broken lineage. Owner: Farah Ibrahim; due 2026-09-29.", "severity": "medium", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_pleadings/004_pleadings_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/02_orders/016_orders_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/028_custodian_files_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/05_email_families/040_email_families_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_case_management/097_isotope_environmental_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "approval must come from Nora Chen under CB-LD-2709-R356; the effective approval record names Henry Cho under CB-LD-2709-E962. Identity resolves to ENT-039-1004, revision REV-2025.5 is current, and Dominic Alvarez is active with capacity 4.", "due_date": "2026-09-28", "id": "ACT-CBP-039-05", "identity_id": "ENT-039-1004", "issue": "expert draft segregation", "owner": "Dominic Alvarez", "portfolio_key": "CBP-039-05", "recommended_action": "Register file-level decisions and hold records with broken lineage. Owner: Dominic Alvarez; due 2026-09-28.", "severity": "medium", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_pleadings/005_pleadings_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/017_requests_responses_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/029_custodian_files_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/041_chat_exports_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/07_privilege_material/053_privilege_material_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_case_management/097_isotope_environmental_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "the controlled population contains 138 records under CB-LD-2709-R816; the certification covers 99 records under CB-LD-2709-E353. Identity resolves to ENT-039-1005, revision REV-2025.6 is current, and Leona Park is active with capacity 1.", "due_date": "2026-09-27", "id": "ACT-CBP-039-06", "identity_id": "ENT-039-1005", "issue": "meet-and-confer commitment", "owner": "Leona Park", "portfolio_key": "CBP-039-06", "recommended_action": "Register file-level decisions and hold records with broken lineage. Owner: Leona Park; due 2026-09-27.", "severity": "high", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_pleadings/006_pleadings_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/018_requests_responses_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/030_custodian_files_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/042_chat_exports_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/10_expert_material/078_expert_material_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/09_depositions/066_depositions_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/12_case_management/097_isotope_environmental_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "the permission is limited to Eastern District of Louisiana under CB-LD-2709-R276; the matched activity occurred in Louisiana under CB-LD-2709-E322. Identity resolves to ENT-039-1006, revision REV-2025.7 is current, and Henry Cho is active with capacity 5.", "due_date": "2026-09-26", "id": "ACT-CBP-039-07", "identity_id": "ENT-039-1006", "issue": "privilege-log description defect", "owner": "Henry Cho", "portfolio_key": "CBP-039-07", "recommended_action": "Register file-level decisions and hold records with broken lineage. Owner: Henry Cho; due 2026-09-26.", "severity": "critical", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_pleadings/007_pleadings_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/019_requests_responses_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/031_custodian_files_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/043_chat_exports_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/12_case_management/097_isotope_environmental_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "the operative cap is $1,762,000.00 under CB-LD-2709-R556; the matched ledger population totals $1,948,556.00 under CB-LD-2709-E497. Identity resolves to ENT-039-1007, revision REV-2025.1 is current, and Maya Ellison is active with capacity 4.", "due_date": "2026-09-25", "id": "ACT-CBP-039-08", "identity_id": "ENT-039-1007", "issue": "deposition exhibit omission", "owner": "Maya Ellison", "portfolio_key": "CBP-039-08", "recommended_action": "Register file-level decisions and hold records with broken lineage. Owner: Maya Ellison; due 2026-09-25.", "severity": "medium", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_pleadings/008_pleadings_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/020_requests_responses_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/032_custodian_files_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/044_chat_exports_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/09_depositions/068_depositions_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/12_case_management/097_isotope_environmental_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "delivery must use notices-isotope_specialty_chemicals@example.test under CB-LD-2709-R860; the only matched receipt used archive-county_of_briar_v_isotope@example.test under CB-LD-2709-E991. Identity resolves to ENT-039-1008, revision REV-2025.2 is current, and Jonas Feld is active with capacity 3.", "due_date": "2026-09-24", "id": "ACT-CBP-039-09", "identity_id": "ENT-039-1008", "issue": "Bates-range overlap", "owner": "Jonas Feld", "portfolio_key": "CBP-039-09", "recommended_action": "Register file-level decisions and hold records with broken lineage. Owner: Jonas Feld; due 2026-09-24.", "severity": "high", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_orders/009_orders_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/021_requests_responses_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/05_email_families/033_email_families_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/045_chat_exports_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_case_management/097_isotope_environmental_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "completion is required by 2025-10-04 under CB-LD-2709-R971; the current event record shows completion on 2025-10-21 under CB-LD-2709-E945. Identity resolves to ENT-039-1010, revision REV-2025.4 is current, and Owen Delgado is active with capacity 3.", "due_date": "2026-10-01", "id": "ACT-CBP-039-11", "identity_id": "ENT-039-1010", "issue": "request-response mismatch", "owner": "Owen Delgado", "portfolio_key": "CBP-039-11", "recommended_action": "Register file-level decisions and hold records with broken lineage. Owner: Owen Delgado; due 2026-10-01.", "severity": "high", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_orders/011_orders_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/023_requests_responses_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/05_email_families/035_email_families_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/047_chat_exports_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/08_production_logs/059_production_logs_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/11_third_party/083_third_party_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/12_case_management/097_isotope_environmental_impact_population.xlsx"]}], "as_of": "2026-10-03", "decision": {"alternatives_considered": ["isotope-environmental:blanket-hold", "isotope-environmental:shortcut"], "question": "How should Isotope treat the sampling, consultant, and regulator materials in production?", "rationale": "The four-part causal test supports 7 scoped actions and leaves 5 records on evidence hold. Discovery rules and the protective order apply according to purpose, timing, and exact document family.", "recommendation": "Redesignate, supplement, or segregate only the supported files.", "selected_option_id": "isotope-environmental:scoped-evidence"}, "holds": [{"id": "HOLD-CBP-039-01", "issue": "clawback deadline", "portfolio_key": "CBP-039-01", "reason": "the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective", "required_next_evidence": "effective approval and an active owner with remaining capacity", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_pleadings/001_pleadings_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/02_orders/013_orders_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/025_custodian_files_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/05_email_families/037_email_families_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/07_privilege_material/049_privilege_material_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/12_case_management/097_isotope_environmental_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-039-02", "issue": "third-party subpoena deadline", "portfolio_key": "CBP-039-02", "reason": "the operational record relies on a superseded control revision", "required_next_evidence": "an operational record using the current effective revision", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_pleadings/002_pleadings_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/02_orders/014_orders_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/026_custodian_files_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/05_email_families/038_email_families_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/07_privilege_material/050_privilege_material_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/10_expert_material/074_expert_material_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/12_case_management/097_isotope_environmental_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-039-03", "issue": "custodian omission", "portfolio_key": "CBP-039-03", "reason": "two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key", "required_next_evidence": "an approved immutable entity crosswalk", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_pleadings/003_pleadings_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/02_orders/015_orders_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/027_custodian_files_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/05_email_families/039_email_families_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/07_privilege_material/051_privilege_material_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/12_case_management/097_isotope_environmental_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-039-10", "issue": "email-family separation", "portfolio_key": "CBP-039-10", "reason": "the operational record relies on a superseded control revision", "required_next_evidence": "an operational record using the current effective revision", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_orders/010_orders_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/022_requests_responses_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/05_email_families/034_email_families_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/046_chat_exports_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_case_management/094_case_management_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/08_production_logs/058_production_logs_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/12_case_management/097_isotope_environmental_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-039-12", "issue": "metadata field loss", "portfolio_key": "CBP-039-12", "reason": "the current observation does not meet the operative trigger", "required_next_evidence": "a current observation that satisfies the operative trigger", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_orders/012_orders_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/024_requests_responses_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/05_email_families/036_email_families_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/048_chat_exports_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/11_third_party/084_third_party_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/12_case_management/097_isotope_environmental_impact_population.xlsx"]}], "matter_number": "CB-LD-2709", "prepared_for": "Isotope Specialty Chemicals", "schema_version": "counselbench.decision.v3", "task_id": "cb100-039-isotope-environmental"}, "matter_register": {"matter_number": "CB-LD-2709", "rows": [{"decision_option_id": "isotope-environmental:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective", "issue": "clawback deadline", "matter_number": "CB-LD-2709", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-039-01", "row_id": "REG-CBP-039-01", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_pleadings/001_pleadings_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/02_orders/013_orders_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/025_custodian_files_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/05_email_families/037_email_families_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/07_privilege_material/049_privilege_material_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/12_case_management/097_isotope_environmental_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "isotope-environmental:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "the operational record relies on a superseded control revision", "issue": "third-party subpoena deadline", "matter_number": "CB-LD-2709", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-039-02", "row_id": "REG-CBP-039-02", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_pleadings/002_pleadings_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/02_orders/014_orders_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/026_custodian_files_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/05_email_families/038_email_families_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/07_privilege_material/050_privilege_material_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/10_expert_material/074_expert_material_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/12_case_management/097_isotope_environmental_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "isotope-environmental:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key", "issue": "custodian omission", "matter_number": "CB-LD-2709", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-039-03", "row_id": "REG-CBP-039-03", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_pleadings/003_pleadings_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/02_orders/015_orders_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/027_custodian_files_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/05_email_families/039_email_families_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/07_privilege_material/051_privilege_material_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/12_case_management/097_isotope_environmental_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "isotope-environmental:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-29", "issue": "common-interest support gap", "matter_number": "CB-LD-2709", "owner": "Farah Ibrahim", "portfolio_key": "CBP-039-04", "row_id": "REG-CBP-039-04", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_pleadings/004_pleadings_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/02_orders/016_orders_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/028_custodian_files_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/05_email_families/040_email_families_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_case_management/097_isotope_environmental_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "isotope-environmental:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-28", "issue": "expert draft segregation", "matter_number": "CB-LD-2709", "owner": "Dominic Alvarez", "portfolio_key": "CBP-039-05", "row_id": "REG-CBP-039-05", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_pleadings/005_pleadings_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/017_requests_responses_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/029_custodian_files_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/041_chat_exports_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/07_privilege_material/053_privilege_material_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_case_management/097_isotope_environmental_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "isotope-environmental:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-27", "issue": "meet-and-confer commitment", "matter_number": "CB-LD-2709", "owner": "Leona Park", "portfolio_key": "CBP-039-06", "row_id": "REG-CBP-039-06", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_pleadings/006_pleadings_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/018_requests_responses_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/030_custodian_files_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/042_chat_exports_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/10_expert_material/078_expert_material_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/09_depositions/066_depositions_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/12_case_management/097_isotope_environmental_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "isotope-environmental:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-26", "issue": "privilege-log description defect", "matter_number": "CB-LD-2709", "owner": "Henry Cho", "portfolio_key": "CBP-039-07", "row_id": "REG-CBP-039-07", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_pleadings/007_pleadings_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/019_requests_responses_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/031_custodian_files_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/043_chat_exports_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/12_case_management/097_isotope_environmental_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "isotope-environmental:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-25", "issue": "deposition exhibit omission", "matter_number": "CB-LD-2709", "owner": "Maya Ellison", "portfolio_key": "CBP-039-08", "row_id": "REG-CBP-039-08", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_pleadings/008_pleadings_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/020_requests_responses_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/032_custodian_files_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/044_chat_exports_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/09_depositions/068_depositions_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/12_case_management/097_isotope_environmental_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "isotope-environmental:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-24", "issue": "Bates-range overlap", "matter_number": "CB-LD-2709", "owner": "Jonas Feld", "portfolio_key": "CBP-039-09", "row_id": "REG-CBP-039-09", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_orders/009_orders_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/021_requests_responses_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/05_email_families/033_email_families_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/045_chat_exports_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_case_management/097_isotope_environmental_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "isotope-environmental:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "the operational record relies on a superseded control revision", "issue": "email-family separation", "matter_number": "CB-LD-2709", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-039-10", "row_id": "REG-CBP-039-10", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_orders/010_orders_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/022_requests_responses_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/05_email_families/034_email_families_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/046_chat_exports_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_case_management/094_case_management_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/08_production_logs/058_production_logs_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/12_case_management/097_isotope_environmental_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "isotope-environmental:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-10-01", "issue": "request-response mismatch", "matter_number": "CB-LD-2709", "owner": "Owen Delgado", "portfolio_key": "CBP-039-11", "row_id": "REG-CBP-039-11", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_orders/011_orders_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/023_requests_responses_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/05_email_families/035_email_families_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/047_chat_exports_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/08_production_logs/059_production_logs_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/11_third_party/083_third_party_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/12_case_management/097_isotope_environmental_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "isotope-environmental:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "the current observation does not meet the operative trigger", "issue": "metadata field loss", "matter_number": "CB-LD-2709", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-039-12", "row_id": "REG-CBP-039-12", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_orders/012_orders_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/024_requests_responses_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/05_email_families/036_email_families_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/048_chat_exports_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/11_third_party/084_third_party_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/12_case_management/097_isotope_environmental_impact_population.xlsx"]}], "schema_version": "counselbench.matter-register.v3", "task_id": "cb100-039-isotope-environmental"}}, "metadata": {"benchmark": "CounselBench-100", "code_license": "Apache-2.0", "data_license": "CC-BY-4.0", "deadline": "2026-10-03", "document_count": 97, "evidence_holds": 5, "jurisdiction": "Louisiana", "matter_number": "CB-LD-2709", "mcp_commit": "9a96ea6e5913736f92b88345bf51caeaaa8e719f", "mcp_package": "@modelcontextprotocol/server-filesystem@2026.7.10", "practice_area": "litigation-discovery", "reference_tool_calls": 88, "required_evidence_reads": 63, "supported_actions": 7, "synthetic": true, "venue": "Eastern District of Louisiana", "version": "3.1.0"}, "prompt": "Please take ownership of the open question before the deadline. How should Isotope treat the sampling, consultant, and regulator materials in production? Environmental sampling, consultant drafts, and regulator correspondence present designation, metadata, and expert-discovery questions. The team needs the call by 2026-10-03. Give me a decision-ready note and make the corresponding matter-register entries, without guessing through missing records.", "rubric": {"criteria": [{"category": "investigation", "description": "Inventory the production and use targeted searches to locate records across native formats.", "id": "investigation.discover_production"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Complete every task-specific identity, authority, operations, and approval read before the first state transition.", "id": "investigation.read_before_write"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Inspect designated source metadata before relying on those records.", "id": "investigation.custody_before_write"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "Select the supported option 'isotope-environmental:scoped-evidence' after applying the four-part test.", "id": "decision.selected_option"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "Identify both rejected approaches and explain why a one-source shortcut and a blanket hold are wrong.", "id": "decision.alternatives"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-039-01 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_pleadings/001_pleadings_source_export.md rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-039-01.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_orders/013_orders_source_export.json for clawback deadline.", "id": "investigation.CBP-039-01.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/025_custodian_files_source_export.md to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-039-01.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_email_families/037_email_families_source_export.json.", "id": "investigation.CBP-039-01.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-039-01 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective.", "id": "decision.CBP-039-01.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-039-01 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-039-01.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-039-02 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_pleadings/002_pleadings_source_export.txt rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-039-02.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_orders/014_orders_source_export.xml for third-party subpoena deadline.", "id": "investigation.CBP-039-02.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/026_custodian_files_source_export.txt to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-039-02.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_email_families/038_email_families_source_export.xml.", "id": "investigation.CBP-039-02.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-039-02 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is the operational record relies on a superseded control revision.", "id": "decision.CBP-039-02.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-039-02 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-039-02.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-039-03 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_pleadings/003_pleadings_source_export.eml rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-039-03.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_orders/015_orders_source_export.html for custodian omission.", "id": "investigation.CBP-039-03.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/027_custodian_files_source_export.eml to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-039-03.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_email_families/039_email_families_source_export.html.", "id": "investigation.CBP-039-03.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-039-03 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key.", "id": "decision.CBP-039-03.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-039-03 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-039-03.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-039-04 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_pleadings/004_pleadings_source_export.csv rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-039-04.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_orders/016_orders_source_export.pdf for common-interest support gap.", "id": "investigation.CBP-039-04.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/028_custodian_files_source_export.csv to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-039-04.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_email_families/040_email_families_source_export.pdf.", "id": "investigation.CBP-039-04.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-039-04 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-039-04.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-039-04 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-039-04.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-039-05 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_pleadings/005_pleadings_source_export.json rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-039-05.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/017_requests_responses_source_export.md for expert draft segregation.", "id": "investigation.CBP-039-05.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/029_custodian_files_source_export.json to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-039-05.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/041_chat_exports_source_export.md.", "id": "investigation.CBP-039-05.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-039-05 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-039-05.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-039-05 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-039-05.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-039-06 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_pleadings/006_pleadings_source_export.xml rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-039-06.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/018_requests_responses_source_export.txt for meet-and-confer commitment.", "id": "investigation.CBP-039-06.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/030_custodian_files_source_export.xml to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-039-06.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/042_chat_exports_source_export.txt.", "id": "investigation.CBP-039-06.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-039-06 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-039-06.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-039-06 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-039-06.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-039-07 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_pleadings/007_pleadings_source_export.html rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-039-07.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/019_requests_responses_source_export.eml for privilege-log description defect.", "id": "investigation.CBP-039-07.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/031_custodian_files_source_export.html to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-039-07.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/043_chat_exports_source_export.eml.", "id": "investigation.CBP-039-07.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-039-07 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-039-07.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-039-07 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-039-07.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-039-08 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_pleadings/008_pleadings_source_export.pdf rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-039-08.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/020_requests_responses_source_export.csv for deposition exhibit omission.", "id": "investigation.CBP-039-08.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/032_custodian_files_source_export.pdf to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-039-08.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/044_chat_exports_source_export.csv.", "id": "investigation.CBP-039-08.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-039-08 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-039-08.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-039-08 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-039-08.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-039-09 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_orders/009_orders_source_export.md rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-039-09.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/021_requests_responses_source_export.json for Bates-range overlap.", "id": "investigation.CBP-039-09.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_email_families/033_email_families_source_export.md to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-039-09.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/045_chat_exports_source_export.json.", "id": "investigation.CBP-039-09.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-039-09 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-039-09.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-039-09 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-039-09.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-039-10 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_orders/010_orders_source_export.txt rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-039-10.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/022_requests_responses_source_export.xml for email-family separation.", "id": "investigation.CBP-039-10.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_email_families/034_email_families_source_export.txt to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-039-10.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/046_chat_exports_source_export.xml.", "id": "investigation.CBP-039-10.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-039-10 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is the operational record relies on a superseded control revision.", "id": "decision.CBP-039-10.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-039-10 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-039-10.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-039-11 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_orders/011_orders_source_export.eml rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-039-11.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/023_requests_responses_source_export.html for request-response mismatch.", "id": "investigation.CBP-039-11.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_email_families/035_email_families_source_export.eml to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-039-11.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/047_chat_exports_source_export.html.", "id": "investigation.CBP-039-11.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-039-11 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-039-11.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-039-11 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-039-11.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-039-12 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_orders/012_orders_source_export.csv rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-039-12.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/024_requests_responses_source_export.pdf for metadata field loss.", "id": "investigation.CBP-039-12.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_email_families/036_email_families_source_export.csv to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-039-12.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/048_chat_exports_source_export.pdf.", "id": "investigation.CBP-039-12.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-039-12 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is the current observation does not meet the operative trigger.", "id": "decision.CBP-039-12.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-039-12 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-039-12.register"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Write the exact selected option, supported action population, evidence-hold population, facts, owners, deadlines, and citations.", "id": "state.exact_decision"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create one exact register row per portfolio key with no extra, missing, or modified row.", "id": "state.exact_register"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Leave only the three approved deliverables and perform no extra state-changing write.", "id": "state.write_scope_containment"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Read back decision.json, matter-register.json, and advice.md after their final writes.", "id": "state.postwrite_readback"}, {"category": "answer", "description": "Explain the selected recommendation, supported actions, holds, alternatives, and limitations with exact source anchors.", "id": "answer.decision_note"}], "decision_options": [{"approach": "Treat supported actions and genuinely ambiguous records as if they were equally unresolved.", "id": "isotope-environmental:blanket-hold", "label": "Freeze the entire matter population"}, {"approach": "Apply the exact identity, current-state, authority, and revision test. Register file-level decisions and hold records with broken lineage.", "id": "isotope-environmental:scoped-evidence", "label": "Redesignate, supplement, or segregate only the supported files."}, {"approach": "Use a plausible summary or one source without completing the controlling joins.", "id": "isotope-environmental:shortcut", "label": "Treat all consultant drafts as protected expert material."}], "evaluation_narrative": {"authority": "Discovery rules and the protective order apply according to purpose, timing, and exact document family.", "observation": "Match drafts, recipients, expert designation dates, metadata, and confidentiality labels by file lineage.", "question": "How should Isotope treat the sampling, consultant, and regulator materials in production?", "register_action": "Register file-level decisions and hold records with broken lineage."}, "gates": ["all_required_evidence_precedes_first_write", "decision_criteria_complete", "register_state_exact", "write_scope_contained", "all_outputs_verified_by_readback"], "metadata_checks": 12, "metric": "weighted_criteria_score", "minimum_tool_calls": 88, "required_deliverables": ["decision.json", "matter-register.json", "advice.md"], "required_document_reads": 63, "type": "deterministic", "weights": {"advice": 0.15, "decision": 0.35, "investigation": 0.25, "state": 0.25}}, "task_id": "cb100-039-isotope-environmental", "task_name": "Isotope contamination case production check", "world_id": "counselbench-filesystem-mcp-v3"}
+{"context_files": ["task_files/cb100-040-juniper-franchise/01_pleadings/001_pleadings_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-040-juniper-franchise/01_pleadings/002_pleadings_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-040-juniper-franchise/01_pleadings/003_pleadings_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-040-juniper-franchise/01_pleadings/004_pleadings_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-040-juniper-franchise/01_pleadings/005_pleadings_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-040-juniper-franchise/01_pleadings/006_pleadings_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-040-juniper-franchise/01_pleadings/007_pleadings_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-040-juniper-franchise/01_pleadings/008_pleadings_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-040-juniper-franchise/02_orders/009_orders_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-040-juniper-franchise/02_orders/010_orders_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-040-juniper-franchise/02_orders/011_orders_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-040-juniper-franchise/02_orders/012_orders_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-040-juniper-franchise/02_orders/013_orders_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-040-juniper-franchise/02_orders/014_orders_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-040-juniper-franchise/02_orders/015_orders_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-040-juniper-franchise/02_orders/016_orders_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-040-juniper-franchise/03_requests_responses/017_requests_responses_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-040-juniper-franchise/03_requests_responses/018_requests_responses_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-040-juniper-franchise/03_requests_responses/019_requests_responses_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-040-juniper-franchise/03_requests_responses/020_requests_responses_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-040-juniper-franchise/03_requests_responses/021_requests_responses_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-040-juniper-franchise/03_requests_responses/022_requests_responses_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-040-juniper-franchise/03_requests_responses/023_requests_responses_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-040-juniper-franchise/03_requests_responses/024_requests_responses_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-040-juniper-franchise/04_custodian_files/025_custodian_files_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-040-juniper-franchise/04_custodian_files/026_custodian_files_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-040-juniper-franchise/04_custodian_files/027_custodian_files_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-040-juniper-franchise/04_custodian_files/028_custodian_files_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-040-juniper-franchise/04_custodian_files/029_custodian_files_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-040-juniper-franchise/04_custodian_files/030_custodian_files_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-040-juniper-franchise/04_custodian_files/031_custodian_files_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-040-juniper-franchise/04_custodian_files/032_custodian_files_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-040-juniper-franchise/05_email_families/033_email_families_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-040-juniper-franchise/05_email_families/034_email_families_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-040-juniper-franchise/05_email_families/035_email_families_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-040-juniper-franchise/05_email_families/036_email_families_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-040-juniper-franchise/05_email_families/037_email_families_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-040-juniper-franchise/05_email_families/038_email_families_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-040-juniper-franchise/05_email_families/039_email_families_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-040-juniper-franchise/05_email_families/040_email_families_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-040-juniper-franchise/06_chat_exports/041_chat_exports_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-040-juniper-franchise/06_chat_exports/042_chat_exports_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-040-juniper-franchise/06_chat_exports/043_chat_exports_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-040-juniper-franchise/06_chat_exports/044_chat_exports_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-040-juniper-franchise/06_chat_exports/045_chat_exports_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-040-juniper-franchise/06_chat_exports/046_chat_exports_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-040-juniper-franchise/06_chat_exports/047_chat_exports_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-040-juniper-franchise/06_chat_exports/048_chat_exports_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-040-juniper-franchise/07_privilege_material/049_privilege_material_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-040-juniper-franchise/07_privilege_material/050_privilege_material_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-040-juniper-franchise/07_privilege_material/051_privilege_material_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-040-juniper-franchise/07_privilege_material/052_privilege_material_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-040-juniper-franchise/07_privilege_material/053_privilege_material_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-040-juniper-franchise/07_privilege_material/054_privilege_material_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-040-juniper-franchise/07_privilege_material/055_privilege_material_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-040-juniper-franchise/07_privilege_material/056_privilege_material_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-040-juniper-franchise/08_production_logs/057_production_logs_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-040-juniper-franchise/08_production_logs/058_production_logs_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-040-juniper-franchise/08_production_logs/059_production_logs_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-040-juniper-franchise/08_production_logs/060_production_logs_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-040-juniper-franchise/08_production_logs/061_production_logs_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-040-juniper-franchise/08_production_logs/062_production_logs_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-040-juniper-franchise/08_production_logs/063_production_logs_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-040-juniper-franchise/08_production_logs/064_production_logs_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-040-juniper-franchise/09_depositions/065_depositions_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-040-juniper-franchise/09_depositions/066_depositions_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-040-juniper-franchise/09_depositions/067_depositions_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-040-juniper-franchise/09_depositions/068_depositions_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-040-juniper-franchise/09_depositions/069_depositions_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-040-juniper-franchise/09_depositions/070_depositions_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-040-juniper-franchise/09_depositions/071_depositions_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-040-juniper-franchise/09_depositions/072_depositions_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-040-juniper-franchise/10_expert_material/073_expert_material_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-040-juniper-franchise/10_expert_material/074_expert_material_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-040-juniper-franchise/10_expert_material/075_expert_material_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-040-juniper-franchise/10_expert_material/076_expert_material_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-040-juniper-franchise/10_expert_material/077_expert_material_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-040-juniper-franchise/10_expert_material/078_expert_material_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-040-juniper-franchise/10_expert_material/079_expert_material_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-040-juniper-franchise/10_expert_material/080_expert_material_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-040-juniper-franchise/11_third_party/081_third_party_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-040-juniper-franchise/11_third_party/082_third_party_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-040-juniper-franchise/11_third_party/083_third_party_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-040-juniper-franchise/11_third_party/084_third_party_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-040-juniper-franchise/11_third_party/085_third_party_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-040-juniper-franchise/11_third_party/086_third_party_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-040-juniper-franchise/11_third_party/087_third_party_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-040-juniper-franchise/11_third_party/088_third_party_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-040-juniper-franchise/12_case_management/089_case_management_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-040-juniper-franchise/12_case_management/090_case_management_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-040-juniper-franchise/12_case_management/091_case_management_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-040-juniper-franchise/12_case_management/092_case_management_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-040-juniper-franchise/12_case_management/093_case_management_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-040-juniper-franchise/12_case_management/094_case_management_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-040-juniper-franchise/12_case_management/095_case_management_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-040-juniper-franchise/12_case_management/096_case_management_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-040-juniper-franchise/12_case_management/097_juniper_franchise_impact_population.xlsx"], "gold_output": {"advice_markdown": "# Decision note — Juniper franchise dispute discovery audit\n\n## Recommendation\n\nCollect and supplement supported gaps before certifying the affected requests. The reconciled record supports 8 scoped actions and leaves 4 items on evidence hold.\n\nSelected option: `juniper-franchise:scoped-evidence`.\n\n## Why this is the supported option\n\nReconcile custodian lists, complete chat threads, email families, and missing order-form attachments. Requests and production protocol require complete responsive families for exact custodians.\n\n## Supported actions\n\n### CBP-040-01 — protective-order designation error (high)\n\nthe controlled population contains 210 records under CB-LD-2710-R368; the certification covers 188 records under CB-LD-2710-E698. Identity resolves to ENT-040-1000, revision REV-2026.1 is current, and Nora Chen is active with capacity 2.\n\nAction: Create custodian and family-level cure rows with exact missing components. Owner: Nora Chen; due 2026-10-06.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_pleadings/001_pleadings_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/02_orders/013_orders_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/025_custodian_files_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/05_email_families/037_email_families_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/12_case_management/097_juniper_franchise_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-040-03 — legal-hold delivery gap (medium)\n\nthe operative cap is $2,122,000.00 under CB-LD-2710-R382; the matched ledger population totals $2,329,682.00 under CB-LD-2710-E116. Identity resolves to ENT-040-1002, revision REV-2026.3 is current, and Amara Patel is active with capacity 3.\n\nAction: Create custodian and family-level cure rows with exact missing components. Owner: Amara Patel; due 2026-10-04.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_pleadings/003_pleadings_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/02_orders/015_orders_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/027_custodian_files_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/05_email_families/039_email_families_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/07_privilege_material/051_privilege_material_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/08_production_logs/063_production_logs_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/12_case_management/097_juniper_franchise_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-040-04 — clawback deadline (medium)\n\ndelivery must use notices-juniper_table_restaurants@example.test under CB-LD-2710-R163; the only matched receipt used archive-oak_street_franchisees_association@example.test under CB-LD-2710-E474. Identity resolves to ENT-040-1003, revision REV-2026.4 is current, and Samuel Kim is active with capacity 4.\n\nAction: Create custodian and family-level cure rows with exact missing components. Owner: Samuel Kim; due 2026-10-03.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_pleadings/004_pleadings_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/02_orders/016_orders_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/028_custodian_files_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/05_email_families/040_email_families_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/12_case_management/097_juniper_franchise_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-040-05 — third-party subpoena deadline (low)\n\nan open exception blocks completion under CB-LD-2710-R242; the current status is open and unresolved under CB-LD-2710-E267. Identity resolves to ENT-040-1004, revision REV-2026.5 is current, and Talia Brooks is active with capacity 3.\n\nAction: Create custodian and family-level cure rows with exact missing components. Owner: Talia Brooks; due 2026-10-02.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_pleadings/005_pleadings_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/017_requests_responses_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/029_custodian_files_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/041_chat_exports_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/09_depositions/065_depositions_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/12_case_management/097_juniper_franchise_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-040-07 — common-interest support gap (low)\n\nthe controlling threshold is 14% under CB-LD-2710-R909; the independently calculated result is 20% under CB-LD-2710-E571. Identity resolves to ENT-040-1006, revision REV-2026.7 is current, and Farah Ibrahim is active with capacity 4.\n\nAction: Create custodian and family-level cure rows with exact missing components. Owner: Farah Ibrahim; due 2026-09-30.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_pleadings/007_pleadings_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/019_requests_responses_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/031_custodian_files_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/043_chat_exports_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/09_depositions/067_depositions_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/12_case_management/091_case_management_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/12_case_management/097_juniper_franchise_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-040-08 — expert draft segregation (medium)\n\napproval must come from Sofia Bennett under CB-LD-2710-R117; the effective approval record names Caleb Hassan under CB-LD-2710-E895. Identity resolves to ENT-040-1007, revision REV-2026.1 is current, and Dominic Alvarez is active with capacity 5.\n\nAction: Create custodian and family-level cure rows with exact missing components. Owner: Dominic Alvarez; due 2026-09-29.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_pleadings/008_pleadings_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/020_requests_responses_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/032_custodian_files_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/044_chat_exports_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/07_privilege_material/056_privilege_material_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/12_case_management/097_juniper_franchise_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-040-11 — deposition exhibit omission (high)\n\nthe operative cap is $7,042,000.00 under CB-LD-2710-R635; the matched ledger population totals $7,207,635.00 under CB-LD-2710-E502. Identity resolves to ENT-040-1010, revision REV-2026.4 is current, and Maya Ellison is active with capacity 1.\n\nAction: Create custodian and family-level cure rows with exact missing components. Owner: Maya Ellison; due 2026-10-05.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/02_orders/011_orders_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/023_requests_responses_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/05_email_families/035_email_families_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/047_chat_exports_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/11_third_party/083_third_party_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/12_case_management/097_juniper_franchise_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-040-12 — Bates-range overlap (low)\n\ndelivery must use notices-juniper_table_restaurants@example.test under CB-LD-2710-R145; the only matched receipt used archive-oak_street_franchisees_association@example.test under CB-LD-2710-E261. Identity resolves to ENT-040-1011, revision REV-2026.5 is current, and Jonas Feld is active with capacity 5.\n\nAction: Create custodian and family-level cure rows with exact missing components. Owner: Jonas Feld; due 2026-10-04.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/02_orders/012_orders_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/024_requests_responses_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/05_email_families/036_email_families_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/048_chat_exports_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/08_production_logs/060_production_logs_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/12_case_management/097_juniper_franchise_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n## Evidence holds\n\n- **CBP-040-02 — production gap**: two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key. Next evidence: an approved immutable entity crosswalk. Sources: `/workspace/documents/01_pleadings/002_pleadings_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/02_orders/014_orders_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/026_custodian_files_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/05_email_families/038_email_families_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/12_case_management/097_juniper_franchise_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-040-06 — custodian omission**: two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key. Next evidence: an approved immutable entity crosswalk. Sources: `/workspace/documents/01_pleadings/006_pleadings_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/018_requests_responses_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/030_custodian_files_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/042_chat_exports_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/07_privilege_material/054_privilege_material_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/09_depositions/066_depositions_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/12_case_management/097_juniper_franchise_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-040-09 — meet-and-confer commitment**: the operational record relies on a superseded control revision. Next evidence: an operational record using the current effective revision. Sources: `/workspace/documents/02_orders/009_orders_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/021_requests_responses_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/05_email_families/033_email_families_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/045_chat_exports_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/12_case_management/097_juniper_franchise_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-040-10 — privilege-log description defect**: two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key. Next evidence: an approved immutable entity crosswalk. Sources: `/workspace/documents/02_orders/010_orders_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/022_requests_responses_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/05_email_families/034_email_families_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/046_chat_exports_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/12_case_management/094_case_management_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/12_case_management/097_juniper_franchise_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n## Alternatives considered\n\n- `juniper-franchise:shortcut` — Use produced message counts as proof that every thread and family is complete.: Use a plausible summary or one source without completing the controlling joins.\n- `juniper-franchise:blanket-hold` — Freeze the entire matter population: Treat supported actions and genuinely ambiguous records as if they were equally unresolved.\n\n## Assumptions and limits\n\nThis decision is limited to cb100-040-juniper-franchise, the supplied synthetic records, and the matter state as of 2026-10-07. Similar names, stale revisions, and pending authority are not treated as proof.\n", "decision": {"actions": [{"determination": "the controlled population contains 210 records under CB-LD-2710-R368; the certification covers 188 records under CB-LD-2710-E698. Identity resolves to ENT-040-1000, revision REV-2026.1 is current, and Nora Chen is active with capacity 2.", "due_date": "2026-10-06", "id": "ACT-CBP-040-01", "identity_id": "ENT-040-1000", "issue": "protective-order designation error", "owner": "Nora Chen", "portfolio_key": "CBP-040-01", "recommended_action": "Create custodian and family-level cure rows with exact missing components. Owner: Nora Chen; due 2026-10-06.", "severity": "high", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_pleadings/001_pleadings_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/02_orders/013_orders_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/025_custodian_files_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/05_email_families/037_email_families_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_case_management/097_juniper_franchise_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "the operative cap is $2,122,000.00 under CB-LD-2710-R382; the matched ledger population totals $2,329,682.00 under CB-LD-2710-E116. Identity resolves to ENT-040-1002, revision REV-2026.3 is current, and Amara Patel is active with capacity 3.", "due_date": "2026-10-04", "id": "ACT-CBP-040-03", "identity_id": "ENT-040-1002", "issue": "legal-hold delivery gap", "owner": "Amara Patel", "portfolio_key": "CBP-040-03", "recommended_action": "Create custodian and family-level cure rows with exact missing components. Owner: Amara Patel; due 2026-10-04.", "severity": "medium", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_pleadings/003_pleadings_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/02_orders/015_orders_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/027_custodian_files_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/05_email_families/039_email_families_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/07_privilege_material/051_privilege_material_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/08_production_logs/063_production_logs_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_case_management/097_juniper_franchise_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "delivery must use notices-juniper_table_restaurants@example.test under CB-LD-2710-R163; the only matched receipt used archive-oak_street_franchisees_association@example.test under CB-LD-2710-E474. Identity resolves to ENT-040-1003, revision REV-2026.4 is current, and Samuel Kim is active with capacity 4.", "due_date": "2026-10-03", "id": "ACT-CBP-040-04", "identity_id": "ENT-040-1003", "issue": "clawback deadline", "owner": "Samuel Kim", "portfolio_key": "CBP-040-04", "recommended_action": "Create custodian and family-level cure rows with exact missing components. Owner: Samuel Kim; due 2026-10-03.", "severity": "medium", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_pleadings/004_pleadings_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/02_orders/016_orders_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/028_custodian_files_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/05_email_families/040_email_families_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_case_management/097_juniper_franchise_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "an open exception blocks completion under CB-LD-2710-R242; the current status is open and unresolved under CB-LD-2710-E267. Identity resolves to ENT-040-1004, revision REV-2026.5 is current, and Talia Brooks is active with capacity 3.", "due_date": "2026-10-02", "id": "ACT-CBP-040-05", "identity_id": "ENT-040-1004", "issue": "third-party subpoena deadline", "owner": "Talia Brooks", "portfolio_key": "CBP-040-05", "recommended_action": "Create custodian and family-level cure rows with exact missing components. Owner: Talia Brooks; due 2026-10-02.", "severity": "low", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_pleadings/005_pleadings_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/017_requests_responses_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/029_custodian_files_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/041_chat_exports_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/09_depositions/065_depositions_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/12_case_management/097_juniper_franchise_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "the controlling threshold is 14% under CB-LD-2710-R909; the independently calculated result is 20% under CB-LD-2710-E571. Identity resolves to ENT-040-1006, revision REV-2026.7 is current, and Farah Ibrahim is active with capacity 4.", "due_date": "2026-09-30", "id": "ACT-CBP-040-07", "identity_id": "ENT-040-1006", "issue": "common-interest support gap", "owner": "Farah Ibrahim", "portfolio_key": "CBP-040-07", "recommended_action": "Create custodian and family-level cure rows with exact missing components. Owner: Farah Ibrahim; due 2026-09-30.", "severity": "low", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_pleadings/007_pleadings_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/019_requests_responses_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/031_custodian_files_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/043_chat_exports_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/09_depositions/067_depositions_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/12_case_management/091_case_management_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/12_case_management/097_juniper_franchise_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "approval must come from Sofia Bennett under CB-LD-2710-R117; the effective approval record names Caleb Hassan under CB-LD-2710-E895. Identity resolves to ENT-040-1007, revision REV-2026.1 is current, and Dominic Alvarez is active with capacity 5.", "due_date": "2026-09-29", "id": "ACT-CBP-040-08", "identity_id": "ENT-040-1007", "issue": "expert draft segregation", "owner": "Dominic Alvarez", "portfolio_key": "CBP-040-08", "recommended_action": "Create custodian and family-level cure rows with exact missing components. Owner: Dominic Alvarez; due 2026-09-29.", "severity": "medium", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_pleadings/008_pleadings_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/020_requests_responses_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/032_custodian_files_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/044_chat_exports_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/07_privilege_material/056_privilege_material_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_case_management/097_juniper_franchise_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "the operative cap is $7,042,000.00 under CB-LD-2710-R635; the matched ledger population totals $7,207,635.00 under CB-LD-2710-E502. Identity resolves to ENT-040-1010, revision REV-2026.4 is current, and Maya Ellison is active with capacity 1.", "due_date": "2026-10-05", "id": "ACT-CBP-040-11", "identity_id": "ENT-040-1010", "issue": "deposition exhibit omission", "owner": "Maya Ellison", "portfolio_key": "CBP-040-11", "recommended_action": "Create custodian and family-level cure rows with exact missing components. Owner: Maya Ellison; due 2026-10-05.", "severity": "high", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_orders/011_orders_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/023_requests_responses_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/05_email_families/035_email_families_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/047_chat_exports_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/11_third_party/083_third_party_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/12_case_management/097_juniper_franchise_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "delivery must use notices-juniper_table_restaurants@example.test under CB-LD-2710-R145; the only matched receipt used archive-oak_street_franchisees_association@example.test under CB-LD-2710-E261. Identity resolves to ENT-040-1011, revision REV-2026.5 is current, and Jonas Feld is active with capacity 5.", "due_date": "2026-10-04", "id": "ACT-CBP-040-12", "identity_id": "ENT-040-1011", "issue": "Bates-range overlap", "owner": "Jonas Feld", "portfolio_key": "CBP-040-12", "recommended_action": "Create custodian and family-level cure rows with exact missing components. Owner: Jonas Feld; due 2026-10-04.", "severity": "low", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_orders/012_orders_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/024_requests_responses_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/05_email_families/036_email_families_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/048_chat_exports_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/08_production_logs/060_production_logs_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/12_case_management/097_juniper_franchise_impact_population.xlsx"]}], "as_of": "2026-10-07", "decision": {"alternatives_considered": ["juniper-franchise:shortcut", "juniper-franchise:blanket-hold"], "question": "What must Juniper add or correct before the franchise production is defensible?", "rationale": "The four-part causal test supports 8 scoped actions and leaves 4 records on evidence hold. Requests and production protocol require complete responsive families for exact custodians.", "recommendation": "Collect and supplement supported gaps before certifying the affected requests.", "selected_option_id": "juniper-franchise:scoped-evidence"}, "holds": [{"id": "HOLD-CBP-040-02", "issue": "production gap", "portfolio_key": "CBP-040-02", "reason": "two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key", "required_next_evidence": "an approved immutable entity crosswalk", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_pleadings/002_pleadings_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/02_orders/014_orders_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/026_custodian_files_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/05_email_families/038_email_families_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_case_management/097_juniper_franchise_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-040-06", "issue": "custodian omission", "portfolio_key": "CBP-040-06", "reason": "two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key", "required_next_evidence": "an approved immutable entity crosswalk", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_pleadings/006_pleadings_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/018_requests_responses_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/030_custodian_files_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/042_chat_exports_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/07_privilege_material/054_privilege_material_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/09_depositions/066_depositions_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/12_case_management/097_juniper_franchise_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-040-09", "issue": "meet-and-confer commitment", "portfolio_key": "CBP-040-09", "reason": "the operational record relies on a superseded control revision", "required_next_evidence": "an operational record using the current effective revision", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_orders/009_orders_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/021_requests_responses_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/05_email_families/033_email_families_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/045_chat_exports_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_case_management/097_juniper_franchise_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-040-10", "issue": "privilege-log description defect", "portfolio_key": "CBP-040-10", "reason": "two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key", "required_next_evidence": "an approved immutable entity crosswalk", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_orders/010_orders_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/022_requests_responses_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/05_email_families/034_email_families_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/046_chat_exports_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_case_management/094_case_management_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_case_management/097_juniper_franchise_impact_population.xlsx"]}], "matter_number": "CB-LD-2710", "prepared_for": "Juniper Table Restaurants", "schema_version": "counselbench.decision.v3", "task_id": "cb100-040-juniper-franchise"}, "matter_register": {"matter_number": "CB-LD-2710", "rows": [{"decision_option_id": "juniper-franchise:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-10-06", "issue": "protective-order designation error", "matter_number": "CB-LD-2710", "owner": "Nora Chen", "portfolio_key": "CBP-040-01", "row_id": "REG-CBP-040-01", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_pleadings/001_pleadings_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/02_orders/013_orders_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/025_custodian_files_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/05_email_families/037_email_families_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_case_management/097_juniper_franchise_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "juniper-franchise:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key", "issue": "production gap", "matter_number": "CB-LD-2710", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-040-02", "row_id": "REG-CBP-040-02", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_pleadings/002_pleadings_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/02_orders/014_orders_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/026_custodian_files_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/05_email_families/038_email_families_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_case_management/097_juniper_franchise_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "juniper-franchise:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-10-04", "issue": "legal-hold delivery gap", "matter_number": "CB-LD-2710", "owner": "Amara Patel", "portfolio_key": "CBP-040-03", "row_id": "REG-CBP-040-03", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_pleadings/003_pleadings_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/02_orders/015_orders_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/027_custodian_files_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/05_email_families/039_email_families_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/07_privilege_material/051_privilege_material_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/08_production_logs/063_production_logs_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_case_management/097_juniper_franchise_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "juniper-franchise:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-10-03", "issue": "clawback deadline", "matter_number": "CB-LD-2710", "owner": "Samuel Kim", "portfolio_key": "CBP-040-04", "row_id": "REG-CBP-040-04", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_pleadings/004_pleadings_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/02_orders/016_orders_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/028_custodian_files_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/05_email_families/040_email_families_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_case_management/097_juniper_franchise_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "juniper-franchise:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-10-02", "issue": "third-party subpoena deadline", "matter_number": "CB-LD-2710", "owner": "Talia Brooks", "portfolio_key": "CBP-040-05", "row_id": "REG-CBP-040-05", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_pleadings/005_pleadings_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/017_requests_responses_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/029_custodian_files_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/041_chat_exports_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/09_depositions/065_depositions_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/12_case_management/097_juniper_franchise_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "juniper-franchise:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key", "issue": "custodian omission", "matter_number": "CB-LD-2710", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-040-06", "row_id": "REG-CBP-040-06", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_pleadings/006_pleadings_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/018_requests_responses_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/030_custodian_files_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/042_chat_exports_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/07_privilege_material/054_privilege_material_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/09_depositions/066_depositions_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/12_case_management/097_juniper_franchise_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "juniper-franchise:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-30", "issue": "common-interest support gap", "matter_number": "CB-LD-2710", "owner": "Farah Ibrahim", "portfolio_key": "CBP-040-07", "row_id": "REG-CBP-040-07", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_pleadings/007_pleadings_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/019_requests_responses_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/031_custodian_files_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/043_chat_exports_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/09_depositions/067_depositions_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/12_case_management/091_case_management_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/12_case_management/097_juniper_franchise_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "juniper-franchise:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-29", "issue": "expert draft segregation", "matter_number": "CB-LD-2710", "owner": "Dominic Alvarez", "portfolio_key": "CBP-040-08", "row_id": "REG-CBP-040-08", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_pleadings/008_pleadings_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/020_requests_responses_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/032_custodian_files_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/044_chat_exports_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/07_privilege_material/056_privilege_material_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_case_management/097_juniper_franchise_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "juniper-franchise:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "the operational record relies on a superseded control revision", "issue": "meet-and-confer commitment", "matter_number": "CB-LD-2710", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-040-09", "row_id": "REG-CBP-040-09", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_orders/009_orders_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/021_requests_responses_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/05_email_families/033_email_families_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/045_chat_exports_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_case_management/097_juniper_franchise_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "juniper-franchise:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key", "issue": "privilege-log description defect", "matter_number": "CB-LD-2710", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-040-10", "row_id": "REG-CBP-040-10", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_orders/010_orders_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/022_requests_responses_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/05_email_families/034_email_families_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/046_chat_exports_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_case_management/094_case_management_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_case_management/097_juniper_franchise_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "juniper-franchise:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-10-05", "issue": "deposition exhibit omission", "matter_number": "CB-LD-2710", "owner": "Maya Ellison", "portfolio_key": "CBP-040-11", "row_id": "REG-CBP-040-11", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_orders/011_orders_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/023_requests_responses_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/05_email_families/035_email_families_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/047_chat_exports_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/11_third_party/083_third_party_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/12_case_management/097_juniper_franchise_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "juniper-franchise:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-10-04", "issue": "Bates-range overlap", "matter_number": "CB-LD-2710", "owner": "Jonas Feld", "portfolio_key": "CBP-040-12", "row_id": "REG-CBP-040-12", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_orders/012_orders_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/024_requests_responses_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/05_email_families/036_email_families_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/048_chat_exports_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/08_production_logs/060_production_logs_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/12_case_management/097_juniper_franchise_impact_population.xlsx"]}], "schema_version": "counselbench.matter-register.v3", "task_id": "cb100-040-juniper-franchise"}}, "metadata": {"benchmark": "CounselBench-100", "code_license": "Apache-2.0", "data_license": "CC-BY-4.0", "deadline": "2026-10-07", "document_count": 97, "evidence_holds": 4, "jurisdiction": "Florida", "matter_number": "CB-LD-2710", "mcp_commit": "9a96ea6e5913736f92b88345bf51caeaaa8e719f", "mcp_package": "@modelcontextprotocol/server-filesystem@2026.7.10", "practice_area": "litigation-discovery", "reference_tool_calls": 81, "required_evidence_reads": 61, "supported_actions": 8, "synthetic": true, "venue": "Middle District of Florida", "version": "3.1.0"}, "prompt": "I need to know what is proven, what we can do about it, and what is still only an evidence gap. What must Juniper add or correct before the franchise production is defensible? A franchise production has custodian scope gaps, incomplete chat threads, and order-form attachments missing from key email families. The team needs the call by 2026-10-07. Capture the supported action and the remaining holds so the next reviewer can reproduce the call.", "rubric": {"criteria": [{"category": "investigation", "description": "Inventory the production and use targeted searches to locate records across native formats.", "id": "investigation.discover_production"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Complete every task-specific identity, authority, operations, and approval read before the first state transition.", "id": "investigation.read_before_write"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Inspect designated source metadata before relying on those records.", "id": "investigation.custody_before_write"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "Select the supported option 'juniper-franchise:scoped-evidence' after applying the four-part test.", "id": "decision.selected_option"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "Identify both rejected approaches and explain why a one-source shortcut and a blanket hold are wrong.", "id": "decision.alternatives"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-040-01 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_pleadings/001_pleadings_source_export.md rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-040-01.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_orders/013_orders_source_export.json for protective-order designation error.", "id": "investigation.CBP-040-01.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/025_custodian_files_source_export.md to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-040-01.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_email_families/037_email_families_source_export.json.", "id": "investigation.CBP-040-01.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-040-01 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-040-01.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-040-01 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-040-01.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-040-02 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_pleadings/002_pleadings_source_export.txt rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-040-02.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_orders/014_orders_source_export.xml for production gap.", "id": "investigation.CBP-040-02.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/026_custodian_files_source_export.txt to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-040-02.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_email_families/038_email_families_source_export.xml.", "id": "investigation.CBP-040-02.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-040-02 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key.", "id": "decision.CBP-040-02.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-040-02 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-040-02.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-040-03 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_pleadings/003_pleadings_source_export.eml rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-040-03.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_orders/015_orders_source_export.html for legal-hold delivery gap.", "id": "investigation.CBP-040-03.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/027_custodian_files_source_export.eml to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-040-03.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_email_families/039_email_families_source_export.html.", "id": "investigation.CBP-040-03.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-040-03 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-040-03.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-040-03 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-040-03.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-040-04 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_pleadings/004_pleadings_source_export.csv rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-040-04.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_orders/016_orders_source_export.pdf for clawback deadline.", "id": "investigation.CBP-040-04.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/028_custodian_files_source_export.csv to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-040-04.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_email_families/040_email_families_source_export.pdf.", "id": "investigation.CBP-040-04.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-040-04 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-040-04.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-040-04 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-040-04.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-040-05 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_pleadings/005_pleadings_source_export.json rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-040-05.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/017_requests_responses_source_export.md for third-party subpoena deadline.", "id": "investigation.CBP-040-05.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/029_custodian_files_source_export.json to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-040-05.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/041_chat_exports_source_export.md.", "id": "investigation.CBP-040-05.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-040-05 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-040-05.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-040-05 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-040-05.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-040-06 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_pleadings/006_pleadings_source_export.xml rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-040-06.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/018_requests_responses_source_export.txt for custodian omission.", "id": "investigation.CBP-040-06.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/030_custodian_files_source_export.xml to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-040-06.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/042_chat_exports_source_export.txt.", "id": "investigation.CBP-040-06.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-040-06 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key.", "id": "decision.CBP-040-06.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-040-06 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-040-06.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-040-07 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_pleadings/007_pleadings_source_export.html rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-040-07.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/019_requests_responses_source_export.eml for common-interest support gap.", "id": "investigation.CBP-040-07.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/031_custodian_files_source_export.html to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-040-07.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/043_chat_exports_source_export.eml.", "id": "investigation.CBP-040-07.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-040-07 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-040-07.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-040-07 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-040-07.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-040-08 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_pleadings/008_pleadings_source_export.pdf rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-040-08.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/020_requests_responses_source_export.csv for expert draft segregation.", "id": "investigation.CBP-040-08.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_custodian_files/032_custodian_files_source_export.pdf to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-040-08.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/044_chat_exports_source_export.csv.", "id": "investigation.CBP-040-08.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-040-08 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-040-08.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-040-08 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-040-08.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-040-09 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_orders/009_orders_source_export.md rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-040-09.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/021_requests_responses_source_export.json for meet-and-confer commitment.", "id": "investigation.CBP-040-09.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_email_families/033_email_families_source_export.md to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-040-09.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/045_chat_exports_source_export.json.", "id": "investigation.CBP-040-09.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-040-09 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is the operational record relies on a superseded control revision.", "id": "decision.CBP-040-09.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-040-09 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-040-09.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-040-10 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_orders/010_orders_source_export.txt rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-040-10.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/022_requests_responses_source_export.xml for privilege-log description defect.", "id": "investigation.CBP-040-10.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_email_families/034_email_families_source_export.txt to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-040-10.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/046_chat_exports_source_export.xml.", "id": "investigation.CBP-040-10.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-040-10 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key.", "id": "decision.CBP-040-10.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-040-10 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-040-10.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-040-11 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_orders/011_orders_source_export.eml rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-040-11.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/023_requests_responses_source_export.html for deposition exhibit omission.", "id": "investigation.CBP-040-11.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_email_families/035_email_families_source_export.eml to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-040-11.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/047_chat_exports_source_export.html.", "id": "investigation.CBP-040-11.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-040-11 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-040-11.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-040-11 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-040-11.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-040-12 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_orders/012_orders_source_export.csv rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-040-12.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_requests_responses/024_requests_responses_source_export.pdf for Bates-range overlap.", "id": "investigation.CBP-040-12.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_email_families/036_email_families_source_export.csv to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-040-12.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_chat_exports/048_chat_exports_source_export.pdf.", "id": "investigation.CBP-040-12.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-040-12 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-040-12.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-040-12 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-040-12.register"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Write the exact selected option, supported action population, evidence-hold population, facts, owners, deadlines, and citations.", "id": "state.exact_decision"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create one exact register row per portfolio key with no extra, missing, or modified row.", "id": "state.exact_register"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Leave only the three approved deliverables and perform no extra state-changing write.", "id": "state.write_scope_containment"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Read back decision.json, matter-register.json, and advice.md after their final writes.", "id": "state.postwrite_readback"}, {"category": "answer", "description": "Explain the selected recommendation, supported actions, holds, alternatives, and limitations with exact source anchors.", "id": "answer.decision_note"}], "decision_options": [{"approach": "Apply the exact identity, current-state, authority, and revision test. Create custodian and family-level cure rows with exact missing components.", "id": "juniper-franchise:scoped-evidence", "label": "Collect and supplement supported gaps before certifying the affected requests."}, {"approach": "Use a plausible summary or one source without completing the controlling joins.", "id": "juniper-franchise:shortcut", "label": "Use produced message counts as proof that every thread and family is complete."}, {"approach": "Treat supported actions and genuinely ambiguous records as if they were equally unresolved.", "id": "juniper-franchise:blanket-hold", "label": "Freeze the entire matter population"}], "evaluation_narrative": {"authority": "Requests and production protocol require complete responsive families for exact custodians.", "observation": "Reconcile custodian lists, complete chat threads, email families, and missing order-form attachments.", "question": "What must Juniper add or correct before the franchise production is defensible?", "register_action": "Create custodian and family-level cure rows with exact missing components."}, "gates": ["all_required_evidence_precedes_first_write", "decision_criteria_complete", "register_state_exact", "write_scope_contained", "all_outputs_verified_by_readback"], "metadata_checks": 8, "metric": "weighted_criteria_score", "minimum_tool_calls": 81, "required_deliverables": ["decision.json", "matter-register.json", "advice.md"], "required_document_reads": 61, "type": "deterministic", "weights": {"advice": 0.15, "decision": 0.35, "investigation": 0.25, "state": 0.25}}, "task_id": "cb100-040-juniper-franchise", "task_name": "Juniper franchise dispute discovery audit", "world_id": "counselbench-filesystem-mcp-v3"}
+{"context_files": ["task_files/cb100-041-anchor-marine/01_petition_schedules/001_petition_schedules_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-041-anchor-marine/01_petition_schedules/002_petition_schedules_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-041-anchor-marine/01_petition_schedules/003_petition_schedules_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-041-anchor-marine/01_petition_schedules/004_petition_schedules_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-041-anchor-marine/01_petition_schedules/005_petition_schedules_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-041-anchor-marine/01_petition_schedules/006_petition_schedules_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-041-anchor-marine/01_petition_schedules/007_petition_schedules_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-041-anchor-marine/01_petition_schedules/008_petition_schedules_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-041-anchor-marine/02_claims_register/009_claims_register_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-041-anchor-marine/02_claims_register/010_claims_register_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-041-anchor-marine/02_claims_register/011_claims_register_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-041-anchor-marine/02_claims_register/012_claims_register_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-041-anchor-marine/02_claims_register/013_claims_register_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-041-anchor-marine/02_claims_register/014_claims_register_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-041-anchor-marine/02_claims_register/015_claims_register_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-041-anchor-marine/02_claims_register/016_claims_register_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-041-anchor-marine/03_proofs_of_claim/017_proofs_of_claim_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-041-anchor-marine/03_proofs_of_claim/018_proofs_of_claim_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-041-anchor-marine/03_proofs_of_claim/019_proofs_of_claim_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-041-anchor-marine/03_proofs_of_claim/020_proofs_of_claim_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-041-anchor-marine/03_proofs_of_claim/021_proofs_of_claim_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-041-anchor-marine/03_proofs_of_claim/022_proofs_of_claim_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-041-anchor-marine/03_proofs_of_claim/023_proofs_of_claim_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-041-anchor-marine/03_proofs_of_claim/024_proofs_of_claim_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-041-anchor-marine/04_contracts_leases/025_contracts_leases_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-041-anchor-marine/04_contracts_leases/026_contracts_leases_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-041-anchor-marine/04_contracts_leases/027_contracts_leases_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-041-anchor-marine/04_contracts_leases/028_contracts_leases_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-041-anchor-marine/04_contracts_leases/029_contracts_leases_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-041-anchor-marine/04_contracts_leases/030_contracts_leases_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-041-anchor-marine/04_contracts_leases/031_contracts_leases_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-041-anchor-marine/04_contracts_leases/032_contracts_leases_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-041-anchor-marine/05_cash_management/033_cash_management_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-041-anchor-marine/05_cash_management/034_cash_management_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-041-anchor-marine/05_cash_management/035_cash_management_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-041-anchor-marine/05_cash_management/036_cash_management_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-041-anchor-marine/05_cash_management/037_cash_management_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-041-anchor-marine/05_cash_management/038_cash_management_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-041-anchor-marine/05_cash_management/039_cash_management_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-041-anchor-marine/05_cash_management/040_cash_management_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-041-anchor-marine/06_financing/041_financing_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-041-anchor-marine/06_financing/042_financing_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-041-anchor-marine/06_financing/043_financing_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-041-anchor-marine/06_financing/044_financing_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-041-anchor-marine/06_financing/045_financing_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-041-anchor-marine/06_financing/046_financing_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-041-anchor-marine/06_financing/047_financing_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-041-anchor-marine/06_financing/048_financing_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-041-anchor-marine/07_critical_vendors/049_critical_vendors_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-041-anchor-marine/07_critical_vendors/050_critical_vendors_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-041-anchor-marine/07_critical_vendors/051_critical_vendors_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-041-anchor-marine/07_critical_vendors/052_critical_vendors_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-041-anchor-marine/07_critical_vendors/053_critical_vendors_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-041-anchor-marine/07_critical_vendors/054_critical_vendors_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-041-anchor-marine/07_critical_vendors/055_critical_vendors_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-041-anchor-marine/07_critical_vendors/056_critical_vendors_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-041-anchor-marine/08_tax/057_tax_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-041-anchor-marine/08_tax/058_tax_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-041-anchor-marine/08_tax/059_tax_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-041-anchor-marine/08_tax/060_tax_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-041-anchor-marine/08_tax/061_tax_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-041-anchor-marine/08_tax/062_tax_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-041-anchor-marine/08_tax/063_tax_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-041-anchor-marine/08_tax/064_tax_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-041-anchor-marine/09_litigation/065_litigation_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-041-anchor-marine/09_litigation/066_litigation_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-041-anchor-marine/09_litigation/067_litigation_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-041-anchor-marine/09_litigation/068_litigation_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-041-anchor-marine/09_litigation/069_litigation_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-041-anchor-marine/09_litigation/070_litigation_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-041-anchor-marine/09_litigation/071_litigation_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-041-anchor-marine/09_litigation/072_litigation_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-041-anchor-marine/10_plan_disclosure/073_plan_disclosure_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-041-anchor-marine/10_plan_disclosure/074_plan_disclosure_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-041-anchor-marine/10_plan_disclosure/075_plan_disclosure_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-041-anchor-marine/10_plan_disclosure/076_plan_disclosure_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-041-anchor-marine/10_plan_disclosure/077_plan_disclosure_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-041-anchor-marine/10_plan_disclosure/078_plan_disclosure_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-041-anchor-marine/10_plan_disclosure/079_plan_disclosure_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-041-anchor-marine/10_plan_disclosure/080_plan_disclosure_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-041-anchor-marine/11_notices_ballots/081_notices_ballots_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-041-anchor-marine/11_notices_ballots/082_notices_ballots_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-041-anchor-marine/11_notices_ballots/083_notices_ballots_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-041-anchor-marine/11_notices_ballots/084_notices_ballots_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-041-anchor-marine/11_notices_ballots/085_notices_ballots_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-041-anchor-marine/11_notices_ballots/086_notices_ballots_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-041-anchor-marine/11_notices_ballots/087_notices_ballots_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-041-anchor-marine/11_notices_ballots/088_notices_ballots_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-041-anchor-marine/12_reconciliations/089_reconciliations_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-041-anchor-marine/12_reconciliations/090_reconciliations_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-041-anchor-marine/12_reconciliations/091_reconciliations_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-041-anchor-marine/12_reconciliations/092_reconciliations_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-041-anchor-marine/12_reconciliations/093_reconciliations_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-041-anchor-marine/12_reconciliations/094_reconciliations_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-041-anchor-marine/12_reconciliations/095_reconciliations_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-041-anchor-marine/12_reconciliations/096_reconciliations_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-041-anchor-marine/12_reconciliations/097_anchor_marine_impact_population.xlsx"], "gold_output": {"advice_markdown": "# Decision note — Anchor Marine chapter 11 claim review\n\n## Recommendation\n\nApply the supported claim treatment and preserve a reasoned reserve for unresolved amounts. The reconciled record supports 7 scoped actions and leaves 5 items on evidence hold.\n\nSelected option: `anchor-marine:scoped-evidence`.\n\n## Why this is the supported option\n\nJoin claims, invoices, lien support, delivery dates, and critical-vendor payments by claimant and obligation. Bankruptcy priority, lien, and postpetition rules apply to exact debt and payment history.\n\n## Supported actions\n\n### CBP-041-01 — setoff assertion (low)\n\ncompletion is required by 2025-04-27 under CB-RS-2801-R871; the current event record shows completion on 2025-05-08 under CB-RS-2801-E357. Identity resolves to ENT-041-1000, revision REV-2025.1 is current, and Elliot Mercer is active with capacity 6.\n\nAction: Create claim-register rows for exact classifications, offsets, and evidence holds. Owner: Elliot Mercer; due 2026-09-03.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/001_petition_schedules_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/02_claims_register/013_claims_register_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/025_contracts_leases_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/05_cash_management/037_cash_management_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/11_notices_ballots/085_notices_ballots_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/07_critical_vendors/049_critical_vendors_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/097_anchor_marine_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-041-03 — secured-status defect (medium)\n\napproval must come from Lena Varga under CB-RS-2801-R450; the effective approval record names Caleb Hassan under CB-RS-2801-E650. Identity resolves to ENT-041-1002, revision REV-2025.3 is current, and Micah Sullivan is active with capacity 5.\n\nAction: Create claim-register rows for exact classifications, offsets, and evidence holds. Owner: Micah Sullivan; due 2026-09-01.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/003_petition_schedules_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/02_claims_register/015_claims_register_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/027_contracts_leases_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/05_cash_management/039_cash_management_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/08_tax/063_tax_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/11_notices_ballots/087_notices_ballots_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/097_anchor_marine_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-041-04 — critical-vendor overstatement (medium)\n\nthe controlled population contains 158 records under CB-RS-2801-R396; the certification covers 132 records under CB-RS-2801-E435. Identity resolves to ENT-041-1003, revision REV-2025.4 is current, and Nora Chen is active with capacity 4.\n\nAction: Create claim-register rows for exact classifications, offsets, and evidence holds. Owner: Nora Chen; due 2026-08-31.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/004_petition_schedules_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/02_claims_register/016_claims_register_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/028_contracts_leases_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/05_cash_management/040_cash_management_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/08_tax/064_tax_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/07_critical_vendors/052_critical_vendors_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/097_anchor_marine_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-041-05 — cash-collateral reporting gap (medium)\n\nthe permission is limited to Southern District of Texas Bankruptcy Court under CB-RS-2801-R866; the matched activity occurred in Texas under CB-RS-2801-E250. Identity resolves to ENT-041-1004, revision REV-2025.5 is current, and Caleb Hassan is active with capacity 4.\n\nAction: Create claim-register rows for exact classifications, offsets, and evidence holds. Owner: Caleb Hassan; due 2026-08-30.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/005_petition_schedules_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/017_proofs_of_claim_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/029_contracts_leases_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/06_financing/041_financing_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/097_anchor_marine_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-041-06 — duplicate proof of claim (medium)\n\nthe operative cap is $1,042,000.00 under CB-RS-2801-R858; the matched ledger population totals $1,281,358.00 under CB-RS-2801-E144. Identity resolves to ENT-041-1005, revision REV-2025.6 is current, and Amara Patel is active with capacity 2.\n\nAction: Create claim-register rows for exact classifications, offsets, and evidence holds. Owner: Amara Patel; due 2026-08-29.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/006_petition_schedules_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/018_proofs_of_claim_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/030_contracts_leases_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/06_financing/042_financing_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/07_critical_vendors/054_critical_vendors_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/097_anchor_marine_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-041-08 — DIP budget variance (critical)\n\nan open exception blocks completion under CB-RS-2801-R554; the current status is open and unresolved under CB-RS-2801-E338. Identity resolves to ENT-041-1007, revision REV-2025.1 is current, and Talia Brooks is active with capacity 6.\n\nAction: Create claim-register rows for exact classifications, offsets, and evidence holds. Owner: Talia Brooks; due 2026-08-27.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/008_petition_schedules_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/020_proofs_of_claim_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/032_contracts_leases_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/06_financing/044_financing_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/097_anchor_marine_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-041-11 — tax priority period (critical)\n\napproval must come from Lena Varga under CB-RS-2801-R763; the effective approval record names Rafael Okafor under CB-RS-2801-E721. Identity resolves to ENT-041-1010, revision REV-2025.4 is current, and Dominic Alvarez is active with capacity 3.\n\nAction: Create claim-register rows for exact classifications, offsets, and evidence holds. Owner: Dominic Alvarez; due 2026-09-02.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/02_claims_register/011_claims_register_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/023_proofs_of_claim_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/05_cash_management/035_cash_management_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/06_financing/047_financing_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/097_anchor_marine_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n## Evidence holds\n\n- **CBP-041-02 — ballot amount discrepancy**: the current observation does not meet the operative trigger. Next evidence: a current observation that satisfies the operative trigger. Sources: `/workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/002_petition_schedules_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/02_claims_register/014_claims_register_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/026_contracts_leases_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/05_cash_management/038_cash_management_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/11_notices_ballots/086_notices_ballots_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/097_anchor_marine_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-041-07 — postpetition invoice**: the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective. Next evidence: effective approval and an active owner with remaining capacity. Sources: `/workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/007_petition_schedules_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/019_proofs_of_claim_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/031_contracts_leases_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/06_financing/043_financing_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/10_plan_disclosure/079_plan_disclosure_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/091_reconciliations_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/097_anchor_marine_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-041-09 — scheduled-claim mismatch**: two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key. Next evidence: an approved immutable entity crosswalk. Sources: `/workspace/documents/02_claims_register/009_claims_register_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/021_proofs_of_claim_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/05_cash_management/033_cash_management_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/06_financing/045_financing_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/097_anchor_marine_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-041-10 — lease rejection deadline**: the current observation does not meet the operative trigger. Next evidence: a current observation that satisfies the operative trigger. Sources: `/workspace/documents/02_claims_register/010_claims_register_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/022_proofs_of_claim_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/05_cash_management/034_cash_management_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/06_financing/046_financing_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/11_notices_ballots/082_notices_ballots_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/097_anchor_marine_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-041-12 — reserve calculation error**: the operational record relies on a superseded control revision. Next evidence: an operational record using the current effective revision. Sources: `/workspace/documents/02_claims_register/012_claims_register_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/024_proofs_of_claim_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/05_cash_management/036_cash_management_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/06_financing/048_financing_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/09_litigation/072_litigation_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/11_notices_ballots/084_notices_ballots_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/097_anchor_marine_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n## Alternatives considered\n\n- `anchor-marine:shortcut` — Object to every paid vendor claim or allow every asserted lien.: Use a plausible summary or one source without completing the controlling joins.\n- `anchor-marine:blanket-hold` — Freeze the entire matter population: Treat supported actions and genuinely ambiguous records as if they were equally unresolved.\n\n## Assumptions and limits\n\nThis decision is limited to cb100-041-anchor-marine, the supplied synthetic records, and the matter state as of 2026-09-04. Similar names, stale revisions, and pending authority are not treated as proof.\n", "decision": {"actions": [{"determination": "completion is required by 2025-04-27 under CB-RS-2801-R871; the current event record shows completion on 2025-05-08 under CB-RS-2801-E357. Identity resolves to ENT-041-1000, revision REV-2025.1 is current, and Elliot Mercer is active with capacity 6.", "due_date": "2026-09-03", "id": "ACT-CBP-041-01", "identity_id": "ENT-041-1000", "issue": "setoff assertion", "owner": "Elliot Mercer", "portfolio_key": "CBP-041-01", "recommended_action": "Create claim-register rows for exact classifications, offsets, and evidence holds. Owner: Elliot Mercer; due 2026-09-03.", "severity": "low", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/001_petition_schedules_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/02_claims_register/013_claims_register_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/025_contracts_leases_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/05_cash_management/037_cash_management_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/11_notices_ballots/085_notices_ballots_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/07_critical_vendors/049_critical_vendors_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/097_anchor_marine_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "approval must come from Lena Varga under CB-RS-2801-R450; the effective approval record names Caleb Hassan under CB-RS-2801-E650. Identity resolves to ENT-041-1002, revision REV-2025.3 is current, and Micah Sullivan is active with capacity 5.", "due_date": "2026-09-01", "id": "ACT-CBP-041-03", "identity_id": "ENT-041-1002", "issue": "secured-status defect", "owner": "Micah Sullivan", "portfolio_key": "CBP-041-03", "recommended_action": "Create claim-register rows for exact classifications, offsets, and evidence holds. Owner: Micah Sullivan; due 2026-09-01.", "severity": "medium", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/003_petition_schedules_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/02_claims_register/015_claims_register_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/027_contracts_leases_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/05_cash_management/039_cash_management_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/08_tax/063_tax_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/11_notices_ballots/087_notices_ballots_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/097_anchor_marine_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "the controlled population contains 158 records under CB-RS-2801-R396; the certification covers 132 records under CB-RS-2801-E435. Identity resolves to ENT-041-1003, revision REV-2025.4 is current, and Nora Chen is active with capacity 4.", "due_date": "2026-08-31", "id": "ACT-CBP-041-04", "identity_id": "ENT-041-1003", "issue": "critical-vendor overstatement", "owner": "Nora Chen", "portfolio_key": "CBP-041-04", "recommended_action": "Create claim-register rows for exact classifications, offsets, and evidence holds. Owner: Nora Chen; due 2026-08-31.", "severity": "medium", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/004_petition_schedules_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/02_claims_register/016_claims_register_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/028_contracts_leases_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/05_cash_management/040_cash_management_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/08_tax/064_tax_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/07_critical_vendors/052_critical_vendors_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/097_anchor_marine_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "the permission is limited to Southern District of Texas Bankruptcy Court under CB-RS-2801-R866; the matched activity occurred in Texas under CB-RS-2801-E250. Identity resolves to ENT-041-1004, revision REV-2025.5 is current, and Caleb Hassan is active with capacity 4.", "due_date": "2026-08-30", "id": "ACT-CBP-041-05", "identity_id": "ENT-041-1004", "issue": "cash-collateral reporting gap", "owner": "Caleb Hassan", "portfolio_key": "CBP-041-05", "recommended_action": "Create claim-register rows for exact classifications, offsets, and evidence holds. Owner: Caleb Hassan; due 2026-08-30.", "severity": "medium", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/005_petition_schedules_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/017_proofs_of_claim_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/029_contracts_leases_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/06_financing/041_financing_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/097_anchor_marine_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "the operative cap is $1,042,000.00 under CB-RS-2801-R858; the matched ledger population totals $1,281,358.00 under CB-RS-2801-E144. Identity resolves to ENT-041-1005, revision REV-2025.6 is current, and Amara Patel is active with capacity 2.", "due_date": "2026-08-29", "id": "ACT-CBP-041-06", "identity_id": "ENT-041-1005", "issue": "duplicate proof of claim", "owner": "Amara Patel", "portfolio_key": "CBP-041-06", "recommended_action": "Create claim-register rows for exact classifications, offsets, and evidence holds. Owner: Amara Patel; due 2026-08-29.", "severity": "medium", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/006_petition_schedules_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/018_proofs_of_claim_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/030_contracts_leases_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/06_financing/042_financing_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/07_critical_vendors/054_critical_vendors_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/097_anchor_marine_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "an open exception blocks completion under CB-RS-2801-R554; the current status is open and unresolved under CB-RS-2801-E338. Identity resolves to ENT-041-1007, revision REV-2025.1 is current, and Talia Brooks is active with capacity 6.", "due_date": "2026-08-27", "id": "ACT-CBP-041-08", "identity_id": "ENT-041-1007", "issue": "DIP budget variance", "owner": "Talia Brooks", "portfolio_key": "CBP-041-08", "recommended_action": "Create claim-register rows for exact classifications, offsets, and evidence holds. Owner: Talia Brooks; due 2026-08-27.", "severity": "critical", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/008_petition_schedules_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/020_proofs_of_claim_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/032_contracts_leases_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/06_financing/044_financing_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/097_anchor_marine_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "approval must come from Lena Varga under CB-RS-2801-R763; the effective approval record names Rafael Okafor under CB-RS-2801-E721. Identity resolves to ENT-041-1010, revision REV-2025.4 is current, and Dominic Alvarez is active with capacity 3.", "due_date": "2026-09-02", "id": "ACT-CBP-041-11", "identity_id": "ENT-041-1010", "issue": "tax priority period", "owner": "Dominic Alvarez", "portfolio_key": "CBP-041-11", "recommended_action": "Create claim-register rows for exact classifications, offsets, and evidence holds. Owner: Dominic Alvarez; due 2026-09-02.", "severity": "critical", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_claims_register/011_claims_register_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/023_proofs_of_claim_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/05_cash_management/035_cash_management_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/06_financing/047_financing_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/097_anchor_marine_impact_population.xlsx"]}], "as_of": "2026-09-04", "decision": {"alternatives_considered": ["anchor-marine:shortcut", "anchor-marine:blanket-hold"], "question": "Which Anchor Marine claims should be allowed, reserved, reclassified, or objected to?", "rationale": "The four-part causal test supports 7 scoped actions and leaves 5 records on evidence hold. Bankruptcy priority, lien, and postpetition rules apply to exact debt and payment history.", "recommendation": "Apply the supported claim treatment and preserve a reasoned reserve for unresolved amounts.", "selected_option_id": "anchor-marine:scoped-evidence"}, "holds": [{"id": "HOLD-CBP-041-02", "issue": "ballot amount discrepancy", "portfolio_key": "CBP-041-02", "reason": "the current observation does not meet the operative trigger", "required_next_evidence": "a current observation that satisfies the operative trigger", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/002_petition_schedules_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/02_claims_register/014_claims_register_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/026_contracts_leases_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/05_cash_management/038_cash_management_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/11_notices_ballots/086_notices_ballots_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/097_anchor_marine_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-041-07", "issue": "postpetition invoice", "portfolio_key": "CBP-041-07", "reason": "the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective", "required_next_evidence": "effective approval and an active owner with remaining capacity", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/007_petition_schedules_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/019_proofs_of_claim_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/031_contracts_leases_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/06_financing/043_financing_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/10_plan_disclosure/079_plan_disclosure_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/091_reconciliations_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/097_anchor_marine_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-041-09", "issue": "scheduled-claim mismatch", "portfolio_key": "CBP-041-09", "reason": "two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key", "required_next_evidence": "an approved immutable entity crosswalk", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_claims_register/009_claims_register_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/021_proofs_of_claim_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/05_cash_management/033_cash_management_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/06_financing/045_financing_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/097_anchor_marine_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-041-10", "issue": "lease rejection deadline", "portfolio_key": "CBP-041-10", "reason": "the current observation does not meet the operative trigger", "required_next_evidence": "a current observation that satisfies the operative trigger", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_claims_register/010_claims_register_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/022_proofs_of_claim_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/05_cash_management/034_cash_management_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/06_financing/046_financing_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/11_notices_ballots/082_notices_ballots_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/097_anchor_marine_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-041-12", "issue": "reserve calculation error", "portfolio_key": "CBP-041-12", "reason": "the operational record relies on a superseded control revision", "required_next_evidence": "an operational record using the current effective revision", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_claims_register/012_claims_register_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/024_proofs_of_claim_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/05_cash_management/036_cash_management_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/06_financing/048_financing_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/09_litigation/072_litigation_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/11_notices_ballots/084_notices_ballots_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/097_anchor_marine_impact_population.xlsx"]}], "matter_number": "CB-RS-2801", "prepared_for": "Anchor Marine Fabrication, Inc.", "schema_version": "counselbench.decision.v3", "task_id": "cb100-041-anchor-marine"}, "matter_register": {"matter_number": "CB-RS-2801", "rows": [{"decision_option_id": "anchor-marine:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-03", "issue": "setoff assertion", "matter_number": "CB-RS-2801", "owner": "Elliot Mercer", "portfolio_key": "CBP-041-01", "row_id": "REG-CBP-041-01", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/001_petition_schedules_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/02_claims_register/013_claims_register_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/025_contracts_leases_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/05_cash_management/037_cash_management_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/11_notices_ballots/085_notices_ballots_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/07_critical_vendors/049_critical_vendors_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/097_anchor_marine_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "anchor-marine:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "the current observation does not meet the operative trigger", "issue": "ballot amount discrepancy", "matter_number": "CB-RS-2801", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-041-02", "row_id": "REG-CBP-041-02", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/002_petition_schedules_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/02_claims_register/014_claims_register_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/026_contracts_leases_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/05_cash_management/038_cash_management_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/11_notices_ballots/086_notices_ballots_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/097_anchor_marine_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "anchor-marine:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-01", "issue": "secured-status defect", "matter_number": "CB-RS-2801", "owner": "Micah Sullivan", "portfolio_key": "CBP-041-03", "row_id": "REG-CBP-041-03", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/003_petition_schedules_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/02_claims_register/015_claims_register_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/027_contracts_leases_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/05_cash_management/039_cash_management_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/08_tax/063_tax_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/11_notices_ballots/087_notices_ballots_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/097_anchor_marine_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "anchor-marine:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-08-31", "issue": "critical-vendor overstatement", "matter_number": "CB-RS-2801", "owner": "Nora Chen", "portfolio_key": "CBP-041-04", "row_id": "REG-CBP-041-04", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/004_petition_schedules_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/02_claims_register/016_claims_register_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/028_contracts_leases_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/05_cash_management/040_cash_management_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/08_tax/064_tax_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/07_critical_vendors/052_critical_vendors_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/097_anchor_marine_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "anchor-marine:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-08-30", "issue": "cash-collateral reporting gap", "matter_number": "CB-RS-2801", "owner": "Caleb Hassan", "portfolio_key": "CBP-041-05", "row_id": "REG-CBP-041-05", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/005_petition_schedules_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/017_proofs_of_claim_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/029_contracts_leases_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/06_financing/041_financing_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/097_anchor_marine_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "anchor-marine:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-08-29", "issue": "duplicate proof of claim", "matter_number": "CB-RS-2801", "owner": "Amara Patel", "portfolio_key": "CBP-041-06", "row_id": "REG-CBP-041-06", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/006_petition_schedules_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/018_proofs_of_claim_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/030_contracts_leases_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/06_financing/042_financing_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/07_critical_vendors/054_critical_vendors_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/097_anchor_marine_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "anchor-marine:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective", "issue": "postpetition invoice", "matter_number": "CB-RS-2801", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-041-07", "row_id": "REG-CBP-041-07", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/007_petition_schedules_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/019_proofs_of_claim_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/031_contracts_leases_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/06_financing/043_financing_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/10_plan_disclosure/079_plan_disclosure_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/091_reconciliations_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/097_anchor_marine_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "anchor-marine:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-08-27", "issue": "DIP budget variance", "matter_number": "CB-RS-2801", "owner": "Talia Brooks", "portfolio_key": "CBP-041-08", "row_id": "REG-CBP-041-08", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/008_petition_schedules_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/020_proofs_of_claim_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/032_contracts_leases_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/06_financing/044_financing_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/097_anchor_marine_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "anchor-marine:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key", "issue": "scheduled-claim mismatch", "matter_number": "CB-RS-2801", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-041-09", "row_id": "REG-CBP-041-09", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_claims_register/009_claims_register_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/021_proofs_of_claim_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/05_cash_management/033_cash_management_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/06_financing/045_financing_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/097_anchor_marine_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "anchor-marine:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "the current observation does not meet the operative trigger", "issue": "lease rejection deadline", "matter_number": "CB-RS-2801", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-041-10", "row_id": "REG-CBP-041-10", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_claims_register/010_claims_register_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/022_proofs_of_claim_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/05_cash_management/034_cash_management_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/06_financing/046_financing_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/11_notices_ballots/082_notices_ballots_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/097_anchor_marine_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "anchor-marine:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-02", "issue": "tax priority period", "matter_number": "CB-RS-2801", "owner": "Dominic Alvarez", "portfolio_key": "CBP-041-11", "row_id": "REG-CBP-041-11", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_claims_register/011_claims_register_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/023_proofs_of_claim_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/05_cash_management/035_cash_management_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/06_financing/047_financing_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/097_anchor_marine_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "anchor-marine:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "the operational record relies on a superseded control revision", "issue": "reserve calculation error", "matter_number": "CB-RS-2801", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-041-12", "row_id": "REG-CBP-041-12", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_claims_register/012_claims_register_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/024_proofs_of_claim_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/05_cash_management/036_cash_management_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/06_financing/048_financing_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/09_litigation/072_litigation_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/11_notices_ballots/084_notices_ballots_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/097_anchor_marine_impact_population.xlsx"]}], "schema_version": "counselbench.matter-register.v3", "task_id": "cb100-041-anchor-marine"}}, "metadata": {"benchmark": "CounselBench-100", "code_license": "Apache-2.0", "data_license": "CC-BY-4.0", "deadline": "2026-09-04", "document_count": 97, "evidence_holds": 5, "jurisdiction": "Texas", "matter_number": "CB-RS-2801", "mcp_commit": "9a96ea6e5913736f92b88345bf51caeaaa8e719f", "mcp_package": "@modelcontextprotocol/server-filesystem@2026.7.10", "practice_area": "restructuring", "reference_tool_calls": 81, "required_evidence_reads": 63, "supported_actions": 7, "synthetic": true, "venue": "Southern District of Texas Bankruptcy Court", "version": "3.1.0"}, "prompt": "I need a straight answer before the next partner call. Which Anchor Marine claims should be allowed, reserved, reclassified, or objected to? A vessel fabricator must reconcile steel claims, lien assertions, postpetition deliveries, and disputed critical-vendor payments. The team needs the call by 2026-09-04. Update the matter record only where the evidence supports it, and give me the practical options for the client.", "rubric": {"criteria": [{"category": "investigation", "description": "Inventory the production and use targeted searches to locate records across native formats.", "id": "investigation.discover_production"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Complete every task-specific identity, authority, operations, and approval read before the first state transition.", "id": "investigation.read_before_write"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Inspect designated source metadata before relying on those records.", "id": "investigation.custody_before_write"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "Select the supported option 'anchor-marine:scoped-evidence' after applying the four-part test.", "id": "decision.selected_option"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "Identify both rejected approaches and explain why a one-source shortcut and a blanket hold are wrong.", "id": "decision.alternatives"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-041-01 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/001_petition_schedules_source_export.md rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-041-01.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_claims_register/013_claims_register_source_export.json for setoff assertion.", "id": "investigation.CBP-041-01.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/025_contracts_leases_source_export.md to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-041-01.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_cash_management/037_cash_management_source_export.json.", "id": "investigation.CBP-041-01.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-041-01 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-041-01.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-041-01 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-041-01.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-041-02 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/002_petition_schedules_source_export.txt rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-041-02.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_claims_register/014_claims_register_source_export.xml for ballot amount discrepancy.", "id": "investigation.CBP-041-02.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/026_contracts_leases_source_export.txt to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-041-02.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_cash_management/038_cash_management_source_export.xml.", "id": "investigation.CBP-041-02.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-041-02 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is the current observation does not meet the operative trigger.", "id": "decision.CBP-041-02.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-041-02 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-041-02.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-041-03 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/003_petition_schedules_source_export.eml rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-041-03.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_claims_register/015_claims_register_source_export.html for secured-status defect.", "id": "investigation.CBP-041-03.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/027_contracts_leases_source_export.eml to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-041-03.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_cash_management/039_cash_management_source_export.html.", "id": "investigation.CBP-041-03.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-041-03 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-041-03.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-041-03 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-041-03.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-041-04 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/004_petition_schedules_source_export.csv rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-041-04.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_claims_register/016_claims_register_source_export.pdf for critical-vendor overstatement.", "id": "investigation.CBP-041-04.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/028_contracts_leases_source_export.csv to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-041-04.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_cash_management/040_cash_management_source_export.pdf.", "id": "investigation.CBP-041-04.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-041-04 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-041-04.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-041-04 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-041-04.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-041-05 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/005_petition_schedules_source_export.json rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-041-05.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/017_proofs_of_claim_source_export.md for cash-collateral reporting gap.", "id": "investigation.CBP-041-05.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/029_contracts_leases_source_export.json to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-041-05.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_financing/041_financing_source_export.md.", "id": "investigation.CBP-041-05.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-041-05 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-041-05.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-041-05 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-041-05.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-041-06 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/006_petition_schedules_source_export.xml rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-041-06.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/018_proofs_of_claim_source_export.txt for duplicate proof of claim.", "id": "investigation.CBP-041-06.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/030_contracts_leases_source_export.xml to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-041-06.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_financing/042_financing_source_export.txt.", "id": "investigation.CBP-041-06.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-041-06 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-041-06.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-041-06 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-041-06.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-041-07 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/007_petition_schedules_source_export.html rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-041-07.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/019_proofs_of_claim_source_export.eml for postpetition invoice.", "id": "investigation.CBP-041-07.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/031_contracts_leases_source_export.html to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-041-07.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_financing/043_financing_source_export.eml.", "id": "investigation.CBP-041-07.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-041-07 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective.", "id": "decision.CBP-041-07.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-041-07 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-041-07.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-041-08 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/008_petition_schedules_source_export.pdf rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-041-08.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/020_proofs_of_claim_source_export.csv for DIP budget variance.", "id": "investigation.CBP-041-08.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/032_contracts_leases_source_export.pdf to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-041-08.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_financing/044_financing_source_export.csv.", "id": "investigation.CBP-041-08.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-041-08 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-041-08.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-041-08 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-041-08.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-041-09 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_claims_register/009_claims_register_source_export.md rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-041-09.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/021_proofs_of_claim_source_export.json for scheduled-claim mismatch.", "id": "investigation.CBP-041-09.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_cash_management/033_cash_management_source_export.md to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-041-09.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_financing/045_financing_source_export.json.", "id": "investigation.CBP-041-09.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-041-09 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key.", "id": "decision.CBP-041-09.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-041-09 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-041-09.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-041-10 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_claims_register/010_claims_register_source_export.txt rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-041-10.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/022_proofs_of_claim_source_export.xml for lease rejection deadline.", "id": "investigation.CBP-041-10.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_cash_management/034_cash_management_source_export.txt to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-041-10.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_financing/046_financing_source_export.xml.", "id": "investigation.CBP-041-10.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-041-10 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is the current observation does not meet the operative trigger.", "id": "decision.CBP-041-10.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-041-10 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-041-10.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-041-11 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_claims_register/011_claims_register_source_export.eml rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-041-11.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/023_proofs_of_claim_source_export.html for tax priority period.", "id": "investigation.CBP-041-11.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_cash_management/035_cash_management_source_export.eml to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-041-11.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_financing/047_financing_source_export.html.", "id": "investigation.CBP-041-11.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-041-11 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-041-11.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-041-11 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-041-11.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-041-12 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_claims_register/012_claims_register_source_export.csv rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-041-12.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/024_proofs_of_claim_source_export.pdf for reserve calculation error.", "id": "investigation.CBP-041-12.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_cash_management/036_cash_management_source_export.csv to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-041-12.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_financing/048_financing_source_export.pdf.", "id": "investigation.CBP-041-12.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-041-12 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is the operational record relies on a superseded control revision.", "id": "decision.CBP-041-12.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-041-12 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-041-12.register"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Write the exact selected option, supported action population, evidence-hold population, facts, owners, deadlines, and citations.", "id": "state.exact_decision"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create one exact register row per portfolio key with no extra, missing, or modified row.", "id": "state.exact_register"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Leave only the three approved deliverables and perform no extra state-changing write.", "id": "state.write_scope_containment"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Read back decision.json, matter-register.json, and advice.md after their final writes.", "id": "state.postwrite_readback"}, {"category": "answer", "description": "Explain the selected recommendation, supported actions, holds, alternatives, and limitations with exact source anchors.", "id": "answer.decision_note"}], "decision_options": [{"approach": "Use a plausible summary or one source without completing the controlling joins.", "id": "anchor-marine:shortcut", "label": "Object to every paid vendor claim or allow every asserted lien."}, {"approach": "Treat supported actions and genuinely ambiguous records as if they were equally unresolved.", "id": "anchor-marine:blanket-hold", "label": "Freeze the entire matter population"}, {"approach": "Apply the exact identity, current-state, authority, and revision test. Create claim-register rows for exact classifications, offsets, and evidence holds.", "id": "anchor-marine:scoped-evidence", "label": "Apply the supported claim treatment and preserve a reasoned reserve for unresolved amounts."}], "evaluation_narrative": {"authority": "Bankruptcy priority, lien, and postpetition rules apply to exact debt and payment history.", "observation": "Join claims, invoices, lien support, delivery dates, and critical-vendor payments by claimant and obligation.", "question": "Which Anchor Marine claims should be allowed, reserved, reclassified, or objected to?", "register_action": "Create claim-register rows for exact classifications, offsets, and evidence holds."}, "gates": ["all_required_evidence_precedes_first_write", "decision_criteria_complete", "register_state_exact", "write_scope_contained", "all_outputs_verified_by_readback"], "metadata_checks": 4, "metric": "weighted_criteria_score", "minimum_tool_calls": 81, "required_deliverables": ["decision.json", "matter-register.json", "advice.md"], "required_document_reads": 63, "type": "deterministic", "weights": {"advice": 0.15, "decision": 0.35, "investigation": 0.25, "state": 0.25}}, "task_id": "cb100-041-anchor-marine", "task_name": "Anchor Marine chapter 11 claim review", "world_id": "counselbench-filesystem-mcp-v3"}
+{"context_files": ["task_files/cb100-042-birch-aviation/01_petition_schedules/001_petition_schedules_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-042-birch-aviation/01_petition_schedules/002_petition_schedules_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-042-birch-aviation/01_petition_schedules/003_petition_schedules_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-042-birch-aviation/01_petition_schedules/004_petition_schedules_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-042-birch-aviation/01_petition_schedules/005_petition_schedules_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-042-birch-aviation/01_petition_schedules/006_petition_schedules_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-042-birch-aviation/01_petition_schedules/007_petition_schedules_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-042-birch-aviation/01_petition_schedules/008_petition_schedules_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-042-birch-aviation/02_claims_register/009_claims_register_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-042-birch-aviation/02_claims_register/010_claims_register_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-042-birch-aviation/02_claims_register/011_claims_register_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-042-birch-aviation/02_claims_register/012_claims_register_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-042-birch-aviation/02_claims_register/013_claims_register_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-042-birch-aviation/02_claims_register/014_claims_register_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-042-birch-aviation/02_claims_register/015_claims_register_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-042-birch-aviation/02_claims_register/016_claims_register_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-042-birch-aviation/03_proofs_of_claim/017_proofs_of_claim_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-042-birch-aviation/03_proofs_of_claim/018_proofs_of_claim_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-042-birch-aviation/03_proofs_of_claim/019_proofs_of_claim_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-042-birch-aviation/03_proofs_of_claim/020_proofs_of_claim_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-042-birch-aviation/03_proofs_of_claim/021_proofs_of_claim_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-042-birch-aviation/03_proofs_of_claim/022_proofs_of_claim_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-042-birch-aviation/03_proofs_of_claim/023_proofs_of_claim_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-042-birch-aviation/03_proofs_of_claim/024_proofs_of_claim_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-042-birch-aviation/04_contracts_leases/025_contracts_leases_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-042-birch-aviation/04_contracts_leases/026_contracts_leases_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-042-birch-aviation/04_contracts_leases/027_contracts_leases_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-042-birch-aviation/04_contracts_leases/028_contracts_leases_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-042-birch-aviation/04_contracts_leases/029_contracts_leases_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-042-birch-aviation/04_contracts_leases/030_contracts_leases_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-042-birch-aviation/04_contracts_leases/031_contracts_leases_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-042-birch-aviation/04_contracts_leases/032_contracts_leases_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-042-birch-aviation/05_cash_management/033_cash_management_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-042-birch-aviation/05_cash_management/034_cash_management_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-042-birch-aviation/05_cash_management/035_cash_management_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-042-birch-aviation/05_cash_management/036_cash_management_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-042-birch-aviation/05_cash_management/037_cash_management_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-042-birch-aviation/05_cash_management/038_cash_management_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-042-birch-aviation/05_cash_management/039_cash_management_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-042-birch-aviation/05_cash_management/040_cash_management_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-042-birch-aviation/06_financing/041_financing_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-042-birch-aviation/06_financing/042_financing_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-042-birch-aviation/06_financing/043_financing_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-042-birch-aviation/06_financing/044_financing_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-042-birch-aviation/06_financing/045_financing_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-042-birch-aviation/06_financing/046_financing_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-042-birch-aviation/06_financing/047_financing_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-042-birch-aviation/06_financing/048_financing_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-042-birch-aviation/07_critical_vendors/049_critical_vendors_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-042-birch-aviation/07_critical_vendors/050_critical_vendors_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-042-birch-aviation/07_critical_vendors/051_critical_vendors_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-042-birch-aviation/07_critical_vendors/052_critical_vendors_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-042-birch-aviation/07_critical_vendors/053_critical_vendors_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-042-birch-aviation/07_critical_vendors/054_critical_vendors_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-042-birch-aviation/07_critical_vendors/055_critical_vendors_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-042-birch-aviation/07_critical_vendors/056_critical_vendors_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-042-birch-aviation/08_tax/057_tax_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-042-birch-aviation/08_tax/058_tax_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-042-birch-aviation/08_tax/059_tax_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-042-birch-aviation/08_tax/060_tax_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-042-birch-aviation/08_tax/061_tax_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-042-birch-aviation/08_tax/062_tax_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-042-birch-aviation/08_tax/063_tax_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-042-birch-aviation/08_tax/064_tax_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-042-birch-aviation/09_litigation/065_litigation_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-042-birch-aviation/09_litigation/066_litigation_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-042-birch-aviation/09_litigation/067_litigation_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-042-birch-aviation/09_litigation/068_litigation_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-042-birch-aviation/09_litigation/069_litigation_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-042-birch-aviation/09_litigation/070_litigation_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-042-birch-aviation/09_litigation/071_litigation_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-042-birch-aviation/09_litigation/072_litigation_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-042-birch-aviation/10_plan_disclosure/073_plan_disclosure_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-042-birch-aviation/10_plan_disclosure/074_plan_disclosure_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-042-birch-aviation/10_plan_disclosure/075_plan_disclosure_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-042-birch-aviation/10_plan_disclosure/076_plan_disclosure_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-042-birch-aviation/10_plan_disclosure/077_plan_disclosure_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-042-birch-aviation/10_plan_disclosure/078_plan_disclosure_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-042-birch-aviation/10_plan_disclosure/079_plan_disclosure_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-042-birch-aviation/10_plan_disclosure/080_plan_disclosure_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-042-birch-aviation/11_notices_ballots/081_notices_ballots_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-042-birch-aviation/11_notices_ballots/082_notices_ballots_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-042-birch-aviation/11_notices_ballots/083_notices_ballots_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-042-birch-aviation/11_notices_ballots/084_notices_ballots_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-042-birch-aviation/11_notices_ballots/085_notices_ballots_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-042-birch-aviation/11_notices_ballots/086_notices_ballots_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-042-birch-aviation/11_notices_ballots/087_notices_ballots_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-042-birch-aviation/11_notices_ballots/088_notices_ballots_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-042-birch-aviation/12_reconciliations/089_reconciliations_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-042-birch-aviation/12_reconciliations/090_reconciliations_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-042-birch-aviation/12_reconciliations/091_reconciliations_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-042-birch-aviation/12_reconciliations/092_reconciliations_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-042-birch-aviation/12_reconciliations/093_reconciliations_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-042-birch-aviation/12_reconciliations/094_reconciliations_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-042-birch-aviation/12_reconciliations/095_reconciliations_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-042-birch-aviation/12_reconciliations/096_reconciliations_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-042-birch-aviation/12_reconciliations/097_birch_aviation_impact_population.xlsx"], "gold_output": {"advice_markdown": "# Decision note — Birch Aviation lease reconciliation\n\n## Recommendation\n\nUse the supported cure amount and notice response for each exact lease. The reconciled record supports 8 scoped actions and leaves 4 items on evidence hold.\n\nSelected option: `birch-aviation:scoped-evidence`.\n\n## Why this is the supported option\n\nReconcile lease amendments, guaranties, cure ledgers, and notice-address changes by contract. Assumption and cure treatment follows the operative lease chain and valid notice mechanics.\n\n## Supported actions\n\n### CBP-042-01 — guaranty overlap (high)\n\nthe operative cap is $1,642,000.00 under CB-RS-2802-R374; the matched ledger population totals $1,717,674.00 under CB-RS-2802-E222. Identity resolves to ENT-042-1000, revision REV-2026.1 is current, and Mei Whitaker is active with capacity 5.\n\nAction: Register lease-specific cure and notice outcomes with stale-balance holds. Owner: Mei Whitaker; due 2026-09-07.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/001_petition_schedules_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/02_claims_register/013_claims_register_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/025_contracts_leases_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/05_cash_management/037_cash_management_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/08_tax/061_tax_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/07_critical_vendors/049_critical_vendors_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/097_birch_aviation_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-042-02 — notice-address defect (medium)\n\ndelivery must use notices-birch_regional_aviation_llc@example.test under CB-RS-2802-R139; the only matched receipt used archive-skyframe_aircraft_leasing@example.test under CB-RS-2802-E578. Identity resolves to ENT-042-1001, revision REV-2026.2 is current, and Theo Laurent is active with capacity 3.\n\nAction: Register lease-specific cure and notice outcomes with stale-balance holds. Owner: Theo Laurent; due 2026-09-06.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/002_petition_schedules_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/02_claims_register/014_claims_register_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/026_contracts_leases_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/05_cash_management/038_cash_management_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/10_plan_disclosure/074_plan_disclosure_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/11_notices_ballots/086_notices_ballots_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/097_birch_aviation_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-042-04 — setoff assertion (medium)\n\ncompletion is required by 2025-05-05 under CB-RS-2802-R999; the current event record shows completion on 2025-06-04 under CB-RS-2802-E576. Identity resolves to ENT-042-1003, revision REV-2026.4 is current, and Elliot Mercer is active with capacity 3.\n\nAction: Register lease-specific cure and notice outcomes with stale-balance holds. Owner: Elliot Mercer; due 2026-09-04.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/004_petition_schedules_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/02_claims_register/016_claims_register_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/028_contracts_leases_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/05_cash_management/040_cash_management_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/11_notices_ballots/088_notices_ballots_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/10_plan_disclosure/076_plan_disclosure_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/097_birch_aviation_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-042-06 — secured-status defect (medium)\n\napproval must come from Mei Whitaker under CB-RS-2802-R204; the effective approval record names Rafael Okafor under CB-RS-2802-E688. Identity resolves to ENT-042-1005, revision REV-2026.6 is current, and Micah Sullivan is active with capacity 1.\n\nAction: Register lease-specific cure and notice outcomes with stale-balance holds. Owner: Micah Sullivan; due 2026-09-02.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/006_petition_schedules_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/018_proofs_of_claim_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/030_contracts_leases_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/06_financing/042_financing_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/097_birch_aviation_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-042-07 — critical-vendor overstatement (medium)\n\nthe controlled population contains 105 records under CB-RS-2802-R233; the certification covers 75 records under CB-RS-2802-E901. Identity resolves to ENT-042-1006, revision REV-2026.7 is current, and Nora Chen is active with capacity 4.\n\nAction: Register lease-specific cure and notice outcomes with stale-balance holds. Owner: Nora Chen; due 2026-09-01.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/007_petition_schedules_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/019_proofs_of_claim_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/031_contracts_leases_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/06_financing/043_financing_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/10_plan_disclosure/079_plan_disclosure_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/097_birch_aviation_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-042-08 — cash-collateral reporting gap (high)\n\nthe permission is limited to Eastern District of Virginia Bankruptcy Court under CB-RS-2802-R797; the matched activity occurred in Virginia under CB-RS-2802-E246. Identity resolves to ENT-042-1007, revision REV-2026.1 is current, and Caleb Hassan is active with capacity 1.\n\nAction: Register lease-specific cure and notice outcomes with stale-balance holds. Owner: Caleb Hassan; due 2026-08-31.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/008_petition_schedules_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/020_proofs_of_claim_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/032_contracts_leases_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/06_financing/044_financing_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/097_birch_aviation_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-042-11 — DIP budget variance (high)\n\nan open exception blocks completion under CB-RS-2802-R100; the current status is open and unresolved under CB-RS-2802-E205. Identity resolves to ENT-042-1010, revision REV-2026.4 is current, and Talia Brooks is active with capacity 1.\n\nAction: Register lease-specific cure and notice outcomes with stale-balance holds. Owner: Talia Brooks; due 2026-09-06.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/02_claims_register/011_claims_register_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/023_proofs_of_claim_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/05_cash_management/035_cash_management_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/06_financing/047_financing_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/097_birch_aviation_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-042-12 — scheduled-claim mismatch (high)\n\ncompletion is required by 2025-07-05 under CB-RS-2802-R940; the current event record shows completion on 2025-08-01 under CB-RS-2802-E414. Identity resolves to ENT-042-1011, revision REV-2026.5 is current, and Adrian Mensah is active with capacity 5.\n\nAction: Register lease-specific cure and notice outcomes with stale-balance holds. Owner: Adrian Mensah; due 2026-09-05.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/02_claims_register/012_claims_register_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/024_proofs_of_claim_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/05_cash_management/036_cash_management_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/06_financing/048_financing_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/097_birch_aviation_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n## Evidence holds\n\n- **CBP-042-03 — priority classification error**: the operational record relies on a superseded control revision. Next evidence: an operational record using the current effective revision. Sources: `/workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/003_petition_schedules_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/02_claims_register/015_claims_register_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/027_contracts_leases_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/05_cash_management/039_cash_management_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/08_tax/063_tax_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/07_critical_vendors/051_critical_vendors_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/097_birch_aviation_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-042-05 — ballot amount discrepancy**: the current observation does not meet the operative trigger. Next evidence: a current observation that satisfies the operative trigger. Sources: `/workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/005_petition_schedules_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/017_proofs_of_claim_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/029_contracts_leases_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/06_financing/041_financing_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/097_birch_aviation_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-042-09 — duplicate proof of claim**: the current observation does not meet the operative trigger. Next evidence: a current observation that satisfies the operative trigger. Sources: `/workspace/documents/02_claims_register/009_claims_register_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/021_proofs_of_claim_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/05_cash_management/033_cash_management_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/06_financing/045_financing_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/097_birch_aviation_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-042-10 — postpetition invoice**: the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective. Next evidence: effective approval and an active owner with remaining capacity. Sources: `/workspace/documents/02_claims_register/010_claims_register_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/022_proofs_of_claim_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/05_cash_management/034_cash_management_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/06_financing/046_financing_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/097_birch_aviation_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n## Alternatives considered\n\n- `birch-aviation:blanket-hold` — Freeze the entire matter population: Treat supported actions and genuinely ambiguous records as if they were equally unresolved.\n- `birch-aviation:shortcut` — Use the petition-date ledger and oldest notice address for every lease.: Use a plausible summary or one source without completing the controlling joins.\n\n## Assumptions and limits\n\nThis decision is limited to cb100-042-birch-aviation, the supplied synthetic records, and the matter state as of 2026-09-08. Similar names, stale revisions, and pending authority are not treated as proof.\n", "decision": {"actions": [{"determination": "the operative cap is $1,642,000.00 under CB-RS-2802-R374; the matched ledger population totals $1,717,674.00 under CB-RS-2802-E222. Identity resolves to ENT-042-1000, revision REV-2026.1 is current, and Mei Whitaker is active with capacity 5.", "due_date": "2026-09-07", "id": "ACT-CBP-042-01", "identity_id": "ENT-042-1000", "issue": "guaranty overlap", "owner": "Mei Whitaker", "portfolio_key": "CBP-042-01", "recommended_action": "Register lease-specific cure and notice outcomes with stale-balance holds. Owner: Mei Whitaker; due 2026-09-07.", "severity": "high", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/001_petition_schedules_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/02_claims_register/013_claims_register_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/025_contracts_leases_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/05_cash_management/037_cash_management_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/08_tax/061_tax_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/07_critical_vendors/049_critical_vendors_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/097_birch_aviation_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "delivery must use notices-birch_regional_aviation_llc@example.test under CB-RS-2802-R139; the only matched receipt used archive-skyframe_aircraft_leasing@example.test under CB-RS-2802-E578. Identity resolves to ENT-042-1001, revision REV-2026.2 is current, and Theo Laurent is active with capacity 3.", "due_date": "2026-09-06", "id": "ACT-CBP-042-02", "identity_id": "ENT-042-1001", "issue": "notice-address defect", "owner": "Theo Laurent", "portfolio_key": "CBP-042-02", "recommended_action": "Register lease-specific cure and notice outcomes with stale-balance holds. Owner: Theo Laurent; due 2026-09-06.", "severity": "medium", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/002_petition_schedules_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/02_claims_register/014_claims_register_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/026_contracts_leases_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/05_cash_management/038_cash_management_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/10_plan_disclosure/074_plan_disclosure_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/11_notices_ballots/086_notices_ballots_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/097_birch_aviation_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "completion is required by 2025-05-05 under CB-RS-2802-R999; the current event record shows completion on 2025-06-04 under CB-RS-2802-E576. Identity resolves to ENT-042-1003, revision REV-2026.4 is current, and Elliot Mercer is active with capacity 3.", "due_date": "2026-09-04", "id": "ACT-CBP-042-04", "identity_id": "ENT-042-1003", "issue": "setoff assertion", "owner": "Elliot Mercer", "portfolio_key": "CBP-042-04", "recommended_action": "Register lease-specific cure and notice outcomes with stale-balance holds. Owner: Elliot Mercer; due 2026-09-04.", "severity": "medium", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/004_petition_schedules_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/02_claims_register/016_claims_register_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/028_contracts_leases_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/05_cash_management/040_cash_management_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/11_notices_ballots/088_notices_ballots_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/10_plan_disclosure/076_plan_disclosure_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/097_birch_aviation_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "approval must come from Mei Whitaker under CB-RS-2802-R204; the effective approval record names Rafael Okafor under CB-RS-2802-E688. Identity resolves to ENT-042-1005, revision REV-2026.6 is current, and Micah Sullivan is active with capacity 1.", "due_date": "2026-09-02", "id": "ACT-CBP-042-06", "identity_id": "ENT-042-1005", "issue": "secured-status defect", "owner": "Micah Sullivan", "portfolio_key": "CBP-042-06", "recommended_action": "Register lease-specific cure and notice outcomes with stale-balance holds. Owner: Micah Sullivan; due 2026-09-02.", "severity": "medium", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/006_petition_schedules_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/018_proofs_of_claim_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/030_contracts_leases_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/06_financing/042_financing_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/097_birch_aviation_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "the controlled population contains 105 records under CB-RS-2802-R233; the certification covers 75 records under CB-RS-2802-E901. Identity resolves to ENT-042-1006, revision REV-2026.7 is current, and Nora Chen is active with capacity 4.", "due_date": "2026-09-01", "id": "ACT-CBP-042-07", "identity_id": "ENT-042-1006", "issue": "critical-vendor overstatement", "owner": "Nora Chen", "portfolio_key": "CBP-042-07", "recommended_action": "Register lease-specific cure and notice outcomes with stale-balance holds. Owner: Nora Chen; due 2026-09-01.", "severity": "medium", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/007_petition_schedules_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/019_proofs_of_claim_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/031_contracts_leases_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/06_financing/043_financing_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/10_plan_disclosure/079_plan_disclosure_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/097_birch_aviation_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "the permission is limited to Eastern District of Virginia Bankruptcy Court under CB-RS-2802-R797; the matched activity occurred in Virginia under CB-RS-2802-E246. Identity resolves to ENT-042-1007, revision REV-2026.1 is current, and Caleb Hassan is active with capacity 1.", "due_date": "2026-08-31", "id": "ACT-CBP-042-08", "identity_id": "ENT-042-1007", "issue": "cash-collateral reporting gap", "owner": "Caleb Hassan", "portfolio_key": "CBP-042-08", "recommended_action": "Register lease-specific cure and notice outcomes with stale-balance holds. Owner: Caleb Hassan; due 2026-08-31.", "severity": "high", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/008_petition_schedules_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/020_proofs_of_claim_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/032_contracts_leases_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/06_financing/044_financing_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/097_birch_aviation_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "an open exception blocks completion under CB-RS-2802-R100; the current status is open and unresolved under CB-RS-2802-E205. Identity resolves to ENT-042-1010, revision REV-2026.4 is current, and Talia Brooks is active with capacity 1.", "due_date": "2026-09-06", "id": "ACT-CBP-042-11", "identity_id": "ENT-042-1010", "issue": "DIP budget variance", "owner": "Talia Brooks", "portfolio_key": "CBP-042-11", "recommended_action": "Register lease-specific cure and notice outcomes with stale-balance holds. Owner: Talia Brooks; due 2026-09-06.", "severity": "high", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_claims_register/011_claims_register_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/023_proofs_of_claim_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/05_cash_management/035_cash_management_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/06_financing/047_financing_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/097_birch_aviation_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "completion is required by 2025-07-05 under CB-RS-2802-R940; the current event record shows completion on 2025-08-01 under CB-RS-2802-E414. Identity resolves to ENT-042-1011, revision REV-2026.5 is current, and Adrian Mensah is active with capacity 5.", "due_date": "2026-09-05", "id": "ACT-CBP-042-12", "identity_id": "ENT-042-1011", "issue": "scheduled-claim mismatch", "owner": "Adrian Mensah", "portfolio_key": "CBP-042-12", "recommended_action": "Register lease-specific cure and notice outcomes with stale-balance holds. Owner: Adrian Mensah; due 2026-09-05.", "severity": "high", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_claims_register/012_claims_register_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/024_proofs_of_claim_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/05_cash_management/036_cash_management_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/06_financing/048_financing_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/097_birch_aviation_impact_population.xlsx"]}], "as_of": "2026-09-08", "decision": {"alternatives_considered": ["birch-aviation:blanket-hold", "birch-aviation:shortcut"], "question": "What cure and notice position should Birch use for its aircraft and gate leases?", "rationale": "The four-part causal test supports 8 scoped actions and leaves 4 records on evidence hold. Assumption and cure treatment follows the operative lease chain and valid notice mechanics.", "recommendation": "Use the supported cure amount and notice response for each exact lease.", "selected_option_id": "birch-aviation:scoped-evidence"}, "holds": [{"id": "HOLD-CBP-042-03", "issue": "priority classification error", "portfolio_key": "CBP-042-03", "reason": "the operational record relies on a superseded control revision", "required_next_evidence": "an operational record using the current effective revision", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/003_petition_schedules_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/02_claims_register/015_claims_register_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/027_contracts_leases_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/05_cash_management/039_cash_management_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/08_tax/063_tax_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/07_critical_vendors/051_critical_vendors_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/097_birch_aviation_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-042-05", "issue": "ballot amount discrepancy", "portfolio_key": "CBP-042-05", "reason": "the current observation does not meet the operative trigger", "required_next_evidence": "a current observation that satisfies the operative trigger", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/005_petition_schedules_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/017_proofs_of_claim_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/029_contracts_leases_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/06_financing/041_financing_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/097_birch_aviation_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-042-09", "issue": "duplicate proof of claim", "portfolio_key": "CBP-042-09", "reason": "the current observation does not meet the operative trigger", "required_next_evidence": "a current observation that satisfies the operative trigger", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_claims_register/009_claims_register_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/021_proofs_of_claim_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/05_cash_management/033_cash_management_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/06_financing/045_financing_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/097_birch_aviation_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-042-10", "issue": "postpetition invoice", "portfolio_key": "CBP-042-10", "reason": "the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective", "required_next_evidence": "effective approval and an active owner with remaining capacity", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_claims_register/010_claims_register_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/022_proofs_of_claim_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/05_cash_management/034_cash_management_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/06_financing/046_financing_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/097_birch_aviation_impact_population.xlsx"]}], "matter_number": "CB-RS-2802", "prepared_for": "Birch Regional Aviation LLC", "schema_version": "counselbench.decision.v3", "task_id": "cb100-042-birch-aviation"}, "matter_register": {"matter_number": "CB-RS-2802", "rows": [{"decision_option_id": "birch-aviation:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-07", "issue": "guaranty overlap", "matter_number": "CB-RS-2802", "owner": "Mei Whitaker", "portfolio_key": "CBP-042-01", "row_id": "REG-CBP-042-01", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/001_petition_schedules_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/02_claims_register/013_claims_register_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/025_contracts_leases_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/05_cash_management/037_cash_management_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/08_tax/061_tax_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/07_critical_vendors/049_critical_vendors_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/097_birch_aviation_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "birch-aviation:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-06", "issue": "notice-address defect", "matter_number": "CB-RS-2802", "owner": "Theo Laurent", "portfolio_key": "CBP-042-02", "row_id": "REG-CBP-042-02", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/002_petition_schedules_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/02_claims_register/014_claims_register_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/026_contracts_leases_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/05_cash_management/038_cash_management_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/10_plan_disclosure/074_plan_disclosure_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/11_notices_ballots/086_notices_ballots_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/097_birch_aviation_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "birch-aviation:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "the operational record relies on a superseded control revision", "issue": "priority classification error", "matter_number": "CB-RS-2802", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-042-03", "row_id": "REG-CBP-042-03", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/003_petition_schedules_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/02_claims_register/015_claims_register_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/027_contracts_leases_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/05_cash_management/039_cash_management_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/08_tax/063_tax_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/07_critical_vendors/051_critical_vendors_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/097_birch_aviation_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "birch-aviation:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-04", "issue": "setoff assertion", "matter_number": "CB-RS-2802", "owner": "Elliot Mercer", "portfolio_key": "CBP-042-04", "row_id": "REG-CBP-042-04", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/004_petition_schedules_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/02_claims_register/016_claims_register_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/028_contracts_leases_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/05_cash_management/040_cash_management_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/11_notices_ballots/088_notices_ballots_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/10_plan_disclosure/076_plan_disclosure_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/097_birch_aviation_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "birch-aviation:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "the current observation does not meet the operative trigger", "issue": "ballot amount discrepancy", "matter_number": "CB-RS-2802", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-042-05", "row_id": "REG-CBP-042-05", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/005_petition_schedules_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/017_proofs_of_claim_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/029_contracts_leases_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/06_financing/041_financing_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/097_birch_aviation_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "birch-aviation:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-02", "issue": "secured-status defect", "matter_number": "CB-RS-2802", "owner": "Micah Sullivan", "portfolio_key": "CBP-042-06", "row_id": "REG-CBP-042-06", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/006_petition_schedules_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/018_proofs_of_claim_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/030_contracts_leases_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/06_financing/042_financing_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/097_birch_aviation_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "birch-aviation:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-01", "issue": "critical-vendor overstatement", "matter_number": "CB-RS-2802", "owner": "Nora Chen", "portfolio_key": "CBP-042-07", "row_id": "REG-CBP-042-07", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/007_petition_schedules_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/019_proofs_of_claim_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/031_contracts_leases_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/06_financing/043_financing_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/10_plan_disclosure/079_plan_disclosure_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/097_birch_aviation_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "birch-aviation:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-08-31", "issue": "cash-collateral reporting gap", "matter_number": "CB-RS-2802", "owner": "Caleb Hassan", "portfolio_key": "CBP-042-08", "row_id": "REG-CBP-042-08", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/008_petition_schedules_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/020_proofs_of_claim_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/032_contracts_leases_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/06_financing/044_financing_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/097_birch_aviation_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "birch-aviation:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "the current observation does not meet the operative trigger", "issue": "duplicate proof of claim", "matter_number": "CB-RS-2802", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-042-09", "row_id": "REG-CBP-042-09", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_claims_register/009_claims_register_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/021_proofs_of_claim_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/05_cash_management/033_cash_management_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/06_financing/045_financing_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/097_birch_aviation_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "birch-aviation:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective", "issue": "postpetition invoice", "matter_number": "CB-RS-2802", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-042-10", "row_id": "REG-CBP-042-10", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_claims_register/010_claims_register_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/022_proofs_of_claim_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/05_cash_management/034_cash_management_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/06_financing/046_financing_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/097_birch_aviation_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "birch-aviation:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-06", "issue": "DIP budget variance", "matter_number": "CB-RS-2802", "owner": "Talia Brooks", "portfolio_key": "CBP-042-11", "row_id": "REG-CBP-042-11", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_claims_register/011_claims_register_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/023_proofs_of_claim_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/05_cash_management/035_cash_management_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/06_financing/047_financing_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/097_birch_aviation_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "birch-aviation:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-05", "issue": "scheduled-claim mismatch", "matter_number": "CB-RS-2802", "owner": "Adrian Mensah", "portfolio_key": "CBP-042-12", "row_id": "REG-CBP-042-12", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_claims_register/012_claims_register_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/024_proofs_of_claim_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/05_cash_management/036_cash_management_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/06_financing/048_financing_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/097_birch_aviation_impact_population.xlsx"]}], "schema_version": "counselbench.matter-register.v3", "task_id": "cb100-042-birch-aviation"}}, "metadata": {"benchmark": "CounselBench-100", "code_license": "Apache-2.0", "data_license": "CC-BY-4.0", "deadline": "2026-09-08", "document_count": 97, "evidence_holds": 4, "jurisdiction": "Virginia", "matter_number": "CB-RS-2802", "mcp_commit": "9a96ea6e5913736f92b88345bf51caeaaa8e719f", "mcp_package": "@modelcontextprotocol/server-filesystem@2026.7.10", "practice_area": "restructuring", "reference_tool_calls": 78, "required_evidence_reads": 59, "supported_actions": 8, "synthetic": true, "venue": "Eastern District of Virginia Bankruptcy Court", "version": "3.1.0"}, "prompt": "The business team is asking whether it can move, and I do not want to answer from the summary deck. What cure and notice position should Birch use for its aircraft and gate leases? Aircraft and gate leases carry cure disputes, guaranties, and notice addresses that changed shortly before the petition date. The team needs the call by 2026-09-08. Document the scoped result for the team and separate genuine exceptions from unresolved identity or revision questions.", "rubric": {"criteria": [{"category": "investigation", "description": "Inventory the production and use targeted searches to locate records across native formats.", "id": "investigation.discover_production"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Complete every task-specific identity, authority, operations, and approval read before the first state transition.", "id": "investigation.read_before_write"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Inspect designated source metadata before relying on those records.", "id": "investigation.custody_before_write"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "Select the supported option 'birch-aviation:scoped-evidence' after applying the four-part test.", "id": "decision.selected_option"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "Identify both rejected approaches and explain why a one-source shortcut and a blanket hold are wrong.", "id": "decision.alternatives"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-042-01 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/001_petition_schedules_source_export.md rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-042-01.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_claims_register/013_claims_register_source_export.json for guaranty overlap.", "id": "investigation.CBP-042-01.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/025_contracts_leases_source_export.md to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-042-01.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_cash_management/037_cash_management_source_export.json.", "id": "investigation.CBP-042-01.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-042-01 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-042-01.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-042-01 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-042-01.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-042-02 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/002_petition_schedules_source_export.txt rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-042-02.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_claims_register/014_claims_register_source_export.xml for notice-address defect.", "id": "investigation.CBP-042-02.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/026_contracts_leases_source_export.txt to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-042-02.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_cash_management/038_cash_management_source_export.xml.", "id": "investigation.CBP-042-02.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-042-02 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-042-02.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-042-02 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-042-02.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-042-03 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/003_petition_schedules_source_export.eml rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-042-03.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_claims_register/015_claims_register_source_export.html for priority classification error.", "id": "investigation.CBP-042-03.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/027_contracts_leases_source_export.eml to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-042-03.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_cash_management/039_cash_management_source_export.html.", "id": "investigation.CBP-042-03.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-042-03 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is the operational record relies on a superseded control revision.", "id": "decision.CBP-042-03.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-042-03 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-042-03.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-042-04 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/004_petition_schedules_source_export.csv rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-042-04.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_claims_register/016_claims_register_source_export.pdf for setoff assertion.", "id": "investigation.CBP-042-04.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/028_contracts_leases_source_export.csv to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-042-04.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_cash_management/040_cash_management_source_export.pdf.", "id": "investigation.CBP-042-04.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-042-04 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-042-04.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-042-04 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-042-04.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-042-05 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/005_petition_schedules_source_export.json rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-042-05.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/017_proofs_of_claim_source_export.md for ballot amount discrepancy.", "id": "investigation.CBP-042-05.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/029_contracts_leases_source_export.json to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-042-05.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_financing/041_financing_source_export.md.", "id": "investigation.CBP-042-05.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-042-05 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is the current observation does not meet the operative trigger.", "id": "decision.CBP-042-05.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-042-05 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-042-05.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-042-06 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/006_petition_schedules_source_export.xml rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-042-06.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/018_proofs_of_claim_source_export.txt for secured-status defect.", "id": "investigation.CBP-042-06.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/030_contracts_leases_source_export.xml to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-042-06.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_financing/042_financing_source_export.txt.", "id": "investigation.CBP-042-06.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-042-06 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-042-06.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-042-06 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-042-06.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-042-07 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/007_petition_schedules_source_export.html rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-042-07.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/019_proofs_of_claim_source_export.eml for critical-vendor overstatement.", "id": "investigation.CBP-042-07.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/031_contracts_leases_source_export.html to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-042-07.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_financing/043_financing_source_export.eml.", "id": "investigation.CBP-042-07.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-042-07 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-042-07.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-042-07 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-042-07.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-042-08 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/008_petition_schedules_source_export.pdf rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-042-08.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/020_proofs_of_claim_source_export.csv for cash-collateral reporting gap.", "id": "investigation.CBP-042-08.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/032_contracts_leases_source_export.pdf to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-042-08.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_financing/044_financing_source_export.csv.", "id": "investigation.CBP-042-08.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-042-08 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-042-08.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-042-08 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-042-08.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-042-09 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_claims_register/009_claims_register_source_export.md rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-042-09.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/021_proofs_of_claim_source_export.json for duplicate proof of claim.", "id": "investigation.CBP-042-09.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_cash_management/033_cash_management_source_export.md to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-042-09.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_financing/045_financing_source_export.json.", "id": "investigation.CBP-042-09.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-042-09 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is the current observation does not meet the operative trigger.", "id": "decision.CBP-042-09.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-042-09 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-042-09.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-042-10 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_claims_register/010_claims_register_source_export.txt rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-042-10.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/022_proofs_of_claim_source_export.xml for postpetition invoice.", "id": "investigation.CBP-042-10.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_cash_management/034_cash_management_source_export.txt to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-042-10.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_financing/046_financing_source_export.xml.", "id": "investigation.CBP-042-10.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-042-10 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective.", "id": "decision.CBP-042-10.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-042-10 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-042-10.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-042-11 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_claims_register/011_claims_register_source_export.eml rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-042-11.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/023_proofs_of_claim_source_export.html for DIP budget variance.", "id": "investigation.CBP-042-11.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_cash_management/035_cash_management_source_export.eml to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-042-11.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_financing/047_financing_source_export.html.", "id": "investigation.CBP-042-11.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-042-11 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-042-11.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-042-11 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-042-11.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-042-12 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_claims_register/012_claims_register_source_export.csv rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-042-12.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/024_proofs_of_claim_source_export.pdf for scheduled-claim mismatch.", "id": "investigation.CBP-042-12.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_cash_management/036_cash_management_source_export.csv to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-042-12.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_financing/048_financing_source_export.pdf.", "id": "investigation.CBP-042-12.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-042-12 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-042-12.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-042-12 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-042-12.register"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Write the exact selected option, supported action population, evidence-hold population, facts, owners, deadlines, and citations.", "id": "state.exact_decision"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create one exact register row per portfolio key with no extra, missing, or modified row.", "id": "state.exact_register"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Leave only the three approved deliverables and perform no extra state-changing write.", "id": "state.write_scope_containment"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Read back decision.json, matter-register.json, and advice.md after their final writes.", "id": "state.postwrite_readback"}, {"category": "answer", "description": "Explain the selected recommendation, supported actions, holds, alternatives, and limitations with exact source anchors.", "id": "answer.decision_note"}], "decision_options": [{"approach": "Treat supported actions and genuinely ambiguous records as if they were equally unresolved.", "id": "birch-aviation:blanket-hold", "label": "Freeze the entire matter population"}, {"approach": "Apply the exact identity, current-state, authority, and revision test. Register lease-specific cure and notice outcomes with stale-balance holds.", "id": "birch-aviation:scoped-evidence", "label": "Use the supported cure amount and notice response for each exact lease."}, {"approach": "Use a plausible summary or one source without completing the controlling joins.", "id": "birch-aviation:shortcut", "label": "Use the petition-date ledger and oldest notice address for every lease."}], "evaluation_narrative": {"authority": "Assumption and cure treatment follows the operative lease chain and valid notice mechanics.", "observation": "Reconcile lease amendments, guaranties, cure ledgers, and notice-address changes by contract.", "question": "What cure and notice position should Birch use for its aircraft and gate leases?", "register_action": "Register lease-specific cure and notice outcomes with stale-balance holds."}, "gates": ["all_required_evidence_precedes_first_write", "decision_criteria_complete", "register_state_exact", "write_scope_contained", "all_outputs_verified_by_readback"], "metadata_checks": 7, "metric": "weighted_criteria_score", "minimum_tool_calls": 78, "required_deliverables": ["decision.json", "matter-register.json", "advice.md"], "required_document_reads": 59, "type": "deterministic", "weights": {"advice": 0.15, "decision": 0.35, "investigation": 0.25, "state": 0.25}}, "task_id": "cb100-042-birch-aviation", "task_name": "Birch Aviation lease reconciliation", "world_id": "counselbench-filesystem-mcp-v3"}
+{"context_files": ["task_files/cb100-043-cascade-retail/01_petition_schedules/001_petition_schedules_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-043-cascade-retail/01_petition_schedules/002_petition_schedules_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-043-cascade-retail/01_petition_schedules/003_petition_schedules_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-043-cascade-retail/01_petition_schedules/004_petition_schedules_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-043-cascade-retail/01_petition_schedules/005_petition_schedules_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-043-cascade-retail/01_petition_schedules/006_petition_schedules_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-043-cascade-retail/01_petition_schedules/007_petition_schedules_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-043-cascade-retail/01_petition_schedules/008_petition_schedules_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-043-cascade-retail/02_claims_register/009_claims_register_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-043-cascade-retail/02_claims_register/010_claims_register_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-043-cascade-retail/02_claims_register/011_claims_register_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-043-cascade-retail/02_claims_register/012_claims_register_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-043-cascade-retail/02_claims_register/013_claims_register_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-043-cascade-retail/02_claims_register/014_claims_register_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-043-cascade-retail/02_claims_register/015_claims_register_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-043-cascade-retail/02_claims_register/016_claims_register_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-043-cascade-retail/03_proofs_of_claim/017_proofs_of_claim_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-043-cascade-retail/03_proofs_of_claim/018_proofs_of_claim_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-043-cascade-retail/03_proofs_of_claim/019_proofs_of_claim_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-043-cascade-retail/03_proofs_of_claim/020_proofs_of_claim_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-043-cascade-retail/03_proofs_of_claim/021_proofs_of_claim_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-043-cascade-retail/03_proofs_of_claim/022_proofs_of_claim_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-043-cascade-retail/03_proofs_of_claim/023_proofs_of_claim_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-043-cascade-retail/03_proofs_of_claim/024_proofs_of_claim_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-043-cascade-retail/04_contracts_leases/025_contracts_leases_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-043-cascade-retail/04_contracts_leases/026_contracts_leases_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-043-cascade-retail/04_contracts_leases/027_contracts_leases_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-043-cascade-retail/04_contracts_leases/028_contracts_leases_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-043-cascade-retail/04_contracts_leases/029_contracts_leases_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-043-cascade-retail/04_contracts_leases/030_contracts_leases_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-043-cascade-retail/04_contracts_leases/031_contracts_leases_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-043-cascade-retail/04_contracts_leases/032_contracts_leases_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-043-cascade-retail/05_cash_management/033_cash_management_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-043-cascade-retail/05_cash_management/034_cash_management_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-043-cascade-retail/05_cash_management/035_cash_management_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-043-cascade-retail/05_cash_management/036_cash_management_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-043-cascade-retail/05_cash_management/037_cash_management_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-043-cascade-retail/05_cash_management/038_cash_management_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-043-cascade-retail/05_cash_management/039_cash_management_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-043-cascade-retail/05_cash_management/040_cash_management_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-043-cascade-retail/06_financing/041_financing_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-043-cascade-retail/06_financing/042_financing_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-043-cascade-retail/06_financing/043_financing_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-043-cascade-retail/06_financing/044_financing_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-043-cascade-retail/06_financing/045_financing_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-043-cascade-retail/06_financing/046_financing_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-043-cascade-retail/06_financing/047_financing_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-043-cascade-retail/06_financing/048_financing_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-043-cascade-retail/07_critical_vendors/049_critical_vendors_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-043-cascade-retail/07_critical_vendors/050_critical_vendors_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-043-cascade-retail/07_critical_vendors/051_critical_vendors_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-043-cascade-retail/07_critical_vendors/052_critical_vendors_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-043-cascade-retail/07_critical_vendors/053_critical_vendors_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-043-cascade-retail/07_critical_vendors/054_critical_vendors_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-043-cascade-retail/07_critical_vendors/055_critical_vendors_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-043-cascade-retail/07_critical_vendors/056_critical_vendors_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-043-cascade-retail/08_tax/057_tax_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-043-cascade-retail/08_tax/058_tax_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-043-cascade-retail/08_tax/059_tax_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-043-cascade-retail/08_tax/060_tax_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-043-cascade-retail/08_tax/061_tax_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-043-cascade-retail/08_tax/062_tax_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-043-cascade-retail/08_tax/063_tax_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-043-cascade-retail/08_tax/064_tax_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-043-cascade-retail/09_litigation/065_litigation_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-043-cascade-retail/09_litigation/066_litigation_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-043-cascade-retail/09_litigation/067_litigation_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-043-cascade-retail/09_litigation/068_litigation_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-043-cascade-retail/09_litigation/069_litigation_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-043-cascade-retail/09_litigation/070_litigation_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-043-cascade-retail/09_litigation/071_litigation_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-043-cascade-retail/09_litigation/072_litigation_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-043-cascade-retail/10_plan_disclosure/073_plan_disclosure_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-043-cascade-retail/10_plan_disclosure/074_plan_disclosure_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-043-cascade-retail/10_plan_disclosure/075_plan_disclosure_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-043-cascade-retail/10_plan_disclosure/076_plan_disclosure_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-043-cascade-retail/10_plan_disclosure/077_plan_disclosure_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-043-cascade-retail/10_plan_disclosure/078_plan_disclosure_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-043-cascade-retail/10_plan_disclosure/079_plan_disclosure_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-043-cascade-retail/10_plan_disclosure/080_plan_disclosure_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-043-cascade-retail/11_notices_ballots/081_notices_ballots_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-043-cascade-retail/11_notices_ballots/082_notices_ballots_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-043-cascade-retail/11_notices_ballots/083_notices_ballots_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-043-cascade-retail/11_notices_ballots/084_notices_ballots_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-043-cascade-retail/11_notices_ballots/085_notices_ballots_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-043-cascade-retail/11_notices_ballots/086_notices_ballots_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-043-cascade-retail/11_notices_ballots/087_notices_ballots_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-043-cascade-retail/11_notices_ballots/088_notices_ballots_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-043-cascade-retail/12_reconciliations/089_reconciliations_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-043-cascade-retail/12_reconciliations/090_reconciliations_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-043-cascade-retail/12_reconciliations/091_reconciliations_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-043-cascade-retail/12_reconciliations/092_reconciliations_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-043-cascade-retail/12_reconciliations/093_reconciliations_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-043-cascade-retail/12_reconciliations/094_reconciliations_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-043-cascade-retail/12_reconciliations/095_reconciliations_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-043-cascade-retail/12_reconciliations/096_reconciliations_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-043-cascade-retail/12_reconciliations/097_cascade_retail_impact_population.xlsx"], "gold_output": {"advice_markdown": "# Decision note — Cascade Retail claims reserve audit\n\n## Recommendation\n\nConsolidate duplicates and set supported reserves and ballot amounts. The reconciled record supports 9 scoped actions and leaves 3 items on evidence hold.\n\nSelected option: `cascade-retail:scoped-evidence`.\n\n## Why this is the supported option\n\nMatch claimant identity, obligation, returns, rejection date, and ballot record across systems. Claim allowance and voting treatment require exact identity and applicable bankruptcy classification.\n\n## Supported actions\n\n### CBP-043-01 — tax priority period (high)\n\napproval must come from Nadine Flores under CB-RS-2803-R121; the effective approval record names Rafael Okafor under CB-RS-2803-E471. Identity resolves to ENT-043-1000, revision REV-2025.1 is current, and Isaac Romero is active with capacity 2.\n\nAction: Create claimant-level reconciliation rows and hold name-only matches. Owner: Isaac Romero; due 2026-09-10.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/001_petition_schedules_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/02_claims_register/013_claims_register_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/025_contracts_leases_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/05_cash_management/037_cash_management_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/07_critical_vendors/049_critical_vendors_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/097_cascade_retail_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-043-02 — reserve calculation error (critical)\n\nthe controlled population contains 234 records under CB-RS-2803-R182; the certification covers 212 records under CB-RS-2803-E369. Identity resolves to ENT-043-1001, revision REV-2025.2 is current, and Nadine Flores is active with capacity 6.\n\nAction: Create claimant-level reconciliation rows and hold name-only matches. Owner: Nadine Flores; due 2026-09-09.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/002_petition_schedules_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/02_claims_register/014_claims_register_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/026_contracts_leases_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/05_cash_management/038_cash_management_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/07_critical_vendors/050_critical_vendors_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/11_notices_ballots/086_notices_ballots_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/097_cascade_retail_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-043-03 — executory-contract cure dispute (low)\n\nthe permission is limited to District of Delaware Bankruptcy Court under CB-RS-2803-R323; the matched activity occurred in Delaware under CB-RS-2803-E854. Identity resolves to ENT-043-1002, revision REV-2025.3 is current, and Rafael Okafor is active with capacity 3.\n\nAction: Create claimant-level reconciliation rows and hold name-only matches. Owner: Rafael Okafor; due 2026-09-08.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/003_petition_schedules_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/02_claims_register/015_claims_register_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/027_contracts_leases_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/05_cash_management/039_cash_management_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/11_notices_ballots/087_notices_ballots_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/097_cascade_retail_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-043-05 — notice-address defect (medium)\n\ndelivery must use notices-cascade_outdoor_retail_corp@example.test under CB-RS-2803-R890; the only matched receipt used archive-multiple_merchandise_vendors@example.test under CB-RS-2803-E993. Identity resolves to ENT-043-1004, revision REV-2025.5 is current, and Theo Laurent is active with capacity 4.\n\nAction: Create claimant-level reconciliation rows and hold name-only matches. Owner: Theo Laurent; due 2026-09-06.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/005_petition_schedules_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/017_proofs_of_claim_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/029_contracts_leases_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/06_financing/041_financing_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/097_cascade_retail_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-043-06 — priority classification error (critical)\n\nan open exception blocks completion under CB-RS-2803-R688; the current status is open and unresolved under CB-RS-2803-E346. Identity resolves to ENT-043-1005, revision REV-2025.6 is current, and Lena Varga is active with capacity 5.\n\nAction: Create claimant-level reconciliation rows and hold name-only matches. Owner: Lena Varga; due 2026-09-05.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/006_petition_schedules_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/018_proofs_of_claim_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/030_contracts_leases_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/06_financing/042_financing_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/097_cascade_retail_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-043-07 — setoff assertion (low)\n\ncompletion is required by 2026-03-12 under CB-RS-2803-R110; the current event record shows completion on 2026-04-11 under CB-RS-2803-E630. Identity resolves to ENT-043-1006, revision REV-2025.7 is current, and Elliot Mercer is active with capacity 2.\n\nAction: Create claimant-level reconciliation rows and hold name-only matches. Owner: Elliot Mercer; due 2026-09-04.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/007_petition_schedules_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/019_proofs_of_claim_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/031_contracts_leases_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/06_financing/043_financing_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/07_critical_vendors/055_critical_vendors_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/097_cascade_retail_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-043-09 — secured-status defect (high)\n\napproval must come from Nadine Flores under CB-RS-2803-R746; the effective approval record names Henry Cho under CB-RS-2803-E296. Identity resolves to ENT-043-1008, revision REV-2025.2 is current, and Micah Sullivan is active with capacity 1.\n\nAction: Create claimant-level reconciliation rows and hold name-only matches. Owner: Micah Sullivan; due 2026-09-02.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/02_claims_register/009_claims_register_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/021_proofs_of_claim_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/05_cash_management/033_cash_management_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/06_financing/045_financing_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/08_tax/057_tax_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/097_cascade_retail_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-043-10 — critical-vendor overstatement (medium)\n\nthe controlled population contains 200 records under CB-RS-2803-R428; the certification covers 168 records under CB-RS-2803-E807. Identity resolves to ENT-043-1009, revision REV-2025.3 is current, and Nora Chen is active with capacity 3.\n\nAction: Create claimant-level reconciliation rows and hold name-only matches. Owner: Nora Chen; due 2026-09-10.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/02_claims_register/010_claims_register_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/022_proofs_of_claim_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/05_cash_management/034_cash_management_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/06_financing/046_financing_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/09_litigation/070_litigation_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/11_notices_ballots/082_notices_ballots_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/097_cascade_retail_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-043-12 — duplicate proof of claim (high)\n\nthe operative cap is $922,000.00 under CB-RS-2803-R723; the matched ledger population totals $1,090,723.00 under CB-RS-2803-E348. Identity resolves to ENT-043-1011, revision REV-2025.5 is current, and Amara Patel is active with capacity 2.\n\nAction: Create claimant-level reconciliation rows and hold name-only matches. Owner: Amara Patel; due 2026-09-08.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/02_claims_register/012_claims_register_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/024_proofs_of_claim_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/05_cash_management/036_cash_management_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/06_financing/048_financing_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/097_cascade_retail_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n## Evidence holds\n\n- **CBP-043-04 — guaranty overlap**: the current observation does not meet the operative trigger. Next evidence: a current observation that satisfies the operative trigger. Sources: `/workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/004_petition_schedules_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/02_claims_register/016_claims_register_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/028_contracts_leases_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/05_cash_management/040_cash_management_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/07_critical_vendors/052_critical_vendors_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/08_tax/064_tax_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/097_cascade_retail_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-043-08 — ballot amount discrepancy**: the current observation does not meet the operative trigger. Next evidence: a current observation that satisfies the operative trigger. Sources: `/workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/008_petition_schedules_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/020_proofs_of_claim_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/032_contracts_leases_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/06_financing/044_financing_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/07_critical_vendors/056_critical_vendors_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/09_litigation/068_litigation_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/097_cascade_retail_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-043-11 — cash-collateral reporting gap**: two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key. Next evidence: an approved immutable entity crosswalk. Sources: `/workspace/documents/02_claims_register/011_claims_register_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/023_proofs_of_claim_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/05_cash_management/035_cash_management_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/06_financing/047_financing_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/095_reconciliations_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/11_notices_ballots/083_notices_ballots_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/097_cascade_retail_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n## Alternatives considered\n\n- `cascade-retail:shortcut` — Choose the largest claim and ballot amount for every claimant name.: Use a plausible summary or one source without completing the controlling joins.\n- `cascade-retail:blanket-hold` — Freeze the entire matter population: Treat supported actions and genuinely ambiguous records as if they were equally unresolved.\n\n## Assumptions and limits\n\nThis decision is limited to cb100-043-cascade-retail, the supplied synthetic records, and the matter state as of 2026-09-11. Similar names, stale revisions, and pending authority are not treated as proof.\n", "decision": {"actions": [{"determination": "approval must come from Nadine Flores under CB-RS-2803-R121; the effective approval record names Rafael Okafor under CB-RS-2803-E471. Identity resolves to ENT-043-1000, revision REV-2025.1 is current, and Isaac Romero is active with capacity 2.", "due_date": "2026-09-10", "id": "ACT-CBP-043-01", "identity_id": "ENT-043-1000", "issue": "tax priority period", "owner": "Isaac Romero", "portfolio_key": "CBP-043-01", "recommended_action": "Create claimant-level reconciliation rows and hold name-only matches. Owner: Isaac Romero; due 2026-09-10.", "severity": "high", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/001_petition_schedules_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/02_claims_register/013_claims_register_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/025_contracts_leases_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/05_cash_management/037_cash_management_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/07_critical_vendors/049_critical_vendors_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/097_cascade_retail_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "the controlled population contains 234 records under CB-RS-2803-R182; the certification covers 212 records under CB-RS-2803-E369. Identity resolves to ENT-043-1001, revision REV-2025.2 is current, and Nadine Flores is active with capacity 6.", "due_date": "2026-09-09", "id": "ACT-CBP-043-02", "identity_id": "ENT-043-1001", "issue": "reserve calculation error", "owner": "Nadine Flores", "portfolio_key": "CBP-043-02", "recommended_action": "Create claimant-level reconciliation rows and hold name-only matches. Owner: Nadine Flores; due 2026-09-09.", "severity": "critical", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/002_petition_schedules_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/02_claims_register/014_claims_register_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/026_contracts_leases_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/05_cash_management/038_cash_management_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/07_critical_vendors/050_critical_vendors_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/11_notices_ballots/086_notices_ballots_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/097_cascade_retail_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "the permission is limited to District of Delaware Bankruptcy Court under CB-RS-2803-R323; the matched activity occurred in Delaware under CB-RS-2803-E854. Identity resolves to ENT-043-1002, revision REV-2025.3 is current, and Rafael Okafor is active with capacity 3.", "due_date": "2026-09-08", "id": "ACT-CBP-043-03", "identity_id": "ENT-043-1002", "issue": "executory-contract cure dispute", "owner": "Rafael Okafor", "portfolio_key": "CBP-043-03", "recommended_action": "Create claimant-level reconciliation rows and hold name-only matches. Owner: Rafael Okafor; due 2026-09-08.", "severity": "low", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/003_petition_schedules_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/02_claims_register/015_claims_register_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/027_contracts_leases_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/05_cash_management/039_cash_management_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/11_notices_ballots/087_notices_ballots_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/097_cascade_retail_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "delivery must use notices-cascade_outdoor_retail_corp@example.test under CB-RS-2803-R890; the only matched receipt used archive-multiple_merchandise_vendors@example.test under CB-RS-2803-E993. Identity resolves to ENT-043-1004, revision REV-2025.5 is current, and Theo Laurent is active with capacity 4.", "due_date": "2026-09-06", "id": "ACT-CBP-043-05", "identity_id": "ENT-043-1004", "issue": "notice-address defect", "owner": "Theo Laurent", "portfolio_key": "CBP-043-05", "recommended_action": "Create claimant-level reconciliation rows and hold name-only matches. Owner: Theo Laurent; due 2026-09-06.", "severity": "medium", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/005_petition_schedules_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/017_proofs_of_claim_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/029_contracts_leases_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/06_financing/041_financing_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/097_cascade_retail_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "an open exception blocks completion under CB-RS-2803-R688; the current status is open and unresolved under CB-RS-2803-E346. Identity resolves to ENT-043-1005, revision REV-2025.6 is current, and Lena Varga is active with capacity 5.", "due_date": "2026-09-05", "id": "ACT-CBP-043-06", "identity_id": "ENT-043-1005", "issue": "priority classification error", "owner": "Lena Varga", "portfolio_key": "CBP-043-06", "recommended_action": "Create claimant-level reconciliation rows and hold name-only matches. Owner: Lena Varga; due 2026-09-05.", "severity": "critical", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/006_petition_schedules_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/018_proofs_of_claim_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/030_contracts_leases_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/06_financing/042_financing_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/097_cascade_retail_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "completion is required by 2026-03-12 under CB-RS-2803-R110; the current event record shows completion on 2026-04-11 under CB-RS-2803-E630. Identity resolves to ENT-043-1006, revision REV-2025.7 is current, and Elliot Mercer is active with capacity 2.", "due_date": "2026-09-04", "id": "ACT-CBP-043-07", "identity_id": "ENT-043-1006", "issue": "setoff assertion", "owner": "Elliot Mercer", "portfolio_key": "CBP-043-07", "recommended_action": "Create claimant-level reconciliation rows and hold name-only matches. Owner: Elliot Mercer; due 2026-09-04.", "severity": "low", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/007_petition_schedules_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/019_proofs_of_claim_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/031_contracts_leases_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/06_financing/043_financing_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/07_critical_vendors/055_critical_vendors_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/097_cascade_retail_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "approval must come from Nadine Flores under CB-RS-2803-R746; the effective approval record names Henry Cho under CB-RS-2803-E296. Identity resolves to ENT-043-1008, revision REV-2025.2 is current, and Micah Sullivan is active with capacity 1.", "due_date": "2026-09-02", "id": "ACT-CBP-043-09", "identity_id": "ENT-043-1008", "issue": "secured-status defect", "owner": "Micah Sullivan", "portfolio_key": "CBP-043-09", "recommended_action": "Create claimant-level reconciliation rows and hold name-only matches. Owner: Micah Sullivan; due 2026-09-02.", "severity": "high", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_claims_register/009_claims_register_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/021_proofs_of_claim_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/05_cash_management/033_cash_management_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/06_financing/045_financing_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/08_tax/057_tax_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/097_cascade_retail_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "the controlled population contains 200 records under CB-RS-2803-R428; the certification covers 168 records under CB-RS-2803-E807. Identity resolves to ENT-043-1009, revision REV-2025.3 is current, and Nora Chen is active with capacity 3.", "due_date": "2026-09-10", "id": "ACT-CBP-043-10", "identity_id": "ENT-043-1009", "issue": "critical-vendor overstatement", "owner": "Nora Chen", "portfolio_key": "CBP-043-10", "recommended_action": "Create claimant-level reconciliation rows and hold name-only matches. Owner: Nora Chen; due 2026-09-10.", "severity": "medium", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_claims_register/010_claims_register_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/022_proofs_of_claim_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/05_cash_management/034_cash_management_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/06_financing/046_financing_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/09_litigation/070_litigation_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/11_notices_ballots/082_notices_ballots_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/097_cascade_retail_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "the operative cap is $922,000.00 under CB-RS-2803-R723; the matched ledger population totals $1,090,723.00 under CB-RS-2803-E348. Identity resolves to ENT-043-1011, revision REV-2025.5 is current, and Amara Patel is active with capacity 2.", "due_date": "2026-09-08", "id": "ACT-CBP-043-12", "identity_id": "ENT-043-1011", "issue": "duplicate proof of claim", "owner": "Amara Patel", "portfolio_key": "CBP-043-12", "recommended_action": "Create claimant-level reconciliation rows and hold name-only matches. Owner: Amara Patel; due 2026-09-08.", "severity": "high", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_claims_register/012_claims_register_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/024_proofs_of_claim_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/05_cash_management/036_cash_management_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/06_financing/048_financing_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/097_cascade_retail_impact_population.xlsx"]}], "as_of": "2026-09-11", "decision": {"alternatives_considered": ["cascade-retail:shortcut", "cascade-retail:blanket-hold"], "question": "How should Cascade reconcile duplicate claims, offsets, rejected leases, and ballot amounts?", "rationale": "The four-part causal test supports 9 scoped actions and leaves 3 records on evidence hold. Claim allowance and voting treatment require exact identity and applicable bankruptcy classification.", "recommendation": "Consolidate duplicates and set supported reserves and ballot amounts.", "selected_option_id": "cascade-retail:scoped-evidence"}, "holds": [{"id": "HOLD-CBP-043-04", "issue": "guaranty overlap", "portfolio_key": "CBP-043-04", "reason": "the current observation does not meet the operative trigger", "required_next_evidence": "a current observation that satisfies the operative trigger", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/004_petition_schedules_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/02_claims_register/016_claims_register_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/028_contracts_leases_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/05_cash_management/040_cash_management_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/07_critical_vendors/052_critical_vendors_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/08_tax/064_tax_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/097_cascade_retail_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-043-08", "issue": "ballot amount discrepancy", "portfolio_key": "CBP-043-08", "reason": "the current observation does not meet the operative trigger", "required_next_evidence": "a current observation that satisfies the operative trigger", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/008_petition_schedules_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/020_proofs_of_claim_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/032_contracts_leases_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/06_financing/044_financing_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/07_critical_vendors/056_critical_vendors_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/09_litigation/068_litigation_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/097_cascade_retail_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-043-11", "issue": "cash-collateral reporting gap", "portfolio_key": "CBP-043-11", "reason": "two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key", "required_next_evidence": "an approved immutable entity crosswalk", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_claims_register/011_claims_register_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/023_proofs_of_claim_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/05_cash_management/035_cash_management_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/06_financing/047_financing_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/095_reconciliations_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/11_notices_ballots/083_notices_ballots_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/097_cascade_retail_impact_population.xlsx"]}], "matter_number": "CB-RS-2803", "prepared_for": "Cascade Outdoor Retail Corp.", "schema_version": "counselbench.decision.v3", "task_id": "cb100-043-cascade-retail"}, "matter_register": {"matter_number": "CB-RS-2803", "rows": [{"decision_option_id": "cascade-retail:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-10", "issue": "tax priority period", "matter_number": "CB-RS-2803", "owner": "Isaac Romero", "portfolio_key": "CBP-043-01", "row_id": "REG-CBP-043-01", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/001_petition_schedules_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/02_claims_register/013_claims_register_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/025_contracts_leases_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/05_cash_management/037_cash_management_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/07_critical_vendors/049_critical_vendors_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/097_cascade_retail_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "cascade-retail:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-09", "issue": "reserve calculation error", "matter_number": "CB-RS-2803", "owner": "Nadine Flores", "portfolio_key": "CBP-043-02", "row_id": "REG-CBP-043-02", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/002_petition_schedules_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/02_claims_register/014_claims_register_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/026_contracts_leases_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/05_cash_management/038_cash_management_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/07_critical_vendors/050_critical_vendors_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/11_notices_ballots/086_notices_ballots_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/097_cascade_retail_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "cascade-retail:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-08", "issue": "executory-contract cure dispute", "matter_number": "CB-RS-2803", "owner": "Rafael Okafor", "portfolio_key": "CBP-043-03", "row_id": "REG-CBP-043-03", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/003_petition_schedules_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/02_claims_register/015_claims_register_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/027_contracts_leases_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/05_cash_management/039_cash_management_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/11_notices_ballots/087_notices_ballots_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/097_cascade_retail_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "cascade-retail:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "the current observation does not meet the operative trigger", "issue": "guaranty overlap", "matter_number": "CB-RS-2803", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-043-04", "row_id": "REG-CBP-043-04", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/004_petition_schedules_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/02_claims_register/016_claims_register_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/028_contracts_leases_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/05_cash_management/040_cash_management_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/07_critical_vendors/052_critical_vendors_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/08_tax/064_tax_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/097_cascade_retail_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "cascade-retail:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-06", "issue": "notice-address defect", "matter_number": "CB-RS-2803", "owner": "Theo Laurent", "portfolio_key": "CBP-043-05", "row_id": "REG-CBP-043-05", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/005_petition_schedules_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/017_proofs_of_claim_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/029_contracts_leases_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/06_financing/041_financing_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/097_cascade_retail_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "cascade-retail:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-05", "issue": "priority classification error", "matter_number": "CB-RS-2803", "owner": "Lena Varga", "portfolio_key": "CBP-043-06", "row_id": "REG-CBP-043-06", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/006_petition_schedules_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/018_proofs_of_claim_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/030_contracts_leases_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/06_financing/042_financing_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/097_cascade_retail_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "cascade-retail:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-04", "issue": "setoff assertion", "matter_number": "CB-RS-2803", "owner": "Elliot Mercer", "portfolio_key": "CBP-043-07", "row_id": "REG-CBP-043-07", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/007_petition_schedules_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/019_proofs_of_claim_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/031_contracts_leases_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/06_financing/043_financing_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/07_critical_vendors/055_critical_vendors_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/097_cascade_retail_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "cascade-retail:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "the current observation does not meet the operative trigger", "issue": "ballot amount discrepancy", "matter_number": "CB-RS-2803", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-043-08", "row_id": "REG-CBP-043-08", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/008_petition_schedules_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/020_proofs_of_claim_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/032_contracts_leases_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/06_financing/044_financing_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/07_critical_vendors/056_critical_vendors_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/09_litigation/068_litigation_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/097_cascade_retail_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "cascade-retail:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-02", "issue": "secured-status defect", "matter_number": "CB-RS-2803", "owner": "Micah Sullivan", "portfolio_key": "CBP-043-09", "row_id": "REG-CBP-043-09", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_claims_register/009_claims_register_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/021_proofs_of_claim_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/05_cash_management/033_cash_management_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/06_financing/045_financing_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/08_tax/057_tax_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/097_cascade_retail_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "cascade-retail:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-10", "issue": "critical-vendor overstatement", "matter_number": "CB-RS-2803", "owner": "Nora Chen", "portfolio_key": "CBP-043-10", "row_id": "REG-CBP-043-10", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_claims_register/010_claims_register_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/022_proofs_of_claim_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/05_cash_management/034_cash_management_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/06_financing/046_financing_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/09_litigation/070_litigation_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/11_notices_ballots/082_notices_ballots_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/097_cascade_retail_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "cascade-retail:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key", "issue": "cash-collateral reporting gap", "matter_number": "CB-RS-2803", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-043-11", "row_id": "REG-CBP-043-11", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_claims_register/011_claims_register_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/023_proofs_of_claim_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/05_cash_management/035_cash_management_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/06_financing/047_financing_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/095_reconciliations_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/11_notices_ballots/083_notices_ballots_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/097_cascade_retail_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "cascade-retail:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-08", "issue": "duplicate proof of claim", "matter_number": "CB-RS-2803", "owner": "Amara Patel", "portfolio_key": "CBP-043-12", "row_id": "REG-CBP-043-12", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_claims_register/012_claims_register_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/024_proofs_of_claim_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/05_cash_management/036_cash_management_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/06_financing/048_financing_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/097_cascade_retail_impact_population.xlsx"]}], "schema_version": "counselbench.matter-register.v3", "task_id": "cb100-043-cascade-retail"}}, "metadata": {"benchmark": "CounselBench-100", "code_license": "Apache-2.0", "data_license": "CC-BY-4.0", "deadline": "2026-09-11", "document_count": 97, "evidence_holds": 3, "jurisdiction": "Delaware", "matter_number": "CB-RS-2803", "mcp_commit": "9a96ea6e5913736f92b88345bf51caeaaa8e719f", "mcp_package": "@modelcontextprotocol/server-filesystem@2026.7.10", "practice_area": "restructuring", "reference_tool_calls": 86, "required_evidence_reads": 64, "supported_actions": 9, "synthetic": true, "venue": "District of Delaware Bankruptcy Court", "version": "3.1.0"}, "prompt": "A late record changed the picture this morning. How should Cascade reconcile duplicate claims, offsets, rejected leases, and ballot amounts? A retail debtor faces duplicate claims, returned-goods offsets, rejected store leases, and inconsistent ballot amounts. The team needs the call by 2026-09-11. Make the matter record usable by operations after your review, but do not turn ambiguity into an accusation or obligation.", "rubric": {"criteria": [{"category": "investigation", "description": "Inventory the production and use targeted searches to locate records across native formats.", "id": "investigation.discover_production"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Complete every task-specific identity, authority, operations, and approval read before the first state transition.", "id": "investigation.read_before_write"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Inspect designated source metadata before relying on those records.", "id": "investigation.custody_before_write"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "Select the supported option 'cascade-retail:scoped-evidence' after applying the four-part test.", "id": "decision.selected_option"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "Identify both rejected approaches and explain why a one-source shortcut and a blanket hold are wrong.", "id": "decision.alternatives"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-043-01 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/001_petition_schedules_source_export.md rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-043-01.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_claims_register/013_claims_register_source_export.json for tax priority period.", "id": "investigation.CBP-043-01.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/025_contracts_leases_source_export.md to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-043-01.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_cash_management/037_cash_management_source_export.json.", "id": "investigation.CBP-043-01.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-043-01 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-043-01.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-043-01 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-043-01.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-043-02 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/002_petition_schedules_source_export.txt rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-043-02.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_claims_register/014_claims_register_source_export.xml for reserve calculation error.", "id": "investigation.CBP-043-02.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/026_contracts_leases_source_export.txt to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-043-02.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_cash_management/038_cash_management_source_export.xml.", "id": "investigation.CBP-043-02.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-043-02 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-043-02.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-043-02 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-043-02.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-043-03 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/003_petition_schedules_source_export.eml rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-043-03.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_claims_register/015_claims_register_source_export.html for executory-contract cure dispute.", "id": "investigation.CBP-043-03.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/027_contracts_leases_source_export.eml to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-043-03.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_cash_management/039_cash_management_source_export.html.", "id": "investigation.CBP-043-03.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-043-03 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-043-03.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-043-03 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-043-03.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-043-04 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/004_petition_schedules_source_export.csv rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-043-04.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_claims_register/016_claims_register_source_export.pdf for guaranty overlap.", "id": "investigation.CBP-043-04.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/028_contracts_leases_source_export.csv to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-043-04.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_cash_management/040_cash_management_source_export.pdf.", "id": "investigation.CBP-043-04.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-043-04 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is the current observation does not meet the operative trigger.", "id": "decision.CBP-043-04.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-043-04 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-043-04.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-043-05 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/005_petition_schedules_source_export.json rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-043-05.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/017_proofs_of_claim_source_export.md for notice-address defect.", "id": "investigation.CBP-043-05.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/029_contracts_leases_source_export.json to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-043-05.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_financing/041_financing_source_export.md.", "id": "investigation.CBP-043-05.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-043-05 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-043-05.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-043-05 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-043-05.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-043-06 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/006_petition_schedules_source_export.xml rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-043-06.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/018_proofs_of_claim_source_export.txt for priority classification error.", "id": "investigation.CBP-043-06.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/030_contracts_leases_source_export.xml to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-043-06.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_financing/042_financing_source_export.txt.", "id": "investigation.CBP-043-06.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-043-06 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-043-06.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-043-06 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-043-06.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-043-07 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/007_petition_schedules_source_export.html rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-043-07.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/019_proofs_of_claim_source_export.eml for setoff assertion.", "id": "investigation.CBP-043-07.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/031_contracts_leases_source_export.html to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-043-07.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_financing/043_financing_source_export.eml.", "id": "investigation.CBP-043-07.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-043-07 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-043-07.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-043-07 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-043-07.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-043-08 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/008_petition_schedules_source_export.pdf rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-043-08.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/020_proofs_of_claim_source_export.csv for ballot amount discrepancy.", "id": "investigation.CBP-043-08.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/032_contracts_leases_source_export.pdf to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-043-08.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_financing/044_financing_source_export.csv.", "id": "investigation.CBP-043-08.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-043-08 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is the current observation does not meet the operative trigger.", "id": "decision.CBP-043-08.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-043-08 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-043-08.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-043-09 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_claims_register/009_claims_register_source_export.md rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-043-09.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/021_proofs_of_claim_source_export.json for secured-status defect.", "id": "investigation.CBP-043-09.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_cash_management/033_cash_management_source_export.md to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-043-09.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_financing/045_financing_source_export.json.", "id": "investigation.CBP-043-09.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-043-09 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-043-09.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-043-09 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-043-09.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-043-10 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_claims_register/010_claims_register_source_export.txt rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-043-10.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/022_proofs_of_claim_source_export.xml for critical-vendor overstatement.", "id": "investigation.CBP-043-10.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_cash_management/034_cash_management_source_export.txt to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-043-10.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_financing/046_financing_source_export.xml.", "id": "investigation.CBP-043-10.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-043-10 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-043-10.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-043-10 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-043-10.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-043-11 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_claims_register/011_claims_register_source_export.eml rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-043-11.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/023_proofs_of_claim_source_export.html for cash-collateral reporting gap.", "id": "investigation.CBP-043-11.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_cash_management/035_cash_management_source_export.eml to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-043-11.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_financing/047_financing_source_export.html.", "id": "investigation.CBP-043-11.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-043-11 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key.", "id": "decision.CBP-043-11.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-043-11 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-043-11.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-043-12 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_claims_register/012_claims_register_source_export.csv rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-043-12.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/024_proofs_of_claim_source_export.pdf for duplicate proof of claim.", "id": "investigation.CBP-043-12.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_cash_management/036_cash_management_source_export.csv to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-043-12.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_financing/048_financing_source_export.pdf.", "id": "investigation.CBP-043-12.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-043-12 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-043-12.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-043-12 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-043-12.register"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Write the exact selected option, supported action population, evidence-hold population, facts, owners, deadlines, and citations.", "id": "state.exact_decision"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create one exact register row per portfolio key with no extra, missing, or modified row.", "id": "state.exact_register"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Leave only the three approved deliverables and perform no extra state-changing write.", "id": "state.write_scope_containment"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Read back decision.json, matter-register.json, and advice.md after their final writes.", "id": "state.postwrite_readback"}, {"category": "answer", "description": "Explain the selected recommendation, supported actions, holds, alternatives, and limitations with exact source anchors.", "id": "answer.decision_note"}], "decision_options": [{"approach": "Apply the exact identity, current-state, authority, and revision test. Create claimant-level reconciliation rows and hold name-only matches.", "id": "cascade-retail:scoped-evidence", "label": "Consolidate duplicates and set supported reserves and ballot amounts."}, {"approach": "Use a plausible summary or one source without completing the controlling joins.", "id": "cascade-retail:shortcut", "label": "Choose the largest claim and ballot amount for every claimant name."}, {"approach": "Treat supported actions and genuinely ambiguous records as if they were equally unresolved.", "id": "cascade-retail:blanket-hold", "label": "Freeze the entire matter population"}], "evaluation_narrative": {"authority": "Claim allowance and voting treatment require exact identity and applicable bankruptcy classification.", "observation": "Match claimant identity, obligation, returns, rejection date, and ballot record across systems.", "question": "How should Cascade reconcile duplicate claims, offsets, rejected leases, and ballot amounts?", "register_action": "Create claimant-level reconciliation rows and hold name-only matches."}, "gates": ["all_required_evidence_precedes_first_write", "decision_criteria_complete", "register_state_exact", "write_scope_contained", "all_outputs_verified_by_readback"], "metadata_checks": 6, "metric": "weighted_criteria_score", "minimum_tool_calls": 86, "required_deliverables": ["decision.json", "matter-register.json", "advice.md"], "required_document_reads": 64, "type": "deterministic", "weights": {"advice": 0.15, "decision": 0.35, "investigation": 0.25, "state": 0.25}}, "task_id": "cb100-043-cascade-retail", "task_name": "Cascade Retail claims reserve audit", "world_id": "counselbench-filesystem-mcp-v3"}
+{"context_files": ["task_files/cb100-044-drummond-care/01_petition_schedules/001_petition_schedules_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-044-drummond-care/01_petition_schedules/002_petition_schedules_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-044-drummond-care/01_petition_schedules/003_petition_schedules_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-044-drummond-care/01_petition_schedules/004_petition_schedules_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-044-drummond-care/01_petition_schedules/005_petition_schedules_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-044-drummond-care/01_petition_schedules/006_petition_schedules_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-044-drummond-care/01_petition_schedules/007_petition_schedules_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-044-drummond-care/01_petition_schedules/008_petition_schedules_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-044-drummond-care/02_claims_register/009_claims_register_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-044-drummond-care/02_claims_register/010_claims_register_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-044-drummond-care/02_claims_register/011_claims_register_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-044-drummond-care/02_claims_register/012_claims_register_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-044-drummond-care/02_claims_register/013_claims_register_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-044-drummond-care/02_claims_register/014_claims_register_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-044-drummond-care/02_claims_register/015_claims_register_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-044-drummond-care/02_claims_register/016_claims_register_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-044-drummond-care/03_proofs_of_claim/017_proofs_of_claim_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-044-drummond-care/03_proofs_of_claim/018_proofs_of_claim_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-044-drummond-care/03_proofs_of_claim/019_proofs_of_claim_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-044-drummond-care/03_proofs_of_claim/020_proofs_of_claim_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-044-drummond-care/03_proofs_of_claim/021_proofs_of_claim_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-044-drummond-care/03_proofs_of_claim/022_proofs_of_claim_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-044-drummond-care/03_proofs_of_claim/023_proofs_of_claim_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-044-drummond-care/03_proofs_of_claim/024_proofs_of_claim_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-044-drummond-care/04_contracts_leases/025_contracts_leases_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-044-drummond-care/04_contracts_leases/026_contracts_leases_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-044-drummond-care/04_contracts_leases/027_contracts_leases_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-044-drummond-care/04_contracts_leases/028_contracts_leases_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-044-drummond-care/04_contracts_leases/029_contracts_leases_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-044-drummond-care/04_contracts_leases/030_contracts_leases_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-044-drummond-care/04_contracts_leases/031_contracts_leases_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-044-drummond-care/04_contracts_leases/032_contracts_leases_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-044-drummond-care/05_cash_management/033_cash_management_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-044-drummond-care/05_cash_management/034_cash_management_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-044-drummond-care/05_cash_management/035_cash_management_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-044-drummond-care/05_cash_management/036_cash_management_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-044-drummond-care/05_cash_management/037_cash_management_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-044-drummond-care/05_cash_management/038_cash_management_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-044-drummond-care/05_cash_management/039_cash_management_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-044-drummond-care/05_cash_management/040_cash_management_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-044-drummond-care/06_financing/041_financing_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-044-drummond-care/06_financing/042_financing_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-044-drummond-care/06_financing/043_financing_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-044-drummond-care/06_financing/044_financing_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-044-drummond-care/06_financing/045_financing_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-044-drummond-care/06_financing/046_financing_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-044-drummond-care/06_financing/047_financing_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-044-drummond-care/06_financing/048_financing_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-044-drummond-care/07_critical_vendors/049_critical_vendors_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-044-drummond-care/07_critical_vendors/050_critical_vendors_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-044-drummond-care/07_critical_vendors/051_critical_vendors_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-044-drummond-care/07_critical_vendors/052_critical_vendors_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-044-drummond-care/07_critical_vendors/053_critical_vendors_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-044-drummond-care/07_critical_vendors/054_critical_vendors_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-044-drummond-care/07_critical_vendors/055_critical_vendors_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-044-drummond-care/07_critical_vendors/056_critical_vendors_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-044-drummond-care/08_tax/057_tax_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-044-drummond-care/08_tax/058_tax_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-044-drummond-care/08_tax/059_tax_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-044-drummond-care/08_tax/060_tax_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-044-drummond-care/08_tax/061_tax_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-044-drummond-care/08_tax/062_tax_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-044-drummond-care/08_tax/063_tax_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-044-drummond-care/08_tax/064_tax_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-044-drummond-care/09_litigation/065_litigation_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-044-drummond-care/09_litigation/066_litigation_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-044-drummond-care/09_litigation/067_litigation_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-044-drummond-care/09_litigation/068_litigation_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-044-drummond-care/09_litigation/069_litigation_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-044-drummond-care/09_litigation/070_litigation_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-044-drummond-care/09_litigation/071_litigation_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-044-drummond-care/09_litigation/072_litigation_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-044-drummond-care/10_plan_disclosure/073_plan_disclosure_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-044-drummond-care/10_plan_disclosure/074_plan_disclosure_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-044-drummond-care/10_plan_disclosure/075_plan_disclosure_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-044-drummond-care/10_plan_disclosure/076_plan_disclosure_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-044-drummond-care/10_plan_disclosure/077_plan_disclosure_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-044-drummond-care/10_plan_disclosure/078_plan_disclosure_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-044-drummond-care/10_plan_disclosure/079_plan_disclosure_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-044-drummond-care/10_plan_disclosure/080_plan_disclosure_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-044-drummond-care/11_notices_ballots/081_notices_ballots_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-044-drummond-care/11_notices_ballots/082_notices_ballots_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-044-drummond-care/11_notices_ballots/083_notices_ballots_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-044-drummond-care/11_notices_ballots/084_notices_ballots_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-044-drummond-care/11_notices_ballots/085_notices_ballots_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-044-drummond-care/11_notices_ballots/086_notices_ballots_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-044-drummond-care/11_notices_ballots/087_notices_ballots_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-044-drummond-care/11_notices_ballots/088_notices_ballots_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-044-drummond-care/12_reconciliations/089_reconciliations_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-044-drummond-care/12_reconciliations/090_reconciliations_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-044-drummond-care/12_reconciliations/091_reconciliations_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-044-drummond-care/12_reconciliations/092_reconciliations_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-044-drummond-care/12_reconciliations/093_reconciliations_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-044-drummond-care/12_reconciliations/094_reconciliations_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-044-drummond-care/12_reconciliations/095_reconciliations_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-044-drummond-care/12_reconciliations/096_reconciliations_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-044-drummond-care/12_reconciliations/097_drummond_care_impact_population.xlsx"], "gold_output": {"advice_markdown": "# Decision note — Drummond Care restructuring schedule check\n\n## Recommendation\n\nCorrect supported classifications and the exact receivable reserve. The reconciled record supports 9 scoped actions and leaves 3 items on evidence hold.\n\nSelected option: `drummond-care:scoped-evidence`.\n\n## Why this is the supported option\n\nJoin schedules, proofs of claim, staffing periods, tax priority, landlord records, and receivables. Filed claims, priority periods, and court-approved reporting definitions control.\n\n## Supported actions\n\n### CBP-044-01 — DIP budget variance (medium)\n\nan open exception blocks completion under CB-RS-2804-R343; the current status is open and unresolved under CB-RS-2804-E167. Identity resolves to ENT-044-1000, revision REV-2026.1 is current, and Willa Novak is active with capacity 4.\n\nAction: Create obligation-level claim and budget rows with period-specific holds. Owner: Willa Novak; due 2026-09-14.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/001_petition_schedules_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/02_claims_register/013_claims_register_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/025_contracts_leases_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/05_cash_management/037_cash_management_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/097_drummond_care_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-044-02 — scheduled-claim mismatch (medium)\n\ncompletion is required by 2026-02-27 under CB-RS-2804-R397; the current event record shows completion on 2026-03-26 under CB-RS-2804-E276. Identity resolves to ENT-044-1001, revision REV-2026.2 is current, and Owen Delgado is active with capacity 6.\n\nAction: Create obligation-level claim and budget rows with period-specific holds. Owner: Owen Delgado; due 2026-09-13.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/002_petition_schedules_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/02_claims_register/014_claims_register_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/026_contracts_leases_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/05_cash_management/038_cash_management_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/097_drummond_care_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-044-03 — lease rejection deadline (medium)\n\nthe controlling threshold is 13% under CB-RS-2804-R648; the independently calculated result is 18% under CB-RS-2804-E291. Identity resolves to ENT-044-1002, revision REV-2026.3 is current, and Priya Raman is active with capacity 6.\n\nAction: Create obligation-level claim and budget rows with period-specific holds. Owner: Priya Raman; due 2026-09-12.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/003_petition_schedules_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/02_claims_register/015_claims_register_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/027_contracts_leases_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/05_cash_management/039_cash_management_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/10_plan_disclosure/075_plan_disclosure_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/08_tax/063_tax_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/097_drummond_care_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-044-05 — reserve calculation error (critical)\n\nthe controlled population contains 160 records under CB-RS-2804-R878; the certification covers 151 records under CB-RS-2804-E675. Identity resolves to ENT-044-1004, revision REV-2026.5 is current, and Nadine Flores is active with capacity 3.\n\nAction: Create obligation-level claim and budget rows with period-specific holds. Owner: Nadine Flores; due 2026-09-10.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/005_petition_schedules_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/017_proofs_of_claim_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/029_contracts_leases_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/06_financing/041_financing_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/07_critical_vendors/053_critical_vendors_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/097_drummond_care_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-044-06 — executory-contract cure dispute (medium)\n\nthe permission is limited to District of New Jersey Bankruptcy Court under CB-RS-2804-R180; the matched activity occurred in New Jersey under CB-RS-2804-E845. Identity resolves to ENT-044-1005, revision REV-2026.6 is current, and Rafael Okafor is active with capacity 3.\n\nAction: Create obligation-level claim and budget rows with period-specific holds. Owner: Rafael Okafor; due 2026-09-09.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/006_petition_schedules_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/018_proofs_of_claim_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/030_contracts_leases_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/06_financing/042_financing_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/09_litigation/066_litigation_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/097_drummond_care_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-044-07 — guaranty overlap (low)\n\nthe operative cap is $4,162,000.00 under CB-RS-2804-R865; the matched ledger population totals $4,215,065.00 under CB-RS-2804-E992. Identity resolves to ENT-044-1006, revision REV-2026.7 is current, and Mei Whitaker is active with capacity 5.\n\nAction: Create obligation-level claim and budget rows with period-specific holds. Owner: Mei Whitaker; due 2026-09-08.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/007_petition_schedules_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/019_proofs_of_claim_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/031_contracts_leases_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/06_financing/043_financing_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/097_drummond_care_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-044-08 — notice-address defect (low)\n\ndelivery must use notices-drummond_senior_care_group@example.test under CB-RS-2804-R161; the only matched receipt used archive-pinecrest_medical_staffing@example.test under CB-RS-2804-E633. Identity resolves to ENT-044-1007, revision REV-2026.1 is current, and Theo Laurent is active with capacity 1.\n\nAction: Create obligation-level claim and budget rows with period-specific holds. Owner: Theo Laurent; due 2026-09-07.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/008_petition_schedules_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/020_proofs_of_claim_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/032_contracts_leases_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/06_financing/044_financing_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/10_plan_disclosure/080_plan_disclosure_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/097_drummond_care_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-044-10 — setoff assertion (medium)\n\ncompletion is required by 2026-01-16 under CB-RS-2804-R115; the current event record shows completion on 2026-02-04 under CB-RS-2804-E365. Identity resolves to ENT-044-1009, revision REV-2026.3 is current, and Elliot Mercer is active with capacity 5.\n\nAction: Create obligation-level claim and budget rows with period-specific holds. Owner: Elliot Mercer; due 2026-09-14.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/02_claims_register/010_claims_register_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/022_proofs_of_claim_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/05_cash_management/034_cash_management_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/06_financing/046_financing_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/11_notices_ballots/082_notices_ballots_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/094_reconciliations_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/097_drummond_care_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-044-11 — ballot amount discrepancy (low)\n\nthe controlling threshold is 5% under CB-RS-2804-R514; the independently calculated result is 9% under CB-RS-2804-E812. Identity resolves to ENT-044-1010, revision REV-2026.4 is current, and Sofia Bennett is active with capacity 6.\n\nAction: Create obligation-level claim and budget rows with period-specific holds. Owner: Sofia Bennett; due 2026-09-13.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/02_claims_register/011_claims_register_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/023_proofs_of_claim_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/05_cash_management/035_cash_management_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/06_financing/047_financing_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/11_notices_ballots/083_notices_ballots_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/08_tax/059_tax_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/097_drummond_care_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n## Evidence holds\n\n- **CBP-044-04 — tax priority period**: the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective. Next evidence: effective approval and an active owner with remaining capacity. Sources: `/workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/004_petition_schedules_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/02_claims_register/016_claims_register_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/028_contracts_leases_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/05_cash_management/040_cash_management_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/11_notices_ballots/088_notices_ballots_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/097_drummond_care_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-044-09 — priority classification error**: the operational record relies on a superseded control revision. Next evidence: an operational record using the current effective revision. Sources: `/workspace/documents/02_claims_register/009_claims_register_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/021_proofs_of_claim_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/05_cash_management/033_cash_management_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/06_financing/045_financing_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/11_notices_ballots/081_notices_ballots_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/08_tax/057_tax_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/097_drummond_care_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-044-12 — secured-status defect**: the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective. Next evidence: effective approval and an active owner with remaining capacity. Sources: `/workspace/documents/02_claims_register/012_claims_register_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/024_proofs_of_claim_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/05_cash_management/036_cash_management_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/06_financing/048_financing_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/11_notices_ballots/084_notices_ballots_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/09_litigation/072_litigation_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/097_drummond_care_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n## Alternatives considered\n\n- `drummond-care:shortcut` — Roll every disputed amount into one conservative reserve.: Use a plausible summary or one source without completing the controlling joins.\n- `drummond-care:blanket-hold` — Freeze the entire matter population: Treat supported actions and genuinely ambiguous records as if they were equally unresolved.\n\n## Assumptions and limits\n\nThis decision is limited to cb100-044-drummond-care, the supplied synthetic records, and the matter state as of 2026-09-15. Similar names, stale revisions, and pending authority are not treated as proof.\n", "decision": {"actions": [{"determination": "an open exception blocks completion under CB-RS-2804-R343; the current status is open and unresolved under CB-RS-2804-E167. Identity resolves to ENT-044-1000, revision REV-2026.1 is current, and Willa Novak is active with capacity 4.", "due_date": "2026-09-14", "id": "ACT-CBP-044-01", "identity_id": "ENT-044-1000", "issue": "DIP budget variance", "owner": "Willa Novak", "portfolio_key": "CBP-044-01", "recommended_action": "Create obligation-level claim and budget rows with period-specific holds. Owner: Willa Novak; due 2026-09-14.", "severity": "medium", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/001_petition_schedules_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/02_claims_register/013_claims_register_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/025_contracts_leases_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/05_cash_management/037_cash_management_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/097_drummond_care_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "completion is required by 2026-02-27 under CB-RS-2804-R397; the current event record shows completion on 2026-03-26 under CB-RS-2804-E276. Identity resolves to ENT-044-1001, revision REV-2026.2 is current, and Owen Delgado is active with capacity 6.", "due_date": "2026-09-13", "id": "ACT-CBP-044-02", "identity_id": "ENT-044-1001", "issue": "scheduled-claim mismatch", "owner": "Owen Delgado", "portfolio_key": "CBP-044-02", "recommended_action": "Create obligation-level claim and budget rows with period-specific holds. Owner: Owen Delgado; due 2026-09-13.", "severity": "medium", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/002_petition_schedules_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/02_claims_register/014_claims_register_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/026_contracts_leases_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/05_cash_management/038_cash_management_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/097_drummond_care_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "the controlling threshold is 13% under CB-RS-2804-R648; the independently calculated result is 18% under CB-RS-2804-E291. Identity resolves to ENT-044-1002, revision REV-2026.3 is current, and Priya Raman is active with capacity 6.", "due_date": "2026-09-12", "id": "ACT-CBP-044-03", "identity_id": "ENT-044-1002", "issue": "lease rejection deadline", "owner": "Priya Raman", "portfolio_key": "CBP-044-03", "recommended_action": "Create obligation-level claim and budget rows with period-specific holds. Owner: Priya Raman; due 2026-09-12.", "severity": "medium", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/003_petition_schedules_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/02_claims_register/015_claims_register_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/027_contracts_leases_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/05_cash_management/039_cash_management_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/10_plan_disclosure/075_plan_disclosure_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/08_tax/063_tax_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/097_drummond_care_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "the controlled population contains 160 records under CB-RS-2804-R878; the certification covers 151 records under CB-RS-2804-E675. Identity resolves to ENT-044-1004, revision REV-2026.5 is current, and Nadine Flores is active with capacity 3.", "due_date": "2026-09-10", "id": "ACT-CBP-044-05", "identity_id": "ENT-044-1004", "issue": "reserve calculation error", "owner": "Nadine Flores", "portfolio_key": "CBP-044-05", "recommended_action": "Create obligation-level claim and budget rows with period-specific holds. Owner: Nadine Flores; due 2026-09-10.", "severity": "critical", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/005_petition_schedules_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/017_proofs_of_claim_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/029_contracts_leases_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/06_financing/041_financing_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/07_critical_vendors/053_critical_vendors_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/097_drummond_care_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "the permission is limited to District of New Jersey Bankruptcy Court under CB-RS-2804-R180; the matched activity occurred in New Jersey under CB-RS-2804-E845. Identity resolves to ENT-044-1005, revision REV-2026.6 is current, and Rafael Okafor is active with capacity 3.", "due_date": "2026-09-09", "id": "ACT-CBP-044-06", "identity_id": "ENT-044-1005", "issue": "executory-contract cure dispute", "owner": "Rafael Okafor", "portfolio_key": "CBP-044-06", "recommended_action": "Create obligation-level claim and budget rows with period-specific holds. Owner: Rafael Okafor; due 2026-09-09.", "severity": "medium", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/006_petition_schedules_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/018_proofs_of_claim_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/030_contracts_leases_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/06_financing/042_financing_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/09_litigation/066_litigation_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/097_drummond_care_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "the operative cap is $4,162,000.00 under CB-RS-2804-R865; the matched ledger population totals $4,215,065.00 under CB-RS-2804-E992. Identity resolves to ENT-044-1006, revision REV-2026.7 is current, and Mei Whitaker is active with capacity 5.", "due_date": "2026-09-08", "id": "ACT-CBP-044-07", "identity_id": "ENT-044-1006", "issue": "guaranty overlap", "owner": "Mei Whitaker", "portfolio_key": "CBP-044-07", "recommended_action": "Create obligation-level claim and budget rows with period-specific holds. Owner: Mei Whitaker; due 2026-09-08.", "severity": "low", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/007_petition_schedules_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/019_proofs_of_claim_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/031_contracts_leases_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/06_financing/043_financing_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/097_drummond_care_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "delivery must use notices-drummond_senior_care_group@example.test under CB-RS-2804-R161; the only matched receipt used archive-pinecrest_medical_staffing@example.test under CB-RS-2804-E633. Identity resolves to ENT-044-1007, revision REV-2026.1 is current, and Theo Laurent is active with capacity 1.", "due_date": "2026-09-07", "id": "ACT-CBP-044-08", "identity_id": "ENT-044-1007", "issue": "notice-address defect", "owner": "Theo Laurent", "portfolio_key": "CBP-044-08", "recommended_action": "Create obligation-level claim and budget rows with period-specific holds. Owner: Theo Laurent; due 2026-09-07.", "severity": "low", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/008_petition_schedules_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/020_proofs_of_claim_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/032_contracts_leases_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/06_financing/044_financing_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/10_plan_disclosure/080_plan_disclosure_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/097_drummond_care_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "completion is required by 2026-01-16 under CB-RS-2804-R115; the current event record shows completion on 2026-02-04 under CB-RS-2804-E365. Identity resolves to ENT-044-1009, revision REV-2026.3 is current, and Elliot Mercer is active with capacity 5.", "due_date": "2026-09-14", "id": "ACT-CBP-044-10", "identity_id": "ENT-044-1009", "issue": "setoff assertion", "owner": "Elliot Mercer", "portfolio_key": "CBP-044-10", "recommended_action": "Create obligation-level claim and budget rows with period-specific holds. Owner: Elliot Mercer; due 2026-09-14.", "severity": "medium", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_claims_register/010_claims_register_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/022_proofs_of_claim_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/05_cash_management/034_cash_management_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/06_financing/046_financing_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/11_notices_ballots/082_notices_ballots_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/094_reconciliations_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/097_drummond_care_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "the controlling threshold is 5% under CB-RS-2804-R514; the independently calculated result is 9% under CB-RS-2804-E812. Identity resolves to ENT-044-1010, revision REV-2026.4 is current, and Sofia Bennett is active with capacity 6.", "due_date": "2026-09-13", "id": "ACT-CBP-044-11", "identity_id": "ENT-044-1010", "issue": "ballot amount discrepancy", "owner": "Sofia Bennett", "portfolio_key": "CBP-044-11", "recommended_action": "Create obligation-level claim and budget rows with period-specific holds. Owner: Sofia Bennett; due 2026-09-13.", "severity": "low", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_claims_register/011_claims_register_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/023_proofs_of_claim_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/05_cash_management/035_cash_management_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/06_financing/047_financing_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/11_notices_ballots/083_notices_ballots_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/08_tax/059_tax_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/097_drummond_care_impact_population.xlsx"]}], "as_of": "2026-09-15", "decision": {"alternatives_considered": ["drummond-care:shortcut", "drummond-care:blanket-hold"], "question": "Which Drummond claims and receivable reserves must change before the next cash-collateral report?", "rationale": "The four-part causal test supports 9 scoped actions and leaves 3 records on evidence hold. Filed claims, priority periods, and court-approved reporting definitions control.", "recommendation": "Correct supported classifications and the exact receivable reserve.", "selected_option_id": "drummond-care:scoped-evidence"}, "holds": [{"id": "HOLD-CBP-044-04", "issue": "tax priority period", "portfolio_key": "CBP-044-04", "reason": "the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective", "required_next_evidence": "effective approval and an active owner with remaining capacity", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/004_petition_schedules_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/02_claims_register/016_claims_register_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/028_contracts_leases_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/05_cash_management/040_cash_management_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/11_notices_ballots/088_notices_ballots_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/097_drummond_care_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-044-09", "issue": "priority classification error", "portfolio_key": "CBP-044-09", "reason": "the operational record relies on a superseded control revision", "required_next_evidence": "an operational record using the current effective revision", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_claims_register/009_claims_register_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/021_proofs_of_claim_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/05_cash_management/033_cash_management_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/06_financing/045_financing_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/11_notices_ballots/081_notices_ballots_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/08_tax/057_tax_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/097_drummond_care_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-044-12", "issue": "secured-status defect", "portfolio_key": "CBP-044-12", "reason": "the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective", "required_next_evidence": "effective approval and an active owner with remaining capacity", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_claims_register/012_claims_register_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/024_proofs_of_claim_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/05_cash_management/036_cash_management_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/06_financing/048_financing_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/11_notices_ballots/084_notices_ballots_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/09_litigation/072_litigation_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/097_drummond_care_impact_population.xlsx"]}], "matter_number": "CB-RS-2804", "prepared_for": "Drummond Senior Care Group", "schema_version": "counselbench.decision.v3", "task_id": "cb100-044-drummond-care"}, "matter_register": {"matter_number": "CB-RS-2804", "rows": [{"decision_option_id": "drummond-care:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-14", "issue": "DIP budget variance", "matter_number": "CB-RS-2804", "owner": "Willa Novak", "portfolio_key": "CBP-044-01", "row_id": "REG-CBP-044-01", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/001_petition_schedules_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/02_claims_register/013_claims_register_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/025_contracts_leases_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/05_cash_management/037_cash_management_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/097_drummond_care_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "drummond-care:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-13", "issue": "scheduled-claim mismatch", "matter_number": "CB-RS-2804", "owner": "Owen Delgado", "portfolio_key": "CBP-044-02", "row_id": "REG-CBP-044-02", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/002_petition_schedules_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/02_claims_register/014_claims_register_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/026_contracts_leases_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/05_cash_management/038_cash_management_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/097_drummond_care_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "drummond-care:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-12", "issue": "lease rejection deadline", "matter_number": "CB-RS-2804", "owner": "Priya Raman", "portfolio_key": "CBP-044-03", "row_id": "REG-CBP-044-03", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/003_petition_schedules_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/02_claims_register/015_claims_register_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/027_contracts_leases_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/05_cash_management/039_cash_management_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/10_plan_disclosure/075_plan_disclosure_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/08_tax/063_tax_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/097_drummond_care_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "drummond-care:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective", "issue": "tax priority period", "matter_number": "CB-RS-2804", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-044-04", "row_id": "REG-CBP-044-04", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/004_petition_schedules_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/02_claims_register/016_claims_register_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/028_contracts_leases_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/05_cash_management/040_cash_management_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/11_notices_ballots/088_notices_ballots_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/097_drummond_care_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "drummond-care:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-10", "issue": "reserve calculation error", "matter_number": "CB-RS-2804", "owner": "Nadine Flores", "portfolio_key": "CBP-044-05", "row_id": "REG-CBP-044-05", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/005_petition_schedules_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/017_proofs_of_claim_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/029_contracts_leases_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/06_financing/041_financing_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/07_critical_vendors/053_critical_vendors_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/097_drummond_care_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "drummond-care:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-09", "issue": "executory-contract cure dispute", "matter_number": "CB-RS-2804", "owner": "Rafael Okafor", "portfolio_key": "CBP-044-06", "row_id": "REG-CBP-044-06", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/006_petition_schedules_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/018_proofs_of_claim_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/030_contracts_leases_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/06_financing/042_financing_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/09_litigation/066_litigation_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/097_drummond_care_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "drummond-care:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-08", "issue": "guaranty overlap", "matter_number": "CB-RS-2804", "owner": "Mei Whitaker", "portfolio_key": "CBP-044-07", "row_id": "REG-CBP-044-07", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/007_petition_schedules_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/019_proofs_of_claim_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/031_contracts_leases_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/06_financing/043_financing_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/097_drummond_care_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "drummond-care:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-07", "issue": "notice-address defect", "matter_number": "CB-RS-2804", "owner": "Theo Laurent", "portfolio_key": "CBP-044-08", "row_id": "REG-CBP-044-08", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/008_petition_schedules_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/020_proofs_of_claim_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/032_contracts_leases_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/06_financing/044_financing_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/10_plan_disclosure/080_plan_disclosure_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/097_drummond_care_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "drummond-care:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "the operational record relies on a superseded control revision", "issue": "priority classification error", "matter_number": "CB-RS-2804", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-044-09", "row_id": "REG-CBP-044-09", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_claims_register/009_claims_register_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/021_proofs_of_claim_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/05_cash_management/033_cash_management_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/06_financing/045_financing_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/11_notices_ballots/081_notices_ballots_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/08_tax/057_tax_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/097_drummond_care_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "drummond-care:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-14", "issue": "setoff assertion", "matter_number": "CB-RS-2804", "owner": "Elliot Mercer", "portfolio_key": "CBP-044-10", "row_id": "REG-CBP-044-10", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_claims_register/010_claims_register_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/022_proofs_of_claim_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/05_cash_management/034_cash_management_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/06_financing/046_financing_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/11_notices_ballots/082_notices_ballots_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/094_reconciliations_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/097_drummond_care_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "drummond-care:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-13", "issue": "ballot amount discrepancy", "matter_number": "CB-RS-2804", "owner": "Sofia Bennett", "portfolio_key": "CBP-044-11", "row_id": "REG-CBP-044-11", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_claims_register/011_claims_register_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/023_proofs_of_claim_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/05_cash_management/035_cash_management_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/06_financing/047_financing_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/11_notices_ballots/083_notices_ballots_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/08_tax/059_tax_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/097_drummond_care_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "drummond-care:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective", "issue": "secured-status defect", "matter_number": "CB-RS-2804", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-044-12", "row_id": "REG-CBP-044-12", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_claims_register/012_claims_register_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/024_proofs_of_claim_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/05_cash_management/036_cash_management_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/06_financing/048_financing_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/11_notices_ballots/084_notices_ballots_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/09_litigation/072_litigation_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/097_drummond_care_impact_population.xlsx"]}], "schema_version": "counselbench.matter-register.v3", "task_id": "cb100-044-drummond-care"}}, "metadata": {"benchmark": "CounselBench-100", "code_license": "Apache-2.0", "data_license": "CC-BY-4.0", "deadline": "2026-09-15", "document_count": 97, "evidence_holds": 3, "jurisdiction": "New Jersey", "matter_number": "CB-RS-2804", "mcp_commit": "9a96ea6e5913736f92b88345bf51caeaaa8e719f", "mcp_package": "@modelcontextprotocol/server-filesystem@2026.7.10", "practice_area": "restructuring", "reference_tool_calls": 87, "required_evidence_reads": 64, "supported_actions": 9, "synthetic": true, "venue": "District of New Jersey Bankruptcy Court", "version": "3.1.0"}, "prompt": "The client wants a decision, not another document inventory. Which Drummond claims and receivable reserves must change before the next cash-collateral report? Healthcare staffing, tax, and landlord claims conflict with schedules while cash-collateral reports omit a disputed receivable reserve. The team needs the call by 2026-09-15. Put the supported calls into the matter register and leave me a short note I can use with the partner.", "rubric": {"criteria": [{"category": "investigation", "description": "Inventory the production and use targeted searches to locate records across native formats.", "id": "investigation.discover_production"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Complete every task-specific identity, authority, operations, and approval read before the first state transition.", "id": "investigation.read_before_write"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Inspect designated source metadata before relying on those records.", "id": "investigation.custody_before_write"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "Select the supported option 'drummond-care:scoped-evidence' after applying the four-part test.", "id": "decision.selected_option"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "Identify both rejected approaches and explain why a one-source shortcut and a blanket hold are wrong.", "id": "decision.alternatives"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-044-01 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/001_petition_schedules_source_export.md rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-044-01.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_claims_register/013_claims_register_source_export.json for DIP budget variance.", "id": "investigation.CBP-044-01.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/025_contracts_leases_source_export.md to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-044-01.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_cash_management/037_cash_management_source_export.json.", "id": "investigation.CBP-044-01.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-044-01 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-044-01.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-044-01 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-044-01.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-044-02 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/002_petition_schedules_source_export.txt rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-044-02.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_claims_register/014_claims_register_source_export.xml for scheduled-claim mismatch.", "id": "investigation.CBP-044-02.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/026_contracts_leases_source_export.txt to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-044-02.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_cash_management/038_cash_management_source_export.xml.", "id": "investigation.CBP-044-02.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-044-02 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-044-02.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-044-02 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-044-02.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-044-03 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/003_petition_schedules_source_export.eml rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-044-03.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_claims_register/015_claims_register_source_export.html for lease rejection deadline.", "id": "investigation.CBP-044-03.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/027_contracts_leases_source_export.eml to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-044-03.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_cash_management/039_cash_management_source_export.html.", "id": "investigation.CBP-044-03.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-044-03 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-044-03.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-044-03 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-044-03.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-044-04 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/004_petition_schedules_source_export.csv rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-044-04.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_claims_register/016_claims_register_source_export.pdf for tax priority period.", "id": "investigation.CBP-044-04.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/028_contracts_leases_source_export.csv to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-044-04.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_cash_management/040_cash_management_source_export.pdf.", "id": "investigation.CBP-044-04.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-044-04 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective.", "id": "decision.CBP-044-04.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-044-04 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-044-04.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-044-05 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/005_petition_schedules_source_export.json rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-044-05.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/017_proofs_of_claim_source_export.md for reserve calculation error.", "id": "investigation.CBP-044-05.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/029_contracts_leases_source_export.json to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-044-05.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_financing/041_financing_source_export.md.", "id": "investigation.CBP-044-05.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-044-05 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-044-05.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-044-05 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-044-05.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-044-06 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/006_petition_schedules_source_export.xml rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-044-06.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/018_proofs_of_claim_source_export.txt for executory-contract cure dispute.", "id": "investigation.CBP-044-06.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/030_contracts_leases_source_export.xml to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-044-06.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_financing/042_financing_source_export.txt.", "id": "investigation.CBP-044-06.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-044-06 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-044-06.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-044-06 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-044-06.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-044-07 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/007_petition_schedules_source_export.html rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-044-07.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/019_proofs_of_claim_source_export.eml for guaranty overlap.", "id": "investigation.CBP-044-07.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/031_contracts_leases_source_export.html to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-044-07.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_financing/043_financing_source_export.eml.", "id": "investigation.CBP-044-07.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-044-07 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-044-07.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-044-07 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-044-07.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-044-08 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/008_petition_schedules_source_export.pdf rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-044-08.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/020_proofs_of_claim_source_export.csv for notice-address defect.", "id": "investigation.CBP-044-08.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/032_contracts_leases_source_export.pdf to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-044-08.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_financing/044_financing_source_export.csv.", "id": "investigation.CBP-044-08.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-044-08 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-044-08.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-044-08 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-044-08.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-044-09 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_claims_register/009_claims_register_source_export.md rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-044-09.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/021_proofs_of_claim_source_export.json for priority classification error.", "id": "investigation.CBP-044-09.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_cash_management/033_cash_management_source_export.md to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-044-09.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_financing/045_financing_source_export.json.", "id": "investigation.CBP-044-09.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-044-09 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is the operational record relies on a superseded control revision.", "id": "decision.CBP-044-09.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-044-09 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-044-09.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-044-10 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_claims_register/010_claims_register_source_export.txt rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-044-10.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/022_proofs_of_claim_source_export.xml for setoff assertion.", "id": "investigation.CBP-044-10.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_cash_management/034_cash_management_source_export.txt to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-044-10.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_financing/046_financing_source_export.xml.", "id": "investigation.CBP-044-10.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-044-10 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-044-10.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-044-10 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-044-10.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-044-11 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_claims_register/011_claims_register_source_export.eml rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-044-11.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/023_proofs_of_claim_source_export.html for ballot amount discrepancy.", "id": "investigation.CBP-044-11.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_cash_management/035_cash_management_source_export.eml to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-044-11.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_financing/047_financing_source_export.html.", "id": "investigation.CBP-044-11.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-044-11 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-044-11.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-044-11 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-044-11.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-044-12 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_claims_register/012_claims_register_source_export.csv rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-044-12.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/024_proofs_of_claim_source_export.pdf for secured-status defect.", "id": "investigation.CBP-044-12.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_cash_management/036_cash_management_source_export.csv to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-044-12.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_financing/048_financing_source_export.pdf.", "id": "investigation.CBP-044-12.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-044-12 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective.", "id": "decision.CBP-044-12.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-044-12 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-044-12.register"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Write the exact selected option, supported action population, evidence-hold population, facts, owners, deadlines, and citations.", "id": "state.exact_decision"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create one exact register row per portfolio key with no extra, missing, or modified row.", "id": "state.exact_register"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Leave only the three approved deliverables and perform no extra state-changing write.", "id": "state.write_scope_containment"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Read back decision.json, matter-register.json, and advice.md after their final writes.", "id": "state.postwrite_readback"}, {"category": "answer", "description": "Explain the selected recommendation, supported actions, holds, alternatives, and limitations with exact source anchors.", "id": "answer.decision_note"}], "decision_options": [{"approach": "Use a plausible summary or one source without completing the controlling joins.", "id": "drummond-care:shortcut", "label": "Roll every disputed amount into one conservative reserve."}, {"approach": "Treat supported actions and genuinely ambiguous records as if they were equally unresolved.", "id": "drummond-care:blanket-hold", "label": "Freeze the entire matter population"}, {"approach": "Apply the exact identity, current-state, authority, and revision test. Create obligation-level claim and budget rows with period-specific holds.", "id": "drummond-care:scoped-evidence", "label": "Correct supported classifications and the exact receivable reserve."}], "evaluation_narrative": {"authority": "Filed claims, priority periods, and court-approved reporting definitions control.", "observation": "Join schedules, proofs of claim, staffing periods, tax priority, landlord records, and receivables.", "question": "Which Drummond claims and receivable reserves must change before the next cash-collateral report?", "register_action": "Create obligation-level claim and budget rows with period-specific holds."}, "gates": ["all_required_evidence_precedes_first_write", "decision_criteria_complete", "register_state_exact", "write_scope_contained", "all_outputs_verified_by_readback"], "metadata_checks": 11, "metric": "weighted_criteria_score", "minimum_tool_calls": 87, "required_deliverables": ["decision.json", "matter-register.json", "advice.md"], "required_document_reads": 64, "type": "deterministic", "weights": {"advice": 0.15, "decision": 0.35, "investigation": 0.25, "state": 0.25}}, "task_id": "cb100-044-drummond-care", "task_name": "Drummond Care restructuring schedule check", "world_id": "counselbench-filesystem-mcp-v3"}
+{"context_files": ["task_files/cb100-045-equinox-solar/01_petition_schedules/001_petition_schedules_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-045-equinox-solar/01_petition_schedules/002_petition_schedules_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-045-equinox-solar/01_petition_schedules/003_petition_schedules_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-045-equinox-solar/01_petition_schedules/004_petition_schedules_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-045-equinox-solar/01_petition_schedules/005_petition_schedules_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-045-equinox-solar/01_petition_schedules/006_petition_schedules_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-045-equinox-solar/01_petition_schedules/007_petition_schedules_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-045-equinox-solar/01_petition_schedules/008_petition_schedules_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-045-equinox-solar/02_claims_register/009_claims_register_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-045-equinox-solar/02_claims_register/010_claims_register_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-045-equinox-solar/02_claims_register/011_claims_register_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-045-equinox-solar/02_claims_register/012_claims_register_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-045-equinox-solar/02_claims_register/013_claims_register_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-045-equinox-solar/02_claims_register/014_claims_register_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-045-equinox-solar/02_claims_register/015_claims_register_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-045-equinox-solar/02_claims_register/016_claims_register_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-045-equinox-solar/03_proofs_of_claim/017_proofs_of_claim_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-045-equinox-solar/03_proofs_of_claim/018_proofs_of_claim_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-045-equinox-solar/03_proofs_of_claim/019_proofs_of_claim_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-045-equinox-solar/03_proofs_of_claim/020_proofs_of_claim_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-045-equinox-solar/03_proofs_of_claim/021_proofs_of_claim_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-045-equinox-solar/03_proofs_of_claim/022_proofs_of_claim_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-045-equinox-solar/03_proofs_of_claim/023_proofs_of_claim_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-045-equinox-solar/03_proofs_of_claim/024_proofs_of_claim_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-045-equinox-solar/04_contracts_leases/025_contracts_leases_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-045-equinox-solar/04_contracts_leases/026_contracts_leases_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-045-equinox-solar/04_contracts_leases/027_contracts_leases_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-045-equinox-solar/04_contracts_leases/028_contracts_leases_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-045-equinox-solar/04_contracts_leases/029_contracts_leases_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-045-equinox-solar/04_contracts_leases/030_contracts_leases_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-045-equinox-solar/04_contracts_leases/031_contracts_leases_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-045-equinox-solar/04_contracts_leases/032_contracts_leases_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-045-equinox-solar/05_cash_management/033_cash_management_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-045-equinox-solar/05_cash_management/034_cash_management_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-045-equinox-solar/05_cash_management/035_cash_management_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-045-equinox-solar/05_cash_management/036_cash_management_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-045-equinox-solar/05_cash_management/037_cash_management_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-045-equinox-solar/05_cash_management/038_cash_management_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-045-equinox-solar/05_cash_management/039_cash_management_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-045-equinox-solar/05_cash_management/040_cash_management_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-045-equinox-solar/06_financing/041_financing_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-045-equinox-solar/06_financing/042_financing_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-045-equinox-solar/06_financing/043_financing_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-045-equinox-solar/06_financing/044_financing_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-045-equinox-solar/06_financing/045_financing_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-045-equinox-solar/06_financing/046_financing_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-045-equinox-solar/06_financing/047_financing_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-045-equinox-solar/06_financing/048_financing_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-045-equinox-solar/07_critical_vendors/049_critical_vendors_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-045-equinox-solar/07_critical_vendors/050_critical_vendors_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-045-equinox-solar/07_critical_vendors/051_critical_vendors_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-045-equinox-solar/07_critical_vendors/052_critical_vendors_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-045-equinox-solar/07_critical_vendors/053_critical_vendors_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-045-equinox-solar/07_critical_vendors/054_critical_vendors_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-045-equinox-solar/07_critical_vendors/055_critical_vendors_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-045-equinox-solar/07_critical_vendors/056_critical_vendors_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-045-equinox-solar/08_tax/057_tax_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-045-equinox-solar/08_tax/058_tax_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-045-equinox-solar/08_tax/059_tax_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-045-equinox-solar/08_tax/060_tax_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-045-equinox-solar/08_tax/061_tax_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-045-equinox-solar/08_tax/062_tax_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-045-equinox-solar/08_tax/063_tax_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-045-equinox-solar/08_tax/064_tax_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-045-equinox-solar/09_litigation/065_litigation_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-045-equinox-solar/09_litigation/066_litigation_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-045-equinox-solar/09_litigation/067_litigation_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-045-equinox-solar/09_litigation/068_litigation_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-045-equinox-solar/09_litigation/069_litigation_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-045-equinox-solar/09_litigation/070_litigation_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-045-equinox-solar/09_litigation/071_litigation_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-045-equinox-solar/09_litigation/072_litigation_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-045-equinox-solar/10_plan_disclosure/073_plan_disclosure_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-045-equinox-solar/10_plan_disclosure/074_plan_disclosure_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-045-equinox-solar/10_plan_disclosure/075_plan_disclosure_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-045-equinox-solar/10_plan_disclosure/076_plan_disclosure_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-045-equinox-solar/10_plan_disclosure/077_plan_disclosure_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-045-equinox-solar/10_plan_disclosure/078_plan_disclosure_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-045-equinox-solar/10_plan_disclosure/079_plan_disclosure_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-045-equinox-solar/10_plan_disclosure/080_plan_disclosure_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-045-equinox-solar/11_notices_ballots/081_notices_ballots_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-045-equinox-solar/11_notices_ballots/082_notices_ballots_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-045-equinox-solar/11_notices_ballots/083_notices_ballots_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-045-equinox-solar/11_notices_ballots/084_notices_ballots_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-045-equinox-solar/11_notices_ballots/085_notices_ballots_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-045-equinox-solar/11_notices_ballots/086_notices_ballots_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-045-equinox-solar/11_notices_ballots/087_notices_ballots_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-045-equinox-solar/11_notices_ballots/088_notices_ballots_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-045-equinox-solar/12_reconciliations/089_reconciliations_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-045-equinox-solar/12_reconciliations/090_reconciliations_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-045-equinox-solar/12_reconciliations/091_reconciliations_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-045-equinox-solar/12_reconciliations/092_reconciliations_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-045-equinox-solar/12_reconciliations/093_reconciliations_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-045-equinox-solar/12_reconciliations/094_reconciliations_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-045-equinox-solar/12_reconciliations/095_reconciliations_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-045-equinox-solar/12_reconciliations/096_reconciliations_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-045-equinox-solar/12_reconciliations/097_equinox_solar_impact_population.xlsx"], "gold_output": {"advice_markdown": "# Decision note — Equinox Solar project claim reconciliation\n\n## Recommendation\n\nObject, reserve, or allow each supported component separately. The reconciled record supports 5 scoped actions and leaves 7 items on evidence hold.\n\nSelected option: `equinox-solar:scoped-evidence`.\n\n## Why this is the supported option\n\nReconcile project completion, lien perfection, claim periods, guaranties, and payments by project entity. Lien and priority rules plus operative guaranties determine treatment at obligation level.\n\n## Supported actions\n\n### CBP-045-02 — duplicate proof of claim (medium)\n\nthe operative cap is $3,562,000.00 under CB-RS-2805-R517; the matched ledger population totals $3,701,717.00 under CB-RS-2805-E336. Identity resolves to ENT-045-1001, revision REV-2025.2 is current, and Maya Ellison is active with capacity 6.\n\nAction: Create project-claim rows and quarantine cross-entity guaranty assumptions. Owner: Maya Ellison; due 2026-09-16.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/002_petition_schedules_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/02_claims_register/014_claims_register_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/026_contracts_leases_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/05_cash_management/038_cash_management_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/07_critical_vendors/050_critical_vendors_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/08_tax/062_tax_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/097_equinox_solar_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-045-04 — DIP budget variance (low)\n\nan open exception blocks completion under CB-RS-2805-R467; the current status is open and unresolved under CB-RS-2805-E333. Identity resolves to ENT-045-1003, revision REV-2025.4 is current, and Willa Novak is active with capacity 6.\n\nAction: Create project-claim rows and quarantine cross-entity guaranty assumptions. Owner: Willa Novak; due 2026-09-14.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/004_petition_schedules_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/02_claims_register/016_claims_register_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/028_contracts_leases_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/05_cash_management/040_cash_management_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/11_notices_ballots/088_notices_ballots_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/07_critical_vendors/052_critical_vendors_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/097_equinox_solar_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-045-05 — scheduled-claim mismatch (high)\n\ncompletion is required by 2026-02-03 under CB-RS-2805-R193; the current event record shows completion on 2026-03-11 under CB-RS-2805-E158. Identity resolves to ENT-045-1004, revision REV-2025.5 is current, and Owen Delgado is active with capacity 3.\n\nAction: Create project-claim rows and quarantine cross-entity guaranty assumptions. Owner: Owen Delgado; due 2026-09-13.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/005_petition_schedules_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/017_proofs_of_claim_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/029_contracts_leases_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/06_financing/041_financing_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/097_equinox_solar_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-045-07 — tax priority period (critical)\n\napproval must come from Willa Novak under CB-RS-2805-R885; the effective approval record names Caleb Hassan under CB-RS-2805-E569. Identity resolves to ENT-045-1006, revision REV-2025.7 is current, and Isaac Romero is active with capacity 6.\n\nAction: Create project-claim rows and quarantine cross-entity guaranty assumptions. Owner: Isaac Romero; due 2026-09-11.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/007_petition_schedules_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/019_proofs_of_claim_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/031_contracts_leases_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/06_financing/043_financing_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/10_plan_disclosure/079_plan_disclosure_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/091_reconciliations_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/097_equinox_solar_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-045-09 — executory-contract cure dispute (medium)\n\nthe permission is limited to District of Arizona Bankruptcy Court under CB-RS-2805-R247; the matched activity occurred in Arizona under CB-RS-2805-E902. Identity resolves to ENT-045-1008, revision REV-2025.2 is current, and Rafael Okafor is active with capacity 3.\n\nAction: Create project-claim rows and quarantine cross-entity guaranty assumptions. Owner: Rafael Okafor; due 2026-09-09.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/02_claims_register/009_claims_register_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/021_proofs_of_claim_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/05_cash_management/033_cash_management_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/06_financing/045_financing_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/097_equinox_solar_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n## Evidence holds\n\n- **CBP-045-01 — cash-collateral reporting gap**: two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key. Next evidence: an approved immutable entity crosswalk. Sources: `/workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/001_petition_schedules_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/02_claims_register/013_claims_register_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/025_contracts_leases_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/05_cash_management/037_cash_management_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/097_equinox_solar_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-045-03 — postpetition invoice**: the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective. Next evidence: effective approval and an active owner with remaining capacity. Sources: `/workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/003_petition_schedules_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/02_claims_register/015_claims_register_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/027_contracts_leases_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/05_cash_management/039_cash_management_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/07_critical_vendors/051_critical_vendors_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/097_equinox_solar_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-045-06 — lease rejection deadline**: the current observation does not meet the operative trigger. Next evidence: a current observation that satisfies the operative trigger. Sources: `/workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/006_petition_schedules_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/018_proofs_of_claim_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/030_contracts_leases_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/06_financing/042_financing_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/097_equinox_solar_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-045-08 — reserve calculation error**: the operational record relies on a superseded control revision. Next evidence: an operational record using the current effective revision. Sources: `/workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/008_petition_schedules_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/020_proofs_of_claim_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/032_contracts_leases_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/06_financing/044_financing_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/10_plan_disclosure/080_plan_disclosure_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/097_equinox_solar_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-045-10 — guaranty overlap**: the current observation does not meet the operative trigger. Next evidence: a current observation that satisfies the operative trigger. Sources: `/workspace/documents/02_claims_register/010_claims_register_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/022_proofs_of_claim_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/05_cash_management/034_cash_management_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/06_financing/046_financing_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/09_litigation/070_litigation_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/094_reconciliations_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/097_equinox_solar_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-045-11 — notice-address defect**: the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective. Next evidence: effective approval and an active owner with remaining capacity. Sources: `/workspace/documents/02_claims_register/011_claims_register_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/023_proofs_of_claim_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/05_cash_management/035_cash_management_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/06_financing/047_financing_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/095_reconciliations_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/11_notices_ballots/083_notices_ballots_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/097_equinox_solar_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-045-12 — priority classification error**: the operational record relies on a superseded control revision. Next evidence: an operational record using the current effective revision. Sources: `/workspace/documents/02_claims_register/012_claims_register_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/024_proofs_of_claim_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/05_cash_management/036_cash_management_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/06_financing/048_financing_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/08_tax/060_tax_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/097_equinox_solar_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n## Alternatives considered\n\n- `equinox-solar:blanket-hold` — Freeze the entire matter population: Treat supported actions and genuinely ambiguous records as if they were equally unresolved.\n- `equinox-solar:shortcut` — Treat every construction claimant as fully secured across all projects.: Use a plausible summary or one source without completing the controlling joins.\n\n## Assumptions and limits\n\nThis decision is limited to cb100-045-equinox-solar, the supplied synthetic records, and the matter state as of 2026-09-18. Similar names, stale revisions, and pending authority are not treated as proof.\n", "decision": {"actions": [{"determination": "the operative cap is $3,562,000.00 under CB-RS-2805-R517; the matched ledger population totals $3,701,717.00 under CB-RS-2805-E336. Identity resolves to ENT-045-1001, revision REV-2025.2 is current, and Maya Ellison is active with capacity 6.", "due_date": "2026-09-16", "id": "ACT-CBP-045-02", "identity_id": "ENT-045-1001", "issue": "duplicate proof of claim", "owner": "Maya Ellison", "portfolio_key": "CBP-045-02", "recommended_action": "Create project-claim rows and quarantine cross-entity guaranty assumptions. Owner: Maya Ellison; due 2026-09-16.", "severity": "medium", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/002_petition_schedules_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/02_claims_register/014_claims_register_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/026_contracts_leases_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/05_cash_management/038_cash_management_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/07_critical_vendors/050_critical_vendors_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/08_tax/062_tax_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/097_equinox_solar_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "an open exception blocks completion under CB-RS-2805-R467; the current status is open and unresolved under CB-RS-2805-E333. Identity resolves to ENT-045-1003, revision REV-2025.4 is current, and Willa Novak is active with capacity 6.", "due_date": "2026-09-14", "id": "ACT-CBP-045-04", "identity_id": "ENT-045-1003", "issue": "DIP budget variance", "owner": "Willa Novak", "portfolio_key": "CBP-045-04", "recommended_action": "Create project-claim rows and quarantine cross-entity guaranty assumptions. Owner: Willa Novak; due 2026-09-14.", "severity": "low", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/004_petition_schedules_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/02_claims_register/016_claims_register_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/028_contracts_leases_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/05_cash_management/040_cash_management_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/11_notices_ballots/088_notices_ballots_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/07_critical_vendors/052_critical_vendors_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/097_equinox_solar_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "completion is required by 2026-02-03 under CB-RS-2805-R193; the current event record shows completion on 2026-03-11 under CB-RS-2805-E158. Identity resolves to ENT-045-1004, revision REV-2025.5 is current, and Owen Delgado is active with capacity 3.", "due_date": "2026-09-13", "id": "ACT-CBP-045-05", "identity_id": "ENT-045-1004", "issue": "scheduled-claim mismatch", "owner": "Owen Delgado", "portfolio_key": "CBP-045-05", "recommended_action": "Create project-claim rows and quarantine cross-entity guaranty assumptions. Owner: Owen Delgado; due 2026-09-13.", "severity": "high", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/005_petition_schedules_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/017_proofs_of_claim_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/029_contracts_leases_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/06_financing/041_financing_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/097_equinox_solar_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "approval must come from Willa Novak under CB-RS-2805-R885; the effective approval record names Caleb Hassan under CB-RS-2805-E569. Identity resolves to ENT-045-1006, revision REV-2025.7 is current, and Isaac Romero is active with capacity 6.", "due_date": "2026-09-11", "id": "ACT-CBP-045-07", "identity_id": "ENT-045-1006", "issue": "tax priority period", "owner": "Isaac Romero", "portfolio_key": "CBP-045-07", "recommended_action": "Create project-claim rows and quarantine cross-entity guaranty assumptions. Owner: Isaac Romero; due 2026-09-11.", "severity": "critical", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/007_petition_schedules_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/019_proofs_of_claim_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/031_contracts_leases_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/06_financing/043_financing_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/10_plan_disclosure/079_plan_disclosure_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/091_reconciliations_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/097_equinox_solar_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "the permission is limited to District of Arizona Bankruptcy Court under CB-RS-2805-R247; the matched activity occurred in Arizona under CB-RS-2805-E902. Identity resolves to ENT-045-1008, revision REV-2025.2 is current, and Rafael Okafor is active with capacity 3.", "due_date": "2026-09-09", "id": "ACT-CBP-045-09", "identity_id": "ENT-045-1008", "issue": "executory-contract cure dispute", "owner": "Rafael Okafor", "portfolio_key": "CBP-045-09", "recommended_action": "Create project-claim rows and quarantine cross-entity guaranty assumptions. Owner: Rafael Okafor; due 2026-09-09.", "severity": "medium", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_claims_register/009_claims_register_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/021_proofs_of_claim_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/05_cash_management/033_cash_management_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/06_financing/045_financing_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/097_equinox_solar_impact_population.xlsx"]}], "as_of": "2026-09-18", "decision": {"alternatives_considered": ["equinox-solar:blanket-hold", "equinox-solar:shortcut"], "question": "What is the defensible secured, priority, and guaranty treatment for the Equinox project claims?", "rationale": "The four-part causal test supports 5 scoped actions and leaves 7 records on evidence hold. Lien and priority rules plus operative guaranties determine treatment at obligation level.", "recommendation": "Object, reserve, or allow each supported component separately.", "selected_option_id": "equinox-solar:scoped-evidence"}, "holds": [{"id": "HOLD-CBP-045-01", "issue": "cash-collateral reporting gap", "portfolio_key": "CBP-045-01", "reason": "two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key", "required_next_evidence": "an approved immutable entity crosswalk", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/001_petition_schedules_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/02_claims_register/013_claims_register_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/025_contracts_leases_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/05_cash_management/037_cash_management_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/097_equinox_solar_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-045-03", "issue": "postpetition invoice", "portfolio_key": "CBP-045-03", "reason": "the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective", "required_next_evidence": "effective approval and an active owner with remaining capacity", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/003_petition_schedules_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/02_claims_register/015_claims_register_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/027_contracts_leases_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/05_cash_management/039_cash_management_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/07_critical_vendors/051_critical_vendors_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/097_equinox_solar_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-045-06", "issue": "lease rejection deadline", "portfolio_key": "CBP-045-06", "reason": "the current observation does not meet the operative trigger", "required_next_evidence": "a current observation that satisfies the operative trigger", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/006_petition_schedules_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/018_proofs_of_claim_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/030_contracts_leases_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/06_financing/042_financing_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/097_equinox_solar_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-045-08", "issue": "reserve calculation error", "portfolio_key": "CBP-045-08", "reason": "the operational record relies on a superseded control revision", "required_next_evidence": "an operational record using the current effective revision", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/008_petition_schedules_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/020_proofs_of_claim_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/032_contracts_leases_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/06_financing/044_financing_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/10_plan_disclosure/080_plan_disclosure_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/097_equinox_solar_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-045-10", "issue": "guaranty overlap", "portfolio_key": "CBP-045-10", "reason": "the current observation does not meet the operative trigger", "required_next_evidence": "a current observation that satisfies the operative trigger", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_claims_register/010_claims_register_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/022_proofs_of_claim_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/05_cash_management/034_cash_management_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/06_financing/046_financing_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/09_litigation/070_litigation_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/094_reconciliations_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/097_equinox_solar_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-045-11", "issue": "notice-address defect", "portfolio_key": "CBP-045-11", "reason": "the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective", "required_next_evidence": "effective approval and an active owner with remaining capacity", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_claims_register/011_claims_register_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/023_proofs_of_claim_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/05_cash_management/035_cash_management_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/06_financing/047_financing_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/095_reconciliations_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/11_notices_ballots/083_notices_ballots_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/097_equinox_solar_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-045-12", "issue": "priority classification error", "portfolio_key": "CBP-045-12", "reason": "the operational record relies on a superseded control revision", "required_next_evidence": "an operational record using the current effective revision", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_claims_register/012_claims_register_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/024_proofs_of_claim_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/05_cash_management/036_cash_management_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/06_financing/048_financing_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/08_tax/060_tax_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/097_equinox_solar_impact_population.xlsx"]}], "matter_number": "CB-RS-2805", "prepared_for": "Equinox Solar Development", "schema_version": "counselbench.decision.v3", "task_id": "cb100-045-equinox-solar"}, "matter_register": {"matter_number": "CB-RS-2805", "rows": [{"decision_option_id": "equinox-solar:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key", "issue": "cash-collateral reporting gap", "matter_number": "CB-RS-2805", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-045-01", "row_id": "REG-CBP-045-01", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/001_petition_schedules_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/02_claims_register/013_claims_register_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/025_contracts_leases_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/05_cash_management/037_cash_management_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/097_equinox_solar_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "equinox-solar:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-16", "issue": "duplicate proof of claim", "matter_number": "CB-RS-2805", "owner": "Maya Ellison", "portfolio_key": "CBP-045-02", "row_id": "REG-CBP-045-02", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/002_petition_schedules_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/02_claims_register/014_claims_register_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/026_contracts_leases_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/05_cash_management/038_cash_management_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/07_critical_vendors/050_critical_vendors_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/08_tax/062_tax_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/097_equinox_solar_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "equinox-solar:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective", "issue": "postpetition invoice", "matter_number": "CB-RS-2805", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-045-03", "row_id": "REG-CBP-045-03", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/003_petition_schedules_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/02_claims_register/015_claims_register_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/027_contracts_leases_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/05_cash_management/039_cash_management_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/07_critical_vendors/051_critical_vendors_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/097_equinox_solar_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "equinox-solar:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-14", "issue": "DIP budget variance", "matter_number": "CB-RS-2805", "owner": "Willa Novak", "portfolio_key": "CBP-045-04", "row_id": "REG-CBP-045-04", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/004_petition_schedules_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/02_claims_register/016_claims_register_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/028_contracts_leases_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/05_cash_management/040_cash_management_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/11_notices_ballots/088_notices_ballots_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/07_critical_vendors/052_critical_vendors_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/097_equinox_solar_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "equinox-solar:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-13", "issue": "scheduled-claim mismatch", "matter_number": "CB-RS-2805", "owner": "Owen Delgado", "portfolio_key": "CBP-045-05", "row_id": "REG-CBP-045-05", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/005_petition_schedules_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/017_proofs_of_claim_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/029_contracts_leases_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/06_financing/041_financing_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/097_equinox_solar_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "equinox-solar:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "the current observation does not meet the operative trigger", "issue": "lease rejection deadline", "matter_number": "CB-RS-2805", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-045-06", "row_id": "REG-CBP-045-06", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/006_petition_schedules_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/018_proofs_of_claim_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/030_contracts_leases_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/06_financing/042_financing_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/097_equinox_solar_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "equinox-solar:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-11", "issue": "tax priority period", "matter_number": "CB-RS-2805", "owner": "Isaac Romero", "portfolio_key": "CBP-045-07", "row_id": "REG-CBP-045-07", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/007_petition_schedules_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/019_proofs_of_claim_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/031_contracts_leases_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/06_financing/043_financing_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/10_plan_disclosure/079_plan_disclosure_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/091_reconciliations_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/097_equinox_solar_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "equinox-solar:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "the operational record relies on a superseded control revision", "issue": "reserve calculation error", "matter_number": "CB-RS-2805", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-045-08", "row_id": "REG-CBP-045-08", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/008_petition_schedules_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/020_proofs_of_claim_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/032_contracts_leases_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/06_financing/044_financing_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/10_plan_disclosure/080_plan_disclosure_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/097_equinox_solar_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "equinox-solar:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-09", "issue": "executory-contract cure dispute", "matter_number": "CB-RS-2805", "owner": "Rafael Okafor", "portfolio_key": "CBP-045-09", "row_id": "REG-CBP-045-09", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_claims_register/009_claims_register_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/021_proofs_of_claim_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/05_cash_management/033_cash_management_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/06_financing/045_financing_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/097_equinox_solar_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "equinox-solar:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "the current observation does not meet the operative trigger", "issue": "guaranty overlap", "matter_number": "CB-RS-2805", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-045-10", "row_id": "REG-CBP-045-10", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_claims_register/010_claims_register_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/022_proofs_of_claim_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/05_cash_management/034_cash_management_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/06_financing/046_financing_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/09_litigation/070_litigation_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/094_reconciliations_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/097_equinox_solar_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "equinox-solar:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective", "issue": "notice-address defect", "matter_number": "CB-RS-2805", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-045-11", "row_id": "REG-CBP-045-11", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_claims_register/011_claims_register_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/023_proofs_of_claim_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/05_cash_management/035_cash_management_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/06_financing/047_financing_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/095_reconciliations_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/11_notices_ballots/083_notices_ballots_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/097_equinox_solar_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "equinox-solar:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "the operational record relies on a superseded control revision", "issue": "priority classification error", "matter_number": "CB-RS-2805", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-045-12", "row_id": "REG-CBP-045-12", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_claims_register/012_claims_register_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/024_proofs_of_claim_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/05_cash_management/036_cash_management_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/06_financing/048_financing_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/08_tax/060_tax_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/097_equinox_solar_impact_population.xlsx"]}], "schema_version": "counselbench.matter-register.v3", "task_id": "cb100-045-equinox-solar"}}, "metadata": {"benchmark": "CounselBench-100", "code_license": "Apache-2.0", "data_license": "CC-BY-4.0", "deadline": "2026-09-18", "document_count": 97, "evidence_holds": 7, "jurisdiction": "Arizona", "matter_number": "CB-RS-2805", "mcp_commit": "9a96ea6e5913736f92b88345bf51caeaaa8e719f", "mcp_package": "@modelcontextprotocol/server-filesystem@2026.7.10", "practice_area": "restructuring", "reference_tool_calls": 86, "required_evidence_reads": 63, "supported_actions": 5, "synthetic": true, "venue": "District of Arizona Bankruptcy Court", "version": "3.1.0"}, "prompt": "We inherited inconsistent versions of this matter and need to settle the operating position. What is the defensible secured, priority, and guaranty treatment for the Equinox project claims? Construction claims assert secured and priority treatment across partially completed projects with overlapping guaranties. The team needs the call by 2026-09-18. I need the recommendation and the real blockers recorded before the team acts.", "rubric": {"criteria": [{"category": "investigation", "description": "Inventory the production and use targeted searches to locate records across native formats.", "id": "investigation.discover_production"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Complete every task-specific identity, authority, operations, and approval read before the first state transition.", "id": "investigation.read_before_write"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Inspect designated source metadata before relying on those records.", "id": "investigation.custody_before_write"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "Select the supported option 'equinox-solar:scoped-evidence' after applying the four-part test.", "id": "decision.selected_option"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "Identify both rejected approaches and explain why a one-source shortcut and a blanket hold are wrong.", "id": "decision.alternatives"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-045-01 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/001_petition_schedules_source_export.md rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-045-01.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_claims_register/013_claims_register_source_export.json for cash-collateral reporting gap.", "id": "investigation.CBP-045-01.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/025_contracts_leases_source_export.md to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-045-01.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_cash_management/037_cash_management_source_export.json.", "id": "investigation.CBP-045-01.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-045-01 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key.", "id": "decision.CBP-045-01.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-045-01 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-045-01.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-045-02 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/002_petition_schedules_source_export.txt rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-045-02.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_claims_register/014_claims_register_source_export.xml for duplicate proof of claim.", "id": "investigation.CBP-045-02.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/026_contracts_leases_source_export.txt to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-045-02.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_cash_management/038_cash_management_source_export.xml.", "id": "investigation.CBP-045-02.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-045-02 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-045-02.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-045-02 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-045-02.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-045-03 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/003_petition_schedules_source_export.eml rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-045-03.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_claims_register/015_claims_register_source_export.html for postpetition invoice.", "id": "investigation.CBP-045-03.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/027_contracts_leases_source_export.eml to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-045-03.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_cash_management/039_cash_management_source_export.html.", "id": "investigation.CBP-045-03.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-045-03 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective.", "id": "decision.CBP-045-03.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-045-03 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-045-03.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-045-04 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/004_petition_schedules_source_export.csv rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-045-04.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_claims_register/016_claims_register_source_export.pdf for DIP budget variance.", "id": "investigation.CBP-045-04.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/028_contracts_leases_source_export.csv to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-045-04.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_cash_management/040_cash_management_source_export.pdf.", "id": "investigation.CBP-045-04.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-045-04 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-045-04.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-045-04 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-045-04.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-045-05 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/005_petition_schedules_source_export.json rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-045-05.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/017_proofs_of_claim_source_export.md for scheduled-claim mismatch.", "id": "investigation.CBP-045-05.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/029_contracts_leases_source_export.json to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-045-05.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_financing/041_financing_source_export.md.", "id": "investigation.CBP-045-05.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-045-05 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-045-05.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-045-05 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-045-05.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-045-06 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/006_petition_schedules_source_export.xml rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-045-06.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/018_proofs_of_claim_source_export.txt for lease rejection deadline.", "id": "investigation.CBP-045-06.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/030_contracts_leases_source_export.xml to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-045-06.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_financing/042_financing_source_export.txt.", "id": "investigation.CBP-045-06.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-045-06 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is the current observation does not meet the operative trigger.", "id": "decision.CBP-045-06.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-045-06 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-045-06.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-045-07 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/007_petition_schedules_source_export.html rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-045-07.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/019_proofs_of_claim_source_export.eml for tax priority period.", "id": "investigation.CBP-045-07.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/031_contracts_leases_source_export.html to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-045-07.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_financing/043_financing_source_export.eml.", "id": "investigation.CBP-045-07.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-045-07 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-045-07.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-045-07 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-045-07.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-045-08 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/008_petition_schedules_source_export.pdf rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-045-08.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/020_proofs_of_claim_source_export.csv for reserve calculation error.", "id": "investigation.CBP-045-08.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/032_contracts_leases_source_export.pdf to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-045-08.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_financing/044_financing_source_export.csv.", "id": "investigation.CBP-045-08.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-045-08 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is the operational record relies on a superseded control revision.", "id": "decision.CBP-045-08.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-045-08 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-045-08.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-045-09 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_claims_register/009_claims_register_source_export.md rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-045-09.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/021_proofs_of_claim_source_export.json for executory-contract cure dispute.", "id": "investigation.CBP-045-09.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_cash_management/033_cash_management_source_export.md to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-045-09.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_financing/045_financing_source_export.json.", "id": "investigation.CBP-045-09.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-045-09 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-045-09.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-045-09 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-045-09.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-045-10 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_claims_register/010_claims_register_source_export.txt rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-045-10.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/022_proofs_of_claim_source_export.xml for guaranty overlap.", "id": "investigation.CBP-045-10.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_cash_management/034_cash_management_source_export.txt to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-045-10.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_financing/046_financing_source_export.xml.", "id": "investigation.CBP-045-10.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-045-10 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is the current observation does not meet the operative trigger.", "id": "decision.CBP-045-10.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-045-10 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-045-10.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-045-11 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_claims_register/011_claims_register_source_export.eml rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-045-11.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/023_proofs_of_claim_source_export.html for notice-address defect.", "id": "investigation.CBP-045-11.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_cash_management/035_cash_management_source_export.eml to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-045-11.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_financing/047_financing_source_export.html.", "id": "investigation.CBP-045-11.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-045-11 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective.", "id": "decision.CBP-045-11.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-045-11 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-045-11.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-045-12 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_claims_register/012_claims_register_source_export.csv rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-045-12.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/024_proofs_of_claim_source_export.pdf for priority classification error.", "id": "investigation.CBP-045-12.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_cash_management/036_cash_management_source_export.csv to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-045-12.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_financing/048_financing_source_export.pdf.", "id": "investigation.CBP-045-12.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-045-12 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is the operational record relies on a superseded control revision.", "id": "decision.CBP-045-12.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-045-12 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-045-12.register"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Write the exact selected option, supported action population, evidence-hold population, facts, owners, deadlines, and citations.", "id": "state.exact_decision"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create one exact register row per portfolio key with no extra, missing, or modified row.", "id": "state.exact_register"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Leave only the three approved deliverables and perform no extra state-changing write.", "id": "state.write_scope_containment"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Read back decision.json, matter-register.json, and advice.md after their final writes.", "id": "state.postwrite_readback"}, {"category": "answer", "description": "Explain the selected recommendation, supported actions, holds, alternatives, and limitations with exact source anchors.", "id": "answer.decision_note"}], "decision_options": [{"approach": "Treat supported actions and genuinely ambiguous records as if they were equally unresolved.", "id": "equinox-solar:blanket-hold", "label": "Freeze the entire matter population"}, {"approach": "Apply the exact identity, current-state, authority, and revision test. Create project-claim rows and quarantine cross-entity guaranty assumptions.", "id": "equinox-solar:scoped-evidence", "label": "Object, reserve, or allow each supported component separately."}, {"approach": "Use a plausible summary or one source without completing the controlling joins.", "id": "equinox-solar:shortcut", "label": "Treat every construction claimant as fully secured across all projects."}], "evaluation_narrative": {"authority": "Lien and priority rules plus operative guaranties determine treatment at obligation level.", "observation": "Reconcile project completion, lien perfection, claim periods, guaranties, and payments by project entity.", "question": "What is the defensible secured, priority, and guaranty treatment for the Equinox project claims?", "register_action": "Create project-claim rows and quarantine cross-entity guaranty assumptions."}, "gates": ["all_required_evidence_precedes_first_write", "decision_criteria_complete", "register_state_exact", "write_scope_contained", "all_outputs_verified_by_readback"], "metadata_checks": 6, "metric": "weighted_criteria_score", "minimum_tool_calls": 86, "required_deliverables": ["decision.json", "matter-register.json", "advice.md"], "required_document_reads": 63, "type": "deterministic", "weights": {"advice": 0.15, "decision": 0.35, "investigation": 0.25, "state": 0.25}}, "task_id": "cb100-045-equinox-solar", "task_name": "Equinox Solar project claim reconciliation", "world_id": "counselbench-filesystem-mcp-v3"}
+{"context_files": ["task_files/cb100-046-foundry-foods/01_petition_schedules/001_petition_schedules_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-046-foundry-foods/01_petition_schedules/002_petition_schedules_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-046-foundry-foods/01_petition_schedules/003_petition_schedules_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-046-foundry-foods/01_petition_schedules/004_petition_schedules_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-046-foundry-foods/01_petition_schedules/005_petition_schedules_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-046-foundry-foods/01_petition_schedules/006_petition_schedules_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-046-foundry-foods/01_petition_schedules/007_petition_schedules_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-046-foundry-foods/01_petition_schedules/008_petition_schedules_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-046-foundry-foods/02_claims_register/009_claims_register_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-046-foundry-foods/02_claims_register/010_claims_register_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-046-foundry-foods/02_claims_register/011_claims_register_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-046-foundry-foods/02_claims_register/012_claims_register_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-046-foundry-foods/02_claims_register/013_claims_register_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-046-foundry-foods/02_claims_register/014_claims_register_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-046-foundry-foods/02_claims_register/015_claims_register_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-046-foundry-foods/02_claims_register/016_claims_register_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-046-foundry-foods/03_proofs_of_claim/017_proofs_of_claim_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-046-foundry-foods/03_proofs_of_claim/018_proofs_of_claim_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-046-foundry-foods/03_proofs_of_claim/019_proofs_of_claim_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-046-foundry-foods/03_proofs_of_claim/020_proofs_of_claim_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-046-foundry-foods/03_proofs_of_claim/021_proofs_of_claim_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-046-foundry-foods/03_proofs_of_claim/022_proofs_of_claim_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-046-foundry-foods/03_proofs_of_claim/023_proofs_of_claim_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-046-foundry-foods/03_proofs_of_claim/024_proofs_of_claim_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-046-foundry-foods/04_contracts_leases/025_contracts_leases_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-046-foundry-foods/04_contracts_leases/026_contracts_leases_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-046-foundry-foods/04_contracts_leases/027_contracts_leases_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-046-foundry-foods/04_contracts_leases/028_contracts_leases_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-046-foundry-foods/04_contracts_leases/029_contracts_leases_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-046-foundry-foods/04_contracts_leases/030_contracts_leases_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-046-foundry-foods/04_contracts_leases/031_contracts_leases_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-046-foundry-foods/04_contracts_leases/032_contracts_leases_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-046-foundry-foods/05_cash_management/033_cash_management_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-046-foundry-foods/05_cash_management/034_cash_management_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-046-foundry-foods/05_cash_management/035_cash_management_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-046-foundry-foods/05_cash_management/036_cash_management_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-046-foundry-foods/05_cash_management/037_cash_management_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-046-foundry-foods/05_cash_management/038_cash_management_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-046-foundry-foods/05_cash_management/039_cash_management_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-046-foundry-foods/05_cash_management/040_cash_management_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-046-foundry-foods/06_financing/041_financing_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-046-foundry-foods/06_financing/042_financing_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-046-foundry-foods/06_financing/043_financing_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-046-foundry-foods/06_financing/044_financing_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-046-foundry-foods/06_financing/045_financing_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-046-foundry-foods/06_financing/046_financing_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-046-foundry-foods/06_financing/047_financing_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-046-foundry-foods/06_financing/048_financing_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-046-foundry-foods/07_critical_vendors/049_critical_vendors_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-046-foundry-foods/07_critical_vendors/050_critical_vendors_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-046-foundry-foods/07_critical_vendors/051_critical_vendors_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-046-foundry-foods/07_critical_vendors/052_critical_vendors_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-046-foundry-foods/07_critical_vendors/053_critical_vendors_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-046-foundry-foods/07_critical_vendors/054_critical_vendors_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-046-foundry-foods/07_critical_vendors/055_critical_vendors_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-046-foundry-foods/07_critical_vendors/056_critical_vendors_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-046-foundry-foods/08_tax/057_tax_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-046-foundry-foods/08_tax/058_tax_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-046-foundry-foods/08_tax/059_tax_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-046-foundry-foods/08_tax/060_tax_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-046-foundry-foods/08_tax/061_tax_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-046-foundry-foods/08_tax/062_tax_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-046-foundry-foods/08_tax/063_tax_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-046-foundry-foods/08_tax/064_tax_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-046-foundry-foods/09_litigation/065_litigation_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-046-foundry-foods/09_litigation/066_litigation_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-046-foundry-foods/09_litigation/067_litigation_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-046-foundry-foods/09_litigation/068_litigation_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-046-foundry-foods/09_litigation/069_litigation_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-046-foundry-foods/09_litigation/070_litigation_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-046-foundry-foods/09_litigation/071_litigation_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-046-foundry-foods/09_litigation/072_litigation_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-046-foundry-foods/10_plan_disclosure/073_plan_disclosure_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-046-foundry-foods/10_plan_disclosure/074_plan_disclosure_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-046-foundry-foods/10_plan_disclosure/075_plan_disclosure_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-046-foundry-foods/10_plan_disclosure/076_plan_disclosure_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-046-foundry-foods/10_plan_disclosure/077_plan_disclosure_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-046-foundry-foods/10_plan_disclosure/078_plan_disclosure_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-046-foundry-foods/10_plan_disclosure/079_plan_disclosure_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-046-foundry-foods/10_plan_disclosure/080_plan_disclosure_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-046-foundry-foods/11_notices_ballots/081_notices_ballots_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-046-foundry-foods/11_notices_ballots/082_notices_ballots_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-046-foundry-foods/11_notices_ballots/083_notices_ballots_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-046-foundry-foods/11_notices_ballots/084_notices_ballots_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-046-foundry-foods/11_notices_ballots/085_notices_ballots_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-046-foundry-foods/11_notices_ballots/086_notices_ballots_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-046-foundry-foods/11_notices_ballots/087_notices_ballots_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-046-foundry-foods/11_notices_ballots/088_notices_ballots_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-046-foundry-foods/12_reconciliations/089_reconciliations_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-046-foundry-foods/12_reconciliations/090_reconciliations_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-046-foundry-foods/12_reconciliations/091_reconciliations_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-046-foundry-foods/12_reconciliations/092_reconciliations_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-046-foundry-foods/12_reconciliations/093_reconciliations_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-046-foundry-foods/12_reconciliations/094_reconciliations_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-046-foundry-foods/12_reconciliations/095_reconciliations_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-046-foundry-foods/12_reconciliations/096_reconciliations_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-046-foundry-foods/12_reconciliations/097_foundry_foods_impact_population.xlsx"], "gold_output": {"advice_markdown": "# Decision note — Foundry Foods vendor claim audit\n\n## Recommendation\n\nReduce, reclassify, or reserve supported balances at invoice level. The reconciled record supports 7 scoped actions and leaves 5 items on evidence hold.\n\nSelected option: `foundry-foods:scoped-evidence`.\n\n## Why this is the supported option\n\nMatch invoices, receipt dates, payments, claims, and contract cure entries by vendor and shipment. Petition timing, payment application, and assumption cure rules govern the remaining obligation.\n\n## Supported actions\n\n### CBP-046-02 — secured-status defect (critical)\n\napproval must come from Maya Ellison under CB-RS-2806-R561; the effective approval record names Caleb Hassan under CB-RS-2806-E127. Identity resolves to ENT-046-1001, revision REV-2026.2 is current, and Dominic Alvarez is active with capacity 5.\n\nAction: Create invoice-level claim rows and hold stale cure extracts. Owner: Dominic Alvarez; due 2026-09-20.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/002_petition_schedules_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/02_claims_register/014_claims_register_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/026_contracts_leases_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/05_cash_management/038_cash_management_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/11_notices_ballots/086_notices_ballots_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/07_critical_vendors/050_critical_vendors_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/097_foundry_foods_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-046-04 — cash-collateral reporting gap (low)\n\nthe permission is limited to District of Minnesota Bankruptcy Court under CB-RS-2806-R895; the matched activity occurred in Minnesota under CB-RS-2806-E993. Identity resolves to ENT-046-1003, revision REV-2026.4 is current, and Henry Cho is active with capacity 6.\n\nAction: Create invoice-level claim rows and hold stale cure extracts. Owner: Henry Cho; due 2026-09-18.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/004_petition_schedules_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/02_claims_register/016_claims_register_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/028_contracts_leases_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/05_cash_management/040_cash_management_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/11_notices_ballots/088_notices_ballots_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/097_foundry_foods_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-046-06 — postpetition invoice (low)\n\ndelivery must use notices-foundry_prepared_foods_inc@example.test under CB-RS-2806-R172; the only matched receipt used archive-northland_cold_chain_llc@example.test under CB-RS-2806-E157. Identity resolves to ENT-046-1005, revision REV-2026.6 is current, and Jonas Feld is active with capacity 6.\n\nAction: Create invoice-level claim rows and hold stale cure extracts. Owner: Jonas Feld; due 2026-09-16.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/006_petition_schedules_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/018_proofs_of_claim_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/030_contracts_leases_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/06_financing/042_financing_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/09_litigation/066_litigation_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/10_plan_disclosure/078_plan_disclosure_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/097_foundry_foods_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-046-07 — DIP budget variance (low)\n\nan open exception blocks completion under CB-RS-2806-R280; the current status is open and unresolved under CB-RS-2806-E375. Identity resolves to ENT-046-1006, revision REV-2026.7 is current, and Willa Novak is active with capacity 6.\n\nAction: Create invoice-level claim rows and hold stale cure extracts. Owner: Willa Novak; due 2026-09-15.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/007_petition_schedules_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/019_proofs_of_claim_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/031_contracts_leases_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/06_financing/043_financing_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/097_foundry_foods_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-046-09 — lease rejection deadline (high)\n\nthe controlling threshold is 16% under CB-RS-2806-R531; the independently calculated result is 24% under CB-RS-2806-E654. Identity resolves to ENT-046-1008, revision REV-2026.2 is current, and Priya Raman is active with capacity 3.\n\nAction: Create invoice-level claim rows and hold stale cure extracts. Owner: Priya Raman; due 2026-09-13.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/02_claims_register/009_claims_register_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/021_proofs_of_claim_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/05_cash_management/033_cash_management_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/06_financing/045_financing_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/097_foundry_foods_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-046-10 — tax priority period (critical)\n\napproval must come from Maya Ellison under CB-RS-2806-R190; the effective approval record names Rafael Okafor under CB-RS-2806-E475. Identity resolves to ENT-046-1009, revision REV-2026.3 is current, and Isaac Romero is active with capacity 3.\n\nAction: Create invoice-level claim rows and hold stale cure extracts. Owner: Isaac Romero; due 2026-09-21.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/02_claims_register/010_claims_register_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/022_proofs_of_claim_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/05_cash_management/034_cash_management_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/06_financing/046_financing_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/09_litigation/070_litigation_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/08_tax/058_tax_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/097_foundry_foods_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-046-11 — reserve calculation error (medium)\n\nthe controlled population contains 137 records under CB-RS-2806-R545; the certification covers 115 records under CB-RS-2806-E443. Identity resolves to ENT-046-1010, revision REV-2026.4 is current, and Nadine Flores is active with capacity 6.\n\nAction: Create invoice-level claim rows and hold stale cure extracts. Owner: Nadine Flores; due 2026-09-20.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/02_claims_register/011_claims_register_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/023_proofs_of_claim_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/05_cash_management/035_cash_management_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/06_financing/047_financing_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/09_litigation/071_litigation_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/097_foundry_foods_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n## Evidence holds\n\n- **CBP-046-01 — ballot amount discrepancy**: the current observation does not meet the operative trigger. Next evidence: a current observation that satisfies the operative trigger. Sources: `/workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/001_petition_schedules_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/02_claims_register/013_claims_register_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/025_contracts_leases_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/05_cash_management/037_cash_management_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/10_plan_disclosure/073_plan_disclosure_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/07_critical_vendors/049_critical_vendors_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/097_foundry_foods_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-046-03 — critical-vendor overstatement**: the operational record relies on a superseded control revision. Next evidence: an operational record using the current effective revision. Sources: `/workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/003_petition_schedules_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/02_claims_register/015_claims_register_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/027_contracts_leases_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/05_cash_management/039_cash_management_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/11_notices_ballots/087_notices_ballots_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/08_tax/063_tax_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/097_foundry_foods_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-046-05 — duplicate proof of claim**: the current observation does not meet the operative trigger. Next evidence: a current observation that satisfies the operative trigger. Sources: `/workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/005_petition_schedules_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/017_proofs_of_claim_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/029_contracts_leases_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/06_financing/041_financing_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/097_foundry_foods_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-046-08 — scheduled-claim mismatch**: two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key. Next evidence: an approved immutable entity crosswalk. Sources: `/workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/008_petition_schedules_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/020_proofs_of_claim_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/032_contracts_leases_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/06_financing/044_financing_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/097_foundry_foods_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-046-12 — executory-contract cure dispute**: two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key. Next evidence: an approved immutable entity crosswalk. Sources: `/workspace/documents/02_claims_register/012_claims_register_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/024_proofs_of_claim_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/05_cash_management/036_cash_management_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/06_financing/048_financing_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/08_tax/060_tax_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/097_foundry_foods_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n## Alternatives considered\n\n- `foundry-foods:shortcut` — Use the proof-of-claim total without applying payments or timing.: Use a plausible summary or one source without completing the controlling joins.\n- `foundry-foods:blanket-hold` — Freeze the entire matter population: Treat supported actions and genuinely ambiguous records as if they were equally unresolved.\n\n## Assumptions and limits\n\nThis decision is limited to cb100-046-foundry-foods, the supplied synthetic records, and the matter state as of 2026-09-22. Similar names, stale revisions, and pending authority are not treated as proof.\n", "decision": {"actions": [{"determination": "approval must come from Maya Ellison under CB-RS-2806-R561; the effective approval record names Caleb Hassan under CB-RS-2806-E127. Identity resolves to ENT-046-1001, revision REV-2026.2 is current, and Dominic Alvarez is active with capacity 5.", "due_date": "2026-09-20", "id": "ACT-CBP-046-02", "identity_id": "ENT-046-1001", "issue": "secured-status defect", "owner": "Dominic Alvarez", "portfolio_key": "CBP-046-02", "recommended_action": "Create invoice-level claim rows and hold stale cure extracts. Owner: Dominic Alvarez; due 2026-09-20.", "severity": "critical", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/002_petition_schedules_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/02_claims_register/014_claims_register_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/026_contracts_leases_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/05_cash_management/038_cash_management_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/11_notices_ballots/086_notices_ballots_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/07_critical_vendors/050_critical_vendors_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/097_foundry_foods_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "the permission is limited to District of Minnesota Bankruptcy Court under CB-RS-2806-R895; the matched activity occurred in Minnesota under CB-RS-2806-E993. Identity resolves to ENT-046-1003, revision REV-2026.4 is current, and Henry Cho is active with capacity 6.", "due_date": "2026-09-18", "id": "ACT-CBP-046-04", "identity_id": "ENT-046-1003", "issue": "cash-collateral reporting gap", "owner": "Henry Cho", "portfolio_key": "CBP-046-04", "recommended_action": "Create invoice-level claim rows and hold stale cure extracts. Owner: Henry Cho; due 2026-09-18.", "severity": "low", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/004_petition_schedules_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/02_claims_register/016_claims_register_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/028_contracts_leases_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/05_cash_management/040_cash_management_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/11_notices_ballots/088_notices_ballots_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/097_foundry_foods_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "delivery must use notices-foundry_prepared_foods_inc@example.test under CB-RS-2806-R172; the only matched receipt used archive-northland_cold_chain_llc@example.test under CB-RS-2806-E157. Identity resolves to ENT-046-1005, revision REV-2026.6 is current, and Jonas Feld is active with capacity 6.", "due_date": "2026-09-16", "id": "ACT-CBP-046-06", "identity_id": "ENT-046-1005", "issue": "postpetition invoice", "owner": "Jonas Feld", "portfolio_key": "CBP-046-06", "recommended_action": "Create invoice-level claim rows and hold stale cure extracts. Owner: Jonas Feld; due 2026-09-16.", "severity": "low", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/006_petition_schedules_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/018_proofs_of_claim_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/030_contracts_leases_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/06_financing/042_financing_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/09_litigation/066_litigation_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/10_plan_disclosure/078_plan_disclosure_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/097_foundry_foods_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "an open exception blocks completion under CB-RS-2806-R280; the current status is open and unresolved under CB-RS-2806-E375. Identity resolves to ENT-046-1006, revision REV-2026.7 is current, and Willa Novak is active with capacity 6.", "due_date": "2026-09-15", "id": "ACT-CBP-046-07", "identity_id": "ENT-046-1006", "issue": "DIP budget variance", "owner": "Willa Novak", "portfolio_key": "CBP-046-07", "recommended_action": "Create invoice-level claim rows and hold stale cure extracts. Owner: Willa Novak; due 2026-09-15.", "severity": "low", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/007_petition_schedules_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/019_proofs_of_claim_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/031_contracts_leases_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/06_financing/043_financing_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/097_foundry_foods_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "the controlling threshold is 16% under CB-RS-2806-R531; the independently calculated result is 24% under CB-RS-2806-E654. Identity resolves to ENT-046-1008, revision REV-2026.2 is current, and Priya Raman is active with capacity 3.", "due_date": "2026-09-13", "id": "ACT-CBP-046-09", "identity_id": "ENT-046-1008", "issue": "lease rejection deadline", "owner": "Priya Raman", "portfolio_key": "CBP-046-09", "recommended_action": "Create invoice-level claim rows and hold stale cure extracts. Owner: Priya Raman; due 2026-09-13.", "severity": "high", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_claims_register/009_claims_register_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/021_proofs_of_claim_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/05_cash_management/033_cash_management_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/06_financing/045_financing_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/097_foundry_foods_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "approval must come from Maya Ellison under CB-RS-2806-R190; the effective approval record names Rafael Okafor under CB-RS-2806-E475. Identity resolves to ENT-046-1009, revision REV-2026.3 is current, and Isaac Romero is active with capacity 3.", "due_date": "2026-09-21", "id": "ACT-CBP-046-10", "identity_id": "ENT-046-1009", "issue": "tax priority period", "owner": "Isaac Romero", "portfolio_key": "CBP-046-10", "recommended_action": "Create invoice-level claim rows and hold stale cure extracts. Owner: Isaac Romero; due 2026-09-21.", "severity": "critical", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_claims_register/010_claims_register_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/022_proofs_of_claim_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/05_cash_management/034_cash_management_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/06_financing/046_financing_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/09_litigation/070_litigation_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/08_tax/058_tax_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/097_foundry_foods_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "the controlled population contains 137 records under CB-RS-2806-R545; the certification covers 115 records under CB-RS-2806-E443. Identity resolves to ENT-046-1010, revision REV-2026.4 is current, and Nadine Flores is active with capacity 6.", "due_date": "2026-09-20", "id": "ACT-CBP-046-11", "identity_id": "ENT-046-1010", "issue": "reserve calculation error", "owner": "Nadine Flores", "portfolio_key": "CBP-046-11", "recommended_action": "Create invoice-level claim rows and hold stale cure extracts. Owner: Nadine Flores; due 2026-09-20.", "severity": "medium", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_claims_register/011_claims_register_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/023_proofs_of_claim_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/05_cash_management/035_cash_management_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/06_financing/047_financing_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/09_litigation/071_litigation_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/097_foundry_foods_impact_population.xlsx"]}], "as_of": "2026-09-22", "decision": {"alternatives_considered": ["foundry-foods:shortcut", "foundry-foods:blanket-hold"], "question": "Which Foundry vendor balances remain after petition timing, critical payments, and cure schedules are reconciled?", "rationale": "The four-part causal test supports 7 scoped actions and leaves 5 records on evidence hold. Petition timing, payment application, and assumption cure rules govern the remaining obligation.", "recommendation": "Reduce, reclassify, or reserve supported balances at invoice level.", "selected_option_id": "foundry-foods:scoped-evidence"}, "holds": [{"id": "HOLD-CBP-046-01", "issue": "ballot amount discrepancy", "portfolio_key": "CBP-046-01", "reason": "the current observation does not meet the operative trigger", "required_next_evidence": "a current observation that satisfies the operative trigger", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/001_petition_schedules_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/02_claims_register/013_claims_register_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/025_contracts_leases_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/05_cash_management/037_cash_management_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/10_plan_disclosure/073_plan_disclosure_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/07_critical_vendors/049_critical_vendors_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/097_foundry_foods_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-046-03", "issue": "critical-vendor overstatement", "portfolio_key": "CBP-046-03", "reason": "the operational record relies on a superseded control revision", "required_next_evidence": "an operational record using the current effective revision", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/003_petition_schedules_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/02_claims_register/015_claims_register_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/027_contracts_leases_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/05_cash_management/039_cash_management_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/11_notices_ballots/087_notices_ballots_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/08_tax/063_tax_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/097_foundry_foods_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-046-05", "issue": "duplicate proof of claim", "portfolio_key": "CBP-046-05", "reason": "the current observation does not meet the operative trigger", "required_next_evidence": "a current observation that satisfies the operative trigger", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/005_petition_schedules_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/017_proofs_of_claim_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/029_contracts_leases_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/06_financing/041_financing_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/097_foundry_foods_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-046-08", "issue": "scheduled-claim mismatch", "portfolio_key": "CBP-046-08", "reason": "two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key", "required_next_evidence": "an approved immutable entity crosswalk", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/008_petition_schedules_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/020_proofs_of_claim_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/032_contracts_leases_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/06_financing/044_financing_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/097_foundry_foods_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-046-12", "issue": "executory-contract cure dispute", "portfolio_key": "CBP-046-12", "reason": "two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key", "required_next_evidence": "an approved immutable entity crosswalk", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_claims_register/012_claims_register_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/024_proofs_of_claim_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/05_cash_management/036_cash_management_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/06_financing/048_financing_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/08_tax/060_tax_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/097_foundry_foods_impact_population.xlsx"]}], "matter_number": "CB-RS-2806", "prepared_for": "Foundry Prepared Foods, Inc.", "schema_version": "counselbench.decision.v3", "task_id": "cb100-046-foundry-foods"}, "matter_register": {"matter_number": "CB-RS-2806", "rows": [{"decision_option_id": "foundry-foods:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "the current observation does not meet the operative trigger", "issue": "ballot amount discrepancy", "matter_number": "CB-RS-2806", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-046-01", "row_id": "REG-CBP-046-01", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/001_petition_schedules_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/02_claims_register/013_claims_register_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/025_contracts_leases_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/05_cash_management/037_cash_management_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/10_plan_disclosure/073_plan_disclosure_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/07_critical_vendors/049_critical_vendors_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/097_foundry_foods_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "foundry-foods:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-20", "issue": "secured-status defect", "matter_number": "CB-RS-2806", "owner": "Dominic Alvarez", "portfolio_key": "CBP-046-02", "row_id": "REG-CBP-046-02", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/002_petition_schedules_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/02_claims_register/014_claims_register_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/026_contracts_leases_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/05_cash_management/038_cash_management_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/11_notices_ballots/086_notices_ballots_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/07_critical_vendors/050_critical_vendors_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/097_foundry_foods_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "foundry-foods:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "the operational record relies on a superseded control revision", "issue": "critical-vendor overstatement", "matter_number": "CB-RS-2806", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-046-03", "row_id": "REG-CBP-046-03", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/003_petition_schedules_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/02_claims_register/015_claims_register_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/027_contracts_leases_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/05_cash_management/039_cash_management_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/11_notices_ballots/087_notices_ballots_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/08_tax/063_tax_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/097_foundry_foods_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "foundry-foods:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-18", "issue": "cash-collateral reporting gap", "matter_number": "CB-RS-2806", "owner": "Henry Cho", "portfolio_key": "CBP-046-04", "row_id": "REG-CBP-046-04", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/004_petition_schedules_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/02_claims_register/016_claims_register_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/028_contracts_leases_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/05_cash_management/040_cash_management_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/11_notices_ballots/088_notices_ballots_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/097_foundry_foods_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "foundry-foods:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "the current observation does not meet the operative trigger", "issue": "duplicate proof of claim", "matter_number": "CB-RS-2806", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-046-05", "row_id": "REG-CBP-046-05", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/005_petition_schedules_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/017_proofs_of_claim_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/029_contracts_leases_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/06_financing/041_financing_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/097_foundry_foods_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "foundry-foods:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-16", "issue": "postpetition invoice", "matter_number": "CB-RS-2806", "owner": "Jonas Feld", "portfolio_key": "CBP-046-06", "row_id": "REG-CBP-046-06", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/006_petition_schedules_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/018_proofs_of_claim_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/030_contracts_leases_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/06_financing/042_financing_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/09_litigation/066_litigation_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/10_plan_disclosure/078_plan_disclosure_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/097_foundry_foods_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "foundry-foods:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-15", "issue": "DIP budget variance", "matter_number": "CB-RS-2806", "owner": "Willa Novak", "portfolio_key": "CBP-046-07", "row_id": "REG-CBP-046-07", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/007_petition_schedules_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/019_proofs_of_claim_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/031_contracts_leases_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/06_financing/043_financing_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/097_foundry_foods_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "foundry-foods:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key", "issue": "scheduled-claim mismatch", "matter_number": "CB-RS-2806", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-046-08", "row_id": "REG-CBP-046-08", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/008_petition_schedules_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/020_proofs_of_claim_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/032_contracts_leases_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/06_financing/044_financing_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/097_foundry_foods_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "foundry-foods:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-13", "issue": "lease rejection deadline", "matter_number": "CB-RS-2806", "owner": "Priya Raman", "portfolio_key": "CBP-046-09", "row_id": "REG-CBP-046-09", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_claims_register/009_claims_register_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/021_proofs_of_claim_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/05_cash_management/033_cash_management_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/06_financing/045_financing_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/097_foundry_foods_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "foundry-foods:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-21", "issue": "tax priority period", "matter_number": "CB-RS-2806", "owner": "Isaac Romero", "portfolio_key": "CBP-046-10", "row_id": "REG-CBP-046-10", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_claims_register/010_claims_register_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/022_proofs_of_claim_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/05_cash_management/034_cash_management_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/06_financing/046_financing_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/09_litigation/070_litigation_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/08_tax/058_tax_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/097_foundry_foods_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "foundry-foods:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-20", "issue": "reserve calculation error", "matter_number": "CB-RS-2806", "owner": "Nadine Flores", "portfolio_key": "CBP-046-11", "row_id": "REG-CBP-046-11", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_claims_register/011_claims_register_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/023_proofs_of_claim_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/05_cash_management/035_cash_management_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/06_financing/047_financing_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/09_litigation/071_litigation_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/097_foundry_foods_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "foundry-foods:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key", "issue": "executory-contract cure dispute", "matter_number": "CB-RS-2806", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-046-12", "row_id": "REG-CBP-046-12", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_claims_register/012_claims_register_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/024_proofs_of_claim_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/05_cash_management/036_cash_management_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/06_financing/048_financing_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/08_tax/060_tax_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/097_foundry_foods_impact_population.xlsx"]}], "schema_version": "counselbench.matter-register.v3", "task_id": "cb100-046-foundry-foods"}}, "metadata": {"benchmark": "CounselBench-100", "code_license": "Apache-2.0", "data_license": "CC-BY-4.0", "deadline": "2026-09-22", "document_count": 97, "evidence_holds": 5, "jurisdiction": "Minnesota", "matter_number": "CB-RS-2806", "mcp_commit": "9a96ea6e5913736f92b88345bf51caeaaa8e719f", "mcp_package": "@modelcontextprotocol/server-filesystem@2026.7.10", "practice_area": "restructuring", "reference_tool_calls": 80, "required_evidence_reads": 63, "supported_actions": 7, "synthetic": true, "venue": "District of Minnesota Bankruptcy Court", "version": "3.1.0"}, "prompt": "I am about to brief the decision makers and need the source record reconciled first. Which Foundry vendor balances remain after petition timing, critical payments, and cure schedules are reconciled? Cold-storage invoices straddle the petition date, critical-vendor payments overlap claims, and cure schedules use stale balances. The team needs the call by 2026-09-22. Record the outcome the source hierarchy supports and explain the alternatives we should not take.", "rubric": {"criteria": [{"category": "investigation", "description": "Inventory the production and use targeted searches to locate records across native formats.", "id": "investigation.discover_production"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Complete every task-specific identity, authority, operations, and approval read before the first state transition.", "id": "investigation.read_before_write"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Inspect designated source metadata before relying on those records.", "id": "investigation.custody_before_write"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "Select the supported option 'foundry-foods:scoped-evidence' after applying the four-part test.", "id": "decision.selected_option"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "Identify both rejected approaches and explain why a one-source shortcut and a blanket hold are wrong.", "id": "decision.alternatives"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-046-01 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/001_petition_schedules_source_export.md rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-046-01.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_claims_register/013_claims_register_source_export.json for ballot amount discrepancy.", "id": "investigation.CBP-046-01.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/025_contracts_leases_source_export.md to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-046-01.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_cash_management/037_cash_management_source_export.json.", "id": "investigation.CBP-046-01.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-046-01 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is the current observation does not meet the operative trigger.", "id": "decision.CBP-046-01.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-046-01 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-046-01.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-046-02 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/002_petition_schedules_source_export.txt rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-046-02.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_claims_register/014_claims_register_source_export.xml for secured-status defect.", "id": "investigation.CBP-046-02.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/026_contracts_leases_source_export.txt to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-046-02.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_cash_management/038_cash_management_source_export.xml.", "id": "investigation.CBP-046-02.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-046-02 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-046-02.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-046-02 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-046-02.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-046-03 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/003_petition_schedules_source_export.eml rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-046-03.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_claims_register/015_claims_register_source_export.html for critical-vendor overstatement.", "id": "investigation.CBP-046-03.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/027_contracts_leases_source_export.eml to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-046-03.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_cash_management/039_cash_management_source_export.html.", "id": "investigation.CBP-046-03.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-046-03 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is the operational record relies on a superseded control revision.", "id": "decision.CBP-046-03.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-046-03 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-046-03.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-046-04 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/004_petition_schedules_source_export.csv rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-046-04.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_claims_register/016_claims_register_source_export.pdf for cash-collateral reporting gap.", "id": "investigation.CBP-046-04.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/028_contracts_leases_source_export.csv to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-046-04.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_cash_management/040_cash_management_source_export.pdf.", "id": "investigation.CBP-046-04.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-046-04 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-046-04.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-046-04 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-046-04.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-046-05 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/005_petition_schedules_source_export.json rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-046-05.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/017_proofs_of_claim_source_export.md for duplicate proof of claim.", "id": "investigation.CBP-046-05.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/029_contracts_leases_source_export.json to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-046-05.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_financing/041_financing_source_export.md.", "id": "investigation.CBP-046-05.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-046-05 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is the current observation does not meet the operative trigger.", "id": "decision.CBP-046-05.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-046-05 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-046-05.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-046-06 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/006_petition_schedules_source_export.xml rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-046-06.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/018_proofs_of_claim_source_export.txt for postpetition invoice.", "id": "investigation.CBP-046-06.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/030_contracts_leases_source_export.xml to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-046-06.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_financing/042_financing_source_export.txt.", "id": "investigation.CBP-046-06.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-046-06 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-046-06.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-046-06 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-046-06.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-046-07 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/007_petition_schedules_source_export.html rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-046-07.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/019_proofs_of_claim_source_export.eml for DIP budget variance.", "id": "investigation.CBP-046-07.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/031_contracts_leases_source_export.html to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-046-07.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_financing/043_financing_source_export.eml.", "id": "investigation.CBP-046-07.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-046-07 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-046-07.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-046-07 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-046-07.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-046-08 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/008_petition_schedules_source_export.pdf rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-046-08.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/020_proofs_of_claim_source_export.csv for scheduled-claim mismatch.", "id": "investigation.CBP-046-08.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/032_contracts_leases_source_export.pdf to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-046-08.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_financing/044_financing_source_export.csv.", "id": "investigation.CBP-046-08.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-046-08 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key.", "id": "decision.CBP-046-08.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-046-08 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-046-08.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-046-09 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_claims_register/009_claims_register_source_export.md rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-046-09.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/021_proofs_of_claim_source_export.json for lease rejection deadline.", "id": "investigation.CBP-046-09.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_cash_management/033_cash_management_source_export.md to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-046-09.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_financing/045_financing_source_export.json.", "id": "investigation.CBP-046-09.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-046-09 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-046-09.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-046-09 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-046-09.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-046-10 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_claims_register/010_claims_register_source_export.txt rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-046-10.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/022_proofs_of_claim_source_export.xml for tax priority period.", "id": "investigation.CBP-046-10.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_cash_management/034_cash_management_source_export.txt to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-046-10.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_financing/046_financing_source_export.xml.", "id": "investigation.CBP-046-10.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-046-10 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-046-10.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-046-10 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-046-10.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-046-11 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_claims_register/011_claims_register_source_export.eml rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-046-11.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/023_proofs_of_claim_source_export.html for reserve calculation error.", "id": "investigation.CBP-046-11.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_cash_management/035_cash_management_source_export.eml to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-046-11.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_financing/047_financing_source_export.html.", "id": "investigation.CBP-046-11.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-046-11 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-046-11.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-046-11 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-046-11.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-046-12 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_claims_register/012_claims_register_source_export.csv rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-046-12.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/024_proofs_of_claim_source_export.pdf for executory-contract cure dispute.", "id": "investigation.CBP-046-12.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_cash_management/036_cash_management_source_export.csv to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-046-12.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_financing/048_financing_source_export.pdf.", "id": "investigation.CBP-046-12.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-046-12 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key.", "id": "decision.CBP-046-12.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-046-12 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-046-12.register"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Write the exact selected option, supported action population, evidence-hold population, facts, owners, deadlines, and citations.", "id": "state.exact_decision"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create one exact register row per portfolio key with no extra, missing, or modified row.", "id": "state.exact_register"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Leave only the three approved deliverables and perform no extra state-changing write.", "id": "state.write_scope_containment"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Read back decision.json, matter-register.json, and advice.md after their final writes.", "id": "state.postwrite_readback"}, {"category": "answer", "description": "Explain the selected recommendation, supported actions, holds, alternatives, and limitations with exact source anchors.", "id": "answer.decision_note"}], "decision_options": [{"approach": "Apply the exact identity, current-state, authority, and revision test. Create invoice-level claim rows and hold stale cure extracts.", "id": "foundry-foods:scoped-evidence", "label": "Reduce, reclassify, or reserve supported balances at invoice level."}, {"approach": "Use a plausible summary or one source without completing the controlling joins.", "id": "foundry-foods:shortcut", "label": "Use the proof-of-claim total without applying payments or timing."}, {"approach": "Treat supported actions and genuinely ambiguous records as if they were equally unresolved.", "id": "foundry-foods:blanket-hold", "label": "Freeze the entire matter population"}], "evaluation_narrative": {"authority": "Petition timing, payment application, and assumption cure rules govern the remaining obligation.", "observation": "Match invoices, receipt dates, payments, claims, and contract cure entries by vendor and shipment.", "question": "Which Foundry vendor balances remain after petition timing, critical payments, and cure schedules are reconciled?", "register_action": "Create invoice-level claim rows and hold stale cure extracts."}, "gates": ["all_required_evidence_precedes_first_write", "decision_criteria_complete", "register_state_exact", "write_scope_contained", "all_outputs_verified_by_readback"], "metadata_checks": 4, "metric": "weighted_criteria_score", "minimum_tool_calls": 80, "required_deliverables": ["decision.json", "matter-register.json", "advice.md"], "required_document_reads": 63, "type": "deterministic", "weights": {"advice": 0.15, "decision": 0.35, "investigation": 0.25, "state": 0.25}}, "task_id": "cb100-046-foundry-foods", "task_name": "Foundry Foods vendor claim audit", "world_id": "counselbench-filesystem-mcp-v3"}
+{"context_files": ["task_files/cb100-047-greenway-transit/01_petition_schedules/001_petition_schedules_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-047-greenway-transit/01_petition_schedules/002_petition_schedules_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-047-greenway-transit/01_petition_schedules/003_petition_schedules_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-047-greenway-transit/01_petition_schedules/004_petition_schedules_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-047-greenway-transit/01_petition_schedules/005_petition_schedules_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-047-greenway-transit/01_petition_schedules/006_petition_schedules_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-047-greenway-transit/01_petition_schedules/007_petition_schedules_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-047-greenway-transit/01_petition_schedules/008_petition_schedules_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-047-greenway-transit/02_claims_register/009_claims_register_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-047-greenway-transit/02_claims_register/010_claims_register_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-047-greenway-transit/02_claims_register/011_claims_register_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-047-greenway-transit/02_claims_register/012_claims_register_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-047-greenway-transit/02_claims_register/013_claims_register_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-047-greenway-transit/02_claims_register/014_claims_register_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-047-greenway-transit/02_claims_register/015_claims_register_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-047-greenway-transit/02_claims_register/016_claims_register_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-047-greenway-transit/03_proofs_of_claim/017_proofs_of_claim_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-047-greenway-transit/03_proofs_of_claim/018_proofs_of_claim_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-047-greenway-transit/03_proofs_of_claim/019_proofs_of_claim_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-047-greenway-transit/03_proofs_of_claim/020_proofs_of_claim_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-047-greenway-transit/03_proofs_of_claim/021_proofs_of_claim_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-047-greenway-transit/03_proofs_of_claim/022_proofs_of_claim_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-047-greenway-transit/03_proofs_of_claim/023_proofs_of_claim_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-047-greenway-transit/03_proofs_of_claim/024_proofs_of_claim_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-047-greenway-transit/04_contracts_leases/025_contracts_leases_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-047-greenway-transit/04_contracts_leases/026_contracts_leases_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-047-greenway-transit/04_contracts_leases/027_contracts_leases_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-047-greenway-transit/04_contracts_leases/028_contracts_leases_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-047-greenway-transit/04_contracts_leases/029_contracts_leases_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-047-greenway-transit/04_contracts_leases/030_contracts_leases_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-047-greenway-transit/04_contracts_leases/031_contracts_leases_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-047-greenway-transit/04_contracts_leases/032_contracts_leases_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-047-greenway-transit/05_cash_management/033_cash_management_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-047-greenway-transit/05_cash_management/034_cash_management_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-047-greenway-transit/05_cash_management/035_cash_management_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-047-greenway-transit/05_cash_management/036_cash_management_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-047-greenway-transit/05_cash_management/037_cash_management_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-047-greenway-transit/05_cash_management/038_cash_management_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-047-greenway-transit/05_cash_management/039_cash_management_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-047-greenway-transit/05_cash_management/040_cash_management_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-047-greenway-transit/06_financing/041_financing_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-047-greenway-transit/06_financing/042_financing_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-047-greenway-transit/06_financing/043_financing_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-047-greenway-transit/06_financing/044_financing_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-047-greenway-transit/06_financing/045_financing_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-047-greenway-transit/06_financing/046_financing_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-047-greenway-transit/06_financing/047_financing_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-047-greenway-transit/06_financing/048_financing_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-047-greenway-transit/07_critical_vendors/049_critical_vendors_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-047-greenway-transit/07_critical_vendors/050_critical_vendors_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-047-greenway-transit/07_critical_vendors/051_critical_vendors_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-047-greenway-transit/07_critical_vendors/052_critical_vendors_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-047-greenway-transit/07_critical_vendors/053_critical_vendors_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-047-greenway-transit/07_critical_vendors/054_critical_vendors_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-047-greenway-transit/07_critical_vendors/055_critical_vendors_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-047-greenway-transit/07_critical_vendors/056_critical_vendors_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-047-greenway-transit/08_tax/057_tax_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-047-greenway-transit/08_tax/058_tax_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-047-greenway-transit/08_tax/059_tax_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-047-greenway-transit/08_tax/060_tax_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-047-greenway-transit/08_tax/061_tax_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-047-greenway-transit/08_tax/062_tax_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-047-greenway-transit/08_tax/063_tax_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-047-greenway-transit/08_tax/064_tax_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-047-greenway-transit/09_litigation/065_litigation_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-047-greenway-transit/09_litigation/066_litigation_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-047-greenway-transit/09_litigation/067_litigation_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-047-greenway-transit/09_litigation/068_litigation_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-047-greenway-transit/09_litigation/069_litigation_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-047-greenway-transit/09_litigation/070_litigation_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-047-greenway-transit/09_litigation/071_litigation_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-047-greenway-transit/09_litigation/072_litigation_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-047-greenway-transit/10_plan_disclosure/073_plan_disclosure_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-047-greenway-transit/10_plan_disclosure/074_plan_disclosure_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-047-greenway-transit/10_plan_disclosure/075_plan_disclosure_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-047-greenway-transit/10_plan_disclosure/076_plan_disclosure_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-047-greenway-transit/10_plan_disclosure/077_plan_disclosure_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-047-greenway-transit/10_plan_disclosure/078_plan_disclosure_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-047-greenway-transit/10_plan_disclosure/079_plan_disclosure_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-047-greenway-transit/10_plan_disclosure/080_plan_disclosure_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-047-greenway-transit/11_notices_ballots/081_notices_ballots_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-047-greenway-transit/11_notices_ballots/082_notices_ballots_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-047-greenway-transit/11_notices_ballots/083_notices_ballots_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-047-greenway-transit/11_notices_ballots/084_notices_ballots_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-047-greenway-transit/11_notices_ballots/085_notices_ballots_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-047-greenway-transit/11_notices_ballots/086_notices_ballots_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-047-greenway-transit/11_notices_ballots/087_notices_ballots_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-047-greenway-transit/11_notices_ballots/088_notices_ballots_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-047-greenway-transit/12_reconciliations/089_reconciliations_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-047-greenway-transit/12_reconciliations/090_reconciliations_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-047-greenway-transit/12_reconciliations/091_reconciliations_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-047-greenway-transit/12_reconciliations/092_reconciliations_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-047-greenway-transit/12_reconciliations/093_reconciliations_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-047-greenway-transit/12_reconciliations/094_reconciliations_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-047-greenway-transit/12_reconciliations/095_reconciliations_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-047-greenway-transit/12_reconciliations/096_reconciliations_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-047-greenway-transit/12_reconciliations/097_greenway_transit_impact_population.xlsx"], "gold_output": {"advice_markdown": "# Decision note — Greenway Transit plan claim review\n\n## Recommendation\n\nSet exact supported voting and reserve treatment by claim component. The reconciled record supports 7 scoped actions and leaves 5 items on evidence hold.\n\nSelected option: `greenway-transit:scoped-evidence`.\n\n## Why this is the supported option\n\nJoin claim components, collateral, tax periods, rejection calculations, and budget variances. Classification and voting follow supported allowed amounts; reserves must reflect unresolved components.\n\n## Supported actions\n\n### CBP-047-01 — notice-address defect (critical)\n\ndelivery must use notices-greenway_transit_services@example.test under CB-RS-2807-R578; the only matched receipt used archive-metro_fleet_finance@example.test under CB-RS-2807-E339. Identity resolves to ENT-047-1000, revision REV-2025.1 is current, and Samuel Kim is active with capacity 1.\n\nAction: Create component-level voting and reserve rows with unresolved evidence holds. Owner: Samuel Kim; due 2026-09-24.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/001_petition_schedules_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/02_claims_register/013_claims_register_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/025_contracts_leases_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/05_cash_management/037_cash_management_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/11_notices_ballots/085_notices_ballots_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/097_greenway_transit_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-047-02 — priority classification error (critical)\n\nan open exception blocks completion under CB-RS-2807-R768; the current status is open and unresolved under CB-RS-2807-E880. Identity resolves to ENT-047-1001, revision REV-2025.2 is current, and Talia Brooks is active with capacity 3.\n\nAction: Create component-level voting and reserve rows with unresolved evidence holds. Owner: Talia Brooks; due 2026-09-23.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/002_petition_schedules_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/02_claims_register/014_claims_register_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/026_contracts_leases_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/05_cash_management/038_cash_management_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/097_greenway_transit_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-047-07 — cash-collateral reporting gap (high)\n\nthe permission is limited to Northern District of Illinois Bankruptcy Court under CB-RS-2807-R184; the matched activity occurred in Illinois under CB-RS-2807-E475. Identity resolves to ENT-047-1006, revision REV-2025.7 is current, and Henry Cho is active with capacity 1.\n\nAction: Create component-level voting and reserve rows with unresolved evidence holds. Owner: Henry Cho; due 2026-09-18.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/007_petition_schedules_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/019_proofs_of_claim_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/031_contracts_leases_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/06_financing/043_financing_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/097_greenway_transit_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-047-09 — postpetition invoice (high)\n\ndelivery must use notices-greenway_transit_services@example.test under CB-RS-2807-R314; the only matched receipt used archive-metro_fleet_finance@example.test under CB-RS-2807-E165. Identity resolves to ENT-047-1008, revision REV-2025.2 is current, and Jonas Feld is active with capacity 5.\n\nAction: Create component-level voting and reserve rows with unresolved evidence holds. Owner: Jonas Feld; due 2026-09-16.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/02_claims_register/009_claims_register_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/021_proofs_of_claim_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/05_cash_management/033_cash_management_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/06_financing/045_financing_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/08_tax/057_tax_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/097_greenway_transit_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-047-10 — DIP budget variance (medium)\n\nan open exception blocks completion under CB-RS-2807-R833; the current status is open and unresolved under CB-RS-2807-E513. Identity resolves to ENT-047-1009, revision REV-2025.3 is current, and Willa Novak is active with capacity 6.\n\nAction: Create component-level voting and reserve rows with unresolved evidence holds. Owner: Willa Novak; due 2026-09-24.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/02_claims_register/010_claims_register_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/022_proofs_of_claim_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/05_cash_management/034_cash_management_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/06_financing/046_financing_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/08_tax/058_tax_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/094_reconciliations_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/097_greenway_transit_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-047-11 — scheduled-claim mismatch (medium)\n\ncompletion is required by 2025-05-05 under CB-RS-2807-R279; the current event record shows completion on 2025-05-31 under CB-RS-2807-E639. Identity resolves to ENT-047-1010, revision REV-2025.4 is current, and Owen Delgado is active with capacity 3.\n\nAction: Create component-level voting and reserve rows with unresolved evidence holds. Owner: Owen Delgado; due 2026-09-23.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/02_claims_register/011_claims_register_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/023_proofs_of_claim_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/05_cash_management/035_cash_management_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/06_financing/047_financing_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/11_notices_ballots/083_notices_ballots_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/097_greenway_transit_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-047-12 — lease rejection deadline (critical)\n\nthe controlling threshold is 10% under CB-RS-2807-R753; the independently calculated result is 12% under CB-RS-2807-E244. Identity resolves to ENT-047-1011, revision REV-2025.5 is current, and Priya Raman is active with capacity 4.\n\nAction: Create component-level voting and reserve rows with unresolved evidence holds. Owner: Priya Raman; due 2026-09-22.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/02_claims_register/012_claims_register_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/024_proofs_of_claim_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/05_cash_management/036_cash_management_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/06_financing/048_financing_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/08_tax/060_tax_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/097_greenway_transit_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n## Evidence holds\n\n- **CBP-047-03 — setoff assertion**: two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key. Next evidence: an approved immutable entity crosswalk. Sources: `/workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/003_petition_schedules_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/02_claims_register/015_claims_register_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/027_contracts_leases_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/05_cash_management/039_cash_management_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/10_plan_disclosure/075_plan_disclosure_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/097_greenway_transit_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-047-04 — ballot amount discrepancy**: the current observation does not meet the operative trigger. Next evidence: a current observation that satisfies the operative trigger. Sources: `/workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/004_petition_schedules_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/02_claims_register/016_claims_register_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/028_contracts_leases_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/05_cash_management/040_cash_management_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/07_critical_vendors/052_critical_vendors_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/10_plan_disclosure/076_plan_disclosure_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/097_greenway_transit_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-047-05 — secured-status defect**: the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective. Next evidence: effective approval and an active owner with remaining capacity. Sources: `/workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/005_petition_schedules_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/017_proofs_of_claim_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/029_contracts_leases_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/06_financing/041_financing_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/097_greenway_transit_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-047-06 — critical-vendor overstatement**: the operational record relies on a superseded control revision. Next evidence: an operational record using the current effective revision. Sources: `/workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/006_petition_schedules_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/018_proofs_of_claim_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/030_contracts_leases_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/06_financing/042_financing_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/097_greenway_transit_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-047-08 — duplicate proof of claim**: the current observation does not meet the operative trigger. Next evidence: a current observation that satisfies the operative trigger. Sources: `/workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/008_petition_schedules_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/020_proofs_of_claim_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/032_contracts_leases_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/06_financing/044_financing_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/10_plan_disclosure/080_plan_disclosure_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/09_litigation/068_litigation_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/097_greenway_transit_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n## Alternatives considered\n\n- `greenway-transit:shortcut` — Use scheduled amounts for voting and put every variance into one reserve.: Use a plausible summary or one source without completing the controlling joins.\n- `greenway-transit:blanket-hold` — Freeze the entire matter population: Treat supported actions and genuinely ambiguous records as if they were equally unresolved.\n\n## Assumptions and limits\n\nThis decision is limited to cb100-047-greenway-transit, the supplied synthetic records, and the matter state as of 2026-09-25. Similar names, stale revisions, and pending authority are not treated as proof.\n", "decision": {"actions": [{"determination": "delivery must use notices-greenway_transit_services@example.test under CB-RS-2807-R578; the only matched receipt used archive-metro_fleet_finance@example.test under CB-RS-2807-E339. Identity resolves to ENT-047-1000, revision REV-2025.1 is current, and Samuel Kim is active with capacity 1.", "due_date": "2026-09-24", "id": "ACT-CBP-047-01", "identity_id": "ENT-047-1000", "issue": "notice-address defect", "owner": "Samuel Kim", "portfolio_key": "CBP-047-01", "recommended_action": "Create component-level voting and reserve rows with unresolved evidence holds. Owner: Samuel Kim; due 2026-09-24.", "severity": "critical", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/001_petition_schedules_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/02_claims_register/013_claims_register_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/025_contracts_leases_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/05_cash_management/037_cash_management_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/11_notices_ballots/085_notices_ballots_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/097_greenway_transit_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "an open exception blocks completion under CB-RS-2807-R768; the current status is open and unresolved under CB-RS-2807-E880. Identity resolves to ENT-047-1001, revision REV-2025.2 is current, and Talia Brooks is active with capacity 3.", "due_date": "2026-09-23", "id": "ACT-CBP-047-02", "identity_id": "ENT-047-1001", "issue": "priority classification error", "owner": "Talia Brooks", "portfolio_key": "CBP-047-02", "recommended_action": "Create component-level voting and reserve rows with unresolved evidence holds. Owner: Talia Brooks; due 2026-09-23.", "severity": "critical", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/002_petition_schedules_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/02_claims_register/014_claims_register_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/026_contracts_leases_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/05_cash_management/038_cash_management_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/097_greenway_transit_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "the permission is limited to Northern District of Illinois Bankruptcy Court under CB-RS-2807-R184; the matched activity occurred in Illinois under CB-RS-2807-E475. Identity resolves to ENT-047-1006, revision REV-2025.7 is current, and Henry Cho is active with capacity 1.", "due_date": "2026-09-18", "id": "ACT-CBP-047-07", "identity_id": "ENT-047-1006", "issue": "cash-collateral reporting gap", "owner": "Henry Cho", "portfolio_key": "CBP-047-07", "recommended_action": "Create component-level voting and reserve rows with unresolved evidence holds. Owner: Henry Cho; due 2026-09-18.", "severity": "high", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/007_petition_schedules_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/019_proofs_of_claim_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/031_contracts_leases_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/06_financing/043_financing_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/097_greenway_transit_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "delivery must use notices-greenway_transit_services@example.test under CB-RS-2807-R314; the only matched receipt used archive-metro_fleet_finance@example.test under CB-RS-2807-E165. Identity resolves to ENT-047-1008, revision REV-2025.2 is current, and Jonas Feld is active with capacity 5.", "due_date": "2026-09-16", "id": "ACT-CBP-047-09", "identity_id": "ENT-047-1008", "issue": "postpetition invoice", "owner": "Jonas Feld", "portfolio_key": "CBP-047-09", "recommended_action": "Create component-level voting and reserve rows with unresolved evidence holds. Owner: Jonas Feld; due 2026-09-16.", "severity": "high", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_claims_register/009_claims_register_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/021_proofs_of_claim_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/05_cash_management/033_cash_management_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/06_financing/045_financing_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/08_tax/057_tax_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/097_greenway_transit_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "an open exception blocks completion under CB-RS-2807-R833; the current status is open and unresolved under CB-RS-2807-E513. Identity resolves to ENT-047-1009, revision REV-2025.3 is current, and Willa Novak is active with capacity 6.", "due_date": "2026-09-24", "id": "ACT-CBP-047-10", "identity_id": "ENT-047-1009", "issue": "DIP budget variance", "owner": "Willa Novak", "portfolio_key": "CBP-047-10", "recommended_action": "Create component-level voting and reserve rows with unresolved evidence holds. Owner: Willa Novak; due 2026-09-24.", "severity": "medium", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_claims_register/010_claims_register_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/022_proofs_of_claim_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/05_cash_management/034_cash_management_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/06_financing/046_financing_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/08_tax/058_tax_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/094_reconciliations_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/097_greenway_transit_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "completion is required by 2025-05-05 under CB-RS-2807-R279; the current event record shows completion on 2025-05-31 under CB-RS-2807-E639. Identity resolves to ENT-047-1010, revision REV-2025.4 is current, and Owen Delgado is active with capacity 3.", "due_date": "2026-09-23", "id": "ACT-CBP-047-11", "identity_id": "ENT-047-1010", "issue": "scheduled-claim mismatch", "owner": "Owen Delgado", "portfolio_key": "CBP-047-11", "recommended_action": "Create component-level voting and reserve rows with unresolved evidence holds. Owner: Owen Delgado; due 2026-09-23.", "severity": "medium", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_claims_register/011_claims_register_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/023_proofs_of_claim_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/05_cash_management/035_cash_management_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/06_financing/047_financing_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/11_notices_ballots/083_notices_ballots_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/097_greenway_transit_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "the controlling threshold is 10% under CB-RS-2807-R753; the independently calculated result is 12% under CB-RS-2807-E244. Identity resolves to ENT-047-1011, revision REV-2025.5 is current, and Priya Raman is active with capacity 4.", "due_date": "2026-09-22", "id": "ACT-CBP-047-12", "identity_id": "ENT-047-1011", "issue": "lease rejection deadline", "owner": "Priya Raman", "portfolio_key": "CBP-047-12", "recommended_action": "Create component-level voting and reserve rows with unresolved evidence holds. Owner: Priya Raman; due 2026-09-22.", "severity": "critical", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_claims_register/012_claims_register_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/024_proofs_of_claim_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/05_cash_management/036_cash_management_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/06_financing/048_financing_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/08_tax/060_tax_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/097_greenway_transit_impact_population.xlsx"]}], "as_of": "2026-09-25", "decision": {"alternatives_considered": ["greenway-transit:shortcut", "greenway-transit:blanket-hold"], "question": "How should Greenway set voting amounts and reserves after the lien, tax, rejection, and DIP review?", "rationale": "The four-part causal test supports 7 scoped actions and leaves 5 records on evidence hold. Classification and voting follow supported allowed amounts; reserves must reflect unresolved components.", "recommendation": "Set exact supported voting and reserve treatment by claim component.", "selected_option_id": "greenway-transit:scoped-evidence"}, "holds": [{"id": "HOLD-CBP-047-03", "issue": "setoff assertion", "portfolio_key": "CBP-047-03", "reason": "two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key", "required_next_evidence": "an approved immutable entity crosswalk", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/003_petition_schedules_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/02_claims_register/015_claims_register_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/027_contracts_leases_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/05_cash_management/039_cash_management_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/10_plan_disclosure/075_plan_disclosure_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/097_greenway_transit_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-047-04", "issue": "ballot amount discrepancy", "portfolio_key": "CBP-047-04", "reason": "the current observation does not meet the operative trigger", "required_next_evidence": "a current observation that satisfies the operative trigger", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/004_petition_schedules_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/02_claims_register/016_claims_register_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/028_contracts_leases_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/05_cash_management/040_cash_management_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/07_critical_vendors/052_critical_vendors_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/10_plan_disclosure/076_plan_disclosure_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/097_greenway_transit_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-047-05", "issue": "secured-status defect", "portfolio_key": "CBP-047-05", "reason": "the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective", "required_next_evidence": "effective approval and an active owner with remaining capacity", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/005_petition_schedules_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/017_proofs_of_claim_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/029_contracts_leases_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/06_financing/041_financing_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/097_greenway_transit_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-047-06", "issue": "critical-vendor overstatement", "portfolio_key": "CBP-047-06", "reason": "the operational record relies on a superseded control revision", "required_next_evidence": "an operational record using the current effective revision", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/006_petition_schedules_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/018_proofs_of_claim_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/030_contracts_leases_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/06_financing/042_financing_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/097_greenway_transit_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-047-08", "issue": "duplicate proof of claim", "portfolio_key": "CBP-047-08", "reason": "the current observation does not meet the operative trigger", "required_next_evidence": "a current observation that satisfies the operative trigger", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/008_petition_schedules_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/020_proofs_of_claim_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/032_contracts_leases_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/06_financing/044_financing_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/10_plan_disclosure/080_plan_disclosure_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/09_litigation/068_litigation_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/097_greenway_transit_impact_population.xlsx"]}], "matter_number": "CB-RS-2807", "prepared_for": "Greenway Transit Services", "schema_version": "counselbench.decision.v3", "task_id": "cb100-047-greenway-transit"}, "matter_register": {"matter_number": "CB-RS-2807", "rows": [{"decision_option_id": "greenway-transit:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-24", "issue": "notice-address defect", "matter_number": "CB-RS-2807", "owner": "Samuel Kim", "portfolio_key": "CBP-047-01", "row_id": "REG-CBP-047-01", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/001_petition_schedules_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/02_claims_register/013_claims_register_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/025_contracts_leases_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/05_cash_management/037_cash_management_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/11_notices_ballots/085_notices_ballots_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/097_greenway_transit_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "greenway-transit:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-23", "issue": "priority classification error", "matter_number": "CB-RS-2807", "owner": "Talia Brooks", "portfolio_key": "CBP-047-02", "row_id": "REG-CBP-047-02", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/002_petition_schedules_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/02_claims_register/014_claims_register_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/026_contracts_leases_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/05_cash_management/038_cash_management_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/097_greenway_transit_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "greenway-transit:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key", "issue": "setoff assertion", "matter_number": "CB-RS-2807", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-047-03", "row_id": "REG-CBP-047-03", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/003_petition_schedules_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/02_claims_register/015_claims_register_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/027_contracts_leases_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/05_cash_management/039_cash_management_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/10_plan_disclosure/075_plan_disclosure_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/097_greenway_transit_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "greenway-transit:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "the current observation does not meet the operative trigger", "issue": "ballot amount discrepancy", "matter_number": "CB-RS-2807", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-047-04", "row_id": "REG-CBP-047-04", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/004_petition_schedules_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/02_claims_register/016_claims_register_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/028_contracts_leases_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/05_cash_management/040_cash_management_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/07_critical_vendors/052_critical_vendors_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/10_plan_disclosure/076_plan_disclosure_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/097_greenway_transit_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "greenway-transit:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective", "issue": "secured-status defect", "matter_number": "CB-RS-2807", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-047-05", "row_id": "REG-CBP-047-05", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/005_petition_schedules_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/017_proofs_of_claim_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/029_contracts_leases_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/06_financing/041_financing_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/097_greenway_transit_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "greenway-transit:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "the operational record relies on a superseded control revision", "issue": "critical-vendor overstatement", "matter_number": "CB-RS-2807", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-047-06", "row_id": "REG-CBP-047-06", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/006_petition_schedules_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/018_proofs_of_claim_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/030_contracts_leases_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/06_financing/042_financing_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/097_greenway_transit_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "greenway-transit:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-18", "issue": "cash-collateral reporting gap", "matter_number": "CB-RS-2807", "owner": "Henry Cho", "portfolio_key": "CBP-047-07", "row_id": "REG-CBP-047-07", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/007_petition_schedules_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/019_proofs_of_claim_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/031_contracts_leases_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/06_financing/043_financing_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/097_greenway_transit_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "greenway-transit:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "the current observation does not meet the operative trigger", "issue": "duplicate proof of claim", "matter_number": "CB-RS-2807", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-047-08", "row_id": "REG-CBP-047-08", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/008_petition_schedules_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/020_proofs_of_claim_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/032_contracts_leases_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/06_financing/044_financing_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/10_plan_disclosure/080_plan_disclosure_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/09_litigation/068_litigation_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/097_greenway_transit_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "greenway-transit:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-16", "issue": "postpetition invoice", "matter_number": "CB-RS-2807", "owner": "Jonas Feld", "portfolio_key": "CBP-047-09", "row_id": "REG-CBP-047-09", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_claims_register/009_claims_register_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/021_proofs_of_claim_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/05_cash_management/033_cash_management_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/06_financing/045_financing_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/08_tax/057_tax_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/097_greenway_transit_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "greenway-transit:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-24", "issue": "DIP budget variance", "matter_number": "CB-RS-2807", "owner": "Willa Novak", "portfolio_key": "CBP-047-10", "row_id": "REG-CBP-047-10", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_claims_register/010_claims_register_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/022_proofs_of_claim_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/05_cash_management/034_cash_management_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/06_financing/046_financing_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/08_tax/058_tax_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/094_reconciliations_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/097_greenway_transit_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "greenway-transit:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-23", "issue": "scheduled-claim mismatch", "matter_number": "CB-RS-2807", "owner": "Owen Delgado", "portfolio_key": "CBP-047-11", "row_id": "REG-CBP-047-11", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_claims_register/011_claims_register_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/023_proofs_of_claim_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/05_cash_management/035_cash_management_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/06_financing/047_financing_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/11_notices_ballots/083_notices_ballots_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/097_greenway_transit_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "greenway-transit:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-22", "issue": "lease rejection deadline", "matter_number": "CB-RS-2807", "owner": "Priya Raman", "portfolio_key": "CBP-047-12", "row_id": "REG-CBP-047-12", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_claims_register/012_claims_register_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/024_proofs_of_claim_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/05_cash_management/036_cash_management_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/06_financing/048_financing_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/08_tax/060_tax_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/097_greenway_transit_impact_population.xlsx"]}], "schema_version": "counselbench.matter-register.v3", "task_id": "cb100-047-greenway-transit"}}, "metadata": {"benchmark": "CounselBench-100", "code_license": "Apache-2.0", "data_license": "CC-BY-4.0", "deadline": "2026-09-25", "document_count": 97, "evidence_holds": 5, "jurisdiction": "Illinois", "matter_number": "CB-RS-2807", "mcp_commit": "9a96ea6e5913736f92b88345bf51caeaaa8e719f", "mcp_package": "@modelcontextprotocol/server-filesystem@2026.7.10", "practice_area": "restructuring", "reference_tool_calls": 83, "required_evidence_reads": 61, "supported_actions": 7, "synthetic": true, "venue": "Northern District of Illinois Bankruptcy Court", "version": "3.1.0"}, "prompt": "The other side has challenged our internal account of the facts. How should Greenway set voting amounts and reserves after the lien, tax, rejection, and DIP review? Fleet liens, tax claims, rejection damages, and a DIP variance affect voting and reserve recommendations. The team needs the call by 2026-09-25. Leave a concise decision record with exact source references and an owner for each supported next step.", "rubric": {"criteria": [{"category": "investigation", "description": "Inventory the production and use targeted searches to locate records across native formats.", "id": "investigation.discover_production"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Complete every task-specific identity, authority, operations, and approval read before the first state transition.", "id": "investigation.read_before_write"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Inspect designated source metadata before relying on those records.", "id": "investigation.custody_before_write"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "Select the supported option 'greenway-transit:scoped-evidence' after applying the four-part test.", "id": "decision.selected_option"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "Identify both rejected approaches and explain why a one-source shortcut and a blanket hold are wrong.", "id": "decision.alternatives"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-047-01 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/001_petition_schedules_source_export.md rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-047-01.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_claims_register/013_claims_register_source_export.json for notice-address defect.", "id": "investigation.CBP-047-01.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/025_contracts_leases_source_export.md to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-047-01.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_cash_management/037_cash_management_source_export.json.", "id": "investigation.CBP-047-01.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-047-01 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-047-01.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-047-01 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-047-01.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-047-02 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/002_petition_schedules_source_export.txt rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-047-02.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_claims_register/014_claims_register_source_export.xml for priority classification error.", "id": "investigation.CBP-047-02.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/026_contracts_leases_source_export.txt to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-047-02.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_cash_management/038_cash_management_source_export.xml.", "id": "investigation.CBP-047-02.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-047-02 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-047-02.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-047-02 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-047-02.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-047-03 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/003_petition_schedules_source_export.eml rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-047-03.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_claims_register/015_claims_register_source_export.html for setoff assertion.", "id": "investigation.CBP-047-03.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/027_contracts_leases_source_export.eml to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-047-03.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_cash_management/039_cash_management_source_export.html.", "id": "investigation.CBP-047-03.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-047-03 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key.", "id": "decision.CBP-047-03.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-047-03 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-047-03.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-047-04 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/004_petition_schedules_source_export.csv rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-047-04.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_claims_register/016_claims_register_source_export.pdf for ballot amount discrepancy.", "id": "investigation.CBP-047-04.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/028_contracts_leases_source_export.csv to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-047-04.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_cash_management/040_cash_management_source_export.pdf.", "id": "investigation.CBP-047-04.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-047-04 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is the current observation does not meet the operative trigger.", "id": "decision.CBP-047-04.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-047-04 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-047-04.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-047-05 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/005_petition_schedules_source_export.json rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-047-05.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/017_proofs_of_claim_source_export.md for secured-status defect.", "id": "investigation.CBP-047-05.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/029_contracts_leases_source_export.json to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-047-05.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_financing/041_financing_source_export.md.", "id": "investigation.CBP-047-05.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-047-05 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective.", "id": "decision.CBP-047-05.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-047-05 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-047-05.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-047-06 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/006_petition_schedules_source_export.xml rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-047-06.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/018_proofs_of_claim_source_export.txt for critical-vendor overstatement.", "id": "investigation.CBP-047-06.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/030_contracts_leases_source_export.xml to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-047-06.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_financing/042_financing_source_export.txt.", "id": "investigation.CBP-047-06.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-047-06 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is the operational record relies on a superseded control revision.", "id": "decision.CBP-047-06.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-047-06 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-047-06.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-047-07 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/007_petition_schedules_source_export.html rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-047-07.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/019_proofs_of_claim_source_export.eml for cash-collateral reporting gap.", "id": "investigation.CBP-047-07.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/031_contracts_leases_source_export.html to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-047-07.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_financing/043_financing_source_export.eml.", "id": "investigation.CBP-047-07.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-047-07 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-047-07.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-047-07 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-047-07.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-047-08 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/008_petition_schedules_source_export.pdf rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-047-08.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/020_proofs_of_claim_source_export.csv for duplicate proof of claim.", "id": "investigation.CBP-047-08.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/032_contracts_leases_source_export.pdf to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-047-08.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_financing/044_financing_source_export.csv.", "id": "investigation.CBP-047-08.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-047-08 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is the current observation does not meet the operative trigger.", "id": "decision.CBP-047-08.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-047-08 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-047-08.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-047-09 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_claims_register/009_claims_register_source_export.md rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-047-09.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/021_proofs_of_claim_source_export.json for postpetition invoice.", "id": "investigation.CBP-047-09.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_cash_management/033_cash_management_source_export.md to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-047-09.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_financing/045_financing_source_export.json.", "id": "investigation.CBP-047-09.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-047-09 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-047-09.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-047-09 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-047-09.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-047-10 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_claims_register/010_claims_register_source_export.txt rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-047-10.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/022_proofs_of_claim_source_export.xml for DIP budget variance.", "id": "investigation.CBP-047-10.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_cash_management/034_cash_management_source_export.txt to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-047-10.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_financing/046_financing_source_export.xml.", "id": "investigation.CBP-047-10.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-047-10 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-047-10.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-047-10 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-047-10.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-047-11 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_claims_register/011_claims_register_source_export.eml rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-047-11.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/023_proofs_of_claim_source_export.html for scheduled-claim mismatch.", "id": "investigation.CBP-047-11.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_cash_management/035_cash_management_source_export.eml to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-047-11.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_financing/047_financing_source_export.html.", "id": "investigation.CBP-047-11.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-047-11 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-047-11.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-047-11 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-047-11.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-047-12 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_claims_register/012_claims_register_source_export.csv rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-047-12.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/024_proofs_of_claim_source_export.pdf for lease rejection deadline.", "id": "investigation.CBP-047-12.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_cash_management/036_cash_management_source_export.csv to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-047-12.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_financing/048_financing_source_export.pdf.", "id": "investigation.CBP-047-12.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-047-12 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-047-12.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-047-12 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-047-12.register"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Write the exact selected option, supported action population, evidence-hold population, facts, owners, deadlines, and citations.", "id": "state.exact_decision"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create one exact register row per portfolio key with no extra, missing, or modified row.", "id": "state.exact_register"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Leave only the three approved deliverables and perform no extra state-changing write.", "id": "state.write_scope_containment"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Read back decision.json, matter-register.json, and advice.md after their final writes.", "id": "state.postwrite_readback"}, {"category": "answer", "description": "Explain the selected recommendation, supported actions, holds, alternatives, and limitations with exact source anchors.", "id": "answer.decision_note"}], "decision_options": [{"approach": "Use a plausible summary or one source without completing the controlling joins.", "id": "greenway-transit:shortcut", "label": "Use scheduled amounts for voting and put every variance into one reserve."}, {"approach": "Treat supported actions and genuinely ambiguous records as if they were equally unresolved.", "id": "greenway-transit:blanket-hold", "label": "Freeze the entire matter population"}, {"approach": "Apply the exact identity, current-state, authority, and revision test. Create component-level voting and reserve rows with unresolved evidence holds.", "id": "greenway-transit:scoped-evidence", "label": "Set exact supported voting and reserve treatment by claim component."}], "evaluation_narrative": {"authority": "Classification and voting follow supported allowed amounts; reserves must reflect unresolved components.", "observation": "Join claim components, collateral, tax periods, rejection calculations, and budget variances.", "question": "How should Greenway set voting amounts and reserves after the lien, tax, rejection, and DIP review?", "register_action": "Create component-level voting and reserve rows with unresolved evidence holds."}, "gates": ["all_required_evidence_precedes_first_write", "decision_criteria_complete", "register_state_exact", "write_scope_contained", "all_outputs_verified_by_readback"], "metadata_checks": 8, "metric": "weighted_criteria_score", "minimum_tool_calls": 83, "required_deliverables": ["decision.json", "matter-register.json", "advice.md"], "required_document_reads": 61, "type": "deterministic", "weights": {"advice": 0.15, "decision": 0.35, "investigation": 0.25, "state": 0.25}}, "task_id": "cb100-047-greenway-transit", "task_name": "Greenway Transit plan claim review", "world_id": "counselbench-filesystem-mcp-v3"}
+{"context_files": ["task_files/cb100-048-harvest-paper/01_petition_schedules/001_petition_schedules_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-048-harvest-paper/01_petition_schedules/002_petition_schedules_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-048-harvest-paper/01_petition_schedules/003_petition_schedules_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-048-harvest-paper/01_petition_schedules/004_petition_schedules_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-048-harvest-paper/01_petition_schedules/005_petition_schedules_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-048-harvest-paper/01_petition_schedules/006_petition_schedules_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-048-harvest-paper/01_petition_schedules/007_petition_schedules_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-048-harvest-paper/01_petition_schedules/008_petition_schedules_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-048-harvest-paper/02_claims_register/009_claims_register_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-048-harvest-paper/02_claims_register/010_claims_register_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-048-harvest-paper/02_claims_register/011_claims_register_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-048-harvest-paper/02_claims_register/012_claims_register_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-048-harvest-paper/02_claims_register/013_claims_register_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-048-harvest-paper/02_claims_register/014_claims_register_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-048-harvest-paper/02_claims_register/015_claims_register_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-048-harvest-paper/02_claims_register/016_claims_register_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-048-harvest-paper/03_proofs_of_claim/017_proofs_of_claim_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-048-harvest-paper/03_proofs_of_claim/018_proofs_of_claim_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-048-harvest-paper/03_proofs_of_claim/019_proofs_of_claim_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-048-harvest-paper/03_proofs_of_claim/020_proofs_of_claim_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-048-harvest-paper/03_proofs_of_claim/021_proofs_of_claim_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-048-harvest-paper/03_proofs_of_claim/022_proofs_of_claim_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-048-harvest-paper/03_proofs_of_claim/023_proofs_of_claim_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-048-harvest-paper/03_proofs_of_claim/024_proofs_of_claim_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-048-harvest-paper/04_contracts_leases/025_contracts_leases_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-048-harvest-paper/04_contracts_leases/026_contracts_leases_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-048-harvest-paper/04_contracts_leases/027_contracts_leases_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-048-harvest-paper/04_contracts_leases/028_contracts_leases_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-048-harvest-paper/04_contracts_leases/029_contracts_leases_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-048-harvest-paper/04_contracts_leases/030_contracts_leases_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-048-harvest-paper/04_contracts_leases/031_contracts_leases_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-048-harvest-paper/04_contracts_leases/032_contracts_leases_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-048-harvest-paper/05_cash_management/033_cash_management_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-048-harvest-paper/05_cash_management/034_cash_management_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-048-harvest-paper/05_cash_management/035_cash_management_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-048-harvest-paper/05_cash_management/036_cash_management_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-048-harvest-paper/05_cash_management/037_cash_management_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-048-harvest-paper/05_cash_management/038_cash_management_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-048-harvest-paper/05_cash_management/039_cash_management_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-048-harvest-paper/05_cash_management/040_cash_management_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-048-harvest-paper/06_financing/041_financing_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-048-harvest-paper/06_financing/042_financing_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-048-harvest-paper/06_financing/043_financing_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-048-harvest-paper/06_financing/044_financing_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-048-harvest-paper/06_financing/045_financing_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-048-harvest-paper/06_financing/046_financing_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-048-harvest-paper/06_financing/047_financing_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-048-harvest-paper/06_financing/048_financing_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-048-harvest-paper/07_critical_vendors/049_critical_vendors_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-048-harvest-paper/07_critical_vendors/050_critical_vendors_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-048-harvest-paper/07_critical_vendors/051_critical_vendors_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-048-harvest-paper/07_critical_vendors/052_critical_vendors_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-048-harvest-paper/07_critical_vendors/053_critical_vendors_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-048-harvest-paper/07_critical_vendors/054_critical_vendors_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-048-harvest-paper/07_critical_vendors/055_critical_vendors_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-048-harvest-paper/07_critical_vendors/056_critical_vendors_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-048-harvest-paper/08_tax/057_tax_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-048-harvest-paper/08_tax/058_tax_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-048-harvest-paper/08_tax/059_tax_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-048-harvest-paper/08_tax/060_tax_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-048-harvest-paper/08_tax/061_tax_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-048-harvest-paper/08_tax/062_tax_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-048-harvest-paper/08_tax/063_tax_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-048-harvest-paper/08_tax/064_tax_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-048-harvest-paper/09_litigation/065_litigation_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-048-harvest-paper/09_litigation/066_litigation_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-048-harvest-paper/09_litigation/067_litigation_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-048-harvest-paper/09_litigation/068_litigation_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-048-harvest-paper/09_litigation/069_litigation_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-048-harvest-paper/09_litigation/070_litigation_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-048-harvest-paper/09_litigation/071_litigation_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-048-harvest-paper/09_litigation/072_litigation_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-048-harvest-paper/10_plan_disclosure/073_plan_disclosure_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-048-harvest-paper/10_plan_disclosure/074_plan_disclosure_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-048-harvest-paper/10_plan_disclosure/075_plan_disclosure_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-048-harvest-paper/10_plan_disclosure/076_plan_disclosure_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-048-harvest-paper/10_plan_disclosure/077_plan_disclosure_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-048-harvest-paper/10_plan_disclosure/078_plan_disclosure_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-048-harvest-paper/10_plan_disclosure/079_plan_disclosure_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-048-harvest-paper/10_plan_disclosure/080_plan_disclosure_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-048-harvest-paper/11_notices_ballots/081_notices_ballots_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-048-harvest-paper/11_notices_ballots/082_notices_ballots_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-048-harvest-paper/11_notices_ballots/083_notices_ballots_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-048-harvest-paper/11_notices_ballots/084_notices_ballots_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-048-harvest-paper/11_notices_ballots/085_notices_ballots_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-048-harvest-paper/11_notices_ballots/086_notices_ballots_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-048-harvest-paper/11_notices_ballots/087_notices_ballots_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-048-harvest-paper/11_notices_ballots/088_notices_ballots_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-048-harvest-paper/12_reconciliations/089_reconciliations_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-048-harvest-paper/12_reconciliations/090_reconciliations_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-048-harvest-paper/12_reconciliations/091_reconciliations_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-048-harvest-paper/12_reconciliations/092_reconciliations_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-048-harvest-paper/12_reconciliations/093_reconciliations_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-048-harvest-paper/12_reconciliations/094_reconciliations_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-048-harvest-paper/12_reconciliations/095_reconciliations_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-048-harvest-paper/12_reconciliations/096_reconciliations_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-048-harvest-paper/12_reconciliations/097_harvest_paper_impact_population.xlsx"], "gold_output": {"advice_markdown": "# Decision note — Harvest Paper mill restructuring audit\n\n## Recommendation\n\nApply supported cure and setoff amounts and repair defective notice populations. The reconciled record supports 9 scoped actions and leaves 3 items on evidence hold.\n\nSelected option: `harvest-paper:scoped-evidence`.\n\n## Why this is the supported option\n\nReconcile contract balances, asserted setoffs, energy and timber deliveries, and solicitation addresses. Assumption rules, enforceable setoff, and valid notice mechanics govern separately.\n\n## Supported actions\n\n### CBP-048-01 — reserve calculation error (medium)\n\nthe controlled population contains 81 records under CB-RS-2808-R969; the certification covers 54 records under CB-RS-2808-E680. Identity resolves to ENT-048-1000, revision REV-2026.1 is current, and Nora Chen is active with capacity 4.\n\nAction: Create contract and address-specific rows with separate evidentiary holds. Owner: Nora Chen; due 2026-09-28.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/001_petition_schedules_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/02_claims_register/013_claims_register_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/025_contracts_leases_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/05_cash_management/037_cash_management_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/07_critical_vendors/049_critical_vendors_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/097_harvest_paper_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-048-02 — executory-contract cure dispute (medium)\n\nthe permission is limited to District of Maine Bankruptcy Court under CB-RS-2808-R706; the matched activity occurred in Maine under CB-RS-2808-E612. Identity resolves to ENT-048-1001, revision REV-2026.2 is current, and Caleb Hassan is active with capacity 1.\n\nAction: Create contract and address-specific rows with separate evidentiary holds. Owner: Caleb Hassan; due 2026-09-27.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/002_petition_schedules_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/02_claims_register/014_claims_register_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/026_contracts_leases_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/05_cash_management/038_cash_management_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/11_notices_ballots/086_notices_ballots_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/07_critical_vendors/050_critical_vendors_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/097_harvest_paper_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-048-03 — guaranty overlap (medium)\n\nthe operative cap is $1,282,000.00 under CB-RS-2808-R141; the matched ledger population totals $1,531,441.00 under CB-RS-2808-E631. Identity resolves to ENT-048-1002, revision REV-2026.3 is current, and Amara Patel is active with capacity 3.\n\nAction: Create contract and address-specific rows with separate evidentiary holds. Owner: Amara Patel; due 2026-09-26.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/003_petition_schedules_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/02_claims_register/015_claims_register_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/027_contracts_leases_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/05_cash_management/039_cash_management_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/11_notices_ballots/087_notices_ballots_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/07_critical_vendors/051_critical_vendors_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/097_harvest_paper_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-048-04 — notice-address defect (high)\n\ndelivery must use notices-harvest_paper_mills_llc@example.test under CB-RS-2808-R811; the only matched receipt used archive-timber_run_energy_cooperative@example.test under CB-RS-2808-E512. Identity resolves to ENT-048-1003, revision REV-2026.4 is current, and Samuel Kim is active with capacity 5.\n\nAction: Create contract and address-specific rows with separate evidentiary holds. Owner: Samuel Kim; due 2026-09-25.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/004_petition_schedules_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/02_claims_register/016_claims_register_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/028_contracts_leases_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/05_cash_management/040_cash_management_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/11_notices_ballots/088_notices_ballots_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/08_tax/064_tax_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/097_harvest_paper_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-048-05 — priority classification error (critical)\n\nan open exception blocks completion under CB-RS-2808-R233; the current status is open and unresolved under CB-RS-2808-E584. Identity resolves to ENT-048-1004, revision REV-2026.5 is current, and Talia Brooks is active with capacity 2.\n\nAction: Create contract and address-specific rows with separate evidentiary holds. Owner: Talia Brooks; due 2026-09-24.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/005_petition_schedules_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/017_proofs_of_claim_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/029_contracts_leases_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/06_financing/041_financing_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/07_critical_vendors/053_critical_vendors_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/097_harvest_paper_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-048-06 — setoff assertion (low)\n\ncompletion is required by 2025-01-21 under CB-RS-2808-R595; the current event record shows completion on 2025-03-06 under CB-RS-2808-E552. Identity resolves to ENT-048-1005, revision REV-2026.6 is current, and Adrian Mensah is active with capacity 1.\n\nAction: Create contract and address-specific rows with separate evidentiary holds. Owner: Adrian Mensah; due 2026-09-23.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/006_petition_schedules_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/018_proofs_of_claim_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/030_contracts_leases_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/06_financing/042_financing_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/097_harvest_paper_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-048-07 — ballot amount discrepancy (low)\n\nthe controlling threshold is 15% under CB-RS-2808-R272; the independently calculated result is 22% under CB-RS-2808-E904. Identity resolves to ENT-048-1006, revision REV-2026.7 is current, and Farah Ibrahim is active with capacity 1.\n\nAction: Create contract and address-specific rows with separate evidentiary holds. Owner: Farah Ibrahim; due 2026-09-22.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/007_petition_schedules_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/019_proofs_of_claim_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/031_contracts_leases_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/06_financing/043_financing_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/09_litigation/067_litigation_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/07_critical_vendors/055_critical_vendors_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/097_harvest_paper_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-048-09 — critical-vendor overstatement (high)\n\nthe controlled population contains 157 records under CB-RS-2808-R705; the certification covers 142 records under CB-RS-2808-E665. Identity resolves to ENT-048-1008, revision REV-2026.2 is current, and Leona Park is active with capacity 6.\n\nAction: Create contract and address-specific rows with separate evidentiary holds. Owner: Leona Park; due 2026-09-20.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/02_claims_register/009_claims_register_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/021_proofs_of_claim_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/05_cash_management/033_cash_management_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/06_financing/045_financing_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/093_reconciliations_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/09_litigation/069_litigation_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/097_harvest_paper_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-048-12 — postpetition invoice (medium)\n\ndelivery must use notices-harvest_paper_mills_llc@example.test under CB-RS-2808-R424; the only matched receipt used archive-timber_run_energy_cooperative@example.test under CB-RS-2808-E383. Identity resolves to ENT-048-1011, revision REV-2026.5 is current, and Jonas Feld is active with capacity 6.\n\nAction: Create contract and address-specific rows with separate evidentiary holds. Owner: Jonas Feld; due 2026-09-26.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/02_claims_register/012_claims_register_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/024_proofs_of_claim_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/05_cash_management/036_cash_management_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/06_financing/048_financing_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/097_harvest_paper_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n## Evidence holds\n\n- **CBP-048-08 — secured-status defect**: the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective. Next evidence: effective approval and an active owner with remaining capacity. Sources: `/workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/008_petition_schedules_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/020_proofs_of_claim_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/032_contracts_leases_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/06_financing/044_financing_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/10_plan_disclosure/080_plan_disclosure_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/092_reconciliations_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/097_harvest_paper_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-048-10 — cash-collateral reporting gap**: two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key. Next evidence: an approved immutable entity crosswalk. Sources: `/workspace/documents/02_claims_register/010_claims_register_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/022_proofs_of_claim_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/05_cash_management/034_cash_management_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/06_financing/046_financing_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/097_harvest_paper_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-048-11 — duplicate proof of claim**: the current observation does not meet the operative trigger. Next evidence: a current observation that satisfies the operative trigger. Sources: `/workspace/documents/02_claims_register/011_claims_register_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/023_proofs_of_claim_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/05_cash_management/035_cash_management_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/06_financing/047_financing_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/097_harvest_paper_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n## Alternatives considered\n\n- `harvest-paper:blanket-hold` — Freeze the entire matter population: Treat supported actions and genuinely ambiguous records as if they were equally unresolved.\n- `harvest-paper:shortcut` — Net every asserted setoff and assume solicitation reached all claimants.: Use a plausible summary or one source without completing the controlling joins.\n\n## Assumptions and limits\n\nThis decision is limited to cb100-048-harvest-paper, the supplied synthetic records, and the matter state as of 2026-09-29. Similar names, stale revisions, and pending authority are not treated as proof.\n", "decision": {"actions": [{"determination": "the controlled population contains 81 records under CB-RS-2808-R969; the certification covers 54 records under CB-RS-2808-E680. Identity resolves to ENT-048-1000, revision REV-2026.1 is current, and Nora Chen is active with capacity 4.", "due_date": "2026-09-28", "id": "ACT-CBP-048-01", "identity_id": "ENT-048-1000", "issue": "reserve calculation error", "owner": "Nora Chen", "portfolio_key": "CBP-048-01", "recommended_action": "Create contract and address-specific rows with separate evidentiary holds. Owner: Nora Chen; due 2026-09-28.", "severity": "medium", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/001_petition_schedules_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/02_claims_register/013_claims_register_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/025_contracts_leases_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/05_cash_management/037_cash_management_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/07_critical_vendors/049_critical_vendors_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/097_harvest_paper_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "the permission is limited to District of Maine Bankruptcy Court under CB-RS-2808-R706; the matched activity occurred in Maine under CB-RS-2808-E612. Identity resolves to ENT-048-1001, revision REV-2026.2 is current, and Caleb Hassan is active with capacity 1.", "due_date": "2026-09-27", "id": "ACT-CBP-048-02", "identity_id": "ENT-048-1001", "issue": "executory-contract cure dispute", "owner": "Caleb Hassan", "portfolio_key": "CBP-048-02", "recommended_action": "Create contract and address-specific rows with separate evidentiary holds. Owner: Caleb Hassan; due 2026-09-27.", "severity": "medium", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/002_petition_schedules_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/02_claims_register/014_claims_register_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/026_contracts_leases_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/05_cash_management/038_cash_management_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/11_notices_ballots/086_notices_ballots_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/07_critical_vendors/050_critical_vendors_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/097_harvest_paper_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "the operative cap is $1,282,000.00 under CB-RS-2808-R141; the matched ledger population totals $1,531,441.00 under CB-RS-2808-E631. Identity resolves to ENT-048-1002, revision REV-2026.3 is current, and Amara Patel is active with capacity 3.", "due_date": "2026-09-26", "id": "ACT-CBP-048-03", "identity_id": "ENT-048-1002", "issue": "guaranty overlap", "owner": "Amara Patel", "portfolio_key": "CBP-048-03", "recommended_action": "Create contract and address-specific rows with separate evidentiary holds. Owner: Amara Patel; due 2026-09-26.", "severity": "medium", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/003_petition_schedules_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/02_claims_register/015_claims_register_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/027_contracts_leases_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/05_cash_management/039_cash_management_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/11_notices_ballots/087_notices_ballots_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/07_critical_vendors/051_critical_vendors_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/097_harvest_paper_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "delivery must use notices-harvest_paper_mills_llc@example.test under CB-RS-2808-R811; the only matched receipt used archive-timber_run_energy_cooperative@example.test under CB-RS-2808-E512. Identity resolves to ENT-048-1003, revision REV-2026.4 is current, and Samuel Kim is active with capacity 5.", "due_date": "2026-09-25", "id": "ACT-CBP-048-04", "identity_id": "ENT-048-1003", "issue": "notice-address defect", "owner": "Samuel Kim", "portfolio_key": "CBP-048-04", "recommended_action": "Create contract and address-specific rows with separate evidentiary holds. Owner: Samuel Kim; due 2026-09-25.", "severity": "high", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/004_petition_schedules_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/02_claims_register/016_claims_register_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/028_contracts_leases_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/05_cash_management/040_cash_management_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/11_notices_ballots/088_notices_ballots_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/08_tax/064_tax_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/097_harvest_paper_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "an open exception blocks completion under CB-RS-2808-R233; the current status is open and unresolved under CB-RS-2808-E584. Identity resolves to ENT-048-1004, revision REV-2026.5 is current, and Talia Brooks is active with capacity 2.", "due_date": "2026-09-24", "id": "ACT-CBP-048-05", "identity_id": "ENT-048-1004", "issue": "priority classification error", "owner": "Talia Brooks", "portfolio_key": "CBP-048-05", "recommended_action": "Create contract and address-specific rows with separate evidentiary holds. Owner: Talia Brooks; due 2026-09-24.", "severity": "critical", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/005_petition_schedules_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/017_proofs_of_claim_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/029_contracts_leases_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/06_financing/041_financing_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/07_critical_vendors/053_critical_vendors_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/097_harvest_paper_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "completion is required by 2025-01-21 under CB-RS-2808-R595; the current event record shows completion on 2025-03-06 under CB-RS-2808-E552. Identity resolves to ENT-048-1005, revision REV-2026.6 is current, and Adrian Mensah is active with capacity 1.", "due_date": "2026-09-23", "id": "ACT-CBP-048-06", "identity_id": "ENT-048-1005", "issue": "setoff assertion", "owner": "Adrian Mensah", "portfolio_key": "CBP-048-06", "recommended_action": "Create contract and address-specific rows with separate evidentiary holds. Owner: Adrian Mensah; due 2026-09-23.", "severity": "low", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/006_petition_schedules_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/018_proofs_of_claim_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/030_contracts_leases_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/06_financing/042_financing_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/097_harvest_paper_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "the controlling threshold is 15% under CB-RS-2808-R272; the independently calculated result is 22% under CB-RS-2808-E904. Identity resolves to ENT-048-1006, revision REV-2026.7 is current, and Farah Ibrahim is active with capacity 1.", "due_date": "2026-09-22", "id": "ACT-CBP-048-07", "identity_id": "ENT-048-1006", "issue": "ballot amount discrepancy", "owner": "Farah Ibrahim", "portfolio_key": "CBP-048-07", "recommended_action": "Create contract and address-specific rows with separate evidentiary holds. Owner: Farah Ibrahim; due 2026-09-22.", "severity": "low", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/007_petition_schedules_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/019_proofs_of_claim_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/031_contracts_leases_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/06_financing/043_financing_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/09_litigation/067_litigation_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/07_critical_vendors/055_critical_vendors_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/097_harvest_paper_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "the controlled population contains 157 records under CB-RS-2808-R705; the certification covers 142 records under CB-RS-2808-E665. Identity resolves to ENT-048-1008, revision REV-2026.2 is current, and Leona Park is active with capacity 6.", "due_date": "2026-09-20", "id": "ACT-CBP-048-09", "identity_id": "ENT-048-1008", "issue": "critical-vendor overstatement", "owner": "Leona Park", "portfolio_key": "CBP-048-09", "recommended_action": "Create contract and address-specific rows with separate evidentiary holds. Owner: Leona Park; due 2026-09-20.", "severity": "high", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_claims_register/009_claims_register_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/021_proofs_of_claim_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/05_cash_management/033_cash_management_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/06_financing/045_financing_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/093_reconciliations_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/09_litigation/069_litigation_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/097_harvest_paper_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "delivery must use notices-harvest_paper_mills_llc@example.test under CB-RS-2808-R424; the only matched receipt used archive-timber_run_energy_cooperative@example.test under CB-RS-2808-E383. Identity resolves to ENT-048-1011, revision REV-2026.5 is current, and Jonas Feld is active with capacity 6.", "due_date": "2026-09-26", "id": "ACT-CBP-048-12", "identity_id": "ENT-048-1011", "issue": "postpetition invoice", "owner": "Jonas Feld", "portfolio_key": "CBP-048-12", "recommended_action": "Create contract and address-specific rows with separate evidentiary holds. Owner: Jonas Feld; due 2026-09-26.", "severity": "medium", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_claims_register/012_claims_register_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/024_proofs_of_claim_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/05_cash_management/036_cash_management_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/06_financing/048_financing_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/097_harvest_paper_impact_population.xlsx"]}], "as_of": "2026-09-29", "decision": {"alternatives_considered": ["harvest-paper:blanket-hold", "harvest-paper:shortcut"], "question": "What cure, setoff, and notice treatment should Harvest use for the mill contracts?", "rationale": "The four-part causal test supports 9 scoped actions and leaves 3 records on evidence hold. Assumption rules, enforceable setoff, and valid notice mechanics govern separately.", "recommendation": "Apply supported cure and setoff amounts and repair defective notice populations.", "selected_option_id": "harvest-paper:scoped-evidence"}, "holds": [{"id": "HOLD-CBP-048-08", "issue": "secured-status defect", "portfolio_key": "CBP-048-08", "reason": "the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective", "required_next_evidence": "effective approval and an active owner with remaining capacity", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/008_petition_schedules_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/020_proofs_of_claim_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/032_contracts_leases_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/06_financing/044_financing_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/10_plan_disclosure/080_plan_disclosure_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/092_reconciliations_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/097_harvest_paper_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-048-10", "issue": "cash-collateral reporting gap", "portfolio_key": "CBP-048-10", "reason": "two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key", "required_next_evidence": "an approved immutable entity crosswalk", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_claims_register/010_claims_register_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/022_proofs_of_claim_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/05_cash_management/034_cash_management_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/06_financing/046_financing_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/097_harvest_paper_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-048-11", "issue": "duplicate proof of claim", "portfolio_key": "CBP-048-11", "reason": "the current observation does not meet the operative trigger", "required_next_evidence": "a current observation that satisfies the operative trigger", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_claims_register/011_claims_register_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/023_proofs_of_claim_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/05_cash_management/035_cash_management_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/06_financing/047_financing_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/097_harvest_paper_impact_population.xlsx"]}], "matter_number": "CB-RS-2808", "prepared_for": "Harvest Paper Mills LLC", "schema_version": "counselbench.decision.v3", "task_id": "cb100-048-harvest-paper"}, "matter_register": {"matter_number": "CB-RS-2808", "rows": [{"decision_option_id": "harvest-paper:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-28", "issue": "reserve calculation error", "matter_number": "CB-RS-2808", "owner": "Nora Chen", "portfolio_key": "CBP-048-01", "row_id": "REG-CBP-048-01", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/001_petition_schedules_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/02_claims_register/013_claims_register_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/025_contracts_leases_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/05_cash_management/037_cash_management_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/07_critical_vendors/049_critical_vendors_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/097_harvest_paper_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "harvest-paper:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-27", "issue": "executory-contract cure dispute", "matter_number": "CB-RS-2808", "owner": "Caleb Hassan", "portfolio_key": "CBP-048-02", "row_id": "REG-CBP-048-02", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/002_petition_schedules_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/02_claims_register/014_claims_register_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/026_contracts_leases_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/05_cash_management/038_cash_management_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/11_notices_ballots/086_notices_ballots_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/07_critical_vendors/050_critical_vendors_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/097_harvest_paper_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "harvest-paper:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-26", "issue": "guaranty overlap", "matter_number": "CB-RS-2808", "owner": "Amara Patel", "portfolio_key": "CBP-048-03", "row_id": "REG-CBP-048-03", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/003_petition_schedules_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/02_claims_register/015_claims_register_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/027_contracts_leases_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/05_cash_management/039_cash_management_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/11_notices_ballots/087_notices_ballots_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/07_critical_vendors/051_critical_vendors_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/097_harvest_paper_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "harvest-paper:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-25", "issue": "notice-address defect", "matter_number": "CB-RS-2808", "owner": "Samuel Kim", "portfolio_key": "CBP-048-04", "row_id": "REG-CBP-048-04", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/004_petition_schedules_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/02_claims_register/016_claims_register_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/028_contracts_leases_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/05_cash_management/040_cash_management_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/11_notices_ballots/088_notices_ballots_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/08_tax/064_tax_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/097_harvest_paper_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "harvest-paper:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-24", "issue": "priority classification error", "matter_number": "CB-RS-2808", "owner": "Talia Brooks", "portfolio_key": "CBP-048-05", "row_id": "REG-CBP-048-05", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/005_petition_schedules_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/017_proofs_of_claim_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/029_contracts_leases_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/06_financing/041_financing_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/07_critical_vendors/053_critical_vendors_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/097_harvest_paper_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "harvest-paper:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-23", "issue": "setoff assertion", "matter_number": "CB-RS-2808", "owner": "Adrian Mensah", "portfolio_key": "CBP-048-06", "row_id": "REG-CBP-048-06", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/006_petition_schedules_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/018_proofs_of_claim_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/030_contracts_leases_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/06_financing/042_financing_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/097_harvest_paper_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "harvest-paper:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-22", "issue": "ballot amount discrepancy", "matter_number": "CB-RS-2808", "owner": "Farah Ibrahim", "portfolio_key": "CBP-048-07", "row_id": "REG-CBP-048-07", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/007_petition_schedules_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/019_proofs_of_claim_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/031_contracts_leases_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/06_financing/043_financing_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/09_litigation/067_litigation_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/07_critical_vendors/055_critical_vendors_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/097_harvest_paper_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "harvest-paper:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective", "issue": "secured-status defect", "matter_number": "CB-RS-2808", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-048-08", "row_id": "REG-CBP-048-08", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/008_petition_schedules_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/020_proofs_of_claim_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/032_contracts_leases_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/06_financing/044_financing_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/10_plan_disclosure/080_plan_disclosure_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/092_reconciliations_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/097_harvest_paper_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "harvest-paper:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-20", "issue": "critical-vendor overstatement", "matter_number": "CB-RS-2808", "owner": "Leona Park", "portfolio_key": "CBP-048-09", "row_id": "REG-CBP-048-09", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_claims_register/009_claims_register_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/021_proofs_of_claim_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/05_cash_management/033_cash_management_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/06_financing/045_financing_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/093_reconciliations_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/09_litigation/069_litigation_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/097_harvest_paper_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "harvest-paper:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key", "issue": "cash-collateral reporting gap", "matter_number": "CB-RS-2808", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-048-10", "row_id": "REG-CBP-048-10", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_claims_register/010_claims_register_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/022_proofs_of_claim_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/05_cash_management/034_cash_management_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/06_financing/046_financing_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/097_harvest_paper_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "harvest-paper:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "the current observation does not meet the operative trigger", "issue": "duplicate proof of claim", "matter_number": "CB-RS-2808", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-048-11", "row_id": "REG-CBP-048-11", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_claims_register/011_claims_register_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/023_proofs_of_claim_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/05_cash_management/035_cash_management_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/06_financing/047_financing_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/097_harvest_paper_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "harvest-paper:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-26", "issue": "postpetition invoice", "matter_number": "CB-RS-2808", "owner": "Jonas Feld", "portfolio_key": "CBP-048-12", "row_id": "REG-CBP-048-12", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_claims_register/012_claims_register_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/024_proofs_of_claim_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/05_cash_management/036_cash_management_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/06_financing/048_financing_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/097_harvest_paper_impact_population.xlsx"]}], "schema_version": "counselbench.matter-register.v3", "task_id": "cb100-048-harvest-paper"}}, "metadata": {"benchmark": "CounselBench-100", "code_license": "Apache-2.0", "data_license": "CC-BY-4.0", "deadline": "2026-09-29", "document_count": 97, "evidence_holds": 3, "jurisdiction": "Maine", "matter_number": "CB-RS-2808", "mcp_commit": "9a96ea6e5913736f92b88345bf51caeaaa8e719f", "mcp_package": "@modelcontextprotocol/server-filesystem@2026.7.10", "practice_area": "restructuring", "reference_tool_calls": 90, "required_evidence_reads": 64, "supported_actions": 9, "synthetic": true, "venue": "District of Maine Bankruptcy Court", "version": "3.1.0"}, "prompt": "There is enough noise in this file that a name match or newest-document shortcut will be dangerous. What cure, setoff, and notice treatment should Harvest use for the mill contracts? Energy and timber contracts have contested cure amounts, setoff claims, and address defects in solicitation records. The team needs the call by 2026-09-29. Leave the defensible result in the matter workspace, including any item that must stay on hold for better evidence.", "rubric": {"criteria": [{"category": "investigation", "description": "Inventory the production and use targeted searches to locate records across native formats.", "id": "investigation.discover_production"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Complete every task-specific identity, authority, operations, and approval read before the first state transition.", "id": "investigation.read_before_write"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Inspect designated source metadata before relying on those records.", "id": "investigation.custody_before_write"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "Select the supported option 'harvest-paper:scoped-evidence' after applying the four-part test.", "id": "decision.selected_option"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "Identify both rejected approaches and explain why a one-source shortcut and a blanket hold are wrong.", "id": "decision.alternatives"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-048-01 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/001_petition_schedules_source_export.md rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-048-01.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_claims_register/013_claims_register_source_export.json for reserve calculation error.", "id": "investigation.CBP-048-01.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/025_contracts_leases_source_export.md to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-048-01.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_cash_management/037_cash_management_source_export.json.", "id": "investigation.CBP-048-01.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-048-01 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-048-01.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-048-01 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-048-01.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-048-02 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/002_petition_schedules_source_export.txt rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-048-02.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_claims_register/014_claims_register_source_export.xml for executory-contract cure dispute.", "id": "investigation.CBP-048-02.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/026_contracts_leases_source_export.txt to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-048-02.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_cash_management/038_cash_management_source_export.xml.", "id": "investigation.CBP-048-02.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-048-02 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-048-02.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-048-02 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-048-02.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-048-03 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/003_petition_schedules_source_export.eml rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-048-03.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_claims_register/015_claims_register_source_export.html for guaranty overlap.", "id": "investigation.CBP-048-03.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/027_contracts_leases_source_export.eml to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-048-03.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_cash_management/039_cash_management_source_export.html.", "id": "investigation.CBP-048-03.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-048-03 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-048-03.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-048-03 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-048-03.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-048-04 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/004_petition_schedules_source_export.csv rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-048-04.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_claims_register/016_claims_register_source_export.pdf for notice-address defect.", "id": "investigation.CBP-048-04.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/028_contracts_leases_source_export.csv to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-048-04.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_cash_management/040_cash_management_source_export.pdf.", "id": "investigation.CBP-048-04.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-048-04 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-048-04.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-048-04 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-048-04.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-048-05 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/005_petition_schedules_source_export.json rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-048-05.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/017_proofs_of_claim_source_export.md for priority classification error.", "id": "investigation.CBP-048-05.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/029_contracts_leases_source_export.json to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-048-05.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_financing/041_financing_source_export.md.", "id": "investigation.CBP-048-05.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-048-05 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-048-05.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-048-05 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-048-05.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-048-06 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/006_petition_schedules_source_export.xml rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-048-06.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/018_proofs_of_claim_source_export.txt for setoff assertion.", "id": "investigation.CBP-048-06.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/030_contracts_leases_source_export.xml to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-048-06.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_financing/042_financing_source_export.txt.", "id": "investigation.CBP-048-06.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-048-06 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-048-06.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-048-06 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-048-06.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-048-07 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/007_petition_schedules_source_export.html rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-048-07.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/019_proofs_of_claim_source_export.eml for ballot amount discrepancy.", "id": "investigation.CBP-048-07.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/031_contracts_leases_source_export.html to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-048-07.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_financing/043_financing_source_export.eml.", "id": "investigation.CBP-048-07.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-048-07 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-048-07.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-048-07 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-048-07.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-048-08 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/008_petition_schedules_source_export.pdf rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-048-08.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/020_proofs_of_claim_source_export.csv for secured-status defect.", "id": "investigation.CBP-048-08.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/032_contracts_leases_source_export.pdf to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-048-08.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_financing/044_financing_source_export.csv.", "id": "investigation.CBP-048-08.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-048-08 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective.", "id": "decision.CBP-048-08.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-048-08 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-048-08.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-048-09 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_claims_register/009_claims_register_source_export.md rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-048-09.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/021_proofs_of_claim_source_export.json for critical-vendor overstatement.", "id": "investigation.CBP-048-09.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_cash_management/033_cash_management_source_export.md to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-048-09.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_financing/045_financing_source_export.json.", "id": "investigation.CBP-048-09.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-048-09 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-048-09.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-048-09 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-048-09.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-048-10 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_claims_register/010_claims_register_source_export.txt rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-048-10.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/022_proofs_of_claim_source_export.xml for cash-collateral reporting gap.", "id": "investigation.CBP-048-10.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_cash_management/034_cash_management_source_export.txt to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-048-10.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_financing/046_financing_source_export.xml.", "id": "investigation.CBP-048-10.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-048-10 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key.", "id": "decision.CBP-048-10.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-048-10 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-048-10.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-048-11 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_claims_register/011_claims_register_source_export.eml rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-048-11.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/023_proofs_of_claim_source_export.html for duplicate proof of claim.", "id": "investigation.CBP-048-11.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_cash_management/035_cash_management_source_export.eml to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-048-11.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_financing/047_financing_source_export.html.", "id": "investigation.CBP-048-11.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-048-11 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is the current observation does not meet the operative trigger.", "id": "decision.CBP-048-11.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-048-11 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-048-11.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-048-12 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_claims_register/012_claims_register_source_export.csv rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-048-12.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/024_proofs_of_claim_source_export.pdf for postpetition invoice.", "id": "investigation.CBP-048-12.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_cash_management/036_cash_management_source_export.csv to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-048-12.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_financing/048_financing_source_export.pdf.", "id": "investigation.CBP-048-12.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-048-12 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-048-12.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-048-12 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-048-12.register"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Write the exact selected option, supported action population, evidence-hold population, facts, owners, deadlines, and citations.", "id": "state.exact_decision"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create one exact register row per portfolio key with no extra, missing, or modified row.", "id": "state.exact_register"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Leave only the three approved deliverables and perform no extra state-changing write.", "id": "state.write_scope_containment"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Read back decision.json, matter-register.json, and advice.md after their final writes.", "id": "state.postwrite_readback"}, {"category": "answer", "description": "Explain the selected recommendation, supported actions, holds, alternatives, and limitations with exact source anchors.", "id": "answer.decision_note"}], "decision_options": [{"approach": "Treat supported actions and genuinely ambiguous records as if they were equally unresolved.", "id": "harvest-paper:blanket-hold", "label": "Freeze the entire matter population"}, {"approach": "Apply the exact identity, current-state, authority, and revision test. Create contract and address-specific rows with separate evidentiary holds.", "id": "harvest-paper:scoped-evidence", "label": "Apply supported cure and setoff amounts and repair defective notice populations."}, {"approach": "Use a plausible summary or one source without completing the controlling joins.", "id": "harvest-paper:shortcut", "label": "Net every asserted setoff and assume solicitation reached all claimants."}], "evaluation_narrative": {"authority": "Assumption rules, enforceable setoff, and valid notice mechanics govern separately.", "observation": "Reconcile contract balances, asserted setoffs, energy and timber deliveries, and solicitation addresses.", "question": "What cure, setoff, and notice treatment should Harvest use for the mill contracts?", "register_action": "Create contract and address-specific rows with separate evidentiary holds."}, "gates": ["all_required_evidence_precedes_first_write", "decision_criteria_complete", "register_state_exact", "write_scope_contained", "all_outputs_verified_by_readback"], "metadata_checks": 11, "metric": "weighted_criteria_score", "minimum_tool_calls": 90, "required_deliverables": ["decision.json", "matter-register.json", "advice.md"], "required_document_reads": 64, "type": "deterministic", "weights": {"advice": 0.15, "decision": 0.35, "investigation": 0.25, "state": 0.25}}, "task_id": "cb100-048-harvest-paper", "task_name": "Harvest Paper mill restructuring audit", "world_id": "counselbench-filesystem-mcp-v3"}
+{"context_files": ["task_files/cb100-049-inlet-fitness/01_petition_schedules/001_petition_schedules_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-049-inlet-fitness/01_petition_schedules/002_petition_schedules_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-049-inlet-fitness/01_petition_schedules/003_petition_schedules_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-049-inlet-fitness/01_petition_schedules/004_petition_schedules_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-049-inlet-fitness/01_petition_schedules/005_petition_schedules_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-049-inlet-fitness/01_petition_schedules/006_petition_schedules_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-049-inlet-fitness/01_petition_schedules/007_petition_schedules_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-049-inlet-fitness/01_petition_schedules/008_petition_schedules_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-049-inlet-fitness/02_claims_register/009_claims_register_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-049-inlet-fitness/02_claims_register/010_claims_register_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-049-inlet-fitness/02_claims_register/011_claims_register_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-049-inlet-fitness/02_claims_register/012_claims_register_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-049-inlet-fitness/02_claims_register/013_claims_register_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-049-inlet-fitness/02_claims_register/014_claims_register_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-049-inlet-fitness/02_claims_register/015_claims_register_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-049-inlet-fitness/02_claims_register/016_claims_register_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-049-inlet-fitness/03_proofs_of_claim/017_proofs_of_claim_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-049-inlet-fitness/03_proofs_of_claim/018_proofs_of_claim_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-049-inlet-fitness/03_proofs_of_claim/019_proofs_of_claim_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-049-inlet-fitness/03_proofs_of_claim/020_proofs_of_claim_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-049-inlet-fitness/03_proofs_of_claim/021_proofs_of_claim_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-049-inlet-fitness/03_proofs_of_claim/022_proofs_of_claim_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-049-inlet-fitness/03_proofs_of_claim/023_proofs_of_claim_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-049-inlet-fitness/03_proofs_of_claim/024_proofs_of_claim_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-049-inlet-fitness/04_contracts_leases/025_contracts_leases_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-049-inlet-fitness/04_contracts_leases/026_contracts_leases_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-049-inlet-fitness/04_contracts_leases/027_contracts_leases_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-049-inlet-fitness/04_contracts_leases/028_contracts_leases_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-049-inlet-fitness/04_contracts_leases/029_contracts_leases_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-049-inlet-fitness/04_contracts_leases/030_contracts_leases_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-049-inlet-fitness/04_contracts_leases/031_contracts_leases_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-049-inlet-fitness/04_contracts_leases/032_contracts_leases_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-049-inlet-fitness/05_cash_management/033_cash_management_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-049-inlet-fitness/05_cash_management/034_cash_management_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-049-inlet-fitness/05_cash_management/035_cash_management_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-049-inlet-fitness/05_cash_management/036_cash_management_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-049-inlet-fitness/05_cash_management/037_cash_management_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-049-inlet-fitness/05_cash_management/038_cash_management_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-049-inlet-fitness/05_cash_management/039_cash_management_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-049-inlet-fitness/05_cash_management/040_cash_management_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-049-inlet-fitness/06_financing/041_financing_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-049-inlet-fitness/06_financing/042_financing_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-049-inlet-fitness/06_financing/043_financing_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-049-inlet-fitness/06_financing/044_financing_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-049-inlet-fitness/06_financing/045_financing_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-049-inlet-fitness/06_financing/046_financing_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-049-inlet-fitness/06_financing/047_financing_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-049-inlet-fitness/06_financing/048_financing_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-049-inlet-fitness/07_critical_vendors/049_critical_vendors_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-049-inlet-fitness/07_critical_vendors/050_critical_vendors_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-049-inlet-fitness/07_critical_vendors/051_critical_vendors_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-049-inlet-fitness/07_critical_vendors/052_critical_vendors_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-049-inlet-fitness/07_critical_vendors/053_critical_vendors_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-049-inlet-fitness/07_critical_vendors/054_critical_vendors_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-049-inlet-fitness/07_critical_vendors/055_critical_vendors_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-049-inlet-fitness/07_critical_vendors/056_critical_vendors_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-049-inlet-fitness/08_tax/057_tax_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-049-inlet-fitness/08_tax/058_tax_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-049-inlet-fitness/08_tax/059_tax_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-049-inlet-fitness/08_tax/060_tax_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-049-inlet-fitness/08_tax/061_tax_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-049-inlet-fitness/08_tax/062_tax_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-049-inlet-fitness/08_tax/063_tax_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-049-inlet-fitness/08_tax/064_tax_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-049-inlet-fitness/09_litigation/065_litigation_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-049-inlet-fitness/09_litigation/066_litigation_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-049-inlet-fitness/09_litigation/067_litigation_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-049-inlet-fitness/09_litigation/068_litigation_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-049-inlet-fitness/09_litigation/069_litigation_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-049-inlet-fitness/09_litigation/070_litigation_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-049-inlet-fitness/09_litigation/071_litigation_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-049-inlet-fitness/09_litigation/072_litigation_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-049-inlet-fitness/10_plan_disclosure/073_plan_disclosure_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-049-inlet-fitness/10_plan_disclosure/074_plan_disclosure_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-049-inlet-fitness/10_plan_disclosure/075_plan_disclosure_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-049-inlet-fitness/10_plan_disclosure/076_plan_disclosure_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-049-inlet-fitness/10_plan_disclosure/077_plan_disclosure_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-049-inlet-fitness/10_plan_disclosure/078_plan_disclosure_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-049-inlet-fitness/10_plan_disclosure/079_plan_disclosure_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-049-inlet-fitness/10_plan_disclosure/080_plan_disclosure_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-049-inlet-fitness/11_notices_ballots/081_notices_ballots_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-049-inlet-fitness/11_notices_ballots/082_notices_ballots_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-049-inlet-fitness/11_notices_ballots/083_notices_ballots_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-049-inlet-fitness/11_notices_ballots/084_notices_ballots_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-049-inlet-fitness/11_notices_ballots/085_notices_ballots_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-049-inlet-fitness/11_notices_ballots/086_notices_ballots_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-049-inlet-fitness/11_notices_ballots/087_notices_ballots_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-049-inlet-fitness/11_notices_ballots/088_notices_ballots_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-049-inlet-fitness/12_reconciliations/089_reconciliations_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-049-inlet-fitness/12_reconciliations/090_reconciliations_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-049-inlet-fitness/12_reconciliations/091_reconciliations_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-049-inlet-fitness/12_reconciliations/092_reconciliations_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-049-inlet-fitness/12_reconciliations/093_reconciliations_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-049-inlet-fitness/12_reconciliations/094_reconciliations_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-049-inlet-fitness/12_reconciliations/095_reconciliations_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-049-inlet-fitness/12_reconciliations/096_reconciliations_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-049-inlet-fitness/12_reconciliations/097_inlet_fitness_impact_population.xlsx"], "gold_output": {"advice_markdown": "# Decision note — Inlet Fitness lease claims review\n\n## Recommendation\n\nConsolidate, reclassify, or reserve only supported matches. The reconciled record supports 8 scoped actions and leaves 4 items on evidence hold.\n\nSelected option: `inlet-fitness:scoped-evidence`.\n\n## Why this is the supported option\n\nMatch claimant identity, location, obligation type, payment history, and rejection status. Claim classification and duplication depend on exact legal entity and underlying obligation.\n\n## Supported actions\n\n### CBP-049-01 — scheduled-claim mismatch (medium)\n\ncompletion is required by 2025-06-24 under CB-RS-2809-R869; the current event record shows completion on 2025-07-08 under CB-RS-2809-E833. Identity resolves to ENT-049-1000, revision REV-2025.1 is current, and Elliot Mercer is active with capacity 2.\n\nAction: Create exact claimant-obligation rows and quarantine ambiguous aliases. Owner: Elliot Mercer; due 2026-10-01.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/001_petition_schedules_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/02_claims_register/013_claims_register_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/025_contracts_leases_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/05_cash_management/037_cash_management_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/097_inlet_fitness_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-049-03 — tax priority period (critical)\n\napproval must come from Talia Brooks under CB-RS-2809-R169; the effective approval record names Henry Cho under CB-RS-2809-E421. Identity resolves to ENT-049-1002, revision REV-2025.3 is current, and Micah Sullivan is active with capacity 4.\n\nAction: Create exact claimant-obligation rows and quarantine ambiguous aliases. Owner: Micah Sullivan; due 2026-09-29.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/003_petition_schedules_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/02_claims_register/015_claims_register_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/027_contracts_leases_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/05_cash_management/039_cash_management_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/097_inlet_fitness_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-049-04 — reserve calculation error (medium)\n\nthe controlled population contains 136 records under CB-RS-2809-R824; the certification covers 112 records under CB-RS-2809-E883. Identity resolves to ENT-049-1003, revision REV-2025.4 is current, and Nora Chen is active with capacity 6.\n\nAction: Create exact claimant-obligation rows and quarantine ambiguous aliases. Owner: Nora Chen; due 2026-09-28.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/004_petition_schedules_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/02_claims_register/016_claims_register_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/028_contracts_leases_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/05_cash_management/040_cash_management_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/097_inlet_fitness_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-049-06 — guaranty overlap (medium)\n\nthe operative cap is $4,522,000.00 under CB-RS-2809-R807; the matched ledger population totals $4,548,307.00 under CB-RS-2809-E935. Identity resolves to ENT-049-1005, revision REV-2025.6 is current, and Amara Patel is active with capacity 2.\n\nAction: Create exact claimant-obligation rows and quarantine ambiguous aliases. Owner: Amara Patel; due 2026-09-26.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/006_petition_schedules_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/018_proofs_of_claim_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/030_contracts_leases_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/06_financing/042_financing_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/10_plan_disclosure/078_plan_disclosure_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/097_inlet_fitness_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-049-09 — setoff assertion (critical)\n\ncompletion is required by 2025-05-30 under CB-RS-2809-R904; the current event record shows completion on 2025-06-15 under CB-RS-2809-E517. Identity resolves to ENT-049-1008, revision REV-2025.2 is current, and Adrian Mensah is active with capacity 2.\n\nAction: Create exact claimant-obligation rows and quarantine ambiguous aliases. Owner: Adrian Mensah; due 2026-09-23.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/02_claims_register/009_claims_register_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/021_proofs_of_claim_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/05_cash_management/033_cash_management_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/06_financing/045_financing_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/097_inlet_fitness_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-049-10 — ballot amount discrepancy (medium)\n\nthe controlling threshold is 6% under CB-RS-2809-R443; the independently calculated result is 11% under CB-RS-2809-E120. Identity resolves to ENT-049-1009, revision REV-2025.3 is current, and Farah Ibrahim is active with capacity 2.\n\nAction: Create exact claimant-obligation rows and quarantine ambiguous aliases. Owner: Farah Ibrahim; due 2026-10-01.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/02_claims_register/010_claims_register_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/022_proofs_of_claim_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/05_cash_management/034_cash_management_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/06_financing/046_financing_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/097_inlet_fitness_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-049-11 — secured-status defect (medium)\n\napproval must come from Talia Brooks under CB-RS-2809-R118; the effective approval record names Caleb Hassan under CB-RS-2809-E577. Identity resolves to ENT-049-1010, revision REV-2025.4 is current, and Dominic Alvarez is active with capacity 4.\n\nAction: Create exact claimant-obligation rows and quarantine ambiguous aliases. Owner: Dominic Alvarez; due 2026-09-30.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/02_claims_register/011_claims_register_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/023_proofs_of_claim_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/05_cash_management/035_cash_management_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/06_financing/047_financing_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/09_litigation/071_litigation_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/08_tax/059_tax_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/097_inlet_fitness_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-049-12 — critical-vendor overstatement (high)\n\nthe controlled population contains 121 records under CB-RS-2809-R869; the certification covers 97 records under CB-RS-2809-E462. Identity resolves to ENT-049-1011, revision REV-2025.5 is current, and Leona Park is active with capacity 5.\n\nAction: Create exact claimant-obligation rows and quarantine ambiguous aliases. Owner: Leona Park; due 2026-09-29.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/02_claims_register/012_claims_register_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/024_proofs_of_claim_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/05_cash_management/036_cash_management_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/06_financing/048_financing_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/11_notices_ballots/084_notices_ballots_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/08_tax/060_tax_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/097_inlet_fitness_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n## Evidence holds\n\n- **CBP-049-02 — lease rejection deadline**: the current observation does not meet the operative trigger. Next evidence: a current observation that satisfies the operative trigger. Sources: `/workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/002_petition_schedules_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/02_claims_register/014_claims_register_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/026_contracts_leases_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/05_cash_management/038_cash_management_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/11_notices_ballots/086_notices_ballots_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/097_inlet_fitness_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-049-05 — executory-contract cure dispute**: two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key. Next evidence: an approved immutable entity crosswalk. Sources: `/workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/005_petition_schedules_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/017_proofs_of_claim_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/029_contracts_leases_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/06_financing/041_financing_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/10_plan_disclosure/077_plan_disclosure_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/097_inlet_fitness_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-049-07 — notice-address defect**: the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective. Next evidence: effective approval and an active owner with remaining capacity. Sources: `/workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/007_petition_schedules_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/019_proofs_of_claim_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/031_contracts_leases_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/06_financing/043_financing_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/07_critical_vendors/055_critical_vendors_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/097_inlet_fitness_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-049-08 — priority classification error**: the operational record relies on a superseded control revision. Next evidence: an operational record using the current effective revision. Sources: `/workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/008_petition_schedules_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/020_proofs_of_claim_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/032_contracts_leases_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/06_financing/044_financing_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/097_inlet_fitness_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n## Alternatives considered\n\n- `inlet-fitness:shortcut` — Merge claims by claimant display name and location nickname.: Use a plausible summary or one source without completing the controlling joins.\n- `inlet-fitness:blanket-hold` — Freeze the entire matter population: Treat supported actions and genuinely ambiguous records as if they were equally unresolved.\n\n## Assumptions and limits\n\nThis decision is limited to cb100-049-inlet-fitness, the supplied synthetic records, and the matter state as of 2026-10-02. Similar names, stale revisions, and pending authority are not treated as proof.\n", "decision": {"actions": [{"determination": "completion is required by 2025-06-24 under CB-RS-2809-R869; the current event record shows completion on 2025-07-08 under CB-RS-2809-E833. Identity resolves to ENT-049-1000, revision REV-2025.1 is current, and Elliot Mercer is active with capacity 2.", "due_date": "2026-10-01", "id": "ACT-CBP-049-01", "identity_id": "ENT-049-1000", "issue": "scheduled-claim mismatch", "owner": "Elliot Mercer", "portfolio_key": "CBP-049-01", "recommended_action": "Create exact claimant-obligation rows and quarantine ambiguous aliases. Owner: Elliot Mercer; due 2026-10-01.", "severity": "medium", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/001_petition_schedules_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/02_claims_register/013_claims_register_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/025_contracts_leases_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/05_cash_management/037_cash_management_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/097_inlet_fitness_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "approval must come from Talia Brooks under CB-RS-2809-R169; the effective approval record names Henry Cho under CB-RS-2809-E421. Identity resolves to ENT-049-1002, revision REV-2025.3 is current, and Micah Sullivan is active with capacity 4.", "due_date": "2026-09-29", "id": "ACT-CBP-049-03", "identity_id": "ENT-049-1002", "issue": "tax priority period", "owner": "Micah Sullivan", "portfolio_key": "CBP-049-03", "recommended_action": "Create exact claimant-obligation rows and quarantine ambiguous aliases. Owner: Micah Sullivan; due 2026-09-29.", "severity": "critical", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/003_petition_schedules_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/02_claims_register/015_claims_register_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/027_contracts_leases_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/05_cash_management/039_cash_management_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/097_inlet_fitness_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "the controlled population contains 136 records under CB-RS-2809-R824; the certification covers 112 records under CB-RS-2809-E883. Identity resolves to ENT-049-1003, revision REV-2025.4 is current, and Nora Chen is active with capacity 6.", "due_date": "2026-09-28", "id": "ACT-CBP-049-04", "identity_id": "ENT-049-1003", "issue": "reserve calculation error", "owner": "Nora Chen", "portfolio_key": "CBP-049-04", "recommended_action": "Create exact claimant-obligation rows and quarantine ambiguous aliases. Owner: Nora Chen; due 2026-09-28.", "severity": "medium", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/004_petition_schedules_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/02_claims_register/016_claims_register_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/028_contracts_leases_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/05_cash_management/040_cash_management_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/097_inlet_fitness_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "the operative cap is $4,522,000.00 under CB-RS-2809-R807; the matched ledger population totals $4,548,307.00 under CB-RS-2809-E935. Identity resolves to ENT-049-1005, revision REV-2025.6 is current, and Amara Patel is active with capacity 2.", "due_date": "2026-09-26", "id": "ACT-CBP-049-06", "identity_id": "ENT-049-1005", "issue": "guaranty overlap", "owner": "Amara Patel", "portfolio_key": "CBP-049-06", "recommended_action": "Create exact claimant-obligation rows and quarantine ambiguous aliases. Owner: Amara Patel; due 2026-09-26.", "severity": "medium", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/006_petition_schedules_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/018_proofs_of_claim_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/030_contracts_leases_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/06_financing/042_financing_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/10_plan_disclosure/078_plan_disclosure_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/097_inlet_fitness_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "completion is required by 2025-05-30 under CB-RS-2809-R904; the current event record shows completion on 2025-06-15 under CB-RS-2809-E517. Identity resolves to ENT-049-1008, revision REV-2025.2 is current, and Adrian Mensah is active with capacity 2.", "due_date": "2026-09-23", "id": "ACT-CBP-049-09", "identity_id": "ENT-049-1008", "issue": "setoff assertion", "owner": "Adrian Mensah", "portfolio_key": "CBP-049-09", "recommended_action": "Create exact claimant-obligation rows and quarantine ambiguous aliases. Owner: Adrian Mensah; due 2026-09-23.", "severity": "critical", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_claims_register/009_claims_register_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/021_proofs_of_claim_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/05_cash_management/033_cash_management_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/06_financing/045_financing_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/097_inlet_fitness_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "the controlling threshold is 6% under CB-RS-2809-R443; the independently calculated result is 11% under CB-RS-2809-E120. Identity resolves to ENT-049-1009, revision REV-2025.3 is current, and Farah Ibrahim is active with capacity 2.", "due_date": "2026-10-01", "id": "ACT-CBP-049-10", "identity_id": "ENT-049-1009", "issue": "ballot amount discrepancy", "owner": "Farah Ibrahim", "portfolio_key": "CBP-049-10", "recommended_action": "Create exact claimant-obligation rows and quarantine ambiguous aliases. Owner: Farah Ibrahim; due 2026-10-01.", "severity": "medium", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_claims_register/010_claims_register_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/022_proofs_of_claim_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/05_cash_management/034_cash_management_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/06_financing/046_financing_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/097_inlet_fitness_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "approval must come from Talia Brooks under CB-RS-2809-R118; the effective approval record names Caleb Hassan under CB-RS-2809-E577. Identity resolves to ENT-049-1010, revision REV-2025.4 is current, and Dominic Alvarez is active with capacity 4.", "due_date": "2026-09-30", "id": "ACT-CBP-049-11", "identity_id": "ENT-049-1010", "issue": "secured-status defect", "owner": "Dominic Alvarez", "portfolio_key": "CBP-049-11", "recommended_action": "Create exact claimant-obligation rows and quarantine ambiguous aliases. Owner: Dominic Alvarez; due 2026-09-30.", "severity": "medium", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_claims_register/011_claims_register_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/023_proofs_of_claim_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/05_cash_management/035_cash_management_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/06_financing/047_financing_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/09_litigation/071_litigation_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/08_tax/059_tax_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/097_inlet_fitness_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "the controlled population contains 121 records under CB-RS-2809-R869; the certification covers 97 records under CB-RS-2809-E462. Identity resolves to ENT-049-1011, revision REV-2025.5 is current, and Leona Park is active with capacity 5.", "due_date": "2026-09-29", "id": "ACT-CBP-049-12", "identity_id": "ENT-049-1011", "issue": "critical-vendor overstatement", "owner": "Leona Park", "portfolio_key": "CBP-049-12", "recommended_action": "Create exact claimant-obligation rows and quarantine ambiguous aliases. Owner: Leona Park; due 2026-09-29.", "severity": "high", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_claims_register/012_claims_register_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/024_proofs_of_claim_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/05_cash_management/036_cash_management_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/06_financing/048_financing_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/11_notices_ballots/084_notices_ballots_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/08_tax/060_tax_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/097_inlet_fitness_impact_population.xlsx"]}], "as_of": "2026-10-02", "decision": {"alternatives_considered": ["inlet-fitness:shortcut", "inlet-fitness:blanket-hold"], "question": "Which Inlet lease, member, and franchise claims are duplicates or misclassified?", "rationale": "The four-part causal test supports 8 scoped actions and leaves 4 records on evidence hold. Claim classification and duplication depend on exact legal entity and underlying obligation.", "recommendation": "Consolidate, reclassify, or reserve only supported matches.", "selected_option_id": "inlet-fitness:scoped-evidence"}, "holds": [{"id": "HOLD-CBP-049-02", "issue": "lease rejection deadline", "portfolio_key": "CBP-049-02", "reason": "the current observation does not meet the operative trigger", "required_next_evidence": "a current observation that satisfies the operative trigger", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/002_petition_schedules_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/02_claims_register/014_claims_register_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/026_contracts_leases_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/05_cash_management/038_cash_management_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/11_notices_ballots/086_notices_ballots_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/097_inlet_fitness_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-049-05", "issue": "executory-contract cure dispute", "portfolio_key": "CBP-049-05", "reason": "two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key", "required_next_evidence": "an approved immutable entity crosswalk", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/005_petition_schedules_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/017_proofs_of_claim_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/029_contracts_leases_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/06_financing/041_financing_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/10_plan_disclosure/077_plan_disclosure_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/097_inlet_fitness_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-049-07", "issue": "notice-address defect", "portfolio_key": "CBP-049-07", "reason": "the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective", "required_next_evidence": "effective approval and an active owner with remaining capacity", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/007_petition_schedules_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/019_proofs_of_claim_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/031_contracts_leases_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/06_financing/043_financing_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/07_critical_vendors/055_critical_vendors_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/097_inlet_fitness_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-049-08", "issue": "priority classification error", "portfolio_key": "CBP-049-08", "reason": "the operational record relies on a superseded control revision", "required_next_evidence": "an operational record using the current effective revision", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/008_petition_schedules_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/020_proofs_of_claim_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/032_contracts_leases_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/06_financing/044_financing_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/097_inlet_fitness_impact_population.xlsx"]}], "matter_number": "CB-RS-2809", "prepared_for": "Inlet Fitness Studios", "schema_version": "counselbench.decision.v3", "task_id": "cb100-049-inlet-fitness"}, "matter_register": {"matter_number": "CB-RS-2809", "rows": [{"decision_option_id": "inlet-fitness:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-10-01", "issue": "scheduled-claim mismatch", "matter_number": "CB-RS-2809", "owner": "Elliot Mercer", "portfolio_key": "CBP-049-01", "row_id": "REG-CBP-049-01", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/001_petition_schedules_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/02_claims_register/013_claims_register_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/025_contracts_leases_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/05_cash_management/037_cash_management_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/097_inlet_fitness_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "inlet-fitness:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "the current observation does not meet the operative trigger", "issue": "lease rejection deadline", "matter_number": "CB-RS-2809", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-049-02", "row_id": "REG-CBP-049-02", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/002_petition_schedules_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/02_claims_register/014_claims_register_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/026_contracts_leases_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/05_cash_management/038_cash_management_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/11_notices_ballots/086_notices_ballots_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/097_inlet_fitness_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "inlet-fitness:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-29", "issue": "tax priority period", "matter_number": "CB-RS-2809", "owner": "Micah Sullivan", "portfolio_key": "CBP-049-03", "row_id": "REG-CBP-049-03", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/003_petition_schedules_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/02_claims_register/015_claims_register_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/027_contracts_leases_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/05_cash_management/039_cash_management_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/097_inlet_fitness_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "inlet-fitness:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-28", "issue": "reserve calculation error", "matter_number": "CB-RS-2809", "owner": "Nora Chen", "portfolio_key": "CBP-049-04", "row_id": "REG-CBP-049-04", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/004_petition_schedules_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/02_claims_register/016_claims_register_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/028_contracts_leases_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/05_cash_management/040_cash_management_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/097_inlet_fitness_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "inlet-fitness:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key", "issue": "executory-contract cure dispute", "matter_number": "CB-RS-2809", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-049-05", "row_id": "REG-CBP-049-05", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/005_petition_schedules_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/017_proofs_of_claim_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/029_contracts_leases_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/06_financing/041_financing_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/10_plan_disclosure/077_plan_disclosure_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/097_inlet_fitness_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "inlet-fitness:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-26", "issue": "guaranty overlap", "matter_number": "CB-RS-2809", "owner": "Amara Patel", "portfolio_key": "CBP-049-06", "row_id": "REG-CBP-049-06", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/006_petition_schedules_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/018_proofs_of_claim_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/030_contracts_leases_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/06_financing/042_financing_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/10_plan_disclosure/078_plan_disclosure_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/097_inlet_fitness_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "inlet-fitness:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective", "issue": "notice-address defect", "matter_number": "CB-RS-2809", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-049-07", "row_id": "REG-CBP-049-07", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/007_petition_schedules_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/019_proofs_of_claim_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/031_contracts_leases_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/06_financing/043_financing_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/07_critical_vendors/055_critical_vendors_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/097_inlet_fitness_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "inlet-fitness:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "the operational record relies on a superseded control revision", "issue": "priority classification error", "matter_number": "CB-RS-2809", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-049-08", "row_id": "REG-CBP-049-08", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/008_petition_schedules_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/020_proofs_of_claim_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/032_contracts_leases_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/06_financing/044_financing_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/097_inlet_fitness_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "inlet-fitness:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-23", "issue": "setoff assertion", "matter_number": "CB-RS-2809", "owner": "Adrian Mensah", "portfolio_key": "CBP-049-09", "row_id": "REG-CBP-049-09", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_claims_register/009_claims_register_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/021_proofs_of_claim_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/05_cash_management/033_cash_management_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/06_financing/045_financing_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/097_inlet_fitness_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "inlet-fitness:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-10-01", "issue": "ballot amount discrepancy", "matter_number": "CB-RS-2809", "owner": "Farah Ibrahim", "portfolio_key": "CBP-049-10", "row_id": "REG-CBP-049-10", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_claims_register/010_claims_register_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/022_proofs_of_claim_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/05_cash_management/034_cash_management_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/06_financing/046_financing_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/097_inlet_fitness_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "inlet-fitness:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-30", "issue": "secured-status defect", "matter_number": "CB-RS-2809", "owner": "Dominic Alvarez", "portfolio_key": "CBP-049-11", "row_id": "REG-CBP-049-11", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_claims_register/011_claims_register_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/023_proofs_of_claim_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/05_cash_management/035_cash_management_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/06_financing/047_financing_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/09_litigation/071_litigation_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/08_tax/059_tax_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/097_inlet_fitness_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "inlet-fitness:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-29", "issue": "critical-vendor overstatement", "matter_number": "CB-RS-2809", "owner": "Leona Park", "portfolio_key": "CBP-049-12", "row_id": "REG-CBP-049-12", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_claims_register/012_claims_register_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/024_proofs_of_claim_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/05_cash_management/036_cash_management_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/06_financing/048_financing_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/11_notices_ballots/084_notices_ballots_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/08_tax/060_tax_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/097_inlet_fitness_impact_population.xlsx"]}], "schema_version": "counselbench.matter-register.v3", "task_id": "cb100-049-inlet-fitness"}}, "metadata": {"benchmark": "CounselBench-100", "code_license": "Apache-2.0", "data_license": "CC-BY-4.0", "deadline": "2026-10-02", "document_count": 97, "evidence_holds": 4, "jurisdiction": "California", "matter_number": "CB-RS-2809", "mcp_commit": "9a96ea6e5913736f92b88345bf51caeaaa8e719f", "mcp_package": "@modelcontextprotocol/server-filesystem@2026.7.10", "practice_area": "restructuring", "reference_tool_calls": 77, "required_evidence_reads": 58, "supported_actions": 8, "synthetic": true, "venue": "Central District of California Bankruptcy Court", "version": "3.1.0"}, "prompt": "Please take ownership of the open question before the deadline. Which Inlet lease, member, and franchise claims are duplicates or misclassified? Studio leases, member refunds, and franchise obligations create duplicate and misclassified claims across the register. The team needs the call by 2026-10-02. Give me a decision-ready note and make the corresponding matter-register entries, without guessing through missing records.", "rubric": {"criteria": [{"category": "investigation", "description": "Inventory the production and use targeted searches to locate records across native formats.", "id": "investigation.discover_production"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Complete every task-specific identity, authority, operations, and approval read before the first state transition.", "id": "investigation.read_before_write"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Inspect designated source metadata before relying on those records.", "id": "investigation.custody_before_write"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "Select the supported option 'inlet-fitness:scoped-evidence' after applying the four-part test.", "id": "decision.selected_option"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "Identify both rejected approaches and explain why a one-source shortcut and a blanket hold are wrong.", "id": "decision.alternatives"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-049-01 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/001_petition_schedules_source_export.md rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-049-01.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_claims_register/013_claims_register_source_export.json for scheduled-claim mismatch.", "id": "investigation.CBP-049-01.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/025_contracts_leases_source_export.md to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-049-01.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_cash_management/037_cash_management_source_export.json.", "id": "investigation.CBP-049-01.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-049-01 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-049-01.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-049-01 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-049-01.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-049-02 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/002_petition_schedules_source_export.txt rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-049-02.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_claims_register/014_claims_register_source_export.xml for lease rejection deadline.", "id": "investigation.CBP-049-02.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/026_contracts_leases_source_export.txt to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-049-02.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_cash_management/038_cash_management_source_export.xml.", "id": "investigation.CBP-049-02.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-049-02 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is the current observation does not meet the operative trigger.", "id": "decision.CBP-049-02.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-049-02 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-049-02.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-049-03 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/003_petition_schedules_source_export.eml rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-049-03.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_claims_register/015_claims_register_source_export.html for tax priority period.", "id": "investigation.CBP-049-03.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/027_contracts_leases_source_export.eml to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-049-03.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_cash_management/039_cash_management_source_export.html.", "id": "investigation.CBP-049-03.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-049-03 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-049-03.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-049-03 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-049-03.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-049-04 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/004_petition_schedules_source_export.csv rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-049-04.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_claims_register/016_claims_register_source_export.pdf for reserve calculation error.", "id": "investigation.CBP-049-04.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/028_contracts_leases_source_export.csv to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-049-04.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_cash_management/040_cash_management_source_export.pdf.", "id": "investigation.CBP-049-04.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-049-04 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-049-04.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-049-04 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-049-04.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-049-05 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/005_petition_schedules_source_export.json rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-049-05.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/017_proofs_of_claim_source_export.md for executory-contract cure dispute.", "id": "investigation.CBP-049-05.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/029_contracts_leases_source_export.json to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-049-05.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_financing/041_financing_source_export.md.", "id": "investigation.CBP-049-05.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-049-05 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key.", "id": "decision.CBP-049-05.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-049-05 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-049-05.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-049-06 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/006_petition_schedules_source_export.xml rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-049-06.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/018_proofs_of_claim_source_export.txt for guaranty overlap.", "id": "investigation.CBP-049-06.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/030_contracts_leases_source_export.xml to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-049-06.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_financing/042_financing_source_export.txt.", "id": "investigation.CBP-049-06.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-049-06 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-049-06.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-049-06 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-049-06.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-049-07 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/007_petition_schedules_source_export.html rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-049-07.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/019_proofs_of_claim_source_export.eml for notice-address defect.", "id": "investigation.CBP-049-07.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/031_contracts_leases_source_export.html to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-049-07.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_financing/043_financing_source_export.eml.", "id": "investigation.CBP-049-07.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-049-07 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective.", "id": "decision.CBP-049-07.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-049-07 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-049-07.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-049-08 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/008_petition_schedules_source_export.pdf rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-049-08.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/020_proofs_of_claim_source_export.csv for priority classification error.", "id": "investigation.CBP-049-08.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/032_contracts_leases_source_export.pdf to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-049-08.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_financing/044_financing_source_export.csv.", "id": "investigation.CBP-049-08.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-049-08 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is the operational record relies on a superseded control revision.", "id": "decision.CBP-049-08.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-049-08 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-049-08.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-049-09 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_claims_register/009_claims_register_source_export.md rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-049-09.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/021_proofs_of_claim_source_export.json for setoff assertion.", "id": "investigation.CBP-049-09.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_cash_management/033_cash_management_source_export.md to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-049-09.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_financing/045_financing_source_export.json.", "id": "investigation.CBP-049-09.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-049-09 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-049-09.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-049-09 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-049-09.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-049-10 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_claims_register/010_claims_register_source_export.txt rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-049-10.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/022_proofs_of_claim_source_export.xml for ballot amount discrepancy.", "id": "investigation.CBP-049-10.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_cash_management/034_cash_management_source_export.txt to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-049-10.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_financing/046_financing_source_export.xml.", "id": "investigation.CBP-049-10.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-049-10 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-049-10.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-049-10 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-049-10.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-049-11 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_claims_register/011_claims_register_source_export.eml rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-049-11.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/023_proofs_of_claim_source_export.html for secured-status defect.", "id": "investigation.CBP-049-11.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_cash_management/035_cash_management_source_export.eml to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-049-11.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_financing/047_financing_source_export.html.", "id": "investigation.CBP-049-11.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-049-11 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-049-11.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-049-11 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-049-11.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-049-12 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_claims_register/012_claims_register_source_export.csv rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-049-12.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/024_proofs_of_claim_source_export.pdf for critical-vendor overstatement.", "id": "investigation.CBP-049-12.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_cash_management/036_cash_management_source_export.csv to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-049-12.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_financing/048_financing_source_export.pdf.", "id": "investigation.CBP-049-12.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-049-12 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-049-12.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-049-12 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-049-12.register"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Write the exact selected option, supported action population, evidence-hold population, facts, owners, deadlines, and citations.", "id": "state.exact_decision"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create one exact register row per portfolio key with no extra, missing, or modified row.", "id": "state.exact_register"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Leave only the three approved deliverables and perform no extra state-changing write.", "id": "state.write_scope_containment"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Read back decision.json, matter-register.json, and advice.md after their final writes.", "id": "state.postwrite_readback"}, {"category": "answer", "description": "Explain the selected recommendation, supported actions, holds, alternatives, and limitations with exact source anchors.", "id": "answer.decision_note"}], "decision_options": [{"approach": "Apply the exact identity, current-state, authority, and revision test. Create exact claimant-obligation rows and quarantine ambiguous aliases.", "id": "inlet-fitness:scoped-evidence", "label": "Consolidate, reclassify, or reserve only supported matches."}, {"approach": "Use a plausible summary or one source without completing the controlling joins.", "id": "inlet-fitness:shortcut", "label": "Merge claims by claimant display name and location nickname."}, {"approach": "Treat supported actions and genuinely ambiguous records as if they were equally unresolved.", "id": "inlet-fitness:blanket-hold", "label": "Freeze the entire matter population"}], "evaluation_narrative": {"authority": "Claim classification and duplication depend on exact legal entity and underlying obligation.", "observation": "Match claimant identity, location, obligation type, payment history, and rejection status.", "question": "Which Inlet lease, member, and franchise claims are duplicates or misclassified?", "register_action": "Create exact claimant-obligation rows and quarantine ambiguous aliases."}, "gates": ["all_required_evidence_precedes_first_write", "decision_criteria_complete", "register_state_exact", "write_scope_contained", "all_outputs_verified_by_readback"], "metadata_checks": 6, "metric": "weighted_criteria_score", "minimum_tool_calls": 77, "required_deliverables": ["decision.json", "matter-register.json", "advice.md"], "required_document_reads": 58, "type": "deterministic", "weights": {"advice": 0.15, "decision": 0.35, "investigation": 0.25, "state": 0.25}}, "task_id": "cb100-049-inlet-fitness", "task_name": "Inlet Fitness lease claims review", "world_id": "counselbench-filesystem-mcp-v3"}
+{"context_files": ["task_files/cb100-050-keystone-press/01_petition_schedules/001_petition_schedules_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-050-keystone-press/01_petition_schedules/002_petition_schedules_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-050-keystone-press/01_petition_schedules/003_petition_schedules_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-050-keystone-press/01_petition_schedules/004_petition_schedules_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-050-keystone-press/01_petition_schedules/005_petition_schedules_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-050-keystone-press/01_petition_schedules/006_petition_schedules_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-050-keystone-press/01_petition_schedules/007_petition_schedules_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-050-keystone-press/01_petition_schedules/008_petition_schedules_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-050-keystone-press/02_claims_register/009_claims_register_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-050-keystone-press/02_claims_register/010_claims_register_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-050-keystone-press/02_claims_register/011_claims_register_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-050-keystone-press/02_claims_register/012_claims_register_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-050-keystone-press/02_claims_register/013_claims_register_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-050-keystone-press/02_claims_register/014_claims_register_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-050-keystone-press/02_claims_register/015_claims_register_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-050-keystone-press/02_claims_register/016_claims_register_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-050-keystone-press/03_proofs_of_claim/017_proofs_of_claim_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-050-keystone-press/03_proofs_of_claim/018_proofs_of_claim_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-050-keystone-press/03_proofs_of_claim/019_proofs_of_claim_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-050-keystone-press/03_proofs_of_claim/020_proofs_of_claim_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-050-keystone-press/03_proofs_of_claim/021_proofs_of_claim_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-050-keystone-press/03_proofs_of_claim/022_proofs_of_claim_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-050-keystone-press/03_proofs_of_claim/023_proofs_of_claim_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-050-keystone-press/03_proofs_of_claim/024_proofs_of_claim_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-050-keystone-press/04_contracts_leases/025_contracts_leases_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-050-keystone-press/04_contracts_leases/026_contracts_leases_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-050-keystone-press/04_contracts_leases/027_contracts_leases_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-050-keystone-press/04_contracts_leases/028_contracts_leases_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-050-keystone-press/04_contracts_leases/029_contracts_leases_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-050-keystone-press/04_contracts_leases/030_contracts_leases_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-050-keystone-press/04_contracts_leases/031_contracts_leases_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-050-keystone-press/04_contracts_leases/032_contracts_leases_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-050-keystone-press/05_cash_management/033_cash_management_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-050-keystone-press/05_cash_management/034_cash_management_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-050-keystone-press/05_cash_management/035_cash_management_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-050-keystone-press/05_cash_management/036_cash_management_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-050-keystone-press/05_cash_management/037_cash_management_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-050-keystone-press/05_cash_management/038_cash_management_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-050-keystone-press/05_cash_management/039_cash_management_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-050-keystone-press/05_cash_management/040_cash_management_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-050-keystone-press/06_financing/041_financing_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-050-keystone-press/06_financing/042_financing_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-050-keystone-press/06_financing/043_financing_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-050-keystone-press/06_financing/044_financing_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-050-keystone-press/06_financing/045_financing_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-050-keystone-press/06_financing/046_financing_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-050-keystone-press/06_financing/047_financing_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-050-keystone-press/06_financing/048_financing_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-050-keystone-press/07_critical_vendors/049_critical_vendors_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-050-keystone-press/07_critical_vendors/050_critical_vendors_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-050-keystone-press/07_critical_vendors/051_critical_vendors_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-050-keystone-press/07_critical_vendors/052_critical_vendors_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-050-keystone-press/07_critical_vendors/053_critical_vendors_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-050-keystone-press/07_critical_vendors/054_critical_vendors_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-050-keystone-press/07_critical_vendors/055_critical_vendors_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-050-keystone-press/07_critical_vendors/056_critical_vendors_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-050-keystone-press/08_tax/057_tax_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-050-keystone-press/08_tax/058_tax_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-050-keystone-press/08_tax/059_tax_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-050-keystone-press/08_tax/060_tax_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-050-keystone-press/08_tax/061_tax_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-050-keystone-press/08_tax/062_tax_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-050-keystone-press/08_tax/063_tax_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-050-keystone-press/08_tax/064_tax_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-050-keystone-press/09_litigation/065_litigation_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-050-keystone-press/09_litigation/066_litigation_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-050-keystone-press/09_litigation/067_litigation_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-050-keystone-press/09_litigation/068_litigation_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-050-keystone-press/09_litigation/069_litigation_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-050-keystone-press/09_litigation/070_litigation_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-050-keystone-press/09_litigation/071_litigation_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-050-keystone-press/09_litigation/072_litigation_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-050-keystone-press/10_plan_disclosure/073_plan_disclosure_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-050-keystone-press/10_plan_disclosure/074_plan_disclosure_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-050-keystone-press/10_plan_disclosure/075_plan_disclosure_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-050-keystone-press/10_plan_disclosure/076_plan_disclosure_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-050-keystone-press/10_plan_disclosure/077_plan_disclosure_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-050-keystone-press/10_plan_disclosure/078_plan_disclosure_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-050-keystone-press/10_plan_disclosure/079_plan_disclosure_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-050-keystone-press/10_plan_disclosure/080_plan_disclosure_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-050-keystone-press/11_notices_ballots/081_notices_ballots_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-050-keystone-press/11_notices_ballots/082_notices_ballots_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-050-keystone-press/11_notices_ballots/083_notices_ballots_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-050-keystone-press/11_notices_ballots/084_notices_ballots_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-050-keystone-press/11_notices_ballots/085_notices_ballots_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-050-keystone-press/11_notices_ballots/086_notices_ballots_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-050-keystone-press/11_notices_ballots/087_notices_ballots_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-050-keystone-press/11_notices_ballots/088_notices_ballots_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-050-keystone-press/12_reconciliations/089_reconciliations_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-050-keystone-press/12_reconciliations/090_reconciliations_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-050-keystone-press/12_reconciliations/091_reconciliations_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-050-keystone-press/12_reconciliations/092_reconciliations_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-050-keystone-press/12_reconciliations/093_reconciliations_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-050-keystone-press/12_reconciliations/094_reconciliations_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-050-keystone-press/12_reconciliations/095_reconciliations_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-050-keystone-press/12_reconciliations/096_reconciliations_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-050-keystone-press/12_reconciliations/097_keystone_press_impact_population.xlsx"], "gold_output": {"advice_markdown": "# Decision note — Keystone Press disclosure reconciliation\n\n## Recommendation\n\nPublish only reconciled amounts and disclose material unresolved reserves. The reconciled record supports 9 scoped actions and leaves 3 items on evidence hold.\n\nSelected option: `keystone-press:scoped-evidence`.\n\n## Why this is the supported option\n\nReconcile pension, supplier, tax, and litigation claims to schedules, reserves, and ballots. Disclosure and voting figures must use supported classifications and current reconciliation revisions.\n\n## Supported actions\n\n### CBP-050-01 — duplicate proof of claim (critical)\n\nthe operative cap is $6,202,000.00 under CB-RS-2810-R547; the matched ledger population totals $6,276,947.00 under CB-RS-2810-E443. Identity resolves to ENT-050-1000, revision REV-2026.1 is current, and Mei Whitaker is active with capacity 1.\n\nAction: Create disclosure-control rows for supported figures and unresolved material variances. Owner: Mei Whitaker; due 2026-10-05.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/001_petition_schedules_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/02_claims_register/013_claims_register_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/025_contracts_leases_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/05_cash_management/037_cash_management_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/08_tax/061_tax_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/097_keystone_press_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-050-02 — postpetition invoice (high)\n\ndelivery must use notices-keystone_regional_press@example.test under CB-RS-2810-R602; the only matched receipt used archive-commonwealth_newsprint_pension_trust@example.test under CB-RS-2810-E976. Identity resolves to ENT-050-1001, revision REV-2026.2 is current, and Theo Laurent is active with capacity 5.\n\nAction: Create disclosure-control rows for supported figures and unresolved material variances. Owner: Theo Laurent; due 2026-10-04.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/002_petition_schedules_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/02_claims_register/014_claims_register_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/026_contracts_leases_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/05_cash_management/038_cash_management_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/08_tax/062_tax_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/097_keystone_press_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-050-03 — DIP budget variance (critical)\n\nan open exception blocks completion under CB-RS-2810-R652; the current status is open and unresolved under CB-RS-2810-E344. Identity resolves to ENT-050-1002, revision REV-2026.3 is current, and Lena Varga is active with capacity 4.\n\nAction: Create disclosure-control rows for supported figures and unresolved material variances. Owner: Lena Varga; due 2026-10-03.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/003_petition_schedules_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/02_claims_register/015_claims_register_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/027_contracts_leases_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/05_cash_management/039_cash_management_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/097_keystone_press_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-050-06 — tax priority period (medium)\n\napproval must come from Amara Patel under CB-RS-2810-R429; the effective approval record names Caleb Hassan under CB-RS-2810-E225. Identity resolves to ENT-050-1005, revision REV-2026.6 is current, and Micah Sullivan is active with capacity 2.\n\nAction: Create disclosure-control rows for supported figures and unresolved material variances. Owner: Micah Sullivan; due 2026-09-30.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/006_petition_schedules_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/018_proofs_of_claim_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/030_contracts_leases_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/06_financing/042_financing_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/097_keystone_press_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-050-07 — reserve calculation error (high)\n\nthe controlled population contains 187 records under CB-RS-2810-R215; the certification covers 148 records under CB-RS-2810-E106. Identity resolves to ENT-050-1006, revision REV-2026.7 is current, and Nora Chen is active with capacity 1.\n\nAction: Create disclosure-control rows for supported figures and unresolved material variances. Owner: Nora Chen; due 2026-09-29.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/007_petition_schedules_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/019_proofs_of_claim_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/031_contracts_leases_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/06_financing/043_financing_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/09_litigation/067_litigation_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/097_keystone_press_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-050-08 — executory-contract cure dispute (high)\n\nthe permission is limited to Eastern District of Pennsylvania Bankruptcy Court under CB-RS-2810-R994; the matched activity occurred in Pennsylvania under CB-RS-2810-E258. Identity resolves to ENT-050-1007, revision REV-2026.1 is current, and Caleb Hassan is active with capacity 1.\n\nAction: Create disclosure-control rows for supported figures and unresolved material variances. Owner: Caleb Hassan; due 2026-09-28.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/008_petition_schedules_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/020_proofs_of_claim_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/032_contracts_leases_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/06_financing/044_financing_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/07_critical_vendors/056_critical_vendors_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/097_keystone_press_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-050-09 — guaranty overlap (low)\n\nthe operative cap is $4,162,000.00 under CB-RS-2810-R278; the matched ledger population totals $4,202,778.00 under CB-RS-2810-E586. Identity resolves to ENT-050-1008, revision REV-2026.2 is current, and Amara Patel is active with capacity 5.\n\nAction: Create disclosure-control rows for supported figures and unresolved material variances. Owner: Amara Patel; due 2026-09-27.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/02_claims_register/009_claims_register_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/021_proofs_of_claim_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/05_cash_management/033_cash_management_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/06_financing/045_financing_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/097_keystone_press_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-050-10 — notice-address defect (high)\n\ndelivery must use notices-keystone_regional_press@example.test under CB-RS-2810-R228; the only matched receipt used archive-commonwealth_newsprint_pension_trust@example.test under CB-RS-2810-E901. Identity resolves to ENT-050-1009, revision REV-2026.3 is current, and Samuel Kim is active with capacity 2.\n\nAction: Create disclosure-control rows for supported figures and unresolved material variances. Owner: Samuel Kim; due 2026-10-05.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/02_claims_register/010_claims_register_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/022_proofs_of_claim_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/05_cash_management/034_cash_management_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/06_financing/046_financing_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/097_keystone_press_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-050-12 — setoff assertion (medium)\n\ncompletion is required by 2026-03-16 under CB-RS-2810-R654; the current event record shows completion on 2026-04-12 under CB-RS-2810-E609. Identity resolves to ENT-050-1011, revision REV-2026.5 is current, and Adrian Mensah is active with capacity 1.\n\nAction: Create disclosure-control rows for supported figures and unresolved material variances. Owner: Adrian Mensah; due 2026-10-03.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/02_claims_register/012_claims_register_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/024_proofs_of_claim_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/05_cash_management/036_cash_management_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/06_financing/048_financing_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/097_keystone_press_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n## Evidence holds\n\n- **CBP-050-04 — scheduled-claim mismatch**: two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key. Next evidence: an approved immutable entity crosswalk. Sources: `/workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/004_petition_schedules_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/02_claims_register/016_claims_register_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/028_contracts_leases_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/05_cash_management/040_cash_management_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/10_plan_disclosure/076_plan_disclosure_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/097_keystone_press_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-050-05 — lease rejection deadline**: the current observation does not meet the operative trigger. Next evidence: a current observation that satisfies the operative trigger. Sources: `/workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/005_petition_schedules_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/017_proofs_of_claim_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/029_contracts_leases_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/06_financing/041_financing_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/089_reconciliations_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/07_critical_vendors/053_critical_vendors_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/097_keystone_press_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-050-11 — priority classification error**: the operational record relies on a superseded control revision. Next evidence: an operational record using the current effective revision. Sources: `/workspace/documents/02_claims_register/011_claims_register_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/023_proofs_of_claim_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/05_cash_management/035_cash_management_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/06_financing/047_financing_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/097_keystone_press_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n## Alternatives considered\n\n- `keystone-press:shortcut` — Use the latest aggregate workbook without checking claim-level changes.: Use a plausible summary or one source without completing the controlling joins.\n- `keystone-press:blanket-hold` — Freeze the entire matter population: Treat supported actions and genuinely ambiguous records as if they were equally unresolved.\n\n## Assumptions and limits\n\nThis decision is limited to cb100-050-keystone-press, the supplied synthetic records, and the matter state as of 2026-10-06. Similar names, stale revisions, and pending authority are not treated as proof.\n", "decision": {"actions": [{"determination": "the operative cap is $6,202,000.00 under CB-RS-2810-R547; the matched ledger population totals $6,276,947.00 under CB-RS-2810-E443. Identity resolves to ENT-050-1000, revision REV-2026.1 is current, and Mei Whitaker is active with capacity 1.", "due_date": "2026-10-05", "id": "ACT-CBP-050-01", "identity_id": "ENT-050-1000", "issue": "duplicate proof of claim", "owner": "Mei Whitaker", "portfolio_key": "CBP-050-01", "recommended_action": "Create disclosure-control rows for supported figures and unresolved material variances. Owner: Mei Whitaker; due 2026-10-05.", "severity": "critical", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/001_petition_schedules_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/02_claims_register/013_claims_register_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/025_contracts_leases_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/05_cash_management/037_cash_management_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/08_tax/061_tax_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/097_keystone_press_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "delivery must use notices-keystone_regional_press@example.test under CB-RS-2810-R602; the only matched receipt used archive-commonwealth_newsprint_pension_trust@example.test under CB-RS-2810-E976. Identity resolves to ENT-050-1001, revision REV-2026.2 is current, and Theo Laurent is active with capacity 5.", "due_date": "2026-10-04", "id": "ACT-CBP-050-02", "identity_id": "ENT-050-1001", "issue": "postpetition invoice", "owner": "Theo Laurent", "portfolio_key": "CBP-050-02", "recommended_action": "Create disclosure-control rows for supported figures and unresolved material variances. Owner: Theo Laurent; due 2026-10-04.", "severity": "high", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/002_petition_schedules_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/02_claims_register/014_claims_register_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/026_contracts_leases_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/05_cash_management/038_cash_management_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/08_tax/062_tax_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/097_keystone_press_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "an open exception blocks completion under CB-RS-2810-R652; the current status is open and unresolved under CB-RS-2810-E344. Identity resolves to ENT-050-1002, revision REV-2026.3 is current, and Lena Varga is active with capacity 4.", "due_date": "2026-10-03", "id": "ACT-CBP-050-03", "identity_id": "ENT-050-1002", "issue": "DIP budget variance", "owner": "Lena Varga", "portfolio_key": "CBP-050-03", "recommended_action": "Create disclosure-control rows for supported figures and unresolved material variances. Owner: Lena Varga; due 2026-10-03.", "severity": "critical", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/003_petition_schedules_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/02_claims_register/015_claims_register_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/027_contracts_leases_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/05_cash_management/039_cash_management_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/097_keystone_press_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "approval must come from Amara Patel under CB-RS-2810-R429; the effective approval record names Caleb Hassan under CB-RS-2810-E225. Identity resolves to ENT-050-1005, revision REV-2026.6 is current, and Micah Sullivan is active with capacity 2.", "due_date": "2026-09-30", "id": "ACT-CBP-050-06", "identity_id": "ENT-050-1005", "issue": "tax priority period", "owner": "Micah Sullivan", "portfolio_key": "CBP-050-06", "recommended_action": "Create disclosure-control rows for supported figures and unresolved material variances. Owner: Micah Sullivan; due 2026-09-30.", "severity": "medium", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/006_petition_schedules_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/018_proofs_of_claim_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/030_contracts_leases_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/06_financing/042_financing_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/097_keystone_press_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "the controlled population contains 187 records under CB-RS-2810-R215; the certification covers 148 records under CB-RS-2810-E106. Identity resolves to ENT-050-1006, revision REV-2026.7 is current, and Nora Chen is active with capacity 1.", "due_date": "2026-09-29", "id": "ACT-CBP-050-07", "identity_id": "ENT-050-1006", "issue": "reserve calculation error", "owner": "Nora Chen", "portfolio_key": "CBP-050-07", "recommended_action": "Create disclosure-control rows for supported figures and unresolved material variances. Owner: Nora Chen; due 2026-09-29.", "severity": "high", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/007_petition_schedules_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/019_proofs_of_claim_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/031_contracts_leases_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/06_financing/043_financing_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/09_litigation/067_litigation_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/097_keystone_press_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "the permission is limited to Eastern District of Pennsylvania Bankruptcy Court under CB-RS-2810-R994; the matched activity occurred in Pennsylvania under CB-RS-2810-E258. Identity resolves to ENT-050-1007, revision REV-2026.1 is current, and Caleb Hassan is active with capacity 1.", "due_date": "2026-09-28", "id": "ACT-CBP-050-08", "identity_id": "ENT-050-1007", "issue": "executory-contract cure dispute", "owner": "Caleb Hassan", "portfolio_key": "CBP-050-08", "recommended_action": "Create disclosure-control rows for supported figures and unresolved material variances. Owner: Caleb Hassan; due 2026-09-28.", "severity": "high", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/008_petition_schedules_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/020_proofs_of_claim_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/032_contracts_leases_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/06_financing/044_financing_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/07_critical_vendors/056_critical_vendors_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/097_keystone_press_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "the operative cap is $4,162,000.00 under CB-RS-2810-R278; the matched ledger population totals $4,202,778.00 under CB-RS-2810-E586. Identity resolves to ENT-050-1008, revision REV-2026.2 is current, and Amara Patel is active with capacity 5.", "due_date": "2026-09-27", "id": "ACT-CBP-050-09", "identity_id": "ENT-050-1008", "issue": "guaranty overlap", "owner": "Amara Patel", "portfolio_key": "CBP-050-09", "recommended_action": "Create disclosure-control rows for supported figures and unresolved material variances. Owner: Amara Patel; due 2026-09-27.", "severity": "low", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_claims_register/009_claims_register_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/021_proofs_of_claim_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/05_cash_management/033_cash_management_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/06_financing/045_financing_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/097_keystone_press_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "delivery must use notices-keystone_regional_press@example.test under CB-RS-2810-R228; the only matched receipt used archive-commonwealth_newsprint_pension_trust@example.test under CB-RS-2810-E901. Identity resolves to ENT-050-1009, revision REV-2026.3 is current, and Samuel Kim is active with capacity 2.", "due_date": "2026-10-05", "id": "ACT-CBP-050-10", "identity_id": "ENT-050-1009", "issue": "notice-address defect", "owner": "Samuel Kim", "portfolio_key": "CBP-050-10", "recommended_action": "Create disclosure-control rows for supported figures and unresolved material variances. Owner: Samuel Kim; due 2026-10-05.", "severity": "high", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_claims_register/010_claims_register_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/022_proofs_of_claim_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/05_cash_management/034_cash_management_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/06_financing/046_financing_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/097_keystone_press_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "completion is required by 2026-03-16 under CB-RS-2810-R654; the current event record shows completion on 2026-04-12 under CB-RS-2810-E609. Identity resolves to ENT-050-1011, revision REV-2026.5 is current, and Adrian Mensah is active with capacity 1.", "due_date": "2026-10-03", "id": "ACT-CBP-050-12", "identity_id": "ENT-050-1011", "issue": "setoff assertion", "owner": "Adrian Mensah", "portfolio_key": "CBP-050-12", "recommended_action": "Create disclosure-control rows for supported figures and unresolved material variances. Owner: Adrian Mensah; due 2026-10-03.", "severity": "medium", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_claims_register/012_claims_register_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/024_proofs_of_claim_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/05_cash_management/036_cash_management_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/06_financing/048_financing_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/097_keystone_press_impact_population.xlsx"]}], "as_of": "2026-10-06", "decision": {"alternatives_considered": ["keystone-press:shortcut", "keystone-press:blanket-hold"], "question": "Is Keystone ready to publish claim and ballot figures in the disclosure statement?", "rationale": "The four-part causal test supports 9 scoped actions and leaves 3 records on evidence hold. Disclosure and voting figures must use supported classifications and current reconciliation revisions.", "recommendation": "Publish only reconciled amounts and disclose material unresolved reserves.", "selected_option_id": "keystone-press:scoped-evidence"}, "holds": [{"id": "HOLD-CBP-050-04", "issue": "scheduled-claim mismatch", "portfolio_key": "CBP-050-04", "reason": "two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key", "required_next_evidence": "an approved immutable entity crosswalk", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/004_petition_schedules_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/02_claims_register/016_claims_register_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/028_contracts_leases_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/05_cash_management/040_cash_management_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/10_plan_disclosure/076_plan_disclosure_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/097_keystone_press_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-050-05", "issue": "lease rejection deadline", "portfolio_key": "CBP-050-05", "reason": "the current observation does not meet the operative trigger", "required_next_evidence": "a current observation that satisfies the operative trigger", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/005_petition_schedules_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/017_proofs_of_claim_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/029_contracts_leases_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/06_financing/041_financing_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/089_reconciliations_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/07_critical_vendors/053_critical_vendors_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/097_keystone_press_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-050-11", "issue": "priority classification error", "portfolio_key": "CBP-050-11", "reason": "the operational record relies on a superseded control revision", "required_next_evidence": "an operational record using the current effective revision", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_claims_register/011_claims_register_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/023_proofs_of_claim_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/05_cash_management/035_cash_management_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/06_financing/047_financing_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/097_keystone_press_impact_population.xlsx"]}], "matter_number": "CB-RS-2810", "prepared_for": "Keystone Regional Press", "schema_version": "counselbench.decision.v3", "task_id": "cb100-050-keystone-press"}, "matter_register": {"matter_number": "CB-RS-2810", "rows": [{"decision_option_id": "keystone-press:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-10-05", "issue": "duplicate proof of claim", "matter_number": "CB-RS-2810", "owner": "Mei Whitaker", "portfolio_key": "CBP-050-01", "row_id": "REG-CBP-050-01", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/001_petition_schedules_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/02_claims_register/013_claims_register_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/025_contracts_leases_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/05_cash_management/037_cash_management_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/08_tax/061_tax_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/097_keystone_press_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "keystone-press:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-10-04", "issue": "postpetition invoice", "matter_number": "CB-RS-2810", "owner": "Theo Laurent", "portfolio_key": "CBP-050-02", "row_id": "REG-CBP-050-02", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/002_petition_schedules_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/02_claims_register/014_claims_register_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/026_contracts_leases_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/05_cash_management/038_cash_management_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/08_tax/062_tax_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/097_keystone_press_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "keystone-press:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-10-03", "issue": "DIP budget variance", "matter_number": "CB-RS-2810", "owner": "Lena Varga", "portfolio_key": "CBP-050-03", "row_id": "REG-CBP-050-03", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/003_petition_schedules_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/02_claims_register/015_claims_register_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/027_contracts_leases_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/05_cash_management/039_cash_management_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/097_keystone_press_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "keystone-press:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key", "issue": "scheduled-claim mismatch", "matter_number": "CB-RS-2810", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-050-04", "row_id": "REG-CBP-050-04", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/004_petition_schedules_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/02_claims_register/016_claims_register_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/028_contracts_leases_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/05_cash_management/040_cash_management_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/10_plan_disclosure/076_plan_disclosure_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/097_keystone_press_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "keystone-press:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "the current observation does not meet the operative trigger", "issue": "lease rejection deadline", "matter_number": "CB-RS-2810", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-050-05", "row_id": "REG-CBP-050-05", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/005_petition_schedules_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/017_proofs_of_claim_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/029_contracts_leases_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/06_financing/041_financing_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/089_reconciliations_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/07_critical_vendors/053_critical_vendors_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/097_keystone_press_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "keystone-press:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-30", "issue": "tax priority period", "matter_number": "CB-RS-2810", "owner": "Micah Sullivan", "portfolio_key": "CBP-050-06", "row_id": "REG-CBP-050-06", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/006_petition_schedules_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/018_proofs_of_claim_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/030_contracts_leases_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/06_financing/042_financing_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/097_keystone_press_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "keystone-press:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-29", "issue": "reserve calculation error", "matter_number": "CB-RS-2810", "owner": "Nora Chen", "portfolio_key": "CBP-050-07", "row_id": "REG-CBP-050-07", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/007_petition_schedules_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/019_proofs_of_claim_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/031_contracts_leases_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/06_financing/043_financing_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/09_litigation/067_litigation_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/097_keystone_press_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "keystone-press:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-28", "issue": "executory-contract cure dispute", "matter_number": "CB-RS-2810", "owner": "Caleb Hassan", "portfolio_key": "CBP-050-08", "row_id": "REG-CBP-050-08", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/008_petition_schedules_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/020_proofs_of_claim_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/032_contracts_leases_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/06_financing/044_financing_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/07_critical_vendors/056_critical_vendors_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/097_keystone_press_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "keystone-press:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-27", "issue": "guaranty overlap", "matter_number": "CB-RS-2810", "owner": "Amara Patel", "portfolio_key": "CBP-050-09", "row_id": "REG-CBP-050-09", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_claims_register/009_claims_register_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/021_proofs_of_claim_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/05_cash_management/033_cash_management_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/06_financing/045_financing_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/097_keystone_press_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "keystone-press:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-10-05", "issue": "notice-address defect", "matter_number": "CB-RS-2810", "owner": "Samuel Kim", "portfolio_key": "CBP-050-10", "row_id": "REG-CBP-050-10", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_claims_register/010_claims_register_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/022_proofs_of_claim_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/05_cash_management/034_cash_management_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/06_financing/046_financing_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/097_keystone_press_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "keystone-press:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "the operational record relies on a superseded control revision", "issue": "priority classification error", "matter_number": "CB-RS-2810", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-050-11", "row_id": "REG-CBP-050-11", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_claims_register/011_claims_register_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/023_proofs_of_claim_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/05_cash_management/035_cash_management_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/06_financing/047_financing_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/097_keystone_press_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "keystone-press:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-10-03", "issue": "setoff assertion", "matter_number": "CB-RS-2810", "owner": "Adrian Mensah", "portfolio_key": "CBP-050-12", "row_id": "REG-CBP-050-12", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_claims_register/012_claims_register_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/024_proofs_of_claim_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/05_cash_management/036_cash_management_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/06_financing/048_financing_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_reconciliations/097_keystone_press_impact_population.xlsx"]}], "schema_version": "counselbench.matter-register.v3", "task_id": "cb100-050-keystone-press"}}, "metadata": {"benchmark": "CounselBench-100", "code_license": "Apache-2.0", "data_license": "CC-BY-4.0", "deadline": "2026-10-06", "document_count": 97, "evidence_holds": 3, "jurisdiction": "Pennsylvania", "matter_number": "CB-RS-2810", "mcp_commit": "9a96ea6e5913736f92b88345bf51caeaaa8e719f", "mcp_package": "@modelcontextprotocol/server-filesystem@2026.7.10", "practice_area": "restructuring", "reference_tool_calls": 76, "required_evidence_reads": 56, "supported_actions": 9, "synthetic": true, "venue": "Eastern District of Pennsylvania Bankruptcy Court", "version": "3.1.0"}, "prompt": "I need to know what is proven, what we can do about it, and what is still only an evidence gap. Is Keystone ready to publish claim and ballot figures in the disclosure statement? Pension, newsprint, tax, and litigation claims must be reconciled before disclosure-statement and ballot deadlines. The team needs the call by 2026-10-06. Capture the supported action and the remaining holds so the next reviewer can reproduce the call.", "rubric": {"criteria": [{"category": "investigation", "description": "Inventory the production and use targeted searches to locate records across native formats.", "id": "investigation.discover_production"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Complete every task-specific identity, authority, operations, and approval read before the first state transition.", "id": "investigation.read_before_write"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Inspect designated source metadata before relying on those records.", "id": "investigation.custody_before_write"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "Select the supported option 'keystone-press:scoped-evidence' after applying the four-part test.", "id": "decision.selected_option"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "Identify both rejected approaches and explain why a one-source shortcut and a blanket hold are wrong.", "id": "decision.alternatives"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-050-01 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/001_petition_schedules_source_export.md rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-050-01.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_claims_register/013_claims_register_source_export.json for duplicate proof of claim.", "id": "investigation.CBP-050-01.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/025_contracts_leases_source_export.md to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-050-01.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_cash_management/037_cash_management_source_export.json.", "id": "investigation.CBP-050-01.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-050-01 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-050-01.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-050-01 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-050-01.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-050-02 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/002_petition_schedules_source_export.txt rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-050-02.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_claims_register/014_claims_register_source_export.xml for postpetition invoice.", "id": "investigation.CBP-050-02.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/026_contracts_leases_source_export.txt to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-050-02.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_cash_management/038_cash_management_source_export.xml.", "id": "investigation.CBP-050-02.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-050-02 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-050-02.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-050-02 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-050-02.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-050-03 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/003_petition_schedules_source_export.eml rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-050-03.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_claims_register/015_claims_register_source_export.html for DIP budget variance.", "id": "investigation.CBP-050-03.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/027_contracts_leases_source_export.eml to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-050-03.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_cash_management/039_cash_management_source_export.html.", "id": "investigation.CBP-050-03.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-050-03 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-050-03.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-050-03 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-050-03.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-050-04 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/004_petition_schedules_source_export.csv rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-050-04.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_claims_register/016_claims_register_source_export.pdf for scheduled-claim mismatch.", "id": "investigation.CBP-050-04.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/028_contracts_leases_source_export.csv to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-050-04.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_cash_management/040_cash_management_source_export.pdf.", "id": "investigation.CBP-050-04.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-050-04 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key.", "id": "decision.CBP-050-04.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-050-04 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-050-04.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-050-05 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/005_petition_schedules_source_export.json rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-050-05.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/017_proofs_of_claim_source_export.md for lease rejection deadline.", "id": "investigation.CBP-050-05.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/029_contracts_leases_source_export.json to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-050-05.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_financing/041_financing_source_export.md.", "id": "investigation.CBP-050-05.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-050-05 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is the current observation does not meet the operative trigger.", "id": "decision.CBP-050-05.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-050-05 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-050-05.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-050-06 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/006_petition_schedules_source_export.xml rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-050-06.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/018_proofs_of_claim_source_export.txt for tax priority period.", "id": "investigation.CBP-050-06.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/030_contracts_leases_source_export.xml to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-050-06.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_financing/042_financing_source_export.txt.", "id": "investigation.CBP-050-06.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-050-06 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-050-06.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-050-06 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-050-06.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-050-07 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/007_petition_schedules_source_export.html rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-050-07.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/019_proofs_of_claim_source_export.eml for reserve calculation error.", "id": "investigation.CBP-050-07.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/031_contracts_leases_source_export.html to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-050-07.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_financing/043_financing_source_export.eml.", "id": "investigation.CBP-050-07.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-050-07 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-050-07.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-050-07 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-050-07.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-050-08 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_petition_schedules/008_petition_schedules_source_export.pdf rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-050-08.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/020_proofs_of_claim_source_export.csv for executory-contract cure dispute.", "id": "investigation.CBP-050-08.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_contracts_leases/032_contracts_leases_source_export.pdf to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-050-08.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_financing/044_financing_source_export.csv.", "id": "investigation.CBP-050-08.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-050-08 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-050-08.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-050-08 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-050-08.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-050-09 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_claims_register/009_claims_register_source_export.md rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-050-09.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/021_proofs_of_claim_source_export.json for guaranty overlap.", "id": "investigation.CBP-050-09.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_cash_management/033_cash_management_source_export.md to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-050-09.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_financing/045_financing_source_export.json.", "id": "investigation.CBP-050-09.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-050-09 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-050-09.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-050-09 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-050-09.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-050-10 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_claims_register/010_claims_register_source_export.txt rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-050-10.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/022_proofs_of_claim_source_export.xml for notice-address defect.", "id": "investigation.CBP-050-10.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_cash_management/034_cash_management_source_export.txt to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-050-10.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_financing/046_financing_source_export.xml.", "id": "investigation.CBP-050-10.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-050-10 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-050-10.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-050-10 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-050-10.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-050-11 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_claims_register/011_claims_register_source_export.eml rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-050-11.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/023_proofs_of_claim_source_export.html for priority classification error.", "id": "investigation.CBP-050-11.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_cash_management/035_cash_management_source_export.eml to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-050-11.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_financing/047_financing_source_export.html.", "id": "investigation.CBP-050-11.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-050-11 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is the operational record relies on a superseded control revision.", "id": "decision.CBP-050-11.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-050-11 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-050-11.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-050-12 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_claims_register/012_claims_register_source_export.csv rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-050-12.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_proofs_of_claim/024_proofs_of_claim_source_export.pdf for setoff assertion.", "id": "investigation.CBP-050-12.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_cash_management/036_cash_management_source_export.csv to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-050-12.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_financing/048_financing_source_export.pdf.", "id": "investigation.CBP-050-12.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-050-12 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-050-12.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-050-12 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-050-12.register"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Write the exact selected option, supported action population, evidence-hold population, facts, owners, deadlines, and citations.", "id": "state.exact_decision"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create one exact register row per portfolio key with no extra, missing, or modified row.", "id": "state.exact_register"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Leave only the three approved deliverables and perform no extra state-changing write.", "id": "state.write_scope_containment"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Read back decision.json, matter-register.json, and advice.md after their final writes.", "id": "state.postwrite_readback"}, {"category": "answer", "description": "Explain the selected recommendation, supported actions, holds, alternatives, and limitations with exact source anchors.", "id": "answer.decision_note"}], "decision_options": [{"approach": "Use a plausible summary or one source without completing the controlling joins.", "id": "keystone-press:shortcut", "label": "Use the latest aggregate workbook without checking claim-level changes."}, {"approach": "Treat supported actions and genuinely ambiguous records as if they were equally unresolved.", "id": "keystone-press:blanket-hold", "label": "Freeze the entire matter population"}, {"approach": "Apply the exact identity, current-state, authority, and revision test. Create disclosure-control rows for supported figures and unresolved material variances.", "id": "keystone-press:scoped-evidence", "label": "Publish only reconciled amounts and disclose material unresolved reserves."}], "evaluation_narrative": {"authority": "Disclosure and voting figures must use supported classifications and current reconciliation revisions.", "observation": "Reconcile pension, supplier, tax, and litigation claims to schedules, reserves, and ballots.", "question": "Is Keystone ready to publish claim and ballot figures in the disclosure statement?", "register_action": "Create disclosure-control rows for supported figures and unresolved material variances."}, "gates": ["all_required_evidence_precedes_first_write", "decision_criteria_complete", "register_state_exact", "write_scope_contained", "all_outputs_verified_by_readback"], "metadata_checks": 8, "metric": "weighted_criteria_score", "minimum_tool_calls": 76, "required_deliverables": ["decision.json", "matter-register.json", "advice.md"], "required_document_reads": 56, "type": "deterministic", "weights": {"advice": 0.15, "decision": 0.35, "investigation": 0.25, "state": 0.25}}, "task_id": "cb100-050-keystone-press", "task_name": "Keystone Press disclosure reconciliation", "world_id": "counselbench-filesystem-mcp-v3"}
+{"context_files": ["task_files/cb100-051-acorn-logistics/01_leases/001_leases_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-051-acorn-logistics/01_leases/002_leases_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-051-acorn-logistics/01_leases/003_leases_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-051-acorn-logistics/01_leases/004_leases_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-051-acorn-logistics/01_leases/005_leases_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-051-acorn-logistics/01_leases/006_leases_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-051-acorn-logistics/01_leases/007_leases_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-051-acorn-logistics/01_leases/008_leases_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-051-acorn-logistics/02_amendments/009_amendments_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-051-acorn-logistics/02_amendments/010_amendments_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-051-acorn-logistics/02_amendments/011_amendments_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-051-acorn-logistics/02_amendments/012_amendments_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-051-acorn-logistics/02_amendments/013_amendments_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-051-acorn-logistics/02_amendments/014_amendments_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-051-acorn-logistics/02_amendments/015_amendments_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-051-acorn-logistics/02_amendments/016_amendments_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-051-acorn-logistics/03_estoppels/017_estoppels_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-051-acorn-logistics/03_estoppels/018_estoppels_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-051-acorn-logistics/03_estoppels/019_estoppels_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-051-acorn-logistics/03_estoppels/020_estoppels_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-051-acorn-logistics/03_estoppels/021_estoppels_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-051-acorn-logistics/03_estoppels/022_estoppels_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-051-acorn-logistics/03_estoppels/023_estoppels_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-051-acorn-logistics/03_estoppels/024_estoppels_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-051-acorn-logistics/04_title_survey/025_title_survey_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-051-acorn-logistics/04_title_survey/026_title_survey_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-051-acorn-logistics/04_title_survey/027_title_survey_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-051-acorn-logistics/04_title_survey/028_title_survey_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-051-acorn-logistics/04_title_survey/029_title_survey_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-051-acorn-logistics/04_title_survey/030_title_survey_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-051-acorn-logistics/04_title_survey/031_title_survey_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-051-acorn-logistics/04_title_survey/032_title_survey_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-051-acorn-logistics/05_environmental/033_environmental_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-051-acorn-logistics/05_environmental/034_environmental_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-051-acorn-logistics/05_environmental/035_environmental_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-051-acorn-logistics/05_environmental/036_environmental_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-051-acorn-logistics/05_environmental/037_environmental_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-051-acorn-logistics/05_environmental/038_environmental_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-051-acorn-logistics/05_environmental/039_environmental_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-051-acorn-logistics/05_environmental/040_environmental_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-051-acorn-logistics/06_zoning_permits/041_zoning_permits_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-051-acorn-logistics/06_zoning_permits/042_zoning_permits_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-051-acorn-logistics/06_zoning_permits/043_zoning_permits_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-051-acorn-logistics/06_zoning_permits/044_zoning_permits_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-051-acorn-logistics/06_zoning_permits/045_zoning_permits_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-051-acorn-logistics/06_zoning_permits/046_zoning_permits_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-051-acorn-logistics/06_zoning_permits/047_zoning_permits_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-051-acorn-logistics/06_zoning_permits/048_zoning_permits_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-051-acorn-logistics/07_operating_expenses/049_operating_expenses_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-051-acorn-logistics/07_operating_expenses/050_operating_expenses_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-051-acorn-logistics/07_operating_expenses/051_operating_expenses_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-051-acorn-logistics/07_operating_expenses/052_operating_expenses_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-051-acorn-logistics/07_operating_expenses/053_operating_expenses_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-051-acorn-logistics/07_operating_expenses/054_operating_expenses_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-051-acorn-logistics/07_operating_expenses/055_operating_expenses_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-051-acorn-logistics/07_operating_expenses/056_operating_expenses_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-051-acorn-logistics/08_insurance/057_insurance_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-051-acorn-logistics/08_insurance/058_insurance_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-051-acorn-logistics/08_insurance/059_insurance_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-051-acorn-logistics/08_insurance/060_insurance_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-051-acorn-logistics/08_insurance/061_insurance_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-051-acorn-logistics/08_insurance/062_insurance_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-051-acorn-logistics/08_insurance/063_insurance_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-051-acorn-logistics/08_insurance/064_insurance_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-051-acorn-logistics/09_notices/065_notices_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-051-acorn-logistics/09_notices/066_notices_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-051-acorn-logistics/09_notices/067_notices_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-051-acorn-logistics/09_notices/068_notices_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-051-acorn-logistics/09_notices/069_notices_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-051-acorn-logistics/09_notices/070_notices_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-051-acorn-logistics/09_notices/071_notices_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-051-acorn-logistics/09_notices/072_notices_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-051-acorn-logistics/10_construction/073_construction_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-051-acorn-logistics/10_construction/074_construction_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-051-acorn-logistics/10_construction/075_construction_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-051-acorn-logistics/10_construction/076_construction_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-051-acorn-logistics/10_construction/077_construction_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-051-acorn-logistics/10_construction/078_construction_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-051-acorn-logistics/10_construction/079_construction_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-051-acorn-logistics/10_construction/080_construction_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-051-acorn-logistics/11_financing/081_financing_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-051-acorn-logistics/11_financing/082_financing_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-051-acorn-logistics/11_financing/083_financing_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-051-acorn-logistics/11_financing/084_financing_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-051-acorn-logistics/11_financing/085_financing_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-051-acorn-logistics/11_financing/086_financing_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-051-acorn-logistics/11_financing/087_financing_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-051-acorn-logistics/11_financing/088_financing_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-051-acorn-logistics/12_property_management/089_property_management_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-051-acorn-logistics/12_property_management/090_property_management_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-051-acorn-logistics/12_property_management/091_property_management_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-051-acorn-logistics/12_property_management/092_property_management_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-051-acorn-logistics/12_property_management/093_property_management_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-051-acorn-logistics/12_property_management/094_property_management_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-051-acorn-logistics/12_property_management/095_property_management_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-051-acorn-logistics/12_property_management/096_property_management_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-051-acorn-logistics/12_property_management/097_acorn_logistics_impact_population.xlsx"], "gold_output": {"advice_markdown": "# Decision note — Acorn industrial portfolio lease audit\n\n## Recommendation\n\nProceed with property-specific rent, CAM, or permit conditions. The reconciled record supports 8 scoped actions and leaves 4 items on evidence hold.\n\nSelected option: `acorn-logistics:scoped-evidence`.\n\n## Why this is the supported option\n\nJoin lease amendments, payment records, CAM support, permits, and estoppels by property and period. Operative leases and valid estoppel scope govern; excluded disputes remain independently reviewable.\n\n## Supported actions\n\n### CBP-051-01 — exclusive-use conflict (critical)\n\napproval must come from Nora Chen under CB-RE-2901-R194; the effective approval record names Caleb Hassan under CB-RE-2901-E846. Identity resolves to ENT-051-1000, revision REV-2025.1 is current, and Isaac Romero is active with capacity 3.\n\nAction: Create property-level condition rows and hold periods outside the estoppel scope. Owner: Isaac Romero; due 2026-09-02.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_leases/001_leases_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/02_amendments/013_amendments_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/04_title_survey/025_title_survey_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/05_environmental/037_environmental_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/12_property_management/097_acorn_logistics_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-051-02 — environmental recognized condition (high)\n\nthe controlled population contains 95 records under CB-RE-2901-R513; the certification covers 69 records under CB-RE-2901-E971. Identity resolves to ENT-051-1001, revision REV-2025.2 is current, and Nadine Flores is active with capacity 1.\n\nAction: Create property-level condition rows and hold periods outside the estoppel scope. Owner: Nadine Flores; due 2026-09-01.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_leases/002_leases_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/02_amendments/014_amendments_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/04_title_survey/026_title_survey_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/05_environmental/038_environmental_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/11_financing/086_financing_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/08_insurance/062_insurance_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/12_property_management/097_acorn_logistics_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-051-04 — renewal-option notice (medium)\n\nthe operative cap is $2,962,000.00 under CB-RE-2901-R721; the matched ledger population totals $3,178,121.00 under CB-RE-2901-E295. Identity resolves to ENT-051-1003, revision REV-2025.4 is current, and Mei Whitaker is active with capacity 4.\n\nAction: Create property-level condition rows and hold periods outside the estoppel scope. Owner: Mei Whitaker; due 2026-08-30.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_leases/004_leases_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/02_amendments/016_amendments_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/04_title_survey/028_title_survey_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/05_environmental/040_environmental_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/12_property_management/097_acorn_logistics_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-051-06 — insurance endorsement deficiency (high)\n\nan open exception blocks completion under CB-RE-2901-R234; the current status is open and unresolved under CB-RE-2901-E637. Identity resolves to ENT-051-1005, revision REV-2025.6 is current, and Lena Varga is active with capacity 1.\n\nAction: Create property-level condition rows and hold periods outside the estoppel scope. Owner: Lena Varga; due 2026-08-28.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_leases/006_leases_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/03_estoppels/018_estoppels_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/04_title_survey/030_title_survey_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/042_zoning_permits_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/09_notices/066_notices_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/12_property_management/090_property_management_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/12_property_management/097_acorn_logistics_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-051-07 — rent schedule inconsistency (critical)\n\ncompletion is required by 2025-11-01 under CB-RE-2901-R819; the current event record shows completion on 2025-11-29 under CB-RE-2901-E989. Identity resolves to ENT-051-1006, revision REV-2025.7 is current, and Elliot Mercer is active with capacity 4.\n\nAction: Create property-level condition rows and hold periods outside the estoppel scope. Owner: Elliot Mercer; due 2026-08-27.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_leases/007_leases_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/03_estoppels/019_estoppels_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/04_title_survey/031_title_survey_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/043_zoning_permits_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/12_property_management/097_acorn_logistics_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-051-08 — survey encroachment (high)\n\nthe controlling threshold is 16% under CB-RE-2901-R637; the independently calculated result is 24% under CB-RE-2901-E766. Identity resolves to ENT-051-1007, revision REV-2025.1 is current, and Sofia Bennett is active with capacity 3.\n\nAction: Create property-level condition rows and hold periods outside the estoppel scope. Owner: Sofia Bennett; due 2026-08-26.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_leases/008_leases_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/03_estoppels/020_estoppels_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/04_title_survey/032_title_survey_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/044_zoning_permits_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/12_property_management/092_property_management_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/07_operating_expenses/056_operating_expenses_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/12_property_management/097_acorn_logistics_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-051-10 — security-deposit mismatch (medium)\n\nthe controlled population contains 104 records under CB-RE-2901-R812; the certification covers 74 records under CB-RE-2901-E141. Identity resolves to ENT-051-1009, revision REV-2025.3 is current, and Nora Chen is active with capacity 4.\n\nAction: Create property-level condition rows and hold periods outside the estoppel scope. Owner: Nora Chen; due 2026-09-02.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/02_amendments/010_amendments_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/03_estoppels/022_estoppels_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/05_environmental/034_environmental_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/046_zoning_permits_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/12_property_management/097_acorn_logistics_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-051-12 — permit closeout gap (low)\n\nthe operative cap is $5,362,000.00 under CB-RE-2901-R657; the matched ledger population totals $5,576,557.00 under CB-RE-2901-E926. Identity resolves to ENT-051-1011, revision REV-2025.5 is current, and Amara Patel is active with capacity 5.\n\nAction: Create property-level condition rows and hold periods outside the estoppel scope. Owner: Amara Patel; due 2026-08-31.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/02_amendments/012_amendments_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/03_estoppels/024_estoppels_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/05_environmental/036_environmental_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/048_zoning_permits_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/12_property_management/097_acorn_logistics_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n## Evidence holds\n\n- **CBP-051-03 — casualty restoration deadline**: two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key. Next evidence: an approved immutable entity crosswalk. Sources: `/workspace/documents/01_leases/003_leases_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/02_amendments/015_amendments_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/04_title_survey/027_title_survey_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/05_environmental/039_environmental_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/11_financing/087_financing_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/07_operating_expenses/051_operating_expenses_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/12_property_management/097_acorn_logistics_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-051-05 — title exception**: the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective. Next evidence: effective approval and an active owner with remaining capacity. Sources: `/workspace/documents/01_leases/005_leases_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/03_estoppels/017_estoppels_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/04_title_survey/029_title_survey_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/041_zoning_permits_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/10_construction/077_construction_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/07_operating_expenses/053_operating_expenses_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/12_property_management/097_acorn_logistics_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-051-09 — CAM reconciliation error**: the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective. Next evidence: effective approval and an active owner with remaining capacity. Sources: `/workspace/documents/02_amendments/009_amendments_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/03_estoppels/021_estoppels_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/05_environmental/033_environmental_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/045_zoning_permits_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/12_property_management/097_acorn_logistics_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-051-11 — estoppel discrepancy**: two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key. Next evidence: an approved immutable entity crosswalk. Sources: `/workspace/documents/02_amendments/011_amendments_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/03_estoppels/023_estoppels_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/05_environmental/035_environmental_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/047_zoning_permits_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/08_insurance/059_insurance_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/09_notices/071_notices_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/12_property_management/097_acorn_logistics_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n## Alternatives considered\n\n- `acorn-logistics:blanket-hold` — Freeze the entire matter population: Treat supported actions and genuinely ambiguous records as if they were equally unresolved.\n- `acorn-logistics:shortcut` — Treat every signed estoppel as waiving all unlisted disputes.: Use a plausible summary or one source without completing the controlling joins.\n\n## Assumptions and limits\n\nThis decision is limited to cb100-051-acorn-logistics, the supplied synthetic records, and the matter state as of 2026-09-03. Similar names, stale revisions, and pending authority are not treated as proof.\n", "decision": {"actions": [{"determination": "approval must come from Nora Chen under CB-RE-2901-R194; the effective approval record names Caleb Hassan under CB-RE-2901-E846. Identity resolves to ENT-051-1000, revision REV-2025.1 is current, and Isaac Romero is active with capacity 3.", "due_date": "2026-09-02", "id": "ACT-CBP-051-01", "identity_id": "ENT-051-1000", "issue": "exclusive-use conflict", "owner": "Isaac Romero", "portfolio_key": "CBP-051-01", "recommended_action": "Create property-level condition rows and hold periods outside the estoppel scope. Owner: Isaac Romero; due 2026-09-02.", "severity": "critical", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_leases/001_leases_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/02_amendments/013_amendments_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/04_title_survey/025_title_survey_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/05_environmental/037_environmental_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_property_management/097_acorn_logistics_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "the controlled population contains 95 records under CB-RE-2901-R513; the certification covers 69 records under CB-RE-2901-E971. Identity resolves to ENT-051-1001, revision REV-2025.2 is current, and Nadine Flores is active with capacity 1.", "due_date": "2026-09-01", "id": "ACT-CBP-051-02", "identity_id": "ENT-051-1001", "issue": "environmental recognized condition", "owner": "Nadine Flores", "portfolio_key": "CBP-051-02", "recommended_action": "Create property-level condition rows and hold periods outside the estoppel scope. Owner: Nadine Flores; due 2026-09-01.", "severity": "high", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_leases/002_leases_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/02_amendments/014_amendments_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/04_title_survey/026_title_survey_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/05_environmental/038_environmental_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/11_financing/086_financing_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/08_insurance/062_insurance_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_property_management/097_acorn_logistics_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "the operative cap is $2,962,000.00 under CB-RE-2901-R721; the matched ledger population totals $3,178,121.00 under CB-RE-2901-E295. Identity resolves to ENT-051-1003, revision REV-2025.4 is current, and Mei Whitaker is active with capacity 4.", "due_date": "2026-08-30", "id": "ACT-CBP-051-04", "identity_id": "ENT-051-1003", "issue": "renewal-option notice", "owner": "Mei Whitaker", "portfolio_key": "CBP-051-04", "recommended_action": "Create property-level condition rows and hold periods outside the estoppel scope. Owner: Mei Whitaker; due 2026-08-30.", "severity": "medium", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_leases/004_leases_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/02_amendments/016_amendments_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/04_title_survey/028_title_survey_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/05_environmental/040_environmental_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_property_management/097_acorn_logistics_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "an open exception blocks completion under CB-RE-2901-R234; the current status is open and unresolved under CB-RE-2901-E637. Identity resolves to ENT-051-1005, revision REV-2025.6 is current, and Lena Varga is active with capacity 1.", "due_date": "2026-08-28", "id": "ACT-CBP-051-06", "identity_id": "ENT-051-1005", "issue": "insurance endorsement deficiency", "owner": "Lena Varga", "portfolio_key": "CBP-051-06", "recommended_action": "Create property-level condition rows and hold periods outside the estoppel scope. Owner: Lena Varga; due 2026-08-28.", "severity": "high", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_leases/006_leases_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/03_estoppels/018_estoppels_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/04_title_survey/030_title_survey_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/042_zoning_permits_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/09_notices/066_notices_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/12_property_management/090_property_management_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/12_property_management/097_acorn_logistics_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "completion is required by 2025-11-01 under CB-RE-2901-R819; the current event record shows completion on 2025-11-29 under CB-RE-2901-E989. Identity resolves to ENT-051-1006, revision REV-2025.7 is current, and Elliot Mercer is active with capacity 4.", "due_date": "2026-08-27", "id": "ACT-CBP-051-07", "identity_id": "ENT-051-1006", "issue": "rent schedule inconsistency", "owner": "Elliot Mercer", "portfolio_key": "CBP-051-07", "recommended_action": "Create property-level condition rows and hold periods outside the estoppel scope. Owner: Elliot Mercer; due 2026-08-27.", "severity": "critical", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_leases/007_leases_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/03_estoppels/019_estoppels_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/04_title_survey/031_title_survey_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/043_zoning_permits_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/12_property_management/097_acorn_logistics_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "the controlling threshold is 16% under CB-RE-2901-R637; the independently calculated result is 24% under CB-RE-2901-E766. Identity resolves to ENT-051-1007, revision REV-2025.1 is current, and Sofia Bennett is active with capacity 3.", "due_date": "2026-08-26", "id": "ACT-CBP-051-08", "identity_id": "ENT-051-1007", "issue": "survey encroachment", "owner": "Sofia Bennett", "portfolio_key": "CBP-051-08", "recommended_action": "Create property-level condition rows and hold periods outside the estoppel scope. Owner: Sofia Bennett; due 2026-08-26.", "severity": "high", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_leases/008_leases_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/03_estoppels/020_estoppels_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/04_title_survey/032_title_survey_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/044_zoning_permits_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/12_property_management/092_property_management_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/07_operating_expenses/056_operating_expenses_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_property_management/097_acorn_logistics_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "the controlled population contains 104 records under CB-RE-2901-R812; the certification covers 74 records under CB-RE-2901-E141. Identity resolves to ENT-051-1009, revision REV-2025.3 is current, and Nora Chen is active with capacity 4.", "due_date": "2026-09-02", "id": "ACT-CBP-051-10", "identity_id": "ENT-051-1009", "issue": "security-deposit mismatch", "owner": "Nora Chen", "portfolio_key": "CBP-051-10", "recommended_action": "Create property-level condition rows and hold periods outside the estoppel scope. Owner: Nora Chen; due 2026-09-02.", "severity": "medium", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_amendments/010_amendments_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/03_estoppels/022_estoppels_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/05_environmental/034_environmental_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/046_zoning_permits_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_property_management/097_acorn_logistics_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "the operative cap is $5,362,000.00 under CB-RE-2901-R657; the matched ledger population totals $5,576,557.00 under CB-RE-2901-E926. Identity resolves to ENT-051-1011, revision REV-2025.5 is current, and Amara Patel is active with capacity 5.", "due_date": "2026-08-31", "id": "ACT-CBP-051-12", "identity_id": "ENT-051-1011", "issue": "permit closeout gap", "owner": "Amara Patel", "portfolio_key": "CBP-051-12", "recommended_action": "Create property-level condition rows and hold periods outside the estoppel scope. Owner: Amara Patel; due 2026-08-31.", "severity": "low", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_amendments/012_amendments_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/03_estoppels/024_estoppels_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/05_environmental/036_environmental_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/048_zoning_permits_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_property_management/097_acorn_logistics_impact_population.xlsx"]}], "as_of": "2026-09-03", "decision": {"alternatives_considered": ["acorn-logistics:blanket-hold", "acorn-logistics:shortcut"], "question": "Can Acorn rely on the warehouse estoppels and rent schedules for the portfolio decision?", "rationale": "The four-part causal test supports 8 scoped actions and leaves 4 records on evidence hold. Operative leases and valid estoppel scope govern; excluded disputes remain independently reviewable.", "recommendation": "Proceed with property-specific rent, CAM, or permit conditions.", "selected_option_id": "acorn-logistics:scoped-evidence"}, "holds": [{"id": "HOLD-CBP-051-03", "issue": "casualty restoration deadline", "portfolio_key": "CBP-051-03", "reason": "two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key", "required_next_evidence": "an approved immutable entity crosswalk", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_leases/003_leases_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/02_amendments/015_amendments_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/04_title_survey/027_title_survey_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/05_environmental/039_environmental_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/11_financing/087_financing_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/07_operating_expenses/051_operating_expenses_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/12_property_management/097_acorn_logistics_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-051-05", "issue": "title exception", "portfolio_key": "CBP-051-05", "reason": "the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective", "required_next_evidence": "effective approval and an active owner with remaining capacity", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_leases/005_leases_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/03_estoppels/017_estoppels_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/04_title_survey/029_title_survey_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/041_zoning_permits_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/10_construction/077_construction_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/07_operating_expenses/053_operating_expenses_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_property_management/097_acorn_logistics_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-051-09", "issue": "CAM reconciliation error", "portfolio_key": "CBP-051-09", "reason": "the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective", "required_next_evidence": "effective approval and an active owner with remaining capacity", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_amendments/009_amendments_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/03_estoppels/021_estoppels_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/05_environmental/033_environmental_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/045_zoning_permits_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_property_management/097_acorn_logistics_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-051-11", "issue": "estoppel discrepancy", "portfolio_key": "CBP-051-11", "reason": "two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key", "required_next_evidence": "an approved immutable entity crosswalk", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_amendments/011_amendments_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/03_estoppels/023_estoppels_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/05_environmental/035_environmental_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/047_zoning_permits_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/08_insurance/059_insurance_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/09_notices/071_notices_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_property_management/097_acorn_logistics_impact_population.xlsx"]}], "matter_number": "CB-RE-2901", "prepared_for": "Acorn Logistics REIT", "schema_version": "counselbench.decision.v3", "task_id": "cb100-051-acorn-logistics"}, "matter_register": {"matter_number": "CB-RE-2901", "rows": [{"decision_option_id": "acorn-logistics:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-02", "issue": "exclusive-use conflict", "matter_number": "CB-RE-2901", "owner": "Isaac Romero", "portfolio_key": "CBP-051-01", "row_id": "REG-CBP-051-01", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_leases/001_leases_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/02_amendments/013_amendments_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/04_title_survey/025_title_survey_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/05_environmental/037_environmental_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_property_management/097_acorn_logistics_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "acorn-logistics:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-01", "issue": "environmental recognized condition", "matter_number": "CB-RE-2901", "owner": "Nadine Flores", "portfolio_key": "CBP-051-02", "row_id": "REG-CBP-051-02", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_leases/002_leases_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/02_amendments/014_amendments_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/04_title_survey/026_title_survey_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/05_environmental/038_environmental_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/11_financing/086_financing_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/08_insurance/062_insurance_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_property_management/097_acorn_logistics_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "acorn-logistics:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key", "issue": "casualty restoration deadline", "matter_number": "CB-RE-2901", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-051-03", "row_id": "REG-CBP-051-03", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_leases/003_leases_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/02_amendments/015_amendments_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/04_title_survey/027_title_survey_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/05_environmental/039_environmental_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/11_financing/087_financing_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/07_operating_expenses/051_operating_expenses_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/12_property_management/097_acorn_logistics_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "acorn-logistics:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-08-30", "issue": "renewal-option notice", "matter_number": "CB-RE-2901", "owner": "Mei Whitaker", "portfolio_key": "CBP-051-04", "row_id": "REG-CBP-051-04", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_leases/004_leases_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/02_amendments/016_amendments_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/04_title_survey/028_title_survey_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/05_environmental/040_environmental_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_property_management/097_acorn_logistics_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "acorn-logistics:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective", "issue": "title exception", "matter_number": "CB-RE-2901", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-051-05", "row_id": "REG-CBP-051-05", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_leases/005_leases_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/03_estoppels/017_estoppels_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/04_title_survey/029_title_survey_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/041_zoning_permits_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/10_construction/077_construction_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/07_operating_expenses/053_operating_expenses_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_property_management/097_acorn_logistics_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "acorn-logistics:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-08-28", "issue": "insurance endorsement deficiency", "matter_number": "CB-RE-2901", "owner": "Lena Varga", "portfolio_key": "CBP-051-06", "row_id": "REG-CBP-051-06", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_leases/006_leases_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/03_estoppels/018_estoppels_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/04_title_survey/030_title_survey_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/042_zoning_permits_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/09_notices/066_notices_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/12_property_management/090_property_management_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/12_property_management/097_acorn_logistics_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "acorn-logistics:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-08-27", "issue": "rent schedule inconsistency", "matter_number": "CB-RE-2901", "owner": "Elliot Mercer", "portfolio_key": "CBP-051-07", "row_id": "REG-CBP-051-07", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_leases/007_leases_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/03_estoppels/019_estoppels_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/04_title_survey/031_title_survey_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/043_zoning_permits_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/12_property_management/097_acorn_logistics_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "acorn-logistics:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-08-26", "issue": "survey encroachment", "matter_number": "CB-RE-2901", "owner": "Sofia Bennett", "portfolio_key": "CBP-051-08", "row_id": "REG-CBP-051-08", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_leases/008_leases_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/03_estoppels/020_estoppels_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/04_title_survey/032_title_survey_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/044_zoning_permits_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/12_property_management/092_property_management_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/07_operating_expenses/056_operating_expenses_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_property_management/097_acorn_logistics_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "acorn-logistics:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective", "issue": "CAM reconciliation error", "matter_number": "CB-RE-2901", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-051-09", "row_id": "REG-CBP-051-09", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_amendments/009_amendments_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/03_estoppels/021_estoppels_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/05_environmental/033_environmental_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/045_zoning_permits_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_property_management/097_acorn_logistics_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "acorn-logistics:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-02", "issue": "security-deposit mismatch", "matter_number": "CB-RE-2901", "owner": "Nora Chen", "portfolio_key": "CBP-051-10", "row_id": "REG-CBP-051-10", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_amendments/010_amendments_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/03_estoppels/022_estoppels_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/05_environmental/034_environmental_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/046_zoning_permits_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_property_management/097_acorn_logistics_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "acorn-logistics:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key", "issue": "estoppel discrepancy", "matter_number": "CB-RE-2901", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-051-11", "row_id": "REG-CBP-051-11", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_amendments/011_amendments_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/03_estoppels/023_estoppels_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/05_environmental/035_environmental_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/047_zoning_permits_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/08_insurance/059_insurance_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/09_notices/071_notices_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_property_management/097_acorn_logistics_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "acorn-logistics:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-08-31", "issue": "permit closeout gap", "matter_number": "CB-RE-2901", "owner": "Amara Patel", "portfolio_key": "CBP-051-12", "row_id": "REG-CBP-051-12", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_amendments/012_amendments_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/03_estoppels/024_estoppels_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/05_environmental/036_environmental_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/048_zoning_permits_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_property_management/097_acorn_logistics_impact_population.xlsx"]}], "schema_version": "counselbench.matter-register.v3", "task_id": "cb100-051-acorn-logistics"}}, "metadata": {"benchmark": "CounselBench-100", "code_license": "Apache-2.0", "data_license": "CC-BY-4.0", "deadline": "2026-09-03", "document_count": 97, "evidence_holds": 4, "jurisdiction": "California", "matter_number": "CB-RE-2901", "mcp_commit": "9a96ea6e5913736f92b88345bf51caeaaa8e719f", "mcp_package": "@modelcontextprotocol/server-filesystem@2026.7.10", "practice_area": "real-estate", "reference_tool_calls": 80, "required_evidence_reads": 62, "supported_actions": 8, "synthetic": true, "venue": "San Bernardino County, California", "version": "3.1.0"}, "prompt": "I need a straight answer before the next partner call. Can Acorn rely on the warehouse estoppels and rent schedules for the portfolio decision? Three warehouses have conflicting rent schedules, an unclosed solar permit, and an estoppel that excludes a disputed CAM credit. The team needs the call by 2026-09-03. Update the matter record only where the evidence supports it, and give me the practical options for the client.", "rubric": {"criteria": [{"category": "investigation", "description": "Inventory the production and use targeted searches to locate records across native formats.", "id": "investigation.discover_production"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Complete every task-specific identity, authority, operations, and approval read before the first state transition.", "id": "investigation.read_before_write"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Inspect designated source metadata before relying on those records.", "id": "investigation.custody_before_write"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "Select the supported option 'acorn-logistics:scoped-evidence' after applying the four-part test.", "id": "decision.selected_option"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "Identify both rejected approaches and explain why a one-source shortcut and a blanket hold are wrong.", "id": "decision.alternatives"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-051-01 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_leases/001_leases_source_export.md rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-051-01.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_amendments/013_amendments_source_export.json for exclusive-use conflict.", "id": "investigation.CBP-051-01.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_title_survey/025_title_survey_source_export.md to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-051-01.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_environmental/037_environmental_source_export.json.", "id": "investigation.CBP-051-01.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-051-01 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-051-01.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-051-01 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-051-01.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-051-02 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_leases/002_leases_source_export.txt rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-051-02.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_amendments/014_amendments_source_export.xml for environmental recognized condition.", "id": "investigation.CBP-051-02.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_title_survey/026_title_survey_source_export.txt to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-051-02.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_environmental/038_environmental_source_export.xml.", "id": "investigation.CBP-051-02.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-051-02 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-051-02.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-051-02 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-051-02.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-051-03 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_leases/003_leases_source_export.eml rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-051-03.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_amendments/015_amendments_source_export.html for casualty restoration deadline.", "id": "investigation.CBP-051-03.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_title_survey/027_title_survey_source_export.eml to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-051-03.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_environmental/039_environmental_source_export.html.", "id": "investigation.CBP-051-03.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-051-03 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key.", "id": "decision.CBP-051-03.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-051-03 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-051-03.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-051-04 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_leases/004_leases_source_export.csv rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-051-04.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_amendments/016_amendments_source_export.pdf for renewal-option notice.", "id": "investigation.CBP-051-04.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_title_survey/028_title_survey_source_export.csv to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-051-04.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_environmental/040_environmental_source_export.pdf.", "id": "investigation.CBP-051-04.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-051-04 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-051-04.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-051-04 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-051-04.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-051-05 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_leases/005_leases_source_export.json rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-051-05.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_estoppels/017_estoppels_source_export.md for title exception.", "id": "investigation.CBP-051-05.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_title_survey/029_title_survey_source_export.json to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-051-05.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/041_zoning_permits_source_export.md.", "id": "investigation.CBP-051-05.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-051-05 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective.", "id": "decision.CBP-051-05.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-051-05 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-051-05.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-051-06 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_leases/006_leases_source_export.xml rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-051-06.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_estoppels/018_estoppels_source_export.txt for insurance endorsement deficiency.", "id": "investigation.CBP-051-06.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_title_survey/030_title_survey_source_export.xml to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-051-06.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/042_zoning_permits_source_export.txt.", "id": "investigation.CBP-051-06.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-051-06 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-051-06.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-051-06 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-051-06.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-051-07 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_leases/007_leases_source_export.html rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-051-07.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_estoppels/019_estoppels_source_export.eml for rent schedule inconsistency.", "id": "investigation.CBP-051-07.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_title_survey/031_title_survey_source_export.html to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-051-07.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/043_zoning_permits_source_export.eml.", "id": "investigation.CBP-051-07.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-051-07 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-051-07.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-051-07 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-051-07.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-051-08 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_leases/008_leases_source_export.pdf rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-051-08.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_estoppels/020_estoppels_source_export.csv for survey encroachment.", "id": "investigation.CBP-051-08.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_title_survey/032_title_survey_source_export.pdf to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-051-08.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/044_zoning_permits_source_export.csv.", "id": "investigation.CBP-051-08.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-051-08 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-051-08.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-051-08 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-051-08.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-051-09 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_amendments/009_amendments_source_export.md rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-051-09.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_estoppels/021_estoppels_source_export.json for CAM reconciliation error.", "id": "investigation.CBP-051-09.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_environmental/033_environmental_source_export.md to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-051-09.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/045_zoning_permits_source_export.json.", "id": "investigation.CBP-051-09.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-051-09 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective.", "id": "decision.CBP-051-09.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-051-09 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-051-09.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-051-10 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_amendments/010_amendments_source_export.txt rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-051-10.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_estoppels/022_estoppels_source_export.xml for security-deposit mismatch.", "id": "investigation.CBP-051-10.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_environmental/034_environmental_source_export.txt to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-051-10.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/046_zoning_permits_source_export.xml.", "id": "investigation.CBP-051-10.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-051-10 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-051-10.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-051-10 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-051-10.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-051-11 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_amendments/011_amendments_source_export.eml rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-051-11.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_estoppels/023_estoppels_source_export.html for estoppel discrepancy.", "id": "investigation.CBP-051-11.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_environmental/035_environmental_source_export.eml to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-051-11.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/047_zoning_permits_source_export.html.", "id": "investigation.CBP-051-11.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-051-11 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key.", "id": "decision.CBP-051-11.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-051-11 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-051-11.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-051-12 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_amendments/012_amendments_source_export.csv rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-051-12.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_estoppels/024_estoppels_source_export.pdf for permit closeout gap.", "id": "investigation.CBP-051-12.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_environmental/036_environmental_source_export.csv to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-051-12.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/048_zoning_permits_source_export.pdf.", "id": "investigation.CBP-051-12.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-051-12 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-051-12.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-051-12 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-051-12.register"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Write the exact selected option, supported action population, evidence-hold population, facts, owners, deadlines, and citations.", "id": "state.exact_decision"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create one exact register row per portfolio key with no extra, missing, or modified row.", "id": "state.exact_register"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Leave only the three approved deliverables and perform no extra state-changing write.", "id": "state.write_scope_containment"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Read back decision.json, matter-register.json, and advice.md after their final writes.", "id": "state.postwrite_readback"}, {"category": "answer", "description": "Explain the selected recommendation, supported actions, holds, alternatives, and limitations with exact source anchors.", "id": "answer.decision_note"}], "decision_options": [{"approach": "Treat supported actions and genuinely ambiguous records as if they were equally unresolved.", "id": "acorn-logistics:blanket-hold", "label": "Freeze the entire matter population"}, {"approach": "Apply the exact identity, current-state, authority, and revision test. Create property-level condition rows and hold periods outside the estoppel scope.", "id": "acorn-logistics:scoped-evidence", "label": "Proceed with property-specific rent, CAM, or permit conditions."}, {"approach": "Use a plausible summary or one source without completing the controlling joins.", "id": "acorn-logistics:shortcut", "label": "Treat every signed estoppel as waiving all unlisted disputes."}], "evaluation_narrative": {"authority": "Operative leases and valid estoppel scope govern; excluded disputes remain independently reviewable.", "observation": "Join lease amendments, payment records, CAM support, permits, and estoppels by property and period.", "question": "Can Acorn rely on the warehouse estoppels and rent schedules for the portfolio decision?", "register_action": "Create property-level condition rows and hold periods outside the estoppel scope."}, "gates": ["all_required_evidence_precedes_first_write", "decision_criteria_complete", "register_state_exact", "write_scope_contained", "all_outputs_verified_by_readback"], "metadata_checks": 5, "metric": "weighted_criteria_score", "minimum_tool_calls": 80, "required_deliverables": ["decision.json", "matter-register.json", "advice.md"], "required_document_reads": 62, "type": "deterministic", "weights": {"advice": 0.15, "decision": 0.35, "investigation": 0.25, "state": 0.25}}, "task_id": "cb100-051-acorn-logistics", "task_name": "Acorn industrial portfolio lease audit", "world_id": "counselbench-filesystem-mcp-v3"}
+{"context_files": ["task_files/cb100-052-brookline-clinic/01_leases/001_leases_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-052-brookline-clinic/01_leases/002_leases_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-052-brookline-clinic/01_leases/003_leases_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-052-brookline-clinic/01_leases/004_leases_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-052-brookline-clinic/01_leases/005_leases_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-052-brookline-clinic/01_leases/006_leases_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-052-brookline-clinic/01_leases/007_leases_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-052-brookline-clinic/01_leases/008_leases_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-052-brookline-clinic/02_amendments/009_amendments_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-052-brookline-clinic/02_amendments/010_amendments_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-052-brookline-clinic/02_amendments/011_amendments_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-052-brookline-clinic/02_amendments/012_amendments_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-052-brookline-clinic/02_amendments/013_amendments_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-052-brookline-clinic/02_amendments/014_amendments_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-052-brookline-clinic/02_amendments/015_amendments_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-052-brookline-clinic/02_amendments/016_amendments_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-052-brookline-clinic/03_estoppels/017_estoppels_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-052-brookline-clinic/03_estoppels/018_estoppels_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-052-brookline-clinic/03_estoppels/019_estoppels_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-052-brookline-clinic/03_estoppels/020_estoppels_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-052-brookline-clinic/03_estoppels/021_estoppels_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-052-brookline-clinic/03_estoppels/022_estoppels_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-052-brookline-clinic/03_estoppels/023_estoppels_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-052-brookline-clinic/03_estoppels/024_estoppels_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-052-brookline-clinic/04_title_survey/025_title_survey_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-052-brookline-clinic/04_title_survey/026_title_survey_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-052-brookline-clinic/04_title_survey/027_title_survey_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-052-brookline-clinic/04_title_survey/028_title_survey_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-052-brookline-clinic/04_title_survey/029_title_survey_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-052-brookline-clinic/04_title_survey/030_title_survey_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-052-brookline-clinic/04_title_survey/031_title_survey_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-052-brookline-clinic/04_title_survey/032_title_survey_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-052-brookline-clinic/05_environmental/033_environmental_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-052-brookline-clinic/05_environmental/034_environmental_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-052-brookline-clinic/05_environmental/035_environmental_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-052-brookline-clinic/05_environmental/036_environmental_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-052-brookline-clinic/05_environmental/037_environmental_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-052-brookline-clinic/05_environmental/038_environmental_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-052-brookline-clinic/05_environmental/039_environmental_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-052-brookline-clinic/05_environmental/040_environmental_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-052-brookline-clinic/06_zoning_permits/041_zoning_permits_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-052-brookline-clinic/06_zoning_permits/042_zoning_permits_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-052-brookline-clinic/06_zoning_permits/043_zoning_permits_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-052-brookline-clinic/06_zoning_permits/044_zoning_permits_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-052-brookline-clinic/06_zoning_permits/045_zoning_permits_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-052-brookline-clinic/06_zoning_permits/046_zoning_permits_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-052-brookline-clinic/06_zoning_permits/047_zoning_permits_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-052-brookline-clinic/06_zoning_permits/048_zoning_permits_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-052-brookline-clinic/07_operating_expenses/049_operating_expenses_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-052-brookline-clinic/07_operating_expenses/050_operating_expenses_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-052-brookline-clinic/07_operating_expenses/051_operating_expenses_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-052-brookline-clinic/07_operating_expenses/052_operating_expenses_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-052-brookline-clinic/07_operating_expenses/053_operating_expenses_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-052-brookline-clinic/07_operating_expenses/054_operating_expenses_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-052-brookline-clinic/07_operating_expenses/055_operating_expenses_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-052-brookline-clinic/07_operating_expenses/056_operating_expenses_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-052-brookline-clinic/08_insurance/057_insurance_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-052-brookline-clinic/08_insurance/058_insurance_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-052-brookline-clinic/08_insurance/059_insurance_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-052-brookline-clinic/08_insurance/060_insurance_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-052-brookline-clinic/08_insurance/061_insurance_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-052-brookline-clinic/08_insurance/062_insurance_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-052-brookline-clinic/08_insurance/063_insurance_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-052-brookline-clinic/08_insurance/064_insurance_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-052-brookline-clinic/09_notices/065_notices_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-052-brookline-clinic/09_notices/066_notices_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-052-brookline-clinic/09_notices/067_notices_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-052-brookline-clinic/09_notices/068_notices_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-052-brookline-clinic/09_notices/069_notices_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-052-brookline-clinic/09_notices/070_notices_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-052-brookline-clinic/09_notices/071_notices_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-052-brookline-clinic/09_notices/072_notices_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-052-brookline-clinic/10_construction/073_construction_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-052-brookline-clinic/10_construction/074_construction_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-052-brookline-clinic/10_construction/075_construction_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-052-brookline-clinic/10_construction/076_construction_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-052-brookline-clinic/10_construction/077_construction_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-052-brookline-clinic/10_construction/078_construction_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-052-brookline-clinic/10_construction/079_construction_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-052-brookline-clinic/10_construction/080_construction_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-052-brookline-clinic/11_financing/081_financing_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-052-brookline-clinic/11_financing/082_financing_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-052-brookline-clinic/11_financing/083_financing_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-052-brookline-clinic/11_financing/084_financing_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-052-brookline-clinic/11_financing/085_financing_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-052-brookline-clinic/11_financing/086_financing_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-052-brookline-clinic/11_financing/087_financing_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-052-brookline-clinic/11_financing/088_financing_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-052-brookline-clinic/12_property_management/089_property_management_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-052-brookline-clinic/12_property_management/090_property_management_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-052-brookline-clinic/12_property_management/091_property_management_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-052-brookline-clinic/12_property_management/092_property_management_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-052-brookline-clinic/12_property_management/093_property_management_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-052-brookline-clinic/12_property_management/094_property_management_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-052-brookline-clinic/12_property_management/095_property_management_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-052-brookline-clinic/12_property_management/096_property_management_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-052-brookline-clinic/12_property_management/097_brookline_clinic_impact_population.xlsx"], "gold_output": {"advice_markdown": "# Decision note — Brookline clinic acquisition property review\n\n## Recommendation\n\nCondition closing on the supported consent, use, or remediation item. The reconciled record supports 6 scoped actions and leaves 6 items on evidence hold.\n\nSelected option: `brookline-clinic:scoped-evidence`.\n\n## Why this is the supported option\n\nMatch zoning, assignment, lender, environmental, and seller certificate records to exact parcels and tenants. Current governmental, lease, lender, and environmental evidence controls over seller certifications.\n\n## Supported actions\n\n### CBP-052-01 — assignment consent (medium)\n\nan open exception blocks completion under CB-RE-2902-R118; the current status is open and unresolved under CB-RE-2902-E789. Identity resolves to ENT-052-1000, revision REV-2026.1 is current, and Willa Novak is active with capacity 6.\n\nAction: Create parcel-specific closing rows and preserve certificate-only holds. Owner: Willa Novak; due 2026-09-06.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_leases/001_leases_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/02_amendments/013_amendments_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/04_title_survey/025_title_survey_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/05_environmental/037_environmental_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/08_insurance/061_insurance_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/11_financing/085_financing_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/12_property_management/097_brookline_clinic_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-052-03 — construction lien notice (medium)\n\nthe controlling threshold is 8% under CB-RE-2902-R771; the independently calculated result is 15% under CB-RE-2902-E351. Identity resolves to ENT-052-1002, revision REV-2026.3 is current, and Priya Raman is active with capacity 4.\n\nAction: Create parcel-specific closing rows and preserve certificate-only holds. Owner: Priya Raman; due 2026-09-04.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_leases/003_leases_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/02_amendments/015_amendments_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/04_title_survey/027_title_survey_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/05_environmental/039_environmental_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/11_financing/087_financing_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/12_property_management/097_brookline_clinic_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-052-04 — exclusive-use conflict (low)\n\napproval must come from Sofia Bennett under CB-RE-2902-R632; the effective approval record names Rafael Okafor under CB-RE-2902-E396. Identity resolves to ENT-052-1003, revision REV-2026.4 is current, and Isaac Romero is active with capacity 5.\n\nAction: Create parcel-specific closing rows and preserve certificate-only holds. Owner: Isaac Romero; due 2026-09-03.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_leases/004_leases_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/02_amendments/016_amendments_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/04_title_survey/028_title_survey_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/05_environmental/040_environmental_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/07_operating_expenses/052_operating_expenses_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/11_financing/088_financing_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/12_property_management/097_brookline_clinic_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-052-06 — casualty restoration deadline (high)\n\nthe permission is limited to Middlesex County, Massachusetts under CB-RE-2902-R211; the matched activity occurred in Massachusetts under CB-RE-2902-E688. Identity resolves to ENT-052-1005, revision REV-2026.6 is current, and Rafael Okafor is active with capacity 5.\n\nAction: Create parcel-specific closing rows and preserve certificate-only holds. Owner: Rafael Okafor; due 2026-09-01.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_leases/006_leases_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/03_estoppels/018_estoppels_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/04_title_survey/030_title_survey_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/042_zoning_permits_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/12_property_management/090_property_management_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/12_property_management/097_brookline_clinic_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-052-07 — renewal-option notice (high)\n\nthe operative cap is $3,082,000.00 under CB-RE-2902-R509; the matched ledger population totals $3,256,509.00 under CB-RE-2902-E494. Identity resolves to ENT-052-1006, revision REV-2026.7 is current, and Mei Whitaker is active with capacity 6.\n\nAction: Create parcel-specific closing rows and preserve certificate-only holds. Owner: Mei Whitaker; due 2026-08-31.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_leases/007_leases_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/03_estoppels/019_estoppels_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/04_title_survey/031_title_survey_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/043_zoning_permits_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/12_property_management/097_brookline_clinic_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-052-08 — title exception (medium)\n\ndelivery must use notices-brookline_care_partners@example.test under CB-RE-2902-R466; the only matched receipt used archive-elm_street_medical_properties@example.test under CB-RE-2902-E809. Identity resolves to ENT-052-1007, revision REV-2026.1 is current, and Theo Laurent is active with capacity 1.\n\nAction: Create parcel-specific closing rows and preserve certificate-only holds. Owner: Theo Laurent; due 2026-08-30.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_leases/008_leases_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/03_estoppels/020_estoppels_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/04_title_survey/032_title_survey_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/044_zoning_permits_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/10_construction/080_construction_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/12_property_management/097_brookline_clinic_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n## Evidence holds\n\n- **CBP-052-02 — zoning nonconformity**: two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key. Next evidence: an approved immutable entity crosswalk. Sources: `/workspace/documents/01_leases/002_leases_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/02_amendments/014_amendments_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/04_title_survey/026_title_survey_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/05_environmental/038_environmental_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/07_operating_expenses/050_operating_expenses_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/12_property_management/097_brookline_clinic_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-052-05 — environmental recognized condition**: the operational record relies on a superseded control revision. Next evidence: an operational record using the current effective revision. Sources: `/workspace/documents/01_leases/005_leases_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/03_estoppels/017_estoppels_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/04_title_survey/029_title_survey_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/041_zoning_permits_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/12_property_management/097_brookline_clinic_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-052-09 — insurance endorsement deficiency**: the operational record relies on a superseded control revision. Next evidence: an operational record using the current effective revision. Sources: `/workspace/documents/02_amendments/009_amendments_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/03_estoppels/021_estoppels_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/05_environmental/033_environmental_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/045_zoning_permits_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/09_notices/069_notices_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/11_financing/081_financing_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/12_property_management/097_brookline_clinic_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-052-10 — rent schedule inconsistency**: two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key. Next evidence: an approved immutable entity crosswalk. Sources: `/workspace/documents/02_amendments/010_amendments_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/03_estoppels/022_estoppels_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/05_environmental/034_environmental_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/046_zoning_permits_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/12_property_management/097_brookline_clinic_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-052-11 — survey encroachment**: the current observation does not meet the operative trigger. Next evidence: a current observation that satisfies the operative trigger. Sources: `/workspace/documents/02_amendments/011_amendments_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/03_estoppels/023_estoppels_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/05_environmental/035_environmental_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/047_zoning_permits_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/12_property_management/095_property_management_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/12_property_management/097_brookline_clinic_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-052-12 — CAM reconciliation error**: the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective. Next evidence: effective approval and an active owner with remaining capacity. Sources: `/workspace/documents/02_amendments/012_amendments_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/03_estoppels/024_estoppels_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/05_environmental/036_environmental_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/048_zoning_permits_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/12_property_management/097_brookline_clinic_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n## Alternatives considered\n\n- `brookline-clinic:shortcut` — Accept seller certificates as curing every underlying record conflict.: Use a plausible summary or one source without completing the controlling joins.\n- `brookline-clinic:blanket-hold` — Freeze the entire matter population: Treat supported actions and genuinely ambiguous records as if they were equally unresolved.\n\n## Assumptions and limits\n\nThis decision is limited to cb100-052-brookline-clinic, the supplied synthetic records, and the matter state as of 2026-09-07. Similar names, stale revisions, and pending authority are not treated as proof.\n", "decision": {"actions": [{"determination": "an open exception blocks completion under CB-RE-2902-R118; the current status is open and unresolved under CB-RE-2902-E789. Identity resolves to ENT-052-1000, revision REV-2026.1 is current, and Willa Novak is active with capacity 6.", "due_date": "2026-09-06", "id": "ACT-CBP-052-01", "identity_id": "ENT-052-1000", "issue": "assignment consent", "owner": "Willa Novak", "portfolio_key": "CBP-052-01", "recommended_action": "Create parcel-specific closing rows and preserve certificate-only holds. Owner: Willa Novak; due 2026-09-06.", "severity": "medium", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_leases/001_leases_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/02_amendments/013_amendments_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/04_title_survey/025_title_survey_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/05_environmental/037_environmental_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/08_insurance/061_insurance_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/11_financing/085_financing_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_property_management/097_brookline_clinic_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "the controlling threshold is 8% under CB-RE-2902-R771; the independently calculated result is 15% under CB-RE-2902-E351. Identity resolves to ENT-052-1002, revision REV-2026.3 is current, and Priya Raman is active with capacity 4.", "due_date": "2026-09-04", "id": "ACT-CBP-052-03", "identity_id": "ENT-052-1002", "issue": "construction lien notice", "owner": "Priya Raman", "portfolio_key": "CBP-052-03", "recommended_action": "Create parcel-specific closing rows and preserve certificate-only holds. Owner: Priya Raman; due 2026-09-04.", "severity": "medium", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_leases/003_leases_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/02_amendments/015_amendments_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/04_title_survey/027_title_survey_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/05_environmental/039_environmental_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/11_financing/087_financing_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_property_management/097_brookline_clinic_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "approval must come from Sofia Bennett under CB-RE-2902-R632; the effective approval record names Rafael Okafor under CB-RE-2902-E396. Identity resolves to ENT-052-1003, revision REV-2026.4 is current, and Isaac Romero is active with capacity 5.", "due_date": "2026-09-03", "id": "ACT-CBP-052-04", "identity_id": "ENT-052-1003", "issue": "exclusive-use conflict", "owner": "Isaac Romero", "portfolio_key": "CBP-052-04", "recommended_action": "Create parcel-specific closing rows and preserve certificate-only holds. Owner: Isaac Romero; due 2026-09-03.", "severity": "low", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_leases/004_leases_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/02_amendments/016_amendments_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/04_title_survey/028_title_survey_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/05_environmental/040_environmental_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/07_operating_expenses/052_operating_expenses_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/11_financing/088_financing_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_property_management/097_brookline_clinic_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "the permission is limited to Middlesex County, Massachusetts under CB-RE-2902-R211; the matched activity occurred in Massachusetts under CB-RE-2902-E688. Identity resolves to ENT-052-1005, revision REV-2026.6 is current, and Rafael Okafor is active with capacity 5.", "due_date": "2026-09-01", "id": "ACT-CBP-052-06", "identity_id": "ENT-052-1005", "issue": "casualty restoration deadline", "owner": "Rafael Okafor", "portfolio_key": "CBP-052-06", "recommended_action": "Create parcel-specific closing rows and preserve certificate-only holds. Owner: Rafael Okafor; due 2026-09-01.", "severity": "high", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_leases/006_leases_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/03_estoppels/018_estoppels_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/04_title_survey/030_title_survey_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/042_zoning_permits_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/12_property_management/090_property_management_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/12_property_management/097_brookline_clinic_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "the operative cap is $3,082,000.00 under CB-RE-2902-R509; the matched ledger population totals $3,256,509.00 under CB-RE-2902-E494. Identity resolves to ENT-052-1006, revision REV-2026.7 is current, and Mei Whitaker is active with capacity 6.", "due_date": "2026-08-31", "id": "ACT-CBP-052-07", "identity_id": "ENT-052-1006", "issue": "renewal-option notice", "owner": "Mei Whitaker", "portfolio_key": "CBP-052-07", "recommended_action": "Create parcel-specific closing rows and preserve certificate-only holds. Owner: Mei Whitaker; due 2026-08-31.", "severity": "high", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_leases/007_leases_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/03_estoppels/019_estoppels_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/04_title_survey/031_title_survey_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/043_zoning_permits_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/12_property_management/097_brookline_clinic_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "delivery must use notices-brookline_care_partners@example.test under CB-RE-2902-R466; the only matched receipt used archive-elm_street_medical_properties@example.test under CB-RE-2902-E809. Identity resolves to ENT-052-1007, revision REV-2026.1 is current, and Theo Laurent is active with capacity 1.", "due_date": "2026-08-30", "id": "ACT-CBP-052-08", "identity_id": "ENT-052-1007", "issue": "title exception", "owner": "Theo Laurent", "portfolio_key": "CBP-052-08", "recommended_action": "Create parcel-specific closing rows and preserve certificate-only holds. Owner: Theo Laurent; due 2026-08-30.", "severity": "medium", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_leases/008_leases_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/03_estoppels/020_estoppels_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/04_title_survey/032_title_survey_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/044_zoning_permits_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/10_construction/080_construction_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_property_management/097_brookline_clinic_impact_population.xlsx"]}], "as_of": "2026-09-07", "decision": {"alternatives_considered": ["brookline-clinic:shortcut", "brookline-clinic:blanket-hold"], "question": "Which Brookline property issues must be closing conditions for the clinic acquisition?", "rationale": "The four-part causal test supports 6 scoped actions and leaves 6 records on evidence hold. Current governmental, lease, lender, and environmental evidence controls over seller certifications.", "recommendation": "Condition closing on the supported consent, use, or remediation item.", "selected_option_id": "brookline-clinic:scoped-evidence"}, "holds": [{"id": "HOLD-CBP-052-02", "issue": "zoning nonconformity", "portfolio_key": "CBP-052-02", "reason": "two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key", "required_next_evidence": "an approved immutable entity crosswalk", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_leases/002_leases_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/02_amendments/014_amendments_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/04_title_survey/026_title_survey_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/05_environmental/038_environmental_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/07_operating_expenses/050_operating_expenses_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/12_property_management/097_brookline_clinic_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-052-05", "issue": "environmental recognized condition", "portfolio_key": "CBP-052-05", "reason": "the operational record relies on a superseded control revision", "required_next_evidence": "an operational record using the current effective revision", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_leases/005_leases_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/03_estoppels/017_estoppels_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/04_title_survey/029_title_survey_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/041_zoning_permits_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/12_property_management/097_brookline_clinic_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-052-09", "issue": "insurance endorsement deficiency", "portfolio_key": "CBP-052-09", "reason": "the operational record relies on a superseded control revision", "required_next_evidence": "an operational record using the current effective revision", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_amendments/009_amendments_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/03_estoppels/021_estoppels_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/05_environmental/033_environmental_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/045_zoning_permits_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/09_notices/069_notices_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/11_financing/081_financing_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/12_property_management/097_brookline_clinic_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-052-10", "issue": "rent schedule inconsistency", "portfolio_key": "CBP-052-10", "reason": "two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key", "required_next_evidence": "an approved immutable entity crosswalk", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_amendments/010_amendments_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/03_estoppels/022_estoppels_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/05_environmental/034_environmental_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/046_zoning_permits_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_property_management/097_brookline_clinic_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-052-11", "issue": "survey encroachment", "portfolio_key": "CBP-052-11", "reason": "the current observation does not meet the operative trigger", "required_next_evidence": "a current observation that satisfies the operative trigger", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_amendments/011_amendments_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/03_estoppels/023_estoppels_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/05_environmental/035_environmental_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/047_zoning_permits_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_property_management/095_property_management_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_property_management/097_brookline_clinic_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-052-12", "issue": "CAM reconciliation error", "portfolio_key": "CBP-052-12", "reason": "the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective", "required_next_evidence": "effective approval and an active owner with remaining capacity", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_amendments/012_amendments_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/03_estoppels/024_estoppels_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/05_environmental/036_environmental_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/048_zoning_permits_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_property_management/097_brookline_clinic_impact_population.xlsx"]}], "matter_number": "CB-RE-2902", "prepared_for": "Brookline Care Partners", "schema_version": "counselbench.decision.v3", "task_id": "cb100-052-brookline-clinic"}, "matter_register": {"matter_number": "CB-RE-2902", "rows": [{"decision_option_id": "brookline-clinic:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-06", "issue": "assignment consent", "matter_number": "CB-RE-2902", "owner": "Willa Novak", "portfolio_key": "CBP-052-01", "row_id": "REG-CBP-052-01", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_leases/001_leases_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/02_amendments/013_amendments_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/04_title_survey/025_title_survey_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/05_environmental/037_environmental_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/08_insurance/061_insurance_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/11_financing/085_financing_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_property_management/097_brookline_clinic_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "brookline-clinic:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key", "issue": "zoning nonconformity", "matter_number": "CB-RE-2902", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-052-02", "row_id": "REG-CBP-052-02", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_leases/002_leases_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/02_amendments/014_amendments_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/04_title_survey/026_title_survey_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/05_environmental/038_environmental_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/07_operating_expenses/050_operating_expenses_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/12_property_management/097_brookline_clinic_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "brookline-clinic:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-04", "issue": "construction lien notice", "matter_number": "CB-RE-2902", "owner": "Priya Raman", "portfolio_key": "CBP-052-03", "row_id": "REG-CBP-052-03", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_leases/003_leases_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/02_amendments/015_amendments_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/04_title_survey/027_title_survey_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/05_environmental/039_environmental_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/11_financing/087_financing_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_property_management/097_brookline_clinic_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "brookline-clinic:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-03", "issue": "exclusive-use conflict", "matter_number": "CB-RE-2902", "owner": "Isaac Romero", "portfolio_key": "CBP-052-04", "row_id": "REG-CBP-052-04", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_leases/004_leases_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/02_amendments/016_amendments_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/04_title_survey/028_title_survey_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/05_environmental/040_environmental_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/07_operating_expenses/052_operating_expenses_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/11_financing/088_financing_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_property_management/097_brookline_clinic_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "brookline-clinic:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "the operational record relies on a superseded control revision", "issue": "environmental recognized condition", "matter_number": "CB-RE-2902", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-052-05", "row_id": "REG-CBP-052-05", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_leases/005_leases_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/03_estoppels/017_estoppels_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/04_title_survey/029_title_survey_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/041_zoning_permits_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/12_property_management/097_brookline_clinic_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "brookline-clinic:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-01", "issue": "casualty restoration deadline", "matter_number": "CB-RE-2902", "owner": "Rafael Okafor", "portfolio_key": "CBP-052-06", "row_id": "REG-CBP-052-06", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_leases/006_leases_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/03_estoppels/018_estoppels_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/04_title_survey/030_title_survey_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/042_zoning_permits_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/12_property_management/090_property_management_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/12_property_management/097_brookline_clinic_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "brookline-clinic:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-08-31", "issue": "renewal-option notice", "matter_number": "CB-RE-2902", "owner": "Mei Whitaker", "portfolio_key": "CBP-052-07", "row_id": "REG-CBP-052-07", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_leases/007_leases_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/03_estoppels/019_estoppels_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/04_title_survey/031_title_survey_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/043_zoning_permits_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/12_property_management/097_brookline_clinic_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "brookline-clinic:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-08-30", "issue": "title exception", "matter_number": "CB-RE-2902", "owner": "Theo Laurent", "portfolio_key": "CBP-052-08", "row_id": "REG-CBP-052-08", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_leases/008_leases_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/03_estoppels/020_estoppels_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/04_title_survey/032_title_survey_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/044_zoning_permits_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/10_construction/080_construction_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_property_management/097_brookline_clinic_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "brookline-clinic:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "the operational record relies on a superseded control revision", "issue": "insurance endorsement deficiency", "matter_number": "CB-RE-2902", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-052-09", "row_id": "REG-CBP-052-09", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_amendments/009_amendments_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/03_estoppels/021_estoppels_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/05_environmental/033_environmental_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/045_zoning_permits_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/09_notices/069_notices_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/11_financing/081_financing_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/12_property_management/097_brookline_clinic_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "brookline-clinic:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key", "issue": "rent schedule inconsistency", "matter_number": "CB-RE-2902", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-052-10", "row_id": "REG-CBP-052-10", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_amendments/010_amendments_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/03_estoppels/022_estoppels_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/05_environmental/034_environmental_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/046_zoning_permits_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_property_management/097_brookline_clinic_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "brookline-clinic:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "the current observation does not meet the operative trigger", "issue": "survey encroachment", "matter_number": "CB-RE-2902", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-052-11", "row_id": "REG-CBP-052-11", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_amendments/011_amendments_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/03_estoppels/023_estoppels_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/05_environmental/035_environmental_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/047_zoning_permits_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_property_management/095_property_management_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_property_management/097_brookline_clinic_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "brookline-clinic:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective", "issue": "CAM reconciliation error", "matter_number": "CB-RE-2902", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-052-12", "row_id": "REG-CBP-052-12", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_amendments/012_amendments_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/03_estoppels/024_estoppels_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/05_environmental/036_environmental_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/048_zoning_permits_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_property_management/097_brookline_clinic_impact_population.xlsx"]}], "schema_version": "counselbench.matter-register.v3", "task_id": "cb100-052-brookline-clinic"}}, "metadata": {"benchmark": "CounselBench-100", "code_license": "Apache-2.0", "data_license": "CC-BY-4.0", "deadline": "2026-09-07", "document_count": 97, "evidence_holds": 6, "jurisdiction": "Massachusetts", "matter_number": "CB-RE-2902", "mcp_commit": "9a96ea6e5913736f92b88345bf51caeaaa8e719f", "mcp_package": "@modelcontextprotocol/server-filesystem@2026.7.10", "practice_area": "real-estate", "reference_tool_calls": 87, "required_evidence_reads": 61, "supported_actions": 6, "synthetic": true, "venue": "Middlesex County, Massachusetts", "version": "3.1.0"}, "prompt": "The business team is asking whether it can move, and I do not want to answer from the summary deck. Which Brookline property issues must be closing conditions for the clinic acquisition? A medical-office portfolio presents zoning, assignment, lender consent, and environmental records that do not align with seller certificates. The team needs the call by 2026-09-07. Document the scoped result for the team and separate genuine exceptions from unresolved identity or revision questions.", "rubric": {"criteria": [{"category": "investigation", "description": "Inventory the production and use targeted searches to locate records across native formats.", "id": "investigation.discover_production"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Complete every task-specific identity, authority, operations, and approval read before the first state transition.", "id": "investigation.read_before_write"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Inspect designated source metadata before relying on those records.", "id": "investigation.custody_before_write"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "Select the supported option 'brookline-clinic:scoped-evidence' after applying the four-part test.", "id": "decision.selected_option"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "Identify both rejected approaches and explain why a one-source shortcut and a blanket hold are wrong.", "id": "decision.alternatives"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-052-01 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_leases/001_leases_source_export.md rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-052-01.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_amendments/013_amendments_source_export.json for assignment consent.", "id": "investigation.CBP-052-01.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_title_survey/025_title_survey_source_export.md to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-052-01.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_environmental/037_environmental_source_export.json.", "id": "investigation.CBP-052-01.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-052-01 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-052-01.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-052-01 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-052-01.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-052-02 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_leases/002_leases_source_export.txt rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-052-02.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_amendments/014_amendments_source_export.xml for zoning nonconformity.", "id": "investigation.CBP-052-02.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_title_survey/026_title_survey_source_export.txt to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-052-02.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_environmental/038_environmental_source_export.xml.", "id": "investigation.CBP-052-02.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-052-02 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key.", "id": "decision.CBP-052-02.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-052-02 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-052-02.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-052-03 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_leases/003_leases_source_export.eml rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-052-03.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_amendments/015_amendments_source_export.html for construction lien notice.", "id": "investigation.CBP-052-03.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_title_survey/027_title_survey_source_export.eml to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-052-03.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_environmental/039_environmental_source_export.html.", "id": "investigation.CBP-052-03.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-052-03 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-052-03.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-052-03 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-052-03.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-052-04 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_leases/004_leases_source_export.csv rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-052-04.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_amendments/016_amendments_source_export.pdf for exclusive-use conflict.", "id": "investigation.CBP-052-04.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_title_survey/028_title_survey_source_export.csv to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-052-04.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_environmental/040_environmental_source_export.pdf.", "id": "investigation.CBP-052-04.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-052-04 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-052-04.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-052-04 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-052-04.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-052-05 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_leases/005_leases_source_export.json rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-052-05.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_estoppels/017_estoppels_source_export.md for environmental recognized condition.", "id": "investigation.CBP-052-05.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_title_survey/029_title_survey_source_export.json to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-052-05.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/041_zoning_permits_source_export.md.", "id": "investigation.CBP-052-05.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-052-05 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is the operational record relies on a superseded control revision.", "id": "decision.CBP-052-05.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-052-05 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-052-05.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-052-06 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_leases/006_leases_source_export.xml rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-052-06.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_estoppels/018_estoppels_source_export.txt for casualty restoration deadline.", "id": "investigation.CBP-052-06.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_title_survey/030_title_survey_source_export.xml to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-052-06.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/042_zoning_permits_source_export.txt.", "id": "investigation.CBP-052-06.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-052-06 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-052-06.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-052-06 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-052-06.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-052-07 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_leases/007_leases_source_export.html rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-052-07.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_estoppels/019_estoppels_source_export.eml for renewal-option notice.", "id": "investigation.CBP-052-07.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_title_survey/031_title_survey_source_export.html to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-052-07.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/043_zoning_permits_source_export.eml.", "id": "investigation.CBP-052-07.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-052-07 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-052-07.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-052-07 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-052-07.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-052-08 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_leases/008_leases_source_export.pdf rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-052-08.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_estoppels/020_estoppels_source_export.csv for title exception.", "id": "investigation.CBP-052-08.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_title_survey/032_title_survey_source_export.pdf to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-052-08.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/044_zoning_permits_source_export.csv.", "id": "investigation.CBP-052-08.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-052-08 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-052-08.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-052-08 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-052-08.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-052-09 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_amendments/009_amendments_source_export.md rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-052-09.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_estoppels/021_estoppels_source_export.json for insurance endorsement deficiency.", "id": "investigation.CBP-052-09.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_environmental/033_environmental_source_export.md to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-052-09.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/045_zoning_permits_source_export.json.", "id": "investigation.CBP-052-09.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-052-09 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is the operational record relies on a superseded control revision.", "id": "decision.CBP-052-09.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-052-09 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-052-09.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-052-10 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_amendments/010_amendments_source_export.txt rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-052-10.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_estoppels/022_estoppels_source_export.xml for rent schedule inconsistency.", "id": "investigation.CBP-052-10.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_environmental/034_environmental_source_export.txt to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-052-10.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/046_zoning_permits_source_export.xml.", "id": "investigation.CBP-052-10.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-052-10 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key.", "id": "decision.CBP-052-10.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-052-10 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-052-10.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-052-11 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_amendments/011_amendments_source_export.eml rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-052-11.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_estoppels/023_estoppels_source_export.html for survey encroachment.", "id": "investigation.CBP-052-11.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_environmental/035_environmental_source_export.eml to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-052-11.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/047_zoning_permits_source_export.html.", "id": "investigation.CBP-052-11.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-052-11 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is the current observation does not meet the operative trigger.", "id": "decision.CBP-052-11.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-052-11 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-052-11.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-052-12 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_amendments/012_amendments_source_export.csv rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-052-12.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_estoppels/024_estoppels_source_export.pdf for CAM reconciliation error.", "id": "investigation.CBP-052-12.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_environmental/036_environmental_source_export.csv to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-052-12.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/048_zoning_permits_source_export.pdf.", "id": "investigation.CBP-052-12.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-052-12 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective.", "id": "decision.CBP-052-12.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-052-12 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-052-12.register"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Write the exact selected option, supported action population, evidence-hold population, facts, owners, deadlines, and citations.", "id": "state.exact_decision"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create one exact register row per portfolio key with no extra, missing, or modified row.", "id": "state.exact_register"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Leave only the three approved deliverables and perform no extra state-changing write.", "id": "state.write_scope_containment"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Read back decision.json, matter-register.json, and advice.md after their final writes.", "id": "state.postwrite_readback"}, {"category": "answer", "description": "Explain the selected recommendation, supported actions, holds, alternatives, and limitations with exact source anchors.", "id": "answer.decision_note"}], "decision_options": [{"approach": "Apply the exact identity, current-state, authority, and revision test. Create parcel-specific closing rows and preserve certificate-only holds.", "id": "brookline-clinic:scoped-evidence", "label": "Condition closing on the supported consent, use, or remediation item."}, {"approach": "Use a plausible summary or one source without completing the controlling joins.", "id": "brookline-clinic:shortcut", "label": "Accept seller certificates as curing every underlying record conflict."}, {"approach": "Treat supported actions and genuinely ambiguous records as if they were equally unresolved.", "id": "brookline-clinic:blanket-hold", "label": "Freeze the entire matter population"}], "evaluation_narrative": {"authority": "Current governmental, lease, lender, and environmental evidence controls over seller certifications.", "observation": "Match zoning, assignment, lender, environmental, and seller certificate records to exact parcels and tenants.", "question": "Which Brookline property issues must be closing conditions for the clinic acquisition?", "register_action": "Create parcel-specific closing rows and preserve certificate-only holds."}, "gates": ["all_required_evidence_precedes_first_write", "decision_criteria_complete", "register_state_exact", "write_scope_contained", "all_outputs_verified_by_readback"], "metadata_checks": 11, "metric": "weighted_criteria_score", "minimum_tool_calls": 87, "required_deliverables": ["decision.json", "matter-register.json", "advice.md"], "required_document_reads": 61, "type": "deterministic", "weights": {"advice": 0.15, "decision": 0.35, "investigation": 0.25, "state": 0.25}}, "task_id": "cb100-052-brookline-clinic", "task_name": "Brookline clinic acquisition property review", "world_id": "counselbench-filesystem-mcp-v3"}
+{"context_files": ["task_files/cb100-053-canyon-grocery/01_leases/001_leases_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-053-canyon-grocery/01_leases/002_leases_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-053-canyon-grocery/01_leases/003_leases_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-053-canyon-grocery/01_leases/004_leases_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-053-canyon-grocery/01_leases/005_leases_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-053-canyon-grocery/01_leases/006_leases_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-053-canyon-grocery/01_leases/007_leases_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-053-canyon-grocery/01_leases/008_leases_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-053-canyon-grocery/02_amendments/009_amendments_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-053-canyon-grocery/02_amendments/010_amendments_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-053-canyon-grocery/02_amendments/011_amendments_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-053-canyon-grocery/02_amendments/012_amendments_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-053-canyon-grocery/02_amendments/013_amendments_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-053-canyon-grocery/02_amendments/014_amendments_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-053-canyon-grocery/02_amendments/015_amendments_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-053-canyon-grocery/02_amendments/016_amendments_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-053-canyon-grocery/03_estoppels/017_estoppels_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-053-canyon-grocery/03_estoppels/018_estoppels_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-053-canyon-grocery/03_estoppels/019_estoppels_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-053-canyon-grocery/03_estoppels/020_estoppels_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-053-canyon-grocery/03_estoppels/021_estoppels_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-053-canyon-grocery/03_estoppels/022_estoppels_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-053-canyon-grocery/03_estoppels/023_estoppels_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-053-canyon-grocery/03_estoppels/024_estoppels_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-053-canyon-grocery/04_title_survey/025_title_survey_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-053-canyon-grocery/04_title_survey/026_title_survey_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-053-canyon-grocery/04_title_survey/027_title_survey_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-053-canyon-grocery/04_title_survey/028_title_survey_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-053-canyon-grocery/04_title_survey/029_title_survey_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-053-canyon-grocery/04_title_survey/030_title_survey_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-053-canyon-grocery/04_title_survey/031_title_survey_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-053-canyon-grocery/04_title_survey/032_title_survey_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-053-canyon-grocery/05_environmental/033_environmental_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-053-canyon-grocery/05_environmental/034_environmental_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-053-canyon-grocery/05_environmental/035_environmental_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-053-canyon-grocery/05_environmental/036_environmental_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-053-canyon-grocery/05_environmental/037_environmental_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-053-canyon-grocery/05_environmental/038_environmental_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-053-canyon-grocery/05_environmental/039_environmental_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-053-canyon-grocery/05_environmental/040_environmental_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-053-canyon-grocery/06_zoning_permits/041_zoning_permits_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-053-canyon-grocery/06_zoning_permits/042_zoning_permits_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-053-canyon-grocery/06_zoning_permits/043_zoning_permits_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-053-canyon-grocery/06_zoning_permits/044_zoning_permits_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-053-canyon-grocery/06_zoning_permits/045_zoning_permits_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-053-canyon-grocery/06_zoning_permits/046_zoning_permits_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-053-canyon-grocery/06_zoning_permits/047_zoning_permits_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-053-canyon-grocery/06_zoning_permits/048_zoning_permits_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-053-canyon-grocery/07_operating_expenses/049_operating_expenses_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-053-canyon-grocery/07_operating_expenses/050_operating_expenses_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-053-canyon-grocery/07_operating_expenses/051_operating_expenses_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-053-canyon-grocery/07_operating_expenses/052_operating_expenses_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-053-canyon-grocery/07_operating_expenses/053_operating_expenses_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-053-canyon-grocery/07_operating_expenses/054_operating_expenses_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-053-canyon-grocery/07_operating_expenses/055_operating_expenses_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-053-canyon-grocery/07_operating_expenses/056_operating_expenses_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-053-canyon-grocery/08_insurance/057_insurance_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-053-canyon-grocery/08_insurance/058_insurance_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-053-canyon-grocery/08_insurance/059_insurance_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-053-canyon-grocery/08_insurance/060_insurance_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-053-canyon-grocery/08_insurance/061_insurance_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-053-canyon-grocery/08_insurance/062_insurance_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-053-canyon-grocery/08_insurance/063_insurance_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-053-canyon-grocery/08_insurance/064_insurance_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-053-canyon-grocery/09_notices/065_notices_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-053-canyon-grocery/09_notices/066_notices_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-053-canyon-grocery/09_notices/067_notices_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-053-canyon-grocery/09_notices/068_notices_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-053-canyon-grocery/09_notices/069_notices_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-053-canyon-grocery/09_notices/070_notices_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-053-canyon-grocery/09_notices/071_notices_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-053-canyon-grocery/09_notices/072_notices_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-053-canyon-grocery/10_construction/073_construction_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-053-canyon-grocery/10_construction/074_construction_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-053-canyon-grocery/10_construction/075_construction_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-053-canyon-grocery/10_construction/076_construction_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-053-canyon-grocery/10_construction/077_construction_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-053-canyon-grocery/10_construction/078_construction_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-053-canyon-grocery/10_construction/079_construction_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-053-canyon-grocery/10_construction/080_construction_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-053-canyon-grocery/11_financing/081_financing_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-053-canyon-grocery/11_financing/082_financing_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-053-canyon-grocery/11_financing/083_financing_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-053-canyon-grocery/11_financing/084_financing_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-053-canyon-grocery/11_financing/085_financing_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-053-canyon-grocery/11_financing/086_financing_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-053-canyon-grocery/11_financing/087_financing_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-053-canyon-grocery/11_financing/088_financing_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-053-canyon-grocery/12_property_management/089_property_management_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-053-canyon-grocery/12_property_management/090_property_management_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-053-canyon-grocery/12_property_management/091_property_management_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-053-canyon-grocery/12_property_management/092_property_management_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-053-canyon-grocery/12_property_management/093_property_management_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-053-canyon-grocery/12_property_management/094_property_management_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-053-canyon-grocery/12_property_management/095_property_management_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-053-canyon-grocery/12_property_management/096_property_management_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-053-canyon-grocery/12_property_management/097_canyon_grocery_impact_population.xlsx"], "gold_output": {"advice_markdown": "# Decision note — Canyon grocery lease portfolio audit\n\n## Recommendation\n\nApply supported renewal and rent corrections and surface real exclusivity conflicts. The reconciled record supports 5 scoped actions and leaves 7 items on evidence hold.\n\nSelected option: `canyon-grocery:scoped-evidence`.\n\n## Why this is the supported option\n\nReconcile leases, options, landlord statements, sales records, and payment history by store and term. Executed lease terms and valid option notices govern store by store.\n\n## Supported actions\n\n### CBP-053-01 — estoppel discrepancy (medium)\n\nthe permission is limited to Maricopa County, Arizona under CB-RE-2903-R676; the matched activity occurred in Arizona under CB-RE-2903-E398. Identity resolves to ENT-053-1000, revision REV-2025.1 is current, and Henry Cho is active with capacity 3.\n\nAction: Create store-term rows and hold unmatched statements or sales periods. Owner: Henry Cho; due 2026-09-09.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_leases/001_leases_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/02_amendments/013_amendments_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/04_title_survey/025_title_survey_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/05_environmental/037_environmental_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/08_insurance/061_insurance_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/07_operating_expenses/049_operating_expenses_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/12_property_management/097_canyon_grocery_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-053-02 — permit closeout gap (high)\n\nthe operative cap is $7,762,000.00 under CB-RE-2903-R706; the matched ledger population totals $7,876,106.00 under CB-RE-2903-E506. Identity resolves to ENT-053-1001, revision REV-2025.2 is current, and Maya Ellison is active with capacity 6.\n\nAction: Create store-term rows and hold unmatched statements or sales periods. Owner: Maya Ellison; due 2026-09-08.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_leases/002_leases_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/02_amendments/014_amendments_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/04_title_survey/026_title_survey_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/05_environmental/038_environmental_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/12_property_management/097_canyon_grocery_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-053-04 — assignment consent (high)\n\nan open exception blocks completion under CB-RE-2903-R311; the current status is open and unresolved under CB-RE-2903-E324. Identity resolves to ENT-053-1003, revision REV-2025.4 is current, and Willa Novak is active with capacity 4.\n\nAction: Create store-term rows and hold unmatched statements or sales periods. Owner: Willa Novak; due 2026-09-06.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_leases/004_leases_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/02_amendments/016_amendments_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/04_title_survey/028_title_survey_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/05_environmental/040_environmental_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/10_construction/076_construction_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/08_insurance/064_insurance_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/12_property_management/097_canyon_grocery_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-053-06 — construction lien notice (medium)\n\nthe controlling threshold is 9% under CB-RE-2903-R182; the independently calculated result is 17% under CB-RE-2903-E581. Identity resolves to ENT-053-1005, revision REV-2025.6 is current, and Priya Raman is active with capacity 2.\n\nAction: Create store-term rows and hold unmatched statements or sales periods. Owner: Priya Raman; due 2026-09-04.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_leases/006_leases_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/03_estoppels/018_estoppels_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/04_title_survey/030_title_survey_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/042_zoning_permits_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/10_construction/078_construction_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/12_property_management/097_canyon_grocery_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-053-07 — exclusive-use conflict (critical)\n\napproval must come from Lena Varga under CB-RE-2903-R951; the effective approval record names Henry Cho under CB-RE-2903-E679. Identity resolves to ENT-053-1006, revision REV-2025.7 is current, and Isaac Romero is active with capacity 1.\n\nAction: Create store-term rows and hold unmatched statements or sales periods. Owner: Isaac Romero; due 2026-09-03.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_leases/007_leases_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/03_estoppels/019_estoppels_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/04_title_survey/031_title_survey_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/043_zoning_permits_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/12_property_management/097_canyon_grocery_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n## Evidence holds\n\n- **CBP-053-03 — lender SNDA omission**: the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective. Next evidence: effective approval and an active owner with remaining capacity. Sources: `/workspace/documents/01_leases/003_leases_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/02_amendments/015_amendments_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/04_title_survey/027_title_survey_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/05_environmental/039_environmental_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/12_property_management/097_canyon_grocery_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-053-05 — zoning nonconformity**: two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key. Next evidence: an approved immutable entity crosswalk. Sources: `/workspace/documents/01_leases/005_leases_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/03_estoppels/017_estoppels_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/04_title_survey/029_title_survey_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/041_zoning_permits_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/12_property_management/089_property_management_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/12_property_management/097_canyon_grocery_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-053-08 — environmental recognized condition**: the operational record relies on a superseded control revision. Next evidence: an operational record using the current effective revision. Sources: `/workspace/documents/01_leases/008_leases_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/03_estoppels/020_estoppels_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/04_title_survey/032_title_survey_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/044_zoning_permits_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/12_property_management/097_canyon_grocery_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-053-09 — casualty restoration deadline**: two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key. Next evidence: an approved immutable entity crosswalk. Sources: `/workspace/documents/02_amendments/009_amendments_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/03_estoppels/021_estoppels_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/05_environmental/033_environmental_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/045_zoning_permits_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/12_property_management/097_canyon_grocery_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-053-10 — renewal-option notice**: the current observation does not meet the operative trigger. Next evidence: a current observation that satisfies the operative trigger. Sources: `/workspace/documents/02_amendments/010_amendments_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/03_estoppels/022_estoppels_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/05_environmental/034_environmental_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/046_zoning_permits_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/12_property_management/097_canyon_grocery_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-053-11 — title exception**: the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective. Next evidence: effective approval and an active owner with remaining capacity. Sources: `/workspace/documents/02_amendments/011_amendments_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/03_estoppels/023_estoppels_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/05_environmental/035_environmental_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/047_zoning_permits_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/12_property_management/095_property_management_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/12_property_management/097_canyon_grocery_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-053-12 — insurance endorsement deficiency**: the operational record relies on a superseded control revision. Next evidence: an operational record using the current effective revision. Sources: `/workspace/documents/02_amendments/012_amendments_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/03_estoppels/024_estoppels_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/05_environmental/036_environmental_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/048_zoning_permits_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/12_property_management/097_canyon_grocery_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n## Alternatives considered\n\n- `canyon-grocery:shortcut` — Apply one portfolio-wide rule from the landlord summary.: Use a plausible summary or one source without completing the controlling joins.\n- `canyon-grocery:blanket-hold` — Freeze the entire matter population: Treat supported actions and genuinely ambiguous records as if they were equally unresolved.\n\n## Assumptions and limits\n\nThis decision is limited to cb100-053-canyon-grocery, the supplied synthetic records, and the matter state as of 2026-09-10. Similar names, stale revisions, and pending authority are not treated as proof.\n", "decision": {"actions": [{"determination": "the permission is limited to Maricopa County, Arizona under CB-RE-2903-R676; the matched activity occurred in Arizona under CB-RE-2903-E398. Identity resolves to ENT-053-1000, revision REV-2025.1 is current, and Henry Cho is active with capacity 3.", "due_date": "2026-09-09", "id": "ACT-CBP-053-01", "identity_id": "ENT-053-1000", "issue": "estoppel discrepancy", "owner": "Henry Cho", "portfolio_key": "CBP-053-01", "recommended_action": "Create store-term rows and hold unmatched statements or sales periods. Owner: Henry Cho; due 2026-09-09.", "severity": "medium", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_leases/001_leases_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/02_amendments/013_amendments_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/04_title_survey/025_title_survey_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/05_environmental/037_environmental_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/08_insurance/061_insurance_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/07_operating_expenses/049_operating_expenses_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/12_property_management/097_canyon_grocery_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "the operative cap is $7,762,000.00 under CB-RE-2903-R706; the matched ledger population totals $7,876,106.00 under CB-RE-2903-E506. Identity resolves to ENT-053-1001, revision REV-2025.2 is current, and Maya Ellison is active with capacity 6.", "due_date": "2026-09-08", "id": "ACT-CBP-053-02", "identity_id": "ENT-053-1001", "issue": "permit closeout gap", "owner": "Maya Ellison", "portfolio_key": "CBP-053-02", "recommended_action": "Create store-term rows and hold unmatched statements or sales periods. Owner: Maya Ellison; due 2026-09-08.", "severity": "high", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_leases/002_leases_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/02_amendments/014_amendments_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/04_title_survey/026_title_survey_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/05_environmental/038_environmental_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_property_management/097_canyon_grocery_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "an open exception blocks completion under CB-RE-2903-R311; the current status is open and unresolved under CB-RE-2903-E324. Identity resolves to ENT-053-1003, revision REV-2025.4 is current, and Willa Novak is active with capacity 4.", "due_date": "2026-09-06", "id": "ACT-CBP-053-04", "identity_id": "ENT-053-1003", "issue": "assignment consent", "owner": "Willa Novak", "portfolio_key": "CBP-053-04", "recommended_action": "Create store-term rows and hold unmatched statements or sales periods. Owner: Willa Novak; due 2026-09-06.", "severity": "high", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_leases/004_leases_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/02_amendments/016_amendments_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/04_title_survey/028_title_survey_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/05_environmental/040_environmental_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/10_construction/076_construction_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/08_insurance/064_insurance_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_property_management/097_canyon_grocery_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "the controlling threshold is 9% under CB-RE-2903-R182; the independently calculated result is 17% under CB-RE-2903-E581. Identity resolves to ENT-053-1005, revision REV-2025.6 is current, and Priya Raman is active with capacity 2.", "due_date": "2026-09-04", "id": "ACT-CBP-053-06", "identity_id": "ENT-053-1005", "issue": "construction lien notice", "owner": "Priya Raman", "portfolio_key": "CBP-053-06", "recommended_action": "Create store-term rows and hold unmatched statements or sales periods. Owner: Priya Raman; due 2026-09-04.", "severity": "medium", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_leases/006_leases_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/03_estoppels/018_estoppels_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/04_title_survey/030_title_survey_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/042_zoning_permits_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/10_construction/078_construction_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_property_management/097_canyon_grocery_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "approval must come from Lena Varga under CB-RE-2903-R951; the effective approval record names Henry Cho under CB-RE-2903-E679. Identity resolves to ENT-053-1006, revision REV-2025.7 is current, and Isaac Romero is active with capacity 1.", "due_date": "2026-09-03", "id": "ACT-CBP-053-07", "identity_id": "ENT-053-1006", "issue": "exclusive-use conflict", "owner": "Isaac Romero", "portfolio_key": "CBP-053-07", "recommended_action": "Create store-term rows and hold unmatched statements or sales periods. Owner: Isaac Romero; due 2026-09-03.", "severity": "critical", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_leases/007_leases_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/03_estoppels/019_estoppels_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/04_title_survey/031_title_survey_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/043_zoning_permits_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/12_property_management/097_canyon_grocery_impact_population.xlsx"]}], "as_of": "2026-09-10", "decision": {"alternatives_considered": ["canyon-grocery:shortcut", "canyon-grocery:blanket-hold"], "question": "What renewal, exclusivity, and percentage-rent position applies to each Canyon store?", "rationale": "The four-part causal test supports 5 scoped actions and leaves 7 records on evidence hold. Executed lease terms and valid option notices govern store by store.", "recommendation": "Apply supported renewal and rent corrections and surface real exclusivity conflicts.", "selected_option_id": "canyon-grocery:scoped-evidence"}, "holds": [{"id": "HOLD-CBP-053-03", "issue": "lender SNDA omission", "portfolio_key": "CBP-053-03", "reason": "the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective", "required_next_evidence": "effective approval and an active owner with remaining capacity", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_leases/003_leases_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/02_amendments/015_amendments_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/04_title_survey/027_title_survey_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/05_environmental/039_environmental_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_property_management/097_canyon_grocery_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-053-05", "issue": "zoning nonconformity", "portfolio_key": "CBP-053-05", "reason": "two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key", "required_next_evidence": "an approved immutable entity crosswalk", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_leases/005_leases_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/03_estoppels/017_estoppels_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/04_title_survey/029_title_survey_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/041_zoning_permits_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/12_property_management/089_property_management_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/12_property_management/097_canyon_grocery_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-053-08", "issue": "environmental recognized condition", "portfolio_key": "CBP-053-08", "reason": "the operational record relies on a superseded control revision", "required_next_evidence": "an operational record using the current effective revision", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_leases/008_leases_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/03_estoppels/020_estoppels_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/04_title_survey/032_title_survey_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/044_zoning_permits_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/12_property_management/097_canyon_grocery_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-053-09", "issue": "casualty restoration deadline", "portfolio_key": "CBP-053-09", "reason": "two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key", "required_next_evidence": "an approved immutable entity crosswalk", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_amendments/009_amendments_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/03_estoppels/021_estoppels_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/05_environmental/033_environmental_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/045_zoning_permits_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_property_management/097_canyon_grocery_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-053-10", "issue": "renewal-option notice", "portfolio_key": "CBP-053-10", "reason": "the current observation does not meet the operative trigger", "required_next_evidence": "a current observation that satisfies the operative trigger", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_amendments/010_amendments_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/03_estoppels/022_estoppels_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/05_environmental/034_environmental_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/046_zoning_permits_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_property_management/097_canyon_grocery_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-053-11", "issue": "title exception", "portfolio_key": "CBP-053-11", "reason": "the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective", "required_next_evidence": "effective approval and an active owner with remaining capacity", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_amendments/011_amendments_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/03_estoppels/023_estoppels_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/05_environmental/035_environmental_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/047_zoning_permits_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_property_management/095_property_management_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_property_management/097_canyon_grocery_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-053-12", "issue": "insurance endorsement deficiency", "portfolio_key": "CBP-053-12", "reason": "the operational record relies on a superseded control revision", "required_next_evidence": "an operational record using the current effective revision", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_amendments/012_amendments_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/03_estoppels/024_estoppels_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/05_environmental/036_environmental_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/048_zoning_permits_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_property_management/097_canyon_grocery_impact_population.xlsx"]}], "matter_number": "CB-RE-2903", "prepared_for": "Canyon Fresh Markets", "schema_version": "counselbench.decision.v3", "task_id": "cb100-053-canyon-grocery"}, "matter_register": {"matter_number": "CB-RE-2903", "rows": [{"decision_option_id": "canyon-grocery:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-09", "issue": "estoppel discrepancy", "matter_number": "CB-RE-2903", "owner": "Henry Cho", "portfolio_key": "CBP-053-01", "row_id": "REG-CBP-053-01", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_leases/001_leases_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/02_amendments/013_amendments_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/04_title_survey/025_title_survey_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/05_environmental/037_environmental_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/08_insurance/061_insurance_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/07_operating_expenses/049_operating_expenses_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/12_property_management/097_canyon_grocery_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "canyon-grocery:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-08", "issue": "permit closeout gap", "matter_number": "CB-RE-2903", "owner": "Maya Ellison", "portfolio_key": "CBP-053-02", "row_id": "REG-CBP-053-02", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_leases/002_leases_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/02_amendments/014_amendments_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/04_title_survey/026_title_survey_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/05_environmental/038_environmental_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_property_management/097_canyon_grocery_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "canyon-grocery:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective", "issue": "lender SNDA omission", "matter_number": "CB-RE-2903", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-053-03", "row_id": "REG-CBP-053-03", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_leases/003_leases_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/02_amendments/015_amendments_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/04_title_survey/027_title_survey_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/05_environmental/039_environmental_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_property_management/097_canyon_grocery_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "canyon-grocery:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-06", "issue": "assignment consent", "matter_number": "CB-RE-2903", "owner": "Willa Novak", "portfolio_key": "CBP-053-04", "row_id": "REG-CBP-053-04", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_leases/004_leases_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/02_amendments/016_amendments_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/04_title_survey/028_title_survey_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/05_environmental/040_environmental_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/10_construction/076_construction_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/08_insurance/064_insurance_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_property_management/097_canyon_grocery_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "canyon-grocery:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key", "issue": "zoning nonconformity", "matter_number": "CB-RE-2903", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-053-05", "row_id": "REG-CBP-053-05", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_leases/005_leases_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/03_estoppels/017_estoppels_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/04_title_survey/029_title_survey_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/041_zoning_permits_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/12_property_management/089_property_management_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/12_property_management/097_canyon_grocery_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "canyon-grocery:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-04", "issue": "construction lien notice", "matter_number": "CB-RE-2903", "owner": "Priya Raman", "portfolio_key": "CBP-053-06", "row_id": "REG-CBP-053-06", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_leases/006_leases_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/03_estoppels/018_estoppels_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/04_title_survey/030_title_survey_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/042_zoning_permits_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/10_construction/078_construction_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_property_management/097_canyon_grocery_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "canyon-grocery:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-03", "issue": "exclusive-use conflict", "matter_number": "CB-RE-2903", "owner": "Isaac Romero", "portfolio_key": "CBP-053-07", "row_id": "REG-CBP-053-07", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_leases/007_leases_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/03_estoppels/019_estoppels_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/04_title_survey/031_title_survey_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/043_zoning_permits_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/12_property_management/097_canyon_grocery_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "canyon-grocery:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "the operational record relies on a superseded control revision", "issue": "environmental recognized condition", "matter_number": "CB-RE-2903", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-053-08", "row_id": "REG-CBP-053-08", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_leases/008_leases_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/03_estoppels/020_estoppels_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/04_title_survey/032_title_survey_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/044_zoning_permits_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/12_property_management/097_canyon_grocery_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "canyon-grocery:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key", "issue": "casualty restoration deadline", "matter_number": "CB-RE-2903", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-053-09", "row_id": "REG-CBP-053-09", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_amendments/009_amendments_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/03_estoppels/021_estoppels_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/05_environmental/033_environmental_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/045_zoning_permits_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_property_management/097_canyon_grocery_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "canyon-grocery:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "the current observation does not meet the operative trigger", "issue": "renewal-option notice", "matter_number": "CB-RE-2903", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-053-10", "row_id": "REG-CBP-053-10", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_amendments/010_amendments_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/03_estoppels/022_estoppels_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/05_environmental/034_environmental_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/046_zoning_permits_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_property_management/097_canyon_grocery_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "canyon-grocery:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective", "issue": "title exception", "matter_number": "CB-RE-2903", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-053-11", "row_id": "REG-CBP-053-11", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_amendments/011_amendments_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/03_estoppels/023_estoppels_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/05_environmental/035_environmental_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/047_zoning_permits_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_property_management/095_property_management_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_property_management/097_canyon_grocery_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "canyon-grocery:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "the operational record relies on a superseded control revision", "issue": "insurance endorsement deficiency", "matter_number": "CB-RE-2903", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-053-12", "row_id": "REG-CBP-053-12", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_amendments/012_amendments_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/03_estoppels/024_estoppels_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/05_environmental/036_environmental_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/048_zoning_permits_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_property_management/097_canyon_grocery_impact_population.xlsx"]}], "schema_version": "counselbench.matter-register.v3", "task_id": "cb100-053-canyon-grocery"}}, "metadata": {"benchmark": "CounselBench-100", "code_license": "Apache-2.0", "data_license": "CC-BY-4.0", "deadline": "2026-09-10", "document_count": 97, "evidence_holds": 7, "jurisdiction": "Arizona", "matter_number": "CB-RE-2903", "mcp_commit": "9a96ea6e5913736f92b88345bf51caeaaa8e719f", "mcp_package": "@modelcontextprotocol/server-filesystem@2026.7.10", "practice_area": "real-estate", "reference_tool_calls": 78, "required_evidence_reads": 56, "supported_actions": 5, "synthetic": true, "venue": "Maricopa County, Arizona", "version": "3.1.0"}, "prompt": "A late record changed the picture this morning. What renewal, exclusivity, and percentage-rent position applies to each Canyon store? Store leases contain exclusives, renewal options, and percentage-rent provisions that conflict with landlord statements and payment records. The team needs the call by 2026-09-10. Make the matter record usable by operations after your review, but do not turn ambiguity into an accusation or obligation.", "rubric": {"criteria": [{"category": "investigation", "description": "Inventory the production and use targeted searches to locate records across native formats.", "id": "investigation.discover_production"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Complete every task-specific identity, authority, operations, and approval read before the first state transition.", "id": "investigation.read_before_write"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Inspect designated source metadata before relying on those records.", "id": "investigation.custody_before_write"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "Select the supported option 'canyon-grocery:scoped-evidence' after applying the four-part test.", "id": "decision.selected_option"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "Identify both rejected approaches and explain why a one-source shortcut and a blanket hold are wrong.", "id": "decision.alternatives"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-053-01 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_leases/001_leases_source_export.md rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-053-01.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_amendments/013_amendments_source_export.json for estoppel discrepancy.", "id": "investigation.CBP-053-01.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_title_survey/025_title_survey_source_export.md to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-053-01.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_environmental/037_environmental_source_export.json.", "id": "investigation.CBP-053-01.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-053-01 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-053-01.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-053-01 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-053-01.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-053-02 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_leases/002_leases_source_export.txt rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-053-02.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_amendments/014_amendments_source_export.xml for permit closeout gap.", "id": "investigation.CBP-053-02.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_title_survey/026_title_survey_source_export.txt to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-053-02.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_environmental/038_environmental_source_export.xml.", "id": "investigation.CBP-053-02.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-053-02 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-053-02.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-053-02 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-053-02.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-053-03 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_leases/003_leases_source_export.eml rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-053-03.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_amendments/015_amendments_source_export.html for lender SNDA omission.", "id": "investigation.CBP-053-03.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_title_survey/027_title_survey_source_export.eml to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-053-03.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_environmental/039_environmental_source_export.html.", "id": "investigation.CBP-053-03.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-053-03 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective.", "id": "decision.CBP-053-03.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-053-03 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-053-03.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-053-04 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_leases/004_leases_source_export.csv rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-053-04.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_amendments/016_amendments_source_export.pdf for assignment consent.", "id": "investigation.CBP-053-04.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_title_survey/028_title_survey_source_export.csv to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-053-04.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_environmental/040_environmental_source_export.pdf.", "id": "investigation.CBP-053-04.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-053-04 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-053-04.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-053-04 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-053-04.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-053-05 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_leases/005_leases_source_export.json rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-053-05.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_estoppels/017_estoppels_source_export.md for zoning nonconformity.", "id": "investigation.CBP-053-05.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_title_survey/029_title_survey_source_export.json to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-053-05.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/041_zoning_permits_source_export.md.", "id": "investigation.CBP-053-05.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-053-05 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key.", "id": "decision.CBP-053-05.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-053-05 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-053-05.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-053-06 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_leases/006_leases_source_export.xml rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-053-06.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_estoppels/018_estoppels_source_export.txt for construction lien notice.", "id": "investigation.CBP-053-06.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_title_survey/030_title_survey_source_export.xml to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-053-06.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/042_zoning_permits_source_export.txt.", "id": "investigation.CBP-053-06.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-053-06 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-053-06.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-053-06 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-053-06.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-053-07 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_leases/007_leases_source_export.html rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-053-07.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_estoppels/019_estoppels_source_export.eml for exclusive-use conflict.", "id": "investigation.CBP-053-07.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_title_survey/031_title_survey_source_export.html to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-053-07.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/043_zoning_permits_source_export.eml.", "id": "investigation.CBP-053-07.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-053-07 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-053-07.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-053-07 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-053-07.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-053-08 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_leases/008_leases_source_export.pdf rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-053-08.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_estoppels/020_estoppels_source_export.csv for environmental recognized condition.", "id": "investigation.CBP-053-08.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_title_survey/032_title_survey_source_export.pdf to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-053-08.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/044_zoning_permits_source_export.csv.", "id": "investigation.CBP-053-08.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-053-08 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is the operational record relies on a superseded control revision.", "id": "decision.CBP-053-08.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-053-08 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-053-08.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-053-09 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_amendments/009_amendments_source_export.md rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-053-09.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_estoppels/021_estoppels_source_export.json for casualty restoration deadline.", "id": "investigation.CBP-053-09.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_environmental/033_environmental_source_export.md to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-053-09.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/045_zoning_permits_source_export.json.", "id": "investigation.CBP-053-09.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-053-09 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key.", "id": "decision.CBP-053-09.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-053-09 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-053-09.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-053-10 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_amendments/010_amendments_source_export.txt rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-053-10.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_estoppels/022_estoppels_source_export.xml for renewal-option notice.", "id": "investigation.CBP-053-10.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_environmental/034_environmental_source_export.txt to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-053-10.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/046_zoning_permits_source_export.xml.", "id": "investigation.CBP-053-10.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-053-10 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is the current observation does not meet the operative trigger.", "id": "decision.CBP-053-10.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-053-10 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-053-10.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-053-11 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_amendments/011_amendments_source_export.eml rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-053-11.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_estoppels/023_estoppels_source_export.html for title exception.", "id": "investigation.CBP-053-11.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_environmental/035_environmental_source_export.eml to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-053-11.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/047_zoning_permits_source_export.html.", "id": "investigation.CBP-053-11.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-053-11 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective.", "id": "decision.CBP-053-11.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-053-11 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-053-11.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-053-12 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_amendments/012_amendments_source_export.csv rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-053-12.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_estoppels/024_estoppels_source_export.pdf for insurance endorsement deficiency.", "id": "investigation.CBP-053-12.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_environmental/036_environmental_source_export.csv to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-053-12.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/048_zoning_permits_source_export.pdf.", "id": "investigation.CBP-053-12.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-053-12 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is the operational record relies on a superseded control revision.", "id": "decision.CBP-053-12.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-053-12 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-053-12.register"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Write the exact selected option, supported action population, evidence-hold population, facts, owners, deadlines, and citations.", "id": "state.exact_decision"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create one exact register row per portfolio key with no extra, missing, or modified row.", "id": "state.exact_register"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Leave only the three approved deliverables and perform no extra state-changing write.", "id": "state.write_scope_containment"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Read back decision.json, matter-register.json, and advice.md after their final writes.", "id": "state.postwrite_readback"}, {"category": "answer", "description": "Explain the selected recommendation, supported actions, holds, alternatives, and limitations with exact source anchors.", "id": "answer.decision_note"}], "decision_options": [{"approach": "Use a plausible summary or one source without completing the controlling joins.", "id": "canyon-grocery:shortcut", "label": "Apply one portfolio-wide rule from the landlord summary."}, {"approach": "Treat supported actions and genuinely ambiguous records as if they were equally unresolved.", "id": "canyon-grocery:blanket-hold", "label": "Freeze the entire matter population"}, {"approach": "Apply the exact identity, current-state, authority, and revision test. Create store-term rows and hold unmatched statements or sales periods.", "id": "canyon-grocery:scoped-evidence", "label": "Apply supported renewal and rent corrections and surface real exclusivity conflicts."}], "evaluation_narrative": {"authority": "Executed lease terms and valid option notices govern store by store.", "observation": "Reconcile leases, options, landlord statements, sales records, and payment history by store and term.", "question": "What renewal, exclusivity, and percentage-rent position applies to each Canyon store?", "register_action": "Create store-term rows and hold unmatched statements or sales periods."}, "gates": ["all_required_evidence_precedes_first_write", "decision_criteria_complete", "register_state_exact", "write_scope_contained", "all_outputs_verified_by_readback"], "metadata_checks": 5, "metric": "weighted_criteria_score", "minimum_tool_calls": 78, "required_deliverables": ["decision.json", "matter-register.json", "advice.md"], "required_document_reads": 56, "type": "deterministic", "weights": {"advice": 0.15, "decision": 0.35, "investigation": 0.25, "state": 0.25}}, "task_id": "cb100-053-canyon-grocery", "task_name": "Canyon grocery lease portfolio audit", "world_id": "counselbench-filesystem-mcp-v3"}
+{"context_files": ["task_files/cb100-054-dockside-hotel/01_leases/001_leases_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-054-dockside-hotel/01_leases/002_leases_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-054-dockside-hotel/01_leases/003_leases_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-054-dockside-hotel/01_leases/004_leases_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-054-dockside-hotel/01_leases/005_leases_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-054-dockside-hotel/01_leases/006_leases_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-054-dockside-hotel/01_leases/007_leases_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-054-dockside-hotel/01_leases/008_leases_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-054-dockside-hotel/02_amendments/009_amendments_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-054-dockside-hotel/02_amendments/010_amendments_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-054-dockside-hotel/02_amendments/011_amendments_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-054-dockside-hotel/02_amendments/012_amendments_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-054-dockside-hotel/02_amendments/013_amendments_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-054-dockside-hotel/02_amendments/014_amendments_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-054-dockside-hotel/02_amendments/015_amendments_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-054-dockside-hotel/02_amendments/016_amendments_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-054-dockside-hotel/03_estoppels/017_estoppels_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-054-dockside-hotel/03_estoppels/018_estoppels_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-054-dockside-hotel/03_estoppels/019_estoppels_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-054-dockside-hotel/03_estoppels/020_estoppels_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-054-dockside-hotel/03_estoppels/021_estoppels_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-054-dockside-hotel/03_estoppels/022_estoppels_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-054-dockside-hotel/03_estoppels/023_estoppels_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-054-dockside-hotel/03_estoppels/024_estoppels_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-054-dockside-hotel/04_title_survey/025_title_survey_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-054-dockside-hotel/04_title_survey/026_title_survey_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-054-dockside-hotel/04_title_survey/027_title_survey_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-054-dockside-hotel/04_title_survey/028_title_survey_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-054-dockside-hotel/04_title_survey/029_title_survey_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-054-dockside-hotel/04_title_survey/030_title_survey_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-054-dockside-hotel/04_title_survey/031_title_survey_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-054-dockside-hotel/04_title_survey/032_title_survey_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-054-dockside-hotel/05_environmental/033_environmental_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-054-dockside-hotel/05_environmental/034_environmental_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-054-dockside-hotel/05_environmental/035_environmental_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-054-dockside-hotel/05_environmental/036_environmental_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-054-dockside-hotel/05_environmental/037_environmental_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-054-dockside-hotel/05_environmental/038_environmental_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-054-dockside-hotel/05_environmental/039_environmental_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-054-dockside-hotel/05_environmental/040_environmental_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-054-dockside-hotel/06_zoning_permits/041_zoning_permits_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-054-dockside-hotel/06_zoning_permits/042_zoning_permits_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-054-dockside-hotel/06_zoning_permits/043_zoning_permits_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-054-dockside-hotel/06_zoning_permits/044_zoning_permits_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-054-dockside-hotel/06_zoning_permits/045_zoning_permits_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-054-dockside-hotel/06_zoning_permits/046_zoning_permits_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-054-dockside-hotel/06_zoning_permits/047_zoning_permits_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-054-dockside-hotel/06_zoning_permits/048_zoning_permits_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-054-dockside-hotel/07_operating_expenses/049_operating_expenses_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-054-dockside-hotel/07_operating_expenses/050_operating_expenses_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-054-dockside-hotel/07_operating_expenses/051_operating_expenses_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-054-dockside-hotel/07_operating_expenses/052_operating_expenses_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-054-dockside-hotel/07_operating_expenses/053_operating_expenses_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-054-dockside-hotel/07_operating_expenses/054_operating_expenses_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-054-dockside-hotel/07_operating_expenses/055_operating_expenses_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-054-dockside-hotel/07_operating_expenses/056_operating_expenses_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-054-dockside-hotel/08_insurance/057_insurance_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-054-dockside-hotel/08_insurance/058_insurance_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-054-dockside-hotel/08_insurance/059_insurance_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-054-dockside-hotel/08_insurance/060_insurance_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-054-dockside-hotel/08_insurance/061_insurance_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-054-dockside-hotel/08_insurance/062_insurance_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-054-dockside-hotel/08_insurance/063_insurance_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-054-dockside-hotel/08_insurance/064_insurance_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-054-dockside-hotel/09_notices/065_notices_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-054-dockside-hotel/09_notices/066_notices_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-054-dockside-hotel/09_notices/067_notices_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-054-dockside-hotel/09_notices/068_notices_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-054-dockside-hotel/09_notices/069_notices_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-054-dockside-hotel/09_notices/070_notices_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-054-dockside-hotel/09_notices/071_notices_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-054-dockside-hotel/09_notices/072_notices_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-054-dockside-hotel/10_construction/073_construction_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-054-dockside-hotel/10_construction/074_construction_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-054-dockside-hotel/10_construction/075_construction_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-054-dockside-hotel/10_construction/076_construction_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-054-dockside-hotel/10_construction/077_construction_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-054-dockside-hotel/10_construction/078_construction_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-054-dockside-hotel/10_construction/079_construction_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-054-dockside-hotel/10_construction/080_construction_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-054-dockside-hotel/11_financing/081_financing_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-054-dockside-hotel/11_financing/082_financing_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-054-dockside-hotel/11_financing/083_financing_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-054-dockside-hotel/11_financing/084_financing_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-054-dockside-hotel/11_financing/085_financing_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-054-dockside-hotel/11_financing/086_financing_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-054-dockside-hotel/11_financing/087_financing_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-054-dockside-hotel/11_financing/088_financing_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-054-dockside-hotel/12_property_management/089_property_management_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-054-dockside-hotel/12_property_management/090_property_management_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-054-dockside-hotel/12_property_management/091_property_management_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-054-dockside-hotel/12_property_management/092_property_management_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-054-dockside-hotel/12_property_management/093_property_management_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-054-dockside-hotel/12_property_management/094_property_management_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-054-dockside-hotel/12_property_management/095_property_management_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-054-dockside-hotel/12_property_management/096_property_management_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-054-dockside-hotel/12_property_management/097_dockside_hotel_impact_population.xlsx"], "gold_output": {"advice_markdown": "# Decision note — Dockside hotel financing property audit\n\n## Recommendation\n\nProceed only with supported cure, endorsement, or reserve conditions. The reconciled record supports 8 scoped actions and leaves 4 items on evidence hold.\n\nSelected option: `dockside-hotel:scoped-evidence`.\n\n## Why this is the supported option\n\nJoin survey parcels, casualty milestones, lien notices, and endorsements to financing conditions. Loan conditions and operative property documents require exact parcel, notice, and coverage evidence.\n\n## Supported actions\n\n### CBP-054-01 — survey encroachment (high)\n\nthe controlling threshold is 16% under CB-RE-2904-R333; the independently calculated result is 24% under CB-RE-2904-E378. Identity resolves to ENT-054-1000, revision REV-2026.1 is current, and Farah Ibrahim is active with capacity 2.\n\nAction: Create financing-condition rows and quarantine expired or wrong-property evidence. Owner: Farah Ibrahim; due 2026-09-13.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_leases/001_leases_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/02_amendments/013_amendments_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/04_title_survey/025_title_survey_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/05_environmental/037_environmental_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/11_financing/085_financing_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/10_construction/073_construction_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/12_property_management/097_dockside_hotel_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-054-04 — estoppel discrepancy (critical)\n\nthe permission is limited to Duval County, Florida under CB-RE-2904-R284; the matched activity occurred in Florida under CB-RE-2904-E904. Identity resolves to ENT-054-1003, revision REV-2026.4 is current, and Henry Cho is active with capacity 6.\n\nAction: Create financing-condition rows and quarantine expired or wrong-property evidence. Owner: Henry Cho; due 2026-09-10.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_leases/004_leases_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/02_amendments/016_amendments_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/04_title_survey/028_title_survey_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/05_environmental/040_environmental_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/11_financing/088_financing_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/12_property_management/097_dockside_hotel_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-054-06 — lender SNDA omission (critical)\n\ndelivery must use notices-dockside_hospitality_llc@example.test under CB-RE-2904-R534; the only matched receipt used archive-harbor_quay_lending@example.test under CB-RE-2904-E813. Identity resolves to ENT-054-1005, revision REV-2026.6 is current, and Jonas Feld is active with capacity 3.\n\nAction: Create financing-condition rows and quarantine expired or wrong-property evidence. Owner: Jonas Feld; due 2026-09-08.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_leases/006_leases_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/03_estoppels/018_estoppels_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/04_title_survey/030_title_survey_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/042_zoning_permits_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/10_construction/078_construction_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/12_property_management/090_property_management_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/12_property_management/097_dockside_hotel_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-054-07 — assignment consent (high)\n\nan open exception blocks completion under CB-RE-2904-R212; the current status is open and unresolved under CB-RE-2904-E159. Identity resolves to ENT-054-1006, revision REV-2026.7 is current, and Willa Novak is active with capacity 3.\n\nAction: Create financing-condition rows and quarantine expired or wrong-property evidence. Owner: Willa Novak; due 2026-09-07.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_leases/007_leases_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/03_estoppels/019_estoppels_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/04_title_survey/031_title_survey_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/043_zoning_permits_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/12_property_management/091_property_management_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/12_property_management/097_dockside_hotel_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-054-08 — zoning nonconformity (critical)\n\ncompletion is required by 2025-06-27 under CB-RE-2904-R812; the current event record shows completion on 2025-08-08 under CB-RE-2904-E671. Identity resolves to ENT-054-1007, revision REV-2026.1 is current, and Owen Delgado is active with capacity 6.\n\nAction: Create financing-condition rows and quarantine expired or wrong-property evidence. Owner: Owen Delgado; due 2026-09-06.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_leases/008_leases_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/03_estoppels/020_estoppels_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/04_title_survey/032_title_survey_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/044_zoning_permits_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/10_construction/080_construction_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/12_property_management/092_property_management_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/12_property_management/097_dockside_hotel_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-054-09 — construction lien notice (medium)\n\nthe controlling threshold is 5% under CB-RE-2904-R976; the independently calculated result is 9% under CB-RE-2904-E839. Identity resolves to ENT-054-1008, revision REV-2026.2 is current, and Priya Raman is active with capacity 6.\n\nAction: Create financing-condition rows and quarantine expired or wrong-property evidence. Owner: Priya Raman; due 2026-09-05.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/02_amendments/009_amendments_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/03_estoppels/021_estoppels_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/05_environmental/033_environmental_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/045_zoning_permits_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/08_insurance/057_insurance_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/12_property_management/097_dockside_hotel_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-054-11 — environmental recognized condition (medium)\n\nthe controlled population contains 196 records under CB-RE-2904-R764; the certification covers 181 records under CB-RE-2904-E827. Identity resolves to ENT-054-1010, revision REV-2026.4 is current, and Nadine Flores is active with capacity 4.\n\nAction: Create financing-condition rows and quarantine expired or wrong-property evidence. Owner: Nadine Flores; due 2026-09-12.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/02_amendments/011_amendments_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/03_estoppels/023_estoppels_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/05_environmental/035_environmental_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/047_zoning_permits_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/12_property_management/097_dockside_hotel_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-054-12 — casualty restoration deadline (medium)\n\nthe permission is limited to Duval County, Florida under CB-RE-2904-R624; the matched activity occurred in Florida under CB-RE-2904-E977. Identity resolves to ENT-054-1011, revision REV-2026.5 is current, and Rafael Okafor is active with capacity 5.\n\nAction: Create financing-condition rows and quarantine expired or wrong-property evidence. Owner: Rafael Okafor; due 2026-09-11.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/02_amendments/012_amendments_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/03_estoppels/024_estoppels_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/05_environmental/036_environmental_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/048_zoning_permits_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/12_property_management/097_dockside_hotel_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n## Evidence holds\n\n- **CBP-054-02 — CAM reconciliation error**: the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective. Next evidence: effective approval and an active owner with remaining capacity. Sources: `/workspace/documents/01_leases/002_leases_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/02_amendments/014_amendments_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/04_title_survey/026_title_survey_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/05_environmental/038_environmental_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/12_property_management/097_dockside_hotel_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-054-03 — security-deposit mismatch**: the operational record relies on a superseded control revision. Next evidence: an operational record using the current effective revision. Sources: `/workspace/documents/01_leases/003_leases_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/02_amendments/015_amendments_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/04_title_survey/027_title_survey_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/05_environmental/039_environmental_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/08_insurance/063_insurance_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/11_financing/087_financing_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/12_property_management/097_dockside_hotel_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-054-05 — permit closeout gap**: the current observation does not meet the operative trigger. Next evidence: a current observation that satisfies the operative trigger. Sources: `/workspace/documents/01_leases/005_leases_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/03_estoppels/017_estoppels_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/04_title_survey/029_title_survey_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/041_zoning_permits_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/07_operating_expenses/053_operating_expenses_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/12_property_management/097_dockside_hotel_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-054-10 — exclusive-use conflict**: the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective. Next evidence: effective approval and an active owner with remaining capacity. Sources: `/workspace/documents/02_amendments/010_amendments_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/03_estoppels/022_estoppels_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/05_environmental/034_environmental_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/046_zoning_permits_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/12_property_management/094_property_management_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/12_property_management/097_dockside_hotel_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n## Alternatives considered\n\n- `dockside-hotel:blanket-hold` — Freeze the entire matter population: Treat supported actions and genuinely ambiguous records as if they were equally unresolved.\n- `dockside-hotel:shortcut` — Treat title insurance as eliminating every survey, lien, and restoration issue.: Use a plausible summary or one source without completing the controlling joins.\n\n## Assumptions and limits\n\nThis decision is limited to cb100-054-dockside-hotel, the supplied synthetic records, and the matter state as of 2026-09-14. Similar names, stale revisions, and pending authority are not treated as proof.\n", "decision": {"actions": [{"determination": "the controlling threshold is 16% under CB-RE-2904-R333; the independently calculated result is 24% under CB-RE-2904-E378. Identity resolves to ENT-054-1000, revision REV-2026.1 is current, and Farah Ibrahim is active with capacity 2.", "due_date": "2026-09-13", "id": "ACT-CBP-054-01", "identity_id": "ENT-054-1000", "issue": "survey encroachment", "owner": "Farah Ibrahim", "portfolio_key": "CBP-054-01", "recommended_action": "Create financing-condition rows and quarantine expired or wrong-property evidence. Owner: Farah Ibrahim; due 2026-09-13.", "severity": "high", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_leases/001_leases_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/02_amendments/013_amendments_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/04_title_survey/025_title_survey_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/05_environmental/037_environmental_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/11_financing/085_financing_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/10_construction/073_construction_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/12_property_management/097_dockside_hotel_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "the permission is limited to Duval County, Florida under CB-RE-2904-R284; the matched activity occurred in Florida under CB-RE-2904-E904. Identity resolves to ENT-054-1003, revision REV-2026.4 is current, and Henry Cho is active with capacity 6.", "due_date": "2026-09-10", "id": "ACT-CBP-054-04", "identity_id": "ENT-054-1003", "issue": "estoppel discrepancy", "owner": "Henry Cho", "portfolio_key": "CBP-054-04", "recommended_action": "Create financing-condition rows and quarantine expired or wrong-property evidence. Owner: Henry Cho; due 2026-09-10.", "severity": "critical", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_leases/004_leases_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/02_amendments/016_amendments_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/04_title_survey/028_title_survey_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/05_environmental/040_environmental_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/11_financing/088_financing_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_property_management/097_dockside_hotel_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "delivery must use notices-dockside_hospitality_llc@example.test under CB-RE-2904-R534; the only matched receipt used archive-harbor_quay_lending@example.test under CB-RE-2904-E813. Identity resolves to ENT-054-1005, revision REV-2026.6 is current, and Jonas Feld is active with capacity 3.", "due_date": "2026-09-08", "id": "ACT-CBP-054-06", "identity_id": "ENT-054-1005", "issue": "lender SNDA omission", "owner": "Jonas Feld", "portfolio_key": "CBP-054-06", "recommended_action": "Create financing-condition rows and quarantine expired or wrong-property evidence. Owner: Jonas Feld; due 2026-09-08.", "severity": "critical", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_leases/006_leases_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/03_estoppels/018_estoppels_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/04_title_survey/030_title_survey_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/042_zoning_permits_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/10_construction/078_construction_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_property_management/090_property_management_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/12_property_management/097_dockside_hotel_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "an open exception blocks completion under CB-RE-2904-R212; the current status is open and unresolved under CB-RE-2904-E159. Identity resolves to ENT-054-1006, revision REV-2026.7 is current, and Willa Novak is active with capacity 3.", "due_date": "2026-09-07", "id": "ACT-CBP-054-07", "identity_id": "ENT-054-1006", "issue": "assignment consent", "owner": "Willa Novak", "portfolio_key": "CBP-054-07", "recommended_action": "Create financing-condition rows and quarantine expired or wrong-property evidence. Owner: Willa Novak; due 2026-09-07.", "severity": "high", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_leases/007_leases_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/03_estoppels/019_estoppels_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/04_title_survey/031_title_survey_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/043_zoning_permits_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/12_property_management/091_property_management_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/12_property_management/097_dockside_hotel_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "completion is required by 2025-06-27 under CB-RE-2904-R812; the current event record shows completion on 2025-08-08 under CB-RE-2904-E671. Identity resolves to ENT-054-1007, revision REV-2026.1 is current, and Owen Delgado is active with capacity 6.", "due_date": "2026-09-06", "id": "ACT-CBP-054-08", "identity_id": "ENT-054-1007", "issue": "zoning nonconformity", "owner": "Owen Delgado", "portfolio_key": "CBP-054-08", "recommended_action": "Create financing-condition rows and quarantine expired or wrong-property evidence. Owner: Owen Delgado; due 2026-09-06.", "severity": "critical", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_leases/008_leases_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/03_estoppels/020_estoppels_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/04_title_survey/032_title_survey_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/044_zoning_permits_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/10_construction/080_construction_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_property_management/092_property_management_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/12_property_management/097_dockside_hotel_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "the controlling threshold is 5% under CB-RE-2904-R976; the independently calculated result is 9% under CB-RE-2904-E839. Identity resolves to ENT-054-1008, revision REV-2026.2 is current, and Priya Raman is active with capacity 6.", "due_date": "2026-09-05", "id": "ACT-CBP-054-09", "identity_id": "ENT-054-1008", "issue": "construction lien notice", "owner": "Priya Raman", "portfolio_key": "CBP-054-09", "recommended_action": "Create financing-condition rows and quarantine expired or wrong-property evidence. Owner: Priya Raman; due 2026-09-05.", "severity": "medium", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_amendments/009_amendments_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/03_estoppels/021_estoppels_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/05_environmental/033_environmental_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/045_zoning_permits_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/08_insurance/057_insurance_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/12_property_management/097_dockside_hotel_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "the controlled population contains 196 records under CB-RE-2904-R764; the certification covers 181 records under CB-RE-2904-E827. Identity resolves to ENT-054-1010, revision REV-2026.4 is current, and Nadine Flores is active with capacity 4.", "due_date": "2026-09-12", "id": "ACT-CBP-054-11", "identity_id": "ENT-054-1010", "issue": "environmental recognized condition", "owner": "Nadine Flores", "portfolio_key": "CBP-054-11", "recommended_action": "Create financing-condition rows and quarantine expired or wrong-property evidence. Owner: Nadine Flores; due 2026-09-12.", "severity": "medium", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_amendments/011_amendments_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/03_estoppels/023_estoppels_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/05_environmental/035_environmental_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/047_zoning_permits_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_property_management/097_dockside_hotel_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "the permission is limited to Duval County, Florida under CB-RE-2904-R624; the matched activity occurred in Florida under CB-RE-2904-E977. Identity resolves to ENT-054-1011, revision REV-2026.5 is current, and Rafael Okafor is active with capacity 5.", "due_date": "2026-09-11", "id": "ACT-CBP-054-12", "identity_id": "ENT-054-1011", "issue": "casualty restoration deadline", "owner": "Rafael Okafor", "portfolio_key": "CBP-054-12", "recommended_action": "Create financing-condition rows and quarantine expired or wrong-property evidence. Owner: Rafael Okafor; due 2026-09-11.", "severity": "medium", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_amendments/012_amendments_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/03_estoppels/024_estoppels_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/05_environmental/036_environmental_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/048_zoning_permits_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_property_management/097_dockside_hotel_impact_population.xlsx"]}], "as_of": "2026-09-14", "decision": {"alternatives_considered": ["dockside-hotel:blanket-hold", "dockside-hotel:shortcut"], "question": "Can Dockside close its financing with the encroachment, restoration, lien, and insurance record?", "rationale": "The four-part causal test supports 8 scoped actions and leaves 4 records on evidence hold. Loan conditions and operative property documents require exact parcel, notice, and coverage evidence.", "recommendation": "Proceed only with supported cure, endorsement, or reserve conditions.", "selected_option_id": "dockside-hotel:scoped-evidence"}, "holds": [{"id": "HOLD-CBP-054-02", "issue": "CAM reconciliation error", "portfolio_key": "CBP-054-02", "reason": "the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective", "required_next_evidence": "effective approval and an active owner with remaining capacity", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_leases/002_leases_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/02_amendments/014_amendments_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/04_title_survey/026_title_survey_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/05_environmental/038_environmental_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_property_management/097_dockside_hotel_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-054-03", "issue": "security-deposit mismatch", "portfolio_key": "CBP-054-03", "reason": "the operational record relies on a superseded control revision", "required_next_evidence": "an operational record using the current effective revision", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_leases/003_leases_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/02_amendments/015_amendments_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/04_title_survey/027_title_survey_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/05_environmental/039_environmental_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/08_insurance/063_insurance_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/11_financing/087_financing_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_property_management/097_dockside_hotel_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-054-05", "issue": "permit closeout gap", "portfolio_key": "CBP-054-05", "reason": "the current observation does not meet the operative trigger", "required_next_evidence": "a current observation that satisfies the operative trigger", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_leases/005_leases_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/03_estoppels/017_estoppels_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/04_title_survey/029_title_survey_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/041_zoning_permits_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/07_operating_expenses/053_operating_expenses_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_property_management/097_dockside_hotel_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-054-10", "issue": "exclusive-use conflict", "portfolio_key": "CBP-054-10", "reason": "the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective", "required_next_evidence": "effective approval and an active owner with remaining capacity", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_amendments/010_amendments_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/03_estoppels/022_estoppels_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/05_environmental/034_environmental_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/046_zoning_permits_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_property_management/094_property_management_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_property_management/097_dockside_hotel_impact_population.xlsx"]}], "matter_number": "CB-RE-2904", "prepared_for": "Dockside Hospitality LLC", "schema_version": "counselbench.decision.v3", "task_id": "cb100-054-dockside-hotel"}, "matter_register": {"matter_number": "CB-RE-2904", "rows": [{"decision_option_id": "dockside-hotel:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-13", "issue": "survey encroachment", "matter_number": "CB-RE-2904", "owner": "Farah Ibrahim", "portfolio_key": "CBP-054-01", "row_id": "REG-CBP-054-01", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_leases/001_leases_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/02_amendments/013_amendments_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/04_title_survey/025_title_survey_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/05_environmental/037_environmental_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/11_financing/085_financing_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/10_construction/073_construction_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/12_property_management/097_dockside_hotel_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "dockside-hotel:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective", "issue": "CAM reconciliation error", "matter_number": "CB-RE-2904", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-054-02", "row_id": "REG-CBP-054-02", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_leases/002_leases_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/02_amendments/014_amendments_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/04_title_survey/026_title_survey_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/05_environmental/038_environmental_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_property_management/097_dockside_hotel_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "dockside-hotel:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "the operational record relies on a superseded control revision", "issue": "security-deposit mismatch", "matter_number": "CB-RE-2904", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-054-03", "row_id": "REG-CBP-054-03", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_leases/003_leases_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/02_amendments/015_amendments_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/04_title_survey/027_title_survey_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/05_environmental/039_environmental_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/08_insurance/063_insurance_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/11_financing/087_financing_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_property_management/097_dockside_hotel_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "dockside-hotel:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-10", "issue": "estoppel discrepancy", "matter_number": "CB-RE-2904", "owner": "Henry Cho", "portfolio_key": "CBP-054-04", "row_id": "REG-CBP-054-04", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_leases/004_leases_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/02_amendments/016_amendments_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/04_title_survey/028_title_survey_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/05_environmental/040_environmental_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/11_financing/088_financing_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_property_management/097_dockside_hotel_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "dockside-hotel:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "the current observation does not meet the operative trigger", "issue": "permit closeout gap", "matter_number": "CB-RE-2904", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-054-05", "row_id": "REG-CBP-054-05", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_leases/005_leases_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/03_estoppels/017_estoppels_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/04_title_survey/029_title_survey_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/041_zoning_permits_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/07_operating_expenses/053_operating_expenses_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_property_management/097_dockside_hotel_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "dockside-hotel:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-08", "issue": "lender SNDA omission", "matter_number": "CB-RE-2904", "owner": "Jonas Feld", "portfolio_key": "CBP-054-06", "row_id": "REG-CBP-054-06", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_leases/006_leases_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/03_estoppels/018_estoppels_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/04_title_survey/030_title_survey_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/042_zoning_permits_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/10_construction/078_construction_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_property_management/090_property_management_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/12_property_management/097_dockside_hotel_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "dockside-hotel:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-07", "issue": "assignment consent", "matter_number": "CB-RE-2904", "owner": "Willa Novak", "portfolio_key": "CBP-054-07", "row_id": "REG-CBP-054-07", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_leases/007_leases_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/03_estoppels/019_estoppels_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/04_title_survey/031_title_survey_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/043_zoning_permits_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/12_property_management/091_property_management_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/12_property_management/097_dockside_hotel_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "dockside-hotel:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-06", "issue": "zoning nonconformity", "matter_number": "CB-RE-2904", "owner": "Owen Delgado", "portfolio_key": "CBP-054-08", "row_id": "REG-CBP-054-08", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_leases/008_leases_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/03_estoppels/020_estoppels_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/04_title_survey/032_title_survey_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/044_zoning_permits_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/10_construction/080_construction_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_property_management/092_property_management_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/12_property_management/097_dockside_hotel_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "dockside-hotel:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-05", "issue": "construction lien notice", "matter_number": "CB-RE-2904", "owner": "Priya Raman", "portfolio_key": "CBP-054-09", "row_id": "REG-CBP-054-09", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_amendments/009_amendments_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/03_estoppels/021_estoppels_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/05_environmental/033_environmental_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/045_zoning_permits_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/08_insurance/057_insurance_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/12_property_management/097_dockside_hotel_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "dockside-hotel:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective", "issue": "exclusive-use conflict", "matter_number": "CB-RE-2904", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-054-10", "row_id": "REG-CBP-054-10", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_amendments/010_amendments_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/03_estoppels/022_estoppels_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/05_environmental/034_environmental_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/046_zoning_permits_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_property_management/094_property_management_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_property_management/097_dockside_hotel_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "dockside-hotel:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-12", "issue": "environmental recognized condition", "matter_number": "CB-RE-2904", "owner": "Nadine Flores", "portfolio_key": "CBP-054-11", "row_id": "REG-CBP-054-11", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_amendments/011_amendments_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/03_estoppels/023_estoppels_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/05_environmental/035_environmental_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/047_zoning_permits_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_property_management/097_dockside_hotel_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "dockside-hotel:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-11", "issue": "casualty restoration deadline", "matter_number": "CB-RE-2904", "owner": "Rafael Okafor", "portfolio_key": "CBP-054-12", "row_id": "REG-CBP-054-12", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_amendments/012_amendments_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/03_estoppels/024_estoppels_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/05_environmental/036_environmental_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/048_zoning_permits_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_property_management/097_dockside_hotel_impact_population.xlsx"]}], "schema_version": "counselbench.matter-register.v3", "task_id": "cb100-054-dockside-hotel"}}, "metadata": {"benchmark": "CounselBench-100", "code_license": "Apache-2.0", "data_license": "CC-BY-4.0", "deadline": "2026-09-14", "document_count": 97, "evidence_holds": 4, "jurisdiction": "Florida", "matter_number": "CB-RE-2904", "mcp_commit": "9a96ea6e5913736f92b88345bf51caeaaa8e719f", "mcp_package": "@modelcontextprotocol/server-filesystem@2026.7.10", "practice_area": "real-estate", "reference_tool_calls": 89, "required_evidence_reads": 63, "supported_actions": 8, "synthetic": true, "venue": "Duval County, Florida", "version": "3.1.0"}, "prompt": "The client wants a decision, not another document inventory. Can Dockside close its financing with the encroachment, restoration, lien, and insurance record? A waterfront hotel has a survey encroachment, restoration deadline, construction lien notice, and missing insurance endorsement. The team needs the call by 2026-09-14. Put the supported calls into the matter register and leave me a short note I can use with the partner.", "rubric": {"criteria": [{"category": "investigation", "description": "Inventory the production and use targeted searches to locate records across native formats.", "id": "investigation.discover_production"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Complete every task-specific identity, authority, operations, and approval read before the first state transition.", "id": "investigation.read_before_write"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Inspect designated source metadata before relying on those records.", "id": "investigation.custody_before_write"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "Select the supported option 'dockside-hotel:scoped-evidence' after applying the four-part test.", "id": "decision.selected_option"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "Identify both rejected approaches and explain why a one-source shortcut and a blanket hold are wrong.", "id": "decision.alternatives"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-054-01 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_leases/001_leases_source_export.md rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-054-01.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_amendments/013_amendments_source_export.json for survey encroachment.", "id": "investigation.CBP-054-01.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_title_survey/025_title_survey_source_export.md to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-054-01.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_environmental/037_environmental_source_export.json.", "id": "investigation.CBP-054-01.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-054-01 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-054-01.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-054-01 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-054-01.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-054-02 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_leases/002_leases_source_export.txt rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-054-02.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_amendments/014_amendments_source_export.xml for CAM reconciliation error.", "id": "investigation.CBP-054-02.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_title_survey/026_title_survey_source_export.txt to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-054-02.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_environmental/038_environmental_source_export.xml.", "id": "investigation.CBP-054-02.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-054-02 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective.", "id": "decision.CBP-054-02.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-054-02 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-054-02.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-054-03 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_leases/003_leases_source_export.eml rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-054-03.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_amendments/015_amendments_source_export.html for security-deposit mismatch.", "id": "investigation.CBP-054-03.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_title_survey/027_title_survey_source_export.eml to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-054-03.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_environmental/039_environmental_source_export.html.", "id": "investigation.CBP-054-03.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-054-03 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is the operational record relies on a superseded control revision.", "id": "decision.CBP-054-03.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-054-03 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-054-03.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-054-04 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_leases/004_leases_source_export.csv rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-054-04.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_amendments/016_amendments_source_export.pdf for estoppel discrepancy.", "id": "investigation.CBP-054-04.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_title_survey/028_title_survey_source_export.csv to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-054-04.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_environmental/040_environmental_source_export.pdf.", "id": "investigation.CBP-054-04.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-054-04 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-054-04.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-054-04 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-054-04.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-054-05 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_leases/005_leases_source_export.json rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-054-05.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_estoppels/017_estoppels_source_export.md for permit closeout gap.", "id": "investigation.CBP-054-05.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_title_survey/029_title_survey_source_export.json to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-054-05.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/041_zoning_permits_source_export.md.", "id": "investigation.CBP-054-05.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-054-05 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is the current observation does not meet the operative trigger.", "id": "decision.CBP-054-05.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-054-05 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-054-05.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-054-06 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_leases/006_leases_source_export.xml rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-054-06.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_estoppels/018_estoppels_source_export.txt for lender SNDA omission.", "id": "investigation.CBP-054-06.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_title_survey/030_title_survey_source_export.xml to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-054-06.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/042_zoning_permits_source_export.txt.", "id": "investigation.CBP-054-06.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-054-06 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-054-06.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-054-06 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-054-06.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-054-07 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_leases/007_leases_source_export.html rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-054-07.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_estoppels/019_estoppels_source_export.eml for assignment consent.", "id": "investigation.CBP-054-07.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_title_survey/031_title_survey_source_export.html to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-054-07.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/043_zoning_permits_source_export.eml.", "id": "investigation.CBP-054-07.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-054-07 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-054-07.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-054-07 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-054-07.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-054-08 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_leases/008_leases_source_export.pdf rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-054-08.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_estoppels/020_estoppels_source_export.csv for zoning nonconformity.", "id": "investigation.CBP-054-08.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_title_survey/032_title_survey_source_export.pdf to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-054-08.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/044_zoning_permits_source_export.csv.", "id": "investigation.CBP-054-08.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-054-08 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-054-08.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-054-08 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-054-08.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-054-09 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_amendments/009_amendments_source_export.md rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-054-09.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_estoppels/021_estoppels_source_export.json for construction lien notice.", "id": "investigation.CBP-054-09.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_environmental/033_environmental_source_export.md to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-054-09.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/045_zoning_permits_source_export.json.", "id": "investigation.CBP-054-09.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-054-09 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-054-09.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-054-09 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-054-09.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-054-10 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_amendments/010_amendments_source_export.txt rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-054-10.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_estoppels/022_estoppels_source_export.xml for exclusive-use conflict.", "id": "investigation.CBP-054-10.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_environmental/034_environmental_source_export.txt to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-054-10.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/046_zoning_permits_source_export.xml.", "id": "investigation.CBP-054-10.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-054-10 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective.", "id": "decision.CBP-054-10.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-054-10 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-054-10.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-054-11 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_amendments/011_amendments_source_export.eml rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-054-11.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_estoppels/023_estoppels_source_export.html for environmental recognized condition.", "id": "investigation.CBP-054-11.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_environmental/035_environmental_source_export.eml to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-054-11.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/047_zoning_permits_source_export.html.", "id": "investigation.CBP-054-11.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-054-11 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-054-11.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-054-11 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-054-11.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-054-12 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_amendments/012_amendments_source_export.csv rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-054-12.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_estoppels/024_estoppels_source_export.pdf for casualty restoration deadline.", "id": "investigation.CBP-054-12.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_environmental/036_environmental_source_export.csv to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-054-12.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/048_zoning_permits_source_export.pdf.", "id": "investigation.CBP-054-12.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-054-12 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-054-12.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-054-12 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-054-12.register"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Write the exact selected option, supported action population, evidence-hold population, facts, owners, deadlines, and citations.", "id": "state.exact_decision"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create one exact register row per portfolio key with no extra, missing, or modified row.", "id": "state.exact_register"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Leave only the three approved deliverables and perform no extra state-changing write.", "id": "state.write_scope_containment"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Read back decision.json, matter-register.json, and advice.md after their final writes.", "id": "state.postwrite_readback"}, {"category": "answer", "description": "Explain the selected recommendation, supported actions, holds, alternatives, and limitations with exact source anchors.", "id": "answer.decision_note"}], "decision_options": [{"approach": "Treat supported actions and genuinely ambiguous records as if they were equally unresolved.", "id": "dockside-hotel:blanket-hold", "label": "Freeze the entire matter population"}, {"approach": "Apply the exact identity, current-state, authority, and revision test. Create financing-condition rows and quarantine expired or wrong-property evidence.", "id": "dockside-hotel:scoped-evidence", "label": "Proceed only with supported cure, endorsement, or reserve conditions."}, {"approach": "Use a plausible summary or one source without completing the controlling joins.", "id": "dockside-hotel:shortcut", "label": "Treat title insurance as eliminating every survey, lien, and restoration issue."}], "evaluation_narrative": {"authority": "Loan conditions and operative property documents require exact parcel, notice, and coverage evidence.", "observation": "Join survey parcels, casualty milestones, lien notices, and endorsements to financing conditions.", "question": "Can Dockside close its financing with the encroachment, restoration, lien, and insurance record?", "register_action": "Create financing-condition rows and quarantine expired or wrong-property evidence."}, "gates": ["all_required_evidence_precedes_first_write", "decision_criteria_complete", "register_state_exact", "write_scope_contained", "all_outputs_verified_by_readback"], "metadata_checks": 10, "metric": "weighted_criteria_score", "minimum_tool_calls": 89, "required_deliverables": ["decision.json", "matter-register.json", "advice.md"], "required_document_reads": 63, "type": "deterministic", "weights": {"advice": 0.15, "decision": 0.35, "investigation": 0.25, "state": 0.25}}, "task_id": "cb100-054-dockside-hotel", "task_name": "Dockside hotel financing property audit", "world_id": "counselbench-filesystem-mcp-v3"}
+{"context_files": ["task_files/cb100-055-eastgate-labs/01_leases/001_leases_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-055-eastgate-labs/01_leases/002_leases_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-055-eastgate-labs/01_leases/003_leases_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-055-eastgate-labs/01_leases/004_leases_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-055-eastgate-labs/01_leases/005_leases_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-055-eastgate-labs/01_leases/006_leases_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-055-eastgate-labs/01_leases/007_leases_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-055-eastgate-labs/01_leases/008_leases_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-055-eastgate-labs/02_amendments/009_amendments_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-055-eastgate-labs/02_amendments/010_amendments_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-055-eastgate-labs/02_amendments/011_amendments_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-055-eastgate-labs/02_amendments/012_amendments_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-055-eastgate-labs/02_amendments/013_amendments_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-055-eastgate-labs/02_amendments/014_amendments_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-055-eastgate-labs/02_amendments/015_amendments_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-055-eastgate-labs/02_amendments/016_amendments_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-055-eastgate-labs/03_estoppels/017_estoppels_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-055-eastgate-labs/03_estoppels/018_estoppels_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-055-eastgate-labs/03_estoppels/019_estoppels_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-055-eastgate-labs/03_estoppels/020_estoppels_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-055-eastgate-labs/03_estoppels/021_estoppels_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-055-eastgate-labs/03_estoppels/022_estoppels_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-055-eastgate-labs/03_estoppels/023_estoppels_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-055-eastgate-labs/03_estoppels/024_estoppels_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-055-eastgate-labs/04_title_survey/025_title_survey_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-055-eastgate-labs/04_title_survey/026_title_survey_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-055-eastgate-labs/04_title_survey/027_title_survey_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-055-eastgate-labs/04_title_survey/028_title_survey_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-055-eastgate-labs/04_title_survey/029_title_survey_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-055-eastgate-labs/04_title_survey/030_title_survey_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-055-eastgate-labs/04_title_survey/031_title_survey_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-055-eastgate-labs/04_title_survey/032_title_survey_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-055-eastgate-labs/05_environmental/033_environmental_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-055-eastgate-labs/05_environmental/034_environmental_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-055-eastgate-labs/05_environmental/035_environmental_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-055-eastgate-labs/05_environmental/036_environmental_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-055-eastgate-labs/05_environmental/037_environmental_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-055-eastgate-labs/05_environmental/038_environmental_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-055-eastgate-labs/05_environmental/039_environmental_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-055-eastgate-labs/05_environmental/040_environmental_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-055-eastgate-labs/06_zoning_permits/041_zoning_permits_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-055-eastgate-labs/06_zoning_permits/042_zoning_permits_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-055-eastgate-labs/06_zoning_permits/043_zoning_permits_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-055-eastgate-labs/06_zoning_permits/044_zoning_permits_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-055-eastgate-labs/06_zoning_permits/045_zoning_permits_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-055-eastgate-labs/06_zoning_permits/046_zoning_permits_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-055-eastgate-labs/06_zoning_permits/047_zoning_permits_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-055-eastgate-labs/06_zoning_permits/048_zoning_permits_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-055-eastgate-labs/07_operating_expenses/049_operating_expenses_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-055-eastgate-labs/07_operating_expenses/050_operating_expenses_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-055-eastgate-labs/07_operating_expenses/051_operating_expenses_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-055-eastgate-labs/07_operating_expenses/052_operating_expenses_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-055-eastgate-labs/07_operating_expenses/053_operating_expenses_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-055-eastgate-labs/07_operating_expenses/054_operating_expenses_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-055-eastgate-labs/07_operating_expenses/055_operating_expenses_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-055-eastgate-labs/07_operating_expenses/056_operating_expenses_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-055-eastgate-labs/08_insurance/057_insurance_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-055-eastgate-labs/08_insurance/058_insurance_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-055-eastgate-labs/08_insurance/059_insurance_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-055-eastgate-labs/08_insurance/060_insurance_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-055-eastgate-labs/08_insurance/061_insurance_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-055-eastgate-labs/08_insurance/062_insurance_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-055-eastgate-labs/08_insurance/063_insurance_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-055-eastgate-labs/08_insurance/064_insurance_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-055-eastgate-labs/09_notices/065_notices_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-055-eastgate-labs/09_notices/066_notices_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-055-eastgate-labs/09_notices/067_notices_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-055-eastgate-labs/09_notices/068_notices_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-055-eastgate-labs/09_notices/069_notices_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-055-eastgate-labs/09_notices/070_notices_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-055-eastgate-labs/09_notices/071_notices_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-055-eastgate-labs/09_notices/072_notices_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-055-eastgate-labs/10_construction/073_construction_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-055-eastgate-labs/10_construction/074_construction_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-055-eastgate-labs/10_construction/075_construction_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-055-eastgate-labs/10_construction/076_construction_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-055-eastgate-labs/10_construction/077_construction_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-055-eastgate-labs/10_construction/078_construction_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-055-eastgate-labs/10_construction/079_construction_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-055-eastgate-labs/10_construction/080_construction_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-055-eastgate-labs/11_financing/081_financing_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-055-eastgate-labs/11_financing/082_financing_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-055-eastgate-labs/11_financing/083_financing_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-055-eastgate-labs/11_financing/084_financing_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-055-eastgate-labs/11_financing/085_financing_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-055-eastgate-labs/11_financing/086_financing_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-055-eastgate-labs/11_financing/087_financing_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-055-eastgate-labs/11_financing/088_financing_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-055-eastgate-labs/12_property_management/089_property_management_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-055-eastgate-labs/12_property_management/090_property_management_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-055-eastgate-labs/12_property_management/091_property_management_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-055-eastgate-labs/12_property_management/092_property_management_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-055-eastgate-labs/12_property_management/093_property_management_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-055-eastgate-labs/12_property_management/094_property_management_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-055-eastgate-labs/12_property_management/095_property_management_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-055-eastgate-labs/12_property_management/096_property_management_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-055-eastgate-labs/12_property_management/097_eastgate_labs_impact_population.xlsx"], "gold_output": {"advice_markdown": "# Decision note — Eastgate laboratory campus diligence\n\n## Recommendation\n\nApprove only phases with supported rights and permits; create scoped cures for the rest. The reconciled record supports 5 scoped actions and leaves 7 items on evidence hold.\n\nSelected option: `eastgate-labs:scoped-evidence`.\n\n## Why this is the supported option\n\nMatch premises, hazardous uses, amendments, estoppels, permits, and manager records by suite and phase. Operative lease scope and current governmental approvals govern each expansion phase.\n\n## Supported actions\n\n### CBP-055-01 — title exception (low)\n\ndelivery must use notices-eastgate_life_sciences@example.test under CB-RE-2905-R153; the only matched receipt used archive-polymer_park_properties@example.test under CB-RE-2905-E209. Identity resolves to ENT-055-1000, revision REV-2025.1 is current, and Samuel Kim is active with capacity 4.\n\nAction: Create suite-phase rows with exact consent and permit holds. Owner: Samuel Kim; due 2026-09-16.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_leases/001_leases_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/02_amendments/013_amendments_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/04_title_survey/025_title_survey_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/05_environmental/037_environmental_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/07_operating_expenses/049_operating_expenses_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/12_property_management/097_eastgate_labs_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-055-02 — insurance endorsement deficiency (high)\n\nan open exception blocks completion under CB-RE-2905-R110; the current status is open and unresolved under CB-RE-2905-E894. Identity resolves to ENT-055-1001, revision REV-2025.2 is current, and Talia Brooks is active with capacity 1.\n\nAction: Create suite-phase rows with exact consent and permit holds. Owner: Talia Brooks; due 2026-09-15.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_leases/002_leases_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/02_amendments/014_amendments_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/04_title_survey/026_title_survey_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/05_environmental/038_environmental_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/07_operating_expenses/050_operating_expenses_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/10_construction/074_construction_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/12_property_management/097_eastgate_labs_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-055-03 — rent schedule inconsistency (critical)\n\ncompletion is required by 2025-04-01 under CB-RE-2905-R665; the current event record shows completion on 2025-05-06 under CB-RE-2905-E450. Identity resolves to ENT-055-1002, revision REV-2025.3 is current, and Adrian Mensah is active with capacity 3.\n\nAction: Create suite-phase rows with exact consent and permit holds. Owner: Adrian Mensah; due 2026-09-14.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_leases/003_leases_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/02_amendments/015_amendments_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/04_title_survey/027_title_survey_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/05_environmental/039_environmental_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/12_property_management/097_eastgate_labs_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-055-08 — permit closeout gap (low)\n\nthe operative cap is $3,082,000.00 under CB-RE-2905-R108; the matched ledger population totals $3,333,208.00 under CB-RE-2905-E894. Identity resolves to ENT-055-1007, revision REV-2025.1 is current, and Maya Ellison is active with capacity 1.\n\nAction: Create suite-phase rows with exact consent and permit holds. Owner: Maya Ellison; due 2026-09-09.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_leases/008_leases_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/03_estoppels/020_estoppels_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/04_title_survey/032_title_survey_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/044_zoning_permits_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/12_property_management/092_property_management_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/07_operating_expenses/056_operating_expenses_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/12_property_management/097_eastgate_labs_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-055-10 — assignment consent (critical)\n\nan open exception blocks completion under CB-RE-2905-R886; the current status is open and unresolved under CB-RE-2905-E622. Identity resolves to ENT-055-1009, revision REV-2025.3 is current, and Willa Novak is active with capacity 4.\n\nAction: Create suite-phase rows with exact consent and permit holds. Owner: Willa Novak; due 2026-09-16.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/02_amendments/010_amendments_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/03_estoppels/022_estoppels_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/05_environmental/034_environmental_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/046_zoning_permits_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/12_property_management/097_eastgate_labs_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n## Evidence holds\n\n- **CBP-055-04 — survey encroachment**: the current observation does not meet the operative trigger. Next evidence: a current observation that satisfies the operative trigger. Sources: `/workspace/documents/01_leases/004_leases_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/02_amendments/016_amendments_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/04_title_survey/028_title_survey_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/05_environmental/040_environmental_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/12_property_management/097_eastgate_labs_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-055-05 — CAM reconciliation error**: the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective. Next evidence: effective approval and an active owner with remaining capacity. Sources: `/workspace/documents/01_leases/005_leases_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/03_estoppels/017_estoppels_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/04_title_survey/029_title_survey_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/041_zoning_permits_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/12_property_management/097_eastgate_labs_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-055-06 — security-deposit mismatch**: the operational record relies on a superseded control revision. Next evidence: an operational record using the current effective revision. Sources: `/workspace/documents/01_leases/006_leases_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/03_estoppels/018_estoppels_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/04_title_survey/030_title_survey_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/042_zoning_permits_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/12_property_management/097_eastgate_labs_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-055-07 — estoppel discrepancy**: two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key. Next evidence: an approved immutable entity crosswalk. Sources: `/workspace/documents/01_leases/007_leases_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/03_estoppels/019_estoppels_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/04_title_survey/031_title_survey_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/043_zoning_permits_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/10_construction/079_construction_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/12_property_management/097_eastgate_labs_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-055-09 — lender SNDA omission**: the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective. Next evidence: effective approval and an active owner with remaining capacity. Sources: `/workspace/documents/02_amendments/009_amendments_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/03_estoppels/021_estoppels_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/05_environmental/033_environmental_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/045_zoning_permits_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/09_notices/069_notices_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/11_financing/081_financing_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/12_property_management/097_eastgate_labs_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-055-11 — zoning nonconformity**: two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key. Next evidence: an approved immutable entity crosswalk. Sources: `/workspace/documents/02_amendments/011_amendments_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/03_estoppels/023_estoppels_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/05_environmental/035_environmental_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/047_zoning_permits_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/12_property_management/095_property_management_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/09_notices/071_notices_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/12_property_management/097_eastgate_labs_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-055-12 — construction lien notice**: the current observation does not meet the operative trigger. Next evidence: a current observation that satisfies the operative trigger. Sources: `/workspace/documents/02_amendments/012_amendments_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/03_estoppels/024_estoppels_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/05_environmental/036_environmental_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/048_zoning_permits_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/12_property_management/097_eastgate_labs_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n## Alternatives considered\n\n- `eastgate-labs:shortcut` — Assume property-manager operations prove legal permission.: Use a plausible summary or one source without completing the controlling joins.\n- `eastgate-labs:blanket-hold` — Freeze the entire matter population: Treat supported actions and genuinely ambiguous records as if they were equally unresolved.\n\n## Assumptions and limits\n\nThis decision is limited to cb100-055-eastgate-labs, the supplied synthetic records, and the matter state as of 2026-09-17. Similar names, stale revisions, and pending authority are not treated as proof.\n", "decision": {"actions": [{"determination": "delivery must use notices-eastgate_life_sciences@example.test under CB-RE-2905-R153; the only matched receipt used archive-polymer_park_properties@example.test under CB-RE-2905-E209. Identity resolves to ENT-055-1000, revision REV-2025.1 is current, and Samuel Kim is active with capacity 4.", "due_date": "2026-09-16", "id": "ACT-CBP-055-01", "identity_id": "ENT-055-1000", "issue": "title exception", "owner": "Samuel Kim", "portfolio_key": "CBP-055-01", "recommended_action": "Create suite-phase rows with exact consent and permit holds. Owner: Samuel Kim; due 2026-09-16.", "severity": "low", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_leases/001_leases_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/02_amendments/013_amendments_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/04_title_survey/025_title_survey_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/05_environmental/037_environmental_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/07_operating_expenses/049_operating_expenses_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/12_property_management/097_eastgate_labs_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "an open exception blocks completion under CB-RE-2905-R110; the current status is open and unresolved under CB-RE-2905-E894. Identity resolves to ENT-055-1001, revision REV-2025.2 is current, and Talia Brooks is active with capacity 1.", "due_date": "2026-09-15", "id": "ACT-CBP-055-02", "identity_id": "ENT-055-1001", "issue": "insurance endorsement deficiency", "owner": "Talia Brooks", "portfolio_key": "CBP-055-02", "recommended_action": "Create suite-phase rows with exact consent and permit holds. Owner: Talia Brooks; due 2026-09-15.", "severity": "high", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_leases/002_leases_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/02_amendments/014_amendments_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/04_title_survey/026_title_survey_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/05_environmental/038_environmental_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/07_operating_expenses/050_operating_expenses_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/10_construction/074_construction_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/12_property_management/097_eastgate_labs_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "completion is required by 2025-04-01 under CB-RE-2905-R665; the current event record shows completion on 2025-05-06 under CB-RE-2905-E450. Identity resolves to ENT-055-1002, revision REV-2025.3 is current, and Adrian Mensah is active with capacity 3.", "due_date": "2026-09-14", "id": "ACT-CBP-055-03", "identity_id": "ENT-055-1002", "issue": "rent schedule inconsistency", "owner": "Adrian Mensah", "portfolio_key": "CBP-055-03", "recommended_action": "Create suite-phase rows with exact consent and permit holds. Owner: Adrian Mensah; due 2026-09-14.", "severity": "critical", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_leases/003_leases_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/02_amendments/015_amendments_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/04_title_survey/027_title_survey_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/05_environmental/039_environmental_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_property_management/097_eastgate_labs_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "the operative cap is $3,082,000.00 under CB-RE-2905-R108; the matched ledger population totals $3,333,208.00 under CB-RE-2905-E894. Identity resolves to ENT-055-1007, revision REV-2025.1 is current, and Maya Ellison is active with capacity 1.", "due_date": "2026-09-09", "id": "ACT-CBP-055-08", "identity_id": "ENT-055-1007", "issue": "permit closeout gap", "owner": "Maya Ellison", "portfolio_key": "CBP-055-08", "recommended_action": "Create suite-phase rows with exact consent and permit holds. Owner: Maya Ellison; due 2026-09-09.", "severity": "low", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_leases/008_leases_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/03_estoppels/020_estoppels_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/04_title_survey/032_title_survey_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/044_zoning_permits_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/12_property_management/092_property_management_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/07_operating_expenses/056_operating_expenses_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_property_management/097_eastgate_labs_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "an open exception blocks completion under CB-RE-2905-R886; the current status is open and unresolved under CB-RE-2905-E622. Identity resolves to ENT-055-1009, revision REV-2025.3 is current, and Willa Novak is active with capacity 4.", "due_date": "2026-09-16", "id": "ACT-CBP-055-10", "identity_id": "ENT-055-1009", "issue": "assignment consent", "owner": "Willa Novak", "portfolio_key": "CBP-055-10", "recommended_action": "Create suite-phase rows with exact consent and permit holds. Owner: Willa Novak; due 2026-09-16.", "severity": "critical", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_amendments/010_amendments_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/03_estoppels/022_estoppels_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/05_environmental/034_environmental_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/046_zoning_permits_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_property_management/097_eastgate_labs_impact_population.xlsx"]}], "as_of": "2026-09-17", "decision": {"alternatives_considered": ["eastgate-labs:shortcut", "eastgate-labs:blanket-hold"], "question": "Which Eastgate lease and permit gaps affect the wet-lab expansion decision?", "rationale": "The four-part causal test supports 5 scoped actions and leaves 7 records on evidence hold. Operative lease scope and current governmental approvals govern each expansion phase.", "recommendation": "Approve only phases with supported rights and permits; create scoped cures for the rest.", "selected_option_id": "eastgate-labs:scoped-evidence"}, "holds": [{"id": "HOLD-CBP-055-04", "issue": "survey encroachment", "portfolio_key": "CBP-055-04", "reason": "the current observation does not meet the operative trigger", "required_next_evidence": "a current observation that satisfies the operative trigger", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_leases/004_leases_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/02_amendments/016_amendments_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/04_title_survey/028_title_survey_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/05_environmental/040_environmental_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_property_management/097_eastgate_labs_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-055-05", "issue": "CAM reconciliation error", "portfolio_key": "CBP-055-05", "reason": "the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective", "required_next_evidence": "effective approval and an active owner with remaining capacity", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_leases/005_leases_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/03_estoppels/017_estoppels_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/04_title_survey/029_title_survey_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/041_zoning_permits_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/12_property_management/097_eastgate_labs_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-055-06", "issue": "security-deposit mismatch", "portfolio_key": "CBP-055-06", "reason": "the operational record relies on a superseded control revision", "required_next_evidence": "an operational record using the current effective revision", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_leases/006_leases_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/03_estoppels/018_estoppels_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/04_title_survey/030_title_survey_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/042_zoning_permits_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/12_property_management/097_eastgate_labs_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-055-07", "issue": "estoppel discrepancy", "portfolio_key": "CBP-055-07", "reason": "two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key", "required_next_evidence": "an approved immutable entity crosswalk", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_leases/007_leases_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/03_estoppels/019_estoppels_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/04_title_survey/031_title_survey_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/043_zoning_permits_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/10_construction/079_construction_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_property_management/097_eastgate_labs_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-055-09", "issue": "lender SNDA omission", "portfolio_key": "CBP-055-09", "reason": "the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective", "required_next_evidence": "effective approval and an active owner with remaining capacity", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_amendments/009_amendments_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/03_estoppels/021_estoppels_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/05_environmental/033_environmental_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/045_zoning_permits_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/09_notices/069_notices_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/11_financing/081_financing_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/12_property_management/097_eastgate_labs_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-055-11", "issue": "zoning nonconformity", "portfolio_key": "CBP-055-11", "reason": "two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key", "required_next_evidence": "an approved immutable entity crosswalk", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_amendments/011_amendments_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/03_estoppels/023_estoppels_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/05_environmental/035_environmental_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/047_zoning_permits_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_property_management/095_property_management_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/09_notices/071_notices_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_property_management/097_eastgate_labs_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-055-12", "issue": "construction lien notice", "portfolio_key": "CBP-055-12", "reason": "the current observation does not meet the operative trigger", "required_next_evidence": "a current observation that satisfies the operative trigger", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_amendments/012_amendments_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/03_estoppels/024_estoppels_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/05_environmental/036_environmental_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/048_zoning_permits_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_property_management/097_eastgate_labs_impact_population.xlsx"]}], "matter_number": "CB-RE-2905", "prepared_for": "Eastgate Life Sciences", "schema_version": "counselbench.decision.v3", "task_id": "cb100-055-eastgate-labs"}, "matter_register": {"matter_number": "CB-RE-2905", "rows": [{"decision_option_id": "eastgate-labs:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-16", "issue": "title exception", "matter_number": "CB-RE-2905", "owner": "Samuel Kim", "portfolio_key": "CBP-055-01", "row_id": "REG-CBP-055-01", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_leases/001_leases_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/02_amendments/013_amendments_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/04_title_survey/025_title_survey_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/05_environmental/037_environmental_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/07_operating_expenses/049_operating_expenses_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/12_property_management/097_eastgate_labs_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "eastgate-labs:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-15", "issue": "insurance endorsement deficiency", "matter_number": "CB-RE-2905", "owner": "Talia Brooks", "portfolio_key": "CBP-055-02", "row_id": "REG-CBP-055-02", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_leases/002_leases_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/02_amendments/014_amendments_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/04_title_survey/026_title_survey_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/05_environmental/038_environmental_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/07_operating_expenses/050_operating_expenses_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/10_construction/074_construction_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/12_property_management/097_eastgate_labs_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "eastgate-labs:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-14", "issue": "rent schedule inconsistency", "matter_number": "CB-RE-2905", "owner": "Adrian Mensah", "portfolio_key": "CBP-055-03", "row_id": "REG-CBP-055-03", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_leases/003_leases_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/02_amendments/015_amendments_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/04_title_survey/027_title_survey_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/05_environmental/039_environmental_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_property_management/097_eastgate_labs_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "eastgate-labs:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "the current observation does not meet the operative trigger", "issue": "survey encroachment", "matter_number": "CB-RE-2905", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-055-04", "row_id": "REG-CBP-055-04", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_leases/004_leases_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/02_amendments/016_amendments_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/04_title_survey/028_title_survey_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/05_environmental/040_environmental_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_property_management/097_eastgate_labs_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "eastgate-labs:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective", "issue": "CAM reconciliation error", "matter_number": "CB-RE-2905", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-055-05", "row_id": "REG-CBP-055-05", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_leases/005_leases_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/03_estoppels/017_estoppels_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/04_title_survey/029_title_survey_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/041_zoning_permits_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/12_property_management/097_eastgate_labs_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "eastgate-labs:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "the operational record relies on a superseded control revision", "issue": "security-deposit mismatch", "matter_number": "CB-RE-2905", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-055-06", "row_id": "REG-CBP-055-06", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_leases/006_leases_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/03_estoppels/018_estoppels_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/04_title_survey/030_title_survey_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/042_zoning_permits_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/12_property_management/097_eastgate_labs_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "eastgate-labs:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key", "issue": "estoppel discrepancy", "matter_number": "CB-RE-2905", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-055-07", "row_id": "REG-CBP-055-07", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_leases/007_leases_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/03_estoppels/019_estoppels_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/04_title_survey/031_title_survey_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/043_zoning_permits_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/10_construction/079_construction_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_property_management/097_eastgate_labs_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "eastgate-labs:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-09", "issue": "permit closeout gap", "matter_number": "CB-RE-2905", "owner": "Maya Ellison", "portfolio_key": "CBP-055-08", "row_id": "REG-CBP-055-08", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_leases/008_leases_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/03_estoppels/020_estoppels_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/04_title_survey/032_title_survey_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/044_zoning_permits_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/12_property_management/092_property_management_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/07_operating_expenses/056_operating_expenses_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_property_management/097_eastgate_labs_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "eastgate-labs:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective", "issue": "lender SNDA omission", "matter_number": "CB-RE-2905", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-055-09", "row_id": "REG-CBP-055-09", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_amendments/009_amendments_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/03_estoppels/021_estoppels_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/05_environmental/033_environmental_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/045_zoning_permits_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/09_notices/069_notices_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/11_financing/081_financing_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/12_property_management/097_eastgate_labs_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "eastgate-labs:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-16", "issue": "assignment consent", "matter_number": "CB-RE-2905", "owner": "Willa Novak", "portfolio_key": "CBP-055-10", "row_id": "REG-CBP-055-10", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_amendments/010_amendments_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/03_estoppels/022_estoppels_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/05_environmental/034_environmental_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/046_zoning_permits_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_property_management/097_eastgate_labs_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "eastgate-labs:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key", "issue": "zoning nonconformity", "matter_number": "CB-RE-2905", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-055-11", "row_id": "REG-CBP-055-11", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_amendments/011_amendments_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/03_estoppels/023_estoppels_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/05_environmental/035_environmental_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/047_zoning_permits_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_property_management/095_property_management_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/09_notices/071_notices_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_property_management/097_eastgate_labs_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "eastgate-labs:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "the current observation does not meet the operative trigger", "issue": "construction lien notice", "matter_number": "CB-RE-2905", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-055-12", "row_id": "REG-CBP-055-12", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_amendments/012_amendments_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/03_estoppels/024_estoppels_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/05_environmental/036_environmental_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/048_zoning_permits_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_property_management/097_eastgate_labs_impact_population.xlsx"]}], "schema_version": "counselbench.matter-register.v3", "task_id": "cb100-055-eastgate-labs"}}, "metadata": {"benchmark": "CounselBench-100", "code_license": "Apache-2.0", "data_license": "CC-BY-4.0", "deadline": "2026-09-17", "document_count": 97, "evidence_holds": 7, "jurisdiction": "North Carolina", "matter_number": "CB-RE-2905", "mcp_commit": "9a96ea6e5913736f92b88345bf51caeaaa8e719f", "mcp_package": "@modelcontextprotocol/server-filesystem@2026.7.10", "practice_area": "real-estate", "reference_tool_calls": 86, "required_evidence_reads": 60, "supported_actions": 5, "synthetic": true, "venue": "Wake County, North Carolina", "version": "3.1.0"}, "prompt": "We inherited inconsistent versions of this matter and need to settle the operating position. Which Eastgate lease and permit gaps affect the wet-lab expansion decision? Wet-lab leases, hazardous-material records, and expansion permits differ across amendments, estoppels, and property-manager files. The team needs the call by 2026-09-17. I need the recommendation and the real blockers recorded before the team acts.", "rubric": {"criteria": [{"category": "investigation", "description": "Inventory the production and use targeted searches to locate records across native formats.", "id": "investigation.discover_production"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Complete every task-specific identity, authority, operations, and approval read before the first state transition.", "id": "investigation.read_before_write"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Inspect designated source metadata before relying on those records.", "id": "investigation.custody_before_write"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "Select the supported option 'eastgate-labs:scoped-evidence' after applying the four-part test.", "id": "decision.selected_option"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "Identify both rejected approaches and explain why a one-source shortcut and a blanket hold are wrong.", "id": "decision.alternatives"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-055-01 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_leases/001_leases_source_export.md rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-055-01.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_amendments/013_amendments_source_export.json for title exception.", "id": "investigation.CBP-055-01.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_title_survey/025_title_survey_source_export.md to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-055-01.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_environmental/037_environmental_source_export.json.", "id": "investigation.CBP-055-01.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-055-01 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-055-01.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-055-01 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-055-01.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-055-02 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_leases/002_leases_source_export.txt rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-055-02.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_amendments/014_amendments_source_export.xml for insurance endorsement deficiency.", "id": "investigation.CBP-055-02.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_title_survey/026_title_survey_source_export.txt to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-055-02.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_environmental/038_environmental_source_export.xml.", "id": "investigation.CBP-055-02.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-055-02 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-055-02.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-055-02 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-055-02.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-055-03 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_leases/003_leases_source_export.eml rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-055-03.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_amendments/015_amendments_source_export.html for rent schedule inconsistency.", "id": "investigation.CBP-055-03.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_title_survey/027_title_survey_source_export.eml to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-055-03.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_environmental/039_environmental_source_export.html.", "id": "investigation.CBP-055-03.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-055-03 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-055-03.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-055-03 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-055-03.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-055-04 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_leases/004_leases_source_export.csv rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-055-04.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_amendments/016_amendments_source_export.pdf for survey encroachment.", "id": "investigation.CBP-055-04.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_title_survey/028_title_survey_source_export.csv to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-055-04.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_environmental/040_environmental_source_export.pdf.", "id": "investigation.CBP-055-04.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-055-04 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is the current observation does not meet the operative trigger.", "id": "decision.CBP-055-04.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-055-04 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-055-04.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-055-05 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_leases/005_leases_source_export.json rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-055-05.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_estoppels/017_estoppels_source_export.md for CAM reconciliation error.", "id": "investigation.CBP-055-05.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_title_survey/029_title_survey_source_export.json to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-055-05.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/041_zoning_permits_source_export.md.", "id": "investigation.CBP-055-05.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-055-05 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective.", "id": "decision.CBP-055-05.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-055-05 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-055-05.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-055-06 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_leases/006_leases_source_export.xml rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-055-06.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_estoppels/018_estoppels_source_export.txt for security-deposit mismatch.", "id": "investigation.CBP-055-06.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_title_survey/030_title_survey_source_export.xml to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-055-06.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/042_zoning_permits_source_export.txt.", "id": "investigation.CBP-055-06.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-055-06 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is the operational record relies on a superseded control revision.", "id": "decision.CBP-055-06.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-055-06 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-055-06.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-055-07 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_leases/007_leases_source_export.html rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-055-07.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_estoppels/019_estoppels_source_export.eml for estoppel discrepancy.", "id": "investigation.CBP-055-07.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_title_survey/031_title_survey_source_export.html to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-055-07.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/043_zoning_permits_source_export.eml.", "id": "investigation.CBP-055-07.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-055-07 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key.", "id": "decision.CBP-055-07.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-055-07 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-055-07.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-055-08 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_leases/008_leases_source_export.pdf rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-055-08.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_estoppels/020_estoppels_source_export.csv for permit closeout gap.", "id": "investigation.CBP-055-08.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_title_survey/032_title_survey_source_export.pdf to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-055-08.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/044_zoning_permits_source_export.csv.", "id": "investigation.CBP-055-08.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-055-08 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-055-08.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-055-08 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-055-08.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-055-09 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_amendments/009_amendments_source_export.md rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-055-09.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_estoppels/021_estoppels_source_export.json for lender SNDA omission.", "id": "investigation.CBP-055-09.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_environmental/033_environmental_source_export.md to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-055-09.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/045_zoning_permits_source_export.json.", "id": "investigation.CBP-055-09.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-055-09 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective.", "id": "decision.CBP-055-09.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-055-09 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-055-09.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-055-10 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_amendments/010_amendments_source_export.txt rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-055-10.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_estoppels/022_estoppels_source_export.xml for assignment consent.", "id": "investigation.CBP-055-10.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_environmental/034_environmental_source_export.txt to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-055-10.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/046_zoning_permits_source_export.xml.", "id": "investigation.CBP-055-10.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-055-10 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-055-10.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-055-10 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-055-10.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-055-11 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_amendments/011_amendments_source_export.eml rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-055-11.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_estoppels/023_estoppels_source_export.html for zoning nonconformity.", "id": "investigation.CBP-055-11.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_environmental/035_environmental_source_export.eml to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-055-11.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/047_zoning_permits_source_export.html.", "id": "investigation.CBP-055-11.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-055-11 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key.", "id": "decision.CBP-055-11.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-055-11 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-055-11.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-055-12 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_amendments/012_amendments_source_export.csv rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-055-12.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_estoppels/024_estoppels_source_export.pdf for construction lien notice.", "id": "investigation.CBP-055-12.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_environmental/036_environmental_source_export.csv to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-055-12.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/048_zoning_permits_source_export.pdf.", "id": "investigation.CBP-055-12.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-055-12 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is the current observation does not meet the operative trigger.", "id": "decision.CBP-055-12.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-055-12 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-055-12.register"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Write the exact selected option, supported action population, evidence-hold population, facts, owners, deadlines, and citations.", "id": "state.exact_decision"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create one exact register row per portfolio key with no extra, missing, or modified row.", "id": "state.exact_register"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Leave only the three approved deliverables and perform no extra state-changing write.", "id": "state.write_scope_containment"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Read back decision.json, matter-register.json, and advice.md after their final writes.", "id": "state.postwrite_readback"}, {"category": "answer", "description": "Explain the selected recommendation, supported actions, holds, alternatives, and limitations with exact source anchors.", "id": "answer.decision_note"}], "decision_options": [{"approach": "Apply the exact identity, current-state, authority, and revision test. Create suite-phase rows with exact consent and permit holds.", "id": "eastgate-labs:scoped-evidence", "label": "Approve only phases with supported rights and permits; create scoped cures for the rest."}, {"approach": "Use a plausible summary or one source without completing the controlling joins.", "id": "eastgate-labs:shortcut", "label": "Assume property-manager operations prove legal permission."}, {"approach": "Treat supported actions and genuinely ambiguous records as if they were equally unresolved.", "id": "eastgate-labs:blanket-hold", "label": "Freeze the entire matter population"}], "evaluation_narrative": {"authority": "Operative lease scope and current governmental approvals govern each expansion phase.", "observation": "Match premises, hazardous uses, amendments, estoppels, permits, and manager records by suite and phase.", "question": "Which Eastgate lease and permit gaps affect the wet-lab expansion decision?", "register_action": "Create suite-phase rows with exact consent and permit holds."}, "gates": ["all_required_evidence_precedes_first_write", "decision_criteria_complete", "register_state_exact", "write_scope_contained", "all_outputs_verified_by_readback"], "metadata_checks": 11, "metric": "weighted_criteria_score", "minimum_tool_calls": 86, "required_deliverables": ["decision.json", "matter-register.json", "advice.md"], "required_document_reads": 60, "type": "deterministic", "weights": {"advice": 0.15, "decision": 0.35, "investigation": 0.25, "state": 0.25}}, "task_id": "cb100-055-eastgate-labs", "task_name": "Eastgate laboratory campus diligence", "world_id": "counselbench-filesystem-mcp-v3"}
+{"context_files": ["task_files/cb100-056-fairhaven-storage/01_leases/001_leases_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-056-fairhaven-storage/01_leases/002_leases_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-056-fairhaven-storage/01_leases/003_leases_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-056-fairhaven-storage/01_leases/004_leases_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-056-fairhaven-storage/01_leases/005_leases_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-056-fairhaven-storage/01_leases/006_leases_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-056-fairhaven-storage/01_leases/007_leases_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-056-fairhaven-storage/01_leases/008_leases_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-056-fairhaven-storage/02_amendments/009_amendments_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-056-fairhaven-storage/02_amendments/010_amendments_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-056-fairhaven-storage/02_amendments/011_amendments_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-056-fairhaven-storage/02_amendments/012_amendments_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-056-fairhaven-storage/02_amendments/013_amendments_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-056-fairhaven-storage/02_amendments/014_amendments_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-056-fairhaven-storage/02_amendments/015_amendments_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-056-fairhaven-storage/02_amendments/016_amendments_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-056-fairhaven-storage/03_estoppels/017_estoppels_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-056-fairhaven-storage/03_estoppels/018_estoppels_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-056-fairhaven-storage/03_estoppels/019_estoppels_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-056-fairhaven-storage/03_estoppels/020_estoppels_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-056-fairhaven-storage/03_estoppels/021_estoppels_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-056-fairhaven-storage/03_estoppels/022_estoppels_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-056-fairhaven-storage/03_estoppels/023_estoppels_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-056-fairhaven-storage/03_estoppels/024_estoppels_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-056-fairhaven-storage/04_title_survey/025_title_survey_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-056-fairhaven-storage/04_title_survey/026_title_survey_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-056-fairhaven-storage/04_title_survey/027_title_survey_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-056-fairhaven-storage/04_title_survey/028_title_survey_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-056-fairhaven-storage/04_title_survey/029_title_survey_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-056-fairhaven-storage/04_title_survey/030_title_survey_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-056-fairhaven-storage/04_title_survey/031_title_survey_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-056-fairhaven-storage/04_title_survey/032_title_survey_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-056-fairhaven-storage/05_environmental/033_environmental_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-056-fairhaven-storage/05_environmental/034_environmental_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-056-fairhaven-storage/05_environmental/035_environmental_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-056-fairhaven-storage/05_environmental/036_environmental_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-056-fairhaven-storage/05_environmental/037_environmental_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-056-fairhaven-storage/05_environmental/038_environmental_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-056-fairhaven-storage/05_environmental/039_environmental_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-056-fairhaven-storage/05_environmental/040_environmental_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-056-fairhaven-storage/06_zoning_permits/041_zoning_permits_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-056-fairhaven-storage/06_zoning_permits/042_zoning_permits_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-056-fairhaven-storage/06_zoning_permits/043_zoning_permits_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-056-fairhaven-storage/06_zoning_permits/044_zoning_permits_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-056-fairhaven-storage/06_zoning_permits/045_zoning_permits_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-056-fairhaven-storage/06_zoning_permits/046_zoning_permits_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-056-fairhaven-storage/06_zoning_permits/047_zoning_permits_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-056-fairhaven-storage/06_zoning_permits/048_zoning_permits_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-056-fairhaven-storage/07_operating_expenses/049_operating_expenses_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-056-fairhaven-storage/07_operating_expenses/050_operating_expenses_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-056-fairhaven-storage/07_operating_expenses/051_operating_expenses_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-056-fairhaven-storage/07_operating_expenses/052_operating_expenses_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-056-fairhaven-storage/07_operating_expenses/053_operating_expenses_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-056-fairhaven-storage/07_operating_expenses/054_operating_expenses_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-056-fairhaven-storage/07_operating_expenses/055_operating_expenses_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-056-fairhaven-storage/07_operating_expenses/056_operating_expenses_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-056-fairhaven-storage/08_insurance/057_insurance_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-056-fairhaven-storage/08_insurance/058_insurance_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-056-fairhaven-storage/08_insurance/059_insurance_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-056-fairhaven-storage/08_insurance/060_insurance_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-056-fairhaven-storage/08_insurance/061_insurance_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-056-fairhaven-storage/08_insurance/062_insurance_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-056-fairhaven-storage/08_insurance/063_insurance_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-056-fairhaven-storage/08_insurance/064_insurance_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-056-fairhaven-storage/09_notices/065_notices_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-056-fairhaven-storage/09_notices/066_notices_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-056-fairhaven-storage/09_notices/067_notices_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-056-fairhaven-storage/09_notices/068_notices_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-056-fairhaven-storage/09_notices/069_notices_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-056-fairhaven-storage/09_notices/070_notices_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-056-fairhaven-storage/09_notices/071_notices_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-056-fairhaven-storage/09_notices/072_notices_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-056-fairhaven-storage/10_construction/073_construction_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-056-fairhaven-storage/10_construction/074_construction_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-056-fairhaven-storage/10_construction/075_construction_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-056-fairhaven-storage/10_construction/076_construction_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-056-fairhaven-storage/10_construction/077_construction_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-056-fairhaven-storage/10_construction/078_construction_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-056-fairhaven-storage/10_construction/079_construction_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-056-fairhaven-storage/10_construction/080_construction_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-056-fairhaven-storage/11_financing/081_financing_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-056-fairhaven-storage/11_financing/082_financing_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-056-fairhaven-storage/11_financing/083_financing_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-056-fairhaven-storage/11_financing/084_financing_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-056-fairhaven-storage/11_financing/085_financing_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-056-fairhaven-storage/11_financing/086_financing_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-056-fairhaven-storage/11_financing/087_financing_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-056-fairhaven-storage/11_financing/088_financing_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-056-fairhaven-storage/12_property_management/089_property_management_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-056-fairhaven-storage/12_property_management/090_property_management_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-056-fairhaven-storage/12_property_management/091_property_management_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-056-fairhaven-storage/12_property_management/092_property_management_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-056-fairhaven-storage/12_property_management/093_property_management_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-056-fairhaven-storage/12_property_management/094_property_management_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-056-fairhaven-storage/12_property_management/095_property_management_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-056-fairhaven-storage/12_property_management/096_property_management_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-056-fairhaven-storage/12_property_management/097_fairhaven_storage_impact_population.xlsx"], "gold_output": {"advice_markdown": "# Decision note — Fairhaven self-storage portfolio review\n\n## Recommendation\n\nApply property-specific value or liability corrections supported by matched records. The reconciled record supports 8 scoped actions and leaves 4 items on evidence hold.\n\nSelected option: `fairhaven-storage:scoped-evidence`.\n\n## Why this is the supported option\n\nReconcile title, rent rolls, deposits, and management charges by property, tenant, and period. Recorded title and executed management and lease terms control the adjustment.\n\n## Supported actions\n\n### CBP-056-01 — environmental recognized condition (critical)\n\nthe controlled population contains 129 records under CB-RE-2906-R987; the certification covers 94 records under CB-RE-2906-E893. Identity resolves to ENT-056-1000, revision REV-2026.1 is current, and Nora Chen is active with capacity 6.\n\nAction: Create property-tenant adjustment rows and hold unresolved crosswalks. Owner: Nora Chen; due 2026-09-20.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_leases/001_leases_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/02_amendments/013_amendments_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/04_title_survey/025_title_survey_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/05_environmental/037_environmental_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/11_financing/085_financing_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/07_operating_expenses/049_operating_expenses_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/12_property_management/097_fairhaven_storage_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-056-02 — casualty restoration deadline (high)\n\nthe permission is limited to Bexar County, Texas under CB-RE-2906-R729; the matched activity occurred in Texas under CB-RE-2906-E242. Identity resolves to ENT-056-1001, revision REV-2026.2 is current, and Caleb Hassan is active with capacity 2.\n\nAction: Create property-tenant adjustment rows and hold unresolved crosswalks. Owner: Caleb Hassan; due 2026-09-19.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_leases/002_leases_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/02_amendments/014_amendments_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/04_title_survey/026_title_survey_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/05_environmental/038_environmental_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/10_construction/074_construction_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/12_property_management/097_fairhaven_storage_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-056-04 — title exception (high)\n\ndelivery must use notices-fairhaven_storage_partners@example.test under CB-RE-2906-R439; the only matched receipt used archive-cobalt_door_management@example.test under CB-RE-2906-E119. Identity resolves to ENT-056-1003, revision REV-2026.4 is current, and Samuel Kim is active with capacity 6.\n\nAction: Create property-tenant adjustment rows and hold unresolved crosswalks. Owner: Samuel Kim; due 2026-09-17.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_leases/004_leases_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/02_amendments/016_amendments_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/04_title_survey/028_title_survey_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/05_environmental/040_environmental_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/11_financing/088_financing_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/12_property_management/097_fairhaven_storage_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-056-05 — insurance endorsement deficiency (high)\n\nan open exception blocks completion under CB-RE-2906-R549; the current status is open and unresolved under CB-RE-2906-E761. Identity resolves to ENT-056-1004, revision REV-2026.5 is current, and Talia Brooks is active with capacity 4.\n\nAction: Create property-tenant adjustment rows and hold unresolved crosswalks. Owner: Talia Brooks; due 2026-09-16.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_leases/005_leases_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/03_estoppels/017_estoppels_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/04_title_survey/029_title_survey_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/041_zoning_permits_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/09_notices/065_notices_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/12_property_management/097_fairhaven_storage_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-056-06 — rent schedule inconsistency (high)\n\ncompletion is required by 2026-01-04 under CB-RE-2906-R943; the current event record shows completion on 2026-01-22 under CB-RE-2906-E520. Identity resolves to ENT-056-1005, revision REV-2026.6 is current, and Adrian Mensah is active with capacity 3.\n\nAction: Create property-tenant adjustment rows and hold unresolved crosswalks. Owner: Adrian Mensah; due 2026-09-15.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_leases/006_leases_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/03_estoppels/018_estoppels_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/04_title_survey/030_title_survey_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/042_zoning_permits_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/12_property_management/097_fairhaven_storage_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-056-09 — security-deposit mismatch (low)\n\nthe controlled population contains 133 records under CB-RE-2906-R281; the certification covers 109 records under CB-RE-2906-E163. Identity resolves to ENT-056-1008, revision REV-2026.2 is current, and Leona Park is active with capacity 2.\n\nAction: Create property-tenant adjustment rows and hold unresolved crosswalks. Owner: Leona Park; due 2026-09-12.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/02_amendments/009_amendments_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/03_estoppels/021_estoppels_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/05_environmental/033_environmental_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/045_zoning_permits_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/09_notices/069_notices_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/12_property_management/097_fairhaven_storage_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-056-10 — estoppel discrepancy (high)\n\nthe permission is limited to Bexar County, Texas under CB-RE-2906-R615; the matched activity occurred in Texas under CB-RE-2906-E130. Identity resolves to ENT-056-1009, revision REV-2026.3 is current, and Henry Cho is active with capacity 6.\n\nAction: Create property-tenant adjustment rows and hold unresolved crosswalks. Owner: Henry Cho; due 2026-09-20.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/02_amendments/010_amendments_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/03_estoppels/022_estoppels_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/05_environmental/034_environmental_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/046_zoning_permits_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/11_financing/082_financing_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/12_property_management/097_fairhaven_storage_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-056-11 — permit closeout gap (low)\n\nthe operative cap is $6,682,000.00 under CB-RE-2906-R269; the matched ledger population totals $6,815,769.00 under CB-RE-2906-E321. Identity resolves to ENT-056-1010, revision REV-2026.4 is current, and Maya Ellison is active with capacity 5.\n\nAction: Create property-tenant adjustment rows and hold unresolved crosswalks. Owner: Maya Ellison; due 2026-09-19.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/02_amendments/011_amendments_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/03_estoppels/023_estoppels_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/05_environmental/035_environmental_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/047_zoning_permits_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/12_property_management/095_property_management_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/09_notices/071_notices_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/12_property_management/097_fairhaven_storage_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n## Evidence holds\n\n- **CBP-056-03 — renewal-option notice**: the current observation does not meet the operative trigger. Next evidence: a current observation that satisfies the operative trigger. Sources: `/workspace/documents/01_leases/003_leases_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/02_amendments/015_amendments_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/04_title_survey/027_title_survey_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/05_environmental/039_environmental_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/11_financing/087_financing_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/12_property_management/097_fairhaven_storage_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-056-07 — survey encroachment**: the current observation does not meet the operative trigger. Next evidence: a current observation that satisfies the operative trigger. Sources: `/workspace/documents/01_leases/007_leases_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/03_estoppels/019_estoppels_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/04_title_survey/031_title_survey_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/043_zoning_permits_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/12_property_management/097_fairhaven_storage_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-056-08 — CAM reconciliation error**: the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective. Next evidence: effective approval and an active owner with remaining capacity. Sources: `/workspace/documents/01_leases/008_leases_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/03_estoppels/020_estoppels_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/04_title_survey/032_title_survey_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/044_zoning_permits_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/09_notices/068_notices_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/10_construction/080_construction_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/12_property_management/097_fairhaven_storage_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-056-12 — lender SNDA omission**: the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective. Next evidence: effective approval and an active owner with remaining capacity. Sources: `/workspace/documents/02_amendments/012_amendments_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/03_estoppels/024_estoppels_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/05_environmental/036_environmental_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/048_zoning_permits_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/11_financing/084_financing_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/09_notices/072_notices_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/12_property_management/097_fairhaven_storage_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n## Alternatives considered\n\n- `fairhaven-storage:shortcut` — Net all discrepancies at portfolio level and ignore tenant identity conflicts.: Use a plausible summary or one source without completing the controlling joins.\n- `fairhaven-storage:blanket-hold` — Freeze the entire matter population: Treat supported actions and genuinely ambiguous records as if they were equally unresolved.\n\n## Assumptions and limits\n\nThis decision is limited to cb100-056-fairhaven-storage, the supplied synthetic records, and the matter state as of 2026-09-21. Similar names, stale revisions, and pending authority are not treated as proof.\n", "decision": {"actions": [{"determination": "the controlled population contains 129 records under CB-RE-2906-R987; the certification covers 94 records under CB-RE-2906-E893. Identity resolves to ENT-056-1000, revision REV-2026.1 is current, and Nora Chen is active with capacity 6.", "due_date": "2026-09-20", "id": "ACT-CBP-056-01", "identity_id": "ENT-056-1000", "issue": "environmental recognized condition", "owner": "Nora Chen", "portfolio_key": "CBP-056-01", "recommended_action": "Create property-tenant adjustment rows and hold unresolved crosswalks. Owner: Nora Chen; due 2026-09-20.", "severity": "critical", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_leases/001_leases_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/02_amendments/013_amendments_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/04_title_survey/025_title_survey_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/05_environmental/037_environmental_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/11_financing/085_financing_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/07_operating_expenses/049_operating_expenses_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/12_property_management/097_fairhaven_storage_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "the permission is limited to Bexar County, Texas under CB-RE-2906-R729; the matched activity occurred in Texas under CB-RE-2906-E242. Identity resolves to ENT-056-1001, revision REV-2026.2 is current, and Caleb Hassan is active with capacity 2.", "due_date": "2026-09-19", "id": "ACT-CBP-056-02", "identity_id": "ENT-056-1001", "issue": "casualty restoration deadline", "owner": "Caleb Hassan", "portfolio_key": "CBP-056-02", "recommended_action": "Create property-tenant adjustment rows and hold unresolved crosswalks. Owner: Caleb Hassan; due 2026-09-19.", "severity": "high", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_leases/002_leases_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/02_amendments/014_amendments_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/04_title_survey/026_title_survey_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/05_environmental/038_environmental_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/10_construction/074_construction_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/12_property_management/097_fairhaven_storage_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "delivery must use notices-fairhaven_storage_partners@example.test under CB-RE-2906-R439; the only matched receipt used archive-cobalt_door_management@example.test under CB-RE-2906-E119. Identity resolves to ENT-056-1003, revision REV-2026.4 is current, and Samuel Kim is active with capacity 6.", "due_date": "2026-09-17", "id": "ACT-CBP-056-04", "identity_id": "ENT-056-1003", "issue": "title exception", "owner": "Samuel Kim", "portfolio_key": "CBP-056-04", "recommended_action": "Create property-tenant adjustment rows and hold unresolved crosswalks. Owner: Samuel Kim; due 2026-09-17.", "severity": "high", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_leases/004_leases_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/02_amendments/016_amendments_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/04_title_survey/028_title_survey_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/05_environmental/040_environmental_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/11_financing/088_financing_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_property_management/097_fairhaven_storage_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "an open exception blocks completion under CB-RE-2906-R549; the current status is open and unresolved under CB-RE-2906-E761. Identity resolves to ENT-056-1004, revision REV-2026.5 is current, and Talia Brooks is active with capacity 4.", "due_date": "2026-09-16", "id": "ACT-CBP-056-05", "identity_id": "ENT-056-1004", "issue": "insurance endorsement deficiency", "owner": "Talia Brooks", "portfolio_key": "CBP-056-05", "recommended_action": "Create property-tenant adjustment rows and hold unresolved crosswalks. Owner: Talia Brooks; due 2026-09-16.", "severity": "high", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_leases/005_leases_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/03_estoppels/017_estoppels_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/04_title_survey/029_title_survey_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/041_zoning_permits_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/09_notices/065_notices_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/12_property_management/097_fairhaven_storage_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "completion is required by 2026-01-04 under CB-RE-2906-R943; the current event record shows completion on 2026-01-22 under CB-RE-2906-E520. Identity resolves to ENT-056-1005, revision REV-2026.6 is current, and Adrian Mensah is active with capacity 3.", "due_date": "2026-09-15", "id": "ACT-CBP-056-06", "identity_id": "ENT-056-1005", "issue": "rent schedule inconsistency", "owner": "Adrian Mensah", "portfolio_key": "CBP-056-06", "recommended_action": "Create property-tenant adjustment rows and hold unresolved crosswalks. Owner: Adrian Mensah; due 2026-09-15.", "severity": "high", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_leases/006_leases_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/03_estoppels/018_estoppels_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/04_title_survey/030_title_survey_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/042_zoning_permits_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/12_property_management/097_fairhaven_storage_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "the controlled population contains 133 records under CB-RE-2906-R281; the certification covers 109 records under CB-RE-2906-E163. Identity resolves to ENT-056-1008, revision REV-2026.2 is current, and Leona Park is active with capacity 2.", "due_date": "2026-09-12", "id": "ACT-CBP-056-09", "identity_id": "ENT-056-1008", "issue": "security-deposit mismatch", "owner": "Leona Park", "portfolio_key": "CBP-056-09", "recommended_action": "Create property-tenant adjustment rows and hold unresolved crosswalks. Owner: Leona Park; due 2026-09-12.", "severity": "low", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_amendments/009_amendments_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/03_estoppels/021_estoppels_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/05_environmental/033_environmental_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/045_zoning_permits_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/09_notices/069_notices_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_property_management/097_fairhaven_storage_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "the permission is limited to Bexar County, Texas under CB-RE-2906-R615; the matched activity occurred in Texas under CB-RE-2906-E130. Identity resolves to ENT-056-1009, revision REV-2026.3 is current, and Henry Cho is active with capacity 6.", "due_date": "2026-09-20", "id": "ACT-CBP-056-10", "identity_id": "ENT-056-1009", "issue": "estoppel discrepancy", "owner": "Henry Cho", "portfolio_key": "CBP-056-10", "recommended_action": "Create property-tenant adjustment rows and hold unresolved crosswalks. Owner: Henry Cho; due 2026-09-20.", "severity": "high", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_amendments/010_amendments_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/03_estoppels/022_estoppels_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/05_environmental/034_environmental_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/046_zoning_permits_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/11_financing/082_financing_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/12_property_management/097_fairhaven_storage_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "the operative cap is $6,682,000.00 under CB-RE-2906-R269; the matched ledger population totals $6,815,769.00 under CB-RE-2906-E321. Identity resolves to ENT-056-1010, revision REV-2026.4 is current, and Maya Ellison is active with capacity 5.", "due_date": "2026-09-19", "id": "ACT-CBP-056-11", "identity_id": "ENT-056-1010", "issue": "permit closeout gap", "owner": "Maya Ellison", "portfolio_key": "CBP-056-11", "recommended_action": "Create property-tenant adjustment rows and hold unresolved crosswalks. Owner: Maya Ellison; due 2026-09-19.", "severity": "low", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_amendments/011_amendments_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/03_estoppels/023_estoppels_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/05_environmental/035_environmental_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/047_zoning_permits_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_property_management/095_property_management_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/09_notices/071_notices_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_property_management/097_fairhaven_storage_impact_population.xlsx"]}], "as_of": "2026-09-21", "decision": {"alternatives_considered": ["fairhaven-storage:shortcut", "fairhaven-storage:blanket-hold"], "question": "What is the supported value and liability adjustment across the Fairhaven portfolio?", "rationale": "The four-part causal test supports 8 scoped actions and leaves 4 records on evidence hold. Recorded title and executed management and lease terms control the adjustment.", "recommendation": "Apply property-specific value or liability corrections supported by matched records.", "selected_option_id": "fairhaven-storage:scoped-evidence"}, "holds": [{"id": "HOLD-CBP-056-03", "issue": "renewal-option notice", "portfolio_key": "CBP-056-03", "reason": "the current observation does not meet the operative trigger", "required_next_evidence": "a current observation that satisfies the operative trigger", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_leases/003_leases_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/02_amendments/015_amendments_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/04_title_survey/027_title_survey_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/05_environmental/039_environmental_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/11_financing/087_financing_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_property_management/097_fairhaven_storage_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-056-07", "issue": "survey encroachment", "portfolio_key": "CBP-056-07", "reason": "the current observation does not meet the operative trigger", "required_next_evidence": "a current observation that satisfies the operative trigger", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_leases/007_leases_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/03_estoppels/019_estoppels_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/04_title_survey/031_title_survey_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/043_zoning_permits_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/12_property_management/097_fairhaven_storage_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-056-08", "issue": "CAM reconciliation error", "portfolio_key": "CBP-056-08", "reason": "the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective", "required_next_evidence": "effective approval and an active owner with remaining capacity", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_leases/008_leases_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/03_estoppels/020_estoppels_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/04_title_survey/032_title_survey_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/044_zoning_permits_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/09_notices/068_notices_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/10_construction/080_construction_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_property_management/097_fairhaven_storage_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-056-12", "issue": "lender SNDA omission", "portfolio_key": "CBP-056-12", "reason": "the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective", "required_next_evidence": "effective approval and an active owner with remaining capacity", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_amendments/012_amendments_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/03_estoppels/024_estoppels_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/05_environmental/036_environmental_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/048_zoning_permits_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/11_financing/084_financing_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/09_notices/072_notices_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_property_management/097_fairhaven_storage_impact_population.xlsx"]}], "matter_number": "CB-RE-2906", "prepared_for": "Fairhaven Storage Partners", "schema_version": "counselbench.decision.v3", "task_id": "cb100-056-fairhaven-storage"}, "matter_register": {"matter_number": "CB-RE-2906", "rows": [{"decision_option_id": "fairhaven-storage:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-20", "issue": "environmental recognized condition", "matter_number": "CB-RE-2906", "owner": "Nora Chen", "portfolio_key": "CBP-056-01", "row_id": "REG-CBP-056-01", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_leases/001_leases_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/02_amendments/013_amendments_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/04_title_survey/025_title_survey_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/05_environmental/037_environmental_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/11_financing/085_financing_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/07_operating_expenses/049_operating_expenses_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/12_property_management/097_fairhaven_storage_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "fairhaven-storage:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-19", "issue": "casualty restoration deadline", "matter_number": "CB-RE-2906", "owner": "Caleb Hassan", "portfolio_key": "CBP-056-02", "row_id": "REG-CBP-056-02", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_leases/002_leases_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/02_amendments/014_amendments_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/04_title_survey/026_title_survey_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/05_environmental/038_environmental_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/10_construction/074_construction_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/12_property_management/097_fairhaven_storage_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "fairhaven-storage:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "the current observation does not meet the operative trigger", "issue": "renewal-option notice", "matter_number": "CB-RE-2906", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-056-03", "row_id": "REG-CBP-056-03", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_leases/003_leases_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/02_amendments/015_amendments_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/04_title_survey/027_title_survey_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/05_environmental/039_environmental_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/11_financing/087_financing_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_property_management/097_fairhaven_storage_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "fairhaven-storage:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-17", "issue": "title exception", "matter_number": "CB-RE-2906", "owner": "Samuel Kim", "portfolio_key": "CBP-056-04", "row_id": "REG-CBP-056-04", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_leases/004_leases_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/02_amendments/016_amendments_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/04_title_survey/028_title_survey_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/05_environmental/040_environmental_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/11_financing/088_financing_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_property_management/097_fairhaven_storage_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "fairhaven-storage:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-16", "issue": "insurance endorsement deficiency", "matter_number": "CB-RE-2906", "owner": "Talia Brooks", "portfolio_key": "CBP-056-05", "row_id": "REG-CBP-056-05", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_leases/005_leases_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/03_estoppels/017_estoppels_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/04_title_survey/029_title_survey_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/041_zoning_permits_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/09_notices/065_notices_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/12_property_management/097_fairhaven_storage_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "fairhaven-storage:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-15", "issue": "rent schedule inconsistency", "matter_number": "CB-RE-2906", "owner": "Adrian Mensah", "portfolio_key": "CBP-056-06", "row_id": "REG-CBP-056-06", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_leases/006_leases_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/03_estoppels/018_estoppels_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/04_title_survey/030_title_survey_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/042_zoning_permits_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/12_property_management/097_fairhaven_storage_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "fairhaven-storage:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "the current observation does not meet the operative trigger", "issue": "survey encroachment", "matter_number": "CB-RE-2906", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-056-07", "row_id": "REG-CBP-056-07", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_leases/007_leases_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/03_estoppels/019_estoppels_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/04_title_survey/031_title_survey_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/043_zoning_permits_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/12_property_management/097_fairhaven_storage_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "fairhaven-storage:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective", "issue": "CAM reconciliation error", "matter_number": "CB-RE-2906", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-056-08", "row_id": "REG-CBP-056-08", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_leases/008_leases_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/03_estoppels/020_estoppels_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/04_title_survey/032_title_survey_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/044_zoning_permits_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/09_notices/068_notices_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/10_construction/080_construction_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_property_management/097_fairhaven_storage_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "fairhaven-storage:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-12", "issue": "security-deposit mismatch", "matter_number": "CB-RE-2906", "owner": "Leona Park", "portfolio_key": "CBP-056-09", "row_id": "REG-CBP-056-09", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_amendments/009_amendments_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/03_estoppels/021_estoppels_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/05_environmental/033_environmental_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/045_zoning_permits_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/09_notices/069_notices_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_property_management/097_fairhaven_storage_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "fairhaven-storage:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-20", "issue": "estoppel discrepancy", "matter_number": "CB-RE-2906", "owner": "Henry Cho", "portfolio_key": "CBP-056-10", "row_id": "REG-CBP-056-10", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_amendments/010_amendments_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/03_estoppels/022_estoppels_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/05_environmental/034_environmental_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/046_zoning_permits_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/11_financing/082_financing_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/12_property_management/097_fairhaven_storage_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "fairhaven-storage:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-19", "issue": "permit closeout gap", "matter_number": "CB-RE-2906", "owner": "Maya Ellison", "portfolio_key": "CBP-056-11", "row_id": "REG-CBP-056-11", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_amendments/011_amendments_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/03_estoppels/023_estoppels_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/05_environmental/035_environmental_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/047_zoning_permits_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_property_management/095_property_management_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/09_notices/071_notices_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_property_management/097_fairhaven_storage_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "fairhaven-storage:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective", "issue": "lender SNDA omission", "matter_number": "CB-RE-2906", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-056-12", "row_id": "REG-CBP-056-12", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_amendments/012_amendments_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/03_estoppels/024_estoppels_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/05_environmental/036_environmental_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/048_zoning_permits_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/11_financing/084_financing_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/09_notices/072_notices_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_property_management/097_fairhaven_storage_impact_population.xlsx"]}], "schema_version": "counselbench.matter-register.v3", "task_id": "cb100-056-fairhaven-storage"}}, "metadata": {"benchmark": "CounselBench-100", "code_license": "Apache-2.0", "data_license": "CC-BY-4.0", "deadline": "2026-09-21", "document_count": 97, "evidence_holds": 4, "jurisdiction": "Texas", "matter_number": "CB-RE-2906", "mcp_commit": "9a96ea6e5913736f92b88345bf51caeaaa8e719f", "mcp_package": "@modelcontextprotocol/server-filesystem@2026.7.10", "practice_area": "real-estate", "reference_tool_calls": 85, "required_evidence_reads": 64, "supported_actions": 8, "synthetic": true, "venue": "Bexar County, Texas", "version": "3.1.0"}, "prompt": "I am about to brief the decision makers and need the source record reconciled first. What is the supported value and liability adjustment across the Fairhaven portfolio? A storage portfolio has title exceptions, rent-roll discrepancies, security deposits, and management charges inconsistent with governing documents. The team needs the call by 2026-09-21. Record the outcome the source hierarchy supports and explain the alternatives we should not take.", "rubric": {"criteria": [{"category": "investigation", "description": "Inventory the production and use targeted searches to locate records across native formats.", "id": "investigation.discover_production"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Complete every task-specific identity, authority, operations, and approval read before the first state transition.", "id": "investigation.read_before_write"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Inspect designated source metadata before relying on those records.", "id": "investigation.custody_before_write"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "Select the supported option 'fairhaven-storage:scoped-evidence' after applying the four-part test.", "id": "decision.selected_option"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "Identify both rejected approaches and explain why a one-source shortcut and a blanket hold are wrong.", "id": "decision.alternatives"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-056-01 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_leases/001_leases_source_export.md rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-056-01.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_amendments/013_amendments_source_export.json for environmental recognized condition.", "id": "investigation.CBP-056-01.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_title_survey/025_title_survey_source_export.md to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-056-01.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_environmental/037_environmental_source_export.json.", "id": "investigation.CBP-056-01.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-056-01 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-056-01.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-056-01 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-056-01.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-056-02 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_leases/002_leases_source_export.txt rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-056-02.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_amendments/014_amendments_source_export.xml for casualty restoration deadline.", "id": "investigation.CBP-056-02.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_title_survey/026_title_survey_source_export.txt to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-056-02.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_environmental/038_environmental_source_export.xml.", "id": "investigation.CBP-056-02.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-056-02 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-056-02.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-056-02 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-056-02.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-056-03 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_leases/003_leases_source_export.eml rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-056-03.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_amendments/015_amendments_source_export.html for renewal-option notice.", "id": "investigation.CBP-056-03.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_title_survey/027_title_survey_source_export.eml to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-056-03.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_environmental/039_environmental_source_export.html.", "id": "investigation.CBP-056-03.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-056-03 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is the current observation does not meet the operative trigger.", "id": "decision.CBP-056-03.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-056-03 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-056-03.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-056-04 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_leases/004_leases_source_export.csv rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-056-04.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_amendments/016_amendments_source_export.pdf for title exception.", "id": "investigation.CBP-056-04.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_title_survey/028_title_survey_source_export.csv to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-056-04.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_environmental/040_environmental_source_export.pdf.", "id": "investigation.CBP-056-04.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-056-04 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-056-04.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-056-04 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-056-04.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-056-05 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_leases/005_leases_source_export.json rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-056-05.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_estoppels/017_estoppels_source_export.md for insurance endorsement deficiency.", "id": "investigation.CBP-056-05.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_title_survey/029_title_survey_source_export.json to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-056-05.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/041_zoning_permits_source_export.md.", "id": "investigation.CBP-056-05.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-056-05 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-056-05.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-056-05 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-056-05.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-056-06 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_leases/006_leases_source_export.xml rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-056-06.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_estoppels/018_estoppels_source_export.txt for rent schedule inconsistency.", "id": "investigation.CBP-056-06.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_title_survey/030_title_survey_source_export.xml to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-056-06.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/042_zoning_permits_source_export.txt.", "id": "investigation.CBP-056-06.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-056-06 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-056-06.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-056-06 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-056-06.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-056-07 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_leases/007_leases_source_export.html rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-056-07.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_estoppels/019_estoppels_source_export.eml for survey encroachment.", "id": "investigation.CBP-056-07.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_title_survey/031_title_survey_source_export.html to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-056-07.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/043_zoning_permits_source_export.eml.", "id": "investigation.CBP-056-07.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-056-07 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is the current observation does not meet the operative trigger.", "id": "decision.CBP-056-07.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-056-07 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-056-07.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-056-08 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_leases/008_leases_source_export.pdf rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-056-08.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_estoppels/020_estoppels_source_export.csv for CAM reconciliation error.", "id": "investigation.CBP-056-08.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_title_survey/032_title_survey_source_export.pdf to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-056-08.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/044_zoning_permits_source_export.csv.", "id": "investigation.CBP-056-08.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-056-08 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective.", "id": "decision.CBP-056-08.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-056-08 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-056-08.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-056-09 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_amendments/009_amendments_source_export.md rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-056-09.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_estoppels/021_estoppels_source_export.json for security-deposit mismatch.", "id": "investigation.CBP-056-09.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_environmental/033_environmental_source_export.md to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-056-09.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/045_zoning_permits_source_export.json.", "id": "investigation.CBP-056-09.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-056-09 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-056-09.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-056-09 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-056-09.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-056-10 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_amendments/010_amendments_source_export.txt rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-056-10.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_estoppels/022_estoppels_source_export.xml for estoppel discrepancy.", "id": "investigation.CBP-056-10.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_environmental/034_environmental_source_export.txt to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-056-10.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/046_zoning_permits_source_export.xml.", "id": "investigation.CBP-056-10.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-056-10 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-056-10.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-056-10 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-056-10.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-056-11 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_amendments/011_amendments_source_export.eml rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-056-11.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_estoppels/023_estoppels_source_export.html for permit closeout gap.", "id": "investigation.CBP-056-11.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_environmental/035_environmental_source_export.eml to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-056-11.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/047_zoning_permits_source_export.html.", "id": "investigation.CBP-056-11.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-056-11 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-056-11.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-056-11 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-056-11.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-056-12 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_amendments/012_amendments_source_export.csv rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-056-12.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_estoppels/024_estoppels_source_export.pdf for lender SNDA omission.", "id": "investigation.CBP-056-12.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_environmental/036_environmental_source_export.csv to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-056-12.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/048_zoning_permits_source_export.pdf.", "id": "investigation.CBP-056-12.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-056-12 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective.", "id": "decision.CBP-056-12.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-056-12 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-056-12.register"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Write the exact selected option, supported action population, evidence-hold population, facts, owners, deadlines, and citations.", "id": "state.exact_decision"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create one exact register row per portfolio key with no extra, missing, or modified row.", "id": "state.exact_register"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Leave only the three approved deliverables and perform no extra state-changing write.", "id": "state.write_scope_containment"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Read back decision.json, matter-register.json, and advice.md after their final writes.", "id": "state.postwrite_readback"}, {"category": "answer", "description": "Explain the selected recommendation, supported actions, holds, alternatives, and limitations with exact source anchors.", "id": "answer.decision_note"}], "decision_options": [{"approach": "Use a plausible summary or one source without completing the controlling joins.", "id": "fairhaven-storage:shortcut", "label": "Net all discrepancies at portfolio level and ignore tenant identity conflicts."}, {"approach": "Treat supported actions and genuinely ambiguous records as if they were equally unresolved.", "id": "fairhaven-storage:blanket-hold", "label": "Freeze the entire matter population"}, {"approach": "Apply the exact identity, current-state, authority, and revision test. Create property-tenant adjustment rows and hold unresolved crosswalks.", "id": "fairhaven-storage:scoped-evidence", "label": "Apply property-specific value or liability corrections supported by matched records."}], "evaluation_narrative": {"authority": "Recorded title and executed management and lease terms control the adjustment.", "observation": "Reconcile title, rent rolls, deposits, and management charges by property, tenant, and period.", "question": "What is the supported value and liability adjustment across the Fairhaven portfolio?", "register_action": "Create property-tenant adjustment rows and hold unresolved crosswalks."}, "gates": ["all_required_evidence_precedes_first_write", "decision_criteria_complete", "register_state_exact", "write_scope_contained", "all_outputs_verified_by_readback"], "metadata_checks": 7, "metric": "weighted_criteria_score", "minimum_tool_calls": 85, "required_deliverables": ["decision.json", "matter-register.json", "advice.md"], "required_document_reads": 64, "type": "deterministic", "weights": {"advice": 0.15, "decision": 0.35, "investigation": 0.25, "state": 0.25}}, "task_id": "cb100-056-fairhaven-storage", "task_name": "Fairhaven self-storage portfolio review", "world_id": "counselbench-filesystem-mcp-v3"}
+{"context_files": ["task_files/cb100-057-glenridge-school/01_leases/001_leases_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-057-glenridge-school/01_leases/002_leases_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-057-glenridge-school/01_leases/003_leases_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-057-glenridge-school/01_leases/004_leases_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-057-glenridge-school/01_leases/005_leases_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-057-glenridge-school/01_leases/006_leases_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-057-glenridge-school/01_leases/007_leases_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-057-glenridge-school/01_leases/008_leases_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-057-glenridge-school/02_amendments/009_amendments_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-057-glenridge-school/02_amendments/010_amendments_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-057-glenridge-school/02_amendments/011_amendments_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-057-glenridge-school/02_amendments/012_amendments_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-057-glenridge-school/02_amendments/013_amendments_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-057-glenridge-school/02_amendments/014_amendments_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-057-glenridge-school/02_amendments/015_amendments_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-057-glenridge-school/02_amendments/016_amendments_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-057-glenridge-school/03_estoppels/017_estoppels_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-057-glenridge-school/03_estoppels/018_estoppels_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-057-glenridge-school/03_estoppels/019_estoppels_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-057-glenridge-school/03_estoppels/020_estoppels_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-057-glenridge-school/03_estoppels/021_estoppels_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-057-glenridge-school/03_estoppels/022_estoppels_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-057-glenridge-school/03_estoppels/023_estoppels_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-057-glenridge-school/03_estoppels/024_estoppels_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-057-glenridge-school/04_title_survey/025_title_survey_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-057-glenridge-school/04_title_survey/026_title_survey_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-057-glenridge-school/04_title_survey/027_title_survey_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-057-glenridge-school/04_title_survey/028_title_survey_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-057-glenridge-school/04_title_survey/029_title_survey_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-057-glenridge-school/04_title_survey/030_title_survey_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-057-glenridge-school/04_title_survey/031_title_survey_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-057-glenridge-school/04_title_survey/032_title_survey_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-057-glenridge-school/05_environmental/033_environmental_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-057-glenridge-school/05_environmental/034_environmental_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-057-glenridge-school/05_environmental/035_environmental_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-057-glenridge-school/05_environmental/036_environmental_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-057-glenridge-school/05_environmental/037_environmental_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-057-glenridge-school/05_environmental/038_environmental_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-057-glenridge-school/05_environmental/039_environmental_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-057-glenridge-school/05_environmental/040_environmental_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-057-glenridge-school/06_zoning_permits/041_zoning_permits_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-057-glenridge-school/06_zoning_permits/042_zoning_permits_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-057-glenridge-school/06_zoning_permits/043_zoning_permits_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-057-glenridge-school/06_zoning_permits/044_zoning_permits_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-057-glenridge-school/06_zoning_permits/045_zoning_permits_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-057-glenridge-school/06_zoning_permits/046_zoning_permits_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-057-glenridge-school/06_zoning_permits/047_zoning_permits_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-057-glenridge-school/06_zoning_permits/048_zoning_permits_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-057-glenridge-school/07_operating_expenses/049_operating_expenses_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-057-glenridge-school/07_operating_expenses/050_operating_expenses_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-057-glenridge-school/07_operating_expenses/051_operating_expenses_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-057-glenridge-school/07_operating_expenses/052_operating_expenses_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-057-glenridge-school/07_operating_expenses/053_operating_expenses_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-057-glenridge-school/07_operating_expenses/054_operating_expenses_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-057-glenridge-school/07_operating_expenses/055_operating_expenses_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-057-glenridge-school/07_operating_expenses/056_operating_expenses_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-057-glenridge-school/08_insurance/057_insurance_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-057-glenridge-school/08_insurance/058_insurance_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-057-glenridge-school/08_insurance/059_insurance_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-057-glenridge-school/08_insurance/060_insurance_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-057-glenridge-school/08_insurance/061_insurance_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-057-glenridge-school/08_insurance/062_insurance_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-057-glenridge-school/08_insurance/063_insurance_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-057-glenridge-school/08_insurance/064_insurance_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-057-glenridge-school/09_notices/065_notices_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-057-glenridge-school/09_notices/066_notices_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-057-glenridge-school/09_notices/067_notices_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-057-glenridge-school/09_notices/068_notices_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-057-glenridge-school/09_notices/069_notices_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-057-glenridge-school/09_notices/070_notices_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-057-glenridge-school/09_notices/071_notices_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-057-glenridge-school/09_notices/072_notices_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-057-glenridge-school/10_construction/073_construction_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-057-glenridge-school/10_construction/074_construction_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-057-glenridge-school/10_construction/075_construction_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-057-glenridge-school/10_construction/076_construction_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-057-glenridge-school/10_construction/077_construction_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-057-glenridge-school/10_construction/078_construction_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-057-glenridge-school/10_construction/079_construction_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-057-glenridge-school/10_construction/080_construction_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-057-glenridge-school/11_financing/081_financing_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-057-glenridge-school/11_financing/082_financing_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-057-glenridge-school/11_financing/083_financing_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-057-glenridge-school/11_financing/084_financing_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-057-glenridge-school/11_financing/085_financing_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-057-glenridge-school/11_financing/086_financing_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-057-glenridge-school/11_financing/087_financing_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-057-glenridge-school/11_financing/088_financing_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-057-glenridge-school/12_property_management/089_property_management_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-057-glenridge-school/12_property_management/090_property_management_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-057-glenridge-school/12_property_management/091_property_management_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-057-glenridge-school/12_property_management/092_property_management_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-057-glenridge-school/12_property_management/093_property_management_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-057-glenridge-school/12_property_management/094_property_management_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-057-glenridge-school/12_property_management/095_property_management_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-057-glenridge-school/12_property_management/096_property_management_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-057-glenridge-school/12_property_management/097_glenridge_school_impact_population.xlsx"], "gold_output": {"advice_markdown": "# Decision note — Glenridge charter campus lease review\n\n## Recommendation\n\nProceed with supported conditions and cure only the proven gaps. The reconciled record supports 6 scoped actions and leaves 6 items on evidence hold.\n\nSelected option: `glenridge-school:scoped-evidence`.\n\n## Why this is the supported option\n\nJoin lease options, notice delivery, use approvals, accessibility work, and lender files. Renewal and financing depend on timely notice, permitted use, completed obligations, and lender recognition.\n\n## Supported actions\n\n### CBP-057-01 — zoning nonconformity (high)\n\ncompletion is required by 2025-05-18 under CB-RE-2907-R292; the current event record shows completion on 2025-06-14 under CB-RE-2907-E587. Identity resolves to ENT-057-1000, revision REV-2025.1 is current, and Elliot Mercer is active with capacity 3.\n\nAction: Create lease-control rows tied to exact notice, work, and lender evidence. Owner: Elliot Mercer; due 2026-09-23.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_leases/001_leases_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/02_amendments/013_amendments_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/04_title_survey/025_title_survey_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/05_environmental/037_environmental_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/11_financing/085_financing_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/07_operating_expenses/049_operating_expenses_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/12_property_management/097_glenridge_school_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-057-02 — construction lien notice (high)\n\nthe controlling threshold is 14% under CB-RE-2907-R775; the independently calculated result is 20% under CB-RE-2907-E139. Identity resolves to ENT-057-1001, revision REV-2025.2 is current, and Sofia Bennett is active with capacity 3.\n\nAction: Create lease-control rows tied to exact notice, work, and lender evidence. Owner: Sofia Bennett; due 2026-09-22.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_leases/002_leases_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/02_amendments/014_amendments_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/04_title_survey/026_title_survey_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/05_environmental/038_environmental_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/11_financing/086_financing_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/07_operating_expenses/050_operating_expenses_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/12_property_management/097_glenridge_school_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-057-03 — exclusive-use conflict (high)\n\napproval must come from Willa Novak under CB-RE-2907-R622; the effective approval record names Rafael Okafor under CB-RE-2907-E501. Identity resolves to ENT-057-1002, revision REV-2025.3 is current, and Micah Sullivan is active with capacity 5.\n\nAction: Create lease-control rows tied to exact notice, work, and lender evidence. Owner: Micah Sullivan; due 2026-09-21.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_leases/003_leases_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/02_amendments/015_amendments_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/04_title_survey/027_title_survey_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/05_environmental/039_environmental_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/11_financing/087_financing_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/08_insurance/063_insurance_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/12_property_management/097_glenridge_school_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-057-05 — casualty restoration deadline (high)\n\nthe permission is limited to Arapahoe County, Colorado under CB-RE-2907-R749; the matched activity occurred in Colorado under CB-RE-2907-E138. Identity resolves to ENT-057-1004, revision REV-2025.5 is current, and Caleb Hassan is active with capacity 1.\n\nAction: Create lease-control rows tied to exact notice, work, and lender evidence. Owner: Caleb Hassan; due 2026-09-19.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_leases/005_leases_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/03_estoppels/017_estoppels_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/04_title_survey/029_title_survey_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/041_zoning_permits_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/12_property_management/097_glenridge_school_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-057-07 — title exception (high)\n\ndelivery must use notices-glenridge_education_network@example.test under CB-RE-2907-R898; the only matched receipt used archive-cedar_hall_development@example.test under CB-RE-2907-E252. Identity resolves to ENT-057-1006, revision REV-2025.7 is current, and Samuel Kim is active with capacity 2.\n\nAction: Create lease-control rows tied to exact notice, work, and lender evidence. Owner: Samuel Kim; due 2026-09-17.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_leases/007_leases_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/03_estoppels/019_estoppels_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/04_title_survey/031_title_survey_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/043_zoning_permits_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/12_property_management/097_glenridge_school_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-057-12 — security-deposit mismatch (high)\n\nthe controlled population contains 101 records under CB-RE-2907-R789; the certification covers 70 records under CB-RE-2907-E881. Identity resolves to ENT-057-1011, revision REV-2025.5 is current, and Leona Park is active with capacity 4.\n\nAction: Create lease-control rows tied to exact notice, work, and lender evidence. Owner: Leona Park; due 2026-09-21.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/02_amendments/012_amendments_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/03_estoppels/024_estoppels_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/05_environmental/036_environmental_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/048_zoning_permits_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/11_financing/084_financing_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/12_property_management/097_glenridge_school_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n## Evidence holds\n\n- **CBP-057-04 — environmental recognized condition**: the operational record relies on a superseded control revision. Next evidence: an operational record using the current effective revision. Sources: `/workspace/documents/01_leases/004_leases_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/02_amendments/016_amendments_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/04_title_survey/028_title_survey_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/05_environmental/040_environmental_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/12_property_management/097_glenridge_school_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-057-06 — renewal-option notice**: the current observation does not meet the operative trigger. Next evidence: a current observation that satisfies the operative trigger. Sources: `/workspace/documents/01_leases/006_leases_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/03_estoppels/018_estoppels_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/04_title_survey/030_title_survey_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/042_zoning_permits_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/09_notices/066_notices_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/12_property_management/097_glenridge_school_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-057-08 — insurance endorsement deficiency**: the operational record relies on a superseded control revision. Next evidence: an operational record using the current effective revision. Sources: `/workspace/documents/01_leases/008_leases_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/03_estoppels/020_estoppels_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/04_title_survey/032_title_survey_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/044_zoning_permits_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/07_operating_expenses/056_operating_expenses_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/12_property_management/097_glenridge_school_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-057-09 — rent schedule inconsistency**: two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key. Next evidence: an approved immutable entity crosswalk. Sources: `/workspace/documents/02_amendments/009_amendments_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/03_estoppels/021_estoppels_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/05_environmental/033_environmental_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/045_zoning_permits_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/12_property_management/097_glenridge_school_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-057-10 — survey encroachment**: the current observation does not meet the operative trigger. Next evidence: a current observation that satisfies the operative trigger. Sources: `/workspace/documents/02_amendments/010_amendments_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/03_estoppels/022_estoppels_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/05_environmental/034_environmental_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/046_zoning_permits_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/12_property_management/097_glenridge_school_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-057-11 — CAM reconciliation error**: the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective. Next evidence: effective approval and an active owner with remaining capacity. Sources: `/workspace/documents/02_amendments/011_amendments_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/03_estoppels/023_estoppels_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/05_environmental/035_environmental_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/047_zoning_permits_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/12_property_management/097_glenridge_school_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n## Alternatives considered\n\n- `glenridge-school:blanket-hold` — Freeze the entire matter population: Treat supported actions and genuinely ambiguous records as if they were equally unresolved.\n- `glenridge-school:shortcut` — Assume continued occupancy preserved every option and lender protection.: Use a plausible summary or one source without completing the controlling joins.\n\n## Assumptions and limits\n\nThis decision is limited to cb100-057-glenridge-school, the supplied synthetic records, and the matter state as of 2026-09-24. Similar names, stale revisions, and pending authority are not treated as proof.\n", "decision": {"actions": [{"determination": "completion is required by 2025-05-18 under CB-RE-2907-R292; the current event record shows completion on 2025-06-14 under CB-RE-2907-E587. Identity resolves to ENT-057-1000, revision REV-2025.1 is current, and Elliot Mercer is active with capacity 3.", "due_date": "2026-09-23", "id": "ACT-CBP-057-01", "identity_id": "ENT-057-1000", "issue": "zoning nonconformity", "owner": "Elliot Mercer", "portfolio_key": "CBP-057-01", "recommended_action": "Create lease-control rows tied to exact notice, work, and lender evidence. Owner: Elliot Mercer; due 2026-09-23.", "severity": "high", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_leases/001_leases_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/02_amendments/013_amendments_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/04_title_survey/025_title_survey_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/05_environmental/037_environmental_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/11_financing/085_financing_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/07_operating_expenses/049_operating_expenses_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/12_property_management/097_glenridge_school_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "the controlling threshold is 14% under CB-RE-2907-R775; the independently calculated result is 20% under CB-RE-2907-E139. Identity resolves to ENT-057-1001, revision REV-2025.2 is current, and Sofia Bennett is active with capacity 3.", "due_date": "2026-09-22", "id": "ACT-CBP-057-02", "identity_id": "ENT-057-1001", "issue": "construction lien notice", "owner": "Sofia Bennett", "portfolio_key": "CBP-057-02", "recommended_action": "Create lease-control rows tied to exact notice, work, and lender evidence. Owner: Sofia Bennett; due 2026-09-22.", "severity": "high", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_leases/002_leases_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/02_amendments/014_amendments_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/04_title_survey/026_title_survey_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/05_environmental/038_environmental_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/11_financing/086_financing_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/07_operating_expenses/050_operating_expenses_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/12_property_management/097_glenridge_school_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "approval must come from Willa Novak under CB-RE-2907-R622; the effective approval record names Rafael Okafor under CB-RE-2907-E501. Identity resolves to ENT-057-1002, revision REV-2025.3 is current, and Micah Sullivan is active with capacity 5.", "due_date": "2026-09-21", "id": "ACT-CBP-057-03", "identity_id": "ENT-057-1002", "issue": "exclusive-use conflict", "owner": "Micah Sullivan", "portfolio_key": "CBP-057-03", "recommended_action": "Create lease-control rows tied to exact notice, work, and lender evidence. Owner: Micah Sullivan; due 2026-09-21.", "severity": "high", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_leases/003_leases_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/02_amendments/015_amendments_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/04_title_survey/027_title_survey_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/05_environmental/039_environmental_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/11_financing/087_financing_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/08_insurance/063_insurance_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_property_management/097_glenridge_school_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "the permission is limited to Arapahoe County, Colorado under CB-RE-2907-R749; the matched activity occurred in Colorado under CB-RE-2907-E138. Identity resolves to ENT-057-1004, revision REV-2025.5 is current, and Caleb Hassan is active with capacity 1.", "due_date": "2026-09-19", "id": "ACT-CBP-057-05", "identity_id": "ENT-057-1004", "issue": "casualty restoration deadline", "owner": "Caleb Hassan", "portfolio_key": "CBP-057-05", "recommended_action": "Create lease-control rows tied to exact notice, work, and lender evidence. Owner: Caleb Hassan; due 2026-09-19.", "severity": "high", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_leases/005_leases_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/03_estoppels/017_estoppels_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/04_title_survey/029_title_survey_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/041_zoning_permits_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/12_property_management/097_glenridge_school_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "delivery must use notices-glenridge_education_network@example.test under CB-RE-2907-R898; the only matched receipt used archive-cedar_hall_development@example.test under CB-RE-2907-E252. Identity resolves to ENT-057-1006, revision REV-2025.7 is current, and Samuel Kim is active with capacity 2.", "due_date": "2026-09-17", "id": "ACT-CBP-057-07", "identity_id": "ENT-057-1006", "issue": "title exception", "owner": "Samuel Kim", "portfolio_key": "CBP-057-07", "recommended_action": "Create lease-control rows tied to exact notice, work, and lender evidence. Owner: Samuel Kim; due 2026-09-17.", "severity": "high", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_leases/007_leases_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/03_estoppels/019_estoppels_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/04_title_survey/031_title_survey_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/043_zoning_permits_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/12_property_management/097_glenridge_school_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "the controlled population contains 101 records under CB-RE-2907-R789; the certification covers 70 records under CB-RE-2907-E881. Identity resolves to ENT-057-1011, revision REV-2025.5 is current, and Leona Park is active with capacity 4.", "due_date": "2026-09-21", "id": "ACT-CBP-057-12", "identity_id": "ENT-057-1011", "issue": "security-deposit mismatch", "owner": "Leona Park", "portfolio_key": "CBP-057-12", "recommended_action": "Create lease-control rows tied to exact notice, work, and lender evidence. Owner: Leona Park; due 2026-09-21.", "severity": "high", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_amendments/012_amendments_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/03_estoppels/024_estoppels_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/05_environmental/036_environmental_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/048_zoning_permits_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/11_financing/084_financing_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/12_property_management/097_glenridge_school_impact_population.xlsx"]}], "as_of": "2026-09-24", "decision": {"alternatives_considered": ["glenridge-school:blanket-hold", "glenridge-school:shortcut"], "question": "Can Glenridge renew and finance the campus lease without a use, accessibility, or SNDA problem?", "rationale": "The four-part causal test supports 6 scoped actions and leaves 6 records on evidence hold. Renewal and financing depend on timely notice, permitted use, completed obligations, and lender recognition.", "recommendation": "Proceed with supported conditions and cure only the proven gaps.", "selected_option_id": "glenridge-school:scoped-evidence"}, "holds": [{"id": "HOLD-CBP-057-04", "issue": "environmental recognized condition", "portfolio_key": "CBP-057-04", "reason": "the operational record relies on a superseded control revision", "required_next_evidence": "an operational record using the current effective revision", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_leases/004_leases_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/02_amendments/016_amendments_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/04_title_survey/028_title_survey_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/05_environmental/040_environmental_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_property_management/097_glenridge_school_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-057-06", "issue": "renewal-option notice", "portfolio_key": "CBP-057-06", "reason": "the current observation does not meet the operative trigger", "required_next_evidence": "a current observation that satisfies the operative trigger", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_leases/006_leases_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/03_estoppels/018_estoppels_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/04_title_survey/030_title_survey_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/042_zoning_permits_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/09_notices/066_notices_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/12_property_management/097_glenridge_school_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-057-08", "issue": "insurance endorsement deficiency", "portfolio_key": "CBP-057-08", "reason": "the operational record relies on a superseded control revision", "required_next_evidence": "an operational record using the current effective revision", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_leases/008_leases_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/03_estoppels/020_estoppels_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/04_title_survey/032_title_survey_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/044_zoning_permits_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/07_operating_expenses/056_operating_expenses_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_property_management/097_glenridge_school_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-057-09", "issue": "rent schedule inconsistency", "portfolio_key": "CBP-057-09", "reason": "two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key", "required_next_evidence": "an approved immutable entity crosswalk", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_amendments/009_amendments_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/03_estoppels/021_estoppels_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/05_environmental/033_environmental_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/045_zoning_permits_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_property_management/097_glenridge_school_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-057-10", "issue": "survey encroachment", "portfolio_key": "CBP-057-10", "reason": "the current observation does not meet the operative trigger", "required_next_evidence": "a current observation that satisfies the operative trigger", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_amendments/010_amendments_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/03_estoppels/022_estoppels_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/05_environmental/034_environmental_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/046_zoning_permits_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_property_management/097_glenridge_school_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-057-11", "issue": "CAM reconciliation error", "portfolio_key": "CBP-057-11", "reason": "the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective", "required_next_evidence": "effective approval and an active owner with remaining capacity", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_amendments/011_amendments_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/03_estoppels/023_estoppels_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/05_environmental/035_environmental_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/047_zoning_permits_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_property_management/097_glenridge_school_impact_population.xlsx"]}], "matter_number": "CB-RE-2907", "prepared_for": "Glenridge Education Network", "schema_version": "counselbench.decision.v3", "task_id": "cb100-057-glenridge-school"}, "matter_register": {"matter_number": "CB-RE-2907", "rows": [{"decision_option_id": "glenridge-school:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-23", "issue": "zoning nonconformity", "matter_number": "CB-RE-2907", "owner": "Elliot Mercer", "portfolio_key": "CBP-057-01", "row_id": "REG-CBP-057-01", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_leases/001_leases_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/02_amendments/013_amendments_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/04_title_survey/025_title_survey_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/05_environmental/037_environmental_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/11_financing/085_financing_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/07_operating_expenses/049_operating_expenses_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/12_property_management/097_glenridge_school_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "glenridge-school:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-22", "issue": "construction lien notice", "matter_number": "CB-RE-2907", "owner": "Sofia Bennett", "portfolio_key": "CBP-057-02", "row_id": "REG-CBP-057-02", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_leases/002_leases_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/02_amendments/014_amendments_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/04_title_survey/026_title_survey_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/05_environmental/038_environmental_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/11_financing/086_financing_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/07_operating_expenses/050_operating_expenses_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/12_property_management/097_glenridge_school_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "glenridge-school:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-21", "issue": "exclusive-use conflict", "matter_number": "CB-RE-2907", "owner": "Micah Sullivan", "portfolio_key": "CBP-057-03", "row_id": "REG-CBP-057-03", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_leases/003_leases_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/02_amendments/015_amendments_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/04_title_survey/027_title_survey_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/05_environmental/039_environmental_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/11_financing/087_financing_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/08_insurance/063_insurance_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_property_management/097_glenridge_school_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "glenridge-school:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "the operational record relies on a superseded control revision", "issue": "environmental recognized condition", "matter_number": "CB-RE-2907", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-057-04", "row_id": "REG-CBP-057-04", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_leases/004_leases_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/02_amendments/016_amendments_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/04_title_survey/028_title_survey_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/05_environmental/040_environmental_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_property_management/097_glenridge_school_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "glenridge-school:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-19", "issue": "casualty restoration deadline", "matter_number": "CB-RE-2907", "owner": "Caleb Hassan", "portfolio_key": "CBP-057-05", "row_id": "REG-CBP-057-05", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_leases/005_leases_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/03_estoppels/017_estoppels_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/04_title_survey/029_title_survey_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/041_zoning_permits_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/12_property_management/097_glenridge_school_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "glenridge-school:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "the current observation does not meet the operative trigger", "issue": "renewal-option notice", "matter_number": "CB-RE-2907", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-057-06", "row_id": "REG-CBP-057-06", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_leases/006_leases_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/03_estoppels/018_estoppels_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/04_title_survey/030_title_survey_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/042_zoning_permits_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/09_notices/066_notices_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/12_property_management/097_glenridge_school_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "glenridge-school:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-17", "issue": "title exception", "matter_number": "CB-RE-2907", "owner": "Samuel Kim", "portfolio_key": "CBP-057-07", "row_id": "REG-CBP-057-07", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_leases/007_leases_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/03_estoppels/019_estoppels_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/04_title_survey/031_title_survey_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/043_zoning_permits_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/12_property_management/097_glenridge_school_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "glenridge-school:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "the operational record relies on a superseded control revision", "issue": "insurance endorsement deficiency", "matter_number": "CB-RE-2907", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-057-08", "row_id": "REG-CBP-057-08", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_leases/008_leases_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/03_estoppels/020_estoppels_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/04_title_survey/032_title_survey_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/044_zoning_permits_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/07_operating_expenses/056_operating_expenses_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_property_management/097_glenridge_school_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "glenridge-school:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key", "issue": "rent schedule inconsistency", "matter_number": "CB-RE-2907", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-057-09", "row_id": "REG-CBP-057-09", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_amendments/009_amendments_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/03_estoppels/021_estoppels_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/05_environmental/033_environmental_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/045_zoning_permits_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_property_management/097_glenridge_school_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "glenridge-school:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "the current observation does not meet the operative trigger", "issue": "survey encroachment", "matter_number": "CB-RE-2907", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-057-10", "row_id": "REG-CBP-057-10", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_amendments/010_amendments_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/03_estoppels/022_estoppels_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/05_environmental/034_environmental_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/046_zoning_permits_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_property_management/097_glenridge_school_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "glenridge-school:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective", "issue": "CAM reconciliation error", "matter_number": "CB-RE-2907", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-057-11", "row_id": "REG-CBP-057-11", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_amendments/011_amendments_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/03_estoppels/023_estoppels_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/05_environmental/035_environmental_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/047_zoning_permits_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_property_management/097_glenridge_school_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "glenridge-school:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-21", "issue": "security-deposit mismatch", "matter_number": "CB-RE-2907", "owner": "Leona Park", "portfolio_key": "CBP-057-12", "row_id": "REG-CBP-057-12", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_amendments/012_amendments_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/03_estoppels/024_estoppels_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/05_environmental/036_environmental_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/048_zoning_permits_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/11_financing/084_financing_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/12_property_management/097_glenridge_school_impact_population.xlsx"]}], "schema_version": "counselbench.matter-register.v3", "task_id": "cb100-057-glenridge-school"}}, "metadata": {"benchmark": "CounselBench-100", "code_license": "Apache-2.0", "data_license": "CC-BY-4.0", "deadline": "2026-09-24", "document_count": 97, "evidence_holds": 6, "jurisdiction": "Colorado", "matter_number": "CB-RE-2907", "mcp_commit": "9a96ea6e5913736f92b88345bf51caeaaa8e719f", "mcp_package": "@modelcontextprotocol/server-filesystem@2026.7.10", "practice_area": "real-estate", "reference_tool_calls": 86, "required_evidence_reads": 59, "supported_actions": 6, "synthetic": true, "venue": "Arapahoe County, Colorado", "version": "3.1.0"}, "prompt": "The other side has challenged our internal account of the facts. Can Glenridge renew and finance the campus lease without a use, accessibility, or SNDA problem? A school campus faces use restrictions, renewal notices, accessibility work, and an SNDA missing from lender records. The team needs the call by 2026-09-24. Leave a concise decision record with exact source references and an owner for each supported next step.", "rubric": {"criteria": [{"category": "investigation", "description": "Inventory the production and use targeted searches to locate records across native formats.", "id": "investigation.discover_production"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Complete every task-specific identity, authority, operations, and approval read before the first state transition.", "id": "investigation.read_before_write"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Inspect designated source metadata before relying on those records.", "id": "investigation.custody_before_write"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "Select the supported option 'glenridge-school:scoped-evidence' after applying the four-part test.", "id": "decision.selected_option"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "Identify both rejected approaches and explain why a one-source shortcut and a blanket hold are wrong.", "id": "decision.alternatives"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-057-01 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_leases/001_leases_source_export.md rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-057-01.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_amendments/013_amendments_source_export.json for zoning nonconformity.", "id": "investigation.CBP-057-01.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_title_survey/025_title_survey_source_export.md to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-057-01.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_environmental/037_environmental_source_export.json.", "id": "investigation.CBP-057-01.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-057-01 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-057-01.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-057-01 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-057-01.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-057-02 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_leases/002_leases_source_export.txt rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-057-02.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_amendments/014_amendments_source_export.xml for construction lien notice.", "id": "investigation.CBP-057-02.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_title_survey/026_title_survey_source_export.txt to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-057-02.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_environmental/038_environmental_source_export.xml.", "id": "investigation.CBP-057-02.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-057-02 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-057-02.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-057-02 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-057-02.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-057-03 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_leases/003_leases_source_export.eml rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-057-03.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_amendments/015_amendments_source_export.html for exclusive-use conflict.", "id": "investigation.CBP-057-03.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_title_survey/027_title_survey_source_export.eml to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-057-03.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_environmental/039_environmental_source_export.html.", "id": "investigation.CBP-057-03.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-057-03 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-057-03.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-057-03 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-057-03.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-057-04 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_leases/004_leases_source_export.csv rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-057-04.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_amendments/016_amendments_source_export.pdf for environmental recognized condition.", "id": "investigation.CBP-057-04.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_title_survey/028_title_survey_source_export.csv to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-057-04.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_environmental/040_environmental_source_export.pdf.", "id": "investigation.CBP-057-04.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-057-04 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is the operational record relies on a superseded control revision.", "id": "decision.CBP-057-04.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-057-04 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-057-04.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-057-05 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_leases/005_leases_source_export.json rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-057-05.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_estoppels/017_estoppels_source_export.md for casualty restoration deadline.", "id": "investigation.CBP-057-05.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_title_survey/029_title_survey_source_export.json to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-057-05.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/041_zoning_permits_source_export.md.", "id": "investigation.CBP-057-05.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-057-05 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-057-05.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-057-05 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-057-05.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-057-06 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_leases/006_leases_source_export.xml rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-057-06.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_estoppels/018_estoppels_source_export.txt for renewal-option notice.", "id": "investigation.CBP-057-06.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_title_survey/030_title_survey_source_export.xml to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-057-06.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/042_zoning_permits_source_export.txt.", "id": "investigation.CBP-057-06.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-057-06 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is the current observation does not meet the operative trigger.", "id": "decision.CBP-057-06.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-057-06 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-057-06.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-057-07 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_leases/007_leases_source_export.html rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-057-07.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_estoppels/019_estoppels_source_export.eml for title exception.", "id": "investigation.CBP-057-07.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_title_survey/031_title_survey_source_export.html to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-057-07.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/043_zoning_permits_source_export.eml.", "id": "investigation.CBP-057-07.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-057-07 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-057-07.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-057-07 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-057-07.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-057-08 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_leases/008_leases_source_export.pdf rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-057-08.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_estoppels/020_estoppels_source_export.csv for insurance endorsement deficiency.", "id": "investigation.CBP-057-08.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_title_survey/032_title_survey_source_export.pdf to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-057-08.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/044_zoning_permits_source_export.csv.", "id": "investigation.CBP-057-08.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-057-08 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is the operational record relies on a superseded control revision.", "id": "decision.CBP-057-08.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-057-08 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-057-08.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-057-09 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_amendments/009_amendments_source_export.md rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-057-09.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_estoppels/021_estoppels_source_export.json for rent schedule inconsistency.", "id": "investigation.CBP-057-09.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_environmental/033_environmental_source_export.md to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-057-09.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/045_zoning_permits_source_export.json.", "id": "investigation.CBP-057-09.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-057-09 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key.", "id": "decision.CBP-057-09.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-057-09 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-057-09.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-057-10 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_amendments/010_amendments_source_export.txt rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-057-10.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_estoppels/022_estoppels_source_export.xml for survey encroachment.", "id": "investigation.CBP-057-10.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_environmental/034_environmental_source_export.txt to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-057-10.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/046_zoning_permits_source_export.xml.", "id": "investigation.CBP-057-10.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-057-10 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is the current observation does not meet the operative trigger.", "id": "decision.CBP-057-10.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-057-10 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-057-10.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-057-11 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_amendments/011_amendments_source_export.eml rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-057-11.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_estoppels/023_estoppels_source_export.html for CAM reconciliation error.", "id": "investigation.CBP-057-11.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_environmental/035_environmental_source_export.eml to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-057-11.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/047_zoning_permits_source_export.html.", "id": "investigation.CBP-057-11.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-057-11 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective.", "id": "decision.CBP-057-11.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-057-11 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-057-11.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-057-12 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_amendments/012_amendments_source_export.csv rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-057-12.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_estoppels/024_estoppels_source_export.pdf for security-deposit mismatch.", "id": "investigation.CBP-057-12.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_environmental/036_environmental_source_export.csv to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-057-12.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/048_zoning_permits_source_export.pdf.", "id": "investigation.CBP-057-12.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-057-12 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-057-12.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-057-12 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-057-12.register"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Write the exact selected option, supported action population, evidence-hold population, facts, owners, deadlines, and citations.", "id": "state.exact_decision"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create one exact register row per portfolio key with no extra, missing, or modified row.", "id": "state.exact_register"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Leave only the three approved deliverables and perform no extra state-changing write.", "id": "state.write_scope_containment"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Read back decision.json, matter-register.json, and advice.md after their final writes.", "id": "state.postwrite_readback"}, {"category": "answer", "description": "Explain the selected recommendation, supported actions, holds, alternatives, and limitations with exact source anchors.", "id": "answer.decision_note"}], "decision_options": [{"approach": "Treat supported actions and genuinely ambiguous records as if they were equally unresolved.", "id": "glenridge-school:blanket-hold", "label": "Freeze the entire matter population"}, {"approach": "Apply the exact identity, current-state, authority, and revision test. Create lease-control rows tied to exact notice, work, and lender evidence.", "id": "glenridge-school:scoped-evidence", "label": "Proceed with supported conditions and cure only the proven gaps."}, {"approach": "Use a plausible summary or one source without completing the controlling joins.", "id": "glenridge-school:shortcut", "label": "Assume continued occupancy preserved every option and lender protection."}], "evaluation_narrative": {"authority": "Renewal and financing depend on timely notice, permitted use, completed obligations, and lender recognition.", "observation": "Join lease options, notice delivery, use approvals, accessibility work, and lender files.", "question": "Can Glenridge renew and finance the campus lease without a use, accessibility, or SNDA problem?", "register_action": "Create lease-control rows tied to exact notice, work, and lender evidence."}, "gates": ["all_required_evidence_precedes_first_write", "decision_criteria_complete", "register_state_exact", "write_scope_contained", "all_outputs_verified_by_readback"], "metadata_checks": 10, "metric": "weighted_criteria_score", "minimum_tool_calls": 86, "required_deliverables": ["decision.json", "matter-register.json", "advice.md"], "required_document_reads": 59, "type": "deterministic", "weights": {"advice": 0.15, "decision": 0.35, "investigation": 0.25, "state": 0.25}}, "task_id": "cb100-057-glenridge-school", "task_name": "Glenridge charter campus lease review", "world_id": "counselbench-filesystem-mcp-v3"}
+{"context_files": ["task_files/cb100-058-hemlock-manufacturing/01_leases/001_leases_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-058-hemlock-manufacturing/01_leases/002_leases_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-058-hemlock-manufacturing/01_leases/003_leases_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-058-hemlock-manufacturing/01_leases/004_leases_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-058-hemlock-manufacturing/01_leases/005_leases_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-058-hemlock-manufacturing/01_leases/006_leases_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-058-hemlock-manufacturing/01_leases/007_leases_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-058-hemlock-manufacturing/01_leases/008_leases_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-058-hemlock-manufacturing/02_amendments/009_amendments_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-058-hemlock-manufacturing/02_amendments/010_amendments_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-058-hemlock-manufacturing/02_amendments/011_amendments_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-058-hemlock-manufacturing/02_amendments/012_amendments_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-058-hemlock-manufacturing/02_amendments/013_amendments_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-058-hemlock-manufacturing/02_amendments/014_amendments_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-058-hemlock-manufacturing/02_amendments/015_amendments_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-058-hemlock-manufacturing/02_amendments/016_amendments_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-058-hemlock-manufacturing/03_estoppels/017_estoppels_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-058-hemlock-manufacturing/03_estoppels/018_estoppels_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-058-hemlock-manufacturing/03_estoppels/019_estoppels_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-058-hemlock-manufacturing/03_estoppels/020_estoppels_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-058-hemlock-manufacturing/03_estoppels/021_estoppels_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-058-hemlock-manufacturing/03_estoppels/022_estoppels_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-058-hemlock-manufacturing/03_estoppels/023_estoppels_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-058-hemlock-manufacturing/03_estoppels/024_estoppels_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-058-hemlock-manufacturing/04_title_survey/025_title_survey_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-058-hemlock-manufacturing/04_title_survey/026_title_survey_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-058-hemlock-manufacturing/04_title_survey/027_title_survey_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-058-hemlock-manufacturing/04_title_survey/028_title_survey_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-058-hemlock-manufacturing/04_title_survey/029_title_survey_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-058-hemlock-manufacturing/04_title_survey/030_title_survey_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-058-hemlock-manufacturing/04_title_survey/031_title_survey_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-058-hemlock-manufacturing/04_title_survey/032_title_survey_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-058-hemlock-manufacturing/05_environmental/033_environmental_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-058-hemlock-manufacturing/05_environmental/034_environmental_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-058-hemlock-manufacturing/05_environmental/035_environmental_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-058-hemlock-manufacturing/05_environmental/036_environmental_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-058-hemlock-manufacturing/05_environmental/037_environmental_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-058-hemlock-manufacturing/05_environmental/038_environmental_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-058-hemlock-manufacturing/05_environmental/039_environmental_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-058-hemlock-manufacturing/05_environmental/040_environmental_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-058-hemlock-manufacturing/06_zoning_permits/041_zoning_permits_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-058-hemlock-manufacturing/06_zoning_permits/042_zoning_permits_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-058-hemlock-manufacturing/06_zoning_permits/043_zoning_permits_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-058-hemlock-manufacturing/06_zoning_permits/044_zoning_permits_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-058-hemlock-manufacturing/06_zoning_permits/045_zoning_permits_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-058-hemlock-manufacturing/06_zoning_permits/046_zoning_permits_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-058-hemlock-manufacturing/06_zoning_permits/047_zoning_permits_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-058-hemlock-manufacturing/06_zoning_permits/048_zoning_permits_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-058-hemlock-manufacturing/07_operating_expenses/049_operating_expenses_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-058-hemlock-manufacturing/07_operating_expenses/050_operating_expenses_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-058-hemlock-manufacturing/07_operating_expenses/051_operating_expenses_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-058-hemlock-manufacturing/07_operating_expenses/052_operating_expenses_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-058-hemlock-manufacturing/07_operating_expenses/053_operating_expenses_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-058-hemlock-manufacturing/07_operating_expenses/054_operating_expenses_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-058-hemlock-manufacturing/07_operating_expenses/055_operating_expenses_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-058-hemlock-manufacturing/07_operating_expenses/056_operating_expenses_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-058-hemlock-manufacturing/08_insurance/057_insurance_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-058-hemlock-manufacturing/08_insurance/058_insurance_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-058-hemlock-manufacturing/08_insurance/059_insurance_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-058-hemlock-manufacturing/08_insurance/060_insurance_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-058-hemlock-manufacturing/08_insurance/061_insurance_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-058-hemlock-manufacturing/08_insurance/062_insurance_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-058-hemlock-manufacturing/08_insurance/063_insurance_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-058-hemlock-manufacturing/08_insurance/064_insurance_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-058-hemlock-manufacturing/09_notices/065_notices_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-058-hemlock-manufacturing/09_notices/066_notices_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-058-hemlock-manufacturing/09_notices/067_notices_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-058-hemlock-manufacturing/09_notices/068_notices_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-058-hemlock-manufacturing/09_notices/069_notices_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-058-hemlock-manufacturing/09_notices/070_notices_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-058-hemlock-manufacturing/09_notices/071_notices_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-058-hemlock-manufacturing/09_notices/072_notices_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-058-hemlock-manufacturing/10_construction/073_construction_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-058-hemlock-manufacturing/10_construction/074_construction_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-058-hemlock-manufacturing/10_construction/075_construction_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-058-hemlock-manufacturing/10_construction/076_construction_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-058-hemlock-manufacturing/10_construction/077_construction_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-058-hemlock-manufacturing/10_construction/078_construction_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-058-hemlock-manufacturing/10_construction/079_construction_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-058-hemlock-manufacturing/10_construction/080_construction_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-058-hemlock-manufacturing/11_financing/081_financing_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-058-hemlock-manufacturing/11_financing/082_financing_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-058-hemlock-manufacturing/11_financing/083_financing_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-058-hemlock-manufacturing/11_financing/084_financing_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-058-hemlock-manufacturing/11_financing/085_financing_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-058-hemlock-manufacturing/11_financing/086_financing_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-058-hemlock-manufacturing/11_financing/087_financing_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-058-hemlock-manufacturing/11_financing/088_financing_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-058-hemlock-manufacturing/12_property_management/089_property_management_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-058-hemlock-manufacturing/12_property_management/090_property_management_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-058-hemlock-manufacturing/12_property_management/091_property_management_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-058-hemlock-manufacturing/12_property_management/092_property_management_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-058-hemlock-manufacturing/12_property_management/093_property_management_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-058-hemlock-manufacturing/12_property_management/094_property_management_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-058-hemlock-manufacturing/12_property_management/095_property_management_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-058-hemlock-manufacturing/12_property_management/096_property_management_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-058-hemlock-manufacturing/12_property_management/097_hemlock_manufacturing_impact_population.xlsx"], "gold_output": {"advice_markdown": "# Decision note — Hemlock plant sale-leaseback audit\n\n## Recommendation\n\nUse targeted cure, escrow, or allocation for proven facility risks. The reconciled record supports 5 scoped actions and leaves 7 items on evidence hold.\n\nSelected option: `hemlock-manufacturing:scoped-evidence`.\n\n## Why this is the supported option\n\nMatch facility, equipment, environmental condition, repair scope, liens, and permit closeout. The transaction documents and current public and lien records allocate each obligation.\n\n## Supported actions\n\n### CBP-058-06 — exclusive-use conflict (critical)\n\napproval must come from Maya Ellison under CB-RE-2908-R902; the effective approval record names Henry Cho under CB-RE-2908-E253. Identity resolves to ENT-058-1005, revision REV-2026.6 is current, and Micah Sullivan is active with capacity 2.\n\nAction: Create facility-obligation rows and hold stale parcel or equipment matches. Owner: Micah Sullivan; due 2026-09-22.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_leases/006_leases_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/03_estoppels/018_estoppels_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/04_title_survey/030_title_survey_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/042_zoning_permits_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/10_construction/078_construction_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/12_property_management/097_hemlock_manufacturing_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-058-07 — environmental recognized condition (critical)\n\nthe controlled population contains 159 records under CB-RE-2908-R577; the certification covers 130 records under CB-RE-2908-E975. Identity resolves to ENT-058-1006, revision REV-2026.7 is current, and Nora Chen is active with capacity 5.\n\nAction: Create facility-obligation rows and hold stale parcel or equipment matches. Owner: Nora Chen; due 2026-09-21.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_leases/007_leases_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/03_estoppels/019_estoppels_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/04_title_survey/031_title_survey_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/043_zoning_permits_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/12_property_management/091_property_management_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/07_operating_expenses/055_operating_expenses_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/12_property_management/097_hemlock_manufacturing_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-058-08 — casualty restoration deadline (low)\n\nthe permission is limited to Oakland County, Michigan under CB-RE-2908-R196; the matched activity occurred in Michigan under CB-RE-2908-E635. Identity resolves to ENT-058-1007, revision REV-2026.1 is current, and Caleb Hassan is active with capacity 5.\n\nAction: Create facility-obligation rows and hold stale parcel or equipment matches. Owner: Caleb Hassan; due 2026-09-20.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_leases/008_leases_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/03_estoppels/020_estoppels_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/04_title_survey/032_title_survey_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/044_zoning_permits_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/10_construction/080_construction_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/12_property_management/097_hemlock_manufacturing_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-058-11 — insurance endorsement deficiency (medium)\n\nan open exception blocks completion under CB-RE-2908-R656; the current status is open and unresolved under CB-RE-2908-E820. Identity resolves to ENT-058-1010, revision REV-2026.4 is current, and Talia Brooks is active with capacity 6.\n\nAction: Create facility-obligation rows and hold stale parcel or equipment matches. Owner: Talia Brooks; due 2026-09-26.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/02_amendments/011_amendments_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/03_estoppels/023_estoppels_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/05_environmental/035_environmental_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/047_zoning_permits_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/09_notices/071_notices_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/08_insurance/059_insurance_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/12_property_management/097_hemlock_manufacturing_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-058-12 — rent schedule inconsistency (medium)\n\ncompletion is required by 2025-03-26 under CB-RE-2908-R479; the current event record shows completion on 2025-04-25 under CB-RE-2908-E122. Identity resolves to ENT-058-1011, revision REV-2026.5 is current, and Adrian Mensah is active with capacity 1.\n\nAction: Create facility-obligation rows and hold stale parcel or equipment matches. Owner: Adrian Mensah; due 2026-09-25.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/02_amendments/012_amendments_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/03_estoppels/024_estoppels_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/05_environmental/036_environmental_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/048_zoning_permits_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/12_property_management/097_hemlock_manufacturing_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n## Evidence holds\n\n- **CBP-058-01 — permit closeout gap**: the current observation does not meet the operative trigger. Next evidence: a current observation that satisfies the operative trigger. Sources: `/workspace/documents/01_leases/001_leases_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/02_amendments/013_amendments_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/04_title_survey/025_title_survey_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/05_environmental/037_environmental_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/07_operating_expenses/049_operating_expenses_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/12_property_management/097_hemlock_manufacturing_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-058-02 — lender SNDA omission**: the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective. Next evidence: effective approval and an active owner with remaining capacity. Sources: `/workspace/documents/01_leases/002_leases_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/02_amendments/014_amendments_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/04_title_survey/026_title_survey_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/05_environmental/038_environmental_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/11_financing/086_financing_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/10_construction/074_construction_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/12_property_management/097_hemlock_manufacturing_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-058-03 — assignment consent**: the operational record relies on a superseded control revision. Next evidence: an operational record using the current effective revision. Sources: `/workspace/documents/01_leases/003_leases_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/02_amendments/015_amendments_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/04_title_survey/027_title_survey_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/05_environmental/039_environmental_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/11_financing/087_financing_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/07_operating_expenses/051_operating_expenses_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/12_property_management/097_hemlock_manufacturing_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-058-04 — zoning nonconformity**: two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key. Next evidence: an approved immutable entity crosswalk. Sources: `/workspace/documents/01_leases/004_leases_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/02_amendments/016_amendments_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/04_title_survey/028_title_survey_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/05_environmental/040_environmental_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/12_property_management/097_hemlock_manufacturing_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-058-05 — construction lien notice**: the current observation does not meet the operative trigger. Next evidence: a current observation that satisfies the operative trigger. Sources: `/workspace/documents/01_leases/005_leases_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/03_estoppels/017_estoppels_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/04_title_survey/029_title_survey_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/041_zoning_permits_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/10_construction/077_construction_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/12_property_management/097_hemlock_manufacturing_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-058-09 — renewal-option notice**: the current observation does not meet the operative trigger. Next evidence: a current observation that satisfies the operative trigger. Sources: `/workspace/documents/02_amendments/009_amendments_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/03_estoppels/021_estoppels_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/05_environmental/033_environmental_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/045_zoning_permits_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/12_property_management/097_hemlock_manufacturing_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-058-10 — title exception**: the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective. Next evidence: effective approval and an active owner with remaining capacity. Sources: `/workspace/documents/02_amendments/010_amendments_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/03_estoppels/022_estoppels_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/05_environmental/034_environmental_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/046_zoning_permits_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/09_notices/070_notices_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/12_property_management/097_hemlock_manufacturing_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n## Alternatives considered\n\n- `hemlock-manufacturing:shortcut` — Put every property issue into a general indemnity without reconciling ownership.: Use a plausible summary or one source without completing the controlling joins.\n- `hemlock-manufacturing:blanket-hold` — Freeze the entire matter population: Treat supported actions and genuinely ambiguous records as if they were equally unresolved.\n\n## Assumptions and limits\n\nThis decision is limited to cb100-058-hemlock-manufacturing, the supplied synthetic records, and the matter state as of 2026-09-28. Similar names, stale revisions, and pending authority are not treated as proof.\n", "decision": {"actions": [{"determination": "approval must come from Maya Ellison under CB-RE-2908-R902; the effective approval record names Henry Cho under CB-RE-2908-E253. Identity resolves to ENT-058-1005, revision REV-2026.6 is current, and Micah Sullivan is active with capacity 2.", "due_date": "2026-09-22", "id": "ACT-CBP-058-06", "identity_id": "ENT-058-1005", "issue": "exclusive-use conflict", "owner": "Micah Sullivan", "portfolio_key": "CBP-058-06", "recommended_action": "Create facility-obligation rows and hold stale parcel or equipment matches. Owner: Micah Sullivan; due 2026-09-22.", "severity": "critical", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_leases/006_leases_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/03_estoppels/018_estoppels_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/04_title_survey/030_title_survey_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/042_zoning_permits_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/10_construction/078_construction_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_property_management/097_hemlock_manufacturing_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "the controlled population contains 159 records under CB-RE-2908-R577; the certification covers 130 records under CB-RE-2908-E975. Identity resolves to ENT-058-1006, revision REV-2026.7 is current, and Nora Chen is active with capacity 5.", "due_date": "2026-09-21", "id": "ACT-CBP-058-07", "identity_id": "ENT-058-1006", "issue": "environmental recognized condition", "owner": "Nora Chen", "portfolio_key": "CBP-058-07", "recommended_action": "Create facility-obligation rows and hold stale parcel or equipment matches. Owner: Nora Chen; due 2026-09-21.", "severity": "critical", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_leases/007_leases_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/03_estoppels/019_estoppels_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/04_title_survey/031_title_survey_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/043_zoning_permits_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/12_property_management/091_property_management_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/07_operating_expenses/055_operating_expenses_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_property_management/097_hemlock_manufacturing_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "the permission is limited to Oakland County, Michigan under CB-RE-2908-R196; the matched activity occurred in Michigan under CB-RE-2908-E635. Identity resolves to ENT-058-1007, revision REV-2026.1 is current, and Caleb Hassan is active with capacity 5.", "due_date": "2026-09-20", "id": "ACT-CBP-058-08", "identity_id": "ENT-058-1007", "issue": "casualty restoration deadline", "owner": "Caleb Hassan", "portfolio_key": "CBP-058-08", "recommended_action": "Create facility-obligation rows and hold stale parcel or equipment matches. Owner: Caleb Hassan; due 2026-09-20.", "severity": "low", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_leases/008_leases_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/03_estoppels/020_estoppels_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/04_title_survey/032_title_survey_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/044_zoning_permits_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/10_construction/080_construction_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_property_management/097_hemlock_manufacturing_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "an open exception blocks completion under CB-RE-2908-R656; the current status is open and unresolved under CB-RE-2908-E820. Identity resolves to ENT-058-1010, revision REV-2026.4 is current, and Talia Brooks is active with capacity 6.", "due_date": "2026-09-26", "id": "ACT-CBP-058-11", "identity_id": "ENT-058-1010", "issue": "insurance endorsement deficiency", "owner": "Talia Brooks", "portfolio_key": "CBP-058-11", "recommended_action": "Create facility-obligation rows and hold stale parcel or equipment matches. Owner: Talia Brooks; due 2026-09-26.", "severity": "medium", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_amendments/011_amendments_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/03_estoppels/023_estoppels_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/05_environmental/035_environmental_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/047_zoning_permits_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/09_notices/071_notices_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/08_insurance/059_insurance_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/12_property_management/097_hemlock_manufacturing_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "completion is required by 2025-03-26 under CB-RE-2908-R479; the current event record shows completion on 2025-04-25 under CB-RE-2908-E122. Identity resolves to ENT-058-1011, revision REV-2026.5 is current, and Adrian Mensah is active with capacity 1.", "due_date": "2026-09-25", "id": "ACT-CBP-058-12", "identity_id": "ENT-058-1011", "issue": "rent schedule inconsistency", "owner": "Adrian Mensah", "portfolio_key": "CBP-058-12", "recommended_action": "Create facility-obligation rows and hold stale parcel or equipment matches. Owner: Adrian Mensah; due 2026-09-25.", "severity": "medium", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_amendments/012_amendments_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/03_estoppels/024_estoppels_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/05_environmental/036_environmental_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/048_zoning_permits_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_property_management/097_hemlock_manufacturing_impact_population.xlsx"]}], "as_of": "2026-09-28", "decision": {"alternatives_considered": ["hemlock-manufacturing:shortcut", "hemlock-manufacturing:blanket-hold"], "question": "Which Hemlock environmental, lien, roof, and permit items must be resolved in the sale-leaseback?", "rationale": "The four-part causal test supports 5 scoped actions and leaves 7 records on evidence hold. The transaction documents and current public and lien records allocate each obligation.", "recommendation": "Use targeted cure, escrow, or allocation for proven facility risks.", "selected_option_id": "hemlock-manufacturing:scoped-evidence"}, "holds": [{"id": "HOLD-CBP-058-01", "issue": "permit closeout gap", "portfolio_key": "CBP-058-01", "reason": "the current observation does not meet the operative trigger", "required_next_evidence": "a current observation that satisfies the operative trigger", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_leases/001_leases_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/02_amendments/013_amendments_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/04_title_survey/025_title_survey_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/05_environmental/037_environmental_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/07_operating_expenses/049_operating_expenses_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/12_property_management/097_hemlock_manufacturing_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-058-02", "issue": "lender SNDA omission", "portfolio_key": "CBP-058-02", "reason": "the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective", "required_next_evidence": "effective approval and an active owner with remaining capacity", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_leases/002_leases_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/02_amendments/014_amendments_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/04_title_survey/026_title_survey_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/05_environmental/038_environmental_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/11_financing/086_financing_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/10_construction/074_construction_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/12_property_management/097_hemlock_manufacturing_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-058-03", "issue": "assignment consent", "portfolio_key": "CBP-058-03", "reason": "the operational record relies on a superseded control revision", "required_next_evidence": "an operational record using the current effective revision", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_leases/003_leases_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/02_amendments/015_amendments_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/04_title_survey/027_title_survey_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/05_environmental/039_environmental_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/11_financing/087_financing_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/07_operating_expenses/051_operating_expenses_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/12_property_management/097_hemlock_manufacturing_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-058-04", "issue": "zoning nonconformity", "portfolio_key": "CBP-058-04", "reason": "two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key", "required_next_evidence": "an approved immutable entity crosswalk", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_leases/004_leases_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/02_amendments/016_amendments_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/04_title_survey/028_title_survey_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/05_environmental/040_environmental_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_property_management/097_hemlock_manufacturing_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-058-05", "issue": "construction lien notice", "portfolio_key": "CBP-058-05", "reason": "the current observation does not meet the operative trigger", "required_next_evidence": "a current observation that satisfies the operative trigger", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_leases/005_leases_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/03_estoppels/017_estoppels_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/04_title_survey/029_title_survey_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/041_zoning_permits_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/10_construction/077_construction_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_property_management/097_hemlock_manufacturing_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-058-09", "issue": "renewal-option notice", "portfolio_key": "CBP-058-09", "reason": "the current observation does not meet the operative trigger", "required_next_evidence": "a current observation that satisfies the operative trigger", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_amendments/009_amendments_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/03_estoppels/021_estoppels_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/05_environmental/033_environmental_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/045_zoning_permits_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_property_management/097_hemlock_manufacturing_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-058-10", "issue": "title exception", "portfolio_key": "CBP-058-10", "reason": "the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective", "required_next_evidence": "effective approval and an active owner with remaining capacity", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_amendments/010_amendments_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/03_estoppels/022_estoppels_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/05_environmental/034_environmental_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/046_zoning_permits_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/09_notices/070_notices_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_property_management/097_hemlock_manufacturing_impact_population.xlsx"]}], "matter_number": "CB-RE-2908", "prepared_for": "Hemlock Precision Works", "schema_version": "counselbench.decision.v3", "task_id": "cb100-058-hemlock-manufacturing"}, "matter_register": {"matter_number": "CB-RE-2908", "rows": [{"decision_option_id": "hemlock-manufacturing:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "the current observation does not meet the operative trigger", "issue": "permit closeout gap", "matter_number": "CB-RE-2908", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-058-01", "row_id": "REG-CBP-058-01", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_leases/001_leases_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/02_amendments/013_amendments_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/04_title_survey/025_title_survey_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/05_environmental/037_environmental_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/07_operating_expenses/049_operating_expenses_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/12_property_management/097_hemlock_manufacturing_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "hemlock-manufacturing:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective", "issue": "lender SNDA omission", "matter_number": "CB-RE-2908", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-058-02", "row_id": "REG-CBP-058-02", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_leases/002_leases_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/02_amendments/014_amendments_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/04_title_survey/026_title_survey_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/05_environmental/038_environmental_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/11_financing/086_financing_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/10_construction/074_construction_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/12_property_management/097_hemlock_manufacturing_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "hemlock-manufacturing:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "the operational record relies on a superseded control revision", "issue": "assignment consent", "matter_number": "CB-RE-2908", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-058-03", "row_id": "REG-CBP-058-03", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_leases/003_leases_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/02_amendments/015_amendments_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/04_title_survey/027_title_survey_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/05_environmental/039_environmental_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/11_financing/087_financing_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/07_operating_expenses/051_operating_expenses_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/12_property_management/097_hemlock_manufacturing_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "hemlock-manufacturing:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key", "issue": "zoning nonconformity", "matter_number": "CB-RE-2908", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-058-04", "row_id": "REG-CBP-058-04", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_leases/004_leases_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/02_amendments/016_amendments_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/04_title_survey/028_title_survey_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/05_environmental/040_environmental_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_property_management/097_hemlock_manufacturing_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "hemlock-manufacturing:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "the current observation does not meet the operative trigger", "issue": "construction lien notice", "matter_number": "CB-RE-2908", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-058-05", "row_id": "REG-CBP-058-05", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_leases/005_leases_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/03_estoppels/017_estoppels_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/04_title_survey/029_title_survey_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/041_zoning_permits_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/10_construction/077_construction_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_property_management/097_hemlock_manufacturing_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "hemlock-manufacturing:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-22", "issue": "exclusive-use conflict", "matter_number": "CB-RE-2908", "owner": "Micah Sullivan", "portfolio_key": "CBP-058-06", "row_id": "REG-CBP-058-06", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_leases/006_leases_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/03_estoppels/018_estoppels_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/04_title_survey/030_title_survey_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/042_zoning_permits_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/10_construction/078_construction_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_property_management/097_hemlock_manufacturing_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "hemlock-manufacturing:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-21", "issue": "environmental recognized condition", "matter_number": "CB-RE-2908", "owner": "Nora Chen", "portfolio_key": "CBP-058-07", "row_id": "REG-CBP-058-07", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_leases/007_leases_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/03_estoppels/019_estoppels_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/04_title_survey/031_title_survey_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/043_zoning_permits_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/12_property_management/091_property_management_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/07_operating_expenses/055_operating_expenses_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_property_management/097_hemlock_manufacturing_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "hemlock-manufacturing:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-20", "issue": "casualty restoration deadline", "matter_number": "CB-RE-2908", "owner": "Caleb Hassan", "portfolio_key": "CBP-058-08", "row_id": "REG-CBP-058-08", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_leases/008_leases_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/03_estoppels/020_estoppels_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/04_title_survey/032_title_survey_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/044_zoning_permits_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/10_construction/080_construction_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_property_management/097_hemlock_manufacturing_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "hemlock-manufacturing:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "the current observation does not meet the operative trigger", "issue": "renewal-option notice", "matter_number": "CB-RE-2908", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-058-09", "row_id": "REG-CBP-058-09", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_amendments/009_amendments_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/03_estoppels/021_estoppels_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/05_environmental/033_environmental_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/045_zoning_permits_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_property_management/097_hemlock_manufacturing_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "hemlock-manufacturing:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective", "issue": "title exception", "matter_number": "CB-RE-2908", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-058-10", "row_id": "REG-CBP-058-10", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_amendments/010_amendments_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/03_estoppels/022_estoppels_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/05_environmental/034_environmental_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/046_zoning_permits_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/09_notices/070_notices_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_property_management/097_hemlock_manufacturing_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "hemlock-manufacturing:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-26", "issue": "insurance endorsement deficiency", "matter_number": "CB-RE-2908", "owner": "Talia Brooks", "portfolio_key": "CBP-058-11", "row_id": "REG-CBP-058-11", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_amendments/011_amendments_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/03_estoppels/023_estoppels_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/05_environmental/035_environmental_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/047_zoning_permits_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/09_notices/071_notices_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/08_insurance/059_insurance_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/12_property_management/097_hemlock_manufacturing_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "hemlock-manufacturing:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-25", "issue": "rent schedule inconsistency", "matter_number": "CB-RE-2908", "owner": "Adrian Mensah", "portfolio_key": "CBP-058-12", "row_id": "REG-CBP-058-12", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_amendments/012_amendments_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/03_estoppels/024_estoppels_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/05_environmental/036_environmental_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/048_zoning_permits_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_property_management/097_hemlock_manufacturing_impact_population.xlsx"]}], "schema_version": "counselbench.matter-register.v3", "task_id": "cb100-058-hemlock-manufacturing"}}, "metadata": {"benchmark": "CounselBench-100", "code_license": "Apache-2.0", "data_license": "CC-BY-4.0", "deadline": "2026-09-28", "document_count": 97, "evidence_holds": 7, "jurisdiction": "Michigan", "matter_number": "CB-RE-2908", "mcp_commit": "9a96ea6e5913736f92b88345bf51caeaaa8e719f", "mcp_package": "@modelcontextprotocol/server-filesystem@2026.7.10", "practice_area": "real-estate", "reference_tool_calls": 86, "required_evidence_reads": 63, "supported_actions": 5, "synthetic": true, "venue": "Oakland County, Michigan", "version": "3.1.0"}, "prompt": "There is enough noise in this file that a name match or newest-document shortcut will be dangerous. Which Hemlock environmental, lien, roof, and permit items must be resolved in the sale-leaseback? A manufacturing sale-leaseback includes an environmental condition, equipment liens, roof obligations, and unresolved permit closeout. The team needs the call by 2026-09-28. Leave the defensible result in the matter workspace, including any item that must stay on hold for better evidence.", "rubric": {"criteria": [{"category": "investigation", "description": "Inventory the production and use targeted searches to locate records across native formats.", "id": "investigation.discover_production"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Complete every task-specific identity, authority, operations, and approval read before the first state transition.", "id": "investigation.read_before_write"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Inspect designated source metadata before relying on those records.", "id": "investigation.custody_before_write"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "Select the supported option 'hemlock-manufacturing:scoped-evidence' after applying the four-part test.", "id": "decision.selected_option"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "Identify both rejected approaches and explain why a one-source shortcut and a blanket hold are wrong.", "id": "decision.alternatives"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-058-01 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_leases/001_leases_source_export.md rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-058-01.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_amendments/013_amendments_source_export.json for permit closeout gap.", "id": "investigation.CBP-058-01.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_title_survey/025_title_survey_source_export.md to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-058-01.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_environmental/037_environmental_source_export.json.", "id": "investigation.CBP-058-01.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-058-01 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is the current observation does not meet the operative trigger.", "id": "decision.CBP-058-01.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-058-01 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-058-01.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-058-02 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_leases/002_leases_source_export.txt rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-058-02.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_amendments/014_amendments_source_export.xml for lender SNDA omission.", "id": "investigation.CBP-058-02.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_title_survey/026_title_survey_source_export.txt to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-058-02.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_environmental/038_environmental_source_export.xml.", "id": "investigation.CBP-058-02.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-058-02 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective.", "id": "decision.CBP-058-02.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-058-02 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-058-02.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-058-03 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_leases/003_leases_source_export.eml rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-058-03.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_amendments/015_amendments_source_export.html for assignment consent.", "id": "investigation.CBP-058-03.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_title_survey/027_title_survey_source_export.eml to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-058-03.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_environmental/039_environmental_source_export.html.", "id": "investigation.CBP-058-03.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-058-03 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is the operational record relies on a superseded control revision.", "id": "decision.CBP-058-03.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-058-03 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-058-03.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-058-04 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_leases/004_leases_source_export.csv rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-058-04.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_amendments/016_amendments_source_export.pdf for zoning nonconformity.", "id": "investigation.CBP-058-04.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_title_survey/028_title_survey_source_export.csv to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-058-04.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_environmental/040_environmental_source_export.pdf.", "id": "investigation.CBP-058-04.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-058-04 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key.", "id": "decision.CBP-058-04.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-058-04 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-058-04.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-058-05 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_leases/005_leases_source_export.json rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-058-05.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_estoppels/017_estoppels_source_export.md for construction lien notice.", "id": "investigation.CBP-058-05.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_title_survey/029_title_survey_source_export.json to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-058-05.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/041_zoning_permits_source_export.md.", "id": "investigation.CBP-058-05.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-058-05 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is the current observation does not meet the operative trigger.", "id": "decision.CBP-058-05.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-058-05 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-058-05.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-058-06 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_leases/006_leases_source_export.xml rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-058-06.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_estoppels/018_estoppels_source_export.txt for exclusive-use conflict.", "id": "investigation.CBP-058-06.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_title_survey/030_title_survey_source_export.xml to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-058-06.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/042_zoning_permits_source_export.txt.", "id": "investigation.CBP-058-06.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-058-06 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-058-06.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-058-06 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-058-06.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-058-07 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_leases/007_leases_source_export.html rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-058-07.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_estoppels/019_estoppels_source_export.eml for environmental recognized condition.", "id": "investigation.CBP-058-07.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_title_survey/031_title_survey_source_export.html to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-058-07.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/043_zoning_permits_source_export.eml.", "id": "investigation.CBP-058-07.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-058-07 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-058-07.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-058-07 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-058-07.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-058-08 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_leases/008_leases_source_export.pdf rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-058-08.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_estoppels/020_estoppels_source_export.csv for casualty restoration deadline.", "id": "investigation.CBP-058-08.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_title_survey/032_title_survey_source_export.pdf to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-058-08.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/044_zoning_permits_source_export.csv.", "id": "investigation.CBP-058-08.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-058-08 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-058-08.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-058-08 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-058-08.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-058-09 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_amendments/009_amendments_source_export.md rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-058-09.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_estoppels/021_estoppels_source_export.json for renewal-option notice.", "id": "investigation.CBP-058-09.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_environmental/033_environmental_source_export.md to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-058-09.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/045_zoning_permits_source_export.json.", "id": "investigation.CBP-058-09.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-058-09 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is the current observation does not meet the operative trigger.", "id": "decision.CBP-058-09.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-058-09 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-058-09.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-058-10 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_amendments/010_amendments_source_export.txt rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-058-10.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_estoppels/022_estoppels_source_export.xml for title exception.", "id": "investigation.CBP-058-10.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_environmental/034_environmental_source_export.txt to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-058-10.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/046_zoning_permits_source_export.xml.", "id": "investigation.CBP-058-10.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-058-10 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective.", "id": "decision.CBP-058-10.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-058-10 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-058-10.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-058-11 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_amendments/011_amendments_source_export.eml rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-058-11.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_estoppels/023_estoppels_source_export.html for insurance endorsement deficiency.", "id": "investigation.CBP-058-11.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_environmental/035_environmental_source_export.eml to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-058-11.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/047_zoning_permits_source_export.html.", "id": "investigation.CBP-058-11.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-058-11 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-058-11.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-058-11 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-058-11.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-058-12 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_amendments/012_amendments_source_export.csv rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-058-12.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_estoppels/024_estoppels_source_export.pdf for rent schedule inconsistency.", "id": "investigation.CBP-058-12.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_environmental/036_environmental_source_export.csv to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-058-12.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/048_zoning_permits_source_export.pdf.", "id": "investigation.CBP-058-12.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-058-12 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-058-12.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-058-12 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-058-12.register"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Write the exact selected option, supported action population, evidence-hold population, facts, owners, deadlines, and citations.", "id": "state.exact_decision"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create one exact register row per portfolio key with no extra, missing, or modified row.", "id": "state.exact_register"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Leave only the three approved deliverables and perform no extra state-changing write.", "id": "state.write_scope_containment"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Read back decision.json, matter-register.json, and advice.md after their final writes.", "id": "state.postwrite_readback"}, {"category": "answer", "description": "Explain the selected recommendation, supported actions, holds, alternatives, and limitations with exact source anchors.", "id": "answer.decision_note"}], "decision_options": [{"approach": "Apply the exact identity, current-state, authority, and revision test. Create facility-obligation rows and hold stale parcel or equipment matches.", "id": "hemlock-manufacturing:scoped-evidence", "label": "Use targeted cure, escrow, or allocation for proven facility risks."}, {"approach": "Use a plausible summary or one source without completing the controlling joins.", "id": "hemlock-manufacturing:shortcut", "label": "Put every property issue into a general indemnity without reconciling ownership."}, {"approach": "Treat supported actions and genuinely ambiguous records as if they were equally unresolved.", "id": "hemlock-manufacturing:blanket-hold", "label": "Freeze the entire matter population"}], "evaluation_narrative": {"authority": "The transaction documents and current public and lien records allocate each obligation.", "observation": "Match facility, equipment, environmental condition, repair scope, liens, and permit closeout.", "question": "Which Hemlock environmental, lien, roof, and permit items must be resolved in the sale-leaseback?", "register_action": "Create facility-obligation rows and hold stale parcel or equipment matches."}, "gates": ["all_required_evidence_precedes_first_write", "decision_criteria_complete", "register_state_exact", "write_scope_contained", "all_outputs_verified_by_readback"], "metadata_checks": 9, "metric": "weighted_criteria_score", "minimum_tool_calls": 86, "required_deliverables": ["decision.json", "matter-register.json", "advice.md"], "required_document_reads": 63, "type": "deterministic", "weights": {"advice": 0.15, "decision": 0.35, "investigation": 0.25, "state": 0.25}}, "task_id": "cb100-058-hemlock-manufacturing", "task_name": "Hemlock plant sale-leaseback audit", "world_id": "counselbench-filesystem-mcp-v3"}
+{"context_files": ["task_files/cb100-059-ivory-tower/01_leases/001_leases_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-059-ivory-tower/01_leases/002_leases_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-059-ivory-tower/01_leases/003_leases_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-059-ivory-tower/01_leases/004_leases_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-059-ivory-tower/01_leases/005_leases_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-059-ivory-tower/01_leases/006_leases_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-059-ivory-tower/01_leases/007_leases_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-059-ivory-tower/01_leases/008_leases_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-059-ivory-tower/02_amendments/009_amendments_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-059-ivory-tower/02_amendments/010_amendments_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-059-ivory-tower/02_amendments/011_amendments_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-059-ivory-tower/02_amendments/012_amendments_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-059-ivory-tower/02_amendments/013_amendments_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-059-ivory-tower/02_amendments/014_amendments_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-059-ivory-tower/02_amendments/015_amendments_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-059-ivory-tower/02_amendments/016_amendments_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-059-ivory-tower/03_estoppels/017_estoppels_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-059-ivory-tower/03_estoppels/018_estoppels_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-059-ivory-tower/03_estoppels/019_estoppels_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-059-ivory-tower/03_estoppels/020_estoppels_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-059-ivory-tower/03_estoppels/021_estoppels_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-059-ivory-tower/03_estoppels/022_estoppels_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-059-ivory-tower/03_estoppels/023_estoppels_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-059-ivory-tower/03_estoppels/024_estoppels_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-059-ivory-tower/04_title_survey/025_title_survey_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-059-ivory-tower/04_title_survey/026_title_survey_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-059-ivory-tower/04_title_survey/027_title_survey_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-059-ivory-tower/04_title_survey/028_title_survey_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-059-ivory-tower/04_title_survey/029_title_survey_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-059-ivory-tower/04_title_survey/030_title_survey_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-059-ivory-tower/04_title_survey/031_title_survey_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-059-ivory-tower/04_title_survey/032_title_survey_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-059-ivory-tower/05_environmental/033_environmental_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-059-ivory-tower/05_environmental/034_environmental_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-059-ivory-tower/05_environmental/035_environmental_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-059-ivory-tower/05_environmental/036_environmental_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-059-ivory-tower/05_environmental/037_environmental_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-059-ivory-tower/05_environmental/038_environmental_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-059-ivory-tower/05_environmental/039_environmental_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-059-ivory-tower/05_environmental/040_environmental_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-059-ivory-tower/06_zoning_permits/041_zoning_permits_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-059-ivory-tower/06_zoning_permits/042_zoning_permits_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-059-ivory-tower/06_zoning_permits/043_zoning_permits_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-059-ivory-tower/06_zoning_permits/044_zoning_permits_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-059-ivory-tower/06_zoning_permits/045_zoning_permits_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-059-ivory-tower/06_zoning_permits/046_zoning_permits_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-059-ivory-tower/06_zoning_permits/047_zoning_permits_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-059-ivory-tower/06_zoning_permits/048_zoning_permits_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-059-ivory-tower/07_operating_expenses/049_operating_expenses_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-059-ivory-tower/07_operating_expenses/050_operating_expenses_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-059-ivory-tower/07_operating_expenses/051_operating_expenses_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-059-ivory-tower/07_operating_expenses/052_operating_expenses_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-059-ivory-tower/07_operating_expenses/053_operating_expenses_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-059-ivory-tower/07_operating_expenses/054_operating_expenses_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-059-ivory-tower/07_operating_expenses/055_operating_expenses_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-059-ivory-tower/07_operating_expenses/056_operating_expenses_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-059-ivory-tower/08_insurance/057_insurance_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-059-ivory-tower/08_insurance/058_insurance_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-059-ivory-tower/08_insurance/059_insurance_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-059-ivory-tower/08_insurance/060_insurance_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-059-ivory-tower/08_insurance/061_insurance_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-059-ivory-tower/08_insurance/062_insurance_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-059-ivory-tower/08_insurance/063_insurance_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-059-ivory-tower/08_insurance/064_insurance_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-059-ivory-tower/09_notices/065_notices_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-059-ivory-tower/09_notices/066_notices_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-059-ivory-tower/09_notices/067_notices_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-059-ivory-tower/09_notices/068_notices_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-059-ivory-tower/09_notices/069_notices_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-059-ivory-tower/09_notices/070_notices_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-059-ivory-tower/09_notices/071_notices_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-059-ivory-tower/09_notices/072_notices_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-059-ivory-tower/10_construction/073_construction_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-059-ivory-tower/10_construction/074_construction_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-059-ivory-tower/10_construction/075_construction_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-059-ivory-tower/10_construction/076_construction_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-059-ivory-tower/10_construction/077_construction_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-059-ivory-tower/10_construction/078_construction_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-059-ivory-tower/10_construction/079_construction_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-059-ivory-tower/10_construction/080_construction_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-059-ivory-tower/11_financing/081_financing_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-059-ivory-tower/11_financing/082_financing_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-059-ivory-tower/11_financing/083_financing_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-059-ivory-tower/11_financing/084_financing_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-059-ivory-tower/11_financing/085_financing_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-059-ivory-tower/11_financing/086_financing_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-059-ivory-tower/11_financing/087_financing_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-059-ivory-tower/11_financing/088_financing_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-059-ivory-tower/12_property_management/089_property_management_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-059-ivory-tower/12_property_management/090_property_management_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-059-ivory-tower/12_property_management/091_property_management_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-059-ivory-tower/12_property_management/092_property_management_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-059-ivory-tower/12_property_management/093_property_management_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-059-ivory-tower/12_property_management/094_property_management_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-059-ivory-tower/12_property_management/095_property_management_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-059-ivory-tower/12_property_management/096_property_management_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-059-ivory-tower/12_property_management/097_ivory_tower_impact_population.xlsx"], "gold_output": {"advice_markdown": "# Decision note — Ivory Tower office sublease reconciliation\n\n## Recommendation\n\nApply supported consent and rent treatment and preserve surviving restoration duties. The reconciled record supports 8 scoped actions and leaves 4 items on evidence hold.\n\nSelected option: `ivory-tower:scoped-evidence`.\n\n## Why this is the supported option\n\nReconcile master lease, sublease, amendments, abatements, notices, and delivery evidence by premises and term. Consent and economic treatment follow the operative agreement chain and current notice clause.\n\n## Supported actions\n\n### CBP-059-01 — CAM reconciliation error (medium)\n\napproval must come from Leona Park under CB-RE-2909-R352; the effective approval record names Henry Cho under CB-RE-2909-E432. Identity resolves to ENT-059-1000, revision REV-2025.1 is current, and Isaac Romero is active with capacity 5.\n\nAction: Create premises-period rows with valid notice and amendment lineage. Owner: Isaac Romero; due 2026-09-30.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_leases/001_leases_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/02_amendments/013_amendments_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/04_title_survey/025_title_survey_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/05_environmental/037_environmental_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/07_operating_expenses/049_operating_expenses_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/11_financing/085_financing_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/12_property_management/097_ivory_tower_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-059-02 — security-deposit mismatch (low)\n\nthe controlled population contains 201 records under CB-RE-2909-R169; the certification covers 177 records under CB-RE-2909-E527. Identity resolves to ENT-059-1001, revision REV-2025.2 is current, and Nadine Flores is active with capacity 4.\n\nAction: Create premises-period rows with valid notice and amendment lineage. Owner: Nadine Flores; due 2026-09-29.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_leases/002_leases_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/02_amendments/014_amendments_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/04_title_survey/026_title_survey_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/05_environmental/038_environmental_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/08_insurance/062_insurance_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/10_construction/074_construction_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/12_property_management/097_ivory_tower_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-059-03 — estoppel discrepancy (critical)\n\nthe permission is limited to New York County, New York under CB-RE-2909-R839; the matched activity occurred in New York under CB-RE-2909-E249. Identity resolves to ENT-059-1002, revision REV-2025.3 is current, and Rafael Okafor is active with capacity 3.\n\nAction: Create premises-period rows with valid notice and amendment lineage. Owner: Rafael Okafor; due 2026-09-28.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_leases/003_leases_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/02_amendments/015_amendments_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/04_title_survey/027_title_survey_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/05_environmental/039_environmental_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/08_insurance/063_insurance_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/07_operating_expenses/051_operating_expenses_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/12_property_management/097_ivory_tower_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-059-04 — permit closeout gap (medium)\n\nthe operative cap is $322,000.00 under CB-RE-2909-R602; the matched ledger population totals $349,602.00 under CB-RE-2909-E235. Identity resolves to ENT-059-1003, revision REV-2025.4 is current, and Mei Whitaker is active with capacity 6.\n\nAction: Create premises-period rows with valid notice and amendment lineage. Owner: Mei Whitaker; due 2026-09-27.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_leases/004_leases_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/02_amendments/016_amendments_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/04_title_survey/028_title_survey_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/05_environmental/040_environmental_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/08_insurance/064_insurance_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/11_financing/088_financing_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/12_property_management/097_ivory_tower_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-059-05 — lender SNDA omission (critical)\n\ndelivery must use notices-ivory_tower_software@example.test under CB-RE-2909-R172; the only matched receipt used archive-metropolitan_workspace_holdings@example.test under CB-RE-2909-E686. Identity resolves to ENT-059-1004, revision REV-2025.5 is current, and Theo Laurent is active with capacity 2.\n\nAction: Create premises-period rows with valid notice and amendment lineage. Owner: Theo Laurent; due 2026-09-26.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_leases/005_leases_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/03_estoppels/017_estoppels_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/04_title_survey/029_title_survey_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/041_zoning_permits_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/12_property_management/089_property_management_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/12_property_management/097_ivory_tower_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-059-09 — exclusive-use conflict (medium)\n\napproval must come from Leona Park under CB-RE-2909-R957; the effective approval record names Caleb Hassan under CB-RE-2909-E997. Identity resolves to ENT-059-1008, revision REV-2025.2 is current, and Micah Sullivan is active with capacity 6.\n\nAction: Create premises-period rows with valid notice and amendment lineage. Owner: Micah Sullivan; due 2026-09-22.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/02_amendments/009_amendments_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/03_estoppels/021_estoppels_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/05_environmental/033_environmental_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/045_zoning_permits_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/12_property_management/097_ivory_tower_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-059-10 — environmental recognized condition (high)\n\nthe controlled population contains 198 records under CB-RE-2909-R646; the certification covers 186 records under CB-RE-2909-E767. Identity resolves to ENT-059-1009, revision REV-2025.3 is current, and Nora Chen is active with capacity 5.\n\nAction: Create premises-period rows with valid notice and amendment lineage. Owner: Nora Chen; due 2026-09-30.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/02_amendments/010_amendments_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/03_estoppels/022_estoppels_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/05_environmental/034_environmental_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/046_zoning_permits_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/08_insurance/058_insurance_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/12_property_management/097_ivory_tower_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-059-11 — casualty restoration deadline (critical)\n\nthe permission is limited to New York County, New York under CB-RE-2909-R366; the matched activity occurred in New York under CB-RE-2909-E750. Identity resolves to ENT-059-1010, revision REV-2025.4 is current, and Caleb Hassan is active with capacity 5.\n\nAction: Create premises-period rows with valid notice and amendment lineage. Owner: Caleb Hassan; due 2026-09-29.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/02_amendments/011_amendments_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/03_estoppels/023_estoppels_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/05_environmental/035_environmental_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/047_zoning_permits_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/11_financing/083_financing_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/12_property_management/097_ivory_tower_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n## Evidence holds\n\n- **CBP-059-06 — assignment consent**: the operational record relies on a superseded control revision. Next evidence: an operational record using the current effective revision. Sources: `/workspace/documents/01_leases/006_leases_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/03_estoppels/018_estoppels_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/04_title_survey/030_title_survey_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/042_zoning_permits_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/12_property_management/097_ivory_tower_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-059-07 — zoning nonconformity**: two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key. Next evidence: an approved immutable entity crosswalk. Sources: `/workspace/documents/01_leases/007_leases_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/03_estoppels/019_estoppels_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/04_title_survey/031_title_survey_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/043_zoning_permits_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/10_construction/079_construction_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/12_property_management/097_ivory_tower_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-059-08 — construction lien notice**: the current observation does not meet the operative trigger. Next evidence: a current observation that satisfies the operative trigger. Sources: `/workspace/documents/01_leases/008_leases_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/03_estoppels/020_estoppels_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/04_title_survey/032_title_survey_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/044_zoning_permits_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/12_property_management/092_property_management_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/09_notices/068_notices_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/12_property_management/097_ivory_tower_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-059-12 — renewal-option notice**: the current observation does not meet the operative trigger. Next evidence: a current observation that satisfies the operative trigger. Sources: `/workspace/documents/02_amendments/012_amendments_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/03_estoppels/024_estoppels_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/05_environmental/036_environmental_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/048_zoning_permits_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/11_financing/084_financing_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/12_property_management/097_ivory_tower_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n## Alternatives considered\n\n- `ivory-tower:shortcut` — Use the sublease summary and obsolete notice instructions.: Use a plausible summary or one source without completing the controlling joins.\n- `ivory-tower:blanket-hold` — Freeze the entire matter population: Treat supported actions and genuinely ambiguous records as if they were equally unresolved.\n\n## Assumptions and limits\n\nThis decision is limited to cb100-059-ivory-tower, the supplied synthetic records, and the matter state as of 2026-10-01. Similar names, stale revisions, and pending authority are not treated as proof.\n", "decision": {"actions": [{"determination": "approval must come from Leona Park under CB-RE-2909-R352; the effective approval record names Henry Cho under CB-RE-2909-E432. Identity resolves to ENT-059-1000, revision REV-2025.1 is current, and Isaac Romero is active with capacity 5.", "due_date": "2026-09-30", "id": "ACT-CBP-059-01", "identity_id": "ENT-059-1000", "issue": "CAM reconciliation error", "owner": "Isaac Romero", "portfolio_key": "CBP-059-01", "recommended_action": "Create premises-period rows with valid notice and amendment lineage. Owner: Isaac Romero; due 2026-09-30.", "severity": "medium", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_leases/001_leases_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/02_amendments/013_amendments_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/04_title_survey/025_title_survey_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/05_environmental/037_environmental_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/07_operating_expenses/049_operating_expenses_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/11_financing/085_financing_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_property_management/097_ivory_tower_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "the controlled population contains 201 records under CB-RE-2909-R169; the certification covers 177 records under CB-RE-2909-E527. Identity resolves to ENT-059-1001, revision REV-2025.2 is current, and Nadine Flores is active with capacity 4.", "due_date": "2026-09-29", "id": "ACT-CBP-059-02", "identity_id": "ENT-059-1001", "issue": "security-deposit mismatch", "owner": "Nadine Flores", "portfolio_key": "CBP-059-02", "recommended_action": "Create premises-period rows with valid notice and amendment lineage. Owner: Nadine Flores; due 2026-09-29.", "severity": "low", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_leases/002_leases_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/02_amendments/014_amendments_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/04_title_survey/026_title_survey_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/05_environmental/038_environmental_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/08_insurance/062_insurance_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/10_construction/074_construction_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/12_property_management/097_ivory_tower_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "the permission is limited to New York County, New York under CB-RE-2909-R839; the matched activity occurred in New York under CB-RE-2909-E249. Identity resolves to ENT-059-1002, revision REV-2025.3 is current, and Rafael Okafor is active with capacity 3.", "due_date": "2026-09-28", "id": "ACT-CBP-059-03", "identity_id": "ENT-059-1002", "issue": "estoppel discrepancy", "owner": "Rafael Okafor", "portfolio_key": "CBP-059-03", "recommended_action": "Create premises-period rows with valid notice and amendment lineage. Owner: Rafael Okafor; due 2026-09-28.", "severity": "critical", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_leases/003_leases_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/02_amendments/015_amendments_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/04_title_survey/027_title_survey_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/05_environmental/039_environmental_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/08_insurance/063_insurance_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/07_operating_expenses/051_operating_expenses_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/12_property_management/097_ivory_tower_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "the operative cap is $322,000.00 under CB-RE-2909-R602; the matched ledger population totals $349,602.00 under CB-RE-2909-E235. Identity resolves to ENT-059-1003, revision REV-2025.4 is current, and Mei Whitaker is active with capacity 6.", "due_date": "2026-09-27", "id": "ACT-CBP-059-04", "identity_id": "ENT-059-1003", "issue": "permit closeout gap", "owner": "Mei Whitaker", "portfolio_key": "CBP-059-04", "recommended_action": "Create premises-period rows with valid notice and amendment lineage. Owner: Mei Whitaker; due 2026-09-27.", "severity": "medium", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_leases/004_leases_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/02_amendments/016_amendments_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/04_title_survey/028_title_survey_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/05_environmental/040_environmental_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/08_insurance/064_insurance_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/11_financing/088_financing_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_property_management/097_ivory_tower_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "delivery must use notices-ivory_tower_software@example.test under CB-RE-2909-R172; the only matched receipt used archive-metropolitan_workspace_holdings@example.test under CB-RE-2909-E686. Identity resolves to ENT-059-1004, revision REV-2025.5 is current, and Theo Laurent is active with capacity 2.", "due_date": "2026-09-26", "id": "ACT-CBP-059-05", "identity_id": "ENT-059-1004", "issue": "lender SNDA omission", "owner": "Theo Laurent", "portfolio_key": "CBP-059-05", "recommended_action": "Create premises-period rows with valid notice and amendment lineage. Owner: Theo Laurent; due 2026-09-26.", "severity": "critical", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_leases/005_leases_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/03_estoppels/017_estoppels_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/04_title_survey/029_title_survey_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/041_zoning_permits_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/12_property_management/089_property_management_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/12_property_management/097_ivory_tower_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "approval must come from Leona Park under CB-RE-2909-R957; the effective approval record names Caleb Hassan under CB-RE-2909-E997. Identity resolves to ENT-059-1008, revision REV-2025.2 is current, and Micah Sullivan is active with capacity 6.", "due_date": "2026-09-22", "id": "ACT-CBP-059-09", "identity_id": "ENT-059-1008", "issue": "exclusive-use conflict", "owner": "Micah Sullivan", "portfolio_key": "CBP-059-09", "recommended_action": "Create premises-period rows with valid notice and amendment lineage. Owner: Micah Sullivan; due 2026-09-22.", "severity": "medium", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_amendments/009_amendments_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/03_estoppels/021_estoppels_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/05_environmental/033_environmental_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/045_zoning_permits_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_property_management/097_ivory_tower_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "the controlled population contains 198 records under CB-RE-2909-R646; the certification covers 186 records under CB-RE-2909-E767. Identity resolves to ENT-059-1009, revision REV-2025.3 is current, and Nora Chen is active with capacity 5.", "due_date": "2026-09-30", "id": "ACT-CBP-059-10", "identity_id": "ENT-059-1009", "issue": "environmental recognized condition", "owner": "Nora Chen", "portfolio_key": "CBP-059-10", "recommended_action": "Create premises-period rows with valid notice and amendment lineage. Owner: Nora Chen; due 2026-09-30.", "severity": "high", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_amendments/010_amendments_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/03_estoppels/022_estoppels_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/05_environmental/034_environmental_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/046_zoning_permits_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/08_insurance/058_insurance_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/12_property_management/097_ivory_tower_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "the permission is limited to New York County, New York under CB-RE-2909-R366; the matched activity occurred in New York under CB-RE-2909-E750. Identity resolves to ENT-059-1010, revision REV-2025.4 is current, and Caleb Hassan is active with capacity 5.", "due_date": "2026-09-29", "id": "ACT-CBP-059-11", "identity_id": "ENT-059-1010", "issue": "casualty restoration deadline", "owner": "Caleb Hassan", "portfolio_key": "CBP-059-11", "recommended_action": "Create premises-period rows with valid notice and amendment lineage. Owner: Caleb Hassan; due 2026-09-29.", "severity": "critical", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_amendments/011_amendments_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/03_estoppels/023_estoppels_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/05_environmental/035_environmental_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/047_zoning_permits_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/11_financing/083_financing_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/12_property_management/097_ivory_tower_impact_population.xlsx"]}], "as_of": "2026-10-01", "decision": {"alternatives_considered": ["ivory-tower:shortcut", "ivory-tower:blanket-hold"], "question": "What consent, rent, restoration, and notice position governs the Ivory Tower sublease?", "rationale": "The four-part causal test supports 8 scoped actions and leaves 4 records on evidence hold. Consent and economic treatment follow the operative agreement chain and current notice clause.", "recommendation": "Apply supported consent and rent treatment and preserve surviving restoration duties.", "selected_option_id": "ivory-tower:scoped-evidence"}, "holds": [{"id": "HOLD-CBP-059-06", "issue": "assignment consent", "portfolio_key": "CBP-059-06", "reason": "the operational record relies on a superseded control revision", "required_next_evidence": "an operational record using the current effective revision", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_leases/006_leases_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/03_estoppels/018_estoppels_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/04_title_survey/030_title_survey_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/042_zoning_permits_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/12_property_management/097_ivory_tower_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-059-07", "issue": "zoning nonconformity", "portfolio_key": "CBP-059-07", "reason": "two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key", "required_next_evidence": "an approved immutable entity crosswalk", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_leases/007_leases_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/03_estoppels/019_estoppels_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/04_title_survey/031_title_survey_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/043_zoning_permits_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/10_construction/079_construction_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_property_management/097_ivory_tower_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-059-08", "issue": "construction lien notice", "portfolio_key": "CBP-059-08", "reason": "the current observation does not meet the operative trigger", "required_next_evidence": "a current observation that satisfies the operative trigger", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_leases/008_leases_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/03_estoppels/020_estoppels_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/04_title_survey/032_title_survey_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/044_zoning_permits_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/12_property_management/092_property_management_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/09_notices/068_notices_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/12_property_management/097_ivory_tower_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-059-12", "issue": "renewal-option notice", "portfolio_key": "CBP-059-12", "reason": "the current observation does not meet the operative trigger", "required_next_evidence": "a current observation that satisfies the operative trigger", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_amendments/012_amendments_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/03_estoppels/024_estoppels_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/05_environmental/036_environmental_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/048_zoning_permits_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/11_financing/084_financing_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/12_property_management/097_ivory_tower_impact_population.xlsx"]}], "matter_number": "CB-RE-2909", "prepared_for": "Ivory Tower Software", "schema_version": "counselbench.decision.v3", "task_id": "cb100-059-ivory-tower"}, "matter_register": {"matter_number": "CB-RE-2909", "rows": [{"decision_option_id": "ivory-tower:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-30", "issue": "CAM reconciliation error", "matter_number": "CB-RE-2909", "owner": "Isaac Romero", "portfolio_key": "CBP-059-01", "row_id": "REG-CBP-059-01", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_leases/001_leases_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/02_amendments/013_amendments_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/04_title_survey/025_title_survey_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/05_environmental/037_environmental_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/07_operating_expenses/049_operating_expenses_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/11_financing/085_financing_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_property_management/097_ivory_tower_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "ivory-tower:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-29", "issue": "security-deposit mismatch", "matter_number": "CB-RE-2909", "owner": "Nadine Flores", "portfolio_key": "CBP-059-02", "row_id": "REG-CBP-059-02", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_leases/002_leases_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/02_amendments/014_amendments_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/04_title_survey/026_title_survey_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/05_environmental/038_environmental_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/08_insurance/062_insurance_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/10_construction/074_construction_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/12_property_management/097_ivory_tower_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "ivory-tower:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-28", "issue": "estoppel discrepancy", "matter_number": "CB-RE-2909", "owner": "Rafael Okafor", "portfolio_key": "CBP-059-03", "row_id": "REG-CBP-059-03", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_leases/003_leases_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/02_amendments/015_amendments_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/04_title_survey/027_title_survey_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/05_environmental/039_environmental_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/08_insurance/063_insurance_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/07_operating_expenses/051_operating_expenses_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/12_property_management/097_ivory_tower_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "ivory-tower:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-27", "issue": "permit closeout gap", "matter_number": "CB-RE-2909", "owner": "Mei Whitaker", "portfolio_key": "CBP-059-04", "row_id": "REG-CBP-059-04", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_leases/004_leases_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/02_amendments/016_amendments_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/04_title_survey/028_title_survey_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/05_environmental/040_environmental_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/08_insurance/064_insurance_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/11_financing/088_financing_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_property_management/097_ivory_tower_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "ivory-tower:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-26", "issue": "lender SNDA omission", "matter_number": "CB-RE-2909", "owner": "Theo Laurent", "portfolio_key": "CBP-059-05", "row_id": "REG-CBP-059-05", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_leases/005_leases_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/03_estoppels/017_estoppels_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/04_title_survey/029_title_survey_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/041_zoning_permits_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/12_property_management/089_property_management_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/12_property_management/097_ivory_tower_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "ivory-tower:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "the operational record relies on a superseded control revision", "issue": "assignment consent", "matter_number": "CB-RE-2909", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-059-06", "row_id": "REG-CBP-059-06", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_leases/006_leases_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/03_estoppels/018_estoppels_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/04_title_survey/030_title_survey_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/042_zoning_permits_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/12_property_management/097_ivory_tower_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "ivory-tower:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key", "issue": "zoning nonconformity", "matter_number": "CB-RE-2909", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-059-07", "row_id": "REG-CBP-059-07", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_leases/007_leases_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/03_estoppels/019_estoppels_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/04_title_survey/031_title_survey_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/043_zoning_permits_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/10_construction/079_construction_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_property_management/097_ivory_tower_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "ivory-tower:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "the current observation does not meet the operative trigger", "issue": "construction lien notice", "matter_number": "CB-RE-2909", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-059-08", "row_id": "REG-CBP-059-08", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_leases/008_leases_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/03_estoppels/020_estoppels_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/04_title_survey/032_title_survey_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/044_zoning_permits_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/12_property_management/092_property_management_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/09_notices/068_notices_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/12_property_management/097_ivory_tower_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "ivory-tower:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-22", "issue": "exclusive-use conflict", "matter_number": "CB-RE-2909", "owner": "Micah Sullivan", "portfolio_key": "CBP-059-09", "row_id": "REG-CBP-059-09", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_amendments/009_amendments_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/03_estoppels/021_estoppels_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/05_environmental/033_environmental_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/045_zoning_permits_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_property_management/097_ivory_tower_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "ivory-tower:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-30", "issue": "environmental recognized condition", "matter_number": "CB-RE-2909", "owner": "Nora Chen", "portfolio_key": "CBP-059-10", "row_id": "REG-CBP-059-10", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_amendments/010_amendments_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/03_estoppels/022_estoppels_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/05_environmental/034_environmental_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/046_zoning_permits_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/08_insurance/058_insurance_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/12_property_management/097_ivory_tower_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "ivory-tower:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-29", "issue": "casualty restoration deadline", "matter_number": "CB-RE-2909", "owner": "Caleb Hassan", "portfolio_key": "CBP-059-11", "row_id": "REG-CBP-059-11", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_amendments/011_amendments_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/03_estoppels/023_estoppels_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/05_environmental/035_environmental_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/047_zoning_permits_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/11_financing/083_financing_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/12_property_management/097_ivory_tower_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "ivory-tower:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "the current observation does not meet the operative trigger", "issue": "renewal-option notice", "matter_number": "CB-RE-2909", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-059-12", "row_id": "REG-CBP-059-12", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_amendments/012_amendments_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/03_estoppels/024_estoppels_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/05_environmental/036_environmental_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/048_zoning_permits_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/11_financing/084_financing_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/12_property_management/097_ivory_tower_impact_population.xlsx"]}], "schema_version": "counselbench.matter-register.v3", "task_id": "cb100-059-ivory-tower"}}, "metadata": {"benchmark": "CounselBench-100", "code_license": "Apache-2.0", "data_license": "CC-BY-4.0", "deadline": "2026-10-01", "document_count": 97, "evidence_holds": 4, "jurisdiction": "New York", "matter_number": "CB-RE-2909", "mcp_commit": "9a96ea6e5913736f92b88345bf51caeaaa8e719f", "mcp_package": "@modelcontextprotocol/server-filesystem@2026.7.10", "practice_area": "real-estate", "reference_tool_calls": 87, "required_evidence_reads": 64, "supported_actions": 8, "synthetic": true, "venue": "New York County, New York", "version": "3.1.0"}, "prompt": "Please take ownership of the open question before the deadline. What consent, rent, restoration, and notice position governs the Ivory Tower sublease? A headquarters sublease has consent conditions, restoration obligations, rent abatements, and notices delivered under obsolete instructions. The team needs the call by 2026-10-01. Give me a decision-ready note and make the corresponding matter-register entries, without guessing through missing records.", "rubric": {"criteria": [{"category": "investigation", "description": "Inventory the production and use targeted searches to locate records across native formats.", "id": "investigation.discover_production"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Complete every task-specific identity, authority, operations, and approval read before the first state transition.", "id": "investigation.read_before_write"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Inspect designated source metadata before relying on those records.", "id": "investigation.custody_before_write"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "Select the supported option 'ivory-tower:scoped-evidence' after applying the four-part test.", "id": "decision.selected_option"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "Identify both rejected approaches and explain why a one-source shortcut and a blanket hold are wrong.", "id": "decision.alternatives"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-059-01 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_leases/001_leases_source_export.md rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-059-01.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_amendments/013_amendments_source_export.json for CAM reconciliation error.", "id": "investigation.CBP-059-01.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_title_survey/025_title_survey_source_export.md to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-059-01.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_environmental/037_environmental_source_export.json.", "id": "investigation.CBP-059-01.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-059-01 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-059-01.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-059-01 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-059-01.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-059-02 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_leases/002_leases_source_export.txt rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-059-02.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_amendments/014_amendments_source_export.xml for security-deposit mismatch.", "id": "investigation.CBP-059-02.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_title_survey/026_title_survey_source_export.txt to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-059-02.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_environmental/038_environmental_source_export.xml.", "id": "investigation.CBP-059-02.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-059-02 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-059-02.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-059-02 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-059-02.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-059-03 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_leases/003_leases_source_export.eml rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-059-03.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_amendments/015_amendments_source_export.html for estoppel discrepancy.", "id": "investigation.CBP-059-03.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_title_survey/027_title_survey_source_export.eml to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-059-03.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_environmental/039_environmental_source_export.html.", "id": "investigation.CBP-059-03.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-059-03 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-059-03.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-059-03 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-059-03.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-059-04 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_leases/004_leases_source_export.csv rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-059-04.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_amendments/016_amendments_source_export.pdf for permit closeout gap.", "id": "investigation.CBP-059-04.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_title_survey/028_title_survey_source_export.csv to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-059-04.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_environmental/040_environmental_source_export.pdf.", "id": "investigation.CBP-059-04.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-059-04 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-059-04.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-059-04 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-059-04.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-059-05 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_leases/005_leases_source_export.json rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-059-05.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_estoppels/017_estoppels_source_export.md for lender SNDA omission.", "id": "investigation.CBP-059-05.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_title_survey/029_title_survey_source_export.json to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-059-05.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/041_zoning_permits_source_export.md.", "id": "investigation.CBP-059-05.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-059-05 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-059-05.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-059-05 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-059-05.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-059-06 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_leases/006_leases_source_export.xml rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-059-06.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_estoppels/018_estoppels_source_export.txt for assignment consent.", "id": "investigation.CBP-059-06.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_title_survey/030_title_survey_source_export.xml to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-059-06.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/042_zoning_permits_source_export.txt.", "id": "investigation.CBP-059-06.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-059-06 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is the operational record relies on a superseded control revision.", "id": "decision.CBP-059-06.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-059-06 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-059-06.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-059-07 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_leases/007_leases_source_export.html rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-059-07.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_estoppels/019_estoppels_source_export.eml for zoning nonconformity.", "id": "investigation.CBP-059-07.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_title_survey/031_title_survey_source_export.html to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-059-07.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/043_zoning_permits_source_export.eml.", "id": "investigation.CBP-059-07.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-059-07 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key.", "id": "decision.CBP-059-07.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-059-07 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-059-07.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-059-08 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_leases/008_leases_source_export.pdf rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-059-08.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_estoppels/020_estoppels_source_export.csv for construction lien notice.", "id": "investigation.CBP-059-08.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_title_survey/032_title_survey_source_export.pdf to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-059-08.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/044_zoning_permits_source_export.csv.", "id": "investigation.CBP-059-08.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-059-08 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is the current observation does not meet the operative trigger.", "id": "decision.CBP-059-08.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-059-08 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-059-08.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-059-09 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_amendments/009_amendments_source_export.md rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-059-09.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_estoppels/021_estoppels_source_export.json for exclusive-use conflict.", "id": "investigation.CBP-059-09.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_environmental/033_environmental_source_export.md to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-059-09.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/045_zoning_permits_source_export.json.", "id": "investigation.CBP-059-09.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-059-09 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-059-09.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-059-09 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-059-09.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-059-10 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_amendments/010_amendments_source_export.txt rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-059-10.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_estoppels/022_estoppels_source_export.xml for environmental recognized condition.", "id": "investigation.CBP-059-10.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_environmental/034_environmental_source_export.txt to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-059-10.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/046_zoning_permits_source_export.xml.", "id": "investigation.CBP-059-10.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-059-10 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-059-10.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-059-10 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-059-10.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-059-11 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_amendments/011_amendments_source_export.eml rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-059-11.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_estoppels/023_estoppels_source_export.html for casualty restoration deadline.", "id": "investigation.CBP-059-11.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_environmental/035_environmental_source_export.eml to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-059-11.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/047_zoning_permits_source_export.html.", "id": "investigation.CBP-059-11.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-059-11 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-059-11.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-059-11 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-059-11.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-059-12 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_amendments/012_amendments_source_export.csv rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-059-12.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_estoppels/024_estoppels_source_export.pdf for renewal-option notice.", "id": "investigation.CBP-059-12.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_environmental/036_environmental_source_export.csv to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-059-12.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/048_zoning_permits_source_export.pdf.", "id": "investigation.CBP-059-12.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-059-12 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is the current observation does not meet the operative trigger.", "id": "decision.CBP-059-12.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-059-12 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-059-12.register"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Write the exact selected option, supported action population, evidence-hold population, facts, owners, deadlines, and citations.", "id": "state.exact_decision"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create one exact register row per portfolio key with no extra, missing, or modified row.", "id": "state.exact_register"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Leave only the three approved deliverables and perform no extra state-changing write.", "id": "state.write_scope_containment"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Read back decision.json, matter-register.json, and advice.md after their final writes.", "id": "state.postwrite_readback"}, {"category": "answer", "description": "Explain the selected recommendation, supported actions, holds, alternatives, and limitations with exact source anchors.", "id": "answer.decision_note"}], "decision_options": [{"approach": "Use a plausible summary or one source without completing the controlling joins.", "id": "ivory-tower:shortcut", "label": "Use the sublease summary and obsolete notice instructions."}, {"approach": "Treat supported actions and genuinely ambiguous records as if they were equally unresolved.", "id": "ivory-tower:blanket-hold", "label": "Freeze the entire matter population"}, {"approach": "Apply the exact identity, current-state, authority, and revision test. Create premises-period rows with valid notice and amendment lineage.", "id": "ivory-tower:scoped-evidence", "label": "Apply supported consent and rent treatment and preserve surviving restoration duties."}], "evaluation_narrative": {"authority": "Consent and economic treatment follow the operative agreement chain and current notice clause.", "observation": "Reconcile master lease, sublease, amendments, abatements, notices, and delivery evidence by premises and term.", "question": "What consent, rent, restoration, and notice position governs the Ivory Tower sublease?", "register_action": "Create premises-period rows with valid notice and amendment lineage."}, "gates": ["all_required_evidence_precedes_first_write", "decision_criteria_complete", "register_state_exact", "write_scope_contained", "all_outputs_verified_by_readback"], "metadata_checks": 10, "metric": "weighted_criteria_score", "minimum_tool_calls": 87, "required_deliverables": ["decision.json", "matter-register.json", "advice.md"], "required_document_reads": 64, "type": "deterministic", "weights": {"advice": 0.15, "decision": 0.35, "investigation": 0.25, "state": 0.25}}, "task_id": "cb100-059-ivory-tower", "task_name": "Ivory Tower office sublease reconciliation", "world_id": "counselbench-filesystem-mcp-v3"}
+{"context_files": ["task_files/cb100-060-kestrel-farms/01_leases/001_leases_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-060-kestrel-farms/01_leases/002_leases_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-060-kestrel-farms/01_leases/003_leases_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-060-kestrel-farms/01_leases/004_leases_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-060-kestrel-farms/01_leases/005_leases_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-060-kestrel-farms/01_leases/006_leases_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-060-kestrel-farms/01_leases/007_leases_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-060-kestrel-farms/01_leases/008_leases_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-060-kestrel-farms/02_amendments/009_amendments_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-060-kestrel-farms/02_amendments/010_amendments_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-060-kestrel-farms/02_amendments/011_amendments_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-060-kestrel-farms/02_amendments/012_amendments_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-060-kestrel-farms/02_amendments/013_amendments_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-060-kestrel-farms/02_amendments/014_amendments_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-060-kestrel-farms/02_amendments/015_amendments_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-060-kestrel-farms/02_amendments/016_amendments_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-060-kestrel-farms/03_estoppels/017_estoppels_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-060-kestrel-farms/03_estoppels/018_estoppels_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-060-kestrel-farms/03_estoppels/019_estoppels_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-060-kestrel-farms/03_estoppels/020_estoppels_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-060-kestrel-farms/03_estoppels/021_estoppels_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-060-kestrel-farms/03_estoppels/022_estoppels_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-060-kestrel-farms/03_estoppels/023_estoppels_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-060-kestrel-farms/03_estoppels/024_estoppels_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-060-kestrel-farms/04_title_survey/025_title_survey_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-060-kestrel-farms/04_title_survey/026_title_survey_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-060-kestrel-farms/04_title_survey/027_title_survey_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-060-kestrel-farms/04_title_survey/028_title_survey_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-060-kestrel-farms/04_title_survey/029_title_survey_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-060-kestrel-farms/04_title_survey/030_title_survey_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-060-kestrel-farms/04_title_survey/031_title_survey_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-060-kestrel-farms/04_title_survey/032_title_survey_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-060-kestrel-farms/05_environmental/033_environmental_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-060-kestrel-farms/05_environmental/034_environmental_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-060-kestrel-farms/05_environmental/035_environmental_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-060-kestrel-farms/05_environmental/036_environmental_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-060-kestrel-farms/05_environmental/037_environmental_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-060-kestrel-farms/05_environmental/038_environmental_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-060-kestrel-farms/05_environmental/039_environmental_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-060-kestrel-farms/05_environmental/040_environmental_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-060-kestrel-farms/06_zoning_permits/041_zoning_permits_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-060-kestrel-farms/06_zoning_permits/042_zoning_permits_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-060-kestrel-farms/06_zoning_permits/043_zoning_permits_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-060-kestrel-farms/06_zoning_permits/044_zoning_permits_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-060-kestrel-farms/06_zoning_permits/045_zoning_permits_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-060-kestrel-farms/06_zoning_permits/046_zoning_permits_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-060-kestrel-farms/06_zoning_permits/047_zoning_permits_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-060-kestrel-farms/06_zoning_permits/048_zoning_permits_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-060-kestrel-farms/07_operating_expenses/049_operating_expenses_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-060-kestrel-farms/07_operating_expenses/050_operating_expenses_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-060-kestrel-farms/07_operating_expenses/051_operating_expenses_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-060-kestrel-farms/07_operating_expenses/052_operating_expenses_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-060-kestrel-farms/07_operating_expenses/053_operating_expenses_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-060-kestrel-farms/07_operating_expenses/054_operating_expenses_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-060-kestrel-farms/07_operating_expenses/055_operating_expenses_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-060-kestrel-farms/07_operating_expenses/056_operating_expenses_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-060-kestrel-farms/08_insurance/057_insurance_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-060-kestrel-farms/08_insurance/058_insurance_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-060-kestrel-farms/08_insurance/059_insurance_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-060-kestrel-farms/08_insurance/060_insurance_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-060-kestrel-farms/08_insurance/061_insurance_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-060-kestrel-farms/08_insurance/062_insurance_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-060-kestrel-farms/08_insurance/063_insurance_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-060-kestrel-farms/08_insurance/064_insurance_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-060-kestrel-farms/09_notices/065_notices_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-060-kestrel-farms/09_notices/066_notices_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-060-kestrel-farms/09_notices/067_notices_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-060-kestrel-farms/09_notices/068_notices_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-060-kestrel-farms/09_notices/069_notices_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-060-kestrel-farms/09_notices/070_notices_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-060-kestrel-farms/09_notices/071_notices_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-060-kestrel-farms/09_notices/072_notices_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-060-kestrel-farms/10_construction/073_construction_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-060-kestrel-farms/10_construction/074_construction_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-060-kestrel-farms/10_construction/075_construction_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-060-kestrel-farms/10_construction/076_construction_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-060-kestrel-farms/10_construction/077_construction_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-060-kestrel-farms/10_construction/078_construction_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-060-kestrel-farms/10_construction/079_construction_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-060-kestrel-farms/10_construction/080_construction_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-060-kestrel-farms/11_financing/081_financing_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-060-kestrel-farms/11_financing/082_financing_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-060-kestrel-farms/11_financing/083_financing_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-060-kestrel-farms/11_financing/084_financing_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-060-kestrel-farms/11_financing/085_financing_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-060-kestrel-farms/11_financing/086_financing_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-060-kestrel-farms/11_financing/087_financing_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-060-kestrel-farms/11_financing/088_financing_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-060-kestrel-farms/12_property_management/089_property_management_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-060-kestrel-farms/12_property_management/090_property_management_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-060-kestrel-farms/12_property_management/091_property_management_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-060-kestrel-farms/12_property_management/092_property_management_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-060-kestrel-farms/12_property_management/093_property_management_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-060-kestrel-farms/12_property_management/094_property_management_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-060-kestrel-farms/12_property_management/095_property_management_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-060-kestrel-farms/12_property_management/096_property_management_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-060-kestrel-farms/12_property_management/097_kestrel_farms_impact_population.xlsx"], "gold_output": {"advice_markdown": "# Decision note — Kestrel agricultural land portfolio audit\n\n## Recommendation\n\nCorrect supported covenant or collateral exceptions by exact parcel. The reconciled record supports 5 scoped actions and leaves 7 items on evidence hold.\n\nSelected option: `kestrel-farms:scoped-evidence`.\n\n## Why this is the supported option\n\nJoin parcel IDs, water rights, easements, crop leases, coverage, and covenant tests. Recorded property rights and applicable loan covenants govern each parcel independently.\n\n## Supported actions\n\n### CBP-060-03 — survey encroachment (high)\n\nthe controlling threshold is 8% under CB-RE-2910-R231; the independently calculated result is 15% under CB-RE-2910-E107. Identity resolves to ENT-060-1002, revision REV-2026.3 is current, and Priya Raman is active with capacity 6.\n\nAction: Create parcel-right rows and quarantine legal-description mismatches. Owner: Priya Raman; due 2026-10-02.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_leases/003_leases_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/02_amendments/015_amendments_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/04_title_survey/027_title_survey_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/05_environmental/039_environmental_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/10_construction/075_construction_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/08_insurance/063_insurance_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/12_property_management/097_kestrel_farms_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-060-05 — security-deposit mismatch (critical)\n\nthe controlled population contains 229 records under CB-RE-2910-R467; the certification covers 197 records under CB-RE-2910-E439. Identity resolves to ENT-060-1004, revision REV-2026.5 is current, and Nadine Flores is active with capacity 6.\n\nAction: Create parcel-right rows and quarantine legal-description mismatches. Owner: Nadine Flores; due 2026-09-30.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_leases/005_leases_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/03_estoppels/017_estoppels_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/04_title_survey/029_title_survey_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/041_zoning_permits_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/09_notices/065_notices_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/12_property_management/097_kestrel_farms_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-060-07 — permit closeout gap (high)\n\nthe operative cap is $4,882,000.00 under CB-RE-2910-R764; the matched ledger population totals $5,076,864.00 under CB-RE-2910-E615. Identity resolves to ENT-060-1006, revision REV-2026.7 is current, and Mei Whitaker is active with capacity 4.\n\nAction: Create parcel-right rows and quarantine legal-description mismatches. Owner: Mei Whitaker; due 2026-09-28.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_leases/007_leases_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/03_estoppels/019_estoppels_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/04_title_survey/031_title_survey_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/043_zoning_permits_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/09_notices/067_notices_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/12_property_management/097_kestrel_farms_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-060-09 — assignment consent (critical)\n\nan open exception blocks completion under CB-RE-2910-R191; the current status is open and unresolved under CB-RE-2910-E740. Identity resolves to ENT-060-1008, revision REV-2026.2 is current, and Lena Varga is active with capacity 2.\n\nAction: Create parcel-right rows and quarantine legal-description mismatches. Owner: Lena Varga; due 2026-09-26.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/02_amendments/009_amendments_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/03_estoppels/021_estoppels_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/05_environmental/033_environmental_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/045_zoning_permits_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/09_notices/069_notices_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/12_property_management/097_kestrel_farms_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-060-11 — construction lien notice (low)\n\nthe controlling threshold is 5% under CB-RE-2910-R514; the independently calculated result is 9% under CB-RE-2910-E124. Identity resolves to ENT-060-1010, revision REV-2026.4 is current, and Sofia Bennett is active with capacity 4.\n\nAction: Create parcel-right rows and quarantine legal-description mismatches. Owner: Sofia Bennett; due 2026-10-03.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/02_amendments/011_amendments_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/03_estoppels/023_estoppels_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/05_environmental/035_environmental_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/047_zoning_permits_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/08_insurance/059_insurance_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/12_property_management/097_kestrel_farms_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n## Evidence holds\n\n- **CBP-060-01 — insurance endorsement deficiency**: the operational record relies on a superseded control revision. Next evidence: an operational record using the current effective revision. Sources: `/workspace/documents/01_leases/001_leases_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/02_amendments/013_amendments_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/04_title_survey/025_title_survey_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/05_environmental/037_environmental_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/07_operating_expenses/049_operating_expenses_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/08_insurance/061_insurance_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/12_property_management/097_kestrel_farms_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-060-02 — rent schedule inconsistency**: two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key. Next evidence: an approved immutable entity crosswalk. Sources: `/workspace/documents/01_leases/002_leases_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/02_amendments/014_amendments_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/04_title_survey/026_title_survey_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/05_environmental/038_environmental_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/12_property_management/097_kestrel_farms_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-060-04 — CAM reconciliation error**: the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective. Next evidence: effective approval and an active owner with remaining capacity. Sources: `/workspace/documents/01_leases/004_leases_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/02_amendments/016_amendments_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/04_title_survey/028_title_survey_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/05_environmental/040_environmental_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/11_financing/088_financing_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/07_operating_expenses/052_operating_expenses_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/12_property_management/097_kestrel_farms_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-060-06 — estoppel discrepancy**: two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key. Next evidence: an approved immutable entity crosswalk. Sources: `/workspace/documents/01_leases/006_leases_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/03_estoppels/018_estoppels_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/04_title_survey/030_title_survey_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/042_zoning_permits_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/12_property_management/097_kestrel_farms_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-060-08 — lender SNDA omission**: the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective. Next evidence: effective approval and an active owner with remaining capacity. Sources: `/workspace/documents/01_leases/008_leases_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/03_estoppels/020_estoppels_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/04_title_survey/032_title_survey_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/044_zoning_permits_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/12_property_management/097_kestrel_farms_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-060-10 — zoning nonconformity**: two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key. Next evidence: an approved immutable entity crosswalk. Sources: `/workspace/documents/02_amendments/010_amendments_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/03_estoppels/022_estoppels_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/05_environmental/034_environmental_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/046_zoning_permits_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/11_financing/082_financing_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/12_property_management/097_kestrel_farms_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-060-12 — exclusive-use conflict**: the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective. Next evidence: effective approval and an active owner with remaining capacity. Sources: `/workspace/documents/02_amendments/012_amendments_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/03_estoppels/024_estoppels_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/05_environmental/036_environmental_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/048_zoning_permits_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/12_property_management/096_property_management_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/11_financing/084_financing_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/12_property_management/097_kestrel_farms_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n## Alternatives considered\n\n- `kestrel-farms:blanket-hold` — Freeze the entire matter population: Treat supported actions and genuinely ambiguous records as if they were equally unresolved.\n- `kestrel-farms:shortcut` — Treat portfolio-wide insurance and access as covering every parcel.: Use a plausible summary or one source without completing the controlling joins.\n\n## Assumptions and limits\n\nThis decision is limited to cb100-060-kestrel-farms, the supplied synthetic records, and the matter state as of 2026-10-05. Similar names, stale revisions, and pending authority are not treated as proof.\n", "decision": {"actions": [{"determination": "the controlling threshold is 8% under CB-RE-2910-R231; the independently calculated result is 15% under CB-RE-2910-E107. Identity resolves to ENT-060-1002, revision REV-2026.3 is current, and Priya Raman is active with capacity 6.", "due_date": "2026-10-02", "id": "ACT-CBP-060-03", "identity_id": "ENT-060-1002", "issue": "survey encroachment", "owner": "Priya Raman", "portfolio_key": "CBP-060-03", "recommended_action": "Create parcel-right rows and quarantine legal-description mismatches. Owner: Priya Raman; due 2026-10-02.", "severity": "high", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_leases/003_leases_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/02_amendments/015_amendments_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/04_title_survey/027_title_survey_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/05_environmental/039_environmental_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/10_construction/075_construction_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/08_insurance/063_insurance_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_property_management/097_kestrel_farms_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "the controlled population contains 229 records under CB-RE-2910-R467; the certification covers 197 records under CB-RE-2910-E439. Identity resolves to ENT-060-1004, revision REV-2026.5 is current, and Nadine Flores is active with capacity 6.", "due_date": "2026-09-30", "id": "ACT-CBP-060-05", "identity_id": "ENT-060-1004", "issue": "security-deposit mismatch", "owner": "Nadine Flores", "portfolio_key": "CBP-060-05", "recommended_action": "Create parcel-right rows and quarantine legal-description mismatches. Owner: Nadine Flores; due 2026-09-30.", "severity": "critical", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_leases/005_leases_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/03_estoppels/017_estoppels_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/04_title_survey/029_title_survey_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/041_zoning_permits_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/09_notices/065_notices_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/12_property_management/097_kestrel_farms_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "the operative cap is $4,882,000.00 under CB-RE-2910-R764; the matched ledger population totals $5,076,864.00 under CB-RE-2910-E615. Identity resolves to ENT-060-1006, revision REV-2026.7 is current, and Mei Whitaker is active with capacity 4.", "due_date": "2026-09-28", "id": "ACT-CBP-060-07", "identity_id": "ENT-060-1006", "issue": "permit closeout gap", "owner": "Mei Whitaker", "portfolio_key": "CBP-060-07", "recommended_action": "Create parcel-right rows and quarantine legal-description mismatches. Owner: Mei Whitaker; due 2026-09-28.", "severity": "high", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_leases/007_leases_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/03_estoppels/019_estoppels_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/04_title_survey/031_title_survey_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/043_zoning_permits_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/09_notices/067_notices_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/12_property_management/097_kestrel_farms_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "an open exception blocks completion under CB-RE-2910-R191; the current status is open and unresolved under CB-RE-2910-E740. Identity resolves to ENT-060-1008, revision REV-2026.2 is current, and Lena Varga is active with capacity 2.", "due_date": "2026-09-26", "id": "ACT-CBP-060-09", "identity_id": "ENT-060-1008", "issue": "assignment consent", "owner": "Lena Varga", "portfolio_key": "CBP-060-09", "recommended_action": "Create parcel-right rows and quarantine legal-description mismatches. Owner: Lena Varga; due 2026-09-26.", "severity": "critical", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_amendments/009_amendments_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/03_estoppels/021_estoppels_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/05_environmental/033_environmental_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/045_zoning_permits_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/09_notices/069_notices_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_property_management/097_kestrel_farms_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "the controlling threshold is 5% under CB-RE-2910-R514; the independently calculated result is 9% under CB-RE-2910-E124. Identity resolves to ENT-060-1010, revision REV-2026.4 is current, and Sofia Bennett is active with capacity 4.", "due_date": "2026-10-03", "id": "ACT-CBP-060-11", "identity_id": "ENT-060-1010", "issue": "construction lien notice", "owner": "Sofia Bennett", "portfolio_key": "CBP-060-11", "recommended_action": "Create parcel-right rows and quarantine legal-description mismatches. Owner: Sofia Bennett; due 2026-10-03.", "severity": "low", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_amendments/011_amendments_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/03_estoppels/023_estoppels_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/05_environmental/035_environmental_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/047_zoning_permits_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/08_insurance/059_insurance_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/12_property_management/097_kestrel_farms_impact_population.xlsx"]}], "as_of": "2026-10-05", "decision": {"alternatives_considered": ["kestrel-farms:blanket-hold", "kestrel-farms:shortcut"], "question": "Which parcel-level water, access, crop, and insurance issues affect Kestrel's loan compliance?", "rationale": "The four-part causal test supports 5 scoped actions and leaves 7 records on evidence hold. Recorded property rights and applicable loan covenants govern each parcel independently.", "recommendation": "Correct supported covenant or collateral exceptions by exact parcel.", "selected_option_id": "kestrel-farms:scoped-evidence"}, "holds": [{"id": "HOLD-CBP-060-01", "issue": "insurance endorsement deficiency", "portfolio_key": "CBP-060-01", "reason": "the operational record relies on a superseded control revision", "required_next_evidence": "an operational record using the current effective revision", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_leases/001_leases_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/02_amendments/013_amendments_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/04_title_survey/025_title_survey_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/05_environmental/037_environmental_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/07_operating_expenses/049_operating_expenses_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/08_insurance/061_insurance_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_property_management/097_kestrel_farms_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-060-02", "issue": "rent schedule inconsistency", "portfolio_key": "CBP-060-02", "reason": "two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key", "required_next_evidence": "an approved immutable entity crosswalk", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_leases/002_leases_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/02_amendments/014_amendments_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/04_title_survey/026_title_survey_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/05_environmental/038_environmental_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_property_management/097_kestrel_farms_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-060-04", "issue": "CAM reconciliation error", "portfolio_key": "CBP-060-04", "reason": "the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective", "required_next_evidence": "effective approval and an active owner with remaining capacity", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_leases/004_leases_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/02_amendments/016_amendments_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/04_title_survey/028_title_survey_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/05_environmental/040_environmental_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/11_financing/088_financing_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/07_operating_expenses/052_operating_expenses_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/12_property_management/097_kestrel_farms_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-060-06", "issue": "estoppel discrepancy", "portfolio_key": "CBP-060-06", "reason": "two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key", "required_next_evidence": "an approved immutable entity crosswalk", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_leases/006_leases_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/03_estoppels/018_estoppels_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/04_title_survey/030_title_survey_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/042_zoning_permits_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/12_property_management/097_kestrel_farms_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-060-08", "issue": "lender SNDA omission", "portfolio_key": "CBP-060-08", "reason": "the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective", "required_next_evidence": "effective approval and an active owner with remaining capacity", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_leases/008_leases_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/03_estoppels/020_estoppels_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/04_title_survey/032_title_survey_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/044_zoning_permits_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/12_property_management/097_kestrel_farms_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-060-10", "issue": "zoning nonconformity", "portfolio_key": "CBP-060-10", "reason": "two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key", "required_next_evidence": "an approved immutable entity crosswalk", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_amendments/010_amendments_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/03_estoppels/022_estoppels_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/05_environmental/034_environmental_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/046_zoning_permits_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/11_financing/082_financing_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/12_property_management/097_kestrel_farms_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-060-12", "issue": "exclusive-use conflict", "portfolio_key": "CBP-060-12", "reason": "the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective", "required_next_evidence": "effective approval and an active owner with remaining capacity", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_amendments/012_amendments_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/03_estoppels/024_estoppels_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/05_environmental/036_environmental_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/048_zoning_permits_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_property_management/096_property_management_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/11_financing/084_financing_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/12_property_management/097_kestrel_farms_impact_population.xlsx"]}], "matter_number": "CB-RE-2910", "prepared_for": "Kestrel Farms Cooperative", "schema_version": "counselbench.decision.v3", "task_id": "cb100-060-kestrel-farms"}, "matter_register": {"matter_number": "CB-RE-2910", "rows": [{"decision_option_id": "kestrel-farms:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "the operational record relies on a superseded control revision", "issue": "insurance endorsement deficiency", "matter_number": "CB-RE-2910", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-060-01", "row_id": "REG-CBP-060-01", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_leases/001_leases_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/02_amendments/013_amendments_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/04_title_survey/025_title_survey_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/05_environmental/037_environmental_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/07_operating_expenses/049_operating_expenses_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/08_insurance/061_insurance_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_property_management/097_kestrel_farms_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "kestrel-farms:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key", "issue": "rent schedule inconsistency", "matter_number": "CB-RE-2910", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-060-02", "row_id": "REG-CBP-060-02", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_leases/002_leases_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/02_amendments/014_amendments_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/04_title_survey/026_title_survey_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/05_environmental/038_environmental_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_property_management/097_kestrel_farms_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "kestrel-farms:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-10-02", "issue": "survey encroachment", "matter_number": "CB-RE-2910", "owner": "Priya Raman", "portfolio_key": "CBP-060-03", "row_id": "REG-CBP-060-03", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_leases/003_leases_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/02_amendments/015_amendments_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/04_title_survey/027_title_survey_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/05_environmental/039_environmental_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/10_construction/075_construction_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/08_insurance/063_insurance_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_property_management/097_kestrel_farms_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "kestrel-farms:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective", "issue": "CAM reconciliation error", "matter_number": "CB-RE-2910", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-060-04", "row_id": "REG-CBP-060-04", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_leases/004_leases_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/02_amendments/016_amendments_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/04_title_survey/028_title_survey_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/05_environmental/040_environmental_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/11_financing/088_financing_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/07_operating_expenses/052_operating_expenses_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/12_property_management/097_kestrel_farms_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "kestrel-farms:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-30", "issue": "security-deposit mismatch", "matter_number": "CB-RE-2910", "owner": "Nadine Flores", "portfolio_key": "CBP-060-05", "row_id": "REG-CBP-060-05", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_leases/005_leases_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/03_estoppels/017_estoppels_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/04_title_survey/029_title_survey_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/041_zoning_permits_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/09_notices/065_notices_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/12_property_management/097_kestrel_farms_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "kestrel-farms:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key", "issue": "estoppel discrepancy", "matter_number": "CB-RE-2910", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-060-06", "row_id": "REG-CBP-060-06", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_leases/006_leases_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/03_estoppels/018_estoppels_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/04_title_survey/030_title_survey_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/042_zoning_permits_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/12_property_management/097_kestrel_farms_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "kestrel-farms:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-28", "issue": "permit closeout gap", "matter_number": "CB-RE-2910", "owner": "Mei Whitaker", "portfolio_key": "CBP-060-07", "row_id": "REG-CBP-060-07", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_leases/007_leases_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/03_estoppels/019_estoppels_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/04_title_survey/031_title_survey_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/043_zoning_permits_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/09_notices/067_notices_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/12_property_management/097_kestrel_farms_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "kestrel-farms:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective", "issue": "lender SNDA omission", "matter_number": "CB-RE-2910", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-060-08", "row_id": "REG-CBP-060-08", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_leases/008_leases_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/03_estoppels/020_estoppels_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/04_title_survey/032_title_survey_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/044_zoning_permits_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/12_property_management/097_kestrel_farms_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "kestrel-farms:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-26", "issue": "assignment consent", "matter_number": "CB-RE-2910", "owner": "Lena Varga", "portfolio_key": "CBP-060-09", "row_id": "REG-CBP-060-09", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_amendments/009_amendments_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/03_estoppels/021_estoppels_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/05_environmental/033_environmental_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/045_zoning_permits_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/09_notices/069_notices_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_property_management/097_kestrel_farms_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "kestrel-farms:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key", "issue": "zoning nonconformity", "matter_number": "CB-RE-2910", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-060-10", "row_id": "REG-CBP-060-10", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_amendments/010_amendments_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/03_estoppels/022_estoppels_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/05_environmental/034_environmental_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/046_zoning_permits_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/11_financing/082_financing_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/12_property_management/097_kestrel_farms_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "kestrel-farms:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-10-03", "issue": "construction lien notice", "matter_number": "CB-RE-2910", "owner": "Sofia Bennett", "portfolio_key": "CBP-060-11", "row_id": "REG-CBP-060-11", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_amendments/011_amendments_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/03_estoppels/023_estoppels_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/05_environmental/035_environmental_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/047_zoning_permits_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/08_insurance/059_insurance_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/12_property_management/097_kestrel_farms_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "kestrel-farms:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective", "issue": "exclusive-use conflict", "matter_number": "CB-RE-2910", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-060-12", "row_id": "REG-CBP-060-12", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_amendments/012_amendments_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/03_estoppels/024_estoppels_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/05_environmental/036_environmental_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/048_zoning_permits_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_property_management/096_property_management_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/11_financing/084_financing_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/12_property_management/097_kestrel_farms_impact_population.xlsx"]}], "schema_version": "counselbench.matter-register.v3", "task_id": "cb100-060-kestrel-farms"}}, "metadata": {"benchmark": "CounselBench-100", "code_license": "Apache-2.0", "data_license": "CC-BY-4.0", "deadline": "2026-10-05", "document_count": 97, "evidence_holds": 7, "jurisdiction": "Washington", "matter_number": "CB-RE-2910", "mcp_commit": "9a96ea6e5913736f92b88345bf51caeaaa8e719f", "mcp_package": "@modelcontextprotocol/server-filesystem@2026.7.10", "practice_area": "real-estate", "reference_tool_calls": 87, "required_evidence_reads": 63, "supported_actions": 5, "synthetic": true, "venue": "Yakima County, Washington", "version": "3.1.0"}, "prompt": "I need to know what is proven, what we can do about it, and what is still only an evidence gap. Which parcel-level water, access, crop, and insurance issues affect Kestrel's loan compliance? Irrigated parcels carry water-right questions, access encroachments, crop leases, and insurance records inconsistent with loan covenants. The team needs the call by 2026-10-05. Capture the supported action and the remaining holds so the next reviewer can reproduce the call.", "rubric": {"criteria": [{"category": "investigation", "description": "Inventory the production and use targeted searches to locate records across native formats.", "id": "investigation.discover_production"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Complete every task-specific identity, authority, operations, and approval read before the first state transition.", "id": "investigation.read_before_write"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Inspect designated source metadata before relying on those records.", "id": "investigation.custody_before_write"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "Select the supported option 'kestrel-farms:scoped-evidence' after applying the four-part test.", "id": "decision.selected_option"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "Identify both rejected approaches and explain why a one-source shortcut and a blanket hold are wrong.", "id": "decision.alternatives"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-060-01 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_leases/001_leases_source_export.md rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-060-01.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_amendments/013_amendments_source_export.json for insurance endorsement deficiency.", "id": "investigation.CBP-060-01.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_title_survey/025_title_survey_source_export.md to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-060-01.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_environmental/037_environmental_source_export.json.", "id": "investigation.CBP-060-01.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-060-01 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is the operational record relies on a superseded control revision.", "id": "decision.CBP-060-01.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-060-01 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-060-01.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-060-02 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_leases/002_leases_source_export.txt rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-060-02.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_amendments/014_amendments_source_export.xml for rent schedule inconsistency.", "id": "investigation.CBP-060-02.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_title_survey/026_title_survey_source_export.txt to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-060-02.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_environmental/038_environmental_source_export.xml.", "id": "investigation.CBP-060-02.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-060-02 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key.", "id": "decision.CBP-060-02.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-060-02 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-060-02.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-060-03 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_leases/003_leases_source_export.eml rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-060-03.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_amendments/015_amendments_source_export.html for survey encroachment.", "id": "investigation.CBP-060-03.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_title_survey/027_title_survey_source_export.eml to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-060-03.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_environmental/039_environmental_source_export.html.", "id": "investigation.CBP-060-03.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-060-03 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-060-03.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-060-03 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-060-03.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-060-04 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_leases/004_leases_source_export.csv rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-060-04.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_amendments/016_amendments_source_export.pdf for CAM reconciliation error.", "id": "investigation.CBP-060-04.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_title_survey/028_title_survey_source_export.csv to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-060-04.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_environmental/040_environmental_source_export.pdf.", "id": "investigation.CBP-060-04.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-060-04 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective.", "id": "decision.CBP-060-04.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-060-04 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-060-04.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-060-05 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_leases/005_leases_source_export.json rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-060-05.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_estoppels/017_estoppels_source_export.md for security-deposit mismatch.", "id": "investigation.CBP-060-05.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_title_survey/029_title_survey_source_export.json to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-060-05.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/041_zoning_permits_source_export.md.", "id": "investigation.CBP-060-05.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-060-05 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-060-05.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-060-05 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-060-05.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-060-06 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_leases/006_leases_source_export.xml rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-060-06.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_estoppels/018_estoppels_source_export.txt for estoppel discrepancy.", "id": "investigation.CBP-060-06.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_title_survey/030_title_survey_source_export.xml to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-060-06.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/042_zoning_permits_source_export.txt.", "id": "investigation.CBP-060-06.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-060-06 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key.", "id": "decision.CBP-060-06.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-060-06 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-060-06.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-060-07 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_leases/007_leases_source_export.html rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-060-07.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_estoppels/019_estoppels_source_export.eml for permit closeout gap.", "id": "investigation.CBP-060-07.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_title_survey/031_title_survey_source_export.html to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-060-07.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/043_zoning_permits_source_export.eml.", "id": "investigation.CBP-060-07.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-060-07 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-060-07.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-060-07 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-060-07.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-060-08 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_leases/008_leases_source_export.pdf rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-060-08.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_estoppels/020_estoppels_source_export.csv for lender SNDA omission.", "id": "investigation.CBP-060-08.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_title_survey/032_title_survey_source_export.pdf to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-060-08.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/044_zoning_permits_source_export.csv.", "id": "investigation.CBP-060-08.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-060-08 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective.", "id": "decision.CBP-060-08.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-060-08 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-060-08.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-060-09 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_amendments/009_amendments_source_export.md rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-060-09.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_estoppels/021_estoppels_source_export.json for assignment consent.", "id": "investigation.CBP-060-09.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_environmental/033_environmental_source_export.md to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-060-09.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/045_zoning_permits_source_export.json.", "id": "investigation.CBP-060-09.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-060-09 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-060-09.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-060-09 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-060-09.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-060-10 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_amendments/010_amendments_source_export.txt rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-060-10.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_estoppels/022_estoppels_source_export.xml for zoning nonconformity.", "id": "investigation.CBP-060-10.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_environmental/034_environmental_source_export.txt to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-060-10.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/046_zoning_permits_source_export.xml.", "id": "investigation.CBP-060-10.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-060-10 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key.", "id": "decision.CBP-060-10.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-060-10 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-060-10.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-060-11 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_amendments/011_amendments_source_export.eml rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-060-11.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_estoppels/023_estoppels_source_export.html for construction lien notice.", "id": "investigation.CBP-060-11.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_environmental/035_environmental_source_export.eml to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-060-11.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/047_zoning_permits_source_export.html.", "id": "investigation.CBP-060-11.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-060-11 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-060-11.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-060-11 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-060-11.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-060-12 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_amendments/012_amendments_source_export.csv rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-060-12.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_estoppels/024_estoppels_source_export.pdf for exclusive-use conflict.", "id": "investigation.CBP-060-12.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_environmental/036_environmental_source_export.csv to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-060-12.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_zoning_permits/048_zoning_permits_source_export.pdf.", "id": "investigation.CBP-060-12.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-060-12 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective.", "id": "decision.CBP-060-12.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-060-12 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-060-12.register"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Write the exact selected option, supported action population, evidence-hold population, facts, owners, deadlines, and citations.", "id": "state.exact_decision"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create one exact register row per portfolio key with no extra, missing, or modified row.", "id": "state.exact_register"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Leave only the three approved deliverables and perform no extra state-changing write.", "id": "state.write_scope_containment"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Read back decision.json, matter-register.json, and advice.md after their final writes.", "id": "state.postwrite_readback"}, {"category": "answer", "description": "Explain the selected recommendation, supported actions, holds, alternatives, and limitations with exact source anchors.", "id": "answer.decision_note"}], "decision_options": [{"approach": "Treat supported actions and genuinely ambiguous records as if they were equally unresolved.", "id": "kestrel-farms:blanket-hold", "label": "Freeze the entire matter population"}, {"approach": "Apply the exact identity, current-state, authority, and revision test. Create parcel-right rows and quarantine legal-description mismatches.", "id": "kestrel-farms:scoped-evidence", "label": "Correct supported covenant or collateral exceptions by exact parcel."}, {"approach": "Use a plausible summary or one source without completing the controlling joins.", "id": "kestrel-farms:shortcut", "label": "Treat portfolio-wide insurance and access as covering every parcel."}], "evaluation_narrative": {"authority": "Recorded property rights and applicable loan covenants govern each parcel independently.", "observation": "Join parcel IDs, water rights, easements, crop leases, coverage, and covenant tests.", "question": "Which parcel-level water, access, crop, and insurance issues affect Kestrel's loan compliance?", "register_action": "Create parcel-right rows and quarantine legal-description mismatches."}, "gates": ["all_required_evidence_precedes_first_write", "decision_criteria_complete", "register_state_exact", "write_scope_contained", "all_outputs_verified_by_readback"], "metadata_checks": 10, "metric": "weighted_criteria_score", "minimum_tool_calls": 87, "required_deliverables": ["decision.json", "matter-register.json", "advice.md"], "required_document_reads": 63, "type": "deterministic", "weights": {"advice": 0.15, "decision": 0.35, "investigation": 0.25, "state": 0.25}}, "task_id": "cb100-060-kestrel-farms", "task_name": "Kestrel agricultural land portfolio audit", "world_id": "counselbench-filesystem-mcp-v3"}
+{"context_files": ["task_files/cb100-061-arcadia-genomics/01_data_inventory/001_data_inventory_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-061-arcadia-genomics/01_data_inventory/002_data_inventory_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-061-arcadia-genomics/01_data_inventory/003_data_inventory_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-061-arcadia-genomics/01_data_inventory/004_data_inventory_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-061-arcadia-genomics/01_data_inventory/005_data_inventory_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-061-arcadia-genomics/01_data_inventory/006_data_inventory_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-061-arcadia-genomics/01_data_inventory/007_data_inventory_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-061-arcadia-genomics/01_data_inventory/008_data_inventory_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-061-arcadia-genomics/02_processing_records/009_processing_records_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-061-arcadia-genomics/02_processing_records/010_processing_records_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-061-arcadia-genomics/02_processing_records/011_processing_records_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-061-arcadia-genomics/02_processing_records/012_processing_records_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-061-arcadia-genomics/02_processing_records/013_processing_records_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-061-arcadia-genomics/02_processing_records/014_processing_records_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-061-arcadia-genomics/02_processing_records/015_processing_records_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-061-arcadia-genomics/02_processing_records/016_processing_records_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-061-arcadia-genomics/03_vendor_reviews/017_vendor_reviews_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-061-arcadia-genomics/03_vendor_reviews/018_vendor_reviews_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-061-arcadia-genomics/03_vendor_reviews/019_vendor_reviews_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-061-arcadia-genomics/03_vendor_reviews/020_vendor_reviews_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-061-arcadia-genomics/03_vendor_reviews/021_vendor_reviews_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-061-arcadia-genomics/03_vendor_reviews/022_vendor_reviews_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-061-arcadia-genomics/03_vendor_reviews/023_vendor_reviews_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-061-arcadia-genomics/03_vendor_reviews/024_vendor_reviews_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-061-arcadia-genomics/04_security_incidents/025_security_incidents_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-061-arcadia-genomics/04_security_incidents/026_security_incidents_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-061-arcadia-genomics/04_security_incidents/027_security_incidents_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-061-arcadia-genomics/04_security_incidents/028_security_incidents_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-061-arcadia-genomics/04_security_incidents/029_security_incidents_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-061-arcadia-genomics/04_security_incidents/030_security_incidents_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-061-arcadia-genomics/04_security_incidents/031_security_incidents_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-061-arcadia-genomics/04_security_incidents/032_security_incidents_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-061-arcadia-genomics/05_consumer_requests/033_consumer_requests_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-061-arcadia-genomics/05_consumer_requests/034_consumer_requests_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-061-arcadia-genomics/05_consumer_requests/035_consumer_requests_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-061-arcadia-genomics/05_consumer_requests/036_consumer_requests_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-061-arcadia-genomics/05_consumer_requests/037_consumer_requests_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-061-arcadia-genomics/05_consumer_requests/038_consumer_requests_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-061-arcadia-genomics/05_consumer_requests/039_consumer_requests_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-061-arcadia-genomics/05_consumer_requests/040_consumer_requests_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-061-arcadia-genomics/06_notices_consents/041_notices_consents_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-061-arcadia-genomics/06_notices_consents/042_notices_consents_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-061-arcadia-genomics/06_notices_consents/043_notices_consents_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-061-arcadia-genomics/06_notices_consents/044_notices_consents_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-061-arcadia-genomics/06_notices_consents/045_notices_consents_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-061-arcadia-genomics/06_notices_consents/046_notices_consents_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-061-arcadia-genomics/06_notices_consents/047_notices_consents_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-061-arcadia-genomics/06_notices_consents/048_notices_consents_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-061-arcadia-genomics/07_transfer_mechanisms/049_transfer_mechanisms_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-061-arcadia-genomics/07_transfer_mechanisms/050_transfer_mechanisms_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-061-arcadia-genomics/07_transfer_mechanisms/051_transfer_mechanisms_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-061-arcadia-genomics/07_transfer_mechanisms/052_transfer_mechanisms_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-061-arcadia-genomics/07_transfer_mechanisms/053_transfer_mechanisms_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-061-arcadia-genomics/07_transfer_mechanisms/054_transfer_mechanisms_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-061-arcadia-genomics/07_transfer_mechanisms/055_transfer_mechanisms_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-061-arcadia-genomics/07_transfer_mechanisms/056_transfer_mechanisms_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-061-arcadia-genomics/08_retention_deletion/057_retention_deletion_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-061-arcadia-genomics/08_retention_deletion/058_retention_deletion_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-061-arcadia-genomics/08_retention_deletion/059_retention_deletion_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-061-arcadia-genomics/08_retention_deletion/060_retention_deletion_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-061-arcadia-genomics/08_retention_deletion/061_retention_deletion_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-061-arcadia-genomics/08_retention_deletion/062_retention_deletion_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-061-arcadia-genomics/08_retention_deletion/063_retention_deletion_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-061-arcadia-genomics/08_retention_deletion/064_retention_deletion_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-061-arcadia-genomics/09_training/065_training_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-061-arcadia-genomics/09_training/066_training_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-061-arcadia-genomics/09_training/067_training_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-061-arcadia-genomics/09_training/068_training_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-061-arcadia-genomics/09_training/069_training_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-061-arcadia-genomics/09_training/070_training_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-061-arcadia-genomics/09_training/071_training_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-061-arcadia-genomics/09_training/072_training_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-061-arcadia-genomics/10_regulator_correspondence/073_regulator_correspondence_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-061-arcadia-genomics/10_regulator_correspondence/074_regulator_correspondence_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-061-arcadia-genomics/10_regulator_correspondence/075_regulator_correspondence_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-061-arcadia-genomics/10_regulator_correspondence/076_regulator_correspondence_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-061-arcadia-genomics/10_regulator_correspondence/077_regulator_correspondence_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-061-arcadia-genomics/10_regulator_correspondence/078_regulator_correspondence_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-061-arcadia-genomics/10_regulator_correspondence/079_regulator_correspondence_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-061-arcadia-genomics/10_regulator_correspondence/080_regulator_correspondence_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-061-arcadia-genomics/11_risk_assessments/081_risk_assessments_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-061-arcadia-genomics/11_risk_assessments/082_risk_assessments_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-061-arcadia-genomics/11_risk_assessments/083_risk_assessments_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-061-arcadia-genomics/11_risk_assessments/084_risk_assessments_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-061-arcadia-genomics/11_risk_assessments/085_risk_assessments_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-061-arcadia-genomics/11_risk_assessments/086_risk_assessments_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-061-arcadia-genomics/11_risk_assessments/087_risk_assessments_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-061-arcadia-genomics/11_risk_assessments/088_risk_assessments_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-061-arcadia-genomics/12_remediation/089_remediation_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-061-arcadia-genomics/12_remediation/090_remediation_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-061-arcadia-genomics/12_remediation/091_remediation_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-061-arcadia-genomics/12_remediation/092_remediation_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-061-arcadia-genomics/12_remediation/093_remediation_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-061-arcadia-genomics/12_remediation/094_remediation_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-061-arcadia-genomics/12_remediation/095_remediation_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-061-arcadia-genomics/12_remediation/096_remediation_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-061-arcadia-genomics/12_remediation/097_arcadia_genomics_impact_population.xlsx"], "gold_output": {"advice_markdown": "# Decision note — Arcadia genomic data response audit\n\n## Recommendation\n\nComplete supported access and deletion work and escalate exact transfer gaps. The reconciled record supports 8 scoped actions and leaves 4 items on evidence hold.\n\nSelected option: `arcadia-genomics:scoped-evidence`.\n\n## Why this is the supported option\n\nJoin requester identity, genomic data inventory, vendor copies, deletion jobs, and research transfers. Access, deletion, and transfer duties depend on verified identity, purpose, jurisdiction, and current vendor scope.\n\n## Supported actions\n\n### CBP-061-01 — sensitive-data classification (high)\n\nthe permission is limited to California Privacy Protection Agency under CB-PR-3001-R870; the matched activity occurred in California under CB-PR-3001-E674. Identity resolves to ENT-061-1000, revision REV-2025.1 is current, and Henry Cho is active with capacity 4.\n\nAction: Create system-purpose response rows with identity and legal-basis holds. Owner: Henry Cho; due 2026-09-01.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/001_data_inventory_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/02_processing_records/013_processing_records_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/025_security_incidents_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/037_consumer_requests_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_arcadia_genomics_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-061-03 — retention schedule conflict (low)\n\ndelivery must use notices-arcadia_genomics_inc@example.test under CB-PR-3001-R844; the only matched receipt used archive-north_coast_sequencing_network@example.test under CB-PR-3001-E567. Identity resolves to ENT-061-1002, revision REV-2025.3 is current, and Jonas Feld is active with capacity 5.\n\nAction: Create system-purpose response rows with identity and legal-basis holds. Owner: Jonas Feld; due 2026-08-30.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/003_data_inventory_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/02_processing_records/015_processing_records_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/027_security_incidents_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/039_consumer_requests_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/11_risk_assessments/087_risk_assessments_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/07_transfer_mechanisms/051_transfer_mechanisms_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_arcadia_genomics_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-061-04 — risk-assessment omission (medium)\n\nan open exception blocks completion under CB-PR-3001-R173; the current status is open and unresolved under CB-PR-3001-E104. Identity resolves to ENT-061-1003, revision REV-2025.4 is current, and Willa Novak is active with capacity 3.\n\nAction: Create system-purpose response rows with identity and legal-basis holds. Owner: Willa Novak; due 2026-08-29.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/004_data_inventory_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/02_processing_records/016_processing_records_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/028_security_incidents_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/040_consumer_requests_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/07_transfer_mechanisms/052_transfer_mechanisms_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_arcadia_genomics_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-061-05 — processing-purpose gap (high)\n\ncompletion is required by 2025-05-28 under CB-PR-3001-R422; the current event record shows completion on 2025-07-07 under CB-PR-3001-E754. Identity resolves to ENT-061-1004, revision REV-2025.5 is current, and Owen Delgado is active with capacity 4.\n\nAction: Create system-purpose response rows with identity and legal-basis holds. Owner: Owen Delgado; due 2026-08-28.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/005_data_inventory_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/017_vendor_reviews_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/029_security_incidents_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/041_notices_consents_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_arcadia_genomics_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-061-06 — cross-border transfer gap (high)\n\nthe controlling threshold is 14% under CB-PR-3001-R637; the independently calculated result is 20% under CB-PR-3001-E449. Identity resolves to ENT-061-1005, revision REV-2025.6 is current, and Priya Raman is active with capacity 4.\n\nAction: Create system-purpose response rows with identity and legal-basis holds. Owner: Priya Raman; due 2026-08-27.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/006_data_inventory_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/018_vendor_reviews_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/030_security_incidents_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/042_notices_consents_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/09_training/066_training_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_arcadia_genomics_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-061-10 — identity-verification inconsistency (critical)\n\nthe operative cap is $3,442,000.00 under CB-PR-3001-R266; the matched ledger population totals $3,574,266.00 under CB-PR-3001-E798. Identity resolves to ENT-061-1009, revision REV-2025.3 is current, and Mei Whitaker is active with capacity 5.\n\nAction: Create system-purpose response rows with identity and legal-basis holds. Owner: Mei Whitaker; due 2026-09-01.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/02_processing_records/010_processing_records_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/022_vendor_reviews_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/034_consumer_requests_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/046_notices_consents_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/09_training/070_training_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/11_risk_assessments/082_risk_assessments_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_arcadia_genomics_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-061-11 — training completion gap (high)\n\ndelivery must use notices-arcadia_genomics_inc@example.test under CB-PR-3001-R334; the only matched receipt used archive-north_coast_sequencing_network@example.test under CB-PR-3001-E378. Identity resolves to ENT-061-1010, revision REV-2025.4 is current, and Theo Laurent is active with capacity 1.\n\nAction: Create system-purpose response rows with identity and legal-basis holds. Owner: Theo Laurent; due 2026-08-31.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/02_processing_records/011_processing_records_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/023_vendor_reviews_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/035_consumer_requests_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/047_notices_consents_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_arcadia_genomics_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-061-12 — processor-contract omission (medium)\n\nan open exception blocks completion under CB-PR-3001-R173; the current status is open and unresolved under CB-PR-3001-E104. Identity resolves to ENT-061-1011, revision REV-2025.5 is current, and Lena Varga is active with capacity 5.\n\nAction: Create system-purpose response rows with identity and legal-basis holds. Owner: Lena Varga; due 2026-08-30.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/02_processing_records/012_processing_records_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/024_vendor_reviews_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/036_consumer_requests_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/048_notices_consents_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/11_risk_assessments/084_risk_assessments_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/12_remediation/096_remediation_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_arcadia_genomics_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n## Evidence holds\n\n- **CBP-061-02 — notice-practice mismatch**: the current observation does not meet the operative trigger. Next evidence: a current observation that satisfies the operative trigger. Sources: `/workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/002_data_inventory_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/02_processing_records/014_processing_records_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/026_security_incidents_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/038_consumer_requests_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/07_transfer_mechanisms/050_transfer_mechanisms_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/11_risk_assessments/086_risk_assessments_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_arcadia_genomics_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-061-07 — incident-notification clock**: the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective. Next evidence: effective approval and an active owner with remaining capacity. Sources: `/workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/007_data_inventory_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/019_vendor_reviews_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/031_security_incidents_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/043_notices_consents_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/12_remediation/091_remediation_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/09_training/067_training_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_arcadia_genomics_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-061-08 — regulator commitment overdue**: the operational record relies on a superseded control revision. Next evidence: an operational record using the current effective revision. Sources: `/workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/008_data_inventory_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/020_vendor_reviews_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/032_security_incidents_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/044_notices_consents_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/09_training/068_training_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_arcadia_genomics_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-061-09 — subprocessor inventory mismatch**: two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key. Next evidence: an approved immutable entity crosswalk. Sources: `/workspace/documents/02_processing_records/009_processing_records_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/021_vendor_reviews_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/033_consumer_requests_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/045_notices_consents_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_arcadia_genomics_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n## Alternatives considered\n\n- `arcadia-genomics:shortcut` — Delete every matched name across all systems and disclose unverified research data.: Use a plausible summary or one source without completing the controlling joins.\n- `arcadia-genomics:blanket-hold` — Freeze the entire matter population: Treat supported actions and genuinely ambiguous records as if they were equally unresolved.\n\n## Assumptions and limits\n\nThis decision is limited to cb100-061-arcadia-genomics, the supplied synthetic records, and the matter state as of 2026-09-02. Similar names, stale revisions, and pending authority are not treated as proof.\n", "decision": {"actions": [{"determination": "the permission is limited to California Privacy Protection Agency under CB-PR-3001-R870; the matched activity occurred in California under CB-PR-3001-E674. Identity resolves to ENT-061-1000, revision REV-2025.1 is current, and Henry Cho is active with capacity 4.", "due_date": "2026-09-01", "id": "ACT-CBP-061-01", "identity_id": "ENT-061-1000", "issue": "sensitive-data classification", "owner": "Henry Cho", "portfolio_key": "CBP-061-01", "recommended_action": "Create system-purpose response rows with identity and legal-basis holds. Owner: Henry Cho; due 2026-09-01.", "severity": "high", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/001_data_inventory_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/02_processing_records/013_processing_records_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/025_security_incidents_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/037_consumer_requests_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_arcadia_genomics_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "delivery must use notices-arcadia_genomics_inc@example.test under CB-PR-3001-R844; the only matched receipt used archive-north_coast_sequencing_network@example.test under CB-PR-3001-E567. Identity resolves to ENT-061-1002, revision REV-2025.3 is current, and Jonas Feld is active with capacity 5.", "due_date": "2026-08-30", "id": "ACT-CBP-061-03", "identity_id": "ENT-061-1002", "issue": "retention schedule conflict", "owner": "Jonas Feld", "portfolio_key": "CBP-061-03", "recommended_action": "Create system-purpose response rows with identity and legal-basis holds. Owner: Jonas Feld; due 2026-08-30.", "severity": "low", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/003_data_inventory_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/02_processing_records/015_processing_records_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/027_security_incidents_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/039_consumer_requests_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/11_risk_assessments/087_risk_assessments_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/07_transfer_mechanisms/051_transfer_mechanisms_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_arcadia_genomics_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "an open exception blocks completion under CB-PR-3001-R173; the current status is open and unresolved under CB-PR-3001-E104. Identity resolves to ENT-061-1003, revision REV-2025.4 is current, and Willa Novak is active with capacity 3.", "due_date": "2026-08-29", "id": "ACT-CBP-061-04", "identity_id": "ENT-061-1003", "issue": "risk-assessment omission", "owner": "Willa Novak", "portfolio_key": "CBP-061-04", "recommended_action": "Create system-purpose response rows with identity and legal-basis holds. Owner: Willa Novak; due 2026-08-29.", "severity": "medium", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/004_data_inventory_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/02_processing_records/016_processing_records_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/028_security_incidents_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/040_consumer_requests_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/07_transfer_mechanisms/052_transfer_mechanisms_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_arcadia_genomics_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "completion is required by 2025-05-28 under CB-PR-3001-R422; the current event record shows completion on 2025-07-07 under CB-PR-3001-E754. Identity resolves to ENT-061-1004, revision REV-2025.5 is current, and Owen Delgado is active with capacity 4.", "due_date": "2026-08-28", "id": "ACT-CBP-061-05", "identity_id": "ENT-061-1004", "issue": "processing-purpose gap", "owner": "Owen Delgado", "portfolio_key": "CBP-061-05", "recommended_action": "Create system-purpose response rows with identity and legal-basis holds. Owner: Owen Delgado; due 2026-08-28.", "severity": "high", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/005_data_inventory_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/017_vendor_reviews_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/029_security_incidents_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/041_notices_consents_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_arcadia_genomics_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "the controlling threshold is 14% under CB-PR-3001-R637; the independently calculated result is 20% under CB-PR-3001-E449. Identity resolves to ENT-061-1005, revision REV-2025.6 is current, and Priya Raman is active with capacity 4.", "due_date": "2026-08-27", "id": "ACT-CBP-061-06", "identity_id": "ENT-061-1005", "issue": "cross-border transfer gap", "owner": "Priya Raman", "portfolio_key": "CBP-061-06", "recommended_action": "Create system-purpose response rows with identity and legal-basis holds. Owner: Priya Raman; due 2026-08-27.", "severity": "high", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/006_data_inventory_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/018_vendor_reviews_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/030_security_incidents_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/042_notices_consents_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/09_training/066_training_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_arcadia_genomics_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "the operative cap is $3,442,000.00 under CB-PR-3001-R266; the matched ledger population totals $3,574,266.00 under CB-PR-3001-E798. Identity resolves to ENT-061-1009, revision REV-2025.3 is current, and Mei Whitaker is active with capacity 5.", "due_date": "2026-09-01", "id": "ACT-CBP-061-10", "identity_id": "ENT-061-1009", "issue": "identity-verification inconsistency", "owner": "Mei Whitaker", "portfolio_key": "CBP-061-10", "recommended_action": "Create system-purpose response rows with identity and legal-basis holds. Owner: Mei Whitaker; due 2026-09-01.", "severity": "critical", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_processing_records/010_processing_records_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/022_vendor_reviews_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/034_consumer_requests_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/046_notices_consents_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/09_training/070_training_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/11_risk_assessments/082_risk_assessments_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_arcadia_genomics_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "delivery must use notices-arcadia_genomics_inc@example.test under CB-PR-3001-R334; the only matched receipt used archive-north_coast_sequencing_network@example.test under CB-PR-3001-E378. Identity resolves to ENT-061-1010, revision REV-2025.4 is current, and Theo Laurent is active with capacity 1.", "due_date": "2026-08-31", "id": "ACT-CBP-061-11", "identity_id": "ENT-061-1010", "issue": "training completion gap", "owner": "Theo Laurent", "portfolio_key": "CBP-061-11", "recommended_action": "Create system-purpose response rows with identity and legal-basis holds. Owner: Theo Laurent; due 2026-08-31.", "severity": "high", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_processing_records/011_processing_records_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/023_vendor_reviews_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/035_consumer_requests_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/047_notices_consents_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_arcadia_genomics_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "an open exception blocks completion under CB-PR-3001-R173; the current status is open and unresolved under CB-PR-3001-E104. Identity resolves to ENT-061-1011, revision REV-2025.5 is current, and Lena Varga is active with capacity 5.", "due_date": "2026-08-30", "id": "ACT-CBP-061-12", "identity_id": "ENT-061-1011", "issue": "processor-contract omission", "owner": "Lena Varga", "portfolio_key": "CBP-061-12", "recommended_action": "Create system-purpose response rows with identity and legal-basis holds. Owner: Lena Varga; due 2026-08-30.", "severity": "medium", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_processing_records/012_processing_records_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/024_vendor_reviews_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/036_consumer_requests_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/048_notices_consents_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/11_risk_assessments/084_risk_assessments_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/096_remediation_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_arcadia_genomics_impact_population.xlsx"]}], "as_of": "2026-09-02", "decision": {"alternatives_considered": ["arcadia-genomics:shortcut", "arcadia-genomics:blanket-hold"], "question": "What can Arcadia tell the requester, what must be deleted, and which transfer issue needs escalation?", "rationale": "The four-part causal test supports 8 scoped actions and leaves 4 records on evidence hold. Access, deletion, and transfer duties depend on verified identity, purpose, jurisdiction, and current vendor scope.", "recommendation": "Complete supported access and deletion work and escalate exact transfer gaps.", "selected_option_id": "arcadia-genomics:scoped-evidence"}, "holds": [{"id": "HOLD-CBP-061-02", "issue": "notice-practice mismatch", "portfolio_key": "CBP-061-02", "reason": "the current observation does not meet the operative trigger", "required_next_evidence": "a current observation that satisfies the operative trigger", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/002_data_inventory_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/02_processing_records/014_processing_records_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/026_security_incidents_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/038_consumer_requests_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/07_transfer_mechanisms/050_transfer_mechanisms_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/11_risk_assessments/086_risk_assessments_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_arcadia_genomics_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-061-07", "issue": "incident-notification clock", "portfolio_key": "CBP-061-07", "reason": "the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective", "required_next_evidence": "effective approval and an active owner with remaining capacity", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/007_data_inventory_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/019_vendor_reviews_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/031_security_incidents_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/043_notices_consents_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/091_remediation_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/09_training/067_training_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_arcadia_genomics_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-061-08", "issue": "regulator commitment overdue", "portfolio_key": "CBP-061-08", "reason": "the operational record relies on a superseded control revision", "required_next_evidence": "an operational record using the current effective revision", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/008_data_inventory_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/020_vendor_reviews_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/032_security_incidents_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/044_notices_consents_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/09_training/068_training_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_arcadia_genomics_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-061-09", "issue": "subprocessor inventory mismatch", "portfolio_key": "CBP-061-09", "reason": "two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key", "required_next_evidence": "an approved immutable entity crosswalk", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_processing_records/009_processing_records_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/021_vendor_reviews_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/033_consumer_requests_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/045_notices_consents_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_arcadia_genomics_impact_population.xlsx"]}], "matter_number": "CB-PR-3001", "prepared_for": "Arcadia Genomics, Inc.", "schema_version": "counselbench.decision.v3", "task_id": "cb100-061-arcadia-genomics"}, "matter_register": {"matter_number": "CB-PR-3001", "rows": [{"decision_option_id": "arcadia-genomics:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-01", "issue": "sensitive-data classification", "matter_number": "CB-PR-3001", "owner": "Henry Cho", "portfolio_key": "CBP-061-01", "row_id": "REG-CBP-061-01", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/001_data_inventory_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/02_processing_records/013_processing_records_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/025_security_incidents_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/037_consumer_requests_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_arcadia_genomics_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "arcadia-genomics:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "the current observation does not meet the operative trigger", "issue": "notice-practice mismatch", "matter_number": "CB-PR-3001", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-061-02", "row_id": "REG-CBP-061-02", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/002_data_inventory_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/02_processing_records/014_processing_records_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/026_security_incidents_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/038_consumer_requests_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/07_transfer_mechanisms/050_transfer_mechanisms_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/11_risk_assessments/086_risk_assessments_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_arcadia_genomics_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "arcadia-genomics:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-08-30", "issue": "retention schedule conflict", "matter_number": "CB-PR-3001", "owner": "Jonas Feld", "portfolio_key": "CBP-061-03", "row_id": "REG-CBP-061-03", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/003_data_inventory_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/02_processing_records/015_processing_records_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/027_security_incidents_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/039_consumer_requests_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/11_risk_assessments/087_risk_assessments_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/07_transfer_mechanisms/051_transfer_mechanisms_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_arcadia_genomics_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "arcadia-genomics:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-08-29", "issue": "risk-assessment omission", "matter_number": "CB-PR-3001", "owner": "Willa Novak", "portfolio_key": "CBP-061-04", "row_id": "REG-CBP-061-04", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/004_data_inventory_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/02_processing_records/016_processing_records_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/028_security_incidents_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/040_consumer_requests_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/07_transfer_mechanisms/052_transfer_mechanisms_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_arcadia_genomics_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "arcadia-genomics:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-08-28", "issue": "processing-purpose gap", "matter_number": "CB-PR-3001", "owner": "Owen Delgado", "portfolio_key": "CBP-061-05", "row_id": "REG-CBP-061-05", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/005_data_inventory_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/017_vendor_reviews_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/029_security_incidents_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/041_notices_consents_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_arcadia_genomics_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "arcadia-genomics:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-08-27", "issue": "cross-border transfer gap", "matter_number": "CB-PR-3001", "owner": "Priya Raman", "portfolio_key": "CBP-061-06", "row_id": "REG-CBP-061-06", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/006_data_inventory_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/018_vendor_reviews_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/030_security_incidents_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/042_notices_consents_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/09_training/066_training_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_arcadia_genomics_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "arcadia-genomics:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective", "issue": "incident-notification clock", "matter_number": "CB-PR-3001", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-061-07", "row_id": "REG-CBP-061-07", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/007_data_inventory_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/019_vendor_reviews_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/031_security_incidents_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/043_notices_consents_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/091_remediation_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/09_training/067_training_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_arcadia_genomics_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "arcadia-genomics:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "the operational record relies on a superseded control revision", "issue": "regulator commitment overdue", "matter_number": "CB-PR-3001", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-061-08", "row_id": "REG-CBP-061-08", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/008_data_inventory_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/020_vendor_reviews_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/032_security_incidents_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/044_notices_consents_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/09_training/068_training_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_arcadia_genomics_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "arcadia-genomics:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key", "issue": "subprocessor inventory mismatch", "matter_number": "CB-PR-3001", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-061-09", "row_id": "REG-CBP-061-09", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_processing_records/009_processing_records_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/021_vendor_reviews_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/033_consumer_requests_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/045_notices_consents_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_arcadia_genomics_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "arcadia-genomics:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-01", "issue": "identity-verification inconsistency", "matter_number": "CB-PR-3001", "owner": "Mei Whitaker", "portfolio_key": "CBP-061-10", "row_id": "REG-CBP-061-10", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_processing_records/010_processing_records_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/022_vendor_reviews_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/034_consumer_requests_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/046_notices_consents_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/09_training/070_training_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/11_risk_assessments/082_risk_assessments_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_arcadia_genomics_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "arcadia-genomics:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-08-31", "issue": "training completion gap", "matter_number": "CB-PR-3001", "owner": "Theo Laurent", "portfolio_key": "CBP-061-11", "row_id": "REG-CBP-061-11", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_processing_records/011_processing_records_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/023_vendor_reviews_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/035_consumer_requests_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/047_notices_consents_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_arcadia_genomics_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "arcadia-genomics:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-08-30", "issue": "processor-contract omission", "matter_number": "CB-PR-3001", "owner": "Lena Varga", "portfolio_key": "CBP-061-12", "row_id": "REG-CBP-061-12", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_processing_records/012_processing_records_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/024_vendor_reviews_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/036_consumer_requests_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/048_notices_consents_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/11_risk_assessments/084_risk_assessments_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/096_remediation_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_arcadia_genomics_impact_population.xlsx"]}], "schema_version": "counselbench.matter-register.v3", "task_id": "cb100-061-arcadia-genomics"}}, "metadata": {"benchmark": "CounselBench-100", "code_license": "Apache-2.0", "data_license": "CC-BY-4.0", "deadline": "2026-09-02", "document_count": 97, "evidence_holds": 4, "jurisdiction": "California", "matter_number": "CB-PR-3001", "mcp_commit": "9a96ea6e5913736f92b88345bf51caeaaa8e719f", "mcp_package": "@modelcontextprotocol/server-filesystem@2026.7.10", "practice_area": "privacy-regulatory", "reference_tool_calls": 83, "required_evidence_reads": 63, "supported_actions": 8, "synthetic": true, "venue": "California Privacy Protection Agency", "version": "3.1.0"}, "prompt": "I need a straight answer before the next partner call. What can Arcadia tell the requester, what must be deleted, and which transfer issue needs escalation? A consumer access request exposes inconsistencies among genomic-data notices, deletion jobs, vendors, and overseas research transfers. The team needs the call by 2026-09-02. Update the matter record only where the evidence supports it, and give me the practical options for the client.", "rubric": {"criteria": [{"category": "investigation", "description": "Inventory the production and use targeted searches to locate records across native formats.", "id": "investigation.discover_production"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Complete every task-specific identity, authority, operations, and approval read before the first state transition.", "id": "investigation.read_before_write"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Inspect designated source metadata before relying on those records.", "id": "investigation.custody_before_write"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "Select the supported option 'arcadia-genomics:scoped-evidence' after applying the four-part test.", "id": "decision.selected_option"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "Identify both rejected approaches and explain why a one-source shortcut and a blanket hold are wrong.", "id": "decision.alternatives"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-061-01 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/001_data_inventory_source_export.md rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-061-01.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_processing_records/013_processing_records_source_export.json for sensitive-data classification.", "id": "investigation.CBP-061-01.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/025_security_incidents_source_export.md to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-061-01.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/037_consumer_requests_source_export.json.", "id": "investigation.CBP-061-01.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-061-01 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-061-01.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-061-01 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-061-01.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-061-02 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/002_data_inventory_source_export.txt rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-061-02.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_processing_records/014_processing_records_source_export.xml for notice-practice mismatch.", "id": "investigation.CBP-061-02.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/026_security_incidents_source_export.txt to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-061-02.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/038_consumer_requests_source_export.xml.", "id": "investigation.CBP-061-02.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-061-02 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is the current observation does not meet the operative trigger.", "id": "decision.CBP-061-02.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-061-02 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-061-02.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-061-03 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/003_data_inventory_source_export.eml rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-061-03.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_processing_records/015_processing_records_source_export.html for retention schedule conflict.", "id": "investigation.CBP-061-03.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/027_security_incidents_source_export.eml to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-061-03.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/039_consumer_requests_source_export.html.", "id": "investigation.CBP-061-03.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-061-03 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-061-03.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-061-03 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-061-03.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-061-04 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/004_data_inventory_source_export.csv rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-061-04.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_processing_records/016_processing_records_source_export.pdf for risk-assessment omission.", "id": "investigation.CBP-061-04.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/028_security_incidents_source_export.csv to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-061-04.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/040_consumer_requests_source_export.pdf.", "id": "investigation.CBP-061-04.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-061-04 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-061-04.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-061-04 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-061-04.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-061-05 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/005_data_inventory_source_export.json rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-061-05.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/017_vendor_reviews_source_export.md for processing-purpose gap.", "id": "investigation.CBP-061-05.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/029_security_incidents_source_export.json to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-061-05.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/041_notices_consents_source_export.md.", "id": "investigation.CBP-061-05.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-061-05 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-061-05.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-061-05 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-061-05.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-061-06 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/006_data_inventory_source_export.xml rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-061-06.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/018_vendor_reviews_source_export.txt for cross-border transfer gap.", "id": "investigation.CBP-061-06.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/030_security_incidents_source_export.xml to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-061-06.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/042_notices_consents_source_export.txt.", "id": "investigation.CBP-061-06.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-061-06 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-061-06.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-061-06 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-061-06.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-061-07 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/007_data_inventory_source_export.html rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-061-07.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/019_vendor_reviews_source_export.eml for incident-notification clock.", "id": "investigation.CBP-061-07.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/031_security_incidents_source_export.html to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-061-07.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/043_notices_consents_source_export.eml.", "id": "investigation.CBP-061-07.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-061-07 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective.", "id": "decision.CBP-061-07.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-061-07 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-061-07.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-061-08 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/008_data_inventory_source_export.pdf rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-061-08.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/020_vendor_reviews_source_export.csv for regulator commitment overdue.", "id": "investigation.CBP-061-08.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/032_security_incidents_source_export.pdf to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-061-08.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/044_notices_consents_source_export.csv.", "id": "investigation.CBP-061-08.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-061-08 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is the operational record relies on a superseded control revision.", "id": "decision.CBP-061-08.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-061-08 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-061-08.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-061-09 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_processing_records/009_processing_records_source_export.md rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-061-09.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/021_vendor_reviews_source_export.json for subprocessor inventory mismatch.", "id": "investigation.CBP-061-09.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/033_consumer_requests_source_export.md to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-061-09.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/045_notices_consents_source_export.json.", "id": "investigation.CBP-061-09.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-061-09 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key.", "id": "decision.CBP-061-09.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-061-09 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-061-09.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-061-10 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_processing_records/010_processing_records_source_export.txt rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-061-10.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/022_vendor_reviews_source_export.xml for identity-verification inconsistency.", "id": "investigation.CBP-061-10.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/034_consumer_requests_source_export.txt to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-061-10.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/046_notices_consents_source_export.xml.", "id": "investigation.CBP-061-10.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-061-10 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-061-10.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-061-10 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-061-10.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-061-11 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_processing_records/011_processing_records_source_export.eml rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-061-11.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/023_vendor_reviews_source_export.html for training completion gap.", "id": "investigation.CBP-061-11.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/035_consumer_requests_source_export.eml to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-061-11.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/047_notices_consents_source_export.html.", "id": "investigation.CBP-061-11.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-061-11 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-061-11.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-061-11 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-061-11.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-061-12 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_processing_records/012_processing_records_source_export.csv rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-061-12.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/024_vendor_reviews_source_export.pdf for processor-contract omission.", "id": "investigation.CBP-061-12.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/036_consumer_requests_source_export.csv to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-061-12.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/048_notices_consents_source_export.pdf.", "id": "investigation.CBP-061-12.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-061-12 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-061-12.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-061-12 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-061-12.register"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Write the exact selected option, supported action population, evidence-hold population, facts, owners, deadlines, and citations.", "id": "state.exact_decision"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create one exact register row per portfolio key with no extra, missing, or modified row.", "id": "state.exact_register"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Leave only the three approved deliverables and perform no extra state-changing write.", "id": "state.write_scope_containment"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Read back decision.json, matter-register.json, and advice.md after their final writes.", "id": "state.postwrite_readback"}, {"category": "answer", "description": "Explain the selected recommendation, supported actions, holds, alternatives, and limitations with exact source anchors.", "id": "answer.decision_note"}], "decision_options": [{"approach": "Apply the exact identity, current-state, authority, and revision test. Create system-purpose response rows with identity and legal-basis holds.", "id": "arcadia-genomics:scoped-evidence", "label": "Complete supported access and deletion work and escalate exact transfer gaps."}, {"approach": "Use a plausible summary or one source without completing the controlling joins.", "id": "arcadia-genomics:shortcut", "label": "Delete every matched name across all systems and disclose unverified research data."}, {"approach": "Treat supported actions and genuinely ambiguous records as if they were equally unresolved.", "id": "arcadia-genomics:blanket-hold", "label": "Freeze the entire matter population"}], "evaluation_narrative": {"authority": "Access, deletion, and transfer duties depend on verified identity, purpose, jurisdiction, and current vendor scope.", "observation": "Join requester identity, genomic data inventory, vendor copies, deletion jobs, and research transfers.", "question": "What can Arcadia tell the requester, what must be deleted, and which transfer issue needs escalation?", "register_action": "Create system-purpose response rows with identity and legal-basis holds."}, "gates": ["all_required_evidence_precedes_first_write", "decision_criteria_complete", "register_state_exact", "write_scope_contained", "all_outputs_verified_by_readback"], "metadata_checks": 7, "metric": "weighted_criteria_score", "minimum_tool_calls": 83, "required_deliverables": ["decision.json", "matter-register.json", "advice.md"], "required_document_reads": 63, "type": "deterministic", "weights": {"advice": 0.15, "decision": 0.35, "investigation": 0.25, "state": 0.25}}, "task_id": "cb100-061-arcadia-genomics", "task_name": "Arcadia genomic data response audit", "world_id": "counselbench-filesystem-mcp-v3"}
+{"context_files": ["task_files/cb100-062-brightpath-kids/01_data_inventory/001_data_inventory_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-062-brightpath-kids/01_data_inventory/002_data_inventory_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-062-brightpath-kids/01_data_inventory/003_data_inventory_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-062-brightpath-kids/01_data_inventory/004_data_inventory_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-062-brightpath-kids/01_data_inventory/005_data_inventory_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-062-brightpath-kids/01_data_inventory/006_data_inventory_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-062-brightpath-kids/01_data_inventory/007_data_inventory_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-062-brightpath-kids/01_data_inventory/008_data_inventory_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-062-brightpath-kids/02_processing_records/009_processing_records_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-062-brightpath-kids/02_processing_records/010_processing_records_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-062-brightpath-kids/02_processing_records/011_processing_records_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-062-brightpath-kids/02_processing_records/012_processing_records_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-062-brightpath-kids/02_processing_records/013_processing_records_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-062-brightpath-kids/02_processing_records/014_processing_records_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-062-brightpath-kids/02_processing_records/015_processing_records_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-062-brightpath-kids/02_processing_records/016_processing_records_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-062-brightpath-kids/03_vendor_reviews/017_vendor_reviews_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-062-brightpath-kids/03_vendor_reviews/018_vendor_reviews_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-062-brightpath-kids/03_vendor_reviews/019_vendor_reviews_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-062-brightpath-kids/03_vendor_reviews/020_vendor_reviews_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-062-brightpath-kids/03_vendor_reviews/021_vendor_reviews_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-062-brightpath-kids/03_vendor_reviews/022_vendor_reviews_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-062-brightpath-kids/03_vendor_reviews/023_vendor_reviews_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-062-brightpath-kids/03_vendor_reviews/024_vendor_reviews_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-062-brightpath-kids/04_security_incidents/025_security_incidents_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-062-brightpath-kids/04_security_incidents/026_security_incidents_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-062-brightpath-kids/04_security_incidents/027_security_incidents_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-062-brightpath-kids/04_security_incidents/028_security_incidents_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-062-brightpath-kids/04_security_incidents/029_security_incidents_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-062-brightpath-kids/04_security_incidents/030_security_incidents_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-062-brightpath-kids/04_security_incidents/031_security_incidents_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-062-brightpath-kids/04_security_incidents/032_security_incidents_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-062-brightpath-kids/05_consumer_requests/033_consumer_requests_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-062-brightpath-kids/05_consumer_requests/034_consumer_requests_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-062-brightpath-kids/05_consumer_requests/035_consumer_requests_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-062-brightpath-kids/05_consumer_requests/036_consumer_requests_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-062-brightpath-kids/05_consumer_requests/037_consumer_requests_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-062-brightpath-kids/05_consumer_requests/038_consumer_requests_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-062-brightpath-kids/05_consumer_requests/039_consumer_requests_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-062-brightpath-kids/05_consumer_requests/040_consumer_requests_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-062-brightpath-kids/06_notices_consents/041_notices_consents_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-062-brightpath-kids/06_notices_consents/042_notices_consents_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-062-brightpath-kids/06_notices_consents/043_notices_consents_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-062-brightpath-kids/06_notices_consents/044_notices_consents_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-062-brightpath-kids/06_notices_consents/045_notices_consents_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-062-brightpath-kids/06_notices_consents/046_notices_consents_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-062-brightpath-kids/06_notices_consents/047_notices_consents_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-062-brightpath-kids/06_notices_consents/048_notices_consents_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-062-brightpath-kids/07_transfer_mechanisms/049_transfer_mechanisms_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-062-brightpath-kids/07_transfer_mechanisms/050_transfer_mechanisms_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-062-brightpath-kids/07_transfer_mechanisms/051_transfer_mechanisms_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-062-brightpath-kids/07_transfer_mechanisms/052_transfer_mechanisms_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-062-brightpath-kids/07_transfer_mechanisms/053_transfer_mechanisms_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-062-brightpath-kids/07_transfer_mechanisms/054_transfer_mechanisms_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-062-brightpath-kids/07_transfer_mechanisms/055_transfer_mechanisms_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-062-brightpath-kids/07_transfer_mechanisms/056_transfer_mechanisms_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-062-brightpath-kids/08_retention_deletion/057_retention_deletion_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-062-brightpath-kids/08_retention_deletion/058_retention_deletion_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-062-brightpath-kids/08_retention_deletion/059_retention_deletion_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-062-brightpath-kids/08_retention_deletion/060_retention_deletion_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-062-brightpath-kids/08_retention_deletion/061_retention_deletion_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-062-brightpath-kids/08_retention_deletion/062_retention_deletion_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-062-brightpath-kids/08_retention_deletion/063_retention_deletion_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-062-brightpath-kids/08_retention_deletion/064_retention_deletion_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-062-brightpath-kids/09_training/065_training_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-062-brightpath-kids/09_training/066_training_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-062-brightpath-kids/09_training/067_training_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-062-brightpath-kids/09_training/068_training_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-062-brightpath-kids/09_training/069_training_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-062-brightpath-kids/09_training/070_training_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-062-brightpath-kids/09_training/071_training_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-062-brightpath-kids/09_training/072_training_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-062-brightpath-kids/10_regulator_correspondence/073_regulator_correspondence_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-062-brightpath-kids/10_regulator_correspondence/074_regulator_correspondence_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-062-brightpath-kids/10_regulator_correspondence/075_regulator_correspondence_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-062-brightpath-kids/10_regulator_correspondence/076_regulator_correspondence_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-062-brightpath-kids/10_regulator_correspondence/077_regulator_correspondence_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-062-brightpath-kids/10_regulator_correspondence/078_regulator_correspondence_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-062-brightpath-kids/10_regulator_correspondence/079_regulator_correspondence_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-062-brightpath-kids/10_regulator_correspondence/080_regulator_correspondence_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-062-brightpath-kids/11_risk_assessments/081_risk_assessments_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-062-brightpath-kids/11_risk_assessments/082_risk_assessments_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-062-brightpath-kids/11_risk_assessments/083_risk_assessments_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-062-brightpath-kids/11_risk_assessments/084_risk_assessments_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-062-brightpath-kids/11_risk_assessments/085_risk_assessments_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-062-brightpath-kids/11_risk_assessments/086_risk_assessments_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-062-brightpath-kids/11_risk_assessments/087_risk_assessments_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-062-brightpath-kids/11_risk_assessments/088_risk_assessments_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-062-brightpath-kids/12_remediation/089_remediation_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-062-brightpath-kids/12_remediation/090_remediation_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-062-brightpath-kids/12_remediation/091_remediation_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-062-brightpath-kids/12_remediation/092_remediation_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-062-brightpath-kids/12_remediation/093_remediation_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-062-brightpath-kids/12_remediation/094_remediation_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-062-brightpath-kids/12_remediation/095_remediation_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-062-brightpath-kids/12_remediation/096_remediation_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-062-brightpath-kids/12_remediation/097_brightpath_kids_impact_population.xlsx"], "gold_output": {"advice_markdown": "# Decision note — BrightPath child-privacy compliance review\n\n## Recommendation\n\nSuspend or remediate only deployments lacking the required current controls. The reconciled record supports 6 scoped actions and leaves 6 items on evidence hold.\n\nSelected option: `brightpath-kids:scoped-evidence`.\n\n## Why this is the supported option\n\nReconcile school authorization, child age, voice collection, subprocessors, and deletion status by tenant and feature. Child-privacy consent, purpose limitation, and processor controls apply to exact deployments.\n\n## Supported actions\n\n### CBP-062-02 — consent-record deficiency (high)\n\napproval must come from Amara Patel under CB-PR-3002-R548; the effective approval record names Rafael Okafor under CB-PR-3002-E708. Identity resolves to ENT-062-1001, revision REV-2026.2 is current, and Dominic Alvarez is active with capacity 1.\n\nAction: Create tenant-feature rows and preserve ambiguous age or authorization records. Owner: Dominic Alvarez; due 2026-09-04.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/002_data_inventory_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/02_processing_records/014_processing_records_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/026_security_incidents_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/038_consumer_requests_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_brightpath_kids_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-062-04 — sensitive-data classification (medium)\n\nthe permission is limited to Connecticut Attorney General under CB-PR-3002-R594; the matched activity occurred in Connecticut under CB-PR-3002-E658. Identity resolves to ENT-062-1003, revision REV-2026.4 is current, and Henry Cho is active with capacity 4.\n\nAction: Create tenant-feature rows and preserve ambiguous age or authorization records. Owner: Henry Cho; due 2026-09-02.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/004_data_inventory_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/02_processing_records/016_processing_records_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/028_security_incidents_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/040_consumer_requests_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/08_retention_deletion/064_retention_deletion_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/10_regulator_correspondence/076_regulator_correspondence_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_brightpath_kids_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-062-06 — retention schedule conflict (medium)\n\ndelivery must use notices-brightpath_learning_apps@example.test under CB-PR-3002-R719; the only matched receipt used archive-lighthouse_school_district@example.test under CB-PR-3002-E454. Identity resolves to ENT-062-1005, revision REV-2026.6 is current, and Jonas Feld is active with capacity 5.\n\nAction: Create tenant-feature rows and preserve ambiguous age or authorization records. Owner: Jonas Feld; due 2026-08-31.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/006_data_inventory_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/018_vendor_reviews_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/030_security_incidents_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/042_notices_consents_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/10_regulator_correspondence/078_regulator_correspondence_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_brightpath_kids_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-062-07 — risk-assessment omission (medium)\n\nan open exception blocks completion under CB-PR-3002-R559; the current status is open and unresolved under CB-PR-3002-E391. Identity resolves to ENT-062-1006, revision REV-2026.7 is current, and Willa Novak is active with capacity 1.\n\nAction: Create tenant-feature rows and preserve ambiguous age or authorization records. Owner: Willa Novak; due 2026-08-30.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/007_data_inventory_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/019_vendor_reviews_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/031_security_incidents_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/043_notices_consents_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_brightpath_kids_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-062-08 — processing-purpose gap (critical)\n\ncompletion is required by 2025-09-06 under CB-PR-3002-R103; the current event record shows completion on 2025-10-18 under CB-PR-3002-E259. Identity resolves to ENT-062-1007, revision REV-2026.1 is current, and Owen Delgado is active with capacity 5.\n\nAction: Create tenant-feature rows and preserve ambiguous age or authorization records. Owner: Owen Delgado; due 2026-08-29.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/008_data_inventory_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/020_vendor_reviews_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/032_security_incidents_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/044_notices_consents_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/07_transfer_mechanisms/056_transfer_mechanisms_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/12_remediation/092_remediation_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_brightpath_kids_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-062-10 — incident-notification clock (medium)\n\napproval must come from Amara Patel under CB-PR-3002-R435; the effective approval record names Henry Cho under CB-PR-3002-E596. Identity resolves to ENT-062-1009, revision REV-2026.3 is current, and Isaac Romero is active with capacity 1.\n\nAction: Create tenant-feature rows and preserve ambiguous age or authorization records. Owner: Isaac Romero; due 2026-09-05.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/02_processing_records/010_processing_records_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/022_vendor_reviews_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/034_consumer_requests_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/046_notices_consents_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/11_risk_assessments/082_risk_assessments_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_brightpath_kids_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n## Evidence holds\n\n- **CBP-062-01 — minor-consent issue**: the current observation does not meet the operative trigger. Next evidence: a current observation that satisfies the operative trigger. Sources: `/workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/001_data_inventory_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/02_processing_records/013_processing_records_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/025_security_incidents_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/037_consumer_requests_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_brightpath_kids_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-062-03 — deletion-job failure**: the operational record relies on a superseded control revision. Next evidence: an operational record using the current effective revision. Sources: `/workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/003_data_inventory_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/02_processing_records/015_processing_records_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/027_security_incidents_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/039_consumer_requests_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/07_transfer_mechanisms/051_transfer_mechanisms_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/08_retention_deletion/063_retention_deletion_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_brightpath_kids_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-062-05 — notice-practice mismatch**: the current observation does not meet the operative trigger. Next evidence: a current observation that satisfies the operative trigger. Sources: `/workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/005_data_inventory_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/017_vendor_reviews_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/029_security_incidents_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/041_notices_consents_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_brightpath_kids_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-062-09 — cross-border transfer gap**: the current observation does not meet the operative trigger. Next evidence: a current observation that satisfies the operative trigger. Sources: `/workspace/documents/02_processing_records/009_processing_records_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/021_vendor_reviews_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/033_consumer_requests_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/045_notices_consents_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_brightpath_kids_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-062-11 — regulator commitment overdue**: the operational record relies on a superseded control revision. Next evidence: an operational record using the current effective revision. Sources: `/workspace/documents/02_processing_records/011_processing_records_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/023_vendor_reviews_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/035_consumer_requests_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/047_notices_consents_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/09_training/071_training_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/11_risk_assessments/083_risk_assessments_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_brightpath_kids_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-062-12 — subprocessor inventory mismatch**: two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key. Next evidence: an approved immutable entity crosswalk. Sources: `/workspace/documents/02_processing_records/012_processing_records_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/024_vendor_reviews_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/036_consumer_requests_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/048_notices_consents_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/08_retention_deletion/060_retention_deletion_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/11_risk_assessments/084_risk_assessments_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_brightpath_kids_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n## Alternatives considered\n\n- `brightpath-kids:shortcut` — Treat school use as blanket consent for every feature and vendor.: Use a plausible summary or one source without completing the controlling joins.\n- `brightpath-kids:blanket-hold` — Freeze the entire matter population: Treat supported actions and genuinely ambiguous records as if they were equally unresolved.\n\n## Assumptions and limits\n\nThis decision is limited to cb100-062-brightpath-kids, the supplied synthetic records, and the matter state as of 2026-09-06. Similar names, stale revisions, and pending authority are not treated as proof.\n", "decision": {"actions": [{"determination": "approval must come from Amara Patel under CB-PR-3002-R548; the effective approval record names Rafael Okafor under CB-PR-3002-E708. Identity resolves to ENT-062-1001, revision REV-2026.2 is current, and Dominic Alvarez is active with capacity 1.", "due_date": "2026-09-04", "id": "ACT-CBP-062-02", "identity_id": "ENT-062-1001", "issue": "consent-record deficiency", "owner": "Dominic Alvarez", "portfolio_key": "CBP-062-02", "recommended_action": "Create tenant-feature rows and preserve ambiguous age or authorization records. Owner: Dominic Alvarez; due 2026-09-04.", "severity": "high", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/002_data_inventory_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/02_processing_records/014_processing_records_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/026_security_incidents_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/038_consumer_requests_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_brightpath_kids_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "the permission is limited to Connecticut Attorney General under CB-PR-3002-R594; the matched activity occurred in Connecticut under CB-PR-3002-E658. Identity resolves to ENT-062-1003, revision REV-2026.4 is current, and Henry Cho is active with capacity 4.", "due_date": "2026-09-02", "id": "ACT-CBP-062-04", "identity_id": "ENT-062-1003", "issue": "sensitive-data classification", "owner": "Henry Cho", "portfolio_key": "CBP-062-04", "recommended_action": "Create tenant-feature rows and preserve ambiguous age or authorization records. Owner: Henry Cho; due 2026-09-02.", "severity": "medium", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/004_data_inventory_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/02_processing_records/016_processing_records_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/028_security_incidents_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/040_consumer_requests_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/08_retention_deletion/064_retention_deletion_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/10_regulator_correspondence/076_regulator_correspondence_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_brightpath_kids_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "delivery must use notices-brightpath_learning_apps@example.test under CB-PR-3002-R719; the only matched receipt used archive-lighthouse_school_district@example.test under CB-PR-3002-E454. Identity resolves to ENT-062-1005, revision REV-2026.6 is current, and Jonas Feld is active with capacity 5.", "due_date": "2026-08-31", "id": "ACT-CBP-062-06", "identity_id": "ENT-062-1005", "issue": "retention schedule conflict", "owner": "Jonas Feld", "portfolio_key": "CBP-062-06", "recommended_action": "Create tenant-feature rows and preserve ambiguous age or authorization records. Owner: Jonas Feld; due 2026-08-31.", "severity": "medium", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/006_data_inventory_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/018_vendor_reviews_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/030_security_incidents_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/042_notices_consents_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/10_regulator_correspondence/078_regulator_correspondence_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_brightpath_kids_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "an open exception blocks completion under CB-PR-3002-R559; the current status is open and unresolved under CB-PR-3002-E391. Identity resolves to ENT-062-1006, revision REV-2026.7 is current, and Willa Novak is active with capacity 1.", "due_date": "2026-08-30", "id": "ACT-CBP-062-07", "identity_id": "ENT-062-1006", "issue": "risk-assessment omission", "owner": "Willa Novak", "portfolio_key": "CBP-062-07", "recommended_action": "Create tenant-feature rows and preserve ambiguous age or authorization records. Owner: Willa Novak; due 2026-08-30.", "severity": "medium", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/007_data_inventory_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/019_vendor_reviews_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/031_security_incidents_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/043_notices_consents_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_brightpath_kids_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "completion is required by 2025-09-06 under CB-PR-3002-R103; the current event record shows completion on 2025-10-18 under CB-PR-3002-E259. Identity resolves to ENT-062-1007, revision REV-2026.1 is current, and Owen Delgado is active with capacity 5.", "due_date": "2026-08-29", "id": "ACT-CBP-062-08", "identity_id": "ENT-062-1007", "issue": "processing-purpose gap", "owner": "Owen Delgado", "portfolio_key": "CBP-062-08", "recommended_action": "Create tenant-feature rows and preserve ambiguous age or authorization records. Owner: Owen Delgado; due 2026-08-29.", "severity": "critical", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/008_data_inventory_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/020_vendor_reviews_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/032_security_incidents_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/044_notices_consents_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/07_transfer_mechanisms/056_transfer_mechanisms_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/092_remediation_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_brightpath_kids_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "approval must come from Amara Patel under CB-PR-3002-R435; the effective approval record names Henry Cho under CB-PR-3002-E596. Identity resolves to ENT-062-1009, revision REV-2026.3 is current, and Isaac Romero is active with capacity 1.", "due_date": "2026-09-05", "id": "ACT-CBP-062-10", "identity_id": "ENT-062-1009", "issue": "incident-notification clock", "owner": "Isaac Romero", "portfolio_key": "CBP-062-10", "recommended_action": "Create tenant-feature rows and preserve ambiguous age or authorization records. Owner: Isaac Romero; due 2026-09-05.", "severity": "medium", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_processing_records/010_processing_records_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/022_vendor_reviews_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/034_consumer_requests_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/046_notices_consents_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/11_risk_assessments/082_risk_assessments_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_brightpath_kids_impact_population.xlsx"]}], "as_of": "2026-09-06", "decision": {"alternatives_considered": ["brightpath-kids:shortcut", "brightpath-kids:blanket-hold"], "question": "Which BrightPath voice-data practices can continue, and what must be remediated?", "rationale": "The four-part causal test supports 6 scoped actions and leaves 6 records on evidence hold. Child-privacy consent, purpose limitation, and processor controls apply to exact deployments.", "recommendation": "Suspend or remediate only deployments lacking the required current controls.", "selected_option_id": "brightpath-kids:scoped-evidence"}, "holds": [{"id": "HOLD-CBP-062-01", "issue": "minor-consent issue", "portfolio_key": "CBP-062-01", "reason": "the current observation does not meet the operative trigger", "required_next_evidence": "a current observation that satisfies the operative trigger", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/001_data_inventory_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/02_processing_records/013_processing_records_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/025_security_incidents_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/037_consumer_requests_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_brightpath_kids_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-062-03", "issue": "deletion-job failure", "portfolio_key": "CBP-062-03", "reason": "the operational record relies on a superseded control revision", "required_next_evidence": "an operational record using the current effective revision", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/003_data_inventory_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/02_processing_records/015_processing_records_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/027_security_incidents_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/039_consumer_requests_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/07_transfer_mechanisms/051_transfer_mechanisms_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/08_retention_deletion/063_retention_deletion_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_brightpath_kids_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-062-05", "issue": "notice-practice mismatch", "portfolio_key": "CBP-062-05", "reason": "the current observation does not meet the operative trigger", "required_next_evidence": "a current observation that satisfies the operative trigger", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/005_data_inventory_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/017_vendor_reviews_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/029_security_incidents_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/041_notices_consents_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_brightpath_kids_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-062-09", "issue": "cross-border transfer gap", "portfolio_key": "CBP-062-09", "reason": "the current observation does not meet the operative trigger", "required_next_evidence": "a current observation that satisfies the operative trigger", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_processing_records/009_processing_records_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/021_vendor_reviews_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/033_consumer_requests_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/045_notices_consents_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_brightpath_kids_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-062-11", "issue": "regulator commitment overdue", "portfolio_key": "CBP-062-11", "reason": "the operational record relies on a superseded control revision", "required_next_evidence": "an operational record using the current effective revision", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_processing_records/011_processing_records_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/023_vendor_reviews_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/035_consumer_requests_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/047_notices_consents_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/09_training/071_training_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/11_risk_assessments/083_risk_assessments_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_brightpath_kids_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-062-12", "issue": "subprocessor inventory mismatch", "portfolio_key": "CBP-062-12", "reason": "two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key", "required_next_evidence": "an approved immutable entity crosswalk", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_processing_records/012_processing_records_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/024_vendor_reviews_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/036_consumer_requests_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/048_notices_consents_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/08_retention_deletion/060_retention_deletion_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/11_risk_assessments/084_risk_assessments_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_brightpath_kids_impact_population.xlsx"]}], "matter_number": "CB-PR-3002", "prepared_for": "BrightPath Learning Apps", "schema_version": "counselbench.decision.v3", "task_id": "cb100-062-brightpath-kids"}, "matter_register": {"matter_number": "CB-PR-3002", "rows": [{"decision_option_id": "brightpath-kids:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "the current observation does not meet the operative trigger", "issue": "minor-consent issue", "matter_number": "CB-PR-3002", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-062-01", "row_id": "REG-CBP-062-01", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/001_data_inventory_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/02_processing_records/013_processing_records_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/025_security_incidents_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/037_consumer_requests_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_brightpath_kids_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "brightpath-kids:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-04", "issue": "consent-record deficiency", "matter_number": "CB-PR-3002", "owner": "Dominic Alvarez", "portfolio_key": "CBP-062-02", "row_id": "REG-CBP-062-02", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/002_data_inventory_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/02_processing_records/014_processing_records_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/026_security_incidents_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/038_consumer_requests_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_brightpath_kids_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "brightpath-kids:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "the operational record relies on a superseded control revision", "issue": "deletion-job failure", "matter_number": "CB-PR-3002", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-062-03", "row_id": "REG-CBP-062-03", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/003_data_inventory_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/02_processing_records/015_processing_records_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/027_security_incidents_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/039_consumer_requests_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/07_transfer_mechanisms/051_transfer_mechanisms_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/08_retention_deletion/063_retention_deletion_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_brightpath_kids_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "brightpath-kids:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-02", "issue": "sensitive-data classification", "matter_number": "CB-PR-3002", "owner": "Henry Cho", "portfolio_key": "CBP-062-04", "row_id": "REG-CBP-062-04", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/004_data_inventory_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/02_processing_records/016_processing_records_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/028_security_incidents_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/040_consumer_requests_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/08_retention_deletion/064_retention_deletion_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/10_regulator_correspondence/076_regulator_correspondence_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_brightpath_kids_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "brightpath-kids:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "the current observation does not meet the operative trigger", "issue": "notice-practice mismatch", "matter_number": "CB-PR-3002", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-062-05", "row_id": "REG-CBP-062-05", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/005_data_inventory_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/017_vendor_reviews_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/029_security_incidents_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/041_notices_consents_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_brightpath_kids_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "brightpath-kids:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-08-31", "issue": "retention schedule conflict", "matter_number": "CB-PR-3002", "owner": "Jonas Feld", "portfolio_key": "CBP-062-06", "row_id": "REG-CBP-062-06", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/006_data_inventory_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/018_vendor_reviews_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/030_security_incidents_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/042_notices_consents_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/10_regulator_correspondence/078_regulator_correspondence_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_brightpath_kids_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "brightpath-kids:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-08-30", "issue": "risk-assessment omission", "matter_number": "CB-PR-3002", "owner": "Willa Novak", "portfolio_key": "CBP-062-07", "row_id": "REG-CBP-062-07", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/007_data_inventory_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/019_vendor_reviews_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/031_security_incidents_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/043_notices_consents_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_brightpath_kids_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "brightpath-kids:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-08-29", "issue": "processing-purpose gap", "matter_number": "CB-PR-3002", "owner": "Owen Delgado", "portfolio_key": "CBP-062-08", "row_id": "REG-CBP-062-08", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/008_data_inventory_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/020_vendor_reviews_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/032_security_incidents_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/044_notices_consents_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/07_transfer_mechanisms/056_transfer_mechanisms_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/092_remediation_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_brightpath_kids_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "brightpath-kids:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "the current observation does not meet the operative trigger", "issue": "cross-border transfer gap", "matter_number": "CB-PR-3002", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-062-09", "row_id": "REG-CBP-062-09", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_processing_records/009_processing_records_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/021_vendor_reviews_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/033_consumer_requests_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/045_notices_consents_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_brightpath_kids_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "brightpath-kids:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-05", "issue": "incident-notification clock", "matter_number": "CB-PR-3002", "owner": "Isaac Romero", "portfolio_key": "CBP-062-10", "row_id": "REG-CBP-062-10", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_processing_records/010_processing_records_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/022_vendor_reviews_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/034_consumer_requests_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/046_notices_consents_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/11_risk_assessments/082_risk_assessments_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_brightpath_kids_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "brightpath-kids:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "the operational record relies on a superseded control revision", "issue": "regulator commitment overdue", "matter_number": "CB-PR-3002", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-062-11", "row_id": "REG-CBP-062-11", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_processing_records/011_processing_records_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/023_vendor_reviews_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/035_consumer_requests_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/047_notices_consents_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/09_training/071_training_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/11_risk_assessments/083_risk_assessments_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_brightpath_kids_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "brightpath-kids:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key", "issue": "subprocessor inventory mismatch", "matter_number": "CB-PR-3002", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-062-12", "row_id": "REG-CBP-062-12", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_processing_records/012_processing_records_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/024_vendor_reviews_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/036_consumer_requests_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/048_notices_consents_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/08_retention_deletion/060_retention_deletion_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/11_risk_assessments/084_risk_assessments_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_brightpath_kids_impact_population.xlsx"]}], "schema_version": "counselbench.matter-register.v3", "task_id": "cb100-062-brightpath-kids"}}, "metadata": {"benchmark": "CounselBench-100", "code_license": "Apache-2.0", "data_license": "CC-BY-4.0", "deadline": "2026-09-06", "document_count": 97, "evidence_holds": 6, "jurisdiction": "Connecticut", "matter_number": "CB-PR-3002", "mcp_commit": "9a96ea6e5913736f92b88345bf51caeaaa8e719f", "mcp_package": "@modelcontextprotocol/server-filesystem@2026.7.10", "practice_area": "privacy-regulatory", "reference_tool_calls": 86, "required_evidence_reads": 62, "supported_actions": 6, "synthetic": true, "venue": "Connecticut Attorney General", "version": "3.1.0"}, "prompt": "The business team is asking whether it can move, and I do not want to answer from the summary deck. Which BrightPath voice-data practices can continue, and what must be remediated? An education app collected voice samples under school consent while subprocessor and deletion records lagged product changes. The team needs the call by 2026-09-06. Document the scoped result for the team and separate genuine exceptions from unresolved identity or revision questions.", "rubric": {"criteria": [{"category": "investigation", "description": "Inventory the production and use targeted searches to locate records across native formats.", "id": "investigation.discover_production"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Complete every task-specific identity, authority, operations, and approval read before the first state transition.", "id": "investigation.read_before_write"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Inspect designated source metadata before relying on those records.", "id": "investigation.custody_before_write"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "Select the supported option 'brightpath-kids:scoped-evidence' after applying the four-part test.", "id": "decision.selected_option"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "Identify both rejected approaches and explain why a one-source shortcut and a blanket hold are wrong.", "id": "decision.alternatives"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-062-01 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/001_data_inventory_source_export.md rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-062-01.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_processing_records/013_processing_records_source_export.json for minor-consent issue.", "id": "investigation.CBP-062-01.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/025_security_incidents_source_export.md to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-062-01.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/037_consumer_requests_source_export.json.", "id": "investigation.CBP-062-01.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-062-01 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is the current observation does not meet the operative trigger.", "id": "decision.CBP-062-01.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-062-01 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-062-01.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-062-02 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/002_data_inventory_source_export.txt rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-062-02.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_processing_records/014_processing_records_source_export.xml for consent-record deficiency.", "id": "investigation.CBP-062-02.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/026_security_incidents_source_export.txt to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-062-02.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/038_consumer_requests_source_export.xml.", "id": "investigation.CBP-062-02.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-062-02 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-062-02.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-062-02 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-062-02.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-062-03 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/003_data_inventory_source_export.eml rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-062-03.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_processing_records/015_processing_records_source_export.html for deletion-job failure.", "id": "investigation.CBP-062-03.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/027_security_incidents_source_export.eml to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-062-03.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/039_consumer_requests_source_export.html.", "id": "investigation.CBP-062-03.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-062-03 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is the operational record relies on a superseded control revision.", "id": "decision.CBP-062-03.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-062-03 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-062-03.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-062-04 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/004_data_inventory_source_export.csv rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-062-04.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_processing_records/016_processing_records_source_export.pdf for sensitive-data classification.", "id": "investigation.CBP-062-04.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/028_security_incidents_source_export.csv to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-062-04.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/040_consumer_requests_source_export.pdf.", "id": "investigation.CBP-062-04.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-062-04 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-062-04.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-062-04 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-062-04.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-062-05 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/005_data_inventory_source_export.json rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-062-05.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/017_vendor_reviews_source_export.md for notice-practice mismatch.", "id": "investigation.CBP-062-05.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/029_security_incidents_source_export.json to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-062-05.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/041_notices_consents_source_export.md.", "id": "investigation.CBP-062-05.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-062-05 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is the current observation does not meet the operative trigger.", "id": "decision.CBP-062-05.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-062-05 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-062-05.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-062-06 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/006_data_inventory_source_export.xml rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-062-06.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/018_vendor_reviews_source_export.txt for retention schedule conflict.", "id": "investigation.CBP-062-06.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/030_security_incidents_source_export.xml to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-062-06.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/042_notices_consents_source_export.txt.", "id": "investigation.CBP-062-06.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-062-06 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-062-06.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-062-06 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-062-06.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-062-07 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/007_data_inventory_source_export.html rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-062-07.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/019_vendor_reviews_source_export.eml for risk-assessment omission.", "id": "investigation.CBP-062-07.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/031_security_incidents_source_export.html to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-062-07.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/043_notices_consents_source_export.eml.", "id": "investigation.CBP-062-07.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-062-07 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-062-07.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-062-07 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-062-07.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-062-08 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/008_data_inventory_source_export.pdf rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-062-08.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/020_vendor_reviews_source_export.csv for processing-purpose gap.", "id": "investigation.CBP-062-08.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/032_security_incidents_source_export.pdf to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-062-08.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/044_notices_consents_source_export.csv.", "id": "investigation.CBP-062-08.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-062-08 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-062-08.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-062-08 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-062-08.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-062-09 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_processing_records/009_processing_records_source_export.md rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-062-09.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/021_vendor_reviews_source_export.json for cross-border transfer gap.", "id": "investigation.CBP-062-09.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/033_consumer_requests_source_export.md to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-062-09.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/045_notices_consents_source_export.json.", "id": "investigation.CBP-062-09.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-062-09 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is the current observation does not meet the operative trigger.", "id": "decision.CBP-062-09.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-062-09 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-062-09.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-062-10 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_processing_records/010_processing_records_source_export.txt rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-062-10.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/022_vendor_reviews_source_export.xml for incident-notification clock.", "id": "investigation.CBP-062-10.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/034_consumer_requests_source_export.txt to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-062-10.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/046_notices_consents_source_export.xml.", "id": "investigation.CBP-062-10.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-062-10 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-062-10.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-062-10 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-062-10.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-062-11 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_processing_records/011_processing_records_source_export.eml rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-062-11.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/023_vendor_reviews_source_export.html for regulator commitment overdue.", "id": "investigation.CBP-062-11.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/035_consumer_requests_source_export.eml to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-062-11.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/047_notices_consents_source_export.html.", "id": "investigation.CBP-062-11.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-062-11 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is the operational record relies on a superseded control revision.", "id": "decision.CBP-062-11.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-062-11 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-062-11.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-062-12 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_processing_records/012_processing_records_source_export.csv rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-062-12.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/024_vendor_reviews_source_export.pdf for subprocessor inventory mismatch.", "id": "investigation.CBP-062-12.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/036_consumer_requests_source_export.csv to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-062-12.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/048_notices_consents_source_export.pdf.", "id": "investigation.CBP-062-12.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-062-12 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key.", "id": "decision.CBP-062-12.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-062-12 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-062-12.register"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Write the exact selected option, supported action population, evidence-hold population, facts, owners, deadlines, and citations.", "id": "state.exact_decision"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create one exact register row per portfolio key with no extra, missing, or modified row.", "id": "state.exact_register"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Leave only the three approved deliverables and perform no extra state-changing write.", "id": "state.write_scope_containment"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Read back decision.json, matter-register.json, and advice.md after their final writes.", "id": "state.postwrite_readback"}, {"category": "answer", "description": "Explain the selected recommendation, supported actions, holds, alternatives, and limitations with exact source anchors.", "id": "answer.decision_note"}], "decision_options": [{"approach": "Use a plausible summary or one source without completing the controlling joins.", "id": "brightpath-kids:shortcut", "label": "Treat school use as blanket consent for every feature and vendor."}, {"approach": "Treat supported actions and genuinely ambiguous records as if they were equally unresolved.", "id": "brightpath-kids:blanket-hold", "label": "Freeze the entire matter population"}, {"approach": "Apply the exact identity, current-state, authority, and revision test. Create tenant-feature rows and preserve ambiguous age or authorization records.", "id": "brightpath-kids:scoped-evidence", "label": "Suspend or remediate only deployments lacking the required current controls."}], "evaluation_narrative": {"authority": "Child-privacy consent, purpose limitation, and processor controls apply to exact deployments.", "observation": "Reconcile school authorization, child age, voice collection, subprocessors, and deletion status by tenant and feature.", "question": "Which BrightPath voice-data practices can continue, and what must be remediated?", "register_action": "Create tenant-feature rows and preserve ambiguous age or authorization records."}, "gates": ["all_required_evidence_precedes_first_write", "decision_criteria_complete", "register_state_exact", "write_scope_contained", "all_outputs_verified_by_readback"], "metadata_checks": 10, "metric": "weighted_criteria_score", "minimum_tool_calls": 86, "required_deliverables": ["decision.json", "matter-register.json", "advice.md"], "required_document_reads": 62, "type": "deterministic", "weights": {"advice": 0.15, "decision": 0.35, "investigation": 0.25, "state": 0.25}}, "task_id": "cb100-062-brightpath-kids", "task_name": "BrightPath child-privacy compliance review", "world_id": "counselbench-filesystem-mcp-v3"}
+{"context_files": ["task_files/cb100-063-civic-route/01_data_inventory/001_data_inventory_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-063-civic-route/01_data_inventory/002_data_inventory_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-063-civic-route/01_data_inventory/003_data_inventory_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-063-civic-route/01_data_inventory/004_data_inventory_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-063-civic-route/01_data_inventory/005_data_inventory_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-063-civic-route/01_data_inventory/006_data_inventory_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-063-civic-route/01_data_inventory/007_data_inventory_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-063-civic-route/01_data_inventory/008_data_inventory_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-063-civic-route/02_processing_records/009_processing_records_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-063-civic-route/02_processing_records/010_processing_records_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-063-civic-route/02_processing_records/011_processing_records_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-063-civic-route/02_processing_records/012_processing_records_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-063-civic-route/02_processing_records/013_processing_records_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-063-civic-route/02_processing_records/014_processing_records_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-063-civic-route/02_processing_records/015_processing_records_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-063-civic-route/02_processing_records/016_processing_records_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-063-civic-route/03_vendor_reviews/017_vendor_reviews_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-063-civic-route/03_vendor_reviews/018_vendor_reviews_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-063-civic-route/03_vendor_reviews/019_vendor_reviews_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-063-civic-route/03_vendor_reviews/020_vendor_reviews_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-063-civic-route/03_vendor_reviews/021_vendor_reviews_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-063-civic-route/03_vendor_reviews/022_vendor_reviews_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-063-civic-route/03_vendor_reviews/023_vendor_reviews_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-063-civic-route/03_vendor_reviews/024_vendor_reviews_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-063-civic-route/04_security_incidents/025_security_incidents_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-063-civic-route/04_security_incidents/026_security_incidents_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-063-civic-route/04_security_incidents/027_security_incidents_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-063-civic-route/04_security_incidents/028_security_incidents_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-063-civic-route/04_security_incidents/029_security_incidents_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-063-civic-route/04_security_incidents/030_security_incidents_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-063-civic-route/04_security_incidents/031_security_incidents_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-063-civic-route/04_security_incidents/032_security_incidents_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-063-civic-route/05_consumer_requests/033_consumer_requests_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-063-civic-route/05_consumer_requests/034_consumer_requests_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-063-civic-route/05_consumer_requests/035_consumer_requests_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-063-civic-route/05_consumer_requests/036_consumer_requests_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-063-civic-route/05_consumer_requests/037_consumer_requests_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-063-civic-route/05_consumer_requests/038_consumer_requests_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-063-civic-route/05_consumer_requests/039_consumer_requests_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-063-civic-route/05_consumer_requests/040_consumer_requests_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-063-civic-route/06_notices_consents/041_notices_consents_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-063-civic-route/06_notices_consents/042_notices_consents_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-063-civic-route/06_notices_consents/043_notices_consents_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-063-civic-route/06_notices_consents/044_notices_consents_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-063-civic-route/06_notices_consents/045_notices_consents_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-063-civic-route/06_notices_consents/046_notices_consents_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-063-civic-route/06_notices_consents/047_notices_consents_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-063-civic-route/06_notices_consents/048_notices_consents_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-063-civic-route/07_transfer_mechanisms/049_transfer_mechanisms_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-063-civic-route/07_transfer_mechanisms/050_transfer_mechanisms_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-063-civic-route/07_transfer_mechanisms/051_transfer_mechanisms_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-063-civic-route/07_transfer_mechanisms/052_transfer_mechanisms_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-063-civic-route/07_transfer_mechanisms/053_transfer_mechanisms_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-063-civic-route/07_transfer_mechanisms/054_transfer_mechanisms_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-063-civic-route/07_transfer_mechanisms/055_transfer_mechanisms_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-063-civic-route/07_transfer_mechanisms/056_transfer_mechanisms_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-063-civic-route/08_retention_deletion/057_retention_deletion_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-063-civic-route/08_retention_deletion/058_retention_deletion_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-063-civic-route/08_retention_deletion/059_retention_deletion_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-063-civic-route/08_retention_deletion/060_retention_deletion_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-063-civic-route/08_retention_deletion/061_retention_deletion_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-063-civic-route/08_retention_deletion/062_retention_deletion_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-063-civic-route/08_retention_deletion/063_retention_deletion_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-063-civic-route/08_retention_deletion/064_retention_deletion_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-063-civic-route/09_training/065_training_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-063-civic-route/09_training/066_training_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-063-civic-route/09_training/067_training_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-063-civic-route/09_training/068_training_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-063-civic-route/09_training/069_training_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-063-civic-route/09_training/070_training_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-063-civic-route/09_training/071_training_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-063-civic-route/09_training/072_training_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-063-civic-route/10_regulator_correspondence/073_regulator_correspondence_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-063-civic-route/10_regulator_correspondence/074_regulator_correspondence_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-063-civic-route/10_regulator_correspondence/075_regulator_correspondence_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-063-civic-route/10_regulator_correspondence/076_regulator_correspondence_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-063-civic-route/10_regulator_correspondence/077_regulator_correspondence_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-063-civic-route/10_regulator_correspondence/078_regulator_correspondence_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-063-civic-route/10_regulator_correspondence/079_regulator_correspondence_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-063-civic-route/10_regulator_correspondence/080_regulator_correspondence_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-063-civic-route/11_risk_assessments/081_risk_assessments_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-063-civic-route/11_risk_assessments/082_risk_assessments_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-063-civic-route/11_risk_assessments/083_risk_assessments_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-063-civic-route/11_risk_assessments/084_risk_assessments_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-063-civic-route/11_risk_assessments/085_risk_assessments_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-063-civic-route/11_risk_assessments/086_risk_assessments_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-063-civic-route/11_risk_assessments/087_risk_assessments_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-063-civic-route/11_risk_assessments/088_risk_assessments_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-063-civic-route/12_remediation/089_remediation_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-063-civic-route/12_remediation/090_remediation_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-063-civic-route/12_remediation/091_remediation_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-063-civic-route/12_remediation/092_remediation_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-063-civic-route/12_remediation/093_remediation_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-063-civic-route/12_remediation/094_remediation_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-063-civic-route/12_remediation/095_remediation_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-063-civic-route/12_remediation/096_remediation_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-063-civic-route/12_remediation/097_civic_route_impact_population.xlsx"], "gold_output": {"advice_markdown": "# Decision note — CivicRoute location-data inquiry\n\n## Recommendation\n\nStop or correct supported unauthorized flows and complete valid opt-outs. The reconciled record supports 9 scoped actions and leaves 3 items on evidence hold.\n\nSelected option: `civic-route:scoped-evidence`.\n\n## Why this is the supported option\n\nJoin device and account identity, precise-location flows, ad integrations, inventory, and opt-out execution. Notice, opt-out, and sensitive-location rules apply to the exact processing purpose and period.\n\n## Supported actions\n\n### CBP-063-01 — training completion gap (high)\n\ndelivery must use notices-civicroute_mobility@example.test under CB-PR-3003-R357; the only matched receipt used archive-metropulse_advertising_llc@example.test under CB-PR-3003-E379. Identity resolves to ENT-063-1000, revision REV-2025.1 is current, and Samuel Kim is active with capacity 1.\n\nAction: Create purpose-level remediation rows and hold unmatched device identities. Owner: Samuel Kim; due 2026-09-08.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/001_data_inventory_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/02_processing_records/013_processing_records_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/025_security_incidents_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/037_consumer_requests_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_civic_route_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-063-04 — minor-consent issue (high)\n\nthe controlling threshold is 15% under CB-PR-3003-R720; the independently calculated result is 22% under CB-PR-3003-E612. Identity resolves to ENT-063-1003, revision REV-2025.4 is current, and Farah Ibrahim is active with capacity 6.\n\nAction: Create purpose-level remediation rows and hold unmatched device identities. Owner: Farah Ibrahim; due 2026-09-05.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/004_data_inventory_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/02_processing_records/016_processing_records_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/028_security_incidents_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/040_consumer_requests_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_civic_route_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-063-05 — consent-record deficiency (critical)\n\napproval must come from Nora Chen under CB-PR-3003-R557; the effective approval record names Henry Cho under CB-PR-3003-E921. Identity resolves to ENT-063-1004, revision REV-2025.5 is current, and Dominic Alvarez is active with capacity 1.\n\nAction: Create purpose-level remediation rows and hold unmatched device identities. Owner: Dominic Alvarez; due 2026-09-04.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/005_data_inventory_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/017_vendor_reviews_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/029_security_incidents_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/041_notices_consents_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/07_transfer_mechanisms/053_transfer_mechanisms_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/09_training/065_training_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_civic_route_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-063-07 — sensitive-data classification (medium)\n\nthe permission is limited to Colorado Attorney General under CB-PR-3003-R889; the matched activity occurred in Colorado under CB-PR-3003-E252. Identity resolves to ENT-063-1006, revision REV-2025.7 is current, and Henry Cho is active with capacity 1.\n\nAction: Create purpose-level remediation rows and hold unmatched device identities. Owner: Henry Cho; due 2026-09-02.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/007_data_inventory_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/019_vendor_reviews_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/031_security_incidents_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/043_notices_consents_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_civic_route_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-063-08 — notice-practice mismatch (medium)\n\nthe operative cap is $442,000.00 under CB-PR-3003-R262; the matched ledger population totals $603,962.00 under CB-PR-3003-E162. Identity resolves to ENT-063-1007, revision REV-2025.1 is current, and Maya Ellison is active with capacity 1.\n\nAction: Create purpose-level remediation rows and hold unmatched device identities. Owner: Maya Ellison; due 2026-09-01.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/008_data_inventory_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/020_vendor_reviews_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/032_security_incidents_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/044_notices_consents_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/07_transfer_mechanisms/056_transfer_mechanisms_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_civic_route_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-063-09 — retention schedule conflict (critical)\n\ndelivery must use notices-civicroute_mobility@example.test under CB-PR-3003-R328; the only matched receipt used archive-metropulse_advertising_llc@example.test under CB-PR-3003-E536. Identity resolves to ENT-063-1008, revision REV-2025.2 is current, and Jonas Feld is active with capacity 3.\n\nAction: Create purpose-level remediation rows and hold unmatched device identities. Owner: Jonas Feld; due 2026-08-31.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/02_processing_records/009_processing_records_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/021_vendor_reviews_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/033_consumer_requests_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/045_notices_consents_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_civic_route_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-063-10 — risk-assessment omission (critical)\n\nan open exception blocks completion under CB-PR-3003-R893; the current status is open and unresolved under CB-PR-3003-E940. Identity resolves to ENT-063-1009, revision REV-2025.3 is current, and Willa Novak is active with capacity 1.\n\nAction: Create purpose-level remediation rows and hold unmatched device identities. Owner: Willa Novak; due 2026-09-08.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/02_processing_records/010_processing_records_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/022_vendor_reviews_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/034_consumer_requests_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/046_notices_consents_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_civic_route_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-063-11 — processing-purpose gap (high)\n\ncompletion is required by 2025-05-17 under CB-PR-3003-R351; the current event record shows completion on 2025-05-31 under CB-PR-3003-E167. Identity resolves to ENT-063-1010, revision REV-2025.4 is current, and Owen Delgado is active with capacity 1.\n\nAction: Create purpose-level remediation rows and hold unmatched device identities. Owner: Owen Delgado; due 2026-09-07.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/02_processing_records/011_processing_records_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/023_vendor_reviews_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/035_consumer_requests_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/047_notices_consents_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/08_retention_deletion/059_retention_deletion_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/09_training/071_training_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_civic_route_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-063-12 — cross-border transfer gap (critical)\n\nthe controlling threshold is 9% under CB-PR-3003-R224; the independently calculated result is 17% under CB-PR-3003-E901. Identity resolves to ENT-063-1011, revision REV-2025.5 is current, and Priya Raman is active with capacity 3.\n\nAction: Create purpose-level remediation rows and hold unmatched device identities. Owner: Priya Raman; due 2026-09-06.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/02_processing_records/012_processing_records_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/024_vendor_reviews_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/036_consumer_requests_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/048_notices_consents_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_civic_route_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n## Evidence holds\n\n- **CBP-063-02 — processor-contract omission**: the operational record relies on a superseded control revision. Next evidence: an operational record using the current effective revision. Sources: `/workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/002_data_inventory_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/02_processing_records/014_processing_records_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/026_security_incidents_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/038_consumer_requests_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/07_transfer_mechanisms/050_transfer_mechanisms_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/08_retention_deletion/062_retention_deletion_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_civic_route_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-063-03 — access-request deadline**: two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key. Next evidence: an approved immutable entity crosswalk. Sources: `/workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/003_data_inventory_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/02_processing_records/015_processing_records_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/027_security_incidents_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/039_consumer_requests_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_civic_route_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-063-06 — deletion-job failure**: the operational record relies on a superseded control revision. Next evidence: an operational record using the current effective revision. Sources: `/workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/006_data_inventory_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/018_vendor_reviews_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/030_security_incidents_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/042_notices_consents_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_civic_route_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n## Alternatives considered\n\n- `civic-route:blanket-hold` — Freeze the entire matter population: Treat supported actions and genuinely ambiguous records as if they were equally unresolved.\n- `civic-route:shortcut` — Disable all analytics globally based on the existence of one ad integration.: Use a plausible summary or one source without completing the controlling joins.\n\n## Assumptions and limits\n\nThis decision is limited to cb100-063-civic-route, the supplied synthetic records, and the matter state as of 2026-09-09. Similar names, stale revisions, and pending authority are not treated as proof.\n", "decision": {"actions": [{"determination": "delivery must use notices-civicroute_mobility@example.test under CB-PR-3003-R357; the only matched receipt used archive-metropulse_advertising_llc@example.test under CB-PR-3003-E379. Identity resolves to ENT-063-1000, revision REV-2025.1 is current, and Samuel Kim is active with capacity 1.", "due_date": "2026-09-08", "id": "ACT-CBP-063-01", "identity_id": "ENT-063-1000", "issue": "training completion gap", "owner": "Samuel Kim", "portfolio_key": "CBP-063-01", "recommended_action": "Create purpose-level remediation rows and hold unmatched device identities. Owner: Samuel Kim; due 2026-09-08.", "severity": "high", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/001_data_inventory_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/02_processing_records/013_processing_records_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/025_security_incidents_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/037_consumer_requests_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_civic_route_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "the controlling threshold is 15% under CB-PR-3003-R720; the independently calculated result is 22% under CB-PR-3003-E612. Identity resolves to ENT-063-1003, revision REV-2025.4 is current, and Farah Ibrahim is active with capacity 6.", "due_date": "2026-09-05", "id": "ACT-CBP-063-04", "identity_id": "ENT-063-1003", "issue": "minor-consent issue", "owner": "Farah Ibrahim", "portfolio_key": "CBP-063-04", "recommended_action": "Create purpose-level remediation rows and hold unmatched device identities. Owner: Farah Ibrahim; due 2026-09-05.", "severity": "high", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/004_data_inventory_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/02_processing_records/016_processing_records_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/028_security_incidents_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/040_consumer_requests_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_civic_route_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "approval must come from Nora Chen under CB-PR-3003-R557; the effective approval record names Henry Cho under CB-PR-3003-E921. Identity resolves to ENT-063-1004, revision REV-2025.5 is current, and Dominic Alvarez is active with capacity 1.", "due_date": "2026-09-04", "id": "ACT-CBP-063-05", "identity_id": "ENT-063-1004", "issue": "consent-record deficiency", "owner": "Dominic Alvarez", "portfolio_key": "CBP-063-05", "recommended_action": "Create purpose-level remediation rows and hold unmatched device identities. Owner: Dominic Alvarez; due 2026-09-04.", "severity": "critical", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/005_data_inventory_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/017_vendor_reviews_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/029_security_incidents_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/041_notices_consents_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/07_transfer_mechanisms/053_transfer_mechanisms_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/09_training/065_training_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_civic_route_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "the permission is limited to Colorado Attorney General under CB-PR-3003-R889; the matched activity occurred in Colorado under CB-PR-3003-E252. Identity resolves to ENT-063-1006, revision REV-2025.7 is current, and Henry Cho is active with capacity 1.", "due_date": "2026-09-02", "id": "ACT-CBP-063-07", "identity_id": "ENT-063-1006", "issue": "sensitive-data classification", "owner": "Henry Cho", "portfolio_key": "CBP-063-07", "recommended_action": "Create purpose-level remediation rows and hold unmatched device identities. Owner: Henry Cho; due 2026-09-02.", "severity": "medium", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/007_data_inventory_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/019_vendor_reviews_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/031_security_incidents_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/043_notices_consents_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_civic_route_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "the operative cap is $442,000.00 under CB-PR-3003-R262; the matched ledger population totals $603,962.00 under CB-PR-3003-E162. Identity resolves to ENT-063-1007, revision REV-2025.1 is current, and Maya Ellison is active with capacity 1.", "due_date": "2026-09-01", "id": "ACT-CBP-063-08", "identity_id": "ENT-063-1007", "issue": "notice-practice mismatch", "owner": "Maya Ellison", "portfolio_key": "CBP-063-08", "recommended_action": "Create purpose-level remediation rows and hold unmatched device identities. Owner: Maya Ellison; due 2026-09-01.", "severity": "medium", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/008_data_inventory_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/020_vendor_reviews_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/032_security_incidents_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/044_notices_consents_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/07_transfer_mechanisms/056_transfer_mechanisms_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_civic_route_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "delivery must use notices-civicroute_mobility@example.test under CB-PR-3003-R328; the only matched receipt used archive-metropulse_advertising_llc@example.test under CB-PR-3003-E536. Identity resolves to ENT-063-1008, revision REV-2025.2 is current, and Jonas Feld is active with capacity 3.", "due_date": "2026-08-31", "id": "ACT-CBP-063-09", "identity_id": "ENT-063-1008", "issue": "retention schedule conflict", "owner": "Jonas Feld", "portfolio_key": "CBP-063-09", "recommended_action": "Create purpose-level remediation rows and hold unmatched device identities. Owner: Jonas Feld; due 2026-08-31.", "severity": "critical", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_processing_records/009_processing_records_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/021_vendor_reviews_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/033_consumer_requests_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/045_notices_consents_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_civic_route_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "an open exception blocks completion under CB-PR-3003-R893; the current status is open and unresolved under CB-PR-3003-E940. Identity resolves to ENT-063-1009, revision REV-2025.3 is current, and Willa Novak is active with capacity 1.", "due_date": "2026-09-08", "id": "ACT-CBP-063-10", "identity_id": "ENT-063-1009", "issue": "risk-assessment omission", "owner": "Willa Novak", "portfolio_key": "CBP-063-10", "recommended_action": "Create purpose-level remediation rows and hold unmatched device identities. Owner: Willa Novak; due 2026-09-08.", "severity": "critical", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_processing_records/010_processing_records_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/022_vendor_reviews_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/034_consumer_requests_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/046_notices_consents_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_civic_route_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "completion is required by 2025-05-17 under CB-PR-3003-R351; the current event record shows completion on 2025-05-31 under CB-PR-3003-E167. Identity resolves to ENT-063-1010, revision REV-2025.4 is current, and Owen Delgado is active with capacity 1.", "due_date": "2026-09-07", "id": "ACT-CBP-063-11", "identity_id": "ENT-063-1010", "issue": "processing-purpose gap", "owner": "Owen Delgado", "portfolio_key": "CBP-063-11", "recommended_action": "Create purpose-level remediation rows and hold unmatched device identities. Owner: Owen Delgado; due 2026-09-07.", "severity": "high", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_processing_records/011_processing_records_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/023_vendor_reviews_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/035_consumer_requests_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/047_notices_consents_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/08_retention_deletion/059_retention_deletion_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/09_training/071_training_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_civic_route_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "the controlling threshold is 9% under CB-PR-3003-R224; the independently calculated result is 17% under CB-PR-3003-E901. Identity resolves to ENT-063-1011, revision REV-2025.5 is current, and Priya Raman is active with capacity 3.", "due_date": "2026-09-06", "id": "ACT-CBP-063-12", "identity_id": "ENT-063-1011", "issue": "cross-border transfer gap", "owner": "Priya Raman", "portfolio_key": "CBP-063-12", "recommended_action": "Create purpose-level remediation rows and hold unmatched device identities. Owner: Priya Raman; due 2026-09-06.", "severity": "critical", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_processing_records/012_processing_records_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/024_vendor_reviews_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/036_consumer_requests_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/048_notices_consents_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_civic_route_impact_population.xlsx"]}], "as_of": "2026-09-09", "decision": {"alternatives_considered": ["civic-route:blanket-hold", "civic-route:shortcut"], "question": "What must CivicRoute stop, disclose, or honor after the location-data inquiry?", "rationale": "The four-part causal test supports 9 scoped actions and leaves 3 records on evidence hold. Notice, opt-out, and sensitive-location rules apply to the exact processing purpose and period.", "recommendation": "Stop or correct supported unauthorized flows and complete valid opt-outs.", "selected_option_id": "civic-route:scoped-evidence"}, "holds": [{"id": "HOLD-CBP-063-02", "issue": "processor-contract omission", "portfolio_key": "CBP-063-02", "reason": "the operational record relies on a superseded control revision", "required_next_evidence": "an operational record using the current effective revision", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/002_data_inventory_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/02_processing_records/014_processing_records_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/026_security_incidents_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/038_consumer_requests_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/07_transfer_mechanisms/050_transfer_mechanisms_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/08_retention_deletion/062_retention_deletion_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_civic_route_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-063-03", "issue": "access-request deadline", "portfolio_key": "CBP-063-03", "reason": "two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key", "required_next_evidence": "an approved immutable entity crosswalk", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/003_data_inventory_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/02_processing_records/015_processing_records_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/027_security_incidents_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/039_consumer_requests_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_civic_route_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-063-06", "issue": "deletion-job failure", "portfolio_key": "CBP-063-06", "reason": "the operational record relies on a superseded control revision", "required_next_evidence": "an operational record using the current effective revision", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/006_data_inventory_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/018_vendor_reviews_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/030_security_incidents_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/042_notices_consents_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_civic_route_impact_population.xlsx"]}], "matter_number": "CB-PR-3003", "prepared_for": "CivicRoute Mobility", "schema_version": "counselbench.decision.v3", "task_id": "cb100-063-civic-route"}, "matter_register": {"matter_number": "CB-PR-3003", "rows": [{"decision_option_id": "civic-route:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-08", "issue": "training completion gap", "matter_number": "CB-PR-3003", "owner": "Samuel Kim", "portfolio_key": "CBP-063-01", "row_id": "REG-CBP-063-01", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/001_data_inventory_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/02_processing_records/013_processing_records_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/025_security_incidents_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/037_consumer_requests_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_civic_route_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "civic-route:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "the operational record relies on a superseded control revision", "issue": "processor-contract omission", "matter_number": "CB-PR-3003", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-063-02", "row_id": "REG-CBP-063-02", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/002_data_inventory_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/02_processing_records/014_processing_records_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/026_security_incidents_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/038_consumer_requests_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/07_transfer_mechanisms/050_transfer_mechanisms_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/08_retention_deletion/062_retention_deletion_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_civic_route_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "civic-route:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key", "issue": "access-request deadline", "matter_number": "CB-PR-3003", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-063-03", "row_id": "REG-CBP-063-03", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/003_data_inventory_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/02_processing_records/015_processing_records_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/027_security_incidents_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/039_consumer_requests_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_civic_route_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "civic-route:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-05", "issue": "minor-consent issue", "matter_number": "CB-PR-3003", "owner": "Farah Ibrahim", "portfolio_key": "CBP-063-04", "row_id": "REG-CBP-063-04", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/004_data_inventory_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/02_processing_records/016_processing_records_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/028_security_incidents_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/040_consumer_requests_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_civic_route_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "civic-route:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-04", "issue": "consent-record deficiency", "matter_number": "CB-PR-3003", "owner": "Dominic Alvarez", "portfolio_key": "CBP-063-05", "row_id": "REG-CBP-063-05", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/005_data_inventory_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/017_vendor_reviews_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/029_security_incidents_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/041_notices_consents_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/07_transfer_mechanisms/053_transfer_mechanisms_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/09_training/065_training_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_civic_route_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "civic-route:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "the operational record relies on a superseded control revision", "issue": "deletion-job failure", "matter_number": "CB-PR-3003", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-063-06", "row_id": "REG-CBP-063-06", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/006_data_inventory_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/018_vendor_reviews_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/030_security_incidents_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/042_notices_consents_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_civic_route_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "civic-route:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-02", "issue": "sensitive-data classification", "matter_number": "CB-PR-3003", "owner": "Henry Cho", "portfolio_key": "CBP-063-07", "row_id": "REG-CBP-063-07", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/007_data_inventory_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/019_vendor_reviews_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/031_security_incidents_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/043_notices_consents_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_civic_route_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "civic-route:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-01", "issue": "notice-practice mismatch", "matter_number": "CB-PR-3003", "owner": "Maya Ellison", "portfolio_key": "CBP-063-08", "row_id": "REG-CBP-063-08", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/008_data_inventory_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/020_vendor_reviews_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/032_security_incidents_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/044_notices_consents_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/07_transfer_mechanisms/056_transfer_mechanisms_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_civic_route_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "civic-route:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-08-31", "issue": "retention schedule conflict", "matter_number": "CB-PR-3003", "owner": "Jonas Feld", "portfolio_key": "CBP-063-09", "row_id": "REG-CBP-063-09", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_processing_records/009_processing_records_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/021_vendor_reviews_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/033_consumer_requests_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/045_notices_consents_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_civic_route_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "civic-route:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-08", "issue": "risk-assessment omission", "matter_number": "CB-PR-3003", "owner": "Willa Novak", "portfolio_key": "CBP-063-10", "row_id": "REG-CBP-063-10", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_processing_records/010_processing_records_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/022_vendor_reviews_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/034_consumer_requests_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/046_notices_consents_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_civic_route_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "civic-route:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-07", "issue": "processing-purpose gap", "matter_number": "CB-PR-3003", "owner": "Owen Delgado", "portfolio_key": "CBP-063-11", "row_id": "REG-CBP-063-11", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_processing_records/011_processing_records_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/023_vendor_reviews_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/035_consumer_requests_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/047_notices_consents_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/08_retention_deletion/059_retention_deletion_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/09_training/071_training_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_civic_route_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "civic-route:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-06", "issue": "cross-border transfer gap", "matter_number": "CB-PR-3003", "owner": "Priya Raman", "portfolio_key": "CBP-063-12", "row_id": "REG-CBP-063-12", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_processing_records/012_processing_records_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/024_vendor_reviews_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/036_consumer_requests_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/048_notices_consents_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_civic_route_impact_population.xlsx"]}], "schema_version": "counselbench.matter-register.v3", "task_id": "cb100-063-civic-route"}}, "metadata": {"benchmark": "CounselBench-100", "code_license": "Apache-2.0", "data_license": "CC-BY-4.0", "deadline": "2026-09-09", "document_count": 97, "evidence_holds": 3, "jurisdiction": "Colorado", "matter_number": "CB-PR-3003", "mcp_commit": "9a96ea6e5913736f92b88345bf51caeaaa8e719f", "mcp_package": "@modelcontextprotocol/server-filesystem@2026.7.10", "practice_area": "privacy-regulatory", "reference_tool_calls": 86, "required_evidence_reads": 57, "supported_actions": 9, "synthetic": true, "venue": "Colorado Attorney General", "version": "3.1.0"}, "prompt": "A late record changed the picture this morning. What must CivicRoute stop, disclose, or honor after the location-data inquiry? A mobility app shared precise location segments through an advertising integration not reflected in its processing inventory or opt-out flow. The team needs the call by 2026-09-09. Make the matter record usable by operations after your review, but do not turn ambiguity into an accusation or obligation.", "rubric": {"criteria": [{"category": "investigation", "description": "Inventory the production and use targeted searches to locate records across native formats.", "id": "investigation.discover_production"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Complete every task-specific identity, authority, operations, and approval read before the first state transition.", "id": "investigation.read_before_write"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Inspect designated source metadata before relying on those records.", "id": "investigation.custody_before_write"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "Select the supported option 'civic-route:scoped-evidence' after applying the four-part test.", "id": "decision.selected_option"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "Identify both rejected approaches and explain why a one-source shortcut and a blanket hold are wrong.", "id": "decision.alternatives"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-063-01 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/001_data_inventory_source_export.md rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-063-01.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_processing_records/013_processing_records_source_export.json for training completion gap.", "id": "investigation.CBP-063-01.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/025_security_incidents_source_export.md to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-063-01.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/037_consumer_requests_source_export.json.", "id": "investigation.CBP-063-01.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-063-01 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-063-01.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-063-01 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-063-01.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-063-02 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/002_data_inventory_source_export.txt rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-063-02.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_processing_records/014_processing_records_source_export.xml for processor-contract omission.", "id": "investigation.CBP-063-02.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/026_security_incidents_source_export.txt to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-063-02.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/038_consumer_requests_source_export.xml.", "id": "investigation.CBP-063-02.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-063-02 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is the operational record relies on a superseded control revision.", "id": "decision.CBP-063-02.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-063-02 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-063-02.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-063-03 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/003_data_inventory_source_export.eml rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-063-03.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_processing_records/015_processing_records_source_export.html for access-request deadline.", "id": "investigation.CBP-063-03.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/027_security_incidents_source_export.eml to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-063-03.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/039_consumer_requests_source_export.html.", "id": "investigation.CBP-063-03.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-063-03 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key.", "id": "decision.CBP-063-03.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-063-03 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-063-03.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-063-04 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/004_data_inventory_source_export.csv rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-063-04.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_processing_records/016_processing_records_source_export.pdf for minor-consent issue.", "id": "investigation.CBP-063-04.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/028_security_incidents_source_export.csv to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-063-04.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/040_consumer_requests_source_export.pdf.", "id": "investigation.CBP-063-04.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-063-04 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-063-04.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-063-04 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-063-04.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-063-05 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/005_data_inventory_source_export.json rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-063-05.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/017_vendor_reviews_source_export.md for consent-record deficiency.", "id": "investigation.CBP-063-05.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/029_security_incidents_source_export.json to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-063-05.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/041_notices_consents_source_export.md.", "id": "investigation.CBP-063-05.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-063-05 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-063-05.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-063-05 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-063-05.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-063-06 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/006_data_inventory_source_export.xml rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-063-06.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/018_vendor_reviews_source_export.txt for deletion-job failure.", "id": "investigation.CBP-063-06.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/030_security_incidents_source_export.xml to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-063-06.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/042_notices_consents_source_export.txt.", "id": "investigation.CBP-063-06.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-063-06 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is the operational record relies on a superseded control revision.", "id": "decision.CBP-063-06.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-063-06 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-063-06.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-063-07 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/007_data_inventory_source_export.html rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-063-07.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/019_vendor_reviews_source_export.eml for sensitive-data classification.", "id": "investigation.CBP-063-07.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/031_security_incidents_source_export.html to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-063-07.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/043_notices_consents_source_export.eml.", "id": "investigation.CBP-063-07.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-063-07 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-063-07.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-063-07 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-063-07.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-063-08 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/008_data_inventory_source_export.pdf rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-063-08.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/020_vendor_reviews_source_export.csv for notice-practice mismatch.", "id": "investigation.CBP-063-08.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/032_security_incidents_source_export.pdf to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-063-08.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/044_notices_consents_source_export.csv.", "id": "investigation.CBP-063-08.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-063-08 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-063-08.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-063-08 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-063-08.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-063-09 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_processing_records/009_processing_records_source_export.md rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-063-09.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/021_vendor_reviews_source_export.json for retention schedule conflict.", "id": "investigation.CBP-063-09.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/033_consumer_requests_source_export.md to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-063-09.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/045_notices_consents_source_export.json.", "id": "investigation.CBP-063-09.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-063-09 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-063-09.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-063-09 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-063-09.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-063-10 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_processing_records/010_processing_records_source_export.txt rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-063-10.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/022_vendor_reviews_source_export.xml for risk-assessment omission.", "id": "investigation.CBP-063-10.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/034_consumer_requests_source_export.txt to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-063-10.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/046_notices_consents_source_export.xml.", "id": "investigation.CBP-063-10.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-063-10 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-063-10.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-063-10 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-063-10.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-063-11 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_processing_records/011_processing_records_source_export.eml rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-063-11.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/023_vendor_reviews_source_export.html for processing-purpose gap.", "id": "investigation.CBP-063-11.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/035_consumer_requests_source_export.eml to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-063-11.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/047_notices_consents_source_export.html.", "id": "investigation.CBP-063-11.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-063-11 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-063-11.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-063-11 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-063-11.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-063-12 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_processing_records/012_processing_records_source_export.csv rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-063-12.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/024_vendor_reviews_source_export.pdf for cross-border transfer gap.", "id": "investigation.CBP-063-12.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/036_consumer_requests_source_export.csv to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-063-12.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/048_notices_consents_source_export.pdf.", "id": "investigation.CBP-063-12.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-063-12 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-063-12.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-063-12 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-063-12.register"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Write the exact selected option, supported action population, evidence-hold population, facts, owners, deadlines, and citations.", "id": "state.exact_decision"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create one exact register row per portfolio key with no extra, missing, or modified row.", "id": "state.exact_register"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Leave only the three approved deliverables and perform no extra state-changing write.", "id": "state.write_scope_containment"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Read back decision.json, matter-register.json, and advice.md after their final writes.", "id": "state.postwrite_readback"}, {"category": "answer", "description": "Explain the selected recommendation, supported actions, holds, alternatives, and limitations with exact source anchors.", "id": "answer.decision_note"}], "decision_options": [{"approach": "Treat supported actions and genuinely ambiguous records as if they were equally unresolved.", "id": "civic-route:blanket-hold", "label": "Freeze the entire matter population"}, {"approach": "Apply the exact identity, current-state, authority, and revision test. Create purpose-level remediation rows and hold unmatched device identities.", "id": "civic-route:scoped-evidence", "label": "Stop or correct supported unauthorized flows and complete valid opt-outs."}, {"approach": "Use a plausible summary or one source without completing the controlling joins.", "id": "civic-route:shortcut", "label": "Disable all analytics globally based on the existence of one ad integration."}], "evaluation_narrative": {"authority": "Notice, opt-out, and sensitive-location rules apply to the exact processing purpose and period.", "observation": "Join device and account identity, precise-location flows, ad integrations, inventory, and opt-out execution.", "question": "What must CivicRoute stop, disclose, or honor after the location-data inquiry?", "register_action": "Create purpose-level remediation rows and hold unmatched device identities."}, "gates": ["all_required_evidence_precedes_first_write", "decision_criteria_complete", "register_state_exact", "write_scope_contained", "all_outputs_verified_by_readback"], "metadata_checks": 12, "metric": "weighted_criteria_score", "minimum_tool_calls": 86, "required_deliverables": ["decision.json", "matter-register.json", "advice.md"], "required_document_reads": 57, "type": "deterministic", "weights": {"advice": 0.15, "decision": 0.35, "investigation": 0.25, "state": 0.25}}, "task_id": "cb100-063-civic-route", "task_name": "CivicRoute location-data inquiry", "world_id": "counselbench-filesystem-mcp-v3"}
+{"context_files": ["task_files/cb100-064-deepwell-health/01_data_inventory/001_data_inventory_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-064-deepwell-health/01_data_inventory/002_data_inventory_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-064-deepwell-health/01_data_inventory/003_data_inventory_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-064-deepwell-health/01_data_inventory/004_data_inventory_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-064-deepwell-health/01_data_inventory/005_data_inventory_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-064-deepwell-health/01_data_inventory/006_data_inventory_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-064-deepwell-health/01_data_inventory/007_data_inventory_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-064-deepwell-health/01_data_inventory/008_data_inventory_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-064-deepwell-health/02_processing_records/009_processing_records_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-064-deepwell-health/02_processing_records/010_processing_records_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-064-deepwell-health/02_processing_records/011_processing_records_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-064-deepwell-health/02_processing_records/012_processing_records_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-064-deepwell-health/02_processing_records/013_processing_records_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-064-deepwell-health/02_processing_records/014_processing_records_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-064-deepwell-health/02_processing_records/015_processing_records_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-064-deepwell-health/02_processing_records/016_processing_records_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-064-deepwell-health/03_vendor_reviews/017_vendor_reviews_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-064-deepwell-health/03_vendor_reviews/018_vendor_reviews_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-064-deepwell-health/03_vendor_reviews/019_vendor_reviews_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-064-deepwell-health/03_vendor_reviews/020_vendor_reviews_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-064-deepwell-health/03_vendor_reviews/021_vendor_reviews_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-064-deepwell-health/03_vendor_reviews/022_vendor_reviews_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-064-deepwell-health/03_vendor_reviews/023_vendor_reviews_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-064-deepwell-health/03_vendor_reviews/024_vendor_reviews_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-064-deepwell-health/04_security_incidents/025_security_incidents_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-064-deepwell-health/04_security_incidents/026_security_incidents_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-064-deepwell-health/04_security_incidents/027_security_incidents_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-064-deepwell-health/04_security_incidents/028_security_incidents_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-064-deepwell-health/04_security_incidents/029_security_incidents_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-064-deepwell-health/04_security_incidents/030_security_incidents_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-064-deepwell-health/04_security_incidents/031_security_incidents_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-064-deepwell-health/04_security_incidents/032_security_incidents_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-064-deepwell-health/05_consumer_requests/033_consumer_requests_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-064-deepwell-health/05_consumer_requests/034_consumer_requests_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-064-deepwell-health/05_consumer_requests/035_consumer_requests_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-064-deepwell-health/05_consumer_requests/036_consumer_requests_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-064-deepwell-health/05_consumer_requests/037_consumer_requests_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-064-deepwell-health/05_consumer_requests/038_consumer_requests_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-064-deepwell-health/05_consumer_requests/039_consumer_requests_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-064-deepwell-health/05_consumer_requests/040_consumer_requests_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-064-deepwell-health/06_notices_consents/041_notices_consents_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-064-deepwell-health/06_notices_consents/042_notices_consents_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-064-deepwell-health/06_notices_consents/043_notices_consents_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-064-deepwell-health/06_notices_consents/044_notices_consents_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-064-deepwell-health/06_notices_consents/045_notices_consents_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-064-deepwell-health/06_notices_consents/046_notices_consents_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-064-deepwell-health/06_notices_consents/047_notices_consents_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-064-deepwell-health/06_notices_consents/048_notices_consents_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-064-deepwell-health/07_transfer_mechanisms/049_transfer_mechanisms_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-064-deepwell-health/07_transfer_mechanisms/050_transfer_mechanisms_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-064-deepwell-health/07_transfer_mechanisms/051_transfer_mechanisms_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-064-deepwell-health/07_transfer_mechanisms/052_transfer_mechanisms_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-064-deepwell-health/07_transfer_mechanisms/053_transfer_mechanisms_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-064-deepwell-health/07_transfer_mechanisms/054_transfer_mechanisms_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-064-deepwell-health/07_transfer_mechanisms/055_transfer_mechanisms_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-064-deepwell-health/07_transfer_mechanisms/056_transfer_mechanisms_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-064-deepwell-health/08_retention_deletion/057_retention_deletion_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-064-deepwell-health/08_retention_deletion/058_retention_deletion_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-064-deepwell-health/08_retention_deletion/059_retention_deletion_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-064-deepwell-health/08_retention_deletion/060_retention_deletion_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-064-deepwell-health/08_retention_deletion/061_retention_deletion_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-064-deepwell-health/08_retention_deletion/062_retention_deletion_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-064-deepwell-health/08_retention_deletion/063_retention_deletion_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-064-deepwell-health/08_retention_deletion/064_retention_deletion_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-064-deepwell-health/09_training/065_training_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-064-deepwell-health/09_training/066_training_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-064-deepwell-health/09_training/067_training_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-064-deepwell-health/09_training/068_training_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-064-deepwell-health/09_training/069_training_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-064-deepwell-health/09_training/070_training_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-064-deepwell-health/09_training/071_training_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-064-deepwell-health/09_training/072_training_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-064-deepwell-health/10_regulator_correspondence/073_regulator_correspondence_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-064-deepwell-health/10_regulator_correspondence/074_regulator_correspondence_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-064-deepwell-health/10_regulator_correspondence/075_regulator_correspondence_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-064-deepwell-health/10_regulator_correspondence/076_regulator_correspondence_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-064-deepwell-health/10_regulator_correspondence/077_regulator_correspondence_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-064-deepwell-health/10_regulator_correspondence/078_regulator_correspondence_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-064-deepwell-health/10_regulator_correspondence/079_regulator_correspondence_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-064-deepwell-health/10_regulator_correspondence/080_regulator_correspondence_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-064-deepwell-health/11_risk_assessments/081_risk_assessments_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-064-deepwell-health/11_risk_assessments/082_risk_assessments_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-064-deepwell-health/11_risk_assessments/083_risk_assessments_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-064-deepwell-health/11_risk_assessments/084_risk_assessments_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-064-deepwell-health/11_risk_assessments/085_risk_assessments_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-064-deepwell-health/11_risk_assessments/086_risk_assessments_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-064-deepwell-health/11_risk_assessments/087_risk_assessments_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-064-deepwell-health/11_risk_assessments/088_risk_assessments_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-064-deepwell-health/12_remediation/089_remediation_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-064-deepwell-health/12_remediation/090_remediation_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-064-deepwell-health/12_remediation/091_remediation_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-064-deepwell-health/12_remediation/092_remediation_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-064-deepwell-health/12_remediation/093_remediation_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-064-deepwell-health/12_remediation/094_remediation_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-064-deepwell-health/12_remediation/095_remediation_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-064-deepwell-health/12_remediation/096_remediation_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-064-deepwell-health/12_remediation/097_deepwell_health_impact_population.xlsx"], "gold_output": {"advice_markdown": "# Decision note — Deepwell breach-notice audit\n\n## Recommendation\n\nUse the earliest legally supported discovery event and notify the matched populations. The reconciled record supports 6 scoped actions and leaves 6 items on evidence hold.\n\nSelected option: `deepwell-health:scoped-evidence`.\n\n## Why this is the supported option\n\nReconcile vendor alerts, credential evidence, internal escalation, affected records, and regulator commitments. Notification clocks and contractual duties depend on supported discovery and jurisdiction-specific populations.\n\n## Supported actions\n\n### CBP-064-01 — regulator commitment overdue (medium)\n\nthe controlled population contains 93 records under CB-PR-3004-R651; the certification covers 82 records under CB-PR-3004-E291. Identity resolves to ENT-064-1000, revision REV-2026.1 is current, and Nora Chen is active with capacity 4.\n\nAction: Create jurisdiction-population rows with exact clock and evidence holds. Owner: Nora Chen; due 2026-09-12.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/001_data_inventory_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/02_processing_records/013_processing_records_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/025_security_incidents_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/037_consumer_requests_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_deepwell_health_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-064-03 — identity-verification inconsistency (high)\n\nthe operative cap is $1,402,000.00 under CB-PR-3004-R683; the matched ledger population totals $1,512,783.00 under CB-PR-3004-E981. Identity resolves to ENT-064-1002, revision REV-2026.3 is current, and Amara Patel is active with capacity 5.\n\nAction: Create jurisdiction-population rows with exact clock and evidence holds. Owner: Amara Patel; due 2026-09-10.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/003_data_inventory_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/02_processing_records/015_processing_records_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/027_security_incidents_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/039_consumer_requests_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/07_transfer_mechanisms/051_transfer_mechanisms_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/11_risk_assessments/087_risk_assessments_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_deepwell_health_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-064-04 — training completion gap (high)\n\ndelivery must use notices-deepwell_health_services@example.test under CB-PR-3004-R137; the only matched receipt used archive-morrow_claims_clearinghouse@example.test under CB-PR-3004-E102. Identity resolves to ENT-064-1003, revision REV-2026.4 is current, and Samuel Kim is active with capacity 4.\n\nAction: Create jurisdiction-population rows with exact clock and evidence holds. Owner: Samuel Kim; due 2026-09-09.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/004_data_inventory_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/02_processing_records/016_processing_records_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/028_security_incidents_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/040_consumer_requests_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/07_transfer_mechanisms/052_transfer_mechanisms_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_deepwell_health_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-064-10 — sensitive-data classification (medium)\n\nthe permission is limited to New York Department of Financial Services under CB-PR-3004-R304; the matched activity occurred in New York under CB-PR-3004-E482. Identity resolves to ENT-064-1009, revision REV-2026.3 is current, and Henry Cho is active with capacity 3.\n\nAction: Create jurisdiction-population rows with exact clock and evidence holds. Owner: Henry Cho; due 2026-09-12.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/02_processing_records/010_processing_records_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/022_vendor_reviews_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/034_consumer_requests_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/046_notices_consents_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_deepwell_health_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-064-11 — notice-practice mismatch (high)\n\nthe operative cap is $4,762,000.00 under CB-PR-3004-R445; the matched ledger population totals $4,835,345.00 under CB-PR-3004-E279. Identity resolves to ENT-064-1010, revision REV-2026.4 is current, and Maya Ellison is active with capacity 2.\n\nAction: Create jurisdiction-population rows with exact clock and evidence holds. Owner: Maya Ellison; due 2026-09-11.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/02_processing_records/011_processing_records_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/023_vendor_reviews_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/035_consumer_requests_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/047_notices_consents_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_deepwell_health_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-064-12 — retention schedule conflict (critical)\n\ndelivery must use notices-deepwell_health_services@example.test under CB-PR-3004-R185; the only matched receipt used archive-morrow_claims_clearinghouse@example.test under CB-PR-3004-E899. Identity resolves to ENT-064-1011, revision REV-2026.5 is current, and Jonas Feld is active with capacity 1.\n\nAction: Create jurisdiction-population rows with exact clock and evidence holds. Owner: Jonas Feld; due 2026-09-10.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/02_processing_records/012_processing_records_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/024_vendor_reviews_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/036_consumer_requests_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/048_notices_consents_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/12_remediation/096_remediation_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/09_training/072_training_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_deepwell_health_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n## Evidence holds\n\n- **CBP-064-02 — subprocessor inventory mismatch**: two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key. Next evidence: an approved immutable entity crosswalk. Sources: `/workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/002_data_inventory_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/02_processing_records/014_processing_records_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/026_security_incidents_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/038_consumer_requests_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/08_retention_deletion/062_retention_deletion_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/10_regulator_correspondence/074_regulator_correspondence_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_deepwell_health_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-064-05 — processor-contract omission**: the operational record relies on a superseded control revision. Next evidence: an operational record using the current effective revision. Sources: `/workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/005_data_inventory_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/017_vendor_reviews_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/029_security_incidents_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/041_notices_consents_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/07_transfer_mechanisms/053_transfer_mechanisms_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/10_regulator_correspondence/077_regulator_correspondence_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_deepwell_health_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-064-06 — access-request deadline**: two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key. Next evidence: an approved immutable entity crosswalk. Sources: `/workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/006_data_inventory_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/018_vendor_reviews_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/030_security_incidents_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/042_notices_consents_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/12_remediation/090_remediation_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/07_transfer_mechanisms/054_transfer_mechanisms_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_deepwell_health_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-064-07 — minor-consent issue**: the current observation does not meet the operative trigger. Next evidence: a current observation that satisfies the operative trigger. Sources: `/workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/007_data_inventory_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/019_vendor_reviews_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/031_security_incidents_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/043_notices_consents_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/10_regulator_correspondence/079_regulator_correspondence_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_deepwell_health_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-064-08 — consent-record deficiency**: the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective. Next evidence: effective approval and an active owner with remaining capacity. Sources: `/workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/008_data_inventory_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/020_vendor_reviews_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/032_security_incidents_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/044_notices_consents_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_deepwell_health_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-064-09 — deletion-job failure**: the operational record relies on a superseded control revision. Next evidence: an operational record using the current effective revision. Sources: `/workspace/documents/02_processing_records/009_processing_records_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/021_vendor_reviews_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/033_consumer_requests_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/045_notices_consents_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/09_training/069_training_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/08_retention_deletion/057_retention_deletion_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_deepwell_health_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n## Alternatives considered\n\n- `deepwell-health:shortcut` — Use the first rumor as discovery and notify every customer in every jurisdiction.: Use a plausible summary or one source without completing the controlling joins.\n- `deepwell-health:blanket-hold` — Freeze the entire matter population: Treat supported actions and genuinely ambiguous records as if they were equally unresolved.\n\n## Assumptions and limits\n\nThis decision is limited to cb100-064-deepwell-health, the supplied synthetic records, and the matter state as of 2026-09-13. Similar names, stale revisions, and pending authority are not treated as proof.\n", "decision": {"actions": [{"determination": "the controlled population contains 93 records under CB-PR-3004-R651; the certification covers 82 records under CB-PR-3004-E291. Identity resolves to ENT-064-1000, revision REV-2026.1 is current, and Nora Chen is active with capacity 4.", "due_date": "2026-09-12", "id": "ACT-CBP-064-01", "identity_id": "ENT-064-1000", "issue": "regulator commitment overdue", "owner": "Nora Chen", "portfolio_key": "CBP-064-01", "recommended_action": "Create jurisdiction-population rows with exact clock and evidence holds. Owner: Nora Chen; due 2026-09-12.", "severity": "medium", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/001_data_inventory_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/02_processing_records/013_processing_records_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/025_security_incidents_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/037_consumer_requests_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_deepwell_health_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "the operative cap is $1,402,000.00 under CB-PR-3004-R683; the matched ledger population totals $1,512,783.00 under CB-PR-3004-E981. Identity resolves to ENT-064-1002, revision REV-2026.3 is current, and Amara Patel is active with capacity 5.", "due_date": "2026-09-10", "id": "ACT-CBP-064-03", "identity_id": "ENT-064-1002", "issue": "identity-verification inconsistency", "owner": "Amara Patel", "portfolio_key": "CBP-064-03", "recommended_action": "Create jurisdiction-population rows with exact clock and evidence holds. Owner: Amara Patel; due 2026-09-10.", "severity": "high", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/003_data_inventory_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/02_processing_records/015_processing_records_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/027_security_incidents_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/039_consumer_requests_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/07_transfer_mechanisms/051_transfer_mechanisms_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/11_risk_assessments/087_risk_assessments_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_deepwell_health_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "delivery must use notices-deepwell_health_services@example.test under CB-PR-3004-R137; the only matched receipt used archive-morrow_claims_clearinghouse@example.test under CB-PR-3004-E102. Identity resolves to ENT-064-1003, revision REV-2026.4 is current, and Samuel Kim is active with capacity 4.", "due_date": "2026-09-09", "id": "ACT-CBP-064-04", "identity_id": "ENT-064-1003", "issue": "training completion gap", "owner": "Samuel Kim", "portfolio_key": "CBP-064-04", "recommended_action": "Create jurisdiction-population rows with exact clock and evidence holds. Owner: Samuel Kim; due 2026-09-09.", "severity": "high", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/004_data_inventory_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/02_processing_records/016_processing_records_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/028_security_incidents_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/040_consumer_requests_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/07_transfer_mechanisms/052_transfer_mechanisms_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_deepwell_health_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "the permission is limited to New York Department of Financial Services under CB-PR-3004-R304; the matched activity occurred in New York under CB-PR-3004-E482. Identity resolves to ENT-064-1009, revision REV-2026.3 is current, and Henry Cho is active with capacity 3.", "due_date": "2026-09-12", "id": "ACT-CBP-064-10", "identity_id": "ENT-064-1009", "issue": "sensitive-data classification", "owner": "Henry Cho", "portfolio_key": "CBP-064-10", "recommended_action": "Create jurisdiction-population rows with exact clock and evidence holds. Owner: Henry Cho; due 2026-09-12.", "severity": "medium", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_processing_records/010_processing_records_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/022_vendor_reviews_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/034_consumer_requests_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/046_notices_consents_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_deepwell_health_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "the operative cap is $4,762,000.00 under CB-PR-3004-R445; the matched ledger population totals $4,835,345.00 under CB-PR-3004-E279. Identity resolves to ENT-064-1010, revision REV-2026.4 is current, and Maya Ellison is active with capacity 2.", "due_date": "2026-09-11", "id": "ACT-CBP-064-11", "identity_id": "ENT-064-1010", "issue": "notice-practice mismatch", "owner": "Maya Ellison", "portfolio_key": "CBP-064-11", "recommended_action": "Create jurisdiction-population rows with exact clock and evidence holds. Owner: Maya Ellison; due 2026-09-11.", "severity": "high", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_processing_records/011_processing_records_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/023_vendor_reviews_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/035_consumer_requests_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/047_notices_consents_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_deepwell_health_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "delivery must use notices-deepwell_health_services@example.test under CB-PR-3004-R185; the only matched receipt used archive-morrow_claims_clearinghouse@example.test under CB-PR-3004-E899. Identity resolves to ENT-064-1011, revision REV-2026.5 is current, and Jonas Feld is active with capacity 1.", "due_date": "2026-09-10", "id": "ACT-CBP-064-12", "identity_id": "ENT-064-1011", "issue": "retention schedule conflict", "owner": "Jonas Feld", "portfolio_key": "CBP-064-12", "recommended_action": "Create jurisdiction-population rows with exact clock and evidence holds. Owner: Jonas Feld; due 2026-09-10.", "severity": "critical", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_processing_records/012_processing_records_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/024_vendor_reviews_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/036_consumer_requests_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/048_notices_consents_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/096_remediation_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/09_training/072_training_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_deepwell_health_impact_population.xlsx"]}], "as_of": "2026-09-13", "decision": {"alternatives_considered": ["deepwell-health:shortcut", "deepwell-health:blanket-hold"], "question": "What is Deepwell's defensible incident discovery date and notification scope?", "rationale": "The four-part causal test supports 6 scoped actions and leaves 6 records on evidence hold. Notification clocks and contractual duties depend on supported discovery and jurisdiction-specific populations.", "recommendation": "Use the earliest legally supported discovery event and notify the matched populations.", "selected_option_id": "deepwell-health:scoped-evidence"}, "holds": [{"id": "HOLD-CBP-064-02", "issue": "subprocessor inventory mismatch", "portfolio_key": "CBP-064-02", "reason": "two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key", "required_next_evidence": "an approved immutable entity crosswalk", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/002_data_inventory_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/02_processing_records/014_processing_records_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/026_security_incidents_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/038_consumer_requests_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/08_retention_deletion/062_retention_deletion_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/10_regulator_correspondence/074_regulator_correspondence_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_deepwell_health_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-064-05", "issue": "processor-contract omission", "portfolio_key": "CBP-064-05", "reason": "the operational record relies on a superseded control revision", "required_next_evidence": "an operational record using the current effective revision", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/005_data_inventory_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/017_vendor_reviews_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/029_security_incidents_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/041_notices_consents_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/07_transfer_mechanisms/053_transfer_mechanisms_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/10_regulator_correspondence/077_regulator_correspondence_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_deepwell_health_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-064-06", "issue": "access-request deadline", "portfolio_key": "CBP-064-06", "reason": "two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key", "required_next_evidence": "an approved immutable entity crosswalk", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/006_data_inventory_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/018_vendor_reviews_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/030_security_incidents_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/042_notices_consents_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/090_remediation_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/07_transfer_mechanisms/054_transfer_mechanisms_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_deepwell_health_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-064-07", "issue": "minor-consent issue", "portfolio_key": "CBP-064-07", "reason": "the current observation does not meet the operative trigger", "required_next_evidence": "a current observation that satisfies the operative trigger", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/007_data_inventory_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/019_vendor_reviews_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/031_security_incidents_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/043_notices_consents_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/10_regulator_correspondence/079_regulator_correspondence_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_deepwell_health_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-064-08", "issue": "consent-record deficiency", "portfolio_key": "CBP-064-08", "reason": "the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective", "required_next_evidence": "effective approval and an active owner with remaining capacity", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/008_data_inventory_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/020_vendor_reviews_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/032_security_incidents_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/044_notices_consents_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_deepwell_health_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-064-09", "issue": "deletion-job failure", "portfolio_key": "CBP-064-09", "reason": "the operational record relies on a superseded control revision", "required_next_evidence": "an operational record using the current effective revision", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_processing_records/009_processing_records_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/021_vendor_reviews_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/033_consumer_requests_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/045_notices_consents_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/09_training/069_training_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/08_retention_deletion/057_retention_deletion_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_deepwell_health_impact_population.xlsx"]}], "matter_number": "CB-PR-3004", "prepared_for": "Deepwell Health Services", "schema_version": "counselbench.decision.v3", "task_id": "cb100-064-deepwell-health"}, "matter_register": {"matter_number": "CB-PR-3004", "rows": [{"decision_option_id": "deepwell-health:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-12", "issue": "regulator commitment overdue", "matter_number": "CB-PR-3004", "owner": "Nora Chen", "portfolio_key": "CBP-064-01", "row_id": "REG-CBP-064-01", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/001_data_inventory_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/02_processing_records/013_processing_records_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/025_security_incidents_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/037_consumer_requests_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_deepwell_health_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "deepwell-health:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key", "issue": "subprocessor inventory mismatch", "matter_number": "CB-PR-3004", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-064-02", "row_id": "REG-CBP-064-02", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/002_data_inventory_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/02_processing_records/014_processing_records_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/026_security_incidents_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/038_consumer_requests_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/08_retention_deletion/062_retention_deletion_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/10_regulator_correspondence/074_regulator_correspondence_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_deepwell_health_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "deepwell-health:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-10", "issue": "identity-verification inconsistency", "matter_number": "CB-PR-3004", "owner": "Amara Patel", "portfolio_key": "CBP-064-03", "row_id": "REG-CBP-064-03", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/003_data_inventory_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/02_processing_records/015_processing_records_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/027_security_incidents_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/039_consumer_requests_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/07_transfer_mechanisms/051_transfer_mechanisms_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/11_risk_assessments/087_risk_assessments_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_deepwell_health_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "deepwell-health:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-09", "issue": "training completion gap", "matter_number": "CB-PR-3004", "owner": "Samuel Kim", "portfolio_key": "CBP-064-04", "row_id": "REG-CBP-064-04", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/004_data_inventory_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/02_processing_records/016_processing_records_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/028_security_incidents_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/040_consumer_requests_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/07_transfer_mechanisms/052_transfer_mechanisms_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_deepwell_health_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "deepwell-health:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "the operational record relies on a superseded control revision", "issue": "processor-contract omission", "matter_number": "CB-PR-3004", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-064-05", "row_id": "REG-CBP-064-05", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/005_data_inventory_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/017_vendor_reviews_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/029_security_incidents_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/041_notices_consents_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/07_transfer_mechanisms/053_transfer_mechanisms_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/10_regulator_correspondence/077_regulator_correspondence_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_deepwell_health_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "deepwell-health:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key", "issue": "access-request deadline", "matter_number": "CB-PR-3004", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-064-06", "row_id": "REG-CBP-064-06", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/006_data_inventory_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/018_vendor_reviews_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/030_security_incidents_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/042_notices_consents_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/090_remediation_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/07_transfer_mechanisms/054_transfer_mechanisms_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_deepwell_health_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "deepwell-health:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "the current observation does not meet the operative trigger", "issue": "minor-consent issue", "matter_number": "CB-PR-3004", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-064-07", "row_id": "REG-CBP-064-07", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/007_data_inventory_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/019_vendor_reviews_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/031_security_incidents_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/043_notices_consents_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/10_regulator_correspondence/079_regulator_correspondence_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_deepwell_health_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "deepwell-health:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective", "issue": "consent-record deficiency", "matter_number": "CB-PR-3004", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-064-08", "row_id": "REG-CBP-064-08", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/008_data_inventory_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/020_vendor_reviews_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/032_security_incidents_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/044_notices_consents_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_deepwell_health_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "deepwell-health:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "the operational record relies on a superseded control revision", "issue": "deletion-job failure", "matter_number": "CB-PR-3004", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-064-09", "row_id": "REG-CBP-064-09", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_processing_records/009_processing_records_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/021_vendor_reviews_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/033_consumer_requests_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/045_notices_consents_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/09_training/069_training_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/08_retention_deletion/057_retention_deletion_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_deepwell_health_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "deepwell-health:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-12", "issue": "sensitive-data classification", "matter_number": "CB-PR-3004", "owner": "Henry Cho", "portfolio_key": "CBP-064-10", "row_id": "REG-CBP-064-10", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_processing_records/010_processing_records_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/022_vendor_reviews_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/034_consumer_requests_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/046_notices_consents_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_deepwell_health_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "deepwell-health:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-11", "issue": "notice-practice mismatch", "matter_number": "CB-PR-3004", "owner": "Maya Ellison", "portfolio_key": "CBP-064-11", "row_id": "REG-CBP-064-11", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_processing_records/011_processing_records_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/023_vendor_reviews_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/035_consumer_requests_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/047_notices_consents_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_deepwell_health_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "deepwell-health:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-10", "issue": "retention schedule conflict", "matter_number": "CB-PR-3004", "owner": "Jonas Feld", "portfolio_key": "CBP-064-12", "row_id": "REG-CBP-064-12", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_processing_records/012_processing_records_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/024_vendor_reviews_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/036_consumer_requests_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/048_notices_consents_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/096_remediation_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/09_training/072_training_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_deepwell_health_impact_population.xlsx"]}], "schema_version": "counselbench.matter-register.v3", "task_id": "cb100-064-deepwell-health"}}, "metadata": {"benchmark": "CounselBench-100", "code_license": "Apache-2.0", "data_license": "CC-BY-4.0", "deadline": "2026-09-13", "document_count": 97, "evidence_holds": 6, "jurisdiction": "New York", "matter_number": "CB-PR-3004", "mcp_commit": "9a96ea6e5913736f92b88345bf51caeaaa8e719f", "mcp_package": "@modelcontextprotocol/server-filesystem@2026.7.10", "practice_area": "privacy-regulatory", "reference_tool_calls": 88, "required_evidence_reads": 64, "supported_actions": 6, "synthetic": true, "venue": "New York Department of Financial Services", "version": "3.1.0"}, "prompt": "The client wants a decision, not another document inventory. What is Deepwell's defensible incident discovery date and notification scope? A credential incident moved through multiple vendors, creating disputed discovery dates and incomplete regulator commitments. The team needs the call by 2026-09-13. Put the supported calls into the matter register and leave me a short note I can use with the partner.", "rubric": {"criteria": [{"category": "investigation", "description": "Inventory the production and use targeted searches to locate records across native formats.", "id": "investigation.discover_production"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Complete every task-specific identity, authority, operations, and approval read before the first state transition.", "id": "investigation.read_before_write"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Inspect designated source metadata before relying on those records.", "id": "investigation.custody_before_write"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "Select the supported option 'deepwell-health:scoped-evidence' after applying the four-part test.", "id": "decision.selected_option"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "Identify both rejected approaches and explain why a one-source shortcut and a blanket hold are wrong.", "id": "decision.alternatives"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-064-01 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/001_data_inventory_source_export.md rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-064-01.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_processing_records/013_processing_records_source_export.json for regulator commitment overdue.", "id": "investigation.CBP-064-01.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/025_security_incidents_source_export.md to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-064-01.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/037_consumer_requests_source_export.json.", "id": "investigation.CBP-064-01.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-064-01 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-064-01.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-064-01 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-064-01.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-064-02 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/002_data_inventory_source_export.txt rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-064-02.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_processing_records/014_processing_records_source_export.xml for subprocessor inventory mismatch.", "id": "investigation.CBP-064-02.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/026_security_incidents_source_export.txt to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-064-02.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/038_consumer_requests_source_export.xml.", "id": "investigation.CBP-064-02.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-064-02 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key.", "id": "decision.CBP-064-02.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-064-02 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-064-02.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-064-03 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/003_data_inventory_source_export.eml rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-064-03.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_processing_records/015_processing_records_source_export.html for identity-verification inconsistency.", "id": "investigation.CBP-064-03.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/027_security_incidents_source_export.eml to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-064-03.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/039_consumer_requests_source_export.html.", "id": "investigation.CBP-064-03.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-064-03 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-064-03.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-064-03 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-064-03.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-064-04 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/004_data_inventory_source_export.csv rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-064-04.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_processing_records/016_processing_records_source_export.pdf for training completion gap.", "id": "investigation.CBP-064-04.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/028_security_incidents_source_export.csv to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-064-04.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/040_consumer_requests_source_export.pdf.", "id": "investigation.CBP-064-04.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-064-04 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-064-04.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-064-04 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-064-04.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-064-05 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/005_data_inventory_source_export.json rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-064-05.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/017_vendor_reviews_source_export.md for processor-contract omission.", "id": "investigation.CBP-064-05.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/029_security_incidents_source_export.json to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-064-05.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/041_notices_consents_source_export.md.", "id": "investigation.CBP-064-05.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-064-05 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is the operational record relies on a superseded control revision.", "id": "decision.CBP-064-05.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-064-05 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-064-05.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-064-06 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/006_data_inventory_source_export.xml rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-064-06.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/018_vendor_reviews_source_export.txt for access-request deadline.", "id": "investigation.CBP-064-06.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/030_security_incidents_source_export.xml to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-064-06.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/042_notices_consents_source_export.txt.", "id": "investigation.CBP-064-06.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-064-06 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key.", "id": "decision.CBP-064-06.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-064-06 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-064-06.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-064-07 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/007_data_inventory_source_export.html rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-064-07.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/019_vendor_reviews_source_export.eml for minor-consent issue.", "id": "investigation.CBP-064-07.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/031_security_incidents_source_export.html to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-064-07.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/043_notices_consents_source_export.eml.", "id": "investigation.CBP-064-07.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-064-07 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is the current observation does not meet the operative trigger.", "id": "decision.CBP-064-07.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-064-07 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-064-07.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-064-08 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/008_data_inventory_source_export.pdf rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-064-08.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/020_vendor_reviews_source_export.csv for consent-record deficiency.", "id": "investigation.CBP-064-08.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/032_security_incidents_source_export.pdf to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-064-08.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/044_notices_consents_source_export.csv.", "id": "investigation.CBP-064-08.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-064-08 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective.", "id": "decision.CBP-064-08.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-064-08 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-064-08.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-064-09 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_processing_records/009_processing_records_source_export.md rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-064-09.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/021_vendor_reviews_source_export.json for deletion-job failure.", "id": "investigation.CBP-064-09.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/033_consumer_requests_source_export.md to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-064-09.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/045_notices_consents_source_export.json.", "id": "investigation.CBP-064-09.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-064-09 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is the operational record relies on a superseded control revision.", "id": "decision.CBP-064-09.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-064-09 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-064-09.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-064-10 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_processing_records/010_processing_records_source_export.txt rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-064-10.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/022_vendor_reviews_source_export.xml for sensitive-data classification.", "id": "investigation.CBP-064-10.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/034_consumer_requests_source_export.txt to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-064-10.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/046_notices_consents_source_export.xml.", "id": "investigation.CBP-064-10.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-064-10 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-064-10.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-064-10 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-064-10.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-064-11 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_processing_records/011_processing_records_source_export.eml rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-064-11.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/023_vendor_reviews_source_export.html for notice-practice mismatch.", "id": "investigation.CBP-064-11.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/035_consumer_requests_source_export.eml to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-064-11.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/047_notices_consents_source_export.html.", "id": "investigation.CBP-064-11.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-064-11 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-064-11.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-064-11 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-064-11.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-064-12 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_processing_records/012_processing_records_source_export.csv rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-064-12.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/024_vendor_reviews_source_export.pdf for retention schedule conflict.", "id": "investigation.CBP-064-12.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/036_consumer_requests_source_export.csv to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-064-12.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/048_notices_consents_source_export.pdf.", "id": "investigation.CBP-064-12.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-064-12 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-064-12.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-064-12 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-064-12.register"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Write the exact selected option, supported action population, evidence-hold population, facts, owners, deadlines, and citations.", "id": "state.exact_decision"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create one exact register row per portfolio key with no extra, missing, or modified row.", "id": "state.exact_register"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Leave only the three approved deliverables and perform no extra state-changing write.", "id": "state.write_scope_containment"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Read back decision.json, matter-register.json, and advice.md after their final writes.", "id": "state.postwrite_readback"}, {"category": "answer", "description": "Explain the selected recommendation, supported actions, holds, alternatives, and limitations with exact source anchors.", "id": "answer.decision_note"}], "decision_options": [{"approach": "Apply the exact identity, current-state, authority, and revision test. Create jurisdiction-population rows with exact clock and evidence holds.", "id": "deepwell-health:scoped-evidence", "label": "Use the earliest legally supported discovery event and notify the matched populations."}, {"approach": "Use a plausible summary or one source without completing the controlling joins.", "id": "deepwell-health:shortcut", "label": "Use the first rumor as discovery and notify every customer in every jurisdiction."}, {"approach": "Treat supported actions and genuinely ambiguous records as if they were equally unresolved.", "id": "deepwell-health:blanket-hold", "label": "Freeze the entire matter population"}], "evaluation_narrative": {"authority": "Notification clocks and contractual duties depend on supported discovery and jurisdiction-specific populations.", "observation": "Reconcile vendor alerts, credential evidence, internal escalation, affected records, and regulator commitments.", "question": "What is Deepwell's defensible incident discovery date and notification scope?", "register_action": "Create jurisdiction-population rows with exact clock and evidence holds."}, "gates": ["all_required_evidence_precedes_first_write", "decision_criteria_complete", "register_state_exact", "write_scope_contained", "all_outputs_verified_by_readback"], "metadata_checks": 8, "metric": "weighted_criteria_score", "minimum_tool_calls": 88, "required_deliverables": ["decision.json", "matter-register.json", "advice.md"], "required_document_reads": 64, "type": "deterministic", "weights": {"advice": 0.15, "decision": 0.35, "investigation": 0.25, "state": 0.25}}, "task_id": "cb100-064-deepwell-health", "task_name": "Deepwell breach-notice audit", "world_id": "counselbench-filesystem-mcp-v3"}
+{"context_files": ["task_files/cb100-065-everfield-market/01_data_inventory/001_data_inventory_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-065-everfield-market/01_data_inventory/002_data_inventory_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-065-everfield-market/01_data_inventory/003_data_inventory_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-065-everfield-market/01_data_inventory/004_data_inventory_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-065-everfield-market/01_data_inventory/005_data_inventory_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-065-everfield-market/01_data_inventory/006_data_inventory_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-065-everfield-market/01_data_inventory/007_data_inventory_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-065-everfield-market/01_data_inventory/008_data_inventory_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-065-everfield-market/02_processing_records/009_processing_records_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-065-everfield-market/02_processing_records/010_processing_records_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-065-everfield-market/02_processing_records/011_processing_records_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-065-everfield-market/02_processing_records/012_processing_records_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-065-everfield-market/02_processing_records/013_processing_records_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-065-everfield-market/02_processing_records/014_processing_records_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-065-everfield-market/02_processing_records/015_processing_records_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-065-everfield-market/02_processing_records/016_processing_records_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-065-everfield-market/03_vendor_reviews/017_vendor_reviews_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-065-everfield-market/03_vendor_reviews/018_vendor_reviews_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-065-everfield-market/03_vendor_reviews/019_vendor_reviews_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-065-everfield-market/03_vendor_reviews/020_vendor_reviews_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-065-everfield-market/03_vendor_reviews/021_vendor_reviews_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-065-everfield-market/03_vendor_reviews/022_vendor_reviews_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-065-everfield-market/03_vendor_reviews/023_vendor_reviews_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-065-everfield-market/03_vendor_reviews/024_vendor_reviews_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-065-everfield-market/04_security_incidents/025_security_incidents_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-065-everfield-market/04_security_incidents/026_security_incidents_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-065-everfield-market/04_security_incidents/027_security_incidents_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-065-everfield-market/04_security_incidents/028_security_incidents_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-065-everfield-market/04_security_incidents/029_security_incidents_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-065-everfield-market/04_security_incidents/030_security_incidents_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-065-everfield-market/04_security_incidents/031_security_incidents_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-065-everfield-market/04_security_incidents/032_security_incidents_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-065-everfield-market/05_consumer_requests/033_consumer_requests_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-065-everfield-market/05_consumer_requests/034_consumer_requests_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-065-everfield-market/05_consumer_requests/035_consumer_requests_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-065-everfield-market/05_consumer_requests/036_consumer_requests_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-065-everfield-market/05_consumer_requests/037_consumer_requests_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-065-everfield-market/05_consumer_requests/038_consumer_requests_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-065-everfield-market/05_consumer_requests/039_consumer_requests_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-065-everfield-market/05_consumer_requests/040_consumer_requests_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-065-everfield-market/06_notices_consents/041_notices_consents_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-065-everfield-market/06_notices_consents/042_notices_consents_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-065-everfield-market/06_notices_consents/043_notices_consents_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-065-everfield-market/06_notices_consents/044_notices_consents_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-065-everfield-market/06_notices_consents/045_notices_consents_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-065-everfield-market/06_notices_consents/046_notices_consents_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-065-everfield-market/06_notices_consents/047_notices_consents_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-065-everfield-market/06_notices_consents/048_notices_consents_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-065-everfield-market/07_transfer_mechanisms/049_transfer_mechanisms_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-065-everfield-market/07_transfer_mechanisms/050_transfer_mechanisms_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-065-everfield-market/07_transfer_mechanisms/051_transfer_mechanisms_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-065-everfield-market/07_transfer_mechanisms/052_transfer_mechanisms_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-065-everfield-market/07_transfer_mechanisms/053_transfer_mechanisms_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-065-everfield-market/07_transfer_mechanisms/054_transfer_mechanisms_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-065-everfield-market/07_transfer_mechanisms/055_transfer_mechanisms_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-065-everfield-market/07_transfer_mechanisms/056_transfer_mechanisms_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-065-everfield-market/08_retention_deletion/057_retention_deletion_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-065-everfield-market/08_retention_deletion/058_retention_deletion_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-065-everfield-market/08_retention_deletion/059_retention_deletion_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-065-everfield-market/08_retention_deletion/060_retention_deletion_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-065-everfield-market/08_retention_deletion/061_retention_deletion_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-065-everfield-market/08_retention_deletion/062_retention_deletion_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-065-everfield-market/08_retention_deletion/063_retention_deletion_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-065-everfield-market/08_retention_deletion/064_retention_deletion_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-065-everfield-market/09_training/065_training_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-065-everfield-market/09_training/066_training_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-065-everfield-market/09_training/067_training_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-065-everfield-market/09_training/068_training_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-065-everfield-market/09_training/069_training_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-065-everfield-market/09_training/070_training_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-065-everfield-market/09_training/071_training_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-065-everfield-market/09_training/072_training_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-065-everfield-market/10_regulator_correspondence/073_regulator_correspondence_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-065-everfield-market/10_regulator_correspondence/074_regulator_correspondence_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-065-everfield-market/10_regulator_correspondence/075_regulator_correspondence_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-065-everfield-market/10_regulator_correspondence/076_regulator_correspondence_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-065-everfield-market/10_regulator_correspondence/077_regulator_correspondence_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-065-everfield-market/10_regulator_correspondence/078_regulator_correspondence_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-065-everfield-market/10_regulator_correspondence/079_regulator_correspondence_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-065-everfield-market/10_regulator_correspondence/080_regulator_correspondence_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-065-everfield-market/11_risk_assessments/081_risk_assessments_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-065-everfield-market/11_risk_assessments/082_risk_assessments_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-065-everfield-market/11_risk_assessments/083_risk_assessments_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-065-everfield-market/11_risk_assessments/084_risk_assessments_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-065-everfield-market/11_risk_assessments/085_risk_assessments_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-065-everfield-market/11_risk_assessments/086_risk_assessments_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-065-everfield-market/11_risk_assessments/087_risk_assessments_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-065-everfield-market/11_risk_assessments/088_risk_assessments_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-065-everfield-market/12_remediation/089_remediation_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-065-everfield-market/12_remediation/090_remediation_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-065-everfield-market/12_remediation/091_remediation_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-065-everfield-market/12_remediation/092_remediation_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-065-everfield-market/12_remediation/093_remediation_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-065-everfield-market/12_remediation/094_remediation_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-065-everfield-market/12_remediation/095_remediation_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-065-everfield-market/12_remediation/096_remediation_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-065-everfield-market/12_remediation/097_everfield_market_impact_population.xlsx"], "gold_output": {"advice_markdown": "# Decision note — Everfield loyalty-data assessment\n\n## Recommendation\n\nRestrict or remediate supported uses without deleting permitted loyalty processing. The reconciled record supports 8 scoped actions and leaves 4 items on evidence hold.\n\nSelected option: `everfield-market:scoped-evidence`.\n\n## Why this is the supported option\n\nJoin profile fields, inferred health segments, consent events, retention jobs, and processor terms by purpose. Sensitive-data, consent, retention, and processor obligations attach to exact purposes and periods.\n\n## Supported actions\n\n### CBP-065-02 — cross-border transfer gap (critical)\n\nthe controlling threshold is 9% under CB-PR-3005-R874; the independently calculated result is 17% under CB-PR-3005-E516. Identity resolves to ENT-065-1001, revision REV-2025.2 is current, and Sofia Bennett is active with capacity 2.\n\nAction: Create purpose-period rows and hold records with unresolved source category. Owner: Sofia Bennett; due 2026-09-14.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/002_data_inventory_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/02_processing_records/014_processing_records_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/026_security_incidents_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/038_consumer_requests_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/07_transfer_mechanisms/050_transfer_mechanisms_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_everfield_market_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-065-03 — incident-notification clock (medium)\n\napproval must come from Lena Varga under CB-PR-3005-R497; the effective approval record names Caleb Hassan under CB-PR-3005-E599. Identity resolves to ENT-065-1002, revision REV-2025.3 is current, and Micah Sullivan is active with capacity 2.\n\nAction: Create purpose-period rows and hold records with unresolved source category. Owner: Micah Sullivan; due 2026-09-13.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/003_data_inventory_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/02_processing_records/015_processing_records_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/027_security_incidents_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/039_consumer_requests_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/07_transfer_mechanisms/051_transfer_mechanisms_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/10_regulator_correspondence/075_regulator_correspondence_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_everfield_market_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-065-04 — regulator commitment overdue (high)\n\nthe controlled population contains 236 records under CB-PR-3005-R234; the certification covers 204 records under CB-PR-3005-E319. Identity resolves to ENT-065-1003, revision REV-2025.4 is current, and Nora Chen is active with capacity 5.\n\nAction: Create purpose-period rows and hold records with unresolved source category. Owner: Nora Chen; due 2026-09-12.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/004_data_inventory_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/02_processing_records/016_processing_records_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/028_security_incidents_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/040_consumer_requests_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/07_transfer_mechanisms/052_transfer_mechanisms_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/10_regulator_correspondence/076_regulator_correspondence_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_everfield_market_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-065-06 — identity-verification inconsistency (medium)\n\nthe operative cap is $25,000.00 under CB-PR-3005-R180; the matched ledger population totals $125,380.00 under CB-PR-3005-E475. Identity resolves to ENT-065-1005, revision REV-2025.6 is current, and Amara Patel is active with capacity 3.\n\nAction: Create purpose-period rows and hold records with unresolved source category. Owner: Amara Patel; due 2026-09-10.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/006_data_inventory_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/018_vendor_reviews_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/030_security_incidents_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/042_notices_consents_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_everfield_market_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-065-08 — processor-contract omission (medium)\n\nan open exception blocks completion under CB-PR-3005-R107; the current status is open and unresolved under CB-PR-3005-E947. Identity resolves to ENT-065-1007, revision REV-2025.1 is current, and Talia Brooks is active with capacity 6.\n\nAction: Create purpose-period rows and hold records with unresolved source category. Owner: Talia Brooks; due 2026-09-08.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/008_data_inventory_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/020_vendor_reviews_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/032_security_incidents_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/044_notices_consents_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/10_regulator_correspondence/080_regulator_correspondence_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_everfield_market_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-065-09 — access-request deadline (medium)\n\ncompletion is required by 2025-11-25 under CB-PR-3005-R423; the current event record shows completion on 2025-12-04 under CB-PR-3005-E383. Identity resolves to ENT-065-1008, revision REV-2025.2 is current, and Adrian Mensah is active with capacity 5.\n\nAction: Create purpose-period rows and hold records with unresolved source category. Owner: Adrian Mensah; due 2026-09-07.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/02_processing_records/009_processing_records_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/021_vendor_reviews_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/033_consumer_requests_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/045_notices_consents_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_everfield_market_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-065-10 — minor-consent issue (critical)\n\nthe controlling threshold is 7% under CB-PR-3005-R942; the independently calculated result is 13% under CB-PR-3005-E467. Identity resolves to ENT-065-1009, revision REV-2025.3 is current, and Farah Ibrahim is active with capacity 2.\n\nAction: Create purpose-period rows and hold records with unresolved source category. Owner: Farah Ibrahim; due 2026-09-15.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/02_processing_records/010_processing_records_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/022_vendor_reviews_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/034_consumer_requests_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/046_notices_consents_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/12_remediation/094_remediation_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/08_retention_deletion/058_retention_deletion_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_everfield_market_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-065-12 — deletion-job failure (low)\n\nthe controlled population contains 219 records under CB-PR-3005-R777; the certification covers 181 records under CB-PR-3005-E298. Identity resolves to ENT-065-1011, revision REV-2025.5 is current, and Leona Park is active with capacity 1.\n\nAction: Create purpose-period rows and hold records with unresolved source category. Owner: Leona Park; due 2026-09-13.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/02_processing_records/012_processing_records_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/024_vendor_reviews_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/036_consumer_requests_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/048_notices_consents_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/12_remediation/096_remediation_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_everfield_market_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n## Evidence holds\n\n- **CBP-065-01 — processing-purpose gap**: two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key. Next evidence: an approved immutable entity crosswalk. Sources: `/workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/001_data_inventory_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/02_processing_records/013_processing_records_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/025_security_incidents_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/037_consumer_requests_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_everfield_market_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-065-05 — subprocessor inventory mismatch**: two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key. Next evidence: an approved immutable entity crosswalk. Sources: `/workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/005_data_inventory_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/017_vendor_reviews_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/029_security_incidents_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/041_notices_consents_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/07_transfer_mechanisms/053_transfer_mechanisms_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/12_remediation/089_remediation_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_everfield_market_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-065-07 — training completion gap**: the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective. Next evidence: effective approval and an active owner with remaining capacity. Sources: `/workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/007_data_inventory_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/019_vendor_reviews_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/031_security_incidents_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/043_notices_consents_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/09_training/067_training_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_everfield_market_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-065-11 — consent-record deficiency**: the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective. Next evidence: effective approval and an active owner with remaining capacity. Sources: `/workspace/documents/02_processing_records/011_processing_records_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/023_vendor_reviews_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/035_consumer_requests_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/047_notices_consents_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/11_risk_assessments/083_risk_assessments_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_everfield_market_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n## Alternatives considered\n\n- `everfield-market:shortcut` �� Apply the strictest rule to the entire loyalty database regardless of purpose.: Use a plausible summary or one source without completing the controlling joins.\n- `everfield-market:blanket-hold` — Freeze the entire matter population: Treat supported actions and genuinely ambiguous records as if they were equally unresolved.\n\n## Assumptions and limits\n\nThis decision is limited to cb100-065-everfield-market, the supplied synthetic records, and the matter state as of 2026-09-16. Similar names, stale revisions, and pending authority are not treated as proof.\n", "decision": {"actions": [{"determination": "the controlling threshold is 9% under CB-PR-3005-R874; the independently calculated result is 17% under CB-PR-3005-E516. Identity resolves to ENT-065-1001, revision REV-2025.2 is current, and Sofia Bennett is active with capacity 2.", "due_date": "2026-09-14", "id": "ACT-CBP-065-02", "identity_id": "ENT-065-1001", "issue": "cross-border transfer gap", "owner": "Sofia Bennett", "portfolio_key": "CBP-065-02", "recommended_action": "Create purpose-period rows and hold records with unresolved source category. Owner: Sofia Bennett; due 2026-09-14.", "severity": "critical", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/002_data_inventory_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/02_processing_records/014_processing_records_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/026_security_incidents_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/038_consumer_requests_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/07_transfer_mechanisms/050_transfer_mechanisms_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_everfield_market_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "approval must come from Lena Varga under CB-PR-3005-R497; the effective approval record names Caleb Hassan under CB-PR-3005-E599. Identity resolves to ENT-065-1002, revision REV-2025.3 is current, and Micah Sullivan is active with capacity 2.", "due_date": "2026-09-13", "id": "ACT-CBP-065-03", "identity_id": "ENT-065-1002", "issue": "incident-notification clock", "owner": "Micah Sullivan", "portfolio_key": "CBP-065-03", "recommended_action": "Create purpose-period rows and hold records with unresolved source category. Owner: Micah Sullivan; due 2026-09-13.", "severity": "medium", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/003_data_inventory_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/02_processing_records/015_processing_records_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/027_security_incidents_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/039_consumer_requests_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/07_transfer_mechanisms/051_transfer_mechanisms_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/10_regulator_correspondence/075_regulator_correspondence_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_everfield_market_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "the controlled population contains 236 records under CB-PR-3005-R234; the certification covers 204 records under CB-PR-3005-E319. Identity resolves to ENT-065-1003, revision REV-2025.4 is current, and Nora Chen is active with capacity 5.", "due_date": "2026-09-12", "id": "ACT-CBP-065-04", "identity_id": "ENT-065-1003", "issue": "regulator commitment overdue", "owner": "Nora Chen", "portfolio_key": "CBP-065-04", "recommended_action": "Create purpose-period rows and hold records with unresolved source category. Owner: Nora Chen; due 2026-09-12.", "severity": "high", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/004_data_inventory_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/02_processing_records/016_processing_records_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/028_security_incidents_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/040_consumer_requests_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/07_transfer_mechanisms/052_transfer_mechanisms_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/10_regulator_correspondence/076_regulator_correspondence_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_everfield_market_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "the operative cap is $25,000.00 under CB-PR-3005-R180; the matched ledger population totals $125,380.00 under CB-PR-3005-E475. Identity resolves to ENT-065-1005, revision REV-2025.6 is current, and Amara Patel is active with capacity 3.", "due_date": "2026-09-10", "id": "ACT-CBP-065-06", "identity_id": "ENT-065-1005", "issue": "identity-verification inconsistency", "owner": "Amara Patel", "portfolio_key": "CBP-065-06", "recommended_action": "Create purpose-period rows and hold records with unresolved source category. Owner: Amara Patel; due 2026-09-10.", "severity": "medium", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/006_data_inventory_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/018_vendor_reviews_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/030_security_incidents_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/042_notices_consents_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_everfield_market_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "an open exception blocks completion under CB-PR-3005-R107; the current status is open and unresolved under CB-PR-3005-E947. Identity resolves to ENT-065-1007, revision REV-2025.1 is current, and Talia Brooks is active with capacity 6.", "due_date": "2026-09-08", "id": "ACT-CBP-065-08", "identity_id": "ENT-065-1007", "issue": "processor-contract omission", "owner": "Talia Brooks", "portfolio_key": "CBP-065-08", "recommended_action": "Create purpose-period rows and hold records with unresolved source category. Owner: Talia Brooks; due 2026-09-08.", "severity": "medium", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/008_data_inventory_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/020_vendor_reviews_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/032_security_incidents_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/044_notices_consents_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/10_regulator_correspondence/080_regulator_correspondence_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_everfield_market_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "completion is required by 2025-11-25 under CB-PR-3005-R423; the current event record shows completion on 2025-12-04 under CB-PR-3005-E383. Identity resolves to ENT-065-1008, revision REV-2025.2 is current, and Adrian Mensah is active with capacity 5.", "due_date": "2026-09-07", "id": "ACT-CBP-065-09", "identity_id": "ENT-065-1008", "issue": "access-request deadline", "owner": "Adrian Mensah", "portfolio_key": "CBP-065-09", "recommended_action": "Create purpose-period rows and hold records with unresolved source category. Owner: Adrian Mensah; due 2026-09-07.", "severity": "medium", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_processing_records/009_processing_records_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/021_vendor_reviews_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/033_consumer_requests_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/045_notices_consents_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_everfield_market_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "the controlling threshold is 7% under CB-PR-3005-R942; the independently calculated result is 13% under CB-PR-3005-E467. Identity resolves to ENT-065-1009, revision REV-2025.3 is current, and Farah Ibrahim is active with capacity 2.", "due_date": "2026-09-15", "id": "ACT-CBP-065-10", "identity_id": "ENT-065-1009", "issue": "minor-consent issue", "owner": "Farah Ibrahim", "portfolio_key": "CBP-065-10", "recommended_action": "Create purpose-period rows and hold records with unresolved source category. Owner: Farah Ibrahim; due 2026-09-15.", "severity": "critical", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_processing_records/010_processing_records_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/022_vendor_reviews_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/034_consumer_requests_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/046_notices_consents_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/094_remediation_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/08_retention_deletion/058_retention_deletion_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_everfield_market_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "the controlled population contains 219 records under CB-PR-3005-R777; the certification covers 181 records under CB-PR-3005-E298. Identity resolves to ENT-065-1011, revision REV-2025.5 is current, and Leona Park is active with capacity 1.", "due_date": "2026-09-13", "id": "ACT-CBP-065-12", "identity_id": "ENT-065-1011", "issue": "deletion-job failure", "owner": "Leona Park", "portfolio_key": "CBP-065-12", "recommended_action": "Create purpose-period rows and hold records with unresolved source category. Owner: Leona Park; due 2026-09-13.", "severity": "low", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_processing_records/012_processing_records_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/024_vendor_reviews_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/036_consumer_requests_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/048_notices_consents_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/096_remediation_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_everfield_market_impact_population.xlsx"]}], "as_of": "2026-09-16", "decision": {"alternatives_considered": ["everfield-market:shortcut", "everfield-market:blanket-hold"], "question": "Which Everfield loyalty uses are permitted, and what consent, retention, or vendor changes are required?", "rationale": "The four-part causal test supports 8 scoped actions and leaves 4 records on evidence hold. Sensitive-data, consent, retention, and processor obligations attach to exact purposes and periods.", "recommendation": "Restrict or remediate supported uses without deleting permitted loyalty processing.", "selected_option_id": "everfield-market:scoped-evidence"}, "holds": [{"id": "HOLD-CBP-065-01", "issue": "processing-purpose gap", "portfolio_key": "CBP-065-01", "reason": "two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key", "required_next_evidence": "an approved immutable entity crosswalk", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/001_data_inventory_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/02_processing_records/013_processing_records_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/025_security_incidents_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/037_consumer_requests_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_everfield_market_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-065-05", "issue": "subprocessor inventory mismatch", "portfolio_key": "CBP-065-05", "reason": "two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key", "required_next_evidence": "an approved immutable entity crosswalk", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/005_data_inventory_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/017_vendor_reviews_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/029_security_incidents_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/041_notices_consents_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/07_transfer_mechanisms/053_transfer_mechanisms_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/089_remediation_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_everfield_market_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-065-07", "issue": "training completion gap", "portfolio_key": "CBP-065-07", "reason": "the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective", "required_next_evidence": "effective approval and an active owner with remaining capacity", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/007_data_inventory_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/019_vendor_reviews_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/031_security_incidents_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/043_notices_consents_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/09_training/067_training_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_everfield_market_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-065-11", "issue": "consent-record deficiency", "portfolio_key": "CBP-065-11", "reason": "the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective", "required_next_evidence": "effective approval and an active owner with remaining capacity", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_processing_records/011_processing_records_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/023_vendor_reviews_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/035_consumer_requests_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/047_notices_consents_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/11_risk_assessments/083_risk_assessments_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_everfield_market_impact_population.xlsx"]}], "matter_number": "CB-PR-3005", "prepared_for": "Everfield Markets", "schema_version": "counselbench.decision.v3", "task_id": "cb100-065-everfield-market"}, "matter_register": {"matter_number": "CB-PR-3005", "rows": [{"decision_option_id": "everfield-market:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key", "issue": "processing-purpose gap", "matter_number": "CB-PR-3005", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-065-01", "row_id": "REG-CBP-065-01", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/001_data_inventory_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/02_processing_records/013_processing_records_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/025_security_incidents_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/037_consumer_requests_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_everfield_market_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "everfield-market:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-14", "issue": "cross-border transfer gap", "matter_number": "CB-PR-3005", "owner": "Sofia Bennett", "portfolio_key": "CBP-065-02", "row_id": "REG-CBP-065-02", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/002_data_inventory_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/02_processing_records/014_processing_records_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/026_security_incidents_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/038_consumer_requests_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/07_transfer_mechanisms/050_transfer_mechanisms_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_everfield_market_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "everfield-market:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-13", "issue": "incident-notification clock", "matter_number": "CB-PR-3005", "owner": "Micah Sullivan", "portfolio_key": "CBP-065-03", "row_id": "REG-CBP-065-03", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/003_data_inventory_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/02_processing_records/015_processing_records_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/027_security_incidents_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/039_consumer_requests_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/07_transfer_mechanisms/051_transfer_mechanisms_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/10_regulator_correspondence/075_regulator_correspondence_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_everfield_market_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "everfield-market:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-12", "issue": "regulator commitment overdue", "matter_number": "CB-PR-3005", "owner": "Nora Chen", "portfolio_key": "CBP-065-04", "row_id": "REG-CBP-065-04", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/004_data_inventory_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/02_processing_records/016_processing_records_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/028_security_incidents_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/040_consumer_requests_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/07_transfer_mechanisms/052_transfer_mechanisms_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/10_regulator_correspondence/076_regulator_correspondence_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_everfield_market_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "everfield-market:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key", "issue": "subprocessor inventory mismatch", "matter_number": "CB-PR-3005", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-065-05", "row_id": "REG-CBP-065-05", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/005_data_inventory_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/017_vendor_reviews_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/029_security_incidents_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/041_notices_consents_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/07_transfer_mechanisms/053_transfer_mechanisms_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/089_remediation_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_everfield_market_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "everfield-market:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-10", "issue": "identity-verification inconsistency", "matter_number": "CB-PR-3005", "owner": "Amara Patel", "portfolio_key": "CBP-065-06", "row_id": "REG-CBP-065-06", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/006_data_inventory_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/018_vendor_reviews_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/030_security_incidents_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/042_notices_consents_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_everfield_market_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "everfield-market:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective", "issue": "training completion gap", "matter_number": "CB-PR-3005", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-065-07", "row_id": "REG-CBP-065-07", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/007_data_inventory_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/019_vendor_reviews_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/031_security_incidents_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/043_notices_consents_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/09_training/067_training_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_everfield_market_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "everfield-market:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-08", "issue": "processor-contract omission", "matter_number": "CB-PR-3005", "owner": "Talia Brooks", "portfolio_key": "CBP-065-08", "row_id": "REG-CBP-065-08", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/008_data_inventory_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/020_vendor_reviews_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/032_security_incidents_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/044_notices_consents_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/10_regulator_correspondence/080_regulator_correspondence_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_everfield_market_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "everfield-market:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-07", "issue": "access-request deadline", "matter_number": "CB-PR-3005", "owner": "Adrian Mensah", "portfolio_key": "CBP-065-09", "row_id": "REG-CBP-065-09", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_processing_records/009_processing_records_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/021_vendor_reviews_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/033_consumer_requests_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/045_notices_consents_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_everfield_market_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "everfield-market:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-15", "issue": "minor-consent issue", "matter_number": "CB-PR-3005", "owner": "Farah Ibrahim", "portfolio_key": "CBP-065-10", "row_id": "REG-CBP-065-10", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_processing_records/010_processing_records_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/022_vendor_reviews_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/034_consumer_requests_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/046_notices_consents_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/094_remediation_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/08_retention_deletion/058_retention_deletion_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_everfield_market_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "everfield-market:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective", "issue": "consent-record deficiency", "matter_number": "CB-PR-3005", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-065-11", "row_id": "REG-CBP-065-11", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_processing_records/011_processing_records_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/023_vendor_reviews_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/035_consumer_requests_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/047_notices_consents_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/11_risk_assessments/083_risk_assessments_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_everfield_market_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "everfield-market:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-13", "issue": "deletion-job failure", "matter_number": "CB-PR-3005", "owner": "Leona Park", "portfolio_key": "CBP-065-12", "row_id": "REG-CBP-065-12", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_processing_records/012_processing_records_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/024_vendor_reviews_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/036_consumer_requests_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/048_notices_consents_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/096_remediation_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_everfield_market_impact_population.xlsx"]}], "schema_version": "counselbench.matter-register.v3", "task_id": "cb100-065-everfield-market"}}, "metadata": {"benchmark": "CounselBench-100", "code_license": "Apache-2.0", "data_license": "CC-BY-4.0", "deadline": "2026-09-16", "document_count": 97, "evidence_holds": 4, "jurisdiction": "Virginia", "matter_number": "CB-PR-3005", "mcp_commit": "9a96ea6e5913736f92b88345bf51caeaaa8e719f", "mcp_package": "@modelcontextprotocol/server-filesystem@2026.7.10", "practice_area": "privacy-regulatory", "reference_tool_calls": 90, "required_evidence_reads": 62, "supported_actions": 8, "synthetic": true, "venue": "Virginia Attorney General", "version": "3.1.0"}, "prompt": "We inherited inconsistent versions of this matter and need to settle the operating position. Which Everfield loyalty uses are permitted, and what consent, retention, or vendor changes are required? Loyalty profiles combine purchase and inferred health data with consent, retention, and processor terms that differ by system. The team needs the call by 2026-09-16. I need the recommendation and the real blockers recorded before the team acts.", "rubric": {"criteria": [{"category": "investigation", "description": "Inventory the production and use targeted searches to locate records across native formats.", "id": "investigation.discover_production"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Complete every task-specific identity, authority, operations, and approval read before the first state transition.", "id": "investigation.read_before_write"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Inspect designated source metadata before relying on those records.", "id": "investigation.custody_before_write"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "Select the supported option 'everfield-market:scoped-evidence' after applying the four-part test.", "id": "decision.selected_option"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "Identify both rejected approaches and explain why a one-source shortcut and a blanket hold are wrong.", "id": "decision.alternatives"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-065-01 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/001_data_inventory_source_export.md rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-065-01.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_processing_records/013_processing_records_source_export.json for processing-purpose gap.", "id": "investigation.CBP-065-01.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/025_security_incidents_source_export.md to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-065-01.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/037_consumer_requests_source_export.json.", "id": "investigation.CBP-065-01.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-065-01 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key.", "id": "decision.CBP-065-01.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-065-01 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-065-01.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-065-02 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/002_data_inventory_source_export.txt rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-065-02.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_processing_records/014_processing_records_source_export.xml for cross-border transfer gap.", "id": "investigation.CBP-065-02.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/026_security_incidents_source_export.txt to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-065-02.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/038_consumer_requests_source_export.xml.", "id": "investigation.CBP-065-02.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-065-02 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-065-02.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-065-02 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-065-02.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-065-03 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/003_data_inventory_source_export.eml rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-065-03.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_processing_records/015_processing_records_source_export.html for incident-notification clock.", "id": "investigation.CBP-065-03.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/027_security_incidents_source_export.eml to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-065-03.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/039_consumer_requests_source_export.html.", "id": "investigation.CBP-065-03.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-065-03 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-065-03.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-065-03 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-065-03.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-065-04 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/004_data_inventory_source_export.csv rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-065-04.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_processing_records/016_processing_records_source_export.pdf for regulator commitment overdue.", "id": "investigation.CBP-065-04.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/028_security_incidents_source_export.csv to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-065-04.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/040_consumer_requests_source_export.pdf.", "id": "investigation.CBP-065-04.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-065-04 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-065-04.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-065-04 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-065-04.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-065-05 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/005_data_inventory_source_export.json rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-065-05.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/017_vendor_reviews_source_export.md for subprocessor inventory mismatch.", "id": "investigation.CBP-065-05.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/029_security_incidents_source_export.json to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-065-05.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/041_notices_consents_source_export.md.", "id": "investigation.CBP-065-05.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-065-05 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key.", "id": "decision.CBP-065-05.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-065-05 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-065-05.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-065-06 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/006_data_inventory_source_export.xml rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-065-06.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/018_vendor_reviews_source_export.txt for identity-verification inconsistency.", "id": "investigation.CBP-065-06.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/030_security_incidents_source_export.xml to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-065-06.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/042_notices_consents_source_export.txt.", "id": "investigation.CBP-065-06.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-065-06 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-065-06.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-065-06 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-065-06.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-065-07 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/007_data_inventory_source_export.html rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-065-07.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/019_vendor_reviews_source_export.eml for training completion gap.", "id": "investigation.CBP-065-07.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/031_security_incidents_source_export.html to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-065-07.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/043_notices_consents_source_export.eml.", "id": "investigation.CBP-065-07.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-065-07 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective.", "id": "decision.CBP-065-07.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-065-07 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-065-07.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-065-08 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/008_data_inventory_source_export.pdf rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-065-08.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/020_vendor_reviews_source_export.csv for processor-contract omission.", "id": "investigation.CBP-065-08.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/032_security_incidents_source_export.pdf to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-065-08.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/044_notices_consents_source_export.csv.", "id": "investigation.CBP-065-08.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-065-08 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-065-08.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-065-08 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-065-08.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-065-09 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_processing_records/009_processing_records_source_export.md rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-065-09.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/021_vendor_reviews_source_export.json for access-request deadline.", "id": "investigation.CBP-065-09.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/033_consumer_requests_source_export.md to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-065-09.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/045_notices_consents_source_export.json.", "id": "investigation.CBP-065-09.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-065-09 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-065-09.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-065-09 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-065-09.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-065-10 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_processing_records/010_processing_records_source_export.txt rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-065-10.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/022_vendor_reviews_source_export.xml for minor-consent issue.", "id": "investigation.CBP-065-10.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/034_consumer_requests_source_export.txt to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-065-10.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/046_notices_consents_source_export.xml.", "id": "investigation.CBP-065-10.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-065-10 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-065-10.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-065-10 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-065-10.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-065-11 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_processing_records/011_processing_records_source_export.eml rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-065-11.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/023_vendor_reviews_source_export.html for consent-record deficiency.", "id": "investigation.CBP-065-11.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/035_consumer_requests_source_export.eml to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-065-11.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/047_notices_consents_source_export.html.", "id": "investigation.CBP-065-11.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-065-11 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective.", "id": "decision.CBP-065-11.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-065-11 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-065-11.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-065-12 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_processing_records/012_processing_records_source_export.csv rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-065-12.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/024_vendor_reviews_source_export.pdf for deletion-job failure.", "id": "investigation.CBP-065-12.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/036_consumer_requests_source_export.csv to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-065-12.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/048_notices_consents_source_export.pdf.", "id": "investigation.CBP-065-12.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-065-12 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-065-12.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-065-12 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-065-12.register"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Write the exact selected option, supported action population, evidence-hold population, facts, owners, deadlines, and citations.", "id": "state.exact_decision"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create one exact register row per portfolio key with no extra, missing, or modified row.", "id": "state.exact_register"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Leave only the three approved deliverables and perform no extra state-changing write.", "id": "state.write_scope_containment"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Read back decision.json, matter-register.json, and advice.md after their final writes.", "id": "state.postwrite_readback"}, {"category": "answer", "description": "Explain the selected recommendation, supported actions, holds, alternatives, and limitations with exact source anchors.", "id": "answer.decision_note"}], "decision_options": [{"approach": "Use a plausible summary or one source without completing the controlling joins.", "id": "everfield-market:shortcut", "label": "Apply the strictest rule to the entire loyalty database regardless of purpose."}, {"approach": "Treat supported actions and genuinely ambiguous records as if they were equally unresolved.", "id": "everfield-market:blanket-hold", "label": "Freeze the entire matter population"}, {"approach": "Apply the exact identity, current-state, authority, and revision test. Create purpose-period rows and hold records with unresolved source category.", "id": "everfield-market:scoped-evidence", "label": "Restrict or remediate supported uses without deleting permitted loyalty processing."}], "evaluation_narrative": {"authority": "Sensitive-data, consent, retention, and processor obligations attach to exact purposes and periods.", "observation": "Join profile fields, inferred health segments, consent events, retention jobs, and processor terms by purpose.", "question": "Which Everfield loyalty uses are permitted, and what consent, retention, or vendor changes are required?", "register_action": "Create purpose-period rows and hold records with unresolved source category."}, "gates": ["all_required_evidence_precedes_first_write", "decision_criteria_complete", "register_state_exact", "write_scope_contained", "all_outputs_verified_by_readback"], "metadata_checks": 12, "metric": "weighted_criteria_score", "minimum_tool_calls": 90, "required_deliverables": ["decision.json", "matter-register.json", "advice.md"], "required_document_reads": 62, "type": "deterministic", "weights": {"advice": 0.15, "decision": 0.35, "investigation": 0.25, "state": 0.25}}, "task_id": "cb100-065-everfield-market", "task_name": "Everfield loyalty-data assessment", "world_id": "counselbench-filesystem-mcp-v3"}
+{"context_files": ["task_files/cb100-066-fable-fintech/01_data_inventory/001_data_inventory_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-066-fable-fintech/01_data_inventory/002_data_inventory_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-066-fable-fintech/01_data_inventory/003_data_inventory_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-066-fable-fintech/01_data_inventory/004_data_inventory_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-066-fable-fintech/01_data_inventory/005_data_inventory_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-066-fable-fintech/01_data_inventory/006_data_inventory_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-066-fable-fintech/01_data_inventory/007_data_inventory_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-066-fable-fintech/01_data_inventory/008_data_inventory_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-066-fable-fintech/02_processing_records/009_processing_records_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-066-fable-fintech/02_processing_records/010_processing_records_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-066-fable-fintech/02_processing_records/011_processing_records_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-066-fable-fintech/02_processing_records/012_processing_records_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-066-fable-fintech/02_processing_records/013_processing_records_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-066-fable-fintech/02_processing_records/014_processing_records_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-066-fable-fintech/02_processing_records/015_processing_records_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-066-fable-fintech/02_processing_records/016_processing_records_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-066-fable-fintech/03_vendor_reviews/017_vendor_reviews_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-066-fable-fintech/03_vendor_reviews/018_vendor_reviews_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-066-fable-fintech/03_vendor_reviews/019_vendor_reviews_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-066-fable-fintech/03_vendor_reviews/020_vendor_reviews_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-066-fable-fintech/03_vendor_reviews/021_vendor_reviews_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-066-fable-fintech/03_vendor_reviews/022_vendor_reviews_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-066-fable-fintech/03_vendor_reviews/023_vendor_reviews_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-066-fable-fintech/03_vendor_reviews/024_vendor_reviews_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-066-fable-fintech/04_security_incidents/025_security_incidents_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-066-fable-fintech/04_security_incidents/026_security_incidents_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-066-fable-fintech/04_security_incidents/027_security_incidents_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-066-fable-fintech/04_security_incidents/028_security_incidents_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-066-fable-fintech/04_security_incidents/029_security_incidents_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-066-fable-fintech/04_security_incidents/030_security_incidents_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-066-fable-fintech/04_security_incidents/031_security_incidents_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-066-fable-fintech/04_security_incidents/032_security_incidents_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-066-fable-fintech/05_consumer_requests/033_consumer_requests_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-066-fable-fintech/05_consumer_requests/034_consumer_requests_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-066-fable-fintech/05_consumer_requests/035_consumer_requests_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-066-fable-fintech/05_consumer_requests/036_consumer_requests_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-066-fable-fintech/05_consumer_requests/037_consumer_requests_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-066-fable-fintech/05_consumer_requests/038_consumer_requests_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-066-fable-fintech/05_consumer_requests/039_consumer_requests_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-066-fable-fintech/05_consumer_requests/040_consumer_requests_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-066-fable-fintech/06_notices_consents/041_notices_consents_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-066-fable-fintech/06_notices_consents/042_notices_consents_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-066-fable-fintech/06_notices_consents/043_notices_consents_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-066-fable-fintech/06_notices_consents/044_notices_consents_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-066-fable-fintech/06_notices_consents/045_notices_consents_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-066-fable-fintech/06_notices_consents/046_notices_consents_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-066-fable-fintech/06_notices_consents/047_notices_consents_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-066-fable-fintech/06_notices_consents/048_notices_consents_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-066-fable-fintech/07_transfer_mechanisms/049_transfer_mechanisms_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-066-fable-fintech/07_transfer_mechanisms/050_transfer_mechanisms_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-066-fable-fintech/07_transfer_mechanisms/051_transfer_mechanisms_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-066-fable-fintech/07_transfer_mechanisms/052_transfer_mechanisms_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-066-fable-fintech/07_transfer_mechanisms/053_transfer_mechanisms_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-066-fable-fintech/07_transfer_mechanisms/054_transfer_mechanisms_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-066-fable-fintech/07_transfer_mechanisms/055_transfer_mechanisms_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-066-fable-fintech/07_transfer_mechanisms/056_transfer_mechanisms_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-066-fable-fintech/08_retention_deletion/057_retention_deletion_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-066-fable-fintech/08_retention_deletion/058_retention_deletion_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-066-fable-fintech/08_retention_deletion/059_retention_deletion_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-066-fable-fintech/08_retention_deletion/060_retention_deletion_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-066-fable-fintech/08_retention_deletion/061_retention_deletion_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-066-fable-fintech/08_retention_deletion/062_retention_deletion_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-066-fable-fintech/08_retention_deletion/063_retention_deletion_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-066-fable-fintech/08_retention_deletion/064_retention_deletion_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-066-fable-fintech/09_training/065_training_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-066-fable-fintech/09_training/066_training_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-066-fable-fintech/09_training/067_training_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-066-fable-fintech/09_training/068_training_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-066-fable-fintech/09_training/069_training_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-066-fable-fintech/09_training/070_training_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-066-fable-fintech/09_training/071_training_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-066-fable-fintech/09_training/072_training_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-066-fable-fintech/10_regulator_correspondence/073_regulator_correspondence_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-066-fable-fintech/10_regulator_correspondence/074_regulator_correspondence_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-066-fable-fintech/10_regulator_correspondence/075_regulator_correspondence_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-066-fable-fintech/10_regulator_correspondence/076_regulator_correspondence_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-066-fable-fintech/10_regulator_correspondence/077_regulator_correspondence_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-066-fable-fintech/10_regulator_correspondence/078_regulator_correspondence_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-066-fable-fintech/10_regulator_correspondence/079_regulator_correspondence_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-066-fable-fintech/10_regulator_correspondence/080_regulator_correspondence_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-066-fable-fintech/11_risk_assessments/081_risk_assessments_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-066-fable-fintech/11_risk_assessments/082_risk_assessments_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-066-fable-fintech/11_risk_assessments/083_risk_assessments_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-066-fable-fintech/11_risk_assessments/084_risk_assessments_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-066-fable-fintech/11_risk_assessments/085_risk_assessments_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-066-fable-fintech/11_risk_assessments/086_risk_assessments_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-066-fable-fintech/11_risk_assessments/087_risk_assessments_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-066-fable-fintech/11_risk_assessments/088_risk_assessments_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-066-fable-fintech/12_remediation/089_remediation_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-066-fable-fintech/12_remediation/090_remediation_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-066-fable-fintech/12_remediation/091_remediation_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-066-fable-fintech/12_remediation/092_remediation_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-066-fable-fintech/12_remediation/093_remediation_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-066-fable-fintech/12_remediation/094_remediation_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-066-fable-fintech/12_remediation/095_remediation_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-066-fable-fintech/12_remediation/096_remediation_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-066-fable-fintech/12_remediation/097_fable_fintech_impact_population.xlsx"], "gold_output": {"advice_markdown": "# Decision note — Fable automated-decision privacy review\n\n## Recommendation\n\nContinue only supported versions and remediate notice, assessment, or deletion gaps. The reconciled record supports 7 scoped actions and leaves 5 items on evidence hold.\n\nSelected option: `fable-fintech:scoped-evidence`.\n\n## Why this is the supported option\n\nReconcile model features, decisions, notices, assessments, deletions, and complaints by workflow version. Automated-decision and privacy controls apply to the effective model and exact decision purpose.\n\n## Supported actions\n\n### CBP-066-02 — retention schedule conflict (medium)\n\ndelivery must use notices-fable_financial_technologies@example.test under CB-PR-3006-R558; the only matched receipt used archive-northbridge_model_services@example.test under CB-PR-3006-E126. Identity resolves to ENT-066-1001, revision REV-2026.2 is current, and Theo Laurent is active with capacity 3.\n\nAction: Create model-version rows with scoped continuation or remediation outcomes. Owner: Theo Laurent; due 2026-09-18.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/002_data_inventory_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/02_processing_records/014_processing_records_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/026_security_incidents_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/038_consumer_requests_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_fable_fintech_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-066-04 — processing-purpose gap (high)\n\ncompletion is required by 2026-03-09 under CB-PR-3006-R467; the current event record shows completion on 2026-04-03 under CB-PR-3006-E227. Identity resolves to ENT-066-1003, revision REV-2026.4 is current, and Elliot Mercer is active with capacity 2.\n\nAction: Create model-version rows with scoped continuation or remediation outcomes. Owner: Elliot Mercer; due 2026-09-16.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/004_data_inventory_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/02_processing_records/016_processing_records_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/028_security_incidents_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/040_consumer_requests_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/08_retention_deletion/064_retention_deletion_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_fable_fintech_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-066-07 — regulator commitment overdue (medium)\n\nthe controlled population contains 205 records under CB-PR-3006-R753; the certification covers 171 records under CB-PR-3006-E667. Identity resolves to ENT-066-1006, revision REV-2026.7 is current, and Nora Chen is active with capacity 4.\n\nAction: Create model-version rows with scoped continuation or remediation outcomes. Owner: Nora Chen; due 2026-09-13.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/007_data_inventory_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/019_vendor_reviews_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/031_security_incidents_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/043_notices_consents_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/12_remediation/091_remediation_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/07_transfer_mechanisms/055_transfer_mechanisms_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_fable_fintech_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-066-08 — subprocessor inventory mismatch (medium)\n\nthe permission is limited to Illinois Department of Financial and Professional Regulation under CB-PR-3006-R992; the matched activity occurred in Illinois under CB-PR-3006-E311. Identity resolves to ENT-066-1007, revision REV-2026.1 is current, and Caleb Hassan is active with capacity 5.\n\nAction: Create model-version rows with scoped continuation or remediation outcomes. Owner: Caleb Hassan; due 2026-09-12.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/008_data_inventory_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/020_vendor_reviews_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/032_security_incidents_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/044_notices_consents_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_fable_fintech_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-066-09 — identity-verification inconsistency (low)\n\nthe operative cap is $1,402,000.00 under CB-PR-3006-R288; the matched ledger population totals $1,502,488.00 under CB-PR-3006-E799. Identity resolves to ENT-066-1008, revision REV-2026.2 is current, and Amara Patel is active with capacity 2.\n\nAction: Create model-version rows with scoped continuation or remediation outcomes. Owner: Amara Patel; due 2026-09-11.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/02_processing_records/009_processing_records_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/021_vendor_reviews_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/033_consumer_requests_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/045_notices_consents_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/12_remediation/093_remediation_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_fable_fintech_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-066-10 — training completion gap (high)\n\ndelivery must use notices-fable_financial_technologies@example.test under CB-PR-3006-R683; the only matched receipt used archive-northbridge_model_services@example.test under CB-PR-3006-E293. Identity resolves to ENT-066-1009, revision REV-2026.3 is current, and Samuel Kim is active with capacity 2.\n\nAction: Create model-version rows with scoped continuation or remediation outcomes. Owner: Samuel Kim; due 2026-09-19.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/02_processing_records/010_processing_records_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/022_vendor_reviews_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/034_consumer_requests_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/046_notices_consents_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/08_retention_deletion/058_retention_deletion_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_fable_fintech_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-066-12 — access-request deadline (medium)\n\ncompletion is required by 2026-01-23 under CB-PR-3006-R242; the current event record shows completion on 2026-02-19 under CB-PR-3006-E214. Identity resolves to ENT-066-1011, revision REV-2026.5 is current, and Adrian Mensah is active with capacity 3.\n\nAction: Create model-version rows with scoped continuation or remediation outcomes. Owner: Adrian Mensah; due 2026-09-17.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/02_processing_records/012_processing_records_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/024_vendor_reviews_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/036_consumer_requests_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/048_notices_consents_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/08_retention_deletion/060_retention_deletion_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/11_risk_assessments/084_risk_assessments_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_fable_fintech_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n## Evidence holds\n\n- **CBP-066-01 — notice-practice mismatch**: the current observation does not meet the operative trigger. Next evidence: a current observation that satisfies the operative trigger. Sources: `/workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/001_data_inventory_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/02_processing_records/013_processing_records_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/025_security_incidents_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/037_consumer_requests_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/11_risk_assessments/085_risk_assessments_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/08_retention_deletion/061_retention_deletion_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_fable_fintech_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-066-03 — risk-assessment omission**: the operational record relies on a superseded control revision. Next evidence: an operational record using the current effective revision. Sources: `/workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/003_data_inventory_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/02_processing_records/015_processing_records_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/027_security_incidents_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/039_consumer_requests_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/07_transfer_mechanisms/051_transfer_mechanisms_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/08_retention_deletion/063_retention_deletion_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_fable_fintech_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-066-05 — cross-border transfer gap**: the current observation does not meet the operative trigger. Next evidence: a current observation that satisfies the operative trigger. Sources: `/workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/005_data_inventory_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/017_vendor_reviews_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/029_security_incidents_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/041_notices_consents_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_fable_fintech_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-066-06 — incident-notification clock**: the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective. Next evidence: effective approval and an active owner with remaining capacity. Sources: `/workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/006_data_inventory_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/018_vendor_reviews_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/030_security_incidents_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/042_notices_consents_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/10_regulator_correspondence/078_regulator_correspondence_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_fable_fintech_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-066-11 — processor-contract omission**: the operational record relies on a superseded control revision. Next evidence: an operational record using the current effective revision. Sources: `/workspace/documents/02_processing_records/011_processing_records_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/023_vendor_reviews_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/035_consumer_requests_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/047_notices_consents_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_fable_fintech_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n## Alternatives considered\n\n- `fable-fintech:blanket-hold` — Freeze the entire matter population: Treat supported actions and genuinely ambiguous records as if they were equally unresolved.\n- `fable-fintech:shortcut` — Pause every credit workflow because one third-party feature appears in the model inventory.: Use a plausible summary or one source without completing the controlling joins.\n\n## Assumptions and limits\n\nThis decision is limited to cb100-066-fable-fintech, the supplied synthetic records, and the matter state as of 2026-09-20. Similar names, stale revisions, and pending authority are not treated as proof.\n", "decision": {"actions": [{"determination": "delivery must use notices-fable_financial_technologies@example.test under CB-PR-3006-R558; the only matched receipt used archive-northbridge_model_services@example.test under CB-PR-3006-E126. Identity resolves to ENT-066-1001, revision REV-2026.2 is current, and Theo Laurent is active with capacity 3.", "due_date": "2026-09-18", "id": "ACT-CBP-066-02", "identity_id": "ENT-066-1001", "issue": "retention schedule conflict", "owner": "Theo Laurent", "portfolio_key": "CBP-066-02", "recommended_action": "Create model-version rows with scoped continuation or remediation outcomes. Owner: Theo Laurent; due 2026-09-18.", "severity": "medium", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/002_data_inventory_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/02_processing_records/014_processing_records_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/026_security_incidents_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/038_consumer_requests_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_fable_fintech_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "completion is required by 2026-03-09 under CB-PR-3006-R467; the current event record shows completion on 2026-04-03 under CB-PR-3006-E227. Identity resolves to ENT-066-1003, revision REV-2026.4 is current, and Elliot Mercer is active with capacity 2.", "due_date": "2026-09-16", "id": "ACT-CBP-066-04", "identity_id": "ENT-066-1003", "issue": "processing-purpose gap", "owner": "Elliot Mercer", "portfolio_key": "CBP-066-04", "recommended_action": "Create model-version rows with scoped continuation or remediation outcomes. Owner: Elliot Mercer; due 2026-09-16.", "severity": "high", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/004_data_inventory_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/02_processing_records/016_processing_records_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/028_security_incidents_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/040_consumer_requests_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/08_retention_deletion/064_retention_deletion_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_fable_fintech_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "the controlled population contains 205 records under CB-PR-3006-R753; the certification covers 171 records under CB-PR-3006-E667. Identity resolves to ENT-066-1006, revision REV-2026.7 is current, and Nora Chen is active with capacity 4.", "due_date": "2026-09-13", "id": "ACT-CBP-066-07", "identity_id": "ENT-066-1006", "issue": "regulator commitment overdue", "owner": "Nora Chen", "portfolio_key": "CBP-066-07", "recommended_action": "Create model-version rows with scoped continuation or remediation outcomes. Owner: Nora Chen; due 2026-09-13.", "severity": "medium", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/007_data_inventory_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/019_vendor_reviews_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/031_security_incidents_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/043_notices_consents_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/091_remediation_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/07_transfer_mechanisms/055_transfer_mechanisms_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_fable_fintech_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "the permission is limited to Illinois Department of Financial and Professional Regulation under CB-PR-3006-R992; the matched activity occurred in Illinois under CB-PR-3006-E311. Identity resolves to ENT-066-1007, revision REV-2026.1 is current, and Caleb Hassan is active with capacity 5.", "due_date": "2026-09-12", "id": "ACT-CBP-066-08", "identity_id": "ENT-066-1007", "issue": "subprocessor inventory mismatch", "owner": "Caleb Hassan", "portfolio_key": "CBP-066-08", "recommended_action": "Create model-version rows with scoped continuation or remediation outcomes. Owner: Caleb Hassan; due 2026-09-12.", "severity": "medium", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/008_data_inventory_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/020_vendor_reviews_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/032_security_incidents_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/044_notices_consents_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_fable_fintech_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "the operative cap is $1,402,000.00 under CB-PR-3006-R288; the matched ledger population totals $1,502,488.00 under CB-PR-3006-E799. Identity resolves to ENT-066-1008, revision REV-2026.2 is current, and Amara Patel is active with capacity 2.", "due_date": "2026-09-11", "id": "ACT-CBP-066-09", "identity_id": "ENT-066-1008", "issue": "identity-verification inconsistency", "owner": "Amara Patel", "portfolio_key": "CBP-066-09", "recommended_action": "Create model-version rows with scoped continuation or remediation outcomes. Owner: Amara Patel; due 2026-09-11.", "severity": "low", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_processing_records/009_processing_records_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/021_vendor_reviews_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/033_consumer_requests_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/045_notices_consents_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/093_remediation_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_fable_fintech_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "delivery must use notices-fable_financial_technologies@example.test under CB-PR-3006-R683; the only matched receipt used archive-northbridge_model_services@example.test under CB-PR-3006-E293. Identity resolves to ENT-066-1009, revision REV-2026.3 is current, and Samuel Kim is active with capacity 2.", "due_date": "2026-09-19", "id": "ACT-CBP-066-10", "identity_id": "ENT-066-1009", "issue": "training completion gap", "owner": "Samuel Kim", "portfolio_key": "CBP-066-10", "recommended_action": "Create model-version rows with scoped continuation or remediation outcomes. Owner: Samuel Kim; due 2026-09-19.", "severity": "high", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_processing_records/010_processing_records_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/022_vendor_reviews_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/034_consumer_requests_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/046_notices_consents_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/08_retention_deletion/058_retention_deletion_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_fable_fintech_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "completion is required by 2026-01-23 under CB-PR-3006-R242; the current event record shows completion on 2026-02-19 under CB-PR-3006-E214. Identity resolves to ENT-066-1011, revision REV-2026.5 is current, and Adrian Mensah is active with capacity 3.", "due_date": "2026-09-17", "id": "ACT-CBP-066-12", "identity_id": "ENT-066-1011", "issue": "access-request deadline", "owner": "Adrian Mensah", "portfolio_key": "CBP-066-12", "recommended_action": "Create model-version rows with scoped continuation or remediation outcomes. Owner: Adrian Mensah; due 2026-09-17.", "severity": "medium", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_processing_records/012_processing_records_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/024_vendor_reviews_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/036_consumer_requests_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/048_notices_consents_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/08_retention_deletion/060_retention_deletion_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/11_risk_assessments/084_risk_assessments_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_fable_fintech_impact_population.xlsx"]}], "as_of": "2026-09-20", "decision": {"alternatives_considered": ["fable-fintech:blanket-hold", "fable-fintech:shortcut"], "question": "Can Fable keep using the prequalification workflow, and what notices or assessment gaps must be fixed?", "rationale": "The four-part causal test supports 7 scoped actions and leaves 5 records on evidence hold. Automated-decision and privacy controls apply to the effective model and exact decision purpose.", "recommendation": "Continue only supported versions and remediate notice, assessment, or deletion gaps.", "selected_option_id": "fable-fintech:scoped-evidence"}, "holds": [{"id": "HOLD-CBP-066-01", "issue": "notice-practice mismatch", "portfolio_key": "CBP-066-01", "reason": "the current observation does not meet the operative trigger", "required_next_evidence": "a current observation that satisfies the operative trigger", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/001_data_inventory_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/02_processing_records/013_processing_records_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/025_security_incidents_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/037_consumer_requests_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/11_risk_assessments/085_risk_assessments_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/08_retention_deletion/061_retention_deletion_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_fable_fintech_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-066-03", "issue": "risk-assessment omission", "portfolio_key": "CBP-066-03", "reason": "the operational record relies on a superseded control revision", "required_next_evidence": "an operational record using the current effective revision", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/003_data_inventory_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/02_processing_records/015_processing_records_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/027_security_incidents_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/039_consumer_requests_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/07_transfer_mechanisms/051_transfer_mechanisms_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/08_retention_deletion/063_retention_deletion_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_fable_fintech_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-066-05", "issue": "cross-border transfer gap", "portfolio_key": "CBP-066-05", "reason": "the current observation does not meet the operative trigger", "required_next_evidence": "a current observation that satisfies the operative trigger", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/005_data_inventory_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/017_vendor_reviews_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/029_security_incidents_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/041_notices_consents_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_fable_fintech_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-066-06", "issue": "incident-notification clock", "portfolio_key": "CBP-066-06", "reason": "the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective", "required_next_evidence": "effective approval and an active owner with remaining capacity", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/006_data_inventory_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/018_vendor_reviews_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/030_security_incidents_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/042_notices_consents_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/10_regulator_correspondence/078_regulator_correspondence_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_fable_fintech_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-066-11", "issue": "processor-contract omission", "portfolio_key": "CBP-066-11", "reason": "the operational record relies on a superseded control revision", "required_next_evidence": "an operational record using the current effective revision", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_processing_records/011_processing_records_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/023_vendor_reviews_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/035_consumer_requests_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/047_notices_consents_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_fable_fintech_impact_population.xlsx"]}], "matter_number": "CB-PR-3006", "prepared_for": "Fable Financial Technologies", "schema_version": "counselbench.decision.v3", "task_id": "cb100-066-fable-fintech"}, "matter_register": {"matter_number": "CB-PR-3006", "rows": [{"decision_option_id": "fable-fintech:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "the current observation does not meet the operative trigger", "issue": "notice-practice mismatch", "matter_number": "CB-PR-3006", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-066-01", "row_id": "REG-CBP-066-01", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/001_data_inventory_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/02_processing_records/013_processing_records_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/025_security_incidents_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/037_consumer_requests_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/11_risk_assessments/085_risk_assessments_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/08_retention_deletion/061_retention_deletion_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_fable_fintech_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "fable-fintech:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-18", "issue": "retention schedule conflict", "matter_number": "CB-PR-3006", "owner": "Theo Laurent", "portfolio_key": "CBP-066-02", "row_id": "REG-CBP-066-02", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/002_data_inventory_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/02_processing_records/014_processing_records_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/026_security_incidents_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/038_consumer_requests_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_fable_fintech_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "fable-fintech:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "the operational record relies on a superseded control revision", "issue": "risk-assessment omission", "matter_number": "CB-PR-3006", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-066-03", "row_id": "REG-CBP-066-03", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/003_data_inventory_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/02_processing_records/015_processing_records_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/027_security_incidents_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/039_consumer_requests_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/07_transfer_mechanisms/051_transfer_mechanisms_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/08_retention_deletion/063_retention_deletion_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_fable_fintech_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "fable-fintech:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-16", "issue": "processing-purpose gap", "matter_number": "CB-PR-3006", "owner": "Elliot Mercer", "portfolio_key": "CBP-066-04", "row_id": "REG-CBP-066-04", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/004_data_inventory_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/02_processing_records/016_processing_records_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/028_security_incidents_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/040_consumer_requests_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/08_retention_deletion/064_retention_deletion_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_fable_fintech_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "fable-fintech:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "the current observation does not meet the operative trigger", "issue": "cross-border transfer gap", "matter_number": "CB-PR-3006", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-066-05", "row_id": "REG-CBP-066-05", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/005_data_inventory_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/017_vendor_reviews_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/029_security_incidents_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/041_notices_consents_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_fable_fintech_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "fable-fintech:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective", "issue": "incident-notification clock", "matter_number": "CB-PR-3006", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-066-06", "row_id": "REG-CBP-066-06", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/006_data_inventory_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/018_vendor_reviews_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/030_security_incidents_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/042_notices_consents_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/10_regulator_correspondence/078_regulator_correspondence_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_fable_fintech_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "fable-fintech:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-13", "issue": "regulator commitment overdue", "matter_number": "CB-PR-3006", "owner": "Nora Chen", "portfolio_key": "CBP-066-07", "row_id": "REG-CBP-066-07", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/007_data_inventory_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/019_vendor_reviews_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/031_security_incidents_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/043_notices_consents_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/091_remediation_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/07_transfer_mechanisms/055_transfer_mechanisms_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_fable_fintech_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "fable-fintech:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-12", "issue": "subprocessor inventory mismatch", "matter_number": "CB-PR-3006", "owner": "Caleb Hassan", "portfolio_key": "CBP-066-08", "row_id": "REG-CBP-066-08", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/008_data_inventory_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/020_vendor_reviews_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/032_security_incidents_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/044_notices_consents_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_fable_fintech_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "fable-fintech:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-11", "issue": "identity-verification inconsistency", "matter_number": "CB-PR-3006", "owner": "Amara Patel", "portfolio_key": "CBP-066-09", "row_id": "REG-CBP-066-09", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_processing_records/009_processing_records_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/021_vendor_reviews_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/033_consumer_requests_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/045_notices_consents_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/093_remediation_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_fable_fintech_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "fable-fintech:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-19", "issue": "training completion gap", "matter_number": "CB-PR-3006", "owner": "Samuel Kim", "portfolio_key": "CBP-066-10", "row_id": "REG-CBP-066-10", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_processing_records/010_processing_records_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/022_vendor_reviews_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/034_consumer_requests_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/046_notices_consents_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/08_retention_deletion/058_retention_deletion_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_fable_fintech_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "fable-fintech:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "the operational record relies on a superseded control revision", "issue": "processor-contract omission", "matter_number": "CB-PR-3006", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-066-11", "row_id": "REG-CBP-066-11", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_processing_records/011_processing_records_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/023_vendor_reviews_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/035_consumer_requests_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/047_notices_consents_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_fable_fintech_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "fable-fintech:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-17", "issue": "access-request deadline", "matter_number": "CB-PR-3006", "owner": "Adrian Mensah", "portfolio_key": "CBP-066-12", "row_id": "REG-CBP-066-12", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_processing_records/012_processing_records_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/024_vendor_reviews_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/036_consumer_requests_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/048_notices_consents_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/08_retention_deletion/060_retention_deletion_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/11_risk_assessments/084_risk_assessments_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_fable_fintech_impact_population.xlsx"]}], "schema_version": "counselbench.matter-register.v3", "task_id": "cb100-066-fable-fintech"}}, "metadata": {"benchmark": "CounselBench-100", "code_license": "Apache-2.0", "data_license": "CC-BY-4.0", "deadline": "2026-09-20", "document_count": 97, "evidence_holds": 5, "jurisdiction": "Illinois", "matter_number": "CB-PR-3006", "mcp_commit": "9a96ea6e5913736f92b88345bf51caeaaa8e719f", "mcp_package": "@modelcontextprotocol/server-filesystem@2026.7.10", "practice_area": "privacy-regulatory", "reference_tool_calls": 84, "required_evidence_reads": 62, "supported_actions": 7, "synthetic": true, "venue": "Illinois Department of Financial and Professional Regulation", "version": "3.1.0"}, "prompt": "I am about to brief the decision makers and need the source record reconciled first. Can Fable keep using the prequalification workflow, and what notices or assessment gaps must be fixed? A credit prequalification workflow uses third-party model features while notices, assessments, deletion records, and complaint responses conflict. The team needs the call by 2026-09-20. Record the outcome the source hierarchy supports and explain the alternatives we should not take.", "rubric": {"criteria": [{"category": "investigation", "description": "Inventory the production and use targeted searches to locate records across native formats.", "id": "investigation.discover_production"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Complete every task-specific identity, authority, operations, and approval read before the first state transition.", "id": "investigation.read_before_write"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Inspect designated source metadata before relying on those records.", "id": "investigation.custody_before_write"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "Select the supported option 'fable-fintech:scoped-evidence' after applying the four-part test.", "id": "decision.selected_option"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "Identify both rejected approaches and explain why a one-source shortcut and a blanket hold are wrong.", "id": "decision.alternatives"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-066-01 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/001_data_inventory_source_export.md rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-066-01.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_processing_records/013_processing_records_source_export.json for notice-practice mismatch.", "id": "investigation.CBP-066-01.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/025_security_incidents_source_export.md to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-066-01.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/037_consumer_requests_source_export.json.", "id": "investigation.CBP-066-01.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-066-01 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is the current observation does not meet the operative trigger.", "id": "decision.CBP-066-01.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-066-01 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-066-01.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-066-02 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/002_data_inventory_source_export.txt rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-066-02.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_processing_records/014_processing_records_source_export.xml for retention schedule conflict.", "id": "investigation.CBP-066-02.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/026_security_incidents_source_export.txt to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-066-02.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/038_consumer_requests_source_export.xml.", "id": "investigation.CBP-066-02.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-066-02 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-066-02.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-066-02 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-066-02.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-066-03 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/003_data_inventory_source_export.eml rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-066-03.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_processing_records/015_processing_records_source_export.html for risk-assessment omission.", "id": "investigation.CBP-066-03.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/027_security_incidents_source_export.eml to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-066-03.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/039_consumer_requests_source_export.html.", "id": "investigation.CBP-066-03.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-066-03 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is the operational record relies on a superseded control revision.", "id": "decision.CBP-066-03.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-066-03 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-066-03.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-066-04 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/004_data_inventory_source_export.csv rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-066-04.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_processing_records/016_processing_records_source_export.pdf for processing-purpose gap.", "id": "investigation.CBP-066-04.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/028_security_incidents_source_export.csv to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-066-04.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/040_consumer_requests_source_export.pdf.", "id": "investigation.CBP-066-04.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-066-04 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-066-04.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-066-04 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-066-04.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-066-05 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/005_data_inventory_source_export.json rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-066-05.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/017_vendor_reviews_source_export.md for cross-border transfer gap.", "id": "investigation.CBP-066-05.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/029_security_incidents_source_export.json to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-066-05.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/041_notices_consents_source_export.md.", "id": "investigation.CBP-066-05.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-066-05 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is the current observation does not meet the operative trigger.", "id": "decision.CBP-066-05.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-066-05 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-066-05.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-066-06 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/006_data_inventory_source_export.xml rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-066-06.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/018_vendor_reviews_source_export.txt for incident-notification clock.", "id": "investigation.CBP-066-06.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/030_security_incidents_source_export.xml to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-066-06.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/042_notices_consents_source_export.txt.", "id": "investigation.CBP-066-06.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-066-06 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective.", "id": "decision.CBP-066-06.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-066-06 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-066-06.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-066-07 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/007_data_inventory_source_export.html rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-066-07.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/019_vendor_reviews_source_export.eml for regulator commitment overdue.", "id": "investigation.CBP-066-07.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/031_security_incidents_source_export.html to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-066-07.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/043_notices_consents_source_export.eml.", "id": "investigation.CBP-066-07.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-066-07 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-066-07.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-066-07 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-066-07.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-066-08 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/008_data_inventory_source_export.pdf rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-066-08.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/020_vendor_reviews_source_export.csv for subprocessor inventory mismatch.", "id": "investigation.CBP-066-08.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/032_security_incidents_source_export.pdf to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-066-08.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/044_notices_consents_source_export.csv.", "id": "investigation.CBP-066-08.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-066-08 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-066-08.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-066-08 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-066-08.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-066-09 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_processing_records/009_processing_records_source_export.md rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-066-09.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/021_vendor_reviews_source_export.json for identity-verification inconsistency.", "id": "investigation.CBP-066-09.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/033_consumer_requests_source_export.md to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-066-09.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/045_notices_consents_source_export.json.", "id": "investigation.CBP-066-09.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-066-09 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-066-09.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-066-09 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-066-09.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-066-10 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_processing_records/010_processing_records_source_export.txt rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-066-10.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/022_vendor_reviews_source_export.xml for training completion gap.", "id": "investigation.CBP-066-10.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/034_consumer_requests_source_export.txt to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-066-10.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/046_notices_consents_source_export.xml.", "id": "investigation.CBP-066-10.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-066-10 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-066-10.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-066-10 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-066-10.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-066-11 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_processing_records/011_processing_records_source_export.eml rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-066-11.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/023_vendor_reviews_source_export.html for processor-contract omission.", "id": "investigation.CBP-066-11.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/035_consumer_requests_source_export.eml to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-066-11.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/047_notices_consents_source_export.html.", "id": "investigation.CBP-066-11.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-066-11 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is the operational record relies on a superseded control revision.", "id": "decision.CBP-066-11.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-066-11 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-066-11.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-066-12 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_processing_records/012_processing_records_source_export.csv rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-066-12.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/024_vendor_reviews_source_export.pdf for access-request deadline.", "id": "investigation.CBP-066-12.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/036_consumer_requests_source_export.csv to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-066-12.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/048_notices_consents_source_export.pdf.", "id": "investigation.CBP-066-12.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-066-12 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-066-12.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-066-12 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-066-12.register"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Write the exact selected option, supported action population, evidence-hold population, facts, owners, deadlines, and citations.", "id": "state.exact_decision"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create one exact register row per portfolio key with no extra, missing, or modified row.", "id": "state.exact_register"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Leave only the three approved deliverables and perform no extra state-changing write.", "id": "state.write_scope_containment"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Read back decision.json, matter-register.json, and advice.md after their final writes.", "id": "state.postwrite_readback"}, {"category": "answer", "description": "Explain the selected recommendation, supported actions, holds, alternatives, and limitations with exact source anchors.", "id": "answer.decision_note"}], "decision_options": [{"approach": "Treat supported actions and genuinely ambiguous records as if they were equally unresolved.", "id": "fable-fintech:blanket-hold", "label": "Freeze the entire matter population"}, {"approach": "Apply the exact identity, current-state, authority, and revision test. Create model-version rows with scoped continuation or remediation outcomes.", "id": "fable-fintech:scoped-evidence", "label": "Continue only supported versions and remediate notice, assessment, or deletion gaps."}, {"approach": "Use a plausible summary or one source without completing the controlling joins.", "id": "fable-fintech:shortcut", "label": "Pause every credit workflow because one third-party feature appears in the model inventory."}], "evaluation_narrative": {"authority": "Automated-decision and privacy controls apply to the effective model and exact decision purpose.", "observation": "Reconcile model features, decisions, notices, assessments, deletions, and complaints by workflow version.", "question": "Can Fable keep using the prequalification workflow, and what notices or assessment gaps must be fixed?", "register_action": "Create model-version rows with scoped continuation or remediation outcomes."}, "gates": ["all_required_evidence_precedes_first_write", "decision_criteria_complete", "register_state_exact", "write_scope_contained", "all_outputs_verified_by_readback"], "metadata_checks": 8, "metric": "weighted_criteria_score", "minimum_tool_calls": 84, "required_deliverables": ["decision.json", "matter-register.json", "advice.md"], "required_document_reads": 62, "type": "deterministic", "weights": {"advice": 0.15, "decision": 0.35, "investigation": 0.25, "state": 0.25}}, "task_id": "cb100-066-fable-fintech", "task_name": "Fable automated-decision privacy review", "world_id": "counselbench-filesystem-mcp-v3"}
+{"context_files": ["task_files/cb100-067-grove-hospitality/01_data_inventory/001_data_inventory_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-067-grove-hospitality/01_data_inventory/002_data_inventory_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-067-grove-hospitality/01_data_inventory/003_data_inventory_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-067-grove-hospitality/01_data_inventory/004_data_inventory_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-067-grove-hospitality/01_data_inventory/005_data_inventory_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-067-grove-hospitality/01_data_inventory/006_data_inventory_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-067-grove-hospitality/01_data_inventory/007_data_inventory_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-067-grove-hospitality/01_data_inventory/008_data_inventory_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-067-grove-hospitality/02_processing_records/009_processing_records_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-067-grove-hospitality/02_processing_records/010_processing_records_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-067-grove-hospitality/02_processing_records/011_processing_records_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-067-grove-hospitality/02_processing_records/012_processing_records_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-067-grove-hospitality/02_processing_records/013_processing_records_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-067-grove-hospitality/02_processing_records/014_processing_records_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-067-grove-hospitality/02_processing_records/015_processing_records_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-067-grove-hospitality/02_processing_records/016_processing_records_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-067-grove-hospitality/03_vendor_reviews/017_vendor_reviews_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-067-grove-hospitality/03_vendor_reviews/018_vendor_reviews_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-067-grove-hospitality/03_vendor_reviews/019_vendor_reviews_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-067-grove-hospitality/03_vendor_reviews/020_vendor_reviews_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-067-grove-hospitality/03_vendor_reviews/021_vendor_reviews_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-067-grove-hospitality/03_vendor_reviews/022_vendor_reviews_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-067-grove-hospitality/03_vendor_reviews/023_vendor_reviews_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-067-grove-hospitality/03_vendor_reviews/024_vendor_reviews_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-067-grove-hospitality/04_security_incidents/025_security_incidents_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-067-grove-hospitality/04_security_incidents/026_security_incidents_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-067-grove-hospitality/04_security_incidents/027_security_incidents_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-067-grove-hospitality/04_security_incidents/028_security_incidents_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-067-grove-hospitality/04_security_incidents/029_security_incidents_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-067-grove-hospitality/04_security_incidents/030_security_incidents_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-067-grove-hospitality/04_security_incidents/031_security_incidents_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-067-grove-hospitality/04_security_incidents/032_security_incidents_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-067-grove-hospitality/05_consumer_requests/033_consumer_requests_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-067-grove-hospitality/05_consumer_requests/034_consumer_requests_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-067-grove-hospitality/05_consumer_requests/035_consumer_requests_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-067-grove-hospitality/05_consumer_requests/036_consumer_requests_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-067-grove-hospitality/05_consumer_requests/037_consumer_requests_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-067-grove-hospitality/05_consumer_requests/038_consumer_requests_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-067-grove-hospitality/05_consumer_requests/039_consumer_requests_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-067-grove-hospitality/05_consumer_requests/040_consumer_requests_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-067-grove-hospitality/06_notices_consents/041_notices_consents_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-067-grove-hospitality/06_notices_consents/042_notices_consents_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-067-grove-hospitality/06_notices_consents/043_notices_consents_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-067-grove-hospitality/06_notices_consents/044_notices_consents_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-067-grove-hospitality/06_notices_consents/045_notices_consents_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-067-grove-hospitality/06_notices_consents/046_notices_consents_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-067-grove-hospitality/06_notices_consents/047_notices_consents_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-067-grove-hospitality/06_notices_consents/048_notices_consents_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-067-grove-hospitality/07_transfer_mechanisms/049_transfer_mechanisms_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-067-grove-hospitality/07_transfer_mechanisms/050_transfer_mechanisms_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-067-grove-hospitality/07_transfer_mechanisms/051_transfer_mechanisms_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-067-grove-hospitality/07_transfer_mechanisms/052_transfer_mechanisms_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-067-grove-hospitality/07_transfer_mechanisms/053_transfer_mechanisms_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-067-grove-hospitality/07_transfer_mechanisms/054_transfer_mechanisms_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-067-grove-hospitality/07_transfer_mechanisms/055_transfer_mechanisms_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-067-grove-hospitality/07_transfer_mechanisms/056_transfer_mechanisms_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-067-grove-hospitality/08_retention_deletion/057_retention_deletion_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-067-grove-hospitality/08_retention_deletion/058_retention_deletion_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-067-grove-hospitality/08_retention_deletion/059_retention_deletion_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-067-grove-hospitality/08_retention_deletion/060_retention_deletion_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-067-grove-hospitality/08_retention_deletion/061_retention_deletion_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-067-grove-hospitality/08_retention_deletion/062_retention_deletion_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-067-grove-hospitality/08_retention_deletion/063_retention_deletion_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-067-grove-hospitality/08_retention_deletion/064_retention_deletion_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-067-grove-hospitality/09_training/065_training_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-067-grove-hospitality/09_training/066_training_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-067-grove-hospitality/09_training/067_training_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-067-grove-hospitality/09_training/068_training_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-067-grove-hospitality/09_training/069_training_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-067-grove-hospitality/09_training/070_training_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-067-grove-hospitality/09_training/071_training_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-067-grove-hospitality/09_training/072_training_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-067-grove-hospitality/10_regulator_correspondence/073_regulator_correspondence_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-067-grove-hospitality/10_regulator_correspondence/074_regulator_correspondence_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-067-grove-hospitality/10_regulator_correspondence/075_regulator_correspondence_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-067-grove-hospitality/10_regulator_correspondence/076_regulator_correspondence_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-067-grove-hospitality/10_regulator_correspondence/077_regulator_correspondence_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-067-grove-hospitality/10_regulator_correspondence/078_regulator_correspondence_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-067-grove-hospitality/10_regulator_correspondence/079_regulator_correspondence_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-067-grove-hospitality/10_regulator_correspondence/080_regulator_correspondence_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-067-grove-hospitality/11_risk_assessments/081_risk_assessments_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-067-grove-hospitality/11_risk_assessments/082_risk_assessments_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-067-grove-hospitality/11_risk_assessments/083_risk_assessments_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-067-grove-hospitality/11_risk_assessments/084_risk_assessments_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-067-grove-hospitality/11_risk_assessments/085_risk_assessments_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-067-grove-hospitality/11_risk_assessments/086_risk_assessments_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-067-grove-hospitality/11_risk_assessments/087_risk_assessments_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-067-grove-hospitality/11_risk_assessments/088_risk_assessments_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-067-grove-hospitality/12_remediation/089_remediation_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-067-grove-hospitality/12_remediation/090_remediation_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-067-grove-hospitality/12_remediation/091_remediation_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-067-grove-hospitality/12_remediation/092_remediation_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-067-grove-hospitality/12_remediation/093_remediation_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-067-grove-hospitality/12_remediation/094_remediation_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-067-grove-hospitality/12_remediation/095_remediation_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-067-grove-hospitality/12_remediation/096_remediation_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-067-grove-hospitality/12_remediation/097_grove_hospitality_impact_population.xlsx"], "gold_output": {"advice_markdown": "# Decision note — Grove guest-data transfer audit\n\n## Recommendation\n\nStop or cure supported noncompliant flows and accurately report unresolved jobs. The reconciled record supports 7 scoped actions and leaves 5 items on evidence hold.\n\nSelected option: `grove-hospitality:scoped-evidence`.\n\n## Why this is the supported option\n\nJoin reservation flows, regional routing, subprocessors, deletion jobs, and regulator commitments. Transfer safeguards and retention promises apply by data flow, vendor, and effective commitment.\n\n## Supported actions\n\n### CBP-067-01 — consent-record deficiency (medium)\n\napproval must come from Nadine Flores under CB-PR-3007-R932; the effective approval record names Rafael Okafor under CB-PR-3007-E784. Identity resolves to ENT-067-1000, revision REV-2025.1 is current, and Isaac Romero is active with capacity 4.\n\nAction: Create flow-vendor rows with exact remediation and disclosure status. Owner: Isaac Romero; due 2026-09-22.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/001_data_inventory_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/02_processing_records/013_processing_records_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/025_security_incidents_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/037_consumer_requests_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/10_regulator_correspondence/073_regulator_correspondence_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/11_risk_assessments/085_risk_assessments_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_grove_hospitality_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-067-02 — deletion-job failure (medium)\n\nthe controlled population contains 239 records under CB-PR-3007-R267; the certification covers 228 records under CB-PR-3007-E109. Identity resolves to ENT-067-1001, revision REV-2025.2 is current, and Nadine Flores is active with capacity 2.\n\nAction: Create flow-vendor rows with exact remediation and disclosure status. Owner: Nadine Flores; due 2026-09-21.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/002_data_inventory_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/02_processing_records/014_processing_records_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/026_security_incidents_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/038_consumer_requests_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_grove_hospitality_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-067-04 — notice-practice mismatch (medium)\n\nthe operative cap is $6,562,000.00 under CB-PR-3007-R756; the matched ledger population totals $6,743,356.00 under CB-PR-3007-E985. Identity resolves to ENT-067-1003, revision REV-2025.4 is current, and Mei Whitaker is active with capacity 3.\n\nAction: Create flow-vendor rows with exact remediation and disclosure status. Owner: Mei Whitaker; due 2026-09-19.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/004_data_inventory_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/02_processing_records/016_processing_records_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/028_security_incidents_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/040_consumer_requests_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_grove_hospitality_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-067-08 — cross-border transfer gap (high)\n\nthe controlling threshold is 6% under CB-PR-3007-R381; the independently calculated result is 11% under CB-PR-3007-E751. Identity resolves to ENT-067-1007, revision REV-2025.1 is current, and Sofia Bennett is active with capacity 3.\n\nAction: Create flow-vendor rows with exact remediation and disclosure status. Owner: Sofia Bennett; due 2026-09-15.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/008_data_inventory_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/020_vendor_reviews_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/032_security_incidents_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/044_notices_consents_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_grove_hospitality_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-067-10 — regulator commitment overdue (high)\n\nthe controlled population contains 195 records under CB-PR-3007-R253; the certification covers 175 records under CB-PR-3007-E797. Identity resolves to ENT-067-1009, revision REV-2025.3 is current, and Nora Chen is active with capacity 5.\n\nAction: Create flow-vendor rows with exact remediation and disclosure status. Owner: Nora Chen; due 2026-09-22.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/02_processing_records/010_processing_records_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/022_vendor_reviews_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/034_consumer_requests_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/046_notices_consents_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/11_risk_assessments/082_risk_assessments_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/08_retention_deletion/058_retention_deletion_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_grove_hospitality_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-067-11 — subprocessor inventory mismatch (medium)\n\nthe permission is limited to Federal Trade Commission under CB-PR-3007-R648; the matched activity occurred in Florida under CB-PR-3007-E820. Identity resolves to ENT-067-1010, revision REV-2025.4 is current, and Caleb Hassan is active with capacity 2.\n\nAction: Create flow-vendor rows with exact remediation and disclosure status. Owner: Caleb Hassan; due 2026-09-21.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/02_processing_records/011_processing_records_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/023_vendor_reviews_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/035_consumer_requests_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/047_notices_consents_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/12_remediation/095_remediation_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_grove_hospitality_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-067-12 — identity-verification inconsistency (medium)\n\nthe operative cap is $3,682,000.00 under CB-PR-3007-R225; the matched ledger population totals $3,816,625.00 under CB-PR-3007-E319. Identity resolves to ENT-067-1011, revision REV-2025.5 is current, and Amara Patel is active with capacity 6.\n\nAction: Create flow-vendor rows with exact remediation and disclosure status. Owner: Amara Patel; due 2026-09-20.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/02_processing_records/012_processing_records_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/024_vendor_reviews_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/036_consumer_requests_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/048_notices_consents_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/11_risk_assessments/084_risk_assessments_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/08_retention_deletion/060_retention_deletion_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_grove_hospitality_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n## Evidence holds\n\n- **CBP-067-03 — sensitive-data classification**: two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key. Next evidence: an approved immutable entity crosswalk. Sources: `/workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/003_data_inventory_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/02_processing_records/015_processing_records_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/027_security_incidents_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/039_consumer_requests_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/11_risk_assessments/087_risk_assessments_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/07_transfer_mechanisms/051_transfer_mechanisms_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_grove_hospitality_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-067-05 — retention schedule conflict**: the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective. Next evidence: effective approval and an active owner with remaining capacity. Sources: `/workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/005_data_inventory_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/017_vendor_reviews_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/029_security_incidents_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/041_notices_consents_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/10_regulator_correspondence/077_regulator_correspondence_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_grove_hospitality_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-067-06 — risk-assessment omission**: the operational record relies on a superseded control revision. Next evidence: an operational record using the current effective revision. Sources: `/workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/006_data_inventory_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/018_vendor_reviews_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/030_security_incidents_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/042_notices_consents_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/10_regulator_correspondence/078_regulator_correspondence_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/09_training/066_training_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_grove_hospitality_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-067-07 — processing-purpose gap**: two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key. Next evidence: an approved immutable entity crosswalk. Sources: `/workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/007_data_inventory_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/019_vendor_reviews_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/031_security_incidents_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/043_notices_consents_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/12_remediation/091_remediation_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/07_transfer_mechanisms/055_transfer_mechanisms_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_grove_hospitality_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-067-09 — incident-notification clock**: the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective. Next evidence: effective approval and an active owner with remaining capacity. Sources: `/workspace/documents/02_processing_records/009_processing_records_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/021_vendor_reviews_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/033_consumer_requests_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/045_notices_consents_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/09_training/069_training_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_grove_hospitality_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n## Alternatives considered\n\n- `grove-hospitality:shortcut` — Represent that all data stayed regional because the primary vendor is local.: Use a plausible summary or one source without completing the controlling joins.\n- `grove-hospitality:blanket-hold` — Freeze the entire matter population: Treat supported actions and genuinely ambiguous records as if they were equally unresolved.\n\n## Assumptions and limits\n\nThis decision is limited to cb100-067-grove-hospitality, the supplied synthetic records, and the matter state as of 2026-09-23. Similar names, stale revisions, and pending authority are not treated as proof.\n", "decision": {"actions": [{"determination": "approval must come from Nadine Flores under CB-PR-3007-R932; the effective approval record names Rafael Okafor under CB-PR-3007-E784. Identity resolves to ENT-067-1000, revision REV-2025.1 is current, and Isaac Romero is active with capacity 4.", "due_date": "2026-09-22", "id": "ACT-CBP-067-01", "identity_id": "ENT-067-1000", "issue": "consent-record deficiency", "owner": "Isaac Romero", "portfolio_key": "CBP-067-01", "recommended_action": "Create flow-vendor rows with exact remediation and disclosure status. Owner: Isaac Romero; due 2026-09-22.", "severity": "medium", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/001_data_inventory_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/02_processing_records/013_processing_records_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/025_security_incidents_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/037_consumer_requests_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/10_regulator_correspondence/073_regulator_correspondence_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/11_risk_assessments/085_risk_assessments_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_grove_hospitality_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "the controlled population contains 239 records under CB-PR-3007-R267; the certification covers 228 records under CB-PR-3007-E109. Identity resolves to ENT-067-1001, revision REV-2025.2 is current, and Nadine Flores is active with capacity 2.", "due_date": "2026-09-21", "id": "ACT-CBP-067-02", "identity_id": "ENT-067-1001", "issue": "deletion-job failure", "owner": "Nadine Flores", "portfolio_key": "CBP-067-02", "recommended_action": "Create flow-vendor rows with exact remediation and disclosure status. Owner: Nadine Flores; due 2026-09-21.", "severity": "medium", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/002_data_inventory_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/02_processing_records/014_processing_records_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/026_security_incidents_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/038_consumer_requests_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_grove_hospitality_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "the operative cap is $6,562,000.00 under CB-PR-3007-R756; the matched ledger population totals $6,743,356.00 under CB-PR-3007-E985. Identity resolves to ENT-067-1003, revision REV-2025.4 is current, and Mei Whitaker is active with capacity 3.", "due_date": "2026-09-19", "id": "ACT-CBP-067-04", "identity_id": "ENT-067-1003", "issue": "notice-practice mismatch", "owner": "Mei Whitaker", "portfolio_key": "CBP-067-04", "recommended_action": "Create flow-vendor rows with exact remediation and disclosure status. Owner: Mei Whitaker; due 2026-09-19.", "severity": "medium", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/004_data_inventory_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/02_processing_records/016_processing_records_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/028_security_incidents_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/040_consumer_requests_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_grove_hospitality_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "the controlling threshold is 6% under CB-PR-3007-R381; the independently calculated result is 11% under CB-PR-3007-E751. Identity resolves to ENT-067-1007, revision REV-2025.1 is current, and Sofia Bennett is active with capacity 3.", "due_date": "2026-09-15", "id": "ACT-CBP-067-08", "identity_id": "ENT-067-1007", "issue": "cross-border transfer gap", "owner": "Sofia Bennett", "portfolio_key": "CBP-067-08", "recommended_action": "Create flow-vendor rows with exact remediation and disclosure status. Owner: Sofia Bennett; due 2026-09-15.", "severity": "high", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/008_data_inventory_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/020_vendor_reviews_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/032_security_incidents_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/044_notices_consents_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_grove_hospitality_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "the controlled population contains 195 records under CB-PR-3007-R253; the certification covers 175 records under CB-PR-3007-E797. Identity resolves to ENT-067-1009, revision REV-2025.3 is current, and Nora Chen is active with capacity 5.", "due_date": "2026-09-22", "id": "ACT-CBP-067-10", "identity_id": "ENT-067-1009", "issue": "regulator commitment overdue", "owner": "Nora Chen", "portfolio_key": "CBP-067-10", "recommended_action": "Create flow-vendor rows with exact remediation and disclosure status. Owner: Nora Chen; due 2026-09-22.", "severity": "high", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_processing_records/010_processing_records_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/022_vendor_reviews_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/034_consumer_requests_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/046_notices_consents_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/11_risk_assessments/082_risk_assessments_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/08_retention_deletion/058_retention_deletion_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_grove_hospitality_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "the permission is limited to Federal Trade Commission under CB-PR-3007-R648; the matched activity occurred in Florida under CB-PR-3007-E820. Identity resolves to ENT-067-1010, revision REV-2025.4 is current, and Caleb Hassan is active with capacity 2.", "due_date": "2026-09-21", "id": "ACT-CBP-067-11", "identity_id": "ENT-067-1010", "issue": "subprocessor inventory mismatch", "owner": "Caleb Hassan", "portfolio_key": "CBP-067-11", "recommended_action": "Create flow-vendor rows with exact remediation and disclosure status. Owner: Caleb Hassan; due 2026-09-21.", "severity": "medium", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_processing_records/011_processing_records_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/023_vendor_reviews_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/035_consumer_requests_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/047_notices_consents_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/095_remediation_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_grove_hospitality_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "the operative cap is $3,682,000.00 under CB-PR-3007-R225; the matched ledger population totals $3,816,625.00 under CB-PR-3007-E319. Identity resolves to ENT-067-1011, revision REV-2025.5 is current, and Amara Patel is active with capacity 6.", "due_date": "2026-09-20", "id": "ACT-CBP-067-12", "identity_id": "ENT-067-1011", "issue": "identity-verification inconsistency", "owner": "Amara Patel", "portfolio_key": "CBP-067-12", "recommended_action": "Create flow-vendor rows with exact remediation and disclosure status. Owner: Amara Patel; due 2026-09-20.", "severity": "medium", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_processing_records/012_processing_records_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/024_vendor_reviews_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/036_consumer_requests_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/048_notices_consents_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/11_risk_assessments/084_risk_assessments_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/08_retention_deletion/060_retention_deletion_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_grove_hospitality_impact_population.xlsx"]}], "as_of": "2026-09-23", "decision": {"alternatives_considered": ["grove-hospitality:shortcut", "grove-hospitality:blanket-hold"], "question": "Which Grove transfers or retention failures require immediate action in the regulator response?", "rationale": "The four-part causal test supports 7 scoped actions and leaves 5 records on evidence hold. Transfer safeguards and retention promises apply by data flow, vendor, and effective commitment.", "recommendation": "Stop or cure supported noncompliant flows and accurately report unresolved jobs.", "selected_option_id": "grove-hospitality:scoped-evidence"}, "holds": [{"id": "HOLD-CBP-067-03", "issue": "sensitive-data classification", "portfolio_key": "CBP-067-03", "reason": "two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key", "required_next_evidence": "an approved immutable entity crosswalk", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/003_data_inventory_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/02_processing_records/015_processing_records_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/027_security_incidents_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/039_consumer_requests_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/11_risk_assessments/087_risk_assessments_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/07_transfer_mechanisms/051_transfer_mechanisms_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_grove_hospitality_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-067-05", "issue": "retention schedule conflict", "portfolio_key": "CBP-067-05", "reason": "the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective", "required_next_evidence": "effective approval and an active owner with remaining capacity", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/005_data_inventory_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/017_vendor_reviews_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/029_security_incidents_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/041_notices_consents_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/10_regulator_correspondence/077_regulator_correspondence_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_grove_hospitality_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-067-06", "issue": "risk-assessment omission", "portfolio_key": "CBP-067-06", "reason": "the operational record relies on a superseded control revision", "required_next_evidence": "an operational record using the current effective revision", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/006_data_inventory_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/018_vendor_reviews_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/030_security_incidents_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/042_notices_consents_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/10_regulator_correspondence/078_regulator_correspondence_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/09_training/066_training_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_grove_hospitality_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-067-07", "issue": "processing-purpose gap", "portfolio_key": "CBP-067-07", "reason": "two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key", "required_next_evidence": "an approved immutable entity crosswalk", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/007_data_inventory_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/019_vendor_reviews_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/031_security_incidents_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/043_notices_consents_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/091_remediation_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/07_transfer_mechanisms/055_transfer_mechanisms_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_grove_hospitality_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-067-09", "issue": "incident-notification clock", "portfolio_key": "CBP-067-09", "reason": "the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective", "required_next_evidence": "effective approval and an active owner with remaining capacity", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_processing_records/009_processing_records_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/021_vendor_reviews_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/033_consumer_requests_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/045_notices_consents_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/09_training/069_training_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_grove_hospitality_impact_population.xlsx"]}], "matter_number": "CB-PR-3007", "prepared_for": "Grove Hospitality Group", "schema_version": "counselbench.decision.v3", "task_id": "cb100-067-grove-hospitality"}, "matter_register": {"matter_number": "CB-PR-3007", "rows": [{"decision_option_id": "grove-hospitality:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-22", "issue": "consent-record deficiency", "matter_number": "CB-PR-3007", "owner": "Isaac Romero", "portfolio_key": "CBP-067-01", "row_id": "REG-CBP-067-01", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/001_data_inventory_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/02_processing_records/013_processing_records_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/025_security_incidents_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/037_consumer_requests_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/10_regulator_correspondence/073_regulator_correspondence_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/11_risk_assessments/085_risk_assessments_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_grove_hospitality_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "grove-hospitality:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-21", "issue": "deletion-job failure", "matter_number": "CB-PR-3007", "owner": "Nadine Flores", "portfolio_key": "CBP-067-02", "row_id": "REG-CBP-067-02", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/002_data_inventory_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/02_processing_records/014_processing_records_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/026_security_incidents_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/038_consumer_requests_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_grove_hospitality_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "grove-hospitality:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key", "issue": "sensitive-data classification", "matter_number": "CB-PR-3007", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-067-03", "row_id": "REG-CBP-067-03", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/003_data_inventory_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/02_processing_records/015_processing_records_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/027_security_incidents_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/039_consumer_requests_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/11_risk_assessments/087_risk_assessments_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/07_transfer_mechanisms/051_transfer_mechanisms_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_grove_hospitality_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "grove-hospitality:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-19", "issue": "notice-practice mismatch", "matter_number": "CB-PR-3007", "owner": "Mei Whitaker", "portfolio_key": "CBP-067-04", "row_id": "REG-CBP-067-04", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/004_data_inventory_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/02_processing_records/016_processing_records_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/028_security_incidents_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/040_consumer_requests_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_grove_hospitality_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "grove-hospitality:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective", "issue": "retention schedule conflict", "matter_number": "CB-PR-3007", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-067-05", "row_id": "REG-CBP-067-05", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/005_data_inventory_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/017_vendor_reviews_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/029_security_incidents_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/041_notices_consents_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/10_regulator_correspondence/077_regulator_correspondence_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_grove_hospitality_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "grove-hospitality:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "the operational record relies on a superseded control revision", "issue": "risk-assessment omission", "matter_number": "CB-PR-3007", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-067-06", "row_id": "REG-CBP-067-06", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/006_data_inventory_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/018_vendor_reviews_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/030_security_incidents_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/042_notices_consents_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/10_regulator_correspondence/078_regulator_correspondence_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/09_training/066_training_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_grove_hospitality_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "grove-hospitality:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key", "issue": "processing-purpose gap", "matter_number": "CB-PR-3007", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-067-07", "row_id": "REG-CBP-067-07", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/007_data_inventory_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/019_vendor_reviews_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/031_security_incidents_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/043_notices_consents_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/091_remediation_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/07_transfer_mechanisms/055_transfer_mechanisms_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_grove_hospitality_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "grove-hospitality:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-15", "issue": "cross-border transfer gap", "matter_number": "CB-PR-3007", "owner": "Sofia Bennett", "portfolio_key": "CBP-067-08", "row_id": "REG-CBP-067-08", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/008_data_inventory_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/020_vendor_reviews_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/032_security_incidents_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/044_notices_consents_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_grove_hospitality_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "grove-hospitality:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective", "issue": "incident-notification clock", "matter_number": "CB-PR-3007", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-067-09", "row_id": "REG-CBP-067-09", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_processing_records/009_processing_records_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/021_vendor_reviews_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/033_consumer_requests_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/045_notices_consents_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/09_training/069_training_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_grove_hospitality_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "grove-hospitality:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-22", "issue": "regulator commitment overdue", "matter_number": "CB-PR-3007", "owner": "Nora Chen", "portfolio_key": "CBP-067-10", "row_id": "REG-CBP-067-10", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_processing_records/010_processing_records_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/022_vendor_reviews_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/034_consumer_requests_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/046_notices_consents_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/11_risk_assessments/082_risk_assessments_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/08_retention_deletion/058_retention_deletion_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_grove_hospitality_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "grove-hospitality:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-21", "issue": "subprocessor inventory mismatch", "matter_number": "CB-PR-3007", "owner": "Caleb Hassan", "portfolio_key": "CBP-067-11", "row_id": "REG-CBP-067-11", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_processing_records/011_processing_records_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/023_vendor_reviews_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/035_consumer_requests_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/047_notices_consents_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/095_remediation_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_grove_hospitality_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "grove-hospitality:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-20", "issue": "identity-verification inconsistency", "matter_number": "CB-PR-3007", "owner": "Amara Patel", "portfolio_key": "CBP-067-12", "row_id": "REG-CBP-067-12", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_processing_records/012_processing_records_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/024_vendor_reviews_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/036_consumer_requests_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/048_notices_consents_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/11_risk_assessments/084_risk_assessments_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/08_retention_deletion/060_retention_deletion_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_grove_hospitality_impact_population.xlsx"]}], "schema_version": "counselbench.matter-register.v3", "task_id": "cb100-067-grove-hospitality"}}, "metadata": {"benchmark": "CounselBench-100", "code_license": "Apache-2.0", "data_license": "CC-BY-4.0", "deadline": "2026-09-23", "document_count": 97, "evidence_holds": 5, "jurisdiction": "Florida", "matter_number": "CB-PR-3007", "mcp_commit": "9a96ea6e5913736f92b88345bf51caeaaa8e719f", "mcp_package": "@modelcontextprotocol/server-filesystem@2026.7.10", "practice_area": "privacy-regulatory", "reference_tool_calls": 91, "required_evidence_reads": 65, "supported_actions": 7, "synthetic": true, "venue": "Federal Trade Commission", "version": "3.1.0"}, "prompt": "The other side has challenged our internal account of the facts. Which Grove transfers or retention failures require immediate action in the regulator response? Reservation data crosses regions through undocumented subprocessors and a failed retention job identified during a regulator response. The team needs the call by 2026-09-23. Leave a concise decision record with exact source references and an owner for each supported next step.", "rubric": {"criteria": [{"category": "investigation", "description": "Inventory the production and use targeted searches to locate records across native formats.", "id": "investigation.discover_production"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Complete every task-specific identity, authority, operations, and approval read before the first state transition.", "id": "investigation.read_before_write"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Inspect designated source metadata before relying on those records.", "id": "investigation.custody_before_write"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "Select the supported option 'grove-hospitality:scoped-evidence' after applying the four-part test.", "id": "decision.selected_option"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "Identify both rejected approaches and explain why a one-source shortcut and a blanket hold are wrong.", "id": "decision.alternatives"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-067-01 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/001_data_inventory_source_export.md rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-067-01.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_processing_records/013_processing_records_source_export.json for consent-record deficiency.", "id": "investigation.CBP-067-01.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/025_security_incidents_source_export.md to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-067-01.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/037_consumer_requests_source_export.json.", "id": "investigation.CBP-067-01.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-067-01 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-067-01.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-067-01 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-067-01.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-067-02 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/002_data_inventory_source_export.txt rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-067-02.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_processing_records/014_processing_records_source_export.xml for deletion-job failure.", "id": "investigation.CBP-067-02.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/026_security_incidents_source_export.txt to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-067-02.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/038_consumer_requests_source_export.xml.", "id": "investigation.CBP-067-02.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-067-02 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-067-02.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-067-02 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-067-02.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-067-03 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/003_data_inventory_source_export.eml rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-067-03.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_processing_records/015_processing_records_source_export.html for sensitive-data classification.", "id": "investigation.CBP-067-03.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/027_security_incidents_source_export.eml to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-067-03.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/039_consumer_requests_source_export.html.", "id": "investigation.CBP-067-03.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-067-03 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key.", "id": "decision.CBP-067-03.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-067-03 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-067-03.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-067-04 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/004_data_inventory_source_export.csv rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-067-04.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_processing_records/016_processing_records_source_export.pdf for notice-practice mismatch.", "id": "investigation.CBP-067-04.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/028_security_incidents_source_export.csv to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-067-04.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/040_consumer_requests_source_export.pdf.", "id": "investigation.CBP-067-04.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-067-04 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-067-04.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-067-04 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-067-04.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-067-05 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/005_data_inventory_source_export.json rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-067-05.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/017_vendor_reviews_source_export.md for retention schedule conflict.", "id": "investigation.CBP-067-05.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/029_security_incidents_source_export.json to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-067-05.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/041_notices_consents_source_export.md.", "id": "investigation.CBP-067-05.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-067-05 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective.", "id": "decision.CBP-067-05.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-067-05 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-067-05.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-067-06 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/006_data_inventory_source_export.xml rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-067-06.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/018_vendor_reviews_source_export.txt for risk-assessment omission.", "id": "investigation.CBP-067-06.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/030_security_incidents_source_export.xml to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-067-06.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/042_notices_consents_source_export.txt.", "id": "investigation.CBP-067-06.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-067-06 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is the operational record relies on a superseded control revision.", "id": "decision.CBP-067-06.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-067-06 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-067-06.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-067-07 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/007_data_inventory_source_export.html rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-067-07.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/019_vendor_reviews_source_export.eml for processing-purpose gap.", "id": "investigation.CBP-067-07.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/031_security_incidents_source_export.html to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-067-07.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/043_notices_consents_source_export.eml.", "id": "investigation.CBP-067-07.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-067-07 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key.", "id": "decision.CBP-067-07.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-067-07 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-067-07.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-067-08 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/008_data_inventory_source_export.pdf rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-067-08.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/020_vendor_reviews_source_export.csv for cross-border transfer gap.", "id": "investigation.CBP-067-08.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/032_security_incidents_source_export.pdf to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-067-08.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/044_notices_consents_source_export.csv.", "id": "investigation.CBP-067-08.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-067-08 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-067-08.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-067-08 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-067-08.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-067-09 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_processing_records/009_processing_records_source_export.md rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-067-09.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/021_vendor_reviews_source_export.json for incident-notification clock.", "id": "investigation.CBP-067-09.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/033_consumer_requests_source_export.md to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-067-09.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/045_notices_consents_source_export.json.", "id": "investigation.CBP-067-09.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-067-09 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective.", "id": "decision.CBP-067-09.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-067-09 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-067-09.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-067-10 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_processing_records/010_processing_records_source_export.txt rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-067-10.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/022_vendor_reviews_source_export.xml for regulator commitment overdue.", "id": "investigation.CBP-067-10.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/034_consumer_requests_source_export.txt to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-067-10.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/046_notices_consents_source_export.xml.", "id": "investigation.CBP-067-10.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-067-10 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-067-10.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-067-10 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-067-10.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-067-11 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_processing_records/011_processing_records_source_export.eml rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-067-11.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/023_vendor_reviews_source_export.html for subprocessor inventory mismatch.", "id": "investigation.CBP-067-11.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/035_consumer_requests_source_export.eml to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-067-11.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/047_notices_consents_source_export.html.", "id": "investigation.CBP-067-11.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-067-11 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-067-11.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-067-11 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-067-11.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-067-12 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_processing_records/012_processing_records_source_export.csv rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-067-12.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/024_vendor_reviews_source_export.pdf for identity-verification inconsistency.", "id": "investigation.CBP-067-12.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/036_consumer_requests_source_export.csv to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-067-12.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/048_notices_consents_source_export.pdf.", "id": "investigation.CBP-067-12.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-067-12 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-067-12.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-067-12 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-067-12.register"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Write the exact selected option, supported action population, evidence-hold population, facts, owners, deadlines, and citations.", "id": "state.exact_decision"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create one exact register row per portfolio key with no extra, missing, or modified row.", "id": "state.exact_register"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Leave only the three approved deliverables and perform no extra state-changing write.", "id": "state.write_scope_containment"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Read back decision.json, matter-register.json, and advice.md after their final writes.", "id": "state.postwrite_readback"}, {"category": "answer", "description": "Explain the selected recommendation, supported actions, holds, alternatives, and limitations with exact source anchors.", "id": "answer.decision_note"}], "decision_options": [{"approach": "Apply the exact identity, current-state, authority, and revision test. Create flow-vendor rows with exact remediation and disclosure status.", "id": "grove-hospitality:scoped-evidence", "label": "Stop or cure supported noncompliant flows and accurately report unresolved jobs."}, {"approach": "Use a plausible summary or one source without completing the controlling joins.", "id": "grove-hospitality:shortcut", "label": "Represent that all data stayed regional because the primary vendor is local."}, {"approach": "Treat supported actions and genuinely ambiguous records as if they were equally unresolved.", "id": "grove-hospitality:blanket-hold", "label": "Freeze the entire matter population"}], "evaluation_narrative": {"authority": "Transfer safeguards and retention promises apply by data flow, vendor, and effective commitment.", "observation": "Join reservation flows, regional routing, subprocessors, deletion jobs, and regulator commitments.", "question": "Which Grove transfers or retention failures require immediate action in the regulator response?", "register_action": "Create flow-vendor rows with exact remediation and disclosure status."}, "gates": ["all_required_evidence_precedes_first_write", "decision_criteria_complete", "register_state_exact", "write_scope_contained", "all_outputs_verified_by_readback"], "metadata_checks": 11, "metric": "weighted_criteria_score", "minimum_tool_calls": 91, "required_deliverables": ["decision.json", "matter-register.json", "advice.md"], "required_document_reads": 65, "type": "deterministic", "weights": {"advice": 0.15, "decision": 0.35, "investigation": 0.25, "state": 0.25}}, "task_id": "cb100-067-grove-hospitality", "task_name": "Grove guest-data transfer audit", "world_id": "counselbench-filesystem-mcp-v3"}
+{"context_files": ["task_files/cb100-068-highline-wearables/01_data_inventory/001_data_inventory_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-068-highline-wearables/01_data_inventory/002_data_inventory_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-068-highline-wearables/01_data_inventory/003_data_inventory_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-068-highline-wearables/01_data_inventory/004_data_inventory_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-068-highline-wearables/01_data_inventory/005_data_inventory_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-068-highline-wearables/01_data_inventory/006_data_inventory_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-068-highline-wearables/01_data_inventory/007_data_inventory_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-068-highline-wearables/01_data_inventory/008_data_inventory_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-068-highline-wearables/02_processing_records/009_processing_records_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-068-highline-wearables/02_processing_records/010_processing_records_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-068-highline-wearables/02_processing_records/011_processing_records_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-068-highline-wearables/02_processing_records/012_processing_records_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-068-highline-wearables/02_processing_records/013_processing_records_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-068-highline-wearables/02_processing_records/014_processing_records_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-068-highline-wearables/02_processing_records/015_processing_records_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-068-highline-wearables/02_processing_records/016_processing_records_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-068-highline-wearables/03_vendor_reviews/017_vendor_reviews_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-068-highline-wearables/03_vendor_reviews/018_vendor_reviews_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-068-highline-wearables/03_vendor_reviews/019_vendor_reviews_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-068-highline-wearables/03_vendor_reviews/020_vendor_reviews_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-068-highline-wearables/03_vendor_reviews/021_vendor_reviews_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-068-highline-wearables/03_vendor_reviews/022_vendor_reviews_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-068-highline-wearables/03_vendor_reviews/023_vendor_reviews_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-068-highline-wearables/03_vendor_reviews/024_vendor_reviews_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-068-highline-wearables/04_security_incidents/025_security_incidents_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-068-highline-wearables/04_security_incidents/026_security_incidents_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-068-highline-wearables/04_security_incidents/027_security_incidents_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-068-highline-wearables/04_security_incidents/028_security_incidents_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-068-highline-wearables/04_security_incidents/029_security_incidents_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-068-highline-wearables/04_security_incidents/030_security_incidents_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-068-highline-wearables/04_security_incidents/031_security_incidents_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-068-highline-wearables/04_security_incidents/032_security_incidents_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-068-highline-wearables/05_consumer_requests/033_consumer_requests_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-068-highline-wearables/05_consumer_requests/034_consumer_requests_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-068-highline-wearables/05_consumer_requests/035_consumer_requests_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-068-highline-wearables/05_consumer_requests/036_consumer_requests_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-068-highline-wearables/05_consumer_requests/037_consumer_requests_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-068-highline-wearables/05_consumer_requests/038_consumer_requests_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-068-highline-wearables/05_consumer_requests/039_consumer_requests_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-068-highline-wearables/05_consumer_requests/040_consumer_requests_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-068-highline-wearables/06_notices_consents/041_notices_consents_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-068-highline-wearables/06_notices_consents/042_notices_consents_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-068-highline-wearables/06_notices_consents/043_notices_consents_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-068-highline-wearables/06_notices_consents/044_notices_consents_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-068-highline-wearables/06_notices_consents/045_notices_consents_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-068-highline-wearables/06_notices_consents/046_notices_consents_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-068-highline-wearables/06_notices_consents/047_notices_consents_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-068-highline-wearables/06_notices_consents/048_notices_consents_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-068-highline-wearables/07_transfer_mechanisms/049_transfer_mechanisms_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-068-highline-wearables/07_transfer_mechanisms/050_transfer_mechanisms_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-068-highline-wearables/07_transfer_mechanisms/051_transfer_mechanisms_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-068-highline-wearables/07_transfer_mechanisms/052_transfer_mechanisms_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-068-highline-wearables/07_transfer_mechanisms/053_transfer_mechanisms_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-068-highline-wearables/07_transfer_mechanisms/054_transfer_mechanisms_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-068-highline-wearables/07_transfer_mechanisms/055_transfer_mechanisms_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-068-highline-wearables/07_transfer_mechanisms/056_transfer_mechanisms_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-068-highline-wearables/08_retention_deletion/057_retention_deletion_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-068-highline-wearables/08_retention_deletion/058_retention_deletion_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-068-highline-wearables/08_retention_deletion/059_retention_deletion_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-068-highline-wearables/08_retention_deletion/060_retention_deletion_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-068-highline-wearables/08_retention_deletion/061_retention_deletion_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-068-highline-wearables/08_retention_deletion/062_retention_deletion_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-068-highline-wearables/08_retention_deletion/063_retention_deletion_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-068-highline-wearables/08_retention_deletion/064_retention_deletion_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-068-highline-wearables/09_training/065_training_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-068-highline-wearables/09_training/066_training_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-068-highline-wearables/09_training/067_training_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-068-highline-wearables/09_training/068_training_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-068-highline-wearables/09_training/069_training_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-068-highline-wearables/09_training/070_training_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-068-highline-wearables/09_training/071_training_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-068-highline-wearables/09_training/072_training_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-068-highline-wearables/10_regulator_correspondence/073_regulator_correspondence_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-068-highline-wearables/10_regulator_correspondence/074_regulator_correspondence_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-068-highline-wearables/10_regulator_correspondence/075_regulator_correspondence_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-068-highline-wearables/10_regulator_correspondence/076_regulator_correspondence_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-068-highline-wearables/10_regulator_correspondence/077_regulator_correspondence_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-068-highline-wearables/10_regulator_correspondence/078_regulator_correspondence_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-068-highline-wearables/10_regulator_correspondence/079_regulator_correspondence_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-068-highline-wearables/10_regulator_correspondence/080_regulator_correspondence_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-068-highline-wearables/11_risk_assessments/081_risk_assessments_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-068-highline-wearables/11_risk_assessments/082_risk_assessments_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-068-highline-wearables/11_risk_assessments/083_risk_assessments_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-068-highline-wearables/11_risk_assessments/084_risk_assessments_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-068-highline-wearables/11_risk_assessments/085_risk_assessments_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-068-highline-wearables/11_risk_assessments/086_risk_assessments_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-068-highline-wearables/11_risk_assessments/087_risk_assessments_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-068-highline-wearables/11_risk_assessments/088_risk_assessments_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-068-highline-wearables/12_remediation/089_remediation_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-068-highline-wearables/12_remediation/090_remediation_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-068-highline-wearables/12_remediation/091_remediation_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-068-highline-wearables/12_remediation/092_remediation_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-068-highline-wearables/12_remediation/093_remediation_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-068-highline-wearables/12_remediation/094_remediation_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-068-highline-wearables/12_remediation/095_remediation_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-068-highline-wearables/12_remediation/096_remediation_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-068-highline-wearables/12_remediation/097_highline_wearables_impact_population.xlsx"], "gold_output": {"advice_markdown": "# Decision note — Highline biometric-data review\n\n## Recommendation\n\nSuspend or remediate unsupported deployments while preserving compliant ones. The reconciled record supports 9 scoped actions and leaves 3 items on evidence hold.\n\nSelected option: `highline-wearables:scoped-evidence`.\n\n## Why this is the supported option\n\nMatch feature launch, user population, consent version, assessment, vendor processing, and deletion control. Biometric and voice controls require current consent and assessed, enforceable vendor handling.\n\n## Supported actions\n\n### CBP-068-02 — access-request deadline (critical)\n\ncompletion is required by 2026-03-19 under CB-PR-3008-R777; the current event record shows completion on 2026-04-29 under CB-PR-3008-E192. Identity resolves to ENT-068-1001, revision REV-2026.2 is current, and Owen Delgado is active with capacity 1.\n\nAction: Create feature-population rows and hold identities or versions that do not join. Owner: Owen Delgado; due 2026-09-25.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/002_data_inventory_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/02_processing_records/014_processing_records_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/026_security_incidents_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/038_consumer_requests_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/08_retention_deletion/062_retention_deletion_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/10_regulator_correspondence/074_regulator_correspondence_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_highline_wearables_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-068-04 — consent-record deficiency (critical)\n\napproval must come from Priya Raman under CB-PR-3008-R317; the effective approval record names Henry Cho under CB-PR-3008-E483. Identity resolves to ENT-068-1003, revision REV-2026.4 is current, and Isaac Romero is active with capacity 3.\n\nAction: Create feature-population rows and hold identities or versions that do not join. Owner: Isaac Romero; due 2026-09-23.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/004_data_inventory_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/02_processing_records/016_processing_records_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/028_security_incidents_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/040_consumer_requests_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/11_risk_assessments/088_risk_assessments_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_highline_wearables_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-068-05 — deletion-job failure (medium)\n\nthe controlled population contains 171 records under CB-PR-3008-R959; the certification covers 151 records under CB-PR-3008-E785. Identity resolves to ENT-068-1004, revision REV-2026.5 is current, and Nadine Flores is active with capacity 2.\n\nAction: Create feature-population rows and hold identities or versions that do not join. Owner: Nadine Flores; due 2026-09-22.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/005_data_inventory_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/017_vendor_reviews_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/029_security_incidents_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/041_notices_consents_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_highline_wearables_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-068-07 — notice-practice mismatch (critical)\n\nthe operative cap is $3,922,000.00 under CB-PR-3008-R899; the matched ledger population totals $3,936,399.00 under CB-PR-3008-E252. Identity resolves to ENT-068-1006, revision REV-2026.7 is current, and Mei Whitaker is active with capacity 3.\n\nAction: Create feature-population rows and hold identities or versions that do not join. Owner: Mei Whitaker; due 2026-09-20.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/007_data_inventory_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/019_vendor_reviews_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/031_security_incidents_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/043_notices_consents_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_highline_wearables_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-068-08 — retention schedule conflict (critical)\n\ndelivery must use notices-highline_wearables_inc@example.test under CB-PR-3008-R665; the only matched receipt used archive-motionkey_analytics@example.test under CB-PR-3008-E133. Identity resolves to ENT-068-1007, revision REV-2026.1 is current, and Theo Laurent is active with capacity 4.\n\nAction: Create feature-population rows and hold identities or versions that do not join. Owner: Theo Laurent; due 2026-09-19.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/008_data_inventory_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/020_vendor_reviews_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/032_security_incidents_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/044_notices_consents_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_highline_wearables_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-068-09 — risk-assessment omission (medium)\n\nan open exception blocks completion under CB-PR-3008-R257; the current status is open and unresolved under CB-PR-3008-E797. Identity resolves to ENT-068-1008, revision REV-2026.2 is current, and Lena Varga is active with capacity 3.\n\nAction: Create feature-population rows and hold identities or versions that do not join. Owner: Lena Varga; due 2026-09-18.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/02_processing_records/009_processing_records_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/021_vendor_reviews_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/033_consumer_requests_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/045_notices_consents_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/09_training/069_training_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/12_remediation/093_remediation_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_highline_wearables_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-068-10 — processing-purpose gap (low)\n\ncompletion is required by 2025-08-18 under CB-PR-3008-R264; the current event record shows completion on 2025-08-28 under CB-PR-3008-E850. Identity resolves to ENT-068-1009, revision REV-2026.3 is current, and Elliot Mercer is active with capacity 2.\n\nAction: Create feature-population rows and hold identities or versions that do not join. Owner: Elliot Mercer; due 2026-09-26.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/02_processing_records/010_processing_records_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/022_vendor_reviews_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/034_consumer_requests_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/046_notices_consents_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_highline_wearables_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-068-11 — cross-border transfer gap (high)\n\nthe controlling threshold is 11% under CB-PR-3008-R790; the independently calculated result is 14% under CB-PR-3008-E193. Identity resolves to ENT-068-1010, revision REV-2026.4 is current, and Sofia Bennett is active with capacity 6.\n\nAction: Create feature-population rows and hold identities or versions that do not join. Owner: Sofia Bennett; due 2026-09-25.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/02_processing_records/011_processing_records_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/023_vendor_reviews_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/035_consumer_requests_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/047_notices_consents_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/08_retention_deletion/059_retention_deletion_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/12_remediation/095_remediation_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_highline_wearables_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-068-12 — incident-notification clock (critical)\n\napproval must come from Priya Raman under CB-PR-3008-R437; the effective approval record names Caleb Hassan under CB-PR-3008-E755. Identity resolves to ENT-068-1011, revision REV-2026.5 is current, and Micah Sullivan is active with capacity 2.\n\nAction: Create feature-population rows and hold identities or versions that do not join. Owner: Micah Sullivan; due 2026-09-24.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/02_processing_records/012_processing_records_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/024_vendor_reviews_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/036_consumer_requests_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/048_notices_consents_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/11_risk_assessments/084_risk_assessments_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/09_training/072_training_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_highline_wearables_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n## Evidence holds\n\n- **CBP-068-01 — processor-contract omission**: the operational record relies on a superseded control revision. Next evidence: an operational record using the current effective revision. Sources: `/workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/001_data_inventory_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/02_processing_records/013_processing_records_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/025_security_incidents_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/037_consumer_requests_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/11_risk_assessments/085_risk_assessments_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_highline_wearables_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-068-03 — minor-consent issue**: the current observation does not meet the operative trigger. Next evidence: a current observation that satisfies the operative trigger. Sources: `/workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/003_data_inventory_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/02_processing_records/015_processing_records_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/027_security_incidents_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/039_consumer_requests_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/11_risk_assessments/087_risk_assessments_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/10_regulator_correspondence/075_regulator_correspondence_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_highline_wearables_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-068-06 — sensitive-data classification**: two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key. Next evidence: an approved immutable entity crosswalk. Sources: `/workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/006_data_inventory_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/018_vendor_reviews_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/030_security_incidents_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/042_notices_consents_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/10_regulator_correspondence/078_regulator_correspondence_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_highline_wearables_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n## Alternatives considered\n\n- `highline-wearables:shortcut` — Keep every feature live because users accepted general terms.: Use a plausible summary or one source without completing the controlling joins.\n- `highline-wearables:blanket-hold` — Freeze the entire matter population: Treat supported actions and genuinely ambiguous records as if they were equally unresolved.\n\n## Assumptions and limits\n\nThis decision is limited to cb100-068-highline-wearables, the supplied synthetic records, and the matter state as of 2026-09-27. Similar names, stale revisions, and pending authority are not treated as proof.\n", "decision": {"actions": [{"determination": "completion is required by 2026-03-19 under CB-PR-3008-R777; the current event record shows completion on 2026-04-29 under CB-PR-3008-E192. Identity resolves to ENT-068-1001, revision REV-2026.2 is current, and Owen Delgado is active with capacity 1.", "due_date": "2026-09-25", "id": "ACT-CBP-068-02", "identity_id": "ENT-068-1001", "issue": "access-request deadline", "owner": "Owen Delgado", "portfolio_key": "CBP-068-02", "recommended_action": "Create feature-population rows and hold identities or versions that do not join. Owner: Owen Delgado; due 2026-09-25.", "severity": "critical", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/002_data_inventory_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/02_processing_records/014_processing_records_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/026_security_incidents_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/038_consumer_requests_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/08_retention_deletion/062_retention_deletion_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/10_regulator_correspondence/074_regulator_correspondence_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_highline_wearables_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "approval must come from Priya Raman under CB-PR-3008-R317; the effective approval record names Henry Cho under CB-PR-3008-E483. Identity resolves to ENT-068-1003, revision REV-2026.4 is current, and Isaac Romero is active with capacity 3.", "due_date": "2026-09-23", "id": "ACT-CBP-068-04", "identity_id": "ENT-068-1003", "issue": "consent-record deficiency", "owner": "Isaac Romero", "portfolio_key": "CBP-068-04", "recommended_action": "Create feature-population rows and hold identities or versions that do not join. Owner: Isaac Romero; due 2026-09-23.", "severity": "critical", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/004_data_inventory_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/02_processing_records/016_processing_records_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/028_security_incidents_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/040_consumer_requests_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/11_risk_assessments/088_risk_assessments_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_highline_wearables_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "the controlled population contains 171 records under CB-PR-3008-R959; the certification covers 151 records under CB-PR-3008-E785. Identity resolves to ENT-068-1004, revision REV-2026.5 is current, and Nadine Flores is active with capacity 2.", "due_date": "2026-09-22", "id": "ACT-CBP-068-05", "identity_id": "ENT-068-1004", "issue": "deletion-job failure", "owner": "Nadine Flores", "portfolio_key": "CBP-068-05", "recommended_action": "Create feature-population rows and hold identities or versions that do not join. Owner: Nadine Flores; due 2026-09-22.", "severity": "medium", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/005_data_inventory_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/017_vendor_reviews_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/029_security_incidents_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/041_notices_consents_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_highline_wearables_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "the operative cap is $3,922,000.00 under CB-PR-3008-R899; the matched ledger population totals $3,936,399.00 under CB-PR-3008-E252. Identity resolves to ENT-068-1006, revision REV-2026.7 is current, and Mei Whitaker is active with capacity 3.", "due_date": "2026-09-20", "id": "ACT-CBP-068-07", "identity_id": "ENT-068-1006", "issue": "notice-practice mismatch", "owner": "Mei Whitaker", "portfolio_key": "CBP-068-07", "recommended_action": "Create feature-population rows and hold identities or versions that do not join. Owner: Mei Whitaker; due 2026-09-20.", "severity": "critical", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/007_data_inventory_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/019_vendor_reviews_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/031_security_incidents_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/043_notices_consents_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_highline_wearables_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "delivery must use notices-highline_wearables_inc@example.test under CB-PR-3008-R665; the only matched receipt used archive-motionkey_analytics@example.test under CB-PR-3008-E133. Identity resolves to ENT-068-1007, revision REV-2026.1 is current, and Theo Laurent is active with capacity 4.", "due_date": "2026-09-19", "id": "ACT-CBP-068-08", "identity_id": "ENT-068-1007", "issue": "retention schedule conflict", "owner": "Theo Laurent", "portfolio_key": "CBP-068-08", "recommended_action": "Create feature-population rows and hold identities or versions that do not join. Owner: Theo Laurent; due 2026-09-19.", "severity": "critical", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/008_data_inventory_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/020_vendor_reviews_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/032_security_incidents_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/044_notices_consents_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_highline_wearables_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "an open exception blocks completion under CB-PR-3008-R257; the current status is open and unresolved under CB-PR-3008-E797. Identity resolves to ENT-068-1008, revision REV-2026.2 is current, and Lena Varga is active with capacity 3.", "due_date": "2026-09-18", "id": "ACT-CBP-068-09", "identity_id": "ENT-068-1008", "issue": "risk-assessment omission", "owner": "Lena Varga", "portfolio_key": "CBP-068-09", "recommended_action": "Create feature-population rows and hold identities or versions that do not join. Owner: Lena Varga; due 2026-09-18.", "severity": "medium", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_processing_records/009_processing_records_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/021_vendor_reviews_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/033_consumer_requests_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/045_notices_consents_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/09_training/069_training_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/093_remediation_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_highline_wearables_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "completion is required by 2025-08-18 under CB-PR-3008-R264; the current event record shows completion on 2025-08-28 under CB-PR-3008-E850. Identity resolves to ENT-068-1009, revision REV-2026.3 is current, and Elliot Mercer is active with capacity 2.", "due_date": "2026-09-26", "id": "ACT-CBP-068-10", "identity_id": "ENT-068-1009", "issue": "processing-purpose gap", "owner": "Elliot Mercer", "portfolio_key": "CBP-068-10", "recommended_action": "Create feature-population rows and hold identities or versions that do not join. Owner: Elliot Mercer; due 2026-09-26.", "severity": "low", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_processing_records/010_processing_records_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/022_vendor_reviews_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/034_consumer_requests_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/046_notices_consents_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_highline_wearables_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "the controlling threshold is 11% under CB-PR-3008-R790; the independently calculated result is 14% under CB-PR-3008-E193. Identity resolves to ENT-068-1010, revision REV-2026.4 is current, and Sofia Bennett is active with capacity 6.", "due_date": "2026-09-25", "id": "ACT-CBP-068-11", "identity_id": "ENT-068-1010", "issue": "cross-border transfer gap", "owner": "Sofia Bennett", "portfolio_key": "CBP-068-11", "recommended_action": "Create feature-population rows and hold identities or versions that do not join. Owner: Sofia Bennett; due 2026-09-25.", "severity": "high", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_processing_records/011_processing_records_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/023_vendor_reviews_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/035_consumer_requests_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/047_notices_consents_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/08_retention_deletion/059_retention_deletion_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/095_remediation_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_highline_wearables_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "approval must come from Priya Raman under CB-PR-3008-R437; the effective approval record names Caleb Hassan under CB-PR-3008-E755. Identity resolves to ENT-068-1011, revision REV-2026.5 is current, and Micah Sullivan is active with capacity 2.", "due_date": "2026-09-24", "id": "ACT-CBP-068-12", "identity_id": "ENT-068-1011", "issue": "incident-notification clock", "owner": "Micah Sullivan", "portfolio_key": "CBP-068-12", "recommended_action": "Create feature-population rows and hold identities or versions that do not join. Owner: Micah Sullivan; due 2026-09-24.", "severity": "critical", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_processing_records/012_processing_records_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/024_vendor_reviews_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/036_consumer_requests_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/048_notices_consents_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/11_risk_assessments/084_risk_assessments_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/09_training/072_training_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_highline_wearables_impact_population.xlsx"]}], "as_of": "2026-09-27", "decision": {"alternatives_considered": ["highline-wearables:shortcut", "highline-wearables:blanket-hold"], "question": "Which Highline biometric and voice deployments can remain live?", "rationale": "The four-part causal test supports 9 scoped actions and leaves 3 records on evidence hold. Biometric and voice controls require current consent and assessed, enforceable vendor handling.", "recommendation": "Suspend or remediate unsupported deployments while preserving compliant ones.", "selected_option_id": "highline-wearables:scoped-evidence"}, "holds": [{"id": "HOLD-CBP-068-01", "issue": "processor-contract omission", "portfolio_key": "CBP-068-01", "reason": "the operational record relies on a superseded control revision", "required_next_evidence": "an operational record using the current effective revision", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/001_data_inventory_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/02_processing_records/013_processing_records_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/025_security_incidents_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/037_consumer_requests_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/11_risk_assessments/085_risk_assessments_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_highline_wearables_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-068-03", "issue": "minor-consent issue", "portfolio_key": "CBP-068-03", "reason": "the current observation does not meet the operative trigger", "required_next_evidence": "a current observation that satisfies the operative trigger", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/003_data_inventory_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/02_processing_records/015_processing_records_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/027_security_incidents_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/039_consumer_requests_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/11_risk_assessments/087_risk_assessments_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/10_regulator_correspondence/075_regulator_correspondence_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_highline_wearables_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-068-06", "issue": "sensitive-data classification", "portfolio_key": "CBP-068-06", "reason": "two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key", "required_next_evidence": "an approved immutable entity crosswalk", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/006_data_inventory_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/018_vendor_reviews_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/030_security_incidents_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/042_notices_consents_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/10_regulator_correspondence/078_regulator_correspondence_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_highline_wearables_impact_population.xlsx"]}], "matter_number": "CB-PR-3008", "prepared_for": "Highline Wearables, Inc.", "schema_version": "counselbench.decision.v3", "task_id": "cb100-068-highline-wearables"}, "matter_register": {"matter_number": "CB-PR-3008", "rows": [{"decision_option_id": "highline-wearables:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "the operational record relies on a superseded control revision", "issue": "processor-contract omission", "matter_number": "CB-PR-3008", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-068-01", "row_id": "REG-CBP-068-01", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/001_data_inventory_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/02_processing_records/013_processing_records_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/025_security_incidents_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/037_consumer_requests_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/11_risk_assessments/085_risk_assessments_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_highline_wearables_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "highline-wearables:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-25", "issue": "access-request deadline", "matter_number": "CB-PR-3008", "owner": "Owen Delgado", "portfolio_key": "CBP-068-02", "row_id": "REG-CBP-068-02", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/002_data_inventory_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/02_processing_records/014_processing_records_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/026_security_incidents_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/038_consumer_requests_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/08_retention_deletion/062_retention_deletion_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/10_regulator_correspondence/074_regulator_correspondence_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_highline_wearables_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "highline-wearables:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "the current observation does not meet the operative trigger", "issue": "minor-consent issue", "matter_number": "CB-PR-3008", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-068-03", "row_id": "REG-CBP-068-03", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/003_data_inventory_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/02_processing_records/015_processing_records_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/027_security_incidents_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/039_consumer_requests_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/11_risk_assessments/087_risk_assessments_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/10_regulator_correspondence/075_regulator_correspondence_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_highline_wearables_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "highline-wearables:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-23", "issue": "consent-record deficiency", "matter_number": "CB-PR-3008", "owner": "Isaac Romero", "portfolio_key": "CBP-068-04", "row_id": "REG-CBP-068-04", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/004_data_inventory_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/02_processing_records/016_processing_records_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/028_security_incidents_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/040_consumer_requests_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/11_risk_assessments/088_risk_assessments_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_highline_wearables_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "highline-wearables:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-22", "issue": "deletion-job failure", "matter_number": "CB-PR-3008", "owner": "Nadine Flores", "portfolio_key": "CBP-068-05", "row_id": "REG-CBP-068-05", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/005_data_inventory_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/017_vendor_reviews_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/029_security_incidents_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/041_notices_consents_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_highline_wearables_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "highline-wearables:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key", "issue": "sensitive-data classification", "matter_number": "CB-PR-3008", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-068-06", "row_id": "REG-CBP-068-06", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/006_data_inventory_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/018_vendor_reviews_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/030_security_incidents_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/042_notices_consents_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/10_regulator_correspondence/078_regulator_correspondence_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_highline_wearables_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "highline-wearables:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-20", "issue": "notice-practice mismatch", "matter_number": "CB-PR-3008", "owner": "Mei Whitaker", "portfolio_key": "CBP-068-07", "row_id": "REG-CBP-068-07", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/007_data_inventory_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/019_vendor_reviews_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/031_security_incidents_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/043_notices_consents_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_highline_wearables_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "highline-wearables:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-19", "issue": "retention schedule conflict", "matter_number": "CB-PR-3008", "owner": "Theo Laurent", "portfolio_key": "CBP-068-08", "row_id": "REG-CBP-068-08", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/008_data_inventory_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/020_vendor_reviews_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/032_security_incidents_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/044_notices_consents_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_highline_wearables_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "highline-wearables:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-18", "issue": "risk-assessment omission", "matter_number": "CB-PR-3008", "owner": "Lena Varga", "portfolio_key": "CBP-068-09", "row_id": "REG-CBP-068-09", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_processing_records/009_processing_records_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/021_vendor_reviews_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/033_consumer_requests_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/045_notices_consents_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/09_training/069_training_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/093_remediation_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_highline_wearables_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "highline-wearables:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-26", "issue": "processing-purpose gap", "matter_number": "CB-PR-3008", "owner": "Elliot Mercer", "portfolio_key": "CBP-068-10", "row_id": "REG-CBP-068-10", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_processing_records/010_processing_records_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/022_vendor_reviews_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/034_consumer_requests_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/046_notices_consents_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_highline_wearables_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "highline-wearables:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-25", "issue": "cross-border transfer gap", "matter_number": "CB-PR-3008", "owner": "Sofia Bennett", "portfolio_key": "CBP-068-11", "row_id": "REG-CBP-068-11", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_processing_records/011_processing_records_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/023_vendor_reviews_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/035_consumer_requests_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/047_notices_consents_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/08_retention_deletion/059_retention_deletion_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/095_remediation_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_highline_wearables_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "highline-wearables:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-24", "issue": "incident-notification clock", "matter_number": "CB-PR-3008", "owner": "Micah Sullivan", "portfolio_key": "CBP-068-12", "row_id": "REG-CBP-068-12", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_processing_records/012_processing_records_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/024_vendor_reviews_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/036_consumer_requests_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/048_notices_consents_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/11_risk_assessments/084_risk_assessments_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/09_training/072_training_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_highline_wearables_impact_population.xlsx"]}], "schema_version": "counselbench.matter-register.v3", "task_id": "cb100-068-highline-wearables"}}, "metadata": {"benchmark": "CounselBench-100", "code_license": "Apache-2.0", "data_license": "CC-BY-4.0", "deadline": "2026-09-27", "document_count": 97, "evidence_holds": 3, "jurisdiction": "Texas", "matter_number": "CB-PR-3008", "mcp_commit": "9a96ea6e5913736f92b88345bf51caeaaa8e719f", "mcp_package": "@modelcontextprotocol/server-filesystem@2026.7.10", "practice_area": "privacy-regulatory", "reference_tool_calls": 83, "required_evidence_reads": 63, "supported_actions": 9, "synthetic": true, "venue": "Texas Attorney General", "version": "3.1.0"}, "prompt": "There is enough noise in this file that a name match or newest-document shortcut will be dangerous. Which Highline biometric and voice deployments can remain live? Wearable telemetry and voice features launched before updated consents, assessments, and vendor deletion controls were complete. The team needs the call by 2026-09-27. Leave the defensible result in the matter workspace, including any item that must stay on hold for better evidence.", "rubric": {"criteria": [{"category": "investigation", "description": "Inventory the production and use targeted searches to locate records across native formats.", "id": "investigation.discover_production"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Complete every task-specific identity, authority, operations, and approval read before the first state transition.", "id": "investigation.read_before_write"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Inspect designated source metadata before relying on those records.", "id": "investigation.custody_before_write"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "Select the supported option 'highline-wearables:scoped-evidence' after applying the four-part test.", "id": "decision.selected_option"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "Identify both rejected approaches and explain why a one-source shortcut and a blanket hold are wrong.", "id": "decision.alternatives"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-068-01 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/001_data_inventory_source_export.md rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-068-01.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_processing_records/013_processing_records_source_export.json for processor-contract omission.", "id": "investigation.CBP-068-01.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/025_security_incidents_source_export.md to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-068-01.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/037_consumer_requests_source_export.json.", "id": "investigation.CBP-068-01.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-068-01 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is the operational record relies on a superseded control revision.", "id": "decision.CBP-068-01.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-068-01 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-068-01.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-068-02 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/002_data_inventory_source_export.txt rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-068-02.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_processing_records/014_processing_records_source_export.xml for access-request deadline.", "id": "investigation.CBP-068-02.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/026_security_incidents_source_export.txt to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-068-02.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/038_consumer_requests_source_export.xml.", "id": "investigation.CBP-068-02.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-068-02 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-068-02.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-068-02 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-068-02.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-068-03 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/003_data_inventory_source_export.eml rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-068-03.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_processing_records/015_processing_records_source_export.html for minor-consent issue.", "id": "investigation.CBP-068-03.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/027_security_incidents_source_export.eml to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-068-03.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/039_consumer_requests_source_export.html.", "id": "investigation.CBP-068-03.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-068-03 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is the current observation does not meet the operative trigger.", "id": "decision.CBP-068-03.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-068-03 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-068-03.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-068-04 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/004_data_inventory_source_export.csv rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-068-04.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_processing_records/016_processing_records_source_export.pdf for consent-record deficiency.", "id": "investigation.CBP-068-04.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/028_security_incidents_source_export.csv to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-068-04.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/040_consumer_requests_source_export.pdf.", "id": "investigation.CBP-068-04.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-068-04 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-068-04.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-068-04 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-068-04.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-068-05 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/005_data_inventory_source_export.json rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-068-05.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/017_vendor_reviews_source_export.md for deletion-job failure.", "id": "investigation.CBP-068-05.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/029_security_incidents_source_export.json to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-068-05.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/041_notices_consents_source_export.md.", "id": "investigation.CBP-068-05.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-068-05 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-068-05.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-068-05 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-068-05.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-068-06 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/006_data_inventory_source_export.xml rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-068-06.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/018_vendor_reviews_source_export.txt for sensitive-data classification.", "id": "investigation.CBP-068-06.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/030_security_incidents_source_export.xml to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-068-06.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/042_notices_consents_source_export.txt.", "id": "investigation.CBP-068-06.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-068-06 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key.", "id": "decision.CBP-068-06.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-068-06 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-068-06.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-068-07 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/007_data_inventory_source_export.html rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-068-07.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/019_vendor_reviews_source_export.eml for notice-practice mismatch.", "id": "investigation.CBP-068-07.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/031_security_incidents_source_export.html to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-068-07.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/043_notices_consents_source_export.eml.", "id": "investigation.CBP-068-07.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-068-07 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-068-07.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-068-07 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-068-07.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-068-08 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/008_data_inventory_source_export.pdf rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-068-08.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/020_vendor_reviews_source_export.csv for retention schedule conflict.", "id": "investigation.CBP-068-08.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/032_security_incidents_source_export.pdf to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-068-08.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/044_notices_consents_source_export.csv.", "id": "investigation.CBP-068-08.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-068-08 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-068-08.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-068-08 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-068-08.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-068-09 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_processing_records/009_processing_records_source_export.md rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-068-09.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/021_vendor_reviews_source_export.json for risk-assessment omission.", "id": "investigation.CBP-068-09.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/033_consumer_requests_source_export.md to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-068-09.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/045_notices_consents_source_export.json.", "id": "investigation.CBP-068-09.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-068-09 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-068-09.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-068-09 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-068-09.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-068-10 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_processing_records/010_processing_records_source_export.txt rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-068-10.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/022_vendor_reviews_source_export.xml for processing-purpose gap.", "id": "investigation.CBP-068-10.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/034_consumer_requests_source_export.txt to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-068-10.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/046_notices_consents_source_export.xml.", "id": "investigation.CBP-068-10.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-068-10 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-068-10.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-068-10 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-068-10.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-068-11 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_processing_records/011_processing_records_source_export.eml rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-068-11.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/023_vendor_reviews_source_export.html for cross-border transfer gap.", "id": "investigation.CBP-068-11.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/035_consumer_requests_source_export.eml to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-068-11.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/047_notices_consents_source_export.html.", "id": "investigation.CBP-068-11.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-068-11 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-068-11.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-068-11 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-068-11.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-068-12 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_processing_records/012_processing_records_source_export.csv rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-068-12.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/024_vendor_reviews_source_export.pdf for incident-notification clock.", "id": "investigation.CBP-068-12.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/036_consumer_requests_source_export.csv to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-068-12.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/048_notices_consents_source_export.pdf.", "id": "investigation.CBP-068-12.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-068-12 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-068-12.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-068-12 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-068-12.register"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Write the exact selected option, supported action population, evidence-hold population, facts, owners, deadlines, and citations.", "id": "state.exact_decision"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create one exact register row per portfolio key with no extra, missing, or modified row.", "id": "state.exact_register"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Leave only the three approved deliverables and perform no extra state-changing write.", "id": "state.write_scope_containment"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Read back decision.json, matter-register.json, and advice.md after their final writes.", "id": "state.postwrite_readback"}, {"category": "answer", "description": "Explain the selected recommendation, supported actions, holds, alternatives, and limitations with exact source anchors.", "id": "answer.decision_note"}], "decision_options": [{"approach": "Use a plausible summary or one source without completing the controlling joins.", "id": "highline-wearables:shortcut", "label": "Keep every feature live because users accepted general terms."}, {"approach": "Treat supported actions and genuinely ambiguous records as if they were equally unresolved.", "id": "highline-wearables:blanket-hold", "label": "Freeze the entire matter population"}, {"approach": "Apply the exact identity, current-state, authority, and revision test. Create feature-population rows and hold identities or versions that do not join.", "id": "highline-wearables:scoped-evidence", "label": "Suspend or remediate unsupported deployments while preserving compliant ones."}], "evaluation_narrative": {"authority": "Biometric and voice controls require current consent and assessed, enforceable vendor handling.", "observation": "Match feature launch, user population, consent version, assessment, vendor processing, and deletion control.", "question": "Which Highline biometric and voice deployments can remain live?", "register_action": "Create feature-population rows and hold identities or versions that do not join."}, "gates": ["all_required_evidence_precedes_first_write", "decision_criteria_complete", "register_state_exact", "write_scope_contained", "all_outputs_verified_by_readback"], "metadata_checks": 4, "metric": "weighted_criteria_score", "minimum_tool_calls": 83, "required_deliverables": ["decision.json", "matter-register.json", "advice.md"], "required_document_reads": 63, "type": "deterministic", "weights": {"advice": 0.15, "decision": 0.35, "investigation": 0.25, "state": 0.25}}, "task_id": "cb100-068-highline-wearables", "task_name": "Highline biometric-data review", "world_id": "counselbench-filesystem-mcp-v3"}
+{"context_files": ["task_files/cb100-069-inkwell-publishing/01_data_inventory/001_data_inventory_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-069-inkwell-publishing/01_data_inventory/002_data_inventory_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-069-inkwell-publishing/01_data_inventory/003_data_inventory_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-069-inkwell-publishing/01_data_inventory/004_data_inventory_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-069-inkwell-publishing/01_data_inventory/005_data_inventory_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-069-inkwell-publishing/01_data_inventory/006_data_inventory_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-069-inkwell-publishing/01_data_inventory/007_data_inventory_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-069-inkwell-publishing/01_data_inventory/008_data_inventory_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-069-inkwell-publishing/02_processing_records/009_processing_records_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-069-inkwell-publishing/02_processing_records/010_processing_records_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-069-inkwell-publishing/02_processing_records/011_processing_records_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-069-inkwell-publishing/02_processing_records/012_processing_records_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-069-inkwell-publishing/02_processing_records/013_processing_records_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-069-inkwell-publishing/02_processing_records/014_processing_records_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-069-inkwell-publishing/02_processing_records/015_processing_records_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-069-inkwell-publishing/02_processing_records/016_processing_records_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-069-inkwell-publishing/03_vendor_reviews/017_vendor_reviews_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-069-inkwell-publishing/03_vendor_reviews/018_vendor_reviews_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-069-inkwell-publishing/03_vendor_reviews/019_vendor_reviews_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-069-inkwell-publishing/03_vendor_reviews/020_vendor_reviews_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-069-inkwell-publishing/03_vendor_reviews/021_vendor_reviews_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-069-inkwell-publishing/03_vendor_reviews/022_vendor_reviews_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-069-inkwell-publishing/03_vendor_reviews/023_vendor_reviews_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-069-inkwell-publishing/03_vendor_reviews/024_vendor_reviews_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-069-inkwell-publishing/04_security_incidents/025_security_incidents_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-069-inkwell-publishing/04_security_incidents/026_security_incidents_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-069-inkwell-publishing/04_security_incidents/027_security_incidents_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-069-inkwell-publishing/04_security_incidents/028_security_incidents_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-069-inkwell-publishing/04_security_incidents/029_security_incidents_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-069-inkwell-publishing/04_security_incidents/030_security_incidents_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-069-inkwell-publishing/04_security_incidents/031_security_incidents_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-069-inkwell-publishing/04_security_incidents/032_security_incidents_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-069-inkwell-publishing/05_consumer_requests/033_consumer_requests_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-069-inkwell-publishing/05_consumer_requests/034_consumer_requests_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-069-inkwell-publishing/05_consumer_requests/035_consumer_requests_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-069-inkwell-publishing/05_consumer_requests/036_consumer_requests_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-069-inkwell-publishing/05_consumer_requests/037_consumer_requests_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-069-inkwell-publishing/05_consumer_requests/038_consumer_requests_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-069-inkwell-publishing/05_consumer_requests/039_consumer_requests_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-069-inkwell-publishing/05_consumer_requests/040_consumer_requests_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-069-inkwell-publishing/06_notices_consents/041_notices_consents_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-069-inkwell-publishing/06_notices_consents/042_notices_consents_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-069-inkwell-publishing/06_notices_consents/043_notices_consents_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-069-inkwell-publishing/06_notices_consents/044_notices_consents_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-069-inkwell-publishing/06_notices_consents/045_notices_consents_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-069-inkwell-publishing/06_notices_consents/046_notices_consents_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-069-inkwell-publishing/06_notices_consents/047_notices_consents_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-069-inkwell-publishing/06_notices_consents/048_notices_consents_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-069-inkwell-publishing/07_transfer_mechanisms/049_transfer_mechanisms_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-069-inkwell-publishing/07_transfer_mechanisms/050_transfer_mechanisms_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-069-inkwell-publishing/07_transfer_mechanisms/051_transfer_mechanisms_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-069-inkwell-publishing/07_transfer_mechanisms/052_transfer_mechanisms_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-069-inkwell-publishing/07_transfer_mechanisms/053_transfer_mechanisms_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-069-inkwell-publishing/07_transfer_mechanisms/054_transfer_mechanisms_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-069-inkwell-publishing/07_transfer_mechanisms/055_transfer_mechanisms_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-069-inkwell-publishing/07_transfer_mechanisms/056_transfer_mechanisms_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-069-inkwell-publishing/08_retention_deletion/057_retention_deletion_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-069-inkwell-publishing/08_retention_deletion/058_retention_deletion_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-069-inkwell-publishing/08_retention_deletion/059_retention_deletion_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-069-inkwell-publishing/08_retention_deletion/060_retention_deletion_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-069-inkwell-publishing/08_retention_deletion/061_retention_deletion_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-069-inkwell-publishing/08_retention_deletion/062_retention_deletion_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-069-inkwell-publishing/08_retention_deletion/063_retention_deletion_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-069-inkwell-publishing/08_retention_deletion/064_retention_deletion_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-069-inkwell-publishing/09_training/065_training_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-069-inkwell-publishing/09_training/066_training_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-069-inkwell-publishing/09_training/067_training_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-069-inkwell-publishing/09_training/068_training_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-069-inkwell-publishing/09_training/069_training_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-069-inkwell-publishing/09_training/070_training_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-069-inkwell-publishing/09_training/071_training_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-069-inkwell-publishing/09_training/072_training_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-069-inkwell-publishing/10_regulator_correspondence/073_regulator_correspondence_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-069-inkwell-publishing/10_regulator_correspondence/074_regulator_correspondence_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-069-inkwell-publishing/10_regulator_correspondence/075_regulator_correspondence_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-069-inkwell-publishing/10_regulator_correspondence/076_regulator_correspondence_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-069-inkwell-publishing/10_regulator_correspondence/077_regulator_correspondence_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-069-inkwell-publishing/10_regulator_correspondence/078_regulator_correspondence_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-069-inkwell-publishing/10_regulator_correspondence/079_regulator_correspondence_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-069-inkwell-publishing/10_regulator_correspondence/080_regulator_correspondence_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-069-inkwell-publishing/11_risk_assessments/081_risk_assessments_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-069-inkwell-publishing/11_risk_assessments/082_risk_assessments_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-069-inkwell-publishing/11_risk_assessments/083_risk_assessments_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-069-inkwell-publishing/11_risk_assessments/084_risk_assessments_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-069-inkwell-publishing/11_risk_assessments/085_risk_assessments_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-069-inkwell-publishing/11_risk_assessments/086_risk_assessments_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-069-inkwell-publishing/11_risk_assessments/087_risk_assessments_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-069-inkwell-publishing/11_risk_assessments/088_risk_assessments_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-069-inkwell-publishing/12_remediation/089_remediation_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-069-inkwell-publishing/12_remediation/090_remediation_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-069-inkwell-publishing/12_remediation/091_remediation_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-069-inkwell-publishing/12_remediation/092_remediation_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-069-inkwell-publishing/12_remediation/093_remediation_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-069-inkwell-publishing/12_remediation/094_remediation_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-069-inkwell-publishing/12_remediation/095_remediation_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-069-inkwell-publishing/12_remediation/096_remediation_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-069-inkwell-publishing/12_remediation/097_inkwell_publishing_impact_population.xlsx"], "gold_output": {"advice_markdown": "# Decision note — Inkwell subscriber request audit\n\n## Recommendation\n\nComplete supported access or deletion and explain lawful holds. The reconciled record supports 5 scoped actions and leaves 7 items on evidence hold.\n\nSelected option: `inkwell-publishing:scoped-evidence`.\n\n## Why this is the supported option\n\nReconcile identity verification, account links, ad disclosures, request scope, and retention exceptions. Request rights require verified identity and exact account-purpose matching, subject to valid retention duties.\n\n## Supported actions\n\n### CBP-069-01 — subprocessor inventory mismatch (high)\n\nthe permission is limited to Oregon Attorney General under CB-PR-3009-R460; the matched activity occurred in Oregon under CB-PR-3009-E703. Identity resolves to ENT-069-1000, revision REV-2025.1 is current, and Henry Cho is active with capacity 2.\n\nAction: Create request-account rows with exact disclosure, deletion, or retention disposition. Owner: Henry Cho; due 2026-09-29.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/001_data_inventory_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/02_processing_records/013_processing_records_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/025_security_incidents_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/037_consumer_requests_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/10_regulator_correspondence/073_regulator_correspondence_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/07_transfer_mechanisms/049_transfer_mechanisms_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_inkwell_publishing_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-069-04 — processor-contract omission (low)\n\nan open exception blocks completion under CB-PR-3009-R404; the current status is open and unresolved under CB-PR-3009-E647. Identity resolves to ENT-069-1003, revision REV-2025.4 is current, and Willa Novak is active with capacity 4.\n\nAction: Create request-account rows with exact disclosure, deletion, or retention disposition. Owner: Willa Novak; due 2026-09-26.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/004_data_inventory_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/02_processing_records/016_processing_records_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/028_security_incidents_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/040_consumer_requests_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_inkwell_publishing_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-069-06 — minor-consent issue (critical)\n\nthe controlling threshold is 3% under CB-PR-3009-R904; the independently calculated result is 5% under CB-PR-3009-E517. Identity resolves to ENT-069-1005, revision REV-2025.6 is current, and Priya Raman is active with capacity 4.\n\nAction: Create request-account rows with exact disclosure, deletion, or retention disposition. Owner: Priya Raman; due 2026-09-24.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/006_data_inventory_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/018_vendor_reviews_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/030_security_incidents_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/042_notices_consents_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/10_regulator_correspondence/078_regulator_correspondence_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/09_training/066_training_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_inkwell_publishing_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-069-07 — consent-record deficiency (critical)\n\napproval must come from Willa Novak under CB-PR-3009-R216; the effective approval record names Caleb Hassan under CB-PR-3009-E318. Identity resolves to ENT-069-1006, revision REV-2025.7 is current, and Isaac Romero is active with capacity 2.\n\nAction: Create request-account rows with exact disclosure, deletion, or retention disposition. Owner: Isaac Romero; due 2026-09-23.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/007_data_inventory_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/019_vendor_reviews_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/031_security_incidents_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/043_notices_consents_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/12_remediation/091_remediation_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_inkwell_publishing_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-069-11 — retention schedule conflict (medium)\n\ndelivery must use notices-inkwell_digital_publishing@example.test under CB-PR-3009-R739; the only matched receipt used archive-blue_quill_audience_systems@example.test under CB-PR-3009-E402. Identity resolves to ENT-069-1010, revision REV-2025.4 is current, and Theo Laurent is active with capacity 3.\n\nAction: Create request-account rows with exact disclosure, deletion, or retention disposition. Owner: Theo Laurent; due 2026-09-28.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/02_processing_records/011_processing_records_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/023_vendor_reviews_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/035_consumer_requests_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/047_notices_consents_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_inkwell_publishing_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n## Evidence holds\n\n- **CBP-069-02 — identity-verification inconsistency**: the current observation does not meet the operative trigger. Next evidence: a current observation that satisfies the operative trigger. Sources: `/workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/002_data_inventory_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/02_processing_records/014_processing_records_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/026_security_incidents_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/038_consumer_requests_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/11_risk_assessments/086_risk_assessments_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/07_transfer_mechanisms/050_transfer_mechanisms_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_inkwell_publishing_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-069-03 — training completion gap**: the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective. Next evidence: effective approval and an active owner with remaining capacity. Sources: `/workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/003_data_inventory_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/02_processing_records/015_processing_records_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/027_security_incidents_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/039_consumer_requests_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_inkwell_publishing_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-069-05 — access-request deadline**: two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key. Next evidence: an approved immutable entity crosswalk. Sources: `/workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/005_data_inventory_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/017_vendor_reviews_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/029_security_incidents_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/041_notices_consents_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/09_training/065_training_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/12_remediation/089_remediation_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_inkwell_publishing_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-069-08 — deletion-job failure**: the operational record relies on a superseded control revision. Next evidence: an operational record using the current effective revision. Sources: `/workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/008_data_inventory_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/020_vendor_reviews_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/032_security_incidents_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/044_notices_consents_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_inkwell_publishing_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-069-09 — sensitive-data classification**: two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key. Next evidence: an approved immutable entity crosswalk. Sources: `/workspace/documents/02_processing_records/009_processing_records_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/021_vendor_reviews_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/033_consumer_requests_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/045_notices_consents_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/12_remediation/093_remediation_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/08_retention_deletion/057_retention_deletion_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_inkwell_publishing_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-069-10 — notice-practice mismatch**: the current observation does not meet the operative trigger. Next evidence: a current observation that satisfies the operative trigger. Sources: `/workspace/documents/02_processing_records/010_processing_records_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/022_vendor_reviews_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/034_consumer_requests_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/046_notices_consents_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/12_remediation/094_remediation_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_inkwell_publishing_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-069-12 — risk-assessment omission**: the operational record relies on a superseded control revision. Next evidence: an operational record using the current effective revision. Sources: `/workspace/documents/02_processing_records/012_processing_records_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/024_vendor_reviews_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/036_consumer_requests_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/048_notices_consents_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/11_risk_assessments/084_risk_assessments_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/12_remediation/096_remediation_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_inkwell_publishing_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n## Alternatives considered\n\n- `inkwell-publishing:blanket-hold` — Freeze the entire matter population: Treat supported actions and genuinely ambiguous records as if they were equally unresolved.\n- `inkwell-publishing:shortcut` — Match on email display name and delete all historical records.: Use a plausible summary or one source without completing the controlling joins.\n\n## Assumptions and limits\n\nThis decision is limited to cb100-069-inkwell-publishing, the supplied synthetic records, and the matter state as of 2026-09-30. Similar names, stale revisions, and pending authority are not treated as proof.\n", "decision": {"actions": [{"determination": "the permission is limited to Oregon Attorney General under CB-PR-3009-R460; the matched activity occurred in Oregon under CB-PR-3009-E703. Identity resolves to ENT-069-1000, revision REV-2025.1 is current, and Henry Cho is active with capacity 2.", "due_date": "2026-09-29", "id": "ACT-CBP-069-01", "identity_id": "ENT-069-1000", "issue": "subprocessor inventory mismatch", "owner": "Henry Cho", "portfolio_key": "CBP-069-01", "recommended_action": "Create request-account rows with exact disclosure, deletion, or retention disposition. Owner: Henry Cho; due 2026-09-29.", "severity": "high", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/001_data_inventory_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/02_processing_records/013_processing_records_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/025_security_incidents_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/037_consumer_requests_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/10_regulator_correspondence/073_regulator_correspondence_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/07_transfer_mechanisms/049_transfer_mechanisms_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_inkwell_publishing_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "an open exception blocks completion under CB-PR-3009-R404; the current status is open and unresolved under CB-PR-3009-E647. Identity resolves to ENT-069-1003, revision REV-2025.4 is current, and Willa Novak is active with capacity 4.", "due_date": "2026-09-26", "id": "ACT-CBP-069-04", "identity_id": "ENT-069-1003", "issue": "processor-contract omission", "owner": "Willa Novak", "portfolio_key": "CBP-069-04", "recommended_action": "Create request-account rows with exact disclosure, deletion, or retention disposition. Owner: Willa Novak; due 2026-09-26.", "severity": "low", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/004_data_inventory_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/02_processing_records/016_processing_records_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/028_security_incidents_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/040_consumer_requests_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_inkwell_publishing_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "the controlling threshold is 3% under CB-PR-3009-R904; the independently calculated result is 5% under CB-PR-3009-E517. Identity resolves to ENT-069-1005, revision REV-2025.6 is current, and Priya Raman is active with capacity 4.", "due_date": "2026-09-24", "id": "ACT-CBP-069-06", "identity_id": "ENT-069-1005", "issue": "minor-consent issue", "owner": "Priya Raman", "portfolio_key": "CBP-069-06", "recommended_action": "Create request-account rows with exact disclosure, deletion, or retention disposition. Owner: Priya Raman; due 2026-09-24.", "severity": "critical", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/006_data_inventory_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/018_vendor_reviews_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/030_security_incidents_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/042_notices_consents_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/10_regulator_correspondence/078_regulator_correspondence_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/09_training/066_training_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_inkwell_publishing_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "approval must come from Willa Novak under CB-PR-3009-R216; the effective approval record names Caleb Hassan under CB-PR-3009-E318. Identity resolves to ENT-069-1006, revision REV-2025.7 is current, and Isaac Romero is active with capacity 2.", "due_date": "2026-09-23", "id": "ACT-CBP-069-07", "identity_id": "ENT-069-1006", "issue": "consent-record deficiency", "owner": "Isaac Romero", "portfolio_key": "CBP-069-07", "recommended_action": "Create request-account rows with exact disclosure, deletion, or retention disposition. Owner: Isaac Romero; due 2026-09-23.", "severity": "critical", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/007_data_inventory_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/019_vendor_reviews_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/031_security_incidents_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/043_notices_consents_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/091_remediation_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_inkwell_publishing_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "delivery must use notices-inkwell_digital_publishing@example.test under CB-PR-3009-R739; the only matched receipt used archive-blue_quill_audience_systems@example.test under CB-PR-3009-E402. Identity resolves to ENT-069-1010, revision REV-2025.4 is current, and Theo Laurent is active with capacity 3.", "due_date": "2026-09-28", "id": "ACT-CBP-069-11", "identity_id": "ENT-069-1010", "issue": "retention schedule conflict", "owner": "Theo Laurent", "portfolio_key": "CBP-069-11", "recommended_action": "Create request-account rows with exact disclosure, deletion, or retention disposition. Owner: Theo Laurent; due 2026-09-28.", "severity": "medium", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_processing_records/011_processing_records_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/023_vendor_reviews_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/035_consumer_requests_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/047_notices_consents_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_inkwell_publishing_impact_population.xlsx"]}], "as_of": "2026-09-30", "decision": {"alternatives_considered": ["inkwell-publishing:blanket-hold", "inkwell-publishing:shortcut"], "question": "How should Inkwell complete the subscriber requests without disclosing or deleting the wrong person's data?", "rationale": "The four-part causal test supports 5 scoped actions and leaves 7 records on evidence hold. Request rights require verified identity and exact account-purpose matching, subject to valid retention duties.", "recommendation": "Complete supported access or deletion and explain lawful holds.", "selected_option_id": "inkwell-publishing:scoped-evidence"}, "holds": [{"id": "HOLD-CBP-069-02", "issue": "identity-verification inconsistency", "portfolio_key": "CBP-069-02", "reason": "the current observation does not meet the operative trigger", "required_next_evidence": "a current observation that satisfies the operative trigger", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/002_data_inventory_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/02_processing_records/014_processing_records_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/026_security_incidents_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/038_consumer_requests_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/11_risk_assessments/086_risk_assessments_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/07_transfer_mechanisms/050_transfer_mechanisms_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_inkwell_publishing_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-069-03", "issue": "training completion gap", "portfolio_key": "CBP-069-03", "reason": "the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective", "required_next_evidence": "effective approval and an active owner with remaining capacity", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/003_data_inventory_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/02_processing_records/015_processing_records_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/027_security_incidents_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/039_consumer_requests_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_inkwell_publishing_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-069-05", "issue": "access-request deadline", "portfolio_key": "CBP-069-05", "reason": "two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key", "required_next_evidence": "an approved immutable entity crosswalk", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/005_data_inventory_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/017_vendor_reviews_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/029_security_incidents_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/041_notices_consents_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/09_training/065_training_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/089_remediation_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_inkwell_publishing_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-069-08", "issue": "deletion-job failure", "portfolio_key": "CBP-069-08", "reason": "the operational record relies on a superseded control revision", "required_next_evidence": "an operational record using the current effective revision", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/008_data_inventory_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/020_vendor_reviews_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/032_security_incidents_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/044_notices_consents_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_inkwell_publishing_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-069-09", "issue": "sensitive-data classification", "portfolio_key": "CBP-069-09", "reason": "two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key", "required_next_evidence": "an approved immutable entity crosswalk", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_processing_records/009_processing_records_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/021_vendor_reviews_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/033_consumer_requests_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/045_notices_consents_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/093_remediation_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/08_retention_deletion/057_retention_deletion_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_inkwell_publishing_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-069-10", "issue": "notice-practice mismatch", "portfolio_key": "CBP-069-10", "reason": "the current observation does not meet the operative trigger", "required_next_evidence": "a current observation that satisfies the operative trigger", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_processing_records/010_processing_records_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/022_vendor_reviews_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/034_consumer_requests_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/046_notices_consents_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/094_remediation_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_inkwell_publishing_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-069-12", "issue": "risk-assessment omission", "portfolio_key": "CBP-069-12", "reason": "the operational record relies on a superseded control revision", "required_next_evidence": "an operational record using the current effective revision", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_processing_records/012_processing_records_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/024_vendor_reviews_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/036_consumer_requests_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/048_notices_consents_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/11_risk_assessments/084_risk_assessments_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/096_remediation_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_inkwell_publishing_impact_population.xlsx"]}], "matter_number": "CB-PR-3009", "prepared_for": "Inkwell Digital Publishing", "schema_version": "counselbench.decision.v3", "task_id": "cb100-069-inkwell-publishing"}, "matter_register": {"matter_number": "CB-PR-3009", "rows": [{"decision_option_id": "inkwell-publishing:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-29", "issue": "subprocessor inventory mismatch", "matter_number": "CB-PR-3009", "owner": "Henry Cho", "portfolio_key": "CBP-069-01", "row_id": "REG-CBP-069-01", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/001_data_inventory_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/02_processing_records/013_processing_records_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/025_security_incidents_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/037_consumer_requests_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/10_regulator_correspondence/073_regulator_correspondence_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/07_transfer_mechanisms/049_transfer_mechanisms_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_inkwell_publishing_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "inkwell-publishing:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "the current observation does not meet the operative trigger", "issue": "identity-verification inconsistency", "matter_number": "CB-PR-3009", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-069-02", "row_id": "REG-CBP-069-02", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/002_data_inventory_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/02_processing_records/014_processing_records_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/026_security_incidents_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/038_consumer_requests_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/11_risk_assessments/086_risk_assessments_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/07_transfer_mechanisms/050_transfer_mechanisms_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_inkwell_publishing_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "inkwell-publishing:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective", "issue": "training completion gap", "matter_number": "CB-PR-3009", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-069-03", "row_id": "REG-CBP-069-03", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/003_data_inventory_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/02_processing_records/015_processing_records_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/027_security_incidents_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/039_consumer_requests_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_inkwell_publishing_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "inkwell-publishing:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-26", "issue": "processor-contract omission", "matter_number": "CB-PR-3009", "owner": "Willa Novak", "portfolio_key": "CBP-069-04", "row_id": "REG-CBP-069-04", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/004_data_inventory_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/02_processing_records/016_processing_records_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/028_security_incidents_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/040_consumer_requests_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_inkwell_publishing_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "inkwell-publishing:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key", "issue": "access-request deadline", "matter_number": "CB-PR-3009", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-069-05", "row_id": "REG-CBP-069-05", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/005_data_inventory_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/017_vendor_reviews_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/029_security_incidents_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/041_notices_consents_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/09_training/065_training_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/089_remediation_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_inkwell_publishing_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "inkwell-publishing:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-24", "issue": "minor-consent issue", "matter_number": "CB-PR-3009", "owner": "Priya Raman", "portfolio_key": "CBP-069-06", "row_id": "REG-CBP-069-06", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/006_data_inventory_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/018_vendor_reviews_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/030_security_incidents_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/042_notices_consents_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/10_regulator_correspondence/078_regulator_correspondence_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/09_training/066_training_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_inkwell_publishing_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "inkwell-publishing:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-23", "issue": "consent-record deficiency", "matter_number": "CB-PR-3009", "owner": "Isaac Romero", "portfolio_key": "CBP-069-07", "row_id": "REG-CBP-069-07", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/007_data_inventory_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/019_vendor_reviews_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/031_security_incidents_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/043_notices_consents_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/091_remediation_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_inkwell_publishing_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "inkwell-publishing:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "the operational record relies on a superseded control revision", "issue": "deletion-job failure", "matter_number": "CB-PR-3009", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-069-08", "row_id": "REG-CBP-069-08", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/008_data_inventory_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/020_vendor_reviews_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/032_security_incidents_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/044_notices_consents_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_inkwell_publishing_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "inkwell-publishing:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key", "issue": "sensitive-data classification", "matter_number": "CB-PR-3009", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-069-09", "row_id": "REG-CBP-069-09", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_processing_records/009_processing_records_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/021_vendor_reviews_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/033_consumer_requests_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/045_notices_consents_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/093_remediation_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/08_retention_deletion/057_retention_deletion_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_inkwell_publishing_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "inkwell-publishing:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "the current observation does not meet the operative trigger", "issue": "notice-practice mismatch", "matter_number": "CB-PR-3009", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-069-10", "row_id": "REG-CBP-069-10", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_processing_records/010_processing_records_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/022_vendor_reviews_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/034_consumer_requests_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/046_notices_consents_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/094_remediation_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_inkwell_publishing_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "inkwell-publishing:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-28", "issue": "retention schedule conflict", "matter_number": "CB-PR-3009", "owner": "Theo Laurent", "portfolio_key": "CBP-069-11", "row_id": "REG-CBP-069-11", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_processing_records/011_processing_records_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/023_vendor_reviews_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/035_consumer_requests_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/047_notices_consents_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_inkwell_publishing_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "inkwell-publishing:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "the operational record relies on a superseded control revision", "issue": "risk-assessment omission", "matter_number": "CB-PR-3009", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-069-12", "row_id": "REG-CBP-069-12", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_processing_records/012_processing_records_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/024_vendor_reviews_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/036_consumer_requests_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/048_notices_consents_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/11_risk_assessments/084_risk_assessments_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/096_remediation_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_inkwell_publishing_impact_population.xlsx"]}], "schema_version": "counselbench.matter-register.v3", "task_id": "cb100-069-inkwell-publishing"}}, "metadata": {"benchmark": "CounselBench-100", "code_license": "Apache-2.0", "data_license": "CC-BY-4.0", "deadline": "2026-09-30", "document_count": 97, "evidence_holds": 7, "jurisdiction": "Oregon", "matter_number": "CB-PR-3009", "mcp_commit": "9a96ea6e5913736f92b88345bf51caeaaa8e719f", "mcp_package": "@modelcontextprotocol/server-filesystem@2026.7.10", "practice_area": "privacy-regulatory", "reference_tool_calls": 82, "required_evidence_reads": 63, "supported_actions": 5, "synthetic": true, "venue": "Oregon Attorney General", "version": "3.1.0"}, "prompt": "Please take ownership of the open question before the deadline. How should Inkwell complete the subscriber requests without disclosing or deleting the wrong person's data? Subscriber access and deletion requests reveal identity-verification, advertising disclosure, and data-retention inconsistencies. The team needs the call by 2026-09-30. Give me a decision-ready note and make the corresponding matter-register entries, without guessing through missing records.", "rubric": {"criteria": [{"category": "investigation", "description": "Inventory the production and use targeted searches to locate records across native formats.", "id": "investigation.discover_production"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Complete every task-specific identity, authority, operations, and approval read before the first state transition.", "id": "investigation.read_before_write"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Inspect designated source metadata before relying on those records.", "id": "investigation.custody_before_write"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "Select the supported option 'inkwell-publishing:scoped-evidence' after applying the four-part test.", "id": "decision.selected_option"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "Identify both rejected approaches and explain why a one-source shortcut and a blanket hold are wrong.", "id": "decision.alternatives"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-069-01 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/001_data_inventory_source_export.md rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-069-01.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_processing_records/013_processing_records_source_export.json for subprocessor inventory mismatch.", "id": "investigation.CBP-069-01.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/025_security_incidents_source_export.md to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-069-01.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/037_consumer_requests_source_export.json.", "id": "investigation.CBP-069-01.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-069-01 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-069-01.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-069-01 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-069-01.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-069-02 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/002_data_inventory_source_export.txt rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-069-02.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_processing_records/014_processing_records_source_export.xml for identity-verification inconsistency.", "id": "investigation.CBP-069-02.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/026_security_incidents_source_export.txt to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-069-02.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/038_consumer_requests_source_export.xml.", "id": "investigation.CBP-069-02.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-069-02 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is the current observation does not meet the operative trigger.", "id": "decision.CBP-069-02.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-069-02 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-069-02.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-069-03 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/003_data_inventory_source_export.eml rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-069-03.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_processing_records/015_processing_records_source_export.html for training completion gap.", "id": "investigation.CBP-069-03.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/027_security_incidents_source_export.eml to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-069-03.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/039_consumer_requests_source_export.html.", "id": "investigation.CBP-069-03.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-069-03 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective.", "id": "decision.CBP-069-03.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-069-03 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-069-03.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-069-04 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/004_data_inventory_source_export.csv rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-069-04.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_processing_records/016_processing_records_source_export.pdf for processor-contract omission.", "id": "investigation.CBP-069-04.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/028_security_incidents_source_export.csv to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-069-04.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/040_consumer_requests_source_export.pdf.", "id": "investigation.CBP-069-04.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-069-04 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-069-04.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-069-04 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-069-04.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-069-05 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/005_data_inventory_source_export.json rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-069-05.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/017_vendor_reviews_source_export.md for access-request deadline.", "id": "investigation.CBP-069-05.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/029_security_incidents_source_export.json to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-069-05.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/041_notices_consents_source_export.md.", "id": "investigation.CBP-069-05.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-069-05 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key.", "id": "decision.CBP-069-05.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-069-05 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-069-05.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-069-06 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/006_data_inventory_source_export.xml rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-069-06.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/018_vendor_reviews_source_export.txt for minor-consent issue.", "id": "investigation.CBP-069-06.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/030_security_incidents_source_export.xml to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-069-06.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/042_notices_consents_source_export.txt.", "id": "investigation.CBP-069-06.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-069-06 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-069-06.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-069-06 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-069-06.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-069-07 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/007_data_inventory_source_export.html rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-069-07.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/019_vendor_reviews_source_export.eml for consent-record deficiency.", "id": "investigation.CBP-069-07.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/031_security_incidents_source_export.html to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-069-07.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/043_notices_consents_source_export.eml.", "id": "investigation.CBP-069-07.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-069-07 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-069-07.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-069-07 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-069-07.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-069-08 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/008_data_inventory_source_export.pdf rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-069-08.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/020_vendor_reviews_source_export.csv for deletion-job failure.", "id": "investigation.CBP-069-08.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/032_security_incidents_source_export.pdf to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-069-08.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/044_notices_consents_source_export.csv.", "id": "investigation.CBP-069-08.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-069-08 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is the operational record relies on a superseded control revision.", "id": "decision.CBP-069-08.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-069-08 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-069-08.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-069-09 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_processing_records/009_processing_records_source_export.md rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-069-09.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/021_vendor_reviews_source_export.json for sensitive-data classification.", "id": "investigation.CBP-069-09.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/033_consumer_requests_source_export.md to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-069-09.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/045_notices_consents_source_export.json.", "id": "investigation.CBP-069-09.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-069-09 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key.", "id": "decision.CBP-069-09.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-069-09 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-069-09.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-069-10 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_processing_records/010_processing_records_source_export.txt rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-069-10.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/022_vendor_reviews_source_export.xml for notice-practice mismatch.", "id": "investigation.CBP-069-10.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/034_consumer_requests_source_export.txt to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-069-10.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/046_notices_consents_source_export.xml.", "id": "investigation.CBP-069-10.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-069-10 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is the current observation does not meet the operative trigger.", "id": "decision.CBP-069-10.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-069-10 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-069-10.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-069-11 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_processing_records/011_processing_records_source_export.eml rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-069-11.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/023_vendor_reviews_source_export.html for retention schedule conflict.", "id": "investigation.CBP-069-11.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/035_consumer_requests_source_export.eml to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-069-11.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/047_notices_consents_source_export.html.", "id": "investigation.CBP-069-11.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-069-11 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-069-11.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-069-11 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-069-11.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-069-12 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_processing_records/012_processing_records_source_export.csv rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-069-12.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/024_vendor_reviews_source_export.pdf for risk-assessment omission.", "id": "investigation.CBP-069-12.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/036_consumer_requests_source_export.csv to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-069-12.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/048_notices_consents_source_export.pdf.", "id": "investigation.CBP-069-12.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-069-12 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is the operational record relies on a superseded control revision.", "id": "decision.CBP-069-12.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-069-12 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-069-12.register"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Write the exact selected option, supported action population, evidence-hold population, facts, owners, deadlines, and citations.", "id": "state.exact_decision"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create one exact register row per portfolio key with no extra, missing, or modified row.", "id": "state.exact_register"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Leave only the three approved deliverables and perform no extra state-changing write.", "id": "state.write_scope_containment"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Read back decision.json, matter-register.json, and advice.md after their final writes.", "id": "state.postwrite_readback"}, {"category": "answer", "description": "Explain the selected recommendation, supported actions, holds, alternatives, and limitations with exact source anchors.", "id": "answer.decision_note"}], "decision_options": [{"approach": "Treat supported actions and genuinely ambiguous records as if they were equally unresolved.", "id": "inkwell-publishing:blanket-hold", "label": "Freeze the entire matter population"}, {"approach": "Apply the exact identity, current-state, authority, and revision test. Create request-account rows with exact disclosure, deletion, or retention disposition.", "id": "inkwell-publishing:scoped-evidence", "label": "Complete supported access or deletion and explain lawful holds."}, {"approach": "Use a plausible summary or one source without completing the controlling joins.", "id": "inkwell-publishing:shortcut", "label": "Match on email display name and delete all historical records."}], "evaluation_narrative": {"authority": "Request rights require verified identity and exact account-purpose matching, subject to valid retention duties.", "observation": "Reconcile identity verification, account links, ad disclosures, request scope, and retention exceptions.", "question": "How should Inkwell complete the subscriber requests without disclosing or deleting the wrong person's data?", "register_action": "Create request-account rows with exact disclosure, deletion, or retention disposition."}, "gates": ["all_required_evidence_precedes_first_write", "decision_criteria_complete", "register_state_exact", "write_scope_contained", "all_outputs_verified_by_readback"], "metadata_checks": 7, "metric": "weighted_criteria_score", "minimum_tool_calls": 82, "required_deliverables": ["decision.json", "matter-register.json", "advice.md"], "required_document_reads": 63, "type": "deterministic", "weights": {"advice": 0.15, "decision": 0.35, "investigation": 0.25, "state": 0.25}}, "task_id": "cb100-069-inkwell-publishing", "task_name": "Inkwell subscriber request audit", "world_id": "counselbench-filesystem-mcp-v3"}
+{"context_files": ["task_files/cb100-070-jetstream-saas/01_data_inventory/001_data_inventory_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-070-jetstream-saas/01_data_inventory/002_data_inventory_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-070-jetstream-saas/01_data_inventory/003_data_inventory_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-070-jetstream-saas/01_data_inventory/004_data_inventory_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-070-jetstream-saas/01_data_inventory/005_data_inventory_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-070-jetstream-saas/01_data_inventory/006_data_inventory_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-070-jetstream-saas/01_data_inventory/007_data_inventory_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-070-jetstream-saas/01_data_inventory/008_data_inventory_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-070-jetstream-saas/02_processing_records/009_processing_records_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-070-jetstream-saas/02_processing_records/010_processing_records_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-070-jetstream-saas/02_processing_records/011_processing_records_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-070-jetstream-saas/02_processing_records/012_processing_records_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-070-jetstream-saas/02_processing_records/013_processing_records_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-070-jetstream-saas/02_processing_records/014_processing_records_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-070-jetstream-saas/02_processing_records/015_processing_records_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-070-jetstream-saas/02_processing_records/016_processing_records_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-070-jetstream-saas/03_vendor_reviews/017_vendor_reviews_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-070-jetstream-saas/03_vendor_reviews/018_vendor_reviews_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-070-jetstream-saas/03_vendor_reviews/019_vendor_reviews_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-070-jetstream-saas/03_vendor_reviews/020_vendor_reviews_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-070-jetstream-saas/03_vendor_reviews/021_vendor_reviews_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-070-jetstream-saas/03_vendor_reviews/022_vendor_reviews_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-070-jetstream-saas/03_vendor_reviews/023_vendor_reviews_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-070-jetstream-saas/03_vendor_reviews/024_vendor_reviews_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-070-jetstream-saas/04_security_incidents/025_security_incidents_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-070-jetstream-saas/04_security_incidents/026_security_incidents_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-070-jetstream-saas/04_security_incidents/027_security_incidents_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-070-jetstream-saas/04_security_incidents/028_security_incidents_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-070-jetstream-saas/04_security_incidents/029_security_incidents_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-070-jetstream-saas/04_security_incidents/030_security_incidents_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-070-jetstream-saas/04_security_incidents/031_security_incidents_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-070-jetstream-saas/04_security_incidents/032_security_incidents_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-070-jetstream-saas/05_consumer_requests/033_consumer_requests_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-070-jetstream-saas/05_consumer_requests/034_consumer_requests_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-070-jetstream-saas/05_consumer_requests/035_consumer_requests_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-070-jetstream-saas/05_consumer_requests/036_consumer_requests_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-070-jetstream-saas/05_consumer_requests/037_consumer_requests_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-070-jetstream-saas/05_consumer_requests/038_consumer_requests_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-070-jetstream-saas/05_consumer_requests/039_consumer_requests_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-070-jetstream-saas/05_consumer_requests/040_consumer_requests_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-070-jetstream-saas/06_notices_consents/041_notices_consents_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-070-jetstream-saas/06_notices_consents/042_notices_consents_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-070-jetstream-saas/06_notices_consents/043_notices_consents_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-070-jetstream-saas/06_notices_consents/044_notices_consents_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-070-jetstream-saas/06_notices_consents/045_notices_consents_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-070-jetstream-saas/06_notices_consents/046_notices_consents_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-070-jetstream-saas/06_notices_consents/047_notices_consents_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-070-jetstream-saas/06_notices_consents/048_notices_consents_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-070-jetstream-saas/07_transfer_mechanisms/049_transfer_mechanisms_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-070-jetstream-saas/07_transfer_mechanisms/050_transfer_mechanisms_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-070-jetstream-saas/07_transfer_mechanisms/051_transfer_mechanisms_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-070-jetstream-saas/07_transfer_mechanisms/052_transfer_mechanisms_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-070-jetstream-saas/07_transfer_mechanisms/053_transfer_mechanisms_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-070-jetstream-saas/07_transfer_mechanisms/054_transfer_mechanisms_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-070-jetstream-saas/07_transfer_mechanisms/055_transfer_mechanisms_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-070-jetstream-saas/07_transfer_mechanisms/056_transfer_mechanisms_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-070-jetstream-saas/08_retention_deletion/057_retention_deletion_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-070-jetstream-saas/08_retention_deletion/058_retention_deletion_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-070-jetstream-saas/08_retention_deletion/059_retention_deletion_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-070-jetstream-saas/08_retention_deletion/060_retention_deletion_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-070-jetstream-saas/08_retention_deletion/061_retention_deletion_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-070-jetstream-saas/08_retention_deletion/062_retention_deletion_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-070-jetstream-saas/08_retention_deletion/063_retention_deletion_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-070-jetstream-saas/08_retention_deletion/064_retention_deletion_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-070-jetstream-saas/09_training/065_training_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-070-jetstream-saas/09_training/066_training_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-070-jetstream-saas/09_training/067_training_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-070-jetstream-saas/09_training/068_training_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-070-jetstream-saas/09_training/069_training_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-070-jetstream-saas/09_training/070_training_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-070-jetstream-saas/09_training/071_training_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-070-jetstream-saas/09_training/072_training_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-070-jetstream-saas/10_regulator_correspondence/073_regulator_correspondence_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-070-jetstream-saas/10_regulator_correspondence/074_regulator_correspondence_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-070-jetstream-saas/10_regulator_correspondence/075_regulator_correspondence_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-070-jetstream-saas/10_regulator_correspondence/076_regulator_correspondence_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-070-jetstream-saas/10_regulator_correspondence/077_regulator_correspondence_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-070-jetstream-saas/10_regulator_correspondence/078_regulator_correspondence_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-070-jetstream-saas/10_regulator_correspondence/079_regulator_correspondence_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-070-jetstream-saas/10_regulator_correspondence/080_regulator_correspondence_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-070-jetstream-saas/11_risk_assessments/081_risk_assessments_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-070-jetstream-saas/11_risk_assessments/082_risk_assessments_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-070-jetstream-saas/11_risk_assessments/083_risk_assessments_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-070-jetstream-saas/11_risk_assessments/084_risk_assessments_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-070-jetstream-saas/11_risk_assessments/085_risk_assessments_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-070-jetstream-saas/11_risk_assessments/086_risk_assessments_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-070-jetstream-saas/11_risk_assessments/087_risk_assessments_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-070-jetstream-saas/11_risk_assessments/088_risk_assessments_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-070-jetstream-saas/12_remediation/089_remediation_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-070-jetstream-saas/12_remediation/090_remediation_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-070-jetstream-saas/12_remediation/091_remediation_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-070-jetstream-saas/12_remediation/092_remediation_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-070-jetstream-saas/12_remediation/093_remediation_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-070-jetstream-saas/12_remediation/094_remediation_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-070-jetstream-saas/12_remediation/095_remediation_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-070-jetstream-saas/12_remediation/096_remediation_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-070-jetstream-saas/12_remediation/097_jetstream_saas_impact_population.xlsx"], "gold_output": {"advice_markdown": "# Decision note — Jetstream regulator commitment check\n\n## Recommendation\n\nClose only commitments supported by current evidence and remediate overdue gaps. The reconciled record supports 8 scoped actions and leaves 4 items on evidence hold.\n\nSelected option: `jetstream-saas:scoped-evidence`.\n\n## Why this is the supported option\n\nJoin assurance scope, vendor reviews, transfers, incidents, training completions, and due dates. The signed assurance and effective control definitions govern completion status.\n\n## Supported actions\n\n### CBP-070-01 — cross-border transfer gap (low)\n\nthe controlling threshold is 9% under CB-PR-3010-R758; the independently calculated result is 17% under CB-PR-3010-E509. Identity resolves to ENT-070-1000, revision REV-2026.1 is current, and Farah Ibrahim is active with capacity 3.\n\nAction: Create commitment-level rows with exact evidence and accountable owners. Owner: Farah Ibrahim; due 2026-10-03.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/001_data_inventory_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/02_processing_records/013_processing_records_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/025_security_incidents_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/037_consumer_requests_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/10_regulator_correspondence/073_regulator_correspondence_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_jetstream_saas_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-070-02 — incident-notification clock (low)\n\napproval must come from Maya Ellison under CB-PR-3010-R348; the effective approval record names Caleb Hassan under CB-PR-3010-E114. Identity resolves to ENT-070-1001, revision REV-2026.2 is current, and Dominic Alvarez is active with capacity 2.\n\nAction: Create commitment-level rows with exact evidence and accountable owners. Owner: Dominic Alvarez; due 2026-10-02.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/002_data_inventory_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/02_processing_records/014_processing_records_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/026_security_incidents_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/038_consumer_requests_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_jetstream_saas_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-070-03 — regulator commitment overdue (critical)\n\nthe controlled population contains 176 records under CB-PR-3010-R724; the certification covers 144 records under CB-PR-3010-E666. Identity resolves to ENT-070-1002, revision REV-2026.3 is current, and Leona Park is active with capacity 4.\n\nAction: Create commitment-level rows with exact evidence and accountable owners. Owner: Leona Park; due 2026-10-01.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/003_data_inventory_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/02_processing_records/015_processing_records_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/027_security_incidents_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/039_consumer_requests_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_jetstream_saas_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-070-05 — identity-verification inconsistency (high)\n\nthe operative cap is $1,162,000.00 under CB-PR-3010-R585; the matched ledger population totals $1,245,685.00 under CB-PR-3010-E975. Identity resolves to ENT-070-1004, revision REV-2026.5 is current, and Maya Ellison is active with capacity 3.\n\nAction: Create commitment-level rows with exact evidence and accountable owners. Owner: Maya Ellison; due 2026-09-29.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/005_data_inventory_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/017_vendor_reviews_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/029_security_incidents_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/041_notices_consents_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_jetstream_saas_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-070-07 — processor-contract omission (medium)\n\nan open exception blocks completion under CB-PR-3010-R828; the current status is open and unresolved under CB-PR-3010-E142. Identity resolves to ENT-070-1006, revision REV-2026.7 is current, and Willa Novak is active with capacity 5.\n\nAction: Create commitment-level rows with exact evidence and accountable owners. Owner: Willa Novak; due 2026-09-27.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/007_data_inventory_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/019_vendor_reviews_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/031_security_incidents_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/043_notices_consents_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/09_training/067_training_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_jetstream_saas_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-070-10 — consent-record deficiency (critical)\n\napproval must come from Maya Ellison under CB-PR-3010-R354; the effective approval record names Rafael Okafor under CB-PR-3010-E750. Identity resolves to ENT-070-1009, revision REV-2026.3 is current, and Isaac Romero is active with capacity 6.\n\nAction: Create commitment-level rows with exact evidence and accountable owners. Owner: Isaac Romero; due 2026-10-03.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/02_processing_records/010_processing_records_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/022_vendor_reviews_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/034_consumer_requests_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/046_notices_consents_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_jetstream_saas_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-070-11 — deletion-job failure (medium)\n\nthe controlled population contains 103 records under CB-PR-3010-R931; the certification covers 76 records under CB-PR-3010-E201. Identity resolves to ENT-070-1010, revision REV-2026.4 is current, and Nadine Flores is active with capacity 5.\n\nAction: Create commitment-level rows with exact evidence and accountable owners. Owner: Nadine Flores; due 2026-10-02.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/02_processing_records/011_processing_records_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/023_vendor_reviews_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/035_consumer_requests_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/047_notices_consents_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_jetstream_saas_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-070-12 — sensitive-data classification (low)\n\nthe permission is limited to Utah Division of Consumer Protection under CB-PR-3010-R829; the matched activity occurred in Utah under CB-PR-3010-E460. Identity resolves to ENT-070-1011, revision REV-2026.5 is current, and Rafael Okafor is active with capacity 5.\n\nAction: Create commitment-level rows with exact evidence and accountable owners. Owner: Rafael Okafor; due 2026-10-01.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/02_processing_records/012_processing_records_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/024_vendor_reviews_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/036_consumer_requests_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/048_notices_consents_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_jetstream_saas_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n## Evidence holds\n\n- **CBP-070-04 — subprocessor inventory mismatch**: two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key. Next evidence: an approved immutable entity crosswalk. Sources: `/workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/004_data_inventory_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/02_processing_records/016_processing_records_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/028_security_incidents_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/040_consumer_requests_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/11_risk_assessments/088_risk_assessments_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_jetstream_saas_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-070-06 — training completion gap**: the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective. Next evidence: effective approval and an active owner with remaining capacity. Sources: `/workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/006_data_inventory_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/018_vendor_reviews_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/030_security_incidents_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/042_notices_consents_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_jetstream_saas_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-070-08 — access-request deadline**: two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key. Next evidence: an approved immutable entity crosswalk. Sources: `/workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/008_data_inventory_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/020_vendor_reviews_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/032_security_incidents_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/044_notices_consents_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/10_regulator_correspondence/080_regulator_correspondence_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_jetstream_saas_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-070-09 — minor-consent issue**: the current observation does not meet the operative trigger. Next evidence: a current observation that satisfies the operative trigger. Sources: `/workspace/documents/02_processing_records/009_processing_records_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/021_vendor_reviews_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/033_consumer_requests_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/045_notices_consents_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/09_training/069_training_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/12_remediation/093_remediation_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_jetstream_saas_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n## Alternatives considered\n\n- `jetstream-saas:shortcut` — Close the assurance from policy publication and aggregate training percentages.: Use a plausible summary or one source without completing the controlling joins.\n- `jetstream-saas:blanket-hold` — Freeze the entire matter population: Treat supported actions and genuinely ambiguous records as if they were equally unresolved.\n\n## Assumptions and limits\n\nThis decision is limited to cb100-070-jetstream-saas, the supplied synthetic records, and the matter state as of 2026-10-04. Similar names, stale revisions, and pending authority are not treated as proof.\n", "decision": {"actions": [{"determination": "the controlling threshold is 9% under CB-PR-3010-R758; the independently calculated result is 17% under CB-PR-3010-E509. Identity resolves to ENT-070-1000, revision REV-2026.1 is current, and Farah Ibrahim is active with capacity 3.", "due_date": "2026-10-03", "id": "ACT-CBP-070-01", "identity_id": "ENT-070-1000", "issue": "cross-border transfer gap", "owner": "Farah Ibrahim", "portfolio_key": "CBP-070-01", "recommended_action": "Create commitment-level rows with exact evidence and accountable owners. Owner: Farah Ibrahim; due 2026-10-03.", "severity": "low", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/001_data_inventory_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/02_processing_records/013_processing_records_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/025_security_incidents_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/037_consumer_requests_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/10_regulator_correspondence/073_regulator_correspondence_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_jetstream_saas_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "approval must come from Maya Ellison under CB-PR-3010-R348; the effective approval record names Caleb Hassan under CB-PR-3010-E114. Identity resolves to ENT-070-1001, revision REV-2026.2 is current, and Dominic Alvarez is active with capacity 2.", "due_date": "2026-10-02", "id": "ACT-CBP-070-02", "identity_id": "ENT-070-1001", "issue": "incident-notification clock", "owner": "Dominic Alvarez", "portfolio_key": "CBP-070-02", "recommended_action": "Create commitment-level rows with exact evidence and accountable owners. Owner: Dominic Alvarez; due 2026-10-02.", "severity": "low", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/002_data_inventory_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/02_processing_records/014_processing_records_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/026_security_incidents_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/038_consumer_requests_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_jetstream_saas_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "the controlled population contains 176 records under CB-PR-3010-R724; the certification covers 144 records under CB-PR-3010-E666. Identity resolves to ENT-070-1002, revision REV-2026.3 is current, and Leona Park is active with capacity 4.", "due_date": "2026-10-01", "id": "ACT-CBP-070-03", "identity_id": "ENT-070-1002", "issue": "regulator commitment overdue", "owner": "Leona Park", "portfolio_key": "CBP-070-03", "recommended_action": "Create commitment-level rows with exact evidence and accountable owners. Owner: Leona Park; due 2026-10-01.", "severity": "critical", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/003_data_inventory_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/02_processing_records/015_processing_records_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/027_security_incidents_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/039_consumer_requests_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_jetstream_saas_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "the operative cap is $1,162,000.00 under CB-PR-3010-R585; the matched ledger population totals $1,245,685.00 under CB-PR-3010-E975. Identity resolves to ENT-070-1004, revision REV-2026.5 is current, and Maya Ellison is active with capacity 3.", "due_date": "2026-09-29", "id": "ACT-CBP-070-05", "identity_id": "ENT-070-1004", "issue": "identity-verification inconsistency", "owner": "Maya Ellison", "portfolio_key": "CBP-070-05", "recommended_action": "Create commitment-level rows with exact evidence and accountable owners. Owner: Maya Ellison; due 2026-09-29.", "severity": "high", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/005_data_inventory_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/017_vendor_reviews_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/029_security_incidents_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/041_notices_consents_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_jetstream_saas_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "an open exception blocks completion under CB-PR-3010-R828; the current status is open and unresolved under CB-PR-3010-E142. Identity resolves to ENT-070-1006, revision REV-2026.7 is current, and Willa Novak is active with capacity 5.", "due_date": "2026-09-27", "id": "ACT-CBP-070-07", "identity_id": "ENT-070-1006", "issue": "processor-contract omission", "owner": "Willa Novak", "portfolio_key": "CBP-070-07", "recommended_action": "Create commitment-level rows with exact evidence and accountable owners. Owner: Willa Novak; due 2026-09-27.", "severity": "medium", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/007_data_inventory_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/019_vendor_reviews_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/031_security_incidents_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/043_notices_consents_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/09_training/067_training_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_jetstream_saas_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "approval must come from Maya Ellison under CB-PR-3010-R354; the effective approval record names Rafael Okafor under CB-PR-3010-E750. Identity resolves to ENT-070-1009, revision REV-2026.3 is current, and Isaac Romero is active with capacity 6.", "due_date": "2026-10-03", "id": "ACT-CBP-070-10", "identity_id": "ENT-070-1009", "issue": "consent-record deficiency", "owner": "Isaac Romero", "portfolio_key": "CBP-070-10", "recommended_action": "Create commitment-level rows with exact evidence and accountable owners. Owner: Isaac Romero; due 2026-10-03.", "severity": "critical", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_processing_records/010_processing_records_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/022_vendor_reviews_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/034_consumer_requests_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/046_notices_consents_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_jetstream_saas_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "the controlled population contains 103 records under CB-PR-3010-R931; the certification covers 76 records under CB-PR-3010-E201. Identity resolves to ENT-070-1010, revision REV-2026.4 is current, and Nadine Flores is active with capacity 5.", "due_date": "2026-10-02", "id": "ACT-CBP-070-11", "identity_id": "ENT-070-1010", "issue": "deletion-job failure", "owner": "Nadine Flores", "portfolio_key": "CBP-070-11", "recommended_action": "Create commitment-level rows with exact evidence and accountable owners. Owner: Nadine Flores; due 2026-10-02.", "severity": "medium", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_processing_records/011_processing_records_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/023_vendor_reviews_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/035_consumer_requests_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/047_notices_consents_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_jetstream_saas_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "the permission is limited to Utah Division of Consumer Protection under CB-PR-3010-R829; the matched activity occurred in Utah under CB-PR-3010-E460. Identity resolves to ENT-070-1011, revision REV-2026.5 is current, and Rafael Okafor is active with capacity 5.", "due_date": "2026-10-01", "id": "ACT-CBP-070-12", "identity_id": "ENT-070-1011", "issue": "sensitive-data classification", "owner": "Rafael Okafor", "portfolio_key": "CBP-070-12", "recommended_action": "Create commitment-level rows with exact evidence and accountable owners. Owner: Rafael Okafor; due 2026-10-01.", "severity": "low", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_processing_records/012_processing_records_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/024_vendor_reviews_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/036_consumer_requests_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/048_notices_consents_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_jetstream_saas_impact_population.xlsx"]}], "as_of": "2026-10-04", "decision": {"alternatives_considered": ["jetstream-saas:shortcut", "jetstream-saas:blanket-hold"], "question": "Has Jetstream met the regulator assurance, and which commitments remain open?", "rationale": "The four-part causal test supports 8 scoped actions and leaves 4 records on evidence hold. The signed assurance and effective control definitions govern completion status.", "recommendation": "Close only commitments supported by current evidence and remediate overdue gaps.", "selected_option_id": "jetstream-saas:scoped-evidence"}, "holds": [{"id": "HOLD-CBP-070-04", "issue": "subprocessor inventory mismatch", "portfolio_key": "CBP-070-04", "reason": "two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key", "required_next_evidence": "an approved immutable entity crosswalk", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/004_data_inventory_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/02_processing_records/016_processing_records_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/028_security_incidents_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/040_consumer_requests_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/11_risk_assessments/088_risk_assessments_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_jetstream_saas_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-070-06", "issue": "training completion gap", "portfolio_key": "CBP-070-06", "reason": "the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective", "required_next_evidence": "effective approval and an active owner with remaining capacity", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/006_data_inventory_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/018_vendor_reviews_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/030_security_incidents_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/042_notices_consents_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_jetstream_saas_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-070-08", "issue": "access-request deadline", "portfolio_key": "CBP-070-08", "reason": "two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key", "required_next_evidence": "an approved immutable entity crosswalk", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/008_data_inventory_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/020_vendor_reviews_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/032_security_incidents_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/044_notices_consents_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/10_regulator_correspondence/080_regulator_correspondence_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_jetstream_saas_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-070-09", "issue": "minor-consent issue", "portfolio_key": "CBP-070-09", "reason": "the current observation does not meet the operative trigger", "required_next_evidence": "a current observation that satisfies the operative trigger", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_processing_records/009_processing_records_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/021_vendor_reviews_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/033_consumer_requests_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/045_notices_consents_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/09_training/069_training_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/093_remediation_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_jetstream_saas_impact_population.xlsx"]}], "matter_number": "CB-PR-3010", "prepared_for": "Jetstream Enterprise SaaS", "schema_version": "counselbench.decision.v3", "task_id": "cb100-070-jetstream-saas"}, "matter_register": {"matter_number": "CB-PR-3010", "rows": [{"decision_option_id": "jetstream-saas:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-10-03", "issue": "cross-border transfer gap", "matter_number": "CB-PR-3010", "owner": "Farah Ibrahim", "portfolio_key": "CBP-070-01", "row_id": "REG-CBP-070-01", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/001_data_inventory_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/02_processing_records/013_processing_records_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/025_security_incidents_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/037_consumer_requests_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/10_regulator_correspondence/073_regulator_correspondence_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_jetstream_saas_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "jetstream-saas:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-10-02", "issue": "incident-notification clock", "matter_number": "CB-PR-3010", "owner": "Dominic Alvarez", "portfolio_key": "CBP-070-02", "row_id": "REG-CBP-070-02", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/002_data_inventory_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/02_processing_records/014_processing_records_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/026_security_incidents_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/038_consumer_requests_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_jetstream_saas_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "jetstream-saas:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-10-01", "issue": "regulator commitment overdue", "matter_number": "CB-PR-3010", "owner": "Leona Park", "portfolio_key": "CBP-070-03", "row_id": "REG-CBP-070-03", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/003_data_inventory_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/02_processing_records/015_processing_records_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/027_security_incidents_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/039_consumer_requests_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_jetstream_saas_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "jetstream-saas:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key", "issue": "subprocessor inventory mismatch", "matter_number": "CB-PR-3010", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-070-04", "row_id": "REG-CBP-070-04", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/004_data_inventory_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/02_processing_records/016_processing_records_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/028_security_incidents_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/040_consumer_requests_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/11_risk_assessments/088_risk_assessments_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_jetstream_saas_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "jetstream-saas:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-29", "issue": "identity-verification inconsistency", "matter_number": "CB-PR-3010", "owner": "Maya Ellison", "portfolio_key": "CBP-070-05", "row_id": "REG-CBP-070-05", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/005_data_inventory_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/017_vendor_reviews_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/029_security_incidents_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/041_notices_consents_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_jetstream_saas_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "jetstream-saas:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective", "issue": "training completion gap", "matter_number": "CB-PR-3010", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-070-06", "row_id": "REG-CBP-070-06", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/006_data_inventory_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/018_vendor_reviews_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/030_security_incidents_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/042_notices_consents_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_jetstream_saas_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "jetstream-saas:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-27", "issue": "processor-contract omission", "matter_number": "CB-PR-3010", "owner": "Willa Novak", "portfolio_key": "CBP-070-07", "row_id": "REG-CBP-070-07", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/007_data_inventory_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/019_vendor_reviews_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/031_security_incidents_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/043_notices_consents_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/09_training/067_training_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_jetstream_saas_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "jetstream-saas:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key", "issue": "access-request deadline", "matter_number": "CB-PR-3010", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-070-08", "row_id": "REG-CBP-070-08", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/008_data_inventory_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/020_vendor_reviews_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/032_security_incidents_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/044_notices_consents_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/10_regulator_correspondence/080_regulator_correspondence_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_jetstream_saas_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "jetstream-saas:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "the current observation does not meet the operative trigger", "issue": "minor-consent issue", "matter_number": "CB-PR-3010", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-070-09", "row_id": "REG-CBP-070-09", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_processing_records/009_processing_records_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/021_vendor_reviews_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/033_consumer_requests_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/045_notices_consents_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/09_training/069_training_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/093_remediation_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_jetstream_saas_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "jetstream-saas:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-10-03", "issue": "consent-record deficiency", "matter_number": "CB-PR-3010", "owner": "Isaac Romero", "portfolio_key": "CBP-070-10", "row_id": "REG-CBP-070-10", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_processing_records/010_processing_records_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/022_vendor_reviews_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/034_consumer_requests_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/046_notices_consents_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_jetstream_saas_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "jetstream-saas:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-10-02", "issue": "deletion-job failure", "matter_number": "CB-PR-3010", "owner": "Nadine Flores", "portfolio_key": "CBP-070-11", "row_id": "REG-CBP-070-11", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_processing_records/011_processing_records_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/023_vendor_reviews_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/035_consumer_requests_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/047_notices_consents_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_jetstream_saas_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "jetstream-saas:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-10-01", "issue": "sensitive-data classification", "matter_number": "CB-PR-3010", "owner": "Rafael Okafor", "portfolio_key": "CBP-070-12", "row_id": "REG-CBP-070-12", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_processing_records/012_processing_records_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/024_vendor_reviews_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/036_consumer_requests_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/048_notices_consents_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_remediation/097_jetstream_saas_impact_population.xlsx"]}], "schema_version": "counselbench.matter-register.v3", "task_id": "cb100-070-jetstream-saas"}}, "metadata": {"benchmark": "CounselBench-100", "code_license": "Apache-2.0", "data_license": "CC-BY-4.0", "deadline": "2026-10-04", "document_count": 97, "evidence_holds": 4, "jurisdiction": "Utah", "matter_number": "CB-PR-3010", "mcp_commit": "9a96ea6e5913736f92b88345bf51caeaaa8e719f", "mcp_package": "@modelcontextprotocol/server-filesystem@2026.7.10", "practice_area": "privacy-regulatory", "reference_tool_calls": 80, "required_evidence_reads": 56, "supported_actions": 8, "synthetic": true, "venue": "Utah Division of Consumer Protection", "version": "3.1.0"}, "prompt": "I need to know what is proven, what we can do about it, and what is still only an evidence gap. Has Jetstream met the regulator assurance, and which commitments remain open? A prior assurance requires vendor reviews and training that do not match current transfer, incident, and completion records. The team needs the call by 2026-10-04. Capture the supported action and the remaining holds so the next reviewer can reproduce the call.", "rubric": {"criteria": [{"category": "investigation", "description": "Inventory the production and use targeted searches to locate records across native formats.", "id": "investigation.discover_production"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Complete every task-specific identity, authority, operations, and approval read before the first state transition.", "id": "investigation.read_before_write"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Inspect designated source metadata before relying on those records.", "id": "investigation.custody_before_write"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "Select the supported option 'jetstream-saas:scoped-evidence' after applying the four-part test.", "id": "decision.selected_option"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "Identify both rejected approaches and explain why a one-source shortcut and a blanket hold are wrong.", "id": "decision.alternatives"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-070-01 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/001_data_inventory_source_export.md rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-070-01.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_processing_records/013_processing_records_source_export.json for cross-border transfer gap.", "id": "investigation.CBP-070-01.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/025_security_incidents_source_export.md to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-070-01.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/037_consumer_requests_source_export.json.", "id": "investigation.CBP-070-01.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-070-01 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-070-01.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-070-01 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-070-01.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-070-02 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/002_data_inventory_source_export.txt rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-070-02.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_processing_records/014_processing_records_source_export.xml for incident-notification clock.", "id": "investigation.CBP-070-02.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/026_security_incidents_source_export.txt to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-070-02.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/038_consumer_requests_source_export.xml.", "id": "investigation.CBP-070-02.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-070-02 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-070-02.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-070-02 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-070-02.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-070-03 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/003_data_inventory_source_export.eml rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-070-03.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_processing_records/015_processing_records_source_export.html for regulator commitment overdue.", "id": "investigation.CBP-070-03.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/027_security_incidents_source_export.eml to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-070-03.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/039_consumer_requests_source_export.html.", "id": "investigation.CBP-070-03.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-070-03 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-070-03.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-070-03 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-070-03.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-070-04 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/004_data_inventory_source_export.csv rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-070-04.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_processing_records/016_processing_records_source_export.pdf for subprocessor inventory mismatch.", "id": "investigation.CBP-070-04.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/028_security_incidents_source_export.csv to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-070-04.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/040_consumer_requests_source_export.pdf.", "id": "investigation.CBP-070-04.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-070-04 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key.", "id": "decision.CBP-070-04.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-070-04 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-070-04.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-070-05 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/005_data_inventory_source_export.json rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-070-05.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/017_vendor_reviews_source_export.md for identity-verification inconsistency.", "id": "investigation.CBP-070-05.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/029_security_incidents_source_export.json to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-070-05.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/041_notices_consents_source_export.md.", "id": "investigation.CBP-070-05.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-070-05 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-070-05.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-070-05 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-070-05.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-070-06 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/006_data_inventory_source_export.xml rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-070-06.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/018_vendor_reviews_source_export.txt for training completion gap.", "id": "investigation.CBP-070-06.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/030_security_incidents_source_export.xml to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-070-06.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/042_notices_consents_source_export.txt.", "id": "investigation.CBP-070-06.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-070-06 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective.", "id": "decision.CBP-070-06.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-070-06 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-070-06.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-070-07 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/007_data_inventory_source_export.html rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-070-07.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/019_vendor_reviews_source_export.eml for processor-contract omission.", "id": "investigation.CBP-070-07.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/031_security_incidents_source_export.html to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-070-07.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/043_notices_consents_source_export.eml.", "id": "investigation.CBP-070-07.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-070-07 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-070-07.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-070-07 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-070-07.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-070-08 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_data_inventory/008_data_inventory_source_export.pdf rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-070-08.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/020_vendor_reviews_source_export.csv for access-request deadline.", "id": "investigation.CBP-070-08.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_security_incidents/032_security_incidents_source_export.pdf to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-070-08.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/044_notices_consents_source_export.csv.", "id": "investigation.CBP-070-08.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-070-08 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key.", "id": "decision.CBP-070-08.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-070-08 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-070-08.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-070-09 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_processing_records/009_processing_records_source_export.md rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-070-09.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/021_vendor_reviews_source_export.json for minor-consent issue.", "id": "investigation.CBP-070-09.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/033_consumer_requests_source_export.md to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-070-09.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/045_notices_consents_source_export.json.", "id": "investigation.CBP-070-09.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-070-09 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is the current observation does not meet the operative trigger.", "id": "decision.CBP-070-09.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-070-09 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-070-09.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-070-10 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_processing_records/010_processing_records_source_export.txt rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-070-10.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/022_vendor_reviews_source_export.xml for consent-record deficiency.", "id": "investigation.CBP-070-10.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/034_consumer_requests_source_export.txt to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-070-10.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/046_notices_consents_source_export.xml.", "id": "investigation.CBP-070-10.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-070-10 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-070-10.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-070-10 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-070-10.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-070-11 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_processing_records/011_processing_records_source_export.eml rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-070-11.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/023_vendor_reviews_source_export.html for deletion-job failure.", "id": "investigation.CBP-070-11.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/035_consumer_requests_source_export.eml to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-070-11.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/047_notices_consents_source_export.html.", "id": "investigation.CBP-070-11.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-070-11 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-070-11.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-070-11 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-070-11.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-070-12 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_processing_records/012_processing_records_source_export.csv rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-070-12.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_vendor_reviews/024_vendor_reviews_source_export.pdf for sensitive-data classification.", "id": "investigation.CBP-070-12.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_consumer_requests/036_consumer_requests_source_export.csv to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-070-12.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_notices_consents/048_notices_consents_source_export.pdf.", "id": "investigation.CBP-070-12.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-070-12 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-070-12.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-070-12 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-070-12.register"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Write the exact selected option, supported action population, evidence-hold population, facts, owners, deadlines, and citations.", "id": "state.exact_decision"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create one exact register row per portfolio key with no extra, missing, or modified row.", "id": "state.exact_register"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Leave only the three approved deliverables and perform no extra state-changing write.", "id": "state.write_scope_containment"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Read back decision.json, matter-register.json, and advice.md after their final writes.", "id": "state.postwrite_readback"}, {"category": "answer", "description": "Explain the selected recommendation, supported actions, holds, alternatives, and limitations with exact source anchors.", "id": "answer.decision_note"}], "decision_options": [{"approach": "Apply the exact identity, current-state, authority, and revision test. Create commitment-level rows with exact evidence and accountable owners.", "id": "jetstream-saas:scoped-evidence", "label": "Close only commitments supported by current evidence and remediate overdue gaps."}, {"approach": "Use a plausible summary or one source without completing the controlling joins.", "id": "jetstream-saas:shortcut", "label": "Close the assurance from policy publication and aggregate training percentages."}, {"approach": "Treat supported actions and genuinely ambiguous records as if they were equally unresolved.", "id": "jetstream-saas:blanket-hold", "label": "Freeze the entire matter population"}], "evaluation_narrative": {"authority": "The signed assurance and effective control definitions govern completion status.", "observation": "Join assurance scope, vendor reviews, transfers, incidents, training completions, and due dates.", "question": "Has Jetstream met the regulator assurance, and which commitments remain open?", "register_action": "Create commitment-level rows with exact evidence and accountable owners."}, "gates": ["all_required_evidence_precedes_first_write", "decision_criteria_complete", "register_state_exact", "write_scope_contained", "all_outputs_verified_by_readback"], "metadata_checks": 11, "metric": "weighted_criteria_score", "minimum_tool_calls": 80, "required_deliverables": ["decision.json", "matter-register.json", "advice.md"], "required_document_reads": 56, "type": "deterministic", "weights": {"advice": 0.15, "decision": 0.35, "investigation": 0.25, "state": 0.25}}, "task_id": "cb100-070-jetstream-saas", "task_name": "Jetstream regulator commitment check", "world_id": "counselbench-filesystem-mcp-v3"}
+{"context_files": ["task_files/cb100-071-alpine-delivery/01_handbooks_policies/001_handbooks_policies_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-071-alpine-delivery/01_handbooks_policies/002_handbooks_policies_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-071-alpine-delivery/01_handbooks_policies/003_handbooks_policies_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-071-alpine-delivery/01_handbooks_policies/004_handbooks_policies_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-071-alpine-delivery/01_handbooks_policies/005_handbooks_policies_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-071-alpine-delivery/01_handbooks_policies/006_handbooks_policies_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-071-alpine-delivery/01_handbooks_policies/007_handbooks_policies_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-071-alpine-delivery/01_handbooks_policies/008_handbooks_policies_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-071-alpine-delivery/02_personnel_records/009_personnel_records_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-071-alpine-delivery/02_personnel_records/010_personnel_records_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-071-alpine-delivery/02_personnel_records/011_personnel_records_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-071-alpine-delivery/02_personnel_records/012_personnel_records_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-071-alpine-delivery/02_personnel_records/013_personnel_records_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-071-alpine-delivery/02_personnel_records/014_personnel_records_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-071-alpine-delivery/02_personnel_records/015_personnel_records_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-071-alpine-delivery/02_personnel_records/016_personnel_records_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-071-alpine-delivery/03_payroll_time/017_payroll_time_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-071-alpine-delivery/03_payroll_time/018_payroll_time_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-071-alpine-delivery/03_payroll_time/019_payroll_time_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-071-alpine-delivery/03_payroll_time/020_payroll_time_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-071-alpine-delivery/03_payroll_time/021_payroll_time_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-071-alpine-delivery/03_payroll_time/022_payroll_time_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-071-alpine-delivery/03_payroll_time/023_payroll_time_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-071-alpine-delivery/03_payroll_time/024_payroll_time_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-071-alpine-delivery/04_compensation_equity/025_compensation_equity_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-071-alpine-delivery/04_compensation_equity/026_compensation_equity_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-071-alpine-delivery/04_compensation_equity/027_compensation_equity_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-071-alpine-delivery/04_compensation_equity/028_compensation_equity_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-071-alpine-delivery/04_compensation_equity/029_compensation_equity_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-071-alpine-delivery/04_compensation_equity/030_compensation_equity_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-071-alpine-delivery/04_compensation_equity/031_compensation_equity_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-071-alpine-delivery/04_compensation_equity/032_compensation_equity_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-071-alpine-delivery/05_leave_accommodation/033_leave_accommodation_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-071-alpine-delivery/05_leave_accommodation/034_leave_accommodation_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-071-alpine-delivery/05_leave_accommodation/035_leave_accommodation_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-071-alpine-delivery/05_leave_accommodation/036_leave_accommodation_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-071-alpine-delivery/05_leave_accommodation/037_leave_accommodation_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-071-alpine-delivery/05_leave_accommodation/038_leave_accommodation_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-071-alpine-delivery/05_leave_accommodation/039_leave_accommodation_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-071-alpine-delivery/05_leave_accommodation/040_leave_accommodation_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-071-alpine-delivery/06_complaints/041_complaints_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-071-alpine-delivery/06_complaints/042_complaints_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-071-alpine-delivery/06_complaints/043_complaints_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-071-alpine-delivery/06_complaints/044_complaints_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-071-alpine-delivery/06_complaints/045_complaints_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-071-alpine-delivery/06_complaints/046_complaints_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-071-alpine-delivery/06_complaints/047_complaints_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-071-alpine-delivery/06_complaints/048_complaints_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-071-alpine-delivery/07_investigations/049_investigations_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-071-alpine-delivery/07_investigations/050_investigations_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-071-alpine-delivery/07_investigations/051_investigations_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-071-alpine-delivery/07_investigations/052_investigations_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-071-alpine-delivery/07_investigations/053_investigations_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-071-alpine-delivery/07_investigations/054_investigations_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-071-alpine-delivery/07_investigations/055_investigations_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-071-alpine-delivery/07_investigations/056_investigations_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-071-alpine-delivery/08_performance_discipline/057_performance_discipline_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-071-alpine-delivery/08_performance_discipline/058_performance_discipline_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-071-alpine-delivery/08_performance_discipline/059_performance_discipline_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-071-alpine-delivery/08_performance_discipline/060_performance_discipline_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-071-alpine-delivery/08_performance_discipline/061_performance_discipline_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-071-alpine-delivery/08_performance_discipline/062_performance_discipline_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-071-alpine-delivery/08_performance_discipline/063_performance_discipline_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-071-alpine-delivery/08_performance_discipline/064_performance_discipline_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-071-alpine-delivery/09_separation/065_separation_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-071-alpine-delivery/09_separation/066_separation_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-071-alpine-delivery/09_separation/067_separation_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-071-alpine-delivery/09_separation/068_separation_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-071-alpine-delivery/09_separation/069_separation_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-071-alpine-delivery/09_separation/070_separation_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-071-alpine-delivery/09_separation/071_separation_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-071-alpine-delivery/09_separation/072_separation_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-071-alpine-delivery/10_contractors/073_contractors_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-071-alpine-delivery/10_contractors/074_contractors_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-071-alpine-delivery/10_contractors/075_contractors_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-071-alpine-delivery/10_contractors/076_contractors_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-071-alpine-delivery/10_contractors/077_contractors_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-071-alpine-delivery/10_contractors/078_contractors_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-071-alpine-delivery/10_contractors/079_contractors_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-071-alpine-delivery/10_contractors/080_contractors_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-071-alpine-delivery/11_training/081_training_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-071-alpine-delivery/11_training/082_training_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-071-alpine-delivery/11_training/083_training_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-071-alpine-delivery/11_training/084_training_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-071-alpine-delivery/11_training/085_training_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-071-alpine-delivery/11_training/086_training_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-071-alpine-delivery/11_training/087_training_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-071-alpine-delivery/11_training/088_training_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-071-alpine-delivery/12_agency_matters/089_agency_matters_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-071-alpine-delivery/12_agency_matters/090_agency_matters_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-071-alpine-delivery/12_agency_matters/091_agency_matters_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-071-alpine-delivery/12_agency_matters/092_agency_matters_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-071-alpine-delivery/12_agency_matters/093_agency_matters_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-071-alpine-delivery/12_agency_matters/094_agency_matters_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-071-alpine-delivery/12_agency_matters/095_agency_matters_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-071-alpine-delivery/12_agency_matters/096_agency_matters_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-071-alpine-delivery/12_agency_matters/097_alpine_delivery_impact_population.xlsx"], "gold_output": {"advice_markdown": "# Decision note — Alpine courier classification audit\n\n## Recommendation\n\nEscalate supported reclassification cases and correct scoped practices. The reconciled record supports 7 scoped actions and leaves 5 items on evidence hold.\n\nSelected option: `alpine-delivery:scoped-evidence`.\n\n## Why this is the supported option\n\nJoin contracts, routing, discipline, hours, equipment, and worker identity across systems. Classification analysis depends on the applicable control factors for each worker and period.\n\n## Supported actions\n\n### CBP-071-01 — complaint escalation gap (medium)\n\ndelivery must use notices-alpine_same_day_delivery@example.test under CB-EL-3101-R626; the only matched receipt used archive-mountain_west_couriers_association@example.test under CB-EL-3101-E183. Identity resolves to ENT-071-1000, revision REV-2025.1 is current, and Samuel Kim is active with capacity 4.\n\nAction: Create worker-period rows and hold name-only or mixed-period records. Owner: Samuel Kim; due 2026-09-04.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/001_handbooks_policies_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/013_personnel_records_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/025_compensation_equity_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/037_leave_accommodation_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/11_training/085_training_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/097_alpine_delivery_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-071-02 — restrictive-covenant conflict (medium)\n\nan open exception blocks completion under CB-EL-3101-R435; the current status is open and unresolved under CB-EL-3101-E225. Identity resolves to ENT-071-1001, revision REV-2025.2 is current, and Talia Brooks is active with capacity 5.\n\nAction: Create worker-period rows and hold name-only or mixed-period records. Owner: Talia Brooks; due 2026-09-03.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/002_handbooks_policies_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/014_personnel_records_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/026_compensation_equity_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/038_leave_accommodation_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/097_alpine_delivery_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-071-03 — classification inconsistency (medium)\n\ncompletion is required by 2025-07-05 under CB-EL-3101-R880; the current event record shows completion on 2025-08-14 under CB-EL-3101-E410. Identity resolves to ENT-071-1002, revision REV-2025.3 is current, and Adrian Mensah is active with capacity 5.\n\nAction: Create worker-period rows and hold name-only or mixed-period records. Owner: Adrian Mensah; due 2026-09-02.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/003_handbooks_policies_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/015_personnel_records_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/027_compensation_equity_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/039_leave_accommodation_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/097_alpine_delivery_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-071-04 — interactive-process lapse (critical)\n\nthe controlling threshold is 9% under CB-EL-3101-R496; the independently calculated result is 17% under CB-EL-3101-E440. Identity resolves to ENT-071-1003, revision REV-2025.4 is current, and Farah Ibrahim is active with capacity 2.\n\nAction: Create worker-period rows and hold name-only or mixed-period records. Owner: Farah Ibrahim; due 2026-09-01.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/004_handbooks_policies_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/016_personnel_records_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/028_compensation_equity_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/040_leave_accommodation_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/11_training/088_training_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/07_investigations/052_investigations_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/097_alpine_delivery_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-071-09 — personnel-file access deadline (medium)\n\ndelivery must use notices-alpine_same_day_delivery@example.test under CB-EL-3101-R878; the only matched receipt used archive-mountain_west_couriers_association@example.test under CB-EL-3101-E834. Identity resolves to ENT-071-1008, revision REV-2025.2 is current, and Jonas Feld is active with capacity 6.\n\nAction: Create worker-period rows and hold name-only or mixed-period records. Owner: Jonas Feld; due 2026-08-27.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/009_personnel_records_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/021_payroll_time_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/033_leave_accommodation_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/06_complaints/045_complaints_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/093_agency_matters_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/097_alpine_delivery_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-071-11 — discipline comparator inconsistency (medium)\n\ncompletion is required by 2025-06-07 under CB-EL-3101-R312; the current event record shows completion on 2025-07-07 under CB-EL-3101-E906. Identity resolves to ENT-071-1010, revision REV-2025.4 is current, and Owen Delgado is active with capacity 6.\n\nAction: Create worker-period rows and hold name-only or mixed-period records. Owner: Owen Delgado; due 2026-09-03.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/011_personnel_records_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/023_payroll_time_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/035_leave_accommodation_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/06_complaints/047_complaints_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/11_training/083_training_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/095_agency_matters_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/097_alpine_delivery_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-071-12 — training completion gap (medium)\n\nthe controlling threshold is 5% under CB-EL-3101-R474; the independently calculated result is 9% under CB-EL-3101-E122. Identity resolves to ENT-071-1011, revision REV-2025.5 is current, and Priya Raman is active with capacity 3.\n\nAction: Create worker-period rows and hold name-only or mixed-period records. Owner: Priya Raman; due 2026-09-02.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/012_personnel_records_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/024_payroll_time_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/036_leave_accommodation_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/06_complaints/048_complaints_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/097_alpine_delivery_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n## Evidence holds\n\n- **CBP-071-05 — separation pay discrepancy**: the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective. Next evidence: effective approval and an active owner with remaining capacity. Sources: `/workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/005_handbooks_policies_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/017_payroll_time_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/029_compensation_equity_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/06_complaints/041_complaints_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/10_contractors/077_contractors_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/09_separation/065_separation_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/097_alpine_delivery_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-071-06 — agency response commitment**: the operational record relies on a superseded control revision. Next evidence: an operational record using the current effective revision. Sources: `/workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/006_handbooks_policies_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/018_payroll_time_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/030_compensation_equity_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/06_complaints/042_complaints_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/07_investigations/054_investigations_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/097_alpine_delivery_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-071-07 — leave designation delay**: two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key. Next evidence: an approved immutable entity crosswalk. Sources: `/workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/007_handbooks_policies_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/019_payroll_time_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/031_compensation_equity_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/06_complaints/043_complaints_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/097_alpine_delivery_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-071-08 — retaliation timing**: the current observation does not meet the operative trigger. Next evidence: a current observation that satisfies the operative trigger. Sources: `/workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/008_handbooks_policies_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/020_payroll_time_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/032_compensation_equity_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/06_complaints/044_complaints_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/097_alpine_delivery_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-071-10 — pay-equity outlier**: the operational record relies on a superseded control revision. Next evidence: an operational record using the current effective revision. Sources: `/workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/010_personnel_records_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/022_payroll_time_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/034_leave_accommodation_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/06_complaints/046_complaints_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/11_training/082_training_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/094_agency_matters_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/097_alpine_delivery_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n## Alternatives considered\n\n- `alpine-delivery:shortcut` — Reclassify every courier because the platform uses routing software.: Use a plausible summary or one source without completing the controlling joins.\n- `alpine-delivery:blanket-hold` — Freeze the entire matter population: Treat supported actions and genuinely ambiguous records as if they were equally unresolved.\n\n## Assumptions and limits\n\nThis decision is limited to cb100-071-alpine-delivery, the supplied synthetic records, and the matter state as of 2026-09-05. Similar names, stale revisions, and pending authority are not treated as proof.\n", "decision": {"actions": [{"determination": "delivery must use notices-alpine_same_day_delivery@example.test under CB-EL-3101-R626; the only matched receipt used archive-mountain_west_couriers_association@example.test under CB-EL-3101-E183. Identity resolves to ENT-071-1000, revision REV-2025.1 is current, and Samuel Kim is active with capacity 4.", "due_date": "2026-09-04", "id": "ACT-CBP-071-01", "identity_id": "ENT-071-1000", "issue": "complaint escalation gap", "owner": "Samuel Kim", "portfolio_key": "CBP-071-01", "recommended_action": "Create worker-period rows and hold name-only or mixed-period records. Owner: Samuel Kim; due 2026-09-04.", "severity": "medium", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/001_handbooks_policies_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/013_personnel_records_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/025_compensation_equity_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/037_leave_accommodation_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/11_training/085_training_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/097_alpine_delivery_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "an open exception blocks completion under CB-EL-3101-R435; the current status is open and unresolved under CB-EL-3101-E225. Identity resolves to ENT-071-1001, revision REV-2025.2 is current, and Talia Brooks is active with capacity 5.", "due_date": "2026-09-03", "id": "ACT-CBP-071-02", "identity_id": "ENT-071-1001", "issue": "restrictive-covenant conflict", "owner": "Talia Brooks", "portfolio_key": "CBP-071-02", "recommended_action": "Create worker-period rows and hold name-only or mixed-period records. Owner: Talia Brooks; due 2026-09-03.", "severity": "medium", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/002_handbooks_policies_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/014_personnel_records_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/026_compensation_equity_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/038_leave_accommodation_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/097_alpine_delivery_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "completion is required by 2025-07-05 under CB-EL-3101-R880; the current event record shows completion on 2025-08-14 under CB-EL-3101-E410. Identity resolves to ENT-071-1002, revision REV-2025.3 is current, and Adrian Mensah is active with capacity 5.", "due_date": "2026-09-02", "id": "ACT-CBP-071-03", "identity_id": "ENT-071-1002", "issue": "classification inconsistency", "owner": "Adrian Mensah", "portfolio_key": "CBP-071-03", "recommended_action": "Create worker-period rows and hold name-only or mixed-period records. Owner: Adrian Mensah; due 2026-09-02.", "severity": "medium", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/003_handbooks_policies_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/015_personnel_records_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/027_compensation_equity_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/039_leave_accommodation_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/097_alpine_delivery_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "the controlling threshold is 9% under CB-EL-3101-R496; the independently calculated result is 17% under CB-EL-3101-E440. Identity resolves to ENT-071-1003, revision REV-2025.4 is current, and Farah Ibrahim is active with capacity 2.", "due_date": "2026-09-01", "id": "ACT-CBP-071-04", "identity_id": "ENT-071-1003", "issue": "interactive-process lapse", "owner": "Farah Ibrahim", "portfolio_key": "CBP-071-04", "recommended_action": "Create worker-period rows and hold name-only or mixed-period records. Owner: Farah Ibrahim; due 2026-09-01.", "severity": "critical", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/004_handbooks_policies_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/016_personnel_records_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/028_compensation_equity_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/040_leave_accommodation_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/11_training/088_training_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/07_investigations/052_investigations_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/097_alpine_delivery_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "delivery must use notices-alpine_same_day_delivery@example.test under CB-EL-3101-R878; the only matched receipt used archive-mountain_west_couriers_association@example.test under CB-EL-3101-E834. Identity resolves to ENT-071-1008, revision REV-2025.2 is current, and Jonas Feld is active with capacity 6.", "due_date": "2026-08-27", "id": "ACT-CBP-071-09", "identity_id": "ENT-071-1008", "issue": "personnel-file access deadline", "owner": "Jonas Feld", "portfolio_key": "CBP-071-09", "recommended_action": "Create worker-period rows and hold name-only or mixed-period records. Owner: Jonas Feld; due 2026-08-27.", "severity": "medium", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/009_personnel_records_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/021_payroll_time_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/033_leave_accommodation_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/06_complaints/045_complaints_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/093_agency_matters_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/097_alpine_delivery_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "completion is required by 2025-06-07 under CB-EL-3101-R312; the current event record shows completion on 2025-07-07 under CB-EL-3101-E906. Identity resolves to ENT-071-1010, revision REV-2025.4 is current, and Owen Delgado is active with capacity 6.", "due_date": "2026-09-03", "id": "ACT-CBP-071-11", "identity_id": "ENT-071-1010", "issue": "discipline comparator inconsistency", "owner": "Owen Delgado", "portfolio_key": "CBP-071-11", "recommended_action": "Create worker-period rows and hold name-only or mixed-period records. Owner: Owen Delgado; due 2026-09-03.", "severity": "medium", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/011_personnel_records_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/023_payroll_time_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/035_leave_accommodation_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/06_complaints/047_complaints_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/11_training/083_training_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/095_agency_matters_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/097_alpine_delivery_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "the controlling threshold is 5% under CB-EL-3101-R474; the independently calculated result is 9% under CB-EL-3101-E122. Identity resolves to ENT-071-1011, revision REV-2025.5 is current, and Priya Raman is active with capacity 3.", "due_date": "2026-09-02", "id": "ACT-CBP-071-12", "identity_id": "ENT-071-1011", "issue": "training completion gap", "owner": "Priya Raman", "portfolio_key": "CBP-071-12", "recommended_action": "Create worker-period rows and hold name-only or mixed-period records. Owner: Priya Raman; due 2026-09-02.", "severity": "medium", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/012_personnel_records_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/024_payroll_time_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/036_leave_accommodation_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/06_complaints/048_complaints_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/097_alpine_delivery_impact_population.xlsx"]}], "as_of": "2026-09-05", "decision": {"alternatives_considered": ["alpine-delivery:shortcut", "alpine-delivery:blanket-hold"], "question": "Which Alpine couriers should be reclassified or remediated based on actual control?", "rationale": "The four-part causal test supports 7 scoped actions and leaves 5 records on evidence hold. Classification analysis depends on the applicable control factors for each worker and period.", "recommendation": "Escalate supported reclassification cases and correct scoped practices.", "selected_option_id": "alpine-delivery:scoped-evidence"}, "holds": [{"id": "HOLD-CBP-071-05", "issue": "separation pay discrepancy", "portfolio_key": "CBP-071-05", "reason": "the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective", "required_next_evidence": "effective approval and an active owner with remaining capacity", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/005_handbooks_policies_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/017_payroll_time_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/029_compensation_equity_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/06_complaints/041_complaints_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/10_contractors/077_contractors_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/09_separation/065_separation_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/097_alpine_delivery_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-071-06", "issue": "agency response commitment", "portfolio_key": "CBP-071-06", "reason": "the operational record relies on a superseded control revision", "required_next_evidence": "an operational record using the current effective revision", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/006_handbooks_policies_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/018_payroll_time_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/030_compensation_equity_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/06_complaints/042_complaints_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/07_investigations/054_investigations_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/097_alpine_delivery_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-071-07", "issue": "leave designation delay", "portfolio_key": "CBP-071-07", "reason": "two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key", "required_next_evidence": "an approved immutable entity crosswalk", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/007_handbooks_policies_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/019_payroll_time_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/031_compensation_equity_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/06_complaints/043_complaints_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/097_alpine_delivery_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-071-08", "issue": "retaliation timing", "portfolio_key": "CBP-071-08", "reason": "the current observation does not meet the operative trigger", "required_next_evidence": "a current observation that satisfies the operative trigger", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/008_handbooks_policies_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/020_payroll_time_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/032_compensation_equity_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/06_complaints/044_complaints_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/097_alpine_delivery_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-071-10", "issue": "pay-equity outlier", "portfolio_key": "CBP-071-10", "reason": "the operational record relies on a superseded control revision", "required_next_evidence": "an operational record using the current effective revision", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/010_personnel_records_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/022_payroll_time_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/034_leave_accommodation_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/06_complaints/046_complaints_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/11_training/082_training_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/094_agency_matters_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/097_alpine_delivery_impact_population.xlsx"]}], "matter_number": "CB-EL-3101", "prepared_for": "Alpine Same-Day Delivery", "schema_version": "counselbench.decision.v3", "task_id": "cb100-071-alpine-delivery"}, "matter_register": {"matter_number": "CB-EL-3101", "rows": [{"decision_option_id": "alpine-delivery:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-04", "issue": "complaint escalation gap", "matter_number": "CB-EL-3101", "owner": "Samuel Kim", "portfolio_key": "CBP-071-01", "row_id": "REG-CBP-071-01", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/001_handbooks_policies_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/013_personnel_records_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/025_compensation_equity_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/037_leave_accommodation_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/11_training/085_training_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/097_alpine_delivery_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "alpine-delivery:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-03", "issue": "restrictive-covenant conflict", "matter_number": "CB-EL-3101", "owner": "Talia Brooks", "portfolio_key": "CBP-071-02", "row_id": "REG-CBP-071-02", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/002_handbooks_policies_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/014_personnel_records_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/026_compensation_equity_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/038_leave_accommodation_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/097_alpine_delivery_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "alpine-delivery:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-02", "issue": "classification inconsistency", "matter_number": "CB-EL-3101", "owner": "Adrian Mensah", "portfolio_key": "CBP-071-03", "row_id": "REG-CBP-071-03", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/003_handbooks_policies_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/015_personnel_records_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/027_compensation_equity_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/039_leave_accommodation_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/097_alpine_delivery_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "alpine-delivery:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-01", "issue": "interactive-process lapse", "matter_number": "CB-EL-3101", "owner": "Farah Ibrahim", "portfolio_key": "CBP-071-04", "row_id": "REG-CBP-071-04", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/004_handbooks_policies_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/016_personnel_records_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/028_compensation_equity_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/040_leave_accommodation_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/11_training/088_training_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/07_investigations/052_investigations_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/097_alpine_delivery_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "alpine-delivery:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective", "issue": "separation pay discrepancy", "matter_number": "CB-EL-3101", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-071-05", "row_id": "REG-CBP-071-05", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/005_handbooks_policies_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/017_payroll_time_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/029_compensation_equity_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/06_complaints/041_complaints_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/10_contractors/077_contractors_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/09_separation/065_separation_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/097_alpine_delivery_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "alpine-delivery:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "the operational record relies on a superseded control revision", "issue": "agency response commitment", "matter_number": "CB-EL-3101", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-071-06", "row_id": "REG-CBP-071-06", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/006_handbooks_policies_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/018_payroll_time_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/030_compensation_equity_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/06_complaints/042_complaints_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/07_investigations/054_investigations_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/097_alpine_delivery_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "alpine-delivery:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key", "issue": "leave designation delay", "matter_number": "CB-EL-3101", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-071-07", "row_id": "REG-CBP-071-07", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/007_handbooks_policies_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/019_payroll_time_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/031_compensation_equity_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/06_complaints/043_complaints_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/097_alpine_delivery_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "alpine-delivery:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "the current observation does not meet the operative trigger", "issue": "retaliation timing", "matter_number": "CB-EL-3101", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-071-08", "row_id": "REG-CBP-071-08", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/008_handbooks_policies_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/020_payroll_time_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/032_compensation_equity_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/06_complaints/044_complaints_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/097_alpine_delivery_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "alpine-delivery:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-08-27", "issue": "personnel-file access deadline", "matter_number": "CB-EL-3101", "owner": "Jonas Feld", "portfolio_key": "CBP-071-09", "row_id": "REG-CBP-071-09", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/009_personnel_records_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/021_payroll_time_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/033_leave_accommodation_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/06_complaints/045_complaints_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/093_agency_matters_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/097_alpine_delivery_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "alpine-delivery:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "the operational record relies on a superseded control revision", "issue": "pay-equity outlier", "matter_number": "CB-EL-3101", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-071-10", "row_id": "REG-CBP-071-10", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/010_personnel_records_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/022_payroll_time_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/034_leave_accommodation_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/06_complaints/046_complaints_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/11_training/082_training_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/094_agency_matters_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/097_alpine_delivery_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "alpine-delivery:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-03", "issue": "discipline comparator inconsistency", "matter_number": "CB-EL-3101", "owner": "Owen Delgado", "portfolio_key": "CBP-071-11", "row_id": "REG-CBP-071-11", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/011_personnel_records_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/023_payroll_time_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/035_leave_accommodation_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/06_complaints/047_complaints_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/11_training/083_training_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/095_agency_matters_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/097_alpine_delivery_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "alpine-delivery:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-02", "issue": "training completion gap", "matter_number": "CB-EL-3101", "owner": "Priya Raman", "portfolio_key": "CBP-071-12", "row_id": "REG-CBP-071-12", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/012_personnel_records_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/024_payroll_time_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/036_leave_accommodation_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/06_complaints/048_complaints_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/097_alpine_delivery_impact_population.xlsx"]}], "schema_version": "counselbench.matter-register.v3", "task_id": "cb100-071-alpine-delivery"}}, "metadata": {"benchmark": "CounselBench-100", "code_license": "Apache-2.0", "data_license": "CC-BY-4.0", "deadline": "2026-09-05", "document_count": 97, "evidence_holds": 5, "jurisdiction": "Colorado", "matter_number": "CB-EL-3101", "mcp_commit": "9a96ea6e5913736f92b88345bf51caeaaa8e719f", "mcp_package": "@modelcontextprotocol/server-filesystem@2026.7.10", "practice_area": "employment", "reference_tool_calls": 88, "required_evidence_reads": 61, "supported_actions": 7, "synthetic": true, "venue": "Colorado Department of Labor and Employment", "version": "3.1.0"}, "prompt": "I need a straight answer before the next partner call. Which Alpine couriers should be reclassified or remediated based on actual control? Courier contracts describe independence while routing, discipline, time, and equipment records show centralized control. The team needs the call by 2026-09-05. Update the matter record only where the evidence supports it, and give me the practical options for the client.", "rubric": {"criteria": [{"category": "investigation", "description": "Inventory the production and use targeted searches to locate records across native formats.", "id": "investigation.discover_production"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Complete every task-specific identity, authority, operations, and approval read before the first state transition.", "id": "investigation.read_before_write"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Inspect designated source metadata before relying on those records.", "id": "investigation.custody_before_write"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "Select the supported option 'alpine-delivery:scoped-evidence' after applying the four-part test.", "id": "decision.selected_option"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "Identify both rejected approaches and explain why a one-source shortcut and a blanket hold are wrong.", "id": "decision.alternatives"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-071-01 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/001_handbooks_policies_source_export.md rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-071-01.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/013_personnel_records_source_export.json for complaint escalation gap.", "id": "investigation.CBP-071-01.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/025_compensation_equity_source_export.md to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-071-01.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/037_leave_accommodation_source_export.json.", "id": "investigation.CBP-071-01.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-071-01 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-071-01.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-071-01 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-071-01.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-071-02 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/002_handbooks_policies_source_export.txt rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-071-02.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/014_personnel_records_source_export.xml for restrictive-covenant conflict.", "id": "investigation.CBP-071-02.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/026_compensation_equity_source_export.txt to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-071-02.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/038_leave_accommodation_source_export.xml.", "id": "investigation.CBP-071-02.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-071-02 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-071-02.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-071-02 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-071-02.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-071-03 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/003_handbooks_policies_source_export.eml rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-071-03.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/015_personnel_records_source_export.html for classification inconsistency.", "id": "investigation.CBP-071-03.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/027_compensation_equity_source_export.eml to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-071-03.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/039_leave_accommodation_source_export.html.", "id": "investigation.CBP-071-03.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-071-03 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-071-03.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-071-03 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-071-03.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-071-04 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/004_handbooks_policies_source_export.csv rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-071-04.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/016_personnel_records_source_export.pdf for interactive-process lapse.", "id": "investigation.CBP-071-04.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/028_compensation_equity_source_export.csv to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-071-04.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/040_leave_accommodation_source_export.pdf.", "id": "investigation.CBP-071-04.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-071-04 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-071-04.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-071-04 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-071-04.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-071-05 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/005_handbooks_policies_source_export.json rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-071-05.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/017_payroll_time_source_export.md for separation pay discrepancy.", "id": "investigation.CBP-071-05.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/029_compensation_equity_source_export.json to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-071-05.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_complaints/041_complaints_source_export.md.", "id": "investigation.CBP-071-05.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-071-05 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective.", "id": "decision.CBP-071-05.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-071-05 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-071-05.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-071-06 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/006_handbooks_policies_source_export.xml rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-071-06.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/018_payroll_time_source_export.txt for agency response commitment.", "id": "investigation.CBP-071-06.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/030_compensation_equity_source_export.xml to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-071-06.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_complaints/042_complaints_source_export.txt.", "id": "investigation.CBP-071-06.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-071-06 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is the operational record relies on a superseded control revision.", "id": "decision.CBP-071-06.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-071-06 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-071-06.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-071-07 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/007_handbooks_policies_source_export.html rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-071-07.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/019_payroll_time_source_export.eml for leave designation delay.", "id": "investigation.CBP-071-07.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/031_compensation_equity_source_export.html to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-071-07.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_complaints/043_complaints_source_export.eml.", "id": "investigation.CBP-071-07.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-071-07 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key.", "id": "decision.CBP-071-07.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-071-07 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-071-07.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-071-08 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/008_handbooks_policies_source_export.pdf rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-071-08.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/020_payroll_time_source_export.csv for retaliation timing.", "id": "investigation.CBP-071-08.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/032_compensation_equity_source_export.pdf to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-071-08.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_complaints/044_complaints_source_export.csv.", "id": "investigation.CBP-071-08.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-071-08 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is the current observation does not meet the operative trigger.", "id": "decision.CBP-071-08.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-071-08 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-071-08.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-071-09 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/009_personnel_records_source_export.md rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-071-09.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/021_payroll_time_source_export.json for personnel-file access deadline.", "id": "investigation.CBP-071-09.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/033_leave_accommodation_source_export.md to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-071-09.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_complaints/045_complaints_source_export.json.", "id": "investigation.CBP-071-09.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-071-09 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-071-09.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-071-09 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-071-09.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-071-10 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/010_personnel_records_source_export.txt rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-071-10.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/022_payroll_time_source_export.xml for pay-equity outlier.", "id": "investigation.CBP-071-10.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/034_leave_accommodation_source_export.txt to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-071-10.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_complaints/046_complaints_source_export.xml.", "id": "investigation.CBP-071-10.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-071-10 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is the operational record relies on a superseded control revision.", "id": "decision.CBP-071-10.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-071-10 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-071-10.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-071-11 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/011_personnel_records_source_export.eml rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-071-11.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/023_payroll_time_source_export.html for discipline comparator inconsistency.", "id": "investigation.CBP-071-11.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/035_leave_accommodation_source_export.eml to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-071-11.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_complaints/047_complaints_source_export.html.", "id": "investigation.CBP-071-11.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-071-11 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-071-11.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-071-11 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-071-11.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-071-12 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/012_personnel_records_source_export.csv rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-071-12.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/024_payroll_time_source_export.pdf for training completion gap.", "id": "investigation.CBP-071-12.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/036_leave_accommodation_source_export.csv to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-071-12.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_complaints/048_complaints_source_export.pdf.", "id": "investigation.CBP-071-12.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-071-12 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-071-12.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-071-12 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-071-12.register"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Write the exact selected option, supported action population, evidence-hold population, facts, owners, deadlines, and citations.", "id": "state.exact_decision"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create one exact register row per portfolio key with no extra, missing, or modified row.", "id": "state.exact_register"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Leave only the three approved deliverables and perform no extra state-changing write.", "id": "state.write_scope_containment"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Read back decision.json, matter-register.json, and advice.md after their final writes.", "id": "state.postwrite_readback"}, {"category": "answer", "description": "Explain the selected recommendation, supported actions, holds, alternatives, and limitations with exact source anchors.", "id": "answer.decision_note"}], "decision_options": [{"approach": "Use a plausible summary or one source without completing the controlling joins.", "id": "alpine-delivery:shortcut", "label": "Reclassify every courier because the platform uses routing software."}, {"approach": "Treat supported actions and genuinely ambiguous records as if they were equally unresolved.", "id": "alpine-delivery:blanket-hold", "label": "Freeze the entire matter population"}, {"approach": "Apply the exact identity, current-state, authority, and revision test. Create worker-period rows and hold name-only or mixed-period records.", "id": "alpine-delivery:scoped-evidence", "label": "Escalate supported reclassification cases and correct scoped practices."}], "evaluation_narrative": {"authority": "Classification analysis depends on the applicable control factors for each worker and period.", "observation": "Join contracts, routing, discipline, hours, equipment, and worker identity across systems.", "question": "Which Alpine couriers should be reclassified or remediated based on actual control?", "register_action": "Create worker-period rows and hold name-only or mixed-period records."}, "gates": ["all_required_evidence_precedes_first_write", "decision_criteria_complete", "register_state_exact", "write_scope_contained", "all_outputs_verified_by_readback"], "metadata_checks": 12, "metric": "weighted_criteria_score", "minimum_tool_calls": 88, "required_deliverables": ["decision.json", "matter-register.json", "advice.md"], "required_document_reads": 61, "type": "deterministic", "weights": {"advice": 0.15, "decision": 0.35, "investigation": 0.25, "state": 0.25}}, "task_id": "cb100-071-alpine-delivery", "task_name": "Alpine courier classification audit", "world_id": "counselbench-filesystem-mcp-v3"}
+{"context_files": ["task_files/cb100-072-bluebird-care/01_handbooks_policies/001_handbooks_policies_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-072-bluebird-care/01_handbooks_policies/002_handbooks_policies_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-072-bluebird-care/01_handbooks_policies/003_handbooks_policies_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-072-bluebird-care/01_handbooks_policies/004_handbooks_policies_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-072-bluebird-care/01_handbooks_policies/005_handbooks_policies_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-072-bluebird-care/01_handbooks_policies/006_handbooks_policies_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-072-bluebird-care/01_handbooks_policies/007_handbooks_policies_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-072-bluebird-care/01_handbooks_policies/008_handbooks_policies_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-072-bluebird-care/02_personnel_records/009_personnel_records_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-072-bluebird-care/02_personnel_records/010_personnel_records_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-072-bluebird-care/02_personnel_records/011_personnel_records_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-072-bluebird-care/02_personnel_records/012_personnel_records_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-072-bluebird-care/02_personnel_records/013_personnel_records_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-072-bluebird-care/02_personnel_records/014_personnel_records_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-072-bluebird-care/02_personnel_records/015_personnel_records_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-072-bluebird-care/02_personnel_records/016_personnel_records_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-072-bluebird-care/03_payroll_time/017_payroll_time_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-072-bluebird-care/03_payroll_time/018_payroll_time_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-072-bluebird-care/03_payroll_time/019_payroll_time_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-072-bluebird-care/03_payroll_time/020_payroll_time_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-072-bluebird-care/03_payroll_time/021_payroll_time_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-072-bluebird-care/03_payroll_time/022_payroll_time_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-072-bluebird-care/03_payroll_time/023_payroll_time_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-072-bluebird-care/03_payroll_time/024_payroll_time_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-072-bluebird-care/04_compensation_equity/025_compensation_equity_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-072-bluebird-care/04_compensation_equity/026_compensation_equity_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-072-bluebird-care/04_compensation_equity/027_compensation_equity_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-072-bluebird-care/04_compensation_equity/028_compensation_equity_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-072-bluebird-care/04_compensation_equity/029_compensation_equity_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-072-bluebird-care/04_compensation_equity/030_compensation_equity_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-072-bluebird-care/04_compensation_equity/031_compensation_equity_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-072-bluebird-care/04_compensation_equity/032_compensation_equity_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-072-bluebird-care/05_leave_accommodation/033_leave_accommodation_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-072-bluebird-care/05_leave_accommodation/034_leave_accommodation_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-072-bluebird-care/05_leave_accommodation/035_leave_accommodation_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-072-bluebird-care/05_leave_accommodation/036_leave_accommodation_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-072-bluebird-care/05_leave_accommodation/037_leave_accommodation_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-072-bluebird-care/05_leave_accommodation/038_leave_accommodation_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-072-bluebird-care/05_leave_accommodation/039_leave_accommodation_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-072-bluebird-care/05_leave_accommodation/040_leave_accommodation_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-072-bluebird-care/06_complaints/041_complaints_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-072-bluebird-care/06_complaints/042_complaints_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-072-bluebird-care/06_complaints/043_complaints_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-072-bluebird-care/06_complaints/044_complaints_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-072-bluebird-care/06_complaints/045_complaints_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-072-bluebird-care/06_complaints/046_complaints_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-072-bluebird-care/06_complaints/047_complaints_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-072-bluebird-care/06_complaints/048_complaints_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-072-bluebird-care/07_investigations/049_investigations_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-072-bluebird-care/07_investigations/050_investigations_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-072-bluebird-care/07_investigations/051_investigations_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-072-bluebird-care/07_investigations/052_investigations_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-072-bluebird-care/07_investigations/053_investigations_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-072-bluebird-care/07_investigations/054_investigations_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-072-bluebird-care/07_investigations/055_investigations_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-072-bluebird-care/07_investigations/056_investigations_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-072-bluebird-care/08_performance_discipline/057_performance_discipline_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-072-bluebird-care/08_performance_discipline/058_performance_discipline_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-072-bluebird-care/08_performance_discipline/059_performance_discipline_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-072-bluebird-care/08_performance_discipline/060_performance_discipline_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-072-bluebird-care/08_performance_discipline/061_performance_discipline_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-072-bluebird-care/08_performance_discipline/062_performance_discipline_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-072-bluebird-care/08_performance_discipline/063_performance_discipline_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-072-bluebird-care/08_performance_discipline/064_performance_discipline_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-072-bluebird-care/09_separation/065_separation_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-072-bluebird-care/09_separation/066_separation_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-072-bluebird-care/09_separation/067_separation_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-072-bluebird-care/09_separation/068_separation_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-072-bluebird-care/09_separation/069_separation_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-072-bluebird-care/09_separation/070_separation_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-072-bluebird-care/09_separation/071_separation_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-072-bluebird-care/09_separation/072_separation_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-072-bluebird-care/10_contractors/073_contractors_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-072-bluebird-care/10_contractors/074_contractors_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-072-bluebird-care/10_contractors/075_contractors_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-072-bluebird-care/10_contractors/076_contractors_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-072-bluebird-care/10_contractors/077_contractors_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-072-bluebird-care/10_contractors/078_contractors_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-072-bluebird-care/10_contractors/079_contractors_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-072-bluebird-care/10_contractors/080_contractors_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-072-bluebird-care/11_training/081_training_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-072-bluebird-care/11_training/082_training_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-072-bluebird-care/11_training/083_training_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-072-bluebird-care/11_training/084_training_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-072-bluebird-care/11_training/085_training_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-072-bluebird-care/11_training/086_training_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-072-bluebird-care/11_training/087_training_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-072-bluebird-care/11_training/088_training_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-072-bluebird-care/12_agency_matters/089_agency_matters_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-072-bluebird-care/12_agency_matters/090_agency_matters_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-072-bluebird-care/12_agency_matters/091_agency_matters_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-072-bluebird-care/12_agency_matters/092_agency_matters_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-072-bluebird-care/12_agency_matters/093_agency_matters_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-072-bluebird-care/12_agency_matters/094_agency_matters_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-072-bluebird-care/12_agency_matters/095_agency_matters_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-072-bluebird-care/12_agency_matters/096_agency_matters_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-072-bluebird-care/12_agency_matters/097_bluebird_care_impact_population.xlsx"], "gold_output": {"advice_markdown": "# Decision note — Bluebird caregiver wage review\n\n## Recommendation\n\nCalculate and record supported pay corrections and control failures. The reconciled record supports 8 scoped actions and leaves 4 items on evidence hold.\n\nSelected option: `bluebird-care:scoped-evidence`.\n\n## Why this is the supported option\n\nReconcile visit logs, travel routes, time records, premiums, policies, and complaints by caregiver and pay period. Applicable pay rules and the effective policy determine compensable time and premium treatment.\n\n## Supported actions\n\n### CBP-072-01 — investigation independence concern (critical)\n\nthe controlled population contains 212 records under CB-EL-3102-R650; the certification covers 192 records under CB-EL-3102-E238. Identity resolves to ENT-072-1000, revision REV-2026.1 is current, and Nora Chen is active with capacity 6.\n\nAction: Create employee-period correction rows and preserve unmatched visit records. Owner: Nora Chen; due 2026-09-08.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/001_handbooks_policies_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/013_personnel_records_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/025_compensation_equity_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/037_leave_accommodation_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/10_contractors/073_contractors_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/097_bluebird_care_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-072-02 — contractor control evidence (high)\n\nthe permission is limited to California Labor Commissioner under CB-EL-3102-R912; the matched activity occurred in California under CB-EL-3102-E730. Identity resolves to ENT-072-1001, revision REV-2026.2 is current, and Caleb Hassan is active with capacity 3.\n\nAction: Create employee-period correction rows and preserve unmatched visit records. Owner: Caleb Hassan; due 2026-09-07.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/002_handbooks_policies_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/014_personnel_records_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/026_compensation_equity_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/038_leave_accommodation_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/097_bluebird_care_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-072-03 — overtime calculation error (critical)\n\nthe operative cap is $4,042,000.00 under CB-EL-3102-R522; the matched ledger population totals $4,199,722.00 under CB-EL-3102-E495. Identity resolves to ENT-072-1002, revision REV-2026.3 is current, and Amara Patel is active with capacity 1.\n\nAction: Create employee-period correction rows and preserve unmatched visit records. Owner: Amara Patel; due 2026-09-06.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/003_handbooks_policies_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/015_personnel_records_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/027_compensation_equity_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/039_leave_accommodation_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/097_bluebird_care_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-072-04 — complaint escalation gap (medium)\n\ndelivery must use notices-bluebird_home_care_services@example.test under CB-EL-3102-R188; the only matched receipt used archive-regional_caregiver_group@example.test under CB-EL-3102-E634. Identity resolves to ENT-072-1003, revision REV-2026.4 is current, and Samuel Kim is active with capacity 2.\n\nAction: Create employee-period correction rows and preserve unmatched visit records. Owner: Samuel Kim; due 2026-09-05.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/004_handbooks_policies_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/016_personnel_records_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/028_compensation_equity_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/040_leave_accommodation_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/10_contractors/076_contractors_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/097_bluebird_care_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-072-05 — restrictive-covenant conflict (medium)\n\nan open exception blocks completion under CB-EL-3102-R846; the current status is open and unresolved under CB-EL-3102-E673. Identity resolves to ENT-072-1004, revision REV-2026.5 is current, and Talia Brooks is active with capacity 1.\n\nAction: Create employee-period correction rows and preserve unmatched visit records. Owner: Talia Brooks; due 2026-09-04.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/005_handbooks_policies_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/017_payroll_time_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/029_compensation_equity_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/06_complaints/041_complaints_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/07_investigations/053_investigations_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/097_bluebird_care_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-072-07 — interactive-process lapse (critical)\n\nthe controlling threshold is 16% under CB-EL-3102-R103; the independently calculated result is 24% under CB-EL-3102-E100. Identity resolves to ENT-072-1006, revision REV-2026.7 is current, and Farah Ibrahim is active with capacity 5.\n\nAction: Create employee-period correction rows and preserve unmatched visit records. Owner: Farah Ibrahim; due 2026-09-02.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/007_handbooks_policies_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/019_payroll_time_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/031_compensation_equity_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/06_complaints/043_complaints_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/07_investigations/055_investigations_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/091_agency_matters_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/097_bluebird_care_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-072-08 — separation pay discrepancy (medium)\n\napproval must come from Farah Ibrahim under CB-EL-3102-R864; the effective approval record names Henry Cho under CB-EL-3102-E727. Identity resolves to ENT-072-1007, revision REV-2026.1 is current, and Dominic Alvarez is active with capacity 6.\n\nAction: Create employee-period correction rows and preserve unmatched visit records. Owner: Dominic Alvarez; due 2026-09-01.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/008_handbooks_policies_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/020_payroll_time_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/032_compensation_equity_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/06_complaints/044_complaints_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/10_contractors/080_contractors_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/07_investigations/056_investigations_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/097_bluebird_care_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-072-12 — personnel-file access deadline (critical)\n\ndelivery must use notices-bluebird_home_care_services@example.test under CB-EL-3102-R932; the only matched receipt used archive-regional_caregiver_group@example.test under CB-EL-3102-E413. Identity resolves to ENT-072-1011, revision REV-2026.5 is current, and Jonas Feld is active with capacity 1.\n\nAction: Create employee-period correction rows and preserve unmatched visit records. Owner: Jonas Feld; due 2026-09-06.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/012_personnel_records_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/024_payroll_time_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/036_leave_accommodation_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/06_complaints/048_complaints_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/11_training/084_training_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/097_bluebird_care_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n## Evidence holds\n\n- **CBP-072-06 — classification inconsistency**: two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key. Next evidence: an approved immutable entity crosswalk. Sources: `/workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/006_handbooks_policies_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/018_payroll_time_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/030_compensation_equity_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/06_complaints/042_complaints_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/090_agency_matters_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/097_bluebird_care_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-072-09 — agency response commitment**: the operational record relies on a superseded control revision. Next evidence: an operational record using the current effective revision. Sources: `/workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/009_personnel_records_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/021_payroll_time_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/033_leave_accommodation_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/06_complaints/045_complaints_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/097_bluebird_care_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-072-10 — leave designation delay**: two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key. Next evidence: an approved immutable entity crosswalk. Sources: `/workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/010_personnel_records_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/022_payroll_time_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/034_leave_accommodation_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/06_complaints/046_complaints_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/097_bluebird_care_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-072-11 — retaliation timing**: the current observation does not meet the operative trigger. Next evidence: a current observation that satisfies the operative trigger. Sources: `/workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/011_personnel_records_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/023_payroll_time_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/035_leave_accommodation_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/06_complaints/047_complaints_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/08_performance_discipline/059_performance_discipline_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/11_training/083_training_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/097_bluebird_care_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n## Alternatives considered\n\n- `bluebird-care:blanket-hold` — Freeze the entire matter population: Treat supported actions and genuinely ambiguous records as if they were equally unresolved.\n- `bluebird-care:shortcut` — Pay a flat estimate to every caregiver based on sampled exceptions.: Use a plausible summary or one source without completing the controlling joins.\n\n## Assumptions and limits\n\nThis decision is limited to cb100-072-bluebird-care, the supplied synthetic records, and the matter state as of 2026-09-09. Similar names, stale revisions, and pending authority are not treated as proof.\n", "decision": {"actions": [{"determination": "the controlled population contains 212 records under CB-EL-3102-R650; the certification covers 192 records under CB-EL-3102-E238. Identity resolves to ENT-072-1000, revision REV-2026.1 is current, and Nora Chen is active with capacity 6.", "due_date": "2026-09-08", "id": "ACT-CBP-072-01", "identity_id": "ENT-072-1000", "issue": "investigation independence concern", "owner": "Nora Chen", "portfolio_key": "CBP-072-01", "recommended_action": "Create employee-period correction rows and preserve unmatched visit records. Owner: Nora Chen; due 2026-09-08.", "severity": "critical", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/001_handbooks_policies_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/013_personnel_records_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/025_compensation_equity_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/037_leave_accommodation_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/10_contractors/073_contractors_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/097_bluebird_care_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "the permission is limited to California Labor Commissioner under CB-EL-3102-R912; the matched activity occurred in California under CB-EL-3102-E730. Identity resolves to ENT-072-1001, revision REV-2026.2 is current, and Caleb Hassan is active with capacity 3.", "due_date": "2026-09-07", "id": "ACT-CBP-072-02", "identity_id": "ENT-072-1001", "issue": "contractor control evidence", "owner": "Caleb Hassan", "portfolio_key": "CBP-072-02", "recommended_action": "Create employee-period correction rows and preserve unmatched visit records. Owner: Caleb Hassan; due 2026-09-07.", "severity": "high", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/002_handbooks_policies_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/014_personnel_records_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/026_compensation_equity_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/038_leave_accommodation_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/097_bluebird_care_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "the operative cap is $4,042,000.00 under CB-EL-3102-R522; the matched ledger population totals $4,199,722.00 under CB-EL-3102-E495. Identity resolves to ENT-072-1002, revision REV-2026.3 is current, and Amara Patel is active with capacity 1.", "due_date": "2026-09-06", "id": "ACT-CBP-072-03", "identity_id": "ENT-072-1002", "issue": "overtime calculation error", "owner": "Amara Patel", "portfolio_key": "CBP-072-03", "recommended_action": "Create employee-period correction rows and preserve unmatched visit records. Owner: Amara Patel; due 2026-09-06.", "severity": "critical", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/003_handbooks_policies_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/015_personnel_records_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/027_compensation_equity_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/039_leave_accommodation_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/097_bluebird_care_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "delivery must use notices-bluebird_home_care_services@example.test under CB-EL-3102-R188; the only matched receipt used archive-regional_caregiver_group@example.test under CB-EL-3102-E634. Identity resolves to ENT-072-1003, revision REV-2026.4 is current, and Samuel Kim is active with capacity 2.", "due_date": "2026-09-05", "id": "ACT-CBP-072-04", "identity_id": "ENT-072-1003", "issue": "complaint escalation gap", "owner": "Samuel Kim", "portfolio_key": "CBP-072-04", "recommended_action": "Create employee-period correction rows and preserve unmatched visit records. Owner: Samuel Kim; due 2026-09-05.", "severity": "medium", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/004_handbooks_policies_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/016_personnel_records_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/028_compensation_equity_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/040_leave_accommodation_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/10_contractors/076_contractors_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/097_bluebird_care_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "an open exception blocks completion under CB-EL-3102-R846; the current status is open and unresolved under CB-EL-3102-E673. Identity resolves to ENT-072-1004, revision REV-2026.5 is current, and Talia Brooks is active with capacity 1.", "due_date": "2026-09-04", "id": "ACT-CBP-072-05", "identity_id": "ENT-072-1004", "issue": "restrictive-covenant conflict", "owner": "Talia Brooks", "portfolio_key": "CBP-072-05", "recommended_action": "Create employee-period correction rows and preserve unmatched visit records. Owner: Talia Brooks; due 2026-09-04.", "severity": "medium", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/005_handbooks_policies_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/017_payroll_time_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/029_compensation_equity_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/06_complaints/041_complaints_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/07_investigations/053_investigations_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/097_bluebird_care_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "the controlling threshold is 16% under CB-EL-3102-R103; the independently calculated result is 24% under CB-EL-3102-E100. Identity resolves to ENT-072-1006, revision REV-2026.7 is current, and Farah Ibrahim is active with capacity 5.", "due_date": "2026-09-02", "id": "ACT-CBP-072-07", "identity_id": "ENT-072-1006", "issue": "interactive-process lapse", "owner": "Farah Ibrahim", "portfolio_key": "CBP-072-07", "recommended_action": "Create employee-period correction rows and preserve unmatched visit records. Owner: Farah Ibrahim; due 2026-09-02.", "severity": "critical", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/007_handbooks_policies_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/019_payroll_time_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/031_compensation_equity_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/06_complaints/043_complaints_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/07_investigations/055_investigations_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/091_agency_matters_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/097_bluebird_care_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "approval must come from Farah Ibrahim under CB-EL-3102-R864; the effective approval record names Henry Cho under CB-EL-3102-E727. Identity resolves to ENT-072-1007, revision REV-2026.1 is current, and Dominic Alvarez is active with capacity 6.", "due_date": "2026-09-01", "id": "ACT-CBP-072-08", "identity_id": "ENT-072-1007", "issue": "separation pay discrepancy", "owner": "Dominic Alvarez", "portfolio_key": "CBP-072-08", "recommended_action": "Create employee-period correction rows and preserve unmatched visit records. Owner: Dominic Alvarez; due 2026-09-01.", "severity": "medium", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/008_handbooks_policies_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/020_payroll_time_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/032_compensation_equity_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/06_complaints/044_complaints_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/10_contractors/080_contractors_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/07_investigations/056_investigations_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/097_bluebird_care_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "delivery must use notices-bluebird_home_care_services@example.test under CB-EL-3102-R932; the only matched receipt used archive-regional_caregiver_group@example.test under CB-EL-3102-E413. Identity resolves to ENT-072-1011, revision REV-2026.5 is current, and Jonas Feld is active with capacity 1.", "due_date": "2026-09-06", "id": "ACT-CBP-072-12", "identity_id": "ENT-072-1011", "issue": "personnel-file access deadline", "owner": "Jonas Feld", "portfolio_key": "CBP-072-12", "recommended_action": "Create employee-period correction rows and preserve unmatched visit records. Owner: Jonas Feld; due 2026-09-06.", "severity": "critical", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/012_personnel_records_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/024_payroll_time_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/036_leave_accommodation_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/06_complaints/048_complaints_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/11_training/084_training_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/097_bluebird_care_impact_population.xlsx"]}], "as_of": "2026-09-09", "decision": {"alternatives_considered": ["bluebird-care:blanket-hold", "bluebird-care:shortcut"], "question": "What wage corrections does Bluebird owe for travel, meals, and complaint handling?", "rationale": "The four-part causal test supports 8 scoped actions and leaves 4 records on evidence hold. Applicable pay rules and the effective policy determine compensable time and premium treatment.", "recommendation": "Calculate and record supported pay corrections and control failures.", "selected_option_id": "bluebird-care:scoped-evidence"}, "holds": [{"id": "HOLD-CBP-072-06", "issue": "classification inconsistency", "portfolio_key": "CBP-072-06", "reason": "two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key", "required_next_evidence": "an approved immutable entity crosswalk", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/006_handbooks_policies_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/018_payroll_time_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/030_compensation_equity_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/06_complaints/042_complaints_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/090_agency_matters_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/097_bluebird_care_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-072-09", "issue": "agency response commitment", "portfolio_key": "CBP-072-09", "reason": "the operational record relies on a superseded control revision", "required_next_evidence": "an operational record using the current effective revision", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/009_personnel_records_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/021_payroll_time_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/033_leave_accommodation_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/06_complaints/045_complaints_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/097_bluebird_care_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-072-10", "issue": "leave designation delay", "portfolio_key": "CBP-072-10", "reason": "two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key", "required_next_evidence": "an approved immutable entity crosswalk", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/010_personnel_records_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/022_payroll_time_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/034_leave_accommodation_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/06_complaints/046_complaints_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/097_bluebird_care_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-072-11", "issue": "retaliation timing", "portfolio_key": "CBP-072-11", "reason": "the current observation does not meet the operative trigger", "required_next_evidence": "a current observation that satisfies the operative trigger", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/011_personnel_records_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/023_payroll_time_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/035_leave_accommodation_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/06_complaints/047_complaints_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/08_performance_discipline/059_performance_discipline_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/11_training/083_training_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/097_bluebird_care_impact_population.xlsx"]}], "matter_number": "CB-EL-3102", "prepared_for": "Bluebird Home Care Services", "schema_version": "counselbench.decision.v3", "task_id": "cb100-072-bluebird-care"}, "matter_register": {"matter_number": "CB-EL-3102", "rows": [{"decision_option_id": "bluebird-care:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-08", "issue": "investigation independence concern", "matter_number": "CB-EL-3102", "owner": "Nora Chen", "portfolio_key": "CBP-072-01", "row_id": "REG-CBP-072-01", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/001_handbooks_policies_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/013_personnel_records_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/025_compensation_equity_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/037_leave_accommodation_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/10_contractors/073_contractors_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/097_bluebird_care_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "bluebird-care:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-07", "issue": "contractor control evidence", "matter_number": "CB-EL-3102", "owner": "Caleb Hassan", "portfolio_key": "CBP-072-02", "row_id": "REG-CBP-072-02", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/002_handbooks_policies_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/014_personnel_records_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/026_compensation_equity_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/038_leave_accommodation_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/097_bluebird_care_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "bluebird-care:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-06", "issue": "overtime calculation error", "matter_number": "CB-EL-3102", "owner": "Amara Patel", "portfolio_key": "CBP-072-03", "row_id": "REG-CBP-072-03", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/003_handbooks_policies_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/015_personnel_records_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/027_compensation_equity_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/039_leave_accommodation_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/097_bluebird_care_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "bluebird-care:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-05", "issue": "complaint escalation gap", "matter_number": "CB-EL-3102", "owner": "Samuel Kim", "portfolio_key": "CBP-072-04", "row_id": "REG-CBP-072-04", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/004_handbooks_policies_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/016_personnel_records_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/028_compensation_equity_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/040_leave_accommodation_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/10_contractors/076_contractors_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/097_bluebird_care_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "bluebird-care:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-04", "issue": "restrictive-covenant conflict", "matter_number": "CB-EL-3102", "owner": "Talia Brooks", "portfolio_key": "CBP-072-05", "row_id": "REG-CBP-072-05", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/005_handbooks_policies_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/017_payroll_time_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/029_compensation_equity_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/06_complaints/041_complaints_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/07_investigations/053_investigations_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/097_bluebird_care_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "bluebird-care:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key", "issue": "classification inconsistency", "matter_number": "CB-EL-3102", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-072-06", "row_id": "REG-CBP-072-06", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/006_handbooks_policies_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/018_payroll_time_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/030_compensation_equity_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/06_complaints/042_complaints_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/090_agency_matters_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/097_bluebird_care_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "bluebird-care:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-02", "issue": "interactive-process lapse", "matter_number": "CB-EL-3102", "owner": "Farah Ibrahim", "portfolio_key": "CBP-072-07", "row_id": "REG-CBP-072-07", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/007_handbooks_policies_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/019_payroll_time_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/031_compensation_equity_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/06_complaints/043_complaints_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/07_investigations/055_investigations_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/091_agency_matters_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/097_bluebird_care_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "bluebird-care:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-01", "issue": "separation pay discrepancy", "matter_number": "CB-EL-3102", "owner": "Dominic Alvarez", "portfolio_key": "CBP-072-08", "row_id": "REG-CBP-072-08", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/008_handbooks_policies_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/020_payroll_time_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/032_compensation_equity_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/06_complaints/044_complaints_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/10_contractors/080_contractors_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/07_investigations/056_investigations_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/097_bluebird_care_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "bluebird-care:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "the operational record relies on a superseded control revision", "issue": "agency response commitment", "matter_number": "CB-EL-3102", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-072-09", "row_id": "REG-CBP-072-09", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/009_personnel_records_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/021_payroll_time_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/033_leave_accommodation_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/06_complaints/045_complaints_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/097_bluebird_care_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "bluebird-care:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key", "issue": "leave designation delay", "matter_number": "CB-EL-3102", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-072-10", "row_id": "REG-CBP-072-10", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/010_personnel_records_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/022_payroll_time_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/034_leave_accommodation_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/06_complaints/046_complaints_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/097_bluebird_care_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "bluebird-care:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "the current observation does not meet the operative trigger", "issue": "retaliation timing", "matter_number": "CB-EL-3102", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-072-11", "row_id": "REG-CBP-072-11", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/011_personnel_records_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/023_payroll_time_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/035_leave_accommodation_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/06_complaints/047_complaints_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/08_performance_discipline/059_performance_discipline_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/11_training/083_training_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/097_bluebird_care_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "bluebird-care:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-06", "issue": "personnel-file access deadline", "matter_number": "CB-EL-3102", "owner": "Jonas Feld", "portfolio_key": "CBP-072-12", "row_id": "REG-CBP-072-12", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/012_personnel_records_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/024_payroll_time_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/036_leave_accommodation_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/06_complaints/048_complaints_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/11_training/084_training_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/097_bluebird_care_impact_population.xlsx"]}], "schema_version": "counselbench.matter-register.v3", "task_id": "cb100-072-bluebird-care"}}, "metadata": {"benchmark": "CounselBench-100", "code_license": "Apache-2.0", "data_license": "CC-BY-4.0", "deadline": "2026-09-09", "document_count": 97, "evidence_holds": 4, "jurisdiction": "California", "matter_number": "CB-EL-3102", "mcp_commit": "9a96ea6e5913736f92b88345bf51caeaaa8e719f", "mcp_package": "@modelcontextprotocol/server-filesystem@2026.7.10", "practice_area": "employment", "reference_tool_calls": 86, "required_evidence_reads": 61, "supported_actions": 8, "synthetic": true, "venue": "California Labor Commissioner", "version": "3.1.0"}, "prompt": "The business team is asking whether it can move, and I do not want to answer from the summary deck. What wage corrections does Bluebird owe for travel, meals, and complaint handling? Payroll, visit logs, and policies conflict on travel time, meal premiums, and complaint escalation for mobile caregivers. The team needs the call by 2026-09-09. Document the scoped result for the team and separate genuine exceptions from unresolved identity or revision questions.", "rubric": {"criteria": [{"category": "investigation", "description": "Inventory the production and use targeted searches to locate records across native formats.", "id": "investigation.discover_production"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Complete every task-specific identity, authority, operations, and approval read before the first state transition.", "id": "investigation.read_before_write"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Inspect designated source metadata before relying on those records.", "id": "investigation.custody_before_write"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "Select the supported option 'bluebird-care:scoped-evidence' after applying the four-part test.", "id": "decision.selected_option"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "Identify both rejected approaches and explain why a one-source shortcut and a blanket hold are wrong.", "id": "decision.alternatives"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-072-01 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/001_handbooks_policies_source_export.md rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-072-01.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/013_personnel_records_source_export.json for investigation independence concern.", "id": "investigation.CBP-072-01.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/025_compensation_equity_source_export.md to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-072-01.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/037_leave_accommodation_source_export.json.", "id": "investigation.CBP-072-01.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-072-01 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-072-01.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-072-01 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-072-01.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-072-02 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/002_handbooks_policies_source_export.txt rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-072-02.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/014_personnel_records_source_export.xml for contractor control evidence.", "id": "investigation.CBP-072-02.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/026_compensation_equity_source_export.txt to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-072-02.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/038_leave_accommodation_source_export.xml.", "id": "investigation.CBP-072-02.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-072-02 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-072-02.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-072-02 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-072-02.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-072-03 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/003_handbooks_policies_source_export.eml rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-072-03.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/015_personnel_records_source_export.html for overtime calculation error.", "id": "investigation.CBP-072-03.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/027_compensation_equity_source_export.eml to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-072-03.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/039_leave_accommodation_source_export.html.", "id": "investigation.CBP-072-03.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-072-03 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-072-03.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-072-03 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-072-03.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-072-04 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/004_handbooks_policies_source_export.csv rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-072-04.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/016_personnel_records_source_export.pdf for complaint escalation gap.", "id": "investigation.CBP-072-04.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/028_compensation_equity_source_export.csv to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-072-04.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/040_leave_accommodation_source_export.pdf.", "id": "investigation.CBP-072-04.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-072-04 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-072-04.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-072-04 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-072-04.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-072-05 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/005_handbooks_policies_source_export.json rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-072-05.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/017_payroll_time_source_export.md for restrictive-covenant conflict.", "id": "investigation.CBP-072-05.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/029_compensation_equity_source_export.json to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-072-05.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_complaints/041_complaints_source_export.md.", "id": "investigation.CBP-072-05.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-072-05 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-072-05.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-072-05 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-072-05.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-072-06 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/006_handbooks_policies_source_export.xml rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-072-06.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/018_payroll_time_source_export.txt for classification inconsistency.", "id": "investigation.CBP-072-06.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/030_compensation_equity_source_export.xml to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-072-06.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_complaints/042_complaints_source_export.txt.", "id": "investigation.CBP-072-06.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-072-06 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key.", "id": "decision.CBP-072-06.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-072-06 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-072-06.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-072-07 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/007_handbooks_policies_source_export.html rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-072-07.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/019_payroll_time_source_export.eml for interactive-process lapse.", "id": "investigation.CBP-072-07.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/031_compensation_equity_source_export.html to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-072-07.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_complaints/043_complaints_source_export.eml.", "id": "investigation.CBP-072-07.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-072-07 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-072-07.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-072-07 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-072-07.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-072-08 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/008_handbooks_policies_source_export.pdf rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-072-08.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/020_payroll_time_source_export.csv for separation pay discrepancy.", "id": "investigation.CBP-072-08.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/032_compensation_equity_source_export.pdf to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-072-08.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_complaints/044_complaints_source_export.csv.", "id": "investigation.CBP-072-08.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-072-08 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-072-08.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-072-08 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-072-08.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-072-09 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/009_personnel_records_source_export.md rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-072-09.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/021_payroll_time_source_export.json for agency response commitment.", "id": "investigation.CBP-072-09.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/033_leave_accommodation_source_export.md to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-072-09.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_complaints/045_complaints_source_export.json.", "id": "investigation.CBP-072-09.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-072-09 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is the operational record relies on a superseded control revision.", "id": "decision.CBP-072-09.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-072-09 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-072-09.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-072-10 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/010_personnel_records_source_export.txt rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-072-10.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/022_payroll_time_source_export.xml for leave designation delay.", "id": "investigation.CBP-072-10.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/034_leave_accommodation_source_export.txt to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-072-10.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_complaints/046_complaints_source_export.xml.", "id": "investigation.CBP-072-10.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-072-10 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key.", "id": "decision.CBP-072-10.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-072-10 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-072-10.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-072-11 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/011_personnel_records_source_export.eml rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-072-11.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/023_payroll_time_source_export.html for retaliation timing.", "id": "investigation.CBP-072-11.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/035_leave_accommodation_source_export.eml to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-072-11.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_complaints/047_complaints_source_export.html.", "id": "investigation.CBP-072-11.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-072-11 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is the current observation does not meet the operative trigger.", "id": "decision.CBP-072-11.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-072-11 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-072-11.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-072-12 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/012_personnel_records_source_export.csv rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-072-12.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/024_payroll_time_source_export.pdf for personnel-file access deadline.", "id": "investigation.CBP-072-12.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/036_leave_accommodation_source_export.csv to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-072-12.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_complaints/048_complaints_source_export.pdf.", "id": "investigation.CBP-072-12.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-072-12 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-072-12.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-072-12 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-072-12.register"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Write the exact selected option, supported action population, evidence-hold population, facts, owners, deadlines, and citations.", "id": "state.exact_decision"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create one exact register row per portfolio key with no extra, missing, or modified row.", "id": "state.exact_register"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Leave only the three approved deliverables and perform no extra state-changing write.", "id": "state.write_scope_containment"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Read back decision.json, matter-register.json, and advice.md after their final writes.", "id": "state.postwrite_readback"}, {"category": "answer", "description": "Explain the selected recommendation, supported actions, holds, alternatives, and limitations with exact source anchors.", "id": "answer.decision_note"}], "decision_options": [{"approach": "Treat supported actions and genuinely ambiguous records as if they were equally unresolved.", "id": "bluebird-care:blanket-hold", "label": "Freeze the entire matter population"}, {"approach": "Apply the exact identity, current-state, authority, and revision test. Create employee-period correction rows and preserve unmatched visit records.", "id": "bluebird-care:scoped-evidence", "label": "Calculate and record supported pay corrections and control failures."}, {"approach": "Use a plausible summary or one source without completing the controlling joins.", "id": "bluebird-care:shortcut", "label": "Pay a flat estimate to every caregiver based on sampled exceptions."}], "evaluation_narrative": {"authority": "Applicable pay rules and the effective policy determine compensable time and premium treatment.", "observation": "Reconcile visit logs, travel routes, time records, premiums, policies, and complaints by caregiver and pay period.", "question": "What wage corrections does Bluebird owe for travel, meals, and complaint handling?", "register_action": "Create employee-period correction rows and preserve unmatched visit records."}, "gates": ["all_required_evidence_precedes_first_write", "decision_criteria_complete", "register_state_exact", "write_scope_contained", "all_outputs_verified_by_readback"], "metadata_checks": 10, "metric": "weighted_criteria_score", "minimum_tool_calls": 86, "required_deliverables": ["decision.json", "matter-register.json", "advice.md"], "required_document_reads": 61, "type": "deterministic", "weights": {"advice": 0.15, "decision": 0.35, "investigation": 0.25, "state": 0.25}}, "task_id": "cb100-072-bluebird-care", "task_name": "Bluebird caregiver wage review", "world_id": "counselbench-filesystem-mcp-v3"}
+{"context_files": ["task_files/cb100-073-copper-state/01_handbooks_policies/001_handbooks_policies_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-073-copper-state/01_handbooks_policies/002_handbooks_policies_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-073-copper-state/01_handbooks_policies/003_handbooks_policies_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-073-copper-state/01_handbooks_policies/004_handbooks_policies_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-073-copper-state/01_handbooks_policies/005_handbooks_policies_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-073-copper-state/01_handbooks_policies/006_handbooks_policies_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-073-copper-state/01_handbooks_policies/007_handbooks_policies_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-073-copper-state/01_handbooks_policies/008_handbooks_policies_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-073-copper-state/02_personnel_records/009_personnel_records_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-073-copper-state/02_personnel_records/010_personnel_records_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-073-copper-state/02_personnel_records/011_personnel_records_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-073-copper-state/02_personnel_records/012_personnel_records_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-073-copper-state/02_personnel_records/013_personnel_records_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-073-copper-state/02_personnel_records/014_personnel_records_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-073-copper-state/02_personnel_records/015_personnel_records_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-073-copper-state/02_personnel_records/016_personnel_records_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-073-copper-state/03_payroll_time/017_payroll_time_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-073-copper-state/03_payroll_time/018_payroll_time_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-073-copper-state/03_payroll_time/019_payroll_time_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-073-copper-state/03_payroll_time/020_payroll_time_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-073-copper-state/03_payroll_time/021_payroll_time_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-073-copper-state/03_payroll_time/022_payroll_time_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-073-copper-state/03_payroll_time/023_payroll_time_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-073-copper-state/03_payroll_time/024_payroll_time_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-073-copper-state/04_compensation_equity/025_compensation_equity_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-073-copper-state/04_compensation_equity/026_compensation_equity_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-073-copper-state/04_compensation_equity/027_compensation_equity_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-073-copper-state/04_compensation_equity/028_compensation_equity_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-073-copper-state/04_compensation_equity/029_compensation_equity_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-073-copper-state/04_compensation_equity/030_compensation_equity_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-073-copper-state/04_compensation_equity/031_compensation_equity_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-073-copper-state/04_compensation_equity/032_compensation_equity_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-073-copper-state/05_leave_accommodation/033_leave_accommodation_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-073-copper-state/05_leave_accommodation/034_leave_accommodation_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-073-copper-state/05_leave_accommodation/035_leave_accommodation_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-073-copper-state/05_leave_accommodation/036_leave_accommodation_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-073-copper-state/05_leave_accommodation/037_leave_accommodation_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-073-copper-state/05_leave_accommodation/038_leave_accommodation_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-073-copper-state/05_leave_accommodation/039_leave_accommodation_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-073-copper-state/05_leave_accommodation/040_leave_accommodation_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-073-copper-state/06_complaints/041_complaints_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-073-copper-state/06_complaints/042_complaints_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-073-copper-state/06_complaints/043_complaints_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-073-copper-state/06_complaints/044_complaints_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-073-copper-state/06_complaints/045_complaints_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-073-copper-state/06_complaints/046_complaints_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-073-copper-state/06_complaints/047_complaints_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-073-copper-state/06_complaints/048_complaints_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-073-copper-state/07_investigations/049_investigations_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-073-copper-state/07_investigations/050_investigations_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-073-copper-state/07_investigations/051_investigations_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-073-copper-state/07_investigations/052_investigations_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-073-copper-state/07_investigations/053_investigations_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-073-copper-state/07_investigations/054_investigations_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-073-copper-state/07_investigations/055_investigations_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-073-copper-state/07_investigations/056_investigations_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-073-copper-state/08_performance_discipline/057_performance_discipline_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-073-copper-state/08_performance_discipline/058_performance_discipline_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-073-copper-state/08_performance_discipline/059_performance_discipline_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-073-copper-state/08_performance_discipline/060_performance_discipline_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-073-copper-state/08_performance_discipline/061_performance_discipline_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-073-copper-state/08_performance_discipline/062_performance_discipline_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-073-copper-state/08_performance_discipline/063_performance_discipline_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-073-copper-state/08_performance_discipline/064_performance_discipline_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-073-copper-state/09_separation/065_separation_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-073-copper-state/09_separation/066_separation_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-073-copper-state/09_separation/067_separation_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-073-copper-state/09_separation/068_separation_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-073-copper-state/09_separation/069_separation_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-073-copper-state/09_separation/070_separation_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-073-copper-state/09_separation/071_separation_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-073-copper-state/09_separation/072_separation_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-073-copper-state/10_contractors/073_contractors_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-073-copper-state/10_contractors/074_contractors_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-073-copper-state/10_contractors/075_contractors_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-073-copper-state/10_contractors/076_contractors_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-073-copper-state/10_contractors/077_contractors_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-073-copper-state/10_contractors/078_contractors_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-073-copper-state/10_contractors/079_contractors_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-073-copper-state/10_contractors/080_contractors_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-073-copper-state/11_training/081_training_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-073-copper-state/11_training/082_training_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-073-copper-state/11_training/083_training_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-073-copper-state/11_training/084_training_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-073-copper-state/11_training/085_training_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-073-copper-state/11_training/086_training_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-073-copper-state/11_training/087_training_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-073-copper-state/11_training/088_training_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-073-copper-state/12_agency_matters/089_agency_matters_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-073-copper-state/12_agency_matters/090_agency_matters_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-073-copper-state/12_agency_matters/091_agency_matters_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-073-copper-state/12_agency_matters/092_agency_matters_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-073-copper-state/12_agency_matters/093_agency_matters_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-073-copper-state/12_agency_matters/094_agency_matters_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-073-copper-state/12_agency_matters/095_agency_matters_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-073-copper-state/12_agency_matters/096_agency_matters_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-073-copper-state/12_agency_matters/097_copper_state_impact_population.xlsx"], "gold_output": {"advice_markdown": "# Decision note — Copper State accommodation audit\n\n## Recommendation\n\nRemediate supported process failures and escalate only corroborated retaliation indicators. The reconciled record supports 8 scoped actions and leaves 4 items on evidence hold.\n\nSelected option: `copper-state:scoped-evidence`.\n\n## Why this is the supported option\n\nJoin requests, restrictions, follow-up, comparator discipline, and termination timing by employee and decision maker. Accommodation process duties and retaliation analysis require exact knowledge, timing, and comparator evidence.\n\n## Supported actions\n\n### CBP-073-02 — training completion gap (high)\n\nthe controlling threshold is 9% under CB-EL-3103-R260; the independently calculated result is 17% under CB-EL-3103-E638. Identity resolves to ENT-073-1001, revision REV-2025.2 is current, and Sofia Bennett is active with capacity 1.\n\nAction: Create separate process and retaliation rows with evidence-specific holds. Owner: Sofia Bennett; due 2026-09-10.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/002_handbooks_policies_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/014_personnel_records_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/026_compensation_equity_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/038_leave_accommodation_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/097_copper_state_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-073-03 — meal-period premium gap (critical)\n\napproval must come from Talia Brooks under CB-EL-3103-R675; the effective approval record names Henry Cho under CB-EL-3103-E451. Identity resolves to ENT-073-1002, revision REV-2025.3 is current, and Micah Sullivan is active with capacity 1.\n\nAction: Create separate process and retaliation rows with evidence-specific holds. Owner: Micah Sullivan; due 2026-09-09.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/003_handbooks_policies_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/015_personnel_records_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/027_compensation_equity_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/039_leave_accommodation_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/097_copper_state_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-073-04 — investigation independence concern (high)\n\nthe controlled population contains 141 records under CB-EL-3103-R739; the certification covers 117 records under CB-EL-3103-E614. Identity resolves to ENT-073-1003, revision REV-2025.4 is current, and Nora Chen is active with capacity 2.\n\nAction: Create separate process and retaliation rows with evidence-specific holds. Owner: Nora Chen; due 2026-09-08.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/004_handbooks_policies_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/016_personnel_records_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/028_compensation_equity_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/040_leave_accommodation_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/07_investigations/052_investigations_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/097_copper_state_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-073-05 — contractor control evidence (critical)\n\nthe permission is limited to Equal Employment Opportunity Commission under CB-EL-3103-R666; the matched activity occurred in Arizona under CB-EL-3103-E503. Identity resolves to ENT-073-1004, revision REV-2025.5 is current, and Caleb Hassan is active with capacity 2.\n\nAction: Create separate process and retaliation rows with evidence-specific holds. Owner: Caleb Hassan; due 2026-09-07.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/005_handbooks_policies_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/017_payroll_time_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/029_compensation_equity_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/06_complaints/041_complaints_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/089_agency_matters_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/097_copper_state_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-073-06 — overtime calculation error (medium)\n\nthe operative cap is $562,000.00 under CB-EL-3103-R363; the matched ledger population totals $577,363.00 under CB-EL-3103-E856. Identity resolves to ENT-073-1005, revision REV-2025.6 is current, and Amara Patel is active with capacity 1.\n\nAction: Create separate process and retaliation rows with evidence-specific holds. Owner: Amara Patel; due 2026-09-06.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/006_handbooks_policies_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/018_payroll_time_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/030_compensation_equity_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/06_complaints/042_complaints_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/090_agency_matters_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/097_copper_state_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-073-09 — classification inconsistency (critical)\n\ncompletion is required by 2026-01-23 under CB-EL-3103-R182; the current event record shows completion on 2026-02-18 under CB-EL-3103-E157. Identity resolves to ENT-073-1008, revision REV-2025.2 is current, and Adrian Mensah is active with capacity 3.\n\nAction: Create separate process and retaliation rows with evidence-specific holds. Owner: Adrian Mensah; due 2026-09-03.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/009_personnel_records_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/021_payroll_time_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/033_leave_accommodation_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/06_complaints/045_complaints_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/093_agency_matters_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/097_copper_state_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-073-10 — interactive-process lapse (medium)\n\nthe controlling threshold is 15% under CB-EL-3103-R584; the independently calculated result is 22% under CB-EL-3103-E393. Identity resolves to ENT-073-1009, revision REV-2025.3 is current, and Farah Ibrahim is active with capacity 2.\n\nAction: Create separate process and retaliation rows with evidence-specific holds. Owner: Farah Ibrahim; due 2026-09-11.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/010_personnel_records_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/022_payroll_time_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/034_leave_accommodation_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/06_complaints/046_complaints_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/08_performance_discipline/058_performance_discipline_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/097_copper_state_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-073-11 — separation pay discrepancy (high)\n\napproval must come from Talia Brooks under CB-EL-3103-R547; the effective approval record names Caleb Hassan under CB-EL-3103-E285. Identity resolves to ENT-073-1010, revision REV-2025.4 is current, and Dominic Alvarez is active with capacity 2.\n\nAction: Create separate process and retaliation rows with evidence-specific holds. Owner: Dominic Alvarez; due 2026-09-10.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/011_personnel_records_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/023_payroll_time_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/035_leave_accommodation_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/06_complaints/047_complaints_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/095_agency_matters_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/097_copper_state_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n## Evidence holds\n\n- **CBP-073-01 — discipline comparator inconsistency**: two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key. Next evidence: an approved immutable entity crosswalk. Sources: `/workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/001_handbooks_policies_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/013_personnel_records_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/025_compensation_equity_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/037_leave_accommodation_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/11_training/085_training_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/08_performance_discipline/061_performance_discipline_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/097_copper_state_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-073-07 — complaint escalation gap**: the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective. Next evidence: effective approval and an active owner with remaining capacity. Sources: `/workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/007_handbooks_policies_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/019_payroll_time_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/031_compensation_equity_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/06_complaints/043_complaints_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/097_copper_state_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-073-08 — restrictive-covenant conflict**: the operational record relies on a superseded control revision. Next evidence: an operational record using the current effective revision. Sources: `/workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/008_handbooks_policies_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/020_payroll_time_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/032_compensation_equity_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/06_complaints/044_complaints_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/097_copper_state_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-073-12 — agency response commitment**: the operational record relies on a superseded control revision. Next evidence: an operational record using the current effective revision. Sources: `/workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/012_personnel_records_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/024_payroll_time_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/036_leave_accommodation_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/06_complaints/048_complaints_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/097_copper_state_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n## Alternatives considered\n\n- `copper-state:shortcut` — Treat close timing alone as proof of retaliation.: Use a plausible summary or one source without completing the controlling joins.\n- `copper-state:blanket-hold` — Freeze the entire matter population: Treat supported actions and genuinely ambiguous records as if they were equally unresolved.\n\n## Assumptions and limits\n\nThis decision is limited to cb100-073-copper-state, the supplied synthetic records, and the matter state as of 2026-09-12. Similar names, stale revisions, and pending authority are not treated as proof.\n", "decision": {"actions": [{"determination": "the controlling threshold is 9% under CB-EL-3103-R260; the independently calculated result is 17% under CB-EL-3103-E638. Identity resolves to ENT-073-1001, revision REV-2025.2 is current, and Sofia Bennett is active with capacity 1.", "due_date": "2026-09-10", "id": "ACT-CBP-073-02", "identity_id": "ENT-073-1001", "issue": "training completion gap", "owner": "Sofia Bennett", "portfolio_key": "CBP-073-02", "recommended_action": "Create separate process and retaliation rows with evidence-specific holds. Owner: Sofia Bennett; due 2026-09-10.", "severity": "high", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/002_handbooks_policies_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/014_personnel_records_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/026_compensation_equity_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/038_leave_accommodation_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/097_copper_state_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "approval must come from Talia Brooks under CB-EL-3103-R675; the effective approval record names Henry Cho under CB-EL-3103-E451. Identity resolves to ENT-073-1002, revision REV-2025.3 is current, and Micah Sullivan is active with capacity 1.", "due_date": "2026-09-09", "id": "ACT-CBP-073-03", "identity_id": "ENT-073-1002", "issue": "meal-period premium gap", "owner": "Micah Sullivan", "portfolio_key": "CBP-073-03", "recommended_action": "Create separate process and retaliation rows with evidence-specific holds. Owner: Micah Sullivan; due 2026-09-09.", "severity": "critical", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/003_handbooks_policies_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/015_personnel_records_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/027_compensation_equity_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/039_leave_accommodation_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/097_copper_state_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "the controlled population contains 141 records under CB-EL-3103-R739; the certification covers 117 records under CB-EL-3103-E614. Identity resolves to ENT-073-1003, revision REV-2025.4 is current, and Nora Chen is active with capacity 2.", "due_date": "2026-09-08", "id": "ACT-CBP-073-04", "identity_id": "ENT-073-1003", "issue": "investigation independence concern", "owner": "Nora Chen", "portfolio_key": "CBP-073-04", "recommended_action": "Create separate process and retaliation rows with evidence-specific holds. Owner: Nora Chen; due 2026-09-08.", "severity": "high", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/004_handbooks_policies_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/016_personnel_records_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/028_compensation_equity_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/040_leave_accommodation_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/07_investigations/052_investigations_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/097_copper_state_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "the permission is limited to Equal Employment Opportunity Commission under CB-EL-3103-R666; the matched activity occurred in Arizona under CB-EL-3103-E503. Identity resolves to ENT-073-1004, revision REV-2025.5 is current, and Caleb Hassan is active with capacity 2.", "due_date": "2026-09-07", "id": "ACT-CBP-073-05", "identity_id": "ENT-073-1004", "issue": "contractor control evidence", "owner": "Caleb Hassan", "portfolio_key": "CBP-073-05", "recommended_action": "Create separate process and retaliation rows with evidence-specific holds. Owner: Caleb Hassan; due 2026-09-07.", "severity": "critical", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/005_handbooks_policies_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/017_payroll_time_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/029_compensation_equity_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/06_complaints/041_complaints_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/089_agency_matters_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/097_copper_state_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "the operative cap is $562,000.00 under CB-EL-3103-R363; the matched ledger population totals $577,363.00 under CB-EL-3103-E856. Identity resolves to ENT-073-1005, revision REV-2025.6 is current, and Amara Patel is active with capacity 1.", "due_date": "2026-09-06", "id": "ACT-CBP-073-06", "identity_id": "ENT-073-1005", "issue": "overtime calculation error", "owner": "Amara Patel", "portfolio_key": "CBP-073-06", "recommended_action": "Create separate process and retaliation rows with evidence-specific holds. Owner: Amara Patel; due 2026-09-06.", "severity": "medium", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/006_handbooks_policies_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/018_payroll_time_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/030_compensation_equity_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/06_complaints/042_complaints_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/090_agency_matters_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/097_copper_state_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "completion is required by 2026-01-23 under CB-EL-3103-R182; the current event record shows completion on 2026-02-18 under CB-EL-3103-E157. Identity resolves to ENT-073-1008, revision REV-2025.2 is current, and Adrian Mensah is active with capacity 3.", "due_date": "2026-09-03", "id": "ACT-CBP-073-09", "identity_id": "ENT-073-1008", "issue": "classification inconsistency", "owner": "Adrian Mensah", "portfolio_key": "CBP-073-09", "recommended_action": "Create separate process and retaliation rows with evidence-specific holds. Owner: Adrian Mensah; due 2026-09-03.", "severity": "critical", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/009_personnel_records_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/021_payroll_time_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/033_leave_accommodation_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/06_complaints/045_complaints_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/093_agency_matters_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/097_copper_state_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "the controlling threshold is 15% under CB-EL-3103-R584; the independently calculated result is 22% under CB-EL-3103-E393. Identity resolves to ENT-073-1009, revision REV-2025.3 is current, and Farah Ibrahim is active with capacity 2.", "due_date": "2026-09-11", "id": "ACT-CBP-073-10", "identity_id": "ENT-073-1009", "issue": "interactive-process lapse", "owner": "Farah Ibrahim", "portfolio_key": "CBP-073-10", "recommended_action": "Create separate process and retaliation rows with evidence-specific holds. Owner: Farah Ibrahim; due 2026-09-11.", "severity": "medium", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/010_personnel_records_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/022_payroll_time_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/034_leave_accommodation_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/06_complaints/046_complaints_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/08_performance_discipline/058_performance_discipline_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/097_copper_state_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "approval must come from Talia Brooks under CB-EL-3103-R547; the effective approval record names Caleb Hassan under CB-EL-3103-E285. Identity resolves to ENT-073-1010, revision REV-2025.4 is current, and Dominic Alvarez is active with capacity 2.", "due_date": "2026-09-10", "id": "ACT-CBP-073-11", "identity_id": "ENT-073-1010", "issue": "separation pay discrepancy", "owner": "Dominic Alvarez", "portfolio_key": "CBP-073-11", "recommended_action": "Create separate process and retaliation rows with evidence-specific holds. Owner: Dominic Alvarez; due 2026-09-10.", "severity": "high", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/011_personnel_records_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/023_payroll_time_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/035_leave_accommodation_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/06_complaints/047_complaints_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/095_agency_matters_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/097_copper_state_impact_population.xlsx"]}], "as_of": "2026-09-12", "decision": {"alternatives_considered": ["copper-state:shortcut", "copper-state:blanket-hold"], "question": "Did Copper State mishandle the accommodation or retaliate, and what action is supported?", "rationale": "The four-part causal test supports 8 scoped actions and leaves 4 records on evidence hold. Accommodation process duties and retaliation analysis require exact knowledge, timing, and comparator evidence.", "recommendation": "Remediate supported process failures and escalate only corroborated retaliation indicators.", "selected_option_id": "copper-state:scoped-evidence"}, "holds": [{"id": "HOLD-CBP-073-01", "issue": "discipline comparator inconsistency", "portfolio_key": "CBP-073-01", "reason": "two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key", "required_next_evidence": "an approved immutable entity crosswalk", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/001_handbooks_policies_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/013_personnel_records_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/025_compensation_equity_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/037_leave_accommodation_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/11_training/085_training_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/08_performance_discipline/061_performance_discipline_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/097_copper_state_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-073-07", "issue": "complaint escalation gap", "portfolio_key": "CBP-073-07", "reason": "the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective", "required_next_evidence": "effective approval and an active owner with remaining capacity", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/007_handbooks_policies_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/019_payroll_time_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/031_compensation_equity_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/06_complaints/043_complaints_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/097_copper_state_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-073-08", "issue": "restrictive-covenant conflict", "portfolio_key": "CBP-073-08", "reason": "the operational record relies on a superseded control revision", "required_next_evidence": "an operational record using the current effective revision", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/008_handbooks_policies_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/020_payroll_time_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/032_compensation_equity_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/06_complaints/044_complaints_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/097_copper_state_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-073-12", "issue": "agency response commitment", "portfolio_key": "CBP-073-12", "reason": "the operational record relies on a superseded control revision", "required_next_evidence": "an operational record using the current effective revision", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/012_personnel_records_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/024_payroll_time_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/036_leave_accommodation_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/06_complaints/048_complaints_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/097_copper_state_impact_population.xlsx"]}], "matter_number": "CB-EL-3103", "prepared_for": "Copper State Manufacturing", "schema_version": "counselbench.decision.v3", "task_id": "cb100-073-copper-state"}, "matter_register": {"matter_number": "CB-EL-3103", "rows": [{"decision_option_id": "copper-state:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key", "issue": "discipline comparator inconsistency", "matter_number": "CB-EL-3103", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-073-01", "row_id": "REG-CBP-073-01", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/001_handbooks_policies_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/013_personnel_records_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/025_compensation_equity_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/037_leave_accommodation_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/11_training/085_training_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/08_performance_discipline/061_performance_discipline_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/097_copper_state_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "copper-state:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-10", "issue": "training completion gap", "matter_number": "CB-EL-3103", "owner": "Sofia Bennett", "portfolio_key": "CBP-073-02", "row_id": "REG-CBP-073-02", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/002_handbooks_policies_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/014_personnel_records_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/026_compensation_equity_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/038_leave_accommodation_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/097_copper_state_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "copper-state:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-09", "issue": "meal-period premium gap", "matter_number": "CB-EL-3103", "owner": "Micah Sullivan", "portfolio_key": "CBP-073-03", "row_id": "REG-CBP-073-03", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/003_handbooks_policies_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/015_personnel_records_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/027_compensation_equity_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/039_leave_accommodation_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/097_copper_state_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "copper-state:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-08", "issue": "investigation independence concern", "matter_number": "CB-EL-3103", "owner": "Nora Chen", "portfolio_key": "CBP-073-04", "row_id": "REG-CBP-073-04", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/004_handbooks_policies_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/016_personnel_records_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/028_compensation_equity_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/040_leave_accommodation_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/07_investigations/052_investigations_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/097_copper_state_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "copper-state:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-07", "issue": "contractor control evidence", "matter_number": "CB-EL-3103", "owner": "Caleb Hassan", "portfolio_key": "CBP-073-05", "row_id": "REG-CBP-073-05", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/005_handbooks_policies_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/017_payroll_time_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/029_compensation_equity_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/06_complaints/041_complaints_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/089_agency_matters_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/097_copper_state_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "copper-state:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-06", "issue": "overtime calculation error", "matter_number": "CB-EL-3103", "owner": "Amara Patel", "portfolio_key": "CBP-073-06", "row_id": "REG-CBP-073-06", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/006_handbooks_policies_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/018_payroll_time_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/030_compensation_equity_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/06_complaints/042_complaints_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/090_agency_matters_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/097_copper_state_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "copper-state:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective", "issue": "complaint escalation gap", "matter_number": "CB-EL-3103", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-073-07", "row_id": "REG-CBP-073-07", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/007_handbooks_policies_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/019_payroll_time_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/031_compensation_equity_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/06_complaints/043_complaints_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/097_copper_state_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "copper-state:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "the operational record relies on a superseded control revision", "issue": "restrictive-covenant conflict", "matter_number": "CB-EL-3103", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-073-08", "row_id": "REG-CBP-073-08", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/008_handbooks_policies_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/020_payroll_time_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/032_compensation_equity_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/06_complaints/044_complaints_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/097_copper_state_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "copper-state:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-03", "issue": "classification inconsistency", "matter_number": "CB-EL-3103", "owner": "Adrian Mensah", "portfolio_key": "CBP-073-09", "row_id": "REG-CBP-073-09", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/009_personnel_records_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/021_payroll_time_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/033_leave_accommodation_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/06_complaints/045_complaints_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/093_agency_matters_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/097_copper_state_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "copper-state:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-11", "issue": "interactive-process lapse", "matter_number": "CB-EL-3103", "owner": "Farah Ibrahim", "portfolio_key": "CBP-073-10", "row_id": "REG-CBP-073-10", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/010_personnel_records_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/022_payroll_time_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/034_leave_accommodation_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/06_complaints/046_complaints_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/08_performance_discipline/058_performance_discipline_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/097_copper_state_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "copper-state:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-10", "issue": "separation pay discrepancy", "matter_number": "CB-EL-3103", "owner": "Dominic Alvarez", "portfolio_key": "CBP-073-11", "row_id": "REG-CBP-073-11", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/011_personnel_records_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/023_payroll_time_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/035_leave_accommodation_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/06_complaints/047_complaints_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/095_agency_matters_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/097_copper_state_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "copper-state:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "the operational record relies on a superseded control revision", "issue": "agency response commitment", "matter_number": "CB-EL-3103", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-073-12", "row_id": "REG-CBP-073-12", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/012_personnel_records_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/024_payroll_time_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/036_leave_accommodation_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/06_complaints/048_complaints_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/097_copper_state_impact_population.xlsx"]}], "schema_version": "counselbench.matter-register.v3", "task_id": "cb100-073-copper-state"}}, "metadata": {"benchmark": "CounselBench-100", "code_license": "Apache-2.0", "data_license": "CC-BY-4.0", "deadline": "2026-09-12", "document_count": 97, "evidence_holds": 4, "jurisdiction": "Arizona", "matter_number": "CB-EL-3103", "mcp_commit": "9a96ea6e5913736f92b88345bf51caeaaa8e719f", "mcp_package": "@modelcontextprotocol/server-filesystem@2026.7.10", "practice_area": "employment", "reference_tool_calls": 76, "required_evidence_reads": 57, "supported_actions": 8, "synthetic": true, "venue": "Equal Employment Opportunity Commission", "version": "3.1.0"}, "prompt": "A late record changed the picture this morning. Did Copper State mishandle the accommodation or retaliate, and what action is supported? Leave and accommodation records show delayed follow-up, differing restrictions, comparator discipline, and close termination timing. The team needs the call by 2026-09-12. Make the matter record usable by operations after your review, but do not turn ambiguity into an accusation or obligation.", "rubric": {"criteria": [{"category": "investigation", "description": "Inventory the production and use targeted searches to locate records across native formats.", "id": "investigation.discover_production"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Complete every task-specific identity, authority, operations, and approval read before the first state transition.", "id": "investigation.read_before_write"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Inspect designated source metadata before relying on those records.", "id": "investigation.custody_before_write"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "Select the supported option 'copper-state:scoped-evidence' after applying the four-part test.", "id": "decision.selected_option"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "Identify both rejected approaches and explain why a one-source shortcut and a blanket hold are wrong.", "id": "decision.alternatives"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-073-01 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/001_handbooks_policies_source_export.md rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-073-01.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/013_personnel_records_source_export.json for discipline comparator inconsistency.", "id": "investigation.CBP-073-01.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/025_compensation_equity_source_export.md to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-073-01.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/037_leave_accommodation_source_export.json.", "id": "investigation.CBP-073-01.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-073-01 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key.", "id": "decision.CBP-073-01.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-073-01 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-073-01.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-073-02 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/002_handbooks_policies_source_export.txt rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-073-02.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/014_personnel_records_source_export.xml for training completion gap.", "id": "investigation.CBP-073-02.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/026_compensation_equity_source_export.txt to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-073-02.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/038_leave_accommodation_source_export.xml.", "id": "investigation.CBP-073-02.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-073-02 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-073-02.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-073-02 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-073-02.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-073-03 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/003_handbooks_policies_source_export.eml rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-073-03.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/015_personnel_records_source_export.html for meal-period premium gap.", "id": "investigation.CBP-073-03.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/027_compensation_equity_source_export.eml to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-073-03.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/039_leave_accommodation_source_export.html.", "id": "investigation.CBP-073-03.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-073-03 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-073-03.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-073-03 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-073-03.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-073-04 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/004_handbooks_policies_source_export.csv rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-073-04.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/016_personnel_records_source_export.pdf for investigation independence concern.", "id": "investigation.CBP-073-04.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/028_compensation_equity_source_export.csv to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-073-04.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/040_leave_accommodation_source_export.pdf.", "id": "investigation.CBP-073-04.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-073-04 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-073-04.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-073-04 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-073-04.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-073-05 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/005_handbooks_policies_source_export.json rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-073-05.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/017_payroll_time_source_export.md for contractor control evidence.", "id": "investigation.CBP-073-05.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/029_compensation_equity_source_export.json to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-073-05.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_complaints/041_complaints_source_export.md.", "id": "investigation.CBP-073-05.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-073-05 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-073-05.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-073-05 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-073-05.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-073-06 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/006_handbooks_policies_source_export.xml rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-073-06.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/018_payroll_time_source_export.txt for overtime calculation error.", "id": "investigation.CBP-073-06.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/030_compensation_equity_source_export.xml to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-073-06.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_complaints/042_complaints_source_export.txt.", "id": "investigation.CBP-073-06.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-073-06 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-073-06.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-073-06 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-073-06.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-073-07 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/007_handbooks_policies_source_export.html rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-073-07.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/019_payroll_time_source_export.eml for complaint escalation gap.", "id": "investigation.CBP-073-07.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/031_compensation_equity_source_export.html to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-073-07.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_complaints/043_complaints_source_export.eml.", "id": "investigation.CBP-073-07.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-073-07 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective.", "id": "decision.CBP-073-07.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-073-07 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-073-07.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-073-08 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/008_handbooks_policies_source_export.pdf rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-073-08.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/020_payroll_time_source_export.csv for restrictive-covenant conflict.", "id": "investigation.CBP-073-08.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/032_compensation_equity_source_export.pdf to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-073-08.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_complaints/044_complaints_source_export.csv.", "id": "investigation.CBP-073-08.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-073-08 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is the operational record relies on a superseded control revision.", "id": "decision.CBP-073-08.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-073-08 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-073-08.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-073-09 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/009_personnel_records_source_export.md rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-073-09.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/021_payroll_time_source_export.json for classification inconsistency.", "id": "investigation.CBP-073-09.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/033_leave_accommodation_source_export.md to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-073-09.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_complaints/045_complaints_source_export.json.", "id": "investigation.CBP-073-09.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-073-09 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-073-09.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-073-09 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-073-09.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-073-10 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/010_personnel_records_source_export.txt rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-073-10.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/022_payroll_time_source_export.xml for interactive-process lapse.", "id": "investigation.CBP-073-10.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/034_leave_accommodation_source_export.txt to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-073-10.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_complaints/046_complaints_source_export.xml.", "id": "investigation.CBP-073-10.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-073-10 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-073-10.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-073-10 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-073-10.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-073-11 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/011_personnel_records_source_export.eml rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-073-11.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/023_payroll_time_source_export.html for separation pay discrepancy.", "id": "investigation.CBP-073-11.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/035_leave_accommodation_source_export.eml to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-073-11.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_complaints/047_complaints_source_export.html.", "id": "investigation.CBP-073-11.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-073-11 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-073-11.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-073-11 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-073-11.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-073-12 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/012_personnel_records_source_export.csv rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-073-12.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/024_payroll_time_source_export.pdf for agency response commitment.", "id": "investigation.CBP-073-12.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/036_leave_accommodation_source_export.csv to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-073-12.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_complaints/048_complaints_source_export.pdf.", "id": "investigation.CBP-073-12.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-073-12 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is the operational record relies on a superseded control revision.", "id": "decision.CBP-073-12.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-073-12 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-073-12.register"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Write the exact selected option, supported action population, evidence-hold population, facts, owners, deadlines, and citations.", "id": "state.exact_decision"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create one exact register row per portfolio key with no extra, missing, or modified row.", "id": "state.exact_register"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Leave only the three approved deliverables and perform no extra state-changing write.", "id": "state.write_scope_containment"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Read back decision.json, matter-register.json, and advice.md after their final writes.", "id": "state.postwrite_readback"}, {"category": "answer", "description": "Explain the selected recommendation, supported actions, holds, alternatives, and limitations with exact source anchors.", "id": "answer.decision_note"}], "decision_options": [{"approach": "Apply the exact identity, current-state, authority, and revision test. Create separate process and retaliation rows with evidence-specific holds.", "id": "copper-state:scoped-evidence", "label": "Remediate supported process failures and escalate only corroborated retaliation indicators."}, {"approach": "Use a plausible summary or one source without completing the controlling joins.", "id": "copper-state:shortcut", "label": "Treat close timing alone as proof of retaliation."}, {"approach": "Treat supported actions and genuinely ambiguous records as if they were equally unresolved.", "id": "copper-state:blanket-hold", "label": "Freeze the entire matter population"}], "evaluation_narrative": {"authority": "Accommodation process duties and retaliation analysis require exact knowledge, timing, and comparator evidence.", "observation": "Join requests, restrictions, follow-up, comparator discipline, and termination timing by employee and decision maker.", "question": "Did Copper State mishandle the accommodation or retaliate, and what action is supported?", "register_action": "Create separate process and retaliation rows with evidence-specific holds."}, "gates": ["all_required_evidence_precedes_first_write", "decision_criteria_complete", "register_state_exact", "write_scope_contained", "all_outputs_verified_by_readback"], "metadata_checks": 6, "metric": "weighted_criteria_score", "minimum_tool_calls": 76, "required_deliverables": ["decision.json", "matter-register.json", "advice.md"], "required_document_reads": 57, "type": "deterministic", "weights": {"advice": 0.15, "decision": 0.35, "investigation": 0.25, "state": 0.25}}, "task_id": "cb100-073-copper-state", "task_name": "Copper State accommodation audit", "world_id": "counselbench-filesystem-mcp-v3"}
+{"context_files": ["task_files/cb100-074-daymark-bank/01_handbooks_policies/001_handbooks_policies_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-074-daymark-bank/01_handbooks_policies/002_handbooks_policies_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-074-daymark-bank/01_handbooks_policies/003_handbooks_policies_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-074-daymark-bank/01_handbooks_policies/004_handbooks_policies_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-074-daymark-bank/01_handbooks_policies/005_handbooks_policies_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-074-daymark-bank/01_handbooks_policies/006_handbooks_policies_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-074-daymark-bank/01_handbooks_policies/007_handbooks_policies_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-074-daymark-bank/01_handbooks_policies/008_handbooks_policies_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-074-daymark-bank/02_personnel_records/009_personnel_records_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-074-daymark-bank/02_personnel_records/010_personnel_records_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-074-daymark-bank/02_personnel_records/011_personnel_records_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-074-daymark-bank/02_personnel_records/012_personnel_records_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-074-daymark-bank/02_personnel_records/013_personnel_records_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-074-daymark-bank/02_personnel_records/014_personnel_records_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-074-daymark-bank/02_personnel_records/015_personnel_records_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-074-daymark-bank/02_personnel_records/016_personnel_records_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-074-daymark-bank/03_payroll_time/017_payroll_time_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-074-daymark-bank/03_payroll_time/018_payroll_time_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-074-daymark-bank/03_payroll_time/019_payroll_time_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-074-daymark-bank/03_payroll_time/020_payroll_time_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-074-daymark-bank/03_payroll_time/021_payroll_time_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-074-daymark-bank/03_payroll_time/022_payroll_time_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-074-daymark-bank/03_payroll_time/023_payroll_time_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-074-daymark-bank/03_payroll_time/024_payroll_time_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-074-daymark-bank/04_compensation_equity/025_compensation_equity_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-074-daymark-bank/04_compensation_equity/026_compensation_equity_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-074-daymark-bank/04_compensation_equity/027_compensation_equity_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-074-daymark-bank/04_compensation_equity/028_compensation_equity_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-074-daymark-bank/04_compensation_equity/029_compensation_equity_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-074-daymark-bank/04_compensation_equity/030_compensation_equity_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-074-daymark-bank/04_compensation_equity/031_compensation_equity_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-074-daymark-bank/04_compensation_equity/032_compensation_equity_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-074-daymark-bank/05_leave_accommodation/033_leave_accommodation_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-074-daymark-bank/05_leave_accommodation/034_leave_accommodation_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-074-daymark-bank/05_leave_accommodation/035_leave_accommodation_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-074-daymark-bank/05_leave_accommodation/036_leave_accommodation_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-074-daymark-bank/05_leave_accommodation/037_leave_accommodation_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-074-daymark-bank/05_leave_accommodation/038_leave_accommodation_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-074-daymark-bank/05_leave_accommodation/039_leave_accommodation_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-074-daymark-bank/05_leave_accommodation/040_leave_accommodation_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-074-daymark-bank/06_complaints/041_complaints_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-074-daymark-bank/06_complaints/042_complaints_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-074-daymark-bank/06_complaints/043_complaints_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-074-daymark-bank/06_complaints/044_complaints_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-074-daymark-bank/06_complaints/045_complaints_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-074-daymark-bank/06_complaints/046_complaints_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-074-daymark-bank/06_complaints/047_complaints_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-074-daymark-bank/06_complaints/048_complaints_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-074-daymark-bank/07_investigations/049_investigations_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-074-daymark-bank/07_investigations/050_investigations_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-074-daymark-bank/07_investigations/051_investigations_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-074-daymark-bank/07_investigations/052_investigations_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-074-daymark-bank/07_investigations/053_investigations_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-074-daymark-bank/07_investigations/054_investigations_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-074-daymark-bank/07_investigations/055_investigations_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-074-daymark-bank/07_investigations/056_investigations_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-074-daymark-bank/08_performance_discipline/057_performance_discipline_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-074-daymark-bank/08_performance_discipline/058_performance_discipline_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-074-daymark-bank/08_performance_discipline/059_performance_discipline_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-074-daymark-bank/08_performance_discipline/060_performance_discipline_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-074-daymark-bank/08_performance_discipline/061_performance_discipline_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-074-daymark-bank/08_performance_discipline/062_performance_discipline_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-074-daymark-bank/08_performance_discipline/063_performance_discipline_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-074-daymark-bank/08_performance_discipline/064_performance_discipline_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-074-daymark-bank/09_separation/065_separation_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-074-daymark-bank/09_separation/066_separation_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-074-daymark-bank/09_separation/067_separation_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-074-daymark-bank/09_separation/068_separation_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-074-daymark-bank/09_separation/069_separation_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-074-daymark-bank/09_separation/070_separation_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-074-daymark-bank/09_separation/071_separation_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-074-daymark-bank/09_separation/072_separation_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-074-daymark-bank/10_contractors/073_contractors_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-074-daymark-bank/10_contractors/074_contractors_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-074-daymark-bank/10_contractors/075_contractors_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-074-daymark-bank/10_contractors/076_contractors_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-074-daymark-bank/10_contractors/077_contractors_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-074-daymark-bank/10_contractors/078_contractors_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-074-daymark-bank/10_contractors/079_contractors_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-074-daymark-bank/10_contractors/080_contractors_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-074-daymark-bank/11_training/081_training_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-074-daymark-bank/11_training/082_training_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-074-daymark-bank/11_training/083_training_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-074-daymark-bank/11_training/084_training_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-074-daymark-bank/11_training/085_training_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-074-daymark-bank/11_training/086_training_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-074-daymark-bank/11_training/087_training_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-074-daymark-bank/11_training/088_training_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-074-daymark-bank/12_agency_matters/089_agency_matters_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-074-daymark-bank/12_agency_matters/090_agency_matters_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-074-daymark-bank/12_agency_matters/091_agency_matters_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-074-daymark-bank/12_agency_matters/092_agency_matters_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-074-daymark-bank/12_agency_matters/093_agency_matters_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-074-daymark-bank/12_agency_matters/094_agency_matters_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-074-daymark-bank/12_agency_matters/095_agency_matters_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-074-daymark-bank/12_agency_matters/096_agency_matters_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-074-daymark-bank/12_agency_matters/097_daymark_bank_impact_population.xlsx"], "gold_output": {"advice_markdown": "# Decision note — Daymark pay-equity privileged audit\n\n## Recommendation\n\nCorrect supported disparities and hold cases with unresolved explanatory factors. The reconciled record supports 8 scoped actions and leaves 4 items on evidence hold.\n\nSelected option: `daymark-bank:scoped-evidence`.\n\n## Why this is the supported option\n\nMatch job level, region, pay, bonuses, ratings, and decision communications by employee and cycle. The approved comparison population and legitimate-factor rules govern outlier treatment.\n\n## Supported actions\n\n### CBP-074-03 — pay-equity outlier (medium)\n\nan open exception blocks completion under CB-EL-3104-R630; the current status is open and unresolved under CB-EL-3104-E395. Identity resolves to ENT-074-1002, revision REV-2026.3 is current, and Lena Varga is active with capacity 5.\n\nAction: Create employee-cycle rows with exact comparator and factor evidence. Owner: Lena Varga; due 2026-09-13.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/003_handbooks_policies_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/015_personnel_records_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/027_compensation_equity_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/039_leave_accommodation_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/097_daymark_bank_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-074-04 — discipline comparator inconsistency (medium)\n\ncompletion is required by 2025-12-16 under CB-EL-3104-R984; the current event record shows completion on 2026-01-13 under CB-EL-3104-E522. Identity resolves to ENT-074-1003, revision REV-2026.4 is current, and Elliot Mercer is active with capacity 1.\n\nAction: Create employee-cycle rows with exact comparator and factor evidence. Owner: Elliot Mercer; due 2026-09-12.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/004_handbooks_policies_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/016_personnel_records_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/028_compensation_equity_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/040_leave_accommodation_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/10_contractors/076_contractors_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/08_performance_discipline/064_performance_discipline_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/097_daymark_bank_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-074-05 — training completion gap (low)\n\nthe controlling threshold is 5% under CB-EL-3104-R992; the independently calculated result is 9% under CB-EL-3104-E523. Identity resolves to ENT-074-1004, revision REV-2026.5 is current, and Sofia Bennett is active with capacity 5.\n\nAction: Create employee-cycle rows with exact comparator and factor evidence. Owner: Sofia Bennett; due 2026-09-11.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/005_handbooks_policies_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/017_payroll_time_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/029_compensation_equity_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/06_complaints/041_complaints_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/09_separation/065_separation_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/097_daymark_bank_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-074-06 — meal-period premium gap (medium)\n\napproval must come from Amara Patel under CB-EL-3104-R829; the effective approval record names Caleb Hassan under CB-EL-3104-E937. Identity resolves to ENT-074-1005, revision REV-2026.6 is current, and Micah Sullivan is active with capacity 3.\n\nAction: Create employee-cycle rows with exact comparator and factor evidence. Owner: Micah Sullivan; due 2026-09-10.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/006_handbooks_policies_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/018_payroll_time_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/030_compensation_equity_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/06_complaints/042_complaints_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/10_contractors/078_contractors_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/097_daymark_bank_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-074-08 — contractor control evidence (high)\n\nthe permission is limited to United States Department of Labor under CB-EL-3104-R748; the matched activity occurred in North Carolina under CB-EL-3104-E826. Identity resolves to ENT-074-1007, revision REV-2026.1 is current, and Caleb Hassan is active with capacity 3.\n\nAction: Create employee-cycle rows with exact comparator and factor evidence. Owner: Caleb Hassan; due 2026-09-08.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/008_handbooks_policies_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/020_payroll_time_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/032_compensation_equity_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/06_complaints/044_complaints_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/09_separation/068_separation_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/092_agency_matters_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/097_daymark_bank_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-074-09 — overtime calculation error (high)\n\nthe operative cap is $7,762,000.00 under CB-EL-3104-R126; the matched ledger population totals $7,784,326.00 under CB-EL-3104-E313. Identity resolves to ENT-074-1008, revision REV-2026.2 is current, and Amara Patel is active with capacity 5.\n\nAction: Create employee-cycle rows with exact comparator and factor evidence. Owner: Amara Patel; due 2026-09-07.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/009_personnel_records_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/021_payroll_time_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/033_leave_accommodation_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/06_complaints/045_complaints_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/11_training/081_training_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/08_performance_discipline/057_performance_discipline_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/097_daymark_bank_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-074-11 — restrictive-covenant conflict (critical)\n\nan open exception blocks completion under CB-EL-3104-R578; the current status is open and unresolved under CB-EL-3104-E234. Identity resolves to ENT-074-1010, revision REV-2026.4 is current, and Talia Brooks is active with capacity 3.\n\nAction: Create employee-cycle rows with exact comparator and factor evidence. Owner: Talia Brooks; due 2026-09-14.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/011_personnel_records_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/023_payroll_time_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/035_leave_accommodation_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/06_complaints/047_complaints_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/08_performance_discipline/059_performance_discipline_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/09_separation/071_separation_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/097_daymark_bank_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-074-12 — classification inconsistency (high)\n\ncompletion is required by 2026-02-16 under CB-EL-3104-R206; the current event record shows completion on 2026-03-15 under CB-EL-3104-E476. Identity resolves to ENT-074-1011, revision REV-2026.5 is current, and Adrian Mensah is active with capacity 1.\n\nAction: Create employee-cycle rows with exact comparator and factor evidence. Owner: Adrian Mensah; due 2026-09-13.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/012_personnel_records_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/024_payroll_time_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/036_leave_accommodation_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/06_complaints/048_complaints_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/096_agency_matters_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/09_separation/072_separation_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/097_daymark_bank_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n## Evidence holds\n\n- **CBP-074-01 — retaliation timing**: the current observation does not meet the operative trigger. Next evidence: a current observation that satisfies the operative trigger. Sources: `/workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/001_handbooks_policies_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/013_personnel_records_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/025_compensation_equity_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/037_leave_accommodation_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/07_investigations/049_investigations_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/097_daymark_bank_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-074-02 — personnel-file access deadline**: the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective. Next evidence: effective approval and an active owner with remaining capacity. Sources: `/workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/002_handbooks_policies_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/014_personnel_records_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/026_compensation_equity_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/038_leave_accommodation_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/11_training/086_training_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/097_daymark_bank_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-074-07 — investigation independence concern**: the operational record relies on a superseded control revision. Next evidence: an operational record using the current effective revision. Sources: `/workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/007_handbooks_policies_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/019_payroll_time_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/031_compensation_equity_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/06_complaints/043_complaints_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/097_daymark_bank_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-074-10 — complaint escalation gap**: the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective. Next evidence: effective approval and an active owner with remaining capacity. Sources: `/workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/010_personnel_records_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/022_payroll_time_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/034_leave_accommodation_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/06_complaints/046_complaints_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/11_training/082_training_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/09_separation/070_separation_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/097_daymark_bank_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n## Alternatives considered\n\n- `daymark-bank:shortcut` — Rank raw pay and correct everyone below the group average.: Use a plausible summary or one source without completing the controlling joins.\n- `daymark-bank:blanket-hold` — Freeze the entire matter population: Treat supported actions and genuinely ambiguous records as if they were equally unresolved.\n\n## Assumptions and limits\n\nThis decision is limited to cb100-074-daymark-bank, the supplied synthetic records, and the matter state as of 2026-09-16. Similar names, stale revisions, and pending authority are not treated as proof.\n", "decision": {"actions": [{"determination": "an open exception blocks completion under CB-EL-3104-R630; the current status is open and unresolved under CB-EL-3104-E395. Identity resolves to ENT-074-1002, revision REV-2026.3 is current, and Lena Varga is active with capacity 5.", "due_date": "2026-09-13", "id": "ACT-CBP-074-03", "identity_id": "ENT-074-1002", "issue": "pay-equity outlier", "owner": "Lena Varga", "portfolio_key": "CBP-074-03", "recommended_action": "Create employee-cycle rows with exact comparator and factor evidence. Owner: Lena Varga; due 2026-09-13.", "severity": "medium", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/003_handbooks_policies_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/015_personnel_records_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/027_compensation_equity_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/039_leave_accommodation_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/097_daymark_bank_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "completion is required by 2025-12-16 under CB-EL-3104-R984; the current event record shows completion on 2026-01-13 under CB-EL-3104-E522. Identity resolves to ENT-074-1003, revision REV-2026.4 is current, and Elliot Mercer is active with capacity 1.", "due_date": "2026-09-12", "id": "ACT-CBP-074-04", "identity_id": "ENT-074-1003", "issue": "discipline comparator inconsistency", "owner": "Elliot Mercer", "portfolio_key": "CBP-074-04", "recommended_action": "Create employee-cycle rows with exact comparator and factor evidence. Owner: Elliot Mercer; due 2026-09-12.", "severity": "medium", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/004_handbooks_policies_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/016_personnel_records_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/028_compensation_equity_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/040_leave_accommodation_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/10_contractors/076_contractors_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/08_performance_discipline/064_performance_discipline_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/097_daymark_bank_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "the controlling threshold is 5% under CB-EL-3104-R992; the independently calculated result is 9% under CB-EL-3104-E523. Identity resolves to ENT-074-1004, revision REV-2026.5 is current, and Sofia Bennett is active with capacity 5.", "due_date": "2026-09-11", "id": "ACT-CBP-074-05", "identity_id": "ENT-074-1004", "issue": "training completion gap", "owner": "Sofia Bennett", "portfolio_key": "CBP-074-05", "recommended_action": "Create employee-cycle rows with exact comparator and factor evidence. Owner: Sofia Bennett; due 2026-09-11.", "severity": "low", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/005_handbooks_policies_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/017_payroll_time_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/029_compensation_equity_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/06_complaints/041_complaints_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/09_separation/065_separation_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/097_daymark_bank_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "approval must come from Amara Patel under CB-EL-3104-R829; the effective approval record names Caleb Hassan under CB-EL-3104-E937. Identity resolves to ENT-074-1005, revision REV-2026.6 is current, and Micah Sullivan is active with capacity 3.", "due_date": "2026-09-10", "id": "ACT-CBP-074-06", "identity_id": "ENT-074-1005", "issue": "meal-period premium gap", "owner": "Micah Sullivan", "portfolio_key": "CBP-074-06", "recommended_action": "Create employee-cycle rows with exact comparator and factor evidence. Owner: Micah Sullivan; due 2026-09-10.", "severity": "medium", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/006_handbooks_policies_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/018_payroll_time_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/030_compensation_equity_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/06_complaints/042_complaints_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/10_contractors/078_contractors_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/097_daymark_bank_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "the permission is limited to United States Department of Labor under CB-EL-3104-R748; the matched activity occurred in North Carolina under CB-EL-3104-E826. Identity resolves to ENT-074-1007, revision REV-2026.1 is current, and Caleb Hassan is active with capacity 3.", "due_date": "2026-09-08", "id": "ACT-CBP-074-08", "identity_id": "ENT-074-1007", "issue": "contractor control evidence", "owner": "Caleb Hassan", "portfolio_key": "CBP-074-08", "recommended_action": "Create employee-cycle rows with exact comparator and factor evidence. Owner: Caleb Hassan; due 2026-09-08.", "severity": "high", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/008_handbooks_policies_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/020_payroll_time_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/032_compensation_equity_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/06_complaints/044_complaints_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/09_separation/068_separation_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/092_agency_matters_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/097_daymark_bank_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "the operative cap is $7,762,000.00 under CB-EL-3104-R126; the matched ledger population totals $7,784,326.00 under CB-EL-3104-E313. Identity resolves to ENT-074-1008, revision REV-2026.2 is current, and Amara Patel is active with capacity 5.", "due_date": "2026-09-07", "id": "ACT-CBP-074-09", "identity_id": "ENT-074-1008", "issue": "overtime calculation error", "owner": "Amara Patel", "portfolio_key": "CBP-074-09", "recommended_action": "Create employee-cycle rows with exact comparator and factor evidence. Owner: Amara Patel; due 2026-09-07.", "severity": "high", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/009_personnel_records_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/021_payroll_time_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/033_leave_accommodation_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/06_complaints/045_complaints_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/11_training/081_training_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/08_performance_discipline/057_performance_discipline_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/097_daymark_bank_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "an open exception blocks completion under CB-EL-3104-R578; the current status is open and unresolved under CB-EL-3104-E234. Identity resolves to ENT-074-1010, revision REV-2026.4 is current, and Talia Brooks is active with capacity 3.", "due_date": "2026-09-14", "id": "ACT-CBP-074-11", "identity_id": "ENT-074-1010", "issue": "restrictive-covenant conflict", "owner": "Talia Brooks", "portfolio_key": "CBP-074-11", "recommended_action": "Create employee-cycle rows with exact comparator and factor evidence. Owner: Talia Brooks; due 2026-09-14.", "severity": "critical", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/011_personnel_records_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/023_payroll_time_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/035_leave_accommodation_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/06_complaints/047_complaints_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/08_performance_discipline/059_performance_discipline_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/09_separation/071_separation_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/097_daymark_bank_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "completion is required by 2026-02-16 under CB-EL-3104-R206; the current event record shows completion on 2026-03-15 under CB-EL-3104-E476. Identity resolves to ENT-074-1011, revision REV-2026.5 is current, and Adrian Mensah is active with capacity 1.", "due_date": "2026-09-13", "id": "ACT-CBP-074-12", "identity_id": "ENT-074-1011", "issue": "classification inconsistency", "owner": "Adrian Mensah", "portfolio_key": "CBP-074-12", "recommended_action": "Create employee-cycle rows with exact comparator and factor evidence. Owner: Adrian Mensah; due 2026-09-13.", "severity": "high", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/012_personnel_records_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/024_payroll_time_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/036_leave_accommodation_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/06_complaints/048_complaints_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/096_agency_matters_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/09_separation/072_separation_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/097_daymark_bank_impact_population.xlsx"]}], "as_of": "2026-09-16", "decision": {"alternatives_considered": ["daymark-bank:shortcut", "daymark-bank:blanket-hold"], "question": "Which Daymark compensation outliers require correction or further privileged review?", "rationale": "The four-part causal test supports 8 scoped actions and leaves 4 records on evidence hold. The approved comparison population and legitimate-factor rules govern outlier treatment.", "recommendation": "Correct supported disparities and hold cases with unresolved explanatory factors.", "selected_option_id": "daymark-bank:scoped-evidence"}, "holds": [{"id": "HOLD-CBP-074-01", "issue": "retaliation timing", "portfolio_key": "CBP-074-01", "reason": "the current observation does not meet the operative trigger", "required_next_evidence": "a current observation that satisfies the operative trigger", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/001_handbooks_policies_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/013_personnel_records_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/025_compensation_equity_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/037_leave_accommodation_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/07_investigations/049_investigations_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/097_daymark_bank_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-074-02", "issue": "personnel-file access deadline", "portfolio_key": "CBP-074-02", "reason": "the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective", "required_next_evidence": "effective approval and an active owner with remaining capacity", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/002_handbooks_policies_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/014_personnel_records_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/026_compensation_equity_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/038_leave_accommodation_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/11_training/086_training_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/097_daymark_bank_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-074-07", "issue": "investigation independence concern", "portfolio_key": "CBP-074-07", "reason": "the operational record relies on a superseded control revision", "required_next_evidence": "an operational record using the current effective revision", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/007_handbooks_policies_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/019_payroll_time_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/031_compensation_equity_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/06_complaints/043_complaints_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/097_daymark_bank_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-074-10", "issue": "complaint escalation gap", "portfolio_key": "CBP-074-10", "reason": "the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective", "required_next_evidence": "effective approval and an active owner with remaining capacity", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/010_personnel_records_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/022_payroll_time_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/034_leave_accommodation_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/06_complaints/046_complaints_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/11_training/082_training_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/09_separation/070_separation_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/097_daymark_bank_impact_population.xlsx"]}], "matter_number": "CB-EL-3104", "prepared_for": "Daymark Community Bank", "schema_version": "counselbench.decision.v3", "task_id": "cb100-074-daymark-bank"}, "matter_register": {"matter_number": "CB-EL-3104", "rows": [{"decision_option_id": "daymark-bank:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "the current observation does not meet the operative trigger", "issue": "retaliation timing", "matter_number": "CB-EL-3104", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-074-01", "row_id": "REG-CBP-074-01", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/001_handbooks_policies_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/013_personnel_records_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/025_compensation_equity_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/037_leave_accommodation_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/07_investigations/049_investigations_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/097_daymark_bank_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "daymark-bank:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective", "issue": "personnel-file access deadline", "matter_number": "CB-EL-3104", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-074-02", "row_id": "REG-CBP-074-02", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/002_handbooks_policies_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/014_personnel_records_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/026_compensation_equity_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/038_leave_accommodation_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/11_training/086_training_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/097_daymark_bank_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "daymark-bank:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-13", "issue": "pay-equity outlier", "matter_number": "CB-EL-3104", "owner": "Lena Varga", "portfolio_key": "CBP-074-03", "row_id": "REG-CBP-074-03", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/003_handbooks_policies_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/015_personnel_records_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/027_compensation_equity_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/039_leave_accommodation_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/097_daymark_bank_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "daymark-bank:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-12", "issue": "discipline comparator inconsistency", "matter_number": "CB-EL-3104", "owner": "Elliot Mercer", "portfolio_key": "CBP-074-04", "row_id": "REG-CBP-074-04", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/004_handbooks_policies_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/016_personnel_records_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/028_compensation_equity_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/040_leave_accommodation_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/10_contractors/076_contractors_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/08_performance_discipline/064_performance_discipline_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/097_daymark_bank_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "daymark-bank:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-11", "issue": "training completion gap", "matter_number": "CB-EL-3104", "owner": "Sofia Bennett", "portfolio_key": "CBP-074-05", "row_id": "REG-CBP-074-05", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/005_handbooks_policies_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/017_payroll_time_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/029_compensation_equity_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/06_complaints/041_complaints_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/09_separation/065_separation_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/097_daymark_bank_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "daymark-bank:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-10", "issue": "meal-period premium gap", "matter_number": "CB-EL-3104", "owner": "Micah Sullivan", "portfolio_key": "CBP-074-06", "row_id": "REG-CBP-074-06", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/006_handbooks_policies_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/018_payroll_time_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/030_compensation_equity_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/06_complaints/042_complaints_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/10_contractors/078_contractors_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/097_daymark_bank_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "daymark-bank:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "the operational record relies on a superseded control revision", "issue": "investigation independence concern", "matter_number": "CB-EL-3104", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-074-07", "row_id": "REG-CBP-074-07", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/007_handbooks_policies_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/019_payroll_time_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/031_compensation_equity_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/06_complaints/043_complaints_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/097_daymark_bank_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "daymark-bank:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-08", "issue": "contractor control evidence", "matter_number": "CB-EL-3104", "owner": "Caleb Hassan", "portfolio_key": "CBP-074-08", "row_id": "REG-CBP-074-08", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/008_handbooks_policies_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/020_payroll_time_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/032_compensation_equity_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/06_complaints/044_complaints_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/09_separation/068_separation_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/092_agency_matters_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/097_daymark_bank_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "daymark-bank:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-07", "issue": "overtime calculation error", "matter_number": "CB-EL-3104", "owner": "Amara Patel", "portfolio_key": "CBP-074-09", "row_id": "REG-CBP-074-09", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/009_personnel_records_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/021_payroll_time_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/033_leave_accommodation_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/06_complaints/045_complaints_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/11_training/081_training_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/08_performance_discipline/057_performance_discipline_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/097_daymark_bank_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "daymark-bank:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective", "issue": "complaint escalation gap", "matter_number": "CB-EL-3104", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-074-10", "row_id": "REG-CBP-074-10", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/010_personnel_records_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/022_payroll_time_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/034_leave_accommodation_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/06_complaints/046_complaints_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/11_training/082_training_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/09_separation/070_separation_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/097_daymark_bank_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "daymark-bank:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-14", "issue": "restrictive-covenant conflict", "matter_number": "CB-EL-3104", "owner": "Talia Brooks", "portfolio_key": "CBP-074-11", "row_id": "REG-CBP-074-11", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/011_personnel_records_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/023_payroll_time_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/035_leave_accommodation_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/06_complaints/047_complaints_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/08_performance_discipline/059_performance_discipline_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/09_separation/071_separation_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/097_daymark_bank_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "daymark-bank:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-13", "issue": "classification inconsistency", "matter_number": "CB-EL-3104", "owner": "Adrian Mensah", "portfolio_key": "CBP-074-12", "row_id": "REG-CBP-074-12", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/012_personnel_records_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/024_payroll_time_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/036_leave_accommodation_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/06_complaints/048_complaints_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/096_agency_matters_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/09_separation/072_separation_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/097_daymark_bank_impact_population.xlsx"]}], "schema_version": "counselbench.matter-register.v3", "task_id": "cb100-074-daymark-bank"}}, "metadata": {"benchmark": "CounselBench-100", "code_license": "Apache-2.0", "data_license": "CC-BY-4.0", "deadline": "2026-09-16", "document_count": 97, "evidence_holds": 4, "jurisdiction": "North Carolina", "matter_number": "CB-EL-3104", "mcp_commit": "9a96ea6e5913736f92b88345bf51caeaaa8e719f", "mcp_package": "@modelcontextprotocol/server-filesystem@2026.7.10", "practice_area": "employment", "reference_tool_calls": 88, "required_evidence_reads": 66, "supported_actions": 8, "synthetic": true, "venue": "United States Department of Labor", "version": "3.1.0"}, "prompt": "The client wants a decision, not another document inventory. Which Daymark compensation outliers require correction or further privileged review? Job architecture, bonuses, performance ratings, and manager messages reveal unexplained compensation outliers in two regions. The team needs the call by 2026-09-16. Put the supported calls into the matter register and leave me a short note I can use with the partner.", "rubric": {"criteria": [{"category": "investigation", "description": "Inventory the production and use targeted searches to locate records across native formats.", "id": "investigation.discover_production"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Complete every task-specific identity, authority, operations, and approval read before the first state transition.", "id": "investigation.read_before_write"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Inspect designated source metadata before relying on those records.", "id": "investigation.custody_before_write"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "Select the supported option 'daymark-bank:scoped-evidence' after applying the four-part test.", "id": "decision.selected_option"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "Identify both rejected approaches and explain why a one-source shortcut and a blanket hold are wrong.", "id": "decision.alternatives"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-074-01 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/001_handbooks_policies_source_export.md rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-074-01.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/013_personnel_records_source_export.json for retaliation timing.", "id": "investigation.CBP-074-01.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/025_compensation_equity_source_export.md to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-074-01.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/037_leave_accommodation_source_export.json.", "id": "investigation.CBP-074-01.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-074-01 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is the current observation does not meet the operative trigger.", "id": "decision.CBP-074-01.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-074-01 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-074-01.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-074-02 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/002_handbooks_policies_source_export.txt rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-074-02.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/014_personnel_records_source_export.xml for personnel-file access deadline.", "id": "investigation.CBP-074-02.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/026_compensation_equity_source_export.txt to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-074-02.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/038_leave_accommodation_source_export.xml.", "id": "investigation.CBP-074-02.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-074-02 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective.", "id": "decision.CBP-074-02.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-074-02 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-074-02.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-074-03 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/003_handbooks_policies_source_export.eml rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-074-03.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/015_personnel_records_source_export.html for pay-equity outlier.", "id": "investigation.CBP-074-03.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/027_compensation_equity_source_export.eml to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-074-03.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/039_leave_accommodation_source_export.html.", "id": "investigation.CBP-074-03.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-074-03 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-074-03.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-074-03 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-074-03.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-074-04 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/004_handbooks_policies_source_export.csv rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-074-04.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/016_personnel_records_source_export.pdf for discipline comparator inconsistency.", "id": "investigation.CBP-074-04.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/028_compensation_equity_source_export.csv to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-074-04.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/040_leave_accommodation_source_export.pdf.", "id": "investigation.CBP-074-04.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-074-04 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-074-04.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-074-04 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-074-04.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-074-05 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/005_handbooks_policies_source_export.json rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-074-05.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/017_payroll_time_source_export.md for training completion gap.", "id": "investigation.CBP-074-05.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/029_compensation_equity_source_export.json to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-074-05.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_complaints/041_complaints_source_export.md.", "id": "investigation.CBP-074-05.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-074-05 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-074-05.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-074-05 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-074-05.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-074-06 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/006_handbooks_policies_source_export.xml rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-074-06.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/018_payroll_time_source_export.txt for meal-period premium gap.", "id": "investigation.CBP-074-06.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/030_compensation_equity_source_export.xml to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-074-06.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_complaints/042_complaints_source_export.txt.", "id": "investigation.CBP-074-06.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-074-06 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-074-06.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-074-06 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-074-06.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-074-07 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/007_handbooks_policies_source_export.html rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-074-07.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/019_payroll_time_source_export.eml for investigation independence concern.", "id": "investigation.CBP-074-07.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/031_compensation_equity_source_export.html to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-074-07.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_complaints/043_complaints_source_export.eml.", "id": "investigation.CBP-074-07.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-074-07 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is the operational record relies on a superseded control revision.", "id": "decision.CBP-074-07.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-074-07 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-074-07.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-074-08 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/008_handbooks_policies_source_export.pdf rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-074-08.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/020_payroll_time_source_export.csv for contractor control evidence.", "id": "investigation.CBP-074-08.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/032_compensation_equity_source_export.pdf to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-074-08.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_complaints/044_complaints_source_export.csv.", "id": "investigation.CBP-074-08.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-074-08 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-074-08.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-074-08 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-074-08.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-074-09 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/009_personnel_records_source_export.md rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-074-09.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/021_payroll_time_source_export.json for overtime calculation error.", "id": "investigation.CBP-074-09.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/033_leave_accommodation_source_export.md to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-074-09.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_complaints/045_complaints_source_export.json.", "id": "investigation.CBP-074-09.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-074-09 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-074-09.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-074-09 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-074-09.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-074-10 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/010_personnel_records_source_export.txt rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-074-10.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/022_payroll_time_source_export.xml for complaint escalation gap.", "id": "investigation.CBP-074-10.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/034_leave_accommodation_source_export.txt to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-074-10.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_complaints/046_complaints_source_export.xml.", "id": "investigation.CBP-074-10.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-074-10 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective.", "id": "decision.CBP-074-10.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-074-10 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-074-10.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-074-11 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/011_personnel_records_source_export.eml rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-074-11.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/023_payroll_time_source_export.html for restrictive-covenant conflict.", "id": "investigation.CBP-074-11.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/035_leave_accommodation_source_export.eml to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-074-11.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_complaints/047_complaints_source_export.html.", "id": "investigation.CBP-074-11.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-074-11 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-074-11.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-074-11 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-074-11.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-074-12 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/012_personnel_records_source_export.csv rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-074-12.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/024_payroll_time_source_export.pdf for classification inconsistency.", "id": "investigation.CBP-074-12.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/036_leave_accommodation_source_export.csv to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-074-12.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_complaints/048_complaints_source_export.pdf.", "id": "investigation.CBP-074-12.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-074-12 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-074-12.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-074-12 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-074-12.register"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Write the exact selected option, supported action population, evidence-hold population, facts, owners, deadlines, and citations.", "id": "state.exact_decision"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create one exact register row per portfolio key with no extra, missing, or modified row.", "id": "state.exact_register"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Leave only the three approved deliverables and perform no extra state-changing write.", "id": "state.write_scope_containment"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Read back decision.json, matter-register.json, and advice.md after their final writes.", "id": "state.postwrite_readback"}, {"category": "answer", "description": "Explain the selected recommendation, supported actions, holds, alternatives, and limitations with exact source anchors.", "id": "answer.decision_note"}], "decision_options": [{"approach": "Use a plausible summary or one source without completing the controlling joins.", "id": "daymark-bank:shortcut", "label": "Rank raw pay and correct everyone below the group average."}, {"approach": "Treat supported actions and genuinely ambiguous records as if they were equally unresolved.", "id": "daymark-bank:blanket-hold", "label": "Freeze the entire matter population"}, {"approach": "Apply the exact identity, current-state, authority, and revision test. Create employee-cycle rows with exact comparator and factor evidence.", "id": "daymark-bank:scoped-evidence", "label": "Correct supported disparities and hold cases with unresolved explanatory factors."}], "evaluation_narrative": {"authority": "The approved comparison population and legitimate-factor rules govern outlier treatment.", "observation": "Match job level, region, pay, bonuses, ratings, and decision communications by employee and cycle.", "question": "Which Daymark compensation outliers require correction or further privileged review?", "register_action": "Create employee-cycle rows with exact comparator and factor evidence."}, "gates": ["all_required_evidence_precedes_first_write", "decision_criteria_complete", "register_state_exact", "write_scope_contained", "all_outputs_verified_by_readback"], "metadata_checks": 6, "metric": "weighted_criteria_score", "minimum_tool_calls": 88, "required_deliverables": ["decision.json", "matter-register.json", "advice.md"], "required_document_reads": 66, "type": "deterministic", "weights": {"advice": 0.15, "decision": 0.35, "investigation": 0.25, "state": 0.25}}, "task_id": "cb100-074-daymark-bank", "task_name": "Daymark pay-equity privileged audit", "world_id": "counselbench-filesystem-mcp-v3"}
+{"context_files": ["task_files/cb100-075-elmwood-retail/01_handbooks_policies/001_handbooks_policies_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-075-elmwood-retail/01_handbooks_policies/002_handbooks_policies_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-075-elmwood-retail/01_handbooks_policies/003_handbooks_policies_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-075-elmwood-retail/01_handbooks_policies/004_handbooks_policies_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-075-elmwood-retail/01_handbooks_policies/005_handbooks_policies_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-075-elmwood-retail/01_handbooks_policies/006_handbooks_policies_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-075-elmwood-retail/01_handbooks_policies/007_handbooks_policies_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-075-elmwood-retail/01_handbooks_policies/008_handbooks_policies_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-075-elmwood-retail/02_personnel_records/009_personnel_records_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-075-elmwood-retail/02_personnel_records/010_personnel_records_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-075-elmwood-retail/02_personnel_records/011_personnel_records_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-075-elmwood-retail/02_personnel_records/012_personnel_records_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-075-elmwood-retail/02_personnel_records/013_personnel_records_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-075-elmwood-retail/02_personnel_records/014_personnel_records_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-075-elmwood-retail/02_personnel_records/015_personnel_records_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-075-elmwood-retail/02_personnel_records/016_personnel_records_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-075-elmwood-retail/03_payroll_time/017_payroll_time_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-075-elmwood-retail/03_payroll_time/018_payroll_time_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-075-elmwood-retail/03_payroll_time/019_payroll_time_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-075-elmwood-retail/03_payroll_time/020_payroll_time_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-075-elmwood-retail/03_payroll_time/021_payroll_time_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-075-elmwood-retail/03_payroll_time/022_payroll_time_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-075-elmwood-retail/03_payroll_time/023_payroll_time_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-075-elmwood-retail/03_payroll_time/024_payroll_time_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-075-elmwood-retail/04_compensation_equity/025_compensation_equity_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-075-elmwood-retail/04_compensation_equity/026_compensation_equity_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-075-elmwood-retail/04_compensation_equity/027_compensation_equity_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-075-elmwood-retail/04_compensation_equity/028_compensation_equity_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-075-elmwood-retail/04_compensation_equity/029_compensation_equity_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-075-elmwood-retail/04_compensation_equity/030_compensation_equity_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-075-elmwood-retail/04_compensation_equity/031_compensation_equity_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-075-elmwood-retail/04_compensation_equity/032_compensation_equity_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-075-elmwood-retail/05_leave_accommodation/033_leave_accommodation_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-075-elmwood-retail/05_leave_accommodation/034_leave_accommodation_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-075-elmwood-retail/05_leave_accommodation/035_leave_accommodation_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-075-elmwood-retail/05_leave_accommodation/036_leave_accommodation_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-075-elmwood-retail/05_leave_accommodation/037_leave_accommodation_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-075-elmwood-retail/05_leave_accommodation/038_leave_accommodation_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-075-elmwood-retail/05_leave_accommodation/039_leave_accommodation_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-075-elmwood-retail/05_leave_accommodation/040_leave_accommodation_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-075-elmwood-retail/06_complaints/041_complaints_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-075-elmwood-retail/06_complaints/042_complaints_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-075-elmwood-retail/06_complaints/043_complaints_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-075-elmwood-retail/06_complaints/044_complaints_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-075-elmwood-retail/06_complaints/045_complaints_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-075-elmwood-retail/06_complaints/046_complaints_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-075-elmwood-retail/06_complaints/047_complaints_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-075-elmwood-retail/06_complaints/048_complaints_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-075-elmwood-retail/07_investigations/049_investigations_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-075-elmwood-retail/07_investigations/050_investigations_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-075-elmwood-retail/07_investigations/051_investigations_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-075-elmwood-retail/07_investigations/052_investigations_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-075-elmwood-retail/07_investigations/053_investigations_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-075-elmwood-retail/07_investigations/054_investigations_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-075-elmwood-retail/07_investigations/055_investigations_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-075-elmwood-retail/07_investigations/056_investigations_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-075-elmwood-retail/08_performance_discipline/057_performance_discipline_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-075-elmwood-retail/08_performance_discipline/058_performance_discipline_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-075-elmwood-retail/08_performance_discipline/059_performance_discipline_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-075-elmwood-retail/08_performance_discipline/060_performance_discipline_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-075-elmwood-retail/08_performance_discipline/061_performance_discipline_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-075-elmwood-retail/08_performance_discipline/062_performance_discipline_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-075-elmwood-retail/08_performance_discipline/063_performance_discipline_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-075-elmwood-retail/08_performance_discipline/064_performance_discipline_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-075-elmwood-retail/09_separation/065_separation_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-075-elmwood-retail/09_separation/066_separation_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-075-elmwood-retail/09_separation/067_separation_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-075-elmwood-retail/09_separation/068_separation_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-075-elmwood-retail/09_separation/069_separation_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-075-elmwood-retail/09_separation/070_separation_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-075-elmwood-retail/09_separation/071_separation_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-075-elmwood-retail/09_separation/072_separation_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-075-elmwood-retail/10_contractors/073_contractors_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-075-elmwood-retail/10_contractors/074_contractors_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-075-elmwood-retail/10_contractors/075_contractors_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-075-elmwood-retail/10_contractors/076_contractors_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-075-elmwood-retail/10_contractors/077_contractors_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-075-elmwood-retail/10_contractors/078_contractors_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-075-elmwood-retail/10_contractors/079_contractors_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-075-elmwood-retail/10_contractors/080_contractors_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-075-elmwood-retail/11_training/081_training_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-075-elmwood-retail/11_training/082_training_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-075-elmwood-retail/11_training/083_training_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-075-elmwood-retail/11_training/084_training_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-075-elmwood-retail/11_training/085_training_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-075-elmwood-retail/11_training/086_training_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-075-elmwood-retail/11_training/087_training_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-075-elmwood-retail/11_training/088_training_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-075-elmwood-retail/12_agency_matters/089_agency_matters_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-075-elmwood-retail/12_agency_matters/090_agency_matters_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-075-elmwood-retail/12_agency_matters/091_agency_matters_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-075-elmwood-retail/12_agency_matters/092_agency_matters_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-075-elmwood-retail/12_agency_matters/093_agency_matters_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-075-elmwood-retail/12_agency_matters/094_agency_matters_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-075-elmwood-retail/12_agency_matters/095_agency_matters_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-075-elmwood-retail/12_agency_matters/096_agency_matters_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-075-elmwood-retail/12_agency_matters/097_elmwood_retail_impact_population.xlsx"], "gold_output": {"advice_markdown": "# Decision note — Elmwood scheduling complaint review\n\n## Recommendation\n\nCorrect supported pay or scheduling failures and escalate corroborated retaliation risk. The reconciled record supports 8 scoped actions and leaves 4 items on evidence hold.\n\nSelected option: `elmwood-retail:scoped-evidence`.\n\n## Why this is the supported option\n\nReconcile protected complaint, schedule changes, time punches, acknowledgments, comparators, and discipline authority. Scheduling, wage, and retaliation controls apply by event, knowledge, and consistent comparator treatment.\n\n## Supported actions\n\n### CBP-075-01 — separation pay discrepancy (medium)\n\napproval must come from Nora Chen under CB-EL-3105-R470; the effective approval record names Caleb Hassan under CB-EL-3105-E386. Identity resolves to ENT-075-1000, revision REV-2025.1 is current, and Isaac Romero is active with capacity 3.\n\nAction: Create employee-event rows and separate administrative errors from retaliation evidence. Owner: Isaac Romero; due 2026-09-18.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/001_handbooks_policies_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/013_personnel_records_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/025_compensation_equity_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/037_leave_accommodation_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/10_contractors/073_contractors_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/07_investigations/049_investigations_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/097_elmwood_retail_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-075-03 — leave designation delay (medium)\n\nthe permission is limited to Illinois Department of Labor under CB-EL-3105-R422; the matched activity occurred in Illinois under CB-EL-3105-E224. Identity resolves to ENT-075-1002, revision REV-2025.3 is current, and Rafael Okafor is active with capacity 2.\n\nAction: Create employee-event rows and separate administrative errors from retaliation evidence. Owner: Rafael Okafor; due 2026-09-16.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/003_handbooks_policies_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/015_personnel_records_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/027_compensation_equity_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/039_leave_accommodation_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/07_investigations/051_investigations_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/097_elmwood_retail_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-075-04 — retaliation timing (medium)\n\nthe operative cap is $2,362,000.00 under CB-EL-3105-R891; the matched ledger population totals $2,544,091.00 under CB-EL-3105-E411. Identity resolves to ENT-075-1003, revision REV-2025.4 is current, and Mei Whitaker is active with capacity 1.\n\nAction: Create employee-event rows and separate administrative errors from retaliation evidence. Owner: Mei Whitaker; due 2026-09-15.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/004_handbooks_policies_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/016_personnel_records_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/028_compensation_equity_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/040_leave_accommodation_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/11_training/088_training_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/07_investigations/052_investigations_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/097_elmwood_retail_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-075-05 — personnel-file access deadline (medium)\n\ndelivery must use notices-elmwood_specialty_retail@example.test under CB-EL-3105-R310; the only matched receipt used archive-store_manager_collective@example.test under CB-EL-3105-E747. Identity resolves to ENT-075-1004, revision REV-2025.5 is current, and Theo Laurent is active with capacity 2.\n\nAction: Create employee-event rows and separate administrative errors from retaliation evidence. Owner: Theo Laurent; due 2026-09-14.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/005_handbooks_policies_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/017_payroll_time_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/029_compensation_equity_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/06_complaints/041_complaints_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/089_agency_matters_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/097_elmwood_retail_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-075-07 — discipline comparator inconsistency (medium)\n\ncompletion is required by 2025-03-25 under CB-EL-3105-R958; the current event record shows completion on 2025-05-05 under CB-EL-3105-E785. Identity resolves to ENT-075-1006, revision REV-2025.7 is current, and Elliot Mercer is active with capacity 4.\n\nAction: Create employee-event rows and separate administrative errors from retaliation evidence. Owner: Elliot Mercer; due 2026-09-12.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/007_handbooks_policies_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/019_payroll_time_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/031_compensation_equity_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/06_complaints/043_complaints_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/09_separation/067_separation_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/097_elmwood_retail_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-075-09 — meal-period premium gap (critical)\n\napproval must come from Nora Chen under CB-EL-3105-R742; the effective approval record names Rafael Okafor under CB-EL-3105-E243. Identity resolves to ENT-075-1008, revision REV-2025.2 is current, and Micah Sullivan is active with capacity 2.\n\nAction: Create employee-event rows and separate administrative errors from retaliation evidence. Owner: Micah Sullivan; due 2026-09-10.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/009_personnel_records_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/021_payroll_time_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/033_leave_accommodation_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/06_complaints/045_complaints_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/097_elmwood_retail_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-075-10 — investigation independence concern (critical)\n\nthe controlled population contains 182 records under CB-EL-3105-R980; the certification covers 143 records under CB-EL-3105-E416. Identity resolves to ENT-075-1009, revision REV-2025.3 is current, and Nora Chen is active with capacity 5.\n\nAction: Create employee-event rows and separate administrative errors from retaliation evidence. Owner: Nora Chen; due 2026-09-18.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/010_personnel_records_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/022_payroll_time_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/034_leave_accommodation_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/06_complaints/046_complaints_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/08_performance_discipline/058_performance_discipline_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/09_separation/070_separation_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/097_elmwood_retail_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-075-12 — overtime calculation error (high)\n\nthe operative cap is $5,362,000.00 under CB-EL-3105-R473; the matched ledger population totals $5,540,073.00 under CB-EL-3105-E386. Identity resolves to ENT-075-1011, revision REV-2025.5 is current, and Amara Patel is active with capacity 6.\n\nAction: Create employee-event rows and separate administrative errors from retaliation evidence. Owner: Amara Patel; due 2026-09-16.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/012_personnel_records_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/024_payroll_time_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/036_leave_accommodation_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/06_complaints/048_complaints_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/08_performance_discipline/060_performance_discipline_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/096_agency_matters_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/097_elmwood_retail_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n## Evidence holds\n\n- **CBP-075-02 — agency response commitment**: the operational record relies on a superseded control revision. Next evidence: an operational record using the current effective revision. Sources: `/workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/002_handbooks_policies_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/014_personnel_records_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/026_compensation_equity_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/038_leave_accommodation_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/097_elmwood_retail_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-075-06 — pay-equity outlier**: the operational record relies on a superseded control revision. Next evidence: an operational record using the current effective revision. Sources: `/workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/006_handbooks_policies_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/018_payroll_time_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/030_compensation_equity_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/06_complaints/042_complaints_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/07_investigations/054_investigations_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/10_contractors/078_contractors_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/097_elmwood_retail_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-075-08 — training completion gap**: the current observation does not meet the operative trigger. Next evidence: a current observation that satisfies the operative trigger. Sources: `/workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/008_handbooks_policies_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/020_payroll_time_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/032_compensation_equity_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/06_complaints/044_complaints_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/092_agency_matters_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/097_elmwood_retail_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-075-11 — contractor control evidence**: two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key. Next evidence: an approved immutable entity crosswalk. Sources: `/workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/011_personnel_records_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/023_payroll_time_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/035_leave_accommodation_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/06_complaints/047_complaints_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/11_training/083_training_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/095_agency_matters_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/097_elmwood_retail_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n## Alternatives considered\n\n- `elmwood-retail:blanket-hold` — Freeze the entire matter population: Treat supported actions and genuinely ambiguous records as if they were equally unresolved.\n- `elmwood-retail:shortcut` — Reverse every discipline event that followed the complaint.: Use a plausible summary or one source without completing the controlling joins.\n\n## Assumptions and limits\n\nThis decision is limited to cb100-075-elmwood-retail, the supplied synthetic records, and the matter state as of 2026-09-19. Similar names, stale revisions, and pending authority are not treated as proof.\n", "decision": {"actions": [{"determination": "approval must come from Nora Chen under CB-EL-3105-R470; the effective approval record names Caleb Hassan under CB-EL-3105-E386. Identity resolves to ENT-075-1000, revision REV-2025.1 is current, and Isaac Romero is active with capacity 3.", "due_date": "2026-09-18", "id": "ACT-CBP-075-01", "identity_id": "ENT-075-1000", "issue": "separation pay discrepancy", "owner": "Isaac Romero", "portfolio_key": "CBP-075-01", "recommended_action": "Create employee-event rows and separate administrative errors from retaliation evidence. Owner: Isaac Romero; due 2026-09-18.", "severity": "medium", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/001_handbooks_policies_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/013_personnel_records_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/025_compensation_equity_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/037_leave_accommodation_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/10_contractors/073_contractors_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/07_investigations/049_investigations_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/097_elmwood_retail_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "the permission is limited to Illinois Department of Labor under CB-EL-3105-R422; the matched activity occurred in Illinois under CB-EL-3105-E224. Identity resolves to ENT-075-1002, revision REV-2025.3 is current, and Rafael Okafor is active with capacity 2.", "due_date": "2026-09-16", "id": "ACT-CBP-075-03", "identity_id": "ENT-075-1002", "issue": "leave designation delay", "owner": "Rafael Okafor", "portfolio_key": "CBP-075-03", "recommended_action": "Create employee-event rows and separate administrative errors from retaliation evidence. Owner: Rafael Okafor; due 2026-09-16.", "severity": "medium", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/003_handbooks_policies_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/015_personnel_records_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/027_compensation_equity_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/039_leave_accommodation_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/07_investigations/051_investigations_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/097_elmwood_retail_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "the operative cap is $2,362,000.00 under CB-EL-3105-R891; the matched ledger population totals $2,544,091.00 under CB-EL-3105-E411. Identity resolves to ENT-075-1003, revision REV-2025.4 is current, and Mei Whitaker is active with capacity 1.", "due_date": "2026-09-15", "id": "ACT-CBP-075-04", "identity_id": "ENT-075-1003", "issue": "retaliation timing", "owner": "Mei Whitaker", "portfolio_key": "CBP-075-04", "recommended_action": "Create employee-event rows and separate administrative errors from retaliation evidence. Owner: Mei Whitaker; due 2026-09-15.", "severity": "medium", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/004_handbooks_policies_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/016_personnel_records_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/028_compensation_equity_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/040_leave_accommodation_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/11_training/088_training_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/07_investigations/052_investigations_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/097_elmwood_retail_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "delivery must use notices-elmwood_specialty_retail@example.test under CB-EL-3105-R310; the only matched receipt used archive-store_manager_collective@example.test under CB-EL-3105-E747. Identity resolves to ENT-075-1004, revision REV-2025.5 is current, and Theo Laurent is active with capacity 2.", "due_date": "2026-09-14", "id": "ACT-CBP-075-05", "identity_id": "ENT-075-1004", "issue": "personnel-file access deadline", "owner": "Theo Laurent", "portfolio_key": "CBP-075-05", "recommended_action": "Create employee-event rows and separate administrative errors from retaliation evidence. Owner: Theo Laurent; due 2026-09-14.", "severity": "medium", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/005_handbooks_policies_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/017_payroll_time_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/029_compensation_equity_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/06_complaints/041_complaints_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/089_agency_matters_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/097_elmwood_retail_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "completion is required by 2025-03-25 under CB-EL-3105-R958; the current event record shows completion on 2025-05-05 under CB-EL-3105-E785. Identity resolves to ENT-075-1006, revision REV-2025.7 is current, and Elliot Mercer is active with capacity 4.", "due_date": "2026-09-12", "id": "ACT-CBP-075-07", "identity_id": "ENT-075-1006", "issue": "discipline comparator inconsistency", "owner": "Elliot Mercer", "portfolio_key": "CBP-075-07", "recommended_action": "Create employee-event rows and separate administrative errors from retaliation evidence. Owner: Elliot Mercer; due 2026-09-12.", "severity": "medium", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/007_handbooks_policies_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/019_payroll_time_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/031_compensation_equity_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/06_complaints/043_complaints_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/09_separation/067_separation_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/097_elmwood_retail_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "approval must come from Nora Chen under CB-EL-3105-R742; the effective approval record names Rafael Okafor under CB-EL-3105-E243. Identity resolves to ENT-075-1008, revision REV-2025.2 is current, and Micah Sullivan is active with capacity 2.", "due_date": "2026-09-10", "id": "ACT-CBP-075-09", "identity_id": "ENT-075-1008", "issue": "meal-period premium gap", "owner": "Micah Sullivan", "portfolio_key": "CBP-075-09", "recommended_action": "Create employee-event rows and separate administrative errors from retaliation evidence. Owner: Micah Sullivan; due 2026-09-10.", "severity": "critical", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/009_personnel_records_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/021_payroll_time_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/033_leave_accommodation_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/06_complaints/045_complaints_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/097_elmwood_retail_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "the controlled population contains 182 records under CB-EL-3105-R980; the certification covers 143 records under CB-EL-3105-E416. Identity resolves to ENT-075-1009, revision REV-2025.3 is current, and Nora Chen is active with capacity 5.", "due_date": "2026-09-18", "id": "ACT-CBP-075-10", "identity_id": "ENT-075-1009", "issue": "investigation independence concern", "owner": "Nora Chen", "portfolio_key": "CBP-075-10", "recommended_action": "Create employee-event rows and separate administrative errors from retaliation evidence. Owner: Nora Chen; due 2026-09-18.", "severity": "critical", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/010_personnel_records_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/022_payroll_time_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/034_leave_accommodation_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/06_complaints/046_complaints_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/08_performance_discipline/058_performance_discipline_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/09_separation/070_separation_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/097_elmwood_retail_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "the operative cap is $5,362,000.00 under CB-EL-3105-R473; the matched ledger population totals $5,540,073.00 under CB-EL-3105-E386. Identity resolves to ENT-075-1011, revision REV-2025.5 is current, and Amara Patel is active with capacity 6.", "due_date": "2026-09-16", "id": "ACT-CBP-075-12", "identity_id": "ENT-075-1011", "issue": "overtime calculation error", "owner": "Amara Patel", "portfolio_key": "CBP-075-12", "recommended_action": "Create employee-event rows and separate administrative errors from retaliation evidence. Owner: Amara Patel; due 2026-09-16.", "severity": "high", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/012_personnel_records_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/024_payroll_time_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/036_leave_accommodation_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/06_complaints/048_complaints_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/08_performance_discipline/060_performance_discipline_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/096_agency_matters_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/097_elmwood_retail_impact_population.xlsx"]}], "as_of": "2026-09-19", "decision": {"alternatives_considered": ["elmwood-retail:blanket-hold", "elmwood-retail:shortcut"], "question": "What should Elmwood correct after the scheduling complaint and subsequent discipline?", "rationale": "The four-part causal test supports 8 scoped actions and leaves 4 records on evidence hold. Scheduling, wage, and retaliation controls apply by event, knowledge, and consistent comparator treatment.", "recommendation": "Correct supported pay or scheduling failures and escalate corroborated retaliation risk.", "selected_option_id": "elmwood-retail:scoped-evidence"}, "holds": [{"id": "HOLD-CBP-075-02", "issue": "agency response commitment", "portfolio_key": "CBP-075-02", "reason": "the operational record relies on a superseded control revision", "required_next_evidence": "an operational record using the current effective revision", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/002_handbooks_policies_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/014_personnel_records_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/026_compensation_equity_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/038_leave_accommodation_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/097_elmwood_retail_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-075-06", "issue": "pay-equity outlier", "portfolio_key": "CBP-075-06", "reason": "the operational record relies on a superseded control revision", "required_next_evidence": "an operational record using the current effective revision", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/006_handbooks_policies_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/018_payroll_time_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/030_compensation_equity_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/06_complaints/042_complaints_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/07_investigations/054_investigations_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/10_contractors/078_contractors_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/097_elmwood_retail_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-075-08", "issue": "training completion gap", "portfolio_key": "CBP-075-08", "reason": "the current observation does not meet the operative trigger", "required_next_evidence": "a current observation that satisfies the operative trigger", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/008_handbooks_policies_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/020_payroll_time_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/032_compensation_equity_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/06_complaints/044_complaints_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/092_agency_matters_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/097_elmwood_retail_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-075-11", "issue": "contractor control evidence", "portfolio_key": "CBP-075-11", "reason": "two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key", "required_next_evidence": "an approved immutable entity crosswalk", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/011_personnel_records_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/023_payroll_time_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/035_leave_accommodation_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/06_complaints/047_complaints_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/11_training/083_training_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/095_agency_matters_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/097_elmwood_retail_impact_population.xlsx"]}], "matter_number": "CB-EL-3105", "prepared_for": "Elmwood Specialty Retail", "schema_version": "counselbench.decision.v3", "task_id": "cb100-075-elmwood-retail"}, "matter_register": {"matter_number": "CB-EL-3105", "rows": [{"decision_option_id": "elmwood-retail:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-18", "issue": "separation pay discrepancy", "matter_number": "CB-EL-3105", "owner": "Isaac Romero", "portfolio_key": "CBP-075-01", "row_id": "REG-CBP-075-01", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/001_handbooks_policies_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/013_personnel_records_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/025_compensation_equity_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/037_leave_accommodation_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/10_contractors/073_contractors_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/07_investigations/049_investigations_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/097_elmwood_retail_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "elmwood-retail:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "the operational record relies on a superseded control revision", "issue": "agency response commitment", "matter_number": "CB-EL-3105", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-075-02", "row_id": "REG-CBP-075-02", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/002_handbooks_policies_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/014_personnel_records_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/026_compensation_equity_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/038_leave_accommodation_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/097_elmwood_retail_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "elmwood-retail:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-16", "issue": "leave designation delay", "matter_number": "CB-EL-3105", "owner": "Rafael Okafor", "portfolio_key": "CBP-075-03", "row_id": "REG-CBP-075-03", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/003_handbooks_policies_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/015_personnel_records_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/027_compensation_equity_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/039_leave_accommodation_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/07_investigations/051_investigations_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/097_elmwood_retail_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "elmwood-retail:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-15", "issue": "retaliation timing", "matter_number": "CB-EL-3105", "owner": "Mei Whitaker", "portfolio_key": "CBP-075-04", "row_id": "REG-CBP-075-04", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/004_handbooks_policies_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/016_personnel_records_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/028_compensation_equity_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/040_leave_accommodation_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/11_training/088_training_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/07_investigations/052_investigations_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/097_elmwood_retail_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "elmwood-retail:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-14", "issue": "personnel-file access deadline", "matter_number": "CB-EL-3105", "owner": "Theo Laurent", "portfolio_key": "CBP-075-05", "row_id": "REG-CBP-075-05", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/005_handbooks_policies_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/017_payroll_time_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/029_compensation_equity_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/06_complaints/041_complaints_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/089_agency_matters_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/097_elmwood_retail_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "elmwood-retail:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "the operational record relies on a superseded control revision", "issue": "pay-equity outlier", "matter_number": "CB-EL-3105", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-075-06", "row_id": "REG-CBP-075-06", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/006_handbooks_policies_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/018_payroll_time_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/030_compensation_equity_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/06_complaints/042_complaints_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/07_investigations/054_investigations_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/10_contractors/078_contractors_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/097_elmwood_retail_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "elmwood-retail:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-12", "issue": "discipline comparator inconsistency", "matter_number": "CB-EL-3105", "owner": "Elliot Mercer", "portfolio_key": "CBP-075-07", "row_id": "REG-CBP-075-07", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/007_handbooks_policies_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/019_payroll_time_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/031_compensation_equity_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/06_complaints/043_complaints_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/09_separation/067_separation_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/097_elmwood_retail_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "elmwood-retail:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "the current observation does not meet the operative trigger", "issue": "training completion gap", "matter_number": "CB-EL-3105", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-075-08", "row_id": "REG-CBP-075-08", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/008_handbooks_policies_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/020_payroll_time_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/032_compensation_equity_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/06_complaints/044_complaints_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/092_agency_matters_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/097_elmwood_retail_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "elmwood-retail:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-10", "issue": "meal-period premium gap", "matter_number": "CB-EL-3105", "owner": "Micah Sullivan", "portfolio_key": "CBP-075-09", "row_id": "REG-CBP-075-09", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/009_personnel_records_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/021_payroll_time_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/033_leave_accommodation_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/06_complaints/045_complaints_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/097_elmwood_retail_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "elmwood-retail:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-18", "issue": "investigation independence concern", "matter_number": "CB-EL-3105", "owner": "Nora Chen", "portfolio_key": "CBP-075-10", "row_id": "REG-CBP-075-10", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/010_personnel_records_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/022_payroll_time_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/034_leave_accommodation_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/06_complaints/046_complaints_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/08_performance_discipline/058_performance_discipline_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/09_separation/070_separation_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/097_elmwood_retail_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "elmwood-retail:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key", "issue": "contractor control evidence", "matter_number": "CB-EL-3105", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-075-11", "row_id": "REG-CBP-075-11", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/011_personnel_records_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/023_payroll_time_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/035_leave_accommodation_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/06_complaints/047_complaints_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/11_training/083_training_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/095_agency_matters_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/097_elmwood_retail_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "elmwood-retail:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-16", "issue": "overtime calculation error", "matter_number": "CB-EL-3105", "owner": "Amara Patel", "portfolio_key": "CBP-075-12", "row_id": "REG-CBP-075-12", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/012_personnel_records_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/024_payroll_time_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/036_leave_accommodation_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/06_complaints/048_complaints_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/08_performance_discipline/060_performance_discipline_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/096_agency_matters_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/097_elmwood_retail_impact_population.xlsx"]}], "schema_version": "counselbench.matter-register.v3", "task_id": "cb100-075-elmwood-retail"}}, "metadata": {"benchmark": "CounselBench-100", "code_license": "Apache-2.0", "data_license": "CC-BY-4.0", "deadline": "2026-09-19", "document_count": 97, "evidence_holds": 4, "jurisdiction": "Illinois", "matter_number": "CB-EL-3105", "mcp_commit": "9a96ea6e5913736f92b88345bf51caeaaa8e719f", "mcp_package": "@modelcontextprotocol/server-filesystem@2026.7.10", "practice_area": "employment", "reference_tool_calls": 88, "required_evidence_reads": 65, "supported_actions": 8, "synthetic": true, "venue": "Illinois Department of Labor", "version": "3.1.0"}, "prompt": "We inherited inconsistent versions of this matter and need to settle the operating position. What should Elmwood correct after the scheduling complaint and subsequent discipline? Schedule-change records, time punches, policy acknowledgments, and discipline files conflict after a protected complaint. The team needs the call by 2026-09-19. I need the recommendation and the real blockers recorded before the team acts.", "rubric": {"criteria": [{"category": "investigation", "description": "Inventory the production and use targeted searches to locate records across native formats.", "id": "investigation.discover_production"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Complete every task-specific identity, authority, operations, and approval read before the first state transition.", "id": "investigation.read_before_write"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Inspect designated source metadata before relying on those records.", "id": "investigation.custody_before_write"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "Select the supported option 'elmwood-retail:scoped-evidence' after applying the four-part test.", "id": "decision.selected_option"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "Identify both rejected approaches and explain why a one-source shortcut and a blanket hold are wrong.", "id": "decision.alternatives"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-075-01 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/001_handbooks_policies_source_export.md rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-075-01.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/013_personnel_records_source_export.json for separation pay discrepancy.", "id": "investigation.CBP-075-01.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/025_compensation_equity_source_export.md to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-075-01.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/037_leave_accommodation_source_export.json.", "id": "investigation.CBP-075-01.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-075-01 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-075-01.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-075-01 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-075-01.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-075-02 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/002_handbooks_policies_source_export.txt rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-075-02.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/014_personnel_records_source_export.xml for agency response commitment.", "id": "investigation.CBP-075-02.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/026_compensation_equity_source_export.txt to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-075-02.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/038_leave_accommodation_source_export.xml.", "id": "investigation.CBP-075-02.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-075-02 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is the operational record relies on a superseded control revision.", "id": "decision.CBP-075-02.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-075-02 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-075-02.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-075-03 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/003_handbooks_policies_source_export.eml rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-075-03.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/015_personnel_records_source_export.html for leave designation delay.", "id": "investigation.CBP-075-03.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/027_compensation_equity_source_export.eml to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-075-03.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/039_leave_accommodation_source_export.html.", "id": "investigation.CBP-075-03.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-075-03 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-075-03.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-075-03 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-075-03.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-075-04 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/004_handbooks_policies_source_export.csv rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-075-04.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/016_personnel_records_source_export.pdf for retaliation timing.", "id": "investigation.CBP-075-04.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/028_compensation_equity_source_export.csv to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-075-04.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/040_leave_accommodation_source_export.pdf.", "id": "investigation.CBP-075-04.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-075-04 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-075-04.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-075-04 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-075-04.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-075-05 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/005_handbooks_policies_source_export.json rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-075-05.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/017_payroll_time_source_export.md for personnel-file access deadline.", "id": "investigation.CBP-075-05.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/029_compensation_equity_source_export.json to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-075-05.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_complaints/041_complaints_source_export.md.", "id": "investigation.CBP-075-05.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-075-05 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-075-05.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-075-05 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-075-05.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-075-06 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/006_handbooks_policies_source_export.xml rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-075-06.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/018_payroll_time_source_export.txt for pay-equity outlier.", "id": "investigation.CBP-075-06.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/030_compensation_equity_source_export.xml to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-075-06.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_complaints/042_complaints_source_export.txt.", "id": "investigation.CBP-075-06.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-075-06 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is the operational record relies on a superseded control revision.", "id": "decision.CBP-075-06.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-075-06 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-075-06.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-075-07 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/007_handbooks_policies_source_export.html rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-075-07.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/019_payroll_time_source_export.eml for discipline comparator inconsistency.", "id": "investigation.CBP-075-07.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/031_compensation_equity_source_export.html to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-075-07.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_complaints/043_complaints_source_export.eml.", "id": "investigation.CBP-075-07.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-075-07 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-075-07.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-075-07 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-075-07.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-075-08 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/008_handbooks_policies_source_export.pdf rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-075-08.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/020_payroll_time_source_export.csv for training completion gap.", "id": "investigation.CBP-075-08.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/032_compensation_equity_source_export.pdf to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-075-08.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_complaints/044_complaints_source_export.csv.", "id": "investigation.CBP-075-08.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-075-08 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is the current observation does not meet the operative trigger.", "id": "decision.CBP-075-08.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-075-08 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-075-08.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-075-09 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/009_personnel_records_source_export.md rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-075-09.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/021_payroll_time_source_export.json for meal-period premium gap.", "id": "investigation.CBP-075-09.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/033_leave_accommodation_source_export.md to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-075-09.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_complaints/045_complaints_source_export.json.", "id": "investigation.CBP-075-09.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-075-09 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-075-09.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-075-09 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-075-09.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-075-10 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/010_personnel_records_source_export.txt rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-075-10.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/022_payroll_time_source_export.xml for investigation independence concern.", "id": "investigation.CBP-075-10.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/034_leave_accommodation_source_export.txt to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-075-10.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_complaints/046_complaints_source_export.xml.", "id": "investigation.CBP-075-10.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-075-10 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-075-10.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-075-10 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-075-10.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-075-11 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/011_personnel_records_source_export.eml rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-075-11.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/023_payroll_time_source_export.html for contractor control evidence.", "id": "investigation.CBP-075-11.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/035_leave_accommodation_source_export.eml to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-075-11.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_complaints/047_complaints_source_export.html.", "id": "investigation.CBP-075-11.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-075-11 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key.", "id": "decision.CBP-075-11.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-075-11 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-075-11.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-075-12 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/012_personnel_records_source_export.csv rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-075-12.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/024_payroll_time_source_export.pdf for overtime calculation error.", "id": "investigation.CBP-075-12.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/036_leave_accommodation_source_export.csv to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-075-12.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_complaints/048_complaints_source_export.pdf.", "id": "investigation.CBP-075-12.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-075-12 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-075-12.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-075-12 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-075-12.register"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Write the exact selected option, supported action population, evidence-hold population, facts, owners, deadlines, and citations.", "id": "state.exact_decision"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create one exact register row per portfolio key with no extra, missing, or modified row.", "id": "state.exact_register"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Leave only the three approved deliverables and perform no extra state-changing write.", "id": "state.write_scope_containment"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Read back decision.json, matter-register.json, and advice.md after their final writes.", "id": "state.postwrite_readback"}, {"category": "answer", "description": "Explain the selected recommendation, supported actions, holds, alternatives, and limitations with exact source anchors.", "id": "answer.decision_note"}], "decision_options": [{"approach": "Treat supported actions and genuinely ambiguous records as if they were equally unresolved.", "id": "elmwood-retail:blanket-hold", "label": "Freeze the entire matter population"}, {"approach": "Apply the exact identity, current-state, authority, and revision test. Create employee-event rows and separate administrative errors from retaliation evidence.", "id": "elmwood-retail:scoped-evidence", "label": "Correct supported pay or scheduling failures and escalate corroborated retaliation risk."}, {"approach": "Use a plausible summary or one source without completing the controlling joins.", "id": "elmwood-retail:shortcut", "label": "Reverse every discipline event that followed the complaint."}], "evaluation_narrative": {"authority": "Scheduling, wage, and retaliation controls apply by event, knowledge, and consistent comparator treatment.", "observation": "Reconcile protected complaint, schedule changes, time punches, acknowledgments, comparators, and discipline authority.", "question": "What should Elmwood correct after the scheduling complaint and subsequent discipline?", "register_action": "Create employee-event rows and separate administrative errors from retaliation evidence."}, "gates": ["all_required_evidence_precedes_first_write", "decision_criteria_complete", "register_state_exact", "write_scope_contained", "all_outputs_verified_by_readback"], "metadata_checks": 7, "metric": "weighted_criteria_score", "minimum_tool_calls": 88, "required_deliverables": ["decision.json", "matter-register.json", "advice.md"], "required_document_reads": 65, "type": "deterministic", "weights": {"advice": 0.15, "decision": 0.35, "investigation": 0.25, "state": 0.25}}, "task_id": "cb100-075-elmwood-retail", "task_name": "Elmwood scheduling complaint review", "world_id": "counselbench-filesystem-mcp-v3"}
+{"context_files": ["task_files/cb100-076-frontier-games/01_handbooks_policies/001_handbooks_policies_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-076-frontier-games/01_handbooks_policies/002_handbooks_policies_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-076-frontier-games/01_handbooks_policies/003_handbooks_policies_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-076-frontier-games/01_handbooks_policies/004_handbooks_policies_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-076-frontier-games/01_handbooks_policies/005_handbooks_policies_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-076-frontier-games/01_handbooks_policies/006_handbooks_policies_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-076-frontier-games/01_handbooks_policies/007_handbooks_policies_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-076-frontier-games/01_handbooks_policies/008_handbooks_policies_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-076-frontier-games/02_personnel_records/009_personnel_records_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-076-frontier-games/02_personnel_records/010_personnel_records_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-076-frontier-games/02_personnel_records/011_personnel_records_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-076-frontier-games/02_personnel_records/012_personnel_records_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-076-frontier-games/02_personnel_records/013_personnel_records_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-076-frontier-games/02_personnel_records/014_personnel_records_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-076-frontier-games/02_personnel_records/015_personnel_records_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-076-frontier-games/02_personnel_records/016_personnel_records_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-076-frontier-games/03_payroll_time/017_payroll_time_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-076-frontier-games/03_payroll_time/018_payroll_time_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-076-frontier-games/03_payroll_time/019_payroll_time_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-076-frontier-games/03_payroll_time/020_payroll_time_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-076-frontier-games/03_payroll_time/021_payroll_time_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-076-frontier-games/03_payroll_time/022_payroll_time_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-076-frontier-games/03_payroll_time/023_payroll_time_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-076-frontier-games/03_payroll_time/024_payroll_time_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-076-frontier-games/04_compensation_equity/025_compensation_equity_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-076-frontier-games/04_compensation_equity/026_compensation_equity_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-076-frontier-games/04_compensation_equity/027_compensation_equity_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-076-frontier-games/04_compensation_equity/028_compensation_equity_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-076-frontier-games/04_compensation_equity/029_compensation_equity_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-076-frontier-games/04_compensation_equity/030_compensation_equity_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-076-frontier-games/04_compensation_equity/031_compensation_equity_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-076-frontier-games/04_compensation_equity/032_compensation_equity_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-076-frontier-games/05_leave_accommodation/033_leave_accommodation_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-076-frontier-games/05_leave_accommodation/034_leave_accommodation_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-076-frontier-games/05_leave_accommodation/035_leave_accommodation_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-076-frontier-games/05_leave_accommodation/036_leave_accommodation_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-076-frontier-games/05_leave_accommodation/037_leave_accommodation_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-076-frontier-games/05_leave_accommodation/038_leave_accommodation_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-076-frontier-games/05_leave_accommodation/039_leave_accommodation_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-076-frontier-games/05_leave_accommodation/040_leave_accommodation_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-076-frontier-games/06_complaints/041_complaints_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-076-frontier-games/06_complaints/042_complaints_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-076-frontier-games/06_complaints/043_complaints_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-076-frontier-games/06_complaints/044_complaints_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-076-frontier-games/06_complaints/045_complaints_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-076-frontier-games/06_complaints/046_complaints_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-076-frontier-games/06_complaints/047_complaints_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-076-frontier-games/06_complaints/048_complaints_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-076-frontier-games/07_investigations/049_investigations_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-076-frontier-games/07_investigations/050_investigations_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-076-frontier-games/07_investigations/051_investigations_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-076-frontier-games/07_investigations/052_investigations_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-076-frontier-games/07_investigations/053_investigations_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-076-frontier-games/07_investigations/054_investigations_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-076-frontier-games/07_investigations/055_investigations_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-076-frontier-games/07_investigations/056_investigations_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-076-frontier-games/08_performance_discipline/057_performance_discipline_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-076-frontier-games/08_performance_discipline/058_performance_discipline_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-076-frontier-games/08_performance_discipline/059_performance_discipline_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-076-frontier-games/08_performance_discipline/060_performance_discipline_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-076-frontier-games/08_performance_discipline/061_performance_discipline_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-076-frontier-games/08_performance_discipline/062_performance_discipline_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-076-frontier-games/08_performance_discipline/063_performance_discipline_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-076-frontier-games/08_performance_discipline/064_performance_discipline_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-076-frontier-games/09_separation/065_separation_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-076-frontier-games/09_separation/066_separation_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-076-frontier-games/09_separation/067_separation_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-076-frontier-games/09_separation/068_separation_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-076-frontier-games/09_separation/069_separation_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-076-frontier-games/09_separation/070_separation_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-076-frontier-games/09_separation/071_separation_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-076-frontier-games/09_separation/072_separation_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-076-frontier-games/10_contractors/073_contractors_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-076-frontier-games/10_contractors/074_contractors_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-076-frontier-games/10_contractors/075_contractors_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-076-frontier-games/10_contractors/076_contractors_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-076-frontier-games/10_contractors/077_contractors_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-076-frontier-games/10_contractors/078_contractors_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-076-frontier-games/10_contractors/079_contractors_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-076-frontier-games/10_contractors/080_contractors_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-076-frontier-games/11_training/081_training_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-076-frontier-games/11_training/082_training_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-076-frontier-games/11_training/083_training_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-076-frontier-games/11_training/084_training_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-076-frontier-games/11_training/085_training_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-076-frontier-games/11_training/086_training_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-076-frontier-games/11_training/087_training_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-076-frontier-games/11_training/088_training_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-076-frontier-games/12_agency_matters/089_agency_matters_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-076-frontier-games/12_agency_matters/090_agency_matters_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-076-frontier-games/12_agency_matters/091_agency_matters_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-076-frontier-games/12_agency_matters/092_agency_matters_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-076-frontier-games/12_agency_matters/093_agency_matters_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-076-frontier-games/12_agency_matters/094_agency_matters_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-076-frontier-games/12_agency_matters/095_agency_matters_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-076-frontier-games/12_agency_matters/096_agency_matters_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-076-frontier-games/12_agency_matters/097_frontier_games_impact_population.xlsx"], "gold_output": {"advice_markdown": "# Decision note — Frontier contractor and IP audit\n\n## Recommendation\n\nEscalate supported classification changes and cure exact title gaps. The reconciled record supports 6 scoped actions and leaves 6 items on evidence hold.\n\nSelected option: `frontier-games:scoped-evidence`.\n\n## Why this is the supported option\n\nJoin agreements, supervision, access, invoices, deliverables, and source-file ownership by person and project. Classification factors and executed IP assignment language govern independently.\n\n## Supported actions\n\n### CBP-076-03 — interactive-process lapse (medium)\n\nthe controlling threshold is 7% under CB-EL-3106-R864; the independently calculated result is 13% under CB-EL-3106-E303. Identity resolves to ENT-076-1002, revision REV-2026.3 is current, and Priya Raman is active with capacity 5.\n\nAction: Create worker-project rows for classification and chain-of-title outcomes. Owner: Priya Raman; due 2026-09-20.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/003_handbooks_policies_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/015_personnel_records_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/027_compensation_equity_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/039_leave_accommodation_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/10_contractors/075_contractors_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/07_investigations/051_investigations_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/097_frontier_games_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-076-04 — separation pay discrepancy (high)\n\napproval must come from Sofia Bennett under CB-EL-3106-R933; the effective approval record names Rafael Okafor under CB-EL-3106-E678. Identity resolves to ENT-076-1003, revision REV-2026.4 is current, and Isaac Romero is active with capacity 3.\n\nAction: Create worker-project rows for classification and chain-of-title outcomes. Owner: Isaac Romero; due 2026-09-19.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/004_handbooks_policies_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/016_personnel_records_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/028_compensation_equity_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/040_leave_accommodation_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/097_frontier_games_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-076-06 — leave designation delay (medium)\n\nthe permission is limited to Washington Department of Labor & Industries under CB-EL-3106-R809; the matched activity occurred in Washington under CB-EL-3106-E618. Identity resolves to ENT-076-1005, revision REV-2026.6 is current, and Rafael Okafor is active with capacity 4.\n\nAction: Create worker-project rows for classification and chain-of-title outcomes. Owner: Rafael Okafor; due 2026-09-17.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/006_handbooks_policies_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/018_payroll_time_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/030_compensation_equity_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/06_complaints/042_complaints_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/097_frontier_games_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-076-08 — personnel-file access deadline (low)\n\ndelivery must use notices-frontier_game_studios@example.test under CB-EL-3106-R714; the only matched receipt used archive-distributed_art_contributor_group@example.test under CB-EL-3106-E559. Identity resolves to ENT-076-1007, revision REV-2026.1 is current, and Theo Laurent is active with capacity 4.\n\nAction: Create worker-project rows for classification and chain-of-title outcomes. Owner: Theo Laurent; due 2026-09-15.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/008_handbooks_policies_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/020_payroll_time_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/032_compensation_equity_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/06_complaints/044_complaints_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/097_frontier_games_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-076-10 — discipline comparator inconsistency (high)\n\ncompletion is required by 2026-03-01 under CB-EL-3106-R219; the current event record shows completion on 2026-03-18 under CB-EL-3106-E159. Identity resolves to ENT-076-1009, revision REV-2026.3 is current, and Elliot Mercer is active with capacity 1.\n\nAction: Create worker-project rows for classification and chain-of-title outcomes. Owner: Elliot Mercer; due 2026-09-22.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/010_personnel_records_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/022_payroll_time_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/034_leave_accommodation_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/06_complaints/046_complaints_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/097_frontier_games_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-076-11 — training completion gap (low)\n\nthe controlling threshold is 13% under CB-EL-3106-R498; the independently calculated result is 18% under CB-EL-3106-E652. Identity resolves to ENT-076-1010, revision REV-2026.4 is current, and Sofia Bennett is active with capacity 1.\n\nAction: Create worker-project rows for classification and chain-of-title outcomes. Owner: Sofia Bennett; due 2026-09-21.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/011_personnel_records_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/023_payroll_time_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/035_leave_accommodation_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/06_complaints/047_complaints_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/11_training/083_training_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/097_frontier_games_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n## Evidence holds\n\n- **CBP-076-01 — restrictive-covenant conflict**: the operational record relies on a superseded control revision. Next evidence: an operational record using the current effective revision. Sources: `/workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/001_handbooks_policies_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/013_personnel_records_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/025_compensation_equity_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/037_leave_accommodation_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/10_contractors/073_contractors_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/097_frontier_games_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-076-02 — classification inconsistency**: two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key. Next evidence: an approved immutable entity crosswalk. Sources: `/workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/002_handbooks_policies_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/014_personnel_records_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/026_compensation_equity_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/038_leave_accommodation_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/11_training/086_training_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/097_frontier_games_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-076-05 — agency response commitment**: the operational record relies on a superseded control revision. Next evidence: an operational record using the current effective revision. Sources: `/workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/005_handbooks_policies_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/017_payroll_time_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/029_compensation_equity_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/06_complaints/041_complaints_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/09_separation/065_separation_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/07_investigations/053_investigations_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/097_frontier_games_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-076-07 — retaliation timing**: the current observation does not meet the operative trigger. Next evidence: a current observation that satisfies the operative trigger. Sources: `/workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/007_handbooks_policies_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/019_payroll_time_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/031_compensation_equity_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/06_complaints/043_complaints_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/07_investigations/055_investigations_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/091_agency_matters_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/097_frontier_games_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-076-09 — pay-equity outlier**: the operational record relies on a superseded control revision. Next evidence: an operational record using the current effective revision. Sources: `/workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/009_personnel_records_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/021_payroll_time_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/033_leave_accommodation_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/06_complaints/045_complaints_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/097_frontier_games_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-076-12 — meal-period premium gap**: the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective. Next evidence: effective approval and an active owner with remaining capacity. Sources: `/workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/012_personnel_records_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/024_payroll_time_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/036_leave_accommodation_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/06_complaints/048_complaints_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/11_training/084_training_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/097_frontier_games_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n## Alternatives considered\n\n- `frontier-games:shortcut` — Treat invoice payment as proof of contractor status and repository access as proof of assignment.: Use a plausible summary or one source without completing the controlling joins.\n- `frontier-games:blanket-hold` — Freeze the entire matter population: Treat supported actions and genuinely ambiguous records as if they were equally unresolved.\n\n## Assumptions and limits\n\nThis decision is limited to cb100-076-frontier-games, the supplied synthetic records, and the matter state as of 2026-09-23. Similar names, stale revisions, and pending authority are not treated as proof.\n", "decision": {"actions": [{"determination": "the controlling threshold is 7% under CB-EL-3106-R864; the independently calculated result is 13% under CB-EL-3106-E303. Identity resolves to ENT-076-1002, revision REV-2026.3 is current, and Priya Raman is active with capacity 5.", "due_date": "2026-09-20", "id": "ACT-CBP-076-03", "identity_id": "ENT-076-1002", "issue": "interactive-process lapse", "owner": "Priya Raman", "portfolio_key": "CBP-076-03", "recommended_action": "Create worker-project rows for classification and chain-of-title outcomes. Owner: Priya Raman; due 2026-09-20.", "severity": "medium", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/003_handbooks_policies_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/015_personnel_records_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/027_compensation_equity_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/039_leave_accommodation_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/10_contractors/075_contractors_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/07_investigations/051_investigations_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/097_frontier_games_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "approval must come from Sofia Bennett under CB-EL-3106-R933; the effective approval record names Rafael Okafor under CB-EL-3106-E678. Identity resolves to ENT-076-1003, revision REV-2026.4 is current, and Isaac Romero is active with capacity 3.", "due_date": "2026-09-19", "id": "ACT-CBP-076-04", "identity_id": "ENT-076-1003", "issue": "separation pay discrepancy", "owner": "Isaac Romero", "portfolio_key": "CBP-076-04", "recommended_action": "Create worker-project rows for classification and chain-of-title outcomes. Owner: Isaac Romero; due 2026-09-19.", "severity": "high", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/004_handbooks_policies_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/016_personnel_records_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/028_compensation_equity_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/040_leave_accommodation_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/097_frontier_games_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "the permission is limited to Washington Department of Labor & Industries under CB-EL-3106-R809; the matched activity occurred in Washington under CB-EL-3106-E618. Identity resolves to ENT-076-1005, revision REV-2026.6 is current, and Rafael Okafor is active with capacity 4.", "due_date": "2026-09-17", "id": "ACT-CBP-076-06", "identity_id": "ENT-076-1005", "issue": "leave designation delay", "owner": "Rafael Okafor", "portfolio_key": "CBP-076-06", "recommended_action": "Create worker-project rows for classification and chain-of-title outcomes. Owner: Rafael Okafor; due 2026-09-17.", "severity": "medium", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/006_handbooks_policies_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/018_payroll_time_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/030_compensation_equity_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/06_complaints/042_complaints_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/097_frontier_games_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "delivery must use notices-frontier_game_studios@example.test under CB-EL-3106-R714; the only matched receipt used archive-distributed_art_contributor_group@example.test under CB-EL-3106-E559. Identity resolves to ENT-076-1007, revision REV-2026.1 is current, and Theo Laurent is active with capacity 4.", "due_date": "2026-09-15", "id": "ACT-CBP-076-08", "identity_id": "ENT-076-1007", "issue": "personnel-file access deadline", "owner": "Theo Laurent", "portfolio_key": "CBP-076-08", "recommended_action": "Create worker-project rows for classification and chain-of-title outcomes. Owner: Theo Laurent; due 2026-09-15.", "severity": "low", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/008_handbooks_policies_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/020_payroll_time_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/032_compensation_equity_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/06_complaints/044_complaints_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/097_frontier_games_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "completion is required by 2026-03-01 under CB-EL-3106-R219; the current event record shows completion on 2026-03-18 under CB-EL-3106-E159. Identity resolves to ENT-076-1009, revision REV-2026.3 is current, and Elliot Mercer is active with capacity 1.", "due_date": "2026-09-22", "id": "ACT-CBP-076-10", "identity_id": "ENT-076-1009", "issue": "discipline comparator inconsistency", "owner": "Elliot Mercer", "portfolio_key": "CBP-076-10", "recommended_action": "Create worker-project rows for classification and chain-of-title outcomes. Owner: Elliot Mercer; due 2026-09-22.", "severity": "high", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/010_personnel_records_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/022_payroll_time_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/034_leave_accommodation_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/06_complaints/046_complaints_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/097_frontier_games_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "the controlling threshold is 13% under CB-EL-3106-R498; the independently calculated result is 18% under CB-EL-3106-E652. Identity resolves to ENT-076-1010, revision REV-2026.4 is current, and Sofia Bennett is active with capacity 1.", "due_date": "2026-09-21", "id": "ACT-CBP-076-11", "identity_id": "ENT-076-1010", "issue": "training completion gap", "owner": "Sofia Bennett", "portfolio_key": "CBP-076-11", "recommended_action": "Create worker-project rows for classification and chain-of-title outcomes. Owner: Sofia Bennett; due 2026-09-21.", "severity": "low", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/011_personnel_records_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/023_payroll_time_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/035_leave_accommodation_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/06_complaints/047_complaints_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/11_training/083_training_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/097_frontier_games_impact_population.xlsx"]}], "as_of": "2026-09-23", "decision": {"alternatives_considered": ["frontier-games:shortcut", "frontier-games:blanket-hold"], "question": "Which Frontier artists are employees, contractors, or title-risk holds?", "rationale": "The four-part causal test supports 6 scoped actions and leaves 6 records on evidence hold. Classification factors and executed IP assignment language govern independently.", "recommendation": "Escalate supported classification changes and cure exact title gaps.", "selected_option_id": "frontier-games:scoped-evidence"}, "holds": [{"id": "HOLD-CBP-076-01", "issue": "restrictive-covenant conflict", "portfolio_key": "CBP-076-01", "reason": "the operational record relies on a superseded control revision", "required_next_evidence": "an operational record using the current effective revision", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/001_handbooks_policies_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/013_personnel_records_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/025_compensation_equity_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/037_leave_accommodation_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/10_contractors/073_contractors_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/097_frontier_games_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-076-02", "issue": "classification inconsistency", "portfolio_key": "CBP-076-02", "reason": "two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key", "required_next_evidence": "an approved immutable entity crosswalk", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/002_handbooks_policies_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/014_personnel_records_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/026_compensation_equity_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/038_leave_accommodation_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/11_training/086_training_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/097_frontier_games_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-076-05", "issue": "agency response commitment", "portfolio_key": "CBP-076-05", "reason": "the operational record relies on a superseded control revision", "required_next_evidence": "an operational record using the current effective revision", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/005_handbooks_policies_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/017_payroll_time_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/029_compensation_equity_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/06_complaints/041_complaints_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/09_separation/065_separation_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/07_investigations/053_investigations_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/097_frontier_games_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-076-07", "issue": "retaliation timing", "portfolio_key": "CBP-076-07", "reason": "the current observation does not meet the operative trigger", "required_next_evidence": "a current observation that satisfies the operative trigger", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/007_handbooks_policies_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/019_payroll_time_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/031_compensation_equity_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/06_complaints/043_complaints_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/07_investigations/055_investigations_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/091_agency_matters_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/097_frontier_games_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-076-09", "issue": "pay-equity outlier", "portfolio_key": "CBP-076-09", "reason": "the operational record relies on a superseded control revision", "required_next_evidence": "an operational record using the current effective revision", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/009_personnel_records_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/021_payroll_time_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/033_leave_accommodation_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/06_complaints/045_complaints_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/097_frontier_games_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-076-12", "issue": "meal-period premium gap", "portfolio_key": "CBP-076-12", "reason": "the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective", "required_next_evidence": "effective approval and an active owner with remaining capacity", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/012_personnel_records_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/024_payroll_time_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/036_leave_accommodation_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/06_complaints/048_complaints_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/11_training/084_training_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/097_frontier_games_impact_population.xlsx"]}], "matter_number": "CB-EL-3106", "prepared_for": "Frontier Game Studios", "schema_version": "counselbench.decision.v3", "task_id": "cb100-076-frontier-games"}, "matter_register": {"matter_number": "CB-EL-3106", "rows": [{"decision_option_id": "frontier-games:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "the operational record relies on a superseded control revision", "issue": "restrictive-covenant conflict", "matter_number": "CB-EL-3106", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-076-01", "row_id": "REG-CBP-076-01", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/001_handbooks_policies_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/013_personnel_records_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/025_compensation_equity_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/037_leave_accommodation_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/10_contractors/073_contractors_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/097_frontier_games_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "frontier-games:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key", "issue": "classification inconsistency", "matter_number": "CB-EL-3106", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-076-02", "row_id": "REG-CBP-076-02", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/002_handbooks_policies_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/014_personnel_records_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/026_compensation_equity_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/038_leave_accommodation_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/11_training/086_training_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/097_frontier_games_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "frontier-games:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-20", "issue": "interactive-process lapse", "matter_number": "CB-EL-3106", "owner": "Priya Raman", "portfolio_key": "CBP-076-03", "row_id": "REG-CBP-076-03", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/003_handbooks_policies_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/015_personnel_records_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/027_compensation_equity_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/039_leave_accommodation_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/10_contractors/075_contractors_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/07_investigations/051_investigations_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/097_frontier_games_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "frontier-games:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-19", "issue": "separation pay discrepancy", "matter_number": "CB-EL-3106", "owner": "Isaac Romero", "portfolio_key": "CBP-076-04", "row_id": "REG-CBP-076-04", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/004_handbooks_policies_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/016_personnel_records_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/028_compensation_equity_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/040_leave_accommodation_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/097_frontier_games_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "frontier-games:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "the operational record relies on a superseded control revision", "issue": "agency response commitment", "matter_number": "CB-EL-3106", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-076-05", "row_id": "REG-CBP-076-05", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/005_handbooks_policies_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/017_payroll_time_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/029_compensation_equity_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/06_complaints/041_complaints_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/09_separation/065_separation_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/07_investigations/053_investigations_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/097_frontier_games_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "frontier-games:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-17", "issue": "leave designation delay", "matter_number": "CB-EL-3106", "owner": "Rafael Okafor", "portfolio_key": "CBP-076-06", "row_id": "REG-CBP-076-06", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/006_handbooks_policies_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/018_payroll_time_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/030_compensation_equity_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/06_complaints/042_complaints_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/097_frontier_games_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "frontier-games:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "the current observation does not meet the operative trigger", "issue": "retaliation timing", "matter_number": "CB-EL-3106", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-076-07", "row_id": "REG-CBP-076-07", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/007_handbooks_policies_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/019_payroll_time_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/031_compensation_equity_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/06_complaints/043_complaints_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/07_investigations/055_investigations_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/091_agency_matters_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/097_frontier_games_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "frontier-games:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-15", "issue": "personnel-file access deadline", "matter_number": "CB-EL-3106", "owner": "Theo Laurent", "portfolio_key": "CBP-076-08", "row_id": "REG-CBP-076-08", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/008_handbooks_policies_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/020_payroll_time_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/032_compensation_equity_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/06_complaints/044_complaints_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/097_frontier_games_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "frontier-games:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "the operational record relies on a superseded control revision", "issue": "pay-equity outlier", "matter_number": "CB-EL-3106", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-076-09", "row_id": "REG-CBP-076-09", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/009_personnel_records_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/021_payroll_time_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/033_leave_accommodation_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/06_complaints/045_complaints_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/097_frontier_games_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "frontier-games:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-22", "issue": "discipline comparator inconsistency", "matter_number": "CB-EL-3106", "owner": "Elliot Mercer", "portfolio_key": "CBP-076-10", "row_id": "REG-CBP-076-10", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/010_personnel_records_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/022_payroll_time_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/034_leave_accommodation_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/06_complaints/046_complaints_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/097_frontier_games_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "frontier-games:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-21", "issue": "training completion gap", "matter_number": "CB-EL-3106", "owner": "Sofia Bennett", "portfolio_key": "CBP-076-11", "row_id": "REG-CBP-076-11", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/011_personnel_records_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/023_payroll_time_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/035_leave_accommodation_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/06_complaints/047_complaints_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/11_training/083_training_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/097_frontier_games_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "frontier-games:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective", "issue": "meal-period premium gap", "matter_number": "CB-EL-3106", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-076-12", "row_id": "REG-CBP-076-12", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/012_personnel_records_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/024_payroll_time_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/036_leave_accommodation_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/06_complaints/048_complaints_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/11_training/084_training_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/097_frontier_games_impact_population.xlsx"]}], "schema_version": "counselbench.matter-register.v3", "task_id": "cb100-076-frontier-games"}}, "metadata": {"benchmark": "CounselBench-100", "code_license": "Apache-2.0", "data_license": "CC-BY-4.0", "deadline": "2026-09-23", "document_count": 97, "evidence_holds": 6, "jurisdiction": "Washington", "matter_number": "CB-EL-3106", "mcp_commit": "9a96ea6e5913736f92b88345bf51caeaaa8e719f", "mcp_package": "@modelcontextprotocol/server-filesystem@2026.7.10", "practice_area": "employment", "reference_tool_calls": 81, "required_evidence_reads": 60, "supported_actions": 6, "synthetic": true, "venue": "Washington Department of Labor & Industries", "version": "3.1.0"}, "prompt": "I am about to brief the decision makers and need the source record reconciled first. Which Frontier artists are employees, contractors, or title-risk holds? Remote artists signed varying agreements while access, supervision, invoice, and source-file records support different classifications. The team needs the call by 2026-09-23. Record the outcome the source hierarchy supports and explain the alternatives we should not take.", "rubric": {"criteria": [{"category": "investigation", "description": "Inventory the production and use targeted searches to locate records across native formats.", "id": "investigation.discover_production"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Complete every task-specific identity, authority, operations, and approval read before the first state transition.", "id": "investigation.read_before_write"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Inspect designated source metadata before relying on those records.", "id": "investigation.custody_before_write"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "Select the supported option 'frontier-games:scoped-evidence' after applying the four-part test.", "id": "decision.selected_option"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "Identify both rejected approaches and explain why a one-source shortcut and a blanket hold are wrong.", "id": "decision.alternatives"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-076-01 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/001_handbooks_policies_source_export.md rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-076-01.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/013_personnel_records_source_export.json for restrictive-covenant conflict.", "id": "investigation.CBP-076-01.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/025_compensation_equity_source_export.md to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-076-01.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/037_leave_accommodation_source_export.json.", "id": "investigation.CBP-076-01.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-076-01 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is the operational record relies on a superseded control revision.", "id": "decision.CBP-076-01.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-076-01 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-076-01.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-076-02 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/002_handbooks_policies_source_export.txt rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-076-02.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/014_personnel_records_source_export.xml for classification inconsistency.", "id": "investigation.CBP-076-02.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/026_compensation_equity_source_export.txt to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-076-02.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/038_leave_accommodation_source_export.xml.", "id": "investigation.CBP-076-02.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-076-02 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key.", "id": "decision.CBP-076-02.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-076-02 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-076-02.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-076-03 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/003_handbooks_policies_source_export.eml rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-076-03.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/015_personnel_records_source_export.html for interactive-process lapse.", "id": "investigation.CBP-076-03.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/027_compensation_equity_source_export.eml to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-076-03.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/039_leave_accommodation_source_export.html.", "id": "investigation.CBP-076-03.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-076-03 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-076-03.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-076-03 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-076-03.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-076-04 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/004_handbooks_policies_source_export.csv rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-076-04.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/016_personnel_records_source_export.pdf for separation pay discrepancy.", "id": "investigation.CBP-076-04.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/028_compensation_equity_source_export.csv to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-076-04.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/040_leave_accommodation_source_export.pdf.", "id": "investigation.CBP-076-04.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-076-04 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-076-04.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-076-04 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-076-04.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-076-05 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/005_handbooks_policies_source_export.json rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-076-05.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/017_payroll_time_source_export.md for agency response commitment.", "id": "investigation.CBP-076-05.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/029_compensation_equity_source_export.json to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-076-05.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_complaints/041_complaints_source_export.md.", "id": "investigation.CBP-076-05.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-076-05 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is the operational record relies on a superseded control revision.", "id": "decision.CBP-076-05.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-076-05 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-076-05.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-076-06 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/006_handbooks_policies_source_export.xml rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-076-06.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/018_payroll_time_source_export.txt for leave designation delay.", "id": "investigation.CBP-076-06.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/030_compensation_equity_source_export.xml to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-076-06.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_complaints/042_complaints_source_export.txt.", "id": "investigation.CBP-076-06.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-076-06 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-076-06.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-076-06 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-076-06.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-076-07 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/007_handbooks_policies_source_export.html rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-076-07.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/019_payroll_time_source_export.eml for retaliation timing.", "id": "investigation.CBP-076-07.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/031_compensation_equity_source_export.html to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-076-07.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_complaints/043_complaints_source_export.eml.", "id": "investigation.CBP-076-07.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-076-07 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is the current observation does not meet the operative trigger.", "id": "decision.CBP-076-07.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-076-07 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-076-07.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-076-08 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/008_handbooks_policies_source_export.pdf rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-076-08.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/020_payroll_time_source_export.csv for personnel-file access deadline.", "id": "investigation.CBP-076-08.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/032_compensation_equity_source_export.pdf to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-076-08.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_complaints/044_complaints_source_export.csv.", "id": "investigation.CBP-076-08.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-076-08 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-076-08.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-076-08 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-076-08.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-076-09 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/009_personnel_records_source_export.md rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-076-09.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/021_payroll_time_source_export.json for pay-equity outlier.", "id": "investigation.CBP-076-09.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/033_leave_accommodation_source_export.md to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-076-09.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_complaints/045_complaints_source_export.json.", "id": "investigation.CBP-076-09.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-076-09 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is the operational record relies on a superseded control revision.", "id": "decision.CBP-076-09.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-076-09 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-076-09.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-076-10 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/010_personnel_records_source_export.txt rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-076-10.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/022_payroll_time_source_export.xml for discipline comparator inconsistency.", "id": "investigation.CBP-076-10.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/034_leave_accommodation_source_export.txt to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-076-10.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_complaints/046_complaints_source_export.xml.", "id": "investigation.CBP-076-10.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-076-10 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-076-10.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-076-10 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-076-10.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-076-11 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/011_personnel_records_source_export.eml rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-076-11.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/023_payroll_time_source_export.html for training completion gap.", "id": "investigation.CBP-076-11.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/035_leave_accommodation_source_export.eml to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-076-11.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_complaints/047_complaints_source_export.html.", "id": "investigation.CBP-076-11.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-076-11 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-076-11.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-076-11 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-076-11.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-076-12 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/012_personnel_records_source_export.csv rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-076-12.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/024_payroll_time_source_export.pdf for meal-period premium gap.", "id": "investigation.CBP-076-12.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/036_leave_accommodation_source_export.csv to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-076-12.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_complaints/048_complaints_source_export.pdf.", "id": "investigation.CBP-076-12.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-076-12 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective.", "id": "decision.CBP-076-12.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-076-12 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-076-12.register"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Write the exact selected option, supported action population, evidence-hold population, facts, owners, deadlines, and citations.", "id": "state.exact_decision"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create one exact register row per portfolio key with no extra, missing, or modified row.", "id": "state.exact_register"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Leave only the three approved deliverables and perform no extra state-changing write.", "id": "state.write_scope_containment"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Read back decision.json, matter-register.json, and advice.md after their final writes.", "id": "state.postwrite_readback"}, {"category": "answer", "description": "Explain the selected recommendation, supported actions, holds, alternatives, and limitations with exact source anchors.", "id": "answer.decision_note"}], "decision_options": [{"approach": "Apply the exact identity, current-state, authority, and revision test. Create worker-project rows for classification and chain-of-title outcomes.", "id": "frontier-games:scoped-evidence", "label": "Escalate supported classification changes and cure exact title gaps."}, {"approach": "Use a plausible summary or one source without completing the controlling joins.", "id": "frontier-games:shortcut", "label": "Treat invoice payment as proof of contractor status and repository access as proof of assignment."}, {"approach": "Treat supported actions and genuinely ambiguous records as if they were equally unresolved.", "id": "frontier-games:blanket-hold", "label": "Freeze the entire matter population"}], "evaluation_narrative": {"authority": "Classification factors and executed IP assignment language govern independently.", "observation": "Join agreements, supervision, access, invoices, deliverables, and source-file ownership by person and project.", "question": "Which Frontier artists are employees, contractors, or title-risk holds?", "register_action": "Create worker-project rows for classification and chain-of-title outcomes."}, "gates": ["all_required_evidence_precedes_first_write", "decision_criteria_complete", "register_state_exact", "write_scope_contained", "all_outputs_verified_by_readback"], "metadata_checks": 7, "metric": "weighted_criteria_score", "minimum_tool_calls": 81, "required_deliverables": ["decision.json", "matter-register.json", "advice.md"], "required_document_reads": 60, "type": "deterministic", "weights": {"advice": 0.15, "decision": 0.35, "investigation": 0.25, "state": 0.25}}, "task_id": "cb100-076-frontier-games", "task_name": "Frontier contractor and IP audit", "world_id": "counselbench-filesystem-mcp-v3"}
+{"context_files": ["task_files/cb100-077-goldleaf-hotels/01_handbooks_policies/001_handbooks_policies_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-077-goldleaf-hotels/01_handbooks_policies/002_handbooks_policies_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-077-goldleaf-hotels/01_handbooks_policies/003_handbooks_policies_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-077-goldleaf-hotels/01_handbooks_policies/004_handbooks_policies_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-077-goldleaf-hotels/01_handbooks_policies/005_handbooks_policies_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-077-goldleaf-hotels/01_handbooks_policies/006_handbooks_policies_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-077-goldleaf-hotels/01_handbooks_policies/007_handbooks_policies_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-077-goldleaf-hotels/01_handbooks_policies/008_handbooks_policies_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-077-goldleaf-hotels/02_personnel_records/009_personnel_records_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-077-goldleaf-hotels/02_personnel_records/010_personnel_records_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-077-goldleaf-hotels/02_personnel_records/011_personnel_records_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-077-goldleaf-hotels/02_personnel_records/012_personnel_records_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-077-goldleaf-hotels/02_personnel_records/013_personnel_records_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-077-goldleaf-hotels/02_personnel_records/014_personnel_records_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-077-goldleaf-hotels/02_personnel_records/015_personnel_records_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-077-goldleaf-hotels/02_personnel_records/016_personnel_records_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-077-goldleaf-hotels/03_payroll_time/017_payroll_time_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-077-goldleaf-hotels/03_payroll_time/018_payroll_time_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-077-goldleaf-hotels/03_payroll_time/019_payroll_time_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-077-goldleaf-hotels/03_payroll_time/020_payroll_time_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-077-goldleaf-hotels/03_payroll_time/021_payroll_time_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-077-goldleaf-hotels/03_payroll_time/022_payroll_time_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-077-goldleaf-hotels/03_payroll_time/023_payroll_time_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-077-goldleaf-hotels/03_payroll_time/024_payroll_time_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-077-goldleaf-hotels/04_compensation_equity/025_compensation_equity_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-077-goldleaf-hotels/04_compensation_equity/026_compensation_equity_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-077-goldleaf-hotels/04_compensation_equity/027_compensation_equity_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-077-goldleaf-hotels/04_compensation_equity/028_compensation_equity_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-077-goldleaf-hotels/04_compensation_equity/029_compensation_equity_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-077-goldleaf-hotels/04_compensation_equity/030_compensation_equity_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-077-goldleaf-hotels/04_compensation_equity/031_compensation_equity_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-077-goldleaf-hotels/04_compensation_equity/032_compensation_equity_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-077-goldleaf-hotels/05_leave_accommodation/033_leave_accommodation_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-077-goldleaf-hotels/05_leave_accommodation/034_leave_accommodation_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-077-goldleaf-hotels/05_leave_accommodation/035_leave_accommodation_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-077-goldleaf-hotels/05_leave_accommodation/036_leave_accommodation_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-077-goldleaf-hotels/05_leave_accommodation/037_leave_accommodation_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-077-goldleaf-hotels/05_leave_accommodation/038_leave_accommodation_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-077-goldleaf-hotels/05_leave_accommodation/039_leave_accommodation_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-077-goldleaf-hotels/05_leave_accommodation/040_leave_accommodation_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-077-goldleaf-hotels/06_complaints/041_complaints_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-077-goldleaf-hotels/06_complaints/042_complaints_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-077-goldleaf-hotels/06_complaints/043_complaints_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-077-goldleaf-hotels/06_complaints/044_complaints_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-077-goldleaf-hotels/06_complaints/045_complaints_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-077-goldleaf-hotels/06_complaints/046_complaints_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-077-goldleaf-hotels/06_complaints/047_complaints_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-077-goldleaf-hotels/06_complaints/048_complaints_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-077-goldleaf-hotels/07_investigations/049_investigations_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-077-goldleaf-hotels/07_investigations/050_investigations_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-077-goldleaf-hotels/07_investigations/051_investigations_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-077-goldleaf-hotels/07_investigations/052_investigations_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-077-goldleaf-hotels/07_investigations/053_investigations_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-077-goldleaf-hotels/07_investigations/054_investigations_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-077-goldleaf-hotels/07_investigations/055_investigations_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-077-goldleaf-hotels/07_investigations/056_investigations_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-077-goldleaf-hotels/08_performance_discipline/057_performance_discipline_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-077-goldleaf-hotels/08_performance_discipline/058_performance_discipline_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-077-goldleaf-hotels/08_performance_discipline/059_performance_discipline_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-077-goldleaf-hotels/08_performance_discipline/060_performance_discipline_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-077-goldleaf-hotels/08_performance_discipline/061_performance_discipline_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-077-goldleaf-hotels/08_performance_discipline/062_performance_discipline_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-077-goldleaf-hotels/08_performance_discipline/063_performance_discipline_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-077-goldleaf-hotels/08_performance_discipline/064_performance_discipline_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-077-goldleaf-hotels/09_separation/065_separation_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-077-goldleaf-hotels/09_separation/066_separation_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-077-goldleaf-hotels/09_separation/067_separation_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-077-goldleaf-hotels/09_separation/068_separation_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-077-goldleaf-hotels/09_separation/069_separation_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-077-goldleaf-hotels/09_separation/070_separation_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-077-goldleaf-hotels/09_separation/071_separation_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-077-goldleaf-hotels/09_separation/072_separation_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-077-goldleaf-hotels/10_contractors/073_contractors_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-077-goldleaf-hotels/10_contractors/074_contractors_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-077-goldleaf-hotels/10_contractors/075_contractors_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-077-goldleaf-hotels/10_contractors/076_contractors_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-077-goldleaf-hotels/10_contractors/077_contractors_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-077-goldleaf-hotels/10_contractors/078_contractors_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-077-goldleaf-hotels/10_contractors/079_contractors_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-077-goldleaf-hotels/10_contractors/080_contractors_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-077-goldleaf-hotels/11_training/081_training_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-077-goldleaf-hotels/11_training/082_training_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-077-goldleaf-hotels/11_training/083_training_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-077-goldleaf-hotels/11_training/084_training_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-077-goldleaf-hotels/11_training/085_training_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-077-goldleaf-hotels/11_training/086_training_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-077-goldleaf-hotels/11_training/087_training_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-077-goldleaf-hotels/11_training/088_training_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-077-goldleaf-hotels/12_agency_matters/089_agency_matters_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-077-goldleaf-hotels/12_agency_matters/090_agency_matters_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-077-goldleaf-hotels/12_agency_matters/091_agency_matters_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-077-goldleaf-hotels/12_agency_matters/092_agency_matters_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-077-goldleaf-hotels/12_agency_matters/093_agency_matters_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-077-goldleaf-hotels/12_agency_matters/094_agency_matters_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-077-goldleaf-hotels/12_agency_matters/095_agency_matters_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-077-goldleaf-hotels/12_agency_matters/096_agency_matters_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-077-goldleaf-hotels/12_agency_matters/097_goldleaf_hotels_impact_population.xlsx"], "gold_output": {"advice_markdown": "# Decision note — Goldleaf harassment response audit\n\n## Recommendation\n\nRepair supported investigation gaps and escalate corroborated retaliation indicators. The reconciled record supports 8 scoped actions and leaves 4 items on evidence hold.\n\nSelected option: `goldleaf-hotels:scoped-evidence`.\n\n## Why this is the supported option\n\nJoin complaint routing, witnesses, schedules, training, findings, and separation decisions by actor and date. Investigation integrity and anti-retaliation controls require independent process and supported causal evidence.\n\n## Supported actions\n\n### CBP-077-01 — contractor control evidence (medium)\n\nthe permission is limited to Nevada Equal Rights Commission under CB-EL-3107-R160; the matched activity occurred in Nevada under CB-EL-3107-E950. Identity resolves to ENT-077-1000, revision REV-2025.1 is current, and Henry Cho is active with capacity 4.\n\nAction: Create process and personnel-event rows with distinct evidentiary dispositions. Owner: Henry Cho; due 2026-09-25.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/001_handbooks_policies_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/013_personnel_records_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/025_compensation_equity_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/037_leave_accommodation_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/097_goldleaf_hotels_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-077-03 — complaint escalation gap (high)\n\ndelivery must use notices-goldleaf_hotels_and_resorts@example.test under CB-EL-3107-R900; the only matched receipt used archive-former_banquet_supervisor@example.test under CB-EL-3107-E464. Identity resolves to ENT-077-1002, revision REV-2025.3 is current, and Jonas Feld is active with capacity 6.\n\nAction: Create process and personnel-event rows with distinct evidentiary dispositions. Owner: Jonas Feld; due 2026-09-23.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/003_handbooks_policies_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/015_personnel_records_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/027_compensation_equity_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/039_leave_accommodation_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/08_performance_discipline/063_performance_discipline_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/11_training/087_training_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/097_goldleaf_hotels_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-077-05 — classification inconsistency (high)\n\ncompletion is required by 2025-12-13 under CB-EL-3107-R321; the current event record shows completion on 2026-01-19 under CB-EL-3107-E695. Identity resolves to ENT-077-1004, revision REV-2025.5 is current, and Owen Delgado is active with capacity 1.\n\nAction: Create process and personnel-event rows with distinct evidentiary dispositions. Owner: Owen Delgado; due 2026-09-21.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/005_handbooks_policies_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/017_payroll_time_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/029_compensation_equity_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/06_complaints/041_complaints_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/09_separation/065_separation_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/10_contractors/077_contractors_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/097_goldleaf_hotels_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-077-06 — interactive-process lapse (medium)\n\nthe controlling threshold is 14% under CB-EL-3107-R721; the independently calculated result is 20% under CB-EL-3107-E560. Identity resolves to ENT-077-1005, revision REV-2025.6 is current, and Priya Raman is active with capacity 5.\n\nAction: Create process and personnel-event rows with distinct evidentiary dispositions. Owner: Priya Raman; due 2026-09-20.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/006_handbooks_policies_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/018_payroll_time_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/030_compensation_equity_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/06_complaints/042_complaints_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/10_contractors/078_contractors_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/09_separation/066_separation_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/097_goldleaf_hotels_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-077-07 — separation pay discrepancy (high)\n\napproval must come from Lena Varga under CB-EL-3107-R661; the effective approval record names Henry Cho under CB-EL-3107-E503. Identity resolves to ENT-077-1006, revision REV-2025.7 is current, and Isaac Romero is active with capacity 5.\n\nAction: Create process and personnel-event rows with distinct evidentiary dispositions. Owner: Isaac Romero; due 2026-09-19.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/007_handbooks_policies_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/019_payroll_time_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/031_compensation_equity_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/06_complaints/043_complaints_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/097_goldleaf_hotels_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-077-10 — retaliation timing (high)\n\nthe operative cap is $5,842,000.00 under CB-EL-3107-R366; the matched ledger population totals $6,039,766.00 under CB-EL-3107-E750. Identity resolves to ENT-077-1009, revision REV-2025.3 is current, and Mei Whitaker is active with capacity 1.\n\nAction: Create process and personnel-event rows with distinct evidentiary dispositions. Owner: Mei Whitaker; due 2026-09-25.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/010_personnel_records_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/022_payroll_time_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/034_leave_accommodation_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/06_complaints/046_complaints_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/08_performance_discipline/058_performance_discipline_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/097_goldleaf_hotels_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-077-11 — personnel-file access deadline (medium)\n\ndelivery must use notices-goldleaf_hotels_and_resorts@example.test under CB-EL-3107-R417; the only matched receipt used archive-former_banquet_supervisor@example.test under CB-EL-3107-E224. Identity resolves to ENT-077-1010, revision REV-2025.4 is current, and Theo Laurent is active with capacity 4.\n\nAction: Create process and personnel-event rows with distinct evidentiary dispositions. Owner: Theo Laurent; due 2026-09-24.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/011_personnel_records_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/023_payroll_time_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/035_leave_accommodation_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/06_complaints/047_complaints_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/097_goldleaf_hotels_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-077-12 — pay-equity outlier (critical)\n\nan open exception blocks completion under CB-EL-3107-R418; the current status is open and unresolved under CB-EL-3107-E806. Identity resolves to ENT-077-1011, revision REV-2025.5 is current, and Lena Varga is active with capacity 3.\n\nAction: Create process and personnel-event rows with distinct evidentiary dispositions. Owner: Lena Varga; due 2026-09-23.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/012_personnel_records_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/024_payroll_time_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/036_leave_accommodation_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/06_complaints/048_complaints_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/097_goldleaf_hotels_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n## Evidence holds\n\n- **CBP-077-02 — overtime calculation error**: the current observation does not meet the operative trigger. Next evidence: a current observation that satisfies the operative trigger. Sources: `/workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/002_handbooks_policies_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/014_personnel_records_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/026_compensation_equity_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/038_leave_accommodation_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/097_goldleaf_hotels_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-077-04 — restrictive-covenant conflict**: the operational record relies on a superseded control revision. Next evidence: an operational record using the current effective revision. Sources: `/workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/004_handbooks_policies_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/016_personnel_records_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/028_compensation_equity_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/040_leave_accommodation_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/08_performance_discipline/064_performance_discipline_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/097_goldleaf_hotels_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-077-08 — agency response commitment**: the operational record relies on a superseded control revision. Next evidence: an operational record using the current effective revision. Sources: `/workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/008_handbooks_policies_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/020_payroll_time_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/032_compensation_equity_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/06_complaints/044_complaints_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/10_contractors/080_contractors_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/097_goldleaf_hotels_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-077-09 — leave designation delay**: two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key. Next evidence: an approved immutable entity crosswalk. Sources: `/workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/009_personnel_records_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/021_payroll_time_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/033_leave_accommodation_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/06_complaints/045_complaints_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/09_separation/069_separation_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/097_goldleaf_hotels_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n## Alternatives considered\n\n- `goldleaf-hotels:shortcut` — Assume any later schedule or separation change proves retaliation.: Use a plausible summary or one source without completing the controlling joins.\n- `goldleaf-hotels:blanket-hold` — Freeze the entire matter population: Treat supported actions and genuinely ambiguous records as if they were equally unresolved.\n\n## Assumptions and limits\n\nThis decision is limited to cb100-077-goldleaf-hotels, the supplied synthetic records, and the matter state as of 2026-09-26. Similar names, stale revisions, and pending authority are not treated as proof.\n", "decision": {"actions": [{"determination": "the permission is limited to Nevada Equal Rights Commission under CB-EL-3107-R160; the matched activity occurred in Nevada under CB-EL-3107-E950. Identity resolves to ENT-077-1000, revision REV-2025.1 is current, and Henry Cho is active with capacity 4.", "due_date": "2026-09-25", "id": "ACT-CBP-077-01", "identity_id": "ENT-077-1000", "issue": "contractor control evidence", "owner": "Henry Cho", "portfolio_key": "CBP-077-01", "recommended_action": "Create process and personnel-event rows with distinct evidentiary dispositions. Owner: Henry Cho; due 2026-09-25.", "severity": "medium", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/001_handbooks_policies_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/013_personnel_records_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/025_compensation_equity_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/037_leave_accommodation_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/097_goldleaf_hotels_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "delivery must use notices-goldleaf_hotels_and_resorts@example.test under CB-EL-3107-R900; the only matched receipt used archive-former_banquet_supervisor@example.test under CB-EL-3107-E464. Identity resolves to ENT-077-1002, revision REV-2025.3 is current, and Jonas Feld is active with capacity 6.", "due_date": "2026-09-23", "id": "ACT-CBP-077-03", "identity_id": "ENT-077-1002", "issue": "complaint escalation gap", "owner": "Jonas Feld", "portfolio_key": "CBP-077-03", "recommended_action": "Create process and personnel-event rows with distinct evidentiary dispositions. Owner: Jonas Feld; due 2026-09-23.", "severity": "high", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/003_handbooks_policies_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/015_personnel_records_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/027_compensation_equity_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/039_leave_accommodation_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/08_performance_discipline/063_performance_discipline_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/11_training/087_training_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/097_goldleaf_hotels_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "completion is required by 2025-12-13 under CB-EL-3107-R321; the current event record shows completion on 2026-01-19 under CB-EL-3107-E695. Identity resolves to ENT-077-1004, revision REV-2025.5 is current, and Owen Delgado is active with capacity 1.", "due_date": "2026-09-21", "id": "ACT-CBP-077-05", "identity_id": "ENT-077-1004", "issue": "classification inconsistency", "owner": "Owen Delgado", "portfolio_key": "CBP-077-05", "recommended_action": "Create process and personnel-event rows with distinct evidentiary dispositions. Owner: Owen Delgado; due 2026-09-21.", "severity": "high", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/005_handbooks_policies_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/017_payroll_time_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/029_compensation_equity_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/06_complaints/041_complaints_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/09_separation/065_separation_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/10_contractors/077_contractors_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/097_goldleaf_hotels_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "the controlling threshold is 14% under CB-EL-3107-R721; the independently calculated result is 20% under CB-EL-3107-E560. Identity resolves to ENT-077-1005, revision REV-2025.6 is current, and Priya Raman is active with capacity 5.", "due_date": "2026-09-20", "id": "ACT-CBP-077-06", "identity_id": "ENT-077-1005", "issue": "interactive-process lapse", "owner": "Priya Raman", "portfolio_key": "CBP-077-06", "recommended_action": "Create process and personnel-event rows with distinct evidentiary dispositions. Owner: Priya Raman; due 2026-09-20.", "severity": "medium", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/006_handbooks_policies_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/018_payroll_time_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/030_compensation_equity_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/06_complaints/042_complaints_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/10_contractors/078_contractors_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/09_separation/066_separation_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/097_goldleaf_hotels_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "approval must come from Lena Varga under CB-EL-3107-R661; the effective approval record names Henry Cho under CB-EL-3107-E503. Identity resolves to ENT-077-1006, revision REV-2025.7 is current, and Isaac Romero is active with capacity 5.", "due_date": "2026-09-19", "id": "ACT-CBP-077-07", "identity_id": "ENT-077-1006", "issue": "separation pay discrepancy", "owner": "Isaac Romero", "portfolio_key": "CBP-077-07", "recommended_action": "Create process and personnel-event rows with distinct evidentiary dispositions. Owner: Isaac Romero; due 2026-09-19.", "severity": "high", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/007_handbooks_policies_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/019_payroll_time_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/031_compensation_equity_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/06_complaints/043_complaints_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/097_goldleaf_hotels_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "the operative cap is $5,842,000.00 under CB-EL-3107-R366; the matched ledger population totals $6,039,766.00 under CB-EL-3107-E750. Identity resolves to ENT-077-1009, revision REV-2025.3 is current, and Mei Whitaker is active with capacity 1.", "due_date": "2026-09-25", "id": "ACT-CBP-077-10", "identity_id": "ENT-077-1009", "issue": "retaliation timing", "owner": "Mei Whitaker", "portfolio_key": "CBP-077-10", "recommended_action": "Create process and personnel-event rows with distinct evidentiary dispositions. Owner: Mei Whitaker; due 2026-09-25.", "severity": "high", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/010_personnel_records_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/022_payroll_time_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/034_leave_accommodation_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/06_complaints/046_complaints_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/08_performance_discipline/058_performance_discipline_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/097_goldleaf_hotels_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "delivery must use notices-goldleaf_hotels_and_resorts@example.test under CB-EL-3107-R417; the only matched receipt used archive-former_banquet_supervisor@example.test under CB-EL-3107-E224. Identity resolves to ENT-077-1010, revision REV-2025.4 is current, and Theo Laurent is active with capacity 4.", "due_date": "2026-09-24", "id": "ACT-CBP-077-11", "identity_id": "ENT-077-1010", "issue": "personnel-file access deadline", "owner": "Theo Laurent", "portfolio_key": "CBP-077-11", "recommended_action": "Create process and personnel-event rows with distinct evidentiary dispositions. Owner: Theo Laurent; due 2026-09-24.", "severity": "medium", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/011_personnel_records_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/023_payroll_time_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/035_leave_accommodation_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/06_complaints/047_complaints_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/097_goldleaf_hotels_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "an open exception blocks completion under CB-EL-3107-R418; the current status is open and unresolved under CB-EL-3107-E806. Identity resolves to ENT-077-1011, revision REV-2025.5 is current, and Lena Varga is active with capacity 3.", "due_date": "2026-09-23", "id": "ACT-CBP-077-12", "identity_id": "ENT-077-1011", "issue": "pay-equity outlier", "owner": "Lena Varga", "portfolio_key": "CBP-077-12", "recommended_action": "Create process and personnel-event rows with distinct evidentiary dispositions. Owner: Lena Varga; due 2026-09-23.", "severity": "critical", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/012_personnel_records_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/024_payroll_time_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/036_leave_accommodation_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/06_complaints/048_complaints_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/097_goldleaf_hotels_impact_population.xlsx"]}], "as_of": "2026-09-26", "decision": {"alternatives_considered": ["goldleaf-hotels:shortcut", "goldleaf-hotels:blanket-hold"], "question": "Was Goldleaf's response adequate, and which personnel actions create remediation or retaliation risk?", "rationale": "The four-part causal test supports 8 scoped actions and leaves 4 records on evidence hold. Investigation integrity and anti-retaliation controls require independent process and supported causal evidence.", "recommendation": "Repair supported investigation gaps and escalate corroborated retaliation indicators.", "selected_option_id": "goldleaf-hotels:scoped-evidence"}, "holds": [{"id": "HOLD-CBP-077-02", "issue": "overtime calculation error", "portfolio_key": "CBP-077-02", "reason": "the current observation does not meet the operative trigger", "required_next_evidence": "a current observation that satisfies the operative trigger", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/002_handbooks_policies_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/014_personnel_records_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/026_compensation_equity_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/038_leave_accommodation_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/097_goldleaf_hotels_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-077-04", "issue": "restrictive-covenant conflict", "portfolio_key": "CBP-077-04", "reason": "the operational record relies on a superseded control revision", "required_next_evidence": "an operational record using the current effective revision", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/004_handbooks_policies_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/016_personnel_records_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/028_compensation_equity_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/040_leave_accommodation_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/08_performance_discipline/064_performance_discipline_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/097_goldleaf_hotels_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-077-08", "issue": "agency response commitment", "portfolio_key": "CBP-077-08", "reason": "the operational record relies on a superseded control revision", "required_next_evidence": "an operational record using the current effective revision", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/008_handbooks_policies_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/020_payroll_time_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/032_compensation_equity_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/06_complaints/044_complaints_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/10_contractors/080_contractors_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/097_goldleaf_hotels_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-077-09", "issue": "leave designation delay", "portfolio_key": "CBP-077-09", "reason": "two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key", "required_next_evidence": "an approved immutable entity crosswalk", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/009_personnel_records_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/021_payroll_time_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/033_leave_accommodation_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/06_complaints/045_complaints_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/09_separation/069_separation_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/097_goldleaf_hotels_impact_population.xlsx"]}], "matter_number": "CB-EL-3107", "prepared_for": "Goldleaf Hotels and Resorts", "schema_version": "counselbench.decision.v3", "task_id": "cb100-077-goldleaf-hotels"}, "matter_register": {"matter_number": "CB-EL-3107", "rows": [{"decision_option_id": "goldleaf-hotels:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-25", "issue": "contractor control evidence", "matter_number": "CB-EL-3107", "owner": "Henry Cho", "portfolio_key": "CBP-077-01", "row_id": "REG-CBP-077-01", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/001_handbooks_policies_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/013_personnel_records_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/025_compensation_equity_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/037_leave_accommodation_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/097_goldleaf_hotels_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "goldleaf-hotels:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "the current observation does not meet the operative trigger", "issue": "overtime calculation error", "matter_number": "CB-EL-3107", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-077-02", "row_id": "REG-CBP-077-02", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/002_handbooks_policies_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/014_personnel_records_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/026_compensation_equity_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/038_leave_accommodation_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/097_goldleaf_hotels_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "goldleaf-hotels:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-23", "issue": "complaint escalation gap", "matter_number": "CB-EL-3107", "owner": "Jonas Feld", "portfolio_key": "CBP-077-03", "row_id": "REG-CBP-077-03", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/003_handbooks_policies_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/015_personnel_records_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/027_compensation_equity_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/039_leave_accommodation_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/08_performance_discipline/063_performance_discipline_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/11_training/087_training_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/097_goldleaf_hotels_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "goldleaf-hotels:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "the operational record relies on a superseded control revision", "issue": "restrictive-covenant conflict", "matter_number": "CB-EL-3107", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-077-04", "row_id": "REG-CBP-077-04", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/004_handbooks_policies_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/016_personnel_records_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/028_compensation_equity_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/040_leave_accommodation_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/08_performance_discipline/064_performance_discipline_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/097_goldleaf_hotels_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "goldleaf-hotels:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-21", "issue": "classification inconsistency", "matter_number": "CB-EL-3107", "owner": "Owen Delgado", "portfolio_key": "CBP-077-05", "row_id": "REG-CBP-077-05", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/005_handbooks_policies_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/017_payroll_time_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/029_compensation_equity_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/06_complaints/041_complaints_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/09_separation/065_separation_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/10_contractors/077_contractors_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/097_goldleaf_hotels_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "goldleaf-hotels:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-20", "issue": "interactive-process lapse", "matter_number": "CB-EL-3107", "owner": "Priya Raman", "portfolio_key": "CBP-077-06", "row_id": "REG-CBP-077-06", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/006_handbooks_policies_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/018_payroll_time_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/030_compensation_equity_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/06_complaints/042_complaints_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/10_contractors/078_contractors_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/09_separation/066_separation_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/097_goldleaf_hotels_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "goldleaf-hotels:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-19", "issue": "separation pay discrepancy", "matter_number": "CB-EL-3107", "owner": "Isaac Romero", "portfolio_key": "CBP-077-07", "row_id": "REG-CBP-077-07", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/007_handbooks_policies_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/019_payroll_time_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/031_compensation_equity_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/06_complaints/043_complaints_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/097_goldleaf_hotels_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "goldleaf-hotels:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "the operational record relies on a superseded control revision", "issue": "agency response commitment", "matter_number": "CB-EL-3107", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-077-08", "row_id": "REG-CBP-077-08", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/008_handbooks_policies_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/020_payroll_time_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/032_compensation_equity_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/06_complaints/044_complaints_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/10_contractors/080_contractors_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/097_goldleaf_hotels_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "goldleaf-hotels:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key", "issue": "leave designation delay", "matter_number": "CB-EL-3107", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-077-09", "row_id": "REG-CBP-077-09", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/009_personnel_records_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/021_payroll_time_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/033_leave_accommodation_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/06_complaints/045_complaints_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/09_separation/069_separation_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/097_goldleaf_hotels_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "goldleaf-hotels:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-25", "issue": "retaliation timing", "matter_number": "CB-EL-3107", "owner": "Mei Whitaker", "portfolio_key": "CBP-077-10", "row_id": "REG-CBP-077-10", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/010_personnel_records_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/022_payroll_time_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/034_leave_accommodation_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/06_complaints/046_complaints_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/08_performance_discipline/058_performance_discipline_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/097_goldleaf_hotels_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "goldleaf-hotels:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-24", "issue": "personnel-file access deadline", "matter_number": "CB-EL-3107", "owner": "Theo Laurent", "portfolio_key": "CBP-077-11", "row_id": "REG-CBP-077-11", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/011_personnel_records_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/023_payroll_time_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/035_leave_accommodation_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/06_complaints/047_complaints_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/097_goldleaf_hotels_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "goldleaf-hotels:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-23", "issue": "pay-equity outlier", "matter_number": "CB-EL-3107", "owner": "Lena Varga", "portfolio_key": "CBP-077-12", "row_id": "REG-CBP-077-12", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/012_personnel_records_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/024_payroll_time_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/036_leave_accommodation_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/06_complaints/048_complaints_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/097_goldleaf_hotels_impact_population.xlsx"]}], "schema_version": "counselbench.matter-register.v3", "task_id": "cb100-077-goldleaf-hotels"}}, "metadata": {"benchmark": "CounselBench-100", "code_license": "Apache-2.0", "data_license": "CC-BY-4.0", "deadline": "2026-09-26", "document_count": 97, "evidence_holds": 4, "jurisdiction": "Nevada", "matter_number": "CB-EL-3107", "mcp_commit": "9a96ea6e5913736f92b88345bf51caeaaa8e719f", "mcp_package": "@modelcontextprotocol/server-filesystem@2026.7.10", "practice_area": "employment", "reference_tool_calls": 86, "required_evidence_reads": 60, "supported_actions": 8, "synthetic": true, "venue": "Nevada Equal Rights Commission", "version": "3.1.0"}, "prompt": "The other side has challenged our internal account of the facts. Was Goldleaf's response adequate, and which personnel actions create remediation or retaliation risk? A complaint moved among HR and operations while witness selection, schedule changes, training, and separation records diverged. The team needs the call by 2026-09-26. Leave a concise decision record with exact source references and an owner for each supported next step.", "rubric": {"criteria": [{"category": "investigation", "description": "Inventory the production and use targeted searches to locate records across native formats.", "id": "investigation.discover_production"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Complete every task-specific identity, authority, operations, and approval read before the first state transition.", "id": "investigation.read_before_write"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Inspect designated source metadata before relying on those records.", "id": "investigation.custody_before_write"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "Select the supported option 'goldleaf-hotels:scoped-evidence' after applying the four-part test.", "id": "decision.selected_option"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "Identify both rejected approaches and explain why a one-source shortcut and a blanket hold are wrong.", "id": "decision.alternatives"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-077-01 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/001_handbooks_policies_source_export.md rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-077-01.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/013_personnel_records_source_export.json for contractor control evidence.", "id": "investigation.CBP-077-01.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/025_compensation_equity_source_export.md to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-077-01.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/037_leave_accommodation_source_export.json.", "id": "investigation.CBP-077-01.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-077-01 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-077-01.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-077-01 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-077-01.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-077-02 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/002_handbooks_policies_source_export.txt rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-077-02.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/014_personnel_records_source_export.xml for overtime calculation error.", "id": "investigation.CBP-077-02.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/026_compensation_equity_source_export.txt to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-077-02.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/038_leave_accommodation_source_export.xml.", "id": "investigation.CBP-077-02.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-077-02 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is the current observation does not meet the operative trigger.", "id": "decision.CBP-077-02.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-077-02 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-077-02.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-077-03 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/003_handbooks_policies_source_export.eml rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-077-03.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/015_personnel_records_source_export.html for complaint escalation gap.", "id": "investigation.CBP-077-03.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/027_compensation_equity_source_export.eml to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-077-03.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/039_leave_accommodation_source_export.html.", "id": "investigation.CBP-077-03.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-077-03 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-077-03.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-077-03 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-077-03.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-077-04 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/004_handbooks_policies_source_export.csv rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-077-04.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/016_personnel_records_source_export.pdf for restrictive-covenant conflict.", "id": "investigation.CBP-077-04.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/028_compensation_equity_source_export.csv to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-077-04.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/040_leave_accommodation_source_export.pdf.", "id": "investigation.CBP-077-04.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-077-04 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is the operational record relies on a superseded control revision.", "id": "decision.CBP-077-04.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-077-04 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-077-04.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-077-05 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/005_handbooks_policies_source_export.json rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-077-05.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/017_payroll_time_source_export.md for classification inconsistency.", "id": "investigation.CBP-077-05.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/029_compensation_equity_source_export.json to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-077-05.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_complaints/041_complaints_source_export.md.", "id": "investigation.CBP-077-05.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-077-05 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-077-05.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-077-05 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-077-05.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-077-06 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/006_handbooks_policies_source_export.xml rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-077-06.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/018_payroll_time_source_export.txt for interactive-process lapse.", "id": "investigation.CBP-077-06.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/030_compensation_equity_source_export.xml to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-077-06.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_complaints/042_complaints_source_export.txt.", "id": "investigation.CBP-077-06.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-077-06 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-077-06.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-077-06 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-077-06.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-077-07 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/007_handbooks_policies_source_export.html rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-077-07.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/019_payroll_time_source_export.eml for separation pay discrepancy.", "id": "investigation.CBP-077-07.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/031_compensation_equity_source_export.html to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-077-07.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_complaints/043_complaints_source_export.eml.", "id": "investigation.CBP-077-07.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-077-07 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-077-07.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-077-07 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-077-07.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-077-08 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/008_handbooks_policies_source_export.pdf rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-077-08.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/020_payroll_time_source_export.csv for agency response commitment.", "id": "investigation.CBP-077-08.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/032_compensation_equity_source_export.pdf to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-077-08.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_complaints/044_complaints_source_export.csv.", "id": "investigation.CBP-077-08.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-077-08 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is the operational record relies on a superseded control revision.", "id": "decision.CBP-077-08.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-077-08 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-077-08.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-077-09 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/009_personnel_records_source_export.md rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-077-09.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/021_payroll_time_source_export.json for leave designation delay.", "id": "investigation.CBP-077-09.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/033_leave_accommodation_source_export.md to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-077-09.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_complaints/045_complaints_source_export.json.", "id": "investigation.CBP-077-09.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-077-09 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key.", "id": "decision.CBP-077-09.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-077-09 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-077-09.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-077-10 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/010_personnel_records_source_export.txt rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-077-10.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/022_payroll_time_source_export.xml for retaliation timing.", "id": "investigation.CBP-077-10.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/034_leave_accommodation_source_export.txt to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-077-10.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_complaints/046_complaints_source_export.xml.", "id": "investigation.CBP-077-10.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-077-10 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-077-10.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-077-10 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-077-10.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-077-11 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/011_personnel_records_source_export.eml rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-077-11.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/023_payroll_time_source_export.html for personnel-file access deadline.", "id": "investigation.CBP-077-11.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/035_leave_accommodation_source_export.eml to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-077-11.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_complaints/047_complaints_source_export.html.", "id": "investigation.CBP-077-11.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-077-11 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-077-11.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-077-11 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-077-11.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-077-12 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/012_personnel_records_source_export.csv rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-077-12.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/024_payroll_time_source_export.pdf for pay-equity outlier.", "id": "investigation.CBP-077-12.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/036_leave_accommodation_source_export.csv to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-077-12.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_complaints/048_complaints_source_export.pdf.", "id": "investigation.CBP-077-12.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-077-12 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-077-12.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-077-12 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-077-12.register"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Write the exact selected option, supported action population, evidence-hold population, facts, owners, deadlines, and citations.", "id": "state.exact_decision"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create one exact register row per portfolio key with no extra, missing, or modified row.", "id": "state.exact_register"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Leave only the three approved deliverables and perform no extra state-changing write.", "id": "state.write_scope_containment"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Read back decision.json, matter-register.json, and advice.md after their final writes.", "id": "state.postwrite_readback"}, {"category": "answer", "description": "Explain the selected recommendation, supported actions, holds, alternatives, and limitations with exact source anchors.", "id": "answer.decision_note"}], "decision_options": [{"approach": "Use a plausible summary or one source without completing the controlling joins.", "id": "goldleaf-hotels:shortcut", "label": "Assume any later schedule or separation change proves retaliation."}, {"approach": "Treat supported actions and genuinely ambiguous records as if they were equally unresolved.", "id": "goldleaf-hotels:blanket-hold", "label": "Freeze the entire matter population"}, {"approach": "Apply the exact identity, current-state, authority, and revision test. Create process and personnel-event rows with distinct evidentiary dispositions.", "id": "goldleaf-hotels:scoped-evidence", "label": "Repair supported investigation gaps and escalate corroborated retaliation indicators."}], "evaluation_narrative": {"authority": "Investigation integrity and anti-retaliation controls require independent process and supported causal evidence.", "observation": "Join complaint routing, witnesses, schedules, training, findings, and separation decisions by actor and date.", "question": "Was Goldleaf's response adequate, and which personnel actions create remediation or retaliation risk?", "register_action": "Create process and personnel-event rows with distinct evidentiary dispositions."}, "gates": ["all_required_evidence_precedes_first_write", "decision_criteria_complete", "register_state_exact", "write_scope_contained", "all_outputs_verified_by_readback"], "metadata_checks": 10, "metric": "weighted_criteria_score", "minimum_tool_calls": 86, "required_deliverables": ["decision.json", "matter-register.json", "advice.md"], "required_document_reads": 60, "type": "deterministic", "weights": {"advice": 0.15, "decision": 0.35, "investigation": 0.25, "state": 0.25}}, "task_id": "cb100-077-goldleaf-hotels", "task_name": "Goldleaf harassment response audit", "world_id": "counselbench-filesystem-mcp-v3"}
+{"context_files": ["task_files/cb100-078-harbor-transit/01_handbooks_policies/001_handbooks_policies_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-078-harbor-transit/01_handbooks_policies/002_handbooks_policies_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-078-harbor-transit/01_handbooks_policies/003_handbooks_policies_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-078-harbor-transit/01_handbooks_policies/004_handbooks_policies_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-078-harbor-transit/01_handbooks_policies/005_handbooks_policies_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-078-harbor-transit/01_handbooks_policies/006_handbooks_policies_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-078-harbor-transit/01_handbooks_policies/007_handbooks_policies_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-078-harbor-transit/01_handbooks_policies/008_handbooks_policies_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-078-harbor-transit/02_personnel_records/009_personnel_records_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-078-harbor-transit/02_personnel_records/010_personnel_records_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-078-harbor-transit/02_personnel_records/011_personnel_records_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-078-harbor-transit/02_personnel_records/012_personnel_records_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-078-harbor-transit/02_personnel_records/013_personnel_records_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-078-harbor-transit/02_personnel_records/014_personnel_records_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-078-harbor-transit/02_personnel_records/015_personnel_records_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-078-harbor-transit/02_personnel_records/016_personnel_records_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-078-harbor-transit/03_payroll_time/017_payroll_time_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-078-harbor-transit/03_payroll_time/018_payroll_time_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-078-harbor-transit/03_payroll_time/019_payroll_time_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-078-harbor-transit/03_payroll_time/020_payroll_time_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-078-harbor-transit/03_payroll_time/021_payroll_time_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-078-harbor-transit/03_payroll_time/022_payroll_time_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-078-harbor-transit/03_payroll_time/023_payroll_time_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-078-harbor-transit/03_payroll_time/024_payroll_time_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-078-harbor-transit/04_compensation_equity/025_compensation_equity_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-078-harbor-transit/04_compensation_equity/026_compensation_equity_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-078-harbor-transit/04_compensation_equity/027_compensation_equity_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-078-harbor-transit/04_compensation_equity/028_compensation_equity_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-078-harbor-transit/04_compensation_equity/029_compensation_equity_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-078-harbor-transit/04_compensation_equity/030_compensation_equity_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-078-harbor-transit/04_compensation_equity/031_compensation_equity_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-078-harbor-transit/04_compensation_equity/032_compensation_equity_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-078-harbor-transit/05_leave_accommodation/033_leave_accommodation_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-078-harbor-transit/05_leave_accommodation/034_leave_accommodation_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-078-harbor-transit/05_leave_accommodation/035_leave_accommodation_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-078-harbor-transit/05_leave_accommodation/036_leave_accommodation_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-078-harbor-transit/05_leave_accommodation/037_leave_accommodation_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-078-harbor-transit/05_leave_accommodation/038_leave_accommodation_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-078-harbor-transit/05_leave_accommodation/039_leave_accommodation_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-078-harbor-transit/05_leave_accommodation/040_leave_accommodation_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-078-harbor-transit/06_complaints/041_complaints_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-078-harbor-transit/06_complaints/042_complaints_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-078-harbor-transit/06_complaints/043_complaints_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-078-harbor-transit/06_complaints/044_complaints_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-078-harbor-transit/06_complaints/045_complaints_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-078-harbor-transit/06_complaints/046_complaints_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-078-harbor-transit/06_complaints/047_complaints_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-078-harbor-transit/06_complaints/048_complaints_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-078-harbor-transit/07_investigations/049_investigations_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-078-harbor-transit/07_investigations/050_investigations_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-078-harbor-transit/07_investigations/051_investigations_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-078-harbor-transit/07_investigations/052_investigations_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-078-harbor-transit/07_investigations/053_investigations_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-078-harbor-transit/07_investigations/054_investigations_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-078-harbor-transit/07_investigations/055_investigations_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-078-harbor-transit/07_investigations/056_investigations_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-078-harbor-transit/08_performance_discipline/057_performance_discipline_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-078-harbor-transit/08_performance_discipline/058_performance_discipline_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-078-harbor-transit/08_performance_discipline/059_performance_discipline_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-078-harbor-transit/08_performance_discipline/060_performance_discipline_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-078-harbor-transit/08_performance_discipline/061_performance_discipline_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-078-harbor-transit/08_performance_discipline/062_performance_discipline_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-078-harbor-transit/08_performance_discipline/063_performance_discipline_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-078-harbor-transit/08_performance_discipline/064_performance_discipline_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-078-harbor-transit/09_separation/065_separation_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-078-harbor-transit/09_separation/066_separation_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-078-harbor-transit/09_separation/067_separation_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-078-harbor-transit/09_separation/068_separation_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-078-harbor-transit/09_separation/069_separation_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-078-harbor-transit/09_separation/070_separation_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-078-harbor-transit/09_separation/071_separation_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-078-harbor-transit/09_separation/072_separation_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-078-harbor-transit/10_contractors/073_contractors_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-078-harbor-transit/10_contractors/074_contractors_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-078-harbor-transit/10_contractors/075_contractors_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-078-harbor-transit/10_contractors/076_contractors_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-078-harbor-transit/10_contractors/077_contractors_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-078-harbor-transit/10_contractors/078_contractors_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-078-harbor-transit/10_contractors/079_contractors_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-078-harbor-transit/10_contractors/080_contractors_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-078-harbor-transit/11_training/081_training_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-078-harbor-transit/11_training/082_training_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-078-harbor-transit/11_training/083_training_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-078-harbor-transit/11_training/084_training_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-078-harbor-transit/11_training/085_training_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-078-harbor-transit/11_training/086_training_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-078-harbor-transit/11_training/087_training_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-078-harbor-transit/11_training/088_training_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-078-harbor-transit/12_agency_matters/089_agency_matters_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-078-harbor-transit/12_agency_matters/090_agency_matters_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-078-harbor-transit/12_agency_matters/091_agency_matters_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-078-harbor-transit/12_agency_matters/092_agency_matters_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-078-harbor-transit/12_agency_matters/093_agency_matters_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-078-harbor-transit/12_agency_matters/094_agency_matters_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-078-harbor-transit/12_agency_matters/095_agency_matters_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-078-harbor-transit/12_agency_matters/096_agency_matters_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-078-harbor-transit/12_agency_matters/097_harbor_transit_impact_population.xlsx"], "gold_output": {"advice_markdown": "# Decision note — Harbor Transit leave compliance review\n\n## Recommendation\n\nReverse supported points, correct pay, and retain valid fitness controls. The reconciled record supports 8 scoped actions and leaves 4 items on evidence hold.\n\nSelected option: `harbor-transit:scoped-evidence`.\n\n## Why this is the supported option\n\nReconcile leave approvals, absences, hours, overtime, fitness releases, and attendance points by employee and date. Leave and wage rules govern exact approved periods and worked time; safety clearance remains separate.\n\n## Supported actions\n\n### CBP-078-01 — training completion gap (low)\n\nthe controlling threshold is 13% under CB-EL-3108-R502; the independently calculated result is 18% under CB-EL-3108-E176. Identity resolves to ENT-078-1000, revision REV-2026.1 is current, and Farah Ibrahim is active with capacity 6.\n\nAction: Create employee-date rows with separate leave, pay, and safety outcomes. Owner: Farah Ibrahim; due 2026-09-29.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/001_handbooks_policies_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/013_personnel_records_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/025_compensation_equity_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/037_leave_accommodation_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/07_investigations/049_investigations_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/097_harbor_transit_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-078-02 — meal-period premium gap (critical)\n\napproval must come from Mei Whitaker under CB-EL-3108-R450; the effective approval record names Henry Cho under CB-EL-3108-E332. Identity resolves to ENT-078-1001, revision REV-2026.2 is current, and Dominic Alvarez is active with capacity 3.\n\nAction: Create employee-date rows with separate leave, pay, and safety outcomes. Owner: Dominic Alvarez; due 2026-09-28.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/002_handbooks_policies_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/014_personnel_records_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/026_compensation_equity_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/038_leave_accommodation_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/07_investigations/050_investigations_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/097_harbor_transit_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-078-06 — complaint escalation gap (medium)\n\ndelivery must use notices-harbor_regional_transit@example.test under CB-EL-3108-R848; the only matched receipt used archive-maintenance_employee_group@example.test under CB-EL-3108-E461. Identity resolves to ENT-078-1005, revision REV-2026.6 is current, and Jonas Feld is active with capacity 2.\n\nAction: Create employee-date rows with separate leave, pay, and safety outcomes. Owner: Jonas Feld; due 2026-09-24.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/006_handbooks_policies_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/018_payroll_time_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/030_compensation_equity_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/06_complaints/042_complaints_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/097_harbor_transit_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-078-07 — restrictive-covenant conflict (medium)\n\nan open exception blocks completion under CB-EL-3108-R197; the current status is open and unresolved under CB-EL-3108-E741. Identity resolves to ENT-078-1006, revision REV-2026.7 is current, and Willa Novak is active with capacity 3.\n\nAction: Create employee-date rows with separate leave, pay, and safety outcomes. Owner: Willa Novak; due 2026-09-23.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/007_handbooks_policies_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/019_payroll_time_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/031_compensation_equity_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/06_complaints/043_complaints_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/09_separation/067_separation_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/10_contractors/079_contractors_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/097_harbor_transit_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-078-08 — classification inconsistency (medium)\n\ncompletion is required by 2025-12-15 under CB-EL-3108-R863; the current event record shows completion on 2025-12-24 under CB-EL-3108-E886. Identity resolves to ENT-078-1007, revision REV-2026.1 is current, and Owen Delgado is active with capacity 6.\n\nAction: Create employee-date rows with separate leave, pay, and safety outcomes. Owner: Owen Delgado; due 2026-09-22.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/008_handbooks_policies_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/020_payroll_time_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/032_compensation_equity_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/06_complaints/044_complaints_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/092_agency_matters_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/097_harbor_transit_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-078-09 — interactive-process lapse (medium)\n\nthe controlling threshold is 10% under CB-EL-3108-R223; the independently calculated result is 12% under CB-EL-3108-E477. Identity resolves to ENT-078-1008, revision REV-2026.2 is current, and Priya Raman is active with capacity 4.\n\nAction: Create employee-date rows with separate leave, pay, and safety outcomes. Owner: Priya Raman; due 2026-09-21.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/009_personnel_records_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/021_payroll_time_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/033_leave_accommodation_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/06_complaints/045_complaints_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/09_separation/069_separation_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/097_harbor_transit_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-078-10 — separation pay discrepancy (low)\n\napproval must come from Mei Whitaker under CB-EL-3108-R734; the effective approval record names Caleb Hassan under CB-EL-3108-E454. Identity resolves to ENT-078-1009, revision REV-2026.3 is current, and Isaac Romero is active with capacity 6.\n\nAction: Create employee-date rows with separate leave, pay, and safety outcomes. Owner: Isaac Romero; due 2026-09-29.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/010_personnel_records_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/022_payroll_time_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/034_leave_accommodation_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/06_complaints/046_complaints_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/097_harbor_transit_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-078-11 — agency response commitment (critical)\n\nthe controlled population contains 138 records under CB-EL-3108-R796; the certification covers 106 records under CB-EL-3108-E193. Identity resolves to ENT-078-1010, revision REV-2026.4 is current, and Nadine Flores is active with capacity 1.\n\nAction: Create employee-date rows with separate leave, pay, and safety outcomes. Owner: Nadine Flores; due 2026-09-28.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/011_personnel_records_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/023_payroll_time_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/035_leave_accommodation_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/06_complaints/047_complaints_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/11_training/083_training_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/095_agency_matters_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/097_harbor_transit_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n## Evidence holds\n\n- **CBP-078-03 — investigation independence concern**: the operational record relies on a superseded control revision. Next evidence: an operational record using the current effective revision. Sources: `/workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/003_handbooks_policies_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/015_personnel_records_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/027_compensation_equity_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/039_leave_accommodation_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/11_training/087_training_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/097_harbor_transit_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-078-04 — contractor control evidence**: two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key. Next evidence: an approved immutable entity crosswalk. Sources: `/workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/004_handbooks_policies_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/016_personnel_records_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/028_compensation_equity_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/040_leave_accommodation_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/08_performance_discipline/064_performance_discipline_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/07_investigations/052_investigations_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/097_harbor_transit_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-078-05 — overtime calculation error**: the current observation does not meet the operative trigger. Next evidence: a current observation that satisfies the operative trigger. Sources: `/workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/005_handbooks_policies_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/017_payroll_time_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/029_compensation_equity_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/06_complaints/041_complaints_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/097_harbor_transit_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-078-12 — leave designation delay**: two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key. Next evidence: an approved immutable entity crosswalk. Sources: `/workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/012_personnel_records_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/024_payroll_time_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/036_leave_accommodation_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/06_complaints/048_complaints_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/08_performance_discipline/060_performance_discipline_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/097_harbor_transit_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n## Alternatives considered\n\n- `harbor-transit:blanket-hold` — Freeze the entire matter population: Treat supported actions and genuinely ambiguous records as if they were equally unresolved.\n- `harbor-transit:shortcut` — Erase every attendance point and fitness condition for anyone with intermittent leave.: Use a plausible summary or one source without completing the controlling joins.\n\n## Assumptions and limits\n\nThis decision is limited to cb100-078-harbor-transit, the supplied synthetic records, and the matter state as of 2026-09-30. Similar names, stale revisions, and pending authority are not treated as proof.\n", "decision": {"actions": [{"determination": "the controlling threshold is 13% under CB-EL-3108-R502; the independently calculated result is 18% under CB-EL-3108-E176. Identity resolves to ENT-078-1000, revision REV-2026.1 is current, and Farah Ibrahim is active with capacity 6.", "due_date": "2026-09-29", "id": "ACT-CBP-078-01", "identity_id": "ENT-078-1000", "issue": "training completion gap", "owner": "Farah Ibrahim", "portfolio_key": "CBP-078-01", "recommended_action": "Create employee-date rows with separate leave, pay, and safety outcomes. Owner: Farah Ibrahim; due 2026-09-29.", "severity": "low", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/001_handbooks_policies_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/013_personnel_records_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/025_compensation_equity_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/037_leave_accommodation_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/07_investigations/049_investigations_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/097_harbor_transit_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "approval must come from Mei Whitaker under CB-EL-3108-R450; the effective approval record names Henry Cho under CB-EL-3108-E332. Identity resolves to ENT-078-1001, revision REV-2026.2 is current, and Dominic Alvarez is active with capacity 3.", "due_date": "2026-09-28", "id": "ACT-CBP-078-02", "identity_id": "ENT-078-1001", "issue": "meal-period premium gap", "owner": "Dominic Alvarez", "portfolio_key": "CBP-078-02", "recommended_action": "Create employee-date rows with separate leave, pay, and safety outcomes. Owner: Dominic Alvarez; due 2026-09-28.", "severity": "critical", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/002_handbooks_policies_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/014_personnel_records_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/026_compensation_equity_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/038_leave_accommodation_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/07_investigations/050_investigations_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/097_harbor_transit_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "delivery must use notices-harbor_regional_transit@example.test under CB-EL-3108-R848; the only matched receipt used archive-maintenance_employee_group@example.test under CB-EL-3108-E461. Identity resolves to ENT-078-1005, revision REV-2026.6 is current, and Jonas Feld is active with capacity 2.", "due_date": "2026-09-24", "id": "ACT-CBP-078-06", "identity_id": "ENT-078-1005", "issue": "complaint escalation gap", "owner": "Jonas Feld", "portfolio_key": "CBP-078-06", "recommended_action": "Create employee-date rows with separate leave, pay, and safety outcomes. Owner: Jonas Feld; due 2026-09-24.", "severity": "medium", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/006_handbooks_policies_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/018_payroll_time_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/030_compensation_equity_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/06_complaints/042_complaints_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/097_harbor_transit_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "an open exception blocks completion under CB-EL-3108-R197; the current status is open and unresolved under CB-EL-3108-E741. Identity resolves to ENT-078-1006, revision REV-2026.7 is current, and Willa Novak is active with capacity 3.", "due_date": "2026-09-23", "id": "ACT-CBP-078-07", "identity_id": "ENT-078-1006", "issue": "restrictive-covenant conflict", "owner": "Willa Novak", "portfolio_key": "CBP-078-07", "recommended_action": "Create employee-date rows with separate leave, pay, and safety outcomes. Owner: Willa Novak; due 2026-09-23.", "severity": "medium", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/007_handbooks_policies_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/019_payroll_time_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/031_compensation_equity_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/06_complaints/043_complaints_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/09_separation/067_separation_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/10_contractors/079_contractors_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/097_harbor_transit_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "completion is required by 2025-12-15 under CB-EL-3108-R863; the current event record shows completion on 2025-12-24 under CB-EL-3108-E886. Identity resolves to ENT-078-1007, revision REV-2026.1 is current, and Owen Delgado is active with capacity 6.", "due_date": "2026-09-22", "id": "ACT-CBP-078-08", "identity_id": "ENT-078-1007", "issue": "classification inconsistency", "owner": "Owen Delgado", "portfolio_key": "CBP-078-08", "recommended_action": "Create employee-date rows with separate leave, pay, and safety outcomes. Owner: Owen Delgado; due 2026-09-22.", "severity": "medium", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/008_handbooks_policies_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/020_payroll_time_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/032_compensation_equity_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/06_complaints/044_complaints_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/092_agency_matters_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/097_harbor_transit_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "the controlling threshold is 10% under CB-EL-3108-R223; the independently calculated result is 12% under CB-EL-3108-E477. Identity resolves to ENT-078-1008, revision REV-2026.2 is current, and Priya Raman is active with capacity 4.", "due_date": "2026-09-21", "id": "ACT-CBP-078-09", "identity_id": "ENT-078-1008", "issue": "interactive-process lapse", "owner": "Priya Raman", "portfolio_key": "CBP-078-09", "recommended_action": "Create employee-date rows with separate leave, pay, and safety outcomes. Owner: Priya Raman; due 2026-09-21.", "severity": "medium", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/009_personnel_records_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/021_payroll_time_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/033_leave_accommodation_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/06_complaints/045_complaints_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/09_separation/069_separation_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/097_harbor_transit_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "approval must come from Mei Whitaker under CB-EL-3108-R734; the effective approval record names Caleb Hassan under CB-EL-3108-E454. Identity resolves to ENT-078-1009, revision REV-2026.3 is current, and Isaac Romero is active with capacity 6.", "due_date": "2026-09-29", "id": "ACT-CBP-078-10", "identity_id": "ENT-078-1009", "issue": "separation pay discrepancy", "owner": "Isaac Romero", "portfolio_key": "CBP-078-10", "recommended_action": "Create employee-date rows with separate leave, pay, and safety outcomes. Owner: Isaac Romero; due 2026-09-29.", "severity": "low", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/010_personnel_records_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/022_payroll_time_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/034_leave_accommodation_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/06_complaints/046_complaints_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/097_harbor_transit_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "the controlled population contains 138 records under CB-EL-3108-R796; the certification covers 106 records under CB-EL-3108-E193. Identity resolves to ENT-078-1010, revision REV-2026.4 is current, and Nadine Flores is active with capacity 1.", "due_date": "2026-09-28", "id": "ACT-CBP-078-11", "identity_id": "ENT-078-1010", "issue": "agency response commitment", "owner": "Nadine Flores", "portfolio_key": "CBP-078-11", "recommended_action": "Create employee-date rows with separate leave, pay, and safety outcomes. Owner: Nadine Flores; due 2026-09-28.", "severity": "critical", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/011_personnel_records_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/023_payroll_time_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/035_leave_accommodation_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/06_complaints/047_complaints_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/11_training/083_training_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/095_agency_matters_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/097_harbor_transit_impact_population.xlsx"]}], "as_of": "2026-09-30", "decision": {"alternatives_considered": ["harbor-transit:blanket-hold", "harbor-transit:shortcut"], "question": "Which Harbor Transit attendance points, overtime, or fitness requirements must be corrected?", "rationale": "The four-part causal test supports 8 scoped actions and leaves 4 records on evidence hold. Leave and wage rules govern exact approved periods and worked time; safety clearance remains separate.", "recommendation": "Reverse supported points, correct pay, and retain valid fitness controls.", "selected_option_id": "harbor-transit:scoped-evidence"}, "holds": [{"id": "HOLD-CBP-078-03", "issue": "investigation independence concern", "portfolio_key": "CBP-078-03", "reason": "the operational record relies on a superseded control revision", "required_next_evidence": "an operational record using the current effective revision", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/003_handbooks_policies_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/015_personnel_records_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/027_compensation_equity_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/039_leave_accommodation_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/11_training/087_training_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/097_harbor_transit_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-078-04", "issue": "contractor control evidence", "portfolio_key": "CBP-078-04", "reason": "two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key", "required_next_evidence": "an approved immutable entity crosswalk", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/004_handbooks_policies_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/016_personnel_records_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/028_compensation_equity_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/040_leave_accommodation_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/08_performance_discipline/064_performance_discipline_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/07_investigations/052_investigations_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/097_harbor_transit_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-078-05", "issue": "overtime calculation error", "portfolio_key": "CBP-078-05", "reason": "the current observation does not meet the operative trigger", "required_next_evidence": "a current observation that satisfies the operative trigger", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/005_handbooks_policies_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/017_payroll_time_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/029_compensation_equity_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/06_complaints/041_complaints_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/097_harbor_transit_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-078-12", "issue": "leave designation delay", "portfolio_key": "CBP-078-12", "reason": "two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key", "required_next_evidence": "an approved immutable entity crosswalk", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/012_personnel_records_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/024_payroll_time_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/036_leave_accommodation_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/06_complaints/048_complaints_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/08_performance_discipline/060_performance_discipline_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/097_harbor_transit_impact_population.xlsx"]}], "matter_number": "CB-EL-3108", "prepared_for": "Harbor Regional Transit", "schema_version": "counselbench.decision.v3", "task_id": "cb100-078-harbor-transit"}, "matter_register": {"matter_number": "CB-EL-3108", "rows": [{"decision_option_id": "harbor-transit:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-29", "issue": "training completion gap", "matter_number": "CB-EL-3108", "owner": "Farah Ibrahim", "portfolio_key": "CBP-078-01", "row_id": "REG-CBP-078-01", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/001_handbooks_policies_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/013_personnel_records_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/025_compensation_equity_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/037_leave_accommodation_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/07_investigations/049_investigations_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/097_harbor_transit_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "harbor-transit:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-28", "issue": "meal-period premium gap", "matter_number": "CB-EL-3108", "owner": "Dominic Alvarez", "portfolio_key": "CBP-078-02", "row_id": "REG-CBP-078-02", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/002_handbooks_policies_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/014_personnel_records_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/026_compensation_equity_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/038_leave_accommodation_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/07_investigations/050_investigations_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/097_harbor_transit_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "harbor-transit:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "the operational record relies on a superseded control revision", "issue": "investigation independence concern", "matter_number": "CB-EL-3108", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-078-03", "row_id": "REG-CBP-078-03", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/003_handbooks_policies_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/015_personnel_records_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/027_compensation_equity_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/039_leave_accommodation_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/11_training/087_training_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/097_harbor_transit_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "harbor-transit:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key", "issue": "contractor control evidence", "matter_number": "CB-EL-3108", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-078-04", "row_id": "REG-CBP-078-04", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/004_handbooks_policies_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/016_personnel_records_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/028_compensation_equity_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/040_leave_accommodation_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/08_performance_discipline/064_performance_discipline_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/07_investigations/052_investigations_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/097_harbor_transit_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "harbor-transit:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "the current observation does not meet the operative trigger", "issue": "overtime calculation error", "matter_number": "CB-EL-3108", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-078-05", "row_id": "REG-CBP-078-05", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/005_handbooks_policies_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/017_payroll_time_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/029_compensation_equity_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/06_complaints/041_complaints_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/097_harbor_transit_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "harbor-transit:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-24", "issue": "complaint escalation gap", "matter_number": "CB-EL-3108", "owner": "Jonas Feld", "portfolio_key": "CBP-078-06", "row_id": "REG-CBP-078-06", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/006_handbooks_policies_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/018_payroll_time_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/030_compensation_equity_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/06_complaints/042_complaints_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/097_harbor_transit_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "harbor-transit:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-23", "issue": "restrictive-covenant conflict", "matter_number": "CB-EL-3108", "owner": "Willa Novak", "portfolio_key": "CBP-078-07", "row_id": "REG-CBP-078-07", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/007_handbooks_policies_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/019_payroll_time_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/031_compensation_equity_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/06_complaints/043_complaints_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/09_separation/067_separation_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/10_contractors/079_contractors_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/097_harbor_transit_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "harbor-transit:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-22", "issue": "classification inconsistency", "matter_number": "CB-EL-3108", "owner": "Owen Delgado", "portfolio_key": "CBP-078-08", "row_id": "REG-CBP-078-08", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/008_handbooks_policies_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/020_payroll_time_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/032_compensation_equity_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/06_complaints/044_complaints_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/092_agency_matters_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/097_harbor_transit_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "harbor-transit:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-21", "issue": "interactive-process lapse", "matter_number": "CB-EL-3108", "owner": "Priya Raman", "portfolio_key": "CBP-078-09", "row_id": "REG-CBP-078-09", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/009_personnel_records_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/021_payroll_time_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/033_leave_accommodation_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/06_complaints/045_complaints_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/09_separation/069_separation_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/097_harbor_transit_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "harbor-transit:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-29", "issue": "separation pay discrepancy", "matter_number": "CB-EL-3108", "owner": "Isaac Romero", "portfolio_key": "CBP-078-10", "row_id": "REG-CBP-078-10", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/010_personnel_records_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/022_payroll_time_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/034_leave_accommodation_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/06_complaints/046_complaints_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/097_harbor_transit_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "harbor-transit:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-28", "issue": "agency response commitment", "matter_number": "CB-EL-3108", "owner": "Nadine Flores", "portfolio_key": "CBP-078-11", "row_id": "REG-CBP-078-11", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/011_personnel_records_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/023_payroll_time_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/035_leave_accommodation_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/06_complaints/047_complaints_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/11_training/083_training_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/095_agency_matters_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/097_harbor_transit_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "harbor-transit:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key", "issue": "leave designation delay", "matter_number": "CB-EL-3108", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-078-12", "row_id": "REG-CBP-078-12", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/012_personnel_records_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/024_payroll_time_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/036_leave_accommodation_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/06_complaints/048_complaints_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/08_performance_discipline/060_performance_discipline_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/097_harbor_transit_impact_population.xlsx"]}], "schema_version": "counselbench.matter-register.v3", "task_id": "cb100-078-harbor-transit"}}, "metadata": {"benchmark": "CounselBench-100", "code_license": "Apache-2.0", "data_license": "CC-BY-4.0", "deadline": "2026-09-30", "document_count": 97, "evidence_holds": 4, "jurisdiction": "Oregon", "matter_number": "CB-EL-3108", "mcp_commit": "9a96ea6e5913736f92b88345bf51caeaaa8e719f", "mcp_package": "@modelcontextprotocol/server-filesystem@2026.7.10", "practice_area": "employment", "reference_tool_calls": 84, "required_evidence_reads": 62, "supported_actions": 8, "synthetic": true, "venue": "Oregon Bureau of Labor and Industries", "version": "3.1.0"}, "prompt": "There is enough noise in this file that a name match or newest-document shortcut will be dangerous. Which Harbor Transit attendance points, overtime, or fitness requirements must be corrected? Intermittent leave, overtime, fitness-for-duty, and attendance points were administered inconsistently across systems. The team needs the call by 2026-09-30. Leave the defensible result in the matter workspace, including any item that must stay on hold for better evidence.", "rubric": {"criteria": [{"category": "investigation", "description": "Inventory the production and use targeted searches to locate records across native formats.", "id": "investigation.discover_production"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Complete every task-specific identity, authority, operations, and approval read before the first state transition.", "id": "investigation.read_before_write"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Inspect designated source metadata before relying on those records.", "id": "investigation.custody_before_write"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "Select the supported option 'harbor-transit:scoped-evidence' after applying the four-part test.", "id": "decision.selected_option"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "Identify both rejected approaches and explain why a one-source shortcut and a blanket hold are wrong.", "id": "decision.alternatives"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-078-01 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/001_handbooks_policies_source_export.md rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-078-01.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/013_personnel_records_source_export.json for training completion gap.", "id": "investigation.CBP-078-01.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/025_compensation_equity_source_export.md to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-078-01.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/037_leave_accommodation_source_export.json.", "id": "investigation.CBP-078-01.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-078-01 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-078-01.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-078-01 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-078-01.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-078-02 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/002_handbooks_policies_source_export.txt rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-078-02.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/014_personnel_records_source_export.xml for meal-period premium gap.", "id": "investigation.CBP-078-02.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/026_compensation_equity_source_export.txt to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-078-02.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/038_leave_accommodation_source_export.xml.", "id": "investigation.CBP-078-02.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-078-02 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-078-02.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-078-02 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-078-02.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-078-03 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/003_handbooks_policies_source_export.eml rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-078-03.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/015_personnel_records_source_export.html for investigation independence concern.", "id": "investigation.CBP-078-03.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/027_compensation_equity_source_export.eml to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-078-03.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/039_leave_accommodation_source_export.html.", "id": "investigation.CBP-078-03.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-078-03 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is the operational record relies on a superseded control revision.", "id": "decision.CBP-078-03.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-078-03 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-078-03.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-078-04 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/004_handbooks_policies_source_export.csv rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-078-04.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/016_personnel_records_source_export.pdf for contractor control evidence.", "id": "investigation.CBP-078-04.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/028_compensation_equity_source_export.csv to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-078-04.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/040_leave_accommodation_source_export.pdf.", "id": "investigation.CBP-078-04.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-078-04 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key.", "id": "decision.CBP-078-04.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-078-04 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-078-04.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-078-05 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/005_handbooks_policies_source_export.json rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-078-05.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/017_payroll_time_source_export.md for overtime calculation error.", "id": "investigation.CBP-078-05.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/029_compensation_equity_source_export.json to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-078-05.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_complaints/041_complaints_source_export.md.", "id": "investigation.CBP-078-05.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-078-05 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is the current observation does not meet the operative trigger.", "id": "decision.CBP-078-05.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-078-05 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-078-05.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-078-06 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/006_handbooks_policies_source_export.xml rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-078-06.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/018_payroll_time_source_export.txt for complaint escalation gap.", "id": "investigation.CBP-078-06.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/030_compensation_equity_source_export.xml to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-078-06.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_complaints/042_complaints_source_export.txt.", "id": "investigation.CBP-078-06.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-078-06 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-078-06.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-078-06 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-078-06.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-078-07 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/007_handbooks_policies_source_export.html rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-078-07.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/019_payroll_time_source_export.eml for restrictive-covenant conflict.", "id": "investigation.CBP-078-07.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/031_compensation_equity_source_export.html to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-078-07.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_complaints/043_complaints_source_export.eml.", "id": "investigation.CBP-078-07.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-078-07 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-078-07.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-078-07 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-078-07.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-078-08 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/008_handbooks_policies_source_export.pdf rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-078-08.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/020_payroll_time_source_export.csv for classification inconsistency.", "id": "investigation.CBP-078-08.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/032_compensation_equity_source_export.pdf to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-078-08.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_complaints/044_complaints_source_export.csv.", "id": "investigation.CBP-078-08.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-078-08 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-078-08.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-078-08 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-078-08.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-078-09 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/009_personnel_records_source_export.md rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-078-09.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/021_payroll_time_source_export.json for interactive-process lapse.", "id": "investigation.CBP-078-09.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/033_leave_accommodation_source_export.md to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-078-09.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_complaints/045_complaints_source_export.json.", "id": "investigation.CBP-078-09.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-078-09 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-078-09.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-078-09 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-078-09.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-078-10 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/010_personnel_records_source_export.txt rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-078-10.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/022_payroll_time_source_export.xml for separation pay discrepancy.", "id": "investigation.CBP-078-10.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/034_leave_accommodation_source_export.txt to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-078-10.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_complaints/046_complaints_source_export.xml.", "id": "investigation.CBP-078-10.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-078-10 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-078-10.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-078-10 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-078-10.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-078-11 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/011_personnel_records_source_export.eml rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-078-11.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/023_payroll_time_source_export.html for agency response commitment.", "id": "investigation.CBP-078-11.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/035_leave_accommodation_source_export.eml to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-078-11.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_complaints/047_complaints_source_export.html.", "id": "investigation.CBP-078-11.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-078-11 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-078-11.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-078-11 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-078-11.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-078-12 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/012_personnel_records_source_export.csv rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-078-12.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/024_payroll_time_source_export.pdf for leave designation delay.", "id": "investigation.CBP-078-12.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/036_leave_accommodation_source_export.csv to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-078-12.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_complaints/048_complaints_source_export.pdf.", "id": "investigation.CBP-078-12.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-078-12 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key.", "id": "decision.CBP-078-12.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-078-12 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-078-12.register"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Write the exact selected option, supported action population, evidence-hold population, facts, owners, deadlines, and citations.", "id": "state.exact_decision"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create one exact register row per portfolio key with no extra, missing, or modified row.", "id": "state.exact_register"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Leave only the three approved deliverables and perform no extra state-changing write.", "id": "state.write_scope_containment"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Read back decision.json, matter-register.json, and advice.md after their final writes.", "id": "state.postwrite_readback"}, {"category": "answer", "description": "Explain the selected recommendation, supported actions, holds, alternatives, and limitations with exact source anchors.", "id": "answer.decision_note"}], "decision_options": [{"approach": "Treat supported actions and genuinely ambiguous records as if they were equally unresolved.", "id": "harbor-transit:blanket-hold", "label": "Freeze the entire matter population"}, {"approach": "Apply the exact identity, current-state, authority, and revision test. Create employee-date rows with separate leave, pay, and safety outcomes.", "id": "harbor-transit:scoped-evidence", "label": "Reverse supported points, correct pay, and retain valid fitness controls."}, {"approach": "Use a plausible summary or one source without completing the controlling joins.", "id": "harbor-transit:shortcut", "label": "Erase every attendance point and fitness condition for anyone with intermittent leave."}], "evaluation_narrative": {"authority": "Leave and wage rules govern exact approved periods and worked time; safety clearance remains separate.", "observation": "Reconcile leave approvals, absences, hours, overtime, fitness releases, and attendance points by employee and date.", "question": "Which Harbor Transit attendance points, overtime, or fitness requirements must be corrected?", "register_action": "Create employee-date rows with separate leave, pay, and safety outcomes."}, "gates": ["all_required_evidence_precedes_first_write", "decision_criteria_complete", "register_state_exact", "write_scope_contained", "all_outputs_verified_by_readback"], "metadata_checks": 9, "metric": "weighted_criteria_score", "minimum_tool_calls": 84, "required_deliverables": ["decision.json", "matter-register.json", "advice.md"], "required_document_reads": 62, "type": "deterministic", "weights": {"advice": 0.15, "decision": 0.35, "investigation": 0.25, "state": 0.25}}, "task_id": "cb100-078-harbor-transit", "task_name": "Harbor Transit leave compliance review", "world_id": "counselbench-filesystem-mcp-v3"}
+{"context_files": ["task_files/cb100-079-island-biologics/01_handbooks_policies/001_handbooks_policies_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-079-island-biologics/01_handbooks_policies/002_handbooks_policies_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-079-island-biologics/01_handbooks_policies/003_handbooks_policies_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-079-island-biologics/01_handbooks_policies/004_handbooks_policies_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-079-island-biologics/01_handbooks_policies/005_handbooks_policies_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-079-island-biologics/01_handbooks_policies/006_handbooks_policies_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-079-island-biologics/01_handbooks_policies/007_handbooks_policies_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-079-island-biologics/01_handbooks_policies/008_handbooks_policies_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-079-island-biologics/02_personnel_records/009_personnel_records_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-079-island-biologics/02_personnel_records/010_personnel_records_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-079-island-biologics/02_personnel_records/011_personnel_records_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-079-island-biologics/02_personnel_records/012_personnel_records_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-079-island-biologics/02_personnel_records/013_personnel_records_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-079-island-biologics/02_personnel_records/014_personnel_records_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-079-island-biologics/02_personnel_records/015_personnel_records_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-079-island-biologics/02_personnel_records/016_personnel_records_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-079-island-biologics/03_payroll_time/017_payroll_time_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-079-island-biologics/03_payroll_time/018_payroll_time_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-079-island-biologics/03_payroll_time/019_payroll_time_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-079-island-biologics/03_payroll_time/020_payroll_time_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-079-island-biologics/03_payroll_time/021_payroll_time_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-079-island-biologics/03_payroll_time/022_payroll_time_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-079-island-biologics/03_payroll_time/023_payroll_time_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-079-island-biologics/03_payroll_time/024_payroll_time_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-079-island-biologics/04_compensation_equity/025_compensation_equity_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-079-island-biologics/04_compensation_equity/026_compensation_equity_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-079-island-biologics/04_compensation_equity/027_compensation_equity_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-079-island-biologics/04_compensation_equity/028_compensation_equity_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-079-island-biologics/04_compensation_equity/029_compensation_equity_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-079-island-biologics/04_compensation_equity/030_compensation_equity_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-079-island-biologics/04_compensation_equity/031_compensation_equity_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-079-island-biologics/04_compensation_equity/032_compensation_equity_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-079-island-biologics/05_leave_accommodation/033_leave_accommodation_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-079-island-biologics/05_leave_accommodation/034_leave_accommodation_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-079-island-biologics/05_leave_accommodation/035_leave_accommodation_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-079-island-biologics/05_leave_accommodation/036_leave_accommodation_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-079-island-biologics/05_leave_accommodation/037_leave_accommodation_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-079-island-biologics/05_leave_accommodation/038_leave_accommodation_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-079-island-biologics/05_leave_accommodation/039_leave_accommodation_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-079-island-biologics/05_leave_accommodation/040_leave_accommodation_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-079-island-biologics/06_complaints/041_complaints_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-079-island-biologics/06_complaints/042_complaints_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-079-island-biologics/06_complaints/043_complaints_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-079-island-biologics/06_complaints/044_complaints_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-079-island-biologics/06_complaints/045_complaints_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-079-island-biologics/06_complaints/046_complaints_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-079-island-biologics/06_complaints/047_complaints_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-079-island-biologics/06_complaints/048_complaints_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-079-island-biologics/07_investigations/049_investigations_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-079-island-biologics/07_investigations/050_investigations_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-079-island-biologics/07_investigations/051_investigations_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-079-island-biologics/07_investigations/052_investigations_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-079-island-biologics/07_investigations/053_investigations_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-079-island-biologics/07_investigations/054_investigations_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-079-island-biologics/07_investigations/055_investigations_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-079-island-biologics/07_investigations/056_investigations_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-079-island-biologics/08_performance_discipline/057_performance_discipline_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-079-island-biologics/08_performance_discipline/058_performance_discipline_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-079-island-biologics/08_performance_discipline/059_performance_discipline_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-079-island-biologics/08_performance_discipline/060_performance_discipline_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-079-island-biologics/08_performance_discipline/061_performance_discipline_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-079-island-biologics/08_performance_discipline/062_performance_discipline_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-079-island-biologics/08_performance_discipline/063_performance_discipline_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-079-island-biologics/08_performance_discipline/064_performance_discipline_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-079-island-biologics/09_separation/065_separation_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-079-island-biologics/09_separation/066_separation_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-079-island-biologics/09_separation/067_separation_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-079-island-biologics/09_separation/068_separation_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-079-island-biologics/09_separation/069_separation_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-079-island-biologics/09_separation/070_separation_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-079-island-biologics/09_separation/071_separation_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-079-island-biologics/09_separation/072_separation_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-079-island-biologics/10_contractors/073_contractors_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-079-island-biologics/10_contractors/074_contractors_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-079-island-biologics/10_contractors/075_contractors_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-079-island-biologics/10_contractors/076_contractors_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-079-island-biologics/10_contractors/077_contractors_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-079-island-biologics/10_contractors/078_contractors_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-079-island-biologics/10_contractors/079_contractors_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-079-island-biologics/10_contractors/080_contractors_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-079-island-biologics/11_training/081_training_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-079-island-biologics/11_training/082_training_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-079-island-biologics/11_training/083_training_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-079-island-biologics/11_training/084_training_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-079-island-biologics/11_training/085_training_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-079-island-biologics/11_training/086_training_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-079-island-biologics/11_training/087_training_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-079-island-biologics/11_training/088_training_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-079-island-biologics/12_agency_matters/089_agency_matters_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-079-island-biologics/12_agency_matters/090_agency_matters_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-079-island-biologics/12_agency_matters/091_agency_matters_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-079-island-biologics/12_agency_matters/092_agency_matters_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-079-island-biologics/12_agency_matters/093_agency_matters_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-079-island-biologics/12_agency_matters/094_agency_matters_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-079-island-biologics/12_agency_matters/095_agency_matters_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-079-island-biologics/12_agency_matters/096_agency_matters_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-079-island-biologics/12_agency_matters/097_island_biologics_impact_population.xlsx"], "gold_output": {"advice_markdown": "# Decision note — Island Biologics separation audit\n\n## Recommendation\n\nPay or revise supported obligations and escalate corroborated retaliation risk. The reconciled record supports 7 scoped actions and leaves 5 items on evidence hold.\n\nSelected option: `island-biologics:scoped-evidence`.\n\n## Why this is the supported option\n\nJoin complaint knowledge, comparator discipline, incentive terms, restrictive covenant, and separation approvals. Payment and covenant duties follow operative agreements; retaliation requires supported knowledge and causation.\n\n## Supported actions\n\n### CBP-079-01 — personnel-file access deadline (low)\n\ndelivery must use notices-island_biologics_corp@example.test under CB-EL-3109-R383; the only matched receipt used archive-former_research_director@example.test under CB-EL-3109-E222. Identity resolves to ENT-079-1000, revision REV-2025.1 is current, and Samuel Kim is active with capacity 3.\n\nAction: Create obligation and decision-event rows with exact owners and holds. Owner: Samuel Kim; due 2026-10-02.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/001_handbooks_policies_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/013_personnel_records_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/025_compensation_equity_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/037_leave_accommodation_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/097_island_biologics_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-079-02 — pay-equity outlier (medium)\n\nan open exception blocks completion under CB-EL-3109-R396; the current status is open and unresolved under CB-EL-3109-E488. Identity resolves to ENT-079-1001, revision REV-2025.2 is current, and Talia Brooks is active with capacity 2.\n\nAction: Create obligation and decision-event rows with exact owners and holds. Owner: Talia Brooks; due 2026-10-01.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/002_handbooks_policies_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/014_personnel_records_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/026_compensation_equity_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/038_leave_accommodation_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/097_island_biologics_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-079-06 — investigation independence concern (medium)\n\nthe controlled population contains 72 records under CB-EL-3109-R720; the certification covers 36 records under CB-EL-3109-E560. Identity resolves to ENT-079-1005, revision REV-2025.6 is current, and Leona Park is active with capacity 6.\n\nAction: Create obligation and decision-event rows with exact owners and holds. Owner: Leona Park; due 2026-09-27.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/006_handbooks_policies_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/018_payroll_time_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/030_compensation_equity_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/06_complaints/042_complaints_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/097_island_biologics_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-079-07 — contractor control evidence (medium)\n\nthe permission is limited to Massachusetts Commission Against Discrimination under CB-EL-3109-R376; the matched activity occurred in Massachusetts under CB-EL-3109-E910. Identity resolves to ENT-079-1006, revision REV-2025.7 is current, and Henry Cho is active with capacity 4.\n\nAction: Create obligation and decision-event rows with exact owners and holds. Owner: Henry Cho; due 2026-09-26.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/007_handbooks_policies_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/019_payroll_time_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/031_compensation_equity_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/06_complaints/043_complaints_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/07_investigations/055_investigations_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/097_island_biologics_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-079-10 — restrictive-covenant conflict (critical)\n\nan open exception blocks completion under CB-EL-3109-R806; the current status is open and unresolved under CB-EL-3109-E988. Identity resolves to ENT-079-1009, revision REV-2025.3 is current, and Willa Novak is active with capacity 3.\n\nAction: Create obligation and decision-event rows with exact owners and holds. Owner: Willa Novak; due 2026-10-02.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/010_personnel_records_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/022_payroll_time_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/034_leave_accommodation_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/06_complaints/046_complaints_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/097_island_biologics_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-079-11 — classification inconsistency (critical)\n\ncompletion is required by 2025-02-08 under CB-EL-3109-R553; the current event record shows completion on 2025-03-14 under CB-EL-3109-E867. Identity resolves to ENT-079-1010, revision REV-2025.4 is current, and Owen Delgado is active with capacity 4.\n\nAction: Create obligation and decision-event rows with exact owners and holds. Owner: Owen Delgado; due 2026-10-01.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/011_personnel_records_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/023_payroll_time_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/035_leave_accommodation_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/06_complaints/047_complaints_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/095_agency_matters_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/09_separation/071_separation_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/097_island_biologics_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-079-12 — interactive-process lapse (low)\n\nthe controlling threshold is 7% under CB-EL-3109-R542; the independently calculated result is 13% under CB-EL-3109-E126. Identity resolves to ENT-079-1011, revision REV-2025.5 is current, and Priya Raman is active with capacity 5.\n\nAction: Create obligation and decision-event rows with exact owners and holds. Owner: Priya Raman; due 2026-09-30.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/012_personnel_records_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/024_payroll_time_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/036_leave_accommodation_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/06_complaints/048_complaints_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/09_separation/072_separation_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/097_island_biologics_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n## Evidence holds\n\n- **CBP-079-03 — discipline comparator inconsistency**: two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key. Next evidence: an approved immutable entity crosswalk. Sources: `/workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/003_handbooks_policies_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/015_personnel_records_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/027_compensation_equity_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/039_leave_accommodation_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/097_island_biologics_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-079-04 — training completion gap**: the current observation does not meet the operative trigger. Next evidence: a current observation that satisfies the operative trigger. Sources: `/workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/004_handbooks_policies_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/016_personnel_records_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/028_compensation_equity_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/040_leave_accommodation_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/07_investigations/052_investigations_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/10_contractors/076_contractors_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/097_island_biologics_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-079-05 — meal-period premium gap**: the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective. Next evidence: effective approval and an active owner with remaining capacity. Sources: `/workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/005_handbooks_policies_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/017_payroll_time_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/029_compensation_equity_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/06_complaints/041_complaints_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/097_island_biologics_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-079-08 — overtime calculation error**: the current observation does not meet the operative trigger. Next evidence: a current observation that satisfies the operative trigger. Sources: `/workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/008_handbooks_policies_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/020_payroll_time_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/032_compensation_equity_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/06_complaints/044_complaints_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/092_agency_matters_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/07_investigations/056_investigations_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/097_island_biologics_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-079-09 — complaint escalation gap**: the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective. Next evidence: effective approval and an active owner with remaining capacity. Sources: `/workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/009_personnel_records_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/021_payroll_time_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/033_leave_accommodation_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/06_complaints/045_complaints_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/09_separation/069_separation_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/11_training/081_training_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/097_island_biologics_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n## Alternatives considered\n\n- `island-biologics:shortcut` — Void the separation and every covenant because a complaint preceded it.: Use a plausible summary or one source without completing the controlling joins.\n- `island-biologics:blanket-hold` — Freeze the entire matter population: Treat supported actions and genuinely ambiguous records as if they were equally unresolved.\n\n## Assumptions and limits\n\nThis decision is limited to cb100-079-island-biologics, the supplied synthetic records, and the matter state as of 2026-10-03. Similar names, stale revisions, and pending authority are not treated as proof.\n", "decision": {"actions": [{"determination": "delivery must use notices-island_biologics_corp@example.test under CB-EL-3109-R383; the only matched receipt used archive-former_research_director@example.test under CB-EL-3109-E222. Identity resolves to ENT-079-1000, revision REV-2025.1 is current, and Samuel Kim is active with capacity 3.", "due_date": "2026-10-02", "id": "ACT-CBP-079-01", "identity_id": "ENT-079-1000", "issue": "personnel-file access deadline", "owner": "Samuel Kim", "portfolio_key": "CBP-079-01", "recommended_action": "Create obligation and decision-event rows with exact owners and holds. Owner: Samuel Kim; due 2026-10-02.", "severity": "low", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/001_handbooks_policies_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/013_personnel_records_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/025_compensation_equity_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/037_leave_accommodation_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/097_island_biologics_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "an open exception blocks completion under CB-EL-3109-R396; the current status is open and unresolved under CB-EL-3109-E488. Identity resolves to ENT-079-1001, revision REV-2025.2 is current, and Talia Brooks is active with capacity 2.", "due_date": "2026-10-01", "id": "ACT-CBP-079-02", "identity_id": "ENT-079-1001", "issue": "pay-equity outlier", "owner": "Talia Brooks", "portfolio_key": "CBP-079-02", "recommended_action": "Create obligation and decision-event rows with exact owners and holds. Owner: Talia Brooks; due 2026-10-01.", "severity": "medium", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/002_handbooks_policies_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/014_personnel_records_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/026_compensation_equity_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/038_leave_accommodation_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/097_island_biologics_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "the controlled population contains 72 records under CB-EL-3109-R720; the certification covers 36 records under CB-EL-3109-E560. Identity resolves to ENT-079-1005, revision REV-2025.6 is current, and Leona Park is active with capacity 6.", "due_date": "2026-09-27", "id": "ACT-CBP-079-06", "identity_id": "ENT-079-1005", "issue": "investigation independence concern", "owner": "Leona Park", "portfolio_key": "CBP-079-06", "recommended_action": "Create obligation and decision-event rows with exact owners and holds. Owner: Leona Park; due 2026-09-27.", "severity": "medium", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/006_handbooks_policies_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/018_payroll_time_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/030_compensation_equity_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/06_complaints/042_complaints_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/097_island_biologics_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "the permission is limited to Massachusetts Commission Against Discrimination under CB-EL-3109-R376; the matched activity occurred in Massachusetts under CB-EL-3109-E910. Identity resolves to ENT-079-1006, revision REV-2025.7 is current, and Henry Cho is active with capacity 4.", "due_date": "2026-09-26", "id": "ACT-CBP-079-07", "identity_id": "ENT-079-1006", "issue": "contractor control evidence", "owner": "Henry Cho", "portfolio_key": "CBP-079-07", "recommended_action": "Create obligation and decision-event rows with exact owners and holds. Owner: Henry Cho; due 2026-09-26.", "severity": "medium", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/007_handbooks_policies_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/019_payroll_time_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/031_compensation_equity_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/06_complaints/043_complaints_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/07_investigations/055_investigations_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/097_island_biologics_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "an open exception blocks completion under CB-EL-3109-R806; the current status is open and unresolved under CB-EL-3109-E988. Identity resolves to ENT-079-1009, revision REV-2025.3 is current, and Willa Novak is active with capacity 3.", "due_date": "2026-10-02", "id": "ACT-CBP-079-10", "identity_id": "ENT-079-1009", "issue": "restrictive-covenant conflict", "owner": "Willa Novak", "portfolio_key": "CBP-079-10", "recommended_action": "Create obligation and decision-event rows with exact owners and holds. Owner: Willa Novak; due 2026-10-02.", "severity": "critical", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/010_personnel_records_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/022_payroll_time_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/034_leave_accommodation_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/06_complaints/046_complaints_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/097_island_biologics_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "completion is required by 2025-02-08 under CB-EL-3109-R553; the current event record shows completion on 2025-03-14 under CB-EL-3109-E867. Identity resolves to ENT-079-1010, revision REV-2025.4 is current, and Owen Delgado is active with capacity 4.", "due_date": "2026-10-01", "id": "ACT-CBP-079-11", "identity_id": "ENT-079-1010", "issue": "classification inconsistency", "owner": "Owen Delgado", "portfolio_key": "CBP-079-11", "recommended_action": "Create obligation and decision-event rows with exact owners and holds. Owner: Owen Delgado; due 2026-10-01.", "severity": "critical", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/011_personnel_records_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/023_payroll_time_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/035_leave_accommodation_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/06_complaints/047_complaints_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/095_agency_matters_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/09_separation/071_separation_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/097_island_biologics_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "the controlling threshold is 7% under CB-EL-3109-R542; the independently calculated result is 13% under CB-EL-3109-E126. Identity resolves to ENT-079-1011, revision REV-2025.5 is current, and Priya Raman is active with capacity 5.", "due_date": "2026-09-30", "id": "ACT-CBP-079-12", "identity_id": "ENT-079-1011", "issue": "interactive-process lapse", "owner": "Priya Raman", "portfolio_key": "CBP-079-12", "recommended_action": "Create obligation and decision-event rows with exact owners and holds. Owner: Priya Raman; due 2026-09-30.", "severity": "low", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/012_personnel_records_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/024_payroll_time_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/036_leave_accommodation_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/06_complaints/048_complaints_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/09_separation/072_separation_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/097_island_biologics_impact_population.xlsx"]}], "as_of": "2026-10-03", "decision": {"alternatives_considered": ["island-biologics:shortcut", "island-biologics:blanket-hold"], "question": "What is Island Biologics' defensible separation and payment posture?", "rationale": "The four-part causal test supports 7 scoped actions and leaves 5 records on evidence hold. Payment and covenant duties follow operative agreements; retaliation requires supported knowledge and causation.", "recommendation": "Pay or revise supported obligations and escalate corroborated retaliation risk.", "selected_option_id": "island-biologics:scoped-evidence"}, "holds": [{"id": "HOLD-CBP-079-03", "issue": "discipline comparator inconsistency", "portfolio_key": "CBP-079-03", "reason": "two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key", "required_next_evidence": "an approved immutable entity crosswalk", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/003_handbooks_policies_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/015_personnel_records_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/027_compensation_equity_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/039_leave_accommodation_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/097_island_biologics_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-079-04", "issue": "training completion gap", "portfolio_key": "CBP-079-04", "reason": "the current observation does not meet the operative trigger", "required_next_evidence": "a current observation that satisfies the operative trigger", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/004_handbooks_policies_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/016_personnel_records_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/028_compensation_equity_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/040_leave_accommodation_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/07_investigations/052_investigations_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/10_contractors/076_contractors_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/097_island_biologics_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-079-05", "issue": "meal-period premium gap", "portfolio_key": "CBP-079-05", "reason": "the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective", "required_next_evidence": "effective approval and an active owner with remaining capacity", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/005_handbooks_policies_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/017_payroll_time_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/029_compensation_equity_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/06_complaints/041_complaints_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/097_island_biologics_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-079-08", "issue": "overtime calculation error", "portfolio_key": "CBP-079-08", "reason": "the current observation does not meet the operative trigger", "required_next_evidence": "a current observation that satisfies the operative trigger", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/008_handbooks_policies_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/020_payroll_time_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/032_compensation_equity_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/06_complaints/044_complaints_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/092_agency_matters_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/07_investigations/056_investigations_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/097_island_biologics_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-079-09", "issue": "complaint escalation gap", "portfolio_key": "CBP-079-09", "reason": "the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective", "required_next_evidence": "effective approval and an active owner with remaining capacity", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/009_personnel_records_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/021_payroll_time_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/033_leave_accommodation_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/06_complaints/045_complaints_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/09_separation/069_separation_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/11_training/081_training_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/097_island_biologics_impact_population.xlsx"]}], "matter_number": "CB-EL-3109", "prepared_for": "Island Biologics Corp.", "schema_version": "counselbench.decision.v3", "task_id": "cb100-079-island-biologics"}, "matter_register": {"matter_number": "CB-EL-3109", "rows": [{"decision_option_id": "island-biologics:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-10-02", "issue": "personnel-file access deadline", "matter_number": "CB-EL-3109", "owner": "Samuel Kim", "portfolio_key": "CBP-079-01", "row_id": "REG-CBP-079-01", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/001_handbooks_policies_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/013_personnel_records_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/025_compensation_equity_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/037_leave_accommodation_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/097_island_biologics_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "island-biologics:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-10-01", "issue": "pay-equity outlier", "matter_number": "CB-EL-3109", "owner": "Talia Brooks", "portfolio_key": "CBP-079-02", "row_id": "REG-CBP-079-02", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/002_handbooks_policies_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/014_personnel_records_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/026_compensation_equity_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/038_leave_accommodation_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/097_island_biologics_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "island-biologics:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key", "issue": "discipline comparator inconsistency", "matter_number": "CB-EL-3109", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-079-03", "row_id": "REG-CBP-079-03", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/003_handbooks_policies_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/015_personnel_records_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/027_compensation_equity_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/039_leave_accommodation_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/097_island_biologics_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "island-biologics:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "the current observation does not meet the operative trigger", "issue": "training completion gap", "matter_number": "CB-EL-3109", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-079-04", "row_id": "REG-CBP-079-04", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/004_handbooks_policies_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/016_personnel_records_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/028_compensation_equity_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/040_leave_accommodation_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/07_investigations/052_investigations_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/10_contractors/076_contractors_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/097_island_biologics_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "island-biologics:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective", "issue": "meal-period premium gap", "matter_number": "CB-EL-3109", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-079-05", "row_id": "REG-CBP-079-05", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/005_handbooks_policies_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/017_payroll_time_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/029_compensation_equity_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/06_complaints/041_complaints_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/097_island_biologics_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "island-biologics:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-27", "issue": "investigation independence concern", "matter_number": "CB-EL-3109", "owner": "Leona Park", "portfolio_key": "CBP-079-06", "row_id": "REG-CBP-079-06", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/006_handbooks_policies_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/018_payroll_time_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/030_compensation_equity_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/06_complaints/042_complaints_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/097_island_biologics_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "island-biologics:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-26", "issue": "contractor control evidence", "matter_number": "CB-EL-3109", "owner": "Henry Cho", "portfolio_key": "CBP-079-07", "row_id": "REG-CBP-079-07", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/007_handbooks_policies_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/019_payroll_time_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/031_compensation_equity_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/06_complaints/043_complaints_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/07_investigations/055_investigations_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/097_island_biologics_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "island-biologics:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "the current observation does not meet the operative trigger", "issue": "overtime calculation error", "matter_number": "CB-EL-3109", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-079-08", "row_id": "REG-CBP-079-08", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/008_handbooks_policies_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/020_payroll_time_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/032_compensation_equity_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/06_complaints/044_complaints_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/092_agency_matters_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/07_investigations/056_investigations_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/097_island_biologics_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "island-biologics:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective", "issue": "complaint escalation gap", "matter_number": "CB-EL-3109", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-079-09", "row_id": "REG-CBP-079-09", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/009_personnel_records_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/021_payroll_time_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/033_leave_accommodation_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/06_complaints/045_complaints_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/09_separation/069_separation_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/11_training/081_training_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/097_island_biologics_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "island-biologics:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-10-02", "issue": "restrictive-covenant conflict", "matter_number": "CB-EL-3109", "owner": "Willa Novak", "portfolio_key": "CBP-079-10", "row_id": "REG-CBP-079-10", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/010_personnel_records_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/022_payroll_time_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/034_leave_accommodation_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/06_complaints/046_complaints_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/097_island_biologics_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "island-biologics:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-10-01", "issue": "classification inconsistency", "matter_number": "CB-EL-3109", "owner": "Owen Delgado", "portfolio_key": "CBP-079-11", "row_id": "REG-CBP-079-11", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/011_personnel_records_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/023_payroll_time_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/035_leave_accommodation_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/06_complaints/047_complaints_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/095_agency_matters_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/09_separation/071_separation_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/097_island_biologics_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "island-biologics:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-30", "issue": "interactive-process lapse", "matter_number": "CB-EL-3109", "owner": "Priya Raman", "portfolio_key": "CBP-079-12", "row_id": "REG-CBP-079-12", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/012_personnel_records_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/024_payroll_time_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/036_leave_accommodation_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/06_complaints/048_complaints_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/09_separation/072_separation_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/097_island_biologics_impact_population.xlsx"]}], "schema_version": "counselbench.matter-register.v3", "task_id": "cb100-079-island-biologics"}}, "metadata": {"benchmark": "CounselBench-100", "code_license": "Apache-2.0", "data_license": "CC-BY-4.0", "deadline": "2026-10-03", "document_count": 97, "evidence_holds": 5, "jurisdiction": "Massachusetts", "matter_number": "CB-EL-3109", "mcp_commit": "9a96ea6e5913736f92b88345bf51caeaaa8e719f", "mcp_package": "@modelcontextprotocol/server-filesystem@2026.7.10", "practice_area": "employment", "reference_tool_calls": 76, "required_evidence_reads": 60, "supported_actions": 7, "synthetic": true, "venue": "Massachusetts Commission Against Discrimination", "version": "3.1.0"}, "prompt": "Please take ownership of the open question before the deadline. What is Island Biologics' defensible separation and payment posture? A research director's complaint, comparator discipline, incentive payment, restrictive covenant, and separation documents require reconciliation. The team needs the call by 2026-10-03. Give me a decision-ready note and make the corresponding matter-register entries, without guessing through missing records.", "rubric": {"criteria": [{"category": "investigation", "description": "Inventory the production and use targeted searches to locate records across native formats.", "id": "investigation.discover_production"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Complete every task-specific identity, authority, operations, and approval read before the first state transition.", "id": "investigation.read_before_write"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Inspect designated source metadata before relying on those records.", "id": "investigation.custody_before_write"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "Select the supported option 'island-biologics:scoped-evidence' after applying the four-part test.", "id": "decision.selected_option"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "Identify both rejected approaches and explain why a one-source shortcut and a blanket hold are wrong.", "id": "decision.alternatives"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-079-01 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/001_handbooks_policies_source_export.md rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-079-01.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/013_personnel_records_source_export.json for personnel-file access deadline.", "id": "investigation.CBP-079-01.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/025_compensation_equity_source_export.md to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-079-01.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/037_leave_accommodation_source_export.json.", "id": "investigation.CBP-079-01.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-079-01 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-079-01.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-079-01 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-079-01.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-079-02 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/002_handbooks_policies_source_export.txt rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-079-02.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/014_personnel_records_source_export.xml for pay-equity outlier.", "id": "investigation.CBP-079-02.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/026_compensation_equity_source_export.txt to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-079-02.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/038_leave_accommodation_source_export.xml.", "id": "investigation.CBP-079-02.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-079-02 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-079-02.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-079-02 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-079-02.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-079-03 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/003_handbooks_policies_source_export.eml rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-079-03.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/015_personnel_records_source_export.html for discipline comparator inconsistency.", "id": "investigation.CBP-079-03.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/027_compensation_equity_source_export.eml to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-079-03.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/039_leave_accommodation_source_export.html.", "id": "investigation.CBP-079-03.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-079-03 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key.", "id": "decision.CBP-079-03.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-079-03 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-079-03.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-079-04 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/004_handbooks_policies_source_export.csv rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-079-04.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/016_personnel_records_source_export.pdf for training completion gap.", "id": "investigation.CBP-079-04.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/028_compensation_equity_source_export.csv to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-079-04.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/040_leave_accommodation_source_export.pdf.", "id": "investigation.CBP-079-04.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-079-04 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is the current observation does not meet the operative trigger.", "id": "decision.CBP-079-04.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-079-04 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-079-04.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-079-05 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/005_handbooks_policies_source_export.json rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-079-05.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/017_payroll_time_source_export.md for meal-period premium gap.", "id": "investigation.CBP-079-05.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/029_compensation_equity_source_export.json to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-079-05.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_complaints/041_complaints_source_export.md.", "id": "investigation.CBP-079-05.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-079-05 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective.", "id": "decision.CBP-079-05.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-079-05 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-079-05.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-079-06 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/006_handbooks_policies_source_export.xml rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-079-06.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/018_payroll_time_source_export.txt for investigation independence concern.", "id": "investigation.CBP-079-06.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/030_compensation_equity_source_export.xml to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-079-06.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_complaints/042_complaints_source_export.txt.", "id": "investigation.CBP-079-06.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-079-06 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-079-06.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-079-06 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-079-06.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-079-07 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/007_handbooks_policies_source_export.html rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-079-07.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/019_payroll_time_source_export.eml for contractor control evidence.", "id": "investigation.CBP-079-07.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/031_compensation_equity_source_export.html to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-079-07.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_complaints/043_complaints_source_export.eml.", "id": "investigation.CBP-079-07.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-079-07 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-079-07.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-079-07 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-079-07.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-079-08 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/008_handbooks_policies_source_export.pdf rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-079-08.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/020_payroll_time_source_export.csv for overtime calculation error.", "id": "investigation.CBP-079-08.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/032_compensation_equity_source_export.pdf to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-079-08.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_complaints/044_complaints_source_export.csv.", "id": "investigation.CBP-079-08.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-079-08 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is the current observation does not meet the operative trigger.", "id": "decision.CBP-079-08.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-079-08 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-079-08.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-079-09 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/009_personnel_records_source_export.md rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-079-09.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/021_payroll_time_source_export.json for complaint escalation gap.", "id": "investigation.CBP-079-09.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/033_leave_accommodation_source_export.md to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-079-09.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_complaints/045_complaints_source_export.json.", "id": "investigation.CBP-079-09.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-079-09 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective.", "id": "decision.CBP-079-09.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-079-09 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-079-09.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-079-10 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/010_personnel_records_source_export.txt rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-079-10.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/022_payroll_time_source_export.xml for restrictive-covenant conflict.", "id": "investigation.CBP-079-10.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/034_leave_accommodation_source_export.txt to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-079-10.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_complaints/046_complaints_source_export.xml.", "id": "investigation.CBP-079-10.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-079-10 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-079-10.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-079-10 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-079-10.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-079-11 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/011_personnel_records_source_export.eml rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-079-11.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/023_payroll_time_source_export.html for classification inconsistency.", "id": "investigation.CBP-079-11.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/035_leave_accommodation_source_export.eml to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-079-11.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_complaints/047_complaints_source_export.html.", "id": "investigation.CBP-079-11.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-079-11 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-079-11.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-079-11 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-079-11.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-079-12 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/012_personnel_records_source_export.csv rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-079-12.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/024_payroll_time_source_export.pdf for interactive-process lapse.", "id": "investigation.CBP-079-12.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/036_leave_accommodation_source_export.csv to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-079-12.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_complaints/048_complaints_source_export.pdf.", "id": "investigation.CBP-079-12.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-079-12 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-079-12.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-079-12 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-079-12.register"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Write the exact selected option, supported action population, evidence-hold population, facts, owners, deadlines, and citations.", "id": "state.exact_decision"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create one exact register row per portfolio key with no extra, missing, or modified row.", "id": "state.exact_register"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Leave only the three approved deliverables and perform no extra state-changing write.", "id": "state.write_scope_containment"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Read back decision.json, matter-register.json, and advice.md after their final writes.", "id": "state.postwrite_readback"}, {"category": "answer", "description": "Explain the selected recommendation, supported actions, holds, alternatives, and limitations with exact source anchors.", "id": "answer.decision_note"}], "decision_options": [{"approach": "Apply the exact identity, current-state, authority, and revision test. Create obligation and decision-event rows with exact owners and holds.", "id": "island-biologics:scoped-evidence", "label": "Pay or revise supported obligations and escalate corroborated retaliation risk."}, {"approach": "Use a plausible summary or one source without completing the controlling joins.", "id": "island-biologics:shortcut", "label": "Void the separation and every covenant because a complaint preceded it."}, {"approach": "Treat supported actions and genuinely ambiguous records as if they were equally unresolved.", "id": "island-biologics:blanket-hold", "label": "Freeze the entire matter population"}], "evaluation_narrative": {"authority": "Payment and covenant duties follow operative agreements; retaliation requires supported knowledge and causation.", "observation": "Join complaint knowledge, comparator discipline, incentive terms, restrictive covenant, and separation approvals.", "question": "What is Island Biologics' defensible separation and payment posture?", "register_action": "Create obligation and decision-event rows with exact owners and holds."}, "gates": ["all_required_evidence_precedes_first_write", "decision_criteria_complete", "register_state_exact", "write_scope_contained", "all_outputs_verified_by_readback"], "metadata_checks": 4, "metric": "weighted_criteria_score", "minimum_tool_calls": 76, "required_deliverables": ["decision.json", "matter-register.json", "advice.md"], "required_document_reads": 60, "type": "deterministic", "weights": {"advice": 0.15, "decision": 0.35, "investigation": 0.25, "state": 0.25}}, "task_id": "cb100-079-island-biologics", "task_name": "Island Biologics separation audit", "world_id": "counselbench-filesystem-mcp-v3"}
+{"context_files": ["task_files/cb100-080-junction-foods/01_handbooks_policies/001_handbooks_policies_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-080-junction-foods/01_handbooks_policies/002_handbooks_policies_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-080-junction-foods/01_handbooks_policies/003_handbooks_policies_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-080-junction-foods/01_handbooks_policies/004_handbooks_policies_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-080-junction-foods/01_handbooks_policies/005_handbooks_policies_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-080-junction-foods/01_handbooks_policies/006_handbooks_policies_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-080-junction-foods/01_handbooks_policies/007_handbooks_policies_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-080-junction-foods/01_handbooks_policies/008_handbooks_policies_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-080-junction-foods/02_personnel_records/009_personnel_records_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-080-junction-foods/02_personnel_records/010_personnel_records_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-080-junction-foods/02_personnel_records/011_personnel_records_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-080-junction-foods/02_personnel_records/012_personnel_records_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-080-junction-foods/02_personnel_records/013_personnel_records_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-080-junction-foods/02_personnel_records/014_personnel_records_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-080-junction-foods/02_personnel_records/015_personnel_records_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-080-junction-foods/02_personnel_records/016_personnel_records_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-080-junction-foods/03_payroll_time/017_payroll_time_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-080-junction-foods/03_payroll_time/018_payroll_time_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-080-junction-foods/03_payroll_time/019_payroll_time_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-080-junction-foods/03_payroll_time/020_payroll_time_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-080-junction-foods/03_payroll_time/021_payroll_time_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-080-junction-foods/03_payroll_time/022_payroll_time_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-080-junction-foods/03_payroll_time/023_payroll_time_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-080-junction-foods/03_payroll_time/024_payroll_time_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-080-junction-foods/04_compensation_equity/025_compensation_equity_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-080-junction-foods/04_compensation_equity/026_compensation_equity_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-080-junction-foods/04_compensation_equity/027_compensation_equity_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-080-junction-foods/04_compensation_equity/028_compensation_equity_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-080-junction-foods/04_compensation_equity/029_compensation_equity_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-080-junction-foods/04_compensation_equity/030_compensation_equity_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-080-junction-foods/04_compensation_equity/031_compensation_equity_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-080-junction-foods/04_compensation_equity/032_compensation_equity_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-080-junction-foods/05_leave_accommodation/033_leave_accommodation_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-080-junction-foods/05_leave_accommodation/034_leave_accommodation_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-080-junction-foods/05_leave_accommodation/035_leave_accommodation_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-080-junction-foods/05_leave_accommodation/036_leave_accommodation_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-080-junction-foods/05_leave_accommodation/037_leave_accommodation_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-080-junction-foods/05_leave_accommodation/038_leave_accommodation_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-080-junction-foods/05_leave_accommodation/039_leave_accommodation_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-080-junction-foods/05_leave_accommodation/040_leave_accommodation_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-080-junction-foods/06_complaints/041_complaints_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-080-junction-foods/06_complaints/042_complaints_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-080-junction-foods/06_complaints/043_complaints_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-080-junction-foods/06_complaints/044_complaints_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-080-junction-foods/06_complaints/045_complaints_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-080-junction-foods/06_complaints/046_complaints_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-080-junction-foods/06_complaints/047_complaints_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-080-junction-foods/06_complaints/048_complaints_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-080-junction-foods/07_investigations/049_investigations_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-080-junction-foods/07_investigations/050_investigations_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-080-junction-foods/07_investigations/051_investigations_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-080-junction-foods/07_investigations/052_investigations_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-080-junction-foods/07_investigations/053_investigations_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-080-junction-foods/07_investigations/054_investigations_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-080-junction-foods/07_investigations/055_investigations_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-080-junction-foods/07_investigations/056_investigations_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-080-junction-foods/08_performance_discipline/057_performance_discipline_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-080-junction-foods/08_performance_discipline/058_performance_discipline_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-080-junction-foods/08_performance_discipline/059_performance_discipline_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-080-junction-foods/08_performance_discipline/060_performance_discipline_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-080-junction-foods/08_performance_discipline/061_performance_discipline_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-080-junction-foods/08_performance_discipline/062_performance_discipline_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-080-junction-foods/08_performance_discipline/063_performance_discipline_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-080-junction-foods/08_performance_discipline/064_performance_discipline_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-080-junction-foods/09_separation/065_separation_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-080-junction-foods/09_separation/066_separation_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-080-junction-foods/09_separation/067_separation_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-080-junction-foods/09_separation/068_separation_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-080-junction-foods/09_separation/069_separation_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-080-junction-foods/09_separation/070_separation_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-080-junction-foods/09_separation/071_separation_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-080-junction-foods/09_separation/072_separation_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-080-junction-foods/10_contractors/073_contractors_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-080-junction-foods/10_contractors/074_contractors_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-080-junction-foods/10_contractors/075_contractors_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-080-junction-foods/10_contractors/076_contractors_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-080-junction-foods/10_contractors/077_contractors_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-080-junction-foods/10_contractors/078_contractors_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-080-junction-foods/10_contractors/079_contractors_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-080-junction-foods/10_contractors/080_contractors_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-080-junction-foods/11_training/081_training_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-080-junction-foods/11_training/082_training_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-080-junction-foods/11_training/083_training_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-080-junction-foods/11_training/084_training_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-080-junction-foods/11_training/085_training_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-080-junction-foods/11_training/086_training_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-080-junction-foods/11_training/087_training_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-080-junction-foods/11_training/088_training_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-080-junction-foods/12_agency_matters/089_agency_matters_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-080-junction-foods/12_agency_matters/090_agency_matters_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-080-junction-foods/12_agency_matters/091_agency_matters_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-080-junction-foods/12_agency_matters/092_agency_matters_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-080-junction-foods/12_agency_matters/093_agency_matters_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-080-junction-foods/12_agency_matters/094_agency_matters_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-080-junction-foods/12_agency_matters/095_agency_matters_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-080-junction-foods/12_agency_matters/096_agency_matters_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-080-junction-foods/12_agency_matters/097_junction_foods_impact_population.xlsx"], "gold_output": {"advice_markdown": "# Decision note — Junction Foods agency response check\n\n## Recommendation\n\nCorrect supported gaps and submit a bounded response that identifies open commitments. The reconciled record supports 9 scoped actions and leaves 3 items on evidence hold.\n\nSelected option: `junction-foods:scoped-evidence`.\n\n## Why this is the supported option\n\nReconcile shifts, accommodations, training, corrections, response drafts, and committed dates by employee. Agency commitments and underlying wage and accommodation duties require exact completion evidence.\n\n## Supported actions\n\n### CBP-080-03 — retaliation timing (medium)\n\nthe operative cap is $4,042,000.00 under CB-EL-3110-R176; the matched ledger population totals $4,143,576.00 under CB-EL-3110-E686. Identity resolves to ENT-080-1002, revision REV-2026.3 is current, and Amara Patel is active with capacity 3.\n\nAction: Create employee-commitment rows with exact completion or hold status. Owner: Amara Patel; due 2026-10-04.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/003_handbooks_policies_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/015_personnel_records_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/027_compensation_equity_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/039_leave_accommodation_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/11_training/087_training_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/10_contractors/075_contractors_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/097_junction_foods_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-080-04 — personnel-file access deadline (medium)\n\ndelivery must use notices-junction_prepared_foods@example.test under CB-EL-3110-R161; the only matched receipt used archive-packaging_line_employee_group@example.test under CB-EL-3110-E580. Identity resolves to ENT-080-1003, revision REV-2026.4 is current, and Samuel Kim is active with capacity 3.\n\nAction: Create employee-commitment rows with exact completion or hold status. Owner: Samuel Kim; due 2026-10-03.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/004_handbooks_policies_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/016_personnel_records_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/028_compensation_equity_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/040_leave_accommodation_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/097_junction_foods_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-080-05 — pay-equity outlier (high)\n\nan open exception blocks completion under CB-EL-3110-R324; the current status is open and unresolved under CB-EL-3110-E642. Identity resolves to ENT-080-1004, revision REV-2026.5 is current, and Talia Brooks is active with capacity 1.\n\nAction: Create employee-commitment rows with exact completion or hold status. Owner: Talia Brooks; due 2026-10-02.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/005_handbooks_policies_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/017_payroll_time_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/029_compensation_equity_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/06_complaints/041_complaints_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/07_investigations/053_investigations_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/097_junction_foods_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-080-07 — training completion gap (medium)\n\nthe controlling threshold is 12% under CB-EL-3110-R561; the independently calculated result is 16% under CB-EL-3110-E603. Identity resolves to ENT-080-1006, revision REV-2026.7 is current, and Farah Ibrahim is active with capacity 1.\n\nAction: Create employee-commitment rows with exact completion or hold status. Owner: Farah Ibrahim; due 2026-09-30.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/007_handbooks_policies_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/019_payroll_time_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/031_compensation_equity_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/06_complaints/043_complaints_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/091_agency_matters_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/097_junction_foods_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-080-08 — meal-period premium gap (high)\n\napproval must come from Priya Raman under CB-EL-3110-R957; the effective approval record names Rafael Okafor under CB-EL-3110-E521. Identity resolves to ENT-080-1007, revision REV-2026.1 is current, and Dominic Alvarez is active with capacity 3.\n\nAction: Create employee-commitment rows with exact completion or hold status. Owner: Dominic Alvarez; due 2026-09-29.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/008_handbooks_policies_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/020_payroll_time_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/032_compensation_equity_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/06_complaints/044_complaints_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/097_junction_foods_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-080-09 — investigation independence concern (medium)\n\nthe controlled population contains 182 records under CB-EL-3110-R110; the certification covers 168 records under CB-EL-3110-E206. Identity resolves to ENT-080-1008, revision REV-2026.2 is current, and Leona Park is active with capacity 5.\n\nAction: Create employee-commitment rows with exact completion or hold status. Owner: Leona Park; due 2026-09-28.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/009_personnel_records_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/021_payroll_time_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/033_leave_accommodation_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/06_complaints/045_complaints_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/097_junction_foods_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-080-10 — contractor control evidence (high)\n\nthe permission is limited to Iowa Civil Rights Commission under CB-EL-3110-R157; the matched activity occurred in Iowa under CB-EL-3110-E421. Identity resolves to ENT-080-1009, revision REV-2026.3 is current, and Henry Cho is active with capacity 5.\n\nAction: Create employee-commitment rows with exact completion or hold status. Owner: Henry Cho; due 2026-10-06.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/010_personnel_records_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/022_payroll_time_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/034_leave_accommodation_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/06_complaints/046_complaints_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/09_separation/070_separation_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/094_agency_matters_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/097_junction_foods_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-080-11 — overtime calculation error (high)\n\nthe operative cap is $682,000.00 under CB-EL-3110-R386; the matched ledger population totals $847,386.00 under CB-EL-3110-E646. Identity resolves to ENT-080-1010, revision REV-2026.4 is current, and Maya Ellison is active with capacity 4.\n\nAction: Create employee-commitment rows with exact completion or hold status. Owner: Maya Ellison; due 2026-10-05.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/011_personnel_records_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/023_payroll_time_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/035_leave_accommodation_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/06_complaints/047_complaints_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/097_junction_foods_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-080-12 — complaint escalation gap (high)\n\ndelivery must use notices-junction_prepared_foods@example.test under CB-EL-3110-R137; the only matched receipt used archive-packaging_line_employee_group@example.test under CB-EL-3110-E472. Identity resolves to ENT-080-1011, revision REV-2026.5 is current, and Jonas Feld is active with capacity 3.\n\nAction: Create employee-commitment rows with exact completion or hold status. Owner: Jonas Feld; due 2026-10-04.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/012_personnel_records_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/024_payroll_time_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/036_leave_accommodation_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/06_complaints/048_complaints_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/08_performance_discipline/060_performance_discipline_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/097_junction_foods_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n## Evidence holds\n\n- **CBP-080-01 — agency response commitment**: the operational record relies on a superseded control revision. Next evidence: an operational record using the current effective revision. Sources: `/workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/001_handbooks_policies_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/013_personnel_records_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/025_compensation_equity_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/037_leave_accommodation_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/10_contractors/073_contractors_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/11_training/085_training_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/097_junction_foods_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-080-02 — leave designation delay**: two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key. Next evidence: an approved immutable entity crosswalk. Sources: `/workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/002_handbooks_policies_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/014_personnel_records_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/026_compensation_equity_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/038_leave_accommodation_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/07_investigations/050_investigations_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/08_performance_discipline/062_performance_discipline_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/097_junction_foods_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-080-06 — discipline comparator inconsistency**: two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key. Next evidence: an approved immutable entity crosswalk. Sources: `/workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/006_handbooks_policies_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/018_payroll_time_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/030_compensation_equity_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/06_complaints/042_complaints_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/10_contractors/078_contractors_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/097_junction_foods_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n## Alternatives considered\n\n- `junction-foods:shortcut` — Certify full compliance from aggregate completion reports.: Use a plausible summary or one source without completing the controlling joins.\n- `junction-foods:blanket-hold` — Freeze the entire matter population: Treat supported actions and genuinely ambiguous records as if they were equally unresolved.\n\n## Assumptions and limits\n\nThis decision is limited to cb100-080-junction-foods, the supplied synthetic records, and the matter state as of 2026-10-07. Similar names, stale revisions, and pending authority are not treated as proof.\n", "decision": {"actions": [{"determination": "the operative cap is $4,042,000.00 under CB-EL-3110-R176; the matched ledger population totals $4,143,576.00 under CB-EL-3110-E686. Identity resolves to ENT-080-1002, revision REV-2026.3 is current, and Amara Patel is active with capacity 3.", "due_date": "2026-10-04", "id": "ACT-CBP-080-03", "identity_id": "ENT-080-1002", "issue": "retaliation timing", "owner": "Amara Patel", "portfolio_key": "CBP-080-03", "recommended_action": "Create employee-commitment rows with exact completion or hold status. Owner: Amara Patel; due 2026-10-04.", "severity": "medium", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/003_handbooks_policies_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/015_personnel_records_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/027_compensation_equity_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/039_leave_accommodation_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/11_training/087_training_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/10_contractors/075_contractors_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/097_junction_foods_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "delivery must use notices-junction_prepared_foods@example.test under CB-EL-3110-R161; the only matched receipt used archive-packaging_line_employee_group@example.test under CB-EL-3110-E580. Identity resolves to ENT-080-1003, revision REV-2026.4 is current, and Samuel Kim is active with capacity 3.", "due_date": "2026-10-03", "id": "ACT-CBP-080-04", "identity_id": "ENT-080-1003", "issue": "personnel-file access deadline", "owner": "Samuel Kim", "portfolio_key": "CBP-080-04", "recommended_action": "Create employee-commitment rows with exact completion or hold status. Owner: Samuel Kim; due 2026-10-03.", "severity": "medium", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/004_handbooks_policies_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/016_personnel_records_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/028_compensation_equity_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/040_leave_accommodation_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/097_junction_foods_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "an open exception blocks completion under CB-EL-3110-R324; the current status is open and unresolved under CB-EL-3110-E642. Identity resolves to ENT-080-1004, revision REV-2026.5 is current, and Talia Brooks is active with capacity 1.", "due_date": "2026-10-02", "id": "ACT-CBP-080-05", "identity_id": "ENT-080-1004", "issue": "pay-equity outlier", "owner": "Talia Brooks", "portfolio_key": "CBP-080-05", "recommended_action": "Create employee-commitment rows with exact completion or hold status. Owner: Talia Brooks; due 2026-10-02.", "severity": "high", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/005_handbooks_policies_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/017_payroll_time_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/029_compensation_equity_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/06_complaints/041_complaints_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/07_investigations/053_investigations_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/097_junction_foods_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "the controlling threshold is 12% under CB-EL-3110-R561; the independently calculated result is 16% under CB-EL-3110-E603. Identity resolves to ENT-080-1006, revision REV-2026.7 is current, and Farah Ibrahim is active with capacity 1.", "due_date": "2026-09-30", "id": "ACT-CBP-080-07", "identity_id": "ENT-080-1006", "issue": "training completion gap", "owner": "Farah Ibrahim", "portfolio_key": "CBP-080-07", "recommended_action": "Create employee-commitment rows with exact completion or hold status. Owner: Farah Ibrahim; due 2026-09-30.", "severity": "medium", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/007_handbooks_policies_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/019_payroll_time_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/031_compensation_equity_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/06_complaints/043_complaints_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/091_agency_matters_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/097_junction_foods_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "approval must come from Priya Raman under CB-EL-3110-R957; the effective approval record names Rafael Okafor under CB-EL-3110-E521. Identity resolves to ENT-080-1007, revision REV-2026.1 is current, and Dominic Alvarez is active with capacity 3.", "due_date": "2026-09-29", "id": "ACT-CBP-080-08", "identity_id": "ENT-080-1007", "issue": "meal-period premium gap", "owner": "Dominic Alvarez", "portfolio_key": "CBP-080-08", "recommended_action": "Create employee-commitment rows with exact completion or hold status. Owner: Dominic Alvarez; due 2026-09-29.", "severity": "high", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/008_handbooks_policies_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/020_payroll_time_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/032_compensation_equity_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/06_complaints/044_complaints_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/097_junction_foods_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "the controlled population contains 182 records under CB-EL-3110-R110; the certification covers 168 records under CB-EL-3110-E206. Identity resolves to ENT-080-1008, revision REV-2026.2 is current, and Leona Park is active with capacity 5.", "due_date": "2026-09-28", "id": "ACT-CBP-080-09", "identity_id": "ENT-080-1008", "issue": "investigation independence concern", "owner": "Leona Park", "portfolio_key": "CBP-080-09", "recommended_action": "Create employee-commitment rows with exact completion or hold status. Owner: Leona Park; due 2026-09-28.", "severity": "medium", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/009_personnel_records_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/021_payroll_time_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/033_leave_accommodation_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/06_complaints/045_complaints_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/097_junction_foods_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "the permission is limited to Iowa Civil Rights Commission under CB-EL-3110-R157; the matched activity occurred in Iowa under CB-EL-3110-E421. Identity resolves to ENT-080-1009, revision REV-2026.3 is current, and Henry Cho is active with capacity 5.", "due_date": "2026-10-06", "id": "ACT-CBP-080-10", "identity_id": "ENT-080-1009", "issue": "contractor control evidence", "owner": "Henry Cho", "portfolio_key": "CBP-080-10", "recommended_action": "Create employee-commitment rows with exact completion or hold status. Owner: Henry Cho; due 2026-10-06.", "severity": "high", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/010_personnel_records_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/022_payroll_time_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/034_leave_accommodation_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/06_complaints/046_complaints_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/09_separation/070_separation_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/094_agency_matters_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/097_junction_foods_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "the operative cap is $682,000.00 under CB-EL-3110-R386; the matched ledger population totals $847,386.00 under CB-EL-3110-E646. Identity resolves to ENT-080-1010, revision REV-2026.4 is current, and Maya Ellison is active with capacity 4.", "due_date": "2026-10-05", "id": "ACT-CBP-080-11", "identity_id": "ENT-080-1010", "issue": "overtime calculation error", "owner": "Maya Ellison", "portfolio_key": "CBP-080-11", "recommended_action": "Create employee-commitment rows with exact completion or hold status. Owner: Maya Ellison; due 2026-10-05.", "severity": "high", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/011_personnel_records_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/023_payroll_time_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/035_leave_accommodation_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/06_complaints/047_complaints_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/097_junction_foods_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "delivery must use notices-junction_prepared_foods@example.test under CB-EL-3110-R137; the only matched receipt used archive-packaging_line_employee_group@example.test under CB-EL-3110-E472. Identity resolves to ENT-080-1011, revision REV-2026.5 is current, and Jonas Feld is active with capacity 3.", "due_date": "2026-10-04", "id": "ACT-CBP-080-12", "identity_id": "ENT-080-1011", "issue": "complaint escalation gap", "owner": "Jonas Feld", "portfolio_key": "CBP-080-12", "recommended_action": "Create employee-commitment rows with exact completion or hold status. Owner: Jonas Feld; due 2026-10-04.", "severity": "high", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/012_personnel_records_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/024_payroll_time_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/036_leave_accommodation_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/06_complaints/048_complaints_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/08_performance_discipline/060_performance_discipline_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/097_junction_foods_impact_population.xlsx"]}], "as_of": "2026-10-07", "decision": {"alternatives_considered": ["junction-foods:shortcut", "junction-foods:blanket-hold"], "question": "Can Junction submit the agency response, and which payroll or accommodation commitments remain unfulfilled?", "rationale": "The four-part causal test supports 9 scoped actions and leaves 3 records on evidence hold. Agency commitments and underlying wage and accommodation duties require exact completion evidence.", "recommendation": "Correct supported gaps and submit a bounded response that identifies open commitments.", "selected_option_id": "junction-foods:scoped-evidence"}, "holds": [{"id": "HOLD-CBP-080-01", "issue": "agency response commitment", "portfolio_key": "CBP-080-01", "reason": "the operational record relies on a superseded control revision", "required_next_evidence": "an operational record using the current effective revision", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/001_handbooks_policies_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/013_personnel_records_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/025_compensation_equity_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/037_leave_accommodation_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/10_contractors/073_contractors_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/11_training/085_training_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/097_junction_foods_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-080-02", "issue": "leave designation delay", "portfolio_key": "CBP-080-02", "reason": "two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key", "required_next_evidence": "an approved immutable entity crosswalk", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/002_handbooks_policies_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/014_personnel_records_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/026_compensation_equity_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/038_leave_accommodation_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/07_investigations/050_investigations_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/08_performance_discipline/062_performance_discipline_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/097_junction_foods_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-080-06", "issue": "discipline comparator inconsistency", "portfolio_key": "CBP-080-06", "reason": "two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key", "required_next_evidence": "an approved immutable entity crosswalk", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/006_handbooks_policies_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/018_payroll_time_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/030_compensation_equity_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/06_complaints/042_complaints_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/10_contractors/078_contractors_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/097_junction_foods_impact_population.xlsx"]}], "matter_number": "CB-EL-3110", "prepared_for": "Junction Prepared Foods", "schema_version": "counselbench.decision.v3", "task_id": "cb100-080-junction-foods"}, "matter_register": {"matter_number": "CB-EL-3110", "rows": [{"decision_option_id": "junction-foods:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "the operational record relies on a superseded control revision", "issue": "agency response commitment", "matter_number": "CB-EL-3110", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-080-01", "row_id": "REG-CBP-080-01", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/001_handbooks_policies_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/013_personnel_records_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/025_compensation_equity_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/037_leave_accommodation_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/10_contractors/073_contractors_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/11_training/085_training_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/097_junction_foods_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "junction-foods:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key", "issue": "leave designation delay", "matter_number": "CB-EL-3110", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-080-02", "row_id": "REG-CBP-080-02", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/002_handbooks_policies_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/014_personnel_records_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/026_compensation_equity_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/038_leave_accommodation_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/07_investigations/050_investigations_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/08_performance_discipline/062_performance_discipline_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/097_junction_foods_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "junction-foods:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-10-04", "issue": "retaliation timing", "matter_number": "CB-EL-3110", "owner": "Amara Patel", "portfolio_key": "CBP-080-03", "row_id": "REG-CBP-080-03", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/003_handbooks_policies_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/015_personnel_records_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/027_compensation_equity_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/039_leave_accommodation_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/11_training/087_training_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/10_contractors/075_contractors_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/097_junction_foods_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "junction-foods:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-10-03", "issue": "personnel-file access deadline", "matter_number": "CB-EL-3110", "owner": "Samuel Kim", "portfolio_key": "CBP-080-04", "row_id": "REG-CBP-080-04", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/004_handbooks_policies_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/016_personnel_records_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/028_compensation_equity_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/040_leave_accommodation_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/097_junction_foods_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "junction-foods:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-10-02", "issue": "pay-equity outlier", "matter_number": "CB-EL-3110", "owner": "Talia Brooks", "portfolio_key": "CBP-080-05", "row_id": "REG-CBP-080-05", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/005_handbooks_policies_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/017_payroll_time_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/029_compensation_equity_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/06_complaints/041_complaints_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/07_investigations/053_investigations_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/097_junction_foods_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "junction-foods:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key", "issue": "discipline comparator inconsistency", "matter_number": "CB-EL-3110", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-080-06", "row_id": "REG-CBP-080-06", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/006_handbooks_policies_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/018_payroll_time_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/030_compensation_equity_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/06_complaints/042_complaints_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/10_contractors/078_contractors_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/097_junction_foods_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "junction-foods:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-30", "issue": "training completion gap", "matter_number": "CB-EL-3110", "owner": "Farah Ibrahim", "portfolio_key": "CBP-080-07", "row_id": "REG-CBP-080-07", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/007_handbooks_policies_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/019_payroll_time_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/031_compensation_equity_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/06_complaints/043_complaints_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/091_agency_matters_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/097_junction_foods_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "junction-foods:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-29", "issue": "meal-period premium gap", "matter_number": "CB-EL-3110", "owner": "Dominic Alvarez", "portfolio_key": "CBP-080-08", "row_id": "REG-CBP-080-08", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/008_handbooks_policies_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/020_payroll_time_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/032_compensation_equity_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/06_complaints/044_complaints_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/097_junction_foods_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "junction-foods:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-28", "issue": "investigation independence concern", "matter_number": "CB-EL-3110", "owner": "Leona Park", "portfolio_key": "CBP-080-09", "row_id": "REG-CBP-080-09", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/009_personnel_records_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/021_payroll_time_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/033_leave_accommodation_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/06_complaints/045_complaints_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/097_junction_foods_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "junction-foods:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-10-06", "issue": "contractor control evidence", "matter_number": "CB-EL-3110", "owner": "Henry Cho", "portfolio_key": "CBP-080-10", "row_id": "REG-CBP-080-10", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/010_personnel_records_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/022_payroll_time_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/034_leave_accommodation_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/06_complaints/046_complaints_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/09_separation/070_separation_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/094_agency_matters_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/097_junction_foods_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "junction-foods:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-10-05", "issue": "overtime calculation error", "matter_number": "CB-EL-3110", "owner": "Maya Ellison", "portfolio_key": "CBP-080-11", "row_id": "REG-CBP-080-11", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/011_personnel_records_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/023_payroll_time_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/035_leave_accommodation_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/06_complaints/047_complaints_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/097_junction_foods_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "junction-foods:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-10-04", "issue": "complaint escalation gap", "matter_number": "CB-EL-3110", "owner": "Jonas Feld", "portfolio_key": "CBP-080-12", "row_id": "REG-CBP-080-12", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/012_personnel_records_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/024_payroll_time_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/036_leave_accommodation_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/06_complaints/048_complaints_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/08_performance_discipline/060_performance_discipline_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/12_agency_matters/097_junction_foods_impact_population.xlsx"]}], "schema_version": "counselbench.matter-register.v3", "task_id": "cb100-080-junction-foods"}}, "metadata": {"benchmark": "CounselBench-100", "code_license": "Apache-2.0", "data_license": "CC-BY-4.0", "deadline": "2026-10-07", "document_count": 97, "evidence_holds": 3, "jurisdiction": "Iowa", "matter_number": "CB-EL-3110", "mcp_commit": "9a96ea6e5913736f92b88345bf51caeaaa8e719f", "mcp_package": "@modelcontextprotocol/server-filesystem@2026.7.10", "practice_area": "employment", "reference_tool_calls": 79, "required_evidence_reads": 62, "supported_actions": 9, "synthetic": true, "venue": "Iowa Civil Rights Commission", "version": "3.1.0"}, "prompt": "I need to know what is proven, what we can do about it, and what is still only an evidence gap. Can Junction submit the agency response, and which payroll or accommodation commitments remain unfulfilled? Shift records, accommodations, training, payroll corrections, and agency commitments contain conflicting dates and owners. The team needs the call by 2026-10-07. Capture the supported action and the remaining holds so the next reviewer can reproduce the call.", "rubric": {"criteria": [{"category": "investigation", "description": "Inventory the production and use targeted searches to locate records across native formats.", "id": "investigation.discover_production"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Complete every task-specific identity, authority, operations, and approval read before the first state transition.", "id": "investigation.read_before_write"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Inspect designated source metadata before relying on those records.", "id": "investigation.custody_before_write"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "Select the supported option 'junction-foods:scoped-evidence' after applying the four-part test.", "id": "decision.selected_option"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "Identify both rejected approaches and explain why a one-source shortcut and a blanket hold are wrong.", "id": "decision.alternatives"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-080-01 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/001_handbooks_policies_source_export.md rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-080-01.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/013_personnel_records_source_export.json for agency response commitment.", "id": "investigation.CBP-080-01.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/025_compensation_equity_source_export.md to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-080-01.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/037_leave_accommodation_source_export.json.", "id": "investigation.CBP-080-01.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-080-01 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is the operational record relies on a superseded control revision.", "id": "decision.CBP-080-01.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-080-01 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-080-01.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-080-02 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/002_handbooks_policies_source_export.txt rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-080-02.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/014_personnel_records_source_export.xml for leave designation delay.", "id": "investigation.CBP-080-02.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/026_compensation_equity_source_export.txt to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-080-02.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/038_leave_accommodation_source_export.xml.", "id": "investigation.CBP-080-02.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-080-02 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key.", "id": "decision.CBP-080-02.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-080-02 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-080-02.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-080-03 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/003_handbooks_policies_source_export.eml rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-080-03.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/015_personnel_records_source_export.html for retaliation timing.", "id": "investigation.CBP-080-03.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/027_compensation_equity_source_export.eml to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-080-03.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/039_leave_accommodation_source_export.html.", "id": "investigation.CBP-080-03.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-080-03 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-080-03.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-080-03 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-080-03.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-080-04 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/004_handbooks_policies_source_export.csv rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-080-04.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/016_personnel_records_source_export.pdf for personnel-file access deadline.", "id": "investigation.CBP-080-04.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/028_compensation_equity_source_export.csv to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-080-04.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/040_leave_accommodation_source_export.pdf.", "id": "investigation.CBP-080-04.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-080-04 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-080-04.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-080-04 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-080-04.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-080-05 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/005_handbooks_policies_source_export.json rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-080-05.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/017_payroll_time_source_export.md for pay-equity outlier.", "id": "investigation.CBP-080-05.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/029_compensation_equity_source_export.json to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-080-05.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_complaints/041_complaints_source_export.md.", "id": "investigation.CBP-080-05.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-080-05 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-080-05.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-080-05 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-080-05.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-080-06 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/006_handbooks_policies_source_export.xml rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-080-06.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/018_payroll_time_source_export.txt for discipline comparator inconsistency.", "id": "investigation.CBP-080-06.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/030_compensation_equity_source_export.xml to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-080-06.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_complaints/042_complaints_source_export.txt.", "id": "investigation.CBP-080-06.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-080-06 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key.", "id": "decision.CBP-080-06.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-080-06 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-080-06.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-080-07 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/007_handbooks_policies_source_export.html rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-080-07.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/019_payroll_time_source_export.eml for training completion gap.", "id": "investigation.CBP-080-07.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/031_compensation_equity_source_export.html to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-080-07.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_complaints/043_complaints_source_export.eml.", "id": "investigation.CBP-080-07.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-080-07 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-080-07.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-080-07 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-080-07.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-080-08 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_handbooks_policies/008_handbooks_policies_source_export.pdf rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-080-08.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/020_payroll_time_source_export.csv for meal-period premium gap.", "id": "investigation.CBP-080-08.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_compensation_equity/032_compensation_equity_source_export.pdf to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-080-08.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_complaints/044_complaints_source_export.csv.", "id": "investigation.CBP-080-08.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-080-08 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-080-08.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-080-08 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-080-08.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-080-09 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/009_personnel_records_source_export.md rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-080-09.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/021_payroll_time_source_export.json for investigation independence concern.", "id": "investigation.CBP-080-09.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/033_leave_accommodation_source_export.md to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-080-09.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_complaints/045_complaints_source_export.json.", "id": "investigation.CBP-080-09.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-080-09 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-080-09.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-080-09 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-080-09.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-080-10 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/010_personnel_records_source_export.txt rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-080-10.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/022_payroll_time_source_export.xml for contractor control evidence.", "id": "investigation.CBP-080-10.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/034_leave_accommodation_source_export.txt to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-080-10.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_complaints/046_complaints_source_export.xml.", "id": "investigation.CBP-080-10.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-080-10 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-080-10.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-080-10 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-080-10.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-080-11 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/011_personnel_records_source_export.eml rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-080-11.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/023_payroll_time_source_export.html for overtime calculation error.", "id": "investigation.CBP-080-11.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/035_leave_accommodation_source_export.eml to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-080-11.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_complaints/047_complaints_source_export.html.", "id": "investigation.CBP-080-11.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-080-11 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-080-11.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-080-11 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-080-11.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-080-12 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_personnel_records/012_personnel_records_source_export.csv rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-080-12.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_payroll_time/024_payroll_time_source_export.pdf for complaint escalation gap.", "id": "investigation.CBP-080-12.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_leave_accommodation/036_leave_accommodation_source_export.csv to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-080-12.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_complaints/048_complaints_source_export.pdf.", "id": "investigation.CBP-080-12.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-080-12 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-080-12.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-080-12 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-080-12.register"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Write the exact selected option, supported action population, evidence-hold population, facts, owners, deadlines, and citations.", "id": "state.exact_decision"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create one exact register row per portfolio key with no extra, missing, or modified row.", "id": "state.exact_register"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Leave only the three approved deliverables and perform no extra state-changing write.", "id": "state.write_scope_containment"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Read back decision.json, matter-register.json, and advice.md after their final writes.", "id": "state.postwrite_readback"}, {"category": "answer", "description": "Explain the selected recommendation, supported actions, holds, alternatives, and limitations with exact source anchors.", "id": "answer.decision_note"}], "decision_options": [{"approach": "Use a plausible summary or one source without completing the controlling joins.", "id": "junction-foods:shortcut", "label": "Certify full compliance from aggregate completion reports."}, {"approach": "Treat supported actions and genuinely ambiguous records as if they were equally unresolved.", "id": "junction-foods:blanket-hold", "label": "Freeze the entire matter population"}, {"approach": "Apply the exact identity, current-state, authority, and revision test. Create employee-commitment rows with exact completion or hold status.", "id": "junction-foods:scoped-evidence", "label": "Correct supported gaps and submit a bounded response that identifies open commitments."}], "evaluation_narrative": {"authority": "Agency commitments and underlying wage and accommodation duties require exact completion evidence.", "observation": "Reconcile shifts, accommodations, training, corrections, response drafts, and committed dates by employee.", "question": "Can Junction submit the agency response, and which payroll or accommodation commitments remain unfulfilled?", "register_action": "Create employee-commitment rows with exact completion or hold status."}, "gates": ["all_required_evidence_precedes_first_write", "decision_criteria_complete", "register_state_exact", "write_scope_contained", "all_outputs_verified_by_readback"], "metadata_checks": 4, "metric": "weighted_criteria_score", "minimum_tool_calls": 79, "required_deliverables": ["decision.json", "matter-register.json", "advice.md"], "required_document_reads": 62, "type": "deterministic", "weights": {"advice": 0.15, "decision": 0.35, "investigation": 0.25, "state": 0.25}}, "task_id": "cb100-080-junction-foods", "task_name": "Junction Foods agency response check", "world_id": "counselbench-filesystem-mcp-v3"}
+{"context_files": ["task_files/cb100-081-aperture-robotics/01_patents/001_patents_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-081-aperture-robotics/01_patents/002_patents_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-081-aperture-robotics/01_patents/003_patents_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-081-aperture-robotics/01_patents/004_patents_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-081-aperture-robotics/01_patents/005_patents_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-081-aperture-robotics/01_patents/006_patents_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-081-aperture-robotics/01_patents/007_patents_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-081-aperture-robotics/01_patents/008_patents_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-081-aperture-robotics/02_trademarks/009_trademarks_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-081-aperture-robotics/02_trademarks/010_trademarks_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-081-aperture-robotics/02_trademarks/011_trademarks_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-081-aperture-robotics/02_trademarks/012_trademarks_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-081-aperture-robotics/02_trademarks/013_trademarks_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-081-aperture-robotics/02_trademarks/014_trademarks_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-081-aperture-robotics/02_trademarks/015_trademarks_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-081-aperture-robotics/02_trademarks/016_trademarks_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-081-aperture-robotics/03_copyrights/017_copyrights_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-081-aperture-robotics/03_copyrights/018_copyrights_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-081-aperture-robotics/03_copyrights/019_copyrights_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-081-aperture-robotics/03_copyrights/020_copyrights_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-081-aperture-robotics/03_copyrights/021_copyrights_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-081-aperture-robotics/03_copyrights/022_copyrights_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-081-aperture-robotics/03_copyrights/023_copyrights_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-081-aperture-robotics/03_copyrights/024_copyrights_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-081-aperture-robotics/04_invention_assignments/025_invention_assignments_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-081-aperture-robotics/04_invention_assignments/026_invention_assignments_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-081-aperture-robotics/04_invention_assignments/027_invention_assignments_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-081-aperture-robotics/04_invention_assignments/028_invention_assignments_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-081-aperture-robotics/04_invention_assignments/029_invention_assignments_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-081-aperture-robotics/04_invention_assignments/030_invention_assignments_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-081-aperture-robotics/04_invention_assignments/031_invention_assignments_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-081-aperture-robotics/04_invention_assignments/032_invention_assignments_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-081-aperture-robotics/05_licenses_in/033_licenses_in_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-081-aperture-robotics/05_licenses_in/034_licenses_in_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-081-aperture-robotics/05_licenses_in/035_licenses_in_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-081-aperture-robotics/05_licenses_in/036_licenses_in_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-081-aperture-robotics/05_licenses_in/037_licenses_in_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-081-aperture-robotics/05_licenses_in/038_licenses_in_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-081-aperture-robotics/05_licenses_in/039_licenses_in_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-081-aperture-robotics/05_licenses_in/040_licenses_in_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-081-aperture-robotics/06_licenses_out/041_licenses_out_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-081-aperture-robotics/06_licenses_out/042_licenses_out_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-081-aperture-robotics/06_licenses_out/043_licenses_out_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-081-aperture-robotics/06_licenses_out/044_licenses_out_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-081-aperture-robotics/06_licenses_out/045_licenses_out_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-081-aperture-robotics/06_licenses_out/046_licenses_out_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-081-aperture-robotics/06_licenses_out/047_licenses_out_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-081-aperture-robotics/06_licenses_out/048_licenses_out_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-081-aperture-robotics/07_open_source/049_open_source_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-081-aperture-robotics/07_open_source/050_open_source_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-081-aperture-robotics/07_open_source/051_open_source_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-081-aperture-robotics/07_open_source/052_open_source_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-081-aperture-robotics/07_open_source/053_open_source_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-081-aperture-robotics/07_open_source/054_open_source_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-081-aperture-robotics/07_open_source/055_open_source_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-081-aperture-robotics/07_open_source/056_open_source_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-081-aperture-robotics/08_domain_accounts/057_domain_accounts_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-081-aperture-robotics/08_domain_accounts/058_domain_accounts_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-081-aperture-robotics/08_domain_accounts/059_domain_accounts_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-081-aperture-robotics/08_domain_accounts/060_domain_accounts_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-081-aperture-robotics/08_domain_accounts/061_domain_accounts_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-081-aperture-robotics/08_domain_accounts/062_domain_accounts_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-081-aperture-robotics/08_domain_accounts/063_domain_accounts_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-081-aperture-robotics/08_domain_accounts/064_domain_accounts_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-081-aperture-robotics/09_development_records/065_development_records_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-081-aperture-robotics/09_development_records/066_development_records_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-081-aperture-robotics/09_development_records/067_development_records_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-081-aperture-robotics/09_development_records/068_development_records_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-081-aperture-robotics/09_development_records/069_development_records_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-081-aperture-robotics/09_development_records/070_development_records_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-081-aperture-robotics/09_development_records/071_development_records_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-081-aperture-robotics/09_development_records/072_development_records_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-081-aperture-robotics/10_disputes/073_disputes_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-081-aperture-robotics/10_disputes/074_disputes_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-081-aperture-robotics/10_disputes/075_disputes_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-081-aperture-robotics/10_disputes/076_disputes_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-081-aperture-robotics/10_disputes/077_disputes_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-081-aperture-robotics/10_disputes/078_disputes_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-081-aperture-robotics/10_disputes/079_disputes_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-081-aperture-robotics/10_disputes/080_disputes_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-081-aperture-robotics/11_maintenance/081_maintenance_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-081-aperture-robotics/11_maintenance/082_maintenance_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-081-aperture-robotics/11_maintenance/083_maintenance_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-081-aperture-robotics/11_maintenance/084_maintenance_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-081-aperture-robotics/11_maintenance/085_maintenance_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-081-aperture-robotics/11_maintenance/086_maintenance_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-081-aperture-robotics/11_maintenance/087_maintenance_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-081-aperture-robotics/11_maintenance/088_maintenance_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-081-aperture-robotics/12_security_interests/089_security_interests_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-081-aperture-robotics/12_security_interests/090_security_interests_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-081-aperture-robotics/12_security_interests/091_security_interests_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-081-aperture-robotics/12_security_interests/092_security_interests_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-081-aperture-robotics/12_security_interests/093_security_interests_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-081-aperture-robotics/12_security_interests/094_security_interests_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-081-aperture-robotics/12_security_interests/095_security_interests_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-081-aperture-robotics/12_security_interests/096_security_interests_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-081-aperture-robotics/12_security_interests/097_aperture_robotics_impact_population.xlsx"], "gold_output": {"advice_markdown": "# Decision note — Aperture robotics chain-of-title review\n\n## Recommendation\n\nCure supported assignments or releases before representing clean title. The reconciled record supports 5 scoped actions and leaves 7 items on evidence hold.\n\nSelected option: `aperture-robotics:scoped-evidence`.\n\n## Why this is the supported option\n\nJoin inventors, assignments, repositories, university grants, and security interests by asset and entity. Executed chain-of-title and recorded releases govern ownership; access and employment alone do not.\n\n## Supported actions\n\n### CBP-081-01 — inventor assignment gap (medium)\n\ncompletion is required by 2025-09-09 under CB-IP-3201-R766; the current event record shows completion on 2025-09-30 under CB-IP-3201-E298. Identity resolves to ENT-081-1000, revision REV-2025.1 is current, and Elliot Mercer is active with capacity 6.\n\nAction: Create asset-interest rows and quarantine ambiguous contributor identities. Owner: Elliot Mercer; due 2026-09-03.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_patents/001_patents_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/02_trademarks/013_trademarks_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/025_invention_assignments_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/037_licenses_in_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/11_maintenance/085_maintenance_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/097_aperture_robotics_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-081-02 — coexistence restriction (medium)\n\nthe controlling threshold is 15% under CB-IP-3201-R122; the independently calculated result is 22% under CB-IP-3201-E736. Identity resolves to ENT-081-1001, revision REV-2025.2 is current, and Sofia Bennett is active with capacity 1.\n\nAction: Create asset-interest rows and quarantine ambiguous contributor identities. Owner: Sofia Bennett; due 2026-09-02.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_patents/002_patents_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/02_trademarks/014_trademarks_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/026_invention_assignments_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/038_licenses_in_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/08_domain_accounts/062_domain_accounts_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/11_maintenance/086_maintenance_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/097_aperture_robotics_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-081-04 — security-interest release gap (medium)\n\nthe controlled population contains 155 records under CB-IP-3201-R133; the certification covers 127 records under CB-IP-3201-E154. Identity resolves to ENT-081-1003, revision REV-2025.4 is current, and Nora Chen is active with capacity 3.\n\nAction: Create asset-interest rows and quarantine ambiguous contributor identities. Owner: Nora Chen; due 2026-08-31.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_patents/004_patents_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/02_trademarks/016_trademarks_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/028_invention_assignments_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/040_licenses_in_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/07_open_source/052_open_source_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/097_aperture_robotics_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-081-08 — foreign-filing restriction (low)\n\nan open exception blocks completion under CB-IP-3201-R695; the current status is open and unresolved under CB-IP-3201-E187. Identity resolves to ENT-081-1007, revision REV-2025.1 is current, and Talia Brooks is active with capacity 6.\n\nAction: Create asset-interest rows and quarantine ambiguous contributor identities. Owner: Talia Brooks; due 2026-08-27.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_patents/008_patents_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/03_copyrights/020_copyrights_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/032_invention_assignments_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/044_licenses_out_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/092_security_interests_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/09_development_records/068_development_records_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/097_aperture_robotics_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-081-09 — inbound-license field restriction (medium)\n\ncompletion is required by 2025-07-22 under CB-IP-3201-R357; the current event record shows completion on 2025-09-04 under CB-IP-3201-E697. Identity resolves to ENT-081-1008, revision REV-2025.2 is current, and Adrian Mensah is active with capacity 2.\n\nAction: Create asset-interest rows and quarantine ambiguous contributor identities. Owner: Adrian Mensah; due 2026-08-26.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/02_trademarks/009_trademarks_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/03_copyrights/021_copyrights_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/033_licenses_in_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/045_licenses_out_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/097_aperture_robotics_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n## Evidence holds\n\n- **CBP-081-03 — copyleft distribution trigger**: the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective. Next evidence: effective approval and an active owner with remaining capacity. Sources: `/workspace/documents/01_patents/003_patents_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/02_trademarks/015_trademarks_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/027_invention_assignments_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/039_licenses_in_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/08_domain_accounts/063_domain_accounts_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/097_aperture_robotics_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-081-05 — trademark specimen issue**: two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key. Next evidence: an approved immutable entity crosswalk. Sources: `/workspace/documents/01_patents/005_patents_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/03_copyrights/017_copyrights_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/029_invention_assignments_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/041_licenses_out_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/089_security_interests_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/097_aperture_robotics_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-081-06 — outbound sublicense overreach**: the current observation does not meet the operative trigger. Next evidence: a current observation that satisfies the operative trigger. Sources: `/workspace/documents/01_patents/006_patents_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/03_copyrights/018_copyrights_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/030_invention_assignments_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/042_licenses_out_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/10_disputes/078_disputes_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/09_development_records/066_development_records_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/097_aperture_robotics_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-081-07 — cease-and-desist deadline**: the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective. Next evidence: effective approval and an active owner with remaining capacity. Sources: `/workspace/documents/01_patents/007_patents_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/03_copyrights/019_copyrights_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/031_invention_assignments_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/043_licenses_out_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/091_security_interests_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/10_disputes/079_disputes_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/097_aperture_robotics_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-081-10 — repository access anomaly**: the current observation does not meet the operative trigger. Next evidence: a current observation that satisfies the operative trigger. Sources: `/workspace/documents/02_trademarks/010_trademarks_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/03_copyrights/022_copyrights_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/034_licenses_in_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/046_licenses_out_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/097_aperture_robotics_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-081-11 — maintenance-fee deadline**: the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective. Next evidence: effective approval and an active owner with remaining capacity. Sources: `/workspace/documents/02_trademarks/011_trademarks_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/03_copyrights/023_copyrights_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/035_licenses_in_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/047_licenses_out_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/097_aperture_robotics_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-081-12 — source-code ownership gap**: the operational record relies on a superseded control revision. Next evidence: an operational record using the current effective revision. Sources: `/workspace/documents/02_trademarks/012_trademarks_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/03_copyrights/024_copyrights_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/036_licenses_in_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/048_licenses_out_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/11_maintenance/084_maintenance_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/097_aperture_robotics_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n## Alternatives considered\n\n- `aperture-robotics:blanket-hold` — Freeze the entire matter population: Treat supported actions and genuinely ambiguous records as if they were equally unresolved.\n- `aperture-robotics:shortcut` — Treat possession of source and patent prosecution control as complete ownership.: Use a plausible summary or one source without completing the controlling joins.\n\n## Assumptions and limits\n\nThis decision is limited to cb100-081-aperture-robotics, the supplied synthetic records, and the matter state as of 2026-09-04. Similar names, stale revisions, and pending authority are not treated as proof.\n", "decision": {"actions": [{"determination": "completion is required by 2025-09-09 under CB-IP-3201-R766; the current event record shows completion on 2025-09-30 under CB-IP-3201-E298. Identity resolves to ENT-081-1000, revision REV-2025.1 is current, and Elliot Mercer is active with capacity 6.", "due_date": "2026-09-03", "id": "ACT-CBP-081-01", "identity_id": "ENT-081-1000", "issue": "inventor assignment gap", "owner": "Elliot Mercer", "portfolio_key": "CBP-081-01", "recommended_action": "Create asset-interest rows and quarantine ambiguous contributor identities. Owner: Elliot Mercer; due 2026-09-03.", "severity": "medium", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_patents/001_patents_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/02_trademarks/013_trademarks_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/025_invention_assignments_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/037_licenses_in_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/11_maintenance/085_maintenance_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/097_aperture_robotics_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "the controlling threshold is 15% under CB-IP-3201-R122; the independently calculated result is 22% under CB-IP-3201-E736. Identity resolves to ENT-081-1001, revision REV-2025.2 is current, and Sofia Bennett is active with capacity 1.", "due_date": "2026-09-02", "id": "ACT-CBP-081-02", "identity_id": "ENT-081-1001", "issue": "coexistence restriction", "owner": "Sofia Bennett", "portfolio_key": "CBP-081-02", "recommended_action": "Create asset-interest rows and quarantine ambiguous contributor identities. Owner: Sofia Bennett; due 2026-09-02.", "severity": "medium", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_patents/002_patents_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/02_trademarks/014_trademarks_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/026_invention_assignments_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/038_licenses_in_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/08_domain_accounts/062_domain_accounts_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/11_maintenance/086_maintenance_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/097_aperture_robotics_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "the controlled population contains 155 records under CB-IP-3201-R133; the certification covers 127 records under CB-IP-3201-E154. Identity resolves to ENT-081-1003, revision REV-2025.4 is current, and Nora Chen is active with capacity 3.", "due_date": "2026-08-31", "id": "ACT-CBP-081-04", "identity_id": "ENT-081-1003", "issue": "security-interest release gap", "owner": "Nora Chen", "portfolio_key": "CBP-081-04", "recommended_action": "Create asset-interest rows and quarantine ambiguous contributor identities. Owner: Nora Chen; due 2026-08-31.", "severity": "medium", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_patents/004_patents_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/02_trademarks/016_trademarks_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/028_invention_assignments_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/040_licenses_in_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/07_open_source/052_open_source_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/097_aperture_robotics_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "an open exception blocks completion under CB-IP-3201-R695; the current status is open and unresolved under CB-IP-3201-E187. Identity resolves to ENT-081-1007, revision REV-2025.1 is current, and Talia Brooks is active with capacity 6.", "due_date": "2026-08-27", "id": "ACT-CBP-081-08", "identity_id": "ENT-081-1007", "issue": "foreign-filing restriction", "owner": "Talia Brooks", "portfolio_key": "CBP-081-08", "recommended_action": "Create asset-interest rows and quarantine ambiguous contributor identities. Owner: Talia Brooks; due 2026-08-27.", "severity": "low", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_patents/008_patents_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/03_copyrights/020_copyrights_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/032_invention_assignments_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/044_licenses_out_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/092_security_interests_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/09_development_records/068_development_records_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/097_aperture_robotics_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "completion is required by 2025-07-22 under CB-IP-3201-R357; the current event record shows completion on 2025-09-04 under CB-IP-3201-E697. Identity resolves to ENT-081-1008, revision REV-2025.2 is current, and Adrian Mensah is active with capacity 2.", "due_date": "2026-08-26", "id": "ACT-CBP-081-09", "identity_id": "ENT-081-1008", "issue": "inbound-license field restriction", "owner": "Adrian Mensah", "portfolio_key": "CBP-081-09", "recommended_action": "Create asset-interest rows and quarantine ambiguous contributor identities. Owner: Adrian Mensah; due 2026-08-26.", "severity": "medium", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_trademarks/009_trademarks_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/03_copyrights/021_copyrights_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/033_licenses_in_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/045_licenses_out_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/097_aperture_robotics_impact_population.xlsx"]}], "as_of": "2026-09-04", "decision": {"alternatives_considered": ["aperture-robotics:blanket-hold", "aperture-robotics:shortcut"], "question": "Does Aperture own the robotics portfolio free of university, contractor, founder, or lender claims?", "rationale": "The four-part causal test supports 5 scoped actions and leaves 7 records on evidence hold. Executed chain-of-title and recorded releases govern ownership; access and employment alone do not.", "recommendation": "Cure supported assignments or releases before representing clean title.", "selected_option_id": "aperture-robotics:scoped-evidence"}, "holds": [{"id": "HOLD-CBP-081-03", "issue": "copyleft distribution trigger", "portfolio_key": "CBP-081-03", "reason": "the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective", "required_next_evidence": "effective approval and an active owner with remaining capacity", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_patents/003_patents_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/02_trademarks/015_trademarks_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/027_invention_assignments_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/039_licenses_in_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/08_domain_accounts/063_domain_accounts_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/097_aperture_robotics_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-081-05", "issue": "trademark specimen issue", "portfolio_key": "CBP-081-05", "reason": "two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key", "required_next_evidence": "an approved immutable entity crosswalk", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_patents/005_patents_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/03_copyrights/017_copyrights_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/029_invention_assignments_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/041_licenses_out_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/089_security_interests_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/097_aperture_robotics_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-081-06", "issue": "outbound sublicense overreach", "portfolio_key": "CBP-081-06", "reason": "the current observation does not meet the operative trigger", "required_next_evidence": "a current observation that satisfies the operative trigger", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_patents/006_patents_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/03_copyrights/018_copyrights_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/030_invention_assignments_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/042_licenses_out_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/10_disputes/078_disputes_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/09_development_records/066_development_records_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/097_aperture_robotics_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-081-07", "issue": "cease-and-desist deadline", "portfolio_key": "CBP-081-07", "reason": "the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective", "required_next_evidence": "effective approval and an active owner with remaining capacity", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_patents/007_patents_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/03_copyrights/019_copyrights_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/031_invention_assignments_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/043_licenses_out_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/091_security_interests_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/10_disputes/079_disputes_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/097_aperture_robotics_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-081-10", "issue": "repository access anomaly", "portfolio_key": "CBP-081-10", "reason": "the current observation does not meet the operative trigger", "required_next_evidence": "a current observation that satisfies the operative trigger", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_trademarks/010_trademarks_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/03_copyrights/022_copyrights_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/034_licenses_in_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/046_licenses_out_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/097_aperture_robotics_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-081-11", "issue": "maintenance-fee deadline", "portfolio_key": "CBP-081-11", "reason": "the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective", "required_next_evidence": "effective approval and an active owner with remaining capacity", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_trademarks/011_trademarks_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/03_copyrights/023_copyrights_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/035_licenses_in_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/047_licenses_out_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/097_aperture_robotics_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-081-12", "issue": "source-code ownership gap", "portfolio_key": "CBP-081-12", "reason": "the operational record relies on a superseded control revision", "required_next_evidence": "an operational record using the current effective revision", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_trademarks/012_trademarks_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/03_copyrights/024_copyrights_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/036_licenses_in_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/048_licenses_out_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/11_maintenance/084_maintenance_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/097_aperture_robotics_impact_population.xlsx"]}], "matter_number": "CB-IP-3201", "prepared_for": "Aperture Robotics, Inc.", "schema_version": "counselbench.decision.v3", "task_id": "cb100-081-aperture-robotics"}, "matter_register": {"matter_number": "CB-IP-3201", "rows": [{"decision_option_id": "aperture-robotics:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-03", "issue": "inventor assignment gap", "matter_number": "CB-IP-3201", "owner": "Elliot Mercer", "portfolio_key": "CBP-081-01", "row_id": "REG-CBP-081-01", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_patents/001_patents_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/02_trademarks/013_trademarks_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/025_invention_assignments_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/037_licenses_in_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/11_maintenance/085_maintenance_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/097_aperture_robotics_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "aperture-robotics:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-02", "issue": "coexistence restriction", "matter_number": "CB-IP-3201", "owner": "Sofia Bennett", "portfolio_key": "CBP-081-02", "row_id": "REG-CBP-081-02", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_patents/002_patents_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/02_trademarks/014_trademarks_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/026_invention_assignments_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/038_licenses_in_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/08_domain_accounts/062_domain_accounts_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/11_maintenance/086_maintenance_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/097_aperture_robotics_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "aperture-robotics:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective", "issue": "copyleft distribution trigger", "matter_number": "CB-IP-3201", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-081-03", "row_id": "REG-CBP-081-03", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_patents/003_patents_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/02_trademarks/015_trademarks_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/027_invention_assignments_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/039_licenses_in_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/08_domain_accounts/063_domain_accounts_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/097_aperture_robotics_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "aperture-robotics:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-08-31", "issue": "security-interest release gap", "matter_number": "CB-IP-3201", "owner": "Nora Chen", "portfolio_key": "CBP-081-04", "row_id": "REG-CBP-081-04", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_patents/004_patents_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/02_trademarks/016_trademarks_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/028_invention_assignments_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/040_licenses_in_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/07_open_source/052_open_source_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/097_aperture_robotics_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "aperture-robotics:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key", "issue": "trademark specimen issue", "matter_number": "CB-IP-3201", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-081-05", "row_id": "REG-CBP-081-05", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_patents/005_patents_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/03_copyrights/017_copyrights_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/029_invention_assignments_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/041_licenses_out_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/089_security_interests_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/097_aperture_robotics_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "aperture-robotics:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "the current observation does not meet the operative trigger", "issue": "outbound sublicense overreach", "matter_number": "CB-IP-3201", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-081-06", "row_id": "REG-CBP-081-06", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_patents/006_patents_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/03_copyrights/018_copyrights_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/030_invention_assignments_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/042_licenses_out_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/10_disputes/078_disputes_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/09_development_records/066_development_records_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/097_aperture_robotics_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "aperture-robotics:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective", "issue": "cease-and-desist deadline", "matter_number": "CB-IP-3201", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-081-07", "row_id": "REG-CBP-081-07", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_patents/007_patents_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/03_copyrights/019_copyrights_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/031_invention_assignments_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/043_licenses_out_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/091_security_interests_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/10_disputes/079_disputes_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/097_aperture_robotics_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "aperture-robotics:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-08-27", "issue": "foreign-filing restriction", "matter_number": "CB-IP-3201", "owner": "Talia Brooks", "portfolio_key": "CBP-081-08", "row_id": "REG-CBP-081-08", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_patents/008_patents_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/03_copyrights/020_copyrights_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/032_invention_assignments_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/044_licenses_out_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/092_security_interests_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/09_development_records/068_development_records_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/097_aperture_robotics_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "aperture-robotics:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-08-26", "issue": "inbound-license field restriction", "matter_number": "CB-IP-3201", "owner": "Adrian Mensah", "portfolio_key": "CBP-081-09", "row_id": "REG-CBP-081-09", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_trademarks/009_trademarks_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/03_copyrights/021_copyrights_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/033_licenses_in_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/045_licenses_out_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/097_aperture_robotics_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "aperture-robotics:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "the current observation does not meet the operative trigger", "issue": "repository access anomaly", "matter_number": "CB-IP-3201", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-081-10", "row_id": "REG-CBP-081-10", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_trademarks/010_trademarks_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/03_copyrights/022_copyrights_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/034_licenses_in_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/046_licenses_out_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/097_aperture_robotics_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "aperture-robotics:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective", "issue": "maintenance-fee deadline", "matter_number": "CB-IP-3201", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-081-11", "row_id": "REG-CBP-081-11", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_trademarks/011_trademarks_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/03_copyrights/023_copyrights_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/035_licenses_in_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/047_licenses_out_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/097_aperture_robotics_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "aperture-robotics:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "the operational record relies on a superseded control revision", "issue": "source-code ownership gap", "matter_number": "CB-IP-3201", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-081-12", "row_id": "REG-CBP-081-12", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_trademarks/012_trademarks_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/03_copyrights/024_copyrights_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/036_licenses_in_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/048_licenses_out_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/11_maintenance/084_maintenance_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/097_aperture_robotics_impact_population.xlsx"]}], "schema_version": "counselbench.matter-register.v3", "task_id": "cb100-081-aperture-robotics"}}, "metadata": {"benchmark": "CounselBench-100", "code_license": "Apache-2.0", "data_license": "CC-BY-4.0", "deadline": "2026-09-04", "document_count": 97, "evidence_holds": 7, "jurisdiction": "Delaware", "matter_number": "CB-IP-3201", "mcp_commit": "9a96ea6e5913736f92b88345bf51caeaaa8e719f", "mcp_package": "@modelcontextprotocol/server-filesystem@2026.7.10", "practice_area": "ip-technology", "reference_tool_calls": 85, "required_evidence_reads": 62, "supported_actions": 5, "synthetic": true, "venue": "United States Patent and Trademark Office", "version": "3.1.0"}, "prompt": "I need a straight answer before the next partner call. Does Aperture own the robotics portfolio free of university, contractor, founder, or lender claims? Robotics patents and source repositories include founder, contractor, university, and lender interests that are not consistently recorded. The team needs the call by 2026-09-04. Update the matter record only where the evidence supports it, and give me the practical options for the client.", "rubric": {"criteria": [{"category": "investigation", "description": "Inventory the production and use targeted searches to locate records across native formats.", "id": "investigation.discover_production"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Complete every task-specific identity, authority, operations, and approval read before the first state transition.", "id": "investigation.read_before_write"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Inspect designated source metadata before relying on those records.", "id": "investigation.custody_before_write"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "Select the supported option 'aperture-robotics:scoped-evidence' after applying the four-part test.", "id": "decision.selected_option"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "Identify both rejected approaches and explain why a one-source shortcut and a blanket hold are wrong.", "id": "decision.alternatives"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-081-01 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_patents/001_patents_source_export.md rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-081-01.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_trademarks/013_trademarks_source_export.json for inventor assignment gap.", "id": "investigation.CBP-081-01.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/025_invention_assignments_source_export.md to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-081-01.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/037_licenses_in_source_export.json.", "id": "investigation.CBP-081-01.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-081-01 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-081-01.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-081-01 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-081-01.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-081-02 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_patents/002_patents_source_export.txt rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-081-02.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_trademarks/014_trademarks_source_export.xml for coexistence restriction.", "id": "investigation.CBP-081-02.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/026_invention_assignments_source_export.txt to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-081-02.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/038_licenses_in_source_export.xml.", "id": "investigation.CBP-081-02.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-081-02 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-081-02.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-081-02 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-081-02.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-081-03 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_patents/003_patents_source_export.eml rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-081-03.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_trademarks/015_trademarks_source_export.html for copyleft distribution trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-081-03.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/027_invention_assignments_source_export.eml to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-081-03.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/039_licenses_in_source_export.html.", "id": "investigation.CBP-081-03.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-081-03 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective.", "id": "decision.CBP-081-03.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-081-03 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-081-03.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-081-04 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_patents/004_patents_source_export.csv rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-081-04.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_trademarks/016_trademarks_source_export.pdf for security-interest release gap.", "id": "investigation.CBP-081-04.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/028_invention_assignments_source_export.csv to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-081-04.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/040_licenses_in_source_export.pdf.", "id": "investigation.CBP-081-04.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-081-04 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-081-04.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-081-04 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-081-04.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-081-05 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_patents/005_patents_source_export.json rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-081-05.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_copyrights/017_copyrights_source_export.md for trademark specimen issue.", "id": "investigation.CBP-081-05.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/029_invention_assignments_source_export.json to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-081-05.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/041_licenses_out_source_export.md.", "id": "investigation.CBP-081-05.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-081-05 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key.", "id": "decision.CBP-081-05.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-081-05 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-081-05.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-081-06 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_patents/006_patents_source_export.xml rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-081-06.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_copyrights/018_copyrights_source_export.txt for outbound sublicense overreach.", "id": "investigation.CBP-081-06.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/030_invention_assignments_source_export.xml to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-081-06.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/042_licenses_out_source_export.txt.", "id": "investigation.CBP-081-06.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-081-06 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is the current observation does not meet the operative trigger.", "id": "decision.CBP-081-06.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-081-06 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-081-06.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-081-07 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_patents/007_patents_source_export.html rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-081-07.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_copyrights/019_copyrights_source_export.eml for cease-and-desist deadline.", "id": "investigation.CBP-081-07.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/031_invention_assignments_source_export.html to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-081-07.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/043_licenses_out_source_export.eml.", "id": "investigation.CBP-081-07.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-081-07 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective.", "id": "decision.CBP-081-07.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-081-07 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-081-07.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-081-08 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_patents/008_patents_source_export.pdf rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-081-08.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_copyrights/020_copyrights_source_export.csv for foreign-filing restriction.", "id": "investigation.CBP-081-08.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/032_invention_assignments_source_export.pdf to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-081-08.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/044_licenses_out_source_export.csv.", "id": "investigation.CBP-081-08.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-081-08 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-081-08.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-081-08 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-081-08.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-081-09 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_trademarks/009_trademarks_source_export.md rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-081-09.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_copyrights/021_copyrights_source_export.json for inbound-license field restriction.", "id": "investigation.CBP-081-09.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/033_licenses_in_source_export.md to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-081-09.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/045_licenses_out_source_export.json.", "id": "investigation.CBP-081-09.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-081-09 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-081-09.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-081-09 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-081-09.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-081-10 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_trademarks/010_trademarks_source_export.txt rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-081-10.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_copyrights/022_copyrights_source_export.xml for repository access anomaly.", "id": "investigation.CBP-081-10.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/034_licenses_in_source_export.txt to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-081-10.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/046_licenses_out_source_export.xml.", "id": "investigation.CBP-081-10.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-081-10 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is the current observation does not meet the operative trigger.", "id": "decision.CBP-081-10.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-081-10 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-081-10.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-081-11 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_trademarks/011_trademarks_source_export.eml rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-081-11.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_copyrights/023_copyrights_source_export.html for maintenance-fee deadline.", "id": "investigation.CBP-081-11.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/035_licenses_in_source_export.eml to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-081-11.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/047_licenses_out_source_export.html.", "id": "investigation.CBP-081-11.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-081-11 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective.", "id": "decision.CBP-081-11.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-081-11 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-081-11.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-081-12 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_trademarks/012_trademarks_source_export.csv rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-081-12.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_copyrights/024_copyrights_source_export.pdf for source-code ownership gap.", "id": "investigation.CBP-081-12.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/036_licenses_in_source_export.csv to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-081-12.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/048_licenses_out_source_export.pdf.", "id": "investigation.CBP-081-12.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-081-12 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is the operational record relies on a superseded control revision.", "id": "decision.CBP-081-12.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-081-12 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-081-12.register"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Write the exact selected option, supported action population, evidence-hold population, facts, owners, deadlines, and citations.", "id": "state.exact_decision"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create one exact register row per portfolio key with no extra, missing, or modified row.", "id": "state.exact_register"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Leave only the three approved deliverables and perform no extra state-changing write.", "id": "state.write_scope_containment"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Read back decision.json, matter-register.json, and advice.md after their final writes.", "id": "state.postwrite_readback"}, {"category": "answer", "description": "Explain the selected recommendation, supported actions, holds, alternatives, and limitations with exact source anchors.", "id": "answer.decision_note"}], "decision_options": [{"approach": "Treat supported actions and genuinely ambiguous records as if they were equally unresolved.", "id": "aperture-robotics:blanket-hold", "label": "Freeze the entire matter population"}, {"approach": "Apply the exact identity, current-state, authority, and revision test. Create asset-interest rows and quarantine ambiguous contributor identities.", "id": "aperture-robotics:scoped-evidence", "label": "Cure supported assignments or releases before representing clean title."}, {"approach": "Use a plausible summary or one source without completing the controlling joins.", "id": "aperture-robotics:shortcut", "label": "Treat possession of source and patent prosecution control as complete ownership."}], "evaluation_narrative": {"authority": "Executed chain-of-title and recorded releases govern ownership; access and employment alone do not.", "observation": "Join inventors, assignments, repositories, university grants, and security interests by asset and entity.", "question": "Does Aperture own the robotics portfolio free of university, contractor, founder, or lender claims?", "register_action": "Create asset-interest rows and quarantine ambiguous contributor identities."}, "gates": ["all_required_evidence_precedes_first_write", "decision_criteria_complete", "register_state_exact", "write_scope_contained", "all_outputs_verified_by_readback"], "metadata_checks": 11, "metric": "weighted_criteria_score", "minimum_tool_calls": 85, "required_deliverables": ["decision.json", "matter-register.json", "advice.md"], "required_document_reads": 62, "type": "deterministic", "weights": {"advice": 0.15, "decision": 0.35, "investigation": 0.25, "state": 0.25}}, "task_id": "cb100-081-aperture-robotics", "task_name": "Aperture robotics chain-of-title review", "world_id": "counselbench-filesystem-mcp-v3"}
+{"context_files": ["task_files/cb100-082-blue-fern/01_patents/001_patents_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-082-blue-fern/01_patents/002_patents_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-082-blue-fern/01_patents/003_patents_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-082-blue-fern/01_patents/004_patents_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-082-blue-fern/01_patents/005_patents_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-082-blue-fern/01_patents/006_patents_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-082-blue-fern/01_patents/007_patents_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-082-blue-fern/01_patents/008_patents_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-082-blue-fern/02_trademarks/009_trademarks_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-082-blue-fern/02_trademarks/010_trademarks_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-082-blue-fern/02_trademarks/011_trademarks_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-082-blue-fern/02_trademarks/012_trademarks_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-082-blue-fern/02_trademarks/013_trademarks_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-082-blue-fern/02_trademarks/014_trademarks_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-082-blue-fern/02_trademarks/015_trademarks_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-082-blue-fern/02_trademarks/016_trademarks_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-082-blue-fern/03_copyrights/017_copyrights_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-082-blue-fern/03_copyrights/018_copyrights_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-082-blue-fern/03_copyrights/019_copyrights_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-082-blue-fern/03_copyrights/020_copyrights_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-082-blue-fern/03_copyrights/021_copyrights_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-082-blue-fern/03_copyrights/022_copyrights_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-082-blue-fern/03_copyrights/023_copyrights_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-082-blue-fern/03_copyrights/024_copyrights_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-082-blue-fern/04_invention_assignments/025_invention_assignments_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-082-blue-fern/04_invention_assignments/026_invention_assignments_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-082-blue-fern/04_invention_assignments/027_invention_assignments_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-082-blue-fern/04_invention_assignments/028_invention_assignments_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-082-blue-fern/04_invention_assignments/029_invention_assignments_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-082-blue-fern/04_invention_assignments/030_invention_assignments_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-082-blue-fern/04_invention_assignments/031_invention_assignments_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-082-blue-fern/04_invention_assignments/032_invention_assignments_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-082-blue-fern/05_licenses_in/033_licenses_in_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-082-blue-fern/05_licenses_in/034_licenses_in_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-082-blue-fern/05_licenses_in/035_licenses_in_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-082-blue-fern/05_licenses_in/036_licenses_in_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-082-blue-fern/05_licenses_in/037_licenses_in_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-082-blue-fern/05_licenses_in/038_licenses_in_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-082-blue-fern/05_licenses_in/039_licenses_in_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-082-blue-fern/05_licenses_in/040_licenses_in_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-082-blue-fern/06_licenses_out/041_licenses_out_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-082-blue-fern/06_licenses_out/042_licenses_out_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-082-blue-fern/06_licenses_out/043_licenses_out_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-082-blue-fern/06_licenses_out/044_licenses_out_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-082-blue-fern/06_licenses_out/045_licenses_out_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-082-blue-fern/06_licenses_out/046_licenses_out_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-082-blue-fern/06_licenses_out/047_licenses_out_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-082-blue-fern/06_licenses_out/048_licenses_out_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-082-blue-fern/07_open_source/049_open_source_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-082-blue-fern/07_open_source/050_open_source_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-082-blue-fern/07_open_source/051_open_source_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-082-blue-fern/07_open_source/052_open_source_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-082-blue-fern/07_open_source/053_open_source_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-082-blue-fern/07_open_source/054_open_source_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-082-blue-fern/07_open_source/055_open_source_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-082-blue-fern/07_open_source/056_open_source_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-082-blue-fern/08_domain_accounts/057_domain_accounts_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-082-blue-fern/08_domain_accounts/058_domain_accounts_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-082-blue-fern/08_domain_accounts/059_domain_accounts_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-082-blue-fern/08_domain_accounts/060_domain_accounts_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-082-blue-fern/08_domain_accounts/061_domain_accounts_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-082-blue-fern/08_domain_accounts/062_domain_accounts_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-082-blue-fern/08_domain_accounts/063_domain_accounts_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-082-blue-fern/08_domain_accounts/064_domain_accounts_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-082-blue-fern/09_development_records/065_development_records_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-082-blue-fern/09_development_records/066_development_records_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-082-blue-fern/09_development_records/067_development_records_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-082-blue-fern/09_development_records/068_development_records_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-082-blue-fern/09_development_records/069_development_records_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-082-blue-fern/09_development_records/070_development_records_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-082-blue-fern/09_development_records/071_development_records_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-082-blue-fern/09_development_records/072_development_records_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-082-blue-fern/10_disputes/073_disputes_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-082-blue-fern/10_disputes/074_disputes_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-082-blue-fern/10_disputes/075_disputes_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-082-blue-fern/10_disputes/076_disputes_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-082-blue-fern/10_disputes/077_disputes_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-082-blue-fern/10_disputes/078_disputes_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-082-blue-fern/10_disputes/079_disputes_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-082-blue-fern/10_disputes/080_disputes_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-082-blue-fern/11_maintenance/081_maintenance_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-082-blue-fern/11_maintenance/082_maintenance_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-082-blue-fern/11_maintenance/083_maintenance_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-082-blue-fern/11_maintenance/084_maintenance_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-082-blue-fern/11_maintenance/085_maintenance_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-082-blue-fern/11_maintenance/086_maintenance_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-082-blue-fern/11_maintenance/087_maintenance_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-082-blue-fern/11_maintenance/088_maintenance_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-082-blue-fern/12_security_interests/089_security_interests_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-082-blue-fern/12_security_interests/090_security_interests_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-082-blue-fern/12_security_interests/091_security_interests_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-082-blue-fern/12_security_interests/092_security_interests_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-082-blue-fern/12_security_interests/093_security_interests_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-082-blue-fern/12_security_interests/094_security_interests_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-082-blue-fern/12_security_interests/095_security_interests_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-082-blue-fern/12_security_interests/096_security_interests_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-082-blue-fern/12_security_interests/097_blue_fern_impact_population.xlsx"], "gold_output": {"advice_markdown": "# Decision note — Blue Fern brand portfolio audit\n\n## Recommendation\n\nCorrect or condition supported uses without abandoning clean territories. The reconciled record supports 6 scoped actions and leaves 6 items on evidence hold.\n\nSelected option: `blue-fern:scoped-evidence`.\n\n## Why this is the supported option\n\nReconcile registrations, specimens, coexistence terms, domains, and distributor licenses by mark and territory. Current registrations and executed territorial restrictions govern each use.\n\n## Supported actions\n\n### CBP-082-02 — work-for-hire defect (low)\n\ndelivery must use notices-blue_fern_beverages@example.test under CB-IP-3202-R843; the only matched receipt used archive-fern_field_cooperative@example.test under CB-IP-3202-E514. Identity resolves to ENT-082-1001, revision REV-2026.2 is current, and Theo Laurent is active with capacity 1.\n\nAction: Create mark-territory rows with exact right, restriction, and evidence hold. Owner: Theo Laurent; due 2026-09-06.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_patents/002_patents_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/02_trademarks/014_trademarks_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/026_invention_assignments_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/038_licenses_in_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/097_blue_fern_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-082-03 — notice-file omission (critical)\n\nan open exception blocks completion under CB-IP-3202-R564; the current status is open and unresolved under CB-IP-3202-E339. Identity resolves to ENT-082-1002, revision REV-2026.3 is current, and Lena Varga is active with capacity 5.\n\nAction: Create mark-territory rows with exact right, restriction, and evidence hold. Owner: Lena Varga; due 2026-09-05.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_patents/003_patents_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/02_trademarks/015_trademarks_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/027_invention_assignments_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/039_licenses_in_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/097_blue_fern_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-082-05 — coexistence restriction (critical)\n\nthe controlling threshold is 7% under CB-IP-3202-R902; the independently calculated result is 13% under CB-IP-3202-E306. Identity resolves to ENT-082-1004, revision REV-2026.5 is current, and Sofia Bennett is active with capacity 1.\n\nAction: Create mark-territory rows with exact right, restriction, and evidence hold. Owner: Sofia Bennett; due 2026-09-03.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_patents/005_patents_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/03_copyrights/017_copyrights_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/029_invention_assignments_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/041_licenses_out_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/09_development_records/065_development_records_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/097_blue_fern_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-082-06 — copyleft distribution trigger (critical)\n\napproval must come from Maya Ellison under CB-IP-3202-R819; the effective approval record names Henry Cho under CB-IP-3202-E830. Identity resolves to ENT-082-1005, revision REV-2026.6 is current, and Micah Sullivan is active with capacity 3.\n\nAction: Create mark-territory rows with exact right, restriction, and evidence hold. Owner: Micah Sullivan; due 2026-09-02.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_patents/006_patents_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/03_copyrights/018_copyrights_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/030_invention_assignments_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/042_licenses_out_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/090_security_interests_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/07_open_source/054_open_source_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/097_blue_fern_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-082-10 — cease-and-desist deadline (low)\n\ndelivery must use notices-blue_fern_beverages@example.test under CB-IP-3202-R609; the only matched receipt used archive-fern_field_cooperative@example.test under CB-IP-3202-E977. Identity resolves to ENT-082-1009, revision REV-2026.3 is current, and Samuel Kim is active with capacity 6.\n\nAction: Create mark-territory rows with exact right, restriction, and evidence hold. Owner: Samuel Kim; due 2026-09-07.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/02_trademarks/010_trademarks_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/03_copyrights/022_copyrights_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/034_licenses_in_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/046_licenses_out_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/11_maintenance/082_maintenance_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/09_development_records/070_development_records_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/097_blue_fern_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-082-12 — inbound-license field restriction (high)\n\ncompletion is required by 2025-09-25 under CB-IP-3202-R422; the current event record shows completion on 2025-10-20 under CB-IP-3202-E860. Identity resolves to ENT-082-1011, revision REV-2026.5 is current, and Adrian Mensah is active with capacity 4.\n\nAction: Create mark-territory rows with exact right, restriction, and evidence hold. Owner: Adrian Mensah; due 2026-09-05.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/02_trademarks/012_trademarks_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/03_copyrights/024_copyrights_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/036_licenses_in_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/048_licenses_out_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/097_blue_fern_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n## Evidence holds\n\n- **CBP-082-01 — recorded-owner mismatch**: the current observation does not meet the operative trigger. Next evidence: a current observation that satisfies the operative trigger. Sources: `/workspace/documents/01_patents/001_patents_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/02_trademarks/013_trademarks_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/025_invention_assignments_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/037_licenses_in_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/10_disputes/073_disputes_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/097_blue_fern_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-082-04 — inventor assignment gap**: two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key. Next evidence: an approved immutable entity crosswalk. Sources: `/workspace/documents/01_patents/004_patents_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/02_trademarks/016_trademarks_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/028_invention_assignments_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/040_licenses_in_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/10_disputes/076_disputes_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/097_blue_fern_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-082-07 — security-interest release gap**: the operational record relies on a superseded control revision. Next evidence: an operational record using the current effective revision. Sources: `/workspace/documents/01_patents/007_patents_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/03_copyrights/019_copyrights_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/031_invention_assignments_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/043_licenses_out_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/091_security_interests_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/097_blue_fern_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-082-08 — trademark specimen issue**: two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key. Next evidence: an approved immutable entity crosswalk. Sources: `/workspace/documents/01_patents/008_patents_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/03_copyrights/020_copyrights_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/032_invention_assignments_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/044_licenses_out_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/097_blue_fern_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-082-09 — outbound sublicense overreach**: the current observation does not meet the operative trigger. Next evidence: a current observation that satisfies the operative trigger. Sources: `/workspace/documents/02_trademarks/009_trademarks_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/03_copyrights/021_copyrights_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/033_licenses_in_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/045_licenses_out_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/08_domain_accounts/057_domain_accounts_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/097_blue_fern_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-082-11 — foreign-filing restriction**: the operational record relies on a superseded control revision. Next evidence: an operational record using the current effective revision. Sources: `/workspace/documents/02_trademarks/011_trademarks_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/03_copyrights/023_copyrights_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/035_licenses_in_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/047_licenses_out_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/097_blue_fern_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n## Alternatives considered\n\n- `blue-fern:shortcut` — Apply the narrowest restriction to the entire global brand portfolio.: Use a plausible summary or one source without completing the controlling joins.\n- `blue-fern:blanket-hold` — Freeze the entire matter population: Treat supported actions and genuinely ambiguous records as if they were equally unresolved.\n\n## Assumptions and limits\n\nThis decision is limited to cb100-082-blue-fern, the supplied synthetic records, and the matter state as of 2026-09-08. Similar names, stale revisions, and pending authority are not treated as proof.\n", "decision": {"actions": [{"determination": "delivery must use notices-blue_fern_beverages@example.test under CB-IP-3202-R843; the only matched receipt used archive-fern_field_cooperative@example.test under CB-IP-3202-E514. Identity resolves to ENT-082-1001, revision REV-2026.2 is current, and Theo Laurent is active with capacity 1.", "due_date": "2026-09-06", "id": "ACT-CBP-082-02", "identity_id": "ENT-082-1001", "issue": "work-for-hire defect", "owner": "Theo Laurent", "portfolio_key": "CBP-082-02", "recommended_action": "Create mark-territory rows with exact right, restriction, and evidence hold. Owner: Theo Laurent; due 2026-09-06.", "severity": "low", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_patents/002_patents_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/02_trademarks/014_trademarks_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/026_invention_assignments_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/038_licenses_in_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/097_blue_fern_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "an open exception blocks completion under CB-IP-3202-R564; the current status is open and unresolved under CB-IP-3202-E339. Identity resolves to ENT-082-1002, revision REV-2026.3 is current, and Lena Varga is active with capacity 5.", "due_date": "2026-09-05", "id": "ACT-CBP-082-03", "identity_id": "ENT-082-1002", "issue": "notice-file omission", "owner": "Lena Varga", "portfolio_key": "CBP-082-03", "recommended_action": "Create mark-territory rows with exact right, restriction, and evidence hold. Owner: Lena Varga; due 2026-09-05.", "severity": "critical", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_patents/003_patents_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/02_trademarks/015_trademarks_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/027_invention_assignments_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/039_licenses_in_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/097_blue_fern_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "the controlling threshold is 7% under CB-IP-3202-R902; the independently calculated result is 13% under CB-IP-3202-E306. Identity resolves to ENT-082-1004, revision REV-2026.5 is current, and Sofia Bennett is active with capacity 1.", "due_date": "2026-09-03", "id": "ACT-CBP-082-05", "identity_id": "ENT-082-1004", "issue": "coexistence restriction", "owner": "Sofia Bennett", "portfolio_key": "CBP-082-05", "recommended_action": "Create mark-territory rows with exact right, restriction, and evidence hold. Owner: Sofia Bennett; due 2026-09-03.", "severity": "critical", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_patents/005_patents_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/03_copyrights/017_copyrights_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/029_invention_assignments_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/041_licenses_out_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/09_development_records/065_development_records_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/097_blue_fern_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "approval must come from Maya Ellison under CB-IP-3202-R819; the effective approval record names Henry Cho under CB-IP-3202-E830. Identity resolves to ENT-082-1005, revision REV-2026.6 is current, and Micah Sullivan is active with capacity 3.", "due_date": "2026-09-02", "id": "ACT-CBP-082-06", "identity_id": "ENT-082-1005", "issue": "copyleft distribution trigger", "owner": "Micah Sullivan", "portfolio_key": "CBP-082-06", "recommended_action": "Create mark-territory rows with exact right, restriction, and evidence hold. Owner: Micah Sullivan; due 2026-09-02.", "severity": "critical", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_patents/006_patents_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/03_copyrights/018_copyrights_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/030_invention_assignments_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/042_licenses_out_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/090_security_interests_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/07_open_source/054_open_source_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/097_blue_fern_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "delivery must use notices-blue_fern_beverages@example.test under CB-IP-3202-R609; the only matched receipt used archive-fern_field_cooperative@example.test under CB-IP-3202-E977. Identity resolves to ENT-082-1009, revision REV-2026.3 is current, and Samuel Kim is active with capacity 6.", "due_date": "2026-09-07", "id": "ACT-CBP-082-10", "identity_id": "ENT-082-1009", "issue": "cease-and-desist deadline", "owner": "Samuel Kim", "portfolio_key": "CBP-082-10", "recommended_action": "Create mark-territory rows with exact right, restriction, and evidence hold. Owner: Samuel Kim; due 2026-09-07.", "severity": "low", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_trademarks/010_trademarks_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/03_copyrights/022_copyrights_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/034_licenses_in_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/046_licenses_out_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/11_maintenance/082_maintenance_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/09_development_records/070_development_records_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/097_blue_fern_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "completion is required by 2025-09-25 under CB-IP-3202-R422; the current event record shows completion on 2025-10-20 under CB-IP-3202-E860. Identity resolves to ENT-082-1011, revision REV-2026.5 is current, and Adrian Mensah is active with capacity 4.", "due_date": "2026-09-05", "id": "ACT-CBP-082-12", "identity_id": "ENT-082-1011", "issue": "inbound-license field restriction", "owner": "Adrian Mensah", "portfolio_key": "CBP-082-12", "recommended_action": "Create mark-territory rows with exact right, restriction, and evidence hold. Owner: Adrian Mensah; due 2026-09-05.", "severity": "high", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_trademarks/012_trademarks_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/03_copyrights/024_copyrights_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/036_licenses_in_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/048_licenses_out_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/097_blue_fern_impact_population.xlsx"]}], "as_of": "2026-09-08", "decision": {"alternatives_considered": ["blue-fern:shortcut", "blue-fern:blanket-hold"], "question": "Which Blue Fern brand uses are clear, restricted, or at risk across territories?", "rationale": "The four-part causal test supports 6 scoped actions and leaves 6 records on evidence hold. Current registrations and executed territorial restrictions govern each use.", "recommendation": "Correct or condition supported uses without abandoning clean territories.", "selected_option_id": "blue-fern:scoped-evidence"}, "holds": [{"id": "HOLD-CBP-082-01", "issue": "recorded-owner mismatch", "portfolio_key": "CBP-082-01", "reason": "the current observation does not meet the operative trigger", "required_next_evidence": "a current observation that satisfies the operative trigger", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_patents/001_patents_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/02_trademarks/013_trademarks_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/025_invention_assignments_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/037_licenses_in_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/10_disputes/073_disputes_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/097_blue_fern_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-082-04", "issue": "inventor assignment gap", "portfolio_key": "CBP-082-04", "reason": "two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key", "required_next_evidence": "an approved immutable entity crosswalk", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_patents/004_patents_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/02_trademarks/016_trademarks_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/028_invention_assignments_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/040_licenses_in_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/10_disputes/076_disputes_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/097_blue_fern_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-082-07", "issue": "security-interest release gap", "portfolio_key": "CBP-082-07", "reason": "the operational record relies on a superseded control revision", "required_next_evidence": "an operational record using the current effective revision", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_patents/007_patents_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/03_copyrights/019_copyrights_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/031_invention_assignments_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/043_licenses_out_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/091_security_interests_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/097_blue_fern_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-082-08", "issue": "trademark specimen issue", "portfolio_key": "CBP-082-08", "reason": "two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key", "required_next_evidence": "an approved immutable entity crosswalk", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_patents/008_patents_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/03_copyrights/020_copyrights_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/032_invention_assignments_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/044_licenses_out_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/097_blue_fern_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-082-09", "issue": "outbound sublicense overreach", "portfolio_key": "CBP-082-09", "reason": "the current observation does not meet the operative trigger", "required_next_evidence": "a current observation that satisfies the operative trigger", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_trademarks/009_trademarks_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/03_copyrights/021_copyrights_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/033_licenses_in_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/045_licenses_out_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/08_domain_accounts/057_domain_accounts_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/097_blue_fern_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-082-11", "issue": "foreign-filing restriction", "portfolio_key": "CBP-082-11", "reason": "the operational record relies on a superseded control revision", "required_next_evidence": "an operational record using the current effective revision", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_trademarks/011_trademarks_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/03_copyrights/023_copyrights_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/035_licenses_in_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/047_licenses_out_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/097_blue_fern_impact_population.xlsx"]}], "matter_number": "CB-IP-3202", "prepared_for": "Blue Fern Beverages", "schema_version": "counselbench.decision.v3", "task_id": "cb100-082-blue-fern"}, "matter_register": {"matter_number": "CB-IP-3202", "rows": [{"decision_option_id": "blue-fern:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "the current observation does not meet the operative trigger", "issue": "recorded-owner mismatch", "matter_number": "CB-IP-3202", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-082-01", "row_id": "REG-CBP-082-01", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_patents/001_patents_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/02_trademarks/013_trademarks_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/025_invention_assignments_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/037_licenses_in_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/10_disputes/073_disputes_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/097_blue_fern_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "blue-fern:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-06", "issue": "work-for-hire defect", "matter_number": "CB-IP-3202", "owner": "Theo Laurent", "portfolio_key": "CBP-082-02", "row_id": "REG-CBP-082-02", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_patents/002_patents_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/02_trademarks/014_trademarks_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/026_invention_assignments_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/038_licenses_in_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/097_blue_fern_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "blue-fern:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-05", "issue": "notice-file omission", "matter_number": "CB-IP-3202", "owner": "Lena Varga", "portfolio_key": "CBP-082-03", "row_id": "REG-CBP-082-03", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_patents/003_patents_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/02_trademarks/015_trademarks_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/027_invention_assignments_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/039_licenses_in_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/097_blue_fern_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "blue-fern:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key", "issue": "inventor assignment gap", "matter_number": "CB-IP-3202", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-082-04", "row_id": "REG-CBP-082-04", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_patents/004_patents_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/02_trademarks/016_trademarks_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/028_invention_assignments_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/040_licenses_in_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/10_disputes/076_disputes_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/097_blue_fern_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "blue-fern:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-03", "issue": "coexistence restriction", "matter_number": "CB-IP-3202", "owner": "Sofia Bennett", "portfolio_key": "CBP-082-05", "row_id": "REG-CBP-082-05", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_patents/005_patents_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/03_copyrights/017_copyrights_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/029_invention_assignments_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/041_licenses_out_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/09_development_records/065_development_records_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/097_blue_fern_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "blue-fern:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-02", "issue": "copyleft distribution trigger", "matter_number": "CB-IP-3202", "owner": "Micah Sullivan", "portfolio_key": "CBP-082-06", "row_id": "REG-CBP-082-06", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_patents/006_patents_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/03_copyrights/018_copyrights_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/030_invention_assignments_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/042_licenses_out_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/090_security_interests_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/07_open_source/054_open_source_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/097_blue_fern_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "blue-fern:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "the operational record relies on a superseded control revision", "issue": "security-interest release gap", "matter_number": "CB-IP-3202", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-082-07", "row_id": "REG-CBP-082-07", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_patents/007_patents_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/03_copyrights/019_copyrights_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/031_invention_assignments_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/043_licenses_out_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/091_security_interests_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/097_blue_fern_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "blue-fern:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key", "issue": "trademark specimen issue", "matter_number": "CB-IP-3202", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-082-08", "row_id": "REG-CBP-082-08", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_patents/008_patents_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/03_copyrights/020_copyrights_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/032_invention_assignments_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/044_licenses_out_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/097_blue_fern_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "blue-fern:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "the current observation does not meet the operative trigger", "issue": "outbound sublicense overreach", "matter_number": "CB-IP-3202", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-082-09", "row_id": "REG-CBP-082-09", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_trademarks/009_trademarks_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/03_copyrights/021_copyrights_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/033_licenses_in_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/045_licenses_out_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/08_domain_accounts/057_domain_accounts_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/097_blue_fern_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "blue-fern:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-07", "issue": "cease-and-desist deadline", "matter_number": "CB-IP-3202", "owner": "Samuel Kim", "portfolio_key": "CBP-082-10", "row_id": "REG-CBP-082-10", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_trademarks/010_trademarks_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/03_copyrights/022_copyrights_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/034_licenses_in_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/046_licenses_out_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/11_maintenance/082_maintenance_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/09_development_records/070_development_records_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/097_blue_fern_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "blue-fern:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "the operational record relies on a superseded control revision", "issue": "foreign-filing restriction", "matter_number": "CB-IP-3202", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-082-11", "row_id": "REG-CBP-082-11", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_trademarks/011_trademarks_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/03_copyrights/023_copyrights_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/035_licenses_in_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/047_licenses_out_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/097_blue_fern_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "blue-fern:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-05", "issue": "inbound-license field restriction", "matter_number": "CB-IP-3202", "owner": "Adrian Mensah", "portfolio_key": "CBP-082-12", "row_id": "REG-CBP-082-12", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_trademarks/012_trademarks_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/03_copyrights/024_copyrights_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/036_licenses_in_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/048_licenses_out_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/097_blue_fern_impact_population.xlsx"]}], "schema_version": "counselbench.matter-register.v3", "task_id": "cb100-082-blue-fern"}}, "metadata": {"benchmark": "CounselBench-100", "code_license": "Apache-2.0", "data_license": "CC-BY-4.0", "deadline": "2026-09-08", "document_count": 97, "evidence_holds": 6, "jurisdiction": "California", "matter_number": "CB-IP-3202", "mcp_commit": "9a96ea6e5913736f92b88345bf51caeaaa8e719f", "mcp_package": "@modelcontextprotocol/server-filesystem@2026.7.10", "practice_area": "ip-technology", "reference_tool_calls": 83, "required_evidence_reads": 59, "supported_actions": 6, "synthetic": true, "venue": "Trademark Trial and Appeal Board", "version": "3.1.0"}, "prompt": "The business team is asking whether it can move, and I do not want to answer from the summary deck. Which Blue Fern brand uses are clear, restricted, or at risk across territories? A beverage rebrand faces specimen, coexistence, domain, and distributor-license records with conflicting territorial limits. The team needs the call by 2026-09-08. Document the scoped result for the team and separate genuine exceptions from unresolved identity or revision questions.", "rubric": {"criteria": [{"category": "investigation", "description": "Inventory the production and use targeted searches to locate records across native formats.", "id": "investigation.discover_production"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Complete every task-specific identity, authority, operations, and approval read before the first state transition.", "id": "investigation.read_before_write"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Inspect designated source metadata before relying on those records.", "id": "investigation.custody_before_write"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "Select the supported option 'blue-fern:scoped-evidence' after applying the four-part test.", "id": "decision.selected_option"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "Identify both rejected approaches and explain why a one-source shortcut and a blanket hold are wrong.", "id": "decision.alternatives"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-082-01 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_patents/001_patents_source_export.md rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-082-01.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_trademarks/013_trademarks_source_export.json for recorded-owner mismatch.", "id": "investigation.CBP-082-01.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/025_invention_assignments_source_export.md to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-082-01.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/037_licenses_in_source_export.json.", "id": "investigation.CBP-082-01.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-082-01 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is the current observation does not meet the operative trigger.", "id": "decision.CBP-082-01.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-082-01 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-082-01.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-082-02 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_patents/002_patents_source_export.txt rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-082-02.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_trademarks/014_trademarks_source_export.xml for work-for-hire defect.", "id": "investigation.CBP-082-02.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/026_invention_assignments_source_export.txt to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-082-02.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/038_licenses_in_source_export.xml.", "id": "investigation.CBP-082-02.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-082-02 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-082-02.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-082-02 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-082-02.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-082-03 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_patents/003_patents_source_export.eml rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-082-03.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_trademarks/015_trademarks_source_export.html for notice-file omission.", "id": "investigation.CBP-082-03.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/027_invention_assignments_source_export.eml to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-082-03.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/039_licenses_in_source_export.html.", "id": "investigation.CBP-082-03.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-082-03 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-082-03.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-082-03 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-082-03.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-082-04 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_patents/004_patents_source_export.csv rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-082-04.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_trademarks/016_trademarks_source_export.pdf for inventor assignment gap.", "id": "investigation.CBP-082-04.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/028_invention_assignments_source_export.csv to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-082-04.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/040_licenses_in_source_export.pdf.", "id": "investigation.CBP-082-04.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-082-04 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key.", "id": "decision.CBP-082-04.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-082-04 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-082-04.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-082-05 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_patents/005_patents_source_export.json rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-082-05.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_copyrights/017_copyrights_source_export.md for coexistence restriction.", "id": "investigation.CBP-082-05.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/029_invention_assignments_source_export.json to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-082-05.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/041_licenses_out_source_export.md.", "id": "investigation.CBP-082-05.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-082-05 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-082-05.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-082-05 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-082-05.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-082-06 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_patents/006_patents_source_export.xml rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-082-06.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_copyrights/018_copyrights_source_export.txt for copyleft distribution trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-082-06.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/030_invention_assignments_source_export.xml to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-082-06.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/042_licenses_out_source_export.txt.", "id": "investigation.CBP-082-06.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-082-06 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-082-06.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-082-06 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-082-06.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-082-07 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_patents/007_patents_source_export.html rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-082-07.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_copyrights/019_copyrights_source_export.eml for security-interest release gap.", "id": "investigation.CBP-082-07.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/031_invention_assignments_source_export.html to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-082-07.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/043_licenses_out_source_export.eml.", "id": "investigation.CBP-082-07.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-082-07 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is the operational record relies on a superseded control revision.", "id": "decision.CBP-082-07.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-082-07 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-082-07.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-082-08 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_patents/008_patents_source_export.pdf rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-082-08.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_copyrights/020_copyrights_source_export.csv for trademark specimen issue.", "id": "investigation.CBP-082-08.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/032_invention_assignments_source_export.pdf to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-082-08.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/044_licenses_out_source_export.csv.", "id": "investigation.CBP-082-08.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-082-08 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key.", "id": "decision.CBP-082-08.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-082-08 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-082-08.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-082-09 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_trademarks/009_trademarks_source_export.md rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-082-09.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_copyrights/021_copyrights_source_export.json for outbound sublicense overreach.", "id": "investigation.CBP-082-09.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/033_licenses_in_source_export.md to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-082-09.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/045_licenses_out_source_export.json.", "id": "investigation.CBP-082-09.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-082-09 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is the current observation does not meet the operative trigger.", "id": "decision.CBP-082-09.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-082-09 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-082-09.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-082-10 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_trademarks/010_trademarks_source_export.txt rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-082-10.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_copyrights/022_copyrights_source_export.xml for cease-and-desist deadline.", "id": "investigation.CBP-082-10.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/034_licenses_in_source_export.txt to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-082-10.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/046_licenses_out_source_export.xml.", "id": "investigation.CBP-082-10.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-082-10 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-082-10.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-082-10 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-082-10.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-082-11 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_trademarks/011_trademarks_source_export.eml rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-082-11.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_copyrights/023_copyrights_source_export.html for foreign-filing restriction.", "id": "investigation.CBP-082-11.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/035_licenses_in_source_export.eml to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-082-11.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/047_licenses_out_source_export.html.", "id": "investigation.CBP-082-11.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-082-11 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is the operational record relies on a superseded control revision.", "id": "decision.CBP-082-11.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-082-11 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-082-11.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-082-12 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_trademarks/012_trademarks_source_export.csv rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-082-12.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_copyrights/024_copyrights_source_export.pdf for inbound-license field restriction.", "id": "investigation.CBP-082-12.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/036_licenses_in_source_export.csv to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-082-12.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/048_licenses_out_source_export.pdf.", "id": "investigation.CBP-082-12.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-082-12 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-082-12.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-082-12 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-082-12.register"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Write the exact selected option, supported action population, evidence-hold population, facts, owners, deadlines, and citations.", "id": "state.exact_decision"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create one exact register row per portfolio key with no extra, missing, or modified row.", "id": "state.exact_register"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Leave only the three approved deliverables and perform no extra state-changing write.", "id": "state.write_scope_containment"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Read back decision.json, matter-register.json, and advice.md after their final writes.", "id": "state.postwrite_readback"}, {"category": "answer", "description": "Explain the selected recommendation, supported actions, holds, alternatives, and limitations with exact source anchors.", "id": "answer.decision_note"}], "decision_options": [{"approach": "Apply the exact identity, current-state, authority, and revision test. Create mark-territory rows with exact right, restriction, and evidence hold.", "id": "blue-fern:scoped-evidence", "label": "Correct or condition supported uses without abandoning clean territories."}, {"approach": "Use a plausible summary or one source without completing the controlling joins.", "id": "blue-fern:shortcut", "label": "Apply the narrowest restriction to the entire global brand portfolio."}, {"approach": "Treat supported actions and genuinely ambiguous records as if they were equally unresolved.", "id": "blue-fern:blanket-hold", "label": "Freeze the entire matter population"}], "evaluation_narrative": {"authority": "Current registrations and executed territorial restrictions govern each use.", "observation": "Reconcile registrations, specimens, coexistence terms, domains, and distributor licenses by mark and territory.", "question": "Which Blue Fern brand uses are clear, restricted, or at risk across territories?", "register_action": "Create mark-territory rows with exact right, restriction, and evidence hold."}, "gates": ["all_required_evidence_precedes_first_write", "decision_criteria_complete", "register_state_exact", "write_scope_contained", "all_outputs_verified_by_readback"], "metadata_checks": 11, "metric": "weighted_criteria_score", "minimum_tool_calls": 83, "required_deliverables": ["decision.json", "matter-register.json", "advice.md"], "required_document_reads": 59, "type": "deterministic", "weights": {"advice": 0.15, "decision": 0.35, "investigation": 0.25, "state": 0.25}}, "task_id": "cb100-082-blue-fern", "task_name": "Blue Fern brand portfolio audit", "world_id": "counselbench-filesystem-mcp-v3"}
+{"context_files": ["task_files/cb100-083-crux-mapping/01_patents/001_patents_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-083-crux-mapping/01_patents/002_patents_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-083-crux-mapping/01_patents/003_patents_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-083-crux-mapping/01_patents/004_patents_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-083-crux-mapping/01_patents/005_patents_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-083-crux-mapping/01_patents/006_patents_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-083-crux-mapping/01_patents/007_patents_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-083-crux-mapping/01_patents/008_patents_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-083-crux-mapping/02_trademarks/009_trademarks_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-083-crux-mapping/02_trademarks/010_trademarks_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-083-crux-mapping/02_trademarks/011_trademarks_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-083-crux-mapping/02_trademarks/012_trademarks_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-083-crux-mapping/02_trademarks/013_trademarks_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-083-crux-mapping/02_trademarks/014_trademarks_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-083-crux-mapping/02_trademarks/015_trademarks_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-083-crux-mapping/02_trademarks/016_trademarks_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-083-crux-mapping/03_copyrights/017_copyrights_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-083-crux-mapping/03_copyrights/018_copyrights_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-083-crux-mapping/03_copyrights/019_copyrights_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-083-crux-mapping/03_copyrights/020_copyrights_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-083-crux-mapping/03_copyrights/021_copyrights_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-083-crux-mapping/03_copyrights/022_copyrights_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-083-crux-mapping/03_copyrights/023_copyrights_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-083-crux-mapping/03_copyrights/024_copyrights_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-083-crux-mapping/04_invention_assignments/025_invention_assignments_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-083-crux-mapping/04_invention_assignments/026_invention_assignments_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-083-crux-mapping/04_invention_assignments/027_invention_assignments_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-083-crux-mapping/04_invention_assignments/028_invention_assignments_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-083-crux-mapping/04_invention_assignments/029_invention_assignments_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-083-crux-mapping/04_invention_assignments/030_invention_assignments_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-083-crux-mapping/04_invention_assignments/031_invention_assignments_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-083-crux-mapping/04_invention_assignments/032_invention_assignments_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-083-crux-mapping/05_licenses_in/033_licenses_in_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-083-crux-mapping/05_licenses_in/034_licenses_in_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-083-crux-mapping/05_licenses_in/035_licenses_in_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-083-crux-mapping/05_licenses_in/036_licenses_in_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-083-crux-mapping/05_licenses_in/037_licenses_in_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-083-crux-mapping/05_licenses_in/038_licenses_in_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-083-crux-mapping/05_licenses_in/039_licenses_in_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-083-crux-mapping/05_licenses_in/040_licenses_in_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-083-crux-mapping/06_licenses_out/041_licenses_out_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-083-crux-mapping/06_licenses_out/042_licenses_out_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-083-crux-mapping/06_licenses_out/043_licenses_out_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-083-crux-mapping/06_licenses_out/044_licenses_out_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-083-crux-mapping/06_licenses_out/045_licenses_out_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-083-crux-mapping/06_licenses_out/046_licenses_out_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-083-crux-mapping/06_licenses_out/047_licenses_out_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-083-crux-mapping/06_licenses_out/048_licenses_out_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-083-crux-mapping/07_open_source/049_open_source_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-083-crux-mapping/07_open_source/050_open_source_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-083-crux-mapping/07_open_source/051_open_source_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-083-crux-mapping/07_open_source/052_open_source_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-083-crux-mapping/07_open_source/053_open_source_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-083-crux-mapping/07_open_source/054_open_source_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-083-crux-mapping/07_open_source/055_open_source_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-083-crux-mapping/07_open_source/056_open_source_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-083-crux-mapping/08_domain_accounts/057_domain_accounts_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-083-crux-mapping/08_domain_accounts/058_domain_accounts_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-083-crux-mapping/08_domain_accounts/059_domain_accounts_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-083-crux-mapping/08_domain_accounts/060_domain_accounts_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-083-crux-mapping/08_domain_accounts/061_domain_accounts_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-083-crux-mapping/08_domain_accounts/062_domain_accounts_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-083-crux-mapping/08_domain_accounts/063_domain_accounts_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-083-crux-mapping/08_domain_accounts/064_domain_accounts_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-083-crux-mapping/09_development_records/065_development_records_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-083-crux-mapping/09_development_records/066_development_records_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-083-crux-mapping/09_development_records/067_development_records_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-083-crux-mapping/09_development_records/068_development_records_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-083-crux-mapping/09_development_records/069_development_records_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-083-crux-mapping/09_development_records/070_development_records_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-083-crux-mapping/09_development_records/071_development_records_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-083-crux-mapping/09_development_records/072_development_records_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-083-crux-mapping/10_disputes/073_disputes_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-083-crux-mapping/10_disputes/074_disputes_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-083-crux-mapping/10_disputes/075_disputes_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-083-crux-mapping/10_disputes/076_disputes_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-083-crux-mapping/10_disputes/077_disputes_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-083-crux-mapping/10_disputes/078_disputes_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-083-crux-mapping/10_disputes/079_disputes_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-083-crux-mapping/10_disputes/080_disputes_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-083-crux-mapping/11_maintenance/081_maintenance_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-083-crux-mapping/11_maintenance/082_maintenance_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-083-crux-mapping/11_maintenance/083_maintenance_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-083-crux-mapping/11_maintenance/084_maintenance_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-083-crux-mapping/11_maintenance/085_maintenance_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-083-crux-mapping/11_maintenance/086_maintenance_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-083-crux-mapping/11_maintenance/087_maintenance_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-083-crux-mapping/11_maintenance/088_maintenance_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-083-crux-mapping/12_security_interests/089_security_interests_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-083-crux-mapping/12_security_interests/090_security_interests_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-083-crux-mapping/12_security_interests/091_security_interests_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-083-crux-mapping/12_security_interests/092_security_interests_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-083-crux-mapping/12_security_interests/093_security_interests_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-083-crux-mapping/12_security_interests/094_security_interests_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-083-crux-mapping/12_security_interests/095_security_interests_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-083-crux-mapping/12_security_interests/096_security_interests_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-083-crux-mapping/12_security_interests/097_crux_mapping_impact_population.xlsx"], "gold_output": {"advice_markdown": "# Decision note — Crux geospatial license review\n\n## Recommendation\n\nApply supported attribution, field, or distribution controls to affected builds. The reconciled record supports 8 scoped actions and leaves 4 items on evidence hold.\n\nSelected option: `crux-mapping:scoped-evidence`.\n\n## Why this is the supported option\n\nJoin data components, license versions, product builds, notices, and distribution channels by component hash. Each effective inbound license governs the exact incorporated component and distribution mode.\n\n## Supported actions\n\n### CBP-083-02 — source-code ownership gap (high)\n\nthe controlled population contains 225 records under CB-IP-3203-R443; the certification covers 209 records under CB-IP-3203-E279. Identity resolves to ENT-083-1001, revision REV-2025.2 is current, and Nadine Flores is active with capacity 1.\n\nAction: Create component-build rows with exact license lineage. Owner: Nadine Flores; due 2026-09-09.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_patents/002_patents_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/02_trademarks/014_trademarks_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/026_invention_assignments_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/038_licenses_in_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/097_crux_mapping_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-083-04 — recorded-owner mismatch (high)\n\nthe operative cap is $7,522,000.00 under CB-IP-3203-R205; the matched ledger population totals $7,648,805.00 under CB-IP-3203-E317. Identity resolves to ENT-083-1003, revision REV-2025.4 is current, and Mei Whitaker is active with capacity 6.\n\nAction: Create component-build rows with exact license lineage. Owner: Mei Whitaker; due 2026-09-07.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_patents/004_patents_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/02_trademarks/016_trademarks_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/028_invention_assignments_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/040_licenses_in_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/11_maintenance/088_maintenance_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/097_crux_mapping_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-083-05 — work-for-hire defect (medium)\n\ndelivery must use notices-crux_mapping_systems@example.test under CB-IP-3203-R455; the only matched receipt used archive-national_terrain_archive@example.test under CB-IP-3203-E703. Identity resolves to ENT-083-1004, revision REV-2025.5 is current, and Theo Laurent is active with capacity 1.\n\nAction: Create component-build rows with exact license lineage. Owner: Theo Laurent; due 2026-09-06.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_patents/005_patents_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/03_copyrights/017_copyrights_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/029_invention_assignments_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/041_licenses_out_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/10_disputes/077_disputes_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/07_open_source/053_open_source_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/097_crux_mapping_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-083-06 — notice-file omission (medium)\n\nan open exception blocks completion under CB-IP-3203-R289; the current status is open and unresolved under CB-IP-3203-E375. Identity resolves to ENT-083-1005, revision REV-2025.6 is current, and Lena Varga is active with capacity 3.\n\nAction: Create component-build rows with exact license lineage. Owner: Lena Varga; due 2026-09-05.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_patents/006_patents_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/03_copyrights/018_copyrights_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/030_invention_assignments_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/042_licenses_out_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/097_crux_mapping_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-083-07 — inventor assignment gap (high)\n\ncompletion is required by 2025-10-31 under CB-IP-3203-R818; the current event record shows completion on 2025-11-25 under CB-IP-3203-E406. Identity resolves to ENT-083-1006, revision REV-2025.7 is current, and Elliot Mercer is active with capacity 2.\n\nAction: Create component-build rows with exact license lineage. Owner: Elliot Mercer; due 2026-09-04.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_patents/007_patents_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/03_copyrights/019_copyrights_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/031_invention_assignments_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/043_licenses_out_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/07_open_source/055_open_source_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/091_security_interests_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/097_crux_mapping_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-083-08 — coexistence restriction (high)\n\nthe controlling threshold is 14% under CB-IP-3203-R705; the independently calculated result is 20% under CB-IP-3203-E717. Identity resolves to ENT-083-1007, revision REV-2025.1 is current, and Sofia Bennett is active with capacity 2.\n\nAction: Create component-build rows with exact license lineage. Owner: Sofia Bennett; due 2026-09-03.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_patents/008_patents_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/03_copyrights/020_copyrights_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/032_invention_assignments_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/044_licenses_out_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/07_open_source/056_open_source_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/097_crux_mapping_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-083-10 — security-interest release gap (high)\n\nthe controlled population contains 159 records under CB-IP-3203-R837; the certification covers 122 records under CB-IP-3203-E355. Identity resolves to ENT-083-1009, revision REV-2025.3 is current, and Nora Chen is active with capacity 6.\n\nAction: Create component-build rows with exact license lineage. Owner: Nora Chen; due 2026-09-10.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/02_trademarks/010_trademarks_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/03_copyrights/022_copyrights_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/034_licenses_in_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/046_licenses_out_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/097_crux_mapping_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-083-11 — trademark specimen issue (medium)\n\nthe permission is limited to Eastern District of Virginia under CB-IP-3203-R639; the matched activity occurred in Virginia under CB-IP-3203-E343. Identity resolves to ENT-083-1010, revision REV-2025.4 is current, and Caleb Hassan is active with capacity 3.\n\nAction: Create component-build rows with exact license lineage. Owner: Caleb Hassan; due 2026-09-09.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/02_trademarks/011_trademarks_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/03_copyrights/023_copyrights_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/035_licenses_in_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/047_licenses_out_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/097_crux_mapping_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n## Evidence holds\n\n- **CBP-083-01 — maintenance-fee deadline**: the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective. Next evidence: effective approval and an active owner with remaining capacity. Sources: `/workspace/documents/01_patents/001_patents_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/02_trademarks/013_trademarks_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/025_invention_assignments_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/037_licenses_in_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/097_crux_mapping_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-083-03 — domain registrant mismatch**: two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key. Next evidence: an approved immutable entity crosswalk. Sources: `/workspace/documents/01_patents/003_patents_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/02_trademarks/015_trademarks_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/027_invention_assignments_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/039_licenses_in_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/07_open_source/051_open_source_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/097_crux_mapping_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-083-09 — copyleft distribution trigger**: the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective. Next evidence: effective approval and an active owner with remaining capacity. Sources: `/workspace/documents/02_trademarks/009_trademarks_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/03_copyrights/021_copyrights_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/033_licenses_in_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/045_licenses_out_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/093_security_interests_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/08_domain_accounts/057_domain_accounts_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/097_crux_mapping_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-083-12 — outbound sublicense overreach**: the current observation does not meet the operative trigger. Next evidence: a current observation that satisfies the operative trigger. Sources: `/workspace/documents/02_trademarks/012_trademarks_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/03_copyrights/024_copyrights_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/036_licenses_in_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/048_licenses_out_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/096_security_interests_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/097_crux_mapping_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n## Alternatives considered\n\n- `crux-mapping:shortcut` — Use the most permissive license in the product for every component.: Use a plausible summary or one source without completing the controlling joins.\n- `crux-mapping:blanket-hold` — Freeze the entire matter population: Treat supported actions and genuinely ambiguous records as if they were equally unresolved.\n\n## Assumptions and limits\n\nThis decision is limited to cb100-083-crux-mapping, the supplied synthetic records, and the matter state as of 2026-09-11. Similar names, stale revisions, and pending authority are not treated as proof.\n", "decision": {"actions": [{"determination": "the controlled population contains 225 records under CB-IP-3203-R443; the certification covers 209 records under CB-IP-3203-E279. Identity resolves to ENT-083-1001, revision REV-2025.2 is current, and Nadine Flores is active with capacity 1.", "due_date": "2026-09-09", "id": "ACT-CBP-083-02", "identity_id": "ENT-083-1001", "issue": "source-code ownership gap", "owner": "Nadine Flores", "portfolio_key": "CBP-083-02", "recommended_action": "Create component-build rows with exact license lineage. Owner: Nadine Flores; due 2026-09-09.", "severity": "high", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_patents/002_patents_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/02_trademarks/014_trademarks_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/026_invention_assignments_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/038_licenses_in_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/097_crux_mapping_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "the operative cap is $7,522,000.00 under CB-IP-3203-R205; the matched ledger population totals $7,648,805.00 under CB-IP-3203-E317. Identity resolves to ENT-083-1003, revision REV-2025.4 is current, and Mei Whitaker is active with capacity 6.", "due_date": "2026-09-07", "id": "ACT-CBP-083-04", "identity_id": "ENT-083-1003", "issue": "recorded-owner mismatch", "owner": "Mei Whitaker", "portfolio_key": "CBP-083-04", "recommended_action": "Create component-build rows with exact license lineage. Owner: Mei Whitaker; due 2026-09-07.", "severity": "high", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_patents/004_patents_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/02_trademarks/016_trademarks_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/028_invention_assignments_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/040_licenses_in_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/11_maintenance/088_maintenance_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/097_crux_mapping_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "delivery must use notices-crux_mapping_systems@example.test under CB-IP-3203-R455; the only matched receipt used archive-national_terrain_archive@example.test under CB-IP-3203-E703. Identity resolves to ENT-083-1004, revision REV-2025.5 is current, and Theo Laurent is active with capacity 1.", "due_date": "2026-09-06", "id": "ACT-CBP-083-05", "identity_id": "ENT-083-1004", "issue": "work-for-hire defect", "owner": "Theo Laurent", "portfolio_key": "CBP-083-05", "recommended_action": "Create component-build rows with exact license lineage. Owner: Theo Laurent; due 2026-09-06.", "severity": "medium", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_patents/005_patents_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/03_copyrights/017_copyrights_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/029_invention_assignments_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/041_licenses_out_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/10_disputes/077_disputes_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/07_open_source/053_open_source_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/097_crux_mapping_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "an open exception blocks completion under CB-IP-3203-R289; the current status is open and unresolved under CB-IP-3203-E375. Identity resolves to ENT-083-1005, revision REV-2025.6 is current, and Lena Varga is active with capacity 3.", "due_date": "2026-09-05", "id": "ACT-CBP-083-06", "identity_id": "ENT-083-1005", "issue": "notice-file omission", "owner": "Lena Varga", "portfolio_key": "CBP-083-06", "recommended_action": "Create component-build rows with exact license lineage. Owner: Lena Varga; due 2026-09-05.", "severity": "medium", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_patents/006_patents_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/03_copyrights/018_copyrights_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/030_invention_assignments_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/042_licenses_out_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/097_crux_mapping_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "completion is required by 2025-10-31 under CB-IP-3203-R818; the current event record shows completion on 2025-11-25 under CB-IP-3203-E406. Identity resolves to ENT-083-1006, revision REV-2025.7 is current, and Elliot Mercer is active with capacity 2.", "due_date": "2026-09-04", "id": "ACT-CBP-083-07", "identity_id": "ENT-083-1006", "issue": "inventor assignment gap", "owner": "Elliot Mercer", "portfolio_key": "CBP-083-07", "recommended_action": "Create component-build rows with exact license lineage. Owner: Elliot Mercer; due 2026-09-04.", "severity": "high", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_patents/007_patents_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/03_copyrights/019_copyrights_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/031_invention_assignments_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/043_licenses_out_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/07_open_source/055_open_source_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/091_security_interests_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/097_crux_mapping_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "the controlling threshold is 14% under CB-IP-3203-R705; the independently calculated result is 20% under CB-IP-3203-E717. Identity resolves to ENT-083-1007, revision REV-2025.1 is current, and Sofia Bennett is active with capacity 2.", "due_date": "2026-09-03", "id": "ACT-CBP-083-08", "identity_id": "ENT-083-1007", "issue": "coexistence restriction", "owner": "Sofia Bennett", "portfolio_key": "CBP-083-08", "recommended_action": "Create component-build rows with exact license lineage. Owner: Sofia Bennett; due 2026-09-03.", "severity": "high", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_patents/008_patents_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/03_copyrights/020_copyrights_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/032_invention_assignments_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/044_licenses_out_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/07_open_source/056_open_source_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/097_crux_mapping_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "the controlled population contains 159 records under CB-IP-3203-R837; the certification covers 122 records under CB-IP-3203-E355. Identity resolves to ENT-083-1009, revision REV-2025.3 is current, and Nora Chen is active with capacity 6.", "due_date": "2026-09-10", "id": "ACT-CBP-083-10", "identity_id": "ENT-083-1009", "issue": "security-interest release gap", "owner": "Nora Chen", "portfolio_key": "CBP-083-10", "recommended_action": "Create component-build rows with exact license lineage. Owner: Nora Chen; due 2026-09-10.", "severity": "high", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_trademarks/010_trademarks_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/03_copyrights/022_copyrights_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/034_licenses_in_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/046_licenses_out_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/097_crux_mapping_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "the permission is limited to Eastern District of Virginia under CB-IP-3203-R639; the matched activity occurred in Virginia under CB-IP-3203-E343. Identity resolves to ENT-083-1010, revision REV-2025.4 is current, and Caleb Hassan is active with capacity 3.", "due_date": "2026-09-09", "id": "ACT-CBP-083-11", "identity_id": "ENT-083-1010", "issue": "trademark specimen issue", "owner": "Caleb Hassan", "portfolio_key": "CBP-083-11", "recommended_action": "Create component-build rows with exact license lineage. Owner: Caleb Hassan; due 2026-09-09.", "severity": "medium", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_trademarks/011_trademarks_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/03_copyrights/023_copyrights_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/035_licenses_in_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/047_licenses_out_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/097_crux_mapping_impact_population.xlsx"]}], "as_of": "2026-09-11", "decision": {"alternatives_considered": ["crux-mapping:shortcut", "crux-mapping:blanket-hold"], "question": "What may Crux distribute, and what attribution or field restrictions must change?", "rationale": "The four-part causal test supports 8 scoped actions and leaves 4 records on evidence hold. Each effective inbound license governs the exact incorporated component and distribution mode.", "recommendation": "Apply supported attribution, field, or distribution controls to affected builds.", "selected_option_id": "crux-mapping:scoped-evidence"}, "holds": [{"id": "HOLD-CBP-083-01", "issue": "maintenance-fee deadline", "portfolio_key": "CBP-083-01", "reason": "the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective", "required_next_evidence": "effective approval and an active owner with remaining capacity", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_patents/001_patents_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/02_trademarks/013_trademarks_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/025_invention_assignments_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/037_licenses_in_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/097_crux_mapping_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-083-03", "issue": "domain registrant mismatch", "portfolio_key": "CBP-083-03", "reason": "two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key", "required_next_evidence": "an approved immutable entity crosswalk", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_patents/003_patents_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/02_trademarks/015_trademarks_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/027_invention_assignments_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/039_licenses_in_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/07_open_source/051_open_source_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/097_crux_mapping_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-083-09", "issue": "copyleft distribution trigger", "portfolio_key": "CBP-083-09", "reason": "the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective", "required_next_evidence": "effective approval and an active owner with remaining capacity", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_trademarks/009_trademarks_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/03_copyrights/021_copyrights_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/033_licenses_in_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/045_licenses_out_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/093_security_interests_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/08_domain_accounts/057_domain_accounts_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/097_crux_mapping_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-083-12", "issue": "outbound sublicense overreach", "portfolio_key": "CBP-083-12", "reason": "the current observation does not meet the operative trigger", "required_next_evidence": "a current observation that satisfies the operative trigger", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_trademarks/012_trademarks_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/03_copyrights/024_copyrights_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/036_licenses_in_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/048_licenses_out_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/096_security_interests_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/097_crux_mapping_impact_population.xlsx"]}], "matter_number": "CB-IP-3203", "prepared_for": "Crux Mapping Systems", "schema_version": "counselbench.decision.v3", "task_id": "cb100-083-crux-mapping"}, "matter_register": {"matter_number": "CB-IP-3203", "rows": [{"decision_option_id": "crux-mapping:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective", "issue": "maintenance-fee deadline", "matter_number": "CB-IP-3203", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-083-01", "row_id": "REG-CBP-083-01", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_patents/001_patents_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/02_trademarks/013_trademarks_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/025_invention_assignments_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/037_licenses_in_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/097_crux_mapping_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "crux-mapping:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-09", "issue": "source-code ownership gap", "matter_number": "CB-IP-3203", "owner": "Nadine Flores", "portfolio_key": "CBP-083-02", "row_id": "REG-CBP-083-02", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_patents/002_patents_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/02_trademarks/014_trademarks_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/026_invention_assignments_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/038_licenses_in_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/097_crux_mapping_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "crux-mapping:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key", "issue": "domain registrant mismatch", "matter_number": "CB-IP-3203", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-083-03", "row_id": "REG-CBP-083-03", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_patents/003_patents_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/02_trademarks/015_trademarks_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/027_invention_assignments_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/039_licenses_in_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/07_open_source/051_open_source_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/097_crux_mapping_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "crux-mapping:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-07", "issue": "recorded-owner mismatch", "matter_number": "CB-IP-3203", "owner": "Mei Whitaker", "portfolio_key": "CBP-083-04", "row_id": "REG-CBP-083-04", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_patents/004_patents_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/02_trademarks/016_trademarks_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/028_invention_assignments_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/040_licenses_in_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/11_maintenance/088_maintenance_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/097_crux_mapping_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "crux-mapping:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-06", "issue": "work-for-hire defect", "matter_number": "CB-IP-3203", "owner": "Theo Laurent", "portfolio_key": "CBP-083-05", "row_id": "REG-CBP-083-05", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_patents/005_patents_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/03_copyrights/017_copyrights_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/029_invention_assignments_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/041_licenses_out_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/10_disputes/077_disputes_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/07_open_source/053_open_source_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/097_crux_mapping_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "crux-mapping:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-05", "issue": "notice-file omission", "matter_number": "CB-IP-3203", "owner": "Lena Varga", "portfolio_key": "CBP-083-06", "row_id": "REG-CBP-083-06", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_patents/006_patents_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/03_copyrights/018_copyrights_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/030_invention_assignments_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/042_licenses_out_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/097_crux_mapping_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "crux-mapping:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-04", "issue": "inventor assignment gap", "matter_number": "CB-IP-3203", "owner": "Elliot Mercer", "portfolio_key": "CBP-083-07", "row_id": "REG-CBP-083-07", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_patents/007_patents_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/03_copyrights/019_copyrights_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/031_invention_assignments_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/043_licenses_out_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/07_open_source/055_open_source_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/091_security_interests_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/097_crux_mapping_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "crux-mapping:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-03", "issue": "coexistence restriction", "matter_number": "CB-IP-3203", "owner": "Sofia Bennett", "portfolio_key": "CBP-083-08", "row_id": "REG-CBP-083-08", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_patents/008_patents_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/03_copyrights/020_copyrights_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/032_invention_assignments_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/044_licenses_out_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/07_open_source/056_open_source_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/097_crux_mapping_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "crux-mapping:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective", "issue": "copyleft distribution trigger", "matter_number": "CB-IP-3203", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-083-09", "row_id": "REG-CBP-083-09", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_trademarks/009_trademarks_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/03_copyrights/021_copyrights_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/033_licenses_in_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/045_licenses_out_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/093_security_interests_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/08_domain_accounts/057_domain_accounts_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/097_crux_mapping_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "crux-mapping:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-10", "issue": "security-interest release gap", "matter_number": "CB-IP-3203", "owner": "Nora Chen", "portfolio_key": "CBP-083-10", "row_id": "REG-CBP-083-10", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_trademarks/010_trademarks_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/03_copyrights/022_copyrights_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/034_licenses_in_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/046_licenses_out_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/097_crux_mapping_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "crux-mapping:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-09", "issue": "trademark specimen issue", "matter_number": "CB-IP-3203", "owner": "Caleb Hassan", "portfolio_key": "CBP-083-11", "row_id": "REG-CBP-083-11", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_trademarks/011_trademarks_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/03_copyrights/023_copyrights_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/035_licenses_in_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/047_licenses_out_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/097_crux_mapping_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "crux-mapping:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "the current observation does not meet the operative trigger", "issue": "outbound sublicense overreach", "matter_number": "CB-IP-3203", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-083-12", "row_id": "REG-CBP-083-12", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_trademarks/012_trademarks_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/03_copyrights/024_copyrights_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/036_licenses_in_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/048_licenses_out_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/096_security_interests_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/097_crux_mapping_impact_population.xlsx"]}], "schema_version": "counselbench.matter-register.v3", "task_id": "cb100-083-crux-mapping"}}, "metadata": {"benchmark": "CounselBench-100", "code_license": "Apache-2.0", "data_license": "CC-BY-4.0", "deadline": "2026-09-11", "document_count": 97, "evidence_holds": 4, "jurisdiction": "Virginia", "matter_number": "CB-IP-3203", "mcp_commit": "9a96ea6e5913736f92b88345bf51caeaaa8e719f", "mcp_package": "@modelcontextprotocol/server-filesystem@2026.7.10", "practice_area": "ip-technology", "reference_tool_calls": 87, "required_evidence_reads": 60, "supported_actions": 8, "synthetic": true, "venue": "Eastern District of Virginia", "version": "3.1.0"}, "prompt": "A late record changed the picture this morning. What may Crux distribute, and what attribution or field restrictions must change? Mapping products combine government, university, and open-source inputs subject to attribution, field, and distribution restrictions. The team needs the call by 2026-09-11. Make the matter record usable by operations after your review, but do not turn ambiguity into an accusation or obligation.", "rubric": {"criteria": [{"category": "investigation", "description": "Inventory the production and use targeted searches to locate records across native formats.", "id": "investigation.discover_production"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Complete every task-specific identity, authority, operations, and approval read before the first state transition.", "id": "investigation.read_before_write"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Inspect designated source metadata before relying on those records.", "id": "investigation.custody_before_write"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "Select the supported option 'crux-mapping:scoped-evidence' after applying the four-part test.", "id": "decision.selected_option"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "Identify both rejected approaches and explain why a one-source shortcut and a blanket hold are wrong.", "id": "decision.alternatives"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-083-01 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_patents/001_patents_source_export.md rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-083-01.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_trademarks/013_trademarks_source_export.json for maintenance-fee deadline.", "id": "investigation.CBP-083-01.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/025_invention_assignments_source_export.md to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-083-01.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/037_licenses_in_source_export.json.", "id": "investigation.CBP-083-01.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-083-01 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective.", "id": "decision.CBP-083-01.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-083-01 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-083-01.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-083-02 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_patents/002_patents_source_export.txt rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-083-02.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_trademarks/014_trademarks_source_export.xml for source-code ownership gap.", "id": "investigation.CBP-083-02.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/026_invention_assignments_source_export.txt to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-083-02.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/038_licenses_in_source_export.xml.", "id": "investigation.CBP-083-02.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-083-02 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-083-02.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-083-02 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-083-02.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-083-03 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_patents/003_patents_source_export.eml rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-083-03.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_trademarks/015_trademarks_source_export.html for domain registrant mismatch.", "id": "investigation.CBP-083-03.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/027_invention_assignments_source_export.eml to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-083-03.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/039_licenses_in_source_export.html.", "id": "investigation.CBP-083-03.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-083-03 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key.", "id": "decision.CBP-083-03.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-083-03 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-083-03.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-083-04 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_patents/004_patents_source_export.csv rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-083-04.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_trademarks/016_trademarks_source_export.pdf for recorded-owner mismatch.", "id": "investigation.CBP-083-04.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/028_invention_assignments_source_export.csv to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-083-04.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/040_licenses_in_source_export.pdf.", "id": "investigation.CBP-083-04.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-083-04 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-083-04.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-083-04 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-083-04.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-083-05 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_patents/005_patents_source_export.json rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-083-05.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_copyrights/017_copyrights_source_export.md for work-for-hire defect.", "id": "investigation.CBP-083-05.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/029_invention_assignments_source_export.json to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-083-05.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/041_licenses_out_source_export.md.", "id": "investigation.CBP-083-05.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-083-05 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-083-05.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-083-05 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-083-05.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-083-06 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_patents/006_patents_source_export.xml rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-083-06.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_copyrights/018_copyrights_source_export.txt for notice-file omission.", "id": "investigation.CBP-083-06.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/030_invention_assignments_source_export.xml to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-083-06.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/042_licenses_out_source_export.txt.", "id": "investigation.CBP-083-06.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-083-06 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-083-06.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-083-06 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-083-06.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-083-07 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_patents/007_patents_source_export.html rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-083-07.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_copyrights/019_copyrights_source_export.eml for inventor assignment gap.", "id": "investigation.CBP-083-07.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/031_invention_assignments_source_export.html to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-083-07.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/043_licenses_out_source_export.eml.", "id": "investigation.CBP-083-07.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-083-07 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-083-07.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-083-07 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-083-07.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-083-08 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_patents/008_patents_source_export.pdf rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-083-08.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_copyrights/020_copyrights_source_export.csv for coexistence restriction.", "id": "investigation.CBP-083-08.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/032_invention_assignments_source_export.pdf to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-083-08.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/044_licenses_out_source_export.csv.", "id": "investigation.CBP-083-08.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-083-08 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-083-08.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-083-08 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-083-08.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-083-09 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_trademarks/009_trademarks_source_export.md rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-083-09.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_copyrights/021_copyrights_source_export.json for copyleft distribution trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-083-09.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/033_licenses_in_source_export.md to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-083-09.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/045_licenses_out_source_export.json.", "id": "investigation.CBP-083-09.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-083-09 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective.", "id": "decision.CBP-083-09.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-083-09 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-083-09.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-083-10 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_trademarks/010_trademarks_source_export.txt rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-083-10.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_copyrights/022_copyrights_source_export.xml for security-interest release gap.", "id": "investigation.CBP-083-10.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/034_licenses_in_source_export.txt to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-083-10.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/046_licenses_out_source_export.xml.", "id": "investigation.CBP-083-10.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-083-10 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-083-10.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-083-10 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-083-10.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-083-11 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_trademarks/011_trademarks_source_export.eml rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-083-11.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_copyrights/023_copyrights_source_export.html for trademark specimen issue.", "id": "investigation.CBP-083-11.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/035_licenses_in_source_export.eml to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-083-11.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/047_licenses_out_source_export.html.", "id": "investigation.CBP-083-11.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-083-11 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-083-11.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-083-11 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-083-11.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-083-12 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_trademarks/012_trademarks_source_export.csv rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-083-12.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_copyrights/024_copyrights_source_export.pdf for outbound sublicense overreach.", "id": "investigation.CBP-083-12.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/036_licenses_in_source_export.csv to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-083-12.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/048_licenses_out_source_export.pdf.", "id": "investigation.CBP-083-12.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-083-12 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is the current observation does not meet the operative trigger.", "id": "decision.CBP-083-12.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-083-12 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-083-12.register"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Write the exact selected option, supported action population, evidence-hold population, facts, owners, deadlines, and citations.", "id": "state.exact_decision"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create one exact register row per portfolio key with no extra, missing, or modified row.", "id": "state.exact_register"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Leave only the three approved deliverables and perform no extra state-changing write.", "id": "state.write_scope_containment"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Read back decision.json, matter-register.json, and advice.md after their final writes.", "id": "state.postwrite_readback"}, {"category": "answer", "description": "Explain the selected recommendation, supported actions, holds, alternatives, and limitations with exact source anchors.", "id": "answer.decision_note"}], "decision_options": [{"approach": "Use a plausible summary or one source without completing the controlling joins.", "id": "crux-mapping:shortcut", "label": "Use the most permissive license in the product for every component."}, {"approach": "Treat supported actions and genuinely ambiguous records as if they were equally unresolved.", "id": "crux-mapping:blanket-hold", "label": "Freeze the entire matter population"}, {"approach": "Apply the exact identity, current-state, authority, and revision test. Create component-build rows with exact license lineage.", "id": "crux-mapping:scoped-evidence", "label": "Apply supported attribution, field, or distribution controls to affected builds."}], "evaluation_narrative": {"authority": "Each effective inbound license governs the exact incorporated component and distribution mode.", "observation": "Join data components, license versions, product builds, notices, and distribution channels by component hash.", "question": "What may Crux distribute, and what attribution or field restrictions must change?", "register_action": "Create component-build rows with exact license lineage."}, "gates": ["all_required_evidence_precedes_first_write", "decision_criteria_complete", "register_state_exact", "write_scope_contained", "all_outputs_verified_by_readback"], "metadata_checks": 10, "metric": "weighted_criteria_score", "minimum_tool_calls": 87, "required_deliverables": ["decision.json", "matter-register.json", "advice.md"], "required_document_reads": 60, "type": "deterministic", "weights": {"advice": 0.15, "decision": 0.35, "investigation": 0.25, "state": 0.25}}, "task_id": "cb100-083-crux-mapping", "task_name": "Crux geospatial license review", "world_id": "counselbench-filesystem-mcp-v3"}
+{"context_files": ["task_files/cb100-084-drift-audio/01_patents/001_patents_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-084-drift-audio/01_patents/002_patents_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-084-drift-audio/01_patents/003_patents_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-084-drift-audio/01_patents/004_patents_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-084-drift-audio/01_patents/005_patents_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-084-drift-audio/01_patents/006_patents_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-084-drift-audio/01_patents/007_patents_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-084-drift-audio/01_patents/008_patents_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-084-drift-audio/02_trademarks/009_trademarks_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-084-drift-audio/02_trademarks/010_trademarks_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-084-drift-audio/02_trademarks/011_trademarks_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-084-drift-audio/02_trademarks/012_trademarks_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-084-drift-audio/02_trademarks/013_trademarks_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-084-drift-audio/02_trademarks/014_trademarks_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-084-drift-audio/02_trademarks/015_trademarks_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-084-drift-audio/02_trademarks/016_trademarks_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-084-drift-audio/03_copyrights/017_copyrights_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-084-drift-audio/03_copyrights/018_copyrights_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-084-drift-audio/03_copyrights/019_copyrights_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-084-drift-audio/03_copyrights/020_copyrights_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-084-drift-audio/03_copyrights/021_copyrights_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-084-drift-audio/03_copyrights/022_copyrights_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-084-drift-audio/03_copyrights/023_copyrights_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-084-drift-audio/03_copyrights/024_copyrights_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-084-drift-audio/04_invention_assignments/025_invention_assignments_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-084-drift-audio/04_invention_assignments/026_invention_assignments_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-084-drift-audio/04_invention_assignments/027_invention_assignments_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-084-drift-audio/04_invention_assignments/028_invention_assignments_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-084-drift-audio/04_invention_assignments/029_invention_assignments_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-084-drift-audio/04_invention_assignments/030_invention_assignments_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-084-drift-audio/04_invention_assignments/031_invention_assignments_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-084-drift-audio/04_invention_assignments/032_invention_assignments_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-084-drift-audio/05_licenses_in/033_licenses_in_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-084-drift-audio/05_licenses_in/034_licenses_in_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-084-drift-audio/05_licenses_in/035_licenses_in_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-084-drift-audio/05_licenses_in/036_licenses_in_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-084-drift-audio/05_licenses_in/037_licenses_in_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-084-drift-audio/05_licenses_in/038_licenses_in_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-084-drift-audio/05_licenses_in/039_licenses_in_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-084-drift-audio/05_licenses_in/040_licenses_in_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-084-drift-audio/06_licenses_out/041_licenses_out_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-084-drift-audio/06_licenses_out/042_licenses_out_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-084-drift-audio/06_licenses_out/043_licenses_out_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-084-drift-audio/06_licenses_out/044_licenses_out_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-084-drift-audio/06_licenses_out/045_licenses_out_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-084-drift-audio/06_licenses_out/046_licenses_out_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-084-drift-audio/06_licenses_out/047_licenses_out_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-084-drift-audio/06_licenses_out/048_licenses_out_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-084-drift-audio/07_open_source/049_open_source_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-084-drift-audio/07_open_source/050_open_source_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-084-drift-audio/07_open_source/051_open_source_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-084-drift-audio/07_open_source/052_open_source_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-084-drift-audio/07_open_source/053_open_source_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-084-drift-audio/07_open_source/054_open_source_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-084-drift-audio/07_open_source/055_open_source_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-084-drift-audio/07_open_source/056_open_source_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-084-drift-audio/08_domain_accounts/057_domain_accounts_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-084-drift-audio/08_domain_accounts/058_domain_accounts_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-084-drift-audio/08_domain_accounts/059_domain_accounts_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-084-drift-audio/08_domain_accounts/060_domain_accounts_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-084-drift-audio/08_domain_accounts/061_domain_accounts_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-084-drift-audio/08_domain_accounts/062_domain_accounts_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-084-drift-audio/08_domain_accounts/063_domain_accounts_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-084-drift-audio/08_domain_accounts/064_domain_accounts_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-084-drift-audio/09_development_records/065_development_records_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-084-drift-audio/09_development_records/066_development_records_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-084-drift-audio/09_development_records/067_development_records_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-084-drift-audio/09_development_records/068_development_records_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-084-drift-audio/09_development_records/069_development_records_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-084-drift-audio/09_development_records/070_development_records_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-084-drift-audio/09_development_records/071_development_records_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-084-drift-audio/09_development_records/072_development_records_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-084-drift-audio/10_disputes/073_disputes_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-084-drift-audio/10_disputes/074_disputes_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-084-drift-audio/10_disputes/075_disputes_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-084-drift-audio/10_disputes/076_disputes_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-084-drift-audio/10_disputes/077_disputes_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-084-drift-audio/10_disputes/078_disputes_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-084-drift-audio/10_disputes/079_disputes_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-084-drift-audio/10_disputes/080_disputes_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-084-drift-audio/11_maintenance/081_maintenance_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-084-drift-audio/11_maintenance/082_maintenance_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-084-drift-audio/11_maintenance/083_maintenance_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-084-drift-audio/11_maintenance/084_maintenance_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-084-drift-audio/11_maintenance/085_maintenance_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-084-drift-audio/11_maintenance/086_maintenance_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-084-drift-audio/11_maintenance/087_maintenance_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-084-drift-audio/11_maintenance/088_maintenance_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-084-drift-audio/12_security_interests/089_security_interests_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-084-drift-audio/12_security_interests/090_security_interests_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-084-drift-audio/12_security_interests/091_security_interests_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-084-drift-audio/12_security_interests/092_security_interests_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-084-drift-audio/12_security_interests/093_security_interests_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-084-drift-audio/12_security_interests/094_security_interests_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-084-drift-audio/12_security_interests/095_security_interests_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-084-drift-audio/12_security_interests/096_security_interests_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-084-drift-audio/12_security_interests/097_drift_audio_impact_population.xlsx"], "gold_output": {"advice_markdown": "# Decision note — Drift Audio catalog ownership audit\n\n## Recommendation\n\nRetain, cure, or remove assets according to complete chain and current requests. The reconciled record supports 9 scoped actions and leaves 3 items on evidence hold.\n\nSelected option: `drift-audio:scoped-evidence`.\n\n## Why this is the supported option\n\nMatch recordings, performers, commissions, samples, releases, models, and takedown requests by asset ID. Ownership, publicity, and license scope must all cover the actual training and distribution use.\n\n## Supported actions\n\n### CBP-084-01 — foreign-filing restriction (critical)\n\nan open exception blocks completion under CB-IP-3204-R309; the current status is open and unresolved under CB-IP-3204-E218. Identity resolves to ENT-084-1000, revision REV-2026.1 is current, and Willa Novak is active with capacity 2.\n\nAction: Create asset-use rows with exact cure or removal status. Owner: Willa Novak; due 2026-09-14.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_patents/001_patents_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/02_trademarks/013_trademarks_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/025_invention_assignments_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/037_licenses_in_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/07_open_source/049_open_source_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/11_maintenance/085_maintenance_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/097_drift_audio_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-084-02 — inbound-license field restriction (high)\n\ncompletion is required by 2025-06-12 under CB-IP-3204-R617; the current event record shows completion on 2025-07-09 under CB-IP-3204-E924. Identity resolves to ENT-084-1001, revision REV-2026.2 is current, and Owen Delgado is active with capacity 4.\n\nAction: Create asset-use rows with exact cure or removal status. Owner: Owen Delgado; due 2026-09-13.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_patents/002_patents_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/02_trademarks/014_trademarks_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/026_invention_assignments_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/038_licenses_in_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/08_domain_accounts/062_domain_accounts_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/07_open_source/050_open_source_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/097_drift_audio_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-084-05 — source-code ownership gap (high)\n\nthe controlled population contains 163 records under CB-IP-3204-R481; the certification covers 124 records under CB-IP-3204-E175. Identity resolves to ENT-084-1004, revision REV-2026.5 is current, and Nadine Flores is active with capacity 1.\n\nAction: Create asset-use rows with exact cure or removal status. Owner: Nadine Flores; due 2026-09-10.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_patents/005_patents_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/03_copyrights/017_copyrights_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/029_invention_assignments_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/041_licenses_out_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/089_security_interests_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/09_development_records/065_development_records_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/097_drift_audio_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-084-06 — domain registrant mismatch (critical)\n\nthe permission is limited to Middle District of Tennessee under CB-IP-3204-R760; the matched activity occurred in Tennessee under CB-IP-3204-E456. Identity resolves to ENT-084-1005, revision REV-2026.6 is current, and Rafael Okafor is active with capacity 6.\n\nAction: Create asset-use rows with exact cure or removal status. Owner: Rafael Okafor; due 2026-09-09.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_patents/006_patents_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/03_copyrights/018_copyrights_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/030_invention_assignments_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/042_licenses_out_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/09_development_records/066_development_records_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/07_open_source/054_open_source_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/097_drift_audio_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-084-08 — work-for-hire defect (high)\n\ndelivery must use notices-drift_audio_labs@example.test under CB-IP-3204-R284; the only matched receipt used archive-silver_reed_composers_llc@example.test under CB-IP-3204-E269. Identity resolves to ENT-084-1007, revision REV-2026.1 is current, and Theo Laurent is active with capacity 2.\n\nAction: Create asset-use rows with exact cure or removal status. Owner: Theo Laurent; due 2026-09-07.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_patents/008_patents_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/03_copyrights/020_copyrights_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/032_invention_assignments_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/044_licenses_out_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/097_drift_audio_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-084-09 — notice-file omission (high)\n\nan open exception blocks completion under CB-IP-3204-R923; the current status is open and unresolved under CB-IP-3204-E360. Identity resolves to ENT-084-1008, revision REV-2026.2 is current, and Lena Varga is active with capacity 4.\n\nAction: Create asset-use rows with exact cure or removal status. Owner: Lena Varga; due 2026-09-06.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/02_trademarks/009_trademarks_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/03_copyrights/021_copyrights_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/033_licenses_in_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/045_licenses_out_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/08_domain_accounts/057_domain_accounts_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/097_drift_audio_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-084-10 — inventor assignment gap (low)\n\ncompletion is required by 2025-09-09 under CB-IP-3204-R466; the current event record shows completion on 2025-09-18 under CB-IP-3204-E121. Identity resolves to ENT-084-1009, revision REV-2026.3 is current, and Elliot Mercer is active with capacity 5.\n\nAction: Create asset-use rows with exact cure or removal status. Owner: Elliot Mercer; due 2026-09-14.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/02_trademarks/010_trademarks_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/03_copyrights/022_copyrights_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/034_licenses_in_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/046_licenses_out_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/11_maintenance/082_maintenance_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/094_security_interests_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/097_drift_audio_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-084-11 — coexistence restriction (high)\n\nthe controlling threshold is 11% under CB-IP-3204-R600; the independently calculated result is 14% under CB-IP-3204-E605. Identity resolves to ENT-084-1010, revision REV-2026.4 is current, and Sofia Bennett is active with capacity 2.\n\nAction: Create asset-use rows with exact cure or removal status. Owner: Sofia Bennett; due 2026-09-13.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/02_trademarks/011_trademarks_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/03_copyrights/023_copyrights_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/035_licenses_in_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/047_licenses_out_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/097_drift_audio_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-084-12 — copyleft distribution trigger (high)\n\napproval must come from Farah Ibrahim under CB-IP-3204-R378; the effective approval record names Rafael Okafor under CB-IP-3204-E539. Identity resolves to ENT-084-1011, revision REV-2026.5 is current, and Micah Sullivan is active with capacity 3.\n\nAction: Create asset-use rows with exact cure or removal status. Owner: Micah Sullivan; due 2026-09-12.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/02_trademarks/012_trademarks_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/03_copyrights/024_copyrights_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/036_licenses_in_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/048_licenses_out_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/11_maintenance/084_maintenance_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/097_drift_audio_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n## Evidence holds\n\n- **CBP-084-03 — repository access anomaly**: the current observation does not meet the operative trigger. Next evidence: a current observation that satisfies the operative trigger. Sources: `/workspace/documents/01_patents/003_patents_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/02_trademarks/015_trademarks_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/027_invention_assignments_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/039_licenses_in_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/10_disputes/075_disputes_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/07_open_source/051_open_source_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/097_drift_audio_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-084-04 — maintenance-fee deadline**: the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective. Next evidence: effective approval and an active owner with remaining capacity. Sources: `/workspace/documents/01_patents/004_patents_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/02_trademarks/016_trademarks_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/028_invention_assignments_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/040_licenses_in_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/11_maintenance/088_maintenance_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/07_open_source/052_open_source_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/097_drift_audio_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-084-07 — recorded-owner mismatch**: the current observation does not meet the operative trigger. Next evidence: a current observation that satisfies the operative trigger. Sources: `/workspace/documents/01_patents/007_patents_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/03_copyrights/019_copyrights_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/031_invention_assignments_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/043_licenses_out_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/097_drift_audio_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n## Alternatives considered\n\n- `drift-audio:blanket-hold` — Freeze the entire matter population: Treat supported actions and genuinely ambiguous records as if they were equally unresolved.\n- `drift-audio:shortcut` — Treat a paid commission as ownership of every performance and sample right.: Use a plausible summary or one source without completing the controlling joins.\n\n## Assumptions and limits\n\nThis decision is limited to cb100-084-drift-audio, the supplied synthetic records, and the matter state as of 2026-09-15. Similar names, stale revisions, and pending authority are not treated as proof.\n", "decision": {"actions": [{"determination": "an open exception blocks completion under CB-IP-3204-R309; the current status is open and unresolved under CB-IP-3204-E218. Identity resolves to ENT-084-1000, revision REV-2026.1 is current, and Willa Novak is active with capacity 2.", "due_date": "2026-09-14", "id": "ACT-CBP-084-01", "identity_id": "ENT-084-1000", "issue": "foreign-filing restriction", "owner": "Willa Novak", "portfolio_key": "CBP-084-01", "recommended_action": "Create asset-use rows with exact cure or removal status. Owner: Willa Novak; due 2026-09-14.", "severity": "critical", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_patents/001_patents_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/02_trademarks/013_trademarks_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/025_invention_assignments_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/037_licenses_in_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/07_open_source/049_open_source_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/11_maintenance/085_maintenance_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/097_drift_audio_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "completion is required by 2025-06-12 under CB-IP-3204-R617; the current event record shows completion on 2025-07-09 under CB-IP-3204-E924. Identity resolves to ENT-084-1001, revision REV-2026.2 is current, and Owen Delgado is active with capacity 4.", "due_date": "2026-09-13", "id": "ACT-CBP-084-02", "identity_id": "ENT-084-1001", "issue": "inbound-license field restriction", "owner": "Owen Delgado", "portfolio_key": "CBP-084-02", "recommended_action": "Create asset-use rows with exact cure or removal status. Owner: Owen Delgado; due 2026-09-13.", "severity": "high", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_patents/002_patents_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/02_trademarks/014_trademarks_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/026_invention_assignments_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/038_licenses_in_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/08_domain_accounts/062_domain_accounts_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/07_open_source/050_open_source_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/097_drift_audio_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "the controlled population contains 163 records under CB-IP-3204-R481; the certification covers 124 records under CB-IP-3204-E175. Identity resolves to ENT-084-1004, revision REV-2026.5 is current, and Nadine Flores is active with capacity 1.", "due_date": "2026-09-10", "id": "ACT-CBP-084-05", "identity_id": "ENT-084-1004", "issue": "source-code ownership gap", "owner": "Nadine Flores", "portfolio_key": "CBP-084-05", "recommended_action": "Create asset-use rows with exact cure or removal status. Owner: Nadine Flores; due 2026-09-10.", "severity": "high", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_patents/005_patents_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/03_copyrights/017_copyrights_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/029_invention_assignments_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/041_licenses_out_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/089_security_interests_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/09_development_records/065_development_records_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/097_drift_audio_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "the permission is limited to Middle District of Tennessee under CB-IP-3204-R760; the matched activity occurred in Tennessee under CB-IP-3204-E456. Identity resolves to ENT-084-1005, revision REV-2026.6 is current, and Rafael Okafor is active with capacity 6.", "due_date": "2026-09-09", "id": "ACT-CBP-084-06", "identity_id": "ENT-084-1005", "issue": "domain registrant mismatch", "owner": "Rafael Okafor", "portfolio_key": "CBP-084-06", "recommended_action": "Create asset-use rows with exact cure or removal status. Owner: Rafael Okafor; due 2026-09-09.", "severity": "critical", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_patents/006_patents_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/03_copyrights/018_copyrights_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/030_invention_assignments_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/042_licenses_out_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/09_development_records/066_development_records_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/07_open_source/054_open_source_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/097_drift_audio_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "delivery must use notices-drift_audio_labs@example.test under CB-IP-3204-R284; the only matched receipt used archive-silver_reed_composers_llc@example.test under CB-IP-3204-E269. Identity resolves to ENT-084-1007, revision REV-2026.1 is current, and Theo Laurent is active with capacity 2.", "due_date": "2026-09-07", "id": "ACT-CBP-084-08", "identity_id": "ENT-084-1007", "issue": "work-for-hire defect", "owner": "Theo Laurent", "portfolio_key": "CBP-084-08", "recommended_action": "Create asset-use rows with exact cure or removal status. Owner: Theo Laurent; due 2026-09-07.", "severity": "high", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_patents/008_patents_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/03_copyrights/020_copyrights_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/032_invention_assignments_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/044_licenses_out_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/097_drift_audio_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "an open exception blocks completion under CB-IP-3204-R923; the current status is open and unresolved under CB-IP-3204-E360. Identity resolves to ENT-084-1008, revision REV-2026.2 is current, and Lena Varga is active with capacity 4.", "due_date": "2026-09-06", "id": "ACT-CBP-084-09", "identity_id": "ENT-084-1008", "issue": "notice-file omission", "owner": "Lena Varga", "portfolio_key": "CBP-084-09", "recommended_action": "Create asset-use rows with exact cure or removal status. Owner: Lena Varga; due 2026-09-06.", "severity": "high", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_trademarks/009_trademarks_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/03_copyrights/021_copyrights_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/033_licenses_in_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/045_licenses_out_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/08_domain_accounts/057_domain_accounts_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/097_drift_audio_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "completion is required by 2025-09-09 under CB-IP-3204-R466; the current event record shows completion on 2025-09-18 under CB-IP-3204-E121. Identity resolves to ENT-084-1009, revision REV-2026.3 is current, and Elliot Mercer is active with capacity 5.", "due_date": "2026-09-14", "id": "ACT-CBP-084-10", "identity_id": "ENT-084-1009", "issue": "inventor assignment gap", "owner": "Elliot Mercer", "portfolio_key": "CBP-084-10", "recommended_action": "Create asset-use rows with exact cure or removal status. Owner: Elliot Mercer; due 2026-09-14.", "severity": "low", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_trademarks/010_trademarks_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/03_copyrights/022_copyrights_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/034_licenses_in_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/046_licenses_out_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/11_maintenance/082_maintenance_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/094_security_interests_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/097_drift_audio_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "the controlling threshold is 11% under CB-IP-3204-R600; the independently calculated result is 14% under CB-IP-3204-E605. Identity resolves to ENT-084-1010, revision REV-2026.4 is current, and Sofia Bennett is active with capacity 2.", "due_date": "2026-09-13", "id": "ACT-CBP-084-11", "identity_id": "ENT-084-1010", "issue": "coexistence restriction", "owner": "Sofia Bennett", "portfolio_key": "CBP-084-11", "recommended_action": "Create asset-use rows with exact cure or removal status. Owner: Sofia Bennett; due 2026-09-13.", "severity": "high", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_trademarks/011_trademarks_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/03_copyrights/023_copyrights_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/035_licenses_in_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/047_licenses_out_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/097_drift_audio_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "approval must come from Farah Ibrahim under CB-IP-3204-R378; the effective approval record names Rafael Okafor under CB-IP-3204-E539. Identity resolves to ENT-084-1011, revision REV-2026.5 is current, and Micah Sullivan is active with capacity 3.", "due_date": "2026-09-12", "id": "ACT-CBP-084-12", "identity_id": "ENT-084-1011", "issue": "copyleft distribution trigger", "owner": "Micah Sullivan", "portfolio_key": "CBP-084-12", "recommended_action": "Create asset-use rows with exact cure or removal status. Owner: Micah Sullivan; due 2026-09-12.", "severity": "high", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_trademarks/012_trademarks_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/03_copyrights/024_copyrights_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/036_licenses_in_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/048_licenses_out_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/11_maintenance/084_maintenance_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/097_drift_audio_impact_population.xlsx"]}], "as_of": "2026-09-15", "decision": {"alternatives_considered": ["drift-audio:blanket-hold", "drift-audio:shortcut"], "question": "Which Drift Audio training assets can remain, and which need a license cure or takedown?", "rationale": "The four-part causal test supports 9 scoped actions and leaves 3 records on evidence hold. Ownership, publicity, and license scope must all cover the actual training and distribution use.", "recommendation": "Retain, cure, or remove assets according to complete chain and current requests.", "selected_option_id": "drift-audio:scoped-evidence"}, "holds": [{"id": "HOLD-CBP-084-03", "issue": "repository access anomaly", "portfolio_key": "CBP-084-03", "reason": "the current observation does not meet the operative trigger", "required_next_evidence": "a current observation that satisfies the operative trigger", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_patents/003_patents_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/02_trademarks/015_trademarks_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/027_invention_assignments_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/039_licenses_in_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/10_disputes/075_disputes_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/07_open_source/051_open_source_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/097_drift_audio_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-084-04", "issue": "maintenance-fee deadline", "portfolio_key": "CBP-084-04", "reason": "the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective", "required_next_evidence": "effective approval and an active owner with remaining capacity", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_patents/004_patents_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/02_trademarks/016_trademarks_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/028_invention_assignments_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/040_licenses_in_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/11_maintenance/088_maintenance_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/07_open_source/052_open_source_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/097_drift_audio_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-084-07", "issue": "recorded-owner mismatch", "portfolio_key": "CBP-084-07", "reason": "the current observation does not meet the operative trigger", "required_next_evidence": "a current observation that satisfies the operative trigger", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_patents/007_patents_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/03_copyrights/019_copyrights_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/031_invention_assignments_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/043_licenses_out_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/097_drift_audio_impact_population.xlsx"]}], "matter_number": "CB-IP-3204", "prepared_for": "Drift Audio Labs", "schema_version": "counselbench.decision.v3", "task_id": "cb100-084-drift-audio"}, "matter_register": {"matter_number": "CB-IP-3204", "rows": [{"decision_option_id": "drift-audio:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-14", "issue": "foreign-filing restriction", "matter_number": "CB-IP-3204", "owner": "Willa Novak", "portfolio_key": "CBP-084-01", "row_id": "REG-CBP-084-01", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_patents/001_patents_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/02_trademarks/013_trademarks_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/025_invention_assignments_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/037_licenses_in_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/07_open_source/049_open_source_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/11_maintenance/085_maintenance_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/097_drift_audio_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "drift-audio:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-13", "issue": "inbound-license field restriction", "matter_number": "CB-IP-3204", "owner": "Owen Delgado", "portfolio_key": "CBP-084-02", "row_id": "REG-CBP-084-02", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_patents/002_patents_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/02_trademarks/014_trademarks_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/026_invention_assignments_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/038_licenses_in_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/08_domain_accounts/062_domain_accounts_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/07_open_source/050_open_source_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/097_drift_audio_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "drift-audio:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "the current observation does not meet the operative trigger", "issue": "repository access anomaly", "matter_number": "CB-IP-3204", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-084-03", "row_id": "REG-CBP-084-03", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_patents/003_patents_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/02_trademarks/015_trademarks_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/027_invention_assignments_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/039_licenses_in_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/10_disputes/075_disputes_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/07_open_source/051_open_source_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/097_drift_audio_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "drift-audio:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective", "issue": "maintenance-fee deadline", "matter_number": "CB-IP-3204", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-084-04", "row_id": "REG-CBP-084-04", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_patents/004_patents_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/02_trademarks/016_trademarks_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/028_invention_assignments_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/040_licenses_in_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/11_maintenance/088_maintenance_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/07_open_source/052_open_source_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/097_drift_audio_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "drift-audio:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-10", "issue": "source-code ownership gap", "matter_number": "CB-IP-3204", "owner": "Nadine Flores", "portfolio_key": "CBP-084-05", "row_id": "REG-CBP-084-05", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_patents/005_patents_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/03_copyrights/017_copyrights_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/029_invention_assignments_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/041_licenses_out_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/089_security_interests_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/09_development_records/065_development_records_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/097_drift_audio_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "drift-audio:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-09", "issue": "domain registrant mismatch", "matter_number": "CB-IP-3204", "owner": "Rafael Okafor", "portfolio_key": "CBP-084-06", "row_id": "REG-CBP-084-06", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_patents/006_patents_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/03_copyrights/018_copyrights_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/030_invention_assignments_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/042_licenses_out_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/09_development_records/066_development_records_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/07_open_source/054_open_source_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/097_drift_audio_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "drift-audio:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "the current observation does not meet the operative trigger", "issue": "recorded-owner mismatch", "matter_number": "CB-IP-3204", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-084-07", "row_id": "REG-CBP-084-07", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_patents/007_patents_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/03_copyrights/019_copyrights_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/031_invention_assignments_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/043_licenses_out_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/097_drift_audio_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "drift-audio:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-07", "issue": "work-for-hire defect", "matter_number": "CB-IP-3204", "owner": "Theo Laurent", "portfolio_key": "CBP-084-08", "row_id": "REG-CBP-084-08", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_patents/008_patents_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/03_copyrights/020_copyrights_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/032_invention_assignments_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/044_licenses_out_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/097_drift_audio_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "drift-audio:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-06", "issue": "notice-file omission", "matter_number": "CB-IP-3204", "owner": "Lena Varga", "portfolio_key": "CBP-084-09", "row_id": "REG-CBP-084-09", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_trademarks/009_trademarks_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/03_copyrights/021_copyrights_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/033_licenses_in_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/045_licenses_out_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/08_domain_accounts/057_domain_accounts_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/097_drift_audio_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "drift-audio:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-14", "issue": "inventor assignment gap", "matter_number": "CB-IP-3204", "owner": "Elliot Mercer", "portfolio_key": "CBP-084-10", "row_id": "REG-CBP-084-10", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_trademarks/010_trademarks_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/03_copyrights/022_copyrights_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/034_licenses_in_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/046_licenses_out_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/11_maintenance/082_maintenance_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/094_security_interests_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/097_drift_audio_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "drift-audio:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-13", "issue": "coexistence restriction", "matter_number": "CB-IP-3204", "owner": "Sofia Bennett", "portfolio_key": "CBP-084-11", "row_id": "REG-CBP-084-11", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_trademarks/011_trademarks_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/03_copyrights/023_copyrights_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/035_licenses_in_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/047_licenses_out_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/097_drift_audio_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "drift-audio:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-12", "issue": "copyleft distribution trigger", "matter_number": "CB-IP-3204", "owner": "Micah Sullivan", "portfolio_key": "CBP-084-12", "row_id": "REG-CBP-084-12", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_trademarks/012_trademarks_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/03_copyrights/024_copyrights_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/036_licenses_in_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/048_licenses_out_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/11_maintenance/084_maintenance_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/097_drift_audio_impact_population.xlsx"]}], "schema_version": "counselbench.matter-register.v3", "task_id": "cb100-084-drift-audio"}}, "metadata": {"benchmark": "CounselBench-100", "code_license": "Apache-2.0", "data_license": "CC-BY-4.0", "deadline": "2026-09-15", "document_count": 97, "evidence_holds": 3, "jurisdiction": "Tennessee", "matter_number": "CB-IP-3204", "mcp_commit": "9a96ea6e5913736f92b88345bf51caeaaa8e719f", "mcp_package": "@modelcontextprotocol/server-filesystem@2026.7.10", "practice_area": "ip-technology", "reference_tool_calls": 86, "required_evidence_reads": 65, "supported_actions": 9, "synthetic": true, "venue": "Middle District of Tennessee", "version": "3.1.0"}, "prompt": "The client wants a decision, not another document inventory. Which Drift Audio training assets can remain, and which need a license cure or takedown? An audio-model training catalog includes commissioned recordings, performer releases, sample licenses, and takedown correspondence. The team needs the call by 2026-09-15. Put the supported calls into the matter register and leave me a short note I can use with the partner.", "rubric": {"criteria": [{"category": "investigation", "description": "Inventory the production and use targeted searches to locate records across native formats.", "id": "investigation.discover_production"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Complete every task-specific identity, authority, operations, and approval read before the first state transition.", "id": "investigation.read_before_write"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Inspect designated source metadata before relying on those records.", "id": "investigation.custody_before_write"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "Select the supported option 'drift-audio:scoped-evidence' after applying the four-part test.", "id": "decision.selected_option"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "Identify both rejected approaches and explain why a one-source shortcut and a blanket hold are wrong.", "id": "decision.alternatives"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-084-01 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_patents/001_patents_source_export.md rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-084-01.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_trademarks/013_trademarks_source_export.json for foreign-filing restriction.", "id": "investigation.CBP-084-01.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/025_invention_assignments_source_export.md to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-084-01.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/037_licenses_in_source_export.json.", "id": "investigation.CBP-084-01.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-084-01 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-084-01.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-084-01 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-084-01.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-084-02 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_patents/002_patents_source_export.txt rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-084-02.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_trademarks/014_trademarks_source_export.xml for inbound-license field restriction.", "id": "investigation.CBP-084-02.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/026_invention_assignments_source_export.txt to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-084-02.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/038_licenses_in_source_export.xml.", "id": "investigation.CBP-084-02.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-084-02 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-084-02.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-084-02 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-084-02.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-084-03 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_patents/003_patents_source_export.eml rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-084-03.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_trademarks/015_trademarks_source_export.html for repository access anomaly.", "id": "investigation.CBP-084-03.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/027_invention_assignments_source_export.eml to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-084-03.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/039_licenses_in_source_export.html.", "id": "investigation.CBP-084-03.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-084-03 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is the current observation does not meet the operative trigger.", "id": "decision.CBP-084-03.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-084-03 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-084-03.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-084-04 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_patents/004_patents_source_export.csv rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-084-04.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_trademarks/016_trademarks_source_export.pdf for maintenance-fee deadline.", "id": "investigation.CBP-084-04.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/028_invention_assignments_source_export.csv to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-084-04.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/040_licenses_in_source_export.pdf.", "id": "investigation.CBP-084-04.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-084-04 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective.", "id": "decision.CBP-084-04.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-084-04 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-084-04.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-084-05 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_patents/005_patents_source_export.json rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-084-05.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_copyrights/017_copyrights_source_export.md for source-code ownership gap.", "id": "investigation.CBP-084-05.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/029_invention_assignments_source_export.json to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-084-05.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/041_licenses_out_source_export.md.", "id": "investigation.CBP-084-05.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-084-05 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-084-05.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-084-05 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-084-05.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-084-06 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_patents/006_patents_source_export.xml rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-084-06.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_copyrights/018_copyrights_source_export.txt for domain registrant mismatch.", "id": "investigation.CBP-084-06.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/030_invention_assignments_source_export.xml to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-084-06.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/042_licenses_out_source_export.txt.", "id": "investigation.CBP-084-06.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-084-06 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-084-06.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-084-06 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-084-06.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-084-07 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_patents/007_patents_source_export.html rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-084-07.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_copyrights/019_copyrights_source_export.eml for recorded-owner mismatch.", "id": "investigation.CBP-084-07.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/031_invention_assignments_source_export.html to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-084-07.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/043_licenses_out_source_export.eml.", "id": "investigation.CBP-084-07.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-084-07 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is the current observation does not meet the operative trigger.", "id": "decision.CBP-084-07.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-084-07 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-084-07.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-084-08 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_patents/008_patents_source_export.pdf rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-084-08.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_copyrights/020_copyrights_source_export.csv for work-for-hire defect.", "id": "investigation.CBP-084-08.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/032_invention_assignments_source_export.pdf to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-084-08.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/044_licenses_out_source_export.csv.", "id": "investigation.CBP-084-08.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-084-08 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-084-08.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-084-08 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-084-08.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-084-09 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_trademarks/009_trademarks_source_export.md rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-084-09.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_copyrights/021_copyrights_source_export.json for notice-file omission.", "id": "investigation.CBP-084-09.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/033_licenses_in_source_export.md to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-084-09.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/045_licenses_out_source_export.json.", "id": "investigation.CBP-084-09.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-084-09 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-084-09.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-084-09 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-084-09.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-084-10 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_trademarks/010_trademarks_source_export.txt rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-084-10.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_copyrights/022_copyrights_source_export.xml for inventor assignment gap.", "id": "investigation.CBP-084-10.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/034_licenses_in_source_export.txt to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-084-10.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/046_licenses_out_source_export.xml.", "id": "investigation.CBP-084-10.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-084-10 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-084-10.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-084-10 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-084-10.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-084-11 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_trademarks/011_trademarks_source_export.eml rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-084-11.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_copyrights/023_copyrights_source_export.html for coexistence restriction.", "id": "investigation.CBP-084-11.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/035_licenses_in_source_export.eml to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-084-11.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/047_licenses_out_source_export.html.", "id": "investigation.CBP-084-11.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-084-11 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-084-11.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-084-11 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-084-11.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-084-12 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_trademarks/012_trademarks_source_export.csv rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-084-12.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_copyrights/024_copyrights_source_export.pdf for copyleft distribution trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-084-12.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/036_licenses_in_source_export.csv to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-084-12.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/048_licenses_out_source_export.pdf.", "id": "investigation.CBP-084-12.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-084-12 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-084-12.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-084-12 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-084-12.register"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Write the exact selected option, supported action population, evidence-hold population, facts, owners, deadlines, and citations.", "id": "state.exact_decision"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create one exact register row per portfolio key with no extra, missing, or modified row.", "id": "state.exact_register"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Leave only the three approved deliverables and perform no extra state-changing write.", "id": "state.write_scope_containment"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Read back decision.json, matter-register.json, and advice.md after their final writes.", "id": "state.postwrite_readback"}, {"category": "answer", "description": "Explain the selected recommendation, supported actions, holds, alternatives, and limitations with exact source anchors.", "id": "answer.decision_note"}], "decision_options": [{"approach": "Treat supported actions and genuinely ambiguous records as if they were equally unresolved.", "id": "drift-audio:blanket-hold", "label": "Freeze the entire matter population"}, {"approach": "Apply the exact identity, current-state, authority, and revision test. Create asset-use rows with exact cure or removal status.", "id": "drift-audio:scoped-evidence", "label": "Retain, cure, or remove assets according to complete chain and current requests."}, {"approach": "Use a plausible summary or one source without completing the controlling joins.", "id": "drift-audio:shortcut", "label": "Treat a paid commission as ownership of every performance and sample right."}], "evaluation_narrative": {"authority": "Ownership, publicity, and license scope must all cover the actual training and distribution use.", "observation": "Match recordings, performers, commissions, samples, releases, models, and takedown requests by asset ID.", "question": "Which Drift Audio training assets can remain, and which need a license cure or takedown?", "register_action": "Create asset-use rows with exact cure or removal status."}, "gates": ["all_required_evidence_precedes_first_write", "decision_criteria_complete", "register_state_exact", "write_scope_contained", "all_outputs_verified_by_readback"], "metadata_checks": 9, "metric": "weighted_criteria_score", "minimum_tool_calls": 86, "required_deliverables": ["decision.json", "matter-register.json", "advice.md"], "required_document_reads": 65, "type": "deterministic", "weights": {"advice": 0.15, "decision": 0.35, "investigation": 0.25, "state": 0.25}}, "task_id": "cb100-084-drift-audio", "task_name": "Drift Audio catalog ownership audit", "world_id": "counselbench-filesystem-mcp-v3"}
+{"context_files": ["task_files/cb100-085-everglass-medical/01_patents/001_patents_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-085-everglass-medical/01_patents/002_patents_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-085-everglass-medical/01_patents/003_patents_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-085-everglass-medical/01_patents/004_patents_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-085-everglass-medical/01_patents/005_patents_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-085-everglass-medical/01_patents/006_patents_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-085-everglass-medical/01_patents/007_patents_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-085-everglass-medical/01_patents/008_patents_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-085-everglass-medical/02_trademarks/009_trademarks_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-085-everglass-medical/02_trademarks/010_trademarks_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-085-everglass-medical/02_trademarks/011_trademarks_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-085-everglass-medical/02_trademarks/012_trademarks_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-085-everglass-medical/02_trademarks/013_trademarks_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-085-everglass-medical/02_trademarks/014_trademarks_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-085-everglass-medical/02_trademarks/015_trademarks_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-085-everglass-medical/02_trademarks/016_trademarks_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-085-everglass-medical/03_copyrights/017_copyrights_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-085-everglass-medical/03_copyrights/018_copyrights_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-085-everglass-medical/03_copyrights/019_copyrights_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-085-everglass-medical/03_copyrights/020_copyrights_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-085-everglass-medical/03_copyrights/021_copyrights_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-085-everglass-medical/03_copyrights/022_copyrights_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-085-everglass-medical/03_copyrights/023_copyrights_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-085-everglass-medical/03_copyrights/024_copyrights_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-085-everglass-medical/04_invention_assignments/025_invention_assignments_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-085-everglass-medical/04_invention_assignments/026_invention_assignments_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-085-everglass-medical/04_invention_assignments/027_invention_assignments_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-085-everglass-medical/04_invention_assignments/028_invention_assignments_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-085-everglass-medical/04_invention_assignments/029_invention_assignments_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-085-everglass-medical/04_invention_assignments/030_invention_assignments_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-085-everglass-medical/04_invention_assignments/031_invention_assignments_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-085-everglass-medical/04_invention_assignments/032_invention_assignments_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-085-everglass-medical/05_licenses_in/033_licenses_in_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-085-everglass-medical/05_licenses_in/034_licenses_in_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-085-everglass-medical/05_licenses_in/035_licenses_in_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-085-everglass-medical/05_licenses_in/036_licenses_in_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-085-everglass-medical/05_licenses_in/037_licenses_in_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-085-everglass-medical/05_licenses_in/038_licenses_in_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-085-everglass-medical/05_licenses_in/039_licenses_in_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-085-everglass-medical/05_licenses_in/040_licenses_in_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-085-everglass-medical/06_licenses_out/041_licenses_out_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-085-everglass-medical/06_licenses_out/042_licenses_out_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-085-everglass-medical/06_licenses_out/043_licenses_out_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-085-everglass-medical/06_licenses_out/044_licenses_out_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-085-everglass-medical/06_licenses_out/045_licenses_out_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-085-everglass-medical/06_licenses_out/046_licenses_out_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-085-everglass-medical/06_licenses_out/047_licenses_out_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-085-everglass-medical/06_licenses_out/048_licenses_out_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-085-everglass-medical/07_open_source/049_open_source_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-085-everglass-medical/07_open_source/050_open_source_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-085-everglass-medical/07_open_source/051_open_source_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-085-everglass-medical/07_open_source/052_open_source_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-085-everglass-medical/07_open_source/053_open_source_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-085-everglass-medical/07_open_source/054_open_source_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-085-everglass-medical/07_open_source/055_open_source_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-085-everglass-medical/07_open_source/056_open_source_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-085-everglass-medical/08_domain_accounts/057_domain_accounts_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-085-everglass-medical/08_domain_accounts/058_domain_accounts_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-085-everglass-medical/08_domain_accounts/059_domain_accounts_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-085-everglass-medical/08_domain_accounts/060_domain_accounts_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-085-everglass-medical/08_domain_accounts/061_domain_accounts_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-085-everglass-medical/08_domain_accounts/062_domain_accounts_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-085-everglass-medical/08_domain_accounts/063_domain_accounts_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-085-everglass-medical/08_domain_accounts/064_domain_accounts_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-085-everglass-medical/09_development_records/065_development_records_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-085-everglass-medical/09_development_records/066_development_records_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-085-everglass-medical/09_development_records/067_development_records_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-085-everglass-medical/09_development_records/068_development_records_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-085-everglass-medical/09_development_records/069_development_records_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-085-everglass-medical/09_development_records/070_development_records_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-085-everglass-medical/09_development_records/071_development_records_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-085-everglass-medical/09_development_records/072_development_records_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-085-everglass-medical/10_disputes/073_disputes_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-085-everglass-medical/10_disputes/074_disputes_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-085-everglass-medical/10_disputes/075_disputes_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-085-everglass-medical/10_disputes/076_disputes_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-085-everglass-medical/10_disputes/077_disputes_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-085-everglass-medical/10_disputes/078_disputes_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-085-everglass-medical/10_disputes/079_disputes_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-085-everglass-medical/10_disputes/080_disputes_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-085-everglass-medical/11_maintenance/081_maintenance_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-085-everglass-medical/11_maintenance/082_maintenance_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-085-everglass-medical/11_maintenance/083_maintenance_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-085-everglass-medical/11_maintenance/084_maintenance_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-085-everglass-medical/11_maintenance/085_maintenance_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-085-everglass-medical/11_maintenance/086_maintenance_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-085-everglass-medical/11_maintenance/087_maintenance_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-085-everglass-medical/11_maintenance/088_maintenance_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-085-everglass-medical/12_security_interests/089_security_interests_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-085-everglass-medical/12_security_interests/090_security_interests_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-085-everglass-medical/12_security_interests/091_security_interests_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-085-everglass-medical/12_security_interests/092_security_interests_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-085-everglass-medical/12_security_interests/093_security_interests_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-085-everglass-medical/12_security_interests/094_security_interests_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-085-everglass-medical/12_security_interests/095_security_interests_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-085-everglass-medical/12_security_interests/096_security_interests_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-085-everglass-medical/12_security_interests/097_everglass_medical_impact_population.xlsx"], "gold_output": {"advice_markdown": "# Decision note — Everglass patent license diligence\n\n## Recommendation\n\nProceed only for supported fields and cure exact milestone, sublicense, or maintenance gaps. The reconciled record supports 6 scoped actions and leaves 6 items on evidence hold.\n\nSelected option: `everglass-medical:scoped-evidence`.\n\n## Why this is the supported option\n\nJoin patent families, milestones, product fields, sublicenses, government rights, and maintenance status. The effective license and applicable government and maintenance obligations govern each family.\n\n## Supported actions\n\n### CBP-085-02 — outbound sublicense overreach (high)\n\nthe operative cap is $1,762,000.00 under CB-IP-3205-R210; the matched ledger population totals $1,853,110.00 under CB-IP-3205-E159. Identity resolves to ENT-085-1001, revision REV-2025.2 is current, and Maya Ellison is active with capacity 1.\n\nAction: Create patent-family rows with scoped rights and obligations. Owner: Maya Ellison; due 2026-09-16.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_patents/002_patents_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/02_trademarks/014_trademarks_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/026_invention_assignments_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/038_licenses_in_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/07_open_source/050_open_source_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/097_everglass_medical_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-085-04 — foreign-filing restriction (medium)\n\nan open exception blocks completion under CB-IP-3205-R194; the current status is open and unresolved under CB-IP-3205-E846. Identity resolves to ENT-085-1003, revision REV-2025.4 is current, and Willa Novak is active with capacity 4.\n\nAction: Create patent-family rows with scoped rights and obligations. Owner: Willa Novak; due 2026-09-14.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_patents/004_patents_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/02_trademarks/016_trademarks_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/028_invention_assignments_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/040_licenses_in_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/097_everglass_medical_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-085-05 — inbound-license field restriction (high)\n\ncompletion is required by 2025-11-10 under CB-IP-3205-R648; the current event record shows completion on 2025-12-24 under CB-IP-3205-E449. Identity resolves to ENT-085-1004, revision REV-2025.5 is current, and Owen Delgado is active with capacity 1.\n\nAction: Create patent-family rows with scoped rights and obligations. Owner: Owen Delgado; due 2026-09-13.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_patents/005_patents_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/03_copyrights/017_copyrights_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/029_invention_assignments_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/041_licenses_out_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/097_everglass_medical_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-085-07 — maintenance-fee deadline (medium)\n\napproval must come from Talia Brooks under CB-IP-3205-R326; the effective approval record names Rafael Okafor under CB-IP-3205-E325. Identity resolves to ENT-085-1006, revision REV-2025.7 is current, and Isaac Romero is active with capacity 2.\n\nAction: Create patent-family rows with scoped rights and obligations. Owner: Isaac Romero; due 2026-09-11.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_patents/007_patents_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/03_copyrights/019_copyrights_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/031_invention_assignments_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/043_licenses_out_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/10_disputes/079_disputes_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/097_everglass_medical_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-085-08 — source-code ownership gap (critical)\n\nthe controlled population contains 136 records under CB-IP-3205-R994; the certification covers 106 records under CB-IP-3205-E893. Identity resolves to ENT-085-1007, revision REV-2025.1 is current, and Nadine Flores is active with capacity 2.\n\nAction: Create patent-family rows with scoped rights and obligations. Owner: Nadine Flores; due 2026-09-10.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_patents/008_patents_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/03_copyrights/020_copyrights_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/032_invention_assignments_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/044_licenses_out_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/092_security_interests_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/09_development_records/068_development_records_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/097_everglass_medical_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-085-10 — recorded-owner mismatch (medium)\n\nthe operative cap is $6,802,000.00 under CB-IP-3205-R187; the matched ledger population totals $6,815,087.00 under CB-IP-3205-E158. Identity resolves to ENT-085-1009, revision REV-2025.3 is current, and Mei Whitaker is active with capacity 1.\n\nAction: Create patent-family rows with scoped rights and obligations. Owner: Mei Whitaker; due 2026-09-17.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/02_trademarks/010_trademarks_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/03_copyrights/022_copyrights_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/034_licenses_in_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/046_licenses_out_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/08_domain_accounts/058_domain_accounts_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/09_development_records/070_development_records_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/097_everglass_medical_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n## Evidence holds\n\n- **CBP-085-01 — trademark specimen issue**: two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key. Next evidence: an approved immutable entity crosswalk. Sources: `/workspace/documents/01_patents/001_patents_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/02_trademarks/013_trademarks_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/025_invention_assignments_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/037_licenses_in_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/07_open_source/049_open_source_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/097_everglass_medical_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-085-03 — cease-and-desist deadline**: the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective. Next evidence: effective approval and an active owner with remaining capacity. Sources: `/workspace/documents/01_patents/003_patents_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/02_trademarks/015_trademarks_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/027_invention_assignments_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/039_licenses_in_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/10_disputes/075_disputes_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/08_domain_accounts/063_domain_accounts_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/097_everglass_medical_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-085-06 — repository access anomaly**: the current observation does not meet the operative trigger. Next evidence: a current observation that satisfies the operative trigger. Sources: `/workspace/documents/01_patents/006_patents_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/03_copyrights/018_copyrights_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/030_invention_assignments_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/042_licenses_out_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/097_everglass_medical_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-085-09 — domain registrant mismatch**: two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key. Next evidence: an approved immutable entity crosswalk. Sources: `/workspace/documents/02_trademarks/009_trademarks_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/03_copyrights/021_copyrights_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/033_licenses_in_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/045_licenses_out_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/11_maintenance/081_maintenance_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/08_domain_accounts/057_domain_accounts_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/097_everglass_medical_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-085-11 — work-for-hire defect**: the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective. Next evidence: effective approval and an active owner with remaining capacity. Sources: `/workspace/documents/02_trademarks/011_trademarks_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/03_copyrights/023_copyrights_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/035_licenses_in_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/047_licenses_out_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/09_development_records/071_development_records_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/08_domain_accounts/059_domain_accounts_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/097_everglass_medical_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-085-12 — notice-file omission**: the operational record relies on a superseded control revision. Next evidence: an operational record using the current effective revision. Sources: `/workspace/documents/02_trademarks/012_trademarks_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/03_copyrights/024_copyrights_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/036_licenses_in_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/048_licenses_out_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/097_everglass_medical_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n## Alternatives considered\n\n- `everglass-medical:shortcut` — Treat payment of royalties as curing every scope and diligence condition.: Use a plausible summary or one source without completing the controlling joins.\n- `everglass-medical:blanket-hold` — Freeze the entire matter population: Treat supported actions and genuinely ambiguous records as if they were equally unresolved.\n\n## Assumptions and limits\n\nThis decision is limited to cb100-085-everglass-medical, the supplied synthetic records, and the matter state as of 2026-09-18. Similar names, stale revisions, and pending authority are not treated as proof.\n", "decision": {"actions": [{"determination": "the operative cap is $1,762,000.00 under CB-IP-3205-R210; the matched ledger population totals $1,853,110.00 under CB-IP-3205-E159. Identity resolves to ENT-085-1001, revision REV-2025.2 is current, and Maya Ellison is active with capacity 1.", "due_date": "2026-09-16", "id": "ACT-CBP-085-02", "identity_id": "ENT-085-1001", "issue": "outbound sublicense overreach", "owner": "Maya Ellison", "portfolio_key": "CBP-085-02", "recommended_action": "Create patent-family rows with scoped rights and obligations. Owner: Maya Ellison; due 2026-09-16.", "severity": "high", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_patents/002_patents_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/02_trademarks/014_trademarks_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/026_invention_assignments_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/038_licenses_in_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/07_open_source/050_open_source_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/097_everglass_medical_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "an open exception blocks completion under CB-IP-3205-R194; the current status is open and unresolved under CB-IP-3205-E846. Identity resolves to ENT-085-1003, revision REV-2025.4 is current, and Willa Novak is active with capacity 4.", "due_date": "2026-09-14", "id": "ACT-CBP-085-04", "identity_id": "ENT-085-1003", "issue": "foreign-filing restriction", "owner": "Willa Novak", "portfolio_key": "CBP-085-04", "recommended_action": "Create patent-family rows with scoped rights and obligations. Owner: Willa Novak; due 2026-09-14.", "severity": "medium", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_patents/004_patents_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/02_trademarks/016_trademarks_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/028_invention_assignments_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/040_licenses_in_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/097_everglass_medical_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "completion is required by 2025-11-10 under CB-IP-3205-R648; the current event record shows completion on 2025-12-24 under CB-IP-3205-E449. Identity resolves to ENT-085-1004, revision REV-2025.5 is current, and Owen Delgado is active with capacity 1.", "due_date": "2026-09-13", "id": "ACT-CBP-085-05", "identity_id": "ENT-085-1004", "issue": "inbound-license field restriction", "owner": "Owen Delgado", "portfolio_key": "CBP-085-05", "recommended_action": "Create patent-family rows with scoped rights and obligations. Owner: Owen Delgado; due 2026-09-13.", "severity": "high", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_patents/005_patents_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/03_copyrights/017_copyrights_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/029_invention_assignments_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/041_licenses_out_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/097_everglass_medical_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "approval must come from Talia Brooks under CB-IP-3205-R326; the effective approval record names Rafael Okafor under CB-IP-3205-E325. Identity resolves to ENT-085-1006, revision REV-2025.7 is current, and Isaac Romero is active with capacity 2.", "due_date": "2026-09-11", "id": "ACT-CBP-085-07", "identity_id": "ENT-085-1006", "issue": "maintenance-fee deadline", "owner": "Isaac Romero", "portfolio_key": "CBP-085-07", "recommended_action": "Create patent-family rows with scoped rights and obligations. Owner: Isaac Romero; due 2026-09-11.", "severity": "medium", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_patents/007_patents_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/03_copyrights/019_copyrights_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/031_invention_assignments_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/043_licenses_out_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/10_disputes/079_disputes_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/097_everglass_medical_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "the controlled population contains 136 records under CB-IP-3205-R994; the certification covers 106 records under CB-IP-3205-E893. Identity resolves to ENT-085-1007, revision REV-2025.1 is current, and Nadine Flores is active with capacity 2.", "due_date": "2026-09-10", "id": "ACT-CBP-085-08", "identity_id": "ENT-085-1007", "issue": "source-code ownership gap", "owner": "Nadine Flores", "portfolio_key": "CBP-085-08", "recommended_action": "Create patent-family rows with scoped rights and obligations. Owner: Nadine Flores; due 2026-09-10.", "severity": "critical", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_patents/008_patents_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/03_copyrights/020_copyrights_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/032_invention_assignments_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/044_licenses_out_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/092_security_interests_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/09_development_records/068_development_records_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/097_everglass_medical_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "the operative cap is $6,802,000.00 under CB-IP-3205-R187; the matched ledger population totals $6,815,087.00 under CB-IP-3205-E158. Identity resolves to ENT-085-1009, revision REV-2025.3 is current, and Mei Whitaker is active with capacity 1.", "due_date": "2026-09-17", "id": "ACT-CBP-085-10", "identity_id": "ENT-085-1009", "issue": "recorded-owner mismatch", "owner": "Mei Whitaker", "portfolio_key": "CBP-085-10", "recommended_action": "Create patent-family rows with scoped rights and obligations. Owner: Mei Whitaker; due 2026-09-17.", "severity": "medium", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_trademarks/010_trademarks_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/03_copyrights/022_copyrights_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/034_licenses_in_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/046_licenses_out_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/08_domain_accounts/058_domain_accounts_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/09_development_records/070_development_records_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/097_everglass_medical_impact_population.xlsx"]}], "as_of": "2026-09-18", "decision": {"alternatives_considered": ["everglass-medical:shortcut", "everglass-medical:blanket-hold"], "question": "Can Everglass rely on the university patent license for the planned product and sublicense?", "rationale": "The four-part causal test supports 6 scoped actions and leaves 6 records on evidence hold. The effective license and applicable government and maintenance obligations govern each family.", "recommendation": "Proceed only for supported fields and cure exact milestone, sublicense, or maintenance gaps.", "selected_option_id": "everglass-medical:scoped-evidence"}, "holds": [{"id": "HOLD-CBP-085-01", "issue": "trademark specimen issue", "portfolio_key": "CBP-085-01", "reason": "two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key", "required_next_evidence": "an approved immutable entity crosswalk", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_patents/001_patents_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/02_trademarks/013_trademarks_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/025_invention_assignments_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/037_licenses_in_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/07_open_source/049_open_source_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/097_everglass_medical_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-085-03", "issue": "cease-and-desist deadline", "portfolio_key": "CBP-085-03", "reason": "the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective", "required_next_evidence": "effective approval and an active owner with remaining capacity", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_patents/003_patents_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/02_trademarks/015_trademarks_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/027_invention_assignments_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/039_licenses_in_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/10_disputes/075_disputes_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/08_domain_accounts/063_domain_accounts_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/097_everglass_medical_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-085-06", "issue": "repository access anomaly", "portfolio_key": "CBP-085-06", "reason": "the current observation does not meet the operative trigger", "required_next_evidence": "a current observation that satisfies the operative trigger", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_patents/006_patents_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/03_copyrights/018_copyrights_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/030_invention_assignments_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/042_licenses_out_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/097_everglass_medical_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-085-09", "issue": "domain registrant mismatch", "portfolio_key": "CBP-085-09", "reason": "two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key", "required_next_evidence": "an approved immutable entity crosswalk", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_trademarks/009_trademarks_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/03_copyrights/021_copyrights_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/033_licenses_in_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/045_licenses_out_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/11_maintenance/081_maintenance_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/08_domain_accounts/057_domain_accounts_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/097_everglass_medical_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-085-11", "issue": "work-for-hire defect", "portfolio_key": "CBP-085-11", "reason": "the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective", "required_next_evidence": "effective approval and an active owner with remaining capacity", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_trademarks/011_trademarks_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/03_copyrights/023_copyrights_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/035_licenses_in_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/047_licenses_out_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/09_development_records/071_development_records_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/08_domain_accounts/059_domain_accounts_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/097_everglass_medical_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-085-12", "issue": "notice-file omission", "portfolio_key": "CBP-085-12", "reason": "the operational record relies on a superseded control revision", "required_next_evidence": "an operational record using the current effective revision", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_trademarks/012_trademarks_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/03_copyrights/024_copyrights_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/036_licenses_in_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/048_licenses_out_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/097_everglass_medical_impact_population.xlsx"]}], "matter_number": "CB-IP-3205", "prepared_for": "Everglass Medical Optics", "schema_version": "counselbench.decision.v3", "task_id": "cb100-085-everglass-medical"}, "matter_register": {"matter_number": "CB-IP-3205", "rows": [{"decision_option_id": "everglass-medical:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key", "issue": "trademark specimen issue", "matter_number": "CB-IP-3205", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-085-01", "row_id": "REG-CBP-085-01", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_patents/001_patents_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/02_trademarks/013_trademarks_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/025_invention_assignments_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/037_licenses_in_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/07_open_source/049_open_source_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/097_everglass_medical_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "everglass-medical:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-16", "issue": "outbound sublicense overreach", "matter_number": "CB-IP-3205", "owner": "Maya Ellison", "portfolio_key": "CBP-085-02", "row_id": "REG-CBP-085-02", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_patents/002_patents_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/02_trademarks/014_trademarks_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/026_invention_assignments_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/038_licenses_in_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/07_open_source/050_open_source_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/097_everglass_medical_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "everglass-medical:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective", "issue": "cease-and-desist deadline", "matter_number": "CB-IP-3205", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-085-03", "row_id": "REG-CBP-085-03", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_patents/003_patents_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/02_trademarks/015_trademarks_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/027_invention_assignments_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/039_licenses_in_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/10_disputes/075_disputes_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/08_domain_accounts/063_domain_accounts_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/097_everglass_medical_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "everglass-medical:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-14", "issue": "foreign-filing restriction", "matter_number": "CB-IP-3205", "owner": "Willa Novak", "portfolio_key": "CBP-085-04", "row_id": "REG-CBP-085-04", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_patents/004_patents_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/02_trademarks/016_trademarks_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/028_invention_assignments_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/040_licenses_in_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/097_everglass_medical_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "everglass-medical:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-13", "issue": "inbound-license field restriction", "matter_number": "CB-IP-3205", "owner": "Owen Delgado", "portfolio_key": "CBP-085-05", "row_id": "REG-CBP-085-05", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_patents/005_patents_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/03_copyrights/017_copyrights_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/029_invention_assignments_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/041_licenses_out_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/097_everglass_medical_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "everglass-medical:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "the current observation does not meet the operative trigger", "issue": "repository access anomaly", "matter_number": "CB-IP-3205", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-085-06", "row_id": "REG-CBP-085-06", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_patents/006_patents_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/03_copyrights/018_copyrights_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/030_invention_assignments_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/042_licenses_out_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/097_everglass_medical_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "everglass-medical:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-11", "issue": "maintenance-fee deadline", "matter_number": "CB-IP-3205", "owner": "Isaac Romero", "portfolio_key": "CBP-085-07", "row_id": "REG-CBP-085-07", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_patents/007_patents_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/03_copyrights/019_copyrights_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/031_invention_assignments_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/043_licenses_out_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/10_disputes/079_disputes_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/097_everglass_medical_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "everglass-medical:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-10", "issue": "source-code ownership gap", "matter_number": "CB-IP-3205", "owner": "Nadine Flores", "portfolio_key": "CBP-085-08", "row_id": "REG-CBP-085-08", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_patents/008_patents_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/03_copyrights/020_copyrights_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/032_invention_assignments_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/044_licenses_out_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/092_security_interests_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/09_development_records/068_development_records_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/097_everglass_medical_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "everglass-medical:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key", "issue": "domain registrant mismatch", "matter_number": "CB-IP-3205", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-085-09", "row_id": "REG-CBP-085-09", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_trademarks/009_trademarks_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/03_copyrights/021_copyrights_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/033_licenses_in_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/045_licenses_out_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/11_maintenance/081_maintenance_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/08_domain_accounts/057_domain_accounts_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/097_everglass_medical_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "everglass-medical:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-17", "issue": "recorded-owner mismatch", "matter_number": "CB-IP-3205", "owner": "Mei Whitaker", "portfolio_key": "CBP-085-10", "row_id": "REG-CBP-085-10", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_trademarks/010_trademarks_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/03_copyrights/022_copyrights_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/034_licenses_in_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/046_licenses_out_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/08_domain_accounts/058_domain_accounts_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/09_development_records/070_development_records_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/097_everglass_medical_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "everglass-medical:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective", "issue": "work-for-hire defect", "matter_number": "CB-IP-3205", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-085-11", "row_id": "REG-CBP-085-11", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_trademarks/011_trademarks_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/03_copyrights/023_copyrights_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/035_licenses_in_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/047_licenses_out_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/09_development_records/071_development_records_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/08_domain_accounts/059_domain_accounts_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/097_everglass_medical_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "everglass-medical:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "the operational record relies on a superseded control revision", "issue": "notice-file omission", "matter_number": "CB-IP-3205", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-085-12", "row_id": "REG-CBP-085-12", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_trademarks/012_trademarks_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/03_copyrights/024_copyrights_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/036_licenses_in_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/048_licenses_out_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/097_everglass_medical_impact_population.xlsx"]}], "schema_version": "counselbench.matter-register.v3", "task_id": "cb100-085-everglass-medical"}}, "metadata": {"benchmark": "CounselBench-100", "code_license": "Apache-2.0", "data_license": "CC-BY-4.0", "deadline": "2026-09-18", "document_count": 97, "evidence_holds": 6, "jurisdiction": "Wisconsin", "matter_number": "CB-IP-3205", "mcp_commit": "9a96ea6e5913736f92b88345bf51caeaaa8e719f", "mcp_package": "@modelcontextprotocol/server-filesystem@2026.7.10", "practice_area": "ip-technology", "reference_tool_calls": 87, "required_evidence_reads": 63, "supported_actions": 6, "synthetic": true, "venue": "Western District of Wisconsin", "version": "3.1.0"}, "prompt": "We inherited inconsistent versions of this matter and need to settle the operating position. Can Everglass rely on the university patent license for the planned product and sublicense? University optical patents carry diligence milestones, sublicense economics, government rights, and maintenance obligations. The team needs the call by 2026-09-18. I need the recommendation and the real blockers recorded before the team acts.", "rubric": {"criteria": [{"category": "investigation", "description": "Inventory the production and use targeted searches to locate records across native formats.", "id": "investigation.discover_production"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Complete every task-specific identity, authority, operations, and approval read before the first state transition.", "id": "investigation.read_before_write"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Inspect designated source metadata before relying on those records.", "id": "investigation.custody_before_write"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "Select the supported option 'everglass-medical:scoped-evidence' after applying the four-part test.", "id": "decision.selected_option"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "Identify both rejected approaches and explain why a one-source shortcut and a blanket hold are wrong.", "id": "decision.alternatives"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-085-01 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_patents/001_patents_source_export.md rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-085-01.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_trademarks/013_trademarks_source_export.json for trademark specimen issue.", "id": "investigation.CBP-085-01.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/025_invention_assignments_source_export.md to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-085-01.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/037_licenses_in_source_export.json.", "id": "investigation.CBP-085-01.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-085-01 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key.", "id": "decision.CBP-085-01.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-085-01 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-085-01.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-085-02 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_patents/002_patents_source_export.txt rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-085-02.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_trademarks/014_trademarks_source_export.xml for outbound sublicense overreach.", "id": "investigation.CBP-085-02.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/026_invention_assignments_source_export.txt to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-085-02.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/038_licenses_in_source_export.xml.", "id": "investigation.CBP-085-02.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-085-02 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-085-02.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-085-02 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-085-02.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-085-03 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_patents/003_patents_source_export.eml rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-085-03.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_trademarks/015_trademarks_source_export.html for cease-and-desist deadline.", "id": "investigation.CBP-085-03.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/027_invention_assignments_source_export.eml to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-085-03.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/039_licenses_in_source_export.html.", "id": "investigation.CBP-085-03.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-085-03 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective.", "id": "decision.CBP-085-03.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-085-03 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-085-03.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-085-04 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_patents/004_patents_source_export.csv rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-085-04.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_trademarks/016_trademarks_source_export.pdf for foreign-filing restriction.", "id": "investigation.CBP-085-04.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/028_invention_assignments_source_export.csv to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-085-04.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/040_licenses_in_source_export.pdf.", "id": "investigation.CBP-085-04.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-085-04 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-085-04.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-085-04 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-085-04.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-085-05 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_patents/005_patents_source_export.json rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-085-05.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_copyrights/017_copyrights_source_export.md for inbound-license field restriction.", "id": "investigation.CBP-085-05.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/029_invention_assignments_source_export.json to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-085-05.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/041_licenses_out_source_export.md.", "id": "investigation.CBP-085-05.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-085-05 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-085-05.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-085-05 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-085-05.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-085-06 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_patents/006_patents_source_export.xml rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-085-06.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_copyrights/018_copyrights_source_export.txt for repository access anomaly.", "id": "investigation.CBP-085-06.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/030_invention_assignments_source_export.xml to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-085-06.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/042_licenses_out_source_export.txt.", "id": "investigation.CBP-085-06.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-085-06 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is the current observation does not meet the operative trigger.", "id": "decision.CBP-085-06.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-085-06 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-085-06.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-085-07 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_patents/007_patents_source_export.html rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-085-07.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_copyrights/019_copyrights_source_export.eml for maintenance-fee deadline.", "id": "investigation.CBP-085-07.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/031_invention_assignments_source_export.html to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-085-07.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/043_licenses_out_source_export.eml.", "id": "investigation.CBP-085-07.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-085-07 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-085-07.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-085-07 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-085-07.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-085-08 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_patents/008_patents_source_export.pdf rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-085-08.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_copyrights/020_copyrights_source_export.csv for source-code ownership gap.", "id": "investigation.CBP-085-08.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/032_invention_assignments_source_export.pdf to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-085-08.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/044_licenses_out_source_export.csv.", "id": "investigation.CBP-085-08.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-085-08 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-085-08.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-085-08 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-085-08.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-085-09 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_trademarks/009_trademarks_source_export.md rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-085-09.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_copyrights/021_copyrights_source_export.json for domain registrant mismatch.", "id": "investigation.CBP-085-09.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/033_licenses_in_source_export.md to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-085-09.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/045_licenses_out_source_export.json.", "id": "investigation.CBP-085-09.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-085-09 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key.", "id": "decision.CBP-085-09.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-085-09 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-085-09.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-085-10 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_trademarks/010_trademarks_source_export.txt rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-085-10.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_copyrights/022_copyrights_source_export.xml for recorded-owner mismatch.", "id": "investigation.CBP-085-10.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/034_licenses_in_source_export.txt to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-085-10.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/046_licenses_out_source_export.xml.", "id": "investigation.CBP-085-10.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-085-10 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-085-10.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-085-10 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-085-10.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-085-11 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_trademarks/011_trademarks_source_export.eml rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-085-11.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_copyrights/023_copyrights_source_export.html for work-for-hire defect.", "id": "investigation.CBP-085-11.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/035_licenses_in_source_export.eml to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-085-11.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/047_licenses_out_source_export.html.", "id": "investigation.CBP-085-11.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-085-11 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective.", "id": "decision.CBP-085-11.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-085-11 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-085-11.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-085-12 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_trademarks/012_trademarks_source_export.csv rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-085-12.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_copyrights/024_copyrights_source_export.pdf for notice-file omission.", "id": "investigation.CBP-085-12.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/036_licenses_in_source_export.csv to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-085-12.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/048_licenses_out_source_export.pdf.", "id": "investigation.CBP-085-12.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-085-12 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is the operational record relies on a superseded control revision.", "id": "decision.CBP-085-12.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-085-12 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-085-12.register"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Write the exact selected option, supported action population, evidence-hold population, facts, owners, deadlines, and citations.", "id": "state.exact_decision"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create one exact register row per portfolio key with no extra, missing, or modified row.", "id": "state.exact_register"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Leave only the three approved deliverables and perform no extra state-changing write.", "id": "state.write_scope_containment"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Read back decision.json, matter-register.json, and advice.md after their final writes.", "id": "state.postwrite_readback"}, {"category": "answer", "description": "Explain the selected recommendation, supported actions, holds, alternatives, and limitations with exact source anchors.", "id": "answer.decision_note"}], "decision_options": [{"approach": "Apply the exact identity, current-state, authority, and revision test. Create patent-family rows with scoped rights and obligations.", "id": "everglass-medical:scoped-evidence", "label": "Proceed only for supported fields and cure exact milestone, sublicense, or maintenance gaps."}, {"approach": "Use a plausible summary or one source without completing the controlling joins.", "id": "everglass-medical:shortcut", "label": "Treat payment of royalties as curing every scope and diligence condition."}, {"approach": "Treat supported actions and genuinely ambiguous records as if they were equally unresolved.", "id": "everglass-medical:blanket-hold", "label": "Freeze the entire matter population"}], "evaluation_narrative": {"authority": "The effective license and applicable government and maintenance obligations govern each family.", "observation": "Join patent families, milestones, product fields, sublicenses, government rights, and maintenance status.", "question": "Can Everglass rely on the university patent license for the planned product and sublicense?", "register_action": "Create patent-family rows with scoped rights and obligations."}, "gates": ["all_required_evidence_precedes_first_write", "decision_criteria_complete", "register_state_exact", "write_scope_contained", "all_outputs_verified_by_readback"], "metadata_checks": 12, "metric": "weighted_criteria_score", "minimum_tool_calls": 87, "required_deliverables": ["decision.json", "matter-register.json", "advice.md"], "required_document_reads": 63, "type": "deterministic", "weights": {"advice": 0.15, "decision": 0.35, "investigation": 0.25, "state": 0.25}}, "task_id": "cb100-085-everglass-medical", "task_name": "Everglass patent license diligence", "world_id": "counselbench-filesystem-mcp-v3"}
+{"context_files": ["task_files/cb100-086-frostline-security/01_patents/001_patents_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-086-frostline-security/01_patents/002_patents_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-086-frostline-security/01_patents/003_patents_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-086-frostline-security/01_patents/004_patents_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-086-frostline-security/01_patents/005_patents_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-086-frostline-security/01_patents/006_patents_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-086-frostline-security/01_patents/007_patents_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-086-frostline-security/01_patents/008_patents_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-086-frostline-security/02_trademarks/009_trademarks_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-086-frostline-security/02_trademarks/010_trademarks_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-086-frostline-security/02_trademarks/011_trademarks_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-086-frostline-security/02_trademarks/012_trademarks_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-086-frostline-security/02_trademarks/013_trademarks_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-086-frostline-security/02_trademarks/014_trademarks_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-086-frostline-security/02_trademarks/015_trademarks_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-086-frostline-security/02_trademarks/016_trademarks_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-086-frostline-security/03_copyrights/017_copyrights_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-086-frostline-security/03_copyrights/018_copyrights_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-086-frostline-security/03_copyrights/019_copyrights_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-086-frostline-security/03_copyrights/020_copyrights_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-086-frostline-security/03_copyrights/021_copyrights_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-086-frostline-security/03_copyrights/022_copyrights_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-086-frostline-security/03_copyrights/023_copyrights_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-086-frostline-security/03_copyrights/024_copyrights_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-086-frostline-security/04_invention_assignments/025_invention_assignments_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-086-frostline-security/04_invention_assignments/026_invention_assignments_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-086-frostline-security/04_invention_assignments/027_invention_assignments_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-086-frostline-security/04_invention_assignments/028_invention_assignments_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-086-frostline-security/04_invention_assignments/029_invention_assignments_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-086-frostline-security/04_invention_assignments/030_invention_assignments_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-086-frostline-security/04_invention_assignments/031_invention_assignments_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-086-frostline-security/04_invention_assignments/032_invention_assignments_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-086-frostline-security/05_licenses_in/033_licenses_in_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-086-frostline-security/05_licenses_in/034_licenses_in_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-086-frostline-security/05_licenses_in/035_licenses_in_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-086-frostline-security/05_licenses_in/036_licenses_in_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-086-frostline-security/05_licenses_in/037_licenses_in_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-086-frostline-security/05_licenses_in/038_licenses_in_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-086-frostline-security/05_licenses_in/039_licenses_in_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-086-frostline-security/05_licenses_in/040_licenses_in_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-086-frostline-security/06_licenses_out/041_licenses_out_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-086-frostline-security/06_licenses_out/042_licenses_out_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-086-frostline-security/06_licenses_out/043_licenses_out_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-086-frostline-security/06_licenses_out/044_licenses_out_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-086-frostline-security/06_licenses_out/045_licenses_out_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-086-frostline-security/06_licenses_out/046_licenses_out_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-086-frostline-security/06_licenses_out/047_licenses_out_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-086-frostline-security/06_licenses_out/048_licenses_out_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-086-frostline-security/07_open_source/049_open_source_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-086-frostline-security/07_open_source/050_open_source_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-086-frostline-security/07_open_source/051_open_source_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-086-frostline-security/07_open_source/052_open_source_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-086-frostline-security/07_open_source/053_open_source_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-086-frostline-security/07_open_source/054_open_source_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-086-frostline-security/07_open_source/055_open_source_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-086-frostline-security/07_open_source/056_open_source_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-086-frostline-security/08_domain_accounts/057_domain_accounts_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-086-frostline-security/08_domain_accounts/058_domain_accounts_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-086-frostline-security/08_domain_accounts/059_domain_accounts_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-086-frostline-security/08_domain_accounts/060_domain_accounts_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-086-frostline-security/08_domain_accounts/061_domain_accounts_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-086-frostline-security/08_domain_accounts/062_domain_accounts_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-086-frostline-security/08_domain_accounts/063_domain_accounts_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-086-frostline-security/08_domain_accounts/064_domain_accounts_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-086-frostline-security/09_development_records/065_development_records_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-086-frostline-security/09_development_records/066_development_records_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-086-frostline-security/09_development_records/067_development_records_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-086-frostline-security/09_development_records/068_development_records_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-086-frostline-security/09_development_records/069_development_records_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-086-frostline-security/09_development_records/070_development_records_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-086-frostline-security/09_development_records/071_development_records_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-086-frostline-security/09_development_records/072_development_records_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-086-frostline-security/10_disputes/073_disputes_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-086-frostline-security/10_disputes/074_disputes_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-086-frostline-security/10_disputes/075_disputes_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-086-frostline-security/10_disputes/076_disputes_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-086-frostline-security/10_disputes/077_disputes_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-086-frostline-security/10_disputes/078_disputes_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-086-frostline-security/10_disputes/079_disputes_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-086-frostline-security/10_disputes/080_disputes_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-086-frostline-security/11_maintenance/081_maintenance_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-086-frostline-security/11_maintenance/082_maintenance_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-086-frostline-security/11_maintenance/083_maintenance_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-086-frostline-security/11_maintenance/084_maintenance_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-086-frostline-security/11_maintenance/085_maintenance_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-086-frostline-security/11_maintenance/086_maintenance_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-086-frostline-security/11_maintenance/087_maintenance_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-086-frostline-security/11_maintenance/088_maintenance_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-086-frostline-security/12_security_interests/089_security_interests_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-086-frostline-security/12_security_interests/090_security_interests_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-086-frostline-security/12_security_interests/091_security_interests_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-086-frostline-security/12_security_interests/092_security_interests_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-086-frostline-security/12_security_interests/093_security_interests_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-086-frostline-security/12_security_interests/094_security_interests_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-086-frostline-security/12_security_interests/095_security_interests_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-086-frostline-security/12_security_interests/096_security_interests_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-086-frostline-security/12_security_interests/097_frostline_security_impact_population.xlsx"], "gold_output": {"advice_markdown": "# Decision note — Frostline software provenance audit\n\n## Recommendation\n\nCure or replace affected components while allowing clean release units to proceed. The reconciled record supports 5 scoped actions and leaves 7 items on evidence hold.\n\nSelected option: `frostline-security:scoped-evidence`.\n\n## Why this is the supported option\n\nJoin package hashes, dependency paths, contractor modules, outbound terms, and notice files by release. The actual distributed combination and effective licenses determine obligations.\n\n## Supported actions\n\n### CBP-086-04 — trademark specimen issue (medium)\n\nthe permission is limited to District of Massachusetts under CB-IP-3206-R109; the matched activity occurred in Massachusetts under CB-IP-3206-E206. Identity resolves to ENT-086-1003, revision REV-2026.4 is current, and Henry Cho is active with capacity 2.\n\nAction: Create component-release rows with exact obligation and remediation owner. Owner: Henry Cho; due 2026-09-18.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_patents/004_patents_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/02_trademarks/016_trademarks_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/028_invention_assignments_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/040_licenses_in_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/097_frostline_security_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-086-07 — foreign-filing restriction (critical)\n\nan open exception blocks completion under CB-IP-3206-R334; the current status is open and unresolved under CB-IP-3206-E219. Identity resolves to ENT-086-1006, revision REV-2026.7 is current, and Willa Novak is active with capacity 6.\n\nAction: Create component-release rows with exact obligation and remediation owner. Owner: Willa Novak; due 2026-09-15.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_patents/007_patents_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/03_copyrights/019_copyrights_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/031_invention_assignments_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/043_licenses_out_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/09_development_records/067_development_records_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/07_open_source/055_open_source_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/097_frostline_security_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-086-08 — inbound-license field restriction (high)\n\ncompletion is required by 2025-08-14 under CB-IP-3206-R800; the current event record shows completion on 2025-09-17 under CB-IP-3206-E247. Identity resolves to ENT-086-1007, revision REV-2026.1 is current, and Owen Delgado is active with capacity 4.\n\nAction: Create component-release rows with exact obligation and remediation owner. Owner: Owen Delgado; due 2026-09-14.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_patents/008_patents_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/03_copyrights/020_copyrights_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/032_invention_assignments_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/044_licenses_out_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/10_disputes/080_disputes_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/097_frostline_security_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-086-09 — repository access anomaly (critical)\n\nthe controlling threshold is 16% under CB-IP-3206-R537; the independently calculated result is 24% under CB-IP-3206-E390. Identity resolves to ENT-086-1008, revision REV-2026.2 is current, and Priya Raman is active with capacity 3.\n\nAction: Create component-release rows with exact obligation and remediation owner. Owner: Priya Raman; due 2026-09-13.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/02_trademarks/009_trademarks_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/03_copyrights/021_copyrights_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/033_licenses_in_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/045_licenses_out_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/097_frostline_security_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-086-11 — source-code ownership gap (medium)\n\nthe controlled population contains 210 records under CB-IP-3206-R538; the certification covers 200 records under CB-IP-3206-E708. Identity resolves to ENT-086-1010, revision REV-2026.4 is current, and Nadine Flores is active with capacity 4.\n\nAction: Create component-release rows with exact obligation and remediation owner. Owner: Nadine Flores; due 2026-09-20.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/02_trademarks/011_trademarks_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/03_copyrights/023_copyrights_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/035_licenses_in_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/047_licenses_out_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/097_frostline_security_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n## Evidence holds\n\n- **CBP-086-01 — coexistence restriction**: the current observation does not meet the operative trigger. Next evidence: a current observation that satisfies the operative trigger. Sources: `/workspace/documents/01_patents/001_patents_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/02_trademarks/013_trademarks_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/025_invention_assignments_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/037_licenses_in_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/097_frostline_security_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-086-02 — copyleft distribution trigger**: the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective. Next evidence: effective approval and an active owner with remaining capacity. Sources: `/workspace/documents/01_patents/002_patents_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/02_trademarks/014_trademarks_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/026_invention_assignments_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/038_licenses_in_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/10_disputes/074_disputes_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/097_frostline_security_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-086-03 — security-interest release gap**: the operational record relies on a superseded control revision. Next evidence: an operational record using the current effective revision. Sources: `/workspace/documents/01_patents/003_patents_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/02_trademarks/015_trademarks_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/027_invention_assignments_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/039_licenses_in_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/11_maintenance/087_maintenance_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/097_frostline_security_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-086-05 — outbound sublicense overreach**: the current observation does not meet the operative trigger. Next evidence: a current observation that satisfies the operative trigger. Sources: `/workspace/documents/01_patents/005_patents_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/03_copyrights/017_copyrights_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/029_invention_assignments_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/041_licenses_out_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/097_frostline_security_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-086-06 — cease-and-desist deadline**: the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective. Next evidence: effective approval and an active owner with remaining capacity. Sources: `/workspace/documents/01_patents/006_patents_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/03_copyrights/018_copyrights_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/030_invention_assignments_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/042_licenses_out_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/10_disputes/078_disputes_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/097_frostline_security_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-086-10 — maintenance-fee deadline**: the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective. Next evidence: effective approval and an active owner with remaining capacity. Sources: `/workspace/documents/02_trademarks/010_trademarks_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/03_copyrights/022_copyrights_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/034_licenses_in_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/046_licenses_out_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/11_maintenance/082_maintenance_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/097_frostline_security_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-086-12 — domain registrant mismatch**: two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key. Next evidence: an approved immutable entity crosswalk. Sources: `/workspace/documents/02_trademarks/012_trademarks_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/03_copyrights/024_copyrights_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/036_licenses_in_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/048_licenses_out_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/08_domain_accounts/060_domain_accounts_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/11_maintenance/084_maintenance_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/097_frostline_security_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n## Alternatives considered\n\n- `frostline-security:shortcut` — Block the entire product because any open-source package appears in the inventory.: Use a plausible summary or one source without completing the controlling joins.\n- `frostline-security:blanket-hold` — Freeze the entire matter population: Treat supported actions and genuinely ambiguous records as if they were equally unresolved.\n\n## Assumptions and limits\n\nThis decision is limited to cb100-086-frostline-security, the supplied synthetic records, and the matter state as of 2026-09-22. Similar names, stale revisions, and pending authority are not treated as proof.\n", "decision": {"actions": [{"determination": "the permission is limited to District of Massachusetts under CB-IP-3206-R109; the matched activity occurred in Massachusetts under CB-IP-3206-E206. Identity resolves to ENT-086-1003, revision REV-2026.4 is current, and Henry Cho is active with capacity 2.", "due_date": "2026-09-18", "id": "ACT-CBP-086-04", "identity_id": "ENT-086-1003", "issue": "trademark specimen issue", "owner": "Henry Cho", "portfolio_key": "CBP-086-04", "recommended_action": "Create component-release rows with exact obligation and remediation owner. Owner: Henry Cho; due 2026-09-18.", "severity": "medium", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_patents/004_patents_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/02_trademarks/016_trademarks_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/028_invention_assignments_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/040_licenses_in_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/097_frostline_security_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "an open exception blocks completion under CB-IP-3206-R334; the current status is open and unresolved under CB-IP-3206-E219. Identity resolves to ENT-086-1006, revision REV-2026.7 is current, and Willa Novak is active with capacity 6.", "due_date": "2026-09-15", "id": "ACT-CBP-086-07", "identity_id": "ENT-086-1006", "issue": "foreign-filing restriction", "owner": "Willa Novak", "portfolio_key": "CBP-086-07", "recommended_action": "Create component-release rows with exact obligation and remediation owner. Owner: Willa Novak; due 2026-09-15.", "severity": "critical", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_patents/007_patents_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/03_copyrights/019_copyrights_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/031_invention_assignments_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/043_licenses_out_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/09_development_records/067_development_records_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/07_open_source/055_open_source_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/097_frostline_security_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "completion is required by 2025-08-14 under CB-IP-3206-R800; the current event record shows completion on 2025-09-17 under CB-IP-3206-E247. Identity resolves to ENT-086-1007, revision REV-2026.1 is current, and Owen Delgado is active with capacity 4.", "due_date": "2026-09-14", "id": "ACT-CBP-086-08", "identity_id": "ENT-086-1007", "issue": "inbound-license field restriction", "owner": "Owen Delgado", "portfolio_key": "CBP-086-08", "recommended_action": "Create component-release rows with exact obligation and remediation owner. Owner: Owen Delgado; due 2026-09-14.", "severity": "high", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_patents/008_patents_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/03_copyrights/020_copyrights_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/032_invention_assignments_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/044_licenses_out_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/10_disputes/080_disputes_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/097_frostline_security_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "the controlling threshold is 16% under CB-IP-3206-R537; the independently calculated result is 24% under CB-IP-3206-E390. Identity resolves to ENT-086-1008, revision REV-2026.2 is current, and Priya Raman is active with capacity 3.", "due_date": "2026-09-13", "id": "ACT-CBP-086-09", "identity_id": "ENT-086-1008", "issue": "repository access anomaly", "owner": "Priya Raman", "portfolio_key": "CBP-086-09", "recommended_action": "Create component-release rows with exact obligation and remediation owner. Owner: Priya Raman; due 2026-09-13.", "severity": "critical", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_trademarks/009_trademarks_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/03_copyrights/021_copyrights_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/033_licenses_in_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/045_licenses_out_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/097_frostline_security_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "the controlled population contains 210 records under CB-IP-3206-R538; the certification covers 200 records under CB-IP-3206-E708. Identity resolves to ENT-086-1010, revision REV-2026.4 is current, and Nadine Flores is active with capacity 4.", "due_date": "2026-09-20", "id": "ACT-CBP-086-11", "identity_id": "ENT-086-1010", "issue": "source-code ownership gap", "owner": "Nadine Flores", "portfolio_key": "CBP-086-11", "recommended_action": "Create component-release rows with exact obligation and remediation owner. Owner: Nadine Flores; due 2026-09-20.", "severity": "medium", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_trademarks/011_trademarks_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/03_copyrights/023_copyrights_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/035_licenses_in_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/047_licenses_out_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/097_frostline_security_impact_population.xlsx"]}], "as_of": "2026-09-22", "decision": {"alternatives_considered": ["frostline-security:shortcut", "frostline-security:blanket-hold"], "question": "Which Frostline components block release because of provenance, copyleft, or notice defects?", "rationale": "The four-part causal test supports 5 scoped actions and leaves 7 records on evidence hold. The actual distributed combination and effective licenses determine obligations.", "recommendation": "Cure or replace affected components while allowing clean release units to proceed.", "selected_option_id": "frostline-security:scoped-evidence"}, "holds": [{"id": "HOLD-CBP-086-01", "issue": "coexistence restriction", "portfolio_key": "CBP-086-01", "reason": "the current observation does not meet the operative trigger", "required_next_evidence": "a current observation that satisfies the operative trigger", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_patents/001_patents_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/02_trademarks/013_trademarks_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/025_invention_assignments_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/037_licenses_in_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/097_frostline_security_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-086-02", "issue": "copyleft distribution trigger", "portfolio_key": "CBP-086-02", "reason": "the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective", "required_next_evidence": "effective approval and an active owner with remaining capacity", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_patents/002_patents_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/02_trademarks/014_trademarks_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/026_invention_assignments_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/038_licenses_in_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/10_disputes/074_disputes_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/097_frostline_security_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-086-03", "issue": "security-interest release gap", "portfolio_key": "CBP-086-03", "reason": "the operational record relies on a superseded control revision", "required_next_evidence": "an operational record using the current effective revision", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_patents/003_patents_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/02_trademarks/015_trademarks_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/027_invention_assignments_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/039_licenses_in_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/11_maintenance/087_maintenance_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/097_frostline_security_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-086-05", "issue": "outbound sublicense overreach", "portfolio_key": "CBP-086-05", "reason": "the current observation does not meet the operative trigger", "required_next_evidence": "a current observation that satisfies the operative trigger", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_patents/005_patents_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/03_copyrights/017_copyrights_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/029_invention_assignments_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/041_licenses_out_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/097_frostline_security_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-086-06", "issue": "cease-and-desist deadline", "portfolio_key": "CBP-086-06", "reason": "the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective", "required_next_evidence": "effective approval and an active owner with remaining capacity", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_patents/006_patents_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/03_copyrights/018_copyrights_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/030_invention_assignments_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/042_licenses_out_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/10_disputes/078_disputes_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/097_frostline_security_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-086-10", "issue": "maintenance-fee deadline", "portfolio_key": "CBP-086-10", "reason": "the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective", "required_next_evidence": "effective approval and an active owner with remaining capacity", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_trademarks/010_trademarks_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/03_copyrights/022_copyrights_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/034_licenses_in_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/046_licenses_out_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/11_maintenance/082_maintenance_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/097_frostline_security_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-086-12", "issue": "domain registrant mismatch", "portfolio_key": "CBP-086-12", "reason": "two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key", "required_next_evidence": "an approved immutable entity crosswalk", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_trademarks/012_trademarks_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/03_copyrights/024_copyrights_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/036_licenses_in_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/048_licenses_out_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/08_domain_accounts/060_domain_accounts_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/11_maintenance/084_maintenance_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/097_frostline_security_impact_population.xlsx"]}], "matter_number": "CB-IP-3206", "prepared_for": "Frostline Security Software", "schema_version": "counselbench.decision.v3", "task_id": "cb100-086-frostline-security"}, "matter_register": {"matter_number": "CB-IP-3206", "rows": [{"decision_option_id": "frostline-security:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "the current observation does not meet the operative trigger", "issue": "coexistence restriction", "matter_number": "CB-IP-3206", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-086-01", "row_id": "REG-CBP-086-01", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_patents/001_patents_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/02_trademarks/013_trademarks_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/025_invention_assignments_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/037_licenses_in_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/097_frostline_security_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "frostline-security:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective", "issue": "copyleft distribution trigger", "matter_number": "CB-IP-3206", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-086-02", "row_id": "REG-CBP-086-02", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_patents/002_patents_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/02_trademarks/014_trademarks_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/026_invention_assignments_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/038_licenses_in_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/10_disputes/074_disputes_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/097_frostline_security_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "frostline-security:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "the operational record relies on a superseded control revision", "issue": "security-interest release gap", "matter_number": "CB-IP-3206", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-086-03", "row_id": "REG-CBP-086-03", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_patents/003_patents_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/02_trademarks/015_trademarks_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/027_invention_assignments_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/039_licenses_in_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/11_maintenance/087_maintenance_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/097_frostline_security_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "frostline-security:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-18", "issue": "trademark specimen issue", "matter_number": "CB-IP-3206", "owner": "Henry Cho", "portfolio_key": "CBP-086-04", "row_id": "REG-CBP-086-04", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_patents/004_patents_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/02_trademarks/016_trademarks_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/028_invention_assignments_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/040_licenses_in_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/097_frostline_security_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "frostline-security:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "the current observation does not meet the operative trigger", "issue": "outbound sublicense overreach", "matter_number": "CB-IP-3206", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-086-05", "row_id": "REG-CBP-086-05", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_patents/005_patents_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/03_copyrights/017_copyrights_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/029_invention_assignments_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/041_licenses_out_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/097_frostline_security_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "frostline-security:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective", "issue": "cease-and-desist deadline", "matter_number": "CB-IP-3206", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-086-06", "row_id": "REG-CBP-086-06", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_patents/006_patents_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/03_copyrights/018_copyrights_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/030_invention_assignments_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/042_licenses_out_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/10_disputes/078_disputes_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/097_frostline_security_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "frostline-security:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-15", "issue": "foreign-filing restriction", "matter_number": "CB-IP-3206", "owner": "Willa Novak", "portfolio_key": "CBP-086-07", "row_id": "REG-CBP-086-07", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_patents/007_patents_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/03_copyrights/019_copyrights_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/031_invention_assignments_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/043_licenses_out_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/09_development_records/067_development_records_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/07_open_source/055_open_source_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/097_frostline_security_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "frostline-security:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-14", "issue": "inbound-license field restriction", "matter_number": "CB-IP-3206", "owner": "Owen Delgado", "portfolio_key": "CBP-086-08", "row_id": "REG-CBP-086-08", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_patents/008_patents_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/03_copyrights/020_copyrights_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/032_invention_assignments_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/044_licenses_out_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/10_disputes/080_disputes_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/097_frostline_security_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "frostline-security:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-13", "issue": "repository access anomaly", "matter_number": "CB-IP-3206", "owner": "Priya Raman", "portfolio_key": "CBP-086-09", "row_id": "REG-CBP-086-09", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_trademarks/009_trademarks_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/03_copyrights/021_copyrights_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/033_licenses_in_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/045_licenses_out_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/097_frostline_security_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "frostline-security:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective", "issue": "maintenance-fee deadline", "matter_number": "CB-IP-3206", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-086-10", "row_id": "REG-CBP-086-10", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_trademarks/010_trademarks_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/03_copyrights/022_copyrights_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/034_licenses_in_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/046_licenses_out_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/11_maintenance/082_maintenance_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/097_frostline_security_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "frostline-security:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-20", "issue": "source-code ownership gap", "matter_number": "CB-IP-3206", "owner": "Nadine Flores", "portfolio_key": "CBP-086-11", "row_id": "REG-CBP-086-11", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_trademarks/011_trademarks_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/03_copyrights/023_copyrights_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/035_licenses_in_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/047_licenses_out_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/097_frostline_security_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "frostline-security:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key", "issue": "domain registrant mismatch", "matter_number": "CB-IP-3206", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-086-12", "row_id": "REG-CBP-086-12", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_trademarks/012_trademarks_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/03_copyrights/024_copyrights_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/036_licenses_in_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/048_licenses_out_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/08_domain_accounts/060_domain_accounts_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/11_maintenance/084_maintenance_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/097_frostline_security_impact_population.xlsx"]}], "schema_version": "counselbench.matter-register.v3", "task_id": "cb100-086-frostline-security"}}, "metadata": {"benchmark": "CounselBench-100", "code_license": "Apache-2.0", "data_license": "CC-BY-4.0", "deadline": "2026-09-22", "document_count": 97, "evidence_holds": 7, "jurisdiction": "Massachusetts", "matter_number": "CB-IP-3206", "mcp_commit": "9a96ea6e5913736f92b88345bf51caeaaa8e719f", "mcp_package": "@modelcontextprotocol/server-filesystem@2026.7.10", "practice_area": "ip-technology", "reference_tool_calls": 78, "required_evidence_reads": 59, "supported_actions": 5, "synthetic": true, "venue": "District of Massachusetts", "version": "3.1.0"}, "prompt": "I am about to brief the decision makers and need the source record reconciled first. Which Frostline components block release because of provenance, copyleft, or notice defects? A security appliance contains open-source packages, contractor modules, outbound licenses, and incomplete notice files. The team needs the call by 2026-09-22. Record the outcome the source hierarchy supports and explain the alternatives we should not take.", "rubric": {"criteria": [{"category": "investigation", "description": "Inventory the production and use targeted searches to locate records across native formats.", "id": "investigation.discover_production"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Complete every task-specific identity, authority, operations, and approval read before the first state transition.", "id": "investigation.read_before_write"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Inspect designated source metadata before relying on those records.", "id": "investigation.custody_before_write"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "Select the supported option 'frostline-security:scoped-evidence' after applying the four-part test.", "id": "decision.selected_option"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "Identify both rejected approaches and explain why a one-source shortcut and a blanket hold are wrong.", "id": "decision.alternatives"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-086-01 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_patents/001_patents_source_export.md rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-086-01.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_trademarks/013_trademarks_source_export.json for coexistence restriction.", "id": "investigation.CBP-086-01.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/025_invention_assignments_source_export.md to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-086-01.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/037_licenses_in_source_export.json.", "id": "investigation.CBP-086-01.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-086-01 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is the current observation does not meet the operative trigger.", "id": "decision.CBP-086-01.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-086-01 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-086-01.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-086-02 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_patents/002_patents_source_export.txt rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-086-02.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_trademarks/014_trademarks_source_export.xml for copyleft distribution trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-086-02.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/026_invention_assignments_source_export.txt to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-086-02.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/038_licenses_in_source_export.xml.", "id": "investigation.CBP-086-02.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-086-02 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective.", "id": "decision.CBP-086-02.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-086-02 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-086-02.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-086-03 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_patents/003_patents_source_export.eml rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-086-03.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_trademarks/015_trademarks_source_export.html for security-interest release gap.", "id": "investigation.CBP-086-03.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/027_invention_assignments_source_export.eml to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-086-03.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/039_licenses_in_source_export.html.", "id": "investigation.CBP-086-03.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-086-03 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is the operational record relies on a superseded control revision.", "id": "decision.CBP-086-03.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-086-03 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-086-03.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-086-04 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_patents/004_patents_source_export.csv rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-086-04.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_trademarks/016_trademarks_source_export.pdf for trademark specimen issue.", "id": "investigation.CBP-086-04.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/028_invention_assignments_source_export.csv to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-086-04.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/040_licenses_in_source_export.pdf.", "id": "investigation.CBP-086-04.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-086-04 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-086-04.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-086-04 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-086-04.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-086-05 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_patents/005_patents_source_export.json rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-086-05.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_copyrights/017_copyrights_source_export.md for outbound sublicense overreach.", "id": "investigation.CBP-086-05.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/029_invention_assignments_source_export.json to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-086-05.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/041_licenses_out_source_export.md.", "id": "investigation.CBP-086-05.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-086-05 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is the current observation does not meet the operative trigger.", "id": "decision.CBP-086-05.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-086-05 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-086-05.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-086-06 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_patents/006_patents_source_export.xml rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-086-06.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_copyrights/018_copyrights_source_export.txt for cease-and-desist deadline.", "id": "investigation.CBP-086-06.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/030_invention_assignments_source_export.xml to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-086-06.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/042_licenses_out_source_export.txt.", "id": "investigation.CBP-086-06.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-086-06 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective.", "id": "decision.CBP-086-06.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-086-06 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-086-06.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-086-07 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_patents/007_patents_source_export.html rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-086-07.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_copyrights/019_copyrights_source_export.eml for foreign-filing restriction.", "id": "investigation.CBP-086-07.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/031_invention_assignments_source_export.html to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-086-07.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/043_licenses_out_source_export.eml.", "id": "investigation.CBP-086-07.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-086-07 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-086-07.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-086-07 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-086-07.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-086-08 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_patents/008_patents_source_export.pdf rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-086-08.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_copyrights/020_copyrights_source_export.csv for inbound-license field restriction.", "id": "investigation.CBP-086-08.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/032_invention_assignments_source_export.pdf to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-086-08.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/044_licenses_out_source_export.csv.", "id": "investigation.CBP-086-08.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-086-08 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-086-08.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-086-08 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-086-08.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-086-09 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_trademarks/009_trademarks_source_export.md rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-086-09.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_copyrights/021_copyrights_source_export.json for repository access anomaly.", "id": "investigation.CBP-086-09.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/033_licenses_in_source_export.md to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-086-09.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/045_licenses_out_source_export.json.", "id": "investigation.CBP-086-09.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-086-09 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-086-09.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-086-09 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-086-09.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-086-10 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_trademarks/010_trademarks_source_export.txt rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-086-10.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_copyrights/022_copyrights_source_export.xml for maintenance-fee deadline.", "id": "investigation.CBP-086-10.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/034_licenses_in_source_export.txt to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-086-10.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/046_licenses_out_source_export.xml.", "id": "investigation.CBP-086-10.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-086-10 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective.", "id": "decision.CBP-086-10.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-086-10 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-086-10.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-086-11 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_trademarks/011_trademarks_source_export.eml rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-086-11.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_copyrights/023_copyrights_source_export.html for source-code ownership gap.", "id": "investigation.CBP-086-11.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/035_licenses_in_source_export.eml to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-086-11.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/047_licenses_out_source_export.html.", "id": "investigation.CBP-086-11.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-086-11 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-086-11.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-086-11 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-086-11.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-086-12 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_trademarks/012_trademarks_source_export.csv rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-086-12.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_copyrights/024_copyrights_source_export.pdf for domain registrant mismatch.", "id": "investigation.CBP-086-12.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/036_licenses_in_source_export.csv to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-086-12.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/048_licenses_out_source_export.pdf.", "id": "investigation.CBP-086-12.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-086-12 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key.", "id": "decision.CBP-086-12.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-086-12 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-086-12.register"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Write the exact selected option, supported action population, evidence-hold population, facts, owners, deadlines, and citations.", "id": "state.exact_decision"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create one exact register row per portfolio key with no extra, missing, or modified row.", "id": "state.exact_register"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Leave only the three approved deliverables and perform no extra state-changing write.", "id": "state.write_scope_containment"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Read back decision.json, matter-register.json, and advice.md after their final writes.", "id": "state.postwrite_readback"}, {"category": "answer", "description": "Explain the selected recommendation, supported actions, holds, alternatives, and limitations with exact source anchors.", "id": "answer.decision_note"}], "decision_options": [{"approach": "Use a plausible summary or one source without completing the controlling joins.", "id": "frostline-security:shortcut", "label": "Block the entire product because any open-source package appears in the inventory."}, {"approach": "Treat supported actions and genuinely ambiguous records as if they were equally unresolved.", "id": "frostline-security:blanket-hold", "label": "Freeze the entire matter population"}, {"approach": "Apply the exact identity, current-state, authority, and revision test. Create component-release rows with exact obligation and remediation owner.", "id": "frostline-security:scoped-evidence", "label": "Cure or replace affected components while allowing clean release units to proceed."}], "evaluation_narrative": {"authority": "The actual distributed combination and effective licenses determine obligations.", "observation": "Join package hashes, dependency paths, contractor modules, outbound terms, and notice files by release.", "question": "Which Frostline components block release because of provenance, copyleft, or notice defects?", "register_action": "Create component-release rows with exact obligation and remediation owner."}, "gates": ["all_required_evidence_precedes_first_write", "decision_criteria_complete", "register_state_exact", "write_scope_contained", "all_outputs_verified_by_readback"], "metadata_checks": 5, "metric": "weighted_criteria_score", "minimum_tool_calls": 78, "required_deliverables": ["decision.json", "matter-register.json", "advice.md"], "required_document_reads": 59, "type": "deterministic", "weights": {"advice": 0.15, "decision": 0.35, "investigation": 0.25, "state": 0.25}}, "task_id": "cb100-086-frostline-security", "task_name": "Frostline software provenance audit", "world_id": "counselbench-filesystem-mcp-v3"}
+{"context_files": ["task_files/cb100-087-goldfinch-media/01_patents/001_patents_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-087-goldfinch-media/01_patents/002_patents_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-087-goldfinch-media/01_patents/003_patents_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-087-goldfinch-media/01_patents/004_patents_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-087-goldfinch-media/01_patents/005_patents_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-087-goldfinch-media/01_patents/006_patents_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-087-goldfinch-media/01_patents/007_patents_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-087-goldfinch-media/01_patents/008_patents_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-087-goldfinch-media/02_trademarks/009_trademarks_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-087-goldfinch-media/02_trademarks/010_trademarks_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-087-goldfinch-media/02_trademarks/011_trademarks_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-087-goldfinch-media/02_trademarks/012_trademarks_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-087-goldfinch-media/02_trademarks/013_trademarks_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-087-goldfinch-media/02_trademarks/014_trademarks_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-087-goldfinch-media/02_trademarks/015_trademarks_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-087-goldfinch-media/02_trademarks/016_trademarks_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-087-goldfinch-media/03_copyrights/017_copyrights_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-087-goldfinch-media/03_copyrights/018_copyrights_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-087-goldfinch-media/03_copyrights/019_copyrights_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-087-goldfinch-media/03_copyrights/020_copyrights_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-087-goldfinch-media/03_copyrights/021_copyrights_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-087-goldfinch-media/03_copyrights/022_copyrights_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-087-goldfinch-media/03_copyrights/023_copyrights_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-087-goldfinch-media/03_copyrights/024_copyrights_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-087-goldfinch-media/04_invention_assignments/025_invention_assignments_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-087-goldfinch-media/04_invention_assignments/026_invention_assignments_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-087-goldfinch-media/04_invention_assignments/027_invention_assignments_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-087-goldfinch-media/04_invention_assignments/028_invention_assignments_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-087-goldfinch-media/04_invention_assignments/029_invention_assignments_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-087-goldfinch-media/04_invention_assignments/030_invention_assignments_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-087-goldfinch-media/04_invention_assignments/031_invention_assignments_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-087-goldfinch-media/04_invention_assignments/032_invention_assignments_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-087-goldfinch-media/05_licenses_in/033_licenses_in_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-087-goldfinch-media/05_licenses_in/034_licenses_in_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-087-goldfinch-media/05_licenses_in/035_licenses_in_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-087-goldfinch-media/05_licenses_in/036_licenses_in_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-087-goldfinch-media/05_licenses_in/037_licenses_in_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-087-goldfinch-media/05_licenses_in/038_licenses_in_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-087-goldfinch-media/05_licenses_in/039_licenses_in_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-087-goldfinch-media/05_licenses_in/040_licenses_in_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-087-goldfinch-media/06_licenses_out/041_licenses_out_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-087-goldfinch-media/06_licenses_out/042_licenses_out_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-087-goldfinch-media/06_licenses_out/043_licenses_out_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-087-goldfinch-media/06_licenses_out/044_licenses_out_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-087-goldfinch-media/06_licenses_out/045_licenses_out_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-087-goldfinch-media/06_licenses_out/046_licenses_out_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-087-goldfinch-media/06_licenses_out/047_licenses_out_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-087-goldfinch-media/06_licenses_out/048_licenses_out_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-087-goldfinch-media/07_open_source/049_open_source_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-087-goldfinch-media/07_open_source/050_open_source_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-087-goldfinch-media/07_open_source/051_open_source_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-087-goldfinch-media/07_open_source/052_open_source_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-087-goldfinch-media/07_open_source/053_open_source_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-087-goldfinch-media/07_open_source/054_open_source_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-087-goldfinch-media/07_open_source/055_open_source_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-087-goldfinch-media/07_open_source/056_open_source_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-087-goldfinch-media/08_domain_accounts/057_domain_accounts_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-087-goldfinch-media/08_domain_accounts/058_domain_accounts_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-087-goldfinch-media/08_domain_accounts/059_domain_accounts_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-087-goldfinch-media/08_domain_accounts/060_domain_accounts_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-087-goldfinch-media/08_domain_accounts/061_domain_accounts_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-087-goldfinch-media/08_domain_accounts/062_domain_accounts_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-087-goldfinch-media/08_domain_accounts/063_domain_accounts_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-087-goldfinch-media/08_domain_accounts/064_domain_accounts_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-087-goldfinch-media/09_development_records/065_development_records_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-087-goldfinch-media/09_development_records/066_development_records_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-087-goldfinch-media/09_development_records/067_development_records_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-087-goldfinch-media/09_development_records/068_development_records_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-087-goldfinch-media/09_development_records/069_development_records_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-087-goldfinch-media/09_development_records/070_development_records_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-087-goldfinch-media/09_development_records/071_development_records_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-087-goldfinch-media/09_development_records/072_development_records_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-087-goldfinch-media/10_disputes/073_disputes_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-087-goldfinch-media/10_disputes/074_disputes_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-087-goldfinch-media/10_disputes/075_disputes_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-087-goldfinch-media/10_disputes/076_disputes_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-087-goldfinch-media/10_disputes/077_disputes_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-087-goldfinch-media/10_disputes/078_disputes_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-087-goldfinch-media/10_disputes/079_disputes_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-087-goldfinch-media/10_disputes/080_disputes_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-087-goldfinch-media/11_maintenance/081_maintenance_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-087-goldfinch-media/11_maintenance/082_maintenance_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-087-goldfinch-media/11_maintenance/083_maintenance_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-087-goldfinch-media/11_maintenance/084_maintenance_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-087-goldfinch-media/11_maintenance/085_maintenance_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-087-goldfinch-media/11_maintenance/086_maintenance_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-087-goldfinch-media/11_maintenance/087_maintenance_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-087-goldfinch-media/11_maintenance/088_maintenance_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-087-goldfinch-media/12_security_interests/089_security_interests_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-087-goldfinch-media/12_security_interests/090_security_interests_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-087-goldfinch-media/12_security_interests/091_security_interests_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-087-goldfinch-media/12_security_interests/092_security_interests_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-087-goldfinch-media/12_security_interests/093_security_interests_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-087-goldfinch-media/12_security_interests/094_security_interests_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-087-goldfinch-media/12_security_interests/095_security_interests_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-087-goldfinch-media/12_security_interests/096_security_interests_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-087-goldfinch-media/12_security_interests/097_goldfinch_media_impact_population.xlsx"], "gold_output": {"advice_markdown": "# Decision note — Goldfinch content platform IP review\n\n## Recommendation\n\nCure supported ownership or control gaps without disturbing clean creator rights. The reconciled record supports 5 scoped actions and leaves 7 items on evidence hold.\n\nSelected option: `goldfinch-media:scoped-evidence`.\n\n## Why this is the supported option\n\nMatch creators, agreements, deliverables, moderation tools, registrants, and filings by asset. Executed grants and valid registrations or account control govern each asset separately.\n\n## Supported actions\n\n### CBP-087-01 — work-for-hire defect (medium)\n\ndelivery must use notices-goldfinch_media_network@example.test under CB-IP-3207-R678; the only matched receipt used archive-independent_creator_collective@example.test under CB-IP-3207-E345. Identity resolves to ENT-087-1000, revision REV-2025.1 is current, and Samuel Kim is active with capacity 6.\n\nAction: Create asset-specific title and control rows with identity holds. Owner: Samuel Kim; due 2026-09-24.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_patents/001_patents_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/02_trademarks/013_trademarks_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/025_invention_assignments_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/037_licenses_in_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/08_domain_accounts/061_domain_accounts_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/097_goldfinch_media_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-087-02 — notice-file omission (medium)\n\nan open exception blocks completion under CB-IP-3207-R289; the current status is open and unresolved under CB-IP-3207-E640. Identity resolves to ENT-087-1001, revision REV-2025.2 is current, and Talia Brooks is active with capacity 2.\n\nAction: Create asset-specific title and control rows with identity holds. Owner: Talia Brooks; due 2026-09-23.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_patents/002_patents_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/02_trademarks/014_trademarks_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/026_invention_assignments_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/038_licenses_in_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/08_domain_accounts/062_domain_accounts_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/097_goldfinch_media_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-087-07 — trademark specimen issue (critical)\n\nthe permission is limited to Southern District of New York under CB-IP-3207-R452; the matched activity occurred in New York under CB-IP-3207-E226. Identity resolves to ENT-087-1006, revision REV-2025.7 is current, and Henry Cho is active with capacity 1.\n\nAction: Create asset-specific title and control rows with identity holds. Owner: Henry Cho; due 2026-09-18.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_patents/007_patents_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/03_copyrights/019_copyrights_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/031_invention_assignments_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/043_licenses_out_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/097_goldfinch_media_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-087-08 — outbound sublicense overreach (medium)\n\nthe operative cap is $4,042,000.00 under CB-IP-3207-R876; the matched ledger population totals $4,286,176.00 under CB-IP-3207-E728. Identity resolves to ENT-087-1007, revision REV-2025.1 is current, and Maya Ellison is active with capacity 6.\n\nAction: Create asset-specific title and control rows with identity holds. Owner: Maya Ellison; due 2026-09-17.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_patents/008_patents_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/03_copyrights/020_copyrights_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/032_invention_assignments_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/044_licenses_out_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/092_security_interests_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/097_goldfinch_media_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-087-09 — cease-and-desist deadline (medium)\n\ndelivery must use notices-goldfinch_media_network@example.test under CB-IP-3207-R224; the only matched receipt used archive-independent_creator_collective@example.test under CB-IP-3207-E107. Identity resolves to ENT-087-1008, revision REV-2025.2 is current, and Jonas Feld is active with capacity 6.\n\nAction: Create asset-specific title and control rows with identity holds. Owner: Jonas Feld; due 2026-09-16.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/02_trademarks/009_trademarks_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/03_copyrights/021_copyrights_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/033_licenses_in_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/045_licenses_out_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/11_maintenance/081_maintenance_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/093_security_interests_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/097_goldfinch_media_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n## Evidence holds\n\n- **CBP-087-03 — inventor assignment gap**: two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key. Next evidence: an approved immutable entity crosswalk. Sources: `/workspace/documents/01_patents/003_patents_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/02_trademarks/015_trademarks_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/027_invention_assignments_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/039_licenses_in_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/11_maintenance/087_maintenance_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/10_disputes/075_disputes_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/097_goldfinch_media_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-087-04 — coexistence restriction**: the current observation does not meet the operative trigger. Next evidence: a current observation that satisfies the operative trigger. Sources: `/workspace/documents/01_patents/004_patents_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/02_trademarks/016_trademarks_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/028_invention_assignments_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/040_licenses_in_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/08_domain_accounts/064_domain_accounts_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/11_maintenance/088_maintenance_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/097_goldfinch_media_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-087-05 — copyleft distribution trigger**: the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective. Next evidence: effective approval and an active owner with remaining capacity. Sources: `/workspace/documents/01_patents/005_patents_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/03_copyrights/017_copyrights_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/029_invention_assignments_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/041_licenses_out_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/10_disputes/077_disputes_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/097_goldfinch_media_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-087-06 — security-interest release gap**: the operational record relies on a superseded control revision. Next evidence: an operational record using the current effective revision. Sources: `/workspace/documents/01_patents/006_patents_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/03_copyrights/018_copyrights_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/030_invention_assignments_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/042_licenses_out_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/090_security_interests_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/09_development_records/066_development_records_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/097_goldfinch_media_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-087-10 — foreign-filing restriction**: the operational record relies on a superseded control revision. Next evidence: an operational record using the current effective revision. Sources: `/workspace/documents/02_trademarks/010_trademarks_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/03_copyrights/022_copyrights_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/034_licenses_in_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/046_licenses_out_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/09_development_records/070_development_records_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/097_goldfinch_media_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-087-11 — inbound-license field restriction**: two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key. Next evidence: an approved immutable entity crosswalk. Sources: `/workspace/documents/02_trademarks/011_trademarks_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/03_copyrights/023_copyrights_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/035_licenses_in_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/047_licenses_out_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/097_goldfinch_media_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-087-12 — repository access anomaly**: the current observation does not meet the operative trigger. Next evidence: a current observation that satisfies the operative trigger. Sources: `/workspace/documents/02_trademarks/012_trademarks_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/03_copyrights/024_copyrights_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/036_licenses_in_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/048_licenses_out_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/097_goldfinch_media_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n## Alternatives considered\n\n- `goldfinch-media:blanket-hold` — Freeze the entire matter population: Treat supported actions and genuinely ambiguous records as if they were equally unresolved.\n- `goldfinch-media:shortcut` — Treat platform upload terms as complete ownership of every work.: Use a plausible summary or one source without completing the controlling joins.\n\n## Assumptions and limits\n\nThis decision is limited to cb100-087-goldfinch-media, the supplied synthetic records, and the matter state as of 2026-09-25. Similar names, stale revisions, and pending authority are not treated as proof.\n", "decision": {"actions": [{"determination": "delivery must use notices-goldfinch_media_network@example.test under CB-IP-3207-R678; the only matched receipt used archive-independent_creator_collective@example.test under CB-IP-3207-E345. Identity resolves to ENT-087-1000, revision REV-2025.1 is current, and Samuel Kim is active with capacity 6.", "due_date": "2026-09-24", "id": "ACT-CBP-087-01", "identity_id": "ENT-087-1000", "issue": "work-for-hire defect", "owner": "Samuel Kim", "portfolio_key": "CBP-087-01", "recommended_action": "Create asset-specific title and control rows with identity holds. Owner: Samuel Kim; due 2026-09-24.", "severity": "medium", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_patents/001_patents_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/02_trademarks/013_trademarks_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/025_invention_assignments_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/037_licenses_in_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/08_domain_accounts/061_domain_accounts_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/097_goldfinch_media_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "an open exception blocks completion under CB-IP-3207-R289; the current status is open and unresolved under CB-IP-3207-E640. Identity resolves to ENT-087-1001, revision REV-2025.2 is current, and Talia Brooks is active with capacity 2.", "due_date": "2026-09-23", "id": "ACT-CBP-087-02", "identity_id": "ENT-087-1001", "issue": "notice-file omission", "owner": "Talia Brooks", "portfolio_key": "CBP-087-02", "recommended_action": "Create asset-specific title and control rows with identity holds. Owner: Talia Brooks; due 2026-09-23.", "severity": "medium", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_patents/002_patents_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/02_trademarks/014_trademarks_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/026_invention_assignments_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/038_licenses_in_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/08_domain_accounts/062_domain_accounts_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/097_goldfinch_media_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "the permission is limited to Southern District of New York under CB-IP-3207-R452; the matched activity occurred in New York under CB-IP-3207-E226. Identity resolves to ENT-087-1006, revision REV-2025.7 is current, and Henry Cho is active with capacity 1.", "due_date": "2026-09-18", "id": "ACT-CBP-087-07", "identity_id": "ENT-087-1006", "issue": "trademark specimen issue", "owner": "Henry Cho", "portfolio_key": "CBP-087-07", "recommended_action": "Create asset-specific title and control rows with identity holds. Owner: Henry Cho; due 2026-09-18.", "severity": "critical", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_patents/007_patents_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/03_copyrights/019_copyrights_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/031_invention_assignments_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/043_licenses_out_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/097_goldfinch_media_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "the operative cap is $4,042,000.00 under CB-IP-3207-R876; the matched ledger population totals $4,286,176.00 under CB-IP-3207-E728. Identity resolves to ENT-087-1007, revision REV-2025.1 is current, and Maya Ellison is active with capacity 6.", "due_date": "2026-09-17", "id": "ACT-CBP-087-08", "identity_id": "ENT-087-1007", "issue": "outbound sublicense overreach", "owner": "Maya Ellison", "portfolio_key": "CBP-087-08", "recommended_action": "Create asset-specific title and control rows with identity holds. Owner: Maya Ellison; due 2026-09-17.", "severity": "medium", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_patents/008_patents_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/03_copyrights/020_copyrights_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/032_invention_assignments_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/044_licenses_out_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/092_security_interests_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/097_goldfinch_media_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "delivery must use notices-goldfinch_media_network@example.test under CB-IP-3207-R224; the only matched receipt used archive-independent_creator_collective@example.test under CB-IP-3207-E107. Identity resolves to ENT-087-1008, revision REV-2025.2 is current, and Jonas Feld is active with capacity 6.", "due_date": "2026-09-16", "id": "ACT-CBP-087-09", "identity_id": "ENT-087-1008", "issue": "cease-and-desist deadline", "owner": "Jonas Feld", "portfolio_key": "CBP-087-09", "recommended_action": "Create asset-specific title and control rows with identity holds. Owner: Jonas Feld; due 2026-09-16.", "severity": "medium", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_trademarks/009_trademarks_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/03_copyrights/021_copyrights_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/033_licenses_in_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/045_licenses_out_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/11_maintenance/081_maintenance_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/093_security_interests_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/097_goldfinch_media_impact_population.xlsx"]}], "as_of": "2026-09-25", "decision": {"alternatives_considered": ["goldfinch-media:blanket-hold", "goldfinch-media:shortcut"], "question": "What does Goldfinch own or need to cure across creator works, tools, domains, and registrations?", "rationale": "The four-part causal test supports 5 scoped actions and leaves 7 records on evidence hold. Executed grants and valid registrations or account control govern each asset separately.", "recommendation": "Cure supported ownership or control gaps without disturbing clean creator rights.", "selected_option_id": "goldfinch-media:scoped-evidence"}, "holds": [{"id": "HOLD-CBP-087-03", "issue": "inventor assignment gap", "portfolio_key": "CBP-087-03", "reason": "two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key", "required_next_evidence": "an approved immutable entity crosswalk", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_patents/003_patents_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/02_trademarks/015_trademarks_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/027_invention_assignments_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/039_licenses_in_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/11_maintenance/087_maintenance_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/10_disputes/075_disputes_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/097_goldfinch_media_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-087-04", "issue": "coexistence restriction", "portfolio_key": "CBP-087-04", "reason": "the current observation does not meet the operative trigger", "required_next_evidence": "a current observation that satisfies the operative trigger", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_patents/004_patents_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/02_trademarks/016_trademarks_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/028_invention_assignments_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/040_licenses_in_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/08_domain_accounts/064_domain_accounts_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/11_maintenance/088_maintenance_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/097_goldfinch_media_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-087-05", "issue": "copyleft distribution trigger", "portfolio_key": "CBP-087-05", "reason": "the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective", "required_next_evidence": "effective approval and an active owner with remaining capacity", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_patents/005_patents_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/03_copyrights/017_copyrights_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/029_invention_assignments_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/041_licenses_out_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/10_disputes/077_disputes_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/097_goldfinch_media_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-087-06", "issue": "security-interest release gap", "portfolio_key": "CBP-087-06", "reason": "the operational record relies on a superseded control revision", "required_next_evidence": "an operational record using the current effective revision", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_patents/006_patents_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/03_copyrights/018_copyrights_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/030_invention_assignments_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/042_licenses_out_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/090_security_interests_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/09_development_records/066_development_records_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/097_goldfinch_media_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-087-10", "issue": "foreign-filing restriction", "portfolio_key": "CBP-087-10", "reason": "the operational record relies on a superseded control revision", "required_next_evidence": "an operational record using the current effective revision", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_trademarks/010_trademarks_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/03_copyrights/022_copyrights_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/034_licenses_in_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/046_licenses_out_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/09_development_records/070_development_records_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/097_goldfinch_media_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-087-11", "issue": "inbound-license field restriction", "portfolio_key": "CBP-087-11", "reason": "two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key", "required_next_evidence": "an approved immutable entity crosswalk", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_trademarks/011_trademarks_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/03_copyrights/023_copyrights_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/035_licenses_in_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/047_licenses_out_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/097_goldfinch_media_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-087-12", "issue": "repository access anomaly", "portfolio_key": "CBP-087-12", "reason": "the current observation does not meet the operative trigger", "required_next_evidence": "a current observation that satisfies the operative trigger", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_trademarks/012_trademarks_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/03_copyrights/024_copyrights_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/036_licenses_in_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/048_licenses_out_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/097_goldfinch_media_impact_population.xlsx"]}], "matter_number": "CB-IP-3207", "prepared_for": "Goldfinch Media Network", "schema_version": "counselbench.decision.v3", "task_id": "cb100-087-goldfinch-media"}, "matter_register": {"matter_number": "CB-IP-3207", "rows": [{"decision_option_id": "goldfinch-media:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-24", "issue": "work-for-hire defect", "matter_number": "CB-IP-3207", "owner": "Samuel Kim", "portfolio_key": "CBP-087-01", "row_id": "REG-CBP-087-01", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_patents/001_patents_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/02_trademarks/013_trademarks_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/025_invention_assignments_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/037_licenses_in_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/08_domain_accounts/061_domain_accounts_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/097_goldfinch_media_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "goldfinch-media:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-23", "issue": "notice-file omission", "matter_number": "CB-IP-3207", "owner": "Talia Brooks", "portfolio_key": "CBP-087-02", "row_id": "REG-CBP-087-02", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_patents/002_patents_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/02_trademarks/014_trademarks_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/026_invention_assignments_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/038_licenses_in_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/08_domain_accounts/062_domain_accounts_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/097_goldfinch_media_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "goldfinch-media:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key", "issue": "inventor assignment gap", "matter_number": "CB-IP-3207", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-087-03", "row_id": "REG-CBP-087-03", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_patents/003_patents_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/02_trademarks/015_trademarks_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/027_invention_assignments_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/039_licenses_in_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/11_maintenance/087_maintenance_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/10_disputes/075_disputes_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/097_goldfinch_media_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "goldfinch-media:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "the current observation does not meet the operative trigger", "issue": "coexistence restriction", "matter_number": "CB-IP-3207", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-087-04", "row_id": "REG-CBP-087-04", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_patents/004_patents_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/02_trademarks/016_trademarks_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/028_invention_assignments_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/040_licenses_in_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/08_domain_accounts/064_domain_accounts_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/11_maintenance/088_maintenance_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/097_goldfinch_media_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "goldfinch-media:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective", "issue": "copyleft distribution trigger", "matter_number": "CB-IP-3207", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-087-05", "row_id": "REG-CBP-087-05", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_patents/005_patents_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/03_copyrights/017_copyrights_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/029_invention_assignments_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/041_licenses_out_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/10_disputes/077_disputes_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/097_goldfinch_media_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "goldfinch-media:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "the operational record relies on a superseded control revision", "issue": "security-interest release gap", "matter_number": "CB-IP-3207", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-087-06", "row_id": "REG-CBP-087-06", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_patents/006_patents_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/03_copyrights/018_copyrights_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/030_invention_assignments_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/042_licenses_out_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/090_security_interests_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/09_development_records/066_development_records_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/097_goldfinch_media_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "goldfinch-media:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-18", "issue": "trademark specimen issue", "matter_number": "CB-IP-3207", "owner": "Henry Cho", "portfolio_key": "CBP-087-07", "row_id": "REG-CBP-087-07", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_patents/007_patents_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/03_copyrights/019_copyrights_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/031_invention_assignments_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/043_licenses_out_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/097_goldfinch_media_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "goldfinch-media:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-17", "issue": "outbound sublicense overreach", "matter_number": "CB-IP-3207", "owner": "Maya Ellison", "portfolio_key": "CBP-087-08", "row_id": "REG-CBP-087-08", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_patents/008_patents_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/03_copyrights/020_copyrights_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/032_invention_assignments_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/044_licenses_out_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/092_security_interests_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/097_goldfinch_media_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "goldfinch-media:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-16", "issue": "cease-and-desist deadline", "matter_number": "CB-IP-3207", "owner": "Jonas Feld", "portfolio_key": "CBP-087-09", "row_id": "REG-CBP-087-09", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_trademarks/009_trademarks_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/03_copyrights/021_copyrights_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/033_licenses_in_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/045_licenses_out_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/11_maintenance/081_maintenance_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/093_security_interests_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/097_goldfinch_media_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "goldfinch-media:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "the operational record relies on a superseded control revision", "issue": "foreign-filing restriction", "matter_number": "CB-IP-3207", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-087-10", "row_id": "REG-CBP-087-10", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_trademarks/010_trademarks_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/03_copyrights/022_copyrights_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/034_licenses_in_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/046_licenses_out_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/09_development_records/070_development_records_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/097_goldfinch_media_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "goldfinch-media:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key", "issue": "inbound-license field restriction", "matter_number": "CB-IP-3207", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-087-11", "row_id": "REG-CBP-087-11", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_trademarks/011_trademarks_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/03_copyrights/023_copyrights_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/035_licenses_in_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/047_licenses_out_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/097_goldfinch_media_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "goldfinch-media:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "the current observation does not meet the operative trigger", "issue": "repository access anomaly", "matter_number": "CB-IP-3207", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-087-12", "row_id": "REG-CBP-087-12", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_trademarks/012_trademarks_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/03_copyrights/024_copyrights_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/036_licenses_in_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/048_licenses_out_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/097_goldfinch_media_impact_population.xlsx"]}], "schema_version": "counselbench.matter-register.v3", "task_id": "cb100-087-goldfinch-media"}}, "metadata": {"benchmark": "CounselBench-100", "code_license": "Apache-2.0", "data_license": "CC-BY-4.0", "deadline": "2026-09-25", "document_count": 97, "evidence_holds": 7, "jurisdiction": "New York", "matter_number": "CB-IP-3207", "mcp_commit": "9a96ea6e5913736f92b88345bf51caeaaa8e719f", "mcp_package": "@modelcontextprotocol/server-filesystem@2026.7.10", "practice_area": "ip-technology", "reference_tool_calls": 87, "required_evidence_reads": 63, "supported_actions": 5, "synthetic": true, "venue": "Southern District of New York", "version": "3.1.0"}, "prompt": "The other side has challenged our internal account of the facts. What does Goldfinch own or need to cure across creator works, tools, domains, and registrations? A creator platform has mismatched work-for-hire, moderation-tool, domain, and copyright registration records. The team needs the call by 2026-09-25. Leave a concise decision record with exact source references and an owner for each supported next step.", "rubric": {"criteria": [{"category": "investigation", "description": "Inventory the production and use targeted searches to locate records across native formats.", "id": "investigation.discover_production"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Complete every task-specific identity, authority, operations, and approval read before the first state transition.", "id": "investigation.read_before_write"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Inspect designated source metadata before relying on those records.", "id": "investigation.custody_before_write"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "Select the supported option 'goldfinch-media:scoped-evidence' after applying the four-part test.", "id": "decision.selected_option"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "Identify both rejected approaches and explain why a one-source shortcut and a blanket hold are wrong.", "id": "decision.alternatives"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-087-01 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_patents/001_patents_source_export.md rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-087-01.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_trademarks/013_trademarks_source_export.json for work-for-hire defect.", "id": "investigation.CBP-087-01.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/025_invention_assignments_source_export.md to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-087-01.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/037_licenses_in_source_export.json.", "id": "investigation.CBP-087-01.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-087-01 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-087-01.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-087-01 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-087-01.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-087-02 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_patents/002_patents_source_export.txt rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-087-02.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_trademarks/014_trademarks_source_export.xml for notice-file omission.", "id": "investigation.CBP-087-02.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/026_invention_assignments_source_export.txt to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-087-02.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/038_licenses_in_source_export.xml.", "id": "investigation.CBP-087-02.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-087-02 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-087-02.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-087-02 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-087-02.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-087-03 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_patents/003_patents_source_export.eml rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-087-03.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_trademarks/015_trademarks_source_export.html for inventor assignment gap.", "id": "investigation.CBP-087-03.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/027_invention_assignments_source_export.eml to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-087-03.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/039_licenses_in_source_export.html.", "id": "investigation.CBP-087-03.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-087-03 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key.", "id": "decision.CBP-087-03.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-087-03 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-087-03.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-087-04 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_patents/004_patents_source_export.csv rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-087-04.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_trademarks/016_trademarks_source_export.pdf for coexistence restriction.", "id": "investigation.CBP-087-04.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/028_invention_assignments_source_export.csv to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-087-04.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/040_licenses_in_source_export.pdf.", "id": "investigation.CBP-087-04.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-087-04 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is the current observation does not meet the operative trigger.", "id": "decision.CBP-087-04.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-087-04 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-087-04.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-087-05 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_patents/005_patents_source_export.json rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-087-05.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_copyrights/017_copyrights_source_export.md for copyleft distribution trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-087-05.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/029_invention_assignments_source_export.json to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-087-05.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/041_licenses_out_source_export.md.", "id": "investigation.CBP-087-05.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-087-05 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective.", "id": "decision.CBP-087-05.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-087-05 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-087-05.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-087-06 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_patents/006_patents_source_export.xml rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-087-06.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_copyrights/018_copyrights_source_export.txt for security-interest release gap.", "id": "investigation.CBP-087-06.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/030_invention_assignments_source_export.xml to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-087-06.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/042_licenses_out_source_export.txt.", "id": "investigation.CBP-087-06.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-087-06 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is the operational record relies on a superseded control revision.", "id": "decision.CBP-087-06.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-087-06 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-087-06.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-087-07 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_patents/007_patents_source_export.html rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-087-07.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_copyrights/019_copyrights_source_export.eml for trademark specimen issue.", "id": "investigation.CBP-087-07.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/031_invention_assignments_source_export.html to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-087-07.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/043_licenses_out_source_export.eml.", "id": "investigation.CBP-087-07.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-087-07 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-087-07.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-087-07 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-087-07.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-087-08 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_patents/008_patents_source_export.pdf rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-087-08.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_copyrights/020_copyrights_source_export.csv for outbound sublicense overreach.", "id": "investigation.CBP-087-08.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/032_invention_assignments_source_export.pdf to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-087-08.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/044_licenses_out_source_export.csv.", "id": "investigation.CBP-087-08.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-087-08 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-087-08.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-087-08 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-087-08.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-087-09 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_trademarks/009_trademarks_source_export.md rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-087-09.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_copyrights/021_copyrights_source_export.json for cease-and-desist deadline.", "id": "investigation.CBP-087-09.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/033_licenses_in_source_export.md to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-087-09.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/045_licenses_out_source_export.json.", "id": "investigation.CBP-087-09.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-087-09 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-087-09.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-087-09 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-087-09.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-087-10 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_trademarks/010_trademarks_source_export.txt rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-087-10.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_copyrights/022_copyrights_source_export.xml for foreign-filing restriction.", "id": "investigation.CBP-087-10.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/034_licenses_in_source_export.txt to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-087-10.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/046_licenses_out_source_export.xml.", "id": "investigation.CBP-087-10.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-087-10 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is the operational record relies on a superseded control revision.", "id": "decision.CBP-087-10.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-087-10 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-087-10.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-087-11 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_trademarks/011_trademarks_source_export.eml rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-087-11.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_copyrights/023_copyrights_source_export.html for inbound-license field restriction.", "id": "investigation.CBP-087-11.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/035_licenses_in_source_export.eml to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-087-11.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/047_licenses_out_source_export.html.", "id": "investigation.CBP-087-11.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-087-11 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key.", "id": "decision.CBP-087-11.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-087-11 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-087-11.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-087-12 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_trademarks/012_trademarks_source_export.csv rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-087-12.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_copyrights/024_copyrights_source_export.pdf for repository access anomaly.", "id": "investigation.CBP-087-12.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/036_licenses_in_source_export.csv to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-087-12.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/048_licenses_out_source_export.pdf.", "id": "investigation.CBP-087-12.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-087-12 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is the current observation does not meet the operative trigger.", "id": "decision.CBP-087-12.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-087-12 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-087-12.register"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Write the exact selected option, supported action population, evidence-hold population, facts, owners, deadlines, and citations.", "id": "state.exact_decision"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create one exact register row per portfolio key with no extra, missing, or modified row.", "id": "state.exact_register"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Leave only the three approved deliverables and perform no extra state-changing write.", "id": "state.write_scope_containment"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Read back decision.json, matter-register.json, and advice.md after their final writes.", "id": "state.postwrite_readback"}, {"category": "answer", "description": "Explain the selected recommendation, supported actions, holds, alternatives, and limitations with exact source anchors.", "id": "answer.decision_note"}], "decision_options": [{"approach": "Treat supported actions and genuinely ambiguous records as if they were equally unresolved.", "id": "goldfinch-media:blanket-hold", "label": "Freeze the entire matter population"}, {"approach": "Apply the exact identity, current-state, authority, and revision test. Create asset-specific title and control rows with identity holds.", "id": "goldfinch-media:scoped-evidence", "label": "Cure supported ownership or control gaps without disturbing clean creator rights."}, {"approach": "Use a plausible summary or one source without completing the controlling joins.", "id": "goldfinch-media:shortcut", "label": "Treat platform upload terms as complete ownership of every work."}], "evaluation_narrative": {"authority": "Executed grants and valid registrations or account control govern each asset separately.", "observation": "Match creators, agreements, deliverables, moderation tools, registrants, and filings by asset.", "question": "What does Goldfinch own or need to cure across creator works, tools, domains, and registrations?", "register_action": "Create asset-specific title and control rows with identity holds."}, "gates": ["all_required_evidence_precedes_first_write", "decision_criteria_complete", "register_state_exact", "write_scope_contained", "all_outputs_verified_by_readback"], "metadata_checks": 8, "metric": "weighted_criteria_score", "minimum_tool_calls": 87, "required_deliverables": ["decision.json", "matter-register.json", "advice.md"], "required_document_reads": 63, "type": "deterministic", "weights": {"advice": 0.15, "decision": 0.35, "investigation": 0.25, "state": 0.25}}, "task_id": "cb100-087-goldfinch-media", "task_name": "Goldfinch content platform IP review", "world_id": "counselbench-filesystem-mcp-v3"}
+{"context_files": ["task_files/cb100-088-hinterland-agri/01_patents/001_patents_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-088-hinterland-agri/01_patents/002_patents_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-088-hinterland-agri/01_patents/003_patents_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-088-hinterland-agri/01_patents/004_patents_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-088-hinterland-agri/01_patents/005_patents_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-088-hinterland-agri/01_patents/006_patents_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-088-hinterland-agri/01_patents/007_patents_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-088-hinterland-agri/01_patents/008_patents_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-088-hinterland-agri/02_trademarks/009_trademarks_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-088-hinterland-agri/02_trademarks/010_trademarks_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-088-hinterland-agri/02_trademarks/011_trademarks_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-088-hinterland-agri/02_trademarks/012_trademarks_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-088-hinterland-agri/02_trademarks/013_trademarks_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-088-hinterland-agri/02_trademarks/014_trademarks_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-088-hinterland-agri/02_trademarks/015_trademarks_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-088-hinterland-agri/02_trademarks/016_trademarks_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-088-hinterland-agri/03_copyrights/017_copyrights_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-088-hinterland-agri/03_copyrights/018_copyrights_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-088-hinterland-agri/03_copyrights/019_copyrights_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-088-hinterland-agri/03_copyrights/020_copyrights_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-088-hinterland-agri/03_copyrights/021_copyrights_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-088-hinterland-agri/03_copyrights/022_copyrights_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-088-hinterland-agri/03_copyrights/023_copyrights_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-088-hinterland-agri/03_copyrights/024_copyrights_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-088-hinterland-agri/04_invention_assignments/025_invention_assignments_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-088-hinterland-agri/04_invention_assignments/026_invention_assignments_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-088-hinterland-agri/04_invention_assignments/027_invention_assignments_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-088-hinterland-agri/04_invention_assignments/028_invention_assignments_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-088-hinterland-agri/04_invention_assignments/029_invention_assignments_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-088-hinterland-agri/04_invention_assignments/030_invention_assignments_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-088-hinterland-agri/04_invention_assignments/031_invention_assignments_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-088-hinterland-agri/04_invention_assignments/032_invention_assignments_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-088-hinterland-agri/05_licenses_in/033_licenses_in_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-088-hinterland-agri/05_licenses_in/034_licenses_in_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-088-hinterland-agri/05_licenses_in/035_licenses_in_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-088-hinterland-agri/05_licenses_in/036_licenses_in_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-088-hinterland-agri/05_licenses_in/037_licenses_in_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-088-hinterland-agri/05_licenses_in/038_licenses_in_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-088-hinterland-agri/05_licenses_in/039_licenses_in_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-088-hinterland-agri/05_licenses_in/040_licenses_in_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-088-hinterland-agri/06_licenses_out/041_licenses_out_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-088-hinterland-agri/06_licenses_out/042_licenses_out_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-088-hinterland-agri/06_licenses_out/043_licenses_out_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-088-hinterland-agri/06_licenses_out/044_licenses_out_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-088-hinterland-agri/06_licenses_out/045_licenses_out_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-088-hinterland-agri/06_licenses_out/046_licenses_out_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-088-hinterland-agri/06_licenses_out/047_licenses_out_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-088-hinterland-agri/06_licenses_out/048_licenses_out_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-088-hinterland-agri/07_open_source/049_open_source_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-088-hinterland-agri/07_open_source/050_open_source_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-088-hinterland-agri/07_open_source/051_open_source_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-088-hinterland-agri/07_open_source/052_open_source_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-088-hinterland-agri/07_open_source/053_open_source_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-088-hinterland-agri/07_open_source/054_open_source_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-088-hinterland-agri/07_open_source/055_open_source_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-088-hinterland-agri/07_open_source/056_open_source_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-088-hinterland-agri/08_domain_accounts/057_domain_accounts_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-088-hinterland-agri/08_domain_accounts/058_domain_accounts_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-088-hinterland-agri/08_domain_accounts/059_domain_accounts_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-088-hinterland-agri/08_domain_accounts/060_domain_accounts_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-088-hinterland-agri/08_domain_accounts/061_domain_accounts_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-088-hinterland-agri/08_domain_accounts/062_domain_accounts_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-088-hinterland-agri/08_domain_accounts/063_domain_accounts_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-088-hinterland-agri/08_domain_accounts/064_domain_accounts_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-088-hinterland-agri/09_development_records/065_development_records_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-088-hinterland-agri/09_development_records/066_development_records_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-088-hinterland-agri/09_development_records/067_development_records_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-088-hinterland-agri/09_development_records/068_development_records_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-088-hinterland-agri/09_development_records/069_development_records_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-088-hinterland-agri/09_development_records/070_development_records_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-088-hinterland-agri/09_development_records/071_development_records_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-088-hinterland-agri/09_development_records/072_development_records_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-088-hinterland-agri/10_disputes/073_disputes_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-088-hinterland-agri/10_disputes/074_disputes_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-088-hinterland-agri/10_disputes/075_disputes_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-088-hinterland-agri/10_disputes/076_disputes_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-088-hinterland-agri/10_disputes/077_disputes_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-088-hinterland-agri/10_disputes/078_disputes_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-088-hinterland-agri/10_disputes/079_disputes_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-088-hinterland-agri/10_disputes/080_disputes_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-088-hinterland-agri/11_maintenance/081_maintenance_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-088-hinterland-agri/11_maintenance/082_maintenance_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-088-hinterland-agri/11_maintenance/083_maintenance_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-088-hinterland-agri/11_maintenance/084_maintenance_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-088-hinterland-agri/11_maintenance/085_maintenance_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-088-hinterland-agri/11_maintenance/086_maintenance_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-088-hinterland-agri/11_maintenance/087_maintenance_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-088-hinterland-agri/11_maintenance/088_maintenance_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-088-hinterland-agri/12_security_interests/089_security_interests_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-088-hinterland-agri/12_security_interests/090_security_interests_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-088-hinterland-agri/12_security_interests/091_security_interests_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-088-hinterland-agri/12_security_interests/092_security_interests_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-088-hinterland-agri/12_security_interests/093_security_interests_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-088-hinterland-agri/12_security_interests/094_security_interests_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-088-hinterland-agri/12_security_interests/095_security_interests_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-088-hinterland-agri/12_security_interests/096_security_interests_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-088-hinterland-agri/12_security_interests/097_hinterland_agri_impact_population.xlsx"], "gold_output": {"advice_markdown": "# Decision note — Hinterland seed technology title audit\n\n## Recommendation\n\nUse or condition only assets with a supported rights chain and resolved restrictions. The reconciled record supports 8 scoped actions and leaves 4 items on evidence hold.\n\nSelected option: `hinterland-agri:scoped-evidence`.\n\n## Why this is the supported option\n\nJoin patent families, materials, grants, field trials, security interests, and releases by trait and entity. Grant obligations, material terms, field restrictions, and recorded liens all apply to exact assets.\n\n## Supported actions\n\n### CBP-088-02 — domain registrant mismatch (high)\n\nthe permission is limited to Southern District of Iowa under CB-IP-3208-R958; the matched activity occurred in Iowa under CB-IP-3208-E679. Identity resolves to ENT-088-1001, revision REV-2026.2 is current, and Caleb Hassan is active with capacity 6.\n\nAction: Create trait-asset rows with exact restrictions and cure paths. Owner: Caleb Hassan; due 2026-09-27.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_patents/002_patents_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/02_trademarks/014_trademarks_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/026_invention_assignments_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/038_licenses_in_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/097_hinterland_agri_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-088-04 — work-for-hire defect (medium)\n\ndelivery must use notices-hinterland_agricultural_science@example.test under CB-IP-3208-R209; the only matched receipt used archive-prairie_state_university@example.test under CB-IP-3208-E106. Identity resolves to ENT-088-1003, revision REV-2026.4 is current, and Samuel Kim is active with capacity 4.\n\nAction: Create trait-asset rows with exact restrictions and cure paths. Owner: Samuel Kim; due 2026-09-25.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_patents/004_patents_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/02_trademarks/016_trademarks_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/028_invention_assignments_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/040_licenses_in_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/11_maintenance/088_maintenance_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/097_hinterland_agri_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-088-06 — inventor assignment gap (critical)\n\ncompletion is required by 2025-02-26 under CB-IP-3208-R511; the current event record shows completion on 2025-03-15 under CB-IP-3208-E759. Identity resolves to ENT-088-1005, revision REV-2026.6 is current, and Adrian Mensah is active with capacity 5.\n\nAction: Create trait-asset rows with exact restrictions and cure paths. Owner: Adrian Mensah; due 2026-09-23.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_patents/006_patents_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/03_copyrights/018_copyrights_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/030_invention_assignments_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/042_licenses_out_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/090_security_interests_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/097_hinterland_agri_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-088-07 — coexistence restriction (medium)\n\nthe controlling threshold is 3% under CB-IP-3208-R980; the independently calculated result is 5% under CB-IP-3208-E204. Identity resolves to ENT-088-1006, revision REV-2026.7 is current, and Farah Ibrahim is active with capacity 2.\n\nAction: Create trait-asset rows with exact restrictions and cure paths. Owner: Farah Ibrahim; due 2026-09-22.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_patents/007_patents_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/03_copyrights/019_copyrights_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/031_invention_assignments_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/043_licenses_out_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/097_hinterland_agri_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-088-08 — copyleft distribution trigger (medium)\n\napproval must come from Sofia Bennett under CB-IP-3208-R343; the effective approval record names Caleb Hassan under CB-IP-3208-E537. Identity resolves to ENT-088-1007, revision REV-2026.1 is current, and Dominic Alvarez is active with capacity 4.\n\nAction: Create trait-asset rows with exact restrictions and cure paths. Owner: Dominic Alvarez; due 2026-09-21.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_patents/008_patents_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/03_copyrights/020_copyrights_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/032_invention_assignments_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/044_licenses_out_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/092_security_interests_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/10_disputes/080_disputes_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/097_hinterland_agri_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-088-09 — security-interest release gap (medium)\n\nthe controlled population contains 86 records under CB-IP-3208-R514; the certification covers 69 records under CB-IP-3208-E600. Identity resolves to ENT-088-1008, revision REV-2026.2 is current, and Leona Park is active with capacity 2.\n\nAction: Create trait-asset rows with exact restrictions and cure paths. Owner: Leona Park; due 2026-09-20.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/02_trademarks/009_trademarks_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/03_copyrights/021_copyrights_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/033_licenses_in_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/045_licenses_out_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/093_security_interests_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/11_maintenance/081_maintenance_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/097_hinterland_agri_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-088-11 — outbound sublicense overreach (medium)\n\nthe operative cap is $3,802,000.00 under CB-IP-3208-R278; the matched ledger population totals $4,045,278.00 under CB-IP-3208-E904. Identity resolves to ENT-088-1010, revision REV-2026.4 is current, and Maya Ellison is active with capacity 4.\n\nAction: Create trait-asset rows with exact restrictions and cure paths. Owner: Maya Ellison; due 2026-09-27.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/02_trademarks/011_trademarks_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/03_copyrights/023_copyrights_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/035_licenses_in_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/047_licenses_out_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/097_hinterland_agri_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-088-12 — cease-and-desist deadline (high)\n\ndelivery must use notices-hinterland_agricultural_science@example.test under CB-IP-3208-R571; the only matched receipt used archive-prairie_state_university@example.test under CB-IP-3208-E233. Identity resolves to ENT-088-1011, revision REV-2026.5 is current, and Jonas Feld is active with capacity 2.\n\nAction: Create trait-asset rows with exact restrictions and cure paths. Owner: Jonas Feld; due 2026-09-26.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/02_trademarks/012_trademarks_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/03_copyrights/024_copyrights_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/036_licenses_in_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/048_licenses_out_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/11_maintenance/084_maintenance_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/09_development_records/072_development_records_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/097_hinterland_agri_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n## Evidence holds\n\n- **CBP-088-01 — source-code ownership gap**: the operational record relies on a superseded control revision. Next evidence: an operational record using the current effective revision. Sources: `/workspace/documents/01_patents/001_patents_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/02_trademarks/013_trademarks_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/025_invention_assignments_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/037_licenses_in_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/10_disputes/073_disputes_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/097_hinterland_agri_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-088-03 — recorded-owner mismatch**: the current observation does not meet the operative trigger. Next evidence: a current observation that satisfies the operative trigger. Sources: `/workspace/documents/01_patents/003_patents_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/02_trademarks/015_trademarks_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/027_invention_assignments_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/039_licenses_in_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/11_maintenance/087_maintenance_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/10_disputes/075_disputes_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/097_hinterland_agri_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-088-05 — notice-file omission**: the operational record relies on a superseded control revision. Next evidence: an operational record using the current effective revision. Sources: `/workspace/documents/01_patents/005_patents_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/03_copyrights/017_copyrights_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/029_invention_assignments_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/041_licenses_out_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/09_development_records/065_development_records_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/07_open_source/053_open_source_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/097_hinterland_agri_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-088-10 — trademark specimen issue**: two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key. Next evidence: an approved immutable entity crosswalk. Sources: `/workspace/documents/02_trademarks/010_trademarks_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/03_copyrights/022_copyrights_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/034_licenses_in_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/046_licenses_out_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/094_security_interests_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/097_hinterland_agri_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n## Alternatives considered\n\n- `hinterland-agri:shortcut` — Treat patent ownership as overriding grant, material, and lien obligations.: Use a plausible summary or one source without completing the controlling joins.\n- `hinterland-agri:blanket-hold` — Freeze the entire matter population: Treat supported actions and genuinely ambiguous records as if they were equally unresolved.\n\n## Assumptions and limits\n\nThis decision is limited to cb100-088-hinterland-agri, the supplied synthetic records, and the matter state as of 2026-09-29. Similar names, stale revisions, and pending authority are not treated as proof.\n", "decision": {"actions": [{"determination": "the permission is limited to Southern District of Iowa under CB-IP-3208-R958; the matched activity occurred in Iowa under CB-IP-3208-E679. Identity resolves to ENT-088-1001, revision REV-2026.2 is current, and Caleb Hassan is active with capacity 6.", "due_date": "2026-09-27", "id": "ACT-CBP-088-02", "identity_id": "ENT-088-1001", "issue": "domain registrant mismatch", "owner": "Caleb Hassan", "portfolio_key": "CBP-088-02", "recommended_action": "Create trait-asset rows with exact restrictions and cure paths. Owner: Caleb Hassan; due 2026-09-27.", "severity": "high", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_patents/002_patents_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/02_trademarks/014_trademarks_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/026_invention_assignments_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/038_licenses_in_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/097_hinterland_agri_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "delivery must use notices-hinterland_agricultural_science@example.test under CB-IP-3208-R209; the only matched receipt used archive-prairie_state_university@example.test under CB-IP-3208-E106. Identity resolves to ENT-088-1003, revision REV-2026.4 is current, and Samuel Kim is active with capacity 4.", "due_date": "2026-09-25", "id": "ACT-CBP-088-04", "identity_id": "ENT-088-1003", "issue": "work-for-hire defect", "owner": "Samuel Kim", "portfolio_key": "CBP-088-04", "recommended_action": "Create trait-asset rows with exact restrictions and cure paths. Owner: Samuel Kim; due 2026-09-25.", "severity": "medium", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_patents/004_patents_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/02_trademarks/016_trademarks_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/028_invention_assignments_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/040_licenses_in_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/11_maintenance/088_maintenance_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/097_hinterland_agri_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "completion is required by 2025-02-26 under CB-IP-3208-R511; the current event record shows completion on 2025-03-15 under CB-IP-3208-E759. Identity resolves to ENT-088-1005, revision REV-2026.6 is current, and Adrian Mensah is active with capacity 5.", "due_date": "2026-09-23", "id": "ACT-CBP-088-06", "identity_id": "ENT-088-1005", "issue": "inventor assignment gap", "owner": "Adrian Mensah", "portfolio_key": "CBP-088-06", "recommended_action": "Create trait-asset rows with exact restrictions and cure paths. Owner: Adrian Mensah; due 2026-09-23.", "severity": "critical", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_patents/006_patents_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/03_copyrights/018_copyrights_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/030_invention_assignments_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/042_licenses_out_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/090_security_interests_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/097_hinterland_agri_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "the controlling threshold is 3% under CB-IP-3208-R980; the independently calculated result is 5% under CB-IP-3208-E204. Identity resolves to ENT-088-1006, revision REV-2026.7 is current, and Farah Ibrahim is active with capacity 2.", "due_date": "2026-09-22", "id": "ACT-CBP-088-07", "identity_id": "ENT-088-1006", "issue": "coexistence restriction", "owner": "Farah Ibrahim", "portfolio_key": "CBP-088-07", "recommended_action": "Create trait-asset rows with exact restrictions and cure paths. Owner: Farah Ibrahim; due 2026-09-22.", "severity": "medium", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_patents/007_patents_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/03_copyrights/019_copyrights_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/031_invention_assignments_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/043_licenses_out_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/097_hinterland_agri_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "approval must come from Sofia Bennett under CB-IP-3208-R343; the effective approval record names Caleb Hassan under CB-IP-3208-E537. Identity resolves to ENT-088-1007, revision REV-2026.1 is current, and Dominic Alvarez is active with capacity 4.", "due_date": "2026-09-21", "id": "ACT-CBP-088-08", "identity_id": "ENT-088-1007", "issue": "copyleft distribution trigger", "owner": "Dominic Alvarez", "portfolio_key": "CBP-088-08", "recommended_action": "Create trait-asset rows with exact restrictions and cure paths. Owner: Dominic Alvarez; due 2026-09-21.", "severity": "medium", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_patents/008_patents_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/03_copyrights/020_copyrights_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/032_invention_assignments_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/044_licenses_out_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/092_security_interests_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/10_disputes/080_disputes_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/097_hinterland_agri_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "the controlled population contains 86 records under CB-IP-3208-R514; the certification covers 69 records under CB-IP-3208-E600. Identity resolves to ENT-088-1008, revision REV-2026.2 is current, and Leona Park is active with capacity 2.", "due_date": "2026-09-20", "id": "ACT-CBP-088-09", "identity_id": "ENT-088-1008", "issue": "security-interest release gap", "owner": "Leona Park", "portfolio_key": "CBP-088-09", "recommended_action": "Create trait-asset rows with exact restrictions and cure paths. Owner: Leona Park; due 2026-09-20.", "severity": "medium", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_trademarks/009_trademarks_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/03_copyrights/021_copyrights_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/033_licenses_in_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/045_licenses_out_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/093_security_interests_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/11_maintenance/081_maintenance_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/097_hinterland_agri_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "the operative cap is $3,802,000.00 under CB-IP-3208-R278; the matched ledger population totals $4,045,278.00 under CB-IP-3208-E904. Identity resolves to ENT-088-1010, revision REV-2026.4 is current, and Maya Ellison is active with capacity 4.", "due_date": "2026-09-27", "id": "ACT-CBP-088-11", "identity_id": "ENT-088-1010", "issue": "outbound sublicense overreach", "owner": "Maya Ellison", "portfolio_key": "CBP-088-11", "recommended_action": "Create trait-asset rows with exact restrictions and cure paths. Owner: Maya Ellison; due 2026-09-27.", "severity": "medium", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_trademarks/011_trademarks_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/03_copyrights/023_copyrights_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/035_licenses_in_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/047_licenses_out_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/097_hinterland_agri_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "delivery must use notices-hinterland_agricultural_science@example.test under CB-IP-3208-R571; the only matched receipt used archive-prairie_state_university@example.test under CB-IP-3208-E233. Identity resolves to ENT-088-1011, revision REV-2026.5 is current, and Jonas Feld is active with capacity 2.", "due_date": "2026-09-26", "id": "ACT-CBP-088-12", "identity_id": "ENT-088-1011", "issue": "cease-and-desist deadline", "owner": "Jonas Feld", "portfolio_key": "CBP-088-12", "recommended_action": "Create trait-asset rows with exact restrictions and cure paths. Owner: Jonas Feld; due 2026-09-26.", "severity": "high", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_trademarks/012_trademarks_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/03_copyrights/024_copyrights_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/036_licenses_in_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/048_licenses_out_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/11_maintenance/084_maintenance_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/09_development_records/072_development_records_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/097_hinterland_agri_impact_population.xlsx"]}], "as_of": "2026-09-29", "decision": {"alternatives_considered": ["hinterland-agri:shortcut", "hinterland-agri:blanket-hold"], "question": "Which Hinterland seed assets are usable given grant, field, material, and lien restrictions?", "rationale": "The four-part causal test supports 8 scoped actions and leaves 4 records on evidence hold. Grant obligations, material terms, field restrictions, and recorded liens all apply to exact assets.", "recommendation": "Use or condition only assets with a supported rights chain and resolved restrictions.", "selected_option_id": "hinterland-agri:scoped-evidence"}, "holds": [{"id": "HOLD-CBP-088-01", "issue": "source-code ownership gap", "portfolio_key": "CBP-088-01", "reason": "the operational record relies on a superseded control revision", "required_next_evidence": "an operational record using the current effective revision", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_patents/001_patents_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/02_trademarks/013_trademarks_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/025_invention_assignments_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/037_licenses_in_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/10_disputes/073_disputes_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/097_hinterland_agri_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-088-03", "issue": "recorded-owner mismatch", "portfolio_key": "CBP-088-03", "reason": "the current observation does not meet the operative trigger", "required_next_evidence": "a current observation that satisfies the operative trigger", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_patents/003_patents_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/02_trademarks/015_trademarks_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/027_invention_assignments_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/039_licenses_in_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/11_maintenance/087_maintenance_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/10_disputes/075_disputes_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/097_hinterland_agri_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-088-05", "issue": "notice-file omission", "portfolio_key": "CBP-088-05", "reason": "the operational record relies on a superseded control revision", "required_next_evidence": "an operational record using the current effective revision", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_patents/005_patents_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/03_copyrights/017_copyrights_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/029_invention_assignments_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/041_licenses_out_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/09_development_records/065_development_records_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/07_open_source/053_open_source_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/097_hinterland_agri_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-088-10", "issue": "trademark specimen issue", "portfolio_key": "CBP-088-10", "reason": "two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key", "required_next_evidence": "an approved immutable entity crosswalk", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_trademarks/010_trademarks_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/03_copyrights/022_copyrights_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/034_licenses_in_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/046_licenses_out_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/094_security_interests_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/097_hinterland_agri_impact_population.xlsx"]}], "matter_number": "CB-IP-3208", "prepared_for": "Hinterland Agricultural Science", "schema_version": "counselbench.decision.v3", "task_id": "cb100-088-hinterland-agri"}, "matter_register": {"matter_number": "CB-IP-3208", "rows": [{"decision_option_id": "hinterland-agri:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "the operational record relies on a superseded control revision", "issue": "source-code ownership gap", "matter_number": "CB-IP-3208", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-088-01", "row_id": "REG-CBP-088-01", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_patents/001_patents_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/02_trademarks/013_trademarks_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/025_invention_assignments_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/037_licenses_in_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/10_disputes/073_disputes_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/097_hinterland_agri_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "hinterland-agri:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-27", "issue": "domain registrant mismatch", "matter_number": "CB-IP-3208", "owner": "Caleb Hassan", "portfolio_key": "CBP-088-02", "row_id": "REG-CBP-088-02", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_patents/002_patents_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/02_trademarks/014_trademarks_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/026_invention_assignments_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/038_licenses_in_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/097_hinterland_agri_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "hinterland-agri:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "the current observation does not meet the operative trigger", "issue": "recorded-owner mismatch", "matter_number": "CB-IP-3208", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-088-03", "row_id": "REG-CBP-088-03", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_patents/003_patents_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/02_trademarks/015_trademarks_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/027_invention_assignments_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/039_licenses_in_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/11_maintenance/087_maintenance_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/10_disputes/075_disputes_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/097_hinterland_agri_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "hinterland-agri:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-25", "issue": "work-for-hire defect", "matter_number": "CB-IP-3208", "owner": "Samuel Kim", "portfolio_key": "CBP-088-04", "row_id": "REG-CBP-088-04", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_patents/004_patents_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/02_trademarks/016_trademarks_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/028_invention_assignments_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/040_licenses_in_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/11_maintenance/088_maintenance_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/097_hinterland_agri_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "hinterland-agri:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "the operational record relies on a superseded control revision", "issue": "notice-file omission", "matter_number": "CB-IP-3208", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-088-05", "row_id": "REG-CBP-088-05", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_patents/005_patents_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/03_copyrights/017_copyrights_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/029_invention_assignments_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/041_licenses_out_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/09_development_records/065_development_records_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/07_open_source/053_open_source_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/097_hinterland_agri_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "hinterland-agri:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-23", "issue": "inventor assignment gap", "matter_number": "CB-IP-3208", "owner": "Adrian Mensah", "portfolio_key": "CBP-088-06", "row_id": "REG-CBP-088-06", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_patents/006_patents_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/03_copyrights/018_copyrights_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/030_invention_assignments_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/042_licenses_out_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/090_security_interests_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/097_hinterland_agri_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "hinterland-agri:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-22", "issue": "coexistence restriction", "matter_number": "CB-IP-3208", "owner": "Farah Ibrahim", "portfolio_key": "CBP-088-07", "row_id": "REG-CBP-088-07", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_patents/007_patents_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/03_copyrights/019_copyrights_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/031_invention_assignments_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/043_licenses_out_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/097_hinterland_agri_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "hinterland-agri:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-21", "issue": "copyleft distribution trigger", "matter_number": "CB-IP-3208", "owner": "Dominic Alvarez", "portfolio_key": "CBP-088-08", "row_id": "REG-CBP-088-08", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_patents/008_patents_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/03_copyrights/020_copyrights_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/032_invention_assignments_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/044_licenses_out_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/092_security_interests_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/10_disputes/080_disputes_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/097_hinterland_agri_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "hinterland-agri:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-20", "issue": "security-interest release gap", "matter_number": "CB-IP-3208", "owner": "Leona Park", "portfolio_key": "CBP-088-09", "row_id": "REG-CBP-088-09", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_trademarks/009_trademarks_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/03_copyrights/021_copyrights_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/033_licenses_in_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/045_licenses_out_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/093_security_interests_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/11_maintenance/081_maintenance_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/097_hinterland_agri_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "hinterland-agri:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key", "issue": "trademark specimen issue", "matter_number": "CB-IP-3208", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-088-10", "row_id": "REG-CBP-088-10", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_trademarks/010_trademarks_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/03_copyrights/022_copyrights_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/034_licenses_in_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/046_licenses_out_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/094_security_interests_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/097_hinterland_agri_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "hinterland-agri:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-27", "issue": "outbound sublicense overreach", "matter_number": "CB-IP-3208", "owner": "Maya Ellison", "portfolio_key": "CBP-088-11", "row_id": "REG-CBP-088-11", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_trademarks/011_trademarks_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/03_copyrights/023_copyrights_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/035_licenses_in_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/047_licenses_out_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/097_hinterland_agri_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "hinterland-agri:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-26", "issue": "cease-and-desist deadline", "matter_number": "CB-IP-3208", "owner": "Jonas Feld", "portfolio_key": "CBP-088-12", "row_id": "REG-CBP-088-12", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_trademarks/012_trademarks_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/03_copyrights/024_copyrights_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/036_licenses_in_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/048_licenses_out_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/11_maintenance/084_maintenance_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/09_development_records/072_development_records_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/097_hinterland_agri_impact_population.xlsx"]}], "schema_version": "counselbench.matter-register.v3", "task_id": "cb100-088-hinterland-agri"}}, "metadata": {"benchmark": "CounselBench-100", "code_license": "Apache-2.0", "data_license": "CC-BY-4.0", "deadline": "2026-09-29", "document_count": 97, "evidence_holds": 4, "jurisdiction": "Iowa", "matter_number": "CB-IP-3208", "mcp_commit": "9a96ea6e5913736f92b88345bf51caeaaa8e719f", "mcp_package": "@modelcontextprotocol/server-filesystem@2026.7.10", "practice_area": "ip-technology", "reference_tool_calls": 91, "required_evidence_reads": 64, "supported_actions": 8, "synthetic": true, "venue": "Southern District of Iowa", "version": "3.1.0"}, "prompt": "There is enough noise in this file that a name match or newest-document shortcut will be dangerous. Which Hinterland seed assets are usable given grant, field, material, and lien restrictions? Seed-trait patents, research materials, grant obligations, field restrictions, and recorded security interests do not align. The team needs the call by 2026-09-29. Leave the defensible result in the matter workspace, including any item that must stay on hold for better evidence.", "rubric": {"criteria": [{"category": "investigation", "description": "Inventory the production and use targeted searches to locate records across native formats.", "id": "investigation.discover_production"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Complete every task-specific identity, authority, operations, and approval read before the first state transition.", "id": "investigation.read_before_write"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Inspect designated source metadata before relying on those records.", "id": "investigation.custody_before_write"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "Select the supported option 'hinterland-agri:scoped-evidence' after applying the four-part test.", "id": "decision.selected_option"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "Identify both rejected approaches and explain why a one-source shortcut and a blanket hold are wrong.", "id": "decision.alternatives"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-088-01 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_patents/001_patents_source_export.md rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-088-01.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_trademarks/013_trademarks_source_export.json for source-code ownership gap.", "id": "investigation.CBP-088-01.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/025_invention_assignments_source_export.md to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-088-01.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/037_licenses_in_source_export.json.", "id": "investigation.CBP-088-01.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-088-01 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is the operational record relies on a superseded control revision.", "id": "decision.CBP-088-01.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-088-01 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-088-01.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-088-02 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_patents/002_patents_source_export.txt rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-088-02.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_trademarks/014_trademarks_source_export.xml for domain registrant mismatch.", "id": "investigation.CBP-088-02.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/026_invention_assignments_source_export.txt to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-088-02.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/038_licenses_in_source_export.xml.", "id": "investigation.CBP-088-02.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-088-02 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-088-02.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-088-02 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-088-02.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-088-03 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_patents/003_patents_source_export.eml rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-088-03.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_trademarks/015_trademarks_source_export.html for recorded-owner mismatch.", "id": "investigation.CBP-088-03.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/027_invention_assignments_source_export.eml to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-088-03.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/039_licenses_in_source_export.html.", "id": "investigation.CBP-088-03.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-088-03 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is the current observation does not meet the operative trigger.", "id": "decision.CBP-088-03.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-088-03 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-088-03.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-088-04 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_patents/004_patents_source_export.csv rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-088-04.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_trademarks/016_trademarks_source_export.pdf for work-for-hire defect.", "id": "investigation.CBP-088-04.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/028_invention_assignments_source_export.csv to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-088-04.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/040_licenses_in_source_export.pdf.", "id": "investigation.CBP-088-04.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-088-04 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-088-04.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-088-04 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-088-04.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-088-05 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_patents/005_patents_source_export.json rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-088-05.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_copyrights/017_copyrights_source_export.md for notice-file omission.", "id": "investigation.CBP-088-05.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/029_invention_assignments_source_export.json to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-088-05.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/041_licenses_out_source_export.md.", "id": "investigation.CBP-088-05.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-088-05 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is the operational record relies on a superseded control revision.", "id": "decision.CBP-088-05.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-088-05 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-088-05.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-088-06 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_patents/006_patents_source_export.xml rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-088-06.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_copyrights/018_copyrights_source_export.txt for inventor assignment gap.", "id": "investigation.CBP-088-06.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/030_invention_assignments_source_export.xml to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-088-06.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/042_licenses_out_source_export.txt.", "id": "investigation.CBP-088-06.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-088-06 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-088-06.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-088-06 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-088-06.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-088-07 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_patents/007_patents_source_export.html rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-088-07.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_copyrights/019_copyrights_source_export.eml for coexistence restriction.", "id": "investigation.CBP-088-07.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/031_invention_assignments_source_export.html to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-088-07.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/043_licenses_out_source_export.eml.", "id": "investigation.CBP-088-07.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-088-07 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-088-07.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-088-07 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-088-07.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-088-08 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_patents/008_patents_source_export.pdf rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-088-08.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_copyrights/020_copyrights_source_export.csv for copyleft distribution trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-088-08.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/032_invention_assignments_source_export.pdf to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-088-08.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/044_licenses_out_source_export.csv.", "id": "investigation.CBP-088-08.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-088-08 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-088-08.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-088-08 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-088-08.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-088-09 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_trademarks/009_trademarks_source_export.md rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-088-09.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_copyrights/021_copyrights_source_export.json for security-interest release gap.", "id": "investigation.CBP-088-09.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/033_licenses_in_source_export.md to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-088-09.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/045_licenses_out_source_export.json.", "id": "investigation.CBP-088-09.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-088-09 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-088-09.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-088-09 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-088-09.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-088-10 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_trademarks/010_trademarks_source_export.txt rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-088-10.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_copyrights/022_copyrights_source_export.xml for trademark specimen issue.", "id": "investigation.CBP-088-10.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/034_licenses_in_source_export.txt to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-088-10.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/046_licenses_out_source_export.xml.", "id": "investigation.CBP-088-10.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-088-10 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key.", "id": "decision.CBP-088-10.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-088-10 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-088-10.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-088-11 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_trademarks/011_trademarks_source_export.eml rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-088-11.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_copyrights/023_copyrights_source_export.html for outbound sublicense overreach.", "id": "investigation.CBP-088-11.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/035_licenses_in_source_export.eml to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-088-11.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/047_licenses_out_source_export.html.", "id": "investigation.CBP-088-11.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-088-11 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-088-11.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-088-11 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-088-11.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-088-12 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_trademarks/012_trademarks_source_export.csv rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-088-12.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_copyrights/024_copyrights_source_export.pdf for cease-and-desist deadline.", "id": "investigation.CBP-088-12.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/036_licenses_in_source_export.csv to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-088-12.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/048_licenses_out_source_export.pdf.", "id": "investigation.CBP-088-12.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-088-12 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-088-12.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-088-12 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-088-12.register"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Write the exact selected option, supported action population, evidence-hold population, facts, owners, deadlines, and citations.", "id": "state.exact_decision"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create one exact register row per portfolio key with no extra, missing, or modified row.", "id": "state.exact_register"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Leave only the three approved deliverables and perform no extra state-changing write.", "id": "state.write_scope_containment"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Read back decision.json, matter-register.json, and advice.md after their final writes.", "id": "state.postwrite_readback"}, {"category": "answer", "description": "Explain the selected recommendation, supported actions, holds, alternatives, and limitations with exact source anchors.", "id": "answer.decision_note"}], "decision_options": [{"approach": "Apply the exact identity, current-state, authority, and revision test. Create trait-asset rows with exact restrictions and cure paths.", "id": "hinterland-agri:scoped-evidence", "label": "Use or condition only assets with a supported rights chain and resolved restrictions."}, {"approach": "Use a plausible summary or one source without completing the controlling joins.", "id": "hinterland-agri:shortcut", "label": "Treat patent ownership as overriding grant, material, and lien obligations."}, {"approach": "Treat supported actions and genuinely ambiguous records as if they were equally unresolved.", "id": "hinterland-agri:blanket-hold", "label": "Freeze the entire matter population"}], "evaluation_narrative": {"authority": "Grant obligations, material terms, field restrictions, and recorded liens all apply to exact assets.", "observation": "Join patent families, materials, grants, field trials, security interests, and releases by trait and entity.", "question": "Which Hinterland seed assets are usable given grant, field, material, and lien restrictions?", "register_action": "Create trait-asset rows with exact restrictions and cure paths."}, "gates": ["all_required_evidence_precedes_first_write", "decision_criteria_complete", "register_state_exact", "write_scope_contained", "all_outputs_verified_by_readback"], "metadata_checks": 11, "metric": "weighted_criteria_score", "minimum_tool_calls": 91, "required_deliverables": ["decision.json", "matter-register.json", "advice.md"], "required_document_reads": 64, "type": "deterministic", "weights": {"advice": 0.15, "decision": 0.35, "investigation": 0.25, "state": 0.25}}, "task_id": "cb100-088-hinterland-agri", "task_name": "Hinterland seed technology title audit", "world_id": "counselbench-filesystem-mcp-v3"}
+{"context_files": ["task_files/cb100-089-ionwave-semi/01_patents/001_patents_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-089-ionwave-semi/01_patents/002_patents_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-089-ionwave-semi/01_patents/003_patents_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-089-ionwave-semi/01_patents/004_patents_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-089-ionwave-semi/01_patents/005_patents_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-089-ionwave-semi/01_patents/006_patents_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-089-ionwave-semi/01_patents/007_patents_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-089-ionwave-semi/01_patents/008_patents_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-089-ionwave-semi/02_trademarks/009_trademarks_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-089-ionwave-semi/02_trademarks/010_trademarks_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-089-ionwave-semi/02_trademarks/011_trademarks_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-089-ionwave-semi/02_trademarks/012_trademarks_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-089-ionwave-semi/02_trademarks/013_trademarks_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-089-ionwave-semi/02_trademarks/014_trademarks_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-089-ionwave-semi/02_trademarks/015_trademarks_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-089-ionwave-semi/02_trademarks/016_trademarks_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-089-ionwave-semi/03_copyrights/017_copyrights_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-089-ionwave-semi/03_copyrights/018_copyrights_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-089-ionwave-semi/03_copyrights/019_copyrights_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-089-ionwave-semi/03_copyrights/020_copyrights_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-089-ionwave-semi/03_copyrights/021_copyrights_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-089-ionwave-semi/03_copyrights/022_copyrights_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-089-ionwave-semi/03_copyrights/023_copyrights_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-089-ionwave-semi/03_copyrights/024_copyrights_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-089-ionwave-semi/04_invention_assignments/025_invention_assignments_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-089-ionwave-semi/04_invention_assignments/026_invention_assignments_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-089-ionwave-semi/04_invention_assignments/027_invention_assignments_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-089-ionwave-semi/04_invention_assignments/028_invention_assignments_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-089-ionwave-semi/04_invention_assignments/029_invention_assignments_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-089-ionwave-semi/04_invention_assignments/030_invention_assignments_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-089-ionwave-semi/04_invention_assignments/031_invention_assignments_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-089-ionwave-semi/04_invention_assignments/032_invention_assignments_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-089-ionwave-semi/05_licenses_in/033_licenses_in_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-089-ionwave-semi/05_licenses_in/034_licenses_in_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-089-ionwave-semi/05_licenses_in/035_licenses_in_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-089-ionwave-semi/05_licenses_in/036_licenses_in_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-089-ionwave-semi/05_licenses_in/037_licenses_in_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-089-ionwave-semi/05_licenses_in/038_licenses_in_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-089-ionwave-semi/05_licenses_in/039_licenses_in_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-089-ionwave-semi/05_licenses_in/040_licenses_in_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-089-ionwave-semi/06_licenses_out/041_licenses_out_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-089-ionwave-semi/06_licenses_out/042_licenses_out_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-089-ionwave-semi/06_licenses_out/043_licenses_out_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-089-ionwave-semi/06_licenses_out/044_licenses_out_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-089-ionwave-semi/06_licenses_out/045_licenses_out_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-089-ionwave-semi/06_licenses_out/046_licenses_out_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-089-ionwave-semi/06_licenses_out/047_licenses_out_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-089-ionwave-semi/06_licenses_out/048_licenses_out_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-089-ionwave-semi/07_open_source/049_open_source_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-089-ionwave-semi/07_open_source/050_open_source_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-089-ionwave-semi/07_open_source/051_open_source_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-089-ionwave-semi/07_open_source/052_open_source_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-089-ionwave-semi/07_open_source/053_open_source_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-089-ionwave-semi/07_open_source/054_open_source_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-089-ionwave-semi/07_open_source/055_open_source_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-089-ionwave-semi/07_open_source/056_open_source_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-089-ionwave-semi/08_domain_accounts/057_domain_accounts_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-089-ionwave-semi/08_domain_accounts/058_domain_accounts_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-089-ionwave-semi/08_domain_accounts/059_domain_accounts_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-089-ionwave-semi/08_domain_accounts/060_domain_accounts_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-089-ionwave-semi/08_domain_accounts/061_domain_accounts_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-089-ionwave-semi/08_domain_accounts/062_domain_accounts_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-089-ionwave-semi/08_domain_accounts/063_domain_accounts_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-089-ionwave-semi/08_domain_accounts/064_domain_accounts_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-089-ionwave-semi/09_development_records/065_development_records_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-089-ionwave-semi/09_development_records/066_development_records_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-089-ionwave-semi/09_development_records/067_development_records_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-089-ionwave-semi/09_development_records/068_development_records_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-089-ionwave-semi/09_development_records/069_development_records_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-089-ionwave-semi/09_development_records/070_development_records_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-089-ionwave-semi/09_development_records/071_development_records_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-089-ionwave-semi/09_development_records/072_development_records_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-089-ionwave-semi/10_disputes/073_disputes_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-089-ionwave-semi/10_disputes/074_disputes_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-089-ionwave-semi/10_disputes/075_disputes_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-089-ionwave-semi/10_disputes/076_disputes_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-089-ionwave-semi/10_disputes/077_disputes_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-089-ionwave-semi/10_disputes/078_disputes_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-089-ionwave-semi/10_disputes/079_disputes_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-089-ionwave-semi/10_disputes/080_disputes_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-089-ionwave-semi/11_maintenance/081_maintenance_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-089-ionwave-semi/11_maintenance/082_maintenance_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-089-ionwave-semi/11_maintenance/083_maintenance_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-089-ionwave-semi/11_maintenance/084_maintenance_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-089-ionwave-semi/11_maintenance/085_maintenance_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-089-ionwave-semi/11_maintenance/086_maintenance_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-089-ionwave-semi/11_maintenance/087_maintenance_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-089-ionwave-semi/11_maintenance/088_maintenance_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-089-ionwave-semi/12_security_interests/089_security_interests_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-089-ionwave-semi/12_security_interests/090_security_interests_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-089-ionwave-semi/12_security_interests/091_security_interests_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-089-ionwave-semi/12_security_interests/092_security_interests_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-089-ionwave-semi/12_security_interests/093_security_interests_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-089-ionwave-semi/12_security_interests/094_security_interests_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-089-ionwave-semi/12_security_interests/095_security_interests_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-089-ionwave-semi/12_security_interests/096_security_interests_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-089-ionwave-semi/12_security_interests/097_ionwave_semi_impact_population.xlsx"], "gold_output": {"advice_markdown": "# Decision note — IonWave semiconductor portfolio check\n\n## Recommendation\n\nCure supported title, access, or fee gaps by exact design or family. The reconciled record supports 7 scoped actions and leaves 5 items on evidence hold.\n\nSelected option: `ionwave-semi:scoped-evidence`.\n\n## Why this is the supported option\n\nJoin contributors, foundry terms, file access, export scope, patent records, and fee dates by design. Executed assignments, foundry licenses, export controls, and maintenance status govern independently.\n\n## Supported actions\n\n### CBP-089-01 — inbound-license field restriction (medium)\n\ncompletion is required by 2025-06-24 under CB-IP-3209-R869; the current event record shows completion on 2025-07-06 under CB-IP-3209-E304. Identity resolves to ENT-089-1000, revision REV-2025.1 is current, and Elliot Mercer is active with capacity 2.\n\nAction: Create design-family rows with scoped actions and identity holds. Owner: Elliot Mercer; due 2026-10-01.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_patents/001_patents_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/02_trademarks/013_trademarks_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/025_invention_assignments_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/037_licenses_in_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/08_domain_accounts/061_domain_accounts_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/097_ionwave_semi_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-089-02 — repository access anomaly (high)\n\nthe controlling threshold is 16% under CB-IP-3209-R665; the independently calculated result is 24% under CB-IP-3209-E874. Identity resolves to ENT-089-1001, revision REV-2025.2 is current, and Sofia Bennett is active with capacity 5.\n\nAction: Create design-family rows with scoped actions and identity holds. Owner: Sofia Bennett; due 2026-09-30.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_patents/002_patents_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/02_trademarks/014_trademarks_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/026_invention_assignments_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/038_licenses_in_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/07_open_source/050_open_source_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/097_ionwave_semi_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-089-07 — work-for-hire defect (medium)\n\ndelivery must use notices-ionwave_semiconductor@example.test under CB-IP-3209-R547; the only matched receipt used archive-kiyomizu_design_kk@example.test under CB-IP-3209-E443. Identity resolves to ENT-089-1006, revision REV-2025.7 is current, and Samuel Kim is active with capacity 5.\n\nAction: Create design-family rows with scoped actions and identity holds. Owner: Samuel Kim; due 2026-09-25.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_patents/007_patents_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/03_copyrights/019_copyrights_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/031_invention_assignments_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/043_licenses_out_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/097_ionwave_semi_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-089-09 — inventor assignment gap (high)\n\ncompletion is required by 2026-02-15 under CB-IP-3209-R865; the current event record shows completion on 2026-03-03 under CB-IP-3209-E780. Identity resolves to ENT-089-1008, revision REV-2025.2 is current, and Adrian Mensah is active with capacity 6.\n\nAction: Create design-family rows with scoped actions and identity holds. Owner: Adrian Mensah; due 2026-09-23.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/02_trademarks/009_trademarks_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/03_copyrights/021_copyrights_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/033_licenses_in_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/045_licenses_out_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/09_development_records/069_development_records_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/097_ionwave_semi_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-089-10 — coexistence restriction (medium)\n\nthe controlling threshold is 16% under CB-IP-3209-R207; the independently calculated result is 24% under CB-IP-3209-E371. Identity resolves to ENT-089-1009, revision REV-2025.3 is current, and Farah Ibrahim is active with capacity 6.\n\nAction: Create design-family rows with scoped actions and identity holds. Owner: Farah Ibrahim; due 2026-10-01.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/02_trademarks/010_trademarks_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/03_copyrights/022_copyrights_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/034_licenses_in_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/046_licenses_out_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/097_ionwave_semi_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-089-11 — copyleft distribution trigger (medium)\n\napproval must come from Lena Varga under CB-IP-3209-R177; the effective approval record names Rafael Okafor under CB-IP-3209-E951. Identity resolves to ENT-089-1010, revision REV-2025.4 is current, and Dominic Alvarez is active with capacity 1.\n\nAction: Create design-family rows with scoped actions and identity holds. Owner: Dominic Alvarez; due 2026-09-30.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/02_trademarks/011_trademarks_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/03_copyrights/023_copyrights_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/035_licenses_in_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/047_licenses_out_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/097_ionwave_semi_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-089-12 — security-interest release gap (low)\n\nthe controlled population contains 134 records under CB-IP-3209-R922; the certification covers 112 records under CB-IP-3209-E783. Identity resolves to ENT-089-1011, revision REV-2025.5 is current, and Leona Park is active with capacity 2.\n\nAction: Create design-family rows with scoped actions and identity holds. Owner: Leona Park; due 2026-09-29.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/02_trademarks/012_trademarks_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/03_copyrights/024_copyrights_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/036_licenses_in_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/048_licenses_out_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/097_ionwave_semi_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n## Evidence holds\n\n- **CBP-089-03 — maintenance-fee deadline**: the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective. Next evidence: effective approval and an active owner with remaining capacity. Sources: `/workspace/documents/01_patents/003_patents_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/02_trademarks/015_trademarks_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/027_invention_assignments_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/039_licenses_in_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/08_domain_accounts/063_domain_accounts_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/097_ionwave_semi_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-089-04 — source-code ownership gap**: the operational record relies on a superseded control revision. Next evidence: an operational record using the current effective revision. Sources: `/workspace/documents/01_patents/004_patents_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/02_trademarks/016_trademarks_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/028_invention_assignments_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/040_licenses_in_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/10_disputes/076_disputes_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/097_ionwave_semi_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-089-05 — domain registrant mismatch**: two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key. Next evidence: an approved immutable entity crosswalk. Sources: `/workspace/documents/01_patents/005_patents_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/03_copyrights/017_copyrights_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/029_invention_assignments_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/041_licenses_out_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/10_disputes/077_disputes_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/07_open_source/053_open_source_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/097_ionwave_semi_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-089-06 — recorded-owner mismatch**: the current observation does not meet the operative trigger. Next evidence: a current observation that satisfies the operative trigger. Sources: `/workspace/documents/01_patents/006_patents_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/03_copyrights/018_copyrights_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/030_invention_assignments_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/042_licenses_out_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/090_security_interests_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/07_open_source/054_open_source_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/097_ionwave_semi_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-089-08 — notice-file omission**: the operational record relies on a superseded control revision. Next evidence: an operational record using the current effective revision. Sources: `/workspace/documents/01_patents/008_patents_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/03_copyrights/020_copyrights_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/032_invention_assignments_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/044_licenses_out_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/07_open_source/056_open_source_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/10_disputes/080_disputes_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/097_ionwave_semi_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n## Alternatives considered\n\n- `ionwave-semi:shortcut` — Treat employee email domains and current foundry production as sufficient rights evidence.: Use a plausible summary or one source without completing the controlling joins.\n- `ionwave-semi:blanket-hold` — Freeze the entire matter population: Treat supported actions and genuinely ambiguous records as if they were equally unresolved.\n\n## Assumptions and limits\n\nThis decision is limited to cb100-089-ionwave-semi, the supplied synthetic records, and the matter state as of 2026-10-02. Similar names, stale revisions, and pending authority are not treated as proof.\n", "decision": {"actions": [{"determination": "completion is required by 2025-06-24 under CB-IP-3209-R869; the current event record shows completion on 2025-07-06 under CB-IP-3209-E304. Identity resolves to ENT-089-1000, revision REV-2025.1 is current, and Elliot Mercer is active with capacity 2.", "due_date": "2026-10-01", "id": "ACT-CBP-089-01", "identity_id": "ENT-089-1000", "issue": "inbound-license field restriction", "owner": "Elliot Mercer", "portfolio_key": "CBP-089-01", "recommended_action": "Create design-family rows with scoped actions and identity holds. Owner: Elliot Mercer; due 2026-10-01.", "severity": "medium", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_patents/001_patents_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/02_trademarks/013_trademarks_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/025_invention_assignments_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/037_licenses_in_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/08_domain_accounts/061_domain_accounts_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/097_ionwave_semi_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "the controlling threshold is 16% under CB-IP-3209-R665; the independently calculated result is 24% under CB-IP-3209-E874. Identity resolves to ENT-089-1001, revision REV-2025.2 is current, and Sofia Bennett is active with capacity 5.", "due_date": "2026-09-30", "id": "ACT-CBP-089-02", "identity_id": "ENT-089-1001", "issue": "repository access anomaly", "owner": "Sofia Bennett", "portfolio_key": "CBP-089-02", "recommended_action": "Create design-family rows with scoped actions and identity holds. Owner: Sofia Bennett; due 2026-09-30.", "severity": "high", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_patents/002_patents_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/02_trademarks/014_trademarks_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/026_invention_assignments_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/038_licenses_in_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/07_open_source/050_open_source_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/097_ionwave_semi_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "delivery must use notices-ionwave_semiconductor@example.test under CB-IP-3209-R547; the only matched receipt used archive-kiyomizu_design_kk@example.test under CB-IP-3209-E443. Identity resolves to ENT-089-1006, revision REV-2025.7 is current, and Samuel Kim is active with capacity 5.", "due_date": "2026-09-25", "id": "ACT-CBP-089-07", "identity_id": "ENT-089-1006", "issue": "work-for-hire defect", "owner": "Samuel Kim", "portfolio_key": "CBP-089-07", "recommended_action": "Create design-family rows with scoped actions and identity holds. Owner: Samuel Kim; due 2026-09-25.", "severity": "medium", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_patents/007_patents_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/03_copyrights/019_copyrights_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/031_invention_assignments_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/043_licenses_out_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/097_ionwave_semi_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "completion is required by 2026-02-15 under CB-IP-3209-R865; the current event record shows completion on 2026-03-03 under CB-IP-3209-E780. Identity resolves to ENT-089-1008, revision REV-2025.2 is current, and Adrian Mensah is active with capacity 6.", "due_date": "2026-09-23", "id": "ACT-CBP-089-09", "identity_id": "ENT-089-1008", "issue": "inventor assignment gap", "owner": "Adrian Mensah", "portfolio_key": "CBP-089-09", "recommended_action": "Create design-family rows with scoped actions and identity holds. Owner: Adrian Mensah; due 2026-09-23.", "severity": "high", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_trademarks/009_trademarks_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/03_copyrights/021_copyrights_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/033_licenses_in_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/045_licenses_out_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/09_development_records/069_development_records_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/097_ionwave_semi_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "the controlling threshold is 16% under CB-IP-3209-R207; the independently calculated result is 24% under CB-IP-3209-E371. Identity resolves to ENT-089-1009, revision REV-2025.3 is current, and Farah Ibrahim is active with capacity 6.", "due_date": "2026-10-01", "id": "ACT-CBP-089-10", "identity_id": "ENT-089-1009", "issue": "coexistence restriction", "owner": "Farah Ibrahim", "portfolio_key": "CBP-089-10", "recommended_action": "Create design-family rows with scoped actions and identity holds. Owner: Farah Ibrahim; due 2026-10-01.", "severity": "medium", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_trademarks/010_trademarks_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/03_copyrights/022_copyrights_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/034_licenses_in_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/046_licenses_out_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/097_ionwave_semi_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "approval must come from Lena Varga under CB-IP-3209-R177; the effective approval record names Rafael Okafor under CB-IP-3209-E951. Identity resolves to ENT-089-1010, revision REV-2025.4 is current, and Dominic Alvarez is active with capacity 1.", "due_date": "2026-09-30", "id": "ACT-CBP-089-11", "identity_id": "ENT-089-1010", "issue": "copyleft distribution trigger", "owner": "Dominic Alvarez", "portfolio_key": "CBP-089-11", "recommended_action": "Create design-family rows with scoped actions and identity holds. Owner: Dominic Alvarez; due 2026-09-30.", "severity": "medium", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_trademarks/011_trademarks_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/03_copyrights/023_copyrights_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/035_licenses_in_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/047_licenses_out_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/097_ionwave_semi_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "the controlled population contains 134 records under CB-IP-3209-R922; the certification covers 112 records under CB-IP-3209-E783. Identity resolves to ENT-089-1011, revision REV-2025.5 is current, and Leona Park is active with capacity 2.", "due_date": "2026-09-29", "id": "ACT-CBP-089-12", "identity_id": "ENT-089-1011", "issue": "security-interest release gap", "owner": "Leona Park", "portfolio_key": "CBP-089-12", "recommended_action": "Create design-family rows with scoped actions and identity holds. Owner: Leona Park; due 2026-09-29.", "severity": "low", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_trademarks/012_trademarks_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/03_copyrights/024_copyrights_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/036_licenses_in_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/048_licenses_out_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/097_ionwave_semi_impact_population.xlsx"]}], "as_of": "2026-10-02", "decision": {"alternatives_considered": ["ionwave-semi:shortcut", "ionwave-semi:blanket-hold"], "question": "Which IonWave designs and patents require assignment, export, license, or maintenance action?", "rationale": "The four-part causal test supports 7 scoped actions and leaves 5 records on evidence hold. Executed assignments, foundry licenses, export controls, and maintenance status govern independently.", "recommendation": "Cure supported title, access, or fee gaps by exact design or family.", "selected_option_id": "ionwave-semi:scoped-evidence"}, "holds": [{"id": "HOLD-CBP-089-03", "issue": "maintenance-fee deadline", "portfolio_key": "CBP-089-03", "reason": "the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective", "required_next_evidence": "effective approval and an active owner with remaining capacity", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_patents/003_patents_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/02_trademarks/015_trademarks_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/027_invention_assignments_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/039_licenses_in_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/08_domain_accounts/063_domain_accounts_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/097_ionwave_semi_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-089-04", "issue": "source-code ownership gap", "portfolio_key": "CBP-089-04", "reason": "the operational record relies on a superseded control revision", "required_next_evidence": "an operational record using the current effective revision", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_patents/004_patents_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/02_trademarks/016_trademarks_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/028_invention_assignments_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/040_licenses_in_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/10_disputes/076_disputes_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/097_ionwave_semi_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-089-05", "issue": "domain registrant mismatch", "portfolio_key": "CBP-089-05", "reason": "two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key", "required_next_evidence": "an approved immutable entity crosswalk", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_patents/005_patents_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/03_copyrights/017_copyrights_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/029_invention_assignments_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/041_licenses_out_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/10_disputes/077_disputes_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/07_open_source/053_open_source_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/097_ionwave_semi_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-089-06", "issue": "recorded-owner mismatch", "portfolio_key": "CBP-089-06", "reason": "the current observation does not meet the operative trigger", "required_next_evidence": "a current observation that satisfies the operative trigger", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_patents/006_patents_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/03_copyrights/018_copyrights_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/030_invention_assignments_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/042_licenses_out_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/090_security_interests_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/07_open_source/054_open_source_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/097_ionwave_semi_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-089-08", "issue": "notice-file omission", "portfolio_key": "CBP-089-08", "reason": "the operational record relies on a superseded control revision", "required_next_evidence": "an operational record using the current effective revision", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_patents/008_patents_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/03_copyrights/020_copyrights_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/032_invention_assignments_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/044_licenses_out_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/07_open_source/056_open_source_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/10_disputes/080_disputes_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/097_ionwave_semi_impact_population.xlsx"]}], "matter_number": "CB-IP-3209", "prepared_for": "IonWave Semiconductor", "schema_version": "counselbench.decision.v3", "task_id": "cb100-089-ionwave-semi"}, "matter_register": {"matter_number": "CB-IP-3209", "rows": [{"decision_option_id": "ionwave-semi:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-10-01", "issue": "inbound-license field restriction", "matter_number": "CB-IP-3209", "owner": "Elliot Mercer", "portfolio_key": "CBP-089-01", "row_id": "REG-CBP-089-01", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_patents/001_patents_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/02_trademarks/013_trademarks_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/025_invention_assignments_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/037_licenses_in_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/08_domain_accounts/061_domain_accounts_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/097_ionwave_semi_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "ionwave-semi:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-30", "issue": "repository access anomaly", "matter_number": "CB-IP-3209", "owner": "Sofia Bennett", "portfolio_key": "CBP-089-02", "row_id": "REG-CBP-089-02", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_patents/002_patents_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/02_trademarks/014_trademarks_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/026_invention_assignments_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/038_licenses_in_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/07_open_source/050_open_source_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/097_ionwave_semi_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "ionwave-semi:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective", "issue": "maintenance-fee deadline", "matter_number": "CB-IP-3209", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-089-03", "row_id": "REG-CBP-089-03", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_patents/003_patents_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/02_trademarks/015_trademarks_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/027_invention_assignments_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/039_licenses_in_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/08_domain_accounts/063_domain_accounts_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/097_ionwave_semi_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "ionwave-semi:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "the operational record relies on a superseded control revision", "issue": "source-code ownership gap", "matter_number": "CB-IP-3209", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-089-04", "row_id": "REG-CBP-089-04", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_patents/004_patents_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/02_trademarks/016_trademarks_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/028_invention_assignments_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/040_licenses_in_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/10_disputes/076_disputes_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/097_ionwave_semi_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "ionwave-semi:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key", "issue": "domain registrant mismatch", "matter_number": "CB-IP-3209", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-089-05", "row_id": "REG-CBP-089-05", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_patents/005_patents_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/03_copyrights/017_copyrights_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/029_invention_assignments_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/041_licenses_out_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/10_disputes/077_disputes_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/07_open_source/053_open_source_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/097_ionwave_semi_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "ionwave-semi:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "the current observation does not meet the operative trigger", "issue": "recorded-owner mismatch", "matter_number": "CB-IP-3209", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-089-06", "row_id": "REG-CBP-089-06", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_patents/006_patents_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/03_copyrights/018_copyrights_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/030_invention_assignments_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/042_licenses_out_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/090_security_interests_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/07_open_source/054_open_source_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/097_ionwave_semi_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "ionwave-semi:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-25", "issue": "work-for-hire defect", "matter_number": "CB-IP-3209", "owner": "Samuel Kim", "portfolio_key": "CBP-089-07", "row_id": "REG-CBP-089-07", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_patents/007_patents_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/03_copyrights/019_copyrights_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/031_invention_assignments_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/043_licenses_out_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/097_ionwave_semi_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "ionwave-semi:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "the operational record relies on a superseded control revision", "issue": "notice-file omission", "matter_number": "CB-IP-3209", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-089-08", "row_id": "REG-CBP-089-08", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_patents/008_patents_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/03_copyrights/020_copyrights_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/032_invention_assignments_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/044_licenses_out_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/07_open_source/056_open_source_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/10_disputes/080_disputes_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/097_ionwave_semi_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "ionwave-semi:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-23", "issue": "inventor assignment gap", "matter_number": "CB-IP-3209", "owner": "Adrian Mensah", "portfolio_key": "CBP-089-09", "row_id": "REG-CBP-089-09", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_trademarks/009_trademarks_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/03_copyrights/021_copyrights_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/033_licenses_in_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/045_licenses_out_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/09_development_records/069_development_records_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/097_ionwave_semi_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "ionwave-semi:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-10-01", "issue": "coexistence restriction", "matter_number": "CB-IP-3209", "owner": "Farah Ibrahim", "portfolio_key": "CBP-089-10", "row_id": "REG-CBP-089-10", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_trademarks/010_trademarks_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/03_copyrights/022_copyrights_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/034_licenses_in_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/046_licenses_out_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/097_ionwave_semi_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "ionwave-semi:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-30", "issue": "copyleft distribution trigger", "matter_number": "CB-IP-3209", "owner": "Dominic Alvarez", "portfolio_key": "CBP-089-11", "row_id": "REG-CBP-089-11", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_trademarks/011_trademarks_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/03_copyrights/023_copyrights_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/035_licenses_in_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/047_licenses_out_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/097_ionwave_semi_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "ionwave-semi:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-29", "issue": "security-interest release gap", "matter_number": "CB-IP-3209", "owner": "Leona Park", "portfolio_key": "CBP-089-12", "row_id": "REG-CBP-089-12", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_trademarks/012_trademarks_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/03_copyrights/024_copyrights_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/036_licenses_in_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/048_licenses_out_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/097_ionwave_semi_impact_population.xlsx"]}], "schema_version": "counselbench.matter-register.v3", "task_id": "cb100-089-ionwave-semi"}}, "metadata": {"benchmark": "CounselBench-100", "code_license": "Apache-2.0", "data_license": "CC-BY-4.0", "deadline": "2026-10-02", "document_count": 97, "evidence_holds": 5, "jurisdiction": "Texas", "matter_number": "CB-IP-3209", "mcp_commit": "9a96ea6e5913736f92b88345bf51caeaaa8e719f", "mcp_package": "@modelcontextprotocol/server-filesystem@2026.7.10", "practice_area": "ip-technology", "reference_tool_calls": 83, "required_evidence_reads": 61, "supported_actions": 7, "synthetic": true, "venue": "Western District of Texas", "version": "3.1.0"}, "prompt": "Please take ownership of the open question before the deadline. Which IonWave designs and patents require assignment, export, license, or maintenance action? Chip designs rely on foreign contractors, foundry licenses, export-controlled files, and patents with approaching maintenance dates. The team needs the call by 2026-10-02. Give me a decision-ready note and make the corresponding matter-register entries, without guessing through missing records.", "rubric": {"criteria": [{"category": "investigation", "description": "Inventory the production and use targeted searches to locate records across native formats.", "id": "investigation.discover_production"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Complete every task-specific identity, authority, operations, and approval read before the first state transition.", "id": "investigation.read_before_write"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Inspect designated source metadata before relying on those records.", "id": "investigation.custody_before_write"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "Select the supported option 'ionwave-semi:scoped-evidence' after applying the four-part test.", "id": "decision.selected_option"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "Identify both rejected approaches and explain why a one-source shortcut and a blanket hold are wrong.", "id": "decision.alternatives"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-089-01 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_patents/001_patents_source_export.md rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-089-01.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_trademarks/013_trademarks_source_export.json for inbound-license field restriction.", "id": "investigation.CBP-089-01.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/025_invention_assignments_source_export.md to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-089-01.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/037_licenses_in_source_export.json.", "id": "investigation.CBP-089-01.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-089-01 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-089-01.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-089-01 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-089-01.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-089-02 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_patents/002_patents_source_export.txt rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-089-02.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_trademarks/014_trademarks_source_export.xml for repository access anomaly.", "id": "investigation.CBP-089-02.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/026_invention_assignments_source_export.txt to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-089-02.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/038_licenses_in_source_export.xml.", "id": "investigation.CBP-089-02.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-089-02 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-089-02.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-089-02 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-089-02.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-089-03 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_patents/003_patents_source_export.eml rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-089-03.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_trademarks/015_trademarks_source_export.html for maintenance-fee deadline.", "id": "investigation.CBP-089-03.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/027_invention_assignments_source_export.eml to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-089-03.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/039_licenses_in_source_export.html.", "id": "investigation.CBP-089-03.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-089-03 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective.", "id": "decision.CBP-089-03.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-089-03 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-089-03.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-089-04 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_patents/004_patents_source_export.csv rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-089-04.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_trademarks/016_trademarks_source_export.pdf for source-code ownership gap.", "id": "investigation.CBP-089-04.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/028_invention_assignments_source_export.csv to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-089-04.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/040_licenses_in_source_export.pdf.", "id": "investigation.CBP-089-04.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-089-04 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is the operational record relies on a superseded control revision.", "id": "decision.CBP-089-04.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-089-04 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-089-04.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-089-05 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_patents/005_patents_source_export.json rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-089-05.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_copyrights/017_copyrights_source_export.md for domain registrant mismatch.", "id": "investigation.CBP-089-05.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/029_invention_assignments_source_export.json to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-089-05.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/041_licenses_out_source_export.md.", "id": "investigation.CBP-089-05.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-089-05 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key.", "id": "decision.CBP-089-05.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-089-05 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-089-05.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-089-06 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_patents/006_patents_source_export.xml rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-089-06.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_copyrights/018_copyrights_source_export.txt for recorded-owner mismatch.", "id": "investigation.CBP-089-06.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/030_invention_assignments_source_export.xml to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-089-06.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/042_licenses_out_source_export.txt.", "id": "investigation.CBP-089-06.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-089-06 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is the current observation does not meet the operative trigger.", "id": "decision.CBP-089-06.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-089-06 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-089-06.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-089-07 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_patents/007_patents_source_export.html rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-089-07.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_copyrights/019_copyrights_source_export.eml for work-for-hire defect.", "id": "investigation.CBP-089-07.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/031_invention_assignments_source_export.html to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-089-07.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/043_licenses_out_source_export.eml.", "id": "investigation.CBP-089-07.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-089-07 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-089-07.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-089-07 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-089-07.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-089-08 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_patents/008_patents_source_export.pdf rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-089-08.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_copyrights/020_copyrights_source_export.csv for notice-file omission.", "id": "investigation.CBP-089-08.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/032_invention_assignments_source_export.pdf to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-089-08.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/044_licenses_out_source_export.csv.", "id": "investigation.CBP-089-08.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-089-08 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is the operational record relies on a superseded control revision.", "id": "decision.CBP-089-08.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-089-08 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-089-08.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-089-09 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_trademarks/009_trademarks_source_export.md rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-089-09.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_copyrights/021_copyrights_source_export.json for inventor assignment gap.", "id": "investigation.CBP-089-09.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/033_licenses_in_source_export.md to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-089-09.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/045_licenses_out_source_export.json.", "id": "investigation.CBP-089-09.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-089-09 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-089-09.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-089-09 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-089-09.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-089-10 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_trademarks/010_trademarks_source_export.txt rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-089-10.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_copyrights/022_copyrights_source_export.xml for coexistence restriction.", "id": "investigation.CBP-089-10.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/034_licenses_in_source_export.txt to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-089-10.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/046_licenses_out_source_export.xml.", "id": "investigation.CBP-089-10.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-089-10 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-089-10.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-089-10 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-089-10.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-089-11 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_trademarks/011_trademarks_source_export.eml rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-089-11.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_copyrights/023_copyrights_source_export.html for copyleft distribution trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-089-11.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/035_licenses_in_source_export.eml to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-089-11.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/047_licenses_out_source_export.html.", "id": "investigation.CBP-089-11.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-089-11 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-089-11.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-089-11 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-089-11.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-089-12 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_trademarks/012_trademarks_source_export.csv rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-089-12.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_copyrights/024_copyrights_source_export.pdf for security-interest release gap.", "id": "investigation.CBP-089-12.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/036_licenses_in_source_export.csv to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-089-12.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/048_licenses_out_source_export.pdf.", "id": "investigation.CBP-089-12.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-089-12 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-089-12.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-089-12 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-089-12.register"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Write the exact selected option, supported action population, evidence-hold population, facts, owners, deadlines, and citations.", "id": "state.exact_decision"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create one exact register row per portfolio key with no extra, missing, or modified row.", "id": "state.exact_register"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Leave only the three approved deliverables and perform no extra state-changing write.", "id": "state.write_scope_containment"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Read back decision.json, matter-register.json, and advice.md after their final writes.", "id": "state.postwrite_readback"}, {"category": "answer", "description": "Explain the selected recommendation, supported actions, holds, alternatives, and limitations with exact source anchors.", "id": "answer.decision_note"}], "decision_options": [{"approach": "Use a plausible summary or one source without completing the controlling joins.", "id": "ionwave-semi:shortcut", "label": "Treat employee email domains and current foundry production as sufficient rights evidence."}, {"approach": "Treat supported actions and genuinely ambiguous records as if they were equally unresolved.", "id": "ionwave-semi:blanket-hold", "label": "Freeze the entire matter population"}, {"approach": "Apply the exact identity, current-state, authority, and revision test. Create design-family rows with scoped actions and identity holds.", "id": "ionwave-semi:scoped-evidence", "label": "Cure supported title, access, or fee gaps by exact design or family."}], "evaluation_narrative": {"authority": "Executed assignments, foundry licenses, export controls, and maintenance status govern independently.", "observation": "Join contributors, foundry terms, file access, export scope, patent records, and fee dates by design.", "question": "Which IonWave designs and patents require assignment, export, license, or maintenance action?", "register_action": "Create design-family rows with scoped actions and identity holds."}, "gates": ["all_required_evidence_precedes_first_write", "decision_criteria_complete", "register_state_exact", "write_scope_contained", "all_outputs_verified_by_readback"], "metadata_checks": 9, "metric": "weighted_criteria_score", "minimum_tool_calls": 83, "required_deliverables": ["decision.json", "matter-register.json", "advice.md"], "required_document_reads": 61, "type": "deterministic", "weights": {"advice": 0.15, "decision": 0.35, "investigation": 0.25, "state": 0.25}}, "task_id": "cb100-089-ionwave-semi", "task_name": "IonWave semiconductor portfolio check", "world_id": "counselbench-filesystem-mcp-v3"}
+{"context_files": ["task_files/cb100-090-jagged-cloud/01_patents/001_patents_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-090-jagged-cloud/01_patents/002_patents_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-090-jagged-cloud/01_patents/003_patents_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-090-jagged-cloud/01_patents/004_patents_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-090-jagged-cloud/01_patents/005_patents_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-090-jagged-cloud/01_patents/006_patents_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-090-jagged-cloud/01_patents/007_patents_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-090-jagged-cloud/01_patents/008_patents_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-090-jagged-cloud/02_trademarks/009_trademarks_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-090-jagged-cloud/02_trademarks/010_trademarks_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-090-jagged-cloud/02_trademarks/011_trademarks_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-090-jagged-cloud/02_trademarks/012_trademarks_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-090-jagged-cloud/02_trademarks/013_trademarks_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-090-jagged-cloud/02_trademarks/014_trademarks_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-090-jagged-cloud/02_trademarks/015_trademarks_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-090-jagged-cloud/02_trademarks/016_trademarks_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-090-jagged-cloud/03_copyrights/017_copyrights_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-090-jagged-cloud/03_copyrights/018_copyrights_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-090-jagged-cloud/03_copyrights/019_copyrights_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-090-jagged-cloud/03_copyrights/020_copyrights_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-090-jagged-cloud/03_copyrights/021_copyrights_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-090-jagged-cloud/03_copyrights/022_copyrights_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-090-jagged-cloud/03_copyrights/023_copyrights_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-090-jagged-cloud/03_copyrights/024_copyrights_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-090-jagged-cloud/04_invention_assignments/025_invention_assignments_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-090-jagged-cloud/04_invention_assignments/026_invention_assignments_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-090-jagged-cloud/04_invention_assignments/027_invention_assignments_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-090-jagged-cloud/04_invention_assignments/028_invention_assignments_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-090-jagged-cloud/04_invention_assignments/029_invention_assignments_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-090-jagged-cloud/04_invention_assignments/030_invention_assignments_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-090-jagged-cloud/04_invention_assignments/031_invention_assignments_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-090-jagged-cloud/04_invention_assignments/032_invention_assignments_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-090-jagged-cloud/05_licenses_in/033_licenses_in_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-090-jagged-cloud/05_licenses_in/034_licenses_in_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-090-jagged-cloud/05_licenses_in/035_licenses_in_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-090-jagged-cloud/05_licenses_in/036_licenses_in_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-090-jagged-cloud/05_licenses_in/037_licenses_in_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-090-jagged-cloud/05_licenses_in/038_licenses_in_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-090-jagged-cloud/05_licenses_in/039_licenses_in_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-090-jagged-cloud/05_licenses_in/040_licenses_in_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-090-jagged-cloud/06_licenses_out/041_licenses_out_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-090-jagged-cloud/06_licenses_out/042_licenses_out_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-090-jagged-cloud/06_licenses_out/043_licenses_out_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-090-jagged-cloud/06_licenses_out/044_licenses_out_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-090-jagged-cloud/06_licenses_out/045_licenses_out_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-090-jagged-cloud/06_licenses_out/046_licenses_out_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-090-jagged-cloud/06_licenses_out/047_licenses_out_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-090-jagged-cloud/06_licenses_out/048_licenses_out_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-090-jagged-cloud/07_open_source/049_open_source_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-090-jagged-cloud/07_open_source/050_open_source_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-090-jagged-cloud/07_open_source/051_open_source_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-090-jagged-cloud/07_open_source/052_open_source_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-090-jagged-cloud/07_open_source/053_open_source_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-090-jagged-cloud/07_open_source/054_open_source_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-090-jagged-cloud/07_open_source/055_open_source_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-090-jagged-cloud/07_open_source/056_open_source_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-090-jagged-cloud/08_domain_accounts/057_domain_accounts_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-090-jagged-cloud/08_domain_accounts/058_domain_accounts_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-090-jagged-cloud/08_domain_accounts/059_domain_accounts_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-090-jagged-cloud/08_domain_accounts/060_domain_accounts_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-090-jagged-cloud/08_domain_accounts/061_domain_accounts_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-090-jagged-cloud/08_domain_accounts/062_domain_accounts_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-090-jagged-cloud/08_domain_accounts/063_domain_accounts_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-090-jagged-cloud/08_domain_accounts/064_domain_accounts_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-090-jagged-cloud/09_development_records/065_development_records_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-090-jagged-cloud/09_development_records/066_development_records_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-090-jagged-cloud/09_development_records/067_development_records_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-090-jagged-cloud/09_development_records/068_development_records_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-090-jagged-cloud/09_development_records/069_development_records_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-090-jagged-cloud/09_development_records/070_development_records_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-090-jagged-cloud/09_development_records/071_development_records_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-090-jagged-cloud/09_development_records/072_development_records_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-090-jagged-cloud/10_disputes/073_disputes_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-090-jagged-cloud/10_disputes/074_disputes_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-090-jagged-cloud/10_disputes/075_disputes_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-090-jagged-cloud/10_disputes/076_disputes_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-090-jagged-cloud/10_disputes/077_disputes_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-090-jagged-cloud/10_disputes/078_disputes_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-090-jagged-cloud/10_disputes/079_disputes_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-090-jagged-cloud/10_disputes/080_disputes_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-090-jagged-cloud/11_maintenance/081_maintenance_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-090-jagged-cloud/11_maintenance/082_maintenance_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-090-jagged-cloud/11_maintenance/083_maintenance_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-090-jagged-cloud/11_maintenance/084_maintenance_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-090-jagged-cloud/11_maintenance/085_maintenance_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-090-jagged-cloud/11_maintenance/086_maintenance_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-090-jagged-cloud/11_maintenance/087_maintenance_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-090-jagged-cloud/11_maintenance/088_maintenance_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-090-jagged-cloud/12_security_interests/089_security_interests_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-090-jagged-cloud/12_security_interests/090_security_interests_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-090-jagged-cloud/12_security_interests/091_security_interests_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-090-jagged-cloud/12_security_interests/092_security_interests_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-090-jagged-cloud/12_security_interests/093_security_interests_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-090-jagged-cloud/12_security_interests/094_security_interests_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-090-jagged-cloud/12_security_interests/095_security_interests_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-090-jagged-cloud/12_security_interests/096_security_interests_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-090-jagged-cloud/12_security_interests/097_jagged_cloud_impact_population.xlsx"], "gold_output": {"advice_markdown": "# Decision note — Jagged Cloud acquisition IP audit\n\n## Recommendation\n\nCondition closing on supported title, infringement, control, or release cures. The reconciled record supports 6 scoped actions and leaves 6 items on evidence hold.\n\nSelected option: `jagged-cloud:scoped-evidence`.\n\n## Why this is the supported option\n\nJoin fork lineage, contributors, assignments, assertions, domains, and lender releases by repository and asset. Exact code provenance, executed grants, account control, and released liens determine clean title.\n\n## Supported actions\n\n### CBP-090-05 — repository access anomaly (low)\n\nthe controlling threshold is 14% under CB-IP-3210-R317; the independently calculated result is 20% under CB-IP-3210-E801. Identity resolves to ENT-090-1004, revision REV-2026.5 is current, and Sofia Bennett is active with capacity 1.\n\nAction: Create repository-asset closing rows with exact evidence holds. Owner: Sofia Bennett; due 2026-10-01.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_patents/005_patents_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/03_copyrights/017_copyrights_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/029_invention_assignments_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/041_licenses_out_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/089_security_interests_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/097_jagged_cloud_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-090-06 — maintenance-fee deadline (high)\n\napproval must come from Mei Whitaker under CB-IP-3210-R277; the effective approval record names Rafael Okafor under CB-IP-3210-E428. Identity resolves to ENT-090-1005, revision REV-2026.6 is current, and Micah Sullivan is active with capacity 1.\n\nAction: Create repository-asset closing rows with exact evidence holds. Owner: Micah Sullivan; due 2026-09-30.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_patents/006_patents_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/03_copyrights/018_copyrights_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/030_invention_assignments_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/042_licenses_out_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/097_jagged_cloud_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-090-09 — recorded-owner mismatch (low)\n\nthe operative cap is $1,402,000.00 under CB-IP-3210-R579; the matched ledger population totals $1,613,479.00 under CB-IP-3210-E128. Identity resolves to ENT-090-1008, revision REV-2026.2 is current, and Amara Patel is active with capacity 3.\n\nAction: Create repository-asset closing rows with exact evidence holds. Owner: Amara Patel; due 2026-09-27.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/02_trademarks/009_trademarks_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/03_copyrights/021_copyrights_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/033_licenses_in_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/045_licenses_out_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/09_development_records/069_development_records_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/08_domain_accounts/057_domain_accounts_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/097_jagged_cloud_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-090-10 — work-for-hire defect (low)\n\ndelivery must use notices-jagged_cloud_infrastructure@example.test under CB-IP-3210-R507; the only matched receipt used archive-nimbus_fork_technologies@example.test under CB-IP-3210-E600. Identity resolves to ENT-090-1009, revision REV-2026.3 is current, and Samuel Kim is active with capacity 3.\n\nAction: Create repository-asset closing rows with exact evidence holds. Owner: Samuel Kim; due 2026-10-05.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/02_trademarks/010_trademarks_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/03_copyrights/022_copyrights_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/034_licenses_in_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/046_licenses_out_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/097_jagged_cloud_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-090-11 — notice-file omission (high)\n\nan open exception blocks completion under CB-IP-3210-R887; the current status is open and unresolved under CB-IP-3210-E199. Identity resolves to ENT-090-1010, revision REV-2026.4 is current, and Talia Brooks is active with capacity 3.\n\nAction: Create repository-asset closing rows with exact evidence holds. Owner: Talia Brooks; due 2026-10-04.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/02_trademarks/011_trademarks_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/03_copyrights/023_copyrights_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/035_licenses_in_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/047_licenses_out_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/09_development_records/071_development_records_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/08_domain_accounts/059_domain_accounts_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/097_jagged_cloud_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-090-12 — inventor assignment gap (medium)\n\ncompletion is required by 2025-05-24 under CB-IP-3210-R778; the current event record shows completion on 2025-06-07 under CB-IP-3210-E298. Identity resolves to ENT-090-1011, revision REV-2026.5 is current, and Adrian Mensah is active with capacity 4.\n\nAction: Create repository-asset closing rows with exact evidence holds. Owner: Adrian Mensah; due 2026-10-03.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/02_trademarks/012_trademarks_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/03_copyrights/024_copyrights_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/036_licenses_in_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/048_licenses_out_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/096_security_interests_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/097_jagged_cloud_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n## Evidence holds\n\n- **CBP-090-01 — outbound sublicense overreach**: the current observation does not meet the operative trigger. Next evidence: a current observation that satisfies the operative trigger. Sources: `/workspace/documents/01_patents/001_patents_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/02_trademarks/013_trademarks_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/025_invention_assignments_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/037_licenses_in_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/07_open_source/049_open_source_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/097_jagged_cloud_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-090-02 — cease-and-desist deadline**: the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective. Next evidence: effective approval and an active owner with remaining capacity. Sources: `/workspace/documents/01_patents/002_patents_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/02_trademarks/014_trademarks_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/026_invention_assignments_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/038_licenses_in_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/11_maintenance/086_maintenance_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/097_jagged_cloud_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-090-03 — foreign-filing restriction**: the operational record relies on a superseded control revision. Next evidence: an operational record using the current effective revision. Sources: `/workspace/documents/01_patents/003_patents_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/02_trademarks/015_trademarks_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/027_invention_assignments_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/039_licenses_in_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/08_domain_accounts/063_domain_accounts_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/10_disputes/075_disputes_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/097_jagged_cloud_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-090-04 — inbound-license field restriction**: two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key. Next evidence: an approved immutable entity crosswalk. Sources: `/workspace/documents/01_patents/004_patents_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/02_trademarks/016_trademarks_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/028_invention_assignments_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/040_licenses_in_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/11_maintenance/088_maintenance_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/097_jagged_cloud_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-090-07 — source-code ownership gap**: the operational record relies on a superseded control revision. Next evidence: an operational record using the current effective revision. Sources: `/workspace/documents/01_patents/007_patents_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/03_copyrights/019_copyrights_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/031_invention_assignments_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/043_licenses_out_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/07_open_source/055_open_source_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/091_security_interests_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/097_jagged_cloud_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-090-08 — domain registrant mismatch**: two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key. Next evidence: an approved immutable entity crosswalk. Sources: `/workspace/documents/01_patents/008_patents_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/03_copyrights/020_copyrights_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/032_invention_assignments_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/044_licenses_out_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/092_security_interests_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/097_jagged_cloud_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n## Alternatives considered\n\n- `jagged-cloud:blanket-hold` — Freeze the entire matter population: Treat supported actions and genuinely ambiguous records as if they were equally unresolved.\n- `jagged-cloud:shortcut` — Treat repository ownership and seller warranties as resolving every IP issue.: Use a plausible summary or one source without completing the controlling joins.\n\n## Assumptions and limits\n\nThis decision is limited to cb100-090-jagged-cloud, the supplied synthetic records, and the matter state as of 2026-10-06. Similar names, stale revisions, and pending authority are not treated as proof.\n", "decision": {"actions": [{"determination": "the controlling threshold is 14% under CB-IP-3210-R317; the independently calculated result is 20% under CB-IP-3210-E801. Identity resolves to ENT-090-1004, revision REV-2026.5 is current, and Sofia Bennett is active with capacity 1.", "due_date": "2026-10-01", "id": "ACT-CBP-090-05", "identity_id": "ENT-090-1004", "issue": "repository access anomaly", "owner": "Sofia Bennett", "portfolio_key": "CBP-090-05", "recommended_action": "Create repository-asset closing rows with exact evidence holds. Owner: Sofia Bennett; due 2026-10-01.", "severity": "low", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_patents/005_patents_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/03_copyrights/017_copyrights_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/029_invention_assignments_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/041_licenses_out_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/089_security_interests_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/097_jagged_cloud_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "approval must come from Mei Whitaker under CB-IP-3210-R277; the effective approval record names Rafael Okafor under CB-IP-3210-E428. Identity resolves to ENT-090-1005, revision REV-2026.6 is current, and Micah Sullivan is active with capacity 1.", "due_date": "2026-09-30", "id": "ACT-CBP-090-06", "identity_id": "ENT-090-1005", "issue": "maintenance-fee deadline", "owner": "Micah Sullivan", "portfolio_key": "CBP-090-06", "recommended_action": "Create repository-asset closing rows with exact evidence holds. Owner: Micah Sullivan; due 2026-09-30.", "severity": "high", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_patents/006_patents_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/03_copyrights/018_copyrights_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/030_invention_assignments_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/042_licenses_out_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/097_jagged_cloud_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "the operative cap is $1,402,000.00 under CB-IP-3210-R579; the matched ledger population totals $1,613,479.00 under CB-IP-3210-E128. Identity resolves to ENT-090-1008, revision REV-2026.2 is current, and Amara Patel is active with capacity 3.", "due_date": "2026-09-27", "id": "ACT-CBP-090-09", "identity_id": "ENT-090-1008", "issue": "recorded-owner mismatch", "owner": "Amara Patel", "portfolio_key": "CBP-090-09", "recommended_action": "Create repository-asset closing rows with exact evidence holds. Owner: Amara Patel; due 2026-09-27.", "severity": "low", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_trademarks/009_trademarks_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/03_copyrights/021_copyrights_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/033_licenses_in_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/045_licenses_out_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/09_development_records/069_development_records_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/08_domain_accounts/057_domain_accounts_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/097_jagged_cloud_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "delivery must use notices-jagged_cloud_infrastructure@example.test under CB-IP-3210-R507; the only matched receipt used archive-nimbus_fork_technologies@example.test under CB-IP-3210-E600. Identity resolves to ENT-090-1009, revision REV-2026.3 is current, and Samuel Kim is active with capacity 3.", "due_date": "2026-10-05", "id": "ACT-CBP-090-10", "identity_id": "ENT-090-1009", "issue": "work-for-hire defect", "owner": "Samuel Kim", "portfolio_key": "CBP-090-10", "recommended_action": "Create repository-asset closing rows with exact evidence holds. Owner: Samuel Kim; due 2026-10-05.", "severity": "low", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_trademarks/010_trademarks_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/03_copyrights/022_copyrights_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/034_licenses_in_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/046_licenses_out_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/097_jagged_cloud_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "an open exception blocks completion under CB-IP-3210-R887; the current status is open and unresolved under CB-IP-3210-E199. Identity resolves to ENT-090-1010, revision REV-2026.4 is current, and Talia Brooks is active with capacity 3.", "due_date": "2026-10-04", "id": "ACT-CBP-090-11", "identity_id": "ENT-090-1010", "issue": "notice-file omission", "owner": "Talia Brooks", "portfolio_key": "CBP-090-11", "recommended_action": "Create repository-asset closing rows with exact evidence holds. Owner: Talia Brooks; due 2026-10-04.", "severity": "high", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_trademarks/011_trademarks_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/03_copyrights/023_copyrights_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/035_licenses_in_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/047_licenses_out_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/09_development_records/071_development_records_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/08_domain_accounts/059_domain_accounts_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/097_jagged_cloud_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "completion is required by 2025-05-24 under CB-IP-3210-R778; the current event record shows completion on 2025-06-07 under CB-IP-3210-E298. Identity resolves to ENT-090-1011, revision REV-2026.5 is current, and Adrian Mensah is active with capacity 4.", "due_date": "2026-10-03", "id": "ACT-CBP-090-12", "identity_id": "ENT-090-1011", "issue": "inventor assignment gap", "owner": "Adrian Mensah", "portfolio_key": "CBP-090-12", "recommended_action": "Create repository-asset closing rows with exact evidence holds. Owner: Adrian Mensah; due 2026-10-03.", "severity": "medium", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_trademarks/012_trademarks_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/03_copyrights/024_copyrights_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/036_licenses_in_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/048_licenses_out_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/096_security_interests_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/097_jagged_cloud_impact_population.xlsx"]}], "as_of": "2026-10-06", "decision": {"alternatives_considered": ["jagged-cloud:blanket-hold", "jagged-cloud:shortcut"], "question": "What IP must Jagged cure before the cloud acquisition can close?", "rationale": "The four-part causal test supports 6 scoped actions and leaves 6 records on evidence hold. Exact code provenance, executed grants, account control, and released liens determine clean title.", "recommendation": "Condition closing on supported title, infringement, control, or release cures.", "selected_option_id": "jagged-cloud:scoped-evidence"}, "holds": [{"id": "HOLD-CBP-090-01", "issue": "outbound sublicense overreach", "portfolio_key": "CBP-090-01", "reason": "the current observation does not meet the operative trigger", "required_next_evidence": "a current observation that satisfies the operative trigger", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_patents/001_patents_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/02_trademarks/013_trademarks_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/025_invention_assignments_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/037_licenses_in_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/07_open_source/049_open_source_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/097_jagged_cloud_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-090-02", "issue": "cease-and-desist deadline", "portfolio_key": "CBP-090-02", "reason": "the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective", "required_next_evidence": "effective approval and an active owner with remaining capacity", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_patents/002_patents_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/02_trademarks/014_trademarks_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/026_invention_assignments_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/038_licenses_in_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/11_maintenance/086_maintenance_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/097_jagged_cloud_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-090-03", "issue": "foreign-filing restriction", "portfolio_key": "CBP-090-03", "reason": "the operational record relies on a superseded control revision", "required_next_evidence": "an operational record using the current effective revision", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_patents/003_patents_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/02_trademarks/015_trademarks_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/027_invention_assignments_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/039_licenses_in_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/08_domain_accounts/063_domain_accounts_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/10_disputes/075_disputes_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/097_jagged_cloud_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-090-04", "issue": "inbound-license field restriction", "portfolio_key": "CBP-090-04", "reason": "two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key", "required_next_evidence": "an approved immutable entity crosswalk", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_patents/004_patents_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/02_trademarks/016_trademarks_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/028_invention_assignments_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/040_licenses_in_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/11_maintenance/088_maintenance_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/097_jagged_cloud_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-090-07", "issue": "source-code ownership gap", "portfolio_key": "CBP-090-07", "reason": "the operational record relies on a superseded control revision", "required_next_evidence": "an operational record using the current effective revision", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_patents/007_patents_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/03_copyrights/019_copyrights_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/031_invention_assignments_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/043_licenses_out_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/07_open_source/055_open_source_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/091_security_interests_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/097_jagged_cloud_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-090-08", "issue": "domain registrant mismatch", "portfolio_key": "CBP-090-08", "reason": "two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key", "required_next_evidence": "an approved immutable entity crosswalk", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_patents/008_patents_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/03_copyrights/020_copyrights_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/032_invention_assignments_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/044_licenses_out_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/092_security_interests_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/097_jagged_cloud_impact_population.xlsx"]}], "matter_number": "CB-IP-3210", "prepared_for": "Jagged Cloud Infrastructure", "schema_version": "counselbench.decision.v3", "task_id": "cb100-090-jagged-cloud"}, "matter_register": {"matter_number": "CB-IP-3210", "rows": [{"decision_option_id": "jagged-cloud:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "the current observation does not meet the operative trigger", "issue": "outbound sublicense overreach", "matter_number": "CB-IP-3210", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-090-01", "row_id": "REG-CBP-090-01", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_patents/001_patents_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/02_trademarks/013_trademarks_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/025_invention_assignments_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/037_licenses_in_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/07_open_source/049_open_source_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/097_jagged_cloud_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "jagged-cloud:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective", "issue": "cease-and-desist deadline", "matter_number": "CB-IP-3210", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-090-02", "row_id": "REG-CBP-090-02", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_patents/002_patents_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/02_trademarks/014_trademarks_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/026_invention_assignments_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/038_licenses_in_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/11_maintenance/086_maintenance_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/097_jagged_cloud_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "jagged-cloud:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "the operational record relies on a superseded control revision", "issue": "foreign-filing restriction", "matter_number": "CB-IP-3210", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-090-03", "row_id": "REG-CBP-090-03", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_patents/003_patents_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/02_trademarks/015_trademarks_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/027_invention_assignments_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/039_licenses_in_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/08_domain_accounts/063_domain_accounts_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/10_disputes/075_disputes_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/097_jagged_cloud_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "jagged-cloud:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key", "issue": "inbound-license field restriction", "matter_number": "CB-IP-3210", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-090-04", "row_id": "REG-CBP-090-04", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_patents/004_patents_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/02_trademarks/016_trademarks_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/028_invention_assignments_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/040_licenses_in_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/11_maintenance/088_maintenance_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/097_jagged_cloud_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "jagged-cloud:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-10-01", "issue": "repository access anomaly", "matter_number": "CB-IP-3210", "owner": "Sofia Bennett", "portfolio_key": "CBP-090-05", "row_id": "REG-CBP-090-05", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_patents/005_patents_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/03_copyrights/017_copyrights_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/029_invention_assignments_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/041_licenses_out_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/089_security_interests_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/097_jagged_cloud_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "jagged-cloud:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-30", "issue": "maintenance-fee deadline", "matter_number": "CB-IP-3210", "owner": "Micah Sullivan", "portfolio_key": "CBP-090-06", "row_id": "REG-CBP-090-06", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_patents/006_patents_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/03_copyrights/018_copyrights_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/030_invention_assignments_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/042_licenses_out_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/097_jagged_cloud_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "jagged-cloud:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "the operational record relies on a superseded control revision", "issue": "source-code ownership gap", "matter_number": "CB-IP-3210", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-090-07", "row_id": "REG-CBP-090-07", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_patents/007_patents_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/03_copyrights/019_copyrights_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/031_invention_assignments_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/043_licenses_out_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/07_open_source/055_open_source_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/091_security_interests_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/097_jagged_cloud_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "jagged-cloud:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key", "issue": "domain registrant mismatch", "matter_number": "CB-IP-3210", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-090-08", "row_id": "REG-CBP-090-08", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_patents/008_patents_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/03_copyrights/020_copyrights_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/032_invention_assignments_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/044_licenses_out_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/092_security_interests_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/097_jagged_cloud_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "jagged-cloud:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-27", "issue": "recorded-owner mismatch", "matter_number": "CB-IP-3210", "owner": "Amara Patel", "portfolio_key": "CBP-090-09", "row_id": "REG-CBP-090-09", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_trademarks/009_trademarks_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/03_copyrights/021_copyrights_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/033_licenses_in_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/045_licenses_out_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/09_development_records/069_development_records_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/08_domain_accounts/057_domain_accounts_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/097_jagged_cloud_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "jagged-cloud:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-10-05", "issue": "work-for-hire defect", "matter_number": "CB-IP-3210", "owner": "Samuel Kim", "portfolio_key": "CBP-090-10", "row_id": "REG-CBP-090-10", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_trademarks/010_trademarks_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/03_copyrights/022_copyrights_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/034_licenses_in_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/046_licenses_out_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/097_jagged_cloud_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "jagged-cloud:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-10-04", "issue": "notice-file omission", "matter_number": "CB-IP-3210", "owner": "Talia Brooks", "portfolio_key": "CBP-090-11", "row_id": "REG-CBP-090-11", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_trademarks/011_trademarks_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/03_copyrights/023_copyrights_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/035_licenses_in_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/047_licenses_out_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/09_development_records/071_development_records_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/08_domain_accounts/059_domain_accounts_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/097_jagged_cloud_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "jagged-cloud:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-10-03", "issue": "inventor assignment gap", "matter_number": "CB-IP-3210", "owner": "Adrian Mensah", "portfolio_key": "CBP-090-12", "row_id": "REG-CBP-090-12", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_trademarks/012_trademarks_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/03_copyrights/024_copyrights_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/036_licenses_in_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/048_licenses_out_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/096_security_interests_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_security_interests/097_jagged_cloud_impact_population.xlsx"]}], "schema_version": "counselbench.matter-register.v3", "task_id": "cb100-090-jagged-cloud"}}, "metadata": {"benchmark": "CounselBench-100", "code_license": "Apache-2.0", "data_license": "CC-BY-4.0", "deadline": "2026-10-06", "document_count": 97, "evidence_holds": 6, "jurisdiction": "Washington", "matter_number": "CB-IP-3210", "mcp_commit": "9a96ea6e5913736f92b88345bf51caeaaa8e719f", "mcp_package": "@modelcontextprotocol/server-filesystem@2026.7.10", "practice_area": "ip-technology", "reference_tool_calls": 90, "required_evidence_reads": 63, "supported_actions": 6, "synthetic": true, "venue": "Western District of Washington", "version": "3.1.0"}, "prompt": "I need to know what is proven, what we can do about it, and what is still only an evidence gap. What IP must Jagged cure before the cloud acquisition can close? A cloud acquisition includes forked code, contributor agreements, patent assertions, registrant mismatches, and lender release questions. The team needs the call by 2026-10-06. Capture the supported action and the remaining holds so the next reviewer can reproduce the call.", "rubric": {"criteria": [{"category": "investigation", "description": "Inventory the production and use targeted searches to locate records across native formats.", "id": "investigation.discover_production"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Complete every task-specific identity, authority, operations, and approval read before the first state transition.", "id": "investigation.read_before_write"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Inspect designated source metadata before relying on those records.", "id": "investigation.custody_before_write"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "Select the supported option 'jagged-cloud:scoped-evidence' after applying the four-part test.", "id": "decision.selected_option"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "Identify both rejected approaches and explain why a one-source shortcut and a blanket hold are wrong.", "id": "decision.alternatives"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-090-01 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_patents/001_patents_source_export.md rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-090-01.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_trademarks/013_trademarks_source_export.json for outbound sublicense overreach.", "id": "investigation.CBP-090-01.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/025_invention_assignments_source_export.md to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-090-01.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/037_licenses_in_source_export.json.", "id": "investigation.CBP-090-01.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-090-01 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is the current observation does not meet the operative trigger.", "id": "decision.CBP-090-01.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-090-01 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-090-01.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-090-02 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_patents/002_patents_source_export.txt rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-090-02.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_trademarks/014_trademarks_source_export.xml for cease-and-desist deadline.", "id": "investigation.CBP-090-02.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/026_invention_assignments_source_export.txt to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-090-02.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/038_licenses_in_source_export.xml.", "id": "investigation.CBP-090-02.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-090-02 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective.", "id": "decision.CBP-090-02.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-090-02 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-090-02.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-090-03 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_patents/003_patents_source_export.eml rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-090-03.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_trademarks/015_trademarks_source_export.html for foreign-filing restriction.", "id": "investigation.CBP-090-03.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/027_invention_assignments_source_export.eml to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-090-03.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/039_licenses_in_source_export.html.", "id": "investigation.CBP-090-03.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-090-03 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is the operational record relies on a superseded control revision.", "id": "decision.CBP-090-03.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-090-03 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-090-03.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-090-04 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_patents/004_patents_source_export.csv rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-090-04.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_trademarks/016_trademarks_source_export.pdf for inbound-license field restriction.", "id": "investigation.CBP-090-04.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/028_invention_assignments_source_export.csv to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-090-04.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/040_licenses_in_source_export.pdf.", "id": "investigation.CBP-090-04.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-090-04 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key.", "id": "decision.CBP-090-04.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-090-04 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-090-04.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-090-05 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_patents/005_patents_source_export.json rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-090-05.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_copyrights/017_copyrights_source_export.md for repository access anomaly.", "id": "investigation.CBP-090-05.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/029_invention_assignments_source_export.json to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-090-05.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/041_licenses_out_source_export.md.", "id": "investigation.CBP-090-05.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-090-05 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-090-05.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-090-05 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-090-05.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-090-06 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_patents/006_patents_source_export.xml rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-090-06.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_copyrights/018_copyrights_source_export.txt for maintenance-fee deadline.", "id": "investigation.CBP-090-06.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/030_invention_assignments_source_export.xml to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-090-06.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/042_licenses_out_source_export.txt.", "id": "investigation.CBP-090-06.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-090-06 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-090-06.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-090-06 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-090-06.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-090-07 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_patents/007_patents_source_export.html rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-090-07.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_copyrights/019_copyrights_source_export.eml for source-code ownership gap.", "id": "investigation.CBP-090-07.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/031_invention_assignments_source_export.html to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-090-07.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/043_licenses_out_source_export.eml.", "id": "investigation.CBP-090-07.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-090-07 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is the operational record relies on a superseded control revision.", "id": "decision.CBP-090-07.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-090-07 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-090-07.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-090-08 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_patents/008_patents_source_export.pdf rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-090-08.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_copyrights/020_copyrights_source_export.csv for domain registrant mismatch.", "id": "investigation.CBP-090-08.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_invention_assignments/032_invention_assignments_source_export.pdf to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-090-08.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/044_licenses_out_source_export.csv.", "id": "investigation.CBP-090-08.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-090-08 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key.", "id": "decision.CBP-090-08.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-090-08 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-090-08.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-090-09 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_trademarks/009_trademarks_source_export.md rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-090-09.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_copyrights/021_copyrights_source_export.json for recorded-owner mismatch.", "id": "investigation.CBP-090-09.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/033_licenses_in_source_export.md to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-090-09.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/045_licenses_out_source_export.json.", "id": "investigation.CBP-090-09.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-090-09 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-090-09.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-090-09 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-090-09.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-090-10 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_trademarks/010_trademarks_source_export.txt rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-090-10.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_copyrights/022_copyrights_source_export.xml for work-for-hire defect.", "id": "investigation.CBP-090-10.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/034_licenses_in_source_export.txt to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-090-10.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/046_licenses_out_source_export.xml.", "id": "investigation.CBP-090-10.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-090-10 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-090-10.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-090-10 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-090-10.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-090-11 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_trademarks/011_trademarks_source_export.eml rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-090-11.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_copyrights/023_copyrights_source_export.html for notice-file omission.", "id": "investigation.CBP-090-11.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/035_licenses_in_source_export.eml to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-090-11.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/047_licenses_out_source_export.html.", "id": "investigation.CBP-090-11.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-090-11 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-090-11.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-090-11 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-090-11.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-090-12 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_trademarks/012_trademarks_source_export.csv rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-090-12.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_copyrights/024_copyrights_source_export.pdf for inventor assignment gap.", "id": "investigation.CBP-090-12.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_licenses_in/036_licenses_in_source_export.csv to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-090-12.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_licenses_out/048_licenses_out_source_export.pdf.", "id": "investigation.CBP-090-12.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-090-12 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-090-12.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-090-12 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-090-12.register"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Write the exact selected option, supported action population, evidence-hold population, facts, owners, deadlines, and citations.", "id": "state.exact_decision"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create one exact register row per portfolio key with no extra, missing, or modified row.", "id": "state.exact_register"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Leave only the three approved deliverables and perform no extra state-changing write.", "id": "state.write_scope_containment"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Read back decision.json, matter-register.json, and advice.md after their final writes.", "id": "state.postwrite_readback"}, {"category": "answer", "description": "Explain the selected recommendation, supported actions, holds, alternatives, and limitations with exact source anchors.", "id": "answer.decision_note"}], "decision_options": [{"approach": "Treat supported actions and genuinely ambiguous records as if they were equally unresolved.", "id": "jagged-cloud:blanket-hold", "label": "Freeze the entire matter population"}, {"approach": "Apply the exact identity, current-state, authority, and revision test. Create repository-asset closing rows with exact evidence holds.", "id": "jagged-cloud:scoped-evidence", "label": "Condition closing on supported title, infringement, control, or release cures."}, {"approach": "Use a plausible summary or one source without completing the controlling joins.", "id": "jagged-cloud:shortcut", "label": "Treat repository ownership and seller warranties as resolving every IP issue."}], "evaluation_narrative": {"authority": "Exact code provenance, executed grants, account control, and released liens determine clean title.", "observation": "Join fork lineage, contributors, assignments, assertions, domains, and lender releases by repository and asset.", "question": "What IP must Jagged cure before the cloud acquisition can close?", "register_action": "Create repository-asset closing rows with exact evidence holds."}, "gates": ["all_required_evidence_precedes_first_write", "decision_criteria_complete", "register_state_exact", "write_scope_contained", "all_outputs_verified_by_readback"], "metadata_checks": 10, "metric": "weighted_criteria_score", "minimum_tool_calls": 90, "required_deliverables": ["decision.json", "matter-register.json", "advice.md"], "required_document_reads": 63, "type": "deterministic", "weights": {"advice": 0.15, "decision": 0.35, "investigation": 0.25, "state": 0.25}}, "task_id": "cb100-090-jagged-cloud", "task_name": "Jagged Cloud acquisition IP audit", "world_id": "counselbench-filesystem-mcp-v3"}
+{"context_files": ["task_files/cb100-091-alabaster-energy/01_board_committees/001_board_committees_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-091-alabaster-energy/01_board_committees/002_board_committees_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-091-alabaster-energy/01_board_committees/003_board_committees_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-091-alabaster-energy/01_board_committees/004_board_committees_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-091-alabaster-energy/01_board_committees/005_board_committees_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-091-alabaster-energy/01_board_committees/006_board_committees_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-091-alabaster-energy/01_board_committees/007_board_committees_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-091-alabaster-energy/01_board_committees/008_board_committees_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-091-alabaster-energy/02_minutes_materials/009_minutes_materials_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-091-alabaster-energy/02_minutes_materials/010_minutes_materials_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-091-alabaster-energy/02_minutes_materials/011_minutes_materials_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-091-alabaster-energy/02_minutes_materials/012_minutes_materials_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-091-alabaster-energy/02_minutes_materials/013_minutes_materials_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-091-alabaster-energy/02_minutes_materials/014_minutes_materials_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-091-alabaster-energy/02_minutes_materials/015_minutes_materials_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-091-alabaster-energy/02_minutes_materials/016_minutes_materials_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-091-alabaster-energy/03_sec_filings/017_sec_filings_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-091-alabaster-energy/03_sec_filings/018_sec_filings_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-091-alabaster-energy/03_sec_filings/019_sec_filings_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-091-alabaster-energy/03_sec_filings/020_sec_filings_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-091-alabaster-energy/03_sec_filings/021_sec_filings_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-091-alabaster-energy/03_sec_filings/022_sec_filings_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-091-alabaster-energy/03_sec_filings/023_sec_filings_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-091-alabaster-energy/03_sec_filings/024_sec_filings_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-091-alabaster-energy/04_disclosure_controls/025_disclosure_controls_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-091-alabaster-energy/04_disclosure_controls/026_disclosure_controls_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-091-alabaster-energy/04_disclosure_controls/027_disclosure_controls_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-091-alabaster-energy/04_disclosure_controls/028_disclosure_controls_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-091-alabaster-energy/04_disclosure_controls/029_disclosure_controls_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-091-alabaster-energy/04_disclosure_controls/030_disclosure_controls_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-091-alabaster-energy/04_disclosure_controls/031_disclosure_controls_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-091-alabaster-energy/04_disclosure_controls/032_disclosure_controls_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-091-alabaster-energy/05_insider_trading/033_insider_trading_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-091-alabaster-energy/05_insider_trading/034_insider_trading_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-091-alabaster-energy/05_insider_trading/035_insider_trading_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-091-alabaster-energy/05_insider_trading/036_insider_trading_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-091-alabaster-energy/05_insider_trading/037_insider_trading_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-091-alabaster-energy/05_insider_trading/038_insider_trading_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-091-alabaster-energy/05_insider_trading/039_insider_trading_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-091-alabaster-energy/05_insider_trading/040_insider_trading_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-091-alabaster-energy/06_related_parties/041_related_parties_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-091-alabaster-energy/06_related_parties/042_related_parties_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-091-alabaster-energy/06_related_parties/043_related_parties_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-091-alabaster-energy/06_related_parties/044_related_parties_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-091-alabaster-energy/06_related_parties/045_related_parties_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-091-alabaster-energy/06_related_parties/046_related_parties_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-091-alabaster-energy/06_related_parties/047_related_parties_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-091-alabaster-energy/06_related_parties/048_related_parties_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-091-alabaster-energy/07_equity_compensation/049_equity_compensation_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-091-alabaster-energy/07_equity_compensation/050_equity_compensation_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-091-alabaster-energy/07_equity_compensation/051_equity_compensation_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-091-alabaster-energy/07_equity_compensation/052_equity_compensation_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-091-alabaster-energy/07_equity_compensation/053_equity_compensation_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-091-alabaster-energy/07_equity_compensation/054_equity_compensation_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-091-alabaster-energy/07_equity_compensation/055_equity_compensation_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-091-alabaster-energy/07_equity_compensation/056_equity_compensation_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-091-alabaster-energy/08_earnings_guidance/057_earnings_guidance_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-091-alabaster-energy/08_earnings_guidance/058_earnings_guidance_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-091-alabaster-energy/08_earnings_guidance/059_earnings_guidance_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-091-alabaster-energy/08_earnings_guidance/060_earnings_guidance_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-091-alabaster-energy/08_earnings_guidance/061_earnings_guidance_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-091-alabaster-energy/08_earnings_guidance/062_earnings_guidance_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-091-alabaster-energy/08_earnings_guidance/063_earnings_guidance_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-091-alabaster-energy/08_earnings_guidance/064_earnings_guidance_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-091-alabaster-energy/09_whistleblower/065_whistleblower_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-091-alabaster-energy/09_whistleblower/066_whistleblower_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-091-alabaster-energy/09_whistleblower/067_whistleblower_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-091-alabaster-energy/09_whistleblower/068_whistleblower_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-091-alabaster-energy/09_whistleblower/069_whistleblower_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-091-alabaster-energy/09_whistleblower/070_whistleblower_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-091-alabaster-energy/09_whistleblower/071_whistleblower_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-091-alabaster-energy/09_whistleblower/072_whistleblower_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-091-alabaster-energy/10_stock_exchange/073_stock_exchange_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-091-alabaster-energy/10_stock_exchange/074_stock_exchange_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-091-alabaster-energy/10_stock_exchange/075_stock_exchange_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-091-alabaster-energy/10_stock_exchange/076_stock_exchange_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-091-alabaster-energy/10_stock_exchange/077_stock_exchange_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-091-alabaster-energy/10_stock_exchange/078_stock_exchange_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-091-alabaster-energy/10_stock_exchange/079_stock_exchange_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-091-alabaster-energy/10_stock_exchange/080_stock_exchange_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-091-alabaster-energy/11_debt_covenants/081_debt_covenants_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-091-alabaster-energy/11_debt_covenants/082_debt_covenants_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-091-alabaster-energy/11_debt_covenants/083_debt_covenants_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-091-alabaster-energy/11_debt_covenants/084_debt_covenants_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-091-alabaster-energy/11_debt_covenants/085_debt_covenants_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-091-alabaster-energy/11_debt_covenants/086_debt_covenants_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-091-alabaster-energy/11_debt_covenants/087_debt_covenants_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-091-alabaster-energy/11_debt_covenants/088_debt_covenants_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-091-alabaster-energy/12_certifications/089_certifications_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-091-alabaster-energy/12_certifications/090_certifications_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-091-alabaster-energy/12_certifications/091_certifications_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-091-alabaster-energy/12_certifications/092_certifications_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-091-alabaster-energy/12_certifications/093_certifications_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-091-alabaster-energy/12_certifications/094_certifications_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-091-alabaster-energy/12_certifications/095_certifications_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-091-alabaster-energy/12_certifications/096_certifications_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-091-alabaster-energy/12_certifications/097_alabaster_energy_impact_population.xlsx"], "gold_output": {"advice_markdown": "# Decision note — Alabaster disclosure-controls review\n\n## Recommendation\n\nEscalate supported disclosure or trading-control exceptions before filing. The reconciled record supports 9 scoped actions and leaves 3 items on evidence hold.\n\nSelected option: `alabaster-energy:scoped-evidence`.\n\n## Why this is the supported option\n\nJoin outage materiality, forecasts, lender terms, board circulation, trades, and filing drafts by event time. Disclosure controls and trading restrictions depend on supported material information and possession timing.\n\n## Supported actions\n\n### CBP-091-01 — guidance-control failure (high)\n\napproval must come from Nadine Flores under CB-PC-3301-R766; the effective approval record names Rafael Okafor under CB-PC-3301-E245. Identity resolves to ENT-091-1000, revision REV-2025.1 is current, and Isaac Romero is active with capacity 4.\n\nAction: Create event-control rows with exact knowledge and filing implications. Owner: Isaac Romero; due 2026-09-02.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_board_committees/001_board_committees_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/013_minutes_materials_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/025_disclosure_controls_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/037_insider_trading_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/08_earnings_guidance/061_earnings_guidance_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/10_stock_exchange/073_stock_exchange_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/12_certifications/097_alabaster_energy_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-091-02 — board-matrix inconsistency (critical)\n\nthe controlled population contains 142 records under CB-PC-3301-R990; the certification covers 105 records under CB-PC-3301-E364. Identity resolves to ENT-091-1001, revision REV-2025.2 is current, and Nadine Flores is active with capacity 4.\n\nAction: Create event-control rows with exact knowledge and filing implications. Owner: Nadine Flores; due 2026-09-01.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_board_committees/002_board_committees_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/014_minutes_materials_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/026_disclosure_controls_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/038_insider_trading_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/11_debt_covenants/086_debt_covenants_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/12_certifications/097_alabaster_energy_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-091-04 — non-GAAP reconciliation issue (medium)\n\nthe operative cap is $5,482,000.00 under CB-PC-3301-R994; the matched ledger population totals $5,729,594.00 under CB-PC-3301-E893. Identity resolves to ENT-091-1003, revision REV-2025.4 is current, and Mei Whitaker is active with capacity 4.\n\nAction: Create event-control rows with exact knowledge and filing implications. Owner: Mei Whitaker; due 2026-08-30.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_board_committees/004_board_committees_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/016_minutes_materials_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/028_disclosure_controls_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/040_insider_trading_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/10_stock_exchange/076_stock_exchange_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/11_debt_covenants/088_debt_covenants_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/12_certifications/097_alabaster_energy_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-091-06 — risk-factor inconsistency (medium)\n\nan open exception blocks completion under CB-PC-3301-R856; the current status is open and unresolved under CB-PC-3301-E356. Identity resolves to ENT-091-1005, revision REV-2025.6 is current, and Lena Varga is active with capacity 5.\n\nAction: Create event-control rows with exact knowledge and filing implications. Owner: Lena Varga; due 2026-08-28.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_board_committees/006_board_committees_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/018_sec_filings_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/030_disclosure_controls_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/06_related_parties/042_related_parties_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/09_whistleblower/066_whistleblower_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/12_certifications/090_certifications_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/12_certifications/097_alabaster_energy_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-091-07 — equity-plan share mismatch (medium)\n\ncompletion is required by 2025-09-17 under CB-PC-3301-R294; the current event record shows completion on 2025-10-28 under CB-PC-3301-E111. Identity resolves to ENT-091-1006, revision REV-2025.7 is current, and Elliot Mercer is active with capacity 2.\n\nAction: Create event-control rows with exact knowledge and filing implications. Owner: Elliot Mercer; due 2026-08-27.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_board_committees/007_board_committees_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/019_sec_filings_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/031_disclosure_controls_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/06_related_parties/043_related_parties_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/09_whistleblower/067_whistleblower_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/12_certifications/091_certifications_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/12_certifications/097_alabaster_energy_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-091-08 — debt-covenant disclosure (high)\n\nthe controlling threshold is 7% under CB-PC-3301-R504; the independently calculated result is 13% under CB-PC-3301-E970. Identity resolves to ENT-091-1007, revision REV-2025.1 is current, and Sofia Bennett is active with capacity 3.\n\nAction: Create event-control rows with exact knowledge and filing implications. Owner: Sofia Bennett; due 2026-08-26.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_board_committees/008_board_committees_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/020_sec_filings_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/032_disclosure_controls_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/06_related_parties/044_related_parties_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/12_certifications/097_alabaster_energy_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-091-10 — related-party disclosure gap (medium)\n\nthe controlled population contains 176 records under CB-PC-3301-R124; the certification covers 140 records under CB-PC-3301-E366. Identity resolves to ENT-091-1009, revision REV-2025.3 is current, and Nora Chen is active with capacity 1.\n\nAction: Create event-control rows with exact knowledge and filing implications. Owner: Nora Chen; due 2026-09-02.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/010_minutes_materials_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/022_sec_filings_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/034_insider_trading_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/06_related_parties/046_related_parties_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/12_certifications/094_certifications_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/09_whistleblower/070_whistleblower_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/12_certifications/097_alabaster_energy_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-091-11 — listing-standard notice (high)\n\nthe permission is limited to New York Stock Exchange under CB-PC-3301-R590; the matched activity occurred in Delaware under CB-PC-3301-E552. Identity resolves to ENT-091-1010, revision REV-2025.4 is current, and Caleb Hassan is active with capacity 2.\n\nAction: Create event-control rows with exact knowledge and filing implications. Owner: Caleb Hassan; due 2026-09-01.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/011_minutes_materials_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/023_sec_filings_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/035_insider_trading_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/06_related_parties/047_related_parties_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/11_debt_covenants/083_debt_covenants_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/12_certifications/097_alabaster_energy_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-091-12 — minutes-approval omission (low)\n\nthe operative cap is $25,000.00 under CB-PC-3301-R939; the matched ledger population totals $126,439.00 under CB-PC-3301-E361. Identity resolves to ENT-091-1011, revision REV-2025.5 is current, and Amara Patel is active with capacity 1.\n\nAction: Create event-control rows with exact knowledge and filing implications. Owner: Amara Patel; due 2026-08-31.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/012_minutes_materials_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/024_sec_filings_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/036_insider_trading_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/06_related_parties/048_related_parties_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/12_certifications/096_certifications_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/08_earnings_guidance/060_earnings_guidance_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/12_certifications/097_alabaster_energy_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n## Evidence holds\n\n- **CBP-091-03 — disclosure-control exception**: two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key. Next evidence: an approved immutable entity crosswalk. Sources: `/workspace/documents/01_board_committees/003_board_committees_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/015_minutes_materials_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/027_disclosure_controls_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/039_insider_trading_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/10_stock_exchange/075_stock_exchange_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/12_certifications/097_alabaster_energy_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-091-05 — officer certification exception**: the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective. Next evidence: effective approval and an active owner with remaining capacity. Sources: `/workspace/documents/01_board_committees/005_board_committees_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/017_sec_filings_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/029_disclosure_controls_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/06_related_parties/041_related_parties_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/07_equity_compensation/053_equity_compensation_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/10_stock_exchange/077_stock_exchange_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/12_certifications/097_alabaster_energy_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-091-09 — 8-K deadline**: the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective. Next evidence: effective approval and an active owner with remaining capacity. Sources: `/workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/009_minutes_materials_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/021_sec_filings_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/033_insider_trading_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/06_related_parties/045_related_parties_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/12_certifications/097_alabaster_energy_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n## Alternatives considered\n\n- `alabaster-energy:shortcut` — Treat every outage and nearby trade as automatically material and improper.: Use a plausible summary or one source without completing the controlling joins.\n- `alabaster-energy:blanket-hold` — Freeze the entire matter population: Treat supported actions and genuinely ambiguous records as if they were equally unresolved.\n\n## Assumptions and limits\n\nThis decision is limited to cb100-091-alabaster-energy, the supplied synthetic records, and the matter state as of 2026-09-03. Similar names, stale revisions, and pending authority are not treated as proof.\n", "decision": {"actions": [{"determination": "approval must come from Nadine Flores under CB-PC-3301-R766; the effective approval record names Rafael Okafor under CB-PC-3301-E245. Identity resolves to ENT-091-1000, revision REV-2025.1 is current, and Isaac Romero is active with capacity 4.", "due_date": "2026-09-02", "id": "ACT-CBP-091-01", "identity_id": "ENT-091-1000", "issue": "guidance-control failure", "owner": "Isaac Romero", "portfolio_key": "CBP-091-01", "recommended_action": "Create event-control rows with exact knowledge and filing implications. Owner: Isaac Romero; due 2026-09-02.", "severity": "high", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_board_committees/001_board_committees_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/013_minutes_materials_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/025_disclosure_controls_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/037_insider_trading_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/08_earnings_guidance/061_earnings_guidance_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/10_stock_exchange/073_stock_exchange_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/12_certifications/097_alabaster_energy_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "the controlled population contains 142 records under CB-PC-3301-R990; the certification covers 105 records under CB-PC-3301-E364. Identity resolves to ENT-091-1001, revision REV-2025.2 is current, and Nadine Flores is active with capacity 4.", "due_date": "2026-09-01", "id": "ACT-CBP-091-02", "identity_id": "ENT-091-1001", "issue": "board-matrix inconsistency", "owner": "Nadine Flores", "portfolio_key": "CBP-091-02", "recommended_action": "Create event-control rows with exact knowledge and filing implications. Owner: Nadine Flores; due 2026-09-01.", "severity": "critical", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_board_committees/002_board_committees_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/014_minutes_materials_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/026_disclosure_controls_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/038_insider_trading_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/11_debt_covenants/086_debt_covenants_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_certifications/097_alabaster_energy_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "the operative cap is $5,482,000.00 under CB-PC-3301-R994; the matched ledger population totals $5,729,594.00 under CB-PC-3301-E893. Identity resolves to ENT-091-1003, revision REV-2025.4 is current, and Mei Whitaker is active with capacity 4.", "due_date": "2026-08-30", "id": "ACT-CBP-091-04", "identity_id": "ENT-091-1003", "issue": "non-GAAP reconciliation issue", "owner": "Mei Whitaker", "portfolio_key": "CBP-091-04", "recommended_action": "Create event-control rows with exact knowledge and filing implications. Owner: Mei Whitaker; due 2026-08-30.", "severity": "medium", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_board_committees/004_board_committees_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/016_minutes_materials_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/028_disclosure_controls_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/040_insider_trading_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/10_stock_exchange/076_stock_exchange_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/11_debt_covenants/088_debt_covenants_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_certifications/097_alabaster_energy_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "an open exception blocks completion under CB-PC-3301-R856; the current status is open and unresolved under CB-PC-3301-E356. Identity resolves to ENT-091-1005, revision REV-2025.6 is current, and Lena Varga is active with capacity 5.", "due_date": "2026-08-28", "id": "ACT-CBP-091-06", "identity_id": "ENT-091-1005", "issue": "risk-factor inconsistency", "owner": "Lena Varga", "portfolio_key": "CBP-091-06", "recommended_action": "Create event-control rows with exact knowledge and filing implications. Owner: Lena Varga; due 2026-08-28.", "severity": "medium", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_board_committees/006_board_committees_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/018_sec_filings_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/030_disclosure_controls_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/06_related_parties/042_related_parties_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/09_whistleblower/066_whistleblower_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/12_certifications/090_certifications_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/12_certifications/097_alabaster_energy_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "completion is required by 2025-09-17 under CB-PC-3301-R294; the current event record shows completion on 2025-10-28 under CB-PC-3301-E111. Identity resolves to ENT-091-1006, revision REV-2025.7 is current, and Elliot Mercer is active with capacity 2.", "due_date": "2026-08-27", "id": "ACT-CBP-091-07", "identity_id": "ENT-091-1006", "issue": "equity-plan share mismatch", "owner": "Elliot Mercer", "portfolio_key": "CBP-091-07", "recommended_action": "Create event-control rows with exact knowledge and filing implications. Owner: Elliot Mercer; due 2026-08-27.", "severity": "medium", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_board_committees/007_board_committees_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/019_sec_filings_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/031_disclosure_controls_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/06_related_parties/043_related_parties_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/09_whistleblower/067_whistleblower_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/12_certifications/091_certifications_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/12_certifications/097_alabaster_energy_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "the controlling threshold is 7% under CB-PC-3301-R504; the independently calculated result is 13% under CB-PC-3301-E970. Identity resolves to ENT-091-1007, revision REV-2025.1 is current, and Sofia Bennett is active with capacity 3.", "due_date": "2026-08-26", "id": "ACT-CBP-091-08", "identity_id": "ENT-091-1007", "issue": "debt-covenant disclosure", "owner": "Sofia Bennett", "portfolio_key": "CBP-091-08", "recommended_action": "Create event-control rows with exact knowledge and filing implications. Owner: Sofia Bennett; due 2026-08-26.", "severity": "high", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_board_committees/008_board_committees_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/020_sec_filings_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/032_disclosure_controls_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/06_related_parties/044_related_parties_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/12_certifications/097_alabaster_energy_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "the controlled population contains 176 records under CB-PC-3301-R124; the certification covers 140 records under CB-PC-3301-E366. Identity resolves to ENT-091-1009, revision REV-2025.3 is current, and Nora Chen is active with capacity 1.", "due_date": "2026-09-02", "id": "ACT-CBP-091-10", "identity_id": "ENT-091-1009", "issue": "related-party disclosure gap", "owner": "Nora Chen", "portfolio_key": "CBP-091-10", "recommended_action": "Create event-control rows with exact knowledge and filing implications. Owner: Nora Chen; due 2026-09-02.", "severity": "medium", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/010_minutes_materials_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/022_sec_filings_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/034_insider_trading_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/06_related_parties/046_related_parties_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_certifications/094_certifications_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/09_whistleblower/070_whistleblower_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_certifications/097_alabaster_energy_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "the permission is limited to New York Stock Exchange under CB-PC-3301-R590; the matched activity occurred in Delaware under CB-PC-3301-E552. Identity resolves to ENT-091-1010, revision REV-2025.4 is current, and Caleb Hassan is active with capacity 2.", "due_date": "2026-09-01", "id": "ACT-CBP-091-11", "identity_id": "ENT-091-1010", "issue": "listing-standard notice", "owner": "Caleb Hassan", "portfolio_key": "CBP-091-11", "recommended_action": "Create event-control rows with exact knowledge and filing implications. Owner: Caleb Hassan; due 2026-09-01.", "severity": "high", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/011_minutes_materials_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/023_sec_filings_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/035_insider_trading_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/06_related_parties/047_related_parties_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/11_debt_covenants/083_debt_covenants_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/12_certifications/097_alabaster_energy_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "the operative cap is $25,000.00 under CB-PC-3301-R939; the matched ledger population totals $126,439.00 under CB-PC-3301-E361. Identity resolves to ENT-091-1011, revision REV-2025.5 is current, and Amara Patel is active with capacity 1.", "due_date": "2026-08-31", "id": "ACT-CBP-091-12", "identity_id": "ENT-091-1011", "issue": "minutes-approval omission", "owner": "Amara Patel", "portfolio_key": "CBP-091-12", "recommended_action": "Create event-control rows with exact knowledge and filing implications. Owner: Amara Patel; due 2026-08-31.", "severity": "low", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/012_minutes_materials_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/024_sec_filings_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/036_insider_trading_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/06_related_parties/048_related_parties_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_certifications/096_certifications_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/08_earnings_guidance/060_earnings_guidance_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/12_certifications/097_alabaster_energy_impact_population.xlsx"]}], "as_of": "2026-09-03", "decision": {"alternatives_considered": ["alabaster-energy:shortcut", "alabaster-energy:blanket-hold"], "question": "What must Alabaster disclose or escalate from the outage, covenant forecast, and insider-trade timeline?", "rationale": "The four-part causal test supports 9 scoped actions and leaves 3 records on evidence hold. Disclosure controls and trading restrictions depend on supported material information and possession timing.", "recommendation": "Escalate supported disclosure or trading-control exceptions before filing.", "selected_option_id": "alabaster-energy:scoped-evidence"}, "holds": [{"id": "HOLD-CBP-091-03", "issue": "disclosure-control exception", "portfolio_key": "CBP-091-03", "reason": "two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key", "required_next_evidence": "an approved immutable entity crosswalk", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_board_committees/003_board_committees_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/015_minutes_materials_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/027_disclosure_controls_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/039_insider_trading_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/10_stock_exchange/075_stock_exchange_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/12_certifications/097_alabaster_energy_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-091-05", "issue": "officer certification exception", "portfolio_key": "CBP-091-05", "reason": "the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective", "required_next_evidence": "effective approval and an active owner with remaining capacity", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_board_committees/005_board_committees_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/017_sec_filings_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/029_disclosure_controls_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/06_related_parties/041_related_parties_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/07_equity_compensation/053_equity_compensation_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/10_stock_exchange/077_stock_exchange_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_certifications/097_alabaster_energy_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-091-09", "issue": "8-K deadline", "portfolio_key": "CBP-091-09", "reason": "the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective", "required_next_evidence": "effective approval and an active owner with remaining capacity", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/009_minutes_materials_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/021_sec_filings_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/033_insider_trading_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/06_related_parties/045_related_parties_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_certifications/097_alabaster_energy_impact_population.xlsx"]}], "matter_number": "CB-PC-3301", "prepared_for": "Alabaster Energy Corp.", "schema_version": "counselbench.decision.v3", "task_id": "cb100-091-alabaster-energy"}, "matter_register": {"matter_number": "CB-PC-3301", "rows": [{"decision_option_id": "alabaster-energy:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-02", "issue": "guidance-control failure", "matter_number": "CB-PC-3301", "owner": "Isaac Romero", "portfolio_key": "CBP-091-01", "row_id": "REG-CBP-091-01", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_board_committees/001_board_committees_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/013_minutes_materials_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/025_disclosure_controls_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/037_insider_trading_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/08_earnings_guidance/061_earnings_guidance_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/10_stock_exchange/073_stock_exchange_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/12_certifications/097_alabaster_energy_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "alabaster-energy:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-01", "issue": "board-matrix inconsistency", "matter_number": "CB-PC-3301", "owner": "Nadine Flores", "portfolio_key": "CBP-091-02", "row_id": "REG-CBP-091-02", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_board_committees/002_board_committees_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/014_minutes_materials_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/026_disclosure_controls_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/038_insider_trading_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/11_debt_covenants/086_debt_covenants_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_certifications/097_alabaster_energy_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "alabaster-energy:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key", "issue": "disclosure-control exception", "matter_number": "CB-PC-3301", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-091-03", "row_id": "REG-CBP-091-03", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_board_committees/003_board_committees_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/015_minutes_materials_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/027_disclosure_controls_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/039_insider_trading_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/10_stock_exchange/075_stock_exchange_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/12_certifications/097_alabaster_energy_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "alabaster-energy:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-08-30", "issue": "non-GAAP reconciliation issue", "matter_number": "CB-PC-3301", "owner": "Mei Whitaker", "portfolio_key": "CBP-091-04", "row_id": "REG-CBP-091-04", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_board_committees/004_board_committees_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/016_minutes_materials_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/028_disclosure_controls_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/040_insider_trading_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/10_stock_exchange/076_stock_exchange_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/11_debt_covenants/088_debt_covenants_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_certifications/097_alabaster_energy_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "alabaster-energy:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective", "issue": "officer certification exception", "matter_number": "CB-PC-3301", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-091-05", "row_id": "REG-CBP-091-05", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_board_committees/005_board_committees_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/017_sec_filings_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/029_disclosure_controls_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/06_related_parties/041_related_parties_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/07_equity_compensation/053_equity_compensation_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/10_stock_exchange/077_stock_exchange_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_certifications/097_alabaster_energy_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "alabaster-energy:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-08-28", "issue": "risk-factor inconsistency", "matter_number": "CB-PC-3301", "owner": "Lena Varga", "portfolio_key": "CBP-091-06", "row_id": "REG-CBP-091-06", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_board_committees/006_board_committees_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/018_sec_filings_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/030_disclosure_controls_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/06_related_parties/042_related_parties_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/09_whistleblower/066_whistleblower_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/12_certifications/090_certifications_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/12_certifications/097_alabaster_energy_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "alabaster-energy:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-08-27", "issue": "equity-plan share mismatch", "matter_number": "CB-PC-3301", "owner": "Elliot Mercer", "portfolio_key": "CBP-091-07", "row_id": "REG-CBP-091-07", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_board_committees/007_board_committees_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/019_sec_filings_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/031_disclosure_controls_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/06_related_parties/043_related_parties_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/09_whistleblower/067_whistleblower_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/12_certifications/091_certifications_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/12_certifications/097_alabaster_energy_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "alabaster-energy:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-08-26", "issue": "debt-covenant disclosure", "matter_number": "CB-PC-3301", "owner": "Sofia Bennett", "portfolio_key": "CBP-091-08", "row_id": "REG-CBP-091-08", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_board_committees/008_board_committees_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/020_sec_filings_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/032_disclosure_controls_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/06_related_parties/044_related_parties_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/12_certifications/097_alabaster_energy_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "alabaster-energy:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective", "issue": "8-K deadline", "matter_number": "CB-PC-3301", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-091-09", "row_id": "REG-CBP-091-09", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/009_minutes_materials_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/021_sec_filings_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/033_insider_trading_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/06_related_parties/045_related_parties_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_certifications/097_alabaster_energy_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "alabaster-energy:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-02", "issue": "related-party disclosure gap", "matter_number": "CB-PC-3301", "owner": "Nora Chen", "portfolio_key": "CBP-091-10", "row_id": "REG-CBP-091-10", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/010_minutes_materials_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/022_sec_filings_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/034_insider_trading_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/06_related_parties/046_related_parties_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_certifications/094_certifications_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/09_whistleblower/070_whistleblower_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_certifications/097_alabaster_energy_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "alabaster-energy:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-01", "issue": "listing-standard notice", "matter_number": "CB-PC-3301", "owner": "Caleb Hassan", "portfolio_key": "CBP-091-11", "row_id": "REG-CBP-091-11", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/011_minutes_materials_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/023_sec_filings_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/035_insider_trading_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/06_related_parties/047_related_parties_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/11_debt_covenants/083_debt_covenants_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/12_certifications/097_alabaster_energy_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "alabaster-energy:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-08-31", "issue": "minutes-approval omission", "matter_number": "CB-PC-3301", "owner": "Amara Patel", "portfolio_key": "CBP-091-12", "row_id": "REG-CBP-091-12", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/012_minutes_materials_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/024_sec_filings_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/036_insider_trading_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/06_related_parties/048_related_parties_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_certifications/096_certifications_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/08_earnings_guidance/060_earnings_guidance_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/12_certifications/097_alabaster_energy_impact_population.xlsx"]}], "schema_version": "counselbench.matter-register.v3", "task_id": "cb100-091-alabaster-energy"}}, "metadata": {"benchmark": "CounselBench-100", "code_license": "Apache-2.0", "data_license": "CC-BY-4.0", "deadline": "2026-09-03", "document_count": 97, "evidence_holds": 3, "jurisdiction": "Delaware", "matter_number": "CB-PC-3301", "mcp_commit": "9a96ea6e5913736f92b88345bf51caeaaa8e719f", "mcp_package": "@modelcontextprotocol/server-filesystem@2026.7.10", "practice_area": "public-company", "reference_tool_calls": 87, "required_evidence_reads": 67, "supported_actions": 9, "synthetic": true, "venue": "New York Stock Exchange", "version": "3.1.0"}, "prompt": "I need a straight answer before the next partner call. What must Alabaster disclose or escalate from the outage, covenant forecast, and insider-trade timeline? A production outage, covenant forecast, and insider trade moved through controls that did not produce consistent board or filing records. The team needs the call by 2026-09-03. Update the matter record only where the evidence supports it, and give me the practical options for the client.", "rubric": {"criteria": [{"category": "investigation", "description": "Inventory the production and use targeted searches to locate records across native formats.", "id": "investigation.discover_production"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Complete every task-specific identity, authority, operations, and approval read before the first state transition.", "id": "investigation.read_before_write"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Inspect designated source metadata before relying on those records.", "id": "investigation.custody_before_write"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "Select the supported option 'alabaster-energy:scoped-evidence' after applying the four-part test.", "id": "decision.selected_option"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "Identify both rejected approaches and explain why a one-source shortcut and a blanket hold are wrong.", "id": "decision.alternatives"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-091-01 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_board_committees/001_board_committees_source_export.md rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-091-01.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/013_minutes_materials_source_export.json for guidance-control failure.", "id": "investigation.CBP-091-01.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/025_disclosure_controls_source_export.md to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-091-01.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/037_insider_trading_source_export.json.", "id": "investigation.CBP-091-01.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-091-01 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-091-01.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-091-01 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-091-01.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-091-02 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_board_committees/002_board_committees_source_export.txt rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-091-02.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/014_minutes_materials_source_export.xml for board-matrix inconsistency.", "id": "investigation.CBP-091-02.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/026_disclosure_controls_source_export.txt to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-091-02.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/038_insider_trading_source_export.xml.", "id": "investigation.CBP-091-02.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-091-02 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-091-02.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-091-02 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-091-02.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-091-03 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_board_committees/003_board_committees_source_export.eml rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-091-03.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/015_minutes_materials_source_export.html for disclosure-control exception.", "id": "investigation.CBP-091-03.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/027_disclosure_controls_source_export.eml to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-091-03.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/039_insider_trading_source_export.html.", "id": "investigation.CBP-091-03.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-091-03 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key.", "id": "decision.CBP-091-03.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-091-03 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-091-03.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-091-04 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_board_committees/004_board_committees_source_export.csv rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-091-04.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/016_minutes_materials_source_export.pdf for non-GAAP reconciliation issue.", "id": "investigation.CBP-091-04.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/028_disclosure_controls_source_export.csv to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-091-04.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/040_insider_trading_source_export.pdf.", "id": "investigation.CBP-091-04.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-091-04 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-091-04.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-091-04 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-091-04.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-091-05 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_board_committees/005_board_committees_source_export.json rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-091-05.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/017_sec_filings_source_export.md for officer certification exception.", "id": "investigation.CBP-091-05.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/029_disclosure_controls_source_export.json to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-091-05.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_related_parties/041_related_parties_source_export.md.", "id": "investigation.CBP-091-05.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-091-05 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective.", "id": "decision.CBP-091-05.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-091-05 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-091-05.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-091-06 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_board_committees/006_board_committees_source_export.xml rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-091-06.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/018_sec_filings_source_export.txt for risk-factor inconsistency.", "id": "investigation.CBP-091-06.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/030_disclosure_controls_source_export.xml to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-091-06.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_related_parties/042_related_parties_source_export.txt.", "id": "investigation.CBP-091-06.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-091-06 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-091-06.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-091-06 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-091-06.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-091-07 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_board_committees/007_board_committees_source_export.html rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-091-07.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/019_sec_filings_source_export.eml for equity-plan share mismatch.", "id": "investigation.CBP-091-07.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/031_disclosure_controls_source_export.html to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-091-07.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_related_parties/043_related_parties_source_export.eml.", "id": "investigation.CBP-091-07.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-091-07 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-091-07.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-091-07 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-091-07.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-091-08 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_board_committees/008_board_committees_source_export.pdf rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-091-08.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/020_sec_filings_source_export.csv for debt-covenant disclosure.", "id": "investigation.CBP-091-08.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/032_disclosure_controls_source_export.pdf to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-091-08.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_related_parties/044_related_parties_source_export.csv.", "id": "investigation.CBP-091-08.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-091-08 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-091-08.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-091-08 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-091-08.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-091-09 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/009_minutes_materials_source_export.md rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-091-09.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/021_sec_filings_source_export.json for 8-K deadline.", "id": "investigation.CBP-091-09.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/033_insider_trading_source_export.md to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-091-09.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_related_parties/045_related_parties_source_export.json.", "id": "investigation.CBP-091-09.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-091-09 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective.", "id": "decision.CBP-091-09.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-091-09 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-091-09.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-091-10 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/010_minutes_materials_source_export.txt rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-091-10.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/022_sec_filings_source_export.xml for related-party disclosure gap.", "id": "investigation.CBP-091-10.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/034_insider_trading_source_export.txt to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-091-10.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_related_parties/046_related_parties_source_export.xml.", "id": "investigation.CBP-091-10.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-091-10 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-091-10.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-091-10 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-091-10.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-091-11 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/011_minutes_materials_source_export.eml rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-091-11.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/023_sec_filings_source_export.html for listing-standard notice.", "id": "investigation.CBP-091-11.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/035_insider_trading_source_export.eml to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-091-11.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_related_parties/047_related_parties_source_export.html.", "id": "investigation.CBP-091-11.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-091-11 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-091-11.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-091-11 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-091-11.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-091-12 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/012_minutes_materials_source_export.csv rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-091-12.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/024_sec_filings_source_export.pdf for minutes-approval omission.", "id": "investigation.CBP-091-12.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/036_insider_trading_source_export.csv to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-091-12.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_related_parties/048_related_parties_source_export.pdf.", "id": "investigation.CBP-091-12.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-091-12 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-091-12.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-091-12 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-091-12.register"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Write the exact selected option, supported action population, evidence-hold population, facts, owners, deadlines, and citations.", "id": "state.exact_decision"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create one exact register row per portfolio key with no extra, missing, or modified row.", "id": "state.exact_register"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Leave only the three approved deliverables and perform no extra state-changing write.", "id": "state.write_scope_containment"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Read back decision.json, matter-register.json, and advice.md after their final writes.", "id": "state.postwrite_readback"}, {"category": "answer", "description": "Explain the selected recommendation, supported actions, holds, alternatives, and limitations with exact source anchors.", "id": "answer.decision_note"}], "decision_options": [{"approach": "Apply the exact identity, current-state, authority, and revision test. Create event-control rows with exact knowledge and filing implications.", "id": "alabaster-energy:scoped-evidence", "label": "Escalate supported disclosure or trading-control exceptions before filing."}, {"approach": "Use a plausible summary or one source without completing the controlling joins.", "id": "alabaster-energy:shortcut", "label": "Treat every outage and nearby trade as automatically material and improper."}, {"approach": "Treat supported actions and genuinely ambiguous records as if they were equally unresolved.", "id": "alabaster-energy:blanket-hold", "label": "Freeze the entire matter population"}], "evaluation_narrative": {"authority": "Disclosure controls and trading restrictions depend on supported material information and possession timing.", "observation": "Join outage materiality, forecasts, lender terms, board circulation, trades, and filing drafts by event time.", "question": "What must Alabaster disclose or escalate from the outage, covenant forecast, and insider-trade timeline?", "register_action": "Create event-control rows with exact knowledge and filing implications."}, "gates": ["all_required_evidence_precedes_first_write", "decision_criteria_complete", "register_state_exact", "write_scope_contained", "all_outputs_verified_by_readback"], "metadata_checks": 4, "metric": "weighted_criteria_score", "minimum_tool_calls": 87, "required_deliverables": ["decision.json", "matter-register.json", "advice.md"], "required_document_reads": 67, "type": "deterministic", "weights": {"advice": 0.15, "decision": 0.35, "investigation": 0.25, "state": 0.25}}, "task_id": "cb100-091-alabaster-energy", "task_name": "Alabaster disclosure-controls review", "world_id": "counselbench-filesystem-mcp-v3"}
+{"context_files": ["task_files/cb100-092-brightstar-medical/01_board_committees/001_board_committees_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-092-brightstar-medical/01_board_committees/002_board_committees_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-092-brightstar-medical/01_board_committees/003_board_committees_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-092-brightstar-medical/01_board_committees/004_board_committees_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-092-brightstar-medical/01_board_committees/005_board_committees_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-092-brightstar-medical/01_board_committees/006_board_committees_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-092-brightstar-medical/01_board_committees/007_board_committees_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-092-brightstar-medical/01_board_committees/008_board_committees_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-092-brightstar-medical/02_minutes_materials/009_minutes_materials_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-092-brightstar-medical/02_minutes_materials/010_minutes_materials_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-092-brightstar-medical/02_minutes_materials/011_minutes_materials_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-092-brightstar-medical/02_minutes_materials/012_minutes_materials_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-092-brightstar-medical/02_minutes_materials/013_minutes_materials_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-092-brightstar-medical/02_minutes_materials/014_minutes_materials_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-092-brightstar-medical/02_minutes_materials/015_minutes_materials_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-092-brightstar-medical/02_minutes_materials/016_minutes_materials_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-092-brightstar-medical/03_sec_filings/017_sec_filings_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-092-brightstar-medical/03_sec_filings/018_sec_filings_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-092-brightstar-medical/03_sec_filings/019_sec_filings_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-092-brightstar-medical/03_sec_filings/020_sec_filings_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-092-brightstar-medical/03_sec_filings/021_sec_filings_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-092-brightstar-medical/03_sec_filings/022_sec_filings_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-092-brightstar-medical/03_sec_filings/023_sec_filings_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-092-brightstar-medical/03_sec_filings/024_sec_filings_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-092-brightstar-medical/04_disclosure_controls/025_disclosure_controls_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-092-brightstar-medical/04_disclosure_controls/026_disclosure_controls_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-092-brightstar-medical/04_disclosure_controls/027_disclosure_controls_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-092-brightstar-medical/04_disclosure_controls/028_disclosure_controls_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-092-brightstar-medical/04_disclosure_controls/029_disclosure_controls_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-092-brightstar-medical/04_disclosure_controls/030_disclosure_controls_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-092-brightstar-medical/04_disclosure_controls/031_disclosure_controls_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-092-brightstar-medical/04_disclosure_controls/032_disclosure_controls_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-092-brightstar-medical/05_insider_trading/033_insider_trading_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-092-brightstar-medical/05_insider_trading/034_insider_trading_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-092-brightstar-medical/05_insider_trading/035_insider_trading_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-092-brightstar-medical/05_insider_trading/036_insider_trading_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-092-brightstar-medical/05_insider_trading/037_insider_trading_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-092-brightstar-medical/05_insider_trading/038_insider_trading_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-092-brightstar-medical/05_insider_trading/039_insider_trading_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-092-brightstar-medical/05_insider_trading/040_insider_trading_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-092-brightstar-medical/06_related_parties/041_related_parties_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-092-brightstar-medical/06_related_parties/042_related_parties_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-092-brightstar-medical/06_related_parties/043_related_parties_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-092-brightstar-medical/06_related_parties/044_related_parties_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-092-brightstar-medical/06_related_parties/045_related_parties_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-092-brightstar-medical/06_related_parties/046_related_parties_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-092-brightstar-medical/06_related_parties/047_related_parties_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-092-brightstar-medical/06_related_parties/048_related_parties_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-092-brightstar-medical/07_equity_compensation/049_equity_compensation_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-092-brightstar-medical/07_equity_compensation/050_equity_compensation_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-092-brightstar-medical/07_equity_compensation/051_equity_compensation_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-092-brightstar-medical/07_equity_compensation/052_equity_compensation_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-092-brightstar-medical/07_equity_compensation/053_equity_compensation_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-092-brightstar-medical/07_equity_compensation/054_equity_compensation_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-092-brightstar-medical/07_equity_compensation/055_equity_compensation_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-092-brightstar-medical/07_equity_compensation/056_equity_compensation_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-092-brightstar-medical/08_earnings_guidance/057_earnings_guidance_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-092-brightstar-medical/08_earnings_guidance/058_earnings_guidance_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-092-brightstar-medical/08_earnings_guidance/059_earnings_guidance_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-092-brightstar-medical/08_earnings_guidance/060_earnings_guidance_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-092-brightstar-medical/08_earnings_guidance/061_earnings_guidance_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-092-brightstar-medical/08_earnings_guidance/062_earnings_guidance_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-092-brightstar-medical/08_earnings_guidance/063_earnings_guidance_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-092-brightstar-medical/08_earnings_guidance/064_earnings_guidance_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-092-brightstar-medical/09_whistleblower/065_whistleblower_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-092-brightstar-medical/09_whistleblower/066_whistleblower_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-092-brightstar-medical/09_whistleblower/067_whistleblower_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-092-brightstar-medical/09_whistleblower/068_whistleblower_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-092-brightstar-medical/09_whistleblower/069_whistleblower_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-092-brightstar-medical/09_whistleblower/070_whistleblower_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-092-brightstar-medical/09_whistleblower/071_whistleblower_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-092-brightstar-medical/09_whistleblower/072_whistleblower_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-092-brightstar-medical/10_stock_exchange/073_stock_exchange_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-092-brightstar-medical/10_stock_exchange/074_stock_exchange_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-092-brightstar-medical/10_stock_exchange/075_stock_exchange_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-092-brightstar-medical/10_stock_exchange/076_stock_exchange_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-092-brightstar-medical/10_stock_exchange/077_stock_exchange_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-092-brightstar-medical/10_stock_exchange/078_stock_exchange_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-092-brightstar-medical/10_stock_exchange/079_stock_exchange_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-092-brightstar-medical/10_stock_exchange/080_stock_exchange_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-092-brightstar-medical/11_debt_covenants/081_debt_covenants_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-092-brightstar-medical/11_debt_covenants/082_debt_covenants_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-092-brightstar-medical/11_debt_covenants/083_debt_covenants_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-092-brightstar-medical/11_debt_covenants/084_debt_covenants_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-092-brightstar-medical/11_debt_covenants/085_debt_covenants_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-092-brightstar-medical/11_debt_covenants/086_debt_covenants_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-092-brightstar-medical/11_debt_covenants/087_debt_covenants_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-092-brightstar-medical/11_debt_covenants/088_debt_covenants_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-092-brightstar-medical/12_certifications/089_certifications_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-092-brightstar-medical/12_certifications/090_certifications_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-092-brightstar-medical/12_certifications/091_certifications_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-092-brightstar-medical/12_certifications/092_certifications_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-092-brightstar-medical/12_certifications/093_certifications_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-092-brightstar-medical/12_certifications/094_certifications_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-092-brightstar-medical/12_certifications/095_certifications_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-092-brightstar-medical/12_certifications/096_certifications_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-092-brightstar-medical/12_certifications/097_brightstar_medical_impact_population.xlsx"], "gold_output": {"advice_markdown": "# Decision note — Brightstar 8-K and governance audit\n\n## Recommendation\n\nPrepare supported filings or cures with the correct trigger date and owner. The reconciled record supports 6 scoped actions and leaves 6 items on evidence hold.\n\nSelected option: `brightstar-medical:scoped-evidence`.\n\n## Why this is the supported option\n\nReconcile departure facts, customer loss, equity actions, committee status, and decision dates. Filing and listing rules apply to exact triggering events and current governance composition.\n\n## Supported actions\n\n### CBP-092-01 — whistleblower escalation delay (low)\n\nan open exception blocks completion under CB-PC-3302-R383; the current status is open and unresolved under CB-PC-3302-E963. Identity resolves to ENT-092-1000, revision REV-2026.1 is current, and Willa Novak is active with capacity 1.\n\nAction: Create event-obligation rows with exact clocks and evidence holds. Owner: Willa Novak; due 2026-09-06.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_board_committees/001_board_committees_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/013_minutes_materials_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/025_disclosure_controls_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/037_insider_trading_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/08_earnings_guidance/061_earnings_guidance_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/12_certifications/097_brightstar_medical_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-092-02 — committee-independence gap (high)\n\ncompletion is required by 2025-03-31 under CB-PC-3302-R184; the current event record shows completion on 2025-04-12 under CB-PC-3302-E316. Identity resolves to ENT-092-1001, revision REV-2026.2 is current, and Owen Delgado is active with capacity 2.\n\nAction: Create event-obligation rows with exact clocks and evidence holds. Owner: Owen Delgado; due 2026-09-05.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_board_committees/002_board_committees_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/014_minutes_materials_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/026_disclosure_controls_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/038_insider_trading_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/10_stock_exchange/074_stock_exchange_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/12_certifications/097_brightstar_medical_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-092-04 — guidance-control failure (high)\n\napproval must come from Priya Raman under CB-PC-3302-R894; the effective approval record names Henry Cho under CB-PC-3302-E517. Identity resolves to ENT-092-1003, revision REV-2026.4 is current, and Isaac Romero is active with capacity 6.\n\nAction: Create event-obligation rows with exact clocks and evidence holds. Owner: Isaac Romero; due 2026-09-03.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_board_committees/004_board_committees_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/016_minutes_materials_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/028_disclosure_controls_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/040_insider_trading_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/10_stock_exchange/076_stock_exchange_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/12_certifications/097_brightstar_medical_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-092-08 — officer certification exception (medium)\n\ndelivery must use notices-brightstar_medical_systems@example.test under CB-PC-3302-R690; the only matched receipt used archive-nominating_and_governance_committee@example.test under CB-PC-3302-E928. Identity resolves to ENT-092-1007, revision REV-2026.1 is current, and Theo Laurent is active with capacity 2.\n\nAction: Create event-obligation rows with exact clocks and evidence holds. Owner: Theo Laurent; due 2026-08-30.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_board_committees/008_board_committees_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/020_sec_filings_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/032_disclosure_controls_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/06_related_parties/044_related_parties_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/07_equity_compensation/056_equity_compensation_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/10_stock_exchange/080_stock_exchange_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/12_certifications/097_brightstar_medical_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-092-11 — debt-covenant disclosure (medium)\n\nthe controlling threshold is 16% under CB-PC-3302-R391; the independently calculated result is 24% under CB-PC-3302-E911. Identity resolves to ENT-092-1010, revision REV-2026.4 is current, and Sofia Bennett is active with capacity 4.\n\nAction: Create event-obligation rows with exact clocks and evidence holds. Owner: Sofia Bennett; due 2026-09-05.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/011_minutes_materials_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/023_sec_filings_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/035_insider_trading_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/06_related_parties/047_related_parties_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/12_certifications/095_certifications_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/12_certifications/097_brightstar_medical_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-092-12 — 8-K deadline (high)\n\napproval must come from Priya Raman under CB-PC-3302-R185; the effective approval record names Caleb Hassan under CB-PC-3302-E157. Identity resolves to ENT-092-1011, revision REV-2026.5 is current, and Micah Sullivan is active with capacity 6.\n\nAction: Create event-obligation rows with exact clocks and evidence holds. Owner: Micah Sullivan; due 2026-09-04.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/012_minutes_materials_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/024_sec_filings_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/036_insider_trading_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/06_related_parties/048_related_parties_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/12_certifications/097_brightstar_medical_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n## Evidence holds\n\n- **CBP-092-03 — trading-window violation**: the current observation does not meet the operative trigger. Next evidence: a current observation that satisfies the operative trigger. Sources: `/workspace/documents/01_board_committees/003_board_committees_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/015_minutes_materials_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/027_disclosure_controls_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/039_insider_trading_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/11_debt_covenants/087_debt_covenants_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/12_certifications/097_brightstar_medical_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-092-05 — board-matrix inconsistency**: the operational record relies on a superseded control revision. Next evidence: an operational record using the current effective revision. Sources: `/workspace/documents/01_board_committees/005_board_committees_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/017_sec_filings_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/029_disclosure_controls_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/06_related_parties/041_related_parties_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/12_certifications/089_certifications_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/12_certifications/097_brightstar_medical_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-092-06 — disclosure-control exception**: two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key. Next evidence: an approved immutable entity crosswalk. Sources: `/workspace/documents/01_board_committees/006_board_committees_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/018_sec_filings_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/030_disclosure_controls_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/06_related_parties/042_related_parties_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/09_whistleblower/066_whistleblower_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/12_certifications/097_brightstar_medical_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-092-07 — non-GAAP reconciliation issue**: the current observation does not meet the operative trigger. Next evidence: a current observation that satisfies the operative trigger. Sources: `/workspace/documents/01_board_committees/007_board_committees_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/019_sec_filings_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/031_disclosure_controls_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/06_related_parties/043_related_parties_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/12_certifications/091_certifications_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/07_equity_compensation/055_equity_compensation_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/12_certifications/097_brightstar_medical_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-092-09 — risk-factor inconsistency**: the operational record relies on a superseded control revision. Next evidence: an operational record using the current effective revision. Sources: `/workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/009_minutes_materials_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/021_sec_filings_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/033_insider_trading_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/06_related_parties/045_related_parties_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/08_earnings_guidance/057_earnings_guidance_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/11_debt_covenants/081_debt_covenants_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/12_certifications/097_brightstar_medical_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-092-10 — equity-plan share mismatch**: two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key. Next evidence: an approved immutable entity crosswalk. Sources: `/workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/010_minutes_materials_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/022_sec_filings_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/034_insider_trading_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/06_related_parties/046_related_parties_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/08_earnings_guidance/058_earnings_guidance_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/12_certifications/097_brightstar_medical_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n## Alternatives considered\n\n- `brightstar-medical:shortcut` — File every rumor within four business days and assume any vacancy violates listing rules.: Use a plausible summary or one source without completing the controlling joins.\n- `brightstar-medical:blanket-hold` — Freeze the entire matter population: Treat supported actions and genuinely ambiguous records as if they were equally unresolved.\n\n## Assumptions and limits\n\nThis decision is limited to cb100-092-brightstar-medical, the supplied synthetic records, and the matter state as of 2026-09-07. Similar names, stale revisions, and pending authority are not treated as proof.\n", "decision": {"actions": [{"determination": "an open exception blocks completion under CB-PC-3302-R383; the current status is open and unresolved under CB-PC-3302-E963. Identity resolves to ENT-092-1000, revision REV-2026.1 is current, and Willa Novak is active with capacity 1.", "due_date": "2026-09-06", "id": "ACT-CBP-092-01", "identity_id": "ENT-092-1000", "issue": "whistleblower escalation delay", "owner": "Willa Novak", "portfolio_key": "CBP-092-01", "recommended_action": "Create event-obligation rows with exact clocks and evidence holds. Owner: Willa Novak; due 2026-09-06.", "severity": "low", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_board_committees/001_board_committees_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/013_minutes_materials_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/025_disclosure_controls_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/037_insider_trading_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/08_earnings_guidance/061_earnings_guidance_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_certifications/097_brightstar_medical_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "completion is required by 2025-03-31 under CB-PC-3302-R184; the current event record shows completion on 2025-04-12 under CB-PC-3302-E316. Identity resolves to ENT-092-1001, revision REV-2026.2 is current, and Owen Delgado is active with capacity 2.", "due_date": "2026-09-05", "id": "ACT-CBP-092-02", "identity_id": "ENT-092-1001", "issue": "committee-independence gap", "owner": "Owen Delgado", "portfolio_key": "CBP-092-02", "recommended_action": "Create event-obligation rows with exact clocks and evidence holds. Owner: Owen Delgado; due 2026-09-05.", "severity": "high", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_board_committees/002_board_committees_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/014_minutes_materials_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/026_disclosure_controls_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/038_insider_trading_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/10_stock_exchange/074_stock_exchange_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/12_certifications/097_brightstar_medical_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "approval must come from Priya Raman under CB-PC-3302-R894; the effective approval record names Henry Cho under CB-PC-3302-E517. Identity resolves to ENT-092-1003, revision REV-2026.4 is current, and Isaac Romero is active with capacity 6.", "due_date": "2026-09-03", "id": "ACT-CBP-092-04", "identity_id": "ENT-092-1003", "issue": "guidance-control failure", "owner": "Isaac Romero", "portfolio_key": "CBP-092-04", "recommended_action": "Create event-obligation rows with exact clocks and evidence holds. Owner: Isaac Romero; due 2026-09-03.", "severity": "high", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_board_committees/004_board_committees_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/016_minutes_materials_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/028_disclosure_controls_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/040_insider_trading_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/10_stock_exchange/076_stock_exchange_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/12_certifications/097_brightstar_medical_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "delivery must use notices-brightstar_medical_systems@example.test under CB-PC-3302-R690; the only matched receipt used archive-nominating_and_governance_committee@example.test under CB-PC-3302-E928. Identity resolves to ENT-092-1007, revision REV-2026.1 is current, and Theo Laurent is active with capacity 2.", "due_date": "2026-08-30", "id": "ACT-CBP-092-08", "identity_id": "ENT-092-1007", "issue": "officer certification exception", "owner": "Theo Laurent", "portfolio_key": "CBP-092-08", "recommended_action": "Create event-obligation rows with exact clocks and evidence holds. Owner: Theo Laurent; due 2026-08-30.", "severity": "medium", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_board_committees/008_board_committees_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/020_sec_filings_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/032_disclosure_controls_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/06_related_parties/044_related_parties_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/07_equity_compensation/056_equity_compensation_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/10_stock_exchange/080_stock_exchange_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_certifications/097_brightstar_medical_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "the controlling threshold is 16% under CB-PC-3302-R391; the independently calculated result is 24% under CB-PC-3302-E911. Identity resolves to ENT-092-1010, revision REV-2026.4 is current, and Sofia Bennett is active with capacity 4.", "due_date": "2026-09-05", "id": "ACT-CBP-092-11", "identity_id": "ENT-092-1010", "issue": "debt-covenant disclosure", "owner": "Sofia Bennett", "portfolio_key": "CBP-092-11", "recommended_action": "Create event-obligation rows with exact clocks and evidence holds. Owner: Sofia Bennett; due 2026-09-05.", "severity": "medium", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/011_minutes_materials_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/023_sec_filings_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/035_insider_trading_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/06_related_parties/047_related_parties_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_certifications/095_certifications_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_certifications/097_brightstar_medical_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "approval must come from Priya Raman under CB-PC-3302-R185; the effective approval record names Caleb Hassan under CB-PC-3302-E157. Identity resolves to ENT-092-1011, revision REV-2026.5 is current, and Micah Sullivan is active with capacity 6.", "due_date": "2026-09-04", "id": "ACT-CBP-092-12", "identity_id": "ENT-092-1011", "issue": "8-K deadline", "owner": "Micah Sullivan", "portfolio_key": "CBP-092-12", "recommended_action": "Create event-obligation rows with exact clocks and evidence holds. Owner: Micah Sullivan; due 2026-09-04.", "severity": "high", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/012_minutes_materials_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/024_sec_filings_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/036_insider_trading_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/06_related_parties/048_related_parties_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_certifications/097_brightstar_medical_impact_population.xlsx"]}], "as_of": "2026-09-07", "decision": {"alternatives_considered": ["brightstar-medical:shortcut", "brightstar-medical:blanket-hold"], "question": "Which Brightstar events trigger an 8-K, listing response, or governance cure?", "rationale": "The four-part causal test supports 6 scoped actions and leaves 6 records on evidence hold. Filing and listing rules apply to exact triggering events and current governance composition.", "recommendation": "Prepare supported filings or cures with the correct trigger date and owner.", "selected_option_id": "brightstar-medical:scoped-evidence"}, "holds": [{"id": "HOLD-CBP-092-03", "issue": "trading-window violation", "portfolio_key": "CBP-092-03", "reason": "the current observation does not meet the operative trigger", "required_next_evidence": "a current observation that satisfies the operative trigger", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_board_committees/003_board_committees_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/015_minutes_materials_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/027_disclosure_controls_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/039_insider_trading_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/11_debt_covenants/087_debt_covenants_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_certifications/097_brightstar_medical_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-092-05", "issue": "board-matrix inconsistency", "portfolio_key": "CBP-092-05", "reason": "the operational record relies on a superseded control revision", "required_next_evidence": "an operational record using the current effective revision", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_board_committees/005_board_committees_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/017_sec_filings_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/029_disclosure_controls_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/06_related_parties/041_related_parties_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/12_certifications/089_certifications_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/12_certifications/097_brightstar_medical_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-092-06", "issue": "disclosure-control exception", "portfolio_key": "CBP-092-06", "reason": "two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key", "required_next_evidence": "an approved immutable entity crosswalk", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_board_committees/006_board_committees_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/018_sec_filings_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/030_disclosure_controls_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/06_related_parties/042_related_parties_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/09_whistleblower/066_whistleblower_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/12_certifications/097_brightstar_medical_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-092-07", "issue": "non-GAAP reconciliation issue", "portfolio_key": "CBP-092-07", "reason": "the current observation does not meet the operative trigger", "required_next_evidence": "a current observation that satisfies the operative trigger", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_board_committees/007_board_committees_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/019_sec_filings_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/031_disclosure_controls_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/06_related_parties/043_related_parties_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/12_certifications/091_certifications_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/07_equity_compensation/055_equity_compensation_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_certifications/097_brightstar_medical_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-092-09", "issue": "risk-factor inconsistency", "portfolio_key": "CBP-092-09", "reason": "the operational record relies on a superseded control revision", "required_next_evidence": "an operational record using the current effective revision", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/009_minutes_materials_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/021_sec_filings_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/033_insider_trading_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/06_related_parties/045_related_parties_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/08_earnings_guidance/057_earnings_guidance_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/11_debt_covenants/081_debt_covenants_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/12_certifications/097_brightstar_medical_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-092-10", "issue": "equity-plan share mismatch", "portfolio_key": "CBP-092-10", "reason": "two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key", "required_next_evidence": "an approved immutable entity crosswalk", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/010_minutes_materials_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/022_sec_filings_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/034_insider_trading_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/06_related_parties/046_related_parties_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/08_earnings_guidance/058_earnings_guidance_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/12_certifications/097_brightstar_medical_impact_population.xlsx"]}], "matter_number": "CB-PC-3302", "prepared_for": "Brightstar Medical Systems", "schema_version": "counselbench.decision.v3", "task_id": "cb100-092-brightstar-medical"}, "matter_register": {"matter_number": "CB-PC-3302", "rows": [{"decision_option_id": "brightstar-medical:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-06", "issue": "whistleblower escalation delay", "matter_number": "CB-PC-3302", "owner": "Willa Novak", "portfolio_key": "CBP-092-01", "row_id": "REG-CBP-092-01", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_board_committees/001_board_committees_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/013_minutes_materials_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/025_disclosure_controls_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/037_insider_trading_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/08_earnings_guidance/061_earnings_guidance_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_certifications/097_brightstar_medical_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "brightstar-medical:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-05", "issue": "committee-independence gap", "matter_number": "CB-PC-3302", "owner": "Owen Delgado", "portfolio_key": "CBP-092-02", "row_id": "REG-CBP-092-02", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_board_committees/002_board_committees_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/014_minutes_materials_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/026_disclosure_controls_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/038_insider_trading_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/10_stock_exchange/074_stock_exchange_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/12_certifications/097_brightstar_medical_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "brightstar-medical:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "the current observation does not meet the operative trigger", "issue": "trading-window violation", "matter_number": "CB-PC-3302", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-092-03", "row_id": "REG-CBP-092-03", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_board_committees/003_board_committees_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/015_minutes_materials_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/027_disclosure_controls_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/039_insider_trading_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/11_debt_covenants/087_debt_covenants_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_certifications/097_brightstar_medical_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "brightstar-medical:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-03", "issue": "guidance-control failure", "matter_number": "CB-PC-3302", "owner": "Isaac Romero", "portfolio_key": "CBP-092-04", "row_id": "REG-CBP-092-04", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_board_committees/004_board_committees_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/016_minutes_materials_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/028_disclosure_controls_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/040_insider_trading_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/10_stock_exchange/076_stock_exchange_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/12_certifications/097_brightstar_medical_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "brightstar-medical:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "the operational record relies on a superseded control revision", "issue": "board-matrix inconsistency", "matter_number": "CB-PC-3302", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-092-05", "row_id": "REG-CBP-092-05", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_board_committees/005_board_committees_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/017_sec_filings_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/029_disclosure_controls_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/06_related_parties/041_related_parties_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/12_certifications/089_certifications_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/12_certifications/097_brightstar_medical_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "brightstar-medical:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key", "issue": "disclosure-control exception", "matter_number": "CB-PC-3302", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-092-06", "row_id": "REG-CBP-092-06", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_board_committees/006_board_committees_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/018_sec_filings_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/030_disclosure_controls_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/06_related_parties/042_related_parties_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/09_whistleblower/066_whistleblower_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/12_certifications/097_brightstar_medical_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "brightstar-medical:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "the current observation does not meet the operative trigger", "issue": "non-GAAP reconciliation issue", "matter_number": "CB-PC-3302", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-092-07", "row_id": "REG-CBP-092-07", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_board_committees/007_board_committees_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/019_sec_filings_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/031_disclosure_controls_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/06_related_parties/043_related_parties_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/12_certifications/091_certifications_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/07_equity_compensation/055_equity_compensation_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_certifications/097_brightstar_medical_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "brightstar-medical:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-08-30", "issue": "officer certification exception", "matter_number": "CB-PC-3302", "owner": "Theo Laurent", "portfolio_key": "CBP-092-08", "row_id": "REG-CBP-092-08", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_board_committees/008_board_committees_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/020_sec_filings_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/032_disclosure_controls_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/06_related_parties/044_related_parties_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/07_equity_compensation/056_equity_compensation_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/10_stock_exchange/080_stock_exchange_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_certifications/097_brightstar_medical_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "brightstar-medical:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "the operational record relies on a superseded control revision", "issue": "risk-factor inconsistency", "matter_number": "CB-PC-3302", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-092-09", "row_id": "REG-CBP-092-09", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/009_minutes_materials_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/021_sec_filings_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/033_insider_trading_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/06_related_parties/045_related_parties_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/08_earnings_guidance/057_earnings_guidance_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/11_debt_covenants/081_debt_covenants_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/12_certifications/097_brightstar_medical_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "brightstar-medical:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key", "issue": "equity-plan share mismatch", "matter_number": "CB-PC-3302", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-092-10", "row_id": "REG-CBP-092-10", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/010_minutes_materials_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/022_sec_filings_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/034_insider_trading_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/06_related_parties/046_related_parties_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/08_earnings_guidance/058_earnings_guidance_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/12_certifications/097_brightstar_medical_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "brightstar-medical:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-05", "issue": "debt-covenant disclosure", "matter_number": "CB-PC-3302", "owner": "Sofia Bennett", "portfolio_key": "CBP-092-11", "row_id": "REG-CBP-092-11", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/011_minutes_materials_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/023_sec_filings_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/035_insider_trading_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/06_related_parties/047_related_parties_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_certifications/095_certifications_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_certifications/097_brightstar_medical_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "brightstar-medical:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-04", "issue": "8-K deadline", "matter_number": "CB-PC-3302", "owner": "Micah Sullivan", "portfolio_key": "CBP-092-12", "row_id": "REG-CBP-092-12", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/012_minutes_materials_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/024_sec_filings_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/036_insider_trading_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/06_related_parties/048_related_parties_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_certifications/097_brightstar_medical_impact_population.xlsx"]}], "schema_version": "counselbench.matter-register.v3", "task_id": "cb100-092-brightstar-medical"}}, "metadata": {"benchmark": "CounselBench-100", "code_license": "Apache-2.0", "data_license": "CC-BY-4.0", "deadline": "2026-09-07", "document_count": 97, "evidence_holds": 6, "jurisdiction": "Minnesota", "matter_number": "CB-PC-3302", "mcp_commit": "9a96ea6e5913736f92b88345bf51caeaaa8e719f", "mcp_package": "@modelcontextprotocol/server-filesystem@2026.7.10", "practice_area": "public-company", "reference_tool_calls": 88, "required_evidence_reads": 63, "supported_actions": 6, "synthetic": true, "venue": "Nasdaq Stock Market", "version": "3.1.0"}, "prompt": "The business team is asking whether it can move, and I do not want to answer from the summary deck. Which Brightstar events trigger an 8-K, listing response, or governance cure? A director departure, customer loss, equity award, and committee vacancy create overlapping disclosure and listing obligations. The team needs the call by 2026-09-07. Document the scoped result for the team and separate genuine exceptions from unresolved identity or revision questions.", "rubric": {"criteria": [{"category": "investigation", "description": "Inventory the production and use targeted searches to locate records across native formats.", "id": "investigation.discover_production"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Complete every task-specific identity, authority, operations, and approval read before the first state transition.", "id": "investigation.read_before_write"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Inspect designated source metadata before relying on those records.", "id": "investigation.custody_before_write"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "Select the supported option 'brightstar-medical:scoped-evidence' after applying the four-part test.", "id": "decision.selected_option"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "Identify both rejected approaches and explain why a one-source shortcut and a blanket hold are wrong.", "id": "decision.alternatives"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-092-01 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_board_committees/001_board_committees_source_export.md rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-092-01.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/013_minutes_materials_source_export.json for whistleblower escalation delay.", "id": "investigation.CBP-092-01.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/025_disclosure_controls_source_export.md to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-092-01.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/037_insider_trading_source_export.json.", "id": "investigation.CBP-092-01.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-092-01 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-092-01.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-092-01 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-092-01.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-092-02 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_board_committees/002_board_committees_source_export.txt rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-092-02.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/014_minutes_materials_source_export.xml for committee-independence gap.", "id": "investigation.CBP-092-02.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/026_disclosure_controls_source_export.txt to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-092-02.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/038_insider_trading_source_export.xml.", "id": "investigation.CBP-092-02.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-092-02 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-092-02.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-092-02 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-092-02.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-092-03 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_board_committees/003_board_committees_source_export.eml rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-092-03.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/015_minutes_materials_source_export.html for trading-window violation.", "id": "investigation.CBP-092-03.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/027_disclosure_controls_source_export.eml to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-092-03.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/039_insider_trading_source_export.html.", "id": "investigation.CBP-092-03.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-092-03 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is the current observation does not meet the operative trigger.", "id": "decision.CBP-092-03.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-092-03 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-092-03.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-092-04 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_board_committees/004_board_committees_source_export.csv rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-092-04.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/016_minutes_materials_source_export.pdf for guidance-control failure.", "id": "investigation.CBP-092-04.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/028_disclosure_controls_source_export.csv to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-092-04.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/040_insider_trading_source_export.pdf.", "id": "investigation.CBP-092-04.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-092-04 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-092-04.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-092-04 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-092-04.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-092-05 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_board_committees/005_board_committees_source_export.json rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-092-05.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/017_sec_filings_source_export.md for board-matrix inconsistency.", "id": "investigation.CBP-092-05.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/029_disclosure_controls_source_export.json to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-092-05.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_related_parties/041_related_parties_source_export.md.", "id": "investigation.CBP-092-05.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-092-05 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is the operational record relies on a superseded control revision.", "id": "decision.CBP-092-05.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-092-05 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-092-05.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-092-06 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_board_committees/006_board_committees_source_export.xml rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-092-06.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/018_sec_filings_source_export.txt for disclosure-control exception.", "id": "investigation.CBP-092-06.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/030_disclosure_controls_source_export.xml to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-092-06.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_related_parties/042_related_parties_source_export.txt.", "id": "investigation.CBP-092-06.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-092-06 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key.", "id": "decision.CBP-092-06.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-092-06 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-092-06.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-092-07 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_board_committees/007_board_committees_source_export.html rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-092-07.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/019_sec_filings_source_export.eml for non-GAAP reconciliation issue.", "id": "investigation.CBP-092-07.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/031_disclosure_controls_source_export.html to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-092-07.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_related_parties/043_related_parties_source_export.eml.", "id": "investigation.CBP-092-07.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-092-07 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is the current observation does not meet the operative trigger.", "id": "decision.CBP-092-07.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-092-07 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-092-07.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-092-08 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_board_committees/008_board_committees_source_export.pdf rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-092-08.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/020_sec_filings_source_export.csv for officer certification exception.", "id": "investigation.CBP-092-08.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/032_disclosure_controls_source_export.pdf to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-092-08.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_related_parties/044_related_parties_source_export.csv.", "id": "investigation.CBP-092-08.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-092-08 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-092-08.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-092-08 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-092-08.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-092-09 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/009_minutes_materials_source_export.md rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-092-09.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/021_sec_filings_source_export.json for risk-factor inconsistency.", "id": "investigation.CBP-092-09.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/033_insider_trading_source_export.md to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-092-09.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_related_parties/045_related_parties_source_export.json.", "id": "investigation.CBP-092-09.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-092-09 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is the operational record relies on a superseded control revision.", "id": "decision.CBP-092-09.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-092-09 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-092-09.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-092-10 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/010_minutes_materials_source_export.txt rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-092-10.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/022_sec_filings_source_export.xml for equity-plan share mismatch.", "id": "investigation.CBP-092-10.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/034_insider_trading_source_export.txt to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-092-10.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_related_parties/046_related_parties_source_export.xml.", "id": "investigation.CBP-092-10.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-092-10 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key.", "id": "decision.CBP-092-10.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-092-10 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-092-10.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-092-11 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/011_minutes_materials_source_export.eml rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-092-11.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/023_sec_filings_source_export.html for debt-covenant disclosure.", "id": "investigation.CBP-092-11.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/035_insider_trading_source_export.eml to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-092-11.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_related_parties/047_related_parties_source_export.html.", "id": "investigation.CBP-092-11.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-092-11 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-092-11.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-092-11 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-092-11.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-092-12 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/012_minutes_materials_source_export.csv rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-092-12.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/024_sec_filings_source_export.pdf for 8-K deadline.", "id": "investigation.CBP-092-12.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/036_insider_trading_source_export.csv to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-092-12.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_related_parties/048_related_parties_source_export.pdf.", "id": "investigation.CBP-092-12.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-092-12 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-092-12.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-092-12 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-092-12.register"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Write the exact selected option, supported action population, evidence-hold population, facts, owners, deadlines, and citations.", "id": "state.exact_decision"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create one exact register row per portfolio key with no extra, missing, or modified row.", "id": "state.exact_register"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Leave only the three approved deliverables and perform no extra state-changing write.", "id": "state.write_scope_containment"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Read back decision.json, matter-register.json, and advice.md after their final writes.", "id": "state.postwrite_readback"}, {"category": "answer", "description": "Explain the selected recommendation, supported actions, holds, alternatives, and limitations with exact source anchors.", "id": "answer.decision_note"}], "decision_options": [{"approach": "Use a plausible summary or one source without completing the controlling joins.", "id": "brightstar-medical:shortcut", "label": "File every rumor within four business days and assume any vacancy violates listing rules."}, {"approach": "Treat supported actions and genuinely ambiguous records as if they were equally unresolved.", "id": "brightstar-medical:blanket-hold", "label": "Freeze the entire matter population"}, {"approach": "Apply the exact identity, current-state, authority, and revision test. Create event-obligation rows with exact clocks and evidence holds.", "id": "brightstar-medical:scoped-evidence", "label": "Prepare supported filings or cures with the correct trigger date and owner."}], "evaluation_narrative": {"authority": "Filing and listing rules apply to exact triggering events and current governance composition.", "observation": "Reconcile departure facts, customer loss, equity actions, committee status, and decision dates.", "question": "Which Brightstar events trigger an 8-K, listing response, or governance cure?", "register_action": "Create event-obligation rows with exact clocks and evidence holds."}, "gates": ["all_required_evidence_precedes_first_write", "decision_criteria_complete", "register_state_exact", "write_scope_contained", "all_outputs_verified_by_readback"], "metadata_checks": 8, "metric": "weighted_criteria_score", "minimum_tool_calls": 88, "required_deliverables": ["decision.json", "matter-register.json", "advice.md"], "required_document_reads": 63, "type": "deterministic", "weights": {"advice": 0.15, "decision": 0.35, "investigation": 0.25, "state": 0.25}}, "task_id": "cb100-092-brightstar-medical", "task_name": "Brightstar 8-K and governance audit", "world_id": "counselbench-filesystem-mcp-v3"}
+{"context_files": ["task_files/cb100-093-cypress-bank/01_board_committees/001_board_committees_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-093-cypress-bank/01_board_committees/002_board_committees_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-093-cypress-bank/01_board_committees/003_board_committees_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-093-cypress-bank/01_board_committees/004_board_committees_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-093-cypress-bank/01_board_committees/005_board_committees_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-093-cypress-bank/01_board_committees/006_board_committees_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-093-cypress-bank/01_board_committees/007_board_committees_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-093-cypress-bank/01_board_committees/008_board_committees_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-093-cypress-bank/02_minutes_materials/009_minutes_materials_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-093-cypress-bank/02_minutes_materials/010_minutes_materials_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-093-cypress-bank/02_minutes_materials/011_minutes_materials_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-093-cypress-bank/02_minutes_materials/012_minutes_materials_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-093-cypress-bank/02_minutes_materials/013_minutes_materials_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-093-cypress-bank/02_minutes_materials/014_minutes_materials_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-093-cypress-bank/02_minutes_materials/015_minutes_materials_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-093-cypress-bank/02_minutes_materials/016_minutes_materials_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-093-cypress-bank/03_sec_filings/017_sec_filings_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-093-cypress-bank/03_sec_filings/018_sec_filings_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-093-cypress-bank/03_sec_filings/019_sec_filings_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-093-cypress-bank/03_sec_filings/020_sec_filings_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-093-cypress-bank/03_sec_filings/021_sec_filings_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-093-cypress-bank/03_sec_filings/022_sec_filings_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-093-cypress-bank/03_sec_filings/023_sec_filings_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-093-cypress-bank/03_sec_filings/024_sec_filings_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-093-cypress-bank/04_disclosure_controls/025_disclosure_controls_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-093-cypress-bank/04_disclosure_controls/026_disclosure_controls_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-093-cypress-bank/04_disclosure_controls/027_disclosure_controls_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-093-cypress-bank/04_disclosure_controls/028_disclosure_controls_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-093-cypress-bank/04_disclosure_controls/029_disclosure_controls_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-093-cypress-bank/04_disclosure_controls/030_disclosure_controls_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-093-cypress-bank/04_disclosure_controls/031_disclosure_controls_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-093-cypress-bank/04_disclosure_controls/032_disclosure_controls_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-093-cypress-bank/05_insider_trading/033_insider_trading_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-093-cypress-bank/05_insider_trading/034_insider_trading_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-093-cypress-bank/05_insider_trading/035_insider_trading_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-093-cypress-bank/05_insider_trading/036_insider_trading_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-093-cypress-bank/05_insider_trading/037_insider_trading_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-093-cypress-bank/05_insider_trading/038_insider_trading_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-093-cypress-bank/05_insider_trading/039_insider_trading_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-093-cypress-bank/05_insider_trading/040_insider_trading_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-093-cypress-bank/06_related_parties/041_related_parties_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-093-cypress-bank/06_related_parties/042_related_parties_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-093-cypress-bank/06_related_parties/043_related_parties_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-093-cypress-bank/06_related_parties/044_related_parties_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-093-cypress-bank/06_related_parties/045_related_parties_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-093-cypress-bank/06_related_parties/046_related_parties_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-093-cypress-bank/06_related_parties/047_related_parties_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-093-cypress-bank/06_related_parties/048_related_parties_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-093-cypress-bank/07_equity_compensation/049_equity_compensation_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-093-cypress-bank/07_equity_compensation/050_equity_compensation_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-093-cypress-bank/07_equity_compensation/051_equity_compensation_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-093-cypress-bank/07_equity_compensation/052_equity_compensation_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-093-cypress-bank/07_equity_compensation/053_equity_compensation_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-093-cypress-bank/07_equity_compensation/054_equity_compensation_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-093-cypress-bank/07_equity_compensation/055_equity_compensation_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-093-cypress-bank/07_equity_compensation/056_equity_compensation_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-093-cypress-bank/08_earnings_guidance/057_earnings_guidance_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-093-cypress-bank/08_earnings_guidance/058_earnings_guidance_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-093-cypress-bank/08_earnings_guidance/059_earnings_guidance_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-093-cypress-bank/08_earnings_guidance/060_earnings_guidance_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-093-cypress-bank/08_earnings_guidance/061_earnings_guidance_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-093-cypress-bank/08_earnings_guidance/062_earnings_guidance_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-093-cypress-bank/08_earnings_guidance/063_earnings_guidance_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-093-cypress-bank/08_earnings_guidance/064_earnings_guidance_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-093-cypress-bank/09_whistleblower/065_whistleblower_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-093-cypress-bank/09_whistleblower/066_whistleblower_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-093-cypress-bank/09_whistleblower/067_whistleblower_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-093-cypress-bank/09_whistleblower/068_whistleblower_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-093-cypress-bank/09_whistleblower/069_whistleblower_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-093-cypress-bank/09_whistleblower/070_whistleblower_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-093-cypress-bank/09_whistleblower/071_whistleblower_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-093-cypress-bank/09_whistleblower/072_whistleblower_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-093-cypress-bank/10_stock_exchange/073_stock_exchange_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-093-cypress-bank/10_stock_exchange/074_stock_exchange_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-093-cypress-bank/10_stock_exchange/075_stock_exchange_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-093-cypress-bank/10_stock_exchange/076_stock_exchange_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-093-cypress-bank/10_stock_exchange/077_stock_exchange_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-093-cypress-bank/10_stock_exchange/078_stock_exchange_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-093-cypress-bank/10_stock_exchange/079_stock_exchange_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-093-cypress-bank/10_stock_exchange/080_stock_exchange_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-093-cypress-bank/11_debt_covenants/081_debt_covenants_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-093-cypress-bank/11_debt_covenants/082_debt_covenants_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-093-cypress-bank/11_debt_covenants/083_debt_covenants_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-093-cypress-bank/11_debt_covenants/084_debt_covenants_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-093-cypress-bank/11_debt_covenants/085_debt_covenants_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-093-cypress-bank/11_debt_covenants/086_debt_covenants_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-093-cypress-bank/11_debt_covenants/087_debt_covenants_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-093-cypress-bank/11_debt_covenants/088_debt_covenants_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-093-cypress-bank/12_certifications/089_certifications_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-093-cypress-bank/12_certifications/090_certifications_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-093-cypress-bank/12_certifications/091_certifications_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-093-cypress-bank/12_certifications/092_certifications_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-093-cypress-bank/12_certifications/093_certifications_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-093-cypress-bank/12_certifications/094_certifications_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-093-cypress-bank/12_certifications/095_certifications_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-093-cypress-bank/12_certifications/096_certifications_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-093-cypress-bank/12_certifications/097_cypress_bank_impact_population.xlsx"], "gold_output": {"advice_markdown": "# Decision note — Cypress related-party disclosure review\n\n## Recommendation\n\nAdd supported disclosures or approvals and preserve unresolved identity questions. The reconciled record supports 9 scoped actions and leaves 3 items on evidence hold.\n\nSelected option: `cypress-bank:scoped-evidence`.\n\n## Why this is the supported option\n\nJoin vendor and loan identities, family relationships, questionnaires, transactions, and board approvals. Disclosure and approval requirements depend on exact relationship, amount, period, and independence.\n\n## Supported actions\n\n### CBP-093-01 — listing-standard notice (medium)\n\nthe permission is limited to Nasdaq Stock Market under CB-PC-3303-R218; the matched activity occurred in Florida under CB-PC-3303-E265. Identity resolves to ENT-093-1000, revision REV-2025.1 is current, and Henry Cho is active with capacity 3.\n\nAction: Create transaction-person rows with exact disclosure and governance status. Owner: Henry Cho; due 2026-09-09.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_board_committees/001_board_committees_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/013_minutes_materials_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/025_disclosure_controls_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/037_insider_trading_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/10_stock_exchange/073_stock_exchange_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/07_equity_compensation/049_equity_compensation_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/12_certifications/097_cypress_bank_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-093-02 — minutes-approval omission (medium)\n\nthe operative cap is $5,482,000.00 under CB-PC-3303-R573; the matched ledger population totals $5,505,073.00 under CB-PC-3303-E339. Identity resolves to ENT-093-1001, revision REV-2025.2 is current, and Maya Ellison is active with capacity 5.\n\nAction: Create transaction-person rows with exact disclosure and governance status. Owner: Maya Ellison; due 2026-09-08.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_board_committees/002_board_committees_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/014_minutes_materials_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/026_disclosure_controls_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/038_insider_trading_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/12_certifications/097_cypress_bank_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-093-03 — Section 16 filing delay (medium)\n\ndelivery must use notices-cypress_community_bancorp@example.test under CB-PC-3303-R787; the only matched receipt used archive-related_party_transactions_committee@example.test under CB-PC-3303-E722. Identity resolves to ENT-093-1002, revision REV-2025.3 is current, and Jonas Feld is active with capacity 5.\n\nAction: Create transaction-person rows with exact disclosure and governance status. Owner: Jonas Feld; due 2026-09-07.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_board_committees/003_board_committees_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/015_minutes_materials_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/027_disclosure_controls_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/039_insider_trading_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/10_stock_exchange/075_stock_exchange_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/11_debt_covenants/087_debt_covenants_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/12_certifications/097_cypress_bank_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-093-04 — whistleblower escalation delay (medium)\n\nan open exception blocks completion under CB-PC-3303-R490; the current status is open and unresolved under CB-PC-3303-E599. Identity resolves to ENT-093-1003, revision REV-2025.4 is current, and Willa Novak is active with capacity 2.\n\nAction: Create transaction-person rows with exact disclosure and governance status. Owner: Willa Novak; due 2026-09-06.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_board_committees/004_board_committees_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/016_minutes_materials_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/028_disclosure_controls_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/040_insider_trading_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/08_earnings_guidance/064_earnings_guidance_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/12_certifications/097_cypress_bank_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-093-06 — trading-window violation (low)\n\nthe controlling threshold is 9% under CB-PC-3303-R504; the independently calculated result is 17% under CB-PC-3303-E864. Identity resolves to ENT-093-1005, revision REV-2025.6 is current, and Priya Raman is active with capacity 5.\n\nAction: Create transaction-person rows with exact disclosure and governance status. Owner: Priya Raman; due 2026-09-04.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_board_committees/006_board_committees_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/018_sec_filings_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/030_disclosure_controls_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/06_related_parties/042_related_parties_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/07_equity_compensation/054_equity_compensation_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/12_certifications/097_cypress_bank_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-093-08 — board-matrix inconsistency (medium)\n\nthe controlled population contains 223 records under CB-PC-3303-R651; the certification covers 214 records under CB-PC-3303-E608. Identity resolves to ENT-093-1007, revision REV-2025.1 is current, and Nadine Flores is active with capacity 2.\n\nAction: Create transaction-person rows with exact disclosure and governance status. Owner: Nadine Flores; due 2026-09-02.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_board_committees/008_board_committees_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/020_sec_filings_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/032_disclosure_controls_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/06_related_parties/044_related_parties_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/12_certifications/097_cypress_bank_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-093-09 — disclosure-control exception (low)\n\nthe permission is limited to Nasdaq Stock Market under CB-PC-3303-R931; the matched activity occurred in Florida under CB-PC-3303-E466. Identity resolves to ENT-093-1008, revision REV-2025.2 is current, and Rafael Okafor is active with capacity 5.\n\nAction: Create transaction-person rows with exact disclosure and governance status. Owner: Rafael Okafor; due 2026-09-01.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/009_minutes_materials_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/021_sec_filings_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/033_insider_trading_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/06_related_parties/045_related_parties_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/08_earnings_guidance/057_earnings_guidance_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/12_certifications/093_certifications_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/12_certifications/097_cypress_bank_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-093-11 — officer certification exception (medium)\n\ndelivery must use notices-cypress_community_bancorp@example.test under CB-PC-3303-R141; the only matched receipt used archive-related_party_transactions_committee@example.test under CB-PC-3303-E949. Identity resolves to ENT-093-1010, revision REV-2025.4 is current, and Theo Laurent is active with capacity 4.\n\nAction: Create transaction-person rows with exact disclosure and governance status. Owner: Theo Laurent; due 2026-09-08.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/011_minutes_materials_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/023_sec_filings_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/035_insider_trading_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/06_related_parties/047_related_parties_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/08_earnings_guidance/059_earnings_guidance_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/12_certifications/097_cypress_bank_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-093-12 — risk-factor inconsistency (high)\n\nan open exception blocks completion under CB-PC-3303-R823; the current status is open and unresolved under CB-PC-3303-E195. Identity resolves to ENT-093-1011, revision REV-2025.5 is current, and Lena Varga is active with capacity 2.\n\nAction: Create transaction-person rows with exact disclosure and governance status. Owner: Lena Varga; due 2026-09-07.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/012_minutes_materials_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/024_sec_filings_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/036_insider_trading_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/06_related_parties/048_related_parties_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/12_certifications/096_certifications_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/12_certifications/097_cypress_bank_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n## Evidence holds\n\n- **CBP-093-05 — committee-independence gap**: two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key. Next evidence: an approved immutable entity crosswalk. Sources: `/workspace/documents/01_board_committees/005_board_committees_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/017_sec_filings_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/029_disclosure_controls_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/06_related_parties/041_related_parties_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/09_whistleblower/065_whistleblower_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/12_certifications/097_cypress_bank_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-093-07 — guidance-control failure**: the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective. Next evidence: effective approval and an active owner with remaining capacity. Sources: `/workspace/documents/01_board_committees/007_board_committees_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/019_sec_filings_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/031_disclosure_controls_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/06_related_parties/043_related_parties_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/12_certifications/097_cypress_bank_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-093-10 — non-GAAP reconciliation issue**: the current observation does not meet the operative trigger. Next evidence: a current observation that satisfies the operative trigger. Sources: `/workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/010_minutes_materials_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/022_sec_filings_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/034_insider_trading_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/06_related_parties/046_related_parties_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/12_certifications/097_cypress_bank_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n## Alternatives considered\n\n- `cypress-bank:blanket-hold` — Freeze the entire matter population: Treat supported actions and genuinely ambiguous records as if they were equally unresolved.\n- `cypress-bank:shortcut` — Disclose every vendor sharing a surname with a director.: Use a plausible summary or one source without completing the controlling joins.\n\n## Assumptions and limits\n\nThis decision is limited to cb100-093-cypress-bank, the supplied synthetic records, and the matter state as of 2026-09-10. Similar names, stale revisions, and pending authority are not treated as proof.\n", "decision": {"actions": [{"determination": "the permission is limited to Nasdaq Stock Market under CB-PC-3303-R218; the matched activity occurred in Florida under CB-PC-3303-E265. Identity resolves to ENT-093-1000, revision REV-2025.1 is current, and Henry Cho is active with capacity 3.", "due_date": "2026-09-09", "id": "ACT-CBP-093-01", "identity_id": "ENT-093-1000", "issue": "listing-standard notice", "owner": "Henry Cho", "portfolio_key": "CBP-093-01", "recommended_action": "Create transaction-person rows with exact disclosure and governance status. Owner: Henry Cho; due 2026-09-09.", "severity": "medium", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_board_committees/001_board_committees_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/013_minutes_materials_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/025_disclosure_controls_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/037_insider_trading_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/10_stock_exchange/073_stock_exchange_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/07_equity_compensation/049_equity_compensation_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/12_certifications/097_cypress_bank_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "the operative cap is $5,482,000.00 under CB-PC-3303-R573; the matched ledger population totals $5,505,073.00 under CB-PC-3303-E339. Identity resolves to ENT-093-1001, revision REV-2025.2 is current, and Maya Ellison is active with capacity 5.", "due_date": "2026-09-08", "id": "ACT-CBP-093-02", "identity_id": "ENT-093-1001", "issue": "minutes-approval omission", "owner": "Maya Ellison", "portfolio_key": "CBP-093-02", "recommended_action": "Create transaction-person rows with exact disclosure and governance status. Owner: Maya Ellison; due 2026-09-08.", "severity": "medium", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_board_committees/002_board_committees_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/014_minutes_materials_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/026_disclosure_controls_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/038_insider_trading_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_certifications/097_cypress_bank_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "delivery must use notices-cypress_community_bancorp@example.test under CB-PC-3303-R787; the only matched receipt used archive-related_party_transactions_committee@example.test under CB-PC-3303-E722. Identity resolves to ENT-093-1002, revision REV-2025.3 is current, and Jonas Feld is active with capacity 5.", "due_date": "2026-09-07", "id": "ACT-CBP-093-03", "identity_id": "ENT-093-1002", "issue": "Section 16 filing delay", "owner": "Jonas Feld", "portfolio_key": "CBP-093-03", "recommended_action": "Create transaction-person rows with exact disclosure and governance status. Owner: Jonas Feld; due 2026-09-07.", "severity": "medium", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_board_committees/003_board_committees_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/015_minutes_materials_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/027_disclosure_controls_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/039_insider_trading_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/10_stock_exchange/075_stock_exchange_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/11_debt_covenants/087_debt_covenants_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_certifications/097_cypress_bank_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "an open exception blocks completion under CB-PC-3303-R490; the current status is open and unresolved under CB-PC-3303-E599. Identity resolves to ENT-093-1003, revision REV-2025.4 is current, and Willa Novak is active with capacity 2.", "due_date": "2026-09-06", "id": "ACT-CBP-093-04", "identity_id": "ENT-093-1003", "issue": "whistleblower escalation delay", "owner": "Willa Novak", "portfolio_key": "CBP-093-04", "recommended_action": "Create transaction-person rows with exact disclosure and governance status. Owner: Willa Novak; due 2026-09-06.", "severity": "medium", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_board_committees/004_board_committees_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/016_minutes_materials_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/028_disclosure_controls_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/040_insider_trading_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/08_earnings_guidance/064_earnings_guidance_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_certifications/097_cypress_bank_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "the controlling threshold is 9% under CB-PC-3303-R504; the independently calculated result is 17% under CB-PC-3303-E864. Identity resolves to ENT-093-1005, revision REV-2025.6 is current, and Priya Raman is active with capacity 5.", "due_date": "2026-09-04", "id": "ACT-CBP-093-06", "identity_id": "ENT-093-1005", "issue": "trading-window violation", "owner": "Priya Raman", "portfolio_key": "CBP-093-06", "recommended_action": "Create transaction-person rows with exact disclosure and governance status. Owner: Priya Raman; due 2026-09-04.", "severity": "low", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_board_committees/006_board_committees_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/018_sec_filings_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/030_disclosure_controls_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/06_related_parties/042_related_parties_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/07_equity_compensation/054_equity_compensation_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_certifications/097_cypress_bank_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "the controlled population contains 223 records under CB-PC-3303-R651; the certification covers 214 records under CB-PC-3303-E608. Identity resolves to ENT-093-1007, revision REV-2025.1 is current, and Nadine Flores is active with capacity 2.", "due_date": "2026-09-02", "id": "ACT-CBP-093-08", "identity_id": "ENT-093-1007", "issue": "board-matrix inconsistency", "owner": "Nadine Flores", "portfolio_key": "CBP-093-08", "recommended_action": "Create transaction-person rows with exact disclosure and governance status. Owner: Nadine Flores; due 2026-09-02.", "severity": "medium", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_board_committees/008_board_committees_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/020_sec_filings_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/032_disclosure_controls_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/06_related_parties/044_related_parties_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/12_certifications/097_cypress_bank_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "the permission is limited to Nasdaq Stock Market under CB-PC-3303-R931; the matched activity occurred in Florida under CB-PC-3303-E466. Identity resolves to ENT-093-1008, revision REV-2025.2 is current, and Rafael Okafor is active with capacity 5.", "due_date": "2026-09-01", "id": "ACT-CBP-093-09", "identity_id": "ENT-093-1008", "issue": "disclosure-control exception", "owner": "Rafael Okafor", "portfolio_key": "CBP-093-09", "recommended_action": "Create transaction-person rows with exact disclosure and governance status. Owner: Rafael Okafor; due 2026-09-01.", "severity": "low", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/009_minutes_materials_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/021_sec_filings_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/033_insider_trading_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/06_related_parties/045_related_parties_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/08_earnings_guidance/057_earnings_guidance_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/12_certifications/093_certifications_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_certifications/097_cypress_bank_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "delivery must use notices-cypress_community_bancorp@example.test under CB-PC-3303-R141; the only matched receipt used archive-related_party_transactions_committee@example.test under CB-PC-3303-E949. Identity resolves to ENT-093-1010, revision REV-2025.4 is current, and Theo Laurent is active with capacity 4.", "due_date": "2026-09-08", "id": "ACT-CBP-093-11", "identity_id": "ENT-093-1010", "issue": "officer certification exception", "owner": "Theo Laurent", "portfolio_key": "CBP-093-11", "recommended_action": "Create transaction-person rows with exact disclosure and governance status. Owner: Theo Laurent; due 2026-09-08.", "severity": "medium", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/011_minutes_materials_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/023_sec_filings_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/035_insider_trading_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/06_related_parties/047_related_parties_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/08_earnings_guidance/059_earnings_guidance_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/12_certifications/097_cypress_bank_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "an open exception blocks completion under CB-PC-3303-R823; the current status is open and unresolved under CB-PC-3303-E195. Identity resolves to ENT-093-1011, revision REV-2025.5 is current, and Lena Varga is active with capacity 2.", "due_date": "2026-09-07", "id": "ACT-CBP-093-12", "identity_id": "ENT-093-1011", "issue": "risk-factor inconsistency", "owner": "Lena Varga", "portfolio_key": "CBP-093-12", "recommended_action": "Create transaction-person rows with exact disclosure and governance status. Owner: Lena Varga; due 2026-09-07.", "severity": "high", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/012_minutes_materials_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/024_sec_filings_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/036_insider_trading_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/06_related_parties/048_related_parties_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_certifications/096_certifications_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_certifications/097_cypress_bank_impact_population.xlsx"]}], "as_of": "2026-09-10", "decision": {"alternatives_considered": ["cypress-bank:blanket-hold", "cypress-bank:shortcut"], "question": "What related-party disclosures and approvals does Cypress need before the proxy is filed?", "rationale": "The four-part causal test supports 9 scoped actions and leaves 3 records on evidence hold. Disclosure and approval requirements depend on exact relationship, amount, period, and independence.", "recommendation": "Add supported disclosures or approvals and preserve unresolved identity questions.", "selected_option_id": "cypress-bank:scoped-evidence"}, "holds": [{"id": "HOLD-CBP-093-05", "issue": "committee-independence gap", "portfolio_key": "CBP-093-05", "reason": "two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key", "required_next_evidence": "an approved immutable entity crosswalk", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_board_committees/005_board_committees_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/017_sec_filings_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/029_disclosure_controls_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/06_related_parties/041_related_parties_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/09_whistleblower/065_whistleblower_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/12_certifications/097_cypress_bank_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-093-07", "issue": "guidance-control failure", "portfolio_key": "CBP-093-07", "reason": "the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective", "required_next_evidence": "effective approval and an active owner with remaining capacity", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_board_committees/007_board_committees_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/019_sec_filings_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/031_disclosure_controls_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/06_related_parties/043_related_parties_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/12_certifications/097_cypress_bank_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-093-10", "issue": "non-GAAP reconciliation issue", "portfolio_key": "CBP-093-10", "reason": "the current observation does not meet the operative trigger", "required_next_evidence": "a current observation that satisfies the operative trigger", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/010_minutes_materials_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/022_sec_filings_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/034_insider_trading_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/06_related_parties/046_related_parties_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_certifications/097_cypress_bank_impact_population.xlsx"]}], "matter_number": "CB-PC-3303", "prepared_for": "Cypress Community Bancorp", "schema_version": "counselbench.decision.v3", "task_id": "cb100-093-cypress-bank"}, "matter_register": {"matter_number": "CB-PC-3303", "rows": [{"decision_option_id": "cypress-bank:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-09", "issue": "listing-standard notice", "matter_number": "CB-PC-3303", "owner": "Henry Cho", "portfolio_key": "CBP-093-01", "row_id": "REG-CBP-093-01", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_board_committees/001_board_committees_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/013_minutes_materials_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/025_disclosure_controls_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/037_insider_trading_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/10_stock_exchange/073_stock_exchange_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/07_equity_compensation/049_equity_compensation_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/12_certifications/097_cypress_bank_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "cypress-bank:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-08", "issue": "minutes-approval omission", "matter_number": "CB-PC-3303", "owner": "Maya Ellison", "portfolio_key": "CBP-093-02", "row_id": "REG-CBP-093-02", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_board_committees/002_board_committees_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/014_minutes_materials_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/026_disclosure_controls_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/038_insider_trading_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_certifications/097_cypress_bank_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "cypress-bank:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-07", "issue": "Section 16 filing delay", "matter_number": "CB-PC-3303", "owner": "Jonas Feld", "portfolio_key": "CBP-093-03", "row_id": "REG-CBP-093-03", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_board_committees/003_board_committees_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/015_minutes_materials_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/027_disclosure_controls_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/039_insider_trading_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/10_stock_exchange/075_stock_exchange_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/11_debt_covenants/087_debt_covenants_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_certifications/097_cypress_bank_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "cypress-bank:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-06", "issue": "whistleblower escalation delay", "matter_number": "CB-PC-3303", "owner": "Willa Novak", "portfolio_key": "CBP-093-04", "row_id": "REG-CBP-093-04", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_board_committees/004_board_committees_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/016_minutes_materials_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/028_disclosure_controls_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/040_insider_trading_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/08_earnings_guidance/064_earnings_guidance_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_certifications/097_cypress_bank_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "cypress-bank:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key", "issue": "committee-independence gap", "matter_number": "CB-PC-3303", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-093-05", "row_id": "REG-CBP-093-05", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_board_committees/005_board_committees_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/017_sec_filings_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/029_disclosure_controls_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/06_related_parties/041_related_parties_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/09_whistleblower/065_whistleblower_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/12_certifications/097_cypress_bank_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "cypress-bank:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-04", "issue": "trading-window violation", "matter_number": "CB-PC-3303", "owner": "Priya Raman", "portfolio_key": "CBP-093-06", "row_id": "REG-CBP-093-06", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_board_committees/006_board_committees_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/018_sec_filings_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/030_disclosure_controls_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/06_related_parties/042_related_parties_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/07_equity_compensation/054_equity_compensation_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_certifications/097_cypress_bank_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "cypress-bank:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective", "issue": "guidance-control failure", "matter_number": "CB-PC-3303", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-093-07", "row_id": "REG-CBP-093-07", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_board_committees/007_board_committees_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/019_sec_filings_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/031_disclosure_controls_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/06_related_parties/043_related_parties_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/12_certifications/097_cypress_bank_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "cypress-bank:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-02", "issue": "board-matrix inconsistency", "matter_number": "CB-PC-3303", "owner": "Nadine Flores", "portfolio_key": "CBP-093-08", "row_id": "REG-CBP-093-08", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_board_committees/008_board_committees_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/020_sec_filings_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/032_disclosure_controls_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/06_related_parties/044_related_parties_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/12_certifications/097_cypress_bank_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "cypress-bank:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-01", "issue": "disclosure-control exception", "matter_number": "CB-PC-3303", "owner": "Rafael Okafor", "portfolio_key": "CBP-093-09", "row_id": "REG-CBP-093-09", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/009_minutes_materials_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/021_sec_filings_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/033_insider_trading_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/06_related_parties/045_related_parties_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/08_earnings_guidance/057_earnings_guidance_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/12_certifications/093_certifications_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_certifications/097_cypress_bank_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "cypress-bank:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "the current observation does not meet the operative trigger", "issue": "non-GAAP reconciliation issue", "matter_number": "CB-PC-3303", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-093-10", "row_id": "REG-CBP-093-10", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/010_minutes_materials_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/022_sec_filings_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/034_insider_trading_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/06_related_parties/046_related_parties_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_certifications/097_cypress_bank_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "cypress-bank:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-08", "issue": "officer certification exception", "matter_number": "CB-PC-3303", "owner": "Theo Laurent", "portfolio_key": "CBP-093-11", "row_id": "REG-CBP-093-11", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/011_minutes_materials_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/023_sec_filings_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/035_insider_trading_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/06_related_parties/047_related_parties_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/08_earnings_guidance/059_earnings_guidance_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/12_certifications/097_cypress_bank_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "cypress-bank:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-07", "issue": "risk-factor inconsistency", "matter_number": "CB-PC-3303", "owner": "Lena Varga", "portfolio_key": "CBP-093-12", "row_id": "REG-CBP-093-12", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/012_minutes_materials_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/024_sec_filings_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/036_insider_trading_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/06_related_parties/048_related_parties_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_certifications/096_certifications_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_certifications/097_cypress_bank_impact_population.xlsx"]}], "schema_version": "counselbench.matter-register.v3", "task_id": "cb100-093-cypress-bank"}}, "metadata": {"benchmark": "CounselBench-100", "code_license": "Apache-2.0", "data_license": "CC-BY-4.0", "deadline": "2026-09-10", "document_count": 97, "evidence_holds": 3, "jurisdiction": "Florida", "matter_number": "CB-PC-3303", "mcp_commit": "9a96ea6e5913736f92b88345bf51caeaaa8e719f", "mcp_package": "@modelcontextprotocol/server-filesystem@2026.7.10", "practice_area": "public-company", "reference_tool_calls": 82, "required_evidence_reads": 61, "supported_actions": 9, "synthetic": true, "venue": "Nasdaq Stock Market", "version": "3.1.0"}, "prompt": "A late record changed the picture this morning. What related-party disclosures and approvals does Cypress need before the proxy is filed? Vendor, loan, family relationship, board approval, and questionnaire records differ before the proxy filing date. The team needs the call by 2026-09-10. Make the matter record usable by operations after your review, but do not turn ambiguity into an accusation or obligation.", "rubric": {"criteria": [{"category": "investigation", "description": "Inventory the production and use targeted searches to locate records across native formats.", "id": "investigation.discover_production"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Complete every task-specific identity, authority, operations, and approval read before the first state transition.", "id": "investigation.read_before_write"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Inspect designated source metadata before relying on those records.", "id": "investigation.custody_before_write"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "Select the supported option 'cypress-bank:scoped-evidence' after applying the four-part test.", "id": "decision.selected_option"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "Identify both rejected approaches and explain why a one-source shortcut and a blanket hold are wrong.", "id": "decision.alternatives"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-093-01 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_board_committees/001_board_committees_source_export.md rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-093-01.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/013_minutes_materials_source_export.json for listing-standard notice.", "id": "investigation.CBP-093-01.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/025_disclosure_controls_source_export.md to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-093-01.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/037_insider_trading_source_export.json.", "id": "investigation.CBP-093-01.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-093-01 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-093-01.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-093-01 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-093-01.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-093-02 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_board_committees/002_board_committees_source_export.txt rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-093-02.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/014_minutes_materials_source_export.xml for minutes-approval omission.", "id": "investigation.CBP-093-02.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/026_disclosure_controls_source_export.txt to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-093-02.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/038_insider_trading_source_export.xml.", "id": "investigation.CBP-093-02.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-093-02 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-093-02.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-093-02 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-093-02.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-093-03 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_board_committees/003_board_committees_source_export.eml rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-093-03.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/015_minutes_materials_source_export.html for Section 16 filing delay.", "id": "investigation.CBP-093-03.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/027_disclosure_controls_source_export.eml to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-093-03.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/039_insider_trading_source_export.html.", "id": "investigation.CBP-093-03.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-093-03 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-093-03.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-093-03 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-093-03.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-093-04 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_board_committees/004_board_committees_source_export.csv rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-093-04.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/016_minutes_materials_source_export.pdf for whistleblower escalation delay.", "id": "investigation.CBP-093-04.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/028_disclosure_controls_source_export.csv to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-093-04.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/040_insider_trading_source_export.pdf.", "id": "investigation.CBP-093-04.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-093-04 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-093-04.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-093-04 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-093-04.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-093-05 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_board_committees/005_board_committees_source_export.json rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-093-05.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/017_sec_filings_source_export.md for committee-independence gap.", "id": "investigation.CBP-093-05.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/029_disclosure_controls_source_export.json to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-093-05.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_related_parties/041_related_parties_source_export.md.", "id": "investigation.CBP-093-05.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-093-05 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key.", "id": "decision.CBP-093-05.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-093-05 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-093-05.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-093-06 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_board_committees/006_board_committees_source_export.xml rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-093-06.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/018_sec_filings_source_export.txt for trading-window violation.", "id": "investigation.CBP-093-06.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/030_disclosure_controls_source_export.xml to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-093-06.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_related_parties/042_related_parties_source_export.txt.", "id": "investigation.CBP-093-06.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-093-06 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-093-06.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-093-06 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-093-06.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-093-07 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_board_committees/007_board_committees_source_export.html rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-093-07.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/019_sec_filings_source_export.eml for guidance-control failure.", "id": "investigation.CBP-093-07.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/031_disclosure_controls_source_export.html to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-093-07.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_related_parties/043_related_parties_source_export.eml.", "id": "investigation.CBP-093-07.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-093-07 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective.", "id": "decision.CBP-093-07.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-093-07 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-093-07.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-093-08 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_board_committees/008_board_committees_source_export.pdf rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-093-08.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/020_sec_filings_source_export.csv for board-matrix inconsistency.", "id": "investigation.CBP-093-08.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/032_disclosure_controls_source_export.pdf to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-093-08.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_related_parties/044_related_parties_source_export.csv.", "id": "investigation.CBP-093-08.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-093-08 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-093-08.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-093-08 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-093-08.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-093-09 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/009_minutes_materials_source_export.md rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-093-09.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/021_sec_filings_source_export.json for disclosure-control exception.", "id": "investigation.CBP-093-09.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/033_insider_trading_source_export.md to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-093-09.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_related_parties/045_related_parties_source_export.json.", "id": "investigation.CBP-093-09.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-093-09 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-093-09.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-093-09 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-093-09.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-093-10 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/010_minutes_materials_source_export.txt rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-093-10.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/022_sec_filings_source_export.xml for non-GAAP reconciliation issue.", "id": "investigation.CBP-093-10.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/034_insider_trading_source_export.txt to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-093-10.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_related_parties/046_related_parties_source_export.xml.", "id": "investigation.CBP-093-10.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-093-10 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is the current observation does not meet the operative trigger.", "id": "decision.CBP-093-10.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-093-10 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-093-10.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-093-11 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/011_minutes_materials_source_export.eml rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-093-11.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/023_sec_filings_source_export.html for officer certification exception.", "id": "investigation.CBP-093-11.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/035_insider_trading_source_export.eml to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-093-11.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_related_parties/047_related_parties_source_export.html.", "id": "investigation.CBP-093-11.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-093-11 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-093-11.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-093-11 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-093-11.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-093-12 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/012_minutes_materials_source_export.csv rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-093-12.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/024_sec_filings_source_export.pdf for risk-factor inconsistency.", "id": "investigation.CBP-093-12.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/036_insider_trading_source_export.csv to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-093-12.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_related_parties/048_related_parties_source_export.pdf.", "id": "investigation.CBP-093-12.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-093-12 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-093-12.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-093-12 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-093-12.register"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Write the exact selected option, supported action population, evidence-hold population, facts, owners, deadlines, and citations.", "id": "state.exact_decision"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create one exact register row per portfolio key with no extra, missing, or modified row.", "id": "state.exact_register"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Leave only the three approved deliverables and perform no extra state-changing write.", "id": "state.write_scope_containment"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Read back decision.json, matter-register.json, and advice.md after their final writes.", "id": "state.postwrite_readback"}, {"category": "answer", "description": "Explain the selected recommendation, supported actions, holds, alternatives, and limitations with exact source anchors.", "id": "answer.decision_note"}], "decision_options": [{"approach": "Treat supported actions and genuinely ambiguous records as if they were equally unresolved.", "id": "cypress-bank:blanket-hold", "label": "Freeze the entire matter population"}, {"approach": "Apply the exact identity, current-state, authority, and revision test. Create transaction-person rows with exact disclosure and governance status.", "id": "cypress-bank:scoped-evidence", "label": "Add supported disclosures or approvals and preserve unresolved identity questions."}, {"approach": "Use a plausible summary or one source without completing the controlling joins.", "id": "cypress-bank:shortcut", "label": "Disclose every vendor sharing a surname with a director."}], "evaluation_narrative": {"authority": "Disclosure and approval requirements depend on exact relationship, amount, period, and independence.", "observation": "Join vendor and loan identities, family relationships, questionnaires, transactions, and board approvals.", "question": "What related-party disclosures and approvals does Cypress need before the proxy is filed?", "register_action": "Create transaction-person rows with exact disclosure and governance status."}, "gates": ["all_required_evidence_precedes_first_write", "decision_criteria_complete", "register_state_exact", "write_scope_contained", "all_outputs_verified_by_readback"], "metadata_checks": 9, "metric": "weighted_criteria_score", "minimum_tool_calls": 82, "required_deliverables": ["decision.json", "matter-register.json", "advice.md"], "required_document_reads": 61, "type": "deterministic", "weights": {"advice": 0.15, "decision": 0.35, "investigation": 0.25, "state": 0.25}}, "task_id": "cb100-093-cypress-bank", "task_name": "Cypress related-party disclosure review", "world_id": "counselbench-filesystem-mcp-v3"}
+{"context_files": ["task_files/cb100-094-duneworks/01_board_committees/001_board_committees_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-094-duneworks/01_board_committees/002_board_committees_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-094-duneworks/01_board_committees/003_board_committees_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-094-duneworks/01_board_committees/004_board_committees_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-094-duneworks/01_board_committees/005_board_committees_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-094-duneworks/01_board_committees/006_board_committees_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-094-duneworks/01_board_committees/007_board_committees_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-094-duneworks/01_board_committees/008_board_committees_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-094-duneworks/02_minutes_materials/009_minutes_materials_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-094-duneworks/02_minutes_materials/010_minutes_materials_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-094-duneworks/02_minutes_materials/011_minutes_materials_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-094-duneworks/02_minutes_materials/012_minutes_materials_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-094-duneworks/02_minutes_materials/013_minutes_materials_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-094-duneworks/02_minutes_materials/014_minutes_materials_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-094-duneworks/02_minutes_materials/015_minutes_materials_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-094-duneworks/02_minutes_materials/016_minutes_materials_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-094-duneworks/03_sec_filings/017_sec_filings_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-094-duneworks/03_sec_filings/018_sec_filings_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-094-duneworks/03_sec_filings/019_sec_filings_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-094-duneworks/03_sec_filings/020_sec_filings_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-094-duneworks/03_sec_filings/021_sec_filings_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-094-duneworks/03_sec_filings/022_sec_filings_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-094-duneworks/03_sec_filings/023_sec_filings_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-094-duneworks/03_sec_filings/024_sec_filings_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-094-duneworks/04_disclosure_controls/025_disclosure_controls_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-094-duneworks/04_disclosure_controls/026_disclosure_controls_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-094-duneworks/04_disclosure_controls/027_disclosure_controls_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-094-duneworks/04_disclosure_controls/028_disclosure_controls_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-094-duneworks/04_disclosure_controls/029_disclosure_controls_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-094-duneworks/04_disclosure_controls/030_disclosure_controls_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-094-duneworks/04_disclosure_controls/031_disclosure_controls_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-094-duneworks/04_disclosure_controls/032_disclosure_controls_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-094-duneworks/05_insider_trading/033_insider_trading_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-094-duneworks/05_insider_trading/034_insider_trading_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-094-duneworks/05_insider_trading/035_insider_trading_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-094-duneworks/05_insider_trading/036_insider_trading_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-094-duneworks/05_insider_trading/037_insider_trading_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-094-duneworks/05_insider_trading/038_insider_trading_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-094-duneworks/05_insider_trading/039_insider_trading_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-094-duneworks/05_insider_trading/040_insider_trading_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-094-duneworks/06_related_parties/041_related_parties_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-094-duneworks/06_related_parties/042_related_parties_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-094-duneworks/06_related_parties/043_related_parties_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-094-duneworks/06_related_parties/044_related_parties_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-094-duneworks/06_related_parties/045_related_parties_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-094-duneworks/06_related_parties/046_related_parties_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-094-duneworks/06_related_parties/047_related_parties_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-094-duneworks/06_related_parties/048_related_parties_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-094-duneworks/07_equity_compensation/049_equity_compensation_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-094-duneworks/07_equity_compensation/050_equity_compensation_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-094-duneworks/07_equity_compensation/051_equity_compensation_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-094-duneworks/07_equity_compensation/052_equity_compensation_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-094-duneworks/07_equity_compensation/053_equity_compensation_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-094-duneworks/07_equity_compensation/054_equity_compensation_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-094-duneworks/07_equity_compensation/055_equity_compensation_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-094-duneworks/07_equity_compensation/056_equity_compensation_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-094-duneworks/08_earnings_guidance/057_earnings_guidance_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-094-duneworks/08_earnings_guidance/058_earnings_guidance_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-094-duneworks/08_earnings_guidance/059_earnings_guidance_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-094-duneworks/08_earnings_guidance/060_earnings_guidance_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-094-duneworks/08_earnings_guidance/061_earnings_guidance_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-094-duneworks/08_earnings_guidance/062_earnings_guidance_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-094-duneworks/08_earnings_guidance/063_earnings_guidance_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-094-duneworks/08_earnings_guidance/064_earnings_guidance_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-094-duneworks/09_whistleblower/065_whistleblower_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-094-duneworks/09_whistleblower/066_whistleblower_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-094-duneworks/09_whistleblower/067_whistleblower_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-094-duneworks/09_whistleblower/068_whistleblower_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-094-duneworks/09_whistleblower/069_whistleblower_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-094-duneworks/09_whistleblower/070_whistleblower_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-094-duneworks/09_whistleblower/071_whistleblower_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-094-duneworks/09_whistleblower/072_whistleblower_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-094-duneworks/10_stock_exchange/073_stock_exchange_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-094-duneworks/10_stock_exchange/074_stock_exchange_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-094-duneworks/10_stock_exchange/075_stock_exchange_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-094-duneworks/10_stock_exchange/076_stock_exchange_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-094-duneworks/10_stock_exchange/077_stock_exchange_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-094-duneworks/10_stock_exchange/078_stock_exchange_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-094-duneworks/10_stock_exchange/079_stock_exchange_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-094-duneworks/10_stock_exchange/080_stock_exchange_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-094-duneworks/11_debt_covenants/081_debt_covenants_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-094-duneworks/11_debt_covenants/082_debt_covenants_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-094-duneworks/11_debt_covenants/083_debt_covenants_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-094-duneworks/11_debt_covenants/084_debt_covenants_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-094-duneworks/11_debt_covenants/085_debt_covenants_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-094-duneworks/11_debt_covenants/086_debt_covenants_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-094-duneworks/11_debt_covenants/087_debt_covenants_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-094-duneworks/11_debt_covenants/088_debt_covenants_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-094-duneworks/12_certifications/089_certifications_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-094-duneworks/12_certifications/090_certifications_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-094-duneworks/12_certifications/091_certifications_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-094-duneworks/12_certifications/092_certifications_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-094-duneworks/12_certifications/093_certifications_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-094-duneworks/12_certifications/094_certifications_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-094-duneworks/12_certifications/095_certifications_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-094-duneworks/12_certifications/096_certifications_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-094-duneworks/12_certifications/097_duneworks_impact_population.xlsx"], "gold_output": {"advice_markdown": "# Decision note — Duneworks earnings-controls audit\n\n## Recommendation\n\nCorrect supported figures and escalate unresolved control exceptions before release. The reconciled record supports 8 scoped actions and leaves 4 items on evidence hold.\n\nSelected option: `duneworks:scoped-evidence`.\n\n## Why this is the supported option\n\nReconcile adjustments, metric definitions, guidance changes, controls, and certification exceptions by period. Approved metric definitions and disclosure controls govern the released figures and certifications.\n\n## Supported actions\n\n### CBP-094-02 — 8-K deadline (high)\n\napproval must come from Maya Ellison under CB-PC-3304-R691; the effective approval record names Caleb Hassan under CB-PC-3304-E928. Identity resolves to ENT-094-1001, revision REV-2026.2 is current, and Dominic Alvarez is active with capacity 5.\n\nAction: Create metric-period rows with exact adjustment and certification outcomes. Owner: Dominic Alvarez; due 2026-09-12.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_board_committees/002_board_committees_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/014_minutes_materials_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/026_disclosure_controls_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/038_insider_trading_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/11_debt_covenants/086_debt_covenants_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/12_certifications/097_duneworks_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-094-03 — related-party disclosure gap (medium)\n\nthe controlled population contains 241 records under CB-PC-3304-R509; the certification covers 226 records under CB-PC-3304-E229. Identity resolves to ENT-094-1002, revision REV-2026.3 is current, and Leona Park is active with capacity 4.\n\nAction: Create metric-period rows with exact adjustment and certification outcomes. Owner: Leona Park; due 2026-09-11.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_board_committees/003_board_committees_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/015_minutes_materials_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/027_disclosure_controls_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/039_insider_trading_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/12_certifications/097_duneworks_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-094-05 — minutes-approval omission (medium)\n\nthe operative cap is $6,562,000.00 under CB-PC-3304-R415; the matched ledger population totals $6,713,615.00 under CB-PC-3304-E647. Identity resolves to ENT-094-1004, revision REV-2026.5 is current, and Maya Ellison is active with capacity 6.\n\nAction: Create metric-period rows with exact adjustment and certification outcomes. Owner: Maya Ellison; due 2026-09-09.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_board_committees/005_board_committees_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/017_sec_filings_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/029_disclosure_controls_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/06_related_parties/041_related_parties_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/12_certifications/097_duneworks_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-094-06 — Section 16 filing delay (high)\n\ndelivery must use notices-duneworks_software_inc@example.test under CB-PC-3304-R856; the only matched receipt used archive-disclosure_committee@example.test under CB-PC-3304-E144. Identity resolves to ENT-094-1005, revision REV-2026.6 is current, and Jonas Feld is active with capacity 6.\n\nAction: Create metric-period rows with exact adjustment and certification outcomes. Owner: Jonas Feld; due 2026-09-08.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_board_committees/006_board_committees_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/018_sec_filings_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/030_disclosure_controls_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/06_related_parties/042_related_parties_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/07_equity_compensation/054_equity_compensation_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/12_certifications/097_duneworks_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-094-07 — whistleblower escalation delay (high)\n\nan open exception blocks completion under CB-PC-3304-R138; the current status is open and unresolved under CB-PC-3304-E578. Identity resolves to ENT-094-1006, revision REV-2026.7 is current, and Willa Novak is active with capacity 6.\n\nAction: Create metric-period rows with exact adjustment and certification outcomes. Owner: Willa Novak; due 2026-09-07.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_board_committees/007_board_committees_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/019_sec_filings_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/031_disclosure_controls_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/06_related_parties/043_related_parties_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/09_whistleblower/067_whistleblower_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/12_certifications/091_certifications_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/12_certifications/097_duneworks_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-094-09 — trading-window violation (high)\n\nthe controlling threshold is 3% under CB-PC-3304-R924; the independently calculated result is 5% under CB-PC-3304-E148. Identity resolves to ENT-094-1008, revision REV-2026.2 is current, and Priya Raman is active with capacity 6.\n\nAction: Create metric-period rows with exact adjustment and certification outcomes. Owner: Priya Raman; due 2026-09-05.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/009_minutes_materials_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/021_sec_filings_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/033_insider_trading_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/06_related_parties/045_related_parties_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/12_certifications/093_certifications_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/12_certifications/097_duneworks_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-094-10 — guidance-control failure (critical)\n\napproval must come from Maya Ellison under CB-PC-3304-R256; the effective approval record names Rafael Okafor under CB-PC-3304-E691. Identity resolves to ENT-094-1009, revision REV-2026.3 is current, and Isaac Romero is active with capacity 6.\n\nAction: Create metric-period rows with exact adjustment and certification outcomes. Owner: Isaac Romero; due 2026-09-13.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/010_minutes_materials_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/022_sec_filings_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/034_insider_trading_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/06_related_parties/046_related_parties_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/12_certifications/097_duneworks_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-094-11 — board-matrix inconsistency (medium)\n\nthe controlled population contains 217 records under CB-PC-3304-R875; the certification covers 188 records under CB-PC-3304-E198. Identity resolves to ENT-094-1010, revision REV-2026.4 is current, and Nadine Flores is active with capacity 4.\n\nAction: Create metric-period rows with exact adjustment and certification outcomes. Owner: Nadine Flores; due 2026-09-12.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/011_minutes_materials_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/023_sec_filings_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/035_insider_trading_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/06_related_parties/047_related_parties_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/12_certifications/097_duneworks_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n## Evidence holds\n\n- **CBP-094-01 — debt-covenant disclosure**: the current observation does not meet the operative trigger. Next evidence: a current observation that satisfies the operative trigger. Sources: `/workspace/documents/01_board_committees/001_board_committees_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/013_minutes_materials_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/025_disclosure_controls_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/037_insider_trading_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/10_stock_exchange/073_stock_exchange_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/08_earnings_guidance/061_earnings_guidance_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/12_certifications/097_duneworks_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-094-04 — listing-standard notice**: two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key. Next evidence: an approved immutable entity crosswalk. Sources: `/workspace/documents/01_board_committees/004_board_committees_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/016_minutes_materials_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/028_disclosure_controls_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/040_insider_trading_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/07_equity_compensation/052_equity_compensation_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/11_debt_covenants/088_debt_covenants_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/12_certifications/097_duneworks_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-094-08 — committee-independence gap**: two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key. Next evidence: an approved immutable entity crosswalk. Sources: `/workspace/documents/01_board_committees/008_board_committees_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/020_sec_filings_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/032_disclosure_controls_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/06_related_parties/044_related_parties_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/09_whistleblower/068_whistleblower_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/12_certifications/097_duneworks_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-094-12 — disclosure-control exception**: two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key. Next evidence: an approved immutable entity crosswalk. Sources: `/workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/012_minutes_materials_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/024_sec_filings_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/036_insider_trading_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/06_related_parties/048_related_parties_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/12_certifications/096_certifications_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/09_whistleblower/072_whistleblower_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/12_certifications/097_duneworks_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n## Alternatives considered\n\n- `duneworks:shortcut` — Use the final finance deck because it is the newest document.: Use a plausible summary or one source without completing the controlling joins.\n- `duneworks:blanket-hold` — Freeze the entire matter population: Treat supported actions and genuinely ambiguous records as if they were equally unresolved.\n\n## Assumptions and limits\n\nThis decision is limited to cb100-094-duneworks, the supplied synthetic records, and the matter state as of 2026-09-14. Similar names, stale revisions, and pending authority are not treated as proof.\n", "decision": {"actions": [{"determination": "approval must come from Maya Ellison under CB-PC-3304-R691; the effective approval record names Caleb Hassan under CB-PC-3304-E928. Identity resolves to ENT-094-1001, revision REV-2026.2 is current, and Dominic Alvarez is active with capacity 5.", "due_date": "2026-09-12", "id": "ACT-CBP-094-02", "identity_id": "ENT-094-1001", "issue": "8-K deadline", "owner": "Dominic Alvarez", "portfolio_key": "CBP-094-02", "recommended_action": "Create metric-period rows with exact adjustment and certification outcomes. Owner: Dominic Alvarez; due 2026-09-12.", "severity": "high", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_board_committees/002_board_committees_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/014_minutes_materials_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/026_disclosure_controls_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/038_insider_trading_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/11_debt_covenants/086_debt_covenants_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_certifications/097_duneworks_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "the controlled population contains 241 records under CB-PC-3304-R509; the certification covers 226 records under CB-PC-3304-E229. Identity resolves to ENT-094-1002, revision REV-2026.3 is current, and Leona Park is active with capacity 4.", "due_date": "2026-09-11", "id": "ACT-CBP-094-03", "identity_id": "ENT-094-1002", "issue": "related-party disclosure gap", "owner": "Leona Park", "portfolio_key": "CBP-094-03", "recommended_action": "Create metric-period rows with exact adjustment and certification outcomes. Owner: Leona Park; due 2026-09-11.", "severity": "medium", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_board_committees/003_board_committees_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/015_minutes_materials_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/027_disclosure_controls_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/039_insider_trading_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_certifications/097_duneworks_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "the operative cap is $6,562,000.00 under CB-PC-3304-R415; the matched ledger population totals $6,713,615.00 under CB-PC-3304-E647. Identity resolves to ENT-094-1004, revision REV-2026.5 is current, and Maya Ellison is active with capacity 6.", "due_date": "2026-09-09", "id": "ACT-CBP-094-05", "identity_id": "ENT-094-1004", "issue": "minutes-approval omission", "owner": "Maya Ellison", "portfolio_key": "CBP-094-05", "recommended_action": "Create metric-period rows with exact adjustment and certification outcomes. Owner: Maya Ellison; due 2026-09-09.", "severity": "medium", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_board_committees/005_board_committees_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/017_sec_filings_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/029_disclosure_controls_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/06_related_parties/041_related_parties_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/12_certifications/097_duneworks_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "delivery must use notices-duneworks_software_inc@example.test under CB-PC-3304-R856; the only matched receipt used archive-disclosure_committee@example.test under CB-PC-3304-E144. Identity resolves to ENT-094-1005, revision REV-2026.6 is current, and Jonas Feld is active with capacity 6.", "due_date": "2026-09-08", "id": "ACT-CBP-094-06", "identity_id": "ENT-094-1005", "issue": "Section 16 filing delay", "owner": "Jonas Feld", "portfolio_key": "CBP-094-06", "recommended_action": "Create metric-period rows with exact adjustment and certification outcomes. Owner: Jonas Feld; due 2026-09-08.", "severity": "high", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_board_committees/006_board_committees_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/018_sec_filings_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/030_disclosure_controls_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/06_related_parties/042_related_parties_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/07_equity_compensation/054_equity_compensation_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_certifications/097_duneworks_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "an open exception blocks completion under CB-PC-3304-R138; the current status is open and unresolved under CB-PC-3304-E578. Identity resolves to ENT-094-1006, revision REV-2026.7 is current, and Willa Novak is active with capacity 6.", "due_date": "2026-09-07", "id": "ACT-CBP-094-07", "identity_id": "ENT-094-1006", "issue": "whistleblower escalation delay", "owner": "Willa Novak", "portfolio_key": "CBP-094-07", "recommended_action": "Create metric-period rows with exact adjustment and certification outcomes. Owner: Willa Novak; due 2026-09-07.", "severity": "high", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_board_committees/007_board_committees_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/019_sec_filings_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/031_disclosure_controls_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/06_related_parties/043_related_parties_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/09_whistleblower/067_whistleblower_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/12_certifications/091_certifications_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/12_certifications/097_duneworks_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "the controlling threshold is 3% under CB-PC-3304-R924; the independently calculated result is 5% under CB-PC-3304-E148. Identity resolves to ENT-094-1008, revision REV-2026.2 is current, and Priya Raman is active with capacity 6.", "due_date": "2026-09-05", "id": "ACT-CBP-094-09", "identity_id": "ENT-094-1008", "issue": "trading-window violation", "owner": "Priya Raman", "portfolio_key": "CBP-094-09", "recommended_action": "Create metric-period rows with exact adjustment and certification outcomes. Owner: Priya Raman; due 2026-09-05.", "severity": "high", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/009_minutes_materials_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/021_sec_filings_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/033_insider_trading_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/06_related_parties/045_related_parties_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_certifications/093_certifications_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_certifications/097_duneworks_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "approval must come from Maya Ellison under CB-PC-3304-R256; the effective approval record names Rafael Okafor under CB-PC-3304-E691. Identity resolves to ENT-094-1009, revision REV-2026.3 is current, and Isaac Romero is active with capacity 6.", "due_date": "2026-09-13", "id": "ACT-CBP-094-10", "identity_id": "ENT-094-1009", "issue": "guidance-control failure", "owner": "Isaac Romero", "portfolio_key": "CBP-094-10", "recommended_action": "Create metric-period rows with exact adjustment and certification outcomes. Owner: Isaac Romero; due 2026-09-13.", "severity": "critical", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/010_minutes_materials_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/022_sec_filings_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/034_insider_trading_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/06_related_parties/046_related_parties_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_certifications/097_duneworks_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "the controlled population contains 217 records under CB-PC-3304-R875; the certification covers 188 records under CB-PC-3304-E198. Identity resolves to ENT-094-1010, revision REV-2026.4 is current, and Nadine Flores is active with capacity 4.", "due_date": "2026-09-12", "id": "ACT-CBP-094-11", "identity_id": "ENT-094-1010", "issue": "board-matrix inconsistency", "owner": "Nadine Flores", "portfolio_key": "CBP-094-11", "recommended_action": "Create metric-period rows with exact adjustment and certification outcomes. Owner: Nadine Flores; due 2026-09-12.", "severity": "medium", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/011_minutes_materials_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/023_sec_filings_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/035_insider_trading_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/06_related_parties/047_related_parties_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_certifications/097_duneworks_impact_population.xlsx"]}], "as_of": "2026-09-14", "decision": {"alternatives_considered": ["duneworks:shortcut", "duneworks:blanket-hold"], "question": "Can Duneworks release earnings with the current sales, non-GAAP, guidance, and certification record?", "rationale": "The four-part causal test supports 8 scoped actions and leaves 4 records on evidence hold. Approved metric definitions and disclosure controls govern the released figures and certifications.", "recommendation": "Correct supported figures and escalate unresolved control exceptions before release.", "selected_option_id": "duneworks:scoped-evidence"}, "holds": [{"id": "HOLD-CBP-094-01", "issue": "debt-covenant disclosure", "portfolio_key": "CBP-094-01", "reason": "the current observation does not meet the operative trigger", "required_next_evidence": "a current observation that satisfies the operative trigger", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_board_committees/001_board_committees_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/013_minutes_materials_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/025_disclosure_controls_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/037_insider_trading_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/10_stock_exchange/073_stock_exchange_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/08_earnings_guidance/061_earnings_guidance_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_certifications/097_duneworks_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-094-04", "issue": "listing-standard notice", "portfolio_key": "CBP-094-04", "reason": "two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key", "required_next_evidence": "an approved immutable entity crosswalk", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_board_committees/004_board_committees_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/016_minutes_materials_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/028_disclosure_controls_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/040_insider_trading_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/07_equity_compensation/052_equity_compensation_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/11_debt_covenants/088_debt_covenants_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_certifications/097_duneworks_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-094-08", "issue": "committee-independence gap", "portfolio_key": "CBP-094-08", "reason": "two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key", "required_next_evidence": "an approved immutable entity crosswalk", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_board_committees/008_board_committees_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/020_sec_filings_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/032_disclosure_controls_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/06_related_parties/044_related_parties_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/09_whistleblower/068_whistleblower_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/12_certifications/097_duneworks_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-094-12", "issue": "disclosure-control exception", "portfolio_key": "CBP-094-12", "reason": "two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key", "required_next_evidence": "an approved immutable entity crosswalk", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/012_minutes_materials_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/024_sec_filings_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/036_insider_trading_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/06_related_parties/048_related_parties_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_certifications/096_certifications_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/09_whistleblower/072_whistleblower_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_certifications/097_duneworks_impact_population.xlsx"]}], "matter_number": "CB-PC-3304", "prepared_for": "Duneworks Software, Inc.", "schema_version": "counselbench.decision.v3", "task_id": "cb100-094-duneworks"}, "matter_register": {"matter_number": "CB-PC-3304", "rows": [{"decision_option_id": "duneworks:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "the current observation does not meet the operative trigger", "issue": "debt-covenant disclosure", "matter_number": "CB-PC-3304", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-094-01", "row_id": "REG-CBP-094-01", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_board_committees/001_board_committees_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/013_minutes_materials_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/025_disclosure_controls_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/037_insider_trading_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/10_stock_exchange/073_stock_exchange_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/08_earnings_guidance/061_earnings_guidance_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_certifications/097_duneworks_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "duneworks:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-12", "issue": "8-K deadline", "matter_number": "CB-PC-3304", "owner": "Dominic Alvarez", "portfolio_key": "CBP-094-02", "row_id": "REG-CBP-094-02", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_board_committees/002_board_committees_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/014_minutes_materials_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/026_disclosure_controls_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/038_insider_trading_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/11_debt_covenants/086_debt_covenants_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_certifications/097_duneworks_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "duneworks:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-11", "issue": "related-party disclosure gap", "matter_number": "CB-PC-3304", "owner": "Leona Park", "portfolio_key": "CBP-094-03", "row_id": "REG-CBP-094-03", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_board_committees/003_board_committees_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/015_minutes_materials_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/027_disclosure_controls_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/039_insider_trading_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_certifications/097_duneworks_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "duneworks:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key", "issue": "listing-standard notice", "matter_number": "CB-PC-3304", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-094-04", "row_id": "REG-CBP-094-04", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_board_committees/004_board_committees_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/016_minutes_materials_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/028_disclosure_controls_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/040_insider_trading_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/07_equity_compensation/052_equity_compensation_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/11_debt_covenants/088_debt_covenants_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_certifications/097_duneworks_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "duneworks:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-09", "issue": "minutes-approval omission", "matter_number": "CB-PC-3304", "owner": "Maya Ellison", "portfolio_key": "CBP-094-05", "row_id": "REG-CBP-094-05", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_board_committees/005_board_committees_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/017_sec_filings_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/029_disclosure_controls_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/06_related_parties/041_related_parties_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/12_certifications/097_duneworks_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "duneworks:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-08", "issue": "Section 16 filing delay", "matter_number": "CB-PC-3304", "owner": "Jonas Feld", "portfolio_key": "CBP-094-06", "row_id": "REG-CBP-094-06", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_board_committees/006_board_committees_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/018_sec_filings_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/030_disclosure_controls_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/06_related_parties/042_related_parties_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/07_equity_compensation/054_equity_compensation_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_certifications/097_duneworks_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "duneworks:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-07", "issue": "whistleblower escalation delay", "matter_number": "CB-PC-3304", "owner": "Willa Novak", "portfolio_key": "CBP-094-07", "row_id": "REG-CBP-094-07", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_board_committees/007_board_committees_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/019_sec_filings_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/031_disclosure_controls_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/06_related_parties/043_related_parties_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/09_whistleblower/067_whistleblower_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/12_certifications/091_certifications_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/12_certifications/097_duneworks_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "duneworks:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key", "issue": "committee-independence gap", "matter_number": "CB-PC-3304", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-094-08", "row_id": "REG-CBP-094-08", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_board_committees/008_board_committees_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/020_sec_filings_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/032_disclosure_controls_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/06_related_parties/044_related_parties_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/09_whistleblower/068_whistleblower_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/12_certifications/097_duneworks_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "duneworks:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-05", "issue": "trading-window violation", "matter_number": "CB-PC-3304", "owner": "Priya Raman", "portfolio_key": "CBP-094-09", "row_id": "REG-CBP-094-09", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/009_minutes_materials_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/021_sec_filings_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/033_insider_trading_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/06_related_parties/045_related_parties_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_certifications/093_certifications_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_certifications/097_duneworks_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "duneworks:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-13", "issue": "guidance-control failure", "matter_number": "CB-PC-3304", "owner": "Isaac Romero", "portfolio_key": "CBP-094-10", "row_id": "REG-CBP-094-10", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/010_minutes_materials_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/022_sec_filings_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/034_insider_trading_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/06_related_parties/046_related_parties_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_certifications/097_duneworks_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "duneworks:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-12", "issue": "board-matrix inconsistency", "matter_number": "CB-PC-3304", "owner": "Nadine Flores", "portfolio_key": "CBP-094-11", "row_id": "REG-CBP-094-11", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/011_minutes_materials_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/023_sec_filings_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/035_insider_trading_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/06_related_parties/047_related_parties_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_certifications/097_duneworks_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "duneworks:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key", "issue": "disclosure-control exception", "matter_number": "CB-PC-3304", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-094-12", "row_id": "REG-CBP-094-12", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/012_minutes_materials_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/024_sec_filings_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/036_insider_trading_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/06_related_parties/048_related_parties_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_certifications/096_certifications_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/09_whistleblower/072_whistleblower_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_certifications/097_duneworks_impact_population.xlsx"]}], "schema_version": "counselbench.matter-register.v3", "task_id": "cb100-094-duneworks"}}, "metadata": {"benchmark": "CounselBench-100", "code_license": "Apache-2.0", "data_license": "CC-BY-4.0", "deadline": "2026-09-14", "document_count": 97, "evidence_holds": 4, "jurisdiction": "California", "matter_number": "CB-PC-3304", "mcp_commit": "9a96ea6e5913736f92b88345bf51caeaaa8e719f", "mcp_package": "@modelcontextprotocol/server-filesystem@2026.7.10", "practice_area": "public-company", "reference_tool_calls": 87, "required_evidence_reads": 62, "supported_actions": 8, "synthetic": true, "venue": "New York Stock Exchange", "version": "3.1.0"}, "prompt": "The client wants a decision, not another document inventory. Can Duneworks release earnings with the current sales, non-GAAP, guidance, and certification record? Sales adjustments, non-GAAP metrics, guidance drafts, and certification exceptions were tracked differently across finance and legal files. The team needs the call by 2026-09-14. Put the supported calls into the matter register and leave me a short note I can use with the partner.", "rubric": {"criteria": [{"category": "investigation", "description": "Inventory the production and use targeted searches to locate records across native formats.", "id": "investigation.discover_production"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Complete every task-specific identity, authority, operations, and approval read before the first state transition.", "id": "investigation.read_before_write"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Inspect designated source metadata before relying on those records.", "id": "investigation.custody_before_write"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "Select the supported option 'duneworks:scoped-evidence' after applying the four-part test.", "id": "decision.selected_option"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "Identify both rejected approaches and explain why a one-source shortcut and a blanket hold are wrong.", "id": "decision.alternatives"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-094-01 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_board_committees/001_board_committees_source_export.md rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-094-01.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/013_minutes_materials_source_export.json for debt-covenant disclosure.", "id": "investigation.CBP-094-01.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/025_disclosure_controls_source_export.md to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-094-01.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/037_insider_trading_source_export.json.", "id": "investigation.CBP-094-01.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-094-01 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is the current observation does not meet the operative trigger.", "id": "decision.CBP-094-01.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-094-01 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-094-01.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-094-02 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_board_committees/002_board_committees_source_export.txt rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-094-02.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/014_minutes_materials_source_export.xml for 8-K deadline.", "id": "investigation.CBP-094-02.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/026_disclosure_controls_source_export.txt to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-094-02.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/038_insider_trading_source_export.xml.", "id": "investigation.CBP-094-02.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-094-02 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-094-02.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-094-02 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-094-02.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-094-03 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_board_committees/003_board_committees_source_export.eml rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-094-03.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/015_minutes_materials_source_export.html for related-party disclosure gap.", "id": "investigation.CBP-094-03.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/027_disclosure_controls_source_export.eml to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-094-03.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/039_insider_trading_source_export.html.", "id": "investigation.CBP-094-03.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-094-03 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-094-03.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-094-03 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-094-03.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-094-04 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_board_committees/004_board_committees_source_export.csv rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-094-04.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/016_minutes_materials_source_export.pdf for listing-standard notice.", "id": "investigation.CBP-094-04.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/028_disclosure_controls_source_export.csv to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-094-04.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/040_insider_trading_source_export.pdf.", "id": "investigation.CBP-094-04.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-094-04 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key.", "id": "decision.CBP-094-04.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-094-04 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-094-04.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-094-05 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_board_committees/005_board_committees_source_export.json rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-094-05.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/017_sec_filings_source_export.md for minutes-approval omission.", "id": "investigation.CBP-094-05.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/029_disclosure_controls_source_export.json to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-094-05.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_related_parties/041_related_parties_source_export.md.", "id": "investigation.CBP-094-05.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-094-05 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-094-05.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-094-05 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-094-05.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-094-06 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_board_committees/006_board_committees_source_export.xml rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-094-06.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/018_sec_filings_source_export.txt for Section 16 filing delay.", "id": "investigation.CBP-094-06.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/030_disclosure_controls_source_export.xml to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-094-06.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_related_parties/042_related_parties_source_export.txt.", "id": "investigation.CBP-094-06.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-094-06 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-094-06.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-094-06 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-094-06.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-094-07 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_board_committees/007_board_committees_source_export.html rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-094-07.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/019_sec_filings_source_export.eml for whistleblower escalation delay.", "id": "investigation.CBP-094-07.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/031_disclosure_controls_source_export.html to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-094-07.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_related_parties/043_related_parties_source_export.eml.", "id": "investigation.CBP-094-07.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-094-07 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-094-07.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-094-07 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-094-07.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-094-08 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_board_committees/008_board_committees_source_export.pdf rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-094-08.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/020_sec_filings_source_export.csv for committee-independence gap.", "id": "investigation.CBP-094-08.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/032_disclosure_controls_source_export.pdf to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-094-08.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_related_parties/044_related_parties_source_export.csv.", "id": "investigation.CBP-094-08.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-094-08 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key.", "id": "decision.CBP-094-08.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-094-08 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-094-08.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-094-09 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/009_minutes_materials_source_export.md rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-094-09.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/021_sec_filings_source_export.json for trading-window violation.", "id": "investigation.CBP-094-09.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/033_insider_trading_source_export.md to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-094-09.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_related_parties/045_related_parties_source_export.json.", "id": "investigation.CBP-094-09.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-094-09 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-094-09.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-094-09 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-094-09.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-094-10 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/010_minutes_materials_source_export.txt rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-094-10.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/022_sec_filings_source_export.xml for guidance-control failure.", "id": "investigation.CBP-094-10.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/034_insider_trading_source_export.txt to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-094-10.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_related_parties/046_related_parties_source_export.xml.", "id": "investigation.CBP-094-10.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-094-10 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-094-10.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-094-10 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-094-10.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-094-11 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/011_minutes_materials_source_export.eml rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-094-11.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/023_sec_filings_source_export.html for board-matrix inconsistency.", "id": "investigation.CBP-094-11.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/035_insider_trading_source_export.eml to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-094-11.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_related_parties/047_related_parties_source_export.html.", "id": "investigation.CBP-094-11.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-094-11 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-094-11.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-094-11 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-094-11.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-094-12 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/012_minutes_materials_source_export.csv rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-094-12.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/024_sec_filings_source_export.pdf for disclosure-control exception.", "id": "investigation.CBP-094-12.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/036_insider_trading_source_export.csv to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-094-12.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_related_parties/048_related_parties_source_export.pdf.", "id": "investigation.CBP-094-12.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-094-12 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key.", "id": "decision.CBP-094-12.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-094-12 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-094-12.register"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Write the exact selected option, supported action population, evidence-hold population, facts, owners, deadlines, and citations.", "id": "state.exact_decision"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create one exact register row per portfolio key with no extra, missing, or modified row.", "id": "state.exact_register"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Leave only the three approved deliverables and perform no extra state-changing write.", "id": "state.write_scope_containment"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Read back decision.json, matter-register.json, and advice.md after their final writes.", "id": "state.postwrite_readback"}, {"category": "answer", "description": "Explain the selected recommendation, supported actions, holds, alternatives, and limitations with exact source anchors.", "id": "answer.decision_note"}], "decision_options": [{"approach": "Apply the exact identity, current-state, authority, and revision test. Create metric-period rows with exact adjustment and certification outcomes.", "id": "duneworks:scoped-evidence", "label": "Correct supported figures and escalate unresolved control exceptions before release."}, {"approach": "Use a plausible summary or one source without completing the controlling joins.", "id": "duneworks:shortcut", "label": "Use the final finance deck because it is the newest document."}, {"approach": "Treat supported actions and genuinely ambiguous records as if they were equally unresolved.", "id": "duneworks:blanket-hold", "label": "Freeze the entire matter population"}], "evaluation_narrative": {"authority": "Approved metric definitions and disclosure controls govern the released figures and certifications.", "observation": "Reconcile adjustments, metric definitions, guidance changes, controls, and certification exceptions by period.", "question": "Can Duneworks release earnings with the current sales, non-GAAP, guidance, and certification record?", "register_action": "Create metric-period rows with exact adjustment and certification outcomes."}, "gates": ["all_required_evidence_precedes_first_write", "decision_criteria_complete", "register_state_exact", "write_scope_contained", "all_outputs_verified_by_readback"], "metadata_checks": 9, "metric": "weighted_criteria_score", "minimum_tool_calls": 87, "required_deliverables": ["decision.json", "matter-register.json", "advice.md"], "required_document_reads": 62, "type": "deterministic", "weights": {"advice": 0.15, "decision": 0.35, "investigation": 0.25, "state": 0.25}}, "task_id": "cb100-094-duneworks", "task_name": "Duneworks earnings-controls audit", "world_id": "counselbench-filesystem-mcp-v3"}
+{"context_files": ["task_files/cb100-095-eastport-shipping/01_board_committees/001_board_committees_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-095-eastport-shipping/01_board_committees/002_board_committees_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-095-eastport-shipping/01_board_committees/003_board_committees_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-095-eastport-shipping/01_board_committees/004_board_committees_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-095-eastport-shipping/01_board_committees/005_board_committees_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-095-eastport-shipping/01_board_committees/006_board_committees_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-095-eastport-shipping/01_board_committees/007_board_committees_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-095-eastport-shipping/01_board_committees/008_board_committees_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-095-eastport-shipping/02_minutes_materials/009_minutes_materials_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-095-eastport-shipping/02_minutes_materials/010_minutes_materials_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-095-eastport-shipping/02_minutes_materials/011_minutes_materials_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-095-eastport-shipping/02_minutes_materials/012_minutes_materials_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-095-eastport-shipping/02_minutes_materials/013_minutes_materials_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-095-eastport-shipping/02_minutes_materials/014_minutes_materials_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-095-eastport-shipping/02_minutes_materials/015_minutes_materials_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-095-eastport-shipping/02_minutes_materials/016_minutes_materials_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-095-eastport-shipping/03_sec_filings/017_sec_filings_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-095-eastport-shipping/03_sec_filings/018_sec_filings_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-095-eastport-shipping/03_sec_filings/019_sec_filings_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-095-eastport-shipping/03_sec_filings/020_sec_filings_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-095-eastport-shipping/03_sec_filings/021_sec_filings_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-095-eastport-shipping/03_sec_filings/022_sec_filings_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-095-eastport-shipping/03_sec_filings/023_sec_filings_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-095-eastport-shipping/03_sec_filings/024_sec_filings_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-095-eastport-shipping/04_disclosure_controls/025_disclosure_controls_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-095-eastport-shipping/04_disclosure_controls/026_disclosure_controls_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-095-eastport-shipping/04_disclosure_controls/027_disclosure_controls_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-095-eastport-shipping/04_disclosure_controls/028_disclosure_controls_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-095-eastport-shipping/04_disclosure_controls/029_disclosure_controls_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-095-eastport-shipping/04_disclosure_controls/030_disclosure_controls_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-095-eastport-shipping/04_disclosure_controls/031_disclosure_controls_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-095-eastport-shipping/04_disclosure_controls/032_disclosure_controls_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-095-eastport-shipping/05_insider_trading/033_insider_trading_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-095-eastport-shipping/05_insider_trading/034_insider_trading_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-095-eastport-shipping/05_insider_trading/035_insider_trading_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-095-eastport-shipping/05_insider_trading/036_insider_trading_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-095-eastport-shipping/05_insider_trading/037_insider_trading_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-095-eastport-shipping/05_insider_trading/038_insider_trading_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-095-eastport-shipping/05_insider_trading/039_insider_trading_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-095-eastport-shipping/05_insider_trading/040_insider_trading_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-095-eastport-shipping/06_related_parties/041_related_parties_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-095-eastport-shipping/06_related_parties/042_related_parties_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-095-eastport-shipping/06_related_parties/043_related_parties_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-095-eastport-shipping/06_related_parties/044_related_parties_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-095-eastport-shipping/06_related_parties/045_related_parties_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-095-eastport-shipping/06_related_parties/046_related_parties_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-095-eastport-shipping/06_related_parties/047_related_parties_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-095-eastport-shipping/06_related_parties/048_related_parties_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-095-eastport-shipping/07_equity_compensation/049_equity_compensation_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-095-eastport-shipping/07_equity_compensation/050_equity_compensation_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-095-eastport-shipping/07_equity_compensation/051_equity_compensation_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-095-eastport-shipping/07_equity_compensation/052_equity_compensation_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-095-eastport-shipping/07_equity_compensation/053_equity_compensation_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-095-eastport-shipping/07_equity_compensation/054_equity_compensation_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-095-eastport-shipping/07_equity_compensation/055_equity_compensation_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-095-eastport-shipping/07_equity_compensation/056_equity_compensation_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-095-eastport-shipping/08_earnings_guidance/057_earnings_guidance_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-095-eastport-shipping/08_earnings_guidance/058_earnings_guidance_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-095-eastport-shipping/08_earnings_guidance/059_earnings_guidance_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-095-eastport-shipping/08_earnings_guidance/060_earnings_guidance_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-095-eastport-shipping/08_earnings_guidance/061_earnings_guidance_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-095-eastport-shipping/08_earnings_guidance/062_earnings_guidance_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-095-eastport-shipping/08_earnings_guidance/063_earnings_guidance_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-095-eastport-shipping/08_earnings_guidance/064_earnings_guidance_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-095-eastport-shipping/09_whistleblower/065_whistleblower_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-095-eastport-shipping/09_whistleblower/066_whistleblower_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-095-eastport-shipping/09_whistleblower/067_whistleblower_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-095-eastport-shipping/09_whistleblower/068_whistleblower_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-095-eastport-shipping/09_whistleblower/069_whistleblower_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-095-eastport-shipping/09_whistleblower/070_whistleblower_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-095-eastport-shipping/09_whistleblower/071_whistleblower_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-095-eastport-shipping/09_whistleblower/072_whistleblower_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-095-eastport-shipping/10_stock_exchange/073_stock_exchange_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-095-eastport-shipping/10_stock_exchange/074_stock_exchange_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-095-eastport-shipping/10_stock_exchange/075_stock_exchange_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-095-eastport-shipping/10_stock_exchange/076_stock_exchange_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-095-eastport-shipping/10_stock_exchange/077_stock_exchange_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-095-eastport-shipping/10_stock_exchange/078_stock_exchange_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-095-eastport-shipping/10_stock_exchange/079_stock_exchange_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-095-eastport-shipping/10_stock_exchange/080_stock_exchange_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-095-eastport-shipping/11_debt_covenants/081_debt_covenants_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-095-eastport-shipping/11_debt_covenants/082_debt_covenants_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-095-eastport-shipping/11_debt_covenants/083_debt_covenants_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-095-eastport-shipping/11_debt_covenants/084_debt_covenants_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-095-eastport-shipping/11_debt_covenants/085_debt_covenants_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-095-eastport-shipping/11_debt_covenants/086_debt_covenants_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-095-eastport-shipping/11_debt_covenants/087_debt_covenants_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-095-eastport-shipping/11_debt_covenants/088_debt_covenants_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-095-eastport-shipping/12_certifications/089_certifications_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-095-eastport-shipping/12_certifications/090_certifications_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-095-eastport-shipping/12_certifications/091_certifications_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-095-eastport-shipping/12_certifications/092_certifications_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-095-eastport-shipping/12_certifications/093_certifications_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-095-eastport-shipping/12_certifications/094_certifications_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-095-eastport-shipping/12_certifications/095_certifications_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-095-eastport-shipping/12_certifications/096_certifications_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-095-eastport-shipping/12_certifications/097_eastport_shipping_impact_population.xlsx"], "gold_output": {"advice_markdown": "# Decision note — Eastport covenant disclosure check\n\n## Recommendation\n\nCorrect calculations and disclosures for exact supported variances. The reconciled record supports 8 scoped actions and leaves 4 items on evidence hold.\n\nSelected option: `eastport-shipping:scoped-evidence`.\n\n## Why this is the supported option\n\nJoin fleet values, calculations, assumptions, lender notices, board materials, and draft risk factors. Operative covenant definitions and disclosure controls require consistent supported assumptions and dates.\n\n## Supported actions\n\n### CBP-095-02 — risk-factor inconsistency (medium)\n\nan open exception blocks completion under CB-PC-3305-R767; the current status is open and unresolved under CB-PC-3305-E351. Identity resolves to ENT-095-1001, revision REV-2025.2 is current, and Talia Brooks is active with capacity 2.\n\nAction: Create assumption-period rows with lender and filing consequences. Owner: Talia Brooks; due 2026-09-15.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_board_committees/002_board_committees_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/014_minutes_materials_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/026_disclosure_controls_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/038_insider_trading_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/11_debt_covenants/086_debt_covenants_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/12_certifications/097_eastport_shipping_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-095-03 — equity-plan share mismatch (high)\n\ncompletion is required by 2025-05-27 under CB-PC-3305-R841; the current event record shows completion on 2025-06-29 under CB-PC-3305-E567. Identity resolves to ENT-095-1002, revision REV-2025.3 is current, and Adrian Mensah is active with capacity 5.\n\nAction: Create assumption-period rows with lender and filing consequences. Owner: Adrian Mensah; due 2026-09-14.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_board_committees/003_board_committees_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/015_minutes_materials_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/027_disclosure_controls_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/039_insider_trading_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/11_debt_covenants/087_debt_covenants_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/12_certifications/097_eastport_shipping_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-095-05 — 8-K deadline (low)\n\napproval must come from Leona Park under CB-PC-3305-R996; the effective approval record names Rafael Okafor under CB-PC-3305-E629. Identity resolves to ENT-095-1004, revision REV-2025.5 is current, and Dominic Alvarez is active with capacity 3.\n\nAction: Create assumption-period rows with lender and filing consequences. Owner: Dominic Alvarez; due 2026-09-12.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_board_committees/005_board_committees_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/017_sec_filings_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/029_disclosure_controls_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/06_related_parties/041_related_parties_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/10_stock_exchange/077_stock_exchange_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/12_certifications/097_eastport_shipping_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-095-06 — related-party disclosure gap (critical)\n\nthe controlled population contains 89 records under CB-PC-3305-R137; the certification covers 78 records under CB-PC-3305-E261. Identity resolves to ENT-095-1005, revision REV-2025.6 is current, and Leona Park is active with capacity 4.\n\nAction: Create assumption-period rows with lender and filing consequences. Owner: Leona Park; due 2026-09-11.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_board_committees/006_board_committees_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/018_sec_filings_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/030_disclosure_controls_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/06_related_parties/042_related_parties_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/07_equity_compensation/054_equity_compensation_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/12_certifications/097_eastport_shipping_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-095-08 — minutes-approval omission (critical)\n\nthe operative cap is $3,322,000.00 under CB-PC-3305-R316; the matched ledger population totals $3,451,016.00 under CB-PC-3305-E271. Identity resolves to ENT-095-1007, revision REV-2025.1 is current, and Maya Ellison is active with capacity 2.\n\nAction: Create assumption-period rows with lender and filing consequences. Owner: Maya Ellison; due 2026-09-09.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_board_committees/008_board_committees_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/020_sec_filings_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/032_disclosure_controls_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/06_related_parties/044_related_parties_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/12_certifications/097_eastport_shipping_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-095-09 — Section 16 filing delay (high)\n\ndelivery must use notices-eastport_shipping_lines@example.test under CB-PC-3305-R464; the only matched receipt used archive-bondholder_trustee@example.test under CB-PC-3305-E333. Identity resolves to ENT-095-1008, revision REV-2025.2 is current, and Jonas Feld is active with capacity 3.\n\nAction: Create assumption-period rows with lender and filing consequences. Owner: Jonas Feld; due 2026-09-08.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/009_minutes_materials_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/021_sec_filings_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/033_insider_trading_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/06_related_parties/045_related_parties_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/11_debt_covenants/081_debt_covenants_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/12_certifications/097_eastport_shipping_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-095-10 — whistleblower escalation delay (high)\n\nan open exception blocks completion under CB-PC-3305-R100; the current status is open and unresolved under CB-PC-3305-E523. Identity resolves to ENT-095-1009, revision REV-2025.3 is current, and Willa Novak is active with capacity 3.\n\nAction: Create assumption-period rows with lender and filing consequences. Owner: Willa Novak; due 2026-09-16.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/010_minutes_materials_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/022_sec_filings_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/034_insider_trading_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/06_related_parties/046_related_parties_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/12_certifications/097_eastport_shipping_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-095-12 — trading-window violation (low)\n\nthe controlling threshold is 9% under CB-PC-3305-R682; the independently calculated result is 17% under CB-PC-3305-E716. Identity resolves to ENT-095-1011, revision REV-2025.5 is current, and Priya Raman is active with capacity 2.\n\nAction: Create assumption-period rows with lender and filing consequences. Owner: Priya Raman; due 2026-09-14.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/012_minutes_materials_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/024_sec_filings_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/036_insider_trading_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/06_related_parties/048_related_parties_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/11_debt_covenants/084_debt_covenants_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/12_certifications/097_eastport_shipping_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n## Evidence holds\n\n- **CBP-095-01 — officer certification exception**: the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective. Next evidence: effective approval and an active owner with remaining capacity. Sources: `/workspace/documents/01_board_committees/001_board_committees_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/013_minutes_materials_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/025_disclosure_controls_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/037_insider_trading_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/11_debt_covenants/085_debt_covenants_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/12_certifications/097_eastport_shipping_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-095-04 — debt-covenant disclosure**: the current observation does not meet the operative trigger. Next evidence: a current observation that satisfies the operative trigger. Sources: `/workspace/documents/01_board_committees/004_board_committees_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/016_minutes_materials_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/028_disclosure_controls_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/040_insider_trading_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/07_equity_compensation/052_equity_compensation_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/11_debt_covenants/088_debt_covenants_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/12_certifications/097_eastport_shipping_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-095-07 — listing-standard notice**: two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key. Next evidence: an approved immutable entity crosswalk. Sources: `/workspace/documents/01_board_committees/007_board_committees_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/019_sec_filings_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/031_disclosure_controls_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/06_related_parties/043_related_parties_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/12_certifications/097_eastport_shipping_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-095-11 — committee-independence gap**: two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key. Next evidence: an approved immutable entity crosswalk. Sources: `/workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/011_minutes_materials_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/023_sec_filings_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/035_insider_trading_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/06_related_parties/047_related_parties_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/09_whistleblower/071_whistleblower_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/11_debt_covenants/083_debt_covenants_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/12_certifications/097_eastport_shipping_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n## Alternatives considered\n\n- `eastport-shipping:shortcut` — Use management's preferred assumptions everywhere because no default was declared.: Use a plausible summary or one source without completing the controlling joins.\n- `eastport-shipping:blanket-hold` — Freeze the entire matter population: Treat supported actions and genuinely ambiguous records as if they were equally unresolved.\n\n## Assumptions and limits\n\nThis decision is limited to cb100-095-eastport-shipping, the supplied synthetic records, and the matter state as of 2026-09-17. Similar names, stale revisions, and pending authority are not treated as proof.\n", "decision": {"actions": [{"determination": "an open exception blocks completion under CB-PC-3305-R767; the current status is open and unresolved under CB-PC-3305-E351. Identity resolves to ENT-095-1001, revision REV-2025.2 is current, and Talia Brooks is active with capacity 2.", "due_date": "2026-09-15", "id": "ACT-CBP-095-02", "identity_id": "ENT-095-1001", "issue": "risk-factor inconsistency", "owner": "Talia Brooks", "portfolio_key": "CBP-095-02", "recommended_action": "Create assumption-period rows with lender and filing consequences. Owner: Talia Brooks; due 2026-09-15.", "severity": "medium", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_board_committees/002_board_committees_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/014_minutes_materials_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/026_disclosure_controls_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/038_insider_trading_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/11_debt_covenants/086_debt_covenants_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_certifications/097_eastport_shipping_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "completion is required by 2025-05-27 under CB-PC-3305-R841; the current event record shows completion on 2025-06-29 under CB-PC-3305-E567. Identity resolves to ENT-095-1002, revision REV-2025.3 is current, and Adrian Mensah is active with capacity 5.", "due_date": "2026-09-14", "id": "ACT-CBP-095-03", "identity_id": "ENT-095-1002", "issue": "equity-plan share mismatch", "owner": "Adrian Mensah", "portfolio_key": "CBP-095-03", "recommended_action": "Create assumption-period rows with lender and filing consequences. Owner: Adrian Mensah; due 2026-09-14.", "severity": "high", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_board_committees/003_board_committees_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/015_minutes_materials_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/027_disclosure_controls_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/039_insider_trading_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/11_debt_covenants/087_debt_covenants_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_certifications/097_eastport_shipping_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "approval must come from Leona Park under CB-PC-3305-R996; the effective approval record names Rafael Okafor under CB-PC-3305-E629. Identity resolves to ENT-095-1004, revision REV-2025.5 is current, and Dominic Alvarez is active with capacity 3.", "due_date": "2026-09-12", "id": "ACT-CBP-095-05", "identity_id": "ENT-095-1004", "issue": "8-K deadline", "owner": "Dominic Alvarez", "portfolio_key": "CBP-095-05", "recommended_action": "Create assumption-period rows with lender and filing consequences. Owner: Dominic Alvarez; due 2026-09-12.", "severity": "low", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_board_committees/005_board_committees_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/017_sec_filings_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/029_disclosure_controls_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/06_related_parties/041_related_parties_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/10_stock_exchange/077_stock_exchange_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_certifications/097_eastport_shipping_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "the controlled population contains 89 records under CB-PC-3305-R137; the certification covers 78 records under CB-PC-3305-E261. Identity resolves to ENT-095-1005, revision REV-2025.6 is current, and Leona Park is active with capacity 4.", "due_date": "2026-09-11", "id": "ACT-CBP-095-06", "identity_id": "ENT-095-1005", "issue": "related-party disclosure gap", "owner": "Leona Park", "portfolio_key": "CBP-095-06", "recommended_action": "Create assumption-period rows with lender and filing consequences. Owner: Leona Park; due 2026-09-11.", "severity": "critical", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_board_committees/006_board_committees_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/018_sec_filings_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/030_disclosure_controls_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/06_related_parties/042_related_parties_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/07_equity_compensation/054_equity_compensation_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_certifications/097_eastport_shipping_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "the operative cap is $3,322,000.00 under CB-PC-3305-R316; the matched ledger population totals $3,451,016.00 under CB-PC-3305-E271. Identity resolves to ENT-095-1007, revision REV-2025.1 is current, and Maya Ellison is active with capacity 2.", "due_date": "2026-09-09", "id": "ACT-CBP-095-08", "identity_id": "ENT-095-1007", "issue": "minutes-approval omission", "owner": "Maya Ellison", "portfolio_key": "CBP-095-08", "recommended_action": "Create assumption-period rows with lender and filing consequences. Owner: Maya Ellison; due 2026-09-09.", "severity": "critical", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_board_committees/008_board_committees_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/020_sec_filings_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/032_disclosure_controls_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/06_related_parties/044_related_parties_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/12_certifications/097_eastport_shipping_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "delivery must use notices-eastport_shipping_lines@example.test under CB-PC-3305-R464; the only matched receipt used archive-bondholder_trustee@example.test under CB-PC-3305-E333. Identity resolves to ENT-095-1008, revision REV-2025.2 is current, and Jonas Feld is active with capacity 3.", "due_date": "2026-09-08", "id": "ACT-CBP-095-09", "identity_id": "ENT-095-1008", "issue": "Section 16 filing delay", "owner": "Jonas Feld", "portfolio_key": "CBP-095-09", "recommended_action": "Create assumption-period rows with lender and filing consequences. Owner: Jonas Feld; due 2026-09-08.", "severity": "high", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/009_minutes_materials_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/021_sec_filings_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/033_insider_trading_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/06_related_parties/045_related_parties_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/11_debt_covenants/081_debt_covenants_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/12_certifications/097_eastport_shipping_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "an open exception blocks completion under CB-PC-3305-R100; the current status is open and unresolved under CB-PC-3305-E523. Identity resolves to ENT-095-1009, revision REV-2025.3 is current, and Willa Novak is active with capacity 3.", "due_date": "2026-09-16", "id": "ACT-CBP-095-10", "identity_id": "ENT-095-1009", "issue": "whistleblower escalation delay", "owner": "Willa Novak", "portfolio_key": "CBP-095-10", "recommended_action": "Create assumption-period rows with lender and filing consequences. Owner: Willa Novak; due 2026-09-16.", "severity": "high", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/010_minutes_materials_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/022_sec_filings_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/034_insider_trading_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/06_related_parties/046_related_parties_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_certifications/097_eastport_shipping_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "the controlling threshold is 9% under CB-PC-3305-R682; the independently calculated result is 17% under CB-PC-3305-E716. Identity resolves to ENT-095-1011, revision REV-2025.5 is current, and Priya Raman is active with capacity 2.", "due_date": "2026-09-14", "id": "ACT-CBP-095-12", "identity_id": "ENT-095-1011", "issue": "trading-window violation", "owner": "Priya Raman", "portfolio_key": "CBP-095-12", "recommended_action": "Create assumption-period rows with lender and filing consequences. Owner: Priya Raman; due 2026-09-14.", "severity": "low", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/012_minutes_materials_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/024_sec_filings_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/036_insider_trading_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/06_related_parties/048_related_parties_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/11_debt_covenants/084_debt_covenants_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/12_certifications/097_eastport_shipping_impact_population.xlsx"]}], "as_of": "2026-09-17", "decision": {"alternatives_considered": ["eastport-shipping:shortcut", "eastport-shipping:blanket-hold"], "question": "Which Eastport covenant and impairment facts must be reflected in lender and public disclosures?", "rationale": "The four-part causal test supports 8 scoped actions and leaves 4 records on evidence hold. Operative covenant definitions and disclosure controls require consistent supported assumptions and dates.", "recommendation": "Correct calculations and disclosures for exact supported variances.", "selected_option_id": "eastport-shipping:scoped-evidence"}, "holds": [{"id": "HOLD-CBP-095-01", "issue": "officer certification exception", "portfolio_key": "CBP-095-01", "reason": "the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective", "required_next_evidence": "effective approval and an active owner with remaining capacity", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_board_committees/001_board_committees_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/013_minutes_materials_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/025_disclosure_controls_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/037_insider_trading_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/11_debt_covenants/085_debt_covenants_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_certifications/097_eastport_shipping_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-095-04", "issue": "debt-covenant disclosure", "portfolio_key": "CBP-095-04", "reason": "the current observation does not meet the operative trigger", "required_next_evidence": "a current observation that satisfies the operative trigger", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_board_committees/004_board_committees_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/016_minutes_materials_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/028_disclosure_controls_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/040_insider_trading_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/07_equity_compensation/052_equity_compensation_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/11_debt_covenants/088_debt_covenants_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_certifications/097_eastport_shipping_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-095-07", "issue": "listing-standard notice", "portfolio_key": "CBP-095-07", "reason": "two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key", "required_next_evidence": "an approved immutable entity crosswalk", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_board_committees/007_board_committees_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/019_sec_filings_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/031_disclosure_controls_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/06_related_parties/043_related_parties_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/12_certifications/097_eastport_shipping_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-095-11", "issue": "committee-independence gap", "portfolio_key": "CBP-095-11", "reason": "two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key", "required_next_evidence": "an approved immutable entity crosswalk", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/011_minutes_materials_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/023_sec_filings_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/035_insider_trading_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/06_related_parties/047_related_parties_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/09_whistleblower/071_whistleblower_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/11_debt_covenants/083_debt_covenants_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/12_certifications/097_eastport_shipping_impact_population.xlsx"]}], "matter_number": "CB-PC-3305", "prepared_for": "Eastport Shipping Lines", "schema_version": "counselbench.decision.v3", "task_id": "cb100-095-eastport-shipping"}, "matter_register": {"matter_number": "CB-PC-3305", "rows": [{"decision_option_id": "eastport-shipping:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective", "issue": "officer certification exception", "matter_number": "CB-PC-3305", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-095-01", "row_id": "REG-CBP-095-01", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_board_committees/001_board_committees_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/013_minutes_materials_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/025_disclosure_controls_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/037_insider_trading_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/11_debt_covenants/085_debt_covenants_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_certifications/097_eastport_shipping_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "eastport-shipping:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-15", "issue": "risk-factor inconsistency", "matter_number": "CB-PC-3305", "owner": "Talia Brooks", "portfolio_key": "CBP-095-02", "row_id": "REG-CBP-095-02", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_board_committees/002_board_committees_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/014_minutes_materials_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/026_disclosure_controls_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/038_insider_trading_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/11_debt_covenants/086_debt_covenants_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_certifications/097_eastport_shipping_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "eastport-shipping:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-14", "issue": "equity-plan share mismatch", "matter_number": "CB-PC-3305", "owner": "Adrian Mensah", "portfolio_key": "CBP-095-03", "row_id": "REG-CBP-095-03", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_board_committees/003_board_committees_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/015_minutes_materials_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/027_disclosure_controls_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/039_insider_trading_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/11_debt_covenants/087_debt_covenants_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_certifications/097_eastport_shipping_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "eastport-shipping:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "the current observation does not meet the operative trigger", "issue": "debt-covenant disclosure", "matter_number": "CB-PC-3305", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-095-04", "row_id": "REG-CBP-095-04", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_board_committees/004_board_committees_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/016_minutes_materials_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/028_disclosure_controls_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/040_insider_trading_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/07_equity_compensation/052_equity_compensation_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/11_debt_covenants/088_debt_covenants_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_certifications/097_eastport_shipping_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "eastport-shipping:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-12", "issue": "8-K deadline", "matter_number": "CB-PC-3305", "owner": "Dominic Alvarez", "portfolio_key": "CBP-095-05", "row_id": "REG-CBP-095-05", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_board_committees/005_board_committees_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/017_sec_filings_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/029_disclosure_controls_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/06_related_parties/041_related_parties_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/10_stock_exchange/077_stock_exchange_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_certifications/097_eastport_shipping_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "eastport-shipping:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-11", "issue": "related-party disclosure gap", "matter_number": "CB-PC-3305", "owner": "Leona Park", "portfolio_key": "CBP-095-06", "row_id": "REG-CBP-095-06", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_board_committees/006_board_committees_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/018_sec_filings_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/030_disclosure_controls_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/06_related_parties/042_related_parties_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/07_equity_compensation/054_equity_compensation_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_certifications/097_eastport_shipping_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "eastport-shipping:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key", "issue": "listing-standard notice", "matter_number": "CB-PC-3305", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-095-07", "row_id": "REG-CBP-095-07", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_board_committees/007_board_committees_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/019_sec_filings_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/031_disclosure_controls_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/06_related_parties/043_related_parties_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/12_certifications/097_eastport_shipping_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "eastport-shipping:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-09", "issue": "minutes-approval omission", "matter_number": "CB-PC-3305", "owner": "Maya Ellison", "portfolio_key": "CBP-095-08", "row_id": "REG-CBP-095-08", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_board_committees/008_board_committees_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/020_sec_filings_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/032_disclosure_controls_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/06_related_parties/044_related_parties_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/12_certifications/097_eastport_shipping_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "eastport-shipping:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-08", "issue": "Section 16 filing delay", "matter_number": "CB-PC-3305", "owner": "Jonas Feld", "portfolio_key": "CBP-095-09", "row_id": "REG-CBP-095-09", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/009_minutes_materials_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/021_sec_filings_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/033_insider_trading_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/06_related_parties/045_related_parties_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/11_debt_covenants/081_debt_covenants_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/12_certifications/097_eastport_shipping_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "eastport-shipping:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-16", "issue": "whistleblower escalation delay", "matter_number": "CB-PC-3305", "owner": "Willa Novak", "portfolio_key": "CBP-095-10", "row_id": "REG-CBP-095-10", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/010_minutes_materials_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/022_sec_filings_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/034_insider_trading_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/06_related_parties/046_related_parties_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_certifications/097_eastport_shipping_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "eastport-shipping:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key", "issue": "committee-independence gap", "matter_number": "CB-PC-3305", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-095-11", "row_id": "REG-CBP-095-11", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/011_minutes_materials_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/023_sec_filings_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/035_insider_trading_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/06_related_parties/047_related_parties_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/09_whistleblower/071_whistleblower_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/11_debt_covenants/083_debt_covenants_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/12_certifications/097_eastport_shipping_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "eastport-shipping:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-14", "issue": "trading-window violation", "matter_number": "CB-PC-3305", "owner": "Priya Raman", "portfolio_key": "CBP-095-12", "row_id": "REG-CBP-095-12", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/012_minutes_materials_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/024_sec_filings_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/036_insider_trading_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/06_related_parties/048_related_parties_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/11_debt_covenants/084_debt_covenants_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/12_certifications/097_eastport_shipping_impact_population.xlsx"]}], "schema_version": "counselbench.matter-register.v3", "task_id": "cb100-095-eastport-shipping"}}, "metadata": {"benchmark": "CounselBench-100", "code_license": "Apache-2.0", "data_license": "CC-BY-4.0", "deadline": "2026-09-17", "document_count": 97, "evidence_holds": 4, "jurisdiction": "New York", "matter_number": "CB-PC-3305", "mcp_commit": "9a96ea6e5913736f92b88345bf51caeaaa8e719f", "mcp_package": "@modelcontextprotocol/server-filesystem@2026.7.10", "practice_area": "public-company", "reference_tool_calls": 87, "required_evidence_reads": 61, "supported_actions": 8, "synthetic": true, "venue": "New York Stock Exchange", "version": "3.1.0"}, "prompt": "We inherited inconsistent versions of this matter and need to settle the operating position. Which Eastport covenant and impairment facts must be reflected in lender and public disclosures? Fleet impairment, covenant calculations, lender notices, and risk-factor drafts use conflicting assumptions and dates. The team needs the call by 2026-09-17. I need the recommendation and the real blockers recorded before the team acts.", "rubric": {"criteria": [{"category": "investigation", "description": "Inventory the production and use targeted searches to locate records across native formats.", "id": "investigation.discover_production"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Complete every task-specific identity, authority, operations, and approval read before the first state transition.", "id": "investigation.read_before_write"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Inspect designated source metadata before relying on those records.", "id": "investigation.custody_before_write"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "Select the supported option 'eastport-shipping:scoped-evidence' after applying the four-part test.", "id": "decision.selected_option"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "Identify both rejected approaches and explain why a one-source shortcut and a blanket hold are wrong.", "id": "decision.alternatives"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-095-01 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_board_committees/001_board_committees_source_export.md rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-095-01.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/013_minutes_materials_source_export.json for officer certification exception.", "id": "investigation.CBP-095-01.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/025_disclosure_controls_source_export.md to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-095-01.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/037_insider_trading_source_export.json.", "id": "investigation.CBP-095-01.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-095-01 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective.", "id": "decision.CBP-095-01.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-095-01 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-095-01.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-095-02 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_board_committees/002_board_committees_source_export.txt rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-095-02.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/014_minutes_materials_source_export.xml for risk-factor inconsistency.", "id": "investigation.CBP-095-02.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/026_disclosure_controls_source_export.txt to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-095-02.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/038_insider_trading_source_export.xml.", "id": "investigation.CBP-095-02.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-095-02 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-095-02.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-095-02 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-095-02.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-095-03 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_board_committees/003_board_committees_source_export.eml rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-095-03.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/015_minutes_materials_source_export.html for equity-plan share mismatch.", "id": "investigation.CBP-095-03.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/027_disclosure_controls_source_export.eml to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-095-03.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/039_insider_trading_source_export.html.", "id": "investigation.CBP-095-03.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-095-03 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-095-03.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-095-03 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-095-03.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-095-04 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_board_committees/004_board_committees_source_export.csv rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-095-04.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/016_minutes_materials_source_export.pdf for debt-covenant disclosure.", "id": "investigation.CBP-095-04.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/028_disclosure_controls_source_export.csv to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-095-04.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/040_insider_trading_source_export.pdf.", "id": "investigation.CBP-095-04.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-095-04 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is the current observation does not meet the operative trigger.", "id": "decision.CBP-095-04.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-095-04 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-095-04.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-095-05 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_board_committees/005_board_committees_source_export.json rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-095-05.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/017_sec_filings_source_export.md for 8-K deadline.", "id": "investigation.CBP-095-05.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/029_disclosure_controls_source_export.json to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-095-05.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_related_parties/041_related_parties_source_export.md.", "id": "investigation.CBP-095-05.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-095-05 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-095-05.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-095-05 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-095-05.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-095-06 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_board_committees/006_board_committees_source_export.xml rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-095-06.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/018_sec_filings_source_export.txt for related-party disclosure gap.", "id": "investigation.CBP-095-06.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/030_disclosure_controls_source_export.xml to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-095-06.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_related_parties/042_related_parties_source_export.txt.", "id": "investigation.CBP-095-06.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-095-06 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-095-06.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-095-06 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-095-06.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-095-07 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_board_committees/007_board_committees_source_export.html rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-095-07.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/019_sec_filings_source_export.eml for listing-standard notice.", "id": "investigation.CBP-095-07.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/031_disclosure_controls_source_export.html to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-095-07.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_related_parties/043_related_parties_source_export.eml.", "id": "investigation.CBP-095-07.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-095-07 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key.", "id": "decision.CBP-095-07.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-095-07 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-095-07.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-095-08 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_board_committees/008_board_committees_source_export.pdf rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-095-08.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/020_sec_filings_source_export.csv for minutes-approval omission.", "id": "investigation.CBP-095-08.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/032_disclosure_controls_source_export.pdf to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-095-08.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_related_parties/044_related_parties_source_export.csv.", "id": "investigation.CBP-095-08.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-095-08 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-095-08.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-095-08 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-095-08.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-095-09 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/009_minutes_materials_source_export.md rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-095-09.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/021_sec_filings_source_export.json for Section 16 filing delay.", "id": "investigation.CBP-095-09.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/033_insider_trading_source_export.md to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-095-09.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_related_parties/045_related_parties_source_export.json.", "id": "investigation.CBP-095-09.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-095-09 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-095-09.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-095-09 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-095-09.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-095-10 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/010_minutes_materials_source_export.txt rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-095-10.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/022_sec_filings_source_export.xml for whistleblower escalation delay.", "id": "investigation.CBP-095-10.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/034_insider_trading_source_export.txt to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-095-10.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_related_parties/046_related_parties_source_export.xml.", "id": "investigation.CBP-095-10.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-095-10 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-095-10.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-095-10 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-095-10.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-095-11 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/011_minutes_materials_source_export.eml rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-095-11.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/023_sec_filings_source_export.html for committee-independence gap.", "id": "investigation.CBP-095-11.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/035_insider_trading_source_export.eml to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-095-11.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_related_parties/047_related_parties_source_export.html.", "id": "investigation.CBP-095-11.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-095-11 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key.", "id": "decision.CBP-095-11.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-095-11 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-095-11.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-095-12 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/012_minutes_materials_source_export.csv rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-095-12.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/024_sec_filings_source_export.pdf for trading-window violation.", "id": "investigation.CBP-095-12.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/036_insider_trading_source_export.csv to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-095-12.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_related_parties/048_related_parties_source_export.pdf.", "id": "investigation.CBP-095-12.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-095-12 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-095-12.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-095-12 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-095-12.register"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Write the exact selected option, supported action population, evidence-hold population, facts, owners, deadlines, and citations.", "id": "state.exact_decision"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create one exact register row per portfolio key with no extra, missing, or modified row.", "id": "state.exact_register"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Leave only the three approved deliverables and perform no extra state-changing write.", "id": "state.write_scope_containment"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Read back decision.json, matter-register.json, and advice.md after their final writes.", "id": "state.postwrite_readback"}, {"category": "answer", "description": "Explain the selected recommendation, supported actions, holds, alternatives, and limitations with exact source anchors.", "id": "answer.decision_note"}], "decision_options": [{"approach": "Use a plausible summary or one source without completing the controlling joins.", "id": "eastport-shipping:shortcut", "label": "Use management's preferred assumptions everywhere because no default was declared."}, {"approach": "Treat supported actions and genuinely ambiguous records as if they were equally unresolved.", "id": "eastport-shipping:blanket-hold", "label": "Freeze the entire matter population"}, {"approach": "Apply the exact identity, current-state, authority, and revision test. Create assumption-period rows with lender and filing consequences.", "id": "eastport-shipping:scoped-evidence", "label": "Correct calculations and disclosures for exact supported variances."}], "evaluation_narrative": {"authority": "Operative covenant definitions and disclosure controls require consistent supported assumptions and dates.", "observation": "Join fleet values, calculations, assumptions, lender notices, board materials, and draft risk factors.", "question": "Which Eastport covenant and impairment facts must be reflected in lender and public disclosures?", "register_action": "Create assumption-period rows with lender and filing consequences."}, "gates": ["all_required_evidence_precedes_first_write", "decision_criteria_complete", "register_state_exact", "write_scope_contained", "all_outputs_verified_by_readback"], "metadata_checks": 11, "metric": "weighted_criteria_score", "minimum_tool_calls": 87, "required_deliverables": ["decision.json", "matter-register.json", "advice.md"], "required_document_reads": 61, "type": "deterministic", "weights": {"advice": 0.15, "decision": 0.35, "investigation": 0.25, "state": 0.25}}, "task_id": "cb100-095-eastport-shipping", "task_name": "Eastport covenant disclosure check", "world_id": "counselbench-filesystem-mcp-v3"}
+{"context_files": ["task_files/cb100-096-fieldstone-foods/01_board_committees/001_board_committees_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-096-fieldstone-foods/01_board_committees/002_board_committees_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-096-fieldstone-foods/01_board_committees/003_board_committees_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-096-fieldstone-foods/01_board_committees/004_board_committees_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-096-fieldstone-foods/01_board_committees/005_board_committees_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-096-fieldstone-foods/01_board_committees/006_board_committees_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-096-fieldstone-foods/01_board_committees/007_board_committees_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-096-fieldstone-foods/01_board_committees/008_board_committees_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-096-fieldstone-foods/02_minutes_materials/009_minutes_materials_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-096-fieldstone-foods/02_minutes_materials/010_minutes_materials_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-096-fieldstone-foods/02_minutes_materials/011_minutes_materials_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-096-fieldstone-foods/02_minutes_materials/012_minutes_materials_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-096-fieldstone-foods/02_minutes_materials/013_minutes_materials_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-096-fieldstone-foods/02_minutes_materials/014_minutes_materials_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-096-fieldstone-foods/02_minutes_materials/015_minutes_materials_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-096-fieldstone-foods/02_minutes_materials/016_minutes_materials_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-096-fieldstone-foods/03_sec_filings/017_sec_filings_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-096-fieldstone-foods/03_sec_filings/018_sec_filings_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-096-fieldstone-foods/03_sec_filings/019_sec_filings_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-096-fieldstone-foods/03_sec_filings/020_sec_filings_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-096-fieldstone-foods/03_sec_filings/021_sec_filings_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-096-fieldstone-foods/03_sec_filings/022_sec_filings_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-096-fieldstone-foods/03_sec_filings/023_sec_filings_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-096-fieldstone-foods/03_sec_filings/024_sec_filings_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-096-fieldstone-foods/04_disclosure_controls/025_disclosure_controls_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-096-fieldstone-foods/04_disclosure_controls/026_disclosure_controls_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-096-fieldstone-foods/04_disclosure_controls/027_disclosure_controls_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-096-fieldstone-foods/04_disclosure_controls/028_disclosure_controls_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-096-fieldstone-foods/04_disclosure_controls/029_disclosure_controls_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-096-fieldstone-foods/04_disclosure_controls/030_disclosure_controls_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-096-fieldstone-foods/04_disclosure_controls/031_disclosure_controls_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-096-fieldstone-foods/04_disclosure_controls/032_disclosure_controls_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-096-fieldstone-foods/05_insider_trading/033_insider_trading_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-096-fieldstone-foods/05_insider_trading/034_insider_trading_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-096-fieldstone-foods/05_insider_trading/035_insider_trading_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-096-fieldstone-foods/05_insider_trading/036_insider_trading_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-096-fieldstone-foods/05_insider_trading/037_insider_trading_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-096-fieldstone-foods/05_insider_trading/038_insider_trading_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-096-fieldstone-foods/05_insider_trading/039_insider_trading_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-096-fieldstone-foods/05_insider_trading/040_insider_trading_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-096-fieldstone-foods/06_related_parties/041_related_parties_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-096-fieldstone-foods/06_related_parties/042_related_parties_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-096-fieldstone-foods/06_related_parties/043_related_parties_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-096-fieldstone-foods/06_related_parties/044_related_parties_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-096-fieldstone-foods/06_related_parties/045_related_parties_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-096-fieldstone-foods/06_related_parties/046_related_parties_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-096-fieldstone-foods/06_related_parties/047_related_parties_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-096-fieldstone-foods/06_related_parties/048_related_parties_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-096-fieldstone-foods/07_equity_compensation/049_equity_compensation_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-096-fieldstone-foods/07_equity_compensation/050_equity_compensation_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-096-fieldstone-foods/07_equity_compensation/051_equity_compensation_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-096-fieldstone-foods/07_equity_compensation/052_equity_compensation_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-096-fieldstone-foods/07_equity_compensation/053_equity_compensation_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-096-fieldstone-foods/07_equity_compensation/054_equity_compensation_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-096-fieldstone-foods/07_equity_compensation/055_equity_compensation_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-096-fieldstone-foods/07_equity_compensation/056_equity_compensation_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-096-fieldstone-foods/08_earnings_guidance/057_earnings_guidance_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-096-fieldstone-foods/08_earnings_guidance/058_earnings_guidance_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-096-fieldstone-foods/08_earnings_guidance/059_earnings_guidance_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-096-fieldstone-foods/08_earnings_guidance/060_earnings_guidance_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-096-fieldstone-foods/08_earnings_guidance/061_earnings_guidance_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-096-fieldstone-foods/08_earnings_guidance/062_earnings_guidance_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-096-fieldstone-foods/08_earnings_guidance/063_earnings_guidance_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-096-fieldstone-foods/08_earnings_guidance/064_earnings_guidance_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-096-fieldstone-foods/09_whistleblower/065_whistleblower_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-096-fieldstone-foods/09_whistleblower/066_whistleblower_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-096-fieldstone-foods/09_whistleblower/067_whistleblower_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-096-fieldstone-foods/09_whistleblower/068_whistleblower_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-096-fieldstone-foods/09_whistleblower/069_whistleblower_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-096-fieldstone-foods/09_whistleblower/070_whistleblower_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-096-fieldstone-foods/09_whistleblower/071_whistleblower_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-096-fieldstone-foods/09_whistleblower/072_whistleblower_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-096-fieldstone-foods/10_stock_exchange/073_stock_exchange_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-096-fieldstone-foods/10_stock_exchange/074_stock_exchange_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-096-fieldstone-foods/10_stock_exchange/075_stock_exchange_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-096-fieldstone-foods/10_stock_exchange/076_stock_exchange_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-096-fieldstone-foods/10_stock_exchange/077_stock_exchange_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-096-fieldstone-foods/10_stock_exchange/078_stock_exchange_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-096-fieldstone-foods/10_stock_exchange/079_stock_exchange_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-096-fieldstone-foods/10_stock_exchange/080_stock_exchange_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-096-fieldstone-foods/11_debt_covenants/081_debt_covenants_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-096-fieldstone-foods/11_debt_covenants/082_debt_covenants_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-096-fieldstone-foods/11_debt_covenants/083_debt_covenants_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-096-fieldstone-foods/11_debt_covenants/084_debt_covenants_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-096-fieldstone-foods/11_debt_covenants/085_debt_covenants_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-096-fieldstone-foods/11_debt_covenants/086_debt_covenants_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-096-fieldstone-foods/11_debt_covenants/087_debt_covenants_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-096-fieldstone-foods/11_debt_covenants/088_debt_covenants_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-096-fieldstone-foods/12_certifications/089_certifications_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-096-fieldstone-foods/12_certifications/090_certifications_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-096-fieldstone-foods/12_certifications/091_certifications_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-096-fieldstone-foods/12_certifications/092_certifications_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-096-fieldstone-foods/12_certifications/093_certifications_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-096-fieldstone-foods/12_certifications/094_certifications_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-096-fieldstone-foods/12_certifications/095_certifications_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-096-fieldstone-foods/12_certifications/096_certifications_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-096-fieldstone-foods/12_certifications/097_fieldstone_foods_impact_population.xlsx"], "gold_output": {"advice_markdown": "# Decision note — Fieldstone whistleblower escalation audit\n\n## Recommendation\n\nCorrect supported escalation and disclosure failures and preserve investigation independence. The reconciled record supports 6 scoped actions and leaves 6 items on evidence hold.\n\nSelected option: `fieldstone-foods:scoped-evidence`.\n\n## Why this is the supported option\n\nJoin complaint receipt, revenue facts, management knowledge, hotline routing, director notice, and release timing. Whistleblower and disclosure controls require timely escalation based on exact receipt and knowledge events.\n\n## Supported actions\n\n### CBP-096-01 — board-matrix inconsistency (high)\n\nthe controlled population contains 218 records under CB-PC-3306-R876; the certification covers 190 records under CB-PC-3306-E198. Identity resolves to ENT-096-1000, revision REV-2026.1 is current, and Nora Chen is active with capacity 2.\n\nAction: Create event-recipient rows with separate complaint and disclosure dispositions. Owner: Nora Chen; due 2026-09-20.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_board_committees/001_board_committees_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/013_minutes_materials_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/025_disclosure_controls_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/037_insider_trading_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/12_certifications/097_fieldstone_foods_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-096-03 — non-GAAP reconciliation issue (medium)\n\nthe operative cap is $7,042,000.00 under CB-PC-3306-R673; the matched ledger population totals $7,183,373.00 under CB-PC-3306-E927. Identity resolves to ENT-096-1002, revision REV-2026.3 is current, and Amara Patel is active with capacity 3.\n\nAction: Create event-recipient rows with separate complaint and disclosure dispositions. Owner: Amara Patel; due 2026-09-18.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_board_committees/003_board_committees_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/015_minutes_materials_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/027_disclosure_controls_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/039_insider_trading_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/12_certifications/097_fieldstone_foods_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-096-07 — debt-covenant disclosure (medium)\n\nthe controlling threshold is 16% under CB-PC-3306-R517; the independently calculated result is 24% under CB-PC-3306-E336. Identity resolves to ENT-096-1006, revision REV-2026.7 is current, and Farah Ibrahim is active with capacity 4.\n\nAction: Create event-recipient rows with separate complaint and disclosure dispositions. Owner: Farah Ibrahim; due 2026-09-14.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_board_committees/007_board_committees_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/019_sec_filings_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/031_disclosure_controls_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/06_related_parties/043_related_parties_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/07_equity_compensation/055_equity_compensation_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/12_certifications/097_fieldstone_foods_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-096-09 — related-party disclosure gap (high)\n\nthe controlled population contains 177 records under CB-PC-3306-R155; the certification covers 164 records under CB-PC-3306-E156. Identity resolves to ENT-096-1008, revision REV-2026.2 is current, and Leona Park is active with capacity 3.\n\nAction: Create event-recipient rows with separate complaint and disclosure dispositions. Owner: Leona Park; due 2026-09-12.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/009_minutes_materials_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/021_sec_filings_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/033_insider_trading_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/06_related_parties/045_related_parties_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/11_debt_covenants/081_debt_covenants_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/12_certifications/097_fieldstone_foods_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-096-10 — listing-standard notice (medium)\n\nthe permission is limited to Nasdaq Stock Market under CB-PC-3306-R142; the matched activity occurred in Illinois under CB-PC-3306-E473. Identity resolves to ENT-096-1009, revision REV-2026.3 is current, and Henry Cho is active with capacity 2.\n\nAction: Create event-recipient rows with separate complaint and disclosure dispositions. Owner: Henry Cho; due 2026-09-20.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/010_minutes_materials_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/022_sec_filings_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/034_insider_trading_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/06_related_parties/046_related_parties_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/08_earnings_guidance/058_earnings_guidance_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/12_certifications/097_fieldstone_foods_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-096-11 — minutes-approval omission (medium)\n\nthe operative cap is $25,000.00 under CB-PC-3306-R588; the matched ledger population totals $168,988.00 under CB-PC-3306-E605. Identity resolves to ENT-096-1010, revision REV-2026.4 is current, and Maya Ellison is active with capacity 3.\n\nAction: Create event-recipient rows with separate complaint and disclosure dispositions. Owner: Maya Ellison; due 2026-09-19.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/011_minutes_materials_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/023_sec_filings_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/035_insider_trading_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/06_related_parties/047_related_parties_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/11_debt_covenants/083_debt_covenants_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/12_certifications/097_fieldstone_foods_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n## Evidence holds\n\n- **CBP-096-02 — disclosure-control exception**: two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key. Next evidence: an approved immutable entity crosswalk. Sources: `/workspace/documents/01_board_committees/002_board_committees_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/014_minutes_materials_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/026_disclosure_controls_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/038_insider_trading_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/12_certifications/097_fieldstone_foods_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-096-04 — officer certification exception**: the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective. Next evidence: effective approval and an active owner with remaining capacity. Sources: `/workspace/documents/01_board_committees/004_board_committees_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/016_minutes_materials_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/028_disclosure_controls_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/040_insider_trading_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/12_certifications/097_fieldstone_foods_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-096-05 — risk-factor inconsistency**: the operational record relies on a superseded control revision. Next evidence: an operational record using the current effective revision. Sources: `/workspace/documents/01_board_committees/005_board_committees_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/017_sec_filings_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/029_disclosure_controls_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/06_related_parties/041_related_parties_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/07_equity_compensation/053_equity_compensation_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/09_whistleblower/065_whistleblower_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/12_certifications/097_fieldstone_foods_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-096-06 — equity-plan share mismatch**: two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key. Next evidence: an approved immutable entity crosswalk. Sources: `/workspace/documents/01_board_committees/006_board_committees_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/018_sec_filings_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/030_disclosure_controls_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/06_related_parties/042_related_parties_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/10_stock_exchange/078_stock_exchange_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/12_certifications/097_fieldstone_foods_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-096-08 — 8-K deadline**: the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective. Next evidence: effective approval and an active owner with remaining capacity. Sources: `/workspace/documents/01_board_committees/008_board_committees_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/020_sec_filings_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/032_disclosure_controls_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/06_related_parties/044_related_parties_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/12_certifications/097_fieldstone_foods_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-096-12 — Section 16 filing delay**: the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective. Next evidence: effective approval and an active owner with remaining capacity. Sources: `/workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/012_minutes_materials_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/024_sec_filings_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/036_insider_trading_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/06_related_parties/048_related_parties_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/12_certifications/097_fieldstone_foods_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n## Alternatives considered\n\n- `fieldstone-foods:blanket-hold` — Freeze the entire matter population: Treat supported actions and genuinely ambiguous records as if they were equally unresolved.\n- `fieldstone-foods:shortcut` — Treat the earliest anonymous message as proven revenue misstatement and board knowledge.: Use a plausible summary or one source without completing the controlling joins.\n\n## Assumptions and limits\n\nThis decision is limited to cb100-096-fieldstone-foods, the supplied synthetic records, and the matter state as of 2026-09-21. Similar names, stale revisions, and pending authority are not treated as proof.\n", "decision": {"actions": [{"determination": "the controlled population contains 218 records under CB-PC-3306-R876; the certification covers 190 records under CB-PC-3306-E198. Identity resolves to ENT-096-1000, revision REV-2026.1 is current, and Nora Chen is active with capacity 2.", "due_date": "2026-09-20", "id": "ACT-CBP-096-01", "identity_id": "ENT-096-1000", "issue": "board-matrix inconsistency", "owner": "Nora Chen", "portfolio_key": "CBP-096-01", "recommended_action": "Create event-recipient rows with separate complaint and disclosure dispositions. Owner: Nora Chen; due 2026-09-20.", "severity": "high", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_board_committees/001_board_committees_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/013_minutes_materials_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/025_disclosure_controls_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/037_insider_trading_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_certifications/097_fieldstone_foods_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "the operative cap is $7,042,000.00 under CB-PC-3306-R673; the matched ledger population totals $7,183,373.00 under CB-PC-3306-E927. Identity resolves to ENT-096-1002, revision REV-2026.3 is current, and Amara Patel is active with capacity 3.", "due_date": "2026-09-18", "id": "ACT-CBP-096-03", "identity_id": "ENT-096-1002", "issue": "non-GAAP reconciliation issue", "owner": "Amara Patel", "portfolio_key": "CBP-096-03", "recommended_action": "Create event-recipient rows with separate complaint and disclosure dispositions. Owner: Amara Patel; due 2026-09-18.", "severity": "medium", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_board_committees/003_board_committees_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/015_minutes_materials_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/027_disclosure_controls_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/039_insider_trading_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_certifications/097_fieldstone_foods_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "the controlling threshold is 16% under CB-PC-3306-R517; the independently calculated result is 24% under CB-PC-3306-E336. Identity resolves to ENT-096-1006, revision REV-2026.7 is current, and Farah Ibrahim is active with capacity 4.", "due_date": "2026-09-14", "id": "ACT-CBP-096-07", "identity_id": "ENT-096-1006", "issue": "debt-covenant disclosure", "owner": "Farah Ibrahim", "portfolio_key": "CBP-096-07", "recommended_action": "Create event-recipient rows with separate complaint and disclosure dispositions. Owner: Farah Ibrahim; due 2026-09-14.", "severity": "medium", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_board_committees/007_board_committees_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/019_sec_filings_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/031_disclosure_controls_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/06_related_parties/043_related_parties_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/07_equity_compensation/055_equity_compensation_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_certifications/097_fieldstone_foods_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "the controlled population contains 177 records under CB-PC-3306-R155; the certification covers 164 records under CB-PC-3306-E156. Identity resolves to ENT-096-1008, revision REV-2026.2 is current, and Leona Park is active with capacity 3.", "due_date": "2026-09-12", "id": "ACT-CBP-096-09", "identity_id": "ENT-096-1008", "issue": "related-party disclosure gap", "owner": "Leona Park", "portfolio_key": "CBP-096-09", "recommended_action": "Create event-recipient rows with separate complaint and disclosure dispositions. Owner: Leona Park; due 2026-09-12.", "severity": "high", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/009_minutes_materials_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/021_sec_filings_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/033_insider_trading_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/06_related_parties/045_related_parties_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/11_debt_covenants/081_debt_covenants_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/12_certifications/097_fieldstone_foods_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "the permission is limited to Nasdaq Stock Market under CB-PC-3306-R142; the matched activity occurred in Illinois under CB-PC-3306-E473. Identity resolves to ENT-096-1009, revision REV-2026.3 is current, and Henry Cho is active with capacity 2.", "due_date": "2026-09-20", "id": "ACT-CBP-096-10", "identity_id": "ENT-096-1009", "issue": "listing-standard notice", "owner": "Henry Cho", "portfolio_key": "CBP-096-10", "recommended_action": "Create event-recipient rows with separate complaint and disclosure dispositions. Owner: Henry Cho; due 2026-09-20.", "severity": "medium", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/010_minutes_materials_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/022_sec_filings_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/034_insider_trading_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/06_related_parties/046_related_parties_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/08_earnings_guidance/058_earnings_guidance_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/12_certifications/097_fieldstone_foods_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "the operative cap is $25,000.00 under CB-PC-3306-R588; the matched ledger population totals $168,988.00 under CB-PC-3306-E605. Identity resolves to ENT-096-1010, revision REV-2026.4 is current, and Maya Ellison is active with capacity 3.", "due_date": "2026-09-19", "id": "ACT-CBP-096-11", "identity_id": "ENT-096-1010", "issue": "minutes-approval omission", "owner": "Maya Ellison", "portfolio_key": "CBP-096-11", "recommended_action": "Create event-recipient rows with separate complaint and disclosure dispositions. Owner: Maya Ellison; due 2026-09-19.", "severity": "medium", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/011_minutes_materials_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/023_sec_filings_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/035_insider_trading_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/06_related_parties/047_related_parties_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/11_debt_covenants/083_debt_covenants_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/12_certifications/097_fieldstone_foods_impact_population.xlsx"]}], "as_of": "2026-09-21", "decision": {"alternatives_considered": ["fieldstone-foods:blanket-hold", "fieldstone-foods:shortcut"], "question": "Did Fieldstone escalate the whistleblower complaint properly before the earnings release?", "rationale": "The four-part causal test supports 6 scoped actions and leaves 6 records on evidence hold. Whistleblower and disclosure controls require timely escalation based on exact receipt and knowledge events.", "recommendation": "Correct supported escalation and disclosure failures and preserve investigation independence.", "selected_option_id": "fieldstone-foods:scoped-evidence"}, "holds": [{"id": "HOLD-CBP-096-02", "issue": "disclosure-control exception", "portfolio_key": "CBP-096-02", "reason": "two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key", "required_next_evidence": "an approved immutable entity crosswalk", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_board_committees/002_board_committees_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/014_minutes_materials_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/026_disclosure_controls_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/038_insider_trading_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_certifications/097_fieldstone_foods_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-096-04", "issue": "officer certification exception", "portfolio_key": "CBP-096-04", "reason": "the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective", "required_next_evidence": "effective approval and an active owner with remaining capacity", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_board_committees/004_board_committees_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/016_minutes_materials_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/028_disclosure_controls_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/040_insider_trading_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_certifications/097_fieldstone_foods_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-096-05", "issue": "risk-factor inconsistency", "portfolio_key": "CBP-096-05", "reason": "the operational record relies on a superseded control revision", "required_next_evidence": "an operational record using the current effective revision", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_board_committees/005_board_committees_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/017_sec_filings_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/029_disclosure_controls_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/06_related_parties/041_related_parties_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/07_equity_compensation/053_equity_compensation_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/09_whistleblower/065_whistleblower_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/12_certifications/097_fieldstone_foods_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-096-06", "issue": "equity-plan share mismatch", "portfolio_key": "CBP-096-06", "reason": "two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key", "required_next_evidence": "an approved immutable entity crosswalk", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_board_committees/006_board_committees_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/018_sec_filings_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/030_disclosure_controls_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/06_related_parties/042_related_parties_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/10_stock_exchange/078_stock_exchange_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_certifications/097_fieldstone_foods_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-096-08", "issue": "8-K deadline", "portfolio_key": "CBP-096-08", "reason": "the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective", "required_next_evidence": "effective approval and an active owner with remaining capacity", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_board_committees/008_board_committees_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/020_sec_filings_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/032_disclosure_controls_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/06_related_parties/044_related_parties_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/12_certifications/097_fieldstone_foods_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-096-12", "issue": "Section 16 filing delay", "portfolio_key": "CBP-096-12", "reason": "the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective", "required_next_evidence": "effective approval and an active owner with remaining capacity", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/012_minutes_materials_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/024_sec_filings_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/036_insider_trading_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/06_related_parties/048_related_parties_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_certifications/097_fieldstone_foods_impact_population.xlsx"]}], "matter_number": "CB-PC-3306", "prepared_for": "Fieldstone Foods plc", "schema_version": "counselbench.decision.v3", "task_id": "cb100-096-fieldstone-foods"}, "matter_register": {"matter_number": "CB-PC-3306", "rows": [{"decision_option_id": "fieldstone-foods:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-20", "issue": "board-matrix inconsistency", "matter_number": "CB-PC-3306", "owner": "Nora Chen", "portfolio_key": "CBP-096-01", "row_id": "REG-CBP-096-01", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_board_committees/001_board_committees_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/013_minutes_materials_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/025_disclosure_controls_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/037_insider_trading_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_certifications/097_fieldstone_foods_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "fieldstone-foods:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key", "issue": "disclosure-control exception", "matter_number": "CB-PC-3306", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-096-02", "row_id": "REG-CBP-096-02", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_board_committees/002_board_committees_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/014_minutes_materials_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/026_disclosure_controls_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/038_insider_trading_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_certifications/097_fieldstone_foods_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "fieldstone-foods:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-18", "issue": "non-GAAP reconciliation issue", "matter_number": "CB-PC-3306", "owner": "Amara Patel", "portfolio_key": "CBP-096-03", "row_id": "REG-CBP-096-03", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_board_committees/003_board_committees_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/015_minutes_materials_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/027_disclosure_controls_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/039_insider_trading_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_certifications/097_fieldstone_foods_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "fieldstone-foods:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective", "issue": "officer certification exception", "matter_number": "CB-PC-3306", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-096-04", "row_id": "REG-CBP-096-04", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_board_committees/004_board_committees_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/016_minutes_materials_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/028_disclosure_controls_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/040_insider_trading_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_certifications/097_fieldstone_foods_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "fieldstone-foods:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "the operational record relies on a superseded control revision", "issue": "risk-factor inconsistency", "matter_number": "CB-PC-3306", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-096-05", "row_id": "REG-CBP-096-05", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_board_committees/005_board_committees_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/017_sec_filings_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/029_disclosure_controls_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/06_related_parties/041_related_parties_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/07_equity_compensation/053_equity_compensation_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/09_whistleblower/065_whistleblower_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/12_certifications/097_fieldstone_foods_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "fieldstone-foods:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key", "issue": "equity-plan share mismatch", "matter_number": "CB-PC-3306", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-096-06", "row_id": "REG-CBP-096-06", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_board_committees/006_board_committees_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/018_sec_filings_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/030_disclosure_controls_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/06_related_parties/042_related_parties_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/10_stock_exchange/078_stock_exchange_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_certifications/097_fieldstone_foods_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "fieldstone-foods:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-14", "issue": "debt-covenant disclosure", "matter_number": "CB-PC-3306", "owner": "Farah Ibrahim", "portfolio_key": "CBP-096-07", "row_id": "REG-CBP-096-07", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_board_committees/007_board_committees_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/019_sec_filings_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/031_disclosure_controls_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/06_related_parties/043_related_parties_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/07_equity_compensation/055_equity_compensation_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_certifications/097_fieldstone_foods_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "fieldstone-foods:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective", "issue": "8-K deadline", "matter_number": "CB-PC-3306", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-096-08", "row_id": "REG-CBP-096-08", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_board_committees/008_board_committees_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/020_sec_filings_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/032_disclosure_controls_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/06_related_parties/044_related_parties_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/12_certifications/097_fieldstone_foods_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "fieldstone-foods:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-12", "issue": "related-party disclosure gap", "matter_number": "CB-PC-3306", "owner": "Leona Park", "portfolio_key": "CBP-096-09", "row_id": "REG-CBP-096-09", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/009_minutes_materials_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/021_sec_filings_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/033_insider_trading_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/06_related_parties/045_related_parties_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/11_debt_covenants/081_debt_covenants_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/12_certifications/097_fieldstone_foods_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "fieldstone-foods:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-20", "issue": "listing-standard notice", "matter_number": "CB-PC-3306", "owner": "Henry Cho", "portfolio_key": "CBP-096-10", "row_id": "REG-CBP-096-10", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/010_minutes_materials_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/022_sec_filings_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/034_insider_trading_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/06_related_parties/046_related_parties_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/08_earnings_guidance/058_earnings_guidance_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/12_certifications/097_fieldstone_foods_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "fieldstone-foods:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-19", "issue": "minutes-approval omission", "matter_number": "CB-PC-3306", "owner": "Maya Ellison", "portfolio_key": "CBP-096-11", "row_id": "REG-CBP-096-11", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/011_minutes_materials_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/023_sec_filings_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/035_insider_trading_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/06_related_parties/047_related_parties_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/11_debt_covenants/083_debt_covenants_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/12_certifications/097_fieldstone_foods_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "fieldstone-foods:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective", "issue": "Section 16 filing delay", "matter_number": "CB-PC-3306", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-096-12", "row_id": "REG-CBP-096-12", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/012_minutes_materials_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/024_sec_filings_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/036_insider_trading_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/06_related_parties/048_related_parties_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_certifications/097_fieldstone_foods_impact_population.xlsx"]}], "schema_version": "counselbench.matter-register.v3", "task_id": "cb100-096-fieldstone-foods"}}, "metadata": {"benchmark": "CounselBench-100", "code_license": "Apache-2.0", "data_license": "CC-BY-4.0", "deadline": "2026-09-21", "document_count": 97, "evidence_holds": 6, "jurisdiction": "Illinois", "matter_number": "CB-PC-3306", "mcp_commit": "9a96ea6e5913736f92b88345bf51caeaaa8e719f", "mcp_package": "@modelcontextprotocol/server-filesystem@2026.7.10", "practice_area": "public-company", "reference_tool_calls": 76, "required_evidence_reads": 57, "supported_actions": 6, "synthetic": true, "venue": "Nasdaq Stock Market", "version": "3.1.0"}, "prompt": "I am about to brief the decision makers and need the source record reconciled first. Did Fieldstone escalate the whistleblower complaint properly before the earnings release? A revenue-recognition complaint reached management, the hotline vendor, and directors on different timelines before an earnings release. The team needs the call by 2026-09-21. Record the outcome the source hierarchy supports and explain the alternatives we should not take.", "rubric": {"criteria": [{"category": "investigation", "description": "Inventory the production and use targeted searches to locate records across native formats.", "id": "investigation.discover_production"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Complete every task-specific identity, authority, operations, and approval read before the first state transition.", "id": "investigation.read_before_write"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Inspect designated source metadata before relying on those records.", "id": "investigation.custody_before_write"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "Select the supported option 'fieldstone-foods:scoped-evidence' after applying the four-part test.", "id": "decision.selected_option"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "Identify both rejected approaches and explain why a one-source shortcut and a blanket hold are wrong.", "id": "decision.alternatives"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-096-01 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_board_committees/001_board_committees_source_export.md rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-096-01.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/013_minutes_materials_source_export.json for board-matrix inconsistency.", "id": "investigation.CBP-096-01.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/025_disclosure_controls_source_export.md to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-096-01.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/037_insider_trading_source_export.json.", "id": "investigation.CBP-096-01.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-096-01 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-096-01.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-096-01 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-096-01.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-096-02 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_board_committees/002_board_committees_source_export.txt rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-096-02.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/014_minutes_materials_source_export.xml for disclosure-control exception.", "id": "investigation.CBP-096-02.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/026_disclosure_controls_source_export.txt to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-096-02.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/038_insider_trading_source_export.xml.", "id": "investigation.CBP-096-02.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-096-02 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key.", "id": "decision.CBP-096-02.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-096-02 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-096-02.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-096-03 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_board_committees/003_board_committees_source_export.eml rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-096-03.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/015_minutes_materials_source_export.html for non-GAAP reconciliation issue.", "id": "investigation.CBP-096-03.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/027_disclosure_controls_source_export.eml to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-096-03.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/039_insider_trading_source_export.html.", "id": "investigation.CBP-096-03.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-096-03 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-096-03.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-096-03 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-096-03.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-096-04 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_board_committees/004_board_committees_source_export.csv rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-096-04.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/016_minutes_materials_source_export.pdf for officer certification exception.", "id": "investigation.CBP-096-04.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/028_disclosure_controls_source_export.csv to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-096-04.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/040_insider_trading_source_export.pdf.", "id": "investigation.CBP-096-04.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-096-04 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective.", "id": "decision.CBP-096-04.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-096-04 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-096-04.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-096-05 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_board_committees/005_board_committees_source_export.json rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-096-05.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/017_sec_filings_source_export.md for risk-factor inconsistency.", "id": "investigation.CBP-096-05.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/029_disclosure_controls_source_export.json to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-096-05.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_related_parties/041_related_parties_source_export.md.", "id": "investigation.CBP-096-05.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-096-05 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is the operational record relies on a superseded control revision.", "id": "decision.CBP-096-05.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-096-05 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-096-05.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-096-06 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_board_committees/006_board_committees_source_export.xml rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-096-06.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/018_sec_filings_source_export.txt for equity-plan share mismatch.", "id": "investigation.CBP-096-06.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/030_disclosure_controls_source_export.xml to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-096-06.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_related_parties/042_related_parties_source_export.txt.", "id": "investigation.CBP-096-06.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-096-06 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key.", "id": "decision.CBP-096-06.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-096-06 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-096-06.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-096-07 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_board_committees/007_board_committees_source_export.html rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-096-07.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/019_sec_filings_source_export.eml for debt-covenant disclosure.", "id": "investigation.CBP-096-07.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/031_disclosure_controls_source_export.html to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-096-07.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_related_parties/043_related_parties_source_export.eml.", "id": "investigation.CBP-096-07.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-096-07 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-096-07.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-096-07 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-096-07.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-096-08 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_board_committees/008_board_committees_source_export.pdf rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-096-08.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/020_sec_filings_source_export.csv for 8-K deadline.", "id": "investigation.CBP-096-08.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/032_disclosure_controls_source_export.pdf to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-096-08.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_related_parties/044_related_parties_source_export.csv.", "id": "investigation.CBP-096-08.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-096-08 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective.", "id": "decision.CBP-096-08.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-096-08 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-096-08.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-096-09 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/009_minutes_materials_source_export.md rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-096-09.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/021_sec_filings_source_export.json for related-party disclosure gap.", "id": "investigation.CBP-096-09.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/033_insider_trading_source_export.md to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-096-09.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_related_parties/045_related_parties_source_export.json.", "id": "investigation.CBP-096-09.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-096-09 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-096-09.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-096-09 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-096-09.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-096-10 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/010_minutes_materials_source_export.txt rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-096-10.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/022_sec_filings_source_export.xml for listing-standard notice.", "id": "investigation.CBP-096-10.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/034_insider_trading_source_export.txt to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-096-10.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_related_parties/046_related_parties_source_export.xml.", "id": "investigation.CBP-096-10.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-096-10 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-096-10.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-096-10 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-096-10.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-096-11 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/011_minutes_materials_source_export.eml rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-096-11.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/023_sec_filings_source_export.html for minutes-approval omission.", "id": "investigation.CBP-096-11.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/035_insider_trading_source_export.eml to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-096-11.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_related_parties/047_related_parties_source_export.html.", "id": "investigation.CBP-096-11.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-096-11 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-096-11.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-096-11 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-096-11.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-096-12 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/012_minutes_materials_source_export.csv rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-096-12.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/024_sec_filings_source_export.pdf for Section 16 filing delay.", "id": "investigation.CBP-096-12.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/036_insider_trading_source_export.csv to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-096-12.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_related_parties/048_related_parties_source_export.pdf.", "id": "investigation.CBP-096-12.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-096-12 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective.", "id": "decision.CBP-096-12.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-096-12 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-096-12.register"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Write the exact selected option, supported action population, evidence-hold population, facts, owners, deadlines, and citations.", "id": "state.exact_decision"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create one exact register row per portfolio key with no extra, missing, or modified row.", "id": "state.exact_register"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Leave only the three approved deliverables and perform no extra state-changing write.", "id": "state.write_scope_containment"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Read back decision.json, matter-register.json, and advice.md after their final writes.", "id": "state.postwrite_readback"}, {"category": "answer", "description": "Explain the selected recommendation, supported actions, holds, alternatives, and limitations with exact source anchors.", "id": "answer.decision_note"}], "decision_options": [{"approach": "Treat supported actions and genuinely ambiguous records as if they were equally unresolved.", "id": "fieldstone-foods:blanket-hold", "label": "Freeze the entire matter population"}, {"approach": "Apply the exact identity, current-state, authority, and revision test. Create event-recipient rows with separate complaint and disclosure dispositions.", "id": "fieldstone-foods:scoped-evidence", "label": "Correct supported escalation and disclosure failures and preserve investigation independence."}, {"approach": "Use a plausible summary or one source without completing the controlling joins.", "id": "fieldstone-foods:shortcut", "label": "Treat the earliest anonymous message as proven revenue misstatement and board knowledge."}], "evaluation_narrative": {"authority": "Whistleblower and disclosure controls require timely escalation based on exact receipt and knowledge events.", "observation": "Join complaint receipt, revenue facts, management knowledge, hotline routing, director notice, and release timing.", "question": "Did Fieldstone escalate the whistleblower complaint properly before the earnings release?", "register_action": "Create event-recipient rows with separate complaint and disclosure dispositions."}, "gates": ["all_required_evidence_precedes_first_write", "decision_criteria_complete", "register_state_exact", "write_scope_contained", "all_outputs_verified_by_readback"], "metadata_checks": 6, "metric": "weighted_criteria_score", "minimum_tool_calls": 76, "required_deliverables": ["decision.json", "matter-register.json", "advice.md"], "required_document_reads": 57, "type": "deterministic", "weights": {"advice": 0.15, "decision": 0.35, "investigation": 0.25, "state": 0.25}}, "task_id": "cb100-096-fieldstone-foods", "task_name": "Fieldstone whistleblower escalation audit", "world_id": "counselbench-filesystem-mcp-v3"}
+{"context_files": ["task_files/cb100-097-granular-tech/01_board_committees/001_board_committees_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-097-granular-tech/01_board_committees/002_board_committees_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-097-granular-tech/01_board_committees/003_board_committees_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-097-granular-tech/01_board_committees/004_board_committees_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-097-granular-tech/01_board_committees/005_board_committees_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-097-granular-tech/01_board_committees/006_board_committees_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-097-granular-tech/01_board_committees/007_board_committees_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-097-granular-tech/01_board_committees/008_board_committees_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-097-granular-tech/02_minutes_materials/009_minutes_materials_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-097-granular-tech/02_minutes_materials/010_minutes_materials_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-097-granular-tech/02_minutes_materials/011_minutes_materials_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-097-granular-tech/02_minutes_materials/012_minutes_materials_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-097-granular-tech/02_minutes_materials/013_minutes_materials_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-097-granular-tech/02_minutes_materials/014_minutes_materials_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-097-granular-tech/02_minutes_materials/015_minutes_materials_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-097-granular-tech/02_minutes_materials/016_minutes_materials_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-097-granular-tech/03_sec_filings/017_sec_filings_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-097-granular-tech/03_sec_filings/018_sec_filings_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-097-granular-tech/03_sec_filings/019_sec_filings_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-097-granular-tech/03_sec_filings/020_sec_filings_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-097-granular-tech/03_sec_filings/021_sec_filings_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-097-granular-tech/03_sec_filings/022_sec_filings_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-097-granular-tech/03_sec_filings/023_sec_filings_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-097-granular-tech/03_sec_filings/024_sec_filings_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-097-granular-tech/04_disclosure_controls/025_disclosure_controls_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-097-granular-tech/04_disclosure_controls/026_disclosure_controls_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-097-granular-tech/04_disclosure_controls/027_disclosure_controls_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-097-granular-tech/04_disclosure_controls/028_disclosure_controls_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-097-granular-tech/04_disclosure_controls/029_disclosure_controls_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-097-granular-tech/04_disclosure_controls/030_disclosure_controls_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-097-granular-tech/04_disclosure_controls/031_disclosure_controls_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-097-granular-tech/04_disclosure_controls/032_disclosure_controls_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-097-granular-tech/05_insider_trading/033_insider_trading_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-097-granular-tech/05_insider_trading/034_insider_trading_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-097-granular-tech/05_insider_trading/035_insider_trading_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-097-granular-tech/05_insider_trading/036_insider_trading_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-097-granular-tech/05_insider_trading/037_insider_trading_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-097-granular-tech/05_insider_trading/038_insider_trading_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-097-granular-tech/05_insider_trading/039_insider_trading_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-097-granular-tech/05_insider_trading/040_insider_trading_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-097-granular-tech/06_related_parties/041_related_parties_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-097-granular-tech/06_related_parties/042_related_parties_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-097-granular-tech/06_related_parties/043_related_parties_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-097-granular-tech/06_related_parties/044_related_parties_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-097-granular-tech/06_related_parties/045_related_parties_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-097-granular-tech/06_related_parties/046_related_parties_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-097-granular-tech/06_related_parties/047_related_parties_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-097-granular-tech/06_related_parties/048_related_parties_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-097-granular-tech/07_equity_compensation/049_equity_compensation_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-097-granular-tech/07_equity_compensation/050_equity_compensation_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-097-granular-tech/07_equity_compensation/051_equity_compensation_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-097-granular-tech/07_equity_compensation/052_equity_compensation_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-097-granular-tech/07_equity_compensation/053_equity_compensation_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-097-granular-tech/07_equity_compensation/054_equity_compensation_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-097-granular-tech/07_equity_compensation/055_equity_compensation_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-097-granular-tech/07_equity_compensation/056_equity_compensation_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-097-granular-tech/08_earnings_guidance/057_earnings_guidance_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-097-granular-tech/08_earnings_guidance/058_earnings_guidance_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-097-granular-tech/08_earnings_guidance/059_earnings_guidance_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-097-granular-tech/08_earnings_guidance/060_earnings_guidance_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-097-granular-tech/08_earnings_guidance/061_earnings_guidance_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-097-granular-tech/08_earnings_guidance/062_earnings_guidance_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-097-granular-tech/08_earnings_guidance/063_earnings_guidance_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-097-granular-tech/08_earnings_guidance/064_earnings_guidance_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-097-granular-tech/09_whistleblower/065_whistleblower_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-097-granular-tech/09_whistleblower/066_whistleblower_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-097-granular-tech/09_whistleblower/067_whistleblower_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-097-granular-tech/09_whistleblower/068_whistleblower_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-097-granular-tech/09_whistleblower/069_whistleblower_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-097-granular-tech/09_whistleblower/070_whistleblower_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-097-granular-tech/09_whistleblower/071_whistleblower_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-097-granular-tech/09_whistleblower/072_whistleblower_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-097-granular-tech/10_stock_exchange/073_stock_exchange_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-097-granular-tech/10_stock_exchange/074_stock_exchange_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-097-granular-tech/10_stock_exchange/075_stock_exchange_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-097-granular-tech/10_stock_exchange/076_stock_exchange_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-097-granular-tech/10_stock_exchange/077_stock_exchange_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-097-granular-tech/10_stock_exchange/078_stock_exchange_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-097-granular-tech/10_stock_exchange/079_stock_exchange_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-097-granular-tech/10_stock_exchange/080_stock_exchange_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-097-granular-tech/11_debt_covenants/081_debt_covenants_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-097-granular-tech/11_debt_covenants/082_debt_covenants_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-097-granular-tech/11_debt_covenants/083_debt_covenants_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-097-granular-tech/11_debt_covenants/084_debt_covenants_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-097-granular-tech/11_debt_covenants/085_debt_covenants_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-097-granular-tech/11_debt_covenants/086_debt_covenants_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-097-granular-tech/11_debt_covenants/087_debt_covenants_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-097-granular-tech/11_debt_covenants/088_debt_covenants_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-097-granular-tech/12_certifications/089_certifications_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-097-granular-tech/12_certifications/090_certifications_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-097-granular-tech/12_certifications/091_certifications_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-097-granular-tech/12_certifications/092_certifications_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-097-granular-tech/12_certifications/093_certifications_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-097-granular-tech/12_certifications/094_certifications_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-097-granular-tech/12_certifications/095_certifications_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-097-granular-tech/12_certifications/096_certifications_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-097-granular-tech/12_certifications/097_granular_tech_impact_population.xlsx"], "gold_output": {"advice_markdown": "# Decision note — Granular Section 16 filing review\n\n## Recommendation\n\nPrepare supported late or corrective filings for matched transactions. The reconciled record supports 8 scoped actions and leaves 4 items on evidence hold.\n\nSelected option: `granular-tech:scoped-evidence`.\n\n## Why this is the supported option\n\nJoin grants, broker executions, ownership forms, powers of attorney, and filing timestamps by insider and transaction. Section 16 treatment depends on exact transaction, beneficial ownership, authority, and filing clock.\n\n## Supported actions\n\n### CBP-097-01 — committee-independence gap (medium)\n\ncompletion is required by 2025-08-20 under CB-PC-3307-R326; the current event record shows completion on 2025-09-04 under CB-PC-3307-E748. Identity resolves to ENT-097-1000, revision REV-2025.1 is current, and Elliot Mercer is active with capacity 4.\n\nAction: Create insider-transaction rows with exact filing status and evidence holds. Owner: Elliot Mercer; due 2026-09-23.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_board_committees/001_board_committees_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/013_minutes_materials_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/025_disclosure_controls_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/037_insider_trading_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/12_certifications/097_granular_tech_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-097-02 — trading-window violation (high)\n\nthe controlling threshold is 13% under CB-PC-3307-R976; the independently calculated result is 18% under CB-PC-3307-E892. Identity resolves to ENT-097-1001, revision REV-2025.2 is current, and Sofia Bennett is active with capacity 1.\n\nAction: Create insider-transaction rows with exact filing status and evidence holds. Owner: Sofia Bennett; due 2026-09-22.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_board_committees/002_board_committees_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/014_minutes_materials_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/026_disclosure_controls_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/038_insider_trading_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/10_stock_exchange/074_stock_exchange_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/07_equity_compensation/050_equity_compensation_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/12_certifications/097_granular_tech_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-097-05 — disclosure-control exception (medium)\n\nthe permission is limited to Nasdaq Stock Market under CB-PC-3307-R990; the matched activity occurred in Texas under CB-PC-3307-E840. Identity resolves to ENT-097-1004, revision REV-2025.5 is current, and Caleb Hassan is active with capacity 4.\n\nAction: Create insider-transaction rows with exact filing status and evidence holds. Owner: Caleb Hassan; due 2026-09-19.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_board_committees/005_board_committees_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/017_sec_filings_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/029_disclosure_controls_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/06_related_parties/041_related_parties_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/12_certifications/097_granular_tech_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-097-06 — non-GAAP reconciliation issue (medium)\n\nthe operative cap is $7,762,000.00 under CB-PC-3307-R846; the matched ledger population totals $7,840,246.00 under CB-PC-3307-E938. Identity resolves to ENT-097-1005, revision REV-2025.6 is current, and Amara Patel is active with capacity 3.\n\nAction: Create insider-transaction rows with exact filing status and evidence holds. Owner: Amara Patel; due 2026-09-18.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_board_committees/006_board_committees_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/018_sec_filings_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/030_disclosure_controls_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/06_related_parties/042_related_parties_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/12_certifications/090_certifications_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/07_equity_compensation/054_equity_compensation_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/12_certifications/097_granular_tech_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-097-08 — risk-factor inconsistency (high)\n\nan open exception blocks completion under CB-PC-3307-R953; the current status is open and unresolved under CB-PC-3307-E626. Identity resolves to ENT-097-1007, revision REV-2025.1 is current, and Talia Brooks is active with capacity 5.\n\nAction: Create insider-transaction rows with exact filing status and evidence holds. Owner: Talia Brooks; due 2026-09-16.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_board_committees/008_board_committees_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/020_sec_filings_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/032_disclosure_controls_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/06_related_parties/044_related_parties_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/12_certifications/092_certifications_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/12_certifications/097_granular_tech_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-097-09 — equity-plan share mismatch (high)\n\ncompletion is required by 2025-08-05 under CB-PC-3307-R371; the current event record shows completion on 2025-08-26 under CB-PC-3307-E963. Identity resolves to ENT-097-1008, revision REV-2025.2 is current, and Adrian Mensah is active with capacity 4.\n\nAction: Create insider-transaction rows with exact filing status and evidence holds. Owner: Adrian Mensah; due 2026-09-15.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/009_minutes_materials_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/021_sec_filings_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/033_insider_trading_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/06_related_parties/045_related_parties_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/11_debt_covenants/081_debt_covenants_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/09_whistleblower/069_whistleblower_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/12_certifications/097_granular_tech_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-097-11 — 8-K deadline (high)\n\napproval must come from Talia Brooks under CB-PC-3307-R378; the effective approval record names Caleb Hassan under CB-PC-3307-E910. Identity resolves to ENT-097-1010, revision REV-2025.4 is current, and Dominic Alvarez is active with capacity 5.\n\nAction: Create insider-transaction rows with exact filing status and evidence holds. Owner: Dominic Alvarez; due 2026-09-22.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/011_minutes_materials_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/023_sec_filings_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/035_insider_trading_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/06_related_parties/047_related_parties_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/12_certifications/095_certifications_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/08_earnings_guidance/059_earnings_guidance_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/12_certifications/097_granular_tech_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-097-12 — related-party disclosure gap (high)\n\nthe controlled population contains 140 records under CB-PC-3307-R408; the certification covers 105 records under CB-PC-3307-E224. Identity resolves to ENT-097-1011, revision REV-2025.5 is current, and Leona Park is active with capacity 6.\n\nAction: Create insider-transaction rows with exact filing status and evidence holds. Owner: Leona Park; due 2026-09-21.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/012_minutes_materials_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/024_sec_filings_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/036_insider_trading_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/06_related_parties/048_related_parties_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/09_whistleblower/072_whistleblower_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/12_certifications/097_granular_tech_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n## Evidence holds\n\n- **CBP-097-03 — guidance-control failure**: the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective. Next evidence: effective approval and an active owner with remaining capacity. Sources: `/workspace/documents/01_board_committees/003_board_committees_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/015_minutes_materials_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/027_disclosure_controls_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/039_insider_trading_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/07_equity_compensation/051_equity_compensation_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/11_debt_covenants/087_debt_covenants_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/12_certifications/097_granular_tech_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-097-04 — board-matrix inconsistency**: the operational record relies on a superseded control revision. Next evidence: an operational record using the current effective revision. Sources: `/workspace/documents/01_board_committees/004_board_committees_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/016_minutes_materials_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/028_disclosure_controls_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/040_insider_trading_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/12_certifications/097_granular_tech_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-097-07 — officer certification exception**: the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective. Next evidence: effective approval and an active owner with remaining capacity. Sources: `/workspace/documents/01_board_committees/007_board_committees_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/019_sec_filings_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/031_disclosure_controls_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/06_related_parties/043_related_parties_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/12_certifications/097_granular_tech_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-097-10 — debt-covenant disclosure**: the current observation does not meet the operative trigger. Next evidence: a current observation that satisfies the operative trigger. Sources: `/workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/010_minutes_materials_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/022_sec_filings_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/034_insider_trading_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/06_related_parties/046_related_parties_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/12_certifications/097_granular_tech_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n## Alternatives considered\n\n- `granular-tech:shortcut` — File amendments for every difference between broker and equity-system dates.: Use a plausible summary or one source without completing the controlling joins.\n- `granular-tech:blanket-hold` — Freeze the entire matter population: Treat supported actions and genuinely ambiguous records as if they were equally unresolved.\n\n## Assumptions and limits\n\nThis decision is limited to cb100-097-granular-tech, the supplied synthetic records, and the matter state as of 2026-09-24. Similar names, stale revisions, and pending authority are not treated as proof.\n", "decision": {"actions": [{"determination": "completion is required by 2025-08-20 under CB-PC-3307-R326; the current event record shows completion on 2025-09-04 under CB-PC-3307-E748. Identity resolves to ENT-097-1000, revision REV-2025.1 is current, and Elliot Mercer is active with capacity 4.", "due_date": "2026-09-23", "id": "ACT-CBP-097-01", "identity_id": "ENT-097-1000", "issue": "committee-independence gap", "owner": "Elliot Mercer", "portfolio_key": "CBP-097-01", "recommended_action": "Create insider-transaction rows with exact filing status and evidence holds. Owner: Elliot Mercer; due 2026-09-23.", "severity": "medium", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_board_committees/001_board_committees_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/013_minutes_materials_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/025_disclosure_controls_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/037_insider_trading_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_certifications/097_granular_tech_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "the controlling threshold is 13% under CB-PC-3307-R976; the independently calculated result is 18% under CB-PC-3307-E892. Identity resolves to ENT-097-1001, revision REV-2025.2 is current, and Sofia Bennett is active with capacity 1.", "due_date": "2026-09-22", "id": "ACT-CBP-097-02", "identity_id": "ENT-097-1001", "issue": "trading-window violation", "owner": "Sofia Bennett", "portfolio_key": "CBP-097-02", "recommended_action": "Create insider-transaction rows with exact filing status and evidence holds. Owner: Sofia Bennett; due 2026-09-22.", "severity": "high", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_board_committees/002_board_committees_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/014_minutes_materials_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/026_disclosure_controls_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/038_insider_trading_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/10_stock_exchange/074_stock_exchange_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/07_equity_compensation/050_equity_compensation_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/12_certifications/097_granular_tech_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "the permission is limited to Nasdaq Stock Market under CB-PC-3307-R990; the matched activity occurred in Texas under CB-PC-3307-E840. Identity resolves to ENT-097-1004, revision REV-2025.5 is current, and Caleb Hassan is active with capacity 4.", "due_date": "2026-09-19", "id": "ACT-CBP-097-05", "identity_id": "ENT-097-1004", "issue": "disclosure-control exception", "owner": "Caleb Hassan", "portfolio_key": "CBP-097-05", "recommended_action": "Create insider-transaction rows with exact filing status and evidence holds. Owner: Caleb Hassan; due 2026-09-19.", "severity": "medium", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_board_committees/005_board_committees_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/017_sec_filings_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/029_disclosure_controls_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/06_related_parties/041_related_parties_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/12_certifications/097_granular_tech_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "the operative cap is $7,762,000.00 under CB-PC-3307-R846; the matched ledger population totals $7,840,246.00 under CB-PC-3307-E938. Identity resolves to ENT-097-1005, revision REV-2025.6 is current, and Amara Patel is active with capacity 3.", "due_date": "2026-09-18", "id": "ACT-CBP-097-06", "identity_id": "ENT-097-1005", "issue": "non-GAAP reconciliation issue", "owner": "Amara Patel", "portfolio_key": "CBP-097-06", "recommended_action": "Create insider-transaction rows with exact filing status and evidence holds. Owner: Amara Patel; due 2026-09-18.", "severity": "medium", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_board_committees/006_board_committees_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/018_sec_filings_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/030_disclosure_controls_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/06_related_parties/042_related_parties_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/12_certifications/090_certifications_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/07_equity_compensation/054_equity_compensation_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_certifications/097_granular_tech_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "an open exception blocks completion under CB-PC-3307-R953; the current status is open and unresolved under CB-PC-3307-E626. Identity resolves to ENT-097-1007, revision REV-2025.1 is current, and Talia Brooks is active with capacity 5.", "due_date": "2026-09-16", "id": "ACT-CBP-097-08", "identity_id": "ENT-097-1007", "issue": "risk-factor inconsistency", "owner": "Talia Brooks", "portfolio_key": "CBP-097-08", "recommended_action": "Create insider-transaction rows with exact filing status and evidence holds. Owner: Talia Brooks; due 2026-09-16.", "severity": "high", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_board_committees/008_board_committees_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/020_sec_filings_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/032_disclosure_controls_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/06_related_parties/044_related_parties_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/12_certifications/092_certifications_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/12_certifications/097_granular_tech_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "completion is required by 2025-08-05 under CB-PC-3307-R371; the current event record shows completion on 2025-08-26 under CB-PC-3307-E963. Identity resolves to ENT-097-1008, revision REV-2025.2 is current, and Adrian Mensah is active with capacity 4.", "due_date": "2026-09-15", "id": "ACT-CBP-097-09", "identity_id": "ENT-097-1008", "issue": "equity-plan share mismatch", "owner": "Adrian Mensah", "portfolio_key": "CBP-097-09", "recommended_action": "Create insider-transaction rows with exact filing status and evidence holds. Owner: Adrian Mensah; due 2026-09-15.", "severity": "high", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/009_minutes_materials_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/021_sec_filings_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/033_insider_trading_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/06_related_parties/045_related_parties_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/11_debt_covenants/081_debt_covenants_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/09_whistleblower/069_whistleblower_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_certifications/097_granular_tech_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "approval must come from Talia Brooks under CB-PC-3307-R378; the effective approval record names Caleb Hassan under CB-PC-3307-E910. Identity resolves to ENT-097-1010, revision REV-2025.4 is current, and Dominic Alvarez is active with capacity 5.", "due_date": "2026-09-22", "id": "ACT-CBP-097-11", "identity_id": "ENT-097-1010", "issue": "8-K deadline", "owner": "Dominic Alvarez", "portfolio_key": "CBP-097-11", "recommended_action": "Create insider-transaction rows with exact filing status and evidence holds. Owner: Dominic Alvarez; due 2026-09-22.", "severity": "high", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/011_minutes_materials_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/023_sec_filings_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/035_insider_trading_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/06_related_parties/047_related_parties_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_certifications/095_certifications_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/08_earnings_guidance/059_earnings_guidance_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/12_certifications/097_granular_tech_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "the controlled population contains 140 records under CB-PC-3307-R408; the certification covers 105 records under CB-PC-3307-E224. Identity resolves to ENT-097-1011, revision REV-2025.5 is current, and Leona Park is active with capacity 6.", "due_date": "2026-09-21", "id": "ACT-CBP-097-12", "identity_id": "ENT-097-1011", "issue": "related-party disclosure gap", "owner": "Leona Park", "portfolio_key": "CBP-097-12", "recommended_action": "Create insider-transaction rows with exact filing status and evidence holds. Owner: Leona Park; due 2026-09-21.", "severity": "high", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/012_minutes_materials_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/024_sec_filings_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/036_insider_trading_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/06_related_parties/048_related_parties_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/09_whistleblower/072_whistleblower_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_certifications/097_granular_tech_impact_population.xlsx"]}], "as_of": "2026-09-24", "decision": {"alternatives_considered": ["granular-tech:shortcut", "granular-tech:blanket-hold"], "question": "Which Granular insider reports are late or inaccurate, and what must be amended?", "rationale": "The four-part causal test supports 8 scoped actions and leaves 4 records on evidence hold. Section 16 treatment depends on exact transaction, beneficial ownership, authority, and filing clock.", "recommendation": "Prepare supported late or corrective filings for matched transactions.", "selected_option_id": "granular-tech:scoped-evidence"}, "holds": [{"id": "HOLD-CBP-097-03", "issue": "guidance-control failure", "portfolio_key": "CBP-097-03", "reason": "the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective", "required_next_evidence": "effective approval and an active owner with remaining capacity", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_board_committees/003_board_committees_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/015_minutes_materials_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/027_disclosure_controls_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/039_insider_trading_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/07_equity_compensation/051_equity_compensation_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/11_debt_covenants/087_debt_covenants_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_certifications/097_granular_tech_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-097-04", "issue": "board-matrix inconsistency", "portfolio_key": "CBP-097-04", "reason": "the operational record relies on a superseded control revision", "required_next_evidence": "an operational record using the current effective revision", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_board_committees/004_board_committees_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/016_minutes_materials_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/028_disclosure_controls_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/040_insider_trading_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_certifications/097_granular_tech_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-097-07", "issue": "officer certification exception", "portfolio_key": "CBP-097-07", "reason": "the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective", "required_next_evidence": "effective approval and an active owner with remaining capacity", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_board_committees/007_board_committees_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/019_sec_filings_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/031_disclosure_controls_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/06_related_parties/043_related_parties_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/12_certifications/097_granular_tech_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-097-10", "issue": "debt-covenant disclosure", "portfolio_key": "CBP-097-10", "reason": "the current observation does not meet the operative trigger", "required_next_evidence": "a current observation that satisfies the operative trigger", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/010_minutes_materials_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/022_sec_filings_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/034_insider_trading_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/06_related_parties/046_related_parties_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_certifications/097_granular_tech_impact_population.xlsx"]}], "matter_number": "CB-PC-3307", "prepared_for": "Granular Technology Corp.", "schema_version": "counselbench.decision.v3", "task_id": "cb100-097-granular-tech"}, "matter_register": {"matter_number": "CB-PC-3307", "rows": [{"decision_option_id": "granular-tech:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-23", "issue": "committee-independence gap", "matter_number": "CB-PC-3307", "owner": "Elliot Mercer", "portfolio_key": "CBP-097-01", "row_id": "REG-CBP-097-01", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_board_committees/001_board_committees_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/013_minutes_materials_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/025_disclosure_controls_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/037_insider_trading_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_certifications/097_granular_tech_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "granular-tech:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-22", "issue": "trading-window violation", "matter_number": "CB-PC-3307", "owner": "Sofia Bennett", "portfolio_key": "CBP-097-02", "row_id": "REG-CBP-097-02", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_board_committees/002_board_committees_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/014_minutes_materials_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/026_disclosure_controls_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/038_insider_trading_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/10_stock_exchange/074_stock_exchange_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/07_equity_compensation/050_equity_compensation_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/12_certifications/097_granular_tech_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "granular-tech:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective", "issue": "guidance-control failure", "matter_number": "CB-PC-3307", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-097-03", "row_id": "REG-CBP-097-03", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_board_committees/003_board_committees_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/015_minutes_materials_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/027_disclosure_controls_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/039_insider_trading_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/07_equity_compensation/051_equity_compensation_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/11_debt_covenants/087_debt_covenants_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_certifications/097_granular_tech_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "granular-tech:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "the operational record relies on a superseded control revision", "issue": "board-matrix inconsistency", "matter_number": "CB-PC-3307", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-097-04", "row_id": "REG-CBP-097-04", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_board_committees/004_board_committees_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/016_minutes_materials_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/028_disclosure_controls_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/040_insider_trading_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_certifications/097_granular_tech_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "granular-tech:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-19", "issue": "disclosure-control exception", "matter_number": "CB-PC-3307", "owner": "Caleb Hassan", "portfolio_key": "CBP-097-05", "row_id": "REG-CBP-097-05", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_board_committees/005_board_committees_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/017_sec_filings_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/029_disclosure_controls_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/06_related_parties/041_related_parties_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/12_certifications/097_granular_tech_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "granular-tech:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-18", "issue": "non-GAAP reconciliation issue", "matter_number": "CB-PC-3307", "owner": "Amara Patel", "portfolio_key": "CBP-097-06", "row_id": "REG-CBP-097-06", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_board_committees/006_board_committees_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/018_sec_filings_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/030_disclosure_controls_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/06_related_parties/042_related_parties_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/12_certifications/090_certifications_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/07_equity_compensation/054_equity_compensation_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_certifications/097_granular_tech_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "granular-tech:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective", "issue": "officer certification exception", "matter_number": "CB-PC-3307", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-097-07", "row_id": "REG-CBP-097-07", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_board_committees/007_board_committees_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/019_sec_filings_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/031_disclosure_controls_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/06_related_parties/043_related_parties_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/12_certifications/097_granular_tech_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "granular-tech:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-16", "issue": "risk-factor inconsistency", "matter_number": "CB-PC-3307", "owner": "Talia Brooks", "portfolio_key": "CBP-097-08", "row_id": "REG-CBP-097-08", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_board_committees/008_board_committees_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/020_sec_filings_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/032_disclosure_controls_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/06_related_parties/044_related_parties_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/12_certifications/092_certifications_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/12_certifications/097_granular_tech_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "granular-tech:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-15", "issue": "equity-plan share mismatch", "matter_number": "CB-PC-3307", "owner": "Adrian Mensah", "portfolio_key": "CBP-097-09", "row_id": "REG-CBP-097-09", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/009_minutes_materials_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/021_sec_filings_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/033_insider_trading_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/06_related_parties/045_related_parties_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/11_debt_covenants/081_debt_covenants_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/09_whistleblower/069_whistleblower_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_certifications/097_granular_tech_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "granular-tech:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "the current observation does not meet the operative trigger", "issue": "debt-covenant disclosure", "matter_number": "CB-PC-3307", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-097-10", "row_id": "REG-CBP-097-10", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/010_minutes_materials_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/022_sec_filings_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/034_insider_trading_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/06_related_parties/046_related_parties_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_certifications/097_granular_tech_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "granular-tech:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-22", "issue": "8-K deadline", "matter_number": "CB-PC-3307", "owner": "Dominic Alvarez", "portfolio_key": "CBP-097-11", "row_id": "REG-CBP-097-11", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/011_minutes_materials_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/023_sec_filings_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/035_insider_trading_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/06_related_parties/047_related_parties_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_certifications/095_certifications_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/08_earnings_guidance/059_earnings_guidance_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/12_certifications/097_granular_tech_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "granular-tech:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-21", "issue": "related-party disclosure gap", "matter_number": "CB-PC-3307", "owner": "Leona Park", "portfolio_key": "CBP-097-12", "row_id": "REG-CBP-097-12", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/012_minutes_materials_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/024_sec_filings_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/036_insider_trading_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/06_related_parties/048_related_parties_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/09_whistleblower/072_whistleblower_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_certifications/097_granular_tech_impact_population.xlsx"]}], "schema_version": "counselbench.matter-register.v3", "task_id": "cb100-097-granular-tech"}}, "metadata": {"benchmark": "CounselBench-100", "code_license": "Apache-2.0", "data_license": "CC-BY-4.0", "deadline": "2026-09-24", "document_count": 97, "evidence_holds": 4, "jurisdiction": "Texas", "matter_number": "CB-PC-3307", "mcp_commit": "9a96ea6e5913736f92b88345bf51caeaaa8e719f", "mcp_package": "@modelcontextprotocol/server-filesystem@2026.7.10", "practice_area": "public-company", "reference_tool_calls": 88, "required_evidence_reads": 62, "supported_actions": 8, "synthetic": true, "venue": "Nasdaq Stock Market", "version": "3.1.0"}, "prompt": "The other side has challenged our internal account of the facts. Which Granular insider reports are late or inaccurate, and what must be amended? Equity grants, broker confirmations, powers of attorney, and filing records reveal late or inconsistent insider reports. The team needs the call by 2026-09-24. Leave a concise decision record with exact source references and an owner for each supported next step.", "rubric": {"criteria": [{"category": "investigation", "description": "Inventory the production and use targeted searches to locate records across native formats.", "id": "investigation.discover_production"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Complete every task-specific identity, authority, operations, and approval read before the first state transition.", "id": "investigation.read_before_write"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Inspect designated source metadata before relying on those records.", "id": "investigation.custody_before_write"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "Select the supported option 'granular-tech:scoped-evidence' after applying the four-part test.", "id": "decision.selected_option"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "Identify both rejected approaches and explain why a one-source shortcut and a blanket hold are wrong.", "id": "decision.alternatives"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-097-01 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_board_committees/001_board_committees_source_export.md rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-097-01.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/013_minutes_materials_source_export.json for committee-independence gap.", "id": "investigation.CBP-097-01.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/025_disclosure_controls_source_export.md to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-097-01.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/037_insider_trading_source_export.json.", "id": "investigation.CBP-097-01.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-097-01 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-097-01.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-097-01 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-097-01.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-097-02 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_board_committees/002_board_committees_source_export.txt rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-097-02.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/014_minutes_materials_source_export.xml for trading-window violation.", "id": "investigation.CBP-097-02.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/026_disclosure_controls_source_export.txt to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-097-02.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/038_insider_trading_source_export.xml.", "id": "investigation.CBP-097-02.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-097-02 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-097-02.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-097-02 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-097-02.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-097-03 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_board_committees/003_board_committees_source_export.eml rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-097-03.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/015_minutes_materials_source_export.html for guidance-control failure.", "id": "investigation.CBP-097-03.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/027_disclosure_controls_source_export.eml to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-097-03.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/039_insider_trading_source_export.html.", "id": "investigation.CBP-097-03.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-097-03 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective.", "id": "decision.CBP-097-03.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-097-03 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-097-03.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-097-04 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_board_committees/004_board_committees_source_export.csv rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-097-04.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/016_minutes_materials_source_export.pdf for board-matrix inconsistency.", "id": "investigation.CBP-097-04.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/028_disclosure_controls_source_export.csv to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-097-04.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/040_insider_trading_source_export.pdf.", "id": "investigation.CBP-097-04.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-097-04 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is the operational record relies on a superseded control revision.", "id": "decision.CBP-097-04.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-097-04 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-097-04.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-097-05 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_board_committees/005_board_committees_source_export.json rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-097-05.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/017_sec_filings_source_export.md for disclosure-control exception.", "id": "investigation.CBP-097-05.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/029_disclosure_controls_source_export.json to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-097-05.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_related_parties/041_related_parties_source_export.md.", "id": "investigation.CBP-097-05.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-097-05 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-097-05.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-097-05 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-097-05.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-097-06 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_board_committees/006_board_committees_source_export.xml rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-097-06.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/018_sec_filings_source_export.txt for non-GAAP reconciliation issue.", "id": "investigation.CBP-097-06.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/030_disclosure_controls_source_export.xml to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-097-06.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_related_parties/042_related_parties_source_export.txt.", "id": "investigation.CBP-097-06.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-097-06 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-097-06.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-097-06 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-097-06.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-097-07 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_board_committees/007_board_committees_source_export.html rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-097-07.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/019_sec_filings_source_export.eml for officer certification exception.", "id": "investigation.CBP-097-07.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/031_disclosure_controls_source_export.html to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-097-07.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_related_parties/043_related_parties_source_export.eml.", "id": "investigation.CBP-097-07.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-097-07 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective.", "id": "decision.CBP-097-07.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-097-07 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-097-07.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-097-08 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_board_committees/008_board_committees_source_export.pdf rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-097-08.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/020_sec_filings_source_export.csv for risk-factor inconsistency.", "id": "investigation.CBP-097-08.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/032_disclosure_controls_source_export.pdf to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-097-08.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_related_parties/044_related_parties_source_export.csv.", "id": "investigation.CBP-097-08.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-097-08 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-097-08.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-097-08 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-097-08.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-097-09 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/009_minutes_materials_source_export.md rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-097-09.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/021_sec_filings_source_export.json for equity-plan share mismatch.", "id": "investigation.CBP-097-09.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/033_insider_trading_source_export.md to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-097-09.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_related_parties/045_related_parties_source_export.json.", "id": "investigation.CBP-097-09.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-097-09 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-097-09.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-097-09 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-097-09.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-097-10 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/010_minutes_materials_source_export.txt rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-097-10.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/022_sec_filings_source_export.xml for debt-covenant disclosure.", "id": "investigation.CBP-097-10.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/034_insider_trading_source_export.txt to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-097-10.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_related_parties/046_related_parties_source_export.xml.", "id": "investigation.CBP-097-10.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-097-10 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is the current observation does not meet the operative trigger.", "id": "decision.CBP-097-10.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-097-10 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-097-10.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-097-11 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/011_minutes_materials_source_export.eml rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-097-11.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/023_sec_filings_source_export.html for 8-K deadline.", "id": "investigation.CBP-097-11.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/035_insider_trading_source_export.eml to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-097-11.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_related_parties/047_related_parties_source_export.html.", "id": "investigation.CBP-097-11.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-097-11 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-097-11.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-097-11 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-097-11.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-097-12 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/012_minutes_materials_source_export.csv rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-097-12.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/024_sec_filings_source_export.pdf for related-party disclosure gap.", "id": "investigation.CBP-097-12.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/036_insider_trading_source_export.csv to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-097-12.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_related_parties/048_related_parties_source_export.pdf.", "id": "investigation.CBP-097-12.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-097-12 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-097-12.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-097-12 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-097-12.register"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Write the exact selected option, supported action population, evidence-hold population, facts, owners, deadlines, and citations.", "id": "state.exact_decision"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create one exact register row per portfolio key with no extra, missing, or modified row.", "id": "state.exact_register"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Leave only the three approved deliverables and perform no extra state-changing write.", "id": "state.write_scope_containment"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Read back decision.json, matter-register.json, and advice.md after their final writes.", "id": "state.postwrite_readback"}, {"category": "answer", "description": "Explain the selected recommendation, supported actions, holds, alternatives, and limitations with exact source anchors.", "id": "answer.decision_note"}], "decision_options": [{"approach": "Apply the exact identity, current-state, authority, and revision test. Create insider-transaction rows with exact filing status and evidence holds.", "id": "granular-tech:scoped-evidence", "label": "Prepare supported late or corrective filings for matched transactions."}, {"approach": "Use a plausible summary or one source without completing the controlling joins.", "id": "granular-tech:shortcut", "label": "File amendments for every difference between broker and equity-system dates."}, {"approach": "Treat supported actions and genuinely ambiguous records as if they were equally unresolved.", "id": "granular-tech:blanket-hold", "label": "Freeze the entire matter population"}], "evaluation_narrative": {"authority": "Section 16 treatment depends on exact transaction, beneficial ownership, authority, and filing clock.", "observation": "Join grants, broker executions, ownership forms, powers of attorney, and filing timestamps by insider and transaction.", "question": "Which Granular insider reports are late or inaccurate, and what must be amended?", "register_action": "Create insider-transaction rows with exact filing status and evidence holds."}, "gates": ["all_required_evidence_precedes_first_write", "decision_criteria_complete", "register_state_exact", "write_scope_contained", "all_outputs_verified_by_readback"], "metadata_checks": 10, "metric": "weighted_criteria_score", "minimum_tool_calls": 88, "required_deliverables": ["decision.json", "matter-register.json", "advice.md"], "required_document_reads": 62, "type": "deterministic", "weights": {"advice": 0.15, "decision": 0.35, "investigation": 0.25, "state": 0.25}}, "task_id": "cb100-097-granular-tech", "task_name": "Granular Section 16 filing review", "world_id": "counselbench-filesystem-mcp-v3"}
+{"context_files": ["task_files/cb100-098-highwater-utilities/01_board_committees/001_board_committees_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-098-highwater-utilities/01_board_committees/002_board_committees_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-098-highwater-utilities/01_board_committees/003_board_committees_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-098-highwater-utilities/01_board_committees/004_board_committees_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-098-highwater-utilities/01_board_committees/005_board_committees_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-098-highwater-utilities/01_board_committees/006_board_committees_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-098-highwater-utilities/01_board_committees/007_board_committees_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-098-highwater-utilities/01_board_committees/008_board_committees_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-098-highwater-utilities/02_minutes_materials/009_minutes_materials_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-098-highwater-utilities/02_minutes_materials/010_minutes_materials_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-098-highwater-utilities/02_minutes_materials/011_minutes_materials_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-098-highwater-utilities/02_minutes_materials/012_minutes_materials_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-098-highwater-utilities/02_minutes_materials/013_minutes_materials_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-098-highwater-utilities/02_minutes_materials/014_minutes_materials_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-098-highwater-utilities/02_minutes_materials/015_minutes_materials_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-098-highwater-utilities/02_minutes_materials/016_minutes_materials_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-098-highwater-utilities/03_sec_filings/017_sec_filings_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-098-highwater-utilities/03_sec_filings/018_sec_filings_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-098-highwater-utilities/03_sec_filings/019_sec_filings_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-098-highwater-utilities/03_sec_filings/020_sec_filings_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-098-highwater-utilities/03_sec_filings/021_sec_filings_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-098-highwater-utilities/03_sec_filings/022_sec_filings_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-098-highwater-utilities/03_sec_filings/023_sec_filings_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-098-highwater-utilities/03_sec_filings/024_sec_filings_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-098-highwater-utilities/04_disclosure_controls/025_disclosure_controls_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-098-highwater-utilities/04_disclosure_controls/026_disclosure_controls_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-098-highwater-utilities/04_disclosure_controls/027_disclosure_controls_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-098-highwater-utilities/04_disclosure_controls/028_disclosure_controls_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-098-highwater-utilities/04_disclosure_controls/029_disclosure_controls_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-098-highwater-utilities/04_disclosure_controls/030_disclosure_controls_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-098-highwater-utilities/04_disclosure_controls/031_disclosure_controls_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-098-highwater-utilities/04_disclosure_controls/032_disclosure_controls_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-098-highwater-utilities/05_insider_trading/033_insider_trading_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-098-highwater-utilities/05_insider_trading/034_insider_trading_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-098-highwater-utilities/05_insider_trading/035_insider_trading_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-098-highwater-utilities/05_insider_trading/036_insider_trading_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-098-highwater-utilities/05_insider_trading/037_insider_trading_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-098-highwater-utilities/05_insider_trading/038_insider_trading_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-098-highwater-utilities/05_insider_trading/039_insider_trading_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-098-highwater-utilities/05_insider_trading/040_insider_trading_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-098-highwater-utilities/06_related_parties/041_related_parties_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-098-highwater-utilities/06_related_parties/042_related_parties_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-098-highwater-utilities/06_related_parties/043_related_parties_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-098-highwater-utilities/06_related_parties/044_related_parties_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-098-highwater-utilities/06_related_parties/045_related_parties_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-098-highwater-utilities/06_related_parties/046_related_parties_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-098-highwater-utilities/06_related_parties/047_related_parties_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-098-highwater-utilities/06_related_parties/048_related_parties_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-098-highwater-utilities/07_equity_compensation/049_equity_compensation_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-098-highwater-utilities/07_equity_compensation/050_equity_compensation_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-098-highwater-utilities/07_equity_compensation/051_equity_compensation_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-098-highwater-utilities/07_equity_compensation/052_equity_compensation_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-098-highwater-utilities/07_equity_compensation/053_equity_compensation_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-098-highwater-utilities/07_equity_compensation/054_equity_compensation_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-098-highwater-utilities/07_equity_compensation/055_equity_compensation_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-098-highwater-utilities/07_equity_compensation/056_equity_compensation_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-098-highwater-utilities/08_earnings_guidance/057_earnings_guidance_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-098-highwater-utilities/08_earnings_guidance/058_earnings_guidance_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-098-highwater-utilities/08_earnings_guidance/059_earnings_guidance_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-098-highwater-utilities/08_earnings_guidance/060_earnings_guidance_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-098-highwater-utilities/08_earnings_guidance/061_earnings_guidance_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-098-highwater-utilities/08_earnings_guidance/062_earnings_guidance_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-098-highwater-utilities/08_earnings_guidance/063_earnings_guidance_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-098-highwater-utilities/08_earnings_guidance/064_earnings_guidance_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-098-highwater-utilities/09_whistleblower/065_whistleblower_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-098-highwater-utilities/09_whistleblower/066_whistleblower_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-098-highwater-utilities/09_whistleblower/067_whistleblower_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-098-highwater-utilities/09_whistleblower/068_whistleblower_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-098-highwater-utilities/09_whistleblower/069_whistleblower_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-098-highwater-utilities/09_whistleblower/070_whistleblower_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-098-highwater-utilities/09_whistleblower/071_whistleblower_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-098-highwater-utilities/09_whistleblower/072_whistleblower_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-098-highwater-utilities/10_stock_exchange/073_stock_exchange_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-098-highwater-utilities/10_stock_exchange/074_stock_exchange_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-098-highwater-utilities/10_stock_exchange/075_stock_exchange_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-098-highwater-utilities/10_stock_exchange/076_stock_exchange_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-098-highwater-utilities/10_stock_exchange/077_stock_exchange_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-098-highwater-utilities/10_stock_exchange/078_stock_exchange_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-098-highwater-utilities/10_stock_exchange/079_stock_exchange_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-098-highwater-utilities/10_stock_exchange/080_stock_exchange_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-098-highwater-utilities/11_debt_covenants/081_debt_covenants_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-098-highwater-utilities/11_debt_covenants/082_debt_covenants_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-098-highwater-utilities/11_debt_covenants/083_debt_covenants_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-098-highwater-utilities/11_debt_covenants/084_debt_covenants_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-098-highwater-utilities/11_debt_covenants/085_debt_covenants_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-098-highwater-utilities/11_debt_covenants/086_debt_covenants_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-098-highwater-utilities/11_debt_covenants/087_debt_covenants_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-098-highwater-utilities/11_debt_covenants/088_debt_covenants_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-098-highwater-utilities/12_certifications/089_certifications_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-098-highwater-utilities/12_certifications/090_certifications_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-098-highwater-utilities/12_certifications/091_certifications_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-098-highwater-utilities/12_certifications/092_certifications_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-098-highwater-utilities/12_certifications/093_certifications_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-098-highwater-utilities/12_certifications/094_certifications_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-098-highwater-utilities/12_certifications/095_certifications_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-098-highwater-utilities/12_certifications/096_certifications_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-098-highwater-utilities/12_certifications/097_highwater_utilities_impact_population.xlsx"], "gold_output": {"advice_markdown": "# Decision note — Highwater board independence audit\n\n## Recommendation\n\nUpdate supported independence and matrix disclosures and cure committee gaps. The reconciled record supports 6 scoped actions and leaves 6 items on evidence hold.\n\nSelected option: `highwater-utilities:scoped-evidence`.\n\n## Why this is the supported option\n\nJoin consulting payments, family ties, appointments, questionnaires, and committee service by person and period. Independence and committee rules require exact relationships, materiality, and current service dates.\n\n## Supported actions\n\n### CBP-098-02 — Section 16 filing delay (medium)\n\ndelivery must use notices-highwater_utilities_inc@example.test under CB-PC-3308-R519; the only matched receipt used archive-nominating_committee@example.test under CB-PC-3308-E124. Identity resolves to ENT-098-1001, revision REV-2026.2 is current, and Theo Laurent is active with capacity 6.\n\nAction: Create director-period rows with exact relationship and committee outcomes. Owner: Theo Laurent; due 2026-09-26.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_board_committees/002_board_committees_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/014_minutes_materials_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/026_disclosure_controls_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/038_insider_trading_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/07_equity_compensation/050_equity_compensation_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/12_certifications/097_highwater_utilities_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-098-06 — guidance-control failure (high)\n\napproval must come from Amara Patel under CB-PC-3308-R871; the effective approval record names Caleb Hassan under CB-PC-3308-E515. Identity resolves to ENT-098-1005, revision REV-2026.6 is current, and Micah Sullivan is active with capacity 6.\n\nAction: Create director-period rows with exact relationship and committee outcomes. Owner: Micah Sullivan; due 2026-09-22.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_board_committees/006_board_committees_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/018_sec_filings_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/030_disclosure_controls_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/06_related_parties/042_related_parties_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/10_stock_exchange/078_stock_exchange_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/12_certifications/090_certifications_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/12_certifications/097_highwater_utilities_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-098-07 — board-matrix inconsistency (medium)\n\nthe controlled population contains 238 records under CB-PC-3308-R416; the certification covers 216 records under CB-PC-3308-E859. Identity resolves to ENT-098-1006, revision REV-2026.7 is current, and Nora Chen is active with capacity 1.\n\nAction: Create director-period rows with exact relationship and committee outcomes. Owner: Nora Chen; due 2026-09-21.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_board_committees/007_board_committees_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/019_sec_filings_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/031_disclosure_controls_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/06_related_parties/043_related_parties_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/12_certifications/091_certifications_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/09_whistleblower/067_whistleblower_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/12_certifications/097_highwater_utilities_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-098-08 — disclosure-control exception (critical)\n\nthe permission is limited to New York Stock Exchange under CB-PC-3308-R157; the matched activity occurred in Oregon under CB-PC-3308-E262. Identity resolves to ENT-098-1007, revision REV-2026.1 is current, and Caleb Hassan is active with capacity 6.\n\nAction: Create director-period rows with exact relationship and committee outcomes. Owner: Caleb Hassan; due 2026-09-20.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_board_committees/008_board_committees_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/020_sec_filings_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/032_disclosure_controls_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/06_related_parties/044_related_parties_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/12_certifications/097_highwater_utilities_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-098-09 — non-GAAP reconciliation issue (medium)\n\nthe operative cap is $7,282,000.00 under CB-PC-3308-R552; the matched ledger population totals $7,520,152.00 under CB-PC-3308-E920. Identity resolves to ENT-098-1008, revision REV-2026.2 is current, and Amara Patel is active with capacity 5.\n\nAction: Create director-period rows with exact relationship and committee outcomes. Owner: Amara Patel; due 2026-09-19.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/009_minutes_materials_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/021_sec_filings_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/033_insider_trading_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/06_related_parties/045_related_parties_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/08_earnings_guidance/057_earnings_guidance_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/11_debt_covenants/081_debt_covenants_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/12_certifications/097_highwater_utilities_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-098-10 — officer certification exception (critical)\n\ndelivery must use notices-highwater_utilities_inc@example.test under CB-PC-3308-R191; the only matched receipt used archive-nominating_committee@example.test under CB-PC-3308-E899. Identity resolves to ENT-098-1009, revision REV-2026.3 is current, and Samuel Kim is active with capacity 3.\n\nAction: Create director-period rows with exact relationship and committee outcomes. Owner: Samuel Kim; due 2026-09-27.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/010_minutes_materials_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/022_sec_filings_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/034_insider_trading_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/06_related_parties/046_related_parties_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/12_certifications/097_highwater_utilities_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n## Evidence holds\n\n- **CBP-098-01 — minutes-approval omission**: the current observation does not meet the operative trigger. Next evidence: a current observation that satisfies the operative trigger. Sources: `/workspace/documents/01_board_committees/001_board_committees_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/013_minutes_materials_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/025_disclosure_controls_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/037_insider_trading_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/12_certifications/097_highwater_utilities_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-098-03 — whistleblower escalation delay**: the operational record relies on a superseded control revision. Next evidence: an operational record using the current effective revision. Sources: `/workspace/documents/01_board_committees/003_board_committees_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/015_minutes_materials_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/027_disclosure_controls_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/039_insider_trading_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/07_equity_compensation/051_equity_compensation_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/12_certifications/097_highwater_utilities_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-098-04 — committee-independence gap**: two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key. Next evidence: an approved immutable entity crosswalk. Sources: `/workspace/documents/01_board_committees/004_board_committees_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/016_minutes_materials_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/028_disclosure_controls_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/040_insider_trading_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/10_stock_exchange/076_stock_exchange_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/08_earnings_guidance/064_earnings_guidance_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/12_certifications/097_highwater_utilities_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-098-05 — trading-window violation**: the current observation does not meet the operative trigger. Next evidence: a current observation that satisfies the operative trigger. Sources: `/workspace/documents/01_board_committees/005_board_committees_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/017_sec_filings_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/029_disclosure_controls_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/06_related_parties/041_related_parties_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/10_stock_exchange/077_stock_exchange_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/12_certifications/097_highwater_utilities_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-098-11 — risk-factor inconsistency**: the operational record relies on a superseded control revision. Next evidence: an operational record using the current effective revision. Sources: `/workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/011_minutes_materials_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/023_sec_filings_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/035_insider_trading_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/06_related_parties/047_related_parties_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/12_certifications/095_certifications_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/09_whistleblower/071_whistleblower_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/12_certifications/097_highwater_utilities_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-098-12 — equity-plan share mismatch**: two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key. Next evidence: an approved immutable entity crosswalk. Sources: `/workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/012_minutes_materials_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/024_sec_filings_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/036_insider_trading_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/06_related_parties/048_related_parties_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/09_whistleblower/072_whistleblower_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/12_certifications/097_highwater_utilities_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n## Alternatives considered\n\n- `highwater-utilities:shortcut` — Classify every director with any company payment or family connection as nonindependent.: Use a plausible summary or one source without completing the controlling joins.\n- `highwater-utilities:blanket-hold` — Freeze the entire matter population: Treat supported actions and genuinely ambiguous records as if they were equally unresolved.\n\n## Assumptions and limits\n\nThis decision is limited to cb100-098-highwater-utilities, the supplied synthetic records, and the matter state as of 2026-09-28. Similar names, stale revisions, and pending authority are not treated as proof.\n", "decision": {"actions": [{"determination": "delivery must use notices-highwater_utilities_inc@example.test under CB-PC-3308-R519; the only matched receipt used archive-nominating_committee@example.test under CB-PC-3308-E124. Identity resolves to ENT-098-1001, revision REV-2026.2 is current, and Theo Laurent is active with capacity 6.", "due_date": "2026-09-26", "id": "ACT-CBP-098-02", "identity_id": "ENT-098-1001", "issue": "Section 16 filing delay", "owner": "Theo Laurent", "portfolio_key": "CBP-098-02", "recommended_action": "Create director-period rows with exact relationship and committee outcomes. Owner: Theo Laurent; due 2026-09-26.", "severity": "medium", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_board_committees/002_board_committees_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/014_minutes_materials_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/026_disclosure_controls_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/038_insider_trading_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/07_equity_compensation/050_equity_compensation_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/12_certifications/097_highwater_utilities_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "approval must come from Amara Patel under CB-PC-3308-R871; the effective approval record names Caleb Hassan under CB-PC-3308-E515. Identity resolves to ENT-098-1005, revision REV-2026.6 is current, and Micah Sullivan is active with capacity 6.", "due_date": "2026-09-22", "id": "ACT-CBP-098-06", "identity_id": "ENT-098-1005", "issue": "guidance-control failure", "owner": "Micah Sullivan", "portfolio_key": "CBP-098-06", "recommended_action": "Create director-period rows with exact relationship and committee outcomes. Owner: Micah Sullivan; due 2026-09-22.", "severity": "high", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_board_committees/006_board_committees_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/018_sec_filings_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/030_disclosure_controls_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/06_related_parties/042_related_parties_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/10_stock_exchange/078_stock_exchange_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_certifications/090_certifications_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/12_certifications/097_highwater_utilities_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "the controlled population contains 238 records under CB-PC-3308-R416; the certification covers 216 records under CB-PC-3308-E859. Identity resolves to ENT-098-1006, revision REV-2026.7 is current, and Nora Chen is active with capacity 1.", "due_date": "2026-09-21", "id": "ACT-CBP-098-07", "identity_id": "ENT-098-1006", "issue": "board-matrix inconsistency", "owner": "Nora Chen", "portfolio_key": "CBP-098-07", "recommended_action": "Create director-period rows with exact relationship and committee outcomes. Owner: Nora Chen; due 2026-09-21.", "severity": "medium", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_board_committees/007_board_committees_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/019_sec_filings_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/031_disclosure_controls_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/06_related_parties/043_related_parties_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/12_certifications/091_certifications_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/09_whistleblower/067_whistleblower_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/12_certifications/097_highwater_utilities_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "the permission is limited to New York Stock Exchange under CB-PC-3308-R157; the matched activity occurred in Oregon under CB-PC-3308-E262. Identity resolves to ENT-098-1007, revision REV-2026.1 is current, and Caleb Hassan is active with capacity 6.", "due_date": "2026-09-20", "id": "ACT-CBP-098-08", "identity_id": "ENT-098-1007", "issue": "disclosure-control exception", "owner": "Caleb Hassan", "portfolio_key": "CBP-098-08", "recommended_action": "Create director-period rows with exact relationship and committee outcomes. Owner: Caleb Hassan; due 2026-09-20.", "severity": "critical", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_board_committees/008_board_committees_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/020_sec_filings_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/032_disclosure_controls_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/06_related_parties/044_related_parties_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/12_certifications/097_highwater_utilities_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "the operative cap is $7,282,000.00 under CB-PC-3308-R552; the matched ledger population totals $7,520,152.00 under CB-PC-3308-E920. Identity resolves to ENT-098-1008, revision REV-2026.2 is current, and Amara Patel is active with capacity 5.", "due_date": "2026-09-19", "id": "ACT-CBP-098-09", "identity_id": "ENT-098-1008", "issue": "non-GAAP reconciliation issue", "owner": "Amara Patel", "portfolio_key": "CBP-098-09", "recommended_action": "Create director-period rows with exact relationship and committee outcomes. Owner: Amara Patel; due 2026-09-19.", "severity": "medium", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/009_minutes_materials_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/021_sec_filings_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/033_insider_trading_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/06_related_parties/045_related_parties_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/08_earnings_guidance/057_earnings_guidance_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/11_debt_covenants/081_debt_covenants_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/12_certifications/097_highwater_utilities_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "delivery must use notices-highwater_utilities_inc@example.test under CB-PC-3308-R191; the only matched receipt used archive-nominating_committee@example.test under CB-PC-3308-E899. Identity resolves to ENT-098-1009, revision REV-2026.3 is current, and Samuel Kim is active with capacity 3.", "due_date": "2026-09-27", "id": "ACT-CBP-098-10", "identity_id": "ENT-098-1009", "issue": "officer certification exception", "owner": "Samuel Kim", "portfolio_key": "CBP-098-10", "recommended_action": "Create director-period rows with exact relationship and committee outcomes. Owner: Samuel Kim; due 2026-09-27.", "severity": "critical", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/010_minutes_materials_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/022_sec_filings_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/034_insider_trading_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/06_related_parties/046_related_parties_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_certifications/097_highwater_utilities_impact_population.xlsx"]}], "as_of": "2026-09-28", "decision": {"alternatives_considered": ["highwater-utilities:shortcut", "highwater-utilities:blanket-hold"], "question": "Which Highwater directors remain independent and what board disclosures must change?", "rationale": "The four-part causal test supports 6 scoped actions and leaves 6 records on evidence hold. Independence and committee rules require exact relationships, materiality, and current service dates.", "recommendation": "Update supported independence and matrix disclosures and cure committee gaps.", "selected_option_id": "highwater-utilities:scoped-evidence"}, "holds": [{"id": "HOLD-CBP-098-01", "issue": "minutes-approval omission", "portfolio_key": "CBP-098-01", "reason": "the current observation does not meet the operative trigger", "required_next_evidence": "a current observation that satisfies the operative trigger", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_board_committees/001_board_committees_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/013_minutes_materials_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/025_disclosure_controls_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/037_insider_trading_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_certifications/097_highwater_utilities_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-098-03", "issue": "whistleblower escalation delay", "portfolio_key": "CBP-098-03", "reason": "the operational record relies on a superseded control revision", "required_next_evidence": "an operational record using the current effective revision", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_board_committees/003_board_committees_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/015_minutes_materials_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/027_disclosure_controls_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/039_insider_trading_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/07_equity_compensation/051_equity_compensation_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/12_certifications/097_highwater_utilities_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-098-04", "issue": "committee-independence gap", "portfolio_key": "CBP-098-04", "reason": "two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key", "required_next_evidence": "an approved immutable entity crosswalk", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_board_committees/004_board_committees_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/016_minutes_materials_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/028_disclosure_controls_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/040_insider_trading_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/10_stock_exchange/076_stock_exchange_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/08_earnings_guidance/064_earnings_guidance_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_certifications/097_highwater_utilities_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-098-05", "issue": "trading-window violation", "portfolio_key": "CBP-098-05", "reason": "the current observation does not meet the operative trigger", "required_next_evidence": "a current observation that satisfies the operative trigger", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_board_committees/005_board_committees_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/017_sec_filings_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/029_disclosure_controls_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/06_related_parties/041_related_parties_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/10_stock_exchange/077_stock_exchange_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_certifications/097_highwater_utilities_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-098-11", "issue": "risk-factor inconsistency", "portfolio_key": "CBP-098-11", "reason": "the operational record relies on a superseded control revision", "required_next_evidence": "an operational record using the current effective revision", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/011_minutes_materials_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/023_sec_filings_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/035_insider_trading_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/06_related_parties/047_related_parties_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_certifications/095_certifications_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/09_whistleblower/071_whistleblower_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_certifications/097_highwater_utilities_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-098-12", "issue": "equity-plan share mismatch", "portfolio_key": "CBP-098-12", "reason": "two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key", "required_next_evidence": "an approved immutable entity crosswalk", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/012_minutes_materials_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/024_sec_filings_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/036_insider_trading_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/06_related_parties/048_related_parties_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/09_whistleblower/072_whistleblower_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_certifications/097_highwater_utilities_impact_population.xlsx"]}], "matter_number": "CB-PC-3308", "prepared_for": "Highwater Utilities, Inc.", "schema_version": "counselbench.decision.v3", "task_id": "cb100-098-highwater-utilities"}, "matter_register": {"matter_number": "CB-PC-3308", "rows": [{"decision_option_id": "highwater-utilities:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "the current observation does not meet the operative trigger", "issue": "minutes-approval omission", "matter_number": "CB-PC-3308", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-098-01", "row_id": "REG-CBP-098-01", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_board_committees/001_board_committees_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/013_minutes_materials_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/025_disclosure_controls_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/037_insider_trading_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_certifications/097_highwater_utilities_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "highwater-utilities:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-26", "issue": "Section 16 filing delay", "matter_number": "CB-PC-3308", "owner": "Theo Laurent", "portfolio_key": "CBP-098-02", "row_id": "REG-CBP-098-02", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_board_committees/002_board_committees_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/014_minutes_materials_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/026_disclosure_controls_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/038_insider_trading_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/07_equity_compensation/050_equity_compensation_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/12_certifications/097_highwater_utilities_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "highwater-utilities:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "the operational record relies on a superseded control revision", "issue": "whistleblower escalation delay", "matter_number": "CB-PC-3308", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-098-03", "row_id": "REG-CBP-098-03", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_board_committees/003_board_committees_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/015_minutes_materials_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/027_disclosure_controls_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/039_insider_trading_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/07_equity_compensation/051_equity_compensation_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/12_certifications/097_highwater_utilities_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "highwater-utilities:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key", "issue": "committee-independence gap", "matter_number": "CB-PC-3308", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-098-04", "row_id": "REG-CBP-098-04", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_board_committees/004_board_committees_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/016_minutes_materials_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/028_disclosure_controls_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/040_insider_trading_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/10_stock_exchange/076_stock_exchange_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/08_earnings_guidance/064_earnings_guidance_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_certifications/097_highwater_utilities_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "highwater-utilities:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "the current observation does not meet the operative trigger", "issue": "trading-window violation", "matter_number": "CB-PC-3308", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-098-05", "row_id": "REG-CBP-098-05", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_board_committees/005_board_committees_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/017_sec_filings_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/029_disclosure_controls_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/06_related_parties/041_related_parties_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/10_stock_exchange/077_stock_exchange_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_certifications/097_highwater_utilities_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "highwater-utilities:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-22", "issue": "guidance-control failure", "matter_number": "CB-PC-3308", "owner": "Micah Sullivan", "portfolio_key": "CBP-098-06", "row_id": "REG-CBP-098-06", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_board_committees/006_board_committees_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/018_sec_filings_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/030_disclosure_controls_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/06_related_parties/042_related_parties_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/10_stock_exchange/078_stock_exchange_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_certifications/090_certifications_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/12_certifications/097_highwater_utilities_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "highwater-utilities:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-21", "issue": "board-matrix inconsistency", "matter_number": "CB-PC-3308", "owner": "Nora Chen", "portfolio_key": "CBP-098-07", "row_id": "REG-CBP-098-07", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_board_committees/007_board_committees_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/019_sec_filings_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/031_disclosure_controls_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/06_related_parties/043_related_parties_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/12_certifications/091_certifications_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/09_whistleblower/067_whistleblower_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/12_certifications/097_highwater_utilities_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "highwater-utilities:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-20", "issue": "disclosure-control exception", "matter_number": "CB-PC-3308", "owner": "Caleb Hassan", "portfolio_key": "CBP-098-08", "row_id": "REG-CBP-098-08", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_board_committees/008_board_committees_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/020_sec_filings_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/032_disclosure_controls_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/06_related_parties/044_related_parties_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/12_certifications/097_highwater_utilities_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "highwater-utilities:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-19", "issue": "non-GAAP reconciliation issue", "matter_number": "CB-PC-3308", "owner": "Amara Patel", "portfolio_key": "CBP-098-09", "row_id": "REG-CBP-098-09", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/009_minutes_materials_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/021_sec_filings_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/033_insider_trading_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/06_related_parties/045_related_parties_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/08_earnings_guidance/057_earnings_guidance_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/11_debt_covenants/081_debt_covenants_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/12_certifications/097_highwater_utilities_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "highwater-utilities:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-27", "issue": "officer certification exception", "matter_number": "CB-PC-3308", "owner": "Samuel Kim", "portfolio_key": "CBP-098-10", "row_id": "REG-CBP-098-10", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/010_minutes_materials_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/022_sec_filings_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/034_insider_trading_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/06_related_parties/046_related_parties_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_certifications/097_highwater_utilities_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "highwater-utilities:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "the operational record relies on a superseded control revision", "issue": "risk-factor inconsistency", "matter_number": "CB-PC-3308", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-098-11", "row_id": "REG-CBP-098-11", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/011_minutes_materials_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/023_sec_filings_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/035_insider_trading_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/06_related_parties/047_related_parties_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_certifications/095_certifications_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/09_whistleblower/071_whistleblower_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_certifications/097_highwater_utilities_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "highwater-utilities:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key", "issue": "equity-plan share mismatch", "matter_number": "CB-PC-3308", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-098-12", "row_id": "REG-CBP-098-12", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/012_minutes_materials_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/024_sec_filings_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/036_insider_trading_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/06_related_parties/048_related_parties_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/09_whistleblower/072_whistleblower_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_certifications/097_highwater_utilities_impact_population.xlsx"]}], "schema_version": "counselbench.matter-register.v3", "task_id": "cb100-098-highwater-utilities"}}, "metadata": {"benchmark": "CounselBench-100", "code_license": "Apache-2.0", "data_license": "CC-BY-4.0", "deadline": "2026-09-28", "document_count": 97, "evidence_holds": 6, "jurisdiction": "Oregon", "matter_number": "CB-PC-3308", "mcp_commit": "9a96ea6e5913736f92b88345bf51caeaaa8e719f", "mcp_package": "@modelcontextprotocol/server-filesystem@2026.7.10", "practice_area": "public-company", "reference_tool_calls": 84, "required_evidence_reads": 64, "supported_actions": 6, "synthetic": true, "venue": "New York Stock Exchange", "version": "3.1.0"}, "prompt": "There is enough noise in this file that a name match or newest-document shortcut will be dangerous. Which Highwater directors remain independent and what board disclosures must change? Consulting payments, family ties, committee appointments, and questionnaires affect director independence and board-matrix disclosures. The team needs the call by 2026-09-28. Leave the defensible result in the matter workspace, including any item that must stay on hold for better evidence.", "rubric": {"criteria": [{"category": "investigation", "description": "Inventory the production and use targeted searches to locate records across native formats.", "id": "investigation.discover_production"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Complete every task-specific identity, authority, operations, and approval read before the first state transition.", "id": "investigation.read_before_write"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Inspect designated source metadata before relying on those records.", "id": "investigation.custody_before_write"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "Select the supported option 'highwater-utilities:scoped-evidence' after applying the four-part test.", "id": "decision.selected_option"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "Identify both rejected approaches and explain why a one-source shortcut and a blanket hold are wrong.", "id": "decision.alternatives"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-098-01 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_board_committees/001_board_committees_source_export.md rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-098-01.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/013_minutes_materials_source_export.json for minutes-approval omission.", "id": "investigation.CBP-098-01.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/025_disclosure_controls_source_export.md to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-098-01.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/037_insider_trading_source_export.json.", "id": "investigation.CBP-098-01.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-098-01 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is the current observation does not meet the operative trigger.", "id": "decision.CBP-098-01.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-098-01 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-098-01.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-098-02 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_board_committees/002_board_committees_source_export.txt rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-098-02.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/014_minutes_materials_source_export.xml for Section 16 filing delay.", "id": "investigation.CBP-098-02.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/026_disclosure_controls_source_export.txt to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-098-02.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/038_insider_trading_source_export.xml.", "id": "investigation.CBP-098-02.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-098-02 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-098-02.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-098-02 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-098-02.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-098-03 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_board_committees/003_board_committees_source_export.eml rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-098-03.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/015_minutes_materials_source_export.html for whistleblower escalation delay.", "id": "investigation.CBP-098-03.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/027_disclosure_controls_source_export.eml to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-098-03.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/039_insider_trading_source_export.html.", "id": "investigation.CBP-098-03.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-098-03 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is the operational record relies on a superseded control revision.", "id": "decision.CBP-098-03.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-098-03 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-098-03.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-098-04 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_board_committees/004_board_committees_source_export.csv rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-098-04.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/016_minutes_materials_source_export.pdf for committee-independence gap.", "id": "investigation.CBP-098-04.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/028_disclosure_controls_source_export.csv to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-098-04.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/040_insider_trading_source_export.pdf.", "id": "investigation.CBP-098-04.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-098-04 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key.", "id": "decision.CBP-098-04.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-098-04 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-098-04.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-098-05 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_board_committees/005_board_committees_source_export.json rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-098-05.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/017_sec_filings_source_export.md for trading-window violation.", "id": "investigation.CBP-098-05.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/029_disclosure_controls_source_export.json to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-098-05.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_related_parties/041_related_parties_source_export.md.", "id": "investigation.CBP-098-05.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-098-05 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is the current observation does not meet the operative trigger.", "id": "decision.CBP-098-05.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-098-05 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-098-05.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-098-06 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_board_committees/006_board_committees_source_export.xml rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-098-06.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/018_sec_filings_source_export.txt for guidance-control failure.", "id": "investigation.CBP-098-06.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/030_disclosure_controls_source_export.xml to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-098-06.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_related_parties/042_related_parties_source_export.txt.", "id": "investigation.CBP-098-06.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-098-06 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-098-06.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-098-06 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-098-06.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-098-07 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_board_committees/007_board_committees_source_export.html rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-098-07.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/019_sec_filings_source_export.eml for board-matrix inconsistency.", "id": "investigation.CBP-098-07.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/031_disclosure_controls_source_export.html to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-098-07.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_related_parties/043_related_parties_source_export.eml.", "id": "investigation.CBP-098-07.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-098-07 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-098-07.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-098-07 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-098-07.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-098-08 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_board_committees/008_board_committees_source_export.pdf rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-098-08.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/020_sec_filings_source_export.csv for disclosure-control exception.", "id": "investigation.CBP-098-08.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/032_disclosure_controls_source_export.pdf to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-098-08.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_related_parties/044_related_parties_source_export.csv.", "id": "investigation.CBP-098-08.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-098-08 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-098-08.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-098-08 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-098-08.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-098-09 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/009_minutes_materials_source_export.md rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-098-09.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/021_sec_filings_source_export.json for non-GAAP reconciliation issue.", "id": "investigation.CBP-098-09.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/033_insider_trading_source_export.md to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-098-09.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_related_parties/045_related_parties_source_export.json.", "id": "investigation.CBP-098-09.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-098-09 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-098-09.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-098-09 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-098-09.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-098-10 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/010_minutes_materials_source_export.txt rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-098-10.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/022_sec_filings_source_export.xml for officer certification exception.", "id": "investigation.CBP-098-10.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/034_insider_trading_source_export.txt to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-098-10.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_related_parties/046_related_parties_source_export.xml.", "id": "investigation.CBP-098-10.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-098-10 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-098-10.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-098-10 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-098-10.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-098-11 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/011_minutes_materials_source_export.eml rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-098-11.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/023_sec_filings_source_export.html for risk-factor inconsistency.", "id": "investigation.CBP-098-11.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/035_insider_trading_source_export.eml to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-098-11.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_related_parties/047_related_parties_source_export.html.", "id": "investigation.CBP-098-11.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-098-11 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is the operational record relies on a superseded control revision.", "id": "decision.CBP-098-11.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-098-11 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-098-11.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-098-12 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/012_minutes_materials_source_export.csv rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-098-12.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/024_sec_filings_source_export.pdf for equity-plan share mismatch.", "id": "investigation.CBP-098-12.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/036_insider_trading_source_export.csv to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-098-12.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_related_parties/048_related_parties_source_export.pdf.", "id": "investigation.CBP-098-12.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-098-12 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key.", "id": "decision.CBP-098-12.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-098-12 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-098-12.register"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Write the exact selected option, supported action population, evidence-hold population, facts, owners, deadlines, and citations.", "id": "state.exact_decision"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create one exact register row per portfolio key with no extra, missing, or modified row.", "id": "state.exact_register"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Leave only the three approved deliverables and perform no extra state-changing write.", "id": "state.write_scope_containment"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Read back decision.json, matter-register.json, and advice.md after their final writes.", "id": "state.postwrite_readback"}, {"category": "answer", "description": "Explain the selected recommendation, supported actions, holds, alternatives, and limitations with exact source anchors.", "id": "answer.decision_note"}], "decision_options": [{"approach": "Use a plausible summary or one source without completing the controlling joins.", "id": "highwater-utilities:shortcut", "label": "Classify every director with any company payment or family connection as nonindependent."}, {"approach": "Treat supported actions and genuinely ambiguous records as if they were equally unresolved.", "id": "highwater-utilities:blanket-hold", "label": "Freeze the entire matter population"}, {"approach": "Apply the exact identity, current-state, authority, and revision test. Create director-period rows with exact relationship and committee outcomes.", "id": "highwater-utilities:scoped-evidence", "label": "Update supported independence and matrix disclosures and cure committee gaps."}], "evaluation_narrative": {"authority": "Independence and committee rules require exact relationships, materiality, and current service dates.", "observation": "Join consulting payments, family ties, appointments, questionnaires, and committee service by person and period.", "question": "Which Highwater directors remain independent and what board disclosures must change?", "register_action": "Create director-period rows with exact relationship and committee outcomes."}, "gates": ["all_required_evidence_precedes_first_write", "decision_criteria_complete", "register_state_exact", "write_scope_contained", "all_outputs_verified_by_readback"], "metadata_checks": 8, "metric": "weighted_criteria_score", "minimum_tool_calls": 84, "required_deliverables": ["decision.json", "matter-register.json", "advice.md"], "required_document_reads": 64, "type": "deterministic", "weights": {"advice": 0.15, "decision": 0.35, "investigation": 0.25, "state": 0.25}}, "task_id": "cb100-098-highwater-utilities", "task_name": "Highwater board independence audit", "world_id": "counselbench-filesystem-mcp-v3"}
+{"context_files": ["task_files/cb100-099-ironclad-logistics/01_board_committees/001_board_committees_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-099-ironclad-logistics/01_board_committees/002_board_committees_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-099-ironclad-logistics/01_board_committees/003_board_committees_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-099-ironclad-logistics/01_board_committees/004_board_committees_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-099-ironclad-logistics/01_board_committees/005_board_committees_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-099-ironclad-logistics/01_board_committees/006_board_committees_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-099-ironclad-logistics/01_board_committees/007_board_committees_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-099-ironclad-logistics/01_board_committees/008_board_committees_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-099-ironclad-logistics/02_minutes_materials/009_minutes_materials_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-099-ironclad-logistics/02_minutes_materials/010_minutes_materials_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-099-ironclad-logistics/02_minutes_materials/011_minutes_materials_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-099-ironclad-logistics/02_minutes_materials/012_minutes_materials_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-099-ironclad-logistics/02_minutes_materials/013_minutes_materials_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-099-ironclad-logistics/02_minutes_materials/014_minutes_materials_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-099-ironclad-logistics/02_minutes_materials/015_minutes_materials_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-099-ironclad-logistics/02_minutes_materials/016_minutes_materials_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-099-ironclad-logistics/03_sec_filings/017_sec_filings_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-099-ironclad-logistics/03_sec_filings/018_sec_filings_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-099-ironclad-logistics/03_sec_filings/019_sec_filings_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-099-ironclad-logistics/03_sec_filings/020_sec_filings_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-099-ironclad-logistics/03_sec_filings/021_sec_filings_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-099-ironclad-logistics/03_sec_filings/022_sec_filings_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-099-ironclad-logistics/03_sec_filings/023_sec_filings_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-099-ironclad-logistics/03_sec_filings/024_sec_filings_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-099-ironclad-logistics/04_disclosure_controls/025_disclosure_controls_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-099-ironclad-logistics/04_disclosure_controls/026_disclosure_controls_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-099-ironclad-logistics/04_disclosure_controls/027_disclosure_controls_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-099-ironclad-logistics/04_disclosure_controls/028_disclosure_controls_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-099-ironclad-logistics/04_disclosure_controls/029_disclosure_controls_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-099-ironclad-logistics/04_disclosure_controls/030_disclosure_controls_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-099-ironclad-logistics/04_disclosure_controls/031_disclosure_controls_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-099-ironclad-logistics/04_disclosure_controls/032_disclosure_controls_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-099-ironclad-logistics/05_insider_trading/033_insider_trading_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-099-ironclad-logistics/05_insider_trading/034_insider_trading_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-099-ironclad-logistics/05_insider_trading/035_insider_trading_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-099-ironclad-logistics/05_insider_trading/036_insider_trading_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-099-ironclad-logistics/05_insider_trading/037_insider_trading_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-099-ironclad-logistics/05_insider_trading/038_insider_trading_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-099-ironclad-logistics/05_insider_trading/039_insider_trading_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-099-ironclad-logistics/05_insider_trading/040_insider_trading_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-099-ironclad-logistics/06_related_parties/041_related_parties_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-099-ironclad-logistics/06_related_parties/042_related_parties_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-099-ironclad-logistics/06_related_parties/043_related_parties_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-099-ironclad-logistics/06_related_parties/044_related_parties_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-099-ironclad-logistics/06_related_parties/045_related_parties_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-099-ironclad-logistics/06_related_parties/046_related_parties_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-099-ironclad-logistics/06_related_parties/047_related_parties_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-099-ironclad-logistics/06_related_parties/048_related_parties_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-099-ironclad-logistics/07_equity_compensation/049_equity_compensation_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-099-ironclad-logistics/07_equity_compensation/050_equity_compensation_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-099-ironclad-logistics/07_equity_compensation/051_equity_compensation_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-099-ironclad-logistics/07_equity_compensation/052_equity_compensation_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-099-ironclad-logistics/07_equity_compensation/053_equity_compensation_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-099-ironclad-logistics/07_equity_compensation/054_equity_compensation_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-099-ironclad-logistics/07_equity_compensation/055_equity_compensation_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-099-ironclad-logistics/07_equity_compensation/056_equity_compensation_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-099-ironclad-logistics/08_earnings_guidance/057_earnings_guidance_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-099-ironclad-logistics/08_earnings_guidance/058_earnings_guidance_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-099-ironclad-logistics/08_earnings_guidance/059_earnings_guidance_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-099-ironclad-logistics/08_earnings_guidance/060_earnings_guidance_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-099-ironclad-logistics/08_earnings_guidance/061_earnings_guidance_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-099-ironclad-logistics/08_earnings_guidance/062_earnings_guidance_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-099-ironclad-logistics/08_earnings_guidance/063_earnings_guidance_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-099-ironclad-logistics/08_earnings_guidance/064_earnings_guidance_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-099-ironclad-logistics/09_whistleblower/065_whistleblower_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-099-ironclad-logistics/09_whistleblower/066_whistleblower_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-099-ironclad-logistics/09_whistleblower/067_whistleblower_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-099-ironclad-logistics/09_whistleblower/068_whistleblower_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-099-ironclad-logistics/09_whistleblower/069_whistleblower_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-099-ironclad-logistics/09_whistleblower/070_whistleblower_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-099-ironclad-logistics/09_whistleblower/071_whistleblower_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-099-ironclad-logistics/09_whistleblower/072_whistleblower_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-099-ironclad-logistics/10_stock_exchange/073_stock_exchange_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-099-ironclad-logistics/10_stock_exchange/074_stock_exchange_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-099-ironclad-logistics/10_stock_exchange/075_stock_exchange_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-099-ironclad-logistics/10_stock_exchange/076_stock_exchange_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-099-ironclad-logistics/10_stock_exchange/077_stock_exchange_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-099-ironclad-logistics/10_stock_exchange/078_stock_exchange_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-099-ironclad-logistics/10_stock_exchange/079_stock_exchange_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-099-ironclad-logistics/10_stock_exchange/080_stock_exchange_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-099-ironclad-logistics/11_debt_covenants/081_debt_covenants_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-099-ironclad-logistics/11_debt_covenants/082_debt_covenants_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-099-ironclad-logistics/11_debt_covenants/083_debt_covenants_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-099-ironclad-logistics/11_debt_covenants/084_debt_covenants_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-099-ironclad-logistics/11_debt_covenants/085_debt_covenants_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-099-ironclad-logistics/11_debt_covenants/086_debt_covenants_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-099-ironclad-logistics/11_debt_covenants/087_debt_covenants_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-099-ironclad-logistics/11_debt_covenants/088_debt_covenants_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-099-ironclad-logistics/12_certifications/089_certifications_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-099-ironclad-logistics/12_certifications/090_certifications_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-099-ironclad-logistics/12_certifications/091_certifications_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-099-ironclad-logistics/12_certifications/092_certifications_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-099-ironclad-logistics/12_certifications/093_certifications_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-099-ironclad-logistics/12_certifications/094_certifications_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-099-ironclad-logistics/12_certifications/095_certifications_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-099-ironclad-logistics/12_certifications/096_certifications_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-099-ironclad-logistics/12_certifications/097_ironclad_logistics_impact_population.xlsx"], "gold_output": {"advice_markdown": "# Decision note — Ironclad trading-window inquiry\n\n## Recommendation\n\nEscalate supported trade-control failures and correct related disclosure processes. The reconciled record supports 8 scoped actions and leaves 4 items on evidence hold.\n\nSelected option: `ironclad-logistics:scoped-evidence`.\n\n## Why this is the supported option\n\nJoin acquisition talks, repurchase updates, trade execution, preclearance, knowledge, and window status by person and time. Trading controls depend on actual possession, materiality, preclearance scope, and the effective window.\n\n## Supported actions\n\n### CBP-099-01 — 8-K deadline (critical)\n\napproval must come from Nora Chen under CB-PC-3309-R394; the effective approval record names Caleb Hassan under CB-PC-3309-E646. Identity resolves to ENT-099-1000, revision REV-2025.1 is current, and Isaac Romero is active with capacity 5.\n\nAction: Create person-trade rows with exact knowledge and authorization evidence. Owner: Isaac Romero; due 2026-09-30.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_board_committees/001_board_committees_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/013_minutes_materials_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/025_disclosure_controls_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/037_insider_trading_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/11_debt_covenants/085_debt_covenants_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/12_certifications/097_ironclad_logistics_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-099-03 — listing-standard notice (critical)\n\nthe permission is limited to New York Stock Exchange under CB-PC-3309-R173; the matched activity occurred in Georgia under CB-PC-3309-E316. Identity resolves to ENT-099-1002, revision REV-2025.3 is current, and Rafael Okafor is active with capacity 5.\n\nAction: Create person-trade rows with exact knowledge and authorization evidence. Owner: Rafael Okafor; due 2026-09-28.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_board_committees/003_board_committees_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/015_minutes_materials_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/027_disclosure_controls_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/039_insider_trading_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/12_certifications/097_ironclad_logistics_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-099-04 — minutes-approval omission (medium)\n\nthe operative cap is $322,000.00 under CB-PC-3309-R857; the matched ledger population totals $375,657.00 under CB-PC-3309-E250. Identity resolves to ENT-099-1003, revision REV-2025.4 is current, and Mei Whitaker is active with capacity 3.\n\nAction: Create person-trade rows with exact knowledge and authorization evidence. Owner: Mei Whitaker; due 2026-09-27.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_board_committees/004_board_committees_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/016_minutes_materials_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/028_disclosure_controls_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/040_insider_trading_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/10_stock_exchange/076_stock_exchange_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/12_certifications/097_ironclad_logistics_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-099-05 — Section 16 filing delay (critical)\n\ndelivery must use notices-ironclad_logistics_corp@example.test under CB-PC-3309-R941; the only matched receipt used archive-special_committee@example.test under CB-PC-3309-E625. Identity resolves to ENT-099-1004, revision REV-2025.5 is current, and Theo Laurent is active with capacity 2.\n\nAction: Create person-trade rows with exact knowledge and authorization evidence. Owner: Theo Laurent; due 2026-09-26.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_board_committees/005_board_committees_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/017_sec_filings_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/029_disclosure_controls_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/06_related_parties/041_related_parties_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/09_whistleblower/065_whistleblower_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/10_stock_exchange/077_stock_exchange_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/12_certifications/097_ironclad_logistics_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-099-06 — whistleblower escalation delay (medium)\n\nan open exception blocks completion under CB-PC-3309-R736; the current status is open and unresolved under CB-PC-3309-E719. Identity resolves to ENT-099-1005, revision REV-2025.6 is current, and Lena Varga is active with capacity 6.\n\nAction: Create person-trade rows with exact knowledge and authorization evidence. Owner: Lena Varga; due 2026-09-25.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_board_committees/006_board_committees_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/018_sec_filings_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/030_disclosure_controls_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/06_related_parties/042_related_parties_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/07_equity_compensation/054_equity_compensation_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/12_certifications/097_ironclad_logistics_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-099-08 — trading-window violation (medium)\n\nthe controlling threshold is 10% under CB-PC-3309-R383; the independently calculated result is 12% under CB-PC-3309-E222. Identity resolves to ENT-099-1007, revision REV-2025.1 is current, and Sofia Bennett is active with capacity 5.\n\nAction: Create person-trade rows with exact knowledge and authorization evidence. Owner: Sofia Bennett; due 2026-09-23.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_board_committees/008_board_committees_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/020_sec_filings_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/032_disclosure_controls_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/06_related_parties/044_related_parties_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/12_certifications/097_ironclad_logistics_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-099-11 — disclosure-control exception (medium)\n\nthe permission is limited to New York Stock Exchange under CB-PC-3309-R806; the matched activity occurred in Georgia under CB-PC-3309-E882. Identity resolves to ENT-099-1010, revision REV-2025.4 is current, and Caleb Hassan is active with capacity 3.\n\nAction: Create person-trade rows with exact knowledge and authorization evidence. Owner: Caleb Hassan; due 2026-09-29.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/011_minutes_materials_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/023_sec_filings_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/035_insider_trading_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/06_related_parties/047_related_parties_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/12_certifications/097_ironclad_logistics_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-099-12 — non-GAAP reconciliation issue (high)\n\nthe operative cap is $802,000.00 under CB-PC-3309-R525; the matched ledger population totals $1,045,225.00 under CB-PC-3309-E125. Identity resolves to ENT-099-1011, revision REV-2025.5 is current, and Amara Patel is active with capacity 5.\n\nAction: Create person-trade rows with exact knowledge and authorization evidence. Owner: Amara Patel; due 2026-09-28.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/012_minutes_materials_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/024_sec_filings_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/036_insider_trading_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/06_related_parties/048_related_parties_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/12_certifications/097_ironclad_logistics_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n## Evidence holds\n\n- **CBP-099-02 — related-party disclosure gap**: the operational record relies on a superseded control revision. Next evidence: an operational record using the current effective revision. Sources: `/workspace/documents/01_board_committees/002_board_committees_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/014_minutes_materials_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/026_disclosure_controls_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/038_insider_trading_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/10_stock_exchange/074_stock_exchange_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/07_equity_compensation/050_equity_compensation_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/12_certifications/097_ironclad_logistics_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-099-07 — committee-independence gap**: two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key. Next evidence: an approved immutable entity crosswalk. Sources: `/workspace/documents/01_board_committees/007_board_committees_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/019_sec_filings_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/031_disclosure_controls_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/06_related_parties/043_related_parties_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/12_certifications/091_certifications_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/10_stock_exchange/079_stock_exchange_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/12_certifications/097_ironclad_logistics_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-099-09 — guidance-control failure**: the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective. Next evidence: effective approval and an active owner with remaining capacity. Sources: `/workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/009_minutes_materials_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/021_sec_filings_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/033_insider_trading_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/06_related_parties/045_related_parties_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/09_whistleblower/069_whistleblower_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/11_debt_covenants/081_debt_covenants_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/12_certifications/097_ironclad_logistics_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-099-10 — board-matrix inconsistency**: the operational record relies on a superseded control revision. Next evidence: an operational record using the current effective revision. Sources: `/workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/010_minutes_materials_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/022_sec_filings_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/034_insider_trading_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/06_related_parties/046_related_parties_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/11_debt_covenants/082_debt_covenants_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/12_certifications/097_ironclad_logistics_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n## Alternatives considered\n\n- `ironclad-logistics:blanket-hold` — Freeze the entire matter population: Treat supported actions and genuinely ambiguous records as if they were equally unresolved.\n- `ironclad-logistics:shortcut` — Treat any sale near acquisition activity as an automatic violation.: Use a plausible summary or one source without completing the controlling joins.\n\n## Assumptions and limits\n\nThis decision is limited to cb100-099-ironclad-logistics, the supplied synthetic records, and the matter state as of 2026-10-01. Similar names, stale revisions, and pending authority are not treated as proof.\n", "decision": {"actions": [{"determination": "approval must come from Nora Chen under CB-PC-3309-R394; the effective approval record names Caleb Hassan under CB-PC-3309-E646. Identity resolves to ENT-099-1000, revision REV-2025.1 is current, and Isaac Romero is active with capacity 5.", "due_date": "2026-09-30", "id": "ACT-CBP-099-01", "identity_id": "ENT-099-1000", "issue": "8-K deadline", "owner": "Isaac Romero", "portfolio_key": "CBP-099-01", "recommended_action": "Create person-trade rows with exact knowledge and authorization evidence. Owner: Isaac Romero; due 2026-09-30.", "severity": "critical", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_board_committees/001_board_committees_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/013_minutes_materials_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/025_disclosure_controls_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/037_insider_trading_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/11_debt_covenants/085_debt_covenants_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_certifications/097_ironclad_logistics_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "the permission is limited to New York Stock Exchange under CB-PC-3309-R173; the matched activity occurred in Georgia under CB-PC-3309-E316. Identity resolves to ENT-099-1002, revision REV-2025.3 is current, and Rafael Okafor is active with capacity 5.", "due_date": "2026-09-28", "id": "ACT-CBP-099-03", "identity_id": "ENT-099-1002", "issue": "listing-standard notice", "owner": "Rafael Okafor", "portfolio_key": "CBP-099-03", "recommended_action": "Create person-trade rows with exact knowledge and authorization evidence. Owner: Rafael Okafor; due 2026-09-28.", "severity": "critical", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_board_committees/003_board_committees_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/015_minutes_materials_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/027_disclosure_controls_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/039_insider_trading_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_certifications/097_ironclad_logistics_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "the operative cap is $322,000.00 under CB-PC-3309-R857; the matched ledger population totals $375,657.00 under CB-PC-3309-E250. Identity resolves to ENT-099-1003, revision REV-2025.4 is current, and Mei Whitaker is active with capacity 3.", "due_date": "2026-09-27", "id": "ACT-CBP-099-04", "identity_id": "ENT-099-1003", "issue": "minutes-approval omission", "owner": "Mei Whitaker", "portfolio_key": "CBP-099-04", "recommended_action": "Create person-trade rows with exact knowledge and authorization evidence. Owner: Mei Whitaker; due 2026-09-27.", "severity": "medium", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_board_committees/004_board_committees_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/016_minutes_materials_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/028_disclosure_controls_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/040_insider_trading_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/10_stock_exchange/076_stock_exchange_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/12_certifications/097_ironclad_logistics_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "delivery must use notices-ironclad_logistics_corp@example.test under CB-PC-3309-R941; the only matched receipt used archive-special_committee@example.test under CB-PC-3309-E625. Identity resolves to ENT-099-1004, revision REV-2025.5 is current, and Theo Laurent is active with capacity 2.", "due_date": "2026-09-26", "id": "ACT-CBP-099-05", "identity_id": "ENT-099-1004", "issue": "Section 16 filing delay", "owner": "Theo Laurent", "portfolio_key": "CBP-099-05", "recommended_action": "Create person-trade rows with exact knowledge and authorization evidence. Owner: Theo Laurent; due 2026-09-26.", "severity": "critical", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_board_committees/005_board_committees_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/017_sec_filings_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/029_disclosure_controls_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/06_related_parties/041_related_parties_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/09_whistleblower/065_whistleblower_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/10_stock_exchange/077_stock_exchange_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_certifications/097_ironclad_logistics_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "an open exception blocks completion under CB-PC-3309-R736; the current status is open and unresolved under CB-PC-3309-E719. Identity resolves to ENT-099-1005, revision REV-2025.6 is current, and Lena Varga is active with capacity 6.", "due_date": "2026-09-25", "id": "ACT-CBP-099-06", "identity_id": "ENT-099-1005", "issue": "whistleblower escalation delay", "owner": "Lena Varga", "portfolio_key": "CBP-099-06", "recommended_action": "Create person-trade rows with exact knowledge and authorization evidence. Owner: Lena Varga; due 2026-09-25.", "severity": "medium", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_board_committees/006_board_committees_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/018_sec_filings_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/030_disclosure_controls_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/06_related_parties/042_related_parties_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/07_equity_compensation/054_equity_compensation_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_certifications/097_ironclad_logistics_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "the controlling threshold is 10% under CB-PC-3309-R383; the independently calculated result is 12% under CB-PC-3309-E222. Identity resolves to ENT-099-1007, revision REV-2025.1 is current, and Sofia Bennett is active with capacity 5.", "due_date": "2026-09-23", "id": "ACT-CBP-099-08", "identity_id": "ENT-099-1007", "issue": "trading-window violation", "owner": "Sofia Bennett", "portfolio_key": "CBP-099-08", "recommended_action": "Create person-trade rows with exact knowledge and authorization evidence. Owner: Sofia Bennett; due 2026-09-23.", "severity": "medium", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_board_committees/008_board_committees_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/020_sec_filings_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/032_disclosure_controls_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/06_related_parties/044_related_parties_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/12_certifications/097_ironclad_logistics_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "the permission is limited to New York Stock Exchange under CB-PC-3309-R806; the matched activity occurred in Georgia under CB-PC-3309-E882. Identity resolves to ENT-099-1010, revision REV-2025.4 is current, and Caleb Hassan is active with capacity 3.", "due_date": "2026-09-29", "id": "ACT-CBP-099-11", "identity_id": "ENT-099-1010", "issue": "disclosure-control exception", "owner": "Caleb Hassan", "portfolio_key": "CBP-099-11", "recommended_action": "Create person-trade rows with exact knowledge and authorization evidence. Owner: Caleb Hassan; due 2026-09-29.", "severity": "medium", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/011_minutes_materials_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/023_sec_filings_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/035_insider_trading_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/06_related_parties/047_related_parties_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_certifications/097_ironclad_logistics_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "the operative cap is $802,000.00 under CB-PC-3309-R525; the matched ledger population totals $1,045,225.00 under CB-PC-3309-E125. Identity resolves to ENT-099-1011, revision REV-2025.5 is current, and Amara Patel is active with capacity 5.", "due_date": "2026-09-28", "id": "ACT-CBP-099-12", "identity_id": "ENT-099-1011", "issue": "non-GAAP reconciliation issue", "owner": "Amara Patel", "portfolio_key": "CBP-099-12", "recommended_action": "Create person-trade rows with exact knowledge and authorization evidence. Owner: Amara Patel; due 2026-09-28.", "severity": "high", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/012_minutes_materials_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/024_sec_filings_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/036_insider_trading_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/06_related_parties/048_related_parties_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_certifications/097_ironclad_logistics_impact_population.xlsx"]}], "as_of": "2026-10-01", "decision": {"alternatives_considered": ["ironclad-logistics:blanket-hold", "ironclad-logistics:shortcut"], "question": "Did the Ironclad sale violate the trading window, and what disclosure or control response is needed?", "rationale": "The four-part causal test supports 8 scoped actions and leaves 4 records on evidence hold. Trading controls depend on actual possession, materiality, preclearance scope, and the effective window.", "recommendation": "Escalate supported trade-control failures and correct related disclosure processes.", "selected_option_id": "ironclad-logistics:scoped-evidence"}, "holds": [{"id": "HOLD-CBP-099-02", "issue": "related-party disclosure gap", "portfolio_key": "CBP-099-02", "reason": "the operational record relies on a superseded control revision", "required_next_evidence": "an operational record using the current effective revision", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_board_committees/002_board_committees_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/014_minutes_materials_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/026_disclosure_controls_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/038_insider_trading_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/10_stock_exchange/074_stock_exchange_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/07_equity_compensation/050_equity_compensation_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/12_certifications/097_ironclad_logistics_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-099-07", "issue": "committee-independence gap", "portfolio_key": "CBP-099-07", "reason": "two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key", "required_next_evidence": "an approved immutable entity crosswalk", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_board_committees/007_board_committees_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/019_sec_filings_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/031_disclosure_controls_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/06_related_parties/043_related_parties_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/12_certifications/091_certifications_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/10_stock_exchange/079_stock_exchange_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_certifications/097_ironclad_logistics_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-099-09", "issue": "guidance-control failure", "portfolio_key": "CBP-099-09", "reason": "the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective", "required_next_evidence": "effective approval and an active owner with remaining capacity", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/009_minutes_materials_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/021_sec_filings_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/033_insider_trading_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/06_related_parties/045_related_parties_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/09_whistleblower/069_whistleblower_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/11_debt_covenants/081_debt_covenants_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/12_certifications/097_ironclad_logistics_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-099-10", "issue": "board-matrix inconsistency", "portfolio_key": "CBP-099-10", "reason": "the operational record relies on a superseded control revision", "required_next_evidence": "an operational record using the current effective revision", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/010_minutes_materials_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/022_sec_filings_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/034_insider_trading_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/06_related_parties/046_related_parties_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/11_debt_covenants/082_debt_covenants_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/12_certifications/097_ironclad_logistics_impact_population.xlsx"]}], "matter_number": "CB-PC-3309", "prepared_for": "Ironclad Logistics Corp.", "schema_version": "counselbench.decision.v3", "task_id": "cb100-099-ironclad-logistics"}, "matter_register": {"matter_number": "CB-PC-3309", "rows": [{"decision_option_id": "ironclad-logistics:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-30", "issue": "8-K deadline", "matter_number": "CB-PC-3309", "owner": "Isaac Romero", "portfolio_key": "CBP-099-01", "row_id": "REG-CBP-099-01", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_board_committees/001_board_committees_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/013_minutes_materials_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/025_disclosure_controls_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/037_insider_trading_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/11_debt_covenants/085_debt_covenants_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_certifications/097_ironclad_logistics_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "ironclad-logistics:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "the operational record relies on a superseded control revision", "issue": "related-party disclosure gap", "matter_number": "CB-PC-3309", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-099-02", "row_id": "REG-CBP-099-02", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_board_committees/002_board_committees_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/014_minutes_materials_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/026_disclosure_controls_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/038_insider_trading_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/10_stock_exchange/074_stock_exchange_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/07_equity_compensation/050_equity_compensation_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/12_certifications/097_ironclad_logistics_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "ironclad-logistics:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-28", "issue": "listing-standard notice", "matter_number": "CB-PC-3309", "owner": "Rafael Okafor", "portfolio_key": "CBP-099-03", "row_id": "REG-CBP-099-03", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_board_committees/003_board_committees_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/015_minutes_materials_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/027_disclosure_controls_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/039_insider_trading_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_certifications/097_ironclad_logistics_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "ironclad-logistics:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-27", "issue": "minutes-approval omission", "matter_number": "CB-PC-3309", "owner": "Mei Whitaker", "portfolio_key": "CBP-099-04", "row_id": "REG-CBP-099-04", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_board_committees/004_board_committees_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/016_minutes_materials_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/028_disclosure_controls_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/040_insider_trading_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/10_stock_exchange/076_stock_exchange_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/12_certifications/097_ironclad_logistics_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "ironclad-logistics:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-26", "issue": "Section 16 filing delay", "matter_number": "CB-PC-3309", "owner": "Theo Laurent", "portfolio_key": "CBP-099-05", "row_id": "REG-CBP-099-05", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_board_committees/005_board_committees_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/017_sec_filings_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/029_disclosure_controls_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/06_related_parties/041_related_parties_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/09_whistleblower/065_whistleblower_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/10_stock_exchange/077_stock_exchange_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_certifications/097_ironclad_logistics_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "ironclad-logistics:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-25", "issue": "whistleblower escalation delay", "matter_number": "CB-PC-3309", "owner": "Lena Varga", "portfolio_key": "CBP-099-06", "row_id": "REG-CBP-099-06", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_board_committees/006_board_committees_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/018_sec_filings_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/030_disclosure_controls_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/06_related_parties/042_related_parties_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/07_equity_compensation/054_equity_compensation_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_certifications/097_ironclad_logistics_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "ironclad-logistics:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key", "issue": "committee-independence gap", "matter_number": "CB-PC-3309", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-099-07", "row_id": "REG-CBP-099-07", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_board_committees/007_board_committees_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/019_sec_filings_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/031_disclosure_controls_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/06_related_parties/043_related_parties_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/12_certifications/091_certifications_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/10_stock_exchange/079_stock_exchange_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_certifications/097_ironclad_logistics_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "ironclad-logistics:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-23", "issue": "trading-window violation", "matter_number": "CB-PC-3309", "owner": "Sofia Bennett", "portfolio_key": "CBP-099-08", "row_id": "REG-CBP-099-08", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_board_committees/008_board_committees_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/020_sec_filings_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/032_disclosure_controls_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/06_related_parties/044_related_parties_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/12_certifications/097_ironclad_logistics_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "ironclad-logistics:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective", "issue": "guidance-control failure", "matter_number": "CB-PC-3309", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-099-09", "row_id": "REG-CBP-099-09", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/009_minutes_materials_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/021_sec_filings_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/033_insider_trading_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/06_related_parties/045_related_parties_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/09_whistleblower/069_whistleblower_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/11_debt_covenants/081_debt_covenants_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/12_certifications/097_ironclad_logistics_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "ironclad-logistics:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "the operational record relies on a superseded control revision", "issue": "board-matrix inconsistency", "matter_number": "CB-PC-3309", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-099-10", "row_id": "REG-CBP-099-10", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/010_minutes_materials_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/022_sec_filings_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/034_insider_trading_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/06_related_parties/046_related_parties_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/11_debt_covenants/082_debt_covenants_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/12_certifications/097_ironclad_logistics_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "ironclad-logistics:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-29", "issue": "disclosure-control exception", "matter_number": "CB-PC-3309", "owner": "Caleb Hassan", "portfolio_key": "CBP-099-11", "row_id": "REG-CBP-099-11", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/011_minutes_materials_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/023_sec_filings_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/035_insider_trading_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/06_related_parties/047_related_parties_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_certifications/097_ironclad_logistics_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "ironclad-logistics:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-28", "issue": "non-GAAP reconciliation issue", "matter_number": "CB-PC-3309", "owner": "Amara Patel", "portfolio_key": "CBP-099-12", "row_id": "REG-CBP-099-12", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/012_minutes_materials_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/024_sec_filings_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/036_insider_trading_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/06_related_parties/048_related_parties_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_certifications/097_ironclad_logistics_impact_population.xlsx"]}], "schema_version": "counselbench.matter-register.v3", "task_id": "cb100-099-ironclad-logistics"}}, "metadata": {"benchmark": "CounselBench-100", "code_license": "Apache-2.0", "data_license": "CC-BY-4.0", "deadline": "2026-10-01", "document_count": 97, "evidence_holds": 4, "jurisdiction": "Georgia", "matter_number": "CB-PC-3309", "mcp_commit": "9a96ea6e5913736f92b88345bf51caeaaa8e719f", "mcp_package": "@modelcontextprotocol/server-filesystem@2026.7.10", "practice_area": "public-company", "reference_tool_calls": 89, "required_evidence_reads": 62, "supported_actions": 8, "synthetic": true, "venue": "New York Stock Exchange", "version": "3.1.0"}, "prompt": "Please take ownership of the open question before the deadline. Did the Ironclad sale violate the trading window, and what disclosure or control response is needed? A repurchase update, acquisition talks, executive sale, and preclearance record raise control and disclosure timing questions. The team needs the call by 2026-10-01. Give me a decision-ready note and make the corresponding matter-register entries, without guessing through missing records.", "rubric": {"criteria": [{"category": "investigation", "description": "Inventory the production and use targeted searches to locate records across native formats.", "id": "investigation.discover_production"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Complete every task-specific identity, authority, operations, and approval read before the first state transition.", "id": "investigation.read_before_write"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Inspect designated source metadata before relying on those records.", "id": "investigation.custody_before_write"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "Select the supported option 'ironclad-logistics:scoped-evidence' after applying the four-part test.", "id": "decision.selected_option"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "Identify both rejected approaches and explain why a one-source shortcut and a blanket hold are wrong.", "id": "decision.alternatives"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-099-01 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_board_committees/001_board_committees_source_export.md rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-099-01.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/013_minutes_materials_source_export.json for 8-K deadline.", "id": "investigation.CBP-099-01.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/025_disclosure_controls_source_export.md to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-099-01.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/037_insider_trading_source_export.json.", "id": "investigation.CBP-099-01.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-099-01 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-099-01.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-099-01 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-099-01.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-099-02 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_board_committees/002_board_committees_source_export.txt rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-099-02.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/014_minutes_materials_source_export.xml for related-party disclosure gap.", "id": "investigation.CBP-099-02.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/026_disclosure_controls_source_export.txt to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-099-02.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/038_insider_trading_source_export.xml.", "id": "investigation.CBP-099-02.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-099-02 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is the operational record relies on a superseded control revision.", "id": "decision.CBP-099-02.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-099-02 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-099-02.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-099-03 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_board_committees/003_board_committees_source_export.eml rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-099-03.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/015_minutes_materials_source_export.html for listing-standard notice.", "id": "investigation.CBP-099-03.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/027_disclosure_controls_source_export.eml to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-099-03.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/039_insider_trading_source_export.html.", "id": "investigation.CBP-099-03.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-099-03 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-099-03.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-099-03 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-099-03.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-099-04 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_board_committees/004_board_committees_source_export.csv rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-099-04.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/016_minutes_materials_source_export.pdf for minutes-approval omission.", "id": "investigation.CBP-099-04.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/028_disclosure_controls_source_export.csv to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-099-04.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/040_insider_trading_source_export.pdf.", "id": "investigation.CBP-099-04.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-099-04 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-099-04.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-099-04 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-099-04.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-099-05 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_board_committees/005_board_committees_source_export.json rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-099-05.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/017_sec_filings_source_export.md for Section 16 filing delay.", "id": "investigation.CBP-099-05.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/029_disclosure_controls_source_export.json to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-099-05.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_related_parties/041_related_parties_source_export.md.", "id": "investigation.CBP-099-05.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-099-05 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-099-05.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-099-05 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-099-05.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-099-06 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_board_committees/006_board_committees_source_export.xml rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-099-06.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/018_sec_filings_source_export.txt for whistleblower escalation delay.", "id": "investigation.CBP-099-06.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/030_disclosure_controls_source_export.xml to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-099-06.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_related_parties/042_related_parties_source_export.txt.", "id": "investigation.CBP-099-06.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-099-06 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-099-06.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-099-06 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-099-06.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-099-07 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_board_committees/007_board_committees_source_export.html rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-099-07.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/019_sec_filings_source_export.eml for committee-independence gap.", "id": "investigation.CBP-099-07.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/031_disclosure_controls_source_export.html to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-099-07.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_related_parties/043_related_parties_source_export.eml.", "id": "investigation.CBP-099-07.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-099-07 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key.", "id": "decision.CBP-099-07.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-099-07 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-099-07.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-099-08 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_board_committees/008_board_committees_source_export.pdf rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-099-08.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/020_sec_filings_source_export.csv for trading-window violation.", "id": "investigation.CBP-099-08.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/032_disclosure_controls_source_export.pdf to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-099-08.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_related_parties/044_related_parties_source_export.csv.", "id": "investigation.CBP-099-08.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-099-08 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-099-08.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-099-08 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-099-08.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-099-09 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/009_minutes_materials_source_export.md rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-099-09.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/021_sec_filings_source_export.json for guidance-control failure.", "id": "investigation.CBP-099-09.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/033_insider_trading_source_export.md to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-099-09.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_related_parties/045_related_parties_source_export.json.", "id": "investigation.CBP-099-09.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-099-09 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective.", "id": "decision.CBP-099-09.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-099-09 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-099-09.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-099-10 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/010_minutes_materials_source_export.txt rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-099-10.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/022_sec_filings_source_export.xml for board-matrix inconsistency.", "id": "investigation.CBP-099-10.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/034_insider_trading_source_export.txt to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-099-10.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_related_parties/046_related_parties_source_export.xml.", "id": "investigation.CBP-099-10.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-099-10 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is the operational record relies on a superseded control revision.", "id": "decision.CBP-099-10.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-099-10 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-099-10.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-099-11 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/011_minutes_materials_source_export.eml rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-099-11.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/023_sec_filings_source_export.html for disclosure-control exception.", "id": "investigation.CBP-099-11.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/035_insider_trading_source_export.eml to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-099-11.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_related_parties/047_related_parties_source_export.html.", "id": "investigation.CBP-099-11.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-099-11 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-099-11.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-099-11 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-099-11.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-099-12 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/012_minutes_materials_source_export.csv rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-099-12.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/024_sec_filings_source_export.pdf for non-GAAP reconciliation issue.", "id": "investigation.CBP-099-12.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/036_insider_trading_source_export.csv to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-099-12.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_related_parties/048_related_parties_source_export.pdf.", "id": "investigation.CBP-099-12.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-099-12 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-099-12.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-099-12 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-099-12.register"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Write the exact selected option, supported action population, evidence-hold population, facts, owners, deadlines, and citations.", "id": "state.exact_decision"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create one exact register row per portfolio key with no extra, missing, or modified row.", "id": "state.exact_register"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Leave only the three approved deliverables and perform no extra state-changing write.", "id": "state.write_scope_containment"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Read back decision.json, matter-register.json, and advice.md after their final writes.", "id": "state.postwrite_readback"}, {"category": "answer", "description": "Explain the selected recommendation, supported actions, holds, alternatives, and limitations with exact source anchors.", "id": "answer.decision_note"}], "decision_options": [{"approach": "Treat supported actions and genuinely ambiguous records as if they were equally unresolved.", "id": "ironclad-logistics:blanket-hold", "label": "Freeze the entire matter population"}, {"approach": "Apply the exact identity, current-state, authority, and revision test. Create person-trade rows with exact knowledge and authorization evidence.", "id": "ironclad-logistics:scoped-evidence", "label": "Escalate supported trade-control failures and correct related disclosure processes."}, {"approach": "Use a plausible summary or one source without completing the controlling joins.", "id": "ironclad-logistics:shortcut", "label": "Treat any sale near acquisition activity as an automatic violation."}], "evaluation_narrative": {"authority": "Trading controls depend on actual possession, materiality, preclearance scope, and the effective window.", "observation": "Join acquisition talks, repurchase updates, trade execution, preclearance, knowledge, and window status by person and time.", "question": "Did the Ironclad sale violate the trading window, and what disclosure or control response is needed?", "register_action": "Create person-trade rows with exact knowledge and authorization evidence."}, "gates": ["all_required_evidence_precedes_first_write", "decision_criteria_complete", "register_state_exact", "write_scope_contained", "all_outputs_verified_by_readback"], "metadata_checks": 12, "metric": "weighted_criteria_score", "minimum_tool_calls": 89, "required_deliverables": ["decision.json", "matter-register.json", "advice.md"], "required_document_reads": 62, "type": "deterministic", "weights": {"advice": 0.15, "decision": 0.35, "investigation": 0.25, "state": 0.25}}, "task_id": "cb100-099-ironclad-logistics", "task_name": "Ironclad trading-window inquiry", "world_id": "counselbench-filesystem-mcp-v3"}
+{"context_files": ["task_files/cb100-100-juniper-photonics/01_board_committees/001_board_committees_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-100-juniper-photonics/01_board_committees/002_board_committees_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-100-juniper-photonics/01_board_committees/003_board_committees_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-100-juniper-photonics/01_board_committees/004_board_committees_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-100-juniper-photonics/01_board_committees/005_board_committees_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-100-juniper-photonics/01_board_committees/006_board_committees_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-100-juniper-photonics/01_board_committees/007_board_committees_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-100-juniper-photonics/01_board_committees/008_board_committees_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-100-juniper-photonics/02_minutes_materials/009_minutes_materials_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-100-juniper-photonics/02_minutes_materials/010_minutes_materials_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-100-juniper-photonics/02_minutes_materials/011_minutes_materials_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-100-juniper-photonics/02_minutes_materials/012_minutes_materials_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-100-juniper-photonics/02_minutes_materials/013_minutes_materials_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-100-juniper-photonics/02_minutes_materials/014_minutes_materials_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-100-juniper-photonics/02_minutes_materials/015_minutes_materials_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-100-juniper-photonics/02_minutes_materials/016_minutes_materials_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-100-juniper-photonics/03_sec_filings/017_sec_filings_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-100-juniper-photonics/03_sec_filings/018_sec_filings_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-100-juniper-photonics/03_sec_filings/019_sec_filings_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-100-juniper-photonics/03_sec_filings/020_sec_filings_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-100-juniper-photonics/03_sec_filings/021_sec_filings_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-100-juniper-photonics/03_sec_filings/022_sec_filings_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-100-juniper-photonics/03_sec_filings/023_sec_filings_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-100-juniper-photonics/03_sec_filings/024_sec_filings_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-100-juniper-photonics/04_disclosure_controls/025_disclosure_controls_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-100-juniper-photonics/04_disclosure_controls/026_disclosure_controls_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-100-juniper-photonics/04_disclosure_controls/027_disclosure_controls_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-100-juniper-photonics/04_disclosure_controls/028_disclosure_controls_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-100-juniper-photonics/04_disclosure_controls/029_disclosure_controls_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-100-juniper-photonics/04_disclosure_controls/030_disclosure_controls_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-100-juniper-photonics/04_disclosure_controls/031_disclosure_controls_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-100-juniper-photonics/04_disclosure_controls/032_disclosure_controls_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-100-juniper-photonics/05_insider_trading/033_insider_trading_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-100-juniper-photonics/05_insider_trading/034_insider_trading_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-100-juniper-photonics/05_insider_trading/035_insider_trading_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-100-juniper-photonics/05_insider_trading/036_insider_trading_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-100-juniper-photonics/05_insider_trading/037_insider_trading_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-100-juniper-photonics/05_insider_trading/038_insider_trading_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-100-juniper-photonics/05_insider_trading/039_insider_trading_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-100-juniper-photonics/05_insider_trading/040_insider_trading_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-100-juniper-photonics/06_related_parties/041_related_parties_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-100-juniper-photonics/06_related_parties/042_related_parties_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-100-juniper-photonics/06_related_parties/043_related_parties_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-100-juniper-photonics/06_related_parties/044_related_parties_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-100-juniper-photonics/06_related_parties/045_related_parties_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-100-juniper-photonics/06_related_parties/046_related_parties_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-100-juniper-photonics/06_related_parties/047_related_parties_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-100-juniper-photonics/06_related_parties/048_related_parties_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-100-juniper-photonics/07_equity_compensation/049_equity_compensation_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-100-juniper-photonics/07_equity_compensation/050_equity_compensation_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-100-juniper-photonics/07_equity_compensation/051_equity_compensation_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-100-juniper-photonics/07_equity_compensation/052_equity_compensation_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-100-juniper-photonics/07_equity_compensation/053_equity_compensation_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-100-juniper-photonics/07_equity_compensation/054_equity_compensation_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-100-juniper-photonics/07_equity_compensation/055_equity_compensation_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-100-juniper-photonics/07_equity_compensation/056_equity_compensation_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-100-juniper-photonics/08_earnings_guidance/057_earnings_guidance_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-100-juniper-photonics/08_earnings_guidance/058_earnings_guidance_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-100-juniper-photonics/08_earnings_guidance/059_earnings_guidance_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-100-juniper-photonics/08_earnings_guidance/060_earnings_guidance_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-100-juniper-photonics/08_earnings_guidance/061_earnings_guidance_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-100-juniper-photonics/08_earnings_guidance/062_earnings_guidance_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-100-juniper-photonics/08_earnings_guidance/063_earnings_guidance_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-100-juniper-photonics/08_earnings_guidance/064_earnings_guidance_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-100-juniper-photonics/09_whistleblower/065_whistleblower_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-100-juniper-photonics/09_whistleblower/066_whistleblower_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-100-juniper-photonics/09_whistleblower/067_whistleblower_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-100-juniper-photonics/09_whistleblower/068_whistleblower_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-100-juniper-photonics/09_whistleblower/069_whistleblower_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-100-juniper-photonics/09_whistleblower/070_whistleblower_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-100-juniper-photonics/09_whistleblower/071_whistleblower_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-100-juniper-photonics/09_whistleblower/072_whistleblower_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-100-juniper-photonics/10_stock_exchange/073_stock_exchange_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-100-juniper-photonics/10_stock_exchange/074_stock_exchange_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-100-juniper-photonics/10_stock_exchange/075_stock_exchange_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-100-juniper-photonics/10_stock_exchange/076_stock_exchange_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-100-juniper-photonics/10_stock_exchange/077_stock_exchange_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-100-juniper-photonics/10_stock_exchange/078_stock_exchange_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-100-juniper-photonics/10_stock_exchange/079_stock_exchange_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-100-juniper-photonics/10_stock_exchange/080_stock_exchange_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-100-juniper-photonics/11_debt_covenants/081_debt_covenants_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-100-juniper-photonics/11_debt_covenants/082_debt_covenants_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-100-juniper-photonics/11_debt_covenants/083_debt_covenants_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-100-juniper-photonics/11_debt_covenants/084_debt_covenants_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-100-juniper-photonics/11_debt_covenants/085_debt_covenants_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-100-juniper-photonics/11_debt_covenants/086_debt_covenants_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-100-juniper-photonics/11_debt_covenants/087_debt_covenants_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-100-juniper-photonics/11_debt_covenants/088_debt_covenants_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-100-juniper-photonics/12_certifications/089_certifications_source_export.md", "task_files/cb100-100-juniper-photonics/12_certifications/090_certifications_source_export.txt", "task_files/cb100-100-juniper-photonics/12_certifications/091_certifications_source_export.eml", "task_files/cb100-100-juniper-photonics/12_certifications/092_certifications_source_export.csv", "task_files/cb100-100-juniper-photonics/12_certifications/093_certifications_source_export.json", "task_files/cb100-100-juniper-photonics/12_certifications/094_certifications_source_export.xml", "task_files/cb100-100-juniper-photonics/12_certifications/095_certifications_source_export.html", "task_files/cb100-100-juniper-photonics/12_certifications/096_certifications_source_export.pdf", "task_files/cb100-100-juniper-photonics/12_certifications/097_juniper_photonics_impact_population.xlsx"], "gold_output": {"advice_markdown": "# Decision note — Juniper Photonics filing readiness audit\n\n## Recommendation\n\nFile only after supported figures and certifications are corrected or explicitly held open. The reconciled record supports 8 scoped actions and leaves 4 items on evidence hold.\n\nSelected option: `juniper-photonics:scoped-evidence`.\n\n## Why this is the supported option\n\nReconcile current incidents, concentration metrics, plan shares, committee status, and certifications to the reporting period. The filing checklist and applicable disclosure and governance controls require current, source-consistent support.\n\n## Supported actions\n\n### CBP-100-02 — equity-plan share mismatch (high)\n\ncompletion is required by 2025-01-31 under CB-PC-3310-R125; the current event record shows completion on 2025-02-28 under CB-PC-3310-E525. Identity resolves to ENT-100-1001, revision REV-2026.2 is current, and Owen Delgado is active with capacity 3.\n\nAction: Create disclosure-topic rows with exact corrections, owners, and filing holds. Owner: Owen Delgado; due 2026-10-03.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_board_committees/002_board_committees_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/014_minutes_materials_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/026_disclosure_controls_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/038_insider_trading_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/08_earnings_guidance/062_earnings_guidance_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/10_stock_exchange/074_stock_exchange_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/12_certifications/097_juniper_photonics_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-100-03 — debt-covenant disclosure (high)\n\nthe controlling threshold is 5% under CB-PC-3310-R192; the independently calculated result is 9% under CB-PC-3310-E476. Identity resolves to ENT-100-1002, revision REV-2026.3 is current, and Priya Raman is active with capacity 5.\n\nAction: Create disclosure-topic rows with exact corrections, owners, and filing holds. Owner: Priya Raman; due 2026-10-02.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_board_committees/003_board_committees_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/015_minutes_materials_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/027_disclosure_controls_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/039_insider_trading_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/08_earnings_guidance/063_earnings_guidance_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/12_certifications/097_juniper_photonics_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-100-07 — minutes-approval omission (high)\n\nthe operative cap is $3,082,000.00 under CB-PC-3310-R122; the matched ledger population totals $3,293,022.00 under CB-PC-3310-E418. Identity resolves to ENT-100-1006, revision REV-2026.7 is current, and Mei Whitaker is active with capacity 3.\n\nAction: Create disclosure-topic rows with exact corrections, owners, and filing holds. Owner: Mei Whitaker; due 2026-09-28.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_board_committees/007_board_committees_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/019_sec_filings_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/031_disclosure_controls_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/06_related_parties/043_related_parties_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/09_whistleblower/067_whistleblower_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/12_certifications/097_juniper_photonics_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-100-08 — Section 16 filing delay (low)\n\ndelivery must use notices-juniper_photonics_inc@example.test under CB-PC-3310-R497; the only matched receipt used archive-disclosure_committee@example.test under CB-PC-3310-E652. Identity resolves to ENT-100-1007, revision REV-2026.1 is current, and Theo Laurent is active with capacity 1.\n\nAction: Create disclosure-topic rows with exact corrections, owners, and filing holds. Owner: Theo Laurent; due 2026-09-27.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/01_board_committees/008_board_committees_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/020_sec_filings_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/032_disclosure_controls_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/06_related_parties/044_related_parties_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/12_certifications/092_certifications_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/09_whistleblower/068_whistleblower_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/12_certifications/097_juniper_photonics_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-100-09 — whistleblower escalation delay (medium)\n\nan open exception blocks completion under CB-PC-3310-R768; the current status is open and unresolved under CB-PC-3310-E404. Identity resolves to ENT-100-1008, revision REV-2026.2 is current, and Lena Varga is active with capacity 2.\n\nAction: Create disclosure-topic rows with exact corrections, owners, and filing holds. Owner: Lena Varga; due 2026-09-26.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/009_minutes_materials_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/021_sec_filings_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/033_insider_trading_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/06_related_parties/045_related_parties_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/12_certifications/097_juniper_photonics_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-100-10 — committee-independence gap (medium)\n\ncompletion is required by 2026-01-22 under CB-PC-3310-R961; the current event record shows completion on 2026-02-13 under CB-PC-3310-E415. Identity resolves to ENT-100-1009, revision REV-2026.3 is current, and Elliot Mercer is active with capacity 2.\n\nAction: Create disclosure-topic rows with exact corrections, owners, and filing holds. Owner: Elliot Mercer; due 2026-10-04.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/010_minutes_materials_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/022_sec_filings_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/034_insider_trading_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/06_related_parties/046_related_parties_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/12_certifications/094_certifications_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/12_certifications/097_juniper_photonics_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-100-11 — trading-window violation (medium)\n\nthe controlling threshold is 3% under CB-PC-3310-R146; the independently calculated result is 5% under CB-PC-3310-E685. Identity resolves to ENT-100-1010, revision REV-2026.4 is current, and Sofia Bennett is active with capacity 5.\n\nAction: Create disclosure-topic rows with exact corrections, owners, and filing holds. Owner: Sofia Bennett; due 2026-10-03.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/011_minutes_materials_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/023_sec_filings_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/035_insider_trading_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/06_related_parties/047_related_parties_source_export.html`, `/workspace/documents/11_debt_covenants/083_debt_covenants_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/08_earnings_guidance/059_earnings_guidance_source_export.eml`, `/workspace/documents/12_certifications/097_juniper_photonics_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n### CBP-100-12 — guidance-control failure (medium)\n\napproval must come from Sofia Bennett under CB-PC-3310-R243; the effective approval record names Henry Cho under CB-PC-3310-E214. Identity resolves to ENT-100-1011, revision REV-2026.5 is current, and Micah Sullivan is active with capacity 1.\n\nAction: Create disclosure-topic rows with exact corrections, owners, and filing holds. Owner: Micah Sullivan; due 2026-10-02.\n\nSources: `/workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/012_minutes_materials_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/024_sec_filings_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/036_insider_trading_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/06_related_parties/048_related_parties_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/12_certifications/097_juniper_photonics_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n## Evidence holds\n\n- **CBP-100-01 — risk-factor inconsistency**: the operational record relies on a superseded control revision. Next evidence: an operational record using the current effective revision. Sources: `/workspace/documents/01_board_committees/001_board_committees_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/013_minutes_materials_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/025_disclosure_controls_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/037_insider_trading_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/07_equity_compensation/049_equity_compensation_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/12_certifications/097_juniper_photonics_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-100-04 — 8-K deadline**: the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective. Next evidence: effective approval and an active owner with remaining capacity. Sources: `/workspace/documents/01_board_committees/004_board_committees_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/016_minutes_materials_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/028_disclosure_controls_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/040_insider_trading_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/10_stock_exchange/076_stock_exchange_source_export.csv`, `/workspace/documents/11_debt_covenants/088_debt_covenants_source_export.pdf`, `/workspace/documents/12_certifications/097_juniper_photonics_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-100-05 — related-party disclosure gap**: the operational record relies on a superseded control revision. Next evidence: an operational record using the current effective revision. Sources: `/workspace/documents/01_board_committees/005_board_committees_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/017_sec_filings_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/029_disclosure_controls_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/06_related_parties/041_related_parties_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/09_whistleblower/065_whistleblower_source_export.md`, `/workspace/documents/07_equity_compensation/053_equity_compensation_source_export.json`, `/workspace/documents/12_certifications/097_juniper_photonics_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n- **CBP-100-06 — listing-standard notice**: two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key. Next evidence: an approved immutable entity crosswalk. Sources: `/workspace/documents/01_board_committees/006_board_committees_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/018_sec_filings_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/030_disclosure_controls_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/06_related_parties/042_related_parties_source_export.txt`, `/workspace/documents/10_stock_exchange/078_stock_exchange_source_export.xml`, `/workspace/documents/12_certifications/097_juniper_photonics_impact_population.xlsx`\n\n## Alternatives considered\n\n- `juniper-photonics:shortcut` — Use the near-final filing draft as proof that every underlying control passed.: Use a plausible summary or one source without completing the controlling joins.\n- `juniper-photonics:blanket-hold` — Freeze the entire matter population: Treat supported actions and genuinely ambiguous records as if they were equally unresolved.\n\n## Assumptions and limits\n\nThis decision is limited to cb100-100-juniper-photonics, the supplied synthetic records, and the matter state as of 2026-10-05. Similar names, stale revisions, and pending authority are not treated as proof.\n", "decision": {"actions": [{"determination": "completion is required by 2025-01-31 under CB-PC-3310-R125; the current event record shows completion on 2025-02-28 under CB-PC-3310-E525. Identity resolves to ENT-100-1001, revision REV-2026.2 is current, and Owen Delgado is active with capacity 3.", "due_date": "2026-10-03", "id": "ACT-CBP-100-02", "identity_id": "ENT-100-1001", "issue": "equity-plan share mismatch", "owner": "Owen Delgado", "portfolio_key": "CBP-100-02", "recommended_action": "Create disclosure-topic rows with exact corrections, owners, and filing holds. Owner: Owen Delgado; due 2026-10-03.", "severity": "high", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_board_committees/002_board_committees_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/014_minutes_materials_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/026_disclosure_controls_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/038_insider_trading_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/08_earnings_guidance/062_earnings_guidance_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/10_stock_exchange/074_stock_exchange_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/12_certifications/097_juniper_photonics_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "the controlling threshold is 5% under CB-PC-3310-R192; the independently calculated result is 9% under CB-PC-3310-E476. Identity resolves to ENT-100-1002, revision REV-2026.3 is current, and Priya Raman is active with capacity 5.", "due_date": "2026-10-02", "id": "ACT-CBP-100-03", "identity_id": "ENT-100-1002", "issue": "debt-covenant disclosure", "owner": "Priya Raman", "portfolio_key": "CBP-100-03", "recommended_action": "Create disclosure-topic rows with exact corrections, owners, and filing holds. Owner: Priya Raman; due 2026-10-02.", "severity": "high", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_board_committees/003_board_committees_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/015_minutes_materials_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/027_disclosure_controls_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/039_insider_trading_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/08_earnings_guidance/063_earnings_guidance_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_certifications/097_juniper_photonics_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "the operative cap is $3,082,000.00 under CB-PC-3310-R122; the matched ledger population totals $3,293,022.00 under CB-PC-3310-E418. Identity resolves to ENT-100-1006, revision REV-2026.7 is current, and Mei Whitaker is active with capacity 3.", "due_date": "2026-09-28", "id": "ACT-CBP-100-07", "identity_id": "ENT-100-1006", "issue": "minutes-approval omission", "owner": "Mei Whitaker", "portfolio_key": "CBP-100-07", "recommended_action": "Create disclosure-topic rows with exact corrections, owners, and filing holds. Owner: Mei Whitaker; due 2026-09-28.", "severity": "high", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_board_committees/007_board_committees_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/019_sec_filings_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/031_disclosure_controls_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/06_related_parties/043_related_parties_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/09_whistleblower/067_whistleblower_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/12_certifications/097_juniper_photonics_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "delivery must use notices-juniper_photonics_inc@example.test under CB-PC-3310-R497; the only matched receipt used archive-disclosure_committee@example.test under CB-PC-3310-E652. Identity resolves to ENT-100-1007, revision REV-2026.1 is current, and Theo Laurent is active with capacity 1.", "due_date": "2026-09-27", "id": "ACT-CBP-100-08", "identity_id": "ENT-100-1007", "issue": "Section 16 filing delay", "owner": "Theo Laurent", "portfolio_key": "CBP-100-08", "recommended_action": "Create disclosure-topic rows with exact corrections, owners, and filing holds. Owner: Theo Laurent; due 2026-09-27.", "severity": "low", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_board_committees/008_board_committees_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/020_sec_filings_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/032_disclosure_controls_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/06_related_parties/044_related_parties_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/12_certifications/092_certifications_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/09_whistleblower/068_whistleblower_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/12_certifications/097_juniper_photonics_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "an open exception blocks completion under CB-PC-3310-R768; the current status is open and unresolved under CB-PC-3310-E404. Identity resolves to ENT-100-1008, revision REV-2026.2 is current, and Lena Varga is active with capacity 2.", "due_date": "2026-09-26", "id": "ACT-CBP-100-09", "identity_id": "ENT-100-1008", "issue": "whistleblower escalation delay", "owner": "Lena Varga", "portfolio_key": "CBP-100-09", "recommended_action": "Create disclosure-topic rows with exact corrections, owners, and filing holds. Owner: Lena Varga; due 2026-09-26.", "severity": "medium", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/009_minutes_materials_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/021_sec_filings_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/033_insider_trading_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/06_related_parties/045_related_parties_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_certifications/097_juniper_photonics_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "completion is required by 2026-01-22 under CB-PC-3310-R961; the current event record shows completion on 2026-02-13 under CB-PC-3310-E415. Identity resolves to ENT-100-1009, revision REV-2026.3 is current, and Elliot Mercer is active with capacity 2.", "due_date": "2026-10-04", "id": "ACT-CBP-100-10", "identity_id": "ENT-100-1009", "issue": "committee-independence gap", "owner": "Elliot Mercer", "portfolio_key": "CBP-100-10", "recommended_action": "Create disclosure-topic rows with exact corrections, owners, and filing holds. Owner: Elliot Mercer; due 2026-10-04.", "severity": "medium", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/010_minutes_materials_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/022_sec_filings_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/034_insider_trading_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/06_related_parties/046_related_parties_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_certifications/094_certifications_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_certifications/097_juniper_photonics_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "the controlling threshold is 3% under CB-PC-3310-R146; the independently calculated result is 5% under CB-PC-3310-E685. Identity resolves to ENT-100-1010, revision REV-2026.4 is current, and Sofia Bennett is active with capacity 5.", "due_date": "2026-10-03", "id": "ACT-CBP-100-11", "identity_id": "ENT-100-1010", "issue": "trading-window violation", "owner": "Sofia Bennett", "portfolio_key": "CBP-100-11", "recommended_action": "Create disclosure-topic rows with exact corrections, owners, and filing holds. Owner: Sofia Bennett; due 2026-10-03.", "severity": "medium", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/011_minutes_materials_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/023_sec_filings_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/035_insider_trading_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/06_related_parties/047_related_parties_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/11_debt_covenants/083_debt_covenants_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/08_earnings_guidance/059_earnings_guidance_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/12_certifications/097_juniper_photonics_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"determination": "approval must come from Sofia Bennett under CB-PC-3310-R243; the effective approval record names Henry Cho under CB-PC-3310-E214. Identity resolves to ENT-100-1011, revision REV-2026.5 is current, and Micah Sullivan is active with capacity 1.", "due_date": "2026-10-02", "id": "ACT-CBP-100-12", "identity_id": "ENT-100-1011", "issue": "guidance-control failure", "owner": "Micah Sullivan", "portfolio_key": "CBP-100-12", "recommended_action": "Create disclosure-topic rows with exact corrections, owners, and filing holds. Owner: Micah Sullivan; due 2026-10-02.", "severity": "medium", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/012_minutes_materials_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/024_sec_filings_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/036_insider_trading_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/06_related_parties/048_related_parties_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_certifications/097_juniper_photonics_impact_population.xlsx"]}], "as_of": "2026-10-05", "decision": {"alternatives_considered": ["juniper-photonics:shortcut", "juniper-photonics:blanket-hold"], "question": "Is Juniper Photonics ready to file, and which cyber, customer, equity, committee, or certification issues remain open?", "rationale": "The four-part causal test supports 8 scoped actions and leaves 4 records on evidence hold. The filing checklist and applicable disclosure and governance controls require current, source-consistent support.", "recommendation": "File only after supported figures and certifications are corrected or explicitly held open.", "selected_option_id": "juniper-photonics:scoped-evidence"}, "holds": [{"id": "HOLD-CBP-100-01", "issue": "risk-factor inconsistency", "portfolio_key": "CBP-100-01", "reason": "the operational record relies on a superseded control revision", "required_next_evidence": "an operational record using the current effective revision", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_board_committees/001_board_committees_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/013_minutes_materials_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/025_disclosure_controls_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/037_insider_trading_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/07_equity_compensation/049_equity_compensation_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/12_certifications/097_juniper_photonics_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-100-04", "issue": "8-K deadline", "portfolio_key": "CBP-100-04", "reason": "the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective", "required_next_evidence": "effective approval and an active owner with remaining capacity", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_board_committees/004_board_committees_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/016_minutes_materials_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/028_disclosure_controls_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/040_insider_trading_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/10_stock_exchange/076_stock_exchange_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/11_debt_covenants/088_debt_covenants_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_certifications/097_juniper_photonics_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-100-05", "issue": "related-party disclosure gap", "portfolio_key": "CBP-100-05", "reason": "the operational record relies on a superseded control revision", "required_next_evidence": "an operational record using the current effective revision", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_board_committees/005_board_committees_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/017_sec_filings_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/029_disclosure_controls_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/06_related_parties/041_related_parties_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/09_whistleblower/065_whistleblower_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/07_equity_compensation/053_equity_compensation_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_certifications/097_juniper_photonics_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"id": "HOLD-CBP-100-06", "issue": "listing-standard notice", "portfolio_key": "CBP-100-06", "reason": "two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key", "required_next_evidence": "an approved immutable entity crosswalk", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_board_committees/006_board_committees_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/018_sec_filings_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/030_disclosure_controls_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/06_related_parties/042_related_parties_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/10_stock_exchange/078_stock_exchange_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_certifications/097_juniper_photonics_impact_population.xlsx"]}], "matter_number": "CB-PC-3310", "prepared_for": "Juniper Photonics, Inc.", "schema_version": "counselbench.decision.v3", "task_id": "cb100-100-juniper-photonics"}, "matter_register": {"matter_number": "CB-PC-3310", "rows": [{"decision_option_id": "juniper-photonics:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "the operational record relies on a superseded control revision", "issue": "risk-factor inconsistency", "matter_number": "CB-PC-3310", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-100-01", "row_id": "REG-CBP-100-01", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_board_committees/001_board_committees_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/013_minutes_materials_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/025_disclosure_controls_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/037_insider_trading_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/07_equity_compensation/049_equity_compensation_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/12_certifications/097_juniper_photonics_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "juniper-photonics:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-10-03", "issue": "equity-plan share mismatch", "matter_number": "CB-PC-3310", "owner": "Owen Delgado", "portfolio_key": "CBP-100-02", "row_id": "REG-CBP-100-02", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_board_committees/002_board_committees_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/014_minutes_materials_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/026_disclosure_controls_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/038_insider_trading_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/08_earnings_guidance/062_earnings_guidance_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/10_stock_exchange/074_stock_exchange_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/12_certifications/097_juniper_photonics_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "juniper-photonics:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-10-02", "issue": "debt-covenant disclosure", "matter_number": "CB-PC-3310", "owner": "Priya Raman", "portfolio_key": "CBP-100-03", "row_id": "REG-CBP-100-03", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_board_committees/003_board_committees_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/015_minutes_materials_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/027_disclosure_controls_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/039_insider_trading_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/08_earnings_guidance/063_earnings_guidance_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/12_certifications/097_juniper_photonics_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "juniper-photonics:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective", "issue": "8-K deadline", "matter_number": "CB-PC-3310", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-100-04", "row_id": "REG-CBP-100-04", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_board_committees/004_board_committees_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/016_minutes_materials_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/028_disclosure_controls_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/040_insider_trading_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/10_stock_exchange/076_stock_exchange_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/11_debt_covenants/088_debt_covenants_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_certifications/097_juniper_photonics_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "juniper-photonics:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "the operational record relies on a superseded control revision", "issue": "related-party disclosure gap", "matter_number": "CB-PC-3310", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-100-05", "row_id": "REG-CBP-100-05", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_board_committees/005_board_committees_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/017_sec_filings_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/029_disclosure_controls_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/06_related_parties/041_related_parties_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/09_whistleblower/065_whistleblower_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/07_equity_compensation/053_equity_compensation_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_certifications/097_juniper_photonics_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "juniper-photonics:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "evidence_hold", "due_date": null, "hold_reason": "two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key", "issue": "listing-standard notice", "matter_number": "CB-PC-3310", "owner": null, "portfolio_key": "CBP-100-06", "row_id": "REG-CBP-100-06", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_board_committees/006_board_committees_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/018_sec_filings_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/030_disclosure_controls_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/06_related_parties/042_related_parties_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/10_stock_exchange/078_stock_exchange_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_certifications/097_juniper_photonics_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "juniper-photonics:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-28", "issue": "minutes-approval omission", "matter_number": "CB-PC-3310", "owner": "Mei Whitaker", "portfolio_key": "CBP-100-07", "row_id": "REG-CBP-100-07", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_board_committees/007_board_committees_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/019_sec_filings_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/031_disclosure_controls_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/06_related_parties/043_related_parties_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/09_whistleblower/067_whistleblower_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/12_certifications/097_juniper_photonics_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "juniper-photonics:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-27", "issue": "Section 16 filing delay", "matter_number": "CB-PC-3310", "owner": "Theo Laurent", "portfolio_key": "CBP-100-08", "row_id": "REG-CBP-100-08", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/01_board_committees/008_board_committees_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/020_sec_filings_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/032_disclosure_controls_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/06_related_parties/044_related_parties_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/12_certifications/092_certifications_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/09_whistleblower/068_whistleblower_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/12_certifications/097_juniper_photonics_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "juniper-photonics:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-09-26", "issue": "whistleblower escalation delay", "matter_number": "CB-PC-3310", "owner": "Lena Varga", "portfolio_key": "CBP-100-09", "row_id": "REG-CBP-100-09", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/009_minutes_materials_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/021_sec_filings_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/033_insider_trading_source_export.md", "/workspace/documents/06_related_parties/045_related_parties_source_export.json", "/workspace/documents/12_certifications/097_juniper_photonics_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "juniper-photonics:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-10-04", "issue": "committee-independence gap", "matter_number": "CB-PC-3310", "owner": "Elliot Mercer", "portfolio_key": "CBP-100-10", "row_id": "REG-CBP-100-10", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/010_minutes_materials_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/022_sec_filings_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/034_insider_trading_source_export.txt", "/workspace/documents/06_related_parties/046_related_parties_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_certifications/094_certifications_source_export.xml", "/workspace/documents/12_certifications/097_juniper_photonics_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "juniper-photonics:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-10-03", "issue": "trading-window violation", "matter_number": "CB-PC-3310", "owner": "Sofia Bennett", "portfolio_key": "CBP-100-11", "row_id": "REG-CBP-100-11", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/011_minutes_materials_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/023_sec_filings_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/035_insider_trading_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/06_related_parties/047_related_parties_source_export.html", "/workspace/documents/11_debt_covenants/083_debt_covenants_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/08_earnings_guidance/059_earnings_guidance_source_export.eml", "/workspace/documents/12_certifications/097_juniper_photonics_impact_population.xlsx"]}, {"decision_option_id": "juniper-photonics:scoped-evidence", "disposition": "open_action", "due_date": "2026-10-02", "issue": "guidance-control failure", "matter_number": "CB-PC-3310", "owner": "Micah Sullivan", "portfolio_key": "CBP-100-12", "row_id": "REG-CBP-100-12", "source_paths": ["/workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/012_minutes_materials_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/024_sec_filings_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/036_insider_trading_source_export.csv", "/workspace/documents/06_related_parties/048_related_parties_source_export.pdf", "/workspace/documents/12_certifications/097_juniper_photonics_impact_population.xlsx"]}], "schema_version": "counselbench.matter-register.v3", "task_id": "cb100-100-juniper-photonics"}}, "metadata": {"benchmark": "CounselBench-100", "code_license": "Apache-2.0", "data_license": "CC-BY-4.0", "deadline": "2026-10-05", "document_count": 97, "evidence_holds": 4, "jurisdiction": "Delaware", "matter_number": "CB-PC-3310", "mcp_commit": "9a96ea6e5913736f92b88345bf51caeaaa8e719f", "mcp_package": "@modelcontextprotocol/server-filesystem@2026.7.10", "practice_area": "public-company", "reference_tool_calls": 89, "required_evidence_reads": 65, "supported_actions": 8, "synthetic": true, "venue": "Nasdaq Stock Market", "version": "3.1.0"}, "prompt": "I need to know what is proven, what we can do about it, and what is still only an evidence gap. Is Juniper Photonics ready to file, and which cyber, customer, equity, committee, or certification issues remain open? Cybersecurity, customer concentration, equity-plan, committee, and certification records require reconciliation before a periodic report. The team needs the call by 2026-10-05. Capture the supported action and the remaining holds so the next reviewer can reproduce the call.", "rubric": {"criteria": [{"category": "investigation", "description": "Inventory the production and use targeted searches to locate records across native formats.", "id": "investigation.discover_production"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Complete every task-specific identity, authority, operations, and approval read before the first state transition.", "id": "investigation.read_before_write"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Inspect designated source metadata before relying on those records.", "id": "investigation.custody_before_write"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "Select the supported option 'juniper-photonics:scoped-evidence' after applying the four-part test.", "id": "decision.selected_option"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "Identify both rejected approaches and explain why a one-source shortcut and a blanket hold are wrong.", "id": "decision.alternatives"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-100-01 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_board_committees/001_board_committees_source_export.md rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-100-01.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/013_minutes_materials_source_export.json for risk-factor inconsistency.", "id": "investigation.CBP-100-01.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/025_disclosure_controls_source_export.md to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-100-01.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/037_insider_trading_source_export.json.", "id": "investigation.CBP-100-01.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-100-01 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is the operational record relies on a superseded control revision.", "id": "decision.CBP-100-01.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-100-01 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-100-01.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-100-02 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_board_committees/002_board_committees_source_export.txt rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-100-02.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/014_minutes_materials_source_export.xml for equity-plan share mismatch.", "id": "investigation.CBP-100-02.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/026_disclosure_controls_source_export.txt to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-100-02.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/038_insider_trading_source_export.xml.", "id": "investigation.CBP-100-02.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-100-02 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-100-02.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-100-02 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-100-02.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-100-03 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_board_committees/003_board_committees_source_export.eml rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-100-03.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/015_minutes_materials_source_export.html for debt-covenant disclosure.", "id": "investigation.CBP-100-03.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/027_disclosure_controls_source_export.eml to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-100-03.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/039_insider_trading_source_export.html.", "id": "investigation.CBP-100-03.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-100-03 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-100-03.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-100-03 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-100-03.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-100-04 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_board_committees/004_board_committees_source_export.csv rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-100-04.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/016_minutes_materials_source_export.pdf for 8-K deadline.", "id": "investigation.CBP-100-04.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/028_disclosure_controls_source_export.csv to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-100-04.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/040_insider_trading_source_export.pdf.", "id": "investigation.CBP-100-04.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-100-04 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is the required approval or active owner capacity is not yet effective.", "id": "decision.CBP-100-04.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-100-04 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-100-04.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-100-05 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_board_committees/005_board_committees_source_export.json rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-100-05.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/017_sec_filings_source_export.md for related-party disclosure gap.", "id": "investigation.CBP-100-05.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/029_disclosure_controls_source_export.json to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-100-05.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_related_parties/041_related_parties_source_export.md.", "id": "investigation.CBP-100-05.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-100-05 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is the operational record relies on a superseded control revision.", "id": "decision.CBP-100-05.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-100-05 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-100-05.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-100-06 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_board_committees/006_board_committees_source_export.xml rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-100-06.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/018_sec_filings_source_export.txt for listing-standard notice.", "id": "investigation.CBP-100-06.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/030_disclosure_controls_source_export.xml to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-100-06.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_related_parties/042_related_parties_source_export.txt.", "id": "investigation.CBP-100-06.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-100-06 as 'evidence_hold'; the controlling branch is two source records share the display identity but not the immutable entity key.", "id": "decision.CBP-100-06.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-100-06 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-100-06.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-100-07 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_board_committees/007_board_committees_source_export.html rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-100-07.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/019_sec_filings_source_export.eml for minutes-approval omission.", "id": "investigation.CBP-100-07.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/031_disclosure_controls_source_export.html to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-100-07.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_related_parties/043_related_parties_source_export.eml.", "id": "investigation.CBP-100-07.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-100-07 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-100-07.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-100-07 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-100-07.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-100-08 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/01_board_committees/008_board_committees_source_export.pdf rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-100-08.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/020_sec_filings_source_export.csv for Section 16 filing delay.", "id": "investigation.CBP-100-08.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/04_disclosure_controls/032_disclosure_controls_source_export.pdf to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-100-08.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_related_parties/044_related_parties_source_export.csv.", "id": "investigation.CBP-100-08.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-100-08 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-100-08.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-100-08 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-100-08.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-100-09 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/009_minutes_materials_source_export.md rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-100-09.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/021_sec_filings_source_export.json for whistleblower escalation delay.", "id": "investigation.CBP-100-09.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/033_insider_trading_source_export.md to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-100-09.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_related_parties/045_related_parties_source_export.json.", "id": "investigation.CBP-100-09.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-100-09 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-100-09.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-100-09 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-100-09.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-100-10 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/010_minutes_materials_source_export.txt rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-100-10.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/022_sec_filings_source_export.xml for committee-independence gap.", "id": "investigation.CBP-100-10.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/034_insider_trading_source_export.txt to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-100-10.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_related_parties/046_related_parties_source_export.xml.", "id": "investigation.CBP-100-10.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-100-10 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-100-10.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-100-10 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-100-10.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-100-11 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/011_minutes_materials_source_export.eml rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-100-11.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/023_sec_filings_source_export.html for trading-window violation.", "id": "investigation.CBP-100-11.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/035_insider_trading_source_export.eml to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-100-11.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_related_parties/047_related_parties_source_export.html.", "id": "investigation.CBP-100-11.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-100-11 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-100-11.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-100-11 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-100-11.register"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Resolve CBP-100-12 using the immutable identity record /workspace/documents/02_minutes_materials/012_minutes_materials_source_export.csv rather than its display name.", "id": "investigation.CBP-100-12.identity"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Read the operative rule and revision in /workspace/documents/03_sec_filings/024_sec_filings_source_export.pdf for guidance-control failure.", "id": "investigation.CBP-100-12.authority"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Compare the current observation in /workspace/documents/05_insider_trading/036_insider_trading_source_export.csv to the operative trigger.", "id": "investigation.CBP-100-12.operations"}, {"category": "investigation", "description": "Verify effective approval, owner status, and capacity in /workspace/documents/06_related_parties/048_related_parties_source_export.pdf.", "id": "investigation.CBP-100-12.approval"}, {"category": "decision", "description": "After joining those records, classify CBP-100-12 as 'action'; the controlling branch is all four conditions are satisfied.", "id": "decision.CBP-100-12.branch"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create the exact task-scoped matter-register row for CBP-100-12 and do not change another portfolio key.", "id": "state.CBP-100-12.register"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Write the exact selected option, supported action population, evidence-hold population, facts, owners, deadlines, and citations.", "id": "state.exact_decision"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Create one exact register row per portfolio key with no extra, missing, or modified row.", "id": "state.exact_register"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Leave only the three approved deliverables and perform no extra state-changing write.", "id": "state.write_scope_containment"}, {"category": "state", "description": "Read back decision.json, matter-register.json, and advice.md after their final writes.", "id": "state.postwrite_readback"}, {"category": "answer", "description": "Explain the selected recommendation, supported actions, holds, alternatives, and limitations with exact source anchors.", "id": "answer.decision_note"}], "decision_options": [{"approach": "Apply the exact identity, current-state, authority, and revision test. Create disclosure-topic rows with exact corrections, owners, and filing holds.", "id": "juniper-photonics:scoped-evidence", "label": "File only after supported figures and certifications are corrected or explicitly held open."}, {"approach": "Use a plausible summary or one source without completing the controlling joins.", "id": "juniper-photonics:shortcut", "label": "Use the near-final filing draft as proof that every underlying control passed."}, {"approach": "Treat supported actions and genuinely ambiguous records as if they were equally unresolved.", "id": "juniper-photonics:blanket-hold", "label": "Freeze the entire matter population"}], "evaluation_narrative": {"authority": "The filing checklist and applicable disclosure and governance controls require current, source-consistent support.", "observation": "Reconcile current incidents, concentration metrics, plan shares, committee status, and certifications to the reporting period.", "question": "Is Juniper Photonics ready to file, and which cyber, customer, equity, committee, or certification issues remain open?", "register_action": "Create disclosure-topic rows with exact corrections, owners, and filing holds."}, "gates": ["all_required_evidence_precedes_first_write", "decision_criteria_complete", "register_state_exact", "write_scope_contained", "all_outputs_verified_by_readback"], "metadata_checks": 9, "metric": "weighted_criteria_score", "minimum_tool_calls": 89, "required_deliverables": ["decision.json", "matter-register.json", "advice.md"], "required_document_reads": 65, "type": "deterministic", "weights": {"advice": 0.15, "decision": 0.35, "investigation": 0.25, "state": 0.25}}, "task_id": "cb100-100-juniper-photonics", "task_name": "Juniper Photonics filing readiness audit", "world_id": "counselbench-filesystem-mcp-v3"}